The URL can be used to link to this page

Agenda 11/12/2024 Item #16A 5 (Release of a Code Enforcement Lien for Folio# 00127760002 Located at 1509 Immokalee Dr., Collier County, FL)11/12/2024 Item # 16.A.5 ID# 2024-1655 Executive Summary Recommendation to approve the release of a code enforcement lien with an accrued value of $1,640,000, for a reduced payment of $5,066.60, in the code enforcement action titled Board of County Commissioners vs. Ignacio Soto for Star Mobile Home Park LLC., relating to Folio # 00127760002 located at 1509 Immokalee Dr., Collier County, Florida. OBJECTIVE: The Board of County Commissioners accept an offer to release a code enforcement lien with an accrued value of $1,640,000 for payment of $5,066.60, in relation to Code Enforcement Board (CEB) Case No. 2005090125 CEB 2005-43. CONSIDERATIONS: As a result of a code violation consisting of the unauthorized placement of four mobile home- type structures, and one shed-type structure without prior Collier County Zoning and Planning review and a Collier County Building Permit, the Code Enforcement Board ordered the imposition of a lien against Ignacio Soto for Star Mobile Home Park LLC., in Case No. 2005090125 CEB 2005-43. The corrected lien was recorded on November 1, 2007, at O.R. Book 4298, Page 0631, in the amount of $93,980.78. Fines continued to accrue and the lien amount of $1,640,000, is based on 6,560 days at ($250 per day from February 17, 2006, through February 2, 2024), resulting in a total balance of $1,640,000. The property was brought into compliance on February 2, 2024. Pursuant to Resolution No. 2023-90, a request for reduction of fines may be considered, in part, when a lien encumbers property under new ownership and the new owner has diligently pursued abatement and achieved compliance and/or when payment of the lien would impose a severe financial hardship on the owner. When Mr. Soto purchased Star Mobile Home Park in 2004, all mobile homes and storage sheds were pre-existing structures on the property. To improve the park’s infrastructure, Mr. Soto began to make improvements to the property by bringing the park up to current code standards. He relied on the help of his office manager to obtain the required permits and develop a Site Improvement Plan (SIP). Despite the reassurance of his former employee, the permitting process and SIP applications weren’t effectively managed, fines continued to accrue, and taxes went unpaid leaving the Soto family in a precarious financial situation. It took substantial amounts of time and money to develop an approved Site Improvement Plan, extensive follow-up, demolition, permit fees, and inspections to achieve compliance. The recommended payment of $5,066.60 is based on ten percent of the Collier County Property Appraiser’s Assessed Value of $50,666 and meets the criteria outlined in Resolution 2023-90. There are no known violations at this time. FISCAL IMPACT: Acceptance of payment of $5,066.60 to settle the lien will correlate to what is outlined in Collier County Resolution 2023-90. GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There is no growth management impact associated with this action. LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: The County Attorney’s Office has reviewed this item and approved it as to form and legality. Majority support is required for approval. This item conforms to the Board’s policy contained in Resolution 2023-90. RTT RECOMMENDATIONS: To approve the recommended reduction of fines in the amount of $1,634,933.40, accept payment amount of $5,066.60, release the liens, and authorize the Chairman to sign the attached release and satisfaction of lien for recording in the Official Public Records. PREPARED BY: Tom Iandimarino, Director, Code Enforcement Division ATTACHMENTS: 1. Code Lien Relief - Folio 00127680002 (2 of 3) 2. Worksheet - Folio 00127680002 3. Code Lien Relief - Letter 4. 2005090123 CodeCaseDetails (CDPlus) 2005 - 2007 Page 821 of 5419 11/12/2024 Item # 16.A.5 ID# 2024-1655 5. 2005090123 Code Case Details (CityView) 6. 2005090123 OFF CEB 2005-43 7. 2005090123 IOF CEB 2005-43 8. 2005090123 IOF Corrected CEB 2005-43 9. 2005090123 - AOC 10. signed release Page 822 of 5419 Cottttly Growth Managernent Departrnent Code Enforcement Divi sion 2800 Horseshoe Drive N, Naples, FL 34104 Phone: (239) 252-2440 APPLICATION FOR LIEN REDUCTION PURSUANT TO RESOLUTION 23.90 1. Applicants must fill out and sign the form below and provide all required supporting documents. 2. Applicants should provide the completed application to the Code Enforcement Division at the address listed above. 3. Payment of $150 is due at the time of the application 4. All administrative fees and hard costs must be paid at the time of submission of this application 5. The applicant must have no other active o'ode violations on any other property in Collier County. 6. All ad valorem property taxes, special assessments, Collier County utility charges or other Collier County fees or liens against the subject real property and all other properties owned by the applicant must be current. 7 . There must be no expired permits on property owned by the applicant or managing member of the applicant. E. The County may request further documentation Date: 0510612024 code case Numb..r. 2005090123 Phone Number: Name of Apprican,. lgnacio soto Original Violator (if different) StarMHPl4@gmail.com Email Address: 239‐707‐0032 P O Box 250 Felda, FL 33930 Address of Applicant: Property Owner(s) Name (if different from applicant): Applicant's relationship / afliliation with the violator named in lien(s): Managing Member's Name (if applicable) 1509 lmmokalee Dr, lmmokalee, FL34142 Address(es) of Liened ProPerty: 00127680002 Folio Numbers: Description of underlying violation(s): Pre Existing MHP did not have approved SIP Page 823 of 5419 Number of other properties located within unincorporated Collier County owned by Owner / Applicant / Managing Member: 5 lf any, attach list oJ property addresses. Are there any active (Code) violations on these properties? Yes- No X Is the property current fisted for sale? Yes NoX Does this property have a contract for sale pending: Yes NoX If yes, attach the contract dnd all relevanl documents. Anticipated closing date: What is the current use of the property: MOBILE HOME PARK Are there applicant: any expired permits on the property or any other property owned by the Yes No x lfyes, please provide an explanation. Was this property sold or transferred after the lien was recorded: Yes_ No_x If yes, please attach all closing documents incl.uding the purchase agreemenl. Ifyes, was the property obtained via:Tax Deed Foreclosure Sale Other (i.e. traditional purchase, received via inheritance). If yes, was a title insurance policy issued at the time of sale? Yes- No X If yes, please attach title insurance policy. If no title insurance was procured, please provide an explanation ds to why no title insurance is available Jbr the property: Number of liens submitted as part of this application: State the amount you are requesting to pay for each lien:S506660 The reasons, if any, compliance was not obtained prior to the order of imposition: "lease=ee attaaFad provide the factual basis as to why a reduction ofthe lien should be granted' Please describe the extent to which payment of the full lien would impose a severe financial hardship' the measurable expenses incurred to bring the property into compliance, and the diligence of the pursuit to bring the property into compliance. All supporting documents to show the measurable expenses shall be attached. (Attach additittttal pages documents if necessary) Please see attached Page 824 of 5419 Select all documents that are being submitted in support ofthe application. _Title insurance Closing documents Contract for pending sale Proof of expenses to bring property into compliance Other. olease ir1sn1ify.. Approved SIP I swear or afTirm that all information is true to the best of my knowledge as of the date of this signature STA¶E OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER The foregong hsment was ac‐knowledgedbeforemebymeans ofh pК sm∝or_祠 ¨na誼 zaum′血sadapttn物女=型 `byイ拝突盪壷″ (Signature-of Notary Public-State of Florida) (Print, Type, or Stamp Commissioners Name of Notary Public) - Personalty Known OR -lt 4troduced ldentification ESILEJ NuLL ¨#HH 131278 巨¨ “ June5,a125 興 hT●7F●h―m叫綱。 Type of Identification Produced: Ar'u dD<-l''u'r'4' U gt n *1- Page 825 of 5419 Code Enforcement Lien Relief Program Resolution 2023-90 1 Ignacio Soto for Star Mobile Home Park LLC Folio # 00127680002 Legal: 5 47 29 DB 25 PG 473 OR 672 PG 185-186 Section 1: Property Overview RESOLUTION NO. 2023-90 Case Number: 2005090123 CEB 2005-43, Unauthorized placement of 4 mobile home type structures without prior Collier County Zoning and Planning review without a Collier County Building Permit. •9/6/2005 - Original Date Case Opened •Order Imposing Lien OR 4205 PG 0700 & Corrected Lien OR 4298 PG 0631 •2/2/2024 – Violation Abated Has the applicant been found to have repeat violations in the past five years: NO History of other violations: None on subject property Section 2: In order to qualify for the Lien Relief Program, the following criteria must be met by the applicant: •12/14/2023 – Subject property tax paid and utility charges are current for the mobile home park. •Folio 00127600008 – 1507 Immokalee Rd: property taxes paid 12/14/2023. •Folio 00127640000 – 447 N 15th St: property taxes paid 12/14/2023. •Folio 00127720001 – 439 N 15th St: property taxes paid 12/14/2023. •Folio 00127760003 – 1509 Immokalee Dr: property taxes paid 12/14/2023 •Folio 00075880006 - vacant: property taxes paid 12/13/2023, vacant no utilities. •Folio 00075920005 – 1009 N 29th St: property taxes paid 12/13/2023 and utility charges are current. •Folio 00081080007 – 3022 Immokalee Dr, vacant: property taxes paid 12/13/2023, vacant no utilities. •Folio 63862280005 – vacant: property taxes paid 12/13/2023, vacant