CCLAAC Minutes 11/01/2023November 1, 2023
28.A.3
MINUTES OF THE CONSERVATION COLLIER LAND ACQUISITION
ADVISORY COMMITTEE MEETING
Naples, Florida, November 1, 2023
LET IT BE REMEMBERED, the Conservation Collier Land Acquisition Advisory
Committee in and for the County of Collier, having conducted business herein, met on this
date at 1:00 P.M. in REGULAR SESSION at Administrative Building "F", 3'
Floor, Collier County Government Complex Naples, Florida with the following
members present:
CHAIR: Michele Lenhard
VICE CHAIR: Brittany Patterson -Weber (Excused)
Gary Bromley
Ron Clark
Karyn Allman
Rhys Watkins (via Zoom)
John Courtright
Corey McCloskey (via Zoom)
Nick Pearson (Excused)
ALSO PRESENT: Summer Araque, Conservation Collier Program Coordinator
Sally Ashkar, Assistant County Attorney
Melissa Hennig, Environmental Specialist I
Mitchell Barazowksi, Environmental Specialist I
Packet Pg. 338
November 1, 2023
28.A.3
1. Roll Call
Chair Lenhard called the meeting to order at 1:1OP.M. Roll call was taken and a quorum was established
with 5 Members present.
A. Approval of CCLAAC Members attending the meeting remotely
Mr. Bromley moved to allow Ms. McCloskey and Mr. Watkins to participate in the meeting remotely
due to an extraordinary circumstance. Second by Ms. Allman. Carried unanimously S — 0.
2. Approval of Agenda
Mr. Courtright moved to approve the Agenda subject to hearing Public General Comments after Item
4. C. Second by Mr. Bromley. Carried unanimously 7 — 0.
3. Approval of October 4, 2023 Meeting Minutes
Mr. Courtright moved to approve the minutes of the October 4, 2023 meeting as presented. Second by
Mr. Bromley. Carried unanimously 7 — 0.
4. Old Business
A. Acquisition Updates - Current Acquisition Status report updated monthly in advance of CCLAAC
meeting provided as part of meeting packet and under Acquisition News at
www.conservationcollier.com for information purposes. The report will be updated monthly (last
updated October 25, 2023) including parcels the County has acquired to date, offers made by the
County, pending acquisitions and those properties where the owner withdrew the application.
Ms. Araque noted 7 properties are scheduled for closing in November with 14 others anticipated over
the next 30 — 60 days.
B. Purchase Agreements
Ms. Araque provided the "Map of Purchase Parcel Agreements — October 4, 2023 " for information
purposes and presented the following Purchase and Sale agreement for consideration - (The Committee
approved the Purchase and Sale Agreements listed below in one motion but were listed separately for
recording purposes).
1. Winchester Head Preserve multi -parcel project
a. Mooney
Mr. Courtright moved to recommend the Board of County Commissioners approve the
Purchase and Sale Agreement for the Mooney Property. Second by Mr. Bromley. Carried
unanimously 7 — 0.
C. Cycle 12A Initial Screening Criteria (ISC)
1. Land Quest Holdings — near Panther Walk Project Area
Ms. Hennig provided an update on the "Initial Screening Criteria Form" for the above referenced
parcel. It is in NGGE Unit 47, NW corner of intersection of Everglades Blvd. and 68th Ave. NE;
just east of Panther Walk Preserve project area and 2.81 acres in size.
• The Transportation Department has indicated they have a future interest in the parcel for
stormwater retention however a final report on the location of any potential structures has
not been completed, nor the funds approved for any purchases of land in the area.
• The Public Utilities Department reported they are awaiting determinations made by the
Transportation Department on the location of improvements before any decisions on their
needs for the property.
• There is no timeline established for the decision by the Departments.
2
Packet Pg. 339
28.A.3
November 1, 2023
During Committee discussion it was noted:
• If the property is acquired by the Program, the deed would contain provisions on the
County's potential future uses eliminating the need for utilizing the Program's Exceptional
Benefits Ordinance.
The parcel would have been included in the Panther Walk Preserve Target Protection Area;
however the Committee was aware of its potential uses by other County Departments.
The Board of County Commissioners established new funding guidelines for the Program
however the directive noted the Committee should make any recommendations for purchase
based on the Program's criteria, not potential funding sources.
