Agenda 10/22/2024 Item #16B19 (Execute Grant Agreemnt between BCC and Florida Dept. of Environmental Protection for reimbursement for Collier County Beach Renourishment Projects)10/22/2024
Item # 16.B.19
ID# 2024-1192
Executive Summary
Recommendation to accept the award and authorize the Chairman to execute Grant Agreement No. 24CO1 between
Collier County Board of County Commissioners and the Florida Department of Environmental Protection for funding
reimbursement and support for Collier County Beach Renourishment Projects.
OBJECTIVE: To accept the award and execute the grant agreement with the Florida Department of Environmental
Protection (FDEP) for the reimbursement of the County’s beach and inlet maintenance projects.
CONSIDERATIONS: Collier County Beach Nourishment works with FDEP Bureau of Beaches and Coastal Systems
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program to provide funding for monitoring and renourishment. Beach
monitoring is the process of collecting and analyzing data to determine beach and water quality and can also include
water quality testing, public notification, beach condition assessment, shore and reef assessments, database maintenance,
sand measurement and surface model creation. The monitoring is required by state permit for beach renourishment and
takes place annually. Each year, applications are submitted by Local Government Funding Request (LGFR) process for
the Beach Management Funding Assistance Program. The LGFR for this award was approved by the Board of County
Commissioners (BCC) as agenda item 16B4 on July 25, 2023.
This item is consistent with the Quality of Place Objectives of the County’s Strategic Plan.
FISCAL IMPACT: Execution of this FDEP grant will provide for partial cost-share reimbursement of up to 42.38% for
the design and monitoring (annual required physical and biological surveys) for the Vanderbilt, Park Shore and Naples
beaches with a total FDEP participation not to exceed more than $580,606.00. Funding for this renourishment will be
provided from the TDC Beach Renourishment Fund (1105). Accordingly, reimbursements to this agreement will be
deposited in Fund 1105.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: This item is consistent with the Conservation and Coastal Management
Element of the Growth Management Plan.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This item is approved as to form and legality and requires majority vote for approval. –
CMG
RECOMMENDATIONS: To accept the award and authorize the Chairman to execute Grant Agreement No.
24CO1 between Collier County Board of County Commissioners and the Florida Department of Environmental
Protection for funding reimbursement and support for Collier County Beach Renourishment Projects.
PREPARED BY: Andrew Miller, P.E., Coastal Zone Management, Capital Project Planning, Impact Fees and Program
Management Division
ATTACHMENTS:
1. 24CO1 Agreement
2. FINAL_FY24_25_Wiggins Pass
3. FINAL- FY24-25 - Collier Beach Renourishment
4. FINAL_FY24_25- South Marco
Page 3343 of 7162
Page 3344 of 7162
Page 3345 of 7162
Page 3346 of 7162
Page 3347 of 7162
Page 3348 of 7162
Page 3349 of 7162
Page 3350 of 7162
Page 3351 of 7162
Page 3352 of 7162
Page 3353 of 7162
Page 3354 of 7162
Page 3355 of 7162
Page 3356 of 7162
Page 3357 of 7162
Page 3358 of 7162
Page 3359 of 7162
Page 3360 of 7162
Page 3361 of 7162
Page 3362 of 7162
Page 3363 of 7162
Page 3364 of 7162
Page 3365 of 7162
Page 3366 of 7162
Page 3367 of 7162
Page 3368 of 7162
Page 3369 of 7162
Page 3370 of 7162
Page 3371 of 7162
Page 3372 of 7162
Page 3373 of 7162
Page 3374 of 7162
Page 3375 of 7162
Page 3376 of 7162
Page 3377 of 7162
Page 3378 of 7162
Page 3379 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Inlet Projects Application
PART is GENERAL INFORMATION
Local Sponsor Board of County Commissioners Collier County, Florida
Federal ID Number (FEID) 59-6000558 1
Primary Contact Name Andrew Miller Title Manager
Mailing Address Line 1 3299 Tamiami Trail East Suite 202
Mailing Address Line 2
City Naples Zip Code 34112-5746 Telephone Number (239)-252-2922, c6]
Email Address Andrew.Miller@colliercountyfl.gov
Additional Contact Information
Michelle D'Andrea
Grants Coordinator
Michelle.Dandrea@colliercountyfl.gov
239-252-5809
PART II: CERTIFICATION
I hereby certify that all information proyidedwit this application is true and complete to the best of my knowledge.
Signature of Local Sponsor'
T
Electronic orsconned signatures accepted.
Printed Name Rick LoCastro, Chairman Date T ZS' 23
4 (
IAppr
v as to form and legality
ATTEST +",Fa°'
CRYSTAL . cLE--R Assistant Count Attorney
t NAMI ' A
to W
a. \
way{v vay v..v u y
Page 3380 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Inlet Projects Application
PART III: EVALUATION CRITERIA
1. Project Name: As listed in the Inlet Management Plan (IMP) or Strategic Beach Management Plan (SBMP)
Wiggins Pass Inlet Management
2. Project Description: Include county, location with reference to DEP range monuments, brief project history, and description of
proposed activities.
The Wiggins Pass Project is located on the southwest Florida coastline in Collier County between
FDEP monuments R-16 and R-17.
The initial phase of the latest Inlet Management Plan Study was implemented in 2013 for maintenance
dredging and initial realignment of the channel.
In 2015, an interim maintenance dredging project cleared the shoal across the main inlet entrance
channel. Material was placed in the ebb shoal disposal area north of the channel and within the flood
shoal disposal.
