Agenda 11/27/2007 R
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY BOARD (CRAB)
AGENDA
November 27, 2007
9:00 AM
Jim Coletta, BCC Chairman, District 5; CRAB Vice-Chairman
Tom Henning, BCC Vice- Chairman, District 3
Donna Fiala, BCC Commissioner, District 1; CRAB Chairman
Frank Halas, BCe Commissioner, District 2
Fred W. Coyle, BCC Commissioner, District 4
NOTICE: ALL PERSONS WISHING TO SPEAK ON ANY AGENDA ITEM MUST REGISTER PRIOR TO
SPEAKING. SPEAKERS MUST REGISTER WITH THE COUNTY MANAGER PRIOR TO THE
PRESENTATION OF THE AGENDA ITEM TO BE ADDRESSED. ALL REGISTERED SPEAKERS
WILL RECEIVE UP TO THREE (3) MINUTES UNLESS THE TIME IS ADJUSTED BY THE CHAIRMAN.
COLLIER COUNTY ORDINANCE NO. 2003-53, AS AMENDED BY ORDINANCE 2004-05 AND 2007-24,
REQUIRES THAT ALL LOBBYISTS SHALL, BEFORE ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES
(INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, ADDRESSING THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS),
REGISTER WITH THE CLERK TO THE BOARD AT THE BOARD MINUTES AND RECORDS
DEPARTMENT.
REQUESTS TO ADDRESS THE BOARD ON SUBJECTS WHICH ARE NOT ON THIS AGENDA MUST BE
SUBMITTED IN WRITING WITH EXPLANATION TO THE COUNTY MANAGER AT LEAST 13 DAYS
PRIOR TO THE DATE OF THE MEETING AND WILL BE HEARD UNDER "PUBLIC PETITIONS."
ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL A DECISION OF THIS BOARD WILL NEED A RECORD OF
THE PROCEEDINGS PERTAINING THERETO, AND THEREFORE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A
VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY
AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED.
IF YOU ARE A PERSON WITH A DISABILITY WHO NEEDS ANY ACCOMMODATION IN ORDER TO
PARTICIPATE IN THIS PROCEEDING, YOU ARE ENTITLED, AT NO COST TO YOU, TO THE
PROVISION OF CERTAIN ASSISTANCE. PLEASE CONTACT THE COLLIER COUNTY FACILITIES
MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT LOCATED AT 3301 EAST TAMIAMI TRAIL, NAPLES, FLORIDA, 34112,
(239) 774-8380; ASSISTED LISTENING DEVICES FOR THE HEARING IMPAIRED ARE AVAILABLE IN
THE COUNTY COMMISSIONERS' OFFICE.
LUNCH RECESS SCHEDULED FOR 12:00 NOON TO 1:00 P.M.
1 of 11
1. INVOCATION AND PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
2. AGENDA AND MINUTES
A. Approval of today's regular, consent and summary agenda as amended. (Ex Parte Disclosure
provided by Commission members for consent and summary agenda.)
B. October 9, 2007 - BCCIRegular Meeting
C. October 18,2007 - Value Adjustment Board Special Magistrate Davia Mazur
D. October 23-24, 2007 - BCC/Regular Meeting
E. October 24, 2007 - BCC/LDC Meeting
F. October 29, 2007 - Value Adjustment Board Special Magistrate Stephen Cunningham
G. October 30, 2007 - Value Adjustment Board Special Magistrate Stephen Cunningham
H. October 30, 2007 - BCC/Land Development Code Meeting
I. October 31, 2007 - Value Adjustment Board Special Magistrate Scott Watson
J. October 31, 2007 - Vaiue Adjustment Board Special Magistrate Davia Mazur
K. November 2, 2007 - BCC/Pre-Legislative Session Workshop
3. SERVICE AWARDS: (EMPLOYEE AND ADVISORY BOARD MEMBERS)
A. 20 Year Attendees
1. Donald Champlin, Road Maintenance
2. Kelly Grandy, Library
3. Miguel Herrera, Road Maintenance
4. Susan Rossi, CDES Operations
B. 25 Year Attendees
1. Helen Ortega, EMS
4. PROCLAMATIONS
A. Sandra Arnold-Lawson be congratulated for receiving the Certified Emergency Manager (CEM)
designation from the International Association of Emergency Manager (IAEM). To be accepted
by Sandra Arnold-Lawson.
B. Proclamation to recognize the CCPC for their work on the AUIR. To be accepted by Planning
Commission members.
C. Proclamation to recognize members of the Productivity Committee for their work on the AUIR.
To be accepted by Productivity Committee members.
D. Proclamation to recognize Matthew Berning, Troop 2001 Life Scout Eagle candidate, for his
efforts to organize an electronics recycling round up event and to designate December 1, 2007,
as a Day of Recycling for Electronic Waste in Collier County. To be accepted by Life Scout
Eagle Candidate Matthew Berning.
2 of 11
5. PRESENTATIONS
A. Presentation by Chip Merriam, Deputy Executive Director, South Florida Water Management
District, regarding the local Comprehensive Pian as it relates to S.B. 360 and 444.
B. Recommendation to recognize Jim von Rinteln, Emergency Management Coordinator, Bureau
of Emergency Services, as Employee of the Month for November 2007.
C. Contractor Presentation on the New, Collier County, Courthouse Annex; Project No. 52533;
Kraft Construction eM at Risk Contract.
D. This item to be heard at 11 :00 a.m. Swearing in ceremony for the newly eiected Florida House
of Representatives Member, District 101.
6. PUBLIC PETITIONS
A. Public petition request by Mary Mayville, Collier County Agricultural Fair & Exposition, Inc., to
discuss reinstatement of a permanent beer license.
B. Public petition request by Mark Adamczyk to discuss the construction of a County park in the
Delasol community.
C. Public petition request by Patrick White to discuss Orders Finding Violation relating to property
owned by Jerry and Kimberlea Blocker.
D. Public petition request by Craig Brugger to discuss waiver to contract with FGUA for their
Goiden Gate Wastewater Plant Injection Well.
E. Pubiic petition request by Robert Lockhart to discuss CEB Case No. 2004-026 and related
fines.
Item 7 and 8 to be heard no sooner than 1 :00 p.m" unless otherwise noted.
7. BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
8. ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS
A. This item requires that all participants be sworn in and ex parte disclosure be provided by
Commission members. Petition: PUDZ-2006-AR-l0648: Naples Motorcoach Resort Inc.,
represented by Robert L. Duane, AICP, of HoleMontes, Inc., and Richard D. Yovanovich,
esquire, of Goodlette, Coleman, & Johnson, P.A., is requesting a rezone from the Mobile Home,
Travel Trailer Recreational Vehicle Campground, and Heavy Commercial Zoning Districts (MH,
TTRVC & C-5) to the Commercial Planned Unit Development District (CPUD) for a project to be
known as the Naples Motorcoach Resort CPUD. This project proposes to allow development of
up to 200 motorcoach lots as well as various amenities such as a boat ramp and boat slips. The
subject property, consisting of 23.2 acres, is located on the southwest side of Tamiami Trail,
East, approximately three quarters of a mile east of Collier Boulevard (CR 951), in Section 3,
Township 51 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida.
3 of 11
B. This item requires that all participants be sworn in and ex parte disclosure be provided by
Commission members. Petition: CU-2007-AR-11970, American Dream Builders, represented by
James McCord, is requesting a Conditional Use for the extension of a Model Home/Sales
Center, which has been in existence since 1997. The subject property is located in Golden Gate
Estates on Tract 119, in Unit 26, at the Southwest corner of 13th Ave SW and Collier Boulevard
(CR 951), Section 15, Township 49 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida
C. This item continued from the June 12, 2007 and October 23,2007 BCC meetings. This item
requires that all participants be sworn In and ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission
members. PUDZ-2006-AR-l0698: A. Grover Matheney, Trustee, represented by R. Bruce
Anderson esquire, of Roetzel & Andress, LPA and Margaret Perry, AICP, of Wilson Miller, Inc., is
requesting a rezone from Planned Unit Development (PUD) to Commercial Planned Unit
Development (CPUD) for a project to be known as the Gaspar Station PUD. The subject
property, consisting of 17.7 acres, is located on the south side of Immokalee Road (CR 846),
approximately one quarter mile west of the 1-75/lmmokalee Road, interchange, in Section 30,
Township 48 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida.
9. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
A. This item to be heard at 10:00 a.m. Presentation by Andrea B. Sims of The Waters-Oidani
Executive Recruitment, a division of the Waters Consulting Group, Inc.
B. Appointment of member to the Vanderbilt Beach Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee.
C. Appointment of member to the Collier County Code Enforcement Board.
D. Appointment of member to the Affordabie Housing Commission.
E. Appointment of member to the Immokalee EZDA.
10. COUNTY MANAGER'S REPORT
A. Obtain direction from the Board of County Commissioners on accepting after-fhe-fact
developer applications for deferral of 100% of Collier County impact fees for owner-occupied
affordable housing units and provide direction to staff to amend the Consolidated Impact Fee
Ordinance. Board direction on this item will directly impact the following items on todays
agenda: lOB, 10C, 100, 10E, 10F, lOG, 10H, 101, 10J, 10K, 10L, 10M and 10N.
B. Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with Garry Jean Baptiste and Syndy Jean Baptiste (Owners)
for deferral of 100% of Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable housing
unit located at Lot 26, Block 11, Naples Manor Lakes and authorizes a reimbursement of the
fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc on Building Permit 2007041982 in the
amount of $26,204.83.
c. Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with Araceli Ramirez (Owner) for deferral of 100% of Collier
County impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable housing unit located at Lot 8, Liberty
Landing and authorizes a reimbursement of the fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier
County Inc on Building Permit 2007020738 in the amount of $12,442.52.
D. Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with Roberto Maciel Chavez and Gloria Maciel (Owners) for
deferral of 100% of Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable housing unit
located at Lot 15, Trail Ridge and authorizes a reimbursement of the fees paid by Habitat for
Humanity of Collier County Inc on Building Permit 2006064370 in the amount of $13,616.20.
4 of 11
E. Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with David Licot and Nancy Licot (Owners) for deferral of
100% of Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable housing unit located at
Lot 121, Trail Ridge and authorizes a reimbursement of the fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of
Collier County Inc on Building Permit 2007012026 in the amount of $19,372.52.
F. Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with Jean S. Jean Noel and Marie J. Montfort (Owners) for
deferral of 100% of Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable housing unit
located at Lot 5, Liberty Landing and authorizes a reimbursement of the fees paid by Habitat for
Humanity of Collier County Inc on Building Permit 2007020743 in the amount of $12,442.52.
G. Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with Clairicia Achille (Owner) for deferral of 100% of Collier
County impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable housing unit located at Lot 7, Liberty
Landing and authorizes a reimbursement of the fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier
County Inc on Building Permit 2007020740 in the amount of $12,442.52.
H. Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with Monica Martinez (Owner) for deferral of 100% 'of Collier
County impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable housing unit located at Lot 14, Trail
Ridge and authorizes a reimbursement of the fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Coliier
County inc on Building Permit 2006064365 in the amount of $13,616.20.
I. Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with Miguel Vera Vera and Maria Elena Vera (Owners) for
deferral of 100% of Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable housing unit
located at Lot 16, Liberty Landing and authorizes a reimbursement of the fees paid by Habitat
for Humanity of Collier County inc on Buiiding Permit 2007020728 in the amount of $12,442.52.
J. Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with Marise Omeus (Owner) for deferral of 100% of Collier
County impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable housing unit iocated at Lot 18, Trail
Ridge and authorizes a reimbursement of the fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier
County Inc on Building Permit 2006064384 in the amount of $13,616.20.
K. Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with Guerline Mathieu (Owner) for deferral of 100% of
Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable housing unit located at Lot 13,
Liberty Landing and authorizes a reimbursement of the fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of
Coliier County Inc on Building Permit 2007020732 in the amount of $12,442.52.
L. Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with Inel Tanis and Almonise Tanis (Owners) for deferral of
100% of Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable housing unit located at
Lot 19, Block 14, Naples Manor Lakes and authorizes a reimbursement of the fees paid by
Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc on Building Permit 2007052698 in the amount of
$26,240.68.
M. Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with Nicolas Huerta Lara and Juana Cortes Alvarez
(Owners) for deferral of 100% of Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable
housing unit located at Lot 16, Trail Ridge and authorizes a reimbursement of the fees paid by
Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc on Building Permit 2006064377 in the amount of
$13,616.20.
5 of 11
N. Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with Jean C. Jean Pierre and Marie Jose Jean Pierre
(Owners) for deferral of 100% of Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable
housing unit located at Lot 11, Block 6, Naples Manor Lakes and authorizes a reimbursement of
the fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc on Building Permit 2007041987 in
the amount of $26,204.83.
O. Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners provide direction related to the
acceptance of after-the-fact developer applications from Habitat for Humanity of Collier County,
Incorporated for 48 properties and the reimbursement of impact fees paid prior to issuance of a
Building Permit and execution of an impact fee deferral agreement (Amy Patterson, Impact
Fee/EDC Manager, Community Development & Environmental Services Division)
P. Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners evaluate and consider each option
presented with respect to including less than five acre illegal Rural Fringe Mixed Use District
(RFMUD) Sending Land properties into the Transfer of Development Rights (TOR) Program for
the purposes of programmatic participation relative to TOR severance. (Joe Thompson,
Planner, Comprehensive Planning, Community Development & Environmental Services
Division)
Q. Recommendation for the Board of County Commissioners to approve a funding change for the
Goodlette Frank Road Project (60005); Collier Bouievard South Project (60001); and the Davis
Boulevard Project (60073) in the amount of $2,279,900. (Norman Feder, Transportation Services
Administrator)
R. This item to be heard at 4:00 p.m. Recommendation to grant final approval of the roadway
(private) and drainage improvements for the final plat of Strada Bella (Olde Cypress PUDlo The
roadway and drainage improvements will be privately maintained.(Stan Chrzanowski, Senior
Engineer, Engineering & Environmental Services Department, Community Development &
Environmental Services Division)
S. Recommendation to adopt a Resolution (Initiating Resolution) of the Board of County
Commissioners of Collier County, Fiorida, pursuant to Part II of Chapter 171, Florida Statutes
(Florida's interlocal Service Boundary Act) to commence the process for negotiating an
interlocal service boundary agreement regarding 204.19 acres of land, more or less, described
as the Hole in the Wall Golf Club, proposed to be annexed into the City of Naples. (Jim Mudd,
County Manager)
T. Recommendation to approve a modification to Agreement 07-EC-33-09-21-01-486 between the
State of Florida, Division of Emergency Management and Collier County accepting an
additional $1,693,940 towards the construction of a new County Emergency Operations Center
(EOC) within the Emergency Services Center (ESC) and approve the Budget Amendment
necessary to recognize and appropriate $1,693,940 as revenue. (Jim von Rinteln, Emergency
Management Coordinator)
U. Recommendation to adopt a Resolution amending the Collier County Administrative Code Fee
Schedule of development-related review and processing fees as provided for in The Code of
Laws and Ordinances, Section 2-11 (Companion Item to 10V) (Joe Schmitt, Community
Development Administrator)
V. Recommendation to adopt a Resolution amending the Collier County Administrative Code Fee
Schedule of development-related review and processing fees as provided for in The Code of
Laws and Ordinances, Section 2-11 (Companion Item to 10U) (Joe Schmitt, Community
Development Administrator)
W. Recommendation to amend the Countys Purchasing Policy to further modernize the Countys
business practices. (Steve Carnell, Purchasing Department Director)
6 of 11
11. PUBLIC COMMENTS ON GENERAL TOPICS
12. COUNTY ATTORNEY'S REPORT
13. OTHER CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICERS
14. AIRPORT AUTHORITY AND/OR COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY
15. STAFF AND COMMISSION GENERAL COMMUNICATIONS
16. CONSENT AGENDA - All matters listed under this item are considered to be routine and action will
be taken by one motion without separate discussion of each item. If discussion is desired by a
member of the Board, that item(s) will be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered
separately.
------------------------------.-----.--.----------------------------.--------------.----------------------------.--------------_._------------
A. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
1. Recommendation to have the Board of County Commissioners (BeC) prioritize the watersheds
for development of the Watershed Management Plans.
2. Recommendation to approve the Release and Satisfactions of Lien for payments received for
the following Code Enforcement actions.
3. To accept final and unconditional conveyance of the water utility facility for Falling Waters
North Preserve.
4. Release and Satisfactions of Lien
5. To accept final and unconditional conveyance of the water utility facility for Calusa Island
Village.
6. Recommendation to approve final acceptance of the water and sewer utility facility for
VeronaWalk, Phase 2A.
7. Recommendation to approve final acceptance of the water and sewer utility facilities for
VeronaWalk, Phase 2B.
8. Recommendation to approve final acceptance of the water and sewer utility conveyance for
VeronaWalk,Phase 2C.
9. Recommendation to approve final acceptance of the water and sewer utility facilities for
Heritage Bay, Phase 1 B.
10. Recommendation to approve final acceptance of the water and sewer utility facilities for Forest
Park, Phase 4
11. Recommendation to approve final acceptance of the water and sewer utility facilities for North
Naples Research and Technology Park.
12. This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission Members. Should a
hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to
approve for recording the finai plat of Ave Maria Unit 6, Bellerawalk Phase 1 B, approval of the
standard form Construction and Maintenance Agreement and approval of the amount of the
performance security.
7 of 11
B. TRANSPORTATION SERVICES
1. Recommendation to authorize Board of County Commissioners Chairman to enter into a Local
Agency Program (LAP) Agreement with the Florida Department of Transportation, on behalf of
Collier County, for receipt of Federal dollars in the amount of $134,000 for landscaping
enhancements for SR 93/1-75 at Golden Gate Parkway.
2. Recommendation for the Board of County Commissioners to approve a funding source change
for past and future expenditures in the amount of $500,000 for Fleet Maintenance expenses and
the Collier Area Transit facility repair and renovation expenses.
3. Recommendation to approve a budget amendment to transfer funds into a new stormwater
project known as the Golden Gate City Stormwater Outfall Replacements, Project Number
510291, in the amount of $66,500.
4. To obtain Board of County Commissioner approval of an Easement Agreement and acceptance
of a Drainage, Access and Maintenance Easement from the District School Board of Collier
County for the purpose of maintaining the current drainage pattern in Section 34, Township
49S, Range 26E.
5. Recommendation for the Board of County Commissioners to approve a budget amendment to
move unspent landscape maintenance fees that rolled from fiscal year 2007 into fiscal year
2008 to the Bridge Repair/Rehabilitation Program in the amount of $621 ,721.61.
C. PUBLIC UTILITIES
1. Recommendation to award Bid Number 07-4192 for the purchase and installation of one 200
KW Generator for the Goodland Repump Station in the amount of $62,999 to Power Pro Tech
Services and approve a budget amendment within the Goodland Water District Fund 441.
2. Recommendation to adopt a Resolution to approve the Satisfaction of Lien for a Solid Waste
residential account wherein the County has received payment and said lien is satisfied in full
for the 1993 Solid Waste Collection and Disposal Services Special Assessment. Fiscal impact
is $20.00 to record the Satisfaction of Lien.
3. Recommendation to Award Bid Number 07-4181 for landscaping of Public Utilities Division
facilities in the estimated amount of $400,000 to Florida Land Maintenance, Amera- Tech
Incorporated, and Ground Zero Landscaping.
4. Recommendation to approve five Work Orders for the development of the 2007 Master Plans
for a not to exceed total of $781,940. Under Contract #05-3785, Fixed Term Contract for
Professional Utilities Engineering Services, with Greeley & Hansen LLC four Work Orders for
the 2007 Water, Wastewater, Irrigation Quality Water and Water Supply Master Plans for a total
of $678,940. Under Contract #07-4071, Fixed Term Contract for Financial Consulting Services,
with Public Resources Management Group, Inc. one Work Order for the 2007 Water,
Wastewater and Irrigation Quality Water Rate and Impact Fee Studies for $103,000. Projects
Numbers 70070, 75007, 73066, 72516, 75005 and 75018 cover these Work Orders.
8 of 11
D. PUBLIC SERVICES
1. Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approve, and authorize the
Chairman to sign, an Amended Subrecipient Agreement with Collier County Housing
Development Corporation (CCHDC). This amendment is to extend the timeline for the
development of Cirrus Pointe. The HOME grant was provided to the CCHDC to acquire
approximately 10 acres of land, which was purchased in December, 2005 including the
developers fee of $30,000 for a total of $320,000. Cirrus Pointe will construct 108 units of which
32 units will be for new affordable housing units in Collier County.
2. Recommendation to approve the after-the-fact submittal of the attached Older Americans Act
grant application to the Area Agency on Aging to provide nutrition programming, in-home
support services and case management for elderly residents in Collier County.
3. Recommendation to approve an agreement between the Board of County Commissioners and
Benderson Development Company to allow the usage of the Golden Gate Kmart Plaza for
parking during Snowfest.
E. ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES
1. Report and ratify Property, Casualty, Workers Compensation and Subrogation Claims settled
and/or closed by the Risk Management Director pursuant to Resolution # 2004-15 for the fourth
quarter of FY 07.
F. COUNTY MANAGER
1. Recommend approval of an interlocal agreement with the City of Naples to lease office space
for use by the Coliier County Film Commission Office.
2. Recommend approval of the award of RFP #07-4175, Collier County Tourism Department Public
Relations Assistance, and corresponding tourism agreement between Collier County and BCF
of Florida, inc. in the annual amount of $140,000
G. AIRPORT AUTHORITY AND/OR COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY
1. Recommendation for the Community Redevelopment Agency to approve a Resolution
terminating a Site Improvement Grant Agreement between the CRA and Sona Gallery and Echo
LLC due to applicants failure to meet terms of the agreement
2. Report to the Collier County Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA) providing an update on
a proposed public referendum allowing the CRA to incur debt and to delay the desired
referendum until November 4, 2008.
H. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
1. Commissioner Henning requests Board approval for reimbursement for attending a function
serving a valid public purpose. Attended the Collier Citizen of the Year event on Thursday,
November 15 at The Naples Elks Lodge; $35.00 to be paid from Commissioner Henning's travel
budget.
2. Commissioner Coletta requests Board approval for reimbursement regarding attendance at a
function serving a valid public purpose. Attending as a "celebrity server" at the Farm City BBQ
on November 21, 2007. $18 to be paid from Commissioner Coletta's travel budget.
3. Commissioner Coletta requests Board approval for reimbursement regarding attendance at a
function serving a valid public purpose. Attending the Leadership COllier 20th Annual Platinum
Holiday Party on December 6, 2007. $45 to be paid from Commissioner Coletta's travel budget.
9 of 11
4. Commissioner Coletta requests Board approval for reimbursement regarding attendance at a
function serving a valid public purpose. Attending Greater Naples Better Government
Committee Holiday Social on December 18, 2007. $10 to be paid from Commissioner Coletta's
travel budget.
I. MISCELLANEOUS CORRESPONDENCE
1. Miscellaneous items to file for record with action as directed.
J. OTHER CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICERS
1. To obtain Board approval for disbursements for the period of November 3, 2007 through
November 9, 2007 and for submission into the official records of the Board.
2. To obtain Board approval for disbursements for the period of November 10, 2007 through
November 16,2007 and for submission into the official records of the Board.
K. COUNTY ATTORNEY
1. Recommendation to approve a re~conveyance of unused portions of certain dedicated rights~
of-way in Immokalees Newmarket Subdivision.
2. Request by the Housing Finance Authority of Collier County for approval of resoiution
authorizing the Authority to issue single family housing revenue bonds to be used to finance a
qualifying singie family project to provide affordable workforce housing.
17. SUMMARY AGENDA - THIS SECTION IS FOR ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS AND MUST MEET
THE FOLLOWING CRITERIA: 1) A RECOMMENDATION FOR APPROVAL FROM STAFF; 2)
UNANIMOUS RECOMMENDATION FOR APPROVAL BY THE COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING
COMMISSION OR OTHER AUTHORIZING AGENCIES OF ALL MEMBERS PRESENT AND VOTING; 3)
NO WRITTEN OR ORAL OBJECTIONS TO THE ITEM RECEIVED BY STAFF, THE COLLIER COUNTY
PLANNING COMMISSION, OTHER AUTHORIZING AGENCIES OR THE BOARD, PRIOR TO THE
COMMENCEMENT OF THE BCC MEETING ON WHICH THE ITEMS ARE SCHEDULED TO BE
HEARD; AND 4) NO INDIVIDUALS ARE REGISTERED TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO THE ITEM.
FOR THOSE ITEMS, WHICH ARE QUASI-JUDICIAL IN NATURE, ALL PARTICIPANTS MUST BE
SWORN IN.
A. This item requires that all participants be sworn in and ex parte disclosure be provided by
Commission members.PE-2007-AR-12164, Keith Basik, Larry Basik, Jeff Basik of Naples Big
Cypress Market Place, represented by Patrick White, Esquire, of Porter, Wright, Morris and
Arthur, LLP, is requesting a Parking Exemption for an irregularly shaped parcel of just less
than ten acres to allow over flow parking facilities of approximately 372 total additional parking
spaces in excess of minimum required parking for Naples Big Cypress Market Place. The
subject property is located at 220 Basik Drive, at the Northwest corner of US 41 and Trinity
Place, Section 17, Township 51 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida.
B. This item requires that all participants be sworn in and ex parte disclosure be provided by
Commission members.PUDEX-2007-AR-12177 (NG) Hammock Woods, LLC, represented by
David R. Underhill, Jr., of Banks Engineering, and Richard D. Yovanovich, Esquire, of
Goodlette, Coleman, and Johnson, P.A., is requesting a two~year extension for the Sierra
Meadows PUD from December 14, 2007 to December 14, 2009 in accordance with LDC Section
10.02.13.D.5(a). The subject property consists of 90.8 acres and is located on the southwest
corner of the intersection of Rattlesnake-Hammock Road (CR 864) and Collier Boulevard (CR
951), in Section 22, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida.
10 of 11
C. Request that the Board of County Commissioners Adopt an Ordinance to Regulate Security of
Certain Convenience Store Businesses to Protect the Physical Security of Convenience
Business Retail Employees and Individuals who Patronize such Businesses.
18. ADJOURN
INQUIRIES CONCERNING CHANGES TO THE BOARD'S AGENDA SHOULD BE MADE TO THE
COUNTY MANAGER'S OFFICE AT 774-8383.
11 of 11
AGENDA CHANGES
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS' MEETING. 2007
November 27. 2007
Item 3A2: Kelly Grandy will not be in attendance to receive her 20-year service award. (Staff's request.)
Continue Item 6C to the December 11. 2007 BCC meetinq: Public petition request by Patrick White to
discuss Orders finding Violation relating to property owned by Jerry and Kimberlea Blocker. (Petitioner's
request.)
Item 8A continued to the December 11. 2007 BCC meetinq: This item requires that all participants be sworn
in and ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Petition: PUDZ-2006-AR-10648: Naples
Motorcoach Resort, Inc., represented by Robert L. Duane, AICP of HoleMontes, Inc., and Richard D.
Yovanovich Esquire, of Goodlette, Coleman & Johnson, P.A., is requesting a rezone from the Mobile Home
Travel Trailer Recreational Vehicle Campground, and Heavy Commercial Zoning Districts (MH, TTRVC & C-
5) to the Commercial Planned Unit Development District (CPUD) for a project to be known as the Naples
Motorcoach Resort CPUD. This project proposes to allow development of up to 200 motorcoach lots as
well as various amenities such as a boat ramp and boat slips. The subject property, consisting of 23.2
acres, is located on the southwest side of Tamiami Trail, East, approximately three quarters of a mile east
of Collier Boulevard (CR 951), in Section 3, Township 51 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida.
(Petitioner's request.)
Item 10A: In the executive summary under Considerations, second page, paragraph two, it refers to "48
additional deferral agreements processed". The correct number is 41. (Staff's request.)
Item 100: The title in the index for this item uses the number 48 in reference to the number of impact fee
deferrals. The correct number is 41, as stated in the executive summary. (Staff's request.)
Item 16A1; Attachments for this item (Table 1 Prioritization Rankings and Figure 1 WMP Watersheds map)
were omitted from the agenda packet. Copies have been distributed and are available for review. (Staff's
request.)
Move 16D1 to 10X: Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approve, and authorize the
Chairman to sign, an Amended Subrecipient Agreement with Collier County Housing Development
Corporation (CCHDC). This amendment is to extend the timeline for the development of Cirrus Pointe. The
HOME grant was provided to the CCHDC to acquire approximately 10 acres of land, which was purchased
in December, 2005 including the developers fee of $30,000 for a total of $320,000. Cirrus Pointe will
construct 108 units of which 32 units will be for new affordable housing units in Collier County.
(Commissioner Halas' request.)
Item 16G2: In the executive summary under Background, last sentence should read, ". . . .. language to
incur debt on the January 29, 2008 (rather than 2007) Presidential Primary ballot." (Staff's request.)
Item 16D3: Under Considerations, 4th sentence should read: "Due to (rather than "do to") continued
growth. . . . ." (Staff's request.)
Time Certain Items:
Item 5D to be heard at 11 :00 a.m. Swearing in ceremony of Matt Hudson, the newly elected Florida House
of Representatives Member, District 101, by Collier County Judge Ramiro Manalich.
Item 9A to be heard at 10:00 a.m. Presentation by Andrea B. Sims of The Waters-Oldani Executive
Recruitment, a division of the Waters Consulting Group, Inc.
Item s1 OA throuQh 100 to be heard at 3:00 p.m.
Item 10R to be heard at 4:00 p.m. Recommendation to grant final approval of the roadway (private) and
drainage improvements for the final plat of Strada Bella (Olde Cypress PUDlo The roadway and drainage
improvements will be privately maintained.
Agenda Item No. 4A
November 27.2007
Page 1 of 2
-
PROCLAMATION
WHEREAS, Sandra Ar""ld-L<rwsan joined the Collier County Government staff in ZOOZ as the
Communications and Customer Relations Coordinator; and,
WHEREAS, before joining Collier County. Sondra was a Navy journalist for Admiral Robert C.
Chaplin, Commander u.s. Naval Forces .Tapan, and a news anchor and reporter for
American Forces Network in Europe; and,
WHEREAS, she has supported the Bureau of Emergency Services during two presidential decfared
disasters (Hurricanes Charley and Wilma), as well as numerous other local
emergencies; and,
WHEREAS, since ZOOZ, Sandra has: completed the Florida Governor's Hurricane Conference Basic
Public Information Officer's Course; earned the Federal Emergency Management
Agency's (FEMA) Emergency Management Institute's Professional Development Series
Certificate; Completed FEMA's Advanced Public Information Officer's Course; became
Accredited in Public Relations (APR); and.
-
WHEREAS, ultimately, this has earned Sandra the Certified Emergency Manager (CEM)
designation from the Internationol Association of Emergency Managers (IAEM) - of
which only 700 individuals internationally currently hold.
NOW THEREFORE, be it proclaimed by the Boord of County Commissioners of Collier County,
Florida, that
Sandra Arnold-Lawson be congratulated for this achievement and recognized
as a valuable asset to Collier County.
DONE AND ORDERED THIS 1 Zth Day of November, Z007.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY. FLORIDA
JAMES COLETTA. CHAIRMAN
ATTEST:
.-
DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
2of2
COLLIER COIJNTV
BOARD OF COUNTY COMrJlISSIONERS
Item Number:
Item Summary:
tl,'"
i'" jr,i ;\r ::,I(J.,Lt,w,;nr' IJ"~ c.rJ1'~t'::;itiI3tf;c! lor rect"V'i (j tne Certih~:;i t,IT'c'rqf'n~',,' M<Jnagc'r
';~'!,1,..~ meltler: In)," 'ne Ir,t""'naIOIBj i S~[F:'ClIiOI cf E,tNT3,'L(>' r,,1a~lauror ,.o::Mj, Tr) I)",
,,:'(-;pe /',:"':cw' U)';,'ur',
Meeting Date:
"I,-:'r
",;.r,I'
I're-pared By
,""'-""1<<'"
','<f.-f.(.t"f(:i:, <1(;:<:'('12 [-!r;-
i_'~f',
;:.lo~r<i ,':1 C;ounl<-
Conmll~si"r'Fc:"O
~~::c Off,e,
'(,li;W:;'I}(I"1: '!h:4JAr\'
Approved 8)'
',"',0'-
"'(';liW'C r'!!~""JD"",c: 'w'
(;,"n-
d,l(
"'''''''';'<'''',,'
')fli:-'
i;{2'UI~'
'\flJlrnwd By
un\,
I'_t"
';f,'j,',
file:! Ie; \AgcndaT est\Export\93- Novem ber%2027, 0/0202007\04, %20PROCl ,A MA TI ONS\4., 11/20/2007
Agenda Item No. 48
November 27, 2007
Page 1 of 2
-
PROCLAMA TION
WHEREAS, a vital part of the mission of Collier Caunty Government is to ensure that
capital improvements for governmental services and infrastructure are
provided to accommodate the Countys expanding population base/ and,
WHEREAS, volunteer members of the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC)
perform an extremely important role within this prevision of capital
improvements through their review of the Annual Update and Inventory
Report (AUIR)/ and,
WHEREAS, during the preporation for the three days of the AUIR workshops, and
the workshops themselves~ the cepe members provided countless hours of
volunteer effort/ and"
WHEREAS, the 'result of the time given during the AUIR workshops by the CCPC
membership provided the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) with
specific recommendations related to the individual components of the
AUIR from a planning perspective unique to the cepe membership: and,
-
WHEREAS. the specific recommendations provided to the BCC allow for that body to
arrive upon decisions related to the proposed capital improvements within
the AUIR that are mast reflective of the wants and needs of the
community, while balanced against fiscal budgetary limitations.
NOW THEREFORE, be it proclaimed by the Board of County Commissioners of Callier
County, Florida, that we express the deepest appreciation to the Collier
County Planning Commission members for their gift to our citizens.
DONE AND ORDERED THIS 27th Day of November, 2007.
BOARD OF COUN7Y COMMISSIONERS
COLUER COUNTY, FLORIDA
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
:! Of?
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD Of COUNTY COMM!SSIONERS
Item NlImber;
IE:
Item Summary:
f-'r;:.;i,nHlllonU:,'!'i<,)pnl:(;Ir-,c
iu" H'~T \nTf', ~."! ii'll,' ',I.HF:':
t..,. ,c,.'C'tmj ,":" Plil:1rllnq
Qf,W11;'ilonrlls",u",rs
Meeting Date:
; ~I l(i-' C(, 0(1 i ,e'l
^Ilprllved 0,-
S'l'c' "iI~;':H;
t~CGUli\-'", ,ii~~:""C' fo tl"',' 8V"
T)3!r,
80Md.-:" ::aunli
::ammjssiPIVT.o
r<;c.Oflic':
11!Si2(1l1i .;::':: PM
Approved By
'",,,,,-;'/;"'\O;IJ
0"''''''\'';''''''-\-10"
I.\co""C c,~' C,':;un',
,o.;mn""'"'."HN
"'fl;
file://C:\AgendaTest\Export\93- Novell1bt~/o2027, oAi202007\04. %20PROCLA MA TJ ONS\4.. J 1/20/2007
Agenda Item No. 4C
November 27,2007
Page 1 of 2
-
PROCLAMA rrON
WHEREAS, a vital part of the mission of Collier County Government is to ensure that
capital improvements for governmental services and infrastructure are
provided to accommodate the County's expanding population base: and,
WHEREAS, volunteer members of the County Government Productivity Committee
(CGPC) perform an extremely important role within this provision of
capital improvements through their review of the Annual Update and
Inventory Report (AUIRJ' and.
WHEREAS, during the preparation for the three days of the AUIR workshops, and
the workshops themselves, the CGPC members provided countless hours of
volunteer effort; and;
WHEREAS, the result of the time given during the AUIR workshops by the CGPC
members provided the Board of County Commissioners (Bee) with specific
recommendations related to the individual components of the AUIR from
a fiscal pe....spective unique to the CGPC membership; and"
-
WHEREAS. the specific recommendatIons provided to the BCC allow for thot body to
arrive upon decisions related to the proposed capital improvements within
the AUIR that are most reflective of the wants and needs of the
community, wht'le balanced against fiscal budgetary limitations.
NOW THEREFORE, be it proclaimed by the Board of County Commissioners of Collier
County, Florida, that we express the deepest appreciation to the Collier
County Productivity Committee members for their gift to our citizens.
DONE AND ORDERED THIS 27th Day of November, 2007.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY. FLORIDA
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
A TrEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
.---
Page 1 of 1
"
P"JQr~ 2
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD 01' COUNTY COtJIM1SSIONE'RS
Item Number:
Item Summary:
"dP'i,<r1<JlIY'
;~In'.,,' rrWmlHY" 'J!' 'n, ",,',,(,1 ".,., ,-,""if' OJ,,,,,,
Vlcn"'ltn','
jr lw er". ',; D\' ;""c(j'J,r:t:'fil" 'j:!'l'1'i,l('~'o' "',"T'i;''''C<
Meeting Date: U',ll.'( ,r,'
PrcPllre1l8y
";;;'-,I,o:>,,,,,-,!,l'
~ ~,'Cml'!", Aic!" ihc, ~ -
,;, ~,-
B<'li,rd 'OJ ,.>,Ur1t"
'_',mn1'~,S'OHH<_
Jfi'cF
1/'0;'20(1" f':,'4'1~ ~,t{
Approved R~
c;\V' ;"ii~,N'
r{;H''''l'''' ,I", .'~
,t.~
'::~ ;;",,', ,_" (,>, (;n'
-G"11t'o.'w'nt."-,-'
'-n',v
, : '~~ '21
"~Pi
Appnl\'l'd II)
'.',l.;(b
:0'''''''',011;'0,''
, ,*-
"'ni
'')fi
file://C:\AgendaTest\Exp0l1\93- November%2027, %202007\04. %20PROCLAMA TI ONS\4.
1]/20/2007
Agenda Item No. 40
r';iovember 27,2007
Page 1 of 2
-
PROCLAMA TION
WHEREAS, electronIC: waste, in the form of PCs. TVs, and other electronic
devices, is the fastest growing part of the waste stream in America
and in Collier County: . and,
JlVHEREAS, just one computer monitor can contain 4 to 8 pounds of leae/, mercury,
and cadmium, that if not recycled properly, could leach into our
environment as well as take up precious landfill space: and.
WHEREAS, with the onset of a new generation of operating systems, computers,
flat screen TVs, and the 2009 digital TV mandate, recycling unwanted
computers and rvs is more important now than ever before,. and"
WHEREAS, Matthew Berning, a Life Scout Eagle Candidate of Troop 2001, feels
strongly that all of Collier County should do their part to protect our
precious environment and has dedicated hL<: Eagle Scout Service project
to 0 public awareness campaign called '"Poison PC", Toxic D's: Recycle
E- yVa;~;fe ;'<esponslb/y'" ana:
-
vVHEREAS, Matthew Berning has organized as a part of his Eagle Scout Service
project a community roundup recycling event ff: conjunct/on with Best
Buy and the ColI/er County Solid Waste Management Department to be
held on December J', 2007, when Collier County residents can recycle
'Poison pes and Toxic TVs' and other e-waSfe responsibly.
NOW THEREFORE, be it proclaimed by the Board of County Commissioners of
Co/lier County, Florida, that December 1, 2007, be designated as
':4 Day af Recycling for Electronic Waste"
DONE AND ORDERED THIS 2Tth Day of November, 200T.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY. FLORIDA
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
,-
PageJofl
A;l'-!I,rJ~1 Itel'~ ~,!O
NiJvembCi27,
P,MJ8:C' 012
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Item Number:
Item Summary:
4,',
~;IC ':"nullo" I' "ecoW,!ZC :";,a!tI1i-N' ':;W:Hl~. T'n)':)p ~:C\()1
".t,: L V-9~""'7L oW 2"" ;!''(If'I!V rr~r~vc.il '~. mu",-< v.
,; (::)11' ;: i)~JI!; ca",'jid"U! lDr n i ,;
nndln0",Si')f'8tfC'i,'C""i!ler
'ie,- d'- f'>v ~~,< ':;Hng tv ::::1'.' 'CO'I,' '-.^,'",s" (':c""'" -"W.'v
;)F .,.evept'. i n';, ~ 'Ie
,,',.:;.:"11' ::,,:, 'If'. ;',,', "(Im~ i\A,litr,rJ'i ,"COT;'!''''
Meetillg Date;
n ~\ ; r, ..-:,Iv!
J'rcJ)ured By
r':'Jt,'iCWi'r\10d,,,;
i.dllllnif,lnn",' ',ioJctr;,t.ll<-: Bce
r~tl
Boned 01' ~;O(jrl1}'
(;arnllw,,,jOrle",.
[SU'
'iGUfiO'<'::4!J:4f::PI\1
Appru"l'd Ry
"i"""e,
r':v,C',,~'i\'(' "be.-"
:'<<tl
bm,,, ""unj',
'''N'' ';S'{J'H"
V"
il.pflrnved Uy
",';'HlC;
\';';,"""",,,
'''(;u~'
.'n",'"".
-"n;'
fiJe://C:\AgendaT cSt\EXp011\93w Novcm ber%1202 7,%202007\04. %20PROCLAMATl 01\'5\4.. ] 1/20!2007
brock_m
Agenda Item I'Jo. 5A
Novembel' 27, 2007
Page 1 of 3
r- From: muddj
Sent: Wednesday, November 14,20079;24 AM
To: brock_m
ee: bodinejudi
Subject: FW: Comp Plan and Water Supply Plan Overview
Mary-Jo,
Please add this to the presentation section.
Attach this email as backup.
Thanks, Jim
From: Tears Jr, Clarence [mailto:ctearsjr@sfwmd.govJ
Sent: Wednesday, November 14, 20079:05 AM
To: mudd.J
Subject: FW: Camp Plan and Wats- Supply Plan Overview
Jim.
It looks like the 27th will work Based on your current agenda when do anticipate Chip's presentation to begin?
Thanks
Clarence
__ From: Elias, Lourdes On Behalf Of Merriam, Chip
Sent: Wednesday, November 14, 2007 8:57 AM
To: Tears Jr, Clarence
Subject: RE: Camp Plan and Wats- Supply Plan Overview
Clarence,
It looks like Chip is available on the 27th for this. Let me know if this works and please send me the
details.
Thanks!
.t.ouwlcs 'M. 'EflaJ
Executive Assistant
Water Resources
South Florida Water Management District
(561) 6822706
(56]) 682.5011 (fax)
lelias@sfwrnd.gov
From: Tears Jr, aarence
Sent: Thursday, November 08, 2007 4:53 PM
To: Merriam, Chip
Subject: FW: Camp Plan and Water Supply Plan Overview
--
Chip,
Does the 27th work for you?
III I 4/2007
Thanks
CLarence
Agenda item No. 5/,\
November 27.2007
Page 2 of3
From: mudd.J [malltD:JamesMudd@coltiergOY.net]
Sent: Thursday, November 08, 2007 4:52 PM
To: Tears Jr, Clarence
SUbject: RE: Camp Plan and Water Supply Plan Overview
Clarence,
How about Nov 27th In the am?
Jim
From: Tears Jr, Clarence [mailtD:ctearsjr@sfwmd_gov]
Sent: Thursday, November 08, 2007 4:36 PM
To: mudd.J
SUbject: Camp Plan and Water Supply Plan Overview
Jim,
Chip Merriam the Deputy Executive Director of the District is requesting 10 minutes at an upcoming Commission
meeting to go over the local Comprehensive Plan as ~ relates to S.B. 360 &444.
Thanks
Clarence
11/14/2007
Page] of J
':'v_
-,cJf?
COLLIER COUNTY
kOtq.~[; D~ CClurHY C:OMMISSIONE'P'S
Item Number;
Item Summary;
,,'IGE '/',ah"- V;C1 ,"~er.-,,,,,t
1"'>1"
r~I'-"
?-V'.:j",
Meeting Dale:
Apprllvctl By
iI'ucr"
" r"~"F UP
oha,,;ol-"uw',
, omr""'~I'):1cr
'un, I,,"; '}C"-
'I_~!. 'H'" ,I:', 'w
file:! 1C:\AgcndaTcst\Export\93- :"Jovcmbcroio202 7. %202001,05.'~ o20PRESENTA T] ()~S\5"
1]/20/2007
Agenda Item No. 58
November 27, 2007
Page 1 of 2
-
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to recognize Jim von Rinteln, Emergency Management
Coordinator, Bureau of Emergency Services, as Employee of the Month for
November 2007.
OBJECTIVE: To obtain approval from the Board of County Commissioners to recognize
Jim von Rinteln, Emergency Management Coordinator, Bureau of Emergency Services,
as Employee of the Month for November 2007.
CONSIDERATIONS: Jim van Rintein, Emergency Management Coordinator, has been
nominated as the "Employee of the Month" for November 2007. Jim is instrumental in
County hurricane, tornado and wildfire evacuations and responses. He is an innovative
thinker with the ability to analyze problems and identify efficient and cost effective
solutions.
With :)ver twenty five years experience in he fieid, jirr; is often called upon to provide
expert advice and gUidance to emergency management agencies across the state, In
his free time. he instructs the Community :::mergencj1 Response Team, conducts
emergency preparedness seminal-s and actively seeks opportunities to improve
emergency awareness. His ',fast knowledge, natural leadership ability and strong
organizational skills resulted in his selection as the project manager for the Emergency
Services Center. Over the past three years, Jim has remained the driving force behind
the funding, programming and construction efforts on this project that broke ground in
February of this year. His professionalism and devotion to duty reflect greatly on Collier
County and make Jim truly deserving of this award.
FISCAL IMPACT: The selected "Employee of the Month" receives a $150.00 cash
award. Funds are available in the Bureau of Emergency Services Budget.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There is no growth management impact
associated with this Executive Summary.
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners approves the
recognition of Jim van Rinteln as "Employee of the Month" for November 2007.
PREPARED BY: Brittney Mahon, Employee Recognition Coordinator, Department of
Human Resources
>>-
Page ] of J
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMM!SSiOI~E.R.S
Item Number:
CE'.
Item Summary:
F'::,,~/ rnrl)'Ow:;a!;lY to r()~U'lf1;n_ UTI "'fl i''iI~\'''ln i:'ITIt'rcl,::)('_' M" ia;.jPT'''';' -'''I'm ',,')lor
L: 1,'0,') -'j ["-''E'r~w:'' '",rVICdc d~ c:rlwlny"c" ;,\ th ".';ont'l it; '"",j\''t'nbc:;'' K)/
Meeting Date:
CT scncV"~J
PreparetJ By
Britlne',.' rl"JfWl1
E:rnp,oy"(' (-~"GO;,lnL\l"p '/,Qrd:nJ!o'
''''i'
i-"jn"II1'slc,'_\L~", Sf)r~ll'()i'
fiumfm Rp'.;(.,,~,,~
1'13!20')7 .22!,,~-1 or,1
Appruved By
.",.,1" r,krri~t
;'lUrlwr, "er;Ol"ce:. [nr"'.;tw
[:2te
'\:'nlfr..Slr~n~", Se",iG('~
HUI1\.nF,esnw"",'
:,';'()[J; ::: 1~; ,'~/
Arpro\'l>u By
i,'i.,,, I'HU
"",,,,.,',,>1,'-/':
;.,.,1'1\""
-"'.lrn,m"""'J'/f.Se'!IO',
J'-.,,,,-,, t"iit,.".
C.,,',,,,;>
".,.;,(,;
:"1',-'
Approndlly
i'PL':',-'
i\'h;',,'" 'T,-,I;""
""f'Jrnl""
1""""'I'J
'c,:;:,,:r;-,:;.jh
Apprnv{'d fly
-\ppruved 1-"1\
Approved By
"',"11
u",,,.<(),
':;(Jr;,m,";ri)",E<rs
'.;)unt\,';,''',;'U'.<:c)1-!'c'
S.'-t,M
file:/ /C:\AgendaT est\Exp0r1\93- Novemher%202 7,%202007\05. %20PRESENT A TJ ONS\5,.
11/20/2007
Page] of I
,",uend<'1ltem NO.5::
!'Ju"t:mber 27, 2007
Paqc 1 of3
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF C<)UNTY COMMISSIONERS
~.
Item Number;
ItemSummllry;
nti'o'OCHJI' "'reseI'l18!:r,'
:Il;
'''" ,11;(" ':;nu'-ity ';0; ,"lr:;:>,15 ,- "."I",ei -'rnl,"..! ~ju
'ilfl'_.n;lS ),K.'_I(;-' 2M 1'<1'<1\ "'11',"cl
Meeting Date:
~ 1:" '~ :;r 'J : 0 c' on . \1'/:
Prcpllloed B)'
Hank..'ones
"lliriri:'r-r""c;:V,'''''JQ'o
'",1.(
':;'drninj',tr,llj"f,:~,.'rviu)'
r',",;'il;\10"I""Hl-w.,,:..m"'rll
I /1 ;~.' ]r:~-I
('~', f:-_[i.
Approved Dr
Stell!"C<lrnell
Ur-:;I',;o'mp-'(,'-'
t!in.'~t.,
");'l'
AO"I;""r.tr~i.Il1c. ;',('r\'1i:W
Cl')' n:>
, "1 ,niY\-;' ~
Approved B)'
f'i'(,,,lde,'-'r',u
",-, ;-t'a"cT
i',jr"i,.,,~t,:)( '.', Y,"vIUl
fi'0
",;",",
Appruved Dy
~;"'" '''mp C'M
"'hi"'"
"""'\ir'i"f:1T',jC
^Ilprul'ed B~'
Approvt'u By
1l'. k,,' ~)h
.-
Approved By
"",,> -,r. ":"~',,'"
Cf;,;nL -";"'0:"""'-" Df\'ic'
"';-(;Ct" ;i.;'r;;'(;f:~"'~''';; (U"""
,'0'-:":
""-'I,
Approved By
.Ja'ilt'~ \' ~',u:jd
':"""'1" i<:JI1;";,c
1:1 ,,~C
b()~rddCO(lllt\
'~G;U]t~ rv.'tn;\Cj(f', :-ft,,:"
I j'j f~I~(i(,7 ~ .50 ["rf
COllltllll>SlOnerr,
fi1e:l/C:\AgelldaTest\Exp0l1\93~ No\'cmhcr'%2027, %,202007\05.l}(,20PRESENT ATJ ONS\5
J 1/2012007
.Agenda Item No. 5C
November 27. 2007
Page 2 of 3
CONTRACTOR PRESENT A nON FORM
Board Presentation Date: NOVEMBER 27, 2007
Contract Nnmber, Project Title, Proiect Number: Contract #04-3576;
PO # 45-00025867; Collicr Courthouse Annex; Project 52533
Firm Name: Kraft Construction Company, Inc.
Project Manal!er: Don Olney
Proiect Description: Site preparation and bnilding construction of a 137,984 sq.ft.,
7 Story, Courthouse Annex connected to the Collier County Courthouse by a 4 story
Atrium. The building will house administrative functions in support of the Collier
County Courthouse: Clerk of Courts (probate, cashiering, traffic, administration,
recording, civil and criminal functions), State Attorney Offices, and Public Defender
Offiees.
Oril!inal Start Date:
Concept Phase: 1/200 I
Design: 6/200 I
Construction: 01/02/2007
i Oril!inal Contract Amount:
Building (7 Stories; 3 finished and 4 shell
only) $36,685,528
Revised Contract Amount:
Building (7 Stories; all 7 finished)
$39,279.123
Oril!inal Completion Date: ] l/12/2008
Revised Completion Date: 3/2/2009
Reason(s) for Variance: Scheduled
completion date increased due to added
interior finishing to top 4 floors.
Reason(s) for Variance: Addition of
interior finish on top 4 floors and deduction
of Direct Material Purchases (over $335,000
in tax savings).
Actions Planned/Taken to Minimize
Variance: Continued Value engineering to
reduce costs.
Actions Planned/Taken to Minimize
Variance: Value Engineering changes to
reduce construction schedule and weekly
attention to schedule details may advance
completion.
Current Project Status: On Schedule
Design: 100%; Building Construction; 24%; Re-Permitting for Interior Finishing of
Top 4 Floors - In Progrss.
Agenda Item No. 5C
November 27 2007
Page 3 of 3
~.
Agenoa Item I~o. SA
November 27 2007
Page'1 of 5
COLLIER COUN1Y MANAGER'S OFFICE
3301 East Tamiami Trail. Naples, Florida 34111 . (239) 774-8383 . FAX (239) 774-4010
November 9, 2007
Mary Mayville
Collier County Agricultural Fair & Exposition, Inc.
751 39'" Avenue NE
Naples, FL 34120
Re: Public Petition Request to Discuss Reinstatement of a Pennanent Beer License
Dear Ms. Mayville:
Please be advised that you are scheduled to appear before the Collier County Board of
Commissioners at the meeting of November 27, 2007, regarding the above referenced
subject.
~
Your petition to the Board of County Commissioners will be limited to ten minutes.
Please be advised that the Board will take no action on your petition at this meeting.
However, your petition may be placed on a future agenda for consideration at the
Board's discretion. Therefore, your petition to the Board shouid be to advise them of
your concern and the need for action by the Board at a future meeting.
The meeting will begin at 9:00 a.m. in the Board's Chambers on the Third Floor of the W.
Harmon Turner Building (Building "F") of the government complex. Please arrange to be
present at this meeting and to respond to inquiries by Board members.
If you require any further information or assistance, please do not hesitate to contact this
office.
Sincerely,
/'7 ~ //
~v. Mudd7
County Manager
JVMfjb
cc: David Weigel, County Attorney
Joseph Schmitt, CD&ES Administrator
Marla Ramsey, Public Services Administrator
.'-
NDV-09-2007-FRI 11:05 AM COLLIER COUNTY FAIR
FAX No. 2394556701
Agenefa m No. 6A
NQvember 27, 2007
Page 2 01 5
Reauest to Speak under' Public Petition
Please print
Name:
Collier County Aaricultural Fair & Exposition. Inc.
751 39th Avenue NE
Address:
Naoles, FL 34120
Phone: (239) 455--1444
Date of the Board Meetlnll vou wish to soeak:
November 27, 2007
Please exnlain In datal/the reason vou are reauestlno to soeak (attach additional
PQQe if necessary):
The past Board of Directors of the Collier County Aoricultural Fair & Exposition.
Inc. allowed the Dermanent beer license to lapse. The present Board of Directors
is attemDtino to re-instate thSlt permanent beer license. The current Board of
Directors has comPleted the OSPR ABT-6001 and 6036 forms aiono with the
fincerprint cards. The Department of Health has Inspected and issued a
satisfactory certificate. However, the Department of Zoning has declined
approval crono eatino pieces and bars/lounces afe those for which they
'normally" aoorove permanent 'alcohol licenses. A copv of our letter to them and
their response Is attached.
Our lease aareement states that the Collier County Aaricultural Fair & Exoosltion.
Inc. has conditional use for utilization of prooertY for the pUfPose of operatino a
falraround facility and is, considered a recreational facility and shall be for the
benefit of the ceneral public. We are deslanated for fairs. concerts, festivals, etc,
In addition to the Annual County Fair we host numerous Demolition Derbv's,
Concerts. Home & Garden Shows, Boat Shows throuohout the calendar year. In
March 2008, we anticipate hostina the 3-dav Annual Country Jam alona with the
CollierCounty Parks and Recreation. We are onlv allowed three (3) 11213-day
temoorarv beer licenses In the calendar vear. This does not allow us to vend
beer at all the events. especiallv if they are week-Iona.
c:\Do"""onto ond ll8lIingllColior County Foil\Oell<lop1l'ubllo PotIIIon Roq....t Form-complotod._
NQV-09-2007-FRI 11:05 AM COLLIER COUNTY FAIR
FAX No. 2394556701
AgenJa ~ No. 6A
Nqvember '27 2007
D age 3 01 5
Please emls!" in detail the action YOU are aski"a the Commission to take (attach
additional Daae If necessary):
We are re8Dectfullv aski"a the Cammi88ion to vote In favor of allowina the Collier
County Aarlcultural Fair & ExDosltion. Inc. to aaDly for the reinstatement of a
permanent beer license with the slaned approval bv the DeDartment of Zonlna ,
C:\Oocumenlll ond 8eIllngtIColftar County Falr\D8OktOplPublia PetItion Requeot Form-comploted.doo
NGY-09-2007-FRI 11:05 AM COLLIER COUNTY FAIR
FAX No. 2394556701
AgendB.lflW No. 6A
November 27.2007
. Page 4 of 5
/
~1~1/' ~"
dII~~ $
.~l
I".:,~~_'
THE COLLIER COUNTY AGlUCULTURAL FAIR & EXPOSITION, INC.
751 39'hAvenueNE
Naples, FL 34120
(239) 455-1444
Fall (239) 455-6701
e-mail; infu@colliercountvfair.coln
www.colliercountyfair.com
September 28, 2007
Mr. Ross ClochenaUf
Plarining Manager
Department of Zoning and
Land Development Review
2800 North Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
Dear Mr. GochenaUf,
TIlis letter is per your request in our endeavor to obtain R pelmanent beer license at the Collier
County Fairgrounds. .
Ow'lflllBe agreement states that the Collier County Agricultural Fair & E1I.position, Inc, has
conditional use fur utilization of property for the purpose of operating a fairground facility and is
considered a recreational facility and shall be fOT the benefit of the general public. Weare
designated for fairs, concerts, etc.
In addition to the Annual County Fair we host numerous Demolition Derby's, Boa! Shows,
Concerts, HOlDe & Garden Shows (just to name a few) throughout the calendar year. In March
2008, we will host !be 3-day Annual Country Jam along with the CollieT County parb lII1d
Recreation. While we arc familiar with the temporary 1/213-day pennit through the Division of
AIcohplic Beverages and Tobacco, we are allowed onIy three (3) of these throughout the
coIendar year. This'certainly does not allow us to vend beer a! all the events we host, especially
ifUley are week-long. At the past events where we held a temporary pennit for beer sales it was
very profitable allowing us to even host an additional event.
As we understand it, prior to the current Fair Board Il!t:lInbers, the Collier COWlty Agricultural
Fair & Exposition, Inc. did hold" permanent liquor license. However, it lapsed during the re-
seating of prior BOBl'ds,
We would appreciate your favorable and timely response to our request.
Sincerely,
CJQ.cft (Beer
Rick Bell
President
. NeV-09-2007-FRI 11:05 AM COLLIER COUNTY FAIR
. .
FAX No, 2394556701
.'oa9nJ~ 00&n I~o. 6'0
"covernber 27 ~71 of J
Page ::c or 5
!!D' Mayville
From:
To:
ec:
Sent:
Attach:
Subject
HI, Mary
"gochenaurj' <RoeaGochenaur@colllergov.nel>
<falrmansger@colllemountyfalr.com>
"lslene.Su.l\n" <SusanIBtenas@Colliergov.nel>; "gochenl\urj' <RoIl8Gochenaur@oolliergov.net>; "CailltlaAshley"
<AshleyCaserte@oolllergov,net>; "cIementsJ<" <KarenCiements@oolllergov.net>; "davlecraig"
<CllIigDavls4!lcolllergov.nel>; "fronLdetlk" <Iront_delk@colliergov.nel>; "hedrlch_d" <:DHedtlch@colllergov.net>;
"LopelaJen" <:JllnLopala@colllergov.nel>; "McNaRBruce" <BruceMcNaIICCOlllergov.net>; "Sanc/lezJuen"
<:JuanSanc/laz@oolliergav.net>; "SawyerMichllel" <MlchaeISawyer@oolliergov.nel>; "soler_o"
<CheryISOler@colllergov.net>; "willoughby _0" <ChrtellneWlaoughby@ool~ergov .net>; "Wl'ightBob"
<BobWrightillloollergov.net>
Wednesday, October 17, 2007 9:17 AM .
LETTER TO ROSS GOCHENAUR 09 28 2007.doo
FVV: COLLIER COUNTY FAIR REQUEST alcohol permit
I apologize again for how long this nas Iaken. I disculll!ed the Zoning Department's role in approving alcohol permits with Susan
Istenes, the Zoning Managar, yesterday. The Land Development Code )LOC) simply says that the Zoning Director may approve
such Iicell8llS, not the circumstances under which we may grant approval other than compliance with localional restrictions. The
LDC deal. with use issues, and II is up to us to detennlne il the use, Including the event involved, Is allowe<l in the zoning district,
and thatthare is is no conflict with the LDC, Typically, esiablillhments that serve lood and/or alcohol as a principal or accessory use
(eating placas and bars or lounges) are those for whioh we normally approve permanenl alcohol licenses.
Currently, we have approved temporary alcohol licenses for speolflc events at the fairground as an accessory usa to the event In
question. In this way, we are able to evaluate whether the event is compatible with the ~onlng, and if serving alcohQj is a typioal
accessory use associated with such an event Many different events are held at the fairgrounds, and serving alcohol would not be
appropriate lor all of them. Allowing temporary alcohol permits on a case-by-case basis is our only means of controlling the use, and
we will have to continue Issuing temporary permits, rather than approving a permanent permit, for Ihis reaSOn,
Please convey this Informallon to Mr.Bell, and apologize to him as well lor the delay. I'm sorry the result Is a negative response, bu
it is my decision that this is the only way to handle the situation in accordance with the provisions of Ihe LDC.
Sincerely,
Ross Gochenaur
Planning Manager
""".,....-..-
From: Mary Mayville [~lto:falrmanager@CORlercOuntyfalr,comJ
Sent: Friday, September 2B, 2007 3:07 PM
ro: gochanaucr
SubjllCt: COWER COUNTY FAIR ~UI;ST
,
Dear Mr. Gochenaur,
With regards to our. request fol' a permanent beer license, attached is a letter from Mr. Rick Bell, President of the Collier
:::OUnty Fait,
rhank you very much for your time.
Vlary L. Mayville
:ntedm Fair ManageI'
10/171'2007
.-
Aaenda Item No 6B
N~ovember 27,2007
Page 1 of 2
COLLIER COUNIY MANAGER'S OFFICE
3301 East Tamiami Ttail . Naples, Florida 34111 . (239) 774-8383 . FAX (239) 774-4010
November 13, 2007
Mark Adamczyk
Peck & Peck
Suite 103, Wachovia Bank Building
5801 Pelican Bay Boulevard
Naples, FL 34108-2709
Re: Public Petition Request to Discuss the Construction of County Park in The Delasol
Community
Dear Mr. Adamczyk:
Please be advised that you are scheduled to appear before the Collier County Board of
Commissioners at the meeting of November 27, 2007, regarding the above referenced
subject.
-
Your petition to the Board of County Commissioners will be limited to ten minutes.
Please be advised that the Board will take no action on your petition at this meeting.
However, your petition may be placed on a future agenda for consideration at the
Board's discretion. Therefore, your petition to the Board should be to advise them of
your concern and the need for action by the Board at a future meeting.
The meeting will begin at 9:00 a.m. in the Board's Chambers on the Third Floor of the W.
Harmon Turner Building (Building "F") of the government complex. Please arrange to be
present at this meeting and to respond to inquiries by Board members.
If you require any further information or assistance, please do not hesitate to contact this
office.
~e:l~
~~~
County Manager
JVM/jb
cc: David Weigel, County Attorney
Marla Ramsey, Public Services Administrator
Name: Mark E. Adamczyk, Delasol homeowner and
Attomey representing the Delasol Homeowner's Associ;;ltinn Inr.
.L\genda Item No. 68
November 27. 2007
RECEIVED Page 2 of 2
OFFICE OF THE COUNTY MANAGER
Reauest to Soeak under Public Petition NOV 1 3 2007
ACTION
Address: Peck & Peck
Suite 103, Wachovia Bank Building
5801 Pelican Bay Boulevard
Naples, FL 34108-2709
Phone: 239-566-3600 (fax 239-566-3977)
Date of the Board Meetina you wish to soeak: November 27, 2007
Please exolain in detail the reason you are reouestina to soeak:
Collier County is beginning to develop a 1 acre County park in the Delasol community
(Madeira PUDlo The homeowner's oppose the development of the park because it
would allow direct public access to the residential area of Delasol via a boardwalk from
the end of Euclid Ave. to the park and directly thru the park into Delasol on an open
pathway.
A major portion of the total expense ($700,000) for the park's construction is for the
boardwalk and the pathways - the proposed playground is very modest.
The homeowners find it unprecedented and unacceptable that the County would spend
this much money on what amounts to a public path into their community. They do not
believe adequate consideration of the park concept was given at the time of PUD
approval. Only in the final debate surrounding the PUD was a gated community without
interconnectivity approved.
Please eXDlain in detail the action yOU are askina the Commission to take:
At a recent homeowner's meeting it was nearly unanimous that the homeowners would
like the Commission to stop the development of the park, save the funds (est. $500,000
of County funding and $200,000 of State funding), and leave the 1 acre as it is - a
green space.
Hand Delivered
11/13/07
Agenda Item No. 6C
November 27, 2007
Page 1 of 2
COlliER COUN1Y MANAGER'S OFFICE
3301 East Tamiami Trail' Naples, Florida 34111 . (239) 774-8383 . FAX (239) 774-4010
November 13, 2007
Patrick G. White, Esq.
Of Counsel
Porter Wright Morris & Arthur LLP
5801 Pelican Bay Boulevard, Suite 300
Naples, FL 34108-2709
Re: Public Petition Request to Discuss Orders Finding Violation Relating to Property
Owned by Jerry and Kimberiea Blocker
Dear Mr. White:
Please be advised that you are scheduled to appear before the Collier County Board of
Commissioners at the meeting of November 27, 2007, regarding the above referenced
subject.
Your petition to the Board of County Commissioners will be limited to ten minutes.
Please be advised that the Board will take no action on your petition at this meeting.
However, your petition may be placed on a future agenda for consideration at the
Board's discretion. Therefore, your petition to the Board should be to advise them of
your concern and the need for action by the Board at a future meeting.
The meeting will begin at 9:00 a.m. in the Board's Chambers on the Third Floor of the W.
Harmon Turner Building (Building "F") of the govemment complex. Please arrange to be
present at this meeting and to respond to inquiries by Board members.
If you require any further information or assistance, please do not hesitate to contact this
office.
aerelY, .
~~W~
James V. Mudd
County Manager
JVM/jb
cc: David Weigel, County Attorney
Joseph Schmitt, CD&ES Administrator
Agenda Item No. 6C
November 27.2007
Page 2 of 2
Reauest to Soeak under Public Petition
Name: Patrick G. White, Esq., Attorney for Jerry and Kimberlea Blocker
Address: 5801 Pelican Bay Blvd., Suite 300 Naples, FL 34108-2709
Phone: 239-593-2963 (office) 239-593-2990 (fax)
Date of the Board Meetina vou wish to speak: November 27,2007
Please eXDlain in detail the reason vou are reauestina to speak:
To discuss alternative means to resolve pending Collier County Code Enforcement
Board (CEB) cases. On Thursday, November 29,2007, the CEB will be considering
whether or not to impose fines in three related, connected cases, which seek to have
the existing use of more than five decades legitimized. As an alternative to rezoning the
subject properties, which would also require an amendment to the County's Growth
Management Plan (GMP), Mr. & Mrs. Blocker request that in the interest of fairness and
equal treatment that the CEB be asked to amend its Orders Finding Violation to allow
County staff and Mr. & Mrs. Blocker to use the Immokalee Initiative's Site Improvement
Plan (SIP) process to abate the present code violations.
Under the existing regulations of both the GMP and LDC, non-conforming mobile home
parks are given the right to come into compliance with today's regulations if they follow
the SIP process. Because the date specified in the LDC has passed to voluntarily enter
the SIP process, however, in order to use the SIP process the CEB must order
respondents to abate their violations under that section of the LDC. Thus, by law, the
CEB may re-open the window and allow a violator to cure the violation in the same
manner as dozens of park owners have previously done under the Immokalee Initiative.
As mentioned, this use has been present on-site since the mid-1950's. Mr. & Mrs.
Blocker have been unable to find any map of the then effective zoning districts and then
existing zoning laws that when taken together prohibit the current use. As a non-
conforming use Mr. & Mrs. Blocker are entitled to use the SIP process if the CEB
amends its Orders.
Please explain in detail the action vou are askina the Commission to take:
To recommend that the CEB modify its Orders Finding Violation to allow County staff
and Mr. & Mrs. Blocker to use the Immokalee Initiative's Site Improvement Plan process
to abate their code violations.
Hand Delivered
11/13/07
NAPLES13318lS v,OI
Agenda Item No. 6D
November 27.2007
Page 1 Of 2
COLLIER COUNIY MANAGER'S OFFICE
3301 East Tamiami Trail' Naples, Florida 34111 . (239) 774-8383 . FAX (239) 774-4010
November 14, 2007
Mr. Craig Brugger
Youngquist Brothers, Inc.
15465 Pine Ridge Road
Fort Myers, FL 33908
Re: Public Petition Request to Discuss Waiver to Contract with FGUA for their Goiden
Gate Wastewater Piant Injection Well
Dear Mr. Brugger:
Please be advised that you are scheduled to appear before the Collier County Board of
Commissioners at the meeting of November 27, 2007, regarding the above referenced
subject.
Your petition to the Board of County Commissioners will be limited to ten minutes.
Please be advised that the Board will take no action on your petition at this meeting.
However, your petition may be placed on a future agenda for consideration at the
Board's discretion. Therefore, your petition to the Board should be to advise them of
your concern and the need for action by the Board at a future meeting.
The meeting will begin at 9:00 a.m. in the Board's Chambers on the Third Floor of the W.
Harmon Turner Building (Building "F") of the government complex. Please arrange to be
present at this meeting and to respond to inquiries by Board mernbers.
If you require any further infonnation or assistance, please do not hesitate to contact this
office.
JVM/jb
cc: David Weigel, County Attorney
Jim DeLony, Public Utilities Administrator
p,qenG3 It8m No. 60
I~.overrmm 27, 2007
:2 of 2
Reouest to Speak under Public Petition
Please print
Name: Craig Brugger / Youngquist Brothers Inc.
Address: 15465 Pine Ridge Road, Fort Myers, FL 33908
Phone:
239-489-4444
Date of the Board Meetino YOU wish to speak:
Nov 27th . 2007
Please explain in detai/the reason vou are reouestino to speak (attach additional
paoe if necessary):
We have a contracted with FGUA to drill a injection well at their Goiden
Gate Waste Water Plant. Our bid and contract was based on 24 hour, 7 day
work schedule. This around the clock schedule is due to nature of deep
well construction, such as Installing thousands of feet steel casings that
can not be stopped until they are completed. Cementing and testing the
well casing is also a continuous process that lasts over 24 hrs. This has to
be done this way to insure that the casing is installed and cemented before
the underground formation collapses. Youngquist Brothers has performed
numerous injection well projects for Collier County Utilities with minimal or
no complaints.
Please explain in detail the action vou are askino the Commission to take (attach
additional paoe if necessary):
We are asking for a waiver for working 24 hours per day, seven days a
week. Drilling days only instead of 24/7, will cost FGUA and their
customers an additional $1.9million. This was an alternate bid item. YBI has
drilled 8 deep Injection wells & the associated dual zone monitors on the
7/24 schedule without issue.
C:\Documents and Settings\bodinejudi\Local Settings\Ternporary Internet Flles\OLK20\Public Petition Request Fonn (2)
(2).doc
Agenda Item No. 6E
November 27. 2007
Page 1 of 3
COllIER COUN1Y MANAGER'S OFFICE
3301 East Tamiami Ttail . Naples, Florida 341]1. (239) 774-8383 . FAX (239) 774-4010
November 15, 2007
Mr. Robert Lockhart
1361 Lake Shore Drive
Naples, FL 34103
Re: Public Petition Request to Discuss CEB Case No. 2004-026 and Related Fines
Dear Mr. Lockhart:
Please be advised that you are scheduled to appear before the Collier County Board of
Commissioners at the meeting of November 27, 2007, regarding the above referenced
subject.
Your petition to the Board of County Commissioners will be limited to ten minutes.
Please be advised that the Board will take no action on YOUt petition at this meeting.
However, your petition may be placed on a future agenda for consideration at the
Board's discretion. Therefore, your petition to the Board should be to advise them of
your concern and the need for action by the Board at a future meeting.
The meeting will begin at 9:00 a.m. in the Board's Chambers on the Third Fioor of the W.
Harmon Turner Building (Building "FO) of the government complex. Please arrange to be
present at this meeting and to respond to inquiries by Board members.
If you require any further information or assistance, please do not hesitate to contact this
office.
James V.
County Manager
JVM/jb
cc: David Weigel, County Attorney
Joseph Schmitt, CD&ES Administrator
HOV-1~-e7 12:35 PM LOCKHART
941 262 59'86
A d I P.02
gen a tern I o. 6E
November 27 2007
Page 2 013
,
R- olD ~ 'I .- PutIIIc PwIlIion
Pleeae print
~~~_~L \.PK~
~~~I%I._~S~ ~.
t.l~L,Et, FL. ~~O~
___ ...._._.._____..._.._.'...l_
Phone: _.~.':'.I59'WD
Date oHhe Rt-.t Meetina 'tOP wish tllpMk: ~..'k 1~l..___
DIa-- ......-n m -..... r "'fl VOl/ ... real~ to ....-.k ,-IIdditiol'le!
Dm81f1'lA1 ~ #l:
Pee. 'D1~aN ~!'!~. ~ID w~SL I lAu""'Y-..
~~ I w.t.; 1'7 1UE. _ 0tlL-1 #lw.w~.~ ~ _,.__
/J., Rs~et.J,""olo..\ 10 ~ 1-\ E1J elJ ~ Prto~
. ~ c.ep, CJQ:. ~o. 'Z.c04---e-z.".' Pf.o~ It!? ~
It.! Cer-\ fLH&JCE, I eo..w \=Iw e; P1o-I D .wJt>__ ~ :I: .
~~T1~ ~O~ "Rl l>ol).J.(L ~.,j,.-.po LI~
-(:%~~ ~~f ~~~_'!
PIa_u _In m ~IM -mnn YOU are.uina 1M Con..Ii_on to !like 1&"*,1)
additional-if... -_":
~I..E. j!l tE;oL..\I~ I..tldJ ft:2-. ~ ,A:n1ta\~
~ .I: ~ ~ RJ&u~ f9'tJ_tJf?~~-:.._
~ ~,~o.j or UBJ ,
-.......---".. -...--
-~'---~-.,_.
C"",_ F"'_. 00101o 7.--.............r_''lIcr_....._
LocKHART ENGINEERING, INc.
941 262 5996 P.03
Aqenda Item 0 '3;=
N~overnber 27 2'ob?
;:. c> ':\ (If ':'
ROBERt It L , Pt
Pmhillu
NOV-iS-a? 12:3~ PM LOCKHART
-
. . . ..,. .~,' .~~~...:..';. J . Ii] .
CIVIL .;; SITE I'I.ANNING ,: ZONINO
ATI'ACHMKNT "A"
Request reduction of Code Enforcement Lien to amount.of
$10,00. the receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, in
exchange for a future cOll'lldtrnent for a total of S9 houn
of Community Service time in the capacity as a Registered
Professional Civil Bngineering Consultant to asaist any
appropriate County Department and/or for special projects,
as directed by the Board, Satisfaction of Lien to be
recorded in Public Records upon execution of this
agreement_
13M L"k~hore Drive . Naples, Florida 34103
Phone/FlX' 1239) 2 2-5986
Agenda Item !\io. 8A
November 27 _ 2007
Page, of 190
-
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Petition: PUDZ-2006-AR-I0648: Naples Motorcoach Resort Inc., represented by Robert L.
Duane, MCP, of HoleMontes, Inc., and Richard D. Yovanovich, esquire, of Goodlette,
Coleman, & Johnson, P.A., is requesting a rezone from the Mobile Home, Travel Trailer
Recreational Vehicle Campground, and Heavy Commercial Zoning Districts (MH, lTRVC &
C-5) to the Commercial Planned Unit Development District (CPUD) for a project to be known
as the Naples Motorcoach Resort CPUD. This project proposes to allow development of up to
200 motorcoach lots as well as various amenities such as a boat ramp and boat slips. The
suhject property, consisting of 23.2 acres, is located on the southwest side of Tamiami Trnil,
East, approximately three quarters of a mile east of Collier BoulevanJ (CR 951), in Section 3,
Township 51 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida
OBJECTIVE; To have the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) review staffs findings and
recommendations along with the recommendations of the Collier County Planning Commission
(CCPC) regarding the above referenced rezone to CPUD and render a deeision regarding the
petition.
CONSIDERATIONS: The petitioner requests that the BeC approve a rezone of the recently
cleared 23.2x acre subject property to allow development of a maximum of 200 motorcoach lots
and amenities such as a clubhouse. swimming pools, tennis courts, a one-story, IS-foot high (actual
height) boat storage facility to house a maximum of32 boats, and a maximum 0[27 boat slips along
.- Henderson Creek, The subject property was the site of the Greystone Mobile Home Park, however
that use has been discontinued and the subject property has been cleared. The petitioner is seeking
six deviations as part of this PUD rezoning petition. Staff's initial analysis of the proposed
deviations is contained in the attached staff report. Staff had originally supported Deviations #1
through #4 and #6, but recommended denial of Deviation #5. The petitioner's agent has modified
Deviation #5 since the staff report was prepared and staff now supports the modified deviation
request. All stipulations associated with staff recommendations for the deviations have been
incorporated into the PUD documents.
.-
TIlls project is located within the Collier County Water/Sewer District. As noted in the staff report,
Utilities staff requested the petitioner to provide a 40 by 50 foot wellfield site and provide access to
a public street. The petitioner complied with the wellfield request on April 6, 2007, however this is
not reflected in the current Planned Unit Development Master Plan. On the basis of the County's
2007 Water Supply Development Plan, the project lies within a targeted area for a wellfield for the
future Southeast Water Treatment Plant.
FISCAL IMPACT: The PUD rezone, by and of itself, will have no fiscal impact on Collier
County. There is no guarantee that the project, at build out, will maximize its authorized level of
development, however, if the PUD rezone is approved, a portion of the existing land will be
developed and the new development will result in an impact on Collier County public facilities.
The County collects impact fees prior to the issuance of building permits to help offset the impacts
of each new development on public facilities. These impact fees are used to fund projects identified
in the Capital Improvement Element (CIE) of the GroWth Management Plan (GMP) as needed to
maintain adopted Level of Service (LOS) for public facilities, Additionally, in order to meet the
requirements of concurrency management, the developer of every local development order
Naples Motorcoach Resort CPUD
PUDZ-2006-AR-10648
Executive Summary for 11/27107 Bee
Page 1 of6
/\genda Item No" SA
!\jDvember 27, 2007
Page 2 of '[ 90
approved by Collier County is required to pay 50 percent of the estimated Transportation ImpllL't
Fees associated with the project. Other fees collected prior to issuance of a building permit include
building permit review fees and utility fees associated with connecting to the County's water and
sewer system. Finally, additional revenue is generated by applying ad valorem tax rates to
applicable properties, and that revenue is directly related to the value of improvements. Please note
that the inclusion of impact fees and taxes collected are for informational purposes only; they are
not included in the criteria used by Staff and the Planning Commission to analyze this petition.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN IMPACT:
Future Land Use Element (FLUE): The subject property is designated Urban Mixed Use District,
Urban Coastal Fringe Subdistrict, and is within the Coastal High Hazard Area, all as identified on
the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) of the GMP. This designation allows the proposed Travel
TrailerlRecreational Vehicle (ITRV) use. A motorcoach is a type ofTTRV use and it is considered
a commercial use. The GMP allows motorcoach units in the Subdistrict within the Coastal High
Hazard Area subject to compliance with certain criteria. Staff has analyzed the project in light of
that criteria and has determined that the project is compliant. For details, please refer to the Staff
Report prepared for the Collier County Planning Commission.
Transportation Element; Transportation Division Planning staff has reviewed the CPUD Traffic
Impact Statement (TIS) included in the application back-up material and the CPUD docwnents to
ensure the CPUD docwnents contain the appropriate language to address this project's potential
traffic impacts, and to offer a recommendation regarding GMP Transportation Element Policy 5.1.
Those policies require the review of all rezone requests with consideration of its impact on the
overall transportation system, and specifically notes that the County should not approve any request
that significantly impacts a roadway segment already operating and/or projected to operate at an
unacceptable LOS within the 5 year planning period unless mitigating stipulations are approved.
The project review was based on the current TIS guidelines and with respect to GMP Transportation
Element Policy 5.1. The project traffic was distributed on the adjacent roadway network and
analyzed through project build out with consideration given to the five-year planning period. The
Naples Motorcoach Resort PUDZ can be considered consistent with Policies 5.1 and 5.2 of the
Transportation Element of the GMP. The adjacent roadway network is currently over capacity when
considering background traffic plus banked traffic, and cannot accommodate additional trips.
However this project proposes a net reduction of 65 PM Peak Hour, Peak Direction trips. The
project is therefore consistent throughout the five-year planning period. US-41 has a negative
remaining capacity of approximately 288 trips, and is currently at LOS "F."
Conservation and Coastal Management Element: Pursuant to Policy 6.1.8 and the Land
Development Code, an Environmental Impact Statement was not required. However, in accordance
with Policy 7.2.1 the project was required to be evaluated for consistency with the Manatee
Protection Plan. Environmental staff have reviewed that information provided by the applicant and
have found the project consistent with the stated objectives of the Collier County Manatee Protection
Plan (to reduce boat-related manatee mortalities, achieve an optimal sustainable manatee population.
and to protect manatee habitat) by reducing the number of boats which could use the facility and by
restricting any expansion of the boat facility in the future.
There is no existing native vegetation that needs to be retained on site to be deemed consistent with
Policy 6.1.1. No jurisdictional wetlands have been identified as required in Policies 6.2.1 and 6.2.2.
Naples Motorcoach Resort CPUD
PUDZ-2006-AR-10648
Executive Summary for 11/27107 BCC
Page 2 016
/\genc;a Item No 8A
NOV9tTmer 27 2007
P~ge ::; ~)f '190
GMP Conclusion: The GMP is the prevailing document to support land use decisions such as this
proposed rezoning to CPUD. Staff is required to make a recommendation regarding a finding of
consistency or inconsistency with the overall GMP as part of the recommendation for approval,
approval with conditions, or denial of any rezoning petition. A finding of consistency with the
FLUE and FLUM designations is a portion of the overall finding that is required, and staff believes
the petition, as revised before, during and after the CCPC hearing (see CCPC discussion later in the
report), is consistent with the FLUM and the FLUE. The proposed rezone is consistent with the
GMP Transportation Element as previously discussed. Based upon the above analysis, staff
concludes the proposed uses can be deemed consistent with the goals, objective and policies of the
overall GMP if stafPs recommendation is adopted.
AFFORDABLE HOUSING IMPACT:
This request contains no provisions to address the Affordabie- Workforce housing demands that it
may create.
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES:
Environmental Services staff has reviewed the petition and the PUD document to address any
environmental concerns. This petition was not required to submit an Environmental Impact
Statement (EIS). The site is not located within a Special Treatment overlay which would also have
required the submittal of an EIS.
ENVIRONMENTAL ADVISORY COUNCIL (EAC) RECOMMENDATION:
Because an EIS was not required and there are no impacts to wetlands, this petition was not required
to go to the EAC.
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION (CCPC) RECOMMENDATION:
The Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) heard this petition on October 18, 2007; a
motion was made and seconded to forward petition PUDZ-2006-AR-I0648 to the BCC with a
recommendation of approval by a vote of 7 to 0 subject to the following stipulations:
Prior to the Board of County Commissioner's hearing, the PUD documents shall be modified to
address the following:
1. The actual height of the boat storage facilities shall be limited to 15 feet (see Exhibit A., Section
B.5 and Exhibit B Boat Storage Building Maximum Building Height); and
2. Motorcoach units shall be limited to a minimum length of 35 feet and a maximum length of 45
feet (Exhibit A, Permitted Uses, A.l. Definition); and
3. Clarity Exhibit A.B.2 "Small Utility Buildings" shall be limited to 1,000 sqUllJ'e feet; and
4. Revise Exhibit A.B.5 and Exhibit F to indicate that the covered boat storage facility is limited to
a maximum of 32 spaces in one tier (story) only. The covered boat storage facilities can be
accommodated in two separate structures within the Tract 1. Furthermore, no boat trailer
storage (with or without boats) shall be permitted on the subject site except within the covered
boat storage facility; any other boat or boat trailer storage is prohibited; and
5. Revise Exhibit E, Deviation #5 and Exhibit F.2. to indicate that the required landscape buffer
area and number and types of plantings shall not be reduced but instead the same sqUllJ'e footage
and number and types of plantings shall be relocated within each individual recreation and
Naples Motorcoach Resort CPUD
PUDZ-2006-AR-l0648
Executive Summary for 11/27107 Bee
Page 30f6
Agen-ja item i~o. 8l..
r\JovemlJ8r 27 2007
PagE; 4 of i C-)(l
clubhouse areas outside the wheel stops, e.g., between the parking spaces and the structures
rather than between the road right-of-way and the parking spaces; and
6. Revise Exhibit B to reflect a minimum setback along US 41 for the bathhouse shall be 50 feet
instead of 25 feet; and
7. Revise Exhibit F to remove item 5, and revise item 6 to indicate that the motorcoaches shall be
removed from the site if a hurricane watch is issued; and
8. Replace the language in Exhibit F.2 with the following; The developer shall provide a IS-foot
wide buffer area that is comprised of four rows of native trees, planted at a maximum of 25 feet
on center in staggered rows on the Henderson Drive side of the covered boat storage area. Trees
shall be a minimum of] 8 feet tall at time of planting. There shall be two rows of shade/canopy
trees that include no clustering; and two rows trees of varied species that can be clustered. The
IS-foot wide buffer shall also include a double staggered hedgerow that is a minimum of 6 feet
high at time of planting. The buffer area shall also include a wall that is a minimum of 8 feet
high. Half of the required shade/canopy trees shall be planted on the Henderson Drive side of
the wall. (See Exhibit C-I); and
9. Revised Exhibit B, Boat Storage Building front setback to allow a ] O-foot setback instead of a
20-foot setback (for the internal roadway); and
J O. Remove the well casement.
Because there were letters of objection submitted regarding this petition, this petition cannot be
placed on the summary agenda.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS:
This is a site specific request to rezone from the Mobile Home, Travel Trailer Recreational Vehicle
Campground, and Heavy Commercial Zoning Districts (MH, TTRVC & C-5) to the Commercial
Planned Unit Development District (CPUD) for a project to be known as the Naples Motorcoach
Resort CPUD. Site Specific rezones are quasi-judicial in nature. As such the burden falls upon the
applicant to prove that the proposed rezone is consistent with all the criteria set forth below. The
burden then shifts to the Board of County Commissioners (BCC), should it consider denying the
rezone, to determine that such denial would not be arbitrary, discriminatory or unreasonable. This
would be accomplished by finding that the proposal does not meet one or more of the listed criteria
below. Additionally, the applicant is amending some of the development standards including the
removal of conditional uses and reducing the height. These proposals should also be reviewed
utilizing any of the applicable criteria below.
Criteria for PUD Rezones
Ask yourself the following questions_ The answers assist you in making a determination for
approval or not.
I. Consider: The suitability of the area for the type and pattern of development proposed
in relation to physical characteristics of the land, surrounding areas, traffic and access,
drainage, sewer, water, and other utilities.
2. Is there an adequacy of evidence of unified control and suitability of agreements,
contract, or other instruments or for amendments in those proposed, particularly as they
may relate to arrangements or provisions to be made for the continuing operation and
maintenance of such areas and facilities that are not to be provided or maintained at
public expense? The County Attorney has found unified control and suitability of
agreements.
Naples Motorcoach Resort CPUD
PUDZ-2006-AR-l0648
Executive Summary for 11/27107 BCC
Page 4 of6
,L\gencia Item No_ SA
t..Jovember 27, 2007
Page ::' of 190
3. Consider: Conformity of the proposed PUD with the goals, objectives and policies of
the GMP.
4. Consider: The internal and external compatibility of proposed uses, which conditions
may include restrictions on location of improvements, restrictions on design, and
buffering and screening requirements.
5. Is there an adequacy of usable open space areas in existence and as proposed to serve the
development?
6. Consider: The timing or sequence of development (a~ proposed) for the purpose of
assuring the adequacy of available improvements and facilities, both public and private.
7. Consider: The ability of the subject property and of surrounding areas to accommodate
expansion.
8. Consider: Conformity with PUD regulations, or as to desirable modifications of such
regulations in the particular ca~e, based on determination that such modifications are
justified as meeting public purposes to a degree at least equivalent to literal application
of such regulations.
9. Will the proposed change be consistent with the goals, objectives, and policies and
future land use map and the elements of the GMP?
10. Will the proposed PUD Rezone be appropriate considering the existing land use pattern?
11. Would the requested PUD Rezone result in the possible creation of an isolated district
unrelated to adjacent and nearby districts?
12. Consider: Whether existing district boundaries are illogically drawn in relation to
existing conditions on the property proposed for change.
13. Consider: Whether changed or changing conditions make the passage of the proposed
amendment necessary.
14. Will the proposed change adversely influence living conditions in the neighborhood?
15. Will the proposed change create or excessively increase traffic congestion or create
types of traffic deemed incompatible with surrounding land uses, because of peak
volumes or projected types of vehicular traffic, including activity during construction
phases of the development, or otherwise affect public safety?
16. Will the proposed change create a drainage problem?
17. Will the proposed change seriously reduce light and air to adjacent areas?
18. Will the proposed change adversely affect property values in the adjacent area?
Naples Motorcoach Resort CPUD
PUDZ-2006-AR-l0648
Executive Summary for 11/27107 BCC
Page 5 016
Agenda item No, BA
November 27, 2007
PaGe 6 of :[-)0
19. Will the proposed change be a deterrent to the improvement or development of adjacent
property in accordance with existing regulations?
20. Consider: Whether the proposed change will constitute a grant o.fspecial privilege to
an individual owner as contrasted with the public welfare.
21. Are there substantial reasons why the property reasonably cannot be used in accordance
with existing zoning?
22. Is the change suggested out of scale with the needs of the neighborhood or the County?
23. Consider: Whether it is impossible to find other adequate sites in the County for the
proposed use in districts already permitting such use.
24. Consider: The physical characteristics of the property and the degree of site alteration
which would be required to make the property usable for any of the range of potential
uses under the proposed zoning classification.
25. Consider: The impact of dcvelopment resulting from the proposed PUO rezone on the
availability of adequate public facilities and senlices consistent with thc LOS adopted in
the Collier County GMP and as defined and implemented through the Collier County
Adequate Public Facilities Ordinance [Code ch.1 06, art.II}, as amended.
26. Are there other factors, standards, or criteria relating to the PUD rezone request that the
Board of County Commissioners shall deem important in the protection of the public
health, safety, and welfare?
The BeC must base its decision upon the competent, substantial evidence presented by the written
materials supplied to it, induding but not limited to the Staff Report, Executive Summary, maps,
studies, letters from interested persons and the oral testimony presented at the BCC hearing as these
items relate to these criteria.
RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends that the Board of County Commissioners approve Petition PUDZ-2006-AR-
10648 subject to the conditions of approval that have been incorporated in the Ordinance of
Adoption.
PREPARED BY:
Kay Deselem, AICP, Principal Planner
Department of Zoning and Land Development Review
Naples Motorcoach Resort CPUD
PUDZ-2006-AR-10648
Executive Summary for 11/27107 BCC
Page6of6
Page I of ]
Agenda Item ND, BA
November n, 21]07
Page 7 uIE,JO
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD 0;:: COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Item Number:
Item Summary:
nilS j\(-~ '8QI:I(% 'r;iJj "Ii ;:artIGiPant::, bE: ',worn in an,j 61, c,,,r\!', GI~;ciO:;IJC('; tn; c,nvlct,"c! by
,;:"nlll ~S,lW Thin!."", --",'!;!ICW' f'UD?2COI>AR-1DGt,3 hiJ:.)le~; Mot0r~u,"dl Resort in,:
rt':..'rl1sem, ,! by ~,~"-'er1 ~);j3n(''- !c':p ill H(>IBMume~. Inc ""lei F;'I01,lrU [) '(\V:'i1lC''''U'
"',S'1i"'-P -, '--;OQdieli!', l,'Jlenan Ii joh )~,()r, "',A.. 10 rhll1lY"lnq nJ,.D"f' frum tl"o", MGbll~"
I')ml' "HVt' - r:,jirTRvl"",niINH,!I"i;I')";Ii" Cc',rnpgi','l;r,(! )1111
""nrn"ner'::i3i:_U'1IU:
"'1-;':;1'
,TPW;i;
I,~; t'1" "Till': c:;' C ii'" P lil '11";;." , "lj', t') 'O'v"", lPIT1"-'1\: [,j ~',i r I'~!
,) nr::ec' D(1 "('10'''' i d l'r)( i'J,lples Pv'ID1'J:'GUo.U: I,;,
~)n-"i"C' pia: (:';\:) tf
:-1iO\,-' U /'-',1 'P" ~''1' r, ur 2r.'l': 'now ('CW'-, U\S 8',
"'W',J:;;"l':rlll,e',SU;'!
. ~,,"
t"":-;','iiJS
oWI'i,"" ,,"')1)8"\ c'.:r:s:!;llll~
riC",,'t, S Il ~dle<J 'J'1 ti1~
<;umw'," S:(ii' 0 arlllbrn "la',1 _ 3~' dllP"Qi;rfi'Jle:~ TI1r'6' 'lllv'tH' '" ,,,,,It) 6'':0'', Qi
1"D;'fl'v
,;::":lr(1'1
""..'ns1nJ "lWU', F' "'(1'.',j'; '(,'",l'
~': r:;U",1 -'
,-red,',
Meeting Date;
-/I:-'U:;"'(Ji" ire
Prepured By
';"\'
"I'I1L,,;;.;J'\-m,,("
[,,,,,,
- ',n,(\'",,';" ~>,."',hw,,c 't
,':rnT'" ,N'" '~",.,"i
',,,,,,,,, L,M)d-j"'-j' IGO'..""""j f:,c"..,,:,,,__
:'roO'"
Appnn'cd By
0::-:>011
Allprnl'l'd lSy
App~(jwd B~'
..w,:r",,,'"'' "''',C
l r~n ,por.:~ti,-", y,'\__"""
'''''"s;:,''':''v
,',<.I"',,',
Approved By
", "-,,'1" MurrJV, ;" ~~I'
l."".n,;t, ,-,,,,,j [j(",'elvf H",m' ''''L'ctc,
r.)~l<
,;ornmuni1'.' [)""""''-'"''',.r&
E'nv,ronn",n:ai ~~"rVIC0':
;:::"",n:;>;. Gnc! [mv",I(}~;r,.,,,,,\ kPil<\"W
1111.-1,21)1)" If'1,'tH/
A[lp~oved By
.Iud" ",1);9 OtJernhu\,; Anabst
[Jan,
Community Dcvelopnl{jrlt I;. Cortlmunity Development &
[;nvironmcmal Services b\'.lironmcntal Servic.!!; Admin
1\!,41;!0071145IlJJ
Approved By
f'i',orlenoo ~',lvw~,rt Exe~t!liv(, Sccret~ry
[I,ll!'
Community Devolopment.. CommUflity Df)v~'lopment 8,
EnVlwnmcnlal Serviccs Enviwnmcnt,il Service", Admin
11't4/200i 12 m; ;0 ~,;
Approved By
.I[1~'"ph K. SChrnit'
Community Devei"pml1nt &.
E:wironmen1al Service" AdminstraIOI
f);nf'
Community Ueveloprner\t-S
Environmental Service~
(:\"mn,ur,it," Dev()IQP'lI~'nt C;._
b1Vironmentll! Ser~ices;:"jmir1
ilI14::;:Ot)77'4El"M
Appl'oved B}'
OMS Coordinator
AlJpiic.atlOn& ""alyst
Date
Admi"isuJtiveServicos
Inionnallopl"chnoiog:,
11i15120073A2Pt1
Approved By
Marktsackson
5udgejl-m~I:,'st
tl<>te
County M~naget'~ Office
Offie" of Management f. !:Iud",e!
11/16/20079:.27,e.M
Appr-ovedBy
JarfWS V """,dd
'::;Guntyrif..1nagor
DJte
Board ofCou"ty
Commi~sio'H1rs
COUf1t\' W;an~f''''''~ Off'e"
11!1612007&'OfJPNi
file://C:\AgendaTest\Export\93- November%2027 .%202007\08,%20ADVERTISED%20P._,
] \12012007
Agenda item !,-jo. SA
November 27. 200?
Page 8 of 190
Co~~r County
.
STAFF REPORT
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
FROM:
DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DlVIS]ON
HEARING DATE:
OCTOBER I R, 2007
SUBJECT:
PUDZ-2006-AR-I0648: '\IAPLES MOTORCOACH RESORT COMMERCIAL
PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPME1\'T (CrUD)
PROPERTY APPLICANT/AGENT:
APPLICANT:
AGEJ\'TS:
Naples Molorcoach Resort. Inc.
2400 Crestmoor Road, Suite 200
Nashville. TN 37215
Robcli L. Duane. AICr
HoleMonles. Inc.
950 Encore Way
Naples, FL 341]0
Richard D. Yovanovich. Esquire
Goodlette. Coleman & Johnson
4001 Tamiami Trail N. Suite 300
Naples, FL 34103
REQUESTED ACTION:
The petitioner requests that the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) consider a rezone of the
subject site from the Mobile Home (MH), Travel Trailer Recreational Vehicle Campground (TTRVC),
and Heavy Commercial Zoning Districts (C-5) to the Commercial Planned Unit Development District
(CPUD) zoning district for the Naples Motorcoach Resort.
GEOGRAPHIC LOCATION:
The subject property is located on the southwest side of Tamiami Trail, East (US 4]), approximately
three quarters of a mile east of Collier Boulevard (CR (51), in Section 3, Township 5] South, Range 26
East, Collier County, Florida. (See location map on the following page)
PURPOSEIDESCRIPTION OF PROJECT:
The proposed 23.2ct-acre CPUD, if approved, will allow development of a maximum of 200
motorcoach lots and amenities such as a clubhouse, swimming pools, tennis courts, a two-story, 35-foot
high (actual height) boat storage facility to house a maximum of 36 boats, a maximum of 27 boat slips
along Henderson Creek, and open parking spaces for a maximum of 10 boat trailers. The petitioner is
seeking six deviations as part of this PUD rezoning petition.
Naples Motorcoach Resort CPUD, PUDZ-2006-AR-10648 October 18, 2007 CCPC
Page 1 0114
A.aenda Item No. SA
N~oYember 27. 2007
Page 9 of '90
The aerial photo provided below is the most current information available from the Collier County
Property Appraiser. Since that photo was taken the site has been cleared, but the photo shows the
Greystone Mobile Home Park and convenience store that no longer exist.
SURROUNDING LAND USE AND ZONING:
South:
West:
US 41 (Tamiami Trail), then undeveloped tracts within the Winding Cypress
DRI/PUD project, with a PUD zoning designation
San Marcos Mission Catholic Church, with a zoning designation of Agricultural (A),
with a conditional use for a church
Henderson Creek Mobile Home Park, with a Mobile Home (MH) zoning designation
Henderson Creek, then Holiday Manor Mobile Home Cooperative, with a MH zoning
designation, and developing commercial uses within the i\rtesa Pointe PUD. with a
zoning designation of PUD
Northwest:
East:
Aerial Photo (subject site depiction is approximate)
NOTE: The site has been cleared since this photo was taken.
Naples Motorcoach Resort CPUD, PUDZ-2006-AR-l0648 October 18, 2007 CCPC
Page 2 of 14
.L\oencja item [\)0 SA
r\j~ovelllber 27, 2"i]rq
Page 10 of 190
r
WIll/DING CYPRESS DRJ
PUO
WINDING CYPRESS ORI
RSF~3
~
GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN (GMP) CONSISTENCY;
Future Land Use Element (FLUE):
The subject property is designated Urban Mixed Use District, Urban Coastal Fringe Subdistrict. and is
within the Coastal High Hazard Area, all as identified on the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) of the
GMP. This designation allows the proposed Travel Trailer/Recreational Vehicle (TTRV) use. A
motorcoach is a type ofTTRV use and it is considered a commercial use. The "density" of the TTRV
use is not considered a residential use pursuant to the GMP, thus it is not subject to the "density" of the
Density Rating System of the GMP. The LDC contains provisions for the TTRV measure of intensity
of use based upon the number of units per acre, referring to that measure as "density."
The GMP allows motorcoach units in the Subdistrict within the Coastal High Hazard Area subject to
the following criteria, each followed by staff comment in italics:
a) the density is consistent with that pem1itted in the Land Development Code;
b) the site has direct principal access to a road classified as an arterial in the Transportation Element;
and
c) the use will be compatible with surrounding land uses.
The proposed motorcoach use is limited in LDC Table 2.0S.0IA. to a maximum of 12 TTRV units per
acre. This project proposes a TTRV maximum density of 8.62 units per acre, which is in compliance
with the LDC requirements and thus the project is consistent with a) above. The project is shown with
direct access to US 41, an arterial roadway. therefore the petition is consistent with b) above.
Staff does not believe. however, that the project, as it is currently designed, is compatible with item c)
above. FLUE Policy 5.4 requires that all new development be compatible with and complementary to
the surrounding land uses. The Land Development Code (LDC) Section 4.07.02.B and generally
accepted planning principles recognize the concept that when a project proposes elements of
development that could have a negative impact on the neighborhood, then those elements should be
intemalized rather than extemalized. The theory is that those persons who most benefit from the
Naples Motorcoach Resort CPUD, PUDZ-2006-AR-10648 October 18, 2007 CCPC
Page 3 of 14
lJ..aenda Item No. 3.L\
N~ovember 27.2007
Page '1 of 190
causative factor should bear the burden of the impacts. For example, if a project proposes structures or
densities in excess of what exists on the surrounding parcels, then those structures and densities should
be located nearer the center of the project rather than on the perimeter of the project.
Specifically, staff is concerned about the proposed location of the boat storage facilities along
Henderson Drive. The boat storage facility is proposed to be a two-story, 35 foot high (actual height)
structure. The developer has sited that structure along the project's perimeter. This facility is one of
the tallest structures proposed within this project and one of the larger facilities within the project (see
Master Plan).
In reviewing the appropriateness of requested uses, development standards such as building heights,
setbacks, landscape buffers, and potential building mass, building location and orientation, and the
amount and type of open space and location of that open space are considerations of compatibility.
The building's orientation and massing does not show any particular sensitivity to the proposed
perimetcr location. Rather than smaller buildings in an cnd-to-end contiguration that would most
likely be used for the motorcoach lots along Henderson Drive to prcsent a morc similar facade to the
traveling public's view, i.e.. those persons traveling along Henderson Drive, the boat storage facility's
orientation prcsents the most inlensc oricntation and massing to thc public.
Additionally, looking at the acrial photo, it can readily been seen that the church located across
Henderson Drive scts back from the road right-ot:way approximately] 00 feet. The proposed boat
storage facility is proposed to setback only ] 5 feet from the Henderson Dlive right-ot:way. Staff
believcs this proximity is inappropriate. Additional setback could ameliorate the boal storagc
facility's impact, but a better alternative would be to totally relocate the facility more interior to thc
project. It seems more logical to place a boat storage facility closer to thc crcek where the boats will
be uscd. It seems that the applicant may be wishing to retain the aesthetically plcasing view of the
water for the project's lot owncrs at the expcnse of the traveling public who gct no benefit from the
facility. The petitioner is placing the most obnoxious clement of thc project where it will have the
least impact upon those persons who will have the most benefit from the facility. This is contrary to
good planning practice regarding externalizing/internalizing impacts, as noted above.
Staff review also notes that boats in the dry storage will be removed by forklift. Because the dry
storage is located on the opposite side of the project site and is not located adjacent to, or even near,
the boat ramp, the forklift will be required to transport each boat on the internal roadway system. This
poses an unnecessary increased safety risk, particularly in light of the requested deviations in sidewalk
and roadway widths.
In an attempt to mollify staffs concerns, the applicant proposes to provide a buffer for the boat storage
facility within the 15- foot-wide setback area that will be comprised of an eight-foot-high wall along
with a five- foot high hedge and 16- 18 foot high trees, planted 25 foot on center (see PUD Exhibits C-l
and F.3). The LDC would require a I5-foot-wide type D buffer, based upon Transportation Planning
Department's evaluation that Henderson Drive has a 100 foot right-of-way and the requirements set
forth in LDC Section 4.06.02.CA.
Interestingly, Exhibit C- I does not depict the trees at time of planting, but rather depicts what is
characterized in the "Buffer Type 'B' table as the "Growth Habit" thus portraying a potential future
rendition of what the buffer mav look like, if certain trees are planted. To explain, in the PUD written
document, the developer is proposing to provide a buffer that contains an unspecified number of rows
Naples Motorcoach Resort CPUD. PUDZ-2006-AR-10648 October 18, 2007 CCPC
Page 4 of 14
Aqenda item No 8/\
iI:wember- 27. 2007
Page 12 of :90
of trees. The developer does not provide the specified species of trees that will be planted. The
developer only states that the trees will be 16- 18 feet tall when planted and a 5-foot high single row
hedge will be provided along with the eight-foot high wall. Exhibit e-l however depicts three rows of
trees, consisting of 55-foot tall Royal Palms. 35-loot high cabbage palms and 35-foot high Laurel
Oaks trees. Those heights are shown as typical. hut the scaled height on the plans shows trees heights
of 60+ and 40+ feet. (The Royal Palm and Laurel Oak trees are the only two species listed on e - I that
will reach the height shown, thus those must be the species that are depicted in the drawing). The
drawing also shows shrubs that arc taller than the eight foot high wall.
NUMBER OF TREES HEIGHT OF
BUFFER (ROWS)! TREES NUMBER OF SHRUBS
TYPES (ON CENTER rOC] (IN FEET) SHRUBS
REQUIREMENT)
Type D One row/ 10 Double staggered 24" at planting;
@ 30 feet oc hedgerow maintained at 36"
Developer's One row/ Unspecified so 5 feet high at
written 16-18
@ 25 feet oc I single row implied planting
proposal I
3 rows/ @ 25 feet oc Stated 35 and 55
Developer's R #1 Royal Palm typical In excess of 8 feet
artistic R #2 Clusters of 3 Double row
depiction Sabal Palms Shown at 40+ & in height
R #3Canopy trees 60+
Based upon conversations with Zoning Department Landscape Review staff, it seems unlikely that the
buffer proposed by the developer would reach the depicted heights within at least 10 years. Staff
believes Exhibit e-I does not provide a true depiction of the proposed buffer, and furthermore staff is
not convinced that the proposed buffer as it will be planted will adequately address the compatibility
issue. Staff suggests that there are other alternatives to address the issue, such as locating the boat
storage facility interior to the project and adjusting the massing and building orientation.
Staff recommends that the Master Plan be revised to relocate the boat storage facility away from the
project perimeter. This issue is addressed again in the Deviation #5 discussion provided later in this
report. Incidentally, staff advised the petitioner about compatibility concerns in the first review letter
dated November 25, 2006, noting, "Please explain why you have located the boat storage so far from
the waterway the boats will use. The location of the storage area along the exterior of the project
raises compatibility issues. It seems that this use should be internalized rather than externalized." The
petitioner's agent disagrees with staffs contention and has opted to go to hearings to allow the cepe
and Bee to make the detennination regarding this issue.
In support of FLUE Policy 7.1, project access is provided to U.S. 41, an arterial roadway. In support
of FLUE Policy 7.2, the internal roadway system consists of three connected loop roads. Other smart
growth policies under FLUE Objective 7, pertaining to project interconnections and walkable
Naples Motorcaach Resort CPUD, PUDZ-2006-AR-10648 October 18. 2007 CCPC
Page 5 of 14
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27, 2007
Page 13 of 190
communities with a variety of densities, uses and unit types, are not applicable based upon the
proposed land use, proposed private narrow roads, and the development status of surrounding lands
(bordered by a creek, two roads, and a developed mobile home park).
Transportation Element:
Transportation Division Phuming staff has reviewed the CPUD Traffic Impact Statement (TIS)
included in the application back-up material and the CPUD documents to ensure the CPUD documents
contain the appropriate language to address this project's potential traffic impacts, and to offer a
recommendation regarding GMP Transportation Element Policy 5.1. Those policies require the
review of all rezone requests with consideration of its impact on the overall transportation system, and
specifically notes that the County should not approve any request that significantly impacts a roadway
segment already operating andlor projected to operate at an unacceptable Level of Service (LOS)
within the five-year planning period unless specific mitigating stipulations are approved.
The project review was based on the current TIS guidelines and with respect to GMP Transportation
Element Policy 5. I. The project traffic was distributed on the adjacent roadway network and analyzed
through project build out with consideration given to the five-year planning period. The Naples
Motorcoach Res0I1 PUDZ can be considered consistent with Policies 5.1 and 5.2 of the Transp0l1ation
Element of" the Growth Management Plan [GMP]. The adjacent roadway network is currently over
capacity when considering background traffic plus banked tramc. and cannot accommodate additional
trips. However this project proposes a net reduction of 65 PM Peak Hour, Peak Direction trips. The
project is therefore consistent throughout the five-year planning period. USAI has a negative
remaining capacity of approximately 288 tTips. and is currently at LOS "F".
Conservation and Coastal Management Element:
Pursuant to Policy 6.1.8 and the Land Development Code, an Environmental Impact Statement was not
required. However, in accordance with Policy 7.2.1 the project was required to be evaluated for
consistency with the Manatee Protection Plan. Environmental staff have reviewed that information
provided by the applicant and have found the project consistent with the stated objectives of the Collier
County Manatee Protection Plan (to reduce boat-related manatee mortalities, achieve an optimal
sustainable manatee population, and to protect manatee habitat) by reducing the number of boats which
could use the facility and by restricting any expansion of the boat facility in the future.
There is no existing native vegetation that needs to be retained on site to be deemed consistent with
Policy 6.1.1. No jurisdictional wetlands have been identified as required in Policies 6.2.1 and 6.2.2.
GMP Conclusion:
The GMP is the prevailing document to support land use decisions such as this proposed rezoning to
CPUD. Staff is required to make a recommendation regarding a finding of consistency or
inconsistency with the overall GMP as part of the recommendation for approval, approval with
conditions, or denial of any rezoning petition. A finding of consistency with the FLUE and FLUM
designations is a portion of the overall finding that is required, and staff believes the petition is
inconsistent with the FLUM and the FLUE as indicated previously in the GMP discussion. The
proposed rezone is consistent with the GMP Transp011ation Element as previously discussed. Based
upon the above analysis, staff concludes the proposed uses cannot be deemed consistent with the goals,
Naples Motorcoach Resort CPUD, PUDZ-2006-AR-10648 October 18, 2007 CCPC
Page 6 of 14
Aaenda Item No, 8A
N-ovember 27, 2007
Page i4 of 190
objective and policies of the overall GMP unless staffs recommendation regarding the relocation ofthe
boat storage facility is adopted.
ANALYSIS:
StafT completed a comprehensive evaluation of this land use petition and the criteria upon which a
favorable determination must be based. These criteria are specifically noted in Sections] 0.02.13 and
] 0.02. I 3.B.5 of the LDC and required staff evaluation and comment. The stafT evaluation establishes a
factual basis to support the recommendations of staff. The Collier County Planning Commission
(CCPC) uses these same criteria as the basis for their recommendation to the Board of County
Commissioners (BCC). who in turn use the criteria to support their action on the rezoning request.
These evaluations are completed as separate documents and are attached to the staff report (See
Exhibits A and B l.
jo'I1Virol1mclllal Revi",\': Environmental Services staff has rcviewed the petition and the PUD document
to address any environmcntal coneems. This petition was not required to submit an Environment
Impact Statement lEIS) nor was a hearing before thc Environmental Advisory Commission required
because the site was previously developed. The site is not located within an ST overlav which wouid
also have required the submittal of an EIS.
]i-al1S/)Orlalioll Review: Transportation Division stall' has reviewed the petition and the PUD document
and Master Plan lor right-oj~way and access issues. The applicant has incol1)()rated Transportation
Division staffs revisions within thc PU D document, and Transportation Division Plmming staff
recommends approval subject to the Transportation commitments contained in the PUD document.
This includes a provision that thc dcvelopmcnt provide paymcnt in lieu of the installation of sidewalks.
Utilitv Review: This project is located within the Collier County Water/Scwer District. Any portions of
this project to be developed shall be required to comply with the current Ordinance 2004-3] - Collier
County Utilities Standards and Procedures. According to county GI S records, there is an existing 16-
inch force main and 16-inch water main on Tamiami Trail. Utilities staff requested the petitioner
provide a 40 foot by 50 foot wellfield site and provide access to a public street. The petitioner has
complied with the wellfield request.
EmenzencJ! Manai!emenl: Emergency Management staff provided the following comment at the
beginning of the reviewal' this project: "The Naples Motorcoach Resort PUDZ is located in a CAT 1
hurricane surge zone, which requires evacuation during many hurricane events. Adding to the
residential units in this area further taxes an already tight evacuation and sheltering situation within
Collier County. The Collier County LDC may require mitigation for this project as it applies to mobile
home communities." In response to that comment the petitioner has included commitments in the PUD
document to ensure that there will be no permanent residents within this project and furthermore, no
unoccupied motorcoach units will remain on site during hurricane season.
Parks and Recreation: The Public Services Division provided the following comment: "Parks and
Recreation staff recommends that the applicant consider replacing one of the three pools proposed on
the master plan with a CPSC and ASTM certified commercial grade playground designed for 2-12 year
old children. The developer should provide documentation in the PUD file of the proposed recreation
elements and, if providing a playground, should state that the playground meets the above
requirements." The applicant responded that the developer anticipated few children would be
associated with this project and therefore opted not to incorporate any playground facilities.
Naples Motorcoach Resort CPUD, PUDZ-2006-AR-1 0648 October 18, 2007 CCPC
Page 7 of 14
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27, 2007
Page 15 of 190
Zoning Review: The development standards contained in Exhibit B of the PUD documents reflect a
design approach that will provide a project with setbacks that are different from the conventional
TTRVC zoning district. The minimum TTRVC side setbacks are ]0 feet for waterfront and 5 feet for
non-waterfront lots. This petition proposes a nine- and zero-foot setback for all motorcoach lots which
is a typical zero lot line configuration. Rear setbacks in the TTRVC are] 0 feet for waterfront and 8
feet for non-waterfront; the PUD proposes a ] 0 foot setback for all motorcoach slabs. The proposed
street setbacks proposed for this project are significantly less than what is set forth in LDC for TTRVC
zoning district. The TTRVC rcqnires a 50 foot setback from any public street, such as US 41 and
Henderson Drive as shown below:
External Street Setback External Street Setback (from
(from US 41) Henderson Drive)
TTRVC
(Per frontage footnote in 50 feet 50 feet
LDC 8402.01)
-------------- -----_._-_.~. -
i 20 ft for pool deck and tennis 15 ft for Maintenance & Boat storage
courts bldgs, Personal Utility and other
I accessory bldgs and pool deck
I Proposed CPUD
(Shown) 20 ft for tennis courts and motorcoach
25 feet ft all other uses slabs
25 feet ft office, clubhouse and
bathhouse
The diminished Henderson Drive setback (from what the conventional TTRVC district would require)
exacerbates the massing and orientation of the disputed proposed boat storage facility location.
As illustrated in the aerial photograph located on page 2 of the staff report, the surrounding zoning
discussion of this staff report, and the Master Plan, the site is adjacent to Henderson Creek and then
mobile home uses within the Holiday Manor Mobile Home Cooperative to the west (MH zoning); to
the northwest is Tamiami Trail (US 4]), then undeveloped tracts within the Winding Cypress DRI/PUD
project; to the east is Henderson Drive, then San Marcos Mission Catholic Church. To the south is the
Henderson Creek Mobile Home Park (MH zoning). The Mobile Home zoning district, pursuant to
LDC Section 2.02.02 is a residential zoning district. The proposed project requests commercial zoning
and commercial uses, thus the petitioner/developer must address potential compatibility issues arising
from the different use types. The developer proposes Type D buffers that will include a wall around the
northwest (20 feet wide), eastern boundaries (15 feet wide). A type D buffer consists of a double,
staggered hedgerow, with #3 shrubs, 24 inches high at planting that are maintained at 36 inches along
with trees planted 30 feet on center. A 15 foot wide type B buffer is proposed to the south and to the
west along Henderson Creek.
Deviation Discussion:
The petitioner is seeking six deviations from the requirements of the LDC. The deviations are found in
PUD Exhibit F.
Naples Motorcoach Resort CPUD, PUDZ-2006-AR-10648 October 18, 2007 CCPC
Page 8 of 14
Aqenda item No aA
N""oV91l1ber 27. 2007
Page 16 Df 190
Deviation # I seeks relief from LDC Section 4.06.06 of the LDC for the western side of the project along
the creek, to require a fifteen foot buffer south of the boat ramp and adjacent to the canal and to maintain
a 10 foot Type "A" buffer north of the boat ramp. The reduction of the buffer from 15 feet to lO feet is
the subject of this deviation.
Petitioner's Rationale: The applicant states in his justification for this deviation that the land north of
the boat ramp across Henderson Creek is a preserve area; therefore a reduced setback will not impact
any persons.
StafJAna{.vsis and Recommendation: This deviation provides an alternative to the required buffer in an
area that will not impact any persons other than lot owners who may opt to purchase a lot within this
project. Those lot owners would be doser to Hcnderson Creek if the deviation is approved. A location
doser to a water feature is usually viewed as a benefit rather than a detriment, so approval of this
deviation should not result in any internal incompatibilities. This design takes into consideration the
site's location along the creek, and it appears to meet the intent of the LDC requirements. Zoning and
Land Development Review staff recommends APPROVAL. finding that, in compliance with LDC
Section JO.02.I3.A.3. the petitioner has demonstrated that "the element mav be waived without a
detrimental effect on the health. safetv and welfare of the communitv" and LDC Section] O'()2.13.B.5.h.
the petitioner has demonstrated that the deviation is "iustiiied as meeting public purposes to a degree at
least equivalent to literal application of such regulations."
Deviation #2 seeks relief ii'om LDC Section 4.05,(i4 to allow parking I"l' accessory uses to be computed
at 50 percent of the requirement.
Petitioner's Rationale: The applicant states that the accessory uses, such as the pools, tennis COUlis and
clubhouse will be locatcd within a short walking distance of all motorcoach lots, thus lot owners and
their guest wil! walk or use golf carts or bicycles as their primary means of transportation throughout the
project rather than cars.
Staff Analysis and Recommendation: The petitioner wishes to utilize the allowance made for single-
and multi-family dcvelopments in LDC Section 4.05.04 as quoted below:
Where small-sca/e recreation facilities are accessory to a single-family or multifamily project
and intended only for the residents of that project, exclusive of golf courses/clubhouses, the
recreation facilities may be computed at 50 percent of normal requirements where the
majority of the dwelling units are not within 300 feet of the recreation facilities. _ . . . However,
any recreation facility shall have a minimum of 2 spaces exclusive of parking spaces.
Staff has no objection to this deviation as long as the project design provides parking for the alternative
means of transportation proposed by the petitioner, e.g., golf carts and bicycles that wil! not interfere
with open space, buffering or traffic movement. Staff, therefore has included stipulations to address this
issue in the recommendation.
The Master Plan has been designed to provide the two minimum parking spaces referenced in the
citation above. Zoning and Land Development Review staff has reviewed this deviation and
recommends APPROVAL with the stipulation that PUD Exhibit F (Developer Commitments) be revised
to include commitments by the developer to prohibit golf cali parking in any place other than a
designated parking space, and further the developer must provide designated bicycle parking areas at
each recreational amenitv. As stipulated, staff recommends that a finding be made in compliance with
Naples Motorcoach Resort CPUD, PUDZ-2006-AR-10648 October 18. 2007 CCPC
Page 9 of 14
Agenda Item No. 8.1',
November 27. 2007
Page 17 of 190
LDC Section 1O.02.13.A.3, that the petitioner has demonstrated that "the element may be waived
without a detrimental effect on the health, safety and welfare of the community" and LDC Section
10.02.13.B.5.h, the petitioner has demonstrated that the deviation is "justified as meeting public
pumoses to a degree at least equivalent to literal application of such regulations."
Deviation #3 seeks relief trom LDC Section 6.06.0 I that requires local roadways to provide a minimum
60 foot tight-of-way width, to allow a 24-foot right of way width for all project roadways except
project's Tamiami Trail entrance way.
Petitioner's Rationale: The justification for this deviation is that the proposed road tight-of:way will be
wide enough to accommodate the travel lanes, median (if applicable), drainage swales and utilities, and
shall otherwise conform to the Construction Standards Manual.
Staff Ana(vsis and Recommendation: Transportation Planning staff has not voiced opposition to this
deviation, therefore zoning staff does not object, however it needs to be clear that the roadways will be
private and the responsibility for maintenance will be borne by the developer. A commitment to this
effect needs to be added to Exhibit F. Zoning and Land Development Review staff therefore
recommends APPROVAL with the stipulation that PUD Exhibit F be revised as noted above. As
stipulated, staff recommends that a findinl: be made in compliance with LDC Section IO.02.13.A.3. that
the petitioner has demonstrated that "the element mav be waived without a dettimental effect on the
health, safety and welfare of the community" and LDC Section I Cl.02.13.B.5.h, the petitioncr has
demonstrated that the deviation is "iustified as meeting public pumoses to a degree atlcast equivalent to
literal application of such regulations."
Deviation #4 sceks relief from LDC Section 4.05.02.F. that requires off:street parking arcas to be
arranged so that no motor vehicle shall have to back onto any street.
Petitioner's Rationale: The justification for this deviation is to allow for limited parking for
recreational areas depicted on the CPUD Master Plan to back into the private tights-of-way. The
justification for this deviation is that the configuration of these areas is limited in their size and
configuration and as a result the required parking can be more easily acconmlodated with this deviation.
Furthermore, traffic volumes are low due to the nature of the proposed use because most patrons will
walk rather than dtive. Additionally speed limits will be posted at ten miles per hour. These factors
offset safety considerations and allow these limited parking areas to better serve the needs of the resort.
Staff Analysis and Recommendation: As noted in deviation #3, all project rights-of:way will be private
and maintained by the developer or an entity created by the developer such as a property owners'
association. As explained by the petitioner's agent, "traffic" will consist more of bicycles and golf carts
rather than conventional vehicles. Also, the petitioner states (above) that the maximum speed limit will
be posted at ten miles per hour. As such the county's concerns are lessened. However, PUD Exhibit F
needs to be revised to include the petitioner's commitment to limit and post the maximum speed at ten
miles per hour. With that stipulation, Zoning and Land Development Review staff recommends
APPROVAL, finding that, in compliance with LDC Section 10.02.13.A.3, the petitioner has
demonstrated that "the element may be waived without a detrimental effect on the health, safetv and
welfare of the community" and LDC Section 10.02.13.8.5.h, the petitioner has demonstrated that the
deviation is "justified as meeting public pumoses to a degree at least equivalent to literal application of
such regulations."
Naples Motorcoach Resort CPUD, PUDZ-2006-AR-10648 October 18, 2007 CCPC
Page 10 of 14
Aqenda 11em f\jo. 8A.
!\!ovember 27. 2007
Page 18 of 190
Deviation #5 seeks relief from LDC Section 4.06.02.C.4 that requires a 10 foot Type "D" buffer to
separate the road rights-of-way from the recreational areas.
Petitioner's Rationale: The petitioner's justification states the size and configuration of the recreational
area is small so requiring a I O-Ioot wide "buffer in these limited recreational areas adjacent to the
private road right-of-way would hinder the placement of needed parking for these areas."
Staff Analysis and Recommendation: It appears to staff that this deviation is being sought because the
petitioner wishes to maximize the development potential of the site. Omitting a buffer allows more
square footage of development on site. Unlike a variance, no land-related hardship needs to he
provided, however stalf is not convinced that it is appropriate to eliminate a required buffer where there
arc no considerations other than to provide the developer the ability to allow more square footage of
development. The developer could opt to reduce the size of the amenities or reduce the number of
motorcoaeh units. Deviations #2, #3. and #4 are all deviations designed to allow maximum
development of the site, however Deviation #1 docs have some amcliorating factor hecause the preserve
area is located across the creek, and deviations f,2 and #3 are acceptable if the stipulations proposed by
stalf are incorporated into any approval. However. Deviation #5 does not seem to have any puhlic
benefit other than to allow over-development of the silc. Stafr is not convinced that this deviation is
"justilied as meeting public purposes to a degree al least equivalent to literal application of such
regulations" (LDC Section 1(J.()2.13.B.5.h). It is starrs opinion thaI this deviation seems divergent li'om
the Coflier County path to require hulTering to (LDC Section 4.06.0 I ./\.):
1. Landscape Code. The purpose and intent of the landscape code is to:
a. Promote the health. safetv. and welfare of residents of Collier Countv by
establishing minimum uniform standards for the inslallation and mainlenance of
landscaping [underlining added by staff for emphasis};
b. Improve the aeslhetic appearance of commercial, industrial, and residential
developments through the requirement of minimum landscaping in ways that harmonize
the natural and built environment;
c. Promote preservation and planting of native plants and plant communities;
d. Provide physical and psychological benefits to persons through landscaping by
reducing noise and glare;
e. Screen and buffer the harsher visual aspects of urban development; [and}
g. Reduce heat gain in or on buildings or paved areas through the filtering capacity
of trees and vegetation.
The current bulfering requirements of the LDC have been adopted to promote the welfare of the
communitv as noted in the citation above. In staffs opinion, approval of this deviation is not in the best
interest of the welfare of the citizen of Collier Countv. Therefore, Zoning and Land Development
Review staff recommends DENIAL. finding that. in compliance with LDC Section W.02.13.A.3, the
petitioner has not demonstrated that "the element may be waived without a detrimental effect on the
health, safety and welfare of the communitv" and LDC Section I 0.02.13.8.5.h, the petitioner has not
demonstrated that the deviation is "justified as meeting public purposes to a degree at least equivalent to
literal application of such regulations."
Deviation #6 seeks relief from LDC Section 4.05.04, Table 17, from the boat ramp parking requirements
that require a minimum of 10 spaces per boat ramp, to eliminate all boat ramp parking spaces.
Naples Motorcoach Resort CPUD, PUDZ-2006-AR-10648 October 18, 2007 CCPC
Page 11 of 14
Agenda item No. 8A
November 27. 2007
Page 19 of 190
Petitioner's Rationale: The justification for this deviation is that no public access will be allowed to the
boat ramp and trailers will only be permitted to be stored in the boat storage building. Boats will only be
placed in the water using the forklift.
Staff Analysis and Recommendation: Staff has no objection to the concept to require all boats to be
stored in the boat storage facility and requiring all boats to be placed in the water via the facility-
provided fork lift. However, as noted previously in the staff report, Parks and Recreation staff has
concerns about the dry storage, as quoted from their comments, "the dry storage facility is a considerable
distance from the boat ramp [and] the forklift will necessarily be operating on the common road. This
poses a severe safety risk, particularly in light of the requcsted deviations in sidewalk and roadway
widths." Zoning staff can only support this deviation if the boat storage facility is rclocated closer to the
boat ramp. The developer most likely wishes to retain the creek ambiance so motorcoach lots will be
available for purchase lots along the creek; however the boat storage facility (along with the adjacent
recreation area if necessary) and the tennis courts could be exchanged as those uses are shown on the
master plan. That would reserve the waterfront for motorcoach units while still relocating the boat
storage facility closer to the boat ramp. Zoning and Land Development Review staff therefore
recommends APPROVAL with the stipulation that PUD Exhibit F be revised as noted above. As
stipulated. staff recommends that a finding be made in conmliance with LDC Section I 0.02.13.A.3. that
the petitioner [las demonstrated that "the element mav bc waived without a detrimental effect on the
health, safetv and welfare of the cOI1Ul1Unitv" and LDC Section 10.02.13.8.5.h. the petitioner has
demonstrated that the deviation is "justified as meeting public purposes to a degree at least equivalent to
literal application of such regulations."
NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING (NIM):
Synopsis provided by Linda Bedtelyon, Community Planning Coordinator; The agent/applicant duly
noticed and held the required NIM at Manatee Middle School on March 7, 2007, 7:00 p.m.
Approximately 50 neighboring property owners attended, along with the petitioner, his consultants and
county staff.
The applicant's team provided copies of severa! exhibits, including a Master Plan (Exhibit C), a Wall &
Landscape detail for boat storage building, (Exhibit C-l), a list of Requested Deviations from the LDC
(Exhibit E) and Development Commitments Specific to the Project (Exhibit F). The applicant and his
agents presented an overview of the proposal and addressed the following as summarized below:
. Q. Wall/buffering between site and adjacent residential property? A. "Constructing wall around
perimeter of site"
. Q. Lighting? A. "A light on every site is planned; no overhead street lighting"
. Q. Boat storage? A. "The southeast corner of the site will be used for boat storage; a 25 foot high
building will be constructed for dry boat storage, confined by an 8 foot wall; +/- 15 new boat docks to be
allowed;" boat trailer parking, for a maximum of 10 boats, will be provided for in the boat storage area.
. Q. Access/traffic impacts: "One access from US-41; limited access maintenance "road" on
Henderson Drive; access to be shifted to the east-Dn US-4] away from bridge and road improvements"
to be made by state or applicant based on County review.
. Q. Changes to and demolition of current structures on site: "current convenience store on property
to close on March 3 l, 2007; will put up temporary fence on west side of property dwing demolition."
Mr. Henderson went on to say he will compensate for demolition damage to neighboring propeliy
owners. "If you have been danlaged, you will be remedied."
Naples Motorcoach Resort CPUD, PUDZ-2006-AR-10648 October 18, 2007 CCPC
Page 12 of 14
.l>,genda Item No. SA
November 27. 2007
Page :20 of ~,90
· Q. Type of product: "Class A, 35 feet and longer motor coaches; rent or buy sites; 184 sites are
being planned at the present time but the CPUD will allow up to 200 units with a clubhouse and
amenities; no septic system in park. will be city sewer"
. The site will be under construction later this year.
Mr. Randall Henderson stated, "We want to reshict this property to motor-coach, six months occupancy
only according to the CPUD Ordinance; no other types will be permitted... there will be deed
restrictions".
RECOMMENDA TJON:
Zoning and Land Development Review staff recommends that the Collier County Planning Commission
(CCPC) forward Petition PUDZ-2006-AR-I0648 to the Board of County Commissioners (BCe) with a
rccommendation of denial because it is inconsistcnt with the GMP. The staff recommendation for denial
is largcly predicated on the determination that the location of the boat storage facility is incompatible
with the location proposed by the applicant.
However. conditions could be incorporated into the PliD Ordinancc that would adequately addrcss
staff's compatibility concems and thus resolvc the GMP inconsislcncy. These conditions are as f()llows:
The petitioner must revise PliO Exhibit F. Development Commitments. to rcflcctthe following:
1. Golf cart parking in any place other than a designated parking space is prohibited; and
2. The developer shall provide designated bicycle parking areas at each recreational amenity; and
3. Roadways will bc private and the responsibility for maintenance will be bome by the
developer; and
4. The developer shall limit and post the maximum speed at ten miles per hour; and
5. The development shall relocate the boat storage facility somewhere northwest of the lake
shown on the Master Plan. Said relocation shall be subject to staff review and approval as pmi
of the development order/platting process; and
6. Further expansion of boat facility shall be prohibited; and
7. Deviation # 5 is denied.
PREPARED BY:
KAY DESELEM, AICP, PRINCIPAL PLANNER
DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
DATE
Naples Motorcoach Resort CPUD. PUDZ-2006-AR-10648 October 18. 2007 CCPC
Page 13 of 14
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27.2007
Page 21 of 190
REVIEWED BY:
JEFFREY A. KLATZKOW
ASSISTANT COUNTY ATTORNEY
DATE
RA YMOND V. BELLOWS, ZONING MANAGER
DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
DATE
SUSAN M. ISTENES. AICP. DIRECTOR
DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
DATE
APPROVED BY;
JOSEPH K. SCHMITT ADMINISTRATOR DATE
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION
Tentatively scheduled for the November 27,2007 Board of County Commissioners Meeting
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION:
MARK P. STRAIN, CHAIRMAN
DATE
Exhibits; A. Rezone Findings
B. PUD Findings
Napies Motorcoach Resort CPUD, PUDZ-2006-AR-l0648 October 18, 2007 cepe
Page 14 of 14
Aoenda hem No SA
N~ovember 27. 2'007
Page 22 of '190
Exhibit A
REZONE FINDINGS
PETITION PUDZ-2006-AR-10648
Chapter 1O.03.05.G of the Collier County Land Development Code (LDC) requires that the repOli and
recommendations of the Planning Commission to the Board of County Commissioners show that the
Planning Commission has studied and considered the proposed change in relation to the following,
where applicable:
1. Whether the proposed change will be consistent with the goals, objectives, and policies of
the Futnre Land Use Element (FLUE) and Future Land Use Map (FLUM) and the
elements of the Growth Management Plan (GMP).
Pro: County stalf has reviewed this petition and has offered an in-depth analysis (see staff
report) ofthc relevant goals, objectives and policies of the FLUE, the Conservation and Coastal
Management Element, and the Transportation Element of the (IMP offering a recommendation
that this petition be [()und inconsistent with the overall GMP unless staWs recommendation
regarding the boat storage Cacilit)', is incoqx)]"(ltcd into the approval.
Con: The proposed location of the hoat storage facility is inconsistent with FLUE Policy 5.4.
Findin~s: Based upon staffs rcvicw. the proposed development is not in compliance with the
FLUE of the GMP le)r Collier County and all other relevant goals, objectives and policies ofthe
GMP unless staffs recommcndations regarding the boat storage facility are incorporated into
the approval.
2. The existing land use pattern.
Pro: The explanation of the request in the staffrepOli and the location and zoning map that is
attached to the staff report show the proposed development does not leave any remnant parcels.
The proposed rezoning can be accommodated with the existing land use patterns; however
there are no guarantees that the site will acconm10date the maximum development proposed.
Con: The church located along the opposite side of Henderson Drive, another non-residential
use, is set back almost 7 times the distance proposed for uses along Henderson Drive in this
petition.
Findings: Land use patterns are influenced by several key factors such as land ownership,
water feature locations, such as the Henderson Creek, and roadway locations such as US 41 and
Henderson Drive. Also affecting land use patterns are the developer's own site plan proposal.
As noted above, the existing land use pattern along this section of Henderson Drive seems to
indicate that an increased setback would be more in keeping with the existing land use pattern.
As noted in the staff report, the "conventional" TTRVC zoning district requires a 50-foot
setback from an external street; this project only proposes a IS-foot stlUctural setback from
Henderson Drive. The petitioner proposes to follow established property boundaries of a
previously developed site.
Page 1 of 6
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27. 2007
Page 23 of 190
3. The possible creation of an isolated district nnrelated to adjacent and nearby districts.
Pro: This rezone proposes uses somewhat similar to other uses in the area in that the
surrounding developments consist of mobile homes rather than "stick-built" homes. Both the
mobile homes and the motorcoach units are mobile in nature, but the comparison is slight.
Mobile homes are considered residential dwelling units; motorcoach units are commercial
"units."
Con: The nearby mobile home units are residential units of more long term duration while the
proposed motor coach units are clearly transient units of a commercial nature.
Findings: This petition does not create an isolated district because a p01iion of the subject
parcel is cUlTently zoned TTRYC, which would allow development similar to what is proposed.
4. Whether existing district boundaries are illogically drawn in relation to existing
conditions on thc property proposed for change.
Pro: The existing and proposed district boundaries tallow existing property ownership, water,
and roadway boundaries which appear logical.
Con: Evaluation not applicable.
Findinl!s: The district boundaries are logically drawn as discussed above.
5. Whether changed or changing conditions make the passage of the proposed land use
change necessary.
Pro: The proposed change is not necessary, per se; it is being requested in compliance with the
LDC allowances to seek such changes.
Con: The subject tract could be developed in compliance with the existing zoning districts'
uses and development standards. It is the petitioner's choice to seek the proposed action.
Findings: The proposed zoning change would allow what appears to be an appropriate
redevelopment of the site, however there is no evidence to support that changed or changing
conditions make the approval of this petition necessary.
6. Whether the proposed change will adversely influence living conditions in the
neighborhood.
Pro: The proposed CPUD rezone will not adversely affect living conditions in the area because
staff believes the uses proposed will be compatible with the existing land use in the
surrounding area if staff s recommendation regarding the boat storage facility is incorporated
into the approvaL
EXHIBIT A
Rezone Findings
PUDZ-2006-AR-l0648
Page 2 of 6
Agenda item No. SA
November 27.2007
Page 24 of 190
Con: As discussed extensively in the staff repOli, staff believes the project design citing the
boat storage facility along the project perimeter is externalizing one of the tallest, most massive
structures rather than internalizing this more intense element of the project. The proposed
structure is proposed to be located within a minimal setback distance from the public's roadway
thus the structure is oriented to have the most impact upon the traveling public rather than the
least impact.
Findin~s: The development proposes adequate landscaping, setbacks and buffering for the
motor home lot layout component of this development but not for the boat storage facility. The
County's land use policies that are reflected by the Future Land Use Element of the GMP
support placing this development at this location only if staff's recommendation regarding the
boat storage facility is incorporated into the approval.
7. Whether the proposed change will create or cxcessively increase traffic congestion or
create types of traffic deemed incompatible with surrounding land uses because of peak
volumes or projected types of vehicular traffic, including activity during construction
phases of the development,or otherwise affect public safety.
Pro: Development of the subject propcJiy is consistent with provisions of the Transportation
Element of the GMP because thc proposed motorcoach units will not bring additional vehicular
trips to this area since thc TranspOJiation counts the trips fromthc previous mohile home, travel
trailer and convenience store uses as "background trips, thercfore this project's development
will result in a net reduction of 65 PM Peak Hour. Peak Direction trips when compared to the
preVIOUS uses.
Con: The nearby mobile home uses are deemed to be residential in nature while the proposed
motorcoach resort is a commercial use. The neighbors could perceive this to be an
incompatible use.
findings: Evaluation of this project took into account the requirement for consistency with the
Traffic Element of the GMP and the project was found consistent. Additionally, certain
transportation improvements are included in the PUD document.
8. Whether the proposed change will create a drainage problem.
Pro: Road improvements precipitated by this development and water management
improvements to accommodate site development will be designed in compliance with the
requirements of the LDC.
Con: Urban intensification (undeveloped [applicable now because the mobile home use has
been disbanded] vs. developed) could potentially increase area-wide flooding in a severe
rainfall event.
Findings: Evel)' project approved in Collier County involving the utilization of land for some
land use activity is scrutinized and required to mitigate all sub-surface drainage generated by
developmental activities.
EXHIBIT A
Rezone Findings
PUDZ-2006-AR-l0648
Page 3 016
Agenda Item I~o. SA
November 27, 2007
Page 25 of 190
9. Whether the proposed change will seriously reduce light and air to adjacent areas.
Pro: The proposed development standards will ensure that adequate light and air is allowed to
adjacent properties.
Con: None.
Findings: All projects in Collier County are subject to the development standards that are
unique to the zoning district in which it is located. These development standards and others
apply generally and equally to all zoning districts (i.e. open space requirement, corridor
management provisions, etc.) were designed to ensure that light penetration and circulation of
air does not adversely affect adjacent areas.
10. Whether the proposed change will adversely affect property valnes in the adjacent area.
Pro/Con: Evaluation not applieable.
Findings: This is a subjective detennination based upon anticipated results which may bc
intcrnal or extel11al to tbe subject property, and which can affect property values. Property
valuation is affected by a host of factors including zoning; however, zoning by itself mayor
may not affect values, since value determination by law is drivcn by market value. The mere
fact that a property is givcn a new zoning designation mayor may not affect value.
11. Whether the proposed change will be a deterrent to the improvement or development of
adjacent property in accordance with existing regulations.
Pro/Con: Evaluation not applicable.
Findings: The basic premise underlying all of the development standards in the Land
Development Code is that their sound application, when combined with the site development
plan approval process and/or subdivision process, gives reasonable assurance that a change in
zoning will not result in deterrence to improvement or development of adjacent propeliy.
12. Whether the proposed change will constitute a grant of special privilege to an individual
owner as contrasting with the public welfare.
Pro/Con: Evaluation not applicable.
Findings: The proposed development complies with the GMP, a public policy statement
supporting zoning actions when they are consistent with said GMP, with the conditions
recommended by staff. In light of this fact, the proposed change does not constitute a grant of
special privilege. Consistency with the FLUE is further determined to be a public welfare
relationship because actions consistent with plans are in the public interest.
EXHIBIT A
Rezone Findings
PUDZ-2006-AR-l0648
Page 4 of 6
,A,genda Item No, 8b\
t\!ovember 27, 2007
F1age 26 of -: 90
13. Whether there are snhstantial reasons why the property cannot be used in accordance
with existing zoning.
Pro: The subject site was developed with a mobile home park and a convenience store within
the respective existing zoning distlicts that allowed those uses. The site could be redeveloped
in a similar fashion if so desired. The petitioner has opted to seek this rezoning to allow a
different use of this site, seeking rezoning is an allowable action of the LDC.
Con: None.
Findings: Any petition l()r a change in land use is reviewed fllr compliance with the GMP and
the LDC with the Board of County Commissioners ultimately ruling what uses and density or
intensity is approved or. on the contrary, if the petition is denied. This petitioner is proceeding
through the proper channels to gamer tbat Board ruling.
14. Whether the change suggested is out of scale with the Deeds of the neighborhood or the
County;
Pro: Stall believes this petition proposes changes that seem to be within the scale of the nccds
of the neighborhood and County if stairs stipulations are adopted.
Con: None.
Findin~s: With the stipulations recommended hy stan~ the proposed development complies
with the GMP, a poliey statement which has evaluated the scale, density and intensity of land
uses deemed to he acceptable throughout the urban designated areas of Collicr County.
15. Whether it is impossible to find other adequate sitcs in the County for the proposed use in
districts already permitting such use.
Pro/Con: Evaluation not applicable.
Findings: Each zoning petition is reviewed on its own merit for compliance with the GMP and
the LDC; and staff does not review other sites in conjunction with a specific petition.
16. The physical characteristics of the property and the degree of site alteration which would
be required to make the property usahle for any of the range of potential uses under the
proposed zoning classification.
Pro: None perceived.
Con: The site will require extensive alteration to develop the use proposed.
Findings: Any development of this site for the proposed use would require considerable site
alteration.
EXHIBIT A
Rezone Findings
PUDZ-2006-AR-l0648
Page 5 of 6
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27, 2007
Page 27 of 190
17. The impact of development on the availability of adequate public facilities and services
consistent with the levels of service adopted in the Collier Connty Growth Management
Plan and as defined and implemented through the Collier Connty LDC regarding
Adequate Public Facilities.
Pro/Con: Evaluation not applicable.
Findings: A multi-disciplined team responsible for reviewing jurisdictional elements of the
GMP and the LDC public facilities requirements has reviewed this land use petition and found
it consistent and in compliance for zoning approval. A final determination whether this project
meets the full requirements of adequate public facilities specifications will be detennined as
part of the development approval process.
EXHIBIT A
Rezone Findings
PUDZ-2006-AR-l0648
Page 6 of 6
Agenda item t\io. 81:,
November 27. 2007
Page 28 of 190
Exhibit B
PUD FINDINGS
PUDZ-2006-AR-10648
Section 1 O.02.l3.B.5 of the LDC of the Collier County Land Development Code requires the Planning
Commission to make a finding as to the PUD Mastcr Plan's compliance with the following criteria:
1. The snitability of the area for the type and pattern of development proposed in relation
to physical characteristics of the land, surronnding areas, traffic and access, drainage,
sewer, water, and other utilities.
Pro: The ncarby area is developed or is approved for development of a compatible nature.
The petitioner will be required to comply with all county rcgulations regarding drainage.
sewer. water and other utilities.
Con: As discussed at length in the stafT report, the proposed location of the boat storage
facility is not suitable in relationship to the sUlTound areas.
Findin[(: The commitments and limitations included in the PliO document and the
additional stipulations proposed by staff will adequately address the impacts (i'om the
proposed rezoning.
2. Adequacy of evidence of unified control and suitability of any proposed agreements,
contracts, or other instruments, or for amendments in those proposed, particularly as
they may relate to arrangements or provisions to be made for the continuing operation
and maintenance of such areas and facilities that are not to be provided or maintained
at public expense.
Pro/Con: Evaluation not applicable.
Finding: Documents submitted with the application provided evidence of unified control.
The LDC and the PUD documents contain provisions for continuing operation and
maintenance of the proposed pIivate roadways and common areas.
3. Conformity of the proposed Planned Unit Development with the goals, objectives, and
policies of the Growth Management Plan (GMP).
Pro: County staff has reviewed this petition and has offered an analysis (see staff report) of
the relevant goals, objectives and policies of the GMP offering a recommendation that this
petition be found consistent with the overall GMP if staffs stipulation to require the
relocation of the boat storage facility is adopted.
Con: Staffs analysis is subjective. Many of the goals, objective and policies do no have
quantative means to measure compliance. The GMP Transportation Element Policies 5.1
and 5.2 contain measurable components; however, FLUE Policy 5.4 does not.
Compatibility is more subjective.
Page 1 of 3
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27.2007
Page 29 of 190
Finding; Staff has recommended fhat the subject petition has been found consistent with the
goals, objectives and policies of the GMP as provided for in fhe adopting ordinance if staff's
stipulation to require the relocation of the boat storage facility is adopted. Please see the
staff report for a more detailed discussion.
4. The internal and external compatibility of proposed uses, which conditions may
include restrictions on location of improvements, restrictions on design, and bnffering
and screening requirements.
Pro: None
Con: The proposed development standards. landscaping and buffering requirements do not,
in staff's opinion, make the proposed development compatible with the adjacent uses. As
noted in the staff report, the existing church located across Henderson Drive sets back from
the road right-of-way approximately 100 feet. The proposed boat storage facility is
proposed to setback only 15 feet from the Henderson Drive right-of~way. Staff believes this
proximity is inappropriate. Additional setback could ameliorate the boat storage facility's
impact, but a bettcr alternative would be to totally relocate the facility more interior to thc
project. It seems more logical to place a boat storage facility closer to (he creek where the
boats will be used. It seems that the applicant may be wishing to retain the aesthetically
pleasing view oftbe water for the project's lot owners at the expense of the traveling public
who get no benefit from the facility. The petitioner is siting the most obnoxious element of
the project where it will have the least impact upon those persons who will have the most
benefit from the facility. This is contrary to good planning practice regarding
externalizing/internalizing impacts, as noted above.
Finding: This petition is incompatible, both internally and externally, with the surrounding
uses unless the storage facility is relocated on site.
5. The adeqnacy of usable open space areas in existence and as proposed to serve the
development.
Pro/Con: Evaluation not applicable.
Finding: The amount of open space set aside by this project is consistent wifh the
provisions of the Land Development Code however the property development regulations
proposed do allow the project to be developed quite intensely given the requested
deviations.
6. The timing or sequence of development for the purpose of assuring the adequacy of
available improvements and facilities, both public and private.
Pro/Con: Evaluation not applicable.
Finding; Timing or sequence of development in light of concurrency requirements does not
appear to be a significant problem as part of the PUD rezoning process, but the project's
PUD FINDINGS
PUDA-2006-AR-I0648
EXHIBIT B
Page 2 of 3
,i\genda item No. 3A
November 27.2007
Page 30 of '190
development must be in compliance with applicable concurrency management regulations
when development approvals are sought.
7. The ability of the subject property and of surrounding areas to accommodate
expansion.
Pro: County Transportation Division Planning staff has determined that the proposed
rezoning is consistent with the GMP Transportation Element requirements addressing
roadway concerns.
Con: None.
Findin~: I f "ability" implies supporting infrastructure such as wastewater disposal system,
potable waleI' supplies. characteristics of the property relative to hazards, and capacity of
roads, then the subject propcny has the ability to suppClli cxpansion based upon the
commitmer ts made by the petitioner and the fact that adequate public facilities requirements
will be ad(i~ssed when development approvals are sought.
ll. Conform; ty with PliO r'egulations. or as to desirable modifications of sucb regulations
in the p:crticular case, based Oil determination that such modifications are jllstified as
meetin" public purposes to a degree at least equivalent to Iiter'al application of sueh
regulations.
Pro: The petitioner is seeking six dcviations to allow design flexibility in compliance with
the PUlvose and intent of thc Planned Unit Development Districts (LDC Section 2JJ3.06A)
Con: Without additional stipulations Deviations #1, 2, 3, #4 and #6 would not be
supportable. There are no stipulations that would make Deviation #5 supportable; staff is
recommending Denial of Deviation #5.
Finding: This criterion essentially requires an evaluation of the extent to which
development standards and deviations proposed for this PUD depart from development
standards that would be required for the most similar conventional zoning district. With the
exception of Deviation #5 that staff does not support, staff believes, as stipulated, the
deviations proposed can be suppOlied, finding that, in compliance with LDC Section
IO.02.13.A.3, the petitioner has demonstrated that "the elements may be waived without a
detrimental effect on the health, safety and welfare of the community" and LDC Section
I O.02.13.B.5.h, the petitioner has demonstrated that the deviations are 'justified as meeting
public purposes to a degree at least equivalent to literal application of such regulations."
PUD FINDINGS
PUDA-2006-AR-I0648
EXHIBIT B
Page 3 of 3
<(c-.o
.Z<~;':'
~---
_ 0
=(-,J;:;
S!::QiQ)
~.,CJ)
C1:-::: CI:i
""Q ID CL
::;-:>
6.~
<L..
<:
o
"
~
~
Q 1;
=> 0 ~
a. "
~
.
z
o
w-
1-1<
iiio
g
.
o
~
"
~
m
g~
Ci;. ""
o
J
~
---+-
l-.~-
I
~Cl.l-.LDtI,I ~
.
"
a..
<(
~
(!)
Z
Z
o
N
'"
"
'"
0>
~
"'
""
'"
0>
0>
N
N
o
::>
0..
'It
Z
o
f-
f-
Ul
0..
a..
<(
~
z
o
-!
I-
<(
U
o
.....J
Florida Department of
Environmental Protection
Agenda Item 1'-)0. SA
I-Jovember 27 2007
PagO:iriie <Qj;t$l
Governor
Rookery Bay National E!">tuarine Res€'archR(~,'ierve
300 Tower Road
Naples, Florida 34113
(239) 417-6310, Pax (239) 417-6315
JeffKotlkamp
Lt. Governor
Michael W. Sole
Secretary
May 30, 2007
Kay Deselem
Collier County Development Services
2800 North Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
RE: PUDZ-2006-AR-10648 - Naples Motorcoach Resort PUD
Staff have reviewed the abovc,:, n..:-kn~)iCed application, Outlined hplo\,v arc comnlents that
Rookery Bay National Estuarine Research Res"rve (RDNERR) has concerning this project,
located adjacent to the ReSf!rv~.
We believe that the proposed development may negatively impact the primary goals of
RBNERR. RBNElm. is one of the few remaining pristine mangrove estuaries in North America.
Over the past three decades, on behalf of taxpayers across the State, the Department of
Environmental Protection has spent over 57 million dollars to pll1'chase lands within RBNERR
to protect and conserve coastal wetlands for future generations to enjoy. The proposed
development will sustain anthropogenic disturbance in the area, and boating activities
associated with this project may impact aquatic resources, and we have concerns about
secondary and cumulative impacts to adjacent estuarine ecosystem within RBNERR.
In order to protect the long-term ecosystem integrity of RBNERR we believe first consideration
in determining permitted potential impacts to aquatic resources should be avoidance and
minimization. The applicant has not provided sufficient information that the design of the
proposed dry storage facility has taken steps to use a voidance and minimization to lessen
permanent impacts on aquatic resources nor provided any compensatory mitigation plan.
1. Dry Storage Facility
Tbe proposed development is located adjacent to Rookery Bay Aquatic Preserve/RBNERR, and
we believe that the dry storage aspect of the project should be reviewed by Florida Deparhnent
of Environmental Protection Submerged Lands and Environmental Resources Program. Despite
the assertion by the applicants agent within submittal documents, there is no guarantee that a
new ill'y storage facility will not increase the number of boats accessing RBNERR from the
project site as well as alter the type of boats that use the area. Any new boat ramp 01' docks
associated witl1 this property would require an Environmental Resource Permit (ERP), and the
proposed new dry storage facility should also be subject to the ERP review process.
RECEIVED
Pirro/eel. CO/7SenT {flld k/aJla:2c Florida '.1 Em'irulltJ/CI.'I {Inti :Valurat' RCSOIII'(.'CS(I
.'More Pmtecliol1, Less Process"
It'Wl1 '. dC/i,:> /(/ le..!l.lls
JUN 0 6 2007
ZONING DEPARTMENT
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27. 2007
Page 33 of 190
2. Water Qualily
The proposed project may have impacts on water quality both during construction and once
constructed. Since this project area is within the Outstanding Florida Waters (OFW, Chapter 62-
302.700, Florida Administration Code) of the RBNERR and Rookery Bay Aquatic Preserve,
maintaining high water quality is of utmost importance. OFW designation requires that water
quality not be degraded beyond ambient conditions at the time of designation. The pmposed
project has not provided reasonable assurance of compliance with water quality criteria relating
to protecting existing ambient water quality. II is recommended that the water management
system should be designed to meetSF\'\'MD Outstanding Florida Waters design critteria.
Regulatory staff should also ensure the use of Best Management Practices to minlmize any
impacts on water quality during proposed project (e.g. properly secured turbidity screens
around the entire project area, no spilling of gas or oil). In addition, there shOll Id be no
maintenance 01' fish clearilllg allowed a lthe subject property, as we]] as no grease/ oil/ gas
runoff from the moored boat(8). All activities within the proposed project should be consistent
with the "Clean Boating }-IabitsJf as outlined in the "Clean lviarill.a" brochure.
;. Lllited Species Protection
The significance of the animal life ill RBNERR area was an important factor in the designation
as an Aquatic Preserve. Management objectives for thc fauna within the i\BNERR is focused on
their protection, through preservation or restoration of nahlral habitats within the area.
Manatees are known to frequent Henderson Creek, and potential impacts to manatees from
activities associated with this permit should be addressed.
The principal threat to manatees is boat h'affic in essential h'avel corridors and feeding areas,
resting areas, wann-water refuges, and freshwater sources. Manatees use Henderson Creek area
year-round as a feeding and resting area. The presence of boats in the area will degrade
manatee habitat as well as increase the probability of manatee deaths resulting from boat
collision. Improved boater education is also needed and can be enhanced through programs
developed to increase public awareness of the damage that boats can inflict on manatees,
including additional signage regarding the protection of manatees and related speed zones.
4. Secondary and Cumulative Impacts
The open waters and channels of the RBNERR area are shallow, averaging less than 3 feet in
depth. Improved boater education is also needed and can be enhanced through programs
developed to increase public awareness of the damage that boats can inflict on shallow water
communities, including additional signage regarding the protection of seagrass beds and tidal
flats.
5. Please re-initiate the consultation process with RBNERR if modification to project arises.
This staff assessment is preliminary and is designed to assist in the review of the application
prior to final agency action. The comments provided herein are not the final position of the
Department and may be subject to revision pursuant to additional information and further
review.
Prill/cd 0/1 recycled paper.
,A.genda Item No. 8.A.
November 27. 2007
Page 34 of 190
If I Cal1 be of further assistance, plea"e do not hesitate to contact me. Thank you for the
opportunity to comment.
gztXO
RBNERR Resource Management Coordinator
cc:
Robert Duane, [ lole Montes, Tnc.
Mark Mi1ler, FDEP SLERr'
Skip Bergmann, USACOE
Ed Cl'Onyn, SFWMD
Skip Bergmann, US Army Cmps of Engineers (SA) 2000-10(2)
Steven [.enbp.nrerl Collier Count'\-' Environmental Services
u "
Tad Hartareau, RBNERR Environnlental Specialist
Primed 011 rC'cycled pnper.
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27, 2007
Page 35 of 190
MANATEE PROTECTION PLAN SUMMARY
FOR
NAPLES MOTOR COACH RESORT
Prepared for
Mr. Randall Henderson
Updated
JULY 20, 2007
PREPARED BY:
----
.-
TURRELL & ASSOCIATES, INC.
3584 EXCHANGE A VE!':UE, SUITE B
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104
TELEPHONE: (239) 643-0166
FAX: (239) 643-6632
Aaenda !tern r\Jo 8/i.,
t~~ovember 27, 2007
Naples Motor CoaE'lrrJklfiJfl190
Manatee Protection Plan Review
Revised .July 20, 2007
I. INTRODUCTION
This summary analysis was prepared to provide information to Collier County reviewers
in relation to the proposed construction of a boat storage area on Henderson Creek
immediately south of U.S. 41. The storage area would be a part of the proposed
redevelopment of the existing mobile home park to an upscale motor coach resort.
Specifically, we have examined the shoreline and benthic habitats along that stretch of
the creek, we have looked at the known boat related manatee mortality information, and
we have looked at the waterway leading from the building out to the Gulf of Mexico.
The results to date of our findings are described in the f()lIowing report.
The project is located in Section 3, Township 5 I South. Range 26 East. Collier County. It
lies in the southeast quadrant of the L.S 41 Bridge over Henderson Creek, about 1 mile
east of the U.S 41 and CR 951 intersection. The property is approximately 22 acres of
which all of it was devcloped mobile home sites but all of the mobile homes havc been
removed and the entire site has been cleared and is cUlTcntly under construction
(cm1hmoving and sorting).
The propeny has ,iust ovcr 1000 fect of shorelinc. which is sodded. Several rcd
mangroves mixed in \\'ith Brazilian pepper were scattered along the shoreline and
fourteen (14) small doeks had bcen prcsent behind trailers. A staging dock associated
with the existing community boat ramp was also present. This ramp was located adjaecnt
to the boat ramp ncar the ccntcr of the projcct and was available for use to the entire
community (approximately 290 residences). It appears that in thc course of the site
clearing activities; the docks and shoreline vegetation have been recently removed.
Shoreline vegetation removed includes the Brazilian pepper, citrus trees, bougainvillea,
ficus trees, and assorted other landscape plants. A couple of mangroves (one red and one
white) were damaged during the dock and Brazilian pepper removal but the rest of the
shoreline mangroves were undisturbed. The ramp is still in place.
II. PROJECT DESCRIPTION
The proposed project is a conversion of an existing mobile home park into a motor coach
/ recreational vehicle park. As stated above, there were fourteen (14) residential docks
behind mobile homes as well as a community boat ramp with an associated staging dock.
The below descriptions are limited to the proposed boat utilization associated with the
project.
Private Docks
Under the proposal, the owners of the lots along the creek will have the option of
permitting small docks for their private use. In addition, a staging dock for the ramp will
also be constructed. A total of 26 private docks and one community dock (27 total
docks) would result.
Agenda Item No. 8.1\
November 27.2007
Naples Motor CoaE'hrRiiibfitl 190
Manatee Protection Plan Review
Revised July 20, 2007
Boat Ramp
Also proposed, as part of this plan, is a conversion of the existing boat ramp. The
applicant is proposing to construct a boat storage arca on the propeliy that will house up
to 36 vessels and provide storagc space for an additional ] 0 boat trailers. The existing
ramp may be modified to accommodate the proposed lift that will be used to transport the
vessels from the storage building to the water. Only the vessels kept in the storage area
and the 26 private vessels along the creek will be allowed the use of the ramp. This will
result in a substantial decrease from the past conditions of over 290 potential users of the
ramp.
Shoreline
The applicant is considcring installation of a retaining wall along the shoreline of the
propeliy. According to the description provided, this wall will be located landward of
the Mean High Water line, will not impact any mangroves, and will not involve dredgc o!"
fill of wetlands. As such, it will scrve to minimize the potential [e)!" siltation or erosion
from the developmcnt into the creek and will help to maintain the shoreline integrity.
Since no wetlands or mangroves will be impacted, this retaining wall will have no impact
on the shoreline aspect of the Manatee Protection Plan revicw.
III. MANATEE PLAN PARAMETERS
'\later Depths
A celiified survey of the shoreline depths has not been conducted but during the benthic
survey it was clear that there are areas where water depths are less than four feet deep. It
is also known that there arc shallows / shoals between the project and the Gulf of Mexico
that have less than four feet of water at low tides.
Shoreline Resources
In order to assess shoreline resources, an assessment dive was conducted. The basic
objective of the dive was to investigate the area for benthic habitats that could potentially
be impacted by the proposed project. We looked at water depths, water clarity, and for
the presence of seagrasses, marine algae, or oysters. This survey was updated on May 9,
2007 to verify the continued existence of the resources previously observed.
The survey consisted of an observer on the boat and a diver in the water. Shallow water
depths (<8 feet) allowed us to snorkel to transects. We dove both parallel and
perpendicular to the shoreline while investigating the bottom.
The dive turned up a patch of scattered seagrasses along the shoreline. One small patch
of Widgeon Grass (Ruppia maritima) was observed along one area of the shoreline from
the water's edge to about 3 to 5 feet out from the shore. Most likely, this is as deep as it
can grow in this area and still get enough light. During the first survey, there was a lot of
water coming over the weir on the north side of U.S. 41 and between the foam from the
churned water, and the suspended sediments in the water, light penetration (approx 3') as
2
."genda Item No.8."
November 27.2007
Naples Motor CoaE1frRilmtt: 190
Manatee Protection Plan Review
Revised July 20, 2007
well as visibility (approx. 18") was limited. The grass density was sparse and varied
between 2 and 15 percent. The majority of the shoreline had no grasses and no other
quality benthic resources were observed. There were no grasses observed around the
existing boat ramp. During the most recent survey, no water was coming over the weir
but visibility was still very limitcd.
The proposed site plan indicates that there arc 3 lots whose docks could potentially affect
the seagrasses. The extent of the seagrasses observed during the dives was approximately
140 feet along the shoreline extending about 3 to 5 feet out from the shore. We believe
that the access walkways for the docks would impact no more than 9 square feet but this
will have to bc re-assesscd. as pali of the permitting that will occur immediately prior to
any construction.
An exhibit depicting the shoreline dive transects and the area where seagrasses were
observed is included {()!" rcview.
Manatee Mortalitv
The Florida Fish and Wildlife Cunservation Commission (FFWCC) database indicates
that therc have been 130 manatce deaths in Collier County between April 1974 and
December 2006. which are directly attributable to boat impacts. Of thesc, fifteen of them
12')0) have occulTed within livc miles of the project site. Since less than 20% of the
boat rclated deaths within the county have occulTed within 5 miles of thc project site, this
site would not be considered to be within a high manatee use area.
An exhibit depicting the location of the boat related manatee deaths is included for
reV1CW.
IV. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The existing ramp is essentially a "use-as-you-will" ramp with little to no supervision or
boater education. As part of the renovation, a proper management plan should be created
to maintain the marina in up-to-date condition and with most current BMPs in place. In
addition to the management plan, an education program should be developed (preferably
in conjunction with Rookery Bay NERR staff) with infCllmation on manatees, seagrasses,
and the local waterways for patrons of the building. This would add a level of protection
to local resources by informing the boaters of easily defined do's and don'ts in our local
waters.
Due to the width of the waterway and the water depths associated with the project, dock
lengths should be limited to 20 feet. Either perpendicular or parallel mooring is possible
at the site except for those three lots where seagrasses are present. At those lots, only
parallel mooring should be permitted outside of the seagrass footprint. When the
homeowners apply for their dock permits, a benthic survey should be conducted to
3
.-\genda Item No. SA
November 27 2007
Naples Motor CoaE'Tfrltiir'9ft 190
Manatee Protection Plan Review
Revised July 20, 2007
detelmine if the seagrass coverage has expanded. If the proposed dock will affect
seagrasses, then parallel mooring should he proposed outside of the seagrass footprint.
According to the analysis, this property should be classified with a moderate ranking
under the Collier County Manatee Protection Plan. The intended use should not impact
5% of the existing shoreline or benthic resources and it is in a low manatee use area, but
the depths out to the Gulf are less than 4 feet in some places. With a moderate ranking,
the property would be allowed ] 0 slips per] 00 feet of shoreline or approximately ] 10
slips. The moderate ranking also allows for the expansion of existing hoat ramps or dry
storage building but prohibits the construction of new ramps or dry storage huilding. The
Manatee Protection Plan does not address the conversion of a boat ramp to a storage
building but the applicant's opinion is that such a conversion should be consistent with
the intent of the Manatee Protection Plan as long as the intensity of use is not expanded.
In this case, the use would decrease from over 100 vessels using the ramp to a maximum
of 73 vessels including the single-family docks and the proposed storage area. However,
this is not specifically addressed in the Plan and will he up to staif and legal
interpretations.
Tbe proposed project would allow a maximum of 26 private wet slips, a staging dock for
the ramp, storage for 10 boat trailers, and 36 vessels. This is substantially under the
current potential use by all 293 residents and also substantially lower that the 110 wet
slips that could be allowed under the Manatee Protection Plan.
4
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27, 2007
Page 40 of '90
Signs were installed Sat.,Sept. 29, 2007
East Trail Frontage
Henderson Dr Frontage
Agenda Item No. 8/,
November 27.2007
Page 41 of 190
ORDINANCE NO. 2007._
AN ORDINANCE OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA,
AMENDING ORDINANCE NUMBER 2004-41, AS
AMENDED, THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND
DEVELOPMENT CODE WHICH INCLUDES THE
COMPREHENSIVE ZONING REGULATIONS FOR THE
UNINCORPORATED AREA OF COLLIER COUNTY,
FLORIDA, BY AMENDING THE APPROPRIATE ZONING
ATLAS MAP OR MAPS, BY CHANGING THE ZONING
CLASSIFICATION OF THE HEREIN DESCRffiED REAL
PROPERTY FROM THE MOBILE HOME, TRAVEL
TRAILER RECREATIONAL VEHICLE CAMPGROUND,
AND HEAVY COMMERCIAL ZONING DISTRICTS (MH,
TTRVC & C-5) TO THE COMMERCIAL PLANNED UNIT
DEVELOPMENT DISTRICT (CPUn) FOR A PROJECT TO
BE KNOWN AS THE NAPLES MOTORCOACH RESORT
LOCATED ON THE SOUTHWEST SIDE OF TAMIAMI
TRAIL EAST, APPROXIMATELY THREE QUARTERS OF
A MILE EAST OF ISLE OF CAPRI, IN SECTION 3,
TOWNSHIP 51 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST, COLLIER
COUNTY, FLORIDA, CONSISTING OF 23.2 ACRES; ANn
BY PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, Robert L. Duane, AICP, of HoleMOJlle~, Inc., representing Naples
Motorcoach Resort, Inc., petitioned the Board of County Commissioners to change the zoning
classifjcation of the herein described real property.
NOW. THEREFORE. BE IT ORDAINED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that:
SECTION ONE:
The zoning classification of the herein described real property located in Section 3,
Township 51 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida, is changed from the Mobile Home,
Travel Trailer Recreational Vehicle Campground, and Heavy Commercial Zoning Districts (MH,
TTRVC, & C-5) to the Commercial Planned Unit Development District (CPUD) for a project to
be known as the Naples Motorcoach Resort in accordance with the Exhibits attached hereto as
Exhibits A through F and incorporated by reference herein. The appropriate zoning atlas map or
maps. as described in Ordinance Number 2004-41, as amended, the Collier County Land
Development Code, is/are hereby amended accordingly.
SECTION TWO
This Ordinance shall become effective upon filing with the Department of State.
.4.geneja item r-~o. SA
November 27. 2007
Page 42 of 190
PASSED AND DULY ADOPTED by a super-majority vote of the Board of County
Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, this _ day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
By: ~
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY. FLORIDA
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as La form
an Ie . suf i iency:
Jeff Y A. Kla
M' ging Ass
Exhibit A:
Exhibit B:
Exhibit C:
Exhihit D:
Exhibit E:
Exhibit F:
'ow
ant County Attorney
List of i\llowabJe Uses
Commercial Devclopmen: Standards
Master Plan, tbree-page ,<;et of plans
Legal Description
List of Requested Deviations
Development Cormllltmems Specific 10 the Project
.Agenda Item No. SA
November 27. 2007
Page 43 of 190
EXHIBIT A
NAPLES MOTORCOACH RESORT CPUD
ALLOWABLE USES
PERMITTED USES:
No building or structure, or part thereof~ shall be erected, altered or used, or land used. in whole
or in part, for other than the following:
A.
Principalllses:
1. Class A motorcoach vehicles, as described hercin. One (I) Class A motorcoach vehicle per
"lot" (assigned parking space).
Definition: Motorcoach vehicles shall be defined as those vehicles whlch have been categorized
by the Recreational Vehiele Industry Association of Amcrica (RVIA), and the Family
Motorcoach Association (FMA). as Class "A" or "Motorcoaches" and/or factory cnstomized bus
conversions. that: (a) arc mobile, in accordance with the code of standards of the RVIA and
FMA: (b) are seljCpropclled. and completely self-contained vehicles. which include all the
cOllv'Cniences of a home including, hut not limited to cooking, sleeping, shower and bathroom
facilities; (c) are structured so that the driver's seat is accessible fh)lll the living area in a Vi-'alking
position; (d) contain a minimum interior height of 6 feCI in the living arcas: (e) have a minimum
length of 35 feet, Cl ITwximu111 length of 45 feet and a maximum \vidth of 102 inches plus slide
outs; and (f) have a fixed roof. as opposed to the ""pop-up" varielY.
2. Any other use or service which is comparable in nature with the uses set forth herein and is
found to be compatible in the district by the Board of Zoning Appeals.
B.
Accessory Uses:
Accessory uses and structures customarily associated with the permitted principal uses and
structures, including, but not limited to:
I. Amenities customarily associated with recreational vehicle parks, such as recreation and social
facilities (both indoor and outdoor) administration buildings, service/maintenance buildings,
bathrooms, laundries and similar services for occupants of the park. Recreation facilities may
include but are not limited to swimming pools, tennis courts, boating facilities, playground and
clubhouse for indoor recreation.
2. Utility buildings as may be required for the operation or maintenance of the park not to exceed
1000 s.f.
3. Twenty-seven (27) proposed docks.
4. The existing boat ramp.
5. A boat storage facility, in the approximate location shown on the CPUD Master Plan, with up
to 32 spaces. The actual maximum height of the building shall be IS feet.
6. Small utility buildings having a floor area up to 100 square feet are pennitted on eacb
individualmotorcoacb lot and can have bathroom facilities.
Revised 10-24-07
Aaenda Item No SA
t~~ovember T/. 2'007
Page 44 of -: 90
EXHIBIT B
NAPLES MOTORCOACH RESORT CPUD
DEVELOPMENT ST^"I\IDARDS PRINCIPAL AND ACCESSORY STRUCTURES
Minimum Lot Area
Minimum Tract Area
Minimum Lot Width
Minimum Tract Width
2200 SF
N/A
30 Feet
NiA
MINIMUM SETBACKS (IN FEET)
HENDERSON HENDERSON MAX
U.S. 41 DRTVt<: CREEK FRONT SIDE REAR BLDC
tfrom D.E.) HEIGHT*
Office 25' 2)' 25' HI" 10' ]0' 25' -32'
Clubhouse 2S' 25' 2)' 15'** 15' 20' 25' -40'
Bathhouse 50' 2S' I 25' I 20' 5' 25' 20' -27'
I I
I !
I\1aintenance 25' ] 5' 25' ! 20' 5' 15" 25' -32'
B1dg I i
I
Boat Storage 25" ]S' 0-' HI' 5' 15' 13"15'
-)
B1dg
Personal Utility 25' 15' 25' ]5' 0 ] 5' 10' -] 7'
Bldgs.
Pool Deck 20' 15' 15' 15' 5' 15' NA
Tennis Courts 20' 20' 25' 20' 10' 10' N/A
Guard House N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 20'/25'
Motorcoach 2S' 20' 20" N/A 0/9*** 10' NA
Slabs
Other Accessory 25' IS' 25' ]5' 0 IS' 20' - 27'
B]dg
TABLE 1
* Maximum zoned building height per LDC definition / Maximum actual building height per definition
** The porte cochere for the clubhouse shall be located 3 feet from the right-of-way.
*** 0' setback on one side of lot and 9' minimum on other side; side setback for motorcoacb slabs only shall be
measured 20 feet from back of curb
Revised 10/24/07
-'9-
~
!
l'
MINIMUM
LOT
SLAB Be
UTlUTY BLOG
SETBACKS
VEHICLE
SETBACKS
~
IIMI
HOLE MONTES
OONEERS'Pl.o\NNERS-SlJtoIEVORS
LANDSCAPEARCIfl"EClUl:E
Aoenda ltem No. SA
i.....,' "" ,r'l7 '? (',7
Page 45 of 190
63.5':10
:
~
J-
I.u
Ii:
C/) ~
~
_ ~ \,1)1 'it
'fINl"":-'l.'$P
..
J-
l:ij
~ :.,;:
C/)
-rD",r:i/I
~W"g)Il
~t
~~
f
~o.
~\
950 Encore Way
Naples, FL. 34110
Phone: (239) 254-2000
Florida Certificate of
Authorization NO.1 n2
CIECICED BY .
Naples Motorcoach Resort ...CJI. .
Development Standards 1lRA.....~,;,
Typical Motorcoach Lot DAlE '8
EXtIBlT - ITEM
B-1
PRO.ECT No.
l/llII5.1....
CAD FILE NAME:
;~6~
o~
DN----
~r''':,?
;....:r--..;"""
aJ ---~
~Q)W
IT.;:) ::J,
~ tW
';:' ill CL
C ::::
,7':;;
"
JNI' I
10l ~n~ l~"';~::+clJi'
"".,.-..1 '
~I
t51
~I
o
o
~
:~~~~~~~~
I' ~ " ,'. '
.
o
o
Ii
"'"""'1 ,\
I
:~~y!tJtt~
I. ".,,,<[
> I~ 2 ; ; , ~ ~ ;:
a:
<l
:Ii,
:Ii:
::>
en
w'
(l)i :,,::;: ''''
;:)', : >- ~ I:
o ~ ., 0 : ~
jl;Wi~~! '.
.<
,
-
c
~
z
,
,~
,,;,;-.,,----~
f;
"I
,
fH;
~
~I~'
.01
w~
>'cn
Oi,..
UI<
o
m
.D
~
- ~
~I
w,
III
~I
-J
, n
<'
<(2)
3^lllO _ NOS~3r:!.N3H
c
"ic
HJVOJ2WI0~ ,IN;,nl~~
DN""N]:NI.,..r~
S101 H:JVO:JClOlO~
S101 HJ"10JClOlO~
S101 HJ\10:J~010~
~~i S101 H:J\10J~010~
-/'-".
/ '
I __-~-. .,,' .:__'
j(0__
S101 H:J"10:J~OlO~
"Ii
109
3~
~~
~. ~
C1~
~<
~,
!
"
;;~
"'"
'~
",'"
~,~
"
.w
I
z
o
>=
<.)
W
V1
~ ~.
,-'<
<
]lJ^::J]~ 'I'
,J:llSdvma
,
1 '."
I ~g::
) ~~"~:I,I
@g "
b~ :,
&' 0 I~'
,
~
o
~
~
U
<
o
u
"
o
~
o
~
--,..i;~lB,., I
,
"
:
,
., U
, ~
iiir ~ W
~
, I ~ , ,
11 ~ i x
w
, ~ ~
,
S! 0 ~
~ ~
~ , ; I 0
z , 0
N
0 ~ ~~
~
U
w I ~!~
~
co > ,",
~ "! I,
0 ill
<
0
~
,
~ ci
a::~
~
<
Z
. ~
~
~ ~
z
'"
..J
a.
'"
w
...
'"
'"
::;
ci
~
c:
c.i
<
()
~ ~I
H
f~I(E)(~)@
...
iii
;:
XI
WI
I
-'~
':
100",'
w~
J-lr
Z.
~I
~~
! ' :~.
~ ~ :g;;"
""'I,~r
~j_( !t
~;:,i ",:,,)
!lii'i'
,
.
,
,
.
, 0
, >
;~t:
'"""'5
o
~...
~-[5
"''''
Ow
ifl'"
",I
IU
O<!
<!O
00
0'"
",0
Of-
...0
0:2
:2'"
","j
W(L
..J<!
~Z
Z
<::::(1'--::::>
room
-0"-
.'-i,,-
.0
cc~::;
.s OJ ~)
-.0 0)
m;:::m
;2 3) 0-
~6
,,:(}Z
',.:-..".''''''''......'''........ ." '."" .'..c'.y.....j
".,-,~(, ,>,~'.......5 ' ' ".,.~, 'lf4l, -:, '
l ';;:~fo. '~, ;~ I r
", .. ,. "'.ill
" .....,"'j;;... ",k, '__'1,11 :
~.""~'~. .. ,M ,
! .,.,C... . ..,. " .,
u ~-":. - .\' ......~ ," - !A. ~ ' ~
w ~
w H Q~ ~illW~
0
<
,
"
z
5 i ~a ~t g~U
"
9J . "'~ " ;~~~
w -- ..,
w i:
ll. ~
r:: < !
" II "' t~~~
" , M
n:: z i ~;..
5
w " ,
U. r
U. "
< [
::J z !l !
'" .
~ II! f! ,
"',:! ~ ~
" Pi~ S ~~~
" "_G
:<i.;
(f!
"'
~I
;>" I
-",'~
I~
c.JA
~
,
1>:
<(
z
o
i=
<(
>
w
-'
w
ill
<( c.?
<(
0 a::
:r:: 0
0 I-
....J (f)
L.L , ~
.-- "
--- <( ",
0
0 0
Cf) N
CO 0
ill z
....J a:: ....
co
0.. 0 w
,
<( 0
L.L '"
Z n.
C/) -...
-... ....J I"-
0 <( 0
0 E,
:::> l- N -----;-- ~ --
0.. ill !
0 a:: I" I
0 ...
ill -----"c-__ __,-_
ill CO I
--- 0.. I
I- <( 0
a:: l- I!' t
0 0 0 ~ ~
C/) , ,
C/) 0 0 ~ ~
ill Z -...
a:: <( """"
I ....J 0
0 ~ <(
<C ....J ....J
0 ....J ~
0 <C
a:: S C/)
0 ....J -...
I- <C
0 :::> """"
I
~ I- 0
C/) 0.. I-
ill
ill 0 [D
....J Z -
0.. T
<C 0 X
z 0 ill
I
z
o
i=
o
w
(/J
o
w
!;:
n::
I-
(/J
::J
-'
==
,~
~
"
..
..
,
o
3 ~
~_: ~
"
;r
rr ~
~to2"
;;-,::\3",
~:g; ~
-~~
!
,.
~
"
o
~
....
~
"
.
"
"
'..
.3
l,E
IIis
"'
~;
~~
60
o~~
-<
w
"
-;J:c,
c.'z
'0
~~
g
'"
Z
o
~
>
W
-'
W
o
W
I-
<(
n::
I-
(/J
::J
;ji;l
Aoenda Item ~~o 81".
r\!~cwember 27 2'001'
Page 48 of 1 ';;10
EXHIBIT D
LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
PARCEL I
COMMENCING AT THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF BLOCK 10, HENDERSON CREEK
PARK ]ST ADDITION, AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK S, PAGE 4], OF THE PUBLIC
RECORDS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, SAID NORTHEAST CORNER BE]NG THE
INTERSECTION OF THE SOUTHWESTERLY R]GHT-OF-WAY LlNE OF U.S. lIlGHWAY
4] (TAM]AMI TRAIL) AND THE WESTERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY LlNF OF HENDERSON
DRIVE, RUN SOUTH 00 DEC; 41 M]N 40 SEC WEST. ALONG THE EAST LlNE OF SAID
BLOCK 10, FOR 236.6] FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING: THENCE CONT]NUE
SOUTH 00 DEG 41 MIN 40 SEC WEST. ALONG SAID EAST LINE. Fcm 641.92 FH'T TO A
POlNT HEREINAFTER TO BE KNOWN AS POINT "A"; THFNCE RUN NORTH S9 DEG 24
M]N 50 SEC WESl, P'\RALLU WITH .\ND 0500 FEET DISTANT FROM, AS
IvlfASURED AT R]GHT ANGLLS TO, TilE NORTIlERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY liNE OF
SONDERHI'N DR]VI, ,\S SIIOWN ON S/\IIl PI..'\T OF IIFNDERSO!'o: CRELK PARK FIRST
'\DDITION. FOR 515.] 2 FElT: TJIENCI R UN NORTH ") i lEG 2k IvlIN 27 SEC WEST. FOR
] 10.76 FEET: THFNCL RUN NORTH k9 I)]'C, 24 M]N 50 SEC WLST, FOR 305.00 FEET:
THENCF RleN NORTH 29 ])[0(; I" 'vlIN 06 SEC WEST. (IND]CA!ED ON PlAT AS 13F]NG
NORTH 29 DEG 2k MIl' 4(\ SFC WEST) ALONG THE WEST UNF OF LOI I I. BLOCK .I
OF SAID PLAT, FOR 126.23 FEET: THLNCF CONTINUF TO RUN NORTH 29 DEG 17 Ivl]N
06 SEC WEST, FOR 207.47 FEET TO A POINT HEREINAFTER TO BE KNOWN AS POINT
"13"; THENCE RUN NORTH 51 DEG 56 MIN 37 SEC WEST, FOR 45.00 FEET TO A POINT
ON THE WEST LINE OF SAID BLOCK L; THENCE RUN ALONG SAID WEST LINE,
196.24 FEET ALONG THE ARC OF A CURVE, CONCAVE TO THE NORTHWEST,
HAVING RADIUS OF 2854.93 FEET AND SUBTENDED BY A CHORD HAVING A
LENGTH OF 196.20 FEET AND BEARING NORTH 36 DEG 05 MIN J4 SEC EAST;
THENCE RUN SOUTH 54 DEG 20 MIN 16 SEC EAST, ALONG BLOCK 10, FOR 79S.33
FEET; THENCE RUN NORTH 00 DEG 41 MIN 40 SEC EAST, STILL ALONG BLOCK L,
FOR 815.39 FEET; THENCE RUN SOUTH 54 DEG 20 MIN 16 SEC EAST, FOR 42S.38 FEET
TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING.
PARCEL II
A TRACT OF LAND BEING PART OF VACATED BLOCKS A AND B, HENDERSON
CREEK PARK, RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 6, PAGE 8, OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA AND BE]NG DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:
FROM THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF SAID BLOCK A RUN NORTH 54 DEG 20 MIN 16
SEC WEST, 428.38 FEET ALONG THE TAMIAMI TRAIL FOR A POINT OF BEGINNING;
THENCE SOUTH 00 DEG 41 MIN 40 SEC WEST, 1052.00 FEET; THENCE NORTH 54 DEG
20 MIN 16 SEC WEST, 79S.33 FEET TO THE CENTERLINE OF A COUNTY DRA]NAGE
EASEMENT, RECORDED IN OK BOOK 76, PAGE ]27, OF SAID PUBLIC RECORDS;
THENCE 690.95 FEET ALONG THE ARC OF A CURVE, BEING THE AFOREDESCRIBED
CENTERLINE OF SAID EASEMENT. CONCAVE TO THE NORTHWEST, HAVING A
H:\2005\2005 I 44\WP",RezonelResubmittal July 2007 in progres5\fXHlBlT f),doc
I
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27, 2007
Page ~9 of 190
RADIUS OF 2854.93 FEET AND A CHORD BEARING NORTH 27 DEG 1 I MIN 40 SEC
EAST, 688.37 FEET; THENCE NORTH 20 DEG 16 MIN 12 SEC EAST, 187.96 FEET
ALONG SAID CENTERLINE OF EASEMENT TO SAID T AMIAMI TRAIL; THENCE
SOUTH 54 DEG 20 M1N 16 SEC EAST, 346.67 FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING.
PARCEL III
A PORTION OF BLOCK L, HENDERSON CREEK PART 1ST ADDlTlON, AS RECORDED
IN PLAT BOOK 8, PAGE 41, OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF COLLIER COUNTY,
FLORIDA, MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:
COMMENCING AT THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF SECTION 3, TO\'lNSHlP 51 SOUTH,
RANGE 26 EAST. TALLAHASSEE MERIDIAN, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA THENCE
NORTH 89 DEG 24 MIN 50 SEC WEST, ALONC; THE SOUTH I JNE OF SAID SECTION 3,
FOR 60 FEET TO THE EXTENDED CENTERLlNE OF HENDERSON DRIVE: THENCE
NORTH 00 DEG 41 MIN 40 SEC EAST, ALONG SAlD EXTENDED CENTERLlNE AND
ALSO THE CENTERLINE OF HENDERSON DRIVE. 600 FEET TO THE INTERSECTION
OF SONDERHEN DRIVE; THENCE NORTH X9 DEei 24 MJN 50 SFC WEST, AI.ONG THE
CENTERLiNE OF SONDERHEN DRIVE, 50 FEET TO THE WEST RIGHT-OF-WAY OF
I-IENDERSON DRIVE: THENCE NORTH 00 DEG 41 M1N 40 SEC EAST. ALONG SAID
WEST RIGHT-OF-WAY, 973.53 FEET TO THE SOUTHWESTERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY OF
TAMIAMI TRAIL, U.S. 41, TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING: THENCE NORTH 54 DEG 20
MJN 16 SEC WEST, ALONG SAID SOUTJ-IWESTERL Y RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE OF
TAMIAMI TRAIL, U.S. 41, 42X.38 FEET: THENCE SOUTH 00 DEG 41 MIN 40 SEC WEST,
FOR 236.61 FEET; THENCE SOUTH 54 DEG 20 MIN 16 SEC EAST, PARALLEL TO
TAMIAMI TRAIL, U.S. 41, FOR 428.38 FEET; THENCE NORTH 00 DEG 41 MIN 40 SEC
EAST, 236.61 FEET TO SAID SOUTHWESTERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE OF TAMIAMI
TRAIL, U.S. 41, WHICH IS THE POINT OF BEGINNING.
PARCEL IV
EASEMENT INTEREST FOR CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE OF A SEWER
LlNE(S) AND INGRESS AND EGRESS FOR THE PURPOSE OF MAINTAINING SAID
SEWER LINE(S) AS SET FORTH IN THAT CERTAIN EASEMENT AGREEMENT
RECORDED AT O.R. BOOK 588, PAGE 458, OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF COLLIER
COUNTY, FLORlDA, AS AFFECTED BY THAT CERTAIN SUBORDINATION OF
EASEMENT RECORDED AT O.R. BOOK 1401, PAGE 1101, OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS
OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA.
H:\2005\2005144\WP\Rezone\Resubmittal.luly 2007 in progress\EXHIBIT D.doc
2
Agenda item f\Jo. E;,L\
November 27 2007
?age 50 ~f 190
EXHIBIT E
NAPLES MOTORCOACH RESORT CPUD
LIST OF REQUESTED DEVIA nONS FROM LDC
l. SPECIAL BUFFER
A deviation to Section 4.06.06 of the LDC for the western side of the project along the
creek, to require a fifteen foot (15') buffer south of the boat ramp and adjacent to the
canal and to maintain a 10 foot Type A butfer north of the boat ramp. The reduction of
the buJfer from 15 feet to 10 feet is the subject of this deviation. The justification for this
deviation is that north of the hoat ramp the adjoining land use is a preserve. Area located
north of the boat ramp and to the \"/est of the canal. requires a lesser degree of buffer.
This is Deviation #1.
,
PARKING REQUIREMENTS
Parking for accessory uses shall he computed at 5()O,o nf the normal requirement as set
forth in Section 4.05.04 ufthe LDC and thiS is a deviation It.' this section of the LDt'. The
justification for this deviation is, with multiple indoor and outdoor j~lcilitics within a short
walking distance of all mOlorcoach JellS. parking would not he utilized a1 norma!
stanclards,V/alking, golf carts and bikes arc the primary' means or transportation. This is
Deviation #2.
}. PRlVATE ROADW A Y WlDTI-I
A deviation to Section 6.06.01 of the LDC not to require 60 foot ROW width. Excepting
the wide entrance way, private roadways shall have a 24 foot right of way width. The
justification for this deviation is that the road right-of-way is wide enough to
accommodate the travel lanes, median (if applicable), drainage swales and utilities, and
shall otherwise confom1 to the Construction Standards Manual. This is Deviation #3.
4. OFF-STREET PARKING AREA
A deviation to Section 4.05.02.F. of the LDC that requires that off-street parking areas
must be accessible from a street, alley or other public right-of-way and all off-street
parking facilities must be arranged so that no motor vehicle shall have to back onto any
street, excluding single-family and two-family residential dwellings and churches.
The justification for this deviation is to allow for limited parking for recreational areas
depicted on tbe CPUD Master Plan to back into the private right-of-way easement area.
The justification for this deviation is that the configuration of these areas is limited in
their size and configuration and as a result the required parking can be more easily
accommodated with this deviation. Furrhennore, traffic volumes are low due to the nature
of the proposed use as most patrons walk rather than drive and speed limits are posted at
ten miles per hour. These factors will offset safety considerations and allow these limited
parking areas to better serve the needs of the resort. 1l1is is Deviation #4.
Revised 10-24-07
Page 1 of 2
i\genda item I~o. SA
November 27 2007
Page 51 of 190
EXHIBIT E
NAPLES MOTORCOACH RESORT CPUD
LIST OF REQUESTED DEVIATIONS FROM LDC (CONT...)
5. LANDSCAPE BUFFERING
A deviation to Section 4.cJ6.02.C.4 of tbe LDC that requires a 10 foot Type D butTer to a
road right-ot~way internal to the resort at time of site plan approval so as to allow for the
limited parking adjacent to the recreational areas as shown on the CPUD Master Plan.
The justification for this deviation is that the size and configuration of the recreational
areas is limited in size and relocating the buffer area wlll reduce impervious surface and
result in more efficient utilization of these areas. The required buffer will be located
adjacent to the parking areas as shown on the CPUD Master Plan and not adjacent to the
road right-of-\vay. This is Deviatlon #5.
6. BOAT RAMP PARKING
.A deviation to Section 4.05.04, Table 17, parking requirements so as not to require a
minimum of 10 spaces per boat ramp VI!iih a dimension of 10 feet wide by 40 teet long.
The justification for this deviation is that no public access will be allowed to the boat
ramp and trailers will only be permitted to be stored in the boat storage building. Boats
will only be placed in the water using a boat trailer. Boat trailers will not be left at the
boat ramp but rather moved back to the boat storage area until needed to remove the
boats lromthe water. (See also Exhibit C-1.)
Revised 10-24-07
Page 2 of 2
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27, 2007
EXHIBIT F Page 52 of 190
NAPLES MOTORCOACH RESORT CPUD
DEVELOPMENT COMMITMENTS SPECIFIC TO THE PROJECT
1. TR.A.NSPORTATJON R.EQUIRFMENTS
A. All traffic control devices. signs, pavement marking, and design crite!ia shall be in
accordance with the Florida Depanment of Transportation (FOOT) Manual of Uniform
Minimum Standards (MUMS). cUlTcnt edition, FOOT Desib'll Standards, cUlTent edition,
and the Manual un Unifcmn Traffic Control Devices (MUTCD), cUlTent edition.
B. Arterial-level street lighting shall be provided at all access points. Access lighting shall
be in place prior 10 the issuance of tlie final certificate of occupancy (CO).
C. Access Points shown on the pun Master Plan are considered to be conceptual. Nothing
depicted on an}' such Master Plan shall vest any right of access at any specific point along
any property boundary. The number of access points constructed may he less than the
numher depicted on the Master Plan~ however, no additional access poims shall he
considered unless (j PUD amendrncll! is approved.
D. Silt related llllprovcmems (as npposed Lo system related improvcments) necessary for
3afe int.-'Tess and egrcss to this pwjecL JS determined by' Collicr County'. shall not he
eligible for impact fee credits. /\11 required improvements shall he in place and available
to the Puhlic prior to commencement of on-sitc construction.
E. Nothing in any Development Order (DO) shall vest a right of access in excess of a light-
in/right-out condition at any access point. Neither shall the existence of a point of
inb'TeSS, a point of eb~'ess. or a median opening. nor the fack thereof, be the basis for any
future cause of action for damages against tbe County by the Developer, its successor in
title, or assignee. Collier County reserves the right to close any median opening existing
at any time which is found to be adverse to the health, safety, and welfare of the Public.
Any such modifications shall be based on, but not limited 10, safety, operational
circulation, and roadway capacity.
F. If any required turn lane improvement requires the use of existing County or State
Rights-of-Way or easement(s), then compensating Right-of-Way shall be provided at no
cost to Collier County as a consequence of such improvement(s) upon final approval of
the turn lane design during the first subsequent development order. The typical cross
section may not differ from the existing roadway unless approved, in writing, by the
Transportation Division Administrator or his desibJIlee.
G. If, in the sole opinion of Collier County. traffic signal(s), other traffic control device,
sign, pavemenlmarking improvement within a public Right of Way or Easement, or site
related improvements (as opposed to system related improvements) necessary for safe
ingress and egress to this project, as determined by Collier County, is determined to be
necessary. the cost of such improvement shall be the responsibility of the developer, his
successors or assigns. The improvements shall be paid for or installed, at the County's
discretion, Plior to the appropriate cOlTesponding CO.
H. Money in the sum of $77,145.70, in lieu of, will be provided for sidewalks and bike lane
on U.S. 41 within ISO days of adoption of this ordinance.
Revised 10-26-07
Page 1 of 3
Agenda Item t;Jo. 8/"\
November 27, 2007
EXHIBIT F Page 53 of ,90
NAPLES MOTORCOACH RESORT CPUD
DEVELOPMENT COMMITMENTS SPECIFIC TO THE PROJECT
1. Roadways and Speed Limits. Roadways will be private and responsibility for
maintenance shalJ be the responsibility of the developer. Speed will be limited to ten miles
per hour on internal roadways and so posted.
J. Golf cart parking in any place other than a designated parking space is prohibited.
K. Bicycle Parking shall be provided at al] recreation areas.
2. LANDSCAPING REQUIREMENTS
The developer shall provide a 15-foot wide buffer area that is comprised of four rows of
native trees. planted at a maximum of 15 feet on center in staggered rows on the
Henderson Drive side of the covered boat storage area. Trees shall be a minimum of 18
reet ovcraJl average height with a minimum diameter at brcast height (DB H) of three
inches. "T'here shall he two 1'0\\'5 of shade/canopy trees that include no clustering; and two
rows trees of varied species that can be clustered. The IS-foot v,!ide buffer shall also
include a double staggered hedgerow that is a minimum of' 6 feet high at time of planting.
The buffer area shall also include a wall that is a mininlU11l of 8 feet high. ,'\t least, half
of the required shade/canop)' trees shall be planted on the 11endcrson Drive side or the
wall. (See Exhibit ('-1)
3. DUMPSTERS AND TRASH REMOVAL
Subject to site plan approval, the developer shall place a minimum of two large
dumpsters in the maintenance area, where the maintenance crew at the resort will deposit
trash collected (in plastic bags) from each lot. Trash pick-up within the resort shall occur
twice daily and then be collected from the maintenance area by a commercial rubbish
disposal company.
4. HURRICANE PROTECTION/PERMANENT LOCATION OF MOTORCOACH
VEHICLES
Motorcoach vehicles may not be permanently located on any lot and no pennanent
residency is allowed. The maximum stay shall be six months per year. Within 60 days
of plat approval, the developer shall record a covenant running with the land in the Public
Records of Collier County referencing this restriction on pem1anent residency. The
owner, or user, of the unit is responsible for registeling his or her an-ival and departure
with the manager of the resort. Failure to register shall hold the owner or user
responsible for any penalties imposed by Collier County. No unoccupied motorcoaches
shall be left on site during the hurricane season and all motorcoaches must be removed
from the subject project if a hurricane watch is issued.
5. REQUIRED FACILITIES
The developer shall ensure t11at electricity, central water and sewer, and telephone
services are available to eacb motorcoach site.
Trash for the individual lots and from the recreational areas shall be collected daily by the
Resort's staff and placed in the dumpsters provided at the boat storage site. A contract
with a waste management company will be made to empty the dumpsters on an as need
hasis (one dumpster will be for trash and the other for recyclables).
Revised 10-26-07
Page 2 of 3
Agenda Item No, 'BA
November 27. 2007
EXHIBIT F Page 54 of 190
NAPLES MOTORCOACH RESORT CPUD
DEVELOPMENT COMMITMENTS SPECIFIC TO THE PROJECT
The developer shall provide sanitary facilities including flush toilets and showers in the
recreational area adjacent to the cluhhouse but are not required within a 300 foot walking
distance from every lot, since motorcoaches are equipped with these facilities and an
additional restroom is allowed in the utility building permitted on each lot.
6. BOA T DOCKS/BOAT STORAGE
Parking for trailers shall nol be pemlitted al the boat ramp (See Deviation # 6). No
parking for trailers or hoats shall he per1111tted on an}' 1l1otorcoach lot. Boat storage shall
be only permitted in the area shown as "boat storage" in Tract L and said boat storage
shall be limited to (J maximum of 32 boats on trailers in two, single-story structures that
have a maximum heigh! (actual) of 15 feet. In order to control hoat use, the hoats shall
be put in and taken out to the water hy the resort's maintenance crews.
This commitment is consistent with lhe stated objectives of the Collier County Manatee
Protection Plan 10 reduce hoat-related manatee mortalities, achieve an optimal sustainable
manatee population, and protect Immatee habitat. In order to ensure c()nsistenc~' \'v.ith the
Manatee Prnteclj()]1 Plan, further expansion of hoat facility shall be prohihited.
'rhe number or neVI! boat slips for ctlch lot 10 be pcrmitted b)' individutlj owners vvill be
26; plus one at the boat ramp for a total of 27. The proposed boat docks shall be
permitted parallel and perpendicular except where sea grasses are present along the
shoreline. The perpendicular docks will be four feet x 20 feet. If sea,,>rasses are present,
then a three foot wide perpendicular access walkway shall cross the sea grass area to a
parallel dock outside of the sea,,>rasses to the shoreline and shall not exceed four feet in
width and] 2 feet in length. Boat storage for up to 32 boats shall be permitted. Parking
for boat trailers shall not be permitted adjacent to the boat ramp (see Deviation #6).
7. HENDERSON DRIVE ACCESS
The access on Henderson Drive shall only be used for recycle and dumpster use. Access
to the boat storage facility shall not use Henderson Drive and no other delivery vehicles
will use this access.
Revised 10-26-07
Page 3 of 3
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27. 2007
Page 55 of 190
COLT ,IER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
DRIVE
DEPT. OF Z,ONrNG & LAND OEVELOPMENT REVIEW
WWW.CULLIERGUV.NET
2800 NORTH HORSESHOE
(i)
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104
(239) 403-2400 FAX (239) 643-6968
[~~~ .
. ..'.... ~'
.........[1 NM1tNp~ij~~$~, ',. " .
"S$;.;/F;fi.:--~~-],
'l'riiffi(l)'fYt
_~__,.....'D'.I'~T(~'l'Jj~_:.... .
PETITION NO (AR)
PRO,rECT NAME
PRO.mCT NUMBER
DATE PROCESSED
ASSIGNED PLANNER
iU
I
1-
PUDZr2006-AI(,I064H REV: 4
:')rojecl: 2(J060{i.(lOS7
Date: 7/'30/07 DUE: 8127/07
~-I
____I
C"-- .~. "~~'.
.' -\""0 ".
, '-.'.- -.... '
--.. ~
._~~~]
AIWW CA:j'l:t INIIO'RMi\::1.'IUN
. ',,--
" - - .
:..:..:...--;~...;,..,~~..:_~~~'~-
NAME OF APPLICANT(S) Nallles Motorcuacb Resort.,lnc,
ADDRESS 2400 Crestmoor Rd.. Suife 200 CITY Nashville STATE TN ZIP 37215
TELEPHONE /I (615) 279-8140 CELL Ii _. FAX /I (615) 279-8141
E-MAIL ADDRESS: I'lIndan.hcndcrson(almonacoeoach.cotll
NAME OF AGENT Robe,'l L, Dualle, ATCI' orHo!e Montes, Illc.
ADDRESS 950 Encore Way CITY Naples STATE FL ZU' 34110
TELEPHONE /I (239) 254-2000 CELL Ii FAX /I 239254-2099
E-MAIL ADORESS:bobdualleriilhmcnl!.com
NAME OF AGENT Richard D, Yuvanovich, Esq. or Goodlcttc, Coleman & .Johnson
ADDRESS 4001 TamiamiTmilN,Suitc300 CITY Nan!es STATE I<'L ZIP 34]03
TELEI'HUNE /I (239) 435-3535 CELL Ii FAX Ii 239254-2099
E-MAIL ADDRESS:ryoYallov;cb(@.l!cilaw.com
BE AWARE THAT COLLIER COUNTY HAS LOBBYIST REGULATIONS. GUIDE
YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY AND ENSURE THAT YOU ARE IN COMPLIANCE Wmi
THESE RRGULATlONS.
Agenda Item No. SA.
I~ovember 27, 2007
Page 56 of 190
f
,,,'.
. ;; &~gm'@i(i\\.-'~stL
....;,..,,-.,,~..=~..."'"hfJJJ1~...., ,,~jd"""':
'''....'-.,.,.,,'
,.. .
. " . ,. .
-~.,~-,-=~_i-":
~l
-~
Complete the following for all A.~soeiatiol1(s) affiliated with this petition. Provide additional sheets
if necessary.
NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIA TJON: EAST NAI'LES CIVIC ASSOCIATION
MAILING ADDRESS 3823 TAMIAMI TRAIL EAST, PMIl284 CITY NAPLES STATE FL
ZIl'_34112~
NAME 01" HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION:
.---.--......----.. -- "--....--..--.-
MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP
. ---~- ---,.._-.--- -~_.----, --- ._-~.~~-.
NAME OI<' HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: .
MAILING AODRESS
CITY ~_ .~~STATE
ZIP
NAME OF MASTER ASSOCIATION:
MAILING ADDRESS:
CITY
STATE__ZIP
NAME OF CIVIC ASSOCIATION:
MAILING ADDRESS
CITY..
. ~STATE_ ZIP
H:\2005\2005144\WP\ReZOllc\Resuhmittal July 2007 in progress\API'LICA TION 070616.doc
71l8/2007 3:59:22 PM
2
4genda Item No. 8A
November 27. 2007
Page 57 of 190
Pi~~~J:iQ$J;iJg)li~w~mJ!c~iill1D~~!1!~~......
...']
L
a. If the property is owned fee simple by an INDIVIDUAL, tel"'Jlcy by the entirety,
tenancy in common, or joint tenancy, list all parties with an ownership int.erest as
well as the pel'centage of sllch interest. (Use ndditional sheets if neeessary).
Name 'llId Address
Percentage of Ownership
N!A
b. If the property is owned by a CORPORATION, list the officers 'llId stockholders and
lhe percentage of stock owned by each.
Nmne and Address
Pcrccntage of Ownership
:Monaco Coach Curporation
COt'poratc Offices:
91320 Coburg Industr'ial Way
C:ohurg, OR 97408
Phone: (54!) 686.8011
Toll Free: (SOO) 634,0855 Fax: (541) 681.8899
New \'ork Stock [{xchange
LOO %
N~lples Motorcoach Resort, inc., owned by lVfonaco Coach Corporation
91320 Cohurg Industrial Way
Cohurg, OR 97408
Officers and Directors
Henderson, Everett R Jr., Pres.
2400 Creslmoor Road Nashville, TN 37215
N/A 0;',
Daley, Paul M., TD
91320 Coburg Industrial Way
Coburg, OR 97408
N/A_%
Kimball, Charles, SD
91320 Cohurg Industrial Way
Coburg, OR 97408
N!A.%
Nepute, John W., D
91320 Coburg Industrial Way
Coburg, OR 97408
N/A %
Name and Address of Curren! Registered Agent:
Ct Corporation System! as of April 20, 2007
1200 South Pine Island Road
Plantation, FL 33325 US
c. If the property is in the naUle of a TRUSTEE, list the beneficinries of the trust with
the percentage of interest.
1l:\2005\2005144\WP\Rezone\Resubmillal July 2007 in progress\APPUCA nON 070616.doc
7/18/20073:59:22 PM
3
/\aenda Item No 8/\
N~ov9mber 27. 2'007
Page 58 01 190
Name and Address
Percentage of Ownership
N/A
d, If the property is in the name of a GENERAL or LIMITED I' ARTNERSHII', list the
nanlc of (he general andlor Bodted partners.
Name and Address
Percentage of Ownership
_N/A__~__
e. If tbere is a CONTRACT FOR PURCHASE, with >In individnal or individu>lls, a
Corporation~ Trustee, or a Partnership, list the Hames of the contract purchasers
below, including the offiecrs, ,r;,;(ockholdcrs, bCllcHdaries, or partner.~.
Name and Address
Percentage of O,.vnership
N/A
f. If any cOlltingency clause or contract t.erms iuvulve additional parties, list all
individuals or officers, if a rorporatioll, par1nership, or trust.
Name and Address
N/A
g. Date subject property acquired [Z] purchased 19'" day of April. 2007
leased 0 N/A Tenn of lease N/A yrs.!mos.
If, Petitioner bas option to bny, indicate the following:
Date of option:
Date option terminates:
Anticipated closing date
,or
h. Should any changes of ownersbip or changes in contracts for purchase oecnr subsequent
to the date of application, but prior to the date of t.he final pnblic bearing, it is the
responsibility of t.he applicant, or agent. on his behalf, to submit a snpplement.al
disclosure of interest. fonn.
The subject property which was under contract for purchase has been sold and is 'lOW the
sole property of Naples Mororcoach Resorl, Inc. New disclosure of interest is included in
this revised application. In addition, a new affidavit and CO~ICI1QJlt of Unified Contl'o! are
included.
H:\2005\2005144\WP\Rczone\ResubmittaJ July 2007 in progrcss\APPLlCATION 070616.uoc
711812007 3:59:22 PM
4
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27. 2007
Page 59 of 190
c..'....
"";-'"".:"":.
:".c._.:,.:!:._; '0
';' I\RmIljl!.1jj$~n:{!i~.l~ltl!.~ff~c;.
_... . _,0',_
--_._._._._'-"-~-'
....=]
Detailed legal descrifltion of the flrolwrtv covcred hI' the application: (If space is inadc.quate,
attach on separate page,) If requcst involves change to more than one zoning district, include
separate legal description for property involved in each distriel.. Applicant shall submit four (4}
copies of a recent survcy (collll)leted within the last six months, maximum 1" to 400' scale) if
reqnired to do so at the pre-application meeting.
NOTE: The appllc,mt is responsihle for supplying the correct legal description. If questiollS arise
(~oncernin~ the legal description, au engiuccr's ct'.rtific~lHon or scaled survey may he required.
Secliollrrownship/Rallge Q1./ 5IS/_ 26E
Lot: 1 & 2 Block: A, I. Subdivision: GREYSTONE MOBILE PAIU(
Plat Book___..._ Page II: Property l.ll.#: Folio No 4')53008000l & 49584240004
Metes & BOllnds Description: See allllched le!:,,1 description
Size Of!lropertv: ft. X irregular ft. ~. Total S'l' Fl. 1010579.43 A<Tes ,,23.2
Addn,ss/generallocatioll of subjectllroflerty: _13300 T AMlA.MI TRAIL EAST
PUll District (1,DC 2.03.(6): U Residential
[g] Commercial
I. J Commnnity Facilities
U Industrial
[- ..
. .. _ AJ.1JA:",J'N'I~~9fftN~~!r!'!.:mp'~i,J$j~,
Zoning
Land use
N
S
E
W
PUD
MB
A en
I'UD & MM
U.S. 41, WINDING CYPRESS
HENDERSON CREEK MOBILF, HOMES
SAN MARCO MISSION CHURCH
ARTESA l'OL"ITE & HENDERSON CREEK MOBILE HOMES
Dol'S the owner of the subject l,roperty own propert)' contignous to the subject prollerty?
If so, give colUplete legal descr';ption of entire contiguous property. (If space is inadequate,
attach Oil separate page). No
SectionffownshiplRangc / /
Lot: Block: Subdivisiou:
Plat Book_ Page #: Property I.D.#:
Metes & Bounds Description: _..
L__
REZOl'<)CR1j)Q)JES'l'
This application is requesting a rezone from the
CPUll zoning district(s),
Present Use of the propel'ty: I'RESENTLY VACANT
Proposed Use (or range of uses) of tile property 200
MANAGEMENT AND RECREATIONAL AREAS AND
USES.
OriginalPUD Name: N/A
MH ,TTRVC & C-S zoning district(s} to the
MOTORCOACH LOTS, WATER
MISCELLANEOUS ACCESSORY
Ordinance No,:
11:\2005\2005144\WP\Rczonc\Resuhmil1al July 2007 in rrogrc..~~\A PPUCA TION 070616.doc
7/18/2007 3:59:22 PM
5
Agenda Item No SA
November 27, 2007
Page 60 of 190
I
~;V A'LV&TI9r11(:i~tj;p;'it!"A.
-~
Pursuant to Section 10.02.13 of the Collier County Land Development Code, staff's analysis and
recommendation to the I)lanning Commission, and the Planning Commissiun's recommendation to
the Board of Connly Commissioners shall he based npon e.onsideralion of the applicahle criteria
noted below. Provide a narrative statement describing (:he rezone request with specific reference to
the criteria noted below. Include ~lIIY baeknp materials and documentation in support of the
request.
/. The milabilit)' of the an'a lor the type and pattern of development p,'oposed in relation to
physi(~al ebaracteristic."i of (:nc land, surrounding an:3Sl traffic and access, drainage, sewerl
water, and other utilities.
The proposed change in llse .f'rom a mobile lravel trailer flark aud convenience store to a A1oiOl,'
Coach Re.lOrl represents improved suitability, since 110 permanent residc1U:V wdl he permitted
~Vilh Iewer strur;tures (I/l(! lcnFcr densities, the propDsed use will have less impact and is olsQ
he/tel' suited 10 it.'.' !ocn1foll in the C'oasla! Nigh Hazm-d Area. Nlcollln'tiolls ill trollic, .\'cwel' and
1,va{er ore also :wh,r;tantial.. therefore, the !J!'{)posed /.jse is mON' ('umpatiblc lvith [he O}'SG tlwn
the existing use.
2. Adequacy of evidcncc of unil,,,d contl'ol and ",itllbility oC any propo"d agreements,
contract, or other instruments, or for :lmendmcn1.s in those proposed, llarticularly as the)'
fuay relate to arrangements or provisions to he made for the continuing operation and
maint"nllnce of sneh areas and facilities that are not to be provided or maintllined at pnhlic
expense. Findings and recommendations oC this type shall be made only after consultation
with the connty attorney.
The su~iecl property will be under ul1ified C0111/"01 as evidenced by the Slalemenl of Ul1ified
Control filed with the application and provisions con/alued therein. There are no public facililies
proposed in this CPUD. Private jacilities at common areas will be maintained by the resort
management
3. Conformity uf the proposed PUD with the goals, objectives and !lolicies of the growth
nlanagemcnt plan.
71,e subject properly is located ill the Urban Coastal Fringe Sub Dislrict of the Urban-Mixed
Use Dislricl as idenlified 011 the Fulure Land Use Map. The CPUD meets the standards and
permitted uses in thai SubdistricI, as required by Objective 1 of the FLUE. Further, the
proposed project will replace 293 mobile homes and travel trailers (in addition to a convenience
slore) with accommodations for up to 200 molorcoaches. Most of the properly (83%) Is zoned
for Mobile Ijames. Since new rezones to permit mobile home developments are prohibited in
this Subdistricl. [he proposed removal of Ihe mabile homes is, Iherefore, more consistenl wiih the
FLUE of Ihe CoWer Counly Growl" Managemell[ Plall. While part of the property is now zOlled
7TR VC, alld the Molorcoach Resort will gellerally meet or exceed Ihose slandards, all raones in
Ihis Subdislrict are recommended by Ihe FLUE to be in the form of a Planned Unit Developmenl
fhal is provided for in Ihis application.
JI:\200S\20051 >14\WP\Rc2;one\J{e:mbmjual July 2007 in progress\APPLlCATION 07061 G.UU(;
7fI8/2007 3:59:22 PM
6
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27. 2007
Page 61 of 190
The proposed development can also be found consistent witll objective 1.2 of the economic
element that calls for Collier County (0 expand and enhance the tourism industl)' that will be
accomplished by the proposed Motorcoach re.>ort; to provide part-time oCl:upancy for tourists.
Objective 7 of the FLUE and its accompanying policies pertaining to the smart growth do not
appear to be particularly germane 10 the proposed redevelopment. We trust you agree.
The redevelopmellt is consistent with Goal } 2 oj the Conservation and Coastal Management
Element of the GMP by reducing the danger to people and property from the ef(ects of hurricane
damage.
The redevelopment h com:istcnt with Policy lO./.4 of the Conservation and Coastal
Manay,cmcnt Element of the GMP by giving first priority to siting shoreline development in
areas presently developed.
'Ihe redevelopment is consistent l\-'ith PoliGy J 0.1. 6 of the Conservation and Coastal
lv1anagement Element (~( the GMP hy /;:{voring dJY storage in its boating facilities over Ive(
storage.
TIw redevelopment is consistent lvith Of?jective 7.2 [!f the Cnn.wTPaiion and Coastal
A1anagmncnt Element of (he OMP by reducing the anu,nmt and controlling the type of boating
aCI/viIY Hihic/! clIlTently j,y generated/rom thi., :'lite,
4. The internal and external eompatihility of proposed uses, which conditions may indnde
restrictions on location of improvements, restrictions on <le~i.gn, and buffering and
screening requil-cmcnts.
T'lw proposed development is compatible with and complementar)' to existing and jillure
surrounding land uses, as required in Poiicy 5.4 of the FLUE, enhallr:ed through the internal
arrangements of faciii!ies, thc placement of landscaped buffers alld the proposed development
standards contained within the CPUD. The western buffer consists of the conal and u deviation
is proposed to ollly maintain a 10 foot b~fJer, north of the boat romp. This is because a preserve
area is lomted on the west side of the canal at this location that justifies the reductioll ill buffer
width. Internal burrers shall also be utilized, excepting the 10 foot Type D Buffer along the
private R.o. w: acijacent to the recreational areas where parking is needed. (See Deviation # 5.)
5. Tile adequacy of usable o)len space areas in exislence and as proposed to serve the
development.
Open space recreation amenities. lake and canal frontage will meet or exceed open ~pace
requirements for the proposed use.
6. The timing or sequence of development for the purpose of assuring the adequacy of
available improvements and facilities, both pnhlic and private.
The liming of the development will be coordinated with required improvements und(ar.ililies.
7. The ability of lhe snbject property and of su,.,.ounding a,'eas to accommodate expansion.
The redevelopment of the property is a reduction in intensity.
H:\2005\2005144\WP\Rcwnc\Rcsltbmittai July 2()()7 in progrcss:\APPUCA TION 070616.doc
7118120073:59:22 PM
7
~Agenda Item No. oA
r,ovember 27. 2007
Page 62 of 190
8. ' Conformity with PUD regulations, or as to desirable modifications of suclt regulations in
the particular case, based on determination that such modifications are justified as meeting
public IHlrposes to a degree at least equivalent 10 literal application of sneh regulations.
The proposed removal of mobile homes is col1sislenl with Ihe FLUE of Ihe Collier County
Growth Mallogement Plan as well as [he Coastal Area lvfanagement goals. DeviaLions proposed
are minor and appropriate/or the proposed type of dr;velopment inlhis location.
Deed Restrictions: The County is legally precluded [hJIl1 enforcing deed reslrictions, however, many
communities have adopted such reslrictions. You may wish to contad the civic or property owners
association in tbe area for which thi,s use IS being requested in order to ascertain whether or not the
request is affeckd by existing deed restrictions.
IlrcviollS land use petitions on the subicct pro pert\': To your knO\vledge, has a public hearing
been held on this property within the last year'! 0 Yes (g) No
If so, what was [he nature of that hearing?
NOTICE:
This applicatlon will be con:;;idercd "open'. whl.:':l1 the determination of ";.;ufficiency" has been made and
the application is at>signed a pctilion processing Ilumber. The application \\'ill he considered "closed"
when the petitioner withdraws the application through written notice or cease.5.J<>.....1WQ1l1y..pecessary
lDJp[mation to G9t1tinue uroce5sing or oth~r\vise activ~!y PtH'Sl1e the r~zoninf.! for. a ncriod _of SIX (6)
mO]l(I!fi. All application deemed "closed" will not receive fUlthcr processing and an application "closcd"
through inactivity shall be deemed withdrawn. An application deemed "closed" may he rc-opencd by
submitting a new application, repayment of all application fees and granting of a detennination of
"sufficiency". Further review of the project will be subjcct to the then cun'cnt code. (LDC Section
10.03.05.Q.)
H:\2005\2005J44\WP\Rczolle\Resubmiltal July 2007 ill progres~'v\PPLlCATION 0706 I 6.do-:::
7/18/20073:59:22 PM
8
PUD AMENDMENT (PUDAj
PUD REZONE (PUDZj
PUD 10 PUDREZONE (PUDZ.A)
APPLICATiON.
SUBMITT AL CHECKLIST
r It.::! l\i
November 27. 20 7
Page 63 of 1 0
THIS COMPLETED CHECKLIST IS TO BE SUBMITTED WITH APPLICATION PACKET IN THE EXACT ORDER LISTED BELOW
W/COVER SHEETS ATTACHED TO EACH SECTION,
NOTE: INCOMPLETE SUM BITT ALS WILL NOT BE ACCEPTED.
REQUIREMENTS
;$;tAJilP'b;!i.QtREQliJJRENlENf;$iil!:ffi';::tffitj~i\;*~;~~ift''''i'%"a;,fi;";;;;;;;!)';;"'!;:;!,;,,:;;',,,:,,
1 Additional set if located in the Bayshore/Gateway Triangle
Redevelopment Area}
Copies of detailed description of why amendment 15 necessary
Com leted Application (download from website for current form)
Pre-op lication meeting notes
Current Conceptual Site Plan 24" x 36" and One 8 lh" x 11" co
Revised Conce )tual Site Plan 24" x 36"and One 8 l/~" x 11" copy
Original PUD document and Moster Plan 24" y, 36" - ONLY IF AMEND1NG
THE PUD
Revised PUD docutnGnt with changes crossed thru & underlined
I Revised rUD document w Iwnended Title a e ward #'5. LDC 10.02.13.A2
Deeds/Legol's & Survey (if boundary of origina~ PUD is amended}
List identifying Owner & 011 parties of corporation
Owner/Affidavit signed & notori2ecl
Covenant of Unified Control
Completed Addressing checklist
Environmental Impact Statemenf (EIS) and digital/electronic copy of E1S or
exemption jlJstlficotion
Historical Surveyor waiver request
Utility Provisions Statement w /sketches
Architectural rendering of proposed structures
Survey, signed & sealed
Traffic Impact Statement [TIS) or waiver
Recent Aerial Photograph (with hobitat areas defined) min scaled 1 "-ADO'
Electronic copy of all documents in Word format and plans (CORam or
Diskette)
If located In RFMU (Rural Frinae Mixed Use) Receivincl land Areas
Applicant must contact Mr. Gerry J. lacavero! State of Florida
Division of Forestry @ 239~690.3500 for information regarding
"Wildfire Mitigation 8.. Prevention Plo,,", LDC Section 2.03.08.A.2.a.(b)i.c.
;/).4..-1 rf)u.A""~' c; C.
Applicanf / Agent Signature Date
# OF
COPIES
NOT
REQUIRED
REQUIRED
24 Cover letter
24
24 Attached
24 Attached
24 NA
24 NA
24
24 rUD Attached
2 AHclched
2 AttClched
2 Attached
2 Attached
2 Attached
NA
4
4 NA
4 NA
4 NA
4 Attached
7 Analysis Attached
Aerial
5 Attached
Attached
7' /2
;
:2 ,,0 ~
H:\2005\2005 i 44\WP\Rezone 4~2{106iPUDRezonePcUtion.( lO)06] 009. nll\.l'ld.ry,aw.rh .doc
23
PUDZ-2006-AR-l0648
PROJECT #2006060057
DATE: 10/13/06
KA Y m:SELEM
COVENANT OF UNIFIED CONTROL Agenda Item No. 8/\
November 27, 2007
Page 64 of 190
The undersigned do hereby swear or affirm that we are the fee simple titleholders <-lnd owners of record of property
commonly known as Naples Motorcoach Resott. Inc,
(Street address and City, Slate and Zip Code)
and legally described in Exbibit A attached hereto.
The property described herein is the subject of an application f(Jr _.__.,
planned unit development (CPUD) zoning. We hereby designate Robert L J?ual~and Ri~!:m[gJ). Yova.1LQYi~b.. legal
representative thereof, as the legal representatives of the propcl-ty and ~s such) these individuals Elre authorized to legally
bind all owners oCthe property in the course of seeking the necessmy approvals to develop. This authority includes, but is
not limited to, the, hiring and authorization of agents to assist in the preparation of applications, plans, surveys, and studies
necessary to obtain zoning approval on the site, These representatives will remain the only entity to authorize
development activity on the property until such time as a new or amended covenant of unified control is delivered to
Collier County,
The undersigned recogniC':e the [c)l1owing and will he guided accordingly in the pursuit of
development of the project:
]. The property will be developed and used in conformity with the approved master plan including all condition~ placed
on the developnwllt and all cOl11tnitmcnts agreed t{l by the applic.ant in COlUlcction with the plmmed unit development
rezoning.
::!., The legal representative identified hercm is responsible for compliancC;'- wi!h all term~, conditions, saf~g1.lards, and
stipulations made at the lime of approval of th~ master plan, even if the property IS subsequently sold in whole or in
pmi, unless and until a new Dr amended eovcmml orunified contwl is delivered to and recorded by Collier COUIlty,
3< A depm'ture from the provisions of the approved plans or a failure to comply with any requireTllents, conditions, or
,,;afcguards provided for in the plnnned unit development process will constitute n violation oftbe Land Development
Code.
4. All terms and conditions of the planned UJlit development approval '1Ntll be incorporated into covenants and
restrictions which run with the land so as to provide notice to subsequent owners that all development activity within
the planned unit development mmt be consistent with those tcrms and conditions.
5. So long as this covenant is in force, Collier County can, upon thc discovery of noncompliance with the terms,
safeguards, and conditions of the planned unit development, seek equitable relief as necessary (0 compel compliance.
The County will not issue permits, certificates, or licenses to occupy or llse any pmt of the phmned unit development
and the County may stop ongoing construction activity until the project is brought into compliance with all terms,
cOl~g~#ed unit development.
e",,,",, /'f!fe1,v~ ILl" Owner
E. Raadall Henderson. Jr.
Printed Name
Printed Name
STATE OF FLOR.IDA)
COUNTY OF COLLIER)
/. -fv7 .
Sworn to (or affirmed) and subscribed before me this if day of
Jfta-d!
_~, 200I-by
,j;. (2I2(J.:<.1/ lkucIM<;'1'f1 1(______ who is personally known to me or has produced
as idcntificatroJl.
~~~
Notary Public, , /. I
~~h~~I( ~(o
(Name typed, printed or stamped)
t:1\. Stephan.. Karel
~~ j My ~ommtulon 002N124
"YI:t....." ExtNIfl; M.rch 09, 2005
(Serial Number, if any)
Application For Public Hearing For PUD Rezone 0 lI18/D7
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27. 2007
Page 65 of 190
J
AFFIDAVIT
We/I, E. Randall Henderson. Jr. being first duly sworn, depose and say that we/I am/are the
owners of the property described herein and which is the subject motter of the proposed bearing; that
all the answers to the questions in this application, inciuding the disclosure of interest information, all
sketches, data, and other supplementary matter attached to C1nd made a part of this application, are
honest Clnd true to the best of our knowledge and belief. We/I understcmd. that the information
requested on this application must be complete Clnd Clccurate and that the content of this form, whether
computer generoted or County printed sl1C111 not be altered. Public hearings will not be advertised until
this dpplication is deemed complete, and all required informdtion has been submitted.
As property owner We/I further duthorlze RobertJ, DUdne dnd Richard D. Yovdnovich to Clct as
our/my representative in dny mdtters regording this Petition.
/)
~ ~'-
Signature of Property Owner
E. Rondall Henderson. Jr,
Typed or Printed Ndme of Owner
Typed or Printed Name of Owner
The foregoing instrument WdS ocknowledged before me this /;> M day of I11CMC II .
200L by LIUwI.u.r fkpotuS,(H, 1,-: who is personally known to me_or has produced
as identification.
State of Florida
County of Collier
~~~cw.l.t t/.w,~
(Signature of Notary Public - State of
Florida)
,-rJ\. Sltpllonlo 100>I
. -!J. j My Comminlofl 002_4
~lIf,..J Expiret Marth 09. 2008
31:e~I'\;e l4wJ
(Print, Type, or Stamp Commis;ioned
Name of Notary Public)
Apl)licatio!1 For Public Hearit\g For PUD Rezone 01/] 8/07
Agenda liem No. SA
November 27. 2007
Page 66 of 190
STATEMENT OF UTILITY PROVISIONS
FOR PUD REZONE REQUEST
L~
'AIDX!~tff._m!ti~~mt!l!Jg~:h}'"
.-.---,
:--:-.- '.-.1
.-~
NAME OF APPLlCANT(S) NAPLES MOTORCOACH RESORT, INC.
ADDRESS 2400 CRESTMOOR RD., SillTE 200 CITY NASHVILLE STATIc TN ZIP 37215
TEJoEI'HONE # (615) 279-8140 CELL # __ __.FAX # (615 )279-8141
E-MAIL ADDRESS:RANDAI.L.HENDERSON<illMONACOCOACH.COM
ADDRESS OF sunmcr PROPERTY (IF AVAILABLE): 13300 TAMIAMI TRAIL E.
NAPLES,I"L 34114-8701
r-~J];(}AL.JjltscR~rtwN
...----c-..l
...1
SCclionJTown'hipfRaugc 03 151 SI 26E
Lot:.J. & 2 IlIocl<: ~l Subdivhiou:. C;REYSTONE MOBILl: PARK
Plat Book~ rage #:_~ Pmpc,';)' I.D.#: Folio No 49530080001 & 49584240004
Metes & Bounds Dc,eription: Sce attached Je~al de,er;I,t;on (Exhihit D)
L~rXP-!,oiiSE'WAGE OISl'ClSALf"brnfpR9YWEP ..
(Checl< applicable system):
--J
COUNTY UTILITY SYSTEM
a. CITY UTILITY SYSTEM
b. FRANCmSED UTILITY SYSTEM
PROVIDE NAME
d. PACKAGE TREATMENT PLANT
(GPO capacity)___
e. SEPTIC SYSTEM
i:8J
o
o
o
o
I TYPEOF W Al'ERSERVlc:E TOBEI'R(J\TlI?ED
.J
a. COUNTY UTILITY SYSTEM
b. CITY UTILITY SYSTEM
c. FRANCHISED UTILITY SYSTEM
PROVIDE NAME
d. PIliV A TE SYSTEM (WELL)
i:8J
o
n
o
H:\200S\2005 \ 44WlP\ftewllc\Resubmitlal July 2007 ill progrC5sV\I'PLlCA TION 0706] 6.doc
7/18/20073.59.22 PM
9
l\qenda Item No. SA
N"ovember 27, 2007
Page 67 of 190
STATEMENT OF UTILITY PROVISIONS - page 2
PROPOSED UNITS: Seasonal TTRV Units
~----
20
.- - --~
Water 500 x
--~,
Water 500 x
Sewer 500 x
--.--.-.- -~_._-
Sewer 500 x
~--~,
Ox 2.5
~ 500
Population
100 GPD = 50,000
Average daily
150 GPD = 75,000
.--n---..---
100 GPD = 50,000
..__'_ _.___._....____._____u.__.."
130 GPD = 65,000
-- -- --------
Peak daily
Average daily
Peak daily
1)"'11.1(.. .,~'DA:.,V.'i'I{:.'G"I';D'. ,"TbY'l"'P"M'"'' .AN' 'f)S",'P@'n:tt'.{{il"'D\0GB1}'U'i..
.1:':", ",.,~."I;_"_ _ ,-.Llj. '~:" ,J;.1' "~' ':c.....ll!~.._. . '. .,'","_ -:.."',-.:",...'t......",...__,_-:.~;..:.:.r...._.,:"...,:.-.",';".,:.:'
A. WATER-PEAJ( 128,269 G})D (Less) AVERAGE DAlLY 85,512 GPD (Less)
B. SEWER-PEAK 49,270 GPD (Less) AVERAGE DAILY 37.900 G])D (Less)
IF PROPOSING TO BE CONNECTlm TO COLLIER COUNTY REGIONAL WATER
SYSTEM, J'LEASE PROVIDE TIm DATE SERVICE IS EXPECTF.D TO BE
REQUIRED Late 2007
NARRA:'I'IVE8TATEMENT: Provide a brief and concise naJTative statement and schematic
drawing of sewage tTcatulent procc~s to be used as well as a specific statement regarding the
method of affluent and sludge disposaL If percolation ponds arc to be used, then percolation data
and soil involved shall he provided from tests prepared and c.ertified by a professional engineer.
Waste water service to b,U)I"Ovided [!)In' Collier.
COlililJilR,COUNTYi>. U'])ILIT;YI-j!J;I)ICA:r:rll1h'l,.$trXr'])Iif~~!Fd If the project is located
within the services houndaries of Collicr County's utility service system, written notarized
statement shall be provided agreeing to dedicate to Collier County Utilities the water distribution
and sewage collection facilities within the project area "pon completion of the constJ1lc.tion of
these facilities in accordance with all applicable County ordinances in effcct at the at timc. This
statement shall also inclode an agreement that the applicable system development charges and
connection fees will be paid to the County Utilities Division plioI' to the issuance of building
pennits by the County. If applicahle, the statement shall conl>iin shall contain an agreemcnt to
dedicatc thc appropriate utility casements for scrving the water and scwer systems.
Appropriate facilities will be dedicated for the County at Ihe time of constlUction plan approval.
STATEMENT OF AV AILAllILIT>\' CAPAG1!J.;'Y'F:gPM';'.(<jiFiIElt' l\t{l'tWDERS: Unless
waived or otherwise provided for at the pre-application meeting, if the project is to receive sewer
or potable water services from any provider other than the County, a statement from that provider
indicating that there is adequate capacity 10 servc the project shall be provided.
Not applicable.
H:\2005\2005144\WI'\Rc2one\Resubmiual Ju1)'200-1 in progress\APPLlCATION 070616_doc
7/18/20073:59:22 PM
]0
,A.genda item No. OP.
November 27. 2007
Page 68 of : 90
~
'C:/
_ _ _ _._ ~.S. -_~1__ (T ~~~~~_I_ _T~_~~_~!-_?_T2_
4l~::;
-+
qyU
I
q::;1
I
~- CONNECT TO EXISTING
/ WATER MAIN WITH TAPPING
/ SLEEVE AND VALVE.
~
."~'---", '\.
'\ '\ \
'.' \
CONNECT TO EXISTING ,. <:\\ \
FORCE MAIN WITH TAPPING \'.\.\
SLEEVE AND VALVE. \\ \ ' ._
Ii' - \-.
; ~----------~---~
"0 -______=. 1
~ -------'0='=',:0:.=__----- \ ',-
I
,
/
,
t ..-' EXISTING WATER MAIN
--~--------------
.../ EXISTING FORCE MAIN
___-c_______________
g
N
.,-- -
j- - - - - - - -,- - - - '- - - - - -- -
"-=- RIGHT -OF--WAY
I
:.J~MASTER
WATER METER
~
-l
I
I
1
\
\
\
"
~
z
o
~
u
"'
z
z
o
"
t
~
~
o
~
~
~
~
,
o
~.
,
,
~
~
~
:
;j,
.-
I.'
,
o
N
W
~
~
o
-:
-0
2: V
-0
"
\
I \
\
b f \
;0 I \
() f \
r'1 \
~ I \
I \
Z I \
I \
I
I
I
I
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
HIVI
HOLE MONTES
!lQflJlSftIIfIRS._
~
.-'
~
o
o
N
.-'
I
950 Encore Way
Na)'I.., fL 34110
Phano, (239) 254-2000
Florida Cer1U1cate of
Authorizatlon No.1772
UTILITY CONNECTION
NAPLES MOTORCOACH RESORT
PROJ(c.r No.
2005.144-
DftAi\'N'IIY; c"p f1L[ NAME:;
AF.H. OS1+4OOEZ.ON
DATE: [X/ilEllT - lTO~
09 06 UTll CONN
Agenda Item No. 8.1\
November 27. 2007
Page 69 of 190
2007 FOR PROFIT CORPORATION ANNUAL REPORT
DOCUMENT# P97000077469
Entity 'Nam.: NAPLES MOTORCOACH RESORT,INC.
FILED
Apr 20, 2007
Secretary of State
New Principat Place of Business:
Cummt Principal PJaco of 8uctness:
91320 COOURG INDUSTRIAL WAY
COBURG, OR 97408 US
New Malltng Address:
CUlT1lnt MaJllng Address:
91320 COBURG INDUSTRIAL WAY
COBURG,OR 97408 US
FErNumbo( Ap(oIHl-tl For { )
FE1Huf1'lol14fKo(~r.l.f(
c.rtiftcat. of st.ellA. o.sn.d ( )
\
I
fEl~ifl5~1C11441
Name and Address of New Registered Ag~nt;
Name and AddflfSS- of Current RcgJs.tered Agent:
CT CORPORATION SYSTEM
1200 SOUTH PINE ISlAND ROAD
PlANTATION, FL 33324 US
The above name-d entity submits this statement for ttle purpose of changing its registered ofTioo or reJ)isterecf agent, or both,
in the State of Florida,
SIGNATURE:
Eiectronic .Signature ofRegistefCd A9aOl-
EW:tIon c~ Flnl'lOClng Tnnt Find Cootrbution ( ~,
--6a~----
ADDITIONS/CHANGES TO OFFICERS AND OIR.ECTORS:
OFFICERS AND DIRECTOR.S:
Trile:
f\ll;l/ne':
A.ddl-os#;
City-St-Zip:
......
-:
.........:
aty...S'-Zip;
TItle:
N...""
Jl.d<i-e~:
oty:-Sl-ZiD;
......,
....".."
Adchl:$e:
Oty--Sl-zlP:
< ) Chal'1go ( ) AdcilJon
P ( ) D.leht
HENOER.f",.oN, EV5REIT R JR.
2.wo CRESTMOOR RON)
~llE,TN 37215
TIt!.:
NI!IITW'::
Addros.~:
C1ty-st-Z1p":
Tn ()Dttlllt~
~EY. P.A.U1.. M
91320 006URG INDUSTRIAL WAY
COBURG, OR 97406
-:
Nal'l'lfl:
.-..ddrdn:
CifywSt.Zip:
-:
-.."
..........:
Ctty-st..zJc:
) et.nge ) Mdtion
) Ctamo& ).Mdtlon
so { )o.t..
K1M&J..L.(:;Hf.RLES
91320 COBURG tNOUSTRW. WAY
COeURG, O~ fl7408
D { )o.Hne
NEPLn"E, JCJHII W
~'320 COBURG INOUSlRIAt WAY
COBURG. OR g7408
TItle,
Nam.l:
-:
Cfty-st-Zlp:
{)",,",,""l)""""""
I hereby certify that the information supplied with this Wing does llot qU<l}ify lQr the for the exemption stated in Chapter 119,
Florida Slalutes, t furtller certify that the information indicated on lhis report or supplomental report (s true and accurate and that
my eleClronic signature shall have tho saIne legal effect as if made under oath; that I am an officer or director of the corporation or
tile receIver or trustee e-mp,jweored to eXi;'cute this report as required by Chapter 607, Florida statutes', ~nd that my name appears
above, or on an aHaGhm~ltll with an address, will! all other like empowered.
:rtl
04f2fJ/2fJ07
Date
SIGNATURE: PAUL M. DALEY
Electronic Signature of Signing Ofllcer or Director
n.j\'i,i#ti;t~rCoqibr,il.jQIj5
Agenda item No. SA
November 27. 2007
Page 70 of 190
-- -~'.~--- ....--_.,.....:~-.---:---.,--n~,~.";-:::,.::.~~...,,.~._~.:y:=-~c-:;:,,-::-::.-.'.-,.."':':,,-~.,...:----:-.-:--.._.::"-:;-._:::c,
Floridn Profit
NAPLES MOTORCOACH RESORT, INC.
".. -- ----..._~...__._-_.
_____.______.m
PRINCIPAL ADDRESS
91320 COBURG INDUSTRIAL WAY
COBURG OR 97408 US
Changed 04/26/2004
- _,______.__ _.________... ..___w_..,...__,
-----.-."-,.----.
MArLING ADDRESS
91320 COBURG INDUSTRIAL WAY
contJRG OR 97408 US
Changed 04/26/2()()4
Document Numtwr
/'97()()0077469
}l'EI Numbe,'
6510] 1441
Hate FHed
09/08!1997
State
FL
Status
ACI1VE
Effective Dliatc
09/05/1997
Last Event
NAME OlANGE AMENDMENT
Event Date Filed
01123/200]
Event Effective Date
NONE
__"_"___U'_'__~_.,_. _ _..__ .._______~______________. ._____
L
I
I
I
Registered Agent
Name & Address
cr CORPORA nON .I)VSTEM
J1tJO SOlrrH 1'1NEfSLAN[) ROAD
PLA:-\TAf]CJN n. 3JJ~ij
~""mC' (ll~r\l!~d: 03/H..-1003
AddfCS~ Ch~~fed: OJflOf,WO,?
:=J
]
I
-~
Officer/Director Detail
r-
comllw OR 1)7':h')(;
II Title I
~D
-~c:J
li I
Name & Add,'css
HENOERSON. EVEltF.:rT R JR.
2400 CrtESTi\t{10R J{OAO
:-::,\SHVILLE n~ 37215
OALEY, PAUL M
9lJW (DRl,){G !NDL'STRIAL \VA Y
KIM(I!\LL, CllAJU.ES
'>1 no COBt:RG INDUSTRIAL \VA Y
http://www.sunbiz.orglscriptslcordet.exe?al ~DETFIL&n 1 ~P9700()()77469&n2=NAMFWD&n3=OOO1 &n... 5/312007
i\genda Item ~~D. SA
November 27. 2007
Page r, of 190
Division of CorporatiOlls
COl]UJtG OR 9f~(lli
L.-.:~)_~
JC:--J
I _
c
CQlIURG DR 91401\
NEl'L:TE, JOliN \\'
<}IYWCOlllJRG INDUSTRIAI_ WAY
Annual ReDorts
L____-" Report Year IL_ Filed Date -I
1---.----- '"'"" If" o."n~'o" --.J
L__ 2t/i)') ___ .JI Hl.li3/201)(. :J
L lM7 =:IL. 0.c1l1ll/2IiIl7 =.J
--------. ----'J-'
L__~~vious l~mnG._
U~~~~f"in_LJ
I Rl!tum to List.
Vi~.w EY~llts
View Name History
Document Images
Listed below are the images avaiJable for this filing.
lMl20.f2QQ7.=AN1'lliALll.llI'Ql!T
litmLZPill.=l:!M!lti::hl\!lllll
1 OIJJf2J)9~I\N-.!:lliALB.ill'Q.Il.I
\1'!IQSOJ1Q9"~AL.REtQRT
!Wl!1aQQ~IiNUAL REPORT
04126/20.0.4.. A~~
omDa.OO3 ANNHALREIDJ!.I
2J1p3no03 Reg A1:zent Cham'o
!l2IW2002 Alllil!A1J'JlJ>QJl.I
QlLUa~.ANllliA1.&El'Qjl.I
olma~
Q1ll&tlilOO ANNHAL.EEroJIT
]}W1999 Alill!lAI, llJlEQB.I
o.31.lli122~..=-AilllliAL1J.ru'QRT
09/Qm22].=l).9!!,cstic P.rofit Articles
TIllS IS NOT OFFICIAL RECORD; SEE DOCUMENTS IF QUESTION OR CONFLK.'T
htlp://www.ounbiz.orwscnptslcordet.exe?al=DETFIL&nl =P970000774<i9&n2=NAMFWD&n3=OOO1 &n.. 5/3/2007
livision of Corporations
Agenda Item ~-jo, 8,11,
November 27. 2007
Page 72 of 190
NAPLES MOTORCOACH RESORT, INC.
Document Number
P97000077469
Oat. Flied
0'110811997
,Effective Date
0'110511997
Status
Active
i~
iE\TN'J TnT
I
1___,__..-_
11~' "I' ('11 A ,-}( 'I'
!-u\ c ." '... ., ,"
FlLCD
DATE
C fTE:CT!\"E
flAT!':
DESCIUPTIO;\'
1
I
OI,LV]OOI
OLD N;\:vlE WA,~ UUTDOOH I~ES()]{TS OF N
,\PLES, iNC
A;vll.:~<r))\'IENT
AA1J~~.;n:vlD<T
07:'}."/)(I(I{/
THIS IS NOT OFFIClAL RECORD; SEE I)OCUMENTS IF QUESTION OR CONFLICl
;(,,0'( ,:;;",C't).;,;;, :..'5'i~:.;';:it~d..f\w
"'\""~'l{B"urq :lOns.":""tt<'t:iLh'M~
'_:'~~~~i~/~5r~}fr';?c~~1i?~Wf?~\1}':~~~~J;!a}",;J
hUp://www.sunbiz.orglscripts/corevt,exe?aI ""DETEVE&n I =P97000077469&n2=DOMP
5/3/2007
)jvisiOl,l of Corporations
Agenda Item No. SA
Novembel' 27, 2007
Page 73 of 190
ForeiGn Profit
b
MONACOCOACHCORrORATION
"~---
._--.---- ,.,
-~--~-<~. ._-~- ~.~..,._..-.~--
- __0....___'"______'.' __.__
PRINCIPAL ADDRESS
91320 COBURG lNDUSTRlAL WAY
COBURG OR 97408 US
Changed 08/0611997
'._-,.,__ ~_, ._ .,.____..,_...._.,._~__....._m'_
--'_...,._~_...._.-.__..-..-..- ..-
MAILING ADDRESS
91320 COBURG INDUSTRIAL WAY
COmJRG OR 97408 US
Changed 07/0211996
Uocultlent Nwnber
1'930??oo2303
FEI Numhu
351SS0244
1)"1e FlIed
05/14/1993
State
DE
St.tUI
ACl1YE
Effedive Date
NONE
Regl~tered Agent
Name & Address
1
I
C T CQRI'ORATlON
no!) ~(}l1T1l1'INE ISLA;\'D RD.
l'l..\NT ATION n. DJH
OfficerlDirector Detail
C'. Name &: Addr?ss _ __C':~!!I_l"_]
l' \'ANOL.,ml:r<O,"OOlmA" ~[--"~'I
1....__._ 1 lib ""OMA'; 1I0U"d" nt.'",," "" ~j J)
1....~~~~~=~==.':I<>~~~~;:;~~~~~::).'~~~ ---=~=~~-]L~ ~~_. '
'nllo j"QrJURtI t<!)U~trRI."1. .....^); J'
. .. \'f~li_tmO{)Kg.74~__ __.,_ ____.__,
[ ROl,,,,,, Rldri"'", I ",:-l
1~jOtlS^~(JbA";SCA.'jU61'1 ~
[ - ':;~~;;~" - ..... '~]
i----..... ... ...' I
http://www.sunbiz.orglscriptslcordet..exe?al =DETFIL&nl =F93000002303&n2=NAMFWD&n3=OOOO&.. 5/1412007
Division of C01l1orations
Aaenda Item hJo. SA
I~"ovembel 27. 2007
Page 74 of 190
T{)l>LSON, KII Y
') UUl com;!w INl1USTR1Al, W.>\,'I:'
CllllllRG On 'rl<1lJ;s
l-=J
~8
[
('UflUI{O 0[, 9-;.108
IMLEY, r,UJL'\!
',[12U ('()fll.'ltG J~D\;ST!{IAL w.~ y
f\.1lI1ual Reports
L__~__. RCr>OI.tyC"'=:]C - Filed Dote
l__==-~~"-,-'~-- .~-~___~C_, .-- 1)~YJ7!J(t,i5
[=--=~:~------- .:~__ _ ~~--_._JL- (1~-tJS..'2(1(!I,'
r--_'-~--~----"~7~-----'--JI ().ii"2-O!1007
.~~J
--:~_ _-_I
--=-=:J
l
~-~-----_.._---------~---
---._--~------ '.---..---.---------.- .-----.-...-----.-------
1~';;,vic:C,sf'ling.-J j--RelUnliOli&tl
No Events
No Name History InfoIDJation
(---i"oxtF:jjing- _I
---.---._~......_----
Document Images
Listed below arc tbe images available for this filing.
Q<!12.Q,1;!.l!Q1.",_,"-NNUAL REPORI
lMlQ).L2QQk.ANtl1l.AUUlI'.QlIT
W.7.l2Qllk.bW:illAL..REl'.QJIT
~
Q.5LQS12Qll3 ANNU.II.L.RElro.RI
0212li2902 -. ANl'jUAL REPORT
!lU/Q/2001 - ANNlJAL.BEI'Q!U
00lm~Rl:
OQili/.ll'22.=ANNlJAL REPOIIT
01!21Ll22ac ANNUAL..IWff!1IT
m!lOJiLl.2.21.:- ANNUAL REroRI
lOlLL'l9&..:: ANlillAUillPPLT
O..8llJ1LJ.29bAl'illllbkREPQRT
THlS IS NOT OFFIClAL RECORD; SEE DOCUMENTS IF QUESTION OR CONFLICT
http://www.sunbiz.orgiscriptsicordetexe?al =DETFIL&nl=F93000002303&n2~NAMFWD&n3=OOOO&.. 5/1 412007
~
-0
" .(......
\. \.\
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27,2007
4006894 OR: 4211 PG: ~3~'575 of 190
RlCORllBD fn omcm mOiDS gl CllLLlI1 Cllllm. PI
~\111/1001 at 11:11AK DilGBT I. BIOCI, CLIRI
COIS 8001000.00
DC tl'l 52.50
OilC- .10 5&000.00
This instrument prepared by and
alll.... recording return 10:
Retn:KICHILLI H1ClI
llJiKIl SIITIIII11
PO 801 311l
TAMPl rL 11101 1111
Timothy M. Hughos, Esquire
AKERMAN SENTERFITT
401 E. Jackson Street
Suite 1100
Tampa. F10fida 33602
Telephone: (813)223-7333
-~AOO'V{lljlSllNt-rOH~[M.T.-.r----~'-----
THIS WARRANTY 0
as of the 19th day of April.
See Exhibit "N attached hereto and made a part hereof.
TOGETHER WITH aU the tenements. hereditaments and appurtenances Iherelo
belonging or in any way appertaining.
TO HAVE AND TO HOLD the same unto Grantee in fee simple, forever.
tTP2&.%<Jt:2l
,
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27, 2007
OR: 4217 PG; 33~sge 76 of 190
.
AND Grantor hereby covenants wilh Grantee: (1) that Grantor is lawfully seized
of the Real Property in fee simple; (2) that Grantor has good right and lawful authority to
sell and convey the Real Property; (3) that Grantor hereby fully warrants the tiUe to the
Real Property and will defend the same against the lawful daims of all persons
whomSQe~er. and (4) Ihat the Real Property is free of all encumbrances, except !axes
and assessments accruing subsequent to December 31, 2006, and is subject to zoning,
and those matters described on Exhibit "8" attadled hereto, provided, however,
reference thereto shall not serve to reimpose same.
Wherover usod herein, the terms .Cramo..- and "Grantee"' shall be deemed 10 i"dude aU U16
patties 10 Ihis W3fTanty Deed and tho-heirs. lagal raprosentalives and assIgns of indivWuals
:and the successors and assigns of corporations. The singular shan be d(,.>emed to include the
plural. ~od vice versa. 'Nherc the context so pemlilo;..
Signature
P7/i L..,
Sig lu e
~$
Print Name:
L, ~(l '-~1,tt-
[ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ATTACHED ON FOLLOWING PAGEl
ITr1:84b91:11
2
STATE OF FLORIDA
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27. 2007
Page 77 of 190
OR: 4217 PG; 3357
COUNlY OF COLLIER
The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this -1Z!!:day or April.
2007 by Jerome J. Guidish, as President of GREYST<{N}', PARK MOBilE HOMES. INC.,
a Florida COrporation, on behalf of the corporation. He ~ personally known to me or r ]
has produced as identification.
Notary Stamp
1Tl'1l!A69Ul
e. lJS.\RaEeSMm
. -, IWo - .. <It Fbilo
. c--..e-.
c--..
Ilondo.t .
3
Agenda Item No. 8A
. November 27, 2007
OR: 4217PG: 3J5rlge78of190
. .
Exhibit aA"
Property legal Description
Parcoll
Commencing at the Northeast comer of Block l, HENDERSON CREEK PARK 1ST
ADDITION, as recorded in Plat Book 8, Page 41, of the public records of Collier County,
Florida. said Northeast comer being the intersection of Ihe Southwesterly right-<lf-way line
of U.S. Highway 41 (Tamiami Trail) and the Westerly right-of-way line of Henderson Dive,
run Soulh 00 dog 41 min 40 see Wesl. along the East line of said Block L. for 236.61 feet
to the POINT OF BEGINNING; thence continue south 00 deg 41 min 40 see West, along
said East line. for 641.92 feet 10 a point hereinafter 10 be known as Point "A"; thence run
North 69 deg 24 min 50 see Wes!. parallel with and 65.00 feet distant from, as measured
at right angles to. the Northerly right-<lbway,ii1JlrQ onderhen Drive as shown on said plat
of HENDERSON CREEK PARK E ~)\not>m9ttJR~ 15.12 feet; thence run North 59
deg 28 min 27 sec West, for 1 A , ; ~~Qft 9 dog 24 min 50 sac West. for
305.00 feet; thence nm Nor1 69J eg 17 min 06 see >Nt} .\1 dicated on plat as being
North 29 deg 28 min 46 se W tq-alongib~W~ 'ne of ot~' Block J of said pial, for
126.23 feet; thence conlin e t, ruH'WortpJ eg 06 se We t. for 207.47 feet to a point
hereinafter to be known a P ~~~~m' 1 g. min 37 see West, for
45.00 leetlo a point on II e 's fin 0 s id I ; ru along said Wesl/ine,
19624 feel along the arc . J ~ ~~ e rt w $\;< aving radius of 2854.93
feet and sublended by a ldr having aTEmgth 0 ~96.2 f f!JI d bearing North 36 deg 05
min 14 see East; thence (l~ uth 54 deg 20 min. ,s cst' along Block l, for 798_33
feet; thence run North 00 de:y}~~in 40 see East,.~~~ ck l. for 81539 feet;
thence run South 54 deg 20 m n(~~ ['ast, for~e 10 the POINT OF
BEGINNING_ :;; );--..____. (^\)\
',.zrr: erR' /
Parcel II ~. - -'-
A tract of land being part of vacated Blocks A and B, HENDERSON CREEK PARK.
recorded in Plat Book 6, Page 8, of the public records of Collier County, Florida and being
described as follows:
From the Northeast corner of said Block A. run North 54 deg 20 min 16 see West, 426_38
feel along the Tamiami Trail for a POINT OF BEGINNING; U)ence SOUUl 00 deg 41 min
40 sec West. 1052.00 feet; thence North 54 deg 20 min t6 see West 796.33 foot to the
centerline or a County drainage easement, recorded in OR. Book 76, Page 127, of said
public records; thence 690.95 feet along the arc of a curve, being the aforedescribed
centerline of said oasement. concave to the Northwest, having a radius of 2654 .93 feet
and a chord bearing North 27 deg 11 min 40 see East. 688.37 feet; thence North 20 deg
U:glil dc.scriptioo 04tuinoo from Chic~o Titk- lruUrvlC( COI1VV'Y
('~tmcnt No.l00w)Il14, Oat(: Erfct:tNc: July 11. 1006
~:July16,]~
nr28469I:lJ
"
OR: 4217
Agenda Item No. SA
PG,N"iVJflPer 27,2007
. JJPage 79 of 190
16 min 12 sec East. 187.96 leel along said centerline of easement to said Tamiami Trail;
thence South 54 deg 20 min 16 see East, 346.67 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING.
Parcel III
A portion of Block l, HENDERSON CREEK PARK 1 ST ADDITION, as recorded in Plat
Book 8, Page 41, of the public records of Collier County, Rorida, more particularly
described as follows:
Commencing at the Southeast comer of Section 3, Township 51 South, Range 26 East.
Tallahassee Meridian, Collier County, Florida; thence North 89 deg 24 min 50 see West,
along the South line of said Section 3, for 60 feet 10 the extended centerline of Henderson
Drive; thence North 00 deg 41 min 40 sec East. along said extended centerline and also
the centerline of Henderson Drive. 6~~loj1l;t~~rs.eeclion of Sonderhen Drive; thence
North 69 deg 24 min 50 see Wes ,.ar~\itlit.cerlt~t1it1e;o Sonderhon Drive. 50 feet to the
West right-of-way of Henderso. Qlj~;-"fI)ence No 41 min 40 see East. along said
West Iight-of-way. 973.53 fe fu1t(e Soulhweslerly rig f-W{lY of Tamiami Trail, U.S. 41,
to \he POINT OF BEGINNI G; 11~.Q.1/ 20 m 16 see West, along said
Southwesterly light-of-wa lin of i'!imlllf1!i fuil. 0. . 41. 4 8.3 feet; thence South 00
deg 41 min 40 see West. r 6f'\1~; min 16 see East. parallel
to Tamiami Trail. U.S. 41 for 2':3BI t; d 9 1 min 40 sec Ea~l. 236.61
feet to said Southwester! M ~ I iI. . 41. which is the POINT
OF BEGINNING. t,--\ -.... S
\P 0
,h"~ (,
Parcel IV ; \ 0 ^\.
'./.' ~;-:uc0
Easemenl interest for conslructioiNl lfd@i@'~ee- of a sewer line(s) and ingress and
egress for tho purpose of maintaining s I sewer line(s) as set forth in lhat rertain
Easement Agreement recorded at O.R Book 588. Page 458. of tile Public Records of
Comer County, Florida. as affected by thai certain Subordination of Easement lecorded at
OR Book 1401, Page 1101, of tho Public Records of Collier County. Florida.
U:2.1IkKriptiot> fObumrd from ClUca;au Tille Jnll>lWltot;C(,l!'lV'">>Y
CCJmQlilJn(nl No. 20060)&7A. Due EJt<<tjyc: J<<ly J 1.2006
P.evmd; Jll~)l26. 2006
lTf'lU69I~2J
:
Agenda Item No. SA
Novemb1r,;;7,2007
*** OR: 4217 PG: 336>8gl>l'il{)of190
Exhibit "an
Permitted Excoptlons
1.
Taxes and assessments for the year 2007 and subsequent Ye<lrs, which are not yet due
and payable.
Navigational and drainage easement running Northeasterly and Soulhwesterly along the
Weslem boundary line of Parcels I and II of the Property as denoled on the plat lor
Henderson Creel< Parl< 1" Addition recvrded in Platllool< 8, Page 41. Pubfic Records of
Collier County, and aU other matters denoted on such pla~ as well as all other matters
denoted on the plat lor Henderson Clee!< Parlt recorded in Pial Book 6, Page 8, Public
Records of Collier County. AOlida. but spodfically excluding any other navigational aoo
drainage easements shown on either of such plats. (as to Parcels I and II)
2.
3.
Drainage Easement in lavor 01 CgJJi6r~\y;-a~litical subdivision of the Stale of Florida
recorded in OH Book 76, P <!;.1~R&bfic s of Collier County. Florida, which
CClTects easement re~'rJ'o;R:1>OOk 67:'P ~, Public Records of Collier County,
Florida. (as to Parcels I ~J~
Outfali Drainage Ea , t irl~a'"'l[ clUlli' nty, a I subdiVISion of lhe Stale of
Florida recorded in .R. 5..-~ . s f Collier County, Florida. (as
10 Parcels I aoo II) U
Oil and mineral righ ~ 1_ ly Deed recorded in OR
Book 194, Page 191 fCllic Records of Collie . (as to Parcel II)
'(fl. ;..,,)
Oil and mineral rights, -..:~ right 01 enby, ros~! ~ j (' nty Deed recorded in O.R.
Book 322, Page 225, P 1CCJ:~s of Collier ~njl:;. Frida. (as to Parcel II)
'/., ~ _____--" 0:-
Terms and conditions of Easem~~ljmi'lJor. slrudion and maintenance of Sewer
~ne rerorded in O.R. Book 588, P"!l~511~led by SubordinaUon of Easement
recorded in O.R. 800k 140t. Page 1101.l>oth of the Public Records of CoII;.,r County.
Fkxida. (as to Parrel IV)
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
Easement in lavor of United Telephone Company 01 Rorida, a l-1orida CO!]Xlration, recorded
in O.R. Book 937. Page 1944, Public Records of Collier County, Florida. (as to Parcell)
9.
Easement in favor of Florida Power & Light Company, a Florida corporation, recorded in
OR Baal< 944, Page 625, Public Records of Collier County, Florida. (as to Parcel III)
r~iiltt:d Exttptll'os ubt.Unb:1 fromChiCllJn Tille 1o"l.ll'WlCt; ~1
Commilmcnl No.. 20060)87( (}a~ EffC'dive: Jo'y 11,:w06
l\iCVi~: July 26, 2006
ITP'ZS469i:?1
,
.. ~ ~ ~ ....
rl:! 7 . I . !
cuu,,:, :: ::'17Y
r ,'~'~ ~', ;--..22'1
Agenda l1em No. SA
November 27, 2007
PageS101190
."'" I' -'0 ,u. v'
9, fj.l~
I, I
)/' This instrument prepared,
recording requested by and
~hen recorded mail to:
JAMES W. ~LKINS, P.A.
suite 303, The Fairway auilding
1000 TamiaMl Trail North
Naples, Florida 33940
RC,".:...)
,.'dt.O
-,......
, 0' \ 'l. 1\\\\1
~U&
GaBRAL lIAIIIlJlJft'r DBED
TREON'S KW IK SHOP OF NAPLES, rLORIDA, INC., a Florida
corporation, the Grantor,
in consideration of the sum of
$265,000.00 received from JOSEPH J. GUIDISH, the Gx:antoee, of
"-
~
1.3300 Bast Tamitlomi Trail, Naples, Plorida 33942, heroby, on this
~eptember 1982, conveys to the Grantee in fee simple the
reaL property in COHie,V-cO\i"~e~"'s.~~ibed aSI
A portion of BJ.,&J~"L~-1iBIt1ltRSOF"CR-E.'i~~';-'Lst ADDITION,
according to pt~ '~...P1'at Book S, page ~-I'O}e-"pactioularlY
described aS/f~~11 . .. . .~.-..
commenClf/at t. e~l.l.t.hea..a.t corner of Sect) on.3, T wnship 51
south, Ra ge 2 E~~l' T&ll'aha-aaee.....M.,eri ian, llie County,
Florida, hf:'nce N...4t9'ti~,.V50" w. along t e South line of said
section fori 60 feet to\!:.be e tended enterlin of ender-
son Dri e, ~h>.n'E:e:,'N~ P'O?'l"'<~ . '1'~ -tt>em'd e tended
centerl ne "rid 15,\\ efcl t r 0 \en_tile 0,1 Or ve 600
feet .t~ th.~. (>.'n~rs~t~on~Of Oir e D~e, the'nce N.
8'9024'5 . w.l\al ng t e ee te 1 n F-tf{ S de he D~i e, 50
feet to t;J\""e 'W-es \.._R.i~li - -l'l'ay.; 0 ders D iV"~ nee N.
00041140 "-E/ hibn.g:::;sai ""w. tv'Ri.. t-way .3...:53 f ,e~ to tbe
south.".es f'j'1\ Ri9ht-of-way of Tami Tra!, 0.. " to the
point. of -~gi ningJ 1L(.\^..l.-....::
\.,-). .,JX~t~..j
Thence N~~-l.F~~'H. W. aLonq. the saia~i%"~~W9.t..~y llight-
of~way ~i'i.o.,)1':". m1am> TrH1, U.S. H. ",$. If.f:e" ,thence
s.. 0'41'40"\\(. f .236.61 feet, thenc .\.-S,Jt 20'16" E.
paraHeL to 'J'.a,mfaJ, ~ail. U.s. 41, for.fi~~8 eet, thence
N.O ll'41'401t E. 203"6;1+' t=~-t...to the SZli..d~..pdl:.~ terly Right-
of-Way ane of '*e Tg>m~-.'1 "I~.tr1':r;;l.t.'S\.Jp. which 15 the
Point of Begi nning ,""~l.lf~.rJ.~o~~~\:~.:.?.~J..dti.
~,------......-
\,n
'-"
Q
-5)
~
,.
r-
and grants to the Grantee all appurtenant caseTt'.ent(s), if any,
~
~
~
1
and covenant(s), except as provided below, that at the time of
delivery of this ap.ed;
1. the real prol?erty is free of all encumbrances;
2. lawful sei61n of and good tight to convey thE ~eal
property i:l.re vested in the Grantoe (6);
3. tbe real pLoperty is not homestead propertYI and
4. the Grantor(s) hereby fully and generally warrant,(s)
the title to the real property and .....111 defend the same
against the lawful claims of all persona WhOnl60evet.
However, only actual damages, not to exceed the consideration
sta.ted a01Jve, may be recovered f1J[ breach hereof..
Thi s deed
discharges all of the obligations of Grantor{s) under the sales
L
L
a
;;0
CD
<=>
a
:;><:
<::>
"'"
<::>
(Q
co
co
'"0
l>
""
,."
<::>
<=>
""
...
....
,
,.
contract, and Grantee(s) AhaI! hereafter rely only upon th~
covenants contained herein.
This deed and the real property are subj act to;
1.
Oeclara tian., condi tions t r &s& rva ti ons, r estr j ctlona,
limitations and easements 8S listed in a title opjnion
given to Grantee(s) or in a SchedUle of exceptions to
coverage in any title insur4nce policy insuring the
interests of Grantee(B) in the property, or of tecord,
or which are visible, if any, but this provision shall
not operate to re-i~poBe the same.
Zoning and other governmental regulations affecting the
use and occupancy oC the real property.
Taxes and aG8eB6~ents for current and subsequent years.
PUrchase money mortgage given to Grantor(a) by
Crantee(s) herein to B~CUre the Bum of
$200,000.00.
2.
J.
4.
Signed in th e pr eSe-nee of:
(Corp. Seal)
TREON'S KW IK SHOP OF
..-_----".,Pr;'~..,....!~ORIDA, INC~,,'
~ \ ~lbRCOrJ'-'~ /
" ~~ 0- ~~;./---sy:-..:~tv)')<~".-. ~1 ,'.i .
0.' (! Its .... .--,\.
/ ~~ ;:j;" i-,-' ~ ',- \
l.thess,' I I 1'c} ---_..f'i ,'.' .'"
-"".....". Attcel: \; "'U ../ '~.'.,..' ".
I i~::-1 -~":, .\
I ( ("\.!/ '.'J.A.... ~ . ,'~~-
Ii 1<:.;\.:1,- ,.1. (j~~" .ILl V Gr. tor.
Ii \h.'",~ '-Ie, 'co,, 0'~ \ 1
\ (") \ (e::' ,".v'" c' ,,' /:.....
STATE OF FLOR~C^..; \ "".""'11 m )~Il:~. 1, er D. ;."...
COONTY OF eOL '{~:~:\ \ bY. )11. ~. ",,0
I her'.ebY..-oi-c'(rtlfy that on tll1.5 dti', ,~e orff m~.i Notary
Public dUly aue,~r9'T,\.z'ed in the state and ,i!ntpr -6ied <1.bov to
tak.e ackno""ledglIle,n,t'p~r:Retsonal1Y appeared _ . , ,
to me known to be\..,the(o;...p~tson describod as Prqs1.d r'C/of TREON'S
KWIK SHOP OF NAPLES.(tFiJg.k'I~A, INC., n FloS~<..~,q~.dratiQn, and
who executed the fore9:~3(h9' .Wl!'N.4nty d~e ,......i,n...;tllE~\,l).alne of and for
that corporation, affik~~g ~~..F~~~a .~;p,al'~~/€hat co~poration:
that as such corporate of~(coF.1t '!Lt(pe .f.\?c. '-i~."..euly authorized by
that corporation to do so; a-rrd....t-i..~.:t:h..~.E.of'e;going warranty deed
isthe act ancl deed of that corporation.
Witness my hand and official seal in the county and state
named ab~"'/AllPSt~il;j' ~ September 19B2~
~",~\s ",. r I rl.,.,~~,
f~~~':'-"'~~."':'~ ~)\
[ (~<>tg~rJe~~) j
V/:~~~i.~)>~
"~''-'''' lir.R\\l~' ,\.",.,.
"011'1,,"11'
H,.:.-r', h 1.,_ <.I'.:r.: '. . 1" " !'1'~
Del"tv'!tf'rgO'.,and:.,~eptance of this deed by the Gcantee is
hereby acknowledged.
/
, /- -
Date: ,,,~.,. ~ ,';",.
~~
tary PUbli~
M commissio expires:
~
/~.~'
I
/'
,./
/.
.~ 0/1';,/
j
/
~/..
treon.w/d(OfI9.17.B2
~,. ~.
2
L
Agenda Item No. 8A
, November 27.2007
Page 82 of 190
C> =
;0 ""
"" =
C) '"
C) Q;I
:>< Q)
""
<:>
"
,... N>
"'....
m ....
, ":,
-:
. .
.01.823156
llro~nUllTY IlF'CORDEO
PRM :1_ 'rnet.:r:uNII1't Pr~pa.J:'Il'd.'bY1
aul ~. "~ve~u. K~q.
DOC 2UO Qol6an OaU hrltw~y
INT_p, o. a~ 8117
INO_ Nap1u, J.")orl.,Q. JHU..Il1.).7
K1t;hQUt. OPiniQI1 &14 Witho,-,t
bllnetit or ~~~10~t{~~ Dr ~~~16
/,
.,
,
OUl94lJ
OR BOOK
941'1AllS PH12.03
~
'rUtS' QU:tT.C1.I\IM t:>nD, 6XL'::~",.;;ea chiD J,lith. day ot May, 1!.1$4.. by <JoMpn J. Guidhn.
tndi~idu&11y and ~o Truote~ QRANiQR. QRANTOR, ~ith ~~ll r~nr and Quthori~y Ilith~r
tg prCt~ct. con8e~Q, ~n~~Qrl n~ll. convny. .or bo oth~~i80 mAnag6 ot dinpoee ~t
thb ~e41 p~op8r~y de~~ri~d h~~ci", to G~tsTO~~ p~ ~BrL~ H~S. t>>C'j ~ Florida
aorpor.~eion. GRnNTBII who~o POQ~ o(flce ft~drenn 1ft ~3]OO E. T~i~m1 T~~ 1. Napl~6.
F~otid(\ ):I:9H.
tb4~ th~ Q~td GRANtoR tor and in cOft~ide~Qtion of th~ ftUW of T~N DOtLhRS and
othol:' gOQd aod .......J,ucbJ,tt cOl1l1'iduntiolJ1f in h4.l'ld pa..1d by ~1lI fidel QRA~fMur. t.ha 1OlIet!lJ.,pt .
~he~oot ~R h6~6by aQknQ~led90d, do~a h~r~by ~em~9~. ~ele6~o. an~ quit.cl~k~ un~~ tbu
'Gie Q~&5 fQ^eV~~. ~ll the Tigh~. tl~~o. intere~~. OAftt. bnd damanrt wh1eh the ~nid
O~ haD i~ ~n~ to th~ fQ~lowl~9 de~cri~d lot, ploee O~ pare61 of l6nd. ~LtU6tO.
lying an~ ~Ging in the CQun~y of COLLIBR, Scate 0% rlo~~d&l to ~~t:
~~9bl de~c%ipt~on au ~ho atthQned Sxhi~it ~h~.
'tnx FollQ. No,
'TO ru'NB Nm TO HDU;l t::'ho .8ll11'iO llogat.'hoX" vith aU nod sin9'\llooX' the ol\Ppu~tanAnCell
ther6untO balongins or !n t!lnywaYR Appn~t.!~in9. And all the qDt~~~. ~~ght. tl~~a.
LtH;!!'~(\I(l't. l!~l'&. eq..1ity 6.o.d ~ll;l.;lm \lhllt:.~~ve1' or the IlI\J.d GSl'NiTO~. b~tho'( in ,hi,,,, QT.
equ~~y to thD only proper u~e. b~nefit &~d behoof DC tho ~Ai6 QRANTR2 tO~GVe~.
~DWiI'OR. und "CHUIN"!''cn''' !l.re uRfold fot: Id."tlgvlA;r: Ole' plllt"I'lJ.. .dR t.h(1 context. m~-y
),..~quir6 .
tN WITNXQS WH~~OP. ~a!d G~OR hns he~ountQ ~~t GRAN1O~'S hand ~d ~~~l ~hQ
day and year tir~t ~ove ~tceon.
gtgn6~, <<a4~6d ~d ~~liV$;r:6d
in ths p~~ft~~ce of:
fl4~v t:)1,l(lil:r' MIS l\&
M'A.'r1; 011' FUlP.IOA
COUNTY or ~11~
I HtREBf CERTIFY tho.t ~ thin d~y, bs~oX"e m4, an o!!ieat ~ly authati:~~ In the
Stat~ a.to'resdd And in the CoU1lt~~~~~r : ~ llcknQwlrt.dgment.ll. perDl;mAl1.y
appearad ~o<<e~b J, Quid!~h. ~ho ~PttrDonally ~~~ t roo to b& tho pl!l;r:oon d6m~~lbe~
1n 61'ld who tl~l!lO\.ttl!lt1 th., to:(O~olr.ig""1t...lu 041,(1,4 Iltld I. 4(:knOW;l.edgQd bl!!tfQ~ Ule eho.t. he
6x~cut(td. t.h(\ f1M\fl1. OIlt;0d thb 1'1'.;1\ da.y of M4.y. 1'94. ,
~t.iI--
No ."" ,""Lt. fl.. I t 1/,.,,1'1/\0')
My CowoJ.rHdon R)q;Iirlltl: "
c~~i~n~on NuMbor:
---
ti' '.
. ,
. ~
PAIA.K. f1ElJl:IlM.\M
IIoUrlP..olte.Shttts1fl
t1Jec....t~,.1I'tlca. 1.ms.
toIoIl.l'Cl.ct)~
_&RelamTo:
4Pau1K.HOUOOMn
KoIY,-.BI<ot&H-~
, P.o,l!<>(8117
NIpIooo !'tS39-llo/ltt7
Jlel;cf\'tld S_./~~':.10CIC:::'ltfrr St.l\l!lt\ Tillr
R~~t\teQ S I 0\", 'C. lnl.an'Pb)e
" p. Pmo., I II'v~"t1 tax
OHlO"1 !. Of:X~. L'.r.";~ or C ..~ll COURT
at D.C.
PUDZ.2006-AR.j 0648
PROJECT #2006060057.DATE: 10113/06
KA Y DESELEM
..__...,..n._~"
~\.'. Y i09/2006/TUE II: 21 AM
LOU.
,RICKSON, P. A.
FAX NQ, 239 353
\8
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27, 2007
Page 84 of 190
p. OC2
...
,\j .e.,l;{'''t ~<'..Qc\
,t
"
.
01.823156 :-.IUT 18 fll~03
;~" G~I!cll'......... ~........~~pRDED
..~.;: .aul k. Mt\Nlrun.. bQ.
41~_ .uu aoltS&D Ct..1:. ".rkl,i:~y
oi:1 -11. o~ .ao. 111'7
""'1__ ~:1..... '.)01'141, 130'&1..'11'7
lo'i~DUr. q:tialco II.Cld V.lt.bOl1t;
114Ntlt;: of ~oa~lQD ct T.l.r.le
001948
III BOOK
001252
"";E
CO%'1'-.............. b~
'nUS Qal':'.C1.Jl.D( m:::%l, ~cuull Pli:!.. 11th c1a~' ~t __Y. .15"". :by Joa.ph,'J. Guiduh.
ind.h..i~lly o1l.D4 ... 't'rusu... ~. ~. v.l.u- r:l.alJ.. poWlr &.a11 ,,"ut.hor.f.1:)" Ilhh'U"
r;o prQt'="C't. CClQ.aen.., 1IIZ1~Z'. ..11. C'C!GytlY. ~ tllll D~i.. aulaSl'_ oz: dJ.~D'. at
~6 rtal prcpltlt'Cy ~.~!btd httnlln. t:o OREYSTC:KI I'AAJ: _fur HtMB.S, 1'HC'., It FloriO.
t:'<npCtr_dtm. ~. vbQall pen ofti~ ~.. 1_ :uaoo I.. -r-lud. 'Z'1'.il~ ~le..
J'1.orida H9H.
That t:ha &aid ~ for -.nd iJ::l cDa65.d.lrrat'iaa. af" en. .1.1III C!" ':E2{ DOL1oJUI.9 _IS
ot:h.r llClQd !lAcS 'lIal\1.&bl. CClI'3161nt1.0Qa b:l h&:clcS paid by t).w ....id G1IXlft'S~. t~ fi~:lpC.
..m.~.of i. hereby .cll;:Qo.,l.~. dotIa :iwraby ~.-1.., ~.1..... IWd VLl.l:I;-C'l.iII t.IOto the
Nl11 ~ I'MaWlr, all the rlg!:lt.. tiel. 1J2,t.er68t.. Clab! UIotl lSIIaand. wi=- the 8a10
CRAln"aR ha.. 1.D cad 'too the 'f:ollcw.b.1# 4ear:rib;d IDt:. piece or ~~l o~ Iud. ..1tu.a't'e.
lying _tJ: ~i' .:ia u.. Cmwty at ctl~ER. Itat;" of 'lodOa.. 'to ri~:
Legal t!4.cr!Pt:1on an ehfll a.tt-.dUll!. ~lblt -A-.
'1'ax. Folio No.
'l'O JlA'lJJ:: JlJ'm TO HOLD w. .... t:a;reoth.r "lth all aJl.tl w:iagu}.qo Clio. a,ppurt8aaDCU
thel;'Cl,lQto DlilCICIg"i.a.D c:r 10 ~.Y. ~d'AiDllI. -.n4.11 UJ. ..tate. d.Vh!:. t.1U.,
int.:o=...t. 110ft; equl't:)" &Dd e14u.. \ItNItao..va.. ~ th. -.14 tmNflOll. ai-r..MZ' .1", la. 0:-
~1 ty 'to th. aa1~ prgpezo \188. beD.,Ut -.ad );;leboof of thII _:let o.RAIrl'ml ~o~r.
re\u:LiE":~IUUtt'OR' ~4 -CJJOl.la'tI- ..r. \I..a ;tOll; aLns\llar bZ' pl1SYlIlJ., .. the CClftt:a2Ct ~
or VI~a ~p. -.....:ld G:R.J.N7OJt"'" b&T-.Il.D:lt:o aet: C\U\NrOR.'1; ~ _d ...1. 'th.
Wry _d par t'J;r~\; Iabo.... vr1'tt.N\.
S1gne4. ..aJ.lld &Il.~ dlaUYal:'olll ~.
ia tbe pqaeac. of" I
rj~~~t ~~. A
)I" . i../,,~'n
r=. ';;; . .~...' ',--......uy.""...
w.~ .
t'!Nc",ur M U rt+y
;a>rtl.1=.~
STz..:ta' ru n.oJU.DA.
0XDrn'. QJI' CQ.L.1.7U;
.r.ldI;JlEZy.~".-tha1;':.f:llllI.th1a-day., ,bIl:ea~. .-e,..M_ cUl~_~(WJ.Y"'\lUlor.i.s.lt .J.ft..the.
Sut. Uox..ud aad ia. ~ ~:=r:: tJ!; ~1~ta.. p.l!r.ezra,.],1.y
~~~ .:r_~ OJ. 0Ui4i.~, .~ ~ly la:KNzL _ ~o a:. tbtt ~"CIQ ....c:rl.hoo4
i.tI &Nl 'lObO ~cu.'t:ed. the tongo:l.Cl _ekDowl.dqruS botoxe ..,. l;JM,t be
Q;.ewtod eM...... Da:t.d 'thh 16th clay of Vely. 1.99.~ .
-- --U2Tt.1l-'.'
,-:
. 01.8231 56 9~tl~lla PHI2'03
~~~~~~'!t_.n' "oP.".~~?ROED
aul K. H~VermAn. a~q.
DOC ~uo Ooldl!l~ 0"\:.0 S>llrkW'I\Y
INT -P. O. Bt;>>!: un
INO_ "Ap.1.Uj tl'lodda. 31'U~B1.,l,7
l1'iehO\.lt Op,iniatl and. Wf,'Cho\.lt.
Benefit of ~Amtn~tio~ ot T!t16
/.
=.W>l.\UlUll
Tltxs QttIT-ct.Jl,lM tH1SD, l;lxe.Cl\lt.ad chic )..6t.t\ ~QY ot MaY, 19~4. by aoonph. J, Gu!d:lsh.
ind1v1dually and ~D 7ru8tea, G~R, ~RANTQRl ~lth ~ull po~nr ~d nu~hQri~y o1thaT
~o p~t~e~. con8a~G, ~n~~41 1\.11, ~onvay..oe to ot.herwise mAnAge or dinpoa~ of
the ~~~l p~oper~y deacribod hetnln, to G~STON1 ~AnK >>OBTLE H~S. JNC'j ~ Flo~1d4
corpor.ae!on. GRANT~B, Mhon~ poA~ office eddr~~" 1A t~300 ~. Tnndh~i T~~il, Napl~e,
'lot'idt\ 31$161.
That tho nata GRANtOR for and in ~on~idar~tlan of ~h~ cum or TtN DO~~ ana
oeho% 9~ 4nd v~luablo C!on.~rln~~tion~ in hand p~id by th~ D4~~ O~E. ~n6 ~ec~~~t
Wb~rQDf 1B hQ~8by dckrtowledyftd, doe& horeby r~miua. ~BleA~o. and qutt'cl&~m unto tbn
.4idOnANTRH fo~eY~r, ~ll tho xight, ti~1e, {~tBT6~~, c~aim bnd rtamand which ~h& ~nld
aRANTQR has in And tD th~ fo~l~lnq db~crib~d lot, pince O~ parcel of ldnd. a~tuAt~.
~y1ng AnO Qnin~ in the C~unty o~ CO~~t~~, S~~te o~ Plo~!d~/ to w1t:
~9bl d~ncripticn on th* att~Qhed tXhi~it ~~..
'.tu. FoHo No.
TO MAVi ~ TO HOLD tho P~Q nogeth~~ ~ith hit and sinS"l~r the ~pu~ten~cee
thereunto b~loQging Qr in Anywayp ~PP~ht4!n~n9, And a11 the ~Qt&~@, r~Bht, eitlo.
it'lte.l:bl1t, 1..lel':l, equity and eltl,1rn whatr;OQver ot the ah.:l.d GP)UrrO~. td,tlun: in law or
equ1 ty t(;t c.t\o. on.ly p-eOper UBl!I. benefic. !Uld be;hoo! o( th.o ..,,,Jd QRANTli:It 1;'or'Qvor.
~al'V\.NT'OR~ .and. .all..l\1lTtl>. arfl \Htf:ld, .!C1~ 111.hg\1ttlJ;" or p",ur~~, all thn COnl;6l(t. me.y
):(Iquire.
:U~ Mtnmas- W31~)UZOP. ",Aid OR.hNTOR hne hcr.U1~tQ !tat; GJUi.M'rOJl.:'!1 h.!U14 lI.nd o~l\l the
d!l.'r and ye!.r ti.:flt !l.bQve; w-tiu.tm.
S~yn~6r 80alud ~d 6~~i~~ea
in che. pre8iUlce o~ I
Pl'lY
STATE or FWRlDA
cotn."'I'Y or COUU'R.
I HtABSf CERTIFY th~t ~ th~n day, beiQ~c ~~. ah Qltl$ar ~uty auth~~i:e~ 1n tha
St.Ilt.& "o'rnL\'l.d Md in t.he COUJlt}" ~~:~]t ~~ t:~l) l\ak.nQwlt\.dgtfll!Il'l\:B, pf!lX'B..ma.1.ly
lI..p~OU'GCI: J'aaeph, J. Qu!dioh, vhQ ~:rDonally I-.no~ t rno t.o bB tn" p~,"Don rjenedbft.....
1n al'l4, wno (l.lCfleut.~d. th~ t01;""9oirt~",......-~-" .~ ,"'1'- - - 4cla10W'1B6gQd bafoJ:$ me thllLt he
Q;xecut.(l~ tho Ua/lUl. blL~ed. th:l,p :t6r;h day or Ma.y, 1~'1. ,
QJrrj..
"of~U~1~ (i.. I t.I1,",I"''''1
My Cc.nnJ.n:p.l.on Bxpirfltt: .
cCAl'PflifUlion )IUlT\b(k;;:
--
lK.-
".~
P"'IA.~. HI1IElU!.\H
Kootar,'161Ic,!ihttf1fH
MJ eo.:.. Ul'1ru o:T:"!l.1nS
tbI:/II. Jo. tt 1'lBJ1
-
;lR<<onl&RDltJmTC:
PlIu1K./iO<l....."
.I'rloo,_&-
. P.O.9a<&li7
NapIo$ Fl. 33ll4141lt7
R.t.tf'itld $,." 7~~'J(I(:lt;':":~l~r)" S4.A~ Tl\x
1\e;:t.\"~4 S I tI \1i"U 't. ItI'.4flIJlblll
n p "~nl"ll',IJ rl'v~' rt1 Tax
OW~~!. ~r:~~. L:/~ .~r;lI:.u~ ~,OU'1
BI~O.C.
PUDZ-2006-AR-I0648
PROJECT #2006060057
DATE: 10/13106
KAY DESELEM
:~'.li08/2006/TUE 11: 21 AM
LOU.
,R I GKSON, P. A.
FAX No. 239 353
lB
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27.2007
Page 86 of 190
p. Oe2
.
. \/.e)>..l.;'''t ~=c\
'.
"
.
01.823156 S'.l!AlI8 FlIl2>03
~~r?J~~~r~~~?RDED
t...~ 2540 GDldaa Ca.'I:. ....i'k......y
U~T_)o. O. aa. nn
I' "__ IUtpl.lI. 'lDd.4& J:J"",)..,1u"
lI'hhou.t ~1t:llCID iU1C! \l'lttlou.'t
....~~.lt: at lIri::Jl:aai~dlCtl o~ Title
001948
OR BOOK
001252
~CiE
OOIT_r-.""'- Da:J:D
'%YU Qt1%'r-cu..nc >>E:Cl, .-a.n;.iS t'J11~ Ur.h d.ll.)" of JQy. 3."4. by.Jg..ph d. Ouichah.
1n\U~1d:u.a.ill' an4 .... "nutIt.... ~. ~. v.1~ cul,). pClWrr a:alS &'IJ'l:bori:)" a,hlar
"1:0 p:rO~.CI;. c~.., .E1~J:'. ..11, eco.....y~ at' 'r;1lI a~rw.i.... ~ or di.~o.. ot
t:.hll l""'1I1 pn::pert.y 6e.t'rlb1:d tM:['.!11i1.6, to aU!S'1'ONIt P1tJU;: tI:lB~LIt HCMEs4 r~C".. . Flortda
'=Crporat:1on, Ga)Jof'fQ:. vh~H POt:!;. OftJ.C'a ~... 1. lnD~ 1:. ~a..:d. orr..'11. ltIpl.u,
Florida JUn.
Ttlat th4l _:1.4 Wl.NlTOIt .for -.nd J..ra coaJI.1t>>rAtirm. a:: ~ .UCIl or ~ DO~ anlS
ol:h.r VDOCl Ulod v&luab1.. ~:i.&rat:iQl:ql 1%10 tua.ud paJ.4 by t:M ..."" ~J:. tM ~CG'ipl;.
wba~.oJ: i. belttby adaaowledQ0e4. 'SO'.....-.by ~.J..... ~.l...... -.ud qu.l:t-cl.i.mI UQ,t.Q ~
N.i<t ~ fcn.....r. all t:he ld.9bt.~ ~ltl., .lauro.t.. el.s... Ul<< cII:eU1l1 wi=- t:l1. .&10
t:ftAlr'J"OR hila ia ani! ~tl tlw 'fal1DtfJxJgo d.ac::o:r:1bel! 1O't. p:LeCtS C:l:' peretl1. o~ 1~d. ..1e.ua.t'e.
lying II.fId boa!.Q5I .ia the Co\&Il.t.:y o.c: C01J.XEJt, Stal:. of P'lod4a.. ~o 'Wit;:
!Mg.l ~.CTiprion tin !;.he &tu.chec!. ~ibh: ".A'.
T&x. Folio )I'D.
'l'O HAW loRn ro HO~ the ..... tDQ'llth.r \lith all uti .iogoulu the appun:lIll&J:10Ra
thenl.J.tl"'O bt:lCCl9'1.alil .or in .aayway. ~.~:j:d,ag, an4.:u. tt1. ..tate. :rlvht, dUe,
izl.tez..t:. l.ie.ra; .q1Jity" ~ c1&i..- \ftuo1:lItM".r O't. tho" lIl.Lf.4 tUtNI'tOR. .:lc.r :I.. 1.", OZ'
1I'qU1ey to ~. (X1].~ l)~cpe.r uae, _oUt; &!It! ~hoot of the _:l.d G.ItANTIal ~a.reVtl=-.
~~iZ':~IUllttOR. -.ad .GJU.ltIU. .an \I."~ for .~l~ or 91:111:&1, ... th. QtlnU~Z~. may
.DI Vl'l'WD5I "tUlnEOJir, ...:td GSl..l.NrOR h..- he....<=to ..tot; CJ\N'fTOR' $' h.aAd e.I:ll3 ...1. 'the
day and ~-=- t:~~t. aklo..,. writ'C:lIIn.
Sipttd. ..aio12 and del1vu'ed
:ht doe p~__~ Qf I
~~
~~
prY~~7!:I MU r-tf'Y
gJ!#.~,j.6
~**~. . :W -.;r~.,)).y I.Ild. ...
ST~ OF .Ft.OJ..tQA.
C'COII"'n'.OP"(."QLl..J:U
'I"-flZRQIY-..et1t't7n ..thttt- Q:a .t:hJ...4ay~ ,1:.:eOnl ......~_ oc.t"tQU:' _I5l.aY_\l.tbor.i..lled .J.D.,~,
seou ..-...... """ in ... ~~r-ur::"rJ; _'_to, "".''''''''-'y
~ar..s oJ~ J. tNi4.f.lItl. ,w.a l:'-*11y kzaIm. t _ '1:0 be th. ~.ao. da.~
it! -.d 'tIbo "ClJ.ted. tb.a tons-oia .emowl.C2gCl4 before lIIO t;ba.c be
II:ICCC'lJ.ted t~ -...e. DII:t:_d thia 16th day of ~f 1.1'1.
. ....--- - urf2TY.1!'-'
. B-UBLlC NOTICE PUBLIC NOTICE PUBLIC NOTICE. ,
NE'IGHBORHOOD INFORMAtiON MEETING '
. .
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27, 2007
Page 87 of 190
.
. . '
,nepublicis invited to attend a neighborhood meeting held by Motorc6~ch
Resort, Inc., represented by Robert Duane, A.I.C.P., of Hqle,Montes; Inc.
and Richard D. Yovanovich, Esq., of Goodlette, Coleman 8< Johnson on:
. .', .. . .
Wednesday, March 7, 2,007 at 1:00 P.M. at
Manatee Middle School cafeteria,
1920 Manatee Road, Naples
Subject Property: consistingof23.2 acres,' is located on the southwest
side of Tamiami Trail, East, approximately three quarters of a mile east of
Isle of Capri, Naples, Florida. .
RECEIVED
Allfi 2 7 Z007
. .
. .
Motorcoach Resort, Inc., represented. by Hole. Montes; Inc. is requesting
a rezone from the Mobile Home, Travel Trailer Recreational Vehicle
Campground, and Heavy CommercialZoning Districts (MH, 'TTRVC &C-
5) to the Commercial Planned Unit Development District (CPUD) for a
. project to be known as th,e Naples Mdtorcoaoh Resort.' ,
. . .
PlANNING SERVICES DEPARTMENT
-
~ L:;:9Z
'" - ~
... '0 cr
o~
~ ~ ,...
~ 1% M
"":0.'"
;I SOt;
. *""~. ~
, o~~
. t-...l ~
Z
'"
.~. ;;;
'"
"
,
I,
t
.
!
I
-c'. . fi
.
.,
I
~ ..
B
J
i
. 1
I
.,:(. i
.;.,:"'.... .,..1tIDtI
~"''''''SII'ot<<IIl
,
,
o
.................,
<..11".
........~,-
."".......
- '.. .
..."..., .. ~:~:-t
'; ,,',
WE VALUEYOURINPUT
. . .
t"' .'- .' ." . " t " ". .
Business and property. owners, residents. arid visitors are welcome'to .
att61nd try.eJ)re~entatidnand discuss the project with the owner/developer'
and ~olilerCpunty staff. If you are unab,le tQ attend ,his meeting, but have
questions of'comments, they can be directed by mail phone, fax or e-mail
.~yApriI7, 2007 to: .' ....,.
Linda Bedtelyon . . 2800 North Horseshoe Drive'
Community Planning Coordinator Naples, Florida 34104. ,j . ,
Co~munlty Development & . (239) 213-2948' .
.Envlr.o~me~tal Services Fax: (239) 403-2395 .
'Admlnlstratlon .. .'
. lindabedteiyon@colliergov,net
NAPLES DAILY NEWS
Published Daily
Naples, FL 34102
Affidavit of Publication
State of Florida
County of Collier
Before the undersigned tl1ey serve as tl1e autllOrity, personally
appeared B. Lamb, who on oath says that they
serve as the Assistalll Corporate Secretary of the Naples Daily,
a dBily llewspaper Pllblished at Naples. ill Collier County,
Florida; dislributed in Collier and Lee counties of Flonda; that
the attached copy of Lhe advertising, being a
PUBLIC NOTICE
in tlte malter of PUBLIC NOTICE
was published in said newspaper 1 lime in the issue
on Febmary 28'" 2007.
AfTlm)1 further says thai (he said Naples Daily News is a newspaper
published at Naples, in said Collier County, florida, and thai the ~aid
llewspaper ha~ heretofore been continllously published ill :ioid Colliel
County, Florida; distributed in Collier and Lee cOLlniies of Florida,
eacb day a.l1d bas been entered.:\s second eIM;S mail matter at the posl
oflice in N:1ple!;, in said Collier Counfy, Florida, for a period of 1
year neJct preceding the first puhliclition nfthc alt<lched (:opy of
advertisement; and afliun( further suys that he ha.<; neither paid nor
promised allY person, firm or corporation ,tOy discount, rebate,
{'.Ommissio!l or refund rorthc purpose ofsecunng this advertisemenl fOT.
publication ill the said newspaper.
1- j
( Signature of amont)
Sworn to and subscribed before me
This 2Rtl) of February 2007
CXnI"Y.' () Cl1'{~'::(lorkcJLaL
(Sigu"ture of nOIW)' public)
,"~;t..~:'{>W"'" Chanel A. McDonald
{.f" A~'1 MYCOMMISSIONI D0210103 miRES
~~'~:i"~ June 29, 2007
~":r.~D~:t\" BONOW ItlW lROV fAIN I'ISURAtlCt:, IrK
FEI 59-2578327
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27, 2007
Page 88 of 190
RECENt\')
I~W; 1. ? 2U"7
~\rr~ Qtr~\\\\<I~~1
~\ ~l{\w.atil: · ..
<l:r--~
~~
'"'0
E:Gigs
2mtD
-.DOl
ro;::rn
u-Q.
c::'"
'" >
0 w
=>
0 c
~
~, z
=> ..._-.-- -
It) 0
N "
<
~
.M ffi ~
12
..., ~ "
G ~ Ii!
..y ~ g
~
5 0 "
~ "
if w
!i
.~ C ~ ~
'" z
'" "
~
OJ <
~
ro ~
<"l
?
1 I- - ~l:
i:..,
Q. ~o It)
ex: '" m
UJ <"l
c.. ( "
c.. I> ,
.-It)
::> ~ r' "'
2: '"
ex:
~ '" - - "-----.
~ <"l
ex: I" N
0 o~ z
2: :>
-0: 0 V
::I: " >.
() '"
~ w V '"
:> I:l '"
" ru a.
0 ti E E
l1J ~ it u 0
U) ~ to)
~ ~ "
0 0, Cl
Q. " ru c
z (:\ :E
a
< ?f .!I:!
~ I- .g
Z .~
M :::l v c-
o, 0 ~
00 to) 0
"'.~ ~ u c
0)0 U :::J
.", lJ.. .0: 0
'.~M.-I to)
N~ Ii '"
",m .Q
"'''' v
."',.,
v
u
I~ ..
v
~
t; 0
_ u
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27,2007
Page 90 of 190
AFFIDAVIT OF JEROME J. GUIDISH REGARDING
BOAT STORAGE AT GREYSTONE MOBILE HOME PARK
,
J
\\C.c.~\ 'J~"
'j 2\1111
t1lMti '"
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF COLLIER
)
)
BEFORE ME, the undersigned notary public, personally appeared JEROME J. GUIDISH ("Affiant"),
who having been first duly swom according to law, represents, warrants, deposes and says:
1. He has personal knowledge of all matters set forth in this Aftldavit, is over the age 18 years, and
is competent to make, execute and deliver this Affidavit.
2. Affiant is the president of Greys tone Park Mobile Homes, rnc. and as knowledge and familiarity
regarding all aspects of the operation, management and past and present uses of Greystone
Mobile Home Park. Greystone Park Mobile Homes, Inc. is the owner of Greystone Mobile Home
Park located at 1.3300 East Tamiami Trail, Naples, Florida.
3, Greystone Mobile Home Park contains 220 recreational vehicle sites and 73 mobile home sites,
for a combines total of293 sites. A copy of the Lot Layont of Greystone MO'(.b'le Home Park
,.,. I. I \1" //
depicting, among other things, the 293 sites is attached hereto as .t:'?:/1,'t;,,- /t
4. For the last~, boats have been stored on e[/ of the 293 sites. Out of those
6tJ sites, 11 () have carpOlts under which the boats were historically stored. A copy of
the Lot Layout of Greystone Mobile Home Park depicting, among other things, the 293 sites is
j / / II <'_
attached hereto as /5'1fi 6;r A
.
5, In addition to the
6{:)
mobile home and recreational vehirl
are historically stored, Greystolle Mobile Home Park also hee
/1 years, stored an additional ..? t1 boat. '
Home Park. The boat field is and has always been,
(except from those on immediate adjoining sites) by \
sites/vehicles surrounding the boat field. The location o.
Layout of Greystone Mobile Home Park attached hereto a,
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27, 2007
Page 91 of 190
FURTHER AFFIANT SA YETH NAUGHT
/5d.y of\)/Jt0, ;2.L:6 7
DATED this
~.J?>a&
The fOl"egoing instrument was acknowledged before me on the a of...JIln. JlX) 7- by JEROME
J. GUIDISH, who is personally known to me or 0 who has provided a driver's license as identification
-
(check one).
lA~a.jJ~
NOTARY PUBLIC. STATE OF FLORJDA
_~",,\U",.... Lara A. Porreca
(W icommission#DD607799
....~~~ Expires: ocr 23,2010
DOSDED IllltU ATIA'me BONDING co.tINe.
<1:'--0
coom
.o~
ON~
Z .0
,-~N
t:::'" en
$ as w
-..D en
ro=ro
-g ill CL
Q)>
enD
<Z
".~.
-
- .. .~
J .
J '
,:'. ,,' -~1
~.,
., /"
, .
)
I
!
"' :.... ''''J'' 'I 11
tit.,'Il -+ :~;:!;:\\";~ ~
-:/t '.I.." :,;''''j~\'l ~I
" hi~",';,l>\" I".~
'Z1IJ'.'i;.1;'H':
.~ '~~!/))i~ ;~:
W.!..':;j;'Jt'~
,"'''. '1
'.r''-j "il~i
."', .,,'
. ";'.',,,.\.,,.:. .~.
. ....".
'/:i:'., I{ .,
liX~J:~
. ,.. ..,l,;.
. ~_L;.:':a
.' J,t~.
.:~/ 'r~{) .
.Yr ._". .
,'.?,f..:'i
..,Y/'f
0";'/,;,"';1 t}::.
,Ii' .'(':'
\',:"",1'! _~_:,"
f~-
'.l.jJ' . "-'.":- "
:ii., ..../f"
'.. '
',~~'
-. . :(:J~\.'
.-
'.' J
I ) ~-
_ '/''1
.~
~~
.,,~
, '\ ;,~\1t'7
.J Jk~ ":11\ ">~I
~ \if\~t:J"'''r
l".""
i.." J~
'\ ..
I,
-
.-:-
\
\
" 'I
f
<(r--o
~~
,~
.0
F c-~ &1
ii as Q)
-..::::J01
~Ero
;:;:Q.JCL
~ >
\DO
~Z
,
:",i';(i~'~'
"~''''~>l'';-'''',
;,;0'.- ;}~:j
"h~e. .
te:
.,
(Ge~-' i
en No A
, 27,2 7
2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE Page 94 of 190
f NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104
(239) 403-2400 FAX (239) 643-6968
"
., C9LLlER COUNTY GOVERNMENT .
w'li.!'V}!6F ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
w'lvW.COLUERGOV.NET t::\. . .
~, '+fb
.~.
I,
PRE-APPLICATION MEETING NOTES
",'c' ,'.. . "'~~~~~Mfl~~Llp:Uatq.~V~;R~ZQlw[j~UtlAmendi\1E!(,f
· ..... . );;~lJ~fj;~yrr:'{;1
Date:_h'" ~t;"~ Time: \: IS Firm:H.ole. MQ(\,kS
Proiect ~ame: &,e~.sk~ teSenI+ . _ Size of Projecl Site: 2<1 acres
'--->2' . , '
Appliconl Name: ~ D lid ^-" . Phone:
,
Owner Name:.
Phone:
Owner Address:
Existing PUD Name~d Number
Assigned Planner ~(.L ~
'_ .'. "'. ' ,':-. :.... . ,,-:":, -"_"'__',";)"_ ..~, ,C_"':","'<<_.,: ,.,,:,-. ...."..-..- ,'_X-,-"
.f(/\." \>oetlh;.... .~\jti{ml..~U. .'~ilTiil~.!j:'S'..ili\,iilt';sRi;:1ii!..'
.-~~.. '.- .,,'~ 'n'.-..' ~J ..,........,. .: _'C'" ....,..-; .C"':"":,..!,:"" ',.",,,,_,,,;,_<:_,,,,~,~
v' /4
,
City
Stale
ZIP ___
~ubrnittal Requirements (refer fo application for additional requirements)
24 Cople. of the following:
(0 1 a~dilional sel if localed in I~e Bayshore!<?aleway Trian!/Ie Redev~!opmenl Areal..
l2I. Completed Application - 6..z:,W(',\oa.d. <:....u"X'('or-,-',; o..~Ii:\\.<:::o-"""" "\O'i'vY\
IT Pre-o"pplicotion Meeting Notes
0: Conceptual Sife Plan 24X 36" and One 8 V, X 11" copy
Cd:' PUO document and Mosler Plan plu. one 24" x 36" copy of the Moster Pion
2 Copies of the Following:
o Deeds/legals & Survey (if boundary of original PlJD Is amended)
, ~, List iden.tifying Owner & all parties of corporation
. ~ Owner/Agent Affidavit signed & notarized L.+;
. [8l Covenant of Unified Control U,SQ.. '0U.r(<.HI 0 rlYl
o Completed Addressing Checklist
4 Copies of the following:
i~ Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) or waiver on.d digital/electronic copy of EIS
_ Historical Surveyor waiver request .
UtilityProvis.ionsStatementw/sketches f.. l / I) .In C I
o Archilectural rendering of proposed sfruclures} (me liJ f'Vlm .J eCi.>>u.hD( /'\
q Architedural Review required ~7' (J
..fl Suevey, signed & sealed ()O Ma(L- -t1i'"IQVI ~ r'10 0 0\ ---\~r
~ s-"... (7) T. offlc Impm:t-&liM",pnt {TISj-9r v'oi"".. ({II f' R'Eft>RI <; \-101).\ I Nb- W7f\ &VnDtJ
fiiJ
o
Five (5) copies of Re:cent Aerial Photogroph (wi,h habitat areas defined) min scaled J"::::: 400'
One (1) Electronic copy of all doc~!nenls in Wo,d format and plans (CDRom or Diskette) -b( Q.o..cn
~ Q..~ .:S,\,\.,,'u\'/\\i\c\'\5
,
'.
Fees:
- __~i.
OJ:
Application Fee,
:B($1 0,000 (PUD Rezone) + $25 per acre (or fraclion thereof)
o $8,000 (PUD to PUD) + $25 per acre (or fraction thereof)
. 0 $6,000 (PUD Amendment) + $25 per acre (or fraction Ihereof)
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27,2007
Page 95 of 190
$150.00 Fire Code Review
$2,250,00 Comprehensive Planning ConsislenCy Review
.$500,00 Pre-application fee (Applications submilled 9. months or more after the date of the last pre-app
~, eeting s.haUnot be credited towards applkation fees and a new pre-appfication meeting win be required.
}2'1 $760,00 legal Advertising Fee for CCPC meeting (to be reconciled upon receipt of Invoice from Naples Daily
News).
$363.00 legal Advertising Fee for BCe meeting
$2500.00 Environmental impact Statement review fee
Property Owner Notilication fees. Property Owner Notifications $1.00 Non-cerlmed; $3.00 Certified to/vrn
receipt mail ( to be paid ofter receipt of invo.ke from Dep1. of Zoning & Development Review)
1&
~
Fee Total $
'O,.!.
~e~ll\~.N~f!is.'.'
.'.:'c::.....,'
<<:~;:~.~ t~~j;
:':2.l
E.,_~',!F.,',/' t '".
C/Jn>p PIth_I:' t/DbR~5S obJ,cl,vt- _7
P1t U">l.JICS,[bJXllks -t-br~lat'l'.s -cmr/cd rfr,l)lfV~Clixi(J{-:btt 'tn-loOd} tr brgXJgt--I-slde<alkS(J1)
1?I=<:c,\PC'\ N~\M'C' I"\.~~ ,~0\\li'l~"'IN(<, ~ ",Allv\~ (1\:0 H"1:J!(6YdJr
~ we..T \J) \\ I ~ Et.:~ P. -t:'9""\,\FZ,."'T "',\PI 1M\=" (' \-\1/'\ N.~..l..J.~
-Ot\'/V\B ~':\'~~adll.lI . . .
lflr\\ro0t ?\(fv\~ t:7 SLA'om,\~ ~p\o.-\- l Dw\ t.. Ao~\~~. c..\{Q.Qt~
- l)( CD
~ If b e P cg,yyI .YNCE: Tlic...nP.J fil flf::Cr GOGf=:- Iil(:l!-~ \
() 01" , e...Pi ~s ~~3~
~'f~~:~S t(()tff~?)n r~~~d:e~~ n~J~d,
. l II <S- , ' X- A e :".Q n1 9r14:"vJelSl~
. (\ A..A. ~ 4cr'f s;.Q 11 C. (j,t ..
. L..ANfl~('..A=f'e.;;;.: NIaV ^CL !:!Y..tFf::::S:PS ON PLAT. (LF,~)
3F'..e t-A1-/.0SCk'PE: ~Ki-.I~T 'P{)t:... &H'1::P;R j?P-J;JL.1IE'P-:: M~
. Sl-J,otJ BOAT RAM? As tI SXimN&"
tt - II
(Ill/(. frrSil;v( taff IJAI11;1 fir 1.:"-ftfft,4/{ cI'V #/lffr?t.
NaV(!)/~' ~o(.(;/!1!;#f/r/ar/v" /AtiL1,1{S of wl/-l;/1/ k:-t!SIirf-.t
Jl;1'!J lfoAf j)o(.id w/_"?t/~ O-'Y/rfh2!/cfF/J
. ,-"g' :
.:".':..'
;Jt,..;/y:
1M! .M/J1;J
_, G:\Currenl\Pre-App forms\PUO pre-app.doc
Revised October 11, 2005
..
, <I"" D .
'" DO>
, D~
..:: .'C'\J ,-'
"]2 r--:~.
~m.
(j) ,<11
.QO>
- C1l
Co..
(l) .
>
o
.< 'z
~,:
, "'"
~.
dJ
~
i'!i;i\
~
i
~
~
U
~.
.
~.
<
ch
.d:
~
=
'1:1, '
'tJ3
~,
Z
~
i"!!!!'
".J!i
'#,;:4
~~
l-
I '"
'"
'---~
C'(lL
o
I",
~1-
<(
C
~
III
.>
Ill'
e:::
-
'0::
III
E
a.
o
III
>
4>
o
"
c:
c
....
oil
0)
c:
c
o
N
~~
_ VI
C VI
4> ill
E -U
-:: "
c <(
a.
4> C
o
, :E
.
w
t~;:;i.3
1~);
. 'm'"
q
III
i;L'
m
w
Iii:
Q
C)
<C,
....
~
<(
:iE
.
...
t>:.
w
ii;l
~
~.
'"
Zl'
n
:C
d..
f-
D-
W
o
--.
z
Q:iE
lilt>:
>"-
Ci ....
Q
>-
f-
Z
::>
o
U
~
V
. .
l
~ \;'--0- -~
.----- rx
'0 -,-. l U
.'t" -....,
e:::
w
Z
Z w
<( ... :iE
4>
.... ..0 . ~
D- E
0 ::>
w Z
Z
C> Q)
Vl c
". 0
III .!:
<( D-
<=>.
"
o
~
N
0;
,;
"
-
N
~
co
U
"
'v>
."
~
"
o
u
f-'
w
w
:r:
U)
~
z
(!)
'!l
"'
E
.e
0.
0.
<{
.h
~
1"
:!'
:;
S!
b
:~g ,
.. ",""".
~
;:.. a2m
=' fiig'
~
1J.
ZI.
:;;;;
:8
I
....,
......
LU.
t:s
--- ~
43:,~
O~--..-,
~Q::
!:C~
>i.I..
aO~
>- ~
I'- <r
Z --.....
:::l \.
d
0:
w
~
<t
"'"
~
ffi
ca
:e
:::l
.......
ita.
2
o
~
>
i!?
N.
S2
If?
a:>
u
..
..
'>
i!?
.......
.t:
~
~
~
~
c.
~
<.S'
,"'t,
'..
\..::.
:::<-:
~
""
~
\?
~
..,.
'"
?;
~
0)
'J
v
u
o
. "0
,..:
ill
ill
I
CI)
Z
Z
(')
U;
-u;
E
t
-
n.
n.
<(
~
"-
~
~
~
y
o
~
1;"", '05 OS 11: 07a'
UO/84/200&'14:27 TEL
,
Collier CO. RDDRESSING 941-659-5724
92542099 It N LAND DlvELDPNENl
Agenda Item No. 8A
NovembEl" 21, 2007
iaJ o<Aqrge iJ8 of 190
,
.~..
Al)DkESSING CHECKUSi'
-'
'-.
pi;;,.." complete Il)e foliowingAND FAX (239~59-S7U) OR SUBMIT IN PERSON TO THE
ADDRESSING SECTION. FORM MUST BE SIGNED BY ADDRE,<;SlNG PERSONNEL PRIOR T() PRE-
APPLICATION MEETING. Not an .item, will apply to every project. Items in bold type are required.
1.. Legal descriptioll of subject property or properties (copy of lengthy Jesc';!ption may be attachelf) S 03, T5.1.
. R26 - \-..\<G'Ld ~>",I\.l (' A--'<.-"..X. Po-<-\<: .~(,I'.( (.:~ L;,~ Z- ~ \dto.__.ck.6<o." C~c.. i='<!l.<K. f"J kLd
2. .Folio (Property ID) numl>er(s) of above (allach to, or assOciate with, legal description if more than one) G.\K. L .
4'953008000 I. 49584240Q04 Lo.l;- \
:1.' street addt<is or addresses (as applicable. if already assigned)
13300, 13450 Taminmi Troil _
. 4. Location map, showing exact loeati"n "f project/sile in relalion to nearest public rood right-of-way (atTach)
5. Copy of survey (NEEDED ONL YFOR UNPLATTED PROPERTIES)
6. Proposed project nhme (if applicable)
GrevstoneMolorcoachResort -- -R'"b<f~t l'I....'la-...^e... 100-\ ~PFC"D'!~ o...A ~~ .-!.~r;e.....
7. Proposed Street names (if applicable)
E. Site Development Plan Number (FOR EXISTING PROJECTS/SITES ONLY)
SOP
9. Petition Type- (Complete a separate Addressing Checklist for each Petition Type)
DSDP (Site Developmenl Plan) 0 PPL (Plnns & PIal Review)
DSDP A (SDP Amendment) [J psr (Preliminary Subdivision Pial)
o SDPI (SDP Insubslantial Change) [J FP (Fina, PI.t)
o SIP (Site Improvement Plan) 0 LLA (Lot Line Adjustment)
o SIPl (SIPI Insubslmtial Change) 0 BL (Blasting Permit)
o SNR (Street Name Change) 0 ROW (Riehl-of-Way Pennit)
o Vegetation/Exotic (Veg. Removal Permits) 0 EXP (Excavation Permit)
l:8l Land Use Petition (Variance, Conditional Use, 0 VRSFP (Veg. Removal & Sile Fill Pe,mit)
Boat Dock Ex~., Rezone, POO rezone, elV 0 ~R (Tran,::Fer of Devdopment Righl9)
D' Ollier. Descnbe: '7:6 8/~7);~ %totf-r~.t'l~c ~~
10. Project or developmenlllames proposed for, or alreody appearing in. condominium documents (if
applicable; indicate whether proposed or existing)
11. Please Check One: lZl Checklist is to be Fa:xed Back 0 Personally Picked Up
12. Applicant Name Robert L.Duane, AICI' Pbone 239 254-2099 Fax
13. Signatme on Addressing Checklist does nol collStilute Project and/or Slrcct Name approval and is subject to
further review l,y the Addre.;sing Section.
FOR S'fAFF1JSE ONLY
Primary Number l"'=-(T2..I.
Address Numher \ 3\ '1 C :;
Address Nwnber :.~ \ (Q 0"1 D
Address Number
Approved hy .fl..",-,";,;, (YlA7;(an, Date S -05- oG"
"
-..\
(Gieb~~
2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE Page 99 of 190
j NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104
(239) 403-2400 FAX (239) 643-6968
., . Cl;).LlIER COl1NTY GQVERNMENT .
. -"i.~'f}bF ZONING &. LAND DEVElOPMENT REVIEW
.~ :' W.COtLIERGOV.NET 0..... . .. .'
...
'....,.~
l..i '
..
...,..'.
-,";.:.'
PRE-APPLICATION MEETING NOTES
"~~~.~)~~~~~tq,:~~~t~.~~t~'Rgio,ne:p.~U~.AJ'm~.!I~m~ll'.:.,' .. .....,tg;{~:}1:i}:i,~.::
Date:_k dl':-()b Time: \: \S
Proiect Name: &~~)4m(JL '1:-v
Applicant Name~ V(.{tf ^-P
Firm:1bt,. Kt.f\k
te<,o-I-r Size of Project Site: 21./
acres
Phone:
Owner Name:
Phone:~
Owner Address:
City,
State
ZIP
Existing I'UD Name,;:;,;;umber
Assigned Planner 1),c.<-b.M
i,o" .. r...'.. '.""';'.ai,V.i';};"~'"';;';'':si''' ':'!i'&ii'''4'''~
"\.eet.11-9,.J,\!!Jg!il. !!ll;~.; .,~.,.!t!1~Ij\.,\9",....Jj,~wt..
VJ4
,p~\1bmittal Requirements (refer to applicafion for additional ,equ;rements)
24 Copies of the following:
(0 1 a!lditionol set if locoted in tl}e Bayshore/vatewoy Trian!!!e Redevelopment AreaL
l8l. Completed Applicalion - O-D\.l.)(\\Oo.D "....Lt.X"{'(.lC"\""'<; ~~\\.<::o...'n"'"'" ~-( M
{:3:"" rre~a'pplication Meeting Notes
@ Conceptual Site Plan 24X 36" and One 8 '/2 X 11" copy
'1Sl:" PUD document and Mo,ter Plan plus one 24" x 36" copy of the Master Plan
:2 Copies of the foUowing:
Ltl Deed,/legals & Survey (if boundary of original PUD i, amended)
e:g list idenlifyjng Owner & all parties of corporation
. [::ig Owner/Agent Affidavit signed & l>Otorized t -+'0 r IYl
c>9 Covenant of Unified Control U.S.L ~rrD'\
0. Completed Addressing Checkli5t
4 Copies of the following:
i~ Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) or warver ond digital/electronic copy o~ EIS
Historical Surveyor waiver reqvest .
Utility Provi,lom Statement w/sketches L l / I J In (' I
o Architectural rendering of pro.po'ed 'truc:.R! (Ill! ~ (jj f\t{7t\ J tCt /J\thD( 11
o Ard,ilecturol Review required ~ (
--tl Survey, signed & ,ealed 00 MO (L- v'\ ~ (\'10 0 d /'i.~X
)21. SeusR (7) 1,011,< Imp~meo1..(Jl.5.~Wer- (PI f? RtrDRI <; 1-\0 IN I NG- g112lBVuDtJ
-~
N
Five (5) copies of Recent Aerial Photograph (with hobitat areas defined) min scoled 1" = 400'
One (1) EleC1ronic copy of 011 doc~renl' in Word format and plan~ (CDRom or Diskette) -be Q...Qcn
~ e.-~ S~'c\('{\\\\o..\s
.,
fees:
Applicallon Fee,
:8[$10,000 (PUDRezone) + $25 per acre (or fraction Ihereof)
0$8,000 (PUD to PUD) + $25 per acre (or fraction thereof)
. 0 $6,000 (PUD Amendment) + $25 per acre (orfracHon thereof)
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27, 2007
Page 100 of 190
.~i,
.j i. ". $150.00 Fire Code Review
$2,250.00 Comprehensive Planning Consistency Review
. '$500.00 Pre-application fee (Applications submitted 9 months 0' more after the date of the last pre-app
~ting shall not be credited towards application fees and. 0 new pre-application meeting will be required.
~ $760.00 legal Advertising Fee for cepc meeling (to be reconciled upon receipt of Invoice from Naples Doily
News).
$363.00 legal Advertising Fee far BCe meeting
$2500.00 Enviranmentallmpact Statement review fee
Property Owner Notjfjeation fees. Property Owner Notifications $1.00 Non-cerlified/ $3.00 Cerfj{jed return
receipt mail ( to be paid after receipt of invoke from Dept. of Zoning & Development Review)
Q<[
o
~
Fee Total $
..",;"."..,..;:--,
..;:c,..,......
0.:'_-',
..-....
. ,'-":X,
".;j;
;
~~e'inRN~:fe~
"/.'i-':' .".--: ]
.~,'.,..::,..':.)..;:.,-......<:;:.
. ,... .".
C-''''{J PI/I.AJ.: !lopJ!...$S tJbJ~d..tlt- _7
Pit u')~1 01dt11X1.\k6 ~. b kQ IaIY'S .. ookf lr,1)I"ly ~a!Jdd/-S:s,tt 4(7.{pon.f.,.r b'S.XJqt ./-SldMIKSOI)
(J ~<{Ji:
l?RC\ \1:-('''1 \'l.A\M\?" l'\ ~=, ~~-0\.\iPlW,IN"" \\-1E....lli9l1l--1-t=: ()~ r=.
8<c,\,\=c.:.T 001\ I NCi::--=t'-, f'. -\->~F-c\"\-lA\Mp (''r-\iI'\N<?E:: P-?Pl.1Q11\\,\()'Q
Q.6"JV\R ~ --:r~O;~:Ja((df .
Et~illJcl~~ ::!:a?ut,(VIIT ~p\iA-t \ OM l~O~I'J~' cc.;\(Q..QE::
--~.~.~r\\' QfQ-(~)
llu<.< fr1:'. c; . Po:>"'lkm,. ~ NC" "'0 "1}.{/J ri I per; ""x: ";-..,
~(JEf>~~I! "~s ~~-3~
. ) ..\.. "".es ", ~ n ::::=.,\ 0." ~ 11 ,Q-c
i: ~~\;~l . i"~\1 s-i.w ca"na'm<'0rMtl1{welt:J
. . (J: '\Ad 4c(',e ~<2 )\t C-, u€ ..
LANflS'CPcP~: ~..v AU_ /.!v.JEt::l:fP~ ON PLAT. (l..r..~)
'3~tE L-,4"Jr)S(kP~ C.f-fr.>l:..I<..I-IC'., 8iC.. [<p"PFp;J2 .$.E!Yf>L.ueE.n1.~
S1400J BOKJ RAMP As II ~TltJG:1
( . II
IAJft. {flS"tr/&t !o~.+ /J./J/11jJ ~F.tlf+r/f/{ c;W ./!1,1ff~7t
p;2ovr!)f:' ~OC()41fj/(1;:rl<dj1/ 1Af;"!l';1ls of w 1,1./;/1/ it!.}'IS.f1/f/6
A ~1J ?loA f ,10 C/d 1#"1..72/ ~ c~'Vf MVC ""E /J
11-"1///:
fO/? f f1/!/J1;J
G:\Currenl\Pre-App forms\PUD pre~app.doc
Revised October 11, 2005
. .
r- 0,
00>
"::>"-,
I~
.0.
-~
"'0
~~
. ~ OJ
C '"
'"0.:
.>
o
'z
~.
I
~'.
~
.- ~.
~
I;)
t
~
~
I
f
~
'.~",".'
~
z
""".
z
~
~
~
~~
I ~
'-. ~
~Ci
Iw
~~
Cl
~
III
.;;
Ill'
~
-
.c
IllE -(J
-.)
a.
o
III
>
Gl
Q
'1:1
C
.IJ
-'
<>IS
0)
c
';:
o
N
'"
'E '"
III ~
E "tl
- "tl
o <(
a.
Ill. a
Q :E
I
W
~
w
Z
Z
<(
.....
0-
Q
w
z
'52
VI
VI
<(
..
<l>
..0.
E
:>
Z
<l>
C
o
..c.
a.
f~r~
';:'~I.: .
~:.:fti_.::.~
r
tr...
if!
lid.
'~
<(
I.,-
a.
w
Q
---.
Z
O~
Vi~
;;:i:C
Cl "
o
>-
.....
Z
::;)
Q
u
==
<(
~
w
,.
~
v
.
~
~
~
,
'-
-\2
0::'
1.\.1
ai
~
::)
Z
;.y
:2;'
o
:E
a..
()
\)
:::\
w
:E
<(
z
/'
rr::...........
...
o
'"
N
(j;
,;
l'!
N
Q
!Q
'"
i:i
'"
"'
s
l'!
o
o
"0
iJj
W
J:
rn
:s
z
~
rn
V;
E
.g
u
u
1
Q}
a:
'"
c
~
C>
<,i
CJ
~
Ll!
~
a
::::l
z
I;!,!
z
o
:Ij
r:t.
I-
fu ~
d .~
-- -<::
:zr ~
Oz:--..,
....&
<!'l...
>u..
ab~
>- ~
I- .",
Z ~
=! \"
o
'U;
L1I
z:
<l:
Z
~
.......
~
~
~
~
~
c
~
(j
."tS
~
Ib
~.
~
~
""
-<
i5
c.J
'0
'-,
<.>
o
."0
;.:
W
IJJ
I
{f)
Z
Z
Cl
Ui
,;
E
J.j
a.
a.
<}
i"
~
C
i"
'5
~
Cl
;g
<;;
'"
Oi
,;
i"
N
<:>
~
~.}
oj
TI
Q)
'"
'5
i"
,-
,
\';'\:1 05 06 11 ~ 07a
oO/Q4/2006 '14:21 TEL
I,
Collier Co.
S2542fr99
RDDRESSING 941-859-5724
H M lAND DEVELOPMENT
Agenda Item No. 8A
NovembEjl' 21. 2007
\iJ o:ba0tloffiS of 190
"
~.
. ADbkESSING CHEcKLIST
v.
pic;ase complete Il)e following AND FAX (J.JP-659-5724) OR SUBMIT IN I'ERSON TO THE
ADDRESSING SECTION. FORM MUST BE SIGNED BY A1)1>RESSJNG PF.RSONNEL PRIOR T(J l'RE-
APPLICATION MEETING. Not all ilems will apply to every project. ltom. in b"ld type are required.
i.. LeJ:;al di:SeTip1i()D of subject property o~ properties (c~y oflengl/ry descript:O>l may be areach"1f) S 03. T5t.
. R26 - v...~ ~",10 (! ~t: (/0..--"<: Jb\'.( A l,=,~ Z- ~ 1,.!,,,^.d<?,6."'''' ('J-",,-"c" >?"'-'"It f.s.~ ~
2. Foii() (Property ID) number(s) of ahove (Clunch /0, or associate with, legal description if more Iha... Olle} 1';\)(, L .
4'953008000 I, 49584240004 G.J,- \
j.' Street addreSs or addresseS (as applicable. if already assigned)
13300.13450 Tamiami Trail
. 4, LocnnoD llIllP, showing eXaet location' ofprojeetlsile in TeJation to nearest p"hlie road right-of-way (a/wcn)
5. Copy ofs,,.vey (NEEDED ONLY FOR UNPLATTED PROPERTIES)
6. PTOposedproject name (ifapplicable)
Grevstol1c Motorco'ach Resort - RL>~ i'-JCU'^e.... 100-\ D....-ppcoyd o~ -\ ~ ~'ie.....
7. Proposed Street names (if applicrIble) .
8. Site Development plan Number (FOR EXJSTJNG PROJECTS/SITES ONLY)
SDP_
9, Petition Type- (Complete a separate Addrcssing Gleckli.! for each Petition Type)
o SOP (Site Development Plan} 0 PPL (Plans & Plat Review)
o SDpA (SOP Amendmcnt) 0 pSP (preliminary Subdivision Plat)
DSDP! (SDp InsubslllIltial OJange) 0 FP (Final PIal)
o SlP (Site Improvement Plan) 0 LLA (Lot Line Adjustment)
o SlPI (SlPIlnsuhsl.ntial Olange) 0 BL (Blasting Permit)
o SNR(StreeINameCbange) 0 ROW (Righl-of-WayPcnnil)
o Vegetation/Exotic (Veg. Removal PeTIllits) 0 EXP (Excavation Permit)
t8J Land Use Pelition (Vari:mcc, Condition.1 Use, [J VRSFP (Veg. Removal & Site Fill Permit)
Boat Dock Ext., Re2one, 1'00 rezone, e[~. 0 TDR (Transfer of D<.-vdopm=l Righl9)
o Other-Describe: l~Q-iY/)'L 7';;:: ~//~Cf~c -0"
10. Project or development names pTOposed for, or already appenring in, condominium documenTS (If
applicablc; indicate whether proposed or existing)
. 11. Please Check One: . [8l Checklist is to he Faxed nack 0 Personally Picked Up
12. Applicant Name Robert LDuane. Ale? Pbone 239254-2099 Fax _
13. Signanrre on Addressing Checklist does nol constitute Project and/or Street Name approval ond is sl.lbje<ot to
further review by Ihe Addressing Section.
FOR STAFFllSE ONLY
PrimaryNumbeT \3,1'"2...1
Address Numher \ ~\ '1 G.3
Ad~s Number '~.J Co 0'''10
Address Numher
Approved by .ll",,-,";..A ()1,o'!..o...Yr> Date S - 05- 0(,.
...,
Agenda Item No. SA
Novemb~ 27, 2007
REG EI~~U04of 190
MAR 1 2- 2007
REZONE FINDINGS
applicable to Section 10.03.05 H ofthe LDC.
Nature of requirements of planning commission report. ""hen pertaining to the rezoning of land,
the repOli and recommendations of the plamung co=ission to the board of county commissioners
required in 10.02.12 D. shall show that the plam1ing commission has studied and considered the
proposed change in relation to the following, when applicable:
1. Whether the proposed change will be consistent with the goals, objectives, and policies and
future land use map and the elements of the growth management plan.
The subject property can be found consistent with policy 5.1 of the FLUE because the
resultant development intensity is less. For example, only 200 motorcoach homes are
proposed. replacing the 293 existing units. Furthermore, proposed units will only be
occupied on a temporary basis, i.e. six (6) months. In addition, the FLUE discourages
future mobile home rezoning in the Coastal High Hazard Area, The proposed rezoning
request that will prohibit the placement of mobile homes, therefore, will cstablish fi.rther
consistency with the FLUE.
The proposed rezoning request can also be found consistent with Policy 5.4 of the FLUE
because the proposed rezoning request can be found compatible with surrounding land
uses.
2. The existing land use pattem.
The existing land use pattern to the west is MH (developed with mobile homes) and a
residential PUD that is vacant. To the south lands are zoned MH for the Henderson Creek
Mobile Home park. To the east is agricultural zoning with a CU for a church. Lands to the
north shows Us. 41 and vacant agricultural zoning and the Winding Cypress PUD, also
vacant in the general area. The proposed rezoning request can be found consistent with the
fbregoing land use pattern. See also aerial photo provided in the Application.
3. The possible creation of an isolated district unrelated to adjacent and nearby districts.
The proposed request will not result in the creating of an isolated zoning district based on
the surrounding land use pattern.
4. Whether existing district boundaries are illogically drawn in relation to existing conditions on
the property proposed for change.
The existing district bmmdaries are not illogically drawn, the proposed request is merely to
re-designate lands zoned for C-5, TTRVC and MH and incorporate them into a CPUD for a
more appropriate zoning designation as noted in other parts of this Application.
(H:\20D5\2005144\WP\Rezone\Resubmiual in progress\1 c~Rezone Findings.mn.070215.doc)
Page 1 of 3
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27,2007
Page 105 of 190
5. Whether changed or changing conditions make the passage of the proposed amendment
necessary.
The existing park now abandoned of occupied dwellings is ripe for redevelopmellt alld a
lessening of its developmellt illtensity to make it more consistellt with the FLUE by removing
mobile homes and currently permanently occupied dwellings from the Coastal High Hazard
Area. Changed conditions and current county policy that discourages the development of
existing uses make the proposed rezoning request appropriate at the present time.
6. Whether the proposed change will adversely influence living conditions in the neighborhood.
The proposed change will not adversely influence living conditions in the neighborhood.
7. Whether the proposed change will create or excessively increase traffic congestion or create
types of traffic deemed incompatible with surrounding land uses, hecause of peak volumes
or projected types of vehicular traffic, including activity during construction phases of the
development, or otherwise affect public safety.
The proposed change will not adversely or excessively affect traffic congestion in the
neighborhood but rather reduce the traffic congestion based on documentation provided in
this rezoning request pertaining to trip generation. Furthermore, as noted the proposed
request can be found consistent with Policy 5.1 of the FLUE because the development
intensity will be lessened.
8. Whether the proposed change will create a drainage problem.
Based on the data contained in the proposed water management plan the subject property
will not cause a drainage problem in the general area.
9. Whether the proposed change will seriously reduce light and air to adjacent areas.
The proposed change will not seriously reduce light, water and air to adjacent areas, as the
proposed redevelopment is comparable to the formerly existing use.
10. Whether the proposed change will adversely affect property values in the adjacent area.
The proposed request as noted is ripe for redevelopment and will result in an impmvement
in the quality of development that should not adversely affect property values in the general
area.
It. Whether the proposed change will be a deterrent to the improvement or development of
adjacent property in accordance with existing regulations.
The proposed change will not be a deterrent to the improvement or development of adjacent
property in accordance with existing regulations.
(H;\20051.2005144\WP\Rezone\ResubmIUalln progress\1 c-Rezone Flndings.mn,070215.doc)
Page 2 of 3
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27, 2007
Page 106 of 190
12. Whether the proposed change will constitute a grant of special privilege to an individual owner
as contrasted with the public welfare.
The proposed change will not constitute a grant of special privilege to an individual as
contrasted with the public welfare.
13, Whether there are substantial reasons why the property cannot be used in accordance with
existing zoning.
While the existing zoning allows for the existing uses, they are located in the Coastal High
Hazard Area and pose a public safety hazard. Therefore, maintaining the existing use is no
longer as desirable as the proposed use.
14. Whether the change suggested is out of scale with the needs of the neighborhood or the county.
The proposed change is not out of scale with the needs of the neighborhood or the county for
reasons previously set forth in this Application.
15, Whether it is impossible to find other adequate sites in the county for the proposed use in
districts already permitting such use.
The existing zoning allows for the proposed uses, However, the existing zoning does not
provide adequate development standards to develop an upscale motorcoach resort.
16, The physical characteristics of the propeliy and the degree of site alteration which would be
required to make the property usable for any of the range of potential uses under the
proposed zoning classification.
There is limited site alteration that will be required for the proposed use due 10 the nature of
the existing development,
17. The impact of development on the availability of adequate public facilities and services
consistent with the levels of service adopted in the Collier County growth management plan
and as defined and implemented through the Collier County Adequate Public Facilities
Ordinance [Code ch. 106, art. II], as amended.
The proposed request will reduce impact on the traffic, sewer and water through a reduction
in the proposed development intensity and service levels will not be adversely affected by the
proposed development.
18. Such other factors, standards, or criteria that the board of county commissioners shall deem
important in the protection of the public health, safety, and welfare,
The applicant will consider any reasonable changes deemed important to the public health,
safety and welfare.
(H:\2005\2005144\WP\Rezone\Resubmlttal in progress\1 c-Rezone Findings.mn.070215.doc)
Page 3 of 3
..
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27, 2007
Page 107 of 190
. .'
TRIP GENERATION ANALYSIS
NAPLES MOTORCOACH RESORT CPUD
The subject property was platted in 1971, the date the plat was approved, and the present
zoning includes three zoning districts, including C.5 (1.9 acres) for a convenience store,
MH mobile home (19.3 acres), and TTRVC Travel Trailer and Recreational Vehicle
Campground District (2.18 acres). Prcsenlly there are i: 293 structnres that contain a
combination of mobile homes and travel trailer lots (mostly mobile homes) in addition to
the convenience store. The existing density is consistent with policy 5.1 of the Future
Land Use Element.
The proposed plan for redevelopment is for a motorcoach resort park with a maximum of
200 lots, and the commercial use will be eliminated. As can be seen from the data
provided herein, the proposed redevelopment will reduce trip generation in addition to
removing semi-permanent structures from the Coastal High Hazard Area and reducing
evacuation times. The differences in trip generation between the existing and proposed
development are set forth for average daily tTaffic from the 7th Edition of Tri~
Generation prepared by the Institute of Transportation Engineers. This edition of the 7
Edition of Trip Generation does not provide rates for motorcoach resorts, or travcltrailers
so the rate for mobile homes was used since that is the existing predominatc use of the
site and corresponds to trip rates for motorcoach resorts based on the developer's
experience. As can be seen from the table, there is a substantial rednction in traffic with
the proposed redevelopment of the site. Furthermore, fhe Trip Generation rates do not
reflect the fact that the motor coach homes will not be occupied more than six month per
year.
EXISTING USE
Land Use MH*' Units Trips
240 4.99 X 293 - 1462
Land Use Convellience Mart *' S.F. Trips
852 34.57 X 2,400 S.P. - 830
Total -- 2292
*1 Mobile Home- average rate on a weekday 4.99
*2 Convenience Market- open 15-16 hours, 34.58 tl~pS per 1000 S.P.
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27, 2007
Page 108 of 190
Land Use MH Units/S.F. Trips
240 4.99 X 200 - 998
PROPOSED USE
In addition, the existing convenience store includes a check-cashing outlet not reflected
in the trip generation rate.
Traffic data, included herein, demonstrates that the proposed redevelopment will generate
substantially less traffic than the existing development.
The anticipated that trip distribution would be 90% in a westerly direction on US 41
toward Naples or CR 951 and T-75, and 10% would travel easterly toward Everglades
tourist attractions and Miami.
The attached letter, dated May 16, 2006, from Paula Fleislrman, Impact Fees Coordinator
for Collier County, concludes that the proposed 200 motor coach homes are vested for
transportation concUlTeney that supports the limited nature oftms traffic analysis.
,...- ~
Agenda Item No. 8A
COLLIER COUNfY t m~
FINANCIAL ADMINISTRATION AND HOUSING DEPARTMENT
2800 N. Horseshoe Olive' Naples, Rorida 34104 . (U9) 403-2369 . Fu (239) 403-2405 n.f,'
~t t~
May 16,2006
Mr. Robert L Duane, A.I.C.P.
Hole Montes
950 Encore Way
Naples, FI. 34110
R ECe:IV EO
MAR '1 2 2007
RE: Greystone Mobile HomeIRV Park and Retail Store
Folio #4953008000 I and #49584240004
Dear Mr. Duane:
We are in receipt of your lettcr dated May 2, 2006. Thank you for sending the backup
documentation. We have confirmed that Greyslone Mobile HomeIRV Park, folio
#49530080001, was built in 1971 and consists of293 mobile homeIRV lots. The Park is
considered vested for impact fees for the 293 lots. In addition, folio #49584240004 is
vested for a 2,400 square foot retail storc that was built in 1969. The proposed reduction
from 293 mobile homeIRV lots and a retail store to 200 motor coach lots is a decrease in
intensity; therefore, no additional impact fees will be assessed. Please attach a copy of
this letter to the Certificate of Adequate Public Facilities Application when submitted
with the Plat.
Don Scott, Transportation Director, has also reviewed the documentation and agrees that
that the proposed 200 motor coach lots are vested for transportation concurrency.
Please contact me at 212-2924 if you have any questions or if you need any additional
information.
s?:JLo~
Paula D. Fleishman
hnpact Fee.Co6rdinator
Cc: Don Scott, TilIIisportatio~ Director
Amy Patterson, Impact Fee Manager
.-.
-
~,,~ ..
,1It' u;
H
._'. .:;..,~ "
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27, 2007
Page 110 of 190
_.,"-;.,~~,~ TURRELL, HALL & ASSOCIATES, INC.
MARINE & ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULT1NG
3584 Exchange Avenue. Suite B. Naples, FloridR34104-3732. (239) 643-0166. Fax (239) 643-6632
June 26, 2007
Kay Desele.m
Collier County Developme.nt Services
2800 North Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
Dear Mrs. Deselem.
We have received a copy of a letter written by staff at the Rookery Bay National Estuarine Research Reserve
(RBNERR) and would like to make the following comments regarding this letter.
Rookery Bay has asserted that the proposed development will sustain anthropogenic disturbanee in the areR, and
boming activities associated with this project may impact aquatic resources. Their concerns seem to be related
to the potential secondRry and cumulative impacts to adjacent estuarine ecosystem within RBNERR that might
occur as a reimlt of the project. While we can not argue that the project is an anthropogenic disturbance, it is
occurring in an area that WI" previously disturbed. This project is not a new distnrhance in what was previously
pristine environment but is inslead a re-development of an old and outdated system. The proposed project is
improving the upland stoITllwaler management plan, reducing the density of units on the property, and reducing
the number of boats that could potentially use the site. All of t~ese actions only serve to improve the site in
terms of water quality and potential secondary impacts,
The Rookery Bay letter outlined several concerns which we will try to respond to in the same order as rhey were
1',1\ forth.
1. Drv Storul!e Fucility
The RBNERR letter staled that "there is no guarantee that a new dry storage facility will not increase the
number of boats accessing RBNERR from the project site as well as alter the type of boats that use the
area." We are not sure what type of guarantee Rookery Bay stoff wanls to see. The application clearly
stated that no more Ihan 40 vessels would be housed in the storage area illld an additional 26 wet slips
could be pcrmitted along tile creek. This number has been further reduced since the original application
and now consists of only 36 vessels in storage and an additional 26 possible on the creek. The 62
vossels currently proposed is definitely less vessels thlln the more than 300 vessels that were able. to
access the wllter from the site before. This is II defini.le commitment thai has been made through the
application and ClUJ be en.forced through the development order. Additionally, the Collicr County
Manatee Prolcction Plan ,~lows for expansiun ofhoat ramps at moderately ranked facilities so the owner
could potentially expand the historic use if the existing proposal is denied. By limiting the number of
vessels allowed at the ,ite to those described above, this is in fact a guarantee tJJut the proposal will not
increase the number of boats aecess"ing the Re,erve. No dredging or other in-water improvements are
proposed so the type and/or size of vessel, ut the propCliy will also not be changed.,
Any ramp improvements or docks associated with Ihi, property will require an Environmental Resourcc
Permit (ERP), and that process will be duly provided to the County for review if or when those
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27, 2007
Page 111 of 190
'.>"-
Pagc2or3
NI~pICl> Motor Coach DEP Rcspo[1:iC
improvements are proposed. lt is the intent of the owner to allow each lot owner on the river to do their
own permitting for the docks iF they so desire. RBNERR will have the opportunity to comment on each
of those as they are applied for and proceg,ed by DEI', The storage area is an upland facility and will be
utili7.ing an existing launchi'ng area; therefore there is no nexus for DEP Submerged Lands and
Environmcntal Resource Program to become involved, since the project falls into the no-notice general
permit category as deserihed in Chapter 40E-400.3 J 5 FAC.
2. WaterOualily
The RBNERR letter outlined concerns that the proposed project lllay have impacL~ on water quality both
during construction and once constructed, 'Oldr concern was highlighted by the facrlhal thcy statc the
project is within the Outstanding florida Waters (OFW, Chapter 62-302.700. Florida Administration
Code) of the RBNERR and Rookery Bay Aquatic Preserve, Their recommendation was thai the water
management system sbould be designcd to meet SFWMD Outstanding Florida Waters design criteria.
The project has a designed surface water m(lOagement system that is an improvement over the llistorieal
slol'l11water system. The proposed improvements will meet the SFWMD Outstanding Florida W filcrs
design criteria a., requested in the Rookery Bay Jetter.
In addition, the project will be utilizing seventl BMPs on site to minimize the potential for water quality
. degradation. These include, staked turbidity barriers to prevent erosion and/or debris from running of'!'
the sile into the (Idjacent waters. Grassed swales and on-sitc detention wi II improve [)Il-sile waler quality
treatment over historic conditions. And 1I retaining war! along the western edgc of the project (landward
of the MHW line) will substantially separate the proposed development from the creek and minimize the.
potential of washouts or other shoreline disturbances.
3. Listed Speck'll Pr'oteelion
The RBNERR letter states that "the presence of boats in the area will degrade manat.ee habitat as well as
increase the probability of manatee deaths resulting from boat wllisi(ln," As mentioned earlier in their
letter as well us in t.his response. bouts are already present in this system and have been present for al
lea~t the pust 35 tD 40 yeam. This project is reducing the number of vessels that can access the area from
this site. and as such should result in an improvement to munatees, especially since the type lInd size of
vessels is remaining unchanged, We agree Ihat improved bouler educat.ion is needed und can be
enhanced through programs developed ro increase public awarenegs of the damage that boats can inflict
on manatees and their habitat, To tltmc ends, all patrons utilizing the storage facility as well as all
shoreline pmperty owners will be presented with an educational package of muterlaJs related to these
issues, Recognition and understanding of these lllateri als wi II he required before tlse of t.he facility or
dock will be allowed.
4. Secondarv and Cumulative Imnacts
As st.aled nnder #3 above. hoater educatiDn and awareness can be cnhan(;ed through programs developed
to increase public awareness of the damage that hoats can inflict on manatees und tbeir habitats.
including shallow water communities. The information package presented to ownerS at the project site
will include docnmentation such as speed zone maps and information on seagrasscs and mangroves in
t.he area.
Agenda Item ND. SA
November 27, 2007
Page 112 Df 190
P,lgc :. of 3
Naples Motor Coach DEP Response
We discussed tllis project bliet1y with Rookery Bay staff at a January 30, 2007 meeting. AI that t.ime, il seemed
that the slaff agreed that the change on the site from a gcneral use boat ramp to a restricted number 1l~ pl'OpDsed
would be a benefit to the area in that fewer vcssc\s would potentially be utili7-ing the shallow waters into and out
of the project !lrea. In addilion, the historic use of the project site had moslly fuU-time residents and year-rDund
wilization. Thc propDsed project will instcad atlraet palt time resident~ in their motor coaches and will nol have
a year-round crmlponenl. With less units, less allowed vessels, and less presence althe property, it should be
clcar that there will be mueh more control Dver the activities that occur althe project site. With the lower use
and increased control, the potential for water quali ly violations, listed species interactions, or other potential
secondary impacts will be greatly reduced.
We hope that this letter responds to the Concerns raised by the RBNERR and we would welcome the
opportunity to discuss this further should tbey have any remaining questions or comments.