no utilities. •Folio 63862320004 – vacant: property taxes paid 12/13/2023, vacant no utilities. •Folio 63862680003 – vacant: property taxes paid 12/13/2023, vacant no utilities. •Folio 63862720002 – vacant: property taxes paid 12/13/2023, vacant no utilities. •Folio 63862760004 – vacant: property taxes paid 12/13/2023, vacant no utilities. •Folio 70690000505 – vacant: property taxes paid 12/13/2023, vacant no utilities. •Other Collier County liens: •Case 2005090125, folio 00127760003, Lien relief application filed 5/13/2024. •Case 2005090124, folio 00127640000, Lien relief application filed 5/13/2024. Page 826 of 5419 Code Enforcement Lien Relief Program Resolution 2023-90 2 •Expired permits: None •Other properties owned by the applicant in Collier County: Yes •Star Mobile Home Park LLC: •Folio 00127600008, 1507 Immokalee Dr ▪Folio 00127640000, 447 N 15th St ▪Folio 00127720001, 439 N 15th St ▪Folio 00127760003, 1509 Immokalee Dr •Ignacio Soto: ▪Folio 00075880006, vacant ▪Folio 00075920005, 1009 N 29th St ▪Folio 00081080007, 3022 Immokalee Dr (vacant) ▪Folio 63862280005, vacant ▪Folio 63862320004, vacant ▪Folio 63862680003, vacant ▪Folio 63862720002. vacant ▪Folio 63862760004, vacant ▪Folio 70690000505, vacant •Property use in compliance with Zoning laws: Yes, mobile home park. •New owner title insurance policy and/or closing documents included: No, same owner. • 5/13/2024 - Code Lien Relief application received. •5/13/2024 - Application fee of $150 paid. •5/13/2024 - All hard costs, administrative fees, and operational costs were paid. Section 3: Eligibility Lien Relief Attachments 1. Code Lien Relief Application & Documents 7. 2005090123 Code Case Details 2005 - 2007 8. 2005090123 Code Case Details Section 4: Collier County Property Appraiser’s Assessed Value as of May 14, 2024 Land Value $ 68,850.00 (+) Improved Value $ 34,321.00 (=) Market Value $ 103,171.00 (-) 10% Non-Homestead Cap $ 52,505.00 (=) Assessed Value $ 50,666.00 Page 827 of 5419 Code Enforcement Lien Relief Program Resolution 2023-90 3 •Total Fines Accrued: $1,640,000.00. This amount is fixed and no longer accruing. •Fine Accruals: Code Enforcement Board imposition of fines order fines start date 2/17/2006 through compliance date of 2/2/2024: Order Items: $250/day fine x 6,560 days $1,640,000.00 plus $480.78 in operational costs $ 480.78 5/13/24 Paid operational costs $ (480.78) Total Fines: $1,640,000.00 Recommended reduction amount: $(1,634,933.40) 10% of Assessed Value: $ 5,066.60 Applicant’s offer: $ 5,066.60 Page 828 of 5419 I purchased Starling Mobile Home Park form Louise Starling in 2004. All the mobile homes a nd storge units on this property were all pre-existing structures. Since 2005, I have been actively involved in improving the park's infrastructure and ensuring its compliance with all necessary regulations, including the completion ofthe Site lmprovement Plan (SlP) and obtaining relevant permits from the county, During this time, my office manager, Carmen Soto with the responsibility of managing the park and handling office duties, including the completion of permitting applications and documentation required by the county. Despite assurances from Carmen that all permitting applications were in process and being handled in a timely manner, it has become apparent that this was not the case. As time passed, fines were generated due to delays in obtaining the necessary permits, and despite my inquiries for updates, I consistently received the same aesponse: the permits are in process. The failure to effectively manage the permitting process has had serious consequences for the trailer park and has resulted in significant financial penalties. Furthermore, it has caused undue stress and hardship for me as the property owner' Throughout the years, my family and I have been engaged in seasonal work in lndiana, primarily in the corn tields, during the summer months. This commitment has spanned over three decades, during which I have worked for two different companies in lndiana. My responsibilities in lndiana requiaed my presehce for extended periods, often keeping me away ftom lmmokalee. Over the years, I have overseen teams of up to 300 employees who worked under my supervision each summer. The income genelilted from this seasonal employment has been instrumental in supporting various financial commitments, including the maintenance and improvement of our mobile home park in lmmokalee. The proceeds from my summer employment have been dedicated to covering expenses such as property upkeep, mobile home renovations, taxes, and insu.ance premiums. While my presence in lmmokalee may have been limited during these periods, my commitment to the community and its welfarc has remained steedfast. I have discovered a series oftroubling issues that have Sone unresolved, lt has come to my attention that significant financial obligations, including employment taxes, property taxes, and income taxes, have not been addressed. Furthermore, income taxes were never filed during this time period. I was completely unaware of these oversights as my former office manager assured me that everything was being takeh care of. However, it has become apparent that this was not the case, and the consequences of these actions have now caught up with me Page 829 of 5419 The failure to address these financial obligations has placed me in an extremely precarious situation, both personally and financially. I am now faced with the daunting task of rectifying these issues and bringing my affairs back into compliance with all relevant regulations and obligations. With IRS's involvement, it caused me to lose all of my contracts in lndiana that I worked so hard for. I had significant ramifications, impacting not only my property management operations but also my livelihood and financial stability. I have actively worked to address the outstanding employment tax obligations spanning over several years and the associated penalties, but the situation remains challenging. Since its inception, the mobile home park has been a labor of love and a testament to my lifelong commitment to providing for my family and preparing for my retirement. Over the yea rs, I have dedicated myself to improving the park's infrastructure and ensuring its compliance with all necessary regulations. However, this journey has not been without its challenges. ln 2019, I was diagnosed with Non- Hodgkin's Lymphoma Cancer, a diagnosis that required four years of immense strength and determination to overcome. Throughout this difficult period, my focus remained on maintaining the mobile home park and fulfilling my responsibilities as its owner to the best of my ability. Unfortunately, during this time of personal hardship, certain administrative matters regarding the park were not managed as effectively as they should have been. Specifically, issues arose regarding the completion of the Site lmprovement Plan (SlP) and the timely acquisition of necessry permits from the county. I am deeply troubled by these oversights and am committed to addressing them promptly. I am reaching out to you for guidance and assistance as I work to rectify these issues and bring my aflairs back into compliance with all relevant regulations and obligations. With the assistance of the new administration, I have successfully brought all of my taxes, property taxes, and IRS penalties up to date. Additionally, the ongoing Site lmprovement Plan (SlP) has been approved, signaling a positive step forwa rd for the park. However, despite these efforts, I find myself facing an insurmountable financial burden in the form of fines totaling S4.8 million dollars. Given the significant financial hardships I have endured over the past several years, it would be exceedingly difficult for me to pay this amount in full. ln light of these circumstances, I am respectfully requesting that my fines be reduced to a more manageable and affordable amount. I am committed to fulfitling my obligations to the county to the best of my ability and am eager to work collaboratively to find a solution that is mutually beneficial. Page 830 of 5419 5/14/2024 10:37:19 AM CD+ Code Case Details Case Nbr Action Order Nbr Status Department 2005090123 277455 OPEN CODE ENFORCEMENT DEPT Case Type Priority Occupancy Case Level ZONING 0 HEAR Address # Folio # Location 2096 0000000127680002 1507 IMMOKALEE DR Zip Code TAZ Zoning Range Township Section 341420000 0 Subdivision # Subdivision Name Block Lot Planning Community 100 acreage 003 .000 Opened Opened By Closed Closed By Assigned Inspector 9/6/2005 12:00:00 AM JOANNSHIRLY MAZZONE_D Violation Case Description Case Disposition MISC LAND USE 9/6/05 - IMMOKALEE INITIATIVE JS CEB 2005-43 Additional Information Tenant Name Tenant Phone Tenant Fax STAR MOBILE HOME PARK LLC Owner Name Owner Phone Owner Fax Owner Address STAR MOBILE HOME PARK LLC 1507 W IMMOKALEE DR IMMOKALEE, FLB0680 341420000 Owner Status First Visit Date Next Visit Date Last Visit Date Next Hearing Date Last CEBNbr 9/8/2005 12:00:00 AM 12/6/2007 12:00:00 AM 11/21/2007 12:00:00 AM 11/18/2005 12:00:00 AM 2005-43 Contact Information Contact Name Contact Phone Contact Fax Contact Address STAR MOBILE HOME PARK LLC IGNACIO SOTO 1507 IMMOKALEE DR Page 831 of 5419 5/14/2024 10:37:19 AM IMMOKALEE FL 34142 0000 Violator Name Violator Phone Violator Fax Violator Address STAR MOBILE HOME PARK LLC RICHARD SHAW, R/A 813 MONROE COURT IMMOKALEE, FL 34142 Environment Environment Type Management Plan Date Notice Of Violation Date Days To Abate Exotic Plan Date Bldg Permit # Abated Date Landscape Plan Date Development Order Abated By Visits Visit Nbr Visit Date Status Scheduled Date Units Remarks 918023 9/8/2005 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 9/6/2005 12:00:00 AM 2 HRS - RESEARCHED INFORMATION PERTAINING TO ALL FIVE PARCELS THAT MAKE UP THE MOBILE HOME PARK KNOWN AS "STARLING". I PREPARED AN APPROPRIATE NOV FOR THE SPECIFIC VIOLATIONS PERTAINING TO PARCEL 03.00. I MET W/ OWNER MR SOTO, OWNERS DAUGHTER