In Spring 2018, dredging split 2/3 of the total volume to the north and 1/3 of the total volume to the
south to maintain the navigation of the inlet, refine and reinforce the alignment begun with the 2013
project.
In March 2020 the County conducted a small interim dredging project, but due to storms since this
project completion, the County needed an emergency dredging project to remove shoals that impeded
navigation. As such, Wiggins Pass was dredged between January 26, 2022 and March 10, 2022.
The requested funds are for design and monitoring. LS staff have determined that the project is eligible
for a 50% state cost share.
0
Page 3381 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Inlet Projects Application
3. Use of Requested Program Funds: Provide a brief description of tasks to be completed in each requested phase (Feasibility,
Design, Construction, or Monitoring). Indicate which tasks are cost reimbursement from previous fiscal years.
The requested funds are for permitting, design, and monitoring.
4. Map: Provide as an attachment.
Format: The project area must be formatted at a minimum of 1" = 200' d include a compass rose and legend. scale an
Required elements: Project boundary, DEP reference monuments, shoreline designated as critically eroded, area of inlet
influence, and permitted sand bypassing placement area
5. Project length: Total restored project boundary (in feet) as listed in the IMP or SBMP. 10,560 feet
6. Schedule and Budget: Provide as a separate attachment, if needed. Clearly indicate project phase: Feasibility (F), Design (D),
Construction (C), or Monitoring (M). Include the year of post -construction monitoring in the description.
Cost Reimbursement: Specify eligible costs incurred during the three years prior to the current application's fiscal year that arenotinacurrentDEPagreementandhavenotbeenreimbursed (this includes fiscal years 21/22, 22/23, and 23/24). Eligible costs
will be added to the current funding request. Current and Future Costs: Specify eligible costs for the current application's fiscal year that are not in a current DEP agreementandhavenotbeenreimbursedaswellastheestimatedcostsforthenext4years. Note: If Construction costs are requested in thecurrentfiscalyear, then the Year 1 Post -Construction Monitoring costs will be added to the current funding request.
Fiscal
Year
project Phase Description Federal Cost State Cost Local Cost Total Cost
21/22
21/22
21/22
22/23
22/23
22/23 0
Page 3382 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Inlet Projects Application
Yearl Project Phase Description Federal Cost I State Cost Local Cost Total Cost
23/24
23/24
23/24
24/25 Design and Permitting Full Channel Dredging Permitting and Design 0 90,000 90,000 1$180,000
24/25 Monitoring Environmental & Physical Monitoring, and Tilling 0 55,000 55,000 110,000
r224/25
5/26 Construction Full Channel Dredging Construction 0 800,000 800,000 1,600,000
25/26 Monitoring Environmental & Physical Monitoring, and Tilling 0 60,000 60,000 120,000
25/26 I
26/27 Design Interim Dredging Design 0 35,000 35,0001$70,000
26/27 Monitoring Environmental & Physical Monitoring, and Tilling 0 65,500 65,500 131,000
26/27
27/28 Construction Interim Dredging Construction 0 400,000 400,000 800,000
27/28 Monitoring Environmental & Physical Monitoring, and Tilling 0 71 ,400 71,400 142,800
27/28
28/29 Design FuII Channel Dredging Designgg9 0 45,000 45,000 1 $90,000
28/29 Monitoring Environmental & Physical Monitoring, and Tilling 0 78,000 78,000 156,000
28/29
I
Page 3383 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Inlet Projects Application
7. Sand reaching the inlet
Provide the estimated annual quantity (cubic yards) of beach quality sand reaching the --
updrift boundary of the improved jetty or inlet channel: F2O,600 cubic yards per year. i
8. Severity of erosion
Provide the annual bypassing objective (cubic yards/year) adopted by the IMP or SBMP or —
as determined by a Department -approved study: The Strategic Beach Managemer
9. Balancing the sediment budget
Provide the current annual average of bypassed material (cubic yards) since the adoption ,
225 cy since 2018ofabypassobjective:____j
Provide a brief description of when the last
sediment budget engineering analysis was
completed for the inlet and area of inlet
influence. Discuss any proposals to update
the sediment budget.
In 2011, 49,900 cy of material was removed from Wiggins Pass. In 2013 a
total 107,370 cy was dredged from Wiggins Pass. The 2015 interim
dredging excavated 9,400 cy from the inlet entrance channel and the
connecting south channel.
IThe 2018 project removed approximately 95,900 cy from Wiggins Pass.
In 2022 approximately 65,000 cubic yards of sand was removed from
Wiggins Pass
The 1995 Inlet Management Study and corresponding strategic beach
management plan was implemented starting in 2001. A new study was
completed in 2012, permitted and initiated in 2013. FDEP approved the
final plan in April 2018.
The bypassing plan adopted in April 2018 was first implemented with the
2018 dredging event. Since the IMP adoption, the bypassing objectives
have been met.
Page 3384 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Inlet Projects Application
Historical bypassing volumes: In the table below, provide the annual bypassing volumes (cubic yards/year), for the previous ten
years (from the last calendar year or the most recent calculation). Attach additional documentation as needed.