Since.rely,
---- ~l
--I
J? i/ .--"
Timothy Hall
Senior Biologist
Ce: Keith Loakkonen - RBNERR
Murk Millor, I'DEP SLERP
Skip Bergmann, USACOR
Ed Cronyn, SFWMD
-'-
r;ietJJ~.JF.L ~/.kA
. Florida Departmelof. November~fIOj6(fJt
Page 11 3'i'>l'''ffier
Environ~ental ~PfOllctiotL 0 py t;,~~~:n':
Rookery Bay National Estuarme Research Reserve
300 Tower Road
Naples, Florida 34113
(239) 417-6310, Fax (239) 417-6315
Michael W. Sole
Secretary
r
Kay Deselem
Collier County Development Services
2800 North Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
D g @ @; m){j}fF-'-'
J.ff/ - 5 ;WIIIIl
JW
May 30, 2007
RE: PUDZ-2006-AR-I0648 - Naples Motorcoach Resort PUD
Staff have reviewed the above referenced application. Outlined below are comments that
Rookery Bay National Estuarine Research Reserve (RBNERR) has concerning this project,
located adjacent to the Reserve.
We believe that the proposed development may negatively impact the primary goals of
RBNERR. RBNERR is one of the few remaining pristine mangrove estuaries in North America.
Over the past three decades, on behalf of taxpayers across the State, the Deparhnent of
Envirorunental Protection has spent over 57 million dollars to purchase lands within RBNERR
to protect and conserve coastal wetlands for future generations to enjoy. 111e proposed
development will sustain anthropogenic di9turbance in tl1e area, and boating activities
associated with this project may impact aquatic resources, and we have concerns about
secondary and cumulative impacts to adjacent estuarine ecosystem within RBNERR.
In order to protect the long-term ecosystem integrity of RBNERR we believe first consideration
in determining permitted potential impacts to aquatic resources should be avoidance and
minimization. The applicant has not provided sufficient information that the design of the
proposed illy storage facility has taken steps to use avoidance and minimization to lessen
permanent inlpacts on aquatic resources nor provided any compensatory mitigation plan.
1. Dry Storage Facility
The proposed development is located adjacent to Rookery Eay Aquatic Preserve/RBNERR, and
we believe that the dry storage aspect of the project should be reviewed by Florida Department
of Environmental Protection Submerged Lands and Environmental Resources Program. Despite
the assertion by tlle applicants agent within submittal documents, there is no guarantee that a
new dry storage facility will not increase the number of boats accessing RBNERR from the
project site as well as alter the type of boats that use the area. Any new boat ramp or docks
associated with this property would require an Envirorunental Resource Permit (ERP), and the
pl'Oposed new dry storage facility should also be subject to the ERP review process.
"Protect,..Conserve and Manage Florida's Environment and Natural Resources"
"More Protection. Less Pmcess"
www.dep.statejl.us
2. Water Quality
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27, 2007
Page 114 of 190
The proposed project may have impacts on water quality both during construction and once
constructed. Since this project area is within the Outstanding Florida Waters (OFW, Chapter 62-
302.700, Florida Administration Code) of the RBNERR and Rookery Bay Aquatic Preserve,
maintaining high water quality is of utmost importance. OrW designation requires that water
quality not be degraded beyond ambient conditions at the time of designation. The proposed
project has not provided reasonable assurance of compliance with water quality criteria relating
to protecting exigting ambient water quality. It is recommended that the water managellli'nt
system should be designed to meet SFWMD Outstanding Florida Waters design critteria.
Regulatory staff should also ensure the use of Best Management Practices to minimize any
impacts on water quality during proposed project (e.g. properly secured turbidity screens
around the entire project area, no spilling of gas 01' oil). In addition, there should be no
maintenance or fish cleaning allowed at the subject prop"-"ty, as well as no grease! oil! gas
runoff from the moored boat(s). All activities within the proposed project should be consistent
with the "Clean Boating Habits" as outlined in the "Oean Marina" brochure.
3. Listed Species Protection
The significance of the aTdrnalliie in RBNERR area was an important factor in the designation
as an Aquatic Preserve. Management objectives for the fauna within the RBNERR is focused on
their protection, through preservation or restoration of natural habitats within the area.
Manatees are known to frequent Henderson Creek, and potential impacts to manatees from
activities associated with this permit should be addressed.
The principal threat to manatees is boat traffic in essential travel corridors and feeding areas,
resting areas, warm-water refuges, and freshwater sources, Manatees use Henderson Creek area
year-round as a feeding and resting area. The presence of boats in the area will degrade
manatee habitat as well as increase the probability of manatee deaths resulting from boat
collision. Improved boater education is also needed and can be enhanced through programs
developed to increase public awareness ofthe damage that boats can inflict on manatees,
including additional signage regarding the protection of manatees and related speed zones.
4. Secondary and Cumulative Impacts
The open waters and chalmels of the RBNERR area are shallow, averaging less than 3 feet in
depth. Improved boater education is also needed and can be enhal1ced through pro graInS
developed to increase public awareness of the damage that boats can inflict on shallow water
communities, including additional signage regarding the protection of seagrass beds and tidal
fla ts.
5. Please l'e-initiate the consultation pl'Ocess with RBNERR if modification to project arises.
This staff assessment is preliminary and is designed to assist in the review of the application
prior to final agency action. The comments provided herein are not the final position of the
Department and may be subject to revision purSUallt to additional information and further
review.
Printed on recycled paper.
Agenda Item No. 8A
, November 27, 2007
. '. Page 115 of 190
If I can be of further assistance, please do not hesitate to contact me. Thank you for the
opportunity to comment.
f{?p:o .
RBNERR Resource Management Coordinator
cc:
Robert Duane, Hole Montes, Inc.
Mark Miller, FDEP SLERP
Skip Bergmann, USACOE
Ed Cronyn, SFWMD
Skip Bergmann, US Army Corps of Engineers (SA} 2000-1092)
Steven Lenberger, Collier County Environmental SerVices
Tad Bartareau, RBNERR Envi.ronmental Specialist
Prjm~.d on r-ecycled paper.
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27,2007
Page 116 of 190
MANA TEE PROTECTION PLAN SUMMARY
FOR
-
NAPLES MOTOR COACH RESORT
Prepared for
Mr. Randall Henderson
Updated
JULY 20, 2007
RECEIVED
SEP 1 4 2007
PlANNING SERVICES DEPARTMENT
PREPARED BY:
..~
TURIIELL & ASSOCIATES, me.
3584 EXCHANGE AVENUE, SUITE B
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104
TELEPHONE: (239) 643-0166
j<"AX: (239) 643-6632
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27, 2007
Page 117 of 190
Naples Motor Coach Resort
Manatee Pl'atection Plan Review
Revised July 20, 2007
I. INTRODUCTION
This summary analysis was prepared to provide information to Collier County reviewers
in relation to the proposed construction of a boat storage area on Henderson Creek
immediately south of U.s, 41. The storage area would he a part of the proposed
redevelopment of the existing mobile home park to an upscalc motor coach resort.
Specifically, we have examined the shoreline and benthic habitats along that stretch of
the crcck, we have looked at the known boat related manatee mortality information, and
we have looked at the waterway leading from the building out to the Gulf of Mexico.
The results to date of our findings are described in the following report.
The project is located in Section 3, Township 51 South, Range 26 East, Collier County. It
lies in the southeast quadrant of the U.S 41 Bridge over Hcnderson Creek, about 1 mile
east of the V.S 41 and CR 951 intersection. The property is approximately 22 acres of
which all of it was developed mobile home sites but all of the mobile homes have been
removed and the entire site has been cleared and is currently under construction
(earthmoving and sorting),
The property has just over 1000 feet of shoreline, which is sodded. Scveral red
mangroves mixed ill with Brazilian pcpper were scattered along the shoreline and
fourteen (14) small docks had been present behind trailers. A staging dock associated
with the existing community boat ramp was also present. This ramp was located adjacent
to the boat ramp near the center of the project and was available for use to the entire
community (approximately 290 residences). It appcars that in the course of the site
clearing activitics; the docks and shorcline vegetation have been recently rcmoved.
Shoreline vegetation removed includes the Brazilian pepper, citrus trees, bougainvillea,
ficus trees, and assorted other landscape plants. A couple of mangroves (one red and one
white) were damaged during the dock and Brazilian peppcr rcmoval but the rest of the
shoreline mangroves were undisturbed. The ramp is still in place.
II. PROJECT DESCRIPTION
The proposed project is a conversion of an existing mobile home park into a motor coach
I recreational vehicle park. As statcd above, there were fourteen (14) residential docks
behind mobilc homes as well as a community boat ramp with an associated staging dock.
The below descriptions are limited to the proposed boat utilization associated with the
project.
Private Docks
Under the proposal, the owners of the lots along the creek will have the option of
permitting small docks for their private use. In addition, a staging dock for the ramp will
also be constructed. A total of 26 private docks and one community dock (27 total
docks) would result.
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27.2007
Page 118 of 190
Naples Motor Coach Resort
Manatee Protectioll Plan Re"iew
Revised July 20, 2007
Boat Ramo
Also proposed, as part of this plan, is a conversion of the existing boat ramp. The
applicant is proposing to construct a boat storage area on the property that will house up
to 36 vessels and providc storage space for an additional 10 boat trailers. The existing
ramp may be modified Lo accommodate the proposed lift that will be used to transport the
vessels from the storage building to the water. Only the vessels kept in the storage area
and thc 26 private vessels along the creek will be allowed the use of the ramp. This will
result in a substantial decrease fi'om the past conditions of over 290 potential users of the
ramp.
Shoreline
The applicant is considcring installation of a retaining wall along the shoreline of the
property. Accordin'g to the description provided, this wall will be located landward of
the Mean High Water line, will not impact any mangrovcs, and will not involve dredge or
fill of wetlands. As such, it will serve to minimize the potential for siltation or erosion
from the development into the creek and will help to maintain the shoreline integrity.
Since no wetlands or mangrovcs will be impacted, this rctaining wall will have no impact
on the shoreline aspect of the Manatee Protection Plan rcview.
III. MANATEE PLAN PARAMETERS
Water Deoths
A certified survey of the shoreline depths has not been conducted but during the bcnthic
survey it was clear that there are areas where water depths are less than four feet deep. It
is also known that there are shallows / shoals between the project and the Gulf of Mcxico
that have less than four fcet of water at low tides.
Shoreline Resources
In order to assess shoreline resources, an assessment dive was conducted. The basic
objective of the dive was to investigate the area for benthic habitats that could potentially
be impacted by the proposed projcct. We looked at watcr depths; water clarity, and for
the presence of seagrasses, marine algae, or oysters. This survey was updated on May 9,
2007 to verify the continued existence of the resources previously observed.
The survey consisted of an observer on the boat and a diver in the water. Shallow water
depths (<8 feet) allow"d us to snorkel to transects, We dove both parallel and
pcrpendicular to the shorelinc while investigating the bottom.
The dive turned up a patch of scattered seagrasses along the shoreline. One small patch
of Widgeon Grass (Ruppia maritima) was observed along one area ofthe shoreline from
the water's edge to about 3 to 5 feet out from the shore. Most likely, this is as deep as it
can grow in this area and still get enough light. During the first survey, there was a lot of
water coming over the weir on the north side of U.S. 41 and between the foam from the
churned watcr, and the suspended sedimcnts in the water, light penetration (approx 3') as
2
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27, 2007
Page 119 of 190
Naples Motor Coach Resort
Mallatee Protection Plau Review
Revised July 20, 2007
well as visibility (approx. 18") was limited. The grass density was sparse and varied
between 2 and 15 percent. The majority of the shoreline had no grasses and no other
quality benthic resoW"ces were observed, There were no grasses observed around the
existing boat ramp, During the most recent survey, no water was coming over the weir
but visibility was still very limited,
The proposed site plan indicates that there are 3 lots whose docks could potentially affect
the seagrasses, The extent of the seagrasses observed during the dives was approximately
140 feet along the shoreline extending about 3 to 5 feet out fl'Om the shore. We believe
that the access walkways for the docks would impact no more than 9 square feet but this
will have to be re-assessed, as pali of the permitting that will occur immediately prior to
any construction.
An exhibit depicting the shoreline dive transects and the area where seagrasses were
observed is includcd for review.
Manatee MOIia1itv
The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FFWCC) database indicates
that there have been 130 manatee deaths in Collier County between April 1974 and
December 2006, which are directly attributable to boat impacts. Ofthese, fifteen ofthcm
(<12%) have occurrcd within five miles of the project site. Since less than 20% of the
boat related deaths within the county have occurrcd within 5 miles of the project site, this
site would not be considered to be within a high manatce use area.
An exhibit depicting the location of the boat related manatee deaths is included for
review.
IV. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The existing ramp is essentially a "use-as-you-will" ramp with little to no supervision or
boater education. As part of the renovation, a propel' management plan should be creatcd
to maintain the marina in up-to-date condition and with most current BMPs in place, In
addition to the management plan, an education program should be developed (preferably
in conjunction with Rookery Bay NERR staff) with infOlmation on manatees, seagrasses,
and the local waterways for patrons of the building, This would add a level of protection
to local reSources by informing the boater's of easily defincd do's and don'ts in our local
waters.
Due to the width of the waterway and the Water depths associated with the project, dock
lengths should be limited to 20 feet. Either perpendicular or parallel mooring is possible
at the site except for those three lots where seagrasses are present. At those lots, only
parallel mooring should be permitted outside of the seagrass footprint. When the
homeowners apply for their dock permits, a benthic survey should be conducted to
3
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27, 2007
Page 120 of 190
Naples Motor Coach Resort
Manatee Protection Plan Review
Revised July 20, 2007
determine if the seagrass coverage has expanded. If the proposed dock will affect
seagrasses, then parallel mooring should be proposed outside of the seagl'ass footprint.
According to the analysis, this propeliy should be classified with a moderate ranking
under the Collier County Manatee Protection Plan. The Intended use should not impact
5% of the existing shoreline or benthic resources and it is in a low manatee use at'ea, but
the depths out to the Gulf are less than 4 feet in some places. With a moderate ranking,
the propcrty would be allowed 10 slips per 100 feet of shoreline or approximately 110
slips. The moderate ranking also allows for the expansion of existing boat ramps or dry
storage building but prohibits the construction of new ramps or dry storage building. The
Manatee Protection Plan does not address the conversion of a boat ramp to a storage
building but the applicant's opinion is that such a conversion should be consistent with
the intent of the Manatee Protection Plan as long as the intensity of use is not expanded,
In this case, the use would decrease from over 1 00 vessels using the ramp to a maximum
of 73 vessels including the single-family docks and thc proposed storage area, However,
this is not specifically addressed in the Plan and will be up to staff and legal
interpretations.
The proposed project would allow a maximum of 26 private wet slips, a staging dock for
the ramp, storage for 10 boat trailers, and 36 vessels. This is substantially under the
current potential use by all 293 residents and also substantially lower that the 110 wet
slips that could be allowed under the Manatee Protection Plan,
4
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27. 2007
Page 121 of 190
~
hU"
~ I
I
~
'dY:)
:"q.:~;11
."J~$}'~(
,~tJ,~
l' ~~h~
I . 'p ~ii ~
".'~~I~a~
..... UJ
.J
ro
o
~ I-
::>
~ 0
tr: ~
<{ ::.::
0.. g
ill Cl
Z ~
o ~
I- <(
(f) en
~
'0::
C>
~ JAiU
m~ B--t!3 ~~
~/l .~] I~
cog ~ ..:g
~~ ~~!"
~8 ~~ ~i
h ~j J~
~~~ 'l!
:z ~ Gl
S
"A,..
4,'(1)>1'.
;z;~,'i:6.EiH)t. ~
"C;!1:.;i;'
y
N
~
i
~
~
Ul
~
w
"
~
.
'"
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27,2007
Page 122 of 190
COpy
.j. ,..'
')
MenlO
GI'eys(onc
Naples Motorcoach Resort
AR. 10648
June 7, 2007
RE: Trash Location
Kay Deselem sent an e-mail on June 4,2007 concerning access to trash containers.
We have lookcd at the trash & recycle ene10sures and the location appears to meet the
intent of LDC 5.03.04.8, We have prepared 2 exhibits, one for the trash and one fOl' the
r~.c ycle, to show this la' x60' access area.
The recycle enclosure was rotated a little ill order to have the requirect 10'x60' aCG"SS
) area in front of the enclosllre and the radius of the entlY was changed from 30' to SO',
Note the distance from the enclosure to the right-of-way line is about 70 feet.
Note the distance from the enclosure to the edge pavement of Hellderson Drivc is 109'.
The trash truck does not back onlo Henderson Drive, the truck does a 3-point turn around
within the boat storage facility plioI' to exiting the site.
The entry gate off of Henderson Drive will remain open until the truck leaves the project.
)
H:\2005\l44\wp~cll\trash truck access 606-07
Item RA
/" I November 27,2007
I Pa~1230f190
I
J
1
::l ~ ,
I
~ ~ I
I
I 0 15 30
, ,
I SCALE FEET
W: SCALE: ," = 30'
1>1
-,
a:,
0,
1Zl
0:
(/)1
10:1
Wi
oj
1ZI
WI
J:,
1
::l ~ I
~ ~ I
,
I
I
I
j
HVI
HOLE MONTES
BIlJKIRS'MICEIlS.flRt'E'tCIIlS
1NIlIl>I'E""""""'"
950 EnCOffl Way
Naples. FL 34110
Phon<>: (239) 254-2000
florida Cortificate of
Allthonza.tJonNo,1n2.
NAPLES MOTORCOACH
RESORT
DUMPSTER ACCESS
PROJECT No.
2005.1+4
CAD rilE N..wE:
1RASH
(XHIElIT - ITEU
101'2
Aaenda Item No 8A
;:;:Y I Novemoer' /, LU I
, I paN1240f190
,
I
I
I
::l ~ ,
<( I
~ Q:; I
I 30
I 0 15
, I
1 SCALE FEET
W: SCALE: ," = 30'
I>l
-
0:1
C:
'ZI
0:
(/)1
10:'
Wi
Ci
IZ,
WI
I:I
I
::l ~ I
~ Q:; 1
I
I
I
I
IHMI
HOLE MONTES
BklHBllI.fI.NtIal$.6UlVEYOOS
-~
950 EnCore Way
Naples, FL. 34110
Phone: (239) 254-2000
FIorlda Cortlficate of
Authorization No.1n2
NAPLES MOTORCOACH
RESORT
DUMPSTER ACCESS
CH{o.:EO ev : Pf<<M:CT H<l.
J.C.N. 2005,144-
CAD rtLE: .,U.I.l(:
RECYCU:
()CHtBIT - lTfIA
2-QF 2.
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27, 2007
Page 125 of 190
Excerpts from the
Conceptual Water Management Report
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27, 2007
PUDZ-2006-AR.1O~'W'e 126 of 190
PROJECT #2006060057
DATE: 10/13/06
KAY DESELEM
NAPLES
MOTORCOACH RESORT
(GREYS TONE)
23.20 Acres
Water Management Report
for
Rezone purposes
By:
Hole Montes
950 Encore Way
Naples, FL 34110
:<
--;:::::>--z- ~ ____________~ /6 -/ Z.-a-c
/--
Jerry Neal, P.E. 26646
lIM Authorization # 1772
Tel: (239) 254 - 2000
September, 2006
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27, 2007
Page 127 of 190
Naples Motorcoach Resort RPUD
(Greystone)
Narrative
Location
The subject 23.20 acre tract is located on the south side of Tamiami Trail East (US-41)
and east of CR-951 in Collier County. This site has 1,070 linear feet of shoreline on the
creek.
Proposed
The proposed plan is for a motorcoaeh resort with 200 lots, club house, pools and
associated parking lots, teIUlis courts, bath houses and dry boat dock storage facility with
existing and planned boat docks,
This site is on tidal waters and the stolm water management plan is based on the
watershed of 22.09 acres (less the canal) that will be draining to the lake. The stann
water nUJoff will be directed to the lake for water quality, then, thru two structures; (a)
WSC-l with a 3-ineh bleed down orifice, and (b) WCS-2 is an overflow weir for water
level exceeding the water quality elevation.
The water quality calculations provides for 150% of that required by 1" or 2,5"
impervious, The overall site percentage of impervious is 53 % and pervious is 47%.
SITE LAND USE
The overall site land use is as follows:
Items Acres %
Building Miscellaneous 0.28 1.2%
Concrete Pad (motor coaches) 5.19 22.4%
Paved Road/ Parking 3.90 16.8%
Sidewalk area 0.08 0.3%
-
Pool Desk 0.26 1.1%
TelIDis COUlis 0.30 1.3%
Lake 1.59 6.9%
Canal Easement (includes Y2 canal) 1.11 4.8%
Omss/ Open space 10.49 45,2%
Total Site 23.20 100%
% Pervious=
11 ac=
47%
% Impervious=
12.2 ac =
53%
H: \2005\2005] 441 WPISCII05,144STORMREI'ORT9.06.doc
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27, 2007
~ ,.. . ~ 0
' .....:;l~ ,_v
-"
"
Gulf
of
Mexico
N.T.s,
14M
HOLE MONTES
DmlRS I\>>IflRS Slilflll<S
9[,O EncOIe Way
Naples. Ft., 34110
Phone: (239) 254.2000
FlorIda Certificate ell
Aulhrnizalion No.1772
NAPLES MOTORCOACH
RESORT (Grcystone)
VICINITY MAP
CHECKtD OY:
J.C.N
DRAVIiN OY;
S.CJ
OAT[ :
6/30/00
"'RO~CT N..,
2005.144
CAtJ m[ NAI.lE:
EXH./ViclrJlly
Elonan - HrlJ
Vicinity
<(1'-0
coom
=~
,-
o
'm
=~'>JN
Q)~~
_OJ
-.0 OJ
"'EO>
TI OJ ro
c::>o.
0)0
:;{z
'~lT
:lNII.a"",,"",
!
. i I !
'Iii {'I
.~ 1
~!
',; 1!1
I! I!I
II:
Iii I
<:::(z)
o
8 ~ ~
"'"
.....
J ,
. !. ~
i d ,I ~ I
~I' q i "g
"'oW ~.
n In H
-~ i >0 '[~ :r
1 ..
~
-,
i
I :1
! I
'I: Ii
illil "
,'"
" qiJ. I
, ! I i~ I
."\ I
il: II
1\1 i
I:j'
1\11
. . . . ~ -
~"~
i!lll
1'.111
I Iii 'I
i '.1' I
' l~ I
I' '
': I
I' ,
, '1:1'
:,' 'II
~~ tlJ-' I
""1
- ~1J:~
'\.:
, ,
,'"
I'll
ill,
Iii I
1"1 '
:Ii i
~~
!
l' ,
Uil Ii
III;' II
! Ii - I
f. I :1. ,. ~ I
f"j" , i I
~tJ ,i~I' I '
':i11J : !
'{I i I
I f;~' I I
!if,".' II
II t I ! 1<'
j I! h i ( ~
I ! ~ . II g
Ii" II ~
, i
: :
) t
II
II
i I
i i
, I
i i
f i
1 :
I
llO'.....NPo.
lH1Al1!J<_!
, ,
,
! !
! I
ii"
I;
'/1
I'! i I
i I
:-""~~'-:-'-t
f '"
'~
o
~
~
'0
ii
oil
pOl
~
~
N N
~ i',J. ..
~ '" Ii' <>
IPIN
- ~ .
. I" .
I ~.:;;
, , ,g
~ 'll 'B f '"
I,!
I'll
'1'1
~b
z
"
'"
0.
f-
Z
..
"
1;: "
"
z
" f-
" iii
;:
'" ><
~ ..
"
~
ci
:;;
0:
U
I F~o~~
.;1. ll,-
j~'~I'
*~&.
, l~
,
In
:I:~I
u
;;;tr
eno
Wen
"'..
:;''''
z:z:
fLU
o(!i
i'!u
0:'"
og
eno
:!!:>
",en
o~
~~
o
i
II
!
,
Agenda Item No, 8A
November 27, 2007
Page 130 of 190
WATERSHED LAND USE
The canal easement will no be pal1 ofthe onsite watershed which is summarized below:
Items Acres %
Building Misccllaneous 0.28 1.2%
Concrete Pad (motor coaches) 5.19 .c"-
22.4%
Paved Roadl Parking 3.90 16.8%
Sidewalk area 0,08 0.3%
Pool Desk 0.26 1.1%
Tennis Courts 0.30 1.3%
Lake 1.59 6.9%
Grassl Open space 10.49 45.2%
Total Site 22.09 95%
Percent of site pcrvious = 10.49 ae122.09 ac = 48 %
Perccnt of site impervious = 11.60 acl22,09 ac ~ 52 %
The overall site pereentage of impelvious is 52 % and pervious is 48%.
DEW A TERlNG: The installation of utilities will be dug by dewatering and a separate
application will be submitted for this procedure,
Soil Stora!!e
Soil Stora!!e (Lake Side Slopes 0.46 ae)
3.85 = average grade = (2.2 +5.5)12
2.20 = control elevation
1.65 = storage depth
From Chart on page E-3 Figure E-l
1.2 = inches cumulated available storage (1.65 depth to W SWT)
0.025 inches of soil storage [(0.46 ac pervious 122.09 ac total) x 1.2 inehes]
CN = 10001 (0,025+ 10) = 99.75
Soil Stora!!e (North and South Ollter slope perimeter berms 0.47 ac)
6.00 = average grade (5.2 + 6.8)/2
2.20 = control elevation
3.80 = storage depth
H: \2005\20G5144\WP\'\CI\05.] 44STORMREPOR T9-06.doc
. ,
From Chmi on page E-3 Figure E-I
7.25 = inches eumulated available storage (3.80 depth to WSWT)
0.154 = inches of soil storage [(0.47 ac pervious / 22.09 ac total) x 7,25 inches)
CN = 1000/ (0.154 + 10) = 98.48
Soil Storage (East Outer slope perimeter berm 0.20 ac)
6.30 = average grade (5.1 + 7.5)/2
2.20 = eontrol elevation
4,10 = storage depth
From Chart on page E-3 Figure E-l
8.4 = inches cumulated available storage (4.10 depth to WSWT)
0.076 = inches of soil storage [(0.20 ac pervious / 22.09 ac total) x 8.4 inches)
CN = 1000/ (0,076 + 10) = 99.24
Soil Storage (West Outer slope perimeter berms 0.24 ac)
4.50 = averagc grade (3.0 + 6.0)/2
2.20 = eontrol elevation
2.30 = storage depth
From Chart on page E-3 Figure E-!
2.5 = inches cumulated available storage (2.30 depth to WSWT)
0,027 = inches of soil storage [(0.24 ac pervious / 22.09 ac total) x 2.5 inches]
CN= 1000/ (0.027 + 10) = 99.72
Soil Storage (yards 9.12l1c)
5.9 = average grade = (5.5 +6.3)/2
2.2 = eontrol elevation
3.7 = storage depth
From Chart on page E-3 Figure E-I
7.25 = inches cumulated available storage (3.7 depth to WSWT)
2,99 = inches of soil storage [(9.12 ac pelvious /22.09 ac total) x 7.25 inches]
CN = 1000/ (2.99 + 10) = 76.96
H: \2005\2005144\WP\SCJ\05.144STORMREPORT9-06.doc
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27, 2007
Page 131 of 190
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27,2007
Page 132 of 190
Summarv Soil Stora2e
Location
Area
acres
Soil
Storage
inches
Lake side slope
N-S Outer side perimeter berm
West Outer side perimeter berm
N-S Outer side perimeter benn
Yard
Total Pervious
0.46
0.47
0,24
0.20
9.12
10.49
0.03
0.15
0,08
0.03
2.99
3.27
Sta2e Storal!e Volumes
Control Elevation = 2.2
ELEVATION , LAKE SITE TOTAL
2.2 0.00 0.00 0.00
3 1.29 0.00 1.29
-
4 2,98 0.00 2.98
5 4.77 0.00 4,77
5.5 5.71 0,00 5,71
6 6.67 0.98 7.64
7 8.66 5.17 13.83
Water Qualitv Calculations
1. First one iuch treatment for the site 22.09 acres
Site area (22.09 acres) x 1 ft /12 incbes = 1.84 AF
2. (2.5 Inches) x % Impel-yious (Assumed)
Water Quality Area = Development site area ~ (water surface + roof)
= 22.09 acres ~ (1.59 ac + 0.28 ac)
= 20.22 acres for waleI' quality pervious/impervious
Impervious Area = 20.22 ac - pervious
= 20.22 ae -10.49 ac
= 9.73 ac impervious for water quality
H: \2005\2005 144\WP\SCI\05.144STORMREI'ORT9-06.doc
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27,2007
Page 133 of 190
% hnpervious
= (9.73 ac I W.Q. P/I) * 100%
= (9.73 acl 20.22 ac) * ] 00%
= 48.]2%
WQ Required
= 2.5 inches x % Impervious
= 2.5 inches * 0.48]2
= 1.20 inches to be treated
WQ Volume required = inches to be treated x (watershed - lake) x lft/12 inehes
= 1.20 inches x (22.09-1.59) x Htl12 inches
= 2.05 ac-ft required detention storage
The required volume of storage is = 2.05 AF x 150% = 3.075 AF
Water quality elevation for entire system starts at control elevation 2.2 ft NGVD
The water quality volume is met at elevation 4.15 ft NGVD (3.075 AF)
WATER QUALITY
8
1.
1~NGviJ]
7
6
5
4 ~
:>
~ 3
w
2
o
0.00
1.00
2.00
3.00
4.00 5.00 fWD
LAKE VOLUME
7.00
8.00
9.00 10.00
Dischal'ge
Allowable
Unlimited discharge on tidal water = allowab]e discharge per pennit SFWMD BCB
The mean high water = 1. 7 NGVD
Control Sti'ucture
WCS-l
Bleeder =
Weir =
Pipe~
Circular, Invert Elevation = 2.2 ft NGVD, Diameter = 0.25 ft.
Broad Crested, Crest Elevation = 4.2 ft NGVD, Length = 4 ft.
Diameter = 2 it RCP, Manning's n = 0,0]2, Length = 240 ft.
H: \2005\2005144\WP\SCl\05.144STORMHEPORT9-06.rloc
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27, 2007
Page 134 of 190
WCS-2
Bleeder =
Weir =
Pipe =
None.
Sharp Crested, Crest Elevation = 4.2 ft NGVD, Length = 10 ft.
Diameter = 5 ft RCP, Manning's n = 0.012, Length = 275 ft.
Time of Concentration:
TC= roofto driveway + driveway to road + road to inlet + inlet to lake
Individual sub-basins to storage area is about 10 minutes average
Watershed TC ~ 3 min roof + 5 min driveway& road + 1050 If @ 0 00:8 fps in pipe
Watershed TC = 3 + 5 + 22 = 30 minutes = 0.50 hours
Summary of Flood Routines (Cascade 2001)
The peak discharge and stages for the 10 - years (I day), 25- years (3 days) and 100 _
years (3-days) rainfalls are as follows:
Watershed: 22.09 acres
Soil Storage: 3.27 inches
Time of concentration: 0.50 h
Initial Stage: 2.2 ft NGVD
Allowable diseharge: unlimited
Storm Description Duration (days) Resulting System
Retum Frequency Peak Stage ft Conditions Peak
(years) (NGYD) Discharge (cfs)
~
10 years 1 day 4.73 unlimited
25 years 3 days 5.39 unlimited
1 00 years 3 davs 8.30 0.00
Elevations:
Minimum pavement elevations:
Parking spaces
Driveways
Minimum finished floor elevation
= 4.80 ft NGYD
= 5.40 ft NGYD
~ 8.30 ft NGYD
H: \2005\2005144\WP\$CI\05. J 44STORMH EPORT9-06.doc
(\J
c--o u.
:)q~. </ ri 0
J~ ~ >
.0 i ~
,~ l.:')
='''M
ClJ'-..... u
2m :- "
cu~O> ~ "
--,a: co t- ~
a3>o... w </ if)
~ Cl 9 C>
':Y'~ " "- C>
" lL ~ ru
< ::;::
u
~r
.
;
I ~-~.
~~~!i
1i~ 8i
::1Ii'i~
l!H
i~!r'
~
~'.'
<
H
!~I-I -
~ ~ ==:'
~ .::~. --
~II =~ I
& -
=11
L: ~_.
N
.
~
z
~
1
~
<
~
"
o
~
lo~
~J
-0
-1 -------=- .
1 "r<'
"")"-.cl.
~
t;~
W:~
d
0"
a~
iJlJ
t t' ,j
i
.
f-- W
ll'"
0 D'
(n :J
W l-
ll'" U
:J'
:r IX:
u I-
<( (f)
..J
0 ..J <i'
u 0 f--
ll'" n:: W
0 l- e,
f-- z
0 0
2 U
(I) ll'"
W W
..J l-
n. <(
<( 3:
z
~
:!
.
1
.
-~
.
, @
~I.
1J11
~ \\. ~/)
~ ~
j ~ I
(I)
'-'
;:
~
"-'
'"
:::>
LJ t-
U
::>
'"
t-
V>
~ -..
~ s
w 0
:! '"
>-
. . z
. 0
. u
.o-l a:
w
>-
""
;:
m
,
m
z
~
~
.,
'"'
u
~
1>
o
~
=
,
.
N
.
'd
c
o
'"'
>.
.Q
b
fQ'~ g '0 ~ ~
$:; ~ ~ --: b
e (');t U 0 ii
8riN~~ C
ill -m~g ~
o ~ f3 ro ~ :::
If) D-_U ';::
O>~~~~
51L;:;I g
-& ..;( ru
~.<;
..."
>
~
;;;
0.
.
'"'
.
I~I
O.
I~~
..J~
O~
I.
-.
.. .u,' ,. ',1
t i~'
~
.
~
N
,
;;;
OJ
~
,
e<l
<
0-
W
q
/
<
o
Q
. L
~ 4~
ell lD \D .... U'\
o 0 o;i II ~
(Jl ~ m~- ~
i~~~ ~
~
~
.~ if)
g is
1;;_ -~Z"'< ~
~t.l>-u U--' It)
~. ~~~2 0
> . 0
13 ~ ~ ~
lU
<(r--O "-
co 0 OJ. ~ C\J
o~ , C>
ON-- ~ .
Z _0 > i lU
' r-- "
~N(D
- CO
<D~~
_<D '"
-,.DID lU
ro::CJ:l i 0- ::::
-0-'" (/}
:::?;o... "- i "
<DO ~ I I C>
C>
~Z X lU
~ LJ
J~,I
~
I i.g.
I~r:i
.g~.
~~~.
;;1!:l!8
>
~
.1--.9
~~l~
<
,-
I
I
L_-.J
="'=
~ -
~~
....o-=~
~~
,~-
. :;===-
-~~
r
~
~
.
~
,
j
.
d
od
.0
."
de
H!
.
0-
n:: W
o u::
l/) ~
wI-
u:: U
~
I 0::
U 0-
<( l/J
0--,--'
u 0 <(
u:: f-
Ou::w
f- I- 0
o :3
:2' U
(J) a:
~ i:':'
0. <(
<( :;;:
Z
>
"
.
1
~
~
.~
~
\(1 ~
::._~)
<
,
<
~
~ N
f, I
w (!)
~ 0
$
~
.----'-1...1
w
no
=>
....
o
=>
no
....
v,
...J
o
no
....
:z
o
o
a:
w
....
...
-
>
L
.
"
~
"
1i
~
'"
.Q
."
"
iD';;go~ t
";-__O/llJ-.,. 0
~'<t N(ij""": a::
III f') ~ (J 0
(s...Pt)II::"Z r:
U LL. N 1: c ~
C __Go ~
W u)~U15 :.:.:
fi?; ~ti~.~
OJ m " C 0
z g;d"::5 ;g
o 0 0
IE .:f. (1J
~ =>
<
.
. l
. t
:~ j~
""~
- I c-'''."'
~
J
g
.
r
~
~
'"
.,
iU
Q
.
M
"'
,
~
u
'"
...l
.0
d
~
1[3~
f-'
z~
o.
"
:I:~ ~
--'B
Oil
I.
~
.
."
.;
,
<;;
u
'"
,
-'
<'
~
w
~
/
C
d
0.
J L
. .
" f'
\0....... I,/)
o o~ II ::E
CJI aJ~- /'
l:! ~ l:! ~ ~
~ ti ;'!i ~ /
.
:';
" ~
! g
1;u>-u;'O""II; ~
~Vl:Vlg"'~Zg
~ } /j1 ~ tlJ
<(r--o
000 cr;,
--.0 ~
I~
o
-,....
c<."'.Jr;r-;
CJ"""""'"
-0)
-.00)
ro:;:rn
""C,..... ro
~O)ll.
CD >
o
~z
n
"
"
"-Ill I!
~__I'
V' '
:\,'
.,
;1
.'
':'
. '[
.,
,
.,
"
,
"
D i'
~
.,
,
: ij
,1--...
;,p
\"0..
,.'"
~~! ':
,
:~J ,
I' :
.' ! ,
.,f ,
;:.t",
, . : .~~'
! ,: .[/
,
i
,
[: ,
,
,
:
,
,
,
,
:
! l !
, l
.
, ~ ^
!
; i ~ . '0 ~ ~
~ b ! I Ii ~ .
. 5 . ,~ ~ ~
n ~ i 'f I
~ 18 ~ I
, ,
n i . "" 10
~
~
I~l i. N 0
I , "
, :I, m
Iti , .
, , .
.. . x
~ , ~ w
il I .', ~I "___c'
0 ,;;;:(;l l'l!1, " I ~
I, n~'~ ~. r I r
I ~~' ~. h.! ~
" } , ~ n
, ~. I ~;; , i'! .... n
, I N
1 , I ... Y , :.~
_..~._--:-h-i . ~, : t= ~ !
-~ ~" :11
, 1_ .~
I L' ... '.' ~
" 1 , l'i
( .~tL..:Ji'l. ,
, r
1 ,:.J III
l ,
, z
" III 1
'~__',"",,-\\ . , ..
- ,-:;'iiii.--,I' , "'1\ ...
" , 0.
, .11 ,il , II
, , ~ < f-
---.. , Ii
\ ! l ! l l , ! z
I , IU
, 0 i
1 10 ~." , ,~ :;
, [: , , ,. ~." IU
, " II .. <!J <!J
, 1 ,. \,5P -
~ : .~ HI ..
z v' z
0 , .. f-
[("-n~,- ;:: .. Iii
, l.~---- '\ :;
. ~ ,A~ u , -"'Y~l= :E
W ii , . '" ><
"T ' " '" , " IU
t i ! t. f- lU
, . ,. ..
. ~\
,i, : , 3:
~.... ,
oj, , !l ur,o.l ,
, Kfit , ci
,
ill I ,L , 3NO~iiidiili4 :i
,1 v "- j'r ' '
, i , a:
1 l"ifOtl , (j
, '. ~ ,l I /j!
~\1 , ,t;
, "Wl1Vr' F'II, /' e ~~~::f'
," : II " .
, ~ ~~ \, r n: t'~'~
, " ,\..... ,01,',
[>fl- , J"'-- 1"""'-"1<>0 '" :
, ~, JJlD<IOHd ''''''';::~--J - - .~ .----'..i-o;ri~.--:... ~f~~l
__ ~ H'L.. : ';11' <... "
, ~, ~?; : Z~d~
ll':l , ,
l ! ! ! \: ~ ! , ! ! ! l ~ l . ~.
, .
/
J
U
...
Iii
II
."
I"
ih>
Iii .
I~: !
"
I:
!!
)
f'
if
,
':
,"
"
1)'1
~
,
I: ~
j:l
,
)1
~..""
-:"~"
4-"
4';~:;-:r<"
.,....,;./y
I
, !
<::(z) . c i!
i <<
, .., ,
"
H c
~~ ~
"
,.~-,
, ,
, "
,._-..<:~:~>,
I~~
:I:~i
l
,
-l
I
. , ..i
! II
<J
~ f-
'"
,.:: 0
'" on
0 w
on '"
, W :t:
, '" u
, :t: <(
: 0 0
, <( l)
i 0 '"
, " 0
, '" r
" 0 0
,
, ... "
, 0 on
0
, " W
, '" -'
, w n.
, <(
, -' Z
, Q,
, <(
, Z
,
,
,
, sli
,
,
:
,
,
,
,
, ~ !
,
,
:
, I
:
:
,
II
" !
"
~
i
I.
tl1
~:l
}'!
"
~Il
-..... ,,----...... ',," -....-- ....--....... --..................--"..
Agenda item I'JIladiAI of 1
November 27, 25'07
Page 138 of 190
DeselemKay
From: alleygatoralley1@aim.com
Sent: Thursday, October 18, 2007 8:20 AM
To: MurrayRobert; Iindyadel@cs.com; ReedCaronDonna; SchifferBrad; Tuff Russell; Vigliotti Robert; norskitor@aol.com;
pmidney@eollier.org; StrainMark; DeselemKay
Subject: Oct 18 meeting
October 18,2007
Dear Planning Commissioners,
I am writing this letter in regards to one item on your agenda today. Petition # PUDZ-2006-AR-
10648. I have talked to some of you in the past, and in talking to some other county officials and
many residents, I was told that Collier County did not want another RV Park. The site that these
people want to put a Motorcoach Resort on used to be Greystone R V & Mobile Home Park. This was
home to nearly 300 residents, most between the ages of 65 and 85, some of which only occupied their
homes in the winter but they still considered that home and we all looked forward to seeing each
other, as we were a family, not just neighbors. We took our case to court and obviously the big money
won. We all became homeless. We got only a small percentage of what our homes were worth._Not
nearly enough to statt over. Many residents have suffered serious illnesses and several have passed
away.
We ask that the building of a Motorcoach resort not be allowed. Why is it that people feel they
have to knuckle under to other people who have a lot of money? Our senior citizens have spent their
lifetimes working and supporting our country and have made sacrifice after sacrifice and what do
some of them get in return? EVICTED. Something is truly wrong with this picture. I hope that you
still have the letters that were sent to you many months ago by the residents of Greystone. They are
supposed to be part of these meetings. We are all watching to see how things turn out. Thank you
for your time. Denise DeWitt
Phone # 765-215-4882
Ch!,ck. Qut the lIew free AIM.(R) Mail-- Unlimited storage and industry-leading spam and email vims protection.
10/1812007
1 239 5306351 FAG!;: 002 ()!' 002 Agenda Item No. SA
.. '.' '.-':' ::;'::::.\:'::;'::':::': :/:.:~::::::~q;~/.?006 11: 39::,m:.:::,fr1~:~:::r~~:::::,:::,~?:~://:-:-:::,:,:,:-:.:,: . ..'.. '.' '.' ....'....-.....-.-...- ...... "'-:":-":-"::"::':::':'::::::::':::::.<'~~~a~:~i.j2~7-g~Y~6 :. . :.,.
.. .
Fr(nn: .J6bri, and Sandra Pribesh (Greystone Residents) .' . ..
1~. "' KA'V D"E'SE::;l' 'E'M" .
o. ... ",.. ,
As a retired Suhmariner and as with most other Gteystone
. . . . , ... . . .
residents, we have iuvested a healthy portion of our retiremeI
savings to buy into Greystone to become part of a close knit
community. This pastY~arwe'officiaUybecarne Florida resi
as we spend moretime there than in the north. Greystone res
typically 'represent working class.poop-Je who bave found
. southwest Florida to beagreatplaecto .livc both yeaTmulla.
seasonally. Many are tl1their 70's, 80's and 90's livmgoll 11
incomes. V,le use our ffuanciafresources to frequent retailst(
restaurants, golf cOUfses.bowlingaUeys.u.tilities and yvery 0
type of business in Naples and CoUierCounty. On a regular .
we read in the Naples news and hear 011 TV that CotIiercouh
a hard time retaining teachers. police~n.firefighters~etcbel
oftbe lack of affordable housing; pWe\\rantto keeptbls aJfoi
. .
bousingby pursuing the purchase of the property ourselves a;
operating it as a Cooperative housing site.. Doing thiswilIpr-
the displacement oftbe elderly and be a. positive move on the
of CoUier county to retain affordable housing thereby dtminh
the claims that Colliercm.mty only wants tberich. Tothis~n
strongly objecttoanyeffortto rezonetb.isparcel of landfor~
other use thanwhilt it is presently zoned for and request 1hat :
dehy any applica:tion.forrezoning.,.. .
~ ~.o-^
Thank You
John and Sandra.Pribesh ,
· ."'....."^ T' ".." "*', .", '"~'f . f" .........
,'" '1IIH . ~Tr1'$In'n ., ...,.,.... n.. f~ .
/{CUJ- ~
~
L~OO '77,~ M.
~, J-~ 9'fICJY
f).uv.- ~. ~,
'~ -eJ::tw e.~ ~ ~d.. ~ ";/- ~
.1;6 ~U7f~.u ?~, ~ 1'~~u~
1 flu fa.A-L (P.-')~ of ~G }jR-oA-- f"-~' '-fBAX
.:97 ~.. k ~'o.MJ' 7' f-di-uJ ~ aAJ-~ ~
_~ ~ ~ ~.4. 7r~U4U J kf..:t '71(/ ~
~ ~ f'-~'v 0 ~lcd:iv J J C4u-1c;L vJ.y- ~
~tJ ~ tcvct, Jv-. U17t.A ~H.L-1'-dLd ~ ~~->
~ ~ ?VYv ~1~ /UZ1.L;"-;J; ~ ~ of
.~ft""'&'h)~~~-dJ~~
~. 'J7<;uY tJ.ft ~~~L J
,-
~ )LLu.y "a.;rd~ ~UA:../J~ cJ7V ~a.4~
~~ ;t~ /~ ~ .~ C1Ltr0 Aj~u
Xv /Vu., ~~ &j ~~{'0~' ~/vt;. 1Y~
~ ~ ~d...v /u.-0.~ ;;t.r' c/.f ...e-uu.~6
~ ~~ '/!:uJL ? .:JA.e-'t ~~ k ~ ..t:/~ ~~ I
~ ,d-tJ )LrY0 ~~ ~ ~a~ u~.
~. ~~~ ~~_,~~Y/UJU/
~ _ .P~ 1uV!<--' ~ :Jv-d-d-. ~~~~J
~ ~. ' RECEJVE'
~~~ JUN 1 (; 2006
~ /- ~ DEPARTMENT
'-1?() . Agenda Item No. 8.A
r. ,~")t 2- 2.2... November 27, 2007
"Yh _ .. . n, Page 140 of 190
II fZU>'-<Y~ )77 '7l / f 91.f '1
~N, 200b
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27,2007
Page 141 of 190
From: Debby Yerke
To: KAY KESELEM and COLLIER COUNTY COMMISSIONERS,
In January 2005, my fiancee' and I moved to Naples to help care for my
elderly parents. My parents reside in Greystone. My father has some major
health problems and to better care for them we moved from Michigan.
Upon moving here we found that there simply was no affordable housing in
Naples. Jobs were easy (0 come by but no place to live. We managed to
find a home in of all places Diamond Shores. As you are well aware,
everyone was evicted from there. Upon leaving Diamond Shores we were
able to buy a travel trailer in Greystone since my parents lived here. We
purchased our home in January 2006. As you can see we have not lived here
long. At the time of purchase the park management did not inform us that
there would be a possibility ofthe park being sold. We are not elderly,
however we are living on a very fixed income with no where to go, We left
everything behind us when we left Michigan to set up residency here in
Naples. We have no where else to go. My parents stand to lose there home
and we also may lose our home. Neither of us can afford to move our
homes. Even if we could, my home is too old to be moved, as most parks
would not except it. Don'( get me wrong the inside is beautiful, but age is
the problem. After living in Naples, I really don't want to leave, I love it
here. I'm always saying, where can you go to see beautiful palm trees, the
ocean and the wonderful ocean life. I can't imagine living anywhere else.
Please, do not let them rezone our park for any other use then what it is
zoned for, I strongly plead with you to deny any application for the rezoning.
Thank You
~~
Debby Yerke
13300 Tamiami Trail E. Lot 212
Naples FL 34114
Aaenda Ite~! JA
N~ovember 27, 2007
Page 142 of 190
June 13, 2006
Collier County Commissioners,
And Zoning Board,
I am writ:i.ng this letter to you because my
parents have been not1fi.ed that they and all the
other nearly 300 residents have been evicted
from Greystone Park. My parents have been in
Greystone Park since 1993. They brag about how
everyone treats them there. I have visited them a
few times over the years and there truly is
something special about the residents in
Greystone. My father has had open-heart surgery
twice and is currently in the hospital again with
heart problems brought on by the stress of this
situation. Any time either one of them has been
ill or hospitalized, I know that I don't have to
worry about them because their Greystone
Family will watch over them and take care of
them. They all banded together to help all the
people who had damage from Hurricane Wilma
last year. It is really something to see. They fish
together, have been the champions of Collier
County Shuffleboard for something like 13 years,
The put on Variety Shows, go bowling, play cards,
have dances several times a year and have many
other activities. My parents always go to the
dances, and bowl on the league. This has been
wonderful for them. The worst thing an elderly
person can do is just sit around. This gives them
something fun to do, and great people to do it
with. There must be some way that the residents
in Greystone Park can stop the rezoning .
application to turn it into an RV Resort, so they
can co-op their park and keep their homes. Please
help them. I am sure that if this were your
pg" (
Agenda~{e';;\ N5"bA
November 27,2007
Page 143 of 190
parents you would do everything possible to allow
them to stay in their home. It 1s very scary for
an older person to be faced with moving under
good conditions. But when 1t is forced on them
and they will all loose everything, it turns into
something traumatic. Not being able to sell your
home and having it taken away from you is
completely unfair. There have been other
residents that have been put in the hospital with
conditions to flairing up due to the stress. Our
elderly people do not need to be stressed out like
this. They deserve to live out the remainder of
their years in peace. There are several veterans
in Greystone and they fought hard, some of them
in several wars for our rights and our country.
Please show them that the country that they
fought so hard for will fight for them too. I
appreciate any help you can give. Thank you
~ ~ultf
Denise DeWitt
P~.~
Aaenda Item No. 8A
N~ovember 27, 2007
Page 144 of 190
June 17, 2006
Dear Commissioners and Zoning Board,
My name is Naoma (Billie) Adams. I live in
Greystone Park # 45.
I went on vacation and arrived back in the park
on June 1,2006 to be told and given a letter telling
me I was being evicted on November 30,2006.
I was told I could not sell my home, but could
move it. It is a double wide mobil with an attached
room, shed, and screen porch across the front of the
house. I then was told I could not move my home
because it is too old. Even if I could move it there
are no parks willing to accept it. This notice gives
me 6 months to move my home and all it holds. At
this time we were not given the first right of refusal
to make our park a co-op. My home and car (8
years old) are all I have.
I am nearing 80 years of age. I have had a
stroke and 3 stints put in the arteries of my heart.
My husband passed away August 8,2005. I am still
having a hard time with my loss.
I don't know what I can do now. Can anyone
help us? Sincerely,
/4, ;ki/2MLdeI:M'ltGJ/
Mrs. Naoma Adams
Resident of Greystone
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27, 2007
Page 145 of 190
JUNE 17, 2006
COLLIER COUNTY COMMISSIONERS & ZONING
BOARD,
DEAR BOARD MEMBERS,
WE HAVE BEEN TERRIBLY WRONGED. GREYSTONE
PARK IS A WONDERFUL COMMUNITY IN IT SELF.
EVER. YONE IN HERE TAKES CARE OF EVERYONE ELSE
IF SOMEONE IS SICK, OTHERS CHIP IN AND COOK
MEALS FOR ll-lEM, OR CLEAN FOR THEM. WHEN
SOMEONES SPOUSE DIES WE ALL TAKE TUR.NS VISITING
THEM AND TAKING THEM MEALS. AFTER HURRICANE
WILMA CAUSED ALL HER DISTR.UCTION LAST YEAR,
WE ALL CLEANED UP OUR PARK PEOPLE WERE
CLEANING UP DEBR.IS FOR WEEKS. WE HAD PEOPLE
THAT WERE GOING TO GET WATER. AND FOOD FOR
ALL OF US AND DISTRIBUTING IT ALL OVER THE PARK.
HOW CAN IT BE THAT WE CAN ALL BE THROWN AWAY
LIKE SOME USED UP PIECE OF GARBAGE AND NO ONE
CAN DO ANYTHING. EVEN AFTER WE HEARD
RUMORS ABOUT THE PARK BEING SOLD EARLY THIS
YEAR, THE OWNER HIMSELF TOLD EVERYONE TO GO
AHEAD AND FIX UP THEIR PLACES BECAUSE THOSE
WERE ONLY RUMORS:~'THA T THE PARK WOULD
R.EMAIN AS IT IS. WE ALL SPENT A LOT OF MONEY AND
TIME R.EP AIR.ING OUR. HOMES AND CLEANING UP OUR.
PARK. MANY PUT EVERYTHING THEY HAD SAVED INTO
PUTTING OUR HOMES BACK TOGETHER.. NOW, HOW
CAN THIS BE JUSTIFIED. WE HAVE OUR HOMEOWNERS
ASSOCIATION PRESIDENT WORKING ON THINGS FOR
US. HER NAME IS DENISE DEWITT AND SHE CAN BE
/9./
,o,genda Item No. SA
r,ovember 27 2007
Page 146 of 190
R.EACHED AT 765-215-4882. PLEASE HELP US IN SOME
WAY TO KEEP OUR. HOMES. THANK YOU
~J~
/j.c
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27, 2007
Page 147 of 190
Dear Board Members and Commissioners,
I am writing in regards to Greystone Park. We have lived here
several years. Being evicted from our homes is very scary. Think
about how you or your parents would feel ifthis were to happen to
them. We have always been told by the owner himself that we
would always have our park as long as he was alive. Well he is
still alive and look what is happening. This is very affordable to
the elderly. We have stores close by and we can get our medicines
right here too. A lot of us don't like to drive much because of all
the traffic and with stores being a mile from us we are not forced to
be on the road as much. Weare wanting to co-op our park and
keep it just as it is now. The owner would not be out anything. In
fact it would save him the expenses of junking all of our homes. I
do not think this is too much to ask. If this man who wants to buy
our park wants to make an R V Resort, let him go get some land
that is unoccupied and leave us alone. What ever happened to
taking care of our country's elderly and help them to remain in
their homes, We worked for many years to get to where we are
now. And I do not think that we should be faced with these types
of things at our age. Thank you, h .
y} ~ f4e'f"'.()w::>-K:., .
A.tJ~ /(~oWJ-!~
Greystol1e Mobil Home Park.
Agenda Item No. 8.A.
I"ovember 27,2007
Page 148 of 190
From: Eugene and Dolores Rounds
June 12,2006
To: Kay Keselem-Zoning board, and Collier County Commissioners,
I'm sending this letter to address my concern over the recent request to
rezone the Greystone Park. I'm asking that you please reconsider doing this
as it would affect many of us that have lived there for years.
About 10 years ago, we made the decision to move to Naples during the
winter months. Being on a fixed income, we felt that Greystone was the
perfect place to live out our remaining years. We may be considered snow
birds by some but those in our park consider us to be family. People in our
park truly care about each other.
My husband this last year had several problems with his health. My
daughter and her fiance' moved here to help care for him. When we are
north I have a son that takes care of us and when in Florida we now have our
daughter who can take care of us. This is very important to us, however, we
always felt that those already in the park were there to look out for us also.
If the park gets permission to rezone, we will be forced to abandon our
homes. Most of us can not afford to do so, This could very well put a lot of
people on the streets without homes. My daughter will have no where to go.
She gave up a lot to move here.
We have always found Naples to be the perfect place to live. Greystone has
been our home and please let it continue to be.
Sincerely, ,rJ /
c;;~ ~
.Q~~
Eugene and Dolores Rounds
Agenda Item I~o. SA
November 27,2007
Page 149 of 190
~~c:€J~~
3301 cgast- '%run.imIW 'T;'tt/.it
~ 7J9!, 34112
.9'l11n<' %0ItlnIf 93()(l1U/,anJ., ~~
'tuU!/18,2006
'T;", "WA.am, 'Ot- ~~,
'0 Q,fW~0IV8Judf41n1f~anJ.,t/w1n;~wlwr~uzWl.e,ifr,
c:€J~ % 9J. anti; '%~ ~Mkab 13300 1ft. 'T;run.imIW 'T;'tt/.it en, ~ .9'l$-'
'0 Q,fW-~~~, tluutAtwe, ~ ~an-twk-fimvnoJ)={rom-netw
_wJw.,pl.ail/f.o,m.aIt&~tiuJk~~f.o,t/ws.e;~~
~in<~~(V{.<7~anJ.,0IV~~i.nc<;me.-. 'T;~Atwe,
~tl..evv4e-~i.nf,o,tItew~anJ.,~~p:tide'in<~tkm'.
$00lR/4t/ws.e;~peop1e-~~~ 'T;~M,wdtf.o,...ab, fUUf
~anti; Iuut ~ ~I& 'T;/w.C05t>oftno<<lntf tI..evv 1UlnU7 i&-cu.<tof t/w.~
~uiJ,e, I~~ iftltei4- fw.me, SWtAtW.etJ~ tno<<lntfOlltkat w/UJi,. ~ would,
w.eJeome, tIte.m,? .
~ 'f'!-'Vl.5'o.{ ~9'd&1i.ca.f.ed, taMfl(J'Ie~ fww, can- tIuut ~~ f.o, sU.vWQ.W/t/?
"WAe.- wdt rJw, tr/.OIWIf CO#U!' {rom- anJ., wkw wdt tluutfJO'?
~~*mR/~~sWu1f.o.<v 'iJtwuJ.':$-' ~dtize.ns,&ttfl.lW~ t/w. roni#ttf
of fiW,v<J/U?Q/f.o, &'cIuuu;d. 'T;1w.vwi1.t~t/w. r..e&i.dR-nts.-4t/w. c:€J~ ~Mkanti;
~oiJwr.&,iI" 'iJ~of~&.wr-~/~
?J~Iw.t.W~~would,&'if~UieIUl'~f.o,~anJ.,'fCUW~
'i!.ouU 'f<JUI ju&~ 'fCUW fw.me,anJ., w.af,k.aM1<Uf{rom-~ If<Ul/ Iuut ~
f.o.<v 'fCUW e.niiIu!/ I.i(.e-?
~ ~ ~f.o,si.tuutup-/<w t/ws.e;dtize.ns,wJw.,~~f.o,f.i.9Jwf.o.<v
~ ~~~~~t/w.~'fCUW~Atwe,0#l/
t/ws.e; ~ CZJaw~ t/w.pow.tYlI f.o, 1>UIh/~ ~impacb cuv~of t.w-.
~~tk,.'t-letUs.l.ip~'fOUA'~
c:€JoJ, ~ IJ&<'
$~
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27,2007
Page 150 of 190
JVI~~.
~~~~
1314 ~~'I/.
~,em'O 1,8356
'tJJ.3. 'Of '0 ~ (k,afatUf~~CfWi.acbWU!/. '0 awaiJJ 'fOWl'~w
w.o.uUw.d<-AJm.e/atUf~~1JOU'
Aaenda Item I~o. 8A
N-ovember 27,2007
Page 151 of 190
Dear Commissioners and Zoning Board,
I am writing to you with my concerns about what is happening to our
wonderful little Greystone Park. Apparently there is a man who is wanting
to buy this park and make it an RV Resort. We have lived here many years
and are very upset by what is happening. It seems to me that there is some
kind of law that prevents the elderly and handicapped from being thrown out
on the street and have our houses stolen from us. Many of my friends are in
the hospital. The stress is causing health problems, Some with heart, some
with other things. Everyone who lives here is very special and we do not
deserve to be thrown out of our houses. We live in our own little comer of
the world and don't bother a sole. How in the world are we expected to
move aU our things, when we get nothing for our homes and are on fixed
incomes. How are we supposed to buy a new place and make payments on
it. These kinds of things are very upsetting, We thought we were living in
this place for the rest of our lives. We want the park to remain as it is and let
us live out the rest of our lives in peace. Thank you ,
hL ;j~
~~~~
Greystone Park
Agenda Item I~o. SA
November 27, 2007
Page 152 of 190
June 14, 2006
Collier County Commissioners and
Zoning Board
I am writing in reference to the situation in Greystone
Park. I have lived here several years and am very unhappy
about being thrown out of our houses', It was our hard
earned money that bought and paid for these houses and
that put money in 1'/72 Ol!l;ner.<; pocket ai/ these years for lot
rent. The owner of tIle park has a/wc:7}1s told us that we
would never have [0 worry about loo!:;ing our pade It has
been asked many times over the years. Everyone has done
a lot of work recently on our places. We had a lot of
damage from Hurricane Wilma, and the owner told us to go
ahead and finish fixing LID our houses. This was asked of
him just this April of 2006. He already knew what was going
on because we started getting notified 0/7 May 20, 2006 that
we were being evicted. liVe J'esidents want to make a co-op
out of our park and exmtinue to live /7ere as we have for 50
many years. I thank you for your time,
1/&2t4 /lJtP~.
C'0"eystone resident
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27,2007
Page 153 of 190
Kay Deselmen
Collier Zoninq Planner
1 have DAen commlng to GReystone since January,1985 and
have made it my home since March, 2001.
I have a double wide
moble home with two bedrooms, two bathrooms, a dining room,
living room and kitchen with a screened porch across the
front and a car-port and a shed.
I couldn't afford to live
anywhere else in Naples and at 88 years of age, I hate to
think of moving where I would have to find new doctors etc.
WE call this our Greystone family and everyone takes care
of everyone else.
If I had to move, I couldn't afford to buy or even rent
anythimg that would compare with what I have.
Lillian W. Bryant
jJ4, ~j "/.,~ " j , )'
'(.......... r-,....-'--~ """,-' .;'.,1(2'+1'''''
13300 E, Tamiami Tr. #51
Naples PI 34114
Agenda Item No. 8A
N'ovember 27, 2007
Page 154 of 190
From: James Selover
To: Kay Deselern and Coilier County Commissioners,
Hi, I would like to introduce myst:if, and ask ieJ]" a moment of your time. My
name is James Selover, and] am a regi;;terecl voter in Collier County. r am a
full time resident and my place of employment is also in Collier County, ]
al11 writing in reference to the ?Ol1ll1g change asked for at my home,
Cireystone.
I would like to ask you to nut change lhe zoning. It is well known there is
no affordable housinll in Colliter COLli11V. r am here in Florida, because of
-- .
tf1lnily health needs, I was asked to come here. and in illY family, I love my
parents and do whatt'ver 1 need (0 in order to C31'e f()r them as I'm sure you
Ivould.
Mom and Dad have been coming down here Cor the last 10 years or more,
they have a home here, like I do. now, I moved into this 55 yt". or older park
in order to care for my parents. I houg.ht my home less then 6 months ago, [
look out a loan, and the pat'k l11illlag,~menl knew that., but this is ethics, [ alll
not anyone to .iudge anolhlCl',
I am askim1. YOU to make a stand here. can we not have the economic
, . ,
advantage of our "snolo\' l)il'ds", and still have a place, that shows Collier
('ounty wants its economit heG,"! of aff()l'dable housing, too.
To change the zoning wi!! mCClll removing 3 I'etirement housing unit, that
could be looked at 3S 11 very henrtle:,s act. Wiil you tell my parent's why
after working all there liv(':'. YOiJ I'd! take ,meay there home') Can not we at
least have one place tllat Jixed inec'lIles and working people can affOl'd in
Collier County. Can not you sov,. "Yes, we ilre doing something about the
affordable hOLlsing problem."
Thank-you for your time and ':onsjderaLiol1,
/itWO~C~
.lames Se10ver
13300 Tamial1li Trl E, #212
Naples FI 34114
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27, 2007
Page 155 of 190
June 16, 2006
CollieI' County COlllTnissioneps and
Zoning Board ]1,([en1 beTs,
rAT ?e T ]?it]'n f t;'J Fnll '1'] p yf,ere'I1C'e to
vve a1 > lilT .1./. 45 dl. J ,. .. L .. .. c.. . . .' >
Gl"eystone Papk.. r1h? .oa ve lived llere many
yeaI'S and are ll"eI:;i' upset about the
possibility of OUF park being' rezoned and
leveled. 7~1]e .is,S'ue of affcJ}?I.:1.able housing
IDUSt be addpesseci Ln the apea.. The County
should be wen aWf..ll'e of' t.his p1'oblelD,
considering there .e,['e constant job openings
due to the [a,et tJ7/:z.t.q,[foI'I.1.a.ble housing is not
to be fOWld. It c"J.].Jpears t]7atNaples a.nd the
SUI'pou..ndin,g' aI'ea,g are turning into places
for the pich and not tJH3 .lowe.r class citizen.
We feellD.:;,e we a,1'e no lont5-f'ep Tvanted 1n the
aI'ea. Like W"B .'JeFve no .l-nzrpose anymore.
All we want 1,.'] to .keep our pa.rk as it is a,nd
make it a co.op I1.e~;"j() it affoI'da.ble housing
aJ"']d a, great pla,c38 to .liVe, ]J,fy husband has
11('j,d severa,] illnesses ,some sepious and
everyone In tlwpa,pkh!::;,s a.Jways lJeen t.here
to help D78. 7:17.15' is teaI'f..n{{ our GI'eystone
FamilyapfJ.Pt, It is not [air. Please
recoJl,::,'1der c2ny 8pplication for rezoning
Tllank you ,
b-ri ~g/2!.!Y 4#~
Ilerl7 c"lnd Betty Cpitser
Agenda Item No. 8A
I-Jovember 27,2007
Page 156 of 190
June 17, 2006
Zoninu (}Joara and County Commissioners,
I am writinu tfiis to you 6ecause I am 'Very unliappy a60ut wliat is
fiappeninu at (;reystone CFarfv. We liave 6een taU tliat we liave to feave our
par~ %is is truCy a terri6fe tli:in{J. We lia'Ve no wliere elSe to go ami no
money to do it witfi as we are aff on .fiu:td incomes fiere. <TFiey want to ta~
our fiomes ami give us notfiing for tfiem. Prisoners are not even treatea tnis
'way. %ey get 3 meaCs a tfay,jree aenta~ metfica[ ami prescriptions. 'l1ien
w/i.en tfiey get out ofjau tfiey lia'Ve money lia1Uf.etf to tfiem. 'Tfiis is
accumufatea wfiife tfiey are in prison. We are not as~ng for anytfiing .
unreasona6fe. We just want to li!ep ourpark.ami ma~ it a community so
t/i.is can never liappen again. :M.ay6e to some peopfe, ourpark.is no 6ig tfeaf,
6ut to us it is very speci4[ 'l1iere must 6e some ~mi of rufe on tlie 600Rf to
liefp /&ep us from 6eing tlirown out fi/& oU gar6age. It is unfaujur to
tfirow ~ or pets out on tlie stnet, so wliy is it ofi.szy to tnrow ofi{ peopfe
out? 'We wouU appreci4te you liefp in any way. If you liave any Ufeas
pfease refay tfiem to our:J{omeCJWnersflssociation (]!resitfent. :J{ername is
(])enise CDe'Vl/itt, and sfie can 6e reacfiea on lier ceff pfione at 765-215-4882.
7.1ianf00u j07:/ur time,
Ad5 N,ff
'Very concemea (;reystone resUfent
Aaenda Item No. SA
N'ovember 27, 2007
Page 157 of 190
Zoning Board and Commissioners
Collier County
Dear Friends,
I am writing in the hopes that you can offer us some
assistance in saving our Park. (Greystone). There
are a lot of people who have lived here for 25 years
or more and some have been here over 30 years. We
have lived here this long because it is a great
community. We love it here. We are all like family
and we feel this is unjustified. This is causing mass
confusion, people getting sick and ending up in the
hospital and a lot of sadness. I do not understand
why it is so difficult to let us keep our park and make
it a co-op. Some people are not able to drive so they
depend on some of the others in this park to get
medicine and food. How are we supposed to pay for
moving expenses, higher rent, and pay for a new
house on limited incomes. These are the kinds of
things that happen to the elderly. Then people
wonder why they have to eat cat food to survive.
None ofus expect to have things handed to us but we
have very limited incomes and no way of staying in
our budgets and moving. I would like you to
reconsider decisions of rezoning. We have always
been told by the man who currently owns our park
that we would always have homes here as long as he
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27 2007
Page 158 ~f 190
was alive. This is some kind of thank you to us
members of society who have worked as hard as we
have to retire. We supported the elderly when we
were young and had respect for them. I don't see
where this is a way to show respect for us now.
J:;I~
. ~htJtA-C1l1 f.!P~
Greystone Resident
A~enda Item No. 8A
N-ovember 27,2007
Page 159 of 190
June 12, 2006
County Commissioners and
Zoning Board Members,
Re: Greystone Park
I am writing this letter because I am very
disappointed at the current situation with Greystone
Park. I do not understand how this can be
happening. We are being evicted from our homes
that some of us have had for over 30 years. Most
people in here are 70-90 years old. This is very
upsetting for us. Our homes that we have been told
by the owner himself that would always be here as
long as he was alive, are being literally stolen from
under us. A lot of the other counties in Florida have a
law in force that when an' owner wants to sell a
mobi~park he has to offer it to the residents first.
Why is it that Collier County has no such law? This is
very unfair. There must be some way to stop this
from happening. We as the residents want to turn
our park into a co-op and keep our homes. This is
the only place that a lot of us have. We have no
other places to go. There is not enough affordable
housing in our area. Please have the decency to help
us remain here. Thank you
/ikif- f?7~
Greystone resident
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27.2007
Page 160 of 190
June 12,2006
Collier County Commissioners,
Zoning Board,
To Whom It May Concern:
I am writing this regarding Greystone Park. I
have been a resident for many years. I am very
happy living in Greystone and I do not know how I
would survive if I am forced to move from my home.
I go up north for just a couple months each year to
visit family members. The rest of the year I am a
permanent resident here. When I leave to go up
north my neighbors put down all my shutters, turn
off my water and help get my house ready. Also
during hurricanes my neighbors come and get my
house ready so there is less chance of damage.
Where could I possibly live and have neighbors like
this. They are all just like family to me. I would not
be able to live in my own house without the help of
my friends. We get together in the evenings and
play cards. We also have a lot of other activities that
keep up busy and we don't have to leave the park to
do them. It is safer than us having to drive all over
town to participate in activities. We do not want to
loose our park or our homes. Thank you,
tJ~(/;~/L
Yvette Thompson
Greystone resident
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27,2007
Page 161 of 190
June 17,2006
Dear Kay Deselem and Board, ""' J)Dj\)0A 'Ff'A( A "I- CD(71f11 i 5S /?:J ilaS /
I am forced to write this letter because we got eviction
notices. I have lived in Greystone Park for many years and
this is home to me. We all take care of each other and
watch over our neighbors. I do not understand how
members of society can do this to people and not feel bad
about it. This is a nice park with great people in it. Our
roads here can not handle the traffic we have now. I don't
understand how it will handle more. We have habitat going
in with 250 houses to our west and that by itself will cause
a great increase in traffic. Please give us the opportunity to
keep our park and our family together. Thank: you for your
time.
~ /flc~
Greystone Park
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27,2007
Page 162 of 190
I have been a resident of Greystone Park for 32 years. My husband was
a severely handicapped person and we came to give him relief from the
cold northern winter, My aunt had recommended Naples for it's weather
and quiet friendly community. We were lucky when we picked
Greystone~r our first winter stay. Because I needed a place where I
could feel safe and secure. We found the campers and the neighborhood
were just what we needed. The park managers were always quick to
respond to any of our problems. Within a couple of months we
purchased a mobile home and decided to make it our permanent home.
The years have been good and even after losing my husband I don't
want to have to live anywhere else. My money is invested in this mobile
and I don't have enough to invest in a new one. Where in Naples can
you find this kind of affordable housing? Isn't that what every is looking
for? If this park is sold you can add me to that list.
E~1
l'
71/~~'
<(r- 0
ooom
~~
J~
,0
'M
:= ,'\j lO
Q)"-~
_(1)
-.0(1)
"'E'"
"'OQ)cc
c>D...
<DO
gz
. ~ ~-p~.I77-:Y-~
_~a~ aP-~~~~-
-;;JJ. ~~ 7~)
., .~. 'l? ~~
~ ~.-L-~~ ~
-// ~~/~
#_t--~~v:-!~~ ~~,
q:..J'c...,;t ,~~z"
/7?a- jJ ~ ~/
~ ' ~ a-;:>~J ~~.,d'L--- ~
~ "'"? n~<7-'A- ~
~ ~uJ 77J.4b~ 4._~/::~C?&'
~~ /?/~ ~~/-??a..J
~~. / ~.-/ail~ /~--"
~.~cl:A~-:Y.-J d~.-crt.~~
IZr ~ ;JE;7;l~AY~-
/J-;;r;?_~ Z!:::L:jt~ / .
. . .. y~ -# /~ .2---. .'
~ Ag~~Ite;N~8~
November 27. 2007
. :J)~CbL k, " tJ/J7!r-J~u. &21~ Page 164 of 190
JI ~:JLd~, J #t);a<<b ~
GlU!Jdtr/lL.. 7/)66d (Y/zt?U' Jddi, d ?-L:cV7C
& 1)b-n'1-L ~/~ C~c?~ J (}4.L( ~~/L~
.~ ~ C-?~0djj~ uJ~. tZL(2.- tG--L~t75t ~/r{;/e;1
v.~ CUJL c~~ J t!f- nO~ JJ~. ,!O ~ j
W~~~V~/)}Lax- Z;:;Ja~~dJ ~~;r/Io
{%t.{j, 01~A- i jJeul< ~C-~). /)(&5-/-' Cn? &2A//kd d6::J?A'-r
./~ ;)-C-- aJIJo ~~ 4h, W r:Zt.L a.. .; ~~
Mv-ie-.. / {J,'.-?)C:;! "L.'(2-u~ ~"~ /)10 /p/-!fU !J!L~ /I
C~1>~)Y-v' ,u2{fui-- ~~ ~~ d2 lfl1ci
~ O-t-~~;l r"?~ Z-f)~?2-e., .,J2 '-f)~
fiU) /771Ctl? . .' Oi-- ~{ptaa /-o1~1 U~~
~ @U2J h ~?LC-YL /)')V;I f{~ uJ)d
q~f~. ~tR- ~ ~ ~Jad
Co; tL/ ~die- '12~ ~ ,~. (J1dM.
~ ~~ p~~ aboAJI ;t/UL/Ak.ed d ~
~/JU4. :y/VL! ~' ot6 <Hda ~ Iex- ;:;:
./Pt71-k . ~~. /J.a.. Pr! tJVA !t~
12-0'?4- ~,u2z- tU2- /)201 ank~ !t-
eL /M.L ~) 6uJ [,Ue- {v~d Nee. cJk,.J.
MtVni!.& 1-0 tUJ- T tJUA-aiPaLk. L'1]LL ~
w~ tJZUI ~ ...do ~/ed/ uJ.u2d/Ylo'l'
L I U....h. (/;1 Jb d1:..f tVfl.i.b>> ~
L?t I~ ~ .~?a& //L/t-, & r J~ () . . _J (j
.~ '.! cYh...u.)L' '. d. 'hI ;t3tct!T~lQ
~ 2:tu ~ {'(';d~ j Mghjy0
Agenda Item No. 8A
. November 27, 2007
- . I tfUA. ~ ~k~-'~_'-/:;;::'""
A.r;t JJ act ' t:J.Sf./2 . ,~
dd- ftt&1~l,~ c:wd a6~. ~ ~-~
c-l-t>dglJ.t:hut .u-JJ-U.- . ."~ ~
h~ J{Jcd~~l-aI .' ~~,
~ /flY}CJt1~ ~~ tJ:f ~fd
/d I Ck- i.jfft-lA. tf/tMvdJ);j~ ~
o ~~ UjOr- & &-L fl?7cdl. ~
~I tUI tJl j1~ ~i.C-;{6u ///c/ldu
~ i- ~ ditvTlCb ~d-,~ C&
. ,10 ~ i;P;7U/J ~~. ~dL
/1l7^-e ftOA-k fbxvl d~ ~~ k - ,db.-
/~ Ma.l-4 ~a47)~ 0~ k
IJfo do ~. :h c:Jun,zivu A~ ~~
. d(j~aif.
lJ tErJ" f< )< A Y A--/lI il "'2 CJ /1/ I,IV G
8 tJ A-r:.b :;
Agenda liem No SA
~\!ovember 27, 2bo7
, ..::rU;I/ C P8'f'('f'J of B b
7/-f/ .;:,.t.. &'/'/'61<-
.c'v F;rr7' 5' .-4"/ ~I-/- 6
Re.LA-rE3 ;7"(t)
c: r? A '-( s --rt:? /l/ E
;f'Ee-e~
~ -0 BflE-
/1-[7/11 !3 ;0 ~ /< , .s.r::= V tER.-4 c:.-- W e.E J<., S .4<:;;; b - /?(" E-
M rf-/lI A-$ .c ;vi E /fJ7 S' P-1lfT r< e- s) D e /1..J/.::s.. ".+.,.A/ 0 --T:/ o;E
/0 IE V I c r 6' W A/ e R.s __ .r 77 r S /,.V[ to 0 s is .:5
4 /f4-I^<-!) 51-1 ) fJ t'!? N --r p ..vA...v7S .e E e.A-U :5 E Co E
wouJ..iI '/v()--r 6E AI3~ /0 =>E,LL. 8/..-91"<.. /r:Jr:!Jr1EJ
To /C13C-oiJEfl, ---7/-Ir.?- 1/lIf/GS--r~GNr ,-we /f-A-'-rE.
~
/,/1/ C? C/ R. I#.M- E.5 ! 6 c3 C.rrv.:> c 6' r: ',//-/"e AC-:7"/'<:/f'V
Or 7" .4 ~ &. teA Y 5 70,.1./ e .M,..+,/I/ A-G .e ,1/1 IE /Lf'/," ,A /J j)
) /1/ ;A.-1-;II' y <:1.4> E. >11+ &. /' IAA/1/ s rra 0 (~/' CD fr1-z.O v1/IJ ,
tv J L z.-. /U e> ---r /1"1 C) r I - --r;..,/- C ./1/2 0 13 j L C. )c.h:.> MiSs:
(36 C.&f v Se.... ~ rW6Y .4 f<,E.... 70 t.fJ {j) ;( D ~
rxJ t5- ;:::::t!J U A/ I) (} u --r -r I-I-"q.--r 11<--/ JJ=::. ;:> If EsE- N7"
tJ W.4/.eJe. IS :5EJ--L/ /1/~-rHe ;O~O ~eP.. T'y
C& /J-rl Al6 P Jl..FT a;> rJ -r./l-e:. 5' (/ C <'. 4::5 So P v L IZ E. 2o/v J /l'^<:;
o P- -t/r!5- .f'Jreo r cR. -r'r;.
,JJ L e -4 s J~ C& AJ 5 I j::; .E p?:... -;r I/-- A/' 77-1 E I'< k .:z <!/ ,tV )..A/ G
OF --r-r/rs(' ~ CJ P.!?R..TY' CU 0 u)... [) cJ!-"'/-v.s E. .s[;?' v ERE
FIA/A#<2/A-L .L 05.:>" 70 <9dtr 7C/VAAI/..5 ../'IS
tv e./... L.4"-> ;/9-;-<.//1/ G A- WA Y T;.,i;3 11<( He? M 13Z.s flJ. G r
f!1-vF J-/v6D IN rC'K J)LcAdc>/
..5" I ,A/ c-E.;<:(, J.. y
12/ c:. fI;+D G tJ ---ry$ ~;+ 4-t-j<:..
a<-~ I~ 06
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27, 2007
Page 167 of 190
To Kay Dcselem.
I am writing to let you know how much we need to keep our trailer and mobile homes
at Greystone Park, 13300 E. Tamiami Tr. Naples, # 71 . FL 34114
So many of the people here have been here for over 35 years. It is a great park and very
friendly.!, like many others, are over 75 and have no where else to go and no money to
move with. Most of us are here because of age and health problems. This has been like
living with family and the owners have helped us in many ways when needed.
This has put such a stress on me that when up in Mi. visiting family I ended up in the
emergence room with an anxiety attack. Thank heavens it wasn't too bad. Other folks
here have also had medical problems due to the stress we are going through. When you
have no money or any place to go it can make you very sick. This was to be our final
retirement home.
Please do what you can to help us keep our homes. There is no other place in Naples
any of us could afford.
Thank You,
Nancy -Lee Williams
~7of-J~
J"---
c:Jurf41en<;lHIe'RN9 8A
rmv<f.,j))'r Y, <reO 7
Page 168 of 190
To Kay Deselem and Board Members,
When we moved down here to Greystone Park we thought we had found our
retirement home. Now we find out they are selling our park out from under us. Our home
up north has been sold and now have no where to go.
The people in this park are the friendless people we have ever met. And the
owners have always been willing to help in any way they could. This Plirk is close to
stores and phannacies which is handy for those of us who do not drive very far. And we
help run errands for those who can't get out. We have become one large family.
There are so many older folks in here that arc over 70 and up that have no where
to go or the health or money to make a move. What are we suppose to do. It will mean
finding new Doctors that have taken care of us for many years now. That will not be easy
to do.
Plea.qe see what can be done for us to keep our park and homes. Most of our
homes are too old to move out of here . No other Dark will take them and most are not
moveable.
Thank you for all you can do. Our prayers are with all of us.
Sincerely
Joe and Mary Spada
~ 1'1 CCl S,ad~
Agenda liem No. SA
November 27, 2007
Page 169 of 190
Just how can some one have the right to sell our homes out from
under us ? Isn't there a law to protect us from losing our homes ?
So many of us are in our 60's I 70's and 80's and we have no where to go
and some have no families to turn to for help and no money to buy or
rent because we are the cheapest park in Naples. We can't afford
these rich places. Who is going to do their shopping and take them to
the doctor or pick up their meds. We are a family here and some have
been here for over 30 years. Most of our trailers and mobile homes are
too old and most parks won't take them even if we could pull them out.
When Wilma came through and did damage to our park we all pitched in
and went and picked up the water and food that was given for free.
And helped each other clean up. One lady had asked for five years to
have a big tree cut down behind her home but the park said it was fine.
Wilma snapped it in half and it went right down from roof to floor.
Right after Wilma they changed the name of the park from Greystone
Mobile Home Park to R. V. Trailer Park So they knew for some long time
this was going to happen. And it wasn't fair for them to wait until the
snowbirds went back up north before they sent out notices. People had
to come back from Canada to close up.
If you could keep this from being rezoned it would help save our park.
We thank you all for your concern and help.
Dear Kay Deselem,
_. 171 &dtl1z~u- / /~~rV~~~
I JC- /
(j
~
J)
,C.-/,?-pp
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27, 2007
Page 170 of 190
Kay Oeselem ,
We would like you to know how much we need to save Greystone Park. When we
moved in we found it to he a very friendly park and the owners have been here to see
that things were taken care of.
Please help us to keep our park as we have no where else to move to. Living in a
mobile home we can't pull it out of here and don't want to leave such niee people. And it
is close to stores for food and m~dicine which help those of us who don't drive far or
have to depend on others for help.
Greystone has been a great place to live and it is heart sickening to have to leave every
thing behind. It is a very affordable park and a great place to live. There are just too
many of us with no where to go and those of us in trailers that are too old and other parks
won't take them.
So Please try and help us keep our homes in Grcystone Park. 13300 E.Tamiami Tr.
#60.
Thank you,
George and Margaret
/'4end.,.{tb,1'j;2eR <' (,
November 27.2007
Page 171 of 190
To Kay Deselem ,
Never thought I would be writing a letter to ask some one to save our home for
us. We moved down here a few years ago and found it to be the friendless place to live.
The only thing is they are building so many places around us and the traffic is bad
now what will it be like when they get all these homes built around us. We are the
cheapest park in Naples and most of us couldn't move to any where else as we couldn't
afford it. Our park has many activities that help us enjoy life with out having to try and
get some one to drive us into town or else where.
After Wilma came through our park you never say such a great turn out to help
each other. We have many widows here that need looking after and we each take turns
doing that. If the widows had to move who would look after them? Many have no other
family to turn to . We don't want to have to leave them on their own please.
When our Manger Jim Guidish died two years ago the folks in our park donated
A large stone monument in his honor. That is the kind of family we are.
Cliff and Sue Deaner
c 2l./t j)~w I..~.v
Ci ~ ,.)
,-:',L' " rl', 0 G: h~J '../
":J _c_. '...--.--J"'-'
,- t~da Q~o 8A
C 2. 0 0 November 27. 2007
, enu(j ~, p"O"mo,"o
cP-.QffV1 tJ~ th, cr:- ~ v~
j)M C'~--. Lcl..</R ~~ Po-lK Ok
~ ~. }::YJf"'- ~ lLO- ~ ~ ~
a
~IJL ~ tOk"') . r.Js, ~ 6<>>- o.!mC I' on1JY>1.04J
~. w,. Ja- ~ od:LV~ -Q, kmp
i.J.fj, G"'d- . v1 .AJl~ ~ JYl6 ~ -6s
%"' D~ ~ pwJ: ~aF A ~ tb
gt;1.UY J- b Q;A.lwJ . uk ~"td a{JJL p cUk ·
Muoe- xl r {7\A/Md r -flop td J-.. --"-
J,.. ~cJ;;. ..v><CCD'ffi'1. ~,ctc.~ CP"'''-'0
~ ~u\::' ~ ~cUJ2d IQQ c 6),1.~D.ujQ/'fld CJr.-lV
~ ~ F CL ~b.u.. p.J2e(W1. :iF"'
UJJ-~ c~ . d_ '-
r..u::- Ol'__e.QQ/Vu~.
(h~Ld~ 1 '
. cf ~ J;jajC/n~
Jk(f-to,," fW ~
A~'1da-+t~'io,.ti'A~:
November 27, 2001'
Page 173 of 190
-- ... j),Q VtA--, f<' ~ II D&".iJ J ~ rn.
:}o--1. OJ\. 80 .-IJI.T7'N- (f..e..~ o12-d f~ ..oh-Li.J-LL
.. . ,,,chrnco-)..t .~ WovJ-.Q.. k LLJ~?i' ~ D.Jj:-uv *, Cl-A/ L , .
, . /l ~ /n... ..... ~ K~ hv-4. ....' ~ bl<J J'}'I-::J,. ~, . .
'..12 .Aa..A^-L-' .Q.M.A..uL..01v.fJJL.L'-I'~ P().~kL L.~ J~}- .
~h., J;J L.f..,.u ~ PlVi41-1 ~ ()L. , (i./ IU4L jn~:Gif- y ~0 .
ftv LL1.#tu 'fc?~L .tt.i/v; .'jcA,-~ -,j" fu-i('" A-~1U ~. ,LV ~
. StlMLc.'a d~. CVr\...l:~ Lv ~ /,) k ~ O...H_ lp.Jt.~(jul(-"
)0 JlLlt:)\~ y-yCG ).--:!bt.~'-q-L;J, I1.v CL)hvl_<--.JJ2~ )...:JaiL (~~
. -tr~.~ ~~~ ~~~ ~:~L hu }I.~~ l~ C0L CLWCA-cQ(Lk-tL
cv, .JJ;u.c,~ f~ qq ~i7 /1 .M/I c.~,.J- ()"/~ ;lb
~~ \JJ.:,L lAJ..-0...t., /"l{)LL{. -~ ()AcLI)...!..... (r1.i--'l,- Urn ...\-, J...-w
..JlG:-rN.., ~ I .~ l.J 1"lVLL ~.(,u...L. stl'-<-1/"'L ~ jltM-u,
---. '~t.. U".u... /1<w-v-'---eL IJ./x...:>;;t:i.u ~ V )J ~ ~
'j),fJ-vL V- (/<I.ft .-f,.U-C/J QQw.u,btL' ().~(HAQ~ (V/l/v t4f~. .
; ,{{Lt.<.e,- Cl ---\l~ fLw,. --:--/-h"W Q ():---rL ~L /! Q Lf tRJ.-. t~40
. ~.A..IA hct C'PG ;:UL~ AJ-Jjhcv:"i (,{./~d..-,4-.J.L ~ , /j k~--..:r .
iu-tL ~o . to hvo - M n ci=t j1M-'~ :1Jmu :to, 6 (~~
0... r ~L <L-v . ccJ ~_ Q 1~ ,/1(7 (Vot fl tJ..-::-U:0 CULL..
, .. kQ-O ~ ~rn.. s-c.'-L.- CL..)1..>~ CTl.c.."- b L'6 111-0 ~ Ltt.... ~L C'1'~
.. Q[L,J- h{L kn~, .... .. . .
. .JJm.- .to-o (J2d ~-Cl"". f-jcv. . h'~~Pb ~.4/V ;4L~
.. ,J)i/...J..,/J{tc{) CL Jt.u~B O..1[]I~c.L, Lj,l~ Ljfk- r
~(M.u. W'YLO_
. . ... . . -,. . KIA.,?5o...( \. L>\...~h'l-rc::
'~2u~ h~
-'
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27. 2007
// d lage 174 of 190
:10: ^ ~])~ o./d~d>su-....~j~~11
7T r~ a...-I ~ 0Y'" "S"t.-T;" /h,{L all ci Yrv:_k!<zS /yv- ~ I c.. K.
T c 77?;, tI k- cJi. 7 1/11 r2 7' a- '?.{ c"'-V(,I_/r- (. f.l r /4/?7 b<2../)'\ <7:'
F l..1.-+ if (j <I
Cll{., of- /11! h CJ/n..z._ CZh.-d ()-J1 Tfu. :STr<l L/
r hCltJ-L. hot 2vT /Vy,CYn"_~{ {'o 9"~L-r /nTo Uh<llile./--.......
fl'cl. <!. e.:jOli t/e ; h h tZ/")e s.
+/ow C!' A /1 a.. I71A ^ !/JA 0 Fp i- 1-C2. C( Y'S ha ~ "'.a.(111 So
~ 0 () d "0 u. os ; n )"\', <; fCU'"' ~ 7C.-l r /l -S P [~11 h lA m It I..
Q ~ '-~L' 4-! i c...k 0( s. {;; 4--1: ~J.t tu~ I' .e It T .Q. v-e..h d' v ~ Cl
)<1.011 (!.-e,. . 1/ e (j /fi L ; /1 fA..e.. )11 CLI'; S h 0 \-t C1 Ccf:-I ~ lr-
~ 3 h c--c.---' )'0 " "d <:; WQ VDf- P Ct ck.~ h U 1'1" :-+/-0 (:.) :::s i)
Lt h+'\ \- TrJ./). L"L S.
f!&..C1S'~ JoVt'll.J C)LA.....<- pee/'ll< 6--<2.. rQ..-Zob~D.
rn CL n. ~ 0 f {? c..<, P () 1 J Q 1I~ Fo L /I s art'... h 01 W.e.. n,
.z.'t\DVL~~ /D mDUe.., .$.-o'n">..e... Cl.0e..- i 11 (,l_.Jh","'--l ~_J'\Ci..I"";,
CL h.d ci Q ~T Ci -L -r 0 l-LI, I / - l<
+11 ,\ j r;. , . ('~~ 1'-''3 u)i!.v-.e- f"i Ie. <1..
iOC/J 0) t':1- ( ~ 0........'-- - i2 .e If (.~ 0 (.{ 1-1 ~ ,
D k --r 0 f wh a. r fA.e. 1 Th 0 vl2 J.,.r wO ti- IcJ b.L +h -n r- """. ..
v-- ..,-; -r- 110'YN- '1 77J R r-.e... ~ h ()-<A I cl k:)..Q... CL ko.v.J 1 0 'Sl'b
I Q. \ I r..u. rn-a rv f '
. ") I
ih,'i ") .),{\ hd D 1'- E' 1/",~...1;;rv of i? JdJ>/1 r..9..()rl~. 'f- /Qas,,- C:\ D
Q. \ \ ur o-'^- (!. a h. ---ro \"'\.L-I p L/Vl )"h tL kL Th \ s. CL (!..<..y (, P
P Ct r- /L- Cl It J. .),( (l .e. f" (7 (,u- h c7 /Ju' 'S .
,,j h a. It k.. l j ~-t-\..-fe I- LH'''''- r- )ldif, ___ .
(] (1v'"ht~
-~/
.C4;2tJ~UH' ..~/fol;J()CJb"'" ...
'.;z}~-_u ",-u21~; ..----,.---- _u~uu: m_-
.._......~/ .~..O'-~J;;..~.
jf:;-~~,-v.;~....._...
-t~~ c.1;133oo_E,:-:r~
, ~ /'
'(~ '?fl ~/'" '.. ~, 3L.f1 L1-{. .... ....
~;tJ,AUJ~-~/~l-"" . .
CJ~~--~2..-vJ::t-~. .
_.~;~.~.~...~~..~
- .~.~:i:;~..okoP~.4.
.. ~...~Jt=~~I;f:~
..t;4~/1-~i'~ ~.,'Y17:"- - ..
.!!xJ~~u~.~d~.~........- ..- .
.~I~Id-DD~~~~{q"1~
._~~~-~~.~~~------
~~~~~~.L.d-~~~
Ci:-e2u~~~_.-1I2.u2-:~~ ....
~e (Jo-vk~~.-1 ~..
/Y\-O~ j:;;y~-~B7 Ad!)j/.]LJ/~~'
V-LH-ULC.....~. ~~9'11~
~~ d..-11 to(), f~~'~ ..
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27, 2007
Page 175 of 190
qP~~-q_q ". . n. ... .. ..
...._a~~_.~-b~_..................
_.~~~~... .-
fJJ.~~-~CL-j q 7r-=--- .....
~..~...~jO&vt~ "'r
.Q~~~--dc/t-._- . .
~0rz~~-f?~.___......
.~ ~,J~-~-'2- . .....~.._
d~~cu. . .1;;::
'f!.5C-()-L)L?~-.~W~-!?~
....~~~~(;t--~~
/~ ' .. .~?O' ~-~~ ..
D-Le.... .... ..,
.. ~/J/JH_--__n
.._....~~
~.~. ..
....J)a.-u[dT_-r~cuJ~__~
L3.36Dti..f~ _.
-r. ' \.-fJtYf;#
. .~.. C!- ..... -q I - . ..
Cf\~~:;r;)~ .
. 01-/ II Y
Agenda Item No. 8A
r,ovember 27. 2007
Page 176 of 190
2- Y1- t, -1 "3 b '7 (" 8
c~",I>I( Y Z (J,I\I 1 IIJ 6~ 1)0 -"J Ii? 'D
/J f"'lIc-?(r"5;/"'I!"rlJ~ ,,1 J.>w,t,""i{ PAle", //c;tI~/"tJ? IN
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27, 2007
Page 177 of 190
IJAI'LC5 ?
Open letter to all members of Collier ('..aunty zoning Board
Greystone Moblle Home Part.: -13300 E. Tam;"ml TI"2lIl hils requested the:.!!Onlng
board to rezone to 8 Rec:nlatlonal Vehcle Park which will allow the ownerS to'
evict 83 families who have lived In the park, some as long as 30 years,Greystone
has already Issued the evlcl.1on notices which I question the legality of wit~lOUt
just cause ami also to 142 others.
The only reason for rezoning Is to make It easier to sell as they reaolved.a bid
to buy wfth that provlslon In It. Florida law states residents have the right Of
first refusal In case of sale, which is to prevent this type of eviCtIons, but does
not apply If the owner can have the property rezoned before he sells it ,Which is
being attempted In this case. In either event the owners 01' Greysyone will reoelve
the same purchase price whether they are allowed to evict the 225 people or
allow the residents to purcl1ase.
This is I:he only home the 83 permanent residents have known In up to over
30 vears. when evicted, they will lose their homes as Florida law forbids relocating
mobile homes over 10 years old. They will receive no money,have no home and
most of them are existing on sodal security only. Now they will be thrown Into
the street broke, no hope and expected to start from scratd't. Pmbi1bIV Il.ttilrdof
them are crippled, hove old age llilments and some are army \lets wll:h debilitating
lr\luries. .
Greysb::me also has 142 snowbirds who own mobile homes and pay rent. 12
months a year but live there 4 to 6 months a year. the popular ~UsJs If" .we L- h'
our $30,000 to $60,000 mobile homes and cannot save the old folkS homes 'Its
Adios Naples, florida along with our buying powerl We are tlIlklJ\galossof 142
familIeS with l:hildren, grandchildren and 1111 our other relatlvesandfrelnds who
visit y~rly. Most 01' us buy our autos, ~or appliances, all. our food'8fld dOthlng
,restuarants and golf 6 months ill year. In the pa$t several years I have ,iun:h85ed
2 autos, Installed a total new kitchen with all new appllances,new heating and
cooling, redec;orated and furnished the living and dining mOms andlilstalled
Pella Windows thruout.
I wonder how the Chamber of Commerce and local merchants will reel if you give
Greystone the right to evict all U5 families by allowing them to rezone to R.V1
Right now these aid people cry them selves to sleep .at night fearing no pl&ce
to go and be without what they consider their family at Greystone.
The residents of the park are forming II CO-OP to buy the pari( to save
these people, but If It Is :zoned R. V., we will be shut out from buying. Naples will
lose 225 families and gain at least 83 welfare <:ascs, the evicted people willlo$e
an average of $8,000 to $ 10,000 per family or approx. 2 million dollars and
Naples wlllllaln a well deserved bad reputation when the fact!; show up In travel
magllzlqes A.A.A. The Naples Ne~ checking weekly for 1;1 story.
. ..~y'tPl'-10.~.. _..,-'
DtCKFRElWALD It'''W';; ~/llJr:n{~ ;<?A'A!:-f.J ';>>r-<'r A R~
lot 48 In Greysto"e park -
5918B\shoprd. ,A{:j",,,'7 .{<J ,4:0IhTf'-"fl//,c:..,.j'-(t;-f)ILE l1",nc
AI mont, MI. 48003 5i'F Ii".r, t1 v ~ rc. II (] t.i"
248-969-2931
Agenda liem No. 8A
November 27, 2007
Page 178 of 190
June 14,2006
Kay Deselem
Collier County Planner
2800 North Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Fl. 34104
RE: GREYSTONE MOBILE HOME PARK
Dear Ms.Deselem,
I am writing to express our deep concerns with the
proposed plan to convert Greystone Mobile Home
Park to a strictly RV Resort. In the process, over
one hundred and fifty senior residents will be
evicted from their residences. In a time when
Naples is extremely short of "affordable housing" a
developer is planning to destroy over one hundred
and fifty dwellings to produce a recreational
facility. And with the same swipe of the hand put
these people out of their homes.
For many of the residents of Greystone Mobile
Home Park this is their permanent home not a
vacation or secondary home. Their life and future
is invested in the property they purchased thinking
they would be protected for their lifetime.
RECEIVED
JUN 19 2006
ZONING DEP;;RTMENT
Agenda Item I~o. 8A
November 27, 2007
Page 179 of 190
There are no compensation plans for the loss of
their homes. All will be lost and few can afford
the replacement of their destroyed housing.
Several residents have resided at Greystone well
over forty years and they call this community
'their family'. If you would visit in this park you
would see and feel this family experience.
These retired elderly people do not deserve to be
evicted and lose their homes and belongings. A
proposed zoning change should be refused.
Please do not support the zoning change and fight
for a denial of the rezoning.
Respectfully yours,
A/I!tzL ~L,AL
Donald & Goldie Kootsillas
13300 E. Tamiami Tr. #75
Naples, Fl. 34114
248.437.0604
e-mail: kootsil1@earthlink.net
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27. 2007
Page 180 of 190
~~ ~"'-~ ~.,~
?-X (,/0 N i~O^",,",,_ j'Y/>.w""
\\~, 3- J..
O..tcn., l{t\fa..~
~.tc"
~~QJ,.->U1; 0:'4
, c:l I
i :1 :) ~~:-J <;:; ~J:~.../y}"-L(~_~ ~~
'^-"'~.u ,,;.,R ,
l.L),- iX"LQ.. _v.n-:--~~<lu~ ~,,-L, -"do--~ (,o./v./
f~\[1.c c. ~J '", ,c\~in'-' rr,<,.'<c...t.", -\J.",v,'c.. ~>Ctk.b~ !J.D ,l.U<' lU'C(' Q.
, "
-\.,-e. CLJJ-t<,-- ~L.) ._\.,i.l--eA.:.....ifLQ~' .I L.J~..o c:..(>-l'. l\.. LU',L-a ~.c.-yl,/i_ v.v\.-..}
...' .; ~I\ ~,J'
".....1..:.-( t-'-lt.-\.....<i., (V'....\. cl \!.'......Ut tv\. (,::.....CJ___'-<...! .CUL.-Y'--...I...OJ"l vu:,,:-..-r..Q.... ,( ...."-L-'L.-C
,
\ ,_, ,..", .--t- t\ ~ '_
"CuQ l~ ~',-, f-li-<.:'-C,--...('J.- l...J;Q,.-~~..<!LlA_AJI'l ,:<'AJJ-V-"'_I-': t....
. G - ......} ,
5.tcct.J:: 'It:v.\-,,..~ (~0"--<l" j..U1'.. CUd!... ;",.", c".UJ-v ;CdL"e.,,:.LUL4J,
.. [) '." ,,' .1
lLlz Cl~ ,Jlj-c\' -":~'.~ (~:"-1' L\.. "Yul- c..r:.U!..h.VI'-", -'iJ-"-'-^"-tr "'-'1 "Jt/c
ct;cJ....'- K~a..c ,,,-OJ ~J,vnd't\ 'oJ". b. C<..hiL-C'yf-" "ke}
1-" ~', 'J iLo..:L J'jJUu..J..,/uv.... C-,,--^^-, ',../'0,;
C v'[\O\.,-L.- to :~:!co .. U
.J ~I' (. ' .L
, " ~-'.J--I.--u.e.Jv}...-0 1'..:r-Cl:....L,1-C.. JJ--' /
'J "'v../'V' ,y
~-- .) ~
Jc"",-"-,--,,Jt'
.iLL c.",,-~\.. tee.'t.,,,,_,,,,,, u?1J<...<-C.-
q'f!:iJ. ~L i~~,,-,~\..tj:tL i2d-
Jj'"c'....v>'__:;., \\J"(", .!:)- 4-ll 'f
-f (Jt;,..1~~, f.MrA.z<U()
)J'tL'i/4.t,A0 Pa.><.b
/6300 ~".d~"','..,a.mu ~.J.. LoI22-!?
'J !e<-;J.M__ /J.f..
",Nlll/-
RECEIVED
JUN 2 1 2006
ZONING DEPARTMENT
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27, 2007
Page 181 of 190
Ii
i ~~~
II. L' /-tvy\..D. ) 3; ;2oo{.
I/( "tr 7C'~~,)'
I . /..v-. ~~ CfJJvvJL. ~ .
I )Ita~~--d-~k./ /LA~/(~h~
I 'f ..0-~.R~I.(p'I-~ jP a-J;, d-1;zZ P"~,
-I R!;L. crt<i.b./ ....1:ff:: (7 9'4- 7~) ..
i.A..-u--i!. . ~u--,-o-<.J!jL~ ;z:; ~
~ .0./Li~~''l' ' )~~;-,Yf
~i -A/v--i4..J!dhg $if Zk<o-v
1!~~'~~~Y~f /~~Q h~~.
Ii _J;)
! ! .\;1--1"U2.-rt-A ~;f:07--w~. -..-J
I: , 11:/1 fl,
I~' L-o.'.Y-~. ..&- -'\.~.0t &.."A. . uo~
i /f.7 ' /JI ' /1 /J
i C~~ ~l 7ltt:hY-){/-''-
. ~Lc.~ {/
I
I
iRECI,;:IVED
d-- -- - -.
j: .
I: JUN 19 2006
['
i
ZONING DEPARTMENT
it
"
;:
!;
I,
I
.~
/
77,~ J~~" ~ a- c2? /~
~ A-adIv(e-u-<-d ~ ~~~
/~~ a- r:;2~ r~ ~ JJ f~ ~~. d-?~
~,.Yc:>--rry to? ~ ~ ~ /~
~ ~~'1' ~~
~-<V ~ ~ a-~~ fl-t:x;d ~
;lnLJ~~~4~~~.
':J?u~~~~/~ /~r
~ ",~.d// r~
d~~ -I-;?{/.J ~.vU~~~~
~j'~ k,~4~' 7 /~*
-(I '-Y'?g, .
~~~Wb ~
7?14(~ ~
076'00 70 . . 4
7?aA ~
~ ')11A ;t/ -?<U&~~I
J ~ t:::L- /2-e~b4z/
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27,2007
~G?~' Page 182 of 190
/3Ic2CO~
RECEIVED
JUN 1'9 2006
ZONING DEPARTMENT
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27, 2007
Page 183 of 190
{LtLj/ ; #"J ~.lwnL; ; 9t.(JU'.; 'l (lC,?
~:/k~LLml/J~/ad. .
$h~'U /7,~tutr!~?(L -rML#/ff,
~~~ dJLd..J d1iu~!JL'fU./ '76'.;V
. . .-'~v 71 ~ ,~ 7~ .UAe. ~~
I ~,jJ - , '/,. I
/J1~1J:/ (]!...e?1./~k"J<_< . ..F7U6 ~
;d~ 7...6';V - ;; </73 1; ~0 , (VJJ ~
. h1 tv /t~d.~~./Vt-iIJJd de--
~ Ii 4dj -~,- /?tUcV~
raMI
~~~~~tj
. A~.)"r;;; i/;t'lt 1/c, ,t1L.o <~.e" /c i Al L'uL :;tt~L<';lv
/t;~,u' "0 0 /I
Clk~ ~f:II~q;
~dd~li . 041
/33<J()d!. ra . "fJ7Rd~J
YJ AJ:JJ.J:A-1,-t ~~
!J I 3 ,If // f
RECE!VED
JUN (9 2006
ZONING DEPARTMENT
Agenda Item No. SA
~'ovember 27. 2007
Page 184 of 1 90
REC'~'" "'."{'''''')
,~. I .' "";
1__ 1, i...~'-
...~, '~
/330 a c.:. d~l..oU :N.
X~ /'1
)~' . ,FL .3"1//?L
/3 0200 ~
}
b.evJ 1JtJJ. ~/
V W>.v ~~ ~ -<.k ~
Ud:/~~~~~~
fi ~~yG~~~J
/~ ~ ~ /7~ ~~)6~
;t; ~ /P'y ~7 Y-~
y1~~a-~
ApL.<''-/,z.v11 9~~;/iH/ o?6~.
??t;t ~,,<. ~~ ...p e a.-,.ne- .,;L;;
~~~:I /9?'l-Z'<!
CU~ ~ J-<L"'N~#<.-~
-j~dL.- aZ. ~~ ~ ~
~.: ~ ~ ~~a.v
~,
JUN 1 9 2005
ZONING DEPAFlTMEN'1
Agenda Item No. SA
November 27, 2007
Page 185 of 190
~ /~ ~U--
k~r~~~ .y_//~:
71~~ i~ ~ O?-U~~
~~~~/~
tTTt./ ~~. >~~ ~
~~~~~
~/fo ~..MY~~
~.J~~
4 ~~ ~/7urv<r' .~ ~
Wu~~~~4~'
~.e. ~ /u-~ ~~
~. r ~ ~ a->."d ~:-z
aJle-c.-d. .A ~ a..- ./7~ ~ ~
a /7~ ;;6~' c::;2Z ~uV ~
/1
~~~~~
II
~?
~ .:zh.v)b~ ~~ ~ ~.L
p-~~~/~I
~r..L-> ~ _../e ~,'~ a.....U..- ~
~ ~,,,~ ~ 4<L /,
Agenda Item No 8A
November 27. io07
Page 186 of 190
$ ~ ~ r CVYr?<-~? ~C1-L-
C<W~ c/..; ~ ~ ~ ~ --L~-<--~
th<-V ~ '-Iu/~ ~ ~
? cu-4.
~~
~ G. ~crr~k
Agenda Item No. 8A
November 27,2007
Page 187 of 190
Date: June 15. 2006
From: Joe an:d Ine.:oc Klein. (Grcywtone R.e.sido~cc)
To: Kay KlI:lscl~a:n
Reg: t:t.e.z;.oning o-f"Greys'tonc JIvlQlblJc I-Iorne nncl RV l"ark
W"e ~ resideru;'::Ie ofGreyat:on.e PI/I,rk in 1:h~ vvio1",elk' 1:0 escape 'the bi1.'tCr v.,rin.t:ers in
JtvftohiSft.l1. VVc love 'the Nap105 area beoause o1:~ it$ proximity tOo the EvCZ"glH..dc:'J and thClo
beaches. 'VVc es'\;oy 'the 'I"'<l'tB'tftU:ra.n:t"s~ bov,..Jing.. golfi ng. and mlO~es a:vai]ub.1c in the a'I':".e~
WNt:,.'). ""'e ht:tve bees.. C1umilng 1:0 G-rc:::yst~ne for ten Y~,*r5 nnd ha.ve fuund vvonderf'ul people
vvho hu..-ve become like CarnHy 1;0 'Us.
OUt' benrt:!l are rsching for all 01.0 p<:oopJe vvho live in C'n-eysl.<--ne yoar...r.c:n..1TKl. T"hey vviU be
displuccd 1"J"<nX1.. 1:h.e ~nly hlOY"ne they huve and vvill be hard prcS5ed to rmd unyt.hin." They
can a1'1brd in t.he Naples a.l"ea. Some vvho are in t;heir eighTies and ni~e\:ic$ a:rc being t:oJd
to pack up an.d lea:ve vv.jt.h no v.../h'l.:lr'e t.n ,fJ::o ~u:1d in ,:;Iorru::: caso;o,l. .n-o t")ne"(;o hc:lp thiOt'I1. S"..mo
have bc:::un in C-rreystOHC: for ......>l,r~n.t.y Rnd 'thirty )'6Urs_ "IThe Naples DaHy NeV'\.TS has articles
about nec.xling al'roruubJe housing ino. 1:be nre.u.. 'Thi~ park :is un.c pluce thut. .is providi.n.g
housing for poople vvhn do l:D..Illd::l'GHping. ca:t.c:e-ing,. 1I':O.nil delivery,. u.r1d ........ork at K-rvfart. and
Pl1hlix_ "VVe.are a diverse co.rntnun1'ty or good pcop.lc.
Our enly hupe :In that; 1:he zonina change request; is t.urnod d..o"vvn. ftI....d tl'.iEt J>ark res:n.a:ins ...........it.h
it:S1 uurre:nt. 7..A>ning. VV'" e are vvorking on a plan. t:o Il'Urchuse ilie prlOpeny and. mn it" as a.
Cooperative ho'usiug u.nit..
T"hiBI:r,k you TC:JoT" reading -this le't'tt:t:r and t.aking it int:o co:usidcr.f:lll.ioD.
Sincorely.
.Joe and Inez Klein
13300 Taru.ilUl"d Trail E. Lo1: 32
Naples FL 34114
Agenda Item No. B.A.
November 27, 2007
Page 188 of 190
FRc:JM
F'AX NO.
S~p_ 29 2085 09:45PM PL
$-"...$ -e>6
......4~. ~~ ~""'~~_~j
=.9 ~-'-"'--- -=,- .?z.--r<>-&'-""-./ ~ ~~ ______
~~ .~_.-e - c.., ~ -v< - .-.G ~~~-....... =~~
/~~, -<~........._. -~~-.4& _Z'.;.- '~r~-7< '--~._--~~-~7 ~--'-;;:;r
~E~~ _~-~~~. 7.z;,~_<z c;?....~_ ~'-'__~_~
/ ..e. J~- _./
'Cl"~~ - ~r-/ .. ~ !-~ ~________~_~ _____......-<" _ .._.:.---<-- _~~
~~ ~__'<-'Z-~ _~ ?~;?'~_. .-.:....-.--ZA!!'.
~-<--"L..- _..e~ ...<'.,:;-- -~-"7'= ...7"...-e~" ~~,~__ _ ~_~_
--=-- --~-~-- -~rr- ~ 7i?~~ ~~ '~7 ~___~__-" ~
.r-~ ~~--.e_~~.....e...
cSl ~~
:?-?--,""",~.J____~
~-
__~~ "-C7~..::z:'=------....q~ c~_ _
c?"A:--....-:' ~
~:,--~-(. ~--<~
./02/ ":'''''T ~
/' --,;;; -'<... ~ ~ e: ;:;7-"'----.--..... ~_
7'7~~____ / r~e:.... ~ y//y
r".( -- -Y""-w . 6""~.y-.?' 7"7~ =-
i
'I
ii
~:I .
1 I B-fU/)
'ii v,~a ~~
: I~f 66 it, tr-'?-- >>-t~.
, 'i-111UJuv ) '1 iv, 3-fl/cJ;jL
'1/-;
I,'!~ce-: 11C ,p' J! J 1(4 AA/l . ~ ~
il ~ 11-u ~ ~/~ .-
"'1 - - -
::1 10- ~ ~~ cd fJt~u.fJ)~
~~~~ilJ ~--0--'~/'~~ri~()--rA~~/r1j1~, i
:tl.~ OAuu~~~-LO\>r 1J.t;r-aA-.v ~~~~ 1~t2JLd- i
~' l)..U..-t/ .Aj~Jp/fvr~ aLtJJ/tAd)-t.--&"& ~.~ .~.d
:~ . (ILuv~jdu,' ~ tf) ~ ~d
~ .('!)IL#--toJ. -'~..J~~~_ M a25 lfw.-~~u.-A:u.0
::.p/ at?~/?4 lPt/J--~~C41-tjcf) J2a.~ ttM}..
I, rfJt ~ /tieL w ~-L~~ ~~1M/ ~.{} ,
:1 ~4<l t:~\lvl'i.WCUvffiu )
li'l . ) ) ((Jy 'J ) p -, }) .
. . V, . fJ ~ 4fYiU.fY!j 4MU~ ,
,r~tfdv?v~et)A' .' ~/( >>WJ~;t&-LjJ
~j-L ~J(l1U{ 11{)19'hf~ - W 1?~~.~
: ~.() J4~~i/),L) ;It) ~i/' . / -tL~/ at )fie-:F!f;w ~
i ~ a:t JJ cUv qU/Ct1~~
'.' 'i~ t11V tlJ~.~ -/La)!c#. r~ (ytLw c15yw,
'i 1u.v ---A?a4t..U ~.LR. A-t 412 d-l-l-1doV io c1rYYLa-ile->
.:~.jf~ tfJ ~!.v-tl~-"-IL4~~"7Lle-- ~ .
'~.'. ....'.~ . .:6~. ~'1wa~d/lJz{;~14.~ ~?~-1tt:.*
.~~~ ~ .~Jc ~~~~/I/~!P[Je)
.,!a-to ~ ~I~;;Z;;'
I T /f~Ag~a Item No. 8A
fJ 0 rA tero.~....~ biOiO...:rn2 2!.7 ~,~.2?09o:,7/.' . ".:.
(\ c!JGO -=-- ~(h
, . WU G...37L,{/-;L )
; . . '.. .... . ... .
--J~ o.~ ~CJO [,
,
!
,I
,
, i
RECEIVED
JUN 2 7 2006
ZONING DEr"ARHAENT
--,1 -
Agenda Item No. SA
November 47, 2007
"P<lae. ,19b of 190
! ~ !
',', I !
i
I ,i (U.a--o .~ d~t! ~ de-, ' ~-<-<LV)
~I~st~x ~~ CU
'~~e~~~~
'-~ ~. I', ?~ A C-t.Wj ~.6 'ttWe00
I~ ~. ~~V ,rM#f
. -1dr~--a/L.1/ ~;:-&t--r-.o--A
r!J!:j4-~K1./ l!'tSOA.b~~~
1,;0 I A fi-..5- G.. \J
/3. __3 OG ..e ,=-l111Wa;j~~/
7"e.:.: 4 [C-Jr /,Iy
:1 I
I'
;!
Agenda Item No. 88
November 27. 2007
Page 'I of 59
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
CU-2007-AR-11970, James M. McCord representing American Dream Bnilders Inc., is
requesting Conditional Use of a modcl home/sales center granting a two-year extension to
allow thc use beyond the five-year time limit, for property located at 4050 13th Avenue,
S.W., within the Estates "E" Zoning District at the southwest corner of the Intersection of
Collier Boulevard (CR 951) and 13th Avcnue, SW, in Section 15, Township 49 South, Range
26 East, Collicr County, Florida
OBJECTIVE:
To have the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) consider an application for Conditional Use
to permit the continued use of a model home/sales center for an additional two years, and to
ensure the project is in harmony with all the applicable codes and regulations in order to make
certain that the community's intercsts are maintained.
CONSIDERA nONS:
The petitioner seeks a Conditional Use (CU) for the continuation of a model home/sales center
located at 4050 13th Avenue, SW, Over a 10-year period, one temporary use permit. two
conditional use petitions, and one conditional use extension have been granted at this site for use
of a model home and sales center. A Temporary Use Pennit (TUP) was issued in 1997, which
expired three years from the date of issuance, The first Conditional Use petition, CU-2000-12,
was approved by Resolution' 2000-444 on November 28, 2000, for a period not to exceed five
years, expiring November 28,2005. The second petition, CU-2003-AR-4799, was approved by
Resolution 2004-50, for a period of one year, expiring on November 25, 2006. The most recent
petition, CUE-2006-AR-9424, approved on July 25, 2006, granted a one-year Conditional Use
extension, which expires on November 28, 2007. As a result, the petitioner has made the current
Conditional Use request for another two-year extension, which (if approved) would expire on
November 28,2009.
The Board of County Commissioners recently directed a Growth Management Plan amendment
to the Golden Gate Area Master Plan (GGAMP) to extend the life of a model home/sales center
beyond the five-year time limit and/or clarify the language in the plan to allow model homes
located in certain areas of the Estates (mostly along Collier Boulevard CR-951), The Zoning and
Land Development Review Director advises that, in her opinion, if this petition were approved
by the Board o[ Zoning Appeals (BZA), this approval could lawfully extend the life of a model
home beyond the initial five-year time frame as outlined in the GMP, The Comprehensive
Planning Department disagrees with that position as outlined below under the "Growth
Management Plan Impact".
The intent of the proposed GMP amendment as directed by the Board is to reduce the financial
impact to the four or five primary home builders providing affordable housing in Golden Gate
Estates, If at the end of each five-year period, the builder is required to close a model home and
Page] of 5
f\oenda Item r\JCJ. 83
r\l~;:Jven:b8:' ::27. 2007
Page 2. o~' 59
construct a new one, the costs associated with this business practice would cause the builders to
pass the additional costs to the home buyer or move to areas outside of the County where there
are less restrictions. Prior to October 2004, there were no time limits on the life span of a model
home. The current restrictions were instituted as part of the Golden Gate Area Master Plan
restudy amendments approved by the Board in 2003.
American Dream Builders currently has 14 residential units for sale and three units under
construction in the Collier County area. The existing model home serves as a display model for
these homes within a 20-mile radius of the site.
FISCAL IMPACT:
Approval of this Conditional Use petItIon will have a neutral fiscal impact on the County
because building permits were already issued to allow the existing construction, The County
collects impact fees before the issuance of building permits to help offset the impacts of each
new development on public facilities, so impact fees have already been paid. No additional
construction is anticipated if this Conditional Use is approved.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN (GMPl IMPACT:
The subject property is designated Estates (Estates Mixed Use District, Residential Estates
Subdistrict) on the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) of the Growth Management Plan. The
Conditional Uses Subdistrict applicable to this sitc in Golden Gate Estates, reads as follows
(adopted on October 26,2004 and became effective January 13,2005.
e) Special Exceptions to Conditional Use Locational Criteria:
Temporary use (TU) permits for model homes, as defined in the Collier
County Land Development Code, may he allowed anywhere within the
Estates-Mixed Use District. Conditional use pennits submitted for the
purpose of extending the time period for use of the structure as a model
home shall not be subject to the locational criteria of the Conditional
Uses Subdistrict, and may be allowed anywhere within the Estates-Mixed
Use District. Temporary Use permits for model homes shall have a
duration of three (3) years from the date of approval. No subsequent
issuance of a Conditional Use permit shall be for a duration exceeding
two (2) years. The total time period for Temporary Use and Conditional
Use permits together shall not exceed five (5) years.
The above paragraph e) was originally adopted in September, 2003. The October, 2004 adoption
provided clarity. Staff's review shows the initial Conditional Use for the subject property (CU-
2000-12) was approved on November 28, 2000, by Resolution 2000-444 for a period not to
exceed 5 years from its original date of adoption. A second Conditional Use (CU-2003-AR-
4799) was approved on February 10, 2004, by Resolution 2004-50 for a period not to exceed 1
year from its original expiration date of CU-2000-12 (November 25,2(05). This one-year cap
Page 2 of 5
Agenca item No. 88
:~OV0mDB: ::7 2'807
=:. Q~ 59
was based upon the 2003 amendment to the Golden Gate Area Master Plan (GGAMP). Further
analysis shows an extension (CUE-2006-AR-9424) was approved on .July 25, 2006, per
Resolution 2006-188 (after adoption of the 2004 clarification to the GGAMP), not to exceed I
year. Therefore, the conditional use for a model home has existed a total duration of seven (7)
years.
Comprehensive Planning Conclusion: Bascd upon the above analysis, and the special exceptions
provision above, staff concludes the proposed request for extension of a model home for the
subject site well exceeds that allowed and may not be deemed consistent with the GGAMP,
however the petitioner wishes to proceed to hearing to allow the BZA to make final consistency
determination,
AFFORDABLE HOUSING IMPACT:
Approval of this variance will have no affordable housing impact.
ENVIRONMENTAL ADVISORY COUNCIL (EAC):
The Environmental Advisory Council (EAC) did not review this petition because the site is
under the size threshold (10 acres) to require an Environmental Impact Statement.
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION (CCPC) RECOMMENDATION:
The CCPC heard petition CU-2007-AR- I 1970 on October 18, 2007 and by a vote of 8 in favor
and 0 opposed recommended to forward this petition to the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA)
with a recommendation of approval. Because the Comprehensive Planning Department has
recommended denial, this petition could not be placed on the summary agenda.
At the October 18, 2007 CCPC meeting, Chairman Strain noted that he agrees with the position
of the Zoning Director. He stated, "that in times that we have, there's no reason we shouldn't be
able to work with the business community. The solution offered is not a long term solution for
everyone. That's not the intent ofthis petition. The GMP should not be changed unilaterally for
all model homes. That was not the intent of the community when the GMP amendment was
designed. The only way that should be vented, he says, is througb the community process, but to
solve the present problem, he sees the proposal being offered is a good solution,"
Chairman Strain was on the Golden Gate Estates Planning Committee leading the change against
the proliferation of model homes in the Estates. Due to slowing of the economy, down tU111 of
the housing sales, high percentage of unabsorbed housing, record foreclosures, and job losses, he
feels times have changed. He agrees with the flexibility the proposal offers of the Board
approving the model home bascd upon the merits of this case. The model home is kept
immaculate and well maintained, the road it fronts (CR-951) is expanding from 4 to 6 lanes, and
the traffic generated by the model is minimal. Also, negative neighborhood impacts to the
neighborhood were not apparent, and the model home was designed and landscaped in a manner
compatible with the surrounding area,
Page 3 of 5
p-,genoa Item I~CL 86
I'~ovember 27 2007
Paae ~ of 59
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS:
Before you is a recommendation by the Planning Commission for approval of a two-year
Conditional Use authorizing a model home and sales center in the Estates (E) Zoning District. A
Conditional Use is a use that is pern1ittcd in a particular zoning district subject to certain
restrictions. Decisions regarding Conditional Uses are quasi-judicial, and all testimony given
must be under oath. The attached report and recommendations of the Planning Commission
required are advisory only and are not binding on you. The Petitioner has the burden of
demonstrating that the necessary requiremcnts have been met, and you may question Petitioner,
or staff, to satisfy yourself that the necessary criteria has been satisfied. In addition to meeting
the necessary criteria. you may place such conditions and safeguards as you decm appropriate to
allow the use. provided that there is competent, substantial evidence that these additional
conditions and safeguards are necessary to promote the public health. safety. welfare. morals.
order. comfort. convenience. appearance. or the general wclfare of the neighborhood. As a
further condition of approval of the Conditional Use. you may require that suitable areas for
streets. public rights-of-way. schools. parks. and other public facilities be set aside, improved,
and/or dedicated for public usc. subject to appropriate impact fee credits. Approval or denial of
the Petition is by Resolution. with approval of the Conditional Use rcquiring four affirmative
votes of the Board.
In reviewing this Petition, the BZA must detennine or find that the granting of the Conditional
Use will not adversely affect the public interest and that the specific requirements governing the
individual Conditional Use. if any. have been met by the petitioncr and that, further. satisfactory
provision and arrangement has becn made concerning the following matters. wherc applicable:
I. Consistency with this Codc and Growth Management Plan.
2. Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with particular reference
to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience. traffic flow and control. and access
in case of lire or catastrophe.
3. The effect the Conditional Use would have on neighboring properties in relation to noise.
glare. economic or odor effects.
4. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other properties in the district.
NOTE: As outlined in this Executive Summary, there is a difference of opinion between the
Zoning and Land Development Review staff and Comprehensive Planning staff with respect to
whether this petition is consistent with the Growth Management Plan, The Planning
Commission unanimously agreed with the determination of the Zoning and Land Development
Review Director with respect to this issue. The BZA is not bound by this determination, and
must make an independent finding that the granting ofthis Conditional Use is consistent with the
Growth Management Plan. -JAK
RECOMMENDATION:
Page 4 afS
P'9snoa !tem I\jo. ,SS
November 27. 20D7
C, 01 5Sl
Staff recommends that petition CU-2007-AR-11970 be forwarded to the Board of Zoning
Appeals (BZA) with a recommendation of approval subject to the following conditions:
1. This Conditional Use shall expire on November 28,2009; and
2. Approval of this petition by the Board signifies a change in
policy to allow model homes to continue to exist along the
Estates lots abutting CR-95 I , and further clarifies direction to
staff to formulate an amendment to the GGAMP to remove
five year limits, and bring such an amendment to the Board
for consideration in the next series of Gomprehensive plan
amendments.
PREPARED BY:
Willie Brown, AlCP, Principal Planner
Department of Zoning and Land Development Review
Page 5 of5
AGE~t'{'Pn!M~~~oso.~
. r-roV'gr'nti~, "-, < L {
Page 6 of 59
cOffi:r County
-~--
STAFF REPORT
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
FROM:
DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION
HEARING DATE: October 18, 2007
SUBJECT: PETITION CU-2007-AR-l 1970
PROPERTY OWNER/AGENT:
Applicant/Owner:
James M. McCord
American Dream Builders, Inc.
5827 Corporation Circle
Fort Myers, FL 33905-5014
REOUESTED ACTION:
James M. McCord representing American Dream Buildcrs Inc. rcquests approval of Conditional
Use CU-2007-AR-11970 in the Estates Zoning District for a model home/sales center, as specified
per Section 5.04.04.B.3.e of thc Collicr County Land Dcvclopment Code (LDC) on 5 :t acres,
GEOGRAPHIC LOCA TION:
The subjcct parcel is located at the intersectIon of Collier Boulevard (CR 951) and 13th Avenue,
SW, in Section 15, Township 49 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida.
PUUPOSE/DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT:
The petitioner seeks a conditional use (CU) for the continuation of a model home/sales center.
Over a 10-year period, a temporary use permit, two conditional use petitions, and one conditional
use extension have been approved for LIse of a model home and sales center at this site, A
temporary use permit (TUP) was issued in 1997, which expired three years from the date of
issuance. The first conditional use petition, CU-2000-12, was approved by Resolution 2000-444
on November 28, 2000, for a period not to exceed five years, expiring November 28, 2005. The
second petition, CU-2003-AR-4799, was approved by Resolution 2004-50, for a period of one
year, expiring on November 25, 2006, The most recent petition, CUE-2006-AR-9424, approved
on July 25, 2006, granted a one-year conditional use extension, which expires on November 28,
2007, American Dream Builders currently has 14 residential units for sale and three units under
CU-2007-AR-11970 Date ofCCPC Meeting Page ~ ofB
cr---J;
~~~
Z I_~ "",
= (",! il'
~ ~>2!
S~-
.". -
<'Z
".
1 -
. I
"
i w - ;
0
> z "
~
< ;
I' .
i ~ 0..
I <(
WN\':l :::iE
--- ---
! ! !
,
.;
'" !
~ - -
< ,.,.
" C\I
:::l
~
<
0"
;j'
a..~
()~
w
!
-
z
o
w-
'::~
,"0
o
~
w
i...SJ.Sl-U.6
WN\':)
,
"]ll~O\
z
o
"
~
o .
;j 0
Co ~
.
~
(lr,;6 "~r:J)
mW^31nOA
,
.
o
o
~
~ , ,
'" , .
" ~
~ CD . ~
z ... - z W
, ~ , C\I ~
< <
::> if
~... ~ ~
, . I
I -
,
,
-,--~~
,
, ! !
! 5;
" '.
'" ~ 7 "a; ~~ !
r i f
,
! ~ ! !
6. 6. ,
"
., N' ::' g~
,- j ." .1 ~ >-z
I' !' 00 ,
i w- ,
~.,
00
g:g
~f!
~ g~
,
'I ! P !
" 5.
, m! ;"' ~ ~~ i,
I, . .,' " h ,
.d I' ! r
B , g
il g 1IW~1ol;I11'lO':;> IPlV'l
Ii
l
jP
I ,
, i ., ~~ 'i ! ffi ~~ j e! , . IIi.
'v' P -I" " JI i l!;l CiS ~
" 16\ r ~ I . Ii !ii: ~)j l~ ! ~
i
_mNAnlOIl~ j-
.......1 i. t
L llW~_'UM I
!~ !
p
,
'.
.,
,-
i'
V ! . f !
6 II 51': t,..... ! "~
., , ! ,
~ ~ ~ -:::: ~ ~ "~ ,
I' ., j
, i ! I:
t3
~t1!}
'Il;
-~-
L
~!
LJ"L
Q !!=~
~ ~J:!
-~
i'
w
"
z
~
<
,
"
~
I"IQ<OJIOl<
I I--
,
.
,
o
z
z
o
N
o
~
~
.
o
....
'"
-
-
3
~
Ii<
<(
,
....
o
o
N
,
::l
o
..
z
o
...
t-
ill
!l.
.
I
I
Il.
<(
:::iE
z
o
I-
<(
(j
o
..J
~p,qenda Item l\lo. 88
N~ovemb9: 27. 2007
;:'ag8 b of 59
construction in the Collier County area. The model home serves as a display model for homcs
within a 20-mi1c radius of the site.
As a result, the petitioner is requesting another two-year extension. This conditional use (if
approved) would expire on November 28, 2009
SURROUNDING LAND USE & ZONING:
Model Home and Sales Ccnter; zoned "E" Estates
SUBJECT PARCEL:
SURROUNDING:
NOlth:
East:
South:
West:
Florida Homes Model Home and Sales Center; zoned "E"
C.R, 951 right-of-way; zoned "E"
Vacant, undeveloped; zoned "E"
Vacant, undeveloped; zoned "E"
. " . . . . " . o. ~
. . u , . " . "
~
.' .'
..- , . . ~
11II ~
. . . . . . . . ,. ~ !
. . . . . . .; M
W
E
,~ = -
7..
. . . . . . . . ,. .
. . " . " . . ,.
FUI'
~I
"ru ,~
~'
. , . . " ,. " . JI'J/" 'll'
,-.
--"
-
~
Zoning Map & Aerial Photo
CU.2007-AR-11970 Date of cepe Meeting Page 3 of 8
~
,
,
I
I
I
I
<;)'
;Ii,
LEGEND! ABBREVlA liONS
o SE' tRON PW IIYC"" I!.or.l
6 Flll!_ Hili' )Ii{j nil lAB
i:J OlD COIfC MON
o rNR mON I"'i
~ DeNtll /,I,I,'l1(
<"Q.,POIltRPO!C
III ""
C . CAtcU'..lllTI
Y-J.ft,tSIIl/[D
,. - pur. C. OHD
(.ClH!UWllt
Dr. rm"'WAC[[A.S(II[11r
!.Ie - Vr.LnYfASfJJ(lH
A/C. M? ('YJlIDIJI~UI
WfJ _ WA'TRJ.lCrffi
ce _ 'A'CN PASI'I
VI'.. I#NHOI..[
pc - POOL fWIi'J.lO/f
[0/>,1: _ COIICPC!r
1)1,... VI!Ulln
roe ~ lOP D' (JAV':
8 _l>IEi
. ~ sPRINKLE;' /0'[-10
!I _S!lJIJ!"
~ SHI?U(J
=
Murch 9. 20D6
Do\-~- ~f Survey;
Scole: _~.:=_J...9..9~
Pro ject No, ~.flZ~~.l.:t
Fe No. _.2L P._lil_
Job No. __..946 !...~_
COPYRICH, 2?Q5 Bv CArlo:.
BOUNDARY
SURVEY
f\oenda itern l'>JO. sa
r~ovemoer " / 20Ci7
::18g: S- of 5~)
100' RIGHT or WAY
CULLIER BOULEVARD (pla.tted C.R. 951)
:::
TRACT 118
~
h
C>)
-
if.
"". 90",.' SOO'l 9'10'W 330.0 (P&M
~
300.0'(Ml3 roUiiD- - --
e 5/8 ROD
n G) p(\ NO CAP ,
(0 l1l,i<<
m 155.i
-~-I-- ~ --
. (0 l
e ;
!
f
r
[
,
.C
.1
lill~
I
I
I
G
G 80 0",,10
r-\ ill e\ff~0
'""" ":J:
~;-;-;'.;{~'~~~~:'l~t""
.~[
~I
I
I
1
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I 300.0'(M) ()jj.!I<1lJl':l:
NOO'19'\ O'E 330.0'(P&C)
CU-2007-AR-11970
Project: 200304()01 I
Date: 716107 DUE: 813/07
.0
Co fJ
.
iff
FOUND
5/8 ROO
NO CAP
BENT
FOUND
P[RM ~ --qr-
REFERHJCE I
iWNUMl::~n I
I
I
I
I
I
I
vi I
~ I u
~ ~ I .;;
~ 0 I ~
~ ~ ! d
~ a: I ~
~ ~ I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I,w
10
I ,n
'0
I ~
Igj
11/0
ENLARGED DET.1IL :
ONE STORY RESIDENCE I
I
I
____L
:;
~
.
g
g
.
^
.0'
rOUND
5/B ROD
NO CAP
TRACT 103
mls SURI1':Y IS PRf:PARt:D rOR,
AMERICAN DReAM BUILDERS, INC
r hereby certify that this survey meets
tile minimum technical slorrdards 05 per
Chapter 61C17-6 F.A.C.
This is not 0 c(j(lifir;ote of Title, Zoning,
or Freedom of encumbronces.
Abstract has not been reviEwed and
of her eosrJments and restrictions may
apply 10 this parcel. All other easemenls
(lla! R:d.'it ore required to Df: pro\1ded
to Un' slJrveyor by the cfient of his
or ner agent per Fiorido Siatute
6IeI7-6.00J (/0) F.A.C.
a~ ~. )It;J4/
Carol [. Nelsorl, P.L.S. #5013 . tJb I
JJO Wilson Boulevord Svu/h
~WT VALID UNLlSS Nop/r:s, f10rida 34-117-.9364 ,
::M80SSU) Wllfi S~N~ (239) 304-0055 O!ficc I
~.~~!!~S i?E5tR~~~______----.G_~~) J04-0047 Foc:.;imile .__~
LECAL DESCRIP nON
ALL of TRAG T fl9, GOlD[N GA TE
ESTA TtS. UNIT NO. 26 recorded
in Plat Book 4, page 15 0-' {he Public
Records of Collier Cor.m Iy, norido.
ADDRESS OF PROPERTY:
4050 Ufh A VFNUF S W
NOTES:
FLOOD ZONE ~X" - PANEL 120Q57 0425 G.
!:JI~^RINGS BAS,:O ON PHySICAL CENITRlIN( Cf
IJ\11 AV(NUE S.W. AS 8[lt>lG N6S'40'SO'W,
r NG:;Ol\'.
---
,,'
.<;
~
"0
o
'"
'"
TT?ACT 120
TWACT 119
'"
,
o
C0
"0
."
m
~
'-
g
.
"
FOUND
5/8 ROD
NO CAP
REV: 1
....
.....
~
.....
....
~
r;;..,
,Agenda Ite~~N~, ~~
Novem09i ,.::: t . 20u
F'ags 1 (J 0; 5~i
GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN CONSISTENCY:
Future Land Use Element:
Comprehensive Planning staff has reviewed this request and offered the following comments:
The petitioner's property, as identified on the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) of the Growth
Management Plan (GMP), is designated as Estates (Estates Mixed Use District, Residential
Estates Subdistrict), The Conditional Uses Subdistrict, applicable to this site in Golden Gate
Estates, reads as follows (adopted on October 26,2004 and becamc effective January 13,2005.
c) Special Exceptions to Conditional Use Locational Criteria:
Temporary use (TU) permits for model homes, as defined in the Collier
County Land Development Code, may be allowed anywhere within the
Estates-Mixed Use District. Conditional usc permits submitted for the
purpose of extending the time period for usc of the structure as a modcl
home shall not be subject to the locational criteria of thc Conditional
Uses Subdistrict, and may be allowed anywhere within the Estates-Mixed
Use District. Temporary Use permits for model homes shall have a
duration of three (3) years from the date of approval. No subsequent
issuance of a Conditional Use pcrmit shall bc for a duration cxceeding
two (2) years. Thc total timc period for Temporary Use and Conditional
Use permits together shall not exceed five (5) years.
The above paragraph e) was originally adopted in September 2003. The October 2004 adoption
provided clarity. Staff's review shows the initial Conditional Usc for the subject property (CU-
2000-12) was approvcd on November 28, 2000, by Rcsolution 2000-444 for a pcriod not to
exceed 5 years from its original date of adoption. A second Conditional Use (CU-2003-AR-
4799) was approved on February 10, 2004, by Resolution 2004-50 for a period not to exceed I
year [rom it's original expiration date of CU-2000-12 (November 25,2005). This one-year cap
was based upon the 2003 amendment to the Golden Gate Area Master Plan (GGAMP). Further
analysis shows an cxtension (CUE-2006-AR-9424) was approved on July 25, 200G, per
Resolution 2006-188 (after adoption of the 2004 clarification to the GGAMP), not to exceed 1
year. Therefore, the conditional use for a modcl home has existcd a total duration of scven (7)
years.
Comprehensive Planning Conclusion: Based upon the above analysis, and the special exceptions
provision above, staff concludes the proposed request for extension of a model home for the
subject site well exceeds that allowed and may not be deemed consistent with the GGAMP,
however the petitioncr wishes to proceed to hearing to allow the BZA to make final consistcncy
dctermination.
Transportation Element:
Extension of this conditional use can be considered consistent with Policies 5.1 and 5.2 of the
Transportation Element of the Growth Management plan for the following reasons:
1) The traffic associated with this CU is existing, and is included in background traffic. The
extension does not propose to create new traffic.
CU-2007-AR-11970 Date of cepe Meeting Page 5 of 9
Agenc3 ite~!'J~_ _ 8,~
['J:::WenlDSr ';':,'. LOC;,
:)ag~ i 0:" 5f
2) The number of trips can be considered deminimis.
However, the adjacent roadway may be over capacity if not constructed within 5 years (Project
no. 68056 CR-951 from Golden Gate Boulevard to Green Boulevard)
Therefore, this project is consistent with Policy 5.1 and 5.2 of the Transportation Element.
ANALYSIS:
Beforc any Conditional Usc rccommcndation can be offered to the Board of Zoning Appeals, the
Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) must make findings that: 1) approval of the
Cnnditional Use will not adversely affect the public interest; and 2) all specific requircments for
the individual Conditional Use will be met; and 3) satisfactory provisions have been made
concerning the following matters, whcrc applicable:
1. Consistency with the Land Development Code and the Growth Management Plan,
The requested use is not consistent with the applieable elements of the GMP as noted in thc
Comprehensive Planning Department's consistency rcview on page 5. Zoning statT,
however, feels the use is consistent with the LDC as any potential impact may be mitigated
by proper usc and adherencc to the requirements of the I,DC and/or stipulations in the
conditional use. The nature of the model home and its related components are not
incompatible with s1l11'olmding development.
2. Ingress and egress to the property and proposed structures thereon, with particular
reference to automotive and pedestl'ian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control,
and access in case of fire or catastrophe.
Adequate ingress and egress to the site will be provided from CR-951 via 13Lh Avenue SW.
There is clear site distance as welL Thc project docs not add additional trips to tho roadway
network; therefore, it would have minimal impact on the levcl of service of the adjaeent CR-
951 roadway. The project has been doomed consistent with Policies 5.] and 5.2 of the
Transportation Element of the GMP.
3. The effect the Conditional Use would have on neighboring Ilroperties in relation to
noise, glare, economic 01' odor effects.
The use would not have a negative impact on surrounding properties, Only a small portion
of the five acre site is developed. The remaining pOliion is undeveloped, The use, which has
been in existenec for more than] 0 years, does not produce glare, noise, or obnoxious odor.
4, Compatibility with adjacent propel'ties and other property in the district,
The proposed use is compatible with surrounding uses. North and east of the subject
propelty are other model homes, and south and west is vacant, undeveloped land.
Approximately three-fourths of the property is undeveloped and wooded, which provides a
buffer for nearby uses. The model home is constructed as a single family structure, and
would be used as a single-family dwelling after its expiration as a model use. Traffic and
GU-2007.AR-11970 Date of cepe Meeting Page 6 of 9
Aoends !tem No. 88
r,JovemDer 27 2007
Page :2 of 5S
noise impacts produced by the use are minimal. No more than two staff members ill'e
employed on-site at one time.
EAC RECOMMENDATION:
The Environmental Advisory Council did not review this petition because the site is under the
size threshold (10 acres) to require an Environmental Impact Statement.
NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING (NIM):
Synopsis provided by Linda Bedtelyon, Community Planning Coordinator:
The NIM was held at the Americilll Dream Builders model home and sales center located at 4050
13Lh Avenue SW on September 18, 2007 at 5:30pm. Two Collier COWlty staff members were
present: Willie Brown (Principal Plalll1er) and Linda Bedtelyon (Community Planning
Coordinator). No members of the pubic were prescnt. After sitting and talking with the owner
and agent for over 30 minutes, staff eoncluded the meeting.
SUMMARY:
Amcricilll Dream Builders has been in thc business of providing affordable housing to the
residents of Collier County for an extended period oftimc. The subject model home/sales center
has been in existence for the past] 0 years. No more than two employees service the site at one
time. Nothing about the physical arrangement of the site has changed since its construction
when the use was first established. The "initial life" of a Model Home, is comprised of first, a
timc pcriod of 3 ycars via approval of a tcmporaty usc pcrmit, and sccond, by an additional timc
pcriod of 2 ycars by way of Conditional Usc approval. The Zoning Director advised thc applicant
prior to the submittal of this application that, in her opinion, if the application was approved hy
the Board of Zoning Adjustment and Appeals (RZA), this approval could lawfully extend the life
of a model home beyond the initial 5 year time ii'ame as outlined in the GMP. It is the opinion
of the Zoning Director tllat the only way to extend an approval of a model home beyond the
"initial life" of 5 ycars and still remain consistent with the intcnt of thc GMP, is by way of
approval of an extension of time tlu'ough approval of a new Conditional Use application by the
BZA. The Zoning Director has taken the position that the time limitations on a Conditional Use,
pursuant to the language in the GMP as it relates specifically to model homes, is consistent with
and furthers the intent of the GMP and LDC, Specifically, the intent of the GMP was to allow a
limited lifespan of these types of uses as the public deemed appropriate. Because model homes
are considercd temporary uses both by thc GMP and LDC, the public hcaring process required as
part of the Conditional Usc process coupled with the 2-year time limitation for model homes,
provides the oppOItunity for regularly scheduled monitoring and evaluation of the impaets of
what is actually a commercial use in a residential neighborhood. Fmthermore, it provides the
opportunity to the public to voice concerns at a duly advertised public hearing on a once every
two-year time frame. Additionally, tlle Conditional Use process gives the ability to the BZA to
place appropriate stipulations as part of project approval in order to mitigate any potential
negative impacts of the usc, Lastly, it provides thc BZA the opportunity to disapprovc the use
should and when changes in the neighborhood make it so incompatible that even reasonable
buffering requirements or specific activity restrictions are no longer effective and/or the model
home has served out its usefulness to the community.
GU-20D7-AR-11970 Date of cepe Meeting Page 7 of 9
,'\C9n:i:::, iE:rTl j\;::. E:E
i\r~ClV8rTlb~' 2:'" :2007
:::'ag8 ~ ~'j 01 59
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends that the Collier County Planning Commission find that the extension of the
life of model homes beyond 5 years by way of approval of this Conditional Use application
consistent with the GMP, and recommend approval of Petition CU-2007-AR-11970 to the Board
of Zoning for a life of 2 additional years,
PREPARED BY:
w.~ ~W'"'
WILLIE BROWN, AICP, PRINCIPAL PLANNER DATE
DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
REVI
TZKOW
ISTANT COUNTY ATTORNEY
I,
IO/r:;/7
,
DATE
'0:
RA YM 0 V. BELLOWS, ZONING MANAGER DATE
DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
/0- <<:-~G7
~/ '177. ~k/~h.24 ) /0/0' /2co 7
./SUSAN MURRA Y ISTENES, AICP, DIRECTOR DAIlE'
DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
API'ROVED BY:
~
~-
/ok-4?
Jp PH K. SCHMITT, ADMI STRA TOR DATE /
rt MMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION
L.
Cullier County Planning Cummission:
tv evl. e v~L/
MARK. TRAIN, CHAIRMAN
\0- \ 13 --- 0 "7
DATE
Staff report for the October 18, 2007 Collier County Planning Commission Meeting
CU-2007-AR-11970 Date of cepe Meeting Page 8 of 9
;i,aenoa item I\lG 38
r~ovemoer 27,2007
F)age "14 of 5S1
Tentatively seheduled for the November 27,2007 Board of County Commissioners Meeting
Attaclunents: A. Findings of Fact
CU~2007.AR.11970 Date of ccpe Meeting Page 9 of 9
_....__~~...~,,~ _._>..,___._..m."'_"
L,oenoa Ilsrn I\j~" 35
t~ovember 27. 2007
P2;::1S -;5 o~ 59
BY
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
FOR
A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION
FOR
CU-2007-AR-11970
The following facts are found:
1. Section <text> of the Land Developmcnt Code authorizes the conditional use.
2. Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the publie interest and will not
adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because
of:
A, Consistency with the Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan:
Yes No
B. Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with particular
reference to automotivc and pcdestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and
control, and acccss in case oOire or catastrophe:
Adequate ingress & ef,'l'ess
Yes No
C. Affects ncighboring propel1ies in relation to nmse, glare, economIc or odor
cffccts:
No affect or _ Affect mitigated by <text>
_ Affect calUlOt be mitigated
D, Compatibility with adjacent propcl1ies and other property in the district:
Compatible use within district
Yes No
Based on the above findings, this conditional use should, with stipulations, (copy
attached) (should not) be recommended for approval <text>,
DATE:
CHAIRMAN:
Attachment A
,ti,aenCl8 Item l"io. 88
November 27, 200~'
Page 16 of 59
FINDING OF FACT
BY
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
FOR
A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION
FOR
The following facts are found:
1. Section <text> of the Land Development Code authorized tbe conditinnal use.
2. Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will
A. Consistency with tbe Land Development Code and Growtll Management
Plan:
Yes No
B. Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with
particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience,
traffic flow and G()!ltrol, and access in ease of fire or catastrophe:
Adequate ingress & egress
Yes No
C. Affects neighboring propcrties ili rclation to noise, glare, economic or
odor effects:
No affect or _ Affect mitigated by <text>
__ Affect cannot be mitigated
D. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in tbe district:
Compatible use within district
Yes No
Based on the above findings, this conditional use should, with stipulations, (copy
attached) (should not) be reeolllmended for approval <text>.
DATE:
MEMBER:
l'a1!..:lofl
C',:H':",,:;-,
COLLIER COUNTY
CO~,r;;:' OF COlll~TY COMMISSI()I~EF~~,
Item Number:
Item Summary:
"11,,'11'" "i'P'
,.'1; ;.;~CII~I: am" [y' s,,:,.~,; :r,
''''2'1' (1,Seil S'.H(, t,. r,.:' (v.,
~''''n
"'"P'
S~I "
lJC''?'1
.~'n;
-II""
Meeting Dale:
"of
Prepared Bv
Will,(,t-"'-..'"
""'11(:,'-1, ""-'1''''
'"",
(;ommlJn,,;r"'v('laomcnt
t.-n",ronmem;il Ser~,c(y
2GnlnC"-I,""i!)''V'lo"",,,n'h,.v'('I.'
11:,;~(1". 1':;(ib~~ Af.'
Approved By
,IOS<>Iltl V. Scnnlltt
,--OnmIWl!'/t)"V'~,armlCnl<;
!'rw!ronmen(,ii Sl'rv,ees Admmstr:lt",
DJV
:;"m'ttur,,,\' f"'V010rmenti; Cn'W1rl"1!1I' [}"i"I(,,,m(,nl.
t:n'.'"onmcntd! S' rvl~'"
:::fI'.'lr""mcn ,.,1 "!,tv,("'-'~'\()m";
11' 13.'2007 [5~ oP'
Approved Ih
,.Jorn' t: ~e(lr, Id~:
-'r.m&,Jl"m'M,['''-''S,o'''',.~rn'n,str'Jt().
U"t'.
"""",\."YIJI"
""-I"'.~, ~'" 'I(""~ "(]~',,.-,
Approved B~
Jlt,: hi"
(,.,'r
'elm"."
";",," :.,
i"'"''''
0""'"
,,~ y'
'"""""."
Approl'eu H~
j'J",1 C.,1~J'a;"u"Ji
r,p" 'jlr'e~'('
rJ:,"
, f~ 'l~,,,o ,'[J i 'CO"
"""" ",,"''''h,
.F <':
Appro,'ed B.,
:,,'''''~r','''.- "" ",-,.-
".- "~,,t,-/'
'~Grnm""," r"""'OI'",<:nt,'
',('n'~'L""'1 '-'n" I"'W[\(I.
~n"'''or1rnC'1r;: Sn,,"::;
""""",,'''1,
~"', "-'<:,"',
'''I'
Appro\,(,d II}
C>lJs;:l1lj""r.,'.'/-'I.:>'
;,:,-Jr";I"""0p"""l'i.i""G:0'
i.',ll<
';orn"'.'_",I""pv"i(">r",,,,'
'-n,"C""'T,~m ~~l,r"
;"", ,'" '-i.'"'' "'''''''''''''''.'m,,'.''''
: I.' 1 ~.'~(JG-' - ~"! pr.
Appn'\'t'"d B,
.I'.'ffhii\Z;;""
a,.'t ~',Ol!<l',' Att,)"",;
1.'''1'
c-aucl1' (-\()0r'Il'
,')' "I' '" tH" '" '.11 ,', ~
"1S.'~O:'- ~ l:i ry
Approved lJ~'
':)",!O("W,,'(i''':1!;:''
'-\lJL" """"'c, "Il;C;-" ,
'F'"
i,dm,n'S1",i,'" :'''''VIC{-.'~
"':W'fI'" ~v"'n", '0'
, "1 ~:2n[)- c' 43 PI"
Allpruved By
r'''i'''' I~"~'"''
h"ClW'i 'n;.,'
rJ~""
,";OLl'W..' r'~"r :,CH" "Cfi,~c
dl,'''H'''''(,:TIcn :; L,u~oc'
.. "j :.';'~c( " .:--:' A,'
Approved By
Jnrw-," ";,L,d,'
",,~t,' i.',,,,',,,,,,
~'~. .11'
"'~Hr; '''''lIt''f''
'::;'.omml,';'("W:
'.. 'n~
'''',,(.,
fik:II('.' \Agendu T est\EXflOft\93- Nnvem ber%,2027, '%202007\OX, '~o2()A[)VERT] SED'!:o20P
11/20/2007
Aoenda Item No. 88
IJoV121l1De; 27. 2007
Paae 18 of 59
RESOLUTION 07 -_
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OF
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, RELATING TO PETiTION
NUMBER CU-2007,AR-1I970, GRANTING A TWO-YEAR
CONDITiONAL USE FOR A MODEL HOME AND SALES
CENTER AT 4050 13TH AVENUE S.W., LOCATED WITHIN THE
ESTATES DISTRICT "E," IN SECTiON 15, TOWNSHIP 49
SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST, COLLIIJR COUNTY, FLORIDA.
WHEREAS, the Legislature of tile Slate of Florida in Chapror 125, Florida Statures, has
conferred un all counties in Florida the power to cstablish1 coordinate and enforce 7.oning mtd such
business regulations as are necessary for the protection of the public; and
WHEREAS, the County pursuant thereto has adopted a Land Development Code (Ordinance
No. 2004-41, as amended) which establishes regulations for the zoning of patticular geographic
divisions of the County, among which is the granting of Conditional Uses and the extending of the
time periods of approved CondiLional Oscs; and
WHEREAS, on November 2g, 2000, the Board of Zoning Appeals of Collier County, Florida,
adopted Resolulion No. 00-444, a copy of whidl is attached hereto as Exhibit A, gnmling American
Dream Builders, Inc. (Petitioner), a Conditional Use for a model home sales center on property
located within the Estates District "E," more particularly described in Exhibit B, which use expired
November 28,2005; and
WHEREAS, on Fehrllary 10, 2004, the Board of Zoning Appeals of Collier Counly, Florida,
adopt.ed Resolution No. 04-50, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit C, granting a
Conditional Use which extended by one year, to Novcluber 25, 20061 the expiration date originally
established through Resolulion 00-4iJ.t\; and
WHEREAS, on July 25, 2006, the Board of Zuning Appeals adopted Resolution No, 06-188, a
copy of which is attached hereto as Ex.hibit D, which granted Ll one-year extension to the Condilional
Use established through Resolution 04-50 subject to tbe conditions applicable thereto and additional
conditions; ~md
WHEREAS, on November 28, 20{)6, the J)oard of Zoning Appeals adopted Resolutioll No, 06-
306, copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit E, correcting a scrivener's en'or in Resolution No,
04-50 relating to the Conditional Use's expiration date which is (as C01Tcctcd) November 28,2007;
and
WHEREAS, Golden Gate Area Master Plan Section I1I.B.2. provides that "no subsequent
issuance of a Conditional Use pennit shall be for a duration exceeding two (2) years;" and
WHEREAS, the Petitioner has submitted a writteu request for an additional Conditional Use
for the model home sales center; and
0......." 1 "Fry
Aoenuc ilem !'>Jc. 3:=;
I'JCW8;TDS; :=7, 20G-
~;ao!:> 19 0" 5~<
WHEREAS, the Collier County Planning Commission has found as a findings of fact (Exhibit
F) that s3lisfactory provision and all'angernem h~ve been mflde concerning all appli;:;ahle matters
requireu by said regulations and in accordallce wilh Subs.ection lO.OB.OO.D. of the Land
Development Code; and
WHEREAS, the Board of Zoning Appeals has held a public heUling after notice as in said
regulaLions made and provided, and has considered lbc advisability of granting an additional twow
year Condifional Use for lhis properlY; find
WHEREAS, all interested parties have been given oppOltunity Lo be heard by this Board in
public meeting assembled, and the Board having considered all matters presented.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OF
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that:
1. Petition No. CU-2007-AR~1l970, filed by Edward B. Hanf and JClmcs M. McCord on
be-half of American Dream Builders, Inc., for a Condition.1l Uile for a model home and sales celller at
40S0 13111 Avenue S.\V., Naples, Florida, morc particulmly described ill Exhibit E, as shown on the
boundary survey (Exhibit G), is approved subject to the condifiollR ~ct forLh in Exhibit 11.
2. This Conditional Us.e shall expire on November 28. 2009.
BE IT FURTHER IlliSOLVED that this Rewlulion relatlllg to Perition No, CU-2007-AR-
11970, be recorded in the minutes of this Board.
This Re.<:;olution adopted after motion, second and super-majority vote this ~ day of
,2007.
ATIEST:
DWIGHT E BROCK, CLERK
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
13y:
By: .__
JAMES COLETIA, Cllainnan
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as La foml and
leg" SU1 ieie ~
i-
It
IV
A. Klat . (Ow
ing Ass s ant County Attorney
Jeffre
Marw
EXHIllIT A - Copy of Resolurioll No. 00-444
EXHIBIT B - Legal De~criplion
EXHIBIT C - Copy of Resolurioll No, 04-50
EXlllIJITD - Copy of Rc.,olutlon No. 06.188
EXnIDIT E - Copy of Resolution Nu. 06-306
EXHIllIT'r - Finding' of Fact
EXHIBIT G - Boundary .survey
D.......... ') "f:')
17Cl
RESOLUTION NO. 2000- .tiL-
A RESOLUTION PROVIDING FOR THE
ESTABLISHMENT OF A MODEL HOME
CONDITIONAL USE IN THE "E" ESTATES ZONING
DISTRICT PURSUANT TO SECTION 2.6.33.4. \.3 OF
THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE
FOR PROPERTY LOCATED IN SHerrON 15,
TOWNSHIP 49 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST, COLLIER
COUNTY. FLORIDA.
WHEREAS, the Legislature of the State of FJorida in Chapter 67-1246, Laws of Florida, and
Chapter 125, Florida Stamte.s, has conferred on Collier County the power to establish, coordinate and
enforce zoning and such business regulations as are necessary for the prote<:tion of the public; and
WHEREAS, the County pursuant thereto has adopted a Land Development Code (OrdinBnce
No. 91-102) which includes a ComprehensIve Zoning Ordinance establishins regulations for the
zoning ofpanicular geographic divisions of the County, among which is the granting of Conditional
Uses: and
WHEREAS. the Collier CouJUy Planning Commission, being the duly appointed and
constituted planning board for the area hereby affected, has held a public hearing after notice as in said
regulatjens made and provided, and has considered Hm advisability of a Conditional Use pursuant to
Subsection 2.6.33.4.1.3 of the Land Development Code in an "E" Estates Zone for it model home on
the prQPerty hereinafter described, and has found as a matter of fact (Exhibit "A") that slltisfaclory
provision and ammgement have been made concerning all applicabJe matters required by SElid
regulations and in accordance wilh Subsection 2.7.4.4 of the Lalld De....elopment Code for the CoUier
County Planning Commission; and
WHEREAS, aU intcfC.'lted parties have been given opportunity to be heard by this Board in a
public meeting assembled and the Board having considered all matters presented,
NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, BY THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS of
Collier County, Florida that:
The petition flied by James McCord. representing American Dream Builders, Inc., with
respect to the property ner.cinafter described as:
Tract 119, Golden Gate Estates, Unit 26, as recorded in P,at Book 7, Page 15. of Iht:
puhlic records of Collier County, Florida.
-1-
EXHIBIT "A"
Agenda Item No. 88
r<ovelllber 27. 2007
P898 20 of 59
.J,8enC& Item I\!c: 83
1~ovt::mb8i-:=i 20:]-:'
17C '~I
2; c' 5S'
be and the sa....ne is hereby approved for a conditional use pursuant to Subsection 2.6.33.4.1.3 of the
Lund Development Code in the "E" Estates Zoning District for a model home in accordance with the
Conceptual Ma.'1ter Plan (Exhibit UBlt) and subject to the following conditions:
Exhibit "e" which is attached hercto and incorporated by reference herein.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Resolution br::. recorded in the minutes of this
Board.
This Resolution adopted after motion. second and majority vote,
Done thi, 8-ftJ" day of No lX.mbu' ,,2000.
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
BY:
JAMES
A '\JBST.;...
.,D'WT. CiiH'!;~;~OCK, Clerk
'/\~tiSt, 11',",' CllJt.... "
$'jg~~..onrt, '
'~~.:~D.C,
Arpro~l:da,s lo,:ForTIl and
" L~~~rSUf0,~)enc}':
7h~iiJ.!.-J~
Marj eM. Student
Assistant County Attorney
g:lndminlCU.ZOOO-12/ RP~~OIJmONIDM{im
-2-
/\aena2 Item [\jc, 8B
N~ovemDer 27, 2007
Page 22 of 59
17 C~I
FINDING OF FACT
BY
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
FOR
A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION
FOR
CU-2000-12
The following facts are found:
1.
Section ~i ,Iff" If.::: It ~.;'"r1; 'f., .,-of the Land Development Code
authorize 'the conditional use.
2. Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the
public interest and will not adversely affect other property
or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of:
A.
Consistency with
Management Plan:
Yes
the Land Development Code and Growth
/NO
B. Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures
thereon with particular reference to automotive and
pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and
control I and access in ~ase of fire or catastrophe:
Adequate ingr(~ egress
Yes No
c. Affects ighboring properties in relation to noise,
gla economic or odor effects:
No affect or Affect mitigated by
Affect cannot be mitigated
D. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other
property in the district:
Compatible use withi~district
Yes ~ No
Based on the above findings',~h' eo~ti3nal use should, with
stipulations, (copy attached~~oul~ be recommended for
approval -
DATE: //-..;'- tic)
EXHIBI
~,penQ2 ite~:\j:::' 8::
Nove:T:aB:- -'-,: 200"7
::'3;:18 2:"; ,...r ;::;c
17C ~1
FINDING OF FACT
BY
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
FOR
A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION
FOR
CU-2000-12
The following facts are found:
I. Section 2.7,4 of the Land Development Code
authorized the conditional use.
2. Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the
public interest and will not adversely affect other property
or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of:
A. Consistency with the Land Development Code and
Growth Management Plan:
Yes / NO
S. Ingress and egress to property and proposed
structures thereon with particular reference to
automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience,
traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or
catastrophe:
Adequate ingress & 7gress
Yes" No
C. Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise,
glarey economic or odor effects:
V No affect or Affect mitigated by
Affect cannot be mitigated
D. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other
property in the district:
Compatible use/Within district
Yes v' No
Based on the above findings, this conditional uBe(S~ with
stipulations, (copy attached) (",agula Hvl) be recommended for
approval IfIfR/JV,ft /J If) j j, J /
DATE: 11/2/00 MEMBER: ~/fuWd
I I
f/FINDING OF FACT ME~BE~/
f\,qena8 Item t'\c. 88
N-ovember 27. 2007
Page 24 of 59
17 C"'~
FINDING OF FACT
BY
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
FOR
A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION
FOR
CU-2000-12
The following facts are found:
1. Section of the Land Development Code
authorized the conditional use.
2. Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the
public interest and will not adversely affect other property
or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of:
A. Consistency with the Land Development Code and
Growth Management Pl~
Yes V No
B. Ingress and egress to property and proposed
structures thereon with particular reference to
automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience,
traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or
catastrophe: ~-
Adequate ingress & e ss
Yes No
C. Affects eighboring properties in relation to noise,
, economic or odor effects:
No affect or Affect mitigated by
Affect cannot be mitigated
D. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other
property in the distri
Compatible use thin district
Yes No
Based on the above findings, this
stipulations, (copy attached) (~L
approval ~
DATE: t.;5IT' &; ,:2"""
conditional
", at)
f/FINDING OF FACT MBMaERj
L-.C1BlldZ, ite....: 1\;0, E\5
r0C1vemoe:' ;:::-. 2DC-:-
1 7 cage, ce, ce' 5?
FINDING OF FACT
BY
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
FOR
A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION
FOR
CU-2000-12
The following facts are found:
1. Section ~ . (P.~ 3:, .~. S ; ::1.1., ~." S of the Land Development Code
authorized the conditional use.
2. Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the
public interest and will not adversely affect other property
or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of:
A. Consistency with the Land Development Code and
Growth Management Pl~:
Yes V No
B. Ingress and egress to property and proposed
structures thereon with particular reference to
automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience,
traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or
catastrophe:
Adequate ingress & eg;:ess
Yes \,./" No
C. Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise,
glare,~conomic or odor effects:
~ No affect or Affect mitigated by
Affect cannot be mitigated
D. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other
property in the district:
compatible use~thin district
Yes No __
Based on the above findings, ~~ditional
stipulatio~, (c\opy attachedY:(ShO~ not) be
approval J\~"-" .!. . t.::::::~ J
DATE: !/ -~-u.oD ~ MEMBER.
with
for
~
f/FINDING OF FACT MEMaER/
A8enda Item I'io. 88
r~'ovember 27. 2007
Page 26 of 59
17C
.~
FINDING OF FACT
BY
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
FOR
A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION
FOR
CU-2000-l2
The following facts are found:
1. Section of the Land Development Code
authorized the conditional use.
2. Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the
public interest and will not adversely affect other property
or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of:
A. Consistency with the Land Development Code and
Growth Management Plan:
Yes ,/ No
B. Ingress and egress to property and proposed
structures thereon with particular reference to
automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience,
traffic flow and control, and access in case of fi.re or
catastrophe:
Adequate ingress & egpess
Yes ........- No
C. Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise,
glare,~onomic or odor effects:
~No affect or Affect mitigated by
Affect cannot be mitigated
D. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other
property in the district:
Compatible use wi~in distri.ct
Yes ,~ No
Based on the above findings, ~;R r.onditional use should, with
stipulations, (copy attached) (shouldj.._t-) be recommended for
approval , ~
DATE: 11/'7-)00 MEMBER: ~/ /#~7-
, I
f/FINDING OF FACT MEMBER!
i..;"gsnc.:: lie:!' 1'\c, 8::;
hJC)V2IiiDS"' 27 20C,-:'
:->age 27 of 59
17C
FINDING OF FACT
BY
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
FOR
A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION
FOR
CU-2000-l2
The following facts are found:
1. Section of the Land Development Code
authorized the conditional use.
2. Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the
public interest and will not adversely affect 'other property
or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of:
A. Consistency with the Land Development Code and
Growth Management Plan:
Yes V No
B. Ingress and egress to property and proposed
structures thereon with particular reference to
automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience,
traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or
catastrophe:
Adequate ingress &~gress
Yes No
C. Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise,
glare, economic or odor effects:
.../ No affect or Affect mitigated by
Affect cannot be mitigated ---
D. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other
property in the district:
Compatible use ~ithin district
Yes Y No
Based on the above findings, Sditional use should, with
stipulations, (copy attached) (should not) be recommended for
:::::valll ' ?-, '}. ()V~ . MEMBER: '~1 ~~ I C( ..
7
r/FINDIUG OF FACT MEMBER/
Aaenaa Item 1\10. 8B
~~ovembe~ 27. 2007
Paae 28 O~- .....v
17C- -
FINDING OF FACT
BY
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
FOR
A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION
FOR
Ctr-2000-12
The following facts are found:
1. Section of the Land Development Code
authorized the conditional use.
2. Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the
public interest and will not adversely affect other property
or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of:
A. Consistency with the Land Development Code and
Growth Management Plan:
Yes No
B. Ingress and egress to property and proposed
structures thereon with particular reference to
automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience,
traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or
catastrophe:
Adequate ingress & egress
Yes v' No
C. Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise,
glare, economic or odor effects:
V No affect or Affect mitigated by
Affect cannot be mitigated
D. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other
property in the district:
Compatible use within district
Yes -..,/ No
Based on the above findings, this conditional
stipulations, (copy attached) (should not) be
approval
useC;ho~ld,)With
recomriierided for
, ......\
MEMBER: ~.~ '>-)X4~J t-~'P-~"f~
( , / 7/
j (I'
DATE: // /"Z~, ~,
f/FINDrNG OF PACT MBMBER!
.Q
..:,Q.~....~
'0'
~
'"
~ en
~
~
"
~
,
m
~
C)
C)
t:i
'"
'"
~
Q
<> UJ
"
<0 ::l
~
Z
UJ
>
<:
0,
u;
b
:l
en
J:. '"
"'
,1
'.'
-
~
.
If.'" ~
~~J'''''' 'ill;'
~o\~~~ 3
t--\,dJ
*.
,,'
[Q
1m
I
~'l-'~,""d
~,o. .<~..
'l"'..a. ..,.~q..V'-..
", "'tt.' \II'
. ",,,
1-"..... ",.
r~(l.oo,
CERTlflEO TO:
t.<-;:eil~c, :te~ i'\C.' 88
i'J':i\'ernoe:' =7. :OC)"i
-'3ge 29 01 59
7'
in Plill (look 7, PilQeS 15 and 15, of the
~nd rc~~rv~tions of record.
C.R.
951
P tMlD 511RVEY OF
TIle ~Ht tt,)lr (ql of lrilct l19, GOLDEN GrIn- EST^T[S UNIT No, 26. 45. recorded
. P"h~~ '''''''.Of ColllC!r County, F1ortd~. Sobject tn C!asmncnts, r{>s.trictinfJ~
... 100' R/W
-r-:- ~~
l~ . t~ t\.~
U"1-~~ - O""\~'
't-'\'~' --"v oJ';
C."" '11-:-'~~ 0. ==---- S'
~'r \t~~ -- 50"19'IO"W: .;,
30.00'
16.~' I
I
I
I
,
I
I
I
I
I
I--- 76."
I
~ I
~ I
:J: I
\ ~ I
.
~ ~ j
. c> I
: ~ I
~ I
'" ~ I
I
I
I
I
\'
~
I
I '!b"<<-
I t,0'
I rr:>'\'o';;~
.,9-... o.
.00' c"""
t
858
-m~l -
~ .:
I .,
'" l::S
Of
STATE
ROAD
I!V{;e' OF PVMf.
"--- 2" GONe. CORB
1l.IS,7b'lM)
L:;I20.00'(I::O
CONe, WAt.K
85000'{Rl
3'29.94'(C)
-.,
m
u;
.,;
~
~t\.V-
"VO'f'~.~,
~t;"~G~
I j 4.3'
HtE EASf r;~
OF TRACT p5
155,".
4f 4060 I~lh AVE, 5.
CONe.. FOllN04TlO~
l=INIS\.l€D FLOOR el.t:v. ..lOl,M:
\
119
"'
.;
'"
S 0019'lO"W
.33D.OO'{F!1 3'29.~4'{CJ
T~E wv. Of TRACT "g
'330' (Rl
Exhibit "BII
11.6.97 1197006 C06-- B~ BOUNOARI("'A&SUM. eL~ .=.~,.. I'UlIoIM)If alH7JlCK. I'CIM OrAAlNGS 8AS[O ON: PLAT
O"T[ OR[){R rCLO BOO RtvlSlON' AIt. .. ==' I'IEnIUJllX ELEVA'TIONS B.r.SEO Ol\~ ASSUMED DATUM
. MJc:.U IllOoI Wl# lOCAT(O l.'.l n.ooo ZONE: .X"
'.4 ~~/!~ PER F.I.R,~. [)AlEC); b.B.B6
..II.." ~~ C!FlTlflC-'TE
..rouHIl ~J 1~".AIft_""'__-.....tI;r
.2~1I ~ =--~~. ::r..:::~~~
..1ICUlItD _..M1fOf'll..,.u...f\oo:'lft......,
g : ;g~ ~ ~~""~-"y~ ~~~1:=
SURVEYS, INC, ':. ~_~tNT' --. I r_ -vi)' -." 10 =:.... '""...
: ~ ~' WDIOO =":--."'U ~ ~ ':"..":.t-:
..~~ ~ _~ 1.........'-...1_.
.... PtI'i]
TE:L (Ilin 9.]9-.]006.- IMl li-I'ft
FAX (9'0 V3i-1101 . 'ft- _CooI!:r'p~__~ __. Sec.l
00MN'
II
--
~
~
'"
10:,
3i
iii 1
oj
"
~'/..,l,... I
,0. ~I
tt~.
~
c
C>
g
"'
120
w
.
C>
'"
C
:'
01
cO
"'
,,,...v
,tlF1'~'
(.,9>"~~ {).'/.
..-
SCALE: '"'-40'
'"'"
ONLY
"""
........,
''''
7C
..~
.
~
-.
.
A,aenda Item No. 88
rJovemo8: 27.2007
Page 30 of 59
17C
~I
Conditions for Approval of Conditional Use CU.2000-12
(October 5, 20(0)
1. This conditional use approval shall expire five (5) years from its original date of
adoption. Should the property owner wish to continue the approved use beyond five
(5) years, the property owner shall reapply for another conditional use or comply with
applicable land development regulations at the time of expiration of this conditional
use.
2. The Planning Services Director may approve minor changes in the location, siting, or
height of buildings, structures, and improvements authorized by this conditional use.
Expansion of the uses identified and approved within this conditional use application,
or major changes to the site plan submitted as part of this application, shall require
the submittal of a new conditional use application, and shall comply with all
applicable County ordinances in effect at the time of submittal, including Division
3.3, Site Development Plan Review and approval, of the Collier County land
Development Code (Ordinance 91-102).
3. Pursuant to Section 2.2.25.8.1 of the Land Development Code, if, during the course
of site clearing, excavation, or other construction activity a historical or
archaeological artifact is found, all development within the minimum area necessary
to protect the discovery shall be immediately stopped and the Collier County Code
Enforcement Department contacted.
4. Landscape and inigation plans shall be submitted for approval by County planning
Services Staff, and shall be in accordance with applicable Land Development Code
regulations in effect at the time of approval of this conditional use.
Exhibit "e"
,;...;JEnoc. !i.'2T, i\lG. 33
h!Q\/e:TlDe: ;:::-; 200-
=-ag8 3 o~ 5~
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
ALL OF TRACT 119, GOLDEN GATE ESTATES, UNIT NO. 26, ACCORDING
TO THE PLAT THEREOF RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 7, PAGE 15, PUBLIC
RECORDS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA.
EXHIBIT R
7C
RESOLUTION NO..-ill: 50
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
PROVIDING POR THE ESTABLISHMENT OF CONDITIONAL USE
9 IN THE "E" EST A TES ZONING DISTRICT PURSUANT TO
SECTION 2,2.3,3 OF THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND
DEVELOPMENT CODE FOR PROPERTY I.OCATED IN SECTION
15. TOWNSHIP 49 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST, COLLrER COUNTY.
FLORIDA, CONTAINING 5 ACRES.
WHEREAS, the Legislature of the State of Florida in Chapter 67-1246, Laws of florida, and
Chapter 125, Florida St!ltutes, has conferred on Collier County the power to establish, coardinate and
enforce zoning and such business regulations as are necessary for the protectlon of the public; and
WHEREAS, the County pursuant thereto hus uuopted a Land Dt::vt:loprnent Code (Ordinance
No. 91-102) which includes a Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance establishing regula1ions for the zoning
of particular geographic divisions of the County, among which is the granting of Conditional Uses: and
WHEREAS, lhe Board 01 Znning Appeals (Board), being the duly appointt:d and constituted
board for the area hereby affected, has held a public hearing after notice as in ~aid regulations made and
provided, and has considered the advisability of Conditional Use 9 of Sect}nn 2.2.3.3 and 2.6.33.4 of the
Collier County Land Development Code in an "E" Estates Zone for a model borne and sales center on
the property hereinc.fter descrihed, and the Collier County Ptf'llming Commission has found as a maller
01 fact (Exhibit "A") that satisfactory provision and ::mangnmcnl have been made ooncerning all
applicable matters required by said regulations and in accord:,mce with Sub-section 2.7.4.4 of the Land
Deve1Dpment Code; and
WHEREAS, all interested parties have been given opportunity to be heard by this Board
in a public meeting assembled and the Board having considered all matters presented.
NOW. THEREFORE. BE IT RESOLVED BY the Board of Zoning Appeals 01 Collier
Cowlly. Florida, that:
The petition, CU-2003-AR-4799. filed by Edward B, Haot, ot American Dream
Builders, [ne, with respect to the property hereinafter described as:
All of Tract 119, Golden Gate Estates, Unit Nu. 26, according lo the plat thereof
recorded in ptat Book 1, Page 15, Public Records of CoUier County, Florida,
Page I 01 2
EXHIBIT "C"
Aaenda il8:r: !\lC ,~~S
1'-l~ovemb9; 27 2007
of 59
,..
7C
Is hereby approved for Conditional Use 9 of Section 2.2.3.3 ColHer Counly Land Development
Code in the "E" Estates Zoning District for a model home and sales center in accordance with
the Conceptual Master Plan (Exhibit "B") and subject to the tollowing conditions:
Exhibit "e" which is attached hereto and incorporated by reference herein,
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Resolution be recorded in the minutes of this
Board.
This Resolution adopted after motion, second and super~mlJjority vote,
Done this
day of
..2004.
I.\\ll'''''ll',,,,
""\:\('~' . <:.tl:'.... I' "'-"
ATTESTr...-.".....l:..,......:-; ~> '.
DWIGlf(i.~I<:.:..ct.1iRK
f 1 ( \\~'?.':'::,.~:5~) '1 !: i
Jehu!;' ;4'.'I""',~)~ J, r'. i
f ',-,.\.~,"1:.'.. ".' ~~,.~...-
DEPUTy.ct"""",,;;: \J' _-",
,:.~.'"U:l'\O,\\'
MoteIt . ..*_~C
t~""" .Ij,
App~ovcd as to Farm and
~~
Patrick Q, White
A~sisULnt County Attorney
CU-200J.-AR.4799/M[)lIo
'!L_
Paee 2 of 2
,9.1/o/o~
,.
I
i'. :l{I{?'i
Jruitv*
h;:::;\/'.::mD-2' T'-. 2007
::)2;J~ 3: of 59
:ler-, i\!::3::
~
/\genoa Item l\jo, 86
t\Jovembe:' 27, 2007
Page 34 of 59
FINDING OF FACf
BY
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
FOR
A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION
FOR
7C
.",""
CU-2003-AR-4799
The following facts are fOWld:
1. Section 2.2.2,3.3 of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use.
2. Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will
not adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood
because of:
A. Consistency with the Land DeveJopment Code and Growth Management Plan:
Yes v"" No
B, Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with particular
reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and
control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe:
Adequate ingress & egress ,;'
Yes_ No
C. Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic Or odor
effects:
~o affect or _ Affect mitigated by
__ Affect cannot be mitigated
D. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district:
Compatible use within district
Yes V' No
Based on the above findings, this conditional use should, with stipul~ (copy attached)
(should not) be recommended for approval I 1"fk' 'ff '
rJ~1~f:'1'!! f}w,ftJ A (jJJ
DATE:
J /;,'\104-
I I
II ;1
~ X;IrBI'I A
ZJ.NrHI3U ,DIIIN
t:OILlOI ::;U.VQ
I 100"0.001:# ~:)3.rOlld
66Lt-lIV-.OOZ-[l:)
I
l'
11
..
"
,
~~~'
~ ~: -f;
- ~
=- Q
gL9
- '
ii~~
b!..e~
~ It"
;M
r;
d~'
bt!_! ":i\
;;If ;~'1 \
I ill
~
Fi
!
'"
~g
~ ! :~..
v ~"
~ !;i-
" Z 0:
I-< & ~
I-< ~ Q..::t
o ?3. Vllo<
:z. ta ~ b:
~~
~~
<
~%
~~
~"
~"
~.
~
~
.
,
~
~
~
:
I
'I
i i
~ '
,. I
S .
" I
:< ~ <(
~~ >
oH
.'"'-, .. ~: i
'b )1 ful'
\.-/'.l;.w \.oj !
..+j
l: ~
,(
,....'''''...".,.",,,
I,g" J-Iglf/X:;?
~
u
"'
---J (S; ~
~
"
z
.-._~._--._-----_._"-_._._._."
.
I
,I I'
ti. \
(t-
"
.
IF
1~
i'li
t)"
, ~.
......,
fHM18'6i!C '/'I..lf;.8/.00''j
,I
"
i
.
~-1!---
i t..
rN).O(}VCC '3.Cf,t;C!.G{FN
(riMO'OCE: '3.01.61.00'1'1
'"
=0
Co
u
..
""
Co
~
,
~
.~
"
~
g
CIl Q .,.
., 10 :'.:l
- II _ I
c.g~~ 08
"';;~ e tr
Tl :f. U
!:;
~
~
~
!:: ;
'- ,
..~ ~
"'~ ~
~
liis ~
~~ ~
- . ~
~~ ~
E~ ~
zll
M
;0-
w
~
'" .. ~
:::>
'" ,
;
"..
'"
.. ~
Q
;<; "
:::> "
:::> ~
'" "
3
~
z
<
::~
z
.
u
E
,
.
!~
~~
~
~
~
![
.
~,
~ =0
18 C\I
.~ ~
'1<' t-<
~ :;j
~ ~
~
~
.
~l
;,
rl! !
,[ 'j'
iP. ~ \! .
'. :s i! ~ ~ ~ I
',I e", 'I
". i'I,' ',' ,
'I' "I!!
kl'~! 'Ii "I~ '.:
.. ~ '. r " '
";\"1 I ~!!,!~t
jiqi!l: Ili~iiii6
li~i;'!!I:I!iil~'
.!2'1hh!~I.I;ij~l
~ ~.... ..... ...... ~
~
M
ID
~
0,
II
!i! "i
:5~ f,
:'n ~
~ ~ t~~ ~
; 'III! "\11. 'Ill ~li '"
! I I ~!!li~M~ ~;! ~
\m;U hh~!;l!'I!i '" ~
...... . . ". .... h~
:![l!llll!;~~m ~...
I ! lj.
-I. t:let
li ,; Ii i. . 5. ~
Ii! IlIil! 'I 'il'I"
'0:;",", liU 1 I"i :.,-
i~~~iim!!*!!'l!~ ~~~~
,,,,ltMl!,,,,,,..1 ! '-' "n~
';".
L\oena8 Ilem j\jo. 88
r-JoveiTlDe;- 27. 2007
Page 36 of 59
"'.llG ~.
Conditions for Approval of Conditional Use CU-2003-AR.47~9
(January 15, 2004)
I, This conditional use approval shall expire one (I) years from its original
expiration date ofCU-200Q-12 (November 25,2005), Should the property owner
wish to continue the approved use beyond the one (]) year extension, the property
owner shall reapply for another conditional use or comply with applicable land
development regulations at the time of expiration of this conditional use,
2. The Zoning and Land Development Director may approve minor changes in the
location, siting, or height of buildings, structures, and improvements authorized
by this conditional Use. Expansion of the uses identified and approved within this
conditional use application, or major changes to the site plan submitted as part of
this application, shall require the submittal of a new conditional use application,
and shall comply with all applicable County ordinances in effect at the time of
submittal, including Division 3.3, Site Development Plan Review and Approval,
of the Collier County Land Development Code (Ordinance 9] -j 02)
3. Pursuant to Section 2,2,25.8.1 of the Land Development Code, if during the
Course of site clearing, excavation, or other construction activities a historical or
archaeological artifact is fotmd, all development within the minimum area
necessary to protect the discovery shall be immediately stopped and the Collier
County Code Enforcement Department contacted,
4. Pursuant to Section 2.6.33,4,1.2 of the Land Development Code, the model home
or model sales center is not intended to allow the full scope of real estate activities
and shall be restricted primarily to the sale and marketing of the model, or
products similar to the mode}, A model home shall not include offices for
builders, contractors, developers, Or similar activities,
5. A sidewalk shall be design and constructed, to the County's "Local Road"
standards, along the entire frontage of this property on 13th Avenue S.W. within
six months from the approval date of this request.
Exhibit "e"
kpenc;a item l\Jc, 88
\'D"'9mos:^ :7.20(;7
='2gS 37 ::{ 58
RESOLUTION 20116-~
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF ZONING
APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA,
RELATING TO PETITION NUMBER CUE-2006.AR-9424,
GRANTING A ONE-YEAR EXTENSION OF AN
API'ROVED CONDITIONAL USE FOR A MOIlEL
HOME AND SALES CENTER LOCATED AT 4050 l3"1!
A VENUE SOUTHWEST, LOCATED WITHIN ESTATE
DISTRICT "E."
WHEREAS, the Legi~dalure of the Stale of Florida in ChapteT 125, Florida Statules, has
conferred on all counties in Florida the power to establish, coordinate and enforce zoning and
~llch busille~s regulations as are necessary for tbe protection of the public; and
'NHEREAS, the County pursll<lnt thereto adopted a Lund Development Code (LDC)
(Ordinance No. 2004-41, as amend~d), which establishes zoning regulations for the particuhlf
geographic divisions of the County, ilmong ~hidl is the granting of a condilional use llno the
extendillf, of the time period of an approved conditionnl use: and
\VHEREAS, on Fcbru.ury 10, 2004, the Board of ZOlling Appeal-" of Collier County,
Florida, enacted Resolution No. 2()04~50, nttached hereto as Exhibit "A", granting American
Dream 13uilocr:s, Int:. (the "Pelillom:r"), a cOllditionul use for <l. model home and sale.~ center on
property Jocated within Estate District "E", mom particularly described below; and
WIlEREAS, Subsection IO.OR.E.3. of the LDC provides that "The board or zoning
appeals may grant a maximum of olle onc~ycar extension or an approved conditional use upon
wri(t~n request or the petitioner;" and
WI IEREA5 , the Petitioner has submitted a writtcn request to extend the conditional use
approved hy Rcsolution No, 2004-50.
NOW. THEREFORE. BE IT RESOL \lED BY THE BOARD or ZONING APPEALS
OF COLLIER COUNTY.I.LORIDA. that:
1. The wriuen request for one om~-year extension of the condition.'ll lIse for a
model bome and silleS center al 4050 13th Avcnu~ Southwest, located wilhLIl the Esmte::.:
District HE" and more particularly de~cribed as:
All of Tract 119, Golden Gate Estates, Unit 26, according to the plat thereof
recorded in Plat Book 7, Page 15 of the Public Records of Collier County,
Florida,
is approved pursuant 10 Suhsection IU.OS.E.3. of the LDC, and the expiration date for
ResolutIon No. 2004.50, and all conditions applicable tbereto, is thereby extendcci until
Pebruury 10,2007. with the following ~dditional conditions:
a. Petitioner shall provirlen evidence of all ADA (Americalls with Di-"ahilities Act)
accessible route from the cxi~ling or any future handicap parking space(s) to the model
home ann sales center and to th~ acce.s:; rondo
b. Petitioner acknowledges the probability that <lddilional right-of-way mny be
required on the subject property.
Page 1 of2
ExnillIT "D"
Aaenda IIerr. No. 8B
l~ovemDe" 27 2007
Page 38 of 59
c. A Vegetation Rem~'lVat Permit is required for <lilY land cle<lring beyond the one
acre pennitt~d through the ~xii:itillg buikling permit.
d. The property shall be kept free of prohibited exotic vegetation, as defined by the
Collier County Land Development Code.
2_ Resolution shall be recorded in the minute;; of this Board and in the record!> or the
Petition for which this extension is granted.
I'
This Resolution adopted after motion, second, and supel'~majority vote, this ~ d~y
of .\ "'\,; . 2006.
,
A TIEST,
DWIGHT EBRDCK, CLERK
~1hOk~~
At'..,t ....'0 'Ch~ Il"UlOfPuty Clerk
~i');';,\'';',_T''t "::'~1!"
BOARD OF ZONING APPPEALS OF
COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA
?~~
By: ~ -' .r
FRANK HALAS. C lA' AN
A
tin
Jeffre
Assis
Fage2of2
i\genGC: ii:27T1 1\;[ 38
HcwernD2T:=-; 2007
3'" 0: Sf)
RESOLUTlON NO. 06-_~06
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD or ZONING APPEALS TO
CORRECT DATE OF FEBRUARY 10.2007 FOR CUE-2006-AR-
9424. AMEIUCAN DREAM BUILDERS, INC,'S MODEL HOME
AND MODEL HOME SALES CENTER'S CONDITIONAL USE
EXTENSION, TIlE CORRECT DATE HAS nEEN CHANGED TO
NOVEMBER 2B. 2007, FOR THE SUBJECT PROPERTY
LOCATED AT 4050 13TH AVENIlE SOUTII WEST, AT TIffi
CORNER OF 13TH AVE SW AND COLLIER BLVD (CR 951), IN
SECTION IS. TOWNSHIP 49 SOUTH. RANGE 26 EAST,
COLLIER COUNTY. FLOIUDA, AND BY PROVIDING FOR AN
EFFECTIVE DATE
WHEREAS, the Collier County Collier County Board of Zoning Appeals adopted
Resolution No. 200u-188, on July 25, 2006, ami;
WHEREAS, following said actiun adopting H.esolution "Nn. 2006-1&8, staff determined
the datc or February 10,2007 for CUE-2006-AR~9424, American Dream Builders, Inc.'s Model
flomc and Model Home Salcs Center's COllditiotul.1 Use Extensioll, attached to the Resolution did
nnt contain the correct datc for the expimtioll of the conditional use for the model home and sales
center at 4050 13111 Avellue South Wc~t, therefore constitutes a scrivener'!) error.
NOW. TIIEIUOFORE. fJE IT ORDAINED BY THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
OF COLLIER COUNTY. FLORmA. ti,,(
SECTION ONE: SCRIVENER'S ERROR AMENDMENT TO THE EXPIRATION DATE
The expiration date us related to Resolution Number 200u~ 188, i!, hereby amended to
correct il scrivener's crror hy amending said section tll read as follows:
~roa~,.--;w{):;;, No'(c.mfll~r 2& 2007
SECTION TWO: EFFECTIVE DATE
fiE IT RESOLVED dlllt this Resolution relating to Petition Number SE-2006-AR-I0442 be
recorded in the minutes of this Hoard.
This Resolution adof,tcd after motion, second and majorlty vote.
Done this d ~~/...! day of ^(~'H,,'d)(\ ' _,2006.
A nEST: __
DWIGHT E. BROG:. CLERK
GOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLOIUDA
2'~"
~'" . ^
. c' lu:~ UU.<&, h::
~t 4. to GillAfUTY CLERK
11\If\1t..... 00'. "'n 1
proved <1S to form and
al. Jei-Iley:
BY,-~<- .~
FRANK HALAS. CHAI AN
SE-2006.^R.l(l442JMnl~p
Page 1 of I
EXIDBIT "E"
Agenaa !tem l'Jo. 86
November 27. 2007
Page 40 of 59
BV
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
FOR
A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION
FOR
CU-2007-AR-11970
The following facts are found:
1. Section <text> of the Land Development Code authorizes the conditional use,
2. Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will not
adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because
of:
A. Consistency with the Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan:
Yes No
B, Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with palticular
reference to automotive and pedestrian safcty and convenience, traffic flow and
control, and acccss in case of fire or catastrophe:
Adequate ingress & egress
Yes No
C. Affects ncighboring properties in relation to nOIse, glare, economIc or odor
effects:
No affect or Affect mitigated by <text>
- -
_ Affect cannot be mitigated
D. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other propcrty in the district:
Compatible usc within district
Yes No
Based on the above findings, this conditional use should, with stipulations, (copy
attached) (should not) be recommended for approval <text>.
DATE:
CHAIRMAN:
EXHilllT "F"
iTeiTi I\!CJ, fj3
:>,JDV-=::T,D8:- 2~' 2007
~'aJ2 2 'i Q; 5~;
FINDING OF :FACT
BY
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
FOR
A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION
FOR
The following facts are found:
1. Section <text> of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use.
2, Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will
A. Consistency with the Land Development Code and Growth Management
Plan:
Yes No
B, Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with
particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safcty and convenience,
traffic flow and control, and aeccss in case of fire or catastrophe:
Adequate ingress & egress
Y cs No
C. Affects neighboring propcrtics in relation to noise, glare, economic or
odor effects:
No aJTect or _ Affect mitigated by <lext>
_ Affect cannot be mitigated
D. Compatibility with adjaecnt propcltics and other property in the district:
Compatible use within district
Yes No
Bascd on the above findings, this conditional use should, with stipulations, (copy
attachcd) (should not) bc rccommcnded for approval <text>,
DATE:
MEMBER:
~
BOUNDARY SURVEY
p,qenda Item l\Jc. 88
Novernu8t 7. 2007
Page 42 of 59
100' ~IGHI or WA'1'
COLLIER BOULEVARD (platted CR. 951)
FOUND
5/e ROO
NO CAP
BE.NT
FOUNO
PERM~ -qr-
REFERENCE 1
MONUMENT I
..
.g
.1 mfff
Im~ e .
I
I
eel I
e '"'\'i)e e",~\'i)
SL::- ()) L'l' 1B\'i) t
"""'~: ~
~'~A~ftl.~"""'~
"I
';;1
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
1300.0'(M) ClMirrnU
NOO'19'10"E 330.0'(P&C)
ClJ-2007-AR-11970
l'roject: 2003040011
Dulc: 7/6/07 DUE: 8W07
w"'
""'Q",",SOO'19'10"W 330.0 P&M
,
.0
.e (9 ~
.
.,
.
"
"'e.l Tl e
. ~I
.0 (jj
OJ
-~---
~
vi ~ u
~
"<l ~ ':i
~ :., !'o
TRAcr liB ~ 0
"<l " 0
co
0- ii <0
"'t:o <0
~
~
0')
-
i
I
I
I
If"
10
I~
I~
1<0
I'"
ENLARGED DETAIL :
Ot-JE STORY RESI[}ENCE I
I
I
____L
LEGENDI ABBREY1A llONS
o Sl;{"Wl>/pm It"/CAf' "OlJ
r., mo. If"'!/' AIfO {III 1~11
il mn_ ~r, liON
o ""ID, I!fOtl P~I
f> OCl/eN f.I"'R~'
'\h"()II(RPOl.[
@ MH
C ~ CAlCUL~IE(J
V.. AlfA5UP,fD
P - PiU, p. (J["(D
( . COJrF"R!WC
D(. DRAIHACr: (ASO,lC/iT
V[ ~ IHllln' EASCWfIIl
Ale ~ NR COI/DHlONfO
IW _ It'A ~II Jlnrl1
Ce-CATCtllM51N
UN ~ UM;J/OU'
I>r.p!X>lCQuIf'V[/1f
COHC_CONmcrr
IJIS . Ulluncs
rw _ fOf' if II~I/K
e rJ1lIT
.. - SPffm,,~.-? H~"'O
_5f!Jl/P
_ .'iHl/!N1
r,
=,
March 9, 2006
Oole of Survey,
;
~
"
.
f(
"
TRACT 119
~
"
,
.
.'fJ.o'
'FOUND
15/8 ROD
NO CAP
TRACT 10J
7/115 SlJRVCY IS PROPARffJ rOR:
AMERICAN DREAM BUILDERS. INe.
LeCAL DeSCRIPTION
ALL of TRACT 119, GDLDfN CMf
ESTA TES, UNIT NO. 26 recorded
in Plat Book 4, poge 75 of the Public
Records of Corlier County, Florida.
ADDRCSS OF PROPCRTY:
4050 13th A V[NU~. s. It
N07'E:S:
FLOOD ZONE 'X" - PANEL lZ0067 047..5 C.
B(ARII>,'CS BASED ON PHYSICAL CENITRuN[ OF
13lh AVENUE S.W. AS BEING N89'40'SO'W.
"-
rOUNO- - - -
5/8 ROD
NO CAP
::;
~
!'o
o
o
'"
<D
TRACT 120
9
"
,
o
~
o
"'
o
".
m
<Xl
Z
FOUND
5!e ROD
NO CAP
REV: 1
~
f-<
......
:s
:tI
X
""
F{JenOc~ irem i~c 85
f-JovemDer 27 2007
;:'aOE' .:; '::', Q'c Sf;
GGAMP Amendments to Conditional Use "e"
Petition # CPSP-2003-l0
Adopted by BCC on October 10, 2004
,Lt.aenda Iten! I'~G. 88
tJovernber 27. 2007
Page 44 of 59
a, There shall be no adverse impacts to the native veqetation beino retained. The
additional water directed tn this area shall not increase the annual hydro-period
unless it is proven that such would have no adverse impact to the existi no
veaetation.
b. If the proiect requires permittino bv the South Florida Water Manaqement District.
the project shall provide a letter or official document from the District indlcatinq
that the native veqetation within the retention area will not have to be removed to
complv with water manaqement requirements, If the District cannot or will not
supolv such a letter. then the native veqetation retention area shall not be used
for water manaoement purposes.
c. If the proiect is reviewed bv Collier Countv, the County enoineer shall provide
evidence that no removal of native veoetation is necessary to facilitate the
necessary storaqe of water in the water manaoement area,
. Projects within the Neighborhood Center Dcoignotion Subdistrict that are submitted
as PUDs s~all provide a functional public open-space component. Such public
open-space shall be developed as green space within a pedestrian-accessible
courtyard, as per Section 2.4.5.4 of the Collier County Land Deveiopment Code, as
in effect at the time of P.U.D. approval.
. The following principal pennitted uses are prohibited within Neighborhood Centers:
Drinking Places (5813) and Liquor Stores (5921)
Mail Order Houses (5961)
Merchandizing Machine Operators (5962)
Power Laundries (7211)
Crematories (7261) (Does not include non-crematory Funeral Parlors)
Radio, TV Representatives (7313) and Direct Mail Advertising Services (7331)
NEC Recreational Shooting Ranges, Watersiides, etc. (7999)
General Hospitals (8062), Psychiatric Hospitals (8063), and Specialty Hospitals
(8069)
Elementary and Secondary Schools (8211), Colleges (8221). Junior Colleges (8222)
Libraries (8231)
Correctional Institutions (9223)
Waste Management (9511)
Homeless Shelters and Soup Kitchens.
4) Commercial Western Estates Inflll Subdistrict
[revised text, page 31]
a) Size and Location:
. The Subdistrict includes a 6.23-acre parcel, iocated at the southwest corner
of Vanderbilt Beach Road and Collier Boulevard (see Map.:Uj; 1m. The parcel
is identified as Tracl105, Unit 2, Golden Gate Estates.
6)
Conditional Uses Subdistrict, Part b
[revised text, page 31.1]
b) Golden Gate Parkway and Collier Boulevard Special Provisions:
COnEliliclI'lal uses shall enly be perFflittee 9n Caleen GatD Parlw>ay, (JaGt of Livingston Raaa ana
waGt sf Santa Elarbora ea~le\fQrd, ang an tne '.\'ost side of Collier e9\llo\lard, nerth of Groan
Boulevard ana sabll~ af Vaneer~oa8A Road Extension, if the swJ;,jeGt paroel is eirectly
bablAdee by mdsliAg eonditional usos on t....o (2) or more ~ide y:::m;ls, wtth no intervening rights
of way sr watefV\'ays, o:cooFlt fer tho fs'lowin,,:
Words struelc through are deletions; words underlined are additions
23
, ,",
'::':',09nc~,~, i~8TT: i\JC 88
i~~o'J'?mb8'- 27 2007
'-'2g0 of 5f!
Conditional uses (except essential services. as described in Paraqraoh a). above) shall not be
permilt~d on those parcels immediatelv adiacent to the west side of Collier Boulevard within the
Estates DesiGnated Area unless the parcel is directlv bounded bv conditionai uses on two (2) or
more side yards with no interveninq riGhts-of-wav or waterways'
RecoGnizinG the existinG residential nature of the land uses surroundinG the planned 1-75
interchanGe at Golden Gate Parkway, there shall be no further conditional uses for properties
abuttinq Golden Gate Parkwav between Livinaston Road and Santa Barbara Boulevard.
Further. no properties abuttinq streets accessinq Golden Gate Parkway within the above-
defined seament shall be approved for conditional Uses. This provision shall not be construed
to affect the area described in Paraqraph 1, below, nor shall it preclude essential services. as
described in Paraaraph a) . above.
1. EsecmtlOJI ser\'icos, a~ pro>o'iEled in Paragraph OJ), a.bo~
I
1;<. In consideration of the improvements sssociated with the proposed interchange at
Interstate 75 and Golden Gate Parkway. the existing conditional use (church and related
facilities) located at the southeast corner of Golden Gate Parkway and 66'" Street. S.W.
maybe expanded in acreage and intensity along the south side of Golden Gate
Parkway botwoen to the east of 66th Street S,w. a.ne 61" Streot S.'/'I., but the total
project area shall not exceed 8.2124 acres (see Map 12). AffiMion:1l1y, lho pareol
l'ropoc:::cllor oxpa.ncian shall-I'm; bo subjo:::; to tho roquiromont thot it bo directly
bounded on ot b:ltl two cide yarcls i:>y-BefKlilionol ueos.
23. The parcel located immediately south of the Commercial Western Estates Infill
Subdistrict, on the west side of Collier Bouievard, and at the southwest quadrant
of the intersection of Vanderbilt Beach Road and Collier Boulevard. shall be
eligible for a transitional conditional use designation,
~~~~illl,ltiW'EPtron"""o~rnOnalm5e;'e-o~a!iODal2c.r.iWT,ia{w.
~~ ------.:it _ ~ . _ ~__"'--="'~...
revised text, page 31.3]
Temporary use (TU) permits for model homes. ora not subjeotlo tho lecation::!l criloria for
OOflditional uses as defined In the Collier County Land Development Code and may be allowed
anywhere within the Estates-Mixed Use District. Conditional use permits submitted for the
purpose of extendinq the time period for use of the structure as a model home shall not be
subject to the locational criteria of the Conditional Uses Subdistrict. and may be allowed
anyWhere within the Estates-Mixed Use District. Temporary use permits for model homes shall
hsve a duration of three (3) vsars from the date of approval. No subsequent issuance of a
conditional use penmit shall be for a duration exceedinG two (2) vears. The total time oeriod for
temporary use and conditional use pell]1its toqether shall not exceed five (5) vears.
3. AGRICLJL TURAURLJRAL DESIGNATION - RURAL SETTLEMENT AREA DISTRICT
rrevised title, page 34]
Rural Settlement Area District
CPSP.2003-10 AxhlbttA - Bce
G, Comprehensive, 03 Bce Exhibit A's
Qw!10.12.1J4
Words struek threugh are deletions; words underlined are additions
24
Agend2 Item I'k. 88
I\!ovember 2"7. 2007
Page 46 0' 5S}
CPSP-2003-10
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSION
OCTOBER 26, 2004 MINUTES
GGAMP AMENDMENTS TO
CONDITIONAL USE "e"
P,;:l~:nC12. 1leiT: No. ,38
h!~iVsiT;b8r' 27 2C!Ci7
F-'aa~' .:; c or 59
October 2'6, 2004
general reco1llinendation that staff revise the -- make revisions to the
-- some of the language for c1arity purposes provided that those --
those changes were not -- didn't affect any substantive changes.
Other than that, there was one change that the plamling
commission included in their recommendations that was a, sOli of a
last-minute item that was discovered by staff, and it deals with the
twentieth bullet under the -- it's shown on page 5 of the executive
sunmlary at the bottom of the page.
Deals with the tlventieth bullet under the neighborhood center's
subdistrict, and it's simply a clarification that when the bullet mentions
residcntial propeliy, we then define residential prope1iy as prope1iy
zoned E estates and without an approved conditional use.
We were afraid that from a literal translation of residential
zoning, there is no residential zoning tcclmically in the estates. It's all
estates zoning. But we knew that the intent of this was to deal with
estates zoning, so we've made that clarification.
The Collier County Planning Commission did not wish to hear --
or did not wish to consider changes that were proposed by the Golden
Gate Commercial Overlay Ad Hoc Committee regarding the
downtown center commercial subdistrict or the Collier Boulevard
commercial subdistrict.
We also, however, have contained the community's
reconmlendations in the staff report, which is n which is also in your
packet.
There were, however, five substantive changes, that upon
reflection -- now, after the plmming commission meeting, staff is
reconnnending to you -- and these begin on page 6 of the executive
sunmlary about the middle of the page.
And I can go through tllem or we can -- I can simply try to
smllinarize them for you. The first one has to do with the Collier
Boulevard commercial subdistrict. The -- basically the original
subdistrict language allowed two stories. Staff realized that in
Page 173
,Li,genoa iIen< [\!C. 88
I\!ovembe;" 2.7, 2007
Octobet2~, '700'4
allow residential as a use in a mixed use building.
So we didn't want to say there absolutely can't be residential. We
believe that in celiain circumstances there could be residential, and we
even believe that there could be residential -- residential alone
buildings provided that certain qualifications are met.
The next change is -- has to do with -- again, with continual uses
in the C-l, C-2, and C-3 zoning districts. It wasn't clear whether the
existing -- the transmitting language would allow conditional uses
within the entire subdistrict under -- it wasn't clear whether the condi
-- the language that was transmitted would allow conditional uses as
allowed by the existing residential zone, and we believe from staff that
it was the intent of the restudy committee to allow those, so we've
made that change.
And next has to do with the transmitted text, prohibited uses are
those uses not permitted by right or by conditional use. Again, in the
C-l, C-2, and C-3 zoning districts, and then there was an additional
list of uses that were prohibited.
To clarify, most ofthe uses that are prohibited are alTeady not
allowed in the C-l tlTIough C-3 zoning districts, sO.we've simply
eliminated some of that language. And we've -- we have eliminated
the language when it refers to uses that already are not allowed by
right in the C-l through C-3 zoning overlay. So we've just simply
clarified that we're not changing the list of uses in C-1 through C-3.
And those are the only changes that are proposed by staff, and'
the only change that was proposed by the p1mmil1g conunission was to
go through and make sure everything was clear and accurate.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: It says here also that the CCPC
specifically did not wish to consider the changes proposed by the
Golden Gate Commercial Overlay Ad Hoc Committee to the
downtown center conunercial subdistrict. I didn't know what that
really meant.
COMMISSIONER HENNING: Russell Tuff can explain it.
Page 175
ile~-; 1\1:::_ 8D
f'\"JvernD8;- ':_J. 2007
Octobet~u, '713tf~
neighborhood of single-family residences.
In any case, those areas identified consist of older homes, most of
them over 35 years old. Most of the properties are rentals -- they're not
owner-occupied -- and also some apmiments. A11d they've
experienced skyrocketing water rates and insurm1ce rates to the point
where your average home's costing a couple thousand -- you're talking
about a $70,000 home.
If it was 1 cveled to the ground, it would cost the insurance
company $70,000 to replace it, and it's costing over $2,000 a year to
insure these residences.
Additionally, the water company is charging an average of $125
a r11onth. Those two items alone, over $300 a month. It's no longer--
no longer affordable, and what's happened is it's created a tendency for
owners to rent them out as boarding houses or to double up families in
them, and, you know, renting out to multiple families.
So single-family residences, therefore, are in namc only. And
what we have is an overcrowded condition with more crime and code
violations and overtaxed public services, such as code enforcement,
schools, roads, trash collection, and hospitals.
By -- now remember that these same people, you know, both
residents and property owners in a series of public meetings,
overwhelmingly suppOlied the change to create a downtown
subdistrict.
It addresses needs in a blighted segment of the community, we
create local jobs, we create local shops and services and we reduce
traffic countywide by reducing the need to drive 10 miles for services
available locally. So this -- this looks like a win-win situation for
everybody.
I feel like I'm just missing 011e detail here. Let me just take a
look at these notes real quick, make sure I got the whole of it. Okay,
yeah.
The overall vision, all right, which, you know, you heard it in
Page 177
Acenoa 11em I'.k. 83
t~ovemDer 2'. 2007
Octobel2'6,"26'O~4
meetings with the cOlmnunity that involved direct contact with
property owners as well as the neighboring propeliy owners that are
affected in this process.
As Peter mentioned, buffers were an extreme issue when we've
had the community meetings, that it's important to them how those
projects are potentially buffered.
The Parkway has predominantly single-family, duplex, tri-plex
activity. The 40th Terrace, Collier Boulevard areas, we're attempting
to look at that because of the design coming down with the six-laning
of Collier Boulevard and the redevelopment of that whole area, that in
some cases, parcels may need to be put together to redevelop in a
better cOlmnunity acceptable fashion.
So we've reached out to the community about as intense, I think,
as any conmlUnity has ever done out there to get input. I want to share
with you that one of the things we did get from the community was
that govel11ment was going to do what it wanted to do.
And as a committee, we tried to share with the community we
were not forcing anybody out in this project. We wanted to include
people in the project. Potentially there's developers out there that
could come in, give them the value that they're looking for today, and
still make a good conununity project out there.
As I said, no one -- no one is forced out. And with the glitch with
the planning commission, if there's some additional action, we would
ask to -- you do whatever we need to do to continue in our public
fashion and carry on as a conunittee.
It's unfortunate what occurred there, but we are trying to do that
in a very public fashion and include everybody and do redevelopment
that everybody that's okay with. Tharuc you.
MS. FILSON: Your final speaker is Russell Tuff.
MR. TUFF: Good aftcmoon, Connnissioners, and thanks for the
opportll1lity to be here. And, yes, I spent three years with the Golden
Gate master plan, and so with Don, and it was with the estates also we
Page 179
'w';JenG2 item I\J:., BE
1'J:Jvernbe: 27. 20[;7
:;:,...,..,;C< ::," ,-.,!:::;o
October 2"6; 2ob;r
recommended or what our -- the master plan? And I also wanted that
other border.
MR. HEATH: There was a staff adjustment to the borders at
transmittal. It was -- what you transmitted was a smaller area, if you
will, than what the overlay committee is recommending.
MR. TUFF: So I would like to make sure that we keep that as it
was. Because as Peter said, when you drive by and you look during
the day, it looks like a nice little neighborhood, and the people that
live next to it say, well, maybe we could have some changes there.
And so I would like to strongly reconunend that that gets kept.
The other question I had, GleIm, when we were meeting is on the
parking on the C, it said -- was that saying that there is no residential
or was it exclusively? I know we were okay with the mixed use
residential in the downtown conm1ercial area, but we weren't okay
with having exclusively residential with the property.
MR. HEATH: Looking at the way that the language is
constructed as it was transmitted and as we received it, it doesn't
appear that it actually does exclude residential.
It would require the residential to meet specific requirements that
are different from the residential that's in existence now. So it would
not be the same units. It would be different units, and they'd have to
be kind of melded into the overall mixed use subdistrict.
MR. TUFF: And so since that's not clear, I would like to see us
scratch that C, because I think there's a little difference of what we set
up at our last meeting and what ended up on that piece of paper. And
I guess I got -- any other questions on that?
CHAIRMAN FIALA: No, but it sounds exciting.
MR. TUFF: Yeah. It was really neat.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Yeah, it sure does.
Commissioner Helming?
COMMISSIONER HENNING: Don't go away. So what we're
going back into is a two-block instead of one-block on the parkway --
Page 181
Agenda Item 1\10, 88
hJDvemoe' 27. 2007
Octobet2!Q '1etY4'
,
COMMISSIONER HENNING: Okay. Is it time to address that
now or at the land development code?
MR. HEATH: In the sense that the plan amendment creates an
overall set of conditions, you are basically providing guidance towards
the -- any future rezonulg effort, so I think that it would be appropriate
-- if you wish to add some conditions or makes some changes to
conditions, it would be appropriate to do it now.
COMMISSIONER HENNING: Okay. Can we say no big
boxes?
MR. HEATH: Well, then we need to define what a big box is.
MR. TUFF: And not to get confused with the 951 area either.
COMMISSIONER HENNING: Right, exactly.
MR. TUFF: There were lots more intensity --
COMMISSIONER HENNING: This is just a subdistrict.
MR. TUFF: Downtown areas. And then also they cut that
border back on Collier Boulevard, and I'd hate to see that get cut back
too. So those are the two concems I had. That C that he'd mentioned,
what you said on the big box for that area, I believe we could still take
care of that.
COMMISSIONER HENNING: Then don't go away.
MR. TUFF: Don't go away, okay.
MR. HEATH: It was just suggested to me by some of my fellow
staff members that the way around this would be to put some sOli of a
square footage limitation for individual uses within the overlay.
COMMISSIONER HENNING: Okay. Well, we have some
LDC amendments that our architectural people -- architectural review
people are considering what is a big box and what is not. I don't lmow
if you1ve seen some of those --
MR. HEATH: I have not seen those. I've heard that they were
looking at it. I had not seen those specifically. I would have to defer
to Mr. Weeks as to whether those could be inselied into this process.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: How big is a Walgreen's? FOUlieen, five?
Page 183
lIe:.: I';::, 53
:27 2007
October '16~ WDlf
MR. TUFF: Thank you.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Okay.
COMMISSIONER HENNING: -- Madam Chair wishes to.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: I wish to close the public bearing at this
time.
COMMISSIONER HENNING: Make a motion to approve and
putting the boundaries back the way the stakeholder committee
recommends.
COMMISSIONER COLETTA: Second.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Okay. Did you want to address that part
about the distance from the street or is that already taken care of?
COMMISSIONER HENNING: No. That's really what we want,
Gleml. I believe it's putting the buildings towards the streets, and give
you that same thing as 5th Avenue, where you're going to have wide
sidewalks, and --
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Pedestrian-friendly downtown area.
COMMISSIONER HENNING: Pedestrian-friendly.
MR. HEATH: In general, ifI may, Glelm Heath witb the
plmming -- comprehensive planning, In general usage among plmmers
pedestrian-friendly type development would include the buildings up
close to the street with visible parking either limited or completely
moved to the back so that it doesn't -- it doesn't impair the pedestrian
-- the safe feeling that the pedestrian isn't competing with the traffic in
some way.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Is that what you want -- I think that's
what you want, right?
COMMISSIONER HENNING: Right.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Okay. So did you want to incorporate
that into your motion, sir?
COMMISSIONER HENNING: It's already in there.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Is it?
COMMISSIONER HENNING: It's part of the submittal for
Page 185
Agenoa Item I~c. 8B
November- 27 2007
Octobet~u '2(,)0'4
,
here. We're all set to go.
MR. MUDD: And, again, this is the Vanderbilt Beach/Collier
Boulevard cOlmnercial subdistrict, petitioner CP-2003-1, and it's the
second item under 8D.
And Mr. Rich Y ovanovich will represent the petitioner on this
particular item.
MR. YOVANOVICH: For the record, Rich Yovanovich,
representing the petitioner.
To be brief, this is the same information you had when you
transmitted this unanimously, except for one change. Previously we
could have a four-stOlY building. The planning connnission requested
when we came back at the last meeting that we reduce it back to three
stories, so there's a reduction in intensity that the platming conID1ission
approved. They, again, unanimously reconnnended to you-all to
adopt this amendment.
Unless you have specific questions about it, I think your staff
repOli is complete and you've seen it before, and it has received
unanimous approval from the planning commissioner twice, and you
. lTansmitted unanimously.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Connnissioner Helming?
COMMISSIONER HENNING: I don't lmow if we have to do ex
parte communication, but I talked to one of your neighbors in the
. property, and they lil<:ed the proj ect.
Do I have to do ex parie?
MR. YOV ANOVICH: No, I don't think you need to,
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Marjorie's up here.
MR. YOV ANOVICH: I'm sony.
MS. STUDENT: For the record, Marjorie Student, assistant
county attorney. This is legislative and not quasijudicial, so there's no
need to do ex patie nor swear people in.
CHAIR1V1AN FIALA: Thank you.
And we have no speakers?
Page 187
~AgencD 11em 1\10. 8::'
:\Jnvo'~-'bo" ",7 ?OO--;'
Octobe~~&;-~~
CHAIRMAN FIALA: I have a motion on the floor to approve
and a second -- by Commissioner Coyle, a second by Conunissioner
Helming.
At that I will close the public hearing. Did -- we didn't have any
speakers on this, right?
MS. FILSON: No. We don't have any more speakers on 8D.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Even you, Mr. Duane.
Okay. Any discussion?
(No response.)
CHAIR1Y1AN FIALA: AU those in favor, say aye.
COMMISSIONER HALAS: Aye.
COMMISSIONER COLETTA: Aye.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Aye.
COMMI SSIONER COYLE: Aye.
COMMISSIONER HENNING: Aye.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Opposed, like SigIl.
(No response.)
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Thank you.
MR. DUANE: I have the next one, too.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Great presentation.
MR. MUDD: That brings us to the -- wel1, you should ask them
for more.
The next item is number four, petition CPSP-2003-3, petition.
requesting amendment to the future land use amendment and future
land use map and map series to establish Livingston and Veterans
Memorial Boulevard cOllunercial infil1 subdistrict allowing
cOllli11ercial unit n uses in the C-1 district with a maximum of 50,000
square feet for a plus or minus 2. -- two and a quarter acre parcel
located at the southeast comer of Livingston Road north/south and
Livingston Road east/west in Section 13, Township 48 south, Range
25 east.
Mr. Duane?
Page 189
Aaenda 11em [\lo. 88
t~ovember 27, 2007
OctoberOZ@, ~(9'(J.4l
CPSP-2003-l0. That had to do with Golden Gate Area Master Plan.
And that brhlgs us to item number six, which is petition
CPSP-2003-11. A major portion ofthis petition all except wildlife
policies, which you covered under item 8C earlier. It's petition
requesting various glitch amendments consisting of tec1mical
corrections, clarifications, and additional te1111inology to the future
land use element conservation and coastal management element,
capital improvement element, transportation element, and the Golden
Gate Area Master Plan element pertaining to the rural fringe area and
the ruraVeastemlands stewardship area of the future land use element.
And Mr. David Weeks from comprehensive pla.J.ming will
present.
COMMISSIONER COYLE: Motion to approve.
COMMISSIONER HALAS: Motion to approve.
COMMISSIONER COYLE: Second.
CJ-IAIRMAN FIALA: Okay. Do we have any speakers on this
item?
MS. FILSON: No, ma'am.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Okay. The public heating will be closed.
Commissioner Halas has motioned to approve, and
Connnissioner Coyle has seconded that.
Any discussion?
(No response.)
CHAIRMAN FIALA: All those in favor, say aye.
COMMISSIONER HALAS: Aye.
COMMISSIONER COLETTA: Aye.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Aye.
COMMISSIONER COYLE: Aye.
COMMISSIONER HENNING: Aye.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Opposed, like sign.
(No response.)
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Thank you, David.
Page 191
f'-.pf:!l:Je: item i\lJ. 8S
!\laVpn'DCl~- ,:,.j _ 'Jr,)G'
OctobCl'::~~52~U4
MR. WEEKS: No, sir. The -- at your transmittal hearing, you
voted not to transmit that. I will tell you that staff erroneously
advertised for tbe plmming commission that that item would be
considered, but it was not, and for your hearing today, it was not
advertised.
COMMISSIONER COLETTA: Okay. Thank you.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Okay. We have no speakers?
MS. FILSON: No, malam.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Close the public hearing.
Commissioner Halas -- it was Conul1issioner Halas, right, that
motioned to approve?
COMMISSIONER HALAS: Yes. And you said that the density
ill the coastal high hazard area has not been addressed then in this?
MR. WEEKS: That is correct, sir.
COMMISSIONER HALAS: And what was the reason?
MR. WEEKS: Because the board voted at transmittal hearing
not to endorse the change that staff had proposed.
COMMISSIONER HALAS: Okay.
MR. WEEKS: You have your transmittal hearings, then, of
course, today is the adoption hearing. If you vote not to transmit, you
have, in effect, denied that petition. So that part of this petition is
gone. It CalIDot be considered today. That -- granted it was by a split
vote, but -- it was a 3-2 vote, and that's all it takes at transmittal.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Okay. Do you still motion to approve,
Commissioner Halas?
COMMISSIONER HALAS: Yes.
CHAIRI\1AN FIALA: With the second by Conunissioner Coyle.
Any further discussion?
(No response.)
CHATRlvIAN FIALA: All those in favor, signify by saying aye.
COMMISSIONER HALAS: Aye.
COMMISSIONER COLETTA: Aye.
Page 193
Agenaa item l\jc. 88
Oct6bO~~'gj~ 2~"rHi)~
The next item is number nine. It's CPSP-2003-l4. Itls a petition
requesting amendments to the transportation element to revise the
functional classification of various county and/or state roads.
COMMISSIONER HENNING: So move.
COMMISSIONER COLETTA: Second.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Okay. Move to approve?
COMMISSIONER HENNING: Yes.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Okay. Do we have any speakers on this?
MS. FILSON: No, ma'am.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Close the public hearing. I have a motion
on the floor by Commissioner Henning to approve, and a second by
Commissioner Coletta.
AllY discussion?
(No response.)
CHAIRMAN FIALA: All those in favor, say aye.
COMMISSIONER HALAS: Aye.
COMMISSIONER COLETTA: Aye.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Aye.
COMMISSIONER HENNING: Aye.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Opposed, like sign.
(No response.)
CHAIRMAN FIALA: . That's a 4-0
MR. MUDD: Yes, ma'am.
Number 10, it's CPSP-2003-l5. Petition requesting phase II
amendments of the Community Character/Smart Grmvth Advisory
Committee to amend the future land use element, to implement the
community character plan by promoting pedestlian-oriented human
scale development in intercollilection of the neighborhoods and
developments.
MR. SWEAT: For tbe record, again, Jay Sweat, planning.
COMMISSIONER HENNING: Motion to approve.
COM1'vlISSIONER HALAS: Second.
Page 195
,.0,p8n::12 Its:Ti !~O 88
::JDvemb:~. ":-; 7n07
Octooer ~\' -~4Jg
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Oh, okay, fine. I just wanted to make
sure that was on the record so we knew what we were voting on.
Okay. Commissioner Henning?
COMMISSIONER HENNING: It might be out of line for me to
ask now, but when that -- the listed specie (sic) issue comes back, do
you think you might have it ready so I can review which anin1al is
truly on the decline? Can we get some empirical data on that from the
state or the feds?
MR. WEEKS: We'll attempt to. I know what Mr. Lorenz was
saying before is you're either on the lists or you're not. But possibly
the appropriate agencies are doing studies to consider adding --
COMMISSIONER HENNING: Fish and wildlife.
MR. WEEKS: -- an animal or could take one off. So I'll pass
that on to make that effort.
COMMISSIONER HEJ\TNING: Just in Collier County, not --
MR. WEEKS: Yes, sir.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Okay. Now I have a motion to approve
by whom?
COMMISSIONER COYLE: Me.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: By Commissioner Coyle.
COMMISSIONER COLETTA: Second, if you need one.
CHAlRMAN FIALA: Was there a second or is that
Commissioner Coletta?
COMMISSIONER HALAS: He'll be the second.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Okay. Commissioner Coletta is the
second.
MS. FILSON: I had Commissioner--
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Pardon me?
MS. FILSON: I had you n never mind.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: Oh, maybe I did.
COMMISSIONER COLETTA: You can be the second.
CHAIRMAN FIALA: I did, okay.
Page 197
Agsnda Item No. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 1 of 127
.~.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
PUDZ-2006-AR-I0698: A. Grover Matheney, Trustee, represented by R. Bruce Anderson
esquire, of Roetzel & Andress, LPA and Margaret Perry, AICP, of WilsonMiller, Inc., is
requesting a rezone from Planned Unit Development (PUD) to Commercial Planned Unit
Development (CPUD) for a project to be known as the Gaspar Station PUD. The subject
property, consisting oft7.7 acres, is located on the south side ofImmokalee Road (CR 846),
approximately one quarter mile west of the 1-7SlImmokalee Road, interchange, in Section
30, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida.
OBJECTIVE:
To have the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) review staffs rezone and PUD findings and
recommendations along with the recommendations of the Collier County Planning Commission
(CCPC) regarding the above referenced PUD to CPUD rezone petition and render a decision
regarding the petition.
CONSIDERATIONS:
The proposed CPUD, if approved, will allow for retail and service uses at a rate of 7,500 square
feet per gross acre; office uses at a rate of 15,000 square feet per gross acre; and hotel/motel use
at a rate of26 units per gross acre. The CPUD allows for a mix ofInterchange Commerical uses
that are consistent with the GMP.
The project is bordered by Juliet Boulevard on the east, then a Wal-Mart superstore; on the north
by Immokalee Road, then a residential component of the Carlton Lakes project; to the west by
two approximately nine-acre, undeveloped agriculturally zoned tracts; and to the south by lands
within Livingston Lakes PUD, a residential project. Although there are no structures on site,
there are water and sewer lines on the subject tract, and a portion of Juliet Boulevard is located
on the site. The CPUD document and the Master Plan indicate the project will not have access
directly to Immokalee Road; access to the site will be via Juliet Boulevard. No deviations from
Land Development Code (LDC) requirements have been sought.
The subject property was rezoned to PUD as the Stiles PUD in Ordinance 97-74, a copy of which
is included in the application materials. The Stiles PUD was originally approved in Ordinance
86-58 on August 26, 1986, and that ordinance was repealed by another PUD rezoning by the
same name that became effective on December 12, 1997, The petitioner sought to extend the
PUD; however, that extension request, PUDEX-2004-AR-5296, which was submitted on January
28,2004, was deemed withdrawn by statf due to inactivity on August 1,2005. The time within
which to seek approval for a PUD extension has now lapsed, so the petitioner was required to
submit a new rezoning application pursuant to LDC Section 10.02.] 3.D.6.e that states:
~-,
Any PUD developer who has not commenced development pursuant to the sunsetting
provisions set forth in section 10.02.12 of this Code within ten years of the original
PUD approval date shall submit a new rezoning application. The petitioner is seeking
the same uses and intensity that were approved in the Stiles PUD.
Page 1 of 7
Agenda Item No. Be
r<ovember 27. 2007
Page 2 of 127
Unlike most PUD to PUD rezoning petitions, a strike-thru/underline formatted document is not
included because this petition is treated procedurally as if the subject property was rezoning from
any conventional zoning district to PUD, The existing Stiles PUD Ordinance 97-74 is not being
"amended", nor is some language being replaced with new language. Ordinance 97-74 will be
repealed in its entirety if this petition is approved. However, the petitioner, as previously stated,
is seeking approval of the same uses that were approved in the Stiles PUD.
FISCAL IMPACT:
The PUD rezone, by and of itself, will have no fiscal impact on Collier County, There is no
guarantee that the project, at build out, will maximize its authorized level of development,
however, if the PUD amendment is approved, a portion of the existing land will be developed
and the new development will result in an impact on Collier County public facilities.
The County collects impact fees prior to the issuance of building permits to help offset the
impacts of each new development on public facilities. These impact fees are used to fund
projects identified in the Capital Improvement Element of the GMP as needed to maintain
adopted Level of Service (LOS) for public facilities. Additionally, in order to meet the
requirements of concurrency management, the developer of every local development order
approved by Collier County is required to pay 50 percent of the estimated Transportation Impact
Fees associated with the project. Other fees collected prior to issuance of a building permit
include building permit review fees and utility fees associated with connecting to the County's
water and sewer system. Finally, additional revenue is generated by applying ad valorem tax
rates to applicable properties, and that revenue is directly related to the value of improvements.
Please note that the inclusion of impact fees and taxes collected are for informational purposes
only; they are not included in the criteria used by Staff and the Planning Commission to analyze
this petition,
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT:
Future Land Use Element (FLUE): The subject propel1y is designated Urban Commercial
District, Interchange Activity Center Subdistrict, Activity Center #4, as identified on the Future
Land Use Map (FLUM) of the GMP. It is located within the Northwest Transportation
Concurrency Management Area (TCMA). The County has confirmed that the level of service
criteria for the Northwest TCMA in the LDC are being met; however, the final determination of
concurrency will be done during the site development plan process.
The Future Land Use Element (FLUE) of the GMP provides guidelines for Interchange Activity
Centers. Comprehensive Planning staff analyzed those guidelines and believes this petition can
be deemed consistent with the guidelines for the Interchange Activity Center. (The complete
review memo from Comprehensive Planning, dated December 4, 2006 was included as Exhibit
"C" to the Collier County Planning Commission staff report.)
Transportation Element: Transportation Division Planning staff has reviewed this petition's
Traffic Impact Statement (TIS) included in the application back-up material and the CPUD
document to ensure the CPUD document contains the appropriate language to address this
project's potential traffic impacts, and to offer a recommendation regarding GMP Transportation
Page 2 of 7
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 3 of 127
Element, Policies 5.1 and 9.3. Those policies require the review of all rezone requests with
consideration of its impact on the overall transportation system, and specifically note that the
County should not approve any request that significantly impacts a roadway segment already
operating, and/or projected to operate, at an unacceptable level of service (LOS) within the five-
year planning period unless specific mitigating stipulations are approved, The project was
reviewed based on the current TIS guidelines and with respect to Policy 5.1 of the Collier
County GMP Transportation Element. The project traffic was distributed on the adjacent
roadway network and analyzed through project build-out with consideration given to the five-
year planning period.
The trips generated by the Gaspar Station CPUD, previously known as the Stiles PUD, are
considered vested based on the project's prior contributions of right-of-way, and contributions
toward the improvements to the intersection of Immokalee Road and Juliet Boulevard. The
Gaspar Station CPUD can be considered consistent with Policy 5.1 of the Transportation
Element of the GMP, because the trips for this project are already accounted for in the
concurrency system. Although this CPUD is considered vested by Transportation Division
Planning staff, the CPUD remains subject to operational analysis at the time of subsequent
development order application.
However, Transportation Division Planning staff finds this project to be inconsistent with GMP
Transportation Element Policy 9.3 and current LDC requirements because the CPUD Master
Plan does not provide an interconnection to the adjacent parcel to the west. Staff has stipulated
an interconnection be provided to the abutting parcel to the west as a condition of approval.
Conservation and Coastal Management Element: Pursuant to Objective 2.4 and Policies
2.4.1 and 6.5.1, an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) was provided to staff for review. In
accordance with Policy 6,1.1, 25 percent of the existing native vegetation shall be retained on-
site and it has been set aside as preserve areas. The requirement for an ElS pursuant to Policy
6.1.8 has been satisfied. Jurisdictional wetlands have been identified as required in Policies 6.2,1
and 6.2.2. In accordance with Policy 6.2,6, required prescrvation arcas are identified on the
CPUD Master Plan.
GMP Conclusion: The GMP is the prevailing document to support land use decisions such as
this proposed rezoning to CPUD. Staff is required to make a recommendation regarding a
finding of consistency or inconsistency with the overall GMP as part of the recommendation for
approval, approval with stipulations, or denial of any rezoning petition. A finding of consistency
with the FLUE and FLUM designations is a portion of the overall finding that is required, and
staff believes the petition is consistent with the FLUM and the FLUE as indicated previously in
the GMP discussion, The proposed rezone is also consistent with GMP Transportation Element
Policy 5.1 as previously discussed. However the petition, as currcntly proposed, is not consistent
with GMP Transportation Element Policy 9.3 which states, "The County shall require, wherever
feasible, the interconnection of local streets between developments to facilitate convenient
movement throughout the road network." The petitioner has not demonstrated that an
interconnection is not feasible, but has offered the argument contained in letters from the agent
dated January 8, 2007 and February 23, 2007; both letters have been included in the application
packet. Staff provided an analysis of the agent's assertions as part of the zoning analysis later in
this report.
Page 3 of 7
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27.2007
Page 4 of 127
Based upon the staff analysis provided above, staff concludes the proposed uses and density may
be deemed consistent with the goals, objectives and policies of the GMP, except staff concludes
the petition should be deemed inconsistent with GMP Transportation Element Policy 9.3, unless
language is added to the CPUD commitments to address the interconnection, and the petitioner
revises the Master Plan to show an interconnection to the west. Staff has included specific
stipulations as part of the overall recommendation.
AFFORDABLE HOUSING IMPACT:
This request contains no provisions to address the Affordable- Workforce housing demands that it
may create.
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES:
Environmental Services staff has reviewed the petition and the PUD document to address any
environmental concerns. The Environmental Advisory Council reviewed this petition as noted
below.
ENVIRONMENTAL ADVISORY COUNCIL (EAC) RECOMMENDATION:
The Environmental Advisory Commission (EAC) heard this petition on April 4, 2007, and voted
unanimously to approve it with the following stipulation: The lake shape and final size will be
determined at the site development plan stage; however the lake must remain adjacent to the
preserve area.
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION (CCPC) RECOMMENDATION:
The Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) heard this petition on May 3, 2007;
Commissioner Midney made a motion to approve the petition with the following stipulations:
I. The PUD document shall be revised to include the EAC stipulation that the configuration,
i.e., shape and size and the location showing the lake adjacent to preserve shall be
retained; and
2. The developer must provide an interconnection to the parcel to the west; and
3. Certificates of Occupancy shall not be issued until the cloverleaf on 1-75 is open.
Commissioner Strain seconded the motion. Commissioners Adelstein, Strain, Midney, Kolflat
voted in favor of the motion. Those commissioners voting in support of the motion stated
concerns that this project would place an undue bmden upon tbe surrounding roadway network.
Commissioners Tuff, Vigliotti, Schiffer and Murray voted against the motion. Those
commissioners who voted against the motion indicated that they had concerns about including
the stipulation requiring 1-75 cloverleaf improvements because the developer has no control over
those improvements, noting that the improvements may not be made at all. Donna Reed Caron
was absent that day. The CCPC voted 4 to 4 on the motion thus there is no recommendation
from the CCPC to the Board. The petitioner has not revised the PUD document to include CCPC
stipulation because there was no final recommendation, Because the CCPC vote was not
unanimous, this petition cannot be placed on the summary agenda,
Page 4 of 7
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 5 of 127
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS:
This is a site-specific rezone from the Planned Unit Development Zoning District to the
Commercial Planned Unit Development Zoning District for a project known as Gaspar Station
CPUD. Site-specific rezones are quasi-judicial in nature. As such the burden falls upon the
applicant for the rezone to prove that the proposed rezone is consistent with all of the criteria set
forth below. The burden then shifts to the BCC, should it consider denial, that such denial is not
arbitrary, discriminatory or unreasonable. This would be accomplished by finding that the
proposal does not meet one or more of the listed criteria.
Criteria for pun Rezones
Ask yourself the following questions. The answers assist you in making a determination for
approval or not.
I. Consider: The suitability of the area for the type and pattern of development proposed in
relation to physical characteristics of the land, surrounding areas, traffic and access, drainage,
sewer, water, and other utilities,
2. Is there an adequacy of evidence of unified control and suitability of agreements, contract, or
other instruments or for amendments in those proposed, particularly as they may relate to
arrangements or provisions to be made for the continuing operation and maintenance of such
areas and facilities that are nut to be provided or maintained at public expense? Findings and
recommendations of this type shall be made only after consultation with the county attorney.
3, Consider: Conformity of the proposed PUD with the goals, objectives and policies of the
GMP.
4. Consider: The internal and external compatibility of proposed uses, which conditions may
include restrictions on location of improvements, restrictions on design, and buffering and
screening requircments,
5. Is there an adequacy of usable open space areas in existence and as proposed to serve the
development?
6. Consider: The timing or sequence of development (as proposed) for the purpose of assuring
the adequacy of available improvements and facilities, both public and private.
7, Consider: The ability of the subject property and of surrounding areas to accommodate
expansion.
8. Consider: Conformity with PUD regulations, or as to desirable modifications of such
regulations in the particular case, based on determination that such modifications are justified as
meeting public purposes to a degree at least equivalent to literal application of such regulations.
9. Will the proposed change be consistent with the goals, objectives, and policies and future
land use map and the elements of the GMP?
Page 5 of 7
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 6 of 127
10. Will the proposed PUD rezone be appropriate considering the existing land use pattern?
11. Would the requested PUD rezone result in the possible creation of an isolated district
unrelated to adjacent and nearby districts?
12. Consider: Whether existing district boundaries are illogically drawn in relation to existing
conditions on the property proposed for change.
13. Consider: Whether changed or changing conditions make the passage of the proposed
amendment necessary.
14. Will the proposed change adversely influence living conditions in the neighborhood?
15. Will the proposed change create or excessively increase traffic congestion or create types of
traffic deemed incompatible with surrounding land uses, because of peak volumes or projected
types of vehicular traffic, including activity during construction phases of the development, or
otherwise affect public safcty?
16. Will the proposed change create a drainage problem?
17. Will the proposed change seriously reduce light and air to adjacent areas?
18. Will the proposed change adversely affect property values in the adjacent area?
19. Will the proposed change be a deterrent to the improvement or development of adjacent
property in accordance with existing regulations?
20. Consider: Whether the proposed change will constitute a grant of special privilege to an
individual owner as contrasted with the public welfare.
21. Are there substantial reasons why the property cannot ("reasonably") be used in accordance
with existing zoning? (a "core" question. ..)
22. Is the change suggested out of scale with the needs of the neighborhood or the county?
23. Consider: Whether it is impossible to find other adequate sites in the county for the proposed
use in districts already permitting such use.
24. Consider: The physical characteristics of the property and the degree of site alteration which
would be required to make the property usable for any of the range of potential uses under the
proposed zoning classification.
25. Consider: The impact of development resulting from the proposed PUD rezone on the
availability of adequate public facilities and services consistent with the levels of service
adopted in the Collier County GMP as defined and implemented through the Collier County
Adequate Public Facilities Ordinance [Code ch.l 06, art. II], as amended.
Page 6 017
Agenda Item No. 8e
November 27,2007
Page 7 of 127
26. Are there other factors, standards, or criteria relating to the PUD rezone request that the BCC
shall deem important in the protection of the public health, safety, and welfare?
The BCC must base its decision upon the competent, substantial evidence presented by the
written materials supplied to it, including but not limited to the Staff Report, Executive
Summary, maps, studies, letters from interested persons and the oral testimony presented at the
Board of County Commissioners hearing as these materials related to these criteria.
RECOMMENDA nON:
Staff recommends that the Board of County Commissioners approve Petition PUDZ-2006-AR-
10698 subject to the staff recommendation that the petitioner must provide an interconnection to
the property located west of the site,
PREPARED BY:
Kay Deselem, AICP, Principal Planner
Department of Zoning and Land Development Review
Page 7 of 7
Item Number:
Item Summary:
Meeting Date:
Page 1 of 1
Agenda Item No Be
November 27, 2007
Page 8 of 127
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
8C
This Item continued from the June 12, 2007 and October 23, 2007 Bee meetings This item
requires that all participants be sworn in and ex parte disclosure be prOVided by CommiSSion
members PUDZ-2006.AR,,10698 A Gro\'er Matheney, Trustee, represent'Od by R Bruce
Anderson esquire, oj Roetzel & AndresS, I_PA and Margaret Perry, AICP, ofVVilsonMiller,
Inc, is requesting a rezone tram Planned Unit Development (PUO) to CommerCial Planned
Unit Development (CPUD) tor a project to be known as the Gaspar Station PUD The subject
property, conSisting of 17 7 acres, is located on the south side of Immokalee Road (eR 846),
approximately one quarter mile west at the 1-75/lmmokalee Road interchange in Section 30,
Township 48 South, Range 26 East, Collier Count~, Florida
11/27/::'0079:0000A.M
Principal Planner
D,,.
Prepared By
Kay Deselem, AICP
Community [fflvelopment &
Environmental Services
Zoning 8. Land Development Review
5121i20078:46:03AM
Approved By
Chief Planner
DM'
Ray Bellows
Community Development &
Environmental Services
Zoning & Land Development Review
111S!20073:44PM
Date
Approved By
JudyPuig
Community Development &.
Environmental Services
Operations Analyst
Community Development &
Envlronmenta!SerlficesAdmin
11/9120073:47 PM
Norm E Feder, AICP
lranr,portlltion Olvislon Admmlstrator
Dllte
ApprovcdRy
Tral1sportationSOfvlces
Tr~nsportattonServlce&..dmin,
11!13i200711:1BAM
Approved By
MarleneSlewart
Community Development &
Environment~1 Service"
Execut;veSecretMy
Date
Community Develaml1ent &
Environmentll~ Services Admin
11/14f2007'U2AM
Date
Approved By
Susan Murray,AIC?
Community Development &
Environmental Services
Zoning & Land Development Diroctor
Zoning & Land Developmenl Review
1111412007 HI:13 AM
Approved By
Date
Marjorie M. Student-Stirlmg Assistant County Attorney
11114i20071:1f,PM
Approved By
County Attomey COWlty At\orney Offic:o
NickCaslllanguida
MPODiredor
Date
TranspartationServiceti
Tral15port<ltionPlanning
11114120073:45 PM
Approved By
JosephK. Schmitt
Community Development &
Environmental Services
C<>mmunity ()(Jvalopment &
Environmental Services Adminstrator
Date
Community Development &
Env;ronmentaIServicesAdmin.
11114120077:44 PM
Applications Analyst
D~,
ApprO\ledBy
OMBCoordinator
AdministrlltiveServicos
Information Technotogy
11!15120073:38PM
Marll"lr,(lcK\To(1
Budget Analyst
Date
Approved By
County Manager's Office
Office of Management & Budget
11115!20D74:4DPM
ApprovcdBy
James-V. Mudd
8oardofCounty
Commissioners.
County Mllnager
Date
County Manager's Office
1m61200711:24AM
fil~'I/("\A (rf';nclHTe:"t\Fxn(lrt\Q~~ NmfPmhe:,.o/;:"?n77 OJ,,?()?()()7\()R %?()A 1 )VFRTTSFn% ?np
l1nnnnm
Agenda Item No. 8e
November 27, 2007
Page 9 of 127
SUPPLEMENT AL
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
PUDZ-2006-AR-I0698: A. Grover Matheney, Trustee, represented by R. Bruce Anderson esquire,
of Roetzel & Andress, LP A and Margaret Perry, AICP, of WilsonMiller, Inc., is requesting a rezone
from Planned Unit Development (PUD) to Commercial Planned Unit Development (CPUD) for a
project to be known as the Gaspar Station PUD. The subject property, consisting of 17.7 acres, is
located on the south side of Immokalee Road (CR 846), approximately one quarter mile west of the
1-7SlImmokalee Road, interchange, in Section 30, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, Collier
County, Florida
PROJECT STATUS:
This petition was scheduled to be heard by the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) on June 12,2007.
The Executive Summary that was prepared for that hearing has been included in the information provided
for this hearing. On June II, 2007, the petitioner's agent submitted a continuance request to allow
additional time to negotiate late-arising transportation issues (copy attached). The Board continued the
petition to October 23, 2007 as requested by the agent.
On October 9, 2007, the petitioner's agent requested another continuance to allow this petition to be heard
on November 27, 2007 instead of October 23, 2007, citing the need for additional time to resolve the
outstanding transportation issues regarding 1-75 and Immokalee Road intersection improvements to
ensure that adjacent roadway links will operate at an acceptable Level of Service (LOS) within the five-
year planning period. The Metropolitan Planning Organization (MPO) discussed this issue on November
2, 2007.
SUPPLEMENTAL ANALYSIS:
As noted in the Executive Summary prepared for June 12, 2007, the provision of an interconnection to the
property to the west was an unresolved issue between the petitioner and staff. Staff was recommending
approval of the petition only if the petitioner provided an interconnection, however the petitioner did not
accept that stipulation and it seemed that the issue would have ultimately been discussed and resolved at
the Board hearing on June 12,2007. The applicant's agent and County staff agreed upon a stipulation to
require the interconnection. The PUD document has been revised (dated August 27,2007) to include this
stipulation as PUD Section 5.2..!. A copy of the revised PUD has been included in the information for the
Board's consideration.
As noted above, the most recent issue delaying this project's Board hearing is the status of the 1-
75/1mmokalee Road intersection improvements. Final agreement has not been reached between Collier
County and the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT), However, on November 2, 2007, the
MPO approved a plan for an eight-lane diamond design with Immokalee Road to pass under 1-75. This
tentative plan will most likely be presented to the BCC for final resolution within the next month or so.
Until the improvements to Immokalee Road are made as part of the 1-75 project the adjacent roadway
links may fail. Such failure could result in a denial recommendation from Transportation Division staff
based upon a finding of inconsistency with the Growth Management Plan (GMP) Transportation Element
Policy 5.1 because the adjacent links would fall below the adopted acceptable LOS standard in the five-
year planning period.
Page 1 of 2
Agenda Item No. 8e
November 27, 2007
Page 10 of 127
Transportation Division staff however has determined that should the BCC wish to approve this petition,
stipulations can be added to address GMP Transportation Element 5.1, believing that the issue is one of
timing. If the project's roadway impacts are delayed so that the project does not add trips to the deficient
roadway links, then the petition would be consistent with Policy 5.1 and Transportation Division staff
could support the petition. Therefore Transportation Division staff has offered the following stipulation
to address this issue:
The County shall not issue any Certificate of Occupancy or Tempormy Certificate of
Occupancy for any portion of this project until the 1-75/Immokalee Road intersection
improvements thru lanes are substantially complete and open.
The petitioner's agent has been made aware of this stipulation but has not agreed to accept it, citing the
fact that the petitioner is out of the country at this time. Staff anticipates a response from the petitioner
will be provided at the BCC hearing on November 27,2007.
RECOMMENDA nON:
Staff recommends that the Board of County Commissioners approve Petition PUDZ-2006-AR-I0698
subject to the conditions of approval that have been incorporated in the Ordinance of Adoption and the
following stipulation to ensure consistency with GMP Transportation Element 5.1:
The County shall not issue any Certificate of Occupancy or Tempormy Certificate of
Occupancy jilr any portion of this project until the 1-75/Immokalee Road intersection
improvements thru lanes are substantially complete and open.
PREPARED BY:
Kay Deselem, AICP, Principal Planner
Department of Zoning & Land Development Review
Page 2 of 2
SUPPLEMENT AL
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Agenda Item No. 8e
November 27, 2007
Page 11 of 127
PUDZ-2006-AR-I0698: A. Grover Matheney, Trustee, represented by R. Bruce Anderson esquire,
of Roetzel & Andress, LPA and Margaret Perry, AICP, of Wilson Miller, Inc., is requesting a rezone
from Planned Unit Development (PUD) to Commercial Planned Unit Development (CPUD) for a
project to be known as the Gaspar Station PUD. The subject property, consisting of 17.7 acres, is
located on the south side of Immokalee Road (CR 846), approximately one quarter mile west of the
1-7SlImmokalee Road, interchange, in Section 30, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, Collier
County, Florida.
PROJECT STATUS:
This petition was scheduled to be heard by the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) on June 12,2007.
The Executive Summary that was prepared for that hearing has been included in the information provided
for this hearing. On June 11, 2007, the petitioner's agent submitted a continuance request to allow
additional time to negotiate late-arising transportation issues (copy attached). The Board continued the
petition to October 23, 2007 as requested by the agent.
SUPPLEMENTAL ANALYSIS:
As noted in the Executive Summary prepared for June 12,2007, the provision of an interconnection to the
property to the west was an unresolved issue between the petitioner and staff. Staff was recommending
approval of the petition only if the petitioner provided an interconnection, however the petitioner did not
accept that stipulation and it seemed that the issue would have ultimately been discussed and resolved at
the Board hearing on June 12, 2007. The applicant's agent and County staff agreed upon a stipulation to
require the interconnection. The PUD document has been revised (dated August 27,2007) to include this
stipulation as PUD Section 5.2.1,
A copy of the revised PUD has been included in the information forthe Board's consideration.
RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends that the Board of County Commissioners approve Petition PUDZ-2006-AR-10698
subject to the conditions of approval that have been incorporated in the Ordinance of Adoption.
PREPARED BY:
Kay Deselem, AICP, Principal Planner
Department of Zoning & Land Development Review
Page 1 of 1
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 12 of 127
Co~r County
'--- """"'-- -- -
FROM:
STAFF REPORT
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION
HEARING DATE:
MAY 3, 2007
SUBJECT:
PUDZ-2007-AR-I0698; GASPAR STATION COMMERCIAL PLANNED UNIT
DEVELOPMENT (CPUD)
PROPERTY OWNER/AGENT:
APPLICANT:
AGENTS:
A. Grover Matheney, trustee
2351 SW 37th Ave, Apt 11112
Miami, FL 33145
R, Bruce Anderson, esquire
Roetzel & Andress, L.P.A.
850 Park Shore Drive, 3'd Floor
Naples, FL 34103
Margaret Perry, AICP
WilsonMiller
3200 Bailey Lane, Suite 200
Naples, FL 34105
REQUESTED ACTION:
The petitioner requests that the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) consider a rezone of the
subject site from the Stiles Planned Unit Development (PUD) to a new Commercial Planned Unit
Development (CPUD) to be known as the Gaspar Station CPUD.
GEOGRAPHIC LOCATION:
The subject property, consisting of 17,7", acres, is located on the south side ofImmokalee Road (CR
846), approximately one quarter mile west of the I-75/Immokalee Road interchange, in Section 30,
Township 48 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida, (See location map on a following page)
PURPOSEIDESCRIPTION OF PROJECT:
The proposed CPUD, if approved, will allow for retail and service uses at a rate of 7,500 square feet per
gross acre; office uses at a rate of 15,000 square feet per gross acre; and hotel/motel use at a rate of 26
units per gross acre. The CPUD allows for a mix of Interchange Commerical uses that is consistent
with the Growth Management Plan (GMP).
The project is bordered by Juliet Boulevard on the east, then a Wal-Mart superstore; on the north by
Immokalee Road, then a residential component of the Carlton Lakes project; to the west by two
approximately nine-acre, undeveloped agriculturally zoned tracts; and to the south by lands within
Livingston Lakes PUD, a residential project. Although there are no structures on site, there are water
and sewer lines on the subject tract, and a portion of Juliet Boulevard is located on the site. The CPUD
document and the Master Plan indicate the project will not have access directly to Immokalee Road;
Gaspar Station PUD, PUDZ-2006-AR-1 0698 Staff Report May 3. 2007 CCPC
Page 1 of 12
Aaenda Item No. 8e
November 27, 2007
Page 13 of 127
access to the site will be via Juliet Boulevard. No deviations from Land Development Code (LDC)
requirements have been sought.
The subject property was rezoned to PUD as the Stiles PUD in Ordinance 97-74, a copy of which is
included in the application materials. The Stiles PUD was originally approved in Ordinance 86-58 on
August 26, 1986, and that ordinance was repealed by another PUD rezoning by the same name that
became effective on December 12, 1997. The petitioner sought to extend the PUD; however, that
extension request, PUDEX-2004-AR-5296, which was submitted on January 28, 2004, was deemed
withdrawn by staff due to inactivity on August I, 2005. The time within which to seek approval for a
PUD extension has now lapsed, so the petitioner was required to submit a new rezoning application
pursuant to LDC Section I 0.02. 13,D.6.e that states:
Any PUD developer who has not commenced development pursuant to the sunsetting
provisions set forth in section 10.02.12 of this Code within ten years of the original PUD
approval date shall submit a new rezoning application. The petitioner is seeking the same
uses and intensity that were approved in the Stiles PUD.
Unlike most PUD to PUD rezoning petitions, a strike-thrulunderline formatted document is not
included because this petition is treated procedurally as if the subject property was rezoning from any
conventional zoning district to PUD. The existing Stiles PUD ordinance (97-74) is not being
"amended", nor is some language being replaced with new language. Ordinance 97-74 will be repealed
in its entirety if this petition is approved, However. the petitioner, as previously stated, is seeking
approval of the same uses that were approved in the Stiles PUD.
~.
=1'"
1"
::)1'
t,
.f:!'
'-, '~,
.,......".
1=...:.."".....'.....
......."
-'.-~.'
, ~
::\r!,'
Aerial Photo (subject property outline is approximate)
Gaspar Station PUD, PUDZ-2006-AR-10698 Staff Report
May 3, 2007 CCPC
Page 2 of 12
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27. 2007
Page 14 of 127
SURROUNDING LAND USE AND ZONING:
North: Immokalee Road, then Lakeview at Carlton Lakes, a developed, residential, multi-family
project approved at a density of 3.35 units per acre within the residential portion of Carlton
Lakes PUD, with a PUD zoning designation
East: Juliet Boulevard, then Wal-Mart superstore, part of the Donovan Center PUD, with a PUD
zoning designation
South: A portion of the developing Livingston Lakes PUD, a residential, multi-family project
approved at 7 units per acre, with a zoning designation of PUD
West: two undeveloped, approximately nine-acre tracts (both controlled by the same entity) with an
Agricultural zoning designation
GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN CONSISTENCY:
Future Land Use Element:
The subject property is designated Urban Commercial District, Interchange Activity Center Subdistrict,
Activity Center #4, as identified on the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) of the Growth Management
Plan (GMP). It is located within the Northwest Transportation Concurrency Management Area
(TCMA). The County has confirmed that the level of service criteria for the Northwest TCMA in the
LDC are being met; however, the fmal determination of concurrency will be done during the site
development plan process.
The Future Land Use Element (FLUE) of the GMP provides guidelines for Interchange Activity
Centers. Comprehensive Planning staff analyzed those guidelines and believes this petition can be
deemed consistent with the guidelines for Interchange Activity. (The complete review memo from
Comprehensive Planning, dated December 4, 2006 is included as Exhibit "e."
Transportation Element:
Transportation Planning staff has reviewed this petition's Traffic Impact Statement (TIS) included in
the application back-up material and the CPUD document to ensure the CPUD document contains the
appropriate language to address this project's potential traffic impacts, and to offer a recommendation
regarding GMP Transportation Element, Policies 5.1 and 9.3. Those policies require the review of all
rezone requests with consideration of its impact on the overall transportation system, and specifically
note that the County should not approve any request that significantJy impacts a roadway segment
already operating, and/or projected to operate, at an unacceptable level of service (LOS) within the
five-year planning period unless specific mitigating stipulations are approved. The project was
reviewed based on the current TIS guidelines and with respect to Policy 5. I of the Collier County GMP
Transportation Element. The project traffic was distributed on the adjacent roadway network and
analyzed through project build-out with consideration given to the five-year planning period.
The trips generated by the Gaspar Station CPUD, previously known as the Stiles PUD, are considered
vested based on the project's prior contributions of right-of-way, and contributions toward the
improvements to the intersection of Immokalee Road and Juliet Boulevard. The Gaspar Station CPUD
can be considered consistent with Policy 5,J of the Transportation Element of the GMP, because the
Gaspar Station PUD, PUDZ-2006-AR-10698 Staff Report May 3. 2007 eepe
Page 3 of 12
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27,2007
Page 15 of 127
trips for this project are already accounted for in the concurrency system, Although this CPUD is
considered vested by Transportation Planning staff, the CPUD remains subject to operational analysis
at the time of subsequent development order application.
However, Transportation Planning staff finds this project to be inconsistent with OMP Transportation
Element Policy 9.3 and current LDC requirements because the CPUD Master Plan does not provide an
interconnection to the adjacent parcel to the west. Staff has stipulated an interconnection be provided
to the abutting parcel to the west as a condition of approval.
Conservation and Coastal Management Element:
Pursuant to Objective 2.4 and Policies 2.4.1 and 6.5.1, an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) was
provided to staff for review. In accordance with Policy 6.1.1, 25 percent of the existing native
vegetation shall be retained on-site and it has been set aside as preserve areas. The requirement for an
EIS pursuant to Policy 6, 1 ,8 has been satisfied. Jurisdictional wetlands have been identified as required
in Policies 6.2. 1 and 6.2,2, In accordance with Policy 6.2,6, required preservation areas are identified
on the CPUD Master Plan,
GMP Conclusion:
The OMP is the prevailing document to support land use decisions such as this proposed rezoning to
CPUD. Staff is required to make a recommendation regarding a finding of consistency or
inconsistency with the overall OMP as part of the recommendation for approval, approval with
stipulations, or denial of any rezoning petition. A finding of consistency with the FLUE and FLUM
designations is a portion of the overall finding that is required, and staff believes the petition is
consistent with the FLUM and the FLUE as indicated previously in the OMP discussion. The proposed
rezone is also consistent with OMP Transportation Element Policy 5.1 as previously discussed.
However the petition, as currently proposed, is not consistent with OMP Transportation Element Policy
9.3 which states, 'The County shall require, wherever feasible, the interconnection of local streets
between developments to facilitate convenient movement throughout the road network." The petitioner
has not demonstrated that an interconnection is not feasible, but has offered the argument contained in
letters from the agent dated January 8, 2007 and February 23, 2007; both letters have been included in
the application packet. Staff provided an analysis of the agent's assertions as part of the zoning
analysis later in this report.
Based upon the staff analysis provided above, staff concludes the proposed uses and density may be
deemed consistent with the goals, objectives and policies of the OMP, except staff concludes the
petition should be deemed inconsistent with OMP Transportation Element Policy 9.3, unless language
is added to the CPUD commitments to address the interconnection, and petitioner revises the Master
Plan to show an interconnection to the west. Staff has included specific stipulations as part of the
overall recommendation.
ANALYSIS:
Staff completed a comprehensive evaluation of this land use petition and the criteria upon which a
favorable determination must be based. These criteria are specifically noted in Sections 10,02,13 and
1 0.02,13.B.5 of the LDC and required staff evaluation and comment. The staff evaluation establishes a
factual basis to support the recommendations of staff. The CCPC uses these same criteria as the basis
Gaspar Station PUD, PUDZ-2006-AR-10698 Staff Report
May 3, 2007 CCPC
Page 4 of 12
Agsnda Item No. 8e
November 27, 2007
Page 16 of 127
for their recommendation to the Board of County Commissioners (BCC), who in turn use the criteria to
support their action on the rezoning request. These evaluations are completed as separate documents
and are attached to the staffreport (See Exhibits "A" and "B"),
Environmental Review: Environmental Services staff has reviewed the petition and the CPUD
document to address any environmental concerns. The subject property consists of approximately 17.7
acres of which approximately 16,3 acres contains native vegetation. The Juliet Boulevard easement
accounts for approximately 1.4 acres, leaving 16.3 acres of developable property. Wetland areas
consist of 0.4 acres of Cypress-Pine-Cabbage Palm, of which exotic vegetation comprise 25 to 49
percent (FLUCFCS 624E2), There are approximately 14.25 acres of Pine Flatwoods with Palmetto
Understory, 0.70 acres Pine Flatwoods with Graminoid Understory, (Exotics 25 to 49 percent), and
0.40 acres of Cypress-Pine-Cabbage Palm (Exotics 25 to 49 percent). Fifteen percent of native
vegetation on the site must be preserved. Therefore, approximately 2.4 acres of native vegetation are
required to be preserved on the site: (16.3 x .15 = 2.4). The preserve will connect to the Livingston
Woods POO preserve to the south.
There are approximately 0.4 acres of SFWMD jurisdictional wetlands on the site. The SFWMD
performed an informal wetland determination on August 9, 2002. Wetlands on the site are low quality
in function and are proposed for impacts by the proposed development. The presence of Immokalee
Road and associated canal, 1-75 and surrounding development has altered the hydrology of the site. The
wetlands have also been impacted by varying levels of exotic plant infestation of primarily melaleuca
and Brazilian pepper.
Evidence of wildlife utilization on the site was minimal during site inspections. The site is not currently
inhabited or utilized by endangered or threatened species or by species of special concern. There is a
potential for the Big Cypress fox squirrel and the Eastern Indigo snake to utilize the site. A Big Cypress
fox squirrel management plan and an Eastern indigo snake management plan have been prepared and
are included in the EIS,
This petition was heard by the Environmental Advisory Council (EAC) on April 4, 2007, The
recommendation from the EAC is provided later in this report. The staff report prepared by
Environmental staff to that body is attached as Exhibit D,
Transportation Review: Transportation Department staff has reviewed the petition and the CPUD
document and Master Plan for right-of-way and access issues. As noted in the GMP analysis,
Transportation Planning staff recommends that this project be found inconsistent with the GMP unless
an interconnection to the west is provided.
The Board of County Commissioners, in other petitions located proximate to the Immokalee RoadlI-75
interchange, has asked to be provided with a status report of that interchange improvement time table.
At this time, no firm date for the completion of planned 1-75 interchange improvements has been
provided to County Transportation Planning staff. Interchange improvements are incorporated into the
widening ofI-75, and the budget and timeline for the project are controlled by Florida Department of
Transportation (FDOT).
Utility Review: This project is located within the Collier County Water-Sewer District Boundary. Any
portions of this CPUD to be developed would be required to comply with Ordinance 2004-31, as it may
be amended. The project is subj ect to the conditions associated with a Water and Sewer Availability
Letter from the Collier County Utilities Division at the time SDP. According to Collier County
Gaspar Station PUD. PUDZ-2006-AR-10698 Staff Report
May 3, 2007 CCPC
Page 5 of 12
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27,2007
Page 17 of 127
Graphic Information System (GIS) information, a 20-inch water transmission main is located along
Immokalee Road, as is a 20-inch sewer transmission main.
Emerzencv Manazement: The Emergency Management Department has no issues with this CPUD.
The Gaspar Station CPUD is located in a CAT 3 hurricane surge zone and requires evacuation during
some hurricane events.
Zoning Review: As illustrated in the aerial photograph located on a previous page 0 f the staff report,
the surrounding zoning discussion of this staff report, and the Master Plan, the site is bordered by Juliet
Boulevard on the east, then a Wal-Mart superstore; on the north by Immokalee Road, then a residential
component of the Carlton Lakes project; to the west by two, approximately nine-acre, undeveloped
agriculturally zoned tracts controlled by one owner; and to the south by lands within Livingston Lakes
PUD, a residential project.
The project's location within the GMP FLUE/FLUM Urban Commercial District, Interchange Activity
Center Subdistrict, Activity Center #4 allows "the full array of commercial uses, residential and non-
residential uses, institutional uses, hotel/motel uses . . , and industrial uses [limited] . ,. in the
southwest quadrant. . . of Interchange Activity Center #4." Mixed Use Activity Centers, (a category
that includes Interchange Activity Centers) are ". . . designed to concentrate almost all new commercial
zoning in locations where traffic impacts can readily be accommodated, to avoid strip and disorganized
patterns of commercial development and to create focal points within the community." Commerical
uses at this site are appropriate. Given the smaller size of the parccl, the development intensity will be
limited to some extent by LDC requirements such as water management, parking, open space/preserve
and buffering requirements. However, an interconnection to the west is an integral element to the
Activity Center's smooth operation. As noted above, Activity Centers were established "to avoid strip
and disorganized patterns." Activity Centers are designed to provide commercial services to support
the surrounding residential areas, which should occur with the proposed CPUD. The residential
projects along the south side of Immokalee Road could benefit from the proximity of the commercial
services this CPUD will provide, and those residential projects should be afforded the safest access to
the site, which, in staffs opinion, would be an interconnection to the west.
Zoning staff believes the interconnection to the west should be provided on the Master Plan in
compliance with LDC Section 4.07.02 J.4--Design Standards for Planning Unit Developments, which
states:
The interconnection of collector and local streets within the PUD to adjacent lands or
developments shall be required except where determined by the County Manager or designee
that an interconnection is not feasible or warranted due to existing development patterns,
transportation network needs, or the like.
At the zoning stage, a notation on the Master Plan and a commitment in the CPUD document are all
that needs to be provided, The actual configuration or location of the interconnection need not be
determined. It is important to maintain the integrity and capacity of Immokalee Road by combining
access points and directing traffic to signals when possible. If the Gaspar Station project provides an
interconnection to the west, the traffic from the westerly tract could then access the signal at
Juliet/Strand Boulevard and Immokalee Road as shown on the next page.
Gaspar Station PUD, PUDZ-2006-AR-1 0698 Staff Report
May 3, 2007 CCPC
Page 6 of 12
Agenda Item No. 8e
November 27, 2007
Page 18 of 127
Currently there are two, approximately nine-acre tracts under common ownership located to the west of
the Gaspar Station CPUD. The parcels are zoned Agricultural, however given the parcels' Urban
Residential FLUM designation, it is not likely that agricultural uses will be pursued in the future. In all
likelihood, the tracts will be the subject of a rezoning to either RPUD or a conventional residential
zoning district. The parcels on the west of the two nine acre tracts are already zoned and developed
with multi-family dwelling units in the Eboli PUD (Ordinance 97-23) at a density of8.92 units per acre
and the April Circle PUD (Ordinance 89-76) at a density of 12.84 units per acre. Thus it is reasonable
to assume that the two, nine-acre tracts will ultimately seek rezoning to allow similar uses,
The Eboli PUD was required to provide an access easement along the Immokalee Road frontage for the
nine-acre parcel to the east of the Eboli PUD. A copy of the Master Plan for Eboli PUD is attached as
Exhibit "E." The access easement has been recorded and is provided as Exhibit "F." That nine-acre
tract is the westernmost half of the two, nine-acre tracts abutting the Gaspar Station CPUD. The aerial
photo on the previous page shows the Eboli PUD interconnection. The aerial photo shows how the
interconnections through the two, rune-acre tracts could interconnect through the Gaspar Station CPUD
to gain access to the traffic signal at Juliet Boulevard. Staff believes it is more appropriate to provide
residents living along the south side of Immokalee Road between this project and Livingston Road an
opportunity to access the commercial uses within the Gaspar Station project without requiring vehicles
to go onto Immokalee Road only to make a right turn within a short distance. Vehicles accessing
Immokalee Road then immediately turning right could cause confusion for drivers of following
vehicles as such a quick turn again might be unexpected. A westerly interconnection would be safer
and preserve the traffic volume on Immokalee Road for longer destination trips.
The petitioner's letters (cited previously and included in the application materials) contend that, "The
comprehensive plan guidance that encourages interconnections (of local streets) has already been
accomplished through the joint participation of four PUD developments." Staff assumes the reference
made is related to the interconnections shown on the Master Plan for the Donovan Center PUD and the
Gaspar Station PUD, PUDZ-2006-AR-10698 Staff Report
May 3. 2007 eepe
Page 7 of 12
Agenda Item No. 8e
November 27. 2007
Page 19 of 127
Livingston Lakes PUD for Juliet Boulevard. While staff understands the petitioner's position, the fact
that interconnections have been provided to the east do not obviate the need to provide interconnections
to the west.
The petitioner also asserts that an interconnection to the west should not be provided because it "
would be financially and functionally damaging to the site plan, in that land would be lost to the
reservation of a roadway R/W (whether ever built or not) that would otherwise be available for the
intended use. The site has already lost valuable land as a direct result of the expansion of lmmokalee
Road (twice) and to the joint access roadway." The participation in access improvements to serve this
project and the neighboring projects were development commitments agreed to by the petitioner as part
of the Stiles PUD rezoning (See Ordinance 97-74, Section PUD 4.6). That PUD was not developed
within the time allotted; therefore, Immokalee Road has been widened twice since that PUD was
approved in 1997. Furthermore, the petitioner did not develop the Stiles PUD within the timeframe
allotted in the LDC, thus that PUD sunsetted, Because the project's approval date exceeded 10 years,
(the Stiles PUD was originally rezoned to PUD in Ordinance 86-58). The project was required to
submit an entirely new rezoning petition, thence subjecting the project to further scrutiny in 'compliance
with today' s regulations.
Ordinance 86-58 also included development commitments and project descriptions indicating (PUD
Section 4.01.C.2) "The developer (of the Stiles PUD) would make fair contributions toward the capital
cost of a traffic signal at the project entrance when deemed warranted by the County Engineer." The
PUD language "highly recommended" that the developer provide an extension of the median opening
on Immokalee Road serving Regency Village, which is now known as the Pelican Strand PUD. In
Section 4.01.E of Ordinance 86-58, the following is stated: "To comply with the intent of the
Comprehensive Plan, the petitioner agrees to meet the following criteria: . . . 2) To provide an
integrated site plan which provides for integrated development of the parcel and its relationship to
surrounding land.. . .." In staffs opinion, it is inappropriate for the petitioner to argue that previous
commitments obviate the need to comply with current standards,
The petitioner has recorded a docwnent entitled, "Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, Easements
and Restrictions" has been recorded in the official records of Collier County that states: "Southern
Strand Boulevard [now known as Juliet Boulevard] shall remain private and shall not be dedicated to
public use. Use of Southern Strand Boulevard shall be limited to use by the Stiles PUD, Donovan PUD
and Breezewood PUD, and Southern Strand Blvd, shall not interconnect, either directly or indirectly to
any external road other than Immokalee Road." The applicant asserts that he therefore, cannot
interconnect to the property to the west because to do so would be in violation of the declaration.
Staff believes it is appropriate to require the interconnection to the west and has included that as a
stipulation of approval, recommending that the project be deemed inconsistent with the GMP and not in
compliance with the LDC unless the interconnection is provided. Staff does not believe the petitioner
has proven "that an interconnection is not .feasible or warranted due to existing development pattems,
transportation network needs" in compliance with LDC Section 4.07.02 J.4--Design Standards for
Planning Unit Developments.
The development standards contained in Section III of the CPUD document reflect a design approach
similar to what was approved in 1997, except the petitioner has added setbacks to the preserve areas
and showed the location of the preserves on the Master Plan.
Gaspar Station PUD, PUDZ-2006-AR-10698 Staff Report
May 3, 2007 CCPC
Page 8 of 12
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27,2007
Page 20 of 127
FLUE Policy 5.4 requires new land uses to be compatible with the surrounding area. Zoning and Land
Development Review staff reviews for compliance with this requirement as part of the review of the
petition in its entirety. The typical compatibility analysis would include a review of both the subject
proposal and surrounding or nearby properties as to allowed use intensities and densities, development
standards (building heights, setbacks, landscape buffers, etc,), building mass, building location and
orientation, architectural features, amount and type of open space and location, traffic
generation/attraction, etc.
The adjacent tract to the east is developed as a Wal-Mart superstore; the parcel to the south (outside the
Interchange Activity Center) is developing with residential uses (Livingston Lakes PUD); the parcels to
the west, as noted above are agriculturally zoned and undeveloped at this time but within an Urban
GMP FLUM designation; to the north is Immokalee Road and then residential uses within two PUD-
zoned projects. The preserve area shown on the Master Plan for Gaspar Station will "buffer" the
commercial uses of Gaspar Station from the residential uses within Livingston Lakes PUD. The
preserve area has been shown at this location to coincide with the preserve area provided on the
Livingston Lakes PUD.
The Stiles PUD preserve area location was a disputed issue during the review of an application to
extend the PUD (PUDEX-2004-AR-5296). Staff advised the petitioner's agent that staff would not
support a request for an extension, believing that an extension would not be appropriate because the
PUD and its Master Plan would not be in compliance with LDC Section 10.02.13,D.6.b.i. and ii. that
state:
Approval of an extension shall be based on the following:
i. The PUD and the master plan is consistent with the current growth management plan
including, but not limited to, density, intensity and concurrency requirements;
ii. The approved development has not become incompatible with existing and proposed uses
in the surrounding area as the result of development approvals issued subsequent to the
original approval of the PUD zoning;.
Current environmental standards would require the preserve areas to be depicted on the Master Plan.
Such was not case when the PUD was approved. Additionally, the Master Plan approved with
Ordinance 97-74 indicated that the land to the south was zoned agriculturally and was undeveloped.
Livingston Lakes PUD was rezoned from that agricultural zoning district to PUD in Ordinance 99-18
on February 23,1999 to allow for a maximum of 327 multifamily dwelling units, Staff was concerned
about the compatibility of the two projects. Additionally, Livingston Lakes PUD Master Plan shows a
preserve area abutting the Stiles PUD. Current LDC standards require preservation areas to be set aside
in a contiguous fashion when possible. The Stiles PUD Master Plan did not accommodate that
standard. That PUD extension request was deemed withdrawn by staff due to inactivity,
The Master Plan, showing the required preserve area contiguous to the preserve area of the Livingston
Lakes PUD, resolves staffs concerns about the residential and commercial incompatibility. Therefore,
staff believes the proposed use is compatible with the neighborhood and thus consistent with GMP
Policy 5.4,
NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING (NIM):
The agentJapplicant duly noticed and held the required NIM on January 31, 2007 at the North Naples
Regional Park, Room A-3 at 5:30 p.m. The applicant's team and county staff were present and
Gaspar Station PUD. PUDZ-2006-AR-10698 Staff Report
May 3, 2007 CCPC
Page 9 of 12
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 21 of 127
initially, one person from the public attended. At approximately 5:50 p.m., two neighboring property
owners who identified themselves as "Strand" residents, walked in and began to comment and ask
questions of the agent(s), saying "You're ruining our property values. We don't want Target, we don't
want Wal-Mart, we don't want a Burger King; we don't want a gas station", Mrs, Rochelle Dowling
said she "opposes more commercial" and another comment was made, "More commercial will add to
the failing of ImmokaJee Road". Another resident asked questions relative to traffic impacts and
planning for the Wal-Mart store, to which Jeff Perry responded, "(there is) no substantial change to
traffic impacts as it relates to this petition", Project planner for the county, Kay Deselem, invited the
neighboring property owners to her office to discuss the transportation (traffic) review on the petition,
It was also stated by Mr. Perry that the current operating level oflmmokalee Road is at "D". Mr. Bruce
Anderson said that there are "no changes to the permitted use(s) in the PUD and development standards
will be brought up to current county codes". It was also stated that "no retail building would be more
than 35 feet in height" and there is a "60 feet height limitation on hotel uses". After further
conversation, a neighboring property owners said, "I'm not opposed to a nice upscale restaurant or
office building. Please be sensitive to beauty, to enhance the appearance of North Naples." Several
comments were also made regarding the need for children's playgrounds in developments. Ms.
Deselem explained that "playgrounds" are not required by county code in individual developments.
Mr, Craig Timmons, identifying himself as a realtor representing the land owner, responded to a
question regarding tenants by saying, "there are no leases at this time", The meeting concluded at
approximately 7:00 p.m. Synopsis provided by Linda Bedtelyon, Community Planning Coordinator
ENVIRONMENTAL ADVISORY COUNCIL lEAn RECOMMENDATION:
The Environmental Advisory Commission (EAC) heard this petition on April 4, 2007, and voted
unanimously to approve it with the following stipulation: The lake shape and final size will be
determined at the site development plan stage; however the lake must remain adjacent to the preserve
area.
RECOMMENDATION:
Zoning and Land Development Review staff recommends that the Collier County Planning
Commission (CCPC) forward Petition PUDZ-2006-AR-10698 to the Board of County Commissioners
(BCC) with a recommendation of approval of the rezoning request subject to the following stipulations:
1. The petitioner must revise the Master Plan to show an interconnection to the lvest will be
provided; and
2. The following lang1wge shall be inserted into the developer commitments section of the
PUD document:
This project shall provide an interconnection to the west. The developer or assigns of this
project shall ensure that the interconnection can be utilized and, furthermore, the developer
shall accommodate the pe/petual use of such access by incOIporating appropriate language
into the development covenants or plats. The final configuration and location of the
interconnection shall be determined by Collier County Transportation staff prior to the
issuance of any development approval on this site,
Gaspar Station PUD. PUDZ-2006-AR-10698 Staff Report
May 3, 2007 CCPC
Page 10 of 12
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 22 of 127
PREPARED BY:
KAY DESELEM, AICP, PRINCIPAL PLANNER
DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
DATE
REVIEWED BY:
MARJORIE M. STUDENT-STIRLING
ASSISTANT COUNTY ATTORNEY
DATE
RAYMOND V, BELLOWS, ZONING MANAGER
DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
DATE
SUSAN MURRAY, AICP, DIRECTOR
DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
DATE
APPROVED BY:
JOSEPH K. SCHMITT ADMINISTRATOR DATE
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION
Tentatively scheduled for the June 12, 2006 Board of County Commissioners Meeting
Gaspar Station PUD, PUDZ-2006-AR-10698 Staff Report
May 3. 2007 CCPC
Page 110112
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION:
MARK P. STRAIN, CHAIRMAN
Exhibits: A. Rezone Findings
B. PUD Findings
C. Comprehensive Planning Memo, dated December 4, 2006
D. EAC Staff Report
E. Eboli PUD Master Plan
F. Access Easement
Gaspar Station PUD, PUDZ-2006-AR-10698 Staff Report
May 3, 2007 CCPC
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 23 of 127
DATE
Page 12 of 12
u"-"- QL- 3I.....J.QGIJ{I ~I
COON -
~~
a gl
,......,\J~
.$ ill ill ..,
-..00>
",~ro
-0"0- J
cO)
QJ>
0
gz ~I a..
<C
~
C>
" . Z
-
Z
.) 0
N
i " a:1
,
.
e
~ '"
'"
'"
~ I '" 0
~.i ~
~ ' " " . ,
c::
, ' g i <
~ ' ,
" z I ~l '"
0
""" """",,0 0
'"
N
-~= / I:- Cl
::l
a.
..
1,1 I II ~ z
IE" j. l i~'i 0
'i~[] ~ . B, !::
1- . "
. ~ ' ;! <Ii! . 'i ....
I I UJ
a.
-~-
~ I! ! ! ~
z
co tz i, i. I a..
0 ~~ ~ . I . Ii
u ~i wQ ~~; f;li~ ;i.
~- ,!< I I i <C
w 00 I~
w g:g ~ ~
--' ~~
lI."1IJ.VlJIlBlM
IL";;UVlmBIJlJ ~ Z
Iii . I~ B. 0
!i- " ~;
. ! ~E ~ -
I-
<C
Ii II ()
ng. II 0
" .....J
!l
i ! Is
I '~ ~!~
~ i I -
~!P i~ ~
4 I !l
..... -
,~""
--"'--'-"~--
, .._,----,- ..~~.., ~_."".,.....__."_.-...-
'..._~.__._._--
--~---
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 25 of 127
Exhibit A
REZONE FINDINGS
PETITION PUDZ-2006-AR-10698
Chapter IO,03.05.G of the Collier County Land Development Code (LDC) requires that the report and
recommendations of the Planning Commission to the Board of County Commissioners show that the
Planning Commission has studied and considered the proposed change in relation to the following,
where applicable:
1. Whether the proposed change will be consistent with the goals, objectives, and policies of
the Future Land Use Element (FLUE) and Future Land Use Map and the elements of the
Growth Management Plan (GMP).
Pro: County staff has reviewed this petition and has offered an in-depth analysis (see staff
report) of the relevant goals, objectives and policies of the Conservation & Coastal
Management Element, the Future Land Use Element and the Transportation Element of the
GMP offering a recommendation that this petition be found consistent with the overall GMP if
staffs stipulations are incorporated into the approval recommendation.
Con: If staffs recommended stipulations are not included, traffic circulation on Immokalee
Road could be unnecessarily compromised.
Findings: Based upon staffs recommendation with stipulations, the proposed development is
in compliance with the Future Land Use Element (FLUE) of the Growth Management Plan
(GMP) for Collier County and all other relevant goals, objectives and policies ofthe GMP,
2. The existing land use pattern.
Pro: The explanation of the request in the staff report and the location and zoning map that is
attached to the staffreport show the proposed rezoning is a reiteration of two previous rezoning
approvals for the same parcel to allow the same uses.
Con: None.
Finding: Staff believes the proposed rezone is a logical and appropriate recommendation.
3. The possible creation of an isolated district unrelated to adjacent and nearby districts.
Pro/Con: Evaluation not applicable,
Findings: Staff believes the proposed rezoning is a reiteration of two previous rezoning
approvals for the same parcel to allow the same uses thus approval is an appropriate action.
4. Whether existing district boundaries are illogically drawn in relation to existing
conditions on the property proposed for change.
Pro/Con: Evaluation not applicable.
Findings: The district boundaries are logically drawn as discussed in Items 3 and 4 above.
Page 1 of 5
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 26 of 127
5. Whether changed or changing conditions make the passage of the proposed land use
change necessary.
Pro: The proposed change is necessary because LDC Section 10.02.13.D.7 does not allow the
County to accept applications for development order approvals until the zoning is "updated."
Additionally, the petitioner has updated the Master Plan to show the required preserve area
contiguous to the preserve area in the neighboring Livingston Lakes PUD project.
Con: The perceived higher intensity versus undeveloped land may not coincide with the nearby
property owners' perception of the area's potential development.
Findings: The proposed zoning change is appropriate based on the existing conditions of the
property and because its relationship to the FLUE (Future Land Use Element of the GMP) is
positive.
6. Whether the proposed change will adversely influence living conditions in the
neighborhood.
Pro: The County's current land use policies in the FLUE support the proposed action and the
proposed use is not contrary to the CUD'ent land use policies if staff's stipulations are included
in any approval recommendation. The proposed amendment should not adversely influence
living conditions because the use proposed are consistent with the uses proposed for
Interchange Activity Centers,
Con: The perceived higher intensity versus undeveloped land may not coincide with the nearby
property owners' perception of the area's potential development.
Findings: The proposed change should not adversely influence living conditions in the
neighborhood because the preserve area's location will help buffer the only adjacent residential
uses.
7. Whether the proposed change will create or excessively increase traffic congestion or
create types of traffic deemed incompatible with surrounding land uses because of peak
volumes or projected types of vehicular traffic, including activity during construction
phases of the development, or otherwise affect public safety.
Pro: Development of the subject property is consistent with provisions of the Transportation
Element of the GMP and the trips are vested according to Transportation Planning staff (refer
to the discussion in the staff report, The trips were vested as part of the Stiles PUD zoning.
However Transportation Planning staff notes that although this PUD is considered vested by
Transportation Planning staff, the PUD remains subject to operational analysis at the time of
subsequent development order application, Staff has included stipulations to require this
project to provide an interconnection to the west; if staff s stipulation is adopted as part of any
approval recommendation, this project should not create types of traffic deemed incompatible
with surrounding land uses and it should not affect the public safety,
Exhibit A
REZONE FINDINGS
PETITION PUDZ-2006-AR-10698
Page 2 of 5
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27. 2007
Page 27 of 127
Con: The perceived higher intensity versus undeveloped land may not coincide with the nearby
property owners' perception of the area's potential development.
Findings: Evaluation of this project took into account the requirement for consistency with the
Traffic Element of the GMP and the project was found consistent. Additionally, certain
transportation improvements are included in the PUD document.
8. Whether the proposed change will create a drainage problem.
Pro: Road improvements precipitated by this development and water management
improvements to accommodate site development are designed to accommodate the normal
drainage requirement and are already in place for the most part.
Con: Urban intensification could potentially increase area-wide flooding in a severe rainfall
event.
Findings: Every project approved in Collier County involving the utilization of land for some
land use activity is scrutinized and required to mitigate all sub-surface drainage generated by
developmental activities,
9. Whether the proposed change will seriously reduce light and air to adjacent areas.
Pro: The proposed development standards will ensure that adequate light and air is allowed to
adjacent properties,
Con: None.
Findings: All projects in Collier County are subject to the development standards that are
unique to the zoning district in which it is located. These development standards and others
apply generally and equally to all zoning districts (i.e, open space requirement, corridor
management provisions, etc.) were designed to ensure that light penetration and circulation of
air does not adversely affect adjacent areas,
10. Whether the proposed change will adversely affect property values in the adjacent area.
Pro/Con: Evaluation not applicable.
Findings: This is a subjective determination based upon anticipated results which may be
internal or external to the subject property, and which can affect property values. Property
valuation is affected by a host of factors including zoning; however, zoning by itself mayor
may not affect values, since value determination by law is driven by market value
11. Whether the proposed change will be a deterrent to the improvement or development of
adjacent property in accordance with existing regulations.
Exhibit A
REZONE FINDINGS
PETITION PUDZ-2006-AR-10698
Page 3 of 5
Agenda Item No. 8e
November 27,2007
Page 28 of 127
Pro/Con: Evaluation not applicable.
Findings: The basic premise underlying all of the development standards in the Land
Development Code is that their sound application, when combined with the site development
plan approval process and/or subdivision process, gives reasonable assurance that a change in
zoning will not result in deterrence to improvement or development of adjacent property.
12. Whether the proposed change will constitute a grant of special privilege to an individual
owner as contrasting with the public welfare.
Pro/Con: Evaluation not applicable.
Findings: The proposed development complies with the Growth Management Plan (as
stipulated by staff), a public policy statement supporting Zoning actions when they are
consistent with said Comprehensive Plan, In light of this fact, the proposed change does not
constitute a grant of special privilege. Consistency with the FLUE is further determined to be a
public welfare relationship because actions consistent with plans are in the public Interest.
13. Whether there are substantial reasons why the property cannot be used in accordance
with existing zoning.
Pro: The proposed change is necessary because LDC Section 10.02.13.0.7 does not allow the
County to accept applications for development order approvals until the zoning is "updated,"
Con: None.
Findings: Any petition for a change in land use is reviewed for compliance with the GMP and
the LDC with the Board of County Commissioners ultimately ruling what uses and density or
intensity is approved or, on the contrary, if the petition is denied. This petitioner is proceeding
through the proper channels to gamer that Board ruling.
14. Whether the change suggested is out of scale with the needs of the neighborhood or the
County;
Pro: StaffbeJieves this rezoning request proposes changes that are within the scale of the needs
of the neighborhood and County.
Con: None.
Findings: The proposed development complies with the Growth Management Plan (as
stipulated), a policy statement which has evaluated the scale, density and intensity of land uses
deemed to be acceptable throughout the urban designated areas of Collier County.
15. Whether it is impossible to find other adequate sites in the County for the proposed use in
districts already permitting such use.
Exhibit A
REZONE FINDINGS
PETITION PUDZ-2006-AR-10698
Page 4 of 5
Agenda Item No. 8e
November 27.2007
Page 29 of 127
Pro/Con: Evaluation not applicable.
Findings: Because the petitioner is seeking update a sunsetted PUD, this analysis IS not
germane to this petition,
16. The physical characteristics of the property and the degree of site alteration which wonld
be required to make the property usable for any of the range of potential uses under the
proposed zoning classification.
Pro: None perceived.
Con: The subj ect property in this PUD rezoning is undeveloped at this time.
Findings: Any development of this site would require considerable site alteration with the
proposed use of this portion of the site.
17. The impact of development on the availability of adequate public facilities and services
consistent with the levels of service adopted in the Collier County Growth Management
Plan and as defined and implemented through the Collier County LDC regarding
Adequate Public Facilities.
Pro/Con: Evaluation not applicable.
Findings: A multi-disciplined team responsible for reviewing jurisdictional elements of the
GMP and the LDC public facilities requirements has reviewed this land use petition and found
it consistent and in compliance for zoning approval. A final determination whether this project
meets the full requirements of adequate public facilities specifications will be determined as
part of the development approval process.
Exhibit A
REZONE FINDINGS
PETITION PUDZ-2006-AR-10698
Page 5 of 5
Exhibit B
PUD FINDINGS
PUDZ-2006-AR-10698
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27. 2007
Page 30 of 127
Section IO.02.13.B.5 of the LDC of the Collier County Land Development Code requires the Planning
Commission to make a finding as to the PUD Master Plan's compliance with the following criteria:
1. The suitability of the area for the type and pattern of development proposed in relation
to physical characteristics of the land, surrounding areas, traffic and access, drainage,
sewer, water, and other utilities.
Pro: The nearby area is developed or is approved for development of a similar nature. The
petitioner will be required to comply with all county regulations regarding drainage, sewer,
water and other utilities,
Con: None.
Finding: The stipulations included in the PUD document adequately address the impacts
from the proposed amendment.
2. Adequacy of evidence of unified control and suitability of any proposed agreements,
contracts, or other instruments, or for amendments in those proposed, particularly as
they may relate to arrangements or provisions to be made for the continuing operation
and maintenance of such arcas and facilities that are not to be provided or maintained
at pu blic expense.
Pro/Con: Evaluation not applicable.
Finding: Documents submitted with the application provided evidence of unified control.
The PUD document makes appropriate provisions for continuing operation and maintenance
of common areas,
3. Conformity of the proposed Planned Unit Development with the goals, objectives, and
policies of the Growth Management Plan (GMP).
Pro: County staff has reviewed this petition and has offered an analysis (see staff report) of
the relevant goals, objectives and policies of the GMP offering a recommendation that this
petition be found consistent with the overall GMP with the stipulations recommended by
staff.
Con: Staff's analysis is subjective. Many of the goals, objective and policies do no have
quantative means to measure compliance. The GMP Transportation Element Policies 5.1 and
9.3 contain measurable components; however, FLUE Policy 5.4 does not. Compatibility is
more subjective.
Finding: Staff has recommended that the subject petition has been found consistent with the
goals, objectives and policies of the GMP with staff's stipulations as provided for in the
adopting ordinance, Please see the staff report for a more detailed discussion,
Page 1 of 3
Agenda Item No. 8e
November 27. 2007
Page 31 of 127
4. The internalllnd external compatibility of proposed uses, which conditions may include
restrictions on location of improvements, restrictions on design, and buffering and
screening requirements.
Pro: The proposed development standards, landscaping and buffering requirements are
designed to make the proposed residential uses compatible with the adjacent residential uses,
Con: None.
Finding: Staff analysis as contained in the staff report indicates that this pel1l1on is
compatible, both internally and externally, with the proposed uses and with the existing
surrounding uses.
5. The adequacy of usable open space areas in existence and as proposed to serve the
development.
Pro/Con: Evaluation not applicable,
Finding: The amount of open space set aside by this project is consistent with the provisions
of the Land Development Code.
6. The timing or sequence of development for the purpose of assuring the adequacy of
available improvements and facilities, both public and private.
Pro/Con: Evaluation not applicable,
Finding: Timing or sequence of development in light of concurrency requirements does not
appear to be a significant problem as part of the PUD amendment process, but the project's
development must be in compliance with applicable concurrency management regulations
when development approvals are sought.
7. The ability of the subject property and of surrounding areas to accommodate
expansion.
Pro: County Transportation Planning staff has determined that the proposed amendment is
consistent with the GMP Transportation Element requirements addressing roadway concerns
if staffs stipulations are included in any recommendation of approval.
Con: None.
Finding: If "ability" implies supporting infrastructure such as wastewater disposal system,
potable water supplies, characteristics of the property relative to hazards, and capacity of
roads, then the subject property has the ability to support expansion based upon the
commitments made by the petitioner and the fact that adequate public facilities requirements
will be addressed when development approvals are sought.
PUD FINDINGS
PUDZ-2006-AR-10698
Exhibit B
Page 2 of 3
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 32 of 127
8. Conformity with PUD regulations, or as to desirable modifications of such regulations
in the particular case, based on determination that such modifications are justified as
meeting public purposes to a degree at least equivalent to literal application of such
regulations.
Pro/Con: Not applicable.
Finding: This criterion essentially requires an evaluation of the extent to which development
standards and deviations proposed for this PUD depart from development standards that
would be required for the most similar conventional zoning district. The development
standards in this PUD are similar to those standards and the petitioner is not seeking any
deviations.
PUD FINDINGS
PUDZ-2006-AR-10698
Exhibit B
Page 3 of 3
Aaenda Item No. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 33 of 127
Co~-y Count:y
-
Memorandum
To:
Kay Deselem, AICP, Principal Planner, Zoning and Land Development Review
From:
Sue Trone, Planner, Comprehensive Planning
Date:
December 4, 2006
Subject:
Future Land Use Element (FLUE) Consistency Review
PETITION NUMBER: PUDA-2006-AR-I0698
PETITION NAME: Gaspar Station PUD
LOCATION: The subject site is located in Section 30, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, Collier
County, Florida. It takes up 17. H acres of land, The project site is on the south side of Immokalee
Road and is approximately one quarter mile west of the 1-75/lmmokalee Road intersection, The
project has indirect access onto Immokalee Road via an existing entry road (Juliet Boulevard) with a
median opening that aligns with the approved Strand PUD to the north.
REQUEST: The project is currently zoned PUD as a planned interchange commercial center which
includes a mixture of interchange-oriented commercial facilities, predominantly including restaurants,
various types of retail (e.g. clothing stores, home supplies stores, hardware stores, and grocery stores),
and office uses (e.g, real estate, law offices, veterinary offices, and business services). Additionally
the project includes land uses to accommodate stom1 water management, lakes and buffer areas, The
petitioner is requesting to develop this PUD for general commercial uses and to rename the PUD to
Gaspar Station.
COMPREHENSIVE PLANNING COMMENTS: The subject property is designated Urban
Commercial District, Interchange Activity Center Subdistrict, Activity Center #4, as identified on the
Future Land Use Map of the Growth Management Plan. It is located within the Northwest
Transportation Concurrency Management Area (TCMA). The County has confirmed that the level of
service criteria for the Northwest TCMA in the LDC are being met; however, Comprehensive Planning
staff defers to Transportation Planning staff for a more detailed review.
The Future Land Use Element (FLUE) of the Growth Management Plan (GMP) dedicates roughly a
page and a half to guidelines for Interchange Activity Centers (pages 44-45). Comprehensive Planning
comments are primarily limited to the factors for consideration during review of rezone petitions as
enumerated by a bulleted list on page 41,1 of the FLUE, Text from the FLUE is represented below in
italics and staff comments follow in bold.
1. Rezones within Mixed Use Activity Centers are encouraged to be in the form of a Planned Unit
Development. There shall be no minimum acreage limitation for such Planned Unit
1
Exhibit C
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 34 of 127
Developments except all requests for rezoning must meet the requirements for rezoning in the
Land Development Code.
The rezone is a PUD to PUD at 17.7010 acres. This is consistent.
2. The amount, type and location of existing zoned commercial land, and developed commercial
uses, within the Mixed use Activity Center and within two road miles of the Mixed Use Activity
Center.
This information is not required; existing approved commercial uses are consistent with
proposed commercial uses.
3. Market demand and service area for the proposed commercial land uses to be used as a guide
to explore the feasibility of the requested land uses.
A market-demand is not required because commercial uses proposed are generally consistent
with approved commercial uses.
4, Existing patterns of land use within the Mixed Use Activity Center and within two radial miles.
Within the Project Site: Currently the area is vacant but it has been zoned for commercial uses.
Adjacent to the Proiect Site in the Southwest Ouadrant of the Activity Center: there are parcels
with various zoning designations:
To the east of the subject site but within the Interchange Activity Center is the
Donavan Center PUD containing 250,000 square feet of commercial uses and 140
multi-family units.
Outside the Interchange Activity Center but within two radial miles to the west of the
subject site is a parcel zoned Agricultural which is vacant. Given this land's
proximity to 1-17 and its urban designation it is very likely that this land will be
rezoned and developed. While it is not possible now to know how this adjacent parcel
will be developed the petitioner may want to take into consideration various
possibilities when planning the buffer between the parcels.
Outside the Interchange Activity Center but within two radial miles to the south of the
subject site is the Livingston Lakes PUD with 327 multi-family units.
In the Remainder of the Activity Center: are the following developments with respective uses
and zoning designations:
- In the Northwest Quadrant is the Pelican Strand PUD. Total area: 574.56 acres;
200,000 square foot commercial; 237 single-family units; 804 multi-family units;
187.3 acres golf course.
- In the Northeast Quadrant is Northbrooke Plaza PUD. Total area: 39.90 acres;
270,000 square foot commercial; 120 singe-family units; 130 mobile home.
- In the Southeast Quadrant is the Malibu Lake PUD with 178.6 acres for Mixed
Use.
Within two radial miles of the Project Site and Outside the Activity Center: zoning designations
can be found as noted below.
- Agricultural (841 acres)
Commercial (45 acres)
Estates (1,255)
2
Exhibit C
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 35 of 127
Golf Course (618 acres)
Mixed Use PUD (178 acres)
PUD (8575 acres)
Residential Multi-Family (147 acres)
RPUD (51 acres)
Residential Single-Family (2,055 acres)
- Residential Tourist (2 acres)
5, Adequacy of infrastructure capacity. particularly roads.
According to the Transportation Impact Statement, all roadways within the project's area of
influence are currently operating at acceptable levels of service and are expected to operate at
acceptable levels of service through build out of the project (2008). Further, the project appears
to have no significant impact on any County or State roads. Comprehensive Planning Staff
defers to Transportation Planning Staff for a finding of project consistency with regard to these
measures.
Water distribution and sewage collection and transmission and related facilities are to be
designed, constructed, conveyed, owned and maintained by Collier County. Comprehensive
Planning Staff defers to Utilities for a finding of project consistency with regard to these
measures.
6. Compatibility of the proposed development ,,7th. and adequacy of buffering for, adjoining
properties,
The purposes of the planned development fall into the full array of commercial uses (this
includes SIC 6552 which Ray Bellows, Zoning Manager, has reviewed and found to be consistent
with commercial zoning, documented in an email dated December 4, 2006.).
7. Natural or man-made constraints.
Based on observation of the subject site from aerial photographs, the site has not been cleared;
there appear to be no natural or man-made constraints.
8. Rezoning criteria identified in the Land Development Code.
This is provided for in the PUD rezone application. Further, these criteria will be reviewed by
the Zoning and Land Development Review staff.
9. Conformance with Access Management Plan provisions for Mixed Use Activity Centers
contained in the Land Development Code.
This is provided for on the PUD Master Plan. Further, Transportation Planning staff will
review the project for conformance with this LDC provision.
10. Coordinated traffic flow on-site and off-site, as may be demonstrated by a Traffic Impact
Analysis, and a site plan/ master plan indicating on-site traffic movements, access point
locations and type, median opening locations and type on the abutting roadway(s), location of
traffic signals on the abutting roadway(s), and internal and external vehicular and pedestrian
interconnections.
3
Exhibit C
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 36 of 127
This is provided for in the Traffic Impact Statement and the PUD Master Plan. Comprehensive
Planning staff further defer to Transportation Planning staff for more detailed review.
11. Interconnection(s) for pedestrians, bicycles and motor vehicles with existing and future
adjacent projects,
The two access points to Juliet Boulevard allow vehicular access to adjaceut commercial
activities. Construction of sidewalks east of the project site would provide convenient access for
pedestrians. Comprehensive Planning staff further defer to Transportation Planning staff for
more detailed review.
12. Conformance with the architectural design standards as identified in the Land Development
Code.
The Developer intends to establish project-wide guidelines and standards to ensure a high and
consistent level of quality for the proposed land uses. Uniform guidelines and standards will be
created for such features and facilities as landscaping, sign age, lighting, roadway treatments,
fences, walls, buffers, and similar features as indicated in the POO document, Section II, 2.5.C.
Comprehensive Planning staff defers to Zoning and Land Development Review staff for more
detailed review.
FLUE Objective 7 and associated Policies encourages shared access and project interconnections. The
applicant is encouraged to implement appropriate Policies under this Objective that support smart
growth, including walkability and interconnections with adjoining properties. Namely, the addition of
sidewalks would enable pedestrian access to (and along) Juliet Boulevard.
FLUE Policy 504 provides all rezoning must be compatible with the Growth Management Plan.
Comprehensive Planning leaves the determination of compatibility to the Zoning and Land
Development Review staff as part of their review of the petition in its totality.
REVIEW OF THE PUD MASTER PLAN AND PUD DOCUMENT:
. Revise Paragraph I on page ii from reading "Interstate Activity Center Subdistrict" to
"Interchange Activity Center Subdistrict" in both instances and anywhere else where this term
may appear (it is correctly referenced on page I-I, IA.B.).
. A selection from Section I, 1 A.A. reads: "The project has direct access onto Immokalee Road
via an existing entry road (Juliet Boulevard) with a median opening that aligns with the
approved Strand PUD to the north." Section V, 5.2,B. reads: "Access to all parcels fronting
Immokalee Road shall be from the main entrance road with no direct driveway access from
each parcel to Immokalee Road." Based on the first quote and the Master Plan it appears that
the "main entrance road" of the second quote is, in fact, Juliet Boulevard, Please clarify this
point and, if this "main entrance road" is some other road contact staff immediately.
. The project is located within the Northwest Transportation Concurrency Management Area
(TCMA). According to Policy 2.5 of the FLUE these areas are designated by the County to
"encourage compact urban development where an integrated and connected network of roads is
in place that provide multiple, viable alternative travel paths or modes for common trips"
4
Exhibit C
Agenda Item No. Be
Novembsr 27. 2007
Page 37 of 127
(FLUE Policy 2.5, page 12.1). As such, Transportation Planning staff have devised levels of
service standards that, according to the Transportation Impact Statement (TIS), appear to have
been met at the time the TIS was written. FLUE Objectives 5 and 6 have implications for
projects in TCMAs to mitigate urban sprawl, protect environmentally sensitive lands and native
habitat, and promote adequate facilities - especially for transportation circulation. Address the
fact that this development is to occur in a TCMA and how you plan to address FLUE
Objectives 5 and 6 in the Statement of Compliance,
CONCLUSION: Based on the above analvsis the proposed development oithe GASPAR STATION PUD is
consistent with the GMP.
On CD Plus
Cc: Randall Cohen, AICP, Comprehensive Planning Director
David Weeks, AICP, Comprehensive Planning Manager
Susan Murray, AICP, Zoning and Land Development Review Director
Ray Bellows, Zoning and Land Development Review Manager
5
Exhibit C
Agenda Item No. 8e
November 27. 2007
Page 38 of 127
Item VI.A.
ENVIRONMENTAL ADVISORY COUNCIL
STAFF REPORT
MEETING OF April 4. 2007
I. NAME OF PETITIONER/PROJECT
Petition No.:
Petition Name:
Applicant/Developer:
Engineering Consultant:
Environmental Consultant:
PUDZ-2006-AR-10698
Gaspar Station PUD
A. GROVER MATHENEY
WILSONMILLER, INe.
WILSONMILLER, INe.
II. LOCATION
The subject property, consisting of 17.7'" acres, is located on the south side of
Immokalee Road (CR 846), approximately one quarter mile west of the 1-
75/Immokalee Road, interchange, in Section 30, Township 48 South, Range 26
East, Collier County, Florida.
III. DESCRIPTION OF SURROUNDING PROPERTIES
ZONING
DESCRIPTION
N- PUD
Immokalee Road then Carlton Lakes PUD, approved
at a density of 3.35 units per acre
S- PUD
Livingston Lakes, a developing residential project,
approved at 7 units per acre
E- PUD
Donovan Center PUD, developed as a Wal-Mart
superstore and Summer Lakes residential project,
approved at 6.64 units per acre
W - Agriculture
an undeveloped approximately nine acre tract
IV. PROJECT DESCRIPTION
The proposed CPUD, if approved, will allow for retail and service uses at a rate of
7,500 square feet per gross acre, office uses at a rate of 15,000 square feet per
gross acre and hotel/motel use at a rate of 26 units per gross acre. The PUD
Gaspar Station CPUD
PUDZ-2006-AR-10698
Exhibit D
EAC Meeting
Page 2 of7
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 39 of 127
allows for a mix of Interchange Commercial (as described m the Growth
Management Plan [GMPJ),
The project is bordered by Juliet Boulevard on the east, and a Wal-Mart; on the
north by Immokalee Road and Carlton Lakes; to the west by an approximately
nine-acre, undeveloped agriculturally zoned tract; and to the south by lands within
Livingston Lakes PUD, a residential project. The subject property is cwrently
undeveloped. The PUD document and the Master Plan indicate the project will
not have access directly to Immokalee Road; access to the site will be via Juliet
Boulevard,
V. GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN CONSISTENCY
A. Future Land Use Element
The subject property is designated Urban Commercial District, Interchange
Activity Center Subdistrict, and Activity Center #4, as identified on the Future
Land Use Map of the Growth Management Plan, It is located within the
Northwest Transportation Concurrency Management Area (TCMA). The County
has confirmed that the level of service criteria for the Northwest TCMA in the
LDC are being met; however, the final determination of concwrency will be done
during the site development plan process.
The Future Land Use Element (FLUE) of the Growth Management Plan (GMP)
provides guidelines for Interchange Activity Centers. Comprehensive Planning
staff analyzed those guidelines and believes this petition can be deemed consistent
with the guidelines for Interchange Activity.
B. Conservation & Coastal Manal!ement Element
Objective 2.2 of the Conservation and Coastal Management Element of the
Growth Management Plan states "All canals, rivers, and flow ways discharging
into estuaries shall meet all applicable federal, state, or local water quality
standards,
To accomplish that, policy 2,2.2 states "In order to limit the specific and
cumulative impacts of storm water runoff, storm water systems should be designed
in such a way that discharged water does not degrade receiving waters and an
attempt is made to enhance the timing, quantity, and quality of fresh water
( discharge) to the estuarine system.
This project is consistent with the objectives of policy 2.2.2 in that it attempts to
mimic or enhance the quality and quantity of water leaving the site by utilizing
interconnected dry detention areas and a wetland to provide water quality
retention and peak flow attenuation during storm events.
The Gaspar Station project will preserve its required amount of native vegetation.
Gaspar Station CPUD
PUDZ-2006-AR-10698
Exhibit 0
EAC Meeting
Page 3 of7
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27.2007
Page 40 of 127
No submerged marine habitats are proposed for impact and the site is not
contiguous to natural reservations. Habitat management and exotic vegetation
removal/maintenance plans will be required at site development plan submittal
and have been provided as part of the EIS. Preserve areas shall be required to be
maintained free of Category I invasive exotic plants, as defined by the Florida
Exotic Pest Plant Council.
The proposed preserve area is located along the southern boundary of the site
allowing for interconnection to the adjoining off-site preserve area located on the
Livingston Lakes PUD, Littoral shelf planting areas within the wet detention
pond shall be required at the time of Site Development Plan submittal, and will be
required to meet the minimum planting area requirement in Policy 6.1.7.
Jurisdictional wetlands have been identified as required by Policies 6.2,1 and
6.2,2.
In accordance with Policy 6.2.6, required preservation areas have been identified
on the PUD Master Plan. Activities detrimental to preserve areas have been
excluded from the preserve as required by the conservation easement. Use within
the preserve areas are in accordance with Policy 6.2.5(5)(d). Uses within the
preserve areas shall not include any activity detrimental to drainage, flood
control, water conservation, erosion control, or fish and wildlife conservation, and
preservation.
The proposed project is not located within the Conservation Designation on the
Future Land Use Map, the Big Cypress Area of Critical State Concern, the
Natural Resources Protection Area, Sending Lands, or Habitat Stewardship
Areas.
A wildlife survey for listed species in accordance with Policy 7.1.2 is
included in this EIS. No adverse impacts to potential listed species are
anticipated to occur as a result of the proposed future development of Gaspar
Station PUD. Therefore, the project is consistent with the Objectives and
Policies of Goal 7.
VI. MAJOR ISSUES
A. Stormwater Mana2ement
Section 8.06.03 0.2. of the Collier County Land Development Code states "The
surface water management aspects of any petition, that is or will be reviewed and
permitted by South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD), are exempt
from review by the EAC except to evaluate the criteria for allowing treated
stormwater to be discharged into Preserves as allowed in Section 3.05.07."
Gaspar Station CPUD
PUDZ-2006-AR-10698
Exhibit 0
EAC Meeting
Page 4 of7
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 41 01127
County Staff could not find reference to a SFWMD permit for this site on the
SFWMD website, but due to the presence of wetlands on site, this petition will be
reviewed by SFWMD.
Gaspar Station is located within the Cocohatchee River Drainage Basin, which
has an allowable discharge rate of 0.04 cfs per acre per Ordinance 2001-27. The
Cocohatchee Basin has this low discharge rate, which is about a quarter of the
County's standard rate of 0.15 cfs per acre because the basin was analyzed many
years ago and was found to have had its capacity stressed, so the allowable
remaining capacity was divided among the remaining parcels.
The stormwater management system consists of a 2.I-acre lake and the usual
perimeter berm and storm water piping.. The system is designed to provide for
water quality retention and to attenuate the water quantity discharge, The
discharge will be to the north into the Cocohatchee Canal as per the Collier
County Drainage Atlas,
B. Environmental
1. Site Description
The subject property is approximately 17.7 acres in size, The Juliet Boulevard
easement accounts for approximately 1.4 acres, leaving 16.3 acres of developable
property. Wetland areas consist of 0.4 acres of Cypress-Pine-Cabbage Palm,
Exotics 25-49% (FLUCFCS 624E2). There are approximately 14.25 acres of Pine
Flatwoods with Palmetto Understory, 0.70 acres Pine Flatwoods with Graminoid
Understory, (Exotics 25% to 49%), and 0.40 acres of Cypress-Pine-Cabbage Palm
(Exotics 25% to 49%),
2. Wetlands
There are approximately 0.4 acres of SFWMD jurisdictional wetlands on the site.
The SFWMD performed an informal wetland determination on August 9, 2002. A
copy of the SFWMD informal jurisdictional wetland sign-off exhibit is included
with the EIS submittal (See Exhibit G).
Wetlands on the site are low quality in function and are proposed for impacts
by the proposed development. The presence of Immokalee Road and
associated canal, 1-75 and surrounding development has altered the hydrology of
the site. The wetlands have also been impacted by varying levels of exotic plant
infestation of primarily melaleuca and Brazilian pepper,
3. Preservation Requirements
The site is approximately 17.7 acres in size and contains approximately 16.3 acres
of native vegetation, The Juliet Boulevard easement impacts 1.4 acres of habitat.
Fifteen percent (15%) of native vegetation on the site is required to be preserved.
Gaspar Station CPUD
PUDZ-2006-AR-10698
Exhibit 0
EAC Meeting
Page 5 of7
Agenda Item No. 8e
November 27, 2007
Page 42 of 127
Therefore, approximately 2.4 acres of native vegetation are required to be
preserved on the site: (16.3 X .15 = 2.4), Approximately 1.7 acres of pine
flatwoods and 0,7 acres of pine flatwoods-graminoid understory will be preserved,
The preserve will connect to the Livingston Woods PUD preserve to the south.
4. Listed Species
Evidence ofwildlife utilization on the site was minimal. The site is not currently
inhabited or utilized by endangered, threatened or species of special concern.
Wilson Miller ecologists have performed listed species surveys on the subject
property through the 1990's and early 2000's. In March and April 1993,
Wilson Miller ecologists performed a listed species survey and a red-cockaded
woodpecker (RCW) survey on the property, Approximately 100 hours were
spent conducting the surveys and no listed species, RCW s or cavity trees were
observed on the site. On June 16 through July 9,1999, WilsonMiller ecologists
performed a RCW nesting season survey on the subject property. Approximately
40 hours were spent performing the survey and no RCWs, cavity trees, or other
listed species were observed on the site.
In August 2002, October-November 2004 and February 13 through 17,2006
WilsonMiller ecologists performed listed species surveys on the subject property.
No listed wildlife species, RCWs, or cavity trees were observed on the site.
Another listed species survey was conducted by WilsonMiller in February 2006
and no listed species were found.
There is a potential for the Big Cypress fox squirrel and the Eastern Indigo snake
to utilize the site. A Big Cypress fox squirrel management plan has been prepared
and is included with this submittal as Exhibit J of the EIS. An Eastern indigo
snake management plan has also been prepared and is included in this submittal as
Exhibit K of the EIS.
VII. RECOMMENDATIONS
Staff recommends approval of Gaspar Station PUDZ-2006-AR-I0698 with the
following stipulations:
Stormwater Management and Environmental
1. A SFWMD ERP must be obtained prior to the next development order
approval.
PREPARED BY:
Gaspar Station CPUD
PUDZ-2006-AR-10698
Exhibit D
EAC Meeting
Page 6 of7
Agenda Item No. BC
November 27.2007
Page 43 of 127
STAN CHRZANOWSKI, P.E.
ENGINEERING REVIEW MANAGER
ENGINEERING SERVICES DEPARTMENT
DATE
SUMMER ARAQUE
ENVIRONMENTAL SPECIALIST
ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT
DATE
DATE
KAY DESELEM, A.LC.P.
PRINCIPAL PLANNER
DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
REVIEWED BY:
Gaspar Station CPUD
PUDZ-2006-AR-10698
Exhibit D
EAC Meeting
Page 7 of?
Agenda Item No. 8C
November 27, 2007
Page 44 of 127
BARBARA S. BURGESON
PRINCIPAL ENVIRONMENTAL SPECIALIST
ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT
DATE
WILLIAM D, LORENZ, Jr., P.E.
ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT DIRECTOR
DATE
JEFF WRIGHT
ASSISTANT COUNTY ATTORNEY
OFFICE OF THE COLLIER COUNTY ATTORNEY
DATE
APPROVED BY:
JOSEPH K. SCHMITT DATE
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
ADMINISTRATOR
Gaspar Station CPUD
PUDZ-2006-AR-10698
Exhibit D
.....
nll'OltAIf SAUS Tt.All.lA ..
Mule COllwftttAL bACl
EXHIBIT "A"
-..--....-..-..-....-..-
CIM. ('Dr ~o.(W'..tIIrI)
----."....."
. -.--r---"-'-'-
..--... -..
M.lOICAllt/tCWl(IWl'llOWr...or.'/IiIII\t]
----.---.-J . ---_.____
---.-.II:"'t1'.:II..__..
l=:i~-l
'=
-t'
O-!-I
WClN/Tr MAP ..
I--~
::w':::'"
.------
-----
=-..r..:"'_
----
-------
--------
---
=~=:.:'::':".:.-:-~,
~1.:::r*.l=:FJ'-..:r
---...----
,
,
,
,
,
" CUlWIfT tot<<HOl .uJlltCUI.ft.Ht.14
. 1'WO~[D:rOfftlCtPtJD
I .
! I
~ ,i
,
~
.'
-
I
,
I
,
,
,
.
IESlKJrffiIL
......
.'It'" .....
,
i
H
-~
~I
f
I
,
,
I:
"
Ii
"
,
I
I
I
I
I
I
,
,
,
lf~3
I
USJDtHtw.j
....,...
ttcsO(MT'lAL
..""
--
mrostDEIOIAIICal
.
WtlVJUI!MATWAI.
t\.I.IrU.T milM NftA
.
.......,._-
--
.-.-
----.-.....--...--...
...... ......
..... ..... IOMOW ""'
"~~r~:==~..::!JlI.
.. um: _.r-.....
.._ 1'1II.-.........-.
........ .~
_~"fI'__"'"
~ro.t tJJa M
W'An..,...u JtACT
(..... COI<mU<lIOl<l
=:::'=""..~=-
....-...-.--
-~._--
n:1:, ~~..
10 P'ROI"os.n .u.",,'AlII.T
Utm/U7 ACMJ .
DtHS!'N or ...2 W/AC
W1lIl
g."""uu..oc........_
~~1~;;;.~.)
~ltncl,.. Ihvriw,...,)
[A$'f 1..i:~""lhlln'..
ZOoS.." lul&dln,.
om ,-...., .........
ZOoS...., IIlltftlp
""""C__>
""""("--'->
"""'""1:......->
....urAl >
nur.raa.t-u;",_
lJ.ll:U I.lAQR f
tl\ATlMAL tu.mtl.:1' f" ACIU 20
T01A4 t.' AeRtS 1
w:u I IoCatI
N.l.l\IUL KUlTAt t.& Aal't:s
.. If; ..u ~.. AQD
-.JUM Mt4 ..1 AQtS
T01Ai. MEA '.0 "'us 1POlC)
_...1",!Of"'D'D CltOA......ca:ss Am
HGOYER PLANNTNG SHOPPE
IIIL ./lOrD, JoLC.!'. "HIlt _
_.....___..........1ItW
....1IH1l....._..!iM1)_...., 11
l:'U.'"t.i.I:.'::'Iw"'l::::= W
Gaspar Station CPUD
PUDZ-2006-AR-10698
Exhibit E
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 45 of 127
t
,
1
I
t
~
I
I
....
. ...
....
....
. ,~
.J<>'
.,..
....
.....
.10'
~
..-......
.... 0- ~ "'"
~ ..,.::.....
r:~=
, HU
ug"ua
=...8;;
...., -
g~=
-- -...
t..:) ::;:u
p... ag
=-~
...., a ~
u-"J ;...;
('II"') Sri
... :I _
0::: :;;;2g:
00=
-. --
.- --
L.I"") -..
lot"') c::
~fj~
<""> ~-
C""') ....~
_H
~-
lil:<l
B:;-
=-
-
~
~
::I
-
7
~.~
.:>aspar Station CPUD
~UDZ-2006-AR-1 0698
Exhibit F
. PROJECT: Immokalae Road Compensating Right of Way
PARCEL: Eboll PUD (Bermuda Palms, AR 3413)
Agenda Item No. 8e
November 27, 2007
Page 46 of 127
ROAD RIGHT.OF.WAY, DRAINAGE AND UTILITY EASEMENT
THis EASEMENT, is made and entered inlo this ~ day of ~...\'- , 2004,
by BP Devco, LLC, who,e mailing address is 2190 J & C Blvd, Naples, Florida 34109
(hereinafter referred to as "Grantor"). and COLLIER COUNTY, a political subdivision of the
State of Florida, whose mailing eddress Is 3301 Tamiaml Trail East, Naples, Florida 34112, Its
successors and assigns (hereinafter referred to as "Grantee").
(Wherever used herein the larms "Grantor" and "Grantee" include all the parties to this
Instrument and their respective heirs. legal representatives. successors and assigns, Grantor
and Grantee are used for singular or plural, as the context requires,)
W ITN ESSETH:
Grantor, for and in consideration of TEN DOLLARS ($10,00) and other valuable
conslderallon paid by the Grantee, the receipt and sufficiency of which 15 hereby acknowledged,
hereby conveys, grants, bargains and sells unto the Grantee, a perpetual, non-excluslve
easement to enter upon and \0 install and maintain roadway, sidewalk, drainage and ulllity
structures and laclilties on the following described lands located in Collier County, Florida. to
wit:
:oj
See attached Exhibit "A" which is
1ncorporated herein by reference,
Subject to easements, restrictions, and reservaUons of record.
Not Homestead Property
TO HAVE AND TO HOLD the same unlo the Grantee together with the right to enter
upon said land, place, excavate, and remove materials for the purpose of constructing,
operating, and maintaining roadway. sidewalk, drainage and utility facilities Ihereon. The
easement granted hereln shall const1lute an easement running with the land and shall burden
the lands described above,
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Grantor has caused thesa presents 10 be executed the
date and year first above wrItten.
WITNESSES:
~ ~!:f fY/4~
")"'-'~~ Ii. MA"TEtN
Printed Name
{Jd" (lIL~
Signature '
I'larl&lf: J; r,6~1t:S l' ak
Printed Name
\o-:~' __0_ ~~~
St~ J. Mullersm
President
BP Devco. LLC
~.,
=~
~~
< ~
-~ ~
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF COLLIER
IL-n . The fore..Qoing instrument was acknowledged before me thfS ~ day of
n i:..et4r /IT>> 'L , ~ personally known~ or produced Identification .
Type of identification produced: .-
O1ANE EOWARDS
_\~1lIl11CC''''''
"-J;~I'l.E!fJiiUtry9,200s
a/Nrd"'T~l\Iflr:I&'I'f~,,*U_lII4r1
~~4<w.,~
Notal)' Public
My Commission Expires: /~9'- tiS-
"]), '.t1Al6 CDtJlI'RD:5
Notary Printed Name
C:\Documents and SelUngs\nelson\Local SeUlog$\Temporary Internat Ales\OLK119\1mmokal&9 Rd Compensating Right of
Way,doc Page 1 of I
u'-'- ~''"'':' ~~ :,:, ~.
COON ~~ '0
D~ ,;j
c:iN_ iji1l ~,,'!;tll'l ,Ie :'l:JI5l:J ~
z ,0 ~8 ~,,:s"I5~(l tI"t:~ ~ is
". "
,....~r-- ~~ ae:J~\;;~ ~..!.~\!:i iC~~t; ~ :?t~t-..: ~
~ ""
2wQ) t;}~c:~~~~~~~~~~giS "'" "'
-'" OJ ~"' ~(.)~"t~)......!.{tNQItICS-':: "t ~ :,il'!!! '"
C'O'-m ~~. ",~"'~i';"~"'''''' "i';~i'; t..Ji!:'~ ~
-0 CD..
C'" 5~ ct:,lrJ(.!) l.I.::.t: ~~i:lj~~Ii.~~ ;! ~iS!'> 8
0)> ~L:j(S~,h.~ a:;~ e5 'lJ...l...l.I.:1- '" ~v,~
0)0 1;;" ".;i, !J1 ~ ~:t:<.:l lI)l-~ ~ Co
<(z lie;. i!i~ ~.~ \l!..!. ~ ~~~ ~~~~. '" I';'l'''' \l
"'-~ ~~VjE~~I-l.:lt;i '<(~<:l~ t'-.. ~ ~!l..?:; ~
I';~" :;;:-:S~,l")D:;~ ES,?:i I-'!..I'~ ~."" CfLri \tJ~~ ~
:;;:h'~ Ili~' i!l'" ;;,.,:S!:'~l'l1;;~r ~ "'!i" ~
~~lI) ~~;~~B~~~~~~~~~ ~ ef2~ ~
..,'" ~~~lrJ~~~~l.I.:~~~~~~ ~ i:i ",,,.Iii l>!
~~~ ,-lI)~~~~"t~Q~~~8~~~~ Ie ~~':I ~
Elt:l'J ~~~lli~~~~~~~QlI)~~~~ ~ 1';
:tQ~' Q:;i,l:; lQ"i ~:::: ~I-.. ~ci ~I:;.q;
G~Y1 ~~~~~~~~~:'"'~~s~~~ ~~Q ~
8D:;~ lli "l:Jl(""" is''''''''l:J ~~ aJ"'i5 '"
~;;'>-' ~ ~ 0 ~U~~U ~ '" ":SO' !;
",," ~:~~~~i~~I~~~~~~~ "'13 !;'(I:
...~ " ~
~~V,5 I:: a "
Ci~ a,~f3
G>'l'~ ~i;",I';~~,"S~~1'i'~~W~~ &g If) ~<:.Jo ~
ug~~ ~ ;.:= t:!~Cl:V\~U~ j:jl.l.:~~
u~~"'8~~~~~~0I1..::~ :;:; a:~ ~!.:ei ~
~"'''' ~"'8
~ llilS b:~ C:l Q~ ~~ ~.... .t'.,rh: '01;) i:i~
o '~l..i""J k:J~"Q"""~ ~'" O!
q: "t12~ ~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~8 "'''" "
Hil
~,
" -:.
,'''':il
Ii'
._:>{/J/
1-/
I
[.
.~:~
"
\..
'r!
'"
~".-.
l'l~
,,-
~
! t.,
'II ~"'I~:
" I
'I .';1
ji I] Ii
J !))
}I
.I!
Gaspar Station CPUD
PUDZ-2006.AR.10698
Exhibit F
~9.WC
~'~
<:;
~~<Q
~G'~
~~bl
!;i\5.~~
@lli",:i
I--~~e::
i!'" ~
--.... ,L..Jl u~~~a
\1)(18 c:;h~~
~.~ <L;~'~~'"@
",I
___~t:~v~~\ g~
3 .,r,a;.6. S 6' I ti{
,
~i I n~J! I ,-- I
i~'~)\ll ("', L~ - i - L: .. -, _J'-
. i U '''-'' -"',
1/.." l ""-. "'"
,.., ' J
"", ;/ ".
~:' /Jo\\' \ "r _u~_ J r'-- .
"'J/~'>l) LJ 'l L-:-_n_I~~~ ,if - ..",L.
" ,______J It,
, "
"==-'"~~
,//,..,,~.:..,.
!f/ >
rr.'~m
\\
.6r~6~,.
P' __~N!.i_~!1! ::'!!!.~T!?:'~~"@'!:?!.~_
II~I
J II
'" I'
\.... \
'<V~,~ \
'\ ~ 1 1.1
>: L_,
"" \
_-<C
"
I--
as
-
::c:
><
LLJ
\f
'0 "
,., -,
N .
.~,
",."
,rnr
),
I
'.'1.r..
..;
"' ~
~ ~ ~
i! ~~~~~
~~ 1;3~~~'~ ~
~~ ~~~~~
fi,?;;;:lI:::;B.~
t:--oi8::s~ ~
~...~~~ ~
<;.;i;:!O;j"',;,
~<4.. !:;e::i
<:::;'1' ~ ~
. ~ ~ "
~ ~
,l;: ~ 2l
~ ~~r. :e~
Q;) ,...,., tr:lll)
--. 'T ~
:::.: 'f'~... ;~ ~tn
15 ""i 0) ~
t.:t: .q;; 'It !:l:::
~ ~"~ ~'}f~
'" <;3",:>.. ~~
~~~~ ,~
~ is "s ~ ~
~~~k; ~
rtoi:::~
~'~~l~~
"",/(J d~:
~~C'lClji'~O
:c...."''' I' ~
~~~ j.~ ~
~,. ~I-'
~E,j:;; .
<:c:iSl " ~.
~~ ClJB~ ~
u ,u
Ai ~ ~f,9g.6B N
3 "tf.9t.6// S
--''''~ -
c:;
<L;
.... (9rBlriJ)drOI! iriIDiOf{]{[
9,-f1;-Of JO 811(J'((IO lSJlAHUJOJ{ 1H1 10 JM1 H180N JH1
:Dd om :BO m
'"
OJ
'"
OJ
,
'"
~
i;;
,,8
'''is
~~
~a~
Q)(.)d
:S~'"
~~c
"
~~g
0.0."
~"'''
~c:ic:it:t:
~~o..:r.j
I:l "
~
~ ~ 11:
'" '-
'"
" :;; ~ ~
I:l ,. u
eJ ~ ~
I
I
I
O-NOO9l-HO:'lIJo!\lS.:lkl'1:JO\\ 'rlY <0""9'0:60 tOOLIIZ/to 'IN]~t3SV) 1uJ '6Mp'9i:"U-B\~"I'\l'IWd 'f'onr1tJ.38\ll~"O"-,\sb,,P\:~
ur--r--
COON
.:;..o~
,-
o
t: .\!~
$WID
-..0 Q)
CC;:::m
"O~"-
~Ill
->
QJO
.;fZ
,
.
'It ~
;!
,.., I
Z.
~: f
.. " I
,..0
>~
;= ~
U "
0( ~
o
~
~."
(" ~ -
'1fL~J~'7'"
II Ct:; i . ;~h.J ~
----~-- 1'1
, j. @ .- ------.--~_. @ ----------.--.!~
,..~-------======--______'l!L....~_______________
r[~-; IR\~,. <~;-~J:I~iY;
~LS ~ i ",,~J '~ -~ -~ j
1---...""'.....- ,h - ~ --"-- j!
,- .)"1 I 'f~~lC~11 ~ - ~
!?~"(r--~~I - -1 - '::=11 ::,
,\ ~ ( -/" l' :c.'1 ._,
,\ ~ 1 I ~ r.-
I : I " ,ff' \ :._, ,--
1 l' ~ 1 Pr~ ~- - i:
i i \ i \ I - I -_/Y~I-\ . ' .
i " I ill" \ j L'_\:J-i-1:"
__JL~_~___J '_ _~~ ~~ ,_~
, "
I t.'\'lm::'lS;t~
I -
I
I
I
I
II 11_______
i !-.----__________ i , "
'.:.----c~ ..~.. """,. I
I \ --1_~--------L r<,
~ j \ i / -J~d~
~l) I < i i \(fT~
1$~ . fT~
,; ~;(.I Jjj )j
') I ~ i "~_
!>' I - 1
l.'-J _ j l
I ,.!
__.J I !
~.ii,!
I ..
--
. i ~
I I I
"
Q
Z
w
'"
w
..
~
Ill!: ~
!m, .
; ",
'--------';f
~ .
J J:i
~ ~ ~
z :5 ~
o ,
N [3 ctl
(') "- "-"
~ '::l ~
B ~ ~
I . '~. ~]
, ~; r::;: .g
_~.J._ c: ,."~-
-'-'
!
I"
~q
, I,
, ,I
h~
0"'..
o i:c-l'",
~~<i
ii,
.1,
~/C!
.1'
i~~
~I . ) 1
--=j--'F I[F-'~'-l!1 LI_TIi
,.- II r
'. =:=1~-~ L I
~ - t
l
, i
. ,
I
,~
~'f
d
'-!
"
--=r--
.
,
,
,I
;.. ~
'i
I!
q
"
!
..: ____--i
-~-
_I
q
t ~
,
I"
I
"
an,;
l (
1 f
L~
!
I
,
[
MAR-20-07 TUE 09:56 AM
1 516 922 ,$geD9a Item No. 8@. '" 1
r,ovember 27.2007
Page 49 of 127
TO THE COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY:
DONNA FIALA
FRANK HALAS
TOM HENNING KAY DESELEM, PRINCIPAL
FRED COYLE
J 1M COLETTA
PLANNg vI
FROM: RITA EREDICS
DATE: MARCH ~~, 2007
RE: REZONING OF GASPAR STATION PUD (FORMERLY STILES PUD)
THE STRAND OFF IMMOKOLEE ROAD
OVERDEVELOPMENT ON THE GASPAR STATION OUD WILL CREATE THE EQUIVALENT
OF A BLOOD CLOT ON A MAJOR ARTERY. THE INTERSECTION OF JULIET BLVD
AND IMMOKOLEE ROAD IS ALREADY OVERBURENED BY WALMART TRAFFIC AND
THE SIX APARTMENT BUILDINGS KNOWN AS SUMMER LAKES. THERE ARE 20
MORE APARTMENT BUILDINGS UNDER CONSTRUCTION AT THAT SITE; TARGET
IS CNDER CONSTRUCTION AND THE PICTURE FACTORY WILL SHORTLY OPEN.
IMMOKOLEE ROAD AND JULIET BLVD CANNOT ACCOMMODATE MORE HIGH-DENSITY
BUILDINGS; THIS WILL EXASPERATE THE EXISTING TRAFFIC BUILDUP, NO
HOTEL SHOULD BF ALLOWED ON THIS SITE. THE DESIGN OF IMMOKOLEE ROAD
AT THE INTERSECTION OF 1-75 PROJECTED THE SMOOTH FLOW OF TRAFFIC,
JULIET BLVD IS A NARROW STREET THAT IS ALREADY OVERBURENED AND THE
OVERDEVELOPMENT OF THE GASPAR STATION PUD WILL CLOG ANL iMPEDE THE
FLOW OF TRAFFI C.
PLEASE DO NOT RENEW THE COMMERCIAL ZONING UNTIL THE APPLICANT
PRESENTS WHAT IS PROPOSED ON THE SITE AND ITS PROPOSAL SHOULD BE
LIMITED TO LOW-DENSITY USEAGE.
PLEASE NOTE: wE ARE CURRENTLY OBTAINING SIGNATURES ON OUR PETITIO~
REGARDING THIS MATTER AND THEY WILL BE FORWARDED TO YOU.
MAR-20-07 TUE 09:31 AM
1 516 922
2>7'''' P "'"
Agenoa Item No. ~C
November 27,2007
Page 50 of 127
TO THE COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY:
DONNA FIALA
FRANK HALAS
TOM HENNING
FRED COYLE
JIM COLETTA
FROM: ROCHELLE DOWLING
KAY DESELEM, PRIN~IPAL PLANNER
()/
RESIDENT OF THE STRAND OFF IMMOKOLEE ROAD
DATE: MARCH ;lb, 2007
RE: REZONING OF GASPAR STATION PUD (FORMERLY STILES PUD)
I AM A RESIDENT OF THE STRAND OFF IMMOKOLEE ROAD DIRECTLY ACROSS
FROM THE ABOVE-REFERENCED PROPERTY.
I UNDERSTAND ONE OF THE PROPOSED USES FOR THE PROPERTY CAN BE A SIX
STORY HOTEL. THIS IS MOST UNACCEPTABLE AS IT WOULD GENERATE TOO MUCH
TRAFFIC IN AN ALREADY CLOGGED ARE I.E. SUPER WALMART, SUPER TARGET
(YET TO BE BUILT) AND AT LEAST 20 APARTMENT BUILDINGS (MOST OF WHICH
ARE NOT COMPLETED NOR OCCUPIED YET) IN SUMMER LAKES DIRECTLY BEHIND
SUPER WALMART. ALSO, ANY BUILDING MORE THAN TWO STORIES ARE NOT IN
KEEPING WITH THE REST OF THE AREA"S ARCHITECTURE. WHEN ALL THE
AFORE-MENTIONED PROPERTIES ARE COMPLETED AND OCCUPIED, THE ALREADY
CLOGGED IMMOKOLEE ROAD AND ITS ACCESS TO 1-75 WILL BE IMPOSSIBLE TO
ACCESS. THIS WILL ALSO PRESENT A DANGER FOR EMERGENCY VEHICLES FOR
THE RESIDENTS OF THESE APARTMENTS AS JULIET BLVD. HAS JUST ONE WAY our
AND IN TO THE PROPERTY.
I BELIEVE THE LEAST INVASIVE USE FOR THIS PROPERTY WOULD BE A TWO OR
AT MOST THREE STORY OFFICE BUILDING. THIS WOULD GENERATE THE LEAST
IN-OUT TRAFFIC. ANY HIGH-DENSITY USEAGE WOULD IMPACT US AND OTHERS
VERY BADLY AS FAR AS OUR SAFETY, QUALITY OF LIFE AND VALUES OF OUR
PROPERTY. MANY PEOPLE IN OUR AREA CANNOT SELL THEIR PRorERTIES
BECAUSE OF WHAT WAS PUT THERE ALREADY IN WHAT WAS ONCE A LOVELY AREA.
I DO HOPE YOU, THE COMMISSIONERS, WHO ARE ELECTED TO PROTECT YOUR
RESIDENTS WILL ACT KINDLY AND WISELY ON THIS REZONING AND WILL NOT
REZONE WITHOUT THE OWNER BEING TOLD WHAT THEY CAN BUILD ON THIS
PROPERTY -- HOPEFULLY, A LOW DENSITY USE.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR KIND ATTENTION TO THIS MATTER. I KNOW YOU ALL
WANT TO PRESERVE THE BEAUTY, QUALITY OF LIFE WITHOUT INHIBITING
GROWTH IN A PROPER WAY IN BEAUTIFUL NAPLES.
PLEASE NOTE: WE ARE CURRENTLY OBTAINING SIGNATURES ON OUR PETITION
REGARDING THIS MATTER AND THEY WILL BE FORWARDED TO YOU.
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 51 of 127
March 22, 2007
Ms. Kay Deselem AICP
Principsl Planner
Dept. of Zoning and Land Div. Review
Collier County
RE: GASPAR STATION PUD (ALSO KNOWN AS STILES PUD)
Dear Ms. Deselem,
Attached are over 113 signatures on a petition to the given to
the County Commissioners at their hearing on the above property.
The residents of the Strand have signed this petition in opposition
to any change of zoning that would allow a six story hotel or any
six-story building or any other use that would increase traffic on
an already highly congested Immokolee Road. We have a super Walmart,
many apartments behind Walmart (the bulk of which are not occupied
as yet) along with a super Target not yet completed. The residents
are reeling from these buildings and once all is completed, just
these will saturate us.
We don't know why the owner wants to change its name, but if it
is to allow more dense use - IT SHOULD BE REFUSED. WE ARE SATURATED.
Our homes have lost its values and many residents are selling and
have been unable to. We resent our quality of life and our homes
being devalued to please absentee property owners. WE FEEL THE
RESPONSIBILITY OF THE COMMISSIONERS SHOULD BE TO ITS RESIDENTS.
A small two or three story office building would be a good use
for this property.
We look to our Commissioners to act in a responsible manner on
this zoning. We do not want to have to go further on this but
we will.
Kindly present the petitions to the County at the appropriate
time.
WE all thank you for your kind
attention to this matter.
J~'
j0~
Most sincerely,
~~. 5V~
Rochelle Dowling
for the residents of
the Strand.
Attachments: 9
RECEIVED
\'" 2 2 .'
!' '" i..
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27,2007
Page 52 of 127
PETITION TO COLLIER COUNTY'COMMISSIONERS REGARDING GASPAR STATION PUD
waRMERLY STILES PUD REGARDING PROPOSED REZONING AND USEAGE.
W~ '1 HI; t<.E::; I DE et<:e1:;EE-'iltVB-elBf)6'i'-'f0.'-AN.y---..~.--
ZONING OF THIS PROPERTY THAT WOULD PERMIT A SIX-STORY HOTEL OR
SIMILAR I\lJltl)tN~N 'fillS SITE. TilE INTER:JECTION-ElI":-:-JU-H-B'I'-Bb-VEl-AND--
IMMOKOLEE ROAD IS ALREADY TOO HIGHLY CONGESTED, OVERTRAFFICED AND
AN'l HIG!'! U3EAGE -WOULD IMPEDE E~1ERGEN€'t-VElllChE.t;'--W-E-G-I>J-E-Gr-'I'O--_._---
ANY REZONING WITHOUT THE OWNER DISCLOSING WHAT USEAGE OF THE PROPERTY
-"
~r c --\ - 1 'T ) 0 J\~
NAME
ADDRESS
3IfH:Q..___
II 1/
If / I
1.- ';.'
'5 "LO/L
c2 ~__._
l..(<;!) I
So
S- g "8
..6ft, ff
,
c:LMJE_--
S"C-\
'-<...,_..Z[
J),~ ~ /~()r
'-C~oe ~~. ~I.k:.~~
~a.OY'\. ~l0 e- 1;;t:-ZSi52.':t
;) ';?/u'-/ __~_
/
iFlc;OS._____
c' 3 I -rNr< Dr 11 /003-_~~~
-rIll ~ II 1'1 r
/ 11/'l'fi .J 1-1J,v (/r -:;.\= &"0 -z.
'77 II ~ II 'ill, (1
/rrtcJ" row NI~ ( t7P T
~
- //'1/- '/
5gn
rtf(,
r-1? G S'
"r
/Jy!
-3'-j"{-o7.
1P--l6~ l--
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 53 of 127
PETITION TO COLLIER COUNTY COMMISSIONERS REGARDING GASPAR STATION PUD
WITRMERLY STILES PUD REGARDING PROPOSED REZONING AND USEAGE.
--.--,----------W~THE1{ESTDENTs__mr_TItE_SlR_A'NITtlr_F_TMMe!ffll;E_E_-B,L_V1T_0B_3Ee_T--1'0--AN-Y------
ZONING OF THIS PROPERTY THAT WOULD PERMIT A SIX-STORY HOTEL OR
--------STM1t~-BUn;IYtNG'--enrrHi_s__S-I_'l"E_:__'i"H.E_I_N'f-E_R__S_E6_H0N-0F__d-U.L-I ET- BbVD--AN D-.-.--
IMMOKOLEE ROAD IS ALREADY TOO HIGHLY CONGESTED, OVERTRAFFICED AND
------------A"NY4tf(;H-US-E1I:frE-~leIH,f)_I_Mp_E_f)E_EM_ERG_E_Ne_Y_V-EH.:r_GbE_&.--WE--GBJECT-'r:G---.-------
ANY REZONING WITHOUT THE OWNER DISCLOSING WHAT USEAGE OF THE PROPERTY.
ADDRESS
"," (? II ~/'-:".t" '--r J r""" .--t:J/ft'k:r
~) I ~., h f2--&<. --':."" (7/ !) ,-' ( L , ,'$'! J J!J
- ~.--._"._-------~-----
,~c;)1 177r2e.e:kzt/Y' I1[)C-:_jJ!tH2!'!~_!l~~~___
((-,ct8 ~wovtf~?b )~:0("(' :~_::{'I'.t<:o~____
S'd"y,("" ~~0\y"c~.--~~__~_____~\_ ____ ____
5~/ #JL-UItd;~~~-~Y/lq--
~":;'1:JJ.j0j,d iJcdJ(' JO)3JliPjJJ::pL,flL'L<;J J.{L _ _ __ _
--~~I..rJ\:~ \J --- 6 9 3 ~ "&. Q1t-"~&st-T-.k~;c..;..~tJhO 0..
-_~_E--__I?_:=J..__-, - . ,;' o,f1J i:f)ft'/T1AJ,.u III hf-J~.{j ,:? -III 0
___~J1LLo bi ~{\l'I'R 1~~~\\~- .' G U? 0 _XI ~~ii-~ ~_L~I7Q~_~~1~-~__n
3 / ! z /0 7 -0 () /1 " {, t1 e, Ii; -;; ,je (,if ,'l q ~ (,.. :5'-1?lA7J {) /5l(/.I1. II 11-,0 Lk.$ ;/~L. '3 t{ II 0
----.--------..------ - .. .::'./
~fi~}~~~ <~f.O;i:':]~ir~. i::~~~~-
:3!!kkL_0f1JIH"J "flf2. ,NI4U GI5D1 Fo4teWA< cti 1'Ir{'LCc<,jl/.O
_3__11-~) ~l " ~'. U\X<~-<<~. Sf; 'to :S;l/A, ;J.f41~rci-l::Lifj(6Iji-L~}iJ;!~
.,Jb-J.:lfL2 ,) CQrul-,#P [1 ~~M r ,,),. ';, t ).I~.v~), ,t;:fZ5'b31_N~(~!:~X'~!()_
--til-:)~!P..]~_ .. . '-{)ud:~~..-c' ,,~<I1~<1~1~_I{JJ1L
-E.11:..z/o7_____!f/tik.. ~. (!J(})l;;;9/;~v"'_.. 0..1)2'4 "Jt;, : ~/;2i-ll"'~ I 114t.&~,,2:4"__~1~(c.>__cy---
~~;~~Lf!;lb::::t::~j7 J;,;';:;,~; t';~7 ~:;:;t~~~0
_..;z~LL_!~.')~ l-l ~n::l0{j? /I/jY{ D {\';\J 5q t.,'J5 (liP, 1J l)J:T~:'l. ttJ :hi IJAU.'S 'So J~1l J ()
_d~!2- -67 ;0 (ku-</ "111 ~<-> Yip?;> ~'A/~~..It.' /!J2q5 _i/fl.CZ___----
)) /In '"I . ~ C /. /';J -P,j ..... -
__,_'_ i /~ Dc:tl.{CbfA/!1. 4izr,Ii/p{f, Ii> ~o:) fjlJ A/-A.cC{i' LAiI-'.:!:'iu 2_~_____?_ 41 i~_ _ .... ...
DATE NAME
~~~7,'~~' ~ ' ..
-_-=~--.2~-_--_~utJ~~
--. :J.![(jsq----9u&;/-> (j)uX"C-eA(x:!-_
________, '_L.._ ~~ , \ \ "( (;L
..-ii)~-
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27. 2007
Page 54 of 127
PETITION TO COLLIER COUNTY COMMISSIONERS REGARDING GASPAR STATION PUD
~MERLY STILES PUD REGARDING PROPOSED REZONING AND USEAGE.