CERMEN SOTO AND REG. AGENT, RICHARD SHAW, AT MR. SOTOS;S OFFICE ON IMMOK. DR. I View Details Page 832 of 5419 5/14/2024 10:37:19 AM PROVIDED A COPY OF THEIR EXISITNG MAP, BUT W/ ALL PARCELS HIGHLIGHTED. I OBTAINED A SIGNED NOV BY MR SOTO & BY MR SHOA *PLEASE SCAN ATTACHED NOV'S (BOTH)* I PROVIDE COPIES OF ALL APPROP. SEC'S TO BOTH PARTIES - I ALSO PROVIDED SUPERVISOR # 49JM W/ COPIES OF NOV'S. R/C 9-12-05 ET 918697 9/19/2005 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 9/12/2005 12:00:00 AM PREPARED "STATEMENT OF VIO. & REQUEST FOR HEARING" FORM & TURNED BACK- UP INFO. OVER TO # 13 M.A. TO PROCESS FOR CEB REVIEW. R/C 9-23-05 ET View Details 921703 9/27/2005 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 9/23/2005 12:00:00 AM AS PER DAVE HEDRICH CARMEN SOTO CONTACTED COLLIER CO. PLANNER DAVE HEDRICH TODAY TO INFORM THAT SHE WANTS TO SCHEDULE A PRE-AP. MEETING RE: SIP FOR IMMOK. INITIVETIME & DATE TO BE SET IN VERY NEAR FUTURE. MRS View Details Page 833 of 5419 5/14/2024 10:37:19 AM MARTIN OF COLLIER CO. PLANNING WILL INFORM ME OF DETAILS BY EMAIL. R/C 9-30- 05 ET 922753 10/10/2005 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 9/30/2005 12:00:00 AM ( 10 M ) PLEASE SEE ATTACHED "EMAIL" FROM PLANNER DAVE HEDRICH, CONFIRMING THAT A PRE- APP MEETING TO DISCUSS SIP IS SCHEDULED FOR NOV 16, 2005 - I WILL INFORM CEB OF SAME PROGRESS AT THEIR OCT. 27, 05 MEETING. R/C 10-26-05 ET View Details 924395 10/17/2005 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 10/17/2005 12:00:00 AM 1 1/2 HRS - MET WT. IGNACIO & CARMEN SOTO AT THEIR PLACE OF BUSINESS IN IMMOK. - I OBTAINED A SIGNED "STIPULATION AGREEMENT" (COPY ATTACHED) *PLEASE SCAN* R/C 10-25-05 ET View Details 925392 11/2/2005 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 10/26/2005 12:00:00 AM SITE VISIT CONFIRMED THAT HURRICANE WILMA DID NOT EFFECT PROGRESS OF THIS CASE DUE TO DAMGE R/C 11-07-05 ET View Details 926431 11/18/2005 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 11/18/2005 12:00:00 AM 11/18/05 ATTENDED CEB View Details Page 834 of 5419 5/14/2024 10:37:19 AM HEARING. MS. CARMEN SOTO REPRESENTED IGNACIO SOTO AT HEARING. CEB VOTED TO ACCEPT THE TERMS OF OUR STIP. AGREEMENT. THE SOTO'S HAVE COMPLIED WITH TERMS OF PARAGRAPH #2 OF STIP AS A PRE-APP MEETING TOOK PLACE ON 11/16/05. SOTOS NOW HAVE 90 DAYS FROM 11/16/05 TO SUBMIT THEIR SIP OR UNTIL 2/16/06. R/C 12/29/05 JS 928638 1/30/2006 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 12/29/2005 12:00:00 AM I MADE PHONE CONTACT WT CARMEN SOTO ( 657-5200 ) I INFORMED OF FEB 16, 2006 DEADLINE FOR SUBMISSION OF SIP. R/C 2-14-06 ET View Details 937051 2/9/2006 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 2/9/2006 12:00:00 AM AS PER MY PHONE CONVERSATION WITH CARMEN SOTO (657-5200) THEIR "SDP WILL BE SUBMITTED BY THE DUE DATE SET BY THE CEB." SHE WILL ALSO EMAIL ME A NOTE PERTAINING TO TIME FRAME View Details Page 835 of 5419 5/14/2024 10:37:19 AM FOR PERMITS VS. WHAT DAVE HEDRICUT OF COLLIER CO. PLANNING HAS BEEN SAYING -- -- MR. HEDRICH WAS QUOTED AS SAYING IT WILL TAKE AN APPROX 300+/- DAYS?? R/C 2/13/06 LS 939230 9/6/2006 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 9/6/2006 12:00:00 AM CONFIRMED THROUGH COLLIER CO. PLANNER, DAVE HEDRICH THAT SIP AS9250 IS STILL IN NEED OF "RE- SUBMITTAL". I MADE PHONE CONTACT WT. CARMEN SOTO (657-5200) AND INFORMED OF OCT 06,06 DEADLINE TO RESUBMIT. RC 9/22/06 LAZ View Details 966565 10/2/2006 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 10/2/2006 12:00:00 AM 47DM-- I CONTACTED COLLIER CO. PLANNER HEDRICH BY PHONE. HE INFORMED THAT HE HAS NOT BEEN IN RECEIPT OF RE- SUBMITTAL OF SIP, BUT HE HAD SPOKEN TO CARMEN SOTO LAST WEEK & SHE STATED THAT SHE IS WORKING ON SUBMITTING SAME SOME View Details Page 836 of 5419 5/14/2024 10:37:19 AM TIME THIS WEEK. RC 10/4/06 LAZ 969810 10/5/2006 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 10/4/2006 12:00:00 AM I MADE EARLY AM PHONE CONTACT WT. CARMEN SOTO (657--5200) I INFORMED OF 10-6-06 DEADLINE FOR RE-SUBMITTAL OF SIP. MS SOTO STATED "WILL MAKE DEADLINE" PLANNER, HEDRICH OUT OF OFFICE UNTIL MONDAY 10-9-06 DM#47 R/C 10-9-06 DSP View Details 970406 10/9/2006 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 10/9/2006 12:00:00 AM RE-SUBMITTAL NOT TURNED IN TO DATE. I MADE A;M PHONE CONTACT WT. CARMEN SOTO (657-5200) SHE INFORMED THAT SHE HAS BEEN WAITING OVER A WEEK TO GET WRITTEN RESPONSE BACK FROM LEO ROGERS OF IMMOK. FIRE DIST, REGARDING ACCEPTANCE OF ROAD WIDTHS RELATIVE TO THEIR PARK. THIS IS THE ONLY ITEM HOLDING UP THEIR RE- View Details Page 837 of 5419 5/14/2024 10:37:19 AM SUBMITTAL. IN SPEAKING WT. COLLIER CO. PLANNED DAVE HEDRICH, HE STATED THAT HE WILL GRANT ADDT'L TIME IN ORDER TO KEEP WORKING WT. THIS PRESENT RE- SUBMITTAL. DM#47 - R/C 10/13/06 - IR 971725 11/16/2006 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 10/13/2006 12:00:00 AM I MET WT COLLIER CO PLANNER DAVE HEDRICH. HE INFORMED THAT SOTO'S "ABSOLUTE DUE DATE" FOR RESUBMITTAL OF THIS CURRENT SIP AR-9250 IS DEC 05, 06. - I LEFT PHONE MESSAGE (657- 5200) FOR RETURN CALL BY CARMEN SOTO, REGARDING SAME. RC/11- 20LCW View Details 975396 11/29/2006 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 11/20/2006 12:00:00 AM AS PER #48 DM AND #13 M.A. CONVERSATION ON 11-22-06 I COMPLETED AN "AFFIDAVIT OF NON- COMPIANCE" **PLEASE SCAN ATTACHED COPY** I ALSO CONTACTED CARMEN SOTO (657--5200) AND INFORMED OF View Details Page 838 of 5419 5/14/2024 10:37:19 AM SAME. I PROVIDED #28 P.P. WT. COPY OF AFF OF N/C. DM#47 R/C 12- 1-06 DSP 976075 1/16/2007 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 12/1/2006 12:00:00 AM AS PER MY PHONE CONVERSATION WT CARMEN SOTO (707-- 2437) SHE WILL RESUBMIT SIP AR 9250 LATER THIS WEEK. I INFORMED THAT FINES ARE ACCUMULATING DM#47 RCK 1- 26-07 DSP View Details 980707 1/25/2007 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 1/25/2007 12:00:00 AM AS PER MY CONVERSATION WT. COLLIER CO. PLANNER, DAVE HEDRICH, NO RESUBMITTAL OF SIP TO DATE. I PREPARED AN E-MAIL UPDATED STATUS OF COSTS & FINES & FORWARDED SAME TO H. ASHTON AND M. ARNOLD. R/C 2/5/07 - DM#47 - IR View Details 982448 2/13/2007 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 2/5/2007 12:00:00 AM AS PR COLLIER CO PLANNER HEDRICH, NO SIP RESUBMITTAL TO DATE. VIO REMAINS. DM#47 RCK. 2- 27-07 DSP View Details 984255 2/21/2007 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 2/21/2007 12:00:00 AM AS PER MY CONVERSATIN WT View Details Page 839 of 5419 5/14/2024 10:37:19 AM SUPERVISOR #28 PP, CEB CASE NO.2005090123 IS NOW TO BE FORWARDED TO CEB COORD M. BENDISA FOR "IMPOSITION OF FINES". I PROVIDED MS BENDISA WT A COPY OF MY AFFIDAVIT OF NON=- COMPLIANCE DATED NOV 29, 2006. RC/2- 27LCW 985421 2/27/2007 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 2/27/2007 12:00:00 AM CONFIRMED TAHT VIO REMAINS, I PREPARED A CURRENT "AFF OF NON- COMPLIACNE" & PROVIDED SAME TO CEB COORDINATOR THIS DAY. RC/3- 5LCW View Details 985598 3/2/2007 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 3/2/2007 12:00:00 AM I POSTED NOTICE OF HEARING FOR "I.O.F." AT SITE & AT COURT, HS. I TOOK PHOTOS AND DOWNLOADED SAME. I COMPLETED AN AFF. OF SERV. & PROVIDED SAME TO M. BENDISA. I CONTACTED CARMEN SOTO WHILE AT SITE & INFORMED OF MARCH 22, 07 CEB HEARING. R/C 3/9/07 - View Details Page 840 of 5419 5/14/2024 10:37:19 AM DM#47 - IR 986652 3/22/2007 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 3/22/2007 12:00:00 AM CEB IMPOSED FINES. MS. CARMEN SOTO ATTENDED MEETING & SPOKE TO THIS MATTER. SOTO'S WILL RE-SUBMIT THEIR SIP IN NEAR FUTURE. RCK 3/30/07 - DM#47 - IR *FINES TOTALED $93500.00 (FOR ALL 3 CASES) & WILL CONTINUE TO ACCRUE AT $250.00 PER DAY UNTIL ABATED. OPERATIONAL COSTS = $480.78 (PER CASE)* SEE ATTACHED View Details 988463 5/8/2007 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 5/8/2007 12:00:00 AM 47DM - AS PER MY MEETING WT COLLIER CO. PLANNER DAVE HEDRICH, STAR M/H PARK ONLY HAS ANOTHER 90 TO RE- SUBMIT. OUR LETTER WAS SENT ON 12/29/06 - I MADE PHONE CONTACT WT. CARMEN SOTO. SHE STATED "WILL RESUBMIT BY END OF THIS MONTH". RCK 5/28/07. ///MLC View Details 993492 6/8/2007 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 5/28/2007 12:00:00 AM I MET WT COLLIER CO View Details Page 841 of 5419 5/14/2024 10:37:19 AM PLANNER DAVE HEDRICH. HE INFORMED THAT THERE HAS BEEN NO RESUBMITTAL OF SIP TO DATE. OWNERS HAVE AN APPROX 45 DAYS LEFT TO RESUBMIT SIP- AR-9250, OR START OVER AGAIN. DM#47 RCK 6-29-07 DSP 997396 9/26/2007 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 6/29/2007 12:00:00 AM AS PER MY MEETING WT. COLLIER CO PLANNER, D. HEDRICH, CARMEN SOTO STATED THAT RESUBMITTAL SHOULD BE TURNED IN WITHIN THE NEXT 7-10 DAYS. #47DM RCK 10-2-07 DSP View Details 1010843 10/16/2007 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 10/2/2007 12:00:00 AM AS PER REQUEST I PREPARED AN UPDATED AFFIDAVIT OF NON COMPLIANCE FOR THE 10-25- 07 CEB HEARING. COPY ATTACHED. PLEASE SCAN CEB COORDINATOR RECEIVED COPY OF AFF THIS DAY. #47DM RCK 10- 24-07 DSP View Details 1013649 10/25/2007 CLOSE 10/24/2007 CEB ACCEPTED View Details Page 842 of 5419 5/14/2024 10:37:19 AM 12:00:00 AM 12:00:00 AM REQUEST TO FORWARD FORECLOSURE AUTHORIZATION ONTO COUNTY ATTY'S OFFICE FOR PROCESS. #47DM RCK 10- 31-07 DSP 1014576 11/21/2007 12:00:00 AM CLOSE 10/31/2007 12:00:00 AM AS PER MY MEETING WITH COLLIER CO. PLANNER D HEDRICH, NO RESUBMITTAL TO DATE. R/C 12/6/07 - JW44 View Details 1019004 OPEN 12/6/2007 12:00:00 AM View Details Violations Violation Nbr Group Code Status Description 221973 ILU 2.1.15. VIOLATION PROHIBITED USES AND STRUCTURES View Details Charges Board Nbr Type Status Start Date End Date Amount Total 652 2/17/2006 12:00:00 AM 10/12/2007 12:00:00 AM 250.00 150500.00 Code Boards CEBNbr Hearing Date Board Nbr Agency Status Total Amount Due 2005-43 11/18/2005 12:00:00 AM 652 102 DUE Page 843 of 5419 Report Title: Date: Code Case Details 5/14/2024 10:42:23 AM Case Number:2005090123 Case Information 2005090123Case Number: Case Type: Priority: Site Development Normal Inspector: Jurisdiction: Origin: perezcristina Collier County Code Enforcement Anonymous Complaint Detail Description:[CC_DESC:9/6/05 - IMMOKALEE INITIATIVE JS][CC_DISP:CEB 2005-43] Location Comments:[AO_LOC:00127680002][CC_LOC:1507 IMMOKALEE DR] LienedStatus: Date & Time Entered: Entered By: 9/6/2005 12:00:00 AM JoannShirly Case Disposition:Hearing Address 1507 Immokalee DR Immokalee, FL Property 127680002 Address Location Interested Party STAR MOBILE HOME PARK LLC Property Owner STAR MOBILE HOME PARK LLC Tenant STAR MOBILE HOME PARK LLC Violator STAR MOBILE HOME PARK LLC Contacts 1Business Management & Budget Office Page 844 of 5419 Execution Date 5/14/2024 10:42:23 AMCode Case Details Investigations Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 9/12/2005 9/19/2005 Closed [VISIT_NBR:918697][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:PREPARED "STATEMENT OF VIO. & REQUEST FOR HEARING" FORM & TURNED BACK-UP INFO. O Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 9/23/2005 9/27/2005 Closed [VISIT_NBR:921703][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:AS PER DAVE HEDRICH CARMEN SOTO CONTACTED COLLIER CO. PLANNER DAVE HEDRICH TODAY Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 9/30/2005 5/21/2008 Closed [VISIT_NBR:922753][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:( 10 M ) PLEASE SEE ATTACHED "EMAIL" FROM PLANNER DAVE HEDRICH, CONFIRMING THA Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 10/17/2005 10/17/2005 Closed [VISIT_NBR:924395][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:1 1/2 HRS - MET WT. IGNACIO & CARMEN SOTO AT THEIR PLACE OF BUSINESS IN IMMOK. - Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 10/26/2005 11/2/2005 Closed [VISIT_NBR:925392][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:SITE VISIT CONFIRMED THAT HURRICANE WILMA DID NOT EFFECT PROGRESS OF THIS CASE D Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 11/18/2005 11/18/2005 Violation(s) Found [VISIT_NBR:926431][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:11/18/05 ATTENDED CEB HEARING. MS. CARMEN SOTO REPRESENTED IGNACIO SOTO AT HEARI Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 12/29/2005 1/30/2006 Closed [VISIT_NBR:928638][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:I MADE PHONE CONTACT WT CARMEN SOTO ( 657-5200 ) I INFORMED OF FEB 16, 2006 DEAD Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 2/9/2006 2/9/2006 Closed [VISIT_NBR:937051][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:AS PER MY PHONE CONVERSATION WITH CARMEN SOTO (657-5200) THEIR "SDP WILL BE SUBM Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 9/6/2006 9/6/2006 Closed [VISIT_NBR:939230][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:CONFIRMED THROUGH COLLIER CO. PLANNER, DAVE HEDRICH THAT SIP AS9250 IS STILL IN Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 10/2/2006 10/2/2006 Closed [VISIT_NBR:966565][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:47DM-- I CONTACTED COLLIER CO. PLANNER HEDRICH BY PHONE. HE INFORMED THAT HE HA Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 10/4/2006 10/5/2006 Closed [VISIT_NBR:969810][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:I MADE EARLY AM PHONE CONTACT WT. CARMEN SOTO (657-- 5200) I INFORMED OF 10-6- Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 10/9/2006 10/9/2006 Closed [VISIT_NBR:970406][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:RE-SUBMITTAL NOT TURNED IN TO DATE. I MADE A;M PHONE CONTACT WT. CARMEN SOTO (6 Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 10/13/2006 11/16/2006 Closed [VISIT_NBR:971725][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:I MET WT COLLIER CO PLANNER DAVE HEDRICH. HE INFORMED THAT SOTO'S "ABSOLUTE DUE 2Business Management & Budget Office Page 845 of 5419 Execution Date 5/14/2024 10:42:23 AMCode Case Details Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 11/20/2006 11/29/2006 Closed [VISIT_NBR:975396][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:AS PER #48 DM AND #13 M.A. CONVERSATION ON 11-22-06 I COMPLETED AN "AFFIDAVIT O CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 11/20/2006 12/15/2011 Complete Per Director Diane Flagg, Pursuant to BCC direction, please place a "stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park code cases in Immokalee. Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 12/1/2006 1/16/2007 Closed [VISIT_NBR:976075][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:AS PER MY PHONE CONVERSATION WT CARMEN SOTO (707-- 2437) SHE WILL RESUBMIT SIP A Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 1/25/2007 1/25/2007 Closed [VISIT_NBR:980707][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:AS PER MY CONVERSATION WT. COLLIER CO. PLANNER, DAVE HEDRICH, NO RESUBMITTAL OF Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 2/5/2007 2/13/2007 Closed [VISIT_NBR:982448][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:AS PR COLLIER CO PLANNER HEDRICH, NO SIP RESUBMITTAL TO DATE. VIO REMAINS. DM# Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 2/21/2007 2/21/2007 Closed [VISIT_NBR:984255][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:AS PER MY CONVERSATIN WT SUPERVISOR #28 PP, CEB CASE NO.2005090123 IS NOW TO BE Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 2/27/2007 2/27/2007 Closed [VISIT_NBR:985421][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:CONFIRMED TAHT VIO REMAINS, I PREPARED A CURRENT "AFF OF NON-COMPLIACNE" & PROVI Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 3/2/2007 3/2/2007 Closed [VISIT_NBR:985598][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:I POSTED NOTICE OF HEARING FOR "I.O.F." AT SITE & AT COURT, HS. I TOOK PHOTOS AN Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 3/22/2007 3/22/2007 Closed [VISIT_NBR:986652][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:CEB IMPOSED FINES. MS. CARMEN SOTO ATTENDED MEETING & SPOKE TO THIS MATTER. SOT Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 5/8/2007 5/8/2007 Closed [VISIT_NBR:988463][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:47DM - AS PER MY MEETING WT COLLIER CO. PLANNER DAVE HEDRICH, STAR M/H PARK ONLY Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 5/28/2007 6/8/2007 Closed [VISIT_NBR:993492][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:I MET WT COLLIER CO PLANNER DAVE HEDRICH. HE INFORMED THAT THERE HAS BEEN NO RE Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 6/29/2007 9/26/2007 Closed [VISIT_NBR:997396][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:AS PER MY MEETING WT. COLLIER CO PLANNER, D. HEDRICH, CARMEN SOTO STATED THAT RE Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 10/2/2007 10/16/2007 Closed [VISIT_NBR:1010843][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:AS PER REQUEST I PREPARED AN UPDATED AFFIDAVIT OF NON COMPLIANCE FOR THE 10-25-0 3Business Management & Budget Office Page 846 of 5419 Execution Date 5/14/2024 10:42:23 AMCode Case Details Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 10/24/2007 10/25/2007 Non- Compliant [VISIT_NBR:1013649][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:CEB ACCEPTED REQUEST TO FORWARD FORECLOSURE AUTHORIZATION ONTO COUNTY ATTY'S OFF Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 10/31/2007 11/21/2007 Closed [VISIT_NBR:1014576][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:AS PER MY MEETING WITH COLLIER CO. PLANNER D HEDRICH, NO RESUBMITTAL TO DATE. R Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 12/6/2007 12/10/2007 Closed [VISIT_NBR:1019004][FINAL_COND:] [REMARKS:]As per my meeting with Collier County Planner David Hedrick, resubmittal of SIP-AR-9250 is still in a rejected state. Violation remains. R/C 01/07/08 Post Hearing Re-Inspection morad_e 2/7/2008 2/7/2008 Non- Compliant Met with Planner Mike Levy. The resubmittal of SIP-Ar9250 is still in rejected state. Mike gave me a copy of the seven page rejection letter sent to the owner with all the negative comments highlighted. Letter was scan into the case Update Picture(s)morad_e 2/7/2008 2/7/2008 Not Required CE Legal Review seabasty_j 2/7/2008 3/11/2008 Closed CE Staff Review deliciapulse 2/11/2008 2/11/2008 Complete 2005090123_SIP SCANED AND ATTACHED TO CASE SIP-AR-9250 Post Hearing Re-Inspection morad_e 3/11/2008 3/11/2008 Non- Compliant Update Picture(s)morad_e 3/11/2008 3/11/2008 Not Required CE Legal Review morad_e 3/11/2008 3/11/2008 Closed Initial Inspection perezcristina 3/31/2008 4/28/2008 Violation(s) Found 4-28-08 * AR # 9250 HAS BEEN RESUBMITTED. 7 REVIEWS IN PENDING STATUS AS OF 4-16-08. CURRENTLY ONE HAS BEEN COMPLETED, ONE HAS BEEN REJECTED AND 5 ARE PENDING REVIEWS. 11:38AM * ATTEMPTED TO CALL CARMEN SOTO 657-5200, NO ANSWER AND NO MACHINE - MESSAGING SYSTEM WAS FULL UNABLE TO LEAVE A MESSAGE. MONITOR FOR COUNTY REVIEWS TO BE COMPLETED. Post Hearing Re-Inspection morad_e 4/11/2008 3/31/2008 Not Required Turned case over to Inv. Perez Update Picture(s)perezcristina 4/28/2008 2/20/2009 Complete 4Business Management & Budget Office Page 847 of 5419 Execution Date 5/14/2024 10:42:23 AMCode Case Details Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments Re-Inspection perezcristina 5/16/2008 5/21/2008 Non- Compliant 5-21-08 * 2:43 - 2:48 * OBSERVED 10 REVIEWS. 