Year
Quantity Bypassed
cy) - Sand Transfer
Plant
Quantity Bypassed
Icy) _Dredging
Dredge Location Placement or Disposal Area
2011 49,900 Ebb Shoal R12-R14.2
2012 1
2013 1 66,064 Ebb Shoal R12-R16
2014
2015 9,400 Ebb Shoal and Interior Channel R15.5-R16
2016
2017
2018 57,000 Ebb Shoal and Interior Channel, R12-R16
2019
2020 58,400 Ebb Shoal Nearshore R12-R14 and R18-R20
2021
2022 65,000 I
Ebb Shoal and Interior Channel R-18 and R-20
Tmethodr
0 305,764
Total bypass volume:
Years since IMP adoption:
Annual average bypass:
Bypass objective:
305,764 cy - 10 years
5 728 years (since April
1
40,225 cy since 2018 1,
20,600 cy/yr ^
Percentage of bypass objective: 100%
CAD
Page 3385 of 7162
P vEVAgrM
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
o Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Inlet Projects Application
10. Increased bypassing and cost-effectiveness
Provide the estimated increase in annual bypassing of sand (cubic None proposed at this time
yards/year) proposed for the project:
Provide the estimated shortfall of annual bypassing of sand (cubic
yards/year) within the inlet system:
t— aIstheproposedprojectrequestingconstructionphasefundsforamajorinletmanagementprojectcomponent?lYes j
If yes, and for the award of points for the cost-effectiveness of using inlet sand criteria, provide an opinion of probable cost
per unit volume of the inlet and all other sand sources, certified by a licensed professional engineer.
11. Inlet Management Plans
Select all that apply:
Existing IMP: The proposed project has an existing IMP or completed Inlet Management Study that
has been approved by the Department.
Updated IMP: The Department has received and approved an update to an existing IMP in the
C form of a current Inlet Management Study/sediment budget analysis within the previous five years,
or there is an update proposed to an existing IMP in the current application.
New IMP: A new inlet management study is proposed for submission to the Department for an
adoption in an IMP.
12. Enhanced longevity of proximate beach nourishment projects
Annualized beach nourishment volume of proximate beach
nourishment project:
13. Active permits
Does the project have an active state permit? Nc
Permit number: 01452538-008-JC
Authorization date: 1/2/2013 ^
Expiration date: 1/2/2023
57,910 cylyr
Does the project have an active federal permit? No
Permit number: SAJ-2004-07621 (I P-MJD)
Authorization date: 2/13/2013
Expiration date: 2/13/2023 —
Page 3386 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Inlet Projects Application
14. Federal funds available
Does the proposed project have federal funds available? If so, provide supporting documentation. rNo
15. Secured local funds
Has the necessary local funding been secured for the proposed project? If so, provide a copy of the Yes
draft Resolution. The signed Resolution is due by September 21, 2023.
Additional
comments
Page 3387 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Beach Projects Application
PART1: GENERAL INFORMATION
Local Sponsor Board of County Commissioners Collier County, Florida
Federal ID Number (FEID) 59-60000558
Primary Contact Name Andrew Miller Title Manager
Mailing Address Line 1 3299 Tamiami Trail East Suite 202
Mailing Address Line 2
City INaples
T
Zip Code 34112-5746 ? Telephone Number (239)-252-2922
Email Address Andrew.Miller@colIiercountyfl.gov
Additional Contact Information
Michelle D'Andrea
Grants Coordinator
Michelle.Dandrea@colliercountyfl.gov
239-252-5809
PART II: CERTIFICATION
I hereby certify that all information ith this application is true and complete to the best of my knowledge.
Signature of Local Sponsor I
Electronic or scanned signatures accepted.
Printed Name Rick LoCastro, Chairman Date 7 ZS Z 3
Approved as to form and legality
ATT -F'' ; A 4"
Assistant County Attorney
CAC)
astct u'Pnan's
s W Ure`Only
Page 3388 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Beach Projects Application
PART III: EVALUATION CRITERIA
1. Project Name: (as listed in the Strategic Beach Management Plan)
Collier County Beach Renourishment
2. Project Description: Include county, location with reference to DEP range monuments, brief project history, and description of
proposed activities.
IThe project includes nourishment and monitoring of the Collier County beaches, dredging of Doctors
Pass and erosion control structures for sand retention.
The project is located between FDEP R-22+300 to R-30.5, R-42 — R-54+400, and R-57+800 to R-79,
and includes three Vanderbilt Beach, Park Shore, and Naples. Dunes will be restored to pre -storm
conditions when damaged. Permit design is to a 100 ft. wide beach in Vanderbilt and Naples Beaches
and a 85 ft. wide beach in Park Shore, with a 6-year project design life.
Between 2017 and 2020 approximately 38,000 cubic yards of dredged material was placed from Clam
Pass onto the beaches on either side of the inlet and an additional 20,000 cy was placed in the newly
permitted segment.
Park Shore Beach was nourished with approximately 130,000 cubic yards of sand as part of the 2019
project.
Naples Beach received approximately 30,000 cubic yards of sand dredged from Doctors Pass in 2018
placed in the nearshore.
The reach from the Doctors Pass south jetty to R-60 was nourished with sand in late 2020.
Additionally, following the passage of Hurricane Ian, an emergency berm project restored portions of
the dry beach within the project areas in spring/summer 2023.
CCAO
Page 3389 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Beach Projects Application
3. Use of Requested Program Funds: Provide a brief description of tasks to be completed in each requested phase (Feasibility,
Design, Construction, Monitoring, or USACE Multiphase). Indicate which tasks are cost reimbursement from previous fiscal years.
nstruction - FEMA Berm Project - (FY 202312024)
nitoring - Physical, Biological, Shorebirds, Turtles, Tilling - (FY 2024/2025)
sign - Hurricane Ian Post Storm Restoration Design - (FY 2024/2025)
4. Map: Provide as an attachment. The map(s) of the project area must be formatted at a minimum of 1" = 200' scale and include a
compass rose and legend.