.. "--'-'WE-TRE-RESTDENTS-Or--Tm:'-STRAND'-OFF--'IMMOKOLEE BLVD OBJECT TO ANY
ZONING OF THIS PROPERTY THAT WOULD PERMIT A SIX-STORY HOTEL OR
__.. SIMI'r;-AR--BUlLDING-.ON-'l'HIS--S-I4.'E-;----THE--INTER-SECTlON.. OF. JUHET BLVD AND
IMMOKOLEE ROAD IS ALREADY TOO HIGHLY CONGESTED, OVERTRAFFICED AND
"_'ANY"HT:GH'USEAGE:--WOUl:;D-IMPEDEEMERGENGY--VEHIGUS . ... WE ..OBJECT TO
ANY REZONING WITHOUT THE OWNER DISCLOSING WHAT USEAGE OF THE PROPERTY.
__~..._._'_.n_' _____..._....__.,_,______._._.. .'---- . . ...-_...-.._---_..
.. ... DATE
J/-(/(f}-:.-~;&~~~~~~'i--':, ~_,~,-.'~~__-~.__:_.-----._~..-E_():fn }qitC(=A~ LA! /3~/19
,,/;;1,;1 /:1 :'/ _..c.,-!t{~_ fl ;l./lNt :5 9' b'd-@A R ,-I "''(). LN 31/lv
~Il\~f _.n..~LI):.__~~~-~ -'~~=~.~~'.=-':-~-'~?i]:, .. ... BAr~l~ LV! 34-rlD
_ ~l?-- .._.~_.2;i;JfJ:fz~_;E_______.____n_____.__,_6t?~ '_.7~dt-J'l,j)R- .
. ::>/; "1._ .. ... I~,.(L. !!IL;,&.f\.C.../-. A._:... <.L..,_. __, ....._...'._.n .,....,'_....._.,:~.'j.._- 7_.'1...'1......_ .(. ii, , "". "",'. i'" . 7
7, /'!~ ,_ - - ':L___ _ ~ ___ _ - - - -- 4- _ _ .-. .(~,~-- - r,:..::,.Ij~_'.h:;f.'.;::fr"tlf}:.^);;;.
3/1:2. ...__q;,.~.~,_tll!J>cddl!L .___,___' ~~~~.$i !/dfJl] j,411li? (1/;'70 f./ J
. :3/CL. _____~~L1I~IL~4L"cl;-~L---.--.-._- ._____m. ... 5Y.tf.(L~1>:k!..t/~hi~fJ.j,{.l.:!)C~! -
'I ,! 1 '" ,'.', ("f'" '.
, ___.~7 _.,:i!.07i~(1__- _____. . ,,'I,. fy" JlhL~t
/1 ___ ~e4. fl~'C~n..'-:_,_.n______u'u--~-f.~'f. . 5~Nb wfla /.).:; 3&" //
.' / . ...__,_-!.~~.1P./L~-----.--.n-- .___,_._._L~_'u wn_~' '" <, "'l
I 'i. .' u{;~N(-jl !?~lu--.- m__ ........... .__.,._.2~U3.?0rlYtt)d) %JlcpfHr63
3/!;;z/o .1.___ . .~,~j('lIle.,_dc ,.D~l::f[e~~__n_____..__,____11~'5J.L0\(1;.c~.pe,~~/')6(l( <j- .
... ~I.( . __ ,~)h~j?~.-~lf.v__.-_-nu.--.'.--_2'-[~J-(tiiM~C ~Ji .'.
~>/j(/" ~---"';'~I,)lf"''''-cj-;--- "-i!5Z-A~!t70'~ ;) ': ,
:J. .I:~~,:,l'.~ln__ _,..__~~~_Dnf'.J .-'c,Sl,~'c"I~:,,-/):2.'n---S.J~]-0-.... LA))'\i~)I'''-'c-.r,::c).,,;,. r C r"f-".
NAME.
ADDRESS
--------.--..... ..-------~. -.-,...---.....--.--- ,--- _....---
. ____ _Ov._'__ _..._,.____.._....'__ _____.. _....n.'____.___.
.-.. ...-- _ ---.._-,...... _....-..--------".. ...._......--~ -_.,- .----- ..--
___.________n~ __.. _ _ ~--- - ----
Agenda Item No_ 8e
November 27.2007
Page 55 of 127
PETITION TO COLLIER COUNTY COMMISSIONERS REGARDING GASPAR STATION pun
~MERLY STILES PUD REGARDING PROPOSED REZONING AND UStAGE.
-- '-. -------'-WE1'HE~ESTD'ENTS--Ol"11iji;-8'1'ItkNI)-eF'F-:tMM0~eJ:;E-E---Bi:Ne-0B..JEG-T---T0-.ANY------ '_h
ZONING OF THIS PROPERTY THAT WOULD PERMIT A SIX-STORY HOTEL OR
-------S-milA1\-B U'l'tO'tNe-eN--'j.'HI S S I l'E. 1'H-E-Hf'l'-EiR-5-E6-N-6N-8F---JUH-E-T-BL-V-D-AND------
IMMOKOLEE ROAD IS ALREADY TOO HIGHLY CONGESTED, OVERTRAFFICED AND
-..,------kNy---HTett-ltS.!tAeE-We-1:H,f)-I-MPBfJE-EMERB-ENtr't-v-BH-I-GbE&.--WE---O BJEG-T---~O----_._---_
ANY REZONING WITHOUT THE OWNER DISCLOSING WHAT US~AGE OF THE PROPERTY.
---._---~--_.__.,._-_.._.. ._"._._--~
DATE
NAME
ADDRESS
_J..liJ:.LO!L ex u.-1;/;:h 1_v V l.t P L /, ,,/
-1!rlt~-11r;!~~~
db ~/o 7 'C:)70/rr,r3reuM#'
-3~!~'O..:.JJ~/i{~/Ql/.s Isf
-~liu.Q]_~C>ILI~i _
- 3p~-Z.. \ );.;vNd ~)lS.e I
-~~:t~-~~~~
6ft? {.JjUYi--u<~0i~______________
6-n.f ~~iJf2J-
0,-rj (u ?'1~-'LCt~~-----\T_
~~~'[~ Z:;!5'd~
S'<Jj, t '\ ~{f~Jl~t.\,Di1__~Z2()3_____.
6" t/f~J,~;tJ~fi-7-b)----
--------------~-.
b &07 ~~_--Ch:.-1=-:?~--
..,:i-'
--.__._.~----
---.. ~_.__._._-----_._-,-_._.._~_._. -,..._- .....".- --". .,.... '-..
_._--_._--_.~---- ---
---~-------------------------.--- -..--.--.----...--- .. ---- -
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 56 of 127
PETITION TO COLLIER COUNTY COMMISSIONERS REGARDING GASPAR STATION PUD
~MERLY STILES PUD REGARDING PROPOSED REZONING AND USEAGE.
W J; 1 He-RESTl)"ENTS-OF-'l.'I1~'fRA-Nrr-e'F'F-i:MMe!ffi-1:;EE--B-T:;VD-0 B-.J'EG-T--T0--ANY---
ZONING OF THIS PROPERTY THAT WOULD PERMIT A SIX-STORY HOTEL OR
-STM1tA1l.J)tJlI:;Dl~N4.'tI-I--S-S-J:TE , THE-rtff-E-R-&E-€-HeN-0F--J.ul:rI-E'l'~Bb-V-D-AND --
IMMOKOLEE ROAD IS ALREADY TOO HIGHLY CONGESTED, OVERTRAFFlCED AND
_________---,'\~-U-8'EA:e-E-OOtft-D-I-MrED E EME-RtrE-NtrY-V-EH-!:-6hE-&.-WE-GBJEG'f-1'0--------------
ANY REZONING WITHOUT THE OWNER DISCLOSING WHAT USEAGE OF THE PROPERTY,
---.---_.~~---------------_...._-----_.---------'-_._-
NAME
ADDRESS
,._.._--~----_._----~_._._-_._...._. -
. lJ/a$a.L1;t!f~--itt~
. _-fcE'o.~ If*FL=--~41~ Q-.----
l-C1,.o\..l_n. LA"./1--".__ 'p I.,~., ' I " ' I
~;i..'
.~------_._----_._-_._--"
_ ---~~---_._._-~-._----- .--.---'-' ..,---.-- -
_._-_..__._~-----_._----_.. ."..-----.. ,.----
Agenda Item No. 8e
November 27.2007
Page 57 of 127
PETITION TO COLLIER COUNTY COMMISSIONERS REGARDING GASPAR STATION PliO
waRMERLY STILES PUD REGARDING PROPOSED REZONING AND USEAGE.
WI; 1 HI; KE.S I DE M6Iffit-EE-B-!:;V-El-OB.,)'Ee<r---'PO-ANY------.--
ZONING OF THIS PROPERTY THAT WOULD PERMIT A SIX-STORY HOTEL OR
[, IMILAR etlI~N-'i'HI 3 311'E. 'filE IN'ffiRC ECTION-ElF---d-l:l-b-l-E'r-Bb-V-D-AND.---.
IMMOKOLEE ROAD IS ALREADY TOO HIGHLY CONGESTED, OVERTRAFFICED AND
ANY !'IIGI'! USEAGE WOULD WrEDE ElIERGENCY VEllICLES. w-E--G.~'W------_.
ANY REZONING WITHOUT THE OWNER DISCLOSING WHAT USEAGE OF THE PROPERTY
DATE
NAME
ADDRESS
~----
. 3 01___ -_
i
'.
_.;.;.-:...'
i;
-
Agenda Item No. 8e
November 27 2007
Page 58 of 127
PETITION TO COLLIER COUNTY COMMISSIONERS REGARDING GASPAR STATION PUD
~MERLY STILES PUD REGARDING PROPOSED REZONING AND USEAGE,
w t; ~ H ~ RES I DE (}fflJ:;EE-13-J:ViT-0 B-df:e'f--'f0-ANY--.-------
ZONING OF THIS PROPERTY THAT WOULD PERMIT A SIX-STORY HOTEL OR
SIMILAR BUILDING ON nus SITE. 1'1lE INTERGE-6'f-Te-N--BF-J-IJh-H'f-BbV-D-AND---'
IMMOKOLEE ROAD IS ALREADY TOO HIGHLY CONGESTED, OVERTRAFFICED AND
ANY IUCM USEAGE WOULD IMl'-BfrE EtlERGENC'J VffiH-E]hES, ltlE--G-MEG-T-'W------
ANY REZONING WITHOUT THE OWNER DISCLOSING WHAT USEAGE OF THE PROPERTY.
DATE
NAME
ADDRESS
6~pl \~re~ ~v,'~~~-~S}__~::~::_:=
-Y-l n V\A-w \\0, , r\
,J
-.
-:.:.:...:
!P
Agenda Item No. 8e
November 27, 2007
Page 59 of 127
. PETITION TO COLLIER COUNTY COMMISSIONERS REGARDING GASPAR STATION pl1t)
~NERLY STILES PUD REGARDING PROPOSED REZONING AND USEAGE.
W~ ~l1g RESIDENTS OF' THE Sn.ANB oF-F. IHM(}!fflJ:;E;E-ilt;VB-GIBf:6'P-'F0-AN-Y-----m--_.--
ZONING OF THIS PROPERTY THAT WOULD PERMIT A SIX-STORY HOTEL OR
S I I'll tAR II U ILO I N\H1N-fitt8 S aE . THE I N'PER:3 ECT-HtN-BF--J-B-bf-B'I'-B LV-I)-AN D.-m
IMMOKOLEE ROAD IS ALREADY TOO HIGHLY CONGESTED, OVERTRAFFICED AND
AW, !lIGH USEAGE WOULD WrEDB-BMBR-&EN61c'--VBlH-G-bES. I/E--G-I>J.EG+---TO--.------.-.
ANY REZONING WITHOUT THE OWNER DISCLOSING WHAT USEAGE OF THE PROPERTY.
DATE
/9' /PI1--R.
. ,.
" <-
I.' 11.
1/'- "
it. "
I' '1
11 1\
II I)
NAME
J1J- j) l-?JI S EXTe /'1
J e--f lJecJ L'u
J 0-0 Iff RJ-1J 0
tv I vco..(J1Jzs",!y 4& I
5 T&:(?(-.j tlv' -v'. () WIN cf p.(L
Q\r C \ vI,
d 6~-N ~ \ I \f?-.f' \-Q'-!
CTe-~ (!-l<€ '1M IS
ADDRESS
,.---,
51?/' /A",(?,?'ry f),€", /cfCJj?:_______
5 '76 '7 tk,f ~ J;vd>< -t:I- L "71:::.3_______
j.-(71 '7 'Tf-/J ilt-f (.> k ::if. ((., 0 1_
S77; IV'-'}1I-,{ tJrlJ!.f(~l\€----
6"<0.. 'J ;;Z 17 P/--I >' 011 t V t: -,;p 3 (7 2-
.... ~-~_._-~_._---
1\ ~\/
\ 'lit -i:P f t/J3---
~ q \, ~ '\ V\,,0 ~'I~ ~. :2 o_c)J___
60:3! 1f2oCrJt( >>,( -=JbJ-Oc.f
i.:
_:':':l<..i
. .
i!
.-
Agenda Item No. se
November 27, 2007
Page 60 of 127
PETITION TO COLLIER COUNTY COMMISSIONERS REGARDING GASPAR STATION PUD
wcrRMERLY STILES PUD REGARDING PROPOSED REZONING AND USEAGE,
--'WE"THE-RESIDENTS--OF--THl~--STRAND-OFF-nIMMOKOLEE BLVD--OBJECT TO- ANY
ZONING OF THIS PROPERTY THAT WOULD PERMIT A SIX-STORY HOTEL OR
. . ....SIMIL'AR-BUILDING..ON4'H-IS--SITE..'nnTHE.INTERSECTION OF- JULl ET BLVD AND
IMMOKOLEE ROAD IS ALREADY TOO HIGHLY CONGESTED, OVERTRAFFICED AND
---ANY-HIGH--USEAGEWOUl:;D'-IMPEDE-EMERGENCYVEHIGLES. -.. WE. OBJECT. TO
ANY REZONING WITHOUT THE OWNER DISCLOSING WHAT USEAGE OF THE PROPERTY.
DATE NAME ADDRESS
---c. ---L.JJ:,n-Tlm---~-_--__n-______.._-.-.. .'_m h~=-d n
~:~~::l~~~====-=/'(-/.J~~:'b, 1~~~3 3,'::'
:3 ~ ( 5-0 7__f~_r;;~_<...~b__u________n_____Ei.f}jl_l/Lb{-JtJ~~-( ~v <-( . .
3. -/5"-q?--_2~o:~~dL--- ______nn_..___n~_ffl~~~. ~I ltJ::<
3 - ;;"0 -(l'l.-..-jlll!JJ!~=------____-_n---_-------~~'}L/K.Pf'../I,V DR. fr. laJ u .
--
r---
I
,\ ,--;
,;{~:_,Jj kj_:<'-'~;{;:~:,;:';r-~--.
MAID OF COON'l'Y COMMISSIONERS .
COLLIER COON'IY. FLOIUDA, - ',.;. .... ~ ,_
'~"'j'
() . -j,:.., ".
.....,
~ ';~t,
':.... ,~,"._'b.,..".
' -, ~hl~f":-
,N', ~...-.t
is n'l~" ';.j
-0 q..' '.
:x:
_".,,-,11,;.
~
-
-
DRDIHAlIC1< 86-~
All Ol:OIlWlCE .IMDlDING ORDINANC1< 82-2 TIlE COM-
PRLBE!fSIVZ. ZONING REGt1U.TIONS fOR THE UNINCOB.-
PORATED ARt.A OF COLLI!! COUNTY, n.oRIDA BY
AMENDING THE ZONING ATLAS HAP NUHEER 48-26-9 BY
CHANCING THE ZONING CLASSIFICATION OF THE HElEIN
DESCRIBE:D REAL PROPERTY FRQH A-2 TO "POD"
PLAll'FED UNI'l' DEVELOPMENT J::NCMl AS mE STILES
CORPORATION FOR t 18.7 ACRES OF INTERCHANGE
C(Ro'J{ERCIAL DSES (MOTEL BOTEL, RESTAURANTS. ErC.)
FOR PROPERTY LOCATED OR THE SOU'I'H SID! 01'
IMHOKALEE: ROAD. AJlPROXIMATnT ! MILES VEST OF
1-75, IN SECTION 30. TOWNSHIP 48 SOUTH, RANGE 26
t.A5T i AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
.,
'"
~ -
r- n"~
mr-F=
",m~
,... ~i::
:~ ..... :2.:
:::'=:"
::'-;;:-;
,.....,.:
W1IE1U'.AS, Hihoo. Miller, Barton. 5011 and Peek. repn.ent1IJI
tbe Stil.. Corr~r&tlOD petitioned the Board of County Comai..loner.
to change the ZoniO& Cla..ification ot the bardn dUcr1bad real
, property:
NOW, THEJ.EFOR! :BE IT ORDAINED by the :Board of County
~siOD.rs of Collier County, Florida:
.
) .J' SECTION ONE:
The Zoning Cl...ificatioD ot the herein d.scribed r.al property
located in Seedoa 30, Tovnablp 48 South, bage 26 ta'.t. Collier
. Count,., Florida 18 cbaose4 frO*. .1..-2 to "PUD" :Planned Unit
DevelopmeDt in accordance with the POD 40cumant .ttached h.r.to ..
Exhibit "A" which i. incorporated,herein and by reference ..de part
h.reof. The Offici.l Zoning Atlas ~p ~umber 48-26-9, aa described
in Ordinance 82-2, 1_ her_by amended .ccor~ingly.
SECTION 'IW:
'I'hh Ordiunr'l shall bec01II4I .ffective upon recll1pt of notiee
"',that b h.. bua filed vitb tbe Secretary 'of State.
.~t\i :.,
'DATE:
r',.'"
August 26, 1986
. .
1..........4J
...ll'ftf,$~D 0'"
. .'~ "JilltS .0.. lIigS. CLERK
~ ~ .... ...~.....~r',. v. ,.
f.~~./ ~y':.-- j.;;..~~:.~,. ~
;q. "." - :,
g 2:.... ,"~l".',:,/'. . - , , . 'Th" ordtnonc:e fll<<l wlfh ~ . c:
:;"",'.:~ tf,'lr"\ii'>-)':1. .. '.. 's.::_ryofStp'IOff.kVlJll _ go
.~-.... '-il'1'~\'Ell)U,.TO"rolH AIlD LEGAL Sum:CI1JI~dayof,Mp..o:lZ.'
<;.; ..;..~~...<;. and ~~f that
......" ;~~.'j~~d<'1 ~~~.1ifA. cloy .
I.. Ilil.UCE ANDJW.ON ~. By (.JMIe."'-J,J....-(_
ASSISTANt COUNTY ATIORNEY "Crrpurr ~
lOOK 024"lt184
I-86-10C Pun Ordinance
..~,
m
U'.
'" 7J
~ fT1
.."
. "
co ,.,..,
:
'i.l t'l
C.
""'
c-
'""
..
.,
\:~~
'~'-'J
"',
-,; ~-.
:'-1.'"
~,.,
-
-
-
~
., .'y"
:~ ~):,'
:,' """"
~. 1r ::';':J'
'I ' ~. ~', :- .:~
>. I:. : ~I ~
" I, '; .-~
.'.
'.
.~:;~ l'
. .,r.,
PLAllNED ONI1' DEVJI:LOPKnT DO<:1JIlEft
FOR
srILES CORPORArIOa
PLANNED ONIr DSVl!:LOPKnT (P.D.D.)
Section 30, Township C8 Soath, Range 26 Bat
Collier County, Florida
".:\
"':'Ii
r.,.,.,.;..."....,:.,;
~I'; Y:"-;~f;'1: .-
" :
PREPAJU:Il BY.
WILBON, MILLER, BARTON, SOLL , PEtK, INC.
EIlGInEERS, PLARRIRS , LAIID SCRVEYORS
1383 Airport Road North
Hapl.., Florida 33942
'.. ;'-'
'::,;>,,~
'.
C'::I'-r '(. ,\
~::'f,"
~ ...
. ,'-
'.',:'
, ~ .'
.;,:.
DAn
, ,
ORDINAIICI !lllIlllIR
........,
86~58 .
.'
.,
::'
IDOK
024 w.r185
.... '-. ~ ,':-: ~:;~:~;~~~':: !~.'
;....'.J ". ~ I",,;".~
'::1.['; ~:7{&r~;~rf
-,,_.._-,_._.~- ....
-_..._---_.._._.+---~..---_._--~---_.
-,~'":.~..";'".;-...,.,;
-
.
,.
f
'.
. .;....' .:-
~.i!.:!;;: .
1f.!a . .-
:1..'
,'A_..., ..
~'.t.l<.'" .
,'1" ~''',
:i,f' .~
'~~".::'.':'
,.:;:.,~.'
:t..:' ~.
:~~l:'
;\".:
~
SECTION I
SEC'I'ION II
SECTION III
SECTION IV
. -
-
~
List of Exhibit.
Statement of Compliance
Property Description and Ownership
Project Development
Permitted Uses and Standards
General Commitments
.'
1001 024."d86
.'
-
~
11
11i
1-1
2-1
3-1
'-1
{
....-'
."
,;,-
""i ~~..
.-,.
"j.-
~.'
,
--_._--~..~.
-...." . ._'~...
-
.......
~
; ~ '
.. ~
EXHIBIT -A-
EXHIBIT -S-
EXHIBIT .C.
~c
~.:~:
1.~1-'.' .
~'1.
1';"
~};. '..
t~~ii~,{ ;::.-
'~lj,,,.,,
.~,~.:-,~.::: .~(.
.~~'~-"
_:f,...,;.;:;}.....~....;:.~.;-;.;::.....:-'...::
.r
LIST OP EXHIBITS
P,D.D. Master Plan, Aerial Photograph
(WMBS'P Pile No. RZ-133, Sheet 1 of 2)
Soils , Vegetation Map
(WMBS'P Pile No. RZ-133. Sheet 2 of 2)
Boundary ~ Topographic Survey
(WMBS'P Pile No. 4L-389)
.'
'.
.'
"
ii
IDOl 0241ld87
..'
~,"'1;
~..!~J:"
_.-J .', \)_;)'~+."
'.'f;';:.::~r
-; ~:,~~:;j
: "~~~.>;'::'
,.
.~, I .
.~~ -. ~ ,.
,--.
" ~'::
-
-
-
-
STATEMENT OF COMPLIANCE
The development of approximately 18.7 ac~e8 of land in Section
30, Township ~a South, Range 26 Eaat, Collier County, Plorida,
will be in Cott.pliance with the planning 90a18 and objectives of
Collier County as set forth in the Comprehensive Plan for the
f0110..,1n9 reasons:
1) The subject property is located wholly within the inter-
change COmmercial node a8 identified and described in the
Comprehensive Plan.
2)
The subject property has the necessary rating
determine the availability of adequate
facilities and services.
points to
community
3) The pe~itted uses to be Included wIthin the project are
primarily intended to serve the travelling public Using
the interstate system, and reflect the highest and best
use Ot this property.
4) The regulations and standards for development of
corumercial uses On this property shall be governed by
this P~O.D. ordinance, as required by the Comprehensive
Plan.
5) The project development i. planned to incorporate natural
systemr. for water management and/or landscaping in
accord~nce with their natural functions.
:: jL
"
Hi
1001 aZ{ pw 188
. ~i
.~-" ;
..
,'; '1 ~.}~~
,"'i'.' ,(.:.,...
l
.
. I :. '~i'
. ';<-';i:~'
".;:,.;;}~
:O'~.
t.
",. 'i.l~
!.'(?:::::!P{':'--~!~;' :~-I-':f;.';'.~ ~~i7i.%~
, \~)'I
, / ~ ~
, -'1
'. i \.':oii:,,~L';,:J~.~~-r,
Jl.. _ '_'~ J r,.~,.,\, - ~" . '} - ~ .?J.
~ J-.~;;':. f:l~~t.,t','.'-:o'trt-, ::'i \.;..
~'1~'~::';~ f;~!.,Jti:J ~ f.;,,~ta~';., t.:: t"
,t,"" /1-:;;: ,:lr(~IJ.;,\:''\f)~\../\~'
'.~~r/~r:':t.'. I,~:;,:/~~-~~'~~r i
, ::t' .,f"'''''I'~'j
"~~.~;J:,~l~,~~i''f,)tf~'.~C :;~,;
\.'. ',"'X-'.W: " "'j;'_l".J..
.~.. 'ri ;,..-" S;:rl.... I -! ~.:' tf"-$
\' .",::,"r~,}j" "t.,;, 'I"
) ''ij'.1 J.;~~..~t~;<~ ,..~~.' ..ip~)
;,d"r't'~~'~ "'",,'<< ..' "'l:~"'~
. J-'''''''''' ~tl~?,t.. (~:.hl:j'
'. :'\.t-'! ~r;.' . ~~f. .:~
,1;tJwr : '~';""f,. ,',,' ,. ':4:~'; l
"";,/" 't, 'd;\:;,i
'. :i;
;",,>
..-,;,;..t~;"."
, ""~"+:'l';'''! "
. '. ,.:, ;://"'l-.i u .. _;':';{:,\, "
'...: ,,'; 'f~ - _ _ :;;..,;;\
,,~,,~~~A1 .'
"',: :1,,,,,1,~~ t.. ,
: ., ....:(:~l:~.,~_~: -;,:~-~~r'~ '~.::.
',..'.
-
-
.-
SECTION 1
PROPERTY DESCRIPTION AND OHNERSHIP
1.01 INTRODUCTION AND GENERAL LOCATION
It is the intent of Stiles Corporation (hereinafter called
applicant or developer) to establish a Planned Unit
Developmp-nt (P.U.D.) on approxiMately 18.7 acrea of property
located in the southvest quadrant of the interchange between
Interstate is and Immokalee Road (CR 846), approximatelyl.5
miles east of Airport Road (CR31). It io the purpose of
this document to establish the standards and guidelines for
the future develo~ent of this property.
1.02 LEG~L DESC~IPTION
HeBt 1/2 of the Northeast
.30, Township 48 South,
Florida.
T.03 OIINERSHIP
1/~ ot the Northe.st ;/~, Section
Range 26 Ea~t, Collier County,
The subject property is currently under the ownerShip and
unified control 'of Terry K. Stiles, Trustee, 6400 North
Andrews Avenue, Ft. Lauderdale, Florida 33309.
.;:
!' :~.
",.'.
....
.
., ,'._;..~~:.~\;~~ .
"
..;,
"!
,-,
IDDK U24rm189
.-'.
. . : ~
....-~,------._-_.,,'--
...., .._--~-"'_.,-_.__..,.~..
" /
~._-- -.---
-
" ~: ' ,
f'
i
.::- ";, 'f;'"
'," . ".
2.01 ,PURPOSE
SECTION II
PROJECT DEVELOPMENT
The purpose of th Is Section i. to generally describe the
plan of the development and delineate the general con-
ditions thot vill opply to the project.
2.02 GENERAL PLAN OF DEVELOPMENT
The project is a planne~ interchange commecclal center in-
cludinq a mixture of interchange oriented commercial
facilities, and water man8gement related elements. The
P.O.D. Haster Plan, Exhibit .A- is attached.
2.03 COMPLIMICE WITH APPLICABLE ORDINANCES
The project Is intended to be in substantial compliance
W'ith the applicable Collier County ZonIng and SUbdivision
regulations as well 4S other Collier County developnlent
codes in effect at the time permits lind/or plats are re-
quested, except as noted herein.
:2.04 FRACTIONALIZATION OF TRACTS
A. When the develope'r 8ella an entire Tt:'act or a build-
ing pat:'cel lft:'action of a Tract) to a 8ub~equent owner,
or proposes development of such pt:'operty himself, the
developer shall provide to the Administrator for ap-
pro,.al, prior to the. development of the tract by the
developer or, prior to the sale to a aubsequ~nt owner of
such property, a boundary drawing shoving the tract and
the building plIrcel therein (when applicable) and the
sqUAre footage assigned to the property. . Thedt"A"inq
shall also show the location .and sIze of acceSB to
tho!e fractional parts that do not abut a public street.
B. In the event a commercial tract or building parcel is
sold by any subsequent oWn~r, as identified in Section
2.04(Al, in fractional parts to other parties for
development, the subsequent owner shall provide to the
Administt:'Ator, for approval, prior to development of
the tt:'act by the d~veloper or prior 'to the sale of a
subsequent owner of a fractional'- part, A boundary
~rawing showIng his originally purchased tract or
building parcel and the fractional parts therein and
the square footage assigned to each of the fractional
parts. The drawing shall also shoW' the location .and
size of access to those fractional parts that do not
abut a public street.
2-1
ICOI 024 'IOt 190
., '.,,_,:~i: ,\> +.M,
"'~';'l~,.J-' .-....\".r~r.
,. ~.':~':~'.'c~:'fr
............ ......~. >. ':'"1..' j
...,
-
-
-
{- -:' ,.
,"f,,;
/?:
,'t{, ..~/;.~-t~
:>'<"'t;'~'~ ;
"'-v~..i" \~i~;'J.; , .
::/tJ~~ i; (.
c. The developer of any trAct: or building parcel must 8Ub-
mit at the time of application for a building permit, a
detailed plot plan for bis tract or parcel. Such plot
plan shall show the proposed location of all buildings,
access roads, offstreet parking and offstreet lOBding
arebB, refuse and service areas, requ~red yards and
other open spaces, locations for utilities hook-up,
screening and buffering, signs, lighting, landscape
plan, other accessory uses and structures.
D. In evaluating the fractionalization plans the Ad-
ministrator's or hi. designeels decision shall be based
on compliance with the criteria and the development
intent as set forth in this document and the reasonable
accessibility of the fractional parts to pUblic or
private roadway., common Areas, or other. means of
ingress and egress.
E. The maximum number of individual tracts to be fraction-
alb:ed for principal uses as atated in Section 3.02 .(A)
shall be ... parcels. The llaximu1lt number of individual
tracts to be fractionalized for principal uses as
sta~ed in Section 3.02 (B) shall be ... parcelS, however,
1n no instance shall there be more than 4 parcelS with
frontage on Immokalee Road.
P. If Bpproval or denial is not issued within ten ('0)
wor:<ing days, the submission shall be considered AU-
tomatically approved.
2.05 LAND DSeS
Table I is a schedule of the intended land use types, with
approximate acreages incHcated. The arranqement of these
land use types is shown on the P.O.D. Maater Plan. Changes
and variations in design and acreages shall be permitted at
final design to accommodate topography, vegetation and
other site conditions. The specific location and size of
individual tractu and the assignment of specifiC uses
thereto shall be submitted to the Administrator for
approvel as described in Section 2.0.4 of this document.
TABLE I
LAND USE SUMMARY
DESCRrPTION
:{i;',':: ..::... ..
{it::~: ~:m!:t:;~ management
:t-dl.';" , Utility site.
r~:;f,',tl.~;;. ~.,-;" Ac ce I a/Bu f fera/Ki s c.
,\,y . <,'"., '.
It,.:...
"'?t ~t; i:. ':' ('.1.
)i; '.
," -
~.
i ~., .,
.;. ~ .
r
APPROXIMATE AREA
(ACRES). .,..;;",'
,.,'~~W;::'7~:k. t.;~.'l.' w. ":~' '~i"'''( l
'.).~ \ ;-r,,~+;l-~., "
.:.",",{!.1.8!:,t~:!.~;.~ ;'::;;"".;<;' J<tlr.~"
. :: ;\:~~, Q:!:} .~';::r,: ,.:j i-.;~~;i: 1.~:.
" '. ,"~ 7:!;.\!.. "...,.. ,.,',:.'..1' ",\!".,;
.'" ?,r1j.5+'I'~. ""'~'ff,~.~.~:-y,i'
. ""I"7:""""'II'J'.,.. .1t..~ -'.f-" f.!!j". ~'
ID.,1:.:'......":..".. '~,' ~..>1.
Total Site Area
2-2
',,'.
-1m
024mr191
.-..,.~,'~....,,~...-...._<< ._-_.__.. .
2.06 RESERVATION OP NATURAL VEGETATION AND TREE REMOVAL
2.07 EASEMENTS FOR UTILITIES
2.08 EXCEPTIONS TO THE SUBDIVISION RZGULATIONS
:'1:.:.
, ,_ ~. d. .~"
, :JtJ/~'{:H~~!.
,~. ~ -". .;.
, . -
-
-
.,
.i
"
~ ;.; '( ';
.'-,,'.
-;1
.:
"
.: ,r~;
Clearing, grading, earthwork, and site drainage work .hall
be performed in accordance with the applicable Collier
County Development Codes, and standards and commitMents set
forth In this document.
Easements shall be provided for water canageJllent areas,
utiliti~8 and other purposes .. .ay be neede~~ Said ease-
ments and improvements shall be in compliance with the
Collier County Subdivision Regulations.
~11 nece~sary easements, dedications, or other instruments
shall boe granted to insure the continued operation and
maintenance of all service utilities in comp'lianee with
applicable regulations in effeet at the time 8pprovals are
requested.
1. Article XI, Section 10, monuments, valves.
2. Article XI, Section 21, Utility casings (prior to con-
struction.
3. ~rticle XI, Section t7k, reverse curve, Bu~ject to
County Engineer's approval.
,,~ '
"
"
"'."
., <, ~ .
, '
2-3
IDDI 024 PI,,! 192
i
.. ",d"''';:'I'..''~
....u:.cj~,~:.
.~' 'iI,'~'~'.. '
~:";'~f ~ . '.. ,
,I, ~fJ ,'~ I.
,\ 'u. ,.., t.'.. ~
...f:M'\l''l:t'';I
:'::'N(~%!~}.. it,., : q
a
.-,_.~._-'-~---_'-
.~---,-,-,----
-- .-
-
November _
_ Page 7
j:
.....,. :.~.';Jt~\.{,'" ..,'"
.'. ~.'vM"
.,.!~tl~i:~
. .'. ' .' .~...' , ,:', r.=f
:,.,~l'J ~~'-S'
":.r:l."~'I.";~'.!7:~
."
: 'r\
" '
SECTION III
PERMITTED USES AND STANDARDS
~!!
The purpose of this Section is to set forth the permitted
uses an~ development standards for development of the
project.
PERMITTED USES AND STRUCTURES
No building or structure or part thereof, shall be erected,
altered or used, or land or water used, in whole or in part
for other than the following:
A} Interchange Commercial Permitted Principal UseS and
Structures permitted throughout 18.7 acre pareel.
1} Motels, hotels, transient lodging facilities
2) Restaurants, (full service only)
J) Business/professional offices, office/storage,
banks. ..c
4) Rental car agency.
5) Water management facilities and essential services
6) Any other commercial use similar to the foregoing
uses and which the zoning Director determines to
be compatible with the intent of this development.
B) In addition to the above described use., the following
Interchange Commercial Permitted Principal Uses and
Structures are permitted and limited to the northern
interior ~our hundred feet (400') of property fronting
Inunokalee Road. .
A) Automobile service stations
B) Restaurante, (fast food and full service)
C) ,Convenience commercial stores
DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS
A) Minimum Site ALea: Type A uses: 1 acre
Minimum Site Area: Type Buses: 1/2 acre
B) Minimum Site width: One hundred (100) feet as measured
at the front building setback line.
C) Minimum Yard Requirements:
1) Exterior Boundary
Exterior boundary - building, p~rkin9 and impervious
setback of 30 feet shall be provided on a western
and southern project boundaries. This setback area
)-1
aOOl 024. mr 193
"
.
-~.
- ---------
-
-
-
, "
&;\';,\!~",,"'."" , ..
~.:t!~~:i~(~.z.,~~~;; .~;". ',.:.:
~'iJif~'i'!''''.I,_,"i.<'\. ,
, )~4"f,::t:";':(~:":
it,..,.....,
.~ ~. .
~, . -~ ~,. "'. ~ c-'
;,; " "
, ; >~:r.~~:'1~/':: ,:~.r.: .~
"~ j.,;,)~,....t:C'.. '~.i
- ;',;-t,~W;!;~;:;\::,
.'l'
,J .:'" ,I
~.~ :~.
._..r:;'
.;,~~ !.
-:"~' ,"
:;,'"
~, '.'
, '
./'.::
',~ ;-,',,';. ,
~~. ".
1" .~.
, . ~ .
'-~ h'
Rh~ll be kept in na~ive natural ve~etatlon existing
on the site. A berm averaging four (.() feet ahall
be provlcjed in areas oenerally volcJ in native
vegetation. Additional native vegetation shall be
planted if necessary to obtain the opacity required
by the zoning ordinance for a buffer. The buffer
I1hall meet the opacIty requirement by the end of
twelve (12) months from the date of Issuance of the
first certificate of occupancy for the parcel.
Buffering shall be phased to coinciCle with
(Ie....elopment.
These standards will not be required if the
property to the weat and/or south is zoned to a
nlmilar commercial use, in which case a landscaped
ten (101) foot bullding and parking setback shall
be required.
r f the property to the west and/or south is zoned
to a non-residential, non-commercial use, the above
buffering requirements shall not apply and A
lZlndsc~ped fifteen (15) foot building and parking
netback shall be required.
h landscaped ten (10') foot building and parking
oetback fr01!l the eastern project boundary shall be
maintained.
115' J foot building and
northern project boundary
h landscaped fifteen
parking setback from the
Ehall be maintained.
Limited water management facilities [i.e., swales)
may be located in this setback area: however, every
attempt shall be made to limit the amount of tree
clellring. The landsclIpe plan for the :butfer shall
be incorporated into the landscape 'plan to be
approved by the Natural Resources Management
Department and Planning/Zoning Department prior to
issuance of bulldin9 permits.
2) Between Principal Structures
^ distance equal to one-half the Bum of the height
of two adjacent buildings shall be provided.
3) Fractionalization PlIrcels
A minimum fifteen foot (15') building setback shall
be maintained from all fractionalization boundaries
~s described in Secticn 2.04 of this document.
3-2
,-
,.....
024"r,r19t
',-,~, .
~ . ','.-:'
IOQ(
"
.
'.
::'~:'~"~ ",: ;,/<;'~ 1.:r;i:l':
,,-,~,,;i.'{J.;,",.:~}<',r.
"...~"..,. -.'f.!:f
. r, . ,-'.~1\J-'~.', :~:_
""""r.'l"
~':1.-,j;,;.'
<11~l~:.f\" ~:'
t.qt~ ~ . ~
.- '.--;;.'
iJ.l..
l&ii'
f~~.; ,;'I~: ~ . ';,',
.', ..
.] Interior Access Orive
A minimum fifteen foot (IS') building setback shall
be provided along the interior access drive AS
shown on the P.D.D. Master Plan, Exhibit -Aw.
5) Gasoline dispensing operations shall be subject to
the setbacx requirements of the Zoning Ordinance in
effect at the time permits are requested.
Three (3) stories throughout the
0) Maximum Height:
project.
E) Hinhllum Floor Area ot: Principal Structure I One
thousand (1,000) square feet per building on the ground
floor. Exceptions to this requirement for special pur-
pose buildings may be granted by t~e Zoning Director.
F) Maximum Density - Twenty-six (26) units per gross aare
of larad for hotels, motels or tra.nsient lodging
fncilities. Fifteen thousand square feet (15,000)
leasable office area per gross acre. Seventy five
hundr-ed square feet (7500) le8seable area per gross
acre for all other listed principal uses. A maximum of
10,000 square feet of Banking Facilities shall be
permitted. Density shall be determined accorcHng to
the fractionalization parcel in accordance with Section
2.04 of this document.
G) Unless otherwise indicated in this'dc..cument, Ilinimum
standards for signs, parking, lighting, and landscaping
shall be in conformance with applicable Collier County
regulations in effect at the time permit!. are sought.
S) Al though parcela 1, 2, anCl 3 do not have, access frosa
Immokalee Road, the site should, if possible, be
d~si9ned in such a way so that the rear of the
site/building (i.e., loading, solid waste 'receptacles,
etc.) Is not oriented toward Immokalee Road.
, ,
"
'i..._:' ..
lOOK 02~l\[195
3-3
"'-,',:'
t;::....':.:.-.
'J,.-'~' "'
';"; .,
~~:{)";'
::';--..
.j:
,~\.- t..
"., "',..,
,
:~k."
".' <'.'-'
t:
'f.'f)*':~'~. ~""
~J1,(;",t, '
I ~<,.: .' ,', ,
'. ;~~':~~'
l,,:,1tJ', ..
~~1.l:.~',',' .
~",;..,," .
~';,i _'}.'\~ .
, ,;.',
~ ' .>
.~',
SECTION IV
GENERAL COMMITMENTS
..01 PUHPOSE
The purpose of this Section 1s to set forth the general
commitment. agree~ to by the project developer.
A) WATER MANAGEMENT
1) Detailed site drainage plan shall be submitted to the
County Engineer for review. No construction permits
shall be issued unles8 and until approval of the
proposed construction in accordance with the
submitted plans is granted by the County Engineer.
2) An Excavation Pe~it will be required for the
proposed lake in accordance with Collier County
Ordinance No. 8-26, 8S amended by Ordinance No. 83-3,
~nd AS may be amended in the future.
B) UTILITIES
') I'otable vater lIay be provided by either a central
r.ystem connected to the Collier County Water System,
or by on-site wells end treatment facilities, should
the County system be unavailable at the time of
development.
2) 11.11 areZls of the project shall be servu~ by a central
uAstewater collection. system and by . WAsteWAter
treatment plant. The plant shall be expanded to meet
the project demands and shall be phel!'!d=-out at 'such
time ZlS a County system becomes available.
3) The development shall be in cOllp1iance, with e.ppll-
clIble county law8 and ordinances qovernin9 utility
provisions and facilities.
') 'relephone, power service Shall be made available to
the site.
5) The Utilities Division stipulations per their JDeMO
dllted Hay 7, 1986, are attached hereto and
incorporated herein by reference.
~'
~ ~; ';
"
, ,~
\,,-
~,. ,
;F-"
~!
4-1
1001 024 ",! 196
.;,-
{:, "1;
I..'.,.,:.
_:,,' .
"
;j
'~,-
:';'.:tt::'~~
'" ' _ _,' .""! 1'.;t. :~'.., _ ~
", ',"''''f,,'2lli
\ .,:.~..}:.:~:t~~;,W~"~' r't:~.
. '. , ....
-
-
-
"'.
,).
. ", ~
".::t
"
C) TRANSPORTATION
1) The developer shall provide left and right turn loneo
on Immokalee Road at the project entrance.
2) The developer shall lIlake a fair share contribution
toward the capital cost of a traffic sIgnal at the
project entrance when deemed warranted by the County
Engineer.
3) The developer shall provide arterial level street
lighting at the project entrance.
4) The above required imp~overnent8 are considered ~site
related- as defined In Ordinance 85-55 and shall not
be applied a8 credits toward any impact fees required
by that ordinance.
5) Based upon the existing four-lane scction on CR 846
under 1-75 and in consideration of a future six-lane
urban section, the needed right-af-way is reduced
from 50 feet to 25 feet and the right-Of-way donation
is propose-d by easement agreement. Since the
t" ight-of-way donation is essentially to be used for
access improvements under the four-lane condition,
the donation should not be subject to a road impact
fee credit. Also, the land upon which the e"sement
is to be located vill remain the property of the
adjacent p~operty ovner in consideration of landscape
type improvement.
6) Since drainage under. the future six-lane urban
condition' will require an additional outfall and
since the Stiles project incorporates -an overflow
cross drain on CR 946 into the canal along the north
side of CR 846, another road~ay condition for a'
future multi-lane section is to allo~ road runoff to
exist the roadway system via the proposed cross
drain. Accordingly, the County requires access to
the crOBS d~ain for removal of excels roadway runoff
in the futu~e multi-lane condition.
7) As currently proposed, th,e extension of the existing
four-lane road section to the west end thru a common
median opening for Regency vtilage and Stiles
Development is highly recommended. Such an extension
of a four-lane facility will be Bubject to A fair
share road impact fee credit as. applicable to the
added thru lanes. Also, by extending the four-lane
segment thru a common intersection both developers
will be assured of a median opening under the
four-lane condition.
4-2
,cc~ ~4l'I\!jl!l"7
ii'
"f,;.;.~:
::t-~:
""',
..~ >;,'"".
..,-----,---.,,~ .'--. ....
. ....."u. ,,~,. "_,,. _....p--_.,.,-_......_..,~.-
-
-
-
" .,ff~
A;W~i4i':!i';'/': . ," ,::,;.,;.~.?\j'\;;~:\:i;;;L:':!.i~'h.Yi
:h~ tl--~'i~~'" f:'" . . . ' 'l;~i''f~,l,~;tJ,.,',',:"t.i,,~.,,}\~r: "j~ !tl~~~~<~11 ~~~#~;9~ ,;,
l;::;/~ ~:;:-Y~:'i"IIASTER PLAN' ..
~,::\~ A P.D.D. Master plan (wMBS'P File No. RZ-1J3, Sheet 1 of
1. 2) has been provided to assign land uses within the
;'-;;" overall site. In order to facilitate necessary
modifications and changes, while preserving the overall
intent of this P.D.D., .a described in thia document and
depicted by the Haster Plan, all phases of project
development shall be required to obtain administrative
approval In conformance with the Collier County Site
Development Plan Approval process.
E) PROJECT DeVELOPMENT
The intent of this PUD la to be In compliance with the
Collier County Comp~ehenslve Plan ~hich state8 that
.Collier County i8 a unique community and the land uses
8urrouncHng the interchanges should reflect. this. In
many cases, the first qlimpse of Collier County that
visitors see is upon their exit from the inteI"state~
Therefore, the 8urrounding land uses should exemplify
the quality of life which Collier County residents" have
come to enjoy and expect~.
To comply ~ith the intent of the Comprehensive Plan, the
petitioner Agrees to meet the fOllowing criteria:
l' To retain on-site vegetatloh and to provide land-
scaping using but. not, limited to nat"~ve species as
much as possible to preserve the integrity of the
environment,
2) To provlde an integrat.ed site plan whi"ch provides
for integrated development of the parcel anc! 1ta
relationShips to surroundIng land,
3 )
To establish an architectural
with tho Applicoblo Collier
Standards.
theme that complies
County ~ Codes and
...) To provide internal pedestrian access between all
parcels and uses within the development~
"
5) To develop the sites along Immokalee Road in"such a
w~y a8 to provide the appearance of the front ot the
property avoiding or effectively screening loading
areas, trash receptacles and the..like.
<
~'!
, "
';);:\~~l~ft
~-3
"
. '4:.~
,
1001 Uu'm 198
i
,','
"
,'" .'"
- .~----- --
-~~ ---- ~"_._~--,---
-
-
-
"
;. '.~ '
"
~ ',;.
"
',,'
, ,
"-".
..J:,'
. . ~ '
.., .':
;I
';"
F) ENVIRONMENTAL
1. A site clearinq plan shall be submitted to the
Natural Resources Management Oepartment and
Community Development Division for their review and
approval prior to any substantial work on site.
This plan may be submitted in phases to coincide
....ith the development schedule. The site clearing
plan shall clearly depict how the final site layout
incorporates retained native vegetation to the
maximum extent possible and how roadst buildings,
lakes, parking lots, and other facilities have been
oriented to accommodate this goal.
2. Native species shall be utilized, where available,
to the maxiMum extent possible in the site land-
scapin9 design. A landscaping plan will be sub-
mitted to the Natural Resources Management Depart-
ment and Community Development. Division for their
revieW' and approval. This plan ",ill depict the
incorporation of native species and their mix .with
other species, if any. The goal of site landscaping
shall be the re-creation of native vegetation and
habitat characteristics lost on the site during
construction or QUe to past activities.
3. All exotic plants, as defined' in th~ County Code,
shall be removed during elllch phase of construction
from development areas, open spaCe ,"Ireas, and pre-
serv~ AreAS. Fol1o~ing site development a
maintenance prcgram shall be i~plemented to prevent
reinvAsion of the site by such exotic specieB~ This
plan, which will describe control techniques and
inspection intervals, shall be filed wlth and. ap-
proved by the Natural R~sourceB Management.
Department and Community Development OivIsion.
4. If during the course ot. site clearing, ~ excavation,
or other constLuctional activities, an
archaeOlogical or historical aite, artifact, or
other indicator i. discovered, all 6evelopment at.
that location shall be immediately stopped and the
Natural Resources Management Oepartment notified.
DevelOPMent will be suspended for a sufficient
length of time to enable the Natural Resources
Management Department or a designated consultant to
assess the find and determine the proper course of
action in regard to its salVAgeability. The Natural
Resources Management Department will respond to any
such notification in a timely and efficient mAnner
so as to provide only a minimal interruption to. any
constructional activities.
4-4
~: ~ )..
lOOK fJUPllt199
~~
;;.
~
. _..~.,.~._--,._~._--"-'-'--'-_.
-
-
-
Agenda Ite
Novembe'r
Paoe'
j
',,","
",'
',.'
,'r ;: .~
.,
"
. ~~
I~ 'd
,'",' .j
;,1
s. The lake should be designed ldth a littoral zone
that allows for vegetation along the western edge,
and that the excavation de8ign shall be submitted to
Natural ResourceS Management Departllent for review
and approval or disapproval.
6. A retention system shall be constructed to retain
pollu~ant-laden vater for awhile instead of allowing
vater to enter the lake immediately.
G) OPEK SPJ'.CB
1. Open 8pace shall be provide~ to Meet the
requirement. for a COllUDerclal PUD under the 20n1n9
Ordinance in effect at the time permits are
requested.
H) EKGINEERING
1. The proposed entrance to ReqencyVillage of Naples,
on the north side of lmmokalec Road, is near this
project. This entrance should be shown on the
master plan and the road of Stiles Corporation for
this project (Stiles Corp.) should be alignec!l with
it if possible. A realignment of the main entrance
road Bhall only require approval of the County
Engineer and Plannlng!Zoningoirector.
2. Access to all parcels fronting Immolalee Road shall
be from the main road with no direct driveway access
from each parcel to Immokalee Road. '
3.
The main road
standard for a
'right-at-way ..Y
pavement
require~
street.
shall meet the
.inor col1ector.
be as required for 4
Iftinimuat.
Th.
local
I) FIRE CONTROL
1. Hater Illain and hydrants will be required and all
buildings must meet current ood~..
J) OTHER COMMITMENTS
1. Project development shall commence within three
years from date ot approval.
,-
IDD! D24'm200
~-5
"
'h ,.'
I
-------- --.-.-
-
-
.~. .
-
-
r, ~'^
"
-.'--,
-
-
MEMORANDUM
OA~ Hay 1. 1986
'1"Y;~',~~"",.,.~~~,~:t..; Plaflninll: Depart1u.nt
J~';-'<S~J~ :_,
~ . .,,-. '
~ . .". .
, ,p,:" .... ,.Ut1o.1-B6-IOC. BtU.. cO"l'orat:_"" P1lI>
-;'::,'
,
I)
:
"
v. Wtv. reviewed the abovarafar.Deed Pad-Hon and have DO objection to
the re~ODa .. reque.t&d~ However, va requ1r. tba follov{f1g .tipulatio~
a. a caudi~ion to our recommendation {or approval:
-;.) water' Srvar
~
~
l~~. .
,\-;-.
1) 'Water diatribut10D and .evaa. c011_et1011 anI! tranai..11m
.,.ata.. will ba con.truetacl throuehout tha project development by tb.
developer puragant to all curr.n: r.quire~Dt. of Collier County and the
Stat. of Florida. Yater and aever taeilltie. can.tructed vithin platted
rishte-of-vay or within utility ea..m.nt. required by the Couct,. aball be
conveyed to the County for ownerahip, operation and -.intenanca purpose.
punuaot to appropriate (;Qunty Ordinancea and regulationa in ethct at
the tilDe ot conveyance. All vat.r and .ev.r facil1th. con.tructed OD
private property and not required b,. the Count,. to be loe:ated w1thin
utilit,. ea.emente ehall be OVDed~ operated and ..ineained by the
DevelopeYo hi. a..1gna or aue:e:...or.. Upon completion of construction of
the vater and sewer faciIit1.. vithin ths project, the facilities vill b.
tutd to inaut"ll they ...c Collier Count)"'. utility can'tructi01l
require.ents in effect at the tiae con.truction plana are appro...ed. Th.
above tasu lllUet b. compbt.d to tba ,atidactloD af the Ut111t1u
Diviaion prior to placing any utility faei1itle., County owned or
privately owned, ineo .ervice. Upon co-rbtiou of th. vat.r and/or
sever facil1eiu and prior to tha 1"uaoc8 of CertHicate. of OCcupancy
for .eruet'Jt"u withitl. th. project the utility hc11iti.. .hall ba con-.
veted to the County. vhea required by the Utilit1... Dirt.ton. purauaat
to County Ordinances and Resulation. in effect at tha tim:- con....,..nca 1a
reque.ted.
2) All e~truetioa plana and technical apec1f1e.tion. atld propo..d
plata. 1l appl1c.abl.~ for tha propoaed ntar dbtdbutlOl1 and .evag.
collection and tranald.don facil1du auat h. r.viewed atld approved by
the Vtl11tl~a DIvisiOn prior to Co.mance..nt of conatruction.
3) All CUlltOla&n conneceinC to tha ..atar cUatrtbution and ..vaS_
collection faeilit!ea will be customera of the County and viI1 b. billed
by th. County 1n aceordanc. witb the County'a eatabli.bed rat... Should
the County not be in & po.itlon to provide vater -and/or aever aeTVie. ~o
the project, the vater and/or _ever c:uatomera ahall be cuato.era of the
interiJI utility estsblt_bed to aerY. the project until the Count,.'.
off-.ite vater and/or .ever {acllie!e. ar. availabl. to 'arYe th.
project.
;,..:
1001 U2{'I'E2o:J
~~'.
"
--_...~ -.--....-
i
...-.-------
-
-
..
-f
: ~
'tz{"
,," ,.
:i~-d'(\ :a:t~~ . / -'.'
. J ;..r", t!~;r.-, ~ ' ~.
:j~ 1:~;f:~.!~~f' A1 ~ - '
. "'~;:';'~;,_.,~~' ~;_ ,1
.j ( , . ~ '. ,
.', t.":'; .J
:\.~\';
", '
DoptJ.r
To; ADD. HcJ.~,
hC.2,
Kay 7, 1986
Plannins
4) It 18 antldpated that the Count,. VtUit1u Divid.OD will ultiaately
wpply pot alII. vater to mut tbe l:on-=rptlva deund and/or reedve and
trut the I-:vage generated by th,ta project. Should the Count)' 8,.atea
nQt be 1n & podtion to' .upply potable vater to the project and/or
'ncaive the project'. "..C,.eter at tbe tilu de'Yelop1ll.ent COIKIZIenc:ea.. tbe
Developer, .t hi. expen.., Yill tnatal1 and operate intaria vater .upply
and oD-aite treat.ent facl1!tt.. and/or intart. on-alta ..vaga tre.tmen~
and ~ipo..l heilitiu adequate to. .eet .11 requlremlllnu crf ..~h'.
appropriate regulatory agenciea. - ~ ~
5) AD Agree~ct aball be entered into becveen the County and the
D.veloper, 111nd1cI CD the Dev.lop.r. bis asdps or auccaaaors. legally
aceeptabl. to the County. prior to tha appraYal Df conatruceian docuaenta
for the propoaed project, .tating that:
a) The propo.d vater suppl,. and on-aite trutwleat hciItths and/or
on-.lte v.atevater treaODeat and dispo.al taclIit!.., if required; ar. to
b. con.eructed ... part of the pt'opoud projac:c and 8Uat b. regarded a.
interilll; th.,. ahall ~a tonatruct.d to Stat. and Federal atandard. and
are to be ovned, operatad and s&1ata1nad b,. the Developer, his ...igna or
auccesllora until such tille a. tb. County'. off-.it. vater facilities
and/or off-du sewer facilities an available to serTice tbe proj.c:t.
The interim treatlllent facilities ahall auppl,. services onl,. to tho..
landa ovned by the Developet' and approved b,. the County for development.
The utility hdlity(iea) may not b. .xpanded to proTide "aur and/or
..vcr service outside the development boundary approved b, the Count,
witbout tbe vritten con.ent of the County.
b) Upon cocneetion to the County'. oft-dte vater fac:Uit1e., and/or
arwer facilltie., the Developer. hi. .aaigna or aucc..aor. .ball abandon,
dialllaDth aud re.ova frea th. dt. the 1ntaria vater .nd/or aevage
true.ent faeility and dhcont1nue usa of th. vat.r IUPP'1.y .ourc., if
applicable, in a ..nner conai,tant with State of rlorida .tan4ard..
All work r.l~t.d with thi. activity ,hall b, p.rformed. at no co.t to the
Count,...
c) Coanect.loD. to the County'. off-aite vater and/or .,evtr fac:ilitiu
vill be ..d, b,.. the owner., their a..i(O. or aucce.6orl at DO coat to the
County with1:=! 90 day. after .uc:h facilitiu becou avdlabh. Thl co.t
of conneetion _hall include. but Qat b. limited to, .11 engineering
duip and prepauticn of conatruct1oD doc:umentl, peraittina, IIOd1fiea-
tion or refitting of existiog ,evage pu=piD& factlie!ea or c~truct!Oft
of nev ...ter .evage pumping facilities, Interccmnection vith County
off-aite facilities, vater and/or .ewer linel Dec:uI.ry to aka tb.
eonnection(a), .tc.
.,
!,.;-.
",:I:'.,,::.i,.. :,',,~.<,'~L
., r: ;.,j, .:,-....,.f!I. ""p;,~.A ,
, ..\,'1;' ,-...';".4! - ....'.,i-.-,..... . ',l;:'
''>:' .. ".~t,t.",l~~t,f~~
. "o':-';?'/t ">: \:Jif
,," '
,
"
IDD! 024 '"r 204
I
.___.._,~._,_...~___M....."
--~._..._._----~
-
.' :-,1f,
"':;
:', ;~..,:~: ~ . '
,,~. .
"T':""
.,:
..
l TOl AnD. Mdfa,
, Pala 3
, !lay, 7. 198&
D.p.r~tJ r
Pucm.la.1
4) At the tia. County off-atca vater and/or aever faclllt!.. are
......nable for the project to ccmacct with, the following water and/or
..var taciItti.. ahall b.. conveyed to the County purau.nt to appropriate
County Ordinanc~. and Regut.tlona In elfeet at the time:
1) All vaUT and/or uftr fadl1t1e' con.tructed in publicl,.
OYDed rights-of-way or vithfa uel11t1 e..ement. required by the
C2tinty within the project l:1J1liu. required to ..u connact1Oll.
Vtth the County'. off-dte .w.ter .nd/o~ .lNn facUltiu; or,
2) All vater and .ever faellttle. required to eoanect the
project to the County'. off-aite vater .ndtor lever facllltl..
wben the on-alt. vater and/or .~r tacillt!.. ar. con.eructed
on privuc property and Dot required b,. the Count,. to be
located Y1thin utility ..ee=cnt., including but Dot l1ait.d to
the following:
.) Main sevage lift .tatioa and
connecting Yith tbe County .ever
all utility ea.~m~nt. n.e....ry;
force ....1n itl.ter-
f.cilitiee . including
b) Watu dbtributiou. faciliti.. fro. the polet of
connection vitb the County.. vetar facilitiea to tbe
aanar vater Mter aerv1.ug tbe project, heludlng .11
utilit,. ea.ements necea.ary.
e) The cuatomeu lJerved on en 1cteria b.d. by the ~t!lit:,. .yaU.
conaeructed by the Dn.doper .hall bacoae cuatDIHra ot the Caucty at eha
ti.. vben County off-.ite vater and/or .ever f~cl1iti.a are availabl. to
aerve the project and .uch contIectiOD 1. ..de. Prior to COOnectioD of
the project to the County'. off-liu "aur and/or aeWlr .facUities the
Developer. bi_ .aaign.. ot" .ucce..or., shall turn over eo tb. County.
complete 11_t of the cu_t~r_ eervad by tha !nt.ria utilit1e. a,._t.. and
ahall Dot coapet. vith tba Coutlt7 for the ..rvlc. cf thoa. CUUOMra.
The Developer ahall .lao provide the Count7 vith . detailed inventory of
th. f.dl1t!u nrnd vithin the project and tha entIty wbich rill b.
ruponaibll! for the vater and/or ..wer .ervica billine tor the project.
f} All conetructlon plana and technical apacifications ralata4 to
connectiona to the Counc.,.I. ofC-aite water and/or .."ar !acllitta. vill
ba eub.it.ted to tha Utllit1.. Div1aio'Q for reviev .tad IlpprC'Tal priDr tD
cammancematat of conltructioD.
,...:
,.;-.
,', ;,' .,w\;~;:k5}l
'. ."~.~:,":\:;(!7?~~" /f=:
'CD! U24...,,[205
I~'
1(,
.~.;(.: ,.'" .,:':~~:i~;'.~('~
Jl':'t,,:,,-~~.II:':' ."',,
.1,;rt\71!J-";I;"~.:.~ - .
~. -:-..
,-:;
",
.
._.._.-.-._.~-----_.._-'_.~-_..-.
_.~._..._-_..-..- -
----------
,.
"
To: AnD Hc.~.,
PaS_ 4
Ka1 7, 1986
Plannins
.:.
-, ,'..'
'. ';""Yl't'-i. T'
.\~~: :,~:~f:(:t:
. .~ ~ ; ~~ ,;' , .
>,' "1.
f<~;;~.'
:..
Aoe
". . _,' _ '-"',1.'. ...'.l;,;;""'"
.".-'1."'<"""1,1.',:" .'tv.;u".,.:"t:!!'>.
. -,.~ ";~ ~ -''''',',. '~i\"" I
'.':~!~"J;r~~;}fl/~~.\ ~~-' ;~~i:'}., 1.
:~.~:':~;~,i~_i:};. ~J1::~, "-'?~l:;~?~
,,~;I(' "-oJ- " 'f,.~1.1 ".,,,,1:1
',':; '\<:~) ,}t~Cf
. . .i"'t '.. t
..
I) The n.veloper, hll ...iSO- or auc.e...or. _ere. to pay .11 .,..t..
devdopDCDt: c.hars.. at the tiM that lulldias: Pendu ara required,
punuaDt to appropriate Count' Ordin.a.tu:.. and Resuutiona in effect at
the time of Fermie requeet. Thi. requ!rceeat ahall be ~d. known to .11
proe:pec.tive buyeu of propntiu for wbieb buUdinl. pan-ita v111 b.
requIred prior to the start of building-construction.
h) The-County vill leaee to the Developer for operatioD apd malntenane_
tha "fcer distribution and/or ""aga dollect:ion and tnnnlnicm .y.t,._
for the aua of $10.00 per year, vhen .uth ayate. i8 not connected to the
off-8ite vac~r and/or aever facilities awned and operated by the County.
'l'et1D8 ot the lea.e ah.dl be determined upon completion of the propolled
utillty construction and prior to activation' of the vater aupply,
treataent and diatribution taeilitie. and/or tha a.vag* collection,
cran..i..icn and treatment raeilfti.a. The Lea.., if rlquired, .ball
remain in effecc until the County can provide vaCer and/or sevlr s.rviee
through its off-des facilities or until such time that bulk rata vater
and/or aever service agreamenta ara nelotLeted with tbe interia utility
systEm. serving the project.
;""
.;.
.',
",.:".'-t.,
nepu';'n.; r
I":
1-.:'
B) Data required under County Ordinance No.' 80-112 .hoving the avail-
abilitT of aevaga aerviee, .ust b. .ubmitted and approved by the
Utllitiu Division prior to approval Dr the con.truction dOClmeflts for
thl project. Sub.it. cop,. of ~ha approved DEB. pendtl for the .."a.a
col1<<ction &nd tran..l.sioD .yate.. and the vaateveter tre&tuent facilley
to be utilized, upon receipt thereof.
C) If an ioteria on-alte vater supply. trea~Qt 4nd tranaai..icn
facility h utiliz.d to ..". the prapo..d project, it wat b. properl,.
.1:.d to aupply av.r.c. and p.ak 4&1 d~.t!~ de..nd. iD'.dditioa to fir.
flaw de..nd at . rate approvad by the appropriate lir. .Concrol Diatriet
servicing the project area.
D) Conatruction and ownership of the vater and aevar tacilitie.,
including an1 propos.d intert. watar and/or a.va.a trea~nt tacilit1..,
sn.l1 b. in compliance with all Ueiliti.. Divi.ion St.nda~d., Polici...
Ordinancea, Practices, etc. in effect at tha tiaa conatruction .pproval
1. l'''qu~.ted~
E) Detailed hydraulic deaitn reporea coverinl the water distribution and
.evag. collection and tranaci.alan a,..t~ to aerie th. project muat b.
auhaftted with the conatruction docu.anta for tha project. The report.
.hall ltat .11 desiga ...umptions, demand raCe. and otber faetor.
pertinent to the sYB~e. under consideration.
~~~:;;~~;&J'l. .,
lOOK 024'1'-' 206
j ': ~~~,fi?..~ .~~' :.. t/:;
"
'"
.," '"
r
.____w__----
-
-
-
-
Y) Prior to approval of con.true~1CD documents by the Utilitiea Divi.ion,
the Developer must present verlfleatlou, purSUCnt to ~pt.r 367. Florida
StatUte., that the Florida Public Service Commi..ion ba. IT.nted territo_
ri.l right. to the Developer to provide sever and/or WAter service to the
project, if an interim truttllent faell1t"Ch.) 1. requil'ed, until th.
County can provide thua aervlcu through ita vater and Sever faeilities.
C) Wh.!;D the Count,. has the ability. to provide .."ase tnatlllent ind"~';=:
ai.paid and vater .uppl, "hie..,l th..~ neveloper,. hi. ...t,ena. 01'( ,"
,uee..,ora vil1 b. reaponsible to connect to tho.. taeiliti.. at . point to
b. .at.bIt.hed by the County, with the Developer ..'umiDa .l~ Coate tor tb.
Connection '~rk to b. p.rformed.
,
"
. "', , "~:\;l~"
, ,., ./'".' " .,;. ?" ;~~d /j,~;:11~':~I':J.,
" , ,'::: . . .," '- ,'.. I. "<-..1" !'" ,~,\Pl,i"" .' ,,,,"
,';.;.., 1"0<";: ;),l.i'~;i >~;;;fll1-'I):'i. ,
',"',0'''''f'l''i'~';,:,;t"",," ."~''':~ if'i t~;j,.'j ".ii,
.~ '~:'. ~_:-.' ;)~ ;'i,~11'., -'.:' '\::'" . :~'{V :~ f~<r~:f :. ",./::-,_-;;,1:t ..
./;-.., :J." -. ',_.,'.''1;, !t:l!"',\f:.IIf~;.c.~'_V~..{~t1
~,Ii ,<,' ';~'I;"'!)' ';~'("~~'lS:~:'j":t~
R)' Section ~.Ol B Otl1:1.t11U of the PV'D docUIlent .hall be nvbed to mau
referanca to this .eaorandu., by data. and .pec1ly the Petitioner's
acceptanee of the .tip'llations COntained herein. A nvlaed copy of th'e POD
doeument and draft Ordinance for the rezoning approval must be submitted to
the Utili tie. Division for review and approval prior to the Petition beinC
conl1dered by the Board of County Commis.ioners.
m1/oh O~
eCI ~ D. lteynolds v"'"
, '
, '
.-:.'
,~:..
,.;;~t::,
:"-'
!..'
:}'.~:.,-;~].
i .).t-, .;
';, .
","
;" ~. <
4",->t.,.-'
-~(: '''; ,
.'
.i
lOa! U24 Pl'E 207
;. ;' .~'
-
-
-
\.~
'>1,,0
"
'.1\'
~!
"
j;:
~'f
;i~
'I~i.;,.,., ,
~;
~ii~"
'If
STATE OF ~LC~:~A
co~:y OF COL~I~~
!. =kV,~S 8. GILES, Cle~k o~ Courts jn and for ~he
7wentleth Judicial Ci~cult, Col1~e~ County, Flori~a. do
hereby certify t~a~ ~~e !ore~~~~~ ~s a true ori~inal of
O~:::,~;'.:7=!: :-::;. 8S-SS
t~a":; .,a5. a'':'o;~_~~ ":.",- ".:..(: 30a=~ o~ CO'J.:lty CO:Il::l~ssj,o~ers d\i.ring
Regular Sess:o~ O~ t~e 2~t~ ~~y 0: AU~J.st. :ge(.
WITNESS ~y ~a~~ ~~~ t~p. c~~!c~a; sea; of the 30ard 0: County
Com~l&sioners o~ Co:::e:- Cc~~tl" ;:o=lca, th:s 2~~ day of
Septe:nber. : 9 8 6.
;;,:.::::s c. a::::.zs
C :e:k 0: CO'.1rts l!.~;1..' c}.~n1A""""
~:.:-c=tic~o to the.i~~!?V~'QI .....,
County comm18.1ot\ji'ft!}c;),,~,'''~h.. Jio/. ".
t .~ ....,~~.~ii~.\.....". ",
" _~. ....i"1'\.,.~....I... -.'"
. ". ",\\1-, '~.... _
; -::.~' ' '-~.'''. ';.,
:--.; . n ~:::;...
. '.'~:o:
M.g~~ - t.Y'iG t '" f
.\,.......... .J.~.:,....... i!!i
. :0;",::-, ;~:."".~Q':::./
, ,..-to a~'IC~ .,.,.,
............",..'
'D...
-, .
IDD! 024 m, 208
ORDINANCE 97-~
i ~ ::.J~'......
II?;:
"
\
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING ORDINANCE NUMBER
"_ 91-102, THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT
~'CODE, WHICH INCLUDES THE COMPREHENSIVE
..' ZONING REGULATIONS FOR THE UNINCORPORATED
AREA OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, BY
AMENDING THE OFFICIAL ZONING ATLAS MAP
NUMBERED B630N BY CHANGING THE ZONING
CLASSIFICATION OF THE HEREIN DESCRIBED REAL
PROPERTY FROM "PUD" TO "PUD" PLANNED UNIT
DEVELOPMENT KNOWN AS THE STILES PUD, FOR
PROPERTY LOCATED ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF
IMMOKALEE ROAD (C,R. aq6) APPROXIMATELY ~
MILE WEST OF THE INTERSECTION OF 1-75 AND
IMMOKALEE ROAD, IN SECTION 30, TOWNSHIP 48
SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST, COLLIER COUNTY,
FLORIDA, CONSISTING OF 18.13 ACRES;
PROVIDING FOR THE REPEAL OF ORDINANCE
NUMBER 86-58, AS AMENDED, THE FORMER STILES
PUD; AND BY PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
Aqenda Item No
November 27, 2
Page 86 of
V> =
~
~ '"
n
'"
~ ,.,
-<
>-
'" ......, r
<
'" .... m
~ ...'
V> -v 0
-< :>:
,..
.... to
~ .....
WHEREAS, Barbara H. Cawley, AICP of Wilson, Miller, Barton & Peek,
This Ordinance shall become effective upon filing with the
Department of State.
-1-
Inc., representing Owen M. Ward, Trustee, petitioned the Board of County
Commissioners to change the zoning classification of the herein described
real property;
NOW THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF
The Zoning Classification of the herein described real property
located in Section 3D, Township q8 South, Range 26 East, Collier County,
Florida, is changed from "PUD" to UPUDtI Planned Unit Development in
accordance with the PUD Document, attached hereto as Exhibit "1\", which
is incorporated herein and by reference made part hereof. The Official
Zoning Atlas Map numbered 8630N, as described in Ordinance Number 91-102,
the Collier County Land Development Code, is hereby amended accordingly.
Ordinance Number 86-58, as amended, known as the Stiles PUO, adopted
on August 26, 1986 by the Board of County Commissioners of Collier
~unty, is hereby repealed in its entirety.
SECTION THREE:
'Il
.l ~
, .l .,.,~
, '
.
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA;
SECTION ONE:
SECTION TWO:
P~SSED AND DULY ADOPTED by the Board of County Commissioners
c/ S ,/ /
Collier County, Florida, this day of (~".'"'u , . 1997.
Aoenda Item I~
of November 27,
Page 87 of
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BO~RD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORID~
,,/
,~~ ,/' I'
4//
./
Approved as to Form and
Legal Sufficiency
""lJ ordlnant:. flied wltt1 me
SKretory of ~ Office thl
~da-t 0' , aa.
and acknovorl.clg~nt of thot
fillno M_c!i~d ,hi, ~ day
of _~--, /'~7 '7"',,( I
BY._n~" >f
0-,.", ClIirto
~
'-.')1.~.;,h-1.~
Marj ie M. Student
Assistant County Attorney
f!PUD-I!6-10(4)
.
-2-
.
~,
.
STILES pun
PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT
AMENDMENT
Section 30
Township 48 South, Range 26 East
'-'ollier County, Florida
PREPARED FOR:
OWEN WARD, TRUSTEE
866 97TH A VENUE NORTH
NAPLES, FLORIDA
PREPARED BY:
Barbara H. Cawley, AICP
WILSON, MILLER, BARTON & PEEK, INC.
3200 Bailey Lane, Suite 200
Naples, Florida 34105
DATE ORIGINALL Y APPROVED
ORDINANCE NUMBER
AMENDMENT DATE
OIWINANCE NUMBER
AMENDMENT FILED
ORDINANCE NUMBER
Agenda Item No, 8e
November 27,2007
Page 88 of 127
Aueust26. 1986
&Sll
.Tllne 24, 1988
H.8::S:l
Julv 31.1997
97-74
.
.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
LIST OF EXHIBITS
TABLE OF CONTENTS
STATEMENT OF COMPLIANCE AND SHORT TITLE
SECTION I
SECTION II
SECTION III
SECTION IV
Il)'I.IIill_2'l7..V....Dl'.BC.w~
..\....._....
NCW5+<<l1..oo&-mJo..1C/'l!JS
LEGAL DESCRIPTION, PROPERTY
OWNERSHIP, & GENERAL DESCRIPTION
PROJECT DEVELOPMENT
INTERCHANGE COMMERCIAL
LAND USE DISTRICT
DEVELOPMENT COMMITMENTS
u.Q.E
Aaenda Item No, se
I',Tovember 27, 2007
Page 89 of 127
I
ii
iii
1-1
2-1
3-1
4-1
L-
Exhibit A
Exhibit B
.
IMItl.1'141 v. O".BC.~
n......~.
NCWSMlO1.ooB-1'I'UD-109(IS
LIST OF EXHIBITS
PUD Master Plan (WMB&P File No. RZ - 251)
Map of Boundary Survey (WMB&P File No, 4L-1104)
ii
Agenda Item No. 8e
November 27,2007
Page 90 of 127
Aaenda Item No, 8e I
rJovember 27, 2007
Page 91 of 127
STATEMENT OF COMPLIANCE
This document amends and restates the PUD Ordinance Number 88-54, as amended. It is
submitted by Owen Ward. Trustee, hereinafter referred to as the Developer. This PUD, as
amended and restated, pertains to 18.13 acres of land located in Section 30. Township 48 South,
Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida. This document is required by the Collier County Board
of County Commissioners in accordance with Section 2,7,3.4 of the Collier County Land
Development Code which requires an unimproved PUD to be made consistent with all sections of
the current Growth Management Plan and Land Development Code if development has not
commenced within five years of the approval date, This amended and restated PUD document is
intended 10 comply with the items listed by the Board of County Commissioners as not
consistent, to bring the Stiles PUD into compliance with the Growth Management Plan and Land
Development Code, but not to significantly change the underlying commercial zoning of the
PUD.
The name of this Planned Unit Development is "The Stiles PUD" hereinafter called "the Project",
n,e development of the Project is in compliance with the planning goals and objectives of Collier
County as set forth in the Growth Management Plan and with other land development regulations
adopted thereunder, including but not limited to the Collier County Land Development Code
(hereinafter called the Code) for the following reasons:
1. The subject property is in the Interstate Activity Center as identified on the Future Land Use
Map as required in Objcctive I of the Future Land Use Element (FLUE). The purpose of the
Interstate Activity Center is to concentrate almost all new commercial zoning in locations
wherc traffic impacts can readily be accommodated, to avoid strip and disorganized pattems
of commercial development and to create focal points ",ithin the community.
2, The proposed development intensity and use of the Project for commercial actiVIty as
specified in Section 2,6 and Section [[I of this PUD document is consistent with Section VI of
the FLUE which allows for a full array of commercial uses at designated Interstate Activity
Centers,
.
3. The Project is compatible with and complemenlal)' to existing and future surrounding land
uses as required in Policy 5.4 of the Future Land Use Element.
4, Improvements are planned to be in compliance with applicable land development regulations
as set forth in Objective 3 of the Future Land Use Element.
ttnl91.W7<tl v. Ol1-8C~......,
"-.......-,..
NOot~4lII-"UO'}0'XI,
iii
l
Agenda Item No, Be
November 27, 2007
Page 92 of 127
5, The development of the Project will result in an efficient and cconomical extension of
community facilities and serviees as required in Policies 3, J.H and L of the Future Land Use
Element.
6, The Project is planned to incorporate natural systems for water management in accordance
with their natural functions and capabilities as may be required by Objective 1.5 of the
Drainage Sub-Element of the Public Facilities Element.
7, The Project is a functionally interrelated commereial development and is planned to
encourage ingenuity, innovation and imagination as set forth in Section 2.2.20.1 of the Code,
and Section VI and Policy 5.6 of the Future Land Use Element.
8. The Project is located within a designated Interstate Activity Center within the Urban District.
thereby discouraging urban spr'vl as required by Policy 5.3 ofthe Future Land Use Element.
9. The Project is served by a complete range of services and utilities from Collier County.
SHORT TITLE
This ordinance shall be known and cited for the purpose of the updating of the existing Stiles
PUD, as amended, as "THE STILES PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE."
.
10'I.0J1.19'''. v<< Oll.ac-w,
........._""
HlMW-(J02.coa.mJD..109OS
iv
A':Jenca Item f>Jo. Be I
r1ovell1ber 27, 2007
Page 93 of 127 _
SECTION I
LEGAL DESCRIPTION, PROPERTY OWNERSHIP,
AND GENERAL DESCRIPTION
1.1 PURPOSE
The purpose of this section is to set forth the legal description and ownership of the
Project, and to describe the existing condition of the property proposed to be developed.
1.2 LEGAL DESCRIPTION
The Project contains approximately 18.13 acres and is described as follows:
Part of the west'/, of the northeast 'f. of the northwest'/. of Section 30, Township 48 South,
Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida,
less and excepting therefrom;
the north 100 feet thereof;
and further less and excepting therefrom
the lands described in : OR Book 374, Pages 572-573
OR Book 1545, Pages 443-444, and
OR Book 1837, Pages 1099-1101
of the Public Records of Collier County.
The map of the Boundary Survey (WMB&P File No, 4L-l104) is attached at Exhibit B.
1.3 PROPERTY OWNERSHIP
The subject property is currently under the ownership of Owen M, Ward, as Trustee, 866
97th Avenue North, Naples, Florida,
.
1.4
GENERAL DESCRIPTION THE PROJECT:
A. The Project site is generally located on the south side of Immokalee Road (CR
846) and is approximately one quarter mile from the 1-75-lmmokalee Road
intersection. The Project has direct access onto Immokalee Road via an existing
median opening which aligns with the approved Pelican Strand (fka Regency
Village) PUD to the north,
IG'II97.2lIH,Vf:I:OI1.BCaw1q
rL""U_'.
toM).I,...ool.oo&."'UO.109Ol
1.1
L
Agenda Item No. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 94 of 127
B.
The Project is currently zoned PUD as a planned interchange commercial center
which includes a mixture of interchange oriented commercial facilities and water
management related clements,
c.
Elevations with the Project range from 12.4 feet to 13.6 feet above mean sea level.
The Project is located within zone X of the FEMA Firm Maps.
D.
The soil types found on the Project are Arzell fine sand and Sroward fine sand.
These sands are well drained with no wetlands on site,
E,
Vegetation on the Project is predominately pine flatwoods with the dominant plant
species being slash pine, saw palmetto and numerous grass species.
.
JON9l.:tf1.q v.,., O!l.BC.w\e)'
........,_...
I'<<>ls.c...otl~..ooe.I'P'tJD.~0905
1-2
Agenda Item ~~o. Be
November 27,2007
Page 95 of ~ 27
SECTION n
PROJECT DEVELOPMENT
2.1 PURPOSE
The purpose of this Section is to generally describe the plan of development for the
Project, and to identify relationships to applicable County ordinances, policies, and
procedures,
2.2 GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT PLAN AND PROPOSED LAND USES
The Project includes a range of interchange commercial uses, stonnwater management,
lakes, and buffer areas, TI." PUD Master Plan is illustrated graphically on Exhibit "A",
PUD Master Plan (WMB&P, [nc, File No, RZ.25 I), The Dcveloper intcnds to establish
Project wide guidelines and standards to ensure a high and consistent level of quality for
the proposed land uses, Unifonn guidelines and standards will be created for such
features and facilities as landscaping, signage, lighting, roadway treatments, fences, wall,
buffers, benns and other similar features, The Project will comply with the Architectural
Review Guidelines as adopted in the Code. A Land Use Summary indicating approximate
land use acreage is shown on the plan,
2.3 GENERAL COMPLIANCE WITH COUNTY ORDINANCES
A, The development of the Project shall be in accordance with this PUD Ordinance
and applicable sections of the Code (to the extent they are not inconsistent with
this PUD Ordinance) which are in effect at the time of issuance of any
development order which authorizes the construction of improvements to which
said regulation applies, These include, but are not limited to Final Subdivision
Plat, Excavation Pennit and Preliminary Work Authorization. Where this PUD
Ordinance does not provide developmental standards. then the provisions of the
most similar zoning district or section of the Code shall apply.
.
B,
Unless otherwise defined herein, or as necessarily implied by context, the
definitions of all tenns shall be the same as the definitions set forth in the Code in
effeet at the time of development order application.
C. Development pennitted by this ordinance will be subject to a concum:ncy review
under the Adequate Public Facilities Ordinance Code Section 3, IS.
1i)'V91-:nUI v. ol'.BC...lcy
,,-,...,.-,..
N().l~...oo2..oo8.rP'tJO-z09O~
2 - I
L
Agenda Item l\Jo. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 96 of 127
D,
All conditions imposed herein or as represented on the Project PUD Master Plan
(PUD Master Plan) are part of the regulations which govern the manner in which
the land may be developed,
E.
The Subdivisions Division of the Code (Article 3. Division 3,2) shall apply 10 the
Project, except where an exemplion is set forth herein or othernise granled
pursuant to Code Section 3.2.4,
2,4 ROADWAYS
Standards for roads shall be in compliance ....ith the applicable pro\;sions of the
Code regulating subdivisions, unless otherwise approved during Preliminary
Subdivision Plat approval.
2.5 LAND USES
A. The location ofland uses are shown on Ihe PUD Master Plan. Exhibit" A." Minor
changes and variations in building tracts, location and acreage of these uses shall
be permitted at Preliminary Subdivision Plat approval and Final Pial approval to
accommodate topography, vegetation, Slormwater design, and other site conditions
subject to Code Section 2.7.35. The specific location and size of individual tracts
and the assignment of square footage shall be determined at the time of
Preliminary Subdivision Plat approval.
B. Since the property is to be developed over an estimated nine year time period, any
projection of Project development can be no more than an estimate based on
current marketing knowledge. The estimate may change depending upon future
economic factors,
C.
Roads and other infrastructure may be either public or private, depending on
location, capacity, and design, The determination as to whether a road shall be
public or private shall be made by the Developer at the time of Preliminary
Subdivision Plat approval. Developer shall create an appropriate declaration of
covenants and a property owners association which will be responsible for
maintaining the roads, streets, drainage, water and sewer improvements where
such systems are not dedicated to a governmental agency.
.
D. All buildings, landscaping and visible infrastructure shall be architecturally and
aesthetically unified, Said unified architectural theme shall include a similar
architectural design, use of materials and colors throughout all of the buildings to
IQIM7-2914 Vr on-ac-.r,
"-....,'"'-..
NlWs.4-OOJ.(JQ6..mJD..2tJ901
2-2
Agenda Item No, 8e I
r,overnber 27,2007
Page 97 of 127
be erected on the site. A conceptual design master plan shall be submil1ed
concurrent with the first application for Site Development Plan approvaL
2.6 PROJECT INTENSITY
The total acreage of the Stiles PUD is approximately 1&.\3 acres, The Interchange
Commercial retail and office uses shall have a maximum gross floor area of 7500 square
feet per gross acre for a maximum square footage of 135.975 square feet. The office uses
shall be permined at 15.000 square feet per gross acre and the hoteVmotel use is pennined
at 26 units per gross acre, Interchange Commercial pennined principal uses are permitted
throughout the 1&, \3 acre parcel in accordance "ith the requirements stated in this PUD
documenL
2.7 SITE CLEARING AND DRAINAGE
Clearing. grading. earthwoO;, and site drainage woO; shall be perfonned in accordance
"ith the Code and other applicable governmental agencies and the standards and
commitments Oflhis document.
2.8 EASEMENTS FOR UTILITIES
All necessary easements. dedications. or other instruments shall be granted to insure the
continued operation and maintenance of all service utilities in compliance with applicable
regulations in effect althe time approvals are requested.
2.10
OFF-STREET PARKING AND LOADING
2.9 LAKE SETBACK AND EXCAVATION
The lake setback requirements described in Code Section 3.5.7.\, may be reduced with the
administrative approval of the Collier County Development Services Director, All lakes
greater than two (2) acres may be excavatcd to the maximum commercial excavation
depths set forth in Code Section 3,5,7.3,\, subject to meeting the County fetch formula;
however, removal of fill from the Project shall be limited to an amount up to 10 percent
(to a maximum of 20,000 cubic yards) of the total volume excavated unless a commercial
excavation pennit is received,
.
All off-street parking and loading facilities shall be designed in accordance with the Code
Section 2.3,
2.11
USE OF RIGHTS-OF-WAY
Lands within the Project rights-of-way may be utilized for landseaping, decorative
entrance ways, and signage, if a review of the proposed uses, during the development
10'1191.2914' VW. OIl.BC.-ky
Rw'I.(-.'.
Nl)4~-002.ooB."f'UD.109OS
2-3
L
Aaenda Item I~o, 8e
N'overnber 27, 2007
Page 98 of 127
review process and prior to any installations, by the Collier County Development Services
Director shows no adverse engineering or safety considerations,
2.ll SIGNS
Minimum standards for signs shall be in accordance with Code Section 2.5 in effect at the
lime tinallocal development orders are requested,
2.13 OPEN SPACE REQUIREMENTS
Pursuant to Code Section 2,6,32 at least thiny percent (30%) of the Project shall be
devoted to usable open space. The total Project is 18, J 3 acres requiring a minimum of 5.4
acres to be retained as open space, The open space calculation indicated on the PUD
Master Plan identities 5.4 ,des including lakes, miscellaneous buffers and open space
areas which meet the requirement.
2.14 NA TlYE VEGETATION RETENTION REQUIREMENTS
The Project shall retain tifteen percent or 2,7 acres of the viable naturally functioning
vegetation on site as required by Section 3,9.5.5.4 of the Code. This shall be monitored at
each Preliminary Subdivision Plat submittal. The Developer shall receive credit from any
phase whcre the 15% amount is exceeded to be applied to a phase where it is not. In any
phase of development where credit toward the 15% is needed. the Developer shall
delineate on the Preliminary Subdivision Plat the percentage of viable naturally
functioning native vegetation retained and/or areas of landscaping and open space which
are planted with native species, The Developcr shall show the calculations on each
Preliminary Subdivision Plat which totals the overall 15% for the Project build-out.
2.15 TIME LIMITS OF PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL
The time limits for the Project are as provided for within Code Section 2,7.3.4.
.
2.16
PUD MONITORING
An annual monitoring report shall be submitted pursuant to Code Section 2,7.3,6,
2,17
IMPACT FEES
Development within the Project shall be subject to all lawfully adopted impact fees
appropriate for each land use in effect at the time of development and in accordance with
prior agreements bctween the Developer and the County,
l~l.m"V.OI'.ac.....,
...1....._...
~,..-OO2-e<<1.,.I'VO-%090'
2-4
Agenda Item No, 8e I
November 27,2007
Page 99 of 127
SECTION III
INTERCHANGE COMMERCIAL LAND USE DISTRICT
3.1 PURPOSE
The purpose of this section is to set forth the permitted uses and development standards
for the development of the Project.
A, PERMIlTED USES AND STRUCTURES
No building or stnK"tre or part thereof, shall be erected, altered or used, or land
uses, in whole or part, for other than the following:
Interchange Commercial Permitted Principal Uses and Structures permitted
throughout the 18.13 acre parcel:
1. Accounting, Auditing and Bookkeeping Services (Group 8721),
ii. Amusement and Recreation Services (Groups 7911-7941, 7991, 7993).
111, Apparel and Accessory Stores (Groups 5611-5699).
iv, Auto and Home Supply Stores (Group 5531).
v, Automotive Repair, Services, and Parking (Groups 7514, 7515, 7534,
7542) (no service bays shall face Immokalee Road).
VI. Building Materials, Hardware and Garden Supplies (Groups 5211-
5261).
.
Vll.
Business Services (Groups 7311,7313,7334-7335,7371-7379,7384).
viii. Child Day Care Services (Group 8351).
ix. Miscellaneous Retail (Groups 5912.5963, except pawnshops and all
uses dealing with secondhand merchandise, 5992-5999),
x. Depository Institutions (Groups 6011-6099).
IMI9'l'.m4t v.-; Olf.ac.M.ry
IL~~III
NlM:u-oa1..oo&-PPlJI)..2090S
3 - I
r
xi.
xii.
xiii.
xiv,
xv.
xvi.
xvii.
xviii.
xix.
xx,
xxi.
xxii.
.
xxiii.
Agenda Item No, 8e
November 27,2007
Page 100 of 127
Eating and Drinking Places (Groups 5812-5813).
Electrical Repair Shops (Group 7622 automotive radio, radio,
television, stereo and video recorder repair only, 7629 except aircraft,
business and office machines, large appliances such as refrigerators and
washing machines),
Engineering, Accounting, Research, Management, and Related Services
(Groups 8711-8713,8721,8741-8743,8748),
Food Stores (Groups 541 1-5499).
Gasoline Lrvice Stations (Group 5541 except marine service stations
and truck stops subject to Section 2,6,28).
Group Care Facilities (Category J and II); Care Units except for
homeless shelters; and Nursing Homes, subject to Sec. 2,6.26).
General Merchandise Stores (Groups 5311-5399).
Health Services (Groups 801 1-8049, 8082, 8093, 8099).
Holding and Other Investment Offices (Groups 6712-6799),
Home Furniture, Furnishings, and Equipment Stores (Groups 5712-
5736),
Hotels and Motels (Group 70 II in accordance with the development
standards in this PUD document).
Insurance Agents, Brokers, and Service (Group 6411).
Insurance Carriers (Groups 6311-6399),
xxiv. Libraries (Group 8231).
xxv. Legal Services (Group 811l).
xxvi. Membership Organizations (Groups 8611-8661, 8699).
1~-1""'1 v. OII.BCowkJ
"I..'~"
HCM~-llOJ..ooa.."P'UD-;t090$
3.2
Agenda Item I~o, 8e
November 27, 2007
Page 101 of 127
xxvii. Miscellaneous Personal Services (Groups 7211, 7212, 7215, 72 1 6 non-
industrial dry cleaning only, 7221-7251, 7291).
xxviii. Miscellaneous Repair Services (Group 7631).
xxix. Museums and Art Galleries (Group 8412).
xxx. Nondepository Credit Institutions (Groups 611 1.6163).
XXXI. Paint, Glass and Wallpaper Stores (Group 5231),
xxxii. Public Finance, Taxation and Monetary Policy (Group 931] property
tax assessors' office and taxation departments only).
xxxiii. Public Order and Safety (Groups 9211 and 9224),
xxxiv. Real Estate (Groups 6512, 6531-6552).
xxxv. Social Services (Groups 8322 activity centers, elderly or handicapped,
adult day care centers; and day care centers; adult and handicapped
only, and 8351).
xxxvi. United States Postal Service (Group 431], except major distribution
center).
xxxvii. Veterinary Services (Groups 0742, 0752, excluding outside kenneling).
xxxviii. Video Tape Rental (Group 784]).
xxxix,
Any other commercial use or professional service which is comparable
in nature with the foregoing uses and which the Development Services
Director determines to be compatible in this district.
.
B. Permitted Accessory Uses and Structures
1. Uses and structures that are accessory and incidental to uses permitted in
this district.
1M.'91.N1.u v.- (I1t.&C-'cy
".....-.
ND4....-OO]'OOO.I'I'\.JO'2tJ'lOS
3 - 3
I
Agenda Item No, Be
November 27,2007
Page 102 of 127
3,2
DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS FOR ALL PERMITTED USES EXCEPT
HOTEL AND MOTEL USE
Minimum Lot Area: Ten thousand (10,000) square feel.
Minimum Lot Width: One hundred feel (100').
Minimum Yard Requirements:
From Immokalee Road: Fifty feet (50')
,
Front Yard: Twenty-five feet (25').
All other yards: Fifteen feet (15').
Maximum Height: Thirty-five feet (35'), excepl for non-functional architectural
elements (such as bell towers), which shall have a maximum height of fifty feel
(50'),
Minimum Floor Area of Principal Structure: Seven hundred (700) square feet
gross floor area for each building on the ground floor.
Distance between principal structures: None, or a minimum of five feet (5') with
unobstructed passage from front 10 rear yard.
Minimum standards for lighting and landscaping shall be in accordance with the
Code in effect at the time final local development orders are requested.
No outside display of merchandise or storage is permitted unless horizontally
visually screened by an acceptable vertical structure,
3.3 HOTEL AND MOTEL DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS
Minimum Lot Area: One (I) acre.
Minimum Lot Width: One hundred fifty feet (150').
.
Minimum Yard Requirements:
I. From Immokalee Road: Fifty feel (50')
2. Front Yard: Fifty-five percent (55%) of building height with a minimum
of twenty feet (20'),
3. All other yards: Twenty feet (20'),
1......-n.191.. \lot OtT.BCawley
""-'~.
H04~-ooe-I"P1J[).%090'
3-4
Aaenda Item No. 8e
November 27. 2007
Page 103 of 127
_.~~
Maximum Height: Sixty feet (60') or six stories, whichever is greater.
Distance between principal structures: Fifteen feet (IS') or one-half(V,) the sum of
the building heights, whichever is greater,
Minimum standards for lighting and landscaping shall be in accordance with the
Code in effect at the time final local development orders are requested..
3.4 BUFFERS
Minimum standards for buffers shall be in accordance with Code Section 2.4 in effect at
the time final local development orders are requested, unless otherwise specified herein or
on the PUD Master Plan, Exhibit A,
All buffer setbacks shall be measured from planed lot boundaries, The following
identifies the buffer according to land use type:
Internal Buffers on:
A, Interchange Commercial:
I. 10' adjacent to hotel parcel
2. ] 0' adjacent to internal rights-of-way
3. 10' adjacent to eastern boundary with Donovan PUD except 0' where the
joint access road is proposed
B,
Hotel:
I.
2.
3,
10' adjacent to commercial parcels
10' adjacent to internal rights-of-way
10' adjacent to eastern boundary with Donovan PUD except 0' where the
joint access road is proposed
.
The buffer on the western and southern Project boundaries shall be kept in native
vegetation existing on the site to the maximum extent possible or shall be planted with
native vegetation in those areas devoid of native vegetation.
JIIIIi'97_19U'V~ Oll.llC.wIcy
"....,~I.
3 - 5
H04~.ool.ooa-'1'UD-2llQCl1
I
Agenda Item No se
November 27.2007
Page 104 of 127
SECTION IV
DEVELOPMENT COMMrTMENTS
4,1 PURPOSE
The purpose of this section is to set forth the development commitments of the Project.
4.2 ENGINEERING
A. Detailed paving, grading, site drainage and utility plans shall be submitted to the
Development Services Division for review. No construction permits shall be
issued unless and Uf.,'1 approval of the proposed construction in accordance with
the submitted plans is granted by the Development Services Division.
B, Access to all parcels fronting lrnmokalee Road shall be from the main entrance
road with no direct driveway access from each parcel to lmmokalee Road.
C, The main road shall meet the minimum pavement standard for a minor collector,
The required right-of-way may be as required for a local street.
4,3 UTILITIES
A, Water distribution, sewage collection and transmission and interim water anellor
sewage treatment facilities 10 serve the Project are to be designed, constructed,
conveyed. owned and maintained in accordance with Collier County Ordinance
No. 88-76, as amended, and other applicable County rules and regulations or other
applicable agency regulalions, as may be appropriate,
B.
All customers cOIUlecting to the water distribution and sewage collection facilities
to be constructed will be customers of the County and will be billed by the County
in accordance with the County's established rates.
.
C. The utilities for the Project's water distribution and wastewater collection systems
shall be designed and constructed to connect the Project to the District's facilities
in accordance with County criteria and the County's Master Plan,
,""""'-"," v. O.'-Be...wy
11.1.00.,..-_
NIM~"""'P1'I)D.l000'
4 - I
Aqenda Item No, Be
November 27. 2007
Page 105 of 127
~
4,4 WATER MANAGEMENT
A. A copy of South Florida Water Management District Pennit or Early Work Pennit
is required prior to construction plan approval.
B, Detailed water management plans and calculations, signed and sealed by a Florida
Professional Engineer shall be provided,
C. An Excavation Pennit will be required for the proposed lakes in accordance with
Section'3.5 of the Code and the South Florida Water Management District Rules.
4,5 ENVIRONMENTAL
A, As set forth in Sectio" 2.15 herein, the Developer will retain the maximum amount
of native vegetation possible as part of the landscape buffers within the Project.
This acreage shall be counted toward the required 15% native habitat requirement
under the Code,
B,
Petitioner shall submit an Environmental Impact Statement at the time of the next
Development Order submittal.
,,-
C. This Project shall be in compliance with the Collier County Land Development
Code, the Collier County Growth Management Plan, Coastal and Conservation
Management Element in effect at the time of the first Development Order
approval.
4,6 TRANSPORTATION
A. The Developer has provided left and right turn lanes on Immokalee Road at the
Project entrance,
B.
The Developer shall make a fair share contribution toward the capital cost of a
traffic signal at the Project entrance when deemed warranted by the County.
.
c.
All traffic control devices on public roadways, excluding street name signs, shall
conform to the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices as required by
Chapter 316, Florida Statutes.
D. The applicant shall be responsible for the installation of arterial level street lighting
at all Project entrances at the time of approval of the Final Subdivision Plat.
1Cr'Vl7.m4' v~ Oll-ac.wlcy
"'."..-..
N04w..o:n..Q08..P1'tJD.~CI9OJ
4-2
I
E,
.
II>>I"T7.mu v.: Oll-BC.-ky
.......-...
N0454..o'Jt.ooa.f'PtA).109ll,
Agenda Item No, Be
November 27, 2007
Page 106 of 127
The above required improvements are considered "site related" as defined in the
Code and shall not be applied a credits toward any impact fees.
F.
The original PUD required that the Developer dedicate land for the widening of
Immokalee Road, The Developer has previously satisfied this requirement by
conveyance of a twenty-five foot (25') strip ofland by deed recorded in Official
Records Book 1545 at Page 443 of the Official Records of Collier County,
Florida. In addition the Developer conveyed additional land for the expanded
Immobilee right of way by deed recorded in Official Records Book 1837 at
Page 1099.
G,
The original PUD provided that a cross drain across Immokalee Road to the
canal on the north be incorporated and that the County be provided with access
to it for use in connection with the future six-Ianing of Immokalee Road. This
work was completed and paid for by the Developer under an agreement berween
the Developer and the County dated May 4, 1993. The requirements have been
satisfied,
H.
The original PUD strongly recommended the extension of the then existing four-
laned section of Immokalee Road west and through the proposed construction of
a four lane median opening on Immokalee Road aligned with the eastern
boundary of the Project and Pelican Strand (lka Regency Village) to the north of
[mmokalee Road. The median opening was constructed and paid for by the
Developer under the agreement with the County dated May 4, 1993. The four-
laning has been completed to the west. The four lane extension is subject to a
fair share road impact fee credit applicable to the added through lanes,
I.
The Project entry from Immokalee Road will be along its eastern boundary so as
to align with the present median cut in and proposed traffic signal on lmmokalee
Road at the entrance to Pelican Strand. The entry will be designed so that it can be
inter-connected to and used by the lands that are located to the east of the Project
and west of 1-75. The inter-connection and use of the entryway by the adjoining
landowner will be pursuant to a mutually agreeable cross use or cross easement
agreement.
4-3
U'-'-
COON
O~
ON~
Zr--:O
ENb
G)'-"-
~Q)
--'OQ)
(1)~OJ
"'0 c ctI
eg;:o...
CJ"
:;}'Z
~
.'
! p~
r' !,
, I
t
1
, I
,
,
I
, ~,
I i
~
.
~~
.___LfIl~Ir\_~~ ~. ~
[1~ ~::~o:o;=-~.r.r.-c-
.....""""..,_..,~ 'I
OiTDowb~LIID'I'U.J:Io\.C
u.uo
~
- -
=-=-
0I'tI'~AC&1'W'7U.J
U~
U~
~
-=-
~
=~
IUUI;
~~=..__""'Io___
-......=::.:--.--
1l"~....Y_(
""....,.......---::::.-............-
'~.l.IoU.~UlL.lI.~I~
""-
H_
-
-
;J!I'~..:....~Hk
~r'
--
-=..-
--
--
w
"
-
=.5:.W:~
100lAH,OBc,.o.pEIlUffVt
"
lHTEI\ClwtafCm.u.t[IIC......
I
1Nf1~~
,
IIr~lIlA'f!k
_T_
.!tlNl,:~.;.,."tft
.-..-._..-..~..
I -..-..-.-..-..-..-.. -
-..-..-..-..-..-..
-"-"'-"-
=-==
~
;=--=
~
-.
== n.n....i
I
Agenda Item No, Be
r,ovember 27, 2007
Page 10B of 127
STATE OF FLORIDA)
COUNTY OF COLLIER)
I, DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk of Courts in and for the Twentieth
Judicial Circuit, Collier County, Florida, do hereby certify that the
,
foregoing is a true copy of:
ORDINANCE NO. 97-74
Which was adopted by the Board of County Commissioners on the 25th day
of November, 1997, during Regular Session.
WITNESS my hand and the official seal of the Board of County
commissioners of Collier County, Florida, this 26th day of November,
1997.
...'
.
DWIGHT E. BROCK ,.,..',-.;..':;..'::.
Clerk of Courts and,C~epkf~~ J ,."
Ex-officio to BOSl.rd'J,'M'",o..",-,:.; ro~~
County commission~ .~/ ':"}'~ .., '
~ 't',:.' ,t,e,';
~ .~)' -:'~:.~: .~.:~ '.~ .
.........: ,t .-1
By: Maureen Kel'l.YOI'l",.1 0,
Deputy Clerk\ ',/ ~~.
'", J' ..,. .,.,'
. ',~. l::~; 0#'
.h.........
.:; .
.' ..:.:~.~ J
Ol'.. ~. .
"
Aaenda Item No. Be
November 27, 2007
Page 109 of 127
~""
Comr County
- ~,'.' ",'-"'<..""'"-~,,.",~"<.
FROM THE DESK OF KAY DESELEM
4/23/07
Planning Commission Members & Staff:
Please note there is no strike thru/underlil1e version of the Stile PUD
ill this packet.
While it initially appears that this petition is a request for a "PUD to PUD"
rezoning that would include a strike thrulunder version of the previous
PUD that is not the case in this instance, The Gaspar Station petition was
required to submit an entirely new PUD application for this rezoning. The
Stiles PUD has sunsetted and essentially is no longer valid,
Zoning & Land Development Review 213-2931
Agenda Item No, Be
November 27, 2007
Page 110 of 127
ORDIN_-'.NCE NO, 07-_
_"--'f ORDINANCE OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA,
AMENDING ORDINA.'1CE NUMBER 04-41, AS
A.M:ENDED, THE COLLIER COUNTY L-'.ND
DEVELOPMENT CODE, \i/HICH INCLUDES THE
COMPREHENSNE ZOJ>HNG REGULATIONS FOR THE
UNINCORPORATED AREA OF COLLIER COUNTY,
FLORIDA, BY AMENDING THE _.>J>PROPRlATE ZONiNG
ATLAS MAP OR MAPS BY CHANGING THE ZOl\'ING
CLASSIFIeATlON OF THE HEREIN DESCRIBED REAL
PROPERTY FROM PLANNED UN1T DEVELOPMENT
(PUD) TO COMMERCll\L PLilNNED Ul\lT
DEVELOPMENT (CPUD) FOR A PROJECT TO BE KNOWN
AS THE GASPAR STATION CPUD, FOR PROPERTY
LOCATED ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF IMMOKALEE ROAD
(CR 846), APPROXIMATELY ONE QUARTER MILE WEST
OF THE 1-75fIMMOKALEE ROAD, INTERCHANGE, IN
SECTlO:-< 30, TOWNSHIP 48 SOUTIl, RANGE 26 EAST,
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, CONSISTING OF 17,7
ACRES; PROVIDNG FOR THE REPE,I\L OF ORDINANCE
NUMBER 97-74, AS AMENDED, THE STILES
CORPORATlO:-< PUD; A.ND BY PROVIDING AN
EFFECTIVE DATE.
\VHEREAS, Margaret Perry, .t\.ICP of WilsonMil1er, Inc, representing A. Grover
Matheney, as successor trustee, petitioned the Board of County Commissioners to change
the zoning classification of the herein described real property.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA that:
SECTION ONE:
TIle zoning classification of the herein described real property located in Section
30, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida, is changed from Planned
Unit Development (PUD) to Commercial Planned Unit Development (CPUD) for a
project to be lmovro as the Gaspar Station CPLTI in accordance with the CPUD
DOClUllent, attached hereto as Exhibit "A", which is incorporated herein and by reference
made part hereof. The appropriate zoning atlas map or maps, as described in Ordinance
Number 04-41, as amended, the Collier County Land Development Code, is/are hereby
amended accordingly.
SECTlO:-< TWO:
Ordinance Number 97-74, as amended, I:nown as the Stiles Corporation PUD,
adopted on November 25, 1997, by the Board of County Commissioners of Collier
ComIty, is hereby repealed in its entirety.
Gaspar Station' PUDZ-2006-AR-t0698
Page 1 of2
Agenda Item No, Be
November 27. 2007
Page111of127
SECTION THREE:
This Ordinance shall become effective upon filing with the Department of State.
PASSED AND DULY ADOPTED by a super-majority vote by the Board of
County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, this _ day of2007,
ATTEST:
D\VIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
Deputy Clerk
BY:
JAMES N, COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency
--rl<..1 'A ~ 111 !k.ut.wJ:. - {Jt;.Al~
Marj~e M. Student-Stirling.
Assistant County Attorney
PUDZ-2006-AR-l069S/KD/sp
Gaspar Station: PUDZ-2006~AR-10698
Page 2 of2
Received 8/27/07
Agenda ltem No. se
November 27, 2007
Page 112 of 127
Exhibit A
GASPAR STATION CPUD
COMMERCIAL PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT
17.7 Acres located in
Section 30, Township 48 South, Range 26 East
Collier County, Florida
PREPARED FOR:
A, Grover Matheney,
As Successor Trustee
2351 SW 37th Avenue, Apt. 1112
Miami, FL 33145
PREPARED BY:
R. Bruce Anderson
Roetzel & Andress, L.P.A.
850 Park Shore Drive
Trianon Centre, Third Floor
Naples, FL 34103
AND
Margaret Perry, AICP
WilsonMiller, Inc,
3200 Bailey Lane, Suite 200
Naples, Florida 34105
DATE FILED: October 20, 2006
DATE APPROVED:
ORDINANCE NUMBER:
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TABLE OF CONTENTS/LIST OF EXHIBITS
SHORT TITLE
SECTION I
SECTION II
SECTION III
SECTION IV
SECTION V
Exhibit A
Received 8/27/07
LEGAL DESCRIPTION, PROPERTY
OWNERSHIP, & GENERAL DESCRIPTION
PROJECT DEVELOPMENT
INTERCHANGE COMMERCIAL
LAND USE DISTRICT
PRESERVE/NATIVE VEGETATION DISTRICT
DEVELOPMENT COMMITMENTS
LIST OF EXHIBITS
CPUD Master Plan
11
PAGE
Aaenda It8m No. 8e
~,rovember 27, 2007
Page 113 of i 27
Ii
iii
1-1
2-1
3-1
4-1
5-1
Aaenda Item No, Be
~.rovember 27, 2007
Page 114 of 127
SHORT TITLE
This ordinance shall be known and cited as 'THE GASPAR STATION COMMERCIAL PLANNED
UNIT DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE,"
Received 8/27/07
111
Agenda 11em No. Be
November 27,2007
Page 115 of 127
SECTION I
LEGAL DESCRIPTION, PROPERTY OWNERSHIP,
AND GENERAL DESCRIPTION
1,1 PURPOSE
The purpose of this Section is to set forth the legal description and ownership of the project,
and to describe the existing condition of the property proposed to be developed,
1.2 LEGAL DESCRIPTION
The project contains approximately 17.7 acres and is described as follows:
The west 12 of the northeast Y. of the northwest Y. of Section 30, Township 48 South,
Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida.
less and excepting therefrom: the north 100 feet thereof and the lands described In: OR
Book 374, Pages 572-573, OR Book 1545, Pages 443-444, and OR Book 1837, Pages
1099-1101 of the Public Records of Collier County.
1.3 PROPERTY OWNERSHIP
The subject property is currently under the ownership of A. Grover Matheney, as successor
trustee, to Owen Ward, Trustee, under that certain land trust agreement dated June 29,
1988, with the following address: 2351 SW 371h Avenue, Apt. 1112; Miami. FL 33145.
Received 8/27/07
1-1
Agenda Item No, Be
r,ovember 27, 2007
Page 116 of 127
SECTION II
PROJECT DEVELOPMENT
2.1 PURPOSE
The purpose of this Section is to generally describe the plan of development for the project,
and to identify relationships to applicable County ordinances, policies, and procedures,
2.2 GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT PLAN AND PROPOSED LAND USES
The project includes a range of interchange commercial uses, stormwater management,
lakes, and buffer areas, The CPUD Master Plan is illustrated graphically on Exhibit "A."
The developer intends to establish project wide guidelines and standards to ensure a high
and consistent level of quality for the proposed land uses, Uniform guidelines and
standards will be created for such features and facilities as landscaping, signage, lighting,
roadway treatments, fences, wall, buffers, berms and other similar features, The project
will comply with the Architectural Review Guidelines as adopted in the Land Development
Code (LDC). A Land Use Summary indicating approximate land use acreage is shown on
the Master Plan,
2.3 GENERAL PERMITTED USES
Certain uses shall be considered general permitted uses throughout the Gaspar Station
Commercial CPUD except in the Preserve/Native Vegetation District. General permitted
uses are those uses which are typically part of the common infrastructure,
A. General Permitted Uses:
1, Water management facilities and related structures including lakes with
bulkheads or other architectural or structural bank treatments.
2. Guardhouses, gatehouses, and access control structures,
3. Architectural features and elements including walls, fences, arbors, gazebos
and the like,
4, Temporary construction and administrative offices for the developer and
developer's authorized contractors and consultants, including necessary
access ways, parking areas and related uses,
5. Landscape/hardscape features including, but not limited to landscape
buffers, berms, fences, water features and walls.
6, Fill storage, site filling and grading are subject to the standards set forth in
Section 2.8 of this CPUD.
8, Development Standards:
The following development standards shall apply to General Permitted Uses:
Received 8/27/07
2-1
Received 8/27/07
Agenda Item No. 8e
l'Jovember 27, 2007
Page 117 of 127
1.
Guardhouses, gatehouses, signage, landscape features, and access control
structures shall be set back a minimum of ten feet from property lines.
Other general permitted uses (except fences) shall be set back a minimum
of five feet from property lines,
Maximum height of General Permitted Uses buildings - Thirty five feet.
Minimum fioor area - None required,
Minimum lot or parcel area - None required,
2,
3.
4.
5.
6,
Standards for parking, landscaping, signs and other land shall be in
accordance with the LOC provision in effect at the time of site
development plan application.
2-2
A,genda Item No, Be
November 27, 2007
Page 118 of 127
SECTION III
INTERCHANGE COMMERCIAL LAND USE DISTRICT
3.1 PURPOSE
The purpose of this Section is to set forth the permitted uses and development
standards for the development of the project.
A. Principal Uses and Structures:
No building or structure or part thereof, shall be erected, altered or used, or land uses,
in whole or part, for other than the following:
1. Accounting, auditing and bookkeeping services (Group 8721).
2. Amusement and recreation services (Groups 7911-7941,7991,7993).
3. Apparel and accessory stores (Groups 5611-5699).
4. Auto and home supply stores (Group 5531).
5. Automotive repair services, and parking (Groups 7514, 7515, 7534, 7542).
6. Building materials, hardware and garden supplies (Groups 5211-5261).
7, Business services (Groups 7311, 7313, 7334-7335, 7371-7379, 7384).
8. Child day care services (Group 8351).
9, Miscellaneous retail (Groups 5912-5963, except pawnshops and all uses dealing with
secondhand merchandise, 5992-5999).
10. Depository institutions (Groups 6011-6099).
11. Eating and drinking places (Groups 5812-5813),
12. Electrical repair shops (Group 7622 automotive radio, radio, television, stereo and
video recorder repair only, 7629 except aircraft, business and office machines, large
appliances such as refrigerators and washing machines).
13. Engineering, accounting, research, management, and related services (Groups 8711-
8713, 8721, 8741-8743, 8748),
14. Food stores (Groups 5411-5499).
15. Gasoline service stations (Group 5541 except marine service stations and truck stops
subject to the LDC).
Received 8/27/07
3-1
Aoenda Item No, Be
November 27, 2007
Page 119 of 127
16. Group care facilities (Category I and II); Care units except for homeless shelters; and
nursing homes, subject to the LDC.
17. General merchandise stores (Groups 5311-5399).
18, Health services (Groups 8011-8049, 8082, 8093, 8099).
19, Holding and other investment offices (Groups 6712-6799).
20, Home fumiture, fumishings, and equipment stores (Groups 5712-5736),
21, Hotels and motels (Group 7011 in accordance with the development standards in this
CPUD Document).
22. Insurance agents, brokers, and service (Group 6411).
23. Insurance carriers (Groups 6311-6399),
24. Libraries (Group 8231),
25, Legal services (Group 8111),
26, Membership organizations (Groups 8611-8661, 8699).
27. Miscellaneous personal services (Groups 7211, 7212, 7215, 7216 non-industrial dry
cleaning only, 7221-7251, 7291).
28. Miscellaneous repair services (Group 7631).
29. Museums and art galleries (Group 8412).
30. New and used automobile sales (Group 5511).
31. Nondepository credit institutions (Groups 6111-6163).
32. Paint, glass and wallpaper Stores (Group 5231).
33, Public finance, taxation and monetary policy (Group 9311 property tax assessors'
office and taxation departments only).
34, Public order and safety (Groups 9211 and 9224).
35, Real estate (Groups 6512, 6531-6552).
36, Social services (Groups 8322 activity centers, elderly or handicapped, adult day care
centers; and day care centers; adult and handicapped only, and Group 8351),
37. United States Postal Service (Group 4311, except major distribution center).
38. Veterinary services (Groups 0742, 0752, excluding outside kenneling),
Received 8/27/07
3-2
Agenda Item No, se
November 27,2007
Page 120 of 127
39. Video tape rental (Group 7841).
40. Any other uses which are comparable in nature with the foregoing uses and are
approved through the process set forth in the LDC, in effect at the time of the
request for such use.
B. Accessory Uses and Structures:
1, Kiosk vendors.
2. Outdoor dining shall be permitted as an accessory use to an eating establishment.
3. Communication facilities including, but not limited to digital, fiberoptic, microwave,
satellite, UHF, VHG, FM, AM, short-wave, antennas with related ground mounted
dishes and other sending and receiving facilities, subject to applicable permits,
4, Parking structures,
5, Generators.
6, Utility buildings,
7, Chickee or picnic areas.
8. Pool, tennis courts, and recreational amenities associated with a hotel or motel.
9. Any other accessory use which is comparable in nature with the foregoing uses and
is approved through the process set forth in the LDC in effect at the time of the
request for such use.
3.2 DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS FOR PRINCIPAL AND ACCESSORY USES EXCEPT
HOTEL AND MOTEL USE
Minimum Lot Area: Ten thousand (10,000) square feet for principal uses; none for
accessory uses.
Minimum Lot Width: One hundred feet (100') for principal uses; none for accessory uses.
Minimum Yard Requirements:
From Immokalee Road:
Fifty feet (50') for principal uses; twenty feet (20') for
accessory uses.
Front Yard:
Twenty-five feet (25') for principal uses; twenty feet (20') for
accessory uses.
All other yards: Fifteen feet (15') for principal and accessory uses.
Setback from Preserves: Twenty-five feet (25') feet for principal structures; ten feet (10')
feet for accessory structures and all other site alterations, There shall be no site alterations
within the first 10 feet adjacent to any preserve unless it can be demonstrated that It will not
adversely impact the integrity of that preserve.
Maximum Height: Thirty-five feet (35') for principal and accessory structures, except for
non-functional architectural elements (such as bell towers) which shall have a maximum
height of fifty feet (50').
Minimum Floor Area of Principal Structure: Seven hundred (700) square feet of gross floor
area for each building on the ground floor.
Received 8/27/07 3-3
Aaenda Item No Be
November 27,2'007
Page 121 of 127
Minimum Floor Area of Accessory Structure: none required.
Distance between principal structures: None, or a minimum of five feet (5') with
unobstructed passage from front to rear yard. Distance between principal and accessory
structures: None required.
Minimum standards for lighting and landscaping shall be in accordance with the LDC in
effect at the time final local development orders are requested,
3.3 HOTEL AND MOTEL DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS
Minimum Lot Area: One (1) acre for principal uses; none for accessory structures.
Minimum Lot Width: One hundred fifty feet (150') for principal structures; none for
accessory structures,
Minimum Yard Requirements:
1, From Immokalee Road: Fifty feet (50') for principal uses and twenty feet
(20') for accessory structures.
2. Front Yard: Fifty-five percent (55%) of building height or twenty feet (20'),
whichever is greater for principal and accessory structures,
3. All other yards: Twenty feet (20') for principal and accessory structures,
Maximum Height: Sixty feet (60') or six stories, whichever is greater, for principal uses and
thirty-five feet (35') for accessory uses.
Distance between principal structures: Fifteen feet (15') or one-half (Y:>) the sum of the
building heights, whichever is greater.
Distance between principal and accessory structures: none required.
Setback from Preserves: Twenty-five feet (25.) feet for principal structures; ten feet (10')
feet for accessory structures and all other site alterations. There shall be no site
alternations within the first 10 feet adjacent to any preserve unless it can be demonstrated
that it will not adversely impact the integrity of that preserve.
Minimum standards for lighting and landscaping shall be in accordance with the LDC in
effect at the time final local development orders are requested.
Received 8/27/07
3-4
Agenda Item No, Be
November 27,2007
Page 122 of 127
3,4 BUFFERS
The following identifies the buffer according to land use type:
Internal Buffers on:
A. Interchange Commercial:
1. 10 feet adjacent to hotel parcel;
2. 10 feet adjacent to internal rights-of-way;
3. 10 feet adjacent to eastern boundary with Donovan PUD;
B,
Hotel:
1.
2,
3,
10 feet adjacent to commercial parcels;
10 feet adjacent to internal rights-of-way;
10 feet adjacent to eastern boundary with Donovan PUD.
The buffer on the southern project boundary shall be kept in native vegetation existing on
the site or shall be planted with native vegetation in those areas devoid of native
vegetation.
3.5 PROJECT INTENSITY
The total acreage of the Gaspar Station CPUD is approximately 17.7 acres. The
Interchange Commercial retail and service uses shall be penmitted at a rate of 7,500 square
feet per gross acre. The office uses shall be permitted at a rate of 15,000 square feet per
gross acre and the hotel/motel use is permitted at a rate of 26 units per gross acre,
Received 8/27/07
3-5
Aaenda Item No Be
November 27,2'007
Page 123 of 127
SECTION IV
PRESERVE/NATIVE VEGETATION DISTRICT
4.1 PURPOSE
The purpose of this Section is to identify permitted uses and development standards for
the area within the Gaspar Station CPUD designated on the CPUD Master Plan as
"Preserve/Native Vegetation".
4.2 GENERAL DESCRIPTION
Areas designated as Preserve/Native Vegetation District on the Gaspar Station CPUD
Master Plan are designed to accommodate customary uses in preserve areas.
4.3 PERMITTED USES AND STRUCTURES
No building or structure, or part thereof, shall be erected, altered or used, or land or
water used, in whole or in part, for other than the following:
A. Principal Uses and Structures:
1,
2,
3,
4,
5.
Conservation and preserve.
Passive recreational areas, pervious nature trails, and other similar uses.
Water management structures.
Mitigation areas and mitigation maintenance activities.
Any other preservation and related open space activity or use which is
comparable in nature with the foregoing uses and is approved through the
process set forth in the LDC in effect at the time of the request for such
use.
Received 8/27/07
4-1
Agenda Item I~o, Be
November 27, 2007
Page 124 of 127
SECTION V
DEVELOPMENT COMMITMENTS
5.1 PURPOSE
The purpose of this Section is to set forth the development commitments of the project.
5.2 TRANSPORTATION
A. The developer has provided left and right turn lanes on Immokalee Road at Juliet
Boulevard.
B, The developer has made a fair share contribution toward the capital cost of a traffic signal
at the project entrance.
C, All traffic control devices on public roadways shall conform to the Manual on Unifonm Traffic
Control Devices as required by Chapter 316, Florida Statutes, Street signs shall be the
sole responsibility of the developer, his successors, or assigns,
D, The above required improvements shall be considered "site related" as defined in the
LDC and shall not be applied as credits toward any impact fee.
E, The developer has previously conveyed a twenty-five foot (25') strip of land to the
County by deed recorded in Official Records Book 1545 at Page 443 of the Official
Records of Collier County, Florida, for the widening of Immokalee Road. In addition the
developer conveyed additional land for the expanded Immokalee right-of-way by deed
recorded in Official Records Book 1837 at Page 1099 of Collier County, Florida,
F, The developer has provided a cross drain across Immokalee Road to the canal on the
north to be incorporated and provide the County with access to it for use in connection
with the six-Ianing of Immokalee Road. This work was completed and paid for by the
developer under an agreement between the developer and the County dated May 4,
1993,
G. The original PUD strongly recommended the extension of the then existing four-lane
section of Immokalee Road west and through the proposed construction of a four lane
median opening on Immokalee Road aligned with the eastern boundary of the project
and Pelican Strand (flk/a Regency Village) to the north of Immokalee Road. The median
opening was constructed and paid for by the developer under the agreement with the
County dated May 4, 1993. The four-Ianing has been completed to the west. The four
lane extension is subject to a fair share road impact fee credit applicable to the added
through lanes.
H, The project entry from Immokalee Road is located along its eastern boundary and aligns
with the present median cut and traffic signal on Immokalee Road at the entrance to The
Strand PUD. The entry was designed so that it is interconnected to and is used by the
developments that are located to the east of the project and west of 1-75, The inter-
connection and use of the entryway by adjoining landowners is pursuant to an existing
cross use or cross easement agreement.
Received 8/27/07
5-1
Agenda Item No. 8e
November 27.2007
Page 125 of 127
I. Roads will be private. The developer has created the Juliet Boulevard Roadway
Association, Inc" which is responsible for roads, streets and drainage improvements and
maintenance of Juliet Boulevard.
J, At the time of approval of the final plat or final site development plan, whichever comes
first, the developer shall show an interconnection to the property on the west boundary
of the Gaspar Station CPUD to allow the property located on the said west side access
to Juliet Boulevard, The location of the interconnection is to be determined by the
developer of Gaspar Station CPUD and approved by the County. The developer of the
Gaspar Station CPUD shall record the interconnection as an easement prior to issuance
of any county development approvals, The interconnection shall not be deemed to be a
right-of-way, road, or street for the application of either zoning setback or buffering
requirements. The interconnection shall not be deemed to require an amendment of the
CPUD or its CPUD Master Plan, The easement shall provide two-way vehicular access
and one pedestrian access consistent with ADA requirements. At the time of approval of
the final plat or final site development plan, whichever comes first, for the adjacent
westem property, if the owner does not provide an interconnection and record a cross
access easement to the Developer of Gaspar Station, the easement on the Gaspar
Station PUD shall automatically terminate.
5.3 OPEN SPACE REQUIREMENTS
The total project is 17,7 acres requiring a minimum of 5,3 acres to be retained as open
space.
5.4 NATIVE VEGETATION RETENTION REQUIREMENTS
A minimum of 15% of the native vegetation present shall be preserved within the project.
The total native vegetation existing on the site is approximately 16.3 acres and a
minimum of 2.4 acres of native vegetation shall be preserved within the existing and
proposed preserve areas as indicated on the CPUD Master Plan, Areas that fulfill the
native vegetation retention standards shall be set aside as preserve areas and shall be
protected by a permanent conservation easement. A management plan shall be
submitted to identify actions that must be taken to ensure that the preserved areas will
function as proposed. The plan shall include methods to address control and treatment
of invasive exotic species and maintenance of permitted facilities,
5,5 CLEARING AND FILL STORAGE
Fill storage is generally permitted as a temporary principal use throughout the Gaspar
Station CPUD until buildout of the project. Fill material may be transported and stockpiled
within areas which have been disturbed. Prior to stockpiling in these locations, the
developer shall notify the Community Development and Environmental Services
Administrator. The following standards shall apply:
1. Stockpile maximum height: forty five feet;
2, Fill storage areas in excess of five feet in height shall be separated from
developed areas by fencing, excavated water bodies or other physical barriers If
the side slope of the stockpile is steeper than 4 to 1.
Received 8/27/07
5-2
Agenda Item No, Be
November 27, 2007
Page 126 of 127
5.6 LITTORAL SHELF PLANTING
Wet detention ponds shall have a littoral shelf with an area equal to 7% of the pond's
surface area measured at the control elevation and be planted with native aquatic
vegetation,
5,7 AFFORDABLE HOUING
The Developer shall make a donation to Collier County Affordable Housing Trust Fund in
the amount of $0,50 per square foot of gross leasable floor area as depicted on
approved Site Development Plans, The payment shall be made as a condition to the
issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy and the amount shall be for the gross leasable
floor area for that particular Certificate of Occupancy, Such payments shall be credited
against any subsequently adopted fee for affordable or workforce housing by Collier
County,
Received 8/27/07
5-3
L)"-"-
""ON
O~
ON-
'7 ,0
~"-
;:::N~
(i):......,,-
........0
-.OJ'"
E' ==::YJ
'-..-' Q) ro
~>[L
_0
4:2
a::Z if, - ,t: ~~ I.! ~ I ! !~ I c ~
~OO . ~ ' ~~~:i m "-
u' I 'Ii 211~f, ~~' il~.I~ II n: 0
,.; ~J- J:Ji;:! o "=!'~1~ !U ~
VI!;;:=> v I ~ Uli~i ~
c. ~ l'lli! I~ ji B m >-
<Cf-'o.. m I ::;
z '" ~ !J~ :i w
i 0 w
I.::JVI .;~ . ;.: III J:
~ ~ ~ ::>
~ V>
. I u I . <
,
~
;~
~~~~~~
Lll_m'!t<q,....
ON""':N...:r-:
- -
I c:
>- IV 15<11
~ ~l ~i
~ ~-a:; ~ g-u
~ ~i'i~>~
~ 8:: g.~"E
~ ~~eJL~
::l 2~!~g
c ~ ill ~ ~ 1U:-'-'
:? ~"'" c.. ~ ,-=~.g
..J .E~O ~-=:'1-
~"
~~
~~
~ ~
.~ 'S
dr
H,
00
H
iiE
.0
~i
=5
ii~
E 0
:>a
. u ,
C ~ C
. C 0
E Ill.-
;;;11"8
H~
..~
FlV~
..~~
E i:i'!:
"E~
.;
.
~i/
";;"'"
.!!!r.J
a ,
~~
c"
O~
'-"'0
~~
.9
';:~
~~
z a; ~
o ~ u
i= :;:~
~ .~ ~
l!) z<
w "'~
~ ~~
>
!;;:
z
~~~1V:;
E . ~ l
f .!! ~c !
~~ ~~~ i
~ ~ ~.l:' I
1'],.,.. ~~':;:.....:.
w ~Hntla
u *- no. ~ c.~ 5:""
~ ~~~-g.E.!i~~
ZV'l 6:;:a-~5.5V;o
00
~ ~ ~ ~
o ,,",,",0
0-
00
.",
u~
.!f:.:=.
~r-~~---:-""':1j.' i
"" "I .
i .;1-0:------.., \!I \ :
~ I, flI . Ii: "0
l1'" .1, , ~.
'-T J, --.'.'F-'-~= !,i, ~ I I
: \..~J \, L' ~ ; ~
" ii' i i
~:~~~=~~:~-=-~~=~~~ ~~~:~ =:::::;;~'f...=~~;,,-~.:~;:~~_,~ej
--'7,""n"""'~ _n'~ ~ -~~- ~'iii..~ I
~- ;;;~~~7_'~J S'=-o n~~=-~O-IFij;--~-"'----'--. ~Ui I
nl : ,~ .~~ I
I ~ I i,1 ~ r-'/-------,./--'\II' ~ ~llf' )
~ !~f ~ r!l\ j-j i.\I>:'i.-' ~ i
;!; :) ~ ~':a: "':l! , l ,.",,,~~<<:,,,. :3 ,
-1'- '" / ~H \~~~1-~ ~ /
I j~'; i ~~ij ).'t, ~ ,j
I! ~ 1 !i (~~.~':J /
'L: ,----~' j '.", / -
I )' i Jl ( ~__..._~~__~~/l:.\~*~",,, k H ..t~
,: '>', / :~~~~~;~ :1"'F'
! Ii em, ____~--~-,=--'-'-lL----m~ ,_,-:::,-_<,~-=:",dltl\~. i '!1~i
I 1 ~ ~iH
I ~~
I, ,
L.
~I ~I I
~' .
~ j I
i i
=
o ,
.!
~I
~!
1li
~u
~~1;Ij
---:::._.._._-~._...._..-_--':.__...-_..----_._------~.._--_._-
,..-.--.....-..,.........-, -.....-..-
COLLIER COUNTY
130JlRD (IF :aUNTY C()MM!SSlO!~EP.S
--
Item Number:
Item Summary:
- r,i~.; I:,'" I :c, 'lL-iT'C I\.,:C:
r')r,,~q "'.It;'cn by I',nd",',~;; [;
""
b.PCIPI ~,
I'thr- "iT<)I""
Meeting Dllte:
1/'27" 'C 0'1
Prepared 8y
,-"jii'-ilijon
2'~"';\J ;','C, ;!,af;O" ,- to rh'_' F~C
cl::>ani ,,' ~;(>lJnt:.'
::>'-." U';[C
;~"mmi.S5iol""';
ApproverJ By
.'''L',~" '" [.,.hid"
i\':~[\, ,YF
"'.:(J,,' ,re',um',
e.LmL'ih:.";"J
:"'"18
;_'~('(J
Page 1 of 1
tc.(Mnd,j limn No, fJA
:'~::>\iernbe[ 27. 2007
P8ge'1 of 1
'/v',-'1"J'- ')i(jani
I-Ie
,;'f
---
--
filc://C:\AgcndaT est\Export\93-Novc11l ber~"o102 7.'%202007\09_ %20BOAR DO,'<:.2001:%20C.. 1\ /20/2007
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Ageneja Item [\]0. 98
!'~ovemb8r 27, 2007
Page 1 of 15
APPOINTMENT OF MEMBER(S) TO THE VANDERBILT BEACH BEAUTIFICATION
MSTU ADVISORY COMMITTEE
OB.JECTIVE: To appoint 1 member to 4 year term, expiring on November 13, 201], to the
Vanderbilt Bcach Beautification MSTU Advisory Committce.
CONSIDERATIONS: The Vanderbilt Beach Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee
had 2 terms cxpire on November 13, Z007. This 5 member committee was established on July
31, ZOO] by Ordinance No. ZOO 1-43 to aid and assist the BCC in carrying out the purposes of the
MSTU, to prcparc and recommend to thc BCC an itemized budget for thc MSTU and
recommend work programs and priorities to the County Manager. Members must be peI111anent
residents within the MSTU. Terms will be 4 years. A list ofthc current membership is included
in the backup,
The terms for William Llewellyn Schmidt and Carol Wright expired on November 13.2007. A
pl~ess release was issued and resumes \\.'crc rec~lvcd fi"()111 tne foBo\ving .3 interested citizens:
APPLICANT
CATEGORY
DlST ELI(CTOR ABY. COMM,
I Robert A. BU111s Resides within MST1:-withdrt'w -i=i Yes None
i Bruce Resides WithIn ' V"S -
R, I:orman MSTl' '- c._ None
I Jacqueline VI", Rammel Reside',; viitllin )VIST(.withdre" ~ i v Nnn~'
,_ I es
-
~
"
ATTENDANCE: N/A
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Brucc R. FOI11lan
FISCAL IMPACT: NONE
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: NONE
RECOMMENDA TION: That the Board of County Commissioners consider the
recommendation for appointment, appoint I member, and direct the County Attorney to prepare
a resolution confirming the appointment.
Prepared By: Sue Filson, Executive Manager
Board of County Commissioners
Agenda Date: NOVEMBER 27,2008
Page 1 of 1
A::(~l1da Iterll No. 9B
I'JINHnt)(ol 27, 2007
Pane~:of15
COLLIER COUNTY
BOAR;} OF COUNTY CQMMfSSIONEF:S
Item Number:
'5
flemSummary:
Meeting Date:
Lq,)Yr1irlif;n' III nll)(-~ to (flP \'an:ie'-;,,;' r~f';;ln', H[-'21:,tt:'t;:;jl,,}r i'~~:TU r '.1"II,/.1r,' '::'G'fHrilt~2e
cU' ',I',!
Prl'flllrl'd By
SLI""lt,,qr'
':~,%utIVt. ManOf,!!H: , lhf) fie::
I;~t(,
H()Mci0IC()~m;'li
::.ommiss.oncrr,
r:cc .:1t',c~
ApprrlVI'U By
./Jrll"" V, /iIU(j(1
",OUp!v r,'~n~8~"
U)lc:
"h""::',(:,i';;\,,,nw
'_.:J"';Y1;~""','nt"'"
';",-,1'1(,' hhr;~(J"- -,un"".
:)M
file:! /e: \AgendaTest\Export\93" November%2027 ,%202007\09. %.20BOARD%200F%20C.. 11120/2007
fi,qenda item t\Jo. 98
N~ovember 27, 2007
Page 3 of 15
8r (-:Ounty
.,.,.," ---
~< - .
_,- . M._~._..... .........
TO: Sue Filson, Executive Manager
Board of County Commissioners
FROM: Tessie Sillery, Operations Coordinator
DATE: November 8, 2007
SUBJECT: Vanderbilt Beach Beautification MSTU
Recommendation to the Board for filling vacant position.
-
The Vanderbilt Beach Beautification MSTU has received and reviewed three applications by the prescribed
deadline for its two vacancies, Both Mr, Robert Burns and Miss, Jacqueline Bammel withdrew their
applications for personal reasons, The third applicant was evaluated based on the potential contributions
to the Committee. He meets the criteria required to be eligible for the committee and resides within the
MSTU's district boundary.
The Committee recommends the following applicant for appointment to the vacant tenn as indicated
below:
NAME
TYPE OF
APPOINTMENT
New -Appoinnnenl
TERM
EXPIRES
FIELD OF EXPERTISE/CATEGORY
Bruce R. Forman
Resident in Naples 4 + years, BS Ed, - Health
Education. Ohio SllI1e University MPH - Health
Care Organization and Administration -
University of Medicine and Dentistry of New
Jersey
Background: Worked in Pubic Service Field.
specifically Public Health Fields., Consumer &
Environmental Health for 30 years.
Community Activities - Past member of the
Vanderbilt Property Owners A"lsoc. and the
Vanderbilt Beach and Bav A<;sociation.
Please let me know you need any other information
Transportation Services Division
Alt, Transportation Modes Department
,!\Qenda Item No 98
I'J"ovember 27, 2"007
Page 4 of 15
Vanderbilt Beach Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee
Name Work Phone Appt'd J:.xp. Date Term
Home Phone DateRe-appt 21ldExpDate 2nd Term
Mr, Charles C. Arthur 09/24/02 I ] /13/04 2 Years
239 Channel Drive 594-8958 11/16/04 ] 1/13/08 4 Years
Naples, FL 34] 08
E-Mail: ccarthur@msn,com
District: 2
Category: Resident - Conners Vanderbilt Beach Estates
Mr. William Llewellyn Schmidt I 1/] 8/03 11/13/07 4 Years //
v
405 Pine Avenue 596-8546
Naples, FL 34108
E-Mail:
District: 2
Category: Resident-Vanderbilt Beach Estates
Mr. Richard E. Lydon 11113/01 1lI13/05 4 Years
450 Tradewinds Avenue 597-2746 11-15-05 11 -13-09 4 Years
Naples, FL 34108
E-Mail: dlydonl24@aoI.com
District: 2
Category: Resident-East Side ofVanderbiIt Lagoon
Ms. Carol Wright 01/08/02 I 1/13103 2 Years /
9375 GuIfshore Drive 597-9503 11/18/03 11/13/07 4 Years
Naples, FL 34108
E-Mail:
District: 2
Category: Resident-Seawatch Condominiwn
Mr. Alvin Martin, Jr, 01/08/02 11/13/04 3 Years
9790 Gulf shore Drive, #306 514-3067 11/16/04 11/13/08 4 Years
Naples, FL 34108
E-Mail: bud,martin@att,net
District: 2
Category: Resident-Le Dauphin
':,,;. -""""O::;_7:,:';-:::"~:_:_-~:-,-~,-",; _
Wron~d~.Febroaryl~2~7
_~,,:o:
"--'cT',-r_ "'~"'_"""~:'_"',~,;.
-,-
;~""'"",""W_'_"~J-..'
Pagel of 2
Agenda Jtem No. 98
November 27.2007
Page 5:Jf 15
Vanderbilt Beach Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee
Name
Work Phone
Home Phone
Appt'd
DateRe-appt
Exp, Date
2ndExpDate
Term
2nd Term
This 5 member committee was established on July 31, 2001 by Ordinance No, 2001-43 to aid
and assist the BeC in carrying out the purposes of the MSTU, to prepare and recommend to the
BCe an itemized budget for the MSTU and recommend work programs and priorities to the
County Manager. Members must be permanent residents within the MSTU, After initial
appointments, terms will be 4 years,
FL STAT: Chapter 125, 165 & 200
Staff: b<. ElcLMI., Transportation Operations eoordinator: 417-6081
-re >S, -e S;J lut
Wedllesday;Fehruary 14,:2007"
Page 2 oJ2
Agenda Item No, 98
November 27,2007
Page 6 of 15
MEMORANDUM
DATE: September 28, 2007
", t";(.T;C{1 ,;~~10::~;;'
TO:
Elections Office W
Sue Filson, Executive Manager, . .. J
Board of County Commissioner .I
FROM:
RE:
Voter Registration - Advisory Board Appointments
The Board of County Commissioners will soon consider the following individuals for
appointment to one of the county's advisory committees, Please let me know if those listed
below are registered voters in Collier County,
Also, please list the commission district in which each applicant resides,
COMMISSION DISTRICT
VANDERBILT BEACH BEAUT MSTU ADV COM
Robert A. Burns
10173 Gulfshore Drive
Naples, FL 34108
~
Bruce R. Forman
11116 Gulfshore Drive, Unit 903B
Naples, FL 34108
~
Jacqueline W. Barnmel
9486 Gulfshore Drive
Naples, FL 34108
d--
Thank you for your help.
filS0"_S
Page 1 of 1
;-I.Genoa Item !\lo. 9B
l\fovember 27, 2D07
Page 7 of 15
From: sillery_t
Sent: Wednesday, October 24, 2007 8:50 AM
To: filson_s
Cc: sbdburns@comcast.net; RichardDarryl
Subject: FW: Vanderbilt Beach MSTU - vacancies
Sue: Here is Mr. Burns email withdrawing his application
From: sbdburns@comcast.net (mailto:sbdburns@comcast.net]
Sent: Tuesday, October 23, 2007 5:24 PM
To: sillery-t
Subject: Fw: Vanderbilt Beach MSTU
Sorry. Meant to forward prior e-mail.
--- Original Message -----
From: sbdburns@comcastnet
To: sdlery.!
Sent: Friday, October 19, 2007 7: 11 AM
Subject: Vanderbilt Beach MSTU
Tessiel
This will confirm that I must withdraw my application for the Vanderbilt Bcach Beautification MSTU Advisory
Committee, I work during the week and am not able to attend that meetings as scheduled,
Robert A. Bums
--- Original Message ----
From: sillery.t
To: sbdburns@comcast.net
Sent: Thursday, October 18, 2007 5:32 PM
Subject: You requested my email
I notified the committee that you were withdrawing your application due to the time the committee met. Please email me back
when you can,
Tessie Sillery, OperaNons Coordinator
239-252-5840
10/24/2007
filson_s
Page 1 0[2
Agenda Item 1"0, 98
November 27,2007
Page 8 of ',5
0- From: sillery_t
Sent: Monday, October 22, 2007 12:08 PM
To: filson_s
Cc: RichardDarryl; flagg_d
Subject: FW: Vanderbilt Beach MSTU - Request your attendance
Importance: High
Sue: The following applicants have withdrawn their applications:
Mr, Burns - reason:
Phone conversation' The time the meetings are scheduled is not a good time for him,
Miss, Bammel - reason for withdraWing application -see email below,
Note: Mr Forman IS,very interested to be on the mstu board, - Me. Forman - attended the October 18'h meeting - The committee
chose to hold off and vote at their next meeting,
ressie Sillery, Operations Coordinator
From: Jackie Bammel [mailto:jwbammel@embarqmail.com]
-Sent: Sunday, October 21, 20077:07 PM
: slllerLt; jwbammel@embarqmail.com; sbdbums@comcast.net; FBAYVIEW@aol.com
_c: 'Dick Lydon'; RichardDarryl; flagg_d; SCHAPIN43@aOl.com; 'Darlene'
Subject: RE: Vanderbilt Beach MSTU . Request your attendance
Tessie,
After careful consideration, I have decided to withdraw my application for the Vanderbilt MSTU board position, However, I will
continue to support the efforts of the committee by continuing to work toward the burial of the lines and supporting other projects
whenever possible,
Thank you for your consideration,
Jacqueline Bammel
----Original Message-----
From: sillery.t [mailto:TessieSillery@colliergov,net]
Sent: Thursday, October 11, 2007 10:43 AM
To: jWbammel@embarqmail.com; sbdbums@comcast.net; FBAYVIEW@aol,com
Cc: Dick Lydon; RichardDarryl; f1agQ....d; SCHAPIN43@aOl.com; Darlene
Subject: Vanderbilt Beach MSTU - Request your attendance
Attention: Applicants
Robert Burns
Bruce R. Forman Jacqueline Bammel
10/22/2007
.,
Page 2 of2
Agenda item l--io, 98
November 27, 2007
Hello, my name is Tessie Sillery, I am the Operations Coordinator and Danyl Richard is the Project M~fJf!lr ti!!e
Vanderbilt Beach MSTU, This is to notify you of the upcoming Vanderbi~ Beach MSTU meeting and to request your
attendance, The committee will be reviewing your applications,
. Date: October 18, 2007
. Site: SI. John Evangelist Parish Life Center (625 III th Avenue, Naples,)
. Time: 10:00 am
Please let me know if you need any assistance,
Tessie Sillery
Operations eoordinator
252-5840,
10/22/2007
MEMORANDUM
Agenda Item No. 98
November 27, 2007
Page 10 of 15
DATE:
September 28, 2007
TO:
Tessie Sillery, Transportation~\'ons
Sue Filson, Executive Manager X/
Board of County Commissioner.; (\
FROM:
RE:
Vanderbilt Beach Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee
As you know, we currently have vacancies on the above-referenced advisory committee. A press
release was issued requesting citizens interested in serving on this committee to submit an
application for consideration, I have attached the applications received for your review as follows:
Robert A. Burns
10173 Gulfshore Drive
Naples, FL 34108
Bruce R, Forman
] 1116 Gulfshore Drive, Unit 903B
Naples, FL 34108
Jacqueline W. Banunel
9486 Gulfshore Drive
Naples, FL 34108
Please let me know, in writing, the recommendation for appointment of the advisory committee
within the 41 day time-frame, and I will prepare an executive summary for the Board's
consideration,
Please include in your return memo the attendance records of the applicants recommended for
reappointment.
Please categorize the applicants in areas of expertise. If you have any questions, please call me
at 774-8097.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
SF
Attachments
Advisory Board Application
filson_s
From: sbdburns@comcast.net
at: Thursday, September 27,20071:07 PM
~ filson_s
Subject: New On-line Advisory Board Application Submitted
Advisory Board Application Form
Collier County Government
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples, FL 34112
(239)774-8999
Application was received on: 9/27/2007 1:06:59 PM.
Name: /RobertA. Burn~ Home Phone: 1..<:3<1-SQ/.j- ohq::z.
Home Address: I] 0173 GulfShore Driv~
City: Naplesl Zip Code: ~4] 081
Phone Numbers
Fax: I Business: I
. e-Mail Address:~bdburnsla)comcast.ne~
Work Place: !Edison Colleg~
How lon~ have you lived in Collier County: B
Have you ever been convicted of any offense a~ainst the law? IEB
Are you a registered voter in Collier County? ~
Board / Committee Applied for: Iv anderbilt Beach Beatification MSTUI
Category: !Not indicate~
Do you currently hold public offfice? IEB
Do you currently or ever served on a Collier County Board or
. Please list your community activities:
I
Education:
IBA Chemistrv. PhD Chemistrvl
9/27/2007
~
Page I of2
!-\oenda Item !~o 95
hrOv8rnber- 27, 20C:'7
Page 11 of '1::;
Advisory Board Application
lEA Chemistry, PhD Chemistryl
Page 2 of2
Agenda Item I'~o. 98
November 27, 2007
Page 12 of 15
.
'-.
--
9/27/2007
Advisory Board Application
filson_s
Page 1 of2
)\,genda item No. 98
November 27, 20U7
Page 13 of 15
From: FBAYVIEW@aol.com
at: Thursday, September 27,2007 1 :34 PM
~: filson_s
Subject: New On-line AdvisOty Board Application Submitted
\,
Advisory Board Application Form
Collier County Government
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples, FL 34112
(239)774-8999
Application was received on: 9/27/20071:33:36 PM.
Name: !Bruce R, Forman/ Home Phone: ~39-566-85931
Home Address: 111116 Gulfshore Dr.. Unit 9~
City: /Naplesl Zip Code: 134] 081
Phone Numbers
Fal.:: I Business: ~
. e-Mail Address: jFBA YVIEWlaJ,aoLcomj
Work Place: /Retiredj
How lon~ have you lived in Collier County: ~
Have you ever been convicted of any offense a~ainst the law? ~
Are you a registered voter in Collier County? ~
Board / Committee Applied for: !vanderbilt Beach Beautification MSTU Advisory Boardj
Category: /Not indicate~
Do you currently hold public offfice? ~
Do you currently or ever served on a Collier County Board or Committee? ~
. Please list our communi activities:
ast member of the Vanderbilt Pro e Owners Assoc, and the Vanderbilt Beach and Ba
Education:
!B.S, Ed.- Health Ed.- The Ohio State University M,P,H. - Health Care Organization and
9/27/2007
-
dministration- Universi of Medicine and Denti
Page 2 of2
A enda Item No, 98
I oV8mber 27, 2007
Page 14 of 15
Advisory Board Application
~
-9
-.
9/27/2007
of New Jerse .
.
.
.
FR;:J~ .TO'-f\ BHf1M~L
PHOI,IE liD.
S~p, 27 2~3e~~;~~ 8~ OD
N-ovember 27,2007
Page 15 of 15
23'3 5'371.::.73
Board of County Commissioners
33lJl East Tllmiami Trail
Naples. FI" 34112
(239) 252-8097
...: (239) 252-3602
Application for Advisory Committees/Boards
Name:.J@flt~':~ ~. ~~e{ HomePh.ne: c!J..19~6'r7-t:373
H.m.Add....s: uf.ho re. Dr. ~~ Zip Code: ,3Yte R
.'" ':;Q,591-j3 'l ~ Bu.;ness Phon.,'________ "-m'il.d<lr."'.jl,,)b::iJl{med&M~f)1Q, f.
D ' 00""
1'1.<e 6f Employm.nt:_ ll-efi V'<!'d _' __,___, _'____
Board or Committee Appli.d for:J a >'I--1~...iilJ l+- ,8<:h.a4 111 ST2J Ih:I j)1$Cy, ( ~dj~<'!iJ
Cate~ory (>fapplicabie),_ _
Eumpl*': Commiuiun .!lktnc:t, 1>""..I(lp.r. fllll~l"OllD'".e.tnli,t, iM~p;;:-~n, tt~
How lone. have you lived. jn Collier C(Jun~': Y~~rs___iO
Month~
Ar-e. YCiU a re~is:tered voter in ColliE!r County: 'i:" es -..J.{"____No
Do }'OU currently hold public office? \"'e~
if _0, whit t. tl\a~ office'!
'io
Ran YOll ever been convicted of any offense against the Law?
If yt$. eApJain;
~ClS No ~/
Do YOlJ n(IoW $(!rvc. or bavf you ~'tr >erv~, on #II CoWer CouDt)' board or cumminec? Yet _____ No ,/
If yt$1 please H$t tbe coth.mitteeslb<1ard$:
Please list your c(lmmunity acth'tties (dvic elub5, neighborhood a ociations, etc. and positions
held: ' , .
a .~
,1
Education; 4 5~1 aJe.s ~.... + tiA,,), ';"/~\_1 a.v>>-.s.e>.<;;
E~pen.ne~: ~ ~ ~WYleJ-. o~ ~;e ~ hVM-
1';,H~/:; ~ (. ';~ .{:','I,I +1 -e Ay,e
~~ ~7Ef;;~e~f%:i~~{i!;l^~~~f-'r~/.,:::;r -
---
PIM"~ lUt",1 U"}~ 4Idrlilumal i~f9,.IItJUiqfl )Ie.. fi:l!1 Mf'd..."d. ni~ IIpplic>tJ,hm :;hnf</ti ~ Jr>~r-dNt I;' SW-FiJll"IJ, ExtJ~Mti~ MII1'IIl';r-;;--
sh.t &Jard fllCOUMf,l C""'/lfWW-It'rs, J31j 1 EoM Tltm,.,,,,; 71'diJ. Nllpk-;. F'I. 'U I 12, If:!olr whJJ, ~fI fM )'f.'jU ""plicl1WIf M)
(U~)152-J6(J1 or fl-"'"" W ~~r:iiiJoNlilr.rDO;,"u".IU:L Thank Yt1U ft1r ,ttlu,u"'1'11tJ: II; Ikfn'f!"~ CUi"'N~' lI'f C,,1Ji.n C<JM"~
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Agenda Item I~o, 9C
November 27, 2007
Page 1 of 10
APPOINTMENT OF MEMBER(S) TO THE COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT
BOARD
OBJECTIVE: To appoint] member to fultjll the remainder of a vacant term, expiring on
February 14, 2008, to the Collier County Code Enf()rcement Board,
CONSIDERA nONS: The Collier County Code Euforcemcut Board has 1 vacancy due to a
resignation with the tern1 expiring on Febmary 24, 2008. This 7 member board. plus 2 alternate
members. is composed of. but not limited to, individuals representing the occupations of
architect. businessman, engineer, general contrador, subcontractor and Realtor and are
considered, in part, on the basis of experience or interest in the areas of the codes and ordinances
to be enj()rced. Members are required to file a r01111 I Statcment of Financia] Interest each year
with the Supervisor ofEleetions. Terms are 3 years,
A list or the cmrent membership is induded in the backup.
Mr. Gerald J. Lefebvre resigned on September 28. 2007 to become a candidate. A press release
Vlas issued and I resume was received f-l-om the j-(dlowing interested citizen:
APPLICANT
CATEGOIlV
IllST ELECTOR ADV, COMM,
LGerald J. ':.t'1cbvre--lREGUl.AR . Real f:>,tare/Zoning i '
r;:;;~-~
I_~~~
I
ATTENDANCE: Perfect Attendance
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: Quasi-Judicial -- no recommendation
FISCAL IMPACT: NONE
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: NONE
RECOMMENDA nON: That the Board of County Commissioners consider the
recommendation for appointment, appoint I member, and direct the County Attorney to prepare
a resolution confirming the appointments,
Prepared By: Sue Filson, Executive Manager
Board of County Commissioners
Agenda Date: NOVEMBER 27, 2007
--
Page 1 of I
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Item Number:
Item Summary:
Meeting Date:
FT" )i'1;,lne~1 ')' "'kll"~.lC tr, t'w C (-,Ii,,' (11.tr1ty C,c;;e t',',ic"cc"-:fJnt l-l,');Hc!
:1:'2-''',01'
,.-M
Prepared By
Su,,"rlr<)(,
E:~(lCllt""."Mafl"g,,rh\i1(, E,:::C
;:."t"
BnMdof{;oumy
[-',CC-:)ihee
CaMmi!;,,;"n"'r~
Approved By
',W,(H f,'ludd
>w"'-vMarwpw
'_;Me
F''',;,t'( C:Hmt>
-~('f1;'''E''IOrt''''':'
';rH1l1:\1 f)il1nU,lW Uf!'f.'--
'l'1\1120(]72:ihPM
file://C:\AgendaT est\Export\93- November%2027, %202007\09. %20BOARD%200F%20C ... 11/20/2007
,A,genda Item hio. 9C
['..Jovember 27, 2007
Page 3 of 10
Memorandum
To:
Sue Filson, Executive Manager
Board of County Commissioners
From:
Michelle Arnold, Code Enforcement Director
Date:
November 9, 2007
Subject:
Code Enforcement Board
I am in receipt of your memo dated November 2, 2007 in which you requested review of
applications submitted by citizens interested in serving on the Code Enforcement Board (CEB),
The resumes for the applicant listed below were reviewed and meet the Code Enforcement
Board Consolidated Ordinance No. 2007-44, general classification requirements in the following
categories:
NAME
CATEGORY
Gerald J, Lefebvre
Realtor
Mr. Lefebvre was a regular member of the Code Enforcement Board who resigned September
28, 2007 to conform with the Board of County Commissioners' rules requiring advisory board
members running for office to resign, Mr. Lefebvre had a perfect attendance as a member of
the Code Enforcement Board for calendar year 2007.
Please consider the residency of the applicant to ensure that the various communities
throughout the County are being represented,
Should you require additional input please feel free to contact me at 403-2413.
Code Enforcement Department
Agenda Item No, 9C
November 27, 2007
Page ~ of ',Q
Collier County Code Enforcement Board - North
Name Work Phone Appt'd Exp, Date Term
Home Phone DateRe-appt 2ntlExpDate 2nd Term
Mr. Lionel L 'Esperance 273-4424 01/23/07 02114/10 3 Years
86 Mahogany Drive 566-2274
Naples, FL 34108
E-Mail: Lioneljr@aol.com
District: I
Category: ALTERNATE -Plumbing Contractor
Mr. Charles Martin 784-5498 10/24/06 02114/09 3 Years
2222 Gulfshore Boulevard N" #Q3 262-7287
Naples, FL 34102
E-Mail: realtygloba1@aol.com
District: 2 11';;Wi
Categm:v: AL TERNA TE-Realtor j Ro.) UI-" v
. {!rt
Mr. Richard Kraenbring~I1 tJirl'596-2315 10/26/04 02114/06 4 months
l-995 Tarpoo B~' Im"" h #2!H 298-6215 04/26/05 02/24/08 3 Years
Naples, FL,3A119 3r..{/ffR
E-Mail: rkraenbring@swfia.rr.com
District: 3
CategolJ!: REGULAR - Construction
,
,
Ms, Sheri Barnett 09/10/02 02/14/05 ,
591-2149 3 Years I
1160 27th Street, SoW. 455-4296 03/08105 02114/08 3 Years ,
Naples, FL 34117 I
E-Mail: scbamett1@#ear1hlink.net !
,
District: 5 ,
I
CategoIJ': REGULAR - Financial Planning I
I
Mr. Kenneth Kelly I
435-0014 02114/06 02114/07 I Year I
4260 16th Street, N.E. 354-2021 01/23/07 02114/10 3 Years
Naples, FL 34120 i
E-Mail: kenkellyroofing.com
District: 5
Category: REGULAR-Roofing Contractor
Friday, Janaary 26, 2007
Page 1 of3
Agenda Item t'.jo. 8C
November 27, 2007
Page 5 of 10
Collier County Code Enforcement Board - North
Name
Work Phone
Home Phone
Appt'd
DateRe-appt
Exp, Date
2ndExpDate
Term
2nd Term
Mr. Jerry P. Morgan 04/26/05
2350 Mont Claire Drive, #201 594-8204 01/23/07
Naples, FL 34109
E-Mail:
District: 2
Category: REGULAR - Consttuction
Mr, Gerald J. Lefebvre . ,J;
5389 Cove Circle ij.e5i() -0"\
~aple,s,FL 34119 +:I~ '
E-Ml1I/:
District: 3
CategOl}': REGULAR - Real Estate/Zoning
597-8500 04/28/02
nE 8~l)4 0 I /24/06
SQ3 -l(gl('f
Mr, George p, Ponte 02/18/97
565 Augusta Boulevard, Apt 10 793-1370 01/24/06
Naples, FL 34113
E-Mail:
District: 1
Category: REGULAR - Retired CBS Employee
Mr. Larry Dean Mieszcak 06/28/05
7280 Carducci Court 732-1713 01/24/06
Naples, FL 34114
E-Mail: LVMI960@earthlink.net
District: 5
Category: REGULAR - Real Estate
Fr;(Ia.J'. January 26,2007
Page 2 of3
02/14/07
02/14/10
02/14/03
02/14/09
02/14/00
02/14/09
02/14/06
02/14/09
2 Years
3 Years
I Year
3 Years
v/'
3 Years
3 Years
8mos
3 Years
Collier County Code Enforcement Board - North
Name
Work Pllone Appt'd Exp, Date
Home Plltme DateRe-appt 2ndExpDate
Agenda 11em No. 9C
November 27, 2007
Page 6 of 10
Term
2nd Term
This 7 member board was created pursuant to Chapter 162 of the FL Stat by Ordinance 88-89
and is composed of, but not limited to, individuals representing the occupations of architect,
businessman, engineer. general contractor. subconlraclor and Real\Dr and are considered, in
part, on the basis of experience or interest in the areas of the codes and ordinances to be
enforced. Members are required to file a Form 1 Statement of Financial Interest each year with
the Supervisor of Elections, T enns are 3 years, This is a Quasi Judicial Board, Two altemale
members were approved by Ord, 96-78 on 12/3196,
FLSTAT 162
Staff: Michelle Arnold, Code Enforcement Director:: 403-2413
-_.--....
Frida)', Janl/ary 26. 1007
Page 3 of3
,L.,qenda item f\io 9C
1'.Jovelllber 27, 2'007
Page 7 of 0
MEMORANDUM
DATE:
November 2, 2007
Elections Office i'
Sue Filson, Executive Manager \ I .
Board of County Commissioners
TO:
FROM:
RE:
Voter Registration - Advisory Board Appointments
The Board of County Commissioners will soon consider the following individuals for
appointment to one of the county's advisory committees, Please let me know if those listed
below are registered voters in Collier County,
Also, please list the commission district in which each applicant resides,
CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD
COMMISSION DISTRICT
Gerald J. Lefebvre
5389 Cove Circle
Naples, FL 34119
3
Thank you for your help,
MEMORANDUM
Agenda item No, 9C
November 27, 2007
Page 8 of 10
DATE:
November 2, 2007
TO:
Michelle Arnold, Code Enforc~ee~t irector
Sue Filson, Executive Manager '
Board of County Commissione "
FROM:
RE:
Code Enforcement Board
As you know, we currently have a vacancy on the above-referenced advisory committee, A press
release was issued requesting citizens interested in serving on this committee to submit an
application for consideration, 1 have attached the applications received for your review as follows:
Gerald], Lefebvre
5389 Cove Circle
Naples, FL 341] 9
Please let me know, in writing, the recommendation for appointment of the advisory committee
within the 41 day time-frame, and 1 will prepare an executive swnmary for the Board's
consideration,
Please include in your return memo the attendance records of the applicants recommended for
reappointment,
Please categorize the applicants in areas of expertise, If you have any questions, please call me
at 774-8097,
Thank you for your attention to this matler,
SF
Attachments
Advisory Board Application
filson_s
Page I of2
Agenda Item t\Jo. 9C
f'-Jovember 27, 2007
Pag/2 9 of 10
From: naplesproperties@comcasl.net
at: Thursday, November 01, 2007 9:37 AM
~ filson_s
Subje<:t: New On-line Advisory Board Application Submitted
Advisory Board Application Form
Collier County Government
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples, FL 34112
(239)774-8999
Application was received on: 111112007 9:36:48 AM.
Name: perald J. Lefebvr~ Home Phone: ~39-593-484~
Home Address: 15389 Cove Circl~
City: lNaplesl Zip Code: [34] ] 91
Phone Numbers
Fax: ~39-594-38391 Business: ~39-404-019~
. e-Mail Address:lnaplesproperties(iV.comcast.ne~
Work Place: !united Real Estat~
How lon~ have you lived in Collier County: [ill
Have you ever been convicted of any offense a~ainst the law? ~
Are you a registered voter in Collier County? ~
Board I Committee Applied for: !code Enforcement Boardj
Category: !Not indicate~
Do you currently hold public offiice? ~
!code Enforcement Boar~
Do you currently or ever sen'ed on a Collier County Board or Committee? Iy e~
. Please list our community activities:
oun Professional
Education:
luniversity of Connecticut Bachelors of Arts in Political Science!
1111/2007
Ex erience:
ollier County Code Enforcement Board May 2002-Septmenber 2007 Zoning Board of Appeal
allin ford, CT 1998-2001
Page 2 of2
L\genda Item No, ge
November 27,2007
Page 10 of 10
Advisory Board Application
.
-.
-.
1111/2007
Agenda item No. 9D
November 27, 2007
Page 1 of 16
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
APPOINTMENT OF MEMBER(S) TO THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING COMMISSION
OBJECTIVE: To appoint I member to fulfill the remainder of a vacant tcrn1, expiring on
October 1,2008, to the Affordable Housing Commission.
CONSIDERATIONS: The Affordable Housing Commission is a 9 member committee
created by Ordinance 91-65 as amended to monitor the implementation of the Affordable
Housing Task Force's recommendations. and the goals, objectives. and policies ofthe Housing
Elements of the County's Growth Management Plan and the City's Comprehensive Plan;
investigate the feasibility of tax increment Cll1ancing l'or infrastructure f,)r site development of
affordable housing for low income househo Ids; develop means or mechanisms (0 encourage a
voluntary program in which Realtors, and other holding deposits such as escrow accounts of
earnest money deposits or security f,)r rentals would deposit these in a selectcd hank where such
bank would contribute to the Housing Trust Fund a gin calculated on the average collected
balance i()r the month; investigate a plan t"r any linkage and inclusionary mning
recommcndations; revic\\ and determine the clTcct of proposed ordinances of affordable housing
and make recommendations to the Board of County ('ommissioncrs and the Naples City
Council; and investigate 'my other rclevant areas so directed by the Board of County
Commissioners. The Board ofCmmty COlllmissioners will appoint g mcmbers. including the
altemate member, two of which must live in the Rural Area fEast of Collier Boulevard), and one
of those must be a resident oflmlllokalee. The City of Naplcs wiJI appoint 2 members. The
commission shall be comprised of members from the county-at-Iarge. the City of Naples-at-
large. the development community, affordable housing providers, financial institutions, the legal
profession and realtors. Terms are 3 years. A list of the cUlTent membership is included in the
backup.
Ms. Esmeralda SelTata resigned on August 28, 2007. A press release was issued and resumes
were received from the following 3 interested citizens:
APPLICANT
CATEGORY
DIST ELECTOR ADV. COMM.
Fred N. Thomas, Jr. lmmokalee Resident 5 Yes Lake Trafford Task Force
lmmokalee EZDA
Rural Lands Stewardship Comm
Imm Master Plan &Visioning
Dona Schrim Naples Resident 2 Yes
Sheryl Soukup-withdrew Naples Resident 5 Yes
ATTENDANCE: N/A
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDA nON: Fred N. Thomas, Jr.
NOTE: Section Five (D) of Ordinance 2001-55 states that "No person shall serve on more than
.-' two County Boards simultaneously. If application is made for service on a third Board, the
applicant must resign simultaneously from one of his or her cUlTent Board positions, or the
,l\;;JBnda Item !'\jo, 9D
I\Jovember 27, 2007
Page 2 of 16
application for a third Board shall be disqualified. This provision. however, may be waived to
allow for service on additional Boards provided the Commission votes unanimously to waive
such provision. According to my rccords Fred N. Thomas, Jr. currently serves on the 4
committees listed abovc. If M1'. Thomas is appointed the Board will have to waive Scction Fivc
CD) of the ordinance.
FISCAL IMPACT: NONE
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: NONE
RECOMMENDA nON: That the Board of County Commissioners considcr the
rccommendation for appointment. appoint I mcmber, and direct the County Attol11ey to preparc
a resolution confirnling tbe appointmcnt.
Prepared By: Sue Filson, Exccutivc Manager
Board of C:ounty Comnllssioners
Agenda Bate: NOVEMBER 27, 2007
Page 1 of 1
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Item Number;
Item Summary;
Meeting Date:
"PPuIPtner;i C/ ,Tl("IllIY-~; 111s .~,fttYrlflble H:)1I5,ng , ,',Qp-d5S'CtI
"'TCU',"
11: iM
Prepared Uy
SiJ~ f'il5-f)fj
E:x'-,C.U\"j" ~bnJ9"r to tiw;;~
[late
Bc~ni ':)f(.oumV
CommlS5ioners
,;{'" Of be"
Appruved By
)~t'V,~ V I/,"d',:
1-,-":1:';)(>'"
!"7t"
..jOHdo:C.':JUr;ty
~~C1I.-"'-'" r\ljJr.ag'-'"'~-, .,)ffw<Oe
~ i!1:; }[)(F "or I"'~;-
(,""'''''',;L'nnrs
file://C:\Agenda Test\Export\93- Novembcr%2027, %202007\09. %20BOARD%200F%20C.. 11/20/2007
;:',aenda Item t\jo. 9D
November 27 2007
Page 4 of :3
Memorandum
To:
From:
Date:
Subject:
Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant to BCC
Marcy Krumbine, Director of Housing and Human Services
November 13, 2007
Affordable Housing Commission
The Affordable Housing Commission has received and reviewed the two, eligible
applicants for one "Immokalee resident" vacancy on the Commission.
The Commission is recommending the appointment of the following applicant to
the Affordable Housing Commission:
Fred Thomas, Jr. -
Fred has a history of working with public housing for over 30 years with 16 years
as the Executive Director of the Collier County Housing Authority. Fred also has
significant experience with serving on County advisory committees and
community redevelopment.
Other candidates are listed below.
Dona Schrim - realtor - non Immokalee resident
Sheryl Soukoup - Executive Director - Immokalee Non-Profit Housing - non
Immokalee resident
Agenda item No. 9D
November 27, 2007
Page 5 of,6
Affordable Housing Commission
Name
Work Phone Appt'd Exp, Date Term
Home Phone DateRe-appt 2ndExpDate 2nd Term
Mr. James AI Pusateri
4971 Carromar Drive
Naples, FL 34112
E-Mail: jpusat6700@aol.com
District: I
Category: Attorney and Judge
02/13/07
10/01/09
2 Years
775-7029
Mr. Stephen J. Hruby 430-3005 06112/07
1800 Gordon Drive 430-8011 06/12/07
Naples, FL 34102
E-Mail: shruby@architectsunlimited.com
District: 4
Category: County - Architecture; Affordable Housing Dev
] 0/01/07
10/01/10
4 Months
3 Years
- ~
Ms. Sally A. Masters
4401 Pond Apple Drive, S.
Naples, FL 34119
E-Mail: TT4N@aol.com
District: 3
Category: ALTERNATE
253-1579 09111107
592-5853
10/01/10
3 Years
Mr. James A. Warnken
208 Silverado Drive
Naples, FL 34119
E-Mail: jwarnken@markham-norton.eom
District: 3
Category: Finance
433-5554
353-1035
09/11/07
10/01/09
2 Years
-
)/jl1td
Ms. Esmeralda Serrata {-t /I 657-3649
"17 {
603 Nassau Street, Apt. 4 {, ,gO 657-5838
Irnmokalee, FL 34142
E-Mail: cchafl@aol.com
District: 5
Category: Collier COW1ty Housing Authority
OS/24/05
10101/08
3 Years V
.-/.
Th;;;~day, (/:;~b:;-25~2(/;/7~i':'~' ".:=:EWW~i
:',-""~,,:,,,,:'.'~~',:'l/.,:_:'.:..,' '.,:Tt1::.. ':r.c."{\:",~:"" "~-::e-::,,' .,,~= ....:.7'1l(" "'r;;'::";",,c~ :~_., ",
Page 1 of3
':C',"'~_",",,;;,..-:::-r
Affordable Housing Commission
Name
Work Pho"e
Home Pltone
Appt'd
DateRe-appt
3 Years
Mr. John Barlow
4351 Gulf Shore Blvd., N, #19N
Naples, FL 34103
E-Mail: johnbarIow@Ierivage.net
District: 4
Category: Safelite auto Glass
.J
Mr. Larry H. Fleming ~9f:/\ / /)1\
563 Park Shore Drive ( ~' 1-'"
Naples, FL 34103
E-Mail: NaplesRealEst@l.aoJ.com
District: 4
Category: City
649-6380 02/13/07
649-6380
659-6464 05/09/06
434-2120
Mr. Cormac Giblin 649-4040 06/12/07
770 Fountainhead Lane 649-8918
Naples, FL 34103
E-Mail: CormacGiblin@wilsonmiller.com
District: 4
Category: City of Naples
Mr. Kenneth Kelly 435-0014 03/28/06
4260 16th Street, N.E. 354-2021 10/23/07
Naples, FL 34120
E-Mail: ken@kellyroofmg.com
District: 5
Category: Roofing Contractor - Resides East of951
Mr. Brian L. Goguen 262-2600 06/12/07
6210 Golden Oaks Lane 513-0663
Naples, FL 34119
E-Mail: bgoguen@barroncollier.com
District: 3
Category: COUNTY - Bs Mgmt, EDC, Urban Lake Institute
(
'-'c<iJ:!t."''''''':c. ",:,~,,::"":=.1IIK .....~",.::,.".. .~'.
Thursday, October 25,2007
'."'=<l'_"';;";;:~.,' .,~~7_' _'C:;:~ ''3,,'' IT ," ""';:"I!"::',:':-~C:: "-"'_....' ~'.
Page2of3
Exp. Date
2ndExpDate
10/01/10
04/18/09
] ]/18/09
10/01107
10/01110
10/01109
,l\aenda Item No. 90
N'"'ovember 27, 2007
Page 6 of 16
Term
2nd Term
3 Years
2 Years
1 + Year
3 Years
2 Years
Agenda Item No. 90
November 27, 2007
Page 7 of 16
Affordable Housing Commission
Name
Work Phone
Home Phone
Appt'd Exp. Date
DateRe-appt 2ndExpDate
Term
2nd Term
This 9 member commission was created on July 23,1991, by Ordinance No. 91-65, to monitor
the implementation of the Affordable Housing Task Force's Recommendations, and the goals,
objectives, and policies of the Housing Elements of the County's Growth Management Plan and
the City's Comprehensive Plan. Terms are 3 years.
Amended by Ordinance No. 2005-69: the BCC will appoint 8 members, including the altemate
member, two of which must live in the Rural Area (East of Collier Boulevard), and one of those
must be a resident of Immokalee. The City of Naples will appoint 2 members. The commission
shall be comprised of members from the county-at-Iarge, the City of Naples-at-Iarge, the
development community, affordable housing providers, financial institutions, the (egal profession
and realtors.
On 12/14/04 the BCC adopted Ordinance 2004-77 to add 1 Alternate member to be appointed by
the BCC. The Alternate member shall serve in a voting capacity only when a regular member is
absent from a meeting.
On December 13, 2005, the BCC approved Ord. No. 2005-69 changing the composition of the
committee, 9 members and 1 alternate. The BCC will appoint 8 members, including the altemate
(2 of which must live in the Rural Area (East of Collier Boulevard), and one of those must be a
resident of Immokalee) and the City of Naples will appoint 2 members.
Jessica Rosenberg, Deputy City Clerk 213-1015
FLSTAT: none
Staff: Marcy Krumbine, Housing & Huma Services Director: 252-8442
_"'r-' ';""",.' ;...~~. ,,'.
Thursday, October 25, 2007
e>,'_........,
--":-:",.;,.,.
Page 3 of3
',-r,';",
Agenda !tern [\10. 9D
November 27,2007
Page 8 of 16
MEMORANDUM
DATE:
November 2, 2007
TO:
Elections Office ~
Sue Filson, Executive Manager \ /
Board of County Commissioners
FROM:
RE:
V oler Registration - Advisory Board Appointments
The Board of County Commissioners will soon consider the fallowing individuals for
appointment to one of the county's advisory committees. Please let me know if those listed
below are registered voters in Collier County.
Also, please list the eommission district in which each applicant resides.
AFFORDABLE HOUSING COMMlSSION
COMMISSION DISTRICT
Fred N. Thomas,.lr.
] 205 Orchid A venue
Irnrnokalee, FL 34142
5
eX
5
Dona Schrim
7513 Cordoba Circle
Naples, FL 34109
Sheryl Soukup
2675 Orange Grove Trail
Naples, FL 34120
Thank you for your help.
MEMORANDUM
Agenda Item No. 9D
November 27.2007
Page 9 ot 16
DATE:
November 2, 2007
TO:
Marcy Krumbine, Housing and I Serviees Director
Sue Filson, Executive Manager '
Board of County Commissioners v
FROM:
RE:
Affordable Housing Commission
As you know, we currently have a vacancy representing Immokalee on the above-referenced
advisory committee. A press release was issued requesting citizens interested in serving on this
committee to submit an application for consideration. I have attached the applications received for
your review as follows:
Fred N. Thomas, Jr.
1205 Orchid Avenue
Immokalee, FL 34142
Dona Schrim
7513 Cordoba Circle
Naples, FL 34109
Sheryl Soukup
2675 Orange Grove Trail
Naples, FL 34120
Please let me know, in writing, the recommendation for appointment of the advisory committee
within the 41 day time-frame, and I will prepare an executive summary for the Board's
consideration.
Please include in your return memo the attendance records of the applicants recommended for
reappointment.
Please categorize the applicants in areas of expertise. If you have any questions, please call me
at 774-8097.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
SF
Attachments
Advisory Board Application
(
f', 'Ch'~..-:( f{.u r.5
Agenda 1I!\:mft-,J]:l{}1[l
(-- ~~ovBmb-er'27. 2007
Fiage 10 of 16
tuckersam
.
From: filson_s
Sent:
To: tuckersam
Subject: FW: New On-line Advisory Board Application Submitted
From: fntjr@aol.com fmailto:fntjr@aol.com]
Sent: Fr'
To: filson_s
Subject: New On-line Advisory Board Application Submitted
Advisory Board Application Form
Collier County Government
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples, FL 34112
(239)774-8999
Application was received on: 7/13/2007 11:41:04 AM.
. Name: !Fred N. Thomas Jr.1 Home Phone: ~39-657-54471
Home Address: 11205 Orchid A ve.1
City: ~mmokale~ Zip Code: 134142-28301
Phone Numbers
Fax: I Business: ~39-657-81811
e-Mail Address:lfntjr@aol.coml
Work Place: iRetired)
How long have you lived in Collier County: !more than 15[
Have you ever been convicted of any offense against the law? ~
Are you a registered voter in Collier County? Iy e~
. Board / Committee Applied for: nf/o,..d'tt6le. h't!VSl~ C'emmJSs~
Category: /Not indicated)
7/13/2007
.
-1
.
Advisory Board Application
i\aenda 1~'i\J6. <oc2
N"'ovember 27. 2007
Page 11 of 16
Do you currently hold public offfice? ~
rnmokalee CRA Advisory, IMPVC, CAC ofMPO,Imrnokalee Water and Sewe
oard
~ou currently or ever served on a Collier County Board or Committee?
~
PIease list onr communi activities:
ast President or Chair of: Imrnokalee Rotary, Immokalee Chamber 0
Commerce, CCPC, IMPVC.
Edncation:
/BA Psycholomrl
Ex erience:
Retired in 2002, after 37 years in Public Housing Administration, the last 16 years
as tbe Executive Director of the Collier C.9llJ1tYJ{.'2usin~uthority.
7!l3/2007
Advisory Board Application
Page I of2
Agenda Item No. 9'J
November 27. 2007
Page 12 of 16
filson_s
From: Schrim3@aol.com
.t: Monday, October 15, 200712:48 PM
To: filson_s
Subject: New On-line Advisory Board Application Submitted
,
"'.
Advisory Board Application Form
Collier County Government
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples, FL 34112
(239)774-8999
Application was received on: 10/15/2007 12:47:44 PM.
Name: IDona Schrirnj Home Phone: ~39-596-1074)
Home Address: 17513 Cordoba CircJ~
City: iNaple~ Zip Code: 1341091
Phone Numbers
Fax: ~39-659-33331 Business: ~39-404-21811
. e-Mail Address:ISchrim3ia)aol.coml
Work Place: !prudential Florida WCI Realtyj
How lon~ have you lived in Collier County: [Ig
(
Have you ever been convicted of any offense a~ainst the law? ~
Are you a registered voter in Collier County? Iy e~
Board / Committee Applied for: [Affordable Housing Committe~
Cate~ory: !Committee membe~
Do you currently hold public offfice? ~
!Not Indicated!
Do you currently or ever served on a Collier County Board or Committee? ~
. Please list your community activities:
I
Education:
I- Virginia Intermont College: Applied ArtDesign. - Oberlin Conservatory: Applied Music/Piano. _
10/15/2007
Advisory Board Application
- -
ireland Colle e: Business Mana ement.
Page 2 of2
Aaenda Item No. 9D
November 2 ,2007
a ,3 of 16
.
'--...
-e
Ex erience:
Prudential Florida WCI Realtor since 2000. -Over 30 years of Real Estate experience, in both
evelopment and sales. -Redeveloped one of the largest marinas in the country (Founder of Sandusky
ay Development) -Former owner of a Kentucky Subdivision (principal ofHuntertown Properties in
ersailles, KY, a single-family housing development. -Columbus Chamber of Commerce-Economic
eveloper -Franklin County Guardian Ad-Iiturn program -Children's Hospital Econimic Developmen
oard in Columbus, Oho -Started several fundraisers for needy children in Colurnbus,Ohio (Catholic
Social Services and St.Stephen's Community House). -Started several fundraiseTS for the Arts in
Sandusky,Ohio (Arts CouneiI Board of Directors and Junior Art's League Board of Directors) -
ABOR community affairs committee-Habitat for Humanity fundraisers -Barron Collier High
School-fundraiser for my daughter's junior class. -Taught religious education at Stjohn's Church in
aples -Dona Schrim is actively involved in the Naples Area Chamber of Commerce, the Naples
hilhannonic League,Junior League of Southwest Florida and is a supporter of the Sunshine Kids,
Kids with cancer as well as a host of other chari fundraisin events.-
10/15/2007
filson_s
Page 1 of 1
Agenda Item No. 9D
I"ovember 27,2007
Page 14 of 16
From:
IRMAOutlook
Tuesday, October 23,2007 12:34 PM
filson_s
~
~t:
Subject: IRMA Message: Sheryl Soukup--Please Call
Contacts: Soukup, Sheryl
Caller: Sheryl Soukup Company: Immokalee Non-Profit Housing Exec. Dir.
H B (239) 657-8333 C (239) 560-7302
Message: She would like to withdraw her application for the affordable housing commission. Please call.
TELEPHONE MESSAGE
Sent By: AmodeiPatricia
.
.
(/
10/23/2007
Advisory Board Application
filson_s
Page 1 of2
Agenda Item No. 90
November 27, 2007
Page '15 of 16
- From: sherylsoukup@aol.com
~nt: Tuesday, October 09,20073:03 PM
To: filson_s
Subject: New On-line Advisory Board Application Submitted
Advisory Board Application Form
Collier County Government
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples, FL 34112
(239)774-8999
Application was received on: 10/9120073:03:08 PM.
Name: !sheryl Souku~ Home Phone: ~39-560-73021
Home Address: 12675 Orange Grove Traiij
City: lNaples! Zip Code: 1341201
Phone Numbers
Fax: ~39-657-83351 Business: ~39-657-83331
....., e-Mail Address: Isherylsoukup(Gjaol.comj
Work Place: ~mmokalee Non-Profit Housin~
How Ion~ have you lived in Collier County: [!]I
Have you ever been convicted of any offense against the law? 18.21
Are you a registered voter in Collier County? IY e~
Board I Committee Applied for: !Affordable Housing Commissio~
Category: !Not indicated!
Do you currently hold public offfice? 18.21
Do you currently or ever served on a Collier County Board or Committee? ~
.. Please list our communi activities:
mmokalee Foundation, Board member Rotary Club ofImmokalee, Member Leadership Collier, Class
f2008 Interfaith Florida, Board member Lake Trafford Elementary, SAC member All Kids Play
oundation of Corkscrew Communi , Volunteer Education Foundation, Take Stock in Children
10/10/2007
Advisory Board Application
.
.
Education:
!university of Massachusetts, B.S. Microbiology!
Page 2 of2
I -: ~ n:::, I~~,. t,!r, QD
rJovember 27, 2'OG7
Page Ai6of16
.
Ex cricncc:
rofessional: Executive Director of Immokalee Non-Profit Housing (operates two affordable rental
ousing developments in Immokalee, 80% fannworker) Disability Advocacy, including affordable
ousing issues: Immediate Past Chair of Family Care Council, Area 8; former member of Family Car
ouncil Florida; former Board member of Family Cafe (Tallahassee); founder and former Executive
irector of Families First of SWFL; advisory for Florida Developmental Disabilites Council
Tallahassee); Partners in Policymaking, Class of 2004; and mother of a child with developmental
isabilities.
10/10/2007
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
.l\genda Item I~D. 9E
November 27. 2007
Page 1 ot 8
APPOINTMENT OF MEMBER(S) TO THE IMMOKALEE ENTERPRISE ZONE
DEVELOPMENT AGENCY
OBJECTIVE: To appoint I membcr to fulfill the rcmainder of a vacant tcrm, expiring on April
4, 2011, to thc Immokalcc Enterprisc Zone Development Agency.
CONSIDERATIONS: The Immokalee Enterprise Zone Development Agency has I vacancy
with the tenn, expiring on April 4, 20 I I. This 13 mcmbcr committee was created on March 28,
1995, by Ordinance 95-22 to inducc private investment into distressed areas to crcate economic
opportunities and sustainable economic development for designated areas. To pennit Collier
County to pmiicipate in this program, the Board of County Commissioners nominated the
ImmokaJee Community to be considcred by the Florida Depmiment of Commerce for Enterprise
Zone designation in Resolution No. 95-24R, approved Mm'ch 28, 1995. As part of the formal
application for an Enterprise Zone, the Statc required that a comlTlittee consisting of a broad base
of citizens be established. The committee has representation irom the Immokalee Chamber of
Commerce, financial or insurancc cntities,husinesses operating within the nominated area,
residents living within the nominated area, nonprofit community-based organizations operating
within the nominated area, local Workibrcc Developmcnt Board, local code cnfcjrcement agcncy,
and local law enforcement agency. This cIlmmittee also sel'\l,,, as the Immokalce
Rcdevelopmcnt Board. A list of ihc eUlTen! memhership is included in the backup.
-
Carol Sykora, representing Local Codc Enlcjrcemcnt rcsigned on November! 5, 2007. An e-mail
was received from Michelle Edwards Arnold advising that Gary Dantini, a Code Enfc)rcement
employee will be replacing Ms. Sykora on tbe Immokalee EZDA.
ATTENDANCE: NIA
CODE ENFORCEMENT DIRECTOR RECOMMENDATION: Gary Dantini
FISCAL IMPACT: NONE
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: NONE
RECOMMENDATION: That the Bom'd of County Commissioners consider the
recommendation for appointment, appoint I member, and direct the County Attorney to prepare
a resolution confirming the appointment.
Prepared By: Sue Filson, Executive Manager
Board of County Commissioners
Agenda Date: NOVEMBER 27,2007
_.
Pagelofl
!>,oend;:; item No
r,r0Vemr)(;~1 n,
pago 2 0;8
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUrHY COMMISSIONERS
Item Number:
Item Summary:
Meeting Date:
'.i)r'.()ln:merll'ill"",rTlI:J9' 'i:;lhp. :rnmO"d"eE::;O:D:".
. ~'2 . ic'C:,( i" (;C,' 1('- ,:,1v1
Prepareu B~'
~~uc FllC,Of'
['('outivc \ilarl~(ler!<> tl"" Bce
1')1\1..
B"~rG Dr Count'
l:C;C Olfiql'
r';?mm;S,io"N,.
AppruvNl Hy
Jurn",,\'i,1utj,:
':"umy !'.~an~?er
".~tf'
"'0'-' 'j .)1 ':~(}lJn'\
";')1';"" ".'I~r"'q"" " ,':'rtj,,,
j.'15J1r1'
'4"1'.'
',.()rn'Y1i~',W""f';
file://C:\AgenduTest\Exp0l1\93- Novem ber%2027 ,%202007\09 ,%120BOARD%200P%20C.. 1 ] /20/2007
filsoo_s
Page 1 of2
.'1qenda Item No 9E
r-Tovernber 27. 2'007
Page 3 of 8
From:
GreenwoodThomas
Thursday, November 15, 2007 2: 30 PM
filson_s
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Request of BCC to Accept Resignation and Appointment of Code Enforcement Officer to Immokalee EZDA
and CRA Advisory Board
Attachments: Gary Dantinie APPLICATION FORM.docCRAdoc
Dear Ms. Filson:
Please find c!ire_ctlytJ;>JQW an email from Code Enforcement officer Carol Sykora indicating that she is being transferred from
Immokalee.
"It is with deep regret and very much sadness in my heart that I have to tell you my department is taking me out of Immokalee. I
have been told that Gary Dantini witl replace me as a member of the CRA, I am not sure if I will be able to attend the next meeting,
I woutd like to say goodbye to everyone. Immokalee is my heart, I love it here, but unfortunately I do not have a choice. I will
never forget the two years I have been here and wish you well on your endeavors."
Carol Sykora
Collier County Code Enforcement
Field Supervisor
FACE I, II, III CERTIFIED
239-530-6866
Carol!>) 'horarilC ollie rgol', lIet
Please find authorization c!irectly below from Michelle Arnold, Code Enforcement Director authorizing the appointment from of
Code Enforcement Officer Gary Dantini to replace Ms. Sykora on the EZDNCRA Advisory Board as provided by
Ordinance. Please advise if other informanon is needed.
Tom,
As requested, this email is being sent to you to confirm that the Code Enforcement Department would like to replace Carol Sykora
with Gary Dantini as staff representative on the Immokalee CRA Board.
Thank you for your assistance With this process.
Michelle Edwards Arnold
Code Enforcement Director
Please find 1!!!<lc.h;>.c! an application submitted by Gary Dantini to serve on the EZDA and CRA Advisory Boards.
Thanks,
Tom
Thomas Greenwood. AICP
Principal Planner
Collier County Planning Department
11/15/2007
tI
Board of County Commissioners
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, FL 34112
(239) 77 4-8097
Fax: (239) 774-3602
Agenda Item No. 9E
November 27, 2007
P e 4 of 8
Application for Advisory Committees/Boards
Name: GARY DANTINI
Home Phone: 239-348-0732
Home Address: 4285 12TH ST NE
Zip Code:_34120
Fax No._239-304-3912_ Bnsiness Phone: 239-252..()867 e-mail address: GaryDantini@colliergov.net
Place of Employment: _COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT
Board or Committee Applied for: _ CRA
Category (if applicable):
l:xample: Commission District. lkveloper, environmebtalist, lay person, etc.
How long have you lived in Collier Couuty: Years_10 Months _6__
Are you a registered voter in Collier County: Yes_X No
Do you currently hold public office? Yes No_X
If so, what is that office?
Have you ever been convicted of any offense against the Law?
If yes, explain:
Yes
No X
--
Do you now serve., or bave you ever served, on a Collier County board or committee? Yes _X_ No
If yes, please list the committeeslboards: _eRA
Please list your community activities (civic clubs, neighborhood associations, etc. and positions held: _
_GOLDEN GATE AREA CIVIC ASSOC. MEMBER
Education:_HIGH SCHOOL_ FLORIDA ASSOCIATION CODE ENFORCEMENT CERTIFIED
Experience: _30 + YEARS SUPERVISION I MANAGEMENT EXPERIENCE
PleMt! aJtach ~ tu/ditiolUll iIIformofiqn ymtfM pertine1lL TIds .p/ictltion slwulll beforwtU'ded to Silt! FilstHl, ExLcIttit1e MantIgU to
The Board of County Commissioners, 3301 East Tamiami Tf'fIiI. Naples, FL 34112 If you wkh, please/ax your IIppUcation to
(239)774-3602 or e-moiJ to ,H;cfi/wma,'co!lil'rfi!(JI'./li':" Th41tk you/or volunteering to serve the citium ofCoUier County.
AgencJa item No. 9E
hlovember 27. 2007
Page 5 of 8
(
Immokalee Enterprise Zone Development Agency
Name Work Phone Appt'd Exp, Date Term
Home Phone DateRe-appt 2ntlExpDate 2nd Term
Mr. Fred N. Thomas, Jr. 657-8181 04/04/95 04/04/96 I Year
1205 Orchid Avenue 657-5447 04/26/05 04/04/09 4 Years
Immokalee, FL 34142
E-Mail: futjr@aol.com
District: 5
Category: Resident in Zone
Mr. Richard Beers 229-9970 09/21/04 04/04/07 3 Years
507 N. 1 8th Street 657 -4524 04/J 0/07 04/04/11 4 Years
Jmmokalee, FL 34142
E-Mail: rkheers2u@aol.com
District: 5
Categw)': Resident of Zone
Mr. Ira.T. MaIamut 658-3560 03/23/99 04/04/03 4 Years
11990 Wedge Drive 04/1 0/07 04/04/11 4 Years
Ft. Myers, FL 33913
E-Mail:
District: 0
Category: Non-profit Organization
Mr. Richard Rice 657-3237 07/25/06 04/04/07 9 Mos.
1167 Serenita Way 657-6626 04/10/07 04/04/11 4 Years
ImmokaIee, FL 34142
E-Mail: icoc@earthlink.nt
District: 0
Category: Chamber of Commerce
Mr. Bernardo Barnhart 657-3171 04/26/05
913 LaureI Street 657-5328
Immokalee, FL 34142
E-Mail: Bbarnhart@...FloridaCornrnunityBank.net
District:
Category: Finanical Entity
04/04/09
4 Years
(
'.;.~,ii.>iAM.?:~.:-""." ,~=~,,",c.,..:::~~;.....,"':;'~:',-. ,<li'''-'-_,n)\~'':'' ,- ,.."""..,.,-;.:" ""'.c' .'':!';:'-.'''.':: ',"'.\::::~..' ..:';;'.:.:; ;,,~.: ,""h"~\,,-,,!,<',.:- ':'-nt'!;' ._",;" '-'''''';i','''''
Wednesday, April 11, 2007 Page 1 of 4
Agenda Item ~jo. 9E
November 27.2007
Page 6 of S
Immokalee Enterprise Zone Development Agency
Name Work Phone Appt'd Exp. Date Term
Home Phone DateRe-appt 2ndExpDate 2nd Term
Ms. Denise Lujan Blanton 07/25/06 04/09/09 3 Years
1206 CamelIiaAvenue 657-4724
lmmokalee, FL 34142
E-Mail: denisebIanton@earthlink.net
District: 5
Category: Loeal Business in the Zone/Resident
Mr. Floyd Crews 657-2429 11/24/98 04/04/99 4 Months
P.O. Box 5157 657-2370 04/1 0/07 04/04/11 4 Years
lmmokalee, FL 34143
E-Mail:
Distl'ict: 5
Category: Residentlbusiness
Mr. Robert W. Soter 225-2500 09/21/04 04/04/07 3 Years
6209 Emerald Pines 561-0154 04/1 0/07 04/04/11 4 Years
Ft. Myers, FL 33966
E-Mail: rsoter@sfwd.org
District: 0
Category: Private Industry Council
Ms. Eva J. Deyo 668-3630 04/26/05 04/04/06 1 Year
642 Clifton Street 657-6894 OS/23/06 04/04/10 4 Years
Irnmokalee, FL 34142
E-Mail: evadeyo@earthlink.net
District: 5
Category: Resident
Ms. Ana Salazar
109 Georgia Road
Ft. Myers, FL 33966
E-Mail: ana_salazar@earthlink.net
District: 0
Category: Non-Profit Community-Based Organization
658-3318
303-0737
02/08/05
04/10/07
04/04/07
04/04/11
2 Years
4 Years
....J
~Wed;:~;d~, A;ritl r"2orr7 ;'.~t_'-'"W,._,t;'~~;
'f.~,~.."i',,".,,,;<;:,';_~;'.' ";,".:~~",;~_ ,;.",=:",-: ',?"', j";; 'i':.:-_" .."":l:li"':\f', i!''iV''1-'"''':-''' .. -,y",~~-,,~,to/.-;"
Page2of4
i~.qenda Item No. 9E
i~~ovember 27, 2007
Page 7 of S
Immokalee Enterprise Zone Development Agency
Name
Work Phone Appt'd Exp. Date Term
Home Phone DateRe-appt 2ndExpDate 2nd Term
Captain Tom Davis
330] E. Tamiarni Trail
Naples, FL 34112
E-Mail:
District:
Category: Local Law Enforcement
774-4434 06/1 4/05
OS/23/06
I Year
4 Years
Mr. .r ulio Estremera 658-3327 10/1 1/05
] 0220 Boca Circle 594-8073 04/1 0107
Naples, FL 34109
E-Mail: jestreme@fgcu.edu
f)i~trjct: 2
CategOlJ': Nonprofit Community Rased Organization
;\C:')heJ
Ms. Carol Sykora \.e '1 530-6866 04/10/07
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive tl,l% 877-8116
Naples, FL 34104
E-Mail: carolsykora@colliergov.net
District:
Category: Loeal Code Enforcement
Mr. Robert Halman 353-4244 12/09/97
14700 Immokalee Road
ImmokaJee, FL 34120
E-Mail:
District: 5
Category: non-voting ex-officio member
(
~WednestlaY, April;I:~20(j7 C'r;''''><''~'>~",:",.,
,CO',';-,
'.,.~;,'-,O~'
Page 3 of4
04/04/06
04/04/10
04/04/07
04/04/11
2 Years
4 Years
04/04111
4 Years
00/00/00
unlimited
"",'~, ..,--." ')~~",'~I"', ".',:>1::'""<." ','~""
Aqenda Item No. 9E
N'ovember 27,2007
Page 8 of 8
Immokalee Enterprise Zone Development Agency
Name
Work Phone
Home Phone
Appt'd
DateRe-appt
Exp. Date
2ndExpDate
Term
2nd Term
This 13 member committee was created on April 4, 1995, by Ord. No. 95-22 to induce private
investment into distressed areas to create economic opportunities and sustainable economic
development for designated areas. Initial members were appointed by Resolution No. 95-249.
To permit Collier County to participate in this program, the Board of County Commissioners
nominated the Immokalee Community to be considered by the FL Depl of Commerce for
Enterprise Zone designation in Reso. No. 95-248, approved March 28, 1995. As part of the
formal app for an EZ, the State required that a committee consisting of a broad base of citizens
be established. The committee has representation from the Chamber of Commerce, financial or
insurance entities, businesses operating within the nominated area, residents, nonprofit
community-based organizations, local workforce development board, local code enforcement
agency, and loeallaw enforcement agency. Amended by Ord. No. 97-81 Terms are 4 years.
This committee also serves as the Immokalee Redevelopment Board.
FL STAT: 290.001 - 290.0t6
Staff: Thomas Greenwood, Principal Planner: 493-2323
~'~'" .\'.l"tN-.: -.8.'. ~,. ';,~,"l."_...",'- ',,^,,: ".i:-'Y'~"'"
Wednesday, April 11, 2007
'.'."~;'
Page
','~";'';','3,',!'~'' {~,:,~:l;\'t'_~'"
~
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Agenda Item 1'40. 10.4
November 27, 2007
Page 1 of 5
Obtain direction from the Board of County Commissioners on accepting after-the-fact
developer applications for deferral of 100% of Collier County impact fees for owner-
occupied affordable housing units and provide direction to staff to amend the
Consolidated Impact Fee Ordinance. Board direction on this item will directly impact the
following items on today's agenda: lOB, lOC, 10D, IOE, 10F, lOG, 10H, 101, 1 OJ, 10K, tOL,
10M and lON.
OBJECTIVE: That the Board of County Commissioners (Board) provide direction on
accepting aner-the-fact developer applications f(jr deferral of 100% of Collier County impact
fees for owner-occupied aff(mjable housing units.
CONSIDERATIONS: l\liicle IV of Chapter 74 of the Code of Laws and Ordinances
cstahlished a program to defer impact fees fix qualilied aflimlable housing. Pursuant to Section
74-401(a)(2), an application f(n dekrral must be submitted prior to receiving a building permit:
Any person seeking an (dfordoble housing d(f>rro!.(or proposed dely'lopmcnt shallfile with the
county manager an application p". dcft'lnJ/. prior to receiving {/ huilding permit fJr Ihe
propo.\'ed development
Additionally, tbe application submitted prior to rcceiving a building pennit must contain the
following information:
a. The name and address ,,(the applicant;
b. An up to date, complete legal description o( the site upon ,,,hieh the development is
proposed to he located;
c. The maximum income level o{the owner, or i{the owner is a developer or builder, the
income level of the household to which the dwelling unit is to be sold or provided of
occupancy;
d. The square footage and number o{hedrool11s in each dwelling unit of the development
During staffs review of the attached files to process tbe deferral for approval it was determined
that Habitat for Humanity of Collier County, Inc. did not comply with the Ordinance. The
following building pern1its were issued and impact fees paid prior to submission of an
application for deferral:
Pern1it
Number
2007041982
2007020738
2006064370
2007012026
2007020743
2007020740
2006064365
2007020728
2006064384
Payment Posted
6/5/2007
3/27/2007
8/15/2006
2/112007
3/27/2007
3/27/2007
8/15/2006
3/27/2007
8/15/2006
Application Date
81712007
8/23/2007
9/18/2007
9/12/2007
9/5/2007
8/17/2007
9/14/2007
9/28/2007
91712007
Deferral Requested
$26,204.83
S 12,442.52
S 13,6 I 6.20
$19,372.52
$12,442.52
$12,442.52
$13,616.20
S I 2,442.52
$13,616.20
;-\g8ilca Itsrn r\JO. lOA
!\Jovember 27, 2007
2 o~- 5
2007020732
2007052698
2006064377
2007041987
3/27/2007
6/5/2007
8/15/2006
6/512007
9/26/2007
9/7/2007
8/22/2007
8/7/2007
TOTAL
$12,442.52
$26,240.68
$13,616.20
$26204.83
$214,700.26
Staff has discussed this oversight and has determined that an application from the developer
after-the-faet would be required to approve the purchaser's defel1'al rcquest, complete necessary
papef\\ork and maintain consistency with the Ordinance for these files and defelTal agreements.
Stalf is aware of 48 additional deferral agreements processed, approved and lien agreement
recorded with purchasers in which Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc did not comply
with the Ordinance and paid tbe associated impact fees prior to submission of an application Jar
dcferral. Habitat for Humanity of CoJlier County Inc is seeking reimbursement for those fees
paid.
There are an unknown number of other pennits in which this developer has received a building
permit and paid the impact fces prior to sllbmissiol1 of' a quaIilled owner application ti)r deferral.
If the devclopcr \\cre at some point in the lilturc to submit an eligible application and
reimbursemcnt request, tbosc applications would also require acceptance of an afler-tbe-Llct
developer application in order to process the request and maintain consistency \V1tl1 the
Ordinance.
In order to be in full compliance witb Section 74-40] of tbe Code of Laws and Ordinances of
Collier County, stalI seeks Board direction on proceeding with one of the following two
options:
Option One
If the Board directs staff to accept aner-the-fact developer applications for impact fee deferral
we will be in full compliance with Section 74-401 of the Code of Laws and Ordinances of
Collier County. Additionally, acceptance of after-the-fact developer applications will result in
the reimbursement of impact fees paid the developer. All reimbursements are subject to the
availability of program funds and can not be guaranteed. Staff will never exceed the mmual
limit for defelTals 01'3% of the prior fiscal year's collected impact fees.
Option Two
If the Board directs staff to rejecl afler-the-fact developer applications for impact fee deferral,
Sec. 74-401(2)(a) would prohibit Collier County from offering impact fee defelTa]s to the
purchaser of the unit. The thirteen attached applications would be denied based on non-
compliance with the Ordinance.
To avoid future non-compliance and allow tighter control of the limited funds available for
affordable housing impact fee defelTals, staff requests Board direction on amending the current
Consolidated Impact Fee Ordinance. The proposed ehanges are as follows:
· Maintain the CU1Tent limit of 50 deferral agreements open at any single time far an
individual developer, or for any developments that are under common ownership
(Section 74-40 I (7))
Agenda hern No.1 Of\
November 27. 2007
,Cage 3 of 5
. All other agreements require a qualified owner and recorded lien agreement prior to
issuance of a building pern1it
. In the event the qualified owner fails to purchase the propeliy (i.e. has not completed
work hours, change in purchaser's intent, change in purchaser's financial situation), staff
will amend the recorded agreement and assign it to the new qualified purchaser
With Board direction, staff will work wilh tbe County Attorney's office to draft new language
that will incorporate any directed changes to the Ordinance. All changes will be brought to the
Board at a future meeting as an advertised public hearing.
FISCAL IMPACT: If the Board directs staff to aecept these thirteen after-thc- fact developer
applications from Habitat f(Jr Humanity of Collier County lnc and issue the associated
reimbursemcnts, the fClllowing fiscal impact would apply:
Roads
Library
C(JlTcctional Facilities
C;ovcrnmcnt Buildings
Community Parks
Rcgional Parks
Education Facilities
Emergcncy Medical Services
Law Enf(Jrccmcnt
Sewer
Water
TOTAL
$70.3:;5.00
$5,06249
S997.S4
S5,235.96
$10.30:;.00
$22.794.00
$45,164.00
$1.307.67
$2.21 S.30
$26,560.00
$24,700.00
$214,700.26
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: If the Board authorizes the remittance of the
requested impact fee reimbursemcnts it may adversely affect capital project funding. However,
the specified deferrals do not exceed the annual program cap of 3%.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: Dependant on Board direction.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Obtain direction from the Board of County Commissioners
on accepting after-the- fact developer applications for deferral of 100% of Col1ier County impact
fees for owner-occupied affordahle housing units and provide direction to staff to amend the
Consolidated Impact Fee Ordinance. Board direction on this item will directly impact the
following items on today's agenda: lOB, 10C, 10D, 10E, 10F, lOG, 10H, 1OI, 1OJ, 10K, 10L,
10M and JON.
PREPARED BY: Frank Ramsey, SHIP Program Coordinator, Housing and Human Services
ARTICLE IV. AFFORDABLE HOUSING IMPACT FEE DEFERR"'-L'
p,genda Item NO.1 CJA
Noveml:li;< nf2fl07
. -'Page 4 of 5
ARTICLE IV. AFFORDABLE HOUSING IMPACT FEE DEFERRAL'
'Editor's note: Section 4 of Ord. No. 2005-40 retitled art. IV to read as herem set out. Formerly, said
article was entitled affordable housing impact fee waiver or deferral.
Sec. 74401. Impact fee deferral.
(a) Applicability
(1) Pursuant to the requirements established in this section and article IV. the county
shall defer the payment of the impact fee tor any new owner-occupied or rental
development which auaHfies as affordable 00iJSrng under this article.
(2) Any person seeking an affordable housing deferral for proposed development shall
file with the county manager an application for deferral, prior to receiving a building
permi1 for the oroposed deveiopment The apprication for deferral shall contain the
following'
a. The Ilame and address of the applicant:
b. An up to date, complete legal description of the site upon which tne
development is proposed to be located:
c. The maximum income level of the owner, or if the owner IS a developer or
builder, the income level of the household to which the dweliing unit it to be sold
or provided for occupancy;
d. The square footage and number of bedrooms in each dwelling unit of the
development.
(3) If the proposed development meets the raquirements for an affordable housing
deferral as set forth in this article, the county manager may, but is not required to, enter
into an impact fee deferral agreement and is authorized to execute such deferral
agreements along with any corresponding tri-party agreement intended to further define
re-payment obligations, as may be applicable, with the owner or applicant. The impact
fee deferral agreement shall be accepted by the county in lieu of prompt payment of
theimpact fee that would otherwise then be due and payable but for the agreement.
(b) Qualifying owner-occupied dwelling. To qualify for an affordable housing impact fee
deferral, an owner-occupied dwelling unit must meet all of the following criteria:
(1) The owner(s) or anticipated owner(s) of dwelling unit must have a very low, or
moderate income level, at the time of final execution by the county of a deferral
agreement as those IIlcome level terms are defined in section 74-402.
(2) The monthly mortgage payment, including taxes and insurance, must not exceed 3D
percent of that amount which represents the percentage of the median annual gross
income for the applicable household category as indicated in section 74-702. However, it
is not the intent to limit an individual household's ability to devote more than 3D percent
of its income for housing, and housing for which a household devotes more than 30
percent of its income shall be deemed affordable if the first institutional mortgage lender
is satisfied that the household can afford mortgage payments in excess of the 30 percent
hltp:/!library l.municode.com/newords/DocView/1 0578/1 f] 93/197
] 0/26i2007
COLLIER COUNTY
BCJARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIQNERS
Item Number:
,!Ji
Item Summary:
,'l.'iW' C:.'('
'U)n' 'he "',ar:1 (',;",[1: r r:T1-.rol%l, ". "11 .'cc',':fYing G~r,~r .rne :~'ct
Jp: 'C91.0".<, '0'
'a'
:":1'. C,)lil!)' JL;nL' "::'a~.' I,,'Y. T'T O'i!I',e r,_ "f/f:d
:;w"c "L,re;~" IcWll ~ 'Ill". ;1",(.' ~', "C'I'~'" e:wy' oL:':' ,Hl".'I'l1 im, CO~S(;i -1,,1('" ""lICX' ;:::'-'e
"',j, I,'inCf '_"CC1r'~ G;r' - nr G' "," ''''11 ,,}I i':'ec~k ,'-' '-.J~: :'". fur cl'.',"i:l(' It" \,$ 'J:ll,-'~"\'~
':~ [., . [I1~
Meeting Date:
'I',',
Preflllrl'd B~'
>U.i"''''I1';''
SH!> -"'(l'~;:HT ',.,,,,!;,-,, N
I:wtf,
. ':!:ll",. ~ ,,-.,', __
f-V'oJ'.j""'l'1(iHu""'r C,', ',)Ie?'
1::'~;2W'-
. ~:i "',M
\flprnved By
I'i'"",,"'"
H,'
; ,. ':'li ~.: f: " , ,'. ~.;
Approved Il~
1:,"'77""'"
PI."" '-')'n"
.,..;
~,
>\pprn"ed B)
\[Ipr(tn'dlh
'\pl'r<,,~d Ih
~ "i<,
"'111',"
,CO"h'
Apllrl>ved By
"'i;n".,.'.",m"<<",,."';
:....;3n""~I~'."": J; ",,,c"e'. ')"".,,,~,
,J.._
C.C'ur.'.y i'"1ar',,,g',"-"[.Jf'f,,,,
:::'~k;" ,,' r/,;''''l.'1L('''-''''': t H,.;(1(Wl
1:115:m;l7 ~.2',.,M
Allproved By'
j,,,,.,,,,.\ 1,.',ClOd
':,"ur':c'fiJrli''lH
i;;l!O
bO<lrd of ,;,,"'1\,'
(.o"'mISStOr",.r~
cO',"'!\' r,I.),I<l~I~r'", ']f(,ce
:1,':S,'?,\i[l;;:,5'P,,"
file:! /C:\AgendaT cst\Export\93- Novemher%202 7 ,%202007\ I 0.%20COCNTY%20MAN A... ] 1/20/2007
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
.i\genda Item No.1 OB
November 27. 2007
Page 1 of 10
Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioncrs approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a licn agreement with Ga'TY Jean Baptiste and Syndy Jean Baptiste
(Owners) for deferral of 100% of Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied
affordable housing unit located at Lot 26, Block 11, Naples Manor Lakes and authol"izes a
reimbursement of the fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc on Building
Permit 2007041982 in the amount of $26,204.83.
OBJECTIVE: That the Board of County Commissioners (Board) approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, the attached lien agreement with Garry Jean Baptiste and Syndy Jean Baptiste
for deferral of JOO% of Collier County impact fees f()r an owner-occupied affordable housing
unit and authorize a reimburscmcnt of the impact fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier
County Inc. in the amowlt of S26,204.83.
CONSIDERATIONS: Article IV of Chapter 74 of tile Code of Laws and Ordinances
established a program to defer impact fees Ii)!' qualified affordablc housing. Pursuant to this
program. an application I()r deferment was submitted by Garry .lean Baptiste and Syndy .lean
Baptiste, which application, aileI' staff review, was determined to qualify I()J' the program. Legal
status has been veIified and documents are on iile at the omce of Housing and HLlman Services.
The property is loeated in the Naples Manor Lakes subdivision in Naples.
._-,
During staff's review of the tile to process this deferral lor approval it was detennined that
Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc. did not provide an application far the defclTaI
program as a qualified developcr prior to issuancc of thc building pcrnlit 311d paymcnt of
associated impact fees as required. Staff has discussed this oversight with tlie County Attorney's
Office and recommends that the Board acccpt the application Ictter from the developer after-the-
faet in order to complcte tlie rcquired paperwork and maintain consistcncy with the Ordinance
for this file and deferral agreement. Upon approval and execution of this deferral agreement and
lien, impact fecs paid hy Habitat for Humanity of Collicr County Inc. in the amount of
$26,204.83 will be reimbursed.
Section 74-202 of Article II, Chapter 74 of the Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances, the
Collier County Consolidated Impact Fee Ordinance, 2001-13, as 31nended, provides for specific
criteria and procedures for processing routine and non-routine requests for impact fee
reimbursements. Spccifically, as set forth hy Section 74-202 (h) (5):
"All reimbursement requests totaling twenty-jive thousand dollars ($25,000) or more,
cannot be approved administrative(v and must he submitted to the Board of County
Commissioners. "
The ordinance requires that a lien agreement be entered into with the applicant as a condition of
deferral of the impact fees. Section 74-401(3) of the Code authodzes the County Manager to
sign deferral agreements with applicants qualifying for impact fee deferrals for affordable
housing, which has long been the practice. The ordinance, however, gives the County Manager
discretion in whether to enter into the Agreement. Accordingly, in keeping with recent
discussion and direction by the Board, the County Attorney's Office has deternlined that until
directed otherwise by thc Board, these agreements be placed on the Consent Agenda for the
Board's review, approval and Chail111311'S signature.
Agenda Item ['-lo. '10B
r\Jovember 27. 2007
C h. d f' $'6 '04 83" ,. Al hi" Paqe 2 of 10
FISCAL IMP A T: T IS agreement e ers L ,L . l11 Impact lees, t oug 1 It IS expected
that the County will ultimately collect these deferred fees (generally upon the sale of the
residence), there is no guarantee as to if, or when, this would occur.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: The proposed Agreel11ent is fully consistent with the intent and
purpose of Section 74-401 of the Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collier County.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: That the Board approves and authorizes the Chairnlan to sign
the attached Lien Agreement for Deferral of JOO% of Collier County Impact Fees for Owner
Occupied Af1()rdable Housing Dwelling Units tar GaITY kan Baptiste and Syndy Jean Baptiste
located at Lot 26, Block I J, Naples Manor Lakes and anthorizes a reimburscment of the impact
fees paid by Hahitat for Humanity of Collier County lnc on Building Permit 200704 I 982 in the
amount of $26,204.83, and any budget amendments thaI may be required associated to the
reimhursement.
PREPARED BY: Frank Ramsey, SHIP Program Coordinator, Housing andlluman Services
Return!1l
Aaenda Item No.1 08
November 27,2007
Pag6: 3 of 10
FnmL.RllmllCY
COm~'1" nlllllt~' llllS
3301t:.Tllmillmi.111l1l
"illpl(", Jiluridll341 12
Filc# 08-024-1F
ThiSSflHrt forrCfordina
LIEN AGREEMENT FOR llEFERRAL OF 100% OF COLLIER COUNTY IMPACT
FEES FOR OWNER OCCUPIED AFFORDABLE HOI:SING nWELLlNG UNITS
This Agreement is entered into this __L__ day of ()ctobcr. ~007, between Collier County, a
political suhdivision of the State of Florida (COUNTY) and "Garry .Teall Baptiste and Syndy Jean
Baptiste" (OWNER). collectively stated as the "Parties."
NO\\!', THEREFORE, f(lr good and valuable consideration, the rel~cipt ilnd sufficiency uf
.which is rnuluaJJy acknowledged, the Partic~; agree as follows:
This Lien Agreement is made pursuant to Chapter 74 of the Lode of Law~ and OrdinaDl~cs of
Collier Cnunty. Florida. knov,m as ''The Collier County Consolidated ]mpacL Fcc (Jrdinancc"
(Ordimmcl'i. In tk' e\'ent of am I;'Dl1llict with thi~ Agrc~menL the t";~flns pI' the Onlinance
'J,311 ;ti~ply
The lega) desvripuon of the dwelling uml is attached ,.(C, L:;hihit .- A,"
f'hc Knr: nfthi,; A,grcenwtH l~ from rhe: dale set Jonh ~lhO\'l' un;;; itl" imrKlc:t rl:~' i;: repaid.
.. Till' :JJ1Iounl 1..1" th(' impact lL:c~'; dcj:-:lTe.d ;;ha11 he paid h: :he COt ~<T\' ill full upon: aj lhl'
sale oithe dwelling unit: hi the rcilnancing oi'the d\velling unit: c) u los~, "fthe homestead
exemption: or J) the first occurrence <d' any sale or transfer of any part of tIll: affected rea]
property, and in any such event the deferred impact fees shall be paid in full to the COUNTY
not later then the closing of the sale, or not later then the ctlcctivc date of the transfer. As set
forth in Exhibit "8," the amount of the deferred impact fees is Twentv Six Thousand Two
Hundred Four and 83/1 on Dollars ($26.204.1-:3'1. Rcpayment shall include any accrued
interest. Interest shall be computed at thr;: rate of five percent (5%) p~r annum. but. in no
event shall it exceed twenty-fivc percent (2SfVo) of the total fee amount.
5. The deferred impact fees shall be a Hen on the property described in Exhibit "A," which lien
may be foreclosed upon in the event of non-compliance v.,ith the Ordinance or with this
Agreement. This Agreement shall opcratt' as a lien against the dwelling unit. The Lien shall
t\.:~rmjnatc upon the recording of a release or satisfaction of lien in the public records of the
COWlty, The deferrals of impact fees and this Agreement shall run with the land, and neither
the deferred impact fees nor this Agreement shall be transferred, assigned. or otherwise
conveyed. Except as provided by law. regardless of any foreclosure on the first mongage or
other security interest, this lien shall otherwise he superior and paranlount to the interest in
the dwelling unit of any owner, ]CSSl"C, tenant mortgagee, or other person, except that this
lien shall be 011 parity with any lien for County taxes.
6. Upon the satisfactory completion or this Agreement's requirements, COUNTY shall record
any necessary documentation evidencing same.
7. In the event the OVINER is in default under the Ordinance or this Agreement, and the default
is not cured within 30 days after "'Titten notice is provided to the OWNER, the COUNTY
Agenda Item No. 108
November 27, 2007
Page 4 of 10
may, at its sole option. collect the impact fee amount in default as set forth in the Ordinance,
or bring a civil action to enforce this AgreemenL or declare thut the deferred impact fees arc
then in default and immediately due and payable. The COUNTY shall be entitled to recover
all fees and costs, including attorney's fee and costs. incurred by the COUNTY in enforcing
this A&,rreemem, plus interest at the then maximum statutory rate for judgments calculated on
a calendar year basis unlil paid.
8. This Agreement is the sole agreement between the parties with respect to the subject matter
herein, and shall be binding upon the O\VNER'S successors and assigns in interest.
9. This Agreement shall he recorded in the official records of the County at no cost to the
COUNTY.
IN 'WITNESS WHEREOF. the Parties havc executed this Agreement 011 the date and year first
ahove \\Tittcn.
Attest:
DWIGHT E. BROCK. Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY. FLORIDA.
By
By
. Deputy Cler}.;
JAMES COJ ,felTA. CHAIRMAN
OWNER:
Witnesses: ~,~' ..J.
. _n<""'ht.i(~,~-<_ ~. .....,p:>:"..1-t..J:JCf.:,
P. N ,,(,-:- ',. I I
, nnt amc/_ ;f1j,~i)c.L.-1:~'_Ll{:1r--:;)._t./L
_I~_n' 1--.','/)./:'/ . i ?I,'"
Garry Jean Baptiste
Ci.;1~^ /1"
OWNER:
va.mCS51Cs:
/7'f;7 f.
Pnrtt N~me
;-~~/;;'"
f ea
/
STATE OF FLORIDA)
COUNTY OF COLLIER)
"1_ / -D- .' 7')/
.>:..~ rl'LV'Y 6.......'v"M.,/..--,~
Syndy Jean Baptiste
././C.~,
1//1), I I./,V5c/
2007.
Th~ foregoin.g <t...gre.cmcnt'.IVas ,::icknow19dged before me this ~ day of ()( i? ij]/r-
byt.4'cdl' ,f :,'>-,'':-kl. ,Ij 11..,'1 ~:;l.'{'J)Nhe is personally knov-m to me or hao:; produced
'j
.______--=asprON <lfldefilily.
,
~\ :" ;y. .{rf
Signature of PersonfTaKing Acknowledgment
I ,-$'-':"';'" Usa B. Lefkow
:.-?y P-: '\:'~ Commission # D0293446
i ~;~;;:~~~.: Expires March -4. 2008
f "',if',,",;"W"<'f<lJ,,,,,F',,,,,,,,,_,,,, !!fI(;,',"l;,m',
Appr vcd s to form
and I al ienc ..
Recommend Appn?val:
!
j
r
'-"'~'- ~,-~
,/ Marcy Krumbine,MPA
Director
Collier County Housing and Human Services
Jeffrey -
Managl
EXHIBIT "A"
Agenda Item r,o. lOB
November 27. 2007
Page 5 of 10
LEGAL IlESCRII'T10N
Lot 26, Block J 1, Naples Mllnor L~kcs, ~ccordin~ to the Plat tlwreof as n~cordcd in 1)la1 Book
3, pa~c S6 and 87. Puhlic Records of Collier Count~., Florida.
EXHIIlIT "H"
tMI'ACT FEE IlREAKI)OWN
Type of Impact fee
Amount Owed
i\. f;:MS Impact Fce
$100.59
B. Correclional FaciJitie:,; impac! Fce
tlI3.5:;
C. Lihrary lmpacl Fc:c
$460.2]
D. Community Parks impact Fee
$YJ5.1I11
l\cgiOi1~ll !larks Irnp;l(;t Fc-c
$2.:'168.('\\.1
[:",
('dtJcaliorw! r:ll"ili:i,'.!: ~y';lcm Imf1:1cl rL'('
$g.::n.oo
ROl1d Implll:t Fe,;
';;6.:;59,0'")
Ci\lVcrnmt:ni Hu:jdin~~' 11llPllC' h',.
:i:7:2:-,i\I;
u<.: \\ t~njtlr('(,~lllCrll i n Il);L::~ Fe:c
:i;2~:::,.;1i'
Sewer System Fce
S3.5l:i.llC1
k. WateT S:'str.:rn h..'c
S3.4] 5.110
TOTAL IMI'ACT FEES
$2(),204.83
IAI( Approv~d _ I _
q."
:-,C':-!
:>,;"
:-iJ
n: ;-):.,~'_ ,--'
\.11\ ,ie', _, ,~;1
... 1 j,;, J~
('." -:-; ,,~'
I';'""
h':2f "';,,:::,
~}t'jt::l ::-:.r Ll;~:'
::'\,
'he
.
.
Agenda item t\io. '1 DB
November 27. 2007
Page 6 of i 0
K
~,:.
'ii,
.,,'"
~
;:c
"
i
August 7. 20117
.'\!tn: Frank Ramsey
SHIP Program Coordinator
Collier Count\'
3301 E. Tall1iami Trail
Healtb & C()mrnunit) Scn-i~T~ Budding
.\3pIeS. FL ! i 2
Fe:
Impa{'t Fe{> Rcimhursemcm
Dear . ~-;Jnk.
Hahiw: l()r l-lun~(lnlI" .:)!. C (lliicr (',:\ulJr~- ;uc,. i':' :'l_'qucSllI1t; n.'irnNliSenKrlt
fl_H'imp'-Kl paId lhn)~I~n ~ht. impact F'e.: l),::i"erT(t! Plograrn. lee::;
\vert' p~H~i L:r; ('1'C\111 hy ilahiLl1. for HlIm~li1Jty \_-ollier Counl~;. lnc.. In
llrdcr tu cxp,,::,'dite the h'Jijding pr(lcc~;s. IJo\\'eycr the future (H":ners frrr the
properly qualif\ for an impact fee deferral. DescribeJ as follows:
;1;',
Gar,:' & Syndy Jcan Baptistc
534J.Jcnnings St Naples FL 34113
Permit # 2007041982
"
'.'"
f ~ 11-.
Please feel free to contact NOlma Lora (775-0036) if you have any
questions or concerns.
Sincer.e.J'-g;;~;.'At ~./
/^.,-:::' ~/ ///)
/' /.. ,/..<;7/ /
/~~ /Z>/
. r Samuel D~> M. D.
President
", "
;\,
". (I,
-<l'"
Agenda Item NO.1 08
November 27, 2007
Page 7 of 10
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR1103 - Official Receipt
mans Number
L767233
! Date .. _____
i 6/5/20()7 1040:~7 AM
: ~/~~1~;;e =tW-;=i~~r---=::=J
._~-------~~._--- ._-,----_.__._,_._,-,..._---~
Address: 5341 JENNINGS ST
Owner: CAGE, ALlSHA COA #: 07-0272
Permit Type: BR2 Job Desc: FRAMED S/F DET 1 STY-IMMOKALEE "A" 3/1
Applicant HABITAT FOR HUMANITY.SAM
DBA HABITAT FOR HUMANITY OF COLLIER COUNTY, INC.
Swr Meter: SC Wtr Meter: CC
Payor: HABIT AT
Fee Information
i Fee-Code 'Description GL Account - -----p,molil'1iTWaiv8d-.
! 08BCAI' BLDG.CODE CERT SURCHARGE-1113000oooio882000-oo6 $564:---n~
!OBBP.NP._L BLDG F'.E_~_~'lJTS - NAPLE~--____"':"'11~tl8,9Q032211 000Jl,Q()__~=---$5320(j"" -----
'08CPSF . COMM PK IMPACT FEE S/F 34611636336351031346 __$9.3~:Ool-=--=-
'08'EMSFj EMS IMPACT FEE S/F---~014047036351031356 $100.59 i
, 08ENIM I EAST NAPLES FIRE IMPACT 11300000020982000000 - $249.04 !------:
08GBSF I GOVT-SLDG IMPACT FEE-SIF---- i 390122231363510313go--j~- $725.00 ]-u1
, 08JLS( JAIL IMPACT F
08LBSF __ L1BRAR'l'JMPA
08LWSF LAW ENF IMPA
08MFSG MICROFILM SU
08RDGS BLDG. PERMIT
08RPSF REG PK IMPAC
08S~HI SCHOOL~OAR
08SFR4 DIST 4 ROAD 1M
c-
1'08TROP TRANSPORTAT
12SITE SITE INSPECTI
42MTTP COUNTY METE
: 42SSDC ! SEWER SYSTE
42WSDC ttATER SYSTE
~!)ACR BLDG. P,ERMIT
-- -. , -- - -.-..-...---
EE S/F '38111043036351031381 $113.53 __,
CT FEE S/F 35515619036351 03135~... ~- $460.23
CT FEE S/F 38511043336351031385 $2!l.:,;48
.-----
RCHARGE 11313890034144200000 $3.00
SURCHARGE__.. 11300000020880000000 $5.64
T FEE S/F .- 34611636336351031346 $2068.00
-~'--"-"'--'--' -
o IMPACT FEE 11300000020905000000 i .- $8228.00
PACT..FE.~~SINGLE 33616365336351031336 $635\10_0 1
___'0 - ------;
ION ROW. PERMIT 10116364032920000000 $1.50.00 --3
ON-ENGINEERING 1311l8,32732249000000 $150.00
R TAP CHARGE 408~5321234332000000 $676.00
M CHARG.f::_._ 413263613)~3~QQ31413 -I~-- $3515.00
M CHARGE 41127351134336031411 , $3415.00 ! !
-----..-
APP FEE CREDIT 11313890032251000000 , $-100.00 I ,
-_.'-- ____.n
Total
L~27876151
. Continued -
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT
Printed:10/31/20074:27:21 PM
L\genda Hem No.1 OB
November 27, 2007
Page 8 of 10
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR 1103 - Official Receipt
Date
61512007 10:4037 AM
f ~~y~~~+g~ii9~~r .. '-:===j
.~ Post Date
I 61512007
Trans Number
767233__.
-----~-,. -- ~---_.._------
Payment Code __ 'Account/Check Number
CHECK_.._.__L1420Q______ ____
Memo:
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 951NT
Payments
. .. .. ~-."Amounil
. . ___ $27876.15.J
Total Cash
T o\al Non-Cash
$0.00 I
- '______._______________n_.____j
$2787615 ,
Total Paid
$27876.15
-----------------------
Cashierllocation: MURPHYLlNDA 1
User: POTTER.T
Printed: 1 013112007 4:2721 PM
Agenda Item Ho. 10B
November 27, 2007
Page 9 of 10
',"i):T;:i-
'1,n!\'
T1-bJ'l,
\ ,~' I ;:- '-:Il
c.::'),
Ff",C~ \1
iiii':;
'1'" n 1'.;,:HHJC
'-:'.':\'15 PJ;;;h,
jL:r'L~,:':'J S;;l
P.:te[ SOLin~r
1").;JP<1e:
\\',':.)r:~CG!i
"..like '\",(,,1""
t<.ad ';
~'~:'
Ij,,;:;ii.-
'iswn ;6 a U:Of}t:'j',)!'le:r, ~:;':
:'li'
,,-,:t!irlc. ,:,:{ ,',,~
October 29,2007
Attn: Frank Ramsey
SHIP Program Coordinator
ceO] E. Tan1iami Trail
Naples. Florida c4] 12
RE:
Permit #:
5341 Jennings Street. i<a.plcs, FL ,-:'41 J J
200704](j82
Ucar r ;';;~Ej~_
!-Iabj~al f'or j"lUJllan:t>
C()!;\cr
pc: I_ne C
ImpacL r:::.~e
Deferral PrDgranL IdenJ th::.' ,;;hcrvc as an affordable
housing unit. Please iC1 [his lctl~~r SC1"\'f: a~;:m afh:'r~th:;-fac1 appiication and
identification That an income eligihlc. legal resident of tbe United States ,viII
occupy the propen}' once cOlnplete.
Habitat for Humanity of Collier County, Inc paid the Impact Fees upfront in order
to expedite the huilding process,
Please feel free to contact Norma Lora (775-0036) if you have any questions or
concems.
S. I /'
,. mcere ~.... ...<;_.~....
J' .//
7~// :;,//' ~(.;.' . ~
'.j y~.. /' .r
,/',/<;,.,/'" <- ,/ ~//,",
)~ "L' ' //e/
t." ,J' '-'
,,:,r:.
Samuel Durso, M,D.
President
------.-
". ,'-,r1l1~\r:,H; ralJ
~
,!';
':":::-",:)\;.16. ::3S.,i....~.."CI,;;i u<~:~}
Fl(lu: :n<JhfhcnJ!icT,com
-"',.~'iJl't.itz:'{'(l!he: n",g
Page 1 of
p.,oer,da item rJc
N,'),unbc :'7,
Prq01t'
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
ltemNumber:
~ DB
Item Summary:
1-'C,U)~"'''Hh:ic:: .~ hZl' "'C 8C;Fci of' "c:.,tv ~"nr""C~,,(,'1'!,C, <l~;P"') '('5 ~"j aut:lor;Zi'~', 1'1',
'r8IPT,;]"W
-3 ;,f'" ":rC-(e~'" --,,:t.-,
"'-ir',-"jpT'S'"
~. /,-.(1-, 'c' Cl" ~';ac'l: S i(
'WI'WS
'.1<";(";"'"
r;!,Il" ,.'),I"'\"-,' "11;'; T~+" ()' ("""'18' '";';lJpre: efbl,j',nl"
->lb'
. j c:::"" '. Iii!.' L J" ,.. ,H'.~' ;iUt'l'; ",'7 c"-'
-"';1':1 ":'lC'''' "!'",
1,'d;U!)
,al:::"
'T,:'I
:'I~' ,', cU"ri"'..
- ",,~ 'I - ,;"
Meeting Date:
I'rcparedfly
'-,z",-f':a,,,,,,"y
"fi:~' ~''''':,,'''''' "(,.w,; ,,31('
".'LL'
'''lI::,i'i.'',"'',j''''''_
..,,) """".om!H.
';:,-';"1:~ L,ire'it: Art
<\pl'ru",'d By
~"',: :,' Ilt:'
r.jc",
\pl'l'oved BI'
"I'
j'"
Approwd By
'\I'l'ron'd Ih
Appr"v<;d II,
'\ppruvl'd By
"'<-"'.;~ '; I',' -.",ei
':",,,,t': ri'm~',,=i
:'_Jf'.
:;'O"'<ClJ"':GU"T\
c'r,unt\' ~',Jn"g"", Off
~ tr! S:;;,'J~7 1 ~ 3: ",M
;.omn"~";
file://C :\Agcnda T est\Export\93- Novembcr1'/o202 7.%202007\ I O.o'o20COUNTY%20MANA.. ] 1/20/2007
AGenda Item No.1 OC
November 27.2007
Page 1 of 10
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with Araceli Ramirez (Owner) for deferral of 1000/,. of
Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable housing unit located at Lot
8, Liberty Landing and authorizes a reimbursement of the fees paid by Habitat for
Humanity of Collier County Inc on Building Permit 2007020738 in the amount of
$12,442.52,
OBJECTIVE: That the Board of County Commissioners (Board) approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, the attached lien agrecment with Araceli Ramirez for defelTal of 100% of
Collier County impact fees far an owncr-occupied affordable housing unit and authorize a
reimbursement of the impact fees paid by Habitat li}[ Humanity of Collier County Inc. in the
amount of$12.442.52.
CONSIDERATIONS: AliicJe IV of Chapter 74 of the Code of Laws and Ordinances
established a program to defer impact fees for qualiiled affordable housing. Pursuant to this
program, an application for dcfemlent \\as submitted by Araceli Ramirez, which application,
alter staff review, was dctcnnined to qualify f(,r the program. Legal status has been verified and
documents are on tile at the oflice of \-lousing and Human Services. The propeIiy is located in
thc LibeJiy Landing subdivision in ! mmokalee.
--..
During staffs review of the tile to process this deferral for approval it was detemlined that the
Habitat far Humanity of Collier County lnc did not provide an application for the deferral
program as a qualified developcr prior to issuance of the building permit and payment of
associated impact fees as required. Staff has discussed this oversight with the County
Attorney's Office and recommends that the Board accept the application letter from the
developer after-the- fact in order to complete the required paperwork and maintain eonsistency
with the Ordinance for this file and defelTal agreement. Upon approval and execution of this
defelTal agreement and lien, impact fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc. in
the amount of$12,442.52 will be reimbursed.
The ordinance requires that a lien agreement be entered into with the applieant as a condition of
deferral of the impact fees. Section 74-401(3) of the Code authorizes the County Manager to
sign defelTal agreements with applicants qualifying for impact fee deferrals for affordable
housing, which has long been the practice. The ordinance, however, gives the County Manager
discretion in whether to enter into the Agreement. Accordingly, in keeping with recent
discussion and direction by the Board, the County Attorney's Office has detennined that until
directed otherwise by the Board, these agreements be plaeed on the Consent Agenda for the
Board's review, approval and Chairman's signature.
FISCAL IMPACT: This agreement defers $12,442.52 in impact fees. Although it is expected
that the County will ultimately collect these defelTed fees (generally upon the sale of the
residence), there is no guarantee as to if, or when, this would occur.
,--
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: The proposed Agreement is fully consistent with the intent
and purpose of Section 74-401 of the Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collier County.
Agenda Item hio. 10C
November 27, 2007
Page 2 of 10
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: That the Board approves and authorizes the Chairman to
sign the attached Lien Agreement for Deferral of 100% of Collier County Impact Fees for
Owner Occupied Affordable Housing Dwelling Units for Ar3celi Ramirez located at Lot 8,
Liberty Landing, hnmokalee and authorizes a reimbursement ofthe impact fees paid by Habitat
for Humanity of Collier County Inc on Building Pelmit 2007020738 in the amount of
$12,442.52, and any budget amendments that may be required associated to the reimbursement.
PREPARED BY: Frank Ramsey, SHIP Program Coordinator, Housing and Human Services
Rtlnrnlo
Agenda item t'h 1 DC
November 27,2007
Page 3 of 10
Fuol,RlImu'y
Collirr ('ount~' JUtS
]]01 L Tllmi~mi Trail
~lIple~, Horidll34112
File# 08-030-IF
This spat'cfor fC~l>rd;ng
LIEN AGREEMENT FOR I)EFERRAL OF 100% OF COLLIER COlIl'HY IMJ' ACT
FEES FOR OWNER OCClJPlED AFFORDABLE HOUSING llWELLlNG UNITS
[icf{){J.t. ~-'
This Agreement. i~ entered into ihis ~__L_ cia), of 5lI$flt:mkr. 2007, between Collier County, a
[}oiitical subdivision of the State of Florida <'COUNTY) and "Araceli Ramirez'" (OWNER),
;::njjectivcl}' stated as the "Panics."
1\0\\-:, TREREFORE, lor good and valuahle consideration. tht' n~c6rt and sufficiency or
which is mutually ackno'\~ledged. till' !larties agree as follows'
This Lien Agreement IS mmk pursuant to Chapler 74 n.fthc Code of Laws and (irdinanc,:..'s of
Collier County. Florida. kDO\Vn as "The Cullter County Consolidated Impact I-\~e Ordinance"
(Ordinance1- in the ~:v'::nl u.f' :m., c(1nHiC1 with lhi:;-')grecmcnL the terms or the Ordl!lun:..~t-
~;b:ll!
~he )('t!;<l! descrintioJ] 071!1';' chvdiin:,.' umt
~ltb(heu a~ ;::xhihI1
Tn~' 1~:-,11"' or Uli~' j\ l!n:~,-~I1l~~m l~, i'rmr lh~' dale ,;\:, f';\rtl; :lh~lV(' untll 1Jlt' lIr:pa;:.
~:"; reD:Jid
[he amnunt (I; tile Im;:la.::t j(;(v: dcL.:r:"cc; ';hall l1:"
" [:l~ 'u( q<T\'in i'lJii U1Km: ~~! m~
~;alc of the dwellinf: unit: bi the r,::'inancinl; of In:: dwclEng unit: ,; 'I '" Jos~- ollne home:-;tcad
exemption: m d'i the fi;'st occurrcrlcc of un)' sale or lransfe;' 0;- any part of the affected rcai
property. and in any such ('.vem the deferred impact fees shall be paid in full to the COLINTY
not later then the closing of the sale, or not latcr then the eflcctive dat.e ufthe transfer. As set
forth in Exhibit "'S," the amount of the deferred impact fees is Twelve Thousand Four
Hundrcd Fort" Two and 52/100 Dollars ($12.442,52). Repayment shall include any accrued
interest. interest shall he computed at the ratc of five percent (5%) per annum. hut in no
evt:nt shall it. exceed twemy~fivc percent (25%) of the total fee amount.
5. 'fhe deferred impact. fees shall he a lien 011 the property described in Exhibit "A," which lien
may he foreclosed upon in the event of non-compliance with the Ordinance or with this
Agreement. This Ab'TCCment. shall operate a" a lien against the dwelling unit. The lien shall
terminate upon the recording of a release or satisfaction of lien in the public records of thl'
County. The deferrals of impact fees and this A.greemem shall run with the land. and neither
the deferred impact fees nor this Agreement shall be transferred, assigned, or othenvise
conveyed. Except as provided by law, regardless of any f()fCclosure on the first mortgage or
other security int(.~rcst, this lien shall otherwise be superior and pardlTIOllnt lo the interest in
the dwelling unit of any owner, less'-"e. tenant. mortgagee. or other person, except that this
lien shall be on parity with any lien for CounlY taxes.
6. Upon the satisfactory completion of this Agreement's requirements, (~OUNTY shall record
any necessary documentation evidencing same.
7. In the event the OWNER is in default under the Ordinance or this Agreement, and t.he default
is not cured within 30 days after vroHl..'Il notice is provided to the OWNER, tbe COUNTY
,L\genda 1t8m NO.1 DC
November 27, 2007
Page 4 of 10
may. at its sole option, collect the impact fee amount in default a'i set forth in the Ordinance.
or bring a civil action to enforce this Agreement. or declare that the deferred impact fees are
then in default and immediately due and payable. The COUNTY shall he entitled to recover
all fees and costs. including attorney's fee and costs. incurred by the COUNTY in enforcing
this /\.grc(,.'mcnL plus interesl at the then maximwn statutory ratc fOl judgments calculated on
a calendar year basis until paid.
8. 'Ibis Agreement is the sole dgrcement between the parties with respect to the subject mat1er
herein. a.."1.0 shall he hinding upon the O\VNER'S successors and assigns in il1teres1.
9. This A~rccment shall he recnrded in the ofJici<l1 records of the County at no cost to the
C'()L'N'1.~1'
i~ \\'ITr\ESS \\'HEREOF, [he Panics have ::xc'cuted tillS Agreement on the dHk :md year fir::;!
;Ibo\.e \,vnttcn.
\llcc:t.
:)\i.."C:;H') . !1,f{()CK. <'jerk
H.( )/d~J) OF CO! !!'>JT\' COMMISSIONERS
-'()].r ,It:,:R ('(1\ r".."r',;' _ n.CiRIDA.
k:-Jdl',i::-n'
,'1'11,,;';' ('C)':..F'TT'j,.. t.... '\I!~rvl/'<:'
I\\",JU<.
\V,i tn(.~:sc;;.
''\racdi Ramirez
OWNER:
\VilI)Csscs: (
f" ,f._, \ '
1~~~~~~5~l~:-~:~~~-
STATE OF FLORIDA)
COUNTY OF COLLIER)
The fopegoing Agre,~JT1ent was acknowledged before me this --.1___ day of /:..!I..:I-.
2007, by/,hi' ((/5~'J7A::/i./.:'I/l{ ~. ,who is personally known to me or has produced
__~_,_,_,______, _~___ a.~11foof ofidcntii'y.
[NOTARIAL SEA .j
G'=SMENDOZA
,""'"t 1\ )"II~," .. '"444~
'.'.tuJ: ~y ("CiMM\S~\n~ ~ nD:'
.'ilfl.T r,xPl~f.s Setllcrrtx"'1:.11J1;'
.'l..",~.1 1'Il'<"""""t~",,,,,"A- '
I....."~ .."
... ( ,''J :'~ -. 'j, ,//..~, ,:<,_~;, Ii
.;... ) 1/( (;. /i/ ,."."C L.( ,r.... '.-
Signature of PerSo~1 Taking Acknowlcdb'IDent
.1\:
and Ie
~eC!:~:A:]~~C ~,
Ml;c; Krumbide.}I1I'A
Director
Collier County Housing and Human Services
Jeffrey ,
Managin
EXHIBIT "A"
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
Lot 8, Liher~' Landing, according to the plat thereof,
as r'ccorded in Plat Book 47, Pages 71 through 73,
inciusive~ of the Puhlic Records of Collier County. Florida.
eXHIBIT "B"
IMP ACT FEE BREAKDOWN
TYJlt' uflmllact Fee
'\. P..,1S Impact Fee
B. Corrcctionu! Fa(ilitie:- impact F<.~c
ijhrary JmDal" k.c
D. Comnnmily Parb: impact Fet"
j':(;:glona] 1\:rb lrnpaCl Fee
Fduc3.liona: rclc;jftl(~:. <.\.,,!eiT) ImndC1 h:c
tZOdd inlpD~~t i-~'~
H. ',li.)\'::.::rnm~'nt Hllikiings lrnpac'\ Ft~::
La\-\ ~.nh)rcement lrnrJaci h~e
TOTAl. IMPACT FELS
.!AKApprovcd _)_,_
Agenda Item NO.1 OC
November 27, 2007
Page 5 of 10
Amount Owed
$100.59
Slfl2.14
$3(j}:.1 g
S750.00
.;: ~ ,(i:,9.0(\
:-;2)~b:~OO
'_~(J.{))9.0()
:~410.(J(:
~; 171.61
$12.442.52
'i',':Y'.
:'''\ -,'
" '"
\\:;U;;;,TC'\
r,."{'
Co ~ 'i'" "
1'.'(: '
,',':"'.-
\.:
T" \(
i,t-
[<<1;-;
w
.
.
L\genda Item r"o. 10C
November 27, 2007
Page 6 of 10
fr
11;
August =J. :2007
Attn: Frank Ramsey
SHIP Program Coordinator
Collier COUnTy
:;30] E. Tal11iami '] rail
lIealth &, ('()mmunit) Scn'ices Building
'larks. FL _-~~; : ~
Re:
Impact Fee Reimbursement
'):':::(1" 1 '~'r~~l L
:-Ul!'!l,-il ,0'- ! ~lili:1r:11', ;' (>')];!~>r' ,~\un1\ _ il1C.. !~ ~-cquc~<mg r:;.~U;lnUTS'2m::n:
:(:1' anp::/i.'l
lh~' i~:l.pa(': ~--:~~'':'' CJeJ..:r'Ei; Pr':!L:.T'a:m.
'," "
j ncsc ; f;>>
:.:."':.'; ;K-:L-,
v.'::re paid ~.!p IT()n~ Habital f>r :--jllmallit~ ofCnliier CounTY. inc.. in
order to c;,~pedjle the buildinr; process, hov..icvc[ the fUlure (-"0/Dcrs fur ~he
propel1y qualify for an impact fee defcr;-aJ. Describe.d as !()Uov\r:-;
Araceli Ramirez
3548 Liberty Way, Immokalee FL 34142
Permit # 2007020738
Please feel free to contact Norma Lora (775-0036) if you have any
questions or concerns.
Sincerely.
'. / /,/ ..../
;:i:'"i~ny:j._/ .,'>-~~:~,~(;( v/~,~.;---_.
. Nicolls Ko~loheras
Land Development Director
,;_T,;,:,;l'H
:; : .l~.1;
-'-:'(-, ',.'-::,
'-, -', ~" - ~,"', -."
ci, i "-~ Ii . _"'~.
" ,--
:":c({\J:,. ~'Fr:
L;LcfI!; ":"g
Agenda item ~~o. 1 DC
November 27. 2007
Page 7 of 10
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR1103 - Official Receipt
-- ---,~- -. ._._~.._-------- ~ '
rTransNlJmbe-r---- TOate--- ---- ~ Post b-ate .. LPayment Slip Nbr
i 7487 44_ _____13127120()72:i3ii6PM~ JJ>./27 i2007-=:=_=_~~lf"t 20070:207~__.
-j
------..-"..---".-
Address: 3548 LIBERTY WAY
Owner: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY COA #: 06-0220
Permit Type: BR2 Job Desc: FRAMED SIF ATT 1 STY-150 AMP-TWIN VILLAS
Applicant: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY-SAM
DBA
Swr Meter: IMM Wtr Meter: IMM
Payor: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY OF COLLIER COUNTY INC
Fee Information
Fee CodeTbescription_-~-L"'~cl~nt -. ---- AmountlWaived I
08BCAI BLDG. CODE CERf-s'URCHARGE ; 11300000020882000000 -.- __m $6.82 ,--------,
f ~i~~~~~~ ~~~~~~N~F~~~}~~~~~~~-~~....-- ..'[H~1~~;~~~~~i1~m~f.-'-'_~_[-.j~~i~E~~~ ~-j
! 08GBMF GOVT BLDG IMAPCT FEE M/F. ___ i 39012223136353031390_ ,m_ . .._~41000 -----J
'081MFF IMMOKALEE FIRE IMpACT . _ _ _ 1130000002098:;000000 ___~J514.04 _I
108JLMF JAIL IMPACT FEE M/F 38111043036353031381 I $62.14
i 08LBMF ! LIBRARY IMpACT FEE M/F __ ___ ,35515619036353031355 ___I--$368.18J
08LWMF I LAW ENF IMPACT FEE MIF 38511043336353031385 i $171.61 I
. 08MFR5 'DIST 5 ROAD IMPACT FEE-MULTI-F i 33916365936353031339- 1 $6059.00 I
08MFSG MICROFILM SURCHARGE i 11313890034'1442000001 m~_~3.00 i
08!WGS BLDG. PERMIT SU~CHARGE 11300000020880000000T - $6.82 !
08RPMF B.E:G PK IMPACT FEE MIF ..__ 34611636336353031346 _..__ $1659.00" m__~
, 08SCHI SCHOOL BOARD IMPACT FEE 11300000020905000000 $2862.00 I
'11PUDM '-PUD MONOTORING FEE 13113890432248900000 ---- $75.00 j
112SITi::~..1 SITE tNSPECTION-ENGtNEi::RING 131138327:???~9000000 b' $150.-00 ....-..
U)8BA~B..J BLDG. PERMIT APP FE~C;RE[)IT i 11313890032251000000 $-100.00
Total $14651.80
- Continued -
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 951NT
Printed:10/3112007 4:29:59 PM
.6.;lenda item NO.1 OC
Nov.?rnber- 27, 2007
Page 8 of 10
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR1103 - Official Receipt
I Trans Number
; 748744
~ni~~Y~;~+;~i67~~r=-==--=J
Date d Post Date
_ .;'[27/2007 2:23 06 EM 3127/2007 _u_
Payments
-
--
:~<lyment Code ' Acc~l!ntlChe_c_kNumb~r
:C1LECK_ _______~ 3591
-.=-n_--i~~~~~Uf~
Total Cash $0.00
Total Non-Cash $14651.80
._~----
Total Paid
$14651.80
Memo:
Cashier/location: HILLCAROL / 1
User: POTTER_T
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT
Printed:10/31/2007 4:29:59 PM
,4genda Item NO.1 OC
November 27,2007
Page 9 of 10
'1':: 'l!' a, ).), '" I
H''''-D<'11'''','~''
,(':#~:' ')r. 'IT ,,''t';'
'],,: ~.." ..}~:j;btC:_'ta.. ,,'
""'","('; ,!.j
n: ;1
-"mi.:m
'.1:(\1,,::,1
flC:C; \,L\ni~
rei: :1)':1;:
P;;i:h
.If,,i:lf ~ ~'"
'.'1er Snlann
\ie;';~1n_d.>r
\\
;-.c'; nT..
r
tJrnanr
if{; ::'::,!n~'1
;:codd if :.'I''''{
:,;,',!I
f.'; n
;'-i',
i',::..':i"'
October 29.2007
i'\ttn: Frank Ramsey
SHIP Program Coordinator
~301 E. Tamiami 'Trail
Naples. Florida 112
Rt-.:
3548 L..ihen), V""i:-. lrnmokalee, FL ,^"A 142
200702U7:;8
Pc:nnit #:
fkur Frank,
ilabirat j-fumanny i,'cdlil'f (\\[l11t:-. lnc_ per the County \\:ide in1j1:.1C1 Fc~'
;)rcw"'lT' jiltpi;+j."l il'J'-'> "\1"1\'~ '.""f-'1\.'net~C; '1ri\')"1'1\' ')~ ;:'fl ',i'f(Jro~c,'hle
, .,::,J,u.. ", "- .. 'd ,. _,' , '-' ('e.\. ..- J ,-. -...J ........ ["" j ..... '. (~.,..> ,.',' M..... u..
housing unit. Pieast' ie: This kUer serve as an aftC'r-lh::-L~Cl appiic3tion and
identitication thm an income eligible. Je22a! resident cd' the United States \vill
occupy the property' once cornplelc.
Habitat for Humanity of Collicr County. lnc paid the Impact Fees upfront in
order to expcditc the building process.
Please feel free to contaet Norma Lora (775-0036) if you have any questions or
concerns.
Sincer';!r
<~~?;~::;!,:> --------/
-", .,/ / /;;U;~
,'. .-r." - T'
Salp-tlel DurS1:i, 1.D.
President
,:':n :.;;'~ l:lI
L.'tSl
}es, Tl ~.-ciL:;
-, ',I; _.:;;)......-::;.D.J~7 if3\:';
;.JdU,;:SOii, hC:'!(c:l~j!3r.(()1n
"'..~\ 'IJ,t:::.l({ l1:c;_n~g
J of J
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Item Number:
-r<-'
Item Summary:
",e,"""'I'"
:r ilt t ~ ,,-m:: ':-C)'I";I'" :;rll ""%'''''8[0 cJ::T'''-:>''/E;O. etn,) Huthcr'!es the
-."i,'-",l-'S'
'IH' Tlr2",n)~
I,;,r";2J,"JIYI
''''''-,c'' 'r', ~'e'e"'a' Q! 1(:11", ')!
I),,,..: "-'il),,'
. , at'u ~'a~)I( I ';u~, 'U U 1', iue 1,,,,(1 T I u: r
",I)~'-~\i '_"",'JI"; ~;I,:t ,: ,'[ "IZ,"_; I,2Irri" '-"",':11 -' ih'. IH,,' n~-j:'.! ~',\, i/',c,r:a'
'ITFI'W\' 0'
nll-€-I
n'('I,lI
".. t'1\" ~r ''',Wl ,:1
..l4::.C2
Meeting Date:
.1,'
I'n'flllred By
Fe'1n" F~am".,,'
c-;HII.; D;'(l0'-an' CN/d"'31":
rmHO,
hmlicS"-'ilces
fi-'-.lJS"',', "",;Hw,,;:w ,;",,' ;((.,<,
. "l;2lJ(,7 !' 324>; ~M
Appro"c-d B~
')':" ^ '" I'. I""" u; ~,.;
",,-,;1",
hIll'
'-. ~.j
\pproV('(! II~
, ;m
'\pprO\l'tl By
'\pl'nl\'('l! Ih
\pprllwd By
,,-,. - Yie<,
C,CJ(j(:(-'
.\pprovetl II)"
.I.:;n ,',. Ii i) d~-
-....,"nr,-'[,':'rn-,-("'
--'',If
foo'I;:Jw'Cuunty
r:Cuntyr,",'llil{lU',,()ff,ee
11115'200711:$1 AM
r.,"m'l'rs-,'c,nl"~
file://C:\AgendaT est\Export\93- November%2027. %,202007\ 10. %20COUNTY%,20MANA.. 11/20/2007
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Aaenda Item NO.1 OD
November 27, 2007
Page 1 of 10
Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with Roberto Maciel Chavez and Gloria Maciel
(Owners) for deferral of ]00% of Collier County impact fecs for an owner-occupied
affordable housing unit located at Lot 15, Trail Ridge and authorizcs a reimbursement of
thc fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Ine on Building Permit
2006064370 in the amount of $13,616.20.
OBJECTIVE: That the Board of County Commissioners (Board) approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, the attached lien agreement with Roberto Maciel Chavez and Gloria Maciel
for deferral of ] 00% of Collier County impact fees far an owner-oceupied affordable housing
unit and authorize a reimbursement of the impact fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier
County Inc. in the amount of $13,616.20.
CONSIDER.ATIONS: Aliiele IV of Chapter 74 of the Code of Laws and Ordinances
established a program to defer impact fecs for ,!ualilied affordable housing. Pursuant to lhis
program, an application f()r defennent was submitted by Robelto Maciel Chavez and Gloria
Maciel. which application, af1er staiT review, was determined to qualify f,n the program. Lcgal
stalus has bcen vcrificd and documents arc on jile at the office of I-lousing and Human Services.
The propeliy is located in the Trail Ridge subdi\i;ion in Naples.
During staffs review of the file to process this defelTal f()r approval it was deten.l1inedthat the
Habitat far Humanity of Collier County lnc did not provide an application far the deferral
program as a qualified developer prior to issuance of the building permit and payment of
associated impact fees as required. Staff has discussed this oversight with the County Attol11cy's
Office and recommends that the Board accept thc application letter from the developer after-the-
fact in order to eomplete the required paperwork and maintain consistency with the Ordinance
for this file and deferral agreement. Upon approval and execution of this deferral agreement and
lien, impact fees paid hy Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc. in the amount of
$13,616.20 will be reimbursed.
The ordinance requires that a lien agreement be entered into with the applicant as a condition of
deferral of the impact fees. Section 74-401 (3) of the Code authorizes the County Manager to
sign deferral agreements with applicants qualifying for impact fee deferrals for affordable
housing, which has long been the practice. The ordinance, however, gives the County Manager
discretion in whether to enter into the Agreement. Accordingly, in keeping with recent
discussion and direction by the Board, the County Attorney's Office has deternlined that until
directed otherwise by the Board, these agreements be placed on the Consent Agenda for the
Board's review, approval and Chaim1an's signature.
FISCAL IMPACT: This agreement defers $13,616.20 in impact fees. Although it is expected
that the County will ultimately collect these deferred fees (generally upon the sale of the
residence), there is no guarantee as to if, or when, this would occur.
,""".".
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
LEGAL CONSIDERA nONS: The proposed Agreement is fully consistent with the intent and
purpose of Section 74-40] of the Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collier County.
~,genda Itern NO.1 OD
November 27. 2007
. Paae:2 of ~IO
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: That the Board approves and authorIZes the Chainnan to'sign
the attached Lien Agreemcnt for DefclTal of 100% of Collier County Impact Fees for Owncr
Occupied Affordable Housing Dwelling Units for Roberto Maciel Chavez and Gloria Maciel
located at Lot 15, Trail Ridge, Naples and authorizes a reimbursement of the impact fces paid by
Habitat far Humanity of Collier County Inc on Building Permit 2006064370 in the amount of
$13,6 J 6.20, and any budge! amcndments that may bc required associated to thc rcimbursement.
PREPARED BY: Frank Ramsey, SHIP Program Coordinator, Housing and Human Scrvices
Itdurnlll
Agenda Item No. 10D
November 27, 2~07
Page 3 01 10
!
Frank RllnlS....Y
ClIlIicrCountyllllS
3301 E.TlImillmi'I rlil
!'\IlIpl....s, Hnridll J4112
Filc# 08-058-1 F
rhi:; ~pacr fur recording
LIEN AGREEMENT FOR HEFERRAL OF 100% OF COLLIER COUNTY IMPACT
FEES ~-OR ()WN.~R OCClll'lEH AFFORHARLE HOUSING HWELLlNG UNITS
This Agreemc11l is entered into this
day of Octoher. 2007. hetween Collier County, a
political subdivision of the Stntt'- of Florida (COUNTY) and "Roberto Maciel Chavez and Gloria
M.acicl" (OWNER). collectively stakd as the "Panics."
NO'W, THEREFORE. ror good (md vallwhlc cOllsickra\ion. the rcceipi and sufficiency of
which i~ rnutua]jy acknov.,:ledged. the PDrtic<; agree as follows'
This Liefl Agreement is nmde pursuant to Chapter 74 of tht; Code (if 1,::1\.'1'<; and Ordinances of
Collier County. Florida, knO\vrl us "'1'11(, CClllicr Counly Cnns\)jidatcd Impact Fec Ordinance'.
IOrdinance). In thv eVcllt 01" ill1)' Cilllllici "'vilh ihis .'\,grc(:nJcnt. the lcr1l1.':; of lhe Ordinanc.c
shan apply
Ihc ;e~:d d(~s:.:ripti{Jp uf tht' (l\vdlin!: Un!1 :111;lc11e;[ u:" r:xhihil "
!'l1\:.' h:rm oftlli'; /,\!n:\:.~rncnl i~ from lilt' dmc :;('1 ionh ,d'(h(; until ln~' Ifllpac( lee is lcprud
.:1. rilc: ;.inhlLm~ c: the impdl.:l k~':, ~jcrcnl'd s:laF I'lc p,lid Ii' tiE.' ('01 ''',''ry in itdl upm:: iLl till
saie (If the owcliinb unit; pi the rcflOancing ui'th-::: dwelling unlL c', <J loss urthe homeslead
exemption; \IT ell the first occurrence or any sale or transfer or aJ.1) parI of lhe affected rcrd
property, and in any such e\;cnt the deferred impact fees shall be paid in fulJ to the COUNT'I'
not later then the closing of the sale. or not later then the eJTective d,lte of the transfer. As set
forth in Exhibit He:- the amoml1 of the deferred impact fees is 'fhirtcen Thouslli)d Six
Ihmdrcd~Si>;t(,.~eJl and 201100 Dollars ($13.6]6,20). Repayment shall include any accrued
interest. Interest shall tl(~ computed at the rate of five percent (5l}u) per annum. but in no
event shaH it exceed twent.y-fivc percent (25%) of the total fee amount.
5, The deferred impact fees shall he a lien on the property described in Exhibit "A," which licn
may be foreclosed upon in the event of non~eompljance with the Ordinance or with this
Agreement. This Agreement shall op\.:rate as a lien against the dwelling unit. 'nle lien shall
tcnninate upon the recording of a release or satisfaction of lien in the public records of lhe
County, The deferrals of impact fees and this Agreement shall run v.lith the land, and neither
the deferred impact fees nor this Agreement shall be transferred, assigned, or otherwise
conveyed. Except as provided by law, regardless of any foreclosure on the first mortgage or
other security interest, this lien shall otherwise be superior and paramounl to the interest in
the dwelling unit of any owner, lessee, tenant, mortgagee, or other person, cxcL-pl that this
lien shall he on parity v,lith any lien for County taxes,
6. Upon the satisfactory completion of this l\blTCCment's requirements. COUNTY shall record
all}' necessary documentation evidencing same.
7. In the event the OWNER is in default under Ihe Ordinance ar tillS Agreement, and the default
is not cured v.'ithin 30 days after \\Titten notice is provided to the OWNER, the COUNTY
Aaend3 11em No. 100
November 27" 2007
Page ~ 0110
may. at its sole option. collect the impact fee amount in dcf~lIlt a~ set forth in the Ordinance,
or hring ~I civil action 10 enforce 1his Agreement or declare 1hal the dcfen.cd impact fees are
then in default and immeJialely due and payable. The ('OIT1\JT\' shall he entitled to recover
all fees and costs. including atlonwy.s fee and costs. incurred by the COUNT\' in cnforcing
lhis f\grcCITlCIlL plus imcrcsl al th:.' then maximum statutory rail' j()r judgmcms c,dculalcd ()Il
a calendar year basis unl iJ paid.
x. This Agrccmc.'nt is the sol(' agn:emcnl between the parties \vith respect to thc subject matter
herein, and shall he hinding upon the O\VNER'S Sllccessors and assigns in interest.
9 This Agreement shall hc recorded in the plTicial records of the Count) 81 no cost to the
CO\Y'TY
iN \\TrNESS WIIF.REOF, the PJrtic.~ i1~l\':": ~:)"cCLllcd lhi~; '\grcl'nlcnt on tlK' Jalc ;:md year first
ano\'C wnllen.
.'\t1cst
1)\,/1(;1-r1' F. JIR()C.k. Cieri
H(l,l\RI) (Jf' CUlfNT\' CU)Vlrvj]SSI()!'>jFR~
CC )1.1 .!F.T ('()t :I\,:'J",' ."FU)F In/\.
:-],
II-~_'" (i t ., ", ,.\
\r\iH~ '( l~ ,~"i"l /\ -!:..\ ilz\1 i.
) \\' ,'\ [~I<"
\',,"itncs<;e:;;
- ----_.~.__.--~- -~~~--~~---~_.._..__.-
Print NalTI~ ~_~~"""":'_':"'~_~________.__
Roherto J\1acic! (,havCl
OWl\ER:
\\'imesses:
i
i,I
~;-')"-')-'
tL;;:'-__'m::...':::..._____,_"_
Print Name~~'I,--:
Gloria Maciel
STATE OF FLORID^!
COUNTY OF COLLIER)
.n,c foregoing Agreement was acknowledged he fore me this _.!~_ day of
2007. by .", ,(:f ' j / ._. \vho is personally knOv,l1 to me or bas produced
_______L_.i..~_~L.:____.1:..__~ ,.-_ as proofofidcntily,
;~~wr~~;F~~~~EJ""'
:..,....-.......................~'^^'Vv'>-"-.r
-.-,.
Signature of Person Taking Ackn(}wledgmen1
Appro~ed a{.t~ form
and 1e~1 :!I[l,Ciency:->
__~1J.~ t\__~
Jeffrey Ac ~w
Chief As~s1.ant Count v Attorney
1 . - -
Recommend Approval:
, '\
/\';'~_,~~:\~y./~~___-C
Ma'rcy Krumbine; MP A
Direclor
Collier Count) I-lousing and Human SCf\'ices
...
~
EXHIBIT "A"
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
Lot 15. Trail Ridge. acc()rdin~ to the plat thcn~of,
as recorded in Plat Hook 44, Pages?l through 77,
inclusive, of thl~ l)ublic Ret'ords of Collier County, Florida.
EXHIBIT "8"
IMPACT FEF, tlREAKI)OWN
Typt' of Impact Fct"
A. EMS Impact Fce
13. Correctional Facilities lmpaci FL'C
C Lihrary lrnpucl Fee
1) C:ommunity Parks lrnpaci Fcc
Regional J\lrk::; lmpaci Fcc
i":',duC:Jii0n:i] htciiitlc>: ,;<,"Slc1'1-' 11111':1:'\ Fl:C
(I !~o<ld Imp<1c: i",'-c
H CrOVC:1111Wni !~ujidiJlgs lrnp;:h:t l"l't'
l. La.'I' Enforc::mcn1 lmp8ct rc~-'
J. Water lmpuct Fcc
K, Sc\\!er Impact fee
TOT AL IMPACT FEES
I^K I\ppnll'cd I
Agenda Item I~o. 10D
November 27.2007
Page 5 of 10
Amuunt Owed
$100.59
$62.14
$16~.1 g
$750.00
S1.t;5{J.OO
$1i:\,7.0\!
~;:-,~":, 1.00
:>150.24
$s:tOS
S2_760.00
$3.125.00
$13.616.20
.
.
.Agenda Item No, 10D
November 27. 2007
Page 6 of 10
f
r
t,
f.,
September 18. 2007
Attn' Frank Ramsey
SHIP Program Coordinator
Collier COlIl11\
~;~O.I F. T;:lllliami Trail
I-Iealth &. ('(lmmunity Sen'ices Building
Narks. FL ~~:l j :::
Rc:
Impact Fee Reimburscment
J:'<J.: ; ';:mL
'-:,ibiUl: Jr...; :-iUTlWI;i;.\:'-, ;:';;l~;r (,IL:n',\, i;1(... ,'- rcqd::,'sling rC:irn't1ur:-:enlc'nt
{:"'1' .
),~~:;;,,~, r~JIU
lhe lilr:(r~'l F,~'c- TOlcfcr;"a! Progr31L Thest',ll,,:es
\vert' ));:',lU up i'ror;:!~\ ~'Tabi13l for ilU!;.'l~u]i1.\' uf (oIlier County. Inc.. in
()rj{;:.~r to expedite the huilding pr(\ct'~;s_ ho\\"(;\".;;:- t.he future OV;l1ers feiT the
propcrt) quaiil~' 1'0:' an impact fee cL'i'e1Tal. D~scribed ::~~: fo]]ovvs:
Roberto Maciel-Chavcz & Gloria M. Maciel
13340 Covenant Rd, Naples FL 34114
Permit # 2006064370
, ,,',r"
"
Please feel fi'ee to contact Nonna Lora (775-0036) if you have any
questions or concerns.
';'-",
S incereJ y,
~~-:>'.
j/
LislfLefkow
Development Director
i ~ H ~ ",
\.':
. ,,~'"
Agenda item I~o. 100
November 27,2007
Page 7 of 10
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR 1103 - Official Receipt
~~~;&~~~r
J~/~~f;;;. ___=====~;~;~_~3~~r .--=-~_ j
I Date-----
8/15/20062 38:07 PM
Address: 13340 COVENANT RD
Owner: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY OF COA#: 05-0717
PermltType: BR2 Job Desc: FRAMED S/F ATT 1 STY-150 AMP-TWIN VILLAS
Applicant: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY-SAM
DBA:
Swr Meter: SC Wtr Meter: CC
Payor: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY OF COLLIER COUNTY INC
Fee Information
Fee Code ,Description , GL,A~_counL
: Q8BCA1_ BLDG.CODE CEF3:LSURCHARGE___,-t13000Q002().?J3:;>900~)Q0
, 08BPNP BLDG PERMITS - NAPLES 11313890032211000000
Amount
...iE>~:1....
$55360
Waived
__'..H...._. _
08.GPMF I COMM PK_'MPACT FEE M/F ,34615640236353031346
08EMMMF EMS IMPACT FEE M/F 35014047036353031350
08ENIM- - EAST NAPLES FIRE IMPACL..=1130000002098f..OQ900Q. _'
08GBMF i GOVT BLDG IMAPCT FEE M/F __ .._~90122231363530:31~\J0_.
g~~~r: ! ~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~ M/F-------:j ;~~~~$_i~~~~~~~g;im
08LWMF 1 LAW ENF IMPACT FEE M/E.._ . 38511043336353031385
08MFR4 DIST 4 ROAD IMPACT FEI::..:r:JIl.IL.II-F 33616365636353031336
08MFSG MICROFILM SURCHARGE 11313890034144200000
08RDGS BLDG. PERMIT SURCHARGE 11300000020880000000
08RPMF REG PK IMPACT FEE M/F 34615640236353031346
08SCHI SCHOOL BOARD IMPACT FEE 11300000020905000000
11 PUDM PU D MONOTORING FEE 13113890432248900000
12SITE SITE INSPECTION-ENGINEERING 13113832732249000000
42MTTP COUNTY METER TAP CHARGE 40825321234332000000
42SSDC j3EWER SYSTEM C!:I6RGE 413~E>.:361334356031413
~g>C WATER SYSTEM CHARGE .11.1:m51.1:>4336031411
, 08BACR B"-DG..l'.~RMIT APP. FEE CREDIT 113138900322510QQQQO'.----l--
I
Total
- Continued -
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT
$750.00
.._._-----~-
$100.59,
.1._ $30008 I
:_.. $150.24
$62141.. _~
$368.18
$83.05
$3731.00.,
goo
$6.82
$1659.00
$827.QO
$75.00
$150.00
__~:;>215f..!.___
$3125.00
$2760.00
$-100.00
$14833.04
-'1
I
_J
Printed:10/31/2007 4:37:38 PM
Agenda item NO.1 OD
Novernber 27. 2007
Page 8 of 10
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR1103 - Official Receipt
i Trans Number
,69482~~__
.. -T'Dale _~=:~------iPOslDaie
. 113/15/200623807 PM 18/15/2006
Payments
, Payment Code
!yHECK
; AccounUq",_ckNumber
, 11879
Memo:
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT
_____u____.___.__.____
--- I
-------~___1
I
-,-Payment Slip Nbr
i PT 2006064370
-- ------------i---
"--'Amou.iit-:
__~_________J
$1483304 i
-----1
,
Total Cash
Total Non-Cash
$0.00
$14833.04 '
--------------
Total Paid
$14833041
Cashier/location: HILLCAROL I
User: POTTER_ T
Printed: 1 0/31/2007 4:37:38 PM
Agenda item NO.1 OD
November 27,2007
Page 9 of 10
~.J;>~!~t;;;lJ.t t'r.~".r^'
tj~,{~lJ !';': !~'~j~ 'lk. !to V' ....
\k,~' : p',
;;;'::-!"c'r!
N,-orine
",\:.~ni:;;m'
r\'ii,,~ha-("l
"',,icL:;
;c:,i:n Ydi.~kl.
}Otln P (1;-;im~ ~,
r).;:n'id
L.c baGt ~;;lI
Pt'.l;:r Sot::::n(~
\.I<'x.lndel
,;,()::~:(' \'''':'.1':_r 'J,'
f' V.\::'fT'
KJ~! \\'~.
rl(::;",
H,'::
F'i>~ .1' ':
.""r
11 '\ m""~, "~ t'~, ~.^'
.JaiU\';'"t!~, l
,-f ;O,v/l":~ -,. -U'~': , , ; .' ,i' !', i
.. ~H!1i [{, L;
(;;:'1
<f';"<::t
Octo her 29, 2007
Attn: Frank Ramsey
SHIP Program Coordinator
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples. Florida 34112
RE:
Permit #:
13.'140 Covenant. Road, ~~aples, F'-l, ~~4114
2006064370
[):::ar r:rank.
," ,'. ,- -,
llatmat Tor HLlT11a11n~\ ~-_'J C U!iI(:f
, 1 ne. j,2l' thc"
V/idc Lmpact F ~~c
Deferral PTo~rarn. jdenTi!'~2~, lhc atxh(:' tcferenc~;d rr,npcny ;,_:~; an aff()rdahi~'
housing uniT.. Pkase le1 this le1ter serve (1;;: an at1C'j'-lhc-f[:Ic1 appjicalJOn and
identification that an income eligihle, k~',al resident of tbe lJnited States \vill
occupy the property once c,mnp1e1.e.
Habitat for Humanity of Collier County, lnc paid the Impact Fees upfront in
order to expedite the building process.
Please feel free to contact N0l111a Lora (775-0036) if you have any questions or
concerns.
Sincerely/ /7_
-;/ . ,/,,/ ,?~;
//~</./ ,^ ,~./'...,;
//,/,c',. -;?'--'/
-//i>/:~-~"-;"-' ('C"//'
Sam Durso, M.D.
President
,;el,;.a;n," 1 1;
:'
'-I 7-:,.UGj~, 23..::<~'"~5,~'IJ,'77 ;:,~,,_,_'!
;Tj :t:rsrvr.-'h' :':~>:':',FeL('orn
v. \\'''''.L~: ~"
~'K
Pel?!' 1(;
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMI$SIClNERS
Item Number;
Item Summary:
V' 'T'''' '_e<, .. 1',3' fel( 2ndrc Q' (>"llIl1I'I :-::::.I"rn.'"sl'::'li'r~ ~p~J1 ,.",:s -'TJ ;'lIJ~h.~I;'z[,'.; n"
:..,,, ImEW 1(:. S:W' ,IF'" 'J'_:r,": nm'~ V'i1t,., h'i[)' ,',
"''',2'-','"' _ i'n~ :'kTiJ Mil.~ ':'1 ,.- -)-,-...n,'
'JSld
~"-lr\' i~llc)C 'ie'F.:, '0
"NW-
'1,""0 OJ' -)r~,<
".J:;;]I"";
1 ': II i '.-irJ" "_l~ ",-,t :~or:z,", a ""'lent 'H~['n""'ll DI Ii-< c-s ,",.W r!Hln.(
',;',:a:,I','
'II"",, "J;" Ii'.(. ~;IJ-..:j, ,'j "'JW1"
tfli -u..n:r:'
Meeting Date:
'1\'
I'rellared By
~r~nl- F;",."s'_'y
:;f'P"!"cc.."ran',, "}(,,,j,"atnr
L.,*
~"'C' I' - ,"-or., i r:'.;~
'~,Ir"i )"" 'jum~'; ',-",
E.''j ;:()(j7 ~: ::5;<'4 ,\M
\ppruvl'd By
",,1\
-'I.ppnl\'l,dlh
"I"
'i'l
\ppl'ovt'dfl)
\JlprnH'd Ii)
AII!HII\'l,(i U)
"m:
",,:r.:'-'"
Apllrlll'l.'ll B,\
1''''()~ \I. i\',,,,id
: "',-,rH',' 'i-'-'''~r>''r
:",~H
8.~" ;i rA (>)Ullty
C::Jmnl'~510"'."S
.::;",,,,t\ ~I '''''''~te''<, G"
1 '" '~ G/2 GO! [; 1 II p,,;
fi1e:IIC:\AgendaTest\Exoort\93~ Novemher%2027, %202007\ 10. %20COUNTY%20MANA,., 1112012007
,t\genda Item No.1 OE
November 27,2007
Page 1 of 10
EXEClJTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with David Licot and Nancy Licot (Ownel's) for
deferral of 100% of Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable housing
unit located at Lot 121, Trail Ridge and authorizes a J'eimbursement of the fees paid by
Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc on Building Permit 2007012026 in the amount
of $19,372.52.
OBJECTIVE: That the Board of County Commissioners (Board) approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, the attached lien agreement with David Licot and Nancy Lieot far deferral of
] 00% of Collier County impact Cees ft)r an owner-occupied aff'ordable housing unit and
authorize a reimbursement of the impact fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County
Inc. in the amount of $ ] 9,372.52.
CONSIDERATIONS: Article IV of Chapter 74 of the Code of Laws and Ordinances
established a program to defer impact feesl()r qualified atJ()]'(jable housing. Pursuant to this
program. an application J()r deferment was suhmitted by David Licot and Nancy Licot, which
application, atler stalTrcview. was determined 10 qualify J(Jr the program. Legal status has been
verified and documents arc on file at the office of Housing and Human Services. The propcrty is
located in the Trail Ridge subdivision in Naples.
During staff's rcview of the file to process this defcnal for approval it was detennined that the
Habitat for Humanity of Collier County lnc did not provide an application fbr the defenal
program as a qualified developer prior to issuance of the building permit and payment of
associated impact fees as required. Staff has discussed this oversight with the County
Attorney's Office and recommends that the Board accept the application letter from the
developer after-the- fact in order to complete the required paperwork and maintain consisteney
with the Ordinance for this file and defelTal agreement. Upon approval and execution of this
defenal agreement and lien, impact fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc. in
the amount 01'$19,372.52 will be reimbursed.
The ordinance requires that a lien agreement be entered into with the applicant as a condition of
defenal of the impact fees. Section 74-401 (3) of the Code authorizes the County Manager to
sign defelTal agreements with applicants qualifying for impact fee defenaJs for affordable
housing, which has long been the practice. The ordinance, however, gives the County Manager
diseretion in whether to enter into the Agreement. Accordingly, in keeping with recent
diseussion and direction by the Board, the County Attorney's Office has determined that until
directed otherwise by the Board, these agreements be placed on the Consent Agenda for the
Board's review, approval and Chairman's signature.
FISCAL IMPACT: This agreement defers $19,372.52 in impact fees. Although it is expected
that the County will ultimately collect these defened fees (generally upon the sale of the
residence), there is no guarantee as to if, or when, this would occur.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: The proposed Agreement is fully consistent with the intent
and purpose of Section 74-40 I of the Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collier County.
Aaenda !tern NO.1 GE
f~overnber 27, 2007
Page 2 of 10
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: That the Board approves and authorizes the Chairman to
sign the attached Lien Agreement for Deferral of 100% of Collier County Impact Fees far
Owner Occupied Affordable Housing Dwelling Units for David Licot and Nancy Licot located
at Lot 121, Trail Ridge, Naples and authorizes a ['eimbursement of the impact fees paid by
Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc on Building Pennit 2007012026 in the amount of
$19,372.52, and any budget amendments that may be required associated to the reimbursement.
PREPARED BY: Frank Ramsey, SHIP Program Coordinator, Housing and Human Services
J(eturntn
flqenda Irem NO.1 OE
November 27. 2007
Page 3 of 10
"'nm"- Rllm~~y
CnllierCountyllllS
J]{II L TlImillmi Trllil
NlIple~. HIlridll]4112
filc# 08-032-IF
rtJi~ ~f'an" for ncordinll
LIEN AGREEMENT FOR DEFERRAL OF 100% OF COLLIER COUNTY IMPACT
FEES FOR OWNER OCCUPIED AFFORDABLE HOUSING nWELLlNG UNITS
This Agreement is entercd into this ----'--- day of Octoher. ~007, hetween Collier County. a
political subdivision of the Stute of Plorida (C:OUNT'{) and "Dayid Licot and Nancy Lieor'
I OWNER), collectively stated as the "Partics."
NO\\c', THEREFORE, for good and valuahle consideration. the receipt and sufJiciency of
which is mutually ad~ll(l\\'ledg.ed.. the Panics agree <.IS follows:
I. This Lien AgrGement is nwde pursuant to Chapter 74 of the Code or Lu\Vs and Ordinance~, oj
CoHier Counly, Florida, "known as "The Collier County Consolidated Impact Fce Ordinance"
(OrdinaDL~cL In the evclll. of any cllnfk:t witb this Agreement. 11K terms I'I' the Ordinal1<:c
~;h(ll1 irrp!.v.
Tbe icgal description of the ov.'cllin~~ unit i:~ anached a'; :;,;hibit ",\ '
The term of1Jlls'\greCl1lenl IS ham [he date- >;::.:1 ((Ifill ao()\'(' until dK impact kef;'; r~'pald.
.. The ul1lounl or the :111pacl Tees deferred sh3l! he paid \0 tile' ( OLT~'rY in full upon: a) the
sale of the dwelling unit; b) the retinanc.ing nfthc dv..'elling unil~ c) a loss of the homestead
c)iCrnpLion; or ell ihe first occurrence PI any sail' or lran;;fcr of any part of' the alTccled real
property, and in any SUdl event the deferred impact fees shall be paid in full to the COUNT'}"
nollalcr then the dosing llr lilt sale, or not later then the effective date or the transfer. As set
forth in Exhibit "B," the amount of the deferred impact fees is Nineteen Thous,md Three
Hundred Seventy Two and 5'1/100 Dollars ($19.372.52). Repayment shall include any
accrued interest. Interest shall he computed at the rate of five percent (5%) per annum, but in
no evcnt shall it exceed twenty.fivcpcrcent (25%) of the total fee amount.
5. The deferred impact fees shall be a lien on the property described in Exhibit "A," which lien
may be foreclosed upon in the event of non.compliance with the Ordinance or with this
Agreement. This Agreement shall operate as a ljen against the d\\,-elling unit. The lien shaH
terminate upon the recording of a release or satisfaction of lien in the public records of the
County. The deferrals of impact fees and this Agreement shall run with the land, and neither
the deferred impact fees nor this Agreement shall be transfcrred, assigned, or otherwise
conveyed. Except a<; provided by Jaw. regardless of any foreclosure 011 the first mortgage or
other security interest. this lien shall otherwise be superior and paramount to the interest in
the dwelling unit of any owner, lessee, tenant mortgagee, or other person. except that this
lien shall be on parity \l;rith any lien for County taxes.
6. Upon the salisfaclory completion of this AgrccmcnL requirements, COUNTY shall record
any necessary documentation evidencing same.
7. In the event the O\VNER is in default under the Ordinance or this Agreement, and the default
is not cured within 30 days after written noticc is provided to the OWNER, the COUNTY
,Agenda item ~~o. 10::':
November 27, 2007
Page 4 of 10
may_ at its sole option. collect the impact fce amount in default as set forth in the Ordinance,
or bring a civil action to enforce this Agreement or declare that the deferred impact fees are
then in dcfmdl and immediately due ;:md payable. Tht' COUNTY shall be entitled to recover
all ice:;; ;:U1d costs. includint; atlorncy' ~ fee and costs, incurred hy the COUNTY in enforcing
this Agreement plus interest ul lhe then maximum sta[ulor~ rate hlr judgments calculated nn
a ealt:ndar year hasis umi1 paid.
8. This Agreement is the sole agreement hetwcen the parties with respect to the subject matter
herein, and shall he hinding upon the OV'/NER'S successors and assigns in interest.
9. This Agreement shall be rcc(lracd in the official nx:ords of th(~ County a1 no cost 10 the
COI iN"!"\'.
!N \\"ITNESS \V!-IEREOF. th(' PartIes have execUTed tbis i\f!rccmcnt on the date and ycur first
annve wrlllcn.
Attest:
D\\X;ln r~_ m~(JCf..:. Ckd
BO,-\]ZD Oll'(ltr'.;'j Y CtIMM1SSj(Y";ERS
)J ] JFJ;> (';')1 ')\.~TY ':1 (jRTP/\.
, ~v'
]-h
;-"::rm::
, ! ; ~;'\..:
I ,'ddF\..:
",.1
I'.
~--T'r.~" C1 rArRkl,A";
()\\'r<i.'!-:'
~~jtncss('s:
Print
Da\id
O\liNER.
Jh~tnesses: -~,
't'.,,. ,----:-
/~,z-</ ~~;/
,-,,__::'~..c/ ;..<""', ("
",~_..J':
Print Name \ H_~: ~~"-:)? l,...
N anc)' Licot
STATE OF FLORIDA)
COUNTY OF COLLIER)
The foregoing Agreement was acknowledged before me this ~ d3)'
2007. whQ_"iusr--'''Q1}gll~_lD_9wn ~mc or
_u__m____asproofofidcntity. -
produced
^~~
:'~{,,:Z;J
,
'.;';/;
I,',
,L.
Signature of Person Taking Ach:nowlcdgmcnt
ApPTO~ed f-S~O .(Offil
and letP-1 sufici6nc;':
ff&tL---
Jeffrey A.. KJ'a,tzkow
Chief Assiswrtt Countv AUornc\'
I' - .
, i
Recommend AppTO\'31:
- ,
,
,
! i, i
/~~;~~~~tMP~.' ~I
Director
CoBler County Housing and Human Services
'~
EXHIBIT "A"
LEGAL I>ESCRIPTION
Lot 121, Trail Ridge, according to the plat thereof,
as recorded in Plat Book 44, Pages 7] through 77,
inclusive, ufthe Public Records of Collier County, Florida.
EXHIIIIT"Il"
IMI'ACT FI':E BREAKDOWN
Type oflrnpnct Fl't~
A. EMS Impacl Fee
13. Correctional Facilities lmpac1 Fcc
C. Lihrary Impact I'c.t;'
D Community Parks ln1pac.t F('('
E. Eq~i(1na: \'arks lmna(':1 h~c
F. [ducaliom! Faclliti:.:~; SystC:lf; lmpac1 h:t"
Ci Road Imrac1 h~c
H. Govemmcn! Huijding~ ImpaGt Fce
L L,JW Enforccm\:.~nt Impact Fee
.1. Water Impact Fcc
K. Sewer Impact Fee
TOTAL IMI'ACT FEES
Jr\K A.pprovcd _J_J__
Agenda :t6m NO.1 OE
November 27, 2007
Page 5 of 10
Amount Owed
$100.59
$62.14
S::36fUg
S7:'10.00
J1.'i()J)(!
$:2,x62.0()
.'hJ)~4,OO
SA\U.(H(
$171.(,1
Sl.4J5.00
$3.5J5.00
$19,372.52
i;:i....
';."". '_- 'L"
r< ~1' "',,-
\ ;: ~;: r'n ' ,
,'i :b;;,~j , .
J
n;,!
, -G
L,:n\'
t'ch::
\ ;;.n~"', "(
)',,,'
.
Aoenda Item No 10E
T-Jovember 27,2007
Page 6 of 10
.
;'
'~"
ii'
ih:"
~;':
,,<
;c"
iC~): i:J v, j!:' V(
,.
~
Septemhcr I~. ~[l07
,; Un : Frank Ramsey
SHIP Program Coordinator
Collier County
"OJ F. Tamiami Trail
Health & CC)lTllnunil) ~tTvices L~ujJdjng
1'\oplcs, Fl ~-i 112
Rc:
lmpa,'r Fee Reimhursement
'lear : <';uik
Hahitat felI" ifLI!lldIlJi. '; ,.i' (
,
i!lt'l' (_ ('un','-. inc.. '~: rCC!Ul:':'-,lln~' n::::~T:;!Jur:;;:,rnenl
tilt, ; !l1Dac1 .. 0'- ~,Tal Progr;J,rn. rhc,-:cj('(:~:
!mp~l(:l i:":,~
'>":ert' paid :"11:' iron-; i-", j-L:ibiwl for HUITI::.mjt~\' c":- (oIlier C(lunty. inc.. in
order 1P l')\pedilC the !:ruiJdin& nrncess. ho'\\'c\'cr the fulure ov.'ners for The
property qualii~ tor an impact fee deferraL Described cL<'; f'OJ]O\\'S:
David & Nancy Licot
13363 Covenant Rd, Naples FL 34114
Permit # 2007012026
Please feel free to contact Nornla Lara (775-0036) if you have any
questions or concerns.
Sincerely,
/ '
/' ./
r<,:/L
, ,--~,
Nicolas KouJoheras
L.and Development Director
:':F<,
.,;'j,
'h"\ ",.>~
;, t~, ~ :: i) 1", ; i i:',',
Agenda Item No.1 OE
November 27, 2007
Page 7 of 10
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR1103 - Official Receipt
Trans Number
73685L...___ ...
Date
2/1/2007 11 :09:09 AM
-...------- -
Post Date . --lPaVmeiiiSli' Nbr -- ------
.?/1/20QL. .___~I'I.lQQ7()120~13__________,
Address: 13363 COVENANT RD
Owner: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY OF COA #: 05-0717
Permit Type: BR2 Job Desc: FRAMED S/F ATT 1 STY-150 AMP-TWIN VILLAS
Applicant HABITAT FOR HUMANITY-SAM
DBA:
Swr Meter: SC Wtr Meter: CC
Payor: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY OF COLLIER COUNTY INC
Fee Information
Fee Code'-j-[)escnption GL Acco-u-~- - . r--Amount : Waived
--.-~..I..._...._.-
08BCAI ' BLDG. CODE CERT. SURCHAR_Q,E:: 11300000020882000000j... .. $6.82 :
08BPNP BLDG PERMITS - NAPLES 11313890032211000000.1.::.... --$55360 i
08CPMF :c::OMM PK IMPACT FEE M/F ____.'34611636336353031346 I _ _ $750.00:
08EMMMFI EMS IMPACT FEE M/F 35014047036353031350 I $100.59,
Jl~ENIM ! EAST f'lAf'LES -FIRnMPAC_T._"'::'=J 130000()020~~20000OQ....__J ......$30Q.08J
jl8GBMF LGOVT BLDG IMAPCT FEE M/F 39012223136353031390 J- $41000 i'__d
08JLMF ! JAIL IMPACT FEE M/F 38111043036353031381 I $62.141 .,
~~t~~F ; t~~~~I:'~~~~~EE ~fF 1~~~;~;~~;~;~;;;~;~;{;~~~ ~~~~.~~ I i
08MFR4 DIST 4 ROAD IMPACT FEE-MULTI-F 336163l35636353031336__ __ $6059.00
08MFSG MICROFILM SURCHARGE 11313890034144200000 $3.00
08RDGS BLDG. PERMIT SURCHARGE 11300000020880000000 $6.82
08RPMF REG PK IMPACT FEE M/F 34611636336353031346 $1659.00
OaSCHI SCHOOL BOARD IMPACT FEE 1130000Q020905000000 $2862.00
11 PUDM PUD MONOTORING FEE 13113890432248900000' $75.00
:12SiTE S_ITE INSF'ECTION-ENGINEERING '13i-:1383273?24.9_0000()0--J=_.$1~0,Q(J _
42MTTP COUNTY METER TAP CHARGE 40825321234332000000 I $221.52
42SSDC SEWER SYSTEM CHARGE 41326361334356031413 T--~~~ ~:l51500 I
.1028- WBASCQ.Rc::.. WB-LA:DTGL.RpESYRSM.JI-TEMApCpH.AF.RE-<3EJCo. R' E'-D-I'T' -- 41127351134336031411 i_ _$~4.1.Q..OO ' ..--
11313890032251000000 I $-10000:
I
,
1
Total $20589.3.fu
- Continued -
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT
Printed:10/31/2007 439:09 PM
Aaenda Item No 10E
November 27 2CJ07
Page 8 of 10
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR 1103 - Official Receipt
. Trans Number ' Date : Post Date
-~--_..-._--_._---
I 736853 ________ I 2/1/1gQZ 1.1 :09.09 AM .. .. _l?lJ/2007
----rp;;yment Slip Nbr". ___
! PT 200701202~...
Payments
~~~e~tCOde~_}~~~j~t!Cbeck~u_m~:__~ --=-~----~-- --~-=t~ ~;=
Total Cas h
Total Non-Cash
_$.000
__$2058936
Total Paid
$~0589..36
Memo'
Cashier/location: HILLCAROL /
User: POTTER_ T
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 95fNT
Printed: 1 0/31/2007 4:39:09 PM
" 1 d
Ph. ), ~mcer5 Y,-' /-/
\'i.Hd!. //;;,>;:< < _;?'; ,.
<<'/;~;/ /;// /
" :I.> ;//-//---
,/"'c~/
Samuel-Durso. M.D.
P del \J,Jl';' n President
'" :Z\
~,;
'-.
r."1:~l;T;,Ul
rl",1vic) ;",:lsh.
E,U:-jM,} S:H
Y<'fcr ;:;(11.1-'-,0-
'\!e;..:\n,l'_'r Sp;<:-,-
.d?-;'i};(' V;a~X)5C(!tt
;>Ekc t\\:!T' r
l:,.l:'!
Agenda item NO.1 OE
November 27, 2007
Page 9 of 10
,~
t~)f
U!m"::.../rt'~ ~ h,i,
u ~_ ' _y-~;~\;~_ ~#,:
, "J:"
"irm: is. 1-1 li':,_,"Id :;"/:::',O( Ci'C'"i!1'!
ie;,:, II'
\1. ~ October 29. 2007
Attn: frank Ramsey
SHIP Program Coordinator
33i11 E. Tamiami1 rail
Naples. Flc1rida :;41 ].2
RE:
Permit #:
13363 Covenant Road, '~aples" IT _;41 : 4
2007C~ 12026
Dear Frank.
l:mpdc:r F~:'~-
HahlU:ll for Hmncmily Collie1
Deferral Prograrn. id(~nLifies tbt, abCl\(
25 a:J
b()u:~ing unit. Please let this letler S(.'TVC :lS an af~er-thc-fac.~l aT1plJcmion and
identification that an income eligible. legal rec;icicn1 (\f the \ 'nited State, wi]]
occupy [he pr(\penv once completc.
Habitat for Humanity of Collier Count)'. lnc paid tbe Impact Fees upfront in order
to expedite the building process.
.,. ~~ , '
Please feel free to contact N(\m13 Lora (775-0036) if you have any questions or
concerns.
':LH
;~m, -r ,',ni ~'..z:5l
23'1.' '~:~dK'~;\~ ' 2,.~9.-~":: , .
r'nrl H ;,;\ouhh fh, e,iT lL'!
"r\
Page 1 of 1
COLLIER COUNTY
13:JARD OF COUNT\' COMMISSIONERS
ttemNumber:
Item Summary:
lJE
(:0'rTl,' "";'10" 1~8:: ~'lt Emm:, oi c.["l,~,l' c.;:"-nrn"'''t(.'~crs c,:)C,r'~",p'~;. ,Joe! ;-]iJ:hcn~es Inr,
"""'I""',J',jr'-'(]I'i',He'l;'iIC'''',(,nl'.,-,,:n
, ;;I'(! >k.;c. J~ '';-'ir''_'''' try ,1 'lb', 'J D'
r'c;'II:"-" (\L"l;,.
011 "v,, '1,' . .,-- "~ir:'IPC i)7t;)r cl ~ ill CO' 'I ')1 , "I'"
"i!',Y2i
:,. ,"',1 i!':h)'
IC'r:n: ..r~''On''7' i ~:f ~I';"' :f'e'- ~';m.: l-,'-' ~: '1."':'" tel '~:JrI m'l1'!
e--"'"
';<iIWJ;OW,.".;
"1 \I"F' d"":ur,:i
Meeting Date:
,I.)t
I'repll.rcd By
~-~I-" r'Jm~",;
SHIi.' "r~'a,:1tl' i:o"r:Jin~Tr>r
;,<tt
"'m:,~ "''''''.' "'~
"'0'c",(,,,CI(:'i,,,,,;, 3.",'''''''''-
", '9:;;O.~,7 f' <"~'-' (:,\"
^ppruwu By
'iH" ".,-"'nl.'W,,
['''''''.!''
")"t(
",'bh:
"llprowd B~
. J~"
Approved B3
'pprH\',.d [1\
Apprn"l'd Ih
Appr'ovcd By
i~rn(.,
,;"",,:.,";UI"'W'
";''i'
oY,,,,dQ'C:",-,n!y
~'''nn>i';~.'OL''PI''-'
C:Gunl\' ','all.,qel"s ellLee
1\115:2007 ~.3& PM
file:/IC:\Agenda Test\Export\93-Novem ber'%2027. %202007\ I O.%20COUNTY%20MANA.. 11/20/2007
Aoenda Item No. 10F
f~ovembet. 27.2007
Page ~I of 1Cl
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreemeut with Jean S. Jean Noel and Marie J. Montfort
(Owners) for deferral of IOO'Yo of Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied
affordable housing unit located at Lot 5, Liberty Landing and autborizes a reimbursement
of the fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc on Building Permit
2007020743 in the amount of $12,442.52.
OBJECTIVE: That the Board of County Commissioners (Board) approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, the attached lien agreement with .Jean S. .Jean Noel and Marie.J. Montfort for
deferral of 100% of Collier County impact fees tar an owner-occupied affordable housing unit
and authorize a reimbursement of the impact fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier
County Inc. in the amountof $12,442.52.
CONSIDERA TIONS: Article IV of Chapter 74 of the Code of Laws and' Ordinances
established a program to defer impact fees for qualified affordable housing. Pursuant to this
program, an application for deferment was submitted by Jean S. .Jean Noel and Marie .J.
MontfOlt, which application, aftcr staff review, was determined to qualify for the program.
Legal status has been verificd and documents are on file at the office of Housing and Human
Services. The property is located in the Trail Ridge subdivision in Naples.
~.
During staffs review of thc file to process this defen'al for approval it was determined that the
Habitat for Humanity of Collier County lnc did not provide an application Jl1f the deferral
program as a qualified dcveloper prior to issuance of the building permit and payment of
associated impact fees as required. Staff has discussed this oversight with the County
Attorney's Office and recommends that the Board accept the application lctter from the
developer after-the- fact in order to complete the required paperwork and maintain consistency
with the Ordinance for this file and deferral agreement. Upon approval and execution of this
deferral agreement and lien, impact fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc. in
the amount of $ 12,442.52 will be rcimbursed.
The ordinance requires that a lien agreemcnt be entered into with the applicant as a condition of
deferral of the impact fees. Section 74-401(3) of the Code authorizes the County Manager to
sign deferral agreements with applicants qualifying far impact fee deferrals for affordable
housing, which has long been the practicc. The ordinance, however, gives the County Manager
discretion in whether to enter into the Agreement. Accordingly, in keeping with recent
discussion and direction by the Board, the County Attorney's Ofjice has determined that until
directed otherwise by the Board, these agreements be placed on the Consent Agenda for the
Board's review, approval and Chairman's signature.
FISCAL IMPACT: This agreement defers $12,442.52 in impact fees. Although it is expected
that the County will ultimately collect these deferred fees (generally upon the sale of the
residence), there is no guarantee as to if, or when, this would occur.
,-~"
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: The proposed Agreemenl is fully consistent with the intent
and purpose of Section 74-401 of the Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collier County.
L\q~;ndz: ITem h:c>, I'"
f\jovr::;rnber 27. 20C';
F'age .2 of
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: That the Board approves and authorizes the Chairman to
sign the attached Lien Agreement for Deferral of 100% of Collier County Impact Fees for
Owner Oceupied Affordable Housing Dwelling Units for Jean S. Jean Noel and Marie J.
Montfort located at Lot 5, Liberty Landing, Immokalee and authorizes a reimbursement of the
impact fees paid hy Habitat far Humanity of Collier County Inc on Building Permit
2007020743 in the an10unt of $11,441.51, and any budget amendments that may be required
associated to the reimbursement.
PREPARED BY: Frank Ramsey, SHIP Program Coordinator, Housing and Human Services
,.,--,
Agenda item!\J 10F
i\!:JvemDet' 27, 2007
Page, 3 sf 10
Retumto
ft'lUlk RlWl"r~
Collier Count) HH~
BOIL111milUni1rail
Naf'Ic"Fl<>rid>t34111
File# OS-031-!F
Thi"..>\c,'f"rrt-",ording
LIEI\ AGREE\iEI\T FOR DEFERRAL OF 100% OF COLLIER CO{I"TY IMI'ACl
FEES FOR OWNER OCCTP!ED AFFORDABLE HOrSING DWELLING CNITS
This A';"'Tcemem I;'> entered 1111(1 thi:.
Jay of OC10ber. ::007. hctwecn Collier Coum~. ~I
poj1tlca! subdivision or the Siah,' of Floridn IC(nJNTY'j and "Jean S Jean N(l~1 and Marie J
MontfortU (OWNER), coljecI1vel\ stated as the ..Pattlcs,"'
NO'''. THEREFORE. for good and valuable consideration. the receipt and suffiCIency of
which is. mU1~ll~ acknowledged. the Parties ah-'Tec as folJows
This Lien Agreement is made pursuam 10 Chapter 74 oftne Code ufLaws and Ordlllances of
Collier Counry, Fiorida. known as "Tite CollIer County Consolidated impact Fee Ordmam.:e"
{Ordmanc~ i In the ~vent of an~' l:Onf1ici \'dth tillS AgrecmenL Ul~ terms oi t\1..:- Ordmanc;:
shul! arpiy
The legal dcscnpwm of the dwcllmr Ullll l~ attacned as Lxhibll "/\"
';"hl' term {lfth1c Agr:.:::m:;:n; IS from tr.:: jat~ set form ahuvc until tjl'~' ImpaCl f(;(.; IS, repaid
:'nt: amoun1 or U](.; 1l1lpac: fee" uekrrcc: shul! I}..; paid W H1';.~ CUl!!;T'.' 1fj iul: UDan a In:.
3U1:: of tll:: dV...-~l1l11!; uniL bi the r::fimmcint: o~. tn:::: d\\'c!lin;.: um:, l" i (; JO~;i; of lr:l~ homestead
~x(:mptH.m; 0: :J i the flrs1 occurrenCl: (If 3n:,' ,;J.ll' (l~' twm:;:; of ,11l\ part of the affected r::Di
propef1\, ana m am suel1 t':\'en1 tn:: deferred Impact f::es shulJ be paid m full w tnc COU:~-:'\,
not later then the closmg of the salt:. or not iater then th(~ cffcci1\e date of the transfer. As se1
forth in Exhibl1 .'13." the amount or tht.: deicrrcd lmpacl fees l~ l\velve Tl10usand Four
Hundred Fort\' Two and S~100 Do]jar~, (SI2A4~51lRcpavmem shall include any accrued
mterest. intere:;[ shall bl' computed at the rat;,:~ of five percen1 (SU,!}) pt:r annum. but ifl no
event shall it exce~d tv,'cnt\~f1v(; percent (::.'.5(~()) of the towl fee amoum
:'i The deferred Impact fees shall he a [len on the prop':rt:' descrihed in ExhibIt "A.u which lien
may be foreclosed upon 111 the event of nOIl~comphanct' \\ilh the Ordinance or wlth thJ:i
A.=,rrcernenr, This A!:-rreemcllt shall operate as <I hen agalflst the dv,"clIlllg UTIlt Tht: lien shall
term mate upon the recording of a re\case or satlsfactton of lien In the public records or th..:
County The dcferrais of impact fees and this Agreement shall run wnh th,.: iand, and nenher
the deferred Impact fee:: nor tl1]S Agreement shall b~ transferred. assl!,!lled. or otherwise
conveyed Except U5 prov1ded \1\ law, reg:ardiess of an~' foreclosure on to.: first mort);age or
other secunty mterest thl~ lien shall otherWise he supcnor and paramount to the mteres1 in
the dwelling unit of any o\.....I1CL ICSSCl', tenant mortgagee, or other person, e:xcct:l1 that thlS
lien shall he on panty \vith am lien for County t(;lX~S
f., Upon the satlslactory eomrktwn oj thlS Agreement's requm,::ment5. COUNTY shall record
an>' necessarv aocumentatlon evidencing- sam::::
7 In the event the Ov..'NER is in default under the Ordmance or thIS Ag:rc~ment. and the default
IS not curt:d \vnhin 30 da\'S attcr \vntten notice is proviaed to the OWNER, the COUNTY
'c~n-"I'-C' ,,' ~r,
'~'~'._l .....,> t';;::;,~; I \j',-, , ,v
r\jovemDe~- 27, 2' C
L1 0 1
ma\. m m sole oplHm. collect the Impact tet: amOUnl m J::faull :J\ s~t forth In the ('irJmancc.
OT hfln~ a t;1\i! actIon tn enf(lfCe Inn, /\~TccmenL N declare that In~ deferrce impact fees arc
then in ddault and immediately due and payable The COUI\:TY shall he entitled to recover
all ii.::::s and cosls. meluu\ng atlornc~-:, 1\::.' and CO';\:, lllClIlTc,-: by the COUK;'Y 1ll enforcmg
tim Agreement. plus Interest ul the then maximum statulo0 rail' for 1udgments calculated on
a calendar year hasl;'; until paid
S This Agreement is the soil' ak'Tci;;':nlCnl between the panics wnh respect 10 the suhJect maul',)
herem. and shall he.. hllldltl~ upon the O\\'NER'S smTt'ssors and assigns In interest
Q ThIS Agreement shaH ne recorded In the ofilcml records or the Count\' 31 no cost Hi the
COU]'\.'lY
1)\' VdTNESS ","'HEREOF. the Pamcs have executed thlS Agreemenr on the date and :.'ear first
aoove \\Tltlen
/\ttesl
D\\'lGHT,[ BROCk_ Clerk
HOARD OF COl't-:TY COMMISSIONERS
COU,lFR C()Ut-\TY. FLORIDA
15\"
[3:
LkpUT\' Clerk
JAM2S ('(')1...[;1'/\_ ('11AIRM/\~~
OW~:ER
'v.nn<...~sc"
......',-
., --. '
L_J!'-"'--..'_~~_
:ie;;'l~ ~'. .ica,l.f1~oc!
hiam~>
~', -------.- --- ----
()\VNER
\'A/lmesSC5
___._.__~> __________._______ _____'_____n____'-__
Pnnt."t...;ame ______0______. _____._______
-Mane J. Momfort
STATE OF FLORIDA,
COUNTY OF ('OI.LJER,
~' ~r ..w..'.~ oj I', '
~""'...:_..~---'::"__'='-:'_.
or has produ(oeJ
Tile forel!oInL': ;\ureemCnl was acknowicd!!cd before mt' tlllS , day oj
2007. b~___~ ~:~~_~lJ~_J4\)1\.~ i~ pcrsonaliy t..'-;~~---tl1 me
_____ _____________ _____on _ _~ a~-; p;oof of" idcntlt~.
( (
1\ ii\bJ;! vJ~~
sfin-atiSofj);rs~~~ l'aki~g Ackn~~'kdgme~l
[NOTARIAL SF.A!.]
\"~
.,".W. \""'I'j\\''':;ir","[)D,"~"".t:
~,~_~' .;-;,I'I'I~;:.~'~,:~;:'~,~::"i:,,, ,~
Approv:::4as ~..............._r,,^~"""'--
and h:l!al~~uffi,.idt\,;)'~_."
~ : ,,"'c1""~~.
q/' I'
_L':"'~___
.iethe~ A. KJat:;J,o\\
Chief A~,siStant COUl1l\ i\t10rn'~'.',
I .
Recommend ^PlDrovul
~.( -' --;-:. --
. ~1\1arcy krurnbmc, 1M P A
DlrcclOr
Collier County Housll1g and Humun ServlCes
,
\
EXlIIBIT "A"
LEGAL DESCRIPTIO"
Lot 5. Lioerty Landing. according to the piat thereof.
as recorded in Plat Book 47. Pages 71 through 73.
inclusive. of the Public Records of Collier County. Florida.
EXHIBIT "II"
IMPACT FEE IIREAKIlOW!\
Type of 1 m pact Fee
A. EMS Impact Fcc
B Correctional Faciiiw:s Impact Fee
C Librar:.' Impact Fee
D Communit\ Parks Impaci Fee
E Rqporw! Parl~:, Impuct re~:
r: F:ducallOnal Facili1l0~; Svsrcm Imp;:Jct h:::
,.1 r'(oad Impa:::l T'c~:
H CIO\'crOITJenl huilolDt!s impact Y'ce
L,l\\ Eniorccmcm impact Fe;>
nn At IMPACT FEES
i.'\f:i\l'r,"n',!~.__
Amount Owed
$100>9
562. J~
S368. 18
575UOU
$1.65{),()(I
$:U~6::.0n
SC,.U5Q,II(1
):;4I(1()(i
$1'71 bi
S12.4~:.5:!
Agenda item No.1 0
r\lovemoer 27: 1 0
Page 5 0
..-
.
.
L,Qsn'J2 IH::li': I'Jc.
Y.\jO\12iT:DEY 27, 2CJ
::;'8;12 fi 0:
Seplemher ~< ~007
Ann: Frank Ramsc)
SHIP Program Coordinmor
Collier COllnt\
330] E. Tamiami Trail
Health & Community Services Building
Naples. FL 3411 ~
Re:
impact FCl' Reimbursement
Deaf hemI::
Hahitat for Humanil) (If Collier Count). Inc.. i~ requesting reimhurs~mel1t
f(lf impact fees paid through tnE' Imracl i. ec Deferral Program. Th:'::5Ic fees
were paid up 11'on, h\ Hahita, felf HumaniTY of Collicr Count\. Inc.. in
order lei ex;x:'C.iitc the budding prOCCS5. howeve:- the future tyv,-ncrs l()r the
property quaiif\ i'or an llllj:1JCl !'ee ucl'erraL Dcscrihcd as follc)\\'s:
.Jean S. .Jean !\oel & Marie .1. Montfort
3536 Liberty Way Immokalee FL
Permit # 2007020743
Please feci free to contact Norma Lora (77'i-0036) if you have any
questions or concenlS,
Sincerely.
".Jicolas !.:ouloheras
Land Development Director
f,genda Ilern 1'0. 10
i\!overnoer .27. 200
P8a~) -: of 1
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR1103 - Official Receipt
=---
l Trans Number
748740
Date .... _
3/27/2007 221:40 PM
I Payment Slip Nbr
I PT 20070207 4~__
]:fost Date
3/27/2007
-~
Address: 3536 LIBERTY WAY
Owner: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY COA#: 06-0220
Permit Type: BR2 Job Desc: FRAMED S/F ATT 1 STY-150 AMP-TWIN VILLAS
Applicant: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY-SAM
DBA
Swr Meter: IMM Wtr Meter: IMM
Payor: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY OF COLLIER COUNTY INC
Fee Information
! Fee Code Descri tion ... _____.
08BCAI BLDG. CODE CERT SURCHARGE
; 08BPIM BLDG PERMIT
i08CPMF COMM PK IMP
108EMMMF EMS IMPACT F
!08GBMF- GOVT SI..DG 1M
1----..- --.--
I 081!J1FF _ IMMOKALl"sF
'08JLMF J,AILJMPACT F
08LBMF L1BRAR'y-'Mf''''--
08LWMF LAW ENF IMPA
08MFR5 DIST 5 ROAD I
08MFSG MIC_ROFILM SURCHARGE ' 11313890034144200000
08RDGS BLD~ PERMIT SUl3gHAR(~L_ . 11300000020880000000
08RPMF REG PK IMPACT FEE M/F __L~4~11636336353..0_31.3..~6_
: 08SCHI SCHOOL BOARD tMPACT FEE . 11300000020905.900000 I
J lPUDrIil PUD MOi'JQIORING FEE 13113890432248900000
i_12SITE . SITE INSPECTION-ENGINEERING ..1311383273224!1000000
I 08BACB-LB_LDG. PERMIT AP.F". FEE CREDIT 113138900322!>,1 000000
Total
, .82
--.... --..--- ,
S - IMMOKALEE ! 11313890032212000000 , $553.60 ,
ACT FEE M/F _=R.46116363~353031346 r~OPi
EE M/F ,35014047036353031350 ___ $100.59 i
APCT FEE M/F 139012223136353031390 _ _$4100lL
IRE IMPACT ! 11300000020985000000 . $1514.04 --.. . --
EE M/F 38111043036353031381 ,$62.14 ___ _ I
CT F_Ei:: M/F "i_35515619036353031355 I $368.18 I
CT FEE M/F 38511043336353031385 $171.61...'__ I
..--_....._.-~....i
MP ACT FEE-MU L TI-F~ 3391636593635.3031339 $6059.00 .
,
_.-.li3L Account
11300000020882000000
Amount I Waived
$6 ~
$3.00 I
$6.82
$1659.00
$28B2.00
$75.00 I
$150.0~
$-100.00
$14651.80,
-l
- Continued -
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT
Printed:11/1/2007 8:21:10 AM
,L\C1er:ca IrS!:i I'~c 1:J
f'Jcwember 27 20D
Pags Ci o~ 1
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR1103 - Official Receipt
I Post Date
3/27/2007
Trans Number
1748740
I [)ate
,3/27/20072:21 AOJ:rv1
___--j... . Payment Slip Nbr
PT 2007020743
Payments
Amount,
$14651.80 i
1 Payment Code
LGHECK
Account/Check Number
13591
Total Cash
Total Non-Cash
$0.00
$14651.80.
$14651.80 i
. Total Paid
Memo:
Cashier/location: HILLCAROL / 1
User: POTTER_ T
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD. Plus for Windows 95/NT
Printed:11/1/2007 8:21:10 AM
..<\genda Item l\io. 10
I'\!OVemn8'- 27. 200
Page 9 of 1
t'-
'.
Octoher 29. 2007
Attn: Frank Ramsey
SHIP Program Coordinator
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples. Florida 34112
RE:
PerInil #:
3536 Liheny Way. Immokalee. FI. 34142
2007020743
Dcar Frank.
Haoitat j~Jr Humanity of Collier County. lne. per tbe Count, Wide impact Fce
Deferral ProgranL identii-ies the ahove referenced property as an afforciahlc
housing unit. Please let this letter serve as an aftcr-tk-faet application and
identificmion that an income digihk. legal re::;idC'11I urihe l'niled Stmt~;: will
occupy the property once complete.
Habitat i{1[ Humanity of Collier County, Ine paid the Impact Fees uphont in order
to expedite the building process.
Please feel free to contact Norma l.ora (775-0036) ifvou have any questions or
concerns.
Sincerely,
/
~
.., -"SamuerOurso. M.D.
President
l'a!,Cc ] of
;""
:!O' j,:c,;
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD C," COUNT,~ ~OMMISSIONEP.~.
Item Number:
Item$ummary:
,Xd11 C)'W"I "if)'1i,'[,
21 (J ,',J:Il',r,?~
['.'1(1 '" ~io.t i>,-, 'H;;
)1"'U:,"',]2t."
(TH' L:
~T' :l'.n!" 17""
'''IJ',J' "P' I '1f T~ tH<' >'il'C' ~l\
:n,JII\
'",:1::1:"
rn I: . ~
;'1":':::',11":"", <)"10<';'lto'
Meeting Date:
~y
!'rrpllrtd By
~r"nh k,ms(;\.
::;fl,nr""ur3r ~JJof{lm"'("
I._,ll<
r'unli:;c,,'rv,c,,"
~-i"""In,,"ml Hum,mScrv"',-'"
';I,i:20Q7 8,~::,38 A~i
Approvr(] II)
(1,,-,ell-\rumb,n'.
n'reeD'
DJl<
Pulll" St',v,c~,;
f-Wl.'Slnpli.h"rnanSc'\'la,,;
11.',',/20,,; 11JJ"AM
Approved By
,IPlIKIJtZ",C'"
AS5["t~nt C,,,,,,,,' AltomS';
D""
;.""Tll', i,p()Cfl'
i"jI(,rf1C -";,r
, 1 r,!i2[Jr-:" - 5'< p~:
Apllruved By
"'"
"Ui :;c' ,~t;_.",,-, ,,."''-',",,,,,,,',',)
,J"
h..Jf'"
:'.2('0~ "_[\~ r,'.
Approved B~
,:\.,
(,l;
'I:"
''''',''n,,;;()'
',.1;}li:"
pr,
Allpruved lh
I: ~
"i.:"" ",-.,.,,,.., ''''''<1~'
Allpruved U,
r;.~n2"(
;".'"
,un'
'j'",,,, r,'.""aOH (,)filC'
~ 1 '15:20(i~ 4.; r>l/
tile://C: \AgendaT est\Expol1\93- Novcmher%202 7,'%202007\ 1 0_ %LWCOUNTY%20MANA.. 11/20/2007
Aoenaa It8m No. -: OG
'Novemoer 27.2007
F'399 1 of 10
~",...,
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with Clairicia Achille (Owner) for deferral of 100% of
Collier Connty impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable housing unit located at Lot
7, Liberty Landing and authorizes a reimbursement of the fees paid by Habitat for
Humanity of Collier County Inc on Building Permit 2007020740 in the amount of
$12,442.52,
OBJECTIVE: That the Board of County Commissioners (Board) approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, the attached lien agreement with Clairicia Achille for deferral of 100% of
Collier County impaet fees for an owner-occupied affordable housing unit and authorize a
reimbursement of the impact fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc. in the
amount of $12,442.52.
CONSIDERATIONS: Artiele IV of Chapter 74 of the Code of Laws and Ordinances
established a program to defer impact fees for qualified affordable housing. Pursuant to this
program, an application for deferment was submitted by Clairicia Achille, which application,
after staff review, was determined to qualify for thc program. Legal status has been verified and
documents are on file at the office of Housing and Human Services. The property is located in
the Liberty Landing subdivision in I mmokalee.
.,-
During staffs review of the file to process this deferral for approval it was detennined that the
Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc did not provide an application for the deferral
program as a qualified developer prior to issuance of the building pem1it and payment of
associated impaet fees as required. Staff has discussed this oversight with the County
Attorney's Office and recommends that the Board aecept the application letter from the
developer after-the-fact in order to complete the required papef\\ork and maintain consistency
with the Ordinance for this file and deferral agreement. Upon approval and execution of this
deferral agreement and lien, impact fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc. in
the amount of$12,442.52 will be reimbursed.
The ordinance requires that a lien agreement be entered into with the applicant as a condition of
deferral of the impact fees. Section 74-40](3) of the Code authorizes the County Manager to
sign deferral agreements with applicants qualifying for impact fee deferrals for affordable
housing, which has long been the practice. The ordinance, however, gives the County Manager
discretion in whether to enter into the Agreement. Accordingly, in keeping with recent
discussion and direction by the Board, the County Attorney's Office has deternlined that until
directed othef\\ise by the Board, these agreements be placed on the Consent Agenda for the
Board's review, approval and Chairman's signature.
FISCAL IMPACT: This agreement defers $12.442.52 in impact fees. Although it is expected
that the County will ultimately collect these deferred fees (generally upon the sale of the
residence), there is no guarantee as to if, or when, this would occur.
,--
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: The proposed Agreement is fully consistent with the intent
and purpose of Section 74-401 of the Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collier County.
A::jenda ilem r'-.J~> 1(}3
'November 27, 2007
Paos 2 of;()
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: That the Board approves and authorizes the Chairman to
sign the attached Lien Agreement for Deferral of 100% of Collier County Impact Fees for
Owner Occupied Affordable Housing Dwelling Units for Clairicia Achille located at Lot 7,
Liberty Landing, Immokalec and authorizes a reimbursement of the impact fees paid by Habitat
for Humanity of Collier County lne on Building Pemlit 2007020740 in the amount of
$12,442.52. and any budget amendments that may be required associated to the reimbursement.
PREPARED BY: Frank Ramsey. SHIP Program Coordinator. Housing and Human Services
keluml"
i\aenca item 1,,0.1 OG
'Novemoer 27, 2pC7
Page 3 0 ' 10
J nlllk Rllm~~,'
(oilier COl1nt~ HHS
33Ul E. lamiami Trail
N"pl"" Fln.-j,IIIJ4IlZ
File# 08-029-rF
Thi\ """'.. f"rn""nnhnl,:
LIEN AGREEMENT f'OR UEFERRAL OF 100% OF COLLIER COrNTY IMI'ACT
FEES FOR O\V"iER OCClJPIED AFFORDABLE HOI'SING DWELLING I!NITS
ThIS Agreement is entered Into this ~~ day of October, :2007. between Coll1cr County_ u
polItical subdiVISIon of the: State of Florida (COUNTYj and ..Clairicia Achille" (OVvl\TER).
collectively stated as the "Parties,"
NO\\', THEREFORE, for good and valuable consideratlOTL the receipt and sufllciency of
\-\'hich 15 mutually ackno\""lcdgt:d, the Parties agree as follows
TIllS LIen A~n:emcm is made pursuant to Chapler 74 of the Code of Laws and Ordmances of
Collier County. Florida. known a~ "The Collier County Consolidated Impacl Fcc Ordinance"
fOrdmuncc) In the event of any conflict \\'ilh thIS Agreement th:: terms of the Ordinance
shall appi:--
The legui deSCription oftht', dwe]jinf..~ unit IS attached as E:~hibJ1 "/\"
Tne lerm orIh1S A!-!TCcmcnt I:: from th(' date se: fonh above untli Ihe lmpact fC('IS n:paJc
- Ti\~ amount 0, tl1'':: 101oa;:1 Je::.'.', deferred shall lx; paid til the COUt~--;'\' In fuL upon a,l tne
sal:: ofthc dwdiing unit: hi the refmanclI1g of the dwelllnh' unn. Ci ~~ loss oftn:.: homestead
exemption; or J) the first occurrence of any sale or tran~;fer or <.Jny pUrl of the affected real
propen\ and 1fl all:,:' such e":111 the deferred Jlnpact fees shalJ be paid in full to the COUNTY
not later then tn:: cioslO); or the :;aie_ or not later then the dTcClivc date of the transfer As.set
forth in Exhibit "8.-' the amount of the deferred nnpac1 fees is Twelve Thou~and Four
Hundred Fom- TV.io and 52ilOO Dollars ($12.442.S:n Repayment shalllllclude any accrued
IIltcrcst Interest shall be computed at the rate of five percent 150.01 per annum. bUI In no
event shalllt exceed rn-'entv-t1vc percent (25(\\1 of the total fee amount
:' The deferred rmpacl fce~ shall be a hen on the property described ill Exhibit .. A." which lien
may be foreclosed upon In the event of non-compliance \.\'lth the Ordinance or with this
Agreement This Agreement shall operate as a lien agamst the dwelling unit The hen shall
tenninate upon the recording or a release or satIsfaction of lien in the puhlic records of the
Counl~ The deferrals oflmpacl fees and thIS Ap:rcement shall run \'\'Jth the land, and neither
the dderred Impact fee~ nor this Agreement shaD be transferred, assigned. or otherwise
conveyed. Except as prOVIded hy law, n:gardlt:ss of an;.-' foreclosure on the first mongage or
other sccunty InteresL tfllS hen shall othe:nvlse be supeno! and paramount 10 the interest in
the dwelling unit of any owner, lessee. tenant. mongagec or other person. except that this
hen shall be on parity with any lien for County taxes
o Upon the satisfactory completion of thIS Agreement's requIrements. COUNT")' shall re~ord
an\' necessary documentaTIon eVldencmg same.
7 In the event the O\\'NER is In default w1der the Ordinance or this Agreement and the default
IS not cured wlthin 30 days aher \\Tltten notlce, is provided to the OV.!l"ltR, the COUNTY
",C"- I'" 10'
"~' , , "'~.:' '':) ["f'':'
.. +~
..:! 0' "
may. at ItS sole optIOn. collect the Impact fee amount 111 defaul! as set fonh In tile Urdmance.
or hnrlf:! ;i cIvil actIon lr1 enforce tim Agreement or dec]ar~~ that tile defenee Impact fees are
then in default and Immedlatel:- due and pu~'ahlc The COl.r~'T\' shall be cnntled 10 recover
all ices and costs. mc1udm,g atlorncy-s fee and cosh. mcuned h\' the COUl\"T'( In enforcing
thIs Ag-rcemen!, plus Interest al the then maximum statuto~ rate rOT ludgments calculated on
a calendar year nasi", until paid
~ TillS Af,.'Teemem ]s the soie ag-reemenl hctween the pames v.ith respect to the suh.icc1 maner
nerelll. ilno shall be DwdInE:: upon the ()'0/NER'S successors and asslbTfls III Imeresl
9 ThIS Agreement shan he rcrowed in the offlciul records of the County al no cost to the
COUNTY
IN 'VIT~'ESS \\'HEREOF, th~ Pames have executed thIS Agreement on the date and vear ftrsl
ahp\T \\TlDen
Anest
D\,VlCil [1' F I1ROCk Clerk
BOld\[) Of- COL'NTY COMMISSIOl-iEl':S
COLLIER CUtlN']"Y. f'"LORIDi\
h\
k\
_ Deput\ C)!:'rk
.I:\MF~ C(lLFTTA, C."H/\l Rt-.'1A h'
O\\-~ER
Vv'Itnesscs
~:-"~.
!~nn: Nam:.:
(,iame:,:
UW~>JER
\\'nncsses
..J. ',U:-IT'l', l._._ ~~~ ..i1 -{-({-______~_____
))n nt Nam'.:_l-),,?"~~-U':"_!...c___l:L--,~!J.:,:_j_--,-~__
STA TL OF !'LORID/. i
COUNTY OF COLLIER)
The foregol11g Agreemcm was aci..:nowJcdgcd before me this .~~_ dav of ~~ t...- ,__ .
:007, by ,'.!.-.'1 whp 1S personal iy kno\\,n to me or has produced
______ as proof of idcntJt:
[NOTARIAL SEAL
/""","", VIRGINIA CANTU
~ WI CO'>lMtSSION ~ nOS'WI2S
'\'.;"',,/ CXPlRES,~I2.201O
',"",,"'_N()l'AP" n ~'o.-_Q,.
_..~_..~...e__"":"______ ~,~_'~".'..~~ ___
Slgnaturt' of Person 'raklng Ackno\'.,:lt:dgmcnt
Approved as t fonn
and I~~ :~llfi~
'--""-;."
---:._-_.~.\--~~~
.ldI'rcv A-KlatzIW\\
Chlef".'-\ssistantt'ount\ Attorni;'\
I .
.
Re~ommend A~prova]'
I
I
L~_~.J,
-'..-.:,-- -- -~---_._----
--Marcy krumt1fnc. 1\11' i\
Dlrcclur
Coll!('r COUnT\ Housin~ and Human Service:,
_..-
EXHIBIT "A"
LEGAL IlESCRII'T!ON
Lot 7. Liherty L.anding. according to the plat thereof,
as recorded in Plat BOOk 47. Pages 71 through 73.
in(,:iusi\'c. of the Puhlic Records of Collier Count:,"'. Florida.
EXHIBIT "II"
IMPACT FEE BREAKIlOW1\
T~'pe oflmpact Fee
A EMS Impact Fee
B. Correctional FacilitIes Impact Fee
C Libraf';" Impact fee
D Commumty Parb impact h::t
L RegIOnal Park:- Impact Fee
t~ !:ducallonal hlCilllic> S.\-sr:.:m lmnac1 Fec
G Road lmuJ.ct h:e
H Ciovemmenl buildmg:; ImnaC'l ~ee
La\\, I::ni"orcemem impact h:e
TOTAL IMPACT FEE~
':/-!.i1f'f"<lIC:
Amount Owed
S 100.59
$62.14
$368 18
S75CJ,O(i
S,1.654[)U
S~.g62.0n
So.USO.O(i
~~41Cl(li'
S17Uli
S J :'.4~1.52
.';gend2 !Tem ~.JD.i 1 DC;
I'~ovember 27.2007
Page 5 of if:
.
.
,L,;J9n02 lIen-I lye 1 D3
f'Kwe:T!De: 27', 2007
f. of lei
""";0.,;;."
August 17,2007
Attn: Frank Ramsc\
SHIP Program Coordinator
Collier Coum\
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Heal1h &. Community Services Building
Naples, FL 34112
Rc..
,.
Impact Fee Reimbursement
Dear Frank:
liahiwt I()! Hun1anit) ofCnllicr Count:_ incH is requesting reinlbursen1~m
fo:' impact fees paid through the Impact Feo;:.' Deferral Program. These fees
were paid up front b\ Habitat ior Humanit\ orCollier Countv.lne.. in
ordcr to ~xpedile the building proc~ss. howevcr the ruture owners for th~
piopcny qualif~ for an impact rce defcrr:.tl. Described as foll()\vs:
Clairicia Achille
3544 Liherty Way, Immokalee FL 34142
Permit # 2007020740
Please reel free to comact NOIma Lora (77:'-0036) if you have any
questions or conCCmS.
Sincerely.
Samuel Durso. M. [)
Presidel11
A'Js:'wc item i'~G, 'i(}S
"f'\C'lV8iTlbe' 27 20G7
,_J' c'
- Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR1103 - Official Receipt
I
ITrans J'tumber ---- -~---- u,
i Date l Post Date . Payment Slip Nbr
! 3/27/2007222:40 PM - -~- I
748743 PT 2007020740
--------- ... ;,/2J/2007
,
I
Address: 3544 LIBERTY WAY
Owner: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY COA #: 06-0220
Permit Type: BR2 Job Desc: FRAMED S/F ATT 1 STY-150 AMP-TWIN VILLAS
Applicant HABITAT FOR HUMANITY-SAM
DBA:
Swr Meter: IMM WtrMeter: IMM
Payor' HABITAT FOR HUMANITY OF COLLIER COUNTY INC
Fee Information
-. __n - --- ! Amourit~Walvedl
~.code Description - ' GL Account
i 08BCAI BLDG.CODE CERT SURCHARGE 11300000020882000000 i $6.82 ! ---.!
i
108BPIM BLDG PERMITS - IMMOKALEE . _J1313899Q}2212000000 1 $553.60 !
08CPMF..jCOMM PK IMPACT FEE M/F_ 34611636336353031346 I $750.00 .-
-
! 08EMMMElEMS IMPACT FEE M/F _..__ 35014047036353031350 $100.59
.--.
! 08GBMF ! GOVT BLDG IMAPCT FEEMlF ------- 39012223136353031390 $410.00
I 081MFF - $1i~f~H- _.._~
i IMMOKALEE FIRE IMPACT 11300000020985000000 I
, 08JLMF 1 JAIL IMPACT FEE M/F 38111043036353031381 ---~
-
08LBMF I LIBRARY IMPACT FEE M/F 35515619036353031355 1----- $368181
08LWMF LAW ENF IMPACT FEE M/F -- :38511043336353031385 . f-$~~~~~~ 1---
~FR5 DIST 5 ROAD IMPACT FEE-MUL TI-F 133916365936353031339
08MFSG MICROFILM SURCHARGE - I 11313890034144~00000 ,$300~__
, 08RDGS IBLDG-PERMIT SURCHARGE 11300000020880000000 i $6.82 i
I 08RPMF I REG PK IMPACT FEE M/F !34611636336353031346 $1659.00 i
108SCHI . SCHOOL BOARD IMPACT FEE ' 11300000020905000000 $2862.00 I
I ----...
11PUDM I PUD MONOTORING FEE i 13113890432248900000 $75.00 I i
12.SITE-'SITE INSPECTiON-ENGli{EERING---;- 13113832732249000000 -~---------------------- - - I
L-_t1~000 i------.J
1_08BACR 1 BLDG. PERMIT APP. FEE CREDIT ,11313890032251000000 ......l----d~~~~~~ _I
Total
. Continued -
__rn~,
Collier County Board of County Commissioners Printed:11/1/2007 8:23:28 AM
CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT
i:.,qendc i~em I'~o" 10,:::
'NoVember" 27. 2007
F'2ge b of -: (",
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR1103 - Official Receipt
Trans Number
748743
i Date~Dst Date
i 3/27/2007 2:2240PM 3/27!?SJOl_
P?yment Slip Nbr
PT 2007020740
-----._-
Payments
Payment CDde .
CHECK
AccDunt/Check Number
13591
. "E AmDunt:
__ $14651.80
T DIal Cash r $0 00'
TDlal NDn-Cash j'-$14651jQJ
TDtal Paid $1465180 I
MemD:
Cashier/IDcatIDn: HILLCAROL / 1
User: POTTER_ T
CDllier CDunty BDard Df County CDmmissiDners
CD-Plus for WindDws 95/NT
Printed:11/1/2007 8:23:28 AM
Aoenaa Item i\Je.. '1 DC;
-1~\jovemDer '27, 2007
Flage 9 of 10
"71'
t., ""'~',
<n'p;, .,;;,
October 29. 2007
Attn: Frank Ramsey
SHIP Program Coordinator
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples. Florida 34] 12
R.E:
Permit #:
3544 Liberty Way. Immokalee. FL 34 I 42
2007020740
Dear Frank.
Habitat 1,"' Humani!, oCColiicr Count,. Inc. pe,' the COUnT' Wide Impact Fcc
Deferral Program. idemii1es the above referenced propel1\ as an ailordabk
housing unit. Please let this letter serve as an aJler-thc-faet application and
identification that an income eligible. legal resident ,.fthe 1 enited States will
occupy the propeny once complete.
Habitat ielr Humanity of Collier County, Inc paid the Impact Fees up front in order
to expedite the building process.
Please feci free to contact Norma Lara (775-0036) if you have any questions or
concerns.
Sincere!)::..
/'
,;1" _...".
"
,/./",e ~
/ /.,
" .;.<C /.~ / /./ _____-
~/ ,..r_'._".'';:'--''~'
-' Sanlucl Durso. M.D.
President
;.IF
~.-! h~'; ,cr"'
Pa!!c 1 or 1
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF cour~TY COMMISSIONERS
Item Number:
Item Summary:
.. 11,'I".8;;t,0', \"',tJT m' ~;Vl
,('''11', "Yrlrll''''
"-',u",'
,;u n.~r:~l" 1'1'
:,"1;" 1lli.r1 SI(1";
:,'H<eenH,,; 1 \',t" (;Idlr.~.:c: ,".c"H'
". ,. OPI," d I ~-' i C:'CI" ,
,..':."';'
.,)' <1' (l'.'.-I"" V::'l'~IL'(I :il r;'TJlJI,
- ^ ;.-" C' ~j '"
. an,j!'1(] -.]1".(1 d'J" 'YI~e', ? 'e'rTTl' ""rr.e'lt 0' I'v.' I"~'- ::>(0:(1 r, c-j.1[-; '" in' "11.."-f1'-I~IIV T
"r:, I' , 'r I.. :J n 1 '-,",;r (:f ,. ~::: 4:
Meeting Dille:
Prepared By
.-r"'",, "'~m~'.'
Sd'"' i-'r""rJn, '_""WlrWl'"
I"'"
h,bll,-S"rv:ce"
H01""IO ~nd h"m~" ::'er,l(.u-'
l",'"wn7C:(";,2(iAri
Approved By
~/;,1r~V f',rumhlnc
li"C~I,"
Ij~1(
PUbllcSNVlce<:
I-I"'--'$rnn & hUITlJn Service-:
l'-''':20071110Ar,'
Approved H~'
.ieft Klal2.kow
"S51~lJf1t COUllt\' t;t!<1rnE<\
U,11'
(;oumy:,aorne\
COWl!\, Atlom"\' OffiCE<
11IS"2[),,74 [)2 Pri
Approved H~'
r.::" ","",,,,,,,,
hJl;i'~ :o.',crvw, .; ,,",orn"'1 ,:r~tr
~"'!'.
"'(,v; Y;n'''~''
f-'ul"--
',;""""
".;;20
hl.C
Appruvl'd H)
"","'" On' "";",,,,'
So,..",
1t"";"'~11'" -icu"",I(,"
i~:20:',-'
Approved H)
"il"." ., r:"vn
1'.':,on~f1 '111~"~ :; 1:<"""',1 ,",Ii,cr'.".'
'Oll"!" "";,,.;;,,~' (lhc'
rU'11I'''''J'''W,nl ;',,'''''
" '~,) - I~:C\', "I
.-\pproHd H~
.I~m~:~
""',"r',)'i~
,Je'
"')M(1" U_JU'r:....
Comm'55wn",p
CUll"''';',
'. ClUe<'
I :11~i2C07 S<, 1 cj ;,1.'
tile:lIC:\Ap.enda']'est\Export\93- Novemher%202 7.%202007\ I O. %20COUNrY%20MAN A., 11/20/2007
.i\aenJa item No.1 (jH
'f,jcvembe!. 27.2007
Page 1 of 10
EXECl!TlVE SUMMARY
Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with Monica Martinez (Owner) for deferral of 100%
of Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable housing uuit located at
Lot 14, Trail Ridge aud authorizes a reimbursement of the fees paid by Habitat for
Humanity of Collier County Ine on Building Permit 2006064365 in the amount of
$13,616.20.
OBJECTIVE: That the Board of County Commissioners (Board) approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, the attached lien agreement with Monica Martinez for deferral of 100% of
Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable housing unit and authorize a
reimbursement of the impact fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc. in the
amount of $13,6 16.20.
CONSIDERATIONS: Article IV of Chapter 74 of the Code of Laws and Ordinances
established a program to defer impact fees for qualified affordable housing. Pursuant to this
program, an application for deferment was submitted by Monica Martinez, which application,
after staff review, was determined to qualify for the program. Legal status has been verified and
documents are on file at the office of Housing and Human Services. The property is located in
the Trail Ridge subdivision in Naples.
During staff's review of the file to process this deferral for approval it was determined that the
Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc did not provide an application for the defeITal
program as a qualified developer prior to issuance of the building permit and payment of
associated impact fees as required. Staff has discussed this oversight with the County
Attorney's Office and recommends that the Board accept the application letter from the
developer after-the-fact in order to complete the required paperwork and maintain consistency
with the Ordinance for this file and deferral agreement. Upon approval and execution of this
deferral agreement and lien, impact fecs paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County 1nc. in
the amount of $13,616.20 will be reimbursed.
The ordinance requires that a lien agreement be entered into with the applicant as a condition of
deferral of the impact fces. Section 74-401(3) of the Code authorizes the County Manager to
sign deferral agreements with applicants qualifying for impact fee deferrals for affordable
housing, which has long been thc practice. The ordinance, however, gives the County Manager
discretion in whether to enter into the Agreement. Accordingly, in keeping with recent
discussion and direction by the Board, the County Attorney's Office has determined that unlil
directed otberwise by the Board, these agreements be placed on the Consent Agenda for the
Board's review, approval and Chairman's signature.
FISCAL IMPACT: This agreement defers $13,616.20 in impact fees. Although it is expected
that thc County will ultimately collect these deferred fees (generally upon the sale of the
residence), there is no guarantee as to if, or when, this would occur.
,-
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: The proposed Agreement is fully consistent with the intent
and purpose of Section 74-401 ofthe Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collier County.
;'~,;I-?nj? iTem ~w. i Or.
i\ovembet' 27, 2007
P89S 2 of 10
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: That the Board approves and authorizes the Chairman to
sign the attached Lien Agreement for Deferral of 100% of Collier County Impact Fees for
Owner Occupied Affordable Housing Dwelling Units for Monica Martinez located at Lot 14,
Trail Ridge, Naples and authorizes a reimbursement of the impact fees paid by Habitat for
Humanity of Collier County Inc on Building Permit 2006064365 in the amount of $13,616.20,
and any budget amendments that may be required associated to the reimbursement.
PREPARED BY: Frank Ramsey, SHIP Program Coordinator, Housing and Human Services
.' .,~
l~Ctlll'lILO
,Li,qenda Item NO.1 OH
'November 27. 2007
Pa983 of 10
Frail!.: RIlRl~r.\
(:lIlli~t C('lInt\'IIiIS
J3UJ L.'I HRli:lI11;"I rllil
'lillplrs,Flnrit.l..J4112
File# 08-037-11"
Thj~ Spllr~ for rc+:ordill)!
LlE!\ AGREEMENT FOR DEFERRAL OF ]00%, OF COLLIER COUNTY IMPACT
FEES FOR OWNER OCCUPIED AFFORI)AIlLE HOUSING DWELLING UNITS
This Agreement is entered into this
duy of OctobCL 2007. between Collier County, a
political subdivision of the State of Florida (COUNTY) and "Monica Martinez" (OWNr::R).
collectively stated as the "Panics:'
NOW, THEREFORE, fur good and valuable consideration. the receipt and sufficiellcy of
which is mutually acknowledged, the Parties agree as follows:
L This Lien Agreement is made pursuant to Chapter 74 of the Code of Laws and Ordinances of
Collier County. Florida, known as "The Collier County Consolidated Impact Fee Ordinance'"
(Ordinance). In the ewnt of an}' l.:onHiet with this Agreement. the terms of the Ordinance
shaJl apply.
:2. The legal description of the dwelling unit is attached as Exhihit "A."
1. The term nfthis ^k-'Tecment is from the datl' set forth aho\'e until thl' impact fee is repaid.
4. The ampunt of the impl.lct fees deICrred shall be paid to the COUNT):' in full upon: u) the
sak of the dwcliing unit: h') [he rciinancing of the dwelling unit: c:\ a loss of the homestead
exemption: or d) the lirst occurrence of any sale or transfer of any part of the affected real
properly, and in any such event the deferred impact ices shall hl' paid in full to tIw COUNT):'
not later then the closing ofthc sail:, or not later then thl: effective date ofthc transfer. A~ set
forth in Exhibit "B," the amount of the deferred impact fees is Thirteen Thousand Six
Hundred Sixteen and 20/1(J() Dollars ($13.616.20). Repayment shall include all)' accrued
interest. lnterest shall he computed at the rate of five percent (5%) per annum. hut in no
event shall it exceed twenty~five percent (25%) or the total fee amount.
5, Thr.: deferred impact fees shall be a lien on the property descrihed in Exhibit "A." which lien
may he foreclosed upon in the event of non-compliance with the Ordinance or with this
Agreement. This Agreement shall operate as a lic.'n against the dwelling unit. The lien shall
terminate upon the recording of a release or satisfaction of lien in the puhlic records of the
County. The deferrals of impact ICes ami this Agreement shall run with the land, and neither
the deferred impact fees nor this Agreement shall he transferred. assigned, or other\.visc
conveyed. Except as provided by la",'. regardless of anyl()rcclosurc on the first mongage or
other security interest. this lien shall otherwise be superior and paramount to the interest in
the dwdling unit of any owner, lessee, tenant, mongagee, or other person, except that this
lien shall he on parity with any lien for County taxes.
6. Upon the satisfactory completion of this Agreement's requirements. ('OlJNT'r" shall record
any necessary documentation evidencing same.
7. In the event the OVr'NER is in default under the Ordinance or this Agreement. and the dcfimlt
is not cured within 30 days after \vritten notice is provided to the O\VNER, the COUNTY
;..o,;:;e:-1GZ; !F:?rr, :~C;. , '
rIJ::YVemD8i :::1',200;-
Pa9?.d of 10
may. at its sole opt lOlL colkct the imoact fee amount in dl'laull as set forth in the Ordinance,
or bring a civil action to l'nfon.T this :'\grccmcnt. or dcclan:: that the deferred impact fees me
then in dci~\Ult und irmncdiatl'ly JUl' and raY:lbk The COt Tj-":T\' shall be cntitll'J to rCCO'\Tr
all fees and costs, including <.lttorney's fee and costs. incurred hy the COI1NTY in enforcing
this Agreement. plus imerest at tbl' then maximum statutory rate for judgments calculated on
a calendar year hasls until paid.
~. This Agreement is the sole agreement between the parties with respect to the sub.icct matter
herein. and sh311 be binding uponlhc ()\)/NLR'S succcssor:~ and assigns in imcrcst.
l). This Abrecment shall he rc<:orded in the official records oj" the County at 11(\ cos! to th{'
COUNTY.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF. the Parties havl: executed this Agreement on the date and year first
ahove written.