4 ARE COMPLETED AND 6 ARE REJECTED. THE LAST REVIEW WAS COMPLETED ON MAY 13, 2008. REJECTION LETTER IN SYSTEM, IS DATED 5-13-08. ATTEMPTED TO CALL OWNERS DAUGHTER CARMEN (2:40PM) RECEIVED NO ANSWER AND WAS UNABLE TO LEAVE A PHONE MESSAGE. WILL CONTINUE TO MONITOR SIP PROGRESS AND FURTHER ATTEMPT OWNER CONTACT. CP79. Re-Inspection perezcristina 5/27/2008 6/3/2008 Non- Compliant 6-3-08 * 11:34am ATTEMPTED TO CALL OFFICE AGAIN NO ANSWER. MESSAGE BOX IS FULL AND UNABLE TO LEAVE A MESSAGE. WILL CONDUCT SITE VISIT TO ATTEMPT PERSONAL CONTACT. NOTHING HAS BEEN RESUBMITTED YET SINCE LAST REJECTION ON MAY 13, 2008. CP79. Re-Inspection perezcristina 6/5/2008 6/11/2008 Non- Compliant 6-10-09 * NO ANSWER @ CNTACT # FOUND. NO OTHER SUBMITTAL SINCE LAST REJECTION IN MAY. WILL ATTEMPT CONTACT THOUGHT SITE VISIT. NOT YET IN COMPLIANCE WITH COURT ORDER. CP79. CE Staff Review perezcristina 3/6/2009 3/6/2009 Complete OPEN CASE REPORT - CASE WAS HEARD BY CEB, VIOLATION REMAINS ATTEMPTING TO SUBMIT FOR SIP, FINES ACCURING, WILL RESEARCH FURTHER INFO AND TOT TO AREA INVESTIGATOR. CE Staff Review perezcristina 6/26/2009 6/26/2009 Complete OPEN CASE REPORT (6-26-09) Case was referred to County Attorney's Ofiice on 10-25- 07. Violation remains SIP for MH park has not been approved. CP79. CE Staff Review seabasty_j 8/31/2009 9/4/2009 Complete 8-31-09 OPEN CASE REPORT. See staff review notes this day (8-31-09) case closed per IHIP directive from Joe Schmitt. CE Case Research seabasty_j 8/31/2009 9/4/2009 Complete case may not be closed as this has been to hearing . you must check and see if this property is under forclosure. The fines from the case are still accruing. Ks93 CE Staff Review seabasty_j 8/31/2009 8/31/2009 Complete 8-31-09 11:55 AM. OPEN CASE REPORT. See direction of Joe Schmitt regarding IHIP Cases. From: seabasty_j Sent: Tuesday, July 07, 2009 7:42 AM To: SchmittJoseph Cc: seabasty_j Subject: RE: 2000 Immokalee Housing Initiative Program (IHIP) Good Morning Joe, I will proceed, thank you. Jim From: SchmittJoseph Sent: Monday, July 06, 2009 5:38 PM To: seabasty_j Cc: flagg_d; NoonanDick 5Business Management & Budget Office Page 848 of 5419 Execution Date 5/14/2024 10:42:23 AMCode Case Details Subject: RE: 2000 Immokalee Housing Initiative Program (IHIP) Correct. Proceed as stated. Joe Joseph K. Schmitt Administrator Community Development and Environmental Services Division office -- (239) 252-2385/2390 cell -- 595-9751 "Balancing the demands of growth and the demands of the community" From: seabasty_j Sent: Monday, July 06, 2009 2:46 PM To: SchmittJoseph Cc: flagg_d; NoonanDick; seabasty_j Subject: 2000 Immokalee Housing Initiative Program (IHIP) Re: 2000 Immokalee Initiative Housing Program Meeting 6-25-09 Good Afternoon Joe, Thank you for taking time from your busy schedule to meet with Dick Noonan and myself to discuss open (IHIP) cases that originated in the year 2000 to bring up the standard of living in the trailer parks in Immokalee. Since the option to apply for a site improvement plan, apply for and receive permits for trailers and receiving a certificate of occupancy for theses trailers has long passed that deadline we are now left with trailer parks that are not up to current code. Dick Noonan pointed out that many trailers were clandestinely replaced after the initial inspection by the building department without first obtaining a permit. Some of the properties have changed ownership since the initial program was started. It was my understanding that the way to proceed with these case would be to close all open (IHIP) cases due to the lapse in time and open new cases to insure adequate living facilities for the residents according to current code. This now would require a site improvement plan, permits for all trailers and the proper density of trailers allowed on each site. If I misunderstood your direction, please let me know, otherwise, I’ll proceed with closing these cases and opening new ones. Thank you. CE Staff Review ColleenDavids on 9/2/2009 9/2/2009 Complete Forward to CAO on 10/25/2007 by CEB-CD CE Staff Review seabasty_j 9/4/2009 9/4/2009 Complete 9-4-09 8:16 AM. OPEN CASE REPORT. No Lis Pendance or Foreclosure activity at this time. Will attempt to have COA move on this case. 6Business Management & Budget Office Page 849 of 5419 Execution Date 5/14/2024 10:42:23 AMCode Case Details Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments CE Staff Review seabasty_j 9/22/2009 9/24/2009 Complete 9-24-09 12:07 PM. OPEN CASE REPORT. Will send another e-mail to Jeff Wright (CAO) to review all open cases. CE Staff Review seabasty_j 10/22/2009 10/12/2009 Complete 10-12-09 OPEN CASE REPORT Met Jeff Wright on 10-8-09 in Christina Perez's office. We discussed CEB cases as well as OSM case where finds have been accuring. We also discussed open cases which have been on the books for a long time. Jeff needs a little more time to research some of these cases. CE Staff Review seabasty_j 10/22/2009 9/29/2009 Complete 9-29-09 9:36 AM. OPEN CASE REPORT. This case will be discussed with Jeff Wright along with the other outstanding IHIP cases still in open status. E-mail sent to jeff Wright reminding him of these cases. CE Staff Review seabasty_j 10/29/2009 10/29/2009 Complete 10-29-09 OPEN CASE REPORT Case was referred to County Attorney's Ofiice on 10 -25-07. Violation remains SIP for MH park has not been approved. CP79. 10-12-09 OPEN CASE REPORT Met Jeff Wright on 10-8-09 in Christina Perez's office. We discussed CEB cases as well as OSM case where finds have been accuring. We also discussed open cases which have been on the books for a long time. Jeff needs a little more time to research some of these cases. CE Staff Review seabasty_j 10/29/2009 10/29/2009 Complete 10-29-09 OPEN CASE REPORT Case was referred to County Attorney's Ofiice on 10 -25-07. Violation remains SIP for MH park has not been approved. CP79. 10-12-09 OPEN CASE REPORT Met Jeff Wright on 10-8-09 in Christina Perez's office. We discussed CEB cases as well as OSM case where finds have been accuring. We also discussed open cases which have been on the books for a long time. Jeff needs a little more time to research some of these cases. CE Staff Review seabasty_j 11/30/2009 11/30/2009 Complete 11-30-09 11:55 AM. OPEN CASE REPORT Case was referred to County Attorney's Ofiice on 10-25-07. Violation remains SIP for MH park has not been approved. CE Staff Review seabasty_j 12/21/2009 12/21/2009 Complete 12-21-09 OPEN CASE REPORT Case was referred to County Attorney's Ofiice on 10 -25-07. Violation remains SIP for MH park has not been approved. CE Staff Review seabasty_j 1/28/2010 1/29/2010 Complete 1-29-10 OPEN CASE REPORT Case was referred to County Attorney's Ofiice on 10 -25-07. Violation remains SIP for MH park has not been approved. 7Business Management & Budget Office Page 850 of 5419 Execution Date 5/14/2024 10:42:23 AMCode Case Details Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments CE Staff Review seabasty_j 2/26/2010 2/26/2010 Complete 2-26-10 OPEN CASE REPORT Case was referred to County Attorney's Ofiice on 10 -25-07. Violation remains SIP for MH park has not been approved. open case report 2/26/10 hearing date 11/18/05 imposition of fines date 3/27/07 to the CAO office 10/25/07 CE Staff Review kitchellsnow 3/2/2010 3/2/2010 Complete open case report 2/26/10 hearing date 11/18/05 imposition of fines date 3/27/07 CE Staff Review seabasty_j 3/30/2010 3/30/2010 Complete OPEN CASE REPORT 3-30-10 Hearing date 11/18/05, imposition of fines date 3/27/07, to cao office 10/25/07. JS14 CE Staff Review seabasty_j 4/30/2010 4/30/2010 Complete 4-30-10 OPEN CASE REPORT Hearing date 11/18/05, imposition of fines date 3/27/07, to cao office 10/25/07. JS14 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 6/4/2010 6/4/2010 Complete Open case report:06-04-10 Hearing date 11/18/05, imposition of fines date 3/27/07, to cao office 10/25/07. On 06-04-10 spoke with property owner daughter Carmen who stated that she was working with an Eng. to resubmit the SIP will continue to monitor for submittal. MR/49 Open case report 07-06-10 Spoke with property owner daughter stated that she was still working with the ENG to resubmit SIP will continue to monitor. MR/49 Open case report 08-05-10 spoke to carmen who stated that she taking all the information to the Eng next week to start the process to resubmit for SIP will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 8/5/2010 8/5/2010 Complete Spoke to carmen who stated that she would be meeting the Eng to review the old SIP to see what changes needed to be done. will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 9/6/2010 9/9/2010 Complete Open case report:06-04-10 Hearing date 11/18/05, imposition of fines date 3/27/07, to cao office 10/25/07. On 09-08-10 Spoke with carmen she stated that the Eng (H & L Bennett) would be scheduling the preapp meeeting for the SIP. Will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 10/11/2010 10/11/2010 Complete Open case report:10-11-10 Hearing date 11/18/05, imposition of fines date 3/27/07, to cao office 10/25/07Spoke to carmen Soto preapp meeting has not been scheduled will continue to monitor reck in one week. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 10/18/2010 10/19/2010 Complete Property owner has scheduled a preapp meeting with zoning on 10-25-10 will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 11/1/2010 11/1/2010 Complete Preapp meeting scheduled for 11-16-10 with Mike Sawyer will continue to monitor. MR/49 8Business Management & Budget Office Page 851 of 5419 Execution Date 5/14/2024 10:42:23 AMCode Case Details Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 11/17/2010 11/17/2010 Complete Pre hearing was rescheduled 12/08/10 at 1:30 will continue to monitor CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 12/8/2010 12/9/2010 Complete I received a call from the Eng H & L Bennett spoke with Augustin who stated that the pre hearing was today and would be submitting required documents for the SIP in two week will reck in two week to see if they submitted. CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 12/23/2010 12/31/2010 Complete No sip has been submitted at this time will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 1/19/2011 1/20/2011 Complete Property owner did not submit SIP as of today will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Case Research MariaRodrigu ez 2/21/2011 2/23/2011 Complete property owner applied for SIP will monitor for sip to be approved. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 3/9/2011 3/10/2011 Complete SIP is still under reveiw wil continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Case Research MariaRodrigu ez 4/7/2011 4/8/2011 Complete SIP is still under review will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 5/6/2011 5/6/2011 Complete SIP is still under review will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 6/3/2011 6/6/2011 Complete SIP is still under review will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 7/6/2011 7/6/2011 Complete on site observed vioaltion remains SIP is still under review I tc the eng H & L Bennett spoke to Augustine stated that he was still waiting for answer from zonning will reck in a week. MR/49 Legacy Inspection mazzone_d 7/13/2011 9/8/2005 Closed [VISIT_NBR:918023][FINAL_COND:NONE] [REMARKS:2 HRS - RESEARCHED INFORMATION PERTAINING TO ALL FIVE PARCELS THAT MAKE UP THE M CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 7/13/2011 7/14/2011 Complete SIP is still under review will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 8/15/2011 8/15/2011 Complete SIP is still under review will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 9/15/2011 9/16/2011 Complete Spoke to property owner she stated that no word from zonning dept at this time but is waiting to move on the sip will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 9/28/2011 9/30/2011 Complete Zoining remains pending on SIP review will continue to monitor until approved or rejected. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 10/11/2011 10/11/2011 Complete Zoining remains pending on SIP review will continue to monitor until approved or rejected. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 11/1/2011 11/2/2011 Complete SIP has been rejected with zoning spoke to Supervisor Snow and asked what was the procedure for the Settlement Agreement Mr. Snow stated that they needed to call Mike Levy to set an appointment with Ray Bellow and Mike sawyer to discuss the deviation associated with property will continue to monitor. MR/49 9Business Management & Budget Office Page 852 of 5419 Execution Date 5/14/2024 10:42:23 AMCode Case Details Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 11/30/2011 12/1/2011 Complete property owner and the eng alonwg with code will be having a meeting on Friday 12-10-11 as to what is need for the sip. CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 12/5/2011 12/6/2011 Complete property owner and the eng alonwg with code will be having a meeting on Friday 12-10-11 as to what is need for the sip. CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 12/30/2011 12/30/2011 Complete Per Director Diane Flagg, Pursuant to BCC direction, please place a "stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park code cases in Immokalee. CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 2/8/2012 2/13/2012 Complete Per Director Diane Flagg, Pursuant to BCC direction, please place a "stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park code cases in Immokalee. CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 3/7/2012 3/7/2012 Complete Per Director Diane Flagg, Pursuant to BCC direction, please place a "stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park code cases in Immokalee. Spoke to property owner stated that eng would be submitting corrections and requesting a settlement agreement will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 4/4/2012 4/5/2012 Complete Per Director Diane Flagg, Pursuant to BCC direction, please place a "stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park code cases in Immokalee. Spoke to property owner stated that eng would be submitting corrections and requesting a settlement agreement will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 5/3/2012 5/3/2012 Complete Per Director Diane Flagg, Pursuant to BCC direction, please place a "stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park code cases in Immokalee. Spoke to property owner stated that eng would be submitting corrections and requesting a settlement agreement will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 6/4/2012 6/11/2012 Complete Per Director Diane Flagg, Pursuant to BCC direction, please place a "stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park code cases in Immokalee. Spoke to property owner stated that eng would be submitting corrections and requesting a settlement agreement will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Case Research MariaRodrigu ez 7/11/2012 7/12/2012 Complete No changes Per Director Diane Flagg, Pursuant to BCC direction, please place a "stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park code cases in Immokalee. Spoke to property owner stated that eng would be submitting corrections and requesting a settlement agreement will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 8/21/2012 8/22/2012 Complete Pursuant to BCC direction, please place a "stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park code cases in Immokalee. 10Business Management & Budget Office Page 853 of 5419 Execution Date 5/14/2024 10:42:23 AMCode Case Details Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments CE Case Research MariaRodrigu ez 9/24/2012 9/24/2012 Complete Pursuant to BCC direction, please place a "stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park code cases in Immokalee. CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 10/24/2012 10/25/2012 Complete Per Director Diane Flagg, Pursuant to BCC direction, please place a "stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park code cases in Immokalee. Spoke to property owner stated that eng would be submitting corrections and requesting a settlement agreement will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Case Research MariaRodrigu ez 11/26/2012 11/27/2012 Complete Per Director Diane Flagg, Pursuant to BCC direction, please place a "stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park code cases in Immokalee. Spoke to property owner stated that eng would be submitting corrections and requesting a settlement agreement will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 12/27/2012 12/28/2012 Complete Per Director Diane Flagg, Pursuant to BCC direction, please place a "stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park code cases in Immokalee. Spoke to property owner stated that eng would be submitting corrections and requesting a settlement agreement will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Case Research MariaRodrigu ez 1/28/2013 1/29/2013 Not Required Per Director Diane Flagg, Pursuant to BCC direction, please place a "stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park code cases in Immokalee. Spoke to property owner stated that eng would be submitting corrections and requesting a settlement agreement will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 2/28/2013 3/5/2013 Complete The stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park remains will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 5/6/2013 5/8/2013 Complete The stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park remains will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 7/8/2013 7/8/2013 Complete The stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park remains will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 9/9/2013 9/9/2013 Complete The stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park remains will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 11/8/2013 11/13/2013 Complete The stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park remains will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 12/13/2013 12/13/2013 Complete The stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park remains will continue to monitor. MR/49 CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 1/23/2014 1/24/2014 Complete SIP was submitted. Only rejection is date limitation in the LDC. Hearing Examiner Mark Strain was advised owner wants to proceed with SIP and he will work on a settlement for this park. All cases are on hold pending resolution. CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 2/24/2014 2/24/2014 Complete SIP was submitted. Only rejection is date limitation in the LDC. Hearing Examiner Mark Strain was advised owner wants to proceed with SIP and he will work on a settlement for this park. All cases are on hold pending resolution. 11Business Management & Budget Office Page 854 of 5419 Execution Date 5/14/2024 10:42:23 AMCode Case Details Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 3/24/2014 3/24/2014 Complete SIP was submitted. Only rejection is date limitation in the LDC. Hearing Examiner Mark Strain was advised owner wants to proceed with SIP and he will work on a settlement for this park. All cases are on hold pending resolution. CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 4/24/2014 4/9/2014 Complete SIP was submitted. Only rejection is date limitation in the LDC. Hearing Examiner Mark Strain was advised owner wants to proceed with SIP and he will work on a settlement for this park. All cases are on hold pending resolution. CE Staff Review MariaRodrigu ez 5/1/2014 5/1/2014 Complete SIP was submitted. Only rejection is date limitation in the LDC. Hearing Examiner Mark Strain was advised owner wants to proceed with SIP and he will work on a settlement for this park. All cases are on hold pending resolution. CE Staff Review perezcristina 5/28/2014 6/2/2014 Complete “QA, case open with no pending activities. Last completed activity was (5/1). Please review to add new activity or next action. (DC)” CE Staff Review DannyCondo mina 5/28/2014 5/28/2014 Complete QA, case open with no pending activities. Last completed activity was (5/1). Re-Inspection MariaRodrigu ez 6/3/2014 6/3/2014 Non- Compliant On site violation remains no changes and All cases are on hold pending resolution. Re-Inspection MariaRodrigu ez 7/4/2014 7/8/2014 Non- Compliant Pursuant to BCC direction, please place a "stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park code cases in