Ms. Ashkar reported if lands within the Program are transferred to another County Department,
Conservation Collier is reimbursed the land acquisition cost at the time it was purchased by the
County.
Chair Lenhard reported Brad Cornell of the Audubon of the Western Everglades provided
comments via email which outlined support for acquisition of the parcel due to its strategic location
for providing stormwater storage and functional habitat. He noted it also appears to offer wildlife
linkage from the south to the north to CREW land habitats.
Mr. Bromley moved to move the parcel forward in the acquisition process and for Staff to
prepare an Initial Criteria Screening Report. Second by Mr. Courtright. Carried unanimously 7
—0.
9. Public General Comments
Speakers
John Munera requested reconsideration of their application heard by the Committee during the September
meeting where a decision was made not to pursue acquisition of the property. He submitted maps to the
Committee in support of his comments and noted the application met 4 of 6 of the Program's criteria. The
Program's Mission Statement references land preservation not public access to lands. The lot is identified
on a map as an area of historical interest, and he received a letter from the County about a lot he owns on
Inlet Drive which does not have the environmental characteristics of this lot.
Kira Krumm-Munera requested reconsideration of their application heard by the Committee noting it
was purchased for preservation purposes, may potentially be developed and home to various wildlife
species.
Ms. Ashkar noted the Committee is Advisory and is not required to take any action on the request. The
Munera's may consider contacting the Board of County Commissioners who ultimately make the decision
on acquiring properties.
Chair Lenhard noted the Committee is targeting other areas of Marco Island and the Munera's received a
letter for their other parcel as the lot is within this area. The letter was simply to determine if the owner is
interested in selling the land to the County and if so, a detailed evaluation of the property is conducted to
determine if the County will move forward acquiring the property.
Speakers
Richard Blonna, City of Marco Island thanked the Committee for their work on acquiring properties on
Marco Island.
Ronald Brija requested reconsideration of his application heard by the Committee during the September
meeting where a decision was made not to pursue acquisition of his property on Marco Island. The lot is in
3
Packet Pg. 340
28.A.3
November 1, 2023
the same area as the Munera's. The property met 4 out of 6 of the Program's criteria and has the potential
for archeological sites especially given the elevation of the lands.
5. New Business
A. Mcllvane Marsh Preserve Land Management Plan
Mr. Barazowksi presented the "Mcllvane Marsh Preserve Land Management Plan — September 2023
— September 2028 " for consideration. He outlined the components of the Plan including the ownership
history, environmental and wildlife habitat characteristics, management activities, protection of habitat
and species (especially the American Crocodile), budget, site security, etc. The proposed plan was
reviewed by the Land Evaluation and Management Subcommittee who provided input and a
recommendation the plan be approved by the full Committee.
During Committee discussion, it was noted Ms. Allman provided recommendations for revisions to the
Plan via an email dated November 1, 2023 which will be incorporated into the plan.
Mr. Clark moved to recommend the Board of County Commissioners approve the ""Mcllvane Marsh
Preserve Land Management Plan — September 2023 — September 2028"for as presented by Staff.
Second by Mr. Bromley. Carried unanimously 7 — 0.
B. Cycle 12B Initial Screening Criteria Form (ISC)
1. Wildcat Acres
Ms. Hennig presented the "Initial Screening Criteria Form" for the above referenced parcel. It is
just south of the Hendry County line and just east of the Lee County line off SR 82 and
approximately 70 acres in size.
It satisfies S of the Initial Screening Criteria.
Speaker
Sharon Kurgis, Property Manager noted the property has been well maintained including the
removal of exotic species and is home to Sandhill Cranes, Spoonbills, Hawks, Caracara, etc. North
of the property is mitigation lands and on the south and east are groves.
During Committee discussion it was noted given the agriculture activity on adjacent parcels, a
Phase I and II Environmental Assessment may be undertaken if the property moves forward in the
acquisition process.
Chair Lenhard noted Brad Cornell of the Audubon of the Western Everglades provided comments
via email which outlined support for acquisition of the parcel for its hydrologic and wildlife values
for wading birds and mammals such as the Florida Panther. Data suggests wildlife linkage
movements with Hendry County and the property is adjacent to conservation easements on the
north.
