HAAB Minutes 11/29/2007
November 29,2007
MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE COLLIER COUNTY
HISPANIC AFFAIRS ADVISORY BOARD
Naples, Florida, November 29,2007
LET IT BE REMEMBERED, that the Collier County Hispanic Affairs
Advisory Committee in and for the County of Collier, having conducted
business herein, met on this date at 6:00 PM in REGULAR SESSION at
Administrative Building "F", 3rd Floor, Collier County Government Center,
Naples, Florida with the following members present:
Chairman: James Van Fleet
Vice Chairman: David Correa (Excused)
Raymond Cabral
Renato F. Fernandez
Manuel Gonzalez
Valaree D. Maxwell (Excused)
Cosme Perez (Excused)
Ernesto Velasquez
Luis Alejandro Bernal
Also Present:
Mike Sheffield, County Manger's Office
November 29,2007
I. Introduction
A. Opening Remarks/Welcome
The meeting was called to order at 6:00 PM by Chairman James Van Fleet.
Mr. Van Fleet noted the HAAS Committee would not meet in December &
thanked everyone for their service in 2007.
B. Approval of Meeting Agenda
Renato Fernandez moved to approve the Agenda. Second by Ernesto
Velasquez. Motion carried unanimously 6-0.
C. Approval of the October 25, 2007 HAAB Meeting minutes
Ernesto Velasquez moved to approve the Minutes of October 25, 2007.
Second by Raymond Cabral. Motion carried unanimously 6-0.
II. Old Business
None
III. New Business
A. Topics/Projects for 2008
Jim Van Fleet introduced Luis Alejandro Bernal, the newly appointed member of
the HAAB Committee.
Manuel Gonzalez stated the need to identify issues that are of concern to the
Hispanic Community. The stated Mission for the Committee is to transport issues
of the Hispanic Community to the Board of County Commissioners. Noting that
the issues could be nullified by the Board of County Commissioners based on
validity.
Renato Fernandez stated the HAAB function is limited by the Board of County
Commissioners. The Committee is not permitted to act on ideas, noting approval
must be granted by the Board of County Commissioners. He suggested
presenting a proposal to the Board of County Commissioners to allow
communications with the Community.
Luis Bernal stated a need to identify issues that not only affect Hispanics but the
whole community. Recommended conducting research & communicating with
Community Leaders. He suggested relaying the issues though the media. Noting
the research did not need to be extensive i.e. sociological or political, just based
on common sense.
Ernesto Velasquez expressed continuing to enforce the Committee presence with
Government entities i.e. Minorities Group / Sheriffs Department. He also
suggested being more proactive with Schools.
Jim Van Fleet reported he has participated on the School District's Diversity
Committee over the past several years. Stating one objection was the infrequent
meetings. He added for the November meeting he was I of the 3 members that
attended & the next meeting was not scheduled until February. He emphasized
the meetings are "open" & encouraged the Committee members to attend.
2
November 29,2007
Raymond Cabral recommended to be effective to the Board of County
Commissioners adding a Forum to the 2008 Agenda for Community Leaders. He
stated a need to gain community perspective. He reported on an article that
classified Naples High & Immokalee as the "drop out factory."
Renato Fernandez stated Immokalee is classified as an underprivileged
community and is receiving assistance. The area from 951 to US41 has numerous
Spanish people, he suggested inviting Manatee Middle School Principal.
Raymond Cabral suggested inviting Community Club Members to identify
community problems.
Discussions ensued and it was determined holding a community forum consisting
of 5 -7 community leaders would be advantageous. The Committee would
extend an invitation for the January 24, 2008 meeting to the following:
. Manatee Middle School Principal
. Community Leaders
. Chamber of Commerce Members
. Hospitals
. Health Department
Jim Van Fleet recommended the Committee review a Study conducted by the
University of Florida addressing the needs of the young people of Collier County.
Mike Sheffield responded the Study titled "A Child of Well Being" was available
in PDF format & would email to the Committee for their review.
Discussions continued and the Community Forum invitation would also include:
. Hodges University
. Hospitals
. Health Department
. Social Services
. Children & Family Services
. Pace Program
. Tom Davis - Minority Affairs / Sheriffs Offlce
. Economic Development Council
. Chip Program
Mike Sheffield requested a confirmed list of the attendees be emailed to his
office by January IS, 2008.
Renato Fernandez suggested contacting the media.
Mike Sheffield reminded the Committee of the primary purpose of the HAAB
Board was to advise the Board of County Commissioners.
Manuel Gonzalez recommended a time limit be placed on accepting guest
speakers. In order to determine what program would be developed & to make a
recommendation to the Board of County Commissioners.
3
November 29,2007
Jim Van Fleet suggested scheduling a meeting in February to discuss the HAAB
findings.
Luis Bernal announced he has extended an invitation to the President of
Columbia to visit Naples.
Manuel Gonzalez queried Mr. Bernal on the Columbian Government & Latin
American figures historically asserted our political leaders should preserve open
borders between the United States, Mexico, & Canada. He stated the migration
problems were internal due to gross negligence of reform. He noted it should be
addressed inwardly in-lieu of criticizing our leaders & violating our statutes.
Luis Bernal responded that it was a topic that could be discussed for years with
no resolution.
Manuel Gonzalez questioned if it would affect diplomatic relations with Latin
America once the borders were closed.
Luis Bernal replied "no."
Manuel Gonz3Iez reported the findings from the death of a Haitian man who
jumped into a canal trying to flee. The gentleman had a history of severe asthma
with cocaine in his system. It was noted his death was ruled accidental & was not
caused by electrocution from the combination of water & use ofa Taser gun, as
was originally claimed. The deputy was exonerated based on the findings.
An article published by the Associated Press titled "Immigrants Ripped offby
Phone Card Fraud" was distributed. (See attached)
Ernesto Velasquez reported Dr. Thompson / Superintendent of Hodges
University is under scrutiny for initiating change to the "double credit system."
He referenced the "Final Report to the District School Board of Collier County"
written by Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP. expressing concern that students were
receiving credit for courses such as weightlifting. Dr. Thompson would be
visiting his class on Monday & Mr.Velasquez welcomed any questions or
comments that could be of aid to Dr. Thompson. (See attached)
Mike Sheffield stated that comments & questions could be emailed to him &
would be forwarded to Mr.Velasquez.
Manuel Gonzalez stated DCF participation was possible for the Community
Forum.
It was determined that the list would be tabulated and presented to the Jim Van
Fleet for the selection of 2-6 speakers.
IV. Comments / Announcements
None
V. Public Comments
Rosa Castillo / Hispanic Publication stated she would report the results from the
meeting to inform the community.
Jim Van Fleet recommended that an invitation to attend the Community Forum
be extended to the public.
4
November 29,2007
Being no further business for the good of the County, the meeting was adjourned
by order of the Chair at 7:01 P.M.
COLLIER COUNTY HISPANIC AFFAIRS
ADVISORY COMMITTEE
James Van Fleet, Chairman
These Minutes approved by the Board/Committee on
as presented or as amended
5