Map elements must include:
1. Project boundary: DEP reference monuments and shoreline designated as critically eroded
2. Eligibility: Indicate lengths of eligible shoreline based on criteria outlined in Chapter 6213-36.007, F.A.C.
a. Beach access locations: indicate primary or secondary access, and include the shoreline length, number and location
of auto parking spaces, mass transit stops, bike parking spaces, and public restroom facilities within 1 /4 mile walking distance
of each access
b. Public lodging establishments: include the length fronting the project shoreline, and include the length of
street -side frontage for lodging within 1 /4 mile walking distance of a secondary beach access location
3. Recreational benefits: Comprehensive list of current land use designations of properties fronting the project shoreline
4. Value of upland property: Include one -quarter mile buffer and provide a comprehensive list of the values of properties
data from year 2022) that are enclosed or intersected by the buffer. The 2022 property value tax roll data and ArcGIS
shapefiles can be obtained from the Department of Revenue website: https://floridarevenue.comi property/Pages!
DataPortal_RequestAssessmentRoIIGISData.aspx. See Guidance Document for more information.
5. Project length: Total restored project length (in feet) of the critically eroded area R-22+300 to R-30.5=14,996 ft, R-42
as listed in the Strategic Beach Management Plan).
Page 3390 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Beach Projects Application
6. Eligibility: Required for all beach projects pursuant to Chapter 62B-36.007, F.A.C. Provide as a separate attachment, if needed.
location/Access Name: Use the official name of the park or road that is associated with the public access.
DEP Reference Monument: Use the DEP monument that is closest to the main public access location.
Type of Access: Indicate Primary or Secondary beach access in accordance with the definitions in Chapter 62B-36, F.A.C.
Width of Access/Frontage: The length of the legal boundary (in feet) of the public access or lodging along the beach project
shoreline. For public lodging establishments that do not front the beach, indicate the street -side length of the legal property
boundary (in feet) that is used as the main access to the establishment.
Number of Eligible Units: A unit is defined as one automobile parking space, one rental unit in a public lodging establishment, one
mass transit stop, or four bicycle parking spots.
Additional Width from Eligible Units: Total distance (feet) added to the Width of Access/Frontage. If there are multiple types of
eligibility units used for this calculation, show the calculation separately for each.
Total Eligible Shoreline: Sum of the Width of Access/Frontage and Additional Width from Eligible Units columns. Eligible shorelines
cannot overlap.
Website Link for DBPR License: Provide the link to the Department of Business and Professional Regulation (DBPR) website for
proof of licensure for any public lodging establishments used for eligibility or the Recreational Benefits ranking criteria.
Location!
Access Name !
DEP Reference
Monument
Type of Access
Width of
Access!
Frontage (ft)
Number of
Eligible Unitsg
Additional
Width from
Eligible Units
Total Eligible
Shoreline (ft)
Website Link
for DBPR
License
See Attached
I
I
i
i
0
Page 3391 of 7162
o! 2
VI V)
rs.l n. n
n ro Lij
6
00
tui 9 C)
Ld
Q
00
CO 00LLJ
a
C c0 C UCGOauLLLL. U
J j tt) m OO
E cLGLnLn
OpON 00
v r- Z N m Q Q Q Qwz
C m C CT
Z Z Z Z
YC a) UJ 00
LU
Lj
y O a O LLcc
3 N
E E rn
3 Ln
C.
p
r
III
L t
N
Qj
c n m L y N v n o
w y
o
ni i cr Q
E 'c
o
c_ F O O E O w m
a a ma b
a 3 _
a
a
o`
Na)
Y C Y
S d O 0) Ln O a N 3
m v v ui n o Z in m
m N
H W n
c
D
a
A
o =
L° ram. oM ry
n r+i
O
oi0 0o1D
m
v
u
Q
a E E' E 0 0 0
F Q a a o a a o v
N
v
V
v
La
E N tD Qt O R
V1
CO
cc
CO L
q O
L7 Vt
u O a
a a m Y C
E
m a
CC.
L
L
T
O
Aa
m A Rom]
o
m am O
N
OZ CO O
m a 0
m n V E O v
UO
T°
a0 u 0 S
C
a
Oc m7
tc
v
o aN
Page 3392 of 7162
n 0
u CO v
n3QLLtV
rs LL 0o OI
CU CO
Q a Q4 000
6J h
C y 0
0
01,
V 00i
J J co OJrr J LOLO
C
h r`
e h a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a v M a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a
i> Z Z Z Z Z 2 Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z 2 Z Z Z Z
Li LL
a ul O LO
3
o * cil It
y t-t
Lf) Ln M
11 rn
iti s i! vl
d
1 •.•
n o
n
o
0 0 0 o
a
0 0 0 0 0 0 om om a o 0 0 0 o a v
mC k oN 00 o 0 0 0 0O 0x 0B 0In ti 0to w M 6J lO z w W l0 D M M OlW V lD tD 1D l0
w d
N
1O
a)M
O
lD lD 0tD
N Lfl
OSN
E C
C O o o
o m a a o n O
o 0 0 0 o r
O= o0 0 0 v v 0 0 0 0 0W 0S 0S 0 c a
o a M r v D o D n a) C)
N y r; n c c` to x w iD
o>
N 0> 0> 0> 0 N o 0 0 0 0> o> o>
a 3
Vl
N
W
Q
twi
z V
s o 0 0 0 0 0 0 o o o o ti 0 0 o a oo o 0 0 0 N Nr
a
y0
o 0 0 0 0
N
N M
O
m
m
o =
O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O1D O47 Ot0
N OID OlD OW OlD Ot0 OlD lD t0 ID ID ID tD ID t0 1D l0 LD 10 t0 10 l0 t0 t0 t0 tD tD l0
3 "
a
tp l0
QO t9 i"J i0 tC N 0 tC f0 6 tD N i0 0 u tD
0 v0 0o 0 o v o G oC vC 2sC oC oC C
0J CU Ij to E 17 . C C C C C C C C C C C C0 C0 C0 m Co C0 C0 C0 C0 C0 C0 Co 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
a 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 w w w a w w a a a w w w w w w w5.a a o a a 0 w
t!1
w
Vl
w
Vf
w
N
ww w
to N
w
N
w
N
w
V1
w
to
w
N
w
N
w
an N N V1 to to V5 t/1 Vl VS V1 Vl N N N
C N to V1
d
E- kD
to
m D
4^t
Cl
ill
O t ti Nr
M
n
m
r t` F, n t`
eT
n M. oC
3C iD
cG
D tD
CL
c t0
C
tD
K K C K pc K D C K C K C K C r CC 5
O c K
T
Q
tD 0 W C Vl t/1 wv, N n v, in N v, L NE
f4
L
ry
CL CON Z aN Z Z Z Z Z a Vl VtN Vtd VtN in
Ql
N
f0
N
Q!