Immokalee Re-Inspection MariaRodrigu ez 8/8/2014 8/8/2014 Non- Compliant Pursuant to BCC direction, please place a "stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park code cases in Immokalee Re-Inspection MariaRodrigu ez 9/9/2014 9/10/2014 Non- Compliant Pursuant to BCC direction, please place a "stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park code cases in Immokalee Re-Inspection MariaRodrigu ez 10/10/2014 10/20/2014 Non- Compliant Pursuant to BCC direction, please place a "stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park code cases in Immokalee Re-Inspection MariaRodrigu ez 11/21/2014 12/1/2014 Non- Compliant Pursuant to BCC direction, please place a "stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park code cases in Immokalee Re-Inspection MariaRodrigu ez 1/2/2015 1/5/2015 Non- Compliant "stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park code cases in Immokalee Re-Inspection MariaRodrigu ez 2/6/2015 2/9/2015 Non- Compliant No determinations on mobile home parks "stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park code cases in Immokalee will continue. MR/49 Re-Inspection MariaRodrigu ez 3/10/2015 3/10/2015 Non- Compliant No determinations on mobile home parks "stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park code cases in Immokalee will continue. MR/49 Re-Inspection MariaRodrigu ez 4/10/2015 4/13/2015 Non- Compliant No determinations on mobile home parks "stay on enforcement" of all Mobile Home Park code cases in Immokalee will continue. MR/49 12Business Management & Budget Office Page 855 of 5419 Execution Date 5/14/2024 10:42:23 AMCode Case Details Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments Re-Inspection MariaRodrigu ez 5/14/2015 5/14/2015 Non- Compliant No permits found in cityview owners remain the same and no determinations on mobile home parks will continue to monitor. MR/49 Re-Inspection MariaRodrigu ez 6/15/2015 6/15/2015 Non- Compliant On site observed mobile home park and will continue to monitor until BCC takes the hold off mobile home parks. MR/49 Re-Inspection MariaRodrigu ez 7/16/2015 7/21/2015 Non- Compliant On site observed all mobile homes remain and the hold on mobile home parks remain per BCC will continue to monitor. MR/49 Re-Inspection MariaRodrigu ez 8/24/2015 8/25/2015 Non- Compliant On site observed all mobile homes remain and no permit is apply status for park. The hold on mobile home parks remain per BCC will continue to monitor. MR/49 Verify Complainant MariaRodrigu ez 9/30/2015 9/30/2015 Complete Re-Inspection MariaRodrigu ez 10/1/2015 9/30/2015 Non- Compliant On site observed mobile home park remain researched cityview and owner has not applied for an SIP violation remains.The Stay on enforcement on mobile home park will continue to monitor. MR/49 Re-Inspection JosephMucha 1/4/2016 1/6/2016 Non- Compliant I have not been advised on any new information regarding mobile home parks in Immokalee. I will continue to monitor. Re-Inspection JosephMucha 4/6/2016 4/6/2016 Non- Compliant I have not been advised on any new information regarding mobile home parks in Immokalee. I will continue to monitor. Re-Inspection JosephMucha 7/6/2016 7/6/2016 Non- Compliant There are pending changes to the LDC in regards to mobile home parks in Immokalee. I will continue to monitor until these changes are approved by the BCC. Re-Inspection JosephMucha 10/13/2016 10/26/2016 Non- Compliant I received the following email from Mark Strain: The Board approved new standards for site plan submittals for Immokalee mobile home lots and parks. They did this at their first meeting upon returning from vacation. The Admin Code has been updated and the application for this new process is supposed to go online tomorrow. Once it is online the stakeholders will be notified to come in and start applying per the new code. I will start notifying mobile home park owners of the change to the code and the need to apply for an SIP if applicable. Re-Inspection JosephMucha 11/29/2016 12/7/2016 Non- Compliant I spoke to Caroline Cilek. She advises that she has not received any SIP applications yet. She advises to give it a few months as this is a new process and there is some expense involved. Re-Inspection JohnConnetta 3/22/2017 3/22/2017 Non- Compliant 3/22/2017 On site Violation remains. Spoke with Carmen Soto who is aware of the new standards for the site improvement plan and stated that she is having someone work on the new SIP which should be ready within a couple of weeks. Fines continue to accrue. Will continue to monitor. R/c JC-16 13Business Management & Budget Office Page 856 of 5419 Execution Date 5/14/2024 10:42:23 AMCode Case Details Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments Re-Inspection Joseph Mucha 4/25/2017 4/26/2017 Non- Compliant 4/24/2017 On site NOH. When last spoke with Carmen Soto she stated that she had someone preparing the new SIP and once it is finished they will submit them to the County. Will continue to monitor. R/c JC-16. no exchangeURL Re-Inspection JosephMucha 6/6/2017 6/7/2017 Non- Compliant No SIP has been submitted. Owner is aware of the new SIP process. Continue to monitor. JM Re-Inspection perezcristina 10/26/2017 11/2/2017 Non- Compliant 11/2/17 2:40pm This case has been to the Code Enforcement Board and is accuring daily fines. I have previously discussed with Property Owner Carmen Soto, the 90 days grace period provided by the Board if County Commissioners to remove and replace the mobile homes that we damaged by hurricane Irma. I also discussed the newest regulations in the Land Development Code regarding the Site Improvement Plan submittal requirements to get a park approved through that process. Today I emailed her a copy of the requirements. CP79. Re-Inspection perezcristina 12/1/2017 12/14/2017 Non- Compliant Owner is currently working with Mr. Jackie Williams to obtain demo permits for some Mobile Homes that were severlydamaged durring hurrican Irma. Once those demos are complete owner will continue moving towards compliance of the SIP. CP79. Re-Inspection perezcristina 1/5/2018 1/19/2018 Non- Compliant no SIP has been applied for, owner is dealing with sevreal damaged mobile homes from hurricane Irma. Re-Inspection perezcristina 3/6/2018 3/14/2018 Non- Compliant No SIP has been applied for, owner continues to deal with several damaged mobile homes from hurricane Irma. There is another case opened to address that situation. CP79. Re-Inspection perezcristina 4/2/2018 4/11/2018 Non- Compliant No submittal on the SIP process, mobile home park owner has been issued demo permits for destroyed mobile homes within park. Will continue to monitor for compliance. CP79. Re-Inspection perezcristina 6/15/2018 6/26/2018 Non- Compliant 6/22/18 Spoke with Carmen Soto who advised she has hired HL Bennette to work on the Site Improvement Plan (SIP) for the mobile home park. Several mobile homes that were damaged from hurricane Irma have been removed and owner is looking to complete the SIP to replaced the removed structures. CP79 14Business Management & Budget Office Page 857 of 5419 Execution Date 5/14/2024 10:42:23 AMCode Case Details Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments Re-Inspection perezcristina 8/1/2018 8/14/2018 Non- Compliant 8/14/18 Called Carmen Soto at 239-707-2437 5:22pm, left her a voice mail to follow up with me regarding the status of resubmitting for the SIP. Ms. Soto was working on removing several mobile home's via demo permit and has plans of install new mobile homes. She is aware the SIP is needed in order for permits to be issued for installation. Also reminded her to call in the inspections on the demo permits once the structures and litter are all removed, permits expired end of September. CP79. Re-Inspection christopheram bach 9/14/2018 9/28/2018 Non- Compliant Monitoring progress. Re-Inspection christopheram bach 9/29/2018 10/2/2018 Non- Compliant monitoring Re-Inspection christopheram bach 10/25/2018 10/30/2018 Non- Compliant Re submitted for SIP Oct 18th 2018... monitoring. Re-Inspection christopheram bach 12/3/2018 12/5/2018 Non- Compliant PRBD20180014966 reactivated to remove destroyed mobile Home.. monitoring. Re-Inspection christopheram bach 1/8/2019 1/14/2019 Non- Compliant PRBD20180014966 reactivated and issued status. Monitoring permit. Re-Inspection christopheram bach 1/18/2019 2/5/2019 Non- Compliant monitoring permit. Re-Inspection christopheram bach 2/20/2019 2/25/2019 Non- Compliant Permit expired. Re-Inspection christopheram bach 3/27/2019 3/25/2019 Non- Compliant no changes. Monitoring..exp 2018 demo permit on file. Re-Inspection christopheram bach 5/2/2019 5/14/2019 Non- Compliant Demo permit finaled on 4/30/19 so SIP as of today. Monitoring Re-Inspection christopheram bach 8/30/2019 9/6/2019 Non- Compliant I will be meeting with Alimar Smiley permitting/zoning next week to discuss this and two other old SIP cases to see where they are in the process. Re-Inspection christopheram bach 9/12/2019 9/16/2019 Non- Compliant Continue to monitor Re-Inspection christopheram bach 10/3/2019 10/1/2019 Non- Compliant Continue to monitor Re-Inspection christopheram bach 11/1/2019 11/5/2019 Non- Compliant Continue to monitor Re-Inspection christopheram bach 12/13/2019 12/13/2019 Non- Compliant Continue to monitor Re-Inspection christopheram bach 2/14/2020 2/26/2020 Non- Compliant Continue to monitor Re-Inspection christopheram bach 3/26/2020 3/30/2020 Non- Compliant Monitor Re-Inspection christopheram bach 4/30/2020 5/1/2020 Non- Compliant Monitoring Re-Inspection christopheram bach 7/7/2020 7/9/2020 Non- Compliant Monitoring Re-Inspection christopheram bach 9/4/2020 9/4/2020 Non- Compliant monitoring 15Business Management & Budget Office Page 858 of 5419 Execution Date 5/14/2024 10:42:23 AMCode Case Details Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments Re-Inspection christopheram bach 11/12/2020 11/19/2020 Non- Compliant monitoring Re-Inspection christopheram bach 1/14/2021 1/20/2021 