Mr. Bromley moved to move the parcel forward in the acquisition process and for Staff to
prepare an Initial Criteria Screening Report. Second by Mr. Courtright. Carried unanimously 7
—0.
2. Dr. Robert H. Gore Preserve TPMA (the items were combined for presentation purposes)
a. Eid
El
Packet Pg. 341
28.A.3
November 1, 2023
Ms. Hennig presented the "Initial Screening Criteria Form" for the above referenced parcel. It
is in NGGE Unit 91, south of 34th Ave SE, west of Desoto Blvd. S; north of Dr. Robert H. Gore
Preserve project area and approximately 2.27 acres in size.
It satisfies 3 of the Initial Screening Criteria.
b. Pritchard
Ms. Hennig presented the "Initial Screening Criteria Form" for the above referenced parcel. It
is in NGGE Unit 91, south of 34th Ave SE, west of Desoto Blvd. S; north of Dr. Robert H. Gore
Preserve project area and approximately 2.27 acres in size.
It satisfies 3 of the Initial Screening Criteria.
c. Sunny Florida Investments, Inc.
Ms. Hennig presented the "Initial Screening Criteria Form" for the above referenced parcel. It
is in NGGE Unit 91, south of 34th Ave SE, west of Desoto Blvd. S; north of Dr. Robert H. Gore
Preserve project area and approximately 1.14 acres in size.
It satisfies 3 of the Initial Screening Criteria.
Chair Lenhard noted Brad Cornell of the Audubon of the Western Everglades provided
comments via email which outlined support for acquisition of the parcels.
Mr. Courtright moved to move the parcels forward in the acquisition process and for Staff to
prepare Initial Criteria Screening Reports. Second by Mr. Bromley. Carried unanimously 7
—0.
C. Cycle 12B Initial Criteria Screening Report (ICSR) J
1. Wildflowerz Ranch
Ln
Ms. Hennig presented the "Conservation Collier Land Acquisition Program Initial Criteria Screening
Report for Wildflowerz Ranch. " It is located on Oil Well Road, 639.17 acres in size, received a score
of 331 out of 400 and has an estimated value of $5,552,400. M
N
T
Speaker r
T
Hunter Ward, Real Estate Agent for the property noted there are water wells and structures on the
property which aid in manipulating water levels of the 28 acre pond. The property may be subject to a
South Florida Water Management District permit for agricultural irrigation and is characterized by high
numbers of waterfowl during periodic times.
as
Chair Lenhard noted Brad Cornell of the Audubon of the Western Everglades provided comments via
email which outlined support for acquisition of the parcel due to its significant and wide ranging habitat
and mammal movement functions. J
c�
c.�
6. Subcommittee Reports
A. Lands Evaluation & Management — Chair, Ron Clark — Meeting September 21, 2023
Mr. Clark reported the next Subcommittee meeting is anticipated for March or April of 2024.
B. Outreach — Chair, Brittany Patterson -Weber —last meeting January 20, 2023 a
No update necessary.
C. Ordinance Policy and Rules — Chair, Michele Lenhard - last meeting June 1, 2022
No update necessary.
Packet Pg. 342
28.A.3
November 1, 2023
7. Coordinator Communications
A. Conservation Collier updates
None
B. BCC items related to Conservation Collier
1. Previously heard
a. 10/10 - Cycle 12 Target Mailing Areas (approved)
b. 10/10 - Cycle 12A Active Acquisition List (approved)
c. 10/10 - Purchase Agreements (approved)
d. 10/24 - Marco Island parcels(Annecy/Barfield, Chestnut, South Terra Corp (approved);
Agua Colina (not approved)
2. Upcoming
a. 11/14 —Purchase Agreements
b. 11/14 — Red Maple Swamp Preserve Land Management Plan
8. Chair/Committee Member Comments
None
9. Public General Comments
None
10. Staff Comments
Ms. Araque reported there will a presentation on the Program's budget next month.
13. Next Meeting — December 6, 2023
There being no further business for the good of the County, the meeting was adjourned by order of
the chair at 2:36P.M.