to
v tov
vl
W W W a N w v w w w U N W
z
c vm
Y
E n
V
z
v
a
x a
a>
a
a
v
a> a a' a a a a a a a a a ar
a
r~j
a a
r
a a a a a v a
N
OE
M UN Ci 1 N M C V CJ l0 h 00 O1 N m N M N N e•D-i 00 Q N
3 o a o
V
V o s
oom
0
Page 3393 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Beach Projects Application
7. Schedule and Budget: Provide as a separate attachment, if needed. Clearly indicate project phase: Feasibility (F), Design (D),
Construction (C), Monitoring (M), or USACE Multiphase (USACE). Include the year of post -construction monitoring in the description.
Cost Reimbursement: Specify eligible costs incurred during the three years prior to the current application's fiscal year that are
not in a current DEP agreement and have not been reimbursed (this includes fiscal years 21 /22, 22/23, and 23/24). Eligible costs
will be added to the current funding request.
Current and Future Costs: Specify eligible costs for the current application's fiscal year that are not in a current DEP agreement
and have not been reimbursed as well as the estimated costs for the next 4 years. Note: If Construction costs are requested in the
current fiscal year, then the Year 1 Post -Construction Monitoring costs will be added to the current funding request
Fiscal
Year
Project Phase Description Federal Cost State Cost Local Cost Total Cost
21/22 See Attached
r21/22
I
21/22
22/23
22/23
22/23
23/24
23/24
23/24
24/25
24/25
24/25
2S/26
25/26
4
25/26
Page 3394 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Beach Projects Application
Fiscal
Year
project Phase Description Federal Cost State Cost local Cost Total Cost
26/27
26/27
i
26/27
27/28
27/28
27/28
28/29
28/29
28/29
I
8. Tourism -related impacts: Criteria is calculated by the Department using 2022 data. For reference, tax data can be obtained from
the Department of Revenue website: htips://floridarevenue.com/DataPortal/Pages/TaxResearch.aspx See Guidance Document
for more information.
Current funding request includes construction and year one post -construction monitoring
Project is managed by two or more counties
Additional comments
Local Option Sales Tax Coll. July 2021 through June 2022= $112,982,241
Tourist Development Tax July 2021 through June 2022 = $47,922,935
Line 39 of Form 10 April 2022 through end of March 2023 = $72,737,956 p
9. Federal involvement: The documentation to verify authorization, federal cost share percentage, and status of funding award
must be provided with the application materials for the award of points.
Is the project Federally authorized by the USACE? No
Authorization Year: Expiration Year:
Does this project have a signed USACE Chief s report or Civil Works Congressional authorization for the No
requested phase?
7
USACE federal cost share percentage for this project (excluding FCCE): ^
e
Page 3395 of 7162
0
tA
Z.J L N N U v N
C. L h• P
rCY
a x Sr IrT!•
U
NEA n rl rl M In M
n..
V sue. 7 x^•' it-,
C
a t 50°erx? r f c ni l ri
f
f 7,
rl
64 v sa t'`
64 s r
L L 64 Z n Fi3 64 LP Sfi v4 64 CA b ; Zn iA
y7
i
I. Jy
C
C!]
f
f C
U
aL
U
c
x V oc
Vi
en
f.f N l N l x
r l C M t-".. Cc
H
c
r L 4 V
M^ M rM. u
L
n GL
U
V: nP.1
U•
L
G
NO N NO O O G MO
L N N N N N N N
ON rl N rl CN CN N N ON N CN
Page 3396 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Beach Projects Application
Select all that apply for the requested project phase(s) and include documentation with application materials.
C Executed USACE project agreement
C Included in USACE work plan
C Approved FEMA Project Worksheet
C Included in Congressional Appropriations Act
t: Other documentation:
r014. Crwnty nM tha USACE h— ®a Aed a Ind—Ily f—d»C batibi4ty siunY aM Ih» Dmj»ri iz I Vwn in a rv nxN t. i»rai n u1{»I n_, 't
10. Storm damage reduction benefits: Criteria is calculated by the Department,
What is the volume (cy) of advanced nourishment lost since the last sand placement event of vanda"'Ji=0Cy lossParkShore = 0 Cy ions
a beach restoration or nourishment project as measured above the Mean High Water Naples=0 Cy loss
This da!a is frorn annual monitoring repon
contour? Data should be consistent with the annual post -construction monitoring reports. Conducted prior to Hurricane [an,)
For restoration projects, what is the historical erosion rate? 1-0.61 foot/yea r
11. Cost effectiveness: Criteria is calculated by the Department. A project design analysis and supporting documentation must be
provided with the application materials for the award of points. See Guidance Document for more information.