Attest:
DWIGHT L. BROCK.. Clerh
BOARD OF COU1\:TY COMMISSIONERS
COl.LIER COUNTY. FLORIDA,
B:-':
By:
. l1cDut:- ('leI'\:
.lAMES ('OUTIA CHAIRMAN
(IWNFR:
\\'::l-t-llCSSCS:
. ~
~l-;-njca ~1';rt;~"~----;--'
Print Name -
q
()\\'NER'
v.,:itncsscs:
Print Namc
STATL OF FLORIDA)
COUNTY OF COl.LlER)
Thc foregoin!;'. Ag.reement was acknO\vlcdged ot.'forc me this __~___ day of ~~_'~_~'
2007. hy~__~_________~_,_._. viho is _pl:fsonaliy knOwf1_t!l mC or has produced
~_______,_ ._______________________ as pro{lTofi(fcntii-y.
~^"^""'"'::
~rN'6T~Rifr)~i";ALi . :
.~;~~~-
'T i,
Approvc,a as lr fonn
and legal'suiu:biooC\,,:-
<.'~.'
_ _ 1 '.
,- -',
,
, ---
.1 effTe)' A. .Klatzk.ow
Chief AssU:;tant;Count\' Anomc\
i . -
Signature or Person raking. Ackno\1,,;]cdgment
Recommend Approv31:
~-------==-----
-Marcy Krumhinc. MP/\
DircctO!
Collier County I-lousing. and Human Services
,
EXHIBIT "A"
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
Lot 14, Trail Ridge, according- to the plat thereof,
as recorded in Pial Hook 44, Pagc~71 through 77.
inclusive. of the f1ublic Records of Collier Count~', Florida.
EXIIIIIlT "H"
IMPACT FEE BREAKDOWN
Type oflmpact Fec
A. EMS Impact Fcc
B. Correctional I:acilitics Impact Fcc
C. Library' Impact Fcc
D. Community Park;; Impact Fcc
L Regional Parks Impact Fec
F. EducutionaJ Facilities System Impact Fce
G. Road Imparl l'ce:
It Government Buildint!s lmpacl Fe('
1. Law Enforcement Impact h.x'
J. V'/atcr lmpaCl i"ec
1\.. Sewer Impact Fe:;.'
TOT AI, IMPACT FEES
J/I,I\.ArllTovcd__'__:_
Aqenda Item NO.1 OCt
'November 27, 2007
Page 5 Of 10
Amount Owed
$100.59
$62.14
$36g.1 X
$750.00
$1.654.00
$g27.00
513.7:> 1.00
$1 ::;0.24
$~3.(J5
$2.7(,(j.O(j
$3.1 25.00
$13.(,1(,.20
.
.
2,qEnQ2 ii8iTi I~c, 'iC;r--;
IIJ~:)\IemDei- 2.7,2007
Pags 6 of 10
j'
'"
<;',
fP
September 14.2007
Attn: Frank Rumse)
SH1P Program Coordinator
Collier County
330 I E. Tamiami Trail
Health & Community Ser\ices Building
Naples. FL 34] 12
Re:
impact Fee Reimbursement
Dear Frank:
l-lahitat for Humaniry or Coiiier County. Inc., is requesting rcimbursemel11
for impact fees paid through the lmpaet Fec' Deferral Program. These Ceee.
were paid up front b\ Ilahital lor Humanit\ of Collier Count\.Inc.. in
order lO expedit;.> the huilding pr()cc~s. hov,"cver the future o\vners for the
propem clUaiih lc)r an impact fee deferral. Described as follows:
Monica .1. Martinez
13336 Covenant Rd, Naples FL 34114
Permit # 2006064365
Please feci ti'ce to contact Norma Lora t 77S-0036) if you haw any
questions or concerns,
Sincerely; j-
" '/!i-:;/>,:
.' /-t^//>::" ./'
_/,.. '" / ,_. :-.- _.,,/
. Samllel<f Durso/M.D,
Presiden1
:c..,;J8nda Item hK_ ~iOH
I~ovember =7" 20()7
F':'aae -- Of 1;~
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR1103 - Official Receipt
~s Number
694820
.U----I
----------1
,
1 Date
8/15/20062:3739PM
~ Post Date
, 8/15/2006
~ent Slip Nbr
PT 2006064365
--- -----""
Address 13336 COVENANT RD
Owner: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY OF COA#: 05-0717
PermitType: BR2 Job Desc: FRAMED S/F An 1 STY-150 AMP-TWIN VILLAS
Applicant: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY-SAM
DBA:
Swr Meter: SC Wtr Meter: CC
Payor: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY OF COLLIER COUNTY INC
Fee Information
I Fee_CodeiDescription---------------.9L Accour1L~=_---==--=- Amount i Waived I
108BCAI]}[DGCODE CERT. SU.. RCHARGE_. 1130000002Q8..fl2000000 ..... ' ..... $6821- _ ~..:..
, 08B~ lBJ-DG PERMITS - NAPLES 11313890032211000000 I $55360 , i
. 08CPMF 'HCOMM Pi<;IMPACTFEE M/F~461-5640236353031~46 -T $75000 --J
i ~~~~I~MF1~~;~.~~~~g~I~.~.. ~~PACLuu . ;~~~~~~bm. ;~;~;~;;~ i-.. :l~~;~.I._. I
'08GBMF I GOVT BLDG IMAPCT FEE M/F '39012223136353031390 $150.24 .
108JLMF .1 JAIL IMPACT FEE_M/F___38111043036353031:381,u- $62.14: .--'-1
LQ8LBMF 1 L1BI3ARY IMPACT FEEM/F .u. 35515619036353031355.u' _.$36818 I ~
i, ~i-~!~~.F :.~\~~!i5~~f~:. :~~.::.MUL TI-F.. ". ~..m~.~~~mm...~.~. ~~.~. .-r~3~!i: '.. .. .-1
i 08RDGS.'u I BLDG. PERMIT SUR.CHARG.L.. J113000000208800..0. 0000.. ..u.. . $6.82 ~ '
108RPMF I REG PK IMPACT FEE M/F - - '34615640236353031u346 $1659.00 I__
I 08SCHI' TI $.C;I:lOOL BOARDIi\"PACT FEE.- 11300000020905000QOO.. ....... $827.00 '---I
i 11 PUDM . PUD MONOTORING FEE . 13113890432248900000 $75.00 I
~~.~iJ~ ! ~~1~!~~~i~~N~~~~~~~~NG-Immm~~~~~~~~---i. $H~H~ ,---=
!42WSDC WATER SYSTEM CHARGEu-141127351134336031411----t- $2760.00 .._.u_
08BACRBLDG PERIViIT APP FEE CREDIT 111313890032251000000_ j;-10000
Total $14833.04
- Continued -
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT
Printed 11/1/2007 8:2637 AM
i.~C;\/'?nlL)~:
--c- r)[\
- '-~."
8 Of ,:,-
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR1103 - Official Receipt
. Tra-ns Number ! Date .-- .. i Post--Oate
~694820 n .____ 8/15/2006 23739 p~----=r 8/15/2006
_ Payment Slip Nbr
I PT 2006064365
I
-----J
I
Payments
, Payment Code
'CHECK
Account/Check Number
11879
Total Cash -.. $0,00 I
Total Non-Cash 014833.041
Total Paid !$14833:041
Memo:
Cashier/location HILLCAROL 1 1
User POTTER_ T
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT
Pnnted:11/1/2007 8:26:37 AM
.'.\Qsnda lIen; NC!, ~l OH
l.Jovember 27. 2007
Pa98 9 of 10
, ,
>It;" t' ,.
f L ~
, [
Ii.' SIi :.' I' i ";;nt
October 29. 2007
Ann: Fran].; Ramsey
SHIP Program Coordinator
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples. Florida 34112
RE:
,Pem1it #:
13336 Covenam Road. Naples, FL 34114
2006064365
Dear Frank.
Habitat for J lumani(\ of (o!iicr County. Inc. per the Coum: \Viat Impact ree
Dcfen-::ll Prilgran"l. idelltifies the ab()\,T referenced rr(lpen~' as an affordahk housin!:-'
unit. Please let this letter sene as an atlcr-the-faCl appiicmion and identiiicallon
thm an income eligible. legal rcsidcl1\ oflbe 1niled StaTes will OCCUPY the propcrt\'
once complete,
Habitat for Humanit) of Collier County. 1nc paid the impact Fees upfronl in order
to expedite the building process,
Please feel Ji'ee to contact Norma Lora (775-0036) if you have any questions or
concerns.
Sincerely
.-
/".
../"~~/
, 'Samuc1[)ur;o.1vr:6/
President
Page] of]
iTO:T
COLLIER COUI\TY
CCJAF;" (;r COUr.;TY COM~1iSSIONEF::
Item Number:
Item Summary:
-"'1'
,,)'.W: ,Ornrn,,,c,,()n,"
N'';;dJ:i1Gr::-l':tr-"
Eo:','
)('1 ':;i'J
I:"
'''1);,-'
~:I ':)'.',"" ..
"liS'"
:elli('
J')~); ,
;i1!
'J:C,: i'" 'I d' '" :r,ZiC" - 'elml:u,serne'lT 01 Trl'" 'f' ~ r'J:'~ :'\ Har;'
r"HTI;~'1 'v,,:
'".,'I(I:r":;'-C''''1I:
",n" I)llto:-'
Meeting Date:
OC i,M
I'repllred "~
f'-rank Ram~(.'\'
SH" "",'00r3'" :."",(j",~I"
rJim
F':mll~ Se'--'jIG-o,.
:m:JndH",,,:O",:.,,,c'w_
11 iSi2nr,"I L ~).~ : 1 2 ;0, ~',
Appro\'etl By
r{~r( r,rumr"n
r",e,'('"
nat"
Publ" """_'IC"'C.
Hou,,,,,, I: Human S..r\iIU"
11''J.'2DG7 1: 1D A~'
Appro\'cd B~'
.I['~f KlaU~(w,
AsC,lstamC"untvAnornf",
r;,1p'
C,ounut,twrrw'
c..OlJnl'-,'A:lOmc'"Off,u
11!S,'20C; 4:01 P!:
Approved B~
M""";",ms",,
hJr,i:
.; !''''HI'''str~1<''
;"1
'-"_J";I::""'"
I..,,~)W
',1",1,,,,,
".. ~;~7
{,ii
ApprllWdB}
.vcn;,",','"
. ; :,~
i\ '-'r'1r '''~, tfJ\ n."' ~",...
nJ;l'" ""',(,1"".
"'I
Appr"\'l.tl n~
';iV'" ;'i','C'
I,--,"I""f;("'''-'',\","
,'''..n'c'
':"Jr';;C'U :1'i;<;<
;." ,,~ "(.'" 11' <". .. b "0 (Jf
. "{:''I':''
'.~ '01
Apl'rn\('d H)'
J::~'W ' ''''Ml'
';'J'"'' r.;,:;",'
: ~mrn:o >ror)r,,'
,- ".J~r ;1.''''''''':'', CILef'
: 11':"i2C07 ': '11.', p~'
file://C:\AgendaT est\Export\93- November%>2.027. %202007\ I O,%,20COUNTY%20MANA.. ] 1/20/2007
.~G'3:1:;a Irer:i I\i-:J. ~IC.
t~()vember 27, 2007
F'age 1 of 10
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with Miguel Vera Vera and Maria Elena Vera
(Owners) for deferral of 100% of Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied
affordable housing unit located at Lot 16, Liberty Landing and authorizes a
reimbursement of the fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc on
Building Permit 2007020728 in the amount of $12,442.52.
OBJECTIVE: That the Board of County Commissioners (Board) approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, the attached lien agreement with Miguel Vera Vera and Maria Elena Vera for
deferral of 100% of Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable housing unit
and authorize a reimbursement of the impact fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier
County Inc. in the amount of $12.442.52.
CONSIDERATIONS: Article IV of Chapter 74 of the Code of Laws aI1d Ordinances
established a program to defer impact fecs for qualified affordable housing. Pursuant to this
program, an application tor deferment was submitted by Miguel Vera Vera and Maria Elena
Vera, which application, after staff review, was determined to qualify for the program. Legal
status has been verified and documents arc on filc at the office of Housing and Human Services.
The property is located in the Liberty Landing subdivision in lmmokalce.
-
During staff's review of the file to process this deferral lor approval it was determined that the
Habitat for Humanity of Collier County lnc did not provide an application tor the deferral
program as a qualified developcr prior to issuance of the building permit and payment of
associated impact fees as required. Staff has discussed this oversight with the County
Attorney's Office and recommends that the Board aecept the application letter from the
developer after-the-fact in order to complete the required paperwork and maintain consistency
with the Ordinance for this file and deferral agreement. Upon approval and execution of this
deferral agreement and lien, impact fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc. in
the amount of$12,442.52 will be reimbursed.
The ordinance requires that a lien agreement be entered into with the applicant as a condition of
deferral of the impact fees. Section 74-401 (3) of the Code authorizes the County Manager to
sign deferral agreements with applicants qualifying for impact fee dcferrals for affordable
housing, which has long been the practice. The ordinance, however, gives the County Manager
discretion in whether to enter into the Agreement. Accordingly, in keeping with recent
discussion and direction by the Board, the County Attorney's Office has determined that until
directed otherwise by the Board, these agreements be placed on the Consent Agenda for the
Board's review, approval and Chairman's signature.
FISCAL IMPACT: This agreement defers $12.442.52 in impact fees. Although it is expected
that the County will ultimately collect these deferred fees (generally upon the sale of the
residence), there is no guarantee as to if, or when, this would occur.
---
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: The proposed Agreement is fully consistent with the intent
and purpose of Section 74-401 of the Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collier County.
,-'-',J.;'Jf1C8 ItS<YI 1~c' I C"
l~ovelllbH 27,2007
Flags 2 of 10
STAFF RECOMMENDA nON: That the Board approves and authorizes the Chairman to
sign the attached Lien Agreement for Deferral of 100% of Collier County Impact Fees for
Owner Occupied Affordable Housing Dwelling Units for Miguel Vera Vera and Maria Elena
Vera located at Lot 16, Liberty Landing, Immokalee and authorizes a reimbursement of the
impact fees paid by Habitat lor Humanity of Collier County Inc on Building Permit
2007020728 in the amount of $ 12,442.52, and any budget amendments that may be required
associated to the reimbursement.
PREPARED BY: Frank Ramsey, SHIP Program Coordinator, Housing and Hwnan Services
l\09nGEi Item I~o, 1 CJ!
r~ovembe, 2.7. 2007
Page 3 of 10
Itrlllrutl!
linnll. H~Ol'r~
CnllirrCoPlltylHIS
.Hot L TlImiami Trllll
"'lIplc'. Flurillu J.jl 1:2
File# 08.0M-IF
TbisSIlllcrlurrrrurdillt,:
LIEN AGREEMENT FOR ()EFERRAL OF 100% OF COLLIER COU1\'TY IMPACT
FEES FOR OWNER OCCUPIE() AFFORDABLE HOUSING ()WELLlNG UNITS
This Agreement is entered into thi~ iO~ day of October. 2007, ben,veen Collier County, u
political subdivision of the Stall' or Florid'-l (COUNTY) and ..MI!'!uc! Vera Vera and Maria Elcn'-l
Vera"' (OV/NER), colketively stated as the "Parties:'
NO'W, THEREFOH.E, for good and valuable consideration, the receipt and suff1eiellcy of
'vvhicb is mutually acknowledged. thc Pmties agree as follows:
1. This Lien Agreemenl is made purSllUl1t to Chaptt:r 74 of the Code of La\vs and Ordinances of
Collier County, Florida. known '-lS "Th(' Coliier Coumy Consolidated lmpucl fce Ordinance"
(Ordin:mcel. In the event of any conJ1iCl \\.ith this Agreement. the terms of the Ordinance
shnll apply.
Th('lcgal description of tIll.:" chveliilll; unit is atluched us Exhibit "/\,"
"
.. "rill.' [::rl11 of this Agrccl11el1l i~, from the dale set I(Jrlh ahove until tlx' impact fee is repaid.
4, The amount urthe impact J(:i;S Jdi;rrcd shul1 be paid Hllhc C()L~)\TY in full upon: JI the
sak of th(" dwelling unit: h1 the rdlnan~in~ or the dwcliing unit: e) (j loss of the llUnlcstead
c.\t:mption: or J) th:: Erst occurre1JC(' of any sule or trans!:.:r or an) ]lJrt 1.1/ the aiTe;.:ted reui
propert). and 1n any such cvent the deferred impuct jee~; shall be paid in full \0 the COl1\TY
not later then the closint! of the sale:. or not later then the clTc.cti ve date ofthc transfer. As set
forth in Exhibit "B." the amount of tht." deferred impact fees is Twcl\'t Thousund Four
Hundred I"orty 1\vo and 52/100 Dollars ($12.44:2.52), Repayment shall include any accrued
interest. Interest sh'-lll be computed ut the rate or five percent (5(~';J) per unnUl11. but in no
event shaH it exceed t\vcniy-fl\-'C percent (2Y;,,-(,) of the total fel.: amount
5. The deferred impact fees shall be a lien on the property described in Exhibit '.A." which lien
may bc foredo sed upon in the c\'ent or non-compliance \\ith tilt' Ordinance or \vith Ihis
Agreement. This Agreement shalJ operate as a lien against the dwelling unit. The lien shalJ
terminate upon thl.' rt'cording of a releasl.' or satisfaction of lien in the public records of the
Count:'. The dekrruls or impact fees and this Agreement shall run \-vjth lhe land. and neither
the deferred impact fees nor Ihis Agreement shall be transferred. assigned. or otherwise
conveyed. Except as provided hy 13\\, regardless of an) fort~l.:losure on thl.: lirsi mortgage or
other security interest, this lien shall otherwise be superior ;:me! paramount to the interest in
the dwdling unit of uny OWI11:L less!.:c. tenant. mortgagee. or other person, except that lhi:-.
lien shall he 011 parity \vlth any lien ror County taxes.
6. Upon the satisfuc10ry completion nf this Ag:recmcni's requirements. COUNTY shali record
allY necessary documentation cvidencil1t! same.
7. In the event the O\A!NFR is in default under the Ordinance or this Agreement, and the default
is not cured within 30 days aher written notice is provided to the OWNER. the COUNT'\"
ma). Jt its sole option. collect the impact fee amounT in default as set forth in the Ordinance,
or bring a civil action LO cnlclfl:c this Agreement. or uL'clarc thaI the dekrrcd impact lees are
then in deiJull <Jnd immediatel) duC" :wo pnyablc. rhe COl'i'\'TY shall he entitled TO rceov,-'r
ail ti.x~s :llld e(lsts, including :1llorney.s fee anJ costs. incLlrred by tlll' COUNTY in L'nfon.:ill~
this Agreement. plus interest a1 the then maximum stalUll1f: nile for jud!;!mcnts caleubted on
a calendar YC:ll' baSIS until paid.
S. This Agreement is the soil: :lgn:emcnt hetween the panics with respect to the suh.iccl mane!"
herem. and shall he binding upon the OW'\JU{.S successors and assi~l1s in interest.
lJ. This Agrl:ement shall he recordcd III lhl' oriicial records of the CUUn1) at no cos1 10 th::
L,oen;::,;;; iIer; i\JC
!~ovember::'7 2)J"O<
Page':: o~ Ie
COU,TY.
IJ\ \VITJ\ESS "'HEREOF, the Panics h3\'t, c),ecuLed this Agreementlm the date and year fifst
ab(l\'c wri ttcn,
Allest:
DWIGIIT L. BROCk. Clerk
IH!ARJ) UI' COU"iTY COMMISSIO"iLRS
COLULR COl"TY. I'EOR!D.\.
By
B.'
.I.\MES CO!.iIT.\. CII'III(\I;.,\
.1kpUl: CierL
()\\''\IT
V..itnesscc'.
!'rint '\iaml'
,;..:1.
.:"
.,:'.1'
\ll1!ucl \cr,J \ ('f<:1
OW'\iEI(.
\Vitncsscs:
/<-j_,".^---i....
,
. .IL-l'.......---
-------
PrintNamc
E'''I.r ,1
.Ii: ~v_
,,-0"'~ ;-t,< i:: '--_cJ2.CL.1.::'u:'_Y.:9__
l"v1uri3 Eicml Vera
S'I All 01' I'LORIDA I
COLI'TY OF COEUER)
The loregoim!. AurccmCDt wa" ac:knowlcducd bei'ore me this .. ( da\' of
t ..' -'. ~ .'. ' _ ~ -.,.-- .
~(}07, hY..!:::-41'.(/./' . //..6. i - /1 ~~__.-1 '.~ \yh~~_il'~_l)~I~q1!al!;':,l~~~l~':~,!_~O_ !!Jl'
____ _~_____~__ as pr()t)j' oj'idcntil:,
/
[-/:,.., -,~:'::.;.;[--::-
or-J"l{as prodt;ced
[NUlARJAI. SL\LI
t:_1'V~'';':";'^^~'7
;:. ..:',- ,'\"J~E..., L~1E'>i,)Ot_:\ <
) :w,l'!l(""l\II~~I(J" II;""'''';;.?,
s..~;~.,:/ J-)(rHU;~'\'i':",,,.,I_'..\)I" S
i\Ppf(l-Cd~'~-~~
~ ; 'f ~ :.i
and le~al~~ctcu~
Y"T, r,.
~
-.-,.....------ -----.--
.lethey A. t-:.lutzko\\
Chief /\ssist:l.rtl Count: .\tlllnll':
, ,
-----.:..:~: ._~./_. .. ----'-.!:--'::i-l:~~::__i.. ~
Signatui-e of Person 'I'aking Acktlowk':&<~m\'?nl
RccommenJ App!"~l\'QI:
1
.\ '-~-
- Marcy I\.rumbinel, K-1PA
Dm:ctor
Collier County Housing and Human Services
EXHIBIT "A"
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
Lot 16. Lihl'rt) Landing. according to the plat thereof,
as recorded in Plat Book 47. Pages 71 through 73.
inclusive, of tlu'lluhlic Records of Collier Count)', Florida.
EXHIBIT '''B''
IMPACT FEE BREAKDOWN
Type of Impact Fe{'
A. E!\1S Impact Fcc
B, Correctional Facilities impact fee
C. Library Impact F Ct'
D, Community Pmb. Impuct r:cc
F, Regional Parks Impl.lCl F~t'
F. EducaliDnalFa<.:iliiic~ System impact Ft:c
O. [,oad hnpaci. Ice
H. Ci(\\'cmm~n[ Buildinp' Impucl Fee.
l. La"\' Enforcement Impact Fec
TOTAL IMI'ACl FEES
IAK.\ppmvul
Amount Owed
$100.5"
$62.14
$36B.1g
S7:S().on
$1.659.00
$:2.f:;62.0()
~(J.059.{)(i
,,410.1)(1
$171.61
Sl:!.4~2.52
p,oenCEi ItarT': i'Jc. ~i J;
!~ovember 27. 2007
Page 5 of 10
.
.
'-.;'~'enG~~ iISrri I'K 1 ,~:
i\!Ove!T1DS" '::::. 20D?
Pa;E' 5 of 1C
" #,
September 28. 2007
Ann: Frank Ramse:
SHIP Program Coordinator
CoHler County
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Health & Community Scn'ices Building
Naples. FL 341 ] 2
Re:
Impact Fee Reimbursement
Dear F ranL:
Habitat for i--lunlanil: of Collier County. In:..'.. is requesting reimhursemem
for impact L'~.'~ raid through the Impact Fee Deferral Program. These f~es
were raid up front by Habitat for Humanity of CoHier County. Inc.. in
order to expedite the building process. however the future owners f()r the
property quaiif\ for an impact fe(:' defen"al. I}2scrihcc ~s follows:
Miguel V. Vera & Maria E. Vera
.'1580 Libert}. Way, Immokalee FL 34]42
Permit # 2007020728
Please feel free 10 comact Nom1a Lora (775-0036i if you have any
questions or concerns.
Sincerely.
Lisa Letkow
Development Director
:"\2'1; !'~(" ,',
.,::.;' .:..UU,
:i 10
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR1103 - Official Receipt
I Trans Number
'748753
Date
31'27/2007 2:26:22 PM
Post Date
i 3/27/2007
_J
Address: 3580 LIBERTY WAY
Owner: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY COA # 06-0220
Permit Type: BR2 Job Desc: FRAMED S/F ATT 1 STY-150 AMP-TWIN VILLAS
Applicant: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY-SAM
DBA:
Swr Meter: IMM Wtr Meter: IMM
Payor: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY OF COLLIER COUNTY INC
Fee Information
1
! Fee Code DeSCription. ! GL Account ___
i@3CAI-BlOG.CODECERT. SURCHARGE. ~1130000002088l9QOOOO
: 08BPIM BLDG PERMITS - IMMOKALEE 11313890032212000000
08CPMF COMM PK IMPACT FEE M/F.34611_636336353031346
08EMMMF, EMS IMPACT FEE M/F 35014047036353031350
. 08GBMF ! GOV'r--SLDG IMAPCT FE"'.MlE._ j 3901:<2231 36353031390
: 081MFF IIMMOKALEE FIRE IMPACT . 11300000020985000000
108JLMF I JAIL IMPACT FEE M/F .. ------:-38111043036353031381
08LBMF i LIBRARY IMPACT FEE M/F i 35515619036353031355
:08LW~ITLAWENFIMPACT FEEM/F 13851104:J336:J.5.3~j]~
08MFR5 ! DIST 5 ROAD IMPACT FEE,MUL TI-F --+.13916365936353031339
: 08MFSG I MICROfJJ.M SURCHAR.QE.~n=-- . 11313890034144200000
i 08RDGS ! BLDG pERMIT SURCHAR..G_E.__ 11300000020880000000
i 08RPMF REG PK IMPACT FEE M/F .34611636336353031346
:08SCI:II SCHOOL BOARD IMPACT FEE _.j1130000002099501)()OOO
cl1PLJ[Jr'lII__ PUD MONOTORING FEE .131138@432248900000
'I 12SITE I SITE INSPECTION-ENGINEERING. i 13113832732249000000
08BAQIL1.BLDGcPERry1IL6PP. FEE':C;Bl'DIT .. -[ 1131389003225100000_0
Total
- Continued -
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT
Amount. Waived
$6.82
$553.60 !
$750.00 !
$100.59
$410.00 !
=:~II514~04.~-=----=_ I
_m'-~m=62.14
..$36818 .______,
$171)'-:1.__ ;
$6059.00.
$3.00 :
____..1.6..~2. !
$1659.00
$2862.00
$75.00 i
$150.00
$-100.00,
-L_~14651 JlQJ
Printed:11/1/2007 8:29:19 AM
C.J'^iC
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR 1103 - Official Receipt
I Trans Number i Date : Post Date
; 748753-~3/2ii2007 226~2 PM-- . 3/27/2007
Payment Slip Nbr
I PT 2007020728
Payments
: Account/Check Number
i 13ii@1 ..~_
~Yrnent Code
,CHECK
. Amount I
$14651.80 I
Total Cash : - $0.00'
Total Non-Cash =$146~
Total Paid $14651.80 I
Memo:
Cashier/location: HILLCAROL /
User: POTTER_T
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT
Prinled:11/1/2007 8:29:19 AM
c.oencJa 11em f\JG" 10i
November 27, 2007
Page 9 of 1('
<".
r r
October 29,2007
Attn: Frank Ramsey
SHIP Program Coordinator
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples. Florida 34112
RE: 3580 Liberty Way. Iml11okalee. FL 34142
Pemlit #: 2007020728
Dear Frank.
Habilat for Humanity oj' Collier County. Inc. per the County \Vide Impact Fee
Deferral Program. idemiijes the "bove referenced propertv as an afj()rdabic
housing unit. Ple"se let this letter sene as ,m aftcr-thc-iact application and
identification that an income eiigihlc.legal resident of the I, nit:::d Statc~ will
occupy the property once complele.
Habitat f()l' llul11anity of Collier Countv. Inc paid the Impact Fees upfront in order
10 expedite the building process.
Please feel free to contact Norma Lora (775-0036) if you have any questions or
concerns.
Sincerelyv
~. /~.
, '.
, -
"Samuel Durso. M ~
President
Page I of I
i<181';11\'11\]
'n:)(',
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONEf:S
Item Number:
Item$ummilry:
"cw'rn2'10;;" TaT n' ~;Q;m, 0
unh ,- '-~1~lifS'."1P~S ::::~"".)'oJP ,1'lCl "umc,'::c':i "'.'
'1Iii'
,II'"
':I.:h'JI."o I'P,I 'h'-",II'GtJ1;J"
\'". '- ,'c.'\,<lC,.,o
.1C'I,,'T.!, C ,~,
ii"or'~:,ldc
;~:Jte~ ,l[
",DE)' \. L",nJ,n~ Oil .:1 avnc Izes:J 'E'i:T1t;.urf<omA'lt 0' trl~ tee" r;i"j
t at',.t . '("1 i--' an:t'-,. ;:Clj;rt" '~'.JU'lL.' "",:; b.I:IUII":; '-'["~'III 2CJT'::J2':;~:'i', 1t1 :~lr, ,Hll~U""
Meeting Dilte:
-,:-',
C,,',\f.
Prepared B}
hankf<.arnsp\
SH'''' "'romam '~;oonimmCl'
iJ~H-
>'UbllcScrv,cr;>"
HOU$ln"JmjHurna~Serv, e'
1 ,'9,'2007 S :5~' 58 A It
Approved II}
MJr~': ~Jtlm[)mr
DFr~C\()'
IJJtc
hJ~.'"'' "(',-vlce,,
l-1()lI~;"Hl & human S<T.'OCW
11 1~)i200, 11.-~!:- A Ii
Appro\'ed B}
)el;KlallI(Ov
""SISI~nl C.OUnt" AllOme"
LJal~
~,oun!\' J:..tt(jrn~\
(.;:,,,np/Atlo,nf,': ani'"
11l~Jl200, 4' r.~ PI.'
Apprun'u By
I/,~rr~ "~,,
~'ub 1:'
,.""In"" ;"I'.,T~)
I)'H'
;"lm". ~,'" "_
"Ill'll"
"".IW'""
"'1 ~,:2()O~' ,'.; J, t,
Approved H}
~;'"
'<1r",II'II';H."I\', ;o'-""(;L'
"",' ""'" ''-_'',"U;U-'.'
21 ',: .~:,. 0'.,.
AppmvedU)
,;':
-J,,-
'';''<''IF
,. ,,,:,,~,
ApprowulJ}
,)," t'l"~
',lI",n'
IUl'
; ,< ,,() "'~\.
Illml','",,,,,o,,"
;'.',In,,,,,'''' C'ilC<
1 '1 .. ~ ')120(r" 2 j PI'.:
filc:IIC:\Ag.enda T est\Export\93- Novemher"/o2027. %J.02007\ 1 O."/o20COUNTY%20MANA.. 11/20/2007
b,qenda Itern l\Jo. 10..;
I~ovember 2007
PagE': of10
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with Marise Omeus (Owner) for deferral of 100% of
Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable housing unit located at Lot
18, Trail Ridge and authorizes a reimbursement of the fees paid by Habitat for Humanity
of Collier County Inc on Building Permit 2006064384 in the amount of $13,616.20.
OBJECTIVE: That the Board of County Commissioners (Board) approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, the attached lien agreement with Marise Omeus tor deferral of 100% of
Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable bousing unit and authorize a
reimbursement of the impact fees paid by Habitat tor Humanity of Collier County Inc. in the
amount of $ I 3,616.20.
CONSIDERATIONS: Article IV of Chapter 74 of the Codc of Laws and Ordinances
established a program to defer impact fees for qualified affordable housing. Pursuant to this
program, an application for defennent was submitted by Marise Omeus, which application, after
staff review, was determined to qualify for the program. Legal status has been verified and
documents are on file at the office of Housing and Human Services. The property is located in
the Trail Ridge subdivision in Naples.
-
During staffs review of thc tile to proccss this deferral for approval it was deternlined that the
Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc did not provide an application for the deferral
program as a qualified developer prior to issuance of the building pcrnlit and payment of
associated impact fees as rcquired. Staff has discussed this oversight with the County
Attorney's Office and recommends that thc Board accept the application letter from the
developer after-the-fact in order to complcte the required paperwork and maintain consistency
with the Ordinance for this file and deferral agreemcnt. Upon approval and cxecution of this
deferral agreement and lien, impact fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc. in
the amount of$I3,6l6.20 will be reimhursed.
The ordinance requires that a lien agreement be entcred into with the applicant as a condition of
deferral of the impact fees. Section 74-40](3) ofthc Code authorizes the County Manager to
sign deferral agreements with applicants qualifying for impact fee deferrals for affordable
housing, which has long been the practiee. The ordinance. however, givcs the County Manager
discretion in whether to enter into the Agreement. Accordingly, in keeping with recent
discussion and direction by the Board, the County Attorney's Office has detennined that until
directed otherwise by the Board, these agreements be placed on the Consent Agenda for the
Board's review, approval and Chairman's signature.
FISCAL IMPACT: This agreement defers $13,616.20 in impact fees. Although it is expected
that the County will ultimately collect these deferred fees (generally upon the sale of the
residence), there is no guarantee as to if, or when, this would occur.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
----
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: The proposed Agreement is fully consistent with the intent
and purpose of Section 74-401 of the Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collier County.
j.:.,';:.;;~!-;::;c-, :Isrrl i\lG, "i \.,,,:
1'~'-:--_'v:;Tnbe~::? 20C7
PeWS::': of 1 C;
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: That the Board approves and authorizes the Chainnan to
sign the attached Lien Agreement for Deferral of 100% of Collier County lmpact Fees for
Owner Occupied Affordable Housing Dwelling Units for Marise Omeus located at Lot 18. Trail
Ridge, Naples and authorizes a reimbursement of the impact fees paid by Habitat for Humanity
of Collier County lnc on Building Pennit 2006064384 in the amount of $13,616.20, and any
budget amendments that may be required associated to the reimbursement.
PREPARED BY: Frank Ramsey, SHIP Program Coordinator, Housing and Human Services
....~.,
..-""...
Kl'lurn III
AqenJ2 ilen! [";0. iGJ
r~CJvember 27 < 2007
PagE-: 3 of ~i [I
~rankl(lImSl'}
CullirrCnUllly I illS
J.lOl LTHmiwmi'lr/lil
"<lIplc\. Fluridll.l4112
File# OR-035-IF
rllis 'IllIl'c f'lr rcrnnlill~
LIEN AGHEEMENT FOR IlEFEHnAL OF 100% OF COLLIEH COUNTY IMPACT
FEES FOH OWNER OCCUPIED AFFOHDABLE HOIJSING IlWELLlNG UNITS
This Agreement is entered into this ___ day of October, :?007. bctwcm Collier County. (}
political subdivision of the State of Florida (COUNTY) and "Marise Omeus" (O\VNERl.
collectively stated as the "Parties:'
NO\\.', THEREFORE, for good and valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of
which is mutually acknowledged, the Parties agree as follows:
1. This Lien Agreement is made pursuant to Chapter 74 of the Code of Laws and Ordinances or
Collier County, Florida. known as "The Collier County Consolidated Impact Fee Ordinanc!':"
(Ordinance). In the ('vent or any conflict vvith this Agreement. the terms of the Ordinance
shall apply.
"
The legal description oCthe dwelling unit is attached as Exhibit "A."
The term of this i\~rccment is hom thl~ date set forth above unti Itl1(' impacllCc is repaid.
.,
4. The amount 01' thl~ imp:Jcl fee::, de('l~rred sh:Jll he paid hi tht' COUNTY in full upon: al tlK
sale of thl' dwelling unit: h) the refinancing. of the dwelling unit: e) <J loss of the homestead
exemption: or JI the first oceurrenCt: or an; sale or transkr of any pan of tbe affected real
property, and in any such t'ventthe deferred impact fces sha1l1)L~ paid in full to the COUNTY
not later then the dosing of lhl~ sale, or not later then the effcc.ti\'e date of the transfer. As set
forth in Exhibit "B." the amount or the deferred impact fees is Thinccll Thousand Six
Hundred Sixteen and 20/100 Dollars ($13.o16.2m. Repayment shall include any accrued
interest Interest shall he computed at the rate of five percent (5%) per annum. but in no
event shall it exceed twenty-five percent (25%) of the total fce amount
5. The deferred impadlces shall be a lien on the property described in Exhibit "A." which lien
may be foreclosed upon in the c\-'cnt of non-compliance \-vith the Ordinance or with this
Agreement. This Agreement shall operate as a lien against the dwelling unit. The lien shall
terminate upon the recording of' a release or satisfaction of lien in the public records of the
County. The deferrals or impact fees and this Agreement shall run \-vith the land, and Tll:ither
the deferred impact fees nor this Agreement shall he transferred. assigned, or othenvise
conveyed. Except as provided hy la\\'. regurdlcss or any foreclosure on the first mortgage or
othcr security interest. this lien shall othcnvise be superior and paramount to the interest in
the dwelling unit of any owner. lessee. tenant, mortgagee. or other person. I:xcept that this
lien shall he on parity with any lien for County taxes.
6. Upon the satisfactory completion of this Agreement's requirements. COUNT'{ shall record
any necessary documentation evidencing same.
7. In the evenl the O\VNER is in default under the Ordinance or this Agreement. and the default
is not cured within 30 days after written notice is provided to the O,^'NER. the COUNTY
L\C1SnClc; :[8.1'1 i~c. 10",;
1\:c)Vembei' 27. 2007
F'ags.4 of 10
may. at it;; sllk \lrtion. collect tbe impact Ice amnunl in default as set forth in the Ordinance.
or bring a civil aCliol1lU enforce this A:-,recmellt. {lr declare that the defCrreJ impact kes are
then in default 3mj immediately due and payahk Thc COUl\T'r' shall he emilleu 10 recover
all fees ano costs. indudl11g attorney's fee and costs. incurred hy the COL'NTY in enforcin~
this Agreement. plus interest at the then muximum statutory rate for judgments cakuhucd on
a calendar year hasis until paid.
R. This Agreement is the sok agreement hetween the parties with respect to the subject matter
herein. and shall be binding upon the O\\,'NER' S Sllccessors and assigns in interest.
9. This Agreemenl shall he recorded in the official records of the County at no cost to tht
COU1\TY.
IN ","'ITNESS \\-'HEREOF. the Parties have executed this Agreement on the date and year first
above \vriuen.
Attest:
DWIGHT E. BROCI;.. Ckrk
HOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLlEI( COUNTY. FLORIDA,
By:
By:
. ])CPUl:- Ck'rk
JAMES COI.ETTA. CHAIRMAN
(l\\'Nl-'.J~:
\^,'lnlcSSCS'
Prmt Name
i\1arise (Imcus
'-;,
OWNER:
\\;itncsscs:
lJrinl Name
STATE OF FLORIDA)
COUNTY OF COLLIER)
The i"oregoinJ! Agreement wa<; acknowledged hc1<:m: me this~_ day oj'
2007. 1"1) _. ".,rho is personally known to me or has produced
_______~_~__~_______________~~~~ as proof of identily.
~~,,^:,.~~';~J~~~~
(~()1A:\ilA!,StArj .
s,'~',::i':.::v~.,-"^^^^~>"";"'.fV' ~
Signature of Person Taking Acknowledgment
Appmt-:d asia form
.. .~'
and lC~' ,.,~rf'IU'Y'
Nh{.i\"
(-- --j- .- -:
.Jeffrey 'A. Klat~()w --,----
Chief'ASsistant Count \ A !tome\"
~' - .
)
Recommend Appn1val:
\ f-----,~-
Marcy K.rumbine. MPA
Director
Collier County Ilousing and Human Services
EXHIBIT "A"
LEGAL IlESCRIl'T10N
Lot 18, Trail Ridge. aCl'ording to the plat thereof,
as recorded in Plat Buok 44, Pages?l through 77,
inclusive, ufthe Public Records of Collier Countl, Florida.
EXHIIllT "Il"
IMPACT FEE llREAKJ)OWN
Type of Impact Fel'
A. EMS Impact Fee
B. Correctional Facilities Impact Fee
C. Lihrary Impact Fee
D. Community Parks Impact Fcc
F Regional Parks Impact Fcc
F. Educational Facilities System Impact I'"cr:
(I. Road Impact Fcc
n. Govcmment Buildings Impacl Fcc
1. Law Lnforccmcnllmpacl Fe,'
.1. Water impact r;cc
K. Sewer Impact Fcc
TOTAL IMPACT FEES
J^K AppHWCJ J_J__
p,genaEi Item NO.1 OJ
[\Jovember 27. 2007
Page 5 0110
Amount Owed
$100.s9
$62.14
$36R.l R
$750.00
$1.659.00
$R27.00
$~.7.l1.00
$150.14
s)t;3.05
$2.7611.011
$3.1~5.00
$13,(,16.20
.
J..I,ClenGE~ ilern r~Q. 10J
f\!OV9IT1D9~ 27 20CI!'
;:'aoE: e. 0'- 10
.
.w:;
""
t
y
September 7. 2()()7
Ann: Fran!.; Ramse)
SHIP Program Coordinator
Collier COllnty
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Health & Community Services Building
Naples. PL 3-+ 112
Re:
Impact Fee Reimbursement
Dcar Frank:
Hahitat for l-iumanjt\' of Collier Count~. inc.. is requ~sling reimhursement
f{)f impacl f~e:-: paid througlllhe In1pact ret Dei';:rral Program. These ft~e-,
were paid ur front b: Hahi131 for Humanity of Collier COllnty. inc.. in
order tel expedite the nuilding rruc,es~. hov.;c\'cr the future owners for the
propcIl: qualify ror an Impact fee deferral. Descrihed as follows:
Marise Omeus
1 :;:152 Covenant Rd. Naples FL 34114
Permit # 2006064384
Please feel ti-cc to contact Norma Lom 177:'-0036) ifvou have any
questions or concerns.
Sincerely,
-;i;:';'~__,
Nicolas Koulobcras
Land Development Director
l,"GSnGL j"lSm No. ~: 0..)
f~ovember 27 2007
PEWS I' of ~: (1
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR1103 - Official Receipt
, Date
8115120062:39:19PM
i Trans Number
'694823
i Post Date
I 811512006
,---~--'
__~"yment Slip Nbr
i PT 2006064384
._1
i
Address: 13352 COVENANT RD
Owner: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY OF COA#: 05-0717
Permit Type: BR2 Job Desc: FRAMED SIF ATT 1 STY-150 AMP-TWIN VILLAS
Applicant: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY-SAM
DBA
Swr Meter: SC Wtr Meter: CC
Payor: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY OF COLLIER COUNTY INC
Fee Information
I Fee-COde i DescriPtion_TGi.Account----- i Amount i Wai"E;(j-j
I 08BCAI : BLDG.CODE CERT SLJRCHARGE u"11300000020882000000-j' $6821'---
08BPNP BLDG PERMITS - NAPLES i 11313890032211000000 $553.60 I
108CP.MF WOMM PKiMPACT FEE MIF 134615640236353031346 $750.001
i 08f'.MMMF EMSIMPACT FEEJv1IF ,35Q140470363530313~. - L $10059
i 08r::N1M I EAST NAPLES FIRE_IMPACL-__. . 1130000002098200000L- _ $300.08 i
\ 08GBMF , GOVT BLDG IMAPCT FEE MIF i 39012223136353031390 ,---$150.24T
h08JLMF I JAIL IMPACTFEE MIF----138111043036353031381u L- $62~'-41
~LBMF I LIBRARY IMP6CT FEE MIF . 3551561~036353031355 $368181
'f~~~1~: j~~~ ~~o~6~;;~~F~~-MULTI-F-1 ~~~;~~~;~~~~;~~~;~~~ _1~~~~~6
08MFSG I MICROFILM SURCHARGE 11313890034144200000 $309..1-
'OSRDGS BLDG. PERMIT SURCHARGE-"-"-3OOcl00020880000000 $6.82 I
'ID8RPMF I REG PK IMPACTFEE MIF-- 3461564023~53031346 $1659.00 I
D8SCI:II i SCHOOL BOARD IMPACT.~ 11300000020905000000 _ $8276-0-~ ==
11PUDM i PUD MONOTORING FEE 13113890432248900000 $75.00 i
U2sITE . SITi::INSPECTION:r::NGiNEERING_-j' 1311383273??49-0000.QD... -, $150.00 ---1
i 42MTTP I CQUNTY METER.JAP CHARGE _ 40825321234332000000 ----L $221.521 "
42SSDC ,SEWER SYSTEM CHARGE . 41326361334356031413 i $3125.001__ .-. 'l
142WSDC WATER SYSTEM CHARGE----1.41127351134336031~- i $276000 .
08BACR uiBLDG PERMITAPP FEE CR~ 11313890032251D()OOOQ -i $-10000 --~
Total ! $14833.04 I
j
--j
I
~I
- Continued -
Collier County Board of County CommiSSioners
CD-Plus for Windows 951NT
Printed:111112007 8:31 :05 AM
c' c: :l
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR1103 - Official Receipt
Trans Number
694823
JDate
i 8/15/2006 2:3919 PM
~ment Code
CHECK
Account/Check Number
11879
Memo:
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT
Post Date
, 8115/2006
Payments
-,
Pa~ment Slip Nbr
PT 2006064384
--l
,
Amount i
$14833.641
Total Cash ---$O.OO~
Total Non-Cash - $1483364,.
Total Paid
L $14833.04,
Cashier/location: HILLCAROL 1 1
User POTTER_ T
Printed:11/1/2007 8:31:05 AM
,G,aenda Item t\Ju. 10J
November 27. 2007
Pag9 9 of 10
~
h ~
P'
;.,
"""j"'"
t '''c'
;11,
~ ,. , .
October 29, 2007
" ,,: i, ~j
Attn: Frank Ramsey
SHIP Program Coordinator
3301 E Tamiami Trail
Naples. Florida 34112
RE:
Pernlit iI:
13352 Covenant Road. Naples, FL 34114
200()064384
Dear FranL.
Habitat for Humanity of Collier County. inc. per the County VI'ide Impact Fee
Deferral Program. identifies the above referenced propcrty '" an affordable
housing unit. Please let this Icttcr serve as an after-the- fact application and
identification that aJl income eligible, legal resident ofthe United States will
occupy the property once complete.
Habitat for Humanity of Collier County, Inc paid the Impact Fecs upfront in order
TO expedite the building process.
Please feel free to contact Nonna Lora (775-(j()36) if you havc any qucstions or
concerns.
Sincerel)',,/'
l;
- ,,//
/
Samuel.J'lurso, M.D.
President
,;" i;;:T.
'n';;'. '\.'. "
Page lor I
Ie:: l\j,- ~U
COLLIER COUNTY
so; ::: or caur',' ::OM1,1ISSICl'JEP.,
ttemNumber:
ltemSummBry:
f-.' CO'1lIll,,~n~8:10~ !rlat trl" Coo,lr~.l ' , )WI1 ," ',()'11Illr"r;'Oni":' a::r'< '....c,,,; ~_r. j aulnGr';>:", t'1"
',;.'lrrn,lr' <;1"[' d er' a'J'e~Il'er'
:)Il1'"
n-\r)' 1~'; J ,,";0,' r
~'!',Ir" "rj"i I ''O'''c' :J~',
"(I 1I1V:1:;:',.o r'~L,' ....; l
2.: ~~,
I," "I')(J(' 011" 21::r'0 ':"'-:' "'I nr.:! S"rIlfnl ~f 'he 'C" ,. L,a." [1\' Hal:;tal Hl)Ill?nrt',"".11
'II"'" ,,)'.1'"
L;-.llIerl',.,' ~'fi'T
:'.-Y;(j!'.,~ ,,-\.', rr- tl'" ,'II" ')'In'
.' (:1'):'~
Meeting Date:
I'rcparl'd B}
F-ri1,',-RllrlSC\
:,'--1'; f",,~'~1T1 :.""'C;"lin'"
:.1,,"
Plmll~ Se"'llcc~
h('l'~''':: ami Mum,!;", :00rVIC'l
" i '20r:,~ \' 03' 11 ,\~.
Appr""cd By
~::,1rc\' ~,r"mPIIK
[llrccw
[,at,.-
"UllllcScrVIC""',
Hr'lJs",,, (;. H\Jmar ~NVlce"
1j'\1/20;,"l11,2IlAr.1
Approved B)
.lpffKlllllHG',.
;'5';15lanr C(}LJnl,'Att[)m~'.
LJ.11<
C[)Ut1tV A~wrne'
Count': AtlOrtlf"_' OfflC(
11i9:20074,o:,pr,'
Appruvcd H~
ril"'"'' r"'~""
"LJlHr: ('rvle'.' i",'" "'t~t,,-.tc
',.,,:,
C. LJ~, i : 'oC"'V':;V
"'ul.iir: S'.'rv'c~ ' ;,(1,,,,,
" 1~,'2(:r~ \' Jr,,;r:
ApIlmved B~
'jr-,-"c'::"'",,\;n,1\"
.,Um,,,,strO'
''''''''''"''\1',. '"'''.'(''0'''
.. ,,,:20l" '.:,~. pro
Approved Ii}
~.,.~rr "r\,(:
1'",,,,, """-.,'ll, I. :-';;1""'" '^"""v'
.),,,
',1''''''[ , \'~"~" ,h, ~)i"r'
":11 "'hr<<"'''''''''"'''"'!!,l"",,,,
I"PI.'
AIlpm\'l'dll)
,C"" , r:,uJ'
""',W
,wt.-
;:");",',,r':.OUI1'
,. '" ,I, ~,~, 0"'",-
",(eim! r;;~n~w" ')fhe
":G::>JC~ 30!' pro'
fiJe:IIC:\Ap:endaT est\Export\93- Novemher%2027. '%202007\ I 0, %20COUNTY%20MANA" 1 J /20/2007
Aaenda Item NO.1 OK
November 27. 2007
Paps ~I of 10
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with Guerline Mathien (Owner) for deferral of 100%
of Collier County impact fees for an owner-oeeupied affordable housing unit located at
Lot 13, Liberty Landing and authorizes a reimbursement of the fees paid by Habitat for
Humanity of Collier County Inc on Building Permit 2007020732 in the amount of
$12,442.52.
OBJECTIVE: That the Board of County Commissioners (Board) approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, the attached lien agreement with Guerline Mathieu for deferral of 100% of
Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied atfordable housing unit and authorize a
reimbursement of the impact fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc. in the
amount of$12,442.52.
CONSIDERATIONS: Article IV of Chapter 74 of the Code of Laws and Ordinances
established a program to defer impact fees tor qualified atfordable housing. Pursuant to this
program, an application for defernlent was submitted by Guerline Mathieu, which application,
after staff review, was determined to qualify for the program. Legal status has been verified and
doeuments are on tile at the office of Housing and Human Services. The property is located in
the Liberty Landing subdivision in Immokalee.
.-"
During staffs review of the file to process this deferral for approval it was determined that the
Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc did not provide an application for the deferral
progranl as a qualified developer prior to issuanee of the building permit and payment of
associated impact fees as requircd. Staff has discussed this oversight with the County
Attorney's Office and recommends that the Board accept the application letter from the
developer after-the-fact in order to complete the required paperwork and maintain consistency
with the Ordinance for this tile and deferral agreement. Upon approval and execution of this
deferral agreement and lien, impact fees paid by Habitat tor Humanity of Collier County Inc. in
the amount of $12,442.52 will be reimbursed.
The ordinance requires that a lien agreement be entered into with the applicant as a condition of
deferral of the impact fees. Section 74-401(3) of the Code authorizes the County Manager to
sign deferral agreements with applicants qualifying tor impact fee deferrals for affordable
housing, which has long been the practice. The ordinance, however, gives the County Manager
discretion in whether to enter into the Agreement. Accordingly, in keeping with recent
discussion and direction by the Board, the County Attorney's Office has determined that until
directed otherwise by the Board, these agreements be placed on the Consent Agenda for the
Board's review, approval and Chairman's signature.
FISCAL IMPACT: This agreement defers $12,442.52 in impact fees. Although it is expected
that the County will ultimately collect these deferred fees (generally upon the sale of the
residence), there is no guarantee as to if, or when, this would occur.
.~,
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: The proposed Agreement is fully consistent with the intent
and purpose of Section 74-401 of the Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collier County.
P,aenda asrr. I~(;. 1 m~
T\Jovember 27. 2007
2 Gf](I
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: That the Board approves and authorizes the Chairman to
sign the attached Lien Agreement for Deferral of 100% of Collier County Impact Fees for
Owner Occupied Affordable Housing Dwelling Unit for Guerline Mathieu located at Lot 13,
Liberty Landing and authorizes a reimbursement of the impact fees paid by Habitat for
Humanity of Collier County Inc on Building Permit 2007020732 in the amount of $12,442.52,
and any budget amendments that may be required associated to the reimbursement.
PREPARED BY: Frank Ramsey, SHIP Program Coordinator, Housing and Human Services
,.'
j\asnd2 iI8iT'; No, Ai OK
i'~oveIllDer =7, 2007
:) 0: ! C\
H.l.\Urp{"
l'rallklbm.r,\
(:llllierCoonh' IIII~
nUl L T~mlllmi Tnil
'~l'k,.I'lurj(j;, ,'411~
File# 118-061-IF
n'h'flU(l'IIlrn.('t,rdin;!
LIEN AGREEME!'<T FOR DEFERRAL OF 11111% OF COLLIER COUNTY IMPACT
FEES FOR OWNER OCC\JPIED AFFORDABLE HOUSI"<G DWELLING UNITS
Thi;, Agrecment is CnICf('d [nw lhi~~
da: of ()ctobCL .20Ci7. bt.:lwecn Collier Counly. ;J
political suhdivisioll or the StJl(,,' or Florid:.: ICOCNTY) JIlJ "Guerline !vlathicu" ((}\\,'NERl.
collectively staled as the "Parties:-
"'\O\V. THEREFORE. for good ami valuahle consideration. the receipt and sufficienc) of
which is mUlu:llly acknowh:dged. the Parties agree as J()llow,~:
I. This J.ien !\gn:emcnl is made purSUJO! tll Chapter 74 of the Code or La\vs and Ordinances of
Collier Coumy, Florida. known as '.The Collic[' Coul1ty Consolidated hnpacl Fee Ordimmec.'
(Ordinance!. In the c''ent or any contliu with this Agreemenl. the lerms of the Ordinancl'
shall arriy.
,
The iegal description orthe dwdiin~ unit i,; attached a" Exhihit I' \,"
TiK ieI'm (1:'thi~; A::crc\.'1l1cnl i:: h1111l the date :>et forth aO(l\l' umii tll:: ill11xlCt il".' is rqmiJ,
'-1 f'ht: al1l(lUllt pr the impa:,::', J~e;. lklCrrCG shall h..:.' )JuiJ h~ til,--' C!Jl "\'~'Y in lull up(n;: ;;1,1 1.h';'
sale of We d\\'t:llin~' unit: hl the reiinam:in(2 of [h~' dwdiilli-'- unit: () a los<. of UK homestead
exc11lptim~: or ell the llrsl UCCUlTL:')JCl' uf any sale or tr:lt1sfcr or '-Ill)' par, oC tIll' afrl:ctl~d rc:ll
rropel1Y. and in an} SU:;:!I C\Tl11 the dL.'f:"'fn::J impact fees shall be raid in full wthe COl '\:'TY
mlt later then tile el(lsing (lj' till' sail,'. or ll(ll later then the cfkcli"e dale oJ"thc trans]er. A:-; set
furth in i':xhibit "13:' the J,1110unt or the deferred impact fee:; I:; 'Iwel\'(' 'fhous;.md h1\d[
Ilundn:J Forty "]\',(1 and 52/1 ()()I)<1lJ_:.'ifs ,S 1 :.44.2.521. l(cpa;.'l11ent shall include any accrued
inten:st interest shall l1e com pUled at the rate of jIve pl'rcel11 <Y'i;)) rcr annum. but in no
event shall it exceed lWl'nty~llvl' pefcent (25u/I') of the wta] fee amount.
), The deferred impi.lCl kes silall he Ll lien on the prupeI1;: des;,:rilx:d in E:\hibit .'A:' which lien
ma} [1(' foreclosed upon in tile event or nun-compliance with the Ordinance or with this
:\gn:cmcnt. fhis Agreement sh~lll ()pcr:lic uS ~I lien at!-ainst the d\\cJlin~ unit. The lien shall
terminate upon the n:c:ording of a release or smisfaction or lien in the public records of the
Cntwty, rhe deferrab (If impact lees dud this ''\8"reclTlt:'nt shall run with lht' land. :md neither
the defern;'(: impa,:l rl'l'S nor this Agreement shall be transferred. assigned, or othef\\ise
convt'Yl'd, Lxcert as provided hy law. rcg:.mlless of an) fonx:iosurc on the' fIrst mortgag(.: or
other security interest. this lien shall otherwise be supcrint and paramount \0 the interest in
the dwelling unit or any owner. lessee, tenant. mortgagee. or 01her person. excepl that this
lien shall be on parifY with any lien for ('ounty luxe",
(J, \:pnnth~ S:lllsi';.lc!()f: completion of this Agreement's rl~quircmcnts. COL!\'T\' shull record
any lll'Cl'SS:ir') documentatIon evidencing same.
-
]n thl: C"vcnl1hc O\VNE!( is in defauit under the Ordinance or this A~fccmcnL and the default
is not cured \vithin J() days after writh:n notice is provided to the OW1\;1:R, the corl\rrv
l11a~. 3t its sole uption. collcet the impact fee amount in default a~ sel fnrlh 111 the Ordinance.
or hrin!:, a ci\iJ action to cnfurCl: thi~. Agn:cI11CI1L (lr dcdarc that the dcfcrn:d imp:Jct 1ces arc
':CW
~OCI~'
~; 0: ,,,
thcn m default ~lIJJ ltTImcJiml'l:- due und payuhlc. The CO! STY shall he ~'l1titlcd to rl'C()\'cr
;dl kcs and cosL. indudlllt: attornl'; .~: rl:l' anu cosLs. ineurrl'd h; t11(' COt il\"TY ill ent"orcill!'
thi" -,\~rl'CI11CnL plw; interest ~lt the then maximum st~ltlltnr:.. raIl' l(1r judgments e(llC'ulat~d on
~l calendar year hasis until jXllJ
X. This i\grc:.:mel11 i.<; the S(l1e (t~rccl11cnt bCJ\\'-ccn the p~H1ics \\iLh n:spU.'1 1(1 the sub.ice! 11l~ltler
11l'n:in. and shul] hl' hllldlnb' upon th'~' ()\\'''l-I,~'\ ,"ucces.~(lrs and assi~ns in intcrest.
Ii. rhi~ i\g-rce1llcnt shall he recorJeJ in the or'licial records or thc County ~lt no e(lst Lo lhe
c()[:!\TY.
1\' WIT'\ESS WUEREOF. the PaJ1leS han: executcd this At:rl'l'l1ll'n1 (1)1 the date alld year fir:-;\
abO\ c wrillcn.
::"ttest.
DWJ(illJ '. BRUCk. CkrL
IH ).\RD or CC lLl'\TY CU\l\'1lSSI())\ER~
('(IUJ1;:rz ((tli~'TY" J"l.ORI1JA.
H:-
1\;,
.1,\.\;1-::-, C()LI 1:.. C!!\!R\i:\'\'
iknu;\ Ci'':lj
( )\\'l\l],:
\VllnCS:-;l'~'
Print \Ll1\l'.'
(Ju~..'1'i I tl~' i\j;;1 itieli
(.1\\':\'1'1(:
\\'itl1l'SSl'S:
_!'""'(~,-: 1-, r;~ ~^-~.../~
Print NamL' l'JJ..~h,c_ h-IJ:,,':......:lr"J
~'[:\Tl; {li- FLOR]!)'\I
CClt'"T\' OF COI.L1FY}
Thl' fort"goill~ :\;,:n:Cl1lCllt WJ" <.ld~ml,\-kJgeJ h,:I(JH' Jl1<: tllJ' ,-b~ t\f
~007. \1: _~~_________ whu is persnl1ul!;' kll(l\Vn In me p1' hu~ nroduced
:J': PWtlf' nl' idcllli;y.
!"Olo\RIAI. SI.o\! i
T'"~~~~~::'
I ~~........ :-~ ~",.., '-',...."', ~..-.
/\ppro\ cd ,~<.; Ul j!lr~n - .-
and legal ~Ltplci~,nq"
~,..~~-~\,' I'
~"",..I/I\
.Jcffn.~\' A. Klatd~()i\\-
Clllcr.:\s~;ist;:ni,l (\~urlT\ \tt{1111,-'~
, .
Si~nature of Person 'r ukmp. .t\cknowlcd!,.':nll'lli
J<-ccumlllClld .\ppnl\';':!:
,- -- --
------
i\lar;:y Krumhil1~.'r\-'1P:\
1)]rc('[oT
{'nilic1' COlm]: ilousin1; and llulll:tn Scn iccc;
EXHlIlIT "A"
LEGAL IlESCRIPTIO!\
Lot 13. Libcr~' Landing. according to the plat thereof,
as recorded in IJiat Book 47. Pagc~ 71 through 73,
inclusive, of the Publil' Records of Cullier Cuunty. Florida.
EXHIIlIT"Il"
IMPACT FEE IlRlcAKUOWN
T)'pc of Impact Fce
A. EMS Impact Fc(.;
B. Correctional Facilities hnpacl Fee
C. Library lmpac.~t Fee
D. Community Parks Impact FcC'
r:. Regional Parks impact Fee
r. EducationJl Fa(~ilitics Systcln impact r:('e
(j. Road Impa;;l Fc~'
I J. GovernmCllt Building;., Impa(~\ J:Cl'
1. La"", Lnlorccmcnt Impact hx
TOTAl. IMI'ACT FEES
JAKt\rpw\'\:J
Aaenaa Item No. 101<
November" 2007
Page of ~I Ci
Amount Owed
$100.54
$6:2.14
S36g.1g
$75(J.OO
:bl.659.00
S:::.X62,()(;
J;6.(l5LJ.\JU
>4ll1.IiO
$171.61
~1 ::!A41.S2
.
.
iWr:1 I\c 0
2 ,-;
.~, D
September ~6. ~007
c\trn: Frank RJITIsc\
SHIP Program Coordinator
Collier County
330] E. Tamiami Trail
Health &. Community Services Building
'\aples. FL :q 11 ~
Re:
Impact Fee Reimbursement
Dcar Frank:
iiahitat ii.):" r-jUlTlLU1W\ C'Jlii~r Counr>. Jnc.. i:... r::qll~sling reimhursemcnl
for impac: fe':::.; paic through th:: impact Fee Defern:l Pro~ran1. l'ncsc fees
\\/('f(' paid ll;i from by Hai"'\1l31 for Humanil: ofColiier Coumy. inc.. in
order \() e~:r::Jn(' 1h:::' huijding process, how::.''':'''!' the fUlure own~T-; (or Ill;:'
prOjx:n:, c~udi;!'> for an lmp:lcl k~C' c.L:lCrral. Dts~rih(:cl:1:-; follows:
Gucrlinc Mathieu
3568 Liberty Way, Immokalec FL 34142
Permit # 2007020732
Piease feel hee tn contact Nonna LOfa (77S-0(j)6) if you have any
questions or concerns.
Sincerely.
Usa LefkO\\
Dn'elopmem Dircctor
Aaenoa Ilem I'lD. 10K
l~overnbe" :7. 2007
7 c:f- I C\
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR1103 - Official Receipt
'Trans Number
LL48749
i Date I Post Date
13/27/2007224:56 PM i 3/27/2007
i Payment Slip Nbr
I PT 2007020732
I
Address: 3568 LIBERTY WAY
Owner: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY COA#: 06-0220
Permit Type: BR2 Job Desc: FRAMED S/F ATT 1 STY-150 AMP-TWIN VILLAS
Applicant: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY-SAM
DBA:
Swr Meter: IMM Wtr Meter: IMM
Payor: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY OF COLLIER COUNTY INC
Fee Information
~g~lde '~~~~i~~~E CERT. S~~~-H~A~~~g~882~0~~~- - _ !__A~~:waived I
i 08BPIM BLDG PERMITS -IMMOKALEE '11313890032212000000 $55360T---
108CPMF COMM PK IMPACT FEE M/F 34611636336353031346 $75000__
~08EMMM-FTE:MS IMPACT FEEMiE___ [35014()47036353031350 $.10059 i J
Q8GBMF 'GOVT BLDG IMAPCT FEE M/F I 39012223136353031~90 $410,00 I .___1',
081ME~ IM,MOKALEE FIRE_II'v1~!\CT ._1130000QQ;!0985000000 $151404
08JU';FrJ~'iLIMPACTFEEM/F .38111043036353031381 [ $6214 I
08UlM'F1LlBRARYIMPACT FEE M/F -~---135515619036353031355 I $36818 ----I
OBLWMF-'LAW ENF IMPACT FEE M/F . . 38511043336353031385 jr- $17161
08MFR5 i DIST 5 ROAD 1.f\ilI'ACT FEE-MULTI~F.. 33916365936353031339 .. _ _ $6059,00
URCHARGE 11313890034144200000 $3.00 .\
T SURCHARGE , 11300000020880000000 $6,821
CTF-EEM/F '34611636336353031346 I $1659 00
RDIMPACT FEE . 1130000()02090500QOQO___~~111~2()0" I
I 12SITE ,SITE: INSPEC~I~~~]-&TNEERING::~i~~~;~;~;;~~1~8~~g~~ _.~. $m~ _ __
L08BACR BLDG, PERMIT APP, FEE CREDIT..JJ..1l..1389QQ3~2510000QO_ $-10009! 1
Total ___$14651.80
-
i 08MFSG MICROFILM S
I 08RDGS BLDG, PERMI
~RPMF REG PK IMPA
--'"-
~gHI SCHOOL BOA
'11PUDM PUD MONOT
- Continued -
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT
Printed 11/1/2007 8:36:28 AM
',.'.,.J
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR1103 - Official Receipt
Trans Number~. --'r5ate-- : Post Date---
748749 . _ i 3/27'/200722456 PM_~/27/2007
i Payment Slip Nbr
____ PT 2007020732
Payments
--1= ArT10untl
- _~ $146518O.l
i Payment Code
iCHECK
j Account/Check Number
1135!3~_
Total Cash
Total Non-Cash
,--- $0.001
c:::::11465180
$14651.80 i
Total Paid
Memo
Cashier/location: HILLCAROL 1 1
User POTIER_ T
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT
Printed: 11/1/2007 8:36:28 AM
Item N-:J. 10K
~,'" 2007
oi-l()
October 20, 2007
A Un: F rank Ramse~
SHIP Program Coordinator
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
RE:
Pernlit#:
3568 Libert) Way. lmmokalee, FL 34142
2007020732
Dcar Frank.
Habitat jix Hum:.lIlit\' of' Collier Count). Inc. per the C OUn1) Wide impact r'e"
Deferral Program. identifies the above referenced propeny as an aff()rdahie
housing unit. Pieuse let this letter serve as an aher-the-faCl application and
identification lh8t an income eiigiblc. le~al rcsidcm ()rth~' l :nited Slales vvill
occupy the propeny once compi~lc.
Habitat jc)l' Humanity ofColiier Count). Inc paid the Impact Fees upfront in order
\0 expcdite thc building process.
Please feel free 10 contact Norma Lora (77:'-0036) if vou have any quesIions or
concerns.
Sineerd1;':'
/
.,.~----
Saniuel Duiso. M.D
Presidcnt
Page lor]
COLLIER COUNTY
C~'Ar.LJ 0" ;::uur,'T', cor,1/."iSSiO~;:cr.;
Item Number:
Item Summary:
"""
-:;,';)
"'r'.."
1"1,.,
Meeting Dale:
I'rell:\n,d HI
~",,'I, """'15"
,,1'1'
.<:",,,,,,,,,..,.
:,"t'
ApproVl"d II)
!' ~,
";.'''0 I',,-U~'[)'W
1."""'('
1."11'
"em'" :""''''';C'';
H,">,,,,'1" S I,,,,,,c,,, ~,",v,tP
"jJ;;'il-' ":,3"^'"
Apprnvl"d IlJ
, '<-' f ~ V, J<<t.',,,) '.'
;,'S ",,1~"~ ;,.,,,"', ' ,',:l"rr>"
[')Jl'
r,rt(H
/'-,U"'-'H' ()'t" ,
";,',,':11, 'i ':'rJ~ "'\-"
AllproHdllJ
"":CJtr'
",JI',
,',"
Approved II,'
Apllruveu III
''',,,,
',L'"''''
,\ppmwdlh
Idj(~ "
",,,,
Jr',
file://C: \A~endaT est\Export\93- Nove111her(~o202 7.%202007\ 1 O. (%20COlJNTY%20MANA., 11/2012007
i~,qenao Item !'~r.::;. 10
f'~ov6mD8i' T( 20C)
PagE-: 'j of 1
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with Inel Tanis and Almonise Tanis (Owners) for
deferral of 100'\!0 of Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable housing
unit located at Lot 19, Block 14, Naples Manor Lakes and authorizes a reimbursement of
the fees paid by Habitat for Hnmanity of Collier County Inc on Building Permit
2007052698 in the amount of $26,240.68.
OBJECTIVE: That the Board of County Commissioners (Board) approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign. the attached lien agreement with Inel Tanis and Almonise Tanis for deferral
of 100'1" of Collier CounIy impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable housing unit and
authorize a reimbursement of the impact fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County
Inc. in the amount of $26.240.68.
CONSIDERA nONS: Article IV of Chapter 74 of the Code of Laws and Ordinances
established a program to defer impact fees for qualified affordable housing. Pursuant to this
program, an application for deferment was submitted by lncl Tanis and Almonise Tanis, which
application, after staff review. was deternlined to qualify for the program. Legal status has been
verified and documents arc on file at the office of Housing and Human Services. The property is
located in the Naples Manor Lakes subdivision in Naples.
.~.
During staff s review of the file to process this deferral for approval it was detemlined that the
Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc did not provide an application for the deferral
program as a qualified developer prior to issuance of the building permit and payment of
associated impact fees as required. Staff has discussed this oversight with the County
Attorney's Office and recommends that the Board accept the application letter from the
developer after-the-fact in order to complete the required paperwork and maintain consistency
with the Ordinance for tbis file and deferral agreement. Upon approval and execution of this
deferral agreement and lien. impact fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc. in
the amount of$26,240.68 will be reimbursed.
Section 74-202 of Article 11, Chapter 74 of the Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances,
the Collier County Consolidated Impact Fee Ordinance, 2001-13, as amended, provides for
specific criteria and procedures for processing routine and non-routine requests for impact fee
reimbursements. Specifically, as set forth by Section 74-202 (h) (5):
"All reimbursement requests totaling twentv~five thousand dollars ($25,000) or more,
cannot be approved administratively and must be submitted to the Board of County
Commi,,:;sioncr,\'. "
--
The ordinance requires that a lien agreement be entered into with the applicant as a condition of
deferral ofthc impact fees. Seetion 74-401(3) of the Code authorizes the County Manager to
sign deferral agreements with applicants qualifying for impact fee defcn'als for affordable
housing, which has long been the practice. The ordinance. however, gives the County Manager
discretion in whether to enter into the Agreement. Accordingly. in kecping with recent
discussion and direction by the Board. the County Attomey's Office has determined that until
directed otherwise by the Board. these agreemcnts be placed on the Conscnt Agenda for the
Board's review, approval and Chairman's signature.
Agenda Item r'~D. "10
f'Jovernber- :27. 200
Paqe 2 0" 1
FISCAL IMPACT: This agreement defers $26,240.68 in impact fees. Although it is expected
that the County will ultimately collcct these deferred fees (generally upon the sale of the
residence), therc is no guarantee as to if, or whcn, this would occur.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: The proposed Agreement is fully consistent with the intent
and purposc of Section 74-40 I of thc Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collier County.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: That the Board approves and authorizes thc Chairman to
sign the attached Lien Agreement for Deferral of 100% of Collicr County Impact Fces for
Owner Occupied Affordable Housing Dwelling Unit for Inel Tanis and Ahnonise Tanis located
at Lot 19, Block 14, Naplcs Manor Lakes and authorizes a reimbursement of the impact fees
paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc on Building Permit 2007052698 in the
amount of $26,240.68, and any budget an1endments that may bc required associated to the
reimbursement.
PREPARED BY: frank Ramscy, SHIP Program Coordinator, Housing and Human Services
1{~""'III"
,4,genda IE,;tT Nc.': O~
Ncwemne: T'. 200-:'
F'Cl9S ~-; :): "1 ["
I;rllllk Iblll~r.\
(Ulliu(:llunh'IIIIS
3.101 L T8mi~mi Tnli!
'"111",. FI"rilill34111
Fiic# n8-03()~1 F
"hi, 'flHCl' for n',~ordi,,::.
LIEN AGREEMENT FOR DEFERRAL OF 100% OF COLLIER COUNTY IMPACT
FEES FOR OVt'NER OCCUPIED AFFORDAIlLE HOI!SING DWELLING UNITS
This A!!reement is entered into this _~~_ day or ()clob~r. 2007. hetween Cnllicr County_ u
political subdivision of the Stale of Florida (COUNT'r') and "lnel Tanis and Almonise Tanis"
(O\VNER). collccri\c1y stated as the "Panics."'
NOW, THEREFORE, f(lr good and valuable consideration. the receipi and sufficiency of
which is mutually acknowledged, the Parti('s agree as i()llows:
J, This Lien Agreement is made pursuant to Chapter 74 of the Code of Laws und Ordinances of
Collier County, Florida known as 'The Collier County Consolidated lmract Fee Ordinance'.
(Ordinance). In the evem of any conflict with this Agreement. the terms or ll1e Ordinance
shaJI appl).
The legal description orthl: dv.dling unil i:; atiaeheu as Exhibit "AU
-. The teml or thi:; /\t'fcement is from the dale set i"orth annv:: until the irnrac,t fee is repaid,
.. The amounl ()r'th~' lmpacl fees dckrn.:d shall h~' paid 1(1 th~' ("(llJN'f\' in full upon: a:1 till'
sale o1'th:: dv..:eliing unit: h) the rdinancing of the dwcllmj,! unit: c) ,I loss or Ihc bomcswad
exemption: 01 d) thciirs! nCCUITenee of an~ s:.lk or transfer of an; part (lethe- affCclcd real
proper!) , and in any such (,.'venl th;: deferred impact fees shall he raid in full 10 tlK COUNTY
not later then the closing of tl1(' sa.k. or no! bl('r thL'Tl the effective date of the transfer. As set
torth in I:':xhibit "8," the amount of the deferred impact fees is Twenty Si\ 'l'housand 'T\'io
Hundre.d Fort\' and hS/HJO Dollar~_.i$26.2..1-O.6R). Repayment shal! include any accrued
interest. Inter::;;! shall he: comruted at the rale of fJvc rercent (51/;)} per annum, hut in no
event shaJJ it exceed twenty-five pereent (25%) of lhe 101~11 fee amount.
), The deferred impact fees shall he a lien on the property descrihed in Exhihit "A:' which lien
maY be foreclosed upon in the event of non-compliance witb the Ordinance or with this
Agreement. This Agreement shall operate as a lien against the dwelling unit. The lien shall
temlinatc upon the recording or a release or satisfaction of lien in the puhlie records or the
County. The deferrals of impact fees and this Agreemenl shall run with the land, and neither
the deferred impact fees nor this .Agreement shall he transrerr::d. assigned, or otherwise
conveyed. Except as provided by lav..-. regardless of any foreclosure on the first mortgage or
other sel.:urit) ill[l.:n:st. this lien shall othef\visc he superior and paramount to the interest in
the dwelling unit of any ov.;ner, lessee. Wnunt. mortgagt.~e. or other person. except that this
lien shall hc on parity with an:.-- lien j()[ Counly laxes.
6. Upon the satishlcto0' completion of this i\grccment's requirements. COUJ\TY shall record
any necessary documentation evidencing same.
7. In the event the OV./NER is in default under the Ordinance or this Agreement and the default
is not cured within 30 days after \-vritten notice is provided It) the OWNl-:R, the COUNTY
':-',;JS:1Jc! i~e:T1 )'\1:'. 'i ~
[\!(1Venlt')(;;;( 2; 20 -
ma:. at iL~ sole option. C()\lecl the impact fee ammml in JCI~\ult a" Sl't rllrth in the Ordinance.
or kill); a civil actinl1 tn enforcc this Agreement. or dcclarc thai thl. delCrred impact lees are
thell in dehlUlt and immcJiUll'l: due anu payahle. The C(lU\T~ shall he entitled t(1 rcco\'ct
all lees and costs, including allomey's l\:c and costs. inclIrn:u hy the COl:NTY in enforcing
..; 01
this Agreement. plus in wrest at the then maximum statlltllr~ rail' I'm iuu~!mc;nts calculated on
a calendar yt:ar basis until paid.
X. This Agreemclll is the soh: ai,!n:cmcn! hClwccn thl.: panit:s \I,-'ith respcct to the suh.iecL maUCT
hen:in, and shall be hinding upon the O\\'NER'S successors and assipls in interest.
q. This i\gn:cmenl shall he' reemJcd in tlK' nnicia\ rccmus (If the County at no cost \(1 the
COliNTY
IN \VITNESS WHEREOF. the Parties have cxcclIIcd this Agrcem~nt on the date and :'Car tirsl
ahove \I.,Tittel\.
.i\ttest:
DWIGHT 1. BlW[K. [ierh
fIO^RD OF cm 'NTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER CO\iNTY. ElDRIDA.
By:
By:
.I/\\1!'::-; ('(ll_t:rJ.^.. (,1IA]R!\1i\~'
. Dcnut:- CierI:
()\\,}.,(FR:
\\,'itncsscs:
l'nnl Na~lH_'
inl'l 'j am,
()\\'NFR:
Witnl'SSC;;:
Print I\ame Almonisc Tanis
STAlL OF IT,ORIDA)
cm INTY OF COU.IER I
TIlL fon:go1J1); Agreement \VUS acknnw!cdj!ed hclore ml' this da: or
2007. hL_":'__.~----'___"':'________n~:_---" who is personally known Iu me or has produced
_ ____~____ ____ ,_ ._____ as pro()roriucntil~
,~+l;tillJ.ALSMU:'JJ.
----~~---- -- -~~.-
Signature or PersOll lukinl:!- Ackno'vvlcdgment
"?L'V''^'''^''_-'-.'~',;,'''-.'''''''-''VV
Appwved as no form
und legal sptli~i(;!lcy;
~::~
Rel:nmmend Appnlval:
Jeffrey A. KJavkov.
Chief Assistant COutll~ Attornc:
"Marcy Kmmhllll'. MP A
Director
Collier Count: HOllsmg and Human Services
EXIIIBIT "A"
l4.,~enca Ilem i'~c'. ~iOL.
!\JQvembe; 27. 200"";'
F'ags S of '1 ('I
LEGAL IlI'SCRlI'TIOr>
Lot 1 (). mock 14, NaJ)ics Manor L:tkcs. according to thl' Plat then'of as recorded in Plat Book
3, rage H(, and 87, Public Rccord~ of Collier Coun!} , Florida.
EXfllBIT "Il"
IMPACT FEE BREAKDOWN
Type of impact Fee
Amount Owed
A. EMS impact Fcc
$100.59
B Com:ctional Facilities Impact Fce
$149.3H
C. Library impact r:~e
$460.23
II Community Parks hnracl Fcc
$935.00
L. Rcgiol1i.l1 Parts impact tel'
~~.l)6X.(JO
!-'. Educational Fucilities System Inmacl Fee
$i:.:2H.00
(i. RO;ld Impact Fee
$().359.00
I:. (iovcrnmen! Bui]ding~, Impact h::l'
~;72:"Jl!i
Law Lnhm.:cmcnl impact Fe~-'
~~2X5A~;
S~'\\n s,\'s!cm l'cl'
S_~"~ 1 S,(H!
K. Vl'iJlCf' System ITl'
1:.;.-+ 15.00
TOTAL IMPACI FEES
$2b.240.61o;
I.-\L/\I'prtwcd
.
.
it-2i:: h:c,j _
'inn-
~" 0
S~ptember -:'.2007
AUn_ j-rank Ramse\
SI Ill' Program Coordinator
Collier Count)
,,01 f' Tamiami Trail
Health 8: Communi!\ Services Building
"aples. IT ~-11 1=
Rc:
Impact ret' Rcimhurst'ment
UC:J1 Frank'
lJ:J.h]~al Cur t-tulllil11ll: OJ' Cullier Cuunty. 1nc.. i~ r~'(Jlleslin~ reimbursemenl
lei:' 1n11X1:':: fet> raId lhrull~i~ the lrnr;Jc~ r~t' !);:,'fcrn:1 Pro~nJm. These 1'2:;",'
\\'ere paid llr non., \1:- ;-L:hit2.t J(y- }lunl~mjl:' C1:'Col]i~:' COUl11;. inc.. in
order III (.'\.]l:.,:dill' the huildm,g, prCl':':C:';:~:_ ])(1\\':,'\'21' rh-:.' fUIUf(' n\\1~C'~':: for :h:;.'
proper:; qU~liif:- for an impact fee dekrraL Dcscrihcd a;.; f()llov,'s:
Inel &: Almnnise Tanis
5373 Trammel Sl, Naples FL 34113
l't'rmit # 2007052698
Please feci fiee 10 contact Norn13 Lor3 (77'-00:;(>) iJ'VOll have any
questions or concerns.
Sincerely.
.~
~_.
Nicolas Koulohcras
Land Development Director
Aoenda :tem "'JC'
f~overnbe~ 27.
c'aoe ,
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR 11 03 - Official Receipt
r Trans Number ~..::J Date _. ~- I Post Date 1 Paymen~t Slip Nbr
767237 __'pI512007 1042:07 A~~200L_~2007052698
=1
I
,
Address: 5373 TRAMMELL ST
Owner: FRAMED SIF 1 STY VILLA COA # 07-0356
Permit Type: BR2 Job Desc: FRAMED SIF 1 STY 150 AMP SINGLE VILLA
Applicant: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY
DBA:
Swr Meter: SC Wtr Meter: CC
Payor: HABITAT
Fee Information
l~:~g~lde ~~~~i~~~~CERT SURCHAR~E~-:-1~1L3~ggg~~~OB82000000 --=~ A~~~~ ~Walved
i 08BPNp_ BLDG PERMITS - NAPLES__ : 11313890032211000000- ...=L:. $563~
LQ,8C!"SF i COMM PK IMPACT FEE SIE_~._' 34611636336~51031346 . _ $935.00
'OBEMSF I EMS IMPACT FEE SIF i 35014047036351031350 -- 1 . $1005~
08ENTM 'EAST NAPLES FIRE IMPACT- 11300000020982000000 , . $30800 . -~- .
i 08GBSF GOVT BU:JG IMf'ACTFEE SIF_ 139012223j36351031390----i_::_ $725.001 .1
108JLSF i JAIL IMPACT FEE SIF i 38111043036351031381 : -- $149-:381----~
108LBSF .' L1BRARViMPACT FEE SjF=-: =r 35515619036351 031355.~--..---;-' ..~.. $460~L~.1
! 08LWSF{LA.W ENF IMP. AC. T FEE SIF_ . 3851104..3336351031. 385-+-~ $285A8 _ .
08MFSG . MICROFILM SURCHARGE 11313890034144200000 ---1- $3.00' i
~BDGS . [3LDG PERMIT SURCHARGE== 1 113000000208800000QO ' $7.00. . --.
. 08RPSF~_--lREG PK IMPACT FEE SIF ..... 34611636}36351Q31.3~-l $2068~._
. 08SCHI . SCHOOL BOARD IMPACT FEE i 11300000020905000000 I $822800 i _ '
! 0~SFR4 1 DIST 4 RQADIMPACT FE_E-SING~~ i 336J636533635t031336 -- I $635BOO_L___-:=j
i 12SITE i SITE INSPECTION-ENGINEERING i 13113832732249000000 ! $150.001 i
@MTTP ~OUNTY METER TAP CHARGE:____~_ 14082532123~3i6ooooo ~ .. $6:7600' __-=1
!42SSDC ,SEWER SYST!':M CHARGE_ 41326361334356031413 . __$3515:001 i
42WSDC WATER SYSTEM CHARGE 41127351134336031411 -r $341'tOQ+ ,
10BBACR 1 BLDG. PERMIT APP~]:'EE C_REDIT_ 1-11313890032251900000-=--:---. $-10000' -----1
Total . i~_~2785~---
- Continued -
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 951NT
Printed:111112007 8:39:17 AM
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR 11 03 - Official Receipt
!Trans Number
1767237
--------
. __1 Payment Slip Nbr
. ___lPT 2007052698
i Date
16/5/2007 10:4207 AM
Post Date
I 6/5/2007
--,
.=-=--1
Payments
-_.- _..,.._--~-
Payment Code ~ AccounVCheck Number
CHECK [14201 .___
Ar;'-Ou-n~
~2785488 ,
Total Cash
Total Non-Cash
$0.00,
$2785488
Total Paid
$27854tl~
Memo:
Cashierllocation: MURPHYLlNDA / 1
User POTTER_ T
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT
Printed:11/1/2007 8:39:17 AM
.p.;:]enca Iter.: l\iO. 10L
Novembe: 27. 20CI/
;:'-'aae;; of 1C)
October 29. 2007
Attn: Frank Ramsey
SHIP Program Coordinator
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples. Florida ~4112
R"'.
L..
Permit #:
5373 Trammel Strcet. Naples. F1 34113
200705269B
Dear r rank.
I Jabilal for Jiumanil: or Collier COUnl.'. lnc. p'.:r lh~' County 'A'-ide: impac.'l Fee
Deferral Prog:r~UTl. iden1ij~'.:.'''-lhc Jhovc rc:ferenced rr\)per1.' :J<; an uffordahl;:.'
hnusinf' unit. P]c~tSt' lc: thi" leiteI' sern: as an ~ltlcr-lhc-bct 3flpJicarioli and
identificzni(lli that In lllCO!11C eligihk. iegal rcsidcr1: (If lht' l nilcd Slates \vi]j
occupy the property once C0n11,kk.
Habitat j()[ Humanity of Collier COUl11). lnc paid the Impact Fees upfrol1l in
order 10 expedite the buildin~ process.
Please fcel fret' 10 contact Nunna Lon! (77.5-()O~(,) iJ".'ou ha\"c any questions or
concerns.
Sincerelv.,
/'
~~~
Samuel Durso. M.D.
President
Page 1 (If
I"".
COLLIER COUNTY
'\U' 1il;' -,~,-
YJ'
8(.lAFW C' ,~ClUNT\' COMMISSIONERS
ltem Number:
Item Summary'
"~""f,"'1;;"
'"u:'l";r;=p
: J;-~ ('.I'
";'1;'" "l<-,""(;f:h f<-,,"
"::".J:','
Meeting Date:
I'repuNl B~
M""""
"'i:'" -'-"n',,'" C,O(.l''-',n~'"
L"",
~LH,k Coc'.' 'c~'
otiC" ,one: ",urn,,,' C:,C".''''''
: '(,/21' -, ~"1 1 11; .4~.'
Approved R\
r-i,,',~' f,nnTI
,'''<'-;;W
"'1'
hml,: ,",,"
'i,v'"n,1\.H'.mnr::,nvl(.i."
";:!L";
1\1,'
Approved U~
.,.,1: ",I~l?hl\'
o',,,,s;Jn',.00Jlll' i"tt(;
_""",;";"'11'>",'
.lc>"" ',,'c
~:r,.: F-',
ApprovetJ u)
"'1,
Approwdll)
Apprnn"d II~
Apprlln"d B~
file~!IC:\AgendaTest\Export\93- Novemher%2027. %202007\ 1 0.%20COUNTY%20MANA,.
11/20/2007
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Agenda Item NO.1 OM
t~ovember 27.2007
Page 1 of 10
,."-
Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with Nicolas Huerta Lara and Juana Cortes Alvarez
(Owners) for deferral of 100% of Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied
affordable housing unit located at Lot 16, Trail Ridge and autborizes a reimbursement of
the fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc on Building Permit
2006064377 in the amount 0[$13,616.20.
OBJECTIVE: That the Board of County Commissioners (Board) approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, the attached lien agreement with Nieolas Huerta Lara and Juana C011es
Alvarez for defeITal of 100% of Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied affordable
housing unit and authorize a reimbursement of the impact fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of
Collier County Inc. in the amount of $13,616.20.
CONSIDERATIONS: Article IV of Chapter 74 of the Code of Laws and Ordinances
established a program to defer impact fees <<)1' qualified aJTordable housing. Pursuant to this
program, an application f()r defennent was submitted by Nieolas Huerta Lara and .Juana Cortes
Alvarez, which applicatio]1, after staff review, was determined 10 qualify fix tbe program. Legal
status has been verified and documents arc on file a1 the office of Housing and Human Services.
The property is located in thc Trail Ridge subdivision in Naples.
During staffs review of the file to process this defelTaI for approval it was determined that the
.,..- Habitat f()r HWllanity of Collier County Inc did not provide an application tClr the defelTal
program as a qualified developer prior 10 issuance of the building permit and payment of
assoeiated impact fees as required. StaJfhas discussed this oversight with the County Attorney's
Office and recommends that the Board accept the application letter irom the developer after-the-
fact in order to complete the required paperwork and maintain consistency with the Ordinance
for this file and deferral agreement. Upon approval and execution of this deferral agreement and
lien, irnpact fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc. in the amount of
$13,616.20 will be reimbursed.
The ordinance requires that a lien agreement be entered into with the applicant as a condition of
deferral of the impact fees. Section 74-401(3) of the Code authorizes the County Manager to
sign deferral agreements with applicants qualifying for impact fee deferrals for affordable
housing, which has long been the praetice. The ordinance, however, gives the County Manager
discretion in whether to enter into the Agreement. Accordingly, in keeping with recent
discussion and direetion by the Board, the County Attorney's Office has determined that until
directed otherwise by the Board, these agreements be placed on the Consent Agenda for the
Board's review, approval and Chairnlan's signature.
FISCAL IMPACT: This agreement defers $13,616.20 in impact fees. Although it is expeeted
that the County will ultimately collect these deferred fees (generally upon the sale of the
residenee), there is no guarantee as to if, or when, this would occur.
"",.-
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: The proposed Agreement is fully consistent with the intent and
purpose of Section 74-401 of the Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collier County.
/\oencia Item hi01 ,Jfv1
~t\jovember 27, ';::007
, .. Paqe 2 of 1 (}
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: fhat the Board approves and authorIzes the Ch31rrnan to'sign
the attached Lien Agreement for Deferral of 100% of Collier County Impact Fees for Owner
Occupied Affordable Housing Dwelling Units for Nicolas Huerta Lara and Juana Cortez Alvarez
located at Lot 16, Trail Ridge, Naples and authorizes a rcimburscment of tbe impact fees paid by
Habitat for HUm311ity of Collier County Inc on Building Pemlit 2006064377 in the amount of
S13,616.20, and any budget amendments that may be required associated to the reimbursement.
PREPARED BY: Frank Ranlsey, SHIP Program Coordinator, Housing and Human Services
Rttnrnto
/\genda item I~o. 10M
November 27, 2007
Page 3 of 10
lir.ilkRllm~tY
ClIlIirrCounty IIIIS
JJllI t. TlImillmi Trtil
NaJllt~< H"ridll34TI2
l'i1e# 08-027-IF
TbiSSI:NKt' r"r rfcordin!:
LIEN AGREEMENT FOR llEFERRAL 01' 100% OF COLLIER COUNTY IMI'ACT
FEES FOR OWNER OCClIPlEll AFFORllABLE HOlJSING DWELLING UNITS
This Agreement is entered into this _-""'--=_ day of October. 2007, between Collier County, a
political subdivision of the State of Florida (COUNT"{) and "Nicolas Iluerla Lara and Juana Cortes
Alvarez" (OWNER), collectively stated as the "Parties,"
NO\'\/, THEREFORE, for good and valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of"
which is mutually acknowledged, the Purtil.'.<, agree as I;J]]ows;
L This Lien AgTc~~rnent I::; maul' pursuantlo Chaph:r 74 of the Code of Laws and Ordinancc'; of
Collier Coumy, Florida, knDwn as' rile Collier County (on,;olidatt'd Impact Fee (Jrdmunce"
(OrdinanceJ. In the t.'"\'t:nl (If '-lny conflict with this '\~r(,'cmenL the lenns ur the (Irdinancc
:-;hall apply,
rhc legal dt':~;lTiption oftllc' ciwdlirW uni: is altacill:d ;J:' Exhibit"
., nil' tenT\ ()fthl;': /\r!rl~cmcnt i~; fnlJT] the date sc~ r~lrlb !ih(1\-C urnillhe imp,K.i fee is n.'piliJ.
4 The allJouni (,If the impaCl it.X.':, uC\(:rrcd .'jhalj iK' paid te, lilt: C( II. NT\' Hi i-uL upon: Ui the
sale of the dwelling. unit; b') the refinancing or the d\ve!ling unit; C) u. lOSt; of thl' homestead
exemption: or J) the first (lCcurrcncc of allY sale or transfer of any pm1 of tbe affectvd real
property, and in any such eVent the deferred impact fees shall ht, paid in full to the COUNT'{
not IBter then the closing ofLhe sale. or not later then the e1Tective date of the transfer. As set
forth in Exhihit "B," the amount of the deferred impact fees is Thirteen Thousand Six
Hundred Sixteen and 20/1 00 Dollars ($ I 3.6 1 6.20). Repayment snail include any accrued
interest. Interest :-;hall be computed Bt the rate of five- percent (5%) per annum, but in no
event shall it exceed twenty-five percent (25%1) of the total fee amount
5. The deferred impact fees shall be a ljen on the property described in Exhibit "A:' which lien
may be foreclosed upon in the event of non-compliance v.-lth the Ordinance or with this
Agreement. This Agreement shall operate as a lien against the dwelling unit. The lien shall
terminate upon the recording of a release or satisfaction of lien in the public records of the
County. 'Ole deferrals of impact fees and this Agreement shall run with the land, and neither
the deferred impact fees nor this Agreement shall be transferred, assigned, or otherwise
conveyed. Except as provided hy law, regardless of any foreclosure on the first mortgage or
other security interest. this lien shall otherwise be superior and paramount to the interest in
the dwelling unit of any owner, lessee, tenant, mortgagee, or other person, except that this
lien shall he on parity with any lien for County taxes.
6. Upon the satisfacior:y completion of this Agreement's requirements, COUNTY shall record
any necessary documentation evidencing same.
7. In the event the O\VNER is in default under the Ordinance or this Agreement, and the default
is not cured within 30 days after written notice is provided to the OWNER. the COUNTY
Aqellda item No 1 mVI
\Jovember 27,.2007
Page 4 of 10
may, at its sole option. collect the impact fee amount in default a..<; set forth in the Ordinance,
or bring. a civil action to enforce this Agreement. or declare that the deferred impact fees are
then in default and immediately due and puyab1c. The COUNTY shall he entitled to recover
all fees and CllstS. induding attorney's fee and costs. incurred by the COUNTY in enforcing
this Agreement. plus interest at the then maximum statlltory rate {<II judgmenb caicuJated on
a calendar year ba"is until paid.
R. This Ag.reement is the sole agreement between the parties with respect to the subject matter
herein. and sh<'lll he binding upon the OWNER'S suc.cessors and assigns in ImcresL
9. This Agreement shall hl' recorded in the.' otTicial records or the County ;1t no cost 10 the
CO\!J\TY.
IN \\-'ITNESS \VHEREOF. thL' Parties have cxccll\ed lhis Agreement on tbe daw and :"~~ar lirst
above \\Tl11en.
Attest:
;),^,'!C;HT
!JO.\IW OF CUUN!Y COMMISSIONERS
COI ,I ,1l.:R COl. :1\1TY _ 110RID/\..
IHUlCK. Clerk
p",'.
n',
_ r kput\. Cieri;
.L.\1"\'!FS cnl.!' '!.\ 11.'\II(IVj/,-)~
()\;"r~rJ~:
WiTne;;si:s;
_. ;<~"'i '.'-.'~. ',. ' w___~__..._
Pri~l t'-bn;c_._~~SL.jJJ _~~c '~!;Lj~~~>/" --.
,
_"'''_-~__"'____:~:~_''_L____ '-
Nicolas Huena Laia
OWNER:
\\"itnesses:
,,/j/j
/ /~.(A.-
Print Name. ".j
__I
T
._~.:.~-_.
_~;:i;::__,:~no;-- ~__':'N/" ;-e. \ A
Juana Cortes Alvarez
,,14._
.',-/'~ (,j~
i/'-I:,-
STATE OF FLORIDA)
COUNTY OF COLLIER)
. . ,-'J> Fl 12
The (oregoing,Agrec.ment was acknowledged before me- this __.71 day ofL.::~:~.__.
2007, byf\/,/,.ifi c, l+ut...eh1-' , who is personaJly li.noV\'l1 to me or has produced
J ,-,-,,.,...i,... t~r tP":;' ,), "as proal 011dcntltv.
...~.._-~-----'-~-'-~"' .
~OTARI, .' AL]
"PO "_' ',,', -' .,.'1 '_;
~)\A"Il\\tH"P.:::,-~:,:<
I "'-I.'. "11'!."."',\'.W",'U",,!I"".';'-,
>,,"'~ilr ~"'),II:I<',;u" - :"",'
S ~':,;;,:~;",,( ; ,;. ,,,,.,,,,"
" .;' ,/
i ,J .J i
/> Ir r r2 {1 f' .>('-1'--_
~S1g,Mure of Person Taking Acknowledgment
i j
,
j
Appn:L e.d a,. to form
and le,~l!! {\.:~
\;;,,'-t.~__..
.Jeffrev A. Klatzkow
Chicf~A~~istarLt County Attomev
I . . .
'{
Recommend AJV'roval:
i i
i. \!
\-" ~-......,--\ ,A.-, ~/
,....'Marcy Krumbihc. 'MP A
Director
Collier County Housing and Human Services
EXHlHlT"A"
LEGAL IlESCRIPTION
Lot 16, Trail Ridge, according to the plat thereof,
as recorded in Illat Book 44, Pages7) through 77,
inclusive, urthe Public Records of Collier County, Florida.
EXHIHIT "Il"
IMPACT FEE BREAIWOWN
Type of Jmpal't Fec
A. EMS Impacl Fee
R Correctional Facilities impact Fcc
C. Library Impact r:ce
D. Community Parks Impact Fcc
F. Regional Parh,: Impac! f'cc:
r hmlCaliona: hu.:iiilic::; Sy:';lcrn Impact 1 ,-.,
(j Road Jmp:u.:: r'c:.:
! L Ciovcrnmcnt Budding" impaci Fe~'
1. La\'.' [:,nforccmcnt Impact Fcc
J. \)/aler Impact Fee
K. Sewer Impact r:ec
TOTAL IMPACT FEES
IM,Appwvcd._J"l
Agenda Item No. 10M
November 27. 2007
Page 5 of 10
Amount Owed
$100.59
$62.]4
$368.1 B
$75U.00
$1.6.5QOO
tg27.00
~;;3. n 1.00
$150.24
$83.05
$2.760.00
$3.125.00
$13,616.20
'-'-'~---"._...,_.,~..".._,-_..
"c,n
>:,:<,:1 Ff,
'c'\,
.,~n' nC
!,H~. .~.
hiUj"rn
td;"j,,~v! ;: \: ('<;
:'('1,. ; r\~3.;,.."C';1.
: \ ;1
1:':',\1 !';;.,r~-::U71
D:?1,'rd >';:rh, L'.t_!
,r;:' ,: ~-2 ~:,;; i
!'('!C; :~Oj,,!1.0
\..Ji:>'; :1rl(;,.<
>';',llt(('i;!
.,., .r
\.t~ .,,"'~;
i-<;~ (1 1\:" ...,
il
.
.
Agenda item NO.1 OM
November 27, 2007
Page 6 of 10
," 'e
'^,"
iii""
,'1:;
August 22. ::'007
A11n: Frank Ramsey
SHIP Program Coordinator
Collier Count)
.'301 E. Tamiami Trail
Health & Comn1unity Services Building
:\aplcs. F'f ~4 1 -1 ~
Rc:
Impact Fee Reimbursement
Dcar ;:':-ank:
i Libit;1;
(,~ ',--- ~-lllic:;' i,_ ,Lmn nc. .~; rl~(l\Jc:;1.mg :c~rnht.::'::';~:-Tlen~
"'Y' imna'~:!j(;(~:;
th;'(Ju~j; ~!l(' l!llna':':l )'c..:.'v
:'h ::~';(;.'
,,",:ere p(lid up frunt ~~, Hahitat f()j' H;Jnlanjt~ or Collier County, Inc.. in
order to expedite the \luiJdinf; process. howc\'c:- the future owners for the
propert:' qualify (elf an impact fee deferral. Described as follov,,'s:
Nicolas Huerta Lara & Juana Cortes Alvarez
13344 Covenant Rd., Naples FL 34114
Permit # 2006064377
Please feel free to contact Norma Lora (775-0036) if you have any
questions or concerns.
Sincerely,
~~7 ~'/ /~.,/ ~
// .' ~/ :-;///
'/ '~'>>Y' '{%:'0: 2.--~
Nieolas Kouloberas
Land Development Director
:~ ~ ;', ", ~~ i :
,>,
, ." ;",\'< _..- -'" .,."'.
,":,'.11., ,'<: "_"1'. f1, l ((~ f ;; i,' ~
:~;L:f;"Jl!!<.z:'::,
Agenda Item NO.1 OM
November 27,2007
Page 7 of 10
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPRll03 - Official Receipt
iTrans Number
i 6948?2 __
r Date . ~=---=--~--YostDaie-
i 8/15/2006 2:38:41 PM r 8/15/2006
,__~?a}'mentSliP Nbr::=-===:J
...~.JPT 2006064377 __..____ !
Address: 13344 COVENANT RD
Owner HABITAT FOR HUMANITY OF COA #: 05-0717
Permit Type: BR2 Job Desc: FRAMED S/F ATT 1 STY-150 AMP-TWIN VILLAS
Applicant: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY-SAM
DBA:
Swr Meter: SC Wtr Meter: CC
Payor: HABITAT FOR HUMANITY OF COLLIER COUNTY INC
Fee Information
i Fee Code_! Qescription ". .. . ..... :___....=______Gl.ACCOl!~! _--- , -A,i,ount ! walv~cLj
I ~:~g~~ .~~ggg~~~lf~~~~~I:1ARG~ -Ti1ili~~~~;~~~t~~~~~~= .t-:~~~F==j
lJl~CPMF J.S:Orv1M PK IMPACTfEErv1/F__J 34615640236353031346 , .-.:J__E50.00 ____.:
'08EMMMFrEMS IMPACT FEE M/F . i 35014047036353031350 .' $10059, ...r
r-08.ENIM lEAST N.A. PLES FIRE IMPACT '."111300000020982000000 'r... $300,681-- '-~.1
~c:;_BMF i GOVTI3!,DG IMAPCTFE",- MlF_~39012223136353031390 n _, $15024.C.:-......- =~
08JLMF JAIL IMPACT FE;.E M/F 38111043036353031381.. $62.14 i..--.j
,08LBMF LIBRARY IMPACT FEE M/F 35515619036353031355: $368.18 i i
'08LWMF r LAW ENF IMPACT FEE M/F '- 38511043336353031385 - '-,----'$83.05E 1
'_08MFR'4-', DIST 4 ROAD IMPACT FEE-=-MUL TI-F -33616365636353031336 - $3731,00 ==l
08MFSG M
08RDGS BL
. 08RPMF RE
i 0!1.~9:1L._ SC
llPUDM PU
12SITE SI
42MTTP , CO
42SSDC SE
142WSDC I W
[Q8-SACR I BL
._~..- 111313890034144200000 _..~
ICROFILM SURCHARGE - ,~~
DG.PERr.AIT SURCHI'.RGE 11300000020880000000 $6,82
G PK IMPACT FEE M/F ----- 34615640?36353031346_.,.._ $1f)59.00 =l
HOOLBOA~QIMPACTFEE 11300000020905000000 i $827.00
D MONOTORING FEE ! 13113890432248900000 "',:] $75.00
TE LNSPECTION:E-",IGINEERING. . 13113832732249000000 $150.00 '-------,
----j
UNTY METER TAP CHARGE 40825321234332000000 $221,52
WER SYSTEM CHAR.G.L...., 41326361334~~6031413 $3125,00
ATER SYSTEM CtfllBGE ~.. - 41127351134336031411 $2760.00 -,
DG, PERMIT APP. FEE CREDIT 11313890032251000000 $-100.00
Total $14833,04
- Continued -
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT
Printed:ll/l/2007 8:53:56 AM
/\qenda Item "0. 10M
i,ovember 27. 2007
Page 8 of 10
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR1103 - Official Receipt
~~;~~umber~~1 ~/~~2006 23841-P~-__ .L~/~~~--"--l~f=~~~ -~_~_ J
Payments
~t{"Ce;t Ggde~__L~~~ntlCheCk Nu'mtler
---l-- _ Amount.
'_----.114833.004 '
Total Cash
Total Non-Cash
$O.Qgj
~1483304l
Total Paid'
$1483304
Memo:
Cashier/IDeation: HILLCAROL I 1
User: POTTER_ T
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT
Printed:11/1/2007 8:53:56 AM
Agenda Item No. 10M
November 27,2007
Page 9 of 10
.:..,(".
~;<:dh H:'ll:
lUll
Hv
m;J:!" ',,,'
;iil'(!f'fi!^"';'""",,
o "-.:'-';"ri
:,.':'r:-'Ol;',
i1T'
;;<:t~'i:. iliiIei'
\1.: October 29,2007
;-)t-
Ann: Frank Ramsey
SHIP Program Coordinator
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples. Florida 3411:~
RE
Cov(:,nanl f,oad. Naples. FI _:;~-] ] 4
2006064i77
Permit #:
Dear Frank.
HJl::lJtat
t)!' ('JI
"iHmT~ ]nz.:. Pl'T :JH.: (>HJI11\ \),.
Deferral !).rcIgratTL lucnlific:; lilt, ,lDUVC l\.:j:~rence(i propcn:~ ~iS an i-ll'fordablc
housing unit. PJc:1SC let this lcTter sc:nc a::; an CiTler-lhc:.iaCl applicmion and
ident.ification that an incClme eligible, resident of the UniIed States will
occupy the property once complete.
Habitat for Humanity of Collier County, Inc paid the Impact Fees upfront in order
to expedite the building process.
Please feel free to contact Norma Lora (775-0036) if you have any questions or
concerns.
r h. i-f SincereI~:J'.. /'.?<'
- -,-/...' ~/ "/ ;/
',\ill;":1I IIP,:iLl'''' .,.::.//:/. ...... //7 .
/ / ,'~ g"//, " /' ---
" ,/ .. '(. 'v"- /,<:/ ../'., ",/' ..__-
/.- , ;."' /",/ --
, /~/-----
.. ifLl Samuel.Durso,~.
1"10' 'J?I'e.}iQ~l1t
'<r;-n,'t(-
i~.Ihn \Jdk;
:';k;\ i.f!,2,~~
,)'\ i,;,-:i tz;,;.,h,
',' ,"'"
;",,' ,';J r.~ :Hli
F'r\t'f :SOt,l:~(,;
'; \; ,.~ .. 'i;; ..
:,:,<..,'i:t
\ itl, \-\ ,~'rn('~
;,,' \i" \'~"
.,-, "-,,....u nuT:',';:;! F25t(
HYi-,7
:',-o's.{JtYi6 ~:::J;t;,773,ni477 r',:L\:,i
. nd u r~'~{}';;'h th(~(~lJ i e r ,COIn
\cV\',."Vv',h,i.i
Page] of I
:"C)"nd;' \t,.~I~!\k 'iry.J1
'['io\8mb8!
P8g~-' :0
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF :OllNTV COMMISSIONERS
lIemNumber:
'JM
Item Summary;
1_ (~(1C'ln'"
'; t~i3' '['I( :';':'<3r'; n' '-,G :'11, ,- O'Ttrn:OSionH', ;)[)(:ry}p' "no "l:~ho' "i<. :n,"
"I<wrr,;;!' IC
,~r 'J'Y0ell"'I.' ,.'1 ., ~," " 'i'" ,.,"'..... ._,'h. :Jll(' Jeli; ,. crtSe. f\ 'Olc;:'
t.y
nill!" 1f~':JY" "J' ,J' "r "r W:'j9C; ,.,:Inrd"h,<"
,.. '''1'''' "n: I "il~.'" :'l' '1",
": 1 ~1 (1(" -, d l;!I: ",,-
rel"":~l em W1 >'He :,,~, ,'-<,e:
,_I,,~ ,,,_j '(" -, "I ',' rnl
ii:
"'['II:'I"',F'FI""
",,,.,,,,.")"1"
Meetlpg Date:
.[.)
l'rc[Jar~d By
F,c",l:R.2m"t'y
,~HIP P'e,WJrT1 cu",,!>r>.'!';"
~)at"
,.),"-',:~ "Ct, ,""~h
"'Inn ~r'r' ;.;\WU'
"''-;'2f'(,'-
~f: .',r"l
AllproHd By
1'.'LJI'n,n"
",-,,,C"lC
';11. j'",
";'()-
\r'llrnn'dlh
\pl'ru\,'u B)
"I'I'''',''ed jl,
,\pprn\'\'d B~
'-'" ''',a,<,,---,",'
-, 1'"";)"3;'1'.,,,,... -,,"_H'"
:n:;-
'f'
Approved By
,JR.;'e'_\'N,u.-:d
;;"uni"r"an;.1tjet
~J;o1.:
f-,.o~rd()">_"m'__-
("'W1\\, r,"~nJ:""c'-, (jIf'~f.
11!161200'7' ,~2 e>M
-::<lrl'f\1I,' s '0 n"~5
fi1e:/iC:\Af:!cndaTest\Exnort\93- Novclllber%2027 .%202007\ 1 0_ %20COUNTY%20MANA..
] 1/2012007
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Agenda item NO.1 ON
November 27, 2007
Page 1 of 10
,--
Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, a lien agreement with Jean C. Jean Pierre and Marie Jose Jean Pierre
(Owners) for deferral of 100'Y. of Collier County impact fees for an owner-occupied
affordable housing unit located at Lot 11, Block 6, Naples Manor Lakes and authorizes a
reimbursement of the fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc on Building
Permit 2007041987 in the amount 01'$26.204.83.
OBJECTIVE: That the Board of County Commissioners (Board) approves, and authorizes the
Chairman to sign, the attached lien agreement with .Jean C. Jean PielTe and Marie Jose Jean
Pierre fi,r defeITaJ of lOO% of Collier County impact fees j{lr an owner-occupied affordable
housing unit and authorize a reimhursement of the impact fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of
Collier County Ine in the amount of $26,204.83.
CONSIDERATIONS: Anicle IV of ('hapter 74 of the Code of Laws and Ordinanees
established a program to defer impact fees f()r qualified aili.lrdable housing. Pursuant to this
program, an application f(w deferment was submitted by Jean C. Jean Picrre and MaJie .lose .lean
Piene, which application, aller stafr review, was dctennined to qualify for the program. Legal
status has been verified and documents arc on file at the oftiec of Housing and Human Services.
The property is located in the Naples Manor Lakes subdivision in Naples.
During staffs review of the file to process this defclTaI Jor approval it was detemlined that the
- Habitat for Humanity of Collier County lnc did not provide an application fi,r the defenal
program as a qualified developer prior to issuance of the building permit and payment of
associated impact fees as required. Staff has discussed this oversight with the County Attorney's
Office and recommends that the Board accept the application letter from the developer after-the-
fact in order to cornplete the rcquired paperwork and maintain consistency with the Ordinance
for this file and deferral agreement. Upon approval and execution of this deferral agreement and
lien, impact fees paid by Habitat for Humanity of Collier County Inc in the amount of
$26,204.83 will be reimbursed.
Section 74-202 of Article II, Chapter 74 of the Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances, the
Collier County Consolidated Impact Fee Ordinance, 2001 -13, as amended, provides for specific
criteria and procedures for processing routine and non-routine requests for impact fee
reimbursements. Specifically, as set forth by Section 74-202 (h) (5):
"All reimbursement requests totaling twenty-jive thousand dol/aI'S ($25,000) or more,
cannot be approved administratively and must be submitted to the Board of' County
Commissioners. "
.'-
The ordinance requires that a lien agreement be entered into with the applicant as a condition of
deferral of the impact fees. Section 74-401(3) of the Code authorizes the County Manager to
sign deferral agreements with applicants qualifYing for impact fee deferrals for affordable
housing, which has long been the practice. The ordinance, however, gives the County Manager
discretion in whether to enter into the Agreement. Aecordingly, in keeping with recent
discussion and direction by the Board, the County Attorney's Office has determined that liltil
directed otherwise by the Board, these agreements be placed on the Consent Agenda for the
Board's review, approval and Chainnan's signature.
Agenda Item i-\jo. 'ION
November 27, 2007
. .. . .. Paoe 2 of 10
FISCAL IMPACT: This agreement defers $26,204.83 In Impact fees. Although It IS expected
that the County will ultimately collect these deferred fees (generally upon the sale of the
residence), there is no guarantee as to if~ or when, this would occur.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: The proposed Agrecment is fully consistent with the intent and
purpose of Section 74-401 of the Code of Laws and Ordinances ofCollicr County.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: That the Board approves and authorizes the Chairman to sign
the attached Lien Agreement for Deferral of 100olr, of Collier County 1mpact Fees for Owner
Occupied Affordable Housing Dwelling Units for Jean C. Jean Pien'e and Marie Jose Jean Pierre
located at Lot II, Block 6, Naples Manor Lakes and authorizes a reimbw'sement of the impact
fees paid by Habitat 1'01' Humanity of Collier County Inc on Building Permit 2007041987 in the
amount of $26204.83, and any hudget amendments that may be required associated (0 the
reimbursement.
PREPARED BY: Frank Ramsey, SH1P Pl\lgram Coordinator, Housing and J-Itllnan Services
Return to
Agenda Item No.1 ON
November 27 2007
Page:3 of 10
'"
FrIlRkRllm,el'
CollierOlllnfVIII1S
3301 E. Tami~mi Trill
!'\;aples, FI<l..-ida J.4112
File# 08-026-IF
Th.~!rmerrur rCl:unliul,t
LIEN AGREEMENT FOR DEFERRAL OF JOO'Y. OF COLLIER COUNTY IMI'ACT
FEES FOR OWNER OCCUPIED AFFORDABLE HOUSING DWELLING UNITS
"nlis Agreement is entered into tbis _ day of October. 2007, hetween Collier Coun1y. a
pulitical subdivision or the Stale of Florida (COUNTY) and '"Jean C, Jean Pierre and Marie Jose
.lean Pierre" (OWN[:R), collectively staled as the "Parties,"
NO\\!, TI-J.EREFORE, ror good and valuahle cunsideration. the receipt ;.llld suJ1icicnc:y of
which is mutually' ackn(lwlcdgcd. i.hcPartics agree as f()[](l\""S:
], 1111S Lien /\grccmcnt is madc rllrsuant In Charter 74 ufthe Code of Laws and Ordinances of
Cllllicr Coumy,Florida. known as "TIK' ('oHier ('numy Conso]iduted Impact Fc(;:' ()rdinance"
(()rdinanel'), hi ;he (~vent l}f any conflict With thi~; '\!lrel~mcnL the !errn~; or the Ordinance
:-:haIJ apply
'i'he iq:d[ dc,"~ripiinn (,ill1(' dwcilin;: :mit jf'; ::tl:Jcbcd as Lxhii-li! '\,
'"he l'~~m, of ill!,- _'\gr(,clli'_'ll\ !,. 11'01]1 1,lJc dd\c set iuri-b ahuvl' umii file imna:::t ft~l' IS r-CVClllt.
!"hc :Imount (;1' lhe lmpa:1 fee:; dcL~m~d ~;h<d; h~' pai<i tc, lhe (/H '",T\' in Cull upon: :11 jJl("
sa1c of the d\\:ellin[; unit: h'i the rdinancing of lhe dv.'c1ling Ulllt: cl a loss oi'the homestead
exemption: or d) the first occurrence or an)' ~,;~de or transfer of any parl 01 the affected n:a]
property, and in any such event the deferred impilct fees shall he raid in full to UK: COUNTY
not later then the closing of the :c:ale. or not later then the effective date of the transicr. As set
forth in Exhibit "B:' the amount or the deJerl'ed impact fees is Twcntv Six Thousand Two
ITunqred Four and 83/100 Dollars ($26.204.8n Repayment shal! include any a(~crucd
interest. Jnterest shall be computed at the rate of Jive percent (5%) per annum, but in no
event shall it exceed tv,;enty-five percent (25i/;.) of the total fee amount.
5. The deferred impact fees shall be a lien on the property described in Exhibit "A," which lien
may be foreclosed upon in the event of non-compliance with the Ordinance or with this
Agreement. 'Ibis Agreement shall operate as a lien against the dwelling unit. Joe lien shaH
tcnninate upon the recording of a release or satisfaction of lien in the public records of the
County. The deferrals of impact fees and this Agreement shall run with the land, and neither
the deferred impact fees nor this Agreement shall be transferred, assigned, or otherwise
conveyed. Exccpt a<; provided by law, regardless of any foreclosure on the first mortgage or
other security interest, this lien shall otherwise be superior and para.mount to the interest in
the dv,'cJling unit of any 0\\11Cr, lessee, tenant, mortgagee, or other person, except that this
lien shall be on parity with any lien for County taxes.
6. Upon the satisfacwry completion of this Agreement's requirements, COUNTY shall record
any necessary documentation evidencing same.
7, In the event the OWNER is in default under the Ordimmce or this Agreement, and the default
is not cured within 30 days after written notice is provided to the O\VNER, the COUNTY
Agenda Item No. m..J
November 27. 2 07
Paq.e4o 10
may. at its sole option. eo\1ce! the impact [ct: amount in default as set forth in the Ordinance, - "~
or bring (] civil action to enforce this Agreement, or dcclar~ that the deferred impact fees arc
then in default and immediately due and payable, The COUNTY shall be entitled to recover
all fee:;: and cosls. including allOmcy's fee and costs. incurred by the COUNTY in enforcing
this Agreement, plus interest al the then maximum statutory rate for judgments calculmcd 011
a cakndar year basis until paid.
R. This Agreement is the s(1le agreement between the parties with respect to the subject matter
herein. and shall he binding upon the O\,-'NER'S Sllccessors and assigns in Interest.
9, Thj~.; Agn:cmcnt shall he r~cordcd in the official records or the County ill no cost to the
COl'~":T'y'.
IN 'VIT'\iESS \\'HEH.E.oF. the flartic~ h<Jvc cxcclIkd this Abrcclncnl (111 the d:J1.l' and year !Irsl
ahm'c. \"'Tjl1l~tl.
Attest:
fY'J.,']C;I-f! L 1IRnCk__ 'lerk
He ,;\1\]) OF COlil\TY ('OMM1SS]()NI::J~~';
('()UlFl<. ('il] i''\}TY i:IOR-loA.
I"~
; l{ :"llf' :~';O:
'j :,-\ll~i\'l.\i\
\ )\A'~'<LR:
V.'itncss;'.'s'
- -------,~.__.._....,
_.~~-'-~_.-'.__....:.---'---.
Print ;'~ailH;.--':=-~ ,
kun C. .k:::n Pi::'Tfl'
O\VNER:
Witnesses:
,
.'
-"::.,
/,
" ..>'
,':./''1 .-
Print Name
Marie Jose Jean Pierre
STATE OF FLORIDA)
COPKFY OF COLLIER)
2007,
The foregoing, ^b'TCCment ,was acknO\vlcdged before me this _.!.~, day of ""_~__...::~
bL)? r.... 'f- I..iv, !, i,_-}~ who_.is._-pcrsonall~~_.knmvn. lQ"J!l,e or has produced
___.~'-__ as proof of identity.
t~.,~
C /:mOTi\!.R. IAli.'.8E"'.!U:j('
~ \~. ,.,j, -''j,\:;'H'J:'~.':'-.:)''-'-'''.''.'''- ~.
S ~~~:,'~<^" :.;':I'!".!'.- '. '.(':'~.-~'..". ::
".....'vV',:V-..NVVVV."",...,.r.~
Sign;t~~~ ~fP-crs~n Taking Acknowledgment
Recommend Approval:
/ !.
d J!.
/ ..i
L /"-'--:':-^:"::' =.:....=::- A
<'Marcy Krumbiric, MPA
Director
Collier County Housing and Human Services
Jeffrey A\l<-l~\zkow
ManaginglfAsslstant Count\-' Attomt'v
i. H- . .J
"t
EXHIIlIT "A"
r"genda item NO.1 ON
November 27. 2007
Page 5 0110
'.
LEGAL nESCRll'TION
Lot 1], Block 6, Naples Manor Lal(('.l>. 3t'('ording to the Plat tht~reof as recorded in Plat Book 3,
pa~c &6 and 87, Public Rl~l'ords of Collier Count)', ~Iorida.
EXHIBIT "I!"
IMPACT FEE ImEAKnOWN
Type oflmpactF\~c
Amount Owed
A. EMS Imp<ld Fec
$100.59
B Correctiomd !'3ciJilies Impact Fee
$) 13.:'~
C. Library lmpacl Fcc:
$460.1.-'
D Communit: JliJrb Impact J'ee
$935.00
i--, Regional P:wks :mrac\ Fe:.:'
S2,06g.(IO
r;', Lduca!jonL!: Faciijti(:~.; :~Y:';Il'm Imract Fcc'
.",;R.2~:x_()O
;~ U;.lC ImnaC1 rt,l'
";(...' 59_(Jfl
C/(lVC;rnilH.'m E.uiidllWc impucl h,:.".
)::7~S{)n
t,ah l'.nfon.:cmen! Impac: "Ct'
$2b5,4~:
J. Sewer System Fce
$L\I:'.OO
K. \Xi ate]" ~ ysicm Fcc
$JAI5JlO
TOTAL IMI'ACT FEES
$26,204.83
JAf.:API'rovcd_ i
Agenda Item NO.1 ON
November 27,2007
Page 6 of 10
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR11 03 - Official Receipt
. Trans Number
767236___
- -:-Oale------ -. TF'ost Date ,Payment Slip Nbc. . - -----,
615120071041.34 AM c_6f!j1;100L______ll'.I_10070419.!l.'1___ . .___j
Address. 5314 JENNINGS ST
Owner. HABITAT FOR HUMANITY COA #.07-0269
Permit Type: BR2 Job Desc. FRAMED SIF DET 1 STY-IMMOKALEE "A" 311
Applicant HABITAT FOR HUMANITY-SAM
DBA HABITAT FOR HUMANITY OF COLLIER COUNTY. INC.
Swr Meter Wtr Meter'
Payor. HABIT AT
Fee Information
, 08LWSF LAW ENF IMPACT FEE SIF
, 08MFSG MICROFILM SURCHARGE
08RDGS , BLDG. PERMIT SURCHARG
08RPSF REG PK IMPACT FEE S/F
08SCHI SCHOOLBOARDIMPACTF
08SFR4 DIST 4 ROAD IMPAc:T FEE-
, 08TROP TRANSPORTATION R.OW.
I ...--.---..-
~~i~e i~Cb~~'&~E.g,ERT;>YRCH6B~~--~ ~1L3~~~~~~~0882000000-':'--=-~6~~\^JalveQ.
08BPNP ,BLDG PERMITS - NAPLES i 11313890032211000000 n$_5~gOO .__
g~~-~~~~~M:~6~PF~CET ~~E .<;IE--I ;:~~1~~~~~1 ~;1 ~ ._:J~~~g!
I 08ENIM ;-EASTNAPLESFIREIIv1PACT . U1.~Q0000020982000000 - _.124904 :...=:-_ __-_-.,1.
08GBSF GOVT BLDG IMPACT FEESfF--,3901;12231363510313ll.0_ -- $725001
08JLSF JAIL IMPACT FEE S/F 38111043036351031381 $113.53.1'
i 08LBSF i LIElRARYIMPACTFEE S/F 35515619036351031355' $460;1~--
i 38511043336351031385 'I $28548 i
i 11313890034144200000 i $3.00'
E-----1130000002088000000o--t $5.64
r 34611636336351031346-T~06800
EE 111300000020905000000 _...l.__=~8~ 00 ' _
SINGLE 133616365336351031336 ' $6359.00:
PERMIT J.J0116364032920i:iOoooo___ $150.00 i
SITE INSPECTION-ENGINEERING ! 13113832732249000000 i. $150;=.00' --1:
COUNTY METER_TAP CHAR~ i 40825321234331000QOO__t $676~ _"
SEWER SYSTEM CHARGE '41_~26361334356031413 1 $351500
WATER SYSTEM CHARGE 41127351134336031411 i $3415.001
BLDG. PERMIT APP FEE CREDIT ' 11313890032251()Q.D000 T- - $-=100:00l
Total n' $27876.151
1
~"---:
~_i'3ITE
I 42MTTP
42SSDC
I 42WSDC
08BACR
. Continued -
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT
Printed.11/1/2007 9.02.39 AM
Agenda Item NO.1 ON
November 27,2007
Page 7 of 10
Official Receipt - Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CDPR1103 - Official Receipt
I-.--.----~
I Trans Number
i767236
. -. i Date . ---~-Tpost Date ---== TPaYment Slip Nbr
___ T6t5t20671 0:41:34 AM~-1i>/5/2oQ7_~_ ,.._---.f.L2007041987
-I
..~I
Payments
LPayment Code lAccountlcheck-iiumber - --=====------_____
i_C_HECL_______ 114200 .___. _____
Total Cash
Total Non-Cash
1___$2W~u;i I
----$(JQO 1
_ __$27876.15,
Total Paid
. ~27876~~
Memo:
Cashier/location: MU~PHYLlNDA /
User: POTTER_T
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT
Printed:11/1/2007 9:02:39 AM
.
.
Agenda Item NO.1 ON
November 27. 2007
Page 8 01 10
~'
's ~.
nq,'
~. ,<;,. ~"
,
,:n.:" Cl__(;:lH ~:" /;
"/'''-'1
I!
t.' i'{JI!f'Y( f"
',-r';'I'
August 7.2007
,).
Ann: Frank Ramsey
SHIP Program Coordinator
Collier Coun1~.
33(1] E. Tamiarni Trail
llealth & COmmUI1l1) Services Buildin~
!\aples. FL 34 j ].:
Rc:
lmpaet Fee Reimbursement
. L.:;!:- i, :'~lnL
1::~~'lla1 iur iu };::::L~\ II { iii:':'~i' < I.)LlJ!l\. lJJl
:"e'::!ll:::-;;ing i':"lrn;.luI'::,Cil1'.:.'nt
l",}j" lmpaCi lees pmJ Ihruugh the lmpacl F(:-c f,J('ierraj PrpgruJTl. rhcsc fee:::
\~'cre paid up fj'unt b:- Habitat for ~-Jumanit:. C(ll1icr County, Inc,. in
order 10 expedite: the building process. hO\\'';;:'\t'r the fUTure owners for the
property llualii\' i~)r an :n1pacl fee dcfcn'ai. Dcsc.ribed as rt)llow~:
\1.r
Jean C. & Marie .1. .Jean Pierre
531'1 Jennings St. Naples FI34113
Permit # 200704198~~
h:."'er;
,::1'
it' ";'
\\;Ul;V,;
,::,,::cj
,.:;,
Please feel free to contact Norma Lora (775-0036) if you have any
questions or concerns.
l' I ~ " l
1:J..,,(':
, n ~\ ; :;::!: 1<""
Sincer~.\Y-t
- :~:/
,/,,/, /' ~
,
r,' ~ ;-h:1
tL~,t-;t:-;: :;d~
SamuelDurso, M.8
President
!'L>te: S~'tl ;'L
.. ". ':':~ 1(::
\\
-,Ll..C'1 "-::,"
;:r-r:r.1:n,
.: ~ .
'..lr1e::." :;::1
'"ij _.-:' ','
~'-;,~~., :laxi
;. ",' ~ i '\-, ' ,,:~;
, ' , , , '." " ~ '.'! C':: ;;1,
\,V_ '.'. _~l'"i "d'
~:i/.. fib' it-
-_. ..
p.?,:.l\
4'lB~~. '- ~':
'iirso
-..".'
: ,~n'u_""
L..
fvt,:
\L-(
R(>bc'rt
dEU.';/
:;,~;r .n ,.1
Agenda Item No. 10N
Novenlber27.2007
Page 9 of 10
u
nn,':SfiJiJ ;~' d "{,' nrld 'd-t!!",.; c; ,'"'!10m
Ii{ ":-,, '~FU- r~\';If
October 29, 20()7
Al1n: Frank Ramsey
SHIP Program Coordinatur
33()] E. Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34 i 12
RE:
Permit ;I:i:
53] -+ Jennings STreet. '\iaplcs, 'Fl. 3411 J
200704i<J87
lJ:.::ar f';o;:mk.
Hal,ilaf i(Tr
(1 C'oLier C Ol.lm>. Inc. pellhl'
\\ -de lmpac',
Deferral PrCig:':;uTL ;jl'n~jf!c<.: ihe.- ::h()\.c r-;::'icrCnCCG propc-r1"\ as an afTordahJc
housing unit. Plc~l:;e le1 this [Cllef ';cr\'(' as an ::ltter-lhc-J:.ICl ::l]lpiicarion ~lJld
ldentification that an income digible. legal resident of the Uniled Stmes will
occupy the property Ull(~e complete.
Habitat for Humanity of Collier County. Ine paid the Impact Fees upfrol1t in order
to expedite the building process.
Please feel free to contact Norma Lora (775-0036) if you bave any questions or
concerns.
,'h I Sincerely,/' /'?
:;:// ./ /,/' //~,/
\\"'<'''', . ~ ~;//?'>:;:/:/~~-
~~tl,-1-1.1e! >/<1:":[1,;..,/ C'.(",-/:;; ~
SaJ11l~Durso~ M. D.
",,1;;n1(1'; President
,'J'P',(
[viii Ie';
2alln,<:-_~,
David Pi1.,,>!;,
n ;:;rbar<J. s.n;
l'p::ef Sobnn
- h.".;.:l1-.:h'j
\\:"ir:;:'C:li'.
'\-{iJ,;'f' \:\..~n1t"
,<<iff
j ,,::',L,ilfn,},;,:i: ~,,~~:;
t: j ~.:;; i i .'\
:3(:. ~'7::: .C;-'3i-;
:;',1'
..a5un~n(lt'h ~~h{aUi'l;;Lt'(j~}j
"
Page J of 1
A(]8nd8 Iter[' I~C! 1 m~
l\fovembcr 2i' 2ee!
pnge 10 oi 10
COLLIER COUl'iTY
BOARD 0" COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Item Number:
'fJr,
ttemSummary:
- ',;.c.:,)' ~'",H' ,"i<".lor~ ~IVJT i!1i Gare> Cvunt'i: ':'Tnn'!S9(,n?L' ;][)I~H"h'H" an;! "lI~h()1 '=25 th€
-",',m:","" t( <'IV" E __It' "ic:'rFWY~f" v"d", ,iF,in
",OJ" '" U';' W ;',~;mto .Ie,",,; J"'f"--' ::O'!Hn-
,NHlP-,'
';do":,,' 'r,'" '-J1 "lli,,1 ';:lJ'.J"ih';' .pi!(' ;,,8~'
",WOV'II"''i'llC;U;.w,C:lftsr<J"l.'k
"1i;lJ',ir;Uc'
--at,-,
,1<):;:1,'_' 1,,,--,,,,,'-<1-"]""'1,;;;",' ,Hl,'jC]']t!-.l'I-t>" I;WFlI;I"',to""i':,',t
',.',j'1".::CllulJ'\'
W'1,;"I::"')i!.;-(;'
~.. r; I: 'v : n
'l,ilh;d'J IC'c;r, II'.
U,,',;,rr"l)',lcl:-
Meeting Date:
,I"
Prepared By
F',"1~ R1,mo,r,'i
SHIP r'r-c,prMl> C00r:i:nJlo'
~)~W
i;')l'S,,,[,'r,:JH,,m,,,,:,p,'.-''''('''
jf;;;OO- 35"'",0,'/.
h,oliC ~cn;'ce<
AppruwdBy
:"T, ,1r'-,E,,,tc
"":C,",
ilC:'l"
'\ppr<l\'ed II~
'\ppl"uvedB\
'.pprnn'd II)
,,,"pprnvt'dlly
'in""'
"'''ll'''':
-"",,'
:1;'-"",'
""':T,'
C':,:-"
Approvcd B~
,ie, ,,~,~ r '-' ~!; u r;d
;~c.w,. ;,j~n"
1.'.11"
E;{);;ru _~r Cnu""
CommiS"lOnCtS
Count'" ~:; .1I1"~I"r ~ O!f,cp
11,'1'111.:10"' ::];,PM
file://C: \Agenda T est\Export\93- Novemhcr%2027, %202007\ 10. %20COUNTY%20MANA.
11120/2007
Agenda Item No. 100
November 27,2007
Page 1 of 6
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners provide
direction related to the acceptance of after-the-fact developer applications
from Habitat for Humanity of Collier County, Incorporated for 41 properties
and the reimbursement of impact fees paid prior to issuance of a Building
Permit and execution of an impact fee deferral agreement
OBJECTIVE: That the Board of County Commissioners (Board) provide direetion
related to thc acceptance of aftcr-the-fact devcloper applications from Habitat for
Humanity of Collier County, Incorporated tl)r 41 properties and the reimbursement of
impact fees paid prior to the issuance of a Building PC1l11it and execution of an impact fee
deferral agreement.
CONSIDERATIONS: The current provisions of the County-wide Impact Fcc Defenal
Program allow for the defcnal of impact fees Illr qualified owners or dcvelopers of new
affordable housing. Developers are allowed no more than 50 deferral agrecmcnts at any
one timc in the name of the developer. Outside of the :;0 defer",,1 agreements in their
name, Habitat has also applied ii)r Building F'ennits and paid the impact fees in full, prior
to the issuance of the pern1it.
~",,-~
Section 74-40] (a) (2) of the Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances (Code), which
is the Collier County Consolidated Impact Fee Ordinance, provides the following related
to the procedure for applying for the defen'al program:
"Any person seeking an affordable housing deferral fill' proposed development
shallfzle with the countv manager an application for dcfcrral, prior to receiving a
building permit for the proposed development. "
Additionally, the application must eontain the following inf01l1lation:
a. The name and address of the applicant;
b. An up to date, complete legal description of the site upon which the
development is proposed to be located;
c. The maximum income level of the 01H1Cl', or if the owner is a developer or
builder, the income level of the household to which the dwelling unit is to be sold
or provided of occupanLJI;
d. The square footage and number of bedrooms in each dwelling unit of the
development
"-,
During staff's review of the deferral files for 41 homes constructed by Habitat for
Humanity of Collier County, Inc. (Habitat) it was detennined that an application for the
defen'al program, as a qualified developer, prior to issuance of the building permit was
not submitted and therefore Habitat did not comply with the provisions of the program as
set forth in the Code. Each of the units now has a qualified owner and a Board approved
p.genda Item hio. 100
November 27. 2007
Page 2 of 6
deferral agreement and lien on the property in the amount of the deferred impact fees.
Additionally, Habitat has requested a reimbursement of the impact fees previously paid,
the basis of which is that tlle impact fee deferral agreement now stands in lieu of the
payment of the impact fees.
Based on this oversight, in order to be in full compliance with the requirements of the
Program, as set forth in the Code, staff is seeking the Board's direction on this matter and
has developed the following a1tematives for consideration:
Altemative 1: Accept the application from thc developer after-the- fact. in order to
complete the required paperwork and maintain consistency with the Program, for tbese
files and defelTal agreements. This acceptance will also allow for thc rcimburscment of
the impact fees previously paid on thc subject propertics. AJI reimbursements are subject
to the availability of funding and may rcquirc pavmcnt over timc as the funds become
available within the specified impact fee trust funds. These deferrals have already been
accounted l(lr upon their execution and do not exceed the Program cap that limits the
number of available defcrrals 103"" of Ihe prior year's impact lee collections.
Alternative 2: Dcny the request to accept the application Ii'om thc developer after-the-
fact and the associatcd reimbursemcnt of impact Ices. This action would also requirc thc
ficn (In the propel1y to be released as the impact Ices were paid in full by Habitat and
rcmain with the subjcct property. Bascd on this action these units would no longer bc
considered as pal1 ofthe County-wide Impact Fec DcfelTal Program.
FISCAL IMPACT: If the Board accepts the after-the-fact developer applications from
Habitat, the fiscal impacts associated to the rcquested reimbursements arc as follows:
Correctional Facilities
Community Parks
Educational Facilities
EMS
Government Buildings
Law Enforcement
Library
Regional Parks
Transportation
$ 3,965.04
$ 33,206.87
$113,480.00
$ 4,101.42
$ 11,421.84
$ 5,154.80
$ 15,250.06
$ 66,541.60
$200.398.00
TOTAL
$453,519.63
AdditionaJIy, Water and Sewer Impact Fees were paid on lO of the 41 Building Pelmits,
and if the Board aecepts the aftcr-the-fact developer applications from Habitat, those fees
will also be reimbursed to Habitat. However, aJI Water and Sewer Impact Fee deferrals
are fundcd by the budgeted revolving fund which provides $750,000 annually for these
deferrals. Therefore, thcre will be no revenue loss to the Water and Sewer Impact Fee
Trust Funds.
Agenda Item r\jo. i UU
r,ovel11ber 27,2007
Page 3 of 6
As stated above, the authorization for the subject reimbursements should be contingent
on the availability of funding and may require payment over time as the funds become
available within the specified impact fee trust funds.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: If the Board authorizes the remittance of the
requested impact fee reimbursements it may adversely affect eapital project funding
however, the specified deferrals do not exceed the cap that limits the number of available'
deferrals to 3% of the prior year's impact fee collections.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: Each ofthc proposed alternatives provides consistency
with the provisions of Section 74-401 of the Code.
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners provide direction
related to the acceptance of after-the-tilct dcveloper applications from Habitat for
Humanity of Collier County, Incorporated for 41 properties and the reimbursement of
impact fees paid prior to the issuance ofa Building Permit anci execution of an impact fee
deferral agreement.
Prepared by: /"my Patterson, Impact Fee Manager
Busincss Managcmcnt and Budget Office, CDES
Agenda Item NO.1 0(::>
November 27. 2007
Dage 4 of 6
i,! ';;;0;,1,,; -"iw";" "':,"!1}UiH
Ii (i:~
1.;(
October 12. 2007
Attn: Frank Ramse\'
SHIP Program C()()rdillator
3:;0 I E. T:nniarni I rail
Napies.F']orl;.iil :::4112
Lk~lr F"::'ZUlk.
Habitat fcn flun:;:l.nit) of( idlicr I, >ll1l11)< lnc. pc,: 1.h;;,: C
.d(";I'ildi~~'~ tIlt re!'crc:nced he];,)'.\
VVide impact Fcc
j<..., Lu-forcL::lhk housing
lmrL.; Pi:":'HSC c::
::::.:tt:;-:l ('r\;' ::[": 'lJj ~j)le!..HH,'-:ac::
li.:aTl(ll "lill': iC(:!1:1\tC<llJOn
11
"~! :~'
IJ1.;'
"1.
""'-",,,,'\
,-,,,,,'"
,"'''1',1 "; !ap'ia;-I
'he;
"u11:
n;:
ill
:n :)r~ic
it.: Uy-
:( :])( ](:1<;\\11':
Permit 1;'
!..ddre~~s
H
L\(ldres~
"OD() i ] O~'7G
"-~ 1 CC1\T,H3;11 j\oad
::,(lU70:~O-42 -::"4(1
\:
i ! 3367 (1)'i'('ilallT
'i()(Jb{)6'::; -:;6 i ._ 1':;3~~_~~~.'::'_~~L~~~U,<~_~~,9J_~~~~?~ 2CI=;____1<o~ld
i 2006062345 13702 LC~',K) Lane t 200'"'020!.~2_ _~"'24 Ilbcrt~ VI d}
1::':004100746 I I::!04 /tllegiance \lv'a)! I 2007020479 : ,'\::)\ Llherty VI av
~-------><--~-'-"-"---:-""_m"""-""--r---'---------:-'''''-''--r---.---, .
2005083426 I 1279 Allegiance Way 1 2007041986 i 5325 Mitchell Street
2006020535 _LL~.}?.,0.!!!~j~~"YVa~'___.r20070419791 532'] Mitchell Street
:1 2006062402 I 1475 Peace Way 12007020~ 355" Liberty Way
"'I 200606241ft, 1489 Peace Way I 2006064732_+_[492 Peace Way
I 20060624[9_ 14G7 Peace WaY~200606~~I.~_+-.13644 LegaCt..L~~I'
:1 2006062422 ~_~_I".Rcace Way ; 200606240~_~__1479 Peace Way .~_____
j .2007021956 I ]509 Pe~_~~~~~.:.... _ _"J _~(~!?~~~~~?~_! 1326 Constitution Cl. i
! 2007021954 ,12!~".acc IVay I 2006062404 I 1481 PcaceWay~---,
';""~I 2()9702!2~I~IL?_(~~..EE~C Way __~0005~)472?_~l J496 Peace VvT,,'!L___J
~_006064732 1470 Peace Way I 2006062412 !_~~:~5 peace,~_~
,'l-2006064'Zl..~"_ 1466 Peace \Vay ! 20060S0485~, 1.~ 14 Constltutlon Ct~.
I 200606235J 13614 Lel',acv Lane '2006050487 i 1318 Constitution Ct. '
2007020756 3520 Liberty Wav 12006~so462-T-130-6-'(~~-;tjt~;tiZ';-c~~-"1
~ '
2006050506 1334 Constitution Ct. I ___ "1 .~J
d 2006061951 -j-.l.~OO Peace WaYH-.1_ 1_________...;
2006064747 : 1488 Peace Wav --l-- ,
200606234'3T13706 Le~acy Lane I i j
2006062347 13606 Let."':L~ane ! f-.---. __ _~
, 2006062418 1493 Peace \lay 1_ j
"L I . __~~_
",';;;'
" ,,;:
11,\::,."",;
S(-'i: .,
,0,\(:,:,'1
'.
";.\er 'f'"
" "1J"
;";-:"\i;m'lLFll
'>4'-
.,~, C1' n ~.'--'
::1 U i.\i ;-"iy;\f"Knr;~'T.:::()n,1
""'\\" )"('lh~2t :i.':Tiie::-
,:",
',',;"",
f..
" { :~ r-
\\'l ;:,;;,
,~t; '';i~r; ;-
:"\:
r' (''1'('' 1',;? '\ ~ ':; ~t
rVI'ri'.';
h'!-r!"i :';i;:1!
:':~J.\'id p;~~i_'l
'i';nh !.rJ
,'; ~~Ot.;l
,\i; r"Ct'J' b~~!
'.'" c'jr':i(,;,L
''-f ,'"C "'\
~.,;. :.
,).:'"
t
,A,gena8 IIBm t\lo, 100
November 27, 2007
Page 5 of 6
~.f", ,
e;.,tft.E:~
~..'!tr: 1;~I(!r- 'c;, ;! ('?'hi ,: lift!' ;';"C:':.{r:' Ie'
., ,. ~ (fCi" C
Please feel free to contact Norma Lora (77:"-00361 jf\,ou have an\ questions or
concerns.
Sj]]cercly~
Samuel Durso. :\,1. L),
President
,}!':.l
\2..1 ',,;:t11f'~_
.'-,-
-- Ji--"~~' ";c.,_--:;. ,.:;-- '?~
"'''0> ;,,<di(,'"
\' ;:.-: ",I
Item Number:
Item Summary:
Meeting Date:
Page 1 of ]
p,,':J-"IIG;;; item 100
i'kNernbe: , 2007
Paqe fi of6
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
'DO
C-CC rH'1emj"trrJl': tn;;!t ti'".-:, [lD3Td 01 County :::0nl'T~ISSIClneI'S N'0'/:Clr ,Jlr(,Gt,()'O 181a18(j io ale
;''-C;-:o'iJ!c',nc,:' 0' "j;lpr-lIw fm:\ lir-."JeIDper dp:Jircstions irom Hatii1a~)(J~ HLln',8nlt~ D' Collier
''''',un\v 'n,':urpu:<<I",! I J[- "I,~ prupenl2-O ~r;[j ',he i'elml;'lIrSerTlell~ (It l'lIr),:;;;' ;e,"~: I'dld sr;r,)' 'G
io",~lcir',C" Gf;j [,;,111::;11;[1 ','I'!1W sr:c BY( :llll-, 0: an 1f11Dil:'t lee (hl",:r8' aClf'l'p<lI'onl "'fill'
'--',JIlt' ,-'I'; I"':)d'::t F-epi[U::: M"'l,;~J"- ':':'''11'{>'..In;1y [)c\-'f,i,1,.'rlHo)'11 :cr''-.'llunrnunj,-,1 c~')I'vi,~
1:-"''''1
"",':
Dill<"
Prepllred By
AfT'\' ~'i>lV"T,,()"
:;ommunir\, [<"",""OproN'!/;'
r:.p"ji',?"~fl,'n1~i "-"Irv;cv
Imp~p ",l-)f-.' rJ;"n'1gf'f
;::in~n"",: ~"I"'or, [;. Horu;>n\.!
li.'912! /1 ~)G"4f: /.1M
;att-
AVIHo\'ed By
'1""" '("""l(;;n,
,'.'uhl" Sen,;;",;
Approved By
."n"
,",W'
.-~")",-" ,.n i.;
''''I',;,,,,,,'',rO'',o,,,,'It''-',,; ;)';H,
r",-'') ",,' '''~' "II ':;,,"
Appr","cd H}
'''''';''-'-'-' '-J1;n""",,-,,,,,
1IS:20(,; S:I~ di
","''-.1L,''I''';',OI'"'C,'
""rn'I'[)!j''};''f-'f1'i'"''''
'\pJHoved B.\
'-'n";c ',(H":"
'H,
Apllt'oved B;.
::",,,'nun'\\'c.',,v,,oprnc",,,
E:n>'lronmentaISe'-vic,,'
r "'''<A~"\,
.' Di!1'n 'Ilit',' [)C\'~-';cn",'n' '"
;~;T'!ll'O"rnent~: Sen/IC(--'$ i\(imlfl
,'; 14:200, :~';5(. "'Fi
Apprllved B)'
.Jo,;epn f'(,Scr,mitt
COlllmlJt1I!I' Ueve'opm~l1; 1:1.
l:nvlronm",nmiS",rv,cc's;,drninstratGr
Date
Environmt!ntll'So:.rv,,,es
Community DeVlC'Gprnent & Comn,unit,- [)c",,,lopmel11 S.
Erwironmentn!S",rvicesAdmi"
11114:20078:11 PM
Approved By
GanettMl!llee
Community Development &
Env;ronmental Service~
"lnnnc,,;i C!per~!ionl\ Manager
Date
Fimlflcla: Admin, & HOWiillg
1'11:,I:(00710:2Sf\M
Oat"
Approved By
OMS Coordm<ltnr
t,dm,n,strot;""Servln,,,,
J:.ppii~<It;o"s Analyst
j"t(lrm~tion Technology
111,S,'2007:;.38PM
Oat'"
Approved By
Sherry Pryor
Cuunty M~n"W"r'5OffiGe
r,~"nagement e B"dg"', Analyst
Ofiiceof Mal1l,gement& Budget
11f16120079.02AM
O;ole
Approved By
Michiltd Smykowski
County Mllnnge!"c;Offirt'
Management & gudget Directnr
Office or MBllagt!lnel1! & Budget
111161200711:1CAM
D~t"
Approved By
jRme~ V, Mudd
B(mfdofCQunlv
Commlssionors
C(J1mtvManapllf
Cc.untyManager's Office
111161;>0073:1S_'M
file:! IC:\AgendaTcst\Export\93- Novembcr%202 7,%202007\ 1 O.I!-020COUNTY%20MANA_. ] 1/20/2007
Agenda Item No.1 OP
November 27, 2007
Page 1 of 10
~
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners evaluate and consider each
option presented with respect to including Jess than five acre illegal Rural Fringe Mixed
Use District (RFMUD) Sending Land properties into the Transfer of Development Rights
(TOR) Program for the purposes of programmatic participation relative to TOR severance
OBJECTIVE:
That the Board of County Commissioners (BCe) evaluate and consider each option presented as
guidance towards formulating a policy recommendation in relation to the inclusion of less than
five acre illegal RFMUD Sending L,md properties into the TDR Program.
CONSIDERA TIONS:
On October 9,2007, dnring tJle BCC regular meeting, under the County Manager's Report, Hem
lOA, staff responded to an issue heard during the September I 1, 2007 Bee regular meeting
under Public Petition, \tcm nF. The issuc was initiated by !vir. Jim Schulze who petitioned the
Board to allow his less than five acre illegal RFMUD Sending Land property TDR progranl
participation as it relates to severing dcvelopment credit.
~
Staff responded and recommendcd that the Board continue to uphold a prohibition on the
inclusion of RFMUD Sending Land illegal properties into the TDR program (all less then five
acre Sending Land parcels created subsequent to October 14, 1974 - i.e., after the underlying
Agricultural zoning district standards of one dwelling unit per five acres was established in the
Coastal Area Planning District of the County).
Given that an illegal lot or parcel (of less than 5 acres) was created after the underlying
agricultural zoning district standards of I dwelling unit per five acres were already in place, such
properties are not eligible for development per the LDC; as such, these lots do not contain any
development rights to be severed under the RFMUO TDR program.
After extensive discussion, the Board ultimately directed staff to determine how many less than
five acre illegal Sending properties actually existed within the RFMUO. In addition, the Board
directed staff to come back with varions options that would include potential ways to allow the
subject illegal Sending Land properties severance participation via the RFMUD TOR program.
Less than Five Acre RFMUD Sending Land Property Analysis:
The RFMUD property analysis began with a GIS query of all privately owned less than five acre
Sending Land properties. The total number of the subject properties was 256. After the initial
number was garnered, staff used two eliminating factors which allowed for a more accurate
evaluation with the intent of producing a precise assessment.
-,
Agenda Item r..Jo, 10P
November 27. 2007
Page ~of 10
All GIS estimated properties were cross referenced with County Property Appraiser records and
properties that were noted as ilve acres by way of ofIicial records were eliminated. Also, all less
than ilve acre properties that were previously deemed to be legal non-eonfonlling (LNC)
(through individual determinations stemming from TOR program participation) were eliminated.
After the eliminating factors were applied, the nnmber of parcels being evaluated decreased to
189.
The final analysis focused on the subject 189 Icss than Eve acre RFMUD Sending Land
properties. The process for conducting LNC detenninations starts with obtaining the respective
property card for each individual parcel from the County Property Appraiser, which indicates
when the subject parcel was created. The Property Appraiser was able to retrieve 185 property
cards (four properties did not have propelty cards on record).
In cases where there is no property card on record. the requisite documentation needed f(lr a
LNC detennination is incnmbent upon the property owner to produce. Staff primarily relies on
the property cards obtained li'om the Property Appraiser, but if a propclty owner prodnecs other
evidence attesting to when the respective property \\'as created, c.g., recorded deed, recorded
agreement fur deed, th(:l1 such t~vidcnce \\'ill be taken into account \-vhen making LNC
dctcrmin:Jtions.
LNe Determination Resalts:
Upon receiving the 185 property cards fhlm the Property Appraiser, Comprehensive Planning
Department staff forwarded the subject propelty cards to Zoning & Land Development Review
Oepaltment staff fi.lf the necessary LNC detenninations.
Snbject LNC detenninations revealed the f(lllowing:
. 126 parcels deemed LNC (ereated prior to October 14, 1974)
. 51 pal'cels deemed illegal (created after October 14,1974)
. 8 parcels deemed inconclusive, i.e., insufficient property card information
. A maximum of 63 parcels may be deemed iJJegal (51 parcels deemed illegal plus 8
parcels deemed inconclusive plus 4 parcels without a propeliy card on record)
Option 1:
Option I would allow the 5 I illegal lots (up to a maximum of 63) TDR severance participation
on a strictly proportional basis based off ofpropeliy size. All illegal properties could sever under
the same circumstances which would always yield a fi-actional credit issuance. In addition, all
properties would be eligible for complete TOR utilization with respect to base a1ld bonus credit
potentiaL
For instance, using Mr. Schulze's 0.34 acre illegal propelty as all example, the following credit
structure would be applicable:
· 0.34 acre parcel x 0.2 units/acre (I OU/5 acres) = 0.068 base TORs
,L\gencJa Itern No, 10P
l\Jovember 27, 2007
Page ':Bof 10
In this arrangement, the subject 0.34 acre property could potentially yield (if all applicable
credits were achieved) up to 0.272 TDRs - comprised of 0.068 base credits and 0.204 bonus
credits.
Option 1 Advantages:
Option I would afford all illegal lot owners equitable severance participation. Every less than
five acre illegal lot would only be eligible for proportional TDR utilization based solely off of
property size. This option would also pemlit subject illegal lot owners the ability to fully
participate in the TDR program in relation to being eligihle for all applicable credits. An
advantage to full TDR participation deals directly with providing an incentive to subject property
owners relative to encouraging environmental restoration and maintenance and convey,mee.
Option 1 Disadvantages:
From a TDR market perspective, jractional credits conld be deemed undesirable and would l110re
Ihan likely be difficult to sell to developers and investOf's who need to obtain TDR credits in
whole number increments j,"' redemption purposes. Additionally. therc is an established Board
directed and LDC codified minimum sale pricc of $25.000 per TDR credit. If pennitlcd to
participate in the TOR program on a proportional basis, illegal lot owners who sever fractional
credit cannot expect to gamer the al,)rementionedminimum sale price. Further, statr anticipates
having to amend the LDC j,)r the purposes of eodi(ying a policy relative to establishing a
proportional minimum sale price based off the issuance of ti'actional TDR credit.
OptiO/1 2:
Option 2 would allow severance participation by pemlitting all 51 (up to a maximum of 63)
illegal properties the ability to garner one base TDR credit. Notwithstanding property size, all
illegal property being evaluated would be issued one TDR - bonus credits would not be available
to illegal lot paJiicipants under this potential arrangement.
For instance, nsing Mr. Schulze's 034 acre illegal property as an example, the following credit
structure would be applicable:
. 0.34 acre parcel (and all illegal lots regardless of size) = I base TDR
Under this arrangement, the subject 0.34 acre property (and all illegal lots regardless of size)
would be eligible for 1 TDR.
Optioll 2 Adl'alltages:
Option 2 would also be equitable in terms of implementation, All illegal lot owners would be
given a base TDR credit In addition, fractional TDR credits would not be an issue and all
participating illegal lot owners would have a marketable TDR credit.
Agenda item 1\Jo. lOP
r"ovember 27. 2007
Page 4:J.Qf 10
Option 2 Disadvantages:
One potential disadvantage to Option 2 revolves around the future creation of new illegal
RFMUD Sending Land lots. In theory, a five acre Sending Land property owner could split their
property into 20 (cach with an individual folio number) 0.25 acre illegal lots. Instead of severing
based off of one 5 acre propeliy, with an initial credit yield of 4 TDR credits, the owner has an
opportunity to sever 20 TDRs from the newly created illegal lots. Such a situation would become
an unqnestionable detliment to the TDR program.
Should the Board choose this option. careful consideration needs to be focused on addressing
only those illegal lots in existence as of the adoption date of the RFMUD (Jnne 19,2002) or the
day the Board gives fOlmal policy dircction (in order to deter the widcspread creation of
additional illegal lots not cUlTently in existence for the purpose of severing more development
credit).
Option},'
Option 3 would only permit developable illegal lots TOR severance capability. Any illegal Jot
deemed undevelopable (/j'om a propeliy size and lot configuration perspective) would he
ineligible to participate in the TDR program. For example, a 10 foot wide lot is not developahle
and would he ineligible for TDR severance. The TDR credit allocation rate for suhject
developable illegal lots conld be propOliional or based on a 1 credit per parcel basis (referenced
TDR credit allocation advantages and disadvantages described above in options I & 2).
Option 3 Advantages:
Option 3 would be consistent with existing programmatic administration as it relates to the
severance of less than five acre LNC parcels that have participated in the TDR progran1, All less
than five acre LNC properties granted TDR credits have been developable (based on propeliy
size and lot configuration) and all were assumed to be developable lots when the RFMUD
overlay was approved.
Option 3 Disadvantages:
Option 3 wonld be viewed as a disadvantage to non-developable illegal lot owners.
Option 4:
Option 4 would uphold the CUlTent prohibition of TDR severance from illegal Sending Land lots
within the RFMUD.
Agenda !l8rn No, 10P
Novembel" 27. 2007
P8'~e 'Dof 10
Option 4 Advantages:
Option 4 would he consistent with the Growth Management Plan (GMP), and eXlstmg
Agricultural zoning district standards that have existed since 1974. lf illegal lots hecmne
purported impediments to future environmental restoration and maintenance activities -- e.g.,
hydrological restoration -- future land managing agencies could purchase these properties via
market rate acquisition. ]1' any of the illegal lots were in close proximity to management
activities, they would have value and could he marketed to interested public agencies. ]n
addition, this option would not create an inequity for owners of non-RFMUD illegal lots, and
would not givc developmcnt rights that presently do not exist to the owners of illegal lots.
Option 4 Disadvamagcs:
Option 4 would be viewed as J disadvantage by illegal lot owners desiring to sever TDR credits.
lnherentlssues Associated with the [ndu.,ion of 'Illegal Lots illto the TDR Program:
The inclusion of illegal lots of record into the TDR program would create an inequity with
respect to all other categorized illegal lots existing ontside of the RFMUD. If illegal Sending
Land properties were granted the ability to sever development rights, other illegal lot or parcel
owners (ontside ofthc RFMUD) could argue for the right to develop based solely upon the fact
that illegal Sending propel1ies of record are being granted severable development rights. For
example. an owner of a 1.5 acre propel1y in the Estates (one that was created aftcr Estates zoning
standards were established) conld argue for the right to develop based off of the illegal lot TDRs.
FUl1her, there is a fundmnental question of appropriateness with respect to the County granting
owners of illegal lots development rights they presently do not have (by viJiue of processing
illegal lots for TDR severance). ]1' development rights in the fom1 of TDR credits are going to be
granted to owners of illegal lots, it's logical to suspect certain illegal lot owners will decline
TDR severance participation and request the right to develop their property. ]1' granted TDR
credits, owners of illegal lots will have the light to sever TDR credits or develop the pm'cel itself.
Illegal Lot Owner Notification:
] l' option I, 2 or 3 is approved, the inclusion of illegal RFMUD Sending Land lots would require
a Growth Management Plan Amendment (GMPA) and subsequent Land Development Code
Amendments (LDCA). Many owners will not be aware of their impending TDR eligibility until
the fOlmal GMP A process starts and the requisite public hearings commence. As such, each
owner of illegal property (including those lots without a property card and ones deemed
inconclusive) should be notified following any BCC policy direction regarding illegal lot TDR
credit eligibility.
Aoenda Item h.io lOP
1-Jovember 27. '2D07
Page ft)of 10
Requirements for Including Illegal Lots into the RFMUD TDR Program (option 1 or 2):
. Amend respective sections of the GMP - Future Land Use Element
. Develop implementing criteria through amendments to the LDC
. Develop and implement varions administrative modifications
. Project Schednle to develop and publically vet the amendments
. GMP amendment cycle - transmittal hearings projected for March, 2009
. LDC amendment cycle commencing July, 2009
FISCAL IMPACT:
There is no quantiliable fiscal impact associated with this issue; however. the reqnired
amendments to the GMP and LDC will require extensive staff time, possible lcgal advertising
costs, other attcndant costs, and the costs associated with thc unknown impacts on other projects
which could be deprioritizcd as a rcsult.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT:
Inclusion of illegal lots or parcels into the RFMUD's TDR program is inconsistent with the
Future Land Use Element (FUJI:) of the GMP and wonld require a GMPA and subsequent
LDCAs.
LEGAL CONSIDERA nONS:
This Executive Summary is for the purpose of presenting the Board with the background for a
policy discussion by the Board, and as such raises no legal issue. This Office will work with staff
to implement whatever direction the Board may give. - JAK
RECOMMENDA nON:
Staff recommends option 4 as described; in an alternative scenario whereby option 4 IS not
acceptable to the Board, staff recommends option 3.
1. Option 4 would be consistent with the OMP and LDC and consistent with prior
determinations that illegal lots created after October 14, 1974 have no development rights
based upon zoning criteria.
2. In the alternative, although not supported by County Comprehensive Planning staff, as it
would completely disregard standards set forth in the GMP and LDC, the BCC should
consider option 3.
PREPARED BY:
Joe Thompson, Planner, Comprehensive Planning Department
Page 1 of 1
t:,gend'" Ilmh No, 10P
~jch'smbel 2007
i::-,Wf;! oliO
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARn OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
1tem Number:
ltemSummary:
10P
j:.~,.-Jc. JrT::"le'^,dat,()n IJ,at '11(> So<:!rc (0' :~Qunt\' '-,Dll'l11~~,'slurecs eVCl!U8!fC' una ,:','(Ji':r.;:der each
ODt"Jr' r"fsnnVod '.vi\f1 [C'S08C' to 'ricl'.Idirln ,e",. t'l<"', fivf a~-'e ~li8ga: RUri-l: O:"mqe MTt)Q US~
r~"str;;,1 : ",FfJil.'C', '-;()n'itr1'~ L.aroe lyo::,er'h_" 'm:, tm '" iSH' 'U9\miop!l'e'lt F::';lh'_~ 'U"-:J
['r09;(''''-'' ',~'r hI"; pi.q'D ,'"~; of p"-;g'J;r :;1Ii\:(; r'aril tr,)(,lt~lJl- r~"~1t;V') te --DF' SI,,'J~rBi'i::;fO :Jo":-
~'l[l"'P'.''-''', ;Oitn, ''0)'
rnprRhc" ';1','.... f)12r.r'"n~' :;"ril)'"Ullir.v [';i';\;~i( r;,r.nef'; & Cf''V''';!' en',':ll;-]I
'~,,,r'l"~.e"; [)""Sl('
Meeting Date:
(, ')':, '\r.,;l
"repared By
,lo"Thomp$oll
l'i"nnm
[,"'[I)
;.ofl\muni,y D,,'mr('r>l1'\ol'lli~
-:(']!l1preilr,n~i,"" r":iln,,,n,:
1 '~ .' r; ,:;! n () T 1 ' ,,:: 1 S P r.'
,-r."lronm"ntal;,':."m:-"~
AfllHoved By
,('~)';rL,II'nh:V(: "!:mnr,l(' ["""part,m,,.,c
(','lei>!!l (,of"
W" 11'
'''d\.o"
L,,--,.',-''--''I,,'q,'
w"n'~'''\1 ',- ,:,,,,,,<'1"'(;
2{}C,;' ':'\'
''''Jtr','''l'l'Vt1ti'','''"rllC''
.\pl)!'uHd H)
'~,k' ,,"',s
"'M"
'\llprowd n~
Approved By
,'lll'
""''"' , ;-,':",' m'
"",j',
=" '''':''1T'': :~"I :,~"
'-''','''' f,m''''i~
j,tj,U'
; .'~,;~O( , ~:-t..;
Approve118y
1\,., ;-lt1l)': Sa'w~l'l E'~'-'cutiv,., S<-ic'"i'tnr"
D:Jtp
C:or:!munitv D<-vdoprnonl: & ~;()nlmunih< DeVill(Jprn"nt 8-
::n'''rimm',mal ~'"vic"t, 1;:nvir.mmcnta! ~''1'VI<:(:", ;"'dUlin.
11f912ll0"'",,(.>,!IC
Approved Uy
Joseph K. SclHnitt
CornmLJt1ityDelielopmenl:&
Enviw"m'~ntaISer\!icl'5f"j!llin~trJtor
Dale
Community De"~lof!m.,nl: &
En\!lronmenurServices
CornmunityDcv(;!opmoJnt &
Enviwr.mental Servicesf,llnlln
11114/2007543PM
Approved By
OMS CoordInator
Applications Anaiyst
Dat,.
Actmin,strativcServices
Inform~lion Tecl111oiogy
11115120073:39PM
Approved By
Mark Istlcl,son
fJuoge!i\nalyst
Date
C'HJl1ty Manauer'~ Office
Offi~e of Manag(Hl1ent & Budget
111i9i2007 8,1" AM
AllprovedBy
JalllesV_I\IUdd
County Manager
Dat(>
80ilrd of County
CommisslOnen.
County Manager', Office
11/1S120071:02PM
fiJe://C:\AgendaT est\Export\93-November%2027 ,%202007\ I O. '}020COUNTY%20MANA.. 11/20/2007
g9L9~~G~-"..::.:
0'
.,
~!
5: DAVISRIVD
ri~~
~!
'1-)
l.-'
i '
~~~
illEGAL lOTS
(RURAL FRINGE
LEE COUNTY
.
',--"",:"_~:':'!";_l
;C"rH!';,_1,
,;R":E~" 8\VO
o
~
o
,
1_-.
~"-~: -- !
~f~-=-=-=~4'.;,,-
""OI~RO I
-,~- j
'-~---
"
ii'
~,
~j 3!
RATT'fS"'AKE_HA.~~
"'~~<v 81
"%;t
.c
.'
I,
,
,
\.
/
,
"
'y~
: .~
I
I_j-"
~~I
"~':,-~
I.
I'
,",-',
.;
IN SENDIN
MIXED USE
~
'"
Agenda Item NO.1 OP
r.; LAN D November 27. 2007
'" Pace 8 of 1 0
DISTRICT) -
"
,
~~ ""!
o
~
I
II
~f
N
w*,
,
Legend
Roads
... Illegal Lots
RF - Sending land
RF - Receiving land
RF - Neutral Land
il
024
Miles
FIO:llB"hy.~gIOlSlo.~ Roq"..tlSoodmgl.odP.,col
, I
IllEGAL lOTS IN
(NORTH RURAL FRINGE
LEE COUNTY
-
II
Agenda Item t..Jo. 10P
S END I N G l AND November 27, 2007
paae 9 of 10
MIXED USE DISTRIC I)
1
zl
D!
>:
~.
all
z!
0;
""
"'I
"I
IMMQKALEE RD
I
I -d.~
--------l---
I
I
I
1
l
1
I
I
r----------
1
GOLDEN GATE BLVD W
1
Zl
~I
z,
01
"'I
~.
~I
Z
D,
>i
~.
CJ!
Cl.Ji
wi
D'
:),
",I
",'
wi
iUl
,
i
RANDALL BLVD-L_
i
,
,
!
'$,
,
,
,
i
r-- Roads
III Illegal Lots
Legend
RF - Sending Land
RF - Receiving land
RF - Neutral Land
I
I
o 0.5
2
Miles
FIIoZ'/lIOl"Y.nll'CiISiO.t'''.q".ol"..ndir\Q~ndP",oel_Z''''m<
T
o
>
~
al
n:
w
"
---^-,.~
o
u
IllEGAL
(NORTH
LOTS IN
& SOUTH
o
--~.!
al'
,
ffi ~
:J!
~
o
u
/-75
,
Agenda Item NO.1 OP
S END I N G l AND November 27.2007
BELLE !VI E,A, 0 E) PagelOof10
-"-- ..--
-------
'11I101.
"",[
n[
.
I'
"
co
o
>
~
co
co
w
o
S
CJ
n:
w
>
w
N
w(fJf
,
I
! Legend
l_ Roads
I
IIIl1\egal Lots
I
RF - Sending Land
RF - Receiving Land
RF - Neutral Land
I
o 0.5
2
Miles
i
FiI.ZI!!""Y>ng,'GI51[)o,.~""",!s.""~C.ndf'",,,,,'_Zoo",1
Agenda Item 1'0. 100
November 27,2007
Page 1 of 3
-
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation for the Board of Connty Commissioners to approve a shift in
fnnding sources for the Goodlette Frank Road Projeet (60005); Collier Boulevard
South Project (60001); and the Davis Boulevard Project (60073) in the amount of
$2,279,900.
OBJECTIVE: To request approval from the Board of County Commissioners for a
change in funding sow'ces for the Goodlette Frank Road Project (60005); Collier
Boulevard South Project (6000]); and the Davis Boulevard Project (60073) in the amount
of $2,279,900.
CONSIDERA nONS:
In Fiscal Year 2007 road impact fee revenue in Road Impact Fee District Three (Fund
334) was bndgeted and (()rec<lst at $530,000. In tact. the impact fees received j()r tbe
City of Naples District 3 were over $2 million dollars. Increased District 3 Impact Fee
funding would have been allocated originally in 2007 to the Goodlette Frank Road
project; however, staff did not anticipate the fees coming in as high as they did so only
budgeted the project based on what we anticipated the Impact Fce Collections to be.
-
During the tiseal year 2008 budget preparation funding was set up in the Collier
Boulevard South Project (60001) in the amount of $2,279,900 to come trom thc City of
Naples Impact Fee District 3. Although the Transportation Road Impact Fee Ordinanee
allows for impact fees to be used in adjacent districts, stalf is requesting a change in the
allocation of the impact fees from the City of Naples Impact Fee District 3 to be moved
from the Collier Boulevard Project (60001) and reallocated to the Goodlette Frank Road
Project in the anlount of $850,000 and to the Davis Boulevard Project (60073) in the
amount of $1,429,900, Staff feels that both the Goodlette Frank Road and Davis
Boulevard Projects are a better fit since the Goodlette Frank Road is directly within tlle
city limits and the Davis Boulevard Project feeds directly into the City of Naples,
Funding will be reallocated as noted in the below chart,
Current Budget Revised Budget
Impact Fees Gas Taxes Impact Fees Gas Taxes
334 313 334 313
Collier Boulevard 2,279,900 2,279,900
Goodlette Frank
Road 850,000 850,000
Davis Boulevard 1,429,900 1,429,900
Total Project
Budgets 2,279,900 2,279,900 2,279,900 2,279,900
...-
j\genda item NO.1 OCt
hlovember 27, 2007
?age 2 oT:;
FISCAL IMPACT: A bndget amendment is needed to change the funding that has
already been alloeated to the Goodlette Frank Road Project, Davis Boulevard Project and
the Collier Boulevard Project from Impact Fees to Gas Taxes as noted in the above chart.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There is no Growth Management Impact
associated with this Executive Summary.
RECOMMENDA nON: That the Board of County Commissioners approve the shift in
funding sources and the necessary budget amendments
Prepared by: Sharon Newman, Transportation Operations Manager
Page 1 of I
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
IternNumber:
1DO
Item Summary:
~'p(:nmrnl" ostrem (0: ~he Board of C,rIlJl'11\' CDmm!$sio'1E'"5 10 8rpro",' a tuwiin(1 chang\' foe
1:18 -::i JorJ!elk F'-3nk RQ<ld P;ofeu IG0003: ColiiH [jol)le,lard C)'JUII\ ;;-"'Jj8() '1)0001 3"C'1'''''
~_:iJ'!!':' 8cl;levdrd i cOlee ,(j0073: if', Ihs '-iTOW,1 of :t~' 77,',SO[', !f1er-rnC\n "eClIS'
-r:msp'Jl'1al;on S;rvr(.H' ;'(Jrn'I'IIS\I'HlO(;
Meeting Dale:
(;!),',n
I'repllredBy
SilMon ~jeVJ'TI~n
;,tCOtJr:ti"{:S,,pervlsor
lifle
!'rnn5"nrt"t,rJn'N\lI~"'"
j"'nSfJ[HtlI:;cnSen,'ltl-\",,'\drnit'
11'811007 ~'3S;(J:; f'M
Allproved By
IjYm~" FL'";,,r, ;-d:::~'
:"'~'1~,i)i)r,~li,w [>i'jis,rm ,'\dmi'--'I~',lr"t()'
"\0
"ransportJU(W"""'iCW,
"','.-.,uv1,;'l(inr; ~,(;rv;ce~ f\dp1in
:1/91:0071'48 PH
AI,proved By
,,<wwn "J("I'''1~r'
;"":'-Ol,,,:!,,;
I:d'"
.."",;;,,,(1:'11""
-Til,,,',;,,,,"
(it-,-,,,,
';,-"'JU i(l'; ";'~ "!Ii
Approved B~
.';]: "1;<"',,,,,
C:,~',)',"-'tl
''C'il''\'
"""'unrtnt'",,
"",C'V"l''','',C),"','':
^r1pl'oHd By
'\ppI'O\'l"rI By
"',n'\l" ''-:;'"4'1''' :,\F,1',
M,l:';;0'.T't' '- ,~, :"" ",'
/,r,'
Ar'pn!\'cd By
',",",,"- ,,';udti
" ""n~ j' r,; ,)r1] ger
",,1,'
['",';,Yd'/(.O<ll'lV
County ":<lna[jOr"Oiiie,'
. 1 .'1 (1/2007 ~ 2:; n p 10
CCllnn'IS~'()ne",
file://C:\^genda Test\Export\93- November%2027, %202007\ 1 O,%2QCOUNTY%20MANA.. 1 ] /20/2007
Agenda Item NO.1 OR
~Jovernber 27. 2007
Page 1 of 6
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to grant final approval of the roadway (private) and
drainage improvements for the final plat of Strada Bella (Olde Cypress
PUDlo The roadway and drainage improvements will be privately
maintained.
OBJECTIVE:
To grant final approval of the infrastructure improvements associated with that
subdivision known as Strada Bella.
CONSIDERATIONS:
1. On December 3, 2004, Engineering Review Department granted
preliminary acceptance of the roadway and drainage improvements in
Strada Bella.
2. The roadway and drainage improvements will be maintained by the
project's homeowners association.
.-
3. The required improvements have been constructed in accordance with the
Land Development Code. The Engineering Services Department has
inspected the improvements and is recommending final acceptance of the
improvements.
4. A resolution for final acceptance has been prepared and approved by the
County Attorney's Office. A copy of the document is attached.
5. The original developer of this parcel John Soave, Inc. abandoned the
subdivision and a successor developer has assigned the bond security to
the Strada Bella Homeowners Association who have had the
improvements completed. An approval letter from the Homeowner's
Association is attached.
6. Although this PUD has not been closed out, this parcel was not developed
by the PUD developer.
-
7. According to PUD Monitoring, the outstanding PUD commitments are as
follows: Park site, nature trails, fair share contribution for traffic signal.
The developer is in the process of closing out this PUD and addressing
these issues. The County has not yet requested the fair share
contribution for traffic signalization. The developer has requested that
Transportation Services provide a value for the fair share contribution so
that this commitment can be fulfilled. The developer is working with the
Agenda Item 1-.10. 10R
I"ovember 27, 2007
Page 2 of 6
Zoning Department to provide an interpretation on the exact requirements
of the park site and walking trail commitments.
8. Pursuant to Board direction initiated at the PUD monitoring Workshop of
October 11, 2007, staff is providing the status of PUD obligations
associated with this PUD.
9. On March 22, 2002 the Board entered into a Construction and
Maintenance Agreement for Subdivision Improvements with the
developer. The developer has fulfilled his obligations with respect to this
agreement.
FISCAL IMPACT:
The roadway and drainage improvements will be maintained by the project's
homeowners association.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There is no growth management impact.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS:
The County Attorney's Office has reviewed and approved the Resolution for legal
sufficiency.
RECOMMENDATION:
That the Board of County Commissioners grant final acceptance of the roadway
and drainage improvements in Strada Bella and release the maintenance
security.
1. Authorize the Chairman to execute the attached resolution authorizing
final acceptance.
2, Authorize the release of the maintenance security to the Strada Bella
Homeowners Association.
PREPARED BY: Stan Chrzanowski, P.E" Engineering Review Department
n::r--tO
-OD"-
- .00
N.('")
/r---- Q)
-,'.! 0)
;:::-tV
;;;mQ...
~~
roC
~; Q)
:0>
'- ..:J
(11 -,
ry-=--
<(
z
o
w-
t:t(
",0
o
~
I
I
< ~
,
.
" a..
<(
i x:
I UJ
, l-
I -
! V>
I. N
OllYIl."nOO~~JGlO
TJ~r-[i"~rJ=0j.:ll~y\}(-Pl-? -rflt:j~'1\".I~tr.~T(jf
// ! /~\H \ '("'0 1 - \ ~\ ~ Ble') (\J':A '~~
// i ___II I J 7'~, (:. ~ ~ I t~"::'---1 //
/_________ _~-T-,---r---, L i i 1--]' <:________:L VJY. \-J,l/: i \ i
\ \. 0' ' .r:-~ J vY
<~ ' I
j
-'
OJ
CD
<<
~
'"
:;;
TJY:lSOJ..LON / ~
I
. . ~
- ~~
. HllaVH 0
!! !I iWlc1 ~ <
~ ~ .~ ~ i ! a
~ !. I ~~J , i.
~ = " It , " ~
N~l , '.
! II Il ";j I g ;: ~!i
. ! ~r !
I II
T LL .. -I i; ~lA'. nIIl . (l""'fIa1llOll~lOCl 19B'lnl
,-- L_ l !!I-J ~i Ii ~
~ . t)z ~ ^ I' 0" !I. (l i ~
I ' wQ I" , !II air III
0 ,!:< . '.
00 N I N, 0' -
~ 001:":1311I1'>'1 2~ "
g:g l ~! r -'I
:1IItXlSlllI -j ~ I I
>- 1.\ ~;~ ~ c J ,- IW
c-
z 1[- "I
=> b;ffi~tr ~ - ~ l ~ ~~t.l
0 ,
u b . 'I N lieS::
l N "jffil "I"
w ~i ~ E~
~ ~ ClHVAnlO8~l
Il "
~ , i
- 'I' . i ffi. " i Il-
l! ' - l!.l ~! ~~i iI.
,.
, I I~ I .
~"~ ! I
;l-3J.VUNalNl
~J.I<l;r,oo"i1OO -~.= (Ii ~! CJ:::::=: L
~ a
, I !U.-31V.LIlII31N hnI" 11~1!~II, IqI ffi.
U! , . ,
, u_ ,"
, ~!! i'
, ~~
, " ~ lis Il_~
, !l i - !i~ i.- N<m :>'l
a..
<(
x:
z
o
~
u
o
....J
Agenda Item NO.1 OR
November 27. 2007
Page 4 DfG
Collier County Government
c/o Engineering Review
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, FL. 34104
Attn: Stan Chrzanowski, P.E.
RE Strada Bella HOA
Dear Sir:
Please be advised that I represent the (Strada Bella) Homeowner" s Association. The
developer, and/or his professional engineer has explained to our HOA the functioning of
the water management system within our development and explained our responsibility
with respect to maintenance of the water management system, inclnding the lakes,
eulverts structures, and littoral zone plantings. We are also aware of our responsibility to
maintain the roadways, sidewalks. drainage, street lighting, (water and sewer if
applicable) landscaping. and to implement a program of constant removal of exotic
vegetation within our eommnnity.
We are not aware of any outstanding developer commitments or responsibilities with
respect to our subdivision or our PUD.
If I am not a resident of this development, I have had this letter cosigned by a resident
who is an elected representative of the property owners.
If I can be of any further assistance in this regard, please advise.
SineefelY] ;$;. f
Thomas Tatro
Treasure of Strada Bella HOA
Ce: Maryann Devanas, Collier County PUD monitoring
Copy to the district's Commissioner
Copy to the Developer
Page 1 of 1
f,nenda 11",rn No, 'lUR
}j(jvemb8l' 27. :::'007
Paqe ~j oj 6
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
.-
Item Number:
I:JR
Item Summary:
Thl[, ,t"w Ie I},i IleDrba! 400 p IT! R~,cornir,endation Ie grant ImBI apmovc:i Of tile rcadwav
(~'l1vale, ilwl dra.lllagf! ;lT1prOVe'Dents fOI nw lli--"'11 ",'<II of 3!faaa Bella {C10f C\,[\<9'::-- PU:)i
-tlf.' r'(,aclway ):ld d.aimj~f trnpr(;v''''1'ent~ will b':' prl'iall::ly m.N ia:fll'G,:Sian '::hrz:muwsk,
~':Ar.ir-" E_Il~:lI'1er,:'r f:,!lpWeer"1t; t E'1viro~'rrleqtal Servi e," l-)ep2J:'tme'lt (~>)'-n"..'mll)'
"",,'d(;p:~wnt I~ ":I'I"M~';I:":'1"fLt~1 ;;;"1\'-10::';, l-.iI'IiSt::W,;
Meeting Date:
.',,';'CC'; "CVJ(y:' (,f;j
Prepared By
StilnUlrlJrlOwski
Engtnectln\.' R,-,vmwMllll11()el
Dale
Community D",v~lopmsn( &
i:nv;mnm011tllIScrvi"t"
r,nginel'rrngSer<;ic!ls
1111,'2007 31 ~ 2~ p~,"
Approved By
J""V!-''';\I CmOr<1th''Ih ;\n",',.--s!
T'J,,!<,
\\frI"c.:1:), '--,,, ''';'_,plIwn' 8. (:,a"''''''l''\', ~"N'~l'-,pm"''-' ~ I;
~.' ""'Ol1m","";1' "",'v;,,m i,:',n ""'-'n.\',,;r;:~! ;o;e"'"lr;O' 1-',{!rn,1'i
1 ~m ;:()I}, 42;! PM
'\Pllrln-td Uy
. r"-~'jf1'-'\'<i"
''-''\1:rL0t-':i,,\! He 'I~V' ik.-n"nei
_,,,k
""":"',"'>1" '''''I'''rtld:,n:\
':,U;"/;'
--"'"'''''':'-1'''''
:'ll
Apllrnncl B.I
"\1'
Approved n~'
"!1',';'",-"", ,j ''-'~H:ii')''''
"''''''',\ : c'w'r-""V"""pniHl\h,,,'"''''
;'ii
",.-,' ,",;"-11\':''''3; :~,," ',;i"",~,
Apprnvtd Ill'
"
1"C:C!-"lilI1
C:ornmw,itv rJe~"hnm~nl I\,
J~t2
~',nv,ron'n",nw! SE""'C'l', Ar!rn"'~;'Jt()~
Coml1 ,mlt)' Development f; Com'l'unity [lcvl'lopmcnt &
EnvtrG>lm"'nt~1 S...rvicc5 F,y,;w"mel1t..,! Service', Admin
"I'I,":;'I'J071:14PM
Approved By
Wifliam D. LO'NIZ, Jr.. P.E
Environmellt..1 SCrlllc~'" D;rec\Or
n'ltc
Community Dcvelopmsnt &
En\!irDnm"ntIlIServl(;e~
",,,vironmental Service~
11/1512(1)7 ~:3[< PM
Approved By
OMS Coo,dln"ior
Applic)t'Ol1g Analyst
[Into
l\dmilllstratIV" Services
I"formatioll T~chnolouy
l111€i/200710:.39AM
Approved B}'
Mark Isack~on
fjudgslAnalyst
D<lts
County Man:lger'sO!f;ce
Qlfjce of M.lr1Jg€lTwnl & Budget
1',11C:200711:4€ AM
Approved By
Jam..sV Mudd
County Manil[ler
Date
Board ot County
Comm:~si"n(lrs
County Manager's Offies
11116/20071:J2PM
file:l/C:\AgendaTest\Export\93- November%2027 ,%202007\ 1 0, oAi20COUNTY%20MANA" 11/20/2007
Agenda item '-<0. 10R
November 27,2007
Page 6 of 6
RESOLUTION NO. 07-_
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY,
FLORIDA AUTHORIZING FINAL
ACCEPT ANCE OF CERTAIN ROADWAY AND
DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS IN STRADA
BELLA, ACCORDING TO THE PLAT THEREOF
RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 40, PAGES 69
THROUGH 70; RELEASE OF THE
MAINTENANCE SECURITY; AND
ACCEPTANCE OF THE MAINTENANCE
RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE ROADWAY AND
DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS THAT ARE NOT
REQUIRED TO BE MAINTAINED BY THE
STRADA BELLA AT OLDE CYPRESS
NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION, INC.
'WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County. Florida, on
March 26. 2002 approved the plat of Strada Bella for recording; and
WHEREAS. the Developer has constJlJcted and maintained the roadway and
drainage improvements in accordance with the approved plans and specifications as
required by the Land Development Code (Collier County Ordinance No. 04-41, as
amended): and
\V1--rEREAS. the Developer is requesting final acceptance of the roadway and
drainage improvements and re-lease of his maintenance security; and
WHEREAS. the Engineering Services Department has inspected the roadway and
drainage improvements, and is recommending acceptance of said facilities.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORJDA, that final acceptance is hereby
granted for those roadway and drainage improvements in Strada Bella, pursuant to the
plat thereof recorded in Plat Book 40, pages 69 through 70, and the Clerk is hereby
authorized to release the maintenance security.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED AND ORDERED that the County accept the
future maintenance and other attendant costs for those roadway and drainage
improvements that are not required to be maintained by the Strada Bella at OIde Cypress
Neighborhood Association, Inc.
This Resolution adopted after motion, second and majority vote favoring same,
this _ day of ,2007.
DATE;
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORJDA
By:
. Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and legal
~
Jeff. ght
Assistant Collier County Attorney
Agenda Item No. 108
November 27, 2007
Page 1 of 11
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to adopt a Resolution (Initiating Resolution) of
the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida,
pursuant to part II of Chapter 171, Florida Statutes (Florida's
Interlocal Service Boundary Act) to commence the process for
negotiating an interlocal service boundary agreement regarding
204.19 acres of land, more or less, described as the Hole in the
Wall Golf Club, proposed to be annexed into the City of Naples.
OBJECTIVE: Recommendation by the County Manager that the Board of
County Commissioners (Board) adopt the attached Initiating Resolution to
commence the process for negotiating an inter10cal service boundary agreement
regarding approximately 204.19 acres of land, more or less, described in the
Resolution as the Hole in the Wall Golf Club, currently being proposed to be
annexed into the City of Naples. The specified acreage is based solely upon the
application for annexation.
-
CONSIDERATIONS: The area to be discussed is at least the acreage described
in the Resolution as the Hole in the Wall Golf Club, consisting of 204.19 acres,
more or less. The City can add additional acreage for discussion.
The principal purposes of an inter10cal service boundary agreement are to agree
how best to provide services to residents and property in the most efficient and
effective manner while balancing the needs and desires of the Community; Also
to establish a more flexible process for adjusting municipal boundaries and to
address a wider range of the effects of annexation and to encourage
intergovernmental coordination in planning, service delivery, and boundary
adjustments and to reduce intergovernmental conflicts and reduce litigation
between local governments; Also to promote sensible boundaries that reduce
the costs of local governments, avoid duplicating local services, increase political
transparency and accountability and to prevent inefficient service delivery and an
insufficient tax base to support the delivery of services.
This Resolution invites the City of Naples and the North Naples Fire Control and
Rescue District to participate in the agreement negotiation process. The City can
invite certain other participants into the negotiating process.
GROwrH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: An interlocal agreement that may result
from this process can result in growth management impacts regarding Collier
County, but those impacts are not yet known.
-
/~genda Item ['-Jo. 10S
November 27. 2007
Page 2 of 11
FISCAL IMPACT: An intertocal agreement that may result from this process will
have fiscal impacts regarding Collier County, but those impacts are not yet
known.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: According to the County Attomey, the form and
legal sufficiency of this proposed Initiating Resolution complies with Florida's
Interlocal Service Boundary Act.
RECOMMENDATION: Recommendation by the County Manager that the Board
of County Commissioners adopt the attached Initiating Resolution to commence
the process for negotiating an interlocal service boundary agreement regarding
approximately 204.19 acres of land, more or less, described as the Hole in the
Wall Golf Club, currently being proposed to be annexed into the City of Naples.
Prepared by: Tom Palmer, Assistant County Attomey
Page 1 of 1
Pcaellda Item No 10S
I'-JcJvcm;)el 27, ;:007
Pag~') :'\ of 11
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMM!SS!ONERS
Item Number:
Item Summary:
10S
r:ecomll1endalion Ie. Bonp1 ,I ReS61ullon Ilni113\ing Re:old!lOIl) 01 tile Board of COUIlT}'
CUl11r1l!ssicllers Of Collier Count)', FiorldB. ptw;uant 10 ;:-'a,111 01 Ch,~pfer 171. "'iolida Statute5
,"iQfitia5 interloea! ~~8r'i:ce [10cH'UarYM,cn to G:)rnrne'l~,C Ihe prOG8S;, ftJr 119goHalmc; an
''It'O; rI OCb: 5ervicf.' DOlJnr.fill)' ,!g~c;ern rent r eJ ".-dlnq 2(J~ 1,' H';.-e~; 'ii i;ond, r.lOrs OJ' IBS S
(i8S(;f1bH:I iF ti,e Huic II i'K '{);;Ii {:,oli r.,~!'-It) proposs,,: lG ~)", WliKX,!rJ 'n'o \,',' Cil'i of r'''IJles
'i<p'Mum; '::O'-lnll' Mal aq(Yi
Meeting Date:
11:;;7i2ur ":fJD DC-.'\~~
Approved By
Jillr,,,,,.. \" T~lJ(1d
Gaunt, Manilp"r
[Ml",
Soard of c.()un~v
(:',llnml~SI,:.;n",r"
C;"Ui1lJ MilI"'("'''''' Off.""
."14i200TS 40PY
file://C:\AgendaT est\Export\93- November%2027, %202007\] O. %20COUNTY%20!vlJ\~A.. ] 1/20/2007
Agenda item No.1 OS
November 27. 2007
Page 4 of 11
RESOLUTION NO. 2007-
A RESOLUTION (INITIATING RESOLUTION) OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, PURSUANT TO PART II OF
CHAPTER 171, FLORIDA STATUTES (FLORIDA'S INTERLOCAL SERVICE BOUNDARY
ACT) TO COMMENCE THE PROCESS FOR NEGOTIATING AN INTERLOCAL SERVICE
BOUNDARY AGREEMENT REGARDING 204.19 ACRES OF LAND, MORE OR LESS,
DESCRIBED HEREIN AS THE HOLE IN THE WALL GOLF CLUB, PROPOSED TO BE
ANNEXED INTO THE CITY OF NAPLES
WHEREAS, Florida's Interlocal Service Boundary Act (herein "the Acl"), being Chapter 2006-
218, Laws of Florida, includes sections 171.20, 171.201. 171.202, 171.203, 171.204,
171.205, 171.206, 171.207, 171.208, 171.209, 171.21, 171.211 and 171.212, Florida
Statutes, approved by Governor Bush on June 14. 2006; and
WHEREAS, the Act's principal goals, as stated in the Act's section 171.201. are to
encourage local governments to jointly determine how to provide services to residents and
property in the most efficient and effective manner while balancing the needs and desires of
the Community; Also to establish a more flexibie process for adjusting municipal boundaries
and to address a wider range of the effects of annexation and to encourage
intergovernmental coordination in planning, service delivery, and boundary adjustments and
to reduce intergovernmental conflicts and litigation between local governments; Also to
promote sensible boundaries that reduce the costs of local governments, avoid duplicating
local services, and increase political transparency and accountability and to prevent
inefficient service delivery and an insufficient tax base to support the delivery of services; and
WHEREAS, as defined in the Act's subsection 171.202(7). this resolution IS Collier County's
"initiating resolution" to commence the process for negotiating an interlacal service boundary
agreement and which identifies the County's specified unincorporated area and the County's
designated issues for discussion; and
WHEREAS, as defined in the Act's subsection 171.201(8). an "Interlocal service boundary
agreement" means an agreement adopted pursuant to the Act between a county and one or
more municipalities, and which may include one or more defined independent special districts
as parties to the agreement; and
WHEREAS, as defined in the Act's subsection 171.202(3), the applicable "independent
special districts" are limited to special districts as defined in Section 189.403, Florida
Statutes, and that provide fire, emergency medical, water, wastewater, andlor stormwater
services; and
WHEREAS, the Act's subsection 171.203(2) specifies that within sixty (60) days alter receipt
of this initiating resolution, the City of Naples shall adopt its responding resolution, wherein
the City can identify an additional unincorporated area or incorporated area, or both, for
discussion; Also the City may thereby designate additional issues for negotiation, and
pursuant to the Act's subsection 171.202(15), may designate one other special district; and
WHEREAS, as stated in the Act's subsection 171.203(2)(d), each qualified independent
district that receives the County's initiating resolution can participate in the interlocal service
boundary agreement negotiation process by adopting its resolution indicating such intent; and
WHEREAS, as stated in the Act's subsection 171.203(16), the Act does not authorize one
local government to require another local government to enter into an interlocal service
boundary agreement, but when the process for negotiating an interlocal service boundary
agreement is initiated, the local governments shall negotiate in good faith to the conclusion of
the process established in the Act's Section 171.203; and
WHEREAS, as defined in the Act's subsections 171.202(4) and (5), Collier County is the
"Initiating County" and is also the "Initiating local government;" and
WHEREAS. pursuant to the Act's subsection 171.203(1), the land area to be discussed
pursuant to this process is described herein as the Hole in the Wall Golf Club, which
Agenda Item No. 103
November 27, 2007
Page 5 of 11
according to the application for annexation, consists of 204.19 acres, more or less, which
land area is depicted on the map (the "descriptive exhibit") attached to this Resolution as
Exhibit A; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to the Act's subsection 171.203(1), Collier County's designated issues
to be negotiated are listed below in the body of this Resolution; and
WHEREAS, as defined in the Act's subsection 171.202(9), an "invited local government"
means each invited county, municipality, or special district and any other local government
designated as such in an initiating resolution, or is a responding resolution, that invrtes the
respective local government(s) to participate in negotiating an interlocal service boundary
agreement; and
WHEREAS, Collier County's two (2) "Invited local governments" are the City of Naples (the
County's designated "invited municipality"), and the North Naples Fire Control and Rescue
District, an Independent Special District, as a "Notified local government" or and "invited local
government."
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that:
1. The above WHEREAS clauses are incorporated herein.
2. Collier County. as "the initiating county," hereby designates the City of Naples
as the County's "invlted municipality."
3. Collier County, as "the initiating county," hereby notifies the North Naples Fire
Control and Rescue District of this Resolution as a "Notified local government" or and "invited
local government."
4. The County's designated land area, all of which is unincorporated, is described
herein as the Hole in the Wall Go~ Club, which land areas, which according to the application
for annexation, consists of 204.19 acres, more or less, and which acreage is depicted on the
map attached to this Resolution as Exhibrt A ("the descriptive exhibit"). Based upon the
application for annexation, the legal description of this land area proposed to be annexed into
the City of Naples is:
Lots 23-32: Lots 23 through 32, inclusive, of Naples Improvement Company's
Little Farms, according to the Plat thereof, recorded in Plat Book 2 at page 2,
Public Records of Collier County, Florida, consisting of 187.8 acres, more or less;
AND
Parcel A: All that part of the West 198 feet of the Southwest 1/4 of the Northwest
1/4 of Section 23, Township 49 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida
being more particularly described as commencing at the Northwest corner of the
Southwest 1/4 of the Northwest 1/4 of said Section 23; thence North 88"47'48"
East along the quarter section line a distance of 34.14 feet to an intersection with
the Easterly top of bank of Gordon River Drainage Ditch, said intersection being
the point of beginning of the parcel herein being described; thence continue
along said quarter section line North 88"47'48" East 163.86 feet to an
intersection with the Easterly line of said West 198 feet; thence South 01"03'02"
East along said Easterly line a distance of 273.03 feet to an intersection with said
Easterly top of bank of said Drainage Ditch; thence leaving said Easterly line
along said Easterly top of bank of said Ditch on the following (15) described
courses; thence North 53"25'20" West 33.78 feet; thence North 31"33'28" West
53.27 feet; thence North 04"11'51" East 11.28 feet; thence North 47"24'49" East
44.09 feet; thence North 58"17'59" West 18.87 feet; thence South 89"41'10"
West 10.73 feet; thence North 32"14'57" West 8.80 feet; thence North 04"43'32"
West 9.48 feet; thence North 20"23'31" West 41.72 feet; thence North 51"04'36"
West 32.24 feet; thence North 71 "03'18" West 37.17 feet; thence North 63"49'18"
West 18.83 feet; thence North 31"13'48" West 21.70 feet; thence North 07"59'10"
2
Agenda Item NO.1 OS
November 27.2007
Page 6 of 11
West 9.96 feet; thence North 20"35'44" West 29.93 feet to the point of be9inning
of the parcel herein described; containing .46 acres of land, more or less;
AND
Parcel B: All that part of the West 198 feet of the Southwest 1/4 of the Northwest
1/4 of Section 23, Township 49 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida,
being more particularly described as commencing at the Northwest corner of the
Southwest 1/4 of the Northwest 1/4 of said Section 23, thence South 01"03'02"
East alon9 the Westerly line of said Southwest 1/4 of said Northwest 1/4 a
distance of 133.83 feet to an intersection with the Southerly line of said
Southwest 1/4 of said Northwest 1/4; thence North 83"54'01" East along said
Southerly line a distance of 132.59 feet to an intersection wijh the Easterly top of
Bank of the Gordon River Drainage ditch, said intersection being the point of
beginning of the parcel herein being described; thence continue along said
Southerly line of said Southwest 1/4 f said Northwest 1/4 North 88"54'01" East
65.41 feet to an intersection with the Easterly line if said West 198 feet; thence
North 01 "03'02" West along said Easterly line a distance of 111.67 feet to an
intersection with said Easterly top of bank of said Drainage Ditch; thence leaving
said Easterly line along top of bank of said Ditch on the following (4) described
courses; thence South 2rOO'26" West 21.88 feet; thence South 24"05'47" West
46.76 feet; thence South 32"01'31" West 25.39 feet; thence South 35"32'50"
West 35.89 feet to the point of beginning of the parcel herein described;
containing 3,319 square feet of land, more or less;
AND
Parcel C: All that part of the Southwest 1/4 of the Northwest 1/4 of Section 23,
Township 49 South. Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida, being more
particularly described as commencing at the Northwest corner of the Southwest
1/4 of the Northwest 1/4 of said Section 23, then North 88"47'48" East along the
quarter section line a distance of 198.00 feet; thence South 01"03'02" East
364.32 Feet to an intersection with the Westerly top of bank of the Gordon River
drainage ditch said intersection being the point of beginning of the parcel herein
being described; thence continue South 01"03'02" East 736.41 feet to an
intersection with the Westerly top of Bank of said drainage ditch; thence
Northerly along said top of bank of said ditch on the following (21) described
courses; thence North 13"42'35" East 32.39 feet; thence North 26"03'47" East
43.29 feet; thence North 51"45'44" East 49.62 feet; thence North 24"49'56" East
48.02 feet; thence North Or46'47" East 21.12 feet; thence North 18"07'01" West
36.65 feet; thence North 59"17'51" West 11.23 feet; thence North 13"55'41" West
23.82 feet; thence North 12"53'05" East 39.20 feet; thence North 23"26'05" West
11.48 feet; thence North 46"31'46" West 9.64 feet; thence North 21"12'44" West
81.61 feet; thence North 11"17'34" West 41.72 feet; thence North 00"16'46" West
52.13 feet; thence North 10"22'33" East 35.20 feet; thence North 10"15'09" West
31.07 feet; thence North 12"45'32" East 27.21 feet; thence North 03"05'53" East
25.26 feet; thence North 33"51'45" West 21.85 feet; thence North 12"19'53" West
136.08 feet; thence North Or1 0'32" West 15.60 feet to the point of beginning of
the parcel herein described; containing .69 acres of land, more or less;
AND
Parcel D: All that part of the Northwest 1/4 of the Southwest 1/4 of Section 23,
Township 49 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida, being more
particularly described as commencing at the Northwest corner of the Southwest
1/4 of the North 1/4 of said Section 23; thence South 01"03'02" East 1333.83 feet
to the point of beginning of the parcel herein bein9 described; thence South
01"04'22", East 126.09 feet to an intersection with the Westerly top of bank of
the Gordon River Drainage Ditch; thence North aiong the top of the Bank of said
Ditch on the following (2) described courses; thence North 36"04'54" East 137.45
feet; thence North 38"45'50" East to an intersection with the Southerly line of said
Southwest 1/4 of the Northwest 1/4; thence South 88"54'01" West along said
Southerly line a distance of 96.85 Feet to the point of beginning of the parcel
herein described; containing 6,036 square feet of land, more or less.
,
Agenda Item No. 108
November 27. 2007
Page 7 of 11
5. The County's designated issues for negotiation are any and all issues
concerning service delivery, fiscal responsibilities, andlor boundary adjustments. The
interlocal service boundary agreement issues may include, but need not be limited to, the
foliowing:
a.
b.
c.
foliowing services
including:
Identilying a municipal service area.
Identilying an unincorporated service area.
Identilying the local government responsible for delivery or funding of the
within the municipal service area or the unincorporated service "rea
1. Public safety
2. Fire, emergency rescue, and medical.
3. Water and wastewater.
4. Road ownership, construction, and maintenance.
5. Conservation, parks, and recreation.
6. Stormwater management and drainage.
7. Garbageltrash coliection and recycling.
d. The interlocal service boundary agreement may establish a process and
schedule for annexation of an area within the designated municipal service area, if any,
consistent with the Act's Section 171.205.
e. The interlocal service boundary agreement may establish a process for
iand-use decisions consistent with part II of Chapter 163, Florida Statutes, including those
made jointly by the governing bodies of the County and the City of Naples. or aliow the City of
Naples to adopt land-use changes consistent WITh part II of Chapter 163, Florida Statutes, for
other land areas, if any, scheduled to be annexed during the term of years specified in the
interlace! service boundary agreement. If the agreement addresses responsibility for land-
use planning under Chapter 163, Florida Statutes, the agreement may also establish the
procedures for preparing and adopting comprehensive plan amendments, administering land-
development regulations, and issuing development orders.
f. The interlocal service boundary agreement may address other issues
concerning service delivery, including the transfer of services and infrastructure.
g. The interlocal service boundary agreement may provide for the joint use
of facilities and the colocation of services.
h. The interlocal service boundary agreement may Include a requirement
for a report to Collier County from the City of Napies of the City's planned service delivery, as
provided in the Act's Section 171.042, or as otherwise may be determined by the Agreement.
i. The interlocal service boundary agreement may establish a process by
which the local government that is responsible for water and wastewater services shali, within
thirty (30) days after any respective annexation of territory, apply for modifications to permits
of the water management district andlor Florida's Department of Environmental Protection
which are necessary to reflect changes in the entity that is responsible for managing surface
water under such permtts.
j. As stated in the Act's subsection 171.203(8), in order to ensure that the
health and welfare of the residents affected by annexation will be protected, all fire and
emergency medical services shall be provided by the existing provider of fire and emergency
medical services to the annexed area and remain part of the special district unless Collier
County and the City of Naples reach an agreement, through the interlocal service boundary
agreement or other iegally sufficient means, as to which entities shall provide those
emergency services.
6. As stated in the Act's subsections 171.203(1) (a), (b), and (c), the County
Manager shall, by United States certified mail, send copy of this initiating Resolution (a) to
the City Manager of the CITY of Naples, (b) to the City Manager of the City of Marco Island, (c)
to the Mayor of Everglades City, and (d) to the Chief Administrative Officer of the North
Naples Fire Control and Rescue District, Chief Michael L Brown.
4
.
7. This Resolution shall take effect immediately upon adoption.
ADOPTED this _ day of
majority vote favoring adoption.
Agenda Item No. 105
~Iovember 27. 2007
Page 8 of 11
, 2007 after motion, second and
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, Chairman
Approved as to form and legal sufficiency:
/- [)~
By: ~ D V'" d'- IM,<------
Thomas . Palmer, Assistant County Attorney
5
.
.~
HIGHliONDSDIl
"
"'c;HIGAN ~vr.I~!
,81
--.--ie'
WOODSDP.
CYPRfSS__j I
j)
HE.~~~
.
i~
.
IS
, "
2223
ClTYOI" NAPLES
ilL
CITVOFtlAPLfS
(EN1RANCETOROY-,\
PO,NCIANAGOLfCL1I6
~
r-----.... WILDERNESS
I ~CDUN1RYCLU8
Lo
ji
.
EXHIBIT A
No '105
Agenda Item?7 2007
November ~ 9' of '1
Page .
ROYALPOlNCIAH..
GOlf COURSE
,
c,
R[JHL POINCIANA
GGLFCOtJRSE;
~
o
o
'-.
~t:'PL~
~ t(g)" e<l'.....~
~ >< ~1ti~ b'~
~~.. ':'!."-Ii}.~
~ .e:
~ ---"'~
~'>Q<:k
?;' i'
l, ..~ ./ // A. /'
/'t'~0 ~.~
OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER
TELEPHONE (239) 213-1030. FACSIMILE (239) 213-1033
735 EIGHTH STREET SOUTH. NAPLES, FLORIDA 34102-6796
November 20, 2007
Mr. Jim Mudd, County Manager
Collier County
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples, FL 34112
Re: Annexation of the Hole in the Wall Golf Club
Dear Mr. Mudd:
Aoenda Item NO.1 OS
November 27, 2007
/7.... .!ag.e JO oJ 11
L,P"--~ IjeO/"I.
o RECEIVED
FFICE OF THE COUNTY M
ANAGER
NUV L J 2aC?
ACTION ~..k
-- _______....... w. rD
On December 5, 2007, the City of Naples City Council will be considering a petition to
annex the Hole in the Wall Golf Club. Pursuant to Florida Statute Section 171.044(6),
we are providing the Board of County Commissioners with a copy of the notice for this
annexation. If you have any questions or concerns regarding this petition or the attached
notice, please contact my office at your earliest convenience.
Sincerely,
/lj~' / /~
C1"'-f/7;'~1
Chet Hunt
Interim City Manager
CV' r ?, , ff-O
c:d.... ad:.~ ad"~... .~~ k"of,;..; ~ y.fP... (..:e~ m. ad" r.A:d uoe ah.
'I C~A'lE
'.:+::=
N
A
NOTICE OF
VOLUNTARY
ANNEXATION
Notice is hereby given that the Naples
City Council will hold a meeting
beginning at 9:00 a.m., Wednesday,
December 5, 2007, in City Council
Chambers, 735 81h Street South,
Naples, Florida 34102.
Among the public hearings to be
considered is:
ANNEXATION PETITION 07-AX2
ORDINANCE NO, 07-11886
GRANTING VOLUNTARY
ANNEXATION OF APPROXIMATELY
205.38 ACRE TRACT COMMONLY
KNOWN AS HOLE IN THE WALL
GOLF CLUB; MORE FULLY
DESCRIBED HEREIN, AND
PROVIDING A SEVERABILITY
CLAUSE, A REPEALER PROVISION,
AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE,
Petitioner: Hole in the Wall Golf Club
Location: 3880 Goodlette Road North
Agent: John M. Passidomo, Esq.
A complete legal description by metes
and bounds and a copy of the
proposed ordinance may be inspected
by the public at the City Clerk's Office,
735 8th Street South, Naples, Florida,
(239) 213-1015.
ALL INTERESTED PARTIES ARE
INVITED TO APPEAR AT THE
MEETING AND BE HEARD WITH
RESPECT TO THE PROPOSED
ORDINANCE.
Any person who decides to appeal
any decision made by the City
Council with respect to any matter
considered at this hearing will need
a record of the proceedings and
may need to ensure that a verbatim
record is made, which record
includes the testimony and evidence
upon which the appeal is to be
heard. Any person with a disability
requiring auxiliary aids and services
for this meeting may call the City
Clerk's office at 213-1015 with
requests at least two business days
before the meeting date.
City Council of the City of Naples
Tara Norman, City Clerk
.A.genda Item NO.1 OS
I~ovember 27. 2007
Page 11 of '1
Agenda Item NO.1 OT
November 27, 2007
Page 1 of 53
-
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to approve a modification to Agreement 07- EC-33-Q9-21-
01.486 between the State of Florida, Division of Emergency Management
and Collier County accepting an additional $1,693,940 towards the
construction of a new County Emergency Operations Center (eOC) within
the Emergency Services Center (ESC) and approve the Budget Amendment
necessary to recognize and appropriate $1,693,940 as revenue
OBJECTIVE: Board of County Commissioners approved Agreement #07-EC-33-09-
21-01 between the State of Florida, Division of Emergency Management and Collier
County accepting $1,510,094 for the construction of a new County EOC within the
Collier County ESC on May 8, 2007. This modification adds an additional $1,693,940 of
Federal funding to offset the additional construction cost necessary to provide wind
protection above normal Florida building code.
CONSIDERATIONS: The State of Florida, Division of Emergency Management has
approved a total of $3,204,034 towards the construction of the County's new EOC. This
modification to the existing agreement represents the Federal award of $1,693,940 of
Hazard Mitigation Grant Program (HMGP) funding.
-
These General Revenue Funds must be utilized solely for the construction (can not be
used for fixtures, furniture or equipment) of the EOC portion of the overall ESC project.
This modification to the existing Agreement does not change the previous Scope of Work
requirements which have been reviewed by county staff and the design team and are
considered appropriate, achievable and consistent with what is currently programmed.
FISCAL IMPACT: A budget amendment is needed to recognize this additional HMGP
revenue of $1,693,940 and to increase the Emergency Services Center project (52160)
budget by $1,693,940.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners approve the
modification to Agreement 07-EC-33-09-21-01-486 between the State of Florida
Division of Emergency Management and Collier County accepting an additional
$1,693,940 towards the construction of a new County EOC and approve the necessary
budget amendment.
Prepared by: Jim von Rinteln, EM Coordinator
Emergency Management Department
-
Page ] of 1
A~lend", Ilem No_ 1(n
NO'/f:mbei' 27_ 2CJ07
Paqe 2 of 53
COLLIER COUNTY
BOAR() OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Item Number:
Item Summary:
11)T
Fi1o'co,"'rr:endatlon 10 appro"8 8 f)looificall0n10 f<.green'l8n! ()7E'_C-33-0'),2'1.Q",-4fjf. between
nit' "tale Of f-'iona,o, QI\'!SICr1 of Lme,gen':v Managemeni <H1Q Colliel Cotmty iKceptillg an
aw.liticr;al :1'1 ,(,O:UM:) t'Ytiar'05 1i'le con5trl;c\ion ,;,f'ii new CO',mtll :',fll8r9t-m::y C!-",:'fitl(lr1f
'''ll1e' {[OCI wi,hin Irk En',erg8n~v f-;efvIGe~ Cefller iES~Cf (!nd <JcprQVf, tll& Budget
"'IPTvhie;nl nece~',s,H',' it' r{ ~'(Jnr:i2'~" WIG fiOV( ,';"(;1'(;; :,1 -,093,','1:) cas I'PV"!"lW '-,,,-, '.--{)I'
i'i,nlelli. l:::m"rg8Ixy MerlilQenler1',Co':>r(il')<H.or;,
Meeting Date;
'I 1C;'::'OC7,J:OCI0:',Q,l
Approved By
Oa11 L :;urnmfn~
burellu Of Em"'9"ncy :,.".vi(;,,~ Dirw;1:l;Ir
nill,!
C'lllmv P,Jllln3g~r'f, 01'1'
Ej,mwu of :',mergH1cy ~>crviG()s
'i.'19/20C/1 :15/',,"
Appru"ed R~'
:~'L'<l1 'j;;Il!>1
:;""'(d ~"-:~H"rWr1L()n1:/i'Jud\I"t i'n~lyct
!lA",
'';rJUIll\' ~'r;-ln,og,.,,, OFi","
'lH'rC< oi r"'MFLQ(.;;",,,j' [~H:f(l(il
1::~11:'U(),' ~ T: "M
Apllruved 8;y
.. '''(I",:::''',\-,k" "h
!-,',;m:l{l"'n"'-":e."h,nU("1,j"
-;ntc
" ,',,,,tv r'-'fc",~Qf" '; '~)lfic"
;!fj,Ci~ ".- l/'iln"""""",' :', 'wyf
'1.'1'1/;:[,{J7 ~ ,'0' f-'Pi
Approvt'd fly
"on!
file://C:\Agenda Test\Export\93~ Novemher%2027, %202007\] 0, %.20COUNTY%20MANA.. 11/20/2007
!:;gE:mda Hem r\jo. 'lOT
November 27, 2007
Page 3 of 53
Contract Number: 07-EC-33-09-21-01-486
MODIFICATION #1 TO STATE-FUNDED SUBGRANT AGREEMENT
This Modification is made and entered into by and between the State of Florida, Division
of Emergency Management, ("the Division"), and Collier County ("the Recipient.)
to modify the Division's Contract Number 07-EC-33-09-21-01-486, dated June 1, 2007 ("the
Agreement").
WHEREAS. the Division and the Recipient have entered into the Agreement, pursuant to
which the Division has provided a sub grant of $1 ,510,094.00 in state funds to Recipient; and
WHEREAS, the Division now intends to provide additional funds to the Recipient of
$1,693,940.00 in federal funds; and
WHEREAS. the state funds of $1.51 0,094.00 must be expended on or before June 30.
2009, and the federal funds of $1 ,693,940.00 must be expended on or before November 5,2010,
and
WHEREAS. the Division and the Recipient desire to modify the Agreement by amending
the Scope of Work, the Budget and by adding the appropriate federal attachments
NOW, THEREFORE. In conSideration of the mutual promises of the parties contallled
herein, the parties agree as follows.
1. Paragraph 3 of the Agreement is hereby amended is to read as follows:
This Agreement shall begin upon execution by both parties, and shall end November 5,
2010, unless terminated earlier in accordance with the provisions of Paragraph (12) of
this Agreement.
2. Paragraph 17 of the Agreement is hereby amended to increase the total funding under
the Agreement to $3,204,034.00.
3. The Budget and Scope of Work, Attachment A, to this Agreement, is hereby deleted in its
entirety, and the Budget and Scope of Work, Revised Attachment A-State and Revised
Attachment A-Federal, to this Modification, which are attached hereto and incorporated
herein by reference, are substituted in its place and stead. The revised Budget and
Scope of Work, Attachment A-Federal. contains the additional provisions that apply to the
added federal funding.
4. Attachment E, Federal Audit Requirements, is attached hereto and incorporated herein
by reference. Attachment E is required for compliance with federal standards.
5. Attachment F, Federal Recordkeeping, is attached hereto and incorporated herein by
reference, Attachment F is required for compliance with federal standards.
6. Attachment G, Federal Standard Conditions, is attached hereto and incorporated herein
by reference. Attachment G is required for compliance with federal standards.
7. Attachment H, Federal Lobbying Prohibition, is attached hereto and incorporated herein
by reference. Attachment H is required for compliance with federal standards.
8. Attachment I, Federal Certification Regarding Debarment, Suspension, Ineligibility and
Voluntary Exclusion, is attached hereto and incorporated herein by reference.
Attachment I is required for compliance with federal standards.
J\genda item NO.1 (iT
November 27, 2007
Page 4 of 53
9. Attachment J, Federal Statement of Assurances, is attached hereto and Incorporated
herein by reference. Attachment J is required for compliance with federal standards.
10. All provisions not in conflict with this Modification remain in full force and effect. and are
to be performed at the level specified in the Agreement.
11. All provisions of the Agreement being modified and any attachments thereto in conflict
with this Modification shall be and are hereby changed to conform with this Modification,
effective as of the date of the iast execution of this Modification by both parties.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this document as of the
dates set out herein.
RECIPIENT: Collier County Board of County Commissioners
BY:
NAME & TITLE: Jim Coletta, Chairman
DATE'
SAMAS # 07-EC-33-09-21-01-486
F I D# 59-500000558
ATTEST: Dwight E. Brock, Clerk
(Deputy Clerk)
Approved as to Form and legal Sufficiency
Assistant County Attorney
STATE OF FLORIDA
DIVISION OF EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT
BY:
W. Craig Fugate, Director
DATE:
2
t,g'2ncia item ['>la. I u r
r\'ovember 27, 2007
Page 5 of 52.
Revised Attachment A State
Budget and Scope of Work
Draft1c HB 7121 EOC Scope-of-Work; Ref: 2006-71. Laws of Florida
I. SCOPE OF WORK
A. The Recipient shall construct a County Emergency Operations Center (EOC). Use of
grant funds shall be consistent with Section 1(1), Ch. 2006-71, Laws of Florida. Grant funds shall
not be used for land acquisition; purchase of equipment, furnishings. communications, or
operational systems; or recurnng expenditures.
Ellgibie reimbursement costs Include: Architectural and Engineering services and fees: site
survey and soil testing; necessary permits and fees; civil and service utilities site work;
construction of the building's substructure, superstructure, shell (exterior enclosure) and interior
construction; special Inspections; mechanical, plumbing. electrical. conveying and security
systems; lightning protection, and redundant infrastructure systems (e.g.. electric generator.
uninterruptible power supply, potable water and wastewater systems, etc,).
B. The Recipient shall In a timely manner prepare and submit a complete Hazard Mitigation
Grant Program (HMGP) application. benefit-cost analysis, enVIronmental review and such other
documentation as necessary to determine eligibility and allowable costs under said grant
program.
C. The Recipient shall state in writing that for a period of not iess than 15 years from the
date of receipt of Certificate of Occupancy the EOC will be dedicated for emergency management
purposes. The EOC shall remain demonstrably capable of being fully activated within one (1)
hour of detection of an emergency; reference Rule Chapter 9G-6, Florida Administrative Code,
"Emergency Management Capabilities Assessment Checklist."
D. The EOC shall be constructed with sufficient space to house people and equipment for
day-to-day and sustained continuous emergency operations, and capable of full staffing for the
most extensive emergency anticipated. At a minimum, the designated EOC functional area(s),
and essential shared-use area(s) if applicabie, shall be designed for an emergency operations
staff size of 130 persons per shift and a workspace floor area of 11,050 gross square feet.
E. At a minimum, the EOC shall meet the hurricane hazard safety criteria established in
Standards for Hurricane Evacuation Shelter Selection (ARC 4496).
F. The EOC and essential ancillary structures and service equipment shall be designed to
resist the effects of a major hurricane, The wind load design requirements shall be in accordance
with the American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) Standard 7, Minimum Design Loads for
Buildings and Other Structures. The minimum wind design criteria shall include:
Design Wind Speed = 175 miles per hour (3 second gust)
Wind Importance Factor, / = 1.00
Exposure Category = C
Directionaiity Factor, Kd = 1.00
Internal Pressure Coefficient, Gep! = +/- 0.18
3
,L\.genda 11em hlo, 1 Gr
November 27. 2007
Page f, ~f 53
All components and cladding assemblies necessary to maintain a structurally enclosed condition
and prevent rainwater intrusion shall be designed to meet the wind design criteria. Structural
metal decking and cladding materials shall be 22 gauge or thicker. Roof cover waterproofing
barriers shall meet the wind design criteria. Loose roof ballast shall not be used on the roof
cover. Rooftop equipment shall be designed and installed to meet the wind design criteria.
G. The EOC and essentlai ancillary structures and service equipment shall resist penetration
by windborne debris impact. At a minimum, all exterior enclosure components, c1addings and
assemblies (i.e., walls, roofs. louvers, windows, doors, etc.) located within 60 feet in height above
finish grade shall meet the hurricane windborne debris impact criteria specified in the Department
of Energy's (DOE) Standard, Natural Phenomena Hazards Design and Evaluation Criteria, DOE-
STD-1020-2002. That is, the building enclosure must resist penetration by a nominal 2"x4"
lumber plank weighing 15 pounds propelled at 50 miles per hour (74 feet per second) striking
end-on and normal to the assembly surface, or equivalent performance as approved by the
Division. As applicable, impact test procedures shall be consistent w~h recognized state and
national standards; such as, Test Standard for Determining Impact Resistance from Windborne
Debris SSTD 12, American Society of Testing and lv1aterials (ASTIv1) Standards ASTIv1 E 1886
and ASTIv1 E 1996, and Florida Building Code Testing Protocols TAS 201. TP,S 202 and TAS
203. The impact: test procedures may be modified as necessary w accommodate the required missile
weight and velocity.
H. The following information related to wind loads and flooding shall be shown on the
construction drawings: 1. wind design per ASCE 7 with applicable year of revision; 2. design Wind
speed; 3. wind importance factor, /; 4. design wind exposure category; 5. wind directionality
factor, Kd; 6. design internal pressure coefficient, GCpi; 7. design wind pressures in terms of
pounds per square foot (psf) to be used for the design of exterior component and cladding
materials not specifically designed by the principal licensed design professional; 8. wind borne
debris impact performance criteria; 9. finish floor elevation measured relative to the National
Geodetic Vertical Datum (NGVD); and comparison reference of the finished floor elevation to the
base flood eievation, or historical flood elevation if base flood elevation is not determined.
I. The lowest floor for the EOC and essential ancillary structures and service equipment shall
at a minimum be elevated above: Category 5 hurricane storm surge elevation; the base flood
elevation plus three (3) feet; the 500-year (0.2 percent annual chance) flood elevation (if
determined) plus two (2) feet; the highest recorded flood elevation plus three (3) feet if the area is
not in a mapped special flood hazard area; whichever is greater. The site (point maximum, one
square mile) hydrologic design shall ensure that the EOC and essential ancillary structures and
service equipment are not flooded due to a 24 hour, 37.0 inch rainfall event applied over a
precedent 24 hour, 100-year rainfall event.
J. Where secondary (emergency) roof drains or scuppers are required by the Florida Building
Code-Plumbing, the secondary system shall be sized for a rainfall rate of eleven (I 1.0) inches per hour.
K. The EOC shall be designated as a threshold building, and special structural inspections
required. Special inspections shall be conducted in compliance with section 553.79, Florida
Statutes and other applicable statutes, laws and rules,
L. The EOC shall at a minimum be designed for 72 hours of self-contained continuous
operation and shall not be solely reliant upon off-site services and utilities (e.g., water, natural
gas fuel, electricity, etc.)
4
,l\genda Item f\la. 10T
hlovember 27. 2007
Page 7 of 53
M. Force protection and security measures shall be consistent with the guidance published in
Florida's Homeland Security Comprehensive Assessment Model (HLSCAM), United States Air
Force /nstallation Force Protection Guide, or other federal or state recognized best-practices
guide(s) as approved by the Division.
N. The Recipient shall provide an initial timeline and estimated reimbursement allocation
scheduie. Table SW-1, "Initial Timeline and Estimated Reimbursement Allocation Schedule" or
other similar instrument as approved by the Division may be used.
O. During design and construction phases of the EOC project, the Recipient shall track and
provide construction cost data for the designated EOC area as detailed in Tabie SW-2, "Cost
Data for County Emergency Operations Center."
II. PRODUCT ITEMS
A. Per item I.N, Recipient shall prepare an initial timeline with key milestone activities/tasks
schedule, including estimated start and end dates for each activity, and an estimate of state
reimbursement request for each activity. Table SW-1 may be used to meet this product item.
B. Per item I.C. Recipient shall submit a binding written statement that the EOC will be
dedicated for a period of not less than15 years for emergency management purposes, and
demonstrably capable of being fully activated within one (1) hour of detection of an emergency.
C. The Recipient shall provide one (1) copy each of site survey, site master plan, spatial
needs assessment, and schematic design plan or preliminary design drawings for review and
comment by the Division. The spatial needs assessment and schematic design plan/preliminary
design may be consolidated into one document,
D. The Recipient shall provide one (1) set of substantially complete (approximately 70
percent) preliminary design construction drawings and specifications for the EOC and essential
ancillary structures for review and comment by the Division. The construction drawings shall
include site survey information, landscaping, civil, architectural, structural, mechanical, plumbing,
and electrical drawings.
E. The Recipient shall provide one (1) set of bid-ready construction drawings and
specifications for the EOC and essential ancillary structures for review by the Division. The
construction drawings shall include site survey information, landscaping, civil, architectural,
structural, mechanical, plumbing, and electrical drawings and shall be certified by the applicable
registered or licensed design professional(s) of record.
F. The construction drawings shall demonstrate that the EOC will meet the hurricane hazard
safety criteria of ARC 4496, and the wind load, windborne debris impact, fiood and security
design requirements set forth in items I.E through I.M. Failure to supply the required
documentation, or disapproval of this documentation by the Division, shall result in denial of
funds.
G. Per item I.B, Recipient shall submit a complete HMGP application, benefit-cost analysis,
environmental review and such other documentation as necessary to determine eligibility and
cost allowances under said grant program. The Recipient shall also provide two cost estimates
prepared by one or more certified construction contractors that document the cost of constructing
the facility to meet current building code wind and flood design requirements, and the cost
premium of constructing the facility to the above-code wind and flood requirements set forth in
items I. E through I.J.
5
Agenda Item No. lOT
November 27. 2007
Page 8 of 53
H. Per item 1.0, the Recipient shall provide final project cost data. Table SW-2 shall be
used to meet this product item.
I. The Recipient shall provide the Division with copy(s) of pertinent construction permits, the
threshold inspection final report, and the certificate of occupancy upon completion of the
construction project.
III. SCHEDULE OF WORK
A. By June 30, 2007, the Recipient shall provide the Division with Product Items A and B for
review and approval. Failure to supply the required documentation, or disapproval of this
documentation by the Division. shall result in deniai of funds.
B. By September 30, 2007 and at least on a quarterly basis thereafter, Recipient shall report
on progress in relation to the initial timeline, and submit Product Items C througb H in a timely
manner as accomplished. The Division shall be provided 30 calendar days to review and provide
comments of product items pertaining to compliance with the scope-of-work. The Recipient.shall
also submit invoices for reimbursement for work accomplished in accordance with the Division
approved cost reimbursement allocation schedule referenced in Product Item A
C. Bya mutually agreed upon date, the Recipient shall provide the Division with Product
Item F for review and approval. Failure to supply the required documentation, or disapproval of
this documentation by the Division. shall result in denial or reduction of funds at the sole
discretion of the Division
D. By May 15, 2009, the Recipient shall provide final project cost estimate data as set forth
In Table SW-2, certificate of occupancy, close-Qut documentation and final payment invoice.
6
Ag'2nda item I\Ja. 1 T
l'\Jovember :::'7,20 7
Page 9 of :3
Table SW-1. Initial Timeline and Estimated Reimbursement Allocation Schedule
Table SW-l. Initial Timeline and Estimated Reimbursement Allocation Schedule
County Name: Collier
PROJECT PHASE Start Date End Date DEM Funds Other Funds
Board Contract
Approval
Initial Payment of
20% in first Quarter +
A&E Firm Selection
Site Survey and Soil ----------r I
Testing I I
Spatial Needs I --1-- ~___ ____J
I I
Assessment -t-- ----------~ --r-----~--- -----~-- ----------
: Preliminary Design, I I I
, I
I '
i 70% complete I I
------------ - ---~-_."~----",- - "------------------'_._-~--,-_._,--,._~-
~-
i Preliminary Design. I
1100% complete__L. .
! Repulatory Review f-
iBid Document(s)
--t--
I
!
-+- I I
i I !
! ! ~
_ T--~:~:-=----+----- I
I Development & I , I
,
I
Award
Notice to
Proceed/Mobilization
Construction Project
Management &
Special Inspections
Construction 25%
Complete
Construction 50%
Complete
Construction 100%
Comolete
Continaencv
Administrative Fees;
maximum of 5% $
Sub-Totals $ 3,204,034.
TOTAL Estimated
Proiect Cost
A&E - Architectural and Engineering; DEM - Division of Emergency Management; FY -
Fiscal Year
7
,"genda Item NO.1 OT
t~ovelllber 27, 2007
Page 10 of 53
Table SW-2. Cost Data for County Emergency Operations Center
Table SW-2.
Cost Data for County Emergency Operations Center
County Name: ~
... . .
NO. System/Component Description Estimated
Cost
A. SUBSTRUCTURE
1010 Foundation
1020 Slab-on-Grade --
2010 Excavation
2020 Basement Walls
- I
2030 Elevated
Foundation
B. SHELL (ENVELOPE) ---
- -------
B 10 Suoerstructure
-- --~-:--=--=~==~-~=~ --~~-~=~==l~__ ------1
1010 Floor Construction
1020 Roof Construction
1030 Structural Frame i
.. -- , I
1040 Load-Bearinq Wall .- I I
B20 Exterior Enclosure
2010 Exterior Walls
2011 Veneer/Claddina
2012 Louvers
2020 Exterior Windows
2030 Exterior Doors
B30 Roofing
3010 Roof Coverinas
3020 Roof Onenlnas
3021 Soffits
C. INTERIORS
1010 Partitions
1020 Interior Doors
1030 Fittinas
2010 Stair Construction
3010 Wall Finishes
3020 Floor Finishes
3030 Cellina- Finishes
0, SERVICES
010 Convevina
1010 Elevators & Lifts I
1020 Escalators & Walks I I
D20 Plumbinq
2010 Plumbina Fixtures
2020 Domestic Water
Distribution
2021 Back-up Potable
Water Svstem
8
Agenlia Item 1\10. 'j C'T
hJovernber 27 20C7
Page -; 1 :]f -53
2040 Rainwater
Drainaoe
D30 HVAC
3010 Eneroy Supply
3020 Heatino System
3030 CoolinQ System
3050 Terminal &
PackaQe Units
3090 Other HVAC Sys. i -
D40 Fire Protection
4010 Sprinkler Sys. I
4020 Standpipe SYs. i .---
4030 Other Sys. I -
D50 Electrical
5010 Elec. Service &
,
5020
I Distribution L
Lighting & Branch I
'w" I
: mng ,
I Communications & i
, Security !
I Other Elec. Sys.
I
I
,
I
. --------------------t
~
I
,
I
!
! 5030
! 5090
.. ~
5091 Generator Sys. I I !
5092 UPS Sys. I --- -.J- ~
I
E. EQUIPMENT & FURNISHINGS
1010 Commercial Equip.
1020 Institutional Equip. I
1030 Vehicular Eouip.
1090 Other Eouip.
1091 AudioNideo Eouip.
1092 Special Telecom
1093 Information Tech.
1094 Geo. Info. Sys.
F. SPECIAL CONSTRUCTION
1041 Generator
Enclosure
1042 Comm. Tower
1043 Helipad
1090 Other
G. BUILDING SITEWORK
1010 Earthwork
1020 Roadway & Parkino
1030 Drainage & Flood
Control
1040 Security Measures
1090 Other Sitework
9
,Agenda Item No. 'j OT
November 27. 2007
Page 12 0153
Revised Attachment A Federal
Budget and Scope of Work
As a Hazard Mitigation Grant Program project, the Recipient, Collier County, will wind retrofit the
new Collier County EOC located at 8125 Lely Cultural Boulevard in Naples, Florida 34113. The
entire shell and roof will be hardened beyond code against 175 mph winds and hurricane shutters
will be purchased and installed on all windows. If deemed necessary, wind protection will be
provided on any other openings such as skylights, vents, louvers, and exhaust fans. All
construction and installations will be done in strict compliance with Florida Building Codes
Specifications. All materials will be certified to meet the wind and impact standards of 175 mph
wind loads. The local municipal or county building department will inspect and certify
construction and installation according to the manufacturer specifications.
The Period of Performance for thiS project ends November 5. 2010
Schedule of Work
State Contracting:
Site work:
Construction:
Commissioning:
State Finai Inspections:
State Closeout Process:
State Potential Disaster Delavs:
Total Period of Performance
6 Months
3 Months
14 Months
4 Months
3 Months
3 Months
3 Months
36 Months
Line Item Budaet'
Project Cost Federal Share Local Share
Subcontract for materials and
Installation of shutters:
Sub-Total:
Administrative Cost:
Total:
$ 4.675.613.00 $1.639.223.00 $3 036.390.00
$ 4,675,613.00 $1,639,223.00 $3,036,390.00
$ 0.00 $ 54.717.00 $ 0.00
$ 4,675,613.00 $1,693,940.00 $3,036,390.00
. Any line item amount in this Budget may be increased or decreased 10% or less without an
amendment to this Agreement being required, so long as the overall amount of the funds
obligated under this Agreement is not increased.
Fundina Summary
Federal Share:
Local Share:
Total Project Cost:
$ 1,639,223.00 (75%)
$ 3.036.390.00 (25%)
$ 4,675,613.00 (100%)
Recipient Administrative Cost up to $54,717.DO.
The materials and work funded pursuant to this Subgrant Agreement are intended to decrease
the vulnerability of the building to property losses and are specifically not intended to provide for
the safety of inhabitants before, during or after a natural man made disaster.
10
Agenda Item NO.1 aT
November 27, 2007
Page 13 of 53
The funding provided by the Division of Emergency Management under this subgrant shall
compensate for the materials and labor for the installation of storm shutters and/or other
hardening activities as a retrofit measure for the Recipient's building to reduce and/or mitigate the
damage that might otherwise occur from severe weather or other hazards. The funding of this
project by the Department does not confer or imply any warranty of use or suitability for the work
performed pursuant to this agreement. The State of Florida disciaims all warranties with regard
to this mitigation project, express or implied, including but not limited to, any implied warranties
and/or conditions of satisfactory quality and fitness for a particular purpose, merchantability, or
merchantable quality.
This project has not been evaluated by the criteria contained in the standards of the Department
of Homeland Security, Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) guidance manual
FEMA 361-Design and Construction for Community Shelter, and thus does not provide "near
absolute protection." It is understood and agreed by the Department and the Recipient that the
building may have vulnerabilities due to age, design and location which may result in damage to
the building from wind events even after the installation of the mitigation measures funded under
this Subgrant Agreement. It is further understood and agreed by the Department and the
Recipient that the level of wind protection provided by the mitigation action, although meeting
State standards and codes and enhancing the structural integrity of the building. does not ensure
the safety of survival of building occupants.
11
Agenda Item 1'<0. WT
November 27, 2007
Page 14 of 53
Attachment E
Federal Audit Requirements
If the Recipient is a State or local government or a non-profit organization as defined in
OMB Circular A-133, as revised, and in the event that the Recipient expends $500,000 or more in
Federal awards in its fiscal year, the Recipient must have a single or program-specific audit
conducted in accordance with the provisions of OMB Circular A-133, as revised. EXHIBIT 1 to
this Agreement indicates Federal resources awarded through the Division by this Agreement. In
determining the Federal awards expended in its fiscal year, the Recipient shall consider all
sources of Federal awards. The determination of amounts of Federal awards expended should be
in accordance with the guidelines established by OMB Circular A-133, as revised. An audit of the
Recipient conducted by the Auditor General in accordance with the provisions of OMB Circular A-
133, as revised, will meet the requirements of this paragraph.
In connection with the audit requirements addressed in this Paragraph 6 (d) above, the
Recipient shall fulfill the requirements relative to auditee responsibilities as provided in Subpart C
of OMB Circular A-133, as revised.
If the Recipient expends less than $500,000 in Federal awards in Its fiscal year, an audit
conducted in accordance with the provisions of OMB Circular A-133, as revised, is not required.
In the event that the Recipient expends less than $500.000 in Federal awards in its fiscal year
and elects to have an audit conducted in accordance with the provisions of OMB Circular A-133,
as revised, the cost of the audit must be paid from non-Federal resources (i.e., the cost of such
audit must be paid from Recipient resources obtained from other than Federal entities).
Copies of reporting packages for audits conducted in accordance with OMB Circular A-
133, as revised, and required by subparagraph (d) above shall be submitted, when required by
Section .320 (d), OMB Circular A-133, as revised, by or on behalf of the Recipient directlv to each
of the following:
Department of Community Affairs
Office of Audit Services
2555 Shumard Oak Boulevard
Tallahassee, Florida 32399-2100
[an electronic copy shall also be submitted to aurllla.parrish@dca.state.fl.us]
and
Division of Emergency Management
Bureau of Policy and Financial Management
2555 Shumard Oak Boulevard
Tallahassee, Florida 32399-2100
The Federal Audit Clearinghouse designated in OMB Circular A-133, as revised (the number of
copies required by Sections .320(d)(1) and (2), OMB Circular A-133, as revised, should be
submitted to the Federal Audit Clearinghouse), at the following address:
Federal Audit Clearinghouse
Bureau of the Census
1201 East 10th Street
Jeffersonville, IN 47132
Other Federal agencies and pass-through entities in accordance with Sections ,320 (e) and (f),
OMB Circular A-133, as revised.
12
f\genda Item NO.1 OT
November 27. 2007
Page 15 of 53
Pursuant to Section .320 (f), OMB Circular A-133, as revised, the Recipient shall submit a
copy of the reporting package described in Section .320 (c), OMB Circular A-133, as revised, and
any management letter issued by the auditor, to the following addresses:
Department of Community Affairs
Office of Audit Services
2555 Shumard Oak Boulevard
Tallahassee, Florida 32399-2100
[an electronic copy shall also be submitted to aurilla.parrish@dca.state.fl.us]
and
Division of Emergency Management
Bureau of Policy and Financial Management
2555 Shumard Oak Boulevard
Tallahassee, Florida 32399-2100
13
Agenda Item NO.1 OT
November 27,2007
Page 16 oj 53
Attachment F
Federal Recordkeeping
As applicable, Recipient's performance under this Agreement shall be subject to the federal
Common Rule: Uniform Administrative Requirements for State and Local Governments' (53
Federal Register 8034) or OMS Circular No. A-110, 'Grants and Agreements with Institutions of
Higher Education, Hospitals, and Other Nonprofit Organizations," and either OMS Circular No. A-
87, "Cost Principles for State and Local Governments," OMS Circular No. A-21 , "Cost Principles
for Educational Institutions," or OMS Circular No. A-122, "Cost Principles for Nonprofit
Organizations." If this Agreement is made with a commercial (for-profit) organization on a cost-
reimbursement basis, the Recipient shall be subject to Federal Acquisition Regulations 31.2 and
931.2.
14
Agenda Item [\)0. ~i OT
r-,jovember 27. 2007
Page 170' 53
Attachment G
Federal Standard Conditions
With respect to any Recipient which is not a local government or state agency,
and which receives funds under this Agreement from the federal government, by signing this
Agreement, the Recipient certifies, to the best of its knowledge and belief, that it and its
principals:
1. are not presently debarred. suspended, proposed for debarment,
declared ineligible, or voluntarily excluded from covered transactions by a federal department or
agency;
2. have not, within a five-year period preceding this proposal been
convicted of or had a civil Judgment rendered against them for commission of fraud or a criminal
offense in connection with obtaining, attempting to obtain. or performing a public (federal. state or
local) transaction or contract under public transaction; violation of federal or state antitrust
statutes or commiSSion of embezziement, theft, forgery, bribery, falsification or destruction of
records. making false statements, or receiving stolen property;
3. are not presently indicted or otherwise criminally or civilly charged by
a governmental entity (federal, state or iocal) wittl commission of any offenses enumerated In
paragraph 20(h)2. of this certification; and
4, have not wittlin 2 five-year penod preceding this Agreement had one
or more public transactions (federal, state or local) terminated for cause or default
Where the Recipient is unable to certify to any of the statements in this certification. such
Recipient shall attach an explanation to this Agreement
In addition, the Recipient shall submit to the Division (by email or by facsimiie
transmission) the completed "Certification Regarding Debarment, Suspension, Ineligibility And
Voluntary Exclusion" (Attachment K) for each prospective subcontractor which Recipient intends
to fund under this Agreement Such form must be received by the Division prior to the Recipient
entering into a contract with any prospective subcontractor.
The State of Florida's performance and obligation to pay under this Agreement is
contingent upon an annual appropriation by the Legislature, and subject to any modification in
accordance with Chapter 216, Fla. Stat or the Florida Constitution.
Unless inconsistent with the public interest or unreasonable in cost, all unmanufactured
and manufactured articles, materials and supplies which are acquired for public use under this
Agreement must have been produced in the United States as required under41 U.S.C. 10a.
15
Agenda Item No. 'i OT
November 27. 2007
Page 'j 8 of 53
Attachment H
Federal Lobbying Prohibition
The Recipient certifies, by its signature to this Agreement, that to the best of his or her
knowledge and belief:
1. No Federal appropriated funds have been paid or will be paid, by or on behalf of the
undersigned, to any person for influencing or attempting to influence an officer or employee of
any agency, a Member of Congress, an officer or employee of Congress, or an employee of a
Member of Congress in connection with the awarding of any Federal contract, the making of any
Federal grant the making of any Federal loan, the entering Into of any cooperative agreement,
and the extension, continuation, renewal, amendment or modification of any Federal contract,
grant, loan or cooperative agreement.
2. if any funds other than Federal appropriated funds have been paid or will be paid to
any person for Influencing or attempting to influence an officer or employee of any agency, a
Member of Congress, an officer or employee of Congress, or an employee of a Member of
Congress in connection with this Federal contract, grant, loan or cooperative agreement, the
undersigned shall complete and submit Standard Form-LLL, "Disclosure Form to Report
Lobbying," in accordance with Its instructions.
3. The undersigned shall require that the language of this certification be Included in the
award documents for all subawards at all tiers (Including subcontracts, subgrants, and contracts
under grants, loans. and cooperative agreements) and that all subrecipients shall certify and
disclose accordingly.
This certification is a material representation of fact upon which reliance was placed
when this transaction was made or entered into. Submission of this certification is a prerequisite
for making or entering into this transaction imposed by Section 1352, Tille 31, U.S. Code. Any
person who fails to file the required certification shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than
$10,000 and not more than $100,000 for each such failure.
16
Agenda Item NO.1 OT
November 27, 2007
Page 19 of ~3
Attachment I
Contractor Covered Transactions
(1) The prospective contractor of the Recipient,
certifies, by submission of this document, that neither it nor its principals is presently debarred,
suspended, proposed for debarment, declared ineligible, or voluntarily excluded from participation
in this transaction by any Federal department or agency.
(2) Where the Recipient's contractor is unable to certify to the above statement. the
prospective contractor shall attach an explanation to this form.
CONTRACTOR:
By:
Signature
Recipient's Name
Name and Title
Division Contract Number
Street Address
City, Stale, Zip
Date
17
/~genda Item l\jo. ''i 01
November 27,2007
Page 20 01 53
Attachment J
Federal Statement of Assurances
The Recipient hereby assures and certifies compliance with ali Federal statutes, regulations,
policies, guidelines and requirements, including OMS Circulars No. A-21, A-110, A-122, A-128, A-
87; E.O. 12372 and Uniform Administrative Requirements for Grants and Cooperative
Agreements 28 CFR, Part 66, Common rule, that govern the application, acceptance and use of
Federal funds for this federally-assisted project. Also the Applicant assures and certifies that:
1. it wili comply with requirements of the provisions of the Uniform Relocation Assistance and
Real Property Acquisitions Act of 1970 (P.L. 91-646) which provides for fair and equitable
treatment of persons displaced as a result of Federal and federaliy-assisted programs.
2. It will comply with provisions of Federal law which limit certain political activities of employees
of a State or local unit of government whose principal employment is in connection with an activity
financed In whole or In part by Federal grants. (5 use 1501, et seq.)
3. It will comply with the minimum wage and maximum hours provisions of the Federal Fair Labor
Standards Act.
4. It will establish safeguards to prohibit employees from using their positions for a purpose that is
or gives the appearance of being motivated by a desire for private gain for themselves or others,
particularly those with whom they have family, business, or other ties.
5. It will give the sponsoring agency or the Comptrolier General, through any authorized
representative, access to and the right to examine ali records, books, papers, or documents
related to the grant.
6. It will comply with ali requirements imposed by the Federal sponsoring agency concerning
special requirements of law, program requirements, and other administrative requirements.
7. It will insure that the facilities under its ownership, lease or supervision which shali be utilized in
the accomplishment of the project are not listed on the Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA)
list of Violating Facilities and that it will notify the Federal grantor agency of the receipt of any
communication from the Director of the EPA Office of Federal Activities indicating that a facility to
be used in the project is under consideration for listing by the EPA.
8. It will comply with the flood insurance purchase requirements of Section 1 02(a) of the Flood
Disaster Protection Act of 1973, Public Law 93-234, 87 Stat. 975, approved December 31, 1976,
Section 102(a) requires, on and after March 2,1975, the purchase offlood insurance in
communities where such insurance is available as a condition for the receipt of any Federal
financial assistance for construction or acquisition purposes for use in any area that has been
identified by the Secretary of the Department of Housing and Urban Development as an area
having special flood hazards. The phrase 'Federal financial assistance" includes any form of
loan, grant, guaranty, insurance payment, rebate, subsidy, disaster assistance loan or grant, or
any other form of direct or indirect Federal assistance.
9. It wili assist the Federal grantor agency in its compliance with Section 106 of the National
Historic Preservation Act of 1966 as amended (16 USC 470), Executive Order 11593, and the
Archeological and Historical Preservation Act of 1966 (16 USC 569a-1 et seq.) by (a) consulting
with the State Historic Preservation Officer on the conduct of Investigations. as necessary, to
identify properties listed in or eligible for inclusion in the Nationai Register of Historic Places that
are subject to adverse effects (see 36 CFR Part 800.8) by the activity, and notifying the Federal
grantor agency of the existence of any such properties and by (b) compiying with ali requirements
18
AGenda Item r\io : Cl
F,Jovember 27 20'J7
Page of 53
established by the Federal grantor agency to avoid or mitigate adverse effects upon such
properties.
10. It will comply, and assure the compliance of all its subgrantees and contractors, with the
applicable provisions of Title I of the Omnibus Crime Control and Safe Streets Act of 1968, as
amended, the Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention Act, or the Victims of Crime Act, as
appropriate; the provisions of the current edition of the Office of Justice Programs Financial and
Administrative Guide for Grants, M7100.1; and all other applicable Federal laws, orders, circulars,
or regulations.
11. It will comply with the provisions of 28 CFR applicable to grants and cooperative agreements
including Part 18, Administrative Review Procedure; Part 20, Criminal Justice Information
Systems; Part 22, Confidentiality of identifiable Research and Statistical Information; Part 23.
Criminal Intelligence Systems Operating Policies; Part 30, Intergovernmental Review of
Department of Justice Programs and Activities; Part 42. NondiscrlminationfEqual Employment
Opportunity Policies and Procedures; Part 61, Procedures for Implementing the National
Environmental Poiicy Act; Part 63. Floodplain Management and Wetland Protection Procedures;
and Federal laws or regulations applicable to Federal ASSistance Programs.
12, It will comply, and all its contractors will comply, with the non-discrimination requirements of
the Omnibus Crime Control and Safe Streets Act of 1968, as amended, 42 USC 3789(d). 01
Victims of Crime Act (as appropriate); Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, as amended:
Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, as amended; Subtitle A, Title II of the Americans
with Disabliities Act (ADA) (1990); Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972: the Age
Discrimination Act of 1975; Department of Justice Non-Dlscrlmlnalion Regulations. 28 CFR Part
42, Subparts C,D.E, and G; and Department of Justice regulations on disability discrimination. 28
CFR Part 35 and Part 39.
13. In the event a Federal or State court or Federal or State administrative agency rnakes a
finding of discrimination after a due process hearing on the Grounds of race, color, religion,
national origin, sex, or disability against a recipient of funds, the recipient will forward a copy of
the finding to the Office for Civil Rights, Office of Justice Programs.
14. It will provide an Equal Employment Opportunity Program if required to maintain one, where
the application is for $500,000 or more.
15. It will comply with the provisions of the Coastal Barrier Resources Act (P.L 97-348) dated
October 19,1982 (16 USC 3501 et seq.) which prohibits the expenditure of most new Federal
funds within the units of the Coastal Barrier Resources System.
16. DRUG-FREE WORKPLACE (GRANTEES OTHER THAN INDIVIDUALS) As required by the
Drug-Free Workplace Act of 1988, and implemented at 28 CFR Part 67, Subpart F. for grantees,
as defined at 28 CFR Part 67 Sections 67.615 and 67.620.
19
.
Agenda Item NO.1 or
November 27. 2007
Page 22 of 53
STATE OF FLORIDA
DIVISION OF EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT
"State Emergency Response Team"
CHARUE CRIST
Govemor
w. CRAIG FUGATE
OUector
June 1, 2007
RETURN RECEIPT
CERTIFIED MAIL
RECEIVED
...., ,~r>~7
..\.c'.! -- '-; LJ:.;
Dan Summers
Collier County
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
\f;MERllBlCV MIlW\GEMENT
Re: 07-EC-33-09-21-Q1-486
Dear Mr. Summers:
Endosed is your fully executed between Collier County andthe'Division of Emergency
Management. Under section (13)(c), Notice and Contact, of this Agreement, you have been identified as
the Representative of the Recipient responsible fOr the administration of this Agreement. Therefore, it is
your responsibility to thoroughly read, Inlderstand and oversee the compliance of all the conditions within
this Agreement.
Attached is the complete package offorms identified in Section (7) (a) through (e). It is very
important that these reports be fully completed and remitted within the time frames specified Inlder
Section (7). Failure to supply this information in a timely manner can cause non-compliance of this
Agreement or a delay in processing your reimbursement requests.
If you have any questions in this regard, please contact me at 850-413-9920 or by
e-mail: jenene.helms@elll-myflorida.com
Sincerely,
-'}-~
ne Helms
ts Administration Unit
Enclosure
(C(Q)lPY
2555 SHUMARD OAK BOULEVARD . TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 32399-2100
Phone; 850.413.9969 Suncom; 850.293.9969 FAX: 850.488.1016
Internet address: htto:/Iwww.FloridaDisaster,ora
LONG TERM RECOVERY OFFICE . 36 SKYLINE DRIVE . lAKE MARY, FLORIDA 32745
Phone: 407-268-8899 FAX: 407-268-8977
,Agenda item f-.Jo. lOT
r--.Jovernber 27.2007
Page 23 of 53
Contract Number: 07-EC-33-09-21-01-486 ~/
CFSA#52.010~
STATE-FUNDED SUBGRANT AGREEMENT
THIS AGREEMENT is entered into by and between the State of Florida, Division of Emergency
Management, with headquarters in Tallahassee, Florida (hereinafter referred to as the "Division"), and
Collier County, (hereinafter referred to as the "Recipienf').
THIS AGREEMENT IS ENTERED INTO BASED ON THE FOllOWING REPRESENTATIONS:
A. WHEREAS, the Recipient represents that it is fully qualified and eligible to receive these grant
funds 10 provide the services identified herein; and
B. WHEREAS, the Division has received these grant funds from the State of Florida, and has the
authority to subgrant these funds to the Recipient upon the terms and conditions hereinafter set forth; and
C. WHEREAS, the Division has authority to disburse the funds under this Agreement
pursuantto State Fiscal Year 2006 - 2007, Chapter 2006-71, Laws of Florida, Section b. The purpose of
this act implements provisions relating to county emergency operations centers and designated alternate
state emergency operations centers.
NOW, THEREFORE, the Division and the Recipient do mutually agree as follows:
(1) SCOPE OF WORK
The Recipient shall fully perform the obligations in accordance wtth the Budget and
Scope of Work, Attachment A of this Agreement
(2) INCORPORATION OF LAWS. RULES. REGULATIONS AND POLICIES
Both the Recipient and the Division shall be governed by applicable State and Federal
laws, rules and regulations, including but not limited to those identified in Attachment B.
(3) PERIOD OF AGREEMENT.
This Agreement shall begin January 24, 2007, and shall end June 30, 2009, unless
terminated earlier in accordance with the provisions of Paragraph (12) of this Agreement
Agenda Item No. 10T
November 27, 2007
Page 24 of 53
(4) MODIFICATION OF CONTRACT
Either party may request modification of the provisions of this Agreement Changes which are mutually
agreed upon shall be valid only when reduced to writing, duly signed by each of the parties hereto, and attached to the
original of this Agreement
(5) RECORDKEEPING
(a) The Recipient shall retain sufficient records demonstrating its compliance with the terms of this
Agreement and the compliance of all subcontractors or consultants to be paid from funds provided under this Agreement,
for a period of five years from the date the audit report is issued, and shall allow the Division or its designee, the Chief
Financial Officer, or Auditor General access to such records upon request The Recipient shall ensure that audit working
papers are made available to the Division or its designee, the Chief Financial Officer, or Auditor General upon request for
a period of five years from the date the audit report is issued, unless extended in writing by the Department, with the
following exceptions:
1. If any litigation, claim or audit is started before the expiration of the five year period and
.-. extends beyond the five year period, the records will be maintained until all litigation, claims or audit findings involving the
records have been resolved.
2. Records for the disposition of non-expendable personal property valued at $5,000 or mom at
the time of acquisition shall be retained for five years after final disposition.
3. Records relating to real property acquisition shall be retained for five years after closing of title.
(b) The Recipient shall maintain all records, for the Recipient and for all subcontractors or consultants to
be paid from funds provided under this Agreement, including supporting documentation of all program costs, in a form
sufficient to determine compliance with the requirements and objectives of the Budget and Scope of Work - Attachment A
- and all other applicable laws and regulations.
(c) The Recipient, its employees or agents, including all subcontractors or consultants to be paid from
funds provided under this Agreement, shall allow access to its records at reasonable times to the Department, its
employees, and agents. "Reasonable" shall be construed according to the circumstances but ordinarily shall mean during
normal business hours of 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., local time, on Monday through Friday. "Agents" shall include, but not be
limited to, auditors retained by the Division.
2
':,genda item No, lOT
NovelTlber 27. 2ClG 7
Page 25 of 53
(6) AUDIT REQUIREMENTS
(a) The Recipient agrees to maintain financial procedures and support documents, in accordance with
generally accepted accounting principles, to account for the receipt and expenditure of funds under this Agreement
(b) These records shall be available at all reasonable times for inspection, review, or audit by state
personnel and other personnei duly authorized by the Division. "Reasonable" shall be construed according to
circumstances, but ordinarily shall mean normal business hours of 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., local time, Monday through
Friday.
(c) The Recipient shall also provide the Division with the records, reports or financial statements upon
request for the purposes of auditing and monitoring the funds awarded under this Agreement.
(d) If the Recipient is a nonstale entity as defined by Section 215.97, Fla. Stat., it shall comply with the
following:
In the event that the Recipient expends a total amount of State financial assistance equal to or in excess of
$500,000 in any fiscal year of such Recipient, the Recipient must have a State single or project-specific audit for such
fiscal year in accordance with Section 215.97, Fla. Stat.; applicable rules of the Executive Office of the Govemor and the
Chief Financial Officer; and Chapters 10.550 (local govemment entities) or 10.650 (nonprofit and for-profit organizations),
Rules of the Auditor General. EXHIBIT 1 to this Agreement indicates State financial assistance awarded through the
Division by this Agreement In determining the State financial assistance expended in Its fiscal year, the Recipient shall
consider all sources of State financial assistance, including Slate funds received from the Division, other state agencies,
and other nonstate entities. State financial assistance does not include Federal direct or pass-through awards and
resources received by a nonstate entity for Federal program matching requirements,
In connection with the audit requirements addressed in this Paragraph 6(d) above, the Recipient shall ensure
that the audit complies with the requirements of Section 215.97(7), Fla. Stat. This includes submission of a reporting
package as defined by Section 215,97(2)(d), Fla. Stat and Chapters 10.550 (local govemmental entities) or 10.650
(nonprofit and for-profit organizations), Rules of the Auditor General.
If the Recipient expends less than $500,000 in Stale financial assistance in its fiscal year, an audit conducted in
accordance with the provisions of Section 215.97, Fla. Stat, is not required. In the event that the Recipient expends less
than $500,000 in state financial assistance in its fiscal year and eleets to have an audit conducted in a=rdance with the
3
.Agenda Item NO.1 OT
November 27.2007
Page 26 of 53
provisions of Section 215.97, Fla. Stalthe cost of the audn must be paid from the nonstate entity's resources (i.e., the
cost of such an audit must be paid from the Recipienfs resources obtained from other than Stale entities). Additional
information on the Florida Single Audit Act may be found at the following websile:
htto://www.state.fl.us/fsaa/statutes.htm!.
(e) Report Submission
1. The annual financial audit report shall include all management lelters and the Recipienfs
response to all findings, including corrective actions to be taken.
2. The annual financial audit report shall include a schedule of financial assistance specifically
identifying all Agreement and other revenue by sponsoring agency and Agreement number.
3. Copies of financial reporting packages required under this Paragraph 6 shall be submitted by
or on behalf of the Recipient directlv to each of the following:
The Division of Community Affairs at each of the following addresses:
Division of Community Affairs
Office of Aud n Services
2555 Shumard Oak Boulevard
Tallahassee, Florida 32399-2100
[an electronic copy shall also be submitted to aurilla.parrish@dca.state.fl.us]
and
Division of Emergency Management
Bureau of Policy and Budget
2555 Shumard Oak Boulevard
Tallahassee, Florida 32399-2100
The Auditor General's OffICe at the following address:
Auditor General's Office
Room 401, Claude Pepper Building
111 West Madison Street
Tallahassee, Fiorida 32399-1450
4. Any reports, managementlelter, or other information required to be submitted to the Division
or the Department of Community Affairs pursuant to this Agreement shall be submilted timely in accordance with OMB
Circular A-133, Florida statutes, and Chapters 10.550 (local governmental entities) or 10.650 (nonprofit and for-prof~
organizations), Rules of the Auditor General, as applicable.
5. Recipients, when submitting financial reporting packages to the Division or the Department of
Community Affairs for audits done in accordance with OMB Circular A-133 or Chapters 10.550 (local govemmental
4
Aaenda Item I~o 1 CT
November 27. 2007
Page 27 of 53
entities) or 10.650 (nonprofit and for-profit organizations), Rules of the Auditor General, should indicate the date that the
reporting package was delivered to the Recipient in correspondence accompanying the reporting package.
(f) In the event the audit shows that the entire funds disbursed hereunder, or any portion thereof, were not spent
in accordance with the conditions of this Agreement, the Recipient shall be held liable for reimbursement to the Division of
all funds not spent in accordance with these applicable regulations and Agreement provisions within thirty (30) days after
the Division has notified the Recipient of such non-compHance.
(g) The Recipient shall have all audits compieted in accordance with Section 215.97, Fla. Stat by an
independent certified public accountant (IPA) who shall either be a certified public accountant or a public accountant
licensed under Chapter 473, Fla. Stat The IPA shall state that the audit complied with the applicable provisions noted
above. The audit must be submitted to the Division no later than nine (9) months from the end of the Recipient's fiscal
year.
(7) REPORTS
(a) At a minimum, the Recipient shall provide the Division with quarterly reports, and with a close-<lut
report These reports shall include the current status and progress by the Recipient and all subrecipients and
subcontractors in completing the work described in the Scope of Work and the expenditure of funds under this
Agreement, in addition to such other information as requested by the Division.
(b) Quarterly reports are due to be received by the Division no later than 30 days after the end of each
quarter of the program year and shall continue to be submitted each quarter until submission of the administrative close..
out report. The ending dates for each quarter of the program year are March 31, June 30, September 30 and December
31.
(c) The close-<lut report is due 60 days after termination of this Agreement or upon completion of the
activities contained in this Agreement, whichever first occurs.
(d) If all required reports and copies, prescribed above, are not sent to the Division or are not completed
in a manner acceptable to the Division, the Division may withhold further payments until they are completed or may take
such other action as set forth in Paragraph (11) REMEDIES. "Acceptable to the Division" means that the work product
was completed in accordance with the Budget and Scope of Work.
5
Agenda Item NO.1 OT
t~ovember 27.2007
Page 28 of 53
(e) The Recipient shall provide such additional program updates or information as may be required by
the Division.
(8) MONITORING.
The Recipient shall monitor its performance under this Agreement, as well as that of its subcontractors,
subrecipients and consultants who are paid from funds provided under this Agreement, to ensure that time schedules are
met, the Budget and Scope of Work is accomplished within the specified time periods, and other performance goals
stated in this Agreement are achieved. Such review shall be made for each function or activity set forth in Attachment A
to this Agreement, and reported in the quarterly report
In addition to reviews of audits conducted in accordance w'rth OMB Circular A-133, as revised and Section
215.97, Fla. Stat (see Paragraph (6) AUDIT REQUIREMENTS, above), monitoring procedures may include, but not be
limited to, on-site visits by Division staff, limited scope audits as defined by OMB Circular A-133, as revised, and/or o1I1er
procedures. By entering into this Agreement, the Recipient agrees to comply and cooperate with all monitoring
procedures/processes deemed appropriate by the Division. In the event that the Division determines that a limited scope
audit of the Recipient is appropriate, the Recipient agrees to comply with any additional instructions provided by the
Division to the Recipient regarding such audit The Recipient further agrees to comply and cooperate with any
inspections, reviews, investigations or audits deemed necessary by the Chief Financial Officer or Auditor General. In
addition, the Division will monitor the performance and financial management by the Recipient throughout the contract
term to ensure timely completion of all taSKS.
(9) LIABILITY.
(a) Unless Recipient is a State agency or subdivision, as defined in Section 768.28, Fla. Stat, the
Recipient shall be solely responsible to parties with whom it shall deal in carrying out the terms of this Agreement, and
shall hold the Division harmless against all claims of whatever nature by third parties arising out of the performance of
work under this agreement For purposes of this Agreement, Recipient agrees that it is not an employee or agent of the
Division, but is an independent contractor.
(b) Any Recipient who is a state agency or subdivision, as defined in Section 768.28, Fla. Stat. agrees to
be fully responsible to the extent provided by Section 768.28 Fla. Stat for its negligent acts or omissions or tortious acts
which result in claims or suits against the Division, and agrees to be liable for any damages proximately caused by said
6
Agenda Item No. 10T
November 27, 2007
Page 29 of 53
acts or omissions. Nothing herein is intended to serve as a waiver of sovereign immunity by any Recipient to which
sovereign immunity applies. Nothing herein shall be construed as consent by a state agency or subdivision of the State of
Florida to be sued by third parties in any matter arising out of any contract
(10) DEFAULT.
If any of the following events occur ("Events of Defaulf'), all obligations on the part of the Division to make
any further payment of funds hereunder shall, if the Division so elects, terminate and the Division may, at its option,
exercise any of its remedies set forth in Paragraph (11), but the Division may make any payments or parts of payments
after the happening of any Events of Default without thereby waiving the right to exercise such remedies, and without
becoming liable to make any further payment
(a) If any warranty or representation made by the Recipient in this Agreement or any previous Agreement
with the Division shall at any time be false or misleading in any respect, or if the Recipient shall fail to keep, observe or
perform any of the obligations, terms or covenants contained in this Agreement or any previous agreement with the
Division and has not cured such in timely fashion, or is unable or unwilling to meet its obligations thereunder;
(b) If any material adverse change shall occur in the financial condition of the Recipient at any time
during the term of this Agreemen~ and the Recipient fails to cure said material adverse change within thirty (30) days from
the time the date written notice is sent by the Division.
(c) If any reports required by this Agreement have not been submitted to the Division or have been
submitted with incorrect, incomplete or Insufficient information;
(d) If the Recipient has failed to perform and complete in timely fashion any of its obligations under this
Agreement
(11) REMEDIES.
Upon the happening of an Event of Defaul~ then the Division may, at its option, upon thirty (30) calendar
days prior written notice to the Recipient and upon the Recipienfs failure to cure within said thirty (30) day period,
exercise anyone or more of the following remedies, either concurrently or consecutively:
(a) Terminate this Agreement, provided that the Recipient is given at least thirty (30) days prior written
notice of such termination. The notice shall be effective when placed in the United States mall, first class mail, postage
prepaid, by registered or certified mall-retum receipt requested, to the address set forth in Paragraph (13) herein;
7
Agenda Item NO.1 OT
November 27. 2007
Page 30 of 53
(b) Commence an appropriate legal or equitable action to enforce performance of this Agreement;
(c) Withhold or suspend payment of all or any part of a request for payment;
(d) Exercise any corrective or remedial actions, to include but not be limited to:
1. requesting additional information from the Recipient to determine the reasons for or the extent
of non-compliance or lack of performance,
2. issuing a written waming to advise that more serious measures may be taken if the situation is
not corrected,
3. advising the Recipient to suspend, discontinue or refrain from incurring costs for any activities
in question or
4. requiring the Recipient to reimburse the Division for the amount of costs incurred for any items
determined to be ineligible;
(e) Require that the Recipient retum to the Division any funds which were used for ineligible purposes
under the program laws, rules and regulations governing the use of funds under this program;
(I) Exercise any other rights or remedies which may be otherwise available under
law;
(g) The pursuit of anyone of the above remedies shall not preclude the Division from pursuing any other
remedies contained herein or otherwise provided at law or in equity. No waiver by the Division of any right or remedy
granted hereunder or failure to insist on strict performance by the Recipient shall affect or extend or act as a waiver of any
other right or remedy of the Division hereunder, or affect the subsequent exercise of the same right or remedy by the
Division for any further or subsequent default by the Recipient.
(12) TERMINATION.
(a) The Division may terminate this Agreement for cause upon thirty (30) days written notice. Cause
shall include, but not be limited to, misuse of funds; fraud; lack of compliance with applicable rules, laws and regulations;
failure to perfonn in a timely manner, and refusal by the Recipient to permit public access to any document, paper, letter,
or other material subject to disclosure under Chapter 119, Aa. stat., as amended.
(b) The Division may terminate this Agreement for convenience or when it determines, in its sole
discretion, that the continuation of the Agreement would not produce beneficial results commensurate with the further
expenditure of funds, by providing the Recipient with thirty (30) calendar days prior written notice.
8
Aoenda Item No 10T
November 27, 2007
Page 31 of 53
(c) The parties may agree to terminate this Agreement for their mutual convenience as evidenced by
written amendment of this Agreement. The amendment shall establish the effective date of the termination and the
procedures for proper closeout of the Agreement.
(d) In the event that this Agreement is terminated, the Recipient will not incur new obligations for the
terminated portion of the Agreement after the Recipient has received the notification of termination. The Recipient will
cancel as many outstanding obligations as possible. Costs incurred after the date of receipt of notice of the termination
will be disallowed. Notwithstanding the above, the Recipient shall not be relieved of liability to the Division by virtue of
any breach of Agreement by the Recipient. The Division may, to the extent authonzed by law, withhold any paymenls to
the Recipient for purpose of set-off until such time as the exact amount of damages due the Division from the Recipient is
determined.
(13) NOTICE AND CONTACT.
(a) All notices provided under or pursuant to this Agreement shall be in writing, either by hand delivery, or
first class, certified mali, return receipt requested, to the representative identified below at the address set forth below and
said notification attached to the onginal of this Agreement.
(b) The name and address of the Division contract manager for this Agreement is:
Jenene Helms
Division of Emergency Management
Bureau of Policy and Budget
2555 Shumard Oak Boulevard
Tallahassee, FL 32399-2100
Telephone: 850-413-9920
Fax: 850-488-7842
Emali: ienene.helms@em.mvflonda.com
(c) The name and address of the Representative of the Recipient responsible for the administration of
this Agreement is:
Dan Summers, EM Director
Collier County
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Flonda 34112
Telephone: 239-774-8000
Fax: 239-774-3602
Emai!: marvanncole@collieroov.net
(d) In the event that different representatives or addresses are designated by either party after execution
of this Agreement, notice of the name, title and address of the new representative
will be rendered as provided in (13)(a) above.
9
.i<genda Item NO.1 OT
November 27. 2007
Page 32 of 53
(14) SUBCONTRACTS
If the Recipient subcontracts any or all of the work required under this Agreemen~ a copy of the unsigned
subcontract must be forwarded to the Division for review and approval prior to execution of the subcontract by the
Recipient. The Recipient agrees to include in the subcontract that (i) the subcontractor is bound by the terms of this
Agreemen~ (ii) the subcontractor is bound by all applicable state and federal laws and regulations, and (iii) the
subcontractor shall hold the Division and Recipient harmless against all claims of whatever nature arising out of the
subcontractors performance of work under this Agreement, to the extent allowed and required by law. Each
subcontractors progress in performing its work under this Agreement shall be documented in the quarterly report
submitted by the Recipient.
For each subContract, the Recipient shall provide a written statement to the Division as to whether that
subcontractor is a minority vendor, as defined in Section 288.703, Fla. Stat.
(15) TERMS AND CONDITIONS
This Agreement contains all the terms and conditions agreed upDn by the parties.
(16) ATTACHMENTS
(a) All attachments to this Agreement are incorpDrated as if set DUt fully herein.
(b) In the event Df any inconsistencies Dr conflict between the language of this Agreement and the
attachments hereto, the language of such attachments shall be controlling, but only tD the extent of such conflict or
inconsistency.
(c) This Agreement has the follDwing attachments:
Exhibit 1 - Funding SDurces
Attachment A - Budget and Scope of WDrk
Attachment B - Program statutes and RegUlations
Attachment C - Justification Df Advance
Attachment D - Warranties and Representations
(17) FUNDING/CONSIDERATION
(a) This is a cost-reimbursement Agreement. The Recipient shall be reimbursed for costs incurred in the
satisfactory performance of work hereunder in an amount not to exceed $1,510,094 subject to the availability offunds.
10
A.genda Item No.1 OT
November 27. 2007
Page 33 at 53
(b) Any advance payment under this Agreement is subject to Section 216.181(16), Fla. Stat.. and is
contingent upon the Recipienfs acceptance of the rights of the Division under Paragraph (12)(b) of this Agreement. The
amount which may be advanced may not exceed the expected cash needs of the Recipient within the first three (3)
months of the contract term. If an advance payment is requested, the budget data on which the request is based and a
justification statement shall be included in this Agreement as Attachment C. Attachment C will specify the amount of
advance payment needed and provide an explanation of the necessity for and proposed use of these funds.
1.
x
No advance payment is requested.
2.
An advance payment of $
is requested.
(c) After the initial advance, if any, payment shall be made on a reimbursement basis as needed. The
Recipient agrees to expend funds in accordance with the Budget and Scope of Work, Attachment A of this Agreement
If the necessary funds are not available to fund this Agreement as a result of action by Congress, the state
Legislature, the Office of the Chief Financial Officer or the Office of Management and Budgeting, all obligations on the part
of the Division to make any further payment of funds hereunder shall terminate, and the Recipient shall submit its closeout
report within thirty (30) days of receipt of notice from the Department.
(18) REPAYMENTS
All refunds or repayments to be made to the Division under this Agreement are to be made payable to the order of
"Department of Community Affairs", and mailed directly to the Department at the following address:
Department of Community Affairs
Cashier
Finance and Accounting
2555 Shumard Oak Boulevard
Tallahassee Fl 32399-2100
In accordance with Section 215.34(2), Fla. Stat., if a check or other draft is returned to the Division for collection,
Recipient shall pay to the Division an additional service fee of Fifteen Dollars ($15.00) or Five Percent (5%) of the face
amount of the retumed check or draft, whichever is greater.
(19) VENDOR PAYMENTS.
Pursuant to Section 215.422, Fla. Stat.. the Division shall issue payments to vendors within 40 days after
receipt of an acceptable invoice and receipt, inspection, and acceptance of goods and/or services provided in accordance
with the terms and conditions of the Agreement. Failure to issue the warrant within 40 days shall result in the Division
11
Agenda Item NO.1 OT
November 27. 2007
Page 34 of 53
paying interest at a rate as established pursuant to Section 55.03(1) Fla. stat The interest penalty shall be paid within
15 days after issuing the warrant.
Vendors experiencing problems obtaining timely payment(s) from a state agency may receive assistance
by contacting the Vendor Ombudsman at (850) 413-5516.
(20) STANDARD CONDITIONS
(a) The validity of this Agreement is subject to the truth and accuracy of all the information,
representations, and materials submitted or provided by the Recipient in this Agreement. in any subsequent submission or
response to Division request, or in any submission or response to fulfill the requirements of this Agreement, and such
information, representations, and materials are incorporated by reference. The lack of accuracy thereof or any material
changes shall, at the option of the Division and with thirty (30) days written notice to the Recipient. cause the termination
Df this Agreement and the release of the DivisiDn from all its Dbligations tD the Recipient.
(b) This Agreement shall be construed under the laws of the State of Florida, and venue for any actions
arising Dut of this Agreement shall lie in Leon County. If any provision hereof is in conflict with any applicable statute or
rule, or is otherwise unenforceable, then such provision shall be deemed null and void to the extent of such conflict, and
shall be deemed severable, but shall not invalidate any other provision of this Agreement.
(c) Any power of approval or disapproval granted to the Division under the terms of this Agreement shall
survive the terms and life of this Agreement as a whole.
(d) The Agreement may be executed in any number of counterparts, anyone of which may be taken as
an original.
(e) The Recipient agrees to comply with the Americans With Disabilities Act (Public Law 101-336, 42
U.S.C. Section 12101 et sea.), if applicable, which prohibits discrimination by public and private entities on the basis of
disability in !he areas of employment, public accommodations, transportation, State and local govemment services, and in
telecommunications.
(I) A person or affirlate who has been placed on the convicted vendor list following a conviction for a
pUblic entity crime may not submit a bid on a contract to provide any goods or services to a public entity, may not submit a
bid on a contract with a public entity for the construction or repair of a public building or public work. may not submit bids
on leases of real property to a public entity, may not be awarded or perform work: as a contractor, supplier, subcontractor,
12
Aoenda Item No 10T
r~ovember 27.2007
Page 35 of 53
or consultant under a contract with a public entity, and may not transact business with any public entity in excess of
Category Two for a period of 36 months from the date of being placed on the convicted vendor list or on the discriminatory
vendor list
(g) An entity or affiliate who has been placed on the discriminatory vendor list may not submit a bid
on a contract to provide goods or services to a public entity, may not submit a bid on a contract with a public entity for the
construction or repair of a public building or public work, may not submit bids on leases of real property to a public entity,
may not award or perform work as a contractor, supplier, subcontractor, or consultant under contract with any public
entity, and may not transact business with any public entity.
(h) The State of Florida's performance and obligation to pay under this Agreement is contingent upon an
annual appropriation by the Legislature, and subject to any modification in a=rdance with Chapter 216, Fla. Stat or the
Florida Constitution.
(i) All bills for fees or other compensation for services or expenses shall be submitted in detail sufficient
for a proper preaudit and postaudit thereof.
(j) If otherwise allowed under this Agreement all bills for any travel expenses shall be submitted in
accordance with Section 112.061, Fla. Stat
(k) The Division of Community Affairs reserves the right to unilaterally cancel this Agreement for refusal
by the Recipient to allow public access to all documents, papers, letters or other material subject to the provisions of
Chapter 119, Fla. Stat, and made or received by the Recipient in conjunction with this Agreement
(I) If the Recipient is allowed to temporarily invest any advances of funds under this Agreement, any
interest income shall either be retumed to the Division or be applied against the Department's obligation to pay the
contract amount
(m) The State of Florida will not intentionally award publicly-funded contracts to any contractor who
knowingly employs unauthorized alien workers, constituting a violation of the employment provisions contained in 8
U.S.C. Section 1324a(e) [Section 274A(e) of the Immigration and Nationality Act ("INN)]. The Division shall consider the
employment by any contractor of unauthorized aliens a violation of Section 274A(e) of the INA Such violation by the
Recipient of the employment provisions contained in Section 274A(e) of the INA shall be grouncls for unilateral
cancellation of this Agreement by the Department
13
Agenda Item NO.1 OT
November 27. 2007
Page 36 of 53
(n) The Recipient is subject to Florida's Govemment in the Sunshine Law (Section 286.011, Fla. Stat. )
with respect to the meetings of the Recipienfs goveming board or the meetings of any subcommittee making
recommendations to the governing board. All such meetings shall be publicly noticed, open to the public, and the minutes
of all such meetings shall be public records, available to the public in accordance with Chapter 119, Fla Stat
(21) STATE LOBBYING PROHIBITION. No funds or other resources received from the Division in connection
with this Agreement may be used directly or indirectly to influence legislation or any other official aelion by the Florida
Legislature or any state agency.
(22) COPYRIGHT. PATENT AND TRADEMARK
ANY AND ALL PATENT RIGHTS ACCRUING UNDER OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE PERFORMANCE OF THIS
AGREEMENT ARE HEREBY RESERVED TO THE STATE OF FLORIDA. ANY AND ALL COPYRIGHTS ACCRUING
UNDER OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE PERFORMANCE OF THIS AGREEMENT ARE HEREBY TRANSFERRED
BY THE RECIPIENT TO THE ST ATE OF FLORIDA.
(a) If the Recipient brings to the perfonnance of this Agreement a pre-existing patent or copyright, the
Recipient shall retain all rights and entitlements to that pre-existing patent or copyright unless the Agreement provides
otherwise.
(b) If any discovery or invention arises or is developed in the course of or as a result of work or services
perfonned under this Agreement, or in any way connected herewith, the Recipient shall refer the discovery or invention to
the Division for a detennination whether patent protection will be sought in the name of the Slate of Florida. Any and all
patent rights accruing under or in connection with the perfonnance of this Agreement are hereby reserved to the Stale of
Florida. In the event that any books, manuals, films, or other copyrightable material are produced, the Recipient shall
notify the Department Any and all copyrights accruing under or in connection with the perfonnance under this Agreement
are hereby transferred by the Recipient to the State of Florida.
(c) Within thirty (30) days of execution of this Agreement, the Recipient shall disclose all intellectual
properties relevant to the perfonnance of this Agreement which he or she knows or should know could give rise to a
patent or copyright The Recipient shall retain all rights and entitlements to any pre-existing intellectual property which is
so disclosed. Failure to disclose will indicate that no such property exists. The Division shall then, under Paragraph (b),
have the right to all patents and copyrights which accrue during perfonnance of the Agreement
14
Agenda Item NO.1 aT
November 27. 2007
Page 37 of 53
(23) PROPERTY MANAGEMENT
(a) Title to equipment acquired by a Recipient with Slate funds shall vest in the Recipient, subject to
condnions of this section. The Recipient must continue the operation, maintenance, repair and administration of any
equipment or other personal property purchased under this Agreement in accordance with the purposes for which the
funds were originally appropriated and for the period of time expressly specified in the Agreement or, failing to do so, the
Recipient must return to the Division the subgrant funds used to purchase the property.
(b) The Recipient shall not use equipment acquired with state funds to provide services to non-State
outside organizations for a fee that is less than private companies charge for equivalent services, unless specifically
authorized by Florida statute, for as long as the State relains an interest in the equipment
(c) The Recipient shall use the equipment in the project or program for which it was acquired as long as
needed, whether or not the project or program continues to be supported by State funds and shall not encumber the
property without approval of the Division. When no longer needed for the original project or program, the Recipient shall
use the equipment in connection with its other Slate-sponsored activities, in the following order of priority: (i) Activities
sponsored by the Division, then (ii) activities sponsored by other Slate agencies.
(d) During the time that equipment is used on the project or program for which it was acquired, the
Recipient shall make n available for use on other projects or programs if such other use will not interfere with the wor1< on
the project or program for which the equipment was originally acquired. First preference for such other use shall be given
to other projects or programs sponsored by the Division; second preference shall be given to projects or programs
sponsored by other Slate agencies. If the equipment is owned by the Slate of Florida, use on other activities not
sponsored by the state of Florida shall be permissible if authorized by the Division. User charges shall be treated as
program income.
(e) When acquiring replacement equipment, the Recipient may use the equipment to be replaced as
trade-in or sell the equipment and use the proceeds to offset the costs of the replacement equipment subject to the
approval of the Division.
15
Agenda Item NO.1 OT
November 27.2007
Page 38 or 53
(f) The Recipienfs property management standards for equipment acquired with State and State-owned
equipment shall include all of the following.
(1) Equipment records shall be maintained accurately and shall include the following information.
(i) A description of the equipment.
(Ii) Manufacturer's serial number, model number, Federal stock number, national stock number,
or other identification number.
(iii) Source of the equipment, including the award number.
(iv) Whether title vests in the Recipient or the State of Florida.
(v) Acquisition date (or date received, if the'equipment was furnished by the State of Florida) and
cost.
(vi) Information from which one can calculate the percentage of State participation in the cost of
the equipment (not applicable to equipment furnished by the State of Florida).
(vii) Location and condition of the equipment and the date the information was reported.
(viii) Unit acquisition cost
(ix) Ultimate disposition data, including date of disposal and s(ix) Ultimate disposition data,
including date of disposal and sales price or the method used to determine current fair market value
where a Recipient compensates the Division for its share.
(2) Equipment owned by the State of Florida shall be identified to indicate State ownership.
(3) A physical inventory of equipment shall be taken and the results reconciled with the equipment
records at least once every two years. Any differences between quantities determined by the physical inspection
and those shown in the accounting records shall be invest/gated to determine the causes of the difference. The
Recipient shall, in connection with the inventory, verify the existence, current utilization, and continued need for
the equipment.
(4) A control system shall be in effect to insure adequate safeguards to prevent loss, damage, or theft of
the equipment. Any loss, damage, or theft of equipment shall be investigated and fully documented; if the
equipment was owned by the State of Florida, the Recipient shall promptly notify the Division.
(5) Adequate maintenance procedures shall be implemented to keep the equipment in good condition.
(6) Where the Recipient is authorized or required to sell the equipment, proper sales procedures shall be
established which provide for competition to the extent practicable and result in the highest possible retum.
(g) When the Recipient no longer needs the equipment, the equipment may be used for other activities in
accordance with the following standards. For equipment with a current per unit fair market value of $5000 or more, the
16
l-<.gencia item !'-lo. lOT
November 27. 2Ci07
Page 39 of 53
Recipient may retain the equipment for other uses provided that compensation is made to the Division. The amount of
compensation shall be computed by applying the percentage of State participation in the cost of the original project or
program to the current fair market value of the equipment. If the Recipient has no need for the equipment, the Recipient
shall request disposllion instructions from the Division. The Division shall determine whether the equipment can be used
to meet the Division's requirements. If no requirement exists within that agency, the availability of the equipment shall be
reported to the Department of Management Services by the Division to determine whether a requirement for the
equipment exists in other State agencies. The Division shall issue instructions to the Recipient no iater than 120 calendar
days after the Recipient's request and the following procedures shall govern.
(1) If so instructed or if disposition instructions are not issued within 120 calendar days after the
Recipient's request. the Recipient shall sell the equipment and reimburse the Federal awarding agency an
amount computed by applying to the sales proceeds the percentage of Federal participation in the cost of the
original project or program. However, the Recipient shall be permitted to deduct and retain from the State share
$500 or ten percent of the proceeds. whichever is less. for the Recipient's selling and handling expenses.
(2) If the Recipient is instructed to ship the equipment elsewhere, the- Recipient shall be reimbursed by
the State of Florida by an amount which is computed by applying the percentage of the Recipient's participation
in the cost of the original project or program to the current fair market value of the equipment. plus any
reasonable shipping or interim storage costs incurred.
(3) If the Recipient is instructed to otherwise dispose of the equipment, the Recipient shall be reimbursed
by the Division for such costs incurred in its disposition.
(4) The Division may reserve the right to transfer the title to the State of Florida or to a third party named
by the State when such third party is otherwise eligible under existing statutes. Such transfer shall be subject to
the following standards.
(i) The equipment shall be appropriately identified in the award or otherwise made known to the
Recipient in writing.
(ii) The Division shall issue disposition instructions within 120 calendar days after receipt of a final
inventory. The final inventory shall list all equipment acquired with grant funds and federally-owned
equipment If the Division fails to issue disposition instructions within the 120 calendar day period, the
Recipient shall apply the standards of this section, as appropriate.
(iii) When the Division exercises its right to take title, the equipment shall be subject to the provisions for
~wned equipment.
(24) LEGAL AUTHORIZATION.
The Recipient certifies with respect to this Agreement that it possesses the legal authority to receive the
funds to be provided under this Agreement and that, if applicable, its governing body has authorized, by resolution or
17
Agenda Item NO.1 OT
November 27, 2007
Page 40 of 53
otherwise, the execution and acceptance of this Agreement with all covenants and assurances contained herein. The
Recipient also certifies that the undersigned possesses the authority to legally execute and bind Recipient to the terms of
this Agreement
(25) ASSURANCES.
The Recipient shall comply with any Statement of Assurances. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties
hereto have caused this contract to be executed by their undersigned officials as duly authorized.
ReciDient:
By:
Date: Mav 8th, 2007
SAMAS # 07-EC-33-09.21-01-
/
FID# 59-60000558
.,' __') , eD~,t>fj
-(~\, ,...." j 0;
: B~.?~~".~.~ '7}, .
. ',' '.
, " " ".....
:;.: ;,,'" ~---i ..,
. (DreputY-cr~.,.. ,'t lIS to Chalr1l14n ,
(": ' . signature on 1 .
. -f , ~ b ,t\ 'y":'
Approved as to FO"\fnd ~:
\0 ~
l^'\
Assistant County Attorney
STATE OF FLORIDA
DMSION OF EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT
B~ 0?~ &~ tu1J:L
Name and TitJe: W. C'ro.i5 FlJsCt+e., b'(,f'r-Mr
Date: \ 0 ~1-07
18
Agenda Item NO.1 OT
November 27,2007
Page 41 of 53
EXHIBIT - 1
STATE RESOURCES AWARDED TO THE RECIPIENT PURSUANT TO THIS AGREEMENT CONSIST OF THE
FOllOWING:
MATCHING RESOURCES FOR FEDERAL PROGRAMS:
NOTE: If the resources awarded to the recioient for matchina represent more than one Federal prearam. provide the
same information shown below for each Federal proaram and show total State resources awarded for matchina.
Federal Proaram (list Federal a~ency. Catatea of Federal Domestic Assistance title and number) -
$ (amount)
SUBJECT TO SECTION 215.97. FLORIDA STATUTES:
NOTE: If the resources awarded to the recipient represent more than one State proiect provide the same information
shown below for each State proiect and show total state financial assistance awarded that is subiect to Section 215.97.
Florida Statutes.
State Project
State of Florida - Division of Emergency Management
CSFA#52 010
$1,510,094
COMPLIANCE REQUIREMENTS APPLICABLE TO STATE RESOURCES AWARDED PURSUANT TO THIS
AGREEMENT ARE AS FOllOWS:
Ust applicable compliance requirements as follows:
1. First applicable compliance requirement (e.g., what services/purposes resources must be used for).
2. Second applicable compliance requirement (e.g., eligibility f9quif9ments for recipients of the resources).
3. Etc.
State awarding agency may elect to use language that f9quif9s the recipient to comply with the requif9ments of applicable
provisions of specific laws, roles, f9gulations, ele. NOTE: Instead of listing the specific compliance f9quif9ments as
shown above, in the 8Xample, the language may state that the recipient must comply with a specific law(s}, role(s), or
regulation(s) that pertains to how the awarded I9sources must be used or how eligibility determinations af9 to be made.
The State awarding agency, if practical, may want to attach a copy of the specific law, role, or f9gulation referred to.
NOTE: Section .4DO{d) of OMS Circular A-l33, as revised, and Section 215.97(5){a), Florida Statutes, require that the
information about Federal Programs and State Projects included in Exhibit 1 be provided ta the recipient
19
Agenda item l'io.1 OT
Novernber 27, 20CJ7
Page 42 of 53
Attachment A
Budget and Scope of Work
I. SCOPE OF WORK
A The Recipient shall construct a County Emergency Operations Center (EOC). Use of grant funds shall
be consistent with Section 1 (1), Ch. 2006-71, Laws of Florida. Grant funds shall not be used for land
acquisition; purchase of equipment, furnishings, communications, or operational systems; or recurring
expenditures.
Eligible reimbursement costs include: Architectural and Engineering services and fees; site survey and soil
testing; necessary permits and fees; civil and service utilities site work; construction of the building's
substructure, superstructure, shell (exterior enclosure) and interior construction; special inspections;
mechanical, plumbing, electrical, conveying and security systems; lightning protection; and redundant
infrastructure systems (e.g., electric generator, uninterruptible power supply, potable water and wastewater
systems, etc.).
B. The Recipient shall in a timely manner prepare and submit a complete Hazard Mitigation Grant
Program (HMGP) application, benefit-cost analysis, environmenfal review and such other documentation as
necessary to determine eligibility and allowable costs under said grant program
C. The Recipient shall state in writing that for a period of not less than '; 5 years from the date of receipt of
Certificate of Occupancy the EOC will be dedicated for emergency management purposes. The EOC shall
_ remain demonstrably capable of being fully activated within one (1) hour of detection of an emergency;
'eference Rule Chapter 9G-6, Florida Administrative Code, "Emergency Management Capabilities Assessment
Checklist."
D. The EOC shall be constructed with sufficient space to house people and equipment for day-ta-day and
sustained continuous emergency operations, and capable of full staffing for the most extensive emergency
anticipated. At a minimum, the designated EOC functional area(s), and essential shared-use area(s) if
applicable, shall be designed for an emergency operations staff size of 130 persons per shift and a workspace
floor area of 11.050 gross square feet.
E. At a minimum, the EOC shall meet the hurricane hazard safety criteria established in Standards for
Hurricane Evacuation Shelter Selection (ARC 4496).
F. The EOC and essential ancillary structures and service equipment shall be designed to resist the
effects of a major hurricane. The wind load design requirements shall be in accordance with the American
Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) Standard 7, Minimum Design Loads for Buildings and Other Structures. The
minimum wind design criteria shall include:
Design Wind Speed = 175 miles per hour (3 second gust)
Wind Importance Factor, 1= 1.00
Exposure Category = C
Directionality Factor, Kd = 1.00
Internal Pressure CoeffiCient, GCpi = +/- 0.18
All components and cladding assemblies necessary to maintain a structurally enclosed condition and prevent
rainwater intrusion shall be designed to meet the wind design criteria. Structural metal decking and cladding
......."aterials shall be 22 gauge or thicker. Roof cover waterproofing barriers shall meet the wind design criteria.
Jose roof ballast shall not be used on the roof cover. Rooftop equipment shall be designed and installed to
meet the wind design criteria.
20
Agenda Item t>Jo. 10T
~~ovember 27. 2007
Page 43 of 53
G. The EOC and essential ancillary structures and service equipment shall resist penetration by windborne
debris impact. At a minimum, all exterior enclosure components, claddings and assemblies (i.e., walls, roofs,
louvers, windows, doors, etc.) located within 60 feet in height above finish grade shall meet the hurricane
windborne debris impact criteria specified in the Department of Energy's (DOE) Standard, Natural Phenomena
Hazards Design and Evaluation Criteria, DOE-STD-1020-2002. That is, the building enclosure must resist
penetration by a nominaI2"x4" lumber plank weighing 15 pounds propelled at 50 miles per hour (74 feet per
second) striking end-on and normal to the assembly surface, or equivalent performance as approved by the
Division. As applicable, impact test procedures shall be consistent with recognized state and national
standards; such as, Test Standard for Detennining Impact Resistance from Windbome Debris SSTD 12,
American Society of Testing and Materials (ASTM) Standards ASTM E 1886 and ASTM E 1996, and Florida
Building Code Testing Protocols TAS 201, TAS 202 and TAS 203. The impact test procedures may be
modified as necessary to accommodate the required missile weight and velocity.
H. The following information related to wind loads and flooding shall be shown on the construction
drawings: 1. wind design per ASCE 7 with applicable year of revision; 2. design wind speed; 3. wind
importance factor, I; 4. design wind exposure category; 5. wind directionality factor, Kd: 6. design internal
pressure coefficient, GCpi; 7. design wind pressures in terms of pounds per square foot (pst) to be used for the
design of exterior component and cladding materials not specifically designed by the principal licensed design
professional: 8. windbome debris impact performance criteria: 9. finish floor elevation measured relative to the
National Geodetic Vertical Datum (NGVD); and comparison reference of the finished floor elevation to the
base flood elevation, or historical flood elevation if base fiood elevation is not determined.
I. The lowest floor for the EOC and essential ancillary structures and service equipment shall at a
minimum be elevated above: Category 5 hurricane storm surge elevation; the base flood elevation plus three
(3) feet; the 500-year (0.2 percent annual chance) flood elevation (if determined) plus two (2) feet; the highest
recorded flood elevation plus three (3) feet if the area is not in a mapped special flood hazard area; whichever
is greater. The site (point maximum, one square mile) hydrologic design shall ensure that the EOC and
essential ancillary structures and service equipment are not flooded due to a 24 hour, 37.0 inch rainfall event
applied over a precedent 24 hour, 1 DO-year rainfall event.
J. Where secondary (emergency) roof drains or scuppers are required by the Florida Building Code-
Plumbing, the secondary system shall be sized for a rainfall rate of eleven (11.0) inches per hour.
K. The EOC shall be designated as a threshold building, and special structural inspections required.
Special inspections shall be conducted in compliance with section 553.79, Florida StaMes and other
applicable statutes, laws and rules.
L. The EOC shall at a minimum be designed for 72 hours of self-contained continuous operation and shall
not be solely reiiant upon off-site services and utilities (e.g., water, natural gas fuel, electricity, etc.)
M. Force protection and security measures shall be consistent with the guidance published in Florida's
Homefand Security Comprehensive Assessment Model (HLSCAM), United States Air Force Installation Force
Protection Guide, or other federal or state recognized best-practices guiders) as approved by the Division.
N. The Recipient shall provide an initial time line and estimated reimbursement allocation schedule. Table
SW-1 'Initial Timeline and Estimated Reimbursement Allocation Schedule" or other similar instrument as
,
approved by the Division may be used.
O. During design and construction phases of the EOC project, the Recipient shall track and provide
construction cost data for the designated EOC area as detailed in Table SW-2, "Cost Data for County
Emergency Operations Center:
21
L,genda item 1\io, '! Cl
~~ovember 27.2007
Page 44 of 5~j
II. PRODUCT ITEMS
A Per item I. N, Recipient shall prepare an initial timeline with key milestone activitiesltasks schedule, including
estimated start and end dates for each activity, and an estimate of state reimbursement request for each activity. Table
SW-1 may be used to meet this product nem.
B. Per item I.C, Recipient shall submit a binding written statement that the EOC will be dedicated for a period of not
less than15 years for emergency management purposes, and demonstrably capable of being fully activated within one (1)
hour of detection of an emergency.
C. The Recipient shall provide one (1) copy each of site survey, site master plan, spatial needs assessmen~ and
schematic design plan or preliminary design drawings for review and comment by the Division. The spatial needs
assessment and schematic design plan/preliminary design may be consolidated into one document.
D. The Recipient shall provide one (1) set of substantially complete (approximately 70 percent) preliminary design
construction drawings and specifications for the EOC and essential ancillary structures for review and comment by the
Division. The construction drawings shall include 'site survey information, landscaping, civil, architectural, structural,
mechanical, plumbing, and electrical drawings.
E. The Recipient shall provide one (1) set of bid-ready construction drawings and specifications for the EOC and
essentiai ancillary structures for review by the Division. The construction drawings shall include sne survey information,
landscaping, civil, archttectural, structural, mechanical, plumbing, and electrical drawings and shall be certified by the
applicable registered or licensed design professional(s) of record.
F. The construction drawings shall demonstrate that the EOC will meet the hurricane hazard safety criteria of ARC
4496, and the wind load, windbome debris impact, fiood and security design requirements set forth in items I.E through
I.M. Failure to supply the required documentation, or disapproval of this documentation by the Division, shall result in
denial of funds.
G. Per item I.B, Recipient shall submit a complete HMGP application, benefit-cost analysis, environmental review
and such other documentation as necessary to determine eligibility and cost allowances under said grant program. The
Recipient shall also provide two cost estimates prepared by one or more certified construction contractors that document
the cost of constructing the facility to meet current building code wind and flood design requirements, and the cost
premium of constructing the facility to the above-code wind and flood requirements set forth in items I. E through I.J.
H. Per item 1.0, the Recipient shall provide final project cost data. Table SW-2 shall be used to meet this product
item.
I. The Recipient shall provide the Division with copy(s) of pertinent construction permits, the threshold inspection
final report, and the certificate of occupancy upon completion of the construction project.
22
Agenda Item NO.1 OT
November 27,2007
Page 45 of 53
III. SCHEDULE OF WORK
A. By June 30, 2007, the Recipient shall provide the Division with Product Items A and B for review and approval.
Failure to supply the required documentation, or disapproval of this documentation by the Division, shall result in denial of
funds.
B. By September 30, 2007 and at least on a quarterly basis thereafter, Recipient shall report on progress in relation
to the initial timeline, and submit Product Items C through H in a timely manner as accomplished. The Division shall be
provided 30 calendar days to review and provide comments of product items pertaining to compliance with the scope-of-
work. The Recipient shall also submit invoices for reimbursement for work accomplished in accordance with the Division
approved cost reimbursement allocation schedule referenced in Product Item A
C. By a mutually agreed upon date, the Recipient shall provide the Division with Product Item F for review and
approval. Failure to supply the required documentation, or disapproval of this documentation by the Division, shall result
In denial or reduction of funds at the sole discretion of the Division.
D. By May 15,2009, the Recipient shall provide final project cost estimate data as set forth in Table SW-2, certificate
of occupancy, c1ose-out documentation and final payment invoice.
23
Aqenda Item NO.1 OT
f,overnber 27.2007
Page 46 of 53
Table SW-1. Initial Timeline and Estimated Reimbursement Allocation Schedule
~/~ .'.~..... . .";'" . . .././ ~.". . '. ... ....;; '.'
TableSW~1, Initial Timeline and ~lmat8d Reimbursement Allocation Schedule
,'-'-';' ,,,,:,,,,,. . ,-
'<'.'
-"'-''''<;-,;''-',',' ",,:,:.-'.'-- "':'-:',: ::"",,-'~ ,:"'-, ,----, , ':
.98u~lYJ"~",e: COllis.r . ... .. . ~ ~ . ... ~
.,.;..';.."'>........... . ..... ~ . '. . . . . .
PROJECT PHASE Start Date End Date OEM Funds Other Funds
Board Contract 1115/07 4/24/07 0 0
Approval
Initial Payment of N/A N/A 0 0
20% in first auarter
A&E Firm Selection 6/15/03 Complete 0 $ 488,983
Site Survey and Soil 9/15/06 Complete 0 $ 112,703
Testina
Spatial Needs 8/15/99 9/13/01 0 $ 44,870
Assessment
Preliminary Design, 5/15/05 Complete 0 $ 1,370,017
70% complete
Preliminary Design, 5/15106 Complete 0 $ 730,033
100% complete I
Reaulatorv Review 6/15/06 Complete 0 $ 15,196
Bid Document(s) 1 0/15/06 4/24/07 0 0
Development &
Award
Notice to 4/24/07 On-going 0 0
Proceed/Mobilization
Construction Project 4/24/07 On-going 0 $ 1,501,580
Management &
Special Inspections
Construction 25% 12/07 TBD $ 358,647 $15,089,110
Comolete
Construction 50% 4/08 TBD $ 358,647 $15,089,110
Complete
Construction 100% 12/08 TBD $ 717,295 $30,178,218
Complete
Contingency 4/24 12/08 N/A $ 3,000,000
Administrative Fees; - - $ 75,505 $
maximum of 5%
Sub-Totals $1,510,094
TOTAL Estimated $67,619,820
Proiect Cost
A&E - Architectural and Engineering; DEM - Division of Emergency Management; FY - Fiscal Year
24
Agenda Item NO.1 OT
November 27. 2007
Page 47 of 53
Table SW-2. Cost Data for County Emergency Operations Center
Tllb!l!lilW-2;;. ,.... '. ... .., . < ., .. ...... . .
!st~;~~~f()r;o:\ty .E'!lerge~CY OPc8rations Cente~
.' CQun!yNlirr;e:Codie~ ,.
_~~,;:!<;:/,:':i!>, ',"',;'::'~,,:'},/,~-:~ . ... .. ... ...... .,...
NO. System/Component Description Estimated
Cost
A SUBSTRUCTURE
1010 Foundation Site Lay-out $ 48,444
1020 Slab-on-Grade
2010 Excavation Piles, Excavation, Testino $ 696,477
2020 Basement Walls
2030 Elevated Foundation
B. SHELL (ENVELOPE)
B10 Sucarstructure
1010 Floor Construction $ 2,062,854
1020 Roof Construction $ 3,197.918
1030 Structural Frame Columns, Beams, Joists, Frame $ 402,082
1040 Load-Bearina Wall Cast-in-olace concrete ! $ 6,457,855
B20 Exterior Enclosure
2010 Exterior Walls Sealer $ 200,000
2011 VeneerfCladdina Stucco, concrete $ 831,082
2012 Louvers
2020 Exterior Windows Aluminum, imoact resistance, hardware $ 195,476
2030 Exterior Doors Metal, hardware, over11ead $ 290,795
B30 Roofina
3010 Roof Coverinos Membranes, FireDroofino $ 435,082
3020 Roof Ocaninas
3021 Soffits
C; INTERIORS
1010 Partitions Carpentry $ 352,819
1020 I nterior Doors Hollow wood, other hardware $ 162,500
1030 Fittinos Insulation, moisture $ 584,403
2010 Stair Construction
3010 Wall Finishes Cabinets drvwall, tile, acoustical $ 868,965
3020 Floor Finishes Vinvl, rubber, caroet, raised floors $ 858,787
3030 Ceinno Finishes
D. SERViCES
010 Convevina
1010 Elevators & lifts Elevators 1$ 396,155
1020 Escalators & Walks I ,
020 Plumbina
2010 Plumbino Fixtures Miscellaneous, EauiDment $ 691,967
2020 Domestic Water
Distribution
2021 Back-up Potable
Water Svstem
2040 Rainwate~ Drainaae
030 HVAC
3010 Enerav SUDolv I I
25
Agenda Item I~o. 10T
November 27. 2007
Page 48 of 53
3020 Heatine Svstem
3030 Coo line Svstem Incl. 3020, All $ 4,447,375
3050 Terminal & Package
Units
3090 other HV AC Svs.
D40 Fire Protection
4010 Sorinkler Svs. Pumos, FM 200, testina $ 740,361
4020 Sll!ndDiDe Svs.
4030 Other Svs.
D50 Electrical
5010 Elec. Service & All $ 6,295,589
Distribution
5020 Lighting & Branch
WirinQ
5030 Communications &
Securitv
5090 Other Eiec. Svs.
5091 Generator Svs. 2x 2,500 KW w/switch $ 2,500,000
5092 UPS Svs. 1092
E. EQUIPMENT & FURNISHINGS ..-...- -~...~--
1010 Commercial EouiD.
1020 Institutional EQuiD. AnDliances $ 83.436
1030 Vehicular EQuip.
1090 Other EQuiD. Miscellaneous $ 11,309
1091 AudioNideo EQuio.
1092 Soecial Telecom 1093, 1091"lall\ $ 3,531,055
1093 Information Tech.
1094 Goo. Info. Svs.
F. SPECiAl CONSTRUCTION
1041 Generator Enclosure
1042 Comm. Tower 185 foot mono ooie tower $ 262,885
1043 Helioad
1090 other Soecialties $ 226,358
G: BUILDING SITEWORK
1010 Earthwork Lav out $ 48,444
1020 Roadwav & Parkina Curbs, Davina $ 40,339
1030 Drainage & Flood
Control
1040 Securitv Measures Fencina, other $ 468,245
1090 Other Sitework All $4,195,820
26
Agenda !tem No.1 OT
November 27,2007
Page 49 of 53
Attachment B
Program StabJtes and Regulations
1. Sections 215.555(7)(c) and 215.559, Florida Statutes
2. Chapter 252, Florida Statutes
3. Chapter 287, Florida statutes
4. Chapter 119, Florida Statutes
5. Chapter 6OA-1, Florida Administrative Code
6. Chapter 9G-19, Florida Administrative Code
27
Agenda Item t\io. ~! OT
f\Ic1verntJer 27, 2007
Page 50 of 53
Attachment C
JUSTIFICATION OF ADVANCE PAYMENT
RECIPIENT:
Indicate by cbecking one of tbe boxes below, if you are requesting an advance. If an advance payment is reqnested, budget data on
which the request is bued must be snbmitted. Any advance payment under this Agreement is snbject to s. 216.181(16)(a) and (b),
Florida Statutes. The amount whith may be advanced shaD not exceed the expected cash needs of the recipient within the inltial
three months.
[ ] ADVANCE REQUESTED
[ ] NO ADVANCE REQUESTED
Advance payment of $ is reqnested. Balance of
payments will be made on a reimbursement basis. These funds
are needed to pay staff; award benefits to clients, duplicate
forms and purchase start-up supplies and equipment We
would not be able to operate the program without this advance.
I No advance payment is requested. Payment
will be solely on a reimbursement basis. No
additioual infonnation is required.
____...___J
ADVANCE REQUEST WORKSHEET
If you are requesting an advance, complete the following worksheet
1- (A) (B) (C) (D)
FFY 2002 FFY 2003 FFY 2004 Total
,SCRIPTION
1 INITIAL CONTRACT ALLOCATION
2 FIRST THREE MONTHS CONTRACT
EXPENDITURES'
3 AVERAGE PERCENT EXPENDED IN FIRST
THREE MONTHS
IDivide line 2 bv line 1.)
First three mouths expenditures need only be provided for the years ID which you requested an advance. If you do not bave thIS
information, caD your consultant and they will assist yon.
MAXIMUM ADVANCE ALWWED CALULATION:
X $
MAXIMUM
DEM Award
(Do not include any matcb)
Cen D3
ADVANCE
REOUEST FOR WAIVER OF CALCULATED MAXIMUM
[
[
] Recipient has no previous DEM contract bistory. Complete Estimated Expenses cbart and Explanation of
Circumstances below.
] Recipient has exceptional circnmstances that reqnire an advance greater than tbe Maximum Advance calculated above.
Complete estimated expenses chart and Explanation of Circumstances below. Attaeh additional pages if beeded.
28
Agenda Item NO.1 OT
November 27, 2007
Page 51 of 53
ESTIMATED EXPENSES
BUDGET CATEGORY 2004-2005 Anticipated Expeuditures for First Tbree Months of
Contract
ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS
(Include Secondarv Administration. \
PROGRAM EXPENSES
TOTAL EXPENSES
.
ExDlanlllion of ClTCIlmstances.
29
.l\genda Item NO.1 OT
November 27. 2007
Page 52 of 53
Attachment 0
Warranties and Representations
Financial Manaaement
Recipienfs financial management system shall provide for the following:
(1) Accurate, current and complete disclosure of the financial results of this project or program
(2) Records that identify adequately the source and application of funds for all activities. These records shall
contain information pertaining to grant awards, authorizations, obligations, unobligated balances. assets,
outlays, income and interest.
(3) Effective control over and accountability for all funds, property and other assets. Recipient shall adequately
safeguard all such assets and assure that they are used solely for authorized purposes.
(4) Comparison of expenditures with budget amounts for each Request For Payment. Whenever appropriate,
financial information should be related to performance and unit cost data.
(5) Written procedures for determining the reasonableness, allocability and allowability of costs in accordance
with the provisions of the applicable cost principles and the terms and conditions of this grant.
(6) Accounting records, including cost accounting records that are supported by source documentation.
Competition.
All procurement transactions shail be conducted in a manner to provide, to the maximum extent practical, open and free
competition. The Recipient shall be alert to conflicts of interest as well as noncompetitive practices among contractors that
may restrict or eliminate competition or otherwise restrain trade. In order to ensure objective contractor performance and
eliminate unfair competitive advantage, contractors that develop or draft specifications, requirements, statements of work,
invitations for bids and/or requests for proposals shall be excluded from competing for such procurementS. Awards shall
be made 10 the bidder or offeror whose bid or offer is responsive 10 the solicitation and is most advantageous 10 the
Recipient, price, quality and other factors considered. Solicitations shall c1eariy set forth all requirements that the bidder or
offeror shall fulfill in order for the bid or offer 10 be evaluated by the Recipient My and all bids or offers may be rejected
when it is in the Recipient's interest to do so.
Codes of conduct.
The Recipient shall maintain written standards of conduct governing the performance of its employees engaged in the
award and administration of contracts. No employee, officer, or agent shall participate in the selection, award, or
administration of a contract supported by public grant funds if a real or apparent conflict of interest would be involved.
Such a conflict would arise when the employee, officer, or agent, any member of his or her immediate family, his or her
partner, or an organization which employs or is about to employ any of the parties indicated herein, has a financial or
other interest in the flrm selected for an award. The officers, employees, and agents of the Recipient shail neither solicit
nor accept gratuities, favors, or anything of monetary value from contractors, or parties to subcontractS. The standards of
conduct shall provide for disciplinary actions to be applied for violations of such standards by officers, employees, or
agents of the recipient
Business Hours
The Recipient shall have its offices open for business, with the entrance door open to the public, and at least one
employee on site, from 8:00am -5:00pm. Mondav throuah Fridav.
30
,i\genda Item 1'0, 10T
November 27, 2007
Page 53 of 53
LicensinCl and PermittinCl
All subcontractors or employees hired by the Recipient shall have all current licenses and permits required for all of the
particular work for which they are hired by the Recipient
31
Agenda Item No. 10U
November 27. 2007
Page 1 of 50
---
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to adopt a Resolution amending the Collier County Administrative Code
Fee Schednle of development-related review and processing fees as provided for in The
Code of Laws and Ordinances, Section 2-11 (Companion Item 16A13)
OBJECTIVE: To have the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) approve a resolution
amending the Collier County Administrative Code Fee Schedule of development-related review
and processing fees as provided for in The Code of Laws and Ordinances, Section 2- I I.
CONSIDERATION: The vast majority of operations within the Collier County Community
Development and Environmental Services Division (CDES) are funded by fees in the core
service areas of building permits, building inspections, site plan reviews, and subdivision
reviews. Sensitive to the economic conditions within the community, CDES is remaining
consistent in its commitment to maintain the current fee levels for these fees, which have
remained unchanged since 2003. This proposal to amend the fee schedule is targeted at a variety
of peripheral user fees which are not adequately supporting their intended areas, which in turn
leads to a variety of CDES functions being subsidized by the General Fund or by core service
fees.
,..-.
One group of proposed fee changes is related to the Vehicle For Hire Services provided by Code
Enforcement; a general fund supported CDES Department. These proposed fees were approved
by the County's Private Vehicle Advisory Committee (PV AC) as user fees reflective of the
actual cost of providing such services. In the attached listing of proposed fee changes,
"Attachment D", they are outlined in changes number 1 through 4. Approval of these proposed
user fees will insure those citizens engaging this service will directly financially support it,
removing support from the General Fund.
One group of proposed fee changes is related to Growth Management Plan (GMP) consistency
reviews of specific development applications, such reviews being provided by the
Comprehensive Planning Department; a predominantly general fund supported CDES
Department. In the attached listing of proposed fee changes, "Attachment D", they are outlined
in change number 35. Approval of these proposed user fees will insure those developers
engaging the system, and requiring GMP consistency reviews as part of their development
applications, will directly financially support it, removing support from the General Fund.
.-
Another group of proposed fee changes is related to Contractor Licensing Services provided by
the Building Department. The~e fees were approved by the County's Contractor Licensing
Board as user fees reflective of the actual cost of providing such services. Contractor Licensing
fees have not been adjusted since 1993, creating a situation where Collier County fees are
considerably less than surrounding counties. This in turn has encouraged an influx of out-of-
county contractors to come into Collier County to meet their licensing requirements (reciprocity
agreements allow a contractor licensed in one county to work throughout the state). With these
low fees not supporting the cost of providing such services, out-of-county contractor licensing
AgenaEl item hlo. 1 CiU
j-'Jovember 27, 2007
Page 2 of 50
processing costs are being subsidized by unrelated building permits issued for work within the
County. In the attached listing of proposed fee changes, "Altacnment D", they are outlined in
changes number 29 through 33. Approval of these proposed user fees will insure those out-of-
county contractors engaging the system will directly financially support it, removing support
from unrelated in-county building projects.
The largest group of proposed fee changes is related to new review services provided by CDES
due to changes in the Land Development Code (LDC) or required to maintain consistency with
County Ordinance or other Fee Schedule Sections. In the attached listing of proposed fee
changes, "Attachment D", they are outlined in changes number 6 - 19, 22, 25, 26 and 34.
Approval of these proposed user fees will insure those developers engaging these new
rcquirements will directly financially support such activity, removing support from reserves
created by other previous users, which were committed to support those previous user's
applications and on-going review processes.
Another proposed fee change is related to PUD monitoring. Change number 24 is a fee to
recoup the costs associated with the growing and expanding PUD monitoring function. Current
revenue in this section funds two budgeted positions, which is out of an authorized four positions
lor this operation.
Among the miscellaneous proposed fee changes, proposed change number 34 from "Attachment
D" is a reduction in fees, and proposed change number 15 is a minor adjustment of fees related
to building pemlit review functions (Fund 113) preformed by Zoning and Land Development
Review (Fund 131) staff. Similarly, change 21 is a minor clarilication and assessment related to
excavation permits issued by the Engineering and Environmental Services Department, and
change 36 is a change in related copying fees to assure compliance with Resolution 98-498.
The original version of this proposal wa~ discussed with the Development Services Advisory
Committee (DSAC) at their October 10, 2007 meeting, and revisions were made to the proposal
based on their input on required services and the related costs of such services. The resulting
revised proposal was resubmitted to DSAC at their November 7, 2007 meeting. The overall
group of proposed fee revisions was approved by a vote of 10-0, with 5 proposed fee revisions
separated out and receiving denial recommendations. Of those 5 proposed fees recommended
for denial, 4 have been removed from this proposal forwarded to the BCC. The remaining
proposed fee is item 18, a fee associated with PUD closeout, which DSAC failed to endorse on a
5.5 vote. Following the tie vote, DSAC voted 8-2 to defer approval until the PUD closeout
process was finalized. CDES is forwarding this proposed fee due to the timing of potential PUD
processes being enacted and CDES's intent to significantly limit fee schedule requests in the near
future. In including this proposed PUD fee in the overall proposal CDES agrees to seek DSAC's
input on the validity of the fee level lollowing any PUD closeout process being enacted; data
being collected concerning the actual costs of such processes, and then bringing any DSAC
recommendations to revise this fee to the BCe. In their action, DSAC endorsed these proposed
fee changes as fair and of an appropriate level rcflective of actual CDES costs.
Agenda Item ~~o. 10U
l',jovember :7,2007
Page 3 of 50
Included with this Executive Summary are: Attaclunent "A"- the Resolution, Attachment "B".
the revised CDES Fee Schedule, Attachment "C"- CDES Fee Schedule underlines and strike-
through, and Attachment "0" - the listing of proposed fee changes.
FISCAL IMPACT: This Executive Summary requires, nor requests, any increase in the current
allocation of COES operating or personnel expenses already approved by the BCe. It is
anticipated that the requested user fees will generate $300.000 to $400,000 over Fiscal Year
2008, and such revenue will reduce General Fund support of COES activities, and in eliminating
COES core fee support of unrelated functions reduce the pressure to raise such core building
permit and plan review fees.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There are no growth management impacts.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This request has been reviewed by the Collier County
Attorney's Office, and is legally sufficient for the Board of County Commissioners consideration
and approval.
RECOMMENDATION: To have the Board of County Commissioners (BCe) approve a
resolution amending the Collier County Administrative Code Fee Schedule of development-
related review and processing fees as provided for in The Code of Laws and Ordinances, Section
2-11.
PREP AREO BY: Garrett Mullee, Manager COES Business Management and Budget Office.
,...,......
Item Number:
Item Summary:
Meeting Date:
1m;
',";,
~-'ilq(' it
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARO OF COUNTY COMWdSSIONERS
"D'J
r~s~ommellda\IOI1 \0 adlwt a Resoluliun alT1?ndilig lile Collier C/lUmy .Adrnlillstra\l\I(C ~;od~
h,,,, SC'ledllll' Gf dt~~eloprT'Gn;-rela;l)(\ '",,,,,ew [i!',(: p''CI:.es5,n" be:', 8S provldcJ :cr" 'i'lf
r~~>Je 0' Law" Cl"I~' C)r.'jwcn:cli"; :iec!>(LI 2-' -, (, ~("'liJ:o'!:::'" I'wr t~, 1 ['\1 i.lm~ ~icrl'T"t
"umU,.II-':y ~!pvr''llcm'"'Y, ."d:",111Io1IalO",
";:?7;:?UF ~.<J:.l.Ot- ,'rJI
~ Irmnc,,;1 Upcr.1IiDl1~' MmHiqPl
ua!(.
Prepared By
(,Mrel1Muiler.'
CommlHlitv [,evelopment&
~.llv,rol1n",nt~! 5er'lice"
i'rnJllciai .ull1l1n. & Hou,clnl:"
11112.12IlC, ~:04.27 PM
1,:>SlstantCountv Attornev
[,alii
Approved By
.JefrKlatzKO""
County Attornl'.,
Approvell Uy
County Attorney Off,c\'
1111412007 ~:5G AM
,Jo~cpll f',. "Cllmltt
Communi!:1 lJevelOpm"nt&
Env,ronment",,1 St'rvire~, Admtnstralor
DaK
^Ilprovell Uy
C.ommuni<\' [Jevelopmen: /; c.omm\Jnltv Development &
L.nv,,-onrnent~' "ervlce<;Admw,
11114,'200712:22PM
Fnvironmenta: Scrvicf'~
l/twl'HI"'S(,W"""
,'Yf'Ctluvc,SecrPtilr
U<lU
:::'omll1;j[l<!v tJ,., .'Iopmen! <:.. ,.ommunir,' tJevelopmen: I;,
t:nVlforHnem;,1 ,,(>~';IC"",
"~it4,';l(jn 4.:,,1 !Ori
f:nvlronm"nrJi S"nl1c,'rAdnH'
:mcrat,ul1 I'n;u"c
L,at
Approvcll By
,"N':"U'!.
,nrnrrnml ,:UUVCll'rHlwr<
f'>1V,ro"rnenviS'rJ'vo"
vOIT'111'''1;1 [)","'I<)prr,,,nl;,
[cnv,romTl<JntJi ;~("vic"~' I,om",
I;: 1';;2(";0:' 4:~j:' Pli
LJ'li'
Apllroved By
,'I',1F,-:.o-nC',n":,,.
;',1m,n,qr.",v( .."rvi':<"-
kpnl,,,"IIO'l":'i-,[l""'\,',
:1l'orr;,iJ!oo,"Bcnn<>l0n,'
l1il4!201l7440PM
Approved R~
Bud(l~i Analys:
rJail'
rJ",rf.ls<>cksQr,
Count:,' ~'IJna(Jer's Oll,c'
O/ii'Oe{JI Ma"J(]<'lllen ;;, bUd.",,,
11.,'1912[;07 (j :;.7 Ale'
Michae'Sm'l"owsK,
M~n3(]enVmt "" Budge: [!lfe~to'
fjEIH
Allproved By
Count\' Mana!l('r's Olilc~'
Otiice of Manapelllenl & fJua""t
11119120074 12 pr~
Apprnvcll By
.J<1rnet\" Mudd
boardofCOllmv
Cornmiss'onerc
COllnt\' Man3<:l",r
[lat"
Count'.,.' r.rlan~ger.s OfllcP
1111S12007 &;OfiPM
file://C:\Aj!endaT est\Export\93. November%2027. 0/0102007\ 1 O.%20COl JNTY%20MANA..
11/20/2007
Ar:)enaa liem No. '\OU
'f\jovemner T". 2007
Page 5 of 50
RESOLUTION NO. 2007-_
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY. FLORIDA,
AMENDING THE COLLIER COUNTY COMMUNITY
DEVELOPMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES FEE
SCHEDULE; SUPERSEDING RESOLUTION NO. 2007-160;
AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
.....
WHEREAS, on June 26, 2007, the Board of County Commissioners approved Resolution
No. 2007-160, establishing a fee schedule for services performed by Collier County's
Community Development and Environmental Services Division; and
WHEREAS, the Board recognizes that revisions to this fee schedule are necessary to
reflect the actual cost incurred by the County.
NOW. THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY. FLORIDA that:
The Board of County Commissioners hereby declares that the fees set forth in the Collier
County Community Development and Environmental Services Fee Schedule, set forth as Exhibit
"A," are all fair and reasonable sums to be assessed to those who receive the benefits of the
services, reviews, and inspections required pursuant to the Land Development Code and the
County's corresponding development review and permitting processes.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Resolution be recorded in the minutes of this
Board with an immediate effective date upon the Board of County Commissioners approval, and
that Resolution No. 2007-]60 is hereby superseded by the adoption of this Resolution effective
as stated above.
This Resolution adopted after motion, second and majority vote, this _ day of
.2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA,
Chairman
legal sufficiency:
"
(~;
f,r"O~. ,ltOrYl t\l,., 1nll
l~ovember 27. 2007
Page 6 of 50
c
e
r
c
"
K
R
e
y
EXHIBIT B
COLLIER COUNTY COMMUNITY
ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
DEVELOPMENT AND
FEE SCHEDULE
Bee Proposed version. November 27, 2007
Contents:
Al ADMINiSTRATION....
B) BLASTING PERMITS & INSPECTION....
C) ENVIRONMENTAL/LANDSCAPING..
OJ EXCA V A TION PERMITS........
E) FIRE CODE REVIEW rrr'"
F) SITE DEVELOPMENT PLANS .....
C;) SUBDIVISION ..
II) ENGINEERING INSPECTION FEES..
I) TEMPORARY USE PERMITS..
.I) V.,.'ELL PERMITS/lNSPECTlONS..
Kl ZONING/I.AND lISE PETITIONS..
Ll MISCELLANJOLIS...
M} BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION FEE..
N) RllILDlN(; PERMIT FEES..
0) ELECTRICAL PERMIT FEES..
Pl PLUMBING PERMIT FEES..
Qj MECHANICAL PERMIT FEES...
R) FIRE PREVENTION AND CONTROL PERMIT FEES..
51 MOBILE HOME/OFFICE TRAILER AND OTHER TRAILER PERMIT FEES .....
Tl CHICKEES AND SIMILAR STRUCTURES..
[I) POOL OR SPA PERMIT FEES..
V) SCREEN ENCLOSURE PERMIT & PAN ROOF FEES ._.....
W) SIGN PERMIT FEES..
X) CONVENIENCE PERMIT FEES..
Y) REVISION AND AS BUILT PLAN REVIEW FEES; CORRECTIONS TO PLANS..
Z) PERMIT EXTENSION ..
AA) DEMOLITION OF BUILDING OR STRUCTLRE PERMIT rEES..
BB) PRE-MOVING INSPECTION FEES..
eCI INSPECTION FEES..
DO} REINSPECTION FEES..
EF) FAILURE TO OBT AIN A PERMIT ....
FFl LICENSING..
CiG) DUPLlCA TE PERMIT CARDS..
HH) CHANGE OF CONTRACTOR OR SUBCONTRACTORS ......
II) PERMIT FEE REFUNDS..
JJ)-RECORD RETR]EV AL..
KKI COPY FEES..
LL) RESEARCH..
MMI SUBSCRIPTION SERVICE..
NN) ELECTRONIC DATA CONVERSION SURCHARGE..
00) REGISTRATION OF RENTAL DWELLINGS..
1'1') CERTIFICATE TO BOARD BILLING.
QQ) ADDITIONAL FEE REFUND PROVISIONS..
RR) REFUND PROVISIONS..
S5) ADDITIONAL FEE PROVISIONS..
TT) PUBLlC VEHICLE FOR HIRE FEES..
UU) "PAYMENT ]N LIEU OF" FEE !-'OR PATHW A YS (SIDEW ALKS, AND BIKE LANES).. .
..... ...2
................................................2
... ..........2
.............................................3
,
.............4
......................5
.................0
. ..............................................6
. ................................................7
..............7-S
......................... .....9
... ......................................................11
.............]1
.......]2
.... ......................................................12
.....................................J:\
...............................................................\3
............13
.....................................................13
...13
...........14
... ...................14
............................._......14
...........]4
..............................................15
......................................................15
................................................................15
. ............15
.......15
._15
......................... ......................16
.............16
..................... ........................16
..................................................................16
.............16
. ..............................................17
......................................................................_17
..................17
............17
.............................................]7
.....................................................................17
.............IR
18
............18
.............................................18
....... ...]9
Fees are in bold
('DES Financial Administration, rev 11113/07 lw
page 1
('."on....::; 1'0 I\.ir, -:fli:
'f~Qvember 27,2007
Page 7 of 50
FEES ARE ESTABLISHED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS RESOLUTION. AND CANNOT
BE WAIVED OR SUSPENDED WITHOUT AN ACTION BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS.
ANY QUESTIONS CONCERNING THE APPLICABILITY OF FEES SHALL BE CONCLUSIVELY
DETERMINED BY THE DIRECTOR OF THE APPROPIATE DEPARTMENT. AS APPLICABLE. WHERE AS
PART OF A REZONING. PLAT OR SIMILAR APPLICATION TYPE. THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS DIRECTS A~PROV AL OF FUTURE DEVELOPMENT ORDERS DIFFERENT FROM THE
STANDARD TYPE OF APPROY AL PROCESSES REQUIRED. THE DIRECTOR OF THE APPROPRIATE
DEPARTMENT SHALL DETERMINE THE FEES TO BE APPLIED TO THE PROCESS NECESSARY TO MEET
THE BOARDS REQUIREMENTS. THE APPLICABLE FEES SHALL BE THOSE WHICH MOST CLOSELY
RESEMBLE THOSE CHARGED FOR SIMILAR PROCESSES INCLUDING EXTRA FEES FOR ADVERTISING
AND THE LIKE.
A) ADMINISTRA nON
1) Official Interpretation Request of Land Development Code (LDC), Growth Management Plan (GMP). or
Building Construction Administrative Code (Administrative Code). Based on staff hours: Less than 20 hours
$1,500.00. 20 to 40 hours $3,000.00, more than 40 hours $5,000.00
2) Interpretation request submitted in conjunction with a land use petition or requested during site development
plan review process. S250.00
3) Detennination of Vested Rights. $]00.00 (plus the County's out-of-pocket expenses associated with hearing
officer and hearings)
4) Appeal of Vested Rights Detennination. $]00.00
5) Amendment to Land Development Code. $3,01111.110
6) Appeal of an Administrative Decision (as may be provided for in the Collier County Administrative Code or
the LDC). $1000.00 (non.refundable)
7) Appeal to Board of Zoning Appeals or Building Board of Adjustments and Appeals (as may be provided for in
the Collier County Administrative Code or the LDC). $1,000.110 (non-refundable)
B) BLASTING PERMITS & INSPECTION
1) 30 day permit fee, non-refundable payable upon application. $250.00
2) 90 day permit fee. non.refundahle payable upon application. $600.00
3) Yearly permit fee, non.refundable payable upon application. $1,500.00
4) Renewal pemlit fee. non-refundable payable upon application. $200.00
5) After-the-fact fee, due to blasting without a permit. $10,000.00
6) Fine fee, per detonated shot with after-the-fact permir. $200.00
7) Handler fee, for handler who assists the user or blaster in the use of explosives. $100.00
8) Blasting Inspection Fee. $200.00 (per inspection)
9) Inspection fees shall be paid upon issuance of a blasting permit based on the estimated number of
blasts. Upon completion. fees will be adjusted to reflect actual number of blasts.
C) ENVIRONMENT AL/LANDSCAPING
1) Site Clearing Permit, first acre or fraction of an acre. $250.00 Each additional acre or fraction of
an acre. $50.00 ($3.000.00 maximum)
2) Agricultural Land Clearing
a. Land Clearing Notification $250.00
CDES Financial Administration, rev 11/13/07 lw
page 2
Linc.,.-,rb 'To. . i if' 1 nl !
-November 27. 2007
b. Land Clearing Permit $250.00 each additional acre or traction of an acre. $50.00 ($3.1lft4!UlUl of 50
maximum)
3) Landscape Tree Removal Fee $250
4) Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) $2,500.00 for 1st submittal and 2" submittal if applicable,
3rd submittal $1,000.00, 4th and subsequent submittals $500.00 each
5) Landscape Re-inspection 1S1 SSO.OO. 2nd $75.00, every inspection afterward $100.00
6) Vehicle on the Beach Permit Application. $250.00 (Permit fee shall be waived for public and
non-profit organizations engaging in environmental activities for scientific, conservation or
educational purposes).
7) Beach Nourishment Permits - $400
8) Special Treatment Review
a. First five acres or less. $400.00
b. Each additional acre, or fraction thereof $50.00 ($5,000.00 Maximum)
c. Pre-application meeting $250.00 (to be credited toward application fee upon submittal)
9) Coastal Construction Setback Line (CCSL):
a. CCSL Permits $400.00
b. Variance - Petition. $1000.00
10) Sea Turtle Permit-
a. Sea Turtle Handling Permits. $25.00
b. Sea TUl1le Nesting Area Construction Pernlit. S200.00
c. Sea TUlile Nest Relocation. SlOO.OO
11 ) Vegetation Removal Permit
a. First acre or fraction of an acre less. $250.00
b. Each additional acre. or fraction thereof $50.00 ($3,000.00 Maximum)
12) After-the-fact Environmental or Landscape Permits
a. CCSL Variance Petition. 2x n.ormal fee
b. All other Environmental or Landscape Permits. 4x normal fee
13) Informal Wetland Jurisdictional determination for single family parcels up to 5 acres - $300.00
14) Conservation Easement review fee - $300.00 application fee plus the following additional site fee:
$200.00 for CE acres less than 5 acres; $400.00 for CE area between 5 acres and 10 acres; $600.00
for CE area greater than 10 acres and less than 20 acres; $800.00 for CE areas between 20 and 50
acres; and an additional $200.00 for every 40 acres of CE area over 50 acres.
15) Listed or Protected Species review fee (when an EIS is not required) - $1000.00
D) EXCA V A nON PERMITS
I) Annual Renewal. $300.00
2) Application (Private). $400.00
3) Application (Commercial). $2.000.00
4) Application (Development). $400.00
5) $200.00 per inspection paid in advance for 12 months
6) Reapplication: $300.00 plus $200.00 per month inspection fee
7) Cubic Yardage Review Fee: $200.00 first 5000 cy, plus $10.00 per additional 1000 cy with a
maximum of $20,000.00
8) Time Extension. $150.00 plus $200.00 per month inspection fee
9) After-the-fact Excavation Permit. 4x application fee
CDES Financial Administration. rev 11/13107 Iw
page 3
;:.",,'1....... ,...;:::' li'on', 1\.1(' ~ r I I
't\JOV8nlb8: '27.2007
10) Over excavation penalty fee per yard. Plus PermiVReviev.' $0.05 per cubic y'ard fee, unless nm~fniJam~ 50
have been paid.
E) FIRE CODE REVIEW FEES .... .
1) Fire Code Reviev" fees associated with each of the followm~"'proce:ses: .... ,
a. SDP. Site Development Plan $200.00
b. SDPA - Site Development Plan, Amendment S150.00
c. SDPI. Site Development Plan. Insubstantial $100.00
d. SIp. Site Improvement Plan $150.00
e. SIPI. Site Improvement Plan. Insubstantial $100.00
f. PSP. Preliminary Subdivision Plans $150.00
g. PSPA - Preliminary Subdivision Plans, Amendment S100.00
h. PPL. Plans & Plat. Subdivision $100.00
1. FP . Final Plat $100.00
I. CONSTR. Construction Plans. Subdivision/Utilities $100.00
k. ICP - Construction Plans, Insubstantial SIOO.OO
L DRl. Development of Regionallmpaet $200.00
m. DOA . Development Order, Amendment $150.00
n. PUDZ - Planned Unit Development. Rezone $150.00
o. PUDA - Planned Unit Development. Amendment $150.00
p. PDI. Planned Unit DevelupmenL Insubstantial $100.00
q. RZ - Rezone, Regular Zoning SIOO.OO
r. CU. Conditional Use $150.00
F) SITE DEVELOPMENT PLANS
I) Site Development Plan Review (SDP). $5000.00
a. plus $40.00 per Dm
b. plus $100.00 per residential building structure
c. plus S.10 per square foot for non-residential except that structures designed exclusively for parking
(parking garages) shall be calculated at $.05 per square foot.
d. plus $200.00 per building for non-residential
e. Additional fees for 3rd review $I~OOO.OO, 4th review $1~5()O.00, 5th review $2,000.00, 61h and
subsequent reviews $2,500.00
When a building consist of both residential and non-residential (commercial, retail, office) uses, the following
fees will apply.
a. $5000.00 base fee plus $40.00 per DIU
b. $200.00 per building for non-residential
c. plus $0.10 per square foot of non-residential floor area
d. Additional fees for 3rd reviev..! $1,000.00, 41h review $1,500.00. 51h review $2l000.00, 6th and
subsequent reviews $2,500.00
2) Pre-application fee. $500.00 (to be credited toward application fee upon submittaL)
a. Second and subsequent pre-app meetings at the applicant's request shall not be
credited towards application fees.
b. Second and subsequent pre-app meetings at staff's request will be held at no charge
to the applicant.
c. Applications submitted 9 months or more after the date of the last pre-app meeting
shall not be credited towards application fees and a new pre-application meeting
will be required.
3) Simultaneous Review Fee (planning review of simultaneous building pemlit applications) S100.00 per building
permit application.
CDES Financial Administration, rev \ \..'13107 \w
page 4
-
4) Site Development Plan Insubstantial Change
a. Site Development Plan Insubstantial Change.
additional sheet submitted.
b. Additional fees for 3'd review $1,000.00, 4'" Review $1,500.00, 5'" and subsequent review
$2,000.00
t, c> .r) Ire> ,t\in 11\11
November 27.2007
Page 10 of 50
$400.00 for first sheet, $100.00 for each and every
5) Site Development Plan Conceptual.Review (CSP), Unified Development Plan (UDP), Neighborhood Park Site
(NPSP) $750.00
[6) Site Improvement Plan Review (SlP). $1000.00 (plus Engineering review fees)
7) Utility Plan Review & Inspection Fees-
a. Construction Document Review. O.750/i, of probable water and/or sewer construction costs
b. Construction Inspection. 2.250/0 of probable water and/or sewer construction costs
c. Construction Document Resubmission or Document Modification, submit as insubstantial change.
$150.00 for first sheet, $75.00 for each additional sheet
8) Engineering Site Plan Review Fee
a. Construction Documents Review Fee 0.750/0 of probable Paving, Grading, Drainage, Lighting, Code
Minimum Landscaping, and any other appurtenant cost of construction
b. Construction Inspection 2.250/0 of probable Paving, Grading, Drainage, Lighting, Code Minimum
Landscaping, and any other appurtenant cost of construction
9) Site Development Plan Amendment (SDP A) $2,500.00,
a. Plus $40.00 per DIU plus $100.00 per residential building structure
b. plus $.10 per square foot
c. plus $200.00 per building for non-residential
d. Additional fees for 3rd reviev,' $1,000.00, 4th Review $1,500.00, 5th and subsequent review
$2,000.00
10) SBR Fees
a) Pre-Acquisition Meeting $500.00 (no refunds or credits)
b) Pre-application fee. $500.00 (to be credited toward application fee upon submittaL) (all nOlmal pre-
application provisions apply).
c) SBR Fee $5000.00 with hourly reconciliation at project completion for hourly variation greater than
10%, final project charges at $100.00 per hour for all associated staff hours
11) Violation of the conditions of approval of the SDP/SIP or installation of improvements, clearing, or other
land alteration not depicted on, or otherwise authorized as a part of the approved SDP/SIP. 4x the SIP/SDP
application fee
12) Request for alternative architectural design $500.00, no separate or additional fee for appeals to, or requests
for assistance from, the Architectural Arbitration Board.
G) SUBDIVISION
1) Lot Line Adjustment (LLA) and Lot Split Review $250.00
2) Subdivision Review Fees (PPL), (PPLA) -
a. Construction Documents Review Fee 0.750/0 of probable Paving, Grading, Drainage, Lighting, Code
Minimum Landscaping and any other appurtenant cost of construction
b. Subdivision Inspection Fee 2.250,,{, of probable Paving, Grading, Drainage, Lighting, Code Minimum
Landscaping, and any other appurtenant cost of construction
c. Construction Document Resubmission or Document Modification -Submit as Insubstantial Change
$400.00 for first sheet, $100.00 for each additional sheet
d. Subdivisions - 3rd and subsequent additional reviews - $500.00
c. Subdivisions - Substantial deviations from approval construction documents $500.00
CDES Financial Administration, rev 11113/07 lw
page 5
.url:::>.nrb !torr l\i.-, 1 nl I
tlJOVernbSi' ::: f 2007
Page "11 of 50
3) Subdivision. Preliminary Plat (PSP)-
a. Petition Application S1000.00 plus S5.00 per acre (or fraction thereof) for residential, plus S10.00
per acre (or fraction thereof) for non-residential; (mixed use is residential)
4) Subdivision Final Plat (FP) $1.000.00 plus $5.00 per acre (or leaction thereof) for residential. $1000.00 plus
$10.00 per acre (or fraction thereof) for nonresidential: (mixed use is residential)
5) Additional review of construction plans for phased construction of subdivision improvements. S1000.00 per
phase
6) Two-year Extension $150.00
7) Water and Sewer Facilities Construction Document Review O.75(Yo of probable water and/or sewer
construction costs
8) Construction Document Resubmission or Document Modification 0.250/0 of probable water and/or sewer
construction costs
a. 3rd and subsequent re-submittals - $500.00
9) Water and Sewer Facilities Construction Inspection Fee 2.250/0 of probable water and/or sewer construction
costs
10) Violation of the conditions of approval of approved construction plans or installation of improvements,
clearing, or other land alteration not depicted on. or othef\vise authorized as a part of the approved
construction plans or permit. 4, the PPL. PPLA. PSP. CNSTR or Final Plat Review Fee (FP).
11) Administrative Amendment $250.00
H) ENGINEERING INSPECTION FEES
I) Engineering Inspection Fee $150.00 per residential dwelling unit or accessory structure to
residential dwelling unit (single or duplex only). charged at time of building permit
Issuance.
2) Re-inspection Fees: 1st re-inspection $75.00, 2nd re-inspection $100.00, 3rd and thereafter re-
inspection $125.00
I) TEMPORARY USE PERMITS
1) Beach Events Permits-
a. Individual Permit $100.00
b. Block of 25 calendar days $2.250.00
c. Block of 50 calendar days $4,500.00
d. Block of 75 calendar days $6,750.00
e. Block of 100 calendar days $9,000.00
f. Block of 125 calendar days $11,250.00
g. Block of 150 calendar days $13,500.00
2) Temporary Use Permit Special Sales & Event<;. $200.00
3) Model Homes and Sales Centers $500.00
4) Construction and Development, Mobile home. Agricultural Zoning, and Temporary use for "Coming
Soon" sign $125.00
5) Residential and Non-Profit Garage and Yard Sale Penn its No Charge
CDES Financial Administration, rev 11/13!O7 Iw
page 6
[,r"c..vl.. It"",m H,-. 1nll
l~ovember 27, 2007
Page 12 of 50
6) Temporary Use Amendment. $100.00
7) Renewals or extensions requested after the expiration date $200.00
8) Temporary Use Permit for Special Events requiring BeC approval, including Circus and Carnival
Permits. $275.00
9) Political Signs (Bulk Temporary Permit) $5.00
10) Fees for Temporary Use permits issued After the Fact, A TF: 2x normal fee
J) WELL PERMITSIINSPECTIONS
1) Hydraulic elevator shaft permit $300.00
2) Test hole permit (including 1st six holes) $300.00, each additional hole $20.00
3) Well permit (abandonment) $50.00
4) Well permit (construction, repair, or combined construction and abandonment at one site) $300.00
5) Well permit (monitoring) $150.00
6) Well Permit (modification of monitor/test well to a production well) $75.00
7) Well Reinspections
a. First Reinspection
b. Second Reinspection
c. Third Reinspection
$75.00
$100.00
$150.00
8) After the fact well permits 4x normal fee per violation.
NOTE: Multiple wells may be allowed on one permit, but eacb well must be
accounted for and the appropriate fee shall be charged for each well in
accordance with the above listed schedule.
K) ZONING/LAND USE PETITIONS
1) Pre-application meeting fee $500.00 (to be credited toward application fee upon submitta1.)
a. Second and subsequent pre-app meetings at the applicant's request shall not be credited towards
application fees.
b. Second and subsequent pre-app meetings at staffs request will be held at no charge to the applicant.
c. Applications submitted 9 months or more after the date of the last pre-app meeting shall not be
credited towards application fees and a new pre-application meeting will be required.
2) Alcoholic Beverage or Service Station Separation Requirement Waiver $1000.00
3) Boat Dock Extension Petition $1,500.00 Boat Lift Canopy Administrative Review $500.00
4) Conditional Use Permit $4,000.00 when filled witb Rezone Petition ($1,500.00) Additional fee for 5'" and
subsequent reviews - 201% of original fee.
5) Conditional Use Monitoring Review: $750.00
6) Conditional Use Extension $3,000.00
7) DRl Review (In addition to cust of rezone) $10,000.00 plus $25.00 an acre (or fraction thereof) Additional fee
for 5th and subsequent reviews - 200/0 of original fee Amendments deemed to be minor in nature, that is
requiring minor strike thru and underline text amendments of no more than 10 different lines of text changes
in the DRI will be capped at $13,000.00. Any amendment which includes a map and text change \",ill be
assessed the full fee (no cap).
CDES Financial Administration, rev 11/13!07 Iw
page 7
L' ."lpn,....::' Irpn"' hln i 01 I
-November 27, 2007
Page 13 of 50
8) DRI/DO Amendment $6,000.00 plus $25.00 per acre (or fraction thereof). The acreage charge does not apply
for amendments which only change the build-out date of the DO for a time period of less than five years.