Conservation Collier Land Acquisition Advisory Committee
Michele Lenhard, Chair
These minutes approved by the Committee on
as presented or as amended
6
Packet Pg. 343
Conservation Collier Cycle 10, 11, and 12 Property Status Updated November 27, 28.A.4
SUMMARY PAGE
ACQUISITION SUMMARY OF ALL CYCLE 10, 11A, 1113, and 12A PROPERTIES
Appraised or
Purchase Price
Total number of
Total Acres
Estimate
or Estimated
Value*
Value*
properties
ACQUIRED PROPERTIES
460.98
$5,640,495
$5,576,550
53
(CYCLE 10, 11A, 11B, and 12A)
PROPERTIES PENDING ACQUISITION*
341.18
$16,078,600
$15,756,395L28
(CYCLE 10, 11A, 116, and 12A)
*Estimated value used in calculations until Purchase Agreements are signed by Seller and scheduled for Conservation Collier
Land Acquisition Advisory Committee meeting
Q
Packet Pg. 344
Conservation Collier Cycle 10, 11, and 12 Property Status Updated Nov 28.A.4
CYCLE 10 AAL APPROVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ON JANUARY 25, 2022
CYCLE 10 ACQUIRED PROPERTIES
Property Name
Preserve
Size (ac)
Appraised Value
Closing Amount
Acquisition Status
Aguilar, Jorge
Panther Walk
1.14
$40,000
$40,000
Closed 2/13/23
Preserve
Arias, Eladio
Dr. Robert H. Gore
3.16
$63,000
$52,900
Closed 9/22/23
III Preserve
Arias, Eladio
Dr. Robert H. Gore
3.78
$66,000
$63,200
Closed 9/22/23
III Preserve
Arnay, Henrietta
Panther Walk
1.14
$30,000
$30,000
Closed 6/16/23
Preserve
Bailey, Charles E
Dr. Robert H. Gore
1.14
$25,000
$25,000
Closed 9/20/23
III Preserve
Behnke, Lois
Panther Walk
1.14
$57,000
$57,000
Closed 6/16/23
Preserve
Blocker, Brian
Pepper Ranch
24.50
$220,000
$220,000
Closed 7/7/23
Preserve
Burns, Sandra
Panther Walk
1.14
$30,000
$30,000
Closed 1/30/23
Preserve
Caberera, Mercedes
Red Maple Swamp
9.16
$114,500
$114,500
Closed 3/21/22
Preserve
Castillo, Jose
Red Maple Swamp
5.41
$89,300
$84,835
Closed 7/14/23
Preserve
Charles, Paulette
Dr. Robert H. Gore
1.14
$25,100
$22,500
Closed 6/30/23
III Preserve
Craparo, Stephen
Dr. Robert H. Gore
1.64
$44,000
$39,600
Closed 9/15/23
III Preserve
D & 1 Investors
Panther Walk
1.14
$40,000
$40,000
Closed 6/9/23
Preserve
Dessing, Carol A.
Winchester Head
1.14
$18,810
$18,810
Closed 3/28/22
Preserve
Fesser, Ivan
Winchester Head
2.27
$56,800
$53,960
Closed 9/1/23
Preserve
Fleming, Albert
Dr. Robert H. Gore
1.64
$39,000
$37,500
Closed 9/15/23
III Preserve
Gonzalez, Isabel
Panther Walk
1.14
$50,000
$50,000
Closed 6/16/22
Preserve
Gorman, Herman and Alice
Winchester Head
1.14
$18,810
$18,810
Closed 9/26/22
Preserve
Grossman, Barry
Panther Walk
2.73
$63,000
$63,000
Closed 6/16/23
Preserve
Guerra, Sigrid
Red Maple Swamp
1.14
$20,500
$20,500
Closed 7/7/23
Preserve
Hofmann, Adelaida
Dr. Robert H. Gore
1.59
$36,000
$36,000
Closed 2/27/23
III Preserve
Hussey Trust
North Belle Meade
256.00
$2,072,500
$2,072,500
Closed 11/14/22
Preserve
Johnson, Tim R
Panther Walk
1.14
$30,000
$30,000
Closed 1/30/23
Preserve
Joyce, David
Panther Walk
2.27
$52,000
$52,000
Closed 6/9/23
Preserve
Joyce, Martin and Elizabeth
Panther Walk
2.27
$61,300
$55,170
Closed 8/17/23
Preserve
Martinez, Abel Chavez
Red Maple Swamp
2.27
$40,900
$36,000
Closed 8/17/23
Preserve
McLaughlin Trust, Geraldine
Red Maple Swamp
4.61
$57,625
$57,625