What is the proposed sand placement volume (cy)?
What is the nourishment interval (years)?
Select all that apply for the current project funding request:
TBD
5
C' Enhanced longevity: Propose structural or design components that could extend the beach nourishment interval
Dune addition: Incorporate new or enhanced dune structures or new or existing dune restoration and revegetation
projects
Innovative technology: Propose innovative technologies designed to reduce project costs
f , Regionalization: Two or more local sponsors manage projects together or projects propose regional sediment
management strategies to conserve sand resources or reduce project costs
Additional commen
for storm damage
reduction benefits a
cost effectiveness
Page 3397 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Beach Projects Application
12. Previous state commitment
Has the Department previously reviewed, approved, and cost -shared on a feasibility or design phase for this project.
Has the current proposed project phase(s) received a partial state appropriation within 3 years of phase completion?' No
Additional comments
13. Accessible beach area: Criteria is calculated by the Department. Provide additional information for consideration,
Vanderbilt: Using the 2014 MHW the beach area was calculated to be 645,632 sq. ft,
Describe the landward and seaward edge of the • Park Shore: Using the 2014 MHW the beach area was calculated to be 370.532 sq.11
However, in some areas the ECL is front of the MHW.
accessible beach width Naples: Using the 2014 MHW the beach area was calculated to be 1.685,295 sq ft.
Vanderbilt: R-22+300 to R-30.5 = 14,996 feet
Provide the project boundaries (R-monuments) • Park Shore: R-42 to R-54+400 = 12,976 feet
Naples: Doctors Pass to R-79 = 19,340 feet
Collier County, Florida Hardbottom Biological Monitoring Plan for Permits Collier
County Beach Nourishment Project (FDEP Permit No. 033187-004-JM) and Wiggins
Provide citations of reference sources Pass Navigation Channel Expansion and Maintenance Project (FDEP Permit No
0142538-008-JC)
14. Recreational benefits: Provide the percentage of
linear footage within the project boundaries which
is zoned recreational or open space; for commercial
use; or to allow for public lodging establishment, or
the equivalent. Provide additional documentation
and DBPR website link in a separate attachment, if
needed.
Vanderbilt 1,866 ft, 12%
Park Shore 2,544 ft, 20%
Naples 929 ft, 5%
15. Mitigation of inlet effects: Criteria is calculated by the Department.
Approximately 37,600 cy were dredged from Doctors Pass and bypassed south with nearshore
disposal of Naples each in 2018. Utilizing volumes from the Department's FY19/20 CoastalB
Additional comments
Engineering memo, the volume of inlet sand bypassing between 2005 and 2020 has beenapproximately7,180 cy/yr. Supplemental nourishment is achieved by Collier County via beach
nourishment sand placement events to mitigate for the approximate 2,820 cy/yr bypassing deficit.
16. Successive unfunded requests
Is the current proposed project phase(s) a successive, unfunded request? If so, how many years of
successive request(s) is the current application?
Does the successive request add the construction phase?
No
i P
Page 3398 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Beach Projects Application
17. Environmental habitat enhancement: Criteria is calculated by the Department. See Guidance Document for more information
Is the project within a designated critical habitat area for threatened or endangered species that is subject No
to extensive shoreline armoring? —
Is the project within a non -designated area where extensive shoreline armoring threatens the habitat of No
threatened or endangered species? i
If yes to either of the above, does the project exceed best management practices to incorporate turtle -
friendly designs and management strategies to protect resources or benefit critical habitat preservation?
The project proposes a dune addition.
Provide an explanation and
supporting documentation
for the strategies which
exceed best management
practices
18. Readiness to construct
Does the project have an active state permit? 1 Yes
Permit number 0331817-001-JC
Authorization date
Expiration date
Oct. 2, 2015 j
Oct. 2, 2030
Does the project have an active federal permit? ( YesL__
Permit number SAJ-2003-12405 -
Authorization date
Expiration date
April 6, 2016
April 6, 2031
Have all necesssary easements been acquired for the upcoming or proposed construction phase?
Has the necessary local funding been secured for the proposed project? If so, provide a copy of the
draft Resolution. The signed Resolution is due by September 21, 2023.
Is an Erosion Control Line established along the project length?
Additional
comments for
readiness to
construct
Yes
ly- e
YeS —_,Yes
Page 3399 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Beach Projects Application
Provide additional information and comments below or attach supporting documents.
Page 3400 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Beach Projects Application
PART I: GENERAL INFORMATION
Local Sponsor Board of County Commissioners Collier County, Florida
Federal ID Number (FEID) 59-6000558 —
Primary Contact Name Andrew Miller Title Manager
Mailing Address Line 1 3299 Tamiami Trail East Suite 202
Mailing Address Line 2
City Naples Zip Code 34112-5746 Telephone Number 239-252-2922
Email Address andrew.miller@colliercountyfl.com
Additional Contact Information
Michelle D'Andrea
Grants Coordinator
Michelle.Dandrea@colliercountyfl.gov
239-252-5809
PART II: CERTIFICATION
I hereby certify that all information provide his application is true and complete to the best of my knowledge.
Signature of Local Sponsor
Electronic or scanned signatures accepted.
Printed Name Rick LoCastro, Chairman Date 2 23 >
z` •" 'r Approved to form and legality
ATTEST .,
CRY T -E-
1, / yAssistantCountyAtt
BY:
CD
Page 3401 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Beach Projects Application
PART III: EVALUATION CRITERIA
1. Project Name: (as listed in the Strategic Beach Management Plan)
South Marco Island Beach Renourishment Project
2. Project Description: Include county, location with reference to DEP range monuments, brief project history, and description of
proposed activities.