9) DRlABN - DR! Abandonment $1,500.00
10) Flood Variance Petition $1000.00
II) Interim Agriculture Use Petition $350.00
12) Non-Conforming Use Change/Alteration $1,500.00
13) Parking Exemption $1,500.00. Additional fee for 5lh and subsequent reviews - 200/0 of original fee.
14) Parking Reduction (Administrative) $500.00
IS) Rezone Petition (PUD to PUD): $8,000.00 plus $25.00 an acre (or fraction thereof) (Requires a submittal ofa
new PUD document)
16) Property owner notifications: $1.50 non-certified mail, $3.00 certified return receipt mail (Petitioner to
pay this amount prior to advertisement of petition)
17) Planned Unit Development Amendments (PUD) $6,000.00 plus $25.00 an acre or fraction of an acre.
(Substantial changes to the text and Master Plan), Additional fee for 5lh and subsequent reviews - 20%
of original fee. Text changes that do not impact the Master Plan $6_000.00 {the $25.00 an acre fee will not
apply. Amendments deemed to be minor in nature that is requiring minor strike thru and underline
amendments of no more than 10 different lines of text changes in the PUD will be capped at $9,000.00.
Any amendment which includes a map and text change will be assessed the full fee (no cap).
] 8) Planned Unit Development Amendment - Insubstantial (PDl) $1.500.00 requires a hearing hy the CCPC only
for a minor change to the PUD Master Plan. PUD Minor Change (PMC) $1,000.00 (Administrative Review
for minor change to the Master Plan)
19) Rezone Petition (Regular) $6,000.00 plus $25.00 an acre (or fraction thereat) Additional fee for 5lh and
subsequent reviews - 204.1/4.1 of original fee.
20) Rezone Petition (to PUD) $10,000.00 plus $25.00 an acre (or fraction thereof), Additional fee for 5'h and
subsequent reviews - 200/4.1 of original fee.
21) Street Name Change (Platted) $500.00 plus $1.00 for each property owner requiring notification of proposed
street name change
22) Un-platted street name or project name change: $100.00 per application fee plus $50.00 per additional hour or
Partial hour of research required to process application, not to exceed $500.00
23) Variance petition: $2,000.00 residential, $5,000.00 non- residential. Additional fee for 5th and subsequent
Reviews - 20%1 of original fee.
24) Variance (Administrative) $1,000.00
15) Zoning Certificate: Residential: S50.00_ Commercial:$125.00
26) PUD Extension - Sun Setting: $1000.00
27) Sign Variance PetitIOn: $2000.00
CDES Financial Administration, rev I I!] 3/07 \w
page 8
6.'1C>....'~ Ifam ~,Ir, 1n:!
'f\jovember 27. 2007
28) Stewardship Receiving Area Petition (SRA): $7000.00 per SRA plus $25.00 per acre for. Stewardsftiflge ",4 of 50
Sending Area Petition (SSA): $9,500.00, S.ewardship Receiving Alternative Deviation Design (SRDD)
$500.00. SRA Amendments deemed to be minor in nature. that is requiring minor strike thru and
underline text amendments of no more than 10 different lines of text changes in the SRA will be capped
at $10,000.00,
29) After-the-Fact Zoning/Land Use Petitions 2x the nonnal petition fee
30) Land Use Petition Continuances
a. Requested after petition has been advertised $500.00
b, Requested at the meeting $750.00
c. Resultant additional required advertising charged in addition to continuance fees.
31) PUD and SRA_Monitoring (one-time charge at time of building permit pick-up)
a. S100.00 per dwelling unit for residential construction within a PUD and SRA ($3,000.00 maximum
fee per building permit application)
b. SO.12 per square foot for non-residential construction within a PUD and SRA ($3,000.00 maximum
fee per building permit application)
32) Any legal advertising required during any CDES activity or approval process will be charged in addition to
stated fees, at actual costs. CDES reserves the right to charge an estimated amount with the initially required
project fees, and will reconcile and adjust such charges against actual legal advertising billings at the
completion of the project.
33) Mixed Use Project (MUP) $2.500.00
34) Outdoor Servmg Area Permit $300.00
35) Planned Unit Development (rUD) closeout application and processing:
a. PUD's up to 50 acres: $5,000.00
b. PUD's over 50 acres up to 250 acres: $7,000.00
c. PUD's over 250 acres; $9,500.00
36) Development of Regional Impact (DRT) closeout application and processing $10,000.00
L) MISCELLANEOUS
] ) Reserved
2) Reserved
3) Official Zoning Atlas Map Sheet Publications, maps, and reports shan be copied at actual cost.
4) The following fee shall be assessed for all Lien Searches, Title Searches and/or Payoff Requests: $5.00/per
request.
5) The fee for researching records, ordinances, and codes shall be at no charge for the first hour, then at the base
salary hourly rate of the staff member conducting the service for time in excess of 1 hour.
6) The fee for creating and designing special computer generated reports that are not a part of regular standard
reports shall be at no charge for the first hour, then at the base salary hourly rate of the staff member conducting
the service for time in excess of 1 hour.
7) CD Burning: $5.00
8) Complete sets of Official Zoning Atlas Map Sheets $100.00 per set.
('DES Financial Admini~tration. rev 11/13/07 lw
page 9
9) Staff shall charge the following fees for duplication of public records:
"::',-,pn.-i-:> 'n::,m ~,1r, 1 ill
T\!overnber 27, 2007
Page -:5 of 50
a. $0.15 for each one sided photocopy of documents less than 11 x 17 inches.
b. $0.20 for each two sided photocopy of documents less than 11 x 17 inches.
c. $1.00 for each certified copy of a public record.
10) Property Notification Address Listing:
a. MS Excel spreadsheet on Disc $70.00
b. Print out on Paper $75.00 ~ $0.05 for every record over 1500
c. Mailing Labels S80.00 + SO.06 for every record over] 500
d. Print out on Paper + Mailing Labels S85.00 + SO.II for every record over 1500
11) Comprehensive Plan Consistency Reviev./
a. CU's S300.00
b. Rezonings S750.00
c. Pud's or PUD Amendments: S2250.00
d. Letter of GMP consistency to outside agencies: $250
e. SRA - Stewardship Receiving Area - S2,250.00
f. DR] - Development of Regional Impact - $2,250.00
g. FlAM - Fiscal Impact Analysis - S4,000.00
12) Plan Review Fee (for planning review of all building permit applications)
a) Long forms: $125.00 per building permit application, 2nd review 500/0 of fee, 3rd and
subsequent 25(% of fee (2Jld and subsequent reviev.' fees related to Zoning approvals only)
b) Express permits: $50.00 per building pemlit application, 2nJ revie\\' 50GAI of fee. 3rd and
subsequent 25(% of fee (2nd and subsequent reviev.' fees related to Zoning approvals only)
13) Project Meetings: Active applications under review for the following project types will be afforded one inter-
departmental meeting at no charge: Planned Unit Development re-zonings and Site Development Plan
applications (except for conceptual site plan approval and insubstantial change approval). Meeting requests
for all other application types and additional meetings will be subject to the following fees:
a. Meetings with Departmental Project Approval Staff member per applicant request, reviews
and petitions in progress. $150.00 per one hour minimum, $75.00 per Y2 hour thereafter.
Additional Department staff attending meeting per applicant request $75.00 per ~ hour per
staff member.
b. Inter-Departmental Project Meeting per applicant request site plan reviews and land use
petitions in progress, $500.00 per one hour minimum. $250.00 per ~'2 hour thereafter.
14) Adequate Public Facilities
a. Planning Applications requiring COA process review (such as FP's, PPL.s & SIP's, SDPs)
S200.00 + 25.00 per residential dwelling unit or ~ 25.00 per 1000 sq ft commercial
($5000.00 maximum)
b. Building permit applications requiring COA process review not covered under 12.a above
SIOO.OO per building permit application.
15) Zoning Confirmation Letters
a. Standard Response SIOO.OO (includes up to I hour research)
b. Extended Research $100.00 per hour (any response with research in excess of 1 hour)
16) Zoning Letter Appeal $250.00
17)CDD
a. Community Development District $15,000.00
b. Chapter 189 Special District. Independent or Dependent. SI5,OOO.OO
(,DES Financial-Administration, rev] ]/13/07]w
page 10
L\nc.-t.:....' Ii-om 1\.' 101 I
'f,ovember 27. 2007
18) GMP Amendment Page 16 of 50
a. Small Scale $9000.00
b. General $16,700.00 . .
c. Legal advertising in addition to sub-sections a and b fees, and subject to applicable fee schedule
provisions.
d. Pre-application meetings for GMP consistency for development orders and zoning/land use petitions:
$250
e. Pre-application meetings for GMP amendment petitions: $250 (to be credited toward application fee
upon submittal)
19) Application for issuance TDR, $250 (non-refundable); plus $25 per TDR issued and recorded (total fees not to
exceed $2,750.00)
20) Engineering Services
a) Vacation of Easements; $2.000.00
21) Building Board of Adjustments and Appeals $250.00
22) Early Work Authorization (EW A) permit: $500.00 (does not include site clearing fee).
23) Legal Non-conforming Lot (LNC) $100.00
24) Vested Rights Determination (VRD) $1,500.00
M) BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION FEE
I) A permit application fee shall be collected at time of applying for a
building penn it. The pemlit application fee shall be collected when the
plans are submitted for revie\v. The fee shall be applied toward the total
permit fee. The applicant shall forfeit the application fee if the
application is denied or if the application is approved and the permit is
not issued within the time limitation as stated in Section 103.6.1.1 of the
Collier County Ordinance No. 91-56, as amended.
2) Application fee will be computed as follows:
a) 25% of total Building Pem,i! Fee ($.15/sq fl new residential and commercial, $.075 shell and
warehouse)
3) Minimum fee of $50.00 for each of the following: plumbing; mechanical (A/C); electrical; flre; and building,
When applying for additions/alterations. Minimum fee for all other applications = $50.00
4) The balance ofthe total pelmit fee will be collected at the time of issuance of the permit and will include any
fee adjustments necessary.
N) BUILDING PERMIT FEES
1) The fee for a building permit shall be computed as follows: Such fees shall be either based on the contractor's
valuations of construction cost or based on square footage. Minimal accepted calculated costs of construction
are set forth on the attached Building Valuation Data Table (Exhibit B - !BC Building Valuation Data Table,
produced February, 2007). Valuation of construction costs of less than $750.00 - No permit or fee is required,
but construction must comply with all County Codes and Ordinances. If inspections are required by the
Building Official or requested by the applicant, the appropriate fees shall be paid.
EXCEPTION: All work involving structural components and/or fire rated assemblies requires permits and
inspections regardless of construction cost, signs must secure permits as stated in Collier
Collier County Ordinance No. 2001MOl, as amended.
CDES Financial Administration. rev 11/13/07 lw
page 11
bn;:::>nri:;:. Itorn t,ln 1 nl '
November 2 i, 200 '
Gage i7 of 5f'
a. Valuation of construction costs of $750.00 through $4.999.99 - $100.00
b. New construction greater than 500 square feet
I. residential at $0.29 per square foot (living area)
11. warehouse/shell at $0.145 per square foot (total area)
111. build-out at $.0]45 per square foot (total area)
1V. commercial/institutional at $0.29 per square foot (total area)
c. Alterations, other construction, and new construction under 500 square feet (both residential and
commercial) $100 plus 0.300/0 of declared valuation in excess of $5,000
0) ELECTRICAL PERMIT FEES
1) The fees for electrical permits for new structures or placement or relocation
of structures shall be computed as follows:
a. $0.40 per ampere rating of all single-phase panel boards.
b. SO.15 per ampere rating for switch or circuit whichever is greater, if item
#1 above does not apply.
c. When not a complete installation. all s\vitch and circuit breakers ahead of
panel boards shall be computed at $0.15 per ampere.
d. Permit fees for any change in electrical installation shall be computed at
the above rates for that portion of new and/or increased fees in existing
electrical facilities.
e. The minimum for any electrical penn it shall be S50.00 per unit or tenant
space.
f. fifty percent (5W~J) in additional fee costs shall be added to all above fees
for three phase installations.
EXCEPTION: Ordinary repairs limited to a $200 value or less may' be made
without a permit. Repairs must comply with all County Codes and Ordinances. If
inspections are required by the Building Official or requested by the
applicant. the appropriate fees shall be paid.
P) PLUMBING PERMIT FEES
1) The following fee calculations shall be applied separately when the permit
involves mixed occupancies.
a) Residential occupancies: The fee for a plumbing permit shall be computed at
the rate of $50.00 to be charged for each living unit with one to three
bathrooms. An additional fee of$10.00 will be assessed for each additional
bathroom.
b) Nonresidential occupancies: The fee for a plumbing pennit shall be computed
by the following methods, whichever is calculated to be the greatest fee:
aJ The rate of $3.00 per 425 square feet of floor area, orfraction
thereof; or
b) Institutional facilities, hospitals, schools, restaurants and repairs
in any occupancy classification shall be charged at the rate of
$1.00 per fixture unit or
c) Minimum of$50.00 for each occupancy or tenant space.
2) Grease traps: An additional fee of $50.00 shall be assessed for each grease
trap.
CDES Financial Administration, rev] 1/]3/07 lw
page 12
3) The cost for retrofit piping shall be computed at the minimum fee of $50.00
per floor for each main riser.
(', C1 .-l~ ItOn"1 r-,,',-, 1nl!
'November 27, 2007
Page 18 of 50
4) The cost ofa permit for lawn sprinkler systems shall be computed using the dollar valuation as shown under
Section M of this Resolution.
5) The minimum plumbing permit fee shall be $50.00.
Q) MECHANICAL PERMIT FEES
1) The following fee calculations shall be applied separately when the permit involves mixed occupancies.
a. Residential occupancies: The mechanical permit fees shall be computed at the rate of $50.00 for each living
unit up to three tons of air conditioning. Each additional ton or part thereof shall be $3.00 per ton.
b. Nonresidential occupancies: The mechanical permit fees shall be computed by one of the following
methods, whichever is calculated to be the greatest fee: The rate of$50.00 for the first three tons or three
horsepower of air conditioning or other mechanical systems per tenant space, each additional ton of air
conditioning or horsepower shall be $3.00; or The rate of $3.00 per 425 square feet of floor area, or
fraction thereof.
2) The cost of retrofit piping shall be computed at the minimum fee of $50.00 per floor for each cooling tower, or .
$50.00 for the first 3 horsepower and $3.00 for each additional horsepower, whichever is greater.
3) The minimum mechanical permit fee shall be $50.00.
4) A permit for the change out of components shall be calculated at the above mechanical permit fee rate or the
minimum fee whichever is greater.
R) FIRE PREVENTION AND CONTROL PERMIT FEES
1) The fees and exemptions set forth in the "Exhibit B" affixed hereto and made a
part of this Schedule of Development Review and Building Permit Fees shall
apply to Fire Prevention and Control Permits for both the independent and
dependent fire districts.
S) MOBILE HOME/OFFICE TRAILER AND OTHER TRAILER PERMIT FEES
1) The permit fee shall be $50.00 to set-up a single-wide trailer or mobile
home on an approved site plus electrical, plumbing, mechanical and fire
protection fees as applicable.
2) The pemlit fee shall be $75.00 to set-up a double wide or larger mobile
homes on an approved site plus electrical, plumbing, mechanical and fire
protection fees as applicable.
T) CHICKEES AND SIMILAR STRUCTURES
I) The permit fee will be based upon a calculated cost of construction of $4.00
per square foot under roof or the contractor1s estimated cost of construction,
whichever is greater. The fee will then be calculated in accordance with
Section N of this Resolution. Additional permit fees for electric, plumbing,
mechanical, fire, etc., will be charged when applicable.
U) POOL OR SPA PERMIT FEES
1) For construction of each public pool or spa the fee shall be-
a. Valuation of construction costs of up to $4,999.99. $100.00
CDES Financial Administration, rev 1I/13!07 lw
page 13
L."on~:;' i+""n-, r'i~, 1('1 f
l~ovemDet' 27, 200 i
b. Valuation of construction costs of$5000.00 through $49.999.99: $80.00 plus $7.00 per thousam""lErl1Eltlil.o' 5(:
or fraction thereof, of building valuation in excess of$2,000.00.
c. Valuation of construction costs of $50,000.00 through $1.000,000.00: $333,00 plus $3.00 per thousand
dollars, or fraction thereof. of building valuation in excess of $50,000.00.
d. Valuation of construction costs over $1.000,000.00: $3~474.00 plus S3.00 per thousand dollars. or fraction
thereof, of building valuation in excess of$1.000,000.00.
2) For construction of each private pool or spa the fee shall be: S100.00
V) SCREEN ENCLOSURE PERMIT & PAN ROOF FEES
1) Construction costs shall be calculated as follows:
a. Screen Roof. $2.00 per sq. ft. of 1100r area. (Screen Walls Only)
b. Pan Roof. $3.00 per sq. ft. of 1100r area. (Screen Walls Only)
c. Existing Roof. $2.00 per sq. ft. of 1100r area. (Screen Walls Only)
2) The screen enclosure or roof fee will then be calculated in accordance with Section N of this Resolution.
W) SIGN PERMIT FEES
1) Sign permit fees will be calculated in accordance with all applicable Building Permit Fees and Electrical
Permit Fees outlined in this document, the Collier County Development Fee Schedule The minimum building
permit fee for sign shall be $75.00.
2) Multiple signs of the same type (i.e., wall signs) and for a single project may be allowed per one pemlit.
however an appropriate fee shall he charged for each sign in accordance with the schedule set forth in the
above subsection 1 of Sign Pemlit Fees.
Xl CONVENIENCE PERMIT FEES
1) Convenience pemlits are issued in blocks of 10 each. Only licensed contractors are eligible to purchase
convenience permits. Convenience permits are limited to the use specified on the permit. The fee for a book
of 10 convenience permits is S400.00.
Yl REVISION AND AS BUILT PLAN REVIEW FEES; CORRECTIONS TO PLANS
I) PERMIT AND PLAN REVISIONS The fee for each permit revision submitted after permit issuance shall be
calculated using fee schedules outlined in Sections N through R above. The minimum permit fee for revisions
to pennitted projects shall be $50.00.
2) AS BUILT PLANS The fee for "As Built" plan review shall be ten (10.;'.) percent of the original building
permit fee or $150.00, whichever is greater, but shall not exceed S500.00. The fee is intended to cover the cost
of reviewing amended building plans in the office to determine that change orders and various field changes
are in compliance with the minimum construction and fire codes of Collier County. The following arc required
for as-built drawings review:
a. An itemized list of all changes made after permit plan approval.
b. As-built plans that have al] changes made after pennit plan approval
"clouded".
c. As-built plans and changes shall be signed and sealed by the engineer
and/or architect of record.
3) CORRECTIONS TO PLANS
a. First Correction to Plans. No charge
b. Second Correction to Plans. $75.00
c. Third & subsequent correction to plans. S100.00
(,DES Financial Administration, rev] 1/13/07 Iw page 14
Z) PERMIT EXTENSION
1) The filing fee for each permit extension shall be equal to 10% of the original
building permit fee or $100.00, whichever is greater, but shall not exceed
$500.00. The filing fee is intended to cover the cost of reviewing existing or
amended building plans to determine and verify code compliance
b..,""'D.....,...~ Ir~m hi" 1 nl I
'November 17, 2007
Page 20 of 50
AA) DEMOLITION OF BUILDING OR STRUCTURE PERMIT FEES
1) The permit fee shall be $50.00 for the demolition of any building or structure.
BB) PRE-MOVING INSPECTION FEES
1) The fee shall be $150.00 for the pre-moving inspection of any building or
structure.
CC) INSPECTION FEES
1) A charge of $20.00 per inspection shall be assessed for inspections for which
a permit is not necessary.
2) A user fee of $120.00 shall be assessed for all inspections on a
time specified basis.
3) First Partial inspection for single-family & tenant buildout. No charge
4) Second & subsequent partial inspections for single-family & tenant buildout. $25.00
DD) REINSPECTION FEES
1) Re-inspections for any type ofbuilding permit, or required Engineering re-inspections, shall result in
an additional fee of$75.00 per inspection for the first re~inspection, $100.00 for the second re~
inspection and $125.00 for the third and each successive re~inspection.
EE) FAILURE TO OBTAIN A PERMIT
J) Where work for which a permit is required is started or proceeded with prior to obtaining said permit and
where such action ,",,'as cited by Code Enforcement or by Contractor Licensing and resulted in a finding of
violation from either the Code Enforcement Board, the Special Magistrate, or the Contractor Licensing
Board, or as directed by the Board of County Commissioners the fees herein specified shall be 4x the
regular fee.
2) \Vhere work for which a permit is required is started or proceeded with prior to obtaining said permit and
where a contractor or agent/provider where the building official or zoning director (for cases involving land
development) deems that the contractor/provider should have known that a permit was required but
voluntary seeks compliance by obtaining the necessary permits to abate the violation the fees herein
specified shall be 2x the regular fee.
3) Where work for which a permit is required is started or proceeded with prior to obtaining said permit and
where an owner/builder seeks voluntary compliance by obtaining said permit the fees assessed will be 2x
the regular rate as defined in this fee schedule.
4) Where work for which a pemlit is required is started or proceeded with prior to obtaining said permit and
where the unpermitted work was completed by other or prior to the current owner/builder's ownership
of the property an where the current owner/builder seeks voluntary compliance by obtaining said permit to
assure compliance with all applicable codes the fees will be assessed at the regular rate as defined in this
fee schedule.
-
5) The payment of such fee shall not relieve any person from fully complying with the requirements of any
applicable construction code or ordinance in the execution of the work, or from any penalty prescribed
within any construction code, law or ordinance of Collier County.
(,DES Financial Administration, rev 11113/07 Iw
page 15
Lnon"::' Itc. t,;" 1nll
November 27. 2007
Page 21 of 50
FF) LICENSING
1) The fee for licensing items is as follows:
a. Letters of Reciprocity. $25.00
b. Contractors Change of Status. (active to dormant) SI0.00'
c. Voluntary Registration of State Certified Contractors. S10.00
d. Pictures. $2.00
e. Laminating S1.00 (per license)
f Fee for a 6 month temporary contractor's license $25.00
g. Certified copies of Experience letters $35.00
h. Duplicate or replacement (of Competency cards) $25.00
J. Second entity application fee $50.00
2)
Certificated of Competency (Annual)
a. Contractor
Initial License Fee
Renewal Fee
b. Specialty Contractor
Initial License Fee
Renewal Fee
c. Journeyman
Initial License Fee
Renewal Fee
$150.00
$100.00
$135.00
$85.00
$50.00
$25.00
3) Donnant Celtificates of Competency (Annual)
a. Contractor $100.00
b. Specialty Contractor S85.00
c. Penalty fees after 9/30 $10.00 per month until 12/31
4) Reinstatement of Delinquent License
3. Contractor
b. Specialty Contractor
c. Journeyman
d. Examination Administrative Fee
$150.00 plus back years
$135.00 plus back years
$50.00 plus back years
$100.00 good for 6 months
GG) DUPLICATE PERMIT CARDS
]) The fee shall he $5.00 for the issuance of a duplicate penn it card for
whatever reason.
HH) CHANGE OF CONTRACTOR OR SUBCONTRACTORS
I) To record a change of contractor or subcontractor, on a permit that has been
issued, the fee shall be $50.00. This fee includes the issuance of a new
permit card.
II) PERMIT FEE REFUNDS
1) If requested, in writing by the owner or his authorized agent. 50'Yo of the fees
charged, other than the application fee. may be refunded provided that a
permit has been issued, construction has not commenced, and the refund is
applied for prior to the cancellation of the permit.
JJ) RECORD RETRIEVAL
1) No charge for retrieving records from inactive or remote storage including
microfilmed documents
(,DES Financial Administration, rev 11/13/07 Iw
page 16
6.np.nd~ Itom f\i" 1 nl I
November 27, 2007
Page 22 of 50
KK) COPY FEES
1) The fee for blueprint and miscellaneous copying shall be as follows:
a. Microfilm copies, of documents less than 11 x 17 inches: $0.15 other sizes at cost of production.
f. Microfilm or Blueprint copies:
18 X 24 $1.25 per page
30 X 36 $2.50 per page
30 X 42 $3.25 per page
34 X 44 $5.00 per page
g. Community Development self-service copier, public access and not related to public record retrieval
or public record copies: documents less than 14x8.5 inches $0.15 per page inclusive of sales tax.
LL)RESEARCH
] ) The fee for researching records, ordinances, and codes shall be at no charge for the first hour, then at the base
salary hourly rate of the staff member conducting the service for time in excess of 1 hour
2) The fee for creating and designing special computer generated reports that are not part of the regular standard
reports shall be at no charge for the first hOUL then at the base salary hourly rate of the staff member
conducting the service for time in excess of 1 hauL
MM) SUBSCRIPTION SERVICE
The fee for one-year subscription service to be mailed quarterly shall be
$15.00 per year. The subscnption year is from Oct. 1 through Sept. 30.
NN) ELECTRONIC DATA CONVERSION SURCHARGE
1) A surcharge in the amount of 30;(1 of the building permit application fee, with
the minimum surcharge being $3.00 and the maximum being $150.00, will be
applied to every building permit application submitted. A flat fee of$3.00
per permit will be charged for those permits for which an application fee is
not required per item (M) of this Schedule.
00) REGISTRATION OF RENTAL DWELLINGS
1) The fee for registration of rental dwellings is as follows:
a. Initial Registration Fee - $30.00/per property
b. Annual Renewal - $20.00!per property
c. Late Fee - $IO.OO/per day per property up to a maximum of $80.00
d. The term "property" means a parcel or contiguous parcels with any number of rental units
located thereupon under common ownership and/or management.
2) Rental Inspection
a. Rental Inspection - $200.00 per unit
b. Re-inspection Fee - $50.00 per re-inspection per unit.
c. Rental inspections shall not be required for rental units on property covered by a Florida Department
of Business and Professional Regulation ("DBPR") license. A copy of the current DBPR license
shall be provided with the initial rental registration and all subsequent rental renewal applications.
3) Any unpaid fees may be pursued by the Collier Manager or designee through a collection agency.
"-
PP) CERTIFICATE TO BOARD BUILDING
I) Initial Boarding Certificate - $0
2) Boarding Certificate Extension - $150
CDES financial Administration, rev I 1113/07 lw
page 17
An::..,,,:;: Itom t\'r, -; nl i
I-Jovember 2,7. 2007
Page 23 Of 50
QQ) ADDITIONAL FEE REFUND PROVISIONS
1) Requests for fee waivers may only be approved by the Board of County Commissioners. Waiver
requests for development review and building permit fees shall be submitted in writing directly to the
appropriate Community Development & Environmental Services Division Staff, who will prepare an
executive summary for consideration by. the Board. Such requests shall include a statement
indicating the reason for the fee waiver request and, if applicable. the nature of the organization
requesting the fee waiver.
RR) REFUND PROVISIONS
I) PAYMENT OF FEES: Full payment of fees is reqUIred for a complete application. Department
policy requires full payment of fees at the time of application submittal. No work will begin on staff
review of the application until all fees are paid in full. If full payment of fees is not received within
14 calendar days of application submittal, the application will be considered void. At this point. a
new application and full payment of fees will be required to proceed with a project.
:2) There wi]] be no refund of Planning, Environmental, or Engineering related fees, except those
applications which have been deemed not sufficient for staff revie\v and are withdrawn within 30
days of notification will be entitled to a 50%1 refund. After 30 days from such notification, there will
be no refund of submitted fees.
3) In no cases will there be refunds for pre-application fees. data conversion fees, appeals of
administrative decisions. or appeals to the Board of Zoning Appeals or Building Board of
Adjustment.
4) If staff en'or causes the inappropriate or unnecessary filing of an application and payment of fees.
100 percent of all inappropriate fees, shall be refunded upon written request and with the concurrence
of Department management.
SS) ADDITIONAL FEE PROVISIONS
1) In tnose cases where alternative methods or timing of payments for CDES services and ,/ or fees
listed in this schedule associated with SBR reviews are deemed to best serve the public good, the
Community Development and Environmental Services Administrator will nave the authority to
approve such alternatives. Such alternative must be in writing and signed by all principals involved.
In no case shall final e.O. or such certifications of project completeness be issued until payments due
CDES are received in full.
2) All hourly fees are computed and charged from actual Divisional time tracking records.
3) All acreage totals used in fee calculations will be rounded up to the nearest whole acre.
4) When deemed essential for project review or approval. there will be no additional charge for any
meetings requested by CDES staff.
TT) PUBLIC VEHICLE FOR HIRE FEES
1) The following fees shall be assessed for the Public Vehicle for Hire Program:
a. Initia] Application fee (new Companies). $200
b. Initial Certificate to Operate (Feb ].Jan 3]). $325.00
c. Annual Certificate to Operate Renewal $325.00
d. Late Fee for CTO Renewal $200.00
CDES Financial Administration, rev 1 1/13/07 lw
page IH
UrTon",:=! I+orr. t ir, 1 ill I
e.
Sub-Certificate Application Fee (New Companies) - $100.00
Sub-Certificate - $125.00
Annual Sub-Certificate renewal - $125.00
Late Fee for Sub-Certificate Renewal - $100.00
Vehicle Decal - $50.00
I. Temporary Vehicle Decal $5.00 per vehicle/per day
k. Temporary Vehicle Decal (In case of inoperable decaled vehicle) - $5.00/per vehicle
I. Driver Identification Card (InitiallRenewal) - $75.00 per driver
m. 2nd Driver Identification Card - $25.00
Replacement Driver ID - $10.00
On-site Vehicle Permitting - $15.00 per vehicle
~November 27. 2007
Page 24 of 50
f.
g.
h.
1.
n.
o.
UU)"P A YMENT IN LIEU OF" FEE FOR P A THW A YS (SIDEWALKS, AND BIKE LANES)
1) Calculated using the current Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) construction costs or an
engineering estimate not to exceed twenty-five percent (25%) of the submitted application request's total
project cost.
This is the last page of the CDES Fee Schedule
CDES Financial Admini~tration, rev 11113/07 lw
page 19
"
[;;;~ ;
I;,.no :':;.', Iron'^' i.I'-, 1 i I
'!'\iovenlbe,- :1", 2007
Page 25 of 50
c
"
r
c
"
u
M
L
y
EXHIBIT C
STRIKE-THROUGHS AND UNDERLINES
COLLIER COUNTY COMMUNITY
ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
DEVELOPMENT AND
FEE SCHEDULE
Bee Proposed version, November 27, 2007
Contents:
A) ADMIN1STRA TION._....
B) BLASTING PERMITS & INSPECTION..
C) ENVIRONMENTAL/LA NOSe APING..
0) EXCAVATION PERMITS..
E) FIRE CODE RFVIE\V FEES...
F) SITE DEVELOPMENT PI At\iS .
G) SUBDIVISION ,.
H) ENGINEERING INSPECTION FEES..
I) TEMPORARY USE PERMITS..
.I) WELL PERMITS/INSPECTIONS..
K} ZONING/LAND LISE PETITIONS..
I.) MISCELLANEOUS..
M) BUILDING PERMIT APPJ.lCAflON FEE..
N) BUILDING PERMIT FEES..
0) ELECTRICAL PERMIT FEES ,.
P) PLUMBING PERMIT FEES..
QJ MECHANICAL PERMIT FEES..
R) FIRE PREVENTION AND CONTROL PERMJl FEES..
S) MOBILE HOME/OFFICE TRAILER AND OTlIER TRAILI::J{ PERMIT FEES.
T) CH]CKEES AND S]MILAR STRUCTURES
lI) POOL OR SPA PERMIT FEES.
V) SCREEN ENCLOSURE PERMIT & PAN ROOF FEES _. .
W) S]GN.PERM]T FEES..
X) CONVENIENCE PERMIT FEES..
'{) REVIS]ON AND AS 8UILT PLAN REV]EW FEES; CORRECTIONS TO Pl.ANS...
Z) PERMIT EXTENSION _.
Ai\) DEMOLIT]ON OF BUILDING OR STR1ICTlJRE PERM]T FEES.
BB) PRE-MOVING INSPECT]ON FEES..
CC) INSPECT]ON FEES..
DO) REINSPECT]ON FEES.
EE) FA]LURE TO OBTAIN A PERMIT.
FF) LICENSING _....
GO) DUPLICATE PERMIT CARDS_.
HH) CHANGE OF CONTRACTOR OR SUBCONTRACTORS
11) PERMIT FEE REFUNDS.
.!.I)-RECORD RETRIEV AL..
KKI COPY FEES..
LLI RESEARCH..
MM) SUBSCR]PTION SERVICE_.
NN) ELECTRONIC DATA CONVERSION SURCHARGE-...
00) REG]STRATIO)\; OF RENT AL DWELLINGS..
PP) CERT]F]CA TE TO BOARD B]LUNG .
QQ) ADDlT]ONAL FEE REFUND PROVISIONS..
RR) REFUND PROV]S]ONS..
SS) ADDITIONAL FEE PROV]SIONS..
Tl) PUBLIC VEHICLE FOR H]RE FEES.
UU) "PAYMENT]N LIEU OF.. FEE FOR PATHWAy.S (SIDE\\/ALKS. AND BIKE LANES).
............................ ...2
..........__._..........2
. ...... ........ .......... ........... ........................ ........................2
. ......... ..................... ........... ................. ...... ..... ....3
. .........................................................................._A
...... . ... ........ .......... ........ ......... ......__........ __........... ..... 4
.....................................................__.........__.....__.__._...........__....................5
. ...................... .......... ...... ........................................6
......____.....____...__...... 6
....................... .................................................7
. . .....__..___.................. 7-1\
........ ......... ........ ......... ...... .. ................9
.......................11
.................11
...... ......... ................ ... ..................... ...... .... ..12
......]2
............ ............ .........................................13
.-----...........-... ..............]]
..... .......... ............................................................]3
. ..... ............. . ..... . ........ .... .................... ... ................14
._...............................]4
.. ........ .................. ........ .............................._14
...__.._.__......... ..........__.........14
.................. .......... ..... ........ .................................14
..............................14
.... ........................................................15
... .............. ................................._................................!5
............................. ........................................!5
.. ...........................................__.......................................15
.................. .....................................................]5
......]5
.... ................ ........ ...... ............ ....... .................. ]6
16
.. ............................................................17
....................... .......................................................]7
.............................................................................................17
..... .................................................................17
.. ...................... ..... ..............................................]6
17
... ..................................................................................17
.. .._17
..... ...........18
........................18
. ...JR
.........18
._18
................ ...........]9
Fees are in bold
CDES Financia] Administration, rev] ] /13/07 Iw
page 1
/'.""10 r-!" Ite ; "in 1n \
l,ovembe, 27.2007
Page 26 of 50
FEES ARE ESTABLISHED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS RESOLUTION, AND CANNOT
BE WAIVED OR SUSPENDED WITHOUT AN ACTION BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMlSSIONERS.
ANY QUESTIONS CONCERNING THE APPLICABILITY OF FEES SHALL BE CONCLUSIVELY
DETERMINED BY THE DIRECTOR OF THE APPROPIA TE DEPARTMENT, AS APPLICABLE. WHERE AS
PART OF A REZONING, PLAT OR SIMILAR APPLICATION TYPE, THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS DIRECTS APPROVAL OF FUTURE DEVELOPMENT ORDERS DIFFERENT FROM THE
STANDARD TYPE OF APPROVAL PROCESSES REQUIRED, THE DIRECTOR OF THE APPROPRIATE
DEPARTMENT SHALL DETERMINE THE FEES TO BE APPLIED TO THE PROCESS NECESSARY TO MEET
THE BOARDS REQUIREMENTS. THE APPLICABLE FEES SHALL BE THOSE WHICH MOST CLOSELY
RESEMBLE THOSE CHARGED FOR SIMILAR PROCESSES INCLUDING EXTRA FEES FOR ADVERTISING
AND THE LIKE.
A) ADMINISTRATION
I) Official Interpretation Request of Land Development Code (LDC), Growth Management Plan (GMP), or
Building Construction Administrative Code (Administrative Code). Based on staff hours: Less than 20 hours
$1,500.00. 20 to 40 hours $3,000.00, more than 40 hours $5,000.00
2) InteflJretation request submitted in conjunction wifh a land use petition or requested during site development
plan review process. $250.00
3) Determination ofYested Rights. $100.00 (plus the County's out-of-pocket expenses associated with hearing
officer and hearings)
4) Appeal of Vested Rights Determination. $100.00
5) Amendment to Land Development Code. $3.000.00
6) Appeal of an Administrative Decision (as may be provided for in the Collier County Administrative Code or
the LDC). $1000.00 (non-refundable)
7) Appeal to Board of Zoning Appeals or Building Board of Adjustments and Appeals (as may be provided for in
the Collier County Administrative Code or the LDC). $1,000.00 (non-refundable)
B) BLASTING PERMITS & INSPECTION
I) 30 day permit fee, non-refundable payable upon application. $250.00
2) 90 day permit fee, non-refundable payable upon application. $600,00
3) Yearly permit fee, non-refundable payable upon application. $1.500.00
4) Renewal permit fee, non-refundable payable upon application. $200.00
5) After-the-fact fee, due to blasting without a permit. $10,000.00
6) Fine fee, per detonated shot with after-the-fact permit. $200.00
7) Handler fee, for handler who assists the user or blaster in the use of explosives. $]00.00
8) Blasting Inspection Fee. $200.00 (per inspection)
9) Inspection fees shal1 be paid upon issuance of a blasting permit based on the estimated number of
blasts. Upon completion, fees will be adjusted to reflect actual number of blasts.
C) ENVIRONMENTALILANDSCAPING
1) Site Clearing Permit. first acre or fraction of an acre. $250.00 Each additional acre or fraction of
an acre. $50.00 ($3,000.00 maximum)
.-
CDES Financial Administration, rev 1 ] 1\ 3/07 lw
pagel
L. nDn'"'? !Tom t\ir. 1 nl i
l"Jovernber 2/.2007
2) Agricultural Land Clearing ;:)aCl8 27 of 58
a. Land Clearing Notification $250.00
b. Land Clearing Pennit S250.00 each additional acre or fraction of an acre. S50.00 (S3,000.00
maximum)
3) Landscape Tree Removal Fee $250
4) Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) $2,500.00 for I st submittal and 2nd submittal if applicable,
3rd submittal SI,OOO.OO, 4th and subsequent submittals $500.00 each
5) Landscape Re-inspection l~t $50.00, 2nd $75.00. eveI)' inspection aften.vard $100.00
6) Vehicle on the Bcach Pennit Application. S250.00 (Pennit fee shall be waived for public and
non-profit organizations engaging in environmental activities for scientific. conservation or
educational purposes).
7) Beach Nourishment Penn its - S400
R) Special Treatment Review
a. First five acres or less. S400.00
b. Each additional acre, or fraction thereof. S50.00 ($5.000.00 Maximum)
c. Pre-application meetimr $250.00 (to be credited toward application fee upon submittal) .
9) Coastal Construction Setback Line (CCSL):
a. CCSL Penn its S400.00
b. Variance - Petillon. S1000.00
10) Sea Turtle Permit-
a. Sea Turtle Handling Permits. $25.00
b. Sea Turtle Nesting Area Construction Pemlit. $200.00
c. Sea Turtle Nest Relocation. S100.00
11 ) Vegetation Removal Pennit
a. First acre or fraction of an acre less. $250.00
b. Each additional acre, or fraction thereof. $50.00 ($3.000.00 Maximum)
12) After-the-fact Environmental or Landscape Pennits
a. CCSL Variance Petition. 2x normal fee
b. All other Environmental or Landscape Pennits. 4x normal fee
13) Infonnal Wetland Jurisdictional detennination for simIle family parcels up to 5 acres - $300.00
14) Conservation Easement review fee - $300.00 application fee plus the following additional site fee:
$200.00 for CE acres less than 5 acres: $400.00 for CE area between 5 acres and 10 acres: S600.00
for CE area greater than 10 acres and less than 20 acres; $800.00 for CE areas between 20 and 50
acres: and an additional S200.00 for every 40 acres of CE area over 50 acres.
IS) Listed or Protected Species review fee (when an EIS is not required) - $1000.00
D) EXCAVATION PERMITS
1) Annual Renewal. S300.00
2) Application (Private). S400.00
3) Application (Commercial). $2,000.00
4) Application (Development). S400.00
5) $1,0.00 S200.00 per inspection paid in advance for 12 months
6) Reapplication: $300.00 plus $200.00 per month inspection fee
7) Cubic Yardage Review Fee: S200.00 first 5000 cy, plus $10.00 per additional 1000 cy with a
maximum of $20.000.00
8) Time Extension. S150.00 plus $200.00 per month inspection fee
CDES Financial Administration. rev 11/13/07 Iw
page 3
[,""0.'-" :::I hAm J\in 1(111
1~ overnDer 27. 2007
9) After-the-fact Excavation Permit. 4x application fee Page 28 of 50
10) Over excavation penalty fee per vard. Plus PermitlReviev...' $0.05 oer cubic vard fee. unless maximum
have been paid.
.-
E) FIRE CODE REVIEW FEES
I) Fire Code Review fees associated with each of the following processes:
a. SDP - Site Development Plan
b. SDPA - Site Development Plan, Amendment
c. SDPI - Site Development Plan, Insubstantial
d. SIP ~ Site Improvement Plan
e. SIPl - Site Improvement Plan, Insubstantial
f. PSP ~ Preliminary Subdivision Plans
g. PSP A - Preliminary Subdivision Plans. Amendment
h. PPL - Plans & Plat. Subdivision
i. FP - Final Plat
J. CONSTR - Construction Plans, Subdivision/Utilities
k. fCr - Construction Plans. Insubstantial
1. DRl - Development of Regional Impact
m. DOA - Development Order, Amendment
n. PUDZ - Planned Unit Development, Rezone
o. PUDA - Planned Unit Development, Amendment
p. PDI - Planned Unit Development, Insubstantial
q. RZ - Rezone, Regular Zoning
r. Cll - Conditional Use
F) SITE DEVELOPMENT PLANS
I) Site Development Plan Review (SDP). $5000.00
$200.00
$150.00
$100.00
$150.00
$100.00
$150.00
$100.00
$100.00
$100.00
$100.00
$100.00
$200.00
$150.00
$150.00
$150.00
$100.00
$100.00
$150.00
a. plus $40.00 per DIU
b. plus $100.00 per residential building structure
c. plus $.10 per square foot for non-residential except that structures designed exclusively for parking
(parking garages) shall be calculated at $.05 per square foot.
d. plus $200.00 per building for non-residential
e. Additional fees for y<1 review $1,000.00, 41h review $1,500.00, 51h review $2,000.00, 61h and
subsequent reviews $2,500.00
When a building consist of both residential and non-residential (commercial. retail. office) uses. the following
fees will apolv.
a. $5000.00 base fee plus $40.00 per DIU
b. $200.00 per building for non-residential
c. plus $0.10 oer square foot of non-residential floor area
d. Additional fees for 3" review $1.000.00. 4'" review $1.500.00. 5'" review $2.000.00. 6'" and subsequent
reviews $2.500.00
2) Pre-application fee. $500.00 (to be credited toward application fce upon submittal.)
a. Second and subsequent pre-app meetings at the applicant's request shall not be
credited towards application fees.
b. Second and subsequent pre-app meetings at staffs request will be held at no charge
to thc applicant.
c. Applications submitted 9 months or more after the date of the last pre-app meeting
shall not be credited towards application fees and a new pre-application meeting
will be required.
3) Simultaneous Review Fee (planning review of simultaneous building permit applications) $100.00 per building
permit application.
CDES Financial Administration, rev 1]/13/07 \w
page 4
,6;("1;:::,.....,....:;. I~o.v. fUn 1nj
~Novembei 2.7. 200
Pa;18 29 of 5
4) Site Development Plan Insubstantial Change
a. Site Development Plan Insubstantial Change. S400.00 for first sheet. SIOO.OO for each and every
additional sheet submitted.
b. Additional fees for yd reviev.' S1,000.00, 41h Review $1,500.00, Silo and subsequent review
$2.000.00
5) Site Ds' elepmeRt PlaR CSfl6ef3tHal Rs', ie'" t:!iO DQ Site Development Plan ConcePtual Review ((SP). Unified
Development Plan (UDP), Nei~hborhood Park Site (NPSP) $750.00
6) Site Improvement Plan Review (SIP). $1000.00 (plus Engineering review fees)
7) Utility Plan Review & Inspection Fees-
a. Construction Document Review. 0.750;(1 of probable water andior sewer construction costs
b. Construction Inspection. 2.25% of probable water and/or sewer construction costs
c. Construction Document Resubmission or Document Modification, submit as insubstantial change.
$150.00 for first sheet. $75.00 for each additional sheet
8) Engineering Site Plan Review Fee
a. Construction Documents Review Fee O,750;() of probable Paving, Grading, Drainage, Lighting, Code
Minimum Landscaping, and any other appurtenant cost of construction
b. Construction Inspection 2.25% of probable Paving, Grading, Drainage, Lighting, Code Minimum
Landscaping. and any other appurtenant cost of construction
9) Site Development Plan Amendment (SDPA) $2,500.00,
a. Plus $40.00 per DiU plus $]00.00 per residential building structure
b. plus $.10 per square foot
c. plus $200.00 per building for non-residential
d. Additional fees for 3rd review Sl,OOO.OO. 4th Review Sll500.00, 5th and subsequent review
$2,000.00
10) SBR Fees
a) Pre-Acquisition Meeting $500.00 (no refunds or credits)
b) Pre-application fee. $500.00 (to be credited toward application fee upon submitta1.) (all normal pre-
application provisions apply)
c) SBR Fee $5000.00 with hourly reconciliation at project completion for hourly variation greater than
10%, final project charges at S100.00 per hour for all associated staff hours
11) Violation of the conditions of approval of the SDP/SIP or installation of improvements, clearing, or other
land alteration not depicted on, or othenvise authorized as a part of the approved SDP/SIP. 4x the SIP/SDP
application fee
12) Request for alternative architectural design $500.00, no separate or additional fee for appeals to, or requests
for assistance from, the Architectural Arbitration Board.
G) SUBDIVISION
I) Lot Line Adjustment (LLA) and Lot Split Review $250.00
2) Subdivision Review Fees (PPL), (PPLA)-
a. Construction Documents Review Fee 0.750/0 of probable Paving, Grading, Drainage, Lighting, Code
Minimum Landscaping and any other appurtenant cost of construction
b. Subdivision Inspection Fee 2.25% of probable Paving, Grading, Drainage, Lighting, Code Minimum
Landscaping. and any other appurtenant cost of construction
c. Construction Document Resubmission or Document Modification -Submit as Insubstantial Change
$1;;0.00 $400.00 for first sheet. m.oo- $100.0(1 for each additional sheet
CDES Financial Administration, rev Il/l3/07 Iw
page 5
lInonrl~ 1+0""'""' t..l" ~ nil
~Novernber 27. 2007
d. Subdivisions - 3rd and subsequent additional reviews - $500.00 ?age 30 of 50
e. Subdivisions - Substantial deviations from approval construction documentl.j $500.00
3) Subdivision, Preliminary Plat (PSP)-
a. Petition Application $1000.00 plus $5.00 per acre (or fraction thereof) for residential, plus $10.00
per acre (or fraction thereof) for non-residential; (mixed use is residential)
4) Subdivision Final Plat (FP) $1,000.00 plus $5.00 per acre (or fraction thereof) for residential, $1000.00 plus
S10.00 per acre (or fraction thereof) for nonresidential; (mixed use is residential)
5) Additional review of construction plans for phased construction of subdivision improvements. $1000.00 per
phase
6) Two-year Extension $150.00
7) Water and Sewer Facilities Construction Document Review 0.750/0 of probable water and/or sewer
construction costs
8) Construction Document Resubmission or Document Modification 0.250/0 of probable water and/or sewer
construction costs
a. 3rd and subsequent re-submittals - S500.00
9) Vlater and Sewer Facilities Construction Inspection Fee 2.250';;) of probable water and/or sewer construction
costs
-
10) Violation of the conditions of approval of approved construction plans or installation of improvements.
clearing, or other land alteration not depicted on. or otherwise authorized as a pali of the approved
construction plans or permit. 4x the PPL, PPLA, PSP, CNSTR or Final Plat Review Fee (FP).
11) Administrative Amendment $250.00
H) ENGINEERING INSPECTION FEES
1) Engineering Inspection Fee 5150.00 per residential dwelling unit or accessory structure to
residential dwelling unit (single or duplex only), charged at time of building permit
issuance.
2) Re-inspection Fees: ] sl re-inspection $75.00, 2nd re-inspection 5100.00, 3rd and thereafter re-
inspection $125.00
I) TEMPORARY USE PERMITS
I) Beach Events Permits-
a. Individual Permit $100.00
b. Block of 25 calendar days $2.250.00
c. Block of 50 calendar days $4,500.00
d. Block of75 calendar days $6,750.00
e. Block of 100 calendar days $9,000.00
f. Block of 125 calendar days $11,250.00
g. Block of 150 calendar days $13,500.00
2) Temporary Use Permit Special Sales & Events. $200.00
3) Model Homes and Sales Centers $500.00
CDES Financial Administration, rev 11l13/071w
page 6
.G.""onr-!;:o It""rn fin 1 (11 i
November 27. 2007
4) Construction and Development, Mobile home, Agricultural Zoning. and Temporary use for "C5m~31 of 50
Soon'l sign $125.00
5) Residential and Non~Profit Garage and Yard Sale Permits No Charge
6) Temporary Use Amendment. $100.00
7) Renewals or extensions requested after the expiration date $200.00
8) Temporary Use Pemlit for Special Events requiring Bce approvaL including Circus and Carnival
Permits. $275.00
9) Political Signs (Bulk Temporary Permit) $5.00
10) Fees for Temporary Use permits issued After the Fact ATF: 2x nonnal fee
J) WELL PERMITSIlNSPECTlONS
I) Hydraulic elevator shaft permit $300.00
2) Test hole permit (including 1st six holes) $300.00. each additional hole $20.00
3) Well permit (abandonment) $50.00
4) Vlell penn;t (construction, repair, or combined construction and abandonment at one site) $300.00
5) Well pem1it (monitoring) $150.00
6) Well Pernlit(modification of monitor/test well to a production well) $75.00
7) Well Reinspections
3. first Reinspection
b. Second Reinspection
c. Third Reinspection
$75.00
$100.00
$150.00
R) After the fact well permits 4x nomml fee per violation.
NOTE: Multiple v"clls may be allowed on one pennit, but each well must be
accounted for and the appropriate fee shall be charged for each well in
accordance with the above listed schedule.
K) ZONING/LAND USE PETITIONS
1) Pre-application meeting fee $500.00 (to be credited toward application fee upon submittal.)
a. Second and subsequent pre~app meetings at the applicant"s request shall not be credited towards
application fees.
b. Second and subsequent pre~app meetings at staft's request will be held at no charge to the applicant.
c. Applications submitted 9 months or more after the date of the last pre~app meeting shall not be
credited towards application fees and a new pre~application meeting will be required.
2) Alcoholic Beverage or Service Station Separation Requirement Waiver $]000.00
3) Boat Dock Extension Petition $1,500.00 Boat Lift Canopv Administrative Review $500.00
4) Conditional Use Permit $4,000.00 when filled with Rezone Petition ($1,500.00) Additional fee for 5'" and
subsequent reviews - 200/0 of orilIinal fee.
5) Conditional Use Monitoring Review: $750.00
6) Conditional Use Extension $3,000.00
CDES Financial Administration. rev] 1/13/07 lw
page 7
r 0. ,,.;';' Ito "1 l\lr 1nt I
November 27. 2007
7) DR! Review (In addition to cost of rezone) $10,000.00 plus $25.00 aD acre (or fraction thereof) AdClllionaJ):fu"f 50
for 51h and subsequent reviews - 200/0 of original fee. Amendments deemed to be minor in nature. that is
requiring minor strike thm and underline text amendments of no more than lO different lines of text changes
in the DR! will be capped at $13,000.00. Anv amendment which includes a map and text change will be
assessed tbe full fee (no cap).
8) DRIIDO Amendment $6,000.00 plus $25.00 per acre (or fraction thereof). The acreage charge does not apply
for amendments which only change the build-out date of the DO for a time period of less than five years.
9) DRlABN - DRI Abandonment $1,500.00
10) Flood Variance Petition $1000.00
11) Interim Agriculture Use Petition $350.00
12) Non-Conforming Use Change/Alteration $1,500.00
13) Parking Exemption $1,500.00. Additional fee for 51h and subsequent reviews 200/0 of original fee.
14) Parking Reduction (Administrative) $500.00
15) Rezone Petition (PUD to PUD): $8,000.00 plus $25.00 an acre (or fraction thereof) (Requires a submittal of a
new PUD document)
16) Property owner notifications: ~ $1.50 non-certified maiL $3.00 certified return receipt mail (Petitioner to
pay this amount prior to advertisement of petition)
.-
17) Planned Unit Development Amendments ("Hs:taAtial)(PUD) $6,000.00 plus $25.00 an acre or fraction ~
of an acre. (Substantial changes to the text and Master Plan). Additional fee for 51h and subsequent reviews-
20'Ytl of original fee. Text changes that do not impact the Master Plan $6.000.00 (the $25.00 an acre fee will
not applv). Amendments deemed to be minor in nature. that is requirine minor strike thru and underline
amendments of no more than 10 different lines of text changes in the PUD will be capped at $9.000.00. Any
amendment which includes a man and text change will be assessed the full fee (no cap).
18) Planned Unit Development Amendment - Insubstantial (PDT) $1,500.00 requires a hearing bv the cepc only
for a minor change to tbe PUD Master Plan. PUD Minor Change (PMC) $1.000.00 (Administrative Review
for minor change to the Master Plan)
19) Rezone Petition (Regular) $6,000.00 plus $25.00 an acre (or fraction thereof), Additional fee for 5'" and
subsequent reviews - 200/u of original fee.
20) Rezone Petition (to PUD) $10,000.00 plus $25.00 an acre (or fraction tbereof). Additional fee for 5'" and
subsequent reviews - 20lYo of original fee.
21) Street Name Change (Platted) $500.00 plus $1.00 for each property owner requiring notification of proposed
street name change
22) Un-platted street name or project name change: $100.00 per application fee plus $50.00 per additional hour or
Partial hour of research required to process application, not to exceed $500.00
23) Variance petition: $2,000.00 residential, $5,000.00 non- residential. Additional fee for Slh and subsequent
Reviews - 200/0 of original fee.
24) Variance (Administrative) $1,000.00
25) Zoning Certificate: Residential: $50.00, Commercial:$125.00
26) PUD Extension - Sun Setting: $1000.00
CDES Financial Administration, rev 1 I II 3/07 lw
page 8
27) Sign Variance Petition: $2000.00
1.:. ;::::. ,--1;::, lie. J\.i" 1nll
l~CJvembe: 2 ( ^ 2007
;:'aoe 33 of 50
28) Stewardship Receiving Area Petition (SRA): $7000.00 per SRA plus $25.00 per acre for. Stewardship
Sending Area Petition (SSA): $9,500.00, Stewardship Receivim.>: Alternative Deviation Design (SRDD)
$500.00. SRA amendment~ deemed to be minor in nature. that is requiring minor strike thm and underline
text amendments of no more than 10 different lines of text chanaes in the SRA will be capped at
$10,000.
29) After~the~Facl Zoning/Land Use Petitions 2x the normal petition fee
30) Land Use Petition Continuances
a. Requested after petition has been advertised $500.00
b. Requested at the meeting $750.00
c. Resultant additional required advertising charged in addition to continuance fees.
31) PUD and SRA Monitoring (one-time charge at time of building pennit pick-up)
a. S+&OO-$IOO.OO per dwelling unit for residential constructiun within a PUD and SRA, ($3,000.00
maximum fee per building permit application)
b. ~ $0.12 per square foot for non-residential construction within a PUD and SRi\., ($2,999.gO
$3.000.00 maximum fee per building permit application)
32) Any legal advertising required during any CDES activity or approval process will be charged in addition to
stated fees, at actual costs. CDES reserves the right to charge an estimated amount with the initially required
project fees, and v.'ill reconcile and adjust such charges against actual legal advertising billings at the
completion of the project.
33) .^.EilTlinictrati' e Fe' ie" (miASI' €AaFl.;e.. t( P~D Hasler PlaRl ~l.ggg.Qg Mixed Use Proiect (MUP)
$2.500.00
34) Outdoor Servine Area Pennit $300.00
35) Planned Unit Development (PUD) closeout application and processing
a. pun' s up to 50 acres: $5.000.00
b. pun', over 50 acres up [0 250 acres: $7.000.00
c. PUD's over 250 acres: $9.500.00
36) Development ofRel!ional Impact (DR]) closeout application and processing: $]0.000
L) MISCELLANEOUS
I) Reserved
2) Reserved
3) Official Zoning Atlas Map Sheet Publications, maps, and reports shall be copied at actual cost.
4) Re:er, eEl The following fee shall be assessed for all Lien Searches. Title Searches and/or Payoff Requests:
$5.00/per request
5) The fee for researching records, ordinances, and codes shall be at no charge for the first hOUL then at the base
salary hourly rate of the staff member conducting the service for time in excess of 1 hour.
6) The fee for creating and designing special computer generated reports that are not a part of regular standard
reports shall be at no charge for the first hour. then at the base salary hourly rate of the staff member conducting
the service for time in excess of 1 hour.
7) CD Burning: $1.00, fl8~f,' 8i,,1-: s,.a $5.00
CDES Financial Administratjon, rev I 1/13/07 lw
page 9
8) Complete sets of Official Zoning Atlas Map Sheets $100.00 per set.
j;.t'!;:H."rl'1 hot'n I'd" 1rn I
1~ovember 27. 2007
Page 34 of 50
9) PR8te6sJ3ies sf 8e6HmeRt5 less tARR lId '7 iJ.16Re::: No CHarge fer first 5 68~ies sf SRe sissa, l?:, e sises, ether
sizes at 88:'1 Elf prea1:istisR. €it-A aRB fjlil3~BEII:leRt fJRstessJ3ies sf aSSHmeFlt:' les!; tAaA 11;: 1 '7 iRGI:tes.: $g.l~ SRB
:'issB., $0.10 t'.' 8 siesS., etfter sizes at e8st sf J3real::lstisfl. Staff shall charge the following fees for dupfication
of public records: .....
a. Certifies eeJ3~ Elf fll:l191ie [@eeFS ~l.gg BaSH. $0.15 for each one sided photocopy of documents
less than 11x 17 inches.
b. $0.20 [creach two sided photocopy of documents less than llx17 inches.
c. $1.00 for each certified copy of a public record.
10) Property Notification Address Listing:
a. MS Excel spreadsheet on Disc $70.00
b. Print out on Paper $75.00 + $0.05 for every record over 1500
c. Mailing Labels $80.00 + $0.06 for every record over 1500
d. Print out on Paper + Mailing Labels $85.00 + $0.11 for every record over 1500
11) Comprehensive Plan Consistency Review
a. CU's $300.00
b. Rezonings $750.00
c. Pud's or PUD Amendments: 52250.00
d. Letter of GMP consistency to outside agencies: $250
c. SRA - Stewardship Receiving Area - $2.250.00
f. DRI - Development of Reeional Impact ' $2.250.00
g. FlAM Fiscal Impact Analysis ~ $4.000.00
12) Plan Review Fee (for planning review of all building permit applications)
a) Long forms: ~ $125.00 per building permit application, 2nd review 50%. of fee, 3rd and
subsequent 25%.. of fee end and subsequent review fees related to Zoning approvals only)
b) Express permits: ~ $SO.OO per building permit application. 2nd review 50%) of fee. 3'd
and subsequent 251~t of f~and subsequent review fees related to ZoniD!:! approvals
onlv)
13) Project Meetings: Active applications under review for the following project types will be afforded one inter-
departmental meeting at no charge: Planned Unit Development re-zonings and Site Development Plan
applications (except for conceptual site plan approval and insubstantial change approval). Meeting requests
for all other application types and additional meetings will be subject to the following fees:
a. Meetings with Departmental Project Approval Staff member per applicant request, reviews
and petitions in progress. $150.00 per one hour minimum. $75.00 per Y2 hour thereafter.
Additional Department staff attending meeting per applicant request $75.00 per h. hour per
staff member.
b. Inter-Departmental Project Meeting per applicant request, site plan reviews and land use
petitions in progress. $500.00 per one hour minimum, $250.00 per Y2 hour thereafter.
14) Adequate Public Facilities
a. Planning Applications requiring COA process review (such as FP's, PPL's & SIP's, SDPs)
$200.00 + 25.00 per residential dwelling unit or + 25.00 per 1000 sq ft commercial
($5000.00 maximum)
b. Building permit applications requiring COA process review not covered under 12.a above
5100.00 per building permit application.
15) Zoning Confirmation Letters
a. Standard Response $100.00 (includes up to I hour research)
b. Extended Research $100.00 per hour (any response with research in excess of 1 hour)
16) Zoning Letter Appeal $250.00
('DES Financial Administration, rev J 1113/07 Iw
page 10
t.ru:>.r.-t::; Ito"", t\ln 1nll
l'Jovember 2/. 2007
Page 2-5 of 50
17)CDD
a. Community Development District $15,000.00
b. Chapter 189 Special District, Independent or Dependent, $15,000.00
IR) GMP Amendment
a. Small Scale $9000.00
h. General $16,700.00
c. Lega] advertising in addition to sub-sections a and b fees. and subject to applicable fee schedule
provIsIons.
d. Pre-application meetings for GMP consistency for development orders and zoning/land use petitions:
$250
e. Pre-application meetings for GMP amendment petitions: $250 (to be credited toward application fee
upon submittal)
19) Application for issuance TDR, $250 (non-refundable);plus $25 per TDR issued and recorded (total fees not to
exceed $2750)
20) Engineering Services
a) Vacation of Easements: $-I-;IlOO $2.000.00
21) Building Board of Adjustments and Appeals $250.00
22) Early Work Authorization (EWA) permit: $500.00 (does not include site clearing fee).
23) Le"al Non-conformin" Lot (LNC) $100.00
24) Vested RiQ:hts Detemlination (VRD) $1.500.00
M) BUILDING PERMIT APPLICA nON FEE
I) A permit application fee shall be collected at time of applying for a
building permit. The permit application fee shall be collected when the
plans are submitted for review. The fee shall be applied toward the total
penn it fee. The applicant shall forfeit the application fee if the
application is denied or if the application i~ approved and the permit is
not issued within the time hmitation as stated in Section 103.6.1.1 of the
Collier County Ordinance No. 91-56, as amended.
2) Application fee will be computed as follows:
a. SiR;l!? famil) afl8 8l:l13le1: S.O~ J3!?r :'Ej ft.., itA miAiffiHfll GfStOO.OO a) 250;;:1 oftora] Building Permit
Fee ($.15/sq ft new residential and commerciaL $.075 shell and warehouse)
k Haiti FaR1il, & ["",,,,scoial $.0, rer s~ ft ar t" IQ.QgG s~ ft, $.02. fer 8' or I G.GgQ s~. ft.
3) Ma"i","", arrlieatieR fee .;"011 ~rOT ."eee8 $"QOO,OQ.
4) Minimum fee of$50.00 for each of the following: plumbing; mechanical (A/C); electrical; fire; and building,
when applying for additions/alterations. Minimum fee for all other applications = $50.00.
5) The balance of the total permit fee will be collected at the time of issuance of the permit and will include any
fee adjustments necessary.
N) BUILDING PERMIT FEES
1) The fee for a building permit shall be computed as follows: Such fees shall be either based on the contractor's
valuations of construction cost or based on ealsl:llat8a. eElst sf 6SASWHStisR 8S set fanh SA tAe akaeAea :BwileliA';
'.'alHatisA Data Taell?' *(Ed~i~it :~n, " AisAe"l?r i!' ;n~ater the contractor's valuations of construction cost or
based on square footaQ:e. Minimal accepted calculated costs of construction are set forth on the attached
Building Valuation Data Table (Exhibit B - IBC Building Valuation Data Table. produced February. 2007).
Valuation of construction costs of less than $750.00 - No permit or fee is required, but construction must
CDES Financial Administration, rev] 1/13/07 Iw
page 11
!1f"1or-rl;::> Jtp,..,..l\Ir, 1f"111
-November 27. 2007
comply with all County Codes and Ordinances. If inspections are required by the Building Official Bsge 36 of 50
requested by the applicant, the appropriate fees shall be paid.
*ICC 'Tah:latisR TaBle, j3rSBI:l.GBB fSBnlar:, 2QQ:
.'
EXCEPTION: All work involving structural components and/or fire rated
assemblies requires pem1its and inspections regardless of construction cost,
signs must secure permits as stated in Collier County Ordinance No. 2002-01.
as amended.
a. Valuation of construction costs of$750.00 through $4.999.99 .-- '-Vith eRe er Re iRsfleetiGRs S!DJtD, "'ith
nmltiy;;ls iRspeetieRs S100.00
6. Vah:latieR efesRstn:letisR ee.:ts ef$:5,QQQ.Qg tA.reHgA. ~4~S~~.9t;
'VitA. eRe Sf 1'18 ifl.speetiElRs $~D.(}D flh:lS !:tJ.Qg Fer tAel;lsaRs sellaFs, sr fFaetief! tAeFE!et:, efeHilsiR';
"all:l.atief! if! 81;GeSS eft2,999.QQ. 'VitA ml:l.ltifde iRsj3esti8f1..' $SQ.QQ flll:ls $'S.SQ flef lR8usaRa sel1aF,:, er
fFaetisR tHef-eef. efRHilaiflg' all:l.atieR iR e1;SBS:i ef~2QQO.QQ.
New construction greater than 500 square feet
1. residential at $0.29 per square foot (living area)
11. warehouse/shell at $0.145 per square foot (total area)
111. build-out at $.0145 per square foot (total area)
iv. commercial i institutional at $0.29 per square foot (total area)
c. "al"atis. of so.,.tr",tie. cscts 8fiSG.GgG.99 tRfO"gh l:l,GI)Q.QI)Q.QQ $11000 pie, n OQ psr tAO"CaRa
8ellaFs, er [[aetieR thsreef. AfswilsiAC; ','alHatisA iA e;:eess 8f~50"QQO.QQ.
Alterations_ other construction. and new construction under 500 square feet (both residential and
and commercial) $100 plus O.30l~) of declared valuation in excess of $5.000
a. ValeatieR of s8Hstr"s~io. 68;1." 8". or ~1 ,991),999.9G S2350.00 pis, $1.00 psr tAO"."aIla a8l1ar, , 81' ffastiOR
tAoreef, ef8silaiRb ".aleatio. is 01OSec', 8Hl,90Q.G9,'.gG.
0) ELECTRICAL PERMIT FEES
1) The fees for electrical permits for new structures or placement or relocation
of structures shall be computed as follows:
a. $0.40 per ampere rating of all single-phase panel boards.
b. $0.15 per ampere rating for switch or circuit whichever is greater, if item
#1 above does not apply.
c. When not a complete installation, a1] switch and circuit breakers ahead of
panel boards shall be computed at $0.15 per ampere.
d. Permit fees for any change in electrical installation shall be computed at
the above rates for that portion of new and/or increased fees in existing
electrical facilities.
e. The minimum for any electrical permit shall be S50.00 per unit or tenant
space.
f. Fifty percent (50%) in additional fee costs shall be added to all above fees
for three phase installations.
EXCEPTION: Ordinary repairs limited to a $200 value or less may be made
without a permit. Repairs must comply with all County Codes and Ordinances. If
inspections are required by the Building Official or requested by the
applicant, the appropriate fees shall be paid.
P) PLUMBING PERMIT FEES
1) The following fee calcolations shall be applied separately when the permit
involves mixed occupancies.
CDES Financial Administration, rev 1 ]/l3/07 lw
page 12
a) Residential occupancies: The fee for a plumbing permit shall be computed at
the rate of $50.00 to be charged for each living unit with one to three
bathrooms. An additional fee of $10.00 will be assessed for each additional
bathroom.
Linpnrh 1+"" ,J\ir. 1nl!
l\Jewembsr 27.2007
Page 37 of 5(;
b) Nonresidential occupancies: The fee for a plumbing pel1l1it shall be computed
by the following methods, whichever is calculated to be the greatest fee:
a) The rate of $3.00 per 425 square feet of floor area. or fraction
thereof; or
b) Institutional facilities. hospitals. schools, restaurants and repairs
in any occupancy
b) classification shall be charged at the rate ofS1.00 per fixture unit or
c) Minimum of $50.00 for each occupancy or tenant space.
2) Grease traps: An additional fee of$50.00 shall be assessed for each grease
trap.
3) The cost for retrofit piping shall be computed at the minimum fee of$50.00
per floor for each main riser.
4) The cost ofa permit for lawn sprinkler systems shall be computed using the
dollar valuation as shown under Section M of this Resolution.
5) The minimum plumbing pennit fee shall be $50.00.
Q) MECHANICAL PERMIT FEES
1) The following fee calculations shall be applied separately when the permit
involves mixed occupancies.
a. Residential occupancies: The mechanical permit fees shall be computed at the
rate of $SO.OO for each living unit up to three tons of air conditioning. Each additional ton or part thereof shall
be $3.00 per tOil.
b. Nonresidential occupancies: The mechanical permit fees shall be computed by
one of the following methods, whichever is calculated to be the greatest fee:
The rate of $50.00 for the first three tons or three horsepower of air
. conditioning or other mechanical systems per tenant space. each additional ton of air conditioning or
horsepower shall be $3.00~ or The rate of$3.00 per 425 square feet of floor area. or fraction thereof.
2) The cost ofretrofit piping shall be computed at the minimum fee of $50.00
per floor for each cooling tower, or $50.00 for the first 3 horsepower and $3.00 for each additional horsepower,
whichever is greater.
3) The minimum mechanical pennit fee shall be $50.00.
4) A penn it for the change out of components shall be calculated at the above mechanical penn it fee rate or the
minimum fee whichever is greater.
R) FIRE PREVENTION AND CONTROL PERMIT FEES
l) The fees and exemptions set forth in the "Exhibit B" affixed hereto and made a
pan of this Schedule of Development Review and Building Pennit Fees shall
apply to Fire Prevention and Control Permits for both the independent and
dependent fire districts.
S) MOBILE HOME/OFFICE TRAILER AND OTHER TRAILER PERMIT FEES
1) The permit fee shall be $50.00 to set-up a single-wide trailer or mobile
home on an approved site plus electricaL plumbing. mechanical and fire
protection fees as applicable.
CDES financial Administration. rev] ]i13!071w
page ]]
J.-....p, ....:;-, ItCln"l hi,,- 1r\ll
NovemDe;- 27.2007
Page 38 of 50
2) The permit fee shall be $75.00 to set-up a double wide or larger mobile
homes on an approved site plus electrical, plumbing, mechanical and fire
protection fees as applicable.
T) CHlCKEES AND SIMILAR STRUCTURES
l) The permit fee will be based upon a calculated cost of construction of $4.00
per square foot under roof or the contractor's estimated cost of construction,
whichever is greater. The fee will then be calculated in accordance with
Section N of this Resolution. Additional permit fees for electric, plumbing,
mechanical, fire, etc., will be charged when applicable.
U) POOL OR SPA PERMIT FEES
1) For construction of each public pool or spa the fee shall be-
a. Valuation of constructioo costs of up to $4,999.99. $100.00
b. Valuation of construction costs of $5000.00 through $49,999.99: $80.00 plus $7.00 per thousand dollars,
or fraction thereof, of building valuation in excess of $2,000.00.
c. Valuation of construction costs of $50.000.00 through $1,000,000.00: $333.00 plus $3.00 per thousand
dollars, or fraction thereof, of building valuation in excess of $50,000.00.
d. Valuation of construction costs over $1,000,000.00: S3A74.00 plus S3.00 per thousand dollars, or fraction
thereof. of building valuation in excess of$l.OOO,OOO.OO.
2) For construction of each private pool or spa the fee shall be: SIOO.OO
V) SCREEN ENCLOSURE PERMIT & PAN ROOF FEES
l) Construction costs shall be calculated as follows:
a. Screen Roof. $2.00 per sq. ft of floor area. (Screen Walls Only)
b. Pan Roof. $3.00 per sq. ft of floor area. (Screen Walls Only)
c. Existing Roof. $2.00 per sq. ft. of floor area. (Screen Walls Only)
2) The screen enclosure or roof fee will then be calculated in accordance with
Section N of this Resolution.
W) SIGN PERMIT FEES
l) Sign permit fees will be calculated in accordance with all applicable Building Permit Fees and Electrical
Permit Fees outlined in this document, the Collier County Development Fee Schedule The minimum building
permit fee for sign shall be $75.00.
2) Multiple signs of the same type (i.e., wall signs) and for a single project may be allowed per one permit,
however an appropriate fee shall be charged for each sign in accordance with the schedule set forth in the
above subsection 1 of Sign Permit Fees.
X) CONVENIENCE PERMIT FEES
1) Convenience permits are issued in blocks of 1 0 each. Only licensed contractors are eligible to purchase
convenience permits. Convenience permits are limited to the use specified on the permit. The fee for a book
of 1 0 convenience permits is $400.00.
Y) REVISION AND AS BUILT PLAN REVIEW FEES; CORRECTIONS TO PLANS
1) PERMIT AND PLAN REVISIONS The fee for each permit revision submitted after permit issuance shall be
calculated using fee schedules outlined in Sections N through R above. The minimum permit fee for revisions
to permitted projects shall be $50.00.
CDES Financial Administration, rev 11/13/07 lw
page 14
1'r<p'-',.-i::;1 1+0"'" tdr, 1n11
I\lovember 27. 2007
Page 3Si of 50
2) AS BUILT PLANS The fee for "As Built" plan review shall be ten (10%) percent of the original building
permit fee or SI50.00. whichever is greater. but shall not exceed S500.00. The fee is intended to cover the cost
of reviewing amended building plans in the office to determine that change orders and various field changes
are in compliance with the minimum construction and fire codes of Collier County. The following are required
for as-built drawings rcvic\v:
a. An itemized list of all changes made after permit plan approvaL
b. As-built plans that have all changes made after permit plan approval
"clouded" .
c. As-built plans and changes shall be signed and sealed by the engineer
and/or architect of record.
3) CORRECTIONS TO PLANS
a. First Correction to Plans. No charge
b. Second Correction to Plans. $75.00
c. Third & subsequent correction to plans. $100.00
Z) PERMIT EXTENSION
I) The filing fee for each permit extension shall be equal to lOt Yo of the original
building permit fee or 5100.00. whichever is greater, but shall not exceed
S500.00. The filing fee is intended to cover the cost of reviewing existing or
amended building plans to determine and verify code compliance
AA) DEMOLITION OF BUILDING OR STRUCTURE PERMIT FEES
1) The permit fee shall be S50.00 for the demolition of any building or structure.
BB) PRE-MOVING INSPECTION FEES
1) The fee shaH be $150.00 for the pre-moving inspection of any building or
structure.
CC) INSPECTION FEES
1) A charge of 520.00 per inspection shall be assessed for inspections for which
a permit is not necessary.
2) A user fee of$120.00 shall be assessed for all inspections on a
time specified basis.
3) First Partial inspection for single-family & tenant buildout. No charge
4) Second & subsequent paJ1ial inspections for single-family & tenant buildout. $25.00
DD) REINSPECTlON FEES
1) Re-inspections for any type of building permit. or required Engineering re-inspections, shall result in
an additional fee of $75.00 per inspection for the first re-inspection, $100.00 for the second re-
inspection and $125.00 for the third and each successive re-inspection.
EE) FAILURE TO OBTAIN A PERMIT
1) Where work for which a pennit is required is started or proceeded with prior to obtaining said permit and
where such action was cited bv Code Enforcement or bv Contractor Licensing and resulted in a finding of
violation from either the Code Enforcement Board. the Special Magistrate. or the Contractor Licensing
Board_ or as directed bv the Board of County Commissioners the fees herein specified shall be fel::lr timeFi 4x
the regular fee. Het to eJ:eeBEI Sl,QQtU}Q fur fleFmits e8~tiH'; $2SQ.Qg RAa leGS. +-Ae J3eHalt::, f-er fuih:lre te
88ffiiFl a p€TT-Flit "'heR SHe i:' r@~l::liFe8 hR', iHj:; a l38St .;reater thRR $:lSQ.Qg Gl'lall 812 t.. e times thE' rej:;l:Ilar
_.
CDES Financial Administration, rev 11/13/07 lw
page 15
b. D. ...~ 1+"", .'> 1\1 1nll
1,ovember 27, 2007
2) Where work for which a permit is required is started or proceeded with prior to obtaining said peri1'Btlmd.O of 50
where a contractor or agent/provider where the building official or zoning director (for cases involving land
development) deems that the contractor/provider should have known that a permit was required but
voluntary seeks compliance bv obtaining the necessary permits to abate the violation the fees herein
specified shall be 2x the regular fee.
3) Where work for which a permit is required is started or proceeded with prior to obtaining said permit and
where an owner/builder seeks voluntary compliance bv obtaining said permit the fees assessed will be 2x
the regular rate as defined in this fee schedule.
4) Where work for which a permit is required is started or proceeded with prior to obtaining said permit and
where the unpermitted work was completed by other or Prior to the current owner/builder's ownership
of the property an where the current owner/builder seeks voluntary compliance by obtaining said permit to
assure compliance with all applicable codes the fees will be assessed at the regular rate as defined in this
fee schedule.
5) The payment of such fee shall not relieve any person from fully complying with the requirements of any
applicable construction code or ordinance in the execution of the work. or from any penalty prescribed
within any construction code, law or ordinance of Collier County.
FF) LICENSING
I) The fee for licensing items is as follows:
a. Letters of Reciprocity. ~$25.00
b. Contractors Change of Status. (active to dormant) $]0.00
c. Voluntary Registration of State Certified Contractors. $10.00
d. Pictures. $2.00
e. Laminating $1.00 (per license)
f. Fee for a 6 month temporary contractor.s license $25.00
g. Certified copies of Experience letters $35.00
h. Duplicate or replacement (of Competency cards) $25.00
1. Second entity application fee $50.00
2) Certificated of Competency (Annual)
a. Contractor
Initial License Fee
Renewal Fee
b. Specialty Contractor
Initial License Fee
Renewal Fee
c. Journevman
Initial License Fee
Renewal Fee
$150.00
$100.00
$135.00
$85.00
$50.00
$25.00
3) Dormant Certificates of Competency (Annual)
a. Contractor $100.00
b. Specialtv Contractor $85.00
c. Penalty fees after 9/30 $10.00 per month until 12131
4) Reinstatement of Delinquent License
a. Contractor
b. Specialty Contractor
c. Journeyman
d. Examination Administrative Fee
$150.00 plus back vears
$135.00 plus back vears
$50.00 plus back years
$100.00 good for 6 months
GG) DUPLICATE PERMIT CARDS
1) The fee shall be $5.00 for the issuance of a duplicate pern1it card for
whatever reason.
CDES Financial Administration, rev I 1/13/07 Iw
page ]6
HH) CHANGE OF CONTRACTOR OR SUBCONTRACTORS
1) To record a change of contractor or subcontractor, on a pemlit that has been
issued, the fee shall be $50.00. This fee includes the issuance of a new
permit card.
r,,.,.on,.....::. 1+"" . "in 1(': I
tlJOVember 2 (. 2007
Page 4 ': of 50
II) PERMIT FEE REFUNDS
1) If requested. in writing by the owner or his authorized agent. 50lYi, of the fees
charged. other than the application fee, may be refunded provided that a
pemlit has been issued, construction has not commenced. and the refund is
applied for prior to the cancellation of the permit.
JJ) RECORD RETRIEVAL
1) No charge for retrieving records from inactive or remote storage including
microfilmed documents
KK) COPY FEES
1) The fee for blueprint and miscellaneous copying shall be as follows:
a. Microfilm copies, of documents less than l1x 17 inches: SO.15 other sizes at cost of production.
f. Microfilm or Blueprint copies:
18 X 24 $1.25 per page
30 X 36 $2.50 per page
30 X 42 $3.25 per page
34 X 44 $5.00 per page
g. Community Development self-service copier, public access and not related to public record retrieval
or public record copies: documents less than 14x8.5 inches SO.t5 per page inclusive of sales tax.
LL)RESEARCH
1) The fee for researching records. ordinances. and codes shall be at no charge for the first haUL then at the base
salary hourly rate of the staff member conducting the service for time in excess of 1 hour
2) The fee for creating and designing special computer generated reports that are
not part of the regular standard reports shall be at no charge for the first hour, then at the base salary hourly
rate of the staff member conducting the service for time in excess of 1 hour.
MM) SUBSCRIPTION SERVICE
The fee for one-year subscription service to be mailed quarterly shall be
$15.00 per year. The subscription year is from Oct. 1 through Sept. 30.
NN) ELECTRONIC DATA CONVERSION SURCHARGE
1) A surcharge in the amount of 30/0 of the building permit application fee, with
the minimum surcharge being $3.00 and the maximum being $150.00, will be
applied to every building permit application submitted. A flat fee of $3.00
per permit will be charged for those permits for which an application fee is
not required per item (M) of this Schedule.
00) REGISTRATION OF RENTAL DWELLINGS
1) The fee for registration of rental dwellings is as follows:
a. lnitial Registration Fee - $30.00/per property
b. Annual Renewal. $20.00/per property
c. Annual Late Fee - $10.00 per day per property up to a maximum of $80.00.
d. The term "property" means a parcel or contiguous parcels with any number of rental units located
thereupon under common ownership and/or management.
CDES Financial Administration. rev] ] /] 3/07 ]w
page ]7
Anonn:::; Iram t\ln < rll i
l',ovember 27, 2007
2) Rental Inspection Page 42 of 50
a. Rental Inspection - S200.00 per unit
b. Re-inspection Fee - $50.00 per re-inspection per unit
c. Rental inspections shall not be required for rental units on property covered by a Florida Department
of Business and Professional Regulation CUDBPR") license. A copy of the DBPR license shall be
provided with the initial rental registration and all subsequent rental renewal applications.
3) Any unpaid fees may be pursued by the Collier Manager or designee through a collection agency.
PP) CERTIFICATE TO BOARD BUILDING
I) Initial Boarding Certificate - SO
2) Boarding Certificate Extension - $150
QQ) ADDITIONAL FEE REFUND PROVISIONS
1) Requests for fee waivers may only be approved by the Board of County Commissioners. Waiver
requests for development review and building permit fees shall be submitted in writing directly to the
appropriate Community Development & Environmental Services Division Staff, who will prepare an
executive summary for consideration by the Board. Such requests shall include a statement
indicating the reason for the fee waiver request and, if applicable. the nature of the organization
requesting the fee waiver.
RR) REFUND PROVISIONS
1) PAYMENT OF FEES: Full payment offees is required for a complete application. Department
policy requires full payment of fees at the time of application submittal. No work will begin on staff
review of the application until all fees are paid in full. If full payment of fees is not received within
14 calendar days of application submittal, the application will be considered void. At this point, a
new application and full payment of fees will be required to proceed with a project.
2) There will be no refund of Planning, Environmental, or Engineering related fees, except those
applications which have been deemed not sufficient for staff review and are withdrawn within 30
days of notification will be entitled to a 50% refund. After 30 days from such notification, there will
be no refund of submitted fees.
3) In no cases will there be refunds for pre-application fees, data conversion fees, appeals of
administrative decisions, or appeals to the Board of Zoning Appeals or Building Board of
Adjustment.
4) If staff error causes the inappropriate or unnecessary filing of an application and payment of fees,
100 percent of all inappropriate fees, shall be refunded upon written request and with the concurrence
of Department management.
SS) ADDITIONAL FEE PROVISIONS
1) In those cases where alternative methods or timing of payments for CDES services and I or fees
listed in this schedule associated with SBR reviews are deemed to best serve the public good, the
Community Development and Environmental Services Administrator will have the authority to
approve such alternatives. Such alternative must be in writing and signed by aU principals involved.
In no case shall final e.O. or such certifications of project completeness be issued until payments due
CDES are received in full.
2) All hourly fees are computed and charged from actual Divisional time tracking records.
3) All acreage totals used in fee calculations will be rounded up to the nearest whole acre.
COES Financial Administration. rev 11/13/07 lw
page ]8
(,..-.0.....--';::> I+p ,"i., 1(\11
l\!ovemDer 27. 2007
Page 43 of 50
4) When deemed essential for project review or approval. there will be no additional charge for any
meetings requested by CDES staff.
TT) PUBLIC VEHICLE FOR HIRE FEES
1) The following fees shall be assessed for the Public Vehicle for Hire Program:
a. Initial Application fee (new Companies) - $200
b. CortiN8.'. '8 O~€ra'. $2,U Initial Certificate to Operate (Fob I-Jan 31) - $325.00
c. ' 'eRi~le Deeal S~g J3er " eRiele -Annual Certificate to Operate Renewal $325.00
d. Tem]38Far-:, Vehisle DesaI - $~ J3ef' eRiel!? Late Fee for eTO Renewal $200.00
c. I)ri"er IeeRtifieati8A Care S~g J3er sri', er Sub-Certificate Application Fee (New Comoanies) -
$100.00
f. ReJ3laeemeRt IaeAtifisatisR CarB ~I9 fler ears Sub-Certificate - $125.00
g. OR :ite VBRisle Pem:tittiRg ~Hj J3er' shiele Annual Sub-Certificate renewal - $125.00
h. Late Fee for Sub-Certificate Renewal- $100.00
I. Vehicle Decal - $50.00
1. Temoorarv Vehicle Decal $5.00 Del' vehicle/Del' dav
k. Temporary Vehicle Decal (In case ofinooerable decaled vehicle) - $5.00/oer vehicle
I. Driver Identification Card (lnitiallRenewal) - $75.00 oer driver
m. 2nd Driver Identification Card - $25.00
n. Replacement Driver lD - $10.00
o. On-site Vehicle Pemlittinu - $15.00 per vehicle
UU)"PAYMENT IN LIEU OF" FEE FOR PATHWAYS (SIDEWALKS,AND BIKE LANES)
1) Calculated using the current Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) construction costs or an
engineering estimate not to exceed twenty-five percent (2SC%) of the submitted application request's total
project cost.
This is the last page of the CDES Fee Schedule
CDES Financial Administration. rev] li13/07 Iw
page lY
.'\genda Item No.1 OU
NClvembei 27, 2007
Page 44 of 50
Attachment D . Ustina of Fee Schedule Chances
Challl!<l, AdJu'lmcnla""darlfltalion18ni,llnef..-~od.Enforc......nr-Fundl11
R"".nn for challll< _ Dotto ;IlCI'C\lSC In Ih. MSl orha.k~ro.md check> /PVAC~ loa' infnrn..d and a) ,m~.d ch.n~.' to Iho V.hld, lor Hi.c on ?/llf(l7
.
Prevjol)SFeeSchedul"S&ctlon ProhOS<ldFeeSche<luleSect,on
m m
"
b\ Certificate 10 Operate b)lnitiaICertif'caleIoOperalB(Febl-Jan31).S32500
c)VehocJeOecal-S50.00pervehiclil c) Annual Certif.catelo OperalB Ranawal $325.00
Chanee 2: Adju.rmonl anrl darlfiealioD 10 e"'lillj!. ttfi _ Cod. Enforc.....nl- FuMI!1
"....00 for <lIoneo. To .mure tim<l~ .ohm;".1 ..fCTO renowal ",,<k'" 10 ,l.ffror ......i,,"' and "!>pennl before Jon 31'1 "I "".",' vea".., I'''' Ordinane' 2'H~"~9, Se.. 142.~5 (.)
("VAq_...sinfnrn,,'<la..da\)llrtlv.d<"""~cstllth.\'.hl<l.forHi,..,o,,711lI111)
P'evloLJsFeeScheduleSection PfODOSed fee Schedule Section
m m
d) Temporary Vehicle Decal - $500 per vehIcle d) Late Fee for CTO Renewal- $200.00
h) nol applicable h) Late Fee for Sub-CertifIcate Renewal $100.00
Cha"ll.3:A<lJustmentanddarlfl""lionlo.ll,linef.....CodeEnlor<""",nl-FIIndlII
R""...nfor<h.n~.-A< "!rOrdl"",,<<2IH'f.-59.Se<.I.f2-55(al (P\'AClw.,IRfonn<'<landa"PTov.dchlln~cstoth.Vchicl.forHi...on711l107)
PrevIOu5FeeSchedulaSection Pmoos<XI Fee Schadule Section
m m
el Dflver IdentllicallOn Car{). $50.00 per dnver e)Sub-Certificala Appllcallon fee (New Companies)- $100.00
f)ReplacemantldentiticalionCard-$10percard f) Sul>-Certificate. $125.00
g)Or>-5de VehIcle Permlltlng-$15,OO pef vehicle g)AnnLJaISub-Certilicateranewal-$125.oo
k)NotApplicable k) Temporary Vehicle Decal (In case of Imperable decaled veh'de) $5.00Ipervehlcle
m)NotApplicable m)2ndDriverldenlificalionCard-$25,OO
ClIs"llc4:A,lju,'m.nlandclarilic,'lon'ocll"ill\:t"",-CBdc!;nl'urccn..nl. Fund III
R...on for <hn~. _ No <han~. to f.. ju,' TeoT~"ni,.cd l"..c,""'iB"<ly 1."... <.d.<.I & ~ in .crtin" 1"1'1) (rVM. w.' inforn..d and al'l'rov.d cban~..' '0 the V.bld. I", Hire ''''
71H~17I
PrevIOus Fee Schedule Seclion PfOPosedF"eScheduleSoctlon
m m
i) Not ApJ'Oicable ijVehlcleDecai-$50,OO
j) Not Applicable j) Temporary Vehicle Decal $5.00 per vehiclelper day
I) Not ApJ'Oicable I) Drivel Identlftcallon Card (In;tlaIIRenewal) - 175.00 per dnve'
n)NolApphcable n)Repiaceme"'Dllv..rID.$1O.00
0) Not Applicabl" o)Or~stleV..h'c1ePermilting-$15.00pervehicle
Chane.5, N." f...bcln~add.d- Clldc Enforc"men' _ ~'und III
R.a.on ror chane. - W. will h. rnod.lin~ R.,olnUon Nn. 'Jtl--16t1.. which Puhlic litiltti.. i, cuH.nllv u'io~
Previous Fee Schedule Seclion prooosed Fee Schedule Sedlon
" "
41 RooelVed 4)Thelollo~"gfooshallbeaesessedforaIlLienS""rches,TllleSearchesandlor Payoff Requeets
$5lperrequest
Chane" 6: Adju5flllCnl and Cl.dlkltlion to an .llstin~ I". - Z...ninw'Land Ii.. PClillon. _ Fun~ 131
Rea.on for dl"~' _ A<ldod la"'-"'aj!c'o lori, th.., liClltlt und...tand which I.. a 'I'll.. '"~ ...h;..
Previous Fee Sch"dule Soction Prono""dF....ScheduleSoction
K15,17,18 K1517,18
15) Rezone Petdion(PUD to PUD),$8,OOO,OO plus $25.00 an acre (or t radionthereof) 15) Razone Petdion (PUD 10 PUD) $8,000.00 plus $25 00 an acraor Iredionlhe rool (Requires a
submittal 01 a new PUD document)
17) Planned Un~ Development Amendments (substantial $6.000.00 plus $25.00 an acfe 17) Planned Untt Development IPDA) $6,OQOOQ piUS $25.00 an acre orfradlo nofanacre
(or fraction Ihereol) (Substantial changes to thetel<l and MaSler Plan)lext chenges tllal do not impact h e Master Plan
$8,OOO,OO(llle$25.00anacfeleewillr1Otawly)
18) Planned Unit Development Ameooment . InSUOslantlal (POI) $1 ,500.00 Requires a Ileanng by
18) Planned Unn Development AmerKlment (1I1Subsfan1ial) $1.500,00 the CCPC only for a mir10rchange to the PUD Masler Plan
.._.
.'
At",chmenIC. Summary of P'opo.M cllangeo 'otne CDESfee ""Cedule
BlABO_lw
updal~d 11120/2007
Agenda item r'~o_ 10U
Novembe;- 27 2007
Pa;18 .15 of 50
Cllalllle 7: Adjustn..nt and Clarificalion 10 an nisti"l: f... -l.oninWLand lI.e Pml;o", - Fund 131
n""...nforrltance-AdrtOOlanpa~eloh""['lhea,,,[i,,,,ntund"".tand"'hkhr..a[,JIIie.andwln'
Previous F5!l Schadul~ Sect'on Prooosed F~e Schedule Sect,on
" "
5) S~e Development Plan C"tlceptual Review $750 00 5) Siw Oevolooment Plan Conceptual Rev,ew(CSP). Unihed Development Plan IUDPj
N,lIghoo,hoodParl<SlleINPSP)$750,OO
Cha"~e II: Now f... .......ltln~ I....m LDC Am.ndmonl.. l.oninlliLand UK P<<ition. Fund 131
Rea.on. LOC Section 4.tJ1W7 J.Il. a rov<<l9/l1lt!5
Previou.,FeeScnedule5ect1on ProoosedFeeSclleduleSec!lon
" "
J) 80al Dock El<1anSlOn Pet~ion $1 ,50000 31 Boal Dock EXlension Petdlon $1,50000 Boal lift CaI'lOPY, Adm'nislrahveRev,ew
$5OQ,00
Chan~e 9: P",!",.,,,I New ~'ec_l.oninWl...anrlll'e 1'011Iion,. Fund 131
Rea.on _ To dllOCOIIrace them u'lllko we do wllh SOP'. and 10 .nmural'" Ihe.) ,nc.nt 10 hc rr-"I"''''iv''lho fi"'l limo.
Previous Fe" ScheduleSec!,on PtooosadFeeScheduleSec:hoo
K4,7,1317,19,20,23 K4,?1317,1G.20.23
4)Cond~ional U.... PenTI~ $4,000,00 1$1,500,00Iwiloo fillad with Rezone Petot",n 41 Condlhonel Use Perm~ $4,000,00 WIlen filled lMUl Rezone Petlhon ($1,500 DO), Addilionall.... fa
~th ar>d subsequent rev,ews - 200/. olo"9'nal lee
7) DRI Review (In addition to oosl ot relone) $10,000,00 piUS $25 00 an aoe (or Iractlo!] 7IDRIR"vlaw(lneddihcmtoooslofrezone)$tO,OOOOOplu.,$2500anacre (or Iractoon lhereof)
thefeol) Addihonal j,,,, 10! 5th and subsaqu-ant reviews _ ;>0% 01 oliglnel Ier; Amendments deemed to t>e
mmor ,n nature. Ihat ,s ",quinng minor slnke thru and underhne text amendments 01 00 more tha"
10 diffarenl lines 01 Ie"" cilanges.n Ihe DRI will ber;app.,a et$13,000,00, Anya mendmenlwilich
ondudesamepandtextcilarogew,1I 00 assessed tl1e lull lee Ino cap)
13Ip"rkint'lE.ampt'on$1,~00,00 13\ParklngExemp1ion$1,50000, Addihonal lee lor 5th and suvsa<luenl re V09WS- 200!.0Iorlfl'nal
,..
17) Planned Unit Development Amendmenls (suvstanhal) $6.000 00 piuS $25 00 an aG'~ 171 Planned Unit D~v"'IQpme,,1 Amerldments (PUDI $6,000 00 piUS $25,00 an acre or lradion 01 an
(or frad,on thereol) aCle ISLJI)S1antial changes to the leXl aoo MesterPlan)Add~lonal lee for 5th eoo subsequent
,ev.ews - 20'1. of original fee Amendment5 deemed to be mioor In nelure, tlla! 15 requlflng mono,
stnM thru and ur>ded,ne amef)l]ments 01 no more tnan 10 different lines 01 le,1 cilal1(les.n the PUD
WIll be capped at $g,OOO,OO Any amer>dmenl wilieh Includes a map aoo texl eharoge will be
assessed Ihe lull 100 (no capl
19) Remno Petlllon (Regular) $6,OQO,00 plus $25 00 an acre iorrrectlon! hereof) 19) Re20ne Pet1110n (Regular) $6,000,00 plus $2~ 00 an acre lor Iraellon thereol}, Addlllonal fe" fOI
~thanasubseQuentrevlews-20'!ooloflg'nallee
20) R~lone Petition (to PUD) $10,000,00 plus $2~,OO an acm for Iracllon lhereol) 20:, Re20nePetllion(t"PUDI$10,00000pluS$2S,O{l"n acreio,lrac tlontner90flAdd,llonalfaelol
5t1landSUbseQuentravlews.200/00Ior'9,nallae
J3)Vanancapafilion$2,OOOOOrmK1enlial,$5,ooOoonon.",s,r1anhal ?3)Vanancepellt,on,$2,000,OOres'denllel,$5,()()(),OOnon-reSloenlleI Addihunallaelor5thalld
SUbsaqnenl,av'I'!WS_20'!oo!or'f!malfoo
Ch.n~o Ilk P"'I"'sod Foolncr........l.on;"WLand ll,o I'c1IIlon,-Fund 131
R.~""n. Althnu~h Ihore "'vo I"-'on numorou. Inerca.o, in IIOS"'~f tbl. foo II., ,",I h""u (,han~...1 .info
PrevlousFoo$cheduleSect",n ProoosadFooScheduleSect,on
'" '"
16) Property owner notificalions: $1,00 non-cerfitioo mml, $3 00 r~rtlhed 'alum ,,,,calpl t6)PrOpertYOwnefrv.>tlflcallan:$1,~Onon-cedilledmail,$3,OOcediloedfatum,acaiplmail
mail(petiTjonerto pay this amount prior to adved'OOmen!ol petibon) IPellt,onertopeylhisemounlpr",rtoadvertlSementolpetlllon\
Cha"l!o t I: AdJustmenl & C1artllcalion to orlaln~ 100 _ ZDnInWLanoll).c rolltton,. hnd 1.11
Re..on lor chanc. _H<<ull of ~ LDe rni.lon. L1)C ItI.nz.1J E.II_ .... ,rniou.h' IUJ <lc<cri ~ion and 100 wa' odded 10 k:1~
P'ev,ousFeeSche<luleSOOlOn Prooosed fee 5ctlooule Section
"" ""
18) Planned Unit Development Ameooment (Insubslanljal) $1 ,500,00 18) Plaflned Unrt Dev"lopmenl Amer>dmenl - Insubstantial (PDI) $1 ,500,00
Roqu""5ahearingby!h..CCPConlylorem1nofchangetothePUDMaslerP~n
PUD MUlOr Change (PMC) $1,000,00 (Admifl~lrehve Review 10' mil"Klr Cilange
10 the MaSlerPlan)
AllacMment c. ~umm"'vofompo""d cr.ange. to 'heCDES lee $Chedul~
BMBO-Iw
Upo.,M1112012007
Aqenda Item No. 10U
1~ovember 27, 2007
Page 46 of 50
Ch.n~-e \2, N",",' Foc Jl;ffilltin~ trom loDe Amclldmcnl _ z..nin~Land Use l'ctitioo. - Fund 131
R........ foe ChaD~" _ NevI' 1IJ>]l Iy,oc <~tM wltllLDC amond""ol apF"ovcd Feb 1ll.2!KJ(, LOC .echon 2.113.07.1.3 and 1.o.J.1I7.N..;
PreviousFeeScheduleSaclion ProoosedFeeSctleouleSection
'" '"
33) Administrative Rev,8W (minor changA$ to pun Maste, Plan) $1 ,000..0.0. 33) Mixed Uoo Projoct(MUP) $2,50Q,QO
n'an~ 13: New f.. r..ulli~ h...." UK .mcndmenl.. Zooill!VLand II," l'oTilioD5 Fundl)l
Ktason _ Pm,,,,,,,,, <hUh'" in Land n"","""mcnt Cod. LDC~:l(,
Pr9li",us Fee Schedule Sedion ProoosedFeeScnedule$ec!lon
'M ""
34) Not Applicable 34) OuldoorServing Area Permit $300.00
IIConlingent upon approval otloo permilllng process byttle Board ot County Com missioners)
ChaltJ(c ]4, Now fee rtRIltI"llI'rom LDe amndment.\- Mlso.llan...u. (R"","lm.dohyZonln~1
Ro,..on _ N"", .n" tv >I' .....,.rM Wllh LDC .molll1menr., rO\'<'fl2!2H11l/i LDC9_1l3.n~
PreviousfeaSchaduleSect'on ProoosedfeaSctladul"Secllon
'" '"
23) Not Applicable 23) Lagal Non-oonform,ng LOt (LNC) $100.00
CI..n~. l~: Prool'osM F"" Incna!;<'. Mj,..llanfD'" (ll"'lncsln.adell)'Zonint:l
It"",on _ Curt"l'nll"" oleos 01<)1 include ".nUm. 10'. p"",.ralion. ,...,.rch and cnmmuniaUi"n with cu"nmer. The ""...nll.. dool not .rrur.,<'l" rrBrC'! rim. 'l>I'n! on lh.
'.....,<'W.. 35"/.-41\%01.11 "'rmll<r"'''irrr..r.....i<'Wolmorrlh.''11imcs.
Prev,ousfeeSd1eduleSect,on ProoosedfeeScheduleSect,on
L7,12a,12b U.1?a,12b
7) CD Bumlng,$1,OO. fIopp~oisk$.50 71 CD Burmng $5.00
120) Long forms; $75.00 r>erl>u'loing r>erm~ applicalion 12al Long Iorms: $125.00 per I>uiloir>g permt applicatlon, 2nd rev;ew50 %oflee,3<dan,1
sutlsaquenI25%olt"",(2ndaodsul>sequenlreviewleesrelatadloZon''''Japproval'only)
121>1 Expresspermits$l~.OOperbuilding pe,mrt applLcalion 12b) Express permits; $50,00 per buik:1ing permit applicahon, 2nd ,"""ew500/ ,ollee,3rdand
sutlsequent 25% 01 fea (2nd and subsequenl review lees related to Zomrq ap pmvalsonly)
Ch.Dl:.16,Ad.iu'hn.nlanddarltiralionroanulstin~r...2.""i"elLondll..P~ition..FuIll1D1
Ilrason _ LOC ~~Ion 4.OlW7 JX np ,.",,<<t9mlllll!;
Prev,o,-",Fe"ScheouleSeclion Pronos<IdFeeSctleduleSoctron
"" ""
28) Stewardship R_Iv,ng Area p"lrt,on (SRA) $7,000,00 pel" SRA plus $25.00 per acre 28) Stewardship ReceiviJ1{j Area Pelition (SRA): $7,000.00 per SRA plus $25.00 per acre for
1m StewardshipSend'ngArea Petrtion(SSA):$\l,500.00 SlewardshipSendingAreaPetition(SSA)$1l.500.00 StewardshipR_ivlngAl1e,nativeOeviation
Oesign(SRDD)$.SOO,OO SRA Amendmerlls deemed to be moor in nature, thai is requirirq minor
strike thru and unde~'ne tllXt amendments ot 00 more than 10 difleranf lines of text changes in the
SRA I'<lll be capped at $10.000.00
Chaner 17: N...... r.. ....glllnt: Iron, I,DC nnoonolmorn!, _ MI.e"'1.n....". (1t"'l"...madobyZonlnt:l
R.a,on-r.;.,...,1V rr<lltMwlthUlCnm('ndn..nra"'lrovrd2!2t11O(, LDC'J.tI2.lHI
Previous Fee Sctledule Section ProoosedFeeScheduleSeclion
'" '"
24) Not Appiicable 24) Vested Rights Oet....mimrtion (VRDI $1500.00
AtulchmentC Summ..-yofp",pooedchnngestoltleCOESieeso"eclUle
BMBO_iw
upda'ed11120/2007
Aaenda Ilern No.1 OU
T~ovei1lber 27. 2007
~age 47 of 50
Previous Fee Sd1eduleSed'on
i.nlaillclfllceonlh.flrs1I.....land...ndomidinm.onlh..........illl~n""..
r~ SH~I for r......ntial h..lldin~ .n~ $!IIIJ tor a nnn_rrsi~cdlial buildin~.
ncifi'mnlaimhnlhrl'lailandre,id.n1ial.
PlOoosad Fee Schedule Sec1ion
"
1) Wt,..~ a build,ng cor)$jSIS of ootl"l 'esidential and r>o~-rtlSlden(i,,1 {oommafcial, ,eta,1. off,ce) uses
the fees shall be calc:ulatood as follows
a. $5000.00 Base Fes
" !200.00perstruc1ure
C$4000p"r,eside"t1alllWell,nounit
, $OlOp",sQua",footofnon.resKlenhalfloora,ea
.. mol Ih~ir d..tlopmtnl .omml",,~nl" coordiua1ion with SIal. anrl Rl'jtion.1 A~~noi",
Praoosed Fee Schedule Saction
KJ5&KJ6
J5)Planned Unrt DevelopmentlPUDlcklsooutappl'callon and pracess'ng leftad,ve upon final
Board ofCounly CommlSSlOners approval)
a) PUD's up to 50 aCfBS: $5,000.00
b) PUD'sover 50 acres upto 2bOacres: $'i,000.00
c)PUD's over 250 ac.-es $\1,500.00
36) Deveklpment of Reg,onat tmpact IDRII ClOseout appllcat'on and p'ocassn"lQ $10,00000
leffecllve upon I'nal BoerdofCounlyComm'SSKlnersapPlo~al)
(R..!u." mll,te h,. En~~lIOt'rincl
ProoosadFeeScheauleSschon
~o
20) Eng,neenng Services
a. VaCllt'ollof Easemeots $2.000.00
(I<..,UCSl marle I~' En~~n.....in~1
~ mnnth, hut in enor",.. m.,tc_~15tl.tXI. II shOld,1 h... .oad.imllar to DHI~~lltJ""r
PmoosedfseSctleduleSsct,,,n
"
&)$200.00 per inspec:lion pa,d in advance lor 12monfhs
(R..,o..' marlol')' En~illOt'rtngl
I,," ProoosedFeeScheduleSsctKln
'OIOve,e,cavatlonpenallyl""peryard Ptus Pa'mrtlRaview$O 05 per r::ubic ya'd fa". unless
m~",muml'avebae"paid
(R.qu<S! madchy Eat1h'l'.,rtn~)
ialCh.aj(.F..,farSDI",
Prooosed Fee Schedule Sedion
G'
c) ConstructIOn Documenf Resubmission or Document ModiticatlOn- SubmitasiMubslantlal
Change $400.00 for Itm sheet, $100,QO lar each add~lonai sheet
monitarin~. l"xJ.lin~ P[lll Monllorin~ SIaff - 2 IT!':', 10 575.tHltJ I". ~ $150.t~1t1
1~IHI Roslrl.nlialllwcUinjt nnln al 575 ~ 51 U51ltJ plus Comm..rcial S1l{J.tH~t.q ft
nltsconst.uct<<l...ithinaI'Ullto5U~IIRai...Cnm""'r<i.llo50.11
1t1.(HHI x 541.12 ~ SMI.t~~1 Toral S21tJ.1H~I)
P,ooosedFeeScheduleSecholl
'"
" PUD at"ld SRA MOllrto"..g lotl&-tlme charge al t'me of bu,lding permit pick_up)
Cha~" IH, AdjuumCltt and cl.riflcation to an nl'tin~ 1<<. Slt~ D."e!ol,rnem Planl- Funrll3
R.....on-Wllhlh..n..........ign.or.csirl.ntlll]hnUdinj:S5u..hulb.8ayfm...l'cojoot..borOlh..
....ul'<'<l..rltodar;fy..hnwlb..........onldl..,calcu]at<i1insu..h.I..llrlinj(. Th.""rrcntSDPI.....a
\\.......nnetcbarcchotb.ilha'toh.nn..orlhcolh.r,n..cba..Oho..nloOha'1'<52!Ht..,.bulldi
PraviousFee$cheduleSsc(ion
"
l)NotAppllcabls
a. Not Appilcable
b Not Appl'cable
c.NolAppllcabls
d.NotApphcabl"
Chan~.., 19, N.... """"t"OflO$~rl- ZoninWJ-.llnrlli'" Polition,_ Jiund 131
R.ason, Thcdoocw.t J'rOOMOts ..iIIinvulv.puhUr h.arln~., aaffrevw" lo.nsurclb(,l"ojor:l1h2
linthc"",,,nfDRI',).
Pr""iousfe..ScheduleSect,on
K35 and K36
35)NotApplicabls
36) Not Appl,cabl~
(:h.n~c2n,p"'1Ifl...I"""I..n.a.._Mi"""'Jan""u'
ll..a...n_Our"vl'nl..r"'lf..r".oc...ine.,"""'ts~2.IKIIVI'''ilio"
Prevlousfe"SCl1edule5...:hon
~"
20) Eng''''''''''~1 Se""""s
a. Vacation of Easaments: $1,000.00
Chlln~o~l, 1".OllOs{'dhclnr.....sc-E..al'.lin..I'c.n,i15
1I..",n _ whon"ricinall~' aokkd it <l.nultl how .""d PtHt.1~t"crin'pc<1ion p"id in .rl,'"n,o"m
mnnlhin'po<110nf,.,,)
P,aviousfA"Sd'A(juleSect","
"
b)$'50.00perlnSpectio"pa;d'nadva..~eforl?m'mths
ChanCc22,P"'l,05.dN...."..-Ex...,.lIti..nP.rml15
R""...." Cllrr.ntlv m ni",d hI' ollr bcovali"" Or~lnanf<' 22-fl!(3)c.
Previous Fee Schedule SedlOn
ow
10) Not Applicabl..
Cbon~o 2]'Prop05l'rlF...Jnn...._Suh<l;vi'ion
R..,on_l...c.."..th{'aClu.l....tor,..."icw/"."""'.5in..nd.l,oh.,...."'i...,nt..ilh.h.lrnu;,...nt
G'
c) CO"Slrudion Document Resubmlss,on or Document Modif,cat"," - Submit as
tnsubslantial Chanlle$150.00 for f,rst sl1eef. $75 00 for each additional sheet
ChallJ(~ 24, AdJurtm.nl.JK1 darfllcaU.... 10 au rxlsfin~ r... _ I;nl!i.....rln~ .'-"nd 13]
Ron.on - SRA', 2'l' .om"...hk in dcv.h.!'m.nt to I'IID', ..ith appMVl'd l'ommi'm....' ''''1uirtn~
pin. O,..,,..tions ens" S~O.tIIH) E<.f. Total S2IHI.lMIIl) (blsti"c R<v<nUl' Ty"ical Yl'U E..tlmat",1
at 511.1IJ ~ S50.IKtn Total II",' Sf525tKI) ..Ilh 1I..ommcnrl.rl chan~"'" Ra;,.. r,..id.ntia] rl...llin~ u
m....is<i1 R."...... wfth chant1o, PlID <I....llin~ units .ISOn x SlIMI ~ S151l000 1'1", C..mm.rcial 51
eMf,"'. RcvcnucS!(Hj.(Mtn_$21lJ.lltHI~ BUNNt
Pr"viou,;F"sScheduleSaction
'"
3' PUD Monitoring lone-time charge ~t time of build,ng perm" pick_up)
AttaohmentC Summa'yofD'Opo""dcMnga,tolneCDESI.eB<l,edul@
BMBO-Iw
upd.",d"i2Q12007
al $75,00 perdwelllllg unit for rasidantial con5lrudionwilhin a PUD,($3.000,OQ
maximumfaeperbuildingpemtitapplicalron)
b)$O.10perSque,eloottorroorHasidanliaIOOflSlructionwithinaPUO,($2.000,00
maximumlaepe,ouildingpermrtappli<:alion)
Agenda Item NO.1 OU
November 27, 2007
Page 48 of 50
a) $100,00 per dwelling un~ for rasiden1iai oonslrudion within sPUD and SRA ($3,000.00 maximum
lee par buiidlng permit spplicalion)
b)$0.12persqus,sfootforroor;.rasidanlialoonstruc!ionwithinaPUDandSRA($3,000,00
maximumlasperbuildingpermrtapplicalion)
Allacl1mentC Summ~ryofp'opo.edcn.nge.toth"COl,SI"".o""dul"
BMBO.lw
updel&d"12012007
(;h.an~. 25: """"",.d N.... F.... - En~iTonm..nf"IILamUca"in~. Fund 131
1I.""...n_STI>crmi""T<alw."inar""oronvironmon'al'M1,llIvl"'.ndi''ak.,n,o..lIm<10
I<m'ironm..n'al.nd,onin~andl",,,,ihlv.nl!in<<ri"l!l. Ifla"",J '02 hm,..lnclh...nvironm<n
honc doe In ,hi' <010,'1.., nalll" "fill< rovi...... Till. ..'Imol<d ,im. 10' Ihe .n"i"onmen,.1 'I.rr
$2IHI.ud$."'1I.ndlh'ld""" ""11.k,'inloron,id'Tolion Ihe<n" oio dditinn.I'I.lfwhnm."n
PfeVlous Fee ScheduleSe<::ll<:m
"
C) Nol Applicable
(-h.n~< 16: 1"OI>o,.d N..... F...._II...ultin~from l1oacri.I'I'TO....I.nd a~n'<n"n' ,,'ilh FOEI'_l
1l""Orl. \\ as 0' ..ov<<1 It,. Rrr ao,lln.u"",'.cnm..n'.1 A~n'{'m..nl wl'lI rllEI' ').'251117 I"A4
Previous Fee Schedui~ Section
on
13) Nol Applicabi.e
eh.n~,,2,): I',o"",.d N.... F..... E",'ironm"nl"IILanll'.'J1in~_ ~nnd 131
Iloasonloc<h.n~". "0' Ih.. eE f... SlalTpulS in. minimlln, of3hou"'I1Toc'-"'inj:.....'i...in~
I... i' fai, ,inc< ,Om' nc"'.,..... .n. ,m.ll.. ..nll 1Ilk.I." hm< ond mhl'n,hol a.e ve,',' lo,'~e w
Prevlou, Fee SchetJul"Seclion
'"
14) Nol Applicabl~
Ch"n~< 20: I""f.oml N..w~..... l",'iTOIl,"<nlaIlL.n<i<ea"in~. ~und III
1I...,0n lu.. .han~". Li<lffio, 1"''''0''011 '1",.1... I...,ot< 1>.....1 on . ",ini",,,", ",'in..",111I ho"
"""I".U''I,,'cie_,"Iilil..lion.2) ..""i...."I';,''"'I.I'.<i.-',,1"\'..',..1) ..vi"" "f!i,I<d,'I,...i", ~'.I<'.
M." ",,<I ~erl<"'1 ,,'jl,lIif.. n'."ov'".~) .....,irw of liSle<! '1I<',.;e, ",'''a~~'m<nl "Ion,. "n,1 I"~ <om
PtnvIO<lsF""S<:'""I(JI"S""""!1
C1~
15) N<,t Applicable
Chonv" 2~, Adj""m..n' .n,1 <I.cilie"hon "'."e.I"in~ 1<<'. fj"Udi"~ nop' (('onl,o<1"oll.i<<"
Ro..,,,n I"r<h.n~< _ C","r~rl""'n'" Colli", (o"nl,. foclhei..lr""I",n,I",.j'('('S. olh...."",,(i<
PrevIous Fee Sctl€dule Secll"n
ee,
al Letters 01 Rae'pwclly $300
b)ContlaclorsChaogeotSlalus
CI..nv"JlI:Adj""n...n1and<larif<ca'ion'o..islinvl....- Conlu"'"cLi<<H'inv_ ~"n<lliJ
1I0a",,, fo..h.nu<. C"ntr~'lo'" us< Colli".. Cuunl,. forlhdc i." '" ,on..'" i",',-"'h,'c",,unlir
Previo....' Fee Schedule Sect,o~ WebSitnOnlv
ee, nOlappli""bl" Cerllf,catesofCompete~cy
a) 1101 applicable Co<"ltractor
, IniliallloonseF"e $8700
, R"n<ilWaIF.... $87.00
b) ""I applicable SpecialtyConlractor
1. IniliatLiG.msaF"" $72.00
, Renewal Fee $72.00
c)notapplicablo Journeyma~
1. Inrtial LiceoseFee $ 1~,.00
, Re~ewalFee $1500
eh.n~o 31: Allj.."'n"n'.n.rl darif<calio"'o,,..,lin~ 1"",_ Co"I,.."'o, Li<orl'in~. Funll1!3
R....onlo..<II."~<_Cnn....."'onu..eolli"cCo"rl."forlltrirl"'..""',..i,.. f.... olheT "."olir
PravKlus FeeSch"dule Saclion WehSilBOnlv
FF3 not appl,cable DOImantCertlllcatesotCompete~cy
a)nolapplrcable Contractor $8700
b) not applicable SpeaanvComract01 $72.00
P"n"~vl,,e' aftAr Q./30- 10%unliI12/31
v....i~.I< .od ....'.I".I..lh. TNt"...!. \~. neM 011"",", "olf '0 011.,,11 ,h.", ,"<flin~.
'1.0' 10 do Ih. ''''""T,,h foctl.. m"<:lin~, Tho m..rtin~.. usu"l;,' I."" lon~.c Ih.n.n
""i'I"""""n2.nll3hou".afUl.IS1IHllh,lhalwouldl'u.our,'.noos'hotw...."
10al1<nd
PIOIl<)AA<lF"eSchAduleSAchon
CO
c) Pre-appllcalio~ meeting S2~0 00 (to be credite<1 toward apolicallo~ fee upon submlllal)
"nn"'.nl"l/LaOli<<'l'j"~.hnd 1.11
ProoosedfeeSd,ooulcS"ctio~
CD
1311nlarmal WeIland Jurisd,ctional (\eterm'~atlo~ tor 5'nglA iamily p~rcels up to 5 acres - $300.00
1I.li...dn~ I<~.l ('I' documont<' ,011 sile vi,i, OH ohli~alio"-' ur'h" proc." and.n houri)
ok,a f,,1I II.,
ProPO.ad FenSChod<lla SllChot1
CH
114) COfl.Smv~t'on Easemonl ravlew i"". $300 00 a"pllcal,on JAA pius lbe follOWing add~Kl~al srtfl
liaes:$2000QlmCEac'eslesstllan5acres $400.00 for CE area be1wee~ 5 acres e~d 10 acres
1~60000lorCE areawaalerthan 10 actes and les.~1I1an20acres,$800.00forCE: areasoolween
~O and 50 acres; aM a~ addlhonal $200 00 for everv40 acre>; al CE area over ~o acres
10,i()1l"'f,,nnw,"~ ,,,,'i,,,,',, II>j".vi>il,tl,o,n\l(" h.w 11111",... eo,''''"u'' 01 lIu'l'"r<,'I",
I F"d,'",lv"i,lrlinc>andllOlki,.>.4In'lu<<llo,lrd,,'ieol."i".n<,'and,,,...hn~'''';lh
,.Ii,'" n.,'j".., I" oil o~<"'-)' prcmi" I" .""n "",""Ii.n".,
I Plono""" ~~~ Sche<1ulc Sect",,,
I""
115) Listed or Prolected Speaes ,evlewfee lWt1e~ an EIS <s nol r&<,ui,oo) $100000
- ~u",1 II]
h.<~" mud, hi~hrr Ta'e"lte,olu,ion a r ,mv...IM Ih" IW1;.ll1') (.1.11)
ProoosedFeeSch€duleSec"on
ee,
a) LenB," of RecFprodly $2~ 00
b) Conlractors Changa 01 Status (actJVeto dormant)
h.c~r ,""oh li;~h<.. ralo' m...oluli.." Il'rn'M )""h< rlJI on l11i16.'1\71
ProPOsod F~n Sc.hadula Soctio"
FF2CAriihC!lte~urCompAtencYIAnnual)
alConlractOl
In~lal License Fee 515000
RanewalFee S10000
h) Sreaa~y Contractor
I~~'al L'ce~se Fee $135.00
RooowalFoe $8500
c) Jaurnoym""
lnihalLJr.ensaFee :;;5000
RenawalFae $bOO
h'l"V.,"""hhi~lIrr"'I..(II...oluliono)I"ov<<lh,.'lIo,Ul"n 111/1611I71
Prooosed F~~ Schedule Sact,en
FF3DofmantCertjhcatosoICompolen"y(Annual) I
[
a)Conlractol $10000 I
b) Specialty Conlractor $8500
r.)Panaltylaes after 9/30 $1000parmonlhunljl'2131
'"
'"
."
""
..,
ill,
po
,,'
lten';
'J~; .
-:00
.,verr:L:'::=;'
~,""j
20Ci~'
PaJ::' ~.::, of ::'(,
AUoohmer',:C. ~umm.ryotpr,"",,'eucnor>ge'tolheCOESteescheu"le
BMBO-Iw
UlX1a,eo1112N2007
Agenda Item NO.1 OU
November 27. 2007
Page; 50 of 50
I{ea.on lOT chan~. _ Conlr.rlD," me Collier Counh forth,ir I." ex leIl,i~< r..., olbe, <oumi.
PrllViousFeeSch9duleSocI,on Web S,te Onlv
'"
g) nolapplicat!je C"r1;fi"dcopie.;ofExpe"enca~er5$1.00ea
h) noi applicable nolappllcable
i)notapplicable ootapplicable
Ch.n~< .'4: Proposed f"" Chao\:o. Failur. tn Ohlllloa ".rmil
R""..." _ The I.. a' .,.,rrm1I~' ..rlnen i. "'" ~lullabl<. for f..,. under $HO,IKI a 4x thr f.., ehs
permit p,..,ml.. of'''' pr<l~..m i, 10 .chicve tOml.lI.n.< ..ilh tho LanrlD.....I"I'm.nc Code and
and not' "'00'''. a lJro,"'rh ""ocr who i. Inlormo<l "f. vlola';nn a"d., ~i.. fnr" ....millo cn
PrevIous Fee Schedule Sec1lon
'"
1. Whare 'MI1i< for which a pBrm~ is required is startlld or proca8CIed wrth poor 10
obtain"',g said permit, Ihefoos he,,,inspeclhed shall be4x 1118 ,eguler leeootloexC800
$1,OOOOOforpennitscosting $250,00 end less The pene~y forfeilura 10 obta,n a permrt
whenonelsreQU~edhavlng a cost greater then $250.00 snail be2xtt>eragularemoun!
Thepaynllml of such f""shall nol ral,eve any person tromfufly complYing with lhe
requiramanlsofanyappllcablaconstrudioncodaorordinanreinlheaxawt,onof Ihe
wo'\(, or trom any penalty prescribed withIn allY collstructlon code. law or ordinallce of
ColherCounty
O..ItI:"3S:Prol_.d_f..'.Mi5""II.n.....'
R...on. Justlfl"",t1on for SRA & DRI f.",. Th. f"" for PlID I, '>.1.250 ond.n SRA i, a twin flf
flfr.-i",,' FIAM_Wllhthisf..in ~ao.th. uafi"'ofthc.uhminalwlttimlr<l'/c.
Prell....usFeeScheduIOS&e!lon
'"
e) Not ApplicaMa
1) Not Apphcabla
g)Nolappficabla
Ch:o.o~. 36: Adjuslmttll & ClarffiClltlon." an .xl'lin~ 1'.. _ Mlseclta"""""
R.......n. So lllal 11.0 lanjW_h'" .....,mlll"" whal i. "_IM;n R....lut;on ~11-4~~ thaI wa, aPflm'M
P'av'ousFeeSchedUlaSect,on
"
9. Photocopies of documenls less than 11x17 Inchas: No Charge for first 5 copoas of one
s;d9d,twosid9d,otllalsgasatcoslofproductlon6thalldsuhsequentphotocopiasof
dooumantsiasslhan l1xl7inchas: $0,15 one sidad,$0.201v.<l s;ded,OtOOf Slzas alcost
ofprodudlOn
a) Cartifiocl copy of pubfic 'a<X>rd $1,00 e8Lh
b) NolApptiCllble
c)NoIApplicabie
~
..
tiar~e much hl~hcr TIll.. (Resolution .PI.."".... If)' thr CUI on IIl/lMI7)
ProoosedFeaSchedulcSection
FF4 Ralnstatement of DelinQuent L,cense
a) ContraClor $150.00 plus back years
b) SpeClllltyContrllctor $135.00 plus bacl< years
c) Journeyman $50.00 plus bad< years
d) Examination Admonist'ative Fee $100.00goodlor6 mofllhs
hae~.muohhl~lll.rra'o'f1k",lutiDDa lro...lh"ll..CLB..nlOlIM17)
ProDosedFeeSchllduleSacl....n
'"
g) Cerlifoadcopoesof ExperillOcelellers $35.00
h) Dupiicate or rllpjllcament (Of Compelancy CIIfds) $25,00
i) Saoolld entity application faa $100.00
.wo~lrll.. ~""'lcr Illrn tho h tll. fco for H l",rml. roslin~ SlSl.1Il1. Th'. basi.
e ..Imirla hultdi~~ Codo. Tho .y't~m .h....ld "1CO~ra~o volu""f)' ooml~i""""
.intDNlmlUaO.O
prouosedF"',ScheduleSechofl
'"
1. Whera work farwh,ch a pefTDn is re<:lui'ed Isslarled or proceeded with prior 10 obtain ingsaKJ
pafTDit a"'" were such adlOn waS c<led by Code Enforcemant or by Conlractor Licens ingand
lesulted In a flrlding 01 oiolalion trom eill'erlha Code Enforcarnent Boa rd. thllSpac<alMagislrllte,01
Iha Contrador Licensong or as directed llylhe Board of County CommisslOnars lha f easheram
sr>eci~ocI shall be 4, the 'egulll' lee
2. Whareworkfolwl'lchapermnlsfeQuired is slar1ed 0' proC8009dwith pnorl oobtaillingsaid
pefTf11t a"'" whate II oolltradororagentlprovldllrwharllthebuildll19 offICial ar zanj ngdirector(for
casas '"oololl1g larid dllvelopment) dearns Ihat Ihe oonlladorlprov,dBr stlOuld have known Ihal a
permitwasrequ,redbulvotuntary.eal<soomplillncabyobta'ntnglheoooassaryr>ermitsloabi1!athB
vlo!atlon the faes herain specif,oo sl1all bo ~x tne ragulaf faa
3 Whereworkforwhici'apennillsreQu"oo isstarledorprooaedadwitllpriortoobtainmgsaid
permrt and where an ownerlouildar saeks voluntary comphanca by Obtaining said permrt InB f.....s
assessedwitlbe2xthe'egularratoaSdefinocllnth,sfeeschedulll
4. Where wo,k for which a perrnn ,sreQuired is "lar1ad Of proceaded with p'io' I o oblaining said
permilandwi,erlllt,e unpelmill9d"""rkwascomplafed byolhe' 0' prior 10 Ihe current
oWllllrlbuiklar'. oWllerSh'p 01 the proper1y all wherethll currant OWt\Bllbulloorseek svoiunlary
oomplianoo by obtaining .aid permrt to a.sure compliance wilh sll applicable cod... tha f.....s will be
aosessedaltheragularraleasdllfilledin!hist..esd'edula
5.Thapaymentof,uchleashallnotrllliaveanypa,sonfromfullyoompIYII19 with Ihe reQuirement
ofallYllpplicablecoflSlructlOnoodllorordinanoainthaaxecut'onofthev.<lrk. orfmm any penalty
praOCflbocl withIn any construction code, law Of ordinanCII 01 Collier County
IComl' Plannln~ j, r"'l~es1in~ fces wilh inllut from Znninjl, Eown""rintu
I,,' PIIIl. lllu' rerl"iro, v;Mualt" identic:JI review, llort DIU l,.lmll.rl nPlTlliD,co\l'r
Pmoosed Fee ScheduieSadion
'"
aISRASleward.hipReooivingAras-$2,250.00
f) ORI Dllvelopment of Ragional Impact-$2,250.00
g)FIAM,FI.callmpadAnaiysis-$4,OOOOO
,.,. tho Bo.ed nfCounl~' COD'ml,sion~... on n"'151'1~
ProoosedFeeScl1eduteSIIC\....1l
"
9.Staffshallchargethefollowingfe,,"lorduplicationotpu~icfeco'd$
a)$0.15Ioleachoflll~dadpholocopyofdocumantslasslh8nl1,17inches
b)$0.20foreachtwo.idlld pholooopynfctocumllf)l.iessthan 11x17 inches
c)$1.00 for each cllrtifu,d oopyof a public record
Cba"l!c 32: Adjumnl'flt and clarificatioo 10 C"'Sfiof( I....' - C..nlractor Ucc",in~ - l'und 113
Rca,"" I'nr dl.n~e _ Contracto,", u,e com.r (;ounjv foe thcir les. c.'..nsiv~ foes, olhor C<lunli.. <
Pravious Fee Schadule Section
WabSrteOnlv
FF4notapplicabla
Rainslatemlllll 01 DelinQuant Licalloe
a) not applicable
b)nolappllcabla
c) ootappl,cable
Contractor $87.00 plus 10%
Specialtycolltractor $72.00pluslO"k
Journeyman $15.00 plus 10%
Examination Admlllislrative tea $25.00 perllmll
Ch_RIlc 33: Adlumncnr Mnd cl.rili..lion IU ~."tin~ r"", - L..nlra<ler U<ell!;ln~. Fund ll~
Allachma~IC Summa,yoiprwoaedo,,,,"O...lothIlCDESf@lIsch&dule
BMBO-Iw
updalad11/2012007
Agenda Item NO.1 OV
November 27. 2007
Page 1 of 45
~.-
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to adopt a Resolution amending the Collier County Administrative Code
Fee Schedule of development-related review and processing fees as provided for in The
Code of Laws and Ordinances, Section 2-11 (Companion Item to 16A12)
OBJECTIVE: To have the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) approve a resolution
amending the Collier County Administrative Code Fee Schedule of development-related review
and processing fees as provided for in The Code of Laws and Ordinances, Section 2-11.
CONSIDERATION: The vast majority of operations within the Building Review and
Permitting Department of the Collier County Community Development and Environmental
Services Division (CDES) are funded by fees related to the issuance of building permits.
Sensitive to the economic conditions within the community, CDES is remaining consistent in its
commitment to maintain the current fee levels for these fees, which have remained unchanged
since 2003. This proposal is to adjust the timing of such fees, and to adjust the calculation of
such fees to a more fair and consistent methodology.
-
The first proposed ehange concerns that portion of the building permit fee that is collected at the
time the application is submitted, often referred to as thc Application Fee, which is
approximately 8% to 16% of the total building permit fee. The remaining portion of the total
building permit fee is collected at the time the permit is actually issued. This initial 8% to ] 6%
is not refundable, despite whether the pennit is actually issued or not. This Fee Schedule
proposal requests the initial application fee be raised to 25% of the total permit cost, with the
remaining 75% being charged at pernlit issuance. Collecting 25% of the fee at application
covers a significant portion ofthe cost incurred for the plan rcview.<Ind approval process.
CDES staff believes that such a small proportion of the building permit fee being charged at
application has been a factor in contributing to the large rushes of permit applications just prior
to recent building code changes and impact fee revisions. With little financial consequence to
submitting large numbers of applications, the current timing of permit fees encourages
speculative submissions of applications, often detached from actual construction demand. Of the
rush of building permit applications, tor new homes, which were submitted just prior to the June,
2006 impact fee revisions, applications for over 2,000 dwelling units were never issued. These
2,000 dwelling units underwent full staff reviews and processing, with only a small fraction of
the costs recovered by the 8%, to 16% application fee. During periods of building code or impact
fee revisions sueh as June, 2006, an applicant could submit lOa building permit applications and
recover their applieation fees in cost savings if only I application was eventually issued.
-
The effects of such speculative rushes in building permit applications have several effects on
CDES operations, including:
. Since all applications are reviewed and processed, a large portion of CDES costs are not
fully recovered until permit issuance, and the costs of non-issued applications is borne
by revenue received by unrelated issued permit activity.
. Large numbers of building permit applications submitted on speculation skew future
CDES activity projections, creating difficulty in planning future staffing levels. The
Aaenda Item No.1 0\/
.j~overnbei 27. 2007
Page 2 of 45
rush in applications prior to the June, 2006 impact fee change came during the FY 07
budget approval process, leading to increased inspector staffing levels which later
needed to be largely reduced when large numbers of applications were never issued.
. Large numbers of speculative applications create large pools of future inventory which
significantly delay the intended effects of building code or impact fee changes.
The increase to a 25% initial payment on building pemlit application will not change the total
cost of securing a building permit, nor will it prevent applicants from submitting applications just
prior to building code or impact fee changes and being grandfathered. it is CDES' s belief that
this change will create a closer relationship between application levels and actual construction
demand.
The second proposed change in the fee schedule related to the issuance of building permits
involves the methodology used to calculate fee amounts. Currently fees are based on declared
construction valuations, with tables in thc fee code determining minimum valuation amounts.
These tables have rates which are fractional of actual construction costs, and the majority of
declarations are significantly above table amounts. The result of this existing fee calculation
method is that building permit fees can vary significantly for the same sized project, often as
much as 5 fold, despite little difference in the workload incurred by CDES staff. CDES costs are
directly related to the total revenue generated by such permits, so those applicants who declare
full actual valuations are essentially subsidizing those applicants who declare the legal minimal
valuations. This fee system is also tiered, with larger projects paying a much smaller percentage
of their valuations in fees than smaller projects. Further. this system creates inefIiciencies, with
considerable staff time being absorbed in discussions with applicants over declared construction
val uations.
This proposed fee schedule revision requests to change new construction building permit fees to
a flat per square footage basis. All structures of the same size will pay the same building permit
fee, and all structures will pay the same per square footage rate despite size differences. To
insure a revenue neutral result, all building permits actually issued from October 1, 2004 until
present were examined, with the actual fce charged and the fee generated from this proposed
change compared. The new proposed methodology would have generated the same total revenue
during this period. Because of the removal of fee tiers, smaller structures will see fee reductions,
and larger projects will see cost increases. A comparison of new and proposed fees for new
homes shows the following, based on the proposed fee of $0.29 per square foot:
Sq Footage
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
3,500
4,000
Old
Fee
$380
$504
$629
$754
$879
$1,004
$1,128
Proposed
Fee
$290
$435
$580
$725
$870
$U)]5
$1,160
New commerc.ial construction would have a fee of $0.29 per square foot, with $0.145 being
charged for warehouses or shells, and an additional $0. I 45 at build-out. This fee compares
favorably to other jurisdictions using such a methodology:
Aqenaa Item No.1 0\1
l~ov'?mber 27. 2007
F'age 3 of 45
. Lee County 0.15 for shell/warehouse, 0.15 build-out = 0.30 total
. Lake County 0.18 for shell / warehouse, 0.20 build-out, =0.38 total
. Sumter County 0.17 of shell/warehouse. 0.15 build-out. =0.32 total
. Hernando County 0.3 1 total
. Pinellas County 0.37 total
Alterations which are not associated with new square footage will continue to be charged by the
valuation method, based on the same overall average rate already in effect, only with tiers
removed.
The original version of this proposal was discussed with the Development Services Advisory
Committee (DSAC) at their September 5, 2007 meeting, and revisions were made to the proposal
based on their input, and revenue neutral calculations were refined. The resulting revised
proposal was resubmitted to DSAC at their November 7,2007 meeting, and following agreement
on lowering the proposed building permit fee trom $0.30 to $0.29 and the upfront portion from
50% to 25%, the proposal was approved by a vote of 10-0. In their action, DSAC endorsed the
methodology as a fair method of detennining building permit fees, endorsed the proposed rates
as completely revenue neutral. and expressed no concerns or issues for BCC consideration.
Included with this Executive Sunm1ary are: Attachment "A"- the revised CDES Fee Schedule,
Attachment "B"- the Resolution, Attachment "C"- CDES Fee Schedule side by side
comparisons, and Attachment "D" - CDES Fee Schedule strike-through version.
FISCAL IMPACT: This Executive Summary requires, nor requests, any increase in the current
allocation of CDES operating or personnel expenses already approved by the BCe. It is
anticipated that this requcsted fee schedule revision will have no net revenue impact.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There are no growth management impacts.
LEGAL CONSIDERA nONS: This request has been review by the Collier County Attorney's
Office, and is legally sufficient for the Board of County Commissioners consideration and
approval.
RECOMMENDATION: To have the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) approve a
resolution amending the Collier County Administrative Code Fee Schedule of development-
related review and processing fees as provided for in The Code of Laws and Ordinances,
Section 2-11.
PREPARED BY: Garrett Mullee, Manager CDES Business Management and Budget Office.
--
Item Number:
Item$ummllry:
Meeting Date:
Page 1 or
COLLIER COUNTY
5Up,p,r.. :)F C:()Uf;~\ ::::CHJl~.~:SSiOI,:~T~,
(;~O~lr-,,'I1Cl2 ':)1' te cYF:r', c; ~..'f'V)IUllOn ,,1:m nilil10 t!'l -: (i ilC '~:0'"1:1l1' i..cw' '11:-,): ,JlIV[, ::(id"
c</k')UI,
,,~< T('-
I",'
-.r'''''k''
'Ui: ,,~.,
d _"Vie
('>']."1:- L~~
)rll~"..I' i", : C;'\'P (]~ '11'.'1' ,,\.'\~.fc'~~r
r",
;C. tn~ "Cd I ';.lD'.'r"t I"''''' r..~ cl ''''p'.''
()J1.(-
Prepared B~
e",re!'! MullN
:,ommUI :;vi-,e\.'clopmonti;
[nvlronnmntil;Ser','lc"5
hn,l!1e,r;! Adm'" I;; h"u"in~"
,'1/12/20.", ~ :)~"1~,' Ptl'
i',S5'Sl"nt County AttQrn(')
UJtt
A.pproved 8)'
.Jel' r.1~tV..QV
County Attornny
(..ou"t', Attorney Offici_'
11:14Ij(jG73W;I'M
Apprll"ed ill'
t:xecui:ve.:'B:rcctJr',
[i,'ltl
:iiim('neSlewart
Communn.y UfO\." wpml,r1
f':nv"onn,,'nt,.1 c,f'r',";t'~
::',"""'LJI1;'" IJuv"IQ<,r'"nl"
t:n\,,,onm,,m~' S'''Vlcr-,,', Aqrn,r
. "14i/(l07 144 P~'-
.'Ll"'. hi;'.
;In'.))).,:""n ;,n~'''--'
.,,1t'
Allpr"ved By
';{)m",uni:v IJevclQomct.:
Fh\WOnm""t,,' ,,'-"','r~'"
~,nrTl"'Unil' Uevt:icprnn,i' G
, 1 1': 4 2nU, ~;:::' p ~.
t::kJ>r'."""'.-.
_""nlt;
- . ~'rr"L1 ,In'' L..(-.'," .' "'" ,,,,,'
~ "'t.
AllprOVl'd H)'
.1C'~""i;' ;':C'" d.
""., ,')(.,"V0IL'," "".."
E.nvi""'In(.'''t,/SrerllC'''"
:',)'/,r"'"',','''I'''
""','-1,"" ['C""'Hlrr,,'.'
: \11 ~'~'[j-::~
~,n',""''''[j,<,. lJ' Sc'\.',c ;.,(1'1'",
".iJlJ'i'",,,"""
';;:h
Appruvt'd Ill'
';'ff;:',,,rciln.
';'fim,n$t;'1U"I"'''''",-",
",1'''''11:.I,,,,1,,.r''.''''''''''
'.'21',,----
..,~,
bU6,lf.: iUHive,.
[.at<:
ApllrovNI By
ri;;rr, bL~v.~0r'
c,-"",r" I.",'"~(-JC 01\'<;"
,1ff,v, '}I' P"I,"'~q"I1'''' : &. l'5UC~)C'
1:1Cj/20e'" .j(; r,~.'
~,.~'cn~,.,~ ',mv,"-"wsf<i
!f,l<1"n,>rn"nf& bUl!w.;t [.,,,,cr'},
[jJt,.,
A.11llrnved By
CDum,' M"n~qH'" O!i,~(
C)'I'G(-: of r;;~r~(l"men: i~ EW(Ju,c'<
1."'Ji2JG7l,::PI'
Apprnvt'd Uy
Jdme~. V Muu,l
bOMd Df Count~,
~',nmfl"';~I(>nH'
:~"ufll'/ M"nau'/
Um"
;;O\ltlt r,';"na,1l" ,.C-,p,c,
11," ~!i200; t, :'0 pr..~
tile:! 1C:\AgendaT est\Export\93- Novemberl%2027 ,%202007\ 1 0.%20COUNTY%20MANA.. 11/20/2007
Aoend2 item No. .lDV
November 27, 2007
Page::; of 45
RESOLUTION NO. 2007-_
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA,
AMENDING THE COLLIER COUNTY COMMUNITY
DEVELOPMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES FEE
SCHEDULE; SUPERSEDING RESOLUTION NO. 2007-160;
AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
\VHEREAS, on June 26, 2007, the Board of County Commissioners approved Resolution
No. 2007-160, establishing a fee schedule for services performed by Collier County's
Community Development and Environmental Services Division; and
WHEREAS, the Board recognizes that revisions to this fee schedule are necessary to
reflect the actual cost incurred by the County.
NOW. THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA that:
The Board of County Commissioners hereby declares that the fees set forth in the Collier
County Community Development and Environmental Services Fee Schedule, set forth as Exhibit
"A," are all fair and reasonable sums to be assessed to those who receive the benefits of the
services, reviews, and inspections required pursuant to the Land Development Code and the
County's corresponding development review and permitting processes.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Resolution be recorded in the minutes of this
Board with an immediate effective date upon the Board of Coumy Commissioners approval, and
that Resolution No. 2007-160 is hereby superseded by the adoption of this Resolution effective
as stated above.
This Resolution adopted after motion, second and majority vote, this ~ day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
. Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA.
Chairman
Ap
legal sufficiency:
"
I~;
t,..,o....,r'::;' irorr, \ r, 1 \!
T-Jovember 27, 2007
P8C18 6 0' 45
c:;
c
y
c:;
"
u
M
<
y
-
EXHIBIT B
COLLIER COUNTY COMMUNITY
ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
DEVELOPMENT AND
FEE SCHEDULE
Bee Proposed version, November 27, 2007
Contents:
A) ADMINlSTI{A TION.... . .._.. ...2
B} BLASTING PERMITS & INSPECTION ........... ............................. ..................................2
C) ENVIRONMENT AL/LANDSC APING _. . ..2
D) EXCAVATION PERMITS... .......3
E) fiRE CODE REVIEW FEES....... .. ........ ... ........................ ................................4
F) S]TE DEVELOPMENT PLANS.. . ....................... .................................. ....... .........4
(I) SUBDIVISION... ... ...................... .......... ..... ..................5
1-1) ENCilNEERING INSPECTION FEES .6
[) TEMf'ORARV.lJSE PERMITS.. ........................... .......... ......... .......................0
.J) WELL PERMITS/INSPECTIONS.. .. ............ ........... ............................. .........................7
K) ZONING/LAND LSE PETITIONS.. .................. ...... ....... ................... ............... 7-S
l) MISCELL\NJOlIS ......_..._..........9
M) BlJILDING PERMIT APPLICATION FEE.. . . . .... .... .11
Nj BUILDIN(j PERMIT HTS. ................................... ...... ................... ...... .....11
0) ELECTI{!('AL PERMIT FEI::S.. ...--...........__...._........ .._12
p) PLlJMBINCi PERMIT FEES. _.. . .....12
0) MITHANICAL PERM!T FEES.. .........]3
R) rlRE I'REVENTI()N AND CONTROL PERM]"] FEES_. . ............__. ..__...._......_.13
S) MOBILE IIOMEiOFF1CE TRAILER AND OTI-IER TRAILER PERMIT FEES.. ._13
I) CHICK.EES AND SIMILAR STRIICTURES.... .............................. ....... ...... ....... ..... .................13
lJ) POOL OR SPA PERMIT FEES... . .. ....................................................-____..... ........................ .13
\') SCREEN ENCLOSURE PERMIT &. PAN ROOF FEES.. . . ............ .......... ............................................... .... .... . .14
W) SIGN PERM!T FEES.. . .. .................................................................... ..... ....... . ..14
X) CONVENIENCE PERMIT FEES.. . ._._...!4
Y) REVISION AND AS BlJILT PLAN REV!EW FEES; CORRECTIONS TO PLANS.. .. ._..]4
Z) PERMIT EXTENSION. .. .......... ........... ..... ...............................__......................................]5
AA) DEMOLITION OF BUILDING OR STRIICTURL PERMIT FEES_... .... .. .15
HH) PRE-MOVING INSPECTION FEES.._.. .. ......... ................. ................ ............... ...... ..... ...........15
ec) INSPECTION FEES.. .....__.....15
OD) REINSPECTION FEES.. ... ........................................................................... ....... .....15
EE) FA]LlJRE TO OI-n'A]N A PERMIT.. 15
FF) LICENSING.. ... . .. ... .........................-......-... ..........._......16
GG) DUPLICATE PERMIT CARDS.. .. ....................... .........16
HH) CHANGE OF CONTRACTOR OR SUBCONTRACTORS.. .. ....]6
II) PERMIT FEE REFUNDS.. ............................................... ............. ......... ...1 ()
J.l).RECORD RETRIEV AL.. .......... .... ................................... .....................................16
K.K) COPY FEES.. .. ...... ........ ............. ......................................................................17
LL) RESEARCH ..... .. .17
MM) SUBSCRIPTION SERVICE.._. ................................. ................ ....................... ... .........17
NN) ELECTRONIC DATA CONVERSION SURCHARCiE .... ....... ]7
(0) REGISTRATION OF RENTAL DWELLINGS... ... .. .... ....................................17
1'1') CERTIFICATE TO BOARD B]LLlNG . ...................... ................._........_............... ..................17
QQ) ADDITIONAL FEE REFUND PROVIS]ONS.. ....... ....... .................................... .................lls
RR) REFUND PROVISIONS.. ...... 18
SS) ADDIT]ONAL FEE PROVISIONS... ......... ... .... IS
TT) PUBLIC VEH]CLE FOR HIRE FEES.. ......... ............._.18
lJUj"PAYMENT IN LIEU OF" FEE FOR PATHWA'lS (S!DEWALKS, AND BIKE LANES).. ......... .19
Fees are in bold
CDES Financia] Administration, rev IlID/07 Iw
page I
f:,.np.....,..I.... Ito 11.1" 1(\\/
l~ovember 27, 2007
Page 7 of ~5
FEES ARE ESTABLISHED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS RESOLUTION, AND CANNOT
BE WAIVED OR SUSPENDED WITHOUT AN ACTION BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS.
ANY QUESTIONS CONCERNING THE APPLICABILITY OF FEES SHALL BE CONCLUSIVELY
DETERMINED BY THE DIRECTOR OF THE APPROPlA TE DEPARTMENT. AS APPLICABLE. WHERE AS
PART OF A REZONING. PLAT OR SIMILAR APPLICATION TYPE, THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS DIRECTS APPROVAL OF FUTURE DEVELOPMENT ORDERS DIFFERENT FROM THE
STANDARD TYPE OF APPROVAL PROCESSES REQUIRED, THE DIRECTOR OF THE APPROPRIA TE
DEPARTMENT SHALL DETERMINE THE FEES TO BE APPLIED TO THE PROCESS NECESSARY TO MEET
THE BOARDS REQUIREMENTS THE APPLICABLE FEES SHALL BE THOSE WHICH MOST CLOSELY
RESEMBLE THOSE CHARGED FOR SIMILAR PROCESSES INCLUDING EXTRA FEES FOR ADVERTISING
AND THE LIKE.
A) ADMINISTRATION
I) Official Interpretation Request of Land Development Code (LDC). Growth Management Plan (GMP), or
Building Construction Administrative Code (Administrative Code). Based on staff hours: Less than 20 hours
$1.500.00,20 to 40 hours $3,000,00, more than 40 hours $5,000.00
2) Interpretation request submitted in conjunction with a land use petition or requested during site development
plan review process. $250.00
3) Detemlination of Vested Rights. $100.00 (plus the County's out-of-pocket expenses associated \I,'ith hearing
officer and hearings)
4) Appeal of Vested Rights Detennination. $100.00
5) Amendment to Land Development Code. $3\000.00
6) Appeal of an Administrative Decision (as may be provided for in the Collier County Administrative Code or
the LDC). $1000.00 (non-refundable)
7) Appeal to Board of Zoning Appeals or Building Board of Adjustments and Appeals (as may be provided for in
the Collier County Administrative Code or the LDC). $1.000.00 (non-refundable)
BI BLASTING PERMITS & INSPECTION
I) 30 day pennit fee, non-refundable payable upon application. $250.00
2) 90 day penn it fee. non-refundable payable upon application. $600.00
3) Yearly pennit fee, non-refundable payable upon application. $1,500.00
4) Renewal pennit fee, non-refundable payable upon application. $200.00
5) After-the-fact fee, due to blasting without a pennit. $10,000.00
6) Fine fee, per detonated shot with after-the-fact penn it. $200.00
7) Handler fee, for handler who assists the user or blaster in the use of explosives. $] 00.00
8) Blasting Inspection Fee. $200.00 (per inspection)
9) Inspection fees shall be paid upon issuance of a blasting permit based on the estimated number of
blasts. Upon completion, fees will be adjusted to reflect actual number of blasts.
C) ENVIRONMENT AL/LANDSCAPING
1) Site Clearing Permit, first acre or fraction of an acre. $250.00 Each additional acre or fraction of
an acre. $50.00 ($3,000.00 maximum I
2) Agricultural Land Clearing
a. Land Clearing Notification $250.00
CDES Financial Administration, rev I 1;lJ.'07 I.....
page 2
!\rt;:::.nr-l'::l Ih::'n"11\lr! 1(',\.1
November 27, 2007
b, Land Clearing Permit $250.00 each additional acre or fraction of an acre. $50.00 ($3,1l!lll1ll<B of 45
maximum)
3) Landscape Tree Removal Fee $250
..
,-
4) Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) $2,500.00 for 1 st submittal and 2"d'suhinittaI if applicable,
3rd submittal $1,000.00, 4th and subsequent submittals $500.00 each
5) Landscape Re-inspection 1" $50.00, 2"d $75.00, every inspection afterward $100.00
6) Vehicle on the Beach Permit Application. $250.00 (Permit fee shall be waived for public and
non-profit organizations engaging in environmental activities for scientific, conservation or
educational purposes).
7) Beach Nourishment Permits - $400
8) Special Treatment Review
a. First five acres or less. $400.00
b. Each additional acre, or fraction thereof. $50.00 ($5,000.00 Maximum)
c. Pre-application meeting $250.00 (to be credited toward application fee upon submittal)
9) Coastal Construction Setback Line (CCSL):
a. CCSL Permits $400.00
b, Variance - Petition. $1000.00
10) Sea Turtle Permit-
a. Sea Turtle Handling Permits. $25.00
b. Sea Turtle Nesting Area Construction Permit. $200.00
c. Sea Turtle Nest Relocation. $100.00
11 ) Vegetation Removal Permit
a. First acre or fraction of an acre less. $250.00
b. Each additional acre, or fraction thereof. $50.00 ($3,000.00 Maximum)
12) After-the-fact Environmental or Landscape Pemlits
a. CCSL Variance Petition. 2x normal fee
b. All other Environmental or Landscape Permits. 4x normal fee
13) Infonnal \\7etland Jurisdictional determination for single family parcels up to 5 acres - $300.00
14) Conservation Easement review fee - $300.00 application fee plus the following additional site fee:
$200.00 for CE acres less than 5 acres; $400.00 for CE area between 5 acres and 10 acres; $600.00
for CE area greater than 10 acres and less than 20 acres; $800.00 for CE areas between 20 and 50
acres; and an additional $200.00 for every 40 acres of CE area over 50 acres.
15) Listed or Protected Species review fee (when an EIS is not required) - $1000.00
D) EXCA V AnON PERMITS
I) Annual Renewal. $300.00
2) Application (Private). $400.00
3) Application (Commercial). $2,000.00
4) Apphcation (Development). $400.00
5) $200.00 per inspection paid in advance for 12 months
6) Reapplication: $300.00 plus $200.00 per month inspection fee
7) Cubic Yardage Review Fee: $200.00 first 5000 cy, plus $10.00 per additional 1000 cy with a
maximum of $20,000.00
8) Time Extension. $150.00 plus $200.00 per month inspection fee
9) After.the-fact Excavation Permit. 4x application fee
CDES Financial Admini~tration, rev 111l3/071w
page 3
L.,:::. "' iT;;orr, [\1<\ ~ IIV
h!ovemae:. 27, 2007'
10) Over excavation penalty fee per yard. Plus PermitlReview $0.05 per cubic yard fee, unless fi1D.@!Oriumf 45
have been paid.
E) FIRE CODE REVIEW FEES
1) Fire Code Review fees associated with each of the following processes:
$200.00
$150.00
SIOO.OO
S150.00
SIOO.OO
S150.00
$100.00
SIOO.OO
S]()O.OO
SIOO.OO
S)OO.OO
S200.00
S150.00
S150.00
S150.00
S]()O.OO
SIOO.OO
S!50.00
SDP ~ Site Development Plan
SDP A - Site Development Plan. Amendment
SDPI - Site Development Plan. Insubstantial
SIP - Site Improvement Plan
SIPI - Site Improvement Plan. Insubstantial
PSP - Preliminary Subdivision Plan<.;
PSP A - Preliminary Subdivision Plans, Amendment
PPL - Plans & Plat. Subdivision
FP - Final Plat
CONSTR - Construction Plans, Subdivision/Utilities
Iep - Construction Plans. insubstantial
DRI - Development of Regional Impact
m. DOA - Development Order. Amendment
PUDZ - Planned Unit Development Rczone
PUDA - Planned Unit Development, Amendment
PDJ - Planned Unit Development. Insubstantial
RZ - Rezone. Regular Zoning
CU - Conditional Use
a.
b.
c.
d.
e.
f.
"
e'
b.
I.
J.
k.
I.
n.
o.
p.
q.
r.
F) SITE DEVELOPME]\"T PLANS
]) Site Develnpmenl Plan Review (SDP). S5000.00
a. plus S40.00 per DiU
b. plus StoO.OO per residential building structure
c. plus $.10 per square foot for non-residential except that struClUres designed exclusively for parking
(parking garages) shall be calculated at $.05 per square foot.
d. plus $200.00 per building for non-residential
c. Additional fees for 31'<1 review $1,000.00, 41h review $],500.00. 5th review $2,000.00, 6th and
subsequent reviews $2,500.00
When a building consist of both residential and non-residential (commercial, retail, office) uses. the following
fees will apply.
a. $5000.00 base fee plus $40.00 per Dill
b. S200.00 per building for non-residential
c. plus $0.10 per square foot of non-residential floor area
d. Additional fees for 3rd revie\\i $1.000.00, 4th review $1,500.00. stl1 review $2.000.00, 6th and
subsequent reviews $2,500.00
2) Pre-application fee. $500.00 (to be credited toward application fee upon submittal.)
a. Second and subsequent pre-app meetings at the applicant"s request shall not be
credited towards application fees.
b. Second and subsequent pre-app meetings at staff\ request will be held at no charge
to the applicant.
c. Applications submitted 9 months or more after the date of the last pre-app meeting
shall not be credited towards application fees and a ne,,' pre-application meeting
will be required.
3) Simultaneous Reviev.' Fee (planning review of simultaneous building permit applications) $100.00 per building
permit application.
CDES Financial Administration. rev II /l3i()7 lw
page4
-'\ '"1Q~"';;:- li~~ I.i~ < (\\'
4) Site Development Plan Insubstantial Change
a. Site Development Plan Insubstantial Change.
additional sheet submitted.
b. Additional fees for 3rd review $1.000.00. 4th Review $1,500.00, 5th and subsequent review
$2.000.00
T,ovembe' 27. 2007
Page i 0 of L~5
$400.00 for first sheet, $100.00 for each and every
5) Site Development Plan Conceptual Revie\\' (CSP), Unified Development Plan (UDP), Neighborhood Park Site
(NPSP) $750.00
(6) Site Improvement Plan Review (SIP). $1000.00 (plus Engineering review fees)
7) Utility Plan Review & Inspection Fees-
a. Construction Document Review. 0.75%) of probable water and/or sewer construction costs
b. Construction Inspection. 2.250/0 of probable water and/or sewer construction costs
c. Construction Document Resubmission or Document Modification, submit as insubstantial change.
$150.00 for first sheet. $75,00 for each additional sheet
8) Engineering Site Plan Review Fee
a. Construction Documents Review Fee 0.750;() of probable Paving. Grading, Drainage, Lighting, Code
Minimum Landscaping, and any other appurtenant cost of construction
b. ConstructIon Inspection 2.250;(, of probable Paving, Grading, Drainage, Lighting, Code Minimum
Landscaping. and any other appurtenant cost of construction
9) Site Development Plan Amendment (SDI'A) $2,500.00,
a. Plus $40.00 per Dill plus $100.00 per residential building structure
b. plus $.10 per square foot
c. plus $200.00 per building for non-residential
d. Additional fees for 3rd reviev.' $llnOO.Oo, 4th Reviev.r $1.500.00_ 5th and subsequent review
$2.000.00
10) SBR Fees
a) Pre-Acquisition Meeting $500.00 (no refunds or credits)
b) Pre-application fee. $500.00 (to be credited toward application fee upon submittal.) (all nom,.1 pre-
application provisions apply)
c) SBR Fec $5000.00 with hourly reconciliation at project completion for hourly variation greater than
101Yo, final project charges at $100.00 per hour for all associated staff hours
11) Violation of the conditions of approval of the SDP/SIP or installation of improvements, clearing, or other
land alteration not depicted on, or othervvise authorized as a part of the approved SDP/SIP. 4x the SIP/SDP
application fee
12) Request for alternative architectural design $500.00, no separate or additional fee for appeals to, or requests
for assistance from, the Architectural Arbitration Board.
G) SUBDIVISION
I) Lot Line Adjustment (LLA) and Lot Split Review $250.00
2) Subdivision Review Fees (1'1'1.). (PPLA)-
a. Construction Documents Review Fee 0.750A) of probable Paving, Grading, Drainage, Lighting, Code
Minimum Landscaping and any other appurtenant cost of construction
b. Subdivision Inspection Fee 2.25(Yo of probable Paving, Grading, Drainage, Lighting, Code Minimum
Landscaping, and any other appUTtenant cost of construction
c. Construction Document Resubmission or Document Modification -Submit as Insubstantial Change
$400.00 for first sbeet $100.00 for eacb additional sheet
d. Subdivisions -- 3rd and subsequent additional reviews - $500.00
e. Subdivisions ~ Substantial deviations from approval construction documents $500.00
CDES Financial Administration, rev I IIl3i07lw
page 5
3) Subdivision, Preliminary Plat (PSP)-
a. Petition Application $1000.00 plus $5.00 per acre (or fraction thereof) for residential, plus $10.00
per acre (or fraction thereof) for non-residential; (mixed use is residential)
[Inc., """' 1+.0"",1\1" 1n\!
T'Jovember .27, 2007
Pa;le ~ 1 of -45
4) Subdivision Final Plat (FP) $1,000.00 plus $5.00 per acre (or fraclIon thereof) for residential, $1000.00 plus
$10.00 per acre (or fraction thereof) for nonresidential; (mixed use is residential)
5) Additional review of construction plans for phased construction of subdivision improvements. $1000.00 per
phase
6) Two-year Extension $150.00
7) Water and Sewer Facilities Construction Document Review 0.750/0 of probable water and/or sewer
construction costs
8) Construction Document Resubmission or Document Modification 0.250/0 of probable water and/or sewer
construction costs
a. 3rd and subsequent re-submittals . $500.00
9) Water and Sewer Facilities Construction Inspection Fee 2.251% of probable water and/or sewer construction
costs
10) Violation of the conditions of approval of approved construction plans or installation of improvements,
clearing, or other land alteration not depicted on, or otherwise authorized as a part of the approved
construction plans or permit. 4x the PPL PPLA, PSP, CNSTR or Final Plat Review Fee (FP).
11) Administrative Amendment $250.00
H) ENGINEERING INSPECTION FEES
I) Engineering Inspection Fee $150.00 per residential dwelling unit or accessory structure to
residential dwelling unit (single or duplex only), charged at time of building pemlit
Issuance.
2) Re-inspection Fees: 1'1 re-inspection $75.00, 2nrJ re-inspection $100.00, 31d and thereafter re-
inspection $125.00
I) TEMPORARY USE PERMITS
1) Beach Events Penn its-
a. Individual Permit $100.00
b. Block of 25 calendar days $2,250.00
c. B]ock of 50 calendar days $4,500.00
d. B]ock 01'75 calendar days $6,750.00
e. B]ock of 100 calendar days $9,000.00
f. Block of 125 calendar days $11.250.00
g. Block of ]50 calendar days $13.500.00
2) Temporary Use Permit Special Sales & Events. $200.00
3) Model Homes and Sales Centers $500.00
4) Construction and Development, Mobile home, Agricultural Zoning. and Temporary use for "Coming
Soon" sign $125.00
5) Residential and Non-Profit Garage and Yard Sale Pell11its No Charge
CDES Financial Administration, rev] l/13/07Iw
page 6
Lnc\nri:;: !rPr" j\in 1 n\!
T\lovember 27. 2007
Flags- 1~ of 45
6) Temporary Use Amendment. $JOO.OO
7) Renewals or extensions requested after the expiration date $200.00
8) Temporary Use Permit for Special Events requiring Bee approval, including Circus and Carnival
Permits. $275.00
9) Political Signs (Bulk Temporary Permit) $5.00
10) Fees for Temporary Use permits issued After the Fact, ATF: 2x normal fee
J) WELL PERMITSIINSPECTIONS
1) Hydraulic elevator shaft permit $300.00
2) Test hole permit (including 1 st six holes) $300.00, each additional hole $20.00
3) Well permit (ahandonment) $50.00
4) Well permit (construction, repair. or combined construction and abandonment at one site) $300.00
5) Well permit (monitoring) $150.00
6) Well Permit (modification of monitor/test well to a production well) $75.00
7) Well Reinspections
a. First Reinspection
b. Second Reinspection
c. Third Reinspection
$75.00
$100.00
$150.00
R) After the fact we\! permits 4x normal fee per violation.
NOTE: Multiple wells may be allowed on onc pemlit. but each well must be
accounted for and the appropriate fee shall be charged for each well in
accordance with the above listcd schedulc.
K) ZONING/LAND USE PETITIONS
1) Pre-application meeting fee $500.00 (to be credited toward application fee upon submittal.)
a. Second and subsequent pre-app meetings at the applicant's request shall not be credited towards
application fees. .
b. Second and subsequent pre-app meetings at staft's request will be held at no charge to the applicant.
c. Applications submitted 9 months or more after the date of the last pre-app meeting shall not be
credited towards application fees and a new pre-application meeting will be required.
2) Alcoholic Beverage or Service Station Separation Requirement Waiver $]000.00
3) Boat Dock Extension Petition $],500.00 Boat Lift Canopy Administrative Review $500.00
4) Conditional Use Permit $4,000.00 when filled with Rezone Petition ($1,500.00) Additional fee for 5'" and
subsequent reviews - 2001.1 of original fee.
5) Conditional Use Monitoring Review: $750.00
6) Conditional Use Extension $3,000.00
7) DR! Review (In addition to cost of rezone) $]0,000.00 plus $25.00 an acre (or fraction thereof) Additional fee
for 5th and subsequent reviews - 200/0 of original fee Amendments deemed to be minor in nature, that is
requiring minor strike thru and underline text amendments of no more than 10 different lines of text changes
in the DRI will be capped at $13,000.00. Any amendment which includes a map and text change will be
assessed the full fee (no cap).
CDES Financial Administration, rev 11/13/07 lw
page 7
L.'l;::.n"';~< iron, hi' 'in\ '
!\j::::h/emDe:- ~ /. 20G7
of .::S
8) DRIIDO Amendment $6,000.00 plus $25.00 per acre (or fraction thereat). The acreage charge does not apply
for amendments which only change the build-out date of the DO for a time period of less than five years.
9) DRIABN - DRI Abandonment $1,500.00
10) Flood Variance Petitioo $]000.00
11) Interim Agriculture Use Petition $350.00
12) Non-Conforming Use Change/Alteration $1.500.00
13) Parking Exemption $1,500.00. Additional fee for 5111 and subsequent revievvs - 200/0 of original fee.
14) Parking Reduction (Administrative) $500.00
15) Rezone Petition (PUD to PUD): $8.000.00 plus $25.00 an acre (or fraction thereof) (Requires a submittal ofa
new PUD document)
16) Property owner notifications: $1.50 non-certified mail, $3.00 certified return receipt mail (Petitioner to
pay this amount prior to advertisement of petition)
17) Planned Unit Development Amendments (PUD) $6,000.00 plus $25.00 an acre or fraction of an acre.
(Substantial changes to the text and Master Plan), Additional fee for 51h and subsequent reviews ~ 20(%
of original fee. Text changes that do not impact the Master Plan $6,000.00 (the $25.00 an acre fee will not
apply. Amendments deemed to be minor in nature that is requiring minor strike thru and underline
amendments of no more than IO different lines of text changes in the PUD will be capped at $9,000.00.
Any amendment which includes a map and text change will be assessed the full fee (no cap).
18) Planned Unit Deve]opment Amendment - Insubstantial (PD1) $1,500.00 requires a hearing by the cepc only
for a minor change to the rUD Master Plan. PUD Minor Change (PMC) $t.OOO.OO (Administrative Reviev...'
for minor change to the Master Plan)
19) Rezone Petition (Regular) $6,000.00 plus $25.00 an acre (or fraction thereof), Additional fee for 5th and
subsequent review.s- 20% of original fee.
20) Rezone Petition (to PUD) $10,000.00 plus $25.00 an acre (or fraction thereof). Additional fee for 5'" and
subsequent reviews .- 20% of original fee.
2]) Street Name Change (Platted) S500.00 plus $1.00 for each property owner requiring notification of proposed
street name change
22) Un-platted street name or project name change: $tOo.no per application fee plus $50.00 per additional hour or
Partial hour of research required to process application, not to exceed $500.00
23) Variance petition: $2,000.00 residentiaL S5,000.OO 110n- residential. Additional fee for 5th and subsequent
Reviews - 20lYo of original fee.
24) Variance (Administrative) $1,000.00
25) Zoning Certificate: Residential: $50.00, Commercial:$125.00
26) PUD Extension - Sun Setting: $1000.00
27) Sign Variance Petition: $2000.00
('DES Financial Administration, rev IIil3/07lw
page ))
L'npnrl~ \iorn [,-it-, 1 n\'
November 27. 2007
28) Stewardship Receiving Area Petition (SRA): $7000.00 per SRA plus $25.00 per acre for. Stewards!ii~ge 14 of "5
Sending Area Petition (SSA): $9,500.00, Stewardship Receiving Alternative Deviation Design (SRDD)
$500.00. SRA Amendment" deemed to be minor in nature: that is requiring minor strike thru and
underline text amendments of no more than 10 different"lines of text changes in the SRA will be capped
at $10.000.00.
29) After-the-Fact Zoning/Land Use Petitions 2x the normal petition fee
30) Land Use Petition Continuances
a. Requested after petition has been advertised $500.00
b. Requested at the meeting $750.00
c. Resultant additional required advertising charged in addition to continuance fees.
31) PUD and SRA_Monitoring (one-time charge at time of building permit pick-up)
a. $100.00 per dwelling unit for residential construction within a PUD and SRA ($3,000.00 maximum
fee per building pemlit application)
b. $0.12 per square foot for non-residential construction within a PUD and SRA ($3,000.00 maximum
fee per building permit application)
32) Any legal advertising required during any CDES activity or approval process will be charged in addition to
stated fees, at actual costs. CDES reserves the right to charge an estimated amount with the initially required
project fees, and will reconcile and adjust such charges against actual legal advertising billings at the
completion of the project.
33) Mixed Use Project (MUP) $2,500.00
34) Outdoor Serving Area Permit $300.00
35) Planned Unit Development (PUD) closeout application and processing:
a. PUD's up to 50 acres: $5,000.00
b. PUD's over 50 acres up to 250 acres: $7.000.00
c. PUD's over 250 acres; $9,500.00
36) Development of Regional Impact (DRl) closeout application and processing $10,000.00
L) MISCELLANEOUS
I) Reserved
2) Reserved
3) Official Zoning Atlas Map Sheet Publications, maps, and reports shall be copied at actual cost.
4) The following fee shall be assessed for all Lien Searches, Title Searches and/or Payoff Requests: $5.00iper
request.
5) The fee for researching records, ordinances, and codes shall be at no charge for the first hour, then at the base
salary hourly rate of the staff member conducting the service for time in excess of 1 hour.
6) The fee for creating and designing special computer generated reports that are not a part of regular standard
reports shall be at no charge for the first hour, then at the base salary hourly rate of the staff member conducting
the service for time in excess of 1 hour.
7) CD Burning: $5.00
8) Complete sets of Official Zoning Atlas Map Sheets $100.00 per set.
CDES Financial Administration, rev 11/13/071w
page l}
9) Staff shall charge the following fees for duplication of public records:
6'1onr;::, i10...,.-, r'I..-, 4n\f
i'~C}v~:li~)8~ :=, . 20U7
1 ~ ~)i !'~:
3. $0.15 ((lr each one sided photncopy of documents less than 11 x 17 inches.
b. $0.20 for each two sided photocopy of documents less than 11 x 17 inches.
c. $1.00 for each certified copy of a public record.
10) Property Notification Address Listing:
a. MS Excel spreadsheet on Disc $70.00
b. Print out on Paper $75.00 + $0.05 for every record over 1500
c. Mailing Labels $80.00 + $0.06 for every record over 1500
d. Print out on Paper + Mailing Labels $85.00 + $0.11 for every record over 1500
II) Comprehensive Plan Consistency Review
a. CU's $300.00
b. Rezonings $750.00
c. Pud's or PUD Amendments: $2250.00
d. Letter of GMP consistency to outside agencies: $250
e. SRA. ~ Stewardship Receiving Area - $2,250.00
f. DRI - Development of Regiona] Impact - $2,250.00
g. FlAM. Fiscal Impact AnalySIS - $4.000.00
12) Plan Revie\\' Fee (for planning review of all building permit applications)
a) Long fonns: $125.00 per building pemlit application. 2nd review 500;;. of fee. 31d and
subsequent 251~1 affee end and subsequent reviev.' fees related to Zoning approvals only)
b) Express pemlits: S50.00 per building permit application, 2nd reviev.' 500;(1 of fee. 3fd and
subsequent 25'Y(l of fee C~nd and subsequent reviev.' fees related to Zoning approvals only)
13) Project Meetings: Active applications under review for the following project types will he afforded one inter-
departmental meeting at no charge: Planned Unit Deve]opment re-zonings and Site Deve]opment Plan
applications (except for conceptual site plan approval and insuhstantial change approval). Meeting requests
for al] other application types and additional meetings wil] he suhject to the following fees:
a. Meetings with Departmenta] Project Approval Staft. member per applicant request reviews
and petitions in progress, $150.00 per one hour minimum, $75.00 per ~/; hour thereafter.
Additional Department staff attending meeting per applicant request $75.00 per I/! hour per
staff member.
b. Inter-Departmental Project Meeting per applicant request, site plan reviews and land use
petitions in progress. $500.00 per one hour minimum. $250.00 per I/i hour thereafter.
]4) Adequate Public Facilities
a. Planning Applications requiring COA process review (such as FP's. PPL 's & SIP's. SOPs)
$200.00 + 25.00 per residential dwelling unit or + 25.00 per 1000 sq ft commercial
($5000.00 maximum)
b. Building pennit applications requiring COA process review not covered under 12.a above
$100.00 per building pemlit application.
15) Zoning Confirmation Letters
a. Standard Response $100.00 (includes up to 1 hour research)
b. Extended Research SIOO.OO per hour (any response with research in excess of 1 hour)
] 6) Zoning Letter Appeal $250.00
17)CDD
a. Community Deve]opment District $15,000.00
b. Chapter I R9 Special District. Independent or Dependent. $15.000.00
CDES Financia] Administration, rev 11/13/07]w
page ]0
L'no'^"rt~ 110m t..in 1nir
f~QVernbe;. 27, 2007
18) GMP Amendment Pace 16 0; !,5
a. Small Scale $9000.00
b. General $16,700.00
c. Legal advertising in addition to sub. sections a and b fees. and subject to applicable fee schedule
provIsions.
d. Pre-application meetings for GMP consistency for development orders and zoning/land use petitions:
$250
e. Pre-application meetings for GMP amendment petitions: $250 (to be credited toward application fee
upon submittal)
19) Application for issuance TDR. $250 (non-refundable); plus $25 per TDR issued and recorded (total fees not to
exceed $2,750.00)
20) Engineering Services
a) Vacation of Easements: $2.000.00
2 J ) Building Board of Adjustments and Appeals $250.00
22) Early Work Authorization (EW A) permit: $500.00 (does not include site clearing fee).
23) Legal Non-confomling Lot (LNC) $100.00
24) Vested Rights Determination (VRD) $1,500.00
M) BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION FEE
1) A permit application fee shall be collected at time of applying for a
building permit. The pC1l11it application fee shall be collected when the
plans are submitted for review. The fee shall be applied toward the total
permit fee. The applicant shall fodeit the application fee if the
application is denied or if the application is approved and the permit is
not issued within the time limitation as stated in Section 103.0.1.1 of the
Collier County Ordinance No. 91-56. as amended.
2) Application fee will be computed as follows:
a) 25% of total Building Permit Fec ($.15 /sq ft new residential and commercial, $.075 shell and
warehouse)
3) Minimum fee of $50.00 for each of the following: plumbing; mechanical (A/C); electrical; fire; and building,
When applying for additions/alterations. Minimum fee for all other applications = $50.00
4) The balance of the total permit fee will be collected at the time of issuance of the permit and will include any
fee adjustments necessary.
N) BUILDING PERMIT FEES
I) The fee for a bull ding pe1l11it shall be computed as follows: Such fees shall be either based on the contractor's
valuations of construction cost or based on square footage. Minimal accepted calculated costs of construction
are set forth on the attached Building Valuation Data Table (Exhibit B - IBC Building Valuation Data Table,
produced February. 2007). Valuation of construction costs of less than $750.00 - No permit or fee is required,
but construction must comply with all County Codes and Ordinances. If inspections are required by the
Building Official or requested by the applicant. the appropriate fees shall be paid.
EXCEPTION: All work involving structural components and/or fire rated assemblies requires pemlits and
inspections regardless of construction cost, signs must secure permits as stated in Collier
Collier County Ordinance No. 2002-01. as amended.
(,DES Financial Administration, rev 11113/07 Iw
page 11
L '1~n"-;~. :j~r~" I\,r\ '"l
T-.Jc,v~nlbe;- 27. 2DD
Page 17 of 4
a. Valuation of construction costs of $750.00 through $4.999.99 - $100.00
b. New eonst11letion greater than 500 square feet
I. residential at $0.29 per square foot (living area)
II. warehouse/shell at $O.J45 per square foot (tota] area)
111. build-out at~$~OI45 per square foot (total area)
IV. commercial i'institutiona] at $0.29 per square foot (total area)
c. Alterations. other construction. and ne\v construction under 500 square feet (both residential and
commercial) $100 plus 0.300/0 of declared valuation in excess of $5.000
0) ELECTRICAL PERMIT FEES
1) The fees for electrical permits for 11e\\/ structures or placement or relocation
of structures shall be computed as follO\\/s:
a. $0.40 per ampere rating of all single-phase panel boards.
b. $0.15 per ampere rating for s\\iitch or circuit whichever is greater. if item
#1 above does not apply.
c. When not a complete installation. all switch and circuit breakers ahead of
panel boards shall be computed at $0.15 per ampere.
d. Pemlit fees for any change in etectricat installation shall be computed at
the above rates for that pOltioJ1 of new and/or increased fees in existing
e]ectrical facilities.
c. The minimum for any electrical pennit shall bc $SU.OO per unit or tenant
space.
r. Fifty percent (50lYi,) in additional fee costs shall be added to all above fees
for three phase installations.
EXCEPTION: Ordinary' repairs limited to a $200 value or less may' be made
without a permit. Repairs must compl)i with all County Codes and Ordinances. If
inspections are required by' the Building Official or requested by the
applicant. the appropriate fees shall be paid.
P) PLUMBING PERMIT FEES
1 J The following fee calculations shall be applied separately when the pemlit
involves mixed occupancies.
a) Residential occupancies: The fee for a plumbing permit shall be computed at
the rate of $50.00 to be charged for each living unit with one to three
bathrooms. An additional fee of $10.00 will be assessed for each additional
bathroom.
b) Nonresidential occupancies: The fee for a plumbing pemlit shall be computed
by the following methods, whichever is calculated to be the greatest fee:
a) The rate of $3.00 per 425 square feet of floor area, or fraction
thereof; or
b) Institutional facilities. hospitals, schools. restaurants and repairs
in any occupancy classification shall be charged at the rate of
$1.00 per fixture unit or
c) Minimum of $50.00 for each occupancy or tenant space.
2) Grease traps: An additional fee ofS50.00 shall be assessed for each greasc
trap.
("DES Financia] Administration. rev 11/]3/07]w
page 12
3) The cost for retrofit piping shall be computed at the minimum fee of $50.00
per floor for each main riser.
1\nAn.n""l lip"'" 11.1,-, 1n\!
November 27. 2007
Page 18 0145
4) The cost of a pennit for lawn sprinkler systems shall be computed using the dollar valuation as shown under
Section M of this Resolution.
5) The minimum plumbing permit fee shall be $50.00.
Q) MECHANICAL PERMIT FEES
1) The following fee calculations shall be applied separately when the permit involves mixed occupancies.
a. Residential occupancies: The mechanical permit fees shall be computed at the rate of $50.00 for each living
unit up to three tons of air conditioning. Each additional ton Of part thereof shall be $3.00 per ton.
b. Nonresidential occupancies: The mechanical permit fees shall be computed by one of the following
methods, whichever is calculated to be the greatest fee: The rate of $50.00 for the first three tons or three
horsepower of air conditioning or other mechanical systems per tenant space, each additional ton of air
conditioning or horsepower shall be $3.00; or The rate of$3.00 per 425 square feet of floor area, or
fraction thereof.
2) The cost of retrofit piping shall be computed at the minimum fee of $50.00 per floor for each cooling tower, or
$50.00 for the first 3 horsepower and $3.00 for each additional horsepower, whichever is greater.
3) The minimum mechanical permit fee shall be $50.00.
4) A permit for the change out of components shall be calculated at the above mechanical permit fee rate or the
minimum fee whichever is greater.
R) FIRE PREVENTION AND CONTROL PERMIT FEES
1) The fees and exemptions set forth in the "Exhibit B" affixed hereto and made a
part of this Schedule of Development Review and Building Permit Fees shall
apply to Fire Prevention and Control Permits for both the independent and
dependent fire districts.
S) MOBILE HOME/OFFICE TRAILER AND OTHER TRAILER PERMIT FEES
1) The permit fee shall be $50.00 to set-up a single-wide trailer or mobile
home on an approved site plus electrical, plumbing. mechanical and fire
protection fees as applicable.
2) The permit fee shall be $75.00 to set-up a double wide or larger mobile
homes on an approved site plus electrical, plumbing, mechanical and fire
protection fees as applicable.
T) CHlCKEES AND SIMILAR STRUCTURES
1) The permit fee will be based upon a calculated cost of construction of $4.00
per square foot under roof or the contractor's estimated cost of construction,
whichever is greater. The fee will then be calculated in accordance with
Section N of this Resolution. Additional permit fees for electric, plumbing,
mechanical, fire, etc., will be charged when applicable.
U) POOL OR SPA PERMIT FEES
1) For construction of each public pool or spa the fee shall be-
a. Valuation of construction costs of up to $4,999.99. $100.00
CDES Financial Administration, rev 11/13/07 lw
page 13
c.
;',nOf r':;:- itQ,.,., h;- ';(1\'
}\!cwembel. 27. 2007
Valuation or construction costs of $5000.00 through $49,999.99: $80.00 plus $7.00 per thousamd$rJl!\Es,O[ 45
or fraction thereof. of building valuation in excess of $2.000.00.
Valuation of construction costs of $50.000.00 through $1.000.000.00: $333.00 plus $3.00 per thousand
dollars. or fraction thereof, of building valuation in excess of $50.000.00.
Valuation of construction costs over $1.000.000.00: $3.474.00 plus $3.00 per thousand dollars, or fraction
thereof: or building \/aluation in excess of $1.000,000.00.
..
b.
d.
-.
2) For construction of each private pool or spa the fee shall be: $tUU.OO
V) SCREEN ENCLOSURE PERMIT & PAN ROOF FEES
1) Construction costs shall be calculated as follows:
a. Screen Roof. $2.00 per sq. ft. of 1100r area. (Screen Walls Only)
b. Pan Roof $3.00 per sq. ft. of 1100r area. (Screen Walls Only)
c. Existing Roof. $2.00 per sq. ft. affiaaT area. (Screen \Valls Only)
2) The screen enclosure or roof fee will then be calculated in accordance with Section N of this Resolution.
W) SIGN PERMIT FEES
1) Sign permit fees will be calculated in accordance with all applicable Building Pemlit Fees and Electrical
Pe1l11it Fees outlined in this document the Collier County Development Fee Schedule The minimum building
permit fee for sign shall be $75.00.
2) Multiple signs of the same type (i.e.. wall signs) and for a single project may be allowed per one pemlit
however an appropriate fee shall be charged for each sign in accordance with the schedule set forth in the
above subsection] of Sign Pemlit Fees.
Xl CONVE!\"IENCE PERMIT FEES
]) Convenience permits are issued in blocks of 10 cacho Only licensed contractors arc eligible to purchase
convenience permits. Convenience pemlits are limited to the use specified on the permit. The fee for a book
of 10 convenience pemlits is $400.00.
Y) REVISION AND AS BUILT PLAN REVIEW FEES; CORRECTIONS TO PLANS
1) PERMIT AND PLAN REVISIONS The fee for each penn it revision submitted after pennit issuance shall be
calculated using fee schedules outlined in Sections N through R above. The minimum permit fee for revisions
to pennitted projects shall be $50.00.
2) AS BUILT PLANS The fee for "As Built" plan review shall be ten (lO'YiI) percent of the original building
permit fee or $150.00, whichever is greater. but shall not exceed $SOO.O(). The fee is intended to cover the cost
of reviewing amended building plans in the office to determine that change orders and various field changes
are in compliance with the minimum construction and fire codes or Collier County. The following are required
for as-built drawings review:
a. An itemized list of all changes made after permit plan approval.
b. As-built plans that have all changes made after pellnit plan approval
"clouded".
c. As-built plans and changes shall be signed and sealed by the engineer
and/or architect of record.
3) CORRECTIONS TO PLANS
a. First Correction to Plans. No charge
b. Second COlTection to Plans. $75.00
c. Third & subsequent correction to plans. $100.00
CDES rinancial Administration, rev I 1/11/07 lw page 14
Z) PERMIT EXTENSION
1) The filing fee for each permit extension shall be equal to 100/0 of the original
building permit fee or $100.00, whichever is greater, but shall not exceed
$500.00. The filing fee is intended to cover the cost of reviewing existing or
amended building plans to determine and verify code compliance
br\c,n,+' ItorY', t"i~, 1 n\/
l\Jovemoer 2/ 2007
PageJf 45
AA) DEMOLITION OF BUILDING OR STRUCTURE PERMIT FEES
1) The pemit fee shall be S50.00 for the demolition of any building or structure.
BB) PRE-MOVING INSPECTION FEES
1) The fee shall he $150.00 for the pre-moving inspection of any building or
structure.
CC) INSPECTION FEES
1) A charge of $20.00 per inspection shall be assessed for inspections for which
a pemlit is not necessary.
2) A user fee of$120.00 shall be assessed for all inspections on a
time specified basis. .
3) First Partial inspection for single-family & tenant buildout. No charge
4) Second & subsequent partial inspections for single-family & tenant buildout. $25.00
DO) RElNSPECTION FEES
I) Re-inspections for any type of building pennit or required Engineering re-inspections. shall result in
an additional fee of $75.00 per inspection for the first re-inspection, SIOO.OO for the second re-
inspection and $125.00 for the third and each successive re-inspection.
EE) FAILURE TO OBTAIN A PERMIT
1) Where work for which a permit is required is started or proceeded with prior to obtaining said pennit and
where such action was cited by Code Enforcement or by Contractor Licensing and resulted in a finding of
violation from either the Code Enforcement Board, the Special Magistrate, or the Contractor Licensing
Board. or as directed by the Board of County Commissioners the fees herein specified shall be 4x the
regular fee.
2) Where work for which a pennit is required is started or proceeded with prior to obtaining said pernlit and
where a contractor or agent/provider where the building official or zoning director (for cases involving land
development) deems that the contractor/provider should have known that a pemlit was required but
voluntary seeks compliance by obtaining the necessary penn its to abate the violation the fees herein
specified shall be 2x the regular fee.
3) Where work for which a permit is required is started or proceeded with prior to obtaining said permit and
where an owner/builder seeks voluntary compliance by obtaining said permit the fees assessed will be 2x
the regular rate as defined in this fee schedule.
4) Where work for which a pemlit is required is started or proceeded with priorto obtaining said permit and
where the unpermitted work was completed by other or prior to the current owner/builder's ownership
of the property an where the current owner/builder seeks voluntary compliance by obtaining said permit to
assure compliance witn all applicable codes the fees will be assessed at the regular rate as defined in this
fee schedule.
5) The payment of such fee shall not relieve any person from fully complying with the requirements of any
applicable construction code or ordinance in the execution of the work. or from any penalty prescribed
within any construction code, law or ordinance of Collier County.
CDES Financial Administration. rey 11/13/07 lw
page 15
L,,..,C1"'-;~ Ijon, !\'n 11\\ i
f\Jovemne: ':.7. 2007
Page 2 c/45
FF) LICENSING
1) The fee for licensing items is as follows:
a. Letters of Reciprocity. $25.00
b. Contractors Change of Status. (active to donnant) $10.0n
c. Voluntary Registration of State Certified ComraclOrs. $10.00
d. Pictures. $2.00
e. Laminating $1.00 (per license)
f. Fee for a 6 month temporary contractor's license $25.00
g. Certified copies of Experience letters $35.00
h. Duplicate or replacement (of Competency cards) $25.00
1. Second entity application fee $50.00
2)
Certificated of Competency (Annual)
a. Contractor
Initial License Fee
Renewal Fee
b. Specialty Contractor
Initial License Fee
Renewal Fee
c. Joumcyman
Initial License Fee
ReneVo'al Fee
$150.00
$]00.00
$ 135.00
$85.00
$50.00
$25.00
3) DOImant Certificates of Competency (Annual)
a. Contractor $100.00
h. Specialty Contractor $85.00
c. Penalty fees after 9/30 $10.00 per month until 12/3]
4) Reinstatement of Delinquent License
a. Contractor
b. Specialty Contractor
c. Joumeyman
d. Examination Administrative Fee
$150.00 plus hack years
$135.00 plus hack years
$50.00 plus hack years
$100.00 good for 6 months
GG) DUPLICATE PERMIT CARDS
1) The fee shall be $5.00 for the issuance of a duplicate penn it card for
whatever reason.
HH) CHANGE OF CONTRACTOR OR SUBCONTRACTORS
1) To record a change of contractor or subcontractor. on a penn it that has been
issued. the fee shall be $50.00. This fee includes the issuance of a new
pemlit card.
II) PERMIT FEE REFUNDS
1) If requested, in writing by the owner or his authorized agent, SOo;;) of the fees
charged, other than the application fec, may be refunded provided that a
permit has been issued, construction has not commenced, and the refund is
applied for prior to the cancellation of the pennit.
JJ) RECORD RETRIEVAL
I) No charge for retrieving records from inactive or remote storage including
microfilmed documents
CDES Financial Administration. rev 1 j.'1 3/07 Iw
page 16
::'fl""nr;;:o he-",^, 1':" in\i
f\!OV8tTlber 'l.7. 2007
~a~J~;' ::' Of ::i S
.
KK) COPY FEES
1) The fee for blueprint and miscellaneous copying shall be as follows:
a. Microfilm copies, of documents less than 11 x 17 inches: $0.15 other sizes at cost of production.
f. Microfilm or Blueprint copies:
lR X 24 $1.25 per page
30 X 36 $2.50 per page
30 X 42 $3.25 per page
34 X 44 $5.00 per page
g. Community Development self-service copier. public access and not related to public record retrieval
or public record copies: documents less than 14x8.5 inches $0.15 per page inclusive of sales tax.
LL) RESEARCH
1) The fee for researching records, ordinances, and codes shall be at no charge for the first hour, then at the base
salary hourly rate of the staff member conducting the service for time in excess of] hour
2) The fee for creating and designing special computer generated reports that are not part of the regular standard
reports shall be at no charge for the first hour, then at the base salary hourly rate of the staff member
conducting the service for time in excess of 1 hour.
MM) SUBSCRIPTION SERVICE
The fee for (me-year subscription service to be mailed quarterly shall he
$15.00 per year. The subscription year is fi'om Oct. 1 through Sept 30.
NN) ELECTRONIC DATA CONVERSION SURCHARGE
1) A surcharge in the amount of 3%. of the building pemlit application fee, with
the minimum surcharge being $3.00 and the maximum being $150.00. will be
applied to every building pemlit application submitted. A flat fee of $3.00
per permit will be charged for those pellllits for which an application fee is
not required per item (M) of this Schedule.
00) REGISTRATION OF RENTAL DWELLINGS
1) The fee for registration of rental dwellings is as follows:
a. Initial Registration Fee - $30.00iper property
b. Annual Renewal - $20.00iPer property
c. Late Fee - $IO.OO/per day per property up to a maximum of $80.00
d. The term "property" means a parcel or contiguous parcels with any number of rental unit,
located thereupon under common ownership and/or management
2) Rental Inspection
a. Rental Inspection - $200.00 per unit
b. Re-inspection Fee - $50.00 per re-inspection per unit.
c. Rental inspections shall not be required for rental units on property covered by a Florida Department
of Business and Professional Regulation ("DBPR") license. A copy of the current DBPR license
shall be provided with the initial rental registration and all subsequent rental renewal applications.
3) Any unpaid fees may be pursued by the Collier Manager or designee through a collection agency.
PP) CERTIFICATE TO BOARD BUILDING
1) Initial Boarding Certilicate - $0
2) Boarding Certificate Extension - $150
(,DES Financial Administration, rcv 11/13/07Iw
page ]7
L~;""n-~: Ij{.,~.. h'-
27.20CF
.2~~ Of ~ 5
QQ) ADDITIONAL FEE REFUND PROVISIONS
1) Requests for fee waivers may only be approved by the Board of County Commissioners. W"aiver
requests for development review and building permit fees shall be submitted in writing directly to the
appropriate Community Development & Environmental Services Division Staff. who will prepare an
executive summary for consideration by' tne Board. Such requests shall include a statement
indicating the reason for the fee waiver request and, if applicable. the nature of the organization
requesting the fee waiver.
RR) REFUND PROVISIONS
1) PAYMENT OF FEES: Full payment offec5 is required for a complete application. Department
policy requires full payment of fees at the time of application submittal. No work will begin on staff
review of the application until all fees are paid in full. If full payment of fees is not received within
14 calendar days of application submittal, the application will be considered void. At this point a
new application and full payment of fees will be required to proceed with a project.
2) There will be no refund of Planning. EnvironmentaL or Engineering related fees. except those
applications which have been deemed nol sufficient for staff review and are withdrawn within 30
days of notification will be entitled to a 50(;/;) refund. After 30 days from such notification, there will
be no refund of submitted fees.
3) In no cases will there be refunds for pre-application fees, data conversion fees. appeals of
administrative decisions. or appeals to the Board of Zoning Appeals or Building Board of
Adjustment.
4) If staff error causes the inappropriate or unnecessary filing of an application and payment of fees,
100 percent of all inappropriate fees. shall be refunded upon written request and with the concurrence
of Department management.
SS) ADDITIONAL FEE PROVISIONS
1) In those cases where aitemative methods or timing of payments for CDES services and / or fees
listed in this schedule associated with SBR reviews are deemed to best serve the public good, the
Community Development and Environmental Services Administrator will have the authority to
approve such alternatives. Such alternative must be in writing and signed by all principals involved.
In no case shall final e.o. or such certifications of project completeness be issued until payments due
CDES are received in full.
2) All hourly fees are computed and charged from actual Divisional time tracking records.
3) All acreage totals used in fee calculations will be rounded up to the nearest whole acre.
4) When deemed essential for project review or approval. there will be no additional charge for any
meetings requested by CDES staff.
TT) PUBLIC VEHICLE FOR HIRE FEES
1) The follov..'ing fees shall be assessed for the Public Vehicle for Hire Program:
a. Initial Application fee (new Companies) - $200
b. Initial Certificate to Operate (Fcb I-Jan 31) - $325.00
c. Annual Certificate to Operate Renewal $325.00
d. Late Fee fnr CTO Renewal S200.00
(,DES Financial Administration, rev I 1/13/07 Iw
page If!
fjr'Dr,:-'~ Ii::.'"'^' hl( "1(1\'
l"Jovernber 27, 2007
e. Sub-Certificate Application Fee (New Companies) - $100.00 "'aac, 2" Qf ~ 5
f. Sub-Certificate - $125.00
g. Annual Sub-Certificate renewal. $125.00
h. Late Fee for Sub-Certificate Renewal - $100.00
I. Vehicle Decal - $50.00
J. Temporary Vehicle Decal $5.00 per vehicle/per day
k. Tempomry Vehicle Decal (In case of inoperable decaled vehicle) - $5.00/per vehicle
I. Driver Identification Card (Initial/Renewal) - $75.00 per driver
m. 2nd Driver Identification Card - $25.00
n. Replacement Driver ID - $10.00
o. On-site Vehicle Permitting - $15.00 per vehicle
UU)"PAYMENT IN LIEU OF" FEE FOR PATHWAYS (SIDEWALKS. AND BIKE LANES)
1) Calculated using the current Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) construction costs or an
engineering estimate not to exceed twenty~five percent (25%) of the submitted application request's total
project cost.
This is the last page of the CDES Fee Schedule
(,DES Financial Administration, rev 1]113/07 Iw
page ]9
.':.,,"f'::>',":=-; ITor", 1"1," '",
c
"
[~;
1\.'C).J8nlb9r ']J 2C) -:'
~2Jf.' 25 01 ..'
c
T
c
"
u
~
<
y
EXHIBIT C
STRIKE-THROUGHS AND UNDERLINES
COLLIER COUNTY COMMUNITY
ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
DEVELOPMENT AND
FEE SCHEDULE
BCC Proposed version, November 27, 2007
Contents:
A) ADMINISTRATION.
B) BLASTING PERMITS & INSl'lCTIOj\' ,.
C} ENVIRONMENTAL/LANDSCAPING.
D) EXCAVATION PERMITS..
E) FIRE CODE REVlr:W rFF:S..
F) SITl:: lJEVELOPMEj\:T PI.ANS
(i) SUBDIVISION.
H) ENCIl\TERING !NSPITTlON FEES
I) TEMPORMtY USE PERMITS
.1) WEI,L I'ERMITS,iINSPFCTJONS..
K) ZONINCi,il.ANIJ 1,'SF PI-:TITIONS.
l) MISCELLi\NlOl!S ,.
M) I:3lJILDJN(j PERM!T APPLICATION rFT
N) RlllLDINCi PFRMIT FEES
0) r:LECTRICAI PERMlT FEES.
1') PUIMBING PERM!T FITS.
Q) MECIlANICAL PFRMIT FEES..
R) FIRE PREVENTION .'\ND CONTRUL PERMIT FEES ,.
S) MOBIl r IIOMF/OFl;ICE TRAILER AND OTlIER TRAil ,1~R PERMIT FEEs..
T) CIIIC"-EES AND SIMILi\R STRlICTl.IRES.
lJ) POOL OR SPA PU{M!T ru::s
V} SCREEN ENCLOSlIRE PERMIT & PAN Roor UT.S..
\V} SIGN PERMIT F(]-.:S
Xl CONVENIENCE PERMIT FITS.
Y) REVISION AND AS HllILT PLAN REV!EW FITS; CORRECTIONS TO PLANS,.
Z) PERMIT EXTFNSIOl\ .
AA) DEMOLITION or R\JILDINCi OR SIJUlCTlIRI:: PERMIT FEES
B(1) PRE-MOVINCi INSPITTION FEES,.
CCl INSPECTION FEES
un) REINSPFTTI01\ FEES..
EE) Fi\lLlJRE TO OBTAIN A PERMIT ,.
FF) LICENSING.
GG) DlIPL!CATE PERMIT CARDS ,.
HH) CHANGE OF CONTRACTOR OR SUBCONTRACTORS..
II) PERMIT FEE REFLNDS.
JJ)-RECOR[) RETRIEVAL ,.
KK) COPY FEES..
LLl RESEARCH..
MM} SlJBSCRIPT10N SERVICE.
NN) ELECTRONIC DATA CONVERSION SllRCHARGE.
(0) REGISTRATION OF RENTAL D\VELLlNCiS
1'1') ('ERTIFIC ATE TO BOARD BILLING.
()Q) ADDITIONAL FEE REFUND PROVISIONS..
RR) REFtJNj) PROVISIONS..
S5) ADDITIONAL FEE PROVISIONS..
TT) PUBLIC VEIII('LE FOR H!RE FEES
lIU) "P.i\YMENT IN LIElI CW' rEr=: FOR I'A1HWAY5 (SIDEWALKS, AND BIKE LANES)..
...................... .._._.._._..................... ....................2
.. ._. ............2
....................................................... .......2
.....3
......... 4
4
...5
..._.........6
.-..-............................ _....................... .._._6
7
........... 7 ~k
... ...... .......... .........4
..............]]
.11
"
..........12
I'
.'
............ ._.13
................__.....13
........... .. .14
.....................14
14
..... ........_._.. ...... ..........14
.__.....14
.14
15
..............15
...15
._.J5
..... ...... .15
......... ....15
16
...]6
....................... ..........17
._........ .......... ........._......................17
............................ ...17
.._.......................................................17
..16
..............................................17
_._.__............17
.............................17
.__......................................................................18
.1R
IR
IR
...18
...... .............. .19
Fees are in bold
CDES Financial AdministTation, rev Ili1J/071w
page I
6 c> .::, II:m-"' "I \ 1"\;
November 27, 2007
Page 26 of 45
FEES ARE ESTABLISHED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMlSSIONERS RESOLUTION, AND CANNOT
BE WAIVED OR SUSPENDED WITHOUT AN ACTION BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS.
ANY QUESTIONS CONCERNING THE APPLICABILITY OF FEES SHALL BE CONCLUSIVELY
DETERMINED BY THE DIRECTOR OF THE APPROPIA TE DEPARTMENT, AS APPLICABLE. WHERE AS
PART OF A REZONING, PLAT OR SIMILAR APPLICATION TYPE. THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS DIRECTS APPROY AL OF FUTURE DEVELOPMENT ORDERS DIFFERENT FROM THE
STANDARD TYPE OF APPROY AL PROCESSES REQUIRED, THE DIRECTOR OF THE APPROPRIATE
DEPARTMENT SHALL DETERMINE THE FEES TO BE APPLIED TO THE PROCESS NECESSARY TO MEET
THE BOARDS REQUIREMENTS. THE APPLICABLE FEES SHALL BE THOSE WHICH MOST CLOSELY
RESEMBLE THOSE CHARGED FOR SIMILAR PROCESSES INCLUDING EXTRA FEES FOR ADVERTISING
AND THE LIKE.
A) ADMINISTRATION
I) Official Interpretation Request of Land Development Code (LDC), Growth Management Plan (GMP), or
Building Construction Administrative Code (Administrative Code). Based on staff hours: Less than 20 hours
$1,500.00, 20 to 40 hours $3.000.00, more than 40 hours $5,000.00
2) Interpretation request submitted in conjunction with a land use petition or requested during site development
plan review process. $250.00
3) Detennination of Vested Rights. $100.00 (plus the County's out-of-pocket expenses associated with hearing
officer and hearings)
4) Appeal ofYested Right, Detelmination. $100.00
5) Amendment to Land Development Code, $3,000.00
6) Appeal of an Administrative Decision (as may be provided for in the Collier County Administrative Code or
the LDC). $1000.00 (non-refundable)
7) Appeal to Board of Zoning Appeals or Building Board of Adjustments and Appeals (as may be provided for in
the Collier County Administrative Code or the LDC). $1,000.00 (non-refundable)
B) BLASTING PERMITS & INSPECTION
1) 30 day permit fee, non-refundable payable upon application. $250.00
2) 90 day permit fee, non-refundable payable upon application. $600.00
3) Yearly pern1it fee, non-refundable payable upon application. $1,500.00
4) Renewal permit fee, non-refundable payable upon application. $200.00
5) After-tbe-fact fee, due to blasting without a permit. $10,000.00
6) Fine fee, per detonated shot with after-the-fact permit. $200.00
7) Handler fee, for handler who assists the user or blaster in the use of explosives. $100.00
8) Blasting Inspection Fee. $200.00 (per inspection)
9) Inspection fees shall be paid upon issuance of a blasting peTmit based on the estimated number of
blasts. Upon completion, fees will be adjusted to reflect actual number ofblastl;}.
C) ENVIRONMENTAL/LANDSCAPING
1) Site Clearing Permit, first acre or fraction of an acre. $250.00 Each additional acre or fraction of
an acre. $50.00 ($3,000.00 maximum)
(,DES Financial Administration. rev 111]3/07]w
page 2
L"Ion,..,;S' !TprY' I\!r, 1('j\!
hDvember 27. 200 (
2) Agricultural Land Clearing Page 27 of ~;:'
a. Land Clearing Notification $250.00
b. Land Clearing Permit $250.00 each additional acre or fraction of an acre. $50.00 ($3,000.00
maximum)
3) Landscape Tree Removal Fec $250
4) Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) $2,500.00 for 1st submittal and 2!l(! submittal ifapplicable\
3rd submittal $1,000.00, 4th and subsequent submittals $500.00 each
5) Landscape Rc-inspection 1'\ $50.00, 2nd $75.00, every inspection aftenvard $]00.00
6) Vehicle on the Beach Permit Application. $250.00 (Permit fee shall be waived for public and
non-profit organizations engaging in environmental activities for scientific, conservation or
educational purposes).
7) Beach Nourishment Permits - $400
8) Special Treatment Review
a. First five acres or less. $400.00
b. Each additional acrc. or fraction thereof. $50.00 ($5.000.00 Maximum)
c. Pre application meeting $250.00 (to he credited toward application fee upon submittal)
9) Coastal Construction Setback Line (CCSL):
a. CCSI Pemllts $400.00
b. Variance - Petition. $1000.00
10) Sea Turtle Pemlit-
a. Sea Turtle Handling Pemlits. $25.00
b. Sea Turtle Nesting Area Construction Pe1l11it. S200.00
c. Sea Turtle Nest Rclocation. $100.00
11) Vegetation Removal Pelmit
a. First acre or fraction of an acre less. $250.00
b. Each additional acre. or fraction thereof. $50.00 (S3.000.00 Maximum)
12) After-the-fact Environmental or Landscape Pemlits
a. CCSL Variance Petition. 2x normal fee
b. All other Environmental or Landscape Pemlits. 4x normal fee
13) Informal Wetland Jurisdictional detennination for single familv parcels UP to 5 acres ~ S300.00
14) Conservation Easement review fee - $300.00 application fee plus the following additional site fee:
$200.00 for CE acres less than 5 acres; $400.00 for CE area between 5 acres and 10 acres: $600.00
for CE area greater than 10 acres and less than 20 acres: $800.00 for CE areas between 20 and 50
acres: and an additional S200.00 for everv 40 acres of CE area over 50 acres.
15) Listed or Protected Species review fee (when an EIS is not required) - $1000.00
D) EXCAVATION PERMITS
1) Annual Renewal. $300.00
2) Application (Private). $400.00
3) ApplicatIon (Commercial). $2,000.00
4) Application (Development). $400.00
5) n~n.oo $200.00 per inspection paid in advance for 12 months
6) Reapplication: $300.00 plus $200.00 per month inspection fee
7) CubIC Yardage Review Fee: $200.00 first 5000 cy. plus $10.00 per additional 1000 cy with a
maximum of$20.000.00
R) Time Extension. $150.00 plus S200.00 per month inspection fee
CDES Financial Administratioll. rev 11/13/07 Iw
page 3
[,("10.....,.-;: \;PI"1""1 t,l" 1n\1
r~ovelTlber 27.2007
9) After-the-fact Excavation Permit. 4x application fee ?age 28 of is
10) Over excavation penalty fee per vard. Plus Pem1itJReview $0.05 per cubic yard fee, unless maximum
have been oaid.
E) FIRE CODE REVIEW FEES
1) fire Code Revie\',' fees associated with each of the following processes:
a. SDP - Site Development Plan
b. SDP A - Site Development Plan, Amendment
c. SDPl - Site Development Plan, Insubstantial
d. SIp. Site Improvement Plan
e. SIPT - Site Improvement Plan, Insubstantial
f. PSP - Preliminary Subdivision Plans
g. PSPA - Preliminary Subdivision Plans. Amendment
h. PPL - Plans & Plat. Suhdivision
I. FP - Final Plat
J. CONSTR - Construction Plans, SubdivisionlUtilities
k. ICP - Construction Plans, Insubstantial
1. DRI - Development of Regional Impact
m. DOA - Development Order, Amendment
n. PlJDZ.- Planned Unit Development, Rezone
o. PUDA - Planned Unit Development, Amendment
p. PDI - Planned Unit Development. Insubstantial
q. RZ - Rezone. Regular Zoning
r. CU - Conditional Use
F) SITE DEVELOPMENT PLANS
1) Site Development Plan Review (SDP). $5000.00
$200.00
$150.00
$100.00
$150.00
$100.00
$150.00
$100.00
$100.00
$100.00
$100.00
$100.00
$200.00
$150.00
$150.00
$150.00
$100.00
$100.00
$150.00
a. plus $40.00 per DIU
b. plus S100.00 per residential building structure
c. plus $.10 per square foot for non-residential except that structures designed exclusively for parking
(parking garages) shall be calculated at $.05 per square foot.
d. plus $200.00 per building for non-residential
e. Additional fees for 3rd review $1,000.00, 41h review $1,500.00, 5111 review $2,000.00, 6th and
subsequent reviews $2,500.00
When a building consist ofhoth residential and non-residential (commercial. retail. office) uses. the following
fees will applv.
a. $5000.00 base fee plus $40.00 per DIU
b. $200.00 oer building for non-residential
c. olus $0.10 per square foot of non-residential floor area
d. Additional fees for 3rJ review $1.000.00, 4th review $1.500.00_ 5th review $2.000.00_ 61h and subsequent
reviews $2.500.00
2) Pre.application fee. $500.00 (to be credited toward application fee upon submittaL)
a. Second and subsequent pre-app meetings at the applicant's request shall not be
credited towards application fees.
b. Second and subsequent pre-app meetings at staffs request will be held at no charge
to the applicant.
c. Applications suhmitted 9 months or more after the date of the last pre-app meeting
shall not be credited towards application fees and a new pre-application meeting
will be required.
3) Simultaneous Review Fee (planning review of simultaneous building pennit applications) $100.00 per building
pemlit application.
('DES Financial Administration, rev 11/13/07 \w
page 4
L' "1 ''',r~ ~ ii" ry 1,;(', < (1\ '
1-~OVemDer ~7. ~CKL
C:'ags :?C Of ::~,
4) Site Development Plan Insubstantial Change
a. Site Development Plan Insubstantial Change. $400.00 for first sheet, $100.00 tor each and every
additional sheet submitted.
b. Additional fees for 3'.1 review $1,000.00, 4th Review $1.500.00,511' and subsequent review
$2.000.00
5) ~ite De' eI0f1F11l?Ht PlaFl C'eFlseptwal Re' ii::''l $::~gJHJ Site Develoomelll Plan Conceptual Revie\v (CSP), Unified
Development Plan (UDP). Neiehborhood Park Site (NPSP) $750.00
6) Site Improvement Plan Review (SIP), $1000.00 (plus Engineering revie\v fees)
7) Utility Plan Review & Inspection Fees-
a. Construction Document Review. 0.75(% of probable water and/or sewer construction costs
b. Construction Inspection. 2.25tJ;() of probable water and/or sewer construction costs
c. Construction Document Resubmission or Document Modification. submit as insubstantial change.
S 150.00 for first sheet. $75.00 for each additional sheet
R) Engineering Site Plan Review Fee
a. Construction Documents Review Fee 0.75flAI of probable Paving. Grading. Drainage, Lighting. Code
Minimum Landscaping_ an.d any other appurtenant cost of construction
b. Construction Inspection 2.25l~) of probable Paving. Grading. Drainage, Lighting. Code Minimum
Landscaping, and any other appurtenant cost of construction
9) Site Development Plan Amendment (SDrA) $2,500.00.
a. Plus $40.00 per DiU plus $100.00 per residential building structure
b. plus $.10 per square foot
c. plus $200.00 per building for non-residential
d. Additional fees for 3rd revie\\' SLOOO.OO_ 4th Revie\\' $1,500.00. 5th and subsequent review
$2.000.00
10) SBR Fees
a) Pre-Acquisition Meeting $500.00 (no refunds or credits)
b) Pre-application fee. $500.00 (to be credited toward application fee upon submittal.) (all nonnal pre-
application provisions apply)
c) SBR Fcc $5000.00 viith hourly reconciliation at project completion for hourly variation greater than
I Oo/~, final project charges at SIOO.OO per hour for all associated staff hours
11) Violation of the conditions of approval of the SDP/SIP or installation of improvements, clearing, or other
land alteration 110t depicted 011. or otherv.'ise authorized as a part of the approved SDP/SIP. 4x the SIP/SDP
application fee
12) Request for alternative architectural design $500.00, no separate or additional fee for appeals to, or requests
for assistance from, the Architectural Arbitration Board.
G) SUBDIVISION
1) Lot Line Adjustment (LLA) and Lot Split Review $250.00
2) Subdivision Review Fees (PPL), (PPLA) -
a. Construction Documents Review Fee 0.75fl/o of probable Paving. Grading. Drainage, Lighting. Code
Minimum Landscaping and any other appurtenant cost of construction
b. Subdivision Inspection Fee 2.25fl/fl of probable Paving_ Grading, Drainage. Lighting, Code Minimum
Landscaping, and any other appurtenant cost of construction
c. Construction Document Resubmission or Document Modification -Submit as Insubstantial Change
~li;O.OO $400.00 for first sheet. ~ SIOO.OO for each additional sheet
CDES Financial Administration, rev J 1/13/07 Iw
page 5
0De>rf,;:, !ie,'""' hi,' ~ ni.
I'\lovembe, 2. /, 200 (
d. Subdivisions - 3rd and subsequent additional reviews - $500.00 Page 3C of 45
e. Subdivisions- Substantial deviations from approval construction documents $500.00
3) Subdivision, Preliminary Plat (PSP)-
a. Petition Application $1000.00 plus $5.00 per acre (or fraction tbereof) for residential, plus $10.00
per acre (or fraction thereof) for non-residential; (mixed use is residential)
4) Subdivision Final Plat (FP) $1,000.00 plus $5.00 per acre (or fraction thereof) for residential, $1000.00 plus
$]0.00 per acre (or fraction thereof) for nonresidential: (mixed use is residential)
5) Additional review of construction plans for phased construction of subdivision improvements. $]000.00 per
phase
6) Two-year Extension $150.00
7) \\later and Sewer Facilities Construction Document Review 0.75%) of probable viater and/or sewer
construction costs
8) Construction Document Resubmission or Document Modification 0.25(1... of probable water and/or sewer
construction costs
a. 3rd and subsequent re-submittals - $500.00
9) Water and Sewer Facilities Construction Inspection Fee 2.25(X. of probable water and/or sewer construction
costs
10) Violation of the conditions of approval of approved construction plans or installation of improvements.
clearing. or other land alteration not depicted on. or otherwise authorized as a pan of the approved
construction plans or pernlit. 4x the PPL. PPLA. PSP. CNSTR or Final Plat Reviev,' Fee crr).
11) Administrative Amendment S250.00
H) ENGINEERING INSPECTION FEES
1) Engineering Inspection Fee $] 50.00 per residential dwelling unit or accessory structure to
residential dwelling unit (single or duplex only). charged at time of building pennit
issuance.
2) Rc-inspection Fees: 1 ~1 re-inspection $75.00. 2nd re-inspection $]00.00. 3rd and thereafter re~
inspection $125.00
1) TEMPORARY USE PERMITS
1) Beach Events Pemlits-
a. Individual Permit $100.00
b. Block of15 calendar days $2,250.00
c. Block of 50 calendar days $4,500.00
d. Block 01"75 calendar days $6.750.00
e. Block of J 00 calendar days $9,000.00
f. Block of 125 calendar days $11,250.00
g. Block of 150 calendar days $13,500.00
2) Temporary Use Pelmit Special Sales & Events. $200.00
3) Model Homes and Sales Centers $500.00
CDES Financial Administration, rev] 1/13/071w
page 6
i\.,;:::.n....;:. 1Tc:\..,-, h>' ,en'
r~overnDel- .2 (. 2007
4) Construction and Development. Mobile horne, Agricultural Zoning, and Temporary use for "CemiJrg3" of Li~)
Soon" sign $125.00
5) Residential and Non-Profit Garage and Yard Sale Permits No Charge
6) Temporary Use Amendment. $100.00
7) Renewals or extensions requested after the expiration date $20(l.OO
.-..
8) Temporary Use Permit for Special Events requiring Bee approval. including Circus and Carnival
.Permits. $275.00
9) Political SIgns (Bulk Temporary Permit) $5.00
10) Fees for Temporary Use permits issued After the Fact, A TF: 2x normal fee
J) WELL PERMITS/INSPECTIONS
I) Hydraulic elevator shaft permit $300.00
2) Test hole pernlit (including 1st six holes) $300.00. each additional hole $20.00
3) Well permit (ahandnnment) $50.00
4) \Vell permit (construction, repair. or combined construction and abandonment at one site) $300.00
5) Well pemlit (monitoring) $150.00
6) Well Permit (modification of monitor/test well to a production well) $75.00
7) Well Reinspections
a. First Reinspection
b. Second Reinspeclion
c. Third Reinspection
$75.00
$100.00
$150.00
R) After the fact well permits 4x normal fee per violation.
NOTE: Multiple wells may be allov./ed on one pellllic but each well must be
accounted for and the appropriate fee shall be charged for each well in
accordance with the above listed schedule.
K) ZONINGILAND USE PETITIONS
1) Pre-application meeting fee $500.00 (to be credited toward application fee upon submittal.)
a. Second and subsequent pre-app meetings at the applicant's request shall not be credited towards
application fees.
b. Second and subsequent pre-app meetings at staffs request \\'ill be held at no charge to the applicant.
c. Applications submitted 9 months or more after the date of thc last pre-app meeting shall not be
credited towards application fees and a new pre-application meeting will be required.
2) Alcoholic Beverage or Service Station Separation Requirement Waiver $1000.00
3) Boat Dock Extension Petition $1,500.00 Boat Lift Canopy Administrative Review $500.00
4) Conditional Use Permit $4,000.00 when filled with Rezone Petition ($1,500.00) Additional fee for 5'" and
subsequent reviews - 20'% of original fee.
5) Conditional Use Monitoring Review: $750.00
6) Conditional Use Extension $3,000.00
('DES Financial Administration. rev 1\/J3i071w
page 7
D 'l,-~n"';:: lie..,.,-' ~ ir- 1 il\ '
'r'-J8vember 27, 2007
7) DR! Review (In addition to cost of rezone) $10,000.00 plus $25.00 an acre (or fraction thereof) Ad1lJtiarnUll'ee,( 45
for 5th and subsequent reviews - 200;;) of oric:inal fee. Amendments deemed to be minor in nature, that is
requirine minor strike thru and underline text amendments of no more than 10 different lines of text chamzes
in the DR! will be capped at $13.000.00. Anv amendment which includes a map and text change will be
assessed the full fee (no cap).
R) DRl/DO Amendment $6,000.00 plus $25.00 per acre (or fraction thereof). The acreage charge does not apply
for amendments which only change the build-out date of the DO for a time period of less than five years.
9) DRlABN.- DR! Abandonment $1,500.00
10) F]ood Variance Petition $1000.00
11) Interim Agriculture Use Petition $350.00
12) Non-Confonning Use Change/Alteration $1,500.00
13) Parking Exemption $1,500.00. Additional fee for 51h and subsequent reviews - 200/0 of oric:inal fee.
]4) Parking Reduction (Administrative) $500.00
15) Rezone Petition (PUD to PUD): $8,000.00 plus $25.00 an acre (or fraction thereof) (Requires a suhmittal of a.
new PUD document)
16} Property owner notifications: ~ $1.50 non-certified mail, $3.00 certified return receipt mail (Petitioner to
pay this amount prior to advcI1iscment of petition)
] 7) Planned Unit Development Amendments (:y","taHtial)(PlID) $6,000.00 plus $25.00 an acre or fraction ~
of an acre. (Substantial cha11!..!es to the text and Master Plan ). Additional fee for 5th and subsequent reviews
201Yc, of ori\..!inal fee. Text changes that do not impact the Master Plan $6.000.00 (the $25.00 an acre fee will
not applv). Amendments deemed to be minor in nature. that is requiring minor strike thm and underline
amendments of no more than \0 different lines of text chanees in the PUD will be capped at $9.000.00. Anv
amendment which includes a map and text change will be assessed the full fee (no cap).
I8} Planned Unit Development Amendment - Insubstantial (PDl) $],500.00 requires a hearing bv the cepe only
for a minor change to the pun Master Plan, pun Minor Chaouc (PMC') $1.000.00 (Administrative Review
for minor change to the Master Plan)
19) Rezone Petition (Regular) $6,000.00 plus $25.00 an acre (or fraction thereof). Additional fee for 5'" and
subsequent reviews - 200;;1 of ori!!inal fee.
20) Rezone Petition (to PUD) $10.000.00 plus $25.00 an acre (or fraction thereof), Additional fee for 5'" and
subsequent reviews 200;;1 of orii!inal fee.
21) Street Name Change (P]atted) $500.00 plus $1.00 for each property owner requiring notification of proposed
street name change
22) Un-platted street name or project name change: $100.00 per application fee plus $50.00 per additional hour or
Partial hour of research required to process application, not to exceed $500.00
23) Variance petition: $2,000.00 residential, $5,000.00 non- residential, Additional fee for 5th and subsequent
Reviews - 200/0 of original fee.
24) Variance (Administrative) $1.000.00
25} Zoning Certificate: Residential: $50.00, Commercial:$125.00
26) PUD Extension - Sun Setting: $1000.00
CDES Financial Administmtion, rev 11113107 lw
page X
I~ovembe: 27 2007
27) Sign Variance Petition: $2000.00
~), 2:~
2R) Stewardship Receiving Area Petition (SRA): $7000.00 per SRA plus $25.00 per acre for. Stewardship
Sending Area Petition (SSA): $9;500.00, Stewardship ReceiviTI!..! Alternative Deviation Design (SRDD)
$500.00. SRA amendments deemed to be minor in nature. that is requirinl! minor strike thru and underline
text amendments of no more than 10 different lines of text chan!!es in the SRA will be capped at
$10.000.
29) After-the-Fact Zoning/Land Use Petitions 2x the nornlal petition fee
30) Land Use Petition Continuances
a. Requested after petition has heen advertised $500.00
b. Requested at the meeting $750.00
c. Resultant additional required advertising charged in addition to continuance fees.
31) PUD and SRA Monitoring (one-time charge at time of building permit pick-up)
a. ~]OO.OO per dwelling unit for residential construction within a PUO and SRA, ($3,000.00
maximum fee per building permit application)
b. ~ $0.12 per square foot for non-residential construction within a PUD and SRA., ($2,000.00
$3.000.00 maximum fee per building pemlit application)
32) Any legal advertising required during any CDES activity or approval process will be charged in addition to
stated fees, at actual costs. CDES reserves the right to charge an estimated amount with the initially required
project fees, and will reconcile and adjust such charges against actual legal advertising billings at the
completion of the project.
33) ,^.dmiRi..trati' f:' Re' ie" (R'liner EhaR;e,- tc PPD Ha.'ter PlaN) Sf,HOQ.nO Mixed Use Proiect (T\1UP)
$2.500.00
34) Outdoor Servin!! Area Permit $300.00
35) Planned Unit Development (PUD) closeout application and processin!..!
a. PUD's up to 50 acres: $5.000.00
b. PUD's over 50 acres UP to 250 acres: $7.000.00
c. PUll', over 250 acres: $9.500.00
36) Development of Re!..!ional Impact (DR}) closeout application and orocessinl.!:: $10,000
L) MISCELLANEOUS
I ) Reserved
2) Reserved
3) Official Zoning Atlas Map Sheet Publications, maps. and reports shall be copied at actual cost.
4) Rel'Jer. eEl The followinl.!: fee shall be assessed for all Lien Searches. Title Searches and/or Pavoff Requests:
$5.00/per request
5) The fee for researching records, ordinances, and codes shall be at no charge for the first hour, then at the base
salary hourly rate of the staff member conducting the service for time in excess of 1 hour.
6) The fee for creating and designing special computer generated reports that are not a part of regular standard
reports shall be at no charge for the first hour, then at the base salary hourly rate of the stafTmember conducting
the service for timc in excess of 1 hour.
7) CD Burning: ~I.QO, fiarr, ade: $.;;Q $5.00
CDES Financial Administration, rev 11113/{)7 Iw
page Y
8) Complete sets of Official Zoning Atlas Map Sheets $100.00 per set.
L'1c'n.-:~ I '",-'"Y' I\ir' 1 n\!
T~ovembe:- ']7 _ 2007
Pags of.::5
9) PhetessJ3ie[' sf 8eel;lmef1t~ Ie.',' tAaR 111:1 '7 iAehes: No Cho.F;e fer fiL't 5 espies af GRe sieee, t';'0 sieBEl, ether
size~ at 813St af JOlFS81:1.6tiefl. AtR aRB ~'Y8"Si:]l:Jeflt ]3Ret8G8J3ier sf 88G1:lmeFlts le:\' tilaR IIJ~l '7 iRGI:J@s: SO.I~ eRe
siess. $0.101"'8 .'iaea, ether .'izes at 88St sf J3f881:1.Gtiofl. Staff shall charge the following fees for duplication
of Dubhe records:
a. Certifies G8J3: sf ]3I:1Etlic: reGel'S $I 00 E!Q-ai:. $0.15 for each one sided nhotoconv of documents
less than l1x17 inches.
b. $0.20 for each two sided photocopy of documents less than 11 x 17 inches.
c. $1.00 for each certified copy of a public record.
10) Property Notification Address Listing:
a. MS Excel spreadsheet on Disc $70.00
b. Print out on Paper $75.00 + $0.05 for every record over 1500
c. Mailing Labels $80.00 + $0.06 for every record over 1500
d. Print out on Paper + Mailing Labels $85.00 + $0. 11 for every record nver 1500
11) Comprehensive Plan Consistency Review
a. CU's $300.00
b. Rezonings $750.00
c. Pud's or PUD Amendments: $2250.00
d. Letter of GMP consistency to outside agencies: $250
c. SRA. - Stewardship Receivin~ Area - $2.250.00
f. DRl- Development of Rc!!ional Impact - $2.250.00
g. FlAM -~ Fiscal Impact Analysis - $4.000.00
12) Plan Review Fee (for planning review of all building pemlit applications)
a) Long forms: ~ $125.00 per building pemlit application. 2nd review 5()l~, of fee. 3rd and
subsequent 25fy(, of fee (2I1d and suhsequent review fees related to Zoninl:! approvals only)
b) Express pClmits: ~ $50.00 per building pernlit application, 2nd reviev.' 50(~) of fee. 31"d
and subsequent 25%, off~and subsequent review fees related to Zoning approvals
Q!!)yJ.
] 3) Project Meetings: Active.applications under review for the following project types will be afforded one inter-
departmental meeting at no charge: Planned Unit Development re-zonings and Site Development Plan
applications (except for conceptual site plan approval and insubstantial change approval). Meeting requests
for all other application types and additional meetings will be subject to the following fees:
a. Meetings with Departmental Project Approval Staff member per applicant request. reviews
and petitions in progress, $150.00 per one hour minimum, $75.00 per Y2 hour thereafter.
Additional Depanment staff attending meeting per applicant request $75.00 per ~2 hour per
staff member.
b. Inter-Departmental Project Meeting per applicant request, site plan reviews and land use
petitions in progress, $500.00 per one hour minimum. $250.00 per Y2 hour thereafter.
14) Adequate Public Facilities
a. Planning Applications requiring COA process review (such as FP's, PPL's & SIP's, SDPs)
$200.00 + 25.00 per residential dwelling unit or ~ 25.00 per 1000 sq ft commercial
($5000.00 maximum)
b. Building pennit applications requiring COA process review not covered under 12.a above
$100.00 per building permit application.
15) Zoning Confirmation Letters
a. Standard Response $100.00 (includes up to 1 hour research)
b. Extended Research $100.00 per hour (any response with research in excess of 1 hour)
16) Zoning Letter Appeal $250.00
(,DES Financial Administration, rev 11/\3/07 lw
page ]0
17)CDD
a. Community Development District $15,000.00
b. Chapter 1 R9 Special District, Independent or Dependent. $15.000.00
L>'-'on--i~, iJpt"'"' 1\10 ~ ri\ "
lxJCiv81llber 27. 2007
Page 35 of 45
IR) GMP Amendment
a. Small Scale $9000.00
b. General $16.700.00
c. Legaf advenising in addition to sub-sections a and b fees. and subject [0 applicable fee schedule
provisions..
d. Pre-application meetings for GMP consistency for development orders and zoning/land use petitions:
$250
c. Pre-application meetings for GMP amendment petitions: $250 (to be credited toward application fee
upon submittal)
.
19) Application for issuance TOR, $250 (non-rcfundabJe);plus $25 per TDR issued and recorded (total fees not to
exceed $2750)
20) Engineering Services
a) Vacation of Easements: ~ $2.000.00
21) Building Board of Adjustments and Appeals $250.00
22) Early Work Authorization (FW A) permit: $500.00 (does not include site clearing fee).
23) Lef!al Non-conformill!! Lot (LNC) ~lU().OO
24) Vested Ri"hts Determination (VRO) $1.500.00
M) BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION FEE
1) A pemlit application fee shall be collected at time of applying for a
building pemlit. The permit application fee shall be collected when the
plans arc submitted for revie\v. The fee shall be applied toward the total
pemlit fee. The applicant shall forfeit the application fee if the
application is denied or if the application is approved and the permit is
not issued within the time limitation as stated in Section 103.0.1.1 of the
Collier County Ordinance No. 9]-50, as amended.
2) Application fee will be computed as follo\\'"s:
8. SiR.;le faAlil~ aAa al:lJ-'de;: S:.QS Fer sEJ. ft.. jlh miAifRHRl GfS1QQ.lJQ a) 25% of total Buildil1l.! Permit
Fee ($.15/so ft new residential and commercial. $.075 shell and warehouse)
b. '1Hlti Fa",;I,' & CAB,,,,....i.1 $.0, pB":'~ ft H~ 18 19,909 :.~ ft, $ 02. fo.. 8'." 19,Q99 :~. ft.
3) HaJli"'HR' .ppli.a~i8n t<.8 :'h.11 NOT ."6888 $,,000.00.
4) Minimum fee of $50.00 for each of the follov.'ing: plumbing: mechanical (A/C); electrical; fire; and building.
when applying for additions/alterations. Minimum fee for all other applications = $50.00.
5) The balance of the total permit fee will be collected at the time of issuance of the permit and will include any
fee adjustments necessary.
N) BUILDING PERMIT FEES
]) The fee for a building permit shall be computed as follows: Such fees shall be either based on the contractor's
valuations of construction cost or based on ealeHlatea GG:'t sf eSRstrHetiel1 as set [-eRA 8A tAe attaeReEl Bl:lilEliR';
\ 'all::latieH Data TaBle *(E;:hil3it B), '?'RiGRe' 'er i!\ :;reater the contractor's valuations of construction cost or
based on square foota{!e. Minimal accepted calculated cost:-; of construction are set forth on the attached
Buildinc Valuation Data Table (Exhibit B IBC Building Valuation Data Table, produced February. 2007).
Valuation of construction costs of less than $750.00 - No permit or fee is required, but construction must
("DES Financial Administration, rev 11:13/07 h..'
page 11
Fne. r'? Il....n~ ~!r' 1n\/
I~ovember 27, 2007
comply with all County Codes and Ordinances. If inspections are required by the Building Official BEge 36 of 45
requested by tbe applicant. tbe appropriate fees shall be paid.
*ICC 'Tall:lati8H Tael@, J:lf8SI:lEH?S fserHar:/ 20Q?
EXCEPTION: All work involving structural components and/or fire rated
assemblies requires permits and inspections regardless of construction cost
signs must secure permits as stated in Collier County Ordinance No. 2002-01.
as amended.
a. Valuation of construction costs of $750.00 through $4,999.99 ''vith ene 81' FIG iFlsI3eetieFl.: $~g.Og, HTitA
","Itiple iA"po6ti8AS $100.00
13. "al1:tatieFl8fe8flstnietisFI eSNC efi:5,OQQ.OQ tl'lrel.:l..;;h 5:19,990.09
U'itA. SRe 81' 118 iASJ3eetieR: S:~O.go 131M.' $b.OO J:1er the HeaRS sellars, er fmetieR therese, sf BMilEliAg
'all:l.ati8R iR eJ:e8S.' Bff2.QQ9.QQ. "."Pith m.1::I.ltiflle iHsfleGti8Fl.~. $80.00 ,,11::1._' $~.?:O fler thsHSRFl8 sellaL', sr
fraetisFl tFiereef, efsl:lilc:liRg \alwatisR in eJ:Sl?'.' Bf ~2QOQ.OQ.
New construction greater than 500 square feet
1. residential at $0.29 oer square foot (living area)
11. warehouse/shell at $0.]45 per square foot (total area)
111. build-out at $.0145 per square foot (total area)
tv. commercial/institutional at $0.29 per square foot (total area)
G. "all.:l.atisR ef 68R~'trbleti8n 138)\1.' Bf aSQ.QQ9.QO tJ:J.rel.:l.;h a I ,QQO,000 .00 $110.00 J3hc $2.0g J3erth8H~'af1El
8ellar:, 8r fracti8f1 there(,l[ Bf\:~b1il8in; "RlwatioH iR t?J':ee,,'f' ef$5l.\JI00.90.
Alterations, other construction. and new construction under 500 square feet (both residential and
and commercial) $100 plus 0.30(% of declared valuation in excess of $5.000
S. "al\::lati8Fl ef f:18H:truetieH 68:1.. 8. er $:] '()90.QQO.W) S::!3~Y.OQ I'd!::!.' S:1.QO Fer thS1::I.SaHO dollaL'. sr fraetion
thereBf efB\::liIEliA; '.all.:l.atioA il~ en;e~.. flfS::1.0QQ.OQO.QQ.
0) ELECTRICAL PERMIT FEES
]) The fees for electrical permits for new structures or placement or relocation
of structures shall be computed as follows:
a. $0.40 per ampere rating of all single-phase panel boards.
b. $0.15 per ampere rating for switch or circuit whichever is greater, if item
#1 above does not apply.
c. When not a complete installation, all switch and circuit breakers ahead of
panel boards shall be computed at $0.15 per ampere.
d. Pennit fees for any change in electrical installation shall be computed at
the above rates for that portion of new and/or increased fees in ex isting
electrical facilities.
e. The minimum for any electrical pennit shall be $50.00 per unit or tenant
space.
r. Fifty percent (500/0) in additional fee costs shall be added to all above fees
for three phase installations.
EXCEPT10N: Ordinary repairs limited to a $200 value or less may be made
without a pennit. Repairs must comply with all County Codes and Ordinances. If
inspections are required by the Building Official or requested by the
applicant, the appropriate fees shall be paid.
P) PLUMBING PERMIT FEES
1) The following fee calculations shall be applied separately when the pemlit
involves mixed occupancies.
CDES Financial Administration, rev 11 /j 3/07 lw
page 12
a) Residential occupancies: The fee for a plumbing pemlit shall be computed at
the rate of $50.00 to bc charged for each living unit with one to three
bathrooms. An additional fee of$10.00 will he assessed for each additional
bathroom.
r'"lo=.nr""' I.,:.,.,., h' 10\!
t'-Jovember 27 2007
F)aQ~' ~7 ;:>' ..::5
b) Nonresidential occupancies: The fee for a plumbing permit shall be compUled
by the following methods. whichever is calculated to be the greatest fee:
a) The rate of $3.00 per 425 square feet of 11001' area, or tl-action
thereof: or
b) Institutional facilities. hospitals, schools. restaurants and repairs
in any occupancy
b) classification shall be charged at the rate of$1.00 per fixture unit or
c) Minimum of $50.00 for each occupancy or tenant space.
2) Grease traps: An additional fee of $50.00 shall be assessed for each grease
trap.
3) The cost for retrofit piping shall be computed at the minimum fee of $50.00
per floor for each main riser.
4) The cost of a permit for lawn sprinkler systems shall be computed using the
dollar valuation as shown under Section M of this Resolution.
5) The minimum plumbing permit fee shall be $50.00.
Q) MECHANICAL PERMIT FEES
1) The follov..'ing fee calculations shall be applied separately when the pennit
involves mixed occupancies.
a. Residential occupancies: The mechanical permit fees shall be computed at the
rate of $SO.()() for each living unit up to three IOns of air conditioning. Each additional ton or paJ1 thereof shall
be $3.1111 per ton.
b. Nonresidential occupancies: The mcchanical pemlit fees shall be computed by
one of the following methods, whichever is calculated to be the greatest fee:
The rate of $50.00 for the first three tons or three horsepower of air
conditioning or other mechanical systems per tenant space, each additional ton of air conditioning or
horsepower shall be $3.00; or The rate of $3.00 per 425 square feet of floor area, or fraction thereof.
2) The cost of retrofit piping shall be computed at the minimum fee of $50.00
per floor for each cooling tower. or $50.00 for the first 3 horsepower and $3.00 for each additional horsepower,
whichever is greater.
3) The minimum mechanical permit fee shall be $50.00.
4) A permit for the change out of components shall be calculated at the above mechanical pell11it fee rate or the
minimum fee whichever is greater.
R) FIRE PREVENTION AND CONTROL PERMIT FEES
1) The fees and exemptions set fO]1h in the "Exhibit B" affixed hereto and made a
part of this Schedule of Development Revie\\' and Building Permit Fees shall
apply to Fire Prevention and Control Pemlits for both the independent and
dependent fire districts.
S) MOBILE HOME/OFFICE TRAILER AND OTHER TRAILER PERMIT FEES
]) The permit fee shall be $50.00 to set-up a single-wide trailer or mobile
home on an approved site plus electrical, plumbing, mechanical and fire
protection fees as applicable.
('DES Financial Administration. n:v ] 1/13/07 hl,'
page 13
[, ,->nri~ It<:>rYl I;J~' 1 f\\!
T,ovembe: 27 2007
Page 38 of 45
2) The permit fee shall be $75.00 to set-up a douhle wide or larger mobile
homes on an approved site plus electrical, plumbing. mechanical and fire
protection fees as applicable.
T) CHICKEES AND SIMILAR STRUCTURES
]) The permit fee will be based upon a calculated cost of construction of$4.00
per square foot under roof or the contractor's estimated cost of construction,
whichever is greater. The fee will then be calculated in accordance with
Section N of this Resolution. Additional permit fees for electric, plumbing.
mechanical. fire, etc., will be charged when applicable.
U) POOL OR SPA PERMIT FEES
1) For construction of each public pool or spa the fee shall be-
a. Valuation of construction costs of up to $4,999.99. $100.00
b. Valuation of constructIOn costs of $5000.00 through $49.999.99: $80.00 plus $7.00 per thousand dollars,
or fraction tnereof, of building valuation in excess of $2,000.00.
c. Valuation of construction costs of$50,000.00 through $1.000.000.00: $333.00 plus $3.00 per thousand
dollars, or fraction thereof, ufbuilding valuation in excess of$50.000.00.
d. Valuation of construction costs over $] ,000.000.00: $3,474.00 plus $3.00 per thousand dollars, or fraction
thereof, ofbuiJding valuation in excess of$1.000.000.00.
2) For construction of each private pool or spa the fee shall be: $100.00
V) SCREEN ENCLOSURE PERMIT & PAN ROOF FEES
1) Construction costs shall be calculated as follows:
a. Screen Roof. $2.00 per sq. ft. of floor area. (Screen Walls Only)
b. Pan Roof. $3.00 per sq. ft. of floor area. (Screen Walls Only)
c. Existing Roof. $2.00 per sq. f1. of floor area. (Screen Vlalls Only)
2) The screen enclosure or roof fee will then he calculated in accordance with
Section N of this Resolution.
W) SIGN PERMIT FEES
1) Sign permit fees will be calculated in accordance with all applicable Building Permit Fees and Electrical
Penn it Fees outlined in this document. tne Collier County Development Fee Schedule Tne minimum building
pemlit fee for sign shall be $75.00.
2) Multiple signs of the same type (i.e., wall signs) and for a single project may be allowed per one permit,
however an appropriate fee shall be charged for each sign in accordance with the schedule set forth in the
above subsection 1 of Sign Permit Fees.
X) CONVENIENCE PERMIT FEES
1) Convenience pennit" are issued in blocks of 1 0 each. Only licensed contractors are eligible to purchase
convenience permits. Convenience permits are limited to tne use specified on the permit. The fee for a book
of 10 convenience permits is $400.00.
Y) REVISION AND AS BUILT PLAN REVIEW FEES; CORRECTIONS TO PLANS
1) PERMIT AND PLAN REVlSlONS The fee for each permit revision submitted after permit issuance shall be
calculated using fee scnedules outlined in Sections N through R above. The minimum permit fee for revisions
to permitted projects shall be $50.00.
CDES Financial Administration, rev] ]/13/07 lw
page 14
Lnonri~ 1;.1"""'- 1\;" 1')\/
I\JOVe:ilbe, 27. 20T"
3q of ::;,
2) AS BUILT PLANS The fee for "As Built" plan review shall be ten (10%) percent of the original building
pennit fee or $150.00, whichever is greater, but shall not exceed S500.00. The fee is intended to cover the cost
of reviewing amended building plans in the office to detennine that change orders and various field changes
are in compliance with the minimum construction and fire codes of Collier County. The following are required
for as-built drmvings reviev,r:
a. An itemized list of all changes made after pem1it plan approval.
b. As~built plans that have all changes made after pennit plan approval
"clouded".
c. As-built plans and changes shall be signed and sealed hy the engineer
and/or architect of record.
3) CORRECTIONS TO PLANS
a. First Correction to Plans. No charge
b. Second Correction to Plans. $75.00
c. Third & subsequent correction to plans. S100.00
Z) PERMIT EXTENSION
1) The filing fee for each pem1it extension shall be equal to IO'Yl, of the original
building pem1it fee or S100.00, whichever is greater, but,shall not exceed
$500.00. The filing fee is intended to cover the cost of reviewing existing or
amended building plans to detem1ine and verify code compliance
AA) DEMOLITION OF BUILDING OR STRUCTURE PERMIT FEES
1) The pelmit fee shall be S50.00 for the demolition of any building or structure.
BB) PRE-MOVING INSPECTION FEES
1) The fee shall be S150.00 for the pre-moving inspection of any building or
structure.
CC) INSPECTION FEES
1) A charge ofS20.00 per inspection shall be assessed for inspections for which
a pem1it is not necessary.
2) A user fee of $120.00 shall be assessed for all inspections on a
time specified basis.
3) First Partial inspection for single-family & tenant buildout. No charge
4) Second & subsequent pmiial inspections for single-family' & tenant buildout. $25.00
DD) REINSPECTION FEES
1) Re-inspections for any type of building pennit, or required Engineering re-inspections, shall result in
an additional fee of$75.00 per inspection for the first re~inspection, S100.00 for the second re-
inspection and $125.00 for the third and each successive re-inspection.
EE) F AlLURE TO OBTAIN A PERMIT
1) Where work for which a permit is required is started or proceeded with prior to obtaining said permit and
where such action was cited bv Code Enforcement or bv Contractor Licensing and resulted in a findinl! of
violation from either the Code Enforcement Board. the Special Magistrate. or the Contractor Licensing
Board. or as directed bv the Board of County Commissioners the fees herein specified shall be four times 4x
the regular fee. Het t8 el:eeea SI,(J(Jg Qg fer 13eTT-Flits 6sstifl;; S;2~g.g.g afl8 less. +ITe j3efla!PJ f-EIl" faill:lre ta
e19taiA a J3efFFlit "'AeR 8Ae i,' reEJl:lires ha"in; a GOS~ .;reater tAaA S;2~g.gg .'hall ee ('1.8 times tAe repilar
_.
CDES Financial Administration, rev 11/J3/07 Iw
page 15
L\npn,"~~ lie...., t,ic', 1i1\!
T-~ovember 2/ l 2007
2) v.,''here work for which a permit is required is started or proceeded with prior to obtaining said pemrttandO of 45
where a contractor or agent/provider where the building official or zoning director (for cases involving land
development) deems that the contractor/provider should have known that a permit was required but
voluntary seeks compliance bv obtaining the necessary permits to abate the violation the fees herein
specified shall be 2x the regular fee.
3) Where work for which a penn it is required is started or proceeded with prior to obtaining said pennit and
where an owner/builder seeks voluntary compliance by obtaining said permit the fees assessed will be 2x
the regular rate as defined in this fee schedule.
4) Where work for which a permit is required is started or proceeded with prior to obtaining said pennit and
where the unpennitted work was completed by other or prior to the current owner/builder's ownership
of the property an where the current owner/builder seeks voluntary compliance by obtaining said oennit to
assure compliance with all applicable codes the fees will be assessed at the regular rate as defined in this
fee schedule.
5) The payment of such fee shall not relieve any person from fully complying with the requirements of any
apphcable construction code or ordinance in the execution of the work, or from any penalty prescribed
within any construction code, Jawor ordinance of Collier County.
FF) LICENSING
I) The fee for licensing items is as follows:
a. Letters of Reciprocity. ~$25.()0
b. Contractors Change of Status. (active to dom1ant) $10.00
c. Voluntary Registration of State Certified Contractors. $10.00
d. Pictures. $2.00
e. Laminating S1.00 (per license)
f. Fee for a 6 month temporary contractor's license $25.00
g. Certified copies of Experience letters $35.00
h. Duplicate or replacement (ofComoetency cards) $25.00
I. Second entity application fee $SO.OO
2)
Certificated of Competencv (Annual)
a. Contractor
Initial License Fee
Renewal Fee
b. Specialtv Contractor
lnitial License Fee
Renewal Fee
c. Joumevman
Initial License Fee
Renewal Fee
$150.00
$100.00
$135.00
$85.00
$50.00
$25.00
3) Donnant Certificates of Competency (Annual)
a. Contractor $!!!!!.:QQ.
b. . Specialty Contractor $85.00
c. Penalty rees after 9/30 $10.00 per month until 12/31
4) Reinstatement of Delinquent License
a. Contractor
b. Soecialtv Contractor
c. Journeyman
d. Examination Administrative Fee
$150.00 plus back years
$135.00 plus back years
$50.00 plus back years
$100.00 good for 6 months
GG) DUPLICATE PERMIT CARDS
1) The fee shall be $5.00 for the issuance ofa duplicate pennit card for
whatever reason.
CDES Financial Administralion, rev 1 ]/13107Iw
page ]6
HH) CHANGE OF CONTRACTOR OR SUBCONTRACTORS
1) To record a change of contractor or subcontractor, on a penn!t that has been
issued, the fee shall be $50.00. This fee includes the issuance of a new
pem1it card.
j\,iGvembe:- 27. 20CJ'
!i'" :::;; C ~--
II) PERMIT FEE REFUNDS
1) If requested, in writing by the ov-mer or his authorized agent, 500;(1 of the fees
charged, other than the application fee. may he refunded provided that a
pem1it has been issued, construction has not commenced. and the refund is
applied for prior to the cancellation of the permit.
JJ) RECORD RETRIEVAL
1) No charge for retrieving records fi"om inactive or remote storage including
microfilmed documents
KK) COPY FEES
I) The fee for blueprint and miscellaneous copying shall be as follows:
a. Microfilm copies, of documents less than 1] x 17 inches: $0.15 other sizes at cost of production.
f. Microfilm or Blueprint copies:
18 X 24 $1.25 per page
30 X 36 $2.50 per page
30 X 42 $3.25 per page
34 X 44 $5.00 per page
g. Community Development self-service copier. public access and not rclated to public record retrieval
or public record copies: documents less than 14xR.5 inches $0.15 per page inclusive of sales tax.
LL) RESEARCH
1) The fee for researching records. ordinances. and codes shall be at no charge for the first hour. then at the base
salary hourly rate of the staff member conducting the service for time in excess of 1 hour
2) The fee for creating and designing special computer generated rcpol1s that are
not part of the regular standard reports shall be at no charge for the first hour, then at the base salary hourly
rate of the staff member conducting the service for time in excess of 1 hour.
MM) SUBSCRIPTION SERVICE
The fee for one-year subscription service to be mailed quarterly shall be
$15.00 per year. The :mbscription year is from Oct. 1 through Sept. 30.
NN) ELECTRONIC DATA CONVERSION SURCHARGE
1) A surcharge in the amount of 30;;, of the building peru1it application fee, with
the minimum surcharge being $3.00 and the maximum being $150.00, will be
applied to every building penn;t application submitted. A flat fee of$3.00
per permit will be charged for those permits for which an application fee is
not required per item (M) of this Schedule.
00) REGISTRATION OF RENTAL DWELLINGS
]) The fee for registration of rental dwellings is as follows:
a. Initial Registration Fee - S30.00/per property
b. Annual Renewal - $20.00/per property
c. Annual Late Fee - $10.00 per day per property up to a maximum of $80.00.
d. The term "property" means a parcel or contiguous parcels with any number of rental units located
thereupon under common ownership and/or management.
('DES Financial Administration, rev I 1/13(()7 Iw
page 17
!.'''1'=:'h~:; !i.c,.-," t,i,-, i?I';
f"JDvember 27, 2007
2) Relltallnspection Page 42 of 45
a. Rental Inspection - $200000 per unit
b. Re-inspection Fee. $50.00 per re-inspection per unit
c. Rental inspections shall not be required for rental units on property covered by a Florida Department
of Business and Professional Regulation ('"DBPROO) license. A copy of the DBPR license shall be
provided with the initial rental registration and all subsequent rental renewal applications.
3) Any unpaid fees may be pursued hy the Collier Manager or designee through a collection agency.
PP) CERTIFICATE TO BOARD BUILDING
1) Initial Boarding Certificate - $0
2) Boarding Certificate Extension ~ $150
QQ) ADDITIONAL FEE REFUND PROVISIONS
1) Requests for fee waivers may only be approved by the Board of County Commissioners. Vllaiver
requests for development review and building permit fees shall be suhmitted in writing directly to the
appropriate Community Development & Environmental Services Division Staff, who will prepare an
executive summary for consideration by the Board. Such requests shall include a statement
indicating the reason for the fee waiver request and, if applicable, the nature of the organization
requesting the fee waiver.
RR) REFUND PROVISIONS
1) PAYMENT OF FEES: Full payment of fees is required for a complete application. Department
policy requires full payment of fees at the time of application submittal. No work will begin on staff
review of the application until all fees are paid in full. If full payment of fees is not received within
14 calendar days of application submittal, the application will be considered void. At this point, a
neV\' application and full payment of fees \\'ill be required to proceed with a project.
2) There will be no refund of Planning, Environmental, or Engineering related fees, except those
applications which have been deemed not sufficient for staff review and are withdrawn within 30
days of notification will be entitled to a 501il) refund. After 30 days from such notification, there will
be no refund of submitted fees. .
3) In no cases will there be refunds for pre-application fees, data conversion fees, appeals of
administrative decisions, or appeals to the Board of Zoning Appeals or Building Board of
Adjustment.
4) If staff error causes the inappropriate or unnecessary filing of an application and payment of fees,
100 percent of all inappropriate fees, shall be refunded upon written request and with the concun'ence
of Department management.
SS) ADDITIONAL FEE PROVISIONS
1) In those cases where alternative methods or timing of payments for CDES services and / or fees
listed in this schedule associated with SBR reviews are deemed to best serve the public good, the
Community Development and Environmental Services Administrator will have the authority to
approve such alternatives. Such alternative must be in writing and signed by all principals involved.
In no case shall final e.o. or such certifications of project completeness be issued until payments due
CDES are received in full.
2) All hourly fees are computed and charged from actual Divisional time tracking records.
3) All acreage totals used in fee calculations will be rounded up to the nearest whole acre.
CDES Financial Administration, rev 11113/07 lw
page 18
4np-nr'? IiDn"" 1..1,-, .., n\'
NOVeal:)Br 2.;,. 20D i
Page 43 of.:;5
4) \Vhen deemed essential for project review or approval, there will be no additional charge for any
meetings requested by CDES staff.
TT) PUBLIC VEHICLE FOR HIRE FEES
1) The follov..'ing fees shall be assessed for the Public Vehicle for Hire Program:
a. Initial Application fee (new Companies) - $200
b. Cer~ificate to 0J3G'Fat(? $2:~Q Initial Certificate to Operate (Feb l-Jan 31)- $325.00
c. VehiGle Deea] S:~Q reI" eRiele -Annual Certificate to Operate Renewal $325.00
d. TefRfl8F81-:' \'eJqiele eeeal - $~ fler '.eRiele Late Fee for CTO Renewal $200.00
e. Dri' 1:'r IaentifieatioF! Canol $~() fer sri' er Sub-Certificate Application Fee (New Companies) -
$100.00
f P.eJ3laeeA-leFlt lal?Rtifieatiel1 Cara $tQ fler ears Sub-Certificate - $125.00
g. OR :it(' Vehiele PeFFRittiR; ~15 fler' eRiele Annual Sub-Certificate renewaJ- $125.00
h. Late Fee for Sub-Certificate Renewal - $100.00
1. Vehicle Decal- $50.00
J. Temnorary Vehicle Decal $5.00 per vehicle/per dav
k. Temporary Vehicle Decal (In case of inooerable decaled vehicle) - $5.00,/per vehicle
1. Driver Identification Card (lnitialiRenewal) - $75.00 per driver
m. ::::nJ Driver Identification Card - $25.00
n. Replacement Driver ID - $10.00
o. On site Vehicle Pennittin!.! - $15.0U per vehicle
UU)"PAYMENT IN LIEU OF" FEE FOR PATHWAYS (SIDEWALKS, ANI) BIKE LAN~:S)
J) Calculated using the cunent Florida Department of TranSp011ation (FDOT) construction costs or an
engineering estimate not to exceed twenty-five percent (2Y~()) of the submitted application request's total
project cost.
This is the last page of the CDES Fee Schedule
CDES rinallcial Administration. rev] lilJi()7J'^-'
page 19
-- .'~ t.n
--<1
NO
1'~""
, c-r7
~l <1)
~.: g-'
-i;::C-
~Q)
~ ~
G.z
<l
"
'" ~~
- :g
2 _ ~~
~~-
.5 ~ l=l
2,"''''0 ~ ~
0... <<.l > -
~B24-
'- -
o 0
" u
;:: iU
-.n
:;;
~~
~ "0"'::::
~ .::: ~
~ ~~
Z
o 8
~ 1)
-<: .n
U
-
-l
0..
0..
..:
t:
-
'"
~
'"
c:..
.2 ~
~ iU
U -
~1=
~ ft ~
v .~]
,Ill ;;.. [J:
- E ::u
i5 t 23
''':: iU-
t'3 -= "'0
_f-~
6:.~ .~
~ ;:: 1;
;,; _ R ~ v
~ R~a~
::: -< ~ ~
~ ::l~
~ _..0 0..
-
-
.=:
-
<.I
OJ
1JJ
":::l
OJ
'"
o
Q..
::
Q.,
~
::;
:;;
<:':l QJ"';;
~'::E
~~~
';,~
0."0
"'''
"::0
o "
,,-0
u
-15
,,-
~ ~~
: B ~
z o~
9 ~
.... .n
<
U ~
- -;;;
-l "
~ ~
..:
,..
-
-
'"
~
'"
0..
'-'
z
Q
-l
~
c:i
-
-
o
.-
-
<.I
OJ
1JJ
OJ
OJ
~
-
o ;::;
.~ 0..-2
.;d~'"O
'O.f-<,8
0... :::::
'" ;::
.is
'f - ::l
~, g,. 'l; V
5.CJJ~~
-<.5 ~
:2 ;::
~] .[
-
-
OJ
...
...
::
U
~
-
'"
.2 ~
" u
u.=
~f-o
",.
~ :::
"
.;
"
~
~-=
.- '-
o
"
]~
~.2
'" "
" u
,..C ;..=
'"
~ g-
v;~
~
cE
iij""";
0..0
~,.....;
-=0
"0
o C
'" 0
'"0 'E
~ iU
bVl"O
o,.=: ~
~"'B ~
.~ fi @
.2 ~ ~
Cii ctl,~
u ::: "-'
_0"(
0....::
g.,So,
~ ~
:-:: E ~
.~
-:S?
6
13 0
:"::'"0
"'"
0....;:::
~ ti
1:'''0
.~ .~
~
.~ -
'-
o
V
0.0
~,.,..;
-=0
;:!
~ .g
v i::
pllJ-ci
0..::: -2
0."0 -
ctl V g
.~ ~ @
;::::: U:;:FJ
.2 if; ro
"u ~_ 0
~ _ 0 If)
~ 6:'~~,
ctl :~
~ .5 .:: ~
-;;;
~~
5'-
.; ~
.~ '-
0..6
"'.-
'" "
" u
..c:..:::
'"
~ g-
"'ir..5
4- ~ ~
@ c .~ @
~ '"0 V.S:
o.<l.!-=-O
g,'5 ~ 0
1:' "'0._ 9
.~ ::: :3
.2] 0
~ ~ -
.;:: rJ).~
0....: 0
c,; 0... 0
c.. ctl :::v
"0
@
~
c
"
"0
.~
"
~
~
~
'"
'"
~
v;
v
(,j~:g
~ " 0
o iU"'::::
::::~!1J
~ ;;a
:n'i= 3:
ro 5;!
]0..;;
o blJ-
~.= ~
_"0-
6:-:: V'J
u ::s or,
"c:lr-
..c_~
\":ltA
;;. :s
.....'-~
o 0 ~
~
~
0;
o
U
~ ~_u
.2 ,~
~~8
.~
0.
'"
<
N
o
o
Q~
0'-
~g
'00
o
-0
30
I;.
o
.- <:::
> 0'"
, ~
~ :...
"
,"-
.z. -
~ ti ~
..2 o...~
-If'l..
<EO-
:n ~.g 6
'" U
"'0 X ~ 0-
~~E<I:
:l :l'" 0
C--o 58
E-ouo
8 @ ~
]..Q.b~
.~ 0
.~ a @ -
;::::~w....~
~ ~'''= l/j
r...;:. eIJ- N
::: ::: =
.3 'J) ~.,;
"
.~ cr:i.c
0.
0.
<
N
~ ~
.~ .2
~ ~
u~
~(:;j
- :Ii
Ob ::::
:::: .2
:..0::::
==5
o ~
0.5
DfJr..,.;;.
.:: ~
;;..:: 0
6.bo
-"'.
~ ;;-~
" '"
..c ~ II
'0"3 ~
-5 ~.~
'" - u
l\) ""0 .-
- '"
-2.E f;-
~~i
o@""'o
on .,
'" "
'o~~
v ~.2
~.~ v
...u~
.~ ~ :5
~u
....,<1::::;;
o
o
o
o
o
or)
'"
"0
"
"
u
~
"
f-
o
Z
~
-;;;
"
~
C
.s
"
.S<
0.
'"
'"
~
~
~
~
~
~,
'-c
o B1
" ~
.~ ~
- ~
~
~ ~
~~
~ ~
~~
- '"
8 ~
iU4-
.n
-5 r-
'- V
o '"
~-5
~
"''-
1; 0
.n u
~ ~
a
o
~
~ .~
"
.g
~
u
"
E
~
.g
'"
~
-"
"
~
:~
-0
~o
-2~
o
OJ)l/j
'"
>-.11
0.<1:
o.C
(';l .2
- "
~ .~
~o.
, '"
blJ '"
C ~
:2~
'5 -0
.n
'"S1"';j
@,2
u (U
~~
~J
~
.2
.w
~
.2
S
-E
'-
o
~
u
~
"
~
<2
o
o
=
on
'"
'-
o
"
~
- (;-
..~= ~ ~
c-0'B'=
~~~;2
;:;
~,
;;
'- :7
o "
u
.~ ~
- '"-.
~~
-~
-; [f;
"0 0
v~
U '"
..!< u
o~
u >,
" C
.n '"
"
~5
uu
~ .::
~
7
=
,,-'
:;/
f::: ::::
g,'"S1
a
E
2
-5g,
'0 ~
1j;::
~ 0
(';l iU
e; ~
.n a
" 0
-'" ~
f- ~
~
7
~
~,
~
1e,
;QO"1"'
10-
NO
- . LD
-cA ~
~N~:
9 ,~
01 c.,~.
.;::j..c m
~~2-
~ 0
~.=
<11
z
~
.~
-
'"
'"
'"
~
-
"'0
"
";j
'"
'"
"
'"
"'0
"
'"
o
::
I'.
~
Q.) 0 "'Q
if. c/]::o a
~8 ~6~~
_ (':l~o.30
""G.2 -; - 0 v
a ::; '0 c 1; z >"~
;:s l!J w... ...... u-ci
rr. "Z r.r. .g "0 0 5 E 'C;
_5 0 8 g ~; .0 0 0-
u ~..alr~0~.,g
~'"'3~>e~c:3~
:; SP :::- a ._ :s ]
~~~:~~~
"E~~]~_'-::~
_ CIl :::: >, ~
0."'0 ...D .~_
~~(;'otl-o
ti u C:: u: !V 0.
c;j ~ .2 "'6 ;;!~~ ~ ~
J ] l~~ ~;
u"';:'o_>-;:uc;;;
~ -=- r- ::l
- . -" .~ 5;_ ~
u ...... _ 'f.__ .~_~ iii
Of) :- 32 i5::-: .:::
<:':l 2 ._ u '.~ u
- ::1,-",::0-
~v a. a..
~ y; P2 0 "5 or. c;j
~ ~ ?E .3 ~ ~ Ji
6- .2 g!V oF, E'
v; CJ c;j :::;- ~
,~~.u ?v_aJ
:-e ~ tr
t;"Z r--.'f:. ~
cr _ -;:::::> u '='
2 8 S~..;;:"=:, i-'
is
iG ~
"" c
v
"5 ~
0.-=
~ g:
'U_,!
v is
..ow
~
~
-;;;
rJJ [:::
'" CJJ c
!::: =""
~ ~,
::l.n
f!!:. ...D _
a:: ~.:S
[.o.J 2 OJ
""
1
n. V
',"", ~
~ Q.) ~
:5 r- v:
;;:,
:Q N
z
(3 'F
<.r, ~
u 0
~ u
~
u ,2 u
::l u .;::!
c/J ? -;
~ ;!l.s
.2 8 c
2'00
v
~
z
V;. .:f;
~
.2
~ (;j
~ 0
0._
::: ("j
- ,
8 -;t:
u is
.c U
"
~
-:r. 0
u
is ~
v a 0
~ cr. ~
!V Il.J '(3
snti"O~~
z c.. 0 '- (';;l
.,..; c V 0 0.
~z~'SP~
~ 0 ~ =.-_= ~
2~'~ ::l ~
..,2 M
t)~~c;_-';_~
if, -:;v; _ ~
~ co .g'~ 1;' ~
.2:E r.r. ]:''''0 .-
.... '" ~ ~ ~ o.
? ~ ~ -
-~~ 8'~. ~
"'Z ... ,."
(5 ~ z; v:
u ...D ~ ::l
'- c;j u
o
!V-:S
iii
~
" .~_ ._0 0 iii
8 8 ~ u .~ ~
-0 ? ~_' g, Co
Q.) ~. v;. c;j
~ 3.:: ~
_ u'-_
c
0;;
u
~
.~
-
OJ
'"
'"
..!::
=
"'0
'"
-=
OJ
'"
OJ
OJ
'"
-E
'" ~
~ 0.'-
~ ~!) 0
="0
~ ~ ~
f-o :-= :oj
= ::1..0
'" .c
:z:: ~ ~
~ c;:: 'OJ
Qj Qj 5
Cj ~..o '"0
Z 0>
Q ~ $::: ~
....J f- '7i: ..0
;;:,
c::
.2 "0
~ c
~ :.)
~'o
> ,.-
~.2
.::: ;
::: ::I
'::i-;:;
c::l>
'5 v;
.c 0>
'"0 id
?J ~
.:; .:::
0-"'2
2C
-
~
~
=
u
z
>,
.c
""
"
~
~
S"
-0
0>
~
~ .2 ~
-u -
'-'- ;:l.s
is
~"?
~ 0 (5
~~ 9
, 0:5
~ ~, 0
O~U
E- "? 1)
3 51=
u Qj 0
.u
~ '{;.
,3 :3'-
~u]
v; ~5
"::. if.
.::: <j)
~
,0
z
~
2~
o @
i:
.~
~
~
0.
0>
5-0
u U
~'"S1
g
~ a
if
~ ~
.?!I::::
if. '"'1
-<:
z
:2 v.
_ .2::
~:c
u u ~
;...-: cr ~ ~
~ 2 un
.5
u
""
v
~
C"-
o
o
~,
?J .2 ~
,- u
;:l g
is
~:.o
-QoO
iii u
~ 0 ~'
~ ~ 0
~= ~ u
:- "? u
o b1)=
u 1.1 0
, U
.~ ~
.3 .2 .-
~u]
~ ~E
.~ ~
~
?
iii
"
15
v
'-
"0
0>
U
~
-g
E..
oJ
:D
~
f-
"
;;
=:0
.~fJ
;.... '"S1 .'"_.
'0 a
.~
~
0.
U
5-0
U 0>
:i;2
v: g
~_ iii
V
[f, ~
OIJ-
[t ::g '\i: S'
U u 8
>< ~, "6 ,-,
;.w co::; :..IN
.3
;;
o
"
;;-
.~j
:2
5
co
u
co
""
o V
~ ;-
.~
=< =-
z ;:r
Q v
- .~
.
~
0'
0'.
~
0'
0'
.,;
<A
~j
~
o
o
;r;
C"-
<A
~
o
~
~
o
u
.2
u
~
~
is
u
~
o
.2 :>
" 0
=-g
0;;
>V"J
o
~
o
10
0-.0
0'0
ry:-
0''''
0\ if)
-:i g
<A ._
U
ouO>
~ 0.
P ;e
- 0>
oE-
~~
<A
~
~::::
"g;;-
uo
:;
.9 ~
u
o
0;;
g
o
<2
u
iii
~
-;; ~
:s ;:;
u "-
o~"OO\
v <.2 1I<.2 ~
-2 '-'
~~~~~
co::; 5-trl 5--
is- CJ) ~ "" ro
[fI l-. - l-. :::
o ~g ~.g
0_ ",0
If'iN C;:;':"Z
... -: - "::.
~-; - ......
_ VI ~ 0 ._
~[7.";
wc;-;:;
~ ~ '5'0
2 0 ~_
~~.
a '5 (3
:::: ..0 u
~
u
iii
~-;
~ "0 ~
~ 0;""
ou - ~
= 0
:~ 2
;;
;;
u
50:::
u
-"0
5 ";;,
.;:: :t.I
c .
B
~
c
c
~
:::
u
Z
.c
"" .-
a::::
0'
0' 0
~-o
&~
0\ ~
.,. 0
<A 0
--"
- -
on ~
o u
P c-
o
-0
o~
"'"
6 0
c: y;-
o =:;
g~o
N'.gg
<A ~
~o ~ N
ahA
~ ~ ~
~ ~ v;
1.1 ;j
~ X
.- c- 1.1
;!;'
.2
?i u
3 Qj
u c-
o ;e
::5 [f) 0
c: =- .2 trl .-
..,.-, c-":;: .n _
fA 0 :5 VI .9
'0 Q -;:; u: e;
"';;:;;:-~~
- VI ':l!j........ '"
~ ::: 0 ;:-
u ~:.o ~ ~
,.- -:-= Q.:::
.g .~ .E ~ ;:g
:..1:..1<.0- ::l
;:l ~ o"::...c
......v;<..,..:
~ ::: o.,g '0
c .- :u u <.-:
~g~~~
o (5 - .~ ~
.3 ~ .2 UJ
-- c t) r 0
ro co::; E';
=- ...:: - u
ro ~ ~
>::::0::::-::
.3 g
"@ 6
~ ~
> 5
"
.n
~
o
g~
<no
i~
~
o
.2 Q.
u
iVl
u
"
'13
~ ~
~ 0
iii U
~
u
iii
. ~
- -
.g a ""
u -;:; 13
;::l C u
~ ~ r;
c .;;
~ ~.-
~
o
..c .2
o
..o"@
i~~
.~ ~"'O
~ !'.J ?J
_~ ~ E
~ U
< 9: ~
U
o
o
=:;
o~
o. C
0"":
o 0
c; 2
fA~
""5iJg
~ .-
P U
~
-e:
o
c: 0
'-'..,jo
Ol-.C:
ci~g
~.:o~
",0
~~~
'f., if. <.0-
:;;; ::I C
8..s ~
u
.2, u ~
_ c- IlJ
~
;:l ~._
C/] ~.2
8 <I) ~
,-2::1
C c..~
Q ;....
.2 ~ ':llJ
-- 0 c
g~:g
cc VI '5
> I ..c
o
o
o
o
vi"
'"
~
o
~
..=! .g
o.~
o 0
00;;
o ;....
~.~
~:2
~
o.c
o~
00
o
00
9 ?J
.. ~
~-5
fA .3
~ u
o ~
~'7=
o 0
U r./;6
(3 ~ c:
=0
't; o'~
? "D 0
~"E g
_ 80
o [f) ~
u ::l fA
'o~L.-
- 0
.2 ~ ~
~ g ~
~ N Qj
> VI ._
~
-0
Agenda Item No.1 OW
November 27, 2007
Page 1 of 23
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to amend the County's Purchasing Policy to further
modernize the County's business practices
OBJECTIVE: To enable County staff and County vendors to conduct business
in a more cost-efficient and cost-effective manner.
CONSIDERATIONS:
In the FY 2007 budget, the Board of County Commissioners appropriated funds
in the Purchasing Department's operating budget to procure an on line software
solution for soliciting and receiving formal and informal bids and proposals.
The system went into live production in April and has been extremely successful.
Among the benefits to date include the following:
o A nearly 200% increase in the number of vendors registered to receive
ITB/RFP notifications. We now have more than 2,000 vendors registered.
o Authentication of the receipt of bid-related documents by prospective bidders.
o The ability of bidders to view the results of bid openings remotely within
minutes of the event.
o An estimated reduction in annual operating costs of more than $16,000.
The Purchasing Department is recommending that the Board formally amend the
purchasing policy to expressly authorize the use of this new technology. Further,
staff is also recommending additional changes that would further streamline
business processes and clarify the authority of the Purchasing Department (and
in some instances, other staff) to take appropriate cost-effective actions on behalf
of the agency. Additionally, there are minor corrections to existing language in
the policy. The changes would become effective immediately.
FISCAL IMPACT: There is no specific cost associated with the proposed
changes. However, it is anticipated that these changes will collectively serve to
reduce staff time associated with performing various business practices.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There is no impact on the Growth
Management Plan.
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners formally
amends the County's purchasing policy as recommended herein.
PREPARED BY:
Steve Carnell, Purchasing/General Services Director
Page J of 1
Agenda Item No. 10W
November 27,2007
Page 2 of 23
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Item Number:
Item Summ.ry:
lOW
Meeting Date:
Recommendation to amend the County! Purchasing Policy to further modernize the Counlys
husinAss practices. (Steve Cflmell. Purchasing Department Dirac!!)r)
11!2'l120079:00:00AM
Approved By
Slav.Carn.1I Pu~hujngIGen'r.ISye.Dll1lctor D...
Adrnlnl.tr.tlv.S.rvIC:.' Pun;:hnlnlll 11/1JI20077:29PM
Approved By
Len GOlden Prlee Admlnl,lr.ll.... Service. Administrator 0.1.
Admlnl.lrllll....S.rvle.. Admlnl.tlllll.... S.rvlces Admin. 11/1-4/20012:58 PM
Approved By
OMS Coordinator ApplieallontAnllly.t Oat.
Admlnl.tratl....S.rvlc.. InformlllonT.ehnology 11114120014:42 PM
Approved By
lal.lraDa~f.son Managamlnl & Budget AnalYll D...
County ManaUIlr'1l Offlcll Offlee of Manalilllmllnt & Budget 11/16/20071:40PM
Approved By
MlehaalSmykowskl Man,gemenl & Budget olreetor Oalll
County Man'9flr'l OffIca Offlel of Mllnllgllmllnt & Budgllt 11/19/200712:48PM
Approved By
Jam.. V. Mudd County Manager olte
BOllrdofCounly County Managlr't OfTlel 11/19/20011:14 PM
Commls'lonlllll
file://C:\AgendaTest\Export\93-NovemberoIo2027, %202007\ 1 O.%20COUNTY%20MANA.. 11/20/2007
Agenda Item No. 10W
November 27, 2007
Page 3 of 23
RESOLUTION NO. 2007-_
A RESOLUTION OF THE COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS SUPERCEDING COLLIER COUNTY RESOLUTION 2006-268 AND
AMENDING THE PURCHASING POLICY
WHEREAS, Collier County Ordinance 87-25 provides for the establishment of a
purchasing policy to govem all aspects of purchasing administration; and
WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners on October 10. 2006 adopted a
purchasing policy by Resolution 2006-268; and
WHEREAS, County staff seeks to clarify and update existing provisions to further
promote the efficient and effective acquisitions of commodities and services.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that:
Resolution 2006-268 as presently constituted, is hereby superceded by this
Resolution and shall serve to amend the Purchasing Policy attached hereto and
incorporated herein by reference.
This Resolution adopted this _ day of
second and majority vote favoring same.
,2007 after motion,
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
Deputy Clerk
By:
James Colletta, Chairman
Approved as to fomn and
1'K2/v --r
Robert Za ary
Assistant County Attorney
I.
.PURCHASING POLICY OF COLLIER COUNTY
I. ESTABLISHMENT OF PURCHASING POLICY
Ordinance No. 87-25 provides for the adoption of a Purchasing Polley. Collier County Resolution No.
2006-268 establishes the following Purchasing Policy.
II. PURCHASING DEPARTMENT RESPONSIBILITIES
A The Purchasing Department shall be responsible tor'
Seeklna Mwclmum Value: Act to procure for the County the highest quality commodities,
supplies and contractual services at least expense to the County
2 Enc.ouraoino comoetition: Endeavor to obtain as full and open competition as possible on
all purchases and sales.
3 Procedures; Establish and amend, when necessary, operational prOcedures for the
implementation of the Purchaaing Policy provk:led by ordinance, Said procedures shall
become effective only when approved in writing by the County Manager, Copies of the
procedures shall be maintained on file in the office of the Purchasing Department.
4 Purchasina Anal\IBis; Keep informed of current developments in the field of purchasing,
prices, market conditions and new products, and secure for the COunty the beneflts of
research conducted in the field of purchasing by other governmental Jurisdictions, national
technical sodetles, trade associations having national recognition, and by private business
and organizations.
5. Purchaalna Manual; Prescribe and maintain a standard Purchasing Manual for all using
agenctes. The content of said manual wlU be governed by this J)'oIlcy.
6. E.2!:ml: Prescribe and maintain such forms 8S shall be found reasonably necessary to Ihe
operation of this Polley
7. Vendor Certification: Document lhat vendors doing business with the County have
acknowfedged their understanding and acceptance of the terms and conditions of' the
County's Purchasing Policy and have agreed to abide by those terms
8. Bulk Purchases: Exploit the possibilities of buying "in bulk" so as to take full advantage of
discount.
9. Vendors' Cataloo File: Prepare, adopt and maintain a vendor's catalog file $aid catalog
shall be organized according to materials and/or services and shall contain descriptions of
vendors' commodities, prices and discount
10. Tax Exemotlons: Act so as to procure for the County tax exemptions to which it Is entitled.
11. Coooeratlon: Cooperate with using agencies so as to secure for the County the maximum
efficiency in budgeting and accounting.
12 Susoension and Debarment of Vandars: To oversee and facilitate the suspension andlor
debarment of vendors as set forth under Section XXVllI of this policy.
13. lnauiN and Control: Have full authority 10 question the quality, Quantity, and kinds of items
requisitioned in order that the beat Interests of the County Bre served. The Purchasing
Director shalt have final approval authority for all purchases at or below the formal
competItive threshold. To ensure the timely. proper and orderly acquisition of services to the
various using agencies, all authority granted to the Purchasing Director in this policy may be
formally delegated by the Purchasing Director in whole or in part to appropriate staff
members within the County Manager's agency.
Agenda Item No. 10W
NOlrlIiliWer i1J:,.;100,1"on
;."ocoP~ 4 of 23
I-III.
~11:1 n PlJo....uAi. QonI:DiJf:>>URCH~E~OF '1 OOOQ~ Liiii) NOT EXCEEDlNG So1 ooD ~
.ff,I"".~.t_._ O~,r:et '!Aj~ ~-' ..,.,_~ _ef "'.d_'''r!''JI_~. !l~~;J~@~ '9!M.e_F\:.~':IIL"" ~'v.~~by
'i19~ar:ll:R.AtI ler IRCIms~iat8 JlYFGhaea ef Q911RmtailUlI. awt .1 tEI"iA tFa...II'~~8F1<;1itijN8 IIRS UP is.. Ret
1& 8I{BiIB~~' FF1HifRWIIR ''''WI Df 11,00Q ,Purct\ases !ft. do 001 exceea S3000 maW' be aooroved b'w'
the Purchaslna Director without infonnal or 10nnal CO/T1nstltion 0\1 means of a ourcha$e or~r
ourchasinc card or formal aale8rnent lor anv combination therein) as defined under this DOHc~ or
~med 3ooroonate "bv the Purchaslna Director
I'V
QIJQTATIQ~JG.it~f:C_+i.MAl~~:1f.::E-:~iTC!\ (PURCHASES~:~W~,EEC~IN9 $3.000 BUT NC'f
Qt~.kj\!fJ-~_It!f.\NS50~OOO)
A. All ~Y~!:raU8 at 99FA~~"lti..~; 8~"tr:a~@t,',~r;BI. eta ~~_l .88ti"'a'~d".'~~t,~~ ,iF!, 8x&eIlB Qf
eRe lheWlliIRilliIeJlsre {$.:I",OOO) BRiiillalS tt:1SR 9r glll",.1 f9 lhe fam:1al sampatl.1 'a tRN'R8f~ ma~ 11-8
-0'" iR ,*" 91nl"" FRQFht "'ftl:l8IJt f8Fmll rllIsll; a~r:UIWFl;em.Rt IRQ ilt:1ewt fG'RRal G9FRi=l!ItltieR
All purchases exceeding $3,OOO..!WlnQLrn..Q!:.(!:Jhan $50.000 shalf be awarded by the Purchasing
Director to the qualified and responsive vendor submitting the lowest or beat overa" Quote which
meets all specifications, unless the requirement for competition Is waived by the Purchasing
Director in accordance with Sedion 4.8. All such Durchases may be solicited and awarded
without formal Dublic dnnouncement and without formal comoetition
1. Minimum Number Quotes; Open market purchases or sales In excess of $3,000 but less
than or equal to the formal competitive threshold shall be based on a aoed faith effort bv the
Purchaslna Deoartmenl or tf1e US10Q aaencv to obtain at least three (3) competitive quotes~
UL~~.,gE"~i.I!!!._:::'S' _~9!~fJ~. .~.. 1:ie.~.'IRilU ~~;t(d,,~aH !:Ire fflaQe to, ~
lowest, qualified and responsive quote in acoord8nce with the standards set forth In this
Policy.
2. Solicitation of Quotes: The Director may sollat Quotes ara.llv written, or electronically JQr_
open market pricing or sale. using available btdders' and supplier lists. The Director shalt
determine in which instances quotations shall be solicited in writing. Further the Director
shall determine which agency (e,g.; Purchasing or the using agency) shall obtain the
quotations. All quotes In excess of ten thousand dollars $10.000 shall be tendered or
confirmed in writing ~f!~\LQfll~~jIY submitted by the vendor prior to purchase.
3. Public Record: The Director shall keep a record of all open market quotes submitted and
such records shall be open to publiC Inspection after award has been made.
B. The requirement! for requesting quotes from three (3) or more sources are waived and do not
require Boerd actlon for:
1. Purchase of library books, education andlor Peraonnel tests. similar audio visual materials,
perlOdlcall. printed library cards, etc.
2. Profeaeional serv~ and, in Instances when authorized by the Purchasing Director where
commodities or services are purchased cnrectty from the owner of 8 copyright or patent. a
govemmenllll agency, I recognized educattonel institution. a not~for-proflt entity or when
there are no other identifiable sources avsilabte,
3. Purchases fhllthe Director has determined to be \egIUmate single source purchases.
4. Varld public emergencies or other instances deemed by the Director to be in the best
interests of the County.
5. Purchase of services from experts or consuttants by or through the Office of the County
Altomey for purposes of preparing for or defending agslnst imminent or pendIng dvil
litigation or administrative proceedings.
C. All purchases. greater than $1.000 but less than or equal to 53.000 will generally be processed
using a regular purChase order. However, such purchases may be processed using a
purchaslng card tn accordance with Section XXIII of this policy.
,
Agenda Item No. 10W
NQlIllIDber ~ /1Q07 i
77i07OParJe g of2'3~ on
~, Foftn8tted: Strik<<hrough
~ 1 J: Slnkethmogtl
'.~~:.:~.r~~~.~
-
FormIlttlM: Stri~~h
-,
._-~_.
FOI'fNtted: StrillethrolJQh
'DetetecI:.
r"'" ._.~__,.._;
'.~~~-~~~~~~..,-".,,~.
-,
For.......: StrIIl2thl'QlJgh
t f\,.,.. I J: 5tr1k1!throu;h
'.P~~~~~,!!~_~,~_~~ltten ~~.~
.
v.
FORMAL COMPETITIVE THRESHOLD (Purchases In excess of 550.000)
A. It is the intent of the Boarcl of County Commissioners to establish an amount of fifty
thousand dollars ($50,000) as the County's formal compelitive threshold for purchases, The
established limit shall be applied to aU methods of purchase by agencies under the purview
of the Board of County Commissioners, including but not limited to competitive sealed bids,
competitive proposals and competitive selection and negotiation. The requirement for formal
competition may be waived by the Board of County Commissioners where permitted by law.
under the following circumstances.
".:.. Single source purchase,s (pursuant t(;l subs!,ction C).
...1 Valid public emergencies (pursuant to ~tion XX).
d. Whe~ ilis determined to be in the best interests of the County to qo so.
B. All purchases subject to formal competition shall be awarded by the Board of County
Commissioners unless oltJerwtse deleoated by the Board via formal public action.
C. Exemotian For Sinale Source Commodities: Purchases of commoditIes and services from a
single sourca may be exempted from formal competition upon certification by the PurChasing
Director of both of the following conditions:
1. The item(s) is the only one available that can property perform the intended function(s);
2. The recommended vendor/contractor is the only one ready, willing and able to meet the
County's requirements.
AJI Single SOurce purchases in excess of the formal competitlve threshold shall be exempted
from formal competition by the Board. f<ecurnno smale sourl:'..e nurchases shall 1101 re~
~ubse(luentf2Qard aooroval (If"! the same or ;r:Um~..subseouenl t'itr.al Year) orovlded thal,Jl:l.tr.~
!:!.uL~"!!mg!~nLbud.ill!!_!mQ.r.QQrlS'"V.Q.lJ~Jq m'i..~a~r5:n~t!!:~LPurchases less than or equal 10 the
formal competitive threshold may be exempted from competition by the Purchasing Director, as
permitted by law.
D. Use of Past Performance Data: In order to promote the qualitative delivery of commodities and
services. County departments shall record and consider the past performance of vendo", in the
aWBrd of contracts exceeding the formal competitive threshold. This objective shall be
accomplished as follows:
1. The Purchasing Department shall be responsible for each of the following:
a. Developing, implementing and maintaining appropriate admInistrative procedures,
instructions and technOlogies necessary to collect and access vendor performance
data.
b. Ensuring that relevant past performance dala is properly gathered and considered prior
10 award of subsequent contracts.
2. Using agencies shall be responsibkJ for each of the follOWIng:
a. Conducting periodic performance evaluations of vendortl under contract with the County
pursuent to the proceduf'ft estabtlshed pursuant to subsection V.D.1a.
b, COnsidering the past performance of vendOI'$ during the evaluation of formal bids and
proposatlS for subsequent contract awards as set forth in the administrative procedures
referenced under subsection V.D, 1a.
VI COMPETITIVE BID PROCESS
Any purchase of commodities or services costing in excess of the formal competitive threshold shall
be accomplished by competitive sealed bid. by competitive selection and negotiation (per section VII)
or by competitive proposals (per section VlIl). Award of BId Contract shall be made by the Board to the
3
Agenda Item No. 10W
N~er ?7.,?QQ7 .
. ;';'~~ 'l:lro't' f2"3sJ..cn
7.1~.OI ~_.m~_...'_. ,_
~~!-
Detet.dl Page Break..
--_."-
o.Ietlld:lI
ForrnetbJd: font Arid!
'DefftIId:1
, Delehd: 2
Deklted: 3
I.
lowest, qualified and responsive bidder except where otherwise provIded for in this policy or unless an
exception is granted by the Board, Bid limits for requirements utilizing federal or state funds will be
those requtred by said agency granting the funds or the County's requirements, whichever takes
precedence.
A. Notice Invitlna Bids:
1. Announcement: Notice inviting bids shall be publicly posted by the Purchasing Department
in a consistent public location at least ten (10) days preceding the last day established for
the receipt of bid proposals. Bids may be solicited andlor received in one or more steps as
permitted by law and deemed approprlate by the Purchasing Director.
2. Scaoe of Notice: The pub!lC notJce required herein shall include a general description of the
commodities/services to be purchased or sold, shall state where bId instructions and
spedftcatlons may be secured snd the time and place fOf openIng bids.
3. Bidders' List: The Director shall also solicit sealed bids from Qualified prospecuve
vendors/contractors who have J80isterBd ~ir_ fJ~rT!".pn_lhe Camer Countv Purchaslna.
Deoartment Vendor Dalabase, which will 6Iectrot'J~-!Y.J\enq, them,;t nQtIce of the Dmposed
purchase or sale. ~s_el)~.tc;;l.lh"Y!J~rslconlra:ctors on the.(;Qlllet~ty PurChasma
Deoartment Vendor Data.base shan be limited to commodities or services fhat are similar In
character and ordinarily handled by the trade group to ~en the ~.~e sent
Vendors/contractors are resoonslble for mamtalmna l~elr OI'ot'ilesn !.he noled database 10
ensure Droottr nollflc.ations are received.. Vendorsfcontractors may be removed rrom the
noted database .by the Dire<:t9f for . contl'1~Jal rn;m-fe$oonse eo form. ~I anD
vlOlatior'ls io the Purch,:u;JnQ POj~_ Tt1@: \J.Ir8C.tOlJlli!!.1 h.,,. th~ OI$cl"l'rtiQn to continue !(~
m.H1e inm1ai Sl:J{i(;'ll.a1Je:ms afJo, a7,~ fqrmal bKts ~r(loqs~Q!J..2!['l~LJ~!l~!S uS<<'JO D!lf~
where aooroorlale..
4. Bid Deooslts: When deemed necessary by the Director, bid deposits shall be preScribed in
the public noticea invitln& bids. Saki deposits shall be in the amount equal to five percent of
the bid submitted. The Dlreclor shall have the authority to retum the deposits of all bidders
prior to award 01 bid contract by the Board of County Commissioners. A successful bidder
shall forfeit any deposit required by the Director upon failure on the vendOr's part to enter
into a contract within ten (10) working days after written notice of award.
5. Bid Addenda: An addendum to a specfflcation shall be defined as an addition or change In
the already prepared specifications tor whiCh an invitalion has been lU\LtrLfor _~Ofl!lO:'t
quotations or an announcement has been posted for a formal sealed bid. Any addendum to
a request for formal sealed bids shall be apprOVed by the Department Director or designee
and the Purchasing Director. The addendum shall clearly point out any addition or change to
the Invitation for bids. The Purchasing Department shaU be responsibte for in.uring that
addenda are available an the e-orocurement website a~~_all prospective bk:tders who
have.downloaded specl_fl~ti9ns are notified afttla ~ddendUrT1",pr19~. t9 9Qe:nlng_of t?~~.
B.
Procedure for BkD:
1. Sealwd Bids: Sealed bids shall be submitted manuallv or etectronicatlv to the p"'c;tor._a_n91f. .
manual shall be c1earty identified as bids on the outside of the sealed envelope.
2. ~: Bids shaH be opened publicly at the time and plaCB stated in the pUblic notices
and shall be witnessed and certified by the Purchasing Department.
3. Tabulation: A tabulSUOn of aU bide received shall be made either electronicallY or by the
Purchasing Department and shall be available for pub'", Inspection.
c
Tie Bids: Where there are low tie bids, the award process shah first be subject 10 Section 287"
F,S. Should a tie still exist amonG two or more bidders and If the purchase 18 funded In whole or
in part with interagency grant funds, the tie shall be broken in accordance with the grant
conditions or the grantor agency's procedure goveming such matters. If no interagency granl
funds are appropriated for the purchase and anyone of the low qualified vendors has a principal
place of business located in Collier County, the bid shall be awarded to the local bidder.
,
Agenda Item No. 10W
N~er ~?~f2Q07 .Ion
mQ;'JI.~r o~':'f
Deleted: . - -..,...Pitl)e Break............
~
,~.
r"-----',.,'-,..--...,"
~" ~: re4Jelted
, DeIec.d: be placed
i DMetMI: I "bid"s' list"
: Peletlldl the Director .halI malnblin,
i. by
~ Deteted: iog
;~: a copy Of such
: Detemd: ,jIS will acquaint them with
ill1e
\ DHIbM: Invitations
'( o.tetIld: bIdd8nI'lIst
; DetetecI: Invitltlons
'DeJetred:bldders'
. DeIftH: list
. o.lttt8d: cootinuall'101l-reSDQnS8 to
bid requests
. Fonnatted: Font color: Onlnge
FoI'1'rlMted: Font 12 pt. Fort color:
"""'"
FormatUld: Font: 12 pt:
Deleted: ma~ed
""'~"=~"";""''''''''''''~''-='
DeJet.d: received
: DeIlacII l~. 'I..-iting_
,
...----
; Deteted:
'~~:.~:12~_
o
Reiection Of Bids And Neootiation:
1. The Board of County Commissioners shall have the authority to reject any and all bids.
2. If the lowest, qualified responsive bid exceeds the budgeted amount and if the purchase Is
not funded in whole or in part with interagency grant dollars, the Purchasing Director may
negotiate changes with the apparent lowest qualified and responsive bidder that will bring
prices into budgeted limits subject to the flnal approval and acceptance of the Board. If the
budgeted amount indudes grant funds. the Purchasing Director shall be authorized to
conduct such negotiations provided said actions are not prohibited by law or the grant
conditions,
Agenda Item No.1 OW
November 27, 2007
DeJetedJ!:ll"~.rsfOfRl'9-l')i'.}n
7/2C/(f7~
.3 If no bid is received, the Board of County Commissioners may authorize the Purchasing
Director to purChase by negotiation under conditions most favorable to the publiC interest
and when said purchase wilt result in the lowest ultimate cost of the commodities or services
obtained.
o."tMI:
Page Break,-
E. Waiver Of Irreoulerities: The Board of County Commissioners shall have the authority to waive
any and alt irregularities in any and all formal bids.
F. Award Of Bid Contract; The Chairman, when authorized by majority vote of the Board or as
otherwise provided for in this polley, shall execute tonnal contracts having a binding effect upon
the County. Formal, bilateral contracts shall not be required where a purchase order is sufficient.
A formal contract shall be awarded by the Board of County Commissioners to the lowest
qualified and responsive bidder. In addition to Ihe price shall be considered the following;
1. The ability, capacity and skill of the bidder to perform the contract.
2. The ability of the bidder to perform the contract within the time required or the least Ume, if
appropriate, without delay or interference,
3. The experience and effldency of the bidder.
4. The quality snd performance of previous contracts awarded to the bidder.
5. The previous and existing compliance by lhe bidder with laws and ordinances retating to the
contract.
6. The Quality, availability and adaptability of the commodities or contractual services to the
particular use required.
7. The ability of the bidder to provide future maintenance and service (where applicable),
All recommendations for award for bid contract will be reviewed and approved by the Purchasing
Oirector prior to presentation to the Board of County Commissioners,
Bidders competing for a prospective bid award (and their agents/representatiYes) will not be
permitted to publicly or privately address the Board regarding a prospective purchase prior to the
lime of award unless requested to do so by the Purchasing Director or by a majority vote of the
Boar<!.
VII. PROCUREMENT OF PROFESSIONAL SERVICES
A. Because differences in price may only be a minor concem compared to qualitative
considerations, professional services may be exempted by the Purchasing Director from the
competitive bidding proce8S. Instead, professional services will be typically acquired Ihrough one
of the following methods;
1. Competitive Selection and Negotiation.
2. Competitive Proposals (pursuant to Section VIII).
B. A professional service shall be defined as assistance obtained in support of County operations
from an independent contractor In one or more of the following professional fields;
,
I,
1. Appraisal Services ~ reIIl and paBOn.' property appraisers.
Agenda Item No. 10W
N~IDP'er27, 2007
~~rg:bf!jllioll
2. Architecture. professional engineering, landscape architecture, or registered land surveying
.ervice. (0. per SectIon 287.055, F.S.).
3. Audit and Accounting Services - auditors and accountants (excepting the seM!ctIon of the
annU81 auditor which shall be conducted 86 per Section 11,45. F.S.).
4. Consultants - planning, management. technological or so/entfftc advisors.
5. Financial Services - bond counsel, rating and underwriting, financial advisor. and investment
services.
6. Logal Servicaa - attomeya and legal profos.lonal8.
7. Medical Services ~ medicine, psychiatry, dental. hospital, and other health professionals.
C. Requests exclustvely for servlces defined under VltB.2 will be procured In a manner consistent
with Sectton 287.055, F.S.. known 88 '"The Consuttant's CompettUve Negotiation Act" as
required by said statute. Projects may include. but are not strictly limited to one or more of the
following:
1. Fixed 3Slianment contractA: A grouping of minor professional service (including
construction Inapection s8rvi0e6) assignments.
2. Fixed term contract8: Countywide agreements for various and miscellaneous minor
professionel services (Including construction Inspection servlon) on an a8 needed basis.
3. General Professional Servic&A: Includes IdminJstratlon, support and management of
engineering. architectural, surveying and planning actlvltle..
The Dtrector shall be authorized to approve aU work orders where the maximum Initial dottar
amount does not exceed two hundred thousand dollars ($200,000) and where the maximum
initial contract amount don not exceed seven hundred fifty thousand dollars ($750.000). Any
wen. order and/or contract that exceeds that amount subsequent 10 award and prior to
completion of ttle worX shall be subject to the provisions of SectIOn XIV.C of this resolution.
Prqecls shall not be sutJ..dlvided to Circumvent the doller thresholds estabUshed herein.
All fixed term agreements issued under this section shall be eligible for extension or renewal in
accordance with the provisions of SectIon. XIV.D and E respectively.
D. For all servlce procurements In excess of the formal competitive threshold under the
Competitive Selection and Negotiation method, authority to announce and distribute Requests
for Proposals or Letters of Interest and Qualifications and to appotnt and empower a
selection committee shall be pursuant to Section VIlLB hereof.
E. Final selectton of the professional service provider (award of contract) shall be made by the
Board of COunty Commillloners.
F. PUrd18S8S for all professional services estimated to be equal to or lese than the formal
competitive threshold may be approved by the Purchasing Director, as permitted by law.
G. Requests for outside legaJ servlcee will be referred to the County Manager and the COunty
Attorney for review and comment as to whether said seMces are necessary and/or appropriate.
Requests for outside legal services may be exempted from format competition by the Board of
County Commissioners at the request of the COunty Manager or County Attorney.
H. The acquisition of services from experta or consultants for purposes of preparing for or
defending against Imminent or pending litigation or administrative proceedings shall be exempt
from aU competitIve requirements of this policy. Any such aCQuisitions that do not exceed
$50,000 may be approved by the County Attorney and the Purchasing Department, but wlll be
reported at a regular meeting of the Board for ratiftcation.
VIII COMPETiTIVE PROPOSALS
"
I.
A.
The Competitive Proposals proce&8 Is a method of contract s8leCUon thet may be utiliZed by the
PurchasJng Director under circumstances where one or more of the following conditions exist:
1. Where qualibltlve consideratlons are of equal or greater concern than pricing
considerations.
2. Where the conditions of the purchase do not lend themselves to the formal sealed bid
proceS!l or the award of a firm, fixed fee contraGt.
3. Where the County is incapabte of specifically defining the scope of work for which the
commodity(s) Of service(s) is required and \lVhere the qualified offer Is asked to propose a
commodlty(s) Dr oervloe(o) to meet II1e need. of II1e Coonty.
4. Where the County desires to enter Into 8 single contract for the design and construction of a
public construction project(s).
B. For purchases in excess of the fomlal competitive lhf'8Shold and where appropriate or required
by law, the competitive proposals prooeH will be utilized. The process will be conducted in a
manner sim~ar to the sealed bid process 8S set forth under Section VI except where otherwise
staled In this section. The competitive proposals process shall proceed 88 follows:
1, A Request for Proposals (RFP) will be prepared and disbibuted in a manner consistent with
the definition of said term found in section 2 of CoDler County OrdInance No, 81.25. Notice
of saki request(s) shall be publicly posted manuallv Of ~.9p!.callv by the Purchasing
Department at least 21 calendar days preceding the last day established for the receipt of
proposals.
2. Each Request for Proposala shall identify the appropriate evaluetton procedures and aiteria
to be applied to the selection of the best proposal among the respondents. Each RFP
pertaining to the award of a designlbul1d contract(a) shall be subject to the requirements of
Section 287.055 F.S.
3. Prior to the announcement and distribution 01 the RFP, 8 selection committee shall be
appointed by the County Manager to eY8lulte the propoa:ats received. For all purchases
made under lhe Competitive Proposals melhod. the County Manager may empower the
selection committee to designate and rank the proposals prior to the commencement of
negOtiations and to negotiate. tentative agreement, subfecl: to award by the Board.
4. Proposals may be solicited and/or received in one or more steps ~f1!.lallv or electronicallv
as permitted by law and deemed appropriate by the Purchasing Director. Unl"S otherwise
prohibited by law. the Purchasing Director shall have the discretion to solicit aod conduct
sImultaneous or concurrent negotlations with one or more firms.
c. For purchases in excess of the formal competitive threshold, final selection of the awardee will
be made by the Board of County Commissioners.
o Purchases less than or equal to the formal competitive threshold may be authorized by the
Purchasing Director, as permitted by law and shall not require formal solidtation or
announcement unless deemed necessary by the Purchasing Director.
IX. PROCUREMENT OF DESIGNIBUILO CONTRACTS
A. Procurements for the deeiQJ:1 and construction of public construction project& may be obtained
through a single contract with I firm aelecteclln a manner permItted under Section 287.055, F .5.
and the procedures set forth in this section.
B. Upon completion of the Design Criteria Package, procurements of Design/Build services shall
be processed in a manner consistent wittI Section VIII hereof entitled .Competltive Proposals".
C. Administrative procedures shall be establtshed by the County Manager or his designee for
utitlzaUon of the design criteria professional concerning the evaluation of the proposals
submitted by the deslgnlbulld firms. the supervision or the approval by the County of the work
drawings of the project and evaluatIon of the project construction with the deSign criteria
package.
,
Agenda Item No. 10W
Novernbel'27, 2007. .
, ~'jIf..r,w,.'1~bf23^""
The Board of County Commissioners may declare a public emergency, where appropriate and
authorize the using agency to negotiate an agreement for Board apprO\lal with the best qualified
design-build firm available at that time.
X, Smalt and OisadvanlllCJ9d Mfnorltv and Women Bulinesa EnterDrlses
D.
A. PoIIcv Statement; Collier County stands (X)fTlmftled to providing equal opportunities to small
businesses Bnd disadvantaged business enterprises (DBE), minority business enterprises
(MBEs) and women enterprises (WeEs) as well 81 to aU vendors, consultants, contractors and
subcontractors w~o seek to do business with the County.
Pursuant to this policy, Collier County will require its vendors. consultants. contractors and
subcontractors to provide qualified small busfn9s&e8 and DBE's with an equal opportunity to
participate in the formal competlllve processes for the procurement of commodities and services
by tne County.
The Policy is not intended to require or to allow partiality toward or discrimination against any
small bUliness or DBE. MBE, WSE, or any olher vendor, consultant. contractor or subcontractor
on the basis of gender, race or naUanal origin, or other such factorw, but rather to help ensure
that small businesses and OSEe, MBEa, WSEs, and all qualffled vendors, consultants,
contractors and subf;:ontradors have Bin equal opportunity to participate In the County's formal
competitive processes. Nothing In this Policy shafl be constnJed to provide for or require any
preference or set-aside based on gender, race, national orlgfn or any other such factor.
B. Definitions: For purposes of this policy, the term "small business. shsll have the same definition
as set forth under BectIon 288.703. (1), F.S.
The term .DBE" shall include any "smaU business" 81 defined pursuant to Section 288.703(1)
that is It least 51 percenl owned or c:ontroUed by 8 peraon or persons defined as "socially and
economically disadvantaged" Individuals purtuanl to section 14~18.602(18), F .A.C.
Reference to these deflnlUons, however, ShaD In no way be construed to provide that the County
has adopted or Is subject to the provisions of the Statute or Code referenced herein.
C. lmolernenUna Measures; In an effort to implement this poHcy, the County may undertake the
following measures:
1. Designate t~e PurChaaing Director to administer this potiey.
2. Utilize outreach programs to identify, register and educate aman buainesses and DBEs,
MBEs and WBEs to partldpate in the procurement/contract procelS including. but not
limited to;
a. Attending trade fairs wnich Include representatives from theM enterprises.
b. _ding meeting. and social ovan18 whorefn tha.. ante<prioe..
c. Utilizing publications aimed at reaelllng tho.. antarpri_.
d, UUlizing directories and other reference sources that list these enterprises.
e. Publk:iZing thie Policy to encourage these enterprises to participate In the County's
procurement process.
f. Other actions designed to identify these enterprises who seek to prOvide commodities
and services to the County.
3. Malntalf1 a list of these enterprIses.
4. Disseminate information regarding competitive opportunities with the County in order 10
allow qualified small businesses and DBE,. MBE, and WBEs to partldpate In the County's
procurement process.
.
Agenda Item No.1 OW
NovAler 97 9~7-
: DtRJ tr.J'~'fr. HH,n
. "32-,_~_-'-'-O.._"
I.
C~nformttv with AooUcable Law: The provisions of this section shall be construed In conformity
WIth applleable state and federal law. To the extent that slate law conflids with federal law
federsllaw shall supersede such state law. .
XI. PAYMENT OF INVOICES
D.
A. It is the intent of the Board of County Commissioners that all agencies under its purview be in
compliance with Section 218.70 F.S., otherwise known ae the "Florida Prompt Payment Act",
Pursuant to this, the requirements of this section shall apply to the following transactions:
1. The purchase of commodIties and services:
2. The purchase or lease of personal property:
3. The lease of real property.
B
The PurcMslf',y Director sha!lni!Y.:~L!!J.Uill!19(ity to establish and 7laint8i.!) a llrocedure thar"
ia.y.ttlQI\zes /T1lr19LQavment valjances ootween fhe:JlVrchase Q!QrU0.!t..!D:t.9Ice where warrantet;l
The authoriJv to Oilv such vAtian{'.es :)haU nol e'Sceed 5"10 (Jf the DurChdse order iM"ount 0,.$ 500.
whichever is les!?c
C Additlonallv the P.MLChOsinQ Oir~ctor sllall be oermltted 1.0 s.!ltaolish a0Jt!!:ljiinL~!!1..~..J~f9~::sdur~
that authonzes the Davment of fr~rt ana dalive", charces that are not soecificallv identlfied.on
the ourchase order
...Q It~~11 be the ,respQnsi!;)iIIly"of. theC~lhr_~_i!l~"1 fl1@asIJ1(i ['rectO!" .fiRaAQ8 Qi'Wmor, in
consultation with the E~nI!L<;t',*"\J_..iR' ~ al'!d~ u_slngage~,_ tQ ~tabl~t't, 9~~ut!
and administer procedures for the timely payment of all transactlons as deflned under XI.A
hereof. Such procedures shalllndude, but not be limited to the followtng:
1. Formally defining the County's requirements for the content and submission of a proper
invotce, codifying the County's payment requirements and 10nnan)' notifying each vendor of
their availability.
2. Steps required for the receipt of all invoices and the prompt return of Improper invoices.
3. Steps required for the resolution of paymel'll disputes bet'oNeen the County and a vendor.
~,~ p~~~,..tl1e,f:It:l8.~ Pl~ _a~~ ~h,~p-urc!:t~IJn.Q..plre!=tlJ(, ~I.ISllb.Il1~,~j9i!1~ ~~, tp
the Board listing the number and total doflar amount of krt.erest penalty paJ'Tlents made during '.
the preceding fiscal year.
XII PAYMENT OF DUES FOR MEMBERSHIP IN PROFESSIONAL ORGANIZATIONS
.Ii
County funds may be used 10 pay for dues for membership in 8 professional or other organization
provided that such expenditure meets the fol6owing criteria:
1. Such membership Is deemed necessary to meet duUes and responsibilities required by Federal.
State or local mandate or to facilitate proper professional development.
2. The organizaUan of membership is of a non~proflt nalure.
3. Sutndent funds are available within the proper appropriation unit/summary code.
XIII. STANDARDIZATION. COOPERATIVE PURCHASING AND GOVERNMENTAL CONTRACTS
A.. Where standardization is determined to be deslrabte by the Director, the purchase of
commodities may be made by negotiation with the approval of the Board of County
CommIssioners If more than the competitive bid limit or by the County Purchasing/General
Services Drrector jf les8 than or equal to the competitive bid or negotiation threshold.
B. The Director shall have the authorrty to approve purchases under State of Florida and Federal
OSA cooperative contracts. The Director shall also be authorized to join with other units of
government in cooperative purchasing ventures prlor or subSeQuent to award when In the best
9
Agenda Item NO.1 OW
N~er27, 2007
~!iittorrbf21sion
o.Mted: ...,.."....f>age Blt!M...
'~:II'\di!nt:Left:O",
tfitnglng: 0.88-, Tabs: OS.len. +
Natat 0,8)"
oea.t.d: B
_'SIr_""-9h
, FormMilN: Strikethrough
,!~~~_Strlkettlrough
-
j ......,: C
interests of the County. If funds have already been budgeted, no further Board action will be
required. In authorizing all 8uch purchases under pre..exi'lting agreements. the Director shall
have determined that the term and conditions of lhe purchase are competitive in the market and
favol'llble to the County,
XIV. CONTRACT ADMINISTRATION
A. Contract Document: Every procurement of contractual services or commodities shall be
evidenced by a written document containing all provtsloo8 and conditJons of the procurement.
Said document shall Include. but not be limited 10:
1. A listing of the scope of services to be performed or commodities to be purchased,
2. A provision 8pecifying the criteria and the final date by which such criteria must be met for
completion of the contract.
3, A provision specifying Ihe terms of cancellation by the County and where applicable. a
provision specifying the terms of renewal.
4. Where appticable, a provision establishing the appropriate types and levels of Insurance to
be carried by the vendor. Said provision shall be employed in a manner consistent with
minimum insurance stendards approved by the Board of County Commissioners.
5. Where appUcable, pursuant to $ectk)n 287.133 F.S., a prOVIsion requiring the
conti'ectorlvendor to Intonn the COunty if heJshe has been convicted of 8 public entity crime
subsequent to July 1. 1969.
A purchase order that embodIes these provisionl shall be sufficient documentation of the
procurement. The Purchasing Director shall hive the discretion to determine the circumstances
under which a purchase order (and aU documents Inclucled by reference) shall serve as the
contract document.
B. Contract Manaaer: Eve~p,n:x:u!~e.n~_ 9t ~~~II~_ i'!dmlnlst~9Y !t1,e_l.!s!ng agi!!ncy_
(requestino department).
C. Contrad Chanoes: Notices 1s8ued under a purchase or contract may be authoriZed and
exetutecl by the PurchaslnglGeneral Services Director, excepting MOUces that terminate a
Board.approved purchase or contrad in its entirety. Modifications to a Board approved purchase
or contract. including but not limited to change orders, supplemental agreements. amendments
and changes by letter may be authorized and executed by the Purchasing/General Services
Director provided that the chenge (or the sum of the changes) amounts to not more than the
greater of (I) 10 percent of the current Board approved amount, or (il) 510,000.
The proviso at the end of the previous paragraph shall not be applicabfe to teon contracts or
blanket purchase orders where the County ~re' to procure commodities and/or services on
an a. needed basis without having to obligate jtsetf to a total contract. amount. Rather, such
purchases shall be baled on tlxed unit prices or other predetermined pricing methods and shall
be limited in quantity by the amount of funds appropriated in lhe buclget of the using agency(ies).
Such purchases shall be subject to all other provisions of this poljcy.
Notices that terminate an entire purchase or contract that wn Board approved, and contract
modifications that increase the total contract amount beyond the limits set forth above as
appllca~, shall require the approval of the Bosrd of County Commissioners or as otherwise
provided for In this polley. The Boord shan have broad autholily, within thallmits of the law. tD
evaluate and approve any recommended contract modl1lcalion without requlrtng further
competition, All deductive chances oertainino to the use of direct material ourchases incl\.!91llil
those that reduce the contract amount bv more than ten cereent belO'N 1M current Board
aooroved contrac.t amount shall be r&oortBCIto the Board monthl" 3S Dart of the monthly contract
chances reoort and shall not reauire olior Board 800ro"al
D. Contract Extension: Extension(s) of a Board~approved contract for commodities or servtces may
be requested by the contract. manager to the Purchasing/General Services DIrector in writing for
a period not to exceed six (6) months (cumulatlvety) and shall be subject to the same terms and
conditions set forth in the Initial contract. The Purchasing/General Services Director shall have
the authority to authorize and execute all such extensions. Any eXI8nslon(8) that exceed six
10
Agenda Item No. 10W
N~!ler.2i', 2007 m
,7;'~~~'3'6f~"'Dn
-
months (cumulatively) shal be approved by the Board of County Commlnjoners. Extensions of
contracts that do not (Inclusive of the extension) exceed the fonnal competitive threshokt may be
authorized and executed by the Purchasing/General Services Director lNithout Board action.
E. Contract Renewal: The Purchaslng/Genend Services Director shall have the authority to
authorize and execute renewals of contracts for commodities and/or services subject to the
following conditions:
1. That the Contractor has performed In a satisfactory manner and that the Director has
received a request to renew from the Contract Manager verifying the Contractor's
satisfactory performance.
2. lhat the agreement is renewed subject to the terms and conditions set forth in the trUtlal
contract. Costs and terms of any contemplated renewals are included In the Invitation to bid
or request for proposals.
3. That the renewal is done on an annual basis, commencing at the end of ~ inUial contract
period. Any such contracts shall not be renewed for more than 3 years unless competitively
procured.
Proposed renewals that. fail to meet one or more of the conditions set forth herein will reCjuire the
approval of the Board of County Commissioners.
F. Contract ADoroval: All fonnal, bilateral contracts for commodities and services In excess of the
format. competitive threshold shaY be authorized by the Board of County Commissioners. Such
agreements for purchases leas than or equal to the fonnal, competitive threshold may be
authorized and executed by the Purchasing Director, subject to the review and approvel for legal
sufficiency by tho OfIIco of tho County A1tomoy.
G, Work Orders (Not Under CCNA): The Purc:haslngfGeneral Services Director may authorize and
execute any work order If the wortc. order is equal to or below such Board approval parameters
for work orders aa are set forth in either the Board approved term contract: for services under
which the work order is generated, the soIlcltation document (8) that resuUed in the contract or
the Executive Summary that pertains to the contract.
Modifications to a wof1( order may be authorized and executed by the Purchasing/General
Services Director. providetf that the work order, as modlned. doe. not exceed $100.000 or if it
does, the change (or sum of the changes) does not exceed 10% of the current Board approved
amount.
The above provisIons of the section G shall not apply to wortl. orders, or modiflcations to 'NOrk
orders, govemed by Section VII,C above.
H. Consent to Auianments of Contract; For all contractl which exceed the formal compeliUve
threshold. the Board of Cou1ty Commlt.toners shall approve all aHignment8 of contracts
requested by the predecessor contlllctlng pert)'. For such requests for agreements below the
formal competltlw threshold, the PurchatlnglGeneral Services Director shan have the authority
to approve aaaignments on behatf of the agency.
I. Authorltv Limitation and Deleoatlon: Promulaation of Procedures:
The PurchaslnglGeneral Services Director may delegate to one or more other Board employees
any or all aspects of the authority vested in the Purchasing/General Services Director to
aulhortze and/or execule contracls or contract-related documents pursuant to SectIon VII.C
above and SectIons C through G of thl8 ArtIcle XIV or otherwise under law.
All authority to authorize and execute documents that is vested pursuant to this Articte XIV In the
Purchasing/General Servlces Director or any other person shan be subject to the limits of any
apptlcable federal. state or other law.
The Purchasing Department shall be responSible for establishing and maintaining administrative
procedures that set forth any delegations of 8",lhority made pursuant to the foregoing provisions
of this Section I, that set forth fannal processes for each of the Instruments referenced in this
Article XIV, and tt1at are In all respe<;ts subject 10 the provIsions of this Article XIV.
"
Agenda Item No. 10W
NQ,'lllIIli?ertr.;;2Q{l1b ~";"c,,--
. ~trit{Jet 14 O(~'3
Ddeted:
~iliJ!:.~r.~~,"~__
I.
These procedures shan al,o set forth generalized requirements for (i) such pre~execution
relJiews of documents by the Office of the County Attorney and (ii) pre-execution reviews of
documents by such other departments, if any. as the Purchasing/General Services Director
determines to be appropriate and advisable
J.
Pavrnents to Contractors. Vendors and Consultants...
Prior to the execution of a formal contract subject 10 this policy, the Purchasing Department shall
have !he dlscretlon to establish a formal payment schedule and payment term I within the
agreement. Such terms and conditions shall be consistent 'With the requirements of aU applicable
taws and the formal solicitation documents.
1:\ a(GQrd.ar(It..~.Hr"I".~<:1;yn.~_llI:,J,,1;)~~_~_.tbR.I:;:yr:;:!'~~Oj[~c;l.of sr-',~.'lL!'t!~!25.t! oroce'Jvf~l
~n rOOl,c;a \0 S'~z the arnmnl Clt (e!il;naofU~:!~!!!_~ 'iub6~uet11 ;;)~~J!:1_2~~'L::n~
t:s.~-1Q._:LCr":trMtV...hl't!JZ,,"',~";')l:';}..!:::lble'_ The Purchasing Director. or his designee, shall have
the discretion to establish, in wnbng, a Schedule(s) to ~'.,:lli!!!.JiI.r""9g3!1~ reduce the percentage
of cumulative retainage held throughout the course of Ihe projecl schedules,I'~:'c::r~,,;;;'i::!I_~!f~P
The discretion 0' lhe prOject manager 10 reduce the pef'cenlage of curnu/alive retainage shaH be
Subject 10 the following
1. That the term "cumulative retarnage" is deflned to mean "the dollar total of the funds
retained from atl payments issued under the contract divided by the gross dollar total 01 all
monthly pay requests (or the total of all payment amounts deemed aHowal)je by the project
manager, whichever is less)".
2. That any decision to reduce retainage shall be formally communicated in 8 letter to the
Contractor's appropriate representatflJe and that the letter affirmatIvely states that the
Contractor has performed the contract work In a satisfactory manner.
3 That the cumulative retainage not be adjusted until at least 50% of the work has been
completed and payment has been issued.
4. That the Purchasing Director's letter expressly sets. forth the percentage of cumulative
retainage to be held for the remaining pay requests.
The Purchasing Director's designee shall also be granted the discretion to authorize the partial
release or payment of contract retainage to the contractor prior to flnaf completion of all project
work provided that
The contractor has performed in a satisfactory manner to date.
2 The total aggregate work under the agreement is at least 50% completed and accepted (Le.;
payments equaling at least 50% of the contract amounlless retainage have been i.&Ued)
.3 TRI "tilIAae. Ie be ...-IUDS" ic: ~U~WIIRt tQ &htfl.lll aR~ fiR.l PGmplsAclR Qf il8.tsifts~)..
::illlliliJAmIRI(I) Qf FRi"'te~.{tl} i9'RIift.~ iR the Igl'4lmIA'
lw,The retainage dolllill' .mount to be ~1e818d !sbatttd upon and consistent with the prevailing'"',
percentage of cumulative retalnage being held at the time that the retainage is released.
xv.
PERFORMANCE AND PAYMENT eoNDS
XVI.
A contractor or vendor shall provide a surety bond from a surety company to guarantee full and faithful
perfonTlance of a contract obligation and the payment of labor and material expended pun>uant to a
contract whenever, and In such amounts, as required by statute or otherwise as deemed necessary by
the Purchasing Director, An irrevocable letter of credit from a financial instttuUon operating within the
State of Florida (or other alternative forms of surety as permitted under Florida law) may be sufficient
in place of the performance bond if 90 provided for in the bid and contract documents. Alt such bonds
or letters of credit shall be approved as to 'orm by the County Attorney.
UNAUTHORIZED PURCHASES
No County officer or employee shall intentionally orderrOU'!,e! than b:>>.Fi~l& _Plolr_1iIJ:1a.889_~8r .Qurchasma
cards as oerrnltled uMer this oojjc~, the purchase 01 any commodities or services, or make any
contract within the purview of this policy other than through the Purchasing Director. Any purchase
p<<ief or contrapt made contrary to the provisions here,?f shall not nltconarilv be approved and th.e.
]2
Agenda Item NO.1 OW
Nnvea]ber27.2007
~:mQ/jH'f5f6m"""
Formatted: Font: Bold
IlorrrtatUd;Strlkethrough
I_~~tt.ct: ~~~ro<Jgh__ __,___J
Oeteted: 'I
Formaltted: lndent- left O,83~
: Formatted: eu-;;;:;na Numbering
'~:~l_~h
forrMthd: Str,~ethl'tllJQf1
, foI'rMthd: Sb't-.ettlrougl'l
, Ponnatted: Strikethrough
'" ~--,-~
l"Orrnilttedl Font Bold, FootCOlOl'
'"'"
I
County shan not be bound thereby. All purchaseI made within the provtsions of this Polley shaD be
made wtth il~IJ(~tlwt.rPflurchase~ ~nWm ~, whichever IS appropriate.
In the event thai a ourchase transaction, is found to be 10 violation Of this oohcv the PurChasiD.g
Director shall determine the facts oertatnrOQ to the transaction. in consultation 'MtI1 the aooroonate
~j!1~r.,,~ directClr-1hfL.Purdla$lll<l CNactor ~t'Jall ~!ermwit} ..vt<(>t~r It is rt'l tt,e bt'.Jit
llt!!:!.i.!:L12LJt:;~_C<Junt\' Ja.i!rOC8ed Wlft'< the aurehafi.tll and ~,B... ,Inrler_.~(,~n~ if _.2
de~@tiO(1 15"rr'\ade to, proceed ,'Mth !t1e-'Wr~,-,~.l!.",-uChJ!<msact!ons In $-xcess of ItleJ9E!:D2.1
:;QWoetlfive tt:l.~):lQJ.Q,.!QLQJb~!....!!J1miC<lbl(~ Board authorization t~..QLq1",leUQ!.1tL'!Lt!2i.LQqH,Wii'l?J1
~Ulre the aporoval of the Bodrd. All such transactlon~ 10 or less than lh~ formal \:;ornoaliJi.y.f
lL.e::<rHJid m~_~J~Pu,chasir.Q Director
A EXC8otions: This section shall not apply to the payment of premiums for insurance policies that
have been aCQuired through prior Board action. This section shall not apply to nor super,iede
ResoMlon Nos. 86~30. 86.209 and 87.16.
XVII. PROHIBITION AGAINST SUBDIVISION
No contract or purchase shall be subdivided to avoid the requirements of this Policy.
XVIII. PROTEST OF BID OR PROPOSAL AWARD
The purpose of this section is to accommodate legitimate protests concerning formal competItive
invitations and recommended contract awards above the competitive bid or propo&al thresholds prior
to award of contract by the Board of County Commissioners.
A. Ally actual or prospective btdder or respondent to an Invitation for Stds or a Request for
Proposals, who alleges to be aggrieved in connection with the solicitation or award of a contract
(hereafter referred to as ~the protesting party") may protest to the Purchasing Director, who shall
serve as the sole recipfent of any and all notices of Intent to protest and sR fonnel protesta.
B All formal protests wtlh respect to an InvJtabQn for Bkls or a Request for Propoaate shall be
submitled 10 the Purchasing Director In wntlOg not less Ihan four hours prior 10 the opening of
bids or the dOSing Ume for acceptance of ptOpO$81S. The Purch8sing Director, in co"aultabon
wtth the COI1traet manager (and other appropnale County staff), shall have the authority to
address all such protMts received under sublectiOn e and to determine 'Nhettler postponement
of !he btd opentng or proposel closing time Is appr'Qpriate. The Purchasi"Q Dlredor't decision
shan be considered final and conclusive unless the prote6ting party flies a subsequent formal
pratest of !he recommended contract award as described under this section
C. My actual or prospective bidder or respondent to an Invitation for bids or a Request for
Proposals who desires 10 formally protest 8 recommended contract award shallliubmit a notice
of intent to protest to the Purchasing Director within two (2) calendar days, excluding weekends
and County holidays. from the date of the initial posting of the recommended award.
D. All formal protests with respect to a recommended contract award shall be submitted in writing
to the Purchasing Director for II decision. Said protests shall be submitted wtthln five (15)
calendar daYl. excluding weekends and County hotldays. from the date that the notice of Intent
to protest Is received by the Purchasing Director.
The formal protest shall contain, but not be limited 10 the following information:
1. Name and addreea of County agency affected and the bid number and title.
2. The name and address of the protesting party.
3. A statement of disputed issues of material fact. If there ate no disputed material fad$, the
written letter must so indicate.
4. A concise statement of the ultimate facts alleged and of any relevant rules, regulations,
statutes. and constitutional prevlllon. entitling the protesting party to relief,
5. A demand for the relief to which the protestlng party deems himself entitled.
6. Such olher information as the protesting party deems to be malerlal to the issue
E. In the evenl of a timely protest of contract award consistent with the requirements of this section.
the Purchasing Director shall not proceed further with the award of the contract until all
appropriate administratfve remedies as delineated under this sectlon have been exhausted or
until the Board of County Commissioners makes a determination on the record that the award of
13
Agenda Item No. 10W
Nqvj3rn!>ef 27, 2001
~\I~"I!1br23'ion
''''''''--''-
! f'orm..~: Strikethrough
Fonutted: Stnktlthrol.l9h
:~:Strlket:hrough
'~l^~!~ro~h
a contract wIthout delay Is In the best Interests of the County. Neither the protesting party, their
agents or their representatives shall have any private contact or discussions wIth individual
County Commiuioners or any independent hearing officer (where applicable) regardIng the
protest prior to the protest being heard or reviewed by either of the aforementioned unless
requested to do so by the Purdlaslng Director
The Purchasing Director shall review the merits of each timely protest and In consultation with
the contract manager and other appropriate County staff, issue a decision staling the reasons
for the decision and the protesting party's rights of appeal under section XV!!!. Said cteclsion
shall be in writing and maned or otherwise furnished to the protesting party. The decision of the
Purchasing Director shall be final and conclusive unless the protesting party delivers a
subsequent written objection to the Purchasing Director within two (2) calendar days, excluding
weekends and COunty holidays from the date of receipt of the decision.
G. In the event of a subsequent objection pursuant to subsection F, the County Manager shall have
the discretion to appoint an independent hearing officer to review the fatt! relevant to the
protest. The appoInted officer wi" have a maximum of 50 days to schedule and conduct e
hearing into the matter and issue a tlnding of fact and a opinion in writing to the County
Manager fOf submission to the Board of County Commissioners, Prior to commencement of the
hearing, the protesting party shall be required to post a cash surety in an amount equallo one
(1) percent of the using agency's eslimate of the contract amount or one-thousand dollars
($1,000), whIchever is less. Should the Hearing Officer find in favor of the County, the protesting
party shall forfeit the surety as partial payment for undue delay. Otherwise, the surety will be
returned 10 the protesting party.
F.
H. In the event that the protest cannol be resc>>ved by mutual consent, the matter will be referred to
the Board of County Commissioners for final resotulion.
l. Failure to file a formal protest within the time and manner prescribed by SecUQn XVIII shall
constitute a waiver of the right to protest by MY protesting party as defined by subsection A of
this section.
XIX.
CONTRACT CU\IMS .
All actual or prospective claims arising agatnst the County from contractora, vendors or any other party
in direct privity with the County 10 provide commercial commodities or services .,shall tirst be direcUy
addressed by the parties' administrative representatives in a manner consistent with the agreement
bet'Neen the parties and 'n a(.'coLdanc~!.W""Jt.~U-;:QJ,JD.tv'$ Pr(Jc~r~D.QI'],LA.O,fJ1"Dl~1!,~!jY!;i,.l~.r.Qg>J1l!@'~
M_i!!.1..~g~
/tAl ;lei"" lWl:taiAiAg \9 ail 8BFAElRt6 iRGI' ~Ri GG1'1tfVllltrQ'p alF' i681 Il:!all 98 &WtlJBIilH9 aIt8mati'"
~ ~pFan~loIr.3' a&t (stiR wR"er CQWRV/ rIl"89twtien-#-.Q.1--.'J3Q.Gl-itll1:Jt:SMiD11r tRSl;-llRj
r91i9IoJtisFl(S) iRliI tR" thr:esl:lglGI 8.\e~11.~.~ tlllerelR,
For ~ ~-prospectlve or actual claims or disputes ar,~I.0gur1Cler any conl"ilct <:nlerf-:Q W,l,l "'.. !ne
County /let 8wDj.at I'! th. ,..J:tar~9ti'<Q c1ltpl.ltt ,....Juti8.A .pr~J' 1'rNtf!liteNRClIIUII=IINiJI,_ the Purchasing
Director shail have the discretion to arbitrate or medilte the claim or dispute or may appoint an
independent third party to do eo within the authorization threshold Iimit$ of this policy.
XX. EMERGENCY PURCHASES
A, Bv County Manaaer: In case of an emergency which requires Immediate purchase or
commodities or seMoes in excess of the format competitive threshokt, the County Manager
shaU be empowered to authorize the Director to secure by open market procedure as herein set
forth, any commodities or services. The County Manager shall have the authority to act In the
case of any emergency induding the issuance of emergency change ordersJsupplemental
agreements. Any emergency acUon shall be reported at the first available regular or special
meeting of the Board of County Commissioners. The County Manager shall further be
authorized to approve payment(s) to vendors at the time of or shortly after purChase should the
circumstances warrant
8. Bv Purchasina Director: In case of any emergency which requires immediate purchase of
commodities or services equal 10 or less than the formai competitive threshold, the Purchasing
Director shall be empowered to secure such services and commodities by open market
procedure as herein set forth, Such action shall be reported immediately to the County Manager
when appropriate
14
Agenda Item No. 10W
N.er ~ .,~~.
, f'. sion
''''' 8!!l'" 'to ~
Deillted:.. .........Page Bteilk...
< PormIItted: Foot: EkNd
Deteted:
Deleted:
forlrNllt..t: Stnketi'll'Ol.qn
, Formatted..:, Strikethrough
-._~rm~,:.,~~~Y'rotJQh
-----,
_n)
I,
ThiS section in no way constrains the provisions of Collier County Ordinance No. 84.37,
XXI. INSPECTION AND TESTING
The Director shall inspect. or supervise the inspection ot, or cause 10 be inspected, all deliveries of
supplies or services to determine thelf conformance with the specifications set torth in an order or
contract.
A. 1"508<.;'10" bv Usinc Aaencv: The Director shall have the authority 10 authorize using agencies
having the s!.aft and facmUes for adequate inspection to inspect all deliveries made to suCh using
agencies under rules and regulations which Ihe Director shall prescribe
B. ~: The Director shall have the authority to require chemical and physical tests of samples
submitted with bids and samples of detiveries which are necessary to determine their quality and
conformance with specifications. In the performance of such tests, the Director shall have the
authority to make use of laboratory facilities of any agency of the County or of any outside
laboratory.
XXII. SURPLUS SUPPLIES AND TANGIBLE PERSONAL PROPERTY
All using agencies shall submit to the Director, at such times and in such form as shall be prescribed.
reports Showing stoch of all tangible personal property which are no longer used or which have
become obsolete, worn out or scrapped.
A. Transfer: The Director shall have the autholity to transfer surplus stock 10 other using agencies.
B. ~: The Director shall have authority 10 sell all supplies of a value less than the limits proscribed
under Chapter 274 F.S., which have become unsuitable for County use. sal.. under this section
shall be made to the highest responsible bid and in conformance with Section, 274, F .$.
The Director shilU be authorized to approve all sales where the net revenue to the County does not
exceed $50,000. AJI sales exceeding $50,000 in net revenue to the County will be appro.....ed by the
Board prior to completing the sale or conducting the sales e.....ent.
C Trade In: The Director shall be authorized to approve purchases that include the "trade in" of
existing items (including assets) pursuant to the purchase of new. replacement or upgraded
items/services.
D. Donation: Operating departments under the purview at the Board of County Commissioners shall
be authorized to accept items donated to the County. The receipt of allllems not considered to be
assets as defined under Florida law is to be documented by a letter from the operating department
director to the donating entity. Items considered to be assets are to be documented using the
appropriate forms and forwarded to the Fixed Assets Section of the Clerk of Courts Finance
Division. Documentation is to include, but not be limited to; the date the asset(s) was recei.....ed; the
estimated faN' market .....alue of the 8ISeI{S); a description of the a.sel('); a serial number If
applicable and the fund/cost cenler under which the 8S8et(S) will be assigned.
E Oisoosilion of Assets; The Director shall have Ihe authority to determine whether previously~
acquired items (including assets) that are no longer useful to the agency have commercial value
and if not, to dlspo$e of such items in an appropriate manner with or without offering !uCh items
for sale, (rade or donation to other enUties. The Fixed Assets Section of the Cieri<. of Courts'
Finance Division will submitted a quarterly report lhet Identifies any assets that are disposed of
under rhe provisions of this subsection.
XXIII. PURCHASINg CARD PROGRAM
The Director shall be responsible for the overall management and operation of the County's
purchasing card program. For the purpose of this policy, a purchasing card is a credit card officially
assigned to specific employees under the purview of the Board of County Commissioners' agency for
the purpose of transacting small and lor strategic purchases. The Director shall be authorized to assign
cards to employees for these purchases. The Director shatl ha.....e the authority to establish the
following dollar llmits for each assigned card:
1"
Agenda Item No. 10W
N~fiilml1. er fl.,;1fQOZ"O"
'''20Pa!!/8'1~ 0 2"
A. Sinale Transaction Limit: Not to exceed $1.000 per card urness otherwise authorized by the JjeaHl
~
B. Monthlv Soendlna Limit: Not to exceed $10.000 per eard unlets otherwise authorized by the
~~.
c. Strateaic Purchases: The Director may utilize (or delegate the authority to other Purchasing
Department staff to utilize) a P<Jrch...ing card to piece orders \hata.co.o \he limit. .at forth under \hI.
section in instances where one or more of the following is true:
1. Where the purchase is to address a valid public emergency; or
2. Where the County will eam revenue through card program rebates; or
3 Where a vendor is requiring the County to order by purchasing card.
[) Sales Tax COrr]PUi'HJ!;g. Pursuant to Sechon 212,OfH61. FS.. County Durchases transacted with'<
vendors Within the State of F~.m.e exemol from the stale sales and use tax. In such instances
It is the r.esoonsibilitv of the cardholder to oroviae the vendor Witt'! the .~rp..1l.dale tax eXCfTlotlon
,nformation when the card is Dresented to the vendor}n..lhe_event thai the c.ardh.Q.!fL~!J.!'fuse5 to
orant the lax sxemotion when the card iU~!;l,c.1. the cardholder is aufhori7f)d to allow tt1e iax
to be charaed to the card.
II is the oosihon of the Board that it is not cost effective or in the nublie interest to I'8QUlre a
9!rdholder to seek J-P'_!~.iLtm:...~'l,~when the total sale does not exceed $~QfLJ.n
Lh~venl~...tr~JQ,!5!L.'!~LltJj:;x~Q~O the carct!Lolder's deoartmenf director lor_their desianeej
is rasoonsjble to ensure the tax is returned to the Countv for the ourchase.
.E Rebates: All ourchasina caras rebates _will be creOited J!L1.be aeneral fund unleu....,gtherwise
specified by.the d irngJ9I,.
In all such insl8nC81. the Director shall ensure that the purct1ase has been approved subjec1 to aU
other provi$ions of this policy. All fixed assets purchased using a PUrchasing card sMII be properly
recorded and tracked through the Fixed Assets Section of the CIet1t of Courts Finance Oivtsion
The language of this section Is not Intended to supersede the provisions of Cofller County Resolution
200!l-4!lQ. _
XXIV.
SEVERABILITY
If any one or more of the provisions of this Policy should be he.Jd contrary to any provision of law or
contrary to expres.s law, though not expressly prohibited, or against publiC policy, or shall for any
reason whatsoever be held invalid. then $uch provlsion(R) shall be null and void and shall be deemed
severable from the remaining provI$ions of this Pollcy and in no way shall affect the validity of aU other
provisions of this Polley
I.
X)N.
REPEAL PRIOR AND CONFLICTING
AU resolutions and policies or parts of resolutions and policies, in conflict herewith, be and the same
are hereby repeated.
EFFECTIVE DATE
An official copy of this Policy shall be filed in the office of the Clerk to the Board of County
Commissioners Immediately after enactment and this Policy shall take effect at that time.
X)NII. CONFLICT DF INTEREST
When procuring commodities: or services using County funds, each entity and employee under the
purview of the Board of County Commissioners shall oomply wtth aU appHcable state and federal laws
concemlng conflict of Interest. For state or federal Community Development Block Grant.funded
projects, entitles and employees shall comply with the requIrements of Part 85. Section 36(b){3) of the
HousIng and Urban Development Code.
XXVI.
XXVIII. DEBARMENT AND SUSPENSION
16
Agenda Item No, 10W
N~er 27.f;!QOh.;~n
71"Pi!l1Je'19 of 23
~..~:Sltlk8t1'lmvQh
,_.
~,_.,__._.,_..,+_.,.w+.,..+...
: ~;~~~~~~~^---;
Fonnetbld: Indent: left: 0",
Hangl.~,~,~,75"
i FornNltted: Numbered ... Level: 1 ...
! Numbering Style: A. B. C. + start
at: " .;. Alignment: Left... Aligned it:
OS ... Tab after' 0.75"... Indent at:
O.75~
Fom tt..d: Indent: left: 0", FII"SI
, Ilrl!;".~~~~b.!:.. O.75~~~~_,_..,__._ ...,~'
. FclnNttedl No underlll'll!
'~.t: U~;;i;;----~~'
~~.:.~~~~.
Deteted. . flaoI! 81'e$lk." -
-
"1
The Board shall grant authority to County staff to suspend and/or debar vendors, contractors,
consultants and other interested and affected persons from active partidpatlon In obtaining County
contracts. The pUrpo&e of any such action shaN be to protect the County's Interests and the Integrtty of
the COunty's contracting process. The suspensiOn and debarment processes shall be considered to
be separate from and In addition to the award evaluation and vendor performance evaluation
processes authorized elsewhere in this policy.
A. Definition of Terms: For the purposes of this section, the following terms have been defined as
follows:
AfflHate refers to associated business entities or individual. that control or coutd controllhe
contractor or are controlled by the contractor or could be controlled by the contractor.
2. Civil Judgment refers to a judgment or finding of a civil offense by any court of competent
jurisdiction.
3. Contrector means any individual or legal entity that:
a. Directly or Indirectty (e.g.: through an affiliate), submits offers for or is awarded, or
reasonably may be expected to submit offers for or be awarded, a COunty contract for
construction of for procurement of commodities and services, incruding professional
services; or
b, Conducts business. or reasonabty may be expected to condud business, with the
County 88 an agent, surety, representative or subcontractor of another contractor.
c. For the purpos.n of this section, the terms "vendor" and "consultant" shall have the
88me meaning as "contractor" and the term "sub consultant" shall have the same
meaning 8' the term "subcontractor'".
4. Conviction means a judgmenl Of conviction of a criminal offense, felony or misdemeanor, by
any court of competent jurisdiction, whether entered upon a verdict or a piea, and Includes a
conviction entered upon a pJee of no 10 contendere.
5. Debarment means action taken by the County to exclude a contractor from County
contracting and County-approved subcontracting for a reasonable, specified penod as
provided herein.
6. Preponderance of the EvkJenc8 means proof by information that, compared wtth thai
opposing it, leads to the conclusion that the fact at Issue is more probably tNB than not.
7. Subcontractor: Any indlviduat or legal entity thai offers or agrees to provide commodities or
services to fJ party deemed to be a contractor under this section.
8. Suspension refers to action taken by the Purct1asingtGeneral Services Director (hereinafter
referred to a. "th. pas OIreclor") to temporarily disqualify a contractor from County
contracting or County-approved subcontracting.
B. SusDel1sion; The Purchasing/General Servtces Director shall have the authority to suspend a
contractor, subcontractor or person from consideration for award of contracts If there appeers to
be a reasonable basis for debarment as set forth under Section XXXIX. If. suspension
precedes a debarment, the suspension peliod shall be considered in determining the debarment
period. The suspension periOd shall not exceed three months wlthout the approval of the
County Manager, A decision to suspend by the Purchasing/General servicN Director shall be
considered final and conduslve with no right of appeaL
C. D8barment:
t. Causes for Debarment The prospective causes for debarment Indude one or more of the
following:
a. Convfctlon for commission of a criminal offense as an incident to obtaining or attempting
to obtain a publIc or prlvale contract or subcontract, or in the perfofmance of such
contract Of subcontract.
17
Agenda Item NO.1 OW
N~per27,2007
~m~~rfbr2j'ion
j,
b. Conviction under state or federal law of embezzlement, theft, forgery, bribery,
falsifICation or destruction of records. receiving stolen property, or any other offense
indicallng a lack of business integrity or business honesty which currently, seriously and
directly affects responsibility as a contractor.
C. Convk:tion under state or federal antitrust laws arising out of the submission of bids,
proposals or other competitive offers.
d, Violation(s) of county contract(s) provisions, which is (are) deemed 10 be serious and to
warrant debarment. including the failure, without goOd cause, 10 perform in accordance
with the terms, conditions. specifications, scope, sChedule or any other provistons of the
contract(s).
e. Refusal to provide bonds. insurance or other required coverages and certifications
thereof within a reasonable time period.
Refusal to accept a purchase order, agreement or contract, or perform accordingly
provided such order was issued timely and in conformance with the sohcitation and offer
received
g. Presence of principals or corporate officers in the business of concem, who were
principals within another business at the time when the other business was suspended
or debarred within the last three years under the provisions of this section.
h. Violation of the ethical standards set forth under applicable state or county laws.
Debarment of the contractor by another pubiic agency.
j. Any other cause deemed to be so serious and compelling as to materially affect the
Quahficatlons or integrity of the contractor.
2. Debarment Procedure:
8 The county department rSQuesting the debarment action shall submit to the PGS
Director a written complaint setting forth the reason(s) for seeking debarment and shall
identify a recommended debarment periOd.
b. The PGS Director shall review the complaint, verity whether it is compliant with the
provision of this policy, direct any appropriate changes and forward the complaint to the
contractor,
c The contractor shall review the complaint and shall provide a written response (with
supporting documentation) to each allegation. The response shall be provided to the
PGS Director within 10 (ten) business days of receipt of theallegatJons submittat. In the
event that the contractor fails to respond to the complaint within the prescribed time
period. the complaint. as forwarded to the contractor. shalt become an effective
debam1ent decJsion without rurther appeal.
d, In the event that tI'te contractor files a timety and complete response to the complaint
and the debannent action Is based upon a convIction, judgment or other event(s) where
there is no Significant dispute over material facts, the PGS Director shall determine the
per10d of debarment on the basis of the undisputed material Information set forth or
referenced in tne complaint, the contractor's reply and the parameters set fortt! in this
section. In the event that the Contractor objects to the PGS Director's decision, the
Contractor shall have a maximum of three business days to file an appeal of the
debarment decision with the PGS Director. The appeal will be forwarded to and
considered by the County Manager (or his designee), >M"Io will review the debarment
record compiled tly the initiating department and the contractor Should the County
Manager overturn the PGS Director's decision; the County Manager shall formally cite
the reasons for doing so.
e. In the event thai the contractor files a timely and complete reply to the complaint and
where the facts are in dispute, the Purchasing Department will convene a debarment
committee (hereinafter referred to as ~Ihe committee") conSisting of at least three
individuals who will review the comptaint and the contractor's reply The County
IR
Agenda Item No. 10W
NilItiW/;ler :1.7.. .,;20Q, .i,,"
7/-20-;pag&-21 of 2"j
I.
M,,"_ or his designee _ fQrm~y appoint the commilloO. _ will gernooolly
consist of COUnty 8mpfoyees. non. of whom $hall be a member of the department
initiallng the complaint Allhe discretion of the County Manager, a member from private
IndUStry with a particular area of relth-ant expertise may be appointed to the committee,
provided U1at this member is not a direct or indirect competitor 01 the firm in question
The Office of the County Attorney shall appoint a representative 10 attend the heanng.
The repre&efltative shall nol be cootldered Ii VOting member of the commffl8e, but shall
be available to provide legal counsel to the comminee as necessary All members
appointed to s.erve on the debarment comm.ttee 'hall disclose. to the PGS Director, or
his designee. any actual or prospeCllve conflict's of interesl at the lime of appointment or
at the time in wniCt'l Ihe member become1/. aware of the actual or prospective conftict,
f. The PGS Director, or his designee. shall chair the committee and serve as the
Purchasing Department's representatIve to the committee. The Purchasing
representative shall preside over and faedltate the deliberations of the committee as a
non.votlng member and serve as the County's liaison to the Contractor In the
debarment process. All voting committee members are prohibited from having any
communication regarding the debarment Issue outside the committee deliberation, wfth
any of the parties involved In the specific debarment or their representatives until after
the committee decision has been issued or, in the event of an appeal of that decision by
the Contractor, until the conclU$ton of the appeal process. All committee deliberations
are subject to 5ectIon 286.011 F ,So
g. Where the material facta are in dispute, the committee shall evaluate the evidence.
judge the credibility of witnesses and bate its decision upon the preponderance of the
evtdence. Shoutd the contractor fail to appear at the debarment hearing, the contractOr
shall be presumed to be unqualified and or non-rapcnal\le and 'han be subject to
debarment. The cornmil1ee deciSion shat! be by , maJority \late of those 'oIOting
members in attendance. The commin.. shalf be the eoIe trier of fact. In the event that
the committee decides to impose debarment, the debarment decision will formally
include, but not be strictly limited to the following infonnatlon:
1) The spedflc reason. fQ( the debarment;
2) The scope of the debarment; and
3) The period of debarment. including the effective and expiration dates.
The committee.s decision shall be Issued In writing within 20 business days of the
conclusion of the hearing unles8 the committee extends this period for good cause.
h. The PGS Director shall forward the committee's deci8ion to the contractor and affiliates
in\lolved. Should the Contractor object to the commlttee's decision, the Contrador shall
na....e a maximum of three business days to fUe an appeal of the debarment decision
with the PGS Director. The appeel will be Iorwar<led 10 and considered by the County
Manager (or his designee), who will re....lew the debarment record compiled by the
initiating department, the contractor and the committee. Should the County Manager
o....erturn the committee's decision: the County Manager shall formally cite the reasons
for doing 80.