Closed 3/21/22
Preserve
M
N
O
N
L
d
E
O
v
d
a
In
00
ti
N
M
N
r-
N
r
I
3
R
N
J
Q
N
d
R
C
.y
U
Q
Q
C
O
E
t
U
M
Q
Packet Pg. 345
Conservation Collier Cycle 10, 11, and 12 Property Status Updated Nov 28.A.4
CYCLE 10 AAL APPROVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ON JANUARY 25, 2022
CYCLE 10 ACQUIRED PROPERTIES, cont'd
Property Name
Preserve
Size (ac)
Appraised Value
Closing Amount
Acquisition Status
Meyer Trust
Panther Walk
1.59
$72,000
$72,000
Closed 1/30/23
Preserve
Moody Crawford, Jim H
Pepper Ranch
59.79
$505,000
$505,000
Closed 9/22/23
Preserve
Pena, John
Panther Walk
2.27
$52,000
$52,000
Closed 2/13/23
Preserve
Popp, Joe
Rivers Road
19.40
$630,000
$630,000
Closed 9/26/22
Preserve
Quevedo, Odalys
Dr. Robert H. Gore
1.14
$28,000
$26,600
Closed 7/14/23
III Preserve
Rodriguez (f.k.a. Lopez), Terri
Panther Walk
1.59
$42,900
$38,610
Closed 8/17/23
Preserve
Ruben Trust
Winchester Head
1.59
$39,800
$39,800
Closed 7/7/23
Preserve
Rudnick, Carol - Donation
Dr. Robert H. Gore
1.59
N/A
N/A
Closed 6/30/22
III Preserve
Salgado, Julio
Panther Walk
2.73
$73,700
$70,110
Closed 8/17/23
Preserve
Sanchez, PS & NE
Panther Walk
2.73
$63,000
$63,000
Closed 1/30/23
Preserve
Selvig, Maribeth -Donation
Panther Walk
1.14
N/A
N/A
Closed 9/26/22
Preserve
Setser, Carrie, Larry, and Ruby
Red Maple Swamp
5.00
$62,500
$62,500
Closed 3/21/22
Preserve
Sparkman Tamara Gibson
Panther Walk
1.14
$33,000
$33,000
Closed 7/14/23
Preserve
Thommen, William F
Panther Walk
5.00
$100,000
$100,000
Closed 1/30/23
Preserve
Toro, Michael
Winchester Head
1.59
$39,800
$35,820
Closed 6/30/23
Preserve
Trofatter, Frederick
Winchester Head
1.14
$28,000
$25,650
Closed 9/7/23
Preserve
Varney, Gail
Red Maple Swamp
1.14
$14,250
$14,250
Closed 2/14/22
Preserve
Wright, David
Panther Walk
1.14
$30,000
$30,000
Closed 1/30/23
Preserve
Zani, Paul
Dr. Robert H. Gore
2.27
$49,900
$49,900
Closed 7/7/23
III Preserve
Zhuang, Joseph
Panther Walk
2.73
$63,000
$63,000
Closed 1/30/23
Preserve
TOTAL CYCLE 10 ACQUIRED PROPERTIES
453.69
$5,387,995
$5,332,650
Total number of properties = 47
CYCLE 10 PROPERTIES PENDING ACQUISITION
Property Name
Preserve
Size (ac)
Appraised Value
Purchase Price
Acquisition Status
Higdon Trust, Garey D
Winchester Head
1.59
$39,800
$35,820
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on
Preserve
9/26/23; closing pending
Hackmann, Charles
Panther Walk
2.73
$70,000
$63,000
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on
Preserve
10/10/23; closing pending
TOTAL CYCLE 10 PROPERTIES PENDING ACQUISITION
4.32
$109,800
$98,820
Total number of properties = 2
M
N
O
N
L
CD
0
v
d
a
In
00
ti
Q
Packet Pg. 346
Conservation Collier Cycle 10, 11, and 12 Property Status Updated Nov 28.A.4
CYCLE 10 AAL APPROVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ON JANUARY 25, 2022
CYCLE 10 A -LIST PROPERTIES THAT WILL NOT BE ACQUIRED
Property Name
Preserve
Size (ac)
Appraised Value
Offer Amount
Acquisition Status
Amaranth Trust, Forrest G
N/A
71.16
N/A
N/A
Property withdrawn
Anderson, Charles
Panther Walk
2.27
$64,000
$64,000
Offer not accepted
Preserve
Anderson, Charles
Panther Walk
1.14
N/A
N/A
Sold to another
Preserve
Argay, Lorraine D
Dr. Robert H. Gore
7.05
$81,000
$81,000