The South Marco Island Beach Renourishment Project is located on the southwest Florida coastline of
Collier County between Florida Department of Environmental Protection monuments from reference
monument R-144 to R-148+600 (G-4).
IThe project's borrow area is the Caxambas Pass Borrow Area with upland sand mines permitted assupplementalsandsources. Structural repair of five existing erosion control structures was completed
I in 2013/14.
IThe South Marco Island Beach Renourishment Project was then renourished through truck haul
methods in November of 2016 with approximately 13,200 cubic yards of beach compatible material to
offset storm damages caused by Tropical Storm Debby. Approximately 80,000 cy of dredged material
from Caxambas Pass was placed in the South Marco Island Beach project area in March of 2020.
Additionally, emergency sand placement occurred on the dry beach in June 2023 following the passage
of Hurricane Ian.
This project includes yearly physical beach monitoring, beach tilling, and environmental monitoring as
required by FDEP and USACE permits. LS staff has previously determined that 26.93% of the project is
eligible for state cost share.
Page 3402 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Beach Projects Application
3. Use of Requested Program Funds: Provide a brief description of tasks to be completed in each requested phase (Feasibility,
Design, Construction, Monitoring, or USACE Multiphase). Indicate which tasks are cost reimbursement from previous fiscal years.
Monitoring - Physical and turtle monitoring and beach tilling funds.
4. Map: Provide as an attachment. The map(s) of the project area must be formatted at a minimum of 1" = 200' scale and include a
compass rose and legend.
Map elements must include:
1. Project boundary: DEP reference monuments and shoreline designated as critically eroded
2. Eligibility: Indicate lengths of eligible shoreline based on criteria outlined in Chapter 62B-36.007, F.A.C.
a. Beach access locations: indicate primary or secondary access, and include the shoreline length, number and location
of auto parking spaces, mass transit stops, bike parking spaces, and public restroom facilities within 1/4 mile walking distance
of each access
b. Public lodging establishments: include the length fronting the project shoreline, and include the length of
street -side frontage for lodging within 1 /4 mile walking distance of a secondary beach access location
3. Recreational benefits: Comprehensive list of current land use designations of properties fronting the project shoreline
4. Value of upland property: Include one -quarter mile buffer and provide a comprehensive list of the values of properties
data from year 2022) that are enclosed or intersected by the buffer. The 2022 property value tax roll data and ArcGIS
shapefiles can be obtained from the Department of Revenue website: https://floridarevenue.com/property/Pages/
Data Portal_RequestAssessmentRolIGISData.aspx. See Guidance Document for more information.
5. Project length: Total restored project length (in feet) of the critically eroded area Permitted project from R 144 to R148aslistedintheStrategicBeachManagementPlan).
SO
Page 3403 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Beach Projects Application
6. Eligibility: Required for all beach projects pursuant to Chapter 626-36.007, F.A.C. Provide as a separate attachment, if needed.
Location/Access Name: Use the official name of the park or road that is associated with the public access.
DEP Reference Monument: Use the DEP monument that is closest to the main public access location.
Type of Access: Indicate Primary or Secondary beach access in accordance with the definitions in Chapter 626-36, F.A.C.
Width of Access/Frontage: The length of the legal boundary (in feet) of the public access or lodging along the beach project
shoreline. For public lodging establishments that do not front the beach, indicate the street -side length of the legal property
boundary (in feet) that is used as the main access to the establishment.
Number of Eligible Units: A unit is defined as one automobile parking space, one rental unit in a public lodging establishment, one
mass transit stop, or four bicycle parking spots.
Additional Width from Eligible Units: Total distance (feet) added to the Width of Access/Frontage. If there are multiple types of
eligibility units used for this calculation, show the calculation separately for each.
Total Eligible Shoreline: Sum of the Width of Access/Frontage and Additional Width from Eligible Units columns. Eligible shorelines
cannot overlap.
Website Link for DBPR License: Provide the link to the Department of Business and Professional Regulation (DBPR) website for
proof of licensure for any public lodging establishments used for eligibility or the Recreational Benefits ranking criteria.
Location/
Access Name
DEP Reference
Monument
Type of Access
Width of j
Access/
Frontage (ft)
J
Number of
Eligible Units
Additional __
Width from
Eligible Units
Total Eligible
Shoreline (ft)
Website Link
for DBPR
License
Surf Club of Marco R-144 Fp7nmary 297 44 0 297
Marw Island Beach__ R-144 Primary500 320 0 500Hilton
Mamott Crystal snores R-144.2
r
1 Primary 362 71 0 362
Swallow Ave R-148 Secondary 20 72 1860 1880 N/A
j I
i
Page 3404 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Beach Projects Application
7. Schedule and Budget: Provide as a separate attachment, if needed. Clearly indicate project phase: Feasibility (F), Design (D),
Construction (C), Monitoring (M), or USACE Multiphase (USACE). Include the year of post -construction monitoring in the description.
Cost Reimbursement: Specify eligible costs incurred during the three years prior to the current application's fiscal year that are
not in a current DEP agreement and have not been reimbursed (this includes fiscal years 21/22, 22/23, and 23/24). Eligible costs
will be added to the current funding request.