3. Debarment Per1od:
a. At its sole discretion. the committee shall determine the period of debarment. The
debarment period ShSU be commensurate wtth the severity of the cause{S) and in
no event shall be the debarment period exceed flve years without the approval of
the Board.
b. At 115 aole discretiOn, the committee (ha....lng the same or different comPOSition)
may reduce the debarment period upon il written requeel ITom the contractor to do
so. based on one or more of the following reasons:
1. Newly discovered material evidence;
2. A reversal of the con....iction. civil judgment or other action upon which the
debarment was based;
3, Bona fide change in ownership or management:
19
Agenda Item NO.1 OW
N~er 2.7..~7 ..
,. .c,.
,.;:, .Jllll~o 13"
4. Elimination of other causes fOf which the debarment was imposed; or
5 Other reasons that the committee might deem appropriate.
The contractor's reQuest shall be submitted to the PGS Director in writing and shall
be based on one or more or the aforementloned reasons.
c. The declsion of the committee regarding a reduction of the debarment period is
final and not subject to appeal.
4, The Effects of Debarment:
8 Debarred contractors sre 8xoudeO from recetvlng County contracts. Departments
shall nol SOltCi1 offers from, award contracts to, or consenl to subcontractors Wllh
debarred contractors, unless the County Manager or hIs designee determines that
emergency or smgle sourClJ; condllions exist and grants written approval 'or sucn
actions Debarred contractors are excluded hom conductlng busmees with the
County as agents. representatives, 8ubcOntradors or partners of other contractors
b. The Purchasing Department shall notify aU Board departments of the final
debarment decision and the effects of thet dEK:lston with regard to conducting
business with the debarred entity (ies) during the debarment period.
5, Continuation of Current Contracts:
a. Departments may not renew or otherwile extend the durehOn of current contracts
wan debarred contractors '" place at the time of the debarment unless the PGS
Director or rot designee deCer'mll"les tnat it i$ in the belt interests or the COunty 10
anow the contractor to continue or finish the WOt1c: within an addlUonal. hmited
peliOd of time.
b. Debarment shall constitute groundS for terminating an open agreement With a
contractor, However. the contract manager may permit completion of an open
conlracHs) provide<l that the debarred conlractor has performed in a satisfactory
manner to date under the open conlract($) unless otherwise directed by the PGS
Director
6. Restrictions on Subcontracting:
a. When a debarred contractor is proposed U II subcontractor for any subcontract
subJect to County approval. the department Ihatt not consent to lubeontracts WIth
.uch c:ontracI.... unIeu lhe County Man_ Of his designee de1etminea lhat
emervenq or Single source conditior'ls 8xle1. thue justifying such consent and
approves suCh decl1lon.
b. The eo..nty Shall not be responsible for any __ in contracl c:oots or Dlher
_n_ incurred by a contractor a. . result of rejection of PI'OIl<Jlled
subcontractors pursuant 10 subMCUon 6.8 provided that the subcontraetor was
debarred prtor to the submission of the appllcabte bid or proposal offer.
~ The Scope of Debarment' Debarment appliM to all officers, principals. djrectors,"
partners. qualrfief'S, divisions or otner organizatIOnal elements of the debarred
contractor, unless the debl!lm'lent decisIOn IS Ilmiled by its lerms to specific diviSions.
organizallonal elements or commodity/services The committee's declslon JnctudenJ any
eXisting affiliates of the contractor if they are SpeCltlcaUy named and are given wrttlen
noti<<J of the proposed debarment and an opportuntty to respond. Future atflliates of the
contractor are subject CO the pre-ellisllng tl!l:rm9 of the committee's dedsion
20
Agenda Item No. 10W
NMvaper :21"2007.,,,"
"'.(JiPafl'l23 of 23
fonn.tted: Indent: Left. 1~,
HanQlrlQ: 038"
~~:,~lIetsa~!!l!.mberir'(L..
De....: 10/02106
Aaenda item No" 16,L\ 1
- !\lovembe" 27. 2007
Page 1 of 5
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to have the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) prioritize the
watersheds for development of the Watershed Management Plans
OBJECTIVE: The County will develop Watershed Management Plans (WMP) by 2010
to protect Collier County water resources. To facilitate this process, the recommendation
is to have the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) prioritize the watersheds by 2008.
CONSIDERATION: The 2006 Evaluation and Appraisal Report of the Growth
Management Plan (GMP) amendments set the timeline and provided guidelines for
development of the WMPs. Due to the tight schedule set in the GMP, a prioritization of
watersheds is to be completed by January, 2008 and the WMPs are to be completed by
2010. The GMP states that the prioritization is to be based on where the development
growth potential is the greatest and will impact the greatest amount of wetlands and listed
species habitat. The schedule and priorities shall also be coordinated with the Federal
and State agency plans that address Total Maximum Daily Loads (TMDLs).
~.
The FDEP Total Maximum Daily Load TMDL watershed geography was the basis to
perform the geographic information system (GIS) analysis and to identify the boundaries
of the watersheds (Figure I). This version ofthe watersheds was selected because FDEP
is in the process of identifying "Impaired" waters. GIS analysis of growth potential,
wetland, listed species habitat, water quality impaim1ents, and restoration potential was
performed to tabulate data used to rank the watersheds. The results for eaeh parameter
were ranked and then an average ranking was determined (Table 1.).
Staff conducted 2 meetings on September 27, 2007 rmd November 6, 2007 to obtain
public input on developing the prioritized list. This information was then presented to the
Environmental Advisory Council (EAC) on November 7, 2007 (Tablel.). The EAC
recommended unanimously on the motion by Mr. Penniman "to recommend to the Board
of County Commissioners the thoughtful, constructive and timely analysis by the
Environmental Service's Department recommendation on prioritization of the Watersheds
of Collier County."
FISCAL IMPACT: This agenda item does not have an associated fiscal impact. The
total WMP Budget is $4,000,000 and includes the developmcnt of the WMPs and LlDAR
data acquisition. URS has been hired as a Project and Managemcnt Oversight firm for
further WMP development. The priorities identified in this BCC action will be uscd by
staff and URS in the development of the WMPs.
...-.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: Adoption of the watershed priorities fulfills
the requirement of Objective 2. ] of the GMP Conservation and Coastal Management
Element requiring that watersheds be prioritized by January, 2008.
.L\pen08 item l\jc:. ~t6!\'1
l\iJVe:T1De;' 27. 200""7
Page 2 of 5
LEGAL CONSIDERA nON: Conservation and Coastal Management Element
Objective 2.1 requires that "By January, 2008, the County shall complete the
prioritization and begin the process of preparing Watershed Management Plans, which
contain appropriate mechanisms to protect the County's estuarine and wetland systems."
This Objective further requires that "all Watershed Management Plans will be completed
by 2010," This Executive Summary is both consistent with and furthers this Objective,
and as such is legally sufficient for Board review and action.
RECOMMENDATION: That the BCC approve the watershed priorities identified in
Table 1 for the subsequent development of the WMPs.
Prepared by: Mac Hatcher, Senior Environmental Specialist
Page I of]
fVl',m:clli(;r1 Nc IGP
200
'j!jj
COLLIER COUNTV
BOARO OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Item Number:
Item Summary:
ReGln:rn(;n.j81Ion k ;'1-'<\'c me: BadlO 81 ::'UL'nlv ::'cmmls:;ion"T:; 't, ;C, r.r!(/n,.::0 iile
\',.'ater:;rl,lC:',!lI' Ut'v8icnme;"01 Ih,..''Natesr',cdt,ftar,C";J€illentPiani;
Meeting Date:
~ ,'= 7 12.'''
,I,j
)'repared By
Wdllarn [). Lorenc- )r..P,f.
t:rw,ronnmn!JiServlv,sf.)'r\1ClOr
[)at<:'
Commun,tv Uevelonrn~flt i>
Lflvlronmefltal"or,lco,'
E,flV;rQnmentaIServl{,es
t1IC/20(), ~41 :2' pr,~
Approved lIy
MMi()flC Slew~rt
t:Y~cutIV\) SecrUl<.try
Dill,'
Community Development S Community D<1velor>nwm 0.
E:nvlrontllent~1 Services
Environmental Serv'Ct'~ Admin
111~3i2007 11 :00 AM
Appruvctl By
JUdyPu;9
Clnnratwns AnJlye,t
lJate
Commun;tl' u"velopmenl & Commun,tv Development 8.
c.r,,,,ronmpntnISprVIt':<1'
cnv,mnmcnwIServ,c"SA.<lmm
1111312007 l1J~. AM
ApprOVl,d By
Corm:ouni\v{)evHoprnent&
uate
,I05"rl'f.. Scnmit!
€::"V'((1I1rnentai Services!\dmlnstr~tor
;;nmmun!IV Uevalppm<.>,.,t /;. :,omm'Il1l!',' [)[.'v",lop,r,,,,ni I:
S'lVlrCH"1H'nt,',,"""!C'J'
Snv'ml1ln"'llt~: o,,,rvKcsl,nlnn,
'13!2007 B:38 PIl
A[lpru\'ctl B)
;""",n,,,,"'"
Ap,,",'~ol"""; ,c,,,,,IVl;'
!)JU
"'" ,.,.n ~ I 'it: ,~, ,-...., C'
Inn'rnh,'.I(n' - ~~"nn""'<
, '1."1'~!) , ,
Allprovl'd By
f';',',-"I,,"':.,'O
"u(i<l'I ",,,,,bc.'
~') '" "
C,olmL'f\.'Wr\I"lP <, ()HIG"
:Jfw of !iJn""Q~m~n D. hu(](w:
1 , 11 4,'200" k: 44 I\~:'
Ap[lrCJved Hy
,,"C"'''!
c'DLI"\':.. M,,",,;!e:
CaK
ElGa ~<.I nf CouP! \
C'lim\vf,':anM'0' SOfll(;l
~ 1'15i20D7 ~j ;lEi Af/
Comm,,,si,,,,,,,.,,
;,\oends item !'\jo, 1 'S.l:, 1
, !''./o\'en:D8:- 2";:, 20Ci7
Page 4 of 5
Figure 1. WMP Watersheds
WMP Watersheds. FDEP Everglades West Coast Watersheds
I
~.~
.~
--,
h
".
I '
o BCr-'"
DCocMtcheeBeacr
CI(.DCOha"n"~(.o'"scr.w
DF"I<~UnIO"
DF"kaha1'M~
EJGOla~nGateNaPI.SBa'
DGUIT
Legend
FDEP Ewe Watef'$heds ~ Moret> Be",i1
DMatcOl5land
ON""lec
_N",,'e'.8ea't,
D()kaloa'or".~-sr,,~
DR"',""rv~'"
DSouth~jap"'SBe.ct'
DTenThOvsanal...nds
',J'
J
'1
,.
..r=r
/1
I I
\ I
Lee countp---)I
'1- .
",~
DE
'-----,
RB5B
175
,
J
,
,--'
(
I
>
W
<,
'1
m
N
'"
"'
~1v10nroe
I
o
[Ja!3 SOwlte Ei"SlnsfW.I~'sI1~d- FDEP
ueated8yGlS CQESIEnvronrrJo?nt,,'SelVlce'
G\GIS Tmp\'o'\Iil18rshedICC E'1I'0:: W1rsdF"m,d
G\GIS-TmrlVl\ll.'shed\CC-E\'\JC.~W1rsdFJlg
[Ja!a l1hf2007 .-
I
o
3
6
12 Miles
1
-<........-
1
Cullier County
A08noa Item !\io. 16j\1
~ November 17 2007
Page 5 of 5
Table 1. Recommended Watershed Priorities (Overall Rank) used for developing
Watershed Management Plans
WMP Watershed Prioritization Rankings
Growth Wetland Listed
County Potential NWI Species WQ Rest Avg Overall
WATERSHED Acres Acres Rank Rank Rank Rank Rank Rank Rank
Golden Gate Naples Bay 87,533 86.442 4 1 1 3 1 2.0 1
Rookery Bay 107,675 99,684 3 2 2 4 2 2.6 2
Cocohatchee Corkscrew 145.927 98,634 1 6 3 1 6 3.4 3
Okaloacochee.SR29 230.822 153.484 2 8 5 7 5 5.4 4
Faka Union 86,939 86,937 5 5 7 6 8 6.2 5
Fakahatchee 150,177 150,177 6 7 8 5 7 6.6 6
Marco Island 19.534 10.454 10 4 9 8 4 7.0 7
Naples 5,001 4,372 8 3 4 11 11 7.4 B
Ten Thousand Islands 134,278 91,651 9 9 10 10 9 9.4 9
Marco Beach 1,201 107 13 11 6 14 3 9.4 10
BCNP 705,549 513.717 11 13 15 2 10 10.2 11
Gulf 142,634 517 12 14 11 9 13 11.8 12
South Naples Beach 422 24 7 10 13 15 15 12.0 13
Cocohatchee Beach 1.462 23 14 15 12 13 12 13.2 14
Naples Beach 1.527 1 15 12 14 12 14 13.4 15
,~
-
Agenda Item l\jo. 16A2
t~ovember 27. 2007
Page 1 of 84
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to approve the Release and Satisfactions of Lien for payments
received for the following Code Enforcement actions
OBJECTIVE:
To approve execution and recording of the Release and Satisfactions of Lien,
acknowledging compliance and recovery of tines and fees related to prosecution of Code
Enforcement matters.
CONSIDERATIONS:
Reference Owner of Record Property Address Lien
Amount
612 Doak Avenue, Immokalee,
OSM 2006050277 Celeste Garcia Florida 34143 $143.68
6 I 2 Doak Avenue, lmmokalee,
OSM 2006050391 Celeste Garcia Florida 34143 $137.30
5329 Carlton Street, Naples, Florida
OSM 2006-060090 Robert Flick 34112 $2,124.64
5329 Carlton Street, Naples, Florida
OSM 2006-060099 Roben Flick 34112 $2,124.64
221641" SW, Naples, Florida 34116-
OSM 2006040126 Victor & Maria Hinojosa 6510 $1,206.88
221641" SW, Naples, Florida 34116-
OSM 2005081021 Victor & Maria Hiniosa 6510 $158.92
5353 Jennings St, Naples, Florida
OSM 2005031370 Jeanne Louizaire 34113 $5,407.29
5330 Broward St, Naples, Florida
OSM 2005080073 Alejandra Lynch 34113-7835 $243.78
4021 Coconut Cir. S, Naples, Florida
OSM 2005091124 Sheila Lewis 34104 $1,212.79
I 12 2nd St, Naples, Florida 34113-
OSM 2005091059 Elizabeth Lake 8534 $430.46
748 100" Ave. N, Naples, Florida
OSM 2005040781 Uma G. Kakarala 34108 $169.14
596 Hope Circle, Naples, Florida
OSM 2005110769 Monica & Annando Herrera 34142-4233 $220.21
183 Price Street, Naples, Florida
OSM 2005020681 Jesus & Michelle Herrera 34113 $138.04
305553" Street SW, Naples, Florida
OSM 2005030001 Saul and Elsa Garcia 34116-8017 $105.00
507 N. 11 Ie St, Immokalee, Florida
OSM 2006050077 Lara Guillermo & Juaua Cruz 34142-2909 $113.46
5306 Confederate Dr., Naples, Florida
OSM 2005120085 Vernon & Lucy Heiston 34113-8703 $175.83
802 Pine Sl. Exl., Naples, Florida
OSM 2005110533 Oralia Hinojosa 34142 $195,91
Rev 12/06
ite:-n hio, ! 6A2
!\Jovember 27.2007
Page 2 of 84
11238 Tamiami Trail E., Naples,
OSM 2005020167 Holistic Health Healing, Inc. Florida 34113 $177.34
2640 Poincianna Dr., Naples, Florida
OSM 2005080998 Keri Hunt 34105 $351.90
51014" St N.E., Naples, Florida
OSM 2005070109 PaulL. Justman 34120-9477 $200.84
5476 Martin St., Naples, Florida
OSM 2006020994 Virginia Garcia 34113 $157.14
1322 Orange St., Immokalee, Florida
OSM 2006020770 Manuela & Elias Herrera 34142 $130.12
5477 Martin St., Naples, Florida
OSM 2005070672 Emilio Guarrido 34113 $169.42
4532 Tamiami Trail E., Naples,
OSM 2005010942 Gulf Atlantic Association Florida 34112 $1,] 58.5 I
11500 6 L's Fann Rd., Naples, Florida
OSM 2005-050529 Gracelia Guzman 34114-7598 $21,990.60
1406 Orange St., Immokalee, Florida
OSM 2006020761 Trine Guajardo 34142 $122.62
5270 Georgia Ave., Naples. Florida
OSM 7005080392 Rosemonde Gennilus 34113 $5,000.00
906 lmmokalee Dr., lmmokalee,
OSM 2006050187 Victor Grimaldo & Leticia Esparza Florida 34142 $113.46
2991 Areca Avo., Naples, Florida
OSM 2005051131 CSE Properties, LLC 34112-5801 $287.97
1008 1.lampton Circle, Naples, Florida
OSM 7005120429 Stpetim Ramku 34 !O5 $178.80
712 Dade St., Immokalee, Florida
OSM 2006020925 Robeda McKinney, c/o Mike Pannel 34142 $180.79
5401 Mahogany Ridge Dr., Naples,
OSM 2005030468 Ted Luo Florida 341 19 $534.47
OSM 2005120102 Flavia Loredo 306 Porter St., Naples, Florida 34113 $181.54
OSM 2005120103 Flavio Loredo 306 Porter St., Naples, Florida 34113 $181.54
612 New Market Road West,
OSM 2006050400 Martin SOlO Lopez Immokalee, Florida 34142 $124.34
593 92"" A venue North, Naples,
OSM 2005120372 Henry E. Knaust, Tr. Florida 34 lO8 $156.44
5325 Carlton Street, Naples, Florida
OSM 2006070944 Robert Flick 341 J3 $377.01
1278 Highlands Drive, Naples,
OSM 2006020768 Robert Flick Florida 34103 $216.91
5325 Carlton Street, Apt. 0, Naples,
OSM 20050S(J056 Robert Flick Florida 34113 $200.00
I 1580 Riggs Road, Naples, Florida
OSM 2005070525 Ted Zhi Hui & Peng Sy Lou 341 ]4 $616.31
3129 Woodside Avenue, Naples,
OSM 2005051 108 Richard 1,. Licare Florida 341 12 $163.4 7
OSM 2005120637 5249 Alabama A venue, Naples,
Frank Aloia, Jr., Tr., Cinema Land Trust Florida 34113 $182.40
1509 Jimpson Lane, Naples, Florida
OSM 2005090013 Neim & Sebahat Malo 34105 $165.26
Rev 12/06
;S,qenaa item t\;::> .15/-\'2
i\Jovember 27 2007
Pap::; 3 of 84
--
5218 Warren Street, Naples, Florida
OSM 7006050900 Voltaire & Guerda Jean 34113 $135.43
5312 17" A venue SW, Naples,
OSM 2006020504 Kimberly B. Riggie Florida 34116 $350.66
536524" Avenue SW, Naples,
OSM 2006010465 Enrique J. Palacios & Alma Jimenez Florida 34116 $171.78
2275 J & C Boulevard, Naples,
OSM 2004090671 SH & MA. LLC Florida 34109 $269.87
3925 Thomasson Lane, Naples,
OSM 2006040726 Robert C. & Beatrice M. H uvaere Florida 34112 $168.29
214042"" Street SW, Naples, Florida
OSM 2003100457 Julia Gonzalez 34116 $195.00
899 San Marcos Boulevard, Naples,
OSM 2005060699 Robert R. Robinson Florida 34104 $162.85
OSM 2006020768 Robert A. Flick ] 278 Highlands Drive, Naples, FL $216.9]
OSM 2005120715 Timothy G. Flick 27l L 54'" St. SW, Naples, FL $521.27
OSM 2005080056 Robert A. Flick 5325 Carlton St. Apt. D, Naples, FL $200.00
OSM 2005090328 George Faccone Tr and Rita Faccone Tr 4007 Rose Ave, Apt # I, Naples, FL $366.32
OSM 2006030862 Marion Cook 320 Wells Street, Naples, FL $194.91
OSM CO-4229
a/k/a 2005-120473 Roanld Zbikowski 291 II ," Street SW, Naples, FL $12,500.00
OSM 2004120196 John and Michelle Hall 73129'" St. S.W., Naples, FL $138.22
OSM 2006-020919 Paul Zaino 3341 Corana Way. Naples, I'L $174.39
OSM 2006-040807 Paul Zaino 3341 Corana Way, Naples, FL $4,7 I 6.59
OSM 2006040685 Maria M. Alfaro 3444 Carson Lakes Circle, Naples, FL $135.60
Sang and Sounitta Bacam, Janet
OSM 20040203 78 Liemthong Et Al 1705 Benton Road, Naples, FL $3]4.04
OSM 2005050878 Eduardo and Luisa Pereiro 3216 Linwood Avenue, Naples, FL $163.47
A1katotal Limited Partnership, Thomas and
OSM 2006030402 Deborah Cook 450132'" Avenue S.W., Naples, FL $192.70
OSM 2005060699 Robert R. Robinson 899 San Marcos Blvd, Naples, FL $162.85
OSM 2006040] 96 Richard Jandro 19 W. Pelican Street, Naples, FL $220.60
OSM 2005-051077 Ralph and Maria Aguilera 10020 Bayshore Drive, Naples, FL $156.90
OSM 2005-070577 Ted Zhi Luo 11580 Riggs Road, Naples, FL $5,500.00
OSM 2005-070528 Ted Zhi Luo 11580 Riggs Road, Naples, FL $6.700.00
OSM 2004-110790 Ted Zhi Luo 11580 Riggs Road, Naples, FL $2.800.00
OSM 2005120434 EJ Properties, LLC 509 Doak A venue. Naples, FL $3.395.59
OSM 2006050778 Terry Brown 1410 Garthie Road, Naples, FL $124.34
OSM 2005020147 Fravelo, Inc. $94.92
OSM 2006-050089 Jaime Lopez 778 E1 Paso Trail, Naples. FL $500.00
Rev 12'06
Ma E:-m 0(') IL'3nl !,lc. .; 13,L,,~
i\JOVSITlner Ti, 2007
Paae .1 of 8L1
OSM 2006020553 Jean R. & Sidoine Laguene 3352 Poinsettia Ave, Naples, FL $58.69
OSM 2005090757 Fryer Chuck, Inc. and Jack Colbey 3091 Tamiami Trail East, Naples, FL $179.59
Somsanith Thanllnavong. and Tamchay
CEB 2001-0014 lnsixienf:,rmay Folio # 00482167804 N/A
Jaycees Foundation of Naples, Inc.(David 2424 and 2432 Davis Blvd., Naples,
CEB 2007-38 Moran (Reg. Agent)) FL $360.40
CEB 2004-044 Reynolds Cavins and Edie Hunter 819 Church Street, Copeland, FL $5,050.58
CEB 2003-038 A visai Gonzalez 5657 Jose Marti Drive, Naples, FL $947.00
TOTAL $95,161.93
FISCAL IMPACT:
Costs incuned by the County are costs of recording the Release and Satisfactions of Lien
estimated to be $10.00 per release, totaling $790,00, which is budgeted and available in
the cunent fiscal year Code Enforcement budget.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT:
This request will have no impact on the County's Growth Management Plan.
LEGAL CONSIDERATION:
This request has been reviewed ]()r legal sufficiency and has no outstanding legal
considerations.
RECOMMENDATION:
That the Board of County Commissioners approve the Release and Satisfactions of Lien.
PREPARED BY:
Bendisa Marku, Operations Coordinator, Code Enforcement
Rev 12/06
Page I or I
COLLIER COUNTY
80ARD Of UJUNTv COMhl!SSIONn~S
Item Number:
Item Summary:
';;<'1"
:'('.[ ,U\,:T,,"':S C".'.;e,\;,'.CI'
I'"
,Tnl,"
Meeting Date:
PrepllretJ By
H()nCllSJ ~':""'L;
:wc.atwf1'C C,oorum~t<"
["l1'"
,:("llnIL!r.:t'.. UCj"""[H'lC'mi'
(,em "nlor'."'II''''''
:;!/{Jr,'A;17"J(,Pji
!-:~'jlro"rnent<e "er')IC.,'
Approved 8}
('...., ,n;en'- ~:'l" ,~r
'~"""l'v( ;';cvn"r',
U:lh'
\v {j()\,F;Opn-l1 [i\,~ . "nl1rmm'\',.- ["''''f-.'lnnn",,,: i'.
E"VlrnnmcnWI ~erv,c,,'
Env;ro"mentJI S"fvif.f.,,--.,',aml"
11/812007 7;07 ~'R'
AII]lruwtJ n,
,IUo','hJl"
(JPUT,J\IOn', ArHI;'
[j,ttc-'
,;UrT1mun:ty ,wv"lOr"nB'1t L C,ommun,,:, U""c:opm,,'ll L
F-nvn'-"',nwnt'" ~>ar"""v
C.,.,,,,, jf'"ll>tll<<IS'.'""'U".'-'om;r
11Ig:;.>D07 '\(7pr,'
ApprUVl'(J U)
:'.omrnlJtVL-[J<;v"im:m;('
,I u '-.- r" ~ "".,, ,-r,:t
";TV""''''',I''11) ,,,'Jv"", !''-''n;''~'.' ':v
" ,,,,,,,,.."';1',' UP ,'Iup,,.,,n','
f''''::1:'C"",,~,rn;; ,~r'llv <
",,,,,'' U." "in",,"
'1::1"-"(;')
:.:IIVI
:;1'"
"'H"
Appru\'N! B)
"",""",,('1"
H""'..r "''-'10D'''''''.;
"'[1:',
Apl'ru\'l."d Il,
C:lIf'..:;;'
hiC'"
'l',:'"1!1'}'","'''.-,;,,
ITnt1 ,N.'" ~~ l'nl"'"
""'14f2i'" .~' M ['"
A[.provl'd R~
.-,,," 1:.;;J'n,'
"-'uu,"',
','-'U" ";:a ,~')' ,', ~):II'
''>f''I;;[' "r'.;;~r")(]""R'n! L 8m<('",,\
'1!lA:'Z'1f",jH!'W,
Approved By
,!~"''-'" \, 1I1l!'!<'i
'~GlJm rJ'M\J(l",
L~\'
i:,u~r,j" ::,UJ'''
(;UUlW Mal",!!,," Off"".
.." ")7 ~
':,-"nm",<;lDnu".
-
p,pen::::a Item No, "16/\2
!\lOvemD81-:n 2007
Page 6 of 84
'Ibis instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples. Florida 34112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated August 10, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on August 11,
2006, in O.R. Book 4087 at Page 2459 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Celeste Garcia, has been discharged in full:
Celeste Garcia
612 Doak Avenue (referenced incorrectly on lien as 608 Doak Ave)
Immokalee, Florida 34143
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
65074240006
$]43.68
OSM Case No. 2006050277
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Celeste
Garcia and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
I Ou'-', rJ~~
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
;i,~jenca item h!0 ,] 6,2,:':
!"~J\/<;=':Tib8'- 2' 2007
Page 7 of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiarni Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated August 10, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on August II,
2006, in O,R, Book 4087 at Page 2461 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Celeste Garcia, has been discharged in full:
Celeste Garcia
612 Doak Avenue (referenced incorrectly on lien as 608 Doak Ave)
Immokalee, Florida 34143
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
65074240006
$137.30
OSM Case No. 2006050391
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Celeste
Garcia and consents to this lien being discharged of record,
Dated this
day of
,2007,
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E, BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to fonn and
legal sufficiency:
~ ow\ ?~
Thomas t Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
J-;.,gencia liem r~~, .! I;)~,~
N::WernDS;- i.. i, 2007
Page S of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
.<\ssistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiwni Trail
Naples. Florida 34112
(239) 252.8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated May 18, 2007, a certified copy of which was recorded on June 5, 2007, in
O.R. Book 4238, Pages 3427-3429, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Robert Flick, has been discharged in full:
Robert Flick
5329 Carlton Street
Naples, Florida 341 12
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
62099040006
$2.124.64
OSM Case No. 2006-060090
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Robert
Flick. and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
.2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK. Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
ToWl PJ~
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
Jinpnda .,'[pm t\,;- -12 r ":)
'~' -: ~ 'I ~':: J ~!,--:=
i\bvernD8~ .:.::,. 20l'j f
Page 9 of 8.4
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples. Florida 34112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated May 18, 2007, a certified copy of which was recorded on June 5, 2007, in
O.R. Book 4238, Pages 3430-3432, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Robert Flick, has been discharged in full:
Robert Flick
5329 Carlton Street
Naples, Florida 34112
Folio No:
Cost:
Reference:
62099040006
$2,124.64
OSM Case No. 2006-060099
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Robert
Flick, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated. this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Tholt~alm~J~
Assistant County Attorney
,cern l'lC1I:)1.:<:::
:>}( \/9:1':b8; "'-', 2CJ;~-:~
~'ag9 1 C; oi b4
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Arrame)'
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
(239) 252-R400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated May 19,2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on June 5, 2006, in
O.R. Book 4049 at Page 1822 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against
the following described real property. and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Victor & Maria Hinojosa, has been discharged in full:
Victor & Maria Hinojosa
22]6 4]st SW
Naples. Florida 34] 16-65]0
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
3578]200000
$1.206.88
OSM Case No. 2006040]26
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Victor &
Maria Hinojosa. and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAlRMAN
,Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
IO~ Ql4~
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
Aaenda Item l'>Jo, 1 G/\2
~ I\Jovember 27 2007
Page 11 of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples. florida 34112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated December 3, 2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on December 8,
2005, in OK Book 3944 at Page 226 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Victor & Maria Hinojosa, has been discharged in
full:
Victor & Maria Hinojosa
2216 41st SW
Naples, Florida 34116-6510
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
35781200000
$158.92
OSM Case No. 2005081021
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Victor &
Maria Hinojosa, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWlGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
~~ QJ~
Tho as C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
'."rr, I.:e
, ~ 0 ~.
in.....,.::.
H;)I.'E'lliue: 2:. :::CC~~
;:::'aoe !::.: of 84
This instrument prepared by:
'll1omas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples. Florida 34112
(239) 252.8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated September 2, 2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on September
19,2005, in O.R. Book 3892, Pages 1723-1724, of the Public Records of Collier County,
Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real and personal
property located in Collier County, owned by Jeanne Lousizaire, has been discharged in
full:
Jeanne Louizaire
5353 Jennings St
Naples, Florida 341 13
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
62260600000
$5,407.29
OSM Case No. 2005031370
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Jeanne
Lousizaire, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
)O~ fU~.
Thdmas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
-7
iT8m I\;c. 'r 0.L\2
!\JCJvS:T1D8r 27, 20Ci7
Page 13 of 2,4
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated October 12, 2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on October 17,
2005, in O.R. Book 3912 at Page 3642 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier COWlty, owned by Alejandra Lynch, has been discharged in full:
Alejandra Lynch
5330 Broward St
Naples, Florida 341 13-7835
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
62260040000
$243.78
OSM Case No. 2005080073
Thc Wldersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by
Alejandra Lynch, and consents to this lien being discharged ofrecord.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Thom]t~G1Lw--
Assistant COWlty Attorney
;",9(:;ilJ ::sr : ::jr',.
HC,fenlDe: L 2i}:',-
Pags '1.:1 ~lf p,,j
This instrument prepared by'
Thoma,> C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples. Florida 34112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIENS
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated May 5, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on May II, 2006, in
O.R. Book 4035 at Page 441 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, and the
Order of the Special Master dated July 7, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on
July 21, 2006 in O.R. Book 4076 at Page 646 of the Public Records of Collier County,
Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real and personal
property located in Collier County, owned by Sheila Lewis, has been discharged in full:
Sheila Lcwis
4021 Coconut Cir. S.
Naples, Florida 34104
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
26682440004
$1.212.79
OSM Case No. 2005091124
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby rclease this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Sheila
Lewis, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
o~ rJUiv-
Thomb C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
p'c1enca llam Nc t),t.,2
. !\JovE:::T1ber 27 ::::OCI7
F'age 15 of 8L1
This instrument prepared by'
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated June 16,2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on June 27, 2006, in
O.R. Book 4061 at Page 3806 of the Public Records of Collier County. Florida, against
the following described real property. and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County. owned by Elizabeth Lake has been discharged in full:
Elizabeth Lake
112 2nd St
Naples, Florida 34113-8534
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
77210880001
$430.46
OSM Case No. 2005091059
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property. and all other real and personal property owned by
Elizabeth Lake, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK. Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
?~~~
Thoma C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
A;:sn:JL" i18m [\!C, i Gl\~
!\JD\";:lIiD9t 2~ 20Ci-;
~)a9s i 6 01 gL
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County' Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples. Florida 34112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated August 5, 2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on August 9, 2005,
in O.R. Book 3863 at Page 2930 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against
the following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Vma G. Kakarala, has been discharged in full:
Vma G. Kakarala
748 lOoth Ave. N.
Naples, Florida 34108
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
62780480001
$169.14
OSM Case No. 2005040781
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Vma G.
Kakarala, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
.2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
~llit~
--
I t? \'V\
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
A981108 itsm No. 16/\:::
;\jc)\r'3m08~ '27 :20C-"
Pag8 ~i 7 of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated May 5, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on May II, 2006, in
O.R. Book 4035 at Page 433 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against the
following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Monica & Armando Herrera, has been discharged in full:
Monica & Armando Herrera
596 Hope Circle
Naples, Florida 34142-4233
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
27192503304
$220.21
OSM Case No. 2005110769
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Monica
& Armando Herrera, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
day of
; 2007.
Dated this
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
TolV\ ?JLtv----
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
L<,oen:::iC1 iterr: hi:'" '16,L,_
hJC\V8n:~)e:- :::-;' 2Ci~j7
?a';1S 1 0; gi,
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated May 6, 2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on May 13, 2005, in
O.R. Book 3797 at Page 3861 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against
the following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Jesus & Michelle Herrera, has been discharged in full:
Jesus & Michelle Herrera
183 Price Street
Naples, Florida 34113
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
730240004
$138.04
OSM Case No. 2005020681
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Jesus &
Michelle Herrera, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Dcputy Clerk
Approved as to fonn and
legal sufficiency:
IO~ PJU}-
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
Aoenda ltem I\Jo, 16A2
, November 27, 2007
Page 19 of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated April 15, 2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on April 19, 2005, in
O.R, Book 3777 at Page 4045 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against
the following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Saul and Elsa Garcia, has been discharged in full:
Saul and Elsa Garcia
3055 53'd Street, SW
Naples, Florida 34116-8017
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
36434080000
$105.00
OSM Case No, 2005030001
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Saul and
Elsa Garcia, and consents to this lien being discharged ofrecord,
Dated this
day of
,2007,
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E, BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORlDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
/O~ r~
Thomas C, Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
~<;J~';n:::1Z; ilS:r t\:: "j C;L,~'
i\i()\/e:T::)C:' =~. 2Ctr
Paas 20 0184
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assislant County Atturney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated July 7, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on July 21, 2006, in
O.R. Book 4076 at Page 678 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida. against the
following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County. owned by Lara Guillermo & Juana Cruz, has been discharged in full:
Lara Guillermo & Juana Cruz
507 N. 11th St
Immokalee, Florida 34142-2909
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
51240880000
$113.46
OSM Case No. 2006050077
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Lara
Guillermo & Juana Cruz, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
.2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY. FLORlDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA. CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
ID~ \Uu.~
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
p.aenda iTem j\jo, ISA2
. Hovernoe: '::.7. 2DD7
Page 21 of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples. Florida 34112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated February 17, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on February 24,
2006, in O.R. Book 3988 at Page 99] of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Vernon & Lucy Heiston, has been discharged in full:
Vernon & Lucy Heiston
5306 Confederate Dr.
Naples, Florida 34] 13-8703
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
6204636000]
$175.83
OSM Case No. 2005]20085
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Vernon
& Lucy Heiston, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DW]GHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
10M \0t,u.--
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
Apenca item hie, i 6/.\2
l\Jovemoe: :27, 2007
;:"age 22 of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant Count)' Attorney
:nOl East Tamiarni Trail
Naples. Florida 34112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated August 10, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on August 11,
2006, in O.R. Book 4087 age Page 2471 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Oralia Hinojosa, has been discharged in full:
Oralia Hinojosa
802 Pine S1. Ext.
Naples, Florida 34142
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
00077080008
$195.91
OSM Case No. 2005110533
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Oralia
Hinojosa, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
10M WlU'-------
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
Agenoa Item !'.JC, "16,1\2
r\~c_,ven;r:s: =7. 20C-
Pags 23 of S:'
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated August 10, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on August II,
2006, in O.R. Book 4087 at Page 2475, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real properly, and all other real and personal property
locatcd in Collier County, owned by Holistic Health Healing, Inc., c/o Roberto Conti, has
been discharged in full:
Holistic Health Healing, Inc.
11238 Tamiami Trail E.
Naples, Florida 34113
Folio No.:
Cost:
Refcrence:
00439120001
$172.34
OSM Case No. 2005020167
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Holistic
Health Healing, Inc., and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORlDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Thom:~~jfJ~
Assistant County Attorney
F,pS:i:i~: il~;m He ;=.\1..-',,;.
i';()\JE:::l1De~ =7 200'7
Page 24 of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C Palmer
AssIstant County Attorney
330 I East Tamiami Trail
Napies, Florida 34112
(239) 252.84UU
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated June 16,2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on June 27, 2006, in
O.R. Book 4061 at Page 3817 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against
the following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Keri Hunt, has been discharged in full:
Keri Hunt
2640 Poincianna Dr.
Naples. Florida 34105
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
68097560003
$351.90
OSM Case No. 2005080998
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Keri
Hunt and consents to this lien being discharged ofrecord.
Dated this
day of
.2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
1~~ct1w--
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
,i:,penosi ITem t\.lO, 10;\2
l\Jc:vernu;::: 27, 2DC-'
Page 25 of 8'::
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
330\ East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated December 5, 2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on December 8,
2005, in O.R. Book 3944 at Page 230 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by PaulL. Justman, has been discharged in full:
PaulL. Justman
510 14th St., N.E.
Naples, Florida 34120-9477
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
39270920004
$200.84
OSM Case No. 2005070109
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned hy PaulL.
Justman, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
/C1~\J1 (D(4.
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
:terr j\;::> E;:,_
:\)'::)i/SiT:::If,: =-c, 2DJ-
i=1398 26 of 8-4
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C, Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 Ea<;t Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated April 7, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on April 24, 2006, in
O.R. Book 4023 at Page 906 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against the
following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Virginia Garcia, has been discharged in full:
Virginia Garcia
5476 Martin Sl.
Naples, Florida 34113
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
62207720008
$157.14
OSM Case No. 2006020994
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Virginia
Garcia, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
.2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK. Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
~ !f
1M, C/..1.L----.
Thomas C. Pal er
Assistant County Attorney
kpenoa item hlC, "iG,L\2
)\jCJ\/eiTlDe:" .?-7, ;~007
F'age 27 of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiarni Trail
Naples. Florida 14112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated August 10, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on August 11,
2006, in O.R. Book 4087 at Page 2467, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Manuela & Elias Herrera, has been discharged in
full:
Manuela & Elias Herrera
1322 Orange St.
lmmokalee, Florida 34142
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
30733440004
$130.12
OSM Case No. 2006020770
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby relea~e this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Manuela
& Elias Herrera, and consents to this lien being discharged ofrecord.
day of
,2007.
Dated this
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
\D rv\
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
\M~
L.pe:lC1 c; :"lsm l\JC j I~~,L,:::
;,,;(.) ,'ern~)e'..::. 20D7
:;apE:: 28 of 134
This inslrumt::nt prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East lamiami Trail
Naples. Florida 34112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated September 2, 2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on September
19, 2005, in O.R. Book 3892 at Page 1588, of the Public Records of Collier County,
Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real and personal
property located in Collier County, owned by Emilio Guarrido, has been discharged in
full:
Emilio Guarrido
5477 Martin St.
Naples, Florida 34113
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
62207600005
$169.42
OSM Case No. 2005070672
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Emilio
Guarrido, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
.lAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Thom!Pt'palm~J ~
Assistant County Attorney
[tern j'JU, .jl),L,2
l\!ove:T\DS~ .=-C, 2007
F1a98 29 of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples_ Florida 34112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated September 22, 2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on September
23, 2005, in O.R. Book 3896 at Page 1723, of the Public Records of Collier County,
Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real and personal
property located in Collier County, owned by Gulf Atlantic Association, has been
discharged in full:
Gulf Atlantic Association
4532 Tamiami Trail, E.
Naples, Florida 34112
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
67080480007
$1.158.51
OSM Case No. 2005010942
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Gulf
Atlantic Association, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Thoma~~'
Assistant County Attorney
: ls,r: !"JC', '5L,2
I'JC\'S:TiDe T 200-
:='aos 3D of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 Ea'lt Tarniami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master Imposing Fines dated January 19,2007, a certified copy of which was recorded on
February 5, 2007, in O,R. Book 4] 78, Pages 2562-2563, of the Public Records of Collier
County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real and
personal property located in Collier County, owned by Gracelia Guzman, has been
discharged in full:
Gracelia Guzman
]] 5006 L's Farm Rd.
Naples, Florida 34114-7598
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
754480002
$21,990.60
OSM Case No. 2005-050529
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Gracelia
Guzman, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
10M
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
?Jw~
AOenGS item No, 161:,'2
, i\JClVen".oe:" T?, 2007
Page 3 'I of 8Li
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
(2391252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated June 16,2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on June 27, 2006, in
O.R. Book 4061 at Page 3815, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against
the following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Trine Guajardo, has been discharged in full:
Trine Guajardo
] 406 Orange St.
Immokalee, Florida 34]42
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
30681880004
$122.62
OSM Case No. 2006020761
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Trine
Guajardo, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
day of
,2007.
Dated this
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
IP/I\^ (Uu.---
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
!l~-;~r; !'!C Uh_
: \~ ,:e.-r:D9'.:." 2007
Paas 32 of e~
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples. Florida 34112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated August 10, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on August 11,
2006, in O.R. Book 4087 at Page 2439, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Rosemonde Gennilus, has been discharged in full:
Rosemonde Germilus
5270 Georgia Ave.
Naples, Florida 34113
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
62154080008
$5.000
OSM Case No. 2005080392
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by
Rosemonde Gennilus, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
. Deputy Clerk
Approved as to fonn and
legal sufliciency:
JP~ P,J~
Thoma C. Palm~r
Assistant County Attorney
!i,aenda Item 1'00. 16A2
. f\Jov.srnb9" 27, 2007
Paqe 33 of 8-4
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated July 21, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on August 2, 2006, in
O.R. Book 4081 at Page 2834, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against
the following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Victor Grimaldo & Leticio Esparza, has been discharged in
full:
Victor Grimaldo & Leticio Esparza
906 Irnmokalee Dr.
Immokalee, Florida 34142
Folio \10.:
Cost:
Reference:
73180360008
$113.46
OSM Case No. 2006050] 87
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property. and all other real and personal property owned by Victor
Grimaldo & Leticio Esparza, and consents to this lien being discharged ofrecord.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORlDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
To~ flI4~
Thomas . Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
;.\;:~:nCjc, iIen; 1\,:: 'i 6L\~'
I'JJ\::::i:';fJ212;' 2ClCi7
;:)a';18 3.:1 of 84
This in~trumcnt prepared hy:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiarni Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
(239) 252-8400
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated October 12, 2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on October 17,
2005, in O.R. Book 3912 at Page 3640, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County. owned by CSE Properties, LLC, has been discharged in full:
CSE Properties, LLC
2991 Areca Ave.
Naples, Florida 34112-5801
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
7]781760009
$287.97
OSM Case No. 200505113]
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by CSE
Properties, LLC, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated. this
day of
.2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMM1SS10NERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
10 In r JUt---
Thomas C, Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
'~gend2 :tem !\io, -j 6.L\2
f\JOV<;:)!T:ber- 27, 200~'
F;age 35 of 8";
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated May 5, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on May II, 2006 in
O.R. Book 4035 at Page 439 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against the
following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Stpetim Ramku, has been discharged in full:
1008 Hampton Circle
Naples, Florida 34105
Folio No,:
Cost:
Reference:
75020002204
$178.80
OSM No, 2005120429
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole
of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal property
owned by Stpetim Ramku, and consents to this lien being discharged of record,
Dated this
day of
,2007,
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E, BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
IDM rJ~
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
.r"I.~r: '-~n.II\l," '0'" r,'
,~,'~,7:1 ....c. lit ;.,''"!...', - ,.,=
hlOv'emD8r L': 200
Page 36 of 8.1
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C, Palmer
Assistant Coumy Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples. Florida 34104
(239\ 213.2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated May 19, 2006. a certified copy of which was recorded on June 5, 2006 in
O.R. Book 4049 at Page 1832 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against
the following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Robeda McKinney, c/o Mike Pannel, has been discharged in
full:
712 Dade St
Immokalee, Florida 34142
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
63861120001
$180.79
OSM No. 2006020925
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Robeda
McKinney. and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK. Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
,
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
\O~ 0JVv~
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
/-\genoa Item ['~D, "16";2
Novernbe;" 27 2007
Page 37 of 84
This instrument prepared by;
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated December 7, 2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on December 8,
2005 in O.R. Book 3944 at Page 238 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Ted Luo, has been discharged in full:
5401 Mahogany Ridge Dr.
Naples. Florida 34119
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
38280960000
$534.47
OSM No. 2005030468
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property. and all other real and personal property owned by Ted
Luo, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
~
1 0 111\
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
w~
i-<~;7;n::;C; itefT: 1\1:~ H;,L,_
i\L:)\!SiT;:J~: 27, 2U07
Page 30 of 8i
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated March 3, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on March 20, 2006
in O.R. Book 4001 at Page 302 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against
the following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Flavio Loredo, has been discharged in full:
306 Porter St.
Naples, Florida 34113
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
00445960006
$181.54
OSMNo.2005120102
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Flavio
Loredo. and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
.2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
. Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
loW\ \Lf~
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
!TSiT, i'l~;" ")f-,_
I'JCl\'eniD9' 2:, 20(17
Page 3Si of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated March 3, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on March 20,2006
in O.R. Book 4001 at Page 301 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against
the following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier COWlty, owned by Flavio Loredo, has been discharged in full:
306 Porter St.
Naples, Florida 34113
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
00445960006
$181.54
OSMNo.2005120103
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Flavio
Loredo, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
.2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
~MQj~
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
i-<;:;er:~j liS;! i\[:, 'In'::'
i-JQ\:S:11b9:' 2-;- :=:007
F'ape 4C of 8i\
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C, Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiarni Trail
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated July 21, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on August 2, 2006 in
O.R. Book 4081 at Page 2832 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against
the following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Martin Soto Lopez, has been discharged in full:
612 New Market Road, West
Immokalee, Florida 34142
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
63855720006
$124.34
OSM No. 2006050400
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Martin
Soto Lopez, and consents to this lien being discharged ofrecord.
Dated this
day of
.2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORlDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
~OM r~l~
Thomas . Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
,:,:,penc;a iLeTI I'~c, 16L,2
l'JO\lemDe:' '27,2007
Page 4'1 of gLj
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant Count)' Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples. Florida 34 J 04
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated May 19, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on June 5, 2006 in
O.R. Book 4049 at Page 1821 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against
the following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Henry E. Knaust, Tr., has been discharged in full:
593 92nd Avenue, North
Naples, Florida 34108
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
62701720009
$156.44
OSM No. 2005120372
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Henry E.
Knaust, Tr., and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
.2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK. Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
10M W~
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
:'..\J~:r;::::E., : ~::;;T I\Li 03r,:"
, i'~:~ \ie:TiD8'- 27 200'
".age c;2 of 8"
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 341 04
(2J9) 2] 3-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated October 16,2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on February 12,
2007 in O.R. Book 4182 at Page 1 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Robert Flick, has been discharged in full:
5325 Carlton Street
Naples, Florida 34113
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
62099000004
$377.01
OSM No. 2006070944
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Robert
Flick. and consents to this lien being discharged ofrecord.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
IO~ Wew-----
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
,;';;',;::Jena8 :ierYl l\:c.16,;;2
!>Jovembe:- 17. 2007
Page 43 of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated July 7, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on July 21, 2006 in
O,R, Book 4076 at Page 668 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against the
following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Robert Flick, has been discharged in full:
1278 Highlands Drive
Naples, Florida 34103
Folio No,:
Cost:
Reference:
29781920008
$216.91
OSM No. 2006020768
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Robert
Flick, and consents to this lien being discharged ofrecord.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E, BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
[PM. PJ~
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
,:..\,oerl:JCJ item I'\!~" -j 6A~
~ I-JOV2I11be;- ~7, 2007
Page 44 of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistam County Attorney
3301 East Tarniami Trail
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated October 12,2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on October 17,
2005, in O.R. Book 3912 at Page 3629 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Robert Flick, has been discharged in full:
5325 Carlton Street, Apt. D
Naples, Florida 34113
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
62099000004
$200.00
OSM No. 2005080056
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Robert
Flick, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal suffIciency:
lL1~ PJ~
Thoma C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
[le,n hlC, i 6L,~
j'JOvembe, =7, 2007
F'age 45 of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated March 3, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on March 20, 2006
in O.R. Book 400 I at Page 318 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against
the following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Ted Zhi Hui & Peng Sy Lou, has been discharged in full:
11580 Riggs Road
Naples, Florida 34114
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
00762160000
$616.31
OSM No. 2005070525
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Ted Zhi
Hui & Peng Sy Lou, and consents to this lien being discharged ofrecord.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
ID~ WltM--
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
.""\CSI1:j2 Lem i\Jc' 'l':i';~
i~C)V~ :l"ilJS:' 2' 20~~F
Pa98 4b of 8.::]
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Napks, Florida 34104
(239) 2]3-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated September 2, 2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on September
19, 2005, in O.R. Book 3892 at Page 1592 of the Public Records of Collier County,
Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real and personal
property located in Collier County, owned by Richard L Licare, has been discharged in
full:
3129 Woodside Avenue
Naples, Florida 34112
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
48784320000
$163.47
OSM No. 2005051108
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Richard
L Licare, and consents to this lien being discharged ofrecord,
Dated this
day of
,2007,
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E, BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORlDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
~
10M
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
PJWv~
irern 1\10. I L:,L:-,~
i'Jove:rlbe;. 27, 2007
F'age 4'7 of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Thoma,> C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tarniarni Trail
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated March 17, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on April 24, 2006,
in O.R. Book 4023 at Page 879 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against
the following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Frank Aloia, Jr., Tr., Cinema Land Trust, has been discharged
in full:
5249 Alabama Avenue
Naples, Florida 34113
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
62150840006
$182.40
OSM No. 2005120637
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Frank
Aloia, Jr., Tr., Cinema Land Trust, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
,....-----,
I OlfV\
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
rJ~
):m~J(~ iTern I'L I'j-\~
f':::-)\.'e:T:DS:' 2-. 200:-
~'a;:le 48 01 8~
This instrument prepared by:
'Thoma<; C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 Ea<;t Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 213~2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated December 2, 2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on December 8,
2005, in O.R. Book 3944 at Page 255 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Neim & Sebahat Malo, has been discharged in full:
1509 Jimpson Lane
Naples, Florida 34105
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
33132200004
$] 65.26
OSM No. 2005090013
The undersigned is authorized to and does herehy release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Neim &
Sebahat Malo, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
.2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
,--.
I 0 yv'\
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
rcJ~
f..,Oenu3 !ISiTI !',jo, '16;:;.
, j~()vernns~ 27 20(;7
::;ag8 4~j of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated August 10, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on August II,
2006, in O.R, Book 4087 at Page 2455 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Voltaire & Guerda Jean, has been discharged in full:
52]8 Warren Street
Naples, Florida 34113
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
6215164000]
$135.43
OSM No. 2006050900
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Voltaire
& Guerda Jean, and consents to this lien being discharged of record,
Dated this
day of
,2007,
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E, BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMM]SSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Tho~~merrJ~
Assistant County Attorney
Ilem !\JC). i'J,."..c
i\C)\'''';:~I'ID8: ,=7, LOCi"
?ape 50 of 3D
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 213~2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated May 19,2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on June 5, 2006, in
O.R, Book 4049 at Page 1837 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against
the following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Kimberly B, Riggie, has been discharged in full:
531217'h Avenue, SW
Naples, Florida 34116
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
36249600002
$350.66
OSM No. 2006020504
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by
Kimberly B. Riggie, and consents to this lien being discharged ofrccord.
Dated this
day of
.2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E, BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to fonn and
legal sufficiency:
10~ ~J~~
Thomas ,Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
;1.9;1-, i\C. lG,,::,:"
!\lOVe:TitH::,' _ 200i
F'age E, 'I of 8~
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated April 21, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on May 8, 2006, in
O.R. Book 4032 at Page 1132 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against
the following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Enrique J. Palacios & Alma Jimenez, has been discharged in
full:
5365 24th Avenue, SW
Naples, Florida 34116
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
36309480007
$171.78
OSM No. 20060 I 0465
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Enrique
J. Palacios & Alma Jimenez, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Thomlt:;er r J ~~
Assistant County Attorney
IlS~: I'-J C;' , 1 '3,L<=.
(~:::',\ie:'n:E':- ~7. 2007
~'a9S S2 of 84
This instrument prepared b:y:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiarni Trail
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated September 2, 2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on September
19, 2005, in O.R. Book 3892 at Page] 721 of the Public Records of Collier County,
Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real and personal
property located in Collier County, owned by SH & MA, LLC, has been discharged in
full:
2275 J & C Boulevard
Naples, Florida 34] 09
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
0024544000]
$269.87
OSM No. 2004090671
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by SH &
MA LLC, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
.2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMM]SSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Tho:}Op~er ~ u---
Assistant County Attorney
A9snas 1[9;-;; I\;,=-, .;'3.'::,::"
i'<Jevsmb:;:;; 27 200-::'
F'age of 8L1
This instrumenl prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated May 19, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on June 5. 2006, in
O.R. Book 4049 at Page 1841 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against
the following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Robert C. & Beatrice M. Huvaere, has been discharged in full:
3925 Thomasson Lane
Naples, Florida 34112
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
67491960006
$168.29
OSM No. 2006040726
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Robert
C. & Beatrice M. Huvaere, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
day of
.2007.
Dated this
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Tho~~mer r J ~tJv'----
Assistant County Attorney
iism i\IC~' ':)r,_
I"O\l9mo.;;-;,- '::::-. 2D~I-
f='aos 5~ of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated May 6, 2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on May 13, 2005, in
O.R. Book 3797 at Page 3856 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against
the following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Julia Gonzalez, has been discharged in full:
2140 42nd Street, SW
Naples. Florida 34116
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
35740200009
$195.00
OSM No. 2003100457
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Julia
Gonzalez, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY. FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
I {J/Y\- rJ~
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
!t~;:T': ;'!C.
'..),-,-
i\J:J\/emns:-:27 2DO-:::
FlagG 5:\ oi 84
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated September 2, 2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on September
19, 2005, in O.R. Book 3892 at Pages 1604-1605 of the Public Records of Collier
County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real and
personal property located in Collier County, owned by Robert R. Robinson, has been
discharged in full:
899 San Marcos Boulevard
Naples, Florida 34104
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
294760004
$162.85
OSM No. 2005060699
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Robert
R. Robinson, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
~M rJ~
Thomas . Palmer
Assistant County Attorney
.'.:;,~lenCE: ::0:1', !'.::. ,jL._
I\!uv~:rnrje~ =7 ::::OCi~
:=-'a~ls 56 Df 84
This inslrumcnt prcparcd by:
Jeff E. Wnght
Assistant County Attorney
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive, Ste 301
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated July 7, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on July 21, 2006 in
O.R. Book 4076 Page 0668 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against the
following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Robert A. Flick, has been discharged in full.
Robert A. Flick
.1278 Highlands Drive
Naples, FI
Folio No.
Cost:
Reference:
29781920008
$216.91
Case No. 2006020768
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Robert A. Flick, and consents to this lien being
di scharged of record.
Dated this
day of
, 2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COUlER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
kpSI1C1E: Its,r; ;'<W. 16,L,~
i'Jovembe:' 27, 2007
Page 57 of 8.1
This instrument prepared by:
Jeff E. Wright
Assistant County Attorney
2800 t\'. Horseshoe Drive, Stc 301
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated April 7,2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on April 24, 2006, in
O.R. Book 4023, Page 0891, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against the
following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Timothy G. Flick, has been discharged in full:
Timothy G. Flick
271 I 54th SI. SW
Naples, FL
Folio No.
Cost:
Reference:
36322080002
$521.27
OSM Case No: 2005120715
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Timothy G. Flick, and consents to this lien being
di seharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLrER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
(
:-,psn,:.,;;; i~S:Ti 1-";(1 C)L,_
!'j)VS:,1QS:' 27, 20]7
Page 55 of B4
This instrument prepared by:
Jeff E. Wright
Assistant County Attorney
28001\. Horseshoe Drive. Sle 301
Naples, Florida 34104
(39) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated October 12, 2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on October 17,
2005, in O.R. Book 3912, Page 3629, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Robert A. Flick, has been discharged in full:
Robert A. Flick
5325 Carlton St. Apt. D
Naples. FL
Folio No.
Cost:
Rcference:
62099000004
$200.00
OSM Case No. 2005080056
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property. and all other real and personal
property owned by Robert A. Flick, and consents to this lien being
di scharged of record.
Dated this
day of
, 2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
F.p:::,'r;:l:;-,': i1em l\!c-. F._~,~
I-w'v'smt's.; 2~; 2CJT~
F'a~e 58 of 8t
This instrument prepared by:
Jeff E. Wright
Assistant County Attorney
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive. Ste 301
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated March 17, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on April 24, 2006,
in O.R. Book 4023, Page 0868, of the Public Records of Collier County. Florida, against
the following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by George Faccone Tr and Rita Faccone Tr, has been discharged
in full.
George Faccone Tr and Rita Faccone Tr
4007 Rose Ave Apt # 1
Naples, FL
Folio No.
Cost:
Reference:
67493600005
$366.32
OSM Case No: 2005090328
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by George Faccone Tr and Rita Faccone Tr, and consents
to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
, 2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to furm and
legal sufficicncy:
r
,i-,;~:enGa :[~::rn :'~C' 1 Ci,2-,,:.
iWV~':TilJS:' 27 2-JCi:
f='age 60 of b<1
This instrument prepared by:
Jeff E. Wright
Assistant County Attorney
2800 N. Horseshoe Drivc. Stc 301
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated July 7, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on July 21, 2006, in
O.R. Book 4076, Page 0666, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against the
following described real property. and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Marion Cook, has been discharged in full:
Marion Cook
320 Wells Street
Naples, FL
Folio No:
Cost:
Reference:
81320440000
$194.91
OSM Case No. 2006030862
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-descri bed real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Marion Cook. and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLrER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency: r
4.pe:lJCi [tem !'jC,:, 1G,':-,~'
I'n\/e:-nbs~'=:: 200'
F'afJs Eli of 8.1
This instrument prepared by:
Jeff E. Wright
Assistant County Attorney
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive. Sle 301
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated April 6, 2007, a certified copy of which was recorded on April 19,2007, in
O.R. Book 4215, Page(s) 4122 and 4123, of the Public Records of Collier County,
Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real and personal
property located in Collier County, owned by Ronald Zbikowski, has been discharged in
full:
Ronald Zbikowski
291 11th Street SW
Naples, FL
Folio No:
Cost:
Reference:
37015400008
$12,500.00
OSM Case No. CO-4229 a/kla 2005-120473
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Ronald Zbikowski, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
(
IE;'Ti i\JC 6.L,~
~\JCl\le;Ti:)~;: ::27. 2[J]-
;:::'0;18 6::" :::;: 84
This instrument prepared by:
Jeff E. Wright
Assistant County Attomey
2800~. Horseshoe Drive. Sle 301
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated April 15,2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on April 19, 2005, in
O.R. Book 3777, Page 4047, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against the
following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by John and Michelle Hall. has been discharged in full:
John and Michelle Hall
th .'
73129 St. S.W.
Naples. FL
Folio No:
Cost:
Reference:
36812210007
$138.22
OSM Case No. 2004120196
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real propeny, and all other real and personal
property owncd by John and Michelle Hall, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
. 2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
(
IISITi i\J(;, ': 'S::,=:
;\JC:;V':::'illDS: 27" 2(\;7
Page 6S of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Jeff E. Wright
Assistant County Attorney
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive. Ste 301
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated March 2, 2007, a certified copy of which was recorded on March 20, 2007,
in O.R. Book 4199, Page(s) 1608 and 1609, of the Public Records of Collier County,
Florida, against the following described real propeny, and all other real and personal
property located in Collier County, owned by Paul Zaino, has been discharged in full:
Paul Zaino
3341Corana Way
Naples, FL
Folio No:
Cost:
Reference:
68093000004
$174.39
OSM Case No. 2006-020919
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Paul Zaino, and consents to this lien being discharged
of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
t
f~.98iIC;;:~ lten'" !\J2. r;j.t,='
:1::)' O::::l:t:;,e' 27. =-:OCi~
~'age S~ of 8":
This Instrument prepared by:
JeffE. Wright
Assistant County Attorney
2800N. Horseshoe Drive, Ste 301
Naples. Florida 341 04
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated March 2, 2007, a certified copy of which was recorded on March 20, 2007,
in O.R. Book 4199, Pages 1610-1611, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Paul Zaino, has been discharged in full:
Paul Zaino
3341 Corana Way
Naples FL 34105
Folio No:
Cost:
Reference:
68093000004
$4716.59
OSM Case No. 2006-040807
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Paul Zaino, and consents to this lien being discharged
ofrecord.
Dated this
day of
,2007
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
\
9:-
t
t County Attorney
itSrii He::>. "j ~3J:.,'l.
i\lC'\ f:;',':bs: ,=i. ':::OC7
Page S5 of 84
This instrument prepared hy:
Jeff E. Wright
Assistant County Attorney
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive. Ste 301
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated August 10, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on August 11,
2006, in O.R. Book 4087, Page 2473, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Maria M. Alfaro, has been discharged in full:
Maria M. Alfaro
3444 Carson Lakes Circle
Naples, FL
Folio No:
Cost:
Reference:
25377802408
$135.60
OSM Case No. 2006040685
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Maria M. Alfaro, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
L\0r~~~,~~~ i~~~..~i: I~'~ ~lt.C~:~
F'age (36 of 84
This instrument prepared by;
Jeff E. Wright
Assislant County Attorney
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive. Ste J01
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SA TISF ACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated June 3, 2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on July 6, 2005, in
O.R. Book 3837, Page 0562, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against the
following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Sang and Sounitta Bacam. and Janet Liemthong Et AI and has
been discharged in full:
Sang and Sounitta Baccam
Janet Liemthong Et AI
1705 Benton Road
Naples FI
Folio No:
Cost:
Reference:
00324880003
$314.04
OSM Case No. 2004020378
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by by Sang and Sounitta Bacam, and Janet Liemthong Et
AI, and conscnts to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY. FLORIDA
By:
By:
. Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
~'
~
Jeff. ri ht
Assist t County Attorney
l\;18n:JS Item i\)Q
l\jCl\-'elilDe:' 27
PaGe
-]6,1:,2
20Ti
of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Jeff E. Wright
Assistanl County Attorney
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive. Ste 301
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated December 7, 2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on December 8,
2005, in O.R. Book 3944, Page 0229, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Eduardo and Luisa Pereiro, has been discharged in
full:
Eduardo and Luisa Pereiro
3216 Linwood A venue
Naples, FL
Folio No:
Cost:
Reference:
61482400005
$163.47
OSM Case No. 2005050878
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Eduardo and Luisa Pereiro, and consents to this lien
being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
.2007
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
i~sm :\!D "itJ.';':;
I~Q\leT;Je' 27 20C:7
?age G() 0: ElL
This instrument prepared by:
Jeff E. Wright
Assistant County Attorney
2800 N, Horseshoe Drive. Ste 301
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated May 5, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on May 11, 2006, in
O.R. Book 4035, Page 0408, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against the
following described real propeny, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Alkatotal Limited Partnership, Thomas and Deborah Cook, has
been discharged in full:
Alkatotal Limited Partnership
Thomas and Deborah Cook
4501 32nd Avenue S.W.
Naples, FL
Folio No:
Cost:
Reference:
36009040006
$192.70
OSM Case No. 2006030402
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Alkatotal Limited Partnership, Thomas and Deborah
Cook, and consents to this Iicn being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
AoenC2 ilem I'~c. ": 6:'2
. i-JoveIllD2" 27. 20D'
Page 69 01 84
This instrument prepared by:
Jeff E. Wnght
Assistant County Attorney
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive, Ste 301
Nap!es, Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated September 2, 2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on September
19, 2005, in O.R. Book 3892, Page 1604, of the Public Records of Collier County,
Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real and personal
property located in Collier County, owned by Robert R. Robinson, has been discharged in
full:
Robert R. Robinson
899 San Marcos Blvd
Naples, FL
Folio No:
Cost:
Reference:
00294760004
$162.85
OSM Case No. 2005060699
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Robert R. Robinson, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
By:
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
r
ght
t County Attorney
item !\lC. ':G,L'\..:.
i'nvs:-nbe' =-" 2CJC:~
f=;ags 7(; of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Jeff E. Wright
Assistant County AUomcy
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive. Ste 301
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated August 10, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on August 11,
2005, in O.R. Book 4087. Page 2449, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida.
against the following described real property. and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Richard Jandro, has been discharged in full:
Richard Jandro
19 W. Pelican Street
Naples, FL
Folio No:
Cost:
Reference:
52342680000
$220.60
OSM Case No. 2006040196
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Richard J andro, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated thlS
day of
.2007
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSION'ERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
:t:.
}.\981l0a 118m I\JC' 16,6,2
i\JcJvembsi' 27 2007
Page of 84
This instrument prepared by:
JoffE. Wright
Assistant County Attorney
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive. Stc 301
Naples. Florida 341 04
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated January 19, 2007, a certified copy of which was recorded on February 5,
2007, in O.R. Book 4178, Page 2570, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Ralph and Maria Aguilera, has been discharged in
full:
Ralph and Maria Aguilera
10020 Bayshore Drive
Naples, FL
Folio No:
Cost:
Reference:
50890040000
$156.90
OSM Case No. 2005-051077
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Ralph and Maria Aguilera, and consents to this lien
being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
{
Jeff .
Assis
item I'!e, "! Q."<_
i\lO\'-Silll)S:' =7 20[;-
F'ag7; 72 of 8..:
This instrumenl prepared hy:
Jeff E. Wright
Assistanl County Auorney
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive. Ste 301
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 213.2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated June 1,2007, a certified copy of which was recorded on June 15,2007, in
O.R. Book 4244, Page 3890, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against the
following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Ted Zhi Luo. has been discharged in full:
Ted Zhi Luo
11580 Riggs Road
Naples, FL
Folio No:
Cost:
Reference:
00762160000
$5,500.00
OSM Case No. 2005-070577
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Ted Zhi Luo, and consents to this lien being discharged
of record.
Dated this
day of _
.2007
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
~
ItSiTi I\JO. .j (3A:!..
!'JOV8IT1D8'.27 2007
Faoe of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Jeff E. Wright
Assistant County Attorney
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive, Ste 301
Naples. Florida 34 J 04
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated June 1, 2007, a certified copy of which was recorded on June 15,2007, in
O.R. Book 4244, Pagc 3887, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against the
following described real property, and aJl other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Ted Zhi Luo, has been discharged in full:
Ted Zhi Luo
11580 Riggs Road
Naples, FL
Folio No:
Cost:
Reference:
00762160000
$6,700.00
OSM Case No. 2005-070528
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Ted Zhi Luo, and consents to this lien being discharged
of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
(J f~
J~E~
Assistan ounty Attorney
,~,;J8l.i~"Ja il2iii i>JC
hie ,.S;;;:18:' :::?
".'""r,
I ::.J.'"',.;..
20Ci;
;::-'C1Q8 7 ~ or f\.i
This instrument prepared by:
Jeff E. Wright
Assistant County Attorney
2800 1\". Horseshoe Dnve. Sle 301
Naples, Florida 34104-
(139) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated June 1,2007, a certified copy of which was recorded on June 15,2007, in
O.R. Book 4244, Page(s) 3893 and 3894, of the Public Records of Collier County,
Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real and personal
property located in Collier County, owned by Ted Zhi Luo, has been discharged in full:
Ted Zhi Luo
11530 Riggs Road
Naples, FL
Folio No:
Cost:
Reference:
00762400003
$2,800.00
OSM Case No. 2004-110790
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Ted Zhi Luo, and consents to this lien being discharged
of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
(;: l~
Mht
Assistant County Attorney
/.:.'-';::>1"";"'" i-'-l~m ',\ir', '.,('::'.D,')
,'~~>''-'G,~' :..,=-. vc,::;
i'~o\'eIllDe!' ..:: I, 20u}
Page 75 of 84
This instrument prepared by:
J erf E. Wright
Assistant County Attorney
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive. Ste 301
Naples. Florida 34] 04
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SA TISF ACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated March 17, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on April 24, 2006,
in O.R. Book 4023, Page 0869, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against
the following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by EJ Properties LLC, has been discharged in full:
EJ Properties LLC
509 Doak A venue
Naples, FL
Folio No:
Cost:
Reference:
65073440001
$3395.59
OSM Case No. 2005120434
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by EJ Properties LLC, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Iofr~
Assistant County Attorney
ile;TI i<_,. 'iljL\':::
i;,JOv9,Tlt-Je: 27 2D(';7
~'ags 76 of s~
This instrumenl prepared by:
JeffE. Wnght
Assistant County Attorney
28001\.. Horseshoe Drive. Stc 30]
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated August 22, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on September 6,
2006, in O.R. Book 4101, Page 0174, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Terry Brown, has been discharged in full:
Terry Brown
1410 Garthie Road
Naples. FL
Folio No:
Cost:
Reference:
00090800003
$124.34
OSM Case No. 2006050778
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby relcase this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Terry Brown, and consents to this lien being discharged
of record.
Dated thi s
day of
,2007
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Jctfr
Assistant County Attorney
f-',QenCJ3 ilem I\]c, 16/\::::
, NCVUTlbS'," '27,200'
F\age 77 of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Jeff E. Wright
Assistant County Attorney
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive, Ste 301
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated April 20,2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on April 26, 2005, in
O.R. Book 3783, Page 0752, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against the
following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Fravelo, Inc., has been discharged in full:
Cost:
Reference:
$94.92
OSM Case No. 2005020147
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Fravelo, Inc, and consents to this lien being discharged
of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
L,;JenGa !T9m hi'::; ~ 13.[,,2-
hIDVS:liDe::; 200c
F-'a00: ?,s cf 82
This instrument prepared by:
JcffE. Wright
Assistant County Attorney
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive, Ste 301
Naples. Florida 34 ) 04
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated May 18, 2007, a certified copy of which was recorded on June 5, 2007, in
O.R. Book 4238, Page(s) 3421 and 3422, of the Public Records of Collier County,
Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real and personal
property located in Collier County, owned by Jaime Lopez, has been discharged in full:
Jaime Lopez
778 El Paso Trail
Naples, FL
Folio No:
Cost:
Reference:
00082962768
$500.00
OSM Case No. 2006-050089
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Jaime Lopez, and consents to this lien being discharged
of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal suffieiency:
~t
Jeff. ri t
Assist t County Attorney
This instrument prepared by:
Thomas C. Palmer
Assislant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
(239) 252-&400
AfJel103 ilem I~~ ! bt-',.c.:
I\lDVernoS'i- ...: / 20G7
. '-' >~'i _ . Paae 7~! of 84
. '. ~': I '\_'i... 'I' ~
AJr.Jf{iv ~ ;:,-
" ""1'/............... ":"
I (L....'I._,
llll -, , i,~ .
OCT 26
Pi1 I: 44
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated April 7, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on April 24, 2006, in
O.R. Book 4023 at Page 894 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, against the
following described real property, and all other real and personal property located in
Collier County, owned by Jean R. & Sidonie Laguerre, has been discharged in full:
Jean r. & Sidonie Laguerre
3352 Poinsettia Ave
Naples, Florida 34104-4014
Folio No.:
Cost:
Referencc:
63501280007
$58.69
OSM Case No. 2006020553
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the whole of the
above-described real property, and all other real and personal property owned by Jean R.
& Sidonie Laguerre, and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
day of
,2007.
Dated this
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By: _
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
--- ~ PJtM---
ThomJ C.q,almer
Assistant County Attorney
"
~~$"-
'-IV!>/,"> ~
,.1../....
{(?
9.'
L:..-;12i1::Ja Il-?n-i i\" I G;:'__~"
1,::Ve.l,i'2 _-.28Ci
F'age 8D of g.;
This instrument prepared by:
Jeff E. Wright
Assistant County Attorney
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive. Ste 301
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of the Special
Master dated January 6, 2006, a certified copy of which was recorded on January 20,
2006, in O.R. Book 3968, Page 1946, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Fryer Chuck, Ine and Jack Colbey, has been
discharged in full:
Fryer Chuck, Ine and Jack Colbey
3091 Tamiami Trail East
Naples, FL
Folio No:
Cost:
Reference:
82640520007
$179.59
OSM Case No. 2005090757
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Fryer Chuck, Inc and Jack Colbey, and consents to this
lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
~
Jef. ht
Assis ant County Attorney
/\;Jen02 item i\JCr. '16L,=-'
Novemher 27.2007
Pa;)e 8 "; of 84
This instrument prepared by:
Jeff E. Wright
Assistant County Attorney
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive, Ste 301
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising out of the Order of Code
Enforcement Department dated June 25, 2001, a certified copy of which was recorded on
June 28, 2001, in O.R. Book 2850, Pages 2310 through 2312, of the Public Records of
Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real
and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Somsanith Thammavong and
Tamchay Insixiengmay, has been discharged in full:
Folio No.
Cost:
Reference:
00482167804
N/A (acquired and brought into compliance by State)
CEB No. 2001-0014
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Somsaruth Thammavong and Tamchay Insixiengmay,
and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
By:
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
t
t County Attorney
,"-'-.fl'::';ii::ji:, iL.;';:", i'J( !::JL.~
i\!:: \/9i1lbe! =~r ~007
F'ags 8~ of 8.:;
This instrument prepared by:
JetfE. Wright
Assistant County Attorney
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive, Ste 301
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising out of the Code Enforcement Board
Order dated August 27, 2007, a certified copy of which was recorded on August 30, 2007,
in O.R. Book 4276 Pages 3212-13 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Jaycees Foundation of Naples, Inc., has been
discharged in full:
Jaycees Foundation of Naples, Inc. (David Moran (Reg. Agent))
2424 and 2432 Davis Blvd.
Naples, Florida
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
22720480001
$360.40
CEB Case No. 2007-38
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Jaycees Foundation of Naples, Inc., and consents to
this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMESCOLETTA,CH~
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
item !\!O .16.A~
r'~:\Vembei 27 2007
Fiags 23 of 8Ll
This instrument prepared by:
JeffE. Wnght
Assistant County Attorney
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive, Ste 301
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim oflien arising out ofthe Code Enforcement Board
Order dated June 27, 2005, a certified copy of which was recorded on July 1, 2005 in
OR Book 3834 Pages 0709-0710 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida,
against the following described real property, and all other real and personal property
located in Collier County, owned by Reynolds Cavins and Edie Hunter, has been
discharged in full:
Reynolds Cavins and Edie Hunter
819 Church Strect
Copeland, Florida
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
01134802005
$5050.58
CEB Case No. 2004-044
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Reynolds Cavins and Edie Hunter, and consents to this
lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
lega fficiency:
-
,-',;}en:- c' !i::::.,Ti I'L, ! '.j,'-,_
I'~,=, /'::llDei' T' 20C;:
P'C19S 84 of 8Li
This instrument prepared by:
JeffE. Wnght
Assistant County Attorney
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive, Ste 301
Naples. Florida 341 04
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certity that the claim of lien arising out of the Code Enforcement Board
Order dated October 30, 2003, a certified copy of which was recorded on November 4,
2003 in O.R. Book 3436, Pages 0883 through 0885 of the Public Records of Collier
County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real and
personal property located in Collier County, owned by Avisai Gonzalez, has been
discharged in full:
A visai Gonzalez
5657 Jose Marti Drive
Naples, Florida
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
00456120000
$947.00
CEB Case No. 2003-038
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by A visai Gonzalez, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal ficiency:
, ,.
fV\.-X
/\genda Item I~o. 'J 6."\3
November 27,2007
Page 1 of 5
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
To accept final and unconditional conveyance of the water utility facility for Falling
Waters North Preserve
OBJECTIVE: The Board of County Commissioners, Ex-Officio the Governing Board of
the Collier County Water-Sewer District, to accept final and unconditional conveyance of
the water facilities.
CONSIDERATIONS:
1) The Developer of Falling Waters North Preserve has constructed the water facility
within dedicated easements to serve this development. See attached location map.
2) Preliminary acceptance of this water utility facility was approved by the Engineering
Services Department staff on September 10, 1998. At that time, the value of this
utility facility (assets) was $54,118.20 (see attachment[s]). Final Acceptance is in
accordance with Ordinance 2004-31, as amended.
-
3) Staff has recorded all preliminary acceptance documents in the public records of
Collier County, which have been reviewed and approved by the County Attorney's
office as to form and legal sufficiency.
4) The water facility has been operated and maintained by the Collier County Water-
Sewer District during, not less than, the required one (1) year warranty period.
5) A final inspection to discover defects in materials and workmanship has been
conducted by the Engineering Services Department staff and this facility has been
found to be satisfactory and acceptable.
6) All on-site water, pump station shall be owned and maintained by the owner.
7) The PUD Monitoring staff has reviewed this request in relation to possible issues
raised by the applicable Home Owners Association (HOA). Staff is unaware of any
issues that would serve to negate the recommendation to release the applicable
security.
FISCAL IMPACT: Approval of this Executive Summary will have no specific financial
impact. However, approval of this Executive Summary will result in the Collier County
Water-Sewer District receiving unconditional title to the utility facility, which at the time of
preliminary acceptance, had a total (undepreciated) value of $54,118.20.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: Approval of this Executive Summary will have no
growth management impact.
-
j.\.,genda item ~~o. 16p,J
November 27. 2007
Page 2 ('If 5
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: No additional legal review from the County Attorney
was required to complete this final acceptance.
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners, Ex-Officio the
Governing Board of the Collier County Water-Sewer District, to accept final and
unconditional conveyance of the water facility for Falling Waters North Preserve, and
authorize the County Manager, or his designee, to release any Utilities Performance
Security (UPS) to the Project Engineer or the Developer's designated agent.
PREPARED BY: Jodi P. Hughes, Engineering Technician
..'-
Item Number:
ttemSummary:
Meeting Date:
Page J of 1
Aocnc:a Item lfiA3
, 1\1(i'jerrl~)er
P::v:w
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIOI~ERS
16P.~'
T(. au.crt fine,' anu ur:~ mejit:on,,1 ~or'\lev31K.e of ft'-,,, \":"1\0: utiii!.v lacillt" 1m ," 011',,-;; Waters
I~urn~ P!,"~""v"
, 'I? 7 /~~J]{r' ~I ()[) (I,: ,\ M
-'."i'lllni5tr~tive A~si$!.am
Vl.tc
)'repllred By
,Io(j,l-<!Illlllllc,
Cnr"nlunityDllvt!lopf\l~mo,
En.'imn,n"ntaISeNrcec;
COEo; ",.1l9,,,,wrineJ ~;;en,;,.l1~
1(}!JI)I~(JG71:!:12:27 r'M
>l",',I":.ihnv
Vifaler0p'"-ati,,,.,,., Mlll1"GDl
D~rc
Appro\'ed By
Ubl";Utii'l<<'s
V'J,1:2'
l11U2UtF 10:;1,;:,1.1
;"I~t;:" '""n
')~;e
ApprowdBy
'J:ilitICf
"""" - 'fe,. ~"r
-'M,,'
'1.:1:-'(,'
"L1er.Jt"
"".'1"
'\IJproved By
A/;"::',,,t
:".n,n,unLI"d("0i(wnp"
.'f'l'i'f,"nlr\nntn'
.,. r')"'0k"",1f""'i
'\Ifl'roved By
\,':r".'''''''W1t3
"Mn'
, "''1'','.,1':''
'\PllrO>'Nl B~
);1lr1'1CW"',' r)"'.,,,iOi'''''''~'' &
~.n'fimflfn"'''::il' ~~"
"',nt
"iIV'
C Iwi">I,mc h~i :.'F; ''';(,
','i:iZDT ",iON
:"'nl,-,""'Iiln",,,
Dale
Approved B}'
f',,'fvAnn U''''~Ha'
Comn1unitv D~'vQlupment I>
Envi'onn1""',li Serv;c"'~
LOrl1t'\' i; L ~I":: D('o\lelopment REW;"'W
11Jn/ZO(\7454 PM
^llpro\'ed BJ'
J(I~",phK. Schmitt
CIHnrT1un;ry Developmenl &
!::,Wironm<;",laIS",rvices
Community DevololJm(mt &
Environmenta! S"rvic!'~ i\dl1.H1stralor
Dllte
'::'ommunit\' Devalopmen1. &
Environmcrmll Serv.~eH,t\dmin
1'1.11'112007 '12:14 PM
Public UtililJes EngmseringDimctm
Dale
Appro\'ed 8y
Ro,' B. Ander"," ,P.E
Public Uliliti....
PublicUtilit.e$ E:ngineerm9
11114J200712:27PM
Application~ Atl~IV:;l
D;>te
ApprovedB)'
OMS C:oordinata,
Adminrstrativ"Serv"'es
iniarmationTechl1o!ogy
1,114i:20074:35PM
Budget Analvst
Date
Approved By
Marl< IS<lckS(ln
County Manager'sOHicc
Office of M~n~geln'm\ & Budget
11115j20073,03PM
Coumy M"na~er
Date
Approved By
JamesV. Mudd
80ard ai County
Cornrn;ssionen>
County MJnager',;Offir.e
11/18IZ00712:23PM
file://C:\AgendaT est\Export\93. November%2027, %202007\ 16. o/020CONSENT%20AGEN..
11/2012007
.
FALLING WATERS NORTH PRESERVE
.
OTY UNIT PRICE TOTAL COST
POT ABLE WATER
8" PVC 1344 LF $11.80 $17.203.10
FIRE HYO WI VALVE 4 EA $1.750.00 $7.000.00
3" CONDUIT 60 IF $5.25 $315.00
SERVICES 1 lS '1.200.00 $1.200.00
8" BACKFlOW/METER 1 IS $23.000.00 $23,000.00
HOTTAP 1 EA '1.000.00 '1.000.00
PERM SAMPLE POINT 2 EA $1,100.00 $2,400.00
TOTAL WATER $54.118.10
.-
.~-:if-,
... -\,,,
{)f'
Aqenda Item hio. 16A3
- November 27, 2007
Page 4 of 5
r.vi ~_ Lf)
,----(0_
00
N,,>
0- Q)
ZN rn
_<11
-= 11-'0-
([;..Q
~;:::
me;;
~C>
.:=:0
Q;Z
:::n
<r
j,..( ~\'rIj'} Il~,JJ .J.
O\fO>lNOt_W1
r
;.,
,~\
~
I
II
!
;1;
Iii
i
~~
~;~
--",. _..~,
l-~;""IUL [u.s.")
K~ t
~8'"
/
~~
"'ili
~ ~;~
ih
,I."
~~
J
I
I
1
1
I
I
---- \
~
I
--4
z
wQ
~~
roU
o
~
I
I,
"
,.
j ,~'
!~~
------+----~'
~ .--~--_. I a~::'
".. 0 ..,w,_
,0 ../, ~.~
~z
Uo
w --
,r
0"
",0
0.'3
I ,: ~ ,',
~ .' l:!
I~~
"
,
"
,..'
"l
,
~'"
~:g
n
1'"
~~
D~ -
~~
,
~ > ~, hQll ..
!'; !
~~.. ~,
13'~ ~
;:..,
\ J~\'
,7'.
-------' '-
_.~'--
CULF
OF
ft
,
\ -,
,,------~.-._--
~'
/.........~
""
,~~ 1>
:t"'~..
~
l_~-'-
MEXICO
c..
<(
L
I.iJ
I-
CI)
'"
>
'"
'"
'"
'"
0:
'"
>-
'"
o
'"
"'
'"
""
>-
'"
'"
'"
'"
~
...
c..
<(
L
"
z
o
~
u
o
...J
,...~.-.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Agenda lIem Ho. 16A4
November 27, 2007
Page 1 of 53
Recommendation to approve the Release and Satisfaetions of Code Enforcement
Lien for payment received.
OBJECTIVE:
To approve execution and recording of the Release and Satisfactions of Liens,
acknowledging compliance and recovery of fines and fees related to prosecution of Code
Enforcement matters.
CONSIDERA TlONS:
The Following Nuisance Abatement Liens have becn satisfied.
Folio Number
Principal
paid
$::~.:.']5.0D
Resolution Owner Name
3CJ240720004
~!s-< 1 ''::::~lreilcP g bJf~)~cmorc, A.llrtJn":'c
r},G?J(i i~OCJri:l
~[;:~4~:,.nG
9f..37 ~~iC-J:snce ,s, Ai'::'>::-Jnmi'-.ii\:C:V'
r ~9C;"7;;:~.C)c)r:~<
:::':.'5:::"U\
~~OO~;-4CY ',-::i!()IT10"E: (;, k'i::lfi;j p,viic
94-613
2001-41
2000-374
2002-136
,.."._~-_._,,---_.~,~.~
2001-133
2002-389
96-395
--_..._._~"-_..
96-79
.,~---_...~_.__..
2003-446
,_____,..__'_.....M__
2002-445 Efv1C Holdings. Inc.
____~.~~~Z?._____ Jacqueline Eichen
....J904.143__.__l\Aart.'n_..~.lciJ.li.a.".5l-"':'l.amso':'___.__ .
~:J()Ci.3~'~:
200':-2~'~
2005-238
2000-379
2000-380
.._,..w___'__
94-615
96-384
~,_",_-~-,-_.~'..-
99-15
98.223
2003.395
-
5365.79
5406.48 :
51.912.75 i
I
$252.35 !
$381.921
527187 !
i
$24741)
$255.00 1
$2,785.31 I
""I
$2.785.31 i
I
$340.35 I
$315.10 i
I
$121.98 $376.98!
$144.39 $389.39 i
I
$321.04 $576.04 I
.'1
$12.13 $257(131
$30.35 $275.351
$20.00 . $27500 I
$2545 $28045 I
$32.59 $277.59 i
___ $4"1,!2..____j;299n :
:::iinmerk' !,; h/i':1ii:':l /':',VII"l
?S98'/~)2UO(!~)
S2S'-:,()(i
:::::lnrTl';'r;c 8 [./;;;IT,j,c,vil.=:;
~;S9()7 ~1:2()O(;:';
::;;'A~;.CC'
;::iiomerl;-;; &, !Via:'ia ,!wlla
359879200C3
259(;7920003
$255,00
'-i!omen!:i g, Mana ,1\viia
$255.00
lv1agdeiina Blanco
Ivlagdelina Blanco
Magdelina Blanco
Raymond Miller
Sylvia Miller
77262160009
77262200008
77262200008
$245.0CJ
$245.00
$1.08000
Alvaro & Veronica Buitrago
A. & Lydia Campanini
56796000009 5245.00
57654880001 $245.00
56806120002 $245.00
57738200002 $245.00
35992960003 $255.00
62094240005 $1,600,00
62094280007 $1,600.00
61840080009 $245.00
61840080009 $245.00
62256640003 $255.00
62256640003 $245.00
36449960005 $255.00
56944840008 $245.00
57369200002 $245.00
81621640004 $255.00
68300002627 $255.00
48173960000 $245.00
36385240009 $255.00
,~,-,~,-,----'~--~"-'-"-----"----~
Gunter Oligschlaeger Schierenbergstr
Leonard J. Bubri
A. & Lydia Campanlnl
Rose Casteel
Rose Casteel
Arthur & John Piper
. Kelly & James Mohn
Comerica Bank
Bernd & Karin David
Perla Dlaz
Cheryl Dlon
Interest
paid
S2e,15
~:,"\H)9
~"l1 .
S'iL <_
$1C-' u':,
S15Ci,f.S
:12357
$120)"9
$16148
$832.75
$735
$136.92
$26.87
$241
$000
$1.185.31
$1.185.31
$95.35
$70.10
Amount
paid
5373, 'I S
J;264.09
S;296.13
5;35:42
S;40C.99
2AC5,65
S;278.57
-~~OI~~O~- -~~~~r ~~~ ---.-- ---- -. -------~oli~ Nu~~~~----F,-rrnapaf ---Interest--Amounl
_______ ___ __ _ __ ____ _ _______________)Jaid___y~il:l.____P'!icl__
Marlene & Casimiro Egulzaball 57867160000 $245.00 $293.16 $538.16 :
Gaoip Corp_ 74412200000 $25500 $15.34 $270.34 :
Jesus Gomez (;2102840009 $25500 $35.61 $290.(;1 I
Jesus Gomez 62102840009 $24500 $15(;.72 $401.72
Jesus Gomez (;2102840009 $255.00 $'132.36 $387.36
Jesus Gomez 62102840009 $25500 $79.03 $334.03
Jesus Gomez 62102840009 $245.00 $156.96 $401.96
90-552
2002-490
2005-237
2001-145
2002-193
2003-278
2000-321
94-312
2002-491
2002-2::\2
98-226
2000-3f;5
2DOS..2~;7
:~OC(~-6~;
RS:'::I}:
;"~'<J,)r)
..., ,....,,
~j~.;,:;,)(
S4-4Ji
95-25i
95.203
2004-151
Frank & Katherine Gorman
Charlie Mae Gray, Aka Charlie Mae
Black & Willie JGlmes (Biack)
56794760008
~)64U2760002
HI\JH \/en1ures, A Fiondc,:; C;ene;'al ptn
3C325040007
Guy J, larussI, ET UX
557000400U1
Roc::::o tz.zo. Sf-\.
b2573920008
Mar~arila f\/iU:1Q?
IJ04ifOOOOOOO
Jci HO::JDiti'Jlitv. ~n,:
7021or:;40DOF
I\.'illf~.:l:?i ::',:,LIC;ic'. ;,;:-J:)I:'
57676360004
:-.;tu;::" ~\'v.~I\.";
~',f;~' '1 t ~)JC!OI)c;
i;38b:)OgOOUC;
:~;:)8C:::;'12JD ."
~,~+:i0 8 ,;:JrrI ~ ~ iJIV'
r:IC';:'J!-( '-lvf.
._.,_lj. 0,()4ClUC:'
T:lomas & L.~)i-i 1\,r,;:FI'O')-i
577 ~,7:5600(}2
Thomas & LOi.i i\-1anev
E\-nT1560002
Thomas & Lori rv1aney
Miranda Melendez
57737560002
3(;371040006
Total
--.-.--.----- ~~--_._....~~_..._-_.._--
Aoenda Item 1\]0, .16/\4
~- November 27, 2007
Page 2 of ~:3
$24500
$192.00
$437.00
$255 00
S17.89
$272.89
:;;390,00
$6639
$456.39
$290.00
$23.08
OC
3;245.00
$3'! 3.0e
:D2<:15.cn
:I;255 DC':
~295 ,84
&;40,['4
(~:;.~~. DC!
'.~f; (1 -;, '1:?
><:::).:': ';.:~
.., /U.:!(;
;;; li?-::h(:;
S:~i :".h('
'<:'.~:=:.n!)
~~: i r ::) '--:J
S::::\E,:::'.2(
:i:::;:.:S.(i(;
:1,3';::': \)
S-:7:~OC)-'
:E9~:j:;. (;~;
'.""''''''d_
<1":\':" f .~;''':i
\.;,;.j:,:i.Sl~)
~2450(j
$f."! 2.72
$273.1'2.
S24~).ao
$246.89
S;49'1.89
$245.00 $2'lO.18 S455.18
$25500 $45.86 $300.86
__ $17. 0 7:J.oO___'Bl.2.o~...:;:>.5. 579.47
FISCAL IMPACT:
The only expense incurred by the County is the cost of recording the Release and
Satisfaction, which is to be approximately $10.00 per release, totaling $500.00. Funds
are budgeted and available in the current fiscal year in the Code Enforcement budget. The
amount shown above in the "total column" reflects the total paid with interest that
accrued.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT:
This request will have no impact on the County's Growth Management Plan.
LEGAL CONSIDERATION:
This request has been reviewed for legal sufficiency and has no outstanding legal
considerations.
RECOMMENDA nON:
That the Board of County Commissioners approve the Release and Satisfactions of the
Code Enforcement Liens.
,-
PREPARED BY: Shirley M. Garcia, Administrative Secretary - Code Enforcement
Page 1 of 1
Agenda Hem j(jA4
!'icwember 2007
::>898 oi 5:;
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD Or: COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Item Number:
Item Summary:
Meeting Date:
!C/O,"
F,,"I(dSii':mtlS81,siaCliorlsGtL'er
':::)
~<~, AM
I'rerared By
Shine\! Gan;;.,
'-':'?"rlitI0n'.Cr,Q"ltn.,to'
flJ!&
Lorl"rnUnIL'LJ",vt'lopmell~&
"flv'CGomentaiServicDs
;:~Od" E.ntorco"meni
:'Si?DC"i 'J,04'41 ,\M
Approved 8y
M"ri",nc St&W~!.t Exe<;ulivL 5."cretil!)'
U~t!'
(;ommwlily [",v"lopm.-' ,1' g c~om!\lu"itl' r:.l<)V[)IDl'mlCm I:;
.i8I2007a:!\4I'iV'
EnVCf",rmcJ1ia! S Hv"'e,, ["',irotl1lwllt;;! Se','vIU]-' i,drn-"
^rprovt'd By
.)uc'iC',"q
".)....';<110'1"""',;;'\'...
~j::12
':"nmHCl!" jJ"'ei3;:,m,,,,'
',"Plr~"'''1V ::J,\'('lopr.'lLm &
13i2i(.," 1'-'PIt.
'em,,:'
''''''~U\rJ .",,'''1'.'('' 'cer..",
AllprnverJ B~
''''n'.'cJc"'''''',P;1'',,
'I'
",".".....
'''''1'0'''>\''
\ pprov('(j I~)
:....,'",.....".",...";.\.,.3
ApproverJ B~
',uC'rciin'<O'
;',",11 ;,.;.llc,n....... i,."-.,;'.,,,y
"J1'<'
f<dmm'~1r~i,v,,' ,~("cvi~"t
".tormwion Tc~I'1f1t1i;,f,'
1'i'14Inil]~" :\f.PPiI
Apl1rOVNI B~'
r;",~ri' i~"cksc,f'
budget A,IMiyst
Dille
C:oun:y M:>nager's Ofl'"c
OftIC<"0' Managemcn!& Budgei
11115120078:31 AM
Approved By
jame~V. Mudd
CQUl1ty Manager
n,lle
BOlirtiofCmmt\'
Commissioners
CoUnty Manager'~ Offlce
1111~i20tJ7 fi..41> PM
file://C:\AgendaTest\Export\93- November%.2027 ,%202007\ 16. %20CONSENT%20AGEN. _ 11/20/2007
Agenda Item No. 16A4
November 27. 2007
Page 4 of .53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 99- 11 of the
Board of County Commissioner dated January 12, 1999, a certified copy of which was
recorded on February 22, 1999, in O.R. Book 2515, Pages 0906-0907, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Clarence &
Alexandra Abrams, has been discharged in full:
Clarence & Alexandra Abrams
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
36240720004
$345.00
80424-053
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Clarence & Alexandra Abrams, and consents to this
lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLEIT A, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
_Aqenda item No, '16A.4
.. November 27; 2007
5 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Ddve
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 99-37 of the
Board of County Commissioner dated January 12, 1999, a certified copy of which was
recorded on February 22, 1999, in O.R. Book 2515, Pages ]035-1036, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property located in Collier County. owned by Clarence &
Alexandra Abrams, has been discharged in full:
Clarence & Alexandra Abrams
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
36240720004
$245.00
80708-027
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Clarenee & Alexandra Abrams, and consents to this
lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLiER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
~
Agellda Item t\lo. 16A4
November 27, 2007
Page 6 of 53
This instrument prepared by;
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2003-406 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated November 18, 2003, a certified copy of which
was recorded on December 12,2003, in O.R. Book 3462, Pages 1651-1652, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property loeated in Collier County, owned by Filomeno & Maria
Avila, has been discharged in full:
Filomeno & Maria Avila
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
35987920003
$255.00
2305
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Filomeno & Maria A vila, and consents to this lien
being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E, BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to fonn and
legal sufficiency:
~
JeffE W' t
Assis . ounty Attorney
Aoenda Item No. 16A4
"November 27, 2007
Page 7 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code: Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples. Florida 341 04
(239) 252.2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim oflien arising from Resolution No. 2003-66 of the
Board of County Commissioner dated February 11, 2003, a eertified copy of which was
recorded on March 06, 2003, in O.R. Book 3233, Pages 2116-2117, of the Public Records
of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real
and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Fi10meno & Maria J. Avila,
has been discharged in full:
Filomeno & Maria J. Avila
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
35987920003
$255.00
2236
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Filomeno & Maria Avila, and consents to this lien
being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
By:
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Agenda Item I~o. oj 6/\4
November 27, 2007
Page B of S3
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2000-399 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated November 14, 2000, a certified copy of which
was recorded on December 05, 2000, in O.R. Book 2750, Pages 2035-2036, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Filomeno & Maria
Avila, has been discharged in full:
Filomeno & Maria A vila
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
35987920003
$245.00
1437
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Filomeno & Maria Avila, and consents to this lien
being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
\
Jeff .
Assis
Agenda Item No. 15A4
November 27, 2007
Page 9 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SA TlSF ACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2001-274 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated July 31, 2001, a certified copy of which was
recorded on August 21, 2001, in O.R. Book 2879, Pages 0134-0135, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Filomeno & Maria
J. Avila, has been discharged in full:
Filomeno & Maria J. Avila
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
35987920003
$255.00
1767
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Filomeno & Maria J. Avila, and consents to this lien
being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
~
Jeff . t
Assis t County Attorney
Agenda item No. '16A4
November '27. 2007
Page .; 0 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 341 04
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2005-238 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated June 28, 2005, a certified copy of which was
recorded on July 22, 2005, in O.R. Book 3850, Pages 1409-1410, of the Public Records
of Collier County, Florida, against the following deseribed real property, and all other real
and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Filomeno Avila & Maria.l.
A vila, has been discharged in full:
Filomeno Avila & Maria J. Avila
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
35987920003
$255.00
2716
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Filomeno Avila & Maria J. Avila, and consents to this
lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Agenda Item No. 16A4
November 27, 2007
Page 11 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Depanment
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 341 04
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to eertity that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2000-379 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated November 14, 2000, a certified copy of whieh
was recorded on December 05, 2000, in O_R. Book 2750, Pages 1997-1998, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Magdelina Blanco,
has been discharged in full:
Magdelina Blanco
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
77262160009
$245.00
1313
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-deseribed real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Magdelina Blanco, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
~
JeffE. W' t
Assistart ounty Attorney
Aaenda ilern No. 16A4
-. Novernber 27, 2007
Page 12 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2000-380 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated November 14, 2000. a certified eopy ofwhieh
was recorded on December 05, 2000, in O.R. Book 2750, Pages 1999-2000, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Magdelina Blanco,
has been discharged in full:
Magdelina Blanco
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
77262200008
$245.00
1312
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Magdelina Blanco, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATIEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Agenda Item No. 'j 6.1\4
November 27.2007
Page 13 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Depanment
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 341 04
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the e1aim of lien arising from Resolution No. 94-615 of the
Board of County Commissioner dated September 6, 1994, a certified copy of which was
recorded on October 6, 1994, in O.R. Book 1992, Pages 0410-041 I, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Magdelina Blanco,
has been discharged in full:
Magdelina Blanco
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
77262200008
$1.080
207] 5-060
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Magdelina Blanco, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Agenda Item 1'0. 161\4
November 27. 2007
Page 14 of S3
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to eertifY that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 96-384 of the
Board of County Commissioner dated September 3, 1996, a certified copy of which was
recorded on October 4, 1996, in O.R. Book 2236, Pages 0141-0142, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property loeated in Collier County, owned by Raymond A. Miller,
has been discharged in full:
Raymond A. Miller
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
56796000009
$245.00
60503-051
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Raymond A. Miller, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
C
Agenda Item f~o. 16A4
November 27. 2007
Page 15 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252.2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to eertify that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 99-15 of the
Board of County Commissioner dated January 12, 1999, a certified copy of which was
recorded on February 22, 1999, in O.R. Book 2515, Pages 0914-0915, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Sylvia S. Miller, has
been discharged in full:
Sylvia S. Miller
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
57654880001
$245.00
60513-049
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-<iescribed real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Sylvia S. Miller, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
/
~
Agenda Item No. '\6,b\4
November 27. 2007
Page 16 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252.2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to eertify that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 98. 223 of the
Board of County Commissioner dated June 23, 1998, a certified copy of which was
recorded on July 27,1998, in O.R. Book 2444, Pages 2432-2433, of the Publie Records
of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real
and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Guenter Oligschlaeger, has
been diseharged in full:
Guenter Oligschlaeger
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
56806120002
$245.00
70408-061
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Guenter Oligsch1aeger, and consents to this lien being
diseharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
. t
County Attorney
Agenda Item r,o. 16A4
November 27. 2007
Page 17 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnoid
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 96- 184 of the
Board of County Commissioner dated April 2, 1996, a certified copy of which was
recorded on May 06,1996, in O.R. Book 2179, Pages 0066-0067, of the Public Records
of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real
and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Leonard J. Bubri, has been
discharged in full:
Leonard J. Bubri
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
57738200002
$245.00
51129-015
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and ail other real and personal
property owned by Leonard J. Bubri, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficieney:
~
JeffE. W "ght
Assist. County Attorney
Agenda item No, 16A4
November 27.2007
Page 18 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N, Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34 I 04
(239) 252.2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2003-395 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated November 18, 2003, a certified copy of which
was recorded on December 12, 2003, in O.R. Book 3462, Pages 1627-1628, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Alvaro and
Veronica Buitrago, has been discharged in full:
Alvaro and Veronica Buitrago
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
35992960003
$255.00
2297
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Alvaro and Veronica Buitrago, and consents to this lien
being discharged of reeord.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Jefff;);iX
Assistant County Attorney
Agenda Item No. 16M
November 27, 2007
Page 19 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 94-614 of the
Board of County Commissioner dated September 6, 1994, a certified copy of which was
recorded on October 6, 1994, in O.R. Book 1992, Pages 0408-0409, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other rea) and personal property located in Collier County, owned by A. Campanini &
Lydia 1. Campanini, has been discharged in full:
A. Campanini & Lydia 1.. Campanini
L>iioNo.:
Cc'st:
Reference:
62094240005
$1,600.00
20714-061
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by A. Campanini & Lydia 1.. Campanini, and consents to
this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
,t.,genda item No. 16,L\,4
November 27 2007
Page 20 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to eertify that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 94-613 of the
Board of County Commissioner dated September 6, 1994, a certified copy of which was
recorded on October 6, 1994, in O.R. Book 1992, Pages 0406-0407, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property located in Collier County, owned by A. Campanini &
Lydia L. Campanini, has been discharged in full:
A. Campanini & Lydia L. Campanini
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
62094280007
$1,600.00
20714-051
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by A. Campanini & Lydia L. Campanini, and consents to
this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
ll.genda item No. i6A4
November 27, 2007
Page 21 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 252.2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2001-41 of the
Board of County Commissioner dated February 13, 2001, a certified copy of which was
recorded on March 7, 2001, in O.R. Book 2787, Pages 0763-0764, of the Public Records
of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real
and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Rose L. Casteel, has been
discharged in full:
Rose L. Casteel
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
61840080009
$245.00
1103
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above.described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Rose L. Casteel, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Ar18noa Item No. '16A4
~ November 27.2007
Page 22 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252.2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2000-374 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated November 14, 2000, a certified copy of which
was recorded on December 5, 2000, in O.R. Book 2750, Pages 1987- I 988, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Rose L. Casteel, has
been diseharged in full:
Rose L. Casteel
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
61840080009
$245.00
1578
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Rose L. Casteel, and consents to this lien being
discharged ofreeord.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
0\ \~
~
Assis County Attorney
Agenda Item No. 16M
November 27.2007
Page 23 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2002-136 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated March 12,2002, a certified copy of which was
recorded on April 2, 2002, in O.R. Book 3010, Pages 2762-2763, of the Public Reeords
of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real
and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Arthur R. & John A. Piper.
has been discharged in full:
Arthur R. & JohnA. Piper
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
62256640003
$255.00
2040
Ibe undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Arthur R. & John A. Piper, and consents to this lien
being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Aoenda Hern !\jo.16,l\4
L November 27. 2007
Page 24 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Depanment
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 252.2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2001-133 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated April 24, 2001, a certified copy of which was
recorded on May 16,2001, in O.R. Book 2825, Pages 1886-1887, of the Public Records
of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real
and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Kelly Ann & James O. Mohn
II, has been discharged in full:
Kelly Ann & James O. Mohn II
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
62256640003
$245.00
1697
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Kelly Ann & James O. Mohn II, and consents to this
lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
By:
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
~
Je . ri t
Assis t County Attorney
.Agenda item No. 16M
November 27.2007
Page 25 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Fiorida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to eertify that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2002-389 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated September 24, 2002, a certified copy of which
was recorded on October 15, 2002, in O.R. Book 313 I, Pages 2308-2309, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Comerica Bank, has
been discharged in full:
Comerica /Bank
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
36449960005
$255.00
2167
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Comerica Bank, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Agenda Item l'-lo. 16.1\4
November 27.2007
Page 26 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to eertify that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 96-395 of the
Board of County Commissioner dated September 3, 1996, a certified eopy of which was
recorded on October 4, 1996, in O.R. Book 2236, Pages 0163-0164, of the Public
Reeords of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Bernd David &
Karin David, has been discharged in full:
Bernd David & Karin David
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
56944840008
$245.00
60510-021
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Bernd David & Karin David, and consents to this lien
being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
0,
JeffE W gh
Assis ounty Attorney
I
Agenda Item I~o. 16A4
November 27 2007
Page 27 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
'This is to certifY that the elaim of lien arising from Resolution No. 96.79 of the
Board of County Commissioner dated February 20, 1996, a certified copy of which was
recorded on March 22,1996, in O.R. Book 2161, Pages 2136-2137, of the Publie Records
of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real
and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Perla Diaz, has been
discharged in full:
Perla Diaz
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
57369200002
$245.00
50809-072
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Perla Diaz, and consents to this lien being discharged
ofrecord.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
~
JeffE. 'g
Assist County Attorney
Agenda :tem No. 16A4
November 27. 2007
Page 28 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples. Florida 341 04
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2003-446 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated December 16, 2003, a certified copy of which
was recorded on January 8, 2004, in O.R. Book 3480, Pages 1641-1642, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Cheryl 1.. Dion, has
been discharged in full:
Cheryl 1.. Dion
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
81621640004
$255.00
2380
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Cheryl 1.. Dion, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
(
Agenda Item No. 16.1\4
November 27. 2007
Page 29 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2002-445 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated November 5, 2002, a certified copy of which
was recorded on November 27, 2002, in O.R. Book 3163, Pages 0734-0735, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property located in Collier County, owned by EMC Holdings,
Inc., has been discharged in full:
EMC Holdings Inc.
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
68300002627
$255.00
2179
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by EMC Holdings Inc., and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Agenda 11em !\jo. 16";4
November 27. 2007
Page 30 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 95-677 of the
Board of County Commissioner dated December 12, 1995, a eertified copy of which was
recorded on January 16, 1996, in O.R. Book 2138, Pages 1300-1301, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property loeated in Collier County, owned by Jaequeline Anne
Eichen, has been discharged in full:
Jacqueline Anne Eichen
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
48]73960000
$245.00
50615-058
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Jacqueline Anne Eichen, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
.-
t
t County Attorney
Agenda Item r~o. 16A4
November 27.2007
Page 31 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2004-143 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated April 27, 2004, a certified copy of which was
recorded on May 2, 2004, in O.R. Book 3568, Pages 3632-3633, of the Public Records of
Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real
and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Martin 1. & Lillian E.
Benjamson, has been discharged in full:
Martin l. & Lillian E. Benjamson
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
36385240009
$255.00
2481
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Martin 1. & Lillian E. Benjamson, and eonsents to this
lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficieney:
~
JeffE. 'g
Assis County Attorney
Aqenda item No. '16A4
- November 27 < 2007
Page 32 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 90-552 of the
Board of County Commissioner dated November 20, 1990, a certified copy of which was
recorded on December 211990, in O.R. Book 1580, Pages 1712-1713, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Marlene Eguizabal
& Casimiro Eguizabal, has been discharged in full:
Marlene Eguizabal & Casimiro Eguizabal
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
57867160000
$245.00
W89-3393
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Marlene Eguizabal & Casimiro Eguizabal, and
consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
By:
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
/"genda Item r.Jo. 16M
November 27, 2007
Page 33 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2002-490 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated November 17,2002, a certified copy ofwhieh
was recorded on January 9, 2003, in O.R. Book 3192, Pages 2964-2965, of the Public
Reeords of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property loeated in Collier County, owned by Ganip Corp., has
been discharged in full:
Ganip Corp.
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
74412200000
$255,00
2]71
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Ganip Corp., and consents to this lien being discharged
of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Jeff .
Assis
Agenda Item No. 16A4
November 27. 2007
Page 34 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SA TISF ACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2005-237 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated June 28, 2005, a certified eopy of which was
recorded on July 22, 2005, in O.R. Book 3850, Pages 1407-1408, of the Public Records
of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other rea!
and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Jesus Gomez, has been
discharged in full:
Jesus Gomez
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
62102840009
$255.00
2695
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Jesus Gomez, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
By:
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
':2:::
Agenda Item No. 16A4
November 27.2007
Page 35 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to eertifY that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2001-145 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated April 24, 2001, a certified copy of which was
reeorded on May 16,2001, in O.R. Book 2825, Pages 1910-1911, of the Public Records
of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real
and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Jesus Gomez, has been
discharged in full:
.r esus Gomez
Fotio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
62]02840009
$245.00
1691
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Jesus Gomez, and consents to this lien being
discharged of reeord.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
,lJ.,genda item No. "16/\4
November 27. 2007
Page 36 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to eertify that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2002-193 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated April 23, 2002, a certified copy of which was
recorded on May 14, 2002, in O.R. Book 3036, Pages 1498-1499, of the Public Records
of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real
and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Jesus Gomez, has been
diseharged in full:
Jesus Gomez
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
62102840009
$255.00
2104
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Jesus Gomez, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
By:
Approved as to form and
legal suffieiency:
Agenda Item No. 16A4
November 27. 2007
Page 37 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2003-278 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated September 9, 2003, a certified copy of which
was recorded on September 15,2003, in O.R. Book 3396, Pages 2750-2751, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Jesus Gomez, has
been discharged in full:
Jesus Gomez
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
62102840009
$255.00
2286
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Jesus Gomez, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
~~:x
JeffE. gilt
Assistan ounty Attorney
,L.,genda Item f\]o. 16,L\4
November 27, 2007
?age 38 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2000-321 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated September 26, 2000, a certified copy of which
was recorded on October 17, 2000, in O.R. Book 2732, Pages 3340-3341, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Jesus Gomez, has
been discharged in full:
Jesus Gomez
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
62102840009
$245.00
1254
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Jesus Gomez, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
day of
,2007.
Dated this
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
/. ,
( r-'--+-
ttl;i'-/~
JeffE. ri t I
Assistan ounty Attorney
Agenda Item No. 16M
r,ovember 27, 2007
Page 39 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Napies. Florida 34) 04
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 94-312 of the
Board of County Commissioner dated May 3, 1994, a eertified copy of which was
recorded on June 2, 1994, in O.R. Book 1953, Pages 1412-1413, of the Public Records of
Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real
and personal property loeated in Collier County, owned by Frank W. Gorman &
Katherine M. Gorman, has been discharged in full:
Frank W. Gorman & Katherine M. Gorman
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
56794760008
$245.00
30708-017
The undersigned is authorized 10 and does hereby release this lien as 10 the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Frank W. Gorman & Katherine M. Gorman, and
consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
~
Jeff w,'g
Assist t County Attorney
Agenda I[em !'~o, ~16,4A
- November 27. 2007
Page 40 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2002-491 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated Deeember 17, 2002, a certified copy of which
was recorded on January 9, 2003, in O.R. Book 3192, Pages 2966-2967, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Charlie Mae Gray
(a.k.a Charlie Mae Black & Willie James Black), has been discharged in full:
Charlie Mae Gray (a.k.a Charlie Mae Black & Willie James Black)
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
56402760002
$255 00
2184
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Charlie Mae Gray (a.k.a Charlie Mae Black & Willie
Jarnes Black), and consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
C It
~
Assis t County Attorney
Agenda Item No. 16A4
November 27. 2007
Page 41 of 53
This instrument prepared by;
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim. of lien arising from Resolution No. 2002-232 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated May 28, 2002, a certified copy of which was
recorded on June 19,2002, in O.R. Book 3058, Pages 0200-0201, of the Public Records
ofCoJlier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real
and personal property located in Collier County, owned by HNH Ventures, a Florida
General Partnership, has been discharged in full:
HNH Ventures, a Florida General Partnership
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
36325040007
$390.00
2110
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by HNH Ventures, a Florida General Partnership, and
consents to this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
right
t County Attorney
,L,genda Item No. "i6A4
November 27. 2007
Page 42 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 98-226 of the
Board of County Commissioner dated June 23, 1998, a certified copy of which was
reeorded on July 27,1998, in O.R. Book 2444, Pages 2438-2439, of the Public Records
of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real
and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Guy J. Iarussi ET UX, has
been discharged in full:
Guy J. Iarussi ET UX
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
55700040001
$290.00
71 0 I 0-027
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Guy J. Iarussi ET UX, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
~
JeffE. W i
Assista County Attorney
Agenda lterrlNo. 16A4
November 27. 2007
Page 43 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2000-395 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated November 14, 2000, a certified copy of which
was recorded on December 5, 2000, in O.R. Book 2750, Pages 2027-2028, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Rocco Izzo Sr., has
been discharged in full:
Rocco Izzo Sr.
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
62573920008
$245.00
] 179
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Rocco Izzo Sr., and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Aaenda Item 1\]0" 16,A,4
, November 27. 2007
Page 44 of 53
This instrument prepared by
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2005-297 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated September 13, 2005, a certified copy of which
was recorded on October 11,2005, in O.R. Book 3908, Pages 3351-3352, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all
other real and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Margarita Munoz,
has been discharged in full:
Margarita Munoz
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
00440000000
$255.00
2684
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Margarita Munoz, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Agenda Item No. 16A4
November 27. 2007
Page 45 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 252.2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim oflien arising from Resolution No. 2002-65 of the
Board of County Commissioner dated February 12, 2002, a certified copy of which was
recorded on March 6, 2002, in O.R. Book 2993, Pages 3092-3093, of the Public Reeords
of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real
and personal property located in Collier County, owned by J .S. Hospitality, has been
diseharged in full:
J.S. Hospitality
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
76210640006
$345.00
2025
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by J.S. Hospitality, and consents to this lien being
discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORlDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
~
Assistant County Attorney
Aqenda Item No. 'i 6A4
- November 27. 2007
Page 46 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to eertiry that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 89-336 of the
Board of County Commissioner dated October 31, 1989, a certified copy of which was
recorded on December 4, 1989, in O.R. Book 1488, Pages 1332-1333, of the Public
Records of Collier County, Florida, against the following deseribed real property, and all
other real and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Michael J. Kaplan
& Patricia F. Kaplan, has been discharged in full:
Michael J. Kaplan & Patricia F. Kaplan
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
57676360004
S120.00
W880-0947/INV# 07597
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Michael J. Kaplan & Patricia F. Kaplan. and consents
to this lien being discharged of reeord.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal suffieieney:
C \ ..'
Jo~
Assis t County Attorney
Agenda Item No. 16,4.4
November 27.2007
Page 47 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 96-536 of the
Board of County Commissioner dated December 3, 1996, a certified copy of which was
recorded on January 3,1997, in O.R. Book 2268, Pages 0114-01 15, of the Public Records
of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real
and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Stuart O. Kaye Tr., has been
discharged in full:
Stuart O. Kaye Tr.
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
36114520000
$245.00
630717-157
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Stuart O. Kaye Tr., and consents to this lien being
diseharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
C \''1=
Jeff. nght
Assist t County Attorney
Aqenda !tem No. 16A4
.. November 27. 2007
Page 48 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
28001\.. Horseshoe Drive, Ste 301
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 213-2939
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 91-240 of the
Board of County Commissioners dated March 12, 1991, a certified copy of which was
recorded on April 22, 1991, in O.R. Book 1609, Pages 1784-1785. of the Public Records
of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property. and all other real
and personal property located in Collier County. owned by Cade and Carrie C. Long, has
been discharged in full.
Cade & Carrie C. Long
Folio I"o.
Cost:
OSM1"o:
63863080000 I 63863120009
$335.00
90-09-09554
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property. and all other real and personal
property owned by Cade and Carrie C. Long, and consents to thi s lien
being discharged of rccord.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
.
.4aenda !tem No 'I6.A.4
~'r-Jovernber 27'. 2007
Page liS of 53
This Instrument Prepared By:
Shirley Garcia. Administrative Secretary
Code Enforcement Department
2800 North Horseshoe Drive
Naples, FL 34104
(239) 213-2994
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS: That the BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA is the owner and holder of
certain lien by Resolution No. 94-638 against:
Richard Love
4608 Dominion Rd.
Napies. FI 33962
The lien was recorded on 10/06/94 in Official Records Book 1992, Page 0457. in the
Official Records of Collier Counly. State of Florida. The lien secures the principal sum of
Nine Hundred Ninety-Eight and zero cents. plus accrued interest and penalties, if any.
and imposes certain obligations against real property situated In Collier County, Florida,
which property IS descfibed as follows:
AVALON EST UNIT 1 BL~: 7 LOT 9
Cost: $998.00
Reference: 40519-030 Folio 22625040009
Collier County, a political subdivision of the State of Florida. by execution of this
Satisfaction of Lien, acknowledges payment as full satisfaction of the lien and hereby
cancels said lien.
The Clerk of the Circuit Court is hereby directed to record this Release and Satisfaction
of Lien in the Official Records of Collier County, Florida, to acknowledge that the lien
ceases to exist.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County,
Florida, acting through its Chairman, directs execution and recording of the Release and
Satisfaction of Lien, by action of the Board on this day of
,2007.
ATTEST
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA. Chairman
Agenda liem I~o. 16/"4
November 27. 2007
Page 50 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 94-431 of the
Board of County Commissioner dated June 21, 1994, a certified copy of which was
recorded on July 25, 1994, in O.R. Book 1970, Pages 0682-0683, of the Public Records
of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real
and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Thomas P. Maney Jr. & Lori
S. Maney, has been discharged in full:
Thomas P. Maney Jr. & Lori S. Maney
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
57737560002
$245.00
31 ] 08-034
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Thomas P. Maney Jr. & Lori S. Maney, and consents to
this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
, Deputy Clerk
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
By:
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
c! '~-
Jeff~
Assis County Attorney
Agenda Ilem No. 16.A4
November 27.2007
Page 51 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252.2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 95-252 of the
Board of County Commissioner dated April 4, 1995, a certified copy of which was
recorded on May 5,1995, in O.R. Book 2056, Pages 0261-0263, of the Public Records of
Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real
and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Thomas P. Maney Jr. & Lori
S. Maney, has been discharged in full:
Thomas P. Maney Jr. & Lori S. Maney
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
57737560002
$245.00
41101-0]0
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Thomas P. Maney Jr. & Lori S. Maney, and consents to
this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
J; ~.
Jef'~
Assistant County Attorney
f.\oenda item !'\lo. 16l'c4
- November 7..7. 2007
Page 52 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certify that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 96-203 of the
Board of County Commissioner dated April 23, 1996, a certified copy of which was
recorded on May 24,1996, in O.R. Book 2187, Pages 1951-1952, of the Public Records
of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real
and personal property located in Collier County. owned by Thomas P. Maney Jr. & Lori
S. Maney. has been discharged in full:
Thomas P. Maney .Ir. & Lori S. Maney
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
577J75600C2
$245.00
51129-011
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Thomas P. Maney .Ir. & Lori S. Maney, and consents to
this lien being discharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
\
Aaenda item No. .)6,Li.A
.~ November 27.2%7
Page 53 of 53
This instrument prepared by:
Michelle Arnold
Code Enforcement Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples. Florida 34104
(239) 252-2440
RELEASE AND SATISFACTION OF LIEN
This is to certifY that the claim of lien arising from Resolution No. 2004-151 of
the Board of County Commissioner dated April 27, 2004, a certified copy of whieh was
recorded on May 20, 2004, in O.R. Book 3568, Pages 3648-3649, of the Public Records
of Collier County, Florida, against the following described real property, and all other real
and personal property located in Collier County, owned by Miranda Melendez, has been
discharged in full:
Miranda Melendez
Folio No.:
Cost:
Reference:
36371040006
$255.00
2457
The undersigned is authorized to and does hereby release this lien as to the
whole of the above-described real property, and all other real and personal
property owned by Miranda Melendez, and consents to this lien being
diseharged of record.
Dated this
day of
,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Agenda Item No. 16A5
November 27. 2007
Page 1 of 5
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
To accept final and unconditional conveyance of the water utility facility for Calusa
Island Village
OBJECTIVE: The Board of County Commissioners, Ex-Officio the Governing Board of
the Collier County Water-Sewer District, to accept final and unconditional conveyance of
the water facilities.
CONSIDERATIONS:
1) The Developer of Calusa Island Village has constructed the water facility within
dedicated easements to serve this development. See attached location map.
2) Preliminary acceptance of this water utility facility was approved by the Engineering
Services Department staff on April 4, 2005. At that time, the value of this utility facility
(assets) was $16,823.94 (see attachment[s]). Final Acceptance is in accordance with
Ordinance 2004-31, as amended.
3) Staff has recorded all preliminary acceptance documents in the public records of
Collier County, which have been reviewed and approved by the County Attorney's
office as to form and legal sufficiency.
4) The water facility has been operated and maintained by the Collier County Water-
Sewer District during, not less than, the required one (1) year warranty period.
5) A final inspection to discover defects in materials and workmanship has been
conducted by the Engineering Services Department staff and this facility has been
found to be satisfactory and acceptable.
6) The water utility infrastructure connected beyond the master meter is owned and
maintained by the owner.
7) The PUD Monitoring staff has reviewed this request in relation to pOSSible issues
raised by the applicable Home Owners Association (HOA). Staff is unaware of any
issues that would serve to negate the recommendation to release the applicable
secu rity.
FISCAL IMPACT: Approval of this Executive Summary will have no specific financial
impact. However, approval of this Executive Summary will result in the Collier County
Water-Sewer District receiving unconditional title to the utility facility, which at the time of
preliminary acceptance, had a total (undepreciated) value of $16,823.94.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: Approval of this Executive Summary will have no
growth management impact.
/\genda Item No. 16A5
November 27. 2CJ07
Page 2 of 5
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: No additional legal review from the County Attorney
was required to complete this final acceptance.
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners, Ex-Officio the
Governing Board of the Collier County Water-Sewer District, to accept final and
unconditional conveyance of the water facility for Calusa Island Village, and authorize the
County Manager, or his designee, to release any Utilities Performance Security (UPS) to
the Project Engineer or the Developer's designated agent.
PREPARED BY: Jodi Pannullo Hughes, Engineering Technician
Item Number:
ItemSummllry:
Meeting Dllte:
Page I of 1
,L,08noa 11em i-~o 16A
'Novembec27,200
hJ[J83of
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
I ('\ 1\ [~
;' ,lccepl fil.al C!,v:: unumdl'I:}r;ai ::Ollv")' i)'l(:e ()f ~!k w,Her utili I\-' fa,-lllt\-' fe' C,,,,iusa ,~;I,ln(1
" ',I i "~Ji'
I"" ::00'- 9,00 OOArvI
I'rcparcd Dl'
Uni",
,JodiPanflUII(;
C;emnlUnity DpvelQpment &
;:nvironmental Ser/ic"'~
AdmirHstrlltiv<!^';SI"ti<1l1
LLl,,::> ['l9in(,,'ri,-'g ,)~'r,'i(;eh
iO!2J/?0071:0(i:5ZPM
~'G1()
Arrroved D"
JU<:il';.o",,,
C)peratl'_'''~ l,m'I;'~t
;:ClfnmUtl,ry D(".,dopn,nt 8 (':cmmr-,nilv L)s,Cloo1n0nl :l
enVi"o"rnctltv! ,,,:.'r~in"""d1ni'1
10r;;:' ~'O();- : '5:, PM
lCr,virotlIlW"W!"""-"":"c;
'\pprOVl'd Ill'
~}Jt,
:'.):0';01; ~,bl)1'
,,,ii, :iti!itWi:
"0"" '_-}r',,<,~t,(,r,., P.-'", 'iwr
'-"HC"
"J4;'.'(;07G:44q,'1
v""'u,-,,-..,,"tn
APflruv(,d B"
P"i',;,- i'UiirH"
'-:.",,'. 'XI"
'Pi"
'\p""'lVcd B.y
'\pprovedlly
";;j,
';or..'murl!1.' '>"\'O,!O~""~,,, /;,
["",'., "u"rn,'m~l "iJ"v,(,t'~.
Him,'"
""'It"'.; & ! ';1""" ('''J(~i'''_''-'';dl~ Rv..-,,"",,
::>~ .'
"at!:
Apllroved By
r,ft;;mem,Stl-W;;lrt f:>:l";uiivr,Secwc''''y
i1lBi2tW7 3:10 DM
Approved Ill'
Co,.,nnuniti Developmenl & Cummunit'J Du-v"lopment &
Envlronmenta! Services E':l)vlronll1en.~1 S",r/icet Admin
Joseph K_ SCllfllit\
Community Development &
Ellvlronmnl1lnl Services
Community li<'!vBloprnent &
EnvirtJmllf)ntaiScrvic<'!sI\<JminMralu..
D~te
COrnmUl1fty [)e.veiopm"'"t&
E;wirClnmenlill5QrvicesAdmin
1Il1412D0710:3~ AM
Date
Approved By
Roy SAnden-Oil, P.E
PublicUtilitl95
Public Utlliti('~ En~linr"enng Dire:;lor
Public Utilihes Engineer,n9
11114120fi7 12;1(; PM
Dale
Approved By
OMI3Ccordinator
Admirustl'ativeSe,'~ice$
Applications Analyst
Inf'l,mal,OnTechrlOtogy
111141Z0074:26PM
Data
Aprroved By
R~ndyGre,,"w<1id
County Manager's Offlc,"
Management/Budgel An~iysl
OffiClJof M<lnagemenl& Budget
11!151200711:22AM
Date
AppruvedS"
Michael Smykowski
Courlly Manager's Office
M;inllgement& Sud"et Director
Office of Managcrtl'Ont & Budget
n!16:200710:27AM
D3te
Arpro\"ed Bl'
,Jame5 V. Mudd
Boar-dof C()unty
COlnrniss;onBrs
Cnunty Manager
CountyM;'"ol!JOr'S Orfice
11118!2()07 lCj:5;~ AM
file://C:\AgendaTest\Export\93_ November%2027, %202007\ 16. %20CONSEN"fO/o20AGEN.. ] ] 12012007
u..) r-- Lr")
.::1:0'-
C.OO 0
..,-N-:;r
6'-:'Q.J
7" ("oJ 0)
~. ro
c2i):J....
ij)D
=~
.s g;'
"'0
mZ
::7,
<(
"
w
'Ii I
- ~ \ \ I---~ tf~ ~--I-~
j,..-./' ,1$ ....Wd;;-L-LCJ ffi--t--1
\ i/- '<:::~, ~~ l...!
V '( ~\--' =I _ . -~ --1 --r'
r:.'-- \--'>,-1=\ 'r ~1 ,~ J t- ~ ~, \=s:-G \
\:::::rl--~ ~ r-::! / "S~ IC P-1 ,-..\. "-ll
\--~ ~---1 ~ c..--- QBIJt. "'''r\\ \ \ ,--- \--1 r- _J. ~ ~
r----', '\=-\ N- ~\\)}1-v\_ \ \::::-1 \---:J~t-j-< _\ i ~
~) ~A Y /\ \ L\..'~- -),,\---' c- ",",P"":((' 11 "
--(\ -...---f"7 / \~------ l:=j?t \ \.---'l-!.t=~" -'
\ ~->-J I )/, I \ \ '6 --\ \ J'5- ,,\-"
!/""d~ r 'Loc' \:::-:0 ':::J:: -~ \ j!
( \ 8~<' \/~t~'~ I_I, ~-"\V6~J a..
\ \ ~:c(;" ,<)~" ,(-IS _-\ ,---\ ,'-'! \ <t
\ I =-c3\e [',"I'''' '1"\ ~ '~-\ ,-- y)., '-', L
,'__ :J'" __L~ ~ "\-C-~ < -1 --I / j-. J 1
\ ~ .._ W'W ,OSNC' ~ "I __ A \.-\ " / iT I '. i
Ht-~..,-----. -- I < ,'- \ ' J 1 y
\ '.:>0 .: .",.,. \ 1 \",1 ",1,..''''\ '" \N / '. -,....-.. .~,__.l. _--..-J_//
I\i~" " 'Cl'\',"t~lNl2-/ ----~-.' -
, . ---.----------------.- ------....-------.. ./.---- .--
I .
1 _,' _ _ -- ~_(:t.,\ ISA IcLI..NU ,~!>.Gt. - - -
- - -~ - --
-M~RVj c;Tr LIMI"" '
'l.
"
is
9,
b
\
)
-- -- --
_.'.-
--r 1
'2
"
;;;.
o
~I
O.
I W - ,
11-=-1;;;.
. m S j
1-,..
1/
/ l\
. \\,
/ :\,:,;
/ '""
, '
/ \
Ie / '"'-..
C
"
./,
{)\)
(,..,...-)
~co
,,"
'"
,)
0'"
W
t:1
(/)1
w
(!)
:s
..J
<l: ;;:
o
I- Z
_ <l
[D ..J
- Ul
I_
><<
UJUl
::J
..J
<l:
(,)
a..
<(
L
z
o
~
u
o
.....J
.
.
Aqenda Item No. 16,1\5
- November 27. 2007
Page 5 of 5
C.F.RTIFlCATlON OF CONTRmUTORY ASSETS - COUNTY
PROJEc;T NAME:
CALllSA ISLAND VILLAGE
WCATION:
WCA TED WITHIN SECTION 18, TOWNSHIP 52S, RANGE 27E
GOODLAND, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
NAME & ADDRESS OF OWNER.:
CALUSA ISLAND VILLAGE L.e.
5I30 MAIN STREET, SUITE 6
NEW PORT RITCmE, FL. 34652
cg(Q)~W .
TYPE OF UTILITY SYSTEM:
POTABLE WATER
.lTPt ))E!iOUJ"J'J9N SIZE Q\I.umTY UNO' COST 'I'O'I'AL COST
DRI4PVC 10" 20LF 12_68 253.60
0011 HOPE 10" 40LF 11.50 460.00
TAI'PlN(j SLEEVE 8" lEA 518.34 518.34
MASTER METER ASSEMBLY 6" lEA 14.551.32 14,551.32
GATE VALVE &" lEA 642.10 642.10
MJ 45 BEND 10" lEA 2045& 204.5&
MJ REDUCER lU'"Xg-" lEA 194.00 194.00
'~'.
TOTAL 16,lI23.'J4
I DO HEREBY CERl1FY 'f'Y.E ABOYE DESCRIBED UST OF MA'l'ERULS DESCRIBED ABOVE ARE TRUE AND AN ACCUl/ATE l/EPRESENTA110
OF THE AS-lNSl: ~ OF THE SYSTEM.
CERTIFYINg; ~, .
....... /- .j7V
-'l'HOMASr. .PRESlDEIIT
OF: FLO A STATE UNDERGROUND, INC.
tV
454000Ml!STlC AVENUE
NAPLES. FL 34104
STATE OF FLORIDA )
)Ss:
COUNTY OF COUJER)
WAS SlGNEDAND ACKNOWLEDGED BEFORE ME THIS 2:zM' DAY OF JULY. 2004 BYTHOMAS P. MCKlMM
ro MEAND WHO DIDNOTTAKEAN OATH.
SEAL:
CATHYE VANKERSCHAEVER
1\1'lt8ry Public - State of Florida
,., GOmm_ expires Sept 19, 2005
Comm_ No. 00049646
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Agenda Item No. '16A6
November 27. 2007
Page 1 of 8
Recommendation to approve final acceptance of the water and sewer utility
facilities for VeronaWalk, Phase 2A
OBJECTIVE: The Board of County Commissioners, Ex-Officio the Governing Board of
the Collier County Water-Sewer District, to accept final and unconditional conveyance of
these water and/or sewer facilities.
CONSIDERATIONS:
1) The Developer of VeronaWalk, Phase 2A, has constructed the water and sewer
facilities within dedicated easements to serve this development. See attached
location map.
2) Preliminary acceptance of these utility facilities was approved by the Engineering
Services Department staff on May 2, 2005. At that time, the value of these utility
facilities (assets) was $112,827.50 for the water facilities and $139,742 for the sewer
facilities (see attachment[s]). This final acceptance is in accordance with Collier
County Ordinance No. 2004-31, as amended.
3) Staff recorded all preliminary acceptance documents in the public records of Collier
County, which have been reviewed and approved by the County Attorney's office as
to form and legal sufficiency.
4) The water and sewer facilities have been operated and maintained by the Collier
County Water-Sewer District during, not less than, the required one (1) year warranty
period.
5) A final inspection to discover defects in materials and workmanship has been
conducted by the Engineering Services Department staff, and these facilities have
been found to be satisfactory and acceptable.
6) The PUD Monitoring staff has reviewed this request in relation to possible issues
raised by the applicable Home Owners Association (HOA). Staff is unaware of any
issues that would serve to negate the recommendation to release the applicable
security.
FISCAL IMPACT: Approval of this Executive Summary will have no specific financial
impact. However, approval of this Executive Summary will result in the Collier County
Water-Sewer District receiving unconditional title to the utility facilities, which at the time
of preliminary acceptance, had a total (undepreciated) value of $252,569.50.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: Approval of this Executive Summary will have no
growth management impact.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: No additional legal review from the County Attorney is
required to complete this final acceptance.
A,oenda 1t8m No. 16A6
.. November 27, 2007
Flage 2 of 8
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners, Ex-Officio the
Governing Board of the Collier County Water-Sewer District, authorize final acceptance
of these water and sewer utility facilities for VeronaWalk, Phase 2A, and authorize the
County Manager, or his designee, to release any Utilities Performance Security (UPS) to
the Project Engineer or the Developer's designated agent.
PREPARED BY: Jodi Pannullo Hughes, Engineering Technician
ltemNumber:
ItemSllmmary:
Meeting Date:
Page 1 of I
,t.,oenc!8 liern No. 4fJA6
,. NO\jember 27. 2007
paqe:1 of8
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF CQUNT'i COMMISSIONERS
"3No
FiCccr,1!THllG'n.jAtlon (c approve final accemance- 01 the wa~p' <1'1(; sew", uUII\'; If,clill\' to:
\."il'011<,1'fV31~., Phase 2:,
"IC7C~07 9~)() DO '\M
[J<ltr
Prellllred By
J()tiipa'lr]ullo
C;"mrllunilV Dev,,"ltlpmcnt&
~IWir(lrTmcmt8IS,lrviCf:S
p.dmj,.,i'it'MjV(j;'~s;"t;mt
,~D:::S Fng!'1,,€nng $ervic%
10!2:li)O(\7 2(JO'~tl "M
L"H.-
Approved Br
Jud"Puig
Opcr:lticlW. An~lvst
ConlnlUnit, Dcvf'iopm' m [. :;tmllTlL'n,t\, [)(>ve:,mment I<
i'-nv"cnmcntal S"rv"_,,,,, r~d'ni"
I f):'? 3i2G(1~'
;:'t'i
c:rwiron",enta:,:",r',iV'
>;)t"
Apllrl>\'cd Ry
,;tenn,,,, L. ~;~,p
"'u"ljcL:tili1ic,'
".hoH,.'w.":'" ,'ieli<-, "''1''''.1 """9''''
\f'i,,~I';V'_'"t'''
j!)i24!;ciW' "',Iid
"Ilpro\'ed II)
:.Me
'-',,"w.j;,!ii',I
""ut;!"UtJlit"".
/.';1">' """.'''.'<,-""", I''',m,~~,.,
"L';;:'.!"l'-"I;""r:
Allprllwd Hy
',,,,,',',,,1;/
,LI,(l.)hl
\"."".,
Approvcd II}'
-"d,,;,.
"'--""')",,,n :!('-'Ol(;p; '0'"
C""I C-":'\lW ,__, ~,.'rv;:';v
r~PV'''.'''m''n;" ::<'--'.-'IC2
)('.101"
DJt'"
Allpnl\'ed By
r."..~.'-!i ";'I ;_.'~-.I"";:,,
CO"""llWity Developmem &
Env:ronmentaIScC\'icos
Son;o'Planncr
20nmg ;;. L~ncj D0vslopmeni Review
11,'212007 1:!..48PM
D.,te
Approved By
G, George Yilmaz
Public Utiliti,,~
W~$teW~lH Director
Wa,hNJ>I\er
111~12007 B:SB PM
Dare
Approved By
M<lrlcnn Stewart Ewcu\ivi> Secretary
111812007 :>13 PM
Arlproved By
Community Devclopment & Community Development &
E,wironm,-,mnl Servic(!--s En,-"rormlcnta! S{'rvi"e~ Admin
J05ephr;, $<::hmit1
Community Development &
Environmentlll5ervices
Community Develop'nent&
EnVWlnrYH"nllliSeuicesAaminstrator
Dale
Community Development &
EnvjronmentalServicesAdmin.
11/141200710:J3AfIII
Date
Approved Dr
R'I\'B.Andersor"P.E
Public Utilit,es
PubliC Utilities Engin2eringD'ffictor
Pubhc Utilities Enpme--erirlg
11/141200,12:1,PM
D.1te
Approved Dr
OMS Coordinator
AdministrlltiveSorvices
i\ppliclltion!> Analyst
Information Technology
11!14120074:32PM
0<11<:
Approved By
Mart: Is~ckson
County Manager's Office
BudgelAnalyst
Office at Management 8. B'j[jgal
1111412007 S:15PM
Date
Approved By
James V Mudd
Board o! County
Com'n'ssioners
County Wanager
County M:mager'sOffice
t1l15!ZOQ';" 9A~ AM
file:/IC:\Agenda Test\Export\93- Novem ber%2027, %202007\ 16.%20CONSENT%20AGEN.. 11/20/2007
CD 1-- CD
<0_
(0::>0
_N~
cl r-': G)
==~ g
,-- GJ 0
S-2-
s9-l
..,..., ?
~'J
sZ
:7)
<(
i
I
I
I
I
11
I
I
;'" ~
"
3
iF-- d
8
I
z
__ I W Q
~~
IDO
o
~
~
,
1
,.., II
"
I I
I
I
I \
, .
_ .__ Jmlmllll '1
=:1,[-'"1 '''''l ~7';j tcg ; 'I, ,-,,=11I]1II1_1-'1-'~ !~,,,,,,,",JIIilllH[]1L J
=1;=3 ~ ~ c I~~~j~=ml!llr:
i:!1 r~,~\"c~~t>,; l'I..glli~:!~~,mllill~1 '
......, >;/'>'':J', ~ A"'" c~1 I
,-:../.../ \
"""Ol"'''/~
,
l=
,';]
"
-
~
I h
l~ ~
,
i
1-
';:B ..
i'F
'"
__~IIM_
_ I' O!.~
- ~
I'
\
tZ
w2
~~
0<
",0
~o
~
"
n
,"~
-----c
1
~, ! I '" i:lt_
.~ :I'j:;;-I " I!~
::1;:-
h~-
, ! '" ~..:> ,
i I, I I " <, In -T~
~do , " p
i'" i" "
I , I .
j ! , "
I ,! I ,
l ~I
___SL
IUL , --+L-
,
, ,
,
~
ilK'
(LI
<(
L
WI
~
C/)
~i
w
ID'
:i!i
''''
'"
...J
..,
~,
il
>'
j
!
(L
<(
L
z
o
~
u
o
...J
~(Q)~W
.
Agenda Item r,o, 16/\6
November 27, 2007
"'age 5 of 8
CERTIFICATION OF CONTRIBUTORY ASSETS - COUNTY
PROJECT NAME: VERONAWALK PHASE 2A
LOCATION: SECTION 26, TOWNSHIP 50 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
NAME & ADDRESS OF OWNER: DIVOST A AND COMPANY
6005 VANDERBILT ROAD EXTENSION
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34119
TYPE OF UTILITY SYSTEM: POTABLE WATER (MATERIALS ONLY)
I ITEM SIZE QUAN" UNIT COST TOTAL I
6" DR-14 6" 110 LF $9.00 $990.00
6" DR-I8 6" 630 LF $8.00 $5,040.00
8" DR-I' 8" 590 LF $9.00 $5,310.00
10" DR.18 10" 2985 LF $11.50 $34,327.50
16" DR-14 16" 800 LF $20.00 $16,000.00
PERM BLOW OFF 6" 3 EA $750.00 $2,250.00
6" GATE VALVE 6" 3 EA $700.00 $2,100.00
&" GATE VALVE 8" 3 EA $920.00 $2,760.00
JOn GATE VALVE 10" 6 EA $1,075.00 $6,450.00
16" GATE VALVE 16" 1 EA $2,000.00 $2,000.00
PBSP 4 EA $900.00 $3,600.00
SINGLE WATER SERVICE 65 EA $400.00 $26,000.00
DOUBLE SERVICE 30 EA $200.00 $6,000.00
TOTAL COST $112,827.50
. ,
.
.
!~a9nda aem No 16A6
, ~"ovember 27, 2007
Page 6 of 8
J do hereby certify that the quantities of materials described above are a true and accurate
representation of the system,
~-
Brenda K.Merchant
Authorized Agent
OF: Haleakala Construction, Inc.
57 58 Taylor Road
Naples, Florida 34109-1829
STATE OF FLORIDA )
) SS:
COUNTY OF COLLIER )
The foregoing instrument was signed and acknowledged before me this 7th day of February,
2005 by Brenda K. Merchant who is personally known to me and who did not take an oath.
vf~ 1J1a}Wh---
LINDA MAHON
DD 177119
SEAL
...,\\\llllllf~ LindaMahoo
:~:S:-'- Commission #DDl77I19
~;:~.;~ Expires: Feb 21. 2007
-:'~Oip..~"~ BondedThru
"'111'''' AtlanlicBondingCo..1ne.
.
~(Q)[P))f
.
Agenda Item No. 16.1\6
November 27.2007
Page 7 of 8
CERTIFICATION OF CONTRIBUTORY ASSETS - COUNTY
PROJECT NAME: VERONAWALK PHASE 2A
LOCATION: SECTION 26, TOWNSHIP 50 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
NAME & ADDRESS OF OWNER: DIVOSTA AND COMPANY
6005 VANDERBILT ROAD EXTENSION
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34119
TYPE OF UTILITY SYSTEM: SANITARY SEWER (MATERIALS ONLY)
I ITEM SIZE QUAN. UNIT COST TOTAL I
g" SDR-26 0-6' CUT 8" 1448 LF $8.00 $11,584.00
S" SDR~26 6-8' CUT 8" 1452 LF $8.00 $11,616.00
S" SDR-26 8-!O' CUT 8" 982 IF $8.00 $7,856.00
8" SOR-26 10-12' CUT 8" 217 LF $8.00 $1,736.00
4' D1A MANHOLE 0-6' 4' 12 EA $2,000.00 $24,000.00
4' DIA MANHOLE 6-8' 4' 3 EA $2,900.00 $8,700.00
4' DIAMANHOLE 8-10' 4' 5 EA $3,900.00 $19,500.00
4' OrA MANHOLE 10-12' 4' 1 EA $4,10000 $4,10000
DOUBLE SER VICES 75 EA $500.00 $37,500.00
SINGLE SERVICES 10 EA $525.00 $5,250.00
8" DR-18 8" 790 IF $10.00 $7,900.00
TOTAL COST $139,742.00
/
.
.
I\qenda Item I,io 16/1.6
~ November 2i 2007
Page 8 of 8
I do hereby certify that the quantities of materials described above are a true and accurate
representation of the system.
;roo'
~
B ENDAK.MERCHANT
AUTHORIZED AGENT
OF: Haleakala Construction, Inc.
5758 Taylor Road
Naples, Florida 34109-1829
STATE OF FLORIDA )
) SS
COUNTY OF COLLIER )
The foregoing instrument was signed and acknowledged before me this 25th day of February,
2005 Br!,'nda K. Merchant who is personally known to me and who did not take an oath.
SEAL:
Linda Mahon
DD 177119
\"""," LindaMahon
~~~< ComissionIlDDl77II'
~~.. 'll';~Expires: Feb21. 200'
....;:4=Dff;\.~...:- ~.Thru
,""",\ At1anticBoncbJt$lCo.n
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Agenda Item No. 16A7
November 27, 2007
Page 1 of 8
Recommendation to approve final acceptance of the water and sewer utility
facilities for VeronaWalk, Phase 2B
OBJECTIVE: The Board of County Commissioners, Ex-Officio the Governing Board of
the Collier County Water-Sewer District, to accept final and unconditional conveyance of
these water and/or sewer facilities.
CONSIDERATIONS:
1) The Developer of VeronaWalk, Phase 2B, has constructed the water and sewer
facilities within dedicated easements to serve this development. See attached
location map.
2) Preliminary acceptance of these utility facilities was approved by the Engineering
Services Department staff on September 9, 2005. At that time, the value of these
utility facilities (assets) was $99,352.50 for the water facilities and $282,568.60 for
the sewer facilities (see attachment[s]). This final acceptance is in accordance with
Collier County Ordinance No. 2004-31, as amended.
3) Staff recorded all preliminary acceptance documents in the public records of Collier
County, which have been reviewed and approved by the County Attorney's office as
to form and legal sufficiency.
4) The water and sewer facilities have been operated and maintained by the Collier
County Water-Sewer District during, not less than, the required one (1) year warranty
period.
5) A final inspection to discover defects in materials and workmanship has been
conducted by the Engineering Services Department staff, and these facilities have
been found to be satisfactory and acceptable.
6) The PUD Monitoring staff has reviewed this request in relation to possible issues
raised by the applicable Home Owners Association (HOA). Staff is unaware of any
issues that would serve to negate the recommendation to release the applicable
security.
FISCAL IMPACT: Approval of this Executive Summary will have no specific financial
impact However, approval of this Executive Summary will result in the Collier County
Water-Sewer District receiving unconditional title to the utility facilities, which at the time
of preliminary acceptance, had a total (undepreciated) value of $381,921.11.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: Approval of this Executive Summary will have no
growth management impact.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: No additional legal review from the County Attorney is
required to complete this final acceptance.
fl"genda Item No. i 6.!::.,]
November 27. 2007
Page 2 of 8
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners, Ex-Officio the
Governing Board of the Collier County Water-Sewer District, authorize final acceptance
of these water and sewer utility facilities for VeronaWalk, Phase 2B, and authorize the
County Manager, or his designee, to release any Utilities Performance Security (UPS) to
the Project Engineer or the Developer's designated agent.
PREPARED BY: Jodi Pannullo Hughes, Engineering Technician
Item Number:
Item Summary:
Meeting Date:
Page ] of ]
J',acnd" Ilem 16A7
.- l'.Jovember 20a?
Page:; uf 8
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD Of COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
16A7
Recommendation 1'0 aspr!!ve final 8ccertiJ'lUi ot the- '",[lfc" !1nc sew,", util'ty !ar.,lItiE's ior
l.ier[)rlilWalk F'!k]S~ 28
'1/;;'COO"'S'O::i,)U ".M
u~v.
J'rcparcd By
JOdiP,,"nutk,
:':cHTlHHJnlty D,)vo;iopmefH &.
,':n\!j'-onm"nta!SarJice;;
Admin'str,ll'V(,P',sisl:"nt
:::UES r.n\-lineer;r'i' "er"ica~
1[jf~:.1i2007 :.31:$0 PM
:.:);;\<'
Approved By
. 'u" ~. P tJ i S
UperJtiow:.!.!11>ivgt
~,on1fFHj'1Ir,' Development ~~ ::om""'nity De"l'IOpn",ni &
En",mnmenta: ::;,,,v,,_,,,,,A<lnnn
WID"2!07 :;-.1fjPM
r-:.'lvlronm.,m':'I':'O'"VI"'~'"
.'. '0" r'JaS'.
;'JilW
'\ppro~'ecl By
"'ul,I:' Utililif";
'il"~,'-' '.,"l':"-, Cui'e-c,o,': ~j"t";iq'"
',"!~"v,I.":,ncr
''''n~ '!iJirl '::f,"J'.V
_'L,j;,
t""
Appr\!~ed By
rei.>;' j, i;~, "',.
p.;~l'V
'f:.';'.-,;::')
...1",'.'"
'\ JlJ)r-,,\'~'d JJ~
'.f---:,,,
Apl'n'""d Ilv
"''''''r'''.'''H'
'::'''''''''''',:1"[0,, '"elm'''
i':n',-,i'-","""ent<>i ""'1'(;"';'
(.r-~ f'lv'
D~t~
Appnlved By
'J; Dl'V;' ''''~' ',:.', "n.Ji
C.crlmun,t\' ['I'velo"mem&
r:"vlconm"nt~'Sorvic"'s
"cnio"'i'mn("
~'_oni"g I;, l,and f)evll!o.,,,wnt ReView
'li212l1V't:::4i1PM
r::~te
Apllrovcd By
G C;,wrg"Vilm<ll
hlblitUlilities
W,~steWat..,rDir"<;lor
WasteWater
11'Ei!2007S:5lJPM
Dille
Approved By
M~rjent' Stewart Executive Secretary
1118120073:15 PM
AppruveclBy
Community Development & Community Deveiopmenl 11
Env;ronmen(<lIServices Environmentlll:;,'-'RlicesAdmin
JOS"pllf':,Schlllllt
Community Develupment 8;
Environmental Service!>
Comnwnrty Dev"lopment &
Env'ronm'i!ntal Senic:e&Adrmnstriltor
Dale
Communi1.y DeveluPt11""t&
EnvironlY,':ntaIService"Admin.
111141200712:09PM
Date
Approved By
Roy B. Andil~ofl, Pi:;
Pubiic Utilit;e5
Public Utllltie" Engme"nng Dimctor
Public Ut;rities Engineering
11/14/200712:18 PM
Unte.
Approved By
01\1I8 Coordinator
Adm,n;strat,veServices
Appiications Anl>lyst
IntormationTechnology
11'14/20014:32 PM
Dllle
Approve-dBy
M~rk is"ckson
COlmt)'MlInllger'50!fir."
Budgel. Aflalf~t
Offiq, of Managemrml I> ElutJgel
11!141Z007S,2:;:PM
Dale
ApJ}roved By
J</rnes\-'. Mudd
B"lIrd 01 County
(;omm;~sioners
Countylli,an.lger
County Manager'", Offi:;~
11115/20011127 AM
file://C:\AgendaTest\Export\93~November%2027, %202007\] 6, %20CONSENT%20AGEN,. 11/20/2007
.
.
A.genda Item No. '16A7
November 27.2007
?age 4 of 8
CERTIFICATION OF CONTRIBUTORY ASSETS - COUNTY
PROJECT NAME: VERONAWALK PHASE 28
LOCATION: SECTION 26, TOWNSHIP 50 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
~(Q)~W
NAME & ADDRESS OF OWNER: DIVOST A AND COMPANY
6005 VANDERBILT ROAD EXTENSION
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34119
TYPE OF UTILITY SYSTEM POTABLE WATER (MATERIALS ONLY)
I ITEM SIZE QUAN. UNIT COST TOTAL I
6" DR-14 6" 40 LF $9.00 $360.00
6" DR-18 6" 200 LF $8.00 $1,600.00
8" DR-IS 8" 190 LF $9.00 $1,710.00
]0" DR-]' 10" 655 LF $11.50 $7,532.50
16" DR-IS 16" 40 LF $2000 $800.00
16" DR-25 16" 2640 LF $20.00 $52,800.00
PERM BLOW OFF 6" 1 EA $750.00 $750.00
6" GATE VALVE 6" 1 EA $700.00 $700.00
10" GATE VALVE 10" 4 EA $1,075.00 $4,30000
16" GATE VALVE 16" 6 EA $2,000.00 $12,000.00
PBSP 2 EA $900.00 $1,800.00
SINGLE WATER SERV1CE 18 EA $400.00 $7,200.00
DOUBLE SERVICE 39 EA $200.00 $7,800.00
TOTAL COST $99,352.50
:
.
.
Agenda Item No. 16A7
r~ovember 27.2007
Page 5 of 8
I do hereby certify that the quantities of materials described above are a true and accurate
representation of the system.
c~c
\ \ -
Brenda K.Merchant
Authorized Agent
OF: Haleakala Construction, Inc.
5758 Taylor Road
Naples, Florida 34109-1829
STATE OF FLORIDA )
) 55:
COUNTY OF COLLIER)
The foregoing instrument was signed and acknowledged before me this 20th day of May,
2005 by Brenda K. Merchant who is personally known to me and who did not take an oath.
of41~ ~
LINDA MAHON
DO 177119
SEAL:
\\\\\I~"II Linda Mahon
j'l:~"';;.\ Commission #DDI77 119
~;:" \;).;;~Expires:Feb21.2007
--,'~" . :iI',~ Bonded 111m
I,OfIF1.:,' . . I
//,1111\1 Atlanttc BondmgCo.. nc.
.
.
Agenda item t'>Jo. 'j 6,Ji. 7
November 27.2007
Page 6 018
CERTIFICA nON OF CONTRIBUTORY ASSETS - COUNTY
PROJECT NAME: VERONAWALK PHASE 28
LOCATION: SECTION 26, TOWNSHIP 50 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
~@~v
NAME & ADDRESS OF OWNER: DIVOSTA AND COMPANY
6005 VANDER81L T ROAD EXTENSION
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34119
TYPE OF UTILITY SYSTEM: SANITARY SEWER (MATERIALS ONLY)
I ITEM SIZE QUAN. UNIT COST TOTAL I
8" SDR-26 0-6' CUT 8" 902 LF $8.00 $7,216.00
S" SDR-26 6-8' CUT 8" 620 LF $8.00 $4,960.00
8" SDR"26 8-10' CUT 8" 665 LF $8.00 $5,320.00
S" SDR-26 1O~12' CCT 8" 213 LF $8.00 $1,704.00
I!" SDR-26 ]2-14' CUT 8" 633 LF $800 $5,064.00
BOO SDR<:!.6 14-16' CUT 8" 150 LF $8.00 $1,200.00
8" SDR-26 ]6-]8' CUT 8" 242 LF $8.00 $1,936.00
4' DlA MANHOLE 0-6' 4' 5 EA $2,000.00 $12,000.00
4' DlA MANHOLE 6-8' 4' 3 EA $2,900.00 $8,700.00
4' DlA MANHOLE 8-10' 4' 4 EA $3,900.00 $15,60000
4' DlAM,,\NHOLE 10-12' 4' 3 EA $4,100.00 $12,300.00
4' DlA MANHOLE 12-14' 4' 2 EA $5,100.00 $10,200.00
4' DlA MANHOLE 14-16' 4' 2 EA $6,000.00 $12,000.00
4' DlA MANHOLE 16-18' 4' 1 EA $8,000.00 $8,000.00
DOUBLE SERVICES 44 EA $425.00 $18,700.00
SINGLE SERVICES 8 EA $400.00 $3,200.00
LIFT STATION 1 LF $120,000.00 $120,000.00
6" DR-Ig 6" 155 LF $9.00 $1,395.00
g"DR-IS 8" 2660 LF $10.46 $27,823.60
6" PLUG VALVE 6" 2 LF $600.00 $1,200.00
g" PWGVALVE 8" 5 LF $810.00 $4,050.00
TOTAL COST $282,568.60
.
.
I do hereby certify that the quantities of materials described above are a true and accurate
representation of the system.
~~"G'
'" ~~
BR NDA K. MERCHANT
AUTHORIZED AGENT
OF: Haleakala Construction, Inc.
5758 Taylor Road
Naples, Florida 34109-1829
STATE OF FLORIDA)
)SS:
COUNTY OF COLLIER )
The foregoing instrument was signed and acknowledged before me this 11 th day of March,
2005 by Brenda K. Merchant who is personally known to me and who did not take an oath.
cf~~ 171~
Linda Mahon
DD 177119
SEAL:
,\\HI1I1, Linda Mahon
>~.~ Commission #DD177119
~., ~A Expires: Feb 21,2007
<'- 'Z~ Bonded Thru
........,I;,r:t~\\\~ Atl8nticBondingCo., inc.
Agenda Item No. 16/\7
November 27, 2007
Page 7 of 8
r--r--CO
<o~
(OSlO
..,.-NO;)
,....;,-- (])
7N DJ
-,-CO
;:: Q..1Q.,
....D
~~
.-. a;
ct.>
~..s;
-:1,'::-
-:::n
<0:
z
o
w-
...."
000
o
"
1---
,
I
. "
~"
I W 0
l~~~_
I """~'~lll
L__
..... -~===~TT~~~
1---'-1..~.. ,.. .. I
'--_"____~~I. _L~_ _I
-~if-\iTl-~'--,I\'\\ ..::0f~Si )/_-
-l,' Ll_~'...r..:. T'~\ /'11'''=1, .}/)? '.:;{#" / -- '- /
I 1 I :~I ,=--:It-:j /--: J lr,r---/ / -~-~'""
I [ II~I t=.=..~-=::1I---j{---, ~:.,~( ~\I]
_~ ----'------ __ ~ 'I I~ ':::......:.i '---=-1 . -.:.:. i _ L .., I 1~]J'lllm11
I k" ,,d c-_ -~J ~___ '=-___ -_ ;-----' - ",-,""~,J LmB'. J
! - ~- :--- $'0< .. - '? f.:C< (l ~!T!Ji1iJjTllim!illJi3'II~ ( !
. f..' '-:"1 -~~ .:i~j J i~mmmmrrmmli~:f]i:;1;
i ----=;;.;- ~----'~ -:::1'3:--1 'Ire )1<.. """.." ~ ,"""""" < I
-::.,\b: '=:'~l=1 :ci.?' ( ~~::- l , ' "
- ,~~- > l'''-- ~ :?,(>,/ ~> :: i
c '''!-----''4' --\' ~\ )). )
,.c\\t::=i ,A ,",V//> '-'" .
k--\...----_\ '; ~'(:---:J y~^y-...: /;:> ~ ------
II
~I,I
I
-z-
,
J=
,
I
I I"
r ;-
~fG,~
!
I!
,
//1
i ~
,
,
~
,
i."
Ii!
h
lll~
"
~~! ..
"
,',
, l!~
,
,
~.qlO;l
,
,
l
!
~a
,
,
.~
, II
'.
~~
~IO"'~ "-
'I~~ I,
Q..
<t
:E
UJ
I-
CI)
'"
N
W
m
..
lEI
"',
-'
..
;t
..,
5'
~I
Q..
<t
:E
z
o
I-
<t
u
o
..J
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Agenda Item No. 16A8
November 27.2007
Page 1 of 8
Recommendation to approve final acceptance of the water and sewer utility
facilities for VeronaWalk, Phase 2C
OBJECTIVE: The Board of County Commissioners, Ex-Officio the Governing Board of
the Collier County Water-Sewer District, to accept final and unconditional conveyance of
these water and/or sewer facilities.
CONSIDERATIONS:
1) The Developer of VeronaWalk, Phase 2C, has constructed the water and sewer
facilities within dedicated easements to serve this development. See attached
location map.
2) Preliminary acceptance of these utility facilities was approved by the Engineering
Services Department staff on November 4, 2005. At that time, the value of these
utility facilities (assets) was $46,349 for the water facilities and $55,871.92 for the
sewer facilities (see attachment[s]). This final acceptance is in accordance with
Collier County Ordinance No. 2004-31, as amended.
3) Staff recorded all preliminary acceptance documents in the public records of Collier
County, which have been reviewed and approved by the County Attorney's office as
to form and legal sufficiency.
4) The water and sewer facilities have been operated and maintained by the Collier
County Water-Sewer District during, not less than, the required one (1) year warranty
period.
5) A final inspection to discover defects in materials and workmanship has been
conducted by the Engineering Services Department staff, and these facilities have
been found to be satisfactory and acceptable.
6) The PUD Monitoring staff has reviewed this request in relation to possible issues
raised by the applicable Home Owners Association (HOA). Staff is unaware of any
issues that would serve to negate the recommendation to release the applicable
security.
FISCAL IMPACT: Approval of this Executive Summary will have no specific financial
impact. However, approval of this Executive Summary will result in the Collier County
Water-Sewer District receiving unconditional title to the utility facilities, which at the time
of preliminary acceptance, had a total (undepreciated) value of $102,220.92.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: Approval of this Executive Summary will have no
growth management impact.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: No additional legal review from the County Attorney is
.,- required to complete this final acceptance.
.L\genda item No. 16.'\8
November 27,2007
Page 2 of 8
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners, Ex-Officio the
Governing Board of the Collier County Water-Sewer District, authorize final acceptance
of these water and sewer utility facilities for VeronaWalk, Phase 2C, and authorize the
County Manager, or his designee, to release any Utilities Performance Security (UPS) to
the Project Engineer or the Developer's designated agent.
PREPARED BY: Jodi Pannullo Hughes, Engineering Technician
Item Number:
ltemSummary:
Meeting Date:
Page 1 of 1
A\lend3 Item No, 16A8
Novembcl 27
Page 018
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
V5'~G
r~",~"C"r'!1",nJ"l!:()n ~c flP:WWf- firlai "G,~e:JWI1~(, ~,f ~he waler and ';ewel" litilll\.' corweyanc", fo'
verr)r"r.'j\"\/alh.pna~;", 2C
1,C?/2UQ,'9000CAM
t,(im,n;Slrali'/f, :,~sicranl
Date
Prepllred By
,;odiP,mnuIIG
(:omnlUrHty DI,v!JIc,r>mcntii
i-:.n..,rofHTl8nt<l1 S8r~ic"";
rU;;:S':'n"i"nen"!3:o'iHVL<'c:;
10123:;;:J07 2:5~;05 PM
Date
ArrrovedB:l'
ju<1~. DlJig U\)Criltrons r. nail' ~l
1{)/;!:ii;!n07JI<;PIii
Apprnved Hy
CGmrnun!t,' '1(."~,10ptl1,'nt C, ('Dmmunitv [levelopmen! is.
2,wiroDm"ntalo,ervice" ('::n',i,:)r,mentai S~"flC{"" ,~dmin
~:'I'.:Pl1'Hl c.. r"Jp'i
/i""';1PViAe..r die,..!,,,,, "'l~;lc,r
";"Ie'
'.'uiJl,"Ulilit'Hr
\"ill<>W,'I<1"'"
1Oi<:';i2i!1l ,~_<:., r,(/
"""!.'I,'l'1>:>',
/:l""
A.pprovedB)'
,..,,~;,~ )irii',ic'
i;:!q';"F'
'\llproved By
Allpr(lved By
"'r.'
~;,,, r'l"""t r" \'NO""",'" ..
~t<- ,'qrmw;r,/ :~""'l1~n
"''1'''-' ':~,.,"Vl("n
r'l:
r)Jt,.,
Arrrovcd B~
p";"'vA"" U"'V:"'~"
:.Gmmunlt)' ~)e\!el;Jflmer1t I>.
E;...."rO"nleni"I:~NV'Cf'S
"",nn''''i,,nn,,'
~'ol1ing '" L.Jnd Df)v'IGPml>ntr,eview
~1:2/Z0r;" 1:" 4<\ PM
W'lsteWaterDirllctof
Date
Approved By
G. G"org~ Ylirnaz
Pllbli~ IJlililles
WasteWlllec
11/6/2007 a,59PM
rJivrlfmeSteW<lrt
l)~te
Apl)roved B:l'
Community Dev010pmcnt &
Environmen:aISE>rvi""s
['Ke~utive Secrewr;'
Community D!l\!elopment&
Environmental Services AdOli"
11/8120073:18 PM
Approved B)'
Jco&ephK. Schrnlt1
Community Oevi'lopment &.
Env'ronment>lISI!Yvices
CotTlmunay Development &
Environmental$er',lic,""AdminstrJtor
Date
Community Dev<iloprnent&
E,wirnnmental Services AdmIn
11114120071;2,10PM
PUblicUtillt!!,sE"gineeringD'rBctor
Date
ArllrovedBJ'
Roy B. Andernon.P.E
Public Utilities
Public Utilities Enginet'ring
11/1412007 12:1~ PM
D<lte
Arrroved By
OMB Cuordmator
AdministrativeServiees
;,pplicaiionsAnalyst
InlormationTechnology
11114120074:33PM
Date
Approved By
Mllr~. Is~ckson
County Manager'!', Offlee
Budget Analyst
Olf.ce 01 Managernen! & Budget
11114120075:30PM
D,~te
Approved By
.i"m"~V. Mudd
Board dCounty
Commls5ionec$
County Manag",r
(;ounty Man:Jger'& Officll
11115/200711:35 AM
file://C:\AgendaTest\Export\93-Novembcr%2027 ,o/a202007\ 16. o/a20CONSENT%20AGEN... 11/20/2007
-
.
.
Agenda Item No. 16/\8
~..Jovember 27,2007
Page 4 of 3
CERTIFICATION OF CONTRIBUTORY ASSETS. COUNTY
PROJECT NAME: VERONAWALK PHASE 2C
LOCATION: SECTION 26, TOWNSHIP 50 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
~j(Q) jpJ Jp
NAME & ADDRESS OF OWNER: DIVOSTA AND COMPANY
6005 VANDERBILT ROAD EXTENSION
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34119
TYPE OF UTILITY SYSTEM: POTABLE WATER (MATERIALS ONLY)
I ITEM SIZE QUAN. UNIT COST TOTAL I
DR-14 6" 40 LF $6.00 $240.00
DR-I! 6" 300 LF $5.50 $1,650.00
DR-IS 8" 200 LF $6.50 $1,300.00
DR-JK 10" 1280 LF $9.20 $11,77600
DR-18 16" 40 LF $23.80 $952.00
DR~25 16" 560 LF $17.80 $9,968.00
GATE VALVE 6" 1 EA $750.00 $750.00
GATE VALVE 10" 4 EA $1 ,00000 $4,000.00
GATE VALVE 16" 2 EA $2,300.00 $4,600.00
PERM BLQWOFF 6" 1 EA $956.00 $956.00
PBSP 1 EA $929.00 $929.00
SINGLE WATER SERVICE 10 EA $219.00 $2,190.00
DOUBLE WATER SERVICE 23 EA $306.00 $7,038.00
TOTAL COST $46,349.00
/
.,-
.
.
Agenda Item No. 16A8
November 27. 2007
Page 5 ot 8
-~
I do hereby certify that the quantities of materials described above are a true and accurate
representation of the system.
OF: Haleakala Construction, Inc.
5758 Taylor Road
Naples, Florida 34109-1829
STATE OF FLORIDA )
)SS:
COUNTY OF COLLIER )
The foregoing instrument was signed and acknowledged before me this 1 st day of September,
2~JaY~On Oreschnick who is personally known to me and who did not take an oath.
~~ SEAL:
LINDA MAHON
DD 177119
".\1111/11(.. LindaMah.on
,,'R.'~~~ Com!"ission #DDl77119
~;:. ~.:;~ ExpIres: Feb 21,2007
~,,"ij.... 'iif,,' Bonded Thru
"""~~~\,, Atlantic Bonding Co., InC.
"'.
.
.
,t..aenda Item No, 16.Ll.8
- November 27.2007
Page 6 of 8
CERTIFICA TION OF CONTRIBUTORY ASSETS - COUNTY
PROJECT NAME VERONAWALK PHASE 2C
LOCATION: SECTION 26, TOWNSHIP 50 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
~(Q)(P)t
NAME & ADDRESS OF OWNER: DIVOSTA AND COMPANY
6005 VANDERBILT ROAD EXTENSION
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34119
TYPE OF UTILITY SYSTEM: SANITARY SEWER (MATERIALS ONLY)
I ITEM SIZE QUAN. UNIT COST TOTAL I
SDR.26 6.8' CUT 8" 833 LF $4.98 $4,148.34
SDR-26 8-10' CUT 8" 223 LF $4.98 $1,110.54
SDR.26 10-12' CUT 8" 256 LF $4.98 $1,274.88
SDR-26 12.) 4' CUT 8" 350 LF $4.98 $1,743.00
SDR-26 J4-lfi' CUT 8" 570 LF $4.98 $2,838.60
DIA MANHOLE 0-6' 4' 2 EA $2,401.30 $4,80260
DlA MANHOLE 6-8' 4' 2 EA $2,780.00 $5,560.00
DIA MANHOLE 8-]0' 4' EA $3,125.20 $3,125.20
DIA MANHOLE 10-12' 4' 2 EA $3,526.51 $7,053.02
DlA MANHOLE 12-14' 4' 1 EA $4,477.02 $4,477.02
DIA MANHOLE 14-16' 4' 2 EA $5,084.36 $10,168.72
DOUBLE SANITARY SERVICE 6" 26 EA $325.00 $8,450.00
SINGLE SANITARY SERVICE 6" 4 EA $280.00 $1,120.00
TOTAL COST $55,871.92
)
..
..,.:-~
.
.
Agenda Item No. 16.'18
November 27. 2007
Page 7 of 8
I do hereby certify that the quantities of materials described above are a true and accurate
representation of the system.
~
BRENDA K. MERCHANT
AUTHORIZED AGENT
OF: Haleakala Construction, Inc.
5758 Taylor Road
Naples, Florida 34109-1829
STATE OF FLORIDA )
)SS:
COUNTY OF COLLIER)
The foregoing instrument was signed and acknowledged before me this 3rd day of June,
~ Br~nda K. Merchant who is personally known to me and who did not take an oath.
~LV ~- SEAL
Linda Mahon
DD 177119
..\~"IIII Linda Mahon
/#~""f;;~~ Com!11ission #DD 177119
0;;. 'iJ.::~ Expires: Feb 21, 2007
'--'!iio;' ."#.,< Bonded Thru
"II"~\\\ Atlantic Bonding Co., Inc.
~b=
<nOO
-:-Nro
6r--" Q)
ZN 2'
.... >- ,"
cCDD...
~-2
~S
ffiZ
":))
<C
z
w()
~!;;:
000
o
~
I ' ~
! Ii
-~ I ~~~~j /;/ ill)
I . // .
.. _~ /1
I F""~"E,,---~ //;fijs:~;;~ \, ~-r '2\
:____: r-T-=~:=Jil !!(:"Jk{/l$':~ \~@\1j
, :-~r-' .:..,I.~~ I s~f'::::'>/I^'"
. ' ~~r-'lliIU\\,~~/!.//~.!:.$f<<~'
~I""" . _,~, <'" .... ,-,,- , , /' ,,~,'0%>~
lliJ, -[ iT' I, T~li,.-I".\,-,.,.!}".:~ 1.;~:2:/../'." .Ii'
1-'r-1" I.. I'll' "Il'i !.~!..~/I{:'~.:j;v<<)~ .1.-
I I I! 1;1 t~) tl !.;,,,::/:..) />f::;Y / -~
~ I ___:______L__. I' 1 f~lc~ c:}i] .c:.:';f::-:;>// -~ /
" I -I'" '4"~ ",U ,lf',' ",~ ,.,-
I ,!,r,~~~\}-E';:' I - ",' .U"
i I.. ~', J. 9f~ 8.~ &IE~ - -11,i~lll~:ll!~Ulr1rJll'II~lj I
1 ~\ I: . ~-.liF\. ~~:3'. ~r.~\. I~F;iifflj;~il~I~;lI,1
I' s:B ,~"J.. \:;,;'c;>>,' "rrmmmmmggllll'l , ~
vi ,-.';.'0/ - ~'=' -~
/,"", "'>';A -- -~ ~_----.::.' /\
:fl"(:Y.; 01 lON /
'E-
i
1-
;::~
i~
L-__
" , ~
I ; .J ,
, !
,- ....z
" 00
'-.J w -
i ,<
.-! II 00
~g
~ ,.
j ,
;~
-,
'.'~~
;
!. I 1
i 'i ;
i'l 1! I l
. II
I~:l Th
I II c.....~ ~~t1'1C~
ii,'
, , '
! "
..
':.,-11
-'----
,
,
1j
!! I'
L"J
I 1
Ol~
~ :!:
,
~ ~~!
le-
'I! ~
, , ~tiE
'I'
U
~961n
!
"
II it I! :
!j jr 11\
'I
II
~~~
.i
,
i
.,
.
,
,
I
-h "fJi
J ~ ~ ~\l'
jl
........ ---r ~~
"'___ IHJ.=~I
, j
,
~ .
--~
II
,-
~~
~ ~ ~
, 0"
V-
. "
,
,
.
g g~~! ~'\
,
a..
<(
L
UJ
l-
e/)
<.>
N
~,
"",
'"
<L
::.::::i
J'
""
'"
""
is
'"
"'
>
j
I
a..
<(
L
Z
o
~
u
o
...J
Agenda Item No. 16A9
November 27, 2007
Page 1 of 6
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to approve final acceptance of the water and sewer utility
facilities for Heritage Bay, Phase 1B
OBJECTIVE: The Board of County Commissioners, Ex-Officio the Governing Board of
the Collier County Water-Sewer District, to accept final and unconditional conveyance of
these water and/or sewer facilities.
CONSIDERATIONS:
1) The Developer of Heritage Bay, Phase 1 B, has constructed the water and sewer
facilities within dedicated easements to serve this development. See attached
location map.
2) Preliminary acceptance of these utility facilities was approved by the Engineering
Services Department staff on June 23, 2006. At that time, the value of these utility
facilities (assets) was $383,058.75 for the water facilities and $671,444 for the sewer
facilities (see attachment[s]). This final acceptance is in accordance with Collier
County Ordinance No. 2004-31, as amended.
,,_.
3) Staff recorded all preliminary acceptance documents in the public records of Collier
County, which have been reviewed and approved by the County Attorney's office as
to form and legal sufficiency.
4) The water and sewer facilities have been operated and maintained by the Collier
County Water-Sewer District during, not less than, the required one (1) year warranty
period.
5) A final inspection to discover defects in materials and workmanship has been
conducted by the Engineering Services Department staff, and these facilities have
been found to be satisfactory and acceptable.
6) The water utility infrastructure connected beyond the master meter is owned and
maintained by the owner.
7) The PUD Monitoring staff has reviewed this request in relation to possible issues
raised by the applicable Home Owners Association (HOA). Staff is unaware of any
issues that would serve to negate the recommendation to release the applicable
security.
-
FISCAL IMPACT: Approval of this Executive Summary will have no specific financial
impact. However, approval of this Executive Summary will result in the Collier County
Water-Sewer District receiving unconditional title to the utility facilities, which at the time
of preliminary acceptance, had a total (undepreciated) value of $1 ,054,502.75.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: Approval of this Executive Summary will have no
growth management impact.
Agenda Item I~o. 'i6A9
November 27, 2007
Page 2 of6
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: No additional legal review from the County Attorney is
required to complete this final acceptance.
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners, Ex-Officio the
Governing Board of the Collier County Water-Sewer District, authorize final acceptance
of these water and sewer utility facilities for Heritage Bay, Phase 1 B, and authorize the
County Manager, or his designee, to release any Utilities Performance Security (UPS) to
the Project Engineer or the Developer's designated agent.
PREPARED BY: Jodi Pannullo Hughes, Engineering Technician
Item Number:
Item Summary:
Meeting Date:
Page 1 of I
~\gGnIJ8 Itern f',Jo Hi.1.\9
l'.jewembet 27 2007
Pam) j of6
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARO OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
11_,,\<::.
RecommendatIOn to ,wpmve fdl81 dcu:p;ance of U'!!' w<lter arc sewe' iJlIllty~acllnles for
Hpr:tag~ Say. PI1f1Se 1,1'1
. 'iT.,':.'(!079:GCOOL"k,
!,dmi",Olnl.rivf-Ass'st<.m
[)ilt"
Prepared B~'
,Iodi P~r1flu11Cl
CPJmmunityDeveloprnentI>
e:nv'con"'ent~1 Services
CUES t"rlgirmer'ng ',~rvices
10.'2:112('107 J:18:0aPM
Dale
Approved By
.Jr)dy PlIig Dn"'ratlr::mr. Atwly~t
l0i23,'2Q:J~' , 2:: f'M
AppruvedBy
(:;omnll.ln,t\' Duv"lopmnnt i: ~':"mmunit\. [Jnv"",orm",nt /;
!"llYIC,mm"nl"iS,"rvlc'ls E;rlvir"nmcntH:S"rVIl:"<;{-,crmr
C:t('I",,,,n I". hinqy
','i~~,j~WiJi:'H C"iwc\<or" M,.",,,nN
,;nt,
".',,';1, 'Jll!iti",c
''.In'.:.!r1iJat",
1012,' 20(17 ,'.!'" i-',~'
;\pflrun'd By
"'",,, '_'I'
!ifiii
'1;'lT<"
'.':om..
r,,::,.V,:,,:)u
',',"'''''
r,f'
Appnlvcd B)
':"'"'"''
',,';',<;\
\pprovedBj
un', \Un',' ',"',,".:>pn.""
2:n'." ~)r,rl1en,,! ~''''S
,',vi((ll,ri'C''1t,,:
",',,,u,.PI,,,,'1'"
Dnr~
Al'prOl'ctl By
":MVr\",,;;~v'm"';
Community C'..velr::pmunt&
En'Jiro"mental Sf'l'~;c"e
z.ollint, & L.afIC! :>""elopmenl "",View
1112iZ007C4SPM
WasteWat,,,DiwClor
')Jt~,
Approved By
G GeargeYilmJl
Public Utilities
W"stel/Jatf!t'
1-li5/2DQ7eSfl PM
[xeculiveSecr....tary
[law
^Illlrovcd By
~',arlen(J Stewart
Communily D<1volopm<,ml &
Environmenta!Services
Community Devolopmern &
E:rn,ironmcnliJ: Sr.>rIriclls Admm
11i8/20Q73:22PM
Approved By
Jos~phK. Schmitt
Community Development 8;
EnvironmentaiServices
Community Development I>
Env'ronm"ntHlService5Actmin$tr~tor
O~ie
<;'ommunityDovelopmi!nt&
Environmental Sorvic('s Admin
11114120071:1.:11 PM
Date
Approved By
Roy8, Anderson.P.E.
Pubiic Utilitios
Public Utilitjes Engrneering DifE,cwr
Public UliiitlesE:ngjneenng
111141200712::21 PM
Date
Approved By
OMBCoor.dinator
Administrative Services
t.(Jplic"tionsAnaryst
inlormat,onTechnology
111141Z0074,33PM
Budget An"lyst
Date
Approved By
Mar~, Isackson
Couniy MJ:nager's Oflice
OHice of Mllnagemeni 8. Budget
111'1512007!U1AM
Datf>
Approved By
James\'. Mudd
BOMd of County
Commissioners
Count\' M..n"oer
Countl'Manager'sOfrice
1111C!200710:15AM
file://C:\AgendaTest\Export\93- Novem ber%2027. %202007\ 16, %20CONSENT%20AGEN.. 11/20/2007
.
.
!\qenda item No 16,L'-,9
,- November 2i 2007
Page 4 oi 6
CERTIFICATION OF CONTRIBUTORY ASSETS - COUNTY
PROJECT Heritage Bay Phase 1 B
LOCATlm Section 23, Township 48 South, Range 26 East
Collier County, Florida
OWNER: Bayvest, LLC
10492 Six Mile Cypress Parkway
Fort Myers FL 35912
ORIGINAL
TYPE OF UTILITY SYSTEM: POTABLE WATER
ITEM T SIZE UNIT # UNIT Unit Price TOTAL
16" PVC CL 150 Water Main 16" LF 8,159 $26.50 $216,213.50
16" PVC CL200 Water Main 16" LF 262 $28.50 $7,467.00
12" PVC CL 150 Water Main 12" LF 2,305 $15.45 $35,612.25
12" PVC CL200 Water Main 12" LF 113 $17.50 $1,977.50
10" PVC CL 150 Water Main 10" LF 1,347 $16.75 $22,562.25
10" PVC CL200 Water Main 10" LF 253 $17.25 $4,364.25
8" PVC CL 150 Water Main 8" LF 778 $7.25 $5,640.50
8" PVC CL200 Water Main 8" LF 264 $8.25 $2,178.00
6" PVC CL200 Water Main 6" LF 49 $6.50 $318.50
16" Gate Valve 16" EA 19 $2.250.00 $42,750.00
12" Gate Vaive 12" EA I 7 $850.00 $5,950.00
10" Gate Valve 10" EA 7 $800.00 $5,600.00
8" Gate Valve 8" EA 6 $700.00 $4,200.00
6" Gate Valve 6" EA 9 $450.00 $4,050.00
4" Gate Valve 4" EA 1 $375.00 $375.00
Perm. Samnle Point 1" EA 4 $775.00 $3,100.00
Sinnle Water Service ITvD.) 1" EA 27 $250.00 $6,750.00
Double Water Service (Typ.) 1 1/2" EA 30 $465.00 $13,950.00
I TOTAL COST $383,058.75
I do hereby certify that the quantities of material described above are a true and
accurate representation of the as-installed cost of the system.
CERTIFYING:
4~'
. /' /
Brliom Penner
OF: MITCHELL & STARK CONSTRUCTION CO, INC.
SEAL:
i;'I':l\"''-ii-,
:-:' .~ ,,;,
. .
.- '.
~i.~,'i..;i~~~J.i
RUSSELl H. DEJONGE
MY COMMISSION # DO 106258
EXPIRES: August 11, 2006
aonaedThruNota"l''''\IIlI~UndPlWI~er5
1124f2006-164221Ver:l.AHOI.l.AND
C/l.1I43
N0442.203-001. ESBM. 3Q235
.
.
Agenda item No. 16A9
November 27.2007
Page 5 of 6
CERTIFICATION OF CONTRIBUTORY ASSETS" COUNTY
PROJECT Heritage Bay Phase 1 B
LOCATlm Section 23, Township 48 South, Range 26 East
Collier County, Florida
OWNER: Bayvest, LLC
10492 Six Mile Cypress Parkway
Fort Myers, FL 35912
ORIGINAL
TYPE OF UTILITY SYSTEM: SANITARY SEWER
ITEM I SIZE UNIT #UNIT UNIT TOTAL
8" PVC Gravi\v SeweriO'-6' cun 8" LF 1520 $750 $11,400.00
8" PVC Gravitv Sewer 16'-8' cut) 8" LF 2268 $7.50 $17,010.00
8" pve GravITv Sewer (8'-10' cut) 8" LF 2253 $7.50 $16,897.50
8" pve GravrtVSewerl10'-12' culf 8" LF 2130 $7.50 $15,975.00
8" PVC Gravltv Sewerl12'-14' cut) 8" LF 1071 $7.50 $8,032.50
Manhoie 10'-6' cun 4' EA 11 $1,700.00 $18,700.00
Manhoie (6'-8' cut) 4' EA 7 $3,400.00 $23,800.00
Manhoie (8'-10' cut) 4' EA 7 $3',800.00 $26,600.00
Manhole (10'-12' GUn 4' EA 11 $4,800.00 $52,800.00
Manhole (12'-14' cut) 4' EA 5 $6,200.00 $31,000.00
Lift Stationl 8' EA 3 $96,50000 $289,500.00
10" PVC CL 150 Force Main 10" LF 5359 $16.75 $89,763.25
10" PVC CL200 Force Main 10" LF 165 $18.00 $2,970.00
8" PVC CL 150 Force Main 8" LF 1156 $8.00 $9,248.00
6" PVC CL 150 Force Main 6" LF 1493 $4.50 $6,718.50
6" PVC CL200 Force Main 6" LF 109 $5.50 $599.50
4" PVC CL 150 Force Main 4" LF 253 $3.75 $948.75
4" PVC CL200 Force Main 4" LF 172 $4.25 $731.00
10" PlUG Valve 10" EA 4 $1,000.00 $4,000.00
8" PlUG Valve 8" EA 1 $750.00 $750.00
4" Pluo Valve 4" EA 5 $450.00 $2,250.00
Air Release Valve 2" LF 12 $650.00 $7,800.00
Sinale Sanitarv Sewer Laleral 6" EA 47 $484.04 $22,750.00
Double Sanitary Sewer Lateral 6" EA 28 $400.00 $11,200.00
1 TOTAL COST $671,444.00
I do hereby certify that the quantities of material described above are a true and
accurate representation of the as-installed cost of the system.
CERTIFYING:
d /--
/,../~
Brian Penner
OF: MITCHELL & STARK CONSTRUCTION CO. INC.
as signed and acknowledged before me this _16_ day of _March_,
o is personally known to me and who did not take an oath.
SEAL:
I /";:'~'" RUSSELL H. DEJONGE
;.!.,~.r.6."t;l MY COMMISSION I DD 106258
)!~'~'p'<;.i EXPIRES: Augusll1, 2006
~L ~<(~r.:t~*" !londedThru NoIaly Public UndelWr~~ls
1/241'200li-164221Ver:l.AHOLLAND
C"",
~0442-203.oo, .ESBM.30235
OJ 1'-- (0
~go
-N",
ci ~- ill
z~'..r ~
:=1:iCL
~-@
~~
;::::)
QiZ
:7,
<(
"'
w _
~;s
~
:'00
~
I. .~-
I -----
z
o
w-
i- ~
Q) S j
. '.
"\\ 'y
--<.\::---."" '. If'
-- "\'\ill! /~lH
--k~~~~ 8gc~,J
! 1 ;g~t~f'::l]
, "e/"", ,- /
1'---1 \ '0// \ '--------
.' Jrl ) i------------------____.. I
z
='",,"" I ___
- .
" .-
ru...l:ll""ronoo
. .-
s:iIl.L\,lI">O<TIOO
.",,",
SlIo-lJ:).1l"llM'UlO!l
"J....,.....J.Slll...~
.1.<1....
=oiS.:ll"'""",,,
".I.""'
run>JllOS""",,,
!
Ell
., h
C
l
!
5"
.,"':
"
i
o
.... z ~
~Q
~!<
00
g:g
,
,
a
<(
L
w
~I
.
'"
~
o
"'
'"
'"
'"
0-
>-
'"
"',
"'
'"
'"
....
~
~ I!
,
'- 15.
"'~i . a
"
i I' <(
L
~ , ~
~ z
c. ".
-. . 0
" j 'i
" -
i , I ~
i
, ! U
, 0
'. e.
. . ...J
". ~;
i !
w,
j
. ..,
""'0.1."'
ll",OO(T'(lO
,
,
,
,
0
>-
~
z H
"
0 j
u
~ , ,
.~ ,
~
'f.....,DI<l !
I~_._._------
l ~ , l,
D , , . ~-L-1 """"''l'"''''
(""'l.,...."""'. -..
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Agenda item No. 16,1\10
Hovember 27. 2007
Page 1 of 6
Recommendation to approve final acceptance of the water and sewer utility
facilities for Forest Park, Phase 4
OBJECTIVE: The Board of County Commissioners, Ex-Officio the Governing Board of
the Collier County Water-Sewer District, to accept final and unconditional conveyance of
these water and/or sewer facilities.
CONSIDERATIONS:
1) The Developer of Forest Park, Phase 4, has constructed the water and sewer
facilities within dedicated easements to serve this development. See attached
location map.
2) Preliminary acceptance of these utility facilities was approved by the Engineering
Services Department staff on December 29, 2004. At that time, the value of these
utility facilities (assets) was $64,358.94 for the water facilities and $99,645.52 for the
sewer facilities (see attachment[s]). This final acceptance is in accordance with
Collier County Ordinance No. 2004-31, as amended.
3) Staff recorded all preliminary acceptance documents in the public records of Collier
County, which have been reviewed and approved by the County Attorney's office as
to form and legal sufficiency,
("-~
4) The water and sewer facilities have been operated and maintained by the Collier
County Water-Sewer District during, not less than, the required one (1) year warranty
period.
5) A final inspection to discover defects in materials and workmanship has been
conducted by the Engineering Services Department staff, and these facilities have
been found to be satisfactory and acceptable.
6) The PUD Monitoring staff has reviewed this request in relation to possible issues
raised by the applicable Home Owners Association (HOA). Staff is unaware of any
issues that would serve to negate the recommendation to release the applicable
security.
FISCAL IMPACT: Approval of this Executive Summary will have no specific financial
impact. However, approval of this Executive Summary will result in the Collier County
Water-Sewer District receiving unconditional title to the utility facilities, which at the time
of preliminary acceptance, had a total (undepreciated) value of $164,004.46.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: Approval of this Executive Summary will have no
growth management impact.
,..,-
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: No additional legal review from the County Attorney is
required to complete this final acceptance.
Agenda Item No. 16A 10
November 27, 2007
F'age 2 of 6
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners, Ex-Officio the
Governing Board of the Collier County Water-Sewer District, authorize final acceptance
of these water and sewer utility facilities for Forest Park, Phase 4, and authorize the
County Manager, or his designee, to release any Utilities Performance Security (UPS) to
the Project Engineer or the Developer's designated agent.
PREPARED BY: Jodi Pannullo Hughes, Engineering Technician
Item Number:
Item Summary:
Meeting Date:
Page 1 of I
MQell::;,', 118111 r~O, 16.6,10
.. November 27 2CJOi'
Page:j (JiG
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
;1_;,'"10
F(;.~omrllt~' aM,on te, appr'CJ'/E' final n>::ceotanco? of tfl-:' v,atee ilnd .,(IWer Uti!:,\, l;.cilr1ies tor
.-- Gl'ust f'!ir~, "'!U'l~;~"
:'1;,7!;', Do' S.OG(i(j!\M
Adrn,nl",r"t,V("\r:,,tSli1flt
Prepared By
Imh I~a""ull"
~:ommunny Development &
,';n<Jironmel1t"I~rvice~
CUES t'.ng'''"erin<:; Se,,/ic~~
1012:)t:'on7?:::':,U6Pllll
L>nte
Approved By
,Juil,""lIig
,'J:}UJitow,AnJlv",t
',.C;tl1flnW1\'. [j~vt>l[;p",,-,n~ I': ,';urnnH""tv ')~'J("C)prrt-r.i IJ
"flV1r"n'T1~nt~i ~:"C;itCP', t\dfllln
")I2.2-/zr,,, :'",pr..'
bwi""")1""nli.'! ~i"VI('(-'S
i____,,,<,
.<\pprHvcd By
S"":'l(" \jJt'v
1'.t..nl"'.l}tll"i.."
""'<.h'W_":?
";,,,,,,,,,1,""'''(1'''
'\."~H,'\I-)"t{),
1('j;2J ;-C'()~' j!, l f'
"w.,"
I\.':~'l
Approved By
,.,,, ~ ,t dJi',.,
!\pl'fnHdHy
c--,h,'-
':'r.
.\pproved By
':'"m,:",-"l'/i n-; "'I,;n,,'"
:l:"'-"'r',"(:c'"
''''is''''),,-,,
(:.-?'-;,'~"'-i:
LJln
Appr{Ovcd By
;\;""'JP,,',,', [,j,,'c", ,.,0.
C'Jn1munitv(!""eiopm,mt&
E...'!ironrnenlal Se'''1tCe~
Senwc""lannc,
;':ol1ing& L.and D,w"'opn,entH() leV!
11'2.120Clj i250PR(
Oil'"
Approved Ur
G Ge(.rgeYilmal
Public Utilities
W"'sleW~tet'Dire"lOr
W<lsti'V...\er
11/6i20079:CiJPM
Dute
Approved B}'
MHlem, ~~l,,'wurt
COmmunity Development &
t:!l'1'fOr"nflt1laIS"rvic('s
Exe~ul>v", -S",cret..ry
ComlYlllllilyDeveiopment&
EnvironmentaISeflficc!;!\dmin
111B1200';' 3:25 PM
Approved By
Jo':;Cpi1 K Schmitt
Communil\, Developmel1t &
EnvirollmBnta!Services
Community Development&.
Erovironm"ntal Services Aaminstrator
Dale
Cnmmull1lyDevvlopme"t&
Environll1*"taISerJicesA1mln
111141200712:12 PM
Date
Appro\'cd By
RoyS, Anuen;on. r,E
Public Utilities
P:Jblic Utilities Engineeri...g Dimetor
nubli<;; Utilities Engineering
111141200712:22PM
Date
Appruved By
OMB Coordinator
Aamil1istrntiveServices
ApphcalionsAnalyst
Informa!ionTechnology
,1114120074:34 PM
Date
Approved By
M~rh ISi<ckson
County Manage"s Offic~
Burl,,"'l iqlnlyst
Olile,,",,! M"nagemenl & Budget
11"1512007 \l,5, AM
[;"Ie
Approved By
JamesV. Mudd
Board 01 County
Comm,ssioners
COllnty ManZlQer
County ~1,an1lyer's Office
11116.'200710:22 AM
file://C:\AgendaTest\Export\93~ Novemher%2027 ,%202007\ 16. %20CONSENTo/020AGEN.. 11/20/2007
.. . AQ(mda Item :'0. 16A10
_TIFICATION OF CONTRIBUTORY AS ' . COUN~ovember 27. 2001.
Page 4 of b
PROJECT NAME:
Forest Park Phase 4
~(Q)[?JW
LOCATION: a portion of East Y, and East 1/6 and West Y, of Section 33, Township 49S, Range 26E, Collier
County, Florida
NAME & ADDRESS OF OWNER:
Forest Park Development, 75 East Market Street, Akron, Ohio 44308
TYPE OF UTILITY SYSTEM: Potable Water (Malerials Only)
liTEM SIZE QUANTITY UNIT COST TOTAL
PVC C900 DR18 CL 150 8" 3617 If $4.42 $15,987.14
PVC C900 DR14 CL200 8" 627 If $5.58 $3,498.66
Gate Valve & Box 8" 15 ea $558.62 $8,379.30
11 1/4 Degree Bend 8" 10 ea $137.80 $1,378.00
22 Y, Degree Bend 8" 19 ea $137.80 $2,618.20
45 Degree Bend 8" , ea $135.68 $949.76
,
Fire Hydrant Assembly 13 ea $1,22006 $15,860.78
Single Water Service 37 ea $87.93 $3,25341
Double Water Service 33 ea $183.54 $6,056.82
Air Release Valve 5 ea $517 .81 $2,589.05
Permanent Bacterial Sample Point 4 ea $471.81 $1,887.24
Blow Off Assembly 8" 2 ea $950.29 $1,900.58
TOTAL COST $64,358.94
I do hereby certify that the quantilies of material described above are true and accurate representation of the as-
installed cost of !he system.
an
the Islands Construction, Inc.
STATE OF FLORIDA )
)SS:
COUNTY OF COLLIER )
The foregoing instrument was signed and acknowledged before me this 2it!tL day of ffb., I , 2004, by _
!JonI'( /lhiJrJ/1 who is personally known to me and who did not take an oa!h. ,.., "O:'H'~;n"!I'".:
,..:. - of',\r.>o a;lo:.~~-<
SEAL: ,$ ':> ......:......c"2 .~-....
~ ~ ~ ..~~\S;:,JON~.. ....~
~ .",,<:::i 16 1::-t,<J". ~,
~ ."~ .;:,."'~ ''?o/, ?'"'l'~ -::
~J. ( ~ :'" 'i .,"t~"
~*: ...- :*~
~ z, ~ #00113821 .:!?:E
~/>.. :Sl::.
~~)-...~~~ ...cr~"~
~.. "7,:,~..u:.~;-.~ <<~,:'
. . Agenda Item No. 16A10
CE CATION OF CONTRIBUTORY ASSET OUNTY November 27,2007
Page 5 of 6
PROJECT NAME:
Forest Park Phase 4
LOCATION: a portion of East Y, and East 116 and West Y, of Section 33, Township 49S, Range 26E, Collier County,
Florida
NAME & ADDRESS OF OWNER:
Forest Park Deveiopment, 75 East Market Slreet, Akron, Ohio 44308 PROJECT
NAME: Tollgate Business Park, Phase 1
LOCATION: a portion of land located in Section 35, Township 49S, Range 26E, and Section 2, Township 50S, Range
26E, Collier County, Florida
TYPE OF UTILITY SYSTEM: Sanitary Sewer (Materials Only)
lITEM SIZE QUANTITY UNIT COST TOTAL
PVC Sewer Pipe (0-6') 8" 1280 If $2.84 $3,635.20
PVC Sewer Pipe (6' - 8') 8" 1038 If $2.84 $2,947.92
PVC Sewer Pipe (8' - 10') 8" 860 If $2.84 $2,442.40
PVC Sewer Pipe (10' - 12') 8" 663 If $2.84 $1,882.92
Manhole (0-6') 4' 12 ea $1,477.64 $17,731.68
Manhole (6' - 8') 4' 5 ea $2,056.40 $10,282.00
Manhole (8' - 10') 4' 2 ea $2,489.94 $4,979.88
Manhole (10' - 12') 4' 2 ea $2,987.08 $5,974.16
Service Laterals 6" 2602 If $1.64 $4,267.28
Single Clean Outs 6" 45 ea $61.08 $2,748.60
Double Clean Outs 6" 29 ea $61.08 $1,771.32
PVC Force Main CL 150 Pipe 6" 1090 If $2.72 $2,964.80
PVC Force Main CL200 Pipe 6" 40 If $3.43 $137.20
Air Release Valve 2 ea $1,332.95 $2,665.90
Pump Station 1 ea $35,214.26 $35,214.26
TOTAL COST $99,645.52
I do hereby certify that the quantities of material described above are true and accurate representation of the as-installed
cost of the system.
\\\\\'Hllllii~1 .
;'\\ . u 'I,",
,~''c.of.\a nernalfo; I,;;,
~ -;:l .e.......l9.?/r;
S .."*,,\\5SJO..y €"'. ~.
~ /:J.....f:Jj~e'B,2a:..r'%...-::
:: :.:; ':,-.:s 05' '1;,".
~*: ..4;1 :*
~z ~ #OD113821 .:
~s... .2f~
~~;~.~~d~l~ .~'Cf~:
,...,..,;OI./.....~~..,:_~',-,,:
,-",;oLtc !=:TAi'C 0'..:,'
'1/-':/II!!l\\',"-
STATE OF FLORIDA )
)SS:
COUNTY OF COLLIER)
The foregoing instrument was signed and acknowledged before me this /bin day of my
mOOf1n who is personally known to me and who did not take an oath.
,-~d i/Un~ SEAL:
, 2004, by He/It"!
-^"~ :~:~- \
~ j! I J
.'"~'~ : ;i - }~~~
Ji8 ir I!~ ~~\ \y~
,tj \ lp ~~gR
..":,~~ ~liIrF1^, ~-l-\'Y
-l.... t! 1 /J .... "-"HTIir ~,,_ ~-T'
- """ ""'" ---) ~j r~ r:::1i L; , /\ \-1
R' I' - t::1- I r=--~ ,. '-=x:, V C I
-L --~~ / 1= ~j' ~ -rJ 111- f-=r-:~
..; -. [jr j:--t=jl::- l'jV'f(
/ (\-LU1-I:t, :---~ ;--- r/;....;:::/ c_
, ~. ."."","' --~ ,.- 1=' ,~,-' ^ \:"\
::': ''r-'ITII ''l: : , ! "', "["-.j' "Y'- \
\-1 r' -- ,--- -- ~ ~ ' " . _'.___--\ \.----',
,~- . "I~L--i . ,- -, r:::: c ,--(:c,H '-.'_
1---- L--I---.-'~t-----'---1l j f- r=. "--._!,' I "l'
~ :--!, i ;uJ:,___j----; e--=:1 f-:::'l~.-- ':,J,.,;;.-~__j
---, I---t---"..f-r~' r i :-1i"1: '/ /!'2~'.
/'CiT\"Ti :--:-T-r--:----:tj~:=L----J !.- '-<'.' "'" i/
\._)--',+,--tn--;,:,s~-' f~~-f!/'-'>'
'-\-\'-<;ll: r~-i-;- fm--: i-{~!--(
\ ' :'~-I-t--n-i--'---r-I---- , _OJ ..-:_t-.;)
<\:~~-'~~~~~~~L()~,,:-~,=~::::--~_J- ~
,. - I ftjH
=. r---. (0
:; :=:'0
:...,('-': (D
r__ -:j)
~~i i?
-~ 1:/~
~=
~::' Q)
82
,-.:::;..
,1)
<l
'^ ~ w~ ~
~gg i 8ei
t t
"
:;Il; " .
q-
I ! ,E
.. ~~
"
~ , ,
"I ,
L " ~~
0' " .'
-;li - ;1: ~ I'
I I !
~i1~~ -
'wi ~
",,,,;,, "
IS ~ \I.
,
.. ~;;: ~
->l~'
..
GIIV/\TlnOll ~,
~i",
1-
t
.,
-~!
I
!'
,/
-J iJl~-'
I w'2 I
, '= ~ ~__.__.--1-~______
lOOp
I
I
I
1
I
I
,
I
,
"
.
""",.,"'""
E-
a..
<{
L
w
~
CI)
.".
lLJ
(/)
<(
.
.~
gi
~
"'-
Ct:
<(
(L
l-
(/)
W
Ct:
o
u..
~
~
,
-
"
"
,il
~~b
a"",A",
.. ,
i
~ I
i
.!
.
,
~~
ip
Hi
a.. 1
<{
L
,
z
o
~
<{
U
o
-l
~
;
~~
~~
!
,
,
,
!t
II'
,
l
,
,---
"
~! ~
o /..-v>c'" ~~mOJ
l
;
,
I
w
>-
::: (3
I
z
w
"
<5
- co
,~~
i
i
!
"
i
,
"
". ~"'''lR'''
~
I I' III j
f ~! $1~
!
,
~t
;l".,<>xwffiJ~
~!I
.
1,-
;5!:'-
.__.L
....<$>
---
=~~"""'''I... ~H
~~
,"
,
~~
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Agenda Item ;-<0. 16A 11
November 27,2007
Page 1 of 6
Recommendation to approve final acceptance of the water and sewer utility
facilities for North Naples Research and Technology Park
OBJECTIVE: The Board of County Commissioners, Ex-Officio the Governing Board of
the Collier County Water-Sewer District, to accept final and unconditional conveyance of
these water and/or sewer facilities.
CONSIDERATIONS:
1) The Developer of North Naples Research and Technology Park, has constructed the
water and sewer facilities within dedicated easements to serve this development.
See attached location map.
2) Preliminary accel'ltance of these utility facilities was approved by the Engineering
Services Department staff on December 29, 2005. At that time, the value of these
utility facilities (assets) was $55,086 for the water facilities and $99,930.50 for the
sewer facilities (see attachment[s]). This final acceptance is in accordance with
Collier County Ordinance No. 2004-31, as amended.
",--.,
3) Staff recorded all preliminary acceptance documents in the public records of Collier
County, which have been reviewed and approved by the County Attorney's office as
to form and legal sufficiency.
4) The water and sewer facilities have been operated and maintained by the Collier
County Water-Sewer District during, not less than, the required one (1) year warranty
period.
5) A final inspection to discover defects in materials and workmanship has been
conducted by the Engineering Services Department staff, and these facilities have
been found to be satisfactory and acceptable.
6) The PUD Monitoring staff has reviewed this request in relation to possible issues
raised by the applicable Home Owners Association (HOA). Staff is unaware of any
issues that would serve to negate the recommendation to release the applicable
security.
FISCAL IMPACT: Approval of this Executive Summary will have no specific financial
impact. However, approval of this Executive Summary will result in the Collier County
Water-Sewer District receiving unconditional title to the utility facilities, which at the time
of preliminary acceptance, had a total (undepreciated) value of $155,016.50.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: Approval of this Executive Summary will have no
growth management impact.
,- LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: No additional legal review from the County Attorney is
required to complete this final acceptance.
.tI,aenda IteiTl f\lo.16A.11
- November 27< 2'007
Page 2 of 6
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners, Ex-Officio the
Governing Board of the Collier County Water-Sewer District, authorize final acceptance
of these water and sewer utility facilities for North Naples Research and Technology
Park, and authorize the County Manager, or his designee, to release any Utilities
Performance Security (UPS) to the Project Engineer or the Developer's designated
agent.
PREPARED BY: Jodi Pannullo Hughes, Engineering Technician
...-.
Item Number:
ltemSummllry:
Meeting Date:
Pagelofl
i\qr:n:::Ja hem No. '!6!\,11
, ~h /cmbBi' 27, ::007
Pclqc :J of {)
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMM!SSIONERS
16;.11
1<") ~,,,nrr,endatlo'1 t'J app" ve fin,,; aCCH)t<lnU; ot lr,c. 'iiB101 nnrl ,,",we,. ',JIII!!\; r'Clc,ILI",," for Un,ti'
t",ple" F,r"~eBrctl and "I <JC~lil()logy "nrr,
lit ,,",.,'J/ ','Q()'OC !l,M
AclministriltivE!>s<;,star!t
D~lo
Preparetl By
J"d, Plll1nullo
Communit)' D",-,'elop,nent&
Envim,,,nemaISelvlces
CDES!::nginocerin\l S"r''',ces
HJi2S/?Q07 ~,3e ,,?"M
Walee(JperationsMan'lS!cr
eMf'"
Approved By
F"l'l<cl,'-, Lii.'by
Pul>l,:;!Jlilities
Vhki'
1(),'2i;1007;' 22 PM
.I'h,ll:" ;'0''''\0'
i',~te
Apf)ruved By
"';;Vi litilll~LJ"ch
''''ul>I'cc l.'tiiit;f'~
'v\;\I<O'"
'/2:20)7 jl:M;A~'
'~i' ,,""''' ,. ".~,;,.
\-,-jJS".''''-''-''1'.t!''d"",-;,or.'';'f.''''''''',,,
ApI)r,lVed By
"-'":I,,'Ublii,,,:
Al'prflwtl B)
r)"".,C"'J
Apprll\'cd B}
C.Ut!II(.i:':it,,'i,,'
\f.'^";t<"\f,-,,,.,,y
;'Jtc
Appro\'ed By
~l:arj'~m :'''eWd'', 'O:x(>cwli"c """em;.')'
11!8120G7J.27?f\I:
-\pfnovedBy
'>-mtrramit:i f)w,.-c,IGPmw:: & '-.()mrnunitv De'ielopm",,: iI.
Env,ronmel1tal Snrv'c{'s E"nvironnmr:lal Sorv;ee'. Atltmn
M~ryAnn De"an~s
Com'THmily Deveiopmc.nl &
EnvironmentalServkes
Sen,o-Planner
Dare
Zoning & L..1fld DevelopmentRIl'/lew
1118120074:$3 PM
Date
Approved By
Wilt,amD LOFet1z,Jr..PE.
Community Dtlvl1topment&.
ErwironmemalServices
ErTlIir()nmentaISerllice~Dimctor
EnlllronmentilIServicE'~
1111412f1078:57f,M
Approved By
Jo~eph K. Schmitt
Ct'nHnunity D~veloprTlcnt 8-
Envimnmel1taIS'?r'iiGes-
Community Develo~ml1"l &
Environmental Service~ Adminstrator
Dal(l
Cornmclnil,' Developmunt &
[nviml1mentalServicB5Admirt
1111412~[\712;13 PM
Public Utilities Engineerin9 Director
Dale
Approved By
Roy 6. AnCierson,P,E
Publk Utilities
Public Utilities Engine.ering
111141200712:2€PM
Applications Analyst
Date
Appruved By
OMS Coordinator
Admimstmt.iveSer!ices
InfonnMionTechnology
11/14i20U74:34PM
Budg<ltAnalyst
Dale
Appnl\'ed By
Mark Isacks-on
Count\' Manager's Office
Ofr,ce 01 M'magernent & Budget
1111'i17007249PM
D~te
Approved By
JamesV.Mudd
BO:lrdofCmmty
Comrnissioners
County Manager
County Manager's Office
1111C;200? 10:25AM
file://C:\AgendaTest\Export\93-November%2027, %202007\ 16. %20CONSENT%20AGEN.. 11/20/2007
.
.
Agenda Item I~o. 16A 11
November 27, 2007
Page 4 of 6
PROJECT NAME: North Naples Research and Technogoly Park
CERTIFICATh.. . OF COST CONTRIBUTORY ASSETS - ( :NTY
LOCATION: Section 10 Township 48 S Range 25 E
Collier County. Florida
NAME & ADDRESS OF OWNER: The SJG Land Trust
16979 Old US 41
Naples. FL 34110
TYPE OF UTILITY SYSTEM: POTABLE WATER (MATERIALS ONLY)
QUANTITIES SIZES DESCRIPTION
1 Ea. 16" x 12" Reducer (SEMJ)
1390 LF 12" C-900 CL 150
200 LF 12" C-900 CL 200
1 Ea. 121l Gate Valve
4 Ea. 12" 45" Bend
1 Ea. 12" x 6" Anchor Tee
1 Ea. 12" x 10" Reducer (LEMJ)
380 LF 10" C-900 CL 150
815 LF 10" C-900 CL 200
4 Ea. 10" Gate Valve
2 Ea. 10" Tee
9 Ea. 10" 111W Bend
3 Ea. 10" 22 1/2" Bend
7 Ea. 10" 45" Bend
3 Ea. 10" x 6" Anchor Tee
2 Ea. 10" x 6" Reducer (PE x PEl (LEMJ)
1 Ea. Air Release Valve Assembly
80 LF 6" C-900 CL 150
1 Ea. 6" Anchor 90' Bend
2 Ea. Permanent Bacterial Sample Point
100 LF 18" Casing
110 LF 10" Carrier Pipe
TOTAL COST
~(Q)[P)V'
UNIT PRICE
413.00
9.10
11.50
1,010.00
241.00
300.00
155.00
6.40
8.20
850.00
330.00
220.00
220.00
220.00
300.00
100.00
500.00
5.00
100.00
520.00
80.00
80.00
TOTAL COST
413.00
12,649.00
2,300.00
1,010.00
964.00
300.00
155.00
2,432.00
6,683.00
3,400.00
660.00
1,980.00
660.00
1,540.00
900.00
200.00
500.00
400.00
100.00
1,040.00
8,000.00
8,800.00
55,086.00
I do hereby certify that the quantities of materials described above are a true and accurate representation of
of the system being contributed to Collier County,
~
. ansan, President
OF: Jensen Underground Utilities, Inc.
5585 Taylor Road
Naples, FL 34109
STATE OF FLORIDA)
) SS:
COUNTY OF COLLIER )
.... . .._.__.. ....__._._______11....__..._,,_____..1............:..._.........1,.................
The foregoing Instrument was signed and acknowledged before me this 22nd day of June, 2005 by
. -
. .
CERTlFICA Tk OF COST CONTRIBUTORY ASSETS -' .1 INTY
Agenda Item NO.1 GA 11
November 27, 2007
Page 5 Of 6
-
PROJECT NAME: North Naples Research and Tech;;og~IY P~rk
LOCATION: Section 10 Township 48 S Range 25 E
Collier County. Florida
NAME & ADDRESS OF OWNER: The SJG Land Trust
16979 Old US 41
Naples, FL 34110
ce(Q)L0~
TYPE OF UTILITY SYSTEM: SANITARY SEWER (MATERIALS ONLY)
QUANTITIES SIZES DESCRIPTION UNIT PRICE TOTAL COST
1007 LF 4" C-900 CL 150 1.50 1,510.50
395 LF 4" C-900 CL 200 200.00 79,000.00
3 Ea. 4" Plug Valve 400.00 1,200.00
1 Ea. 4" Wye 220.00 220.00
1 Ea. 4" 11114" Bend 100.00 100.00
9 Ea. 4" 45' Bend 100.00 900.00
100 LF 12" Casing 80.00 8,000.00
110 LF 4" Carrier Pipe 80.00 8,800.00
1 Ea. 12" x 4" Reducer 200.00 200.00
TOTAL COST 99,930.50
I do hereby certify that the quantities of materials described above are a true and accurate representation of
of the system being contributed to Collier County.
CERTIFYING:
evinJ
, President
Jensen Underground Utilities, Inc.
5585 Taylor Road
Naples. FL 34109
STATE OF FLORIDA)
) SS:
COUNTY OF COLLIER )
The foregoirg instrument was signed and acknowledged before me this 22nd day of June, 2005 by
Kevin Jens n, w Is rson known to me and who did not take an oath,
SEAL:
~
"""'f,
....m.~...' ".~ DONNA L WNDGREN
i:" .iNolory PublIc . State of Florida
,;", !Mvc...,...... ,1lqoIeo.kn 1.2007
"":ff,'?rl~ Commlsalon 1/ 00199598
,/
_r-.. to
;;60
,.2) N to
-r--:Q..1
::iN ~
~~o..
~~
m=
:=::Q)
;t, 6
::2::;:
ill
:J)
<(
I
I I~O""~ll'"
Zl~--.L I lJJ. J' r
'! L ~~~ ~
~ ~J ,II ~1~~'~1~ - -~-I I=-~
, "I ,I "'''r-T ':::CT--
-, "-, i ! Ii, i . r=-j
-- - -'I,' --, 1_,
"'-;'-~- I I ! I i: -.I
i -[- L':~ ,:tJ ~ct-~
-----~
.~..... J. J "'"_~ '"
......,>-,1
I -
~----
:D'o'J,<ll_D" /
-
-.--
a.
<i
~
LLJ
I-
-I
(/)1
~
~
<l
"-
,..
'"
o
-'
g
:I:
U
w
...
s;
<l
C
~
<l
w
'"
w
~
[Z
t'
<l
Z
:I:
...
~
g
a.
<i
~
,
z
o
~
u
o
..J
IL
-,
~;
.!
"'
~t;;i'i
~u
g
i'
~I "'~::::'
"
I' I ~ i' ! ,i//'\
ILI1' ll_,~'-;__
I'::Y;-~nI~~~~
~. ,C:=J '-'III'iJ~'"r' 'J
~~!~ ~ ~jl~~j\
--'h < ',"'/.,/
-:~ ~,q - "". \
IlbIClI(WYlU.$
.~
"~
,--('0""'"
\,,,,,)0&>11<"
~
l.
,-_:""')~ ;;,1
~€ ~m
TOo<"OI<C
l'V""'"
Ii J
"
',-
~~~ l!i
,.
O~\;'~d~;Wd"'.
O~
,..
...
Z
"
o
u
~ h
l !'
~;-;:!l ':!
@~.e. :i~
!j
j!
::'1
~tll ~"_
O'I,n
, "
"""""""'I.H1CIOQOlw:lY0fl{
(10& '~';)) """1l3'flO."",,~_.
!I
h.'S'~) 1IJ.....,.....l
g~i'"
, -
,
1............'TAAll.- "
(U.s.") III
!,. "I ,
~d "
j MEXICO
-is;:1 OF
! i ~ 5 GULF
Agenda Item No. 16A 12
November 27, 2007
Page 1 of 8
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to approve for recording the final plat of Ave Maria Unit 6, Bellerawalk
Phase 1 B, approval of the standard form Construction and Maintenance Agreement and
approval of the amount of the performance security
OBJECTIVE:
To approve for recording the final plat of Ave Maria Unit 6, Bellerawalk Phase 1 B, a subdivision
of lands located in Section 8, Township 48 South, Range 29 East, Collier County, Florida,
following the alternative procedure for approval of subdivision plats pursuant to Resolution 99-
199.
CONSIDERATIONS:
~-.
Engineering Services Department has completed the review of the construction drawings,
specifications, and final plat of Ave Maria Unit 6, Bellerawalk Phase 1 B. These documents are
in compliance with the County Land Development Code and Florida State Statute No. 177. All
fees have been paid. Security in the amount of 10% of the total cost of the required
improvements, and 100% of the cost of any remaining improvements, together with a
Construction and Maintenance Agreement for Subdivision Improvements, shall be provided and
accepted by the Engineering Services Director and the County Attorney's office prior to the
recording of the final plat. This would be in conformance with the County Land Development
Code -- Section 10.02.04.
Engineering Services Department recommends that the final plat of Ave Maria Unit 6,
Bellerawalk Phase 1 B be approved for recording.
FISCAL IMPACT:
The project cost is $2,041,766.20 (estimated) to be borne by the
developer.
The cost breakdown is as follows:
a)
b)
Water & Sewer
Drainage,
Paving, Grading
- $1,220,949.31
- $ 820,816.89
The Security amount, equal to 110% of the
project cost, is $2,245,942.82
The County will realize revenues as follows:
,-
Fund: Community Development Fund 131
Agency: County Manager
Cost Center: 138327 -- Engineering Project Review
Revenue generated by this project: Total: $25,849.51
l\osnda hem No. 16,;;::)
.~ November 27, 2007
Fees are based on a construction estimate of $820,816.89 (does not incllft.la'EAVef 8
Maria Utilities) and were paid in April, 2006.
The breakdown is as follows:
a) Plat Review Fee ($1,000.00 + $5./ac) -$ 1,225.00
b) Construction Drawing Review Fee
Water &
Sewer (.75% const. est.) - n/a
c) Drainage,
Paving, Grading (.75% const. est.) - $ 6,156.13
d) Construction Inspection Fee
Water &
Sewer (2.25% const. est.) - n/a
e) Drainage, Paving,
Grading(2.25%const.est.) - $18,468.38
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT:
The developer must receive a Certificate of Adequate Public Faciiities prior to the issuance of
the construction plan final approval letter.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS:
The County Attorney's Office has reviewed and approved the plat and associated legal
documents for legal sufficiency.
RECOMMENDATION:
That the Board of County Commissioners approve the final plat of Ave Maria Unit 6,
Bellerawalk Phase 1B for recording with the following stipulations:
1. Approve the amount of $2,245,942.82 as performance security for the required
improvements; or such lesser amount based on work completed, and as is approved by the
Engineering Services Department.
2. Approve the standard form Construction and Maintenance Agreement, and
a. That no Certificates of Occupancy be granted until the required improvements have
received preliminary acceptance.
b. That the plat not be recorded until suitable security and an appropriate Construction
and Maintenance Agreement is approved and accepted by the Engineering Services
Department Director and the County Attorney's office.
Any member of the public or any County Commissioner wishing to review this plat
prior to final approval may contact the Engineering and Environmental Services
Department at 252-5757 to set up an appointment to review this plat at the
Community Development and Environmental Services Division, 2800 N. Horseshoe
Drive
PREPARED BY: John Houldsworth, Senior Engineer, Engineering Review Department
ltemNumber;
Item Summary:
Meeting Date;
Page I of 1
f\qenda hem No 16P,12
. NOVEmr)er 27, 2DD7
P.sgo 30fS
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
16A12
Tt-:is l~e!T r,"qun~s t!IB! e~ ?Bft(~ (j:~:;I()sur(, bf' n:wlde~ by (u!T!Tjssion lVIember~, Sl10uld a
!kcHIrI;1 t.iC' nelo on Pm Item "II {JmtlclcC!nl~ ,'f';: required 10 tlP S\VOH' i!1 PpcornmnldatlD'l tl'
-'"r'1"'" Iw "ecuf..::ing In". flrwl pl,;1 ot .:c.,V{' r.Aaha 0",i" ;:'"lIera1i,1Ik D~las" ; tl 3pp,,!VC!lof
1'". :;!awJa, ~ lmT:' COn~;lIL1~; 'N' in," 1\;1"i'118IVW'C"" ,i",(1ri'')rn"n' ;,wd a"1)['01,'(11::;; 1;1'0' ~,Jr!;oun:. nf
1'",,'pc:rtc''-'lnn'C'';l'(\Irll''
. '/>7:2'j~0 ^)'JWI.L;M
SNlicrf,npllluer
()"te
Prepared By
John Houldsworlh
t:ommlmil~' Development &
E<wir<1nment":Service,,
["'girw€nn0"er'JI;e~
\ ^,i9f~OC" ~} ,20, 3f' .~JI'\
S,"-" C;b"~'''''''1Vr;!<;
f;r"<.Iine~ring po,vi",\' fi'",m19N
01\\('
Approved By
':;;"",rnu,.i1,." D""t.\,>pmcrlt(;
i',nv;r()nn)"'nt~1 ~,;'r' '''"'',
r'r.;.I"",e,'II'I\l2',':"'IlCDS
i jl~)i2(!()i" 1'"'' "fA
r,"dripn< ;';I',""""j
"'i!ll':":';,"U,..",','
ApprovedRy
,',(lwpy;u) i;" D",'''..lu",ne:'1tS
..."....i.>"rn'ntJi
Appl'OVNJ Il~
",,,.,,,,,,,,'
'\ppn"'cLlIl~
"dm!'lih; :'y,'F."WpIY" ,.: i~
C:"vi"c'nn;c''I'.;;'; '-"'cc,'
;"nr'''''lit'li)Wiil;' '.'mH)".'1
--"i;,,"nl~nt:;' "f..
<<:t,;
,"",.......;(Jm'''.'.
::;'nvw.'nm
'I.::;;n..:.i;'"'f>..:,j..ii
,'.f"I".,\;'
AIlI}rovcll U~'
.Iw."ph', S"hmlt1
:,TIl:t'/lI"iti,L"".''''',rH,''''.1
'CllVl!'{)"'\1'.mlp!SNv'cp,'.i<nrn,,,s"'Jt:>'
;J;""
(:cnnmun,t',... Dev,=iapr!i<'nt & Ccornrnuniw [)c\'elopmell( &
E.ny,ronmen\al $ervic"" Admill
,1'14f20D7545r>M
E','1Vi"~!1n"'n\,,1 "'," 'I~€"
flpe>licationsAnalys!
Date
Appro\'etl B)'
OMS Coo,dill~tor
Adm;nistrative Servl~es
InfomlaliollTcchnologv
11i15i20073.43PM
Budget An.)lyst
Date
Appro,'ed 8}'
Mar~,lsa<;"son
County Managt!r'sOfficc
Offi(;e of Man<lgem€nt & Budget
.,1I15l2il074-49PM
County Manager
p"t()
Approvetl By
James V Mudd
Bo~rd of Count I'
C"ll1missior1err,
Co,mt\, Mnnager'", Office
1111C.'l0073:4C"'M
file:! IC:\AgendaT est\Export\93-November%2027, ol,,202007\16.%20CONSENT%20AGEN.. 11/2012007
N ~__ co
-0""-
<00
~N'<j"
f--- q;
~('.: i?
~.3D-
Q)~
=:D
- >
-;~
13-
::n
<[
z
o
w-
>-~
000
o
~
.,
,
/-1~
,~-;~~/'
,
/ \/'
/-
------->;-\
avo~ SIVJ~ d~V:)
o
<
o
"
'\l-ot-'O
ci'''''
0.\.4<-1)..
Qt\lBS30V"F-l!;Jo\3
v
5;': - ~S
>-z
00
w-
,~
00
~9
o
<
o
"
w
~
<
.
o
~
"
Cl.
<{
~
UJ
.-
en
/
/
!Ill
~I
~I
/
-
/
/
1ll'OS OJ !ON / --.
_ .c-
til
'"
I
'"
f-
~
<(
~
'"
g!
<(
Cl.
<{
~
~
~
~
<
o
z
w
~
o
o
z
o
~
u
o
....J
'lJ.~'/.\CO
0'
GIJ\.~
Nr--cO
,'~go
NU')
"-:CV
::)N Q)
ZQ;~
::::-0
OJ:::
.:::::Q)
->
-D~
-~
6:.
t:))
<:
co
'"
~
G
i ,', ~
I ffi
I '~i
I.~~
,
it e ~
a~~i~
'''I'
....!
.,.
,..
,,1l
~~~oJ
("'i",
~
.....-<
~ ~ I
':y;, -.
[fJ ~ I
! c.'
~ '.
~ C\)
'"
:L, ~
z
-
~
~
'"
.-
<
~
..--
"..."f"
-~"--1
0:::
~ '"
~
\
-
......:l
~
c:i
(Q
E--< :::
........
Z ci:
0-
~ C
Z
-
~ ,:r,
;;:
........ c:
~ ~
~
~ ,n
<
::;s
~
! >
~
I
'r',_
~~
-'-
~'. '-
~s
~c
-'"
U:'c::;
~~
~j
;"'"",,
e:;:-,
'J}~
~
;
,.,,'<,.
~!~'~
!l!!
~r~
6 ~ ~
~ ~~,,~
Hn!;~l
8 ~ t ="" :~~
~
~
~
'0
~'~'
tt
~ ~~ g
~ ~
u:
z.
~ ~:
~
.',-
j !i~jf:'
L~~~p=l.~
~i:i~~~~
iilil~
.,
j
II
"
r< __ ~~~_~ '~~ .,
t_,
,
.,
s'
;~
,
"
;~
~~
:;~!!!:illm l:i! i!::mim~ !l! lli~~! ~ II:!!!! iHii!!i!:i~d!~~~~~Bq
:~~~~~\\t~~:;;~~~"~!i~[~g~~ig~~~~~~h~~S:B~~~'~$~ ~~~~",i~_ t:~"dL~. , .\0
~~t~~~~~;'>i"~;~~i2~w_~~,,~ _ ~ ~1-_h~N .
~:
~I
'gl
I
I
c
c
~
i'
!
!
~.
.,
~rg
fj~
, .
i~;
fi
~~~
1m
~~~~
",>r.-,~
~B~~
~~H
!!;li~ :
ijiir~1
~~l:!
-O'l
~ '".
I
e
"" ,w,::, ,<"
'I'Ci'''..
J-~;'-
--=:::i-- -.
--=:::i-- 2; ."
^
z
o
~
"
;;,!O,
~ ~~
~ ::r,
u ('~
~H-
.
!
1
rl h~ ~: ~i
;;; n:~'" :;;~
i" k"~ ~~ ~2~ ~
w~ ~:~~~ ~ ~.~ ~':'" ~,
~l '" "" q, [
~,~ ~_:~'~~ "'~~ ~!'~.j -
;.'.< .t:~: \.~" ~~: ~
c - ~ ~~); ,;~~ _~ ~ "
;! !l!bi:';-'"
:li l!~! ~i!~!i II!
:;:= ,,~t _. ~
.
No,'o;;?
H:
!
~
;;.
,j
~~l
~f ~
lH
t..,~
g~
lm
'"'I
~,;I ~
d~,~:
~
"g
^
w
c
~
"
"
2
~
o
3i
"~
~~
~~
~~
3
c
~
~~~,
[l~
~~
8 ~'~
:c~,
rr22
t ~~
;> ~-g
~ ~~
",-
'" ~,
~;
O:;~.
~ ~,
~
~,
:;;-
~.\',
hi
,.,
Ii!
r:~~
~=~
;:~
~ij~
~i~
~~li;;.
~df
i:,i;
ll!!,
~~~~~
~5BI~
1!I!f
~:~p: ~,
H
~;;
-,
~ ~ ~:;
~~
,
~,~
'-'~
2\;
~: ;
~2
~'.J~
ut ..
~
! ~,~~~~
, t~y~.~ ,
, i~!n
~ ~ !
~8
~a
I!:~ '1
;!il
I 1,1 I!
~" !i!!!!
",;*
0> ~~~~~;
"'>.
g: ,~
~a
~ ::~
::~~
"
,,~
,
:c'r
3
"
~:i
~! i
~:>,
~~ r
0",
n "
qP'
~,: k: ~
we: "'"
~
~
"
o ~g
u "",
~.o
l.,'
"
"
~.~.
t ~'
~g~
~5~
~;.~
~~8 ~,
;~:i
Hi~
c,,^:.!it
~,
~
, ..
~
..
, :0:
, ~
,
,
, ~'
Nr--.C',.)
'.- C) "-
<DO
~Nr..o
. t'-- (])
0('...[ tJ)
7"-ffi
- CUe..
~~
~b
=2
'1'
:0,
<1::
~
I "-I
01
OL
I !~I'
P-
I
reo
I,...,
I
I
I~
I en
<C
1""':-'
..........
10.,
I
I
'V'"
I~
I -,
>--i
<C
>-
.....
<'"
~,
0.::;
~
.....::l
-,
>--i
~
CO
:r
~
~
Yi
"
":!'-<t
"
e::t2
:roo
'Z"':
z.~
'"
-~
t-<t-<
^Z
0.;::'
~8
"",
'"
v.:::s
z-'
00
;::w
w
'"
r/J
'"
8
f-
'"
""
0-
'-
o
z
o
U1
:;
:5
co
:0
r/J
<C""
>--i
~
<C
~
(0
E--<
.........
Z
::J
~
>-
<C
,
,
~ ....
. ;;,
;~
~ :> ,~:
!: i~
jljt!!;
-.J
4;
~..I:.'.
! <.
,
"
~
~:
~
E
~
en
-<
'"
I
Ii
/;
i
,
,
,
8
--~'~.[~,
--~'~'it
-~,
'\~
-~\
r--"'
"~-
- .
/';0 ( ,<
.! /- -"re\ 0-
'\0 '/ ","^"," /
c"'// ""~"
;////
";<~.
/..."
~\'('
;;:-( ,~' "\",,<
'"~: IO.~~'- \.~\'"'; :
~=: <:~o\\",I\.i' ,.,,~. :
.~ '\"~~~~-'~~':!!~:~)
~
,q!~~;;'~ ..
!!iI!..:
~'H~~U:
~o:':'~~~~~
"'~!-'~i-:--'<~
'i:i~
a-
N
OJ
"
Z
~
1/ lii
II !1L
:<0 :c-d,~.~
~
~~~~~Hi ~~ ~~~~
\ .
;\'. "-.c'. \
''\'.... ", i\
'" "'..,
,
_c'\ '.
\
\\
//__~'~-0__~_..............._".., . "~" '~."
( ....'!,i~"':.
"--. 'c. '
'.,
,
",
"
'~,
-~---
.
~ ,;
:t:",':.,,,",,,_,
----,
-C;,'~',.
"
" -',-,.,'
I-:----._--~ ~
..,~'
NOT pLAT
i,!;
Nr---CO
go
:'-11__
1"': Q~
ciN g:
Zilla..
~.D
03:::
=:Q)
m ?:,
-9z
ijj
'="
<(
I~l! ;
6~1 fU1!
o ~:>;;(;:i3E,
m, I i.'l~<i:5--';;~
~ ~ i Mml
o::l
..-I
~
en
<:j
~
0...,
...:
CO
.",
'"
0>
N
'"
"
"
~
'"
E-
O
CO
'V'"
.......
"'1
......
<r:
>-
...-
....,.,
~''-..1
0:::
ro
..
'"
:a~
v::.....
;i~
,"a
00-'
E-""
o)~
~~
:oC
'-'
CO
"'"
0'"
E=:3
'-'a
~u
""
o
E-
'"
.",
p..
""
o
~
"'1
.......,
-,
e-I
~
o::l
co
E-<
.......
Z
~
z
o
Vi
>
:::
'"
"
co
<:j
.......
~
<:j
::E
.",
~
>-
<:j
~~ ~
~~ ~
...
i;Jil.:!li~~:~~~ll;;~ll. i
ii~~ '~~~_~ ~I~~~~~~~
!1!"!!!IHil i~:~,~,
~ ~~~i~~;;~ ~~~~~~~_~~~;~~~
~ --.-'. ~Cg~~~~WaW~I'~~..1
! .=.~,,!!~-~----
flCJ-'-!
'-' ~ I"~ "_ '~I
ii:Z.L hf!.i
---
~ ~....
, ,~"W
:~:7;;;~'i ~";'"~~~r:: l fJ
0".".,
"C'6_ ~ 'q.-_,,~
o
,
,
~
,
--- --
(J<lO?.a..::---;'j",_,__
~O;:.aa-S) " "____
'"
J!:
, "- ~
c-
z
~
~
Is
"".
,
(f.,jOf.t&ta
-:-___~<Ilc/,~~
;~!-fi'" ___-~'~_
---
---
----
. of ~)
(~!llt~:;..--
..:."'L"-"-,--
w.TCfI~IN~
"
,
"
\
~I, -~l
;IU11
II,m;
~-:
,.
;t
>r"
'"
-'"""'~""
"
,
o
--,
~"d:',;f
---
r>J:.:::::::
:;:50
r:.oNo:J
-'''''':m
c~ C'-1 ~i
~ECL
.E~
-S~
~
~:t
C--j
I ~J
I' 2::' I
*!
I
I ~:
I <~i
'Lie
L-~
I
[:i.:l
>
.~
I
I
I
co
~
[:i.:l
!JJ
<C
'T'
-
"'
~
'v'
-
,
~
<C
~
~
~
"'""',/
~
r..,....'
-
,
-
,
-
~
CO
.",
""'-'
::....,
L
........
Z
;:J
~
I--<
~
-<
~
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
-I
:0'\
~~\
S'J
~~l
tt\
;"-\
\ \~~EI
I
\'
I,. "',
1,~\
\
'. \
- \
\
.\
\\" \
. "'-~.
~" ,
~ ,
i, .;
<,~
7,",,",_,",
:: " "'~,
I" '
:r.
~
:D
~
~?
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
=
~
oc
~' i
I
7;:
~.~
c--::;:
~::. .-
:::z
cr::::
z:-:',
~-
~~
~:J
if~ ....:J
o
5~
f-
"
-<
~,
z
(fC
-
~
~
'f)
-<
~--~
~
I
,
I
I
I
I;
I
z
~
~
~
_f
-E
I
.
o
.
:;. ';,
itO::::ii b::;
i~O','E.Tllt:;E-:: --7 :::DC;
EXECCTIVE SUMMARY ....-
Recommendation to authorize the Board of County Commissioners Chairman to enter into
a Local Agency Program (LAP) Agreement with the Florida Department of
Transportation, on behalf of Collier County, for receipt of Federal dollars in the amount of
$134,000 for landscaping enhancements for SR 93/ 1-75 at Golden Gate Parkway.
OBJECTIVE: To obtain Board of County Commissioners authorization for its Chair to enter
into a Local Agency Program (LAP) Agreement with the FI01ida Department of Transportation
for receipt of Federal dollars in the amount of $134,000 Jor landscaping enhancements at SR
93/1-75 at Golden Gate Parkway.
CONSIDERA TIONS: The Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) has programmed
$134,000 of Federal Funds for approximately 1 mile of landscaping fClr SR 93/1-75 at Golden
Gate Parkway which is availablc in Fiscal Ycar 2007/2008. Landscaping and irrigation was
installed as part of the interchange installation; the Local Agency Agreement (LAP) funding will
be used to enhance the existing landscape. The interchange landscaping is being maintained by.
the FJOlida Department of Transportation. FOOT is responsible for maintenance to June 8, 2008.
~
[n order IClr local governments to receive Federal do /lars through the Florida DepaJ1ment of
Transportation. they must enter into 3 Local Agency Program (LAP) Agreement with FDOT.
Construction do/lars are programmed in FY 2007/2008 in the amount of $134,000. For full
reimbursement of cost, the Agency. Collier County agrees to complete the project on or bel(lre
December 3 L 2008. The anticipated overall construction cost of the project is S J 34.000. Collier
County is committed to maintain those arcas which will be landscaped as a pa11 of this LAP
agreenlenL
FISCAL IMPACT: Funds in the amount of $134,000 arc budgeted in the Landscape Project
Budget within Fund (112) project (60043) and will be reimbursed under the LAP Agreement up
to $134,000 by the Florida Department of Transportation once the project is complete. It is
anticipated that the County will enter into a Maintanance of Agreement with the Florida
Department of Transportation and it is estimated that tile aJ111ual maintenance cost will be
$85,339 per mile. This approximates the estimate contained within the April 2003 Landscape
Beautification Master Plan (BCC Approvcd April 22, 2()03, ltem IOC).
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There is no Growth Management Impact associated
with this Executive Summary.
RECOMMENDA TION: Staff recommends that the Board of County Commissioners authorize
its Chairman to enter into a LAP Agreement with the Florida Department of Transportation for
the receipt of$134,OOO for landscaping enhancements at SR 93/1-75 at Golden Gate paJ'kway.
Prepared By: Pamela Lulich. ASLA, Landscape Operations Manager. Alternative
Transportation Modes Department.
~
Attachments:
(1) Local Agency Program (LAP) Agreements - (3) Signed Originals required.
(2) Resolution- (3) Signed Originals required.
!<:)\",
1-'<"'
:J!
PCI,=,C ] 01' 1
COLLIER COUNTY
- ';r'_~i,' :.:.iJ::
Item Number:
Item Summary:
Meeting Date:
PrqJan'd R~
':'a"""I'
'lel1
c"I{,,,'r,'i!H\W;'-'
~. ,~:(
"'''10,,,,
'",.
'C"'"W''' .,r,c, rio,,,,,,,
- :'on~ !;.'..F- >';'
"-l'l'r(lHdBy
_,,,,,;r
"".,'
""."".,,''''',''CO,"
"1,,,,-,, lr'-:",I:'n"pl,(j,' 1',<>(,,)-
. ,~,~)' . ~5: "'ti
Appro"ed f1~
",n
""'J'"
-'-"1'.[>";:'-" :"....,'
',n,',::,,,,"'
,'.'"
':''';1'
"'-'c, 1'1"
Appr"H'd B)
-\pprn\'l'd B)
'\pp1'o",'1I B)
\pp1'o""d 11:
'\pl'rl,,'ed 11,\
'\pprl}\('d B~
";':
Appro\'l'u B~
",'"
''t.
Apprm'ed B~
",.)'
,_~"._.'.n~ "
....._...," ,i\,"''' ,1\,f\f\T'f. (> "I/\l"n....'''''.....'1'I> ',('.\ ("1'''''
1. ',1\.-',1\/\'7
J:::
. ;;': \'~::: --;'; ~-~.
20(;7
RESOLUTION NO. 2007 -
A RESOLUTION BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS,
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA. APPROVING, AND AUTHORIZING ITS
CHAIRMAN TO EXECLTE. A LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM AGREEMENT
WITH THE STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
PERTAINING TO LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE AT SR 93/1-75 AT
GOLDEN GATE PARKWAY FOR FOOT PROJECT NO. 60043.
WHEREAS, at the Novemher~, 2007, meeting of the Board of County Commissioners
the Board approved Agenda Item _, which is a Local Agency Program Agreement ("LAP")
'A'ith the Florida Department of Transportation that provides funding for providing landscape
maintenance services at State Road 93 and 1-75 at Golden Gate Park\\,'a)i, and authorized the
Board of County Commissioners, through its Chairman, to enter into the LAP with the Florida
Department of Transportation; and
WHEREAS, the Florida Department of Transportation requires the Board provide a
resolution memori<:llizing and confinning the Bom"d's aforementioned affirmative vote to
appro'v'e the agreement and authorization for the Chairman tn execute the LAP:
NOW, THEREFORE. BE iT RESOL \lED BY FHE [)QARD OF COl'I'-:TY
COMV11SS10NERS OF COLLIER COUNTY. FLORIDA. that:
011 !\o\emher
.2007, the Board of Coullty Commissioners approved hy majority vote
the LAP Agreement and 3L1thorizcd its chairman. James Coletta. t() e7\ecute that agreement.
4 cel1ified copy of this Resolution vvj]] he forwarded hy the CoJiicr County Clerk 10
FDOT along with the executed .Agreement.
THIS RESOLLTION ADOPTED after motion, second, and majority vote
favoring same, this day of ,2007,
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUI'-:TY COMMISSIONERS
OF COLLIER COUI'-:TY. FLORIDA
By:
By: _
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA. Chairman
Approved as io fonn and legal sufficiency:
Scoti R. Teach,
Assistant County' Attomey
:,::;Ir
''.'' ,'-:,;1',:',2' _.
~.:;7
5T ATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORT AllON
LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM AGREEMENT
~~, W~[H0-40
PROJECT MANAGEMENT OFFICE
03/07
Page 1
FPN: 200732-3-58-01 Fund: SE
Federal No: 0754 148 I Org Code: 55014010106
FPN: Fund:
Federal No: Org Code:
FPN: Fund:
Federal No: Org Code:
FPN: Fund:
Federal No: Org Code:
County No:03 Contract No:
Data Universal Number System (DUNS) No: 80-939-7102
Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance (CFDA): 20.205 Highway Planning and Construction
FLAIR Approp:
FLAIR Obj:
FLAIR Approp:
FLAIR Obj:
FLAIR Approp:
FLAIR Obj:
FLAIR Approp:
FLAIR Obj:
Vendor No: F 596000558004
THIS AGREEMENT, made and entered into this _ day of , _ by and between the STATE
OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION, an agency of the State of Florida, hereinafter called the
Department, and Collier Cour.tv: Board of Count\! Commisioners: 2301 East Tamiami Trail. NaDles, Florida 34112
hereinafter called the Agency.
WIT N E SSE T H:
VVHE:REAS, the ,~genc:y has ths authori;:y to e:lte~ into this Agreemen: and to unaertake the oioJect hereinafter descrjbe~
and the Department h2S bsen grantee tne authority to function adequately ill ali a:-eas of approprlaie jurisdiction in::ludi!1g
the implementation of an integ:-aied an: balan::ed t:-ansDClrtatior. system and is authorized under Se:tion 339,"'i2, Florid,;
Statutes, to enter into this Agreemen:;
r\Jow, THER::FOR:::., in ::onsrderaticm of the mutual covenants. p;--omlses and re;Jresemations herein. the parties agT8e as
follows:
1.00 Purpose of Agreement: The purpose of this Agreement is to provide for the Department's participation in
landscaDlnq and as further described in Exhibit "A" attached hereto and by this reference made a part hereof, hereinafter
called the "project," and to provide Department financial assistance to the Agency and state the terms and conditions
upon which such assistance will be provided and the understandings as to the manner in which the project will be
undertaken and completed.
1.01 Attachments: Exhibit(s) A, S, Land 1 are attached and made a part hereof.
2.01 General Requirements: The Agency shall complete the project as described in Exhibit "A" with all practical
dispatch, in a sound, economical, and efficient manner, and in accordance with the provisions herein, and all applicable
laws. The project will be performed in accordance with cdl applicable Department procedures, guidelines, manuals,
standards, and directives as described in the Department's Local Aoenev Prooram Manual, which by this reference Is
made a part hereof as if fully set forth herein. Time is or the essence as to each and every obligation under this
Agreement.
A full time employee of the Agency, qualified to ensure that the work being pursued is complete, accurate, and consistent
with the terms, conditions, and specifications of this Agreement shall be in charge of each project.
Removal of Any Un billed Funds
If Agency fails to timely perform its obligations in submitting invoices and documents necessary for the close out of the
project, and said failure results in a loss of the remaining unbilled funding either by Federal withdrawal of funds or ioss of
State appropriation authority (which may include both federal funds and state funds, if any state funds are on the proJect),
Agency will be responsible for the remaining unbilled funds on the project. No other funds will be provided by the
Department. Agency waives the right to contest such removal of funds by the Department, if said rel10val is directly
related to Federal (FHWA) withdrawal of funds or loss of State appropriation authority due to Local ."gency's failure or
nonperformance. In addition to loss of funding, the Department will consider de-certification of said Agency fo, future LI'.?
projects.
:t~~ otJ
5T A TE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM AGREEMENT
\1(WS;~'i~J0-;: ~' 2DCi7
F' 2 J:.:: E:i €2s;;;6-40
PROJECT I'.f..il.NAGEMENT OFFICE
03/07
Page 2
Removal of All Funds
If all funds are removed from the project, including amounts previously billed to the Department and reimbursed to the
Agency, and the project Is off the state highway system, then the department will have to request repayment for the
previously billed amounts from the Local Agency. No state funds can be used on off-system projects.
2.02 Expiration of Agreement: The Agency agrees to complete the project on or before December 31. 2008. If the
Agency does not complete the project within this time period, this Agreement will expire on the last day of the scheduled
completion as provided in this paragraph unless an extension of the time period is requested by the Agency and granted
in writing by the Department prior to the expiration of this Agreement. Expiration of this Agreement will be considered
termination of the project. The cost of any work performed after the expiration date of this Agreement will not be
reimbursed by the Department.
2.03 Pursuant to Federal, State, and Local Laws: In the event that any election, referendum, approval, permit, notice
or other proceeding or authorization is requisite under applicable law to enable the Agency to enter into this Agreement or
to undertake the project hereunder or to observe, assume or carry out any of the provisions of the Agreement. the Agency
will initiate and consummate, as provided by law. all actions necessary with respect to any such matters so requisite.
2.04 Agency Funds: The Agency shall initiate and prosecute to completion all proceedings necessary, including
federal-aid requirements. to enable the Agency to proVide the necessary funds for completion of the project.
2.05 Submission of Proceedings, Contracts, and Other Documents: The A;1sncy shall submit to tne Department
such data, reports, re~8rds, cO:1trac:s, and othe~ documents reiatiil;; to the project as the DepanmeL1t a:1d trlC Feje;-ai
Highway Aaministration U"H\W,) may reouire.
3.00 Project Cost:
3.01 Total Cost: The total cost of the project is $ 134.000.00. This amount Is based upon the schedule of funding In
Exhibit "8." The Agency agrees to bear all expenses in excess of the total cost of the project and any deficits involved.
The schedule of funding may be modified by mutual agreement as provided for in paragraph 4.00.
3,02 Department Participation: The Department agrees to participate, including contingencies, in the project cost to the
extent provided in Exhibit "B." This amount includes federal-aid funds which are limited to the actual amount of federal-
aid participation.
3.03 Limits on Department Funds: Project costs eligible for Department participation will be allowed only from the date
of this Agreement. It is understood that Department participation in eligible project costs is subject to:
a) Legislative approval of the Department's appropriation request in the work program year that the project is
scheduled to be committed;
b) Availability of funds as stated In paragraphs 3.04 and 3.05 of this Agreement;
c) Approval of all plans, specifications, contracts or other obiigating documents and all other terms of this
Agreement; and
d) Department approval of the project scope and budget at the time appropriation authority becomes available.
3.04 Appropriation of Funds: The Department's performance and obligation to pay under this Agreement is contingent
upon an annual appropriation by the Legislature. If the Department's funding for this project is in multiple fiscal years,
funds approval from the Department's Comptroller must be received each fiscal year prior to costs being incurred. See
Exhibit "8" for funding levels by fiscal year. Project costs utilizing these fiscal year funds are not eligible for
_. reimbursement if incurred prior to funds approval being received. The Department will notify the Agency, in writing, when
~unds are available.
3.05 Multi-Year Commitment: In the event this Agreement is in excess of $25,000 and has a term for a period of more
than one year. the provisions of Section 339.135(6)(a), Florida Statutes, are hereby incorporated:
,:'):c.
STJ..TE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTp,TION
LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM AGREEMENT
~'::'~:- 'S::5':O'j[}...40
PROJECT MANAGEMENT OFFICE
03/07
Pege3
"(a) The depa,1ment. during any fiscal year, shall not expend money, incur any liability, or enter into any
contract which, by its terms, involves the expenditure of money in excess of the amounts budgeted as
available for expenditure during such fiscal year. Any contract, verbal or written, made in vioiation of this
subsection is null and void. and no money may be paid on such contract. The department shall require a
statement from the comptroller of the Department that funds are available prior to entering into any such
contract or other binding commitment of funds. Nothing herein contained shall prevent the making of
contracts for periods exceeding 1 year, but any contract so made shall be executory only for the value of
the services to be rendered or agreed to be paid for in succeeding fiscal years, and this paragraph shall
be incorporated verbatim in ali contracts of the Department which are for an amount in excess of $25,000
and which have a term for a period of more than 1 year."
3,06 Notice-to-Proceed: No cost may be incurred under this Agreement until the Agency has received a written Notice-
to-Proceed from the Department.
3.07 Limits on Federal Participation: Federal-aid funds shall not participate in any cost which is not incurred in
conformity with aoplicabie Federal and State laws. the reQulations in 23 Code of Federal Regulations (C.F.R.) and 49
C.F.R., 2nd pohsies and procedures prescribed bv the Division Administrator of FHWA Federal funds shall not be paid
on aCCQ'Jnt of an)' cost incurrec priC}i to au~h8~:;::2:iO-: by :he FHW A to the DepaM:ment to proceed with the project or part
ther9C,f nvol'v':iK; ~.'''::::~~ co:,: 123 C.F.r:~_ ~ ,S' I':,)':. !: :::H'/-/f.:, or the De;Jal1ment determines that any amount claimed is not
e:19b!e. fedora: :J2J:tiCI:J8t;0I~ rr',;?;y DE' C1:;;;roV-2C~ in t"lE: a;"';"IO!.-Ji1t determined to be adequately supported and the Department
5'-:21:' P-1S A::::o::.~:lC,V in \":-:,-:'"";' C,!:I'!;: ::1''::' :---?2SQi"'S wh';' :teXls anj amoums are not eli;JibJe for federai particioe:tion.
V\!nE.'rs ca:-re'::13:)i.:::: ~-lo~.t<;::)n':~Jil~i;;:::'-2 1/,'1::-1 :-:)"JV!~~!O':~ -:::,1 ::;::\".' :x FHVv'A reourrernents 8};ists, F=ede:-al funds may be withheid
unlil C::HTDI:anc.tc :s o:J~?i:,e::: V\'r-r?"E iD-'-::;~,::': ;-.-;;I':~.;:. '~' i'~I: c:J,rec:sbis, FHVV.4 0: ths- ~e;J8~me:1t may deny p3,ti:::;ipation
~~-, DJiCf:: Cl~' ~;cl.i~:-: c')~;:~ ;,~ :,2'": D- n i::-!la:
For any amounts determined to be ineligible fo: fede;-a! reimbu:"sement TD, which the De::;2:1men: h8S 2:Jv2nc:e2 payme:1t,
the Agsncy shaH piOrTlDtiy reit7"iburse the Department ior all suer, amo:...rnts within 90 da)'s 07 writteri notice.
4.00 Project ;:stimate and Disbursement Schedule: Prior to the execution of this Agreement, a project schedule of
f .,mclng shall be prepa;-e:: ~:y the AQ8n:;y c:mc 2;);:lrDV'::;O by the Depa;iment. The Agency shall maintain said schedule of
funding, carry out the p;-oject, and sholl insur obiigations against and make disbursements of project funds only in
conformity with the latest appcoved schedUle of fund:ng for t"le project. The schedule offunding may be revised by mutual
v,~itten agreement between the Department and the Agency. If revised, a copy of the revision should be forwarded to the
Department's Comptrolier and to the Department's Federal-aid Program Office. No increase or decrease shall be
effective unless it complies "vill'l fur.j p2rticioa~io:l re:juirem.::nts of this Agreement and is approved by the Department's
Comptroller.
5.00 Records:
5.01 Establishment and Maintenance of Accounting Records: Records of costs Incurred under the terms of this
Agreement shall be maintained and made available upon request to the Department at all times during the period of this
Agreement and for 5 years after the final payment is made. Copies of these documents and records shall be furnished to
the Department upon request. Records of costs incurred include the Agency's general accounting records and the project
records, together with supporting documents and records of the Agency and all subcontractors performing work on the
project and all other records of the Agency and subcontractors considered necessary by the Department for a proper audit
of costs. If any litigation, claim or audit is started before the expiration of the 5-year period, the records shall be retained
until all litigation, claims or audit findings involving the records have been resolved.
5.02 Costs Incurred for Project: The Agency shall charge to the project account all eligible costs of the project except
costs agreed to be borne by the Agency or its contractors and subcontractors. Costs in excess of the programmed
funding or attributable to actions which have not received the required approval of the Department shall not be considered
eligible costs.
5.03 Documentation of Project Costs: All costs charged to the project, including any approved services contributed by
the Agency or others. shall be supp01ed by properly executed payrolls, time records, invoices, contracts or vouchers
evidencing in proper detail the nature and propriety of the charges.
5.04 Audit Reports: Recipients of federal and state funds are to have audits done annually using the following criteria:
i~SiTi ficJ. ";S::'" 'I
-JC)\/f~iTiner' .:: i 2Ci07
F'21;lS 8 ~l~C40
PROJE.CT MANAGEMENT OFFICE
03107
Page 4
STATE OF FLORIDA DE:PARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM AGREEMENT
The administration of resources awarded by the Department to the Agency may be subject to audits and/or monitoring by
the Department, as described in this section,
Monitoring: In addition to reviews of audits conducted in accordance with OMS Circular A-133 and Section 215.97,
Florida Statutes, as revised (see "Audits" below), monitoring procedures may include, but not be limited to, on-site visits
by Department staff, limited scope audits as defined by OMS Circular A-133, as revised, and/or other procedures. By
entering into this Agreement, the recipient agrees to comply and cooperate fully with any monitoring
procedures/processes deemed appropriale by the Department. In the event the Department determines that a limited
scope audit of the recipient is appropriate, the recipient agrees to comply with any additional instructions provided by the
Department staff to the Agency regarding such audit. The Agency further agrees to comply and cooperate with any
inspections, reviews, Investigations or audits deemed necessary by the FDOT's Office of Inspector General (OIG), and
the Chief Financial Officer (CFO) or Auditor General.
Audits
'Part I . Federally Funded: Recipients of federal funds (i.e., state, local government or non-profit organizations as
defined in OMS Circular A-133, as revised) are to have audits done annually using the following criteria:
1. In the event that the recipient expends $500,000 or more in federal awards in its fiscal year, the recipient must
have a singie or program-spe~ific audit conducted in aC8ordan:::e with the provisions of OMS Circular A-133, as
revised. ~xhibit "1" of th!s .Agreement Jndicates fejeial resources awarded through the Departm~nt by this
Agreement. In determining the federal awarcs expencied in Its fIscal year, the recipient shall consider all sources
of fede,a! awards, in:::luding federat resources received from t:,e Depai.ment. The determination of amounts of
federal awards expended shouid be in accordance with the guidelines established by 01'.18 Circuiar A-133, as
revised. An audit of tne r8Gipient conducted by the Auditor Genera! in accordance With the provisions 01'.13
Circular ,t..-~33F as revised. wit: meet the requirements of this part.
2. in connection with the audit requirements addressed in Part I, paragraph 1 the recipient shall fulfill the
requirements relative to auditee responsibilities as provided in Subpart C of OMS Circuiar A-133, as revised.
3. if the recipient expends less than $500,000 in federal awards in Its fiscal year, an audit conducted in accordance
with the provisions of OMS Circular A-133, as revised, Is not required. However, if the recipient eiects to have an
audit conducted in accordance with the provisions of OMS Circular A-133, as revised, the cost of the audit must
be paid from non-federal resources (i.e., the cost of such an audit must be paid from recipient resources obtained
from other than federal entities).
4. Federal awards are to be identified using the Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance (CFDA) title and number,
award number and year, and name of the awarding federal agency.
Part II - State Funded: Recipients of state funds (i.e., a non-state entity as defined by Section 215.97(2) (I), Fiorida
Statutes) are to have audits done annually using the following criteria:
1. in the event that the recipient expends a total amount of state financial assistance equal to or in excess of
$500.000 in any fiscal year of such recipient, the recipient must have a state single or project-specific audit for
such fiscal year in accordance with Section 215.97, Florida Statutes, applicable rules of the Executive Office of
the Governor and the CFO, and Chapters 10.550 (local governmental entilies) or 10.650 (nonprofit and for-profit
organizations), Rules of the Auditor General. Exhibit"1" to this Agreement indicates state financial assistance
awarded through the Department by this Agreement. In determining the state financial assistance expended in its
fiscal year, the recipient shall consider all sources of state financial assistance, including state financial assistance
received from the Department, other state agencies, and other non-state entitles. State financial assistance does
not include federal direct or pass-through awards and resources received by a non-state entity for federal
program matching requirements.
2. In connection with the audit requirements addressed in Part II, paragraph 1, the recipient shall ensure that the
audit complies with the requirements of Section 215.97(7), Florida Statutes, This includes submission of a
financial reporting package as defined by Section 215.97(2) (d), Florida Statutes, and Chapters 10.550 (local
governmental entities) or 10.650 (nonprofit and for-profit organizations), Ruies of the Auditor General.
t\:~:'/S:"i:.'(;'. ~O:-,-
STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM AGREEMENT
~'a;)e ~ :a;5~;:040
PROJECT MANAGEMENT OFFICE
03/D7
PBge5
3. If the recipient expends less than $500,000 in state financial assistance in its fiscal year, an audit conducted in
accordance with the provisions of Section 215.97, Florida Statutes, is not required. However, if the recipient
elects to have audit conducted in accordance with the provisions of Section 215.97, Florida Statutes, the cost of
the audit must be paid from the non-state entity's resources (i.e., the cost of such an audit must be paid from the
recipient's resources obtained from other than State entities).
4. State awards are to be identified using the Catalog of State Financial Assistance (CSFA) title and number, award
number and year, and name of the state agency awarding it.
Part III . Other Audit Requirements: The recipient shall follow up and take corrective action on audit findings.
Preparation of a Summary Schedule of Prior Year Audit Findings, including corrective action and current status of the
audit findings is required. Current year audit findings require corrective action and status offindings.
Records related to unresolved audit findings, appeals or litigation shall be retained until the action is completed or the
dispute is resolved. Access to project records and audit work papers shall be given to the Department, the Department of
Financial Services, and the Auditor General. This section does not limit the authority of the DepartmenftD conduct or
arrange for the conduct of additional audits or evaluations of state financial assistance or limit the authority of any other
state official.
Part IV. Report Submission:
1. Copies 0-; finan:ial rep:l~dil; packa:?ss fo~ aJdits CO:l:Ju::ted in a::G:Jican:::e with Or~f;3 Circular ,.l:..-; 33, 2~ revised,
an::l required by Part I of this Agreement shall be submitted, when required by Se::tion .320 (d), 0lv18 Circular J...-
133, as revised, by or on beha~f of the recipient directly to eaGh of the following:
a) The Depart:llent at each o~ the following 3j~ress(es;:
Michelle S. Peronto
801 North Broadway Avenue
Bartow, Florida 33830
b) The Federal Audit Clearinghouse designated in OMB Circular A-133, as revised (the number of copies
required by Sections .320 (d)(1) and (2), OMB Circular A-133, as revised), at the following address:
Federal Audit Clearinghouse
Bureau of the Census
1201 East 10th Street
Jeffersonville, IN 47132
c) Other federai agencies and pass-through entities in accordance with Sections .320 (e) and (f), OMB Circular
A-133, as revised.
2. In the event that a copy of the financial reporting package required by Part I of this Agreement and conducted in
accordance with OMB Circular A-133, as revised, is not required to be submitted to the Department for reasons
pursuant to Section .320 (e)(2), OMB Circular A-133, as revised, the recipient shall submit the required written
notification pursuant to Section .320 (e)(2) and a copy of the recipient's audited Schedule of Expenditures of
Federal Awards directlv to each of the following:
Michelle S. Peronto
801 North Broadway Avenue
Bartow, Florida 33830
In addition, pursuant to Section .320 (f), OMB Circular A-133, as revised, the recipient shall submit a copy of the
financial reporting package described in Section .320 (c), OMB Circular A-133, as revised, and any Management
Letters issued by the auditor, to the Department at each of the following addresses:
Michelie S. Peronto
STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TR/\NSPORTATION
LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM AGREEMENT
:".;;;T,
,. ~':S25.{;'tD-40
PROJE.CT MANAGEMENT OFFICE
03107
Page 6
801 North Broadway Avenue
Bartow, Florida 33830
3. Copies of the financial reporting package required by Part II of this Agreement shall be submitted by or on behalf
of the recipient directlv to each of the following:
a) The Department at each of the following address(es):
Michelle S. Peronto
801 North Broadway Avenue
Bartow, Fiorida 33830
b) The Auditor General's Office at the following address:
Auditor General's Office
Room 401, Pepper Building
111 West Madison Street
Taliahassee, Florida 32399-1450
4. Copies of reports or the Management Lette~ reqUired by Part 111 of this Agreement shall be submitted by Oi on
behalf of tns reci?ien~ ~ w:
2) The Department at each of the fo!iowin; a::.]ress(es):
Iv!tcnelle S. Peronto
801 f'.jo:-th Broadway,twenJ8
Sartow, ;::Jo!"ida 3383J
5. Any reports, Management Letters, or other information required to be submitted to the Department pursuant to
this Agreement shall be submitted in a timely manner in accordance with OMB Circular A-133, as revised, Florida
Statutes, and Chapters 10.550 (local governmental entities) or 10.650 (nonprofit and for-profit organizations),
Rules of the Auditor General, as applicable.
6. Recipients, when submitting financial reporting packages to the Department for audits done in accordance with
OMB Circular .11-133, as revised, or Chapters 10.550 (local governmental entities) or 10.650 (nonprofit and for-
profit organizations), Ruies of the Auditor General, should indicate the date that the financial reporting package
was delivered to the recipient in correspondence accompanying the financial reporting package.
Part V - Record Retention: The recipient shall retain sufficient records demonstrating its compliance with the terms of
this Agreement for a period of at least 5 years from the date the audit report is Issued and shall allow the Department or its
designee, the state CFO or Auditor General access to such records upon request. The recipient shall ensure that the
independent audit documentation is made availabie to the Department. or its designee, the state CFO or Auditor General
upon request for a period of at least 5 years from the date the audit report is issued, unless extended in writing by the
Department.
5.05 Inspection: The Agency shall permit, and shall require its contractors to permit, the Department's authorized
representatives and authorized agents of FHW A to inspect all work, workmanship, materials, payrolls, and records and to
audit the books, records, and accounts pertaining to the financing and development of the project.
The Department reserves the right to unilaterally cancel this Agreement for refusal by the Agency or any contractor, sub-
contractor or materials vendor to allow public access to all documents, papers, letters or other material subject to the
provisions of Chapter 119, Florida Statutes, and made or received in conjunction with this Agreement (Section 287.058(1)
._.. (c), Florida Statutes).
5.06 Uniform Relocation Assistance and Real Property Statistical Report: For any project requiring additionai right-
of-way, the Agency must submit to the Department an annual report of its real property acquisition and reiocation
assistance activities on the project. Activities shall be reported on a federal fiscal year basis, from October 1 through
September 30. The report must be prepared using the format prescribed in 49 C.F.R Part 24, Appendix B, and be
STATE OF FLORIDADEPARTMEt-n OF TRANSPORTATION
LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM AGREEMENT
-5::5.:D'i'Q-40
PR'JJECT MANAGEMENT OFFICE
03/01
Page 7
submitted to the Department no later than October 15 of each year.
6.00 Requisitions and Payments: Requests for reimbursement for fees or other compensation for services or expenses
incurred shall be submitted in detail sufficient for a proper pre-audit and post-audit thereof (Section 287.058(1 )(a), Florida
Statutes).
All recipients of funds from this Agreement, including those contracted by the Agency, must submit bills for any travel
expenses, when authorized by the terms of this Agreement, in accordance with Section 112.061, Florida Statutes, and
Chapter 3-"Travei" of the Department's Disbursement Operations Manual, Topic 350-030-400 (Section 287.058(1 )(b),
Florida Statutes).
If, after project completion, any claim is made by the Department resulting from an audit or for work or services performed
pursuant to this Agreement, the Department may offset such amount from payments due for work or services done under
any agreement which it has with the Agency owing such amount if, upon demand, payment of the amount is not made
within 60 days to the Department Offsetting any amount pursuant to this paragraph shall not be considered a breach of
contract by the Department.
7.00 Department Obligations: Subject to other provisions hereof, the Department will honor requests for reimbursement
to the Agency in amounts and at times deemed by the Department to be piOper 10 ensure the carrying out of the proje:t
and payment of the eligible costs. However, :lotvvithstanding any ot~e:- provision of this Ag:eemeil~, the Department may
ele::t by noti::e in wiiting no~ to ma~(e 2- ~2yme:l: if:
7.01 1i."1srepresentatbn: ihs f-..gency sha!i have rnaos mis!""epresent::w:)" o~ := male.:5! nsturs in i:5 a;J~lic3tlo"'., or any
supplemen: tneretc: O~ 2m8:1dment th8i'3:l7 or i~ 0" wi:r, res~e8~ tc 2:1:' cJ::'Jms:l~ of Ga~c. fU!"n!shec.: tne:9if/itr, O~ pJ:-s~a:):
herem;
7.0'2 Litiga:tior:: Tnere IS tneil pending lltigi3tion with respect to the oeifo";nalce by tns ,4gency of arlY o~ i:~~ o1Jties or
o:.rligatbns which may jeo~ard;ze 0:- adversely affect the project, the Agreemen: or payments to the :Jroject;
7.03 Approval by Department: The Agency shall have taken any action pertaining to the project which, under this
Agreement. requires the approval of the Department or has made related expenditure or incurred related obligations
without having been advised by the Department that same are approved;
7,04 Conflict of Interests: There has been any violation of the conflict of interest provisions contained here in paragraph
12.06 or 12.07.
7,05 Default: The Agency has been determined by the Department to be in default under any of the provisions of the
Agreement.
7.06 Federal Participation: The Department may suspend or terminate payment for that portion of the project which the
FHWA, or the Department acting in lieu of FHWA, may designate as ineligible for federal-aid.
7.07 Disallowed Costs: In determining the amount of the payment, the Department will exclude all projects costs
incurred by the Agency prior to the effective date of this Agreement or the date of authorization, costs incurred after the
expiration of the Agreement, costs which are not provided for in the latest approved schedule of funding in Exhibit "B" for
the project, costs agreed to be borne by the Agency or its contractors and subcontractors for not meeting the project
commencement and final invoice time lines, and costs attributable to goods or services received under a contract or other
arrangements which have not been approved in writing by the Department.
7.08 Final invoices: The Agency must submit the final invoice on the project to the Department within 120 days after the
completion of the project. Invoices submitted after the 120-day time period may not be paid.
8.00 Termination or Suspension of Project:
8.01 Termination or Suspension Generally: The Department may, by written notice to the Agency, suspend any or all
of its obligations under this Agreement unW such time as the event or condition resulting in such suspension has ceased
or been corrected or the Department may terminate this Agreement in whole or in part at any time the interest of the
Department requires such termination.
STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM AGREEMENT
- '525>010-40
PROJECT t\IiAt~AG=MENT OFFICE
03107
Page 8
If the Department determines that the performance of the Agency is not satisfactory, the Department shall have the option
of (a) immediately terminating this Agreement or (b) suspending this Agreement and notifying the Agency of the deficiency
with a requirement that the deficiency be corrected within a specified time; otherwise this Agreement will be terminated at
the end of such time. Suspension of this Agreement will not affect the time period for completion of the project.
If the Department requires termination of this Agreement for reasons other than unsatisfactory performance of the
Agency, the Department shall notify the Agency of such termination, with instructions as to the effective date of
termination or specify the stage of work at which this Agreement is terminated.
If this Agreement is terminated before performance is completed, the Agency shall be paid for the work satisfactorily
performed. Payment is to be on the basis of substantiated costs.
8.02 Action Subsequent to Notice-of-Termination or Suspension: Upon receipt of any final termination or suspension
notice under this paragraph, the Agency shali proceed promptly to carry out the actions required therein which may
include any or all of the following: (a) necessary action to terminate or suspend, as the case may be, project activities and
contracts and such other action as may be required or desirable to keep to a minimum the costs upon the basis of which
the financing is to be computed; (b) furnish a statement of the project activities and contracts and other undertakings the
cos: 07 which are othe:\:v:SE: i~)cilic:a~):s 2::. projec;, COsts. T:H~ termination or suspension shalt be carried out in conformity
w:U'~ the istest. sct'leduis, p;an. and cost 2S E.!::J;J;Qvej by :he Departme:lt or upan the b2Sis of terms and conditions
Ir~ p2::9:::' !:>y t'"'rE, :;S'~an';F"::n: u:)o:' ths fal:~;:-':':' of ..he L,g2:-i'~Y t(.l furnish the s:::he:iule, pian, ail:] estimate y.,!ithin a reasonabie
t:mE.'. Tn':' ::;;JSi1;; o:...!: 0' ;eje,a: f'T::nc:3: :Jar:!:::!Dati.'::!'! In 1!l(~ proje::;t shall :lot c:mstitute 2 waiver of any c)aim which the
=-_h~n{:-T:i..!S~: '1':3~ c;U){--;iVI'l::,8 h2\/.;:'
ClL;i oj a'lir, ,~r;re'31i',fmt.
9.00 Contracts of Agency:
3,01 Third Party Agreements: Except as othe~wise authorized in writing by the Department, the Agency shall not
execute any contract or obligate itself in any manner requiring the disbursement of Department funds, Including consultant
or construction contracts or amendments thereto, with any third party with respect to the project without the written
approval of the Department. Failure to obtain such approval shall be sufficient cause for nonpayment by the Department.
The Department specifically reserves unto itself the right to review the qualifications of any consultant or contractor and to
approve or disapprove the employment of the same.
9.02 Compliance with Consultants' Competitive Negotiation Act: It is understood and agreed by the parties hereto
that participation by the Department in a project with the Agency, where said project involves a consultant contract for
engineer:ng, architecture or surveying services, is contingent on the Agency's complying in full with provisions of Section
257.055, Florida Statutes, Consuitants' Competitive Negotiation Act At the discretion of the Department, the Agency will
Invoive the Department in the consultant seiection process for all projects. In all cases, the Agency's attorney shall certify
to the Department that selection has been accomplished in compliance with the Consultants' Competitive Negotiation Act.
10.00 Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) Policy and Obligation: It is the policy of the Department that DBE's,
as defined in 49 C.F.R. Part 26, as amended, shall have the opportunity to participate in the performance of contracts
financed in whole or in part with Department funds under this Agreement. The DBE requirements of applicabie federal and
state laws and regulations apply to this Agreement.
The Agency and its contractors agree to ensure that DBE's have the opportunity to participate in the performance of this
Agreement. In this regard, all recipients and contractors shall take all necessary and reasonable steps in accordance with
applicable federal and state laws and regulations to ensure that the DBE's have the opportunity to compete for and
perform contracts. The Agency and its contractors and subcontractors shall not discriminate on the basis of race, color,
national origin or sex in the award and performance of contracts, entered pursuant to this Agreement.
11.00 Compliance with Conditions and Laws: The Agency shall comply and require its contractors and subcontractors
to comply with all terms and conditions of this Agreement and all federai, state, and local laws and regulations applicable
:0 this project. Execution of this Agreement constitutes a certification that the Agency is in compliance with, and will
require its contractors and subcontractors to comply with, all requirements imposed by applicable federal, state, and local
laws and regulations, including the "Certification Regarding Debarment, Suspension, ineligibility and Voluntary Exclusion
- Lower Tier Covered Transactions," in 49 C.F.R. Part 29, when appiicab1e.
STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMEI'.'T OF TRANSPORTATION
LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM AGREEMENT
- ''''':~;:0-40
PROJECT MANAGEMEW OFFICE
03/07
Page 9
12.00 Restrictions, Prohibitions, Controls, and Labor Provisions:
12.01 Equal Employment Opportunity: In conneclion with the carrYing out of any project. the Agency shall not
discriminate against any employee or applicant for employment because of race, age, religion, color, sex, national origin,
disability or marital status. The Agency will take affirmative action to ensure that applicants are employed and that
employees are treated during employment without regard to their ra~e, age, religion, color, gender, national origin,
disability or marital status. Such action sha!! include. but not be limited l~, the following: empioyment upgrading, demotJon
or transfer; recruitment or recruitmen~ adve:-tjslng: layoff or termination; rates of payor other forms of com pensation.; and
selecti::m for training, including appren:iceshi;J. The Age:1cy shall insert the foregoing provision modified only to show the
particular contra(:tual relationship in all its cont~acts in connection v,llth the develo=,ment of operation of the project, except
contracts for the standard commercial supplies or raw materials, and shall reqUire all sucr, contractors to insert a similar
provision in all subcontracts, except subcontracts for standard commercial supplies or raw materials. When the project
involves installation, construction, demolition, removal, site improvement or similar work, the Agency shall post, in
conspicuous places available to employees and applicants for empioyment for project work, notices to be provided by the
Department setting forth the provisions of the nondiscrimination clause.
12.02 Title VI - Civil Rights Act of 1964: The Agency will comply with all the requirements imposed by Title VI of the
Civil Rights Act of 1964, the regulations of the U.S. Department of T~ansportation Issued thereunder, and the assurance
by the Agency pursuant thereto.
The Agency shall in~IJds p:-ovisi;Ji1s in all contracts wit~1 third pa1:ies that e~s'Jre c:xT1::>~iancs with Title VI 0: the CIvil
Rights Act of 1904,':;3 C.r.R. ~'a:t :1. and related sta:Ul8S and regulations.
~2.03 Americans wrth D~sabmties AG: of [SSG (AD.'..): Tile Agen::y wil! corn:tiy' with all the requiremeilts as iiTlP8S9C' by
the ADA, the regulations of th~ reaeral government issued thereuno8:, and 2ssurance by the Agency p:J:suant thereto.
~Z.04 Public EnHt)' Cr;me: p, person 01 affiiist€ Wh8 h2S b~:s':-: ;:':.:-l~.:(c.: 0: t~l~ :;:XT~'I~(e,:: ",:~~n(,8r i:~:,: 2 C:(j:-;'/IC:li::;~'
for a public entity crime may not submit a bid on a CO:l~ia~t tc iX'"O',II:JE 2:-\)' QClD':':S c:- SE:~\'ICe~ tcJ <:' D'..;;:l .C 80~:;\': :rial' nG~
submit a bid on a contract with a public entity for the constructi8f1 0:- f8;J21: of a ;J~!JIIC bu:lc:ng m ;Jc;:Jlic won~: may" 1I.J:
submit bids on leases of real property to a public entity; may nOi t18 3\fV2:dE;C m pe;-fo~rrl wmk as a COilt:-CiCt::X, sU;I:J\ie,.
subcontractor or consultant under a contract with any public ent:t~!; a;-),j m2Y no'l tr3~"';sact b:"Jsirless INith any publiC entity in
excess of the threshold amount provided in Section 287.01? Fiom!a StatUtes. for S...'\TEGOi=\Y ""T"1NO for a period of 3f,
months from the date of being placed on the convicted vendor I,st.
12.05 Discrimination: In accordance with Section 287.134, Florida Statutes, an entity or affiliate who has been placed
on the Discriminatory Vendor List, kept by the Florida Department of Management Services, may not submit a bid on a
contract to provide goods or services to a public entity; may not submit a bid on a contrac1 with a public entity for the
construction or repair of a pubiic building or public work; may not submit bids on leases of real property to a pubiic entity;
may not be awarded or perform work as a contractor. supplier, subcontractor or consultant under a contract with any
public entity: and may not transact business with any pubiic entity.
12.06 Suspension, Revocation, Denial of Qualification or Determination of Contractor Non-Responsibility: An
entity or affiliate who has had its Certificate of Qualifi::atlon suspended, revoked, denied or have further been determined
by the Department to be a non-responsible contractor may not submit a bid or perform work for the construction or repair
of a public building or pubiic work on a contract with the Agency.
12.07 Prohibited Interests: !..Jeither the .4gency nor any or Its contractors or their subcontractors shall enter into any
c:::mtract. subconti2(,;~ or 2rrangernent in connec.tion with the iJ:,:'")ject or any property included or planned t,::1 be Included in
the project in vmich an}1 member. officer O~ 8ilpioyee of the .A.genc}' or the loca!ity during tenure or for 2 years thereafter
has 3ny interest, direct or indirect. If any such present or former member, officer or employee involun~arily acquires or had
a::quired prior 1:J t~le beginnir:',;; of tenure any such interest end if such imerest is immediately disclos,ed to the Agency, the
P\ge:lc.y. v.'n:1 prior c:pprovai or the De;Ja.rt1l1ent, may waive the prohi~ifion contained in this paragra;Jh prcvided that ;;i:lY
such present merlber, officer or emplo]lee shall not partiCIpate in any actioG by the Agency or the locality relating to such
c:Jnt:-a::t, subcontract O~ 8:'":-angeme~:.
The Agency shali insert in all contracts entered into in conne::tlon with the project or any property included or pianned to
be included in any project. and shall require its contractors to insert in each of their subcontracts, the following provision:
ilSiTI !,1:). '1.3=.
t\o\j!3mbs: ':.:7 20G7
PaQs ';4 '!J~~-40
PROJECT MANAGEMENT OFFICE
03/07
Pagill10
STATE OF FL.ORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM AGREEMENT
"No member, officer or employee of the Agency or of the locality during his tenure or for 2 years
thereafter shall have any interest, direct or indirect, in this contract or the proceeds thereof."
The provisions of this paragraph shall not be applicable to any agreement between the Agency and its fiscal depositories
or to any agreement for utility services the rates for which are fixed or controlled by a governmental agency.
12.08 Interest of Members of, or Delegates to, Congress: No member or delegate to the Congress of the United
States shall be admitted to any share or part of this Agreement or any benefit arising therefrom.
13.00 Miscellaneous Provisions:
13.01 Environmental Regulations: The Agency will be solely responsible for compliance with all the applicable
environmental regulations, for any liability arising from non-cDmpliance with these regulations, and will reimburse the
Department for any loss incurred in connection therewith. The Agency will be responsible for securing any applicable
permits.
13.02 Department Not Obligated to Third Parties: The Department shall not be obligated or liable hereunder to any
individual or entity not a party tD this Agreement
13.03 When Rights and Remedies Not Waived: In nD event shall the making by the Department Df any payment to the
Agency constitute 0:- be construed as a waiver by the Department of any breach of covenant or any default which may
then e,:ist ori the part of the Agency and the mat~ing of such paymen~ by the Department, whiie any such breach or default
shaH e):ist, shari in no way impair or prejudice any right or remedy avaiiable to the Departrnen~ with respect tc SUGh breach
m default.
- 13.04 How Agreement ts Affected by Provisions Being: Held invalid: If any provlsion of this .Agreement is held invalid,
.he remainder of this Agreement shall not be affected. In such an instance, the remainder \o\fouid then continue to conform
to the terms and requireme:lts of appli:::;aole iaw..
13.05 Bonus or Commission: By execution of the Agreement, the Agency represents that it has not paid and, also
agrees not to pay, any bonus or commission for the purpose of obtaining an approval of its application for the financing
hereunder.
13.06 State Law: Nothing in the Agreement shall require the Agency to observe or enforce compliance with any provision
or perform any act or do any other thing in contravention of any applicable state law. If any of the provisions of the
Agreement violate any applicable state law, the Agency will at once notify the Department in writing in order that
appropriate changes and modifications may be made by the Department and the Agency to the end that the Agency may
proceed as soon as possible with the project.
13.08 Plans and Specifications: In the event that this Agreement invoives constructing and equipping of facilities on the
State Highway System, the Agency shall submit to the Department for approval all appropriate plans and specifications
covering the project. The Department will review all plans and specifications and wili issue to the Agency a written
approval with any approved portions Df the project and comments or recommendations covering any remainder of the
project deemed appropriate. After resDlution of these comments and recommendations to the Department's satisfaction,
the Department will issue to the Agency a written approval with said remainder of the project. Failure to obtain this written
approval shall be sufficient cause of nonpayment by the Department.
13.09 Right-of-Way Certification: Upon completion of right-of-way activities on the project, the Agency must certify
compliance with all applicable federal and state requirements. Certification is required prior to advertisement for or
solicitation of bids for construction of the project, including those projects for which no right-of-way is required.
13.10 Agency Certification: The Agency will certify in writing, prior to project closeout, that the project was completed in
-- accordance with applicable plans and specifications, is in place on the Agency's facility, adequate title is in the Agency's
1ame, and the project is accepted by the Agency as suitable for the Intended purpose.
13.11 Agreement Format: All words used herein in the singular form shall extend to and include the plural. All words
used in the plural form shall extend to and include the singular. All words used in any gender shall extend to and include
all genders.
::'<c. ; 1.-2\',-; i \~;. i,~::. "I
:\' "7;;Ti:)..:;t.i./ 2CIC:7
STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM AGREEMENT
. :::: ~"..r ~')
, . 'D~5'=C1D-40
PROJECT MANAGE'-AENT OFFICE
03/07
Page 11
13.12 Execution of Agreement: This Agreement may be simultaneously executed in a minimum of two counterparts,
each of which so executed shall be deemed to be an original, and such counterparts together shall constitute one in the
same instrument.
13.13 Restrictions on Lobbying:
Federal: The Agency agrees that no federally-appropriated funds have been paid, or will be paid by or on behalf of the
Agency, to any person for influencing or attempting to influence any officer or employee of any federal agency, a Member
of Congress, an officer or employee of Congress or an employee of a Member of Congress in connection with the
awarding of any federal contract, the making of any federal grant, the making of any federal ioan, the entering into of any
cooperative agreement, and the extension. continuation, renewal, amendment or modification of any federal contract,
grant, loan or cooperative agreement.
If any funds other than federally-appropriated funds have been paid by the Agency to any person for infiuencing or
attempting to Infiuence an officer or empioyee of any federal agency, a Member of Congress, an officer or employee of
Congress or an employee of a Member Df Congress in connection with this Agreement, the undersigned shall cDmplete
and submit Standard FDrm-LLL, "Disclosure Form to RePDrt Lobbying," In accordance with its instructions.
The Agency shall require that the lan-guage of tnis paragraph be included in the award documents for all sub2wards at all
tiers (lndudin;:J sub:::antracts, subgrants, and contracts u71der g:-an:s, leans, and cooperative a;lreemems: and that al!
subrecipients shall certi~y and disclose accordingly.
State: No funds received pursuant to this c8nt.aC! may be expended for lobbying the Legislature. thE j~di:;ja: branch or a
state agency.
13.14. Maintenance: The p.gen:.::y agrees to maintain any project not on the State Highway System constructed under this
Agreement. If the Agency constructs any improveme:1t on Department right-of~way, the Agency (ZJ will U wHl not
maintain the imnrovements made for their useful life.
13.15 Vendors Rights: Vendors (in this document identified as the Agency) providing gDods and services to the
Department should be aware of the fDllowing time frames. UpDn receipt, the Department has 5 working days to inspect
and approve the gODds and services unless the bid specifications, purchase order or contract specifies otherwise. The
Department has 20 days to deliver a request for payment (voucher) to the Department of Financial Services. The 20 days
are measured from the latter of the date the invoice is received or the goods or services are received, inspected, and
approved.
If a payment is not available within 40 days after receipt of the invoice and the receipt, inspection, and approval of goods
and services, a separate interest penalty in accordance with Section 215.422(3)(b), Florida Statutes, will be due and
payabie in addition to the invoice amount to the Agency. Interest penalties of less than one $1 will not be enforced unless
the Agency requests payment. Invoices which have to be returned to the Agency because of Agency preparation errors
will result in a delay in the payment. The invoice payment requirements do not start until a properiy completed invoice is
provided to the Department.
A Vendor Ombudsman has been established within the Department of Financial Services. The duties of this individual
include acting as an advocate for Agencies who may be experiencing problems in obtaining timely payment(s) from the
Department. The Vendor Ombudsman may be contacted at 850-410-9724 or by calling the State CDmptroller's Hotline, 1-
800-848-3792.
itsrn ;'~'::.). 'r '33 i
l..J:Jvembs: ~7, 200"7
? age 'i 6 i::S::wlC-40
PROJECT MANAGEMENT OFFICE
03107
Page 12
STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM AGREEMENT
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have caused these presents to be executed the day and year first above written.
AGENCY COLLIER COUNTY
By:
STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
Name:
Title: BoCC Chairman or Designee
By:
Name: Michael G. Rippe
Title: Director of Transportation Development
Attest:
Title: County Clerk
Attest:
Title: Executive Secretary
As to form:
As to form:
Attorney
District Attorney
See attacned En~umbrance Form for date of funding approval by Comptroller.
5T A TEO 0;: FLORIDA DEPARTM!:.NT OF TR!\NSPORT ATION
LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM AGREEMENT
'S~5.;o,;{)..40
PROJECT MANAGEMENT OFFICE
08/06
Page13
EXHIBIT "A"
PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND RESPONSIBILITIES
FPN: 200732-3-58-01
This exhibit forms an integral part of the Agreement between the State of Florida, Department of Transportation and
Collier Countv
Dated
PROJECT LOCATION: Stale Road 93/i-75; section 031750 from mile post 53.341 to mile post 54.691
The project l81ls 0 is not on the National Highway System.
The proje:t l81 is 0 is not on the State Hi9hwa)' System.
PROJECt DES:'RIPTIO!~: ,L..,cjitlona: janJs::;2;)e and i~Tigatl:J:: instal:ation util:zing the existing FDDi irrigation
instaliatio<!. Co!lier :o'Jnty wi!: stan~a:-d::::s t~IS ii~i;:a::b~. c-Jn:r:Jti'3~ syster;: t:, c j,.,IIJtGro:Z SyslE:m.
SPECIAL COI-6IDEi'(4TIC)!,S EY AG"I'K::Y:
The audit rep:)t"t:s) rS::j'Ji,ed i~ t;,'S A;r'3~'m-s:"',:: s r,::;: I: l:1:;iude 8 S:.heduie of Project Assistance t12t wi!i :-efisct the
Department's contrs::t ilumb'3r, thE: r:inan::i2: ?roje::~ l~umDe! (FPI\), tnE Fejsi2.1 Auth.::.rl:ation I~u~ber ~::=A"'!), wher'2
applicable, the anwunt of state funding a:tlon ,re:eipt and disbursement of funds), any federal or local funding a:tior" and
the funding action from any other source with respect to the proje::;t.
The Agency is required to provide a copy of the design plans for the Department's review and approval to coordinate
permitting with the Department, and notify the Department prior to commencement of any right-of-way activities.
The Agency shall commence the project's activities subsequent to the execution of this Agreement and shall perform in
accordance with the following schedule:
a) Construction contract to be let by March 31. 2008.
b) Construction to be completed by December 31. 2008.
If this schedule cannot be met, the Agency will notify the Department In writing with a revised schedule or the project is
subject to the withdrawal of federal funding.
All work to be conducted outside of the Department Righ1-of-Way shall adhere to the 2005 rlorida Greenbook standards,
as amended. .
All work to be conducted within the Department Right-of-Way shall adhere to the following:
(1) The FDOT standard specification for road and bridge construction, 2007 edition as amended, and
(2) The FOOT roadway and traffic design standard, 2006 edition as amended and design criteria from the PPM, 2007
edition as amended.
STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTM=NT OF TRANSPORTATION
LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM AGREEMENT
..,j'
~t)1640
PROJ!:CT W\NAGEMENT OFFICE
08/06
Page 14
EXHIBIT "A"
PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND RESPONSIBILITIES
For all projects the following will apply:
(a) Section 287.055, F.S. "Consultants Competitive Negotiation Act"
(b) FDOT "Project Development and Environmental Manual," where applicable
(c) The Local Agency Program Manual
The Agency will inform the Department in writing of the commencement and completion of the project. Upon completion
of the project phase, the Department will have forty-five (45) days after receipt of the Agency's invoice to review, inspect
and approve the project phase for payment
SPECIAL COf:'SIDERA TraNS BY DEPARTMi::NT:
The Department shall reimburse the Agency, su::>je::t to funds availability, In the year programmed, which is currentiy
07/08 for construction.
5T AT!:: 0;: FLORIDA O:::PARTMENT 01' TRANSPORTATION
LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM AGREEMENT
-52~",010-40
PR:)JECT MANAGEMENT OFFICE
08/06
Pa~e 1Z
EXHISIT "S"
SCHEDULE OF FUNDING
AGENCY NAME & BILLING ADDRESS
Collier County
1- Finance Department
2671 AiipOT1 Road
Naples, Florida 34112
FPN:
200732-3-58-01
PROJECT DESCRIPTION
Name: LandsGaDina Length: ADDrOximatelv 1 mile
Termini: SR 93fl-75 at the Golden Gate Parkway
This agreement covers the construction phase cost. Funds for construction phase will be available in fiscal year 07/08. No
construction phase work may commence without issuance of a I>JOTICE TO PROCEED from the Department. Availability
of any funds is subjeot to legislative approval.
:::UI\!D!NG
TYPE OF VVO~K By Frscat Y6a:-
TOTAL
PR:;'.I~_:'-;T FL}N:-::;
:2\
~,G::.hI:::'Y
"'Uh.!:JS
;'3;
Si"ATE &.
~~D~R;:"~ ;:"lM:J.?
I Planning
!
2007.2008
20DS~200S
208~;'-201 0
iota.: Planning C8St
,
---,.,--,-- i
I.
Project Development & Environment (PD&E)
2007-2008
I -'
2008-2009 I
I 2009-2010
Total PD&E Cost
I Design 2007-2008 ---~ I
2008-2009 I I
2009-2010 I
! Total Design Cost I I I
i Right-ol-Way 2007.2008 I I i
2008-2009 -,._- I I
2009.2010 I
Tota! Rioht-of-VVav Cost
Construction 2007-2008 I 134 000.00 I le1J2.QQJlO
2008-2009 I
I 2009-2010 I ! i
I
I 20010-2011 , --- I
Total Construction Cost '1~'..~"OC[;_GJ I 1_14-,0(100[1
Construction Engineering and Inspection (eEl) I I ! i
,
2007.2008 !
I I I
I 2008-2009 I ,
2009.2010 , ----. I
: I
, I
,
T ota: eEl Cost
Total Construction and CEt Costs
TOTAL COST OF THE PROJECT
J 134_00000
i 134.000.00
The Department's fiscal year begins on July 1. For this project, funds are not projected to be available until after the
1 st of July of each fiscal year. The Department will notify the Agency, in writing, when funds are available.
STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM AGREEMENT
:19;;': I~~' '':is i
['\lC)'v0-:;lii:J2" T: 2007
F'3;jE' 20 q,hs:'M"0.4o
PROJECT MANAGEMENT OFFICE
08.'06
Page 16
EXHIBIT "L"
LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT (LMA)
Paragraph 13.14 is expanded by the following:
The Department and the Agency agree as follows:
1. Until such time as the project is removed from the project highway pursuant to paragraphs 3 and 5 of this LMA,
the Agency shall, at all times, maintain the project in a reasonable manner and with due care in accordance with all
applicabie Department guidelines, standards, and procedures hereinafter called "Project Standards." Specifically, the
Agency agrees to:
a) Properly water and fertilize all plants, keeping them as free as practicable from disease and harmful
insects:
b) Properly mulch plant beds:
c) Keep the premises free of weeds;
d) Mow and/or cut the g:-2SS to the p"oper ~ength;
e) ?roperly prune all piants whi:h resp:msibility insiucies removing dead or diseased parts of p:ants
an:Uar ~:--uning su~h parts thereof whl:::h present a visual hs.::a:-d TOi those using the roadway: and
f) Remove o~ repla::e dead or- diseased plants irl their entii8ty, or remove or replace those plants that fali
below original Proje:t Standards.
The Agency agrees to repair, remove or replace at Its own expense all or part of the project that falls below
Project Standards caused by the Agency's failure to maintain the same in accordance with the provisions of this LMA. In
the event any part or parts of the project, including plants, has to be removed and replaced for whatever reason, then they
shall be replaced by parts of the same grade, size, and specification as provided in the original plans for the project.
Furthermore, the Agency agrees to keep litter removed from the project highway.
2. Maintenance of the project shall be subject to periodic inspections by the Department. In the event that any of
the aforementioned responsibilities are not carried out or are otherwise determined by the Department to not be in
conformance with the applicable Project Standards, the Department, in addition to Its right of termination under paragraph
4(a), may at Its option perform any necessary maintenance without the need of any prior notice and charge the cost
thereof to the Agency.
3. It is understood between the parties hereto that any portion of or the entire project may be removed, relocated
or adjusted at any time in the future as determined to be necessary by the Department in order that the adjacent state
road be widened, altered or otherwise changed to meet with the future criteria or planning of the Department. The Agency
shall be given notice regarding such removal, relocation or adjustment and shall be allowed 50 days to remove all or part
of the' project at its own cost. The Agency will own that part of the project it removed. After the 50-day removal period,
the Department will become the owner of the unresolved portion of the project, and the Department then may remove,
relocate or adjust the project as it deems best, with the Agency being responsible for the cost incurred for the removal of
the project.
4. This LMA may be terminated under anyone of the following conditions:
a) By the Department, if the Agency fails to perform its duties under this Uv1A following 15 days' written
notice; or
STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM AGREEMENT
,\'-, '~i::; ,
\i'; 0;;1^:i,18' _ 2C:C;(
:='ags 2~ 'f;f~{'-40
PROJECT MANAGEMENT OFFICE
08106
Page 17
EXHIBIT "L"
LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT (LMA)
b) By either party following 50-caiendar days' written notice.
5. In the event this LMA Is terminated in accordance with paragraph 4 hereof, the Agency shall have 50 days after
the date upon which this LMA is effectively terminated to remove all or part of the remaining project at its own cost and
expense. The Agency will own that part of the project it removed. After the 50-day removal period, the Department then
may take any action with the project highway or all or part of the project it deems best, with the Agency being responsible
for any removal costs incurred.
6. This LMA embodies the entire agreement and understanding between the parties hereto, and there are no
other agreements or understandings, oral or written, with reference to the subject matter hereof that are not merged
herein and superseded hereby.
7. This LMA may not be assigned or transferred by the Agency, in whole or in part, without consent of the
Department.
8. This LMf.;, shall be govemed by and construed in aGGordance vvith the taws of the State of Flori~a.
9. AP notices, demancs, reouests o. other instruments shaH be give:! jy depositin~ the same in the U.S. maii,
postage prepaid, registered o. cenified with retum reGeipt requeste::L
2) If to the De~a;tme:lt, addressed to:
IViichelle S. Peronto
801 North Broadwav Avenue
Bartow. Florida 33830
or at such other address as the Department may from time to time designate by written notice to
the Agency; and
b) If to the Agency, addressed to:
Pam Lulich
2885 Horseshoe Drive South
Naples. Florida 34104
or at such other address as the Agency may from time to time designate by written notice
to the Department.
10. This LMA, if attached as an exhibit to the Agreement, forms an integral part of the Agreement between the
parties dated
All time limits provided hereunder shall run from the date of receipt of all such notices, demands, requests, and
other instruments.
'TerTi !-"':0. 103'1
t',i:;Vr::;Tll:ic: 27 20Ci7
STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM AGREEMENT
~'~':;c ~~'0-40
PROJE=r MANAGEMENT OFFICE
08106
Page 18
EXHIBIT "1"
SINGLE AUDIT ACT
Federal Resources Awarded to the Recipient Pursuant to This Agreement Consist of the Following:
Federal Agency: Federal Highway Administration
CFDA #: 20.205 Highway Planning and Construction
Amount: $ 134,000.00
Compliance Requirement:
Allowable Activities: To be eligible. most projects must be located on public roads that are not functionally classified as
local. The major exceptions are the Highway a~idge Replacement and Rehabilitation Program, which provides assistance
for bridges on and off the federal-aid highwa)'s, highway safety activities, bicycle and oedestrian projeGts, transportation
enhancement activities. the recreational trails program, and ;:llannlng. res€2rch. deveic;Jmen~, and technology transfer.
Proposec projects meethg 1:19se and other p:anning d'9sign. environmental, safety, etc., reouirc~mer,ts can De a::)OfC)ve::
on the bas~s 0: slate 3nc iOGai priorities vvitnir. tne ii:Tlit 0; the: Lmcs ap::)o:-tloned or aliO(;8t~c to eacr: statE.
Allowable Costs: Eliglbie activities and allowable costs will be determined in accordance with Title 23 and Titie 49
C,F.R and the OMB cost D~jncipies a:Jplicable to the recrpient'sub-re:::ipient.
- Eligibility: By law, the federal-aid highway program is a federally assisted state program that requires 6a~h state to have
, suitably equipoec an:: org8:li.:::ed lr3~lspo~atic.Jn Ce;18ri.ment. Therefore, most projects are administered by or through
staie De:>a:-tments of 'T:-arsporratfon (State DOT~j). P:ojecis to be funded under the federal-aid highway program are
generally seiected bi' state DOTs or Metropolitan Planning Organizations (MPOs), in cooperation with appropriate local
officials, as specified in 23 U.S.C. an:! imolementing regulations. Territorial highway projects are funded in the same
manner as other federal-aid highway projects. with the territorial transportation agency functioning in a manner similar to a
state DOT. Most Florida Land Highway Program (FLHP) projects are administered by the Federal Highway Administration
(FHWA) Office of Federal Lands Highway and its Divisions or by the various Florida Land Management Agencies
(FLMAs). Under the FLHP, projects in the Indian Reservation Road (IRR) Program are selected by Tribal Governments
and are approved by the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) and the FHWA. Due to recent legislation, Tribal Governments
meeting certain requirements may now administer various IRR projects on behalf of the BIA and FHWA. The Fish and
Wildlife Service (FWS) and the National Park Service (NPS) select projects in the Refuge Road and Park Roads and
Parkways programs. respectively. For the Forest Highway Program, the Forest Service, the States and the FHWA jointly
select projects.
Compliance Requirements Applicable to the Federal Resources Awarded Pursuant to This Agreement Are As
Follows: The recipient of Local Agency Program (LAP) funding must comply with the statutory requirements in Sections
112.061, 215.422. 339.12, and 339.135, Florida Statutes, and Title 23 and Title 49, C.F.R.
,SfT;
.. ,_' '.~r
;\ '~;. ,';-,':::"
- '._,,,,'v_,,
-" .;,":';
~f
~
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation for the Board of County Commissioners to approve a Fiscal Year 2007
funding source change within Collier Area Transit Fund (426) essentially authorizing the
Clerk of Courts - Finance Section via journal entry to reverse payment of $500,000 in Fleet
Charges and other CAT operating expenses from Gas Taxes to FY 2007 5307 IT A Grant
proceeds thus aBowing the use of Gas Tax Dollars for payment of FY 2008 Collier Area
Transit facility expenses.
OBJECTIVE: For the Board of County Commissioners to approve a Fiscal Year 2007 funding
source change within Collier Area Transit Fund (426) essentially authorizing the Clerk of Courts
- Finance Section via journal entry to reverse payment of $500,000 in Fleet Charges and other
CAT operating expenses from Gas Taxes to FY 20075307 FTA Grant proceeds thus allowing
the use of Gas Tax Dollars for payment of FY 2008 Collier Area Transit facility expenses.
CONSIDERA nONS:
The project budget for repair and maintenance of the new Collier Area Transit facility totals
$2,496,178.15 with funding from several sources including;
,-"
Bee approved use of unspent FY 2007 landscape Dollars - S1,l48.493.03 (2/27/07)
Budget balance from CAT Facility Purchase - S367.6S4.72
FT A 5309 Granl - $226,710
FTA 5307 Grant - $500.000
Unencumbered Transportation Disadvantaged (427) Funds - $253,290.40
The Federal Transit Administration (FTA) does not recognize the County's annual bids,
advertisement, or BCC award of annual bids for facility improvements. To utilize FTA grant
funds for facility repair/renovations would have required re-bidding, re-advertisement, and award
by the BCC. Utilizing already awarded BCC annual contracts, enabled staff to expedite
the repair/renovation of the facility therefore reducing staff costs for the County. The FT A
requires no separate bid process for Fleet expenses. Consequently, $500,000 of Fleet
Maintenance expenses and fuel expenses, identified and expended from the FY07 budget, will be
funded by the 5307-07 FTA grant and the facility repair/renovation expenses, by the same
amount, will be funded from local funding: projects 350103, and 31427. No additional funding is
needed for either Fleet Maintenance expenses or facility repair/renovation expenses.
To facilitate the project and address the stringent grant funding requirements related to CAT
Facility expenses, Transportation staff is proposing that the $500,000 FTA 5307 Grant be re-
allocated to pay for fleet and other related operating expenses - which is permissible under FT A
grant guidelines - with a like amount of Gas Taxes used for CAT Facility expenses.
-
FISCAL IMPACT: Accomplishing the desired outcome will require the cooperative efforts of
the Clerk of Court's Finance Section; Transportation staff and OMB. A series of prior year 2007
and current year 2008 journal entries processed by the Clerk of Courts - Finance Section within
the Grant Project Elemenl of CAT Fund 426 and the Transit Facility Element of Gas Tax Fund
, ,~!a
:.1
(313) will occur first; this action will re-allocate expenditures to the desired funding source and
free up budget for movement via Budget Amendment from Fund (426) to Fund (313).
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There is no Growth Management Impact associated
with this Executive Summary.
~Mt4ENDA nON: For the Board of County Commissioners to approve a Fiscal Year
2007 fullding source change within Collier Area Transit Fund (426) essentially authorizing the
Clerk.of Courts - Finance Section via journal entry to reverse payment of $500,000 in Fleet
Charges and other CAT operating expenses from Gas Taxes to FY 2007 5307 FT A Grant
proceeds thus allowing the use of Gas Tax Dollars for payment ofFY 2008 Collier Area Transit
facilily expense and approve all necessary budget amendments.
Prepared by: Sue Faulkner, Principal Planner, Alternative Transportation Modes Department,
Transportation Services Division.
Page I of I
COLLIER COU"iTY
88,,1:[; :,'F :':'Ur,"'~' C:'::', ',~!~;;;I(!I'.'U~:
Item Number:
Item Summary:
,. ~'n'l ,." I-,d,]) ..
0: ~!:"rj C' " OLin!\ '::"~'_" ,'~~,' I'lL" ,<, ,( ,';;:PIC""i'
''''d''T'
2'''' II elf,' t \')ellJI'.I,;rO~ I~' dl"llclU " rJ: ~,~'J
, .. ~ I(',C: I",~ :': 11', :':';d 1":(' c,
I'll :111"-
"rar,<;:rdC:lt'"
"'1'1",.,
Meeting Date:
C:J ~,"-r /)/
f'repared By
Sw,: ~J.ul",'l"1
r':<nGlr"rlP,armQI
['JIB
-'ran~po!"1.illl()"St.cvin','
4I'~rrwt""., "iJ"Sportilt,,,,, Mt'(le~
11 !E:~()O-' 1 C ;..~.. J:, ,', ~~
Approved By
D<.ln;""C r:i~,!(;
L1:~.:CTO" i, Tr'r~ D"f"'~N
u~;,"
ra"~n() 'n""" ;:,["VIGP'
,t:,11"rn~tl'iC -i'l;msranat em hQai;S
1'/IJ'2l10"'IO:3':l<r,/
Approved By
ScoeF:,Tc"ch
"c.",stant(.O<lll:\,/,ttom",-
cJ,'lW
(.OlJnt\,t,tt"rnei
County Atlorn.--, Dif,e,
Ili,:2mF4'.i.!f"I/
Ar1proved B)
":',,,,,,.
,.-,','''''','1'>1'''',. ~:\!n'" PC'"
D~t'"
Apl'rnn'lllh
Al'pr,,"ed II.,
Approved B)
--\ppro\'t'd U)
"',1',1'<;':/"
'L:..Ii' ""..,,,<,,, "t,..,il
"~ , ,.
Approved U)
0,"'00 '-::1'0",..:;11 ,"tor
j.-,'1I;'1~';)11" ". ;"-,,,tv'"
;),,:<-
,',n"",,' l'~th, "'-~""'C"'"
",he"-,,,'
'CqrW"'J'
i4;':;;-r,::;,r
Approved H)
',"~r', i~~ !:SOr,
Fw;'~~t 401;'; .H
~'.-,,, t
;,Q~n;',' 1 """"9"" ~)fk"
(S:","--,,{ ~__-" \';avm"'lti: [,.-:"00'
";':C: .~'.- , "'i
Apprn\'ell Uy
M'(.'j<lD' ::',m~lk(w',<,
r'"~";)~JC"W --" ;;. ~. :c:qet [j"-"ct"r
-..()U"~''- Il~""",',~,
'Y'!ic;(
,:;'t; - ~.." ,::0' ' -' n,
'1&,L'''';''''1
"'''',,-~ ,:_"'lr DI,'
Apflr(>\'(.d lIy
','.rt'~" 1....,,,(/
"'''!Il!'it",,,,,;!'),,,
bo~," c'
,Jil':"'!'~""W"
;'~C"l"\'
J:'!I~'
'.-1 ':;'11(:-7 ~,':'", C')\,
n.- ~,,~.., n' ~,,~"",..,' , , 1\ ~""'" ,,'r>.Tcr-n
iE':IT' 1\)0. : E:B3
!'bVemD8c 27, 2007
F'2gs 1 of 4
~
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to approve a budget amendment to transfer funds into a new stonnwater
project known as the Golden Gate City Stonnwater OutfaU Replacements, Project Number
510291, in the amount of $66,500.
OBJECTIVE: To receive Board approval to transfer funds from project number 511401,
County Wide Storm Sewer Improvements, to a new project known as the Golden Gate City
Stormwater Outfall Replacements, project number 51029 I.
CONSIDERATIONS: Within the four (4) square mile area known as Golden Gate City there
are approximately one hundred forty-five (145) underground storm sewer pipe systems of
varying lengths designed to convey stormwater runoff from neighborhoods and county
mainIained roadways to the canal system. These pipe systems include components such as inlets
or catch basins, pipe segments, and outfall headwalls. Installed in the early nineteen sixties
(I 960s), most all of these systems have exceeded their typical life span and are in need of
replacement.
Numerous reports are received each year of pipe segment failure resulting in areas of ground
subsidence 'within the Golden Gate City area. Small areas of soil and or pavement sink to the
bottom of old collapsing pipes creating a safety issue. Most of the original pipes installed were
made of corrugated metal and have significant levels of corrosion resulting in structural failure
and ground collapse.
The initial effort is planned and ready to begin. Every outfall will be inventoried and assigned a
score as to its current condition. A construction plan will then be generated as replacement
priorities are established for each system. Priority will be determined based on the score of each
system and the perceived level or difficulty of removal and replacement. Based on funds
available, a specified number of systems located in the same general area will then be replaced
each year until all the replacements are complete. Current preliminary estimates believe this
project could span five years and cost upwards of five million dollars
FISCAL IMPACT: An initial work order and project scope has been prepared in the amount of
$66,500 for Fixed Term Engineering Services to complete the existing inventory work. A
budget amendment is needed to transfer $66,500 from project number 51140 I (Fund 325) to
project number 510291 (Fund 325). The source of funding is ad valorem taxes.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMP ACT: There is no Growth Management Impact associated
with this Executive Summary.
RECOMMENDATION: Tbat the Board of County Commissioners approve the necessary
budget amendment.
Prepared By: Jerry Kurtz, P.E., Principal Project Manager, Transportation Services Division,
Storm water Management Department
-
Attachments: (I) Work Order # QGM-FT-3969-08-03 with Proposal dated 10/29/07
Page] of 1
COLLIER COlJl\TY
C<J: F;[..:!'- ::)~t;'" ~':::)i,1i,~!:,,:~,:~j!\~:f':
Item Number:
Item Summary:
'lC':!"'"!':',l:),,;
'IP, 'D'A'" r',r,1' :lPr1il'''.cn: :-ii'1,;'E'" f,J'~r:"
';;:.,,'O""'dl""
I' I:.w-'r.-a, tr:f':i; ,oel <lIe
'''''''wii'Jkr ( ,1f;;1' I ':'ii(l~Ec'
,~,,('rt :';'.'ITH;u
\h
Meeting Date:
i,f,f
Preparcd By
-:;'c"\I(; ~,ur1l
S,~'l:()" EOn()"",..-""
D~t",
Tf""'_'I'Di~';it,on S,'rv,ce5
Srl)"lllWarer MamHJClT't'nt
'1' 1\'.'1007 2(1447 P~I
AppmvnlBy
G8!-:JI~ r,:mz
:;eniocE.np"''''1!r
Ume
rriin:;rcrt~tl(J" S",tv; ;,,~
S!O"mw;:.t'-"r~'I,m;)"''''''''H
'l!'::)O[)~:: :., rw
Approved Hy
(;",,,i;tlcStlto
;'otl"ni"'-"illivtk"','SI~"!
[)ole
1 ,i!"~p"niltICl~ "crviG"~
1r;:l113i!O".al:;ont.n'.m~!'!'''1': "
":''''''1!:.!c!ion
",.'],'2GO~ ~::}(', PM
Approved By
",h"
Jel"
r..""" -,m
;"ap'"
"1-1
Al1l'roH'd H~
AI'I'rIl\'l'd Il,'
Afl)Jrondlh
"ppnnl'd B~
;,'''' ;''1':)'
l"lmtn'stnL','(;:'o")
Irti,'rm.-,t.-co,' ., '''l<l'';'\
,;"'-;::')(;-'r.;:--;.'/
Approvcd By
~," chI" ~ Ill" ';(lV:",".-
r'.';,1n"\",n"__T L. ''''';0':': ,.,....".vc
LJ<'F
C'ltl";" 'j;;' ,;:()~, ,', Office
"~tt u, c.' k;alli', (,-I1""11~' ,'ifF;'
< ~.':'!-'''';~ ::.3i. t.'i
Approvcd By
.t~n,,-,,' \' :I-"uc]r;
_"',n\" .. "',~,,,"
C',"",
b"":Jc':,uunt,
['.C>" ""J";'cw'.-o:
"1<,,1'" '; .:'fiIL~
'1L:~, 0~ rOi
c:,~. lir'", , .____ --1..T.....' r ._~_.\n'" ~ ,~. ,~...1,.._" ".'\f-,-......, "" ...,,,...,(\1\..,-, '/. " ...,(v.,-", '('r"~ lTI\ """('" /'r,'
lr.'...,,,,...,{\(,..,
""._ -'::2 iTC'~-, i . ~.
''i --".:,.,' ;..' ~ .;.... _"
WORK ORDER # QGM-FT-3969-08-03
Agreement for Fixed Term Professional Services Contract
Contract #06-3969
Tl>js Work Order is for Professional (Engineering) Services for work known as:
Project Name; Golden Gate City Drainage System GPSlExisting Condition SUlvey and Inventory
Project No: 510291
The work is specified in the proposal dated October 29, 2007 which is attached hereto and made a
paIt of this Work Order Tn accordance with Terms and Conditions of the Agreement referenced
above, Work Order # QGM-FT-3969-08-03 is assigned to: Q Chady Minor & Associates, P A
Scope of Work: As detailed in the attached proposal and the following;
Task
Description
Fce T"ne
Amount
Task I
Task II
T ask !II
Task IV
Task V
Project KickofFRcscarch
Basc Map Development
Drainage Information
Drainage Maps
ReimbUlsables
L S
L S
L S
L S
1 M
$ 2.00000
$15,00000
$30.000 00
$17.50000
$ 2,000 00
Schedule of Work: Complele the first phase of this work within ninety eight (98) days from receipt
ofthe Notice to Proceed which is accompanying this Work Order
Compensation: In accordance with Article Five of the Agreement, the County will compensate the
Firm in ;,c;cordance 'With following method: (check one only) _Negotiated Lump Sum_Lump
Sum Plus ReimbUlsable Costs _Time & Material (established homly rate - Schedule A)
_Cost Plus Fixed Fee, as provided in the attached proposal.
Task I
Task II
Task III
T ask IV
Task V
$ 2,000.00
$ 1 5,00000
$30,000.00
$17,500.00
$ 2,000 00
TOTAL FEE
$66,500.00 (1.S. & T.M.)
:!E:T: 1\,10. ','::.S
~\.;:)\i:)rTll.:...2" L: 2~;~i
/ ~,
~ .,Ji
Any change made subsequent to final department approval will be considered an additional service
and chmged according to Schedule "A" of the original Contract Agreement.
PREPARED BY:
, j/7 I
L/.Y A/Iv Gee
~ince, Project Manager
<-,:}zj) //11 ~w1s
Jeny KlUtz PE, Principal Project Managcl
d2'~ ~-
Etigene C CalveJt PE, Director
Storrnwater Management Depmtment
(0/7('/:> 7
Ibatf
loll! ler?
Date
/&~/~""7
Datc
REVIEWED BY;
APPROVED BY:
APPROVED BY;
Norman Fcdcr A I CP Administrator
Tr~pOlta(ion Services
ACCEPTED By;~iJ1!
'Q Grady Minor & Associates, P A
Date
D !';VI 0 W. 5 Co '-1/-1\ ! 'fT
Signatmc of Authorized Company Ofi1cel
, 0/5/1 0 7
Date
VICe PIZ.E:~ II?O::""'"
Type or Print Namc and Title
lrans~Stormwatcr. Val
iTs:!: 1'1,::>. 168L
!-wvsmner 27.2007
1 of 10
~
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to approve an Easement Agreement and to accept a Drainage, Access and
Maintenance Easement from the District School Board of Collier County for the purpose of
maintaining the current drainage pattern in Section 34, Township 49S, Range 26E.
OBJECTIVE: To obtain Board of County Conunissioner approval of an Easement Agreemcnt and
acceptance of a Drainage, Access and Maintcnance Easement from the District School Board of
Collier County for the purpose of maintaining thc current drainage pattern in Section 34, Township
49S, Range 26E.
CONSIDERA nONS: An approximately four hundred-fifty foot (450') segment of an existing
drainage ditch is located within and along the west side of the District School BOaJ'd owned
property currentJy in final revicw and approval status for future construction of Elementary School
"G". This existing ditch known as MGG-J 5, depicted on the Stoffilwater Department's map of
primary and secondary drainage system components, has been mapped and identified as pari of the
secondary drainage system inventory for many years. This existing ditch serves as the downstream
segment of a larger system of ditches conveying stonnwater runoff nOJih to the Golden Gate Main
Canal from both the north and south sides of 1-75 [Cll' an approximately four hundred (400) acre
drainag e area.
The regional significance ofthis existing ditch was expressed to representatives ofthe School Board
by COooty stornlwater staff early during the school's design phase. As wcll. it was verified that no
drainage easement existed over the ditch. As the sehool's site design process progressed, it was
deternlined that drainage conveyance could be addressed underground by installation of twin fifty-
four inch (54") pipes while accommodating necessary minor above ground school site infrastructure
within the western-most thirty-six feet (36') of the site. None of the proposed above ground site
improvements will interfere with access to the underground piping. No compensation is due by the
COooty to the District School Board for conveycU1ce of the easement or for installation of the
ooderground piping. Maintenance of all facilities located within the easement will be the
responsibility of the District School Board.
FISCAL IMPACT: fiscal Impact associated with this Executive Summary is $50.00 (recording
fees). Funds are available in Fund 301, Project (5J007!).
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There IS no Growth Management Impact associated
with tlris Executive Summary.
RECOMMENDA nONS: Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners:
J.
Approve the attached Easement Agreement and authorize the Board Chairnlan to
execute same on behalf of the Board;
Accept the Drainage, Access and Maintenance Easement from the District School Board
of Collier County; and
Authorize staff to record same in the public records of Collier County, Florida.
2.
-
o
~.
Prepared By: Jerry Kurtz, P.E., Principal Project Manager, Stormwater Department
Attachments: (J) Easement Agreement; (2) Easement; (3) Location Map
Page 101')
COLLIER COUNTY
f)~." H :J' :~:)UI{"C\ V.J H 1-;" "S::k'Er~c
IlemNumber:
ItemSummilry:
,..:s;".,,'
l"l1\ 'HiHiI' 1'1"
'l:lI".'C'::1
""1(;
~''';:i'i ~,
,.,co"""
r.,j<!Ii'l'C ;~n,~". :.- ,,"['
T.' I",'" r-;rSln;.;' "-'~Cl,
I.';.".'r~' ,_. ::: 11,<.'1
1(01111""
.,v,.u',
'''-'.'.'F;111
'U_'I'
',:m','''llr ''Or:.
""11(;-'
Meeting Dale:
'Iv'
I'rl'pared Br
(,0,21,; i',U""
S<'<lH."h'gln,"c
:)~U
--"'5CCGC;Zm '''''''''''P.'
::wm'vJ.o'e,'i,'I.'l".,,"'rrc_rr'
. : '0i/20n' ~'t:,: :,1.' ,.,~:
ApproVl'dll}
Gerald f\wil
~;"n;(}' E'l(1meu
'Mtr
r,,-.nS;>G"'at,o,,S,,rvi"e,.
S",.rmwJl",r.'lar;,Hwmen1
;11~.'2U,;7 :::;, Pi,'
Approwd By
~,"rn;,oc. ,',crt
;'.:Hlll"'ST".'nV(:;' ,s:~;"";
:'.l\C
, -~r'~r;f)r,mi",; o>8:.,"'''l'[,
ir;jf";nDct,,t""., En<l"'< ''''';(f
~"nG'r,,:l.r'''n
tif!i:2CC - ~; ~[ p~1
Ar'l'rO\'l'd 8,1
""P''':''..V
Apl'mn'd HI
Al'l'rlll'l'd By
Af'prol'l'U B)
~p"r()"l'd B)
, ,[.,,' . 'H)C~J'.,~".,'
i":""""..lC~l."", So,,,
".;:'''."..otl'
oe.,,,.:.,\
, ; ~ ::0':)(' - Ii:; ~ "[,
ApJlrr'H'd B)
f':';~:\~\.,! Sm\ll',o\'li';~
~i.",-;;,(1"m' '1\ L h"'; ,},,.,..,ct,,.
'."J1(
(JUnI\.if<,me;:o'." ..,,___
~)!;'CC of L'7n'J,Tc-n",,,: ~. I:,"tl,,'f.\
-- .~ ",'2;J':~ " ", "II,'
Ar'provrd II}'
:'''''L''
r/,
:JJ"
E\; .'Jr:'I'..;,,,,,:y
'.en" "~.S" IY",
,_,,,,,,t,, r':,~nJ'j
C;il~(,-
i.',,','('U':,
'Jr'_'.A_
_" .~ .... (\......, (\.. ....".... ""..,\ . f n
.'."".r....'."'''>,.
Stonnwater Project: Elementary School G.
ROW Project: 99999 - Miscellaneous
Parceis: 113 DAME
Folio: 00298120909
EASEMENT AGREEMENT
THIS AGREEMENT (hereinafter referred to as the "Agreement") is made and entered
into on this day of , 2007, by and between the DISTRICT
SCHOOL BOARD OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA whose mailing address is 5775
Osceola Trail, Naples, Florida 34109 (hereinafter referred to as "Owner"), to COLLIER
COUNTY, a political subdivision of the State of Florida, whose mailing address is 3301
Tamiaml Trail East, Naples, Florida 34112 (hereinafter referred to as "County')
WITNESSETH:
WHEREAS, County has requested that Owner convey to the County a Perpetual Non-
Exclusive Drainage, Access and Maintenance Easement over, under, upon and across the
lands described in Exhibit "A" (said easements hereinafter referred to as the "Propertt),
which is aUached he~eto and made a part of this Agreement; and
WHEREAS, Owner recognizes the benefjt to Ovmer and desires 10 convey the Property
to the County for the stated purposes, on the terms and conditions set forth herein, said
terms including tnat no compensation shall be due and payable tor the Property requestsd by
County
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of these premises, the sum aT Ten Dollars
($10..00), and other good and vaiuable consideration, the receipt and sufficienc}' of which is
herebi' mutually acknowledged, it is agreed by and between the parties as follows:
1, All of the, above RECITALS are true and correct and are hereby expressly incorporated
herein by reference as if set forth fuJl~' bermv, and all Exhibits referenced herein are
made a part of this Agreement
2 Owner shaH convey the Property to County, in a form acceptable to County and at no
cost tathe County, unless othen.vise stated herein Said conveyance (Owner's deJiv61)'
to County of a property executed easement instrument) is hereinafter referred to as the
"Closing"
3 Prior to Closing, Owner shall obtain from the holders of any liens, exceptions and/or
quafifications encumbering the Properly, the execution of such instruments whioh will
remove. release or subordinate such encumbrances from the Property upon their
recording in the public records of Collier County, Florida Owner shall provide such
instruments, properly executed, to County on or before the date of Closing
4 This Agreement shall be null and void, and of no further force or effect, unless Ciosing
shall occur within ninety (gO) days from the date County executes this Agreement:
provided; however, that County shari have the unifateral right to extend the term of this
Agreement pending receipt of such instruments, properly executed, which either
remove, release or subordinate any and all such liens, encumbrances or qualifications
affecting County's enjoyment of the Property
5 County shall pay all fees to record any curative instruments required to clear title. af!
Easement recording fees. and any and aU costs and/or fees associated with securing
and recording a Release or Subordination of any mortgage, lien or othsr encumbrance
recorded against the property underlying the Easement
6 Maintenance of all facilities, located within the Property area, Is the responsibility of the
Grantor The Grantor is also responsible to replace any material destroyed durtng
mafntenance Bctivities
7 This Agreement and the terms and provisions hereof shall be effective as of the date
this Agreement is executed by both parties and shall inlJre to the benefit of and be
binding upon the parties hereto and their respective heirs, executors, personal
representatives, successors, successor trustees, andfor assignees, whenever the
context so requires or admits
8 Conveyance of the Property by Owner is contingent upon no other provisions,
condffions, or premises other than those so stated above; anc this written Agreement,
including alJ exhibits atta:::hed hereto, shall constitute the entire Agreement and
understanding of the parties, and there are no other prior or contemporaneous writt8n
or oral agreements, unaertakings, promises, warranties, or covemmts not contained
herein
9 This Agreement is governed and const.''l:ed rn accordance wnh the laws of the State of
Fiorija
IN \NITNi::SS WHEREOF, Declarant has caused these presents to be executed the
date and year first above wntten
AS TO COUNTY:
OATEO
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E BROCK
BOARD OF CDUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORiDA
BY:
- JAMES COLETTA, Chairman
, Deputy Clerk
,-\,-,! '::; I ; (; c; : ~~::;;,
ii', ,,~-DC:;.
::~J'.~!7
il 0; 'Ii
AS TO OWNER:
DATED:
WITNESSES:
Witness (Signature)
Name (Print or Type)
Witness (Signature)
Name (Print c~ Type)
Approved as to form and
legal sufficien::y
~---
Elien T Chad,,,,1I ,h.-)
Assistant Coun~I~__
DISTRICT SCHOOL BOARD OF
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By
Steven J Donovan. Chair
~,~.-~-o: '-',"':,r~. ':\','f"':~' ;C'~I"icw
Hid/lief:,'; ~7
,.<:; ; 3:"1 ~! _'"~
-"1'..'7
= i;:';;:- 5 J:
= I~.:::;
~,g~
..; cv
::r;
i~~
- (f,
!E>
~ "
~z
0,
<
~
>
~~
'.
::z: ~!!:'
a ~~.
j::: s; ~
n ,~
.....~
ct ~~...~
() ~8<S
LLJV)~,,~
""'=:'''-
,......, c~~
"'""-l ~<..;~
>.. ~~.~
h :::~S;
G:: ~~(5
lJJ ..., '- ~
Q. b~~
01 ;;~~
(:( ~~~
a.. "....
<
,..
'""
e
:r
:>(
""
.~
, c "
'"
"
I
'"
I
,
"
~
\>:;
'"
~t<~ ~.=::g 'l
15__~"":::6':':~
':;:~~~'D'~""''- '.
~~.;..,~~~~~~
~cl;;'~ ....'e;'~-...~
<:I..>'"":':::~"'~~~
=~~~~H~~~~
:"U';;:0"'-~""~'-'l~~
:;g;:;:;':tx2:: ~.S?ll:: :"?, ~
~-::"""~8~-,-cs~
"';: ~'~ '-';;:::2i;;:' ~;;:O5:'
~"'c.,'e~Z""8::;-2~
~~%~~::;~~~,~~
Wil!i!m
~ 91 "': ~ " _. ~ 00_ _ <~, <::',
~~;'~~';f;-::~&i;:o
~ - ~ \. I ;
", '~.i
a
'''',,>
l ' 'Oct?
~~.
II "S';
, I :.';:,p
I'
, ,
I
, I
I.
, '
, !
-,
I
~
~~~
~~2?
~~~
~~$
<0'.:;:~
~
~~::
:;0'<>.,
<,
~ ~
~g;~ 7.;:<:
",--
~~~
:s:&..~.
~<>::t~
;~tl::
'" <>
I !
L__\
$j.~
.~
~t>\
~~
I!
,
II
,
! '
!
, ,
: I
'" ! ~
'"
~ I
~
'" I ,
~ ' ,
Ii
..., I
... !,
[S
<: , ,I
, !
,
c.
! '
, I
, I
I,
I'
,I
I
I;
I
I,
I
I
\
\
il",
I"",
I <:>t.L'
jjlSlt]
, :T'"
J Ivj ~
j~~
1,,<
I "-
,I
;1
~
I
ZOgE
A1.eQ,6t.88 S
S1mlj-:u.,J~lI=\'!1
P"VN.:JVtrl!W~ A. , I ~
;'(f1J~h;J/~ lI:vV::J e:. 'I (,j! r.:, ~ <:;. ~ "-
Amlll',J1)'-<.J~ -, 'I'" <::> ~
n.,,,,, '"',~'R.'" , ~I " I ~ <h
. .' .
B" i~ ~
~
~
f,C:
o
<:
t;?{
t:'Q.~:
..:;, -;;
~~~
~~~
",;<::",,'
-~<>
r.:2~
2;!"c:
1!Si;.c
't~G~
15d'!'-'
~o~
~~fJ
6~,--_
"',,'"
::-;2::-, ""
~"....., '<> .
;., '"t ,., 0,
""w ""
~~~~
~
~ i:2~
'>
'" R
;]:::
~ ~~~
~ D~"".
t:::l ~'''~
'" 1<<
V) <:; 1.:<:-
--.-J C
~ ~
~~;=1
",--
~t:'~
!t:'~~'
<;"J0;;:'i?
tl::""
Qc:;'"'
'" a
"
ctLQ
~~.
.'--' i
CQ~.,~
a~g
'''-'..>
Q. fi!:>i
)
/
V,
":0.'"
"-,-.
,~,
; ~~
~
'"
1;
~
"
<<
~
'"
~
~
'"
:;
~~
B~
~;::;
~. ~
.....""
,.,'..;,
~~
~"
"-'?'
:t~
''''''
,
~
~
I;l
~
'"
~
~
~
~
o.
~
~
1:!
~
~
~
~"
~~
::~
~:J
2; ~
"2.i;
~C:l
b\,-"
~~
-,c.:
"
~ ~
~Z~~ ~
~~'~~~8 )..
g3~~~~ ~
i3~~:::9~~Ct:
~~~""e" ii;
~~~~~~h~~ ~
l!j" I" I, I,,, ,. i--
~c:;....,- _?io" ,~()
lu QCI..:~<:::Cl;:. <:;'.f:
-J "'_ e:...c:o ~ n:: G Cl
~il
~15
"'-"
:;:'cs
'c:!b:
~
'~
~
~"I '~ ~
.:tI'g '. ~ ....
~ Ui~ I:rJ ~I~ ,~
'" J'I!(i ::t ~ ~ ::::
~ ~ II) (J c:; 4-
....
Of.,.
<: I-. ~ ~
8 fEe.;, ~
""V)kl
9:: LBo;:;:'" ~ '"
~ CI) "'"
V ~;:::"'ii2
V)LLJ lJ.j." ~ '"
c::;", f"'''-..)
Cl l<J LLJ S "-
.... Q) ~ [;i i:
"C :;>lJ.j "''''
Q) <......,,-
l<J ;i': Llj Il.. G
-.I J:ta ~
Q CJ~ ~~
<: l<JO ~~
"" Clo..~"
:t ~$ ~
e.;, . .... '"
I-. Cl 0 "-
lJ.J '." '"
V (,0<"'1::
- \')(!)'...:'
Cr) :q: ~~
~ .
~
;/)
'"
- t ,_
~~ i::- fj 3
Jj~ 2~.J :0
- c... ,,, ,~.':
~;'f, ~.~:F ._
~ $ ~g',~ ~
......:; < ~ ~1 ~
0::: U c::
.:---... & ~
o ~ ~ r,i:lft ~
~~ ~t S
'-'t, '" ~ ~~:
0::.: ~'_
~;'::)co.. 1
s:c~;, h~,)
<;;; '" 'R~~
.........,,, < J!"5'"g
~~~j e:::~
..:-, ct. < ~~~'
~.tr)()' ~~~
c::' ~ ;:: fi:,)~~c:,
-=::t ~ ......:::: ;~i5~
'I-' <.:c:. e"".."
>-.:..., i5 a <' '-'
(J%:tJ P~t2
~ ~~~
~ 1~~~
Q>S c;;::~
~
~.
~
'0
~
"'
:::~
Ch
us"
';;,
~~
STORMWATER PROJECT: Elementary Schoo; G
ROW PROJECT: 99999.Miscellaneous
PARCEL: 113DAME
FOUO NO : 00298120909
DRAINAGE, ACCESS AND MAINTENANCE EASEMENT
THIS El,Sci.1L:.k;-, ma:Je and entered into this day of
, 2007, by the DISTRICT SCHOOL BOARD OF COLLIER
COUNTY, FLORIDA, whose mailing address IS 5775 Osceola Trail, Naples, FL 34109,
(hereinafter referred to as "Grantor'), to COLLIER COUNTY, a political subdivision of
the State of Florida, whose maliing address is 3301 Tamiami Tmil East. Naples, Florida
34112 (hereinafter referred to as "Grantee")
(Wherever used herein the terms "Grantor" and "Grantee" includes c8ch parties'
respective heirs, legal representatives, successors and assigns Grantor and Grantee
A!'e used for sinslUlar or plural, as the context ,equires )
WIT N E SSE T 11:
Gr8mor, f:Jr and irl consideration of TEN DOLLARS ($'10,00) and other valuable
c:lr.sideration paid by the Grantee, the receip~ and suffIciency of which is hereby
acknowiedged, hereny conveys, grant~, bar-gains and se!!s unto the Grante~, a
perpetual non-E'y.dusive diainage, access and maintenancE:' easement to enter upon
and to install and maintain drainage s:r'uctures and fa8iliti8s, i1ciuding but not limited tc
ditches, swales, eartnen berms, rip. rap and retaining wall systems, underground pipes,
and various types of water control stnlclUfCs. over, unde;, upon and across the following
des:::lioRd lands io.:;ated in Collier County, FbndC'J to wi::
See: attached Exhlbit "!-\" which is
Incorparat;;d herein by reference
Subjec";f to easements, restricticr.s. and res~rva(ions of record
TO riA VE AND TO HOLD the same unto tho Grantee together with the right to
enter u,oon said land and to place and/or excavate materials for the purpose of
constructing, operating, and maintaining drainage facilities thereon Grantee's
acceptance and recording of this easement, however, shall not obligate GranteE.: to
perform any act of construction or maintenance within the easement. Construction and
future maintenance af the easement area and aJt facilities therein is the iesponsibHity of
the Grantor, and Grantor reserves unto itself sufficient rights in the casement for thesr~
purposes Tile easement granted herein shell consUlute an easement running with the
land and shari burden the lands describ80 r:Jhove
, -
. "".."'~',
-,,'
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Grantor has caused these presents to be execuled the
date and year first above wrTtten
WITNESSES:
D1STR1CT SCHOOL BOARD OF
COLLIER COUNn', FLORIDA
By:
Witness (Signature)
Steven J Donovan, Chair
Name (Print or Type)
jtiflllc~l;:7
Wrtness (Signature)
Name (Print or Type)
STATE OF
COUNTY OF
The foregoing Drainage, Access and Maintenance Easement was acknowledged before
me this ~..___, day of ,.,._____, 2007. by Steven J Donovan, Chair of the District
Scheo! Board of Collier County, Fiorida who
~s personaJJy known to me
OR
produced
id entity
as proof of
(affix notary Beal>
(Signature of Notary' Public)
(Print Name of Notary Public)
Serial! Commission # (if any):_
My Commission Expires:
Approved as to form and
Legal 5ufficisncy:
Ellen T Chadwell
Assistant County A
I....~t R~"i!;~' 2/ll1/n?
'."'-
! ~ ~~ i ' ""
'~,:/,en,~~ _I ~".
J:
'7
::..C'.::;
. ,........ :J~
cJ_ Q:
7.'- :J
= Qi CV
:::,-9 L
-(1)
~>
=2
/'1)":"'"
0..
<:
6:l;
~I;~
~Ic,;:.
l) ~~. ,:'::"
~i~if
1,..'....11
~. '.:~;
<t
'"'
-
~
-
-
;;::
~
I ~"'"
.: .i-,
ii, .'L
/0>1. "..
i i" ~
_L
<
~
'.
.'
~:~:~
""" ". '~~
-- Q '-
~r~
::~: 2
"
, ~
'"-' ~-, .....,
~tr.-,
v.~~
:5<;:......
~~.~.
c:)q;,o;:.
CioC~
~c:,c:;
~
. ,
", '':~"
" ,'~
','-"
~ -I -'cO
,/
K:~s;..
0'
"
'-,:"j
'"
'"
'0
..,
'""
'"
'" I
'" i
~'l I
is I
-.. I
,I
I'
I
I
II
,
..
['
: 1
,i
~.I-
I,J..J
1.,-,
I~ G3
,<-; ~
:~'"
;'-0~
1"-0
I \'S"l-'
lilt
II
I'
.~
"'. (~
.~<,;;:
,
- ..
'...>''"1
.~~
.. c'
:;:b<
C.:5~
>::: \..~
I
I
.zO'9[
/vl ,6f.62,88 S
.'.~;' n.,;" -", "J, ~Jt). J'II(I'
:~ 3,
;;: ~..:;
.- ~
_ ":.;
'"."'-'.'>
~;' .3-; ....
}, ~~,
fJ)
~
Cl
<:
-'.':;.::--
:S ~ ~
:..~ :.:. S
;";~i ,-'
~~~
? "'-.!. i:
,\ ~~-~: .
..^-..... '"
',',;",,,,
.~ ~ '. _5'::
~~,~ ~
1
I
I
~
C'\I
~~
~
~
~<t
~
.'
Co
"
V,
,~ ~~
g;6
,.,..;'::..:
""'-J~' ~
,
c:i:~
~''',
)'"
l...'--
'o;;i
.,::::
-
\00
....,2
~~
~~:t
"'''''.......
~~~
o.
63
~.,......,
::i~: :3
'.Q '-~ '-::>
'''(;1..,,-
't:.<$",,'
a:g~
Q'r;;;~
~::;'
" ~
"
~
~
"'-
::;
~
<
'~
,).
;? ~
,,;'.,.
",--"
~~
!(~
::-.~
- '..:
~~
'i:.~
~
~,
"
"
'0
'.'J
:~
;)
~
~
,:o?'<
~~
~
<::',';2
~. ..,..
;~
jOt;>
:~ ;~
~2
f.....'"'UI.'Pi','m C',,).'
~
'"
,
~
~ ~J ~
!ni~L ~
QI"'" <.""" V)
~~~~:~:~~~
~ ~'--' '::?G
lJ.J;t;::,':.0,--,'-,,1.:0 r:..::0 :<:::
-.l!,,:u:c::.::;'<>o,,-,.":... .
;
c,c ~
. ~
~ L..~
::,: ~
r:. ~-'
~'''''''L~C'' l;:';;-O~l;~~'~~n
~; "'J ii'<:'f
~i~, r~'IItl.l "-
U, I I~ a
'I r ~I IGJ ~
&-; ~ .,~1 I~I ~
:f 1 ~i~l~i~ ~
~ ~ ~j(~ICEi;:: ~
c5 '.
-.. a ~
<. I-:J:: co
Cl <:(j"
~ ltj,^ (\i
D.. _v,
--lJS>.t
~ li)Cl::;;o"
v ~::c ~~
(3ltJi-:"c
CJl.t.JrGst
-JC!l~g"
"'(0 ~l.t.J "';::
~ -.....;-.I"'.';g
l.t.J ",l.t.J 0 '.
-JCl::Cl~~
ClCl<:';?",
<: l.t.JCl"'::J
"" Cl Q, i2 ;0
~ ~s ~.'"
'-.J ~ -.J P::
t-- aQ <:
~ ~<;;?
U3 l<) ~ f~
~ ~::
--2:
-~
" '_I
. ~ ~;
--, ~ C;:" \;
c:~~;lj
~-, ~ ~ ~~:~! ~
-c::r ~,-' ,." :. ti :::::
(~, == >- jl ~
<5. _. ~ ~
~/~~ ~,",I! ~
'.I: ~ ~~; J _...J
~ ~ ~ ~~ ~
._'j..' '; h ;:~ ~
Ou 'c ~ ~'!.
~ '-"-
""PC,
""'- ..... ~
~~ ~ ':~ M~~:r,
<:.. '" e<;>2~
~~ ~ ~~i~~
~~ ~\~i;~:3
'. -l Vi ";rl'31;3i'~
~.. -~:~""fi,~1
~ ~ ~ :},~~~~-
..,.... ~ :.::: '>'1:)......'" j
'''::''<!Mi>:
--..:;g i') ~ ..; <J
~',:, '" A\;'''''
cY~ fin~
-
..,,~
v,
~
~
~
""
a~
(J)'"
3: ~:
lU"?
ll:~
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
'-',~;:.-;.' kJQ i,::;"
r'JC'\--e:TmS~ _
1Chj7
-'u
Drainage Easement for Section of MGG-15
LOCATION MAP
" ,:: .. ~;>I ~: .;,r~' I.....; . ~~_-.t ~~~~ ~~ ~~. "~~ ~g 5"" ~1';;,; ',-'i ': - h~,::V: -/ ~~:.~.~ ~~. ~~~:::"\..)~;:; "
< '" ~A.."'lt '.'.1'" ...1""" '_'.--, ...LJ,..V "l: ,,~.... ..._~__ ....~.~ .._,___.-...: I, '"
' , ""',,;., < "'" "', ," Z9'" " ". ......" "" .-..-..~.", ,'., ,'c-" ~, ' ~
;:: .--;'~~ ~;- ~. 0"-;; W''''''~, ~'lroi._ r~ "'..;'~ :"... ~.~ .~~ -.!: ...-...' ,......
~!....:~!'~.V J-- '" _"'! ~-""k"-Jt.'''''S::~',:?,",:'''';: -' ~~ 1';_"",~~23!!!~f:J:"6'~-.~_~"~--'-t:";'
"",.-"",-="" .....1' , --.1.,:'_(1)11" ~ \. ,...., :""".1-" . ~ 1e;r~ _
,....~. .. ',' J. L-.'t ti. .. ;1"" .,....'1--#""...... --; - ~"'. ":<:3 '% ~::l,tu"A,,-'...J~_~,~. . '
l.lJ~ "'" _? 3:;:1 l'l'itr.l~ JJ'.~ ,: l7"'::i!::" I. -'~~_to-'.t:-__ ""'~. __ ~~"'-.~~~.
~,' . .r"'i 1 M",G.O wCOO~5 <.. ,,,t. l;<;.... '" .l~ S::,~,,::-'. 'A'=. ,," tr-- _?~")i.' . _..,.... .:,.~.__.
::z:~- .."",..... '"""?i -, w, -..._.... ""'" -' . (,I) ';J'""7"j' wn--...r; . ~ ",,,' .. ~ ~ ~..... ,_...~
.... ~ "'-~ ..:.i._<l'"";:JIi .~.,' > - ~ j. .L.;....t;;\.... " 30THAvESW"" - - .- Ct:f:;J'r..... . "~""'" 30THAVESW,,__.... ;J, ;'I..,~" ~
~-'*'0I-:G5' Gj-: .,\ (,I) -~""""" ,.:. ~?,""~1Jl'~~!tl.U~-'~ CI.I.-; ~ -Fi'\i"'''''~ :;;~->-.-.S:...--.V',;...-f'r
~J,""G) ~rcl'_S":-~"~~:'Fi:::P..~\~'~.t~r.::t"c:~ '''~'~._-~~-''''1i~i::~t;..- ._~L_ ~_"~'"t -~CI.I'-f~~.'~"
~, :~ -r. ~ ~-'~ .~', l;.~\.-.:ti:i ~E:'t;.~f r:: ....::i:,lt- ~ ~:t:I;1::", l~tS:,~_f\:~:rS:..~~,S::?~r..7' ffi~;: ~;,
. b ~.g g '-Ail.' t -. .....,- 13crrHPLsw.~".. '.~ ....,_~ .: --;-:::-i:"'7""CI.I1;'~~tflo- r-::".......:...~~ .~.
-r-,'" ~.t..:", s: r: ~t""l-~. i"';~ ff~~t,:,.=-~...I~~~r..,..~,.:..:~~~ ;..1'~" ~ 'j);- CI.I -':'~,j. ffi:-;t',-"t;L -'~~~-.~(i,
~",O\__CJ',O\~ 'il-,p'tt:.~'- 4.... ....,'~ :4', -<:J ,t!l:-Q~:.tl!L-j...;~-QO .-.......01 (,1)'1.