Offer not accepted
III Preserve
Arnold, Emily
Pepper Ranch
5.00
N/A
N/A
Property withdrawn
Preserve
Arnold, Vanette
Panther Walk
1.14
$30,000
$30,000
Offer not accepted
Preserve
Big Hammock - Area I (Barron
Pepper Ranch
257.3
$900,000
$900,000
Offer not accepted
Collier Partnership)
Preserve
Casasierra Realty LLC
Winchester Head
1.14
$25,650
$25,650
Property withdrawn 3/23/23
Preserve
Cedeno, Kenneth
Dr. Robert H. Gore
2.81
$56,000
$56,000
Offer not accepted
III Preserve
Dahche, Ahmand
Panther Walk
5.00
$130,000
$130,000
Offer not accepted
Preserve
D'Angelo, Eugene
Dr. Robert H. Gore
5.00
$100,000
$100,000
Offer not accepted
III Preserve
Erjavec, Eugene
Rivers Road
4.92
$200,000
$200,000
Offer not accepted
Preserve
Eschuk, Shari
Rivers Road
4.78
$180,000
$180,000
Offer not accepted
Preserve
Fernandez, Erik
Winchester Head
1.59
$39,800
$39,800
Offer not accepted
Preserve
Fischer Trust, Addison
Marco Island
0.63
N/A
N/A
Property withdrawn
Naughton, Veronica
Panther Walk
2.73
N/A
N/A
Sold to another
Preserve
Macrina, Kathleen
Panther Walk
1.14
N/A
N/A
Sold to another
Preserve
Magdalener,losef
Shell Island
18.73
N/A
N/A
Property withdrawn
Preserve
Moylan, Paul E
Panther Walk
2.73
$63,000
$63,000
Offer not accepted
Preserve
Ortega, Gerardo
Panther Walk
1.14
$30,000
$30,000
Property withdrawn
Preserve
Three Brothers
Panther Walk
2.73
$63,000
$63,000
Offer not accepted
Preserve
WISC Investment - Inlet Dr
Marco Island
0.39
$429,000
$429,000
Purchase Agreement not approved by BCC
TOTAL CYCLE 10 A -LIST PROPERTIES THAT WILL NOT BE
400.52
$2,391,450
$2,391,450
Total number of properties = 22
ACQUIRED
M
N
O
N
L
d
E
O
v
d
a
v7
00
ti
N
M
N
N
�I
3
r
R
N
J
Q
N
d
R
a
C
N
U
Q
Q
a+
C
O
E
t
v
M
Q
Packet Pg. 347
Conservation Collier Cycle 10, 11, and 12 Property Status
Updated N 28.A.4
CYCLE 11A AAL APPROVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ON DECEMBER 13, 2022
CYCLE 11A ACQUIRED PROPERTIES
Size (ac)
Appraised Value
Closing Amount
Berman Trust, R F
Dr. Robert H. Gore III
Preserve
1.14
$30,000
$28,500
Closed 9/15/23
McGinnis, Patricia
Panther Walk Preserve
1.14
$45,000
$42,800
Closed 11/17/23
Repola, Andrea
Panther Walk Preserve
1.14
$45,000
$42,800
Closed 9/15/23
Scalley, William J and Martha
Panther Walk Preserve
1.14
$45,000
$42,800
Closed 11/17/23
Trigoura, Delsina
Dr. Robert H. Gore III
Preserve
1.14
$30,000
$30,000
Closed 11/17/23
Vaz, Maurice J
Panther Walk Preserve
1.59
$57,500
$57,000
Closed 9/15/23
TOTAL CYCLE 11A ACQUIRED PROPERTIES
7.29
$252,500
$243,900
Total number of properties = 6
CYCLE 11A PROPERTIES PENDING ACQUISITION
Property Name
Preserve
Size (ac)
Appraised Value
Purchase Price
Acquisition Status
Annecy Marco LLC / Barfield
Marco Island
2.13
$3,140,000
$3,140,000
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 10/24/22
closing pending
Fontela, Maricel Aleu
Dr. Robert H. Gore III
1.14
$25,700
$25,700
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 8/22/23,
Preserve
closing pending
Geren, Jonathan
North Belle Meade
7.84
$129,500
$129,500
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 9/12/23,
Preserve
closing pending
Gutierrez, Michael
North Belle Meade
4.88
$85,400
$81,100
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 9/12/23,