Non- Compliant monitoring Re-Inspection christopheram bach 3/18/2021 3/22/2021 Non- Compliant monitoring Re-Inspection christopheram bach 6/2/2021 6/7/2021 Non- Compliant monitoring Re-Inspection christopheram bach 8/31/2021 9/14/2021 Non- Compliant Re-Inspection christopheram bach 10/28/2021 11/12/2021 Non- Compliant monitoring Re-Inspection christopheram bach 12/22/2021 12/29/2021 Non- Compliant monitoring Re-Inspection christopheram bach 3/3/2022 3/9/2022 Non- Compliant monitoring Re-Inspection christopheram bach 5/12/2022 6/24/2022 Non- Compliant Re-Inspection christopheram bach 6/25/2022 6/30/2022 Non- Compliant Re-Inspection christopheram bach 10/4/2022 10/5/2022 Non- Compliant Re-Inspection christopheram bach 1/12/2023 1/31/2023 Non- Compliant Re-Inspection perezcristina 4/6/2023 4/20/2023 Non- Compliant 4.20.2023 - Email sent to property owner representative Carmen Soto, requesting a call back to discuss open case. Review of related items found a submittal for a Site Improvement Plan was made in September 2022, PL20220006212 for Star Mobile Home Park (SIP). A correction letter was completed on 2.1.2023. Will monitor for call back and SIP resubmital. Mobile Home park remains in site. CP79. Re-Inspection perezcristina 5/1/2023 5/4/2023 Non- Compliant 5.2.2023 Called property owner Carmen Soto 239-707-0028, discussed point of contact for cases, she advised to call her as would like to keep her husband aware of the process to legalize the mobile home park. I explained here is a rejection letter that was issued a few weeks ago and we can provide her a copy. At her request due to language barrier used google translator to translate the last SIP Correction letter to provide her a copy. CP79. Re-Inspection perezcristina 8/1/2023 8/7/2023 Non- Compliant 08/07/2023 Email send to owner's agent who submitted for the SIP, Victoria Soto. I provided copy of the case finding of fact order and imposition of fines order advising that daily fines continue to accrue (docuemnts attached to case documents and images). Mrs. Soto replied they are working on the corrections which are more minim. Setback were all approved, she is currently out of town but will return this week and stop by the office to further discuss. CP79. 16Business Management & Budget Office Page 859 of 5419 Execution Date 5/14/2024 10:42:23 AMCode Case Details Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments Re-Inspection perezcristina 9/1/2023 9/1/2023 Non- Compliant Re-viewed SIP application and found no re- submittals have been made, email was sent to SIP applicant, Victoria Soto, advising/reminding of the resubmittal deadline of October 29, 2023. Previous email communication with Mrs. Soto they are working on the SIP corrections. PerezCristina 09/01/2023 10:38 AM Re-Inspection perezcristina 10/2/2023 10/5/2023 Non- Compliant 10.5.23 SIP application remains in rejection status. Email sent to applicant Victoria Soto reminding her of the resubmittal deadline and advising they may have to request an extension if resubmital is after the deadline of 10.29.2023. Mobile home park remains open, daily fines continue to occur. I met with Mr. Ignacio Soto the park owner, on 9.11.23; Victoria Soto is his daughter-in-law and is assisting him with the SIP process. Mr. Soto advised he was unaware he had not complied with County in regards to the status of the mobile home park. The property was previously under management of someone else whom he thought had addressed any issues and he says he was not aware the park was occurring daily fines until recently when i made contact with Victoria and explained the open code case, hearing order and daily fines. They had started the SIP process because that were told that was the only way they could get permits issued to install new mobile homes. CP79 Re-Inspection perezcristina 11/1/2023 11/1/2023 Non- Compliant 11.1.23 Received email from owner's relative Victoria Soto advising the SIP Application PL20220006212 had been resubmitted, reviewed the SIP application and found its currently under review. Fire has approved their review, there are two reviews pending from addressing and zoning due 11.15.23. Will monitoring for review completion for SIP outcome. CP79. Re-Inspection perezcristina 11/17/2023 12/1/2023 Non- Compliant 12.1.23 - The SIP that was under reivew has been requested as of 11.16.23. Copy of the Comment Letter will be emailed to owner's representative Victoria Soto for her review. CP79 Re-Inspection perezcristina 2/2/2024 2/2/2024 Non- Compliant 2.2.2024: SIP application for the mobile home park PL20220006212 is under review, last resubmittal was made on 1.17.2024, 2 review have been approved, the addressing review remains pending and is due 2.7.2024. Will continue to monitor for reviews to be completed. CP79. 17Business Management & Budget Office Page 860 of 5419 Execution Date 5/14/2024 10:42:23 AMCode Case Details Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments Re-Inspection perezcristina 2/12/2024 2/27/2024 Compliant 2.27.2024 Email discussion with Zoning Planner Stefanie Nawrocki who confirmed the Site Improvement Plan was approved on February 2nd, 2024. Stefenie confirms the SIP automatically approves all the existing improvements on the property and no additional permits are required, any new improvements would require building permit is applicable. Review of the letter does not indicate any conditions needed to be completed, information is noted as informational. Order reviewed to completed the Affidavid of Compliance. CP79. Enter Case Disposition perezcristina 2/27/2024 3/7/2024 Complete Verify Conditions & Close Case perezcristina 3/7/2024 3/7/2024 Complete CE Staff Review helenbuchillon 3/7/2024 3/14/2024 Complete 3/14/24 Scanned & attached notarized AOC – HB Affidavit of Compliance attached to documents and images. CP79. Waiting For Liens to be Released 11/1/2027 3/14/2024 Complete Violations Violation Description Status Entered Corrected Amount Comments PROHIBITED USES AND STRUCTURES Open 9/8/2005 $0 [NBR:221973][FIN:][CODE:2.1.15.][GRP:ILU] Hearings Title Reason Result Compliance Fine/Day Condition 18Business Management & Budget Office Page 861 of 5419 Page 862 of 5419 Page 863 of 5419 Page 864 of 5419 Page 865 of 5419 Page 866 of 5419 Page 867 of 5419 Page 868 of 5419 Page 869 of 5419 Page 870 of 5419 4090436 OR:4298 PG:0631Retn: NAPLES FL 34104 CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Petitioner,CEB NO.2005-43 vs. IGNACIO SOTO, FOR STAR MOBILE HOME PARK LLC, Respondents CORRECTED ORDER IMPOSING FINE/LIEN Nunc pro tunc THIS CAUSE came on for public hearing before the Board on November 18,2005,after due notice to Respondents at which time the Board heard testimony under oath,received evidence,and issued its Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and thereupon issued its oral Order which was reduced to writing on November 23, 2005 and furnished to Respondents and was recorded in the Public Records of Collier County,Florida at OR 3941, PG 0975,et.seq.on December 5,2005. An Affidavit of Non-Compliance has been filed with the Board by the Code Enforcement Official on February 27,2007,which Affidavit certified under oath that the required corrective action has not been taken as ordered. Accordingly,it having been brought to the Board's attention that Respondent has not complied with the Order dated February 2,2007,it is hereby ORDERED,that the Respondent,Ignacio Soto,pay to Collier County fines in the amount of $93,500 for the period of February 17,2006 through February 26,2007 at a rate of $250 per day,plus $480.78 for the operational costs incurred in the prosecution of this case for a total of $93,980.78. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the fines and operational costs shall continue to accrue until Respondent comes into compliance or until Judgment is rendered in a suit to foreclose on a lien filed pursuant to Section 162.09 18.50 CODE BNFORCEMENT RECORDED in the OPFICIAL RECORDS of COLLIER COUNTY,FL REC ERE2800NHORSESHOBDR11/01/2007 at 11:09AM DWIGHT B.BROCK,CLERK Page 871 of 5419 Florida Statutes. xxx OR:4298 PG:0632 *** Any aggrieved party may appeal a final order of the Board to the Circuit Court within thirty (30)days of the execution of the Order appealed.An appeal shall not be a hearing de novo,but shall be limited to appellate review of the record created within.Filing an Appeal shall not stay the Board's Order. This Order may be recorded and shall,pursuant to Section 162.09,Florida Statutes,constitute a lien against the property as described and/or any other real or personal property owned by Respondents. 2007 at Collier County,Florida . > DONE AND ORDERED this 27th day of March,2007 and re-signed this day of CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUN BY: STATE OF FLORIDA) )SS: COUNTY OF COLLIER) Kenneth Kelly,Vice Chair 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples,Florida 34104 hay of October,2007,by personally The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this known to me or who has produced a Florida Driver's License as identification. Kenneth Kelly,Vice Chair of the Code Enforcement Board of Collier County,Florida,who is KRISTINE HOLTON MY COMISSION #DD 686595 EXPIRES:June 18,2011 NOTARY PUBLIC My commission expires: ERTIFICATE OF SERVICE Bonded Thru Notary Public Unders riters I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of this CORRECTED ORDER has been sent by U.S. Mail to Ignacio Soto,Star Mobile Home Park,LLC,1507 West Immo kalee Driv Immokalee Florida 34142 and to Richard Shaw,RA,813 Monroe Court,Immokalee,Florida 34142 this day of Ccda ners 2007. State of FLORIDA Sounty of COLLIER |HEREBY CERTIFY THAT this Is a true and DWIGHT E.BROGK,CLERK OF COURTS M.Jean Rawson,Esq. Florida Bar No.750311 Attorney for the Code Enforcement Board 400 Fifth Avenue S.,Ste.300 Naples,Florida 34102 (239)263-8206 correct capy ot a ao".on file in Board Minutes ars éCottler County my day eal this Page 872 of 5419 Page 873 of 5419 Page 874 of 5419