_....--Il:I~~.,Jl"t~~- '-."' :~",,",".I':'~.~:::::r-"; r.-or-:;:'} f ~".'" -.n r-~!L~,,:lIi!'" QtLow,;, _:;:::-... _ ,,-- \- ...."l-~
~" ~f~,'-"!r"r'r-~, .1':"""':,{;-"':~" ..(', . ~ . '. . ... - ( ,,' ~.... :-:: ~l:_~_ ~'_,_: <O;~ ..,:-~~~ ~
fl1~~~..}o ~,,"'I',. ."...... .3;S~~y/~.1w~::~.:;,.,;,~_ \;}..r~~;..r.~~G~~&:GO~q,~ ",.. ,-:~_: "'t~~r._~.~; \,--..t ..~,:r~
-Q,,~,!,,'I._....:.-;;.t,.....~,....';M~...., 'I : . " .' .H' ,;;.r-r:-:".,. ..,......,,;":-",..~..:of:..., ...-\; 1... ,.. ~..._...._,..;," __. ~ ...._..
'C~'''' ',".~.:.' ,~;';"~ .,. ...... ~,~~""',.....':":'"'""",~ ....'.;.1,..."'.,.. '.' ~.' -- ~'", ...,,.~ '0>
. .:"'~."'.' ,.",-.-~.~,- "ii'i...,.."':;.....l.t1.;~,r.. ..,...,r'l""'.:~-"""~.:l,.'"'r'i.-"}',,.. ~ . ",. .." W
~l-"- ,...."...1-' ~.:-.... -"":'-:r.(~, il\'~.,:' <::-\:2:'..{ $. :,-,,:~:' .,;,.. .... ~-':' ,,;~ ,,' ,31STPL S ...;.
..,.t. .:;,' 31STPLSW, . ..J/!, .;i.e.. " ~.. ~~r."'l!"'" ...;
-~i:c ::;:7~:=~~:';~~="\;:: - 1 "':~N::~~W
32NDA'YE -~~~ - ''"': :1 ,-- - --"?>,';;'" ..-',.'
~ . - ,.;..~,,.,.~ - .,.-
....-.'
....r
c_J.."C,"
S,chCi.~1
/' "
.'.;.....
::;0005
-,
,
':;00':5
1,(,;';'.
\
\
COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
TRANSPORTATION SERVICES DlVIS10N
STORM\\'ATER fvlANAGEMENT DEPARTME'\T
::'~:8:; SCH''!H 1']()R."t,:.sI](iL rmJ\T
h:APU:S FI (IRJD; 3-1-1114 I :::3" I -;"'":'''':'.N! '):'
PROJeCT MANAGeR JerrI' Kurtz DATe 11/7/2007
N
+
0 295 590
I , I
Feet
i ierr, fJCJ< 1635
1\:J\i;:~mner 27, 2007
~>age 1 of 3
.~
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation for the Board of County Commissioners to approve a budget
amendment to move unspent landscape maintenance fees that rolled from fiscal
year 2007 into fiscal year 2008 to the Bridge Repair/Rehabilitation Program in the
amount of$621,72I.6I.
OBJECTIVE: To request approval [rom the Board of County Commissioners for a
budget amendment to move unspent fiscal year 2007 landscape maintenance fees that
were fe-budgeted in fiscal year 200S to the Bridge Repair/Rehabilitation Program.
CONSIDER<\TIONS: A budget amendment is being requested to move unspent
Landscape Maintenance funds from fiscal year 2007 that rolled into fiscal year 200S to be
moved to the Bridge Repair and Rehabilitation program. Landscape maintenance funds
are re-budgeted each year and the unspent funds that rolled from 2007 into 200S are not
needed within the Landscape program.
~
Five (5) bridges were initially idemified as having condition ratings based on FDOT
bridge inspection reports that warran1 attention lor possible repair or rehabilitation.
Transportation hired consultants to review the bridges in detail and design appropriate
improvements to overcome any t'eJJ1her deterioration and to extcnd the useful life of the
strnctures. While none of the bridges are at risk for a catastrophic failure. they do require
attention. Thc final repoli fi'ol11 the consultant is expccted \0 be completcd and provided
to staff in Jalluary 20()8 and will include estimates to repair'rehab these bJidges.
Staff is requesting that the remaining unspent funds from the Landscape Maintenance
program be moved into the Bridge Repair/Rehabilitation program to assist with the cost
of these repairs.
FISCAL IMPACT: A budget amendmcnt is needed to move unspent landscape funds in
the amount of $621,72 1.6 1 in Fund (I 12) within various project accounts to the Bridge
Repair/Rehabilitation Program in the TranspOliation Supported Gas Tax Fund (313),
Project (66066).
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There IS no Growth Management Impact
associated with this Executivc Summary.
RECOMMENDAnON: That the Board of County Commissioners approve the
necessary budget amendments.
Prepared by: Sharon Newman, TranspOliation Operations Manager
Attachments: Spreadsheet breakdown of funding
..-.
_.,-'--".."__.,,..._ ...._.._..,___.,._ .,.._....'n..".. .. ,..."~,,., _,,~.
COLLIER COUNTY
""A:;[
': :.' U !.; T \ (; C' L~ 1',' i ~~ ,.,: (J! ~. ,., ,
Item Number:
Item Summary:
I;,.
C;[:'ll\
r.dJ,";iP'<lCI11P'"
WI'..I)("l;ICln
1~; 1'-"
,.,,;'] '.;1'.:'1 n;'c ~ ~ 'r,;j' ,..",0'(: ,.
.,CD
.,.,p;,:; "1i0'"
,(I"
Meeting Dilte;
;, P,,~
Prepared B~'
Slla",,,N,:'w'nJr
J\G""'J'lj'w.Surwr'",wr
['ill"
:r<lnsp"'tnbonS".'m,<"
'I ,arn,rJQct,1!t"'~ :'(Jf;./lC( .; ;'(IITI'f
';.'9i20C ~ ",,:Ob PP,',
Appn'\'l'uBy
She'lOt, :.,""".'''''",
t>. ~~()LJn(;r-,[; SUIlf.'(:'I~,()'
UiW
l'-,n;,,'''ct,oj,cnS'
,,,,,,,.,""'l,nrtm ~;~'vi'-e'; ,,,m,,,-,
11!e,:;;:UO";"4:iJlJ;>r"
Approved Ily
r,lcml::.h,Jw.U::;o
~,,~ "",-:<:1.10', UI'.'I,>wr i\urnm'Colr~~'Jf
L;,-,,'
':' "'-,,,~: N'
.~", ",,',,;:,,',0' """V'~'" ;'t'm"
11'1~"200" "~(J;. '/
Approved By
h'C.cu""
,.., ":.L:"V,.
::,,'1-
,.,. '.1(' ,,'
'\pproH'd By
'\I'pn",.,tllh
ApprO\'l'd By
.\ppn",,(j HI
,.e,,1'
'w.'
...m ..LT~...' r- ..._~_,,(\~ ~ '_. ~__l_.._o" ...,n...,.., 0" ...,,,...,,,/\..,., 1 ,. o'....,",--'rn "'r~ n'''.....,/\ A ('r~'
.._.._~-_.. --.-^..""-.---.--.
Pa!:!c 1 of]
,.., ((., f ~:::G:
'"
= ":, ~
;:: C:-'C
i~
~ .~
-~
(1) --
2:'
o
~
g ~ g * g gl~ 21g121$ g'glg,g g g gig glg,g g gig g g g gig g g,glglg,g,glg gig
~ 0 MOW <=> <=> W <=> <=> <=> _10'01010 010 010'0 010 010'010 010 <=> 0[0 0 01010 <=> ~Io 010
::: <;> III <D a;I 1.0 '0 0 I t I' 0'
III M CO <=> M '<l" III It- I "'I I
E g; .n <"i"; N I"';.,.. '" I I ' I
~ ~ N N - :N1 ~I I i I
8 : I ' I I
I : I ~ I Ii,
~ N,O 0 III 010 0'0;0 010 -1'OIOiOIOIOiCC!OIO 010 01'<1" 010 0 <=> 0 cclolo <=> 0 M 0 <=> 010 010 III 0 '<l"
~ ~Io~ ~ q q ~:~iqlq q,~ ql~lq q q ~Iqlq 0'0101'<1" 010 <=> 0'0 '<l" 010 e'OINICC M <=> 0 _'0 '<f10 M
>- <Xl co <=> <D,.... <=> 0 O'Ltl'O~olo.... 01.....'01010 ""01,0 010 0 M N 0,0 '<1"1<0 '" 0 CO"" <01_ 0 _10 <;>..... <;> .....Io'w
It-Ir-""'I~ w I III IN I .Ill 1"-, I ' ClC M.... '<fIt- '<l" '<l".... '<l" OIOIW en I"'...... '" ,'''
"iii gl~I'<l".!"":,,,,: r-. eo. I~ ' Fill. Ni , M.. '<l" ""'.I 10:> ",:I"l '<l".1 M '1'-0 '<l"1a;l.I"'";. <'1.1 r-. o::r o. IWI
::l N <0 ....11"-1'<1" 0 "'.... I "" i en ....1 N r-IN '<tIt-1M I..,. M.... Ill.... '<l" III
U I' : IN N I ;....:', i, I.... l<n JJ-'~ 1....1""....1 1- ~
<:{.! Ii, ~. .. I I I . " I
I '~ ~I~:~,W g ~ ~ ~ ~i~ *i~!~ ~lg:ol~!~:g ~1~lg!~:g!~ g:~ ~:~:g ~IIN'~ ~ ~i~:~I~'~lg:~'~ ~
~ ~II~I~ ~i~I'O:~ ~ ~ ~ ~1:,gl~1~i~ ~I~I~,!~ ~i~ E!~I~il,~i~I:",~,Oi*,I~i~I:,~,I~,:,~I~ ~ ~!~i~,I~I~!rnl~ ~"~
-g ~ ,;!:Ii gi~: :.: :o'1g! ,o::;i:1'iI;;;~!~ l:;il:o' :&:1";,0 'I~:ail,o:~ !:il:;il~ Igl~;"; "1:21:&::g!I~'.~I~ I~
~ 1 I' i ,I I, I I ! , I I , 1 ,: 'DL--' I I I' I WJ
:~' ~,IOO 0 0 010 010 0 OIO'OOITIOIOiO T O!OIOilo,o;toIT'lo 0'1,0 0,0101010 0110010 0
a:l2;! I,! I I I
ON! I ': I I I 1 1 1 "
~ I I I I! I !! !
TI
o
.
TI
,
~
"
Q
~
~
~
00
<
L>
W
~ i
Q
~
~
0
>
~
~
Q
Z
~
~ ~I
w
~
<
L>
00 ,~I
Q
z
!S Cll <l> S-
(7, ~ <l> (I)
f ~ <rl ~?5 ~?6
C~ ~ EIX~~&
"-0 ~ 2IXli;I/J<ii- .E(/)~..:::
Q>-~~~,~~=2~~ffi ,~UM
~~~ma:u..:4i8:::~<~:id',~:::
~;;;B<t >-~~-' "'5 rocr:>r:::~"O
~_~mW0~~Effi2~~[~u~~
:;;'5.~2~~<;=:::~S;:':m
o[~~~~~0>-[~~ES~rn~
~~~~i~~u_~~~~~~_',~_'~~u_i
~ Ch Ch ro ill '" .~ 0 (') !f IX .~> .> = IX 0
_~~~OIX<(')(')uu<~~E(f)(')
~
~
>
l'
.~ IX
E;:: g:
0:
~
~ is;::-"Ocr: u.J
~ -oJ Si ~ L5 C1l ~
(L -~~~__
-:t (5.:.:;; ro '" ~ g'
-if .0(\ n (f) (L <l> _.~
~~'~~~'S~E~~
<l> -Z'IC.- '" 0 y "'" ~"O"O
'f~~~iSzS>-:;~
~cy~cr:~:;;~~g~
0iL~g:~~~:i~E
>
~..~ ro ~ ::'i:
u '" [l)"", -
~;~~~ ~g: 'S-e?
2i~~~",~ '~(')2o
~~ro_"O~~~~~~
~;~~~~~&:~~&
~15>=-g ~ ~E: g~ ~~ .o~
~ZS-Z]j='5;;;v;(/)(L"::,
Q3:; ~:;; S';: iJj ~ ~:;.~ IX
8~i:5'g~~~~~'gbg:
~
o
o
:: E :7: 0
~ ~ ~ ~
~ & ~ &
~c-g-:~=
iZ ~ Z ~
~ g>:;
~ ~ ~ ~
~~~~g~2~~~~~~~~~&~~~~~~~2=~~2
OQOOOOOOooo___~_______coooooo
oooooooooooooooooOOOOO~~NNNNN
~ww~w~w~wwww~~~www~www~wwwwww
;r;;:::;;;;;;;:r:~~c;:::;;:::r:;::w
_ _ _ _ N ,.., ..... "- - ~ "'" N '<t ...'"J ..,.
000000000000000
NNNNNNNN,...-,,...-,,.,.,"''''.....'''''
wwwwWWWWWWcDWWW......
~~~;:::~~~~
-~-~~~
NNNNN~~~~~~~ NNNNN~ ~ ~NN~~~~NNN
- - - -- - ~ - --- -- ~ ~ - ~ ~ - - - - - - ~ - - - ~ -- ~ - --
1- ~
'w
IN N
li- ~
1-'
,~ - N
'w w
1
'~
,ro
6
'0
I::;
~
Iw
,~
,-
:g
i~
1
I~
I~
I~
I~
1-.
!-
~
U
2
<5
o
i>
~
e1
~
~
o
o
w
i\c, ern:J-:Y ~ .:e:J.)
~ ~'
Executive Summarv
Recommendation to award Bid Number 07-4192 for the purchase and installation of one
200 KW Generator for the Goodland Repump Station in the amount of $62,999 to Power
Pro Tech Services and approve a budget amendment within the Goodland 'Vater District
Fund 441.
OBJECTIVE: To obtain Board approval to award Bid Number 07-4192 for the purchase and
installation of one 200 KW generator for the Goodland Repump Station in the amount of
$62,999 to Power Pro Tech Services and approve a budget amendment within the Goodland
Water District.
CONSIDERA nONS: The Goodland Repump Station has utilized the original generator that
supplies emergency power to this site, which was installed in the 1970s. The generator is at the
end of its useful life. The cost ofrcpairs in the last three ycars has begun to escalate and finding
paris to complcte thc required repairs has bccome difficult.
Bid Number 07-4192 for the purchase and installation of onc rcplacement 200 KW gencrator
was downloaded by 4Ci companies. Sevcn vendors submitted bids for the project as detailed
below:
Compan~' Total
Power Pro Tech Services I $62.999
Judson Construction Group 571.9S8
Hoops Electric $72.925
TMA (Technical Management Associates) S73.000
CE Power Solutions, LLC $79,352
Douglas N Higgins, Incorporated S88.000
New Tech Construction $97,450
All bids submitted were reviewed by Staff aIld the lowest rcsponsive bidder is Power Pro Tech
Services.
FISCAL IMPACT: The total amount of funds required for this obligation is $62,999. Funds in
this amount are available in the Goodland Water District Fund 44 I. The source of funds is Watcr
User Fees.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: This project meets current Growth Management Plan
standards to ensure the viability of public facilities.
RECOMMENDA TIONS: That the Board of County Commissioners, as Ex-officio the
Governing Board of the Goodland Water-Sewer District, award Bid Number 07-4192 for the
purchase and installation of one 200 KW generator for the GoodlaIld Repump Station in the
amount of 562,999 to Power Pro Tech Services and approve a budget amendment within the
Goodland Watcr District Fund.
Prepared By: Pamela Libby, Water Operations Manager
COLLI[R COn,TY
':; ;.'~! ",- .'1"1;-
Item Number:
Item Summary:
I ~.
')0:,>( _, U:~. ;.leil,C',
~'r" -, ,..
"-,..
Meeting Dale:
)'n"pared By
"':;'T'''''' L1~' ~
','.,',r" Cm"r"''''n~ r.:,''','H''>
,'."\<
'.'C:;) "(i,,,'
''-,.''f.'
. i:':::'~, '2
';1', '.,.,
AI'JHOvell By
r ' 3 ," 8 ' , ~- ~)
\\;~,,,. Dr'
'J,1IL
:.,.c",,,,,,,,,
,oubl"-Ul),t,,,,
\';~'H
',[)'n,':-il~'" 1- Ob A~.~
Appn"'I'd n~
'_"c"~r.
~.x~;.,,, I'.': ;'.:lfn
'"".,
;"j",,"'t,',li'.J'
." r~.",lc.;t-.r,
,_ ;",r. ~'Mi
'\pl'rOVN! B~'
\p[lruH'dU,
'\l'pronli II~
\ppn"ed III
-\ PI' rond II ~
'..i;t,,"
,'Li',,'-"
',_,,"',1;;0;
Allpro\'Cd B~
,\ppn"'l'lI B~
f-;;.:ncL.:;',,< h,-,;I;;
r."~:1i' 'l.',n~": i.~""iG(; '.,;.':<
~.""
\pprovc(] B~
S,." ,,,,,,
;,..~r,: ,,,.,,,.,Cl1', ,
e';'l[
,,~. 'r"~;~'
'.,-.un! "Ja
">(T
:,'::'C'.. !c. 1..,""niH)~r"t-,' :, [j,,,,,,u:
c 1 .',.: ~'OO- f: 2, /, f."
.>\pl'nncd B~
,>""C",,''-'J-j'''\
:"r
~'r;,
':1, !Jr'
.....,....d\~ "'" """ ,~" ,,,,...,,, ,,1>'''''..1 L " "V'rH"..,-'''.Tn '>" A '-,'-',,,
l'af!.C I O!'!
'o-f
c''')"
'.12
.,.......,~ r.";,
~~~
Q)
...J ::J')
:= Q:.6:
K.g
~m
~ >
~ 0
wZ
DO
<1:
0 0 0 0 0 0 0
III 0 0 0 C? 0 0 0
'0 '" 0 00 0 oti 0 '"
'" "' 00 0 '" 0 "'
1; "'. ..... '" 0 "'. o. '"
::l '" t- ~ oj '" '" '"
VI to '" t- OO t- t- t-
... ... ... ... ... ... ...
- '"
~
0 ::l
- U)
'" III
~ '"
::;;: '" '" '" '" '" '" '"
OJ OJ OJ OJ OJ OJ OJ
0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0
'" oi 0 00 0 oti 0 '"
l.>
." '" "' 00 0 '" 0 "'
"'. ..... '" 0 "'. o. '"
~ c.. oj
0 '" t- ~ '" '" '"
ro ;!: to '" t- OO t- t- t-
~ " ... ... ... ... ... ... ...
~ ~
'"
"
'So: :S ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
I::::
'"
'" III
'" ::l
0
III
~
'0
"
III
J::
.!!!
::
::l
"-
'"
'"
~
.... '" '"
,
t- " OJ
'" III ro
'0 c. Ti
iii E a
0 '"
'"
U <1:
~ C
0
'0 n. OJ
" '" => E U
'" a 2'
> OJ ~ U ...J
U (9 E ...J
.::: " '"
a " c <Ii
OJ U .S! ",. '" c
CfJ t) .<:; :2; .S!
J:: => OJ
~ => co '5
u U; ~ .S" u
OJ c U; I .c u (5
f- a " t) .c CfJ
a u a Z OJJ:: ~
~ U _ u OJ
a.. J:: '" W OJ ;:
U c !!1 !::
~ 2 a on a
OJ '" OJ n. <1: a..
;: ;: '0 => a
a OJ => a a :2; w
a.. c ..., 0 I f- U
item r\JQ, ': 6C2
I\iovernber 27 2007
?ags 1 of 4
~
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to adopt a Resolution to approve the Satisfaction of Lien for a Solid
Waste rcsidential acconnt wherein the County has rcceived payment and said lien is
satisfied in full for the 1993 Solid Waste Collection and Disposal Services Special
Assessmcnt. Fiscal impact is $20.00 to record the Satisfaction of Lien.
OBJECnVE: Adopt a Resolution approving the Satisfaction of Lien for a residential account
where tlle County has received payment in full for the 1993 Solid Waste Collection Services
Special Assessment.
CONSIDER;\, TIONS: Resolution No. 94-694 adopted by the Board on September 20, 1994
provided for the recording of thc list of 1993 delinquent solid waste collection and disposal
services special assessment and a mailing of' a written notice of the imposition of each residential
unit lien. Resolution No. 94-694 was recorded on Scptember 22, 1994 in Omcial Record Book
1987, Pages 1514 tllrough 1749 of the Official Records of Collier County, Florida, which placed
a lien on certain residential properties f'6r the 1993 Solid Waste Collection Services Special
Assessment.
Collier County Ordinance No. 90-30, as arnendcd. provides that a Satisfaction of Lien shall be
approved by Reso lution.
The attached Resolution lists the one account that has been paid in full for the 1993 Solid Waste
Collection Services Special Assessmcnt Lien.
FISCAL IMPACT: The fiscal impact for recording the Satisfaction of Lien arld the Resolution
is approximately $20.00, which is to be charged to County Water/Sewer Operating Fund (408).
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: Therc is no Growth Management impact associated
with this item.
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Conmlissioners adopt tlle attached
Resolution approving tlle one Satisfaction of Lien for the account listed in the Resolution aIld
authorizing the Chairman to sign the onc Satisfaction of Lien for tlle 1993 Solid Waste
Collection Services Special Assessment Lien.
PREPARED BY: Parll Callis. Revenue Supervisor, Utility Billing and Customer Service.
-
Pag.e ) or I
COLLIER COCNTY
.'~2:; ~..:)V,'T\' C::"':<b1:,,1S':it:~:'
IlemNumber:
Item Summary:
,',,:,;\;U, E;
:'"
1'3'
'.'<:uent,;
.,"h"",,,
lits 'i.;V':'l"',~; ~'''\ 'TIi,n:
"..;:Ui",,' !,;.jJl"ed
1["hE
'i,';1Fh . ',I'e'V:;:" ,me: [!'~ r'~'''d
"1'.['
I rw;') c:".,( ;. 'T.'W~;\:'::)I',Clt ,..'<''''
Meeting Date:
~'c' ~,r ;,1....1
Prepared By
'>'."r ~,"i!1
F:t'venu,..o,uper'/I,;<>r
'~'l"
~'" :,i, ,. il ~oI it,,.,,
lH' :;~~
n, 2~::" ;., ~ ~ .1~ _:::- "'~,
Appro\'ed H}'
I."N'..'.I;",.
,~, 'fen", :;'u[)'''r.''';nr
,-'~~ '
PutJil~ U\il"",~
:or.,,,,
iO,':'U2DCl7 J::r"P11
Approved B~'
,c'.":,:R,',,,'n
h'.\'~'''IA Midi""''''
,-,,\('
pu~I]~ U',r1it,,;.~
'::i2l1.:7::S';i
<\llproH'dlh
'.",,-.,.
,..rrc-;-'
_"'X,
>..,.,::'", ;ul,""
\ppro\'l'U 1:1,'
.\pprO\l'd 11\
\1'1'1'll\'l'd B)
.\pprmnIB)
F;;/,,,
'Ci'-';'J'."',"it'i.'.>u'
:>'U'
'":J[1<.H
Ap[lrUVl'd By
(.,:',;"1 ;-;'Il\'H,\'
""""':''''.'1:
D~\'c
~>'\F\ty f/,m..:pc .~-'t"c~
Ut 'C( c! r,~J' J(Jemt'''' ,~'-',;"c'
1.., -1';:1.:; ~:,;" h"
i\pprowdHy
J"",'" r,'"HIe'
r",,,,,",.:,,,,,,;!{,
,;,,~,.;; C:o,"","
c.c".:rn".
""I f,', lJ:c' "U;h~c
,':,;:C'C"
-1.;1,,1,'
.. .- .l~' I. ,,~.', ".._ "...\ n" "r.. "._, l.,,~(), ''In'~ -, (J.' '"'In"J"",'" 1 L (J '"'II"',,,. ,(" ""TO.' '"'In ~ I~ ,.:,,'
Ill'"'lni"Jf\I\,
',.
=
RESOLUTION NO. 2007-
A RESOLITIO" APPROVING A SATlSFACTlO" OF LIEN
FOR A CERTAIN ACCOUNT THA T HAS PAID I" FULL
THE 1993 SOLID WASTE COLLECTlO'\ A'\D DISPOSAL
SERVICES SI'ECIAL ASSESS\IEJ\TS
\VHEREAS, pursuant to Collier County Ordinance No, l)O-3(J, as amended, the Board of
Counry' Commissioners on Septemher 20, ] 994 adopted Resolution :\0. 94-694 authorizing the
recording of notices of liens for the deiinquent solid '"vaste collection and disposal services special
assessments for] 993: and
\VHEREAS, Collier Count) Ordinance No. 90-30. as amended, requires the Board to approve
hy' Resolution and record in the Official Records a Satisfaction of Lien on all accounts that have
heen paid ill full.
'10\\. THEREFORE. BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COl')\TY
COM\1ISSI0"\FRS OF COlLlFR COL1\TY, FLORIDA. that pursuant tn Collier COllnt~
Orlllllanu,' 1\0. <-)0-:;(1. a<.., amenued. the Huard l"I."'c()~'llize" full )laymen: and receipt of the ll){)~
Sen'ict' Year Sniid V>aSle Colicctinn ami Disposal Special Assessment ior the foll()\\'Ill~ :lccount
numhered he](1\\. SUD<..,t:'yucn: In the duoplim, of Resolution 1\0. LJ-l--{jl)-t whereupon iJ iien had he en
recorlied 011 reai property pertaining to the account identified he-rein. Tile S31i:;~'acti()n or L.ien
anaehcd hel't"w referencing the account idemilied herem is herehy ,IPllr(l\'cd 3nd the Chairman IS
hereby authorized to sign on heh3lf of the 80<lrd (\1' Count;.-' Commissioners, and the Clerk IS
directed to record this Resolution and this Sntisraction of Lien indi\"idually in the official records of
Collier ('ounty
Account 1\0.
17705
This Resolution adopted this
ma.iority vote.
da~ of
, 2()()7, aftcr motion. second ami
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK. CLERK
BOARD OF COU",TY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COU)\TY, FLORIDA
BY'
JAMES COLLTTA. CHAIR~lAN
Approved as to roml and
legal sufficiency:
David C. v..:cigcl
County Attollley
This instrument prepared by:
Robert Zachary
Assistant County Attorney
Office of the County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail
Naples, Flonda 34112
(239) 774-8400
Property Folio No. 52650680006
SATISFACTION OF LIEN
KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENT: That the BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA was the owner and holder of
a certain Lien against:
GARZA, ENCARNACIONo& NANCY 0
PO BOX 106
IMMOKALEE, FL 339340000
The Lien was recorded on the 22nd day of September 1994. in Official Record
Book 1987, Pages 1514 through 1749, in the Office of the Clerk of the Circuit
Court of Collier County, State of Florida. The Lien secures the principal sum of
One Hundred Three Dollars and Two Cents (,103.02) plus accrued Interest
and penalties, if any, and imposes certain obligations against real property
situated in Collier County, Florida, described as follows:
JOYCE PARK BLK BLOTS 8 + 9 OR 1012 PG 124
Folio No,
Project No.
Account No.
52650680006
63000
17705
Collier County, a political subdivision of the State of Fiorida, hereby
acknowledges receipt of payment in full satisfaction of the Lien and hereby
cancels Lien.
The Clerk of the Circuit Court is hereby directed to record this Satisfaction of
Lien in the official Records of Collier County, Florida, to acknowledge that the
Lien ceases to exist.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County,
Florida, acting through its Chairman, directs execution and recording of this
Satisfaction of Lien. by action of the Board this _ day of ,2007.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
JAMES COLETTA, CHAIRMAN
Approved as to form
and legal sufficiency
David C. Weigel
County Attorney
!T:;;mi f",,;
,1--.,,-
'~(::V'3'-' '~','
~, r,,"
Pcqs ~. 0'
iI-2m r~c. : :iC3
: ,~c.)\/"2inbsr 27. 20Cl7
r-ag21 C)f 5
~
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to Award Bid Number 07-4181 for landscaping of Public Utilities
Division facilities in the estimated amount of $400,000 to Florida Land Maintenance,
Amera-Tech Incorporated, and Ground Zcro Landscaping.
OBJECnVE: The object is to obtain approval from the Board of County Commissioners, Ex-
Officio the governing Board of the Collier County Water-Sewer District to award Bid Number
07-4181 to Florida Land Maintenancc, Amera-Tech Incorporated, and Ground Zero
Landscaping.
CONSIDERAnONS: The Public Utilities Division manages facilities located through out
Collier County. The Water, Wastewater and Solid Waste Departments are responsible to enSlU'e
that the grounds of these facilities are maintained. In addition, the award of this service to the
selected vendors will allow for them to perform unscheduled site repairs after disruption of
service through the main or service breaks.
~
The bid was posted on August 27, 2007, by the Purchasing Depmiment with 46 vendors
requesting packages. The Purchasing Depaliment received three bids. After review of the bids
by Staff all three were found to bc in compliance. The Public Utilities Division recommends
award to all three vendors as the area to be covered is large and thus compels the use of multiple
vendors. in order to have the work completed in an orderly and timely manner. The lowest
bidder, Amera-Tech Incor])orated, will be utilized by the Water Depaliment with the largest
work assigrullents that includes Areas 1 and 2. The otber two Depmiments (Wastewater and
Solid Waste) will be utilizing the second lowest bidder, Florida Land Maintenance, for work in
Area 3. The third vendor, Ground Zero Landscaping, will be utilized for one time site repair
requests and special assignments. A summary analysis of the bid tabulation is attacbed.
FISCAL IMPACT: Funds in the arllount of $400,000 are available within the three Department
budgets that will utilize this contract. Source of funds is the County Water/Sewer Fund (408)
and Solid Waste Disposal Fund (470). The exact amount of the contract will be dependent on
the number of additional work assignments requested, such as site repairs required by the Water
Department.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There rs no impact on the County's Growth
Management Plan.
RECOMMENDAnON: The Board of County Commissioners award Bid #07-4181 for the
maintenance of landscaping at Public Utilities Division facilities to Florida Land Maintenance,
Amera Tech Incorporated, and Ground Zero Landscaping in the estimated amount of $400,000.
Prepared By: Pamela Libby, Water Operations Manager
-
COLLIER COUNTY
s:j;'.nL or ::lU:,T, c::)r',iI'~I:',:,,~ ,._
Item Number:
Item Summary:
f,:,'
'at,) ", -"-Vidr;' (';lL) :,'.J'~l f,' : - .,11:~' ~()t
Q'I"bl;
'no' r><" "'<'HE-' -1("'-': ()t ,'.4JCI 'lee: 1< -1(";';.' ~()ncl i'Jibl'lTo- ::., .~'n',"c'-
~.~, I:~U ,H'U ,';>1:";' - ""
Meeting Date;
;',M
Prepared By
",J"wl~ Lihi:o)
Watt" OU\.,L1l;011!. Ili~,,~,l'"
uate
hJ~)ilC lItilllle~
V'J,ner
1US!2iJP 1(;,c;:C,%AM
Appmvcd By
,I"';i" "CO".,,,
P,,,.eh;',,n,, Aptln'
L;Jt:(
hCin"ntstrJ""" "nr"c(><
c'"rcll,,~i,,\)
11;',,"'2Qn~ t' ii7 t.,r,r
Appro\'ed By
r. arr; '" I;~ '-, lll,:,
\l\iat"",U!kr':;1;cnS~"<It"),,,,,
[)':11~.
l'lIlll". uti I",,,,,
"','ner
11,',;'~(!G, ; ~C' f'r...
Allpn,vl'd By
F'~,l '-.'.J1U,u ,,-I
v,~<. "",I'".G""
,:<':'1(
"'u:'i" U:il,,,"
'\['llrn\'l'd B)
Apnrontllh
\pprund 8,
-\pl'ro\'('dH)
'",-
: :~. ,0;
Ar1pro\'ctlll)
n)()nlil~. \/,'io,,'.'
C;p'.'"nwfI' [.ic',c;m
:.",,,
"lwi;;c'.,'IW'i
'.)!i,.Jj;i"",O""",iinr'
11 'S:2:'G~ 1'; r. i.I':
Apl'roV('d B~
,JJr1',V":,."",-0",
""L.I,:Utii;",.,'I'.ll""n,c.!r;J,',,'
,'''\(
l!tJi'Utili1.I',"
:...,:;,i"
U:.I,l1e, A""','."S1THi,'1'
~ I ,",I 2 U,i ~ ' .,
ApllroV('dll:"
.,'1' :ilJ' aU1i',",
~.'l' lims:r:otlt'" p.s"i ,:;;r"
Lie'!"
,., ub'i~ L'tiji",,~ Li 's"'n
r'"i ":. Uhlit!<",i\OrIHnistrnuor.
1.t',,:20n' " 41., t~'
Approved By
:Jr:'::':.D,-.,'),;a!('
i,p:,;[C~":'n' "'roa'"''
/-,., ej 11 H n i" "-r> t, . '" :;, l~ n,
",i",rnJi,,"
o (,~:n ')0; "8
~li'::'1J::Fr,; f'r.'
Aprrllved Il~
I/"c!\~,'; ,
r<-
",,,;:t,,,,,,,1";;>"'"''''
(;"""".1'. ~rH()CC"" 'Tin:f
,i,~c c'" ;"'k'.1""""".'~. [,t"':'
j'I;]'ji::":
~'7 Pr, ^
AfJl'r(l~'ed R)
1.',,,((
"'dC''''
"'t,
'.n"r"~,' >)W,"
"Jr"'-
'W;(
'1;T2[);;"
,:"
. m,',,'-'- __"r.._,,~',n~
.. ._,u L.,_I\ '...."...,., ,,/ ".,....""..,'. , / " ...."nn. WI'~ ,T'I\..,,, , ,-"r"~'
Page I of I
_'I;~ ~ M
=~:;-offi
~ ,,~ ~ 2.2:
=:"v", lG ~
- ^~ :J '"
;;: 2. 0 gO::
== =:.;:; c::: ~
cr G. 0 ,-
-:~z ~CD
if;z rnro
50 ~ -0
<[ UI-
t1l
0..
.",
~
'(3
t1l
U.
"
c:
'"
o
'00
s
is
'"
~
::>
.~
3
:J
0..
.2
Q)
~
Iii
~
ro
:2
"
c:
'"
'"
c:
'a.
'"
u
'"
"
c:
'"
"
~
co
~
"
I
.....
o
..
"
ii5
>-
:8.....
::J~
.....,.....b
J::N,
~ro~
~~cn
"'-.
23~
1:50..0
.~Q) ([.l
2roro
0..00
g> 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ""
0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 '"
'g. cO cO '" co co 0:; cO co '" '" cO cD u'i cO u'i cD 0:; 0 cO u'i cO c:O m '"
co 0 0 <0 0 0 N <0 N en en 0 0 N '" N '" to 0 co N ~ N '"
" '" 0 '" ..... ..... 0 '" 0 '" '" CC 0 0 '" ~ to ~ 0 ", co It)
'" ",' to' .,: to to N ~ N M '" ..... to ~ N " oi N '" 0 " '"
'E - ~ N - - '" ~ ~ N en co co
OJ M
...J
0
~
CI)
N
-g
:J
0
~
Cl '" '" '" II> '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" .. '" '" '" '" '" '" ... '" '"
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 010 0 0 0 0 0 ""
0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 I~ 0 0 '"
~ cO cO .,.; cO cO .,.; cO cO cO 0 0 '" N c:i c:i 60 CD '" c:i u'i~
0 N ..... CD 0 ,- to to to 0 '" ~ en en '" 0 tOlO ~ N '" '"
N N ..... '" 0 ..... " ". ". '" " en 0, co CD. .,. .,. N 0 ,- I~
'" " co' .,.' .--: 00 ~ <D .,. .,. co '" c;) '" 00 1- 00
I~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 00 'M
- M
1>- I
"" I
I~
'''' I
,- I I I i
1=
1< I
.. <h '" .. <h <h .. <h <h <h '" '" ~ltI'1f17 '" '" '" '" .. '" .. ..
,
0 0 0 obb 010 0 0 0 01010 => lob => 18 0 10 10 o:~
'" 0 0 0 0 => 0 0 0 0 0 0 000 0 0 0 0 0 I~ 0 010
g c:i c:i c:i cO 0 c:i c:i 0 0 0 c:i cicicici 0 0 0 c:i c:i 10 u'i .,.; '"
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 .,. '"
!!! 0, 0 0 0 0 o. 0, 0, 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0, 0, o. 0
a; .,. 6 <D <D to to to to <D to c;) o:i co co co .,.' 0 0 0 0 <Ii
- N '" N N N N N "
c: N
'n;
liE
."
c:
co
...J
...J
u.. .. .. <h .. '" lit '" lit lit lit .. lit .. lit lit <h lit lit .. lit ... II> lit
2
Cii
~
'"
>
0
u
'"
0::
C C <<S
t1l .lll Ig
0:: 0..
~ ~
'" '" 0
~ ~ c: (jj c: ~
c: g 0 ::>
,Q ~ " " ~ <( m 0
ro c: ro ro ~ a; a; .c:
ro .Q c: (jj 2 <;;' (jj c C '2 i:
c: c: ro ~ ,Q 19 <;;' '"
0 ro Cii " ~ ~ ~ Q) Q) t1l
0 a. a; ::> .2
'sr- I? (jj (jj E "" <( " ~ .l!! E '" E '" 0 E 0..
Q) Ig E 2 2 " a; '" .c: .c: c: '" .c:
Q) 0:: :::l c: I~ ~ ~ c: c: u c: u 0 Q) i: Qj V;
0:: :::l a. a. ro Cii Cii !E c: ~ ro 0 0
?: ?: a. E I f- ro a; 0 0 ,:: .!'l ., .!'l '., '2: ro .e- o
:::l Q, Q) "" ~ .c: B ;;: ro ;;: ro E U
"" :::l 5: iO .c: (jj
c: c: a. :::l 0:: Q) c: ~ (jj '" c:
Q, 0:: a. c: 0 ~ c: Q) ~ ,
:::l :::l " ro ro t1l ~ I cO (f) 0
0 0 '" Q, " ~ f- f- c: m ro ro ...J Q) .. .,. "" ~ ." '" 00 '"
U 0:: c: c: E '" ro iii ro .e- ro
u Q) 0:: .lll '" 0 0.. c: I I '" :::; c: ...J 2:
- ro ro !'! Il N !!! '" "" iE g .Q .c Qj .~
.c .c ,~ .~ " c: Q) t1l .c .c: I~ 0 .c iii 0 '"
co t :; c: 0 " ~ co EJl! .~ t :; co E " ot t>"S c:
CI) ro :::l CI) e c: - .0 a. ro
0 0 t1l ro 0 0 t1l ro :J a; 0 0 '" '" 0 Q) 0 0 Q) :J
<: 0 <: E ro ro
z (f) U :2 u (,9 u a u.. f-:2 0.. z (f) <C z ...J (f) Z (f) (f) f- 19 ...J rn :2
,..-;.,-,,.-
'.);:~;~ M
.....,..-,.-- , , -c
:"'CQl
~. Q) >
',.qp,Cii O<<i
L ,,-VI: (l) U
:: CJrf-:::l aJ
a::~'Q) 0'"0::
= ::.~ ~ (/)
CD (1;0 "C
~;;:-Z :fiiii
~:Z: O'lm
:J") ]! (5
<1: U""
'"
(l,
.",
OJ
~
'0
'"
u..
'0
t::
'"
t::
o
'Vi
'j;
is
'"
~
:5
,,"
:0
:oJ
(l,
~
.9
OJ
U
t::
'"
t::
OJ
'E'
'Iii
:2;
'0
t::
'"
'"
t::
'0.
'"
u
'"
'0
t::
'"
,...
~
<Xl
..,.
,
r--
D
'It
'0
ii'i
>-
1lr--
:.:i'?
r--r--
END
ro 1M
(l,<Xl~
i..;-gd>
0>...... ..
2 ~ ~
1:> a.. 0
.~"* "*
(l,QQ
'"
OJ
>-
'"
OJ
>-
'"
OJ
>-
OJ
'"
a3 (lJ 01
U '" t::
:.:i as "5-
'" U '"
~o :,:j ~
u -~ -g
~ 0 ~
cu.!:
o ~ f/)
Oct)
Q) o,~
0. (,) 0
'" OJ ~
~ 0.. a. (/)
-g~"Eifi
ro U':l ~ c:::
....J "'0 :; 'Ci)
....... C U ::::I
c:~_.o
e"O 0 (l)
:; Q) c: U
u~.Q~
-E......c
o = ~ Q)
~5~ ,S
o '- Q) ro
(,) 0> E
'" '"
OJ OJ
>->-
'" '"
OJ OJ
>->-
'" '"
OJ OJ
>->-
'" ,.,
Cti .~
......Q} "6
t::'" (l,
w-roo
i.~: ~ ~
,~OJ _""
'Q)~lJ..o
-oE~Cll
~ :::I ~ U
(lJ E..c:: ~
~ .c :; c
o oE ~ *
:0 - c: 'n;
c 0 -- 00:::;:
cuc:-5o:::::
"C ,Q '~ '0
(J) ro ID c::
c: C u 0
;:Q)c:o:::
~ E .~ ~
O:::l(B--=
1i)ga.'ffi
:.:iO~>
'"
OJ
>-
'"
OJ
>-
'"
OJ
>-
'"
OJ
>-
'"
OJ
>-
'"
OJ
>-
,
;..
].
r----'
~ r't
~ \.--
'~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~~
~ "':;~~
E Ui~
OJ ., (/)
.= c Q)
i} ~g
~ <(>
Public UtIlities L.andKaplng Bid Analya18
FL Land
Area 1 Maintenance Amera-Tech Ground Zero
North County 24,000 13,200 15,500
South County 30.000 14,220 16,000
Carica 6,000 8,775 4,563
Manatee 6,000 4,560 6,708
Capri 6,000 7,000 6,708
Goodland 6,000 8,775 2,028
Countryside 6,000 1,460 1,560
Glades 6,000 1,460 2,028
Foxfire 6.000 1,460 3,393
IQASR 6,000 16,500 3,393
Subtotal Area 1 $102,000 $77,410 $61,881
Area 2
Tamiami 8,000 14.430 27,000
Mule Pen 8.000 ~ .911 6.006
Pelican Bay 8.000 4095 11025
Noeth Hawthorn 8.000 8.892 12,350
South HalNth::>rn 8,000 ~3S50 34"125
Subtotal Area 2 $40,000 $42,578 $90,506
Subtotal (Areas 1 &. 2) $142,000 $120,38& $152,387
Area 3
Naples Landfill 24,000 8,400 19,656
Immokalee Transfer 20,000 5,460 12,168
Landfill #1 20,000 8200 23000
Subtotal Landfill $64,000 $22,060 $54,824
North Lift Stations 20,000 107,016 90,480
South Lift Stations 20,000 88,725 84,825
Subtotal Lift Stations $40,000 $195,741 $175,305
Subtotal (Area 3) $1 04,0tlI $217 ,801 $230,129
Total Bid $246,000 $338,189 $382,516
;19rT: i\'O, 16CA
f'D\!Srnb8~ 27, 2007
Page 1 of SO
.-
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to approve five Work Orders for the development of the 2007 Master
Plans for a not to exceed total of $781,940. Under Contract #05-3785, Fixed Term Contract
for Professional Utilities Engineering Serviccs, with Greeley & Hansen LLC four Work
Orders for the 2007 Water, Wastewater, Irrigation Quality Water and Water Supply
Master Plans for a total of $678,940. Undcr Contract #07-4071, Fixed Term Contract for
Financial Consulting Services, with Public Rcsourees Management Group, Inc. one Work
Order for the 2007 Water, Wastcwatcr and Irrigation Quality Water Rate and Impact Fee
Studies for $103,000. Projects Numbers 70070, 75007, 73066, 72516, 75005 and 75018 cover
these Work Orders.
OBJECTIVE: The public purpose is to posture the Collier County Water-Sewer District to
meet Water, Wastewater, Irrigation Quality (IQ) Water and Water Supply utilities demaJ1ds over
the next 20 years, to stay in regulatory compliance arld to provide Water, Wastewater and IQ
Water User Rates and Impact Fees.
-
CONSIDER'" TIONS: The 2007 Master Plans provide a sound-planning basis for an extensive
capital improvement program. The Master Plans must rci1ect up-to-date planning of Water and
Wastewater capital projects for the five and twenty ycar planning horizons. The significant
decrease in the estimates of County population growth from the 2006 to the 2007 Annual Update
and Inventory RepOli (AUIR) makes these Master Plans neccssary in order to revise the Capital
Improvement Projects Lists to match the nc'cds of the county without over building. This year's
Master Planning project will also include separate lQ Water and Water Supply Master Plans and
capital projects lists. This is the first year that these Master Plans will be included separate from
Water and Wastewater and is done to provide added focus and priority to these essential
planning areas.
The Master Plans are also needed for reviewing impact fees and user rates. The Collier County
Water and Sewer District will be addressing extcmal financing needs in 2008. Public Utilities
may partially address these needs via the issuance of revcnue bonds. The County Financial
Adviser and Bond Counsel have advised staff that Bond Rating Agencies will look most
favorably on recently calculated user rates and impact fees when tl1ey address the financial
strength of the utility.
On October 16,2007, Greeley & Hansen (GH) submitted four proposals totaling $678.940 for
Water, Wastewater, Irrigation Quality (IQ) Water and Water Supply Master Plan Work, a cost
that is comparable to the cost for tl1e 2005 Water and Wastcwater Master Plans despite increases
in labor and administrative costs. Greeley and Hansen's work will also include a complete
hydraulic modeling analysis with thc most recent relcase of the WaterGEMS hydraulic modeling
software.
-
On October 22, 2007, Public Resources Managemcnt Group, Inc. (PRMG), the County's User
Rate and Impact Fee consultant, suhmitted a proposal witl1 a total cost of $103,000 to perfoffil
the 2007 Water, Wastewater and, for the first time, a separate lQ Water User Rate Study and
Impact Fee Analysis.
'I:::::: I ,,~:. ',.
:'J:::j;l;-::::~'ib3' 2~)'J-
"", :.'\.1
Staff has revicwed and approved the above costs, and determined them to be fair and reasonable
bascd on staffs review of similar previous assignments in recent years.
Staff expects to present the Master P]aJ1S and the rates, impact and other special fees studies to
the BCC for adoption on May 27,2008.
FISCAL IMPACT: The Water Master Plan will be funded 50% from Fund 4] 1 (Water Impact
Fee) and 50% fi-om Fund 412 (Water User Fee). The Wastewater Master Plan will be funded
50/50 from Funds 413 (Wastewater Impact Fee) and 4]4 (Wastewater User Fee). The IQ Water
Master Plan will likewise be funded 50/50 from Fund 4]3 and Fund 414. The Water Supply
Master Plan will be funded ii'om Fund 412. PRMG's Water Rate and Impact Fees Study will be
funded 50/50 from Funds 4] 1 and 413. Wastewater and IQ Water Rate and lmpact Fees Study
will be funded 50/50 from Funds 412 and 414.
GROWTH 1\1ANAGEME'\'T IMPACT: These projects arc consistent with the 2005 Water
and Wastewater Master Plan Updates adopted by the BCC on June 6, 2006 as Agenda Hems
IO(B) in that line items jelr Master Plan projects are included. Projects Jelr the Impact Fees and
Rate Studies are not included in the Master Plan but were created and approved later. Thcse
projects arc all included in the Fiscal Year 2008 Capital Budget approved by the BCC on
September 24. 2007.
RECOI\IME1\'DA nO1\': That the Board of Collier County Commissioners. as the Ex-Officio
Governing Board of' the Collier County Water-Sewer District:
A) Authorize thc County Manager, or his designee, to execute fl1Ur work orders with Greeley
and Hanscn LLC fell' Utilities Engineering Scrviccs related to prcparing the Water,
Wastewater, IQ Water and Water Supply Master Plans for a total amount not to exceed
$678,940
B) Authorize the County Manager, or his designee, to execute one work order with PRMG
to per!C1I111 Water, Wastewatcr and lQ Water Rate and Impact Fee Studies for a total
amount not to cxceed $103.000.
PREPARED BY:
PorErio E. Gramatges, P.E.
Plincipal Project Manager, Public Utilities Engineering Department
Page] of" I
COLLIER COt:I"TY
b~,r\RC :)r -",,:~, c'.nn;;;,Si'_ll iCP.5
Item Number:
Item Summary:
-" ^..;.'.'n~-" l:nJIIGI '" ,',;li:.I:h'F. :.1.,' ".,;nck '".(]
"it; r.lt',' Inf.'.~'''''T' 'I",
r'''I~",T(.'' ':'10'1"
" rrc' 'C ''; ",L(; 1:.;'<'1 :;,' ~181
~,DI':I(<- jiO, - W, i "SO - NT ~ Oll e:: iC'
'1III,li" l'-(J'II,~'T'""
'~'.c-t'"" 8- H,nl';>.'
'0
()Ici8!CtO'
"',JlF' ".,iJi,',.,;;tc-,
;;."::'1"/.'0;11"
tdle
Ie>
lulJ: 0 ""I~ ['4'
F;AUJ
" F '1'<"1'';..131 ~;CI.,~,,,i 'I;'
_~"'./I~e~ ',\:itn
)(",'!:'.w r,1a ::;q"lllpr .. 'CJ, 1'1;: ~'I'~' .'/ :'1" ~ ':Jer Tel t'l(
-',",' .',' aSTe\".';lte ;In',:' 'Ir;;,,",1:0:1 :jJ, Illy' '.,.',atpf I.~i):~ ine I~r(;~ '.'8' "tu(i'SS;p -, (Joe
'jVTl;Crt,-OC,-:-:
i)T
':(>1("
-'-,-,,-,c
Meeting Date:
.~<':11 ""/
Prepared By
Phi: E. urJn,,-.rcl"'. 0 [
s: "n,!,~;:-i ~.!Dncl9~'
UD\"
~-,,, :,1 Ie Uti r,tiC'"
'"'-1:11'( UT:li..",. E"'!:n"CrEnll
jn.'! ':2GC'? b.i)~:,;4?rv
Appro\'ctlBy
Tr:MJ13,.Wi:Jm_
(;pcr,1!'OhS r);l'(,C\~~
r)"K
",,:,I"I'l:iil[".'
'co,,:,;,' :It:lit,,,"OlwrJl''-W'
j j I ';,'2Dlr 'C ']"~ i\1.,1
Appro\'cd 8\'
l.'t'" , ;;t",~
~)ir,.:..",['
lroc
""""'"
-,: ~.;
Approvcd II.
Apl'ro\'~d H.,
APl'l'OH'd 11\
'\pproHdB)
,xi::: U, ",,~
"U~ U.' :..
'tiC ~ ,.., ~,,,.,,,
:'(:::::I"--n,!"
Appro,'cd B)
,,,,~.,!,,, \" r!<.L..0":\
:;'.,,'1;, :Jt.ltf().':"cmlC1,,!r','
:.;[,j'
('ullli~ Cd"U"S
r", : ',.II, ~ \I (" u;n,,, It "r ce"
~::(jG~ :~~ I--.~'
Appro\'l'd B)'
~Jr.,"") ::'0 w;l in0:0"
',:'n ;C"ti()'l~ ' ''',OI''',t
~)~I(
L':min:'.'J,>>1:i .,. S""--.f'V"
'nft"III,'lIn,,-rl'cl':1o:og;
Of<'
Appnl\'ed II)
:dl~':! S'l'1\,v~"r"
V"ri<<JUnHlt C, 8"0061 rJ!t-':.~l"-
[JEt,
C:"unr\' ,"DrW9"''--'.' :)fllcc
()f',::;" 0.: ~."Jn"9""''-'" (;. b"floci
'1 '1 si>aa~ :;;;':A P(,"
Appr(l\'(,dll)'
;;:mL" \'. I\,~,-",(;
';,,, n: y [,1.., '111 ~J("
"1<:
"'flMe <,'(:m,;-'
(,()'Y'CCI,S'"r,('r"
\.'''tW~W '};f".:('
r.,,, "".', ^ ~ .,.. .-l..'r" .', T'.._ ~_\,,~ "r '" ..,__... ~_" '.,,,.,., ().- "0"'""\1\"" 'L " "o"r"..;~ ,t. "~ TT!).-.,,, , ,-, T.' ~ r
!.','C.',"._'
__l--,__
,i....;;;': _,
. ')(~
'::::::), ~i'~)
WORK ORDER # GH-FT-3785-08-01
Agreement for Fixcd Tcrm Profcssional Engincering Scrvices
Contract #05-3785 Dated September 27, 2005
This Work Order is for professional engineering services for work known as
Project # 70070/75007 - 2007 Water Master Plan UDdate
The work is specified in the proposal dated October 16, 2007, which is attached hereto and
made a part of this Work Order, In accordance with the Terms and Conditions of the Agreement
referenced above, Work Order # GH~FT-3785-08.0] is assigned to Greelev and Hansen LLC,
ScoDe of Work:
Task 1
Task 2
Task 3
Initial Update Planning Services
Update Waler Master Plan
Additional Services Allowance
Task shall be conducle'd as indicated in the attached Greeley and Hansen LLC proposals_
Schedule of \^/ork: Complete Voiork within 34 \,l,'eeks after receipt of Notice to Proceed,
Compensation: In accordance with Article Five of the Agreement, the County \\'111 compensatE:
the FirIT', in accordance \',-'ith the established hourly rate(s) as enumerated in Exhibit B of the
Proposal .
Task I
Task 2
Task 3
Initial Update Pianning Services
Update \\/ater Master Plan
Additional Services Allowance
TOTALS
> 14,560 LS
>19],710 LS
> ]7.420 T&M
>223.690
Any change within monetary authority of this Work Order made subsequent to final
department approval will be considered an additional service and charged according to
Schedule A of the Agreement.
PREPARED B .
10(2$/07
s, P.E. - Principal Project Manager Date
gineering
AUTHORIZED BY:
/2 /> L~L"-
Roy ~. Anderson, P.E. . Director
Public Utilities Engineering
IC/'Lrf, '1
I
Date
AUTHORIZED BY:
(j1)rd---~~
Paul Mattausch - Director
\~/ater Department
11::>/ZS/,zpP7
D'lte
Page 1 of2
,;~' "~';r'I~:-,-;::.:r :=:
C'--U\,
; .~J. ~'
MHlIORIZED BY:
__-?~dJj)~
Thoma!t,--~ides - Director
FiscalOpcr<ltinns
/0 iO{"
.. ..._".._,-~[)~~t?+.._~._."'_._m.._-
AUlIIORIZED BY:
blTles \V. Dcl..uny. P.E. - Adrninislr.:ilOr
Purdie lJrilitie-s Dr:panmenl
Dnle
.~ nEST:
By.
.i~ll:..~~:i~ ~ i.~:..i},__ J!: .~_,__
Ill"
";-'
.._,..,...._~~:~...,.:+~~=~~~~~~L___
Ro~('r S flo\>vclL P.F., As::;cclale
/)< /:-1',..... /d ;'"'/. (
D,llt.:: Jt'::;:4..e,7
Type \i:1llH' and Titk
(irc!.'!c)' and H~tl1.'\l~n L LC
Pag!.: 2 uf 2
Agen:.is I~em No. 16C4
!"-'\,'"'-:; '::-i-;?-",=7 2=;:-,~
'. ~!, :./r
EXHIBIT A
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
PUBLIC UTILITIES ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT
Work Order # GH-FT-08-0l
2007 Water Master Plan Update
Scope of Services
Greeley and HaJ1sen LLC
October 16, 2007
Greeley and Hansen LLC, herein referred to as ENGINEER, shall perform engineering services
for Collier County, herein referred to us COUNTY, associated with the development aJ1d
preparation of the 2007 Water Master Plan Update, herein referrcd to as the PROJECT, for
COUNTY. This work order shall be completed in accordance with the terms of Contract 05-
3785. herein referred to as CONTRA.CT
The deliverables for the PROJECT shall include 5-year and 20-year water Capital Improvement
Program (ClP) and updated versions of the Collier County 2005 Water Master Plan Update,
dated June 6 2006. The goals of the PROJECT are to update strategies developed in the 2005
Water Master Plan Update, including updates to population, water demand forecasts, 5 aJ1d 20-
year CIP schedules, and maps to show updated projects. Updated hydraulic modeling results for
water system shall be included with the PROJECT. Previous master plans have utilized KYPIPE
2000 software for hydraulic modeling. The 2007 Water Master Plan Update will utilize
WaterGEMS software for hydraulic modeling. Recommendations provided in the 2007 Water
Master Plan Update shall be based on thc goal of providing sufficient system capacity to meet
estimated needs, and to provide water utility services reliably.
The 2007 Water Master Plan Update will serve as the basis for the development of updated rate
structures and impact fees. The 2007 Water Master Plan Update shall be coordinated with the
COUNTY'S Wellfield Program Manager, CDM, and the ongoing development of the 2007
Irrigation Quality (IQ) Master Plan, the 2007 Water Supply Master Plan and the 2007
Wastewater Master Plan Update.
Monthly partial payments for the lump sum services for Tasks I and 2 will be invoiced based on
the percentage of services completed. Payment for Task 3 services will be invoiced based on
percentages of services completed for negotiated lump sum services or time and materials in
accordaJ1ce with Contract 05-3785 hourly rates and invoices received from subconsultants.
rage I of6
TASK 1- INInAL PLANNING UPDATE SERVICES
Task i.1 - Attend Kick-Off Meeting
Attend kick-off meeting. Prepare and distribute meeting notes.
Task 1.2 - Collect and Review Existing Data
Collect and review existing data, including updated project schedule and cost information, water
demands, and operational data and other information relevaJ1t to the PROJECT.
To facilitate the identification of existing water demands by geographic location, the following
information will be provided by the COUNTY:
. GIS shape file/data base of address points corresponding to property parcels
. Water billing data by addresses or other identifiers that will allow the billing data to be
spatially assigned to the address points in the GIS shape file
. GIS shape file/data base of the property parcels
. Current (2007) GIS-compatible aerial photography
. GIS shape file/data base of approved PUDs
. GIS data base/shape files of master water meters
. GIS data base/shape file ofresidential water meters (as may exist)
. GIS data base/shape file of the Water-Sewer District boundaries
. GIS data base/shape files of Rural TraJ1sition Area maps
To facilitate the identification of existing population and projected population by geographic
location, the following information will be provided by the COUNTY:
. GIS shape files showing the 2000 and subsequent census tract/block and Traffic Analysis
Zones (TAZs)
. Existing and projected population projections available from CDES (COUNTY plaJ1ning)
by T AZs
. GIS shape file/data base of zoning for calculation of the maximum allowable density by
TAZ
Task 1.3 - Update Population aJ1d Water Demand Tables
Update cOlliltywide population forecasts based on updated population projections provided by
COUNTY Plarming Services. Updated Plarming Services population projections were provided
on August 10,2007. Update water demands based on data obtained in Task 1.2, available billing
records and new population data. Update spreadsheets to document and summarize population,
water demand estimates for each year from 2007 through 2027.
1)3~e2 of6
l-\,aen::la Item No. 16C4
~ !,.;C)\'e:;ibs,' 'lJ :JJC-"
:: :J, ::-J:, ,
TASK 2 -l.iPDA TE WATER MASTER PLAN
Task 2.1 - Update Regional Treatment Plant Analvses
Update the required county-wide regional treatment plant capacrtles through 2027 based on
updated populations and demands developed in Task 1. Update forecast of when regional plants
need to be constructed aJ1d/or expanded.
Update information describing the existing and proposed water treatment, ground storage tanks,
transfer pumping, and high-service pumping facilities.
Task 2.2 ~ Update Transmission S\'stem Analvses
Task 2.2.1 - Perform Hvdraulic Modeling - The COUNTY's KYPIPE 2000 hydraulic mode]
data will be imported into WaterGEMS software. Update the county-wide layout plan for future
water transmission mains using Vv'aterGEMS software for network hydraulic modeling. Use
current fire code pressure requirements ror the water main analysis, Pcrronn simulation of
maximum day, maximum day plus fire now and peak hour demand conditions for 2012,2017
and 2027 conditions. Update analysis of future storage requirements in the transmission system.
Prepare a county-wide map showing year 2012 and 2027 water treatment plant, booster station,
storage and transmission main facilities.
Task 2.2.2 Prepare Corridor Studies - Prepare Corridor Studies to develop recommended routes
for potable water transmission main routes to the Northeast Service Area, including the
NERWTP. Similar comdor analyses for water supply, wastewater and lQ transmission mains are
included in the 2007 Water Supply Master Plan, 2007 Wastewater Master Plan Update and 2007
lQ Master Plan, respectively. These master plans are being prepared at the same time as the 2007
Water Master Plan Update. The scope of services is based on potable water transmission main
evaluation of not more than three corridors and three options per corridor. Corridor Study
services shall include up to three meetings total with Public Utilities Engineering and Real Estate
Services Departments, obtaining and reviewing existing and proposed utility and road project
plans, identifying property acquisition and pernlitting requirements, preparing preliminary cost
estimates and identifying recommended alignment corridors.
Task 2.3 - Update Capital Improvement Program (CIP) Schedules
Update 5-year and 20-year CIP schedules and budgets for Fllild 411 and Fund 412 capital
improvements identified in Tasks 2.1 and 2.2. CIP schedules and budgets shall include planning,
engineering and construction costs that are included in Funds 41] and 412. ClP updates shall
include input from PUED project managers and Water Department representatives. CIP input
from COUNTY shall include background information related to new projects and reasons for
changes to existing projects.
Task 2.4 - Prepare 2007 Water Master Plan Updates
Pagc3or6
. ,", - ,~ , sr
:;;J; 50
Prepare an update to the 2005 Water Master Plan Update. The updated plan shall consist of the
following sections:
Section I - Executive Summary
Section 2 - Introduction
Section 3 - Water Planning Areas
Section 4 - Existing Facilities
Section 5 - Population and Demand Projections
Section 6 - Concurrency Management and System Reliability
Section 7 - Alternative Water Service Plans
Section 8 - Capital Improvement Projects for Water
Section 9 - Goodland Water Sub-District
Section 10- Summary and Recommendations
Update Appendices A, B, C and 0 from the 2005 Water Master Plan Update as
appropriate.
Submit 35 printed draft review copies each of the updated master plan at both the 60 and 90
percent complete stages to the COUNTY and submit 35 copies of the final master plans in hard
copy format arld in pdf fornlat on CD. The 60 percent review documents shall consist of the
updated CIP's aJ1d population, water demand tables and figures. The 90 percent review
documents shall consist of a text document for each of the sections shown above with tables and
figures. Review comments from 60 and 90 percent submittals shall be incorporated in final
master plans.
Task 2.5 - Attend Meetings
Services shall include not more than six PROJECT meetings with Public Utilities Engineering
Department to coordinate with ongoing COUNTY projects, develop the CIP update, present
preliminary outputs and receive COUNTY review comments.
Services shall also include up to three PROJECT meetings with other COUNTY departments and
representatives as necessary to coordinate other on-going and planned COUNTY activities and
projects that will impact PROJECT recommendations.
Task 2.6 - Assist with Master PlaJ1 Adoption
Prepare and conduct the following presentations in PowerPoint format:
. Public Utilities Administrator (Two presentations)
. County Manager
. Productivity Committee
. Utilities Committee
. Development Services Advisory Subcommittee (DSAC)
. Board of County Commissioners Workshop
. Board of County Commissioners Adoption
Page 4 of6
(,;h ''',,''.''l~''
~; ~I"'---:'
.~ ~'.., I
Prepare and develop responses to frequently asked questions. Prepare written responses to
comments and questions from Productivity aJ1d DSAC Committees.
TASK 3-ADDITIONAL SERVICES ALLOWANCE
Provide additional services for development of the 2007 Water Master Plan Update. The
additional services allowance of up to $17,420 is for additional services requests that are not
included in the scope of services described above. Written approval from the COUNTY Project
Manager is required prior to performing any Additional Services. Additional services under this
work order will be provided up to the limits shown below. Additional change orders will be
required to perform services beyond the limits shown below.
SUMMARY
TASK NO. DESCRIPTIOl\
COMPLETION TIME
(WEEKS)
COST
Initial Update Planning Services
12
$ 14,560 L8
2
Update Water Master Plan
34
$191.710LS
SUBTOTAL
$ 206,270 LS
3
Additional Services Allowance
34
$17,420 LS or T&M
TOTALS
34
$ 223,690
TARGET COMPLETlON DATE: May 26,2008
SUBMITTED BY:
Greele\' and Hansen LLC
Page 5 ofti
Authorized Company Officer
Roger S. Howell, r.E.
Date
WITNESSES (2):
ACCEPTED BY:
Collier Couot), Proiect Mgr.
Date
I~age 6 of 6
-
-'-
=-- ,,; -~
~: h_~ "->J
Z('';-
::: 0: :i
~~~
5;~
:::' :;
i-z
~
<C
w
-<
<S'~
Doo~
E9:J
0":"""7
cis
.co ~
to'"
zz~
6c:::(/)
ow<<
D"
"'''''''
!!:low
~~~
c5o::~
V~b
o
N
.
.u
C~
u~
-g f, g
'" !Q N
~ ~~.
o u -
.... c (ll
-.~
ijl ij).g
~"iiO
~.
u -
"co
III
,,~
. .
15 .
:o~
J5~
'jij ,af TJ
'00'0
f-o::U
4; u 1> U
.c a.> 0 Q
6509
l'f
om
DOC
OW
~
w
~.8Vi
f-38
~w
<oc
""
00
"I
1 u
I <<
o
<
o
w
<
~I
I'
u
.
.
~
w
o
w
W
w
a.
w
w
~
~
w
o
w
~
a.
w
w
o
a.
~ ci T'""
.z:
~
0000
~~:;fg
N ..:~.
"'lo'tW(I)
0000
<fl.oll'lU')
_ N
(1)(1)(1)(1)
0000
OOlN~
/'-l"lNl"l
N:;::.":f
,""w."..".
~ gjlll ~
I 0
! 110
I I ! !O
I ! i
1110
I i iO
INial 0
_~w
00 0100
~~
-.r NI~ ~
"'
w
u
;;
"
w
"'
~w
.~
. <
~D
a.
~
"
z
Z
z
:l
a.
~
<
I~
.
.
"
.
~
u
o
.
E Z
~l :s
I~ 2 ~
~~ ~
I!:; .~ '0 Cf/
c::w ffi :
~ ~ c::~ ~
::2 -;:;;,g(f} W
~I~ ~ = ~
~ ~1~mro8 ~
"1= '0 Q
~ 0 a.
<(0::> ::J
~N"" N
o
00
w
:f
~
000000
"I'lI'lOOQu)
lTll1lr-.to<llm
-iuirD.nl!l-ri
NNNWT'""
""'00'"000000
<<!<"l<':\WW<<IN<O_r-.
NOlO>NNO-.r...,.....N
tri.,....-"":";..-iNN ri;":g"
N
..,.....,(1).....".
..,""...,......,(I).......""'w
o 00
~ 00
_0
,;
lJ')ooonoo 00
NU'l>ilNOO Ot(l
,.... ....NN 0>
ci';i
~ ~~
11:>...,....".."..... (I)",
~~~-~-~~
00 0 0 010
..,. 000 O'LO
l()_o>_r--.lll.lll:I':~
'</"W<D"'.....t")
NNN>ll....
..,"''''..,'''...
0000000000
lDo:llX><VlDa;lNOO,-N
-.oolltO......o_a:l;..,..t"l_oo......
....,.........o.n..,....NM....lD
e ~
......w,...lfJ.".(I) ww '"
I~ ~ ~I~ ~:~ ;!; ~I.~ ~ ~ :::1;:: ~I[ri ~
N N ~ 0.11: ~ ~
. . I
Ii! '
I n II III' I i~ ~
, I I I i~1 I I iNI~ -ININ -I-I-!~ ~
i i Ii! i I1II i I 1100
i I !~I i~1111111 i I!ll II
I ll~lllll: i IIII i~ ~
rr ~1~lgn TNT N I~ ~
o
1<0 NIO ("oj 1IO lIO
.....'<t.,....oq-
IN 0 0 0 0 ~
...-NN01,ON
I~ ~
1-
~ N T ~ N 00 ~I~ ~
o
o 0
o
o
~
~ ~
........NOO'<l"
N.-WQ;)LS)
.... co III '<t N W co lOl'<t N
N N""" l") I/)
~ ~
~
o
1ii
"
. ,
~ G.> III 0
Iii Jj '" ~ ~
(:: c u.. U'J
<( :;) Q ~ 0
1:: c: c:2N .2-0
m .!'! 0 ii ... IN ~ ffi
~.f: 0..;;::; ~ ~ I~ '" ()
ai"ilgJ ~ ~a::,~ 4>~ 50..
E"'8-g 1m cUe ~E ,,,,.2
." II" ., ~ E 8 j".
1-'50 _ '-O<:IIlEu oc:~
~~E ~ ~~~m8;:~6~~~
~I~: ...; I:: ;!~ 5 ~ 5 ~I~ ~:
~ E ~ 9:: Ri :s ~ =>, ii 2 ~ .g ~ ~l<l:
~ 01 ~ ';; II) ~ ~ m ~ E.g U I.) ~I ~ ~o
~ 't: ILl 1i11(ij S!~ IV :is ~ 0 <( U () en 1Il_
~~~n'~~~~~8~~m~~~~
~_N=>Ic..~<:_m~unm_NMU'J
_IN ~ ~ ~ W I
N<'.I NNNN ,
I I
00
- ~
~ N
_ui
~ 0
_ N
~~
N
U
~
ro
.
~
.
~
"iii~
'6 Z
:g c(
w ~
~
~
"
U>
W
"
;;
"
w
"'
~
<<
Z
o
1=
o
"
<
M
00
N~
.W
':M
_ N
N
~~
00
N m
~ w
~ M-
_ N
N
~~
00
o ~
0_ ....0
- ~
~ ~
00
N ~
~~
<Ii"';
;;
~ ~
W ~
~ ~
~
N
~ :;;
o
o
o
N W
- ~
;;;:ie
N
~ ~
OW
~ W
W
o
o
~
ON
~ ~
M
.
"
l'
u
o
ro
.
5
o
I
..
'6
"
"
"
w
Ow
Zu
<<Z
~~
:jg
<<~
CJ<<
Z~
i=~
~<<
""
a.~
II II
_N
g
w
o
w
w
~
-
w
~
:;;
"'
~
v,
~
g
w
1\
.
a.
o
"
~
o
N
..
o
.
o
~
-~
o 0
li~
00
. ~
E'iij
"' .
$Q
,S; 0 ~
Cl ti.o
W ~ '2 l:
fijs~~
'g is i- '2
:l'& ~ ~
<(WUI-
iO
.
"
~
w
E ~
. 0
]j 8:
. ,
'w
<< -
~.11
~o
'Iii:::
~ B
E~
u.!'
<<0
o
.
..
o
W
..
~
~
- "
w{i)<(I-<l:U
~ 0
0;
"
c
.'"
c
W
o
~
.
~ w
- "
o ~
'c -0.
" 0
ww _
gJ ::2 ~
1Ii ~ c .~
.~ ~ Jl ~
~...~~vo
-g ~ 1] :? ~ '~
m !: ~:ii g'~
~ go:: ~ w Ui
-fr~.2 ~ ,1il.~
.~:.E i3 f e g'
c..UU1CLCLW
w
ow "
Il.W!!?!!?Ww
u~~c..i:iJ
w
~
o
'I>.
6
,
.
~
o
"
o
.
0:
0;
Oi
.
"
~
~
o
o
N
r .'e!-,':t:-~;;:
WORK ORDER # GH-FT-3785-08-02
Agreement for Fixed Term Professional Engineering Services
Contract #05-3785 Dated September 27, 2005
This Work Order is for professional engineering services for work known as
Project # 73066/75007 - 2007 Wastewater Master Plan UDdale
The work is specified in the proposal dated October t6, 2007, which is attached hereto and
made a part of this Work Order. In accordance with the Terms and Conditions of the Agreement
referenced above, Work Order # GH-FT-3785.08-02 is assigned to Greeley and Hansen LLC.
ScoDe of Work:
Task I
Task 2
Task 3
Initial Update Planning Services
Update Wastewater Master Plan
Additional Services Allowance
Task shall be conducted as indicated in the attached Greeley and Hansen LLC proposals.
Schedule of Work: Complete work within 34 weeks after receipt of Notice to Proceed.
Compensation: In accordance with Article Five of the Agreement, the County will compensate
the Firm in accordance with the established hourly rate(s) as enumerated in Exhibit B of the
Proposal.
Task I
Task .2
Task 3
Initial Update Planning Services
Update Wastewater Master Plan
Additional Services Allowance
TOTALS
$ 14,560 LS
$]78,110 LS
$ t7.420T&M
$2] 0,090
Any change within monetary authority of this Work Order made subsequent to final
department approval will be considered an additional service and charged according to
Schedule A of the Agreement.
PREPARED BY:
)
>
\O/Zsj07
Project Manager Date
AUTHORIZED BY:
Ie 1> C/
Roy B.lnderson, P.E. - Director
Public Utilities Engineering
1,,/~)-/o7
,
Date
AUTHORIZED BY: ~ ..?"~--==- ~
George Yilmaz, P.E. - Director
Wastewater Department
\1.,
------
IG0- f/'}-
Date
Page 1 of2
'Ioenda Item No. 16C4
f>iYJ3:T:::-'::;i:" -n";"7
~ .:::.:.;: SC:
Ai:TfIClHI/!'11 BY:
/9/ "'~Q;)
._-~~-~,~....---,-- ~. _._---,--
! h\.lmJ~ (I \\ Icll'~ - f)lfCllol
FlscalOpef3tlons
/12 /.....~. 1;,,2
It;-: [ f:1'(!::
AU J'IIORIZED BY:
James W. DcLony, P 1-:. - Adminislf<.l.tc'J"
f'ublil: LtjJjtics Department
Dnte
AlllSI
H\
..\
/.,',",';' t.:',-' ,'y';.! ./ /,/:.
B,.:
LL,"" C I
I.. v ~.___. '-.,
kc\~n S. Howell. P E. Assnci31t.:'
!..',','j'
1'..:/ :
, . ->.
, ,
DaL:'
Ie: 24. ,.
Typ;;; :\i1mc und Tilk
(lrcclr.::;. ilnd flan5l'll L1.C
I'i\i:'.~' :2 of 2
'12.;-;- ',lc i ':.-~=,:L
~ ',::;,"'L ~ ~-' ~~DG7
.: 5:/ :;(\
EXHIBIT A
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
PUBLIC UTILITIES ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT
Work Order # GH-FT-08-03
2007 Wastewater Master Plan Update
Scone of Services
Greeley and Hansen LLC
October 16, 2007
Greeley and Hansen LLC, herein referred to as ENGINEER, shall perform engineering services
for Collier County, herein referred to as COUNTY, associated with the development and
preparation of the 2007 Wastewater Master Plan Update, herein referred to liS the PROJECT, for
COUNTY. This work order shall be completed in accordance with the terms of Contract 05-
3785, herein referred to as CONTRACT.
The deliverables for the PROJECT shall includc 5-year and 20-year wastewater Capital
Improvement Program (CIP) and updated versions of the Collier County 2005 Wastewater
Master Plan, dated June 6 2006. The goals of the PROJECT are to update strategies developed
in the 2005 Wastewater Master Plall Update, including updates to population, wastewater flow
forecasts, 5 and 20-year CIP schedules, and maps to show updated projects. Updated hydraulic
modeling results for the wastewater system shall be included with the PROJECT. Previous
master plans have utilized KYPIPE 2000 software for hydraulic modeling. The 2007 Wastewater
Master Plan Update will utilize WaterGEMS software for hydraulic modeling.
Recommendations provided in the 2007 Wastewater Master Plan Update shall be based on the
goal of providing sufficient system capacity to meet estimated needs, and to provide wastewater
utility services reliably.
The 2007 Wastewater Master PlaIl update will serve as the basis for the development of updated
rate structures and impact fees. The 2007 Wastewater Master Plall Update shall be coordinated
with the ongoing development of the 2007 lrrigation Quality (lQ) Master Plan, 2007 Water
Master Plan Update and the 2007 Water Supply Master Plan.
Monthly partial payments for the lump sum scrvices for Tasks 1 and 2 will be invoiced based on
the percentage of services completed. Payment for Task 3 services will be invoiced based on
percentages of services completed for negotiated lump sum services or time and materials in
accordance with Contract 05-3785 hourly rates and invoices received from subconsultants.
Page) ors
L\:;JenGa Irem 1\10. 16CA
~ .) ::-'
TASK I - INITIAL PLANNING UPDATE SERVICES
Task 1. 1 ~ Attend Kick Off Meeting
Attend kick-ofT meeting. Prepare aJ1d distribute meeting notes.
Task 1.2 - Collect and Review Existing Data
Collect and review existing data, including updated project schedule and cost information,
wastewater flows, operational data and other information relevant to the PROJECT. Data related
to estimations of population will be collected under the 2007 Water Master Plan Update.
To facilitate the assignment of existing aJ1d projected wastewater demands by geographic
location. the following information will be provided by the COlJ:\:TY:
. GIS shape files showing the service areas for each of the existing wastewater treatment
plants
. GIS-based ViaterGEMS hyd~aulic model with its associated data base files
Task].3 - UDda\e PODulation and Wastewate~ Flow Tables
Update countywide population forecasts based on updated population projections provided by
COlfl\'TY Planning Services. Update wastewater flows based on data obtained in Task 1.2,
available billing records and the updated population data. Update spreadsheets to document and
summarize population and wastewater flow estimates by Water Reclamation Facility (WRF)
Service Area for each year from 2007 through 2027.
TASK 2 -UPDATE W ASTEW A TER MASTER PLAN
Task 2.1 Update Regional WRF Analvses
Update the required county-wide regional WRF capacltres through 2027 based on updated
populations and flows developed in Task 1. Update forecast ofwhcn regional WRF's need to be
constructed and expanded.
Update information describing the existing and future wastewater system, including transmission
and treatment.
Task 2.2 - Update Transmission System Analvses
Task 2.2.1 - Perform Hvdraulic Modeling - The COUNTY has prepared a wastewater model of
the pressure force main piping and COUNTY-owned pumping stations using the WaterGEMS
GIS-based hydraulic modeling software. The scope of services does not include recalibration of
Page 2 of5
the model to match eXlstmg flow data.. Update the hydraulic model for future wastewater
transmission facilities. Perform simulations of maximum day and peak hour conditions for 2012,
2017 and 2027. Prepare a county-wide map showing year 20] 2 aJ1d 2027 WRF and transmission
main facilities.
Task 2.2.2 Prepare Corridor Studies - Prepare Corridor Studies to develop recommended routes
for wastewater transmission main routes to the Northeast Service Area, including the NEWRF.
Similar corridor analyses for water transmission, water supply, and IQ transmission mains are
included in the 2007 Water Master Plan Update, 2007 Water Supply Master Plan, and 2007 IQ
Master Plan, respectively. These master plans are being prepared concurrently with the 2007
Wastewater Master Plan Update. The scope of services is based on wastewater transmission
main evaluation of not more than three corridors and three options per corridor. Corridor Study
services shall include up to three meetings total with Public Utilities Engineering and Real Estate
Services Departments, obtaining and reviewing existing aJ1d proposed utility and road project
plans, identifying property acquisition and pcrmitting requirements, preparing preliminary cost
estimates and identifying recommended alignment corridors.
Task 2.3 - Update Capitallmmovement Prouram (CIPI Schedules
Update 5-year and 20-year ell' schedules and budgets for Fund 413 and Fund 4] 4 capital
improvements identified in Tasks 2.] and 2.2. CIP schedules aJ1d budgets shall include planning,
engineering aJ1d construction costs that are included in Funds 4]3 and 4]4. CIP updates shall
include input from pUED project managers and Viastewater Department representatives. CIp
input from COUNTY shall include backgrollild information related to new projects and reasons
for changes to existing projects.
Task 2.4 - Prepare 2007 Wastewater Master Plan Updates
Prepare an update to the 2005 Wastewater Master Plan Update. The updated plaJ1 shall consist of
the following sections:
Section 1 - Executive Sununary
Section 2 - Introduction
Section 3 - Wastewater Planning Areas
Section 4 - Existing Facilities
Section 5 - Population and Flow Projections
Section 6 - Concurrency Management and System Reliability
Section 7 - Alternative Wastewater Service Plans
Section 8 - Capital Improvement Projects for Wastewater
Section 9 - Summary and Recommendations
Update Appendiccs A, B, C and D from the 2005 Wastewater Master Plan Update as
appropriate.
Submit 35 printed draft review copies each of the updated master plan at both the 60 aJ1d 90
percent complete stages to the COUNTY and submit 35 copies of the final master plans in hard
Page 3 of5
b,;r9nda 1t8m No. 16Cc
i-J:::'\'S!Tlh8' ::::"7 :;,::y,;
:} :/ :1(;
copy format and in pdf format on CD. The 60 percent review documents shall consist of the
updated CIP's and population, water demand tables and figures. The 90 percent review
documents shall consist of a text document for each of the sections shown above with tables aJ1d
figures. Review comments from 60 and 90 percent submittals shall be incorporated in final
master plans.
Task 2.5 - Attend Meetings
Services shall include not more thaJ1 six PROJECT meetings with Public Utilities Engineering
Department to coordinate with ongoing COUNTY projects, develop the CIP update, present
preliminary outputs and receive COUNTY review comments.
Services shall also include up to three PROJECT meetings with other COUNTY departments and
representatives as necessary to coordinate other on-going and planned COUNTY activities aJ1d
projects that wi]] impact PROJECT recommendations.
Task 2.6 - Assist with Master PlaJ1 Adootion
Prepare and conduct the following presentations in PowerPoint formal:
. Public Utilities AdministratOI (Two presentations)
. County Manager
. Productivity Committce
. Utilities Committee
. Development Services Advisory Subcommittee (DSAC)
. Board ofCollilty Commissioners Workshop
. Board of County Commissioners Adoption
Prepare and develop responses to frequently asked questions. Prepare written responses to
comments and questions from Productivity and DSAC Committees.
TASK 3- ADDITIONAL SERVICES ALLOWANCE
Provide additional services for development of the 2007 Wastewater Master Plan Update. The
additional services allowance of up to $ 1 7,420 is for additional services requests that are not
included in the scope of services described above. Written approval from the COUNTY Project
Manager is required prior to performing any Additional Services. Additional services under this
work order will be provided up to the limits shown below. Additional change orders will be
required to perform services beyond the limits shown below.
Page 4 of5
SUMMARY
TASK NO. DESCRIPnON COMPLETION TIME COST
(WEEKS)
I Initial Update Plarming Services ]2 $ ]4,560 LS
2 Update Wastewater Master Plan 34 $ ]78.l10LS
SUBTOTAL $ 192,670 LS
3 Additional Services Allowance 34 $ 17,420 LS or T&M
TOTALS 34 $ 210.090
TARGET COMPLETION DA TE: May 26, 2008
SUBMITTED BY:
Gredel' and Hansen LLC
Authorized Company Officer
Date
Roger S. Howell, P.E.
WITNESSES (2):
ACCEPTED BY:
Collier Count\' Project Mgr.
-
Date
Page 5 ors
<::!..'......::;
-~ :=;' ....
::e~c'
~~=~
:: S' :J:
2;~. 2'
~~
;;;:' 0
(l,Z
~
<
'"
o
~Q.
<~~
oooz
~S':s
O~D-
G:+a::
;-:l5~
"Ow
5z~
0"'",
OWw
~o~
~g~
~"'w
00'~
uOW
;:~
w
.
~o
o~
u~
"'0::::2;
c . a
III ~ <V
III iiJ -
_~w
.--
o ~ -
:I::::: III
oo~
"'0 >,.9
~~8
~.
~ -
.0
OJ
~
a
a
~
2 ~ ~
000
f-c:U
Qj~"liiG
..:::: ~ 00
Oi5ug
o
02
o Iii
Ow
~
w
1il.8"1ii
~~8
~"'
",,0'
""
DO
~I
I u
i <
"
"
u
"'
<
.
3
o
I
~I
,~I
w
o
w
CO
W
Q.
w
w
"
"
w
o
w
"
Q.
W
w
u
"-
gj~~
"
!!!~
. .
<5 .
:E~
;l~
0000
il')..,.~(O
I'-"""'Iil
N;:;!'
MMMW
0000
1il1Ollllil
-~
M....WlA-
0000
o en ""....
.... P') NIM
","":i~"
W lA- :1:
~ ~ ~I~
I
I I fa
I I; 10
II
II
II
" ~II>
oor
~"'~~
"'
w
u
50
a:
w
"'
~w
. ~
.",
~IO
1"-
I~
z
~
"
~
'"
"
Z
.
.
if s
~I ~
m.sl ~
ii ~ f/)
Cl"lii ~
~~ ffi
)g ;B -g, :t
ii 3: ~'I;;; ;:
~.~ 2(f) ~
~ III mj<<: Ul
~I.~I!I~ ~
-g ~ ~g ~
Q) ="'000 C
l:' 0 a..:=' CL
<:({,)~(f) ::::)
r:<VP') N
I;
I';
00
- ~
_ w
WN
~ ~
~
~~
o 00000
V IllOOOln
il') C>~(PC>1ll
~- a;;<lJ"""'-Nf"'i
NNC\I.,..,.....
LOOOlllOOOOOO
1ll(')(')alIDCOC\lCO.....t--
Ncr>m"'NO~M.....U)
",-":":oriri NN <'l~" N
~
M lA-MWlA-W
WMMWfoOtMWfoOtWW
a 00
~ 00
_a
'"
1il001000
....LllIO....OO
~ ....NN
a a
a: ~
"," 0
~ ~~
...WfoOt.,W...
~ ~
~~~~~~
~
~
.;
00000
0000<0
"'r--""''''al
00 ui.riri ",-
<V N <Vi..,.....
tIJ""ftl-IIfl""
0000000000
<CCOal<C<.DalNlD..-N
~Cl:lal_oco",,,,C\I<O
.ri":"':<o"ri":N" "'"rD N
w w
6<tW"'Ifl...""...OIJ-...M
~
~
~ ~ ~I~ ~
N"''''vcr>
N N '-,'<l"
'<tM"'....<V"'~"'.........
"'..........MC\I~.....NNV
~ ~
,0
I
I
I~IIII I~ ~
i~1 II iTiTITITIE M
1 r III1 ! i II i i 10 a
I i II1I1 ! ,~ ~
i II 1III i ~ ~
10
II
1111I
i! ! II
1111~i I ;
II 1'''1
0110000 W
N MVNV
~ ~
- ~
10
""(~IN ....''<l" ....
.0
NONOal
.--'<t~'<l"
w
00 W
"
0000...
NNONN
'<t N N'" '<l" N <[I)W<IJ U)
_ M W
~ "'
a
a a
a
I
~"I>II> ;:';
<C....~
;; M
a
~
a a
~ ~
V <IJ co '<l" "1[00 00
N ~_
~
.
c
o
(lJ ii1
. .
"0; :J
I . a
:;: ~ bu
.!ii III <( <{
0:.2 ~ g
ro OJ c:; N .f'"'O
~<< "Iii g:::: IG tl c:
III E c: III ~ 0 ~ ~
ro II) Qj' Ul ::2 0 II) iij, III c: ()
~~"O~ ~ ~C:i'~! o~
<(f)o~ m c:n~ =~ ~.9
~c:~m I ~~~ ~E ~~
:>0_... _ 0-::::"0... 0 UlN
.~~_ :>U"I_UU"ll\IUlll-&:-C:Sl1~(/)
c: EJ"p:: :> III "0 III c: III '" 0 >1 ~ <:(
QU"lti8Ul~=~~~1II5~~~~~r
:::I:~:I:;::~:;I:::
~ ~ 01 !!I ;;1 ~ ~ 3: m,.g i: -6 () u <( III I !!I:;
1il iij 1i'1 ~ ml!!l -g iii e! .g 5 E' (Jj (,) ~ !!!1 ~ r
~"'OD-CL~~!~CLCLUCLOOOWD-CL~
~~""N~ID-<:(<:('--l\I~U"'OlIJ_N"'~
"'~
~ ~
M ~Iml~
NNNN
N
~
o
.
.
~
.
.
. w
" ~
:g~
Wo
~
~
..
"'
w
u
50
~
w
W
~
'"
z
o
"
is
Q
'"
00
N ~
~ 0
::::~ ~
N
~~
a a
~ m
~ a
"':6
- :;
" ~
a a
o ~
o
..'-
" "
a a
~ ~
~ m
woo
-~
" ~
~ M
M W
~
~
~
~ ~
o
o
~
N N
- "'
a _
N "'
N
~3
ow
~ N
W
a
a
~
o ~
. ~
.
.
.
~
~
c
.
.
,
o
I
"
<5
.
.
a:
w
Uw
Zu
"z
g~
::Jg
,,~
CO'"
Z~
-w
~>
~;;;
G.~
II II
_N
o
~
~
o
~
~
"
-
"
".
,
.
~
o
~
.
m
,
"-
o
o
"
a
N
~
. '"
.0 .
-- ~ ~
o u .
1: ~ (f)
g-5, it
.EO';;) ro 0
1;:4) .!1Et
III 0 Ul :J
.~ ~ lii :: ~
~~:Q ~~
w ~ c: c: 'ai 0
~ E ~ ,~
'gol-'c.E~
:l'~ ~ ~.g]
<:((/)Uf-<:(U
o
~
~
a
~
~
"'
~
~
liiUi~f-<U
" U
.
~
Co
c
w
c
m
..
. -
':' t
o c
'c '5
. c
ww
0;
c
m
'.
.
o
~
o
"
"
:;,
"
o
U
c
.
0:
~
.
"
"
"
.
.
"
~
,
a
a
~
.
. _ 0
Cii ~E
~ ~~
. . -
<:( ... ::2 4:; (lJ 2
"Om~g'~~
ffi!;;offig.!Q
"* rct::2 W 4:;
.9-LIJ 0 U n ~
~ ~.~ '~'['~
a.(.)lI.lCLo..W
w
OW 0
n.~~~g:(I)
Q.G. W
w
2~: 0: ~jC'
WORK ORDER # GH-FT-3785-08-03
Agreement for Fixed Term Professional Engineering Services
Contract #05-3785 Dated September 27, 2005
This Work Order is for professional engineering services for work known as
Project # 72516 2007 Irriealion Oualitv Waler Master Plan
The work is specified in the proposal daled October 16, 2007, which is attached hereto and
made a part of this Work Order. In accordance with the Terms and Conditions of the Agreement
referenced above, Work Order # GH-FT-3785-08-03 is assigned to Greeley and Hansen LLC.
ScoDe of Work:
Task I
Task 2
Task 3
Initial Updale Planning Services
Prepare 2007 IQ Water Master Plan
Additional Services Allowance
Task shall be conducted as indicated in the attached Greeley and Hansen LLC proposals.
Schedule of Work: Complete work within 34 weeks after receipt of Notice to Proceed,
Comnensation: In accordance with Article Five of the Agreement, the County will compensate
the Firm in accordance with the established hourly rate(s) as enumerated in Exhibit B of the
Proposal.
Task I
Task 2
Task 3
Initial Update Planning Services
Prepare 2007 IQ Water Master Plan
Additional Services Allowance
TOTALS
$ 16.960 LS
$] 20.060 LS
$ t 1.660 T&M
$148,680
Any change within monetary authority of this Work Order made subsequent to final
department approval will be considered an additional service and charged according to
Schedule A of the Agreement.
IOf'Z.C/07
Project Manager Date
AUTHORIZED BY:
)1~) f7 ~
Roy B. Adderson, P.E. . Director
Public Utilities Engineering
JO)'J../07
r Date
AUTHORIZED BY: '"
..
..F _~
~
./
-
I 0/2 )-/?-
/ Dati'
George Yilmaz, P,E, . Director
Wastewater Department
Page t of2
4genda Item ~,Io, 16C4
'_"':;:"(,~)-3t:;:7 ~~"~i"7
:::: C',1 ~)C)
c\L rIlORJ7.ED l3\
_2-'~d J;).~...
It:! !~j~?_.__
D"IC
ThOI11,l:; G \\"jdc:,.. [)ircctor
Fj~cal Or(:ratil'n~
AUTIJORJZED BY
James \\' Dc1.ol1)', P [, . ^drninislrator
Publil: Ctililies Department
Dute
^ T rES T
ny,
.".. ...' /-")'
_.i,~1i~~J/1 Lj".:,;,:IL-
Ill:
I,,}
V,:-'";!.-A;..,
, : n I
/~;-- ....0.
. v."....~.,.~ ..::: .":.~,._,_~_,~
!{n~t'r ~ /[clwcJL P E Associate
... . / I"~, 1~1;:' ,:/'; ,':- r. i
--,----------..-.-.---..--,.-
D;nc'
":
'-24, D7
] .I,.t'i: 1\ ,lme und .J Itit;.'
Cireeic)' Jnd Hans:::'l: Ll,C
Pa~:.::: of:?
;::::'n'J:::" Ils:-r hie. Ai.J,:::.::
'J::'\'''3r;rl,::'~' 27 2CJC,
r,r., .. '_r
-:.~.. O~ :-k
EXHIBIT A
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
PUBLIC UTILITIES ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT
Work Order #s GH-FT-08-04
2007 Irrigation Quality Water Master Plan
Scope of Services
Greeley and Hansen LLC
October 16, 2007
Greeley and Hansen LLC, herein referred to as ENGINEER, shall perform engineering services
for Collier County, herein referred to as COUNTY, associated with the development and
preparation of the 2007 Irrigation Quality Water Master Plan, herein referred to as the PROJECT,
for COUNTY. This work order shall be completed in accordance with the terms of Contract 05-
3785, herein referred to as CONTRACT.
The deliverabJes for the PROJECT shall consist of draft and final versions of the 2007 Irrigation
Quality Master Plan. The goals of the PROJECT are to prepare irrigation quality (IQ) water
strategies consistent with the IQ Water Policy, including current and projected irrigation quality
availability and demaJ1d forecasts, recommended system expansions, 5 and 20-year CIP
schedules, and maps to show proposed lQ water projects. The existing KYPIPE hydraulic model
for the IQ water system will be imported into WaterGEMS software and utilized for the
PROJECT. Modeling results for selected model runs shall be included with the PROJECT.
The 2007 Irrigation Quality Water Master Plan shall be coordinated willi the ongoing
development of the 2007 Wastewater Master Plan Update, 2007 Water Master PlaJ1 Update and
the 2007 Water Supply Master Plan.
Monthly par1ial payments for the lump sum services for Tasks 1 and 2 will be invoiced based on
the percentage of services completed. Payment for Task 3 services will be invoiced based on
percentages of services completed for negotiated llliTIp sum services or time and materials in
accordance with Contract 05-3785 hourly rates and invoiees received from subconsultaJ1ts.
Page 1 or5
Agenc:e Item No, 16C,1
"","'::'';"1::';';;::''- :::':'!~',7
4
- .... ~,
"":::'J--:: .c.'''''': ;:-/ ;)J
TASK 1- INInAL PLANNING SERVICES
Task 1.1 - Attend Kick-Off Meeting
Attend kick-off meeting. Prepare and distribute meeting notes.
Task].2 - Collect and Review Existing Data
Collect and review existing data, including adopted]Q Water Policy, updated]Q water users aJ1d
demaJ1d information, wastewater flows, operational data, existing ]Q system hydraulic model,
system maps and other information relevant to the PROJECT. Identify highest users (by volume)
of potable water for irrigation. Identify distances from these highest users to the cxisting lQ
transmission system. Collect and review locations of known current and future government
entity users, including schools and other County facilities.
Task 1.3 - Estimate ^vailable ]0 Water and Svstem DemaJ1ds
Estimate range of avaiiable I Q water based on quantities of wastewater developed in the 2007
Wastewater Master Plan Update aJ1d lQ water available from other existing aJ1d potential future
IQ water sources. Estimate range oflQ water demands aJ1d supply through 2027.
TASK 2 -PREP ARE 2007 IQ WATER MASTER PLAN
Task 2.1 - Perform Transmission Svstem Analvses
Task 2.1. 1 - Perform Hvdraulic Modeling - Prepare the county-wide ]Q water transmrSSLOn
hydraulic model using WaterGEMS software for existing and future traJ1smission facilities.
Perform model runs in to simulate maximum day and peak hour demand conditions for 2012,
2017 and 2027 conditions. Prepare a county-wide map showing year 20]2 and 2027 lQ water
transmission main facilities.
Task 2.1.2 Prepare Corridor Studies - Prepare Corridor Studies to develop recommended routes
for IQ water transmission main routes to the Northeast Service Area, including the NEWRF.
Similar corridor analyses for water transmission, water supply, and wastewater transmission
mains are included in the 2007 Water Master PlaJ1 Update, 2007 Water Supply Master Plan, and
2007 Wastewater Master Plan Update, rcspcctively. These master plans are being prepared at the
same time as the 2007 IQ Water Master PlaJ1. The scope of services is based on lQ water
transmission main evaluation of not more than three corridors and three options per corridor.
Corridor Study services shall include up to three meetings total with Public Utilities Engineering
and Real Estate Services Departments, obtaining and reviewing existing and proposed utility and
road project plans, identifying property acquisition and permitting requirements, preparing
preliminary cost estimates and identifying recommended alignment corridors.
Page 2 of5
\, ~,< ri~:'S'
-
Task 2.2 - Prepare Capital Improvement Program (CIP) Schedules
Prepare 5-year and 20-year ClP schedules and budgets for Fund 413 and Fund 414 capital
improvements identified in Tasks 2.1 and 2.2. CIP schedules and budgets shall include planning,
engineering and construction costs that are included in Funds 413 and 414. CIP updates shall
include input from PUED project managers and IQ Progrmn Manager, CIP input from
COUNTY shall include background information related to new projects and reasons for changes
to existing projects.
Task 2.3 - Prepare 2007 Irrigation Qualitv Master Plan
Prepare an update to the 2007 IQ Water Master Plan. The plan shall consist of the following
sections:
Section I - Executive Summary
Section 2 -Introduction
Section 3 -Irrigation Quality Water Service Area
Section 4 - Existing Facilities
Section 5 -Irrigation Quality Water Supplies and Demands
Section 6 - Alternativc Irrigation Quality Watcr Scrvice Plans
Section 7 - Capital Improvement Projects for Irrigation Quality Water
Section 8 - Summary and Recommendations
Prepare Appendices as appropriate.
The master plan shall include:
. a summary of highest potable water users for irrigation (by location aJ1d type of
facility)
. a summary of existing and known future government entity potable water users for
irrigation
. summaries and figures showing the existing IQ systems and the recommended (5-year
aJ1d 20-year) system
. summaries, schedules, and costs for recommended projects to correlate with IQ
supply. Project costs shall include planning, engineering and construction costs for 5-
year and 20-year planning.
Submit 35 printed draft review copies each of the master plan at both the 60 aJ1d 90 percent
complete stages to the COUNTY and submit 35 copies of the final master plans in hard copy
format and in pdf format on CD. The 60 percent review documents shall consist of the updated
CIP's and IQ water supply and demand tables and figures. The 90 percent review documents
shall consist of a text document for each of the sections shown above with tables and figures.
Review comments from 60 and 90 percent submittals shall be incorporated in final master plans.
Page 3 of5
AQsnda tt~rn No. 'I ~~.~
h,:;,'::e,r:l',I-::;''::' .21.;:)'
::'~ 'J' ~/,
Task 2.4 - Attend Meetings
Services shall include not more than six PROJECT meetings with Public Utilities Engineering
Department to coordinate with ongoing COUNTY projects, develop the ClP update, present
preliminary outputs and receive COUNTY review comments.
Services shall also include up to three PROJECT meetings with other COUNTY departments and
representatives as necessary to coordinate other on-going and plarmed COUNTY activities and
projects that will impact PROJECT recommendations.
Task 2.5 - Assist with Master Plan Adoption
Prepare and conduct the following presentations in PowerPoint format:
. Public Utilities Administrator (Two presentations)
. County Manager
. Productivity Committee
. Utilities Committee
Development Services Advisory Subcommittee (DSAC)
. Board of County Commissioners Workshop
Board of County Commissioners Adoption
Prepare and develop responses to frequently asked questions. Prepare written responses to
comments and questions from Productivity and DSAC Committees.
TASK 3- ADDITIONAL SERVICES ALLOWANCE
Provide additional services for development of the 2007 Irrigation Quality Water Master Plan.
The additional services allowance of up to $ 1 I ,660.is for additional services requests that are not
included in the scope of services described above. Written approval from the COUNTY Project
MaJ1ager is required prior to performing any Additional Services. Additional services under this
work order will be provided up to the limits shown below. Additional change orders will be
required to perform services beyond the limits shown below.
SUMMARY
TASK NO, DESCRIPnON
COMPLEnON nME
(WEEKS)
COST
Initial Planning Services
12
$ 16,960 LS
2
Prepare 2007 IQ Quality Water Master Plan 34
$ 120.060 LS
SUBTOTAL
$ 137,020 LS
Page 4 of5
'" \,".::;:~',::>:?' _ ~i'\r'
::"7)' ~i
3
Additional Services AllowaJ1ce
34
$11,660 LS or T&M
TOTALS
34
$ 148,680
TARGET COMPLETION DATE: May 26, 2008
SUBMITTED BY:
Greelev and Hansen LLC
Authorized Company omc,,"
Date
Roger S. Howell, P.E.
WITNESSES (2):
ACCEPTED BY:
Collier County Proiect Mgr.
Date
PageS of5
L..,genda Item No. 16C4
':'V':;;Ti~~\e. :':'[lC"7
~jC;
WORK ORDER # GH-FT-3785-08-04
Agreement for Fixed Term Professional Engineering Services
Contract #05-3785 Dated September 27, 2005
This Work Order is for professional engineering services for work known as
Project # 75005 2007 Water Suoolv Master Piau
The work is specified in the proposal dated October 16, 2007, which is attached hereto and
made a part of this Work Order. In accordance with the Terms and Conditions of the Agreement
referenced above, Work Order # GH-FT-3785-08-04 is assigned to Greclev and Hansen LLC.
Scone of Work:
Task 1
Task 2
Task 3
Initial Planning Services
Prepare 2007 Water Supply Master Plan
Additional Services Allowance
Task shall be conducted as indicated in the attached Greeley and Hansen LLC proposals.
Schedule of 'A-'ork: Complete work within 34 weeks after receipt of Notice to Proceed,
ComN'r:sation: In accordance with Article Five of the Agreement, the County' \\'ill compensat~
the Firm in accord~ :Jce with the established hourly ratc(s) as enumerated in Exhibit B of the
Proposa1.
Task 1
Task :;
Task 3
Init:" Update Planning Services
Prec: c' 2007 IQ Water Supply Master Plan
Ade ional Services Allowance
TO~; ..LS
$ 13,860LS
$75,140LS
$ 7,480 TOoM
$ 96,480
Any change within monetary authority of this Work Order made subsequent to final
department approval will be considered an additional service and charged according to
Schedule A of the Agreement.
PREPARED BY:
10/2.S./07
Project Manager Date
AUTHORlZED BY:
L-
10)1)-)07
Date' I
Roy B. And rson, P.E. . Director
Public Uti! ties Engineering
AUTHORIZED BY:
Qe~L-2P
Pa'" Mattausch . Director
\~hiter Department
I p P1i/z..."p 1
Da'te
Page I of2
'~,\';:\ ~,'i~)2" 27 )(j{!7
.2 ~\ ~,
ALJTHORIZEDnY:_______?~~Q42-
Thomas G, ~~~~ Director
Fis.cal Operations
--~lfl2___
Dat-?-
.,\LIHORIZEIJ ny:
James W DeLcIT1)'. P.E. . Admini::.tralor Ihtc
Public Utilities DCpiJrttncfll
Arr EST:
'I ., r) .',
By: __~~!~[j/!. (i(~_ /- (/~ 1: /~._,~~.-~__.___,~__
By.
...._. 12~,,:_B-:!'~4g______
Roger S. Howell, P E. /\s.so:;iatc
!; :L? ". /ic' {.
Dale.
('t; '-;';:,,4-. c-;
Tyrl' l'\,ll1lC and Tilk
(Jret:j~,y and 11~Jns(:,;J1 LLC
Pat'<.:: ur::
A~E:nGS Item hie. i6eLl
:,,-.;,-, :'i >,:; , - ....::" ~
::Ci:::/5C:'
EXHIBIT A
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
PUBLIC UTILITIES ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT
Work Order # GH-FT-08-02
2007 Water Supply Master Plan
Scope of Services
Greeley and Hansen LLC
October 16, 2007
Greeley and Hansen LLC, herein referred to as ENGINEER, shall perform engineering services
for Collier County, herein referred to as COUNTY, associated with the development and
preparation of the 2007 \i'ater Supply Master Pian, herein referred to as the PROJECT, for
COUNTY. This work order shall be completed in accordance with the terms of Contract 05-
3785, herein referred to as CONTR.'ICT.
The deliverables for the PROJECT shall include draft and final versions of the 2007 Water
Supply Master Plan. The goals of the PROJECT are to update strategies developed in the
Potable Water Supply Development Plan Update (PWSDP), dated August 2007 (CDM).
Hydraulic modeling is not included, Recommendations provided in the 2007 Water Supply
Master Plan shall be based on the goal of providing sufiicient resource to meet estimated needs
through 2027 consistent with the 2007 Water Master Plan Update.
The 2007 Water Supply Master Plan shall be coordinated with the COUNTY'S Well field
Program Manager, CDM, and the ongoing development of the 2007 Irrigation Quality (lQ)
Master Plan, the 2007 Water Master Plan Update and the 2007 Wastewater Master Plan Update.
Corridor studies for other utilities are included with the other ongoing 2007 master plans.
Corridor studics for required water supply mains are being prepared under a scparate
authorization through COM and are not included in this scope of services. The results of these
corridor studies will be included in the 2007 Water Supply Master Plan.
Monthly partial payments for the lump sum services for Tasks] aJ1d 2 will be invoiced based on
the percentage of services completed. Payment for Task 3 services wi]] be invoiced based on
percentages of services completed for negotiated lump sum services or time and materials in
accordance with Contract 05-3785 hourly rates and invoices received from subconsultants.
Pagr I of5
;(-;:1"
TASK 1 - INInAL PLANNING SERVICES
Task l.l - Attend Kick-Off Meeting
Attend kick-off meeting. Prepare and distribute meeting notes.
Task 1.2 - Collect and Review Existing Data
Collect and review existing data, including updated project schedule and cost information, water
demands, and operational data, and other information relevant to the PROJECT.
Task 1.3 - Update Required Water Supplv Tables
Update required water supply based on thc water dcmaJ1ds determined in thc 2007 Water Master
Plan Update. Update the PWSDP to document and summarize water demand requirements
through 2027.
TASK 2 -PREPARE 2007 WATER SUPPLY MASTER PLAN
Task 2.] - Update Water Supply Svstcm Descrintions
Update information describing the existing water supply systems and improvements currently in
progress,
Task 2.2 - Prepare Water Supplv Capital Improvement Program (CIP) Schedules
Services for updating the Fund 41 I and Fund 412 CIP's are included in the 2007 Water Master
Plan Update. A summary of the Fund 411 and 412 projects relating to watcr supply will be
prepared and included in the 2007 Water Supply Master Plan.
Task 7.3 - Prepare 2007 Water Supplv Master Plan
Prepare the 2007 Water Supply Master Plan. The master plan shall consist of the following
sections:
Section I - Executive Sununary
Section 2 - Introduction
Section 3 - Water Planning Areas
Section 4 - Existing Facilities and Improvements Currently in Progress
Section 5 - Population and Demand Projections
Section 6 - Future Water Supply
Section 7 - Capital Improvement Projects for Water
Section 8 - Summary and Recommendations
P.age 2 of5
Provide Appendices as appropriate.
Submit 35 printed draft review copies each of the updated master plaJ1 at both the 60 aJ1d 90
percent complete stages to the COUNTY and submit 35 copies of the final master plaJ1s in hard
copy format and in pdf format on CD. The 60 percent review documents shall consist of the
updated CIP's and population, water demand tables and figures. The 90 percent review
documents shall consist of a text document for each of the sections shown above with tables aJ1d
figures. Review comments from 60 and 90 percent submittals shall be incorporated in final
master plans.
Task 2.4 - Attend Meetings
Services to attend mcctings are included with the 2007 Water Master Plan Update.
Task 2.5 - Assist with Master Plan AdOPtion
Services lO assist with master plan adoption ~rc included with the 2007 Water Master Plan
Update.
TASK 3- ADDITIONAL SERVICES ALLOWANCE
Provide additional services for development of the 2007 Water Supply Master Plan. The
additional services allowance of up to $7,480 is for additional services requests that are not
included in the scope of services described above. Written approval from the COUNTY Project
Manager is required prior to perfonning any Additional Services. Additional services under this
work order will be provided up to the limits shown below. Additional change orders will be
required to pcrform services beyond the limits shown below.
PRgC 3 of5
(,I::Wi3i:^il:i2r.27 2C.I()--:
;::- ~{SO
SUMMARY
TASK DESCRIPnON
COMPLEnON nME COST
(WEEKS)
2
Initial PlaJ1ning Services 12 $ 13,860 LS
Prepare 2007 Water Supply Master Plan 34 $ 75.140 LS
SUBTOTAL $ 89,000 LS
Additional Services Allowance 34 $ 7,480 LS or T&M
TOTALS 34 $ 96.480
3
TARGET COMPLETION DATE: May 26, 2008
SUBMITTED BY:
Greelev and Hansen LLC
Authorized Company Officer
Date
Roger S. Howell, P.E.
WITNESSES (2):
ACCEPTED BY:
Collier County Proiect Mgr.
Date
P3ge 4 ors
A.~enda Item 1\10_ 16C4
;Jm'~':Ti['~;'" 27 ~~O(,-
:)~ :::)" 50
Page5of5
:s;?~
--"J'O
cc
...:::. ,'~ (')
aJ
_ Q: ::7!
;;:.:.::- ::u
==C-
x ~
;20
QiZ
'"
<{
z
~9~
g~a::
~~
on
~
'"
f-O>-
5zo::
0"'''-
v~~
"'''''''
!:!:!ow
:::h:::~
0"''<
O~b
o
N
"
_0
O~
O~~
"E ~ g
lij ~ N
III (tlW-
~ I
~~]
"C >..9
i!~8
mo
"g21
m
!!'~
. ",
'6 m
:5~
Jl~
1S1l2
i5 '0' ~
1-0:0
ii;UiijG
:5~OO
Oi:5UQ.
15
z
Uw
0",
Ow
~
~
5.81;;
~~8
~on
"'"
",co
00
"'I
o
~
'"
o
"
o
iL
"
"
"
o
I
~
"
;;;
E
j;i
w
o
on
iL
W
<L
w
on
~
"-
w
o
on
~
"-
on
w
o
<L
~d"""
.z
'"
0000
10 '<I" "-W
~ ~ ~
N-.....ri
W4o'tVJW
0000
10 10 IOItl
~N
lI:l~('/)1o't
000
mN~
~NW
f'i":ri
"'""t/lu.
ONON
NON
I r
I I 110
10
10
N~O
~~W
~O~
VV
N~-;!:
'"
w
o
;;
'"
W
'"
~W
"?-
m.,
1-0
<L
=>
"
Ii
:l
..
-'
"
"
z
z
:l
<L ..
~ ffi
!: :n
~ "
~ "
o ~
" m -'
.E:i6 ~
iilClj! ~
o coO en
():;;~ tr
c Jj - ~
~ ~ :J~ ~
~.:; en(/') ,..,
';:: 01 Qi<C g
00:::- .....
jj ~ mf,!
- ffi ~~ ~
~ ~o <
~ ~I~~ fu
~ i5 ~~ a:::
<co lJ...(I) 0-
'"':~~ N
~ ~ ~
o
w
=
:i
00
~o
_0
.n",
~ =
~
~~
000
~oo
~ ~
'<t-~w
W
00
vO
~ 0
.riai
~ ~
..,..,~...
w..............,...w.....
00
00
~o
.;
M
00
O~
~M
dei
MM
~~
~ ~
~ M.
000
~oo
~~
"<t-~<D
M
00
<i:ll
...,-rx;;
v~
"" (,/)&'Jvt
~;g~o
~
..,..,..,......wVJutWW
OOOOOOQOON
~ to
o
III~ ~
I IIIII~ g
I I II 1100
i III II~ ~
I III'~;:
I
~
N
I I~I
, . .
IIII
II~I
I ;:
Ii
011">1 0
N~W
N N
~"'
o
W v
N
00
M M
~~~
~w
~ M
~
o
00
o
00
~wo
v
NW
~w
.0
.
~ c
" 0
~ "
o "
U 0
~ E Ul 0
Q ffi J:'l b ()
l ~ ~~ l~ ~ ~
o " ~...... c .!!Ill"! .2 1::1
o ro 0 C --- <t) C
E :! a lll.s Q) III
OI.tIl>.c:O e~ I~~
iii lJ... i5..'-"'O lJ... t: 01 1~
iBu g. a: ~ ti 'c!l '" 2
>~U) -g.!!! ij'E'E Cf. III
Cia.~~lJ... 01:::5! '- E I" ~N
g.::Jiii-Qi .....Glo oloo::f
U) ~ :::: J:'l iii ~ ~ ~IU ~ a ~' ~~
~W~~~ c~~ ~~W$~
.2(ilol):E ~'5:2.>~oQ.oa::...J
~S:~;;:5 ~:).i='UN$:.g~~~
lVlllO>'~ ~.!.lr::~(,)U<(I!!!!!!
.2 (ij l\i.f:....,...... g-:a ~ -g <C 0 O!Gi tiS,...
'" Q. (j) '" a.. .... :l 0 .... WID (,) .... ....
'&.~~lV.~~~~~~o ,lD~~::>
::>a..a..:2<(S:~Cll-OO'C<ll"":N""
~N'<l"\O(P
('.jNNNN
N
c
.
"
~
"
.
~ w
.. "
B Z
~ .,
o ;:
o
-'
-'
.,
'"
w
o
;;
'"
w
'"
-'
"
z
o
i=
C
c
"
M
00
:1::/
"':lSi
m
~~
00
m w
v v
r-:lri'
m
~ ~
00
0"'
~ m
.;
M
~ ~
00
~M
mw
rti.ri
w
~ ~
ON
~~
w
v
N
m m
N
o
o
W
v
N
m 0
w
w ~
M
~ 0
N W
o
o
~~
w
~
~
"
,
.
~
~
c
.
"
"
o
J!!
.
00
..
'6
~
'"
'"
UJ vo
OwO
Zuu
~ ~H~
0'<"
~O'"
~~~
~~=>
,,~on
z~z
-wO
"'>0
~C:(CD
00",:>
..",on
II II II
~NM
o
~
~
o
w
~
~
~
~
~
w
~
::'
~
o
o
m
~
"'
m
.
~
o
o
;;
o
N
~
" eo
.0 .
o~ ~
al~ ~
Q.i:: 'it
E .~ .!!! 8.
0:: W ,!! c.
Il> 0 '" ::l
.~ 13 ffi .:( ~
~1i:1:1 ~ ~
~ ~~.~Z~
'~~~'~'E~
~'~2~~~
<(WU,...<cU
o
~
~
o
w
;;
LIiw2,...<cu
" 0
.
.
c
.'"
c
w
c
o
.0
~ Iii
. "
o c
'c'm
"' c
vow
1ll :: a
iiI ~ '1:
g ~J5
~ m--
<('-.:216030:
-g mal g,~'~
10 ,f:'o Iii g~
~ goo:::1! W Gi
.g-~.2 ,1i ~.~
'E:C ~ e"e':?
a..UWQfi..W
w
OUJ 0
a.w~~lJJfI.l
u~~o..UJ
'"
0;
c
m
o
"'
o
~
o
'"
6
:;,
"
o
o
c
.
0:
"
;;
.
"
~
0.
g.
~
0;
..
'<
~
o
o
N
WORK ORDER # PRMG-FT-4071-08-01
A,pend& item f>Jo, 16C4
!'J- .'S:";:U~~ 27 [}~;;
~'2;;-S ::'..b :).; .su
Agreement for Fixed Term Financial Consulting Services
Contract #07-4071 Dated January 23, 2007
This Work Order is for financial consulting services for work known as
Project # 75018 2007 Water, Waslewater and 10 Water Imnacl Fees and User Rates
Studv
The work is specified in the proposal dated October 22, 2007, which is attached hereto and
made a pan of this Work Order. In accordance with the Terms and Conditions of the Agreement
referenced above, Work Order # PRMG-FT-407t-08-01 is assigned to Public Resources
Management Group. Inc. (PRMG)
Scone of Work:
Task!
Task 2
Task 3
Water and Wastewater User Rate Study
Water and Wastewater Impact Fee Study
Irrigation Quality V/ater Rate Study
Tasks shall be condueled as indicated in the altached PRMG proposal.
Schedule of \\lork: Complete '.vork within:38 weeks after receipt of hot ice to Proceed,
Corr.flcnsatinn: In accordance with Artlcic five of the Agreement, the County \','jJ] comp~nsatc
tht. Firm in accordance \--\'ith the established hourly rale(s) as enumerated in Attachment A of
the Proposal.
Task]
Task 2
Task 3
\\/ater and V/astewater User Rate Study
V/ater and \\rastewater Impact Fee Study
Irrigation Quality \\rater Rate Study
TOTALS
$ 47,000 T&M
$ 26,000 T &M
$ 30.000 T &M
$]03,000
Any change within monetary authority of this Work Order made subsequent to final
department approval will be considered an additional service and charged according to
Schedule A of the Agreement
PREPARED BY:
-- Principal Project
oineering
10(24/07
Manager Date
AUTHORIZED BY:
/'l.,f~Cr~
Roy/8, Anderson, P.E, - Director
Pu~lic Utilities Engineering
/0/2.'-/07
IDate' !
AUTHORIZED BY:
'iL~Ci),[D
10/30/"1
Date
Thomas G, Wides - Director
Fiscal Operations
Page] of2
\.is'Y'!'it.S' -,-I
AUTHORIZED BY:
James W. DeLony, P.E. - Administrator
Public Utilities Department
Date
ATTEST:
I-Ie.....r...' L"Th""'i"lj,~J'- V ;(t' 'r:("~'.c:Q<::,("'I +-
Type l\ame and Title
.12, ~ 0"-'
Robert J. Ori, President
Date: 1l!/d~/"'7
Public Resources Management Group, Inc.
By:
By: #-~/$n~
Page 2 of2
m
Public Resources Management Group, Inc.
Utrlify, RdtL', Fino1icio/ ond /\-fanafemCrtl COl/sultonlS
October 22, 2007
Mr. Thomas G. Wi des
Operations Director, Public Utilities Division
Collier County Government
3301 E. Tamiami Trail, Suite H3
Naples,FL 34112
Subject:
Proposal to Provide Utility Consulting Services
(Proposed Work Authorization No. 2007-04)
Dear Mr. Wid~s:
In a2cordance with Agreement No. U7-407l for FInanc;al Consulting Services dated January 23.
2007 (the "County Agreement") between Collier County (the "County") and Public Resources
Management Group, Inc. (PRMG), we are pleased to submit this proposal (the "Proposal") to
provide utility consulting services to the County. Based on discussions with the County, our
primary resporrsibilities would be to perfonn, on behalf of the County's Water-Sewer District: i)
a v,!ater and W2.ste\\'ater user rate study: iii a water and wastewater impact fee study; and iii) an
irrigation quality (reclaimed) rate study (collecllvely, the "Project"), ]n accordance with our
understanding of the County's nceds rclatJvc to the Project, we propose the following:
PROJECT TEAM AND BILLING RATES
With respect to the perfonnance of this engagement, Mr. Robert Ori would be the principal-in-
charge and primary contact with the County. Mr. Bryan Mantz would serve as the project
manager and lead analyst for the Project. Other staff consultants, analysts and administrative
personnel of PRMG may be utilized during the course of the Project as needed, Attachment A
provides a summary of the Direct Labor Hourly Rates by employee title that would be used to
bill for the consulting services rendered on behalf of the County,
SCOPE OF SERVICES
The scope of services in accordance with this Proposal to be performed by PRMG with respect to
this engagement is included on Attachment B, which is made a part of this Proposal.
COMPENSA nON AND BILLL"IG
Based on the Scope of Services as summarized in Attachment A and the direct labor billing rates
as identified herein, we propose to establish a Work Authorization No. 2007-04 under the
County Agreement in an amount not-to-cxceed $103,000 to complete the Project on behalf of the
County. This cost estimate can be broken down as follows:
1-:':\1 I 25"Jv\Co:llcr Counly\R~le Srudy Upda:r\f'roposnl - Rate Srudy,doc
341 r,ORTII \1'\lTLAND A VENUE. SUITE 300 - ,.lAITLAND. FL 32751
'f'FLEI'Ii()i'E, (407) 62S.26IJO. FI\:\' ('\07) 62:;-2610. L~HIL.: ['!\:v1C;'il,PRMCiil1c.cum
t\',:i',
:-'22'3 ~:~ C/5C,i
Mr. Thomas G. Wides
Collier County Government
October 22, 2007
Page 2
Project Component
Water and Wastewater User Rate Study
Water and Wastewater Impact Fee Study
Irrigation Quality (Reclaimed) Waler Rate Study
Cost
Estimate
$47,000
26,000
30.000
Tolal Projecl Cost Eslimate
$103000
A full cost estimate for Work Authorization No. 2007-04 is shown in Attachment C. This cost
amount includes the direct cost of personnel anticipated to be assigned to conduct the requested
work as well as an allowance for other direct costs such as travel, telephone, delivery charges,
and sub-consulting expenses, if any. The costs incurred by PRMG for such other direct costs, if
any, would be billed to the County based on the standard rates for the recovery of such costs as
identified in the County Agreement.
It should be noted that the proposed budget is a total cost estimate and not a phased cost
estimate. The budget would be billed on an hourly basis predicated on the actual work effort
performed by PRMG and not on a lump-sum basis. To the extent that the Project were
completed at a cost less than the contract budget, PRMG would not invoice the County for any
amounts remaining (unbilled) on such contract except for the provision of any additional services
which the County may request from PRMG, as mutually agreed between the two parties.
PROJECT SCHEDULE
Upon notification to proceed as provided by the County, PRMG would complete the Project in
accordance with the County's time schedule, with a not-to-exceed duration of 180 days. The
completion of the analysis would be subject to the availability of information provided to PRMG
from the County and the overall needs and objectives of the County.
We appreciate the opportunity to provide this Proposal to establish Work Authorization
No. 2007-04 under tl1e County Agreement, and look forward to working with you and other
County staff in the near future.
Very truly yours,
Public Resources Management Group, Inc.
:?~~ rf <:0-<--,
Robert J. Ori
President
Attachments
K:\1125\jv\Collier County\Rale Study Update\ProposaJ - Rate Study,doc
ATTACHMENT A
4QenC2 Iterr No, i6ea
f,':::)\'Srnr'9' ')7 'J!iU-.
COLLIER COUNTY COVERNMENT
WORK AUTHORIZA nON 2007-04
UnLITY CONSULnNG SERVICES
WATER AND W ASTEW A TER USER RATE STUDY, IMP ACT FEE STUDY
AND IRRIGAnON QUALITY (RECLAIMED) WATER RATE STUDY
Project Team Title
Principal
Associate
Executive Consultant
Managing Consultant
Supervising Consultant
Senior Consultanl
Rate Consultant
Consultant
Rate Ana J)'st
Analyst
Assistant Analyst
Administrative
DIRECT LABOR HOURLY RATES
Direct Labor
Hourly Rates
$150.00
$125.00
$] 10.00
$105.00
$ 95.00
$ 85.00
5; 75,00
$ 65.00
$ 55.00
$ 45.00
$ 35.00
$ 45.00
STANDARD COST RA TES
Expense Dt:scription
Mileage Allowance - Personal Car Use Only
Reproduction (black and white) (in house)
Reproduction (color) (in house)
Reproduction (contracted)
Computer Time
Telephone Charges
Delivery Charges
Lodging/Other Travel Costs
Meals
Subconsultant Services
Other Costs for Services Rendered
Standard Rales [*]
IRS Standard Mileage Rate
$0.05 per page
$0.25 per page
Actual Cost
$0.00 per hour
Actual Cost
Actual Cost
Actual Cost
Not to exceed per PRMG
Emp loyee
Per County
Reimbursement Policy
Actual Cost plus 5.0%
Actual Cost
[>OJ Standard CDS! rates will be based on the County reimbursement policy or Florida Statute
Section 112,06], as appropriate, during the billing period referenced on the invoices for
services Amounts shown as example only.
K:\1125\jv\Coflier County\R;He Study Updalc\l-'roposal- Rate Study.doc A-I
..r ~.' .
...;'~' ,-,. ~).,
ATTACHMENT B
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
WORK AUTHORlZA nON NO. 2007-04
UnLITY CONSUL nNG SERVICES-
WATER AND WASTEWATER USER RATE STUDY, IMPACT FEE STUDY
AND IRRIGAnON QUALITY (RECLAIMED) WATER RATE STUDY
SCOPE OF SERVICES
The Project scope of services to be performed by Public Resources Management Group, Inc.
(PRMG) on behalf of the County's Water-Sewer District (the "District") is summarized by task
item as shown below:
WA TER ~"lD W ASTEW A TER USER R<\ TE STUDY
Data Compilation and Review
PRMG will prepare a written data request for the collection of financial, customer billing,
operating, engineering, and planning data necessary to conduct the rate study. Infonnation
requested will include, but will not be limited to, financial statements and analyses, proposed
operating budgets and capital work plans, existing and anticipated debt service schedules, cost
estimates and customer billing data. The initial data request will be as comprehensive as
possible to perf0n11 the study; however, based on a review of the County's initial response it is
contemplated that follow-up data requests may be required during the course of the study.
Historical Customer Statistical Compilation I Bill Frequency Analyses
PRMG will compile historical customcr statistics based on reports generated from the District's
billing system, as well as from information provided by the City of Naples (the "City") regarding
District wastewater customers billed by the City. PRMG will perform bill frequency analyses
for the Fiscal Year 2007 to summarize historical billing data so that we may match the District's
rate structure billing determinaJ1ts and more accurately project monthly user fee revenues. To
the extent that PRMG must analyze raw or incomplete customer data in order to complete the bill
frequency analyses, additional services charges will apply.
Projected Customer Statistics and User Rate Revenues
PRMG will prepare an updated forecast of customer and usage requirements based on detailed
customer account information provided by District. This task will include a review of historical
customer and usage statistics by rate classitication and development of a forecast of customers
and sales based on the best available information regarding future growth. The bill frequency
analyses previously described will be applied to historical and projected customer statistics to
project monthly user fee revenue.
Operating Expense Projections
PRMG will prepare a five-year forecast of the District's operations and maintenance expenses
based on the District's Fiscal Year 2008 Budget and recent historical results. This task involves
the development of the estimated amount of operating expenses required to be funded from water
and wastewater rates. The task will be performed in sufficient detail in order to: i) recognize the
K:\lI25\)v\CollierCounly\Rate Srudy Update\Prop(l~aJ - Rate Study, doc B-1
.c;~'?!l~,;:' Ite;T; r'k" 16:=:.:1
- :)' :':1
primary expenses incurred by the water and wastewater systems; ii) assist in the projection of
expenditures for the applicable forccast period; iii) recognize changes in operating costs due to
changes in regulatory requirements and utility operations; and iv) have sufficient detail in
operating expenses to properly allocate the costs among the utility systems as well as among rate
structure attributes. Finally, other operating expenses such as inter-fund transfers, administrative
allocations, contingency reserves, insurance needs and other expenses will be evaluated to insure
that rates are designed for the full recovery of costs.
Rate Comparisons
PRMG will prepare comparisons of the existing and proposed water and wastewater rates with
those of other neighboring or similar utilities.
Capital Improvement Plan and Funding Analysis
This task involves a detailed review of the District's five-year or applicable capital improvement
program as shown in the Master Plan Update and othcr cngincering planning documents, and the
performance of a funding analysis to identify all sourccs of funds for financing of the capital
rmprovement program.
Financial Target / Other Revenue Requirements Analysis
In order to meet the financial obligations of the District's water and wastewate;- utilIty systems,
PRMG will revicw the financial aspects of the District's utility systems in order to potentially
recognize other revenue requirements that may need to be allocated or included in the rate
analysis. This task will include assistance in the development of fiscal policies in terms of
working capital maintenance, the funding of other departmental capital or maintenance reserves
for items such as vehicles and equipment, and the rccognition of any other transfer requirements
that may be associated with the utility system.
J\et Revenue Requirements / Revenue Sufficiency Analysis
PRMG will prepare a summary of the total net revenue requirements of the water and wastewater
systems and the accompanying rate impact requirements for each fiscal year of the forecast
period.
Debt Service Compliance
This task will be conducted in order to satisfy the rate covenant requirements and the flow of
fund requirements as defined in the authorizing bond resolution and loan documents in
association with the outstanding utility system revenue bonds and loans (system debt). The
compliance analyses will be performed for the projected five-year or applicable period to
maintain the financial integrity of the utility systems.
Water / Wastewater User Rate Design and Customer Impact Analysis
Based on cost of service principles, PRMG will develop water and wastewater rates for each
customer class identified in the study. PRMG will also study the impacts of any proposed rate
adjustments upon each customer class.
K:\1125~v\Collier COllnt)'\Rale Stud)' Updale\Proposal- Rale Sludy.doc B-2
If requested by County staff, PRMG will design guaranteed revenue or capacity reservation fees
which would be imposed upon customers who have paid impact fees and Allowance for Funds
Prudently Invested (AFPI) fees, but have not yet physically connected to the System. The
guaranteed revenue fees would allow for the recovery of certain fixed operating costs incurred by
the District in order to maintain the reserved capacity for the benefit of those applicants
requesting such capacity.
Report Preparation and Presentation
PRMG will prepare: i) a rate study report documenting our assumptions, analyses, and primary
data sources; ii) a briefing document (PowerPoint presentation) to summarize the study results;
and iii) a draft rate schedule in support of the Rate Ordinance preparation by the County as may
be needed.
WATER AND W ASTEW A TER IMP ACT FEE STUDY
Data Compilation and Review
PRMG will prepare a written data request and will interview staff members and the District's
consulting engineers to collect capital and planning documentation as well as other relevant
information needed to perform the impact fee study. lnfonnation to be obtained will include
population projections, updates to current fixed asset data, revised capital improvement plans of
each utility system based on the updated master planning activities being prepared by the
consulting engineers, inventory of existing facilities as it rdates to capacity and utilizatlOl1, and
other related infonnation.
Evaluation of Existing Fixed Assets
PRMG will evaluate existing facility costs and incremental costs to provide utility service to
future service area needs or build-out population.
Review of Levels of Service and Capacity Analysis
Based on existing level of service (LOS) standards, an analysis of the District's existing and
projected Equivalent Residential Connection (ERC) requirements will be conducted. This
analysis is necessary to evaluate the capacity utilization of the water and wastewater facilities
(from both an existing and prospective capital facility standpoint).
Impact Fee Comparison
A comparison of impact fees for neighboring or similar utilities will be prepared. Such impact
fee comparison will include: i) level of fee charged; and ii) method of application where readily
available. This task will be performed concurrent with the impact fee determination to assist in
the finalization of the fee methodolo!,'Y as it pertains to the District.
Evaluation of Capital Improvement Program
PRMG will review the District's updated capital improvement plan and capacity additions
necessary to serve growth.
K.\1125'yv\Collier County\RlIle Study Update\ProposaJ - Rate Study.doc B-3
'-,.=,'
Design of Impact Fees and Allowance for Funds Prudently Invested (AFPI) Fees
Based on the LOS standards and facilities use projections, PRMG will develop impact fees for
water and wastewater service for the District. The fees will be developed recognizing the
reservation and utilization of capacity by an equivalent residential customer (e.g., single-family
residential) and will recognize the contribution to need based on capital facility burden imposed
on the District by new development.
PRMG will also develop a revised schedule of AFPI fees, which are designed to recover the
carrying costs of new capacity.
Report Preparation and Presentation
A report will be prepared which will outline the above referenced tasks and provide the basis for
the. determination of the fees. This task will also include preparation of a briefing document to
summarize the study results and a draft fee schedule for Impact Fee Ordinance preparation as
needed.
IRRlGA nON QUAUTY (RECLAIMED) WATER RATE STUDY
Data Compilation and Review
In order to identify the revenue requirements associated with pwvlding irrigation quality water
service, PRMG will intcrview staff members, collect specific utility cost infonnation, and
schedule field visits such that the data required to evaluate the various fecs for service can be
compiled. PRMG will prepare an information request, coincident with the rate evaluation
efforts, to obtain as much documentation as possible prior to the County staff interview process.
Five- Year Financial Forecast and Cost Allocation Analysis
PRMG will develop a five-ycar financial forecast of irrigation quality water operations. PRMG
will perform a cost allocation analysis to identify the costs of providing irrigation quality water
service. PRMG will also review existing agrcements with large users, the capital improvement
plan as identified in the District's master plan for irrigation quality water, existing fixed asset
records, staffing requirements, and other cost parameters to dcvelop a cost basis for the
allocation process. The cost allocation process will utilize the Fiscal Year 2008 as the "Test
Year" for the determination of irrigation quality water rates.
Design of Irrigation Quality Water Rates
PRMG will develop cost-based rates for the County's irrigation quality water system. PRMG
will work with the County staff to identify and review the irrigation quality water system cost
projections and establish the rate design parameters.
Irrigation Quality Water Rate Comparison
The proposed costs of providing services will be compared with the existing rates and with other
neighboring jurisdictions to assist the County in the evaluation of the proposed rates.
K:\1125~v\Collief COlllllylRllle Study Updlltc\PropoS<lI- Rme Study.duc B-4
~:" :y
Report Presentation and Preparation
PRMG will prepare: i) a rate study report documenting our assumptions, analyses, and primary
data sources; and ii) a briefing document (PowerPoint presentation) to summarize the study
results. This report may be incorporated into the report for the water and wastewater user rate
study. PRMG will assist the County and the Project Team's legal cOllilsel in the preparation of
any modifications to the existing irrigation quality water rate ordinance or development of a new
irrigation quality water rate ordinance in order to adopt the proposed irrigation quality water
rates and to assist in the public hearing process.
MEETINGS
During Project activities, it is anticipated that PRMG will attend up to nine (9) meetings -
including teleconference meetings - with the County, including the presentation of study results
to the County Manager, the County's Productivity Committee, the Developmental Services
Advisory Committee and the Board of County Commissioners. Attendance of these meetings
will be by not more than two (2) employees of PRMG; the attendance of any additional meetings
will be considered as an additional service. Based on PRMG current billing rates and eight hours
of billabie time for the principal and project manager, the cost of an additional meeting would be
$ 1.880.
COUNTY STAFF ASSISTANCE
As with any major study performed for a public utility, the utility staff will be called upon to
provide assistance to PRMG in order to complete the engagement on a timely basis. The
following is a list of the activities anticipated to be perfonned by the staff of the County:
I. Gathering of specific customer, operational, and financial data and infonnation relative to
the Project.
2. Performing certain analyses relative to the compiling of data if not in a usable format in
general records and reports of the District.
3. Providing assistance in the fonnulation of policy decisions relative to cost or need
determination, cost allocation and rate design. An example would include rate-phasing
alternatives, capital improvements project prioritization, etc.
4. Providing assistance in public relations program, scheduling of the Board of County
Commissioners meetings, and communication of the "political" aspects of the Project.
5. Perfonning a general review and providing comments relative to the results of our analyses
and reports to the District.
6. Assistance by the District's legal counsel in the development of the user rate and impact
fee ordinance.
K:\1125\jvIColher Counry\Rale Study update\l'ropo~al - Rale Study,doc B-5
).:,-1en::;:;: Item i'k
::.'r",.=,'
1~iC4
.J'..,'
ADDITIONAL SERVICES
During the course of the study, the District may request additional services relative to the
performance of the water and wastewater user rate study or impact fee study from PRMG. Such
services will not be conducted until authorized by the District as mutually agreed between the
District and PRMG. All invoices for additional services will be billed to the District based on
the hourly rate schedule of PRMG staff as identified in this Proposal or some other basis as
mutually agreed between the District and PRMG. Although no additional services are
anticipated for this engagement, examples of additional services may include, but shall not be
limited to, the following:
I. Attendance of meetings ~ including teleconference meetings - with District staff, District
committees or intcrested parties, or public hcarings with the Board of County
Commissioners in addition to what is contemplated in the scope of services.
2. PRMG's having to analyze raw customer billing data or incomplete data in order to
develop the hill frequency analyses.
.J. The derivation of additional rate design alternatives kyond what is contemplated in the
scope of services,
4. Delays in the Project schedule, which may have Impacts on analyses performed, and which
would affect the budget for the scope of services rei1ected herein.
5. The preparatlOn of a bond feasibility report or capllal financing plan in support of
additional debt which may be contemplated by the County for the purpose of financing the
District's capital improvement program.
To the extcnt additional services are performed by PRMG for this Project but the total cost of the
study, including the additional serviccs, does not exceed the budgeted cost of the study, no
additional services would be billed to the County.
K:\ll ::S\ivICullier Counly\Rate Study Updale\Proposa] - Rate Srudy,doc B-6
..:::. - ~ "
",
Q; ~"
~'~
::-(1)
.::':'>
~ ::>
ifz
g'
"
.~
"
~
"
5
:;;
.
E
~
,
in
.
;;
'"
-
~
.
"
~
"I E
0-
, .
~I'E
~IC::
~!.;
c: ";'
r
~l.:
<:1 l:
,-
't1"C
C, C
"I .
~ .
~I]
,or.
.
.
'"
"
-
c
\)
'2
,
c
"
-
~
'0
"
~ ~
c:S
0: -
~
.
.
"'
.
"
~
c
.
-
.
..
::;
"
S
o
,..
- "
,~ ~
G<
'"
E
"
~ ~
[/) g
'.J
"
c
i
:~
u
'"
~ 201
::l
o
o
~
~
~
o
o
~
00
~
o
o
~
v,
,..,
-
:t:
~
~
.
'"
"
:a
i5
u
.
"F
'"
~~~;?,O'>~~oooo~~
~
'-D~~~OO~
\O\C;=;:::;;
'<t~,...., \C.
\0":--' N r-, \l:i 00
"
"
~
..
c
<
'"
:0
"
:-
or.
!'l
~
~
u u
C .
~ ,- ~ ~
g. '" ~ ~ E
J: a ~ < ~
~ -<t ~ g
mil>", ~ i::
o~ ]~~ 2
... 0:: -< ~::l C
~ OJ ~'g. ~ <U
g- '" ;a ~::l ,~~
c"? g OJ ~ '" .~
u~'" ~~~ ~~
".: "iij .~ c _ 0 --'
r U ~ ~ . ~.
.~ :~ ,~~ ~ ~ ~ II> ~ 0:
] ~ a! ~] ~ .~ ~ 11
~ E t ~ '" ~ 5 '5 ]- '" ~
.g 0 E 5 .~ ~ u 2"" 0 ~ $!
~~~~a~~~~~~
ti..U a l.IJ 0.. 0..1- ~.;:! <U 0..
E-;;-c Qlj_..E~ ~ r::3: ~
<3 ,g ~ .~ 8 ] G <I! ~ ~
o::.s~"'U6.a::zoo
iO .~ e ~ 'o:l c<l c '" '" 'o:l c..
c:::r:c...oo::uW:;z:oi$~
~
;;;
or.
:0
"
'"
,..
-<
"
'"
,..
or.
-<
"
:0
Z
-<
'"
'"
-
"
"
N.... '<t or\ '-D r--:>c. 0' Co
~
N
"
~
..
c
<
~
~,
"
,
c
~
S
B
~
c
,0
~
.
u
c
.
.
B
<'
~
o
"
~
.
o
.
:1
u
.
0'
,t
::
00
~
~;2~
~O~
"'~
~ ~
00
~~
~
NO
~~
'"
N
n
I
1';;2 ~
of
"
.E
c
,9
"
;;
~
~
~
"
.
~
o
~
.
"
'"
" "
",8 :5
:::l C .:ii
0"' ~
:;:.5'E
i:: u 0
,.,,-,<I!:I:
o " .
~ 6 ~
~ ~ ?:
,..,..<
.~
"
.
:1
:;
"-
.s
"
u
B
<'
e,
:::~:=
88
~
~
~
~
~
"
o
"
~
6
.
" u
. Iii
6 ~ ~
... ~~
o ~ '"
"'u.
~ t:' g
;; Ol.l,.t;-
~ ~ g ~
..2~~~
<'
r-OC~~Nj::j
000
00:;
~N ..,
u
.
4
8
u
~
'"
2
Jj
]
E
"
~
'0
'"
..
.
E
'"
c
"
'"
.g
.
u
c
.
.
B
<'
~
o
.
~
,
'"
. 0
" 0
- .
~ :::;
u~
~ ~
~ "
0-
u:1
o
~
~
N
o
o
o
'"
~
~
G
"
o
"
u,
~
o
in
.
..
'"
-
.
:S
-
.
..
"
"'
.
"
'"
c
.
-
~
.
"
u
e
6
1!
6
-
oS
.
u
c
.
,
oS
<'
S
o
,..
~
"
~
.
..
-E
.::J
..
'0
...
~,
N
~
n
~
'-
z.v
rr. .....
G.oe:.-
-:;,
<
u
~
"
~
:;
~
~I'~
, .
~ -
o "
;;~
0'
"I",
~I g;,
'~i :;;
."'1' =~
:; '=
~I.
~i.EI
]1']1'
~ -
] "Ei
='"
= ~
Q::::;
" "
o .
'"
.
.-
-5~
w~
~
o .
.:..Jc::::
"
,~
~.
5
o
U
"
.
.,
U
t' ~
0:0
"
'" "
;;
~
.
:::
"
=
V5
~
.
'"
"
.
;;
"
:1
"
. ,I
:3 il
""fi E
'0 "
. <
U~
c
~._ .':1
~ ]
(J] '~.
I
II
.~
-
u
<
"
"
'0
f-
o
o
.,.;
~
~
;Q
~
v,
"
.::
~
.
.
.
'"
~
"
"
.
"
'"
'<1'~NO''<1"'<tC
NN VN"T
~
<.c -;t OC, cG <.1:' ~ 'C
N _,
~ r~...,. oc 01:' 0':
;.
"
;0
...
~
"'
"'
c.
.
-
..
" E
~, ~
'u 0
a. c::. Q)
. .
-g ~ 1; "--.~
~<g 5E~
OJ "'0 V 2; -<( :;;
.;;: ~ .!:! l5.."'2 d.>
~~~~E;;~
"'0 I>/)U:;,~ = ~.
g J::...... ;:; <<: u ;;
~ :; ~ ~ 5.:: 5
g~~5j~'~
~'o~U'oE[
g- <5 '- ~ 5::: :.:
o '= ..... - 0 0....
U ~ ~ g ] .~ 3
~ --;;; ':;' C. <<l '" c...
cLt&E&C~
"
~
'"
~
N
W
...
<:
::
"'
-
~
~
:::
"
<:
"
"'
-
<:
"
~~;:.~~g...-.
;;;
-,
0;
=
~
..
:3
~
o
0'
.
u
o
!i
E
<:
g
"
~
"
"
:E
u
!
0'
-,
00
~
~8~
NO-vi
MO
N ~
00
ON
.....~
:>
I~ ~
I M
I ~
"'
Is ~I
I v,1
"
~
o
E
."
"
~
~
~
.
"3
l
~
~
.
:E
.
;;
'"
"' ~
o 0
.':..i;=
~ (5 en
~-g2:'
...l 5
,!t ~ ~
o " .
~ 5 ~
-;c (;j t
~~<
c::
o
~
u
E
"
;;:
;J,,..-, ~
~
~
"'
o
"
j
~
i ~
- r; ~
5 l::JB
'5~<
u... u OJ
~ C g
;; ~ ~~
::: ......
..2;:i a:; r:
:;:Gr-f-
~~~;;r"'l"~
o~
O=~
= = 0
0,'" "<t
w'
co
c
u
u
.
-'5
"
,;;
1
i
'5
]
Wi
=
'"
"
~
.
"
"
"
E
"
.
"'
"
~
"
'"
'" '"
. =
~' 3
. -
..::: ;;
'..1=
>, ~
D.. .~
0::E
~
o
o
N
o
o
o
,;
N
~
o
"
-,
]
rn
.
.::
"
.
"-
~
"
.
;;
.
~
.
"
"
o
.
"
.
.
"
"
....
II
rs
.5
o
"
o
"
"
;;
~
.:1
"
C
f-
.
u
o
.
.
E
<:
'jj
o
-
-,
~
~
~
>
- ~\
J;
'-17
l'
""
- ,;"
w
o
~
:(
-,
;;
E
~
o
:.=
"
.-;1 E
~I=
~,-
01 ~
~I=
~j~
d";
~: ;1
0:-:::
-, .
;!~
~I~I
;;1 .
~ >
-01"01
~! =1
O~
o
o "
.",
"'-
. 0
o .
"'
~.5.
.
c
.= ~
- 0
~v.;
. "
o ;;
W",
o .
" "
;:;5
'" "
;;
E
;;
"
"
C
.
;;
.
~
f'
5
,0
~
~
'0
w
"
o
in
"
;;
'"
"
;;
"
~ ~I
.
.,
o
~
"B ~
c-a
-" '"
W"
c
c !:l
~~
(1:' '3
W
i
~
.f;
<
~
~
~
~
c
c
::;j
~
<7,
v,
"
i;
~
.
"
;;
'"
~
0;
"
.'"
o
.
'"
o::r 00 000-. 00
NOI"'l "<t
~
\0 ~;;;,
~ N
'"
~
'"
-
;l
'"
'"
-
:.,
"
~
;;
-<
.2
1'i
.9
'< ~ ~
13 ~ ~ ~
~.., E 52
g ~ c5 ~
:l: .... ~ II) :'A
.~ ~ .f' ~ ~_~
~ ~ re ...
"E~o~]
0: ""ffi g?: _
(:: u ._ >-, 0
~~.~~'E
:-=u:EO'O~
'" - 0
5 ~ '0 go:
u>;- &,';J 1::
~ ~ ~ .~ ~
Cll.i: 0 E:o:::
w
-
~
:2
...l
W
~
>-
f-
::J
'"
'"
0'
Z
2
-
'"
:.=
"
::
...-,I.Cr-oco-,
"<t'<t'<T"l"'<t
N
00 ~
'"
~
N
'"
o
o
~
.,
9
~
o
"-
o
u
o
.
.
.9
;;:
c
.
c
"
""
.
c
.
:!;
.-g,
o
i:
~
~
ro
~
ro _ ~
~~~
N N.-.:i
ro ~
N ~
00
v
~ v
'"
~
~
~~
00
'"
~
N
,
i-.:;l 0
,~ c
I ~
"
E
c
2
e
.
'"
~
~
o
"
o
u
2-
g:,
.i
"'
...
o
~
.
;;
'"
. ""
3~
06
~ -g-t'
...l 0
.9
'E u
'- .
o "
c': 6 ~
~
.
>
'"
'~
.2
;;:
~~
f-f-
c
~
N ~,
V)lf",Lr1
00000-.
0;;; 8.~ N
~
~
~I
~
~
w
u
~
:5
.
u
. C
..c; ~ ~
o "" 0
el:<
"'w.
1:! (:' 2;
; v"::;-
::; :: ~ ~
~~~2
'"
:;:,~::;9, [;:;::: ~
u
0;
,i
o
u
U
~
g
.'!
]
E
.
~
"
..
.
E
"'
o
'iO
"
~
u
u
o
.
.
.9
;;:
~
c
.
~
"
Ul
. .
. 0
"" c
" .
. -
~ .
u=
~ ~
'" .
0-
(.;;2
~
N
~.
.
.
o
U
o
~
is
~
o
<2
~
c
.
"
.9
;;:
'"
o
f-
o
~
o
o
o
.;
~
o
o
o
..;
:::
~
~
~
"
o
ii.
"
;;
'"
lJ
u
U
;;
"
'0
"
E
.;;
."
~
,~
;;
o
0'
c
o
"'
.
~
~
,
o
W
]
.
~
.:J
..
:;
~
'"
:;
'"
f-
~
...l
...l
'"
f-
~
o
u
o
'"
f-
;S
='
f-
~
'"
...l
<
f-
o
f-
-
;;
0'
~
=:; t.......
"'-::>
::>::>
;:, r~)~, L."')
~ ~I''''' r-
::::0 ~ Q
:i"~ .,.. CO
Z -, L."") ~
wN::>
Cl f'.. t....,
.!!!,6!'-
..'2' 0 ~ "0
,-. ~ :.... 0 -
~ ,,'Q.. C""') ro I
J! _ r--.
< CtS -
=""'"
0.0
",0
(.)~
~
'"
.:';
"
Sf
-
"'::'"
~
=
=
.s
t!i
ro
2:
c-
o
=>
N
~
:;
N
1::
o
~
o
N
S'
~
~
0>
o
o
N
'"
o
1:
~
0"
':?
o
~
o
o
"
5
':?
o
I
I
I I
I~
! I
I
I
"
o
:::::
~
o
~
o
"t
o
'"
5
N
5
~
o
"t
o
I., :;;
'1'r-fHj. ,I
1C1P-- -, .~
U :;;1 I I ..."
g~
= N
g
o
..;
o
;;;
'"
~
1~~~d5
c '" .... ..,. <lJ -
If.~~~:~
t~~~'~~
= .;: ~ g "E f2
.z:t~VO~
~.~~~]~
~ ~ ~ :;; -: i
~ ::,; <lJ .-: = '"
JUW
~~]~~~
I!:;:: ... ~ :; 0:; ,0
,:;.: t; ';; ~:;
'HUH
'JHHf
- " :.,. - -
'" IT,"::;::';:"" '"
,HH~H
n milt!
-, ~~~.g'~~ ~
~H~~n~
'HUl!!
c::: <:;:,)..::.: y -;::!i
-' ~.... r-.i
':'
o
~
~
o
;;;
o
<..l
o
m
~
..;
N
N
~
o
~
~
.;
:;:
~-
, i
Ul
Cl>
~
~ >- ~
Cl> '"
~ C. 'C
~ ~ c.
3 Cl> ~ ~
~ ~ ~
Cl> .2i ~ III
~ s: ~ Ul
~ Ul Cl>
s: ~ Cl>
s: 0' ~ Cl>
.... ~ ...
, M s: ,
z '" ,
N , '"
w 0 0 M , 0
> , 0 .. ,
'" ,
w 0 '" , 0 '"
'" , 0
, 0 '"
'" , 0 ,
'" '" , 0 '"
'" '" , ....
,. .... .... '" '" 0
S! M .... '" ...
, M ....
- .... , M M ~
... .... ~
'" , ... ~ ...
Z J: :i: '\' ,
... "
" " J: , :;:
~ ~ " J:
<..l Cl> ~ " '"
(Jl 'C Cl> ~ ~ c.
.~ ~ 'C Cl> Cl> ~
0 0 ~ 'C
0 ~ 'C Cl>
a: '" 0 ~ 'C ~
~ '" 0 ~ e
0 (; '" '" 0 ,
s: ~
s: 0 ~ '" ~
s: 0 ~ .
s: 0 '"
s: c
0
U
<
o
g:
'"
N
~
o
~
~
.;
~
;;;
:CBiT: l\Jo. /i 6=)
i\iove;llDS; 27, 20[;
1 ~f 2
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation that the Board of County Commissioners approves, and authorizes it's
Chairman to sign an Amended Sub recipient Agreement providing Home Investment Partnership
Program (HOME) funding in the amount of $320,000 to the Collier County Housing Development
Corporation (CCHDC).
OBJECTIVE: To approve an amended suhrecipient agreement requesting a change in the timeline as
reflected below.
Previous:
Milestone
Project Start Date
Interim Milestones/ Deadlines (list below):
Close on Land .
Infrastructure Work Begins
Construction of 3 Buildings
Construction of 3 Buildings
Construction of 3 Buildings
All Units CiO
All Affordable Units Occupied by Qualified Buyers
100% Project Completion Date
Deadline
12/1/05
1/31/06
5/30/06
8/31/06
11/30/06
2/28/07
3/31/07
5/31/07
5/30/07
-
Revised:
Milestone
All Units C/O
All Affordable Units Occupied by Qualified Buyers
100% Project Completion Date
Deadline
I 1/30/09
12/31/09
12/31/09
HOME funding was utilized for the land acquisition of approximately 10 acres in Collier County on
which a mixed income condominium development will be built. The nonprofit development partner
was given $320,000 including developer's fee of $30,000 in HOME flUlds to acquire land for tl1e
construction with their for profit paJiner to build 108 units of which 32 will be affordable home
ownership units.
CONSIDERAnONS: The Collier County Housing & Human Services Department proposes to
provide an amended agreement to allow for adjustments in the timeline for permitting, financing and
construction of the 108 unit complcx. This grant was provided as CHDO Set-Aside for land
acquisition with a Developers Fee, which is a mandated category addressed in Code of Federal
Regulation CFR 992.300.
The Board of County Commissioners approved HOME CHDO set-aside of $320,000 on April ] 7,
2005 via Resolution 2005-157 when the Board adopted the One-Year Action Plan for FY 2005-2006.
,--
FISCAL IMPACT: This amended agreement does not change the amount of the grant. No general
fllilds or ad valorum dollars were utilized in this project.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: This grant will result in the construction of new affordable
housing units in accordance with the Housing Element of the Growth Management Plan.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: The proposed Amended Agreement is a standard HUD/Home
Investment Partnership Program (HOME) subrecipient agreement fOffil in use in Collier County since
2001. JAK
RECOMMENDATION: To approve all amended Subrecipient Agreement with Collier County
Housing De\'elopment Corporation (CCHDC) to extend the timeline for the development of Cirrus
Pointe.
Prepared by: Rosa Munoz, Grants Management Coordinator
Housing and Human Services Depaliment
~\;~::n::':;0 i(::';:1; ','>i'::: ",
f"C' '-::::"(1,):';' :27 2:1(;7
:: ']1 ='i
AMENDED AGREEMENT #1
BETWEEN
COLLIER COUNTY
AND
COLLIER COUNTY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION
Catalogue of Federal Domestic Assistance #14,239
HUD Grant # M.05.UC.12.0017
THIS AMENDED AGREEMENT MADE by and between Collier County, a political subdivision of the State of Fiorida,
hereinafter referred to as the "COUNTY", and The Collier County HouslnQ Development Corporation, a private
nonprofit corporation existing under the laws of the State of Fiorida, having it's principal office at 4779 Enterprise.
Avenue, Naples, FL 34104, .and it's Federal Tax Identification Number as 38.3695928, hereinafter referred to as the
"AWARDEE", collectively the "Parties", effective July 1, 2007,
WITNESSETH
WHEREAS, the COUNTY is the recipient of HOME Investment Partnerships Program Funds from the U.S. Department of
Housing and Urban Deveiopment (HUD), including funds that are reserved for the use of Community Housing
Development Organizations (CHDOs); and
WHEREAS, the AWARDEE has been certified with the COUNTY as a CHDO, and has submitted a proposal for use of
CHDO funds for a CHDO-eligible project under HOME regulations;
NOW, THEREFORE in consideration of the mutual covenants and obligations herein contained, including the
Attachments, and subject to the terms and conditions hereinafter stated, the parties hereto understand and agree as
follows:
Section I - Definitions
A. AGENCY. is hereby defined as the Housinq and Human Services Department (HHS), the HOME administering
agency for Collier County. For the purpose of this Amended Agreement and all administration of HOME funds,
the AGENCY shall act on behalf of the COUNTY in the execution and fiscal and programmatic control of this
amended agreement. The term "Approval by the COUNTY" or like term used in this Amended Agreement shall in
no way relieve the AWARDEE from any duties or responsibilities under the terms of this Amended Agreement, or-
obligation State or local law or regulation,
B. DIRECTOR. is hereby defined as the Director of Housino and Human Services Department (HHS) of the County.
C. FEE. is hereby defined as the amount of money the COUNTY agrees to pay and the AWARDEE agrees to
accept as reimbursement in full for all the professional, technical and construction services rendered pursuant to
this Amended Agreement to complete the WORK as further defined in Section 111- SCOPE OF WORK, hereof.
D. WORK. is hereby defined as all the professional, technical and construction services to be rendered or provided
by the AWARDEE as described here.
E. PROJECT. is defined in Section IV below.
Cirrus Pointe Land Acquisition
Amended 2005 CHDO Agreement
Page 1 of 18
'.'",.:.,'
"
F. HOME - is hereby defined as the HOME Investment Partnerships Program as described in 24 CFR Part 92, under
the authority of 42 U.S.C. 3535 (d) and 12701.12839.
Section 11- Term
The AWARDEE expressly agrees to complete all work required by this amended agreement in accordance wrth the
amended timetable set forth.
Milestone Deadline
All Units C/O 11/30/09
All Affordable Units Occupied bv Qualified Buvers 12/31/09
100% Proiect Completion Date I 12/31/09
*Note: This schedule is contingent on acceptable sales of the market units. Acceptable sales means
sufficient market units sold to cover the debt coveraae shortfall created bv the affordable units.
In addition, this project is subject to ongoing compliance requirements of HOME for .2- years from the date of initial.
occupancy. During this compliance period, the AWARDEE will assure continued compliance with HOME requirements.
For homebuyer units this includes monitoring units for principal residency and recapture of funds at time of resale. For
rental units, this includes ongoing property standards, occupancy and rent limits compliance.
Timely completion of the work specified in this amended agreement is an integral and essential part of pertormance. The
expenditure of HOM" funds is subject to rederal deadiines and couid result in the loss of the ::ederal funds. By the
acceptance and execution of this amended agreement, it is understood and agreed by the AWARD"" tnat the PROJ"CT
will be completed as expeditiously as possible and that the AWARD"" will make every effort to ensure tnat the project
will proceed and will not be deiayed. railure to meet these deadiines can result in cancellation of this contract and the
revocation of HOM" funas.
Since it is mutually agreed that time is of the essence as regards to this amended agreement, the AWARDEE shall cause
appropriate provisions to be inserted in all contracts or subcontracts relative to the work tasks required by tnis amended
agreement, in order to ensure that the PROJECT will be completed according to the amended timetable set forth. It is
intended that such provisions inserted in any subcontracts be, to the fullest extent permitted by law and equity, binding for
the benefit of the COUNTY and enforceable by the COUNTY against the AWARDEE and its successors and assigns to
the project or any part thereof or any interest therein.
In the event the AWARDEE is unable to meet the above schedule or complete the above services because of delays
resulting from Acts of God, untimely review and approval by the COUNTY and other governmental authorities having
jurisdiction over the PROJECT, or other delays that are not caused by the AWARDEE, the COUNTY shall grant a
reasonable extension of time for completion of the WORK. It shall be the responsibility of the AWARDEE to notify the
COUNTY promptly in writing whenever a delay is anticipated or experienced, and to inform the COUNTY of all facts and
details related to the delay.
Section III - Scope of Work
The AWARDEE, in close coordination with the COUNTY, shall pertorm all professional services (the 'WORK") necessary
to complete the development and occupancy of the following project in full compliance with the terms of this Amended
Agreement:
Land Acquisition of aooroximatelv 10 acres in Collier County on which a mixed income condominium development
will be built. The development shall consist of 108 owner-occupied units of which at least 10 units will be sold to and
Cirrus Pointe Land Acquisition
Amended 2005 CHDO Agreement
Page 2 of 1 8
!l'.;::it :~C
~ ''31T::J8' _ '=:CiC
E)] ::
occupied bv households at or below 50% of the area median income as established bv the U.S. Department of
Housinq and Urban Development and at least an additional 22 units will be sold to and occupied bv households at or
below 60% of the area median income as established bv the U.S. Department of Housino and Urban Development.
It is understood that the AWARDEE will provide a specific working budget and realistic timetable as relates to:
acquisition, construction/rehabilitation, soft costs, development fees and other allowable costs/activities prior to any fund
usage. Said budget shall identify all sources and uses of funds, and allocate HOME and non. HOME funds to activities or
line items.
The aforementioned Work tasks will be performed in essentially the manner proposed in the AWARDEE's proposal
as received by the AGENCY on Mav 27. 2005. The aforementioned document will be considered to be a part and
portion of this amended agreement for reference.
Section IV - Reimbursement of Expenses & Developer Fees
A Project expenses (excluding developer fee) shall be paid based on vouchers for actual expenses incurred or paid,
not to exceed Three Hundred and Twentv Thousand Dollars $320.000.00. Requests tor reimbursement must be
submitted by the AWARDEE on forms specified by the COUNTY (attachment "8"), with adequate and proper
documentation of eligible costs incurred in compliance with 92.206 and necessary for HUD IDIS disbursement
re~uirements. All such expenses shall be in conformance to the approved project budget. Budget revision and
approval shall be required prior to reimbursenent of any expenses not conforming to the approved project budget.
B. The COUNTY shall pay the AWARDEE, as maximum compensation or FEE for the developer services required
pursuant to the Scope of Work thereot Thirtv Thousand dollars ($30.000.00) of HOME Funds. Progress
payments of FEES (if applicable) will not exceed the foliowing cumulative maximum percentages of total developer
fee at the following stages of project completion:
Milestone Max. Cumulative
Developer Fee %
Acquisition closing 25%
Construction closing / start of construction or rehab 40%
50% construcIion completion 60%
Construction completion (certificate of occupancy) 75%
Sustaining occupancy (or sale) & completion report 100%
:
If multiple projects or buildings are involved, the developer fee may be pro-rated to each building or project, and
the applicable percentage may be applied to each.
Cirrus Pointe Land Acquisition
Amended 2005 CHDO Agreement
Page 3 of 18
._, ,- i:::;::;;:"~;-'; "C
?:--,lD:';-! _ '
C. The COUNTY reserves the right to inspect records and project sites to determine that reimbursement and
compensation requests are reasonable, The COUNTY also reserves the right to hold reimbursement until
adequate documentation has been provided and reviewed,
D. The AWARDEE may submit a final invoice upon completion, Final reimbursement shall be made after the
COUNTY has determined that all services have been rendered, files and documentation delivered, and units have
been placed in service in full compliance with HOME regulations, including submission of a completion report and
documentation of eligible occupancy, property standards and long.term use restrictions.
E. COMPENSATION: The County shall pay the AWARDEE for the performance of this Amended Agreement upon
completion or partial completion of the work tasks as accepted and approved by HHS pursuant to the submittal of
monthly progress reports as identified in Section XVII. Reimbursements shall be made to the AWARDEE when
requested as work progresses, but not more frequently than once per month, Adherence to the work schedule
identified in Section II will be required, unless modified in writing by the parties. Reimbursement will be made upon
receipt of a proper invoice and in compliance with Section 218,70, Fla, Stats., otherwise known as the "Florida
Prompt Payment Act".
F. The COUNTYshali have the right to review and audit all'records of the AWARDEE pertaining to any
reimbursement by the COUNTY, Said records shall be maintained for a period of five years after completion.
Section V - Project Requirements
The AWAr!D== agrees 10 comply witn all reoUlrements of the HOI~= Program as stared In 24 CFr! Part 92, including
but not limited to the follOWing,
A. I~o HOME project funds will be advanced, and no costs can De incurred, until the COUNTY has conducred an
environmental review of the proposed project site as required under 24 CFR Part 58, The environmental
review may result in a decision to proceed with, modify or cancel the project.
Notwithstanding any provision of this Amended Agreement, the parties hereto agree and acknowledge that this
Amended Agreement does not constitute a commitment of funds or site approval, and that such commitment of
funds or approval may occur only upon satisfactory completion of environmental review and receipt by the
COUNTY of a release of funds from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development under 24 CFR Part
S58.
Further, the AWARDEE will not undertake or commit any funds to physical or choice-limiting actions, including
property acquisition, demolition, movement, rehabilitation, conversion, repair or construction prior to the
environmental clearance, and must indicate that the violation of this provision may result in the denial of any funds _
under the amended agreement.
B. The HOME funds reimbursed to the PROJECT will be secured by a note and mortgage, and in the case of a rental
project, a deed covenant as required by 24 CFR Part 92,
C. The AWARDEE will ensure that any expenditure of HOME funds will be in compliance with the requirements at
92.206, and acknowledges that HOME funds will only be provided as reimbursement for eligible costs incurred,
including actual expenditures or invoices for work completed.
D. If the project is to be owner'occupied, the AWARDEE will ensure that all HOME assisted units will be in
compliance with 24 CFR 92.254, including documenting that the property is eligibie under 92,254(a)(1) - (2), and
will maintain compliance during the minimum compliance period, (If the property also contains a rental unit
Cirrus Pointe Land Acquisition
Amended 2005 CHDO Agreement
Page 4 of 18
ItefT; 'J:..J
t'nvsnc;Ds::27 "::"J'~I
7 .::}-f
assisted with HOME funds, the AWARDEE will ensure that occupancy complies with the requirements of
92.254(a)(6).) If the project Is to be rental, the AWARDEE will ensure that that project is eligible under 92.214,
and that It will meet the applicable standards of 24 CFR 92.252 - 253 at occupancy and for the minimum
compliance period.
E. The designated HOME.asslsted units of this PROJECT will meel the affordabillty requirements as found in 24 CFR
92.252 (rental) or 92.254 (owner-occupied) as applicable. The AWARDEE shall collect and maintain Project
beneficiary information pertaining to household size, income levels, anticipated household income, racial
characteristics, and the presence of Female Headed Households in order to determine low and moderate.income
benefit in a cumulative and individual manner through a process approved by the AGENCY. Income
documentation shall be in a form consistent with HOME requirements as stated in the HUD Technical Guide for
Determinino Income and Allowances Under the HOME Proaram.
F. In the selection of occupants for PROJECT units, the AWARDEE shall comply with all non-discrimination
requirements of 24 CFR 92.350. If the project consists. of 5 or more units, the AWARDEE will implement
affirmative marketing procedures as required by 24 CFR 92:351. Such procedures are subject to approval of the
AGENCY.
G. If the PROJECT is occupied at the time of this commitment, the AWARDEE will comply with the relocation
requirements of 24 CFR 92.353.
H. The AWARDEE shall assure compliance with 24 CPR 92.251 as relates to Property Standards and Housing
Quality Standards (HOS), Accessibility Standards under 24 CPR 92.251(a)(3) as applicable, and Lead Based
Paint Requirements as found In 24 CFR 92.355 and 24 CPR Part 35.
I. If the PROJECT is to be owner.occupied, the AWARDEE shall assure that any NOTES and MORTGAG"S
recorded lor homebuyers shall be in compliance with 24 CPR 92.254 and that the AWARDEE will monitor each
unit for principal residency (under 92.254(a)(3)) and resale/recapture (under 92.254 ,a)(4) - (5)).
J. The AWARDEE will provide any documentation required by the AGENCY regarding match as may be required to
document match for purposes of the HOME program.
K. If any project under this amended agreement involves the construction or rehabilitation of 12 or more HOME-
assisted units, the AWARDEE shall comply with the provisions of the Davis.Bacon Act (40 U.S.C. 276 a to a. 7)
as supplemented by Department of Labor regulations (29 CFR, Part 5), as amended.
L. If the property is sold through a lease.purchase agreement, the AWARDEE will ensure compliance with
92.254(a)(7), as modified by the 1999 Appropriations Act, Section 599B.
M. The AWARDEE will be monitored by the AGENCY for compliance with the regulations of 24 CFR 92 for the
compliance period specified above. The AWARDEE will provide reports and access to project files as requested
by the COUNTY during the PROJECT and for Five (5) years after completion and closeout of the AGREEMENT.
Section VI - Repayment of Loan
A. All HOME funds are subject to repayment in the event the PROJECT does not meet the Project Requirements
as outlined above.
B. It is understood that upon the completion of the PROJECT, any HOME funds reserved but not expended
under this amended agreement will revert to the COUNTY.
Cirrus Pointe Land AcqUisition
Amended 2005 CHDO Agreement
Page 5 of 1 8
:":,~p-; \ic. A
)S:;'l::J~' _ _"
C. If the PROJECT is rental, funds will remain a deferred loan forthe period of N/A ,at which time the loan may
be forgiven or extended in the sole discretion of the COUNTY for another term. Sale of the property to another
party may occur only with the approval of the COUNTY, and the purchaser shall assume all obligations of the
AWARDEE under this amended agreement, the note and mortgage, and the deed covenants. Provisions in those
documents will provide for the extinguishment of the requirements only in the event of a third-party foreclosure or
deed in lieu of foreclosure. -Not Applicable,
D. If the PROJECT is for owner-occupancy, the AWARDEE shall lend the HOME funds to the individual buyers in an
amount sufficient to make the purchase affordable. Any HOME funds that reduce the price of the property below
the fair market value of the property shall be secured by a HOME note and mortgage as required in
92.254(a)(5)(ii), using the note and mortgage prescribed or approved by the AGENCY (and consistent with the
method of recapture identified in the COUNTY's Consolidated Plan.")
1) All net sales proceeds from the sale of units are considered to be either:
_ Program Income and must be returned to the AGENCY as repayment of the HOME loan; Q[
.L. CHDO proceeds that may be retained by the AWARDEE and used in conformance with 24 CFR
92.300(a)(2), or as specified below:
N/A
2) Prior to each closing, the AWARD:::E will provide to the AG:::NCY the estimated settlement statement. along
with a reconciliation statement and the draft note and mortgage. The reconciliation statement shall account
for the pro. ration of HOME project funds to the individual unit, and identify those funds thai are to be lent to
the buyer as "Buyer subsidies" secured by the HOME note and mongage, the pro.rated HOME development
funds that are to be forgiven as "Development subsidies". and the amount at developer fee or CHDO sales
proceeds to be reIained from settlement funds.
3) All resale proceeds that are received from buyers as they resell the properties during the compliance period
to other buyers shall be considered "Recaptured Funds" under 24 CFR 92.254(a)(5)(ii)A)(5) and must be
repaid to the COUNTY for use in eligible HOME projects as required by 24 CFR 92.503. The AWARDEE
shall promptly notify the AGENCY of such transactions and will promptly convey any Recaptured Funds to
the AGENCY.
Section VII- CHDO Provisions
It is understood that the AWARDEE has certified that it is and will maintain CHDO (Community Housing Development
Organization) status forthe term of the PROJECT/AGREEMENT in accordance with 24 CFR 92. AWARDEE agrees to-
provide information as may be requested by the AGENCY to document its continued compliance, including but not limited
to an annual board rooster and certification of continued compliance.
Any funds advanced as CHDO pre.development funds must be in compliance with 92.301, and are forgivable only under
the terms in 92.301.
Any funds advanced to the CHDO as CHDO Operating Expenses must be expended in compliance with 24 CFR 92.208,
Any funds that the CHDO is permitted to retain as CHDO proceeds from this project shall be used in compliance with 24
CFR 92.300(a)(2) or as specified in this Amended Agreement.
Cirrus Pointe Land Acquisition
Amended 2005 CHDO Agreement
Page 6 of ] 8
i ~~~ r;- hi -:-: ":':J ,--'
I ,";:,'" Si~--;~)3'- _ ~2,Xj
;::)a;lE: S~/ _
If the project is rental, the AWARDEE will create and follow a tenant participation plan as required in 24 CFR 92.303.
Section VIII- Procurement Standards
The AWARDEE shall establish procurement procedures to ensure that materials and services are obtained in a cost.
effective manner. When procuring for services to be provided under this amended agreement, the AWARDEE shall
comply at a minimum with the nonprofit procurement standards at 24 CFR 84.40 . .48.
In addition, the following requirements are imposed on any procurement under this PROJECT:
nfa
In addition, it is understood that any AWARDEE that can be considered to be a religious organization shall abide by all
portions of 24 CFR 92.257.
Section IX - Conflict of Interest Provisions
HOME conflict of interest provisions, as stated in 92.356(f), apply to the award of any contracts under the amended
agreement and the selection of tenant households to occupy HOME-assisted units. Exceptions must be requested by
the AWARDEE and the AGENCY grant exceptions as permitted by reguiation.
In addition, the COUNTY also has elected to apply the confiict of interest provisions in 24 CFR 92.356(b) - (e) to this
project. Therefore, the award of contracts and the award of any unit benefits to covered parties of the AWARDEE are
subject to prior disclosure by the AWARDEE and an exception from the COUNTY as outlined in 92.356(d} - (e).
The AWARDEE warrants and covenants that it presentty has no interest and shall not acquire any interest, directly or
indirectly, which could conflict in any manner or degree with the performance of its services hereunder. The AWARDEE
further warrants and covenants that in the performance of this contract, no person having such interest shall be
employed.
No member or Delegate to the Congress of the United States shall be permitted to any share or part of this contract or
any benefit to raise herefrom. No member, officer or employee of the COUNTY; or its designees, or agents; or member
of the Collier County Board of County Commissioners; and no other public official of the COUNTY who exercises any
functions or responsibilities with respect to the program during his tenure or for one (1) year thereafter, shall have any
interest direct or indirect, in any contract or subcontract, or the proceeds thereof, for work to be performed under this-
amended agreement.
Section X - COUNTY Responsibilities
The COUNTY shall furnish the AWARDEE with the following services and information from existing COUNTY records and
COUNTY files:
A. The COUNTY shall provide to the AWARDEE information regarding its requirements for the PROJECT.
B. The COUNTY will provide the AWARDEE with any changes in HOME regulations or program limits that affect
the project, including but not limited to income limits, property value limits and rent limits.
Cirrus Pointe Land Acquisition
Amended 2005 CHDO Agreement
Page 7 of 18
['-.i,
\" ''Y:''.::-:~_
'--, j - '
C. The COUNTY will conduct progress inspections of work completed to protect its interests as lender and
regulatory authority for the project, and will provide information to the AWARDEE regarding any progress
inspections or monitoring to assist it in ensuring compliance.
The COUNTY's review and approval of the WORK will relate only to overall compliance with the general requirements of
this Amended Agreement and HOME regulations, and all COUNTY regulations and ordinances.
Nothing contained herein shall relieve the AWARDEE of any responsibility as provided under this Amended Agreement.
Section XI - Equal Employment Opportunity
During the pertormance of this contract, the AWARDEE agrees as follows:
A. The AWARDEE will not discriminate against any employee or applicant for empioyment because of race, color,
religion, sex, or national origin(s). The AWARDEE will take affirmative action to ensure the applicants are
employed, and that employees are treated during employment, without regard to their race, color, religion, sex or
nationalorigin(s). Such action shall include, but not be limited to, the following: employment, upgrading, demotion,
or transfer, recruitment or re8ruitment advertising: layoff or termination; rates of payor other forms of
compensation; and seleclion for training. including apprenticeship. The AWARD::E agrees to post in conspicuous
places, available to employees and applicants for employment notices to be provided by the contracting officer of
the COUNTY setting forth the provisions of this nondiscrimination clause.
S. Tne AWARD:::: will, in all soilcitatlons or advertisements for employees placed by or on behalf oithe AWARD::E,
state that all qualified applicants will receive consideration tor employment without regard to race, color, religion,
sex, or national origin,
C. The AWARDEE wil, send to each labor union or representative of workers with which has a collective bargaining
agreement or other contract or understanding, a notice to be provided by the COUNTY's contracling officer,
advising the labor union or worker's representative of the AWARDEE's commitments under Section 202 of
Executive Order No. 11246 of September 24,1965, and shall post copies of the notice in conspicuous places
available to employees and applicants for employment
D. The AWARDEE will comply with all provisions of Executive Order 11246 of September 24,1965, and of the rules,
reguiations, and relevant orders of the Secretary of Labor.
E. The AWARDEE will furnish all information and reports required by Executive Order 11246 of September 24,1965,
and by the rules, regulations, and orders of the Secretary of Labor, or pursuant thereto, and will permit access to
Its books, records, and accounts by the AGENCY and the Secretary of Labor for purposes of investlgatlon to
ascertain compliance with such rules, regulations, and order.
F. In the event the AWARDEE is found to be in noncompliance with the nondiscrimination clauses of this contract or
with any of such rules, regulations or orders, this contract may be canceled, terminated or suspended in whole or
in part and the AWARDEE may be declared ineligible for further Government contracts in accordance with
procedures authorized in Executive Order 11246 of September 24, 1965, and such other sanctions may be
imposed and remedies invoked as provided in Executive Order 11246 of September 24, 1965 or by rule,
regulations, or order of the Secretary of Labor or as otherwise provided by law.
G. The AWARDEE will include the provisions of paragraphs (a) through (g) of this amended agreement in every
subcontract or purchase order unless exempted by rules, regulations, or orders of the Secretary of Labor issued
pursuant to section 204 of Executive Order 11246 of September 24, 1965, so that such provisions will be binding
Cirrus Pointe Land Acquisition
Amended 2005 CHDO Agreement
Page 8 of 18
Item !~c i ~jw
;'((Ne,Tlber' =- 2~h)
~ ~)f~'
upon each subcontractor or vendor. The AWARDEE will take such action with respect to any subcontract or
purchase order as the AGENCY may direct as a means of enforcing such provisions, including sanctions for
noncompliance; provided, however, that in the event the AWARDEE becomes involved in, or is threatened with
litigation with a subcontractor or vendor as a result of such direction by the AGENCY, the AWARDEE may request
the United States to enter into such litigation to protect the interest of the United States.
Section XII- Labor, Training & Business Opportunity
The AWARDEE agrees to comply with the federal regulations governing training, employment and business
opportunities as follows:
A. It is agreed that the WORK to be performed under this amended agreement is on a project assisted under a
program providing direct Federal financial assistance from the US Department of Housing and Urban
Development and is subject to the requirements of Section 3 of the Housing and Urban Development Act of 1968,
as amended, 12 U.S.C. 1701 u, as well as any and all applicable amendments thereto. Section 3 requires that, to
the greatest extent feasible, opportunities for training and employment be given low and moderate income
residents of the project area, and that contracts for work in connection with the project be awarded to business
concerns which are located in, or owned in substantiai part by persons residing in the project area.
B. The AWARD::E shall comply with the provisions of said Section 3 and the regulations issued pursuantthereto by
the Secretary of Housing and Urban Development set forth in 24 Code of Federal Regulations and all applicable
rules and orders of the AG::NCY of Housing and Urban Development issued thereunder as well as any and all
appiicable amendments thereto prior to the execution of this contract as well as during the term of this contract.
The AWARD:::: certifies and agrees that it is under no contractual or other disability, which would prevent it from
complying with these requirements as well as any and all applicable amendments thereto.
C. The AWARDEE will include this Section 3 clause in every subcontract for work in connection with the project and
will, at the direction of the COUNTY, take appropriate action pursuant to the subcontractor upon a finding that the
subcontractor is in violation of regulations issued by the Secretary of Housing and Urban Development, in 24 Code
of Federal Regulations. The AWARDEE will not subcontract with any subcontractor where it has notice or
knowledge that the latter has been found in violation of regulations under 24 code of Federal Regulations and will
not let any subcontract unless the subcontractor has first provided it with a preliminary statement of ability to
comply with these requirements as well as with any and all applicable amendments thereto.
D. Compliance with the provisions of Section 3, the regulations set forth in 24 Code of Federal Regulations and all
applicable rules and orders of the AGENCY of Housing and Urban Development issued thereunder prior to the
execution of the contract shall be a condition precedent to federal financial assistance being provided to the
PROJECT as well as a continuing condition, binding upon the applicant or recipient for such assistance, its_
successors, and assigns. Failure to fulfill these requirements shall subject the AWARDEE or recipient, its
contractors and subcontractors, its successors, and assigns to those sanctions specified by 24 Code of Federal
Regulations as well as with any and all applicable amendments thereto.
Section XIII - Compliance with Federal, State & Local Laws
The AWARDEE covenants and warrants that it will comply with all applicable laws, ordinances, codes, rules and
regulations of the state local and federal governments, and all amendments thereto, including, but not limited to; Title 8 of
the Civil Rights Act of 1968 PL.90.284; Executive Order 11063 on Equal Opportunity and Housing Section 3 of the
Housing and Urban Development Act of 968; Housing and Community Development Act of 1974, as well as all
requirements set forth in 24 CFR 92 of the HOME INVESTMENT PARTN::RSHIP PROGRAM. The AWARDEE
Cirrus Pointe Land Acquisition
Amended 2005 CHDO Agreement
Page 9 of 18
~ :>'
covenants and warrants that it will indemnify and hold the COUNTY forever free and harmless with respect to any and all
damages whether directly or indirectly arising out of the provisions and maintenance of this contract.
The AWARDEE agrees to comply with all applicable standards, orders, or requirements issued under section 306 of
the Clean Air Act (42 U.S.C. 1857(h)), section 508 of the Clean Water Act (33 U.S.C. 1368), Executive Order 11738,
and Environmental Protection Agency regulations (40 CFR part 15).
The AWARDEE further warrants and agrees to include or cause to be included the criteria and requirements of this
section in every non-exempt subcontract in excess of $1 00,000. The AWARDEE also agrees to take such action as the
federal, state or local government may direct to enforce aforesaid provisions.
Section XIV - Suspension & Termination
In accordance with 24 CFR 85.43, suspension or termination may occur if the AWARDEE materially fails to comply with
any term of the award, and that the award may be terminated for convenience in accordance with 24 CFR 85.44.
If, through any cause, the AWARD"E shall fail to fulfill in timely and proper manner its obligations under this contract, or if
the AWARDEE shall violate any of the covenants, agreements, or stipulations of this contract, the COUNTY shall
thereupon have the right to terminate this contract by giving written notice to the AWARD::E of such termination and
specifying the effective date thereof. at least five (5) days before the effective date of such termination. In such event, the
AWARD::E shall be entitled to receive just and equitable compensation for any work satisfactoril\' completed hereunoer
to the date of said termination. NotWithstanding the above, the AWARD::E shall not be relieved of iiability to the
COUNTY for damages sustained by the COUNTY by virtue of any Dreach ot the contract by the AWARD,,:: and the
COUNTY may withhold any reimbursements tc the AWARD"E for the purpose of setoff until such time as the exact
amount of damages due the COUNTY from the AWARD::E is determined whether by court of competent jurisdiclion or
otherwise,
Section XV - Termination for Convenience of the COUNTY
The COUNTY may terminate for its convenience this contract at any time by giving at least thirty (30) days notice in
writing to the AWARDEE. If the contract is terminated by the COUNTY, as provided herein, the COUNTY will reimburse
for any actual and approved expenses incurred, including those costs involved in terminating the contracts and shutting
down the work as of the date of notice, and the AWARDEE will be paid as a FEE an amount which bears the same ratio
to the total compensation as the services actually performed bear to the total service of the AWARDEE covered by this
contract, less reimbursements of compensation previously made. Claims and disputes between the parties will be
submitted to the American Arbitration Association for resolution. Award or judgment may be entered in any court having
jurisdiction thereof.
Section XVI - Default-Loss of Grant Funds
If the AWARDEE fails in any manner to fully perform and carry out any of the terms, covenants, and conditions of the
amended agreement, and more particularly it the AWARDEE refuses or fails to proceed with the work with such diligence
as will insure its completion within the time fixed by the schedule set forth in SECTION II of this amended agreement, the
AWARDEE shall be in default and notice in writing shall be given to the AWARDEE of such default by the AGENCY or an
agent of the AGENCY. If the AWARDEE fails to cure such default within such time as may be required by such notice,
the COUNTY, acting by and through the AGENCY, may at its option terminate and cancel the contract.
Cirrus Pointe Land Acquisition
Amended 2005 CHDO Agreement
Page ] 0 of 18
il.:::;;T: i0~ ') oJ
'\:::1\IS~Tl~'e! ..:.: ~ :'::']:i
P3;"12 ',~~, O':?
In the event of such termination, all grant funds awarded to the AWARDEE pursuant to this amended agreement shall be
immediately revoked and any approvals related to the PROJECT shall immediately be deemed revoked and canceled. In
such event, the AWARDEE will no longer be entitled to receive any compensation for work undertaken after the date of
the termination of this amended agreement, as the grant funds will no longer be available for this project.
Such termination shall not effect or terminate any of the rights 01 the COUNTY as against the AWARDEE then existing, or
which may thereafter accrue because of such default, and the foregoing provision shall be in addition to all other rights
and remedies available to the COUNTY under the law and the note and mortgage (if in effect), including but not limited to
compelling the AWARDEE to complete the project in accordance with the terms ofthis amended agreement, in a court of
equity.
The waiver of a breach of any term, covenant or condition hereof shall not operate as a waiver of any subsequent breach
of the same or any other term, covenant, or condition hereof.
Section XVII- Reporting Responsibilities
The AWARDEE agrees to submit any and all MONTHLY reports required by HUD or the COUNTY to the AGENCY.
The AGENCY will send the AWARDEE one reminder notice if the MONTHLY report has not been received fourteen (14)
days after the due date. If the AWARDEE has not submitted a report fourteen (14) days after the date on the reminder
notice, the COUNTY will have the opticn to terminate the contract as described in this amended agreement. In addition,
the AWARDEE agrees to provide the AGENCY information as required to determine program eligibility, in meeting
national objectives, and financial records pertinent to the project. Additional reporting requirements are included as
ATTACHMENT -A,.
OUTCOME PERFORMlINCE MEASUREMENTS:
OBJECTIVE OUTCOMES ACTIVITY INDICATORS I
DECENT HOUSING Affordability through land Acquisition for Number of new
the creation of (32) new housing affordable homes built
new affordable construction (32)
housina units
Section XVIII -Inspection, Monitoring & Access to Records
The COUNTY reserves the right to inspect, monitor, and observe work and services performed by the AWARDEE at any
and all reasonable times.
The COUNTY reserves the right to audit the records of the AWARDEE any time during the performance of this Amended
Agreement and for a period of five years after final reimbursement is made under this Agreement.
If required, the AWARDEE will provide the AGENCY with a certified audit of the AWARDEE's records representing the
Fiscal Year during which the PROJECT becomes complete whenever the amount listed in SECTION VII is at or exceeds
$300,000, pursuant to the requirements of OMS Circular A-133.
Access shall be immediately granted to the COUNTY, HUD, the Comptroller General of the United States, or any ofthelr
duly authorized representatives to any books, documents, papers, and records of the AWARDEE or its contractors which
are directly pertinent to that specific contract forthe purpose of making audit, examination, excerpts, and transcriptions.
Cirrus Pointe Land Acquisition
Amended 2005 CHDO Agreement
Page 11 of 18
i~;:T :.,-:-_
.''::::;;~12: _
-):- =: ~
Section XIX - General Conditions
A. All notices or other communication which shall or may be given pursuant to this amended agreement shall be in
writing and shall be delivered by personal service, or by registered mail addressed to the other party at the
address indicated herein or as the same may be changed from time to time. Such notice shall be deemed given
on the day on which personally served; or, if by mail, on the fifth day after being posted or the date of actual
receipt, whichever is earlier.
COUNTY:
Collier County
Housing & Human Services Department
3050 North Horseshoe Drive Suite 110
Naples, FL 34104
AWARDEE:
Collier County Housing Development Corp.
4779 Enterprise Avenue
Naples, FL 34104
Attention: Kathy Patterson
B.
Title and paragraph headings are for convenient reference and are not a part of this Amended Agreement.
C.
In the event of conflict between the terms of this Amenoed Agreement and any terms or conditions contained in
any attached documents, the terms in this Amended Agreement shall rule.
D.
No waiver or breach of any provision of this Amended Agreement shall constitute a waiver of a subsequent breach
of the same or any other provision hereoL anc no waiver shall be effective unless made In writing.
The parties hereto agree that tnis Amended Agreement shall be construed and enforced according to tne laws of
the State of Florida.
, .
Should any provisions. paragraohs, sentences. words or phases contained in this Amended Agreement be
determined by a court of competent jurisdiction 10 be invalid, illegal or otherwise unenforceable under the laws of
the State of Florida or Collier County such provisions, paragraphs, sentences, words or phrases shall be deemed
modified to the extent necessary in order to conform with such laws, or if not modifiable to conform with such laws,
then same shall be deemed severable, and in either event, the remaining terms and provisions of this Amended
Agreement shall remain unmodified and in full force and effect.
G.
The AWARDEE shall compiy with the provisions of the Copeland Anti-Kick-Back Act (18 U.S.C. 874) as
supplemented in the Department of Labor Regulations (29 CFR Part 3), as amended.
H.
The AWARDEE shall comply with the provisions of sections 103 and 107 of the Contract Work Hours and Safety
Standard Act (40 U.S.C. 327-330) as supplemented by Department of Labor regulations (29 CFR, Part 5), as
amended.
I.
The AWARDEE further warrants and agrees to include or cause to be included the criteria and requirements
of paragraphs (G) through (H) of this section in every nonexempt subcontract. The AWARDEE also agrees to
take such action as the federal, state or local government may direct to enforce aforesaid provisions.
J.
The obligations undertaken by AWARDEE pursuant to this Amended Agreement shall not be delegated or
assigned to any other person or agency unless COUNTY shall first consent to the performance or assignment of
such service or any part thereof by another person or agency.
K.
The Amended Agreement shall be binding upon the parties hereto, their heirs, executors, legal representative,
successors and assigns.
Cirrus Pointe Land Acquisition
Amended 2005 CHDO Agreement
Page 12 of 18
iTf;rri
u....'
'::'~'I~!S"
r;,,",F,-,
~'~j:3~ -: :", ~)f .;... ,
L. AWARDEE shall indemnify and save COUNTY harmless from and against any negligent claims, liabilities, losses
and causes of action which may arise out of AWARDEE's activities under this Amended Agreement, including all
other acts or omissions to act on the part of AWARDEE, including any person acting for or on its behalf, and, from
and against any orders, judgments, or decrees which may be entered and from and against all costs, attorneys
fees, expenses and liabilities incurred in the defense of any such claims, or in the investigation thereof.
M. AWARDEE and its employees and agents shall be deemed to be Independent contractors, and not agents or
employees of the COUNTY, and shall not attain any rights or benefits under the civil service or pension
ordinances of the COUNTY, or any rights generally afforded classified or unclassified employee; further they shall
not be deemed entitled to state Compensation benefits as an employee of the COUNTY.
N. Funding for this Amended Agreement is contingent on the availability of funds and continued authorization for
program activities and is subject to amendment or termination due to lack of funds, or authorization, reduction
of funds, and/or change in regulations.
Cirrus Pointe Land Acquisition
Amended 2005 CHDO Agreement
Page 13 of 18
ENTIRE UNDERSTANDING
This Amended Agreement and its provisions merge any prior agreements, if any. between the parties hereto and
constitutes the entire understanding. The parties hereby acknowledge that there have been and are no
representations, warranties, covenants, or undertakings other than those expressly set forth herein.
WITNESS THEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this JJl page amended agreement to be executed by their
undersigned officials as duly authorized effective the 1" day of July, 2007.
COLLIER COUNTY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT
CORPORATION
(SUBRECIPIENT SEAL)
(Optional)
BY:
!(ATHY PATTERSON. EXECUTIVE
DIRECTOR
1."'-:-ESi:
DVvl,:J;--iT C. BRO:f:, CL::Rf<
BOARD 0= COUI'lTY COI~MISSIOI~ECiS
C;OL.LI=F: CClUI~T\/, FLORiDA
By:
SY:
Pall'i8la l'Jior~all. DepulY Clerk
,JPJvlES COL::TT,L\" CHAiRi\~AI'J
I
APprOVeqjS a/orm,!
and le9a s Ufo IC1B.nc.11
. ',' ,'\-.#'1<<,-
_'"/1/ I,
_ F\
r r "-
Jeffrey A.'.I~latzk6w
Chief Ass~tant County Attorney
I.:
\!
\
Cirrus Pointe Land Acquisition
Amended 2005 CHDO Agreement
Page 14 of 1 Ii
i181r' [\lU. ':J_j
\ \'2:.;1~j0:
..:.. .2.XJ!
Of ~
"ATTACHMENT A"
COLLIER COUNTY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION
CIRRUS POINTE
HOME MONTHLY PROGRESS REPORT
Complete form for past month and submit to Housing and Human Services staff by the 10'h
of the following month_
Status Report for Month of
Submittal Date:
Project Name HDC Cirrus Pointe
Project Number
HM05-02 & HM06
Activity Number
182 & 195
Sponsor:
,he Collier County Housino Development COrPoration
Contact Perso~-;
Kathv Patterson. E'xecutive Director
Telephone: ~39-434-2397
Fa>::
239-430-2387
E-mail:
"patte rson@collierchdc.oro
1. Activity Status/Milestones (describe any action taken, relating to this proJect, during the
past month):
2. What eventsiactions are scheduled for the next two months?
3. Describe any affirmative marketing you have implemented regarding this project.
Please list and attach any recent media coverage of your organization relating to
this project.
4. List any additional data relevant to the outcome measures listed on the application
for this project.
5. New leases executed this month (if applicable):
Cirrus Pointe Land Acquisition
Amended 2005 CHDO Agreement
Page 15 of 18
:c;: , .~;:. ',~-, I,.: - :', ,-,' ,
-:::-:1':::-'':;'
:/2'1
Name of Applicant
Security Deposit
Utility Deposit
For projects that serve a particular clientelc, pleasc complete the following infonnation by entering the
appropriate number in the blank spaces and in the chart below. Complete the below chart for NEW clients
served this month. DO NOT DUPLICATE clients served in previous months. You may provide data by
either households or persons served However, if one person received TWO services this counts as TWO
SERVICE UNITS
TOTAL BENEFICIARIES
This project benefits
"househoids" or "persons").
households or persons. Piease circle one category (either
Enter the number of beneficiaries in the blank space and in box "1.'
INCOME
Of the households or persons assisted, are extremely lOW-income income (0-30%)
of the current Median Family Income (MFI). Enter this number in box "2. ,.
Of the households or persons assisted, are very low-income (31-50%) of the current
Median Family Income (MFI). Enter this number in box "3."
Of these households or persons assisted, are low income (51-80%) of the current
Median Family Income (MFI). Enter this number in box "4."
NOTE: The total of boxes 2, 3 and 4 should equal the number in box 1.
FEMALE HEAD OF HOUSEHOLD
This project assisted
this number in box "5" below.
Female Head of Households REGARDLESS of income. Enter
BOX1 BOX2 BOX 3 BOX4 I BOX5
I
Total Number of Extremely Very I Low Income Female Head of
Households or Persons Low Income Low Income (51-80%) Household
Assisted
(0-30%) (31-50%) I
, I i
i I
Cirrus Pointe Land Acquisition
Amended 2005 CHDO Agreement
Page 16 of 18
nefT; l'\!: 'J:")
:0:y/'?::~bs~ 27 2:=jC:
;~), Q::2
Sf?Onsor must indicate total heneficiaries for Race AND Ethnicitv
Definitions of Race:
1. White: A person having origins in any of the original peoples of Europe, the Middle
East, or North Africa.
2. Black or African-American: A person having origins in any of the black racial groups of
Africa.
3. Asian: A person having origins in any of the original peoples of the Far East,
Southeast Asia, or the Indian subcontinent including, for example, Cambodia, China, India,
Japan, Korea, Malaysia, Pakistan, the Philippine Islands, Thailand, and Vietnam.
4. American Indian or Alaska Native: A person having origins in any of the original
peoples of North and South America (including Central America), and who maintains tribal
affiliation or community attachment.
5. Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander: A person having origins in any of the
original people of Hawaii, Guam, Samoa, or other Pacific Islands.
Definitions of Ethnicity:
1. Hispanic or Latino: A person of Cuban, Mexican, Puerto Rican, South or Central
American, or other Spanish culture or origin, regardless of race.
Tabulation Table of Race and Ethnicity Beneficiaries
Race
# Total
I # Hispanic
] White I
Black or African American
Asian I
American Indian or Alaskan Native I
Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander
American Indian/ Alaska Native and White
Asian and White
Black/African American and White I
American Indian/Alaskan Native and Black/African
American
Other Multi-Racial
TOTAL:
Cirrus Pointe Land Acquisition
Amended 2005 CHDO Agreement
Page 17 of 18
..;, .:...
"A TTACHMENT B"
COLLIER COUNTY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION
CIRRUS POL1\'TE
HOME CHDO REQUEST FOR PAYMENT
SECTION I: REQUEST FOR PAYMENT
Subrecipient Name: Collier Countv Housinq Development Corporation
Subrecipient Address: 4779 Enterprise Avenue. Naples. FL 34104
Project Name: HOME - CHDO - CIRRUS POINTE
Project No: HM 05-02 & 06 Payment Request #
Dollar Amount Requested: $
SECTION II: STATUS OF FUNDS
1. Grant Amount Awarded
$
320.000
2. Sum of Past Claims Paid on this Account
$
3. Total Grant Amount Awarded Less Sum
Of Past Claims Paid on this Account
4. Amount of Previous Unpaid Requests
$
$
5. Amount of Today's Request
$
6. Current Grant Balance (Initial Grant Amount Awarded
Less Sum of all requests)
$
I certify that this request for reimbursement has been drawn in accordance with the terms and
cor:J;tions of the Agreement between the County and us as the Sub-recipient. I also certffy that
the amount of the Request for Reimbursement is not in excess of current needs.
Signature
Date
Title
Authorizing Grant Coordinator
Supervisor
Dept Director
(approval authority under $14,999
(approval required $15,000 and above)
CIrrus Pointe Land Acquisition
Amended 2005 CHDO Agreement
Page 18oft8
I',lge 1 of I
COLLIER COUr>TY
SGrr.c :)F::-, ,,;
11', ":;'iC>I'!C'""
Item Number:
Item$ummary:
1-,','-""lr,-,,'''-'''',lf",'r,d:Fi' :::;':,Cdr<::
',com;y: iCiW":;"I:;npl';;,lilW'
-, nc; "';1r ~ r ';" r"
",m',,]I"
a' "n:' nJ',Ji:- "v ll"'<)' ,-,H~':r''-'''''I' "'1" ;:;C\~ 1',',,- ::C" 'I''' i
,,,(,
','e, -[AWe
C):I _," 1~)1 ;~H~
'";1",8"","r
"'''r''';
tr',
-''''e',('"11I'
'Inh
1'1'-
-'qur;
"':''''''1'PI',,'I:
1'rr:C;
::!U:-C:'Lie::, [.''o>''':''<'i
""(:,' "-'I~ !i'l':
I.-'t",'-
H ~. ,- (j Jlj
c,,21
) U"~,,~
C;:rT,'
'C'Yl11b WII! C
'I:S:
L,ClI':il: U'ILO'
W",I'" ,3~' l;IHIS WII! IJS- :<::1 'Ii~-S ~-!;I'. ";jCJlJ'B ry.::w"'" "'litE n: ell!e' ':,ClW',l-
Meeting Date:
1,."-'-i:r":i'::':"C,( ',1,,0'1
rr{'rmred B~
Re;SL l"luo~
':",r;';l;"; r',"'3f\Jp~"'''n' ::;C.Ofdil'l;:W'
~' '<'l<
Cnlllrnun,tiLJ!i''''!OIl''''''''i;.
t:nvlw'\:llf'm~1 S~'r 'Ice~
hn:-mG'''' kG"''''', & '''mU5!nt
'",'" ,','PC' [,,,1::!,Ul
Allprond n~
/o.1~r~v Knm,,-,im:'
LilrCU01
,Jill'
",;l-I':cS"rVIC',",
rw,-,',"''' I--. Hlm,,"- ~:,e"'/'cc"
" i20f;7c"(l;<r\R'
Approved R~
.wl" _071
-'a,..:.",-,;,;"''''''"
[u'
'L"\ 1',:'
Al'prond B~
-\IIJlrn,,'d B~
..\ppn'H'd B)
Appru\'l'd II)
c) C,,','\C!
;"n, ,,,-," '1:'_,,'/:::--
Appru\'('u B}
>nl'n' ,'{J'
;/"'1;1"""" -r,'.
'm',:,'
r"H
(;'''H';;'I,';W,i('f:"-)fj",,,
:'fi,,:c ,,'r, ""?(JHM
f',c'",!","
'-',i;WC~
'-'I.
ApJlI"oletl R~
r, 'c",,':" ~:"',."
nJw:>c' ",;v,'
.'1"
'>,""',- r.',',rl.l~'W" C:"t'~f'
'-',F,J
1\ "'('0'
":1U;..I'/
Approved Il~
,;,,"','-' !-i",d,;
l1!'"
[,Od'-'-' :"U'"'
::om,,,ic_<,,C'n',,,,
I,: ',0. ~u,,: ". :"",< (-
'C:;?UC7 ~ :!~ "'1:
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to approve the after-the-fact submittal of the attacbed Older Americans Act
grant application to the Area Agency on Aging to provide nutrition programming, in-home
support senices and case management for elderly residents in Collier County.
OBJECTIVE: To obtain after-the-fact approval from thc Board of County Commissioners to submit
the 2008-20 I 0 Older Americans Act grant application to the Area Agency on Aging to provide
uninterrupted support services to seniors in Collier County.
CONSIDE~<\TIONS:
For over thirty three (33) years, the Collicr County Housing and Hwnan Services DepaJ1ment, Services
for Senior's program, has been the lead agcncy in Collier County for elder services. Funding from the
Federal Older Americans Act has established a reputation of excellence in the service delivery system
provided by the Housing and Human Services. Services for Seniors program. The high quality of
service to this county's elderly is attested tn hy the excellcnt prograJmnatic and contractual monitoring
results earned hy this prograJll each year.
~
In addition. an enhancement of this agcncy's circel;vc coordination of service is demonstrated by the
high visibility and recognition within Coliicr Coum)'. Our reputation as a quality community resource
for cldcr care is demonstrated by the active role the program serves in Collier County-s community
social service network. To address the sClcial needs of scniors in the community. the depaJ1ment
proyides senior activities throughout the \\'eeh. as \\-c!! as special events such as Senior Expos. at the
Easl Naples Community Park- Scnior Annex. The dcpaJ"lment is also a pal"licipating member in the
Alzheimer's Support Group, Collier Count)' ((\uncil on Aging, TRIAD-SALT Council, and thc Naples
and Immokalee Interagency Councils. This agency is also active in slate-wide eldcr support
organizations such as the Florida Council on Aging and the Florida Association of Service Providers.
As the Lead Agency in Collier County, stafTmust make application for these funds every three years in
order to continue coordination of services and to maintain our Lead Agency status. The application
and award of this grant will ensure that serviccs for Collier's seniors continue unintelTupted through
the year 2010. The grant will run from January 1. 2008 through December 31. 2010.
This grant application was due to the Area Agency on Aging on October 26, 2007 the same day as tile
Novus Deadline. We received the application four weeks prior to its dcadline. This is an intense
application process that requires coordination of effi:lrts from several staff members of both the
programmatic and fiscal staff. There were sevcral high priority activities heing perfon11ed in the
department during the time the application was heing prepared; year-end-close and monitoring by our
grantor agency. In order for staff to ensure that the application was thoroughly reviewed and complete,
it was necessary to request review and approval of the application package by the County Manager to
be followed hy after-the-faet approval of the Board of County Commissioners.
.~
Collier County's Office of the County Manager Administrative Procedure CMA #5330 authorizes the
County Manager to approve the submittal of grant applications with subsequent Board of County
Commissioners action at the next available Board meeting to ratify the approval as "after-the-fact."
FISCAL IMPACT: The total grant amount available is approximately $800,000, however this amount
may change subject to population statistics and funding fonnulas utilized by the DepaJ1ment of Elder
Aflairs prior to the receiving an agreement. This grant requires a 10% match of in-kind and/or cash
match. The BCC has already approved S53,()00 in matching funds for these programs for FY08. The
County's budgeted match amount will be sul1icient. as thc local area in-home service providers must
also contribute matching funds to these services.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There IS no growth management impact from this
recommendation.
LEGAL CONSIDERA nONS: This request is internally consistent, complies with all applicable
laws and is legally sufficient for Board consideration and appro\'a1.
RECOMMENDATION: That the BCC approve the aftcr-the-fact submittal for a 2008-2010 Older
American Act grant.
PREPARED BY: Ten; Daniels, Accounting Supervisor, Housing and Human Services
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
HOUSING AND HUMAN SERVICES DEPARTMENT
SERVICES FOR SENIORS PROGRAM
OAA PROGRAMS
Title III-B
Nutrition Programs C-1/ C-2
Title III-E Caregiver Support Program
REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL
PROGRAM MODULE
01/01/2008 -12/31/2010
SUBMITTED OCTOBER 25, 2007
Co~r County
~ ~ -
.
OAA SERVICES PROPOSAL
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
Service Provider Summary Information
1
RESPONSE TO RFP SPECIFICATIONS
A. PROGRAM MODUL.:: FORMATS
1. Administrative In
a. Synopsis of .
b. Staffing Pia
c. Cost Efficiec
lation:
;kground and Qualifications
2-3
3-5
?Ian
5-6
2. CHent Targetir'
1d Outreach
6-7
3. Client Confid;c
illy Safeguards
S-6.::J::Jendix V.
4. Grievance pc jures/Process for i'.educing or
Termir.atin; Services S-9 ApDend:>: VI
5. Plan For Coo, "ination 9-10
6. Plan to Maintain Quality Control and Monitor Ciient Satisfaction 1 a-Appendix VII .
7. Strategies to Meet Outcome Measures / Goals Related to OAA Services 11-13
8. Service Delivery
a. Description of Service Delivery and Coordination Plan
b. Nutrition Program Special Requirements
c. Service Standards Compliance Checklists
9. New Service / New Provider Business Plan
14-26
27-36
37-46
47-48
SERVICE PROVIDER
SUMMARY INFORMATION PAGE
e.." ~
P SA:....!!-
ORIGINAL SUBMISSION [ X ]
REVISION
1. PROVIDER INFORMATION:
Marcy Krumbine, Director
Housing and Human Services Department
3301 Tamiami Trail E.
Building H, Room 211
Naples, FL 34112
239-252-2273
2. GOVERNING BOARD CHAIR:
{Name/Address/Phone
James Coletta, Chairman
3301 Tamiami Trail E.
Building F, 3Td Floor
Naples, FL 34112
Legal Name of Agency:
Collier County Board of County Commissioners
Housing and Human Services Department
Name of Grantee Agency:
Mailing Address
3301 Tamiami Trail E.
Building H, Room 211
Naples, FL 34112
3. ADVISORY COUNCIL CHAIR:
(if applicable)
{Name/Address/Phone}
Telephone Number: 1239] 252-2Z73
4. TYPE OF AGE:NCY/ORGA'~IZATION:
NOT FOR PROFIT: PRIVATE
~ PUBLIC
5. PROPOSE:D FU/\jDING PE:RIOD:
I!O 1 !2()()~-12/3l!20] ()
A. New Applicant
8. Continuation X
PRIVATE: FOR PROFIT
I 6. FUNDS REQUESTED:
[ x] OAA Title IIIB
[ x] OAA Title IIIC-1
[ x] OAA Title IIIC-2
[ xl OAA Title IIIE
[ ] OAA Title IIID
[ ] OM Title VII
[ ] OM Training
CONTRACTED SERVICES
[]ADI
[]CCE
[J CSS
[ ] EHEAEP
[ ] ELDERLY MEALS
[] LSP
USDA
[] JTPA
[] HCBS
[ ] PROJECT CARE
[] SHINE
[J USDA
[]HCE
OTHER (SPECIFY)
7. SERVICE AREA: [x] Single County Collier
[ ] Multicounty: List:
Seiected Communities of a Count .
8. ADDRESS FOR PAYMENT OF CHECKS ITEM #: x #1
9. CERTIFICATION BY AUTHORIZED AGENCY OFFICER:
I hereby certify that the contents of this document have been reviewed and approved by the Board
of Directors and are true, accurate and complete statements. I acknow dge that inte tional
misrepresentation or falsification may result in the terminatfon of finan I assistance. .
Name: Marcv Krumbine
Signature:
Title:
Director
Date:
October 25. 2007
PI
I
OAA SERVICES PROPOSAL
RESPONSE TO RFP SPECIFICA nONS
1. Administrative Information:
a. Synopsis of your business I agency's background and qualifications:
For more than thirty three (33) years, the Collier County Housing and Human Services
Department, Services for Senior's program, has been the lead agency in Collier County
for elder services. Funding from the Federal Older American's Act has established a
reputation of excellence in service delivery system provided by this agency for that period
of time. The high quality of service to this county's elderly is attested to by the excellent
programmatic and contractual monitoring results earned by this program.
Additional programs in the Housing and Human Services Department also include Social
Services, RSVP (Retired and Senior Volunteer Program), PLAN (Physicians Lead Access
Network), Affordable Housing and Federal/State Grants. As part of Collier County
Government, the department is one of several within the Public Services Division. These
departments include the University Extension Services, Domestic Animal Services,
Libra0' Department, Iv'luseum Department, Veterans Services and Parks and Recreation
Department. The Housing and Human Services Department partners with these other
sister departments to provide high quality senior servi:::es in a variety of :::ommunity
settings.
In addilion, an enhancement of this agency's effective coordination of service is
demonstrated by the high visibiiity and recognition within Collier County. Our reputation
as a quality community resource for elder care is demonstrated by the active role the
program serves in Collier County's community social service network. To address the
social needs of seniors in the community, the department provides senior activities
throughout the week, as well as special events such as Senior Expos, at the East Naples
Community Park- Senior Annex. The department is also a participating member in the
Alzheimer's Support Group, Collier County Council on Aging, TRIAD-SALT Council, and
the Naples and Immokalee Interagency Councils. This agency is also active in state-wide
elder support organizations such as the Florida Council on Aging and the Florida
Association of Service Providers.
The Collier County Board of County Commissioners consistently provides strong support
in this agency's operations and believes in our mission of improving the lives of this
county's elderly residents. Strong board support allows this agency access to financial
resources as well as support resources. The county's legal department assists with
approval of contractual documents and policies. The Finance division of the Clerk of
Courts acts as the agency's bookkeeper and auditor, allowing our fiscal office the
necessary time to monitor and track performance standards. Purchasing acts as this
agency's agent for cost savings in acquiring vendor services and products. Human
Resources ensures our ability to meet high personnel standards, which translates to
premium client care. Because of the availability of these valuable operational resources,
the grantor agency can be assured that quality and accountabiiity will always be
p~
OAA SERVICES PROPOSAL
maintained.
The Services for Seniors program has over 50 years of experience in providing case
management as well as over 15 years experience with fiscal delivery of case
management services. The philosophy of the program has been to employ individuals
who have the skills, knowledge, education, and experience to link individuals to the most
beneficial service that is also the least restrictive.
Assisting individuals to live independently has been the stalwart of the program
throughout its inception. Our services assess an individual's situation in order to
determine what is necessary to either maintain or improve his or her health, family, social,
or medical status to remain in the least restrictive setting possible. As services are
delivered the quality and quantity of the services are carefully measured to ensure
outcomes measures are consistent and on target with the Department of Elder Affairs
statewide outcome and output measures. Case managers also provide advocacy
ensuring that their best interests are upheld both by the service delivery system and the
community at large. Our services seek to assist the client in meeting or exceeding self-
sufficiency and functioning, and helping protect individuals from abuse, neglect, and
exploitation. Our case managers interact frequently with the client's caregiver or family
member ensuring quality communication is provided to coordinate care with these most
important individuals in the client's life. Finally, program integrity is maintained through
balanced caseloads of no more than 70 ciients per case manager. It is important to note
that the entire staff of Coliier County Services for Senior's meet and exceeds training and
certification requirements of the grantor agency and the Fiorida Department of Eider
Affairs. in Collier County, the focus is on providing elders with supports that enhance
their quality of life and uses resources to their maximum capacity.
b. Staffing Plan
Collier County Government Services for Senior's seek to provide services for functionally
impaired elderly persons in a community care, continuum of care service system, which is
designed to allow for Collier County seniors to age in place, with purpose, security, and
with dignity. Staff is respectful and allow for seniors to also age in an elder friendly
environment. Currently, Services for Seniors employees 8 full time employees with one
vacant position. With this in mind, the staffing pattern is described below:
The Director of the Department has a master's degree in Public Administration and has
the authority over all administrative operations of the department. This individual is
responsible for the administration of the Services for Senior's programming and lead
agency functions and ensures that it is managed in accordance with DOEA requirements.
The Director has over 11 years experience working in Collier County Government.
The organization is supported by an administrative secretary, who provides clerical and
administrative support involving preparing operational and administrative forms, reports,
records and summaries; entering data and retrieving information from department
databases; maintaining automated and manual files; and assisting callers and/or visitors.
f3
I
.it.
OAA SERVICES PROPOSAL,
The Collier County Services for Seniors employs an Accounting Supervisor, who has a
master's degree in Public Administration and performs professional and technical
accounting and financial duties for the Services for Seniors Department. The Accounting
Supervisor supervises two (2) full time employees who manage the fiscal component of
the Services for Seniors Program and who provides data entry into the Client Information
Resource Tracking System (CIRTS). Additional responsibilities include receiving invoices
for vendor's services and provide billing data to the Area Agency on Aging for payment to
the respective vendors. In addition, the Accounting Supervisor provides oversight for the
services and contribution reports that report the number of units and the amount of funds
expended to date and variance from current spending patterns. This information is
reviewed by program and fiscal staff on a regular/weekly basis to ensure appropriate
spending patterns associated with care plans are being established for both the current
individuals and new clients associated with the service. Fiscal staff communicates
information to both the Case Management Supervisor and the case managers in order to
maintain the requirements of grants associated with the lead agency responsibilities.
The Case Management Supervisor for Services for Seniors has a bachelor's degree in
Family and Consumer Sciences and is responsible for assigning new cases, managing
the wait list, an:! ensuring maximum productivity ievels are met for the four (4) Case
Managers and one (1) Grant Support Speciaiist assigned to the program. The Case
Management Supervisor a!so evaluates, reviews and monitors client assessments and
ciien! care pians to ensure that policies regarding the prioritization, determination of the
type of services, and the level of service of each client are met through arranging and
coordinating services/resources through county, state, and federal programs. The case
managers currently maintain an average client case load of 55. These caseioad sizes
fluctuate due t:J attrition a:<d funding limitations; however, to date the program staff have
been able to manage the service delivery associated with the lead agency functior.s. In
addition, the Case lvianagement Supervisor also manages referrals associated with the
Area Agency on Aging Elder Helpline, Adult Protective Services referrals and Community
Comprehensive Assessment and Review for Long Term Care Services (CARES)
referrais. The Services for Seniors program provides only case management services
and no other direct services. The Lead Agency contracts for in home services with area
home health agencies, emergency alert response vendors, and adult day care providers.
The Case Management Supervisor currently supervises four (4) full time Case Managers
who are charged with the accessing of clients needs, the development of a plan of care,
and the authorization and coordination of the services needed to meet the client's needs.
The Case Managers have a working knowledge of all programs administered by this
agency and thus are able to access and authorize other resources/services available to
eligible clients. The Case Management Supervisor also supervises a Grant Support
Specialist position which is currentiy vacant.
The proposed staffing plan for the nutrition service includes adding 5 positions under the
supervision of the Services for Seniors Case Management Supervisor. These include a
Nutrition Supervisor who would oversee the day-to-day operations and scheduling of the
two congregate meal sites as well as the home delivered meals. The positions under the
Nutrition Supervisor include 2 Nutrition Assistants (one based in Immokalee and one in
East Naples), two part time drivers (one in Immokalee and on in the Naples area) as well
as a full time Case Management Assistant who would be responsible for outreach for C1
Pi-(-
OAASERVICESPROPOSAL
and all meals assessments for the entire county. All staff would work closely with the
Accounting Supervisor and fiscal staff to coordinate billing and financial matters. Nutrition
education and counseling would be a contracted service. All job descriptions for current
and proposed staff are included in the attachments.
b. Cost Efficiency Plan
The Services for Seniors program has through the Office of Management and Budget the
ability to monitor monthly budget activity and monthly and quarterly performance
measures and compares it to prior year's activities. The internal reports generated
compare client cost and suggest cost saving strategies.
The program also prepares monthly unit cost worksheets that not only isolate unit cost
variances but also identifies areas where cost savings may be necessary before extreme
measures must be initiated. The fiscal staff maintains spreadsheets reviewed daily to
keep apprised of the fluctuations in spending. The contracted agencies are given an
orientation upon the award of the contract with directions on due date's timely submittal
of invoices and the means to tally the costs. Fiscal staff reviews the costs re9ularly with
case management staff.
?rogram effectiveness is determined in several ways. Internally, outcome measures are
an excellent tool in determining how effective we are doing our job. Quantitative
outcomes provide a level of expectations that, at a minimum, are our measure of
successful achievement of our program's goals. This agency uses GIRTS through
monthly review of "turnaround" reports. Internally, case managers routinely check with
clients to assess service needs and monitor their progress. The Gase Ivlanagement
Supervisor makes random checks regarding file documentation and care plans to assure
fulfillment of appropriate client care and grantor program requirements. Formal county
procedures are in place, which evaluate this agency's performance through legal reviews,
internal audits, and annual independent audits. In addition, services for seniors staff
complete GGE, ADI, HCE, and OM service delivery statistics, ADA and ALE HGBS
Waiver statistics and other data and report to Area Agency on Aging of Southwest Florida
and the Department of Elder Affairs in accordance with reporting requirements
established by the Department. A report/invoice system is developed that track and enter
data related to unit's service provided into CIRTS. Services are reported on a weekly
basis to permit staff to verify correctness of information before data entry.
External effectiveness is also evaluated through both programmatic and contractual
grantor monitoring. Through this process we are notified of any deficiencies and
suggestions for corrective actions. As a proactive measure, this agency initiates an
annual satisfaction survey to each client we serve. The feedback is invaluable in
providing what we do well and areas needing improvement. The survey also allows
clients to voice areas of need and what other community resources might better fulfill
their needs.
Accordingly, Services for Seniors Case Managers prepare a plan of care for each eligible
PiS
.
OAA SERVICES PROPOSAL .~
client in a coordinated fashion with the client, and/or caregiver using the approved DOEA
format. The plan addresses all client needs and considers both formal and informal
resources to provide the needed services. Clients are given the option to accept or
decline the care plan and in the cases of denial are provided the opportunity to follow the
grievance procedure outlined elsewhere in this application. Clients are also provided the
opportunity to choose amongst multiple vendors of service when such opportunities are
available and the client's choice of vendor is documented within the case file. In addition,
case managers monitor the quality of services delivered to the client and outlined in the
plan.
P,s a result of the above, Collier County Housing and Human Services Department,
Services for Seniors program maintains a high level of accountability. We are committed
to using the various tools to provide an effective program servicing the needs of Collier
County's elderly.
2. Client Targeting and Outreach:
a. Cast Management OAA Programs:
Targeting 8::;als: (insert separate g::;als for ea:::, ::ounty)
ror the 2008 OAL, contra::t year, this agency expe::ts to provide se:vi::e to 161
total (unduplicated) clients.
. Of these clients, we anticipate that 37 clients will be 60+ below poverty
level minority clients.
. 74 clients will be 60+ below poverty level non-minority clients.
. Additionally, we expect to provide service to 11 clients living in the
rural area of our county.
b. Nutrition Programs:
Targeting Goals: (Insert separate goals for each county)
For the 2008 OM contract year, this agency expects to provide service to 275
total (unduplicated) clients.
Of these clients, we anticipate that 63 clients will be 60+ below poverty
level minority clients.
. 126 clients will be 60+ below poverty level non-minority clients.
. Additionally, we expect to provide service to 20 clients living in the
rural area of our county.
Our pian to meet the above targeting goals is as follows:
Collier is a two-thousand twenty-five square mile county wih a fifty percent population growth
in just the past decade. Both the vast amount of land and ge::>graphic boundaries, either
(to
OAA SERVICES PROPOSAL
natural or man-made, have caused various communities to emerge, both urban and extremely
remote rural. Collier County Services for Seniors (CCSS) serves the entire county, with two of
its case managers specializing in outreach and service delivery to its farthest reaches, which
include Immokalee, Ochopee, Chokoloskee, and Everglades City.
Collier is also considered a wealthy county, with the 3rd highest per capita income in the state.
These numbers work against it when officials apply for federal and state monies, although
income is not evenly distributed throughout Collier's communities. The population distribution
is notable for wealth in the coastal areas, a shrinking middle class, and pockets of extreme
poverty. Studies indicate that nearly ten percent of its population may be living in poverty, and
a significant number of those people are elders living below the poverty level. CCSS
caseworkers have a strong working knowledge based on years of experience as to which
areas need more outreach and attention.
Because Collier County Services for Seniors partners with and receives both referrals and
information from a number of local entities, there is great opportunity for interagency planning,
information sharing, measuring success, or preventing duplication of services. Some of these
community organizations include:
Guadalupe Social Services
Marion Fether Clinic/ Immokalee
Horizons Clinic/Naples
Physician Led Access Network (PLAI\!)
Senior Friendship Center/Ciinic
Salvation Army
The Society of St. Vincent de Paul
Naples Community Hospital and its sateliite facilities
Physician's Regionallvledical Center
Collier County Social Services
Cancer Alliance of Naples
The Alzheimer's Support Network
Seniors and Law Enforcement Together (SALT)
Collier County Sheriffs Office Senior Services Unit
These and many other agencies and entities figure into Collier County Services for Seniors'
outreach plan, along with maintaining a continuous presence at senior centers, public events,
presentations, speaking engagements, interagency councils, and community centers, and by
utilizing our public info mation staff. Case managers are also active in various community
organiz ti ns which c ate even 11)0re opportunity for outreach.
~-Q.
Project re tor
/O/OlS-/OI
. ,
Date
pry
I
OAA SERVICES PROPOSAL
3. Client Confidentiality Safeguards (Specify procedures and training efforts.)
Collier County Housing and Human Services Department (CCHHS) is committed to
providing confidentiality for all clients receiving, or waiting to receive, services from OAA
and other programs that we administer. CCHHS has and follows a Health Insurance
Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) Standard Operating Procedure (Appendix V).
All employees are cognizant of the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of
1996 and have signed a Confidentiality Agreement. Employees are trained in HIPAA
regulations and are knowledgeable of how to contact the Privacy Officer in the
Department should a client request information regarding the privacy practices. Services
for Seniors staff are careful with client information when dealing with other agencies. Only
that information which needs to be shared in order to provide the best service and ensure
the client's safety is given out on a need to know basis. All Services for Seniors staff is
considered in the circle of need to know.
Client fiies are kept in lockable file cabinets. The intake information for the waiting list
and other files relating to clients, are in lockable file cabinets as well. Although it is
manjated that closed files are maintained for five (5) years in locked filing cabinets,
Services for Seniors maintains them for seven (7) years per Collier County policy. After
the time is up. they are shredded. The entire CCHHS office is iocked 24 hours a day, 7
days oer week, and can only be accessed by authorized CCHHS staff using a secure key
pass entry system.
Access to CIKTS is safeguarded by individual passwords that are initiated and changed
periodically by the Area Agency on Aging of SW Florida. The Client Information
Management System database (CIMS) used by Services for Seniors staff is maintained
and secured by the IT Department and is subject to the policies and procedures set forth
by the County Administration (CMA Instruction 5405-Appendix V).
When services are available to meet the client's needs, a Case Manager expiains the
process of authorizing services to the client and obtains a signed Release of Information
(Appendix V). This release gives the Case Manager permission from the client to give
pertinent data to the service provider agency so that services can be arranged and
provided. This release also allows the Case Manager to access other services and
resources on behalf of the client.
All Services for Seniors clients are notified annually of their right to privacy of protected
health information. Services for Seniors clients, upon receipt of the Notice of Privacy
Practices, sign a statement confirming receipt of this notice. This confirmation is
maintained in the client's file. (Appendix V).
4. Grievance Procedures I Process for Reducing or Terminating Services
(Include copy of material given to clients, procedures and method of determining
which clients will receive reductions or termination of services.)
p~
'; ~,
OAA SERVICES PROPOSAL
At the time of the home visit to complete the required assessment, the Case Manager will
explain the Grievance Procedure to the client. A copy of the Grievance Procedure, as well
as the "Minimum Guidelines for Recipient Grievance Procedures Applicable to All
Adverse Actions Deemed Terminations, Suspensions, or Reductions in Service" is given
to the client. The client signs the Grievance Procedure confirming this procedure has
been explained and this confirmation is maintained in the client's file. When a client files
a grievance and requests to implement the appeal process, the Case Manager
references this document and includes a copy of the signed form in the correspondence
to the client. Collier County Housing and Human Services Department has a Standard
Operating Procedure for the Seniors Program related to the Grievance Procedure
(Appendix VI).
The reduction or termination of Services for Seniors clients' services in order to serve
more highly prioritized clients is achieved by identifying those more highly prioritized
clients and determining the service needs and subsequent availability. A waiting list is
maintained with priority scoring, which will be used as a guide when funding is reduced or
higher priorities exist. The Case Management Supervisor will approve a plan of action for
reduction or termination of service and authorizing the new client service care plan. If a
client is being considered for reduction of service, the Case Manager will consider the
impact of the reduction. If the client will be put "at risk" and no non DOE.A service is
available to offset the risk, then no reduction will be made. If the client is able to absorb
the change and/or the services are available through another source, the ciient will be
given ten (10) days notice in order to "grieve" the decision. This same process will also
be applied to termination of service. If the client requests a reduction or termination of
service on their own, the ten (10) day rule and the right to grieve will not apply.
Notification of any adverse actions (such as reducing or terminating services) is
completed by sending a letter to the client at least 10 days in advance of any action with
information related to the Grievance Procedure. If the client chooses to implement the
Grievance Procedure, services cannot be reduced or terminated during this process. All
actions taken are to be documented clearly by the Case Manager or Case Management
Supervisor in the client's case narratives and all correspondence maintained in their files.
Services for Seniors maintains and follows a Standard Operating Procedure for the
Notification of Adverse Actions (Appendix VI).
5. Plan For Coordination Between Aging Network Providers
Collier County Services for Seniors coordinates with the Elder Helpline for receipt of
referrals. The Elder Helpline updates their information on an annual basis to confirm
availability of certain resources. When the caller appears to be appropriate for the services
known or administered by Services for Seniors, a referral is taken and faxed to Services for
Seniors. There is a single contact person at this agency. The referral is received,
documented as received and the client is called. The Case Manager explains available
resources and together with the client will decide what type of resources they wish to
access. This information is noted on the bottom of the referral and is faxed back to the
Elder Helpline. All referrals are kept in a lockable cabinet. All referrals are noted on a
separate referral list.
P9
I
OAA. SERVICES PROPOSAL
The proposed staffing plan for the nutrition component provides a method of regular
communication between the Nutrition Supervisor, congregate meal site staff and Case
Management Supervisor and program staff. Weekly meetings with program staff and fiscal
staff provide current status of surplus/deficits and plans for meeting spending goals are
constantly updated. CCHHS utilizes a centralized system for inputting assessment
information and billing data which assures accurate oversight of the total spending
authority.
6. Plan to Maintain Quality Control and Monitor Client Satisfaction (Describe both
internal methods to assure quality services and process for determining consumer
satisfaction. Also include procedures for handling client complaints.)
The primary tool used in determining client satisfaction is the annual Collier County
Customer Service Survey questionnaire (Appendix VII). This tool has proven to be
valuable in providing constructive feedback on Collier County Services for Seniors
performance as well as the satisfaction with the service providers. This survey allows
clients to voice their concerns not only in the areas of their services but also related to
other community resaurces. Through the use af this boi. Services for Seniors is able l::l
determine the clients' level of satisfacti:>n and identify those areas needing imorove."T1ent.
,ldditionaliy, the fiow of communication between the Case lvianager, client and the
pr:lVide to assure Quality service is ongoing. Case Iv'ianagers are available at all times to
speal~ wit,'] the client regarding their services and to address any areas of CO:lcern. Case
Managers continually monitor client's satisfaction at least twice annually; at the annual
assessment and through the use of the annual survey tool. However, client satisfaction is
often assessed more frequently as a result of additional contacts with the client
throughout the year. Case Managers are in contact with the providers as needed
regarding any of the clients concerns brought to their attention. The supervisor keeps a
record of issues related to the vendors and addresses these issues at the annual
monitoring or with the management of the agency as needed. The client's level of
satisfaction and any issues addressed are documented in the client's case narratives.
Management completes random file reviews to ensure that client's needs are being
addressed, documented and that program requirements are being met.
A formal review process is in place through the Grievance Procedure. Complaints are
brought to the attention of the provider and to Services for Seniors. Every effort is made
to resolve the clients' concerns to the satisfaction of the client. A formalized Incident
Report is used to address more unusual complaints such as those of criminal, legal or
medical nature. Incidents witnessed by the Case Manager, or brought to the attention of
the Case Manager, are reported to the Case Management Supervisor immediately. The
Case Manager or the Case Management Supervisor will call the client and the provider to
gain as much information as possible. Services for Seniors Staff will document all
information and copies of reports are sent to the provider and the Area Agency on Aging
of S.W. Florida to keep them informed of the problem and the procedure used to resolve
the problem If further follow-up is needed, Services for Seniors will do so and keep the
Area Agency apprised of the resolution.
PiD
OAA SERVICES PROPOSAL
Furthermore, formal procedures related to Collier County Government are in place to
evaluate the agency's performance through legal reviews, internal audits, and annual
independent audits
7. Strategies to Meet Outcome Measures / Goals Related to OAA Services:
Percent of Adult Protective Services (APS) referrals who are in need of
immediate services to prevent further harm served within 72 hours
(Nutrition Providers must respond to need for meals on an immediate basis.)
Upon receipt of the referral through AART, the on-call Case Manager is
notified of the referral. The Case Management Supervisor will make every
effort to contact either the APS investigator or the Supervisor to clarify or
confirm the information on the referral. If the referral is a High Risk then the
client is called and, if the client agrees, the Case Manager will see the client
and set up services to start within the 72 hour window of time. There is a back
up to the Supervisor who knows the process and has the authority to move
forvvard with accessi'lg resources. The agency will have procedures in piace
(frozen and shelf stable meals) to resp::>nd to high risk referrals for meals 7
days per week, 24 hours per day.
Percent of elders assessed with high or moderate risk environments who improved
their environment score:
In order to meet the above Outcome, the Agency will:
Address any clients with a high/moderate risk environment score immediately.
The Case Manager will access resources either through EHEAP, SHIP, local
churches or organizations who would have the ability to fix the situation. The
environment issue would be followed until all is addressed the score is lowered
to "no risk".
Percent of new service recipients with high-risk nutrition scores whose
nutritional status improved:
In order to meet the above Outcome, the Agency will:
Provide daily and weekend meals and offer and provide nutrition education and
counseling. When appropriate, the agency will refer clients for food stamps
and/or other financial resources. The agency will assist with finding appropriate
medical assistance including dental services The agency will offer and provide
nutritional supplements as funding allows or through community donations.
The agency will maintain available frozen and shelf stable meals for clients to
receive immediately.
97%
79.3%
66%
Pi!
.
OAA SERVICES PROPOSAL
Percent of new service recipients whose ADL assessment score has been
maintained or improved:
In order to meet the above Outcome, the Agency will:
Improve or maintain the score as a result of the services provided. The
assessment is used as the tool to give the direction to improve the quality of the
client's life. The availabiiity of family/volunteer support or lack thereof will help
determine the level of services needed. All issues are addressed at the annual
screening and assessment because the likelihood of declining health IS
inevitable with the aging process. The goal of the service is to minimize the
impact on the quality of life.
65%
Percent of new service recipients whose IADL assessment score has been
maintained or improved:
In order to meet the above Outcome. the Agency will:
Improve or maintain the score as a result of the services provided. The
assessment is used as the tool to give direction to im:Jrove the quality of the
I clients life. The availability of family/volunteer SUp;XJrt or lack thereof will help
deter:nine the ievel of services needed. Home delivere::! or congregate meals
can be utilized to cover some of the meal preparation concerns. Transportation
can be arranged to ajdress the mobility of the client to access services. 62.3%
rlledication management may need to be looked at by a doctor or other medical
staff. If there is a concern about the client's abiiity to make sound judgments
which may put him at risk then a report to the Fiorida Abuse line may be in
order. All issues are addressed at the annual screening and assessment
because the likelihood of declining health is inevitable with the aging process.
The goal of the service is to minimize the impact on the quality of life.
PilL
OAA SERVICES PROPOSAL
Percent of family and family-assisted caregivers who self-report they are very
likely to provide care:
In order to meet the above Outcome, the Agency will:
Discuss the level of "burn out" being experienced by the caregiver. Services will
be reviewed noting what the caregiver acknowledges he/she needs to keep
providing care. The Case Manager will access resources through churches,
Hospice, OA3E to supplement if needed. The caregiver will be given 89%
information about private pay agencies if in fact that can be afforded. The
National Family Caregiver program offers programs to support and educate the
caregiver. The Alzheimer's Support Network and the Alzheimer's Association
offer support groups and one on one case management if needed. The Adult
Day Care is one of the most popular allowing the caregiver total freedom of
movement during the open hours.
Percent of caregivers whose ability to provide care is maintained or improved
after one year of service intervention (as determined by the caregiver and the
assessor):
In order to meet the above Outcome, the Agency wi!!:
I Make every effort to keep the client in the community and the caregiver feeling
I! more capable and cClnfident through the provisiCln of services. If clients with
caregivers should remain on service for at least Clne year then this agency
i knows they have helped the family through a stressful situation and the family
will know they can manage with assistance. By providing needed services,
CCSS will help the family to remain intact and the client will avoid
institutionalization.
90%
Percent of customers who are at imminent risk of nursing home placement who
are served with community-based services:
In order to meet the above Outcome, the Agency will:
Continually assess clients eligibility for other community based services which
may delay or prevent placement in a nursing home. Case Managers are alert to
the clients who may be better served within the community. The programs
which allow clients to remain in the community are CCE, OM, MW, CDC+, AL
Waiver, and AD!. Since all Case Managers work with almost all programs then
the programs are easily reviewed for access. CARES also helps to note and
process the clients better served in the Community. Case Managers will utilize
other agencies and non profits to assist the clients and families in the home. If
the referral is an APS referral then those clients are seen and assessed within
the designated time frames. The Case Manager remains in close contact with
the family or client throughout whichever program is accessed.
90%
P/3
.
OAA SERVICES PROPOSAL
8. Service Delivery
a. Description of Service Delivery and Coordination Plan: (Provide one for each of the services
that you propose to provide. If a service is provided under more than one funding source, only one description is needed.)
f=ss Services:
. Case Management
. Case Aide
. Intake
. Screening and Assessment
. T ransDortation
In-Home I Supportive Servjces:
. Adult Day Care
. Chore
. Enhanced Chore
. Companionship
. ~mergency AJert Response
. Homemaker
. Personal Care
. Respite
Nutrition Services:
. Congregate Meals
. Congregate Meals
Screening
. Home Deiivered IVleals
. Outrea::::h
. Nut'ition ::duc:ation
. l~utritior, CDunselin~
National Family Caregivers Programs:
. EducationfTraining
. Information
. Screening and Assessment
. Referral/Assistance
. Caregiver training and support
. Gerontological Counseling
. In-home respite
. Facility Based Respite
. T;ansportation
. Child Day Care
. Specialized tvledical Equipment, Services,
ane Suppiies
. Housin~ Improvement
(See Form an TJllowing page)
PI~
~
Administr-ative Services Division
Collier- County Government Center-
3301 E2St Tamiami Trail
Naples, Florida 34112
madenefoord@colliereo".net
(239) 252-4768
(239) 252-8720 (fu)
TO:
Jim Mudd, County Manager
FROM:
Marlene Foord, Grants Coordinator
Applications Reviewed and Approved
by Coun:y M~, or designee for
. "::::: :::;;..-........:,... ...-../
submItl.aL -~'-. -,,:'~/.
-.--- County Manager
I~zf-/(' ";! Idzte)
cc:
Marcy Kru.'Ilbine, Director, Housing and Human Services
DATE:
October 26, 2007
Aftcr~the~Fact Approvn1 by the Bee is
require-.d at 1ne November 27, :2{)(\? Bee
meeting.
ST.JBJECT:
County Manager Approval of Older Americans Act :WOS Request for Proposal
Application.
The Serd(::,es fo:- Senio:1:'s PrClg.-z......n In t~e Rousi!lg e.:'ld :"hL.'1lan Se!"\:ices Depar:l.m~:1t has h(';en
rnSU\L'11ental ~li. cJJrdina"d;::g S~:-'lTi~es 10 C>:};iie~ CO:L"1t:(s ::nos: r:-ail senio:-s for eve:' 33 yez.:-~. This:
2-p;L::z.:iGr, f8: I'.:n:::in; irjili~ a...;:L:r:.1.:r. cyf S:gi~,f~'..JO: l~ t:l:-ou~r. :.b~ .L,~e2 .L.,ge,:lc:,' C:i l..f:ing l:tl=_ :n~
:::-l.Jriiz D'ej)2..-:::rlC:-E e,f :::ja~r ,L_f:2.:':-:, (.:..:1: '\1r:~. ~-:u.:'~::jo::' tH~\'f:~~2.:r~s, ':'1':-:10r':,,1t' ::::.r_?JK}T''L Se:-\j~e~
zn: '=2.S; ],~,;:,:~~;"':':::;e:-l."..
:(..$ l.f.;.e Leai f.gen:y in Cc,Ilier Cot:':1~'
sta:l rD'..!...'-::, ::l3.k~', c:.J:Jli::z:iJ::: for these fu::~ eye:",' iliree \'e::.-'; i::
. r . .
orje:- t~} 0:Jn:i:me :;o.:;:rr:iL::,:;:_:ior: eo! s~,~\'i~::s a:i.(. t::: :-~lai:.l,:zin O'.I; :...~ad l..gen.::y ~...z.:t:s. ~ n:~ 2:?;::;E::2..tjc~!:
v/'I p.,su;-.c. "":;"',ryf sur-.;i"'''''~ fer o..r..- s""uio-.;- ""::\n~';nup U.1llF""',.....JDt.c:.l'\ <fr"'C'urTn thp.. Y""e.~ '''Oln
.. .....u '...'.,u....~..... "-"-~ ~ ........_. "-_,""'~~... ...... . ...",..,- ~ '........u." ==- ",-' "-_ ...
T1H~ ::ittached RFP c.rpii~ation W2...<; due to tbe .'\reo. A.t;enC';' on /l..ging on FriO::':,'. OC-1obcr 26. 20(17, the
Sillne day as our !\'OVUS deadliDc. \Vc recei\'cd the 2.ppiication four \\'~~d~ prior to Jts deadline. This ~s
an intense application process L"at requires coordination of efforts from several staff memhers of both
the programmatic and fiseal staff. There were several high priority activities heing perfonned i:: the
department during the time the appiieation was being prepared: year-end-close and monitoring hy our
grantor agency, Staff \\'anted to ensure the application \\'3.S thorough1y re\'iewed and complete bef(lre
sendillg it through Novu~s. Therefore \\'e are asking for aftcr-the-fact approval to submit the applicatiDn
for the follov.-ing Board of COlillry Cornmissioners meel1ng November 27. 2007, \\'hich ha{,; a Public
Services }.,:ovus deadline ofNoveInber R, 2007.
Once you ha,'e reviewed tile application, please. sign alld date in the box ltbove lind call Marcy
Krumbine at 252-2273 or myself at 252-4168 for pickup.
Please Jet me know if you have any questions.
COLLIER COl'l\n
Item Number
Item Summary
Meeting Date:
I'n'pan>d II~
; [Ja','
: "'\'
"L1
Apl'r",'~d B)
'\pl'ro\'l'd II)
"'-, ,-t.d'
'\pprowd B,
-\I'l'n,,...d Ih
\I'"roved 11.,
,\pprn",'d 11\
"I'p","'ctllh
j'<I!..'l']oi'1
'.'0:n k:,
:ri::;"'.'. ,"-,.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
RECOMMENDATION TO APPROVE AN AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AND BENDERSON DEVELOPMENT
COMPANY TO ALLOW THE USE OF THE GOLDEN GATE KMART PLAZA
FOR PARKING DURING SNOWFEST.
Obiective: To provide an agreement between Collier County and Bendcrson
Development Company for additional parking for Snowfest.
Considerations: This years Snowfest will be held on Saturday, December I from lOam
to 5pm at Golden Gate Community Park and is expected to attract over] 5,000 people to
the event. Due to parking constraints at Golden Gate Community Park all event patrons
are shuttled on buses to the event. We currently have eleven buses that shuttle our event
patrons to Golden Gate Community Park fTom Calusa Elementary School, Berkshire
Commons Plaza, and Naples Christian Academy. Do to continued growth of the event
and the construction on Santa Barbara Blvd the Collier County Sheriffs Office has
requested an additional parl::ing lor to shuttle from. The landlord, Benderson
Development Company is proposing to parmer with the County to provide the
community with free parking at the Goioen Gate Kmart Plaza during the event.
Fiscal Impact: No fiscal impact is asso~iated with this agreement.
Lel!ai Considerations: The County Attorney has reviewed the agreement for legal
sufficiency_
Growth Mana!!ement Impact: No Growth Management Plan impact is associated with
this action.
Recommendation: To approve an agreement between the Board of County
Commissioners and Benderson Development Company to allow the usage of the Golden
Gate Kmart Plaza for parking during Snowfest.
Prepared by: Christina Apkarian, Program Leader
~
COLLIER COl''1TY
Item Nurnber:
Item Summary:
r,',.J
li'
Meeting Date:
Prepared By
K,Wrn",.,t' ';"'~e'
ijnH-
:';1'., r"~ I ;': l' ;'.'1" I "un
"'up":
";;"" Fq-
:\pprU\'NJ Hy
r;"""
[','n"',,-
'~y "~,' ;~:""'''' -
'''1,','",
\(i"j
. :\i;~
Al'prn\'l'(] By
-/'J"~', t.:!"rw.
~J,'l'
:)~:';v
Pat'C I of I
,'I,];',)
o.'r,'
TEMPORARY LICENSE AND AGREEMENT
This Temporary License and Agreement is entered into this 27th day of
November 2007, between Benderson Properties, Inc., Benderson 85-1 Trust and
Ronald Benderson 1993-1 Trust (hereafter "Benderson" or "Licensor") a New
York corporation, doing business in the State of Florida with its principal place of
business at 8441 Cooper Creek Blvd., University Park, Florida 34201 and
COLLIER COUNTY, a political subdivision of the State of Florida, whose mailing
address is 3301 Tamiami Trail East, Naples, Florida 34112 (hereinafter referred
to as "County" or "Licensee"), for the express purpose of allowing the County and
members of the public to use the parking lot on Benderson's property located at
Parkway Plaza, <1945-4955 Golden Gate Parkway, Napies, FL 34103 (the
"Property") for additional parking for the County's annual Snow Fest Event on
Saturda\', December 1, 20:17.
WHEREAS, Benderson and the County have determined and mutually
agree that it is in the best interest of the public to execute this Agreement
allowing the County and the members of the public to use the parking lot located
at Parkway Plaza, 4945-4955 Golden Gate Parkway, Naples, FL 34103 (the
"Property") for additional parking for the County's annual Snow Fest Event on
Saturday, December 1, 2007.
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of these premises, the sum of Ten
Dollars ($10.00), and other good and valuable consideration, the receipt and
sufficiency of which is hereby mutually acknowledged, it is agreed by and
between the parties as follows:
1. Entry onto Benderson's Property by County, shall constitute
acceptance of this Temporary License and Agreement, and such acceptance
shall carry with it the County's promise to obey all laws during its use of the
Property and, to the extent permitted by Florida law and as limited by Florida
Statute S 768.28, to indemnify and hold hannless Benderson from and against
any and all claims and demands and causes of action, which may arise as a
result of County's perfonnance or activities under this agreement, including, but
not limited to, all claims and demands and causes of action, damage to property
sustained by any person, finn, or corporation, including, without limitation, the
employees, agents, or contractors of County, together with all costs and a
reasonable attorney's fee for defending the same.
2. Benderson shall be liable for its own actions and negligence and, to
the extent pennitted by law, Benderson shall indemnify, defend and hold
harmless County against any actions, claims, or' damages arising out. of
Benderson's negligence arising out of and in connection with this Agreement.
3. The foregoin;;! indemnifications by the Parties shall not be
construed to constitute an agreement by either party to indemnify the other party
for such other party's willful or intentional acts or omissions
4. The rights and interests conveyed hereunder are conditioned
upon the reasonable exercise thereof by County. County agrees not to
unreasonably interfere with Benderson's use of the Property. Additionally,
County agrees that it shall, at its cost, repair any damage caused to Benderson's
property as a result of County's negligence.
5. All Right and Privilege given by this Temporary License and
Agreement shall tenninate upon the clean-up and removal of any and all
equipment brought onto the Property by County.
6. County shall furnish Benderson with a Certificate of Insurance
evidencing general liability coverage with a minimum limit for bodily injury and
property damage in the amount of one million dollars ($1,000,000.).
7_ This Temporary License and Agreement is contingent upon no
other provisions, conditions, or premises other than those so stated above; and
there are no other prior or contemporaneous written or oral agreements,
undertakings, promises, warranties, or covenants not contained herein.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, Benderson and the County have caused this
Temporary License and Agreement to be executed by its duly authorized
representatives this 27th day of November, 2007.
WITNESSES:
INC.,
BENDERSON
PROPERTIES,
BENDERSON 85-1 TRUST AND
RONALD BEI..JDERSON 1993-1
TRUST
Witness (Signature)
By:
r-lame (Print or Type)
Name:
Print
Title:
Witness (Signature)
Name (Print or Type)
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
COMMISSIONERS,
By:
Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and legal sufficiency:
Scott R. Teach,
Managing Assistant County Attorney
BOARD OF COUNTY
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA_
By:
J JAMES COLETTA, Chairman
iC::, Ii:::.:"
.,,~,
>i::;v~;mb~,;: ..:..,'
~:~_ICi7
;J: 23
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Report and ratify Property, Casualty, Workers' Compensation and Subrogation
Claims settled and/or closed by the Risk Management Director pursuant to
Resolution # 2004-15 for the fourth quarter of FY 07.
OBJECTIVE: To gain approval from the Board of Commissioners for Property, Casualty,
Workers' Compensation and Subrogation claims settled under the authority of the Risk
Management Director during the fourth quarter of FY 07.
CONSIDERATIONS: Resolution 04-15 grants limited authority to the Risk Management
Director to settle certain damage claims against Collier County and to authorize the
payment of investigation and adjustment expenses as presented to the County's Risk
Management Program. Authority is delegated as follows:
-
Claim Type Delegated Authority
Bodily Injury Liability- Premises Auto. Non-iitlgated claims less than S50,000
Operations
,
I Non-litigated claims less than S75.000.
, Property Damage Liability CialnlS- (lVote- A $75,000 limit is sought due to high
Premises. Auto, Operations valued vehicles and the potential for multiple
I vehicle accidents.)
Errors, Omissions, Professi~nal LiabiliTY. Non-litigated claims less than S50.000
Employment Practices Liability
Property Losses to County Owned Full authority
Property
Full authority subject to the provisions of F.S.
Workers' Compensation 440 and subject to approval by the Judge of
Compensation as needed
Employer's Liability Non-litigated claims less than S50,000
Subrogation- Bodily Injury and Property I Full authority to pursue non-litigated subrogation
Damage I recovenes.
Subrogation- Workers' Compensation I Full authority to pursue non-litigated subrogation
recovene~.
I
Pursuant to the Resolution, claims are settled and paid pursuant to the loss verification
procedures contained in the Resolution which include the completion of claim forms,
documentation of evidence, valuation, and the determination of a finding of liability where
applicable. Closed claims are also subject to review by the external auditor. A listing of
claims closed during the fourth quarter of FY 07 is attached. The report includes those
claims and/or settlements previously approved by the Board of Commissioners.
-
A valid public purpose is served through the delegation of settlement authority to the Risk
Management Director to settle routine, administrative and minor claim matters in order to
promote the efficient use of resources; to promote the efficient administration of the
program; and to allow for a timely response to claimants and/or their representatives.
FISCAL IMPACT: Funds are budgeted and available in Fund 516-121650-645920
(Property and Casualty Self Insurance Fund) and 518-121630-645928 (Work Comp
Claims) for the payment of covered claims and settlements.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There is no growth management impact associated
with this item.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: There are no legal considerations associated with this
item.
RECOMMENDA nON: That the Board of County Commissioners accept the attached
Settlement Report and ratify the actions taken therein.
PREPARED BY: Jeff \fl'a!ker CPCU. ARM. Director, Risk lvianagement Department.
COLLIER COU';T"
,i",.
JtemNumber:
Item Summary:
r:'." 1'<1
Meeting Date:
:1..,'
A[lprowllUy
J~ ref' i ,,I.,. "~,
':'. C~'I'
f',' 1':. ~ ; "'.<'r~ "-', ';
'ille
;<:~'I" c....,,,,,,/- j;C'iIC'_"-
'_".r:,.""'_""",,,,
'::U - ~:;;;, Iy
Al'l'ron'll B~'
,-,;;c
i'c;T' ", :'~';'-'.'
'co-,
/''',,''''''_'r,' ,,,,.,,,, -/'V,'-
''.:''''''1;''',-";,,,''''''
"DI,'
ApproHdBy
:,<';:)1'(""",..
'-n,;,.:'" -"':.1'1"""-
~"
Ie '0""'-;''':<1,
.\ppr"H'tl B~
.\pprun'dlh
-\pI'ro\'l'lJII\
f':l._
^ ~'H._L.T
__._'._._""""''''7''''-'',;1\1\_""
l'a!:'cltlrJ
,- 2
~ ~ a a a a a a a a a a
u ~ m a a 0 a 0 a 0 a a a "
"- a a 6 a a a 6 a a N ,-
E ~
g a a en
'" "' "' N
a N N "
f-
- " ,. .0
- - r
0 "
,
0; u u a a 0 0 a a 0 0 a ro
~ m 0 a 0 a 0 a a 0 a
.:;, ~ "- 6 6 0;; TI
- 5 " a a a a 0 a c
E 0
E '.:) 2
J:.Z
"
'" u u 0 a a a a a a a a
" ~ m 0 a a 0 a a a 0 a
" "- a 6 a 0;; a a 0 6 a
-'" cO
E
-
=:
CI>
E
,..
;:
CI>
>
o
~
>.
-
=:
:::l
o
U
...
CI>
o
U
-
~
o
"'-
ell
!!:.....
.,g
.~ N
u>-
IJ..
"0 ~
ell ell
Ul't:
.2 '"
u "
,.,0
- ~
.- ~
.c ~
.~ 5
...JIJ..
ID
"
u
o
u
w
a
~ u
~ ~
~
,
~
o
o
w
oc
a; u
- f
~
'3
u
:0
~
"
;::
L
~
w
~'
~
x
w
-::; 7.
C' "
::; L
o
E
o
!2
.n
i3
ID
2
u ~
~ iti
" "-
u
E
ID
"
~ ~ .~
> rn ro
c3 U) u
i=
"
o
ID
[(
"
rn
o
"
"
o
~
OJ '5 Q)
~ w ~
Cii ~ ro
z 0 C)
u
"
"
o
0; u
n Qj ~
~ C m
Z 8 2;"
U; a.
~ 0 E
u u w
000
000
6 ci
a a
a a
a a
:::J -Q
~ :=.>
=:, -,
_ :5
Q 0
a a
a a
a a
c-
oo
a
N
2;
N.- [:! W
m:l
,
~
w
c-
oo~
f:l~
MU
N.gl
N 0
u
"
o
o
c r___ <:!:
ill 0 E
~ ~ ~
ro N (/)
::.:::: N i
ro
2
3
0> ~
~ ~c
]i 3 25
mC)
;J; ~ ~,~
l.."l U C =
25 0 ~.3 (3
1--- ;;:;.~ (l) IV
~ N ~ .r:::
o N -0 is'''''''
N 0 ~ OJ ro
q 0 u:c.gs
N g <( s: ~
00
00
000
000
a a
60
000
a a
6 a
a a
a a
a a
a a
a a
006
c; 8
:::> :::J
000
000
000
a a
-:::J 0
o 0
000
000
ci 6
000
a a
000
a a
l(). ~
N N
c-
oo
a
N
OJ
~ I.....
c-
oo
o
N
2;
<:::'w
N ro,
<D
o
o
N
eon
"
~i5
c 0
o ~
" c
~ >-
g :g u::
;~~
W m
OJ ;nl..l.-
<D
o
a
N
;:
03 ~
~
"
E ;2
~ 0
s: :g U
"0 ~?l
" c
() ro ~
w
W iij
-:;LL
m ID
~=
E 0
~:;
C) ~
"
~~
'" 0
ID 5:~; ~
.D ro;.::;:iE
~~~~~o~
~ ~~~-i~~~~
g~~~.D...::..crs8..~
o~c~~-gg'gg-o
"'O~ l.O ~ III ~.g':::.gJ~as
!: ~ ~ .~~ ~ i ~ ~ ~
2
TI ~
C N TI
~:s.::J~
w 0 Q) ro
D.........r::: 1;;
... Q-Vl::::J
tfj a.ro l/)
2c,*~-g
LO ~ W ~ ~
~~~~~
00
a a
c:i ci
o
a
a
a a
00
a a
a
o
o
a a
a a
o 0
a
a a
000
a a
a
a
a
a a
00
00;;
o
o
o
~
o
o
N
m
N Q) ~
N
v
o
o
N
;:
<:::'
U
ID
i5
o
~ v _
If> 000
~ ~ g>
(j) co Ci.
C 0
" "
U .- U5
"
"
~
o
~
"
'3
If>
'3
ro
(L
"'
~
N
o
o
V
o
~ro
"
'~N
- "
rn ~~ :c
c ~"* iii -g ,g>
~ -g (l) ~ C\l ID ('")
~t:5~~~ ~
o ClI 8...8 c U;:: 0
;.oo~6~~~ 0
v ill co 0l..5......"'CI ~
'<:t~':::;CE-OQ) N
oS:~'2:(ll&g-
OID._ Q.) Q.) (/) .... OJ '
8~~oo:SEii~;::;:;
,
;.,....1
,-"....
t:i.,.
i-
Ion
V"
" -
- .21
--: .;0'
~. :'
':1'''':';'''
:7
<:
- =
~\' ~
,
~ _ :::T;
Q:T
-
s::
(l)
E
s::
...
(l)
>
o
'"
>,
-
s::
~
o
U
...
(l)
-
~
o
a.
..
0::....
eg
"CiiN
->-
ULL.
-c ~
.. ..
Ul-
.2(;
U ::l
,.,0
-J::
.- t::
.a ::l
.!:!! 0
..JLL.
o
U
u
E
ro
(;
i-
u u
~ ro
'i D-
u
E
:u
=
o
u u
~ ro
'i 0.
u
E
ro
"
ID
~
u u
~ &.
~
ID
:g
"
o
u
o
o
u u
~ &.
u
E
>
~
o
u
o
CY
u u
S &.
~
'0
-"
Q
~
"'C '2
~ m
L
~
ID
~
iV
Q
X
W
~ ~
~ ~
B
'"
c
o
-S'
i5
n
ID
::;
u u
~ ro
'i 0.
u
E
ID
"
~ tIJ .~
> .3 -
o ro rn
u U5 u
>"
t
o
Q
ID
a:
ID
1i
o
m
"
o
~
QJ <5 Q)
E (]) ~
ctI CO rn
Z 0 U
u
m
ID
o
:u u
E ID :i.
:J "E Qj
Z ID >
E ~ -g
"Cij 0 E
U u w
:j
o
o
6
ro ro
'" '"
,_ c-
~ ~
i
,
,I
o
o
o
00
00
60
o
o
o
00
00
00
I
I
o
o
o
00
00
06
o
o
o
o 0
0'"
o 0
'"
o
ro ro
0; OJ
G
,-
l.') ~
5
o
o 8
0'"
00
'"
o
o
00
00
06
I
I
c-
o
o
'"
N
_w
C-,
o
U
<D;:::
0-
~~
- '
~1!
Nfl
-.:t
>
D
<D _
aT
~ C
;:0 ~
NO
u
o
c-~
2 25 ~
12 ~:g
U ;:8:.
,-
a
o
N
0;
N _ W
N "',
c-
o
o
N
C 25
o ;;
~ u
ro 'u
al 0
b
I
I
I
"
~ c
.c 9 >.
f-"D..Q :gEe:
<(mcE~i::w
()..c ~ =' 0 ro E C"l
Cll ro..lo:: 'c.!2 0 ;:J; Q) 0
t'-rJo2~~~~~S
<D :1: Qj iii.~ :G.8 ~ ~~
0~ ~~~~"2 g--gS
g'~~~~~ffi~~o
8u ~:5Et7j~~_~~
'*~~>,
:> Ol o..!!!
"i:: ro 'i:: ~
; ~ 1iJ g
:.c"D~:2
c ~"o.."O
N 0 ill fI) W
("') (/) :s: ~ >
<.l')!!:!<1J~o
~~UC(ll
QW:E;m>.....;
8~~~~,g1
.. ..
c- ,_
o? "'
c- c-
<D <D
c- ::;
is '"
N ,-
ul ~
- ;:;
:u
.0
o
1:5
o
>.
ro
"
<5
::;
00
00
00
00
00
ci 6
00
00
00
00
00
ci ci
00
00
00
00
00
ci 6
00
00
6 ci
00
00
66
00
'00
00
.. ..
1'- 1"-
"' o?
1"-- r__
<D <D
00
00
00
00
00
00
80
00
o 0
""
00
00
ci ci
00
00
06
c-
o
o
N
0;
fj Oi ~
c-
o
o
N
'"
gj co
c-
o
o
N
25
<D
o
o
N
<D
25
c
_ 0
u
iJ
E
:u
ID
(5 r--- 5
]i g ~
(/) ~:x
:J e w
a: 0.
:2
ill <D
~ 8
E '"
~ N
ID-o ID
~~~~
C Cll";:: .....
U) Q. E If.I 0 J'--
o !!?.g Q) ~ "<t
2; ..c ~._ ~
o c ~ 'o.."D 0'-
b~~~~~ ~~
S~~~~~ ~~
~ 8J?i51? 2ro~;5
00101->$:"0<:;:::0010
(.,-''")
~
,,-
,"-
r-
Vi
0/'
~ 2'
TI TI m m 0 0 N N 0
~ ~ ro M M 0 0 '" '" 0 ""
0- m m 0 0 " ". N ,-
~ M
m m co co N N cO
" <CO '" N N N
-':'i ~ "is W
f-
-- 0- - .0
- P
':.:! "
~ >
1] TI TI 0 0 0 0 0 0
, ~ ro 0 0 0 0 0 0 ro
'0
'C 0 0- 0 0 0 0 0 0 c
~ 0
G.i 2'
'0
'-')
_!,
ro TI TI 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 ~ ro 0 0 0 0 0 0
ill ;; 0- 0 0 0 0 0 0
..J E
ill U U 0 0 0 0 0 0
:is ~ ro 0 0 0 0 0 0
jj ~ 0- 0 0 0 0 0 0
~
ill
0
> TI TI => 0 0 0 0 0
0: 0 " => 0 0 0 0 0
> ~ 0 0 0 0 0 =>
0 ~
a:
0-
" 0' ~ 0 0 N N
B ~. => 0 co <CO
~ 0' a, 0 0 " ".
" ~ m IT> N N
co r:.;:) N N
-
ru -- 0 CJ 0 0 => 0
~ ~ ~ 0 => => 0 => 0
~ ~ => => 0 0 0 =>
, co co
X
W
Q TI TI 0 0 0 0 0 0
c ~ " 0 0 0 0 0 0
15 ;; 0- 0 0 0 0 0 0
~ u
.0 E
i3
ill
2'
ill ~ t- t-
o 0
ro m W 0 0 0
w 0 0 N
0 C ~ ~ 2;
> ro "
0 ii) W N N W N N W N
() () , N ;:: , N ;:: , N ~
'"
0 ,- t-
o
0 0 t- o
..... 0: 0 0 0
N 0 N
c: 0 "' N '"
Ol ro N ;j' N
0 OJ , ". '"
E " N
m ro 0
c: m ~ " w
- 0 ,- rn t-
... ~ ..J I D-
Ol 0 0 0 0 ~ t- o
6 m 0 ~ 0 m 0
> 0- 0 0 " 0 N ~ E 0 0 N
'" E 0 m 0: "' U 0 N U '"
0 ro 0 15 '" "
c:: 0- ro ro ill W N
'" 0 Z 0 () ;> d5 N " , '" 2' '"
,g 0
>- '" N '" " ?o c- - i'! c
.~ 0
..... U >- ii ;; .s t5 eo ro ~ .s '" .s 0 :g ill z 0
c: u.. = '2 E OJ '=' ~ 0 " > c W ill 0 '0 .~
~ 3 c ~ " "- .- W '0 ~ W " c
"tl u 0 0 rn 0 = ill J!! 2 0 0 > ;; .~
::l ~ m 0 () 0; c ~ 0 w U m .2 '0 0 Z. 0 .0 ill 0
'" 2 0 g'U ro !!! rn 0 ;; 0 ill ~ U '0 f- '" "- '"
0 Vl 0 m E U u '" .2 0 .0 a:; 0 W ill m '0 c '" '" " , ~
~ 0 ro '" ;; ;; .2 ;:: 0 0 f- 0 ;;; \'..'1
U .2 '" W 0> ill ro "is ro ~ :S '" m u E c .s ~:g ro 0 '" .
u :5 "
u '" .0 ~ '0 " 0 ro c ~ '0 E w 0 '0 ;; 0 0 0 ::::'
U :J -g W .0 , ~.c 0 0 ~ ~ '0 0 0 .0 0 0
... ,.,0 "" " ~ '0 W .9 .9 C L ~ ,- .1' '" 0 .2 0 t- '" " c "- .9 ;; :c ~ N ~.:::
5 c '0 " 0 C M 0 0 M ro ,Q.'!;: '"
Ol W C 15 0 ~ 15 C ill 0 0 N 0 ~ "-~ N 0 0 > 0 M C E "" ~ 0 M
0 = '" 0 " 0 m 0 M
:!: z > rn ~ t5 ro " '0 E t5 m ~'" ro W N 1" ;; M ~ '0 U '" ,-
::; () ro 0 i'! ro E .9-0 ro 0 0> 0 o;N
E 0 E W ~ f: u E u 0 0 ~ N S2 ro m .2 0 u " N E ro .0 ~ ro j; "- ro" V)
..Q ~ '" Q u W m 0 C 0 0 "-~ '0 C 0 '0 ~ 0 0 w u u E E 0 0
0 :J rn 0 E rn > c u m 0 " a, N 0 i= ~ ill 0 " ill N 0 rn :c rn m '0 N 0
'" U {3 0 0 '1i 0 0 '0 0 0 0 U > rn c rn 0 'yr
U 0 () w i5 "- u E :c '" "- ro u N 0 W ro .0 ;; ;; .0 " .0 ;; N 0 0 ~ t> '0 :c ro '0 N 0 "-
--' u..
u u 0 0 '" '" 0 0 0 0 '" '" ~ :;
0
u ~ ro 0 0 '" '" 0 0 0 0 ro ro 0 '"
-" " C- O 0 a;; a;; 0 6 6 0 .. " N "
M
U U; U; M <0 '"
- '- ro -" 0 0
-. a N
f- a;
" .0
0
'- u
, ':)) 0
.~~~' a; u u 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 '"
~ ro 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ro
.0 "
0 "; "- 6 0 6 6 0 0 6 6 0 6
u 5
2: ~ E :;
Z
ro u u 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0- ~ ro 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
w , "- 0 0 6 6 0 0 6 6 0 0
-' u
E
W TI TI 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
:0 ~ ro 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
jj "; "- a 6 6 6 6 0 6 6 0 6
" ~
u
w
0
~ u u 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
ill ; " 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
> "- 0 0 6 6 0 0 6 0 6 0
0 ~
u
3!
'0 C' ." g 0 ro '" 0 0 0 0 '" '"
~ m 0 '" '" 0 0 0 0 ro ro
u c- o 0 a;; a;; 0 0 0 0 " "
'3 'd u; ~, ~
,0 '" 0 0
~
w u u 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
~ ~ " 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 'I
05 "- 0 0 0 6 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 ~
x
W
0 TI n 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
~ ~ ro 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
5 , "- 6 6 6 6 0 6 0 6 6 6
"! E
:a
i3
w
:;
w ~ ~ ~ ~
Q "' 0 0 0 0
ro a; 0 0 0 0 0
a; M 0 N N N N
Q 0 N 0; 0; " 0;
~ ro m ~
0 ii5 w N W N 0; W N 0; W N 05 w N 0;
U U ;;! N " , N , N , N , N
'" B
1: 0
0 ~ c
0 c " "' ~ "' "'
w ;. 0 0 0 0 w 0
... a: '" "
0 0 0 0 " 0
:: w W N N N ':o! B N
Cl> ro ~ <oii " iD e:> N
0 rn a; 0" w iD iD ro '" w 05
E ~ ~ ;;; c
rn c
M W " '" 0 w ~
:: M is ro M U ~ ro
ro S
- 0 n U c E 13 ro E
... ~ -' ~ ro ~ ~ m 0 "' ~
Cl> 0 a ~ 0 (f) B ro
05 0 0 0 .0 0 0 w 0
> Q. w W .0 0 C 0 w 0 0 " 0 ID 0
Q) E w M " " '" '" c ':o! ID w ':o! c ':o!
Q C
0 r:r: ro rn ro ~ w '" ro or m '" > M '" ~ w
i5 0
..... Z 0 u ii5 "' '" OJ '" 0 , iD '" ro
~ E 0
0
>. ~ N " a " c rn c '" "
... >- ro ~ w "' " ~ .0 W W
U '0 ro .0 rn- ~"8
:: " '0 '" '0 0 C W ro m ~ w
LJ.. ro ~ a; ~ W '" C , E 2 0 '"
u ro W u.. w ~ 0
:::I "0 ~ u E "' ~ ~ W '" ro '" 0 c .0
Q) M 2 M .0 - 0 N ro rn 0 ro :> ~ '0 ,;
.J!! 0 M ro ~ ~
0 W ;;; '0 ro M ~ '" U U Q C '" E ~ M W " C .0 W '"
III 0 '" '0 .0 "' '" ro 0 u "' ." u ,.......
~ C '" W M ro 2 rr 'in u ~ u 2 ;": ~- J
U ..e '" a; U C a; , W '" ar:c :J '" U M '" M 2 ~ '0 C '" E "' "'
C 0 a; 0 :E 0 ro c w 0 "' c::::
U ::: .0 U ~ ~ ~ '" 0 a; ro '" 0 ~ ;;; .0 '0 N . C W 0 0
w 0 '0 ~ W 0 0", 0 , 0 W M W ~
... ~ '" ~ 0 W 0 ~ "' rn w 0 ~ N ~ '0 rn ~ N U in "' N ~ ~ N <
>,0 5 C W E '" ~ 0 ID '" 0 <D W C '" U 0 <D W '0 "' ro ~ 0 rn a; :Q a; ,M 0 <D
Cl> W W ro <D C w rn ;;; M 0 rn-_ oS <D M W C . '" <0 rnrn C <0
~ J: Z ~ ~'O U '" C ~ <D :; ~ C 0 <D ~ ro .0 '" ~ '" 0 '"
U '" .0 ro 0 0 ro
1:: .0 0 _ W "' ~"' 0 E 0 ,,'" 0 ~,ga:;~ <D 0 0 ~ ~ g>* ~ N C ~ '"
ii Q u c ~ w " c 0. 0 '" W '" E 0 l/,)
;;; 2 Q U W 00 ~ 0 ~ 0 '" 0
0 ::: ro 0 E 0 '" > o ' 0 ." '0 3 N 0 .~ gl ~ 'Y N 0 E ~ E e -E; N 0 c m '0 ro N 0 "..,....
'" 0 W 0 ro 0 0 C 0
U ~ 0 U u w '" U U ro ogj 0 U .0 .0 .0 N 0 -' "D:=a.LL N 0 W OJ 0:5 a.N 0 '" .S 0 '" U N 0
LJ..
,-, ~'''~'''~-----~ ~._~~-....
.....
t::
Q)
E
t::
...
Q)
>
o
C)
>.
.....
t::
::l
o
U
...
Q)
.,...
o
C-
Ql
0::.....
:::8
'; N
uiZ
"::l ~
Ql Ql
"'t:
.2 '"
U ::l
>,0
- ~
='2
.a ::l
.!E 0
~u..
o
U
ID
:Q
t3
o
U
ID
o
u u
~ rn
, n.
E
>
~
o
u
"
"
u "'
~ '"
L
~
o
-~
I
<5,;';
"
m
c
ID
'"
x
W
-'
~ [.
~
'"
c
"
~
:0
'0
ID
2'
u u
~ m
, "-
u
E
ID
"
~ ~ ~
E'; m ro
() 45 u
is
"-
ID
0::
ID
ro
o
m
m
o
~
15 ID
ID ~
E ID 0
ro iiJ ro
Z 0 U
o
~
ID
o
~ 0
.0 ~ 0
c ~ <C
~ a:; ID
z u ~
E iil a.
ro 0 E
U u UJ
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
o C>
C> 0
C> 0
C> C>
~.., "',
0' 0)
'" '"
" "
r:'"J "'")
C> C>
C> C>
C> 0
8 g
C> C>
C> C>
C> C>
o C>
00
C> 0
00
C> 0
o C>
00
w
~
~
o
o
N
Oi
N _ W
N on ~
~
o
o
N
Oi
0_ W
N on ~
~
13
"
o
,~
o
o
N
'"
as
"
o
o
N
>'"
'0 "'
C
~
ID 2\
~ ~
c
~ N
~
6
Vi
<5
>
m
~
2
Vi
.0
o
"0
ro N
-g r:::
w N
~mO
ro ~ r: QJ
~~,g:gD
~ _~ ~ g; to
~ -g ~-~ 0
III cu ~ ~;g
OJ ill ..... CL "-
>-:s: iil";:::=1
%o~u;::::
~ E U N
Wrne~N
ro
0>
~c"'O
ro if, C'Il ~.2:
:5Q).o~o::J
(/) Q) E c: III
~ i;'w (]) ~
~~~~..c~
f.Dro c,,:s: 01
~ ~~~rn ~g
c; ro -;: ClI !: w c.o
8E~~Eg~
OWU-02roN
~
'0 ro
ID> "-
::i=o"O~
.s ~ 5:.6
(/) Q) Ul rn
o rn = OJ c:
~!~~o
8~-55rn~
o EC-D..!::
a co ~ ~ @
80:;::UiE
00
o 0
DO
00
DO
00
8 2S
.0 co
~ N
o 0
g g
00>
DO
DO
00
,>
o
o
N
"'
N _ W
N "' ~
~
o
o
~g
;nE
o
0;
~ "- ~
o 0 ~
ro 0 0
~ N 0
~ ;;q: ~
o r::::-o
~ "U
(])"O ~
Q) ~ ~ ~ a;
N ~~C e ~
co (/) _ iil w ~ >-
o 2 Q) E..::. (l) >,
ON ro :> z.."'; .Q-.D
f'- N Vi 0 C;.- c."'O
~ M C ~ 5 ~~ ~
~~~~g~~~t
~~ 8ou;:g:2~ E
DO
00
ci ci
00
00
00
DO
DO
00
o 0
o C>
o 0
00
00
6ei
~
o
o
N
"'
f:j 03
~
o
o
N
;::
~ ;:::
ID
~
ID
'0 ~
o 0
ro 0
~ ~
ro
~ to
"'
on
o
cog
.Q b ~
:5.,.... r.o
"'.0
.t; 0 0
~ N 8
0", 0
L/'''J
~
<
Vi
""-
'"
~ ~ ::> ::> '" '" ~ ::;
::>
u ~ m ::> ::> '" '" ::> '"
E Q. ::> ::> oi oi N ~
0 ~ ~ '"
m E '" '" '"
'0 .; .; ~ N
f- 0; ~
"= I. D ~
0
_. U
0
.' g? '"
0; ~ ~ ::> ::> 0 0
= ~ cr: ~ m ::> ::> 0 0 ro
C- D ci "
-S 15 5 Q. ::> ::> ci
E 0
::; ::;
Co
~
I.
m ~ ~ " ::> ::> 0 0
'" ~ m ::> ::> 0 0
'" 5 Q. 0 0 ci ci
-' E
ill ~ ~ ::> 0 0 0
:0 ~ ro 0 0 0 0
'B 5 Q. 6 0 ci ci
0 E II
~
ill
'"
> ~ ~ 0 0 0 ~
ill ~ ro 0 0 ~ 0
> 5 Q. 0 0 ci ci
8 E
ill
'"
-0 ~ ~ ::> 0 '" "
ill m ::> 0 ., "'
"" '" 0 0 oi '"
-g p, a.
m a,
~ - .; 1.:;
m ~ " 0 0 ~ ~
~ ~ " ::> 0 ~ 0 l;""J
W "- ::> ::> 6 ~
Q ~ '" "
x
W
Q ~ ~ ::> ::> ~ 0
= ~ ro 0 0 ~ 0
0 5 Q. ::> 6 ci ci
"" u 0 0
" '" '"
.is N N
i3
w
::;
w ~
'"
ro m ~ .! 0
0; 0
0 N
> " ro I, <0
0 W N W
() iii () ::> N '" ,
,:: u
! ID
(; is
Co
Q 1 m <0
w c 0
- 0: " 0
t: w 0: ~
Ql " I i5 Q
0 0 ;;;
E m 0
m " G
t: m rn '"
- 0 ~ ~ 0
.. ~ --"
Ql 0 is > c 0
<D 0 N
> 0- w w ~ E <0
m
'" E w 0 U D
0 c:: ro " ro 0 u
r-- U5 <i' ~
C) Z 0 () ~
E 0
0
>- .!!! N rn c
w E~
- U >- w " Qi c ,2 .8 > E
t: "- u " m ~- ro w ~
"C u c ;;; ro '" '0 ro E m ~ w ~ oS 'm
;j ~ m ro ~ 0 u ~ ~~ w ~
'" - E w m ~ ro " ;;; "
0 " w 5 2 0 5 w ro ~ D ~ rn
'" - 0 ~ -5," 1'; .8 . E c 0; , ~
0 ~ ! m ]i W x rn ~ ~ 0 ro ;:; " ,
() '" 0; u E 5 0 '0 ~ c W D ~ C 2' E i:.':::
U::l u I ~ ro '" 0 w rn
D 0; '" '" ro m 0 '" ro ~.~ ~ u ~ ro ro '" w
.. >,0 E > " 0 c ~ '" E D D ,2 '" :<
Ql 0 C 0; .~ ~ w w ~ viU ~ if) (; w
j!; OJ'';::; D i' c '" 0 " 15
::: ~ z w > m '" c u ~ E 0; w wW C ,2 u
'2 () 0 w ._ w ~ ro 0 N rn u f- ~ rn~ ~ f- r-
E 0, E =" ID w ,g > 0 ~ ro 0 o c
:c ;;; '0 i' 0; =" u ~ ~ 0 w E , if) u ~ C .0 6 ro '0 Vl
0 ::l ~ E 0 D " > " 0 0 m W '" D (; Q C
'" 0 0: 0 ro 5 ~ ro N 0 ro 0 0 ~() ro If
() :::; 0 () () W m =" .= "" ;;; () '" 0 '" '0 if) ::; m ~ u ~ " "
"-
_....~,....,"......_.,'-,,-" .~,....~.,.- ....,._~-,-,.- "'---,
~ ~ '" '" e- :;;
n n 0 0 ~ ~ 0 <{
E ~ CO 0 0 CD CD 0
Q. 0 0 '" '" e- ,- on .n ~ ~
on
~ CD CD ,- ,- "' "' .n
ro '" '" ~ ~ CD CD 0
a N N on
W 0
- ~ D
",' - .~
-
- n n 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~
;:::, ~ ~ ro 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 rn
~, -, 5 Q. 0 0 0 0 0 0 6 6 "
- is E "
:;;
- ,-
2) -
:;,
-
ro n n 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 ill iij 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
ill ~ Q. 0 0 6 0 0 0 0 6
~
ill n n 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
os ~ iij 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
~ S Q. 0 0 0 0 0 0 6 6
u
0 E
n
ill
0
> n TI 0 :s 0 0 0 0 0 0
" , " 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
> Q. 0 0 0 6 0 0 0 0
0 ~
U
ill
'"
~ :s :? ~ ~ ~ ~ '" '"
~ ~ CD CD
0 0 '" '" ,- ,- 6 0
" CD CD ,- ,- co co
co '" ~ ~ co co
co N ~
m "=' 8 0 0 0 '5 '5 0 0
~ ill 2- 0 0 0 0
<D 0 0 0 0 0 0 .n on
" '" '"
x -
W
g TI TI 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
~ ro 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
" ~ Q. 0 0 6 6 0 0 6 6
"
.6
i3
ill
:;;
ill e- e-
o e- e- o 0
rn ~ ~ 0 0 0 0
w 0 0 ~ N
0 N '" 25 25
> ro rn eo
0 ~ W N ~ W ~ N W N N
U Ii) U "' 03 ~ "' ;:: ~ "' 03 ~ "' Oi
,::
0- w ill
0 ,- e- ill e-
o. g U "
ill 0 0 " ,- 0
- a: 0 ill 0 ill 0 ill 0 0
~ > ~ > 0 > 3' ~
!:: ill <is 25 ~ 03
ro ~ c ~ N '" ~ rn
aJ 0 "' ill -<
OJ eo ~ '" w ;; "'
E 0 0. 11 0
c C (L c 0
~ " ~ " N " <;;
!:: ~ c rn 0
0 j'
.... ~ 0 ,- c- e- - :5 '" e-
~ 0 0 e- o 0
aJ i5 ill ill 0 ~ 0 i5 c 0 i5 <{ 0
> ~ ill Z ~ " ~ g 0 ill ~
~ C ill ~ <0 ~ c Oi ~ ~ ~ ;::
0 0 ro 0 .~ rn ro '" '"
rn m 0 ill ~ 0 D :s
Cl 0.1'- Z 0 U w eo () U) '" () 0:: " () ~ "'
.,0
0::0
>. N ill :S
E 0 a ~ .8
- >- "'- - m ",'"
!:: u. :::~ 0 .2 " m S '" ill
.!!! " 0 0 ill ~ a c 0 '"
'" D ~ " ill " 5 _ rn
:::l ~ 0 > 0 c ~ ~ rn .2 ~ > D ~ W
U ., m ~ 0 0 0 ~ '" ill U m x -ii ill
0 ~ ill 0 0 .2 ~ 2 u " '" U ro .!!2 .0 '" ill 0 U ro ~ on
"0 ~ OJ "' ",0 ill > '" E' ~ .., E' 0 m (.,/,,)
U '" w u on ~ c c rn !! 0 = -ii CD ~~ ill e- ~ ~ 2 ill W
., 0 rn 0 - 0 .2 W 0 ill c 0 rn .. m 0 0 2::
III " ~ w u 0 ~ ~ Eo:: 0 0 > D ill = 0 0 ~ ~ > z > 0 0
.... 0 0 <{ ,- '0 " 0 ~ .~ e- "' ~ '0 ~ t e- '" :2 '0 ill ~e- :;: ~
c w 0 ~ ill c c ro - 0 CD ill 0 ~ ill ill c = ",,0
aJ 0 ill CD "' ill 0 ~ .6 " rn .0 ~ m "' 10 " ~ 0 "' ~ ill ~ rn .- " e- on
U Z > on ~ 0 m W in 0 '0 ro N <0 rn ill '0 0 ~ ~ '" ill "''0 on
:;:; E u 0 ~ ~ OD ~ C ]I ill rn M E ~ U ill '" c; o c U 0 " c 0 ;;; c;
0 ~ n 0 Q.~ " = E 0 o.rn Ci~ .., U VI
ro <;; 0 0 ill ~ 0 0 ro rn E' 9 0 E' '" 0 0
0 ~ " 0 c N c ~ 0 ro x ill g ro N 0.'0 E rn ro :S N vr
" 0 u u W 0 _ 0 c = t .2 0 U ~ ill = ill N 0 ill <;; <;; ill 0
U <0: "' 0 W c ro > W 0 U "' 0 > ~ o.M 0 W 0. > D "' 0 L,
U.
u u .. .. '" '" 0> 0> '" '" ,~ :2
0>
0 ~ ro CO CO '" '" '" '" ~ '" 0> <(
.EO "- 6 0> ,..; ,..; e- ,..; ~ N N
~ '"
'" '" '" '" D D ori 6
ro .. ". '" '" N N
'0 '" .. 0 0 '"
>- ~ 0>
- .a
0
13
0
~ u U 0> 0> 0> 0> 0> 0> 0> 0> >.
- ~ ro 0> 0> 0> 0> 0> 0> 0> 0> m
'0
~. .:::..' 0 "- 0> 0> 6 6 0> 6 6 6 c
~ 0
" :2
Z
ro u u 0> 0> 0> 0> 0> 0> 0> 0>
" ~ ro 0> 0> 0> 0> 0> 0> 0> 0>
ID "- 0> 0> 6 6 0> 0> 6 6
~ B
E
. u U 0> 0> 0> 0> 0> 0> 0> 0>
:is ~ ro 0> 0> 0> 0> 0> 0> 0> 0
e 5 "- 0 6 6 6 6 0 6 6
0 E
TI
.
00
> u U 0> 0> 0 0> 0 0 0 0
ill ~ ro 0> 0> 0 0> 0> 0 0 0
> "- 0 0> 0 0 0 0 6 0
0 ~
u
.
'"
-0 TI - ~ ~ '" C0 0> 0> '" '"
u ~ " co co '" C0 CD CD cO '"
:a ~ co co ,..; I- ,- ,~
~ N N '" '" '" co co co
~ co co '" '" N N '" '"
.. ~ ori .n
a " :;;
~ D ~ N N N a a a a "
~ c " N N a a a a a
"- co co ~ co co 0 a N N
<D
~ " " " <D a
ro a a "'. '" co co "'
<5 N N '" a
~ = f-
oe K' =- .0
~
'- - ,
:2: ~
c' '" D D a a a a a a a a '"
~ ~ " a a a a a a a a "
. is " "- a a a a a a a 0 c
- E 0
:;;
?
7:
.
'~~
ro D D a a a a a a a a
0 ~ ro a a a a a a a a
w "- a a 0 a 0 a 0 a
~ 1
~ ~ 0 a '" '" '" ~ :;;
" '" 0 0 0
~ ~ m 0 0 0 '" '" '" '" 0 0 0 '"
"- 0 0 a; a; ;: .. .. 0 0 N N
;: ~
cO '" '" <D <D .n 6
" E '" "' 0 0 ~ ~
15 N N ~
e- :;; 0
.0
- 0
r-,:; 1:5
0
, 1) '"
:;; ~ ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
c J' ~ . 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 rn
.0 "- 6 6 ci ci ci 6 '0
2: is 5 0 0 0 0 c
.s 0
"" 2 :;;
s
:v Z
:J"__
<(
" ~ ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
" ~ . 0 0 0 0 0 a 0 0 a 0
m "- ci 0 ci 6 0 ci ci 0 0 0
-' cO
E
-
i::
Q)
E
i::
...
Q)
>
o
C)
>.
-
::::
::::l
o
()
...
.~
o
()
-
~
o
<>.1"-
Q)O
0::;;:
E>-
~LL.
U 0;
-
"C ~
Q) III
II> "
,20
U.::
O~
- "
" 0
<(u.
m
:g
1!
i5
m
o
~ ~
~ rn
0; "-
~
>
~
o
u
o
0:
~ ~
~ ~
"-
.8
"
u
i3
o
"
~ rn
u.
~
ID
if'
C
ID
o
X
W
~
(/1 F.:
L
cO
E
o
E
o
.2
:0
i3
m
:;;
~ ~
~ m
0; "-
u
E
ID
"
~ ~.~ i I
6 co ro
u U5 u
'"
5 I:
o I
m
0::
m
1ii
o
w
m
o
-'
Q) 0 Q)
E <lJ ~ ; I
rei rn ro i'
Z 0 U
<>
w
m
o
Cii t5
E 2 <( 'I'"
:J C w
Z m >
E ~ ~
"iU 0 E
<3 u w
00
00
o 6
o 0
a 0
00
o a
a a
a a
o g
000
000
00
a ci
w
,
I-
o
a
N
m
:;: en ~
u
o
15
o
~
o
x
w:
c
o
~
o
U
c
~ 8
:;; N
> N u
o ill
~.-g
c 1l
~ x
o I'- u::
~ ~:~
(5 ~ =3
u u
"Om>'
~= .S2
__ E.g- g
frj ~ iil.""2 g;
g;~~~ cs
C ill Cl.. Q) c>
o s: UJ 6 S
Kl~~c g;
.3g~2
IDN<llVl 9
~~~~~v
000
000
ci c:i
000
00
o ci
a a
a; '"
'" '"
"' '"
a a
a a
ci 0
000
000
6 ci
~
a
a
'"
~ ~ b!;
c g
m "- m
E 0 ~
c 0 c
Qi ~ ==
> "- 0
o ~ 0:::_
Cl N ~
>. ~
C u
~ rn
o ~ m
() 8 _
~ ~:~
o !::::!""6
UN U
-em>'
~:5 ~
~ Cl.. 0
Q; iji ~ '0= a
(f)"O ._ <.0
~~1:!: :g
.,.... c w 'a... Q) 0
NOS: rJl 6 r--
~g;~JEc ~
g~~~~ ~
8~~~~;mv
m
o
me
~.!!!
- ~
00.0
~ = '"
0"
2 en lP ~
o u;.s: go
c.oQ)TI~8
"<t Q) ro'- l.O
'<:t ~.o ~
o a... $ '-2;
8E:.c~'
ollJ5:rov
000
a a
000
a a
000
a a
'" '"
lD ill
r_ !_
a a
N N
a a
a a
a 6
000
000
6 ci
~
o
o
N
N
:;: co ~
a; "-
E a
c 0
:;; N
> m
o
Cl ;,
>-
c
~
o
U
~
rn
~ 0
000:
00_
~ ~ 0
"0 ~ ~
U ~ 0:
o
OJ"D.-g Q.)
Effie :S
E v Q.l
~ 00 ~
o~~~
.,.... 5: is ro
(() Qj tIl ~
~ ~8 ~
0%0$
8 E c: ~
ow 0:::::
00
00
o ci
000
000
o ci
'" '"
'" '"
~ ..
'" <D
1-- 1__
00
000
ci 0
00
000
ci ci
"-
o
o
N
N
:;: I'-- ~
C
m ~
E a
c 0
:;; N
> CD u
o __.~
o "<t 0
>-
'E al
6 8 J:
U 0 =
~ 53:~
15 -.. (5
U ~ U
00
000
0: ci
000
a a
000
a a
o .:=;
a a
000
000
000
'1
00
000
ci 0
~
o
o
N
N
:;: 03
c
~ g
:;; N
> 25
c3 ~
>-
c
~
o
U '"
~ ~
""6 e
U ~
05
o
'0
:? '"
'0, ~
00 .0
Ewo
00 0"-
~Ei:5
"515;
'6m9
ro ~ v
'0
-8~
oiO'
~ 0 00
"O~~~ ~
,gc--~'Ef!5
~5.~O~g:;2N
gmQ5~~~~
("') >,..c: ::::: t:: (lJ 0 I.!')
o.Qg!B&;;:g~
gEm (]) ~ t:: ' 8
ow..2:5 0.0... 0
(.,,'s
2.::
<(
f-
tI1
vr
,
D D co co 0 0 ~ ~ "
~ 0
g ~ c. " " " ~ 0 0 0 "
0 "- 00 m .,; " N N
00 m "'
E c- " .n
rn m m 0
- ,.~ "'
LL 15 N N ID 0
- f--
- ~, D
- - 0
,- 7"
,
- " 0
~ TI TI 0 0 0 0 0 ro
~ " 0 0 0 0 0 0
" "- 0; 0; '0
- 6 0 0 0 0 C
- E 0
:u "
>
-
I. ~
:7;
<
ro TI TI 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 ~ ro 0 0 0 0 0 0
m "- 0 0 0; 0; 0 0
~ ~
w u u 0 0 0 0 0 0
:is ~ " 0 0 0 0 0 0
'B 5 "- 0 0; 0 0 0 0
, U
TI E
w
'"
> u '2 0 0 0 0 0 0
~ j " 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 "- 0 0 0 0; 0 0
u
&
Q 0 0 0 0 ,- ,-
" e 0 0 " " 0 0
1':, L 0 ~ " "
co co " ,-
0 -
~ N N
ru u 0 0 0 0 0 0
~ ~' Ci 0 0 0 0 0 0
" L 0 0 0; 0; 0 0
0 ~
x
LU
0 U D co co 0 0 0 0
" ~ Ci " " 0 0 0 0
0 " L 00 00 0 0; 0 0
'" u
.0 E m m
'0
m
"
m ~ c- c-
o 0 0
rn w ID 0 0 0
ID 0 N N
" C N "' m
> rn m CO;
0 LU LU LU
U if> u ~ ;; i:: ~ ;; ro ~ ;; i::
;:
~ c c c
0 w m " m ~
0 u
m e E 0 c c- c-
.... 0: '" c 0 C 0 0
> ID ':' ID 0 ~ 0
i:: m N ':'
rn ~ > u > "' u >
Q) 0 N W 0 W 0 ro
" " "' is' " US is' 0 US
E ~ ~ 0 ~ 0 ;e-
w " u C D
== W ~ ~ 5
0 - " c- "
"- ~ 0 ~ 0 c: 0
Q) 0 0 0 0 c- O ~
" 0 0 0 0
> - m ID ~ ':' ~ 0.0 ~ 0
~ E . w '" ~ N ~ N
0 0 rn " "' ro
rn rn '5 a N '5 a '5 a
'" c.r- z " 0 0 0 "' 0 0 US 0 u US
CI> 0
0:: 0
>. N .w E ID
E m
.... >- ID ;e- m w m m w
i:: '" g > ~ "- ID m rn
U. m ~ m c c c
~ .g 0 E '0 ID ~
:::s ~ u " w 0 j; ID "- 0 " rn '" > c W
U CI> w ~ :.c E 0 "- E 0 ~ rn w ID
ID IJ) :S E E "- ID
0 - '0 U " ID rn "' -" co x rn ~ "
"t:l ~ " ::> c m rn a; " u: m " ID '0 m ~ ..- 0 0 j; ro f...-"'i
U CI> "' ID u w rn '0 rn '0 ~- rn j; 0 '0 m w 'i' ,Q i= E 0
0 rn rn .c ~ 1"','"
:: D u rn iii D 0 0 m CO " c c 0 N 0; ~
"- II) E ~ " ~ " c '6 0 ~ W ID m g> rn 0 ~ ~ N ro 0 g ID "'
.2 0 ID ~ g " m w ~ ~ :::c
.!!1 " ID CO 0 0 > u 0 "- C m '5 0 ill 0 N ID W u E m m 0
W 0 jj a; m 2 ..- 'S E (ii.r: ~ - "' co ID ID 0 C rn ro 0
U ~ z > 0 c E ID N " "- m:; c " 0 "' ~ > 'It 0 ~'E E x 0 ,-
::; U 0 E D ID ~ ID '" " " N -" ro ~ 0 N
0 ~ " ~ w w U "' 0 ~ "- o u g ID .2 co 0 ID u 0 ,Q co 0 (",'1
0 - :: ro '" ro '5 ID w w m .c 'i' 0 .c w c " ID 'i' 0 "- > w 2 E ID '0 'ro 'i' 0
0 E U -0 0 rn '0 0 rn , 0 ~ ID 0 E 2 w rn '0 0 0 0,/"'
:: 0 U 0 ."g ID ;; S ~"
U U LU w U "- ~ iii > 0 '" w f-- j; " 0 LU rn '" '0 'iii c E " 0
<( U. 'L_.
TI TI "' "' 0 0 ~ ~ 0 0 ~ :;;
0
E 0 . "' "' 0 0 N N "' "' 0 <<
'i <L N N 0 0 a; '" '" N N
a; ~
~ ill ill '" '" en 0
ro ~. ~
. 15 N N ~
.~ ~ , I- ~ 0
_.- .0
- 0
L' "0
, I 0
0 0 >.
c ':::J; ~ TI TI 0 0 0 0 0 0 ro
~ . 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
.0 'i <L 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 "
~ 0 0
- ~ U
T E :;;
- ..2
;l\ ~
ro TI TI 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
" ~ ii5 , 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
ID " <L 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
--' u I
E
~ :;
TI -g '" '" 0 0 "' "' ~ ~ 0
~ w c N N " " N N 0 <::
"- '" 0 0 0 eo eo ai ai N N
0 "'
~ " .. CO CO "' "' N N "' 0
ro ~, eo 0 0 0 0
05 <"i <"i "'
?- m 0
~ - .c
p
- -- ~ TI TI 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 '"
~ ro 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 '0
- is 5 "- 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 c
- u 0
~ ~ E :;
;;-7
::r
<
ro TI TI 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
" , ro 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
W ~ "- 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
~
~ ~ '" '" '" '" ro ro 0 ~ ;j;
0 0
u ~ ii ro ro ~ ~ N N N N 0 '"
E 5 "- N ro <ri " " <ri '" N N
E N <D <D m m " " <ri '"
ro ro ro <D <D co co 0_ 0 6
'0 "' <ri '"
f- ID 0
- .0
0
-,.~ n
, 0
,1) ID ~ ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 >.
~~ ~ " 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 m
.c 5 "- 0 0 6 6 6 6 0 2'
" 5 0
u 0
.j':: oS 2
~
ro ~ ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
cr ~ ii 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
w 5 "- 0 0 0 0 0 6 6 0
~ E
w ~ ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
" ~ " 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 5 "- 6 0 6 0 0 0 6 0
0 u
~ oS
w
0
> ~ ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
~ ~ " 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 5 "- 0 0 0 0 0 0 6 0
u E
"
'"
" ~ ~ l!";. '" m m ro ro 0 0
t. 00 ro ~ ,> N N N N
U ro <ri " " oi <ri
:0 ~ N N <D <D m 0' " "
~ ro ro <D <D co co 0 0
'" <ri
-
::
Q)
E
::
...
Q)
>
o
C>
>.
-
::
~
o
U
...
Q)
o
U
~
~
o
c.....
",0
O::i'l
=>-
",u.
U~
"Ct:
'" '"
VI "
,20
~:2
~ "
" 0
<tu.
w
~
~
0-
X
W
~ ~
(!) ii;
"-
~
0-
E
o
.s,>
:5
'0
w
;j;
~ ~
~ m
5 "-
u
oS
w
cr
m ID
ID ~ "E
6 ro C'I:l
u ii5 u
'"
t
o
0-
W
'"
W
ro
o
w
w
o
~
o w
w w
E w 0
rn ro C'I:l
zoo
u
w
W
o
ID U
E ill ~
:::J C ID
Z w >
E ~ ~
"m 0 E
U u w
00
00
o 0
00
00
00
o 0
00
00
00
o 0
60
<?
00
o 0
60
00
00
00:
00
00
66
00
00
ci c:i
w
,
~
o
o
N
NW
:; 03-,
~
o
o
N
23
:;;r co ~
:; OJ
~
o
o
N
"
~
o
o
<:::'
:; 03 ~
"
2! b-g
cor;
ID ~ ~
> ro "
o "
0;:::: :5
~
"
~
" u
w ri'i
E ~ ~
c 0 c
:;; 0 =
> ~ 0
o co '"
C) co OJ
c
"
u
m
00
"
W "-
Eo
c 0
ID N
> 23
o co
CJ ro
>
"
o
o "-
o g
~ ~
"
o ro
"
w r-- ~
E o-!:!
c 0 ~
w ~ ~
> co "
o ~ ~
~ f'- '0
> c
" '"
o
o
o
o
<
~
.;;
:5
>
"
o
o "- I
U g _
~ ~ ~
'0
o
I......:I:
o ,
o 0
j? ~:~
"0 ~ '5
o ~ 0
>
"
o
o
u b ~
~ 00
(5 g ~
o ro 0
_0
"-0
w
m
~ E .g;
nJ CI:l CIl (i)
~ ~~ ill
.~ ~ -5 g'
Owe 5i 0
~.~~:{l ~
~i!!.Q' ~ .;::
E ~ .9--5 09
sg;a5.2.g",
"
w
C1j -ro"><:
ro cu c ro
- c 0 C.
~ c.. co (f) (/) b
E~~w~~w.,...
0.2 Vl:..c ~ (/)..... mO
00 w 0 ill 0 - ("{l ro I'-
l!)@~>cg;=rog
U"') .-. _ >, ro >. III OlN
g~~~-D~~1?b
oEoo~E~""'o"-
oLLluUww>_"<t
w~
~Eu__ w
~rs.s~o~
o u 1J) C C c
..QtEwown..
U1cu.cJ::rn(\)
~.b-g.S::::= ;;
~Q)~rn..!!:l~o b
o~..c g-.~..c QJ . ("')
NO?::...... Iii I- 0>..Q;I 0
o c.. ~ l/) > E .!::? ~
8 E 0 ro Q).E ('Il i5,--
ow-o.9-:SE<:l>"<t
w
" m w
8 :::: ~
w- a; e-1?
ID >-w 1I')
E..Q c n.i
N E EW-o
~:::lwc..c
~~E~~
me -
o i!! o,:s;z ~
8 E e g (l)
osa....oD:::
~
m
m
~ ~ ~
"0 ~N
Q) Eo to
~ E 8 ffi
(\j ro:! ~
TI ~;g :;
2 (l) I 8
1ii:5 '<S' 0
<D
m
"
;::
(.ll
~
~
'..,
,<--
__I ;-
-:"" ~,
~_ -;:u
" ~
- -
-
::
Ql
E
...
>:
Ql
>
o
C>
>.
-
::
:J
o
U
t::
o
""....
0>0
tr:~
=>-
~u...
U c;;
-
-0 ~
0> ell
If) "
,20
u
...
.91
o
u
:::
o ~
- "
" 0
<(u..
~
ro
'0
f-
~ ~
3 '"
E
~
~
is
~ ~
~ m
5 '"
E
ro
cr.
ill
-"
~ ~
~ m
5 '"
u
E
'"
:e
t5
~
'"
o
u u
~ m
5 D-
E
>
~
8
ill
"
~ ~
D-
o
~
":::l e::-
II "-'
~
~
ru
~
~
x
w
~
"
- '"
r
g
<5
"
15
TI
ill
::;
~ u
~ ro
5 D-
E
ill
cr
~ ~ .~
> m ro
8 if) u
>"
<5
"
ill
'"
ill
rn
co
"
"
o
-"
Ol) 0 Ol)
>= Ol) ~
ro ro ro
zoo
u
"
'"
o
~ 0
~ '- (.)
c ~ <:.(
::J W a;
Z U b
!; tn n
ro 0 E
U U llJ
'" '"
00 00
o 0
'" '"
00
00
00
ci 0
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
o 0
o 0
~ ~
CJ 0:'
~ ~
; C;
g :s
o ~
o ~
o ~
00
w
,
~
o
o
N
ro
"<t m ~
t5
5
c
~
~
~
o
o
~
"
"
'" ,-
~ g
~ ~ u
o '"
c.:J 03 g
%' "0
o ~
o b u:::
00
~ ~ ~
-0 0
U co u
~.SI2-o
v; 0 ClJ 9:>
~ ~~ ~
ClJ C 0 U
ClJ ::J 2 III
~Ctn~ 00
~g~~ b~
"" 0)- ii l!) <.0
~ C ro co 0
.E;; - C 9 0
S~~,g~'<:t 25
'"
,-
co co
N N
(<") C"'i
;:r; ;:r;
00
00
c:i c:i
00
00
o ci
00
00
ci 0
o 0
o 0
o 0
co co
N N
co co
"' "'
00
o 0
ci 0
00
00
c:i ci
~
o
o
N
i':
"'w
" cr>,
C
ill ~
E 0
c 0
~ i3 u
o co '"
;.rog
c ~
o x
o b u:::
o 0 c
~ ~]
o -0
U en U
,"0
= '"
..;.;: Vi
ii:im
.0 ~
~tn
~ ro
"''D
~2
Q[j)
>>"
c c
W ro
u
ru
>
" 0
ro Q.ro
~ ~~~o
N ~
i2 ZB % iij c
o (j) E C ~
I'- :e Q) 0 ClJ
o.S12 ~~
8~~~
00
,,0
o..c
""
"' co
"' "'
cr> cr>
<D <D
NN
00
00
o 0
00
00
o ci
o 0
o 0
ci 0
o 0
o 0
o 0
l[J LD
LD L.'!
(7- C,
l!':,O
N "
o 2>
o 0
o 0
00
00
ci 0
,-
o
o
N
"'
'<:t en ~
~ 8
l' 0
~ N
:> ?, U
ON",
~ro~
o ~
o b u:::
00
~ ~ ~
o ~"O
U co:.)
on
c
'mID
ro "
E c
~E8
0:...... N
E 60 l!)
.3..::: b en
~:E ~ ~
Ql ,gJco 0
:g ~ ~ 8
E -5.... 0
N N
'" ~
co co
"' "'
00
00
ci 0
o 0
00
c:i c:i
00
00
ci ci
00
00
c:i c:i
N ~
,- ~
co co
co "'
~ 0
00
o ci
00
00
ci ci
~
o
o
N
03
:.;; OJ ~
~
c g
ru ~ '"
c 0
C 0 OJ
~ ~ ~
o NO:
Cl co cil
>. ~
C u
o ro
o ~ '"
U g C
~ ~ ~
ON "0
U co u
'"
"~ -0
~ C
U ro
ro
.0 05
~ "
ro "
~ u
~ ~
~=
0_
<'>0
E '0
W 0
g>
"
~~o
.om"
~ ru c
ro 13 Q.l
~ $: i: Q.l
Q.lClJ-5
OClJ>-o
N.2%,~
oc.::J (.)
8~8~
"'
co
N
;';0
o~
"0
m~
~oo
g9
- ~
;,;"
ru
~~'5Q.l
~D~
.- (I)-Ill
"OJ,~ oI:S
6-o~
:5 "~ '5
:>.:~ ~
~ ~"~
",,~
e ~ ~
;; co
00 00
" "
co. co
~ ::;
0",
ON
N "'
.no
"'
~ 0
."
00
00
00
~
m
"
c
o
::;
00
00
o ci
00
00
00
00
00
c:i ci
co co
00 '"
~ ~
M, M
~ 0
~ 0
00
00
00
ci ci
~
o
o
N
"'
:.;; ~
C
ru ~
E 0
c 0
ID ~
>
o
'" Oi
~
C
o
o I-
o g
~ 23
<5
Om
ill
=
rn
"
~ "M
ro(j)~
D ~
ro V; 0 ~
o oJ) 1--- C"')
.......r::. 0 OJ
c...... 0 ('")
:.; "6 en 0
~"'O 90
"2 ai:.;; g
l/'":\
c:::
<(
r-
l.ll
'VI"'"
~ ~ eo eo "' "' 0 0 0 0 ,~ :2
0; 0
0 ~ " m m "' "' "' "' '" V V 0 "
E 5 "- oj "' oj oj 0 0 N N ci 0 N N
"'
U "' "' .... .... '" '" 0 0 "' '" "' ci
ro E N N .... .... "" eo v_ " N N
-. a " "'" "'
- e- O; ci
- .D
0
-' 1:5
, ~ 0
l' 0; ~ ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~
~ '''., ~ " 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ro
~ 5 "- ci 6 6 0 0 ci 6 ci '0
15 0 0 c
- - u 0
E :2
- 6
-,>
ro ~ ~ i 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
IT ~ " 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
w 5 "- 0 0 ci 6 ci ci ci 0 ci ci
~ E
-
:::
a>
E
,..
i:
a>
>
o
C-'
>.
-
:::
::::
o
U
...
.!!!
o
U
-
~
o
0......
",0
0::0
N
~>-
",u..
- ~
u'"
-o~
'" '"
'" :::
.20
u_
ot:
- :::
::: 0
<Cu..
.
;g
1:3
c
~
.
o
~ ~
~ rn
5 "-
~
>
~
o
u
3!.
~ ~
~ ~
E
c
u
i3
2
~
~
(jj IT
"-
.
if'
ill
2
x
W
12 ii:
3 "-
E
2
E
o
.<2
.0
i3
w
:2
~ ~
~ rn
5 "-
u
E
.
IT
~ ~ .~
E; ro ro
u U) 0
'"
t
o
Q
W
'"
W
rn
o
w
w
o
~
Q) <5 Q)
E Q) ~
co rn ro
Z 0 ()
o
w
W
o
0; U
-0 W :i.
~ c w
z w >
E ~ -5
Om 0 E
(3 () LLI
00
00
ci 0
00
00
ci ci
00
00
00
00
00
ci 6
eo eo
m 0'
"' ro
en I..'l
N N
"' "'
ro "'
oj "'
1-- I.....
1-- 1'-
5 ~
o 0
00
00
00
o 0
o 0
00
00
00
o ci
w
~
,~
o
o
~
~ f2 ~
....
o
o
N
;::
N ~ W
V "' ~
1:3
w
E'
o
~
ID
X
"
5
g;
'0
u
c
w ....
E 0
e 0
0; N
> ?;
c3 ?i
c
w ....
Eo
e 0
W ~ u
> " m
o No
(9 ~::
~ w
c .3
o
o
U
~
5
o ....
U ;5 ~
~ ~ ~
'0 e
() ?i ~
....
0_
0",
~ ~ ~
"5 Q! to
() "u
m.
e u
:..;;:: ro c
U Q.. Q)
.2; (I) E I'--
tn ~ ~ 0
~ i2 ro 0
ID ro ~ r--
Q.l a. U Q) 0
>'C02Q.N
-6.0: W "o..C;;
Es-g~~
W 0 ro ~ "<t
'0
ro
~
ro ~
e'" 0
000
""@Q3:i;c:o
"::;';-50
rl."Q -g;;
~ g~ ~b
~iii~E
N"O......ro~
gQl3~9
0_9- 0 C N
oll.Uro"<t
ro
.
]? ro
~ Qj >,
"OO"i::W"QUl
!:l ~ Ol..c u::! ~
zwc~.S.~ OJ
o g :5 e .s ~ Q) g
;1; a;~~~r- ~u~
LO ~ OJ CO 5:..9;! Q) (]) N
o a. E "0 ..9;! .~ 1:: '5 ~
8Ero8:.c-a50Q..N
OW"O..c5:>c~'V
00
00
ci 0:
00
o 0
o ci
00
00
o 0
00
o 0
o 0
00
"' "'
ci 0
'" '"
eo ""
....
o
o
N
N 2? w
"<t r,-::y
c
C .
~ f'- g
e 0 ~
e 0 -
W N ~
2; ~ ~
(j (D ~
m
w
OS
~
c
o
o ......"0
U ;5]i
~ ~ ~
0: N s:
U ;:0 S
e ~
ro ~ u
'0 0 ro
~ E U
'-tlJClI-oCTl
.g:.c-g]1;!;
w __ ......c
u:; Q. 0 ID (/) 0
C")Q)C6~1::;
~ ~~;;;.~ f.3
2J..QQl'Oa>t.D
is E ~-g:5 ~
o UJ S rn S """
00
00
ci ci
00
00
c:i c.i
00
00
o ci
00
00
00
'" '"
N N
00
" "
-q- '<i
g g
o 0
00
00
00
go
00
o
-;-
00
00
ci ci
00
" "
ci 0
"' ro
N N
....
o
o
N
;::
~ 03 ~
....
o
o
N
N
~ 00
c
W ,~
E 0
eO
0; N
> ?;
o N
19 <D
~
C
o
o
()
c
w ....
E 0
c 0
0; N
> "'
o N
19 ;::
~
m
.... 0
00:
0",
~ Q! 0
"0 ~ ~
() "''''
~
5
o ....
u g
] S5
'0 N
U <D
-0-0 .8
Q) ro en OJ
TI 2 CIJ c
rn Q) 5: ":;"
.DoC Q).J::: Q) ..-
Ul-XQ)=
C\l 0 C\l .- c
o~Q)'-~o 00
..- ..... C) rn ;0. I'- ;;::;
~"--o~-oTI 0
.....:n:Q)Q)lt2~~C"l
"-..::.::: Q)';::; C\l ~ <.D V
go';::; E:.=u90
g~15~{l ~e~ g
(,./"l
C:::
;::
.
Vl
~
D D " " ... ... ... 0;
E ~ " 0 '" 0 <i
"- 0
~ 0 0 ;;; ;;; N N
m 0> co
ro ''c ... '" '" uO 0
" ,,; '" '"
~ - f-- '" '" ID 0
- ~, - "
~ 0
'- ""
: ,
- ,.
]; ::;; J! D D 0 '" 0 0 >.
~ ~ iii 0 0 0 0 ro
(J' 0 5 D- o 0 ci ci ~
u c
CL .EO 0
b 0;
- ~
::;;
<
rn D D 0 0 0 0
" ill rr. 0 0 0 0
W " D- o 0 ci ci
-" :g
-
i::
ClJ
E
i::
ClJ
>
o
~
>.
-
i::
::l
o
()
~
f-
o
a.r-
.,0
o::~
E>-
.!!iLl..
U.,
't:l~
., III
ill '"
00
U
::;
o f-
~ '"
'" 0
<CLl..
.....
ClJ
o
()
w
"
~ ~ ~
6 ro ro
o ~ ()
o
"
w
'"
w
ro
o
~
~
o
~
CIJ 0 (])
c w ~
@ rn ~
Z 0 U
u
~
w
o
ID 0
~ w ~
3 C ID
Z c3 b
C if) a.
rn 0 E
U u w
OJ
::J
c
.
o
c
~
c
co
ru
0>
"
m
w
OS
D
"
"
'E
"
~
ro~
~Vi
W~
" C
(5 ~
c w
g;=
~
.Q~
"0
E ro
OJ "
,-
o
o
N
N ~ u.J
"<t OJ..,
0; ...
c 0
C '"
ID ~
>
ON
'-' ro
~
C D
o m
o ... 0
U go::
j Z3 0
o N ~
U co 0::
.8
rn
E~
6 ro
If)
~.8
'> w
~ro
;;;
~ w
~ .~
OJ,g ~ :S ~
C (1J 0 D
~ ~ ~ -0 1ij ~
.~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
_ C\l Q.l C (I) ,
612~~:O~~~
~ g &5 ~ 'gj ~ g 15 .2
-o~t:0oT""~8.-g~(J)~
Co O-roroou
2Ngc,--Q)C..c~
ro""ow2"Vio~.c
'-.
~
."
~
M
"
~
"
1""'.....
w
ro
-0
I-
"
"
i5
(-<"
::::
l/'l
V
u u 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 ~ ::;
0
E ~ " 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 <<
5 D- o 0 0 0 0 0 ci ci N ..
E .. " .. .. u-i
" <D
'0 ~
;.!;.:.. ;-~ C- O; 0
~ .0
0
U
, ,:'.] 0
0; u u 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 >.
.~ S:: ~ " 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 rn
2 .0 5 D- o 0 0 0 0 0 ci ci '0
is 0
u 0
, E ::;
?~'
~z
~;
" u u 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
" ~ " 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
ID 5 D- o 0 0 0 0 0 ci ci
-' u " " .. ..
E
-
t:
ell
E
t:
....
ell
>
o
Cl
>-
-
t:
:::l
o
U
....
ell
-
~
o
a.
'"
c::
E
~
CJ
"C
'"
lIJ
o
U
z....
"- 0
:":0
.eN
.!:!! >-
-'Ll..
lIJ ~
",,&
.- ~
.~ ctl
- "
00
"..::
=t:
.e"
" 0
O-Ll..
o
U
ID U U 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
:e ~ " 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
U 5 D- o 0 0 0 0 0 ci ci
0 u
u E
ID
0
~ u u 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
ill ~ " 0 0 0 0 o. 0 0 0
> ] "- 0 0 0 0 0 0 ci ci
8
2!.
'0 u u 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
, " 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
u "- 0 00 0 0 00 00 ci ci
TI ~
"
~
ID
~
ill
Q
X
W
u u
~ ro
"-
~
Q
E
o
!2
ii
TI
ID
::;
u u
9! 'm
5 D-
E
ID
"
~ ~ .~
E; rn ro
() if.) u
'"
t
o
Q
ID
0:
ID
rn
o
"
"
o
-'
(l) 0 0)
E Q) ~
ctl m ro
Z 0 U
u
"
ID
o
0; U
.0 CD:i
~ C ID
Z ID >
E ~ ~
'm 0 E
U () w
00 0
00 0
00
00
00
00
g g
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
~
o
o
N
o ~ UJ
<D ~,
~
o
o
N
03
0_ W
<D ~,
~
o
o
N
o ~ LLJ
<D ~,
~
o
o
N
:;,
Oi
<D
o
o
N
in
<D
o
o
N
U '"
o ~
'" <D
o
o
in
"
ID
'0
o
U
~
<1;
I'
,
0;
c- ~
<Ii is
.~ ~
Il. <1;
~
u
Jj ~
1:: ~
"';0
.~ t:!
0,"
w
o
o
N ~
o "
o~
N ID
_ U
~ "
03~
'"
o ~
.0 0
rn _ "
~ gs 2 is
,--LlC :;:;"7
0.... (l) U to
'- 00 !lJ co...-
o~~Q."'Oc8
o02~8Q)r.o
Mo2~illOlE:J;
coO:::::i::J'_C~N
C'1 D.~ ~ g. '6 0 8
r-;' g"'O '- ~ a3 c 6
;::; 0 <:( .2 u a.. UJ (0
c
o
"0 (l) c t
~Q) ;(J)Q)
m"5 (!) = E
U;:@~.8:5c7)~
~(j)ECIl,-"O..-
<n6-o~~.2'~8
.,....u~i-.8-go8
C;;b~.8~.80~
o-c2~~.!.":E~
8 J!:I '!! c 0 III 'm 6
OUE.z2~o(.O
o
eE!
>. c Cii
~:'Q';:
"''0 0
e__ (/)
o a.. 2.~
...- Q) (/) Q.
5S5li>8~
o CIl (/) CD ClI
;; ~'~""Q E
8~~2~
0<(<( o..~
(5 g
ci 6
o 0
00
ci 0:
E
'm
(3
M
~
.
<5
>-
"
;;
"
(,.,"')
D:::
;'=
~1
<
0 0 ,- '"
~ ~ 0 N N 0 0:; 0:; 0 "
~ W " 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
'i 0- 0 0 a) a) en en " " N N
~ U v V N N en en N
ro E en en a) a). "- ,~ en a)
15 ~ ~ .n .n en
e- O; 0
- ~' D
- - 0
"- - ,
":;::-J
- :!' 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
- , :0 jj ~ ~ 0 ii
~ m 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 '0
::t' -::: ,!- i5 5 0- 0 0; 0; 0; 0; 0 0; 0; c
-- u 0
(1', E '"
- -
"
-
<'
ro ~ ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
IT ~ " 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
ID 5 0- 0 0 0; 0 0 0 0 0;
~ u
E
u u 0 0 '" '" ~ ~ :;;
0
U ill " 0 0 '" '" ~ ~ 0 '"
S 3 Q ~ ~ ,,; ,,; '" '" N N
U '0 '" '" '" M M N
ro E 0 0 '" '" ~ .... '" '"
0 N N of of "'
f- ~ ~ ii; 0
- .0
0
':') U
_.,~ 0
ii; U U 0 0 0 0 0 0 >.
.= g,' ~ rn 0 0 0 0 0 0 ro
.2:' -=.' ~ " Q 0 0 0 0 ci ci '0
0 C
U 0
.:I; E :;;
~S
i2
~
ro u u 0 0 0 0 0 0
" ~ " 0 0 0 0 0 0
ill " Q 0 0 0 0 ci ci
-' u
E
,_::T(.."1
.~::-.::
-;- j~
(j" -:::: .-r-
=' = ,,1
~" .r
-: "
-...:;
:J.' .::...
<-
F,' _,
-
:::
Cl)
E
,..
<::
Cl)
>
o
"
>.
-
:::
::l
o
U
...
.!!!
o
u
u'O"C
l:: ~ ";
tC::Ic..
o U
....5
Qj"'tl"'tl
~ ~";
o~a.
U
.5
-"C"C
~ ~";
~ " 0.
-' ,
U
.5
"'"C"C
ii; e ";
> " 0.
o ,
U U
~ 0
"'-
c;'g:Q
u t::: ~
a ~
0..5
'0
o
~'O"C
~ ~ 'tij
~~a.
" "
w-=
c.."'C:E,
E ~ ro
o " 0.
~ ~
iDE
'0
~
'"
~
'"
~ Ul Qi
~ ~.~
u</)u
o
Oc-
,,"0
c:: "
>
l= 0
.= l=
'" -
- "
UC::
"0 '"
" "
'" -
o =
- '"
uz
"C
~
> ~
o ~
E 0
~-'
"'0
~ ~
E oS ::I
m m m
ZClU
,26
,,0
",N
=>-
"u..
Oc~
l= "
o ~
u ~
.", 0
~
".t:
-"'t::
<5 :l
s:~
u
~
~
Cl
~ U
~ " U
E~c.::
:i Q) ~
U 0
E(i)Q.
~ 0 E
uuw
;2::':
rr: .,
" ~
:;::,
~ ~
6:::;
00
00
00
00
gg
00
00
00
00
;: ~
[c-J i"
-
'"". ~
c: ~
~
c:;~~
"
~
ii"
E
-
o
0.
~
'"
~
ro
Cl
~
o
o
;:~
N
?i
~
~ ~
2 ~
?jJ;
""1i
-
~ ~
m
" -
~ 'm
3.0-
g'~
un
m =
w m
~ ~ g 5-
<.D </) ~ '='
~ ~ g ~
co a; (j) ~ </)
(;) ~ g;., G:i ~
8~~~~
o25WC1:
oc w
'""'''',
i' g
55
60
00
00
00
00
co
00
00
00
00
~ ?'
r-- r:::-
~,
- "
c~ ~
,~
o
o
N
c:; 2 l.LJ
w,
0;
'5
~ ~
G.I 8
n <l:
~
0;
>
~
g .5
G.I 2
N c:
~ -S
C3 <<
w
w
,;:
o
-Dm
~-5
_ w
o'ro
n -
= -
o "
2<3
;;; m
w
~ m
!2"S
=-..>t:
W 0
~ 2 :;
" m
C/) cO 0>
m m ~
S: S: D.
(j) -0 E
(j) c 2
Scum
(i i\5 ttl
C 0 ro
wa:: s:
o
oc
w
20
o-
r" '-0
Nm
S;g
00
o
LL' 1.;:)
m m
(Y";
Lr; 11';
00
00
00
00
00
00
o
00
00
o
o _
00
-
~~ ~-~
!~
,~
GJ
c ,:.:; ~
~
'"
~
"
" CG
z
>
o
~
~
N n:
~ (f)
-<t :f:
W
<F. ~
~ .;:
g~
ij~
D
~ -2
w "
c=
m'"
_n
3 =
ro
c; -g lil
~ g~
;2 ~ [j).D
o w ~
NO ell.D
:; 23 ~ ~
9 g E-:g
~ 0 wE
,:,,, C'-J
- ~
(V; ~
1-- 1__
5 g
o 0
o 0
o 0
o 0
~ :5
o 0
g g
o 0
cc :<::
o
cc' 2-
~
L.: 1.;:'
L--:. L:.
~ ~.
~
o
o
N
~ l.LJ
~ O?;; --,
~
'"
03
o
~
o
o d)
0.J Ci.
M 9-
0, Uj
o
"!
]!~
~
:.c ro
no
15 0
r e
o 0
~-5
=
" 0
<.0 ~ g-
~ ~~
i2 ~ ~ 5
8 2 ~ ellE
1..0 :; a. ro
9 0 _ U
0::: ell
~ ,=' W.D
co
Lf'j l;-)
~ ;::
c
00
00
00
00
00
06
00
00
06
00
00
00
N N
6 "
,-
;:_ c'_
,~
~
N
~
~ ~
"'
c5
'"
~ ~
1~"5 (I.'
5
o
o
o
.
0;
Q m
N
N ?
0.J ii:
l;) :.)
~
ro
g:g,
~ ~
'0 0
D .
~~, l
~ ~ g
>= .D ~
iii :u D
0=
~ _ m
rn 2:: ~
S: .!:!2 ~
r-- <1J ..I:: U
OJ ill. m
6 ~ ~ g- ~
'::::, G.I ~ 3-5
t'88 a3 ;; ~
~ G.I (I) U ell
o g :C"2 ~
o is ~ 5i E
~
o J)
,~ r___
r'-. r___
00
00
00
g8
60
gg
60
00
00
06
qc
'" ~
~
~- ~-
?;:J
G2
~
o
o
N
;;:
oc--co~
~
o
o
~ "',
(D ~
~
Q
"0
r-- ::
g ~
~ ~
N 0
l?J a::
"
~ {I)
~QjOl
.!:: D c:
g':e .c
(j) ~ ~
..c -= U
W
- ~ 0
_ a-
m aD
c..:: 1'=
-0 CJ';iii
OJ"::: ttl
o 0_
o = 0
OJ ~D.. C
'-0 (J):>>ell
~ ;z'? E
o c:;J QJ.:!:. ell
;:: 2D OJ:il i;
~ g g;, iii- E
l!"; 0..... 01
OO(i>=.~
ogJj,g~
-.::- oct
~ ~
00
00
06
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
80
;223
,-
(" ('I
%' ?
,-
~
'"
"
ONW
" ,
~
o
o
~
'"
w
a
a
~
D
n
ro
o
r
o
<5
c
o
~
o
2
~ til
o w
ro
o If) S:
~ '" Q)
<0 '-0 (j)
N m ~
L0 ;; 0
9g~
~oW
co
00
~. ~
00
00
00
00
00
60
00
00
00
g8
60
'C';. ,.,..,
~ ('-oJ
L(; [f';,
0::' C:'
,~
,___ 1"-
L7 Ci;
N. G.I
~
'"
f;I
2~~
"
~
o
o
N
Oi'
"'
u
o
5
~O
o ~
om
N x
"' 0
~ ;:
Lr; Vi
~
o
oi:
~ .~
2;(j)
o
"
"
m
E
o
o
W
~
"
o n
m 1i
g 9-
o~u;
~ ~ w
o w
8 M ~
98g-
.,...8LlJ
r0 (")
L..') L..0
~
o
" r0
~~
- ~~;
E -=' .~'-'
5~
~ 0
~:g 8
ZOci
00
00
06
00
00
00
~, (V'";.
cr.' <.0
i2ill
0'; ?;-,
~:;
c,
~
'"
N
Os
Gr.::::~
~
o
o
N
'"
<0
~ "
8 ~
N<<I
cog
0'"
o
ru
~
o
a
E
o
ID
u
E
o
>
ill
E
~
~
~
8M
~ ~
OM
ro~
0'"
~
';' ::;
00
o
00
N N
N N
roro
MM
00
00
00
00
00
cic:i
00
00
60
00
00
60
~ :2
co
o ~;
L.(; L.(;
,,," ":
~
o
o
"
...-w~
~
o
o
N
Co
N
i.D~
z
..
>
.
~
b g?
o ro
N '"
OJffi
"' ~
~
ill
""
~
~=
u2
E~
o c
= m
m~
00
~ ~
~ ~
s~
o
N
o
i2~2
o ~ .
~ M 0
:is ~o eo
ClGG
60 i=
ow
Lf'; L..')
~ ~
('] r0
ro ro
00
00
06
00
00
cic:i
00
00
60
00
00
00
~ ~
a; CD
M ("'.
~ ~
N ~
L.(; L..')
L..; ~,
2; R.
~
8
N
a
02~
~
o
o
N
co
N
o
13
o
E
~ 0
o ~
om
N ~
Co 0
N 2
i.Di7l
"-
m
'"
"
~
rn
m
D
~
D
D
E
o
;;
]!
c
o
~
u
o
;:::; -;;;
o ~
o:g: 5:
~ M 0
o ~ 0
N '" ~
~o%
625 E
oW
;;
o
~
~
c
'"
"
.
~
..
~~
~. ~
,- ~
oc 00
00
00
00
00
00
06
00
00
06
00
00
60
:::
~~
N N
,-
."., C'~
~
'"
N
o
or::::~
~
o
o
N
?3
N
<0 0
o
B
o
o
~ ro
o ~
0'"
r:< -'"
M U
0J 2
<.;3i7l
ro
D
D
rn
rn
'"
c
ro
~
m
'"
~
~ g'
C'\l ~'c
N U m
o :J'p
00 ii; U
t-... (0 w-P
~;: ~~
9 g 9- 13
o 0 I:: :J
ow":;
00
N N
~~
N N
00
00
00
00
00
06
00
00
'0 c:i
00
00
00
?;~
~ ~-
&;3?'
g, 0:;
~
is
N
::J ~ ~
~
o
o
N
"'
N
<0
u
~ -~
'"
N m
~ ~
[D <:
~
..
~
25
'"
3
2G U;
o ~
o ~ 5:
~ CD ~
N '" ~
ill ;; 0
6g~
ow
0;0;
oc ro
~ ~
'" '"
00
qo
00
00
00
60
00
00
00
00
00
06
~
oc ro
,- ~
,7
'7 2
~, L"
~. L..--)
~
25
'''"
"
O~~
2
ro
~
o
o
N
"
N
~~
Z
]
o
~ ~
o ~
~ liS
<0'"
" ro
\.c. u..
o c
o ~ ~
..Q J:: C
N ~~
(lJ]ijji
>=:J (lJ
0'<-- w
-= (lJ ro
~ 5 ~
6 --0 iD
~ 0 E
g',~'ffi
5..-= ~
a} 1> 8
~ U; c CD
o ~ ~-5
C; :2 5: 5: E
b ('] CD ID 2
<.0 ~ W --0 ~
~ 2'-g29-
:% g ~~-g ~
oW 11) (lJ.c
00
00
60
00
00
06
00
00
60
00
00
60
00
00
06
is E
00
c c'
~
o
o
N
00
o2~
~
o
o
N
0;
~
~
o
o ~
N 0
05 %i
Sf
o
ill
.
'0
o
~
~
N ru
m U).
o 0 ill
~u
~ ~ ~ j
N l.() >, (lJ
~:; % w
6gcD~
~ M
N N
N N
:}) OJ
,...--, M
'-fi1.O
00
00
60
00
00
00
00
00
60
00
00
06
2: 05
C": c<)
~
" ~
S ~
c-rJ rv;.
L:') "'-)
,-
o
o
N
cD
oc'\lw
r::: ...,
~
o
o
N
M
;:.::
~
c
E
u
m
..
..
E
.
~
00
~ ~
Ri ~
<Ow
rn
E
o
~
go
'"
m
..
o ~
01'
c 0
.2 8
o 0
- ~
n-
o ~
OD
8.~
~ ~ ~
00"'" :)) ~ 0
.q- 5: t
t-... C0 W (lJ
o <.D W ~
01 '-D >-w
N 0 ~
i:€ g u (lJ
o5Jj~
00
~ ~
~~
~~
~r0
00
00
00
00
00
cici
g8
00
00
00
00
a;~
:=
goo
~ ~,
~
o
o
~
,-
~~~
~
o
o
N
?3
"
u
w
Z
~
00
o 5
N 0
if; 0
N "
<DW
m
g
~
c
'"
rn
..
m ~
ruE
E 0
.2 8
o 0
-~
n -
o ~
mD
8.~
;? ~ ~
o ~ 0
;; OJ 5:--E
r--;:;; <lJ (lJ
~ ~ g;.,;
<.D;;%fJ1
60 E (5
8wu;
M(")
~ ~
'" 00
00
~ ~
00
00
06
00
00
c:i c:i
00
00
c:i c:i
00
00
06
00
0) 0-:'
~ ~
:-") "")
.".. '7
~ CD
0') a
L..') Ll";
~
o
o
N
CO
8 __ UJ
~ >
~
o
o
N
?3
"
u
w
z
~
g ~
0.1 if.
a; 0
N "
<Ow
m
E
,g
~
c
'"
rn
..
m "-
ruE
~ 8
.2 9:!
TI~
ru ~
mD
8-~
x c
ru .
~ 0
i2 ~ ~ ~
as i:R ~-;;;
~o%~
68~.g
~
~
o
L..') iD
~u
~ ~
~ m
00
N
00
00
00
00
00
60
00
00
00
00
00
60
N N
~, Lf';
~R
I'") '.
,..--;, ~
E. ~,
o
o
"'
o;:::~
u
w
z
~
o
o .
N n
ZD 8
" '"
o
]
03
>
!'- ~
015
o 0
N C
g ~
W<(
~
u
2
"
6
~
c
:g
c
m
.
o
o
~c
o rn
g-u
iD ~
J?2
- m
C t Ol
r-- ?!S B W
g~o]J
c.o 0 Ol ~
80 W 0
o is ~ ~
~
co
o
("";. cor;
N ('0.;
W W
,>oJ N
-::;;:0-
--;''-
"'::;'--.,1
:@B
o
i~'J
- ...;.'
-, ..;.
:::: 0
ZaB
00
00
00
6::::i
00
00
00
;;:::;:
:::':-r;
~ k
:;:: -,
N
CO
~ r:.:: ~
'6
c
l'
"
".
.
~
o
c
e-
ill
25
co ~
co ill
o 0
;; 0 0
~ U
00 "
~::;j: [lJ
~ 0 :;;
000
000
00
l,(; L!";
C ::;'J
L.C' l,(;
00
00
06
00
00
00
00
00
00
58
00
3?2i
L!"' L.:":
~
6 ~
o a;
s:; ~
" -
5-
w
;:;
"-
6
~
o
o
N
iO
"
~
0-
o
N~
~ ~
" 0
o
o
E
o
~ ~
ow
o ~
t! "
LJ") 2
r:.:: if)
:co
o ('>oJ 6 n:;
~~~g'
LIS ~ u 2:
;2 0 m-6
9 is .2: ~
~ 0 <i :;;
2' 1'-
l;) l(;
L!"J l,{)
~'-I N
B8
00
00
00
00
58;
00
B8
00
~ ~
e,;;.lt!
~ L[',
,
,,0'-1
~
'"
N
en
ON W
" ,
~
o
o
2'
r:.:: ~
Z
ill
>
ill
~
t'- ~
g ii:
N co
2' m
" ~
l'
%
1i
"
~
~
v-
"ill
~
%ci
c 13
ill rn
;:
o "
2'l.')~E
O~
~ro
OM
~ 0;
00
Co 0
o
c?:;?;
~ ~
",. '"
58
00
66
00
55
00
00
00
00
,. ~
r>oJ ,-.;
~ "7
~
~
o
o
N
"
Or::~
~
o
o
<::.::J if
W
;::::: ~
;;
~
~.
"
~ ,
8 U
':'-I.g
~ 0
.. 0
".
5
o
a,
C
ill
>
~
5
o
o
g'
.. ill
rn ~
5:~
..
~~
~
o
7
;: 7
~~
~o
6 g
:r; 0
i;)~
~j
7
G:.-' G:.-'
N r,
o
0_
00
00
00
00
50
00
gg
68
;;:: ,.....
">oJ
'0.:::' L
"
o
o
'"
oj
-, ~ ~
is
,~
OJ
u
,..... *'
3
~
o
t:::; ~
is m
N ~
~ G
r:.:: if)
~
"
ro
ill
u
~
""
"
ill
~
~.
S ~ ~
::; 0 0
~ '~~
o ill-
~ ill C
........ 00
5o= v;
if, ~ Q.)
Q; m:5
~ 8 ~
('I;g~
g ~ i€
~ 51?
t'- (fj Q191
<fl (/) =
~g~~o
o ~ :r; ----' oj
('>oJ <.D > ro 2 Q.)
;;o%Q~g,
cg~~~~
~
~
ill
<i'
ill ::;
~g'
~C5
~o
o u
0.0
2: :;
w 0
w, a:
o
;:os~
00
Co 0
00
00
00
00
00
00
ci::::i
00
00
00
~ ~-
~
o
N
o~~
~
o
o
N '.IJ
:.3
"
r.:.:: E
o
o
iii
"
S2 ~
Nt>
<3.g
o
r:.:: u
"'~
ro Sl
. ~ 0
m :::: ~
5-,~ Q.)
2:Ec:
~.~ ~
~ _ 0
;, ~ <fl
.3:S ~ .
.~ ~ ~ 5
J!l-t~~
~Et~
~ ~ ill
~ as ~ ~-;:c
<:) g ~ g' Ol
r;::: ("') ~ ~.~ ~
25 2 :r; ~ 1! ~
'-.0 >, CI:i _ U
q 0 % ~ -&, g'
5EE~~
..- ::=> W (/) U 0
<.C. '-D
00
r~ ''!
go
00
00
00
CO
88
00
gg
00
~ l.:")
, 7
~ i?
~
~
o
o
N
"
Ot'JW
oj ,
~
o
~
00 ~
r-.::. ~
~
Q
:Q
t'- ,.2
g ~
~ 1i
u;
" ~
ro
g;
o~
"'~
"
t'- ;::;
68
o
g :5
7
N N
00
00
00
65
00
00
00
00
00
00
00
g6
=- c,
0-
,
.:,>: ,-;
~
'"
f;;;j
g
Clr-:::~
~
o
o
N
Os
i::
u
o
E
o
b 6
C ~
N .
oc g
r:.:: ~
ill
~
.
j!
~
~
~
-'"
~
'5
.
u
.~
6..~
ill ill
- '"
00
u 0
~Qj
D:ro
0'"'*:::
t'- '"") Q.) rn
C) ~ Q.) OJ
co '-.0 >,::::
;:::: .9'6
C)::=> 0......
o g E ~
o CD ~
Q>
~
ill
~
"
"'
. ~
";;; S
ill E
2'5
~-
E ~
We
o
o
Q") Q")
c_ ~
~ ~
N N
M
00
00
::::i6
00
00
00
00
00
66
00
co
00
N N
t:: l{)
~. ~,
~
,
'_ C',
~
is
N
CO
o~~
~
'"
"
N
N
c:
~
o
o
N
~~
i:: -.J
-'"
E
.
ill
g>
'6
ro
g
-'"
E
.
~
U ill
ill U
D C
" ro
:.E'S
uD
~ ill E
0' c: ro
C) m::::
80 <fl m
~ ~ ~~
b 5 Ci Q.)
og~~
~ ~
~ ~
~ ~
88
Q Q
N ~('.i
.2':~
~'-<; ':3
89
~~' _2t
~ ~
-;:5
no
= a
06
8 a
8 a
66
gg
a a
~ ~
cc CJ
~ 32
CJ gZ
,~ I-
NN
c_
"
N
m
c O'J ~
~
a
a
N
N
05
~
a
a
N
t:::: g'
0..1(2
r:::..:::i
~ ~ OJ
0::> ~..g
6 '" ~ ?:
~ t2 ~~
'7 g g- m
ogw_
~;::
~'"'
~ ~
~) l!)
08
a a
06
00
00
06
gg
a a
a a
a a
66
~
~_ or::
l!' l?::
~
~
a
8
N
05
Oro~
~
a
a
N
Oi
N
;:.
~ ]
g~
NO
Oi ^
N U
t:::: <
.s
g'
~
e
.
"
m ~
U .':=
00 ~
~oo
~ >
u 00
-5*
7ii ~
~ to
-g~
oo.s
~~
~ii
ill E
002
~ 0 S" m
o <:t Q) W
m l,{) OJ)..c
N l() ElVJ
~ g ~ ~
5w1:
~
u
00
~
W
$
.s
ill
00
N
N N
NN
r--: t_
0000
00
00
08
80
00
60
00
a a
66
a a
00
06
N N
<.;; r.0
~:z
G G
~' 2:
~
8
8
2'
8Nw
ci3 ,
~
:;;
N
tfj
05
~
8
a
~r
co..:::i
o
~]5
,E2
$ $
.::L.lE
u >
00 0
~ -
_ e
o 00
$ii
.s 00
t!''O
~-
u~
~ ~.~
.~
:;lOi;~
f'-;; Q) ~
000 Q.l en
8 (') >. c
~;; %'~
ogJj%
80
O~
08
88
88
60
08
00
06
80
00
88
80
00
80
08
:::-, c
::: 0
~ ?
_, c
~
a
8
2'
a
ONW
Q,
~
a
a
N
;:
co~
z
~
ro
~ 0
ga:
N U
;;rt
co ~
o
e
Q
"
00
~
~ 0
rne
J!~
" ~
e 0.
00 00
8 rn
g ~
.~ Hi
(liD
~"
ON .t ~
b ~ a; ~
<:t lD >, E
~ 8 % m
68~E
N
ro
8 a
08
88
a a
a a
86
00
a a
60
08
a a
66
80
00
08
6,-,
88
=- 0
a
a
N
d
~~~
~
8
8
N
a
N
05
2
in
"
b~
8
~~
cc.q:
e
00
~
~
E
rn
~
.s
"
o
"
"
e
'* g'
-':l~
^ 0
C; N ~ ~
b PJ ai E
00 l,{) >.S:
8 g %-g
6::::> E tIJ
o w_~
ro
Q
88
88
06
80
08
60
08
80
00
08
08
ci :::i
8 a
8 a
86
50
8 _
c, _
~
g
N
i1
ONW
ci3,
~ ^
~ ~
"'f U
N 00
253,
a
o
>-
B
~ 0
g w
~ 0
N 3S
ci3 ~
ID
~ ~
rn_
E..9
" rn
o e
8:~
0-
.:::.!!1
o ~
a; 1:
" ^
ID
- E
Qi E
E"5
E
o
rn
o 1i1 g
o ~ e
oM-5iO:>
b M Q.) -= E
~ tg g;., ~ e
2'50 % m E
6 g ",:S Q)
o t1J -~:5
8
;;
M M
~ ~
88
<.0 CD
08
88
60
08
80
86
08
08
60
8 a
8 a
08
- c
c c
C'";, "'",
'7 .-,:-
c iE-
8
8
c,
;:
;::~~
~
a
a
~ tJ
N 0
03E
o
~
.
"'
-6 ~
a
N U
~ ~
N 0
63 u
~
8
o
~ 0
N ~
20~
a ~ 0
~ ~ 0
~ ~ b' .
~'-'CiID
00,... OJ
60 C (!J
8 W U
08
o ':::>
88
a a
a a
ci:::i
a a
00
60
8 a
8 a
00
00
00
86
g5
c c
o
- 8
C 8
~
a
a
C'J
u5
o0Jw
dJ -;
~
a
o
~
m
~
m
"
~ ~
a .EO
a
~ g
N '1:
05 <1:
rn
o
u
~
"
00
is
E
rn
"
rn
ID
~
u
00
"
u
o ~
o rn
$",
oo~
cr'o
S.o
o c
lD 0
g-~
^ 00
00 ~
ON s:..Cl
r-- ('f) Q.) C
OM Q.) ID
<:t M >>:::
~8.Qi'i
6 .5 ~ ~
o UJ ~
]i
rn
~
N
;e a
g~
00
00
00
00
00
00
88
80
60
00
80
ci :::i
~ Co
co '='
o
1,-; 11
<.r;.
~
a
o
'"
m
S'0s~
~
a
A
"
N
ro
~
~ '"
a 0
o ~
N '"
~ ,E
N'S
ro ~
rn
E
'5
~
!J!
~
"
;;;
~
N
N
i2~
aM
~ ~
000
00
Co Q
a
8 a
~~
0) en
~
00
00
06
00
80
06
58
00
8 a
a a
06
00
'=' '='
::;:) co
- ~
~
o
o
N
ol0w
05 -,
~
o
o
N
Oi
N
ro
t
o
is
~ 0
a ~
am
N ~
05 <.>
N 0
coif,
"
c
u
c
rn
jj
00
~
~
.
~
.
"
~
"
E ~
~E
c ~
m u
~c
,
ii3~
~ 0
OJ U
~oo
o >
iioo
c ~
W is
~
o "
2 "
~ ~
;:; 0 ~ ~
r-. r-. OJ ~
g r-. OJ 0
('J l.{) t E
~ g @-~
ogw~
rn
N
N
8 -+-
C'J N
LD L.G
-- :g'~
6
:7,
,~ ...-'
[:g g
<00
0'
_0'
0'6
55
0' 0'
o
- ,~
C 8
o
<:: ~
,,: C'!