Preserve
closing scheduled for 1/12/24
Perez Castro, Pedro
Dr. Robert H. Gore III
1.17
$29,000
$27,600
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 9/26/23,
Preserve
closing pending
Perona, Barbara
Winchester Head
1.59
$39,800
$39,800
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 9/12/23,
Preserve
closing scheduled for 12/1/23
Scotti, Mary
North Belle Meade
8.74
$135,500
$128,700
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 9/12/23,
Preserve
closing scheduled for 12/1/23
South Terra Corp
Marco Island
0.56
$1,720,000
$1,620,000
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 10/24/23
closing pending
Sponseller, Robert
North Belle Meade
5.00
$90,000
$90,000
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 9/12/23,
Preserve
closing pending
VanCleave, Matthew
Rivers Road Preserve
0.50
$52,500
$52,500
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 9/26/23,
closing scheduled for 12/8/23
TOTAL CYCLE 11A PROPERTIES PENDING ACQUISITION
33.55
$5,447,400
$5,334,900
Total number of properties = 10
CYCLE 11A A -LIST PROPERTIES THAT WILL NOT BE ACQUIRED
Size (ac)
Appraised Value
Offer Amount
Agua Colina
Marco Island
0.63
$1,120,000
$1,120,000
Purchase Agreement not approved by Board
Berman Rev Trust, R F
Panther Walk Preserve
1.17
$46,000
$43,700
No longer interested in selling
Chestnut, Diane
Marco Island
0.53
$627,500
$627,500
Offer not accepted
Colon, Donna &Patricia Mack
Dr. Robert H. Gore III
Preserve
2.27
$39,500
$37,500
Selling to another
S & B Properties of Marco LLC
Marco Island
0.50
$570,000
$570,000
Offer not accepted
Starnes, Hugh
Caracara Prairie Preserve
4.54
$250,000
$250,000
Offer not accepted
TOTAL CYCLE 11A A -LIST PROPERTIES THAT WILL NOT BE
ACQUIRED
9.64
$2,653,000
$2,648,700
Total number of properties = 6
to
00
ti
N
a
Packet Pg. 348
Conservation Collier Cycle 10, 11, and 12 Property Status
Updated N 28.A.4
CYCLE 11B AAL APPROVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ON FEBRUARY 28, 2023
CYCLE 11B ACQUIRED PROPERTIES
Size (ac)
Appraised Value
Closing Amount
TOTAL CYCLE 11B ACQUIRED PROPERTIES
0.00
$0
Total number of properties = 0
CYCLE 11B PROPERTIES PENDING ACQUISITION
Appraised/Estimated
Purchase
Property Name
Preserve
Size (ac)
Value
Price/Estimated Value
Acquisition Status
Bailey, Scott and Christopher
Winchester Head
1.59
$39,800
$38,S00
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 11/14/2:
Preserve
closing pending
Brewer, Richard
N/A
14.78
$451,000
$405,900
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 9/26/23
closing scheduled for 12/8/23
Dibala Wood Trust
Dr. Robert H. Gore III
18.28
$275,000
$261,300
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 10/10/2:
Preserve
closing scheduled for 12/8/23
Dredge Management Assoc LLC
Shell Island Preserve
18.73
$1,592,500
$1,512,875
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 11/14/2'.
closing pending
English Trust
Pepper Ranch Preserve
59.01
$515,000
$463,500
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 9/26/23closing
scheduled for 12/8/23
Mooney/Hankins-Colon
Winchester Head
1.59
$39,800
$39,800
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 11/14/2'.