Current and Future Costs: Specify eligible costs for the current application's fiscal year that are not in a current DEP agreement
and have not been reimbursed as well as the estimated costs for the next 4 years. Note: If Construction costs are requested in the
cijrrent fiscal year, then the Year 1 Post -Construction Monitoring costs will be added to the current funding request
Fiscal
Year
project Phase Description Federal Cost State Cost I Local Cost Total Cost
21/22
I
21/22
21/22
t
22/23
I
22/23
22/23
23/24
23/24
23/24
24/25 Monitoring Physical, Turtle, Shorebird, Tilling 0 29,800 80,7001$110,500
24/25
24/25
25/26 Design Engineering Design, P&S 0 67,300 182,700 250,000
25/26 Monitoring Physical, Turtle, Shorebird, Tilling 0 33,000
I $
89,500 122,500
25/26
Page 3405 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Beach Projects Application
Fiscal
Year
26/27
Project Phase
Monitoring
Description
Physical, Turtle, Shorebird, Tilling
Federal Cost
0
State Cost
36,000
Local Cost
97,500
Total Cost'I
133,500
26/27
26/27
27/28 Monitoring Physical, Turtle, Shorebird, Tilling 0 39,200 1 $106,300 145,500
27/28 Construction Beach Nourishment and Services 0 673,300 1,826,700 2,500,000
27/28
28/29 Monitoring Physical, Turtle, Shorebird, Tilling 0 42,700 115,900 158,600
28/29
I
28/29
8. Tourism -related impacts: Criteria is calculated by the Department using 2022 data. For reference, tax data can be obtained from
the Department of Revenue website: https://floridarevenue.com/DataPortal/PagesfTaxResearch.aspx See Guidance Document
for more information.
C' Current funding request includes construction and year one post -construction monitoring
C_ Project is managed by two or more counties
Additional comments
As only monitoring funds are requested, only items 1-7 are included in this
application.
9. Federal involvement: The documentation to verify authorization, federal cost share percentage, and status of funding award
must be provided with the application materials for the award of points.
Is the project Federally authorized by the USACE?
Authorization Year: Expiration Year:
Does this project have a signed USACE Chief's report or Civil Works Congressional authorization for the
requested phase?
USACE federal cost share percentage for this project (excluding FCCE):
e
Page 3406 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Beach Projects Application
Select all that apply for the requested project phase(s) and include documentation with application materials.
Executed USACE project agreement
Included in USACE work plan
Approved FEMA Project Worksheet
Included in Congressional Appropriations Act
C Other documentation:
10. Storm damage reduction benefits: Criteria is calculated by the Department.
What is the volume (cy) of advanced nourishment lost since the last sand placement event of
a beach restoration or nourishment project as measured above the Mean High Water
contour? Data should be consistent with the annual post -construction monitoring reports.
For restoration projects, what is the historical erosion rate?
11. Cost effectiveness: Criteria is calculated by the Department. A project design analysis and supporting documentation must be
provided with the application materials for the award of points. See Guidance Document for more information.
What is the proposed sand placement volume (cy)?
What is the nourishment interval (years)?
Select all that apply for the current project funding request:
i Enhanced longevity: Propose structural or design components that could extend the beach nourishment interval
Dune addition: Incorporate new or enhanced dune structures or new or existing dune restoration and revegetation
projects
Innovative technology: Propose innovative technologies designed to reduce project costs
Regionalization: Two or more local sponsors manage projects together or projects propose regional sediment
management strategies to conserve sand resources or reduce project costs
Additional comments
for storm damage
reduction benefits an
cost effectiveness
Page 3407 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Beach Projects Application
12. Previous state commitment
Has the Department previously reviewed, approved, and cost -shared on a feasibility or design phase for this project
Has the current proposed project phase(s) received a partial state appropriation within 3 years of phase completion?l
Additional comments
13. Accessible beach area: Criteria is calculated by the Department. Provide additional information for consideration.
Describe the landward and seaward edge of the
accessible beach width
Provide the project boundaries (R-monuments)
Provide citations of reference sources
14. Recreational benefits: Provide the percentage of
linear footage within the project boundaries which
is zoned recreational or open space; for commercial
use; or to allow for public lodging establishment, or
the equivalent. Provide additional documentation
and DBPR website link in a separate attachment, if
needed.
15. Mitigation of inlet effects: Criteria is calculated by the Department.
Additional comments
16. Successive unfunded requests
Is the current proposed project phase(s) a successive, unfunded request? If so, how many years of
successive request(s) is the current application?
Does the successive request add the construction phase?
CAS
Page 3408 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Beach Projects Application
17. Environmental habitat enhancement: Criteria is calculated by the Department. See Guidance Document for more information.
is the project within a designated critical habitat area for threatened or endangered species that is subject
to extensive shoreline armoring?
Is the project within a non -designated area where extensive shoreline armoring threatens the habitat of
threatened or endangered species?
If yes to either of the above, does the project exceed best management practices to incorporate turtle -
friendly designs and management strategies to protect resources or benefit critical habitat preservation?
Provide an explanation and
supporting documentation
for the strategies which
exceed best management
practices
18. Readiness to construct
Does the project have an active state permit?
Permit number
Authorization date
Expiration date
Does the project have an active federal permit?
Permit number
Authorization date
Expiration date
Have all necesssary easements been acquired for the upcoming or proposed construction phase?
Has the necessary local funding been secured for the proposed project? If so, provide a copy of the
draft Resolution. The signed Resolution is due by September 21, 2023.
Is an Erosion Control Line established along the project length?
Additional
comments for
readiness to
construct
Page 3409 of 7162
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
Local Government Funding Request
Fiscal Year 2024/2025
Beach Projects Application
a -,....,.,,,a.,t holnw or attach supporting documents.
Page 3410 of 7162