Preserve
closing pending
Weir Trust, Celine
Dr. Robert H. Gore III
2.27
$39,500
$37,500
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 9/12/23
Preserve
closing pending
Williams
ancy Payton Preserve
0.50
$60,000
$60,000
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 11/14/2:
closing pending
Wilson Trust
Winchester Head
1.59
$39,800
$39,800
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 10/10/2'.
Preserve
closing scheduled for 12/8/23
Subtotal - Properties with Board Approved Purchase
118.34
$3,052,400
$2,859,175
Subtotal number of properties = 9
Agreements
Descoteau, Donn &Donna*
Dr. Robert H. Gore III
1.14
$25,100
$25,100
Offer accepted; Purchase Agreement pending
Preserve
Relevant Radio, Inc.*
Mcllvane Marsh
10.46
$133,000
$133,000
In Negotiation
Preserve
Subtotal - Properties with Board Approval of Purchase
11.60
$158,100
$158,100
Subtotal number of properties = 2
Agreements Pending
TOTAL CYCLE 11B PROPERTIES PENDING ACQUISITION
129.94
$3,230,500
$3,017,275
Total number of properties = 11
CYCLE 11B A -LIST PROPERTIES THAT WILL NOT BE ACQUIRED
Property Name
Preserve
Size (ac)
Appraised Value
Offer Amount
Acquisition Status
Buckley Enterprises*
Nancy Payton Preserve
80.00
$640,000
$640,000
Under contract to another
Khoury
Otter Mound Preserve
0.43
N/A
N/A
Sold to another
Lie, Run He
Nancy Payton Preserve
0.50
$80,000
$80,000
Offer not accepted
Owl Hammock
N/A
7,378.00
TBD
TBD
On -hold pending State of Florida acquisition
Sit/Chew
Nancy Payton Preserve
3.00
$390,000
$390,000
Offer not accepted
Smith &Montgomery
Dr. Robert H. Gore III
Preserve
2.73
N/A
N/A
Property withdrawn
TOTAL CYCLE 11B A -LIST PROPERTIES THAT WILL NOT BE
ACQUIRED
7,464.66
$1,130,000
$1,110,000
Total number of properties = 6
* Estimated Value used in calculations until Purchase Agreement is signed by Seller and scheduled for Conservation Collier Land Acquisition Advisory Committee meeting
Packet Pg. 349
Conservation Collier Cycle 10,11, and 12 Property Status Updated November 27, 28.A.4
CYCLE 12A AAL APPROVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ON OCTOBER 10, 2023
CYCLE 12A ACQUIRED PROPERTIES
Size (ac)
Appraised Value
Closing Amount
TOTAL CYCLE 12A ACQUIRED PROPERTIES
0.00
$0
$0
Total number of properties = 0
CYCLE 12A PROPERTIES PENDING ACQUISITION
Appraised/Estimated
Purchase
Property Name
Preserve
Size (ac)
Value
Price/Estimated
Acquisition Status
A & T Kleinberger Rev
Dr. Robert H. Gore
5.00
$110,000
$104,500
Offer accepted; Purchase Agreement
Trust*
III Preserve
scheduled for BCC 1/9/24
Aristizabal*
Mcllvane Marsh
5.00
$26,500
$26,500
Appraisal ordered
Preserve
Murawski Trust*
North Belle Meade
4.87
$24,400
$24,400
Appraisal ordered
Preserve
Symphony Properties*
N/A
150.00
$7,100,000
$7,100,000
Phase 1 Environmental Assessment
ordered
Volpe Trust*
North Belle Meade
8.50
$50,000
$50,000
Appraisal ordered
Preserve
TOTAL CYCLE 12A PROPERTIES PENDING
173.37
$7,310,900
$7,305,400
Total number of properties = 5
ACQUISITION
CYCLE 12A A -LIST PROPERTIES THAT WILL NOT BE ACQUIRED
Size (ac)
Appraised Value
Offer Amount
TOTAL CYCLE 12A A -LIST PROPERTIES
0.00
$0
$0
Total number of properties = 0
THAT WILL NOT BE ACQUIRED
* Estimated Value used in calculations until Purchase Agreement is signed by Seller and scheduled for Conservation Collier Land
Acquisition Advisory Committee meeting
1C
C
E
t
ca
Q
Packet Pg. 350