0;
~
M
C C7J ~
~
25
C::I <I>
"
m
2E
o
~
,
~
r::::; ~
" u
N .;2
<3 0
(j; U
"
"
~3
no
g,:~~
E ~
i5E~
ro a If)
2'QJ..c
~ u
~ it ~
~ ro -5i
;;; ~ ~
2::::>~~~
::::> ~ OJ w'O
~ N ~ ~ dl
~g~~~
8 W [l) U
co
"
~
~
o ~
~ ~'
08
00'
0' 0'
0' 0'
0' 0'
8 g
0' 0'
~ "
0' 0
_ 0
o c
c_
9
"
20
cNw
3'i ....,
,-
0'
o
N
o
as
r; ~
o 0
2i8
15
(j, I
""
~
u
~
ro ill
~ ~
:::LV:
- 0
~ ~
CLX
= m
g.; ~
.:=~
~
"
N
2U:;
O'M
o~
:;; N
68
o
ill 5
;;!1~
.20 OJ
-
if
~]!
a\ !:"
ru =
2~
~ ::
o D
WO
,- s
c =:
::: ::::>
80
0'0
6c
00'
0'
o c
0' 0'
<:" C
G:i
>0
o'""w
".. ....,
~
0'
0'
~
I':':'
G ~
~
t- ~
;=:; cr,
7 "
0-, ~
ro
"'
=
~
n
.
u
m
5;
(f)'-:
ffin
5: (IJ
ID "'
C0 ~c:
LD _ Q)
N Q; ~
2 01 ~ ~
S? ~ g;.. ~
m;; 0 t:
6 8 ~ ~
-
o _
~. Q
00
00
CJ CJ
g :5
0'0'
0' 0'
00'
00
c C
0' 0'
00'
00
~
co
,3
ON UJ
0-, -,
0;
"
N
"
N
d
W
"- ~
;-:::;
00
-
e, -2
~ ~
~ B
;2:::: ;:!'E
::::~~-g
<Xl N (IJ CIJ
g;8~~
2, g S:-2
o
o
~
'~
_0
00
o
0_
00'
00'
c g
0' 0
o
Cc
6
if
o~w
d -,
o
o
.~
:s
C'"
~
iii
~
~ *
:i
D
"
ro
co
"
ID
]3
if
'aJ
"
~D
2..9::
~o
o <
ID ~
~
.!!;rc
u 0
,
~~
o
ro _
;::'~
ffi 0)
n
-g.9
n ~
:::r;ffi
o u
- ID
-::;.0
~~
~:s
~ i?J QJ Q
c> M QJ t:
:0 E).!:"
g g-n..!::
65JJ~
7
o
~
~ N
~ :5
"'7 .,r
00'
00'
0' 0'
00
00'
ci ,c
325
00'
<.C' <.D
G ('~
N N
L.') L.r:
c- v.
~
1"-
" ""
[;: ~-
1.:';
3J
cd~
~
"
co
20
~
"
o
n
o _
~ ~-~
OJ :;0-
N
d if;
~
ro
0'2
~ ~
ii5 OJ
if. 5
o n
~ 7A ~
gci~
'" ~
Rl~
o
00'
6>2
<lJ B
~..:.
o ijj
::: ~i
C'
~ ro
LCl L.0
E; 5
~5
00'
00'
0'0'
0'0'
55
0' 0'
~ 7
,co
M
co ~,
~~
y c
C L.:
1.;: L.'";
:z r:--.
::; ~,
K, "
c- ,C':;, UJ
~ ,
'5
g'
~
0;
co
en 2
m m
:E ~ ~
;: 0
'T~~
~5w
-.
<.D0
~: ~
do)
g8
0' 0'
00
00'
0' 0'
00'
0' 0
0' 0'
m m
~ "'".
00
~ N
~ N
.,r~
c: <.D
'" r--.,
~ ,-
'"
C( _
-
c;
7
-
N
~
i::;j
c ~ ~
7
0'
o
C'"
cO ()
~ ~
c"
0'
0'
'"
.~
o
"
,
"
~
7 ~
g ~
g]
N m
rn
:3 8
~
ro Q
N m
~
ID
n
D
"
~
o
co
Co
ro
'0
c
ro
'0
xC
2*
~ ~
- ~)
DO;
~ ~
.9~
m ~
o [1; ~
< ill
o W u
0"'::' <lJ c:
0", "7 >. ro
OJ .2"3
~? g ~E
;:;; 0 UJ <u
~ 0
00
.0 .0
rno>
rn rn
alo)
,,;;
~
00
00
66
00
00
66
0' 0
00
06
om
'--: t-:
M M
~ 0
NN
M M
00
c:: c::
"l'"
1"') I'")
0"; 0:
C'" ~
("'"'. ;::
';; ~:
'~C1\'i::;, .ie-'. C".'I
~ G~ rJ
.-
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommend approval of an Interlocal Agl-eement with the City of Naples to
lease office space for use by the Collier County Film Commission Office
OBJECTIVE: Approve an Interlocal Agreement with the City of Naples 10 lease office space
for use by the Collier County Film Commission.
CONSIDERA nONS: The Collier County Film Commission has contracted with the City of
Naples to lease office space within the NOITis Center t{)r the past three years. The proposed lease
agreement is for a three year \el111, beginning on .lJnuary 1, 2008 and expiring on December 31,
2010, The monthly fee for use of the premises is ~650.00 for the first year and $700.00 pcr
month thereafter for the duration of the' agreement term. Pi-eviously, the 1110nthly lease payment
was S350.00 per month for FY 04-05 and S400.00 per month ie\!' the remainder of the cun'em
agreenlent term.
The current Interlocal Agre~l11cnt with the City of ~~apks expired un .L.u~ust 17.2007. Since
e.'~piratjon. the Film Commission has paid S40(: p~r !~l(mth for }\ollis C,,:ntc1" office space and
staff would like the BCe to authorize continuation of this month to month lease aITangeme11l
-- until such time as the City of \iaples apprcn'cs th\:.' propos~~d ]C:2se agrc~'mcnt and the lease is
e\ecuted.
ADVISORY COMMITTEE RECOMME\DA TIO'\S: The TOC wil] review this agreement
at the November 26, 2007 mceting.
COUNTY ATTORNEY FINDING: The County Atlol11cy's Office has reviewed this item and
considers the agreement legally sufi1eient.
FISCAL IMPACT: Sufficient funds exist within the approved FY 2008 Tourism Fund (194)
budget to satisfy thc current fiscal year lease terms.
GROWTH MANAGEJ\fE!\'T IMPACT: There is no impact to the Growth Management Plan
related to this action.
RECOMMENDA nON: That tbe Board of County Commissioners approves the proposed
three (3) year Interlocal Agreement (1/ I /08 to 12/31/10) providing for lease of certain office
space at the Norris Center hy the Film Commission and fU11her that the Board of County
Commissioners authorize continuation of' the CUlTcnt NOITis Center office space lease on a month
to month hasis until such time as the City of'Naples approves and executes thc proposed
Interlocal Agreement.
-
PREPARED BY: Kelly GreCH for Jack \\'('rt, Tourism Dinctor
COLLIER CC)l:r-'1'\
Item Number:
Item Summary:
I:" I(,~:',
'I',"
Meeting Date:
l'n'parE'U B~
I',C'!
;V' .;"~ -'M',;
;'-1'-'"
~,;;l(
,"'1'
')'i
'cn - :~: ~.;~ . :' "1\
. "n
Approved By
:"),,,.:t ';: D"";(),,, , ~:"i"
" ~,.'
"['proved By
"'W"",-"" Hl-'",'
i_,'.'G.,".,'-'
-,..",
'q'pn\\'t.(] B~
v.,-,"
: ~"
-\pl'r""ed HI
'\pprrow,!/l\
Apl"-O\'{'d II;.
___'-.._"';1\-...,,, -"",(\1\""", ....f".(n.t'f.~TT" ,..,,,, ,"!'~l
I'age lor I
INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT
THIS INTERLOCAL AGREEMENT (the "Agreement") is made this day of
, 2007 by and between COLLIER COUNTY (the "County") and THE CITY OF
NAPLES (the "City").
WITNESSETH:
WHEREAS, Section 163.01, Florida Statues, also known as the Florida Interlocal
Cooperation Act of 1969, permits local governmental units to make the most efficient use of their
powers by enabling them to cooperate with each other to provide services in a manner that will
accord best with geographic, economic, population and other factors influencing the needs and
development of local communities; and
WHEREAS, Collier County through its tourism department employs a person holding the
title of Collier County Film Commissioner; and
WHEREAS, the City and the County have determined that it is in their best interest to
estabiish an office for the Collier County t=iim Commissioner within the Norris Community
Center; and
WHER.EAS, such an office would benefit the citizens of both the City and the County by
providing increased and easier access to the services provided by the Collier County t=ilm
Commission: and
WHEREAS, the City has agreed to grant the County a license to use space in the Norris
Community Center for a Three (3) year period for the office of the Collier County Film
Commissioner on the terms and conditions contained herein.
NOW, THEREFORE, based upon the mutual covenants and premises provided herein,
and other valuable consideration, the parties hereby agree as follows:
1. Recitals Incorporated: The above recitals are true, correct and incorporated
herein.
2. Premises: For purposes of this Agreement, the term "Premises" shall mean an
office in the Norris Community Center, which is located at 755 8th Ave. South,
Naples, Florida 34102. The City hereby grants to the County a revocable license to
occupy the Premises, subject to all of the terms and conditions contained herein.
The County shall have the right to share in the use of any common areas and
facilities appurtenant to the Building with the City.
3. Term: The term of this Agreement shall be for Three (3) years (the "Term"). The
Term shall commence on January 1, 2008 and shall expire on December 31.
2010 (the "Termination Date"). At the end of the Term or if terminated prior to
Termination Date by either party, this Agreement shall absolutely end. The County
acknowledges that it has not obtained any type of easement or permanent interest
in the real property upon which the Premises and Building is located. The
Agreement will be jointly reviewed by the City and the County during the final year
of this Agreement and future recommendations of terms and conditions will be
recommended.
4. License Fee: There shall be no license fees due under this Agreement.
5. Services: The County shall pay all fees and charges directly to the vendor, in
relation to the Collier County Film Commission office phone(s). The City shall
provide climate control, electricity, phone, fax and computer lines to the Premises.
6. Use and Occupancy: The County shall occupy and use the Premises solely for an
office for the Collier County Film Commissioner.
7. Fees and Charoes: The County shall pay $650.00 (for the first year) and $700.00
(for the remainder of agreement) per month to the City for use of the Premises.
The fee due to the City of Naples shall be paid on or before the first day of each
month. All payments should be mailed to the Norris Community Center, 755 8th
Ave. South, Naples, Florida 34102. Make checf:s payabie to the City of Naples.
8. Alterations and improvements: The County shall not alter, improve or change
the Premises, including existing signage, without the written consent of the City.
9. EQuipment UsaQe: The County will be allowed continued usage of property
owned by the City, including; office furniture, file and storage cabinets and
computer in the Collier County Film Commissioner's office and other equipment
located in the Norris Center as needed. Said equipment is property of the City and
is provided for use by the County while on property.
10. Termination: At any time during term of this AGREEMENT, either party may
terminate this AGREEMENT by delivering three (3) month's written notice of the
same to the other party without liability to the other. If the City terminates this
agreement without cause, the County will be allowed an additional (6) months to
re-Iocate office to another location.
11. Assianment: The County shall not assign, sublet, or permit the Premises to be
used by others without the prior written consent of the City in each instance.
12. Indemnification: To the event permitted by law the County shall indemnify,
defend, save, and hold harmless the City, the City's officers, agents and/or
employees from and against any and all losses, penalties, damages, professional
fees, including reasonable attorney's fees and all costs of litigation and judgments,
arising out of any willful misconduct or negligent act, error, or omission of the
2
County arising out of or incidental to the County use of the Premises, or the failure
of the County to perform any duties under this Agreement.
13. Notices and Address Record: All notices required or made pursuant to this
Agreement to be given by the County to the City shall be in writing and shall be
delivered by hand or by United States Postal Services Department, first class mail
services, postage prepaid, return receipt requested, addressed to the following:
City of Naples Community Services Department
280 Riverside Circle
Naples, Florida 34102
All notices required or made pursuant to this Agreement to be given by the City to
the Collier County Film Commission shall be made in writing and shall be delivered
by hand or by United States Postal Services Department, first class mail services,
postage prepaid, return receipt requested, addressed to the following:
Collier County Tourism
3050 Horseshoe Drive
Suite 218
Naples, t="L ::'4104
14. Counterparts: This Agreement may be executed in any number of counterparts,
each of which shall be deemed to be an original as against any party who
signature appears thereon and all of which shall together constitute one and the
same instrument.
15. Effective Date: This Agreement shall take effect on the day of execution by the
last party to execute this agreement.
16. Recordinq: This Agreement shall be recorded by the Collier County Film
Commission in the Official Records of the Collier County within thirty (30) days
after this Agreement is fully executed.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Interlocal Agreement on
the day first written above.
DATED:
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
, Chairman
, Deputy Clerk
3
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Heidi F. Ashton
Assistant County Attorney
CITY OF NAPLES, FLORIDA
By:
BILL BARNETT, Mayor
ATTEST:
TARA NORMAN, City Clerk
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
ROBERT D. PRITT, City Attorney
4
!-;;"". it:
:\;:1 :.:;n::::i;;!"':' 20
'! 01
_.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommend approval of the award of RFP #07-4175, Collier County Tourism
Department Public Relations Assistance, and corresponding tourism
agreement between Collier County and BCF of Florida, Inc. in the annual
amount of $140,000
OBJECTIVE: To provide for public relations assistance to Tourism in order to successfully
promote the Naples, Marco Island, and Everglades City areas,
CONSIDER4.TIONS: The Tourism Department utilizes public relations to enhance our
marketing eff0l1s of Collier County and to introduce I)Ur promotional programs to new markets.
Although we have in-house PR capabilities with a professional statf of communications expel1s.
we need more emphasis in our key feeder markets such as New York and Chicago. For those
services we have looked lOr an outside compan\ with a proven track record for Public Relations
excellence.
-
RFP #07-4 J 75 was posted on .luly 10. 1007. FonY-one notices of the RFP were sent out and six
proposals were received by the due date oC August 10. 2007. The selection committee chose
BCF of Florida. Inc.. by consensus. \0 perform pubiic relations services for an initial two (2)
years with two additional one (J) year renewal peric1cis althe County's discretion. The Selection
Committee recommends that the Board approve thc award and agreement with BCF of Florida.
Inc. for Tourism DepW1ment public relations services.
ADVISORY COMMITTEE RECOMMEND.". TIONS: The TDC will review this agreement
at their November 26.2007 meeting.
COUNTY ATTORNEY FINDING: This item has received approval for legal sufficiency by
the County Attomey', office.
FISCAL IMPACT: The FY 08 adopted Fund (184) budget contains sufficient funds to award
this public relations contract.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There is no impact to the Growth Management Plan
related to this action.
RECOMMENDA TION: Approve the award of RFP # 07-4175 and authorize the Chairman to
execute the agreement between Collier County and BCF oCFlonda, Inc. for Tourism Public
Relations services up to $140,000.
PREPARED BY: Kelly Green for Jack 'Vcrt. Tourism Director
~
COLLIER COI',<n
Item Number:
ltemSummary'
:.C'.
")x",rr,
Meeting Date:
"repnred B~
il-! ~,r'
;. .Jr'," .,. (~', ' i'_~,~I'.::"':'
>n,
C.Ull":' ','''<, ,",n' ()h,,-'
';jUri
~:: ';'n.::-:- ~. 5'._ :~" "Ii
Appro\'ed Ih
",':(
-,"U'1
10.,,-,
,~ .,,'
Aflpn'Vl'd n~
;'L'fl'" ~'r"'IW
,-,,'
;.;:~V:7f. "'-., lei
Ajlflruvcd II)
\pl'f(,,,'d II.-
\1'1''-''''''111"
'\1'1"-"\'('<1 B,
Appr"H'd H~
.\l'llrI"ed B~
j.e,r,'f'
),.le';;,"
J~h
'"'I.,
,_.._ ,_I..T" .',r'.,_.._,',,,~ ~
.n_'_-._" . ",n, n.' ....'n"",... 1,_ " ....,,,-y \~ rcr'~ 'T". ,,, ^ ,.
l'at!L' 1 or I
1T,'"'''.''II\'''''
A G R E E MEN T #07-4175
for
Collier County Tourism Department Public Relations Assistance
THIS AGREEMENT, made and entered into on this day of
2007, by and behveen BCF of Florida, Ine., authorized to do business in the State of Florida,
whose business address is 240 Business Park Driye, Virginia Beach, Virginia 23462
hereinafter called the "Consultant" and Collier Counh', a political subdi\'ision of the State of
Florida, Collier County, Naples, hereinafter called the "County":
WIT N E SSE T H:
1. COMMENCEMENT. The conh'act shall be for a two (2) veal' period, commencing on
the date of appro\'al b\' the Board of County Commissioners, and terminating h,'enh'-
four (24) months thereafter.
The County lna~', at its dis.:retion and v\Ith the cunsent ()f the Consultant, rene,,,, the
.L'.grec111t'nt under all ()f the tenns a.nd conditions contained in t11is Agreenlent for n\'o
(2) addicionaJ one (l) \'car periods. The County sh"ll gi\'e the Consultant written notice
of tlx' County's intention t(1 renew the Agreement term not less than ten (10) ciavs ;'rior
to the l'nd of the Agrl'Cl11'cnt term thL'n in effect.
~
STA TEMENT OF '>\IORK. The Work will be to create and implement an effective
media relations sh'ategv that will includc, but not be limited to, the following:
. h1h'oduce and deYelop a positioning strates'Y for the Naples, Marco Island, mld
["''''glades - Pal'l1disc COllsl destination where appropriate to national, local and in some
cases international media outlets, writers, publications and broadcast organizations
covering the travel (particular]v upscale h'avel), lifesh'le, meetings, food &wine and
other appropriate topic areas.
. Identification of a key message topic a t least monthly for which an effectiye news
release will be developed and dish'ibuted by the Consultant, highlighting appropriate
examples within the destination.
. Public Relations actiyities will, depending on budget, focus on the creation of one
destination event per calendar veal' to inform key h'aYcl media about what's new and
newsworthy in "'aples, t\larco Island and the Everglades. Each eyent will be
appropriately themed and targeted to am'act top tier media, Destination parh1ers that
fit with the event theme will be provided with an opportunity to participate in these
events in some fashion to be determined. Due to budget considerations, this activity
may commence in year hvo of the agreement at the discretion of the Counh'.
Page 1 of R
.~,_:.::;, ;",~.'
· Destination public relations efforts will center on "big picture" messages and news,
but will necessarily involve the mention and promotion of individual resorts, hotels,
attractions, tour operators, retail establishments, restaurants, museums, etc. as
appropriate to effectively illustrate the message. The Consultant will assist the CVB
with researching and compiling new and newsworthy information for the creation of
these regular destination releases. The Consultant must be willing and able to
effectively represent the entire destination as needed.
. Support the CVB with work that may include creation of individual media itineraries,
creation and implementation of group destination press FAM's, response to individual
media requests for information, and support with any and all public relations
initiatives at the bureau as assigned.
. Recommend Internet-based public relations strategies utilizing the latest technologies
and practices for creative and effective 111essage dissenlination, search engine
performance and online peneb'ation.
TIle right llledia coverage ,,,'ill ensure SUCcess in !llccting these kc} objC'ctives by:
. Generating significant COnSU111er a\^.Tarencss of the I\Japles, 1'\'1arco Island and
Everglades area as a desirable, safe, interesting, relaxing anJ cOll1pelling destination
for short ternl visitation 11)' both leisure and group/business travelers.
· Strategically promoting the destination as the first choice of afflllent and discerning
b'avelers.
. Enhancing the Naples, Marco Island, and El'ergladcs - Paradise Coast brand as a symbol of
product excellence.
. Increase visitation, both leisure and group, during the slower season period May
through December.
. Enhance the destination's growing image as a family destination.
3. THE CONTRACT SUM. The County shall pay the Consultant for the performance of
this Agreement an estimated maximum amount of one hundred forty thousand
($140,000.00), based on a monthly fee of $10,000 per month and annual out of pocket
expenses at cost of 520,000. Out of pocket expenses will be billed as follows:
Page 2 of .s
. All County service related charges, to include phone, fax, internal color and black
and white copies, mileage, postage, shipping and art supplies shall be billed at
cost with no mark-up.
. Consultant's travel time will be included in the monthly fee.
. Out of pocket services purchased on behalf of the County, such as photography,
clipping services, printing, specialh' items, etc., will be billed at cost plus 17.65%
up to a maximum of Si2C1,ClClO per year. Out of pocket expenses include travel
expenses as detailed in Item 5 below, but will carry no mark up.
111e above costs are subject to estimates as approved in advance m writing by the
Counh'.
4. PAYMENT: Pavments will be made upon receipt and appnl\"al of invoices submitted
on selTices performed on behalf of Collier County after those sen'ices have been
performed. The number of the Purchase Order bv which authority selTices have been
made, shall appear on illl invoices. Ath,r re,'iew and apprnval. the inn)ices will be
TI"ans1l1ittcd to the: Finance r)~parhnc11t for pa~:n1l'nt. PaYlllcnt \\'i11 b,-=, 111ade upon
r'~'ccirt of a prop~r invoice and in ccHl1pliance \\'jth Section 218.70 Florida Statutes,
otherwise known as the "Florida Prompt P,)nnent Act." Collier County reserves the
right to withhold and/ or reduce an appropriate amount of am' pavment for work not
perfornlcd or for unsatisfactor:-" perfOrIl1anCe of Conh"actu(1] reljuirenlents. The rnonthly
fee will be billed at the first of each month accompanic'd ll\' a report outlining the
Public Relations ,en'ices performed for the pre\'ious month.
::1. TRAVEL EXPENSES: Travel expenses shall be reimbursed at actual cost based on
Collier Countv Resolution 2006-40 as amended and F5125.0104 as amended.
Reimbursements shall be at the following rates:
l\lileaae'
b'
Airfare:
Rental car:
Lodging:
$ .485 per mile
Actual Coach fare ticket cost
Actual rental cost of midsize or smaller car
Actual cost of reasonable lodging
at single occupancy rate
i\ctual cost of parking
Parking:
6. NOTICES. All notices from the Counh' to the Consultant shall be deemed duly served
if mailed or faxed to the Consultant the following Address:
Page:; of g
Communication Consultants, Inc. dlbl a BCF
240 Business Park Drive
Virginia Beach, Virginia 23462
Attention: Art Webb, President and CEO
Telephone: 757-497-4811
Facsimile: 757-497-3685
All Notices from the Consultant to the County shall be deemed duly served if mailed or
faxed to the County to:
Collier County Government Center
Purchasing Deparhl1ent - Purchasing Building
3301 Tamiami Trail, East
Naples, Florida 34112
Atbl: Steve Carnell, PurchasinglGS Director
Telephone: 239-252-8371
Facsin1iIe: 239-252-6384
The Consultant and the County I11ay change the abc)\'€ nlailing address at an:i' tilTH:'
upon ~;i\Ting the other party V\Titten notification. ..0,.1J notices under this Agreenlf.:'nt I11ust
be in '''Titing.
7. NO PARTNERSHIP. Nothing herein contained shall create or be construed as creating
a parhlership between the County and the Consultant or to Cllnstitute the Consultant as
an agent of the County.
8. PERMITS: LICENSES: TAXES. In compliance with Section 21S.S0, F.s., all permits
necessary for the prosecution of the '^-fork shall be obtained by the Consultant. Payment
for all such permits issued by the County shall be processed internally by the County.
All non-County permits necessary for the prosecution of the Work shall be procured
and paid for by the Consultant. The Consultant shall also be solely responsible for
payment of any and all taxes levied on the Consultant. In addition, the Consultant shall
comply with all rules, regulations and laws of Collier County, the State of Florida, or the
U. S. Government now in force or hereafter adopted. The Consultant agrees to comply
with ail laws governing the responsibility of an employer with respect to persons
employed by the Consultant.
9. NO IMPROPER USE. TIle Consultant will not use, nor suffer or permit any person to
use in any manner whatsoever, county facilities for any improper, immoral or offensive
purpose, or for any purpose in violation of any federal, state, county or municipal
ordinance, rule, order or regulation, or of any governmental rule or regulation now in
effect or hereafter enacted or adopted. In the event of such violation by the Consultant
or if the County or its authorized representative shall deem any conduct on the part of
the Consultant to be objectionable or improper, the County shall have the right to
Page 4 of 8
suspend the contract of the Consultant. Should the Consultant fail to correct any such
violation, conduct, or practice to the satisfaction of the Countv within twentv-four (24)
hours after receiving notice of such dolation, conduct. or practice, such suspension to
continue until the \'iolation is cured. The Consultant further agrees not to commence
operation during the suspension period until the violation has been corrected to the
satisfaction of the Counh',
10. TERMINATION, Should the Consultant be found to have failed to perform his
services in a manner satisfactorv to the Counh' as per this Agreement, the County may
terminate said agreement immediatclv for cause; further the County may terminate this
Agreement for convenience with a thirh' (:\0) day written notice. 111e County shall be
sole judge of non-performance.
11. NO DISCRIMINA nON, The Consultant agrees that there shall be no discrimination
as to race, sex, color, creed or national origin.
12. INSURANCE REQUIREMENTS. The Consultant sha1l pnwide insurance as f01l0ws:
A. Corrunercial General Liabiiit\': Co\'t'raLlc sh,111 ha\'c InininlUlll lilnits of S:lSO(],OOO
"
Per Occurrence, Combined Singll' Limit f('r R"dih injun' Liability ilnd Properh'
DalrLage Liability. This shall include Pn..'111isc-s and (Jpcrarions; Independent
Consultants; Prndllcts and C01111'k'ted ()pt'rab~Hls i1nd Contr:lctuaJ Liability.
B. Business Auto LiabiIitv: Con'rage shall have minimum limits of SiSOO,OOO Per
Occurrence, Combined Single Limit fell' Sodi]v Injun' Liabilih' and Property
Damage Liabilih'. This shall include: Owned \'ehicles, Hired and Non-Owned
Vehicles and Emplovee ]\;cm-Ownership.
C. VVorkers' Compensation: Insurance covering all employees meeting Statutory
Limits in compliance with the applicable state and federal laws.
The coYerage must include Emplrwers' Liilbility with a minimum limit of $SOO,OOO
for each accident.
Special Requirements: Collier County sha1l be listed as the Certificate Holder and
included as an Additional Insured on the Comprehensive General Liability
PoliC\'.
Current, \'alid insurance policies meeting the requirement herein identified shall
be maintained bv Consultant during the duration of this Agreement. Renewal
certificates shall be sent to the County thirty (:\0) days prior to any expiration date.
There shall be a thirty (:\0) dav notification to the County in the event of
cancellation or modification of any stipulated insurance coyerage.
Page::; of S
Consultant shall insure that all sub Consultants comply with the same insurance
requirements that he is required to meet. The same Consultant shall provide
County with certificates of insurance meeting the required insurance provisions.
13. INDEMNIFICATION. The Consultant shall indemnify and hold harmless Collier
County, its officers and employees from any and all liabilities, damages, losses and
costs, including, but not limited to, reasonable attorneys' fees and paralegals' fees, to
the extent caused by the negligence, recklessness, or intentionally wrongful conduct of
the Consultant or anyone employed or utilized by the Consultant in the performance of
this Agreement. This indemnification obligation shall not be construed to negate,
abridge or reduce any other rights or remedies which otherwise may be available to an
indemnified party or person described in this paragraph.
This section docs not pertain to any incident arising from the sole negligence of
Collier County.
14. CONTRACT ADMINISTRATION. This Agreement shall be administered on behalf
of the County 10" the Tourism Department.
15. CONFLICT OF INTEREST. Consultant represents that it presently has no interest and
shall acquire no interest, either direct or indirect, which would conflict in am' manner
with the performance of services required hereunder. Consultant further represents
that no persons having anv such interest shall be emp]O\'ed to perform those sCITices.
16. COMPONENT PARTS OF THIS CONTRACT. This Conti'act consists of the attached
component parts, all of which are as fully a part of the conti'act as if herein set out
verbatim: Consultant's Proposal, Insurance Certificate, RFP #07-4175 Specifi-
cations/Scope of Sen'ices.
17. SUBJECT TO APPROPRIATION. It is further understood and agreed by and between
the parties herein that this agreement is subject to appropriation by the Board of County
Commissioners.
18. PROHIBITION OF GIFfS TO COUNTY EMPLOYEES. No organization or individual
shall offer or give, either directly or indirectly, any favor, brift, loan, fee, service or otl1er
item of value to any County employee, as set forth in Chapter 112, Part III, Florida
Statutes, Collier County Ethics Ordinance No. 2004-05, and County Administi'ative
Procedure 5311. Violation of this provision may result in one or more of the following
consequences: a. Prohibition by the individual, firm, and/ or any employee of the firm
from contact with County staff fur a specified period of time; b. Prohibition by the
individual and/ or firm from doing business witl1 the County for a specified period of
time, including but not limited to: submitting bids, RFP. and/or quotes; and, c.
immediate termination of any contract held by the individual and/ or firm for cause.
19. IMMIGRATION LAW COMPLIANCE: By executing and entering into tl1is agreement,
the Consultant is formally acknowledging without exception or stipulation that it is
Page 6of8
fully responsible for complying with the provIsIOns of the Immigration Reform and
Control Act of 1986 as located at 8 U.s.e. 1324, ct set]. and regulations relating thereto,
as either may be amended. Failure bv the Consultant to comply with the laws
referenced herein shall constitute a breach of this agreement and the County shall have
the discretion to unilaterally terminate this agreement immediately.
20. VENUE: Any suit or action brought by either party to this Agreement against the
other party relating to or arising out of this Agreement must be brought in the
appropriate federal or state courts in Collier Countv, Florida, which courts have sole
and exclusive jurisdiction on all such matters.
21. OFFER EXTENDED TO OTHER GOVERNMENTAL ENTITIES: Collier County
encourages and agrees to the successful bidder/proposer extending the pricing,
terms and conditions of this solicitation or resultant contract to other governmental
entities at the discretion of the successful bidder/proposer.
BALANCE OF PAGE LEFT BLANK INTENTIONALLY
Page70fS
',"
IN WITNESS "'HEREOF, the Consultant and the County, have each, respectively, by an
authorized person or agent, hereunder set their hands and seals on the date and year first above
written.
ATTEST:
Dwight E. Brock, Clerk of Courts
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
Dated:
(SEAL)
By:
James Coletta, Chairman
BCF OF FLORIDA, INC.
Consultant
Ev:
First Wib1esS
Signature
!T\'pejprint wibless name!
Second 1Vib1Css
Typed signature and title
!Typejprint wibless name!
Approved as to form and
legal sufficiency:
Assistant County Attorney
Print Name
Page oS ofS
;-~?iTi C,..:;
i\:":; ''i::,tLJ8' ~;JC
i~)1
~
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation for the Community Redevelopment Agency to approve a Resolution
terminating a Site Improvement Grant Agreement between the CRA and Son a Gallery and
Echo LLC due to applicant's failure to meet terms of the agreement
OBJECTIVE: Recommendation I()r the Community Redevelopment Agency to approve a
Resolution terminating a Site Improvement Grant Agreement between the CRA and Sona
Gallery and Echo LLC due to applicant's fililure to mcet the terms of the agreement.
CONSIDERA nONS: On November 14, 2006, the Community Redevelopment Agency
approved a Site Improvement Grant Application 01/2007 for Sona Gallery and Echo LLC a
commercial mixed use project within the Bayshorc Gateway Triangle CRA. The grant's
estimated project cost was $7.607.70 and thc approved CRA matching grant amount was
$2,510.54. or 33% of the total estimated cost.
The owncrs of the propcliy. and grant applicant. inf01111cd the CRA that due to economIc
conditions. they were not going to complete the site improvement project.
.~
The Bayshore Gateway Triimgle CRA Operations Analyst visited the site and confirmed that no
work had been completed. The CR.; Execut ive Director reviewed the exccuted CRA agrccmem.
determined that the agreement expircs on 1\ovcmbcr 1.'1. 2007. and recommmcnds that CRJ, Site
Improvement Agreement with Sona Gallery and Echo LLC dated November 14_ 2006 be
tC1111inated by CRA Resolution. attached.
FISCAL IMPACT: The Site Improvement (irant may provide up to 33% of the cost of
improvements, up to a maximum grant amount of $8.0()O. A maximum grant of $2_5] 0.54 was
approved on November 14, 2006 for thc Site Improvement Grant project. No funds were
expended from Fund] 87, and the $2_510.54 will remain in the grant fund for reallocation.
RECOMMENDATION: That the Community Redevclopmcnt Agency approve a Resolution
terminating a Site Improvemcnt Grant Agreement hetwecn the CRA and Sona Gallery and Echo
LLC due to applicant's failure to mect thc tel111S ofthe agrecment.
Prepared hy: David Jackson on November 14. 2007
Executive Director, Bayshore/Gateway Triangle Community Redevelopment Agency
-
P<l~l: I 01- I
COLLIER COUNn
,. .;,urn
Item Number:
Item Summary:
().F
Meeting Date:
Prrparrll By
[;" v ,,; ,lac k '.~,,'
_. (.c~UU'1 ' [.'t'''~I<:>1
[J.1!(
~C-n"TlI' ,il" h,:",'.",c-IO'-""'HI'
('fiCl'
,.C'._ ",., " "',('U' .'. ,'e ;o=', "~'-' n'
1 :,' 1. ;'~j ~
Apllrn\ll'd H~
~"" ,
C""".t;oI
!,'-'
onw"'- 't. ~"..'j"'"',I"i:",,'-,.'n-
;-'WHi>;
C,", ",u, ',,"" _'.iI' kl--'OC/H,:;,"""_""
/,1,,:
AI'l'rO~l'd R~
IE '''''''iJ!.('
,-I
Appro\'t.{! 11\
''\PI'''''''rdll,'
..I.. "1".'. '...n ',T.._.\l .___'._.',"~ ",~.
...0.....""..,0.....1'.....",-\"7.,.,,-,,, '){u'-'n, ,,"'''lTO......'.' r',.-".
1,.I"().'",,,..,
CRA R.ESOl.ITION ';(). 07-
A RESOIXTION OF THE COM\-llNITY R.LDE\-ELOP\-lEKT
",,(,ENCY OF COLUER COL'cUY. FLORIDA. TER\1IKATL'IG THE
GI:A\;T AC,REEME\;T BETWEE\; CRA A\;1) O\,'\;ER FOR SITE
1\IPRO\'F.ME\;T rOR BA YSIIORElCiATEWA Y TRIANGLE
REDE\'ELOP\-lE\;T ,\REA DATED NO\EMBER 14. 201J(,
(#OI/2007j ;.5 IT RELATES TO PROPERTY AT 3)SO e.;' YSHORE
DRIVE.
\VHERE:\S. on :\o\'cmhcr lot ~O()(.. the C,lmmunity RcdC\::]opmcnt Agen~'y (eRA)
entered mlo :1 SHe lm[nl\cmcnt Grant :\gre~mc:lt 1'01 B:..:.ysho,('/G;jtcWi1~ "I nanglc
Re<.k\'cjorm~nl ArC~1 with Sona E:llerpnses and Echo.I.LC (Owners): ,mo
WHEREAS, the ~()vcmher ] 4. 2()(J6 Ag:"ccTnent p:-O\'ldcc 1'01' [he payment of $2.5! 0,:'>4 to
the OV\'Tlcrs UpOf. ('ompluillll ()r ('c,'lain Sill' Improvements to propcny at ::;::;SO Buysnorc Drive:
:md
\\'lIERL\S. 111'<-' O\I.I1(TS h::\l' nol:Clcd the Cr<.1.. lnUI tl;~': :.1:-(' ul1dhil' !l) ~'UlllpklC the slle
Jn~:)j"(\\l'r;lC':ll r1r~\)l:;;1 \\:lht]l llL'linK' iH~l1~~ '-;-:: f,l:"~)' n :il~' :\'I\~:f,~!)~'; i. ~(!(J(I-\~'r~'2n~:::Ilt; ~lJ)J
\\'ll~:::L::::."\S. li,~' Cl:,' (l;:"lr~~~ tl' I~T!TII"L~jl(' >\';l\~'Ir:h~'" 1""::_ ':(10(, \,-,r~'Cllk:l: :i~ ("J~':' [()
r~:j!Ll\:':;ll,'lll~>.~' ~;'~!n: ILlnd~.
\Cl\\'. TflFREFmL B~:: I1 1-',l:SU;_\,[-]) 1~1 TH!::: :'OLL.ll::R CDl-~";Tl
CCJ!\l\H "'\IT": f~I::DE\'F[J)P\lE'\-I ,\- ;:~'\Cl th;I~'
Tl:~' Sn~ jl~wj'()\ ~'m~~111 (;:-~l11: \,-,r',':::r;;cnl Ill: B~ly"h()]\::/(;~IIC\'<l~ 1 r:~m;it'
R~~Li::\el(1)lnKnl Arcu will', S():~;l E1l\crprls~_~ ClllC E,:I1\'. LL( . d;lteu :\u\':.:mh::f 1-+. ':U()() (,11Uchcd
ller::l\1:J1 Exhihit "",,1,'"1 j" herch) t:..:r11i:lat::J :.1'-1(.1 u1 11(1 lunhcl i"ur('(;" ami ertc::\.
Alll\mcs )llcdgcd LU the Owner" l!lroUgh the November l..L 2006 Agre~mcnt arc
,1V;lil:.:.hic fur re~dl()callon pcrsuant t(l the Bayshon:/GulC\\U: TJi:.ln;le Sile Im)lnl\'cmcTlI G;-:m:
Progr;ll:l.
rhlS Resolutiun ,,11.j)1 hecome ei'i,Xli\c immcdl~ltl'l\ Llpon pas:<lge :mJ ;](joptlon.
This R~S(l!ulinn :ldopleu drier motion. seconu and m;ll(lriT~ \()lC IhlS
U:I;; of
20117.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E BROCK
CO\I\:1L'\;ITY RUJEVELOPME\;T AGE\;CY
Of Cm.LlF:!< CClLK-I Y. FLORIDA
Hy:
lh:
_ D.::pury CierI.
DO'!N.'" FL\L:\:. CHAIR"\1A:'i
.\ pprove-d ;J,S \l1 rOllll
:ond k~J.1 suffic](:nc~
orhv-.J]l.~-~
~~'1. Sludcnl-Slirimg , Q
Assist.lnt CnunlY :\n()rnc~
eaf:M.
1\f,M 1(,61
N.iW'1'1- I IPI"fu
GRANT AGREEMENT BETWEEN eRA AND OWNER
FOR SITE IMPROVEMENT FOR BA YSHORE/GA TEW A Y TRIANGLE
REDEVELOPMENT AREA
THIS AGREEMENT ENTERED this l'L-tJ,day of NOVE~ , 2bv(. by and
between the Collier County Community Redevelopment Agency (hereinafter referred to as
"CRA") and ~..,t\ bi1.k( pc,s..!""\. a ~ J (hereinafter referred to as "Owner")
E:'c I-h-\ L-L C
WITNESSETH:
WHEREAS, in Collier County Ordinance No. 2002-38, the Board of County
Commissioners delegated authority to the eRA to award and administer eRA grants including
contracts with owners for eRA grants; and
VlHEREAS, Owner has applied for a site improvement grant in the amount of6,~(}.:>~
dollars; and
v\'HEREAS, the eRA has determined that Owner meets the eligibiiity requirements and
was approved for a grant award in the amount of:i;;;? ~ [y. 51./- dollars on
!JO.J"dI.A.k:::.-e.. 1'1 , _1.-60'- ("eRA Approval"), \vhicn is 33.~_~o of the costs to
construct the site improvements.
NO\V, 11-IEREFORE, in consideration of the mutUPJ covcnan!:s comain:;:d herein and
other valuable consideration, the parties agree as follows:
1 Ov.ner a::::l::nowleciges to the eRA that Owner has receiv~d a COP) of the Coliier
County Community Site Improvement Grant Program (hereinafter referred to as "Grant
Probrram"), that Ov..rner has read the Grant Program, and that Ovmer has had ample opportunity
to discuss the Grant Program with Owner's counselor advisor. Owner further acknowledges to
the eRA that Owner understands and agrees to abide by all of the terms and conditions of the
Grant Program. Owner agrees to the terms and conditions oflhe Grant Program, a copy of which
is attached as Exhibit "A" and incorporated herein.
2. Owner is the record owner of property described as 3':5~'.:) 1~'{.SJtDCt bQ..tvb.
3 Owner has agreed to make certain improvements to the property pursuant to the
grant application submitted to the eRA dated S{;-PTk7lA.&::1L~ ?,COf;.. . (the "Site
Improvements") Attached hereto as Exhibit A and incorporated herein by reference.
4 Owner agrees to complete the construc..1ion of the Site Improvements within one
(1) year of eRA Approval Owner also agrees to fund at least 50% of the costs of the Site
Improvements.
EXHIBIT "A"
f., -" '-'1
5 eRA has approved a grant to Owner in the amount of _ ? , .) It.. , j to be
administered pursuant to the terms of this A!:,J"feement based on an estimated cost of
117,r/;Cl. 7iJ _ If the actual costs are less than the estimated costs to construct the Site
Improvements, the grant amount shall be reduced to equal the percent of the Site Improvement
costs approved for funding by the eRA.
6. Unless prior disclosure is included in the grant application. no Owner, or any
immediate relative of Owner, shall serve as a contractor or subcontractor for the construction of
the Site Improvements and no Ov.mer, or any immediate relative of Owner, shall receive
compensation for labor for the construction of the Site Improvements. .tuI immediate relative of
Owner shall include mother, father, brother, sister, aunt, uncle and cousin or family member by
marriage to include mother-in-law, father-in-law, brother-in-law and sister-in-law.
7. Owner agrees to obtain all necessary permits and submit any required plans to the
County's Community Development and Environmental Services Division. Upon completion of
the work, Owner shall submit to the eRA staff a project summary report, two (2) 8 x 10 after
photos, a list of materials and construction techniques used, a list of architects and/or contractors,
and any other information specific to the project or requested by the eRA. staff The eRA
through its staff. shall confirm that the Site Improvements were constructed pursuant to the terms
of the application approved by the eRA.
8. v.."ithin forty-five (45) days after confirmation that the Site Improvements were
constructed pursuant to the terms of the approved application, Owner shall be issued a checl: in
the amount of the grant However, if Owner fails to make the improvements pursuant to the
terms of the approved application, or ifth~ project is not completed within one (1) year ofeR-A.
c:.pproval, or if Owner fails to fund at least 50{l,o of the C:Jst oC the Site improvements, the ,grant
shaH be deemed revoked and Owner shall h:;~ emitled to no fundin~~
9
ofFb;ida
This Agreemen~ shall be governed and construed pursuant to the laws of the State
j 0 This Agreement contains the emire agreement of the parties and their
representatives and agents, and incorporates all prior understandings, whether oraJ or \vritten
No change, modification or amendment, or any representation, promise or condition, or any
waiver, to this A.greement shall he binding unless in v,'Titing and signed hy a duly authorized
officer of the party to be charged.
1]. This Agreement is personal to Owner, and may not be assigned or transferred by
Owner or to Owner's respective heirs, personal representatives, successors or assigns without the
prior wTitten const:nt of the eRA.
F~ :
FRX "-'J.
. .,.- ,.' ,,~".
May. 12 2e03 06: 24PM P5
IN WITNESS wtIEREoF, the pani.. have executed tbis ~.... on !be dme llIld )'<OJ'
first wriuen abo~,
(l)~'/~ ~d'1r---
w__
~..: ~1lj11!.
{2)~
4:f,c6<,v.?",,/.a'T/
""-'Ijjiiiij-
. '.~~ [.' (.il Ot:,
ATTEST: .'i c",
DWlO8TE.'~ C1eti:
'."""~:7"..' -. .
..~~
OJ ,!fj~~_' , . ~~~~.
). ,'j
':tet:tU._, __'.
'1\IIlt~/ClIll~,c:_.""
,.. ~ ~\. .
~a!:lo-fora:_
-~:
-y}v,^%,,,-,,. .rb,-,~- fir (Ao _ ,..
__.slidqo /JG ~ 0
-c:....q.........
o
COlLlER COUNrY COMMl.JNITY
RED~l'MENT AGENCY
- ~I ~~ .
9)' /,~.J j~
D~ l'U.LA. a..m.."
II
r\~,:S:T;=\i2~ :::. ::::CiC
1 ::If
~
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Report to the Collier County Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA) providing an
update on a proposed public referendum allowing the CRA to incur debt and to delay the
desired referendum until November 4, 2(H/8.
OBJECTIVE: Provide the Collier Count) Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA) with an
update on a proposed public referendum to allow the CR.L\ to incur debt and to delay the
referendum until November 4, 200R.
BACKGROUND: On September I l, 2007. the County Bond Counsel informed the CRA Board
of the impacts of the recent Florida Supreme Court ruling in the Strand Case on the CRA's then
pending purchase of real propel1y and the procedures for a CRA to incur debt or secure bank
financing following the ruling. On September 25. 2007. the Bayshore Gateway Triangle CR.L\
Executive Director updated the CRA Board on the option to place 'public refcrenduin' language
to incur debt on the January 29. 20()7 Presidential Primary ballot.
CONSIDER<\. TIONS: Since the September 6. 2007 Florida Supreme Court ruling. the Court
held a rehearing on October 9. 20()7. The Court did clarify certain paJis of their ruling. however.
to date the Court has not changcd the requirement for a CRA to receive public approval prior to
issuing any fonn of debt to be paid by Tax Increment Financing (TIF) rcvenues.
~
Florida Redevelopment Association kga! counsel advised that on January 10. 200S the Supreme
COUl1 will hear a Bay County, Florida eRA case conccrning use of TIF and bonding. Counsel
stated that he felt that the Court will not publish any fLniher opinions on CRAs and debt until
they learn more about CRAs and eomplcte the Bay County case, which may be as latc as
February 2008. If the Supreme Court reverses its original mling mandating referendums, a
referendum would be moot.
Also unrelated to the Court ruling, but a factor to consider, is that the Florida State Legislature
has 'property tax ref 01111 , on the January ballot. If sweeping tax refonn questions are passed by
the electorate, it will directly affect the CRA's futurc TIF calculations. New TIF projections will
have to be calculated and documented 10 justify to financial institutions the amount of debt a
CRA would have the financial backing to incur.
Discussions with the County's Bond Counscl, Nabors, Giblin, & Nickerson, confirms that there
are numerous factors to consider (cited above) in determining the appropriate language and
details to be included in a referendum question. Many of these factors are undetel111ined at this
time and will remain variables until the Supreme Couli publishes its opinions and the property
tax reform ballot results are in.
-
The Bayshore Gateway Tliangle CRA Local Advisory BOaJ'd met on November 6, 2007 and
discussed the options, benefits, and liabilities of holding a public referendum on January 29,
2008 or waiting until the November 4, 200S Presidential Election. The Advisory Board
acknowledged that the uncertainties of the tax ref01111 vote and the pending eases before the
Supreme Court could be a clctractor to the passage of such a refcrendum, and that a significant
public infonnation campaign would have to be conducted to educate the votcrs. The sbort time
period before thc January 200S referendum date ineludes two major holiday periods that would
dilutc a public infoll11ation campaign and not bc cost-effective.
The Advisory Board passed a motion to recommcnd to thc CR.<\. to not place a referendum
question on the January 29, 2008 hallot. evaluate the impacts of thc results of the January 2008
tax reform vote to the CRA-s TIF, and hased on the Supreme COUli's anticipated rulings,
develop a strategy to acquire new debt at the earliest opportunity to fund projects that meet the
CR.L\ Redevelopment Master Plan goals and objectives.
FISCAL IMPACT: None. The Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Trust Fund has sufficient
funds to operatc throughout FY2008. Major high-cost projects will bc put on hold until a later
date as the CRA Dircctor cxplores a numhcr oftinancing options which may include but arc not
limited to: the issuance of CRA TIF debt pursuant to a County-wide rcferendum: the issuance of
CRi\ TlF rcferendum debt under the umbrella of a MSTU within the district: sale of existing
CRA prope11y with proceeds applied tov, ard targeted parcels: the pursuit of flexible option
agJTCl11~nlS wh~rein targcted redevelopment J1<lrcds are set asid:.: under a public,'p;oj"ate
panncrship al!o\ving the public emity time to acquire financing.
GROWn! l\1A'\AGEME'\T IMPACT: Plllicv 4.7 or the Future Land Use Element 01 the
Circ1\\th IVlana8cment Plan Slates that n.:dcydopmcnl plans may 11t~ developed for specitlc areas
within the County. including lhi.:' Bi]yshorc Ciak\\ay Ti"junglc eRA.
LEGAL eO'\SIDERA nONS: The COUI1ly Attomcy Officc in conjunction with the Countv's
Bond CounscL 1\abors, Giblin & "iickcrson. jt)!' the rcasons stated would recommend holding the
CRA referendum at a later date. Future referendum language will be drafted by the County
Attol11ey and Bond Counsel ftl!- approval by the CRA and Bee.
RECOMMENDA nON: That the Collier County Community Redevelopment Agency (CR.L\)
I'eeeives this update on the proposed public referendum to allow the CR/\ to incur deht and to
deJay the rcfcrendum until !\Iovcmber 4, 200R.
Prepared by David L. Jackson on November 13_ 2007
Exccutivc Director, Bayshore Gateway Trianglc eRA
COLLIER COl'NT\
Item Number:
Item Summary:
,,,: ~:u
Meeting Date:
'lr;;,r.,'
"rer1uretl By
(.""'n~ ..I1"'h. or,
,,' ,~~"tIV, . MV:l:]'
1M'
'_DIT;"""'\ f";'J",il'!Gr"'<.,n;
:'(" ;,
!",-'Vb
, ,., c..'2' (:,~' ,~.. ~
"W,' , Ku "'v"InJ:l~'U"
'\pprovcd By
:.J1CC,:!:)
u.,,,
"""!T''"'l:t'R'''''''''_''Cllr"",:
1;0"'1(;"
E,k'\'\'!)C' <,~",,':r' F(fc'O"vr,i",,"wn~
'':':'2(;''1':4'
Approved B~
,~:-,," ";1:,-", . :;.;, ,,,.;
,,"11-.,/.;-,,-,W
';'1'
[)"",,/-,.
u, :" ';~ ~"':r' r>\,
-\pI'r""Nj II.,
'\pp!,<".,.d II,'
'~1 ..
-, .1.., ,_.'.r-.._,,_'.n~ ". ....1. __.ll. "r,..,..,,, ''"\,n,,,,..,', 1 /_ n,'-.", -,n','r", ""(1
J'a~t' I Or I
'l,':
ILi:'li;' I';::;. : :Srl i
:',;C iD'-,r,..,):c,y ""r,".~
~ ~.! ~,
, '.); '-)
"-"
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
COMMISSIONER REQUEST FOR BOARD APPROVAL FOR PAYMENT TO
ATTEND FUNCTION SERVING A VALID PUBLIC PURPOSE
OBJECTIVE: For the Board of County Commissioners to declare a valid public
purpose for a Commissioner to attend function/event and approve payment by the Clerk.
CONSIDERATIONS: Pursuant to Resolution No. 99-4l0, the Board of County
CommissioTs has deternlined that attendancc at the functions of fraternal, business,
enVm>nmel "I. educationaL charitable, social. prolessional trade, homeowners, ethnic,
and civic a.' ,(lciation/organizations serves a valid public pU'1)ose, provided that said
functions reasonably relate to Collier County matters. .
COM~' lSSIONER: Tom Henning
FGNCT!ON/EVENT: Collier Citizen of'th.e Year l007 at The Naples Elks Lodge
PUBLIC PURPOSE: To celebrate and honor the individual chosen as Collier Citizen of
the Y car lOCi7.
DA TE OF FUNCTION/EVENT: Thursday. Nmcmoer j 5_ 2007
FISCAL IMPACT: S35.00 Funds to be paid from Commissioner's travcl budget.
RECOMMENDA nON: That the Board of County Commissioners, in accordance with
Resolution No. 99-41 0, approve payment by the Clerk for Commissioner to attend
function serving a \'alid public PUl11osc.
PREPARED BY: SaID Tucker, Executive Aide to BCC
APPROVED BY: Sue Filson, Exccutivc Manager to BCC
AGENDA DATE: NO'vember 27, l007
~."..lli.. NO rO.f.":!?f7~
~~. ~ :ef ~1r~111i
~ ~llk, . ., "\\1: ... ... ,. 0>>0.'.' (\'7
Gli Ule kear ~.',U)cf
\/" ',-'1.'-.1-,'1 ...I-J" -, f' - J-~-' ~,_.L, .J
i[.J/....1,' TIf.--!-CJ-lt>1,,{ 'il...-L. ...), t.t.f/i.;~'''''''L-L'i1'
f I .,/.
-r-/ i \" ,~ .' -"t' ,_
,. i -1' :' ,/ t- ,,- , ....' , 7' t )' i./ . "'1' . / ~~ .1' ;"1' J'_~' "'... l-.-
! !tk;!~,1ji,.1i'I"/,. .. '"-" ~'i..,t <-;"'/l...'2 /'-}
;-,-':''''';:' ,.,'" /\ f'J """'.":: ".1'.... /~~ '-:- t::-,.//i" (- I'
I i ..~, J \'''''i-1t.;...-..'y :..-ll"'-....-.,. ~':'i
/
,- .It ~l /~
/ /1 ,- ./-:"/] / C r""i fl1 ,,11'
\.....-'~~"v-j-.....L-'Vf~ ~) ,-I r,,/lt-.
Dinner 7p.111.
$35 per perSON
RSVP b!f MJv; 17: ?13-6077, 353-1687
or emmf.. k.ltu!f@collierc/ti7en.com
COLLIER COl.NTI
ItcmNumber:
IlemSummary:
Meeting Date:
l>r~p3red B~
,,;,r;
~ '"
:.','1'
,-,-'"
')I:"o(
;},1"-
"r"
"['prowll B~
r.. ~"_ 'em;,
OJ":':
_,''''11
,'::'
.\pprowu '-h
C1.. Ii,'
'" ~~'I'., "'.l-:,,__...\n~ ". u..l._._ll ""n"" (l '1",(\,,-,. U: n ">", .('n H'. .~ lTn' "" , ,'r-.. T
! 'a~'c ; (\1 I
IL:::;;, .~.
:\v' '_.,:::::'~; _. "-'.:C
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
COMMISSIONER REQUEST FOR BOARD APPROVAL FOR PAYMENT TO
ATTEND FUNCTION SERVING A VALID PUBLIC PURPOSE
OBJECTIVE: For the Board of County Commissioners to declare a valid public
purpose for a Commissioner to attend function/event and approve payment by the Clerk.
CONSIDERATIONS: Pursuant to Resolution No. 99-410, the Board of County
Commissioners has determined that attendance at the functions of fratel11al, busincss,
environmental, educational. charitable, social. profcssional. trade, homeowners, cthnic,
and civic association/organizations servcs a valid public purpose, provided that said
functions rcasonably relate to Collicr County matters.
COM\1!SSJONER: .Jim Coletta
FUNCTIO!\!EVE!\'T: Farm City BBi)
PUBLIC PURPOSE: !\elwori: with conslitllents. local and state business leaders, and
govelllll1cll1 officials and demonstrate sllppon for th~ imp0l1ance of agriculture 10 the
area,
DA TE OF FUNCTION/EVENT: Novcmhcr 21,2007
FISCAL IMP ACT: S 1 R.OO - Funds to bc paid ii-om eommissioner's tr3\'cl budget.
RECOMMENDATION: That thc Board of County Commissioners, in accordance with
Resolution No. 99-410, approve paymcnt by the Clerk ICJr Commissioner Coletta to
attcnd function sen,ing a valid public purpose.
PREPARED BY: Lisa Resnick, Administrative Aidc to BCC
APPROVED BY: Sue Filson. Exccutivc Manager to BCC
AGE!\DA DATE: I l/27/07
'"~'-'_.'.'~'-"""--~'-"'-'-"
,."~ ..:- ',)
QQ
~...:..
~ .,..<=11:
:~~.=,' :~,~_;;1k,'
u
~".."t~
:r;'." ~~
~'. .I:lil,......,::v-t
-"....' , "---.-
.., ., ~y~~:;;2.~,~
"_..~~,.,:".- ..
~
November 6, 2007
Commissioner Jim Coletta
Board of County Commissioners
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Nap~ss, FL .34112
C,::w:-lmissione;-' Coletts::
i --;2:-l!~'):,:~ ::y S.;Fe-Sl"'r'; :::' be s <>si-=:~~_l:-:t\; sS'~\ler-' 2J~
V32::- 2 '-2:~
8=;':~. t-JiS2.SS s_Ti\..~ 3.l t~s 3:::0 ='Y- .l"i :152:~
3: ~~',st W~ :;2"" get )r:J~; J:Jrfirts:i \li!~~t: 2:--: ::::;:-':1-: s:-~c' j:~e:: \r:;:...
L':; vour
.. -, ., ." I '
S:2_H')n. ~.):'-S:::i':):;S &:6 rn:;I'Jce: G:", rn~ '2.nC'JSeC)
f~ye:'.
In a;:>prect2tion for your service, vve~ve :ncluds:d a
GQmpiimentaiY Ue;I,et for lunch. If persG;,al ,:x professlonal
policy prevents you from accepting a complimentary tici,st,
ths purchase price would be $18.00. Checks can be made
payable to: Chamber for Farm Citv BBO BBO 2007
and mailed to:Greater Naples Chamber of Commerce
Attil: Stephanie Martin
2390 Tamiami Trail NOlih, Suite 210
l'oJaples, FL 34103
Vlfe appreciate your support and look fOlward to seeing you
at the BSO!
Regaids.
I~ '.
Cyndee V\/oclli€~y
Co-Chair
Farm City BBO
i
,
-'
To promote an enlightened understanding between urb:m and rural residents and to
promote awareness of the importance of agriculture to the area
Wednesday, November 21, 11:30 a.m.
Ave Maria
Off of Oil Well Road, between Everglades Blvd. and Camp Keais Rood.
Turn into Ave Maria and follow the signs.
:' Q~
~ii;\:'~:1
~J:' .::.J,.
;~., ,Jf.;"'--':'
r~:l.:_:":':>' - _:.., <'<~7;
:rp
..;;;.;>"
- ~__i
......-
~
'"
-
--.-/ --
,
.'-'''-,1
~~42J!:,'-''''''
....."'~i,~,.,"""""="'E~_.,J8........-,__,,,.....,.*..,"~,_~,~~..,~....'M.!.1t:iIi',."""'......,,""lII.1:...""''''''.!'H'UIt~.!i>.... _.'...~_!JI.>5';h1il-~'""'............. __ 0"0
- ~ '~~^h2~j-":i!1It:1i.:~i
r~ -
":_~ _.__~-_-_; ,;;:j oJ- :J;'i ":t:f :.r-"l _~ir:-:; ;.;
..! ,.......;I'~'-""........;;~~.J .,J"""'1"':
J
Agricultural Displays
Annual Vegetable Sale
R "1"1 I"'f r h
c.rTle or pnze.$ Qoncte.c. ,-,y:
The Leadership Corlier
Foundation
Music by:
Konnie Morgan
at, ~~ ik.~ €,~ el~ ItC
Portions of the proceeds benefit the
CoUier County 4H Foundation
G,.' ,,(if, a;;;" -.'; ~ (\..c, ~\t
v~ ~,- w~ ~~. ~fr ~lt:
Brought to you each year by
these generous sponsors:
~~:~J !!&:i~~
,;;:;... """-~~",.,-..,,
-'
(~~r;j.j,:
_ ~___ om
,.,~'-
l' -I
/:."':."
~..'.,T"'~ ')
J!.:~;\,i:i,;.t;
"...."_..
,J .. ~"..' \' :', . " ;',
~.). ,:t. I.
f' "
~
pulte
1:(. ,'" ! '1'1: ,'" . Ii ,; ~;:1'." I. I:':: ,iI'i'f: '
.....'''''"'''
;,
~ : ".
Ii "'''''-'-.'.'
'-:.: I."
I '~'.i,,-;'
,,,,"',
- "
- .~< , -~
J:...\ i: M A l~ 1.\
A
~,. \..-
I'''''''''';
,. f'\""
Jt$."",;;'J.,
"... .....;
.. '. i.,.".,; J \. '..
,: r, .' --... 1 ' ~
. . C,Olller
, , i ~
~i~
~. ,v;
"(~ r+V
llt'ST\\-"
~
IE!fm
COLLIER
ENTERPRISES
FeB .{~.+~unitY
Immokalee Chamber of Commerce
Russe[l's Clambakes'" Chapmans
~adfic Collier N 6-L's
Southern Corporate Packers
.. '. !.?ij~ G: 'G""~ c l ((;r tr .,
University of Florida Extension
14700 Immokalee Road
353-4244
Gr"eater Naples Chamber" of Commerce
Visitor's Infor"mation Center
2390 North Tamiami Trail, Naples
262-6376
Immokalee Chamber of Commerce
310 A/aenua St., Imm' ",alee
657-3237
Menu: Grilled Steak, Corn on tne Cob, Baksd Beans, Rolls, Immokalee Salad
Checks made payable to Chamber for Farm City BBQ 2007.
1'<:lf!I.:J(\J'1
COLLIER COUNT)
Item Number:
Item Summary:
l".rVII :"~:.;I j:..,.">';
.' '~,
Meeting Date:
Prl'pllred It}
j:,,, .;r,,~1
r:.''-':;l''U'' L.,nC'h',~llr. EL'C.
DJte
:.. '."'l' .., '~U.Ji'~\
",e'
:"rfi"
ApprnwdB\
~"J(
.,'u,
",ur:i\
:::, .:>n'"n, ,C ,~'''', ,-,
E::
1 'n4.-'~D07
rOj'i
App~OHd B~
Ill"
"'Ie'
,~ D"""
C'",
,~, ~
..._,,-,',(\~ ", ___.1...._".'""'''''''''' ',11,'\1\'7',. 1 t. f) "",\I-.,'nF<'j '~'T''' "'., ,
1'1,""""/\1\-'
i ~"." '
','~, 1~.
1\,'_",
,- '-'-'~'.~
<:'-;'" ~\e' .:.. f ,--~',
'; Df 5
,-.'
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
COMMISSIONER REQUEST FOR BOARD APPROVAL FOR PAYMENT TO
ATTEND FUNCTION SERVING A VALID PUBLIC PURPOSE
OBJECTIVE: For the Board of County Commissioners to declare a valid public
purpose for a Commissioner to altcnd function/evcnt and approve payment by the Clerk.
CONSIDER<\.TIONS: Pursuant to Resolution No. 99-410, the Board of County
Commissioners has determined that attendance at the functions of fraternal, business,
environmentaL educationaL charitable, social. professional, trade. homeowners, ethnic.
and civic association/organizations serves a valid public purpose, provided that said
functions reasonably relate to Collier County matters.
COMMISSIONER: Jim Coletta
FUNCTlON/EVE!\'T: 20'h /\.nnual Leadersbip Collier Plmil1l1l11 Holiday Party
-
PUBLIC PURPOSE: NetworL with local business and community reprcsentatives and
demonstrate suppOli for the Leadership Collier Program.
DA TE OF FUNCTION/EVE!'\T: December 6. 2007
FISCAL IMPACT: $45.00- Funds to be paid from Commissioner's travel budge!.
RECOMMENDA nON: That the Board of County eommissioners, in accordance with
Resolution No. 99-4l0, approve payment by tbe Clerk for Commissioner Coletta to
attend function serving a valid public purpose.
PREPARED BY: Lisa Resnick, Administrative Aide to BCC
APPROVED BY: Sue Filson, Executive Manager to BCC
AGENDA DATE: 1l/27/07
,-
~:;;, '--JC;
,~' ,,' :"'::--':;;' .:'
From: ResnickLisa on behalf of Colettalim
Sent: Wednesday, November 14, 2007 I 1:56 AM
To: Jessica Kardas (jessica(i1maplesehanlber.org)
Subject: RSVP Leadership Collier 20th Annual PlatinUITI PaI1y December 6, 2007
Dear Ms. Kardas:
Thank you for your invitation to join you at the 20th Annual Leadership Collier Platinum
Party on December 6,2007 at the Naples Hilton. 1 aIll pleased that you included me in your
invitation and by way of this letter am letting you know that I plan to attend.
I will send payment under separate letter.
1 am Jookmg forward to this e\'ent and \\'ilJ see you th~n,
Sincerely.
Jim Coletta, Chainllan
Commissioner. District 5
Collier County Govemment
3301 E. Tamiami Trail
Naples, FL 34119
Phone (239) 774-8391 / Fax (239) 774-3602
ji mco I etta(aico lli er[!ov.n et
\V\\'W .collicn:!Ov .net
PI~~lSt: n~H~: Fh;-iJLl has:.::. \ ~ry bn;a~l puhlic r~::()rd:~ ;~',\\.
l\'IUS1 \,;;-itk'l"c cummuni:':~i1ion.'-: 1(\ ()j' i'nll1i u;ric;~lj< r~'~<.lru:;l~":(l~I:l(Y bJsinC'.<..;
arc publIc records 3\3ibhL: to the public and T~l~(kl U)1d111\'1.]1l'..:_"L
\"our '..:.'-m.::li; communi:.:a:iul~:; IL,-l} lrl~T,.'r(}L: h-..:' sdl~i('_~ll.' ;lubll~' (:i!~<.:i\hUL.::.
From: Jessica Kardas [mailto:]essica@napleschamber.org]
Sent: Monday, November 05,20075:36 PM
To: ColettaJim
Subject: Leadership Collier ALUMNI HOLIDAY INVITE
The Leadership Collier Foundation
in cOlziuncrion with the
Creater /Vaples Chamber of Commerce
cordially i!11'ites you to attend the
20th Anllual
Leadership Collier
PLATINUM
) ,
(j;' l
1'[":'
December 6,2007
5:30pm - 7:30pm
at the Hilton Naples
5111 Tamiami Trail North
Cost per Person is $45
CLlCK HERE TO REGISTER ON-LINE
We have a great event planned with fun, prizes and
the announcement of the
2007 Distinguished Alumni (~lthe Year!!!
fife lookfor-ward to seeing you and yourfellow alumni on December
6th
Please RSVP by November 30th
(OLLlEI{ (C)[i'in
Item Number"
Item Summary:
Meeting Date:
l'rl'r~rNI B~
c:'"
"dc"
'\l'prnvl'U RI'
",""I';'"
P',.'
;rcc,'"
'''-''
,~ r:","
.\pprll\l'U n~
,'T
...n ;"..,,", ~ -./n,,,\'," 1 "...",',n-,', -,,')'" "I', ^ "T'~'
1':I!2-c1oi'1
if';; c'"
1\1=: /i";:;r,:"s: ~J 2DO
'i 0:
--
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
COMMISSIONER REQUEST FOR BOARD APPROVAL FOR PAYMENT TO
ATTEND FUNCTION SERVING A VALID PUBLIC PURPOSE
OBJECTIVE: For the Board of County Commissioners to declare a valid public
purpose for a Commissioner to attend function/event and approve payment by the Clerk.
CONSIDERA nONS: Pursuant to Resolution No. 99-4l 0, the Board of County
Commissioners has determined that attendance at the functions of fraternal, business,
environmental, educational, charitable, social. professional, trade, homeowners, ethnic,
and civic association/organizations serves a valid public PUlvose, provided that said
functions reasonably relate to Collier County matters.
COMMISSIONER: Jim Coletta
FUNCTlON/EVEI\T: Greater l\apks Bctkr Govemment Committee :-iolidav Socia]
PUBLIC PCRPOSE: Network with cit\,. county and school dignitaries
~.
DA TE OF FUNCTlON/EVEl'T: December 18.2007
FISCAL IMPACT: $l 0.00 - Funds to he paid ii'om Commissioner-s travel budget.
RECOMMENDA nON: That the Board of County Commissioners, in aCCOrdaI1Ce with
Resolution No. 99-410, approve payment by thc Clerk for Commissioner Coletta to
attend function serving a valid public purpose.
PREPARED BY: Lisa Resnick, Administrative Aide to BCC
APPROVED BY: Sue Filson, Executive Manager to BCC
AGENDA DATE: I 1/27/07
--
COLLIER COLNTY
~v,,' "i'H",,:C'I.,cr;::
Item Number:
Item Summary:
" .,.~::,
';-'.'v"r:.;;'
'; ,JlJI.' ~ fU ,-:-'
;.~W,'-j
~h" '-Io;t Ie' ''''"\(-
1m"""" "111;.J',
co.- '-'-,I:',.
"'r:T,CI("
Meeting Dale:
Pn.paretl S,
,-,'" F,.,,-,,,,_C"'
";'.n.- "".:1"
~ '.11'
tW,r<;e::>""""
.""'r.'I" -'FJ'
w
,~; ,.' ':'" ~. J: _;>~:. r:'r,'
Apprml'd B~
['C""'" ,"_'
i:.l',P'( .un1\
';.urnll'
S'-;"
'~:',~ pr.:
'\PIHO\'t'd By
p, I{!t
",""1 ''''''<'P;
c,.-'"
'~1 H
_."l..._n.';rn""l (l"I\'>I\i\-,.', ,/ n ....'."'.nr<":...l'P"
['age In/" 1
:;1,-,
..
, ,,~:'i
'., ~i;,~'
.n/:. .~.....
~.r,
"
I""',
~:...~,"
t,~....'
I
;1,0
!o ll:Lr'~n\~
tE::s
----"---'h
('\';:,~i.~ ;
'ot! \\ "H!
l---
'1;1;' '. 'In:l, .,Llii~': ~I :j;'~'7~.
J--'I -r-' /.: ~/- ..# V &'--'
( ~ ~"~-I,:<-::,,,: '.-l!' ~
..-'" ..-1~ "'-:~?-L ct~.: .
:..,,/:: \' "- (1'"...-,1 '^"ito < 1!
-" ,^ I"
. ~ "
""~.i,}i ,/
J .
r~__ ,
..:-,'
-",..<-'
,,,,.""
l,.,,,
""'.,~
,,,,,,,,,,
;......"",
,
''''""",,,0
/
.~~:,~,
'<'.'"',,,,",,,-
$lj:~~
......."€
,~.~
,'"':
.".f.:
~,.,''''.
IO~
'",~...
t
'[ 0: L
~
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
MISCELLANEOUS CORRESPONDENCE
November 27,2007
FOR BOARD ACTION:
A Districts:
I.
North Naples Fire Control and Rescue District: Annual Local Government
Financial Report FY 05-06: Districts Audit for the FY End September 30,
2006; District Map; Registered Office and a Registered Agent Lettcr;
Meeting Schedule 2008; Public Facilities Report.
~
East Naples Fire Control & Rescue District: Minutes of September 27,
2007.
,
".
DepaJ1ment of Communi tv AiTairs: Aliesia Naples Community
Development District. Established by Collier County Ordinance 1\,Jo, 2006-
"
.:,u
B. Minutes:
1. Pelican Bav Services Division MSTBU: Agenda of' '\ovemher 7. 2007:
Minutcs of September 5. 20117
a) Budget Committee: Agenda of October 23,2007; Minutes of May
22, 2007
b) Clam Bay Committee: Minutes of August] 5,2007.
2. Code Enforccment Board: Minutcs of August 23,2007: Minutes of
September 27, 2007
3. Affordable Housin~ Commission: Minutes of ApriL 12,2007; Minutes of
May 10. 2007; Minutes of June 14, 2007; Minutes of July ]2, 2007;
Minutes of August 12,2007; Minutcs of September 13,2007.
a) Sub-Committee: Minutes of August 29, 2007.
4. Floodplain Mana!!ement Plannin!! Committee: Minutes of November 15,
2006; Minutes of December 4, 2006; Minutes of January 5, 2007; Minutcs
of Fcbruary 5,2007; Minutcs of March 5, 2007; Minutes of March 19,
2007; Minutes of April 9, 2007; Minutes of May 7, 2007: Minutes of May
21,2007; Minutes of June 4, 2007; Minutes ofJune 18,2007; Minutes of
July 9, 2007; Minutes of July 30, 2007; Minutes of August 6, 2007
Minutes of August 13. 2007.
-
H:Data/Folmat
H:Data!Fol111at
a) Snecial Infonnation Gatherin!! Meetin!!: Minutes of January 22,
2007; Minutes of January 24.2007; Minutes ofJanuary 29, 2007;
Minutes of February 5, 2007: Minutcs of Fcbruary 5, 2007 (2nd
mccting): Minutes of Fcbruary 12. 2007; Minutes of February 27,
2007: Minutes of March 5, 2007; Minutcs of March 12,2007;
Minutes of March 19,2007; Minutes of March 22, 2007: Minutes
ofMaI'Ch 26. 2007.
5. Citizen COI11S Adl'isorv Committee: Minutes and Agenda of Septcmber
19. 2007; Minutes and Agenda of August 15.2007; Minutes of July I R,
2007; Minutes of June 20,2007; Minutes of May 16, 2007; Minutes of
March 21. 2007; Minutes of February 21. 2007; Minutes of January 17,
2007.
6. Public Vehicle Advisorv Committee: Minutes of October 1. 2007
7 Librarv .\dvisorv Board: Agcnda 01 October 2~. 2007: Minutes of
September 2tl. 2007.
~. Hisnanic Affairs Ach'ison Board: ;vIinut::s and Agenuti ofScptem:J"'::f 27.
2007.
9. [nvironmcntal Advlsorv Council: Agenda of l\io\cmkr 7. 2007: '\1inutc:;
(1 I' Octokr ]. 20(J7
10. Emer"cncv Medical Sen'iccs Ach'isorv Council: Minutes of Octolx:r II.
2007.
11. Black Affairs Advisorv Board: Minutcs or October::>.3, 2007; Minutes of
January 22,2007; Minutes of February 26. 2007; Minutcs of March 26.
2007; Minutes of September 24,2007.
12. Isles of Capri Fire/Rescue Advisorv Board: Minutes of October 4,2007
13. eollier County Government Productivitv Committee: Agenda ofJune 20,
2007; Minutes of June 20.2007: Agenda of May 15,2007: Minutes of
May I 5, 2007; Agenda of March 21, 2007; Minutes of March 21, 2007;
Agenda of April IS, 2007; Minutes of Aplil I R, 2007.
a) CDES Bud!!et Revicw: Agenda for June ]5,2007: Minutes of
Junc 15. 2007; Minutes of June L 2007
b) Efficiencv and Effectivencss: Minutes of April 18.2007
c) TransPoliation Construction: Minutes of March 1. 2007; Minutes
of March 15,2007, Minutcs of March 29. 2007
d) Value EngineCling Rcview Of The Collier Count v Emer!!encv
Services Center: Minutes of May 24,2007
14. Collicr Countv Planning eommission: Agenda of November 15, 2007;
Minutes of October 4, 2007; Minutes of September 20, 2007; Minutes of
Scptember 6. 2007.
15. Tourist Development Council Meeting: Minutes of September 24,2007;
Minutes of June 25. 2007; Minutes of May 29, 2007; Minutes of April 23,
2007; Minutes of March 26, 2007; Minutcs of Fcbruary 26, 2007; Minutes
of January 16,2007.
16. Collier Countv AiIl10rt Authoritv: Annual Financial Rcp0l1 for FY 06-07.
C. Other:
I.
Firc Review Task Forcc: Minutes ofCklOher R. 2007: Minutcs of
Septcmbcr 28, 2007; Minutes of August 28.2007; Agenda of October 25.
20()7.
,
Colii~" Count" Snccial \1acistratc: 'vlinutcs ofSc'pteml)Cr 7, 200e;
Minute, 01' Septembcr:2], :2007.
,
-).
C1h' of:\anlcs'.A..nncxalioll nfCnllier Part OfCOl11lTllTce: Urban Sen'ices
KCpOl1 Octobcr 17. 21J06.
4.
S\3te of Florida Denartmcnt of Health: Activities and expcnditures ofthe
CoJiier County Health DepaJimcnt iCl!' the pcriod of October 2006 through
September 2007.
5,
Guv Carlton. Tax Collector: Financial RepOli Ic)r 2005-2006; Combined
Statement of Position Form DBF-AA-402; Fund Group F0I111 DBF-AA-
403.
H: Data/F ornlat
COLLIER COU"iTY
llem Number:
Item Summary:
Meeting Date:
I;{-Tn
iL.:~'()', :r
P,'cpafl'd B.\
1O;t',"".)4rn'(j0
.- ,m", '<,'r,11"/-:, ;,,<.1,: te. ~Il(' r;::;c;
:...."11'
b ,,'nT (J': ',unr)
--'c"r"!:,",
10 v'"
pr,-,
Appruvedlh
,-" (1\1,
,(;''''\',
;::'"mor"s
,:;;.;,::
'1' :';,'::"J') ~. C'~(
AflfJl"OVl'd By
-'n",
, ,',,,:1:' ,v,,-,.. "';~..
,."
"n'
,~ ;' ;'
j~L ,'("" ^ n,'m.-l.,T,,,._,',r:,,_,,_,',{l~ ,,], ,...,), ,.-0,',",'''"7 0 '-Hnl\[\'"7\ 1'" U 'lllf'r",TC'Jo,. 'I~)"H\ ^ (
I'<lselofl
Ill'"!,",,,,,,,",
-~'--'---~'",
'19:1': i\'G. ,oJ",
(\,)v9mbe~ ':::7. :..:DC7
:J ::
,-
EXEClTIVE SUMMARY
To obtain Board approval for disbursements for the period of November 3, 2007
through November 9, 2007 and for submission into the official records ofthe Board.
OBJECTIVE: To present to the Board of County Conunissioners thc disbursemcnts for
the pCliod of November 3, 2007 through November 9, 2007 for approval as well as to
obtain approval for the submission of the disbursement listing into the official records.
CONSIDEMTIONS: In accordance with Florida Statutes, Chapter 136,06(1), the
Clerk's office requests that these listings be approvcd and made part of the official
records of the Board of County Commissioners,
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: "one,
FISCAL IMPACT: Disbursements as totaled on the attached report
RECOMMENDA TION: That the Board of County Commissioners approves the
disbursements listing for the period ofNo\'ember 3. 20Ci7 through No\'ember 9. 2007 and
submit thcsc documen:s into the ofrlcia! records,
Prepared By:
L (I. r1)J~
Lisa N. Melvin
Assi . ant General Operations Ivlanager
Date:
i' /3h::?
Reviewed By:
Constance C. MUlTay, CGF
General Operations Manager
Date:
1I/(~JO'j.
,-
COLLIER COUNTY
, ~'i,lI,~::;:;:G ,,:;,
Item Number:
Item Summary:
f,<-,',';r;
'N'~I"
.C'c ,'~'i" 0'_""- 'n', li',f
Meeting Date:
"Ii
Prepared n~
Uc.~ iil",I'II"
I \',SIC'~, '-'i.II'~r,,' :::IU",,<Cn, ,. r....;""..;\'",,
[JJK
::I,'ri-, (;,-.:::<."
~I 1,"r
""":!liT1':
Apprlf\cd B~
-.~n""c' r""C'-"\
',-,;"_"',n",.;; '~":'I'.,':- knn.liJ~-
~.. ,]1.,
""... of;:',,,,,,,-
1-,n.l'KJ
C 1 ,.- ,~.
Approved H~'
,Iac:<," i-""U
,,"""'; ha,,,.,w,'
0,,;;
'-"<;"""0; ',u"t...
A,,1""""" oner,-
'-'tV ,',M'J""
pre,
l';igc J of]
" ;1;.I~;',
t-r>'
'-, '-' -' -' -' -' 0-'__ -' f-' -' -'-' -' -' I--' -' -' -' i- -' -,-' -' -' -' r-'-' -' I--' -' ,-,...... -' ,--'.... -' -'-' '-' -' I--' -' -,'-' -' -,~~;,~.~."..,.,.-,_'-,lf-'+..J I-"f~'.~ I
-,-, -' -' -' -' t-' -' -' c::; 0::;' 0 C '=' ::;.-::J COO 0:::>;::' ::J-::J 0::: COO - -'::'>::: COO 00 000 00 0 CC)'G'.::5'~'I....;;booo'6'o ',.:........
"- a"I ~.~..... w w r,) 0 IT! ~ 0'\ 0'\ '~'l Ul '51 W i.J lA" W W W 10 LJ U '=' 0 0 Jl.,J::. W LL' \..oj OJ 'I fl:> W tv U -' -' 0 0 0 O.t. I-' tJ 0 0 cr\ ;;;"'Pyh' l\,'l~\i->,C' .
t~OO~0~romm~~~UO~~.t.~~~[01~-'mWOmUlWOOOOO~mw.....-'~Wo~wromUlwooo~Urol--'~io~6~~
UlmUllJ~mmW~m-'~~OOmUl~~.t.W~IJmUlUO~O.t.OJoOO~mWWmUl~OOm~OO~ WI-'~mUlW.t.mUlmo
w-'mmU~mNUlUl.t.m~~OJWWUlONO~~~NOJOOOOW.....OWm-w~Ul-'NOW-'~WOJ .t.w~l--'-'m.t..t.w.t.-'
~zz~~m~cc~n~~rr283n~z~<W03nn~~ow~~~~nn03~~onnm~H3~~z~ZOW3~U
ro3~~oo~~WO~-'~xp~nOO~~H~~HO~~OO~~~W~OC~~~POO~~~ZHnW3~POC~N~
~ ZM~~MW ~33P~ro~C~~~w~~~~~~~~C3~~~~~~~~~5Z3M~O~OO~ nwcz~~p
~O-~=~ roz~ n~o~o~zz~~~~n~~~~W~~ ~~~W~n~~ 2~~~~~2~C~~OOOn~z
m~~~ mon~ ~ ~~ Z WMM on=~~M~~ ~o ~ n~ c~cAm~~MO~~~Mr~=~O
-n~ Hozncz ~~n~ 0 ~>~M~~~~>n~~ ~M ~Mn~~Z ~oz~~c ~ ~~M M
~n~~MM~x~~~Q O~ Z~3 ~ ~~ pW~rw O~ ~O~~~O ~>~~~nz3w~~n~
~o~z~z~~ ~~~ zo~c H~~C~~ ~~~ ~ ~ 3 ~~Z ~n~~ ~ n OH~ ~OH
~~L z~~o~~wZ HH~ ~~zo c n~o~zoo~~ ~n = wrM> O~ ~ n~nzzo 2m
ill~ >O~HX~OWM ~ooc~ ZMPZ~~~OZ> ~H =0 ~0~>~~n>M~HeO~W> ~~w
OH~n~zn~c ~M ~r~~ 0000 z cnc~~c~n ~~ z ~z HOC~M~~ZH O~~ ~C
MOOOM~~WH~~ MHM> H Mr~HwZ~W~HHX~ ~z HW~OwOCwH<r~WMHMHHW~H
~~CWM H~Z H ~z~z Z~~>O~~~ WG~~ ~~ ~~nw~z~ ~MMM~~z3Qn~c>
-:..... ;denD~ n 0 Z en [I"J t-< tIJ ZO c:::;p >-< l.)-- ':) C-.JtrJ;:c en >-< c::: ~-:J :;trJ en -:J-trJ Z L' ~ l.) tI:lG:ltIJ >n 3:
nZCf)~~0Z G:l ~0 H tIJOZC~~X oz=~~~n ~~~~~ OOZ3COOcn ZH ~-:JO
g~~~3~ Z ~~ oz -:J ~~-:J~~tr:l7.~~~~~~x3 ~ m7.g~~z ~~tIJ~~~~ ~~~~oa
=tr:l~O 0 ~ - ~ Z -~ ~~tIJ~ trJ ~O ro ~n ~~-:J ~Cf)~tIJH~ xnz
-:J :"Z,";'t" mCf) Or::: en c::nz'C:J O;tZ H U::--< ~ 0-;:;) [I"] tIJ);>ZO-:J H20 n
~nzCf)O me ~7. en on~ocz-~ ~ ~ZZ x rnxZ-:JZ>-< ZHZ 0
O;:em ~ -trJ 0 ~< XtIJOO~ n xro trlWOH Z ~<-:J n-:JCf) Z
~~ ~O < ~x ~ =~ n~m-:J~H <0 Cf)-:J Z ~ Cf)HtIJ~n C-:J Cf)
'C~ O~ tIJ ~Cf) H n~ OO~~Cf)Z trJ~ ~ H~ n -:J -:Jl.ltIJOO ~~-:J
0-:1 x" ~ 0 ~ H ~;t0C l.l ~ Q DC H tIJtIJ C~ ~= x
XL' >~ H 'CZ -:J Z 'C~zno -0 ~ zn 0 3: z'C n C
~trJ -:J ~ tIJ G:l ~ ~~ z 0 -:J Z n -:J n
~ HO ~ ~'C en Cf) H H~ no 0 H ~ H -; -:J
-H c~ V 0 0'-' ~ L' 0 r L' 0 -i
0::: Z H Z zn e:) Z Z 0
zn :z [T.: Z
r-J n 8 8 ~ 8
~
rr.
a,w
....L."-.Jr-'
C",(""u..'8
.4 U1 ro
< LTl 0,
U" \D '~"
(X.-.J LJ WCDk'
....Li,f..:O I-J,.w~I.J'--'..c
0,::. -' '~'l --.J Ln CD ~ cr, '-1 <J::
--' ~:c' W '-'
\C 0, u..',
,'-'I,J:"'-'I:'C'\;:)
;.4 ,k'_.~ '
0:' ,"';' L~" -' ~n _..J L!l -' C', 1'_
o.
,I- U' 8'\1::
rr
,Fl --' ,l.~
,_~ '_' \'..:' u--' 0:' S' I) I.";'
::'\'D'JIlc" --.: C' I..', ,,' ~ ~,',,-"~'.,.'-::-;, "...' ~ S --' ::D'~.;c. -'- cr. -J 0:" '1-' " :]':, "', ~ U':J '.~.' I.'" ,,- ----.:::;-, ,~,'..[, ~'1 C",,, C' I.':JJ LL'\i'"0---' Jl
:::.'-.J::::-.- 0--' --' V", C' __' L-' 1-"":-: C. --' ,~" ''';c'' _: ~ ~" ~.' ',', c' '~..,:;. :.: '.11 ',.;:' --':::'!Y, '-' 0 c' :...' c:.~" '"', l~', --' --' '~,',::. Cl:'.,:, CD:: -------.: - < ',"' \,C U-'I~'.!-. ,C '.J Jl
.:::; C,.I-- 0 .=. I,)C'. -------.: '=' 8", ('; ','U' eel '--'1 'J---"'",: V J-.J-. =-.-'- '::-__::: c-' l./' --:)"" I~ - '':' C'Ul c:: '.~ ~....~., '-...[ '1"vJ cr'::: 0_' _,L.. < --.J :::.'0--' 'Y,,-!)!-J_..J
=: c, C'C: ','::::)0--- ',::,1~' 0: ,::,--, -' ~~) ~.;... :::"..L =: ,,,',
::: ..L, lr ~ i,' ''J'', "..[ G, J-~'
.;c. 0'-' .::::' ::.l."'.'; Lr.....J:::.-
.L1::'..;).-o2'''-J'-C--JI..J.!-o
~r, .:- cr:', c", --.; ',,: :::-' ,..; '-S ----.'
:~, _ ~ C1
'"'1-=:
::,-:,....J:::):::. l~ .~:;:::: \.:-,:::':{, 7' - ~.., .::::" 2 ~,' I';'';'" ':::' eJ, C, ,~, C .~
,.C, -.:-::, CJ
:::',0,
~~'_'~I_--'~___'__'_--'.-'--''-'__'_~__....J....J_--'....J--'--'--'~__'--'....J--'--'....J__'__--'''''--'__'__--'--'--'--'r-'--'__'--'____,--,--,--,--,
~--'--'--'--'-,-' ----'--'--'~~--~---'--'~---'--'--'--'~'-'---'--'--'--'--'--'--'--'--'~-'-'--'~--'--'--'---'--'~~--'--'--'--'--'
-' -",,-----.-- "---','" -"..._'.~,_.." '-.---, ,," ",-'-, "'.' ---' -,-'._---._---.,.'.------._---._----~----~---",'-----."-._---------'-~
O~OOCO~O::::_O=,=0GaO~C_:::oc=_CC'O::::_OOOO=_C=,=,CCO:::_O=_=OO=_COOCOO0000:::-000
G~W~ ~c~'~~~~~~~ W 8'~-...[~~U~~~c:~~~,~~.J-~~~~__.J__.J_______.:_..J__.J~mG~~Ul~U'U":~ILnLnLn
~.i U I..l '..1 I' "..;, LH.,; U U t ~ ~,1 I ',J r" 1'_ "'~ I..' t,11,' I,:' I,' t'.J i,\ ',: U LJ Ll I,,) L1 I,' 'J t I,,~ 1,\ I,) I,; I',) '-J I,;: J k1 I.J I',' t.) 10 U t.", 1'_' 1_', I,) t,..' t,J 1,110 k)
OOO=-C:::O=,COOGOCOOCGCOOCCOC-C02COOOOCCODO~00COOOOOOOOOO00000
OooooocaOOOOOCOC'COOOCOOOOCOOCOOCOOO::"OOOOOOOOOOOOOOCO000000
-.J~__.J~_..J_..J~_..J_..J~-------':_..J_..J_..J_..J~~~-.J.~~~~~_..J~_..J_..J_..J~_..J_..J_..J-------':~_..J~_..J~_..J'.J_..J_..J-.J~~_..J_..J_..J__.J_..J~-.J~~-.J~-.J
t.l[V I,,) ,..) t..'!-J 1.1 t-J L' 1-.:' t;, t.J t~l I,J i-J I..) 1.1 to t.: 1_' t.J I..) I,) I-J t.) '.J U!..) t-J I'.J~': t..;~.J I";' 1-...\ rJ I..) t.J L' !,-' t.J 10 t--', U t..) '_' I,') I-J i~', L) t..J 10 to 10 :,', t,..) 10 10
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOC'OOOOOOOOooooooaOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO00000
OCOOOOODOaaOOOoocOOOOCOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO0000
OOOOOOOOOOooooooe,OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO00000
~~~~~~~~__,,_,~__,~~~~~~~~~~-,~__,~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~,_,~~....J~~~~~~
~Ln~Ln~Ln~~~~~LnLn~LnLnLn~~~~~~Ln~~Ln~~~~Ln~LnLnm~~~m~Ln~~~~Lnm~~~m~mmmmm
~~~;.4J-~~....~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~J-.4~~~~~~~;.4~~~~WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW
OOOOCOOOOOOOOCOOOC000~=OC=OOOOOOOOOOOOOOO~~W~;.4~J-~~~~~~~~~~
~~mmmoom~mrnoom_..J~~~~-.J-.J_..J~_..J~mmmalm~~~OOOOOOOOOO~~~~~~W~~rnoomoommmm
~ '=' leG) _..J U\L:lL. W U --' 0 '.0 cr _..J 0\ u-,';';' W 'J ~ OlC en <:.~ L:loL m...(~J \.{J (Xl ~ 0\ Ui ~ G' I.l -' 0 '-1:' C:' ~ 0\.... ,dl-.J --' 0 '.0 m -.J C' Ul.L lo) IV
~
~
,
~
~
,
~
C
C
Z
D
H
o
~
'"
.
'<
H
o
>-
>-
~
~
~
"
o
m
~
"
m
S
'"
ro
'l:l
o
~
"
'I~
I
I~
:1
fa!
!~
'.::l'
'fa'
'1.{'3'
Ii'
i;.,.
1-.-:;:-'
ila';
: i.":\t~;
M.~~
>ii
n,
H
.
"
"
o
o
m
~
It"::
'I'
, .
, ,j
!iI
!,o,
,;n;
,EfJtJ
N
'~(i~ II i
i I ~ I
I - -'-=-,
H'"
Z"d
-13:
,"Cl
"'
~~
~"d
"'
'"
<
'"
"'i
tr}
'"
t'l
"'
<
n
'"
,
,
"
(
,
,
I
i
l
,
D
~
,
C
,
,
f-'
f-'
'"
~
f-' '.D
f-' CD W .
W ~ ,.
f-' w' C "
f-' cnc ~'
0, .........::;, ,[~
~
"
,
,
r
,
C
HH
il2:
'if.:
~.~.;'.
:1~1
i -. t
I~ I
"
'"
"
"
'.-..........
00
I:::~
r-lt-J
00
00
...,...,
'. '. u'o .1.....'
; gg ic' i
: 00 I
j-J.--' i
U11J1 I'
1.4..... "
~~!
___.WIV .t. ~,
w
~ ~
0-.",/1\ 0
:: ~ :: (~
~ ~
~ ~
N ,,, 19
000
ceo 0
000
~ ~
UTLnUl
~c~
~ ~
,lo;i.....,
.....C.co
~ .,
. .
",,(XCI:)
~ "~
~ .
!-,C\D
N ~,' N
cODO
000
000
~-~
lnt1lLrO'l
........,L.c....
lnU1LFlJI
v_' W v-' W
--,,,,,no*>
~
.
a 00
" ~
, .
'" -.l
~
. "
7_0:> [1
"~ "
C\ J
~ "
~
.
00 "
~
. ,
W k'
~ ~,
"".;r """',
00 'J CO'L'
~ ~
(t-, ~, l1T
~ ~
~
. ,
00
~ "
lJ\(.n
~ C
,,' N ~,'
cOr-,
CO:=>
coco
- ~
'f l1T L:"
v.-' W v.;
v-\.71 Lr,
r-' N r,'
l~ .. ,,"'
f..:> "- 19 k> N
ace 0
o COO'
OCOCO
..... >-.....>-1-'
LJ1\J'l1TLrU'1
W"".....L"'''''''
Vl,rVlL'lUl
1..:1 1._' N f-'.....
N >-- 0 ~ co
-..l -J....J
r;>'\ '''0"1
00 (r 00
~ "~
~ ~
~ ~
~ ~ ~
cor,crt IJ\
(X COOOal(;DCD'""
"" .... ... ... ~. .... ....
'..DUlLn...4.....""
,~ .... _ \D '" -..l
"~
CO
00
o
~
~~
c~
" ~
, ~
l.r,,,..
,_, N
00
c: 0
co
-~
lnV'l
c~
l~ l1T
~
~
Ie N N
CO _ 0
::: 0.:;;> <:>
:: 0 Co 0
-~ ~
Vlc"lJ\
~~ ~
,PU1 l1T
~ 0
1- 0 '" 0>
~
(7\e,-.,
CD'."
~"
~"
~ ".
...,) -.l ..J -.l .oJ_I ...:-:,~,.1Ar~
"" (" 0, (]', O'l r)\ 0'1 (J., 0\ 'CI> 'G'\ '.."- _
CD ,~' 00 (.1.' 00 "- CD (L> (l:l 't.' 00 0' -,
:: "" :: ~: ~ :: ~ t:, ~ ~ e ~ fif
..., .... \D cro-lcr-,Vl...W '"
~
00
o
CO
-~
lrl1T
"~
,,.U1
o
,.
~
CO
00
CO
~
~
cW
~ ~
o
~
UN "'-'
Ooc
COO
coc
-~
I.J'IJI Lfl
I~' ..... l>-'
~ ~ .
CO o'~
f-'O<.D
t--'t.>
CO
DO
DO
-~
~~
'"' W
(nUl
C 0
.
N 1'-' 19
o 00
00 COO
o 0 C,
~ ~-
<J'I ,,. l1T L~
ow w W ,~'
01&.<>""""
IO\[ \D \,!,
00 "" a. ,,~
,~
CO
o
_ 0
~
Lr'l1T
" W
J ~
c W
c ~
'" 19 ~ N
coco
C 0 C 0
CO C <;:I
>--1-'>-1-'
,rUlL-"UT
l>-' W "-' IN
L5 l1T (_~ l1T
W h;' N
0-': O'J
" ~
cO
CO
o
~
IT l1T
" W
',n.....
'_'N
-':'0'1
l-'>--l-'f-'.....f-'~~~~~_~ ~~~ ~~~~~~~~~_~ ~ ~ ~~'~~~ ~,~~
~~~-~~~~~~~-~~~-~~~~~~~~~~~~~-~ ~~~~~~~-~~~
"-"'--"""-'-'-"'-'-'-'-""'-'-'-'--'--
OCOCOOOCOCOOOCOCOOOCOCOCOGOOOOOOOCOCOCOCOOOO
~~~~~~~~~~~~~-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
--,-,--"-,-,'.,-,---,-,-,-,-""-",,,----,,,
N~NI~~~M~W~N'.'N~N~NI~NI.W~N~N~NI~~~Wt~N~N~N~N~N~NW
OCO~OCO~OCOOOCOCOCOCOCOCO OCOCODO~.000CO 0000
000 0 0 COD 0 0 0 0 0 C 0 COO 0 C 0 c 0 COO C 0 C 0 cOO 0 C 0 ~ 0 _ 000
~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~ ~~~~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~
C_C_d Cc_=occ_c-CCO=C C
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ b ~ ~ ~ S ~ ~ ~ S ~ ~ ~ 8 ~ ~ ~ C ~ ~
~
o
o
o
~
~
~
~
o
V
"
tt
~
v.
~
~
o
~
o
o
00
~~"i
tt:: ~
:>' ::U:-. G
~ <T. 2 I- ;;
CO
tI: 0 ..,? ,..
~ ~~ X Z ~ ~ ~
Z H ~ ~ - ~
16 7' ~ _ ::.; ..~ g: H
~'-~~~~~
() CJ 0 r; M rrJ
><: fJJ .-<:tI tr:' 'r
>-;.0 ~CJ;.'>:l
~~UJ t"';ii
~~e;~
..; t"'P'
:~S~
" ~
~ GJ >,
:;:;:<"~
~ ""' ~
o
"
"
~
. C
" v.
!:J ~
~
~ ~
tJ r'
"
&; '!:
m _.
~ '::.,
:r- :1:'
~ 7.
::-: G'
~ -
m
m
"
" ,-
r-:
~
C
.-,
c
"
-.
3
~
~
.
o.
o.
,.
"
"
V
w
~
t':I r;- ['; - t;;
:r. _ t"' ~ 0
;e IT ~ ~
" "
~
H
o
~
is
~
"
-co
;;:; c:
~ w
o ~
8!::fi
.,.
Cl ;l::...J
'T1t'l71t>l [1J
"" ..., U
() ,-J:J-
"_,:r: r G ~
~
r
r
~
':'t"'
"
-
~
~
o
..0
%
.
~
.. ~
f1;;
" .
"
'T1l:'l
m
~
o
~
~
c
o
o
" n
~ _ 0
~ t) - 8 E
~ .
~
;: 10'
"
~
~
~
w
"
~
~
~
"
7"i :,.
o
>< ~
c.
=
~
U- :r-
o
00
~ 0
~ :- f;;
cr:tt1 t>l,-.;.-
_gu_~_i'.i
H ~' :::
~ :<Q
;po rJ P
Ir' ;!;
trl :;
,.
'"
3
z: :2
'"
,.
'tI ~~
t" c:'''I;l
t>il <: t"
m
co
o
e
to G') H
. ~
~~8
...;' Z ;: ~
to IT: Z
cr; Q ,,-:'
~
.~
~ :::
:t>
~
IT:
"
H
'" -
n
~ 0
L'" )';;-
'"
. 0
., C
~
tr1:n
'" m
tr.l "-'>-i
'"
~
~
"
~
"
~
w
~
co
o .
~ ~
~
'"
Co
~
H
n
~ ~ Vi L~ ~ ,J, 5i ~ :;;
0' oc'o=o,"'t;1
~
"
~
c n
c 0
c ,.
" - 00
H "
~ ~
:-' ~
:;Ci
i:-; ~
o '.' t>l
~ rn
" '"
" H
;; _. B
~ 'C' g ::;
~ r: &; ~
'n
~
C
'"
~
~ g ;:
"
.
w
00
~
o
~
"
'c
w
'-'
o
~
~
o
o
o r,
~ - ;;
" H
tJi ..;
:>:: :0-
C
." I"~
~ :;,.
o
l'l !T1
Ul ;l:
00
~ :.'l:
rn
~
Ir ~
~6
~
"'
"om
w
~
"
o
c
~ ffi U' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
r:: tJ t:I.., tl '='~'
~
o
.
.
o
o
~
"
o
o
"
o
~
~
"
~
o
c
.
w
o
c u: :;:;
~
"
r ~
~
.
"
~
m
o
[Ii ~
'.j,t"
~
'm
~
"
II
Ii
<
S-
o, '.
.
0.
t" ;t,
~
~
"
~
rn
c
~
'"
.
%
,
,
~
~
"
o
~
~
~
o
o
~
E
II
'r.
"!;
r; z:
c "
, ~
~ ~
, .
~ tJ>
n
o
0.
.
'").1J!lJ;
t6 jII l>I
.,~ * ~
=,' .~
p
.
"
)< 0 '>:
---..O'.z
. ~ rn
0,,"
"'"
~
~
"
~ "
~ e
w ~
rn "
~ ".
W "
~.
"
0.
rn
,
,
~
~ ;; ~
'" .
(\l '1....
W
,
~
o
o
~
~ tIJ ~
C
<~
~ :
~ '" -.J
01 "-,01
~,~
lJ1..flU1
~ ~
\D 0'-,,]
..
w
~
~
-0 ~
~') 01
tt~
!.1'Ul
~~
C, ~
-.I o".]---Jo".]
Gl (1\ Q-,(1\
oocowm
'JlU'llJ'U!
~~~
..' W '-' ~
I-' .., ", l.l' CT, W
...J -.l k' 0 >- 010
--J ,~~ I-' ,., olo I, U1
o
o
0_ 0
00...,
~6:::~:-g~;:
~ ~
W ~
~"~
~ ~ g;
H r:r 0
1:" ! ~; tIl
~
, ~
C ~
C
Ul tIl:. f'l
;; is ~'S
>-3 := H
H ll'>.-: "0
@~,~r.:~~
2 s ~s
Cl tf.l 'n
~F971e
~ ;1; "0 n::;
~ ~ ~
=n:'l:!
~ ~; G:I g =
'Il = 'D >
t" >trJ'Il
:: ~~~
m>--otIl
00
." ~ ~
" >
~
~
>
'"
"
-.I ...J _' -.J
G\OIcr,OI
ooooa.'ClD
U' r.n ~n Ul
000
\D C1:' ...:!
_, ....:r -.I
("0\,,,
o-,oom
U'lUlt;r1
oC-'
c"Ul
-.J --.: ..:! ~) ....
0\<]\0\",,,,
(DCD(D<:Il(D
Ul t;r1 Ul c~ 01>
000 c;' \D
... "'"",';-'",,
~ ~
c, ~
w~
C~
C ~
" ~
'0
~
(;1,(1\
oo~
"~
~~
C~
~
~~
~~
-~
'.!.'lC
.., ...
_~ ...:I
(;I, C\
m ~
- ~
" ~
k'l-'
~ ~
:",(1\
~~
"'-""
\D (0
0:.0\0
~
~
>L; '"
w
~
c
c
"'CC~WC"O
'" = 0 =c' \D co Ul
c;.. '-<!:: H >-. H := =:
- ~ ~ I . ~ ~ ~ i & I
Cl 0 - 0 "':0: r::
;; )-: r;:: '.. ~ !j ~
= I:"' 1:"'-
:t> n :-" I':l [T1 t:I'J
t:I'J riP:! r:rJt:I'J
:;.:
~
D'J"<:l
~ ~
cO
"
H
~
~
~
'"
c
~
0'---'
~ ~
g ~
~ OJ
1':1 :"
~
g ~-~
'"
"
~ .~
w
~
~
~ '" -.
"
,
H.
o
o
o
n
o
~
S;E
~'"
'" 0
H ~
~'<~
~ 0
~s;g}
C~
"" rr; <:
t" [T1 H
n
~~
roo
:;
~
~
..
00
;; :;
if; ~ ~
~~ih
:5"ll
:rll:"' t""'
~
w
~
~
W :r VI M 0) \L "., '~1Xl '-C
0) ~ w ~ ~ 0v \0 ~ ~ ~ -.J ~ 0\ _ 0\
-.J C -.J ~ VI ~ co I~ ~ ~ -.I 'f ~
ll'> ::[ 0
:t> ~
.00
~oo
::co
00
" >
~
if;
:-'J()
~o
C~
~S
~
.~
"~
~; 0
~~
DC'"
~:
'>:l t,.!'>:l
t"r=1t"'
~
r
r~
H
"
~
H
~f5
C';Z:
,:) u.
': ~ ~
~~~
~ ~ ~
" z
n"
;;H~
!:-:z: t:"
~~~n[h
trJPJn::
ii;~8~~
cc
:;~~~
~ if,
r '-~ ~
[Tj tIJt"
[() liJ
00
a
c ~
-L~
S~::JO<
"'"
.~
:;;; H
mZ
n
M
='"
::J>-3
n
~
DH
OZ
< ~
Mn
~
~
g~
o
~
"
~
"
'" ~
~ ,-
7
c.)
r;:
"'
;;
=~
-~
:::-'1:"'
:r::Pl
~, :z:
:::;to
:';n
~
~
H
n
~
~
'"~
:~
" ~
~ s: ,",
~ a>,
tIl UJ
crJ n (jJ
,., >-
00 -
8~E
~ M "
~ (;; E
~"n
e
>
H
~
~
"
~
.
~ w
=- \0 "'" N
~~;~:::Jg\r~
"
:;;fl
-~
CQ
':::::>::r
;l' 0
"~
5~ t-:l
~
~
o
c:.,Cl
~ "
C ~
.:;, :>-
;"'l
~
C-,',,,"
~m
"~
woo
" ~
, G"l I.. oo:t
~ g ~ ~
>-<; 0 t"'
~ ~ [:! >-3
" M
R
"
:>" 1:-'
H ~
tl':l [1'; ~ ~
:e ;.;:1
n
C;~
c ~
~ tIl
"
n
.~
:OZ' ::c -
o
,"'; ~
~~
, ~
.1'\0\
m ~
-~
moo
c. ~
-' ~
CT'.""
m~
-~
woo
.w
~
"~
m~
"~
m~
c ~
;;i~~~,II~i=~cH W
~ : ~ : ::E :r~:j~~) IC;~':";, 1'i"
C1> -.l ---c. --.I ...., '-. ::l ~
o \Q 0:, ~ C\ I ~~
,
"
,,'\0
'"
:t~
.-rJPl
~F, to
-~
""
K ~
:[1:>::r
M
'fj(rj
~ 0
~~
nn
M~
U)t/)
~z
.>
~
~~
~~
coo
m
~
g ,J'.' i;
~
C C
(. 0
::::':>;l
-~
C'tl
"" :0<
" ~
.. C
~~
~
-,.. ~
___~n_ .__~..___.._.._j__
~~g6~~~~~6~6~6~~~6~~~6~6g6g~~~~~g~g~g~~6~~g6il'
Q~OOOOOOOOCOODOOOOOCOOOOOOOUOCOG000008000000
O~OOO~OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCOOOOOC00
~-~~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~H>-~~~ H-H-H~~-H>-H~H>-H~H>-
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Ul~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~VlU~~
w~ww~wwwww...wwwwww~wwwwwwww...ww~wwwww~ww...~wwww
~'n~~~~~~~~~~Ul~~~~~~~~~~~Ul~~~~~~~~~~~Ul~~~VI~~~
oom(Dmmrn~-.I-.J~~~~~~~~~~~(1\m~m~~~~~n~~Ult;r1~rn.~.~.~.~
~~~.~ It> m -.J CD Ul W 1'0--' f-I C, \D en ~ Cf\ Ul ~ W.,"'" f-I ~_,~~~_.:':.~.~,::",,,~":':'.--=:,,~~_~~_
~=~~~~~~~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~=~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~!I
""""""""""""""',""""',""
O~OOOCOCODOOOOOOOOOOOOOCOOOCOCODOOOOOOOOOOOO
~~~-.I~~~~~~....~...J~...:I~~~-.J-.I~~...:I~~~...:I~~~~~""-.I~~-.J~~-.I~~~~
"""",'"""""""",-"""""",-"
~6~~~6~~~6~~~~~6~6~6~6~6~~~6~6~6~6~~~6~6~6~~ .
~SS~~~~S~3~3~3~~~3~~e3~3~3333S~3~s~~e~3~~S~S i
;~~.~lf~~~~g~~~~~~~~~~~~~m~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~m~m~~~11
!o OCOCOGO~~~O~OQ~~OOO~OOO~OOO~OOOOOOOCO~OCOO ~
~ I
~ ~
~ !I.i
~
~
0~ ~
M
~~
~
,] g; ~
-= t-t
~~
~
w
N
~
~
t-.l _1U'1
o -J a, ._
~ " ~
-0
TO
^ ~
-'"
c
>n
~O
~>
g~
~" 8
<~
tr.(I;I
~~
~ g ~
Z tl1
"'" "1
:~ >'
r t" 'JJ
m
" -
tfJ e,
~H
tr.I~B
m
~E
M ~
(I) Q
00
~
~
~
t5
m
" -
~ ~
,~ f/)
~~ ~~ ~
~ 0 :g;j ~
O::-t<1~
." f/) IJ)):I >-<" m
r tIl tIJ'tI [fj
~ ~
<: -:: n
... ~
OQH
$5;r;~
~~8
.. ~
mWH"rJ
~ C
~
w
~ ~
w .. 0
"ill
~~~~~
r-p:j.....H[J)
-<;l'l t- J:"' n
rn.....Hn
H ,-J t-:l
~:;J"':O<~
r.r; '>:l ~ ~ 0
;r> ~ >' >' ::>:l
3: 'tJ"Cl 6"
(10< r;, ~ rE
X [I] if) UI '-'
0"
tl)'TJ"iltr
t't;' l-r:
"
9
"
r",
"
~
_-..__.n_n___._._______ _ _________~_____ __ ______ _ .___~,
'"
~
'"
~
~ "
"' l ~
"'"
~ i
'"
'"
~ ~
"
, '"
'"
c
'"
'"
~;:;
~
~'"
S=U1
;;]1-;
:J:> Z
n
~
~~
~n
:J:> ~ u. "'J
'" ~
~g~
~
00
ili
, .1
d' ; g
!:l'O III
~ -"
. , p
p .
~ g
o
o r
Po 0
, 0
p
- "
o ~
o
o C
o
i
>' 0 "'l
,~=
~ ~ .
0>
~ ~
~
~
-
~
~
~
W
00
~
~
W
~
"
C
'"
~
'"
e-
"
Po
.
e
;;.
"
<.
,
~
"
lLi
"
r
,
"
'" C ~
. . ~
"' . ,
, " ~
W
,
W
o
o
~
w ~ 0
'" ~
r
~ ~
~ ;:;
~ -
~ "
~ ~
~ ~
a,()\
w"
~ - ~
a, a\Ol
oorr (J)c;r,
~ ~
0\ I.11VC
... C ..:> 0:
N ~
000
oeo
o Cc 0
~~...
lJI,-nQl
"'.....'W
0\0'0\
"'tv""
~"~
~@~&:~@
~
.0
~ ~
t..l 0',
W ~ ...:
~
~
o
~
~N
00
DO
DO
........
~~
w W
m~
~~
O~
~) W
00
CO
CO
~ ...
lJ",t11
ww
m~
~, ~
~W
~ ~
a a.
~ "~
U1 ~n lJI
IJI VI IJI
-l ry',1JI
-.;. -.l
m
m~
LClUl
c' ~
,C W
-l ..._.-...1
0\ OlO 0,
O)(J)CD(J)(I:(J)
,y lJ1 'J' U1 U t11
lJ1 ...........
I-' C' \D U -..J
eN
cO
00
CO
~...
,,"Ift
c...' W
,. ~
W~
"-,I-'
,.; W '" W k' to.)
DecOcO
cooooo
C' 0 0 0, 0
>-1-'>-'1-'+--....
lJ'1JIlJ'U1lJ'Ul
WWWI.O>L-1>>
mO\m"'m.a,
"'........................
010 m."J C", lJl
'" W "- ..,
OOco
OOCO
OOCO
>-'1-' I-'
(J'.U1lJ'U1
<"';1oI"-'l,o.I
''''''''''''
~~ ~
~. W N I-'
~ ~ ~
"'" C' a,U" 0\
"'-'0;) CI 00 a; 00
LnUl" UI:.rL1l
.............. ....
,~'\ VI .t..., ....
~
~
" ~
,nU'l
eW
~
e. ~
CO
DO
00
~...
~~
ww
m ~
~O
O~
C' ~
CO
CO
00
~ W
~~
w W
~ ~
CO
rn~
t.' W
00
00
DO
~...
C' ~
wW
"~
DO
"~
, ~
~
0"00
C~
W
,. ~
,. N
CO
DO
00
~~
LJ,Ul
WW
"~
00
~ W
~
[',.,.
",.0)
,-, Ul
" W
~
N N
00
00
C., 0
~...
~~
WW
"~
00
W'"
- ~
" ~
c ~
~
W
eW
~N
00
CO
DO
~...
,~~ Ul
wW
"~
O~
O~
~
'')',c,
w~
iY Ul
W
~
" N
CO
00
,CO
~ ~
"~
W
'''11l
~~
" ~
_,-.I
",0\
u ~
,~~ Ul
w~
C ~
~ ~
'" ~. 0\
~w~
11llJ".tn
NWN
~"~
,. N
CO
CO
CO
~~
"~
WW
m~
~~
'-'1-'
- ~
c, m
" ~
l~ t11
~
W
~'lr~
~ ~ 'rS
,
I-'>-....>-....>-....~...>-....>-....>-'....>-....~I-'>-....>-....>-....>-...>-'I-'>-....>-...>-'....>-....>-....>-'...>-....+-- I
1-'>-....-....................................................................................+--...-...............................+--..............................................
,~"'~-~""""""""'~~~,~"'~"~~~~~"~
OOOOOOOCOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOI
~~~~~~~~~~~-~~~-~~~~~-~~~-~~~-~-~~~-~-~~~-~~
~"~"~~~~,~""-"'~~~,~,~""'~~"""-"-
NWW~WWNW~NN~~'~NN~~~WNN~~NWNW~~N~N~N~~NN~WWN~
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCOOOOOOOOOOOO
OCOOOCOCC OCOCOOOOOOOOOOOCOCOCOOOOOCOOOOOOO~
I~~~~~~~ ~ ~-~~~~~~~~~~~-~~~-~-~~~~~-~-~~~-~
--~------- -------- --
L' N
00
00
CO
~...
l~, Ul
WW
~. ~
~~
~~
~, to.:>
00
00
00
~~
m~
c W
m ~
~~
~ W
':---'-"
_..l.--'
C-,_''';'-
m~
(nUl
NN
"....
eN
00
00
00
~...
"~
w W
~, ~
"m
C~
~:;~i~~
000 ,
OOG '
:;; t;: ~ I'
"" w w -,
V1....;.n '
"~~
~~~
I
~
N
~
I
I
I
----
~ ~ c" Ii
:', I
:;: i
c: c=C:=OCdL.-OCC:_CCC:_Ccc ecc: c_c:cc_e::co
~~g~~~8~~~~~~~8~~~~~S~g~~~~~~~8~~~~~g
~
o
o
o
o
J
c ~
v tii
~; ~
:-rJ Pl M
" L~
~
a:: ~
.
~
~
.
M
"
M
"
P
~
~
p
~
~
~
,
o
m
,
~
o
o
~
~
"
~
o
o
~
w
\l: J rn
W 0 C'
~
0;>.1-.""" ...
0:> "0 <r-.
N ~ CO 0 0
~
w
U'_ ~_ -.l
o =-- 0
0"
o
'[. }2 ~
::::;;;:::
~ -
"
rr- g
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
E Co ~ ~: Q ~
_ ~ n ~ ~ ~ ~
~ t"' =:: ..,
~
-
"
r.1 _
.., c?i '
o H ~
g"J~,:"
<: m ~ ~ T
o
~ w
~
o
3: ~ ~
.C
,.
:r.
~
~
r
~
~
~ "
m
~ 7
;;J
n
o
;oj
"
~ 0
-- t'" f~ t"'
~
:::~
'.S
r
~
~
~
~ ,.
~ ~
~ ~ ::: ~ g
~
::JI:"
~
~
c
~,
w
o
m
a ~
o ~ 0
~ ~
~ ~
:j ~
Pi :J:
~ >< - ~
[t" ~ ;t. a1
~::r:::::-,i
~ t: ~ >
>
~~~
[/: g r<:
H =
"
c
n
o
'"
.., -
o
1:: "
~ B; ~
o
t-< ''1
o
C
~ "
"' ~
<
H
~
~
m
~
~
W
~
~
~
~
o
~
~
"
~. e;
" w
~
~
o
~
~
ro
g; ;;;-
.., - ~
t"' !:"
;:;ttl tIl'
"' W
~
m
o w
0.........,.,
o l-' '" ...
00:.'" ::' '"
S
;~~;~;;T~~
?S ~
~ ~ ~
~
>
'.fJ2:
"'~
~
~
m
"'
... r:-;
::r.
" 0
~I
iiW;!
~
''"
!
C'
u;
"
W;! '"
~
~
r.l!:'
OJ]
'"
~
,
~
'l:I ;>--
~
g; ~
o:;~~
CJ:'''lI'S'tllJ'
g~t"'~~~
a r-< tn ,l..
(j t:r1
,..
~
< ,-
o
~
'"
.
'"
\J1 cr 0-.
"' 0
o w
; H
~ ~- ~
00 rn
"' "'
"
~
~ ~
)0' ,""'C
H c m
c n
" ~
t'J ~ ~
:E:vte
o c::'"
~ G ~
"'"~
~'J
2:t'J~
~ 0
'E~~
:'l S
11:;10,
~
o ~
.,..:Z:~
r- ::D
~
o
o
~
.' Q
~
"'
~
7- ~
:r. g
H
:r: ~
~' gJ
~
N
(t) c- I-'
~ " ~
c
I
"' '"
-w ~ !
;:..~
p "
~~
.
"
('; ~
p .
, "
'0 ~
. .
= w
'"
o
o
~
.
.o~
:;-~@
a ~
w ~
~
~
~
~
~ ~
~ e.
W ~
m ~
~ ".
W "
e:
M
'"
'"
.
"
~
,
c
>
,
~ ;; t
"' .
(I> ., t:
,
"
C
G
~
,"
< ~
~ L-J
~ ~
~-J-.l-J-..l~-..l'-';-.l-i...:i -..l
Ol m 0\ cr\ 0\ m 0\ 0', 0'1 0-, 0\ 0',0'1
(1;1 OJ (1;1 OJ (1;1 00 0) cr, W "-, W "-' to
0'1 m 0'1 ~ 0\ 01 0'0 0', U\ Lr' U\ en lJl
co O~Q_OO\C \CI.DIQ
-.J m U\ .1-. t..J t,' I-' 0 IQ [>, -.J 01 Ul
tJNt>.l
o c 0
000
000
...~...
01 (J' 01
W ,,-' W
~~~
~ ~ ~
".. .....' t>.l
"-'t>.lt-.l1\.1
0000
0000
0000
"".........1-'
V"lJlU'lUl
(...;www
010'1010\
~~ -.l '" 0'0
o~~
"'-'6-'1__.;....
ooco
c> 0 0 0
0000
...~...
U'lU'lUlU\
Wl.lw....
"'O'I"'Q\
'" 0'1 (1., 0\
-JO'IUlor>
~~
" ~
~~
", ~
,"'\I>
~
~~
00
00
00
-...
Lr', U\
~ ~
~~
,,~
'''-'1\.1
~~
00
c' 0
00
~...
~'"
w w
~~
,,~
~o
~~
c, ~
~~
'"
" ~
"-'1-'
~
c, ~
~~
CC~
\DO'>
D\,O
, ~
,,~
~~
~ ~
m m
m ~
~
~~
m~
,c ~
"' m
([,U\
~
~~
ill~
,,~
em
.w
,~
" ~
ill~
,,~
""0:>
r,'l-'
_~ -..l
m~
ill~
,,~
ill ~
C' ~
N~
00
00
00
~...
m~
ww
c, ~
..
ill~
,~
0\ 0,
"'~
" ~
~
ill ~
N ~
00
00
00
~...
" '"
"" w
c, ~
'.
w
" ~
c, ~
m ~
,,~
~~
O,U\
,~
~, 0'1
illm
"'"
~ ~
.w
~ ~
m~
om
(fllJl
- ~
,w...
w ~
c, ~
0'0:>
ill'"
,~
::"\0
tj:~~;~~~~W'I' '~~.'-~,!,~ g
~~~~~ :e:,~:~tf"":~;'-
0',0\ 0\ 01 m : .> ' ::I :-<:
CD -.l (:, UI ,4 , ~~
,
"
N~
00
00
00
~...
ill~
l.:W
, ~
WW
ill'"
N~
00
00
00
~...
,,~
,~ w
,,~
~ ~
. ~
1\.-'''''' t-.l
000
000
000
~ ...
()1u\ 'n
W W W
0\0'10\
ww~
1\.-' I-' 0
I
:1
N~
co
00
00
~...
ill'"
ww
D, ~
ill~
W~
N~
00
00
00
~...
LT,U\
W W
c, ~
0' ~
,~
N~
00
00
00
~...
ill'"
w W
ill ~
m~
U'...
N~
00
00
00
~ ...
ill'"
ww
~ ~
~~
w ~
N~
00
00
00
~...
"'"
ww
0, ~
.~ ~
~ ~
~~
00
00
00
~...
~~
ww
~~
.~
~~
_._~.._--~_..._---_.~.._.-
k' N
co
00
00
~...
'"~
~~
,. ~
.~
"'to'
r-llo.l "'-'1\.1
00::>0
0000
0000
f-'.....~....
LnOl<r.U'1
www
0\0'10\0'1
.......WW
CWOO-..l
....f-'....~....~....f-'....f-'.....~....f-'....f-'....f-'I-'.........f-'....f-'....f-'....f-'....f-'....f-'.... ....~....~.....f-'....~....
I-'~....-.....~....f-'....f-'I-'_....~....f-'I-'f-'...._...._...._...._I-'_...._...._...._....._...._...._...._...._
""""""""""""""""""""""
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
-..l~-.l~-..l~~~-..l~-..l~-..l~-..l~-..l~-..l~-..l~-..l~-..l~-..l~-.l~-.J-J-..l~-..l~-..l-J-..l~-..l~-..l~
"-"""-'-','""""""",,-----,--------
~~W~N~Wrv~~N~NWN~N~N~~NNrvWNNWNNNNNNNNN~NNNI__.;NN
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
-..l -..l~-..l-..l-..l~-..l-..l-..l~-.l~-..l-J-..l~-..l-J-..l-..l-..l-J-..l-..l-..l~-..l~-..l~-..l-..l-..l-..l-..l-..l-..l-i-.l~-..l~
-----~._- _._-,._------_.,-~'_._-_.._-_.._-_._--_.._--,
~~~wg~~~~~aw~~~~g~~~~G~~~G~
OOOC000~O~O~OHOOOOO~OOO~O~O
~
o
~
o
o
:-
- ~
~
~ -
~
U'1 '-' .... ['._' w
... cr, _ U'1
W Q, '" C Ul
~
~
.
m
I" \L'VI
-.l (~, 0
n
~ ~
- ~
~
H
- ~
~
~
~
o
~
~
~
~ -
~
:: 2 "-';:;
:::.' <: .,<....
E ~ Ie; ~
Z
~";c
o Jc.;to'
"'3 C "
H ~, t1
" ~
~ i;~ z
~ ,., f-
~ ~ ~
w"
?; tIll~
T_ - :--,
" ;;:-
.~ 'l.'l :;::;
V;l:'" ll'
~'"
~ tIl ;;
~ m
~
leJ
H
Z
n
z
o
~
c
~S!
~
H
~
~
.
o
_ 0
l' g
[T,:Z;
IJ;
o
~ z
C' ~
>
a
o
~
~
ill
t.> 1',01
W ~
. 0
o
c
~
~
~
.
.... ''''V1
or> W U'1 C tv
IJ1 C m C, \<> 11l
"-1--'0',
.,
ro
o
~ ~, ~ C ~ ; g C ~
o
o
if ~
-,,0
::::>:l
:;:;..,
;:~ Ii';:
:::'-;&:1
,
..-; ~
=~
>-01-1
Q
z
;rj"i
fJJ
Z
:c; ~
':':>:l
~H
Pjr.(l
U-.
~n
~~
if_ P:l
~
- ~
c,
~
c, ~
n
-~
o
~
n
~o
z~
~S
~ m
Z~
", ~
;c> g
~[:;
,~' :
~..;
j~
2:;t>'
~g;
i'rJ
,
"tJ :2
~~'1
~ ~
nr.lSi~
2l~"l~
~ L' l:'" ~
C ;"
La '0
U~,
'"'
ri
~
t~ )0
j
o
z
~~
-~
~', ;<
;Tcli'il
-~
C
;r-:i:'
m 0
~ ::0:;
~ ~ ~ g
:s 0 Z
,n ~ - z
:r ::: ~ ~: ~
~ ~ ~
:>:1";:1 :r-.I-l
t., 31 ~ :g g
~ ~~:: ~ '0
0.., ('J Cii ~ 0
:r-l:"'>-:I'tI:.G!-!
~(n~~~
~ I-< >oj
(J, 'Oil Z>, if..!<!:
<: t" n Ii r:::I'"
H Z ~
G 0 <: t"
:S2:r.~
lHn ~
:"'>< l/;
ow
C'l-i
~
.... :;;: ,~
HW
. Ii (~
1< ~
'tl [T;
,.
"II d
l:'" ~
,;
r.5
~~
r
c
c
"
~
H
~ 2 g ~
:t ",. '" 0 -
ta~~~o~
Pil;:;en '--'
<: tI:l :t>'
:I: ~=[ Gl ,<
;;: H
(rj ~ :::: a
:::: Pl"
Zmtll
>' t- H
'tltrlZ
~' ~ ~ "
(/JZtr')
o ~
).''>i! ,.,
~ ~
OH
:.ri1
~; [J;f
~H
~
<: 0
,
H ~
8--)0 il
~:' 'tl (!l
~I_ t"' (L
~
r" tIl (l..
~ ~
('T "1 "
r t" ([1
rr:n
:r; ~
') tll
:::0
:;::;H
~~
K~
o
~..;
H ~
5~
~~~
U])o ..-e
~
l:"'tI;G')3:
~ >' ~
"
:J:-
~
r
r,:
"'
"'1
C
~
~
,
r
,
l3
C
ru
~
"
Co
c
W
"
w
w
o
~
~
. ,
Ul "" a
0_ ..... ,_
o
o
0"'.... ..,J
o a U\ \( <:>
;:~ ~ :;; ~
;t;: tr.I C E-<
~~?
'it! r:r'
H
~&;
C:t" ::;
(f] l..:
I-<~::;:
Z;:tl);
:) <: .-J
H
'/:' n Q
--Jt':I;r;
~~to1L'
~~~~:~~
X tIJ::o 7, t:o:l
"Il rrJ L( ta
<: t":O<>o:I
or', t"'
X
~
E
"
"
o
~
~
< ~
=~
rr:t2J
c ~
C";
m
;.l:1f)
" 0
Z
.,
r
~
u
w
('>
,
~
WenUt
~ , ~
00 C Ut
~
~
~
~
r./:o
W,
~.
W
~ '
~ ~~
W 0
Og::'"3
'>;l (~ "l
(c}L'
" 0
Z ~
"J~~
~ ~
~Q
~~
CH
rz
m~
W
~~
to:! ::- H
~ ~
~
~
~
C"
g ~: ;:
~g~
H ~ H
i,i, < <...,
t2J P_'t>l
~ ?:' 0
ta U,
H
~
~
t-.,
~
o
~
~
~
o
~
~
W D
ro a
~ "
.-J~
~n
~~
H
n
~
~
~ ~
~
0.
r ,
"0.
T
CO'
'"
.
~
~
,
"
~
"
..
"
~
~
"
"'
...
...
,
o
ro
~
~
o
o
~
:Ii
r, ~
o ,
9'0
'0 ~
, ,
o "
'"
a
o
0.
,
...
o
o
o
"
-<-.
~ 0 ~
~~~
'C ~ ~
0"
~ 'C
~
~
~
~
~ "
~ ..
w ~
~ ~
~ ..
~
w ~
..
..
"
0.
~
,
"
~
"
a
,
,
'C C e
. " ~
"' ,
m " ~
w
~
C
o
~
~ 0
r ~
r
~ w
~ w
" W
Z N
~ ,
0)';\
00 a
0)':;,
\.fl'J1
~ 0
-.l <-.l
0\0\'"
I;D ~~', m
O>G>Ch
............
W a ~
~
a ~
WOO
m ~
" ~
m ~
-.: -..\ ~
0,0)0
rn 00 a
C',O\O-,
""......
~W
~~~
0)':1,0)
woW
O>CI\O'I
.... ~. ....
foo' C. \0
-...1 ~. -l
0\ J",O\
'>'OO:T:'(D
[J\O'\ J\O)
I..-.\.>><J.J....
c",...C-,,,"
-.l --.;-l
C-.O):J',O)
LUQ;lO)(J:I
o ",-::rIal
'^'....v..'l,OJ
,t, ... ,~ I-'
~ ~
" ~
moo
m~
w~
OW
~
.,
-:L-a>
m~
k' N
a~
- ~
(""..
CC_'al
O,er.
k' N
C',111
, ~
a ~
" 00
,:1',0>
:-..' N
. W
~ ~
(]",,,, :r,O)
OJlXlCDCXI
(J, a, .:J, 0'1
t.c' I>J ~, ....
h.ll-' c.-'\O
~ ~ :J::,
0:-'00 ;:<,
ChOl :1,
~
"', -.l ~,
~ ~
~m~
a>OllXl
~m~
I-' <-, ....
~"W
..-! ...:J'~~...l
:1\0\ l>'~:
OJCDCOOi)
CJ\O>O-,O)
................0
,,:' l-' ~, \D
,',J::
I
l ili
II
"_.~---~_.,---_._--~-_._._--- ._._-~._._~-~
~~~~;w~~~~ffi~~~g~~w~~g~~~ffi~~~g~~~ffi~ffi5g~g~~~gG I
o O_~~Q~OOOOO~OOOOOOOOOOCOOOQOODCCOOCCOOC~O~ I
NNW~I>J W~N~~NWNN~WN~~NNW~NNW'JI>J~WNI>JNW WkWNNNW
QOO~OOOCOCOCOOOCO o~ooo~ooocooooooooooooooo
0000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000
1-'>-'....-.... I-'>-'....-....-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~ ~-~ ~~~ ~-~
~~~~~rn~~~~~~~~~\r~'n~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~m~~~~~~Lnm
www~www~w wwwww'~wwwwW~WWWWW~WWW www wwW~WwW
~ ~~~~~~~~~;~~~6~~~~:~~~:~:~:~~~:~:~:~:~~~~
1~~~~~~w~~o~ro~~~AWI~~o~~~rn~Aw~~o~~~rn~AWN~O~~~
I~..;""~""'~_I-'_~_I-'>-'I-'_~-_I-"~I-' "'-~I-'_l-'-=--;';:_I-'_I-' ~ I-' ~_I-'_I-'_I-'f-'
I~~~~t~t~~~e~~~~~~~~-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
"-",-,,,-,,'-'-'-'-'-'---'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'-'
INI'NNNNN~N~N~N~~~N~N~N~~NNNNNNNWNNNN~NNNNNNW~
'0 ODOCQDOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCOOOOOOOCOOOOOCOOOOOC
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~4~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~
"
o
~
o
c
~
~"
~ 0,
m
~
~ :~
m
<: I':
~
=
>
.
"
t'I ""
00
~ ~
"
~~
> ~
~~
~
r::"'3
"
tr
71
'i1
;J
'0
o ~
<&>.cr....
w "'""
00 ~ 010 1 ....
W " ~ ,_ N
~ ~
m " w
~
~
l}': 0:: '"
o m
.
o
" ~
'-(.Xl
(~tf; ;;:.::
x><: 'tI;'
~ ~ ~ i; <
M;YJ(f.I
r- a (f, ~ [--< ~
t'o t"ij
"lJ::-- r-:
"
~ "
to; I." 0
"
>
8
~~
"
r
rr,'>,j
V;I-j
'T" ::;
r~
m
~
"'
.
~
~
00
"
o
;;
$ ~ s:~
,.,.. -=;1
~ "
~ ~
~
tI'l to;:;"
g; ~ ~ ~:
o~~~~~~u:
'1:' fill -; 0 .."
>- tlI H ~ ::--
2':, ~ iT) 'tI
t"'T]>
~~~
:;g; ClJ
;:O:Ul
8:=
~
~
r
~
~
r
"'
N
~
~
o
~
~
o
o
,-'0-0
tIed
"-0.
" ~
H
~
.. H
c.'-i
~
~
o
~
H -
lj :',
~ .-
~ ih
~ ~
"'
~
~
~
~
~
~
"
N
~
~
o
o
'F, e
~
~
~
~
~
w
o
~
w
~
~
~
~
~
W
.., ;: Q tI1
~ e; F ~
tf.l d t'"
8 tJ ," c:
~
ro:I ~
::2t""'~
~ ~
~
r
Q
~
~
~ " H
"' m
~
o
c
m
>
. ~ 0
- t"' :" :t:
H :;, H
0:" c
tlJ It'
2j
c"
H 0
(') :r'pj
~ .
~
"o::Il-r::>:l
~ ~
~~g
~ "
fIl~~
~ ..
r< ~ ~
~
H
_ 0
~
" "
a
"
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
j,
C'
l11 L~ W
(0". ....,,""
o c:: 0 L' ...:
o
o
r,:' ~
~
o
o ~ ~
c _ W .J:: ....
.
.. ~
~~
~~
..,
o
o
>z
~
~~
(iJt"
~=
r~
.
"
M
"'
~
~
:;'l :r"
(3 ;::
:: ~ ~ 15 ~
o m
,
._Il' "
to ::;;.
Q :, E
" ~-- ;;:,
:r-; ~
'T; :::: c: ~_
c m
.. "
""t"l j-:
if ~
.
- ~ ?
o
~
.. m
"
z
> "
~ ~ g'
;; r S ;:-
z ~
::"I !>J :;:-
'r' M t:I:~,..
" t"'. r:" tf.l;~
::; ~,. t"' _. ~ "
r.:., tI) crt"
o % ~ ".
C~8 Ul
iil.:r.I-j~,",
~ rr: M r.~ X
~ ~
2 S
H "
~
~
" '
~
~
Ul 'l;j:;: ~ t:ll
:r: ~ T' gl a
~ _:>:: t" - "-1 J'
- H ,-, ~ [Il
C 2: ...
=: I-!
>tl ~ ~ ~
~ @~~
m>::t:l 0
~ ~
fr tIl ~:
~ .. ~
.::I:C:;;"
~ ~ t e . &;
~ 3 "~ g
::: 11 :-: Z r-
;;::: " ;; '.
if l3 ::z:~. 'd
~ _~'S;;
ro 11 (f.I
IJ;tIl "1
~"'
X'i
C'tl
~
~ .
':;'\Il ;..,
~ ,..
~
IlCl ~
~
~
WI.O
~ -
..
W
~
t'" :'"
~ ;
f! :r;
" m
"' c
"
_ 1'l;l iJ)
" ~
~
()
,..
(I.
"
~
::::
~
~
'"
~
~
~
~, ~
~ '.,
. "
"
~ F
>-r: ~ :s
r-<r.:
c,
'0
~
~
0,
Ii:
I
~ "
. ,
" ,
~;o;-
, ~
, ro
~"
.
"
n Z
o ,
, ~
~ ~
, m
, w
"
n
o
~
ro
~~::'2
'0....,;;
0>
w.
~
-
~
~
~ "
~ e
w ",
~ "
::: ~
w ~
~
e,
"
~
rn
.
;;.
. ~ H
~ tIl 1-'
~ ,
ro " H
"
N
C
C
~
o
~ cc
< ~
~ H
~ ~
~ ~ ~
0> C;, 0\ m Cl
(Xl co m co
"':;0, O'l m 0\
\(I \(lCD'Ll
l,n "- ..... t.~, f...<
,--
,
~
~
w
~
w ~
-..lO::<Jc
~ 0
~
~
o
o
o " ~
o ~
~~~
ffi ~; g
g ~
'"
0-0
~ C
~ 00
~ '"
n ,~ H
'" '"
H n
t:J if"
~ 0
8 ' 1:
&:
~ m
"
H
~
:c; fii ~ ~
~t-; ~
~ "~
~: tt1 rr: t'l
~. fS r: ;;;
::r; d ....j t"'
.',:>:l J::1t1il
o S
~~ ~
v'!;i ~ t:l
::Hil;:
'r'lfJ'C!
~
i;fIl
~;;
t ~ _
~
~
:P
"'
,
.
~
~
~
~~
C'
- ~
O~
creeP
~, O'l
" m
w
-.,J ....J ..:J ~.I...l -..l _J --.J -.J ...,
." 01 ~\ '" G, 0\ (1', O'l <:" 0\ 0-, '"
mOO~;OOOJ""CIlmO:'(I:>mm
0', '" ;T1 0\ ,,",0\ U, 0\ m 0\ 0' 0.
CO .X 00 CO men cg 0-''''' ~-.,J
-.I 7' l,n ..:c. ..., ,.,.... C I.Cl w -.l
--.i...l ....:I
0,0\0",0\
woomoo
(1', C'l m '"
~ ~
~ W
~
~
o
.
~
~
w
~
~
~
~
.
w"
we
.
01..... <.T:c..~
o. VI ~ ..., ~..... N
o ~..... ~ ~
Or \ <r. - a>. a: \oJ
o t 0 010 \L
~
.
"
~ ~ S
>-llr:iii
:>:lIT;;::
:l~ 0 :::!
~ "t.5
~ ~ ><:1 tI)
;r!:j :"'''-;
i: n :u ~
~, T1 f'il
~
"~
-, 00
00
o
n
H
>
~
H
o
~
~
H
00
00
H
~
'"
'"
~~
~~
~t"'
'"
>r.t>]
~
~
~
J
o u
CO L.'I lf1
~~
'::: 5
~
[1' 8
~
-~
:";H
: e
~::: b
-'I
-'"
::t'il
,~ B
~
00
- ,.
- ~
c ~ "
i l>'J
~~t
- 0
'"
[I] ~
~ Vl ~ ai
~~~
~~t;
,,~
~
=
..,..~:::>;
:t't"'lT:ttl
::: o,:,!Z
,:tl - ~
H
~~ ~
::~ ()
,- ~ e
or'::' 0
::O-<t"'
;:r, ih ,~. g r:
n L :::' H tr::
~g12~*&i~
;:1J ~ :l"::r- ~ ~ It'
:se:::;:::2H~D;I
[fj""~r,~r~
(f) 0 Ill:r: L >-l
IlI;I t"' n
I!!l~>::~
~ OJ'tI .17 11
:r- '--'I:"' "J
t"' t<::Il'tIl
~ tr.l l'l >-l
l~ U";
~ ~
~ "'"
00 -e
~ - '"
~ '"
'" 00
'"
~
"
'"
k 0
~
ttl -I
;2:>:l ~
"~
~
CD H
~Q
H'"
2 e
t;;
-,
~~
(10 c:r
() 0
~o
..
~ <
~ 0
;J..""
(l Po
0..
0.
c'
~ .
o ~
'T rt
" .
"
'0
~ '"
~ "
t"'", ,...
o "
" ~
~ ~
00
~
~
:n "Ill
'D'd;t>
~S~~
C;
~~;::J~
-< '>;l ;CO
P b ~l ~
c~;r:<1'l
H '"
'r't:l 00
:.'" >'
~
~
~
"
~
"
~~
010\
~~
(j\0\
~
~
~
IT ~
IT'm
m~
,~
c>""
", w
w
o
-..J-..l -J
(]',(tl en
O'Joo::n
0"''''
0\0\"',
""..,)0",
-.l ~'--.l ...] -.l -c ...J
0\ 0 0\ 7\ 0\ 0-, a, .0', a,
c:c CJ, O'J 'l) m r::J, CD ':II 0:>
0\ m 0\ :n 0\ f)-, 0\ G",O'I
0\ 0, 01 .;:rl 0\ ~\ o.n en 1)1
o.n ~ w ~ ~ "" ~- -.l
~ ~
~ IT ~
en '.!c, a,
~
~
00
, ,
~'-~ ~ ~ ~ : ~ ~-* ~ ~ ~ ~.,-~ ~ ~ f~ * ~- ~ ~ ~ ~: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ :' * ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~- ~ ~ ~ I-~I j
~ ~~~ ~~~-~~~~~~~~~~~-~~~-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ .
o.n~o.n~o.n~o.n~o.nro.n~o.n~o.n~o.nrno.nmo.nrno.nwo.n~o.n~o.n~o.nrno.nrno.nrno.nrno.n~o.n~o.n~ ,
W~WWWwWWWWWWWWWWWwWwWWW wwwwwwwww~WWWWWww~WW I
-.l-J-.l-J~-J-.l-J--.l-J-.l-J-.l-J"']-J-.l-J-.l-J-.l-J-.l-J-.l-J-.l-J-.l-J-.l-J-.l-J--.l-J--.l~--.l-J-.l-J-.l-J I
O\:J.O\mo.no.no.n~o.n~lo.n~o.nrn.~.A~~~~~~wwwwWWWWWW~N~~WW~NW~
---; ;; ~; : ;- ;-g'~; ; ;- ~-~-; ~ .g; ~-~~~~-~; ~; : ~ ;; ~; ~; ~; ;. ~-2-~ ;'; ;'I'~,-!!!,'.,'
-'--"",',','"",,-----------------,------
o=ooooooooooocooooooooocooooooooooooo~oooooo
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
'~'~'-".,~,~"'-"""'-"'-""'-,-,-"-,--
~!~W~~~WWW~WW~~IWN~W~N~NWNWWWN~~WI~~WW~)W~WN~NWN
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000 00
ooooooooooooooooooooooocooooooooooooooooo_oo
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~
G-::::; d c-~-::: Q c-c;-:::- d C oc:-Ci'C: a:::: c==~-=-~-=--C' ~,',.'c:- -= Q .'c Q '::: d .-e: c:: ::::: Q '-< c:: C; -'c:l~'-~I
'w~m~mww~m~wwwum~moom~m ~m~mL.m~mwmrnmoomzmocm~,'mu. ,.
t:I :J 0 e 0 '.:J 0 '::1 t:I ':J t:I C t;;l CO 0 t:I :} t::I t:1 t:I C t:I C t:l C t:I :::: t:I 0 t:I 0 t:l :J t:I ::J t:I tJ 0.' t:l "
I
;, ~
00" Pi,
g;rJ !
o ::-' 01 ,~ 0 I," 0 k' W
0:::' 0.;" 0 ')'10 C', U1
",;tt:
=: ~
.; ':-:>:1
o ~: >-
"-00
">;1-1
::::>:
:-; 0
;,::::
, 0
~ .
::-"",
~ H ,-
n
"
~
Ptr.!
o
~
~ ~
.:J:;l-<
:-rJ 0
"' Z
m
0.
.
0.
~tr
, ~
:;::0
~
'-'00
'"
H
H~
~
o
~
~
~
~~
~~
no
::lJH
wn
,.
~~
~
'"
o
~
H
~
~
;;,;>'
c'S
"
~
~:
- Q
:;;; ~
!:; ~
~ :3
z
f.i J
~
~
H ~
HH
~,
o
~, m
"
"-'....
00
co
~ ~
[1" Z
,.
H~
" H
l': C
z
-'1 >-
~
~
~
() 0'j"CI
tz;r:=t"
~ a ~ ~
Ir'>;l ::lJ;t
H ~
t>;I ,. tIl
o e
Ul :;j ~
~
.-11-1 Z 0
K Z u'J ==
" ~
"00 '"
:::.' t"'
:::H 0
~~0::1
"01;1;I
>!I;I :-=; ~ [f:. ~
t"'Gt/J ..
em
H -:: llII :r:
Z I'J t"'
n~'"
C-'t:l:l'r,
Z '" ::0 l-
~::~z
'1:l p ~ '<,
t"' --0 ~
~~~~
!JJ 0-)
~
" c
i;...,
Xt'l
0'
,:.r,
o
~ -
!'~
~~
~~
~~
00
e
c ~
~
~ 0
o
u, 0
>
"':,tJl
t'J1:l;l
..""
" <
H
~fJ
~) tI;l
~
"Z
::r.>
'"
"' ~
c~
00
w
w
- ~
~
w
~
- ~
c
c
c V1
... ,,_ t1l
C'. W 0', U1 \,( V1
V1 _ W "", 0\
C<t"'
C, H
~: 10
Z ~
H
r..t:I
>
~.:.' ~
~ a
H
z~
'-ltll
~
~~
~n
O~
~
cO
~~
~
H
o
~
H
~
~
H
Z
Q
00
~
o 0 (r', t.t>
o _ 0 "-' W
~ t:l :s:
j:H
- t-o;:':,
_ tIl U,
~
ot0
-'"
.~ C
~~
Co
v:. ~
['J"
00
~R
CO
CC"
~H
~
H"
f=;Ul
00
~~
~<
WH
"' n
'" 0
).j'"r:tIl ;!;;
Z
n
z>
~OO
~~
cO
r:r:O
Vir-!
,.
~~
t"'t:l:l
00
~
~O
:'-:>>;l
o C' M
<Ctll
H,"~
fI:l:::;t:l:l
o '"
O~O
~
~
'-'/~i;~~~, iljl~li;r;~
(J) 0\ iIT'\"~Y 0.,.11" .., '-{\I
~~;:~OJ::t/ Q~
6; ~ f, ~ 2;: 1 c/
I
I
I
1,-'
U
tt
~
tt
'"
~
z_
Pl'T5
?22 ,~
~~,
~ ~
"
r;: :;j
o _
'T',:t>'
"H 5;
*~;s
t' m
):>0 (Fj
00
:r> 1"3 'r,
'" ~
o
~~
'"
'" =
H
~
~
'I
...
I!'
i!ll
. ~I
'"
'0
.-(:
"
()::: tr:
o " 0
. '" .
'" ~ "
Il' III 0
, ro
~ 0
"
"
o ,
~ 0
, 0
,
~ "
o ~
o
o C
o
~
m _
g-g
';;'1.',;0:-
g ~
g.~
,
"
,.o~
:e~a
o ~
~'"
~
~
~
~
H _
~ ~.
~ ~
00 "
~ "
~
w ~
"
~.
"
0.
m
.
"
~
it.
00
~
C
o
o
"
_ C ~
. ro ~
00 , ,
. " ~
w
,
U
o
o
~
,
~ ~ 0
~ ~
<: ....,
~ w
~ ~
" ""
0-,(',0\
tD(;'tI> '"
" ""
W w W
\OCL-J 0'
" -
~
U> U',
"
W W
~ ."
"
ct,-"
~ "
"
W
W
-.l oJ ",-I
<l'\ O\l"(1\
OJ U; 0;> m...
" " "
.... w'";,,,,
... C \D CJ;. -l
-"
~
(;,m
"
,,'N
CC,U1
,,-'-.I -..l
O,<l'\ ::>"a,
am -:;70 00
"""
.z. ~ ~~ ::::
~ "-' t>.> --:::'~'I::':--~'::;-N~~-;:;~;::"'--;:;--"--;--;:;-k' N ~;;:;~
OOOOOOOOOOOOOCOOOOOOO
0000000000000 oeooooo
OOOOOOOOOOOCOOOOOOOOO
...~...~...~...~...~...~... ...~...~...~...
11I '-~ 11I U' l1I lI", U1 (J' U'I U" U'I 'r Ul l~ Ul '-~ Ul \J1 l1I LD Ul
w~wwwwwwwww~w~w~wwwww
tl>mmoomamOO."l~-J~-J~-l -J -..l~-J
OCOCOGOC\O~\OW~W\D~\D~moou>
u>~O\U".~ND\OCL-J~l1I~Wr~",c~~-l
"
o
~
W
"
mer
W
W
W
~
~
o
o _ ~
~
W
W
we 111
c. "
~ 0
W _ ~
o.CJ: 0
o 0
w
~
o C -J 0 l .."
o 0, >- 0 '"
w
o
m
e
o
~
~ r
tii ",;5 ( g; r- n ~
() ~ .-, f;J ~
~ tJl ;to' v-,
~ "
H.
n
'"
,.
"
~
~
~
'n0
~
::c' _,
o ,~
~ -
~ ,
> \c- g >-
'tl _ Ii
"
"
Ul :;:.
" c
" c
[I;
m
;: '~:
H -
~ :"
" -
"
~
"
t>:l :2'
~ "
<:"2-
I-j ..~ > :II::
~ ~ S ~ ~
" ~
r15
H
~
"
,.
Z
o
~
'"
~~
m
n
~
,.
-
~ ~ ~
m I
~t?
:"l ,-
:r-- 0
"
~
o
"
,.
~
H
o
~~' :;::
.., :-r
:>:l '"-
H
Z'
~ -
"-- H
,0
=~
[.::0-
~
~tr.I
"'~
r~
7:tlil
~:l
7tr.1
:"'tI;l
'" p
C <
CH
1.':' n
"
'c:t/l.
"
~ ~
'1..
" "
~ ,.
~ ::- Z
:t :r> n
_ H
,. m
n
o
Q~
~ l-i
~..,
" r
o
~
a
(j
~
,.
'"
s:
"
n
,.
\';~
"
--':l:l
:r>tJl
..
"
-'"
~
"
c,
-.J :0:'
'"
.
~
m
c,
"
--.; ..,] -.J
G\ '" C'\
00",0::
~~:::
'=-'\0 C.
-J <-l
(l\CC,(h
QlCfJCl)
....J<-.l
HH~
....J 0\,""
,,~
cO
em
cO
H~
:...~ UI
,,-'. W
,"
~ 00
~W
~
~
~
~
~
o
o
j is:"';:; ~ g
i;] ~ f.J ~:t: ~
tJ:; t"' 'J
~ "G ~
~ Pi c >-:l
~ 00 Ol - 0
-< ri C "0
:.' ~ ~;: ~
~ g ~
.-t/l r t"'
"
" H
"
"
.,-; n
~ ~
H
":: ~
" Z
,. ~
,.
li
z
~
:::l.. H
:::j?;"'~
~
..,.
m
~. :r:
~li
~
~;j
Z
- "
n
l~' W
00
cO
cO
"H
",111
,,-,!.oJ
,"
mOl
0~
~
m
w
w
o
o
o
w
~
~ ~
H
~ :>-
~
~D 25
~ c:::
r _
~, ~
<:: H
15
l,J
'J.."'l
~~~
~ -,. ~
Q ~ ~ ~ i L~
;to ~_, >-
.... :'D re: ~-
" w
m
"1l 5:
"
, "
~ "
m ~.
"
1-"'-'
101"-"
~ _.J-.I
m 0',0\
CO C"_'(JJ
" "
H 0
H " ~
W~
00
co
C 0
H~
,,~ UI
w W
,,"
~ 00
1,,'1-'
"', N
::;:. 0
c-<;>
00
,,~
u, t1l
c' ~
~"
"'-'-.I
o~
.." .j... C
,oJ ~
~
~
m
~
m
Z n "
~ C: ;; ~ ~
>' -:z: n
tt ~
"
" ~
"
" 0
~
~
"
" n
g; (I) ~ ~ :"'
:,! n "CI
mo
" ", ~
~ ,
o
,.
~
s:
=~
>' ":;-
::; g; ~:
- ~
",(5
"
~ - ;;
H (1,3:
w ~
)l:I;t>
,.
;;:\:1:1
".
~
,. n m
,,=,::: r;
::> "'l
"
i
"'~
CO
cO
CO
H~
,,~
wW
-"
,"
m"
~
~
~
~
o
, ~
.-] 0
~li
~ ;' ~
, "
m
~ m
,,"
o
~, -.I
.....:-..1 -.I
8m".'"
comma:>
" "
CoO 0
('\lJ\.:......
r..:. N
DO
CO
co-o
H~
1.;,l.1l
C W
""
" ~
D. ~
,,-''''' '" N
0000
oeco
COOO
>---1-'>-1-'
l~ lJl ,n U1
,""'.... L<-' W
.....:-.1 -..l
"" ~
~W ~
- ~
"
~
c
~
m
m
~
~,
o
c.
o
~
- 0
~ 8
~r:e t:I
~ ::<
;~ H
DO
~
,.
;";:: ~
~ t' 3
_"' z
me
H
I'~ Z
n
~
5:;"
~
.." .~~ IJ.
~
m
"
"
~1
~'
, ~
c. m
om
,"
00
c. H
~, ~~;'_:~~~r:t~., :t:~
'CD 0) <Xl m co-:.: 'c
~ : ~ ~ ~-: tl ~i' ~
,:0 "" en -.I m
,w
co
Om
Om
,,~
,,, ~
eW
,"
-~
c.'\J)
"-' W I'~'
coo
000
000
H~
l~'" UI
e W
"
0\0\
~~
f!1
____ .______u .________..._.._.____ -~-..---~_,
I-'~I-'>-I-'>---I-'~~-I-" I-' I-'~I-'..I-'>-I-'-~~~~~~~~~-~~~ ~~~-~~~- I
~~~-~-~~~-~-~ ~-~~~-~~~-~-~-~-~-~-~~~~~-~~'~-
,------------,---,-------------------~,--~,-
O~OCOCO~OCOGOCO~OOooocooooo~ocooococooococoo
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
"-,-,---,-------,--,---,-,----~---~--------
g~g~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~g~~~~~g~g~g~g~~~g~~~~~ ~
~:~o~o~3~3~Q~Q~3~3~3~S~S~S~S~3~:~Q~S~S~S~3~SI .
~::c::d' =-=c::-=c:r= c: c::,.=_=_='::==-=c::=c::-==--c-c:: c::_c:::-c:,=c::::::'--7
~ ~ g; ~ :g gq~ ~ ~ @ ~ ~ ~ @ ~ L'; ~ 8 ~ ~ ~ ~' ~ gqg ~ ~ :g ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ g g; ~ ~ '~ ~ ~ ~ 8 ~ ~ i .'
1
: I
c
~
e
t:I e;, 'TOO.L
~;ST~ ~
~ <:: t; - ~
~ 0 r" g:; :./ ~
" r H
',;' ~ ~]-':j:::::
'tl 1: G ~
~ II 00 ~ ~
;::: Ul ;: ,~. "
.. ~. ~
'-J::; t ~ Cl ~ 2 '_'
~E0 ;,~ ?J,~
~. 1: u:: >< t-J;u
- "U '1.: ~:t u_ >-
t";:: '0 t"
~ ,3 c e
e ,.
'"
~
""tOJ
"
~
~
w
e h'
e - ~
:..
~
.,
,
:r;
~C.
~
m
~
'Ce-
>
~
e
e
o
~
~~, t.n
eW
, "
:;-.01
C;',Ln
~i
~
,
~
, "
"'
g
r
I
~- t!I tv
-h- ~ ~
r;~ "
iJ.'"
"
"
6' ~
, ~
~ ~
" ,
, ,
~
c
o
~
"
,. 0 ~
''''Z
~ "m
0"
~ ~
~
,
~
~
~ ~
~ M'
e ~
00 M
~ ".
w ~
".
e,
"
~
~
,
,
"
,
c
,
,
'tl Ct-
, w "
W ,
rp " l-
e
c
C
c
" ,
c
<: ,..;
g ~-
Z: '"
...:J ,--'...j'
~ ~
ro ro
~ ~
ro ro
~ ~
~
~
~
~
~
~
n
o
~
~
o
~
:>< ;,.
"
'"
G-,O
Z
~~
o
::)"
~8
~~H
o ,.
; ~
~ ,
~
,z
, 0
~
t" ~
"
~
if
~
"
-..l-..!...:J ...:J
c., a. m 0'10\ (J\
OOOQ""C)wc>>
...) ...t-..!...:J
<:L...:J -.3--.J-.3
c' lO ...:J (h Ul
UN
CO
:::- 0
CO
~~
co ~
'" ~
~ ro
~~
~O
" ~
00
00
C, 0
~ ~
if. ~
(,.;.\0,)
~~
~~
~ ~
U~
00
00
00
~
lf~
w~
ro~
...
-":CP\
~
o
W .-, 01>
N
~
~
.. W
OUC""
OCI-'
~
~
o c:' 00
o c ~
~
,=, 0
;t..:E:
Lrt<:l
~
~
S;
Z
~ ~ 8 ~;;
"10 / Z [!] m
~::tl ~ H ..,. t"
H () @
;:: ~ :>>,'-' @ ~
'-':1::
H
Z
" 0
l':t"'
;;J~
C
om
'DC::
,,~
rr-:. H
~~
'"
~'"
X
'GOO
~ l~
" H
>' c.' >-
"'~"
~ ~ ~
"tt :u >-
r'(fJ
~~
c::;.o;r:-
~)
.::J
ti1H~
{))tr.! ';-
~ ~ M
"
c"ttn
>-Jt" ;u
;p :1'
j j
~
~
>
,~
0.,01
m~
~
- ~
" W
" N
00
00
co
~~
if~
ww
WW
~ ..
~ ..
UN
00
00
co
~~
if~
W W
roro
.~
WN
'., N
a 0
~
" W
N
~ ~
~ " ~
w W
.. - ~
'J., Ul <:>
;::~
~;;
~
~
~
"
,~,
p
~
T, a.
row
- ~
~
'" ~
'" N
00
00
00
~~
~~
ww
", ro
~..
~ 0
o
o
~'"
~;t
:: il ;I; H
>.; -J S
" c
;: ~ ~~
r;:: =<
,.
~ t"
:fJ!n
:rJ >-
~~
?Jt'l
n~
~
H
"Z
:<J n
~tj
a ~
" "
:r."
~o
Z H
:::;o'J
:- :r:
;H
~
~ ~
--.J...:J ,--'...:J
G',O\ m.,.,
a;D:1 :;I,C)
W~ ~
-JO'lmO'l
., \0:;1;'-.1
UN
00
00
co
~~
lf~
......w
ro~
w~
~"
~
o
If
~ a 0
O'lkO
f ~ ~
'"
--.J...:J-....'-.I -.J-.j...:J -.,1-....'.,.:
C'\CP\O\CJlO',CJI(l\"""'""O"I'"
<rwcnwW(Do;JooCl:>."moo
-J-.3 ...:J -..l-J-.l--.J-.l--':...:J
()', CJ\ ,-" <11 G\ CJ\ m Ul '-" Ul LJl Ul
a, Ul W,. I-' \O!i; -.J m Ul
UN
00
co
co
~~
"' ~
ww
""
wW
W~
W
if ~-
f-' :r U1 0'
m ~,
~
'"
o
"
:-c::
CO
.<:: ~
om
~~
...~ :tl
00
n~":
o
m
o
o
.
e
o
z
..
,.
WN
00
00
co
~~
w ~
w W
""
w ~
W~
WW
00
co
co
~~
W~
"-' to)
rnro
ww
ww
~
w
~
~ W
-l ,... 7., 0>
U1 C'.... N
CJ:"-l
W
o
o
~') t: u.
:on
~. l'1
~ ~
Z>
~I ~
jO
-0
" ~
.:::"
I'Jt"'
ZO
~~
'" ~
o z =
s: "0
:to' ~
h
~ ;:a
~
'"
~
~
."
,.
~
m
..
~
,,~
co
00
00
-~
~~
w W
m"
'''';-\oJ
~O
~', '"
co
co
00
~~
,~., Ul
'" W
0"
/-..:' I.,J
\C, '"
~
W
c
~
W
rn
(l)." Co ,,", ~ lr
'" ~. 0 .:J.' ~ :;::,
~~
U :tl
r...;tJ')
r:r:.'tl
"'"
::;:: H
~~
o
C' ,.
, ~
'f....t"'
,.
~m
"
::: "'l
e. ~
~
~
r
o
"
'"
W' ~
0000
g~gg
~~~
I..nUllJ1U1
WWWI.ol
COtvCto",
"'-'WNN
...JC7\lf''''
,-'C. ~
W 0'
- f-' -...) 0
~ ,~. <::>
02:..,:
->':>>:r>
><;3~E
fT: H:':: g:;
?Jf;:HgJ
~~' ~ ~ I'l
c
c ~
'fJ
c,g)
J '"
" 0
"::t"<l
c:;::
~
-Hll
-0
0~
Z~
ili
;j
g~
~
t'
'"
~~
..
t'
N N
..
;;;;::
[1Jl;I:l
t~ "0
~~
".Ii
C)t>;l
"
Cl'i
H
o
Z
H
11
~
."
,.
'"
"
~
~
r; == tr
o ~ 0
, ~ .
..., '-'11
ii (fI CL
o "
~ ~
,
o n
0. 0
. C
"
~ "
o '<
o
o n
o
~
W~
0.,0"1
,rID
~
,nUl
~W
,;\':;~;'j=;G: ::~,
_J...J--.JoJ -.l -.J ...J-.J'
0'\ 01 ~ 0\ (J\ 0\ CT.,O\ m <11
en 00 'J 0> 0: Q:I 0.-' tv ;:~, W
oJ...!-J -.J...J-.3 ...:J
LC. t1I ..~'... "" or- .lJ. ...
~',.. I<> '" oJ cr, VI .... (.oJ
:"'W tIl
,r"ll:r1lJ
o 0
.,....;>r
~, I>.>
00
00
00
~~
lflf
WW
0. W
N W
W W
o
..
W
-~
IT. '"
NW
CO
00
00
~
C" ~
wW
""
w' N
C' 0
,~, ~
DO
00
CO
~
,c ~
WW
ow
~~
'~ "
N
CO
00
00
w~
~~
'" W
m"
- ~
~ ~
N
~
~
W
o
w w
0.........
~, ...,
DO
00
00
- ~
CC~
W W
0"
-~
w..
NW
00
00
C' 0
-~
W~
W w
oro
-~
WW
~
~ :
~
'" 0 '.c-' 1.0
_ u "-, <=' ,r, '-" a
:; = ::- c
~
~.~
~ ~
c a
:;1;;:
~
c;, ,...
~O
PZ
~~
" ,.
M
0:::1,...
Z
" 0
~
~
~
~
m
~
;i
'"
Z
. ~
?;:>< --1
;r.;:~
~: ~ "-
me) "
[Dod
If, ;;:>
'--', '1J
~
~o
nO'
Will
o
:.:;l'r
- <
r 0
r<:; ~ ~o
~r, 0.
.
'T'Q,:)
." C
,.
:~ ~
"t'....
co.
~ ~ "";; -
o ."
." '"
~ -,0
H ._ t::I
J:lJ--1C
~~"
r ~
m
~
~1 tr ~
::''< :J
'-0";
2 ttI
.
~
"
.
"
o
~
trr -,
>-, ~ g f:;1
0;; ~Pl
F ~ tr' Z ,:;:: ttI
'-"w:c0-<Pi1
> tIl
OJ~!JJ;S~'"
C;:t1 a: 0
if! (j to 3: >'
o'~ -< ;o;l
.. n
~~~
~,.
~
~:x:
:':::H
Z
"10
~
~
."
~
'"
~
~
"
~
"
"
_.
"
'"
~
~
,
o
m
,
~
o
o
~
" ~
~~
~
w
~
x
"
~oo
t;J!:l
~ <
H
.';0
~l'l
2:trJ
~t"
C ~
sO!
.~H
:::::)>'
~~
j~
ZH
"~
~;j
~
~Ii
:;~
~: ~ ~ 5:
'"
H'"r;'ttI
1j"g;
oo fa
~
,.
,. ~
-, H
:::tIl
'=' ~
lr:
J: It'
coo
""::>; -.
,~ >< H
g t:
oo
::>'ttl
~
;;;
Fe
'"
1'!<
o
~. '"
:::::0
~ ~o
(,'
;;
~H
o
z>
~~
~H
co
nz
woo
~o>
~,.
,.
s:
s:
W
trJ ...:;
'"
'" "
~
~ ~
'" ~
V)
~
co>
() ~
"0
- ~
8
;;;~
",
C'
..
~
~,~/~:iI:i
CD~W..,-
oJ ...Jr--'
,!.... ....
"-'''' 0
"-'lo.l "-'
OQO
COC.
coe
.... ~......
~ww
www
m ~ m
~l-'D
~O~
~
~;o;l
H
","
~>::-
;jt"'
~'"
~~
to:; to
~H
"z
~
> 0 "
,~ Z
~ W ~
o ~
~ .
W
~
~
~
~
W
m
w
~
w
"
e
~
r
~
~
r'
"
0.
.
,
"
~
c
lo'O:'
~ W
W
c
c.
>
"
~
-
"
r
,
e'
~ C ~
, , ~
'" . ,
, " ~
W
,
w
o
o
~
II'
, 0
'" ~
:;; w
H W
w
N
...,l ...,l-.Jo..l -.J -.J -.J .,J
0\ 0\ 0\ 0, 0\ ", 0\ 0\ (J '" (f, 0\
(tI :<; o:l U" (Xl cr.' CD ~ CO u' o:l '-' o:l
CO (I:' 0> O"J 0> aJ o:l IT Q) CD OJ Cl.' OJ
N k '" tv~. to.:! t,', I-' I-' I-'
.,J C. l1\ W I-' ID Of' -.J VI
~
- ~
~~
a, ~
~
.~
-.J -.J -.J -.J -.J ~
T,O\ 0\ (), 0\ 0'\ J,
';IJ OJ a (tI G' OJ (Xl a
(J, Q) (ll m c::' OJ m Q) cr
!-' <:> 0000
1-"::;'\0 m...,]" VI.l_
-.J ~' ...,]
0\(; 0'\
(l>cr.'<;D
~w~
C 0
WI. l-'
.,J _1-.1 -.J -.J
(J,Q'\(J'O>L"O'\0',O'\
rrmC!'oo ala:>(I:l
CO"'" -,I-.J .,J -.J
;~~~,,\~;,~
-..! -.J ~
~
.(J (D cr
~~
,-,,\0\1
C'~
; ~' ;;;:~ '.'~' :~-:~~
00 cr, CO 0-' (l) <;1l-,~
-.I ~'-.J -.J...j- =:-
o:l CJ:' OJ m o:l aJ
10 u ...,l 0, VT .j..>
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~*h~~~~~~~~~~;I'
!-' I-'~!-' l-'~I-'~I-'~I-'~I-'~I-'~I-'~I-'~!-'~I-'~I-'~I-' I-' I-'~I-'~l-'~I-'~!-'~I-'~! -
VT~~~~~lJllfl1\~VT~l1l~l1l~lJl~l1\~l1\~l1\~Vl~V1lflJlifV1rnV1~V1rnVl~l1\~VTml1\mi
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~! .
\O~~~IO~ID~mcr.=OOo:lCO<;D~mm-.J~-.J~-.J-.Jo..l_-.l~O\ffi~~O\mO\O\O\rnl1\~l1\~V1~ .
_~. : ~~_~~.~ : : : ~ : ~_~ : ~ : : : ~ : ~ : : : : : \r: : ~ : ~ : : : ~ : -.J : ~' : ~ ~ ~I
I-'~I-'~!-'~I-'~I-' l-'~I-'~I-'~I-'-I-'~I-'-I-'-!-'~!-'~I-'~I-'~I-"-I-'~I-' I-'~!-'~!-'- I
ci?ci~~;6;6;ci?ci?ci?ci?6?~?~?~?ci?~?6?~~ci?ci?6?ci?ci?1
-..l -----' -..l -.J -.J -J -..l -.J -.J --,I -.J -.J -..l _~ -.J ,..; -l -.J -.J ...; -.J -J -.J -.J -.J -..J -.J ---.; -.J -..0 -.J --' -..l ~ ...,l -J -..l -.J -.J ~, -.J ..,; -.J -..l I
_""_""_,_-,_,_",___",_,_,,,_____,,,,___ I
~r~~~~~~~~~g~g~g~g~g~~~g~~~~~g~g~g~g~~~g~=~~~ 1
OCOOOOO~OOOCOcoco~OcOCOOOCOCOCOOOCOCOCOCOCOo
-l ...,] -l '-.'::'._': -.J ....;---=:..~_:::'.--=:..~::..::__':~==----=:.~.:::..:::.,::_.::...J..;: :::_--=:...~.:::'~.::_~ -.; ...,]---===------1
==C_C_C_ C~C=_d_==d_aCd~dCdcc-c=c=a=CCd=C=dC!I'
~~~~~8~8 8~~~~~~~~~8~~~g~~~b~~~~~b~8~~~B~~~~1 :
_~__n i-I
!
a,
o
o
~
~
~
o " lJ1
C C
~
~
"
8 -: t;.;
~ ;. g
.
.
: ~ ~ [< ~
tl ~~ 0
~
H
r<:::;'
0'" '1:l
H'C I-"
~ .
on III
~ "
n
Or
~
~
:<
>
"
~
:1
>
o
>
~
N
~
~
o
~
~
~
"" 0>--=
. - ~
n~
n "
? ;:l
"
~
,. ~
;or: <
'l' 0
~ ~
0.
~ :;; ~
rn
t~ ~
~o~:t
~ "
"
[>',p:
IL t'
"
"
r~
~
l':......
" 0
C.'Ul
~e
t:-J~
~
~J
~
~
<'J
~~~::~'!";;;~
H ;:r::: ~
Z 'I; It' CG
Pl g: ~ 'd
H "
:t> '" 0 0;;:
~[>~a-~o>j
~ H [tj 0
n 7:1 _. Z
~ H ~
t"~r) 0
:J;Jt'
"
_ H
2~
~
N
~
o
o
<
o
e.
0.
.
0.
.
~
~
.
"
"
"
~
o
"
e-
o
~
~ "
On"
? r'Il i'~ r.o;
f i:4 '"l
C r
~ 0
" "
H H
n 0
_ tIl _;to ":'
:; tIl ;r; ~
,:';J>< t"
l'j:o;j l'__....
C CJ ~r,
" rn
~ "
~ 0
~ - ~
1; ;: ~ ;S
~
~ ~
t'l>>'
" ~
r
~ "
~ ~
,'J:.2:
~
:::'1:1
;:;~
["]C/)
", ~
~
~
n r
".
.
n
'"
~
~
,
o
~
,
N
o
o
~
~
o
c
~
'"
~
w
c
o
o
o
~ ~
.... :J: LI\
," '", C
~
o
~
o n
~
"
~
~
n
~ 0 :c
o. M _
n
~~:r- ..", ~r
'U i
r
t"1'"
~ ,
::rl ~
(Jj )> :J~
r
r
~
r
~
"
H
r
to< ;:;:
~ -
r ~
w
.
~
.
~
:r- "" ".
~ ~ ~
I-j;:o:1Ul
~
~
m
". '-'
N r:
LC'
~ Z
tr: ".
- ~
< r
m
t tI:l
2 ~
r
"
,
~
o
o
o
~
~
o
~l' g! ~
lJl ',--r<
> lfI' Y. r<
" m
~ 10 >(
, H
~
n
G;J~
r _
r~
~
~
~ 0
)-.3
"
o
.
.
0, ~
C n ~
"
~ ~
H .:: tl
~ S -; ~
f; '.1 a u; s:
lr.I~~~W
H H"=''"'l
~ _ &l ~ M
:..n
~ j; ~ ~
" r
~ 5
Ii ~
rO
~
~
tIl H lfI'
~ ~ - ffi :; t;
::- ~ ~ ~ ".
0< r: ::d i1-~ ':l
t'l ~r :) 11:'> ::- '"
~ ~ tl n 0 7
:~ ~ i ~ ~ ~
o _. M ~ H
C 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ x
~'~~tr)~ ~'CN::J
~ g ~ M ~ M ~ r
~~;j ~~s:: ~Z
Q~@ ~[i~ E~
III ~ ~ .., Q
C--~ M :t"
~ ~ ~
: i ~
~ i ~
~
~
~
~
>; b
"
- H
- "
~
"
o
~,- ()
"
~
~
-
~
00
.
~
~
~
~
o
~
~
o
H v:
~
n o-r:
'"
~
'"
,-<
'"
~
'"
,-<
;: ~ ;:
W ~
'" '.
~
o
~
- ~
~
~
o
~
~
~
~
. "
. ,.
~7"~
" H
" ~
c
~ ~
...
t< v:
M ~
p
,.
~
~
o
n
H
Lr;>'
~
~i(
iT: ~
':F.
~
r
rr:
'" ~
t"' :~
c
~
r
~
W _
W
.
~
z.:! '7
~ :;;
~
~
.
6
"
-
; B!
~ '"
~
a
~
/IJIIr,'
~')
I
'" ~ .
'(1) 0', ill
'0 ::l ::l
-'rt ~;o;-
" ~
~~
o
"
() ~
, .
, "
" ~
. 0
~ III
"
C
~
.
,
,
~
"
~~~
~ ~ .
o~
~ '"
~
~
~
~
~
~
.
~
~
~
-
e.
~
"
~
"
".
e-
"
~
.
.
,
~
,
C
e
,
,
g
" 0 ~
. 00 ~
00 , _
, " ~
w
N
o
o
~
~
t.j ""
<: t-J
H W
Z
~ ~
...:t ~....J....:I
'" m Q'\ {J\ '"
IXJ ::I-' (:l en IXJ
IXJWOl'COIXJ
~ -J '" C', '"
I--'o:'IDW....:I
-J .... ~I ....:I ....J -.l ~. ..J -J
C'\ C\ cr. 0\ C"\ '" m Q'\ 0',
m (J) 0' (l:I CO (rj ~'O> m
~, IXJ ~ CD 00 CD ~ W CO
0) '" C', '" G\ '" a \1l (Jl
0-, I}l .c. .... !,'.... o'-C 0')
~ -'
m 0'
~oo
~ 00,
~w
~ cr,
...:t -J-.l""';-.l-J-.l
'" m '" {h cr.. m '"
(I:IW(gW(OCD(ll'
00 aJ m '.I> (1;1 W C)
lJl lJ1 lJl ,~ U'I (Jl oJ>
lJl ,:,..., '.''''' 0 \Q
-.J ...:I -J -.l -.l
cr', '" G\ '" cr, '"
CIll>>OOl>>O<'CD
CD (XI [];l lD m!XI
.L.....,j......I>..
ro--JO-,!Jl,j......
-.l _I -.l
0-',"'0\'"
(D(DmlX>
mmCIlCD
.1>.........
,,'.... C'ID
-J-.l
mm
ro~
W~
"W
OO~
-.l ~ -'-~~~~;:;jis'rll;-
g; g: ~ g: ~ ~ ~\:"~'~1i r-
iA 00 CIllX> m (1:1 00(1:1 CDrr.l
(,.' W w '" '" W N "-' '
cr., IJ< .... ..... "-' ..... 0.., en
~~W"-'WN~NN"-'~~~"-'N"-'~WWN~"-'UWN"-'NWN"-'~NWWN~INNNWNNW"-'I
gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg!
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO; I
.....~....~.........~.................................. ....~~...........................................................................................................~,
lJl(JllJllJ1lJllJ1lJllJ1lJllJ1lJllJ1lJllJ1lJllJ1l}l~lJl(JllJl(JllJllJ1lJllJ1lJllJ1I}l~IJllJ1lJl(JllJlLnlJllJ1lJllJ1lJllJ1lJllJ1i
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ I
,.J:,...w....w.....WWW.....WWNNNNNNNNN............................................OOODOOOOOOID~1
~~_~_'::: m -.J '" \/1.... wt.l.... Q ",o:.-J'" [}lIP ~'.... DID W-.l~::...::.::::...~~._~~~~_~.....I"..._-=-~_.._
I~.......~..... ... ....~...~... ..... ...~..........~...........~.....~.....~....~...~..................~................~I.
...~..........~...~..........~...~...........~...~..........~...~...........~...~...~.....~.....~...~...~....~I I
""",-",-""""""""""""""",,1 I
OOOCQOOCOOOOOoocooooooaaoooaoooOOOOoooocooool
I~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I
~NNNWNWNWNWNNNW"-'WNWNWNNNW"-'WNW"-'W"-'WNWNWNWNWNWNI
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
,00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
f ~ ~ ~.~ ~ >~u~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~.~ :~ ~ ~ ~..~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .~.~ ~ ~.~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ..
1~~~~~@~~~~~@~5~~~~~~~~~8~5~b~~g~~8~8~~~~~~~@! '
L----.._____.._ .. ..~______..____.._" __~_~__~.._.:__
!
~
~ "-.. ....
~
C
~
~
o
.....J- W W Co-',l> J. "-
tv " (Jl -.J ..J -.J ,n -.J :\, W
(Jl ~, tv .J- ::::> ~. W (Jl
::::> Wcoc~'::'ro
o -, 0 (Jl ~ (Jl W
'"
[f> ~
. _ H
'tI :;: ~
"':;:0
g ~ ~
;;:&;~
tTJ :.-
~
'::' r:l ... ~
~:: 9 t gj A' !: ~:
2 ~ u' 0 ~
.. ~
~ 0
.::r -r; i=:: ~ c::
;::~;;1c~
Q ~ H
> tIl n
o~~ ~Ul
~~~f.:
;3[: ;l>t-j
V, Ul ~'El
~
~
~
n
n
o
iil
o
=
H
~
C It>
'"
~~
~'"
r-0t"
~
zo
~'"
"
~'"
m~
w'"
'"
-~
Cfj;
'"
o
'"
~
o
'"
~
~
~I'<
H
~=
en
'"
~~
~~
gj~
In >'
~~g)
'"
fj;
l;!
11
'"
'"
~
~
~
~
'"
'"
H
=
'"
~
~
~
:l
o
o
~
~
o
'"
H
;'c t:l -,
~
'"
-iil
Z~
(JH
"
P:>l
'"'"
;;5:
~ ~
~ H
~o
m=
"'~
~~
~~
~
o
"
'"
o
'"
~
11
'"
'"
'"
'"
~
H
.... C >- '"
VI ::::> ~J
'" O~'......
0, -.J <:;) :: .
~ a ~.::.:
~ (Jl If' 0
oco::,,,,.owcocw
~ ~ 0 =::::> m~, 0 C (Jl
~. '"
~ 0
.
i:tn
'"
'"
.~
""
:-:>:;
rr' ~
:::'t'l
-~
"j{>:
>...
'"
"
T ::e
~~
~;!
~
:;!t1
~ <
:- H
crl n
L~ l'l
'"
~
L-' H
=
n D1
r
>' 2
"
~ ~
~
- ~
'___ n
~ 0
o
f ~ ~ ~
.. ~ " ~
~ g ~ ~
"1:1 '" -r. ~
~~:~'~c,~
"IJ tr:!Z;
1; ;;i::;
trlt-; t"
~;;j~
H ~
~~>r;l
G)~t'
T...
-m
~()
~Sl
:::0
:,t"
xo
~'"
~H
'"
;:tIl
H
'"
n
~
o
n
~
~
~
~
Z
~
::;J H ~
~f1r-J
<;
~~
'" "
~ ~
~< ::a 'i:'
H
wZ
trlCl
"
<..
-~
r,
;:: ~ 1fI
Ui 0 m
., "
~~~
(1;, 0 n
Ctt:lC'J
;;g~
..., :;
~ >' :tl
~ ~ -
~ ,~
~
~,
~
~
trl 0
'"
c
w
~
~
~,.., tt:l o.,l
~:~~~tr:;
"::a ^"t'l::'::::
[i t" >Jl 0 U!
~ ~ >< ;:
):, CIl ~ ~ H
::::: ~ ::: f;; ::a
~~::~~-
Cl L" 0 l~ '>;I
~; S:~ :s ;: f;
~~ :'l,,~
[J) tIl ~ 0 -,;:;:l
n =:: '"j:: 5: H
0>' A' t:ll 'U Z
~ ~ r:s 53 ~ G)
r" ~ g Q [I- g
;:1"IJ:j"'l~~
~ ~ 0
'"
~
,.
~
fj;
~
~
o
~
~
~
~
'"
~
'"
~ w
0'1', u>
coO',t..)
~
o
H
.... ,~..... <:> t..l
<:> J.. t..l c: "" J'--..J
::::> '-L "'" I.,' N I,' 0\
00 _. -.J .... l.11 [f' -.J
N ... ',', 0'. ,- ::::>
o 1l:l\J:0 co
::::> _ co l~ <::> _ I>!
"1 H
~: ~
:" 0
-: z
-0
"
:::'<1
~. H
~. r:l
m
~:
..0
trlt"
~t"'
~..
,.
7 "
,~ ;j
~
<~
~
:1' ~
," ll"
~~
'"
o
.
w
~
~ W
~ ~
(; ~ C ~ ;:
~gt=.,,:
'"' ::::J n ;".
f1" :: 'J~ ii
". '7 fw' Ii
pi ~ t1
,'!:, ~
o
"
t ::
"
1"
; 2'
e p
p
~ "
>' lfI:OO _c.- Z
o ~ ~" D' r>>
z>, c' 0 'C '0
["~ t" ~ .....
t"' l!) IT III
~ ~ tl ~ If, III
't:I'L'Il'ilC"'J:;"Q
~~S:;:::~Lt"
E; >< 6 ~ :~
t>:I C M
~~8~t<
() 0
~
~
~o
w ~
s~
,I', H
" 0
Z
;:JtIl
z
~ .
"'"
~:;p
~ 01 ;;
P"Iil
~
~
~
g
'"
,.
z
""' l~ W
rn ~
.....\f'
m
~
- ;:
"'"
~~
~, g
"'
" ..
~
~E II:
H 'l . h
~~ J ~
~ ~ ~ il~l.
:e>Of--'
:;:1 >' 11
~ 8 UJ
~
H ;;
~t'"
G
~
x
~
:,.:j
~
c
~
J>
"
I
-6i'1 :~,trilJ:J
r.:;:r ---.(l,{'!I>-1\l
.:l:!"i._O!,!j b
no,! ,"" .;or. ~
f~'-'I-'b ;,(
I ~~
.
"
o Z tIl
o . 0
~ '0 PI
'0 ....I"l
. , 0.
0. .
'< ~,
o
, "
~ 0
, ,
o
~ ~
o '<
o
o 0
o
m
~o..
'~z
~ ~ ~
o ~
~ ~
~
~
~
~
H
~
w
~
rn
~
w
"
e.
~
:;
"
~
e.
"
0.
.
.
o
~
c
c
c,
,
,
~
"
"
,
e
~ ~ ~
. " ~
"' . ,
ro., t::
,
~
o
o
~
~ ~ 0
o rn ~
"
<: '.J
H W
~ ~
~
0..0,
~ ~
~ ,
~
~"
...,l -.J -.,] -..l .,J
.,.. 0\ ,--".,...:}', 01 :J\0'l
",OOm ""0:>000:> (lO(DcD
\C'.L'u>'.!JU>"- ILl ""'" "-
I-'>-'Q OCOOOC
I-' CO \D ao .,J cr', l1' ~'. W k
~
~ c
m ",
~ ~
~
W ,
~"~
OIQ.V.
o:>wm
"'''-''0:>
00\0
1-''=''''
- ~
~
~
" m
~~
" ~
-.,] -J..:I -J--I -J -.l ..J -.l ..,j
m.,..~OI~"" 0\ O'lCO\~,O\O\O\~
(;to 0:> wo:>o:> ~ '" a '" ~ '" W '" m 0:> m
ao:>wo:>roCD~o:>ao:>wo:>mo:>aoo:>ro
"-\D~",,,-,,,um~CDmoo ",wmro
~l1'~W'JI-'C\Dtt~ffil1'~WNI-'O
~
~
m"
m"
~
~ "
;, 0\ ~ '~~z: ':~n r.;
0:> (:(:. m Do 0:> oo--,,~
(D 0-' CD ([) 0:> al:-',~
-.J--.:-J",-.l.-J
-.l 0\ Ul .:- W r-.:,
0=
o w
."
" ~
w ro ,
o .
'"
i: .~. ,.:
f::g, ~,:t-~ ~
--W" '>-,r, ;':l t:l
,i',Q::J;''''r ;0;-
, 0 ~
p
,
"
1-- -~----_._-_._--~---
II; I mill i j i Ii 1iIi1lm llim um I llil ill I i I
I-'~~>-~~~>-I-'>-I-'>-I-'>-I-'-I-'>-I-'>-I-'~I-'~I-'>-I-'~I-'~I-'>-I-'~I-'-I-'>-I-'~I-'~I-'>- I
I-'>-I-'>-I-'>-I-'>-I-'>-I-'>-I-'>-I-'>-I-'>-I-'>-I-'>-I-'~I-'>-I-'>-I-'>-I-'>-I-'~I-'~I-'>-I-'~I-'>-I-'>-i
'lci~~~~~ci~ci66~ci6ci6ci6ci;66ci6ci66?ci6~~ci66?6?ci?ci66~1
-.l~--I_.,J..,j-.l..,j.,J_.,J..,j-.l~--I..J...,l..J...,l-J...:l--l.,J-J.,J..J..:I_..:I_.,J_..:I..J...:l-J.,J-J.,J-J...:l-J.,J-J1
I'~""""'~""""""""""""""'-"
1~~~~~~g~~~~~~;~~~6~~~~~6~~~6~~~~~6~~~~~6~;~~1
,OQOCOOOOO~ooooo~oco~ooooooooocoooco~ocooo~oo
!_~ ~ ::.::~_.::~~~~~~_..., ~ -..)":'. ..., -: ..., ==-.:::::::- --: ':!:: ::::. __...:r ..... -..I -..) "-l -..) -..) ~
:~@~~~~~~~~~@~@~~~~~~~g~@~@~~~8~~~~~~~~~~~@~~ Ii
I ___" --- ------------------.--.---------- --.--.-----------
I
~
~ ... ..., LI'
c~>w-tI1-0
~ ~
W J I.J'1
~, 0
o
o
~ _ g _ g ~ ~ ~ g c g
p,~~ ;;~!.~b-~:,,"
~ - rT _ 0 ,..::t ::c:
'g. i' (J :::: 6" r:-' g- :- P;I 0
Ul ~;:.;:T,~~tr.l ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ M
2 ~ ~ ~ ~~' ~ ~ ~
~~'''<,_g~~,;,m~.trllf,
rT w ~ m " ~ n ~ 0
lb -~. ~ r.' l.'iI '>;l
~ ~~-3 :z:~~:?~
~ o....o~~~g;'2.~~
~ I"'- n "' - '"' Ul (D ~
m ~ < - ~ ~ ~ m
'"ll '0 ~ g ;7 III .g ~ 'Tc!' ;>j
r"' ~ 2: _ I-' 'C 'lIj ,..., n r-
(J)~~~~t1g~ ~~~~;;
"'" !II In >- H H H 0
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
_ H ~ m ~ ~ ~
"l ,tl (fl It>
t10.;: "3 ;:~;~~::
S" '2. t" ~ ":< ~ r-=- ~
IfJ m [oj ~ to l":I
III tIl {/) L'~ tIl.
:1
"'
~
~
o
~
o
w
~
~
~
o
~
~
o
~
o
o
~
w
~ ~ ~
'.)>0 ~-
::: .. [;; ~
tIl. ;;.
&- ;; ;:
. .
o 0
"ll ,,'o:l tI:l
'lIj'T;'o:l :r-
H ~ ~
n n'"
t1J m t';t
tr.l (fj,~ ~ Lc
o 0
'>;I ,,'>;I
;g':1~
~ ~ g
t:l ;,;(/)
.~, :z;
>
If:- 'tl
~~
~
~
t" ~
~
~
~
~
~
~
~,
o
~ '"
cr, '.l W
tv U'IO:....
~
~
o
o
o 0
o c' 0
o
o
o
w
~
o
l>< ?::
o c'
~
~
o c::
7., ~ "
C ~ C
~-, ~
~ g ~
~ 0
> -. n ."
" 1 ~
:;l :r;c
8 8-
~ .,. 0
o _ ~
>OJ ~, tn
~
=
~
~
H
=
.
~
~~
f;;~~
w
~:;"~
~ Z l.O
J~ '"
W 0 ~
~ ~!II
;:j CJ
:.< ::'"0>
" "
III :"
)> ~- ::t:
:l:l '--'''<: :1'
tll' (l ":;
> :>>< - 1'1"
t'::d 0 rr
2::>>< i:;";:: (j;
~ ~
~2't1
l"i!lH t"
--' ~ ':: p:]
~ ~ ,; Ul
~ G' '>I;l
~
~
tri :::
~ ~~ >i
t"':00
~
C ~
d
H
l:"' ;r: ::d
t:j ~( 0
ro 0
~ S ~
'Ij ;>C ~
;;; ~ ~
w ,
~ ,- ~
~
H
H
'" -
.'
;,J!:"'
:"'t'"
" 0
>-
~ ,-
~
>
H
"
W
~
>
~
~
H
=
m
w
~
~
r
o
w
"
~
.'
~
~
o t-_ "'"
o 0 ~
o
o
~ ~ ~ ; ~ rt ~
~ ;U w ~ ::
;.; ("J):
o
g:~s
~ H
...-..,
o H
~~~
[~~ !::! ~
~ is c-~
g' g ttl ~
..,:;'"
l':
~ "
ro
8 sr
T ~ c ~
::d ,< 0
~ .
H c- ta
C:Z; .-. >-
[) r/:' ~
C
"
;; "
- ~
~
. "
- "
:i
" "
o ,.,
~~~
ZJ.>j
t" C
o ~
" H
~~~
;: ~. ~
o
"
o
~
~~
(,~
.'
:':
w
"
"
~
"
"'
.
"1
r
~
~
~
~
w
~
~
UJ ;
t'Il~
"
~ C
H "
o
" "
we
~
~
~
"
~
~
~
o " ~
o ~
o
o
'l>[,:
q;
-n
() e:
. "
,
t'" -J
::-0
(, 0
co.
~ 0'
Jl; :::ill
'tl ~, "<:
~-:;
. r ~
III n' go
"' 0
~ ~ i
d
" -
H
~
~ - w -
o ~
o :>" 'i'
o u: " -
~ ~ ~ ~
" 0
-, ::tl
" H
IF. to. ..
>-3 ~'
=
> ~
'"2 ~ If' t" il
to! '" 'L'
'-'CIl ,--,
c- p t:
"
~ -
,
.
o
~
n
'" ~
~"'l
r:t::t'"
~ ~
)>
,
~ "
'"
m -
o
~
t:1 ;:,
m c
!I.'
'I
<",
,,,
~
II
"
o
~
.
> 0 ~
~~@
O~
"~
~
~
"
~
~
w
~
~
~
w
::,
~
"
0'
"
"
e.
"
o.
.
~
~
c
c
"
" C ~
. . ~
'" , -
Ill., t::
-
N
o
o
~
~
I-'t'J
r
< N
5 ~
z
-.l ~l ....l
Q'\:J\en
~ro~
\DU:'\Ll
en m en
0)--'<7\
N "-' W
0::0 <;;>
C ~ 0
0::0 0
~-~
Ul'..n11l
~.,."..
000
~ ~ ~
,... :=> ~
~~
men cr,
ro~rn
'.t:.'IO\O
(r,o;r, 1)',
U1ol>ou.'
", w
00
00
00
~~
,.nl1l
.~
DO
'" ~
a, ~
IV b.) t~, W
DODO
DOOO
00 C,O
>-'1-'>-'1-'
"'I1llJ"11l
...."..""....
coco
LnI1lUlUl
ml1l....w
-.l -J-.J-J
C7\<'Y\C7\mC7\
Q)'lJQ)OC'(D
1tI'-'='\Ll\O\D
a. U1 01 (.~ UI
"" 0,,; <x>
"~
"'~
OJ 0)
'",10
C' ~
~~
'" W
00
00
00
-~
,~ ~
.~
00
~~
~~
'_'t.J
00
CO
00
~~
lJ"Ul
.~
CO
ro~
O~
~ ~
0\C7\
WID
ro~
~~
en,&.
NW
00
00
00
~~
~~
. ~
00
.~
,~
~~
" ~
rn~
ro~
~ ~
,,, w
WW
00
00
00
~~
~ ~
.~
00
....
~...
C~
a, ~
w~
rn' ~
ll,l7\
_0
6~
co
00
-~
'" ~
.~
C' 0
.~
'-,-'>>-J
~
(l,01
(r,(l>
~
,t....
"' ~
~~
" ~
w~
""10
.~
~~
~~
O~
a~
ro~
""""'
(.~ ""
....:J --.J -.J ~' oJ
0\01 iJ",cnC'\C7\
O:>IXl<XJtx)(lO)
\D "" U:' \D 'D \D
...........".. ""'....
w tV t-' 0 _ !XI
~
c, ~
ro~
rn~
a ~
,~
--.J....l--.J...:I
O',C7\iJ",Q'\
<.tJQ;lCD!XI
\D \t> \D \L>
ow'-" u. W
',n,,", w W
--:-..:re::tE. 11:~il+y,J-::-?-"~' 11l
;;;;;:' ~'~v'Zl~':+1 ~>rl'.:w.:"I':~g;1r ~
CD (J;I rn !XI 00"') ; -.o:_>;.r:" ~"::' ;0;-
~~::;~::;'I 't 1<', do"
D \D rn ~ m I '-'. ~ ~
I r &~
I ~
~~
{t.,a.
ro~
ro, ~
WW
[.J.....
.....'~~~I-'~.....~I-'t-'.....~.....t-'.....~I-'-.....t-'.....-.....t-'I-'t-'....._.....t-'.....>-'.....>-'....._.....t-'....._.....t-'.....t-'
.....-.....t-'I-'~I-'~.....-.....t-'.....~I-'t-'....._.....>-'.....t-'.....~.....t-'....._I-'>-'.....t-'....._.....t-'....._....._....._.....~
,',','"""""""",--""""""""",
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
(D~O)~O)mQ;lmQ)~m~=xm~O)(J;IO)rul,D=O)romro(J;lro(J;lrom~(J;IrolXlro~~~~~--.J...:I--.J
'-"-""""'--"--'-"""""-""'-""-
~~W~~NW~NNW~~~N~NN~NNN~~NNNNNNNN""NN~NWNNNNNN
oaooooooo~ooooooooooooooooocoooooooooooooooo
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
~~~--.J~-.J~--.J~~~~-J ~~~~...:I~...:I--.J~~~--.J~~~~~~~--.J~--.J~~~--.J~~~~
; c:: _- Q -
i!:ll ,:'iWUJ
tl:::ct:J
f-' [ (...le-
o J.- U'l
o w
o
o
o c
o
~
~ :r-;
~ -,
~
,.
~
g
~
H
"
" A
>
~ r-: tIl
t"' ~ 5
-, .
" 0
~
.
~
'"
Cd:::: d '::: Cl ::: Cl
.~c CIl "" tIJ (1;' tf.I [I] t:Il
t:Jtlt:Jt:l~t:lco
Cl:::O:::d cd:::d Cd ':::Cl_d .:::d::::C:::C:::::C Cc::.:::c:....d ~
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~8~~~8~8~~~8~~~8~~
~ '1 to.l t.l N co
e- (J;I en 0) :r t.l 0"- -...l "-' (J;I
0; ro-.J~_O) '" --.J
0;
;;
'"
'"
'"
~
~
;=
- ,
C)r'l
>--jtr
00
:z. 0
,..
~: <
o
~
p.
.
P.
lJ ,0;.
~
~ "
.
" r
C'
'" C
"
~:l
~
~
"
'"
i;: ~.' g
< "
e, ~
0.. r.i
.
Q. ~
"
z. '< 'f~
~~.
.
~
~ :
~
H
"
- Q
t~ !rl
;:.f-il
-&1~
t-:J't:l5:
r '"
G t'l ~;
H ~
;;:; t>l rr ~
~ ~ ,J ~
o n IT u.!
;0 l>;l ,. !:Il
~ "" U} ~
r,t"' '1J
rQ
,.
H
~
,
o
~
,
W
o
o
~
s:::
rtir<
;r;Ul
"
,.
;i ~
~
,. ~
:":'1 ~
JO~~
>-1 H t>;I
Z (,
! ~ ~ ~'
QQ~
g ~
o
o
:r-- ~
"'
;~
j>'
::o:n
_0
" C
r.
. ~
~,.
.
::':" c ~; tf.I
e. g [[, ;;
H ~
~ ~ ~. ~
8 . ~
"
H
~
"
o
"
.
n
o w
o e
0; =
=1 ,
o 'C'
~ ;
u,
~ m
>< u_ n
"': ~ ~
e"
,.
8
H
r
N (1,0
U'l 'r 0
,~
~
~" ~
=1
. '"
n
c, ~
c.M 0
o ~
o - W
~.c, tIl
~;
.
~
:;;N
':0: >-
m
,::::t.1
cO
"
, H
,.
~>1
, '"
"~
"
H
nz
, "
6t-=J
ri;:
~~~H
~ "';l Cr., ~
?~ t"'
c:;:
~
r
'"
~
.... t,) 7,04
--.': 0:> ~ w _ -..l
<.0.' \1l '"
I
I
U ii U ! Hi: I 11111111: Ii I
II
._"_._~- -- ---._--
I
<ON
CO
CO
CO
~~
c' ~
.~
00
. ~
_0
" W
VI "- I,,)
<:0 '.r;, VI 0
0'_'0 I-'
o 'J' I-' ,J. I-'
!\.l ,_~ 0 ,t, \1l
o
o
~~~
... ~
~
~
eo o,J..o._.-.,1 CO 00
o ~ CO co.r; VI ~ -.,1 _ CO _ C
S><'~~~;l;""~
~~$:~~~2~3.:
" " "'
z ~ ~ ~ n ~
'I:l !- fJ S
;' ~ ~ ~
~ [;; ~ tIl
~n~~
rrO
"
o
"..
~ ~
., H
j;:
:!;;t:l
~"'
r ~
tr:,'tl
l(.;J;;
H
~ >-
H
C ~
.
r-:: H
t-::G1
" .
~
r H
e
~~
,,~
CO
w"
..
~~
~
- ..
~
We
~'"
~M
~.
~
~j;:
HID"
ZO
(,'::0
~~
~m
m
u:.,oo
..
~~~
~
"
~
w
~6
,"
!:J>"3
;.Coo
"
..
... ~
is;;> ~
~ C) :; ~
l:j' ~ ~ g
;~ ; ~ ~
no:;: n
:>>:-0"'30
~r ~
lC) ~ ~ ~
tf.l X ~
~...;S :r<
~ Sj >; ,~~ ~
:P ZOl1J
~ ~ ~ >r
C:' " t'"' r
~ i gj
:::1~
" .
0-"
~~
In ~
:c
~g
'" M
, ~
;:~
OM
~~
:< t"'
..
,.
~
~
<:" I-' :T, W \[
<;C<<>U1.l-,l}'l "--'
w ,s;. V1 O!\.l w
o "" 0:-'..... -.J
- H ::c
Z i5
~~
~ ~
~. gJ
1ii ,~
~~~
~ -
:r.:..,. ':l
. ~
:3:-,
V)
r~:
~
~. '<:I
l'J;; [;
n -;;:
" "
~
~
:'1
:;;~
:_~ ..;
~ ~
1:r;t:tJ
Z :t1
oj ~
w.
'c H
x.
~
>"
'n '"
W~
r,
nll'
~~
" 0
~} :t1
ZH
~Z
:t' ,..
0"
r~
c"'
~C) U,\ ~
~~
r;t"'
;:J~
~
r
:r-- z
" .
o
s
:.:: ~
m
- .
.. e
t0111
X' "
~~
"
nrT
,-,
< ~ w
~i ;- r.: a
"
~
=:m
- .
); ~
"
~ .
"
[1Jt<l
, ~
:~o c't;
:;::I-h:>:''"tl
~~~g
--< t'I -1 ~
"
"..
:Sl:'"
~8
"
g~
"'"
l'J'"tl
r
':'--:1:1:I
Uta
:z: ;:D
. " ..
. c ~
~ "
. c
"
~
~
o
"
0.
~
~
00 ~ ~
w ~ 0 _ .J>,
o 0 ~
~ "
, "'
S~
:::::I'J u-;
r-:-:. :t1 H,
0<'18
-0
:; ~ iT,
~
,-
[11 n Cl
'J; :<- ~~
.
<''l;lZ
_!tr:l OJ
t:r:' 1-:l'S
~ Il'" 1)
ITl [(.
H
H ~
- ~ ~
zt':!
"'
~
W.
[T'J'tl
X'"
;:~
"
s:~
Ere
0,
~ -
I
i~
~
I
"-"1-"-:
i' :
n z tt
o w 0
S " .
'0 ~"
. m 0
" .
~ ~
o
o C
0. 0
m ,
"
~ "
o '<
o
o C
o
I
. 0 .
:t1~fij
0,.
~ ~
~
~
H
~
H
~
~
~
~
w
~
e,
~
"
".
~
".
e.
"
p.
o
.
"
x
c
o
,
c,
"
::::
,
'"
e
"
"
,
e
.. 0 ~
. m "
'" . ,
m " H
~
N
o
c
~" c
~~ t>:l \,C
C
< N
~ ....,
~ ~
'ul
"
~
J O'l
," co
~
~
" ~
~~ ~
[",0'\'(',',::"
O"(:Q moo
\DlCI 10'"
_ -..l -.) o.,J
......."".,...
JH~!~H:I
1.\......."".....1>...."'"....:0. I
1;6;;6~~~~~ I
r::-:::::::-II
1,....................'.............................1
15;~~:;~~;;;~;;;
i ::::::::: ,
,~cooooooc ;
S~S~S~::3~SI .
~ I CG~u:,~S;~~'~~--II:1
_ : :::; t:l ::J 0 c t:l c t:J C i
.,
"I
~ ~ I. '.
~ ~
N
- ; Ifl:
~: I
~
c
~ ~
," ~
~oo
\.!'.",
~
~~
"
~
o
0.
-,
T
- ~
~
~ " ~
o
o
~ . 0
"'" " w
~ <
:;:, ~ ~ ~
TH
~~~
~ "
,') ttJ t>J
:t: :>17'0->0:"
M Z:co oe -,
~2sr~~c~~m
If' 0 ~ >':l ~ :;-~
:)~ :r:: Z H
~;r;~:t;~~~:;
_; () ~ H 1i :s
M ;S ~ ~,
~~ri'tt
tfJ H
;:j
m
~ tll
51li) m
;; 0 ~
",
U'l :r>'CI
~
x c
~ ~
tr'r'
7m
r
tr'H
'f:' Z
n
~
~ m
::r- ..,
~
'"
5:
H
~
~
~
s
;;
X
t;
'- ~
~
~
."..
-c~f.~ ~
;:~ ,.." ~,"C" ~
, ,
p
.
"
r. :;::
o .
'"
" ~
. .
~ (Il
n
o
0.
o
~ 0 ~
:;;~~
o ~
~ "
~
"
~
r
r
w
00
~
~
w
,
~
~
~
~
:;
;0.
n
0.
.
~
~
" ;; "
, e
'" ro -
. n "
c
,.
o
c
1____
, "
w
" c
~ w
w
'c
~
~
ffi
o
n
, , , ~ ~ ~
" ~ " ~ " ~ c;, ~
ro 00 ro 00 ro 00 ro 00
" ~ ", ~ <0' ~ ~ ~
ro ~ ~ w w w ~ ~
~ ~ ~ 0 ~ 00
0;:;,"wG jF::=~T,~~[~=:~.m
.-J "~',~~,'_"~' ....'~ "c_''l'ilI"C ll>
01 ""'6"(:"': "'!I-'-'tl~,!--r,'~,";:I~"
Q) CD CD OJ, ci 'ili,',' I~'~-'~V;:O;-
<1" \D \D l,(> '1 !1:,} -J, .,
f...' t>J UN 1li_: t:l ~
Ctl (J1 ~ . ,ft!:- E l\l
l'i'tI g.'<
'fl ~
~:
1"
li'1
! ,
~.
~
~,
n ~ "
0 . C
, " .
" ~ "
. m Q
" .
'< 0
"
n
0 r.
0. 0
m c
0
~ n
0 '<
0
0 r.
0
~
"
o
Q.
(()
o
'0
~
"
n
"
"
ro
. 0 ~
:;;~t;1
O.
~.
~
~
~
~
C,
K
~~2;~~~~~6:;6~ I
0000-::::0000000
cooocoooooool
>-'1-'......>-'........1->>-'...........1
\~ LIl l!1 Ul Ln Ul lJ1 LIl In Ul lD ut
.:o......W.....WWWWWWW I
::)OO'l)I.CCDCDOICTUTLf1Ul
I.D \Q ... ... ,~ ...: 0 -..1 lJ1 W .... !-'
;;;B-~;;f~;;~III'
................................................,..............,.....
OOOOCOOOOOOO
I.D\QCIl-..1~-..1....J...:I-.J-..1-.j,.J
''-"......,.........................................
f. t,J t\J.... 1'.: W t\J '" t.! t..l f'-' N
I CQOOCODOOOOOI I
COOOCOOOOOO~ I IFill
_ -..1 -.J ~ -.J -..1 -.J -..1 -.J -..1 ....J~
>--C~~~O-C c: C Cl c: c: 1"1'
Wi W~OOmQmWm~mWooi :
':J!CClOt:lCt:lCt:lOt:lCt:li I'
--'-~--~--~~
~
~
w
00
~
~
w
.
e.
~
n
0'
~
:0
"
0.
.
.
,
".
!'T
j
~
.,
"
~ ~ c
e '.' U'I \~ -.J
0' 0 '.' C> w
C UT k' ...
W I-' C IV
l:I> c- W u-' '"
r.
"
^
"
~
',r -.J
,:: ...
o
o
....Cl-'.l-O 0
o O>,j.. 0 _ N
,
,
"
C
. ._-o-;::-~-~--~ 1"l 'J. ~ -;~-n---------;-i
~ ". Q g @ [<J ~ i 0 ~: ~ ~ i
r:cl'l ~iJ '::':cu)~ ~ ~'
~ ~ u. ~ ; ~ ~ ~ m ~
~ ~ = ~ m ~ ~ ~ ~ ' , n
. ~,,~T,~3~~~~~1
~ 0 ~ 1-' ~,' ". (!} .. r:: :j ..., ::!
~ m _ _ z n ~ ~ a
J,,>,jt~'t;~tI)~z~~
~B:"'~Il'''f<~i:J>-lX~
~~~~~S8 ~~~~
~ ~ 0 ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ..
.nL'l;'<ot"'ES ~~Ctj~
:t' >' UJ tI'l (;j H ~ f-'I
;S ~;;~ :t>~~g
rTJ ~l' lOJ Z
~ R~2 '>;l~;
>' t-i'U'tl
'rH";l L't"
re<r;; ~[ifh
UJ tol
:>:l'TJ"f
W:-'..
"
"
",
"
r
;:J
..
r
~ 0 ~
, " ~
'" 0 ,
0 " w
w
,
N
0
0
~
i ~ " 0
~ " '0
c
< N
H w
Z ",
c
Z '0
lEl-:.,'
I." I
~ :
'. i
,
:1
I ~ i ~-~
, I,
I',
: !,
w ,
::' iT$
. e;,"',
:;; ~
'-" tho
.... ~'
:!'
wi
~
m
~",
I.';
~~!~
i .
m
'I
~
~'
~
f~
\;li'
r~
,j
, ~"
"
e,i,'
~
-~ ,
I
!I
"" c: .....
. . "
~ 0 ~
o " "
.. c
"
C
o
~
e
c..
,"". ,,~
~,;,~ "~,.,IL'~' :::~ r),'l"
-, "r-,
vt '
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
To ohtain Board approval for disbursements for the period of November 10, 2007
through November 16, 2007 and for submission into the official records of the
Board.
OBJECTIVE: To present to the Board of County Commissioners the disbursements for
the period of November 10, 2007 through November 16, 2007 for approval as well as to
obtain approval for the submission of the disbursement listing into the official records.
CONSIDERc\.TIONS: In accordance with Florida Statutes, Chapter 136.06(1), the
Clerk's office requests that these listings be approved and made paJi of the official
records of the Board of County CommisslOners.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
FISCAL IMPACT: Disburscmcms as totaled on the attached report
RECOMMENDATIO!\': That the Board of COllnty Commissioners approves the
disbursements listing for the period of Novcmber lO. 2007 through Novemoer i 6, 2007
and submit these documents into the official records.
Prepared By: ~ r1 fl2i.~
Lisa N. Melvin
Assist nt General Operations Manager
Date:---.it 1'9/)7
'1-1 I
Reviewed By: _Q'_&~_Date:_1LiLqJ(l7-
Constance C. MUlTay, CGFO V
General Operations Manager
COLLIER COl!I\TY
P:!;';'~;, ::'~ ;'ur:T' ,>Y,1;, ,," ::.r::r:'
Item Number;
ttemSummary:
~nt,,::, F;~"f;'
'-'r (.Ls:':'u' ~U()l[' IS 1 ~;, 'I',t, I'>: r:~
1'['/[,:11l-,(-
to"~ "e~'t;- ' 1 '.:
cine:
I',;:
,,!;}, ~ - "-,,. b: 3' .::
Meeting Date'
iY "IVI
Pn>paretlHy
1iT,\'ir:
;',SO,!~tJn' G{"F~ral ;mcr"t'(.'n~, M<inager
[;<tlt
:;'0rkn':,QL''l.$
"'rrwn~(
:-1",'::!')C- ;~:-, _~.', "Pi
AIlIH"\'t'd n.,
:.;n".;cl,,,cc,,\
',<:'1'"'' :'nera""" '"~,-,,,o,,'
""'l'-
~,.."i c' ,:"U.",~
"';n;ll1'''.
""2'1:--..,:'1DI','
Allpruvcd II.,>
.}tnlV~ r,H,~~
;:',-,,,,,;, ,-.1;;:)(,"
D.'\('
,"'OJ"', , : :::~'"
C",;""""~""""-'
~c:.u,,\ r..",,>.:);;" :Jfhv
'-:'200' '~'4,:Hi
+'1.,.11(' ^ ~"",L.T .._.'.L.._~_"(,, h'~. ,-__1____0.""'"7" """",.,'.][ <>.--",'\rY".I{-!'""n/')", "'I."'"
Pa!le ] of 1
TrCJ:'J'
1'.''ln'''>"n,",
.
i--l f-.l f-' .-J f-' -' r-' -' r-' f-1 ,....., ....... i--l '-' f-' i--l f-' ~....,","".,":" "'"', '"":'_"'"'.....-,--' Fo'."...,F"
'-'I-' D GO 0 O:=J 0 f-' 00 OC' 00...... 00 CYC:rO:O oC> eo':>O
O\t-..) m.J:. W W o:=> 0 >f.>. UlWO 0 00 >f:> -.J OJ,+:, WM;;.f-'I~Cl:=;;rC:::>
OOf-.l-.Jf-.l-.J~~~~-.Jo-.Joom~i--l-.J~-.Jw-.Joo~~oo~mw
moo-.J~~f-.l~WWOW~ ~~ONWN-.J-.JW-.JN-.J
i--lWWO~ow-'ooowmm w~w-.J~-.JOOO-.J-.J-.JOO
~wscn~oon~~~no~Z~~n~3n~~~onn~
~cH~~on~O~~OHn~C~~H~O~~OZOO~
~~~~~ON~OOCZ~~~Z~~~~~~~~H3~~
o~~ w~Z3~~XO~~ynN~~nw ~ZW3~~
~ on ~o ~YH ~ 00 00 ~~~HOO
ozo 03= n~ H~Zpmoz~ ~no~zoo~
~o ~ ZH~OO~> n~s~~~ 3 ~0Z ~~
C~3~ nrZZ ~~H~~~3 oz mn ~
l~HO ~ rQ 8 ~o ~~H~ ~n >00
S~~~ ~~ ~~~ i~~~~~~~ ~~@~~g~
~~m~ H< ~~~ ~3~~ ~~z ~c~ooz~
~~~H ZOO ~~~ z~mO~ XH on~nz~
z 0 OO~ X~~ ~Z~Or~ m O~07,W~H
nof-'Z ~o H 3 ~~Hrn H ~Hr z
o~z ::0'0 zn[IJ ::000 3ZH -,::cn()H'tJn
~Hn H3 ~~z 3~m ooz ~z ~zc
zr zoo oo~ OOX3 A n H~~ro
~~ 0= 03 0=00 00 nH=::om~
~ ~ QHa Henz ~ ozn~::OH
H ::on~ n~~ ::on zn
zn 'd~ P ~ Op
~o OL~ ~ W 0 ~~w
~ ~w~ ~~g ~ nag
n ~H~ x~c ~ OZO
H HZ~ p~~ ~ CPO
~ ona 3 H 0 ~~~
z i ~ ~ Z ~~m
rrl t;j u} 2:
:z: Cd n
-'
,;
C"
f-'
~
'0
w
w
'-'.J-. >-' 0.--' 0\ .L-.L_ U' ,..;,j.;. '-' t,,;,
w~w~~~.L-WOOCW W~~.J-..J-.~OO~
W~>-'C1
'"
=>
co
~.J-.OOt~~~J.L_~~c~~oo~~mmo~'~~>-,~8~a\~~
C>.' _ (Y,.-,) -' 0'. 0, ,:;, t..) [.j.L. \2 l,J (l', --J c,J -' C:'~.) (L' \:.- LTI < -" t.J -.. W '0)
1.[' ~,:' ,,,;,.L..z- CO", v::' ,.=. ::::'XI,J: < Cl', '""" (':t:' '.)::.8 w' <1 0 >-' OJ CD[.~\ ~ >-'::;0
'"
'0
-. 'J.. t.' CD (. _.. ~ :=> .-=:, '-".' '~n 'I' '-Jl cr, C--, ~ ~ J < t.J C;) '-..~' t" C>, C"., t..;'
>4 - l" .::' '0:" I.: ::',8 C', -=' '.:::' 2' ~ 0', l..[ '-' O~!l ::.' '-.;, CD.O c;' '::. c,.r~ cr
'-''-'~~~'-'~~~>-'~~'-'-''-''-'~'-'~-'~~~-''-'~-'-'
~'-'_'~~~~>-'~~~ww~'-''-'~'-'~~~_'~-''-'~~~
,...-----.~--,--,"~.-----.- -------.,-----.-.-----..------.--"~~--.'--..-.-------- ----- " -- -- ", - --
~~-~--~-~-''-'--'~----'~-'-'-~>-'-~~~
o.~a,~m~mcr\Ol~~u-~mc,m.L..L_.J_.~~.r..J_..J_..J_.~~.J_.
- ------------ "- ----- -----. -----.------.-,,---------.-,~'--- '-,------- '----- ----.,'--, --------- --------- --------- --------- -----.--.---- ----,.--------- --, -----. ----------
tJ [--: L~ I' t.J t.J (,) Ll ~.) ~~) I.J t:- t.J t--J t.J IJ tJ tJ t.J \.J I--' ~J 10 I,,] U t.J I-..J ~'_'
ocooooooooooooooooooooo~oooo
0000000000000000000000000000
~~~<~~~<~~~~~<~~<~<~<<<<<<<<
t.Jt.JtJt0t--J~t-..Jt.JrJNI-..Jt.JNtJNI0t--Jt.J~t.JNt.JtJt.Jt--JI-..JUU
0000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~>-'~~~~~~~~~~~~
~~~~~~~~~~~~rnm~m~~~mmmm~~mm~
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.L_~~~
~~<~<~~~~mmrnmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
t0U(JtJ~~~~~Ww~~~wwm~m~m~~~~~~~
~N>_,owoo~m~<mm~WtJ~~wt.J~owm~mm~w
~
:1 ~
,
~
~
: . I ,
; "
; c
c
w
~
,..!'-'
0-::;;
fl'
"
.
n
e
o
"
"
>
~
~
e
"
ro
~
n
ro
S
'"
ro
'0
o
"
"
n
o
"
~
.
"<
"
o
~
~
; ,!'Ii
',~,
I''''.,
I~
i!ll;1
i~
11'1,,'
:~
11
w
~ ,~
0\0,'"
\0\.[,\0
C :::' <::>
N '"'-, ~
~ ~
<-..l
m O\:J\
IJ:J \D ~
00 CJ
'c ~
,., 0 'lC'
...:l _''':
~ ~
\0\,['''''
o 0
~~~
tl;I -~ Vl
~
cr, ~
" \b
00
"~
" ~
, ~
a, ~
,",,'\0
00
~~
~ ~
~~
m~
W~
00
~~
eO
O~
0' ~
m, ~
00
-::;00
a, 0
..oJ -.J..-J-.J
-cr', '" iJ\ '" 0' 0'1
\L' "" \D \D \C1 \D
000000
CO 000
'" oJl" ,... W
~~
00
00
00
~~
m ~
.~
r-;.l.,l
c W
,~
,~
m~
W~
co
C 0
eo
,~
m~
mo
m ~
~ ~
\J.,m
,~
m~
00
m~
I..n\D
,m
-" ~
a,O\
,"0
m ~
m ~
("'"
w ~
DO
00
00
e~
m~
....
~~
~W
'"~
....::1<...,
G', '" 0\ '"
[((Deco:>
<0:. It> \[) \D
\C"'\DID
(,., W ~ 0'
ww
00
00
00
e~
m~
~~
W~
"'-, N
m~
c' w
00
CO
00
~
m ~
~ ~
" ~
, ~
~W
~~
m~
mo
'~ \D
m~
\OW
w W
00
00
00
"~
m ~
~~
1,)e.J
I..; M
,. ~
~~
cr, ~
m 0
" ~
.. 0
~~
, w
00
CO
00
~ ~
m~
. ~
w ~
,,~
c ~
',.,.. .~.
-'",':;-;11,-';;'. :
'" ...i';.,..-.l'C'hl'-
(h 0\ '0,"(1'; -cri' '.
C<lI:l'>CDODro
\D\D\D\D\D
(l:)(l)mQlOO
CJI" W W
w ~
00
00
00
" ~
m ~
~~
,,~
,. ~
m ~
IV.., "-'
000
000
000
~~~
m ~ m
~ ~ ~
hJ"",, r-'
;;,::;: ~
W
W
00-'::> 0
<=> ::c> 0 0 l.c' <':>
- ~ 00 ~ ~ L \0
w ~ <::> ~ ~ 0 ~ I (l) a, ~
... ,', U1 "- In '^-' 0 eJ' '" 'J "" 0 ol>
~ " m
~ 0
~
~
~
~
::c.t!.l
n
'r.t'"
.., H
=
~H
., n
m
;t' ~
" ~
~ ' ~
"tJt"' t"'
t~ ~ ~
~ W N
000
000
o 0
~ ~
~ m ~
~~~
~ ~ N
0'10-','"
WI,,' .....
"-, N '"
000
g~g
1-'1-'>-'
(J'.t1TlJ1
"""".to
~N"-'
m 1JI If>
c~ro
..., "- N
000
000
000
~ ~
l.1TlT1tJl
~.~
N ,--' N
Vll"U1
~m~
WW
00
00
00
e~
m~
~~
N~
m~
~ W
W ~
00
CO
CO
~~
m~
"~
W~
am
w~
~'" Io.l
00
00
00
~ ~
m~
"~
~~
c_ ~
O~
W~
00
00
c' CI
~
~~
" ~
WN
~ ~
", ~
W~
00
00
00
,,~
m~
.~
~, t.)
~W
c. .
~~
00
00
00
~~
c. ~
.~
N~
w W
W~
W~
00
00
00
~~
~~
..
~~
w W
eO
I
I
~-~~~~~ ~ ~ ~~~~-~ ~~~~~~'~-~~'~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~
~~~~~ ~-~-~-~~~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~
",',',--""""-,-",-",,------,,--,,,-,-
~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-
.b.~.b.b~A.b.~.~.~.~.b.b.b.b.A.b.b.A.b.b.bWW
,-,-,---,-,---------------------------,-----
W~N~NMN~W~N~NWN~WNN~W~W~WNW~WNWWWNWW~NWNWWNN
100000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
~' OCOO. OOClCCCOOQCOOOOOCCOOOCCOOQOClCOOOOOOOOOOOC'
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
--'-~-~.'-- _...~._-
. c: c:: c: .:::; ~
I Ul ~S (fJ tn tIl
I l:l '=' tl C't:l
I
~
,
., .,"
S !;:'
" tJ) ,.
H f.'::r:
~ -,
:r- :r'J:r'
C .
8 ". S
< ~
~ ,- g
[<J "~;
~ ~
E:rE
a~~
H , ~
~ ;c't""'
,..
)> z
2: '=.'
~ :'C'
~ ;::
~
C
.,
"
w
~
W
o
"" G: 0'. _
... C- 0 :;I: 0>
.... ",... 0
~
~
~
~
0, ~ ~
N 0
~
m
"
Q
q
'J,lO
g
t'J' ~
..' ~,
::0 b
Q
~ H
- =
n
~o-.c:
. "
7;:>>' :T
r '"'1 (,'
[13m:::..
~:tl C ~ >< z
~~ ~ ~ ~ ,~ ~ ~.... ~
-) tIl '" 1-\ l'" :;; ....., tT:l
Q )0 ~ ;! g tIJ lO
[;)8 t"' H
~~r~r~t.~
-,:"I)It () :=< ~
:r-' 0 'tl
zQ t:"' t"
~>' C 1;l8:,
~
.
~
~
00
't:I ~,
~
'"
"
~
"'
~
co
~
"
~N
.H~
~ N 0, <:> ~ ~ m ~ ~
'" ...J .:> ,... c:. .... ... ..., l' '" ~ cc
<:> :: 01 0 .., ,.. .., 0 e.,
~
o
o <:>"' ~
<:> _ <:> ,C;:....
,,, 0 0
...J ''-00
~ H ~
!:to-~
~ ~ ~
...; ---'
> ..
to< ::-'
:>' :'"
:lJ ';r
~
'::"0
:" c
~ tIl
:r;t-'!
o
'T1 a; ~
:::r:::~
- >
'"
~
"
~J n
o
~~$
~
"
n '~
H
>
~
"
H ~
~ ~
XS
.-,
~~
.. H
::;~
~
~~
n
~
'-;
g
~
VJ :re
H~
rr'...;
:::tIl
u, '"
H!i!
';:tfJ
., H
~ ~
~ :>: 5:
"1'"1:1
r"
lr !ll
,2t1l
;.1 'OJ :z:
~t"'...:j>,
"' .
""
H~
cr::U)
"
'(>OJ
~
c
H
C
zz
>~
'C''tl
r~
~~
lI:.tIl
~~~
r-cwuw
OooQ
0000
00,00
..................
LJ1l,1l<.-nl,1l
........,.....
'-J IV N N
....... !.>-'....
0"11.1'I\001)
W
o
W
I-' ',( co " m
.... 'J' C Cf ,...
(J r;
o
" H
o
"
n n
o ,~ H
t" ~. ...;
~ :1 +<
t'l ); 0
~ ::- '>:l
"
~ "
!:'l -~
m -.
t" 7'
"'
~
~
~
Hm
:>1l/.l
"
r ~
"
~
"
~
c
;;~
Q
r
~ ~
... ~
~
[::'>'
LT: N
H'"
~~
:o<:i"'l
~I
A H
" "
" >
~'"
H
,_, 0
2=
00
u,
~=
U:.>,
~
~~
U:,U)
~
~,~~~~5~'~~
:o'CH5o H71r':l0
fSv:f::~g ~C
)0 ~ ,',
S.~113
o "';::j
~Z~rl
H'T1 ;:
C)r~::u
'"Cl trJ
~ '"
l.'l (0
00
p
~ ~
" r
~
c>
~
r-'tIl
~o
"
"-, H
:J;:)>I
C "'l
~ H
;:: 0
e=
"
o
" .,
N
~
~
:r-')o
[rig
t>J ;;
~- 'l;I
'T1::;: ;T:"
v, ~
~ tIil
zo:'::
< ~ ~
~ '" -
~
~
H
;;1
"
~
>
'>:lG;t"'
~
o
"
H
~
>
~
~
'"
~
..
~
o
o
~
~
!;:
~
H
~
o
=
>:
H
n
>0
(J;~
(Fe'"
00
G~
t"'>'o-l
g! ~ ij
~~z
=
>
n
"
~
00
.,
t(lt"'
~ H
~ ~
'"
~
a:
~~
;3H
W
~
~ ~ ~
-,'::>;:: 7'
trl...:J
~ C
:;,;:tl3J
e::~~
lim :J:
~SQg
15~O~
2; G":I "J 8
::t'ttJo':!:
mH3:"d
(1j~~i!:
"1 ~ ~
" ;; SJ
'tl' Al ~
f;;~~
tr.Io&l
~ (,
~
C~C~C'II
tfJUl rJ_'tI.l rJJ I.
tJ 0 tJ t::l t:1 i ,I
~
~
~
N
~
~
'1;:1:"
~
'H~
I
~
~ ""
tv C
~ .,
~
0"
o <f\
o
p
~
"
~,
I
...
!~'~:
~';!l
]fell
i
I
1
i~-'-
)-;r~;]r g'
i--"<l"P ::l
})jrr, f2: ;0;-
, " X
~~
.
,
n z
o .
" ~
'C ~
. .
" .
"
o
o
~
"
~
o
o
o
,
,
,
,
"
.o~
~~=
" ~ ~
0>
~.
~
~
~
~
~ ~
~ e
w ~
~ "
~ ".
~
W '"
".
e-
,
0-
W
.
"
~
,
c
,
,
~ q ,
. . ,
~ . ,
rn , "
,
.
c
c
~ ~ C
" ,
c
< .
~ "
z
~ ...
'""' ~ ..oJ ..oJ
0\ 010 o;r,G '"
6;g~~;g6~
01,'010,0\0,0'1
(D ""..'1"'v-'1>,l
~ ~
, ~
c ~
o
.,,.,,,,
o
~
~., C.
'D ~
00
'flU!
" ~
~
" ~
,- ~
CO
CC ~
~ ~
, ~
7,00
''':J\I'>
~, 0
,nU1
~~ ....
, ~
C.O,
~ ~
CO
lTI'"
,,,.1\.)
~
C ~
~~
CO
~~ U1
~O
...,. ,_, -.J ...,. -..l -..J ~ --..J ~ _J"'"
(1'< '" 0, Ch 0 '" 0' Ol a- 0\ 0\ Ol 0', '"
~.:g6:g"~6~2'~~::g~:g
~:,,"~~::.l.~.t.~~~~~
~
C' ~
" ~
00
ww
Lr,....
_, ....:a
0, ~
~~
CO
w W
W~
~ ~
(1-,o;r,
"~
DO
w W
~O
:~'!UI:!
0, ~ t;-; ;;;;~'~,Ii)'" 1
c :g ~ :g ~ ~1 t!~
t-..\I>,l IVI>,l tv '
WlXl--:a.U1
i
.Imrrmmmfm~mmmummllilm II
~~~~~~~~~-~~~~~~~-~~~-~-~~'~~~~'~-~-~-~-~'~~~~-'I'
~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~~~~~-~-~-~-~~~-~~~-~-~~~-~-I '
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~, I
.~"',,"~.t.~.l....~....t."'~,""~""~,"'''"'''.l.'''~~.'''''"'''.'''.t.'''.'''.'''.'''.l.'''.'''~' I
"""""-,-,,,--,-,-,-,-,-,-,--,-,,-~,_,_,_I
NN~WNW~WNNI>,l~Nr-v~t-..Nr-vN~NNNWN~NIJl'\.)MNWNWNWNNNr-vN~NN:
ooo~ooooooooocooooocooooooooooocoooooooooooo!
oooooooooooc,ooooooocooooooooooooooOOOOOOODOO~ '
~ ~ ~ -J: -J ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ -J ~ ~ : ~ ~ ~ ~ -c ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ -~ ~ -J ~ -J : ~ ~ -J ~ ~ ~ ~ ~-: ~ ~-~-~-t I'
~~~~~~~B~~~g~~~0~g~g~~~~~@~@~0~~~ ~~~~~~~g~@lli
"-~'~'" . ---,-I
"
c
~
~
N
o
o
~
~
~
~
o 0 ~
.... r 0 _ 0-,
tv ~.... 0
~
~
M
o
~
o
~ ~
H ~ A':;;
C" ~ C: C"
m ~
~ 0 ~
C
~ 5 =. ~
r. , ;j e, ii
3:; :;:;d :>:';>;
tr.I'C
'"
c
~ ""
~,
to< (f.
Z .r;
> -
~
~
~
~
~
~
T'l:!
>
.
~
~
~
~
~
'"
H
~ "
n C
o.
~
~
:!.."
~
~
~, ~ 5::
= ~
:::< r
~ (') CD
~. 0 (I,
:r:3:
(.';'l:!
1: c'
0';;
>
~
~
~
'"
~
~
H
~
H
"
'0
~
o
o
... - '-"
o 0
~
~
o
rJ,O
C C
~ - 5
H r-..;
n
~ ~
!/) ~, f;;
;; ~. ~
.., ,.
C" :r-. H
><: "::;(J
;;cs2
.., 0
~ ::-- ~ ~ H
U'l r--~;; ?5
'>;ltt:1-3
e< [(, H ;S
;j ~
~ f,;
~ '"
,.
~
~
.,
"
~
~
~
c
~
~
~
,., c.c'.... 0
0:' .l. .... C' 0
Co
C
~ ~
H
~
~>
,,;j
o
.,
~;g
j~
'"
~
"
~
~
1;
'"
>
.
; g V
H
";:1-3[')
m ~
T:O'::'''D
~ ,.
~l'~~ =
~ t" 7: S r:-: ~
(f] =:r> (I) ~ C"
>orn '-'li':I
El ~ ~ t.. '"
:t tr::l H '"l'
i~~""~~C"
"D 'tI~>~
C" t"nr-<
li':I ~~lI'l
tI:l Ill;:: t':l
~~~
~n
~o
Cl<
" ~
oS
~
~
~
w
~
~
H
~
H
~
~
~
1,1; :;J',W
~ ~ ~
~ w
~
H
w
N
.... 0::' '"
'"" C <;0 :::. l,()
N
~
wa.... "" '-t_ ...
w 0 a ~ _ 0:' 0
1,1; ~. .... ~ 1,1; C W Q
~ ~
~ ~ ~
. H
0, ,~. 0:' ~
C Lr..... c: Lr.
c
o
H
C
o
c
- ~
, tr
- H
~
~
~
~~
~ "
~: ;.:
8 Z 8
'" 0 ... t"'
c. 0 ~ t1
~ ~ !- ~
>
::0 :- P
..' :<'
.J:t' ..;
~ s ~p l;l;I
,,~~
t<l .~ I.;
T"~"
I"J :l>t":l
:S-:"C1 ,--'
~J ~ 8
,,~ :i ~ ~
rn ([' I:"' r:'
Fi:' H 9-,.. .;-
<: ~ <; )1 iJ
r~ ~ ['J
ID ~ ~
);1-3;r;;: 2:
'D'tl' Cl ~
in ~ ~ i<l
'-iJP! trl
. -
'" ~ ~
" ~
~
" ,.
~ ~
~
-:-,G']
"":>1
- H
o~
~
-~
=- 5
z ~
~
~
:::: 0
mttl
>
c =
;r)-
, ~
)'.g
'"
0"'0
,0
'"
,.
~
~ n
o
i, ~
trJm
.
g~
oj ~
~
~,.
tIC n
"r"J
G-,O
~G
~ ~ ;;J
~ 0
~ ~ :~
~
>l'
G
~
,:-<t"
~~
~ il
, ~
'"
lfj :;
cr:;'tl
X~
<'"
~ID
~ '"
rr:"Il:<< :r;'tI
:'J t" .~ "l :0
~t"~71
~ fJ
~~
;;;'
c
'013: r;
," 0 ,-!:,
H
= "
p;j <
'"
H
>
c
o
w
o
~ -
C
PJ rr:
~
~
o
,
"
~~~~
PJ ....,:0
n ~
~i ::c
, H rr: i:;
j ~ 7 ~
~~~~
[f] 1-1 n
~ '"
(4vtn
2
;;~
~ 'C
~ ~ >
~~;;
> ~
~
z
n"l
~
-c:' 1:1:: ~
t"' ~- t"'
'= g ;. s "
H H
;, ~ ~
"
'"
>
;,-;~
t'1~
~ l1;I ~ g Z
>-' 0 >-~.
'~~ ..00
:2:: I-:i.:j
~
'-"f;jlf~c-
He
~ e:
.
'" ,~
H
r') ~ ,..,;
..
c. ~
~ to3 ~
"H
3:1t<:l UJ
" .
'" ~
::::"1
~
li;S
" ~
"
~;
[J,'t!
" ~
e '"
:t>tr.I
~'"
~t"'
F,
'J;
~
'"
~
w
c
c
~
" ~ ::;
"'iI '"
!I
'i,,:;.r:g ~
~-'n 'tl t:I
f1 o'll" ~
n z
o .
, ~
~ ~
. ,
, .
'<
'I
liE
.
"
o
o
~
,
)> 0 ":
'"___0':;:
~ ~ .
c>
~~
H
,
~
~
H .
H >'
H ~
~ "
~ ,.
~
W ~
,.
"
"
~
"
,
,
~
"Cl C r
, . >
LQ (IJ ,_
, " H
"
"
C
C
o
,., ~
" ~
g ~
z ~
~ ~
'" ""',Cl'l
\0 ,"'\0
>-' >-'
>-' >-'
W 0
o,J --.; o,J ~ -..l
0',(1\ C' O'l 0",'"
\{ \0 'L \D \C \0
.... 1-'........
COOOOO
I.L'D:I-JO'Ilt....
c ~
~~
,~
-">-'
00
~W
,~
a, ~
~~
~~
00
~o
~
a ~
O~
00
O~
", ~
,~
a~
a~
00
O~
,~
-, ~
c, ~
", ~
00
~~
c W
, ~
m~
", ~
00
a~
L'-,"'"
,~
O~
~~
00
~~
~o
, ~
a, ~
O~
00
a~
a~
-J-..1
:-,C'I
a~
00
a~
,~
,~
a~
a~
00
m~
L".
-.:...,)
0',0'>
a~
Co, 0
a~
',~' w
,~
mQl
a~
co
W~
~o
,~
a, ~
a~
00
,~
"_,CO
-J-..l
C-.C'I
~~
:::>0
, ~
,"'
~:,;:-dfi~-~-- il" "rf-r:i.-T-~.~ tll--:
;; ~ ;t~/~nrl ;:-I~:,g', cg..::g g
w'" \,() \D \D IF r"j,q:: le,cr,;.:;:;>l'
000 CI 0 ";'-~:1'1(~>.1, ,,,,
...J -.,J -.J ...:I 0'\ ~; '.'-. 0 ~
~W_O~! I.t~
I
,~
m~
\[JlD
00
-, ~
c' ~
~~NWNWWW~N~WNNWWNNNNNWWWNWNWNWWWNNNWNNWWNNNW I
O~OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOODOOOOOOOOOOI
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
OOOCO 00000000000000000000000000000000000000
....~........I-' ....~....~....~........I-'....I-'............I-'~........I-'....I-'............I-'....I-'....I-'....I-'....I-'....I-'........~
:~:~:~~~:~:~~~:~:~:~:~~~:~:~:~:~:~:~:~:~:~:~ I
W~~~~~W~WW~wWWWWWWWWWWWWW~WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW
~ ~~~n.~.~.~.~.W~~W~WWWWW~WN~NWN~N~_~~~~~ ~
~~W~~o~~~m~~N~O~~~~~. ~~O~~ ~~.~N~O~OO~~~.W~
~.... >-, I-' - I-' ~ ....-~, I-' >--' I-' >--' I-' ~ ....-",:--;::;-::,~~"-.:-';:-~,:::--;:- >- I-' >- I-' 1-.... -," I-' ,. ~:7~-t1~1 '
....>--'I-'-....-I-'~....-I-'-I-'-I-'-....~....-I-'-I-'-....~I-'>--'....-....-....>--'....-I-'-I-'-....-....- I
'~".,~"'-,-,~-"-,-"""---,---,--,-'-'--'I ,
~;~~=~~~~~~~~~~~~~~:~~=~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~=~:~I
,-""'-,-,--~-"'--,-""'-,-"---,--,-,---
W~)~~N~~~~~WNNWU~NN~NNNNNNNNNN~~NNNNNNN>>NN~~N
O~OCC O~OOOOOOOOOCOCOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOoO
onOOOOOOOooooooaOOOOOCOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCOOQO
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~ ~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~I
~ '" ~ ~ ~ .~ ~. ~~ ~_~: ~ ~:~ ~:_g ~ ~ ~ :! ~ !_~ ~ ~ ~ @:_8 ~ ~ ~ 8: g ~ : ~~J II
'>-'
"'
~
"'
~
~
~
o.
~
(r...., '" I-' ~.
N -.J~, I-' C.
<.D lo.: --J ~ '_' t..'
lot> ,. 1.> 0\ ~
~
~
~
~
"' W
>10 r~' 0
~ g ~., 8
;.. :On E ' r-'
~ ti~~
n:C:w
o :, l'"3 '"
H H 00
t"'~g~g~,~
n ~ S. S " t';l
~'~.s~~~E
~S~~;~G'J~
t'J 1"' = 1-1 I
W:"')<[IJt"'trI
'tl (f, ~ rfJ
"'l C't"' H
I:' Z P:l 1-1
vtrJn~~
~
~ g
:;1 ~
>00
g
~
;;;
'"
,.
::"1
s
~
"
~
~ 0 H
lo.: 'f. ~
..., Ul::
~ ~
>-' ~
,~ "" >-- o..l I-'
.... \J;.' W cr.' '" W
l.1l ..., .J' W 4- ..., c:
r <::> 0 0
o OC W <n <.D
, .
~ f::
:J:'t>i]
~
00
,. <
pe.
.0.
o
:rc:P,
?:'tr
~'<
:lE;~
;Y> ~ :~.
$ R =
~
L-, ~~
::' ~ ~
~ ~ ~
::2:::: :;::J
~~,
~
:;;
~
~
C ~
~(1
;~
S'"
~z
~=
.
" ~
~
~M
~1J;I
g
~~
~~
H~
Z.
(;J (1
n
u.
~ ~
;1>'><: '-/)
r.JJtll o-J
{J)~tTJ
g:! ~
~~
~ ~ :
~~~
c S ~n
~ ~
s ~ r:-'
~.
c
M
"'
'"
"
<"
-P'
no
'" 0
,..
<
,---:' 0
".
:;f;'
~o.
~
'".
en "'
n
'tJ CD
~ "
~
"
~ ~
. ~
n
~
.
'"
~
~~
~
~
>-'
,
>-'
w
,
w
o
o
~
It" ~; ~
.;: r:: 0
H rr:: 0
~ ,-
, ,-
R '~
H _
~ ;;' ~
gCI:
'ot!
J..4I:tH
~ "~
<"
-0
n~
n
'"
~M
~~
i~
gt'l
=
",.
~~
"
M
00
~
~
~ '" -.:
o ~, '" '.~ ....
f-' ~ -.) '"
O(lOCO,(tl W
o ~'f-' 0 ~ c ....
~~~~~.~
;; ~ :1>: ~ ~
~. a v' Vol
~ ~ 3
::J1t>
m
?:; ~
;;0
M
~-
M~
<~
'"
7-' 'U
Cj"
~~
CJIOl
'"~
lfJt7J
H
S~
o-J ~
>-~ t"'
~~~
_H M
~~;:;'U
00 ::d
CGH
~gj ~
z ()
Sii'~~~~~
UJ H ;c 'tl
'tJO n
L' el- >' >:" ~
S' H 3S ~ ~ t"' :P 'I'J
~~o~~~i2~
L';:>t":Logtr.l
~~~S~~~~
~&;~~~~f,.i
!Jj (j] I::l n t>i]
'aJ<>>'::d
~t"~o;:{J)~
:~::d~~~
~ .,
~
~'"
~M
:J
...
n
~
M
" "
~ "
o h
H"
liUJ
;S ~
. "
" ,.
C.
>-'
o
o
C tv ,-,-' ~ t,'
...;l""....cC"
~-" '" ': \<l
H
~ ~~
ILl "-', W I.D'" V" 0 ....
U1 o..lC,O, ::-'00 '-"'"
,.. < f-' --:;:, o..l <2 VI k'''' '-'"
o LC" Ul In 0
0:-.' N -' 0
",-<.oc>O".Cl-o'crlJ'1
L~ 00 c.o ,:.. ~ a, 0
"=' ~ -" ~
~ ~ ~
;:C'll
O;!>>-
"
[; 8 ~ ~ ~:
tv'tl-<::e
~
~o
::>:':tl
~ I'i
~iSi'J
~~
"
H
i1
~
'"
~
"
o
~
o
~
"
.. H
~=
'DO
1J.t7J
. "
", ~
,-
'"
~
"
>0
'; ~
'""
.~
H~
gj~~~","~
;>:JH;l>'tIlCll"
;:iO:;::J 'tl
n::lr.c~52f;;
[fJo-i~O;'Str.I
:j~~:i~~
:;:llJtIltf.l
'UP UJI-i "rJ
~ ~
~
~r<
~~
,'ll"
~
'"
!:)
"
'"
.
~
(000
"r1::c
t<:'tI:l
r.-::e
G:Z
...-; H
=
~:t:
[;';~
~~
"...
-.
z=
o-JtI:I
VJtrl
" n
'.-,::c
>-=o:c
o-J:r>'
w
"
;"'" ~
'"
.
~
~
:::53:
mH
~~
o
::DH
;:>:2:
..,,,
('~.! '>:l
Z"i
5'~
~'"
~~
'"'"
'1) Z
:;;l ~
~
[fJ
e,c c'
~C
;::: b
.' ~
~ ~
~H
=
~"
"
?S
T
"'
"
~
~
~
~
"'0
"''1
~.~
~~
<~
~~
u'
~
~
o
~. g
~
"
Z~
L,O
0:;'::
~~
ii'
f'i
OJ
'"
,,-'
'C>tl' '1;;
~gn
c,
,.
i,
c,
~
t"<
'"
(J)
;'l
I
'"".,----------~
, ~
x~
_ 0
.....:;:: <:
en
..,"'-
;;00 M
o-,C::;oc
R"HIJ:;~
;J>m~~~
if,O H A'
~.~~~><
(-;t"'
M "'
:r:-I1ilO
~~~
~~ t'< :r.
~.
.,
Uo
..,
~
.;
t
~
~
m
2
0-)
~
~
C'
:;s
~
G
u
j;
~
~
'1.1,
i i
"_~_I~j_~I_
("J ::;0:
o . 0
51"-' III
" ~ "
. 0 0
" .
'< 0
H
o
o c
~ 0
o "
o
~ H
o '<
o
o C
o
~
~O"
~~;
o.
~"
~
,
~
~
~ "
~ ~
H ~
m H
w ~
~
H "
~
~
"
0.
W
.
"
~
c
o
o
o
,
,
~
"
"
c
"
" C "
.0"
",0'
, " "
,
"
"
c
c
~ c
~ '
" .
H "
Z
~ ~
~
m
~ "
...
~
m
~ ~
." C''\
~ '..c
... ~
U: 111 lr
,-"oJ>\.>.
~ "', tv '.' N
00000
00000
00000
'"" ....>--'1-'
11I U; l1I iJ'l1I
......' .,..4....
... .... u..; W
0'-<)\0\,["-1<:1
0'.1:00"''''
~ ~
m m
ID ~ >c
... ~ ...
m m
~ 0
~
o
CO
00
...
,~~ lJ!
" ~
w...
" ~
~ ~
....l _ ~
Q,O'oC-,C1\
...:-,\C\[..o -.-
...-...
.........01>...
"- 0:> '" CI'\ J
",,!t..)
00
00
C' 0
...
,0 m
.~
c' ...
~~
w ~
~ - ~
mc" ."",
'" \O'~
I-'f-'!-'
~"~
.. '.-.' tv
"" w t-: N 1'0.;. '"
CQCOCO
00 OCO
oaoooo
f-' 1-'>--....
l.~ Ul cf' U1 IT UI
~...........r. "'"
"".....wWeuW
<.t'..o moo Cl'CXl
I:) 1.(' CD ~ '"
~
m
~
...
~
I:) "-,
~ ~ ~
." G', CI'\ ~, '" c-
~"~;:: ~ '-1'
...,.~W W
Q) -..J0'l "'l'-'
~ ~
o 0
000
__ 0 C 0
...-...
l1Icnl1l
............
~:;:~~
~ ~
"-'. N
00
00
~. 0
-...
L'",l1I
,4 ~
. ...
om
-0
~
m
~ "
...
w _
~
~
m
~"
...
w
0''''
~ ~ ~
O'IC\O"-
\Ocr'\D
... ~ ...
tv h W
m m
~
m
'..c'o.c
...
" ~
'-'01>
[,_, w
00
00
00
...
CO m
. ~
w...
~~
" m
'" N
o
00
00
...
Lnl)!
.~
w'"
,~
,m
,,~
00
co
c <=>
- ...
" m
. ~
w...
"~
~ ~
"-', N
00
00
o <=>
-...
tP.l1I
.~
WW
~~
W~
,~
co
00
00
...
cc m
.. ~
c..;w
~~
~O
w "-' tv
o Q co
000
cooo
... ...
tnUllJ'l1I
.1>........
WWU.-W
0>0\"''''
'" 00-''''
- "
m
c' ~
...
c ~
~
'01'1 :n
c' ~ r ~!(~~:;'~:';: 1 " [~
If \C \.f \D ,", \C '.J:) - 11:- 11
>-'::;' f-- ~ f-::;' f--' r"
ll'.l;ll-.;CI\.,"....
,_]-4
cr-,,,",
" ~
-...
~~. w
_0
,~
00
C.Q
00
-...
l.nUl
"~
. W
~m
", ~
"-' w
co
00
00
~...
~m
"~
WW
o m
w~
;;:1;
,,~
00
o
o
...
,. m
.~
wW
" m
o
"-' N "-'
CO
coo
co <:>
f- I-' -'
" m
,,_ 11>...
W..., l.-'
iJ'l1I'Y
\JJ CD _,
I-' I-'f-I-'f-...f-...f-I-'f-....f-...f-I-'~I-'~....f-I-' ........1-'....1-'>--1-' I-'f-I-'f-I-'f-I-'f-I-'~I-'
I-'f-I-'f-I-'f-I-'f-I-'f-I-'f-I-'f-"'~I-'_I-'f-I-'f-I-'f-I-'~I-'f-I-'f-I-'f-I-'f-~~~~~~~~~
""""""""""""""""""",-""
~-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
.~.~.~.A~~.A.~.A~~.A.~.~.~.~.~.~.~.~.~.~.~.~
"""",--"",-",-,--""-"""-",,,,,-
W~N~W~~~~~U~N~~~~~~~~~~~W~N~N~~~W~N~W~.N~N~N~
000 0 0000000 ccooo~ooocOoooooooooooooooocoo
000 ocOoo~ooo_ooocooooooococooocooooooooocoo
~~~~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
,~0~E~@~~g~ffiv~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ffi~~~ffi~~~g~g~~~g~~~
Uvu_,C'_~~~_OOCO~~~COO~O~OCOOOCLC~COCOCOCC~LCO
I
1------.-----.----
i
...
o
~
~
o
o
o
co
~
~
re
o
~ ,.. ~
; ~:tciii
o :r> ~ ~
H - ::tl
~ ;( ::<: -
,. "
~
,_ Ii ~.
o H ~
pj~Q~~
i;j ~'8 :00 ~
.... -,tfj
o U:' H
2: 2 t" ~ ~
tJl ~-,
~
m ,.
~
Ii :;
tIl ?:1
'"
H [:J
~ j
H !.n
= ~
"
~
n"
,. ~
"
~
'F!
'"
~
~
~
H 0
~ " 0
..., .J, <;>
o c 0
o 0
~
C>
~
C
~ = :! t ~
tJl (i ::tl
o
;; g: Z
r~
,..
00
00
"
"
~ ,-
~
>
= ~
,C' >-
o
- "
"
':'Q_X
t::tl 0
~ ~ ~
- ~
;;~
"
'-''C'
'" ~
00 r
...
~
"
~
o
~
H
~
"
~
~
o
~
~
00
."
'"
~
Z
00
~
~
~
00
H
m
o
0:> a c> C 0
or.o <;>
"
i:- '='
r:-:t':l
~
; ~
n
'" ,.
'"
~
:":l::
"
r~_ C"l. "";
ro-:toj
00
~ 00
~ !!:
- ~
~ ~ ~
~ 0 C'
'I> Q X
~tQ~
"tl !.~: l"l
~ 't: ~ g
:; "'3 t" I-l
n ~ j
~~. 0 00_
v. ~ Z ~
~ ~::;
~ '"
~ rJ ~
o
"
~j ~
00
,..
~
= ~
~
,..
'"
- '"
'"
c."
"
Z :!:
~ .
~ ."
):.t"
~
~ 00
~ '"
~
;;:,J'>
'"
'"
o N
" ~
o c' cr,
~
~
o
o
~
~
~
H
~g
,t'Q
-'"
-~
C ,..
:~ ;
~
~
~ ~
o ~
o,;r '-;'t'J
~ ~
...
=
::::0
~ 8
'"
~
~ 0
:xl'::, tll
00 _ '"
C ,..
~ cC.. t:;I
~ "
~:'j
o
~
m
~
m
o
~ " ~
"
'"
00
o
o
~
w
o
N
m
~,
...
...
~
1-'_10 <.n
~~.... w
ol- G_' C lr W
~
c ~ ~ C ~ ~ W rr 0
o c ~ rn <.n - ~ 0
t;:rr;g
~?< ~ 0
~ " ~
~~ Q
= ~ ."
; ~
~
;;:; g
n
~ .
(00
C
"
,..
"'"
.:;iil
:'U=
~n
"
~:'j
::?mr%:
. ~
~
'"
~
00
r-:
~
~~
,:. ~
Zt"
to
,.
~ ~ 11:
rr: tll d
- >< ~- J-;
Il e:o- n
'[0 S ~
:r g;: ~ Pl
~
";"t/:l >'
~ .
~ "
~ ~ t tJ:l
t".::oqtr:
c "
if;
=
~ .
~'"
...
.
.
,..
q
C' ,..
=~"J~
,. ~
~. ~ ~
"
-JI-I
~ ~ ~
~
"
~
t"' ~ m I',
Pl M
~~:.s
'-t C
~ ~ :~
l~ " i
~~9
d~
~
f;:; M
I:J;l '-;1
~
. n ~ Ii
~ 0 ,; :t:
1!i :t..,li
~ H
:,.,~~~~-=
l" t"'
"
t"' ~' 0
~~ f;;
!::()n~
,.. 0 tD
r- ~ ~;:
~~'"
:i-~:?;:~
Otll
o ~
'>iltTJ"O'..-
t" it:
u.
,..
~
'"
,.
II
H
"
~
8
...
t'
H
~
~
~
- ~
~
'"
00
00
~
W (f' t>J
W ~
<
...
. n
t ~
G',t'il
~
H
Et:f,;
o
~ =
~ 2:
[j ~:r;
g;f.J~
Ul [tj
~~w
~
r
m
~
... IV ...,
... ~ w (' tv
W 0 r-' W
H N
c>,r.c.
o :::. ~
::::~~5;;Q~
::l:l [T < tlj r"
:."} >' to;] 0'
;. >< ~ ~ " t"' ~
t, H
00
~ ~
" "
~
'"
~
~ I-l ;;lC
t" "j,
~ "
>'trJ ::0'
=H
,~t'1 if;
~
~ :;:;
'"
frl ir
u;
~
~
n
o
. r
~ ,..
o =
~ H
..;ES;
H C
02::
=;<@
" "
~>[1
~ <;j
~ 'r ~ g
~oo ~
'C'Ul
~ ::>
Io<l':::'H
,,~
"
~
~
~
~
jJ
;ci ~
>:: i'1 ~j
"
o'T;
~ ~ ;;
:-n~
1.1'.' 0
y;.:::: ['C
~ .~
~ "
~ ~
~ j
~
'"
00
~ ,~
:J':
::>
~
:rJ
~
,-
I
I,
,1..._;
II
~
I
.~"n: tIl
,~ '~J (ll
- -n ::l ::l
1;""'rx-
, ~
~~
,
"
n"
o .
" '"
'" ~
, .
~ ~
c
o '
o ,
. ,
,
,
~O'"
:;;~;j
0'"
~ ~
H
~
~
...
~
00
m
~
w
'"
e.
~
"
'"
"
'"
e.
,
o
'"
.
o
"
,.
C
,
,.
\\';'
,~"
"j'
" C ~
. . ...
00 ,
. , H
~
,
N
o
o
~
. ~
~
~
g ;:
::; ~
~ ~
0..,"""
"" 1.(:', \D
N ~
o u., \t>
o '.c:' 0:.
,~
0',0'\
\.::J\O
,~ ~
, ~
- ~
~ ~
O. ~
~~
~
'L" \D
u'....
<, -..l
,,~
\f'''''
e' ~
, ~
.",'tv
~~
'To CJ\
,~
~ ...
\.::I\D
~O
~~
a,a.
~ ~
~~
W~
'" CO
~
m~
\.(;\D
~ ...
([',CO
-''''
,~
o. ~
" ~
~~
m ~
"' .
~' ..:I
0, ~
~~
~~
C':O m
c.-' b.>
-.J-.l-.l
0',010,
I.:JOD\.C'
~
W~
~. <=> '"-'
...!--.I...! ...:I
CII G 0. G\ (1'1
\DVJI.O\VIO
fo'f.-',.........I-'
~ ~ ~
t<> 0\1)"'....
,~
0-,0\
\D""
~...
-~
wN
-.J..:I--J-.l
:?lOlO,O\
I.D\D\D\D
...~...
0)0\0,0\
....In''''
----~:-:--=i-llIl ,~C
, ::-'~.' I,-,~. . ., 'i: . "~I;l;f o:r
.....J ....l -..) -.l LJ--..1I,",~..J .,:~:f:. I-)((l,cl,:;; P>
mOl m Q\ m'O'i 'ey'i' ..,::. '-_'fO:_': ~'fj~'::;' ~
::s ~ ~ ~ ::: ~ ~ I dF*:; l:Jr?[. X'
o. 0'\ G' 0\ if l)'l In ~I ''', Jj:"l
w tv....' 0 \.C lXI ....J I ~~
o
"
~~
0',0\
'.[;\D
"' ~
,~
e' 0
,~
o. ~
m ~
...
m~
1;::.(Xj
U~W~N~U~N~WNN~~NNNUNNNWNNNNNNNWNNN~NNNNNNNWNil
gg~gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggi i
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000; I
,...f.-',.........,.........,.........,.........,.........,.........,.........,.........~~,.........,.........,.........,...~,.........,.........,.........,.........,...~,.........,.........,.........I
~m~~l)'l~l)'l~l)'lml)'l~l)'lml)'lrnl)'lml)'lml)'lml)'lml)'lml)'lml)'lml)'lln~lnl)'lml)'lrnl)'lml)'llnl)'lm.
::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::! .1
~~.~~w~wwwwwwwW~~~~~W~N N~~~~~~~~~~ooCOCOOOOi i
.WN_OWW~~~~WN o~m~~~.wN oWW~~~.WN-OWW~~~.WN~; I
~ ~~~-~-~~~,~~~~~~~~~~ ~ ~-~~~ ~-~-~-~~~-~-~~ I'
~_~_~_~_~_~_~_~_~_~w~_~_~_~_~_~_~_~_~_~_~_~_ I
,-------,-------""--,,,-,-,-,,----,------- ,
~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~- '
~ ~:~:':~ :':~;::~ ;::~;::~ ;::~;:: ~ ;::~;::~ ;::~;::~:':~ ;::~::: ~;::~:':~ ;::~;::~::;::~;:: -:
W~N~N~NWW~N~N~~~~~U~W~N~N~U~W~U~NWNNN~N~N~NN I
g~~g~g~ggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg! ,
~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I I
C ccccCCCCCCdCdC'l'
g:~g:8g:~1l~1l~1l!S1l~1lf'i1ill:
~----:--::::::--1
,
~~~~~~g~~~~~~~ffi~~
~ ',' 0 '~ 0 0 0 ~ 0 c 0 ~ ~ c ~ 0 0
~
~
~
o
~
-
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
.
-
~
~
~
-
N ""c!:. '*" N
"" N ~ ,. ~ _ '*"
.... ",' U1 0 "0 N I""
0>-0 0
o 0\;- 0
~
~
~
d_dcc::cCCt:l
t(llf,'(.O(jJ(tJ [fj(.O [{JtlJ
0'::10 t1t:1 co t::'o
~
o
'0 I, w I-' I-'
Oc!:Ol.J..U1 01
<:> '-~ 0 U1 _ I-'
0\ c I"" ~ 0 - en ::C" I-' 0 _, \0
W'.OI tv U1C:.Lo-',O._l~
();';"'~
:x }c<>'
:>' :::- ::0
~ - n
~:=.s
g tr.I
_ i"':l r:
ttl - :x I:
o l'l:: >'
t"~x fJl
;j H"::1'tl
HZ&;~~
o r; t'" :.::; t"
z ttl~,.:j
00 e
Qtt;1
2ll-'o
Cl'Jjl1l'
~ '"
Gn
c, 0
'"
i::'Cl
"'"
C' H
~~ X 0 t':I'"
Otnt'!
~ '"
,. "'J~
g
H
"
,.
8
..
~
H
~
~ 8:;:: ;;
'~~~
:z: ~: ~
S ~
~
o
'"
~
'"
~ ~
:~ I:;:l
,-,11
H
~::l
~
~~
c'"
- ~
o
~ ~
~~ ~
.. '"
t" ;>J()
"
"
-,
,,~ ~
- ,.
t"' 'J.
~ "
t>'; ~
~ #: 2 ~
~ ~ 2 ~
'r,:>j ~ tIJ
:-rJ t"
~ .
~
:8
~~
~
-~ 0
~ ;.>' -
In!:'''
CH
~~
~
m_
~
~~
z'"
n-
~oo
~
~..
~S
~:tI
;iil-04
~
;t;>
~
~
~
~
~
~
H
n
~
'"
"
o
"
~~
". ~
n Q
crJ 0 .~. '"
~ ~ '.0
-::;:0 "'l
~g~al
~ ~
''J: 0 t" 0
""tIJ:O
~ ;p,.:j
...,"o:l{f.'t/:l
-~-
~.. ~ gj
-J ~ '0
> :5 '~~
~ pj '...J 0
:a::-,r<
00
l>'J If, ~
" " ~
H
~
~
Zr.!
~', c:
_ro
~
o
~~
-,
(/H
~;:5
~ '" "
~ It! ~ ~
~m
;:~~:
H2;:l1l'
~~>'
~[{JH
~ ~
l'
~
'"
~
00
'1:';.>' m:::"drr:
G ~ .:- )0 L:ri r
L' ~ (. ~ r: ~ IT'
~ .... ~....- H
~'-T~~@~
__>i-< c.,....,
;; !i
:1> H ;i:
~~~
~,) ~ j
o
z
g~~
ro " M
n 0 {f,
~o
~
~tj
'n
<
o ~
" ~
0.
"
0.
'"
~ g ~
00
!":i::5
~Z
n
~~
~
~
om
z...
"
~ ~ ~
"','"
~ ..
(OJ In 1:<:1 (lJ
UJ'T1~""
"00
~ ~ ~ ~
G~
i))lj;l,(J
"
w
~
"
C
~
~
r~
..
r ~
.,
"'
,-'
"
~
~;.
c'
;:?:'8
III .-,:.1:
>: cc;.. H
'"
" 0
~ . 00
g ~ >t!
() ...., H
o - "
~"
Z>'
0"
"' ,.
~'"
~
UJt>;l
.._<n
~ ~
c..
~
o
>
~
>
X
'tl r:
H
~ R-' %:
H ~ 0
~~'g,
m .
"C -< III
fg--2
g ~
~ ;S
'" ~
w
o ~
0" 0
z
"'
~
~
~
7.
"'
0,
~
.
~
~
w
.
N
~ .... ... w c;, .... '"-' .....
~ ---.J \1l.!'- \0 .,-r-, W I-' '.: \0 \.oJ ---.J ."_
o 0 ~ 0 ~ I-' 01 O. .... t. ..... a W
C<t '.r' 0 C' 0 c;. U'l
\0 0 Cl: .c:. 0/>.
0/>. c' 0 ,". ~
t.l> ;-. ,L. (. ~
T~ iJ
'F.:a C' 0
qq
;,~ ~. ;d
';>:1() ()
~j 0 ~ H
=: ~~; f:
~~
lpj~~
tr.l "pj
J~~<pj~~
-< "j..(
~3 :;
~
~ n ,_ t'" .;:" ii c:;- ::: CJ --;;:-;;-;;-;;- "" ~
~ ~ 5 ; g wI 5; ~ ~ 2 ~ ~ b ~
~g,",u.7:tr.I P"J ~~'~'"'~'~;
~,~~~ l::~~.o~;;-'t:lC~~
~;t" :o:.'Rv,o a )>0 '.~;;3:
@E2~~~t~~~E~'~::
~.. l:: :"'. ~ ~ == 'J ~, 'J: XI
>-<f.?~.;a>~~~'t,~ tn51
[['O-q;':3~c.J.....;::: 2:'tlo~
~.g2 l>;l trJ l>'J L';: 50> ~"C
e;s.t';'t"1~ : ~~~
~~~ " m c., ~j~g
o It.I :I:: I~
o ~
c '"
" 0
..
~~
p,.
~~
~~
~::t
~H
Ok
Z H
~'"
Q
"
o
'"
'"
n
~
00
~
~
"n
~H
c' ,.
c, ~
,cH
00
, ~
o "
s~ >
~~
~.., :i
r ,.
~
~
e
~
~
:'l~
"~;=:;
);:f;;;
~oo
~
M~
~J t"
H ~ ;';
~
~
!j
,
~
'"
"
<C,
~
,
r
"
"
r
"
lC
~
'-'
D
o
,
~
o
r
~
~ .
~ ,
~ '
,~
-'_.~-
II
n z tI
o . 0
.s'g,~
. . p
" .
~ ,
o
o C
0. 0
. ,
,
~ 0
o ~
o
o C
o
.
~
,. 0 ..
~~'"
~ ~ ~
0"
~ ~
~
-
~
~ .
~ e.
~ ~
~ 0
~ "
~
~ ~
"
".
"
0.
~
.
"
"
,
c
"
n
C'
"
~ c ~
. " ~
<0 0 _
. " ~
~
~
~
c
o
lJl ~ ~
"
< .
H ~
'"
" ~
z ~
-..l ..J-J..:!
mO"C7\O\<:J\
\O\L'..o'-.[,,,,
N k' t.3' L\""
,r... ..."-'''''
.... (.,.!oJ 0
'" ""~ N
o oeo
00000
oeo 0
....,...l-'f_....
U'llJiUllTVl
,r... ..."-'...
..."'"""~..
0:> we>> <LCll
\DCD-.lC'Ul
, ~
0-,(7)
w~
'''' to.)
~w
" ~
~~, to.>
00
00
00
"",
U"Ul
..
...
ro~
.W
-.'I --J -.l -o.J
"" 'I' '" 0\ (f1 e, 01
C,j.\,D'-"lD\f. '" ,-"I<)
I"; W I,,) to.> t>-.' Io..l ~ W
..... ....""W ....
0'1 u,.... W N e>
" ~
CO
CO
00
"",
~~
...
..
X ~
r-..;.I-'
~ w
00
00
00
"",
ro~
..
. .
rn ~
C~
ffi~.,~53~i7gv;g~~~.~
o _ t:I t; ~ :::; t:I t:' t:l _ t:l _
~
~
00
ro
<:r,C:- ....
~ 0
.
.
w
~
:r --: ~
:: :;j
r.; , S
;; ~ ;po
n
_ c
~ ~
<"---': H
tr :~ ~
:: 11 ~ <::
n ~ ~ [!J
"
n ~
I;"' >._
~~~;:tIl
~~{h:~
" ~Bt"
o
n
~>
"
~' t"
2S
~
c::'
" ~
() :.
o
~ ~
-
"
IE
,.
iF
,.
\0 0 S', 0
t-> _ 0 0
~
o
. -
..
~
~ ~
\.o.lt.'\O
0-' Vl
~ - ~
0:..: >' .-c:
t" ~ ~ ;..
~ ~ ["J Pil
lJ_' _ C'.I
~
'00
" ~ -
~
l:" ~
-
N ~
00
00
00
~ ",
ro~
. ..
...
~~
~ ~
,,~
DO
00
DO
-",
~~
...
...
~~
~~
~~
(I'. ~
,,,'\D
N. ~
N~
~ ~
N'"
00
00
00
"",
ro~
"~ ...
. .
,~
. w
-o.J-.J..J -.'I
,::1,<110,(0),,,<11
~lD'-0\Q""lD
Ut>,ltvNWN
'..J ~ ", "'!0'"
-.J!;J\ 'P II> N
N~
CO
00
DO
~",
rn~
..
..
, ~
r-..;,I-'
N,..
DO
CO
DO
-",
"~
..
...
,~
O~
, ~
8',!;J\
.L ~
l_.J N
I,; N
_0
'cw
00
DO
DO
~",
"~
...
...
O~
m ~
10--' N Iv W "-' N
00000=
COCO CO
CODOCO
1-'1-'>-'.......1-'
lJ1l11\r.UllrUl
.t....,to.....,:o. ..
......"'"......
o-,!;J\ m Q'l 0-, Q'\
lJ1 ~ "-' N _, 0
N ~
l",!;J\
" ~
,. "
~",
N ~
~
o. ~
., ~
u...,
",
~~
, ~
o ~
~
N ...
~
c.
., ~
cr. ~
" ~
N"
~~
W~
~
cr ~
"_L lD
N,..
c",
~O
,_.~,......c
-l -l _, -.l ~"-.4:,
0',0\ m '" 0\ Cl'I ,")', ,,",'
<,["lD'i'lD\fJlD,.',\D
"-'l>Jtvl>Jl-.:I>J"-lW
00 OCOOO
lQ CQ <11 U' ~ w t,)
f..-' ..., r-..;
::0 00
c' CO 0
000
~",~
LnUllJ'
..~
"'". "'"
lnVllJ1
VloJ> w
I>J ,-' W
000
000
oeo
~~~
Ul,rlJl
.".
...
11l L,~ UI
,.. 0
,. w
00
CO
00
~",
~" Ul
..
~~
. ..
~ ~
I
::; ... ~ ... ::: :::; ;:: :=; ~ ~ ::;-~ ::: -2~-: ~ ~ ~ ... ::: :=: ::: f- ::: :::; ::: :::;::: :::::::::: ::: ... ::: r-" ::: "2 ::: :: :;-:: i I~...'
",-,----,-"-"-------,-,-,-'._--------,,,,,
~...~...~~~>_'~~I_'~~~~~~I_'~...~f_~>_'~,...~~I_'~~...~...~-I_'H~~~...~-
~~.~.~.~.~.~.~.A."'".~.~.A.A."'".A."'"."'".~.~..."'".~.A
--------------------------------------------
1>J~~NI>J~~NI>J~WWI>JW...,WWt_.JI>JNWWI>JWNWN~~~I>J~~MI>J'_I>J~I>J~'W~NW
0000000000000000000000000000e>000000000000800
OOODODOOODOCOCODO~OOOCOCOOOCODOCOOOCOCODOCOD
-l ..J~-.l-l-.l-l-.l-l-.'l -.l-.J-l-l-l-l-.'l-.J-l -l-l-l-l--J-l..J-l..J-l-l -l~-l-l-l-l-l ..J-J
-...-----
I'
k' W '" I>J
DODO
CODO
0000
>-'1-'>-'....
l~ Ul l~ UI
""....""..
""..........
l.I'lIllflJl
'"-, CO -l 0\
~~~~~~g~;~re~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~0~~_~.@~
t:l~OC"vOCO"O~OCO t:lDO~OD~~C~O'_~c-v~'
~
~
~
f-' ~ J.. I-'
.... e'" C1 c: 0
:::j(':l
~~
;;~
~
;;8
T
r~
[IJt"
~
z: :::..'tl
H A' 0
H ~:3
O~):I
r H
"" ~
~
; ~ 0
.-j w ~
;::: Q x ~ -
~~]~
~ ~
-~
~
r
" ~
~tIl
~
o
;; z
x~
>o;l :;9,0
f: t" -;:; HiS ~ ~
Ir --' >'
IT1 ~ ~ ~ Ii
o ~a ~
~
~
o
~
m
:r~ ~
"
'f~ <:
H
n
e""
~, m
I ":l
~
"
.. ~
~ - ~
W \C I,', '"
~
~ ~ .
I-' C1: ..;; r l-l
w C. '.t U1
<.oJ c tu a- '" -.J '"
U'l 10.) !Xlln\L>
lr, L'l 'C n
;' ~ ~ ~
Z :::;l"
tIl tIJV,l
q x
- ~
~~
'"'
r:d
ffi
~
Z
n
OLe,
F.;~~
o
<~
. t'3 L~
,"H
3g~
"'
;t' ~ P
Il:I 0~'
n:;!
:r,; ~
q
rr:f']
"
ffi
;;'0:1
r
~
;:-: H
,.:tn
U-.,:t:
'-,f']
~ :u 2:
"
~
.
~
~ ~
ffi
tIl ,~. I:<l
~-~:::0I;l
~~~~~
H~) C' n
~ n ""
~ r- 0 [;:j tIl "'
~
t
~
~
~
H i..Cj 0
~ "
n 0
zo
::c cJ"tl
o
q
m
"
~ ;::
~ 2-1
x c-
~
~
::..,
x ~
rr'><
" 0
"0
''-:;l'll
:r- Z lI:l
0:::-'" "'0
~ m
>' r.. tz:
v_ Z
~
~ ",,;j ;too ~
~ 0 r- ~
"tl~~
-~y
~ lr' =:
to :;; 0
" ~
;c >' [l] m
< ~ ~
I;"' '"
~~
~
~
:::g;
~r
~
n
~
~ :p
~ ~
~ ~
r- >0 .;:,
~ "
~
~
~
o ~
o v ~
~
l:" r
ro
ro ~
l-l'CC,,",
~ ~
~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~
<.11.!-"'''''."""
-~
0-01 >- 0 ..J
o e>,~!Xl CT\ '"
.
- .
~~
"
~
x
?~
--i1-3
~~
"H
(f,'.z
~
~
~ ~
H
~
~
'~
~
~H
<to
.
:-~ ~
z ~
~
O--;tIl
Z
~
~
'11
.
H
?C1n
7 ~
:I' H
o
~~
~ ~ .~,
o .;
~!:;:!-<
'-53:
~ (;
'f_,(j
o
~
~
~
~
o
~
0',0
0(' 0
~ ~ ,-
:r-:>> ",'
::; ~ C
~ ~
~1Il
"
.. q
, ~
~"; ~
>
l'. ~
r
. r
H 0
r: v ~ -
~ ~
". ;:C"llj
::::: r.-: 0 _
.
t<.l C,
~ ~ ~
-"trl i't:;
~
~
o
S
~
..,~ ~x
n~ 't'
~ t:l ~ ~ ~
% "'1 tJ) :::'
:<: ll" -]
r:<~z~
v. tI:I -:
(tIrJ
~
C
". ~
-,t'"
.
"
"
'-z,
"
7:
If;-
~
:L~r
~:,1)
" ~..
~ '!
~ I
I
"-' N "-'
OOC
coo
000
~",~
,nUl cr.
-..
....."'"
. . ~
~~~
~
o
o
II
. I
~ ;
x'
s' ~
S ~
~ ~
, ,
, ,
~
o
o
0.
,
o ,
~~
.
"
~o~
:;;~@
o~
~~
~
~
~
~
~ ~
~ ".
~ ~
W "
ro "
~
~ "
e: I
"
0.
.
,
"
'"
'tl :::::,.
, , e
'" . ..
, " e
"
,
<
<
o
< .
~ e
~ ~
-..l -.l -..l ,-'..,J ..,J -.l ...., --.l
C7\ cr. C1I O,o>",C1I 0\ 0\ 0\
"" IDlO \1'''' \V 'll \1-''''' \1)
tJ f>.' r.J to-, to..> N r.J ~, N tv
tn 0:> rn !Xl IT' ct> w tn
0;1 0\ U' ~ ~ >- 0 \,(,
N N N
0010
10 C 10
10 0 0
~ ~
U'l1)'.t,Jl
~ . ~
~~~
W W
W ~
tv N tv
OO~
COO
COO
~~~
V'lJIln
.~.
G~ I.tI In
w to..> k'
o \D CO
r.J ~' tJ
00'0
000
0010
~~~
l.1l(flt,Jl
...~....
U>lnU'l
r.Jt---'t.:I
~~'"
N N
00
00
00
~ ~
~ UO
.~
"'"
'0 N
.w
...t --J.,J
"'mOl
.., \,(j ~
N , N
~ ~
~ ~ ~
~N
00
00
00
~~
~'"
"~
~'"
NN
N~
~'-'~""'f-'
N
~
o
o
~ ~- -::
t"' c:':!:: r;:;
g; r ~ [,
~ ~
~
;; ,. ~
~
H ~
~~~
t" K t"l
:" t<:::cl
H-./n::r;
~ ~LG~
Zlft--4~~
~ '" "
~ ? 0 0
~ u~ ~
',.,tIIl
to;! ir,tIj
~ "
H
-S
R
0"
H
o ~
~ ~,
~
l-> tv a: tJ
0\ U'l c." w
l-> "_' 0 ~ 10
,..,cO
00 0
"
~
~
~
~
w
o
~ "
~ .
:u ~'
~
"
" "
:;~~
~It-1
00
",
>~~~
...,l"]
~
7: ~ :n ><
~ "
~ ~
~~~c1 ;l"
, tr.I [T! l-3 ~
o v~ &; ~ t"'
:t;~"'ro~i:
"dt->'~t-3
&i ~ "II;:: >'
.... >' tr.I t" ~ ~
5:'"'Jl21
"'r~
~ ~
rJl >-j
,.
..,
t< ;p
w
~
~~~
"~
" ~
'.f'ID
,. N
"~
u ~
,~ N
c'e
00
00
~~
~'"
"~
~~
I,-If-'
O~
.... ,,_' tJ,L W _1.....
co cr -..l ,. """, co
VI I 0 c- 0 w
o
o
~
~
~
~
~
~
w
N
~
, .
~
"
~
"
22""
u' ~
H ~
~
:!~
IT!
~
'"
o
"
~
8
,='
,.
o
o
'"" It:!
~~
"',.
" "
p
~
- '"
o
"
~
no
~~
, H
e' "
~:!:
r;>,
'"
~~
~"'
r
[;;~;:l
~
,-
i, ~ ~ g
~g~
~ ~ X ~
~ tr, c~".
,.8
n 00
t ~
m:3
^"
-, :=
~
~ ~
"'"
roo
m
!J:;fl:I
~
"~
cr, ~
", ~
k't..)
~~
WN
NN
00
00
00
~N
~~
,. ~
~ uo
"~
00 ~
--.J-..l....J""':'
G'. 0> 0..0\
.~ \Q \1' '"
.....' r.J ~, N
--.J....:!(T',C7'I
...-0 \i: 0:>
--.J ...:l _) ....:!
(y,(J', Cl\O\ 0,
'.::I"'\! \D\1'
t,) tv /0.:' N.....'
O'.C7'I(l'01 ().
--J01<.roJo.l.-'
~" '" t" ~
cooe;>
00010
00 C',o
l-'....~1-'
UlUlU'Ul
~""~""
UlUllJ'OI
.....f-'f-'+-'
O'VI "'....
~N
00
00
c, 0
~~
~~
"~
~~
~~
~, ~
t---' l>.> tv
000
c.oo
00'0
~
~~
"~
~~
o
O~
O,L 0 C
o 0
~
~
o
': ~
~ ~
~ H
o
"~
~~
"
~
"
~
~
;:;~
glj
0'"
Oto
E
~
~
"
;j
..,
"
~
~ m
~ ~
r..l 1>.'
0\,,,
W -
N
o
o
o
~
~ ~
. ~
~ ~
00
o ~
"N
DO
00
00
~~
~~
.~
m~
00
O~
..,J _J-.d
0\ C, D'I
~" ~
N'N
0\'-"01
0"'0:>
N W
cO
C 0
~O
~~
C" ~
.~
m~
GO
"W
~
D~
"~
c' w
", ~
,~
,_. '."
~.__, 'G IJ''::;
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ;i ~ ir;;~/Gtl~:_" .
\D \0 'I' "" <.D "" u: ~ <.D ID \1:,,..'
1>.' r.J ~J N 1>.) t,J ,,-' N '" r..l ",,'j
Ul 111 UI VI 1.-" U\ ... .... ... ... ...
U'. l>,J.....O\D(Xl-JD'lUl
......'1>.:0
00
CO
00
~~
~~
"~
m~
co
,. ~
- ~
~
.... ~.
.l-- 0 W'_' l-> ~ ~
c.;; ..., .~ W "0-. "" C -.1'
~ l..> 0 \L> _,..., '"
" ,
fTJ 0
~
0-0'
r>:g,E
t
~,
r-: ~
b
"
H
o
.
~
H
"
~
1;;;
~
~
0-1."
""
~ 0
C
'" ~ g
~tr~14
It z tr.I
o
..."~
,,,
< "
o
~ "
0. ~
. "
0. "
o
~
'"
~
o-,'l:"
C::"<
~ t"
C ~
X..,
~
;:~
'Dn
~"
~
",'
.
~
~
.
"
'"
"
~
o
~
~
o
<0
~
~
,
~
~
,
N
o
o
~
l~ W
C[', tv
o - ~
o 0
~
>-J)o X
r:: ~ ~
S ::cl x
,
_ ~ 'TJ
:;, ~ ~
~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~
~ge;t"'
>-< H Ul
" 0
~ tr.I 'J
no~
o "J
~n~ ~
.. '"
~~~
[f)>~
",
is ~ tC
c
).
g
~
C'
, ~
N
~N
00
00
DO
~~
~ ~
.~
m ~
C~
D~
",N
00
DO
CO
~~
~~
-~
.~
~ ~
o~
N c
'" N
co
00
DO
~ ~
~~
" ~
.~
~ ~
O~
NN
00
00
00
~~
~uo
. ~
-~
W~
. ~
NN~
ODD
CoOO
oeo
............-
lilUll!l
- ~-
"~-
<.0 \D 1.0
~~D
.... ~r ...., .....' <:) :: UI .....
C". G- 0 ~, 0 .....' W (" ~ ....'
-.J"'\oC[l1t\La'OO_lOL~
~
o
Qat
:;! oJ ~ $
i5 OO~.
- tr.I C
"
~mUl
~ _ fJ ~
~il::S
>< t,
H
~
;;:) -)
~., ... -;
:; ~ ,.
~
~
~~
,.
~
" ~
~ - ~
~
z '- '".:
~
~ V K
~ '"
;l :; ~
g ::; 'tl
'1,3, t"
;; mjg
." IJl tt:l H
~ ii ~
"' " H
~ ~
"
~
~
~
~
,.
~
a
.., "- -.J \0 ~ 0 a w ~n 11l
ll::l "" Cf U1 \L 0 C, \0 ~, ol>-
~ N' cr.... ~
~!rl;;=:;:~8
:<> ~ ~ :~
~ 00
~
~E
~ ~,
~
:!:; :r>
~
~
>: ;r]
:07'
f?::; ::-;
~ ?i
~ ~
;; Cl
~
~ "
"'''
oo~
-J
.., '"
't:'t"~
I-l ~ [f)
~~
-J
oo
~ :;
~ "
'" m
m
"
. "
r
>' '::1
~
r.: +
" H
..;: ,;..
~
o
~ z;
c
.,0
~
[;'j
C
..H
o 0
Pl~:'-
~~t"'
W't't"
,,~ ~
Hn
~ ~
~ 0
-J"
~ H ~
~ 8
~
~
'"
..
~
:;
i=gj
~t>' ...
U, "
~ ~
X
"
,.
"
m tJ
~ '"
" Z
<
H '"
00
~ C
"' ~
'Ii
-----_.~.
o
o H
rg;
~
~
~
1,~,tDtD
L~:~g g
brrT-ii) ;>'i"'
o ~
~~
o
"
n z
c .
, ~
'0 ~
. m
" .
"
o
o
~
o
c
,
[
,
,
~
o
o
o
~ 0'"
~~fij
o ~
:':~
~
~
w
~ ~
~ e.
~ ~
~ "
~ 0'
~
w "
0'
e.
"
0.
"'
.
"
".
"
~
,
,
,
~ C ,
. . ,
~ m ,
m " ,
"
,
c
c
[;'j ~
~
< ,
H ,
~ ~
~ ~ ~
'h C7,
~ - ~
W W
W W
~ 0
~ ~ ~
0-',0\ 0'\ 0\
Wit>\: \O'r<.:>
to> '^-' W ....
"-'N ).,IUN
"-~ G:) 01 In ....
c ~
C>.il7'I
'-.:oW
~ w
'_' W
L.-', W
~
'_'1<7\
~~
W
utv
o
- ~
~
" ~
c W
e~
~m
-j~ ~ ....:! ...,] ...:I
C',O'\ 0'\ C', 0\ (J., '" [T 0\
''"''\0\1: \0'.(:,""',",, \0'" '"
w..., ,,, W W \,ol W
:~'f':;:~C>--'6~.~
~ ~ -
J',C1\0'
"':'\01.['
~w
DO
",C1\lr'
..,J ....;..J
O\c.(7'1
\0\,['''''
...,,.;....
000
~"~
, ~
~, 0\
\L'\O
W
:JO
o
--l -.J .,J....;..a~,
[", 0'\ ~, 0'\ U' Ol 0-
'-1.'\0 '.j \O\[l\O 1.<:'
~, .., "-' .., "-' t>.l "-'
\l:' \0 I.l-' W ~ \0 \1:.
I.[G:) -.Jo\Ln...c..'
.:;~-~,:~L.L::'~I
: ~ ~':~;L
W'~'N~-~
\O\D\OQ:JI
).,If-'00,
--'-'---~-
l~iJIJillli~!~!!!~I!I~!~!!i~II!II!!!!~!~!I!!II:
~tn~~~~~~~~~;~tn~~~~~;~~~~~~~~~;~;~;~;~;~~~;~~i I
=~G:)~...,]..,J.,J ....:!~...,]-.JO\mO\mO\mO\m~Ln~~~~~~...~.~.~.~.~ww...w...w '
: ~ : ~ : : : ~~ : ~ : : : : : ~ : ~ : : : : : : : ~ : : : : ~ : : ~ : ~ : -~~~-~ 0\ ~~- ; I :.,,',,'
~>--'~~~f-'~>--'~>--'~>--'~~~f-'~>--'~f-'~_~>--'~_~~~_~_~_~_~_~_~_~_
"'~"'~""""""""""""""""""
~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-p-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-
.~.A.~.~.~.~.~.A.A""A""A.A~A~~.~.'~.~.~...~.A.~
,~,-"""",-"--,-",----------------,,,-,-
N~N~WW~NWNW~W~~N~NW~~WW~WNWWW~'WWNW~WNNNNNNNN
00080?080aooo~ooocooOOOOOOOOOCOOOOOCOOOOOOOO
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~
--... -- -~'~-'-~'" -~_.._- -- --_. -. '.--'.. "-_.~
I:
glT~7:gu:af-i~i[;Z;~
tl 7! 0 := t::l I~' t::l ,} tl t:' C ;::1
'C t'" 0<
> .
~ ".
~ H [:
~ ~-
"
.
o
~
>
"
c
,
~
>
g: ~ 'Sl
at""
~
N
"
w
~
~
~
::
~
~
~
o
o
to t- tv UI
'" _, \0 Ct.
~ "'. I;>l ~r V\
~
~
o (:::. ol> ~........ 0 er.
a V\' IJl <.r 0 :r
~
o
.
0'
.
~
" ~
i>~ g' ~ ~
"' ~
.
.
c;,
.
u.,1'l
'::.' 0
2: 'T]'Ij
. .
't1::S11 3:
I-':r> fl" ',' H
: [TJ:;- ~ ~
III ~ ~
2: z: 'tI
<J III 0
'" ~
~ ~
~ ~ ;:: tf) i,
cr:; "l rr: ~ c
.",t" ;0.
.'.F:
"
U'
,
~
,
'C
:J
~
= ~
v',1li
:~ ~
p
>
"
6
s;
~
H
n
o
o
o
'"
" _.()
0'
e?~
'":l ::c' ~
.,1i"J
2: ?J ~
:.- t'1-"-
'0" .",0..
t" t-1Il
~ ~ 0.
([.11>
;;= ~ ::i
00
:;:",
H:<:' c,
~~ ~
f;;:;' ~'
Ij~ III
U,
'iii :;;;
~ ~
~
M
I..'J
_c:::::~ c::cc:::c:o c:c:c
8~gq~g~6'~~~g~~~
~
~
~ 0
~
~ ~ ~
<J\ 0 c', N
I,) C-', ~ ::- ...
o
~, C
t:L:.6
::'C:l
:.~ r:::
c ~
~~
> > H
.- ~ ;' ~
~ H
>
W
"'tr.:
<0
n
r,t:l tl H
;;:c;l!: ~
--'?i ~ ~ - a
~ w
0>--,)
- ~ ><"'3
.=J><: >:
~
.... r::r c, [/)
?:''< >-l'
~ to:
~ ~ ;j ~
_ Pl ... ~
~f;;~:g~tfl~
j~ ~ ~}1
~ :3:.r ffi ~ t~
eJJ
t::l',]
" ~
~ ~ ~
;J
~
o
." " r>:
"
"
.,.~ x
~
~
~
~
g ~
H
~ ~
o C'
>
"::<"tI
> M
~
"
~
~
p
"'
~ ~
'"
H
~
~
W
.
~
H
~
~
~
~
~
~
o
o
~
0.[ ~ - I-' e
I-' .... O. _jOO
<=> 0 ~ ~ I-'
o
- ~
W :r 0
"" ,:1,0
:t 8 s;
.. t'" - :r
~ H
t-;J ~ ~ a!
~,~ t"' M
~
~ ~
::;: 2': :j, g: (-, t:!
tr:::< 8 Q
~nc::2: ~
,. ~ p ~ ~
,n ~ ... ifJ
rr1 H ~,(IJ
xn
<e;)>~::-
~.'.' ~o ~
z ~
tr.l...;
7
~
~ ~
,_ n
'"
- H
C <
>
~. ~
:'t"'
3::p:r
~m
~~
u;, a
>M
cz
"!l ~
~ [TJ'tI )>
~ t<J ~ &;
[r] ~ (fj In
;: <
.H
,~
'"31:"'
,..,/:11 [TJ
"
~
~t"'
",l]l 'cJ
>-'Jr'J '.'
c:: c:::::o_C' C' c:::::o c:c:
y~g~~~~g~~@~~~8~~
~
.... :::. 0,
OJ ::0'
:1:' H
Z :0-
. -
~
~, 't' 't'
~ ~ ~
~
~ ~ '"
. 0 q:)>'
~: ~ 2
~ :>:l _, ;:
;; t"' -, ("J
e 7 ~
'cJ c.:
" ~
r::r- ~ ~
r.!:>:l ll':;
"'~'"
I'" H )>
-~H
~~"l~
~O'cJ
c::;- "CI::"
'f. () ~ >-;l ~
~;:; t R (r.
trl(j G=.to:
;00 "'.;
Q 8 : ~
~
t ~
~
'J)
~
~
~
o
w
m
~
m
H ~
~ ~ 0
.... " .." ~ 0
o
o
o 0 to.)
c _ a ~ ""
~
H
_ ~ :i is 0 ~
~ tr. ... ~ :1;' ~ -
-:c.' t"' ..., ~.<
~ 8;;...= ~
~~ ~:>;~:l::~
><:>0 t<J[TJ:Z:
tI;I ;00 0;>::1H
"'to l'i [l'JI><
,."tll "",:tI
"= is Z ~ Z ~ ~.) ~
~ ~ rr, ), ~
:>:'t':I
W
~~
~
"~
:t<>'
~ "
~er~~
~ ~ ~ ~
~ X
)0 m
n
~ "
g; *
'>;I (0
~
~ ,~, lJ:< -:
:T /:J;l ('J ?:' 0
~ ;~~~
~ r.-' g ~, ~
~ r. f': t'" ."r<
Z .
o
~ ~ ! ~
~:e
._ t:;!
~(:j
,:.r;
':)'1:1
~t"'
c
"
c
u.
"
c
w
.
c
~ ~
~ " ~
.... C', -.J ~
~ 9
t:1 ~~ ~
~
o
"
C l/;
"""0
'tI ::>:
p~t
~ -,
~ ~ ?J
~'"
~
~~
~~~
w..
~
H
- ~
~P'lz
.
" ~
~ ~~!
tr:-;;~~~
0'1:'0<0
~ >- f;; to: [:2
~...~~~~
r 0 p
_, 0
"~, >0 0 i-
g
c
,
~
--r
0,
o c
~ ; ! ~
~:c; i i
~ ~
"l I
~
u!
'"
>
!::
Z
~
-->'"trltrI
':':~:';' ~
o:<rT,(,!;>\"
p "
~~
o
"
o .
.~
'" H
o 0
o .
~
o
o
'"
.
> 0 ~
:e~~
o >
~.
H
~
H
~
H .
~ "
w ~
. "
~ 0'
~
H ~
~
"
"
'"
~
.
o
~
"" C f-
. " "
~ 0 _
. " "
"
,
,
c
c
C'J '"
:;: ...
3 :
-
..,
Ch,G,
.\0 'D
~ ,~
..,
(J'l 'JI
'~'.'...'Cil.-'v
-..l -.J-.J
cJ\ ~\ 0\
\D\.D\D
101"-'1,0>
~ ~
... Co' W
..,..,
0, ~
", ~
~
"..;.,l
o
,..,
" ~
\C. '0
;.; W
0',0\
" m
..,~
cr, ~
W~
ww
cr, ~
~; O'l
..,~
cr, ~
w ~
'J.JW
,,~
~~
..,..,
[},OI
W ~
W' ~
Q\C1'>
wW
...c -.J _, -.J -.; -.l -.J-.l
C\(J'lO\O\(I)(J'l mOl
\VOQ<.D\P\D\O\DID
c.-'WWWWWww
0\ at L~ lJ'I Ln t1I lJl Ul
>-' 0 '"', Q> _~ .,., lJl ..
..,~
cr, ~
W~
w~
~~
ww
~~
c,-"(J'l
\.C,'"
ww
~~
~o
..,..,
cr, ~
W~
w ~
~~
wm
..,..,
m~
w~
," w
~~
"';"01
-.J...:l...J-...l
C\ 0'1 a, 0\
<.D"'<.D\l>
....' W w W
"'''''-'If>
,n... "'-, N
..,~
cr, ~
" ~
W~
~ ~
~o
..,~
,,~
,,~
W~
W ~
""GI
NWNw,a '-~I
00000 III
coooa
OODOC I
,.... ... .~ ... ,....
;;:~~::~I
lJlOllJlUl ,J1
COQ:> COGl 00
\.(0)...)""""
W~N~N~WNUN~NWNWNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN
0000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000
...,.......~...,.......,.......,.......~...,.......,.......,.......,.......,.......,.......,.......,.......,.......
~lJlUllJlt1llJlt1llJllJ'llJlUllJlUllJl~lJllJ'llJl~lJllJ'llJlt1ll"t1IlJlUllJlt1llJlt1l
..."'...~.~...""...~...~.."'...""...~..."'..."'..."'...~..."'...~...
O\mcJ\C\O\~O\m""C\O\~(J'lm(J'lmO\m.,..m(J'lmO\m(J'lmO\mO\lJlt1l
NNWNNNWNW,.......~...,.......,.......,.......OOOODOOOOO~~
G1-.JOIV1...wWl-'O\DGI-.J(J'llJl...wWl-'O\D(Z>...jO\lJl..WWl-'O\D1lO
NNNW~'Wt0N
00000000
OOOQOOO~
00000000
"'-1-&>-'1-'>-'1-'>-'1-1
lJ1U1LJ1U1\J1UlLJ1U1
-4.-4....-4...."'....
'J1U1U'UI(rLUlLJ1U1
CL'\O\.C\Q'.n\O \L\D
...1 '" LJ1'" we..> f-' 0
I-',....I-',....I-',....I-',....l-',....I-'>-'I-'~l-'>-'l-'f-'I-'>-'l-'>-'l-',....l-'>-'I-',....I-'>-'I-'...-I-'>-'I-',....I-'f-'I-'~I-'~I-'>-' I
1-'>-'1-'>-'1-'>-'1-'>-'1-'>-'1-'>-'1-1 >-'I-'>-'I-''''''I-I>-'I-''''''I-'f-'I-'>-'I-'>-'I-''''''I-''''''I-I>-,I-' f-'I-I""'I-I >-'1-1>-'1-'>-' I
...... ,......'-"......,.....,................................... ...............,............, ,...... ,.............................. ......",'...... ,......"........... ,'...... --- I I
l-',....I-'~I-'...-I-',....I-',....I-'>-'I-'f-'I-',....I-',....I-'>-'I-',....I-'...-I-'>-'I-',....I-',....I-'~I-',....l-'>-'I-',....I-',....I-',....I-I>-'
....-4.-4....-4..."'...."'....-4.~....~...."'..."'...."'....-4..."'...."'....~....~."'....~....~....~...."'....'" I
"......,......,......,......,......,..............................,......................................................,..................,..................,......"......"......,......
N~~~~NNN~~N~NNNNNNNNWNW~WNWNNUWUW~N~NNNUW~NN
OOOCQOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCOOOOOCOOOCOOOOOOOOOOOC
IOOOCOOOCOOOOOOOOOCOOOOOOOOOOOCOCOOOOOOOOOOOSI.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-~~~~~~~-~~~~
i-a- - = c: c: ::Ci" - c:: ::: c:: c c ::: c:: ::: = ::: d Cd c: Cl C = ::: = c Cl ::: c:: c CI' -::: c:: C c:::l ::: c:::l Cd::: II
' tfl [jj tI) (F. ll:l UJ ro (F., D:l i?, D:l IJ; D:l /.f; tI:l [J) to W tQ [jl to v; to :J:' tfl u; (f.I [J) t/:l Ul l:f.l W trl 1.1;' tQ '.j) to L~ to If. Ul Ul to [fJ; 'I
~~O~'O~ODOOO:::OOOOOO~OOOOOOOOOOOOOO:::OOOOOOOdOOi i
I
W
00
W ,,, I-l f-
a:s.1;II a:
"-',
~
--II-'
-..lcr-lc 0\
U1 U1 "- 0:>
~ "
W
~
~
w
w"
~ c ~
\>V Ie I-' l..
M W ~
IJI -.; Ul ::: ~ 'n l-' '-',...
a ~ 0 GOO ~ ~
U' ~...,
t.: -l.L.UI
CD ~J W C' W
~ ~ ~
Ul cr W Q-.. '-".::)',...;J I-'
VI 1I ..., ~ <:> a"". c..' Ch
,!.. \O.j.. L~ \I>
.;.. '" [." hi C <;
UlOU1 0---,
o
o
W - 0 ~, 0 ~ <:> c 0
w C-'O.=:O 0
~
~ "
o ~ 0
o G 0 _
o 0
oeo
::::e
o CL' 0
0'," 0
o
~o
o
00
o co'!" 0 Q, 0 <:>_
o 0 OJ'.OOO
._--_.~---_._----- --"-'-_..'---~-'-- -~-'--'-'._~------
~
o
~
"'
~
~
~ r "'
" C
~ .' ~
w '"
~ '"
H r ,.
~ II :o:r
~, :JOl
;: v ~
. "'
e" r~
"' C H
trJ ~ ~ ;1
" .
c
~
"
r H
~
~,3eE.g;~'~:r,~~};,;:i=
." G'l r..::r:;:::t::O:11 ,-=- ()
,- '< .-: 5 ~ 0 0 ,=.:! ~ '"
Z ~ _, ~ ~ ~ ~.~ ~_
:S~ S~",::l'<J~~;:~::;
~:'g.;~2~~Qf,-jri:~~
:::: "< ...~ I-l f--' to lJ; u:l '.f... 1Il
l', ~:'-ocont:llr;1S
;;~~~~:"''I1t>j'r;;g~
~~;r'S~;g_fj6'g. ~
'V III [{)::tl ::d;<:'::tl::>J a. Q
r 1-1 :::: 'i "" >i '"", tit ~ I'fJ
[i~~~~><~~=~":l~t"
<: l:'" '-3
H ~
~ iLd~ ~
o 1-1 H ...,.
~ ~f:j~0 ~
; l"3'""J~~ ~
~ ~ if]
'" .
"' "
'"
"'
.,
"
.
,.
oJ ~ ~
~E:~:
:-, tI'J _.~.. '"8
~ ~ '
"" l!:: rr't'l
::.:<" tDtl,!
-e~~:~~~
-:~~&: ii
[;; ~ ,,!i V Ei
I-I"iil-l
'J 0 = ~ >'
~fz:~c;J~!i
'D I-l 'D n >- H
:;Zr-ozz
;;00 tTI" <-<H
.,., [fj'a{fJto
'-'3 .-'J~
O~200J~~
Z = (;, 'i :::;::!
~~~~~~
~>i'ljP1 n
:;::;11' L':O ~"
<-< tTIt1J~ trl
.., [fj n J:>
:st"'r~trl(l;li:;
~ ~~~
~
:: ~
:::: ll:I
If,trJ
o-i S
:8
~- ~
N t'lO
G;~;j
t"l mo<
;g::!~'"'l
~
(I; ~ ?:
~&!~g
~~~~
:=: ~ .~.t;
~ ;: r. ~
.. Z
IJ;t":<>:E:
trlt'!l'D>'
;:lJOO&;Ej
::; "II ~~
(", t" =
;;: "'3>'
(1) r-' "d
"
'"
"'
~"
~;:;
, '"
r.Jt':!
'D"d
~,.
;0:"
.~ ~
:~
" 0
~.,
p
g-;~
d
"'
~~
:::~
:t.'l'l
,,~
~~
'"
p"
.
., . ~
"~H
,.
~: '":l
p"
~ 0
= e
, .
.
~i;"~t'~~
e; :; ~ p ~ ~
!-' C' H '<; ~ ::::
,,,t' 71t:1
c'.... r... 0
c: liJ ~
,.
o Z
G 10-'-',
m 0
:,... tl "7
;"! ~ g
,,~ ~
~ ~ ,... Z
o
~i5 ;s:?
tI;.C: t"';:t>
;O::ifiiS~
',; 1-1 o>::r- ~.
;" n ::::
'1"] IOl 0' ::l:n
::' 'o;l .,., 0 tl Ii' i:l"
~~S;~~;~:
;C4r:N~"~t11
ij,'< IT ;. ~ = '1 ~
z;:~gz~;z
)00 'tl '0 m '" .... ';;' "
'D!-'>-'rt'Cft ,.....>lj
~ (II fll III >-' III rr!-' '"l
tr:JtII UJ II tr, a.;Cl:'"
lFJ Z' [f. 'lCI III tJ1
;J~~i~e"~~~
. ~
.
~
;: ~ ~
'C::Ul '"
-! ~
S1 B
-, ,.
I'." ~ '""J
~~
m
~;:
~ ~
8i;
::l ~
....,;>;1
W
00
u,o
n~
=n
~~
5",
00
Q
mn
~,.
~
H
o
Z
..
tJlZ~
~ ~
d m
H ~
pi
"''"
""
H
"
[jJ
'", ~
gf.,]
0~
~
'"
"
.,
"
:r;
~
~
:;
.,
"
s:
:to":O;
U
u
[f, ..,
"
z;..t
;; ~ 2=
c< 0 r
~~~
er:fu;
[:"< lIil l~J
m
~
~
~
.,
"
l'1;I"'J
t" t"
'T;''l\l
r:< cr;.
-,
"
~
H
Z
_~IL
rn
~
~
o ~
c ,
. ~
" ~
. .
" "
~
c
o
0.
.
~
o
o
o
. 0 '"
:;~~
o.
~ '"
~
~
~
~ '"
~ _.
w ~
00 "
~ "
~
w "
;;:
"
0.
rn
.
"
~
,
c
,
,
'" C "
. . "
co 0 '
o " "
~
,
c
e
Xc
~ ,
~
< .
H ~
2:...
~ ~
~ ~
'" '~OI
\D \O\i.;
....,lo.oI>~
:: ~ ~ Q.
to.) W tv W
0=.000
ooooC>
000000
I-'.....I-o'f-'....
lft 'J Ul Lr t1I
.><-ll>......
"'C',a.C\'"
00 Wr;I) roQlo
c:o CJ\U'....
...:r ~,
.,.. U
\j)~
~ ..
W ~
~ ~
-.1 -.3 ..., -..l
'" ~ 0\ C Cl'I [f 01 e,
oD\[ 'Ll '-1:'\0 \DID\,[
."..t......,J:. __ .... ~ ...
..... .... b,l rv N ~'
..... tv'" ~ ID OC ~ G,
UN
00
~O
DO
~~
~~
.~
" m
ro ~
,~' ...
,C N
DO
DO
DO
~~
'~ ~
..
0, m
ro~
~ 0
'" N
00
DO
~O
~
'"~
.~
0, ~
~~
~~
"-'N"-'t.:>
0000
DO 0
=>e;:~
\J1UllJ'Ul
.t>....t....
cr, '" m C7'l
-J..J....r...:;l
-JO\<.r..
~ -'
0,",
~ ~
~ ~
N ~
~ ~
-..] -.J "-..l
'" ,., 0, ['\ (J\
\0 '4-'1C\L'\O
..............
N h' I>.) r", I-'
....,."1-' ::::.",
,. N
DO
_ 0
CO
~~
~~
..
m m
,~
~N
~N
00
00
00
~~
'""'
.~
0'0,
,~
~O
"-''''
00
C.O:>
00
~~
,~ ~
..
mm
mm
,~
, ~
om
~~
~.
~~
o. ~
~
0,
~~
~.
~~
C<,(I\
~
c. m
1,1)100'4:
~~
~ ~
~ w ,
~ ~
0'1,:)",0\
~~~
..w
~~~
I-'CO
~_' lo.) '" N
00:;'0
000 __ 0
0000
.....1-'-''"''
'-~ Ul '.11 VI
""...04...
m O"l 01 G'1o
Ul....I--....
\Ow~o
~
C~
'. ~
~w
(1', m
~~
~
e,,,,
, ~
~
O~
, ~
, ~
m
\C\D\('
l~ .... .....'
ccoom
Lr..
--.l ~ ...:ri'~-"":c-I'l" ~,
~ ~; ~ t;;_.~ '~~1-
lo> l,,-''''' \.oJ.... '"'-'''I
00 roO) -..]..;I...J
N O\vCQ....r
i-~;::-m :I"n
c:e
(.-,1 ~rJ
i ,~
'II
~I
-'-1-', ,.'
jjr,:
","'j
i '/,
,
I
II;
1"-.' N h.' N
OOCD
0000
DOCO
~ ~ ~
l.~ Ul lJ' tIT
.1.>........
0' 01 ~ '"
W...."-'....
'-01XI--.!CJ\
,c N
00
00
DO
~~
'""'
..
m~
~~
'N
00
00
DO
~~
'""'
..
~ m
~~
.N
"N
DO
DO
00
~~
'""'
..
mm
w w
~O
~N
DO
DO
00
~~
'"~
..
m~
mm
~ m
," W
00
00
80
w~
:..-~ 111
..
om
om
~.
""W"-'N
000 c' 0
0000
0000
~w~
<J1UllJ1U1
.4....::.....
m 01 0\ 0\
0;0\0'<01
....w.....O
~ ~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-~~~ ~~~-~~~~~~~-~-~-~~
~-~-~ ~-~-~~~-~-~~~~~-~-~-~-~~~-~-~-~-~~~-~~
~~"'~"'~"~"',"~~,~~"""""",""'"
~-~~~-~~~-~-~-~~~-~-~-~-~-~-~I-'~-~-~~~-~-~-~-
~m~m~m~~~~~m~~~~~m~m~~~m~m~m~ffi~~~~~~~~~~~~~A
""""""'-"~"'~""---,---,-~,--,-,-,-
NI~NNNN~WW~~~WN~~W~W~~~~~'~~N~~W~~~~N~W~W~W~W~
oecco oeococoCO~OC080CO~OOOCOOO~OOOCOCO occo
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~
~~~~;~~~g~~~~~ffi~g~~~~0~~~
~O~D~O~OOD~OCO~80~~OOOO~O
~
w
U
c
C'
a
~ ~
o 0
wor 0
c
o
~
C
o 0 c~ I-'
0-0 ...:
~
~
~
~ ~
:1'
S
~
~j~'C~~,: ~_
g:; S ~ 0> ~
:I: ;:. Po
o ~
" - "
;; ~; ~
~ <
~ "
ftj l'-r-o
If.I V.O
~
"llenS:
~ c ~
c" ~
~
n
~;:
C~
t'3t<
Ujl"i/
'"
~~ ~
~
m
"
~'"
1l''tJ ,..,
:3 0
(L"l ;C
n ro- Q
~ M
M
.
.
.
"
M
'<
'"
~~~
(J; ::l
G-IT If
.
~ ~ S
",
g.:;
'<
00 fl .... -
I'"'" ;J 0
- III - 11 ..", tc
G_ :; ;. () ~ ~
III ;;:: ~ l'f'
~ Ii ~
'"
~
.
.
z
'"' tIl
[r, j:
U,'O
~,'tl <
n 0
;S!1 n
::. l'f" (I'
e,
"
~ ~
, '"
t>l ::>
~ it;
o
M
(1.' n :::'
".
T jl:I
,- !1 :><:
~
.
.
;.8"
"
~
w
~
~
"
~
w
~
~
o ~
t.r. _ 0\
:f:; .0"
~ 0 r:l 6
". _ n
o ~_.
< ~
1-'. H I-'
III ~ P. r
~
n r :
~ .
(.'0 l"l
~; ~ ~ :
"
w ~~; S
.., p. >::
'>:l I'" 11 u: 0
F;" ,....,fO-(r. '""
,:J l:I,..
2- ~ Q ~
o is (D
t: ~ <
m '.J! II
. ~
:EZ'tl
. , ~
Ill'::' ..,.
".~"
fO- (1:' m
t:l U,O"
'" "
..,. ""'Ii
o r 10 >-J
t! P'><
~
n
w
~
~
<:;> ,J. 0 (7:l
o 'f1 0 cC, ~
~ .... - ~
tv '- 0 .... N
.... u" (7:l 0
I-l" (7:l
~ 0
^
o
c'
: :: s: ~
'" ;::.>-
(tI 11' T
" .
II' ~,p-
I- 'r'
'"
'"
~ --
~q; ,-
,.,.,. '"'
::: I!> .~
..
'.:''''J
""11
.
~ .
"Ill
:::c
;; .:!
"
" ~
gg
.
.
~ .
~
~~
~"
-'<
::"
irQ
m _ '"
o "" c
~ " c
::c ..,- ....
~ ~
~
o ..
... tr.
.--:.11
n
o [T: "':l
S ~ C"'
~"~
~o~~
0_"
~ ~ ~ ~ ..
~~ ~
:r-ro 0
.-Jtf.I 2:
~~'"
0",: r-o
[t):<::
Pl"tJ'll
~ ~ ~
::" tIl :a:t
"
~
"
~
~
~
"
~
'"
~
~
~
'"
'"
~
ffi~~g~~~ffi~~~~~ffi~~~ffi..
Clt:I':Jt:lOt:lCJOC't:l'::Jt:lCO::Jt:lOOO
~
~ ~
~ ~ ~
U1 >- t.l ,'" W
W ~ ro
.~ ;J ;;, ~
::::tf) tf)
:: E g
.? ~ >.. ~
;G g ~' tii :T'
~ tIl ~,;;! :s
t=~SQ-
'=' ~ ,,", 3: e'
" ~
in ;;:,
m"
~ c: '1J
r-:g ""
~g~
"'l ~
~ ll:l :::j
~"
C'1i) (j
~ ~ ~
tn '-fJ 0 r)
~~~~E'
c." ~
:: H l'
l-l ?: >' ~
t""'-<:1::
'"
--u.
~ ;i
"
t p;
~
.:; ~
~~ III
C
~
~gj
[;gj
c, ~
~ ~
~
"
n
'"
~
o
~
'"
~
'"
~"
~ '"'
,~i ~
-- "
- R ~'
~>'~
~ "
"'.
~ ..,. ~J
~~
L~ t:l ~,
"
-- ~
r X
w
~
~
w
ro
'"
o 0
o l~' ~
i: b
-- " --
~. >' r
;:;:.1:"
~
~ ,
H [lJ
n <
~ ~
~
.
<
. ,
. H
". e
~~
e S
~r,j
M ~
~
g -
..
o
'"
~
~
o
~
o
o
o
o
cr_ _ cr,
1.-' ... J."'" ,..,
(D 0 oC~
~
"
C :r 0
o ~
~ "g; ~ 8
r:--;; t>l ;:f:fI :':ti
~ =:;r ,,_,;r<
t:<; >-r: '0:1
.
~
2g
(I;t1
sg
~;j
~
- ~
~. ~
"
"
'"
~
~'"
r~
:: ~
<
.
f:l :<>
.., ~
t"' ~
'p It:'
~c
;: ~ ~
e
~;. "" ::7
~
~ ~
:L
..-J :;;: ~.
t ~ ;:
em
S.., :;:;
I:" "J
'"
"
"
'"
"
'>J~
rr:t;j
>-, ~
~
;=-J ;:
~
r ~
~ ~ ~
~
~
,.
o
c
~
b-J
(f)
r
Ii
'-;""01 tJ1
'He r, III
.~ 'fl :l t!
''''',I1\;>r
; ~';':;
, .
~~
.
"
(j :;::
o .
, '"
~ ~
., ,
~ ~
o
o
~
,
"'0'"
~~gj
o.
~'"
"
~
w
~
~ '"
~ "-
w ~
ro "
~ ".
~
w ~
~
e-
M
~
W
.
,
~
,
,
,
,
~ C "
. . "
'" , -
, " "
"
,
c
c
<
::i ~
Z
- .
~
___,__J
I~
'~
~
;;
"
~
~
"
~
:)
"
"
"
.,J-J.,J-.J.,J
0\0'\0\0',""
OD\P\C>\OOD
..............
iI7I Ct, 0\ m 0\
<.rI w ~ _, C>
n z
o .
, '"
'" ~
. .
o .
'"
-.!-.J ..J
a Cl'l m CI'I
\,( \1:1\(,'"
01'-...1-...
\T U1 lJ1 Ul
\l:CI>-..JU1
-~
mOo
, ~
.~
.~
" ~
~L:~'I~i~,~~r-'--~~:' [~i i-
'.E.: ';:: ~p, ..;1'-i~",,"I')""'Ie-;o;-
..............l> I-,.."'::"::l:-:
,l...... tv t-' 0 (-' E al
I; , &"<
.
"
~~
',00
", ~
.~
t"U1
". W
~~
" ~
~~
"~
___~ UI
k: I-'
-, ~
0'00
~~
"~
l;'...
c, \P
~~
"00
"~
"~
. ~
~~
Ii,
i '~h
I
I
~~~~~*~~~~~~*~~~~~~~~~~~!II
~-I-' I-'~I-'~I-'~I-'_I-' 1-'-1-'-1-' I-'~I-'~ I
Ul~UllJ1UllJ1U1lJ1Ul~~lJ1<.r1lJ1U1lJ1UllJ1U1lJ1U1~UllJ1 I
.........~..."'"....~..."'".."'"........4.~."'"........"'"
~-.!.,J..J.,J..J.,J..J.,J-.!.,J..J~..J.,J..J.,J..J.,J..J.,J..JO\~
ww....www....~I-'~I-'_0000000ooo\Drnl
_~_~_~_':'_ N 0 ~_~_~'--~_ 0 I,t) CD ..., cr. Ul "" w r-..' I-" 0 <;> ~ I
2~2~2~2~2~2~2~222~22E~2~ II
I-'~I-'-I-"-I-'~I-"~t-'~I-"~I-'~I-'~I-"~I-"~t-'~
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~
MNUNUUUNUNUNMNMNUNMNYNMN, '~
000000000000000000000000 I
000000000000000000000000
.,J-J-.J-J.,J-J.,J-J..J-J.,J-J.,J-J."J-J.,J-J.,J-.,J.,J-J-.l-J '~.
1- 5: ,:- g ~ ~ ~- ~ ~ 5l ~ ~(~~ if: ~ &:. ~ ~ ~ @ ~ ~ ~ ~ m ~ ! I i ~;~,~
Ci~0000 O~~OQO~O~OO~~DOO~_: I
I .
c___+---~_~.
, ,
I I
, I
".
"
"
"
,
"
~
Y
VI .;:-, o.-l __ I-' a, ...
0::') \oJ '4_ --.l 0"\
-.l -.l k'.... ,t 0
"
w
__ 0"\ c~' .... ,.' O'l 0'0
t.:> .... LF..... 0
Ie>.~ "" c.. V1 '" Co
l:l:>COO 0 Co
,,<;> -.l'!'" I-'
-.J 00 0"\[,.....
0.... VI cr e 0, 0
ocO'\t..-'O'l <::> ococco
o IDrIoOJ,QC<.'O 0__0
~~1:i
:O-[fjN
:>;l r-!'C
~ X ~
g: ~ m
~
'" . "
... 'T] n
O~H
~R~
" ~
%
..
~
~ ~
w~w
"'~=
H
~~~
a ~
~ n
~ ~
0"
~'"
~
~~
~
H
b ~
n
(f, I-' '!) >-!
~ 0 c'
Cto
to -,1:1::
;;~~~
r:l fr...
;;iJ~t'Ij
"I-! I><
>;;top;g
~ t/) tr: t'Ij
(;j d () to
'" ~ "
,~, 'tl :>J
(:. ~ '. ~
~
:r;~
~"
~
~~
,,~
O'tl
~o
=
[f)"O
~
~o
tll ~
"'.~ Pl
r..
~Q
~
r~
M~
w
r
~
r
o 0 (n,,-.~co
o c' 0 ""; U\ ,,-, .... c. 0 _
s::t': to
:t:>)o Z 1:01
'C ~ l0;g
'~C<l ~ ~
~ 3: ~ t>;l
~,.
(n:::: H
>' Z 2:
~~~I
If)~un
~w
r~~8
to c' 3::
~;S
!:2"
'" " ,.
Ct'"
~::j'"
g
trJ:-'; 'I]
gts:ll'
"n
>H
n~
;j
~(;)
-~
r;:: ~
t~
", H
~1l
2: 0
, ~
- ..
.....
~ ~ ~
.]
m
1: '"
'"
@~
I'J
g! ~
'"
!:"
t:lQ
= "
..
...
t" CJ
"
o co
o
5~
"
:J: :.<
H g
,.
'"
cO
Z%
(jH
H
r..
m
"'"
-~
8'"
~H
:r:>5
n'"
"
tT:-'III
~...
m
~
~
~
"
~
r
~
...
ill
___..Lm.__.~_,~_
o
o
0.
.
~
o
o
o
,
,
,
,
,
.. 0 ~
,~z
~ ~ ~
0"
~ ~
~
-
~
~
r ~
~ ..
w ~
~ ~
~ "
~
W H
"
.-
"
0.
.
.
,
..
,
L
,
,
,
~
~ -.
I>> WI-
m . -
III ., ~
,.
c
c
~ X c
I-'[>J "
r
< .
H "
Z
r _
Z ~
~
ii,
o
-J -:~-J
C',CtlO-'C'lcr.C'I
"_"'''-'10 >D
"-'"........ "-' ~
1;'\ 111 C 0 C' 0
~, (r'O ~n ~ (r'O
"
~
Cc
,.
"
c
"
o
cr.
c
"
,
~
, "
"
I
,~. ..:0
C' 0
a 0
o
~~
~~
.~
~ ~
" ~
'" ~
-J -J -.i ..:J -J
C'O\ C,O\ (:',0\ 0,
"- loI;I U,,,,\!,t.C'-"
,C.... ~ ~.:......
OOOCO\j)
~... N,... 0 I.D
------~---
- -"~ ~t=; l ii'-'in . ~:'~ trt
~ ~ ~ '~:~:~~~ ; f~~: r~:-~ ~
~ ~ :;: ~ :;: ~-- ':I'~ T :;l :>:
0\ In.... '.,.; N....' :~ I ~ ~
6 ~
-B' Ii
Q'
l<'
4i
"
l
"
"
.
~~
co
00
co
~~
~" \11
.~
~ Ul
,~
~n 00
C~
C '"
co
co
~~
,~ ~
.~
IJ'UI
C~
D~
""'Nt-JW
0000
o,~ co
oeo
~~~
'J1I11Lnl1l
>l>,.."",.
<J1ol>wW
'-'~ '" In ...
ro.,JlJlt.o>
....Jt..iI
co
co
co
~~
~~
.~
~
a~
~~
..,
~ m
~ "
t.o>c.-'
~ "
~ -
: I
c ~ ,~~J~I
ggggg:;g: !
;:,oocooc,: '
tfl ~ ~ i;: ~ t;: ~ i i
.I.... ""'.......... ""',
N:::;:~~~:~!
.... '-' N t- 0 ~_l__'
~ I
I
::C:CC_C_Cl O_ClCC:CCl CleCl
~~8~~~~~g~8~8~8~g~~~~
~t-~,...~ ~ ~t-~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~~t-~t-~t-~t-~t-~t-~,...~t-~t-~~
~~,~,~"~"""~~,~"
~~t-~~~t-~t-~t-~t-~t-~~~t-~~
rn 111 .:.. .... ~ ... ... ... ... ... ~ ... .:.. ... .:.. ... .:.. ... .:.. ... "'"
~"""~~""""-'"
NN~N~WNN~WWNNNNN~NNNN
_ooooooooooococooooo
00000000000000000000
-.i~-.i~_:-:~-: ..:J-.i-:~..:J~-:-J..:J-.i-:
g
~, (.oJ v- '"
~ '" ~
o C- 0 0
o
o
~ i: ,- ~
:"o.!) ='
~ " .
.
~
~ ~
. , ~
_ t:: ~: 110
- ,..,. " "
~ ~.
- '" (f
~.; W t"'
o :::: I:"
,~ n
~;;
"
~
.
~ .
~~
~
~
;
"
~
~
'"
o
~
"
~=
!T lJI
" "
~
~ .
::-- III ~
~.f:.
~ ~
(f.
ec'
'"
~
~
~
.
o
o
~-' cr 0
00 0
'" " j:rj ~::t :::r
g. {' &; > ::: - ;::
III ~ t-<.o- j:rj
r. ~ ~ 0 _
. >"
::r~~~:;::m<
;" &; cr' ~
(I) m 'r1?:i
~ ~
~on
"on
~ III
2 2:
" PI
01'0
,1 ~
;:; :
[n
~
~
(,~ t"'
"
'1:: ~ -r: [Il
- ~
'" T
,.!l::
;:
n ~
o ' ~
~~~
g ~ ~ ~
;;;;~
;S~~
I':l'illr!
tr_toL',
'>;l ~,
~ "
~
~ "
~ r
.
~
'"
~
~
~
~
~
'" ,;1 0 l' W ~ '"
-..J 0 0 0
x ~
rr; b
on
:::: 0 ",
~- ~
"
c
" ~
~ (5 :1' n
c-~ 0
~ ~ rr: ~ ,~
'TJ $ 't1 i< ><:
~!;:f-3
rr; Pi ,_ ~
~ ~
)< Z
~ ~
~
c
r
.:--0; ~
~ 5
~~
m
'"
~
81;
,- n
o
:~
>'"
":'t;:I
rei
r,::to
n
o
~
~
eI
n
, ~
;;:"
~::
~;:;
~..
3: tJ::!f.l
>-'10 i.r'
rH
~ ~
'"
n
'_c ;l"
x
"
"
,:,;
~
r
~
~
~
..
~
"~
~
~
~
~
~
~
n
"
~ ~
~~
~
'::' 2 8:r'
r-+ t"'",
~ ;::
7" g; ~ ~ '"
() () (f]
~s~~
~ - ~ ~'
~
~ ~
~
t~
"'"
r~
"' >
:~
"8>-
r ~
'r11:"'
1J.Pl'
'"
m~UJ
~,,~
>-J;'l>'O
"'"
'" ~
co
n n ~
'D H trJ
" >
~ "
~ E~.
t'J ~-'
~>';
'C''l;I~
~ &; tIJ
i.rtDUJ
~ ~
~r~
~
~
~
o
o
o
I
~ "
r r
:1
" =:
, .
, ~
'" ~
. .
, .
~
o
o
Q.
.
>o~
~~&i
0>
~ ~
~
~
~
~
w
o
~
~
w
~
e.
~
"
".
~
~.
,
Q.
o
.
o
~
,
,
,
,
'tl :::: l-
. . "
on . _
. , "
<
,
.,
c
c
N:--< \D
< .
~ ~
~
r:: :;
iI~"
'3~n~::e'
il.'
I ,
I '
:,IlJ.,'
I i
'I
---'
~ 'I
o II I
--1---
~
cr
w
W
"
"
w
~ ~
.~
C
&
,
,
,
,
c
~
"
c
,
,
~
~ c ,
. . ,
<0 . ,
0 " ,
"
,
"
0
c
" ~
-I, w ~ 0
w M "
r
< ~
H W
~ ~
"
___L__~
,,-
--
1<-='\lS:T::. ~ .::.j
EXEC(;TJVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to approve a re-conveyancc unused portions of certain dedicated rights-
of-way in Immokalee's Newmarket Subdivision.
OBJECTIVE: To obtain the BOaI'd of County Conunissioners' approval to convey by
quitclaim deeds certain portions of right-ol-way dedicated as Charlotte and Broward Street by
the Newmarket Plat.
CONSIDERATIONS: On June 5, liJ5l the Board of County Conunissioners approved the
plat of Newmarket Subdivision rccorded at Plat Book 1, Pages I 04- I 05. The plat dedicated
certain 80-foot rights-of-way named Broward Street and Charlotte Street to the public. These
two streets converge at a f0l1y-five degree anglc just north of Block 47 and terminate at that
location. The CUlTent owners of the land adjoining these dedicated rights-of-way have requested
re-conveyance under s. 255.22, Fla. Stat., of those portions of eharJotte and Broward Streets
which are cross-hatched on the attached drawing. and more fully described in the attached deeds.
Section 255.22, Fla. Stat.. provides tbat ''[]jn the event any party owning adjoining land conveys
real ])J'Op'cI1y, without receipt of \'aluable consideration. to any municipality or county for a
specific purpose or use and if such cOllnty llr municipality fails to use such properly for such
pUl1Jose f;Jr a period of 60 consecutive months. .then, upon written dCl11and of the grantor. or
grantor's successors in title owning such adjoining land. the municipality or county may cxecute
and deliver a quitclaim deed to the pal1y making such demand provided such pal1y is the owner
of land adjoining such propel1y on at least one side." The statute provides fUl1her that if the
purpose for which the propel1y is conveyed requires maintenance, and the county fails to
maintain such property for the 60 month period, the County is deemed to have abandoned the
propeliy for the purpose of which it was conveyed. These portions of Charlotte and Broward
Street have never been utilized or maintained by the County. Rather, the owner of Block 47, The
Dorsey Curtis Ratliff Trust, and the owners of Lots 6-10 of Block 48, .Ten')l and Kimberlea
Blocker, to a lesser extent, have utilized file subject property as their own. As can be seen in the
attached aerial photograph, the land is currently being used as a junkyard. These operations
have resulted in enforcement action by the Florida Dep3l1ment of Environmental Protection
(FDEP) for violation of state regulations regarding the storage of waste and tires on site. Any
person with an ownership interest in this site, which now includes the subject rights-of-way
bordering Block 47, may by liable for civil and possibly criminal penalties for the environmental
vio lations.
The Blockers and the Ratliff Trust have agreed to entry of the attached Consent Order. This
order will be entered after recording of the conveyances. Staff is requesting filat the delivery of
these conveyances be conditioned on the cxecution of the Consent Order and review by the
County Attorney's Office.
Due to filc abandonment of these rights-oj~way dccades ago under 255.22, Fla. Stat., and the
pending FDEP action, it is recommended that the Board authorize the re-conveyance of these
lands by execution of the attached quit claim deccls. This action will clear title and avoid any
potcntial liability on thc [Xlii of the County resulting fi'Oln the FOEP action and the adjoining
o\\.'ners' use.
FISCAL IMPACT: None. All recording fees will be paid by the grantees. Moreover, the
conveyance of these rights-of-way insulates the county ii-om potential clean-up costs associated
with the Florida DEP cnforcement action against the adjoining property owners.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
RECOMMENDA nON:
That the Board of County Commissioncrs:
1. Approl'c the rc-conveyance of those portions of Charlotte and Broward Street
depicted on the attached plat and more fully described in the attached quitclaim deeds:
2. Authorize the Chairman to execute the quit claim deeds and dcliver same to
County A\tol11ey's Office:
, Authorize the escrow of said dccds until such time as an executed Conscnt Order
h<:.:s been rc\'ie\\'~d by the County AUprnc),'":-; Of1ice: and
PREP ARi,[) BY: Ellcn T. Chadwell. Assis',ant Counlv AUor!lc\
.kerr-C\. A. Klatzkc'\\". Chicf Assistant County .'\\10111e\
(J":'-( '().\-(l(i(l(l};2
2
COLLIER COUNTY
_'C ,: '~r
',,!ur,'~' ,~<;,~
Item Number:
Item Summary:
~'C '
'J~" .
Meeting Date:
I'n.r}~rcd B~
1.'.:1"" c:",o.,1'i""
'S13,,1 [.ct" " , ...110H"."
:')~l<
".I''',,''
, ',,,,, ~"i ;" t1 or".'.' " 'F: ,r:,
/(':2l'~" ... "-,' I: ;:.'r,'
Approved II.,
!:i'Co"
"tin-
Approved By
"I,:
j""; <, :1:,
~".,'~ta,"
;,tw,,'~-
,:t
,w: \1',.,'
. co,;r" t;-".".", ~'.'H,c,,'
,,:t;:""
t,;>,
i\pprnvcd 11\
""'I:"
".,,,'
Approvt'd I"
\I'pron.(] g,
-\PI'I"O\'l'd 11_,
." -.,,,,,.., ".""....,,,,'"". ,/ (\ ,","r',nT'-'-~"'"",,,,,,
l':l!1cloJI
....- ..
t;;G<~'
;.~ :il.
f4.q-.C4' "<'O:'~.
'"
-~.,
_-c
..~~
!$ -,
__,";C,:.~
~
~'"
_ J' r~
1"":;:-
~.".-m
0.'~~~~
i.-."
~r4o.,.
;ti:l
-'.
..;:;: '"
;:z
<:
~~-;""'f'1;:.i
.~,:;-:~';<'
't.n.-;-. !:_
!b;'; '. '.-!.
'4~" .j.'
,C-_:,~'t-,
~(p-", ,;:~.
,.;.~
=.:,:~;..'s::
;;;; ~._':i.~..f
~-;- ,~
z,--=-- 1':
:w
~>='^s-:
;:t:' :~t:
~____'i:
w.~"o't.,
".t-
I;to"'~..
.!:S' ',,^,,
:~.-
:~--
'"
';(l,.:
~j.:J~~:
~t
&-'~:::~:~-
~
',p-..
".I)',
!l;
"~
'.re
';."1 ,':.;C'
e,; . o~:,:"
.;.;.t:".,.
w~ ';;:1:';
.0..'.
-',
;:5,- ';~i:.-; ,..-;::-~
.,,'"~.0i:,
'- 3.".'
'.!E-'
.....,.
~J-.
-
v,. ..:
DRAFT
BEFORE THE ST ATE OF FLORIDA
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT
OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION,
IN THE OFFICE OF THE
SOUTH DISTRICT
Complainant,
OGC CASE NO. 07-1269
V5.
ROBERT HUDGINS,
THE DORSEY CURTIS RATLIFF TRUST,
JERRY BLOCKER, and
KIlv1BERLEA BLOCKER,
Respondents.
/
CO "-'SENT ORDER
This Consent Order is entered into among the State of Florida Department of
Environmental Protection ("Department") Robert Hudgins, the Dorsey Curtis Ratliff
Trust, Jerry Blocker and Kimberlea Blocker ("Respondents") to reach settlement of
certain matters at issue between the Department and Respondents.
The Department finds and the Respondents admit the following:
1. The Department is the administrative agency of the State of Florida
having the power and duty to administer and enforce the provisions of Chapter 403,
Florida Statutes ("Fla. Stat.O), and the rules promulgated thereu:1der, Title 62, Florida
Administrative Code ("Fla. Admin. Code"). The Department has jurisdiction over the
matters addressed in this Consent Order.
2. Respondent Robert Hudgins is a natural person who operates an
automotive dismantling and recycling business on a parcel of real property located at
106 Dixie Avenue East, Immokalee, Collier County, Florida.
3. Respondent Dorsey Curtis Ratliff Trust is [iI1seijgeseript:foii] that owns
the property underlying the Charlotte Street right-of-way and the westerly 40 feet of the
Broward Street right-of-way.
4. Respondents Jerry and Kimberlea Blocker are natural persons who own
the property underlying the easterly 40 feet of the Broward Street right-of-way.
5. Respondents are perso:l.s within the meaning of Section 403.031(5), Florida
Statutes.
6. Department inspections conducted on September 26, 2006 and January 4,
2007 revealed that between 20,000 and 40,000 waste tires and incidental solid waste are
located in lmmokalee, Collier County, Florida on the undeveloped rights-of-way
platted as Charlotte Street and Broward Street abutting Strap No. 520300 4711E34 to its
north and east (hereinafter "Property"). A copy of the Property record and aerial
photograph are attached and hereby incorporated as Exhibit I.
7. The Department finds that the following violations occurred:
a. Respondents have not obtained a Department permit to store waste
tires on the Property, in violation of Fla. Admin. Code Rules 62-
701.300(1)(a) and 62-711.400(1).
b, The waste tires are stored within 200 feet of a natural or artificial
body of water, in violation of Fla. Admin. Code Rule 62-711.540(3)(a).
2
c. Respondents have not provided for control of mosquitoes to
protect the public health and welfare, in violation of Fla. Admin. Code
Rule 62-711.540(1)0).
d. Respondents have not kept the Property free of grass, underbrush,
and other potentially flammable vegetation at all times, in violation of Fla.
Admin. Code RUle 62-711.540(3)(f).
e. Respondents have not complied with the waste tire storage
requirements set forth in Fla. Admin. Code R. 62-711.540.
8. Having reached a resolution of the matter the Department and the
Respondents mutually agree and it is,
ORDERED:
9. R"spondents shall not bring any additional waste tires or solid waste onto
the Property.
10. Respondent Robert Hudgins shall comply with the following corrective
actions within the stated time periods:
a. Respondent shall forthwith comply with all Department rules
regarding solid waste management and waste tire storage. Respondent shall
correct and address all violations in the time periods required below and shall
. amply with all applicable rules in Fla. Admin. Code Chapters 62-701 and 62-
711.
b. Within 180 days of the effective date of this Consent Order,
Respondent shall properly recycle or dispose of all waste tires on the Property.
3
-,.::.\"
-,r-..c-;
All recycling or disposal shall be at a facility permitted or registered by the
Department. Respondent shall submit receipts verifying proper disposal or
recycling to the Department within fifteen (15) days of removing the waste tires
from the Property. The waste tire removal shall be in accordance with the waste
removal schedule, attached and hereby incorporated as Exhibit II. All waste tires
and incidental solid waste shall be removed from the Property within 180 days of
entry of this Consent Order.
c. Respondent shall segregate, and properly manage and dispose of,
any incidental solid V\yaste encountered \r\yhile removing the \vaste tires. If any
spe:ial waste, such as usee oil or lead-acid batteries is discovered, Respondent
shall promptly notify the Department and shall store and dispose of the waste in
accordance with the applicable rules and statutes.
d. The Department will not require Respondent Robert Hudgins to
obtain a general permit to operate mobile waste tire processing equipment on the
Property as long as Respondent performs the tire abatement in compliance with
the tem1S of this Consent Order.
11. Respondents Jerry and Kimberlea Blocker shall remain liable to the
Department for removal of the tires and incidental solid waste on the easterly 40 feet of
the Broward Street right-of-way if Respondent Robert Hudgins fails to perform the tire
abatement in accordance with Paragraph 10 of this Consent Order.
12. The Department shall perform inspections at regular intervals to monitor
the progress of waste removal from the Property. If any waste removal deadline is not
4
met, the Department will notify all Respondents in writing, and ALL waste tires must
then be removed in a manner approved by the Department within thirty (30) days of
receipt of such notification.
13. In the event that Respondent Robert Hudgins fails to meet any deadline
for removal of tires from the Property in accordance with Paragraph 10 of this Consent
Order, Respondents Robert Hudgins, the Dorsey Curtis Ratliff Trust, Jerry Blocker and
Kimberlea Blocker agree to allow the Department access to the Property to initiate site
stabilization and abatement, with the understanding that the Department will seek cost
reCo\'ery from the Property Q\!'.'ners tor site stabilization and/ or abatement activities
conducted bv the Department or its desigr,ated contractors.
14. Within thirty (30) days of the effective date of this Consent Order,
Respondent Dorsev Curtis Ratliff Trust shall pay the Department $1,000 for costs and
expenses incurred during the investigation of this matter and the preparation and
tracking of this Consent Order. Payment shall be made by cashier's check or money
order payable to the "State of Florida Department of Environmental Protection" and
shall include thereon the OGC case number assigned to this case and the notation
"Ecosystem Management and Restoration Trust Fund." The payment shall be sent to
Department of Environmental Protection, P.O. Box 2549, Fort Myers, Florida 33902-
2549.
15. If any event, including administrative or judicial challenges by third
parties unrelated to the Respondents, occurs which causes delay or the reasonable
likelihood of delay, in complying with the requirements of this Consent Order,
5
;':,!,
CJ;
Respondents shall have the burden of proving the delay was or will be caused by
circumstances beyond the reasonable control of the Respondents and could not have
been or cannot be overcome by Respondents' due diligence. Economic circumstances
shall not be considered circumstances beyond the control of Respondents, nor shall the
failure of a contractor, subcontractor, materialman or other agent (collectively referred
to as "contractor") to whom responsibility for performance is delegated to meet
contractually imposed deadlines be a cause beyond the control of Respondents, unless
the cause of the contractor's late performance was also beyond the contractor's control.
Upon occurrence of an event causing delay, or upon becoming aware of a potential for
delay, Respondents shall notify the Department orally within 24 how's or by the next
working dav and shall, within seven calendar davs of oral notification to the
~ .
Department, notify the Deparhnent in writing of the anticipated length and cause of the
delay, the measures taken or to be taken to prevent or minimize the delay and the
timetable by which Respondents intend to implement these measures. If the parties can
agree that the delay or anticipated delay has been or will be caused by circumstances
beyond the reasonable control of Respondents, the time for performance hereunder
shall be extended for a period equal to the agreed delay resulting from such
circumstances. Such agreement shall adopt all reasonable measures necessary to avoid
or minimize delay. Failure of Respondents to comply with the notice requirements of
this Paragraph in a timely manner shall constitute a waiver of Respondents' right to
request an extension of time for compliance with the requirements of this Consent
Order.
6
16. Respondent Dorsey Curtis Ratliff Trust shall publish the following notice
in a newspaper of daily circulation in Collier County, Florida. The notice shall be
published one time only within thirty (30) days after the effective date of the Consent
Order.
ST ATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
NOTICE OF CONSENT ORDER
The Department of Environmental Protection gives notice of agency action of
entering into a Consent Order with Robert Hudgins, the Dorsey Curtis Ratliff Trust,
Jerry Blocker and Kimberlea Blocker pursuant to Section 120.57(4), Florida Statutes. The
Consent Order addresses unauthorized disposal of waste tires on the property located
in lmmokalee, Collier County, ?lorida on the undeveloped rights-of-way platted as
Charlotte Street and Broward Sh-eet abutting Strap No. 520300 4711E34 to its north and
east. The Consent Order is available for public inspection during normal business
hours, 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., Monday through Friday, except legal holidays, at the
Department of Environmental Protection, South District Office, 2295 Victoria Avenue,
Suite 364, Fort Myers, FL 33902.
Persons whose substantial interests are affected by this Consent Order have a
right, pursuant to Sections 120.569 and 120.57, Florida Statutes, to petition for an
administrative hearing on it. The Petition must contain the information set forth below
and must be filed (received) at the Department's Office of General Counsel, 3900
Conunonwealth Boulevard, MS-35, Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3000, within 21 days of
receipt of this notice. A copy of the Petition must also be mailed at the time of filing to
7
, ~); .
0. ..:-'
the District Office named above at the address indicated. Failure to file a petition
within the 21 days constitutes a waiver of any right such person has to an
administrative hearing pursuant to Sections 120.569 and 120.57, Florida Statutes.
The petition shall contain the following information: (a) The name, address, and
telephone number of each petitioner; the Department's Consent Order identification
number and the county in which the subject rnatter or activity is located; (b) A
statement of how and when each petitioner received notice of the Consent Order; (c) A
statement of how each petitioner's substantial interests are affected by the Consent
Order; (d) A statement of the materia! facts disputed by petitioner, if any; (e) A
statement of facts which petitioner contends warrant reversal or modification of the
Consent Order; (f) A statement of which rules or statutes petitioner contends require
reversal or modification of the Consent Order; (g) A statement of the relief sought by
petitioner, stating precisely the action petitioner wants the Department to take with
respect to the Consent Order.
If a petition is filed, the administrative hearing process is designed to formulate
agency action. Accordingly, the Department's final action may be different from the
position taken by it in this Notice. Persons whose substantial interests will be affected
by any decision of the Department \ovith regard to the subject Consent Order have the
right to petition to become a party to the proceeding The petition must conform to the
requirements specified above and be filed (received) within 21 days of receipt of this
notice in the Office of General Counsel at the above address of the Department. Failure
to petition within the allowed time frame constitutes a waiver of any right such person
8
has to request a hearing under Sections 120.569 and 120.57, Florida Statutes, and to
participate as a party to this proceeding. Any subsequent intervention will only be at
the approval of the presiding officer upon motion filed pursuant to Rule 28-106,205,
Florida Administrative Code.
A person whose substantial interests are affected by the Consent Order may file a
timely petition for an administrative hearing under Sections 120.569 and 120.57, Florida
Statutes, or may choose to pursue mediation as an alternative remedy under Section
120.573, Florida Statutes, before the deadline for filing a petition. Choosing mediation
wiU not adversely affect the right to a hearing if mediation does not result in a
settlement. The procedures ror pursuing mediation are set rorth below.
Mediation may onlv take place if the Department and all the parties to the
proceeding agree that mediation is appropriate. A person may pursue mediation by
reaching a mediation agreement with all parties to the proceeding (which include the
Respondents, the Department, and any person who has filed a timely and sufficient
petition for a hearing) and by showing how the substantial interests of each mediating
party are affected by the Consent Order. The agreement must be filed in (received by)
the Office of General Counsel of the Department at 3900 Commonwealth Boulevard,
Mail Station 35, Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3000, within 10 days after the deadline as set
forth above for the filing of a petition.
The agreement to mediate must include the rollowing:
(a) The names, addresses, and telephone numbers of any persons who may
attend the mediation;
9
, I,.,
(b) The name, address, and telephone number of the mediator selected by the
parties, or a provision for selecting a mediator within a specified time;
(c) The agreed allocation of the costs and fees associated with the mediation;
(d) The agreement of the parties on the confidentiality of discussions and
documents introduced during mediation;
(e) The date, time, and place of the first mediation session, or a deadline for
holding the first session, if no mediator has yet been chosen;
(f) The name of each party's representative who shall have authority to settle or
recommend settlement; and
(g) Either an explanation of how the substantial interests of each mediating
party will be affected by the action or proposed action addressed in this notice of intent
or a statement clearly identifying the petition for hearing that each party has already
filed, and incorporating it by reference.
(h) The signatures of all parties or their authorized representatives.
As provided in Section 120.573, Florida Statutes, the tirnely agreement of all
parties to mediate will toll the time limitations imposed by Sections 120.569 and 120.57,
Florida Statutes, for requesting and holding an administrative hearing. Unless
otherwise agreed by the parties, the mediation must be concluded within sixty days of
the execution of the agreement. If mediation results in settlement of the administrative
dispute, the Department must enter a final order incorporating the agreement of the
parties, Persons whose substantial interests will be affected by such a modified final
decision of the Department have a right to petition for a hearing only in accordance
10
with the requirements for such petitions set forth above, and must therefore file their
petitions within 21 days of receipt of this notice. If mediation terminates without
settlement of the dispute, the Department shall notify all parties in writing that the
administrative hearing processes under Sections 120.569 and 120.57, Florida Statutes,
remain available for disposition of the dispute, and the notice will specify the deadlines
that then will apply for challenging the agency action and electing remedies under
those two statutes.
17. Entry of this Consent Order does not relieve Respondents of the need to
comply \^lith a?plicable federaL state or lo::::al1aV\'s, regulations or ordinances.
18. The terlT'.5 and conditions set forth in this Consent Order may be enforced
in a court of competent jurisdiction pursuant to Sections 120.69 and 403.121, Florida
Statutes. Failure to comply with the terms of this Consent Order shall constitute a
violation of Section 403.161(1)(b), Florida Statutes.
19. Respondents are fully aware that a violation of the terms of this Consent
Order may subject Respondents to judicial imposition of damages, civil penalties up to
$10,000 per day per violation and criminal penalties.
20. Respondents shall allow all authorized representatives of the Department
access to the property and facility at reasonable times for the purpose of determining
compliance with the terms of this Consent Order and the rules and statutes of the
Department.
11
,';2 ,. _'~'
21. All submittals and payments required by this Consent Order to be
submitted to the Deparhnent shall be sent to the Florida Department of Environmental
Protection, Waste Program, P.O. Box 2549, Fort Myers, Florida 33902-2549.
22. The Department hereby expressly reserves the right to initiate appropriate
legal action to prevent or prohibit any violations of applicable statutes, or the rules
promulgated thereunder that are not specifically addressed by the terms of this
Consent Order, including but not limited to undisclosed releases, contamination or
polluting conditions.
23. The Department, for and in coro.sideration of the complete and timely
perrorn1.ance by Responden:s of the obligations ag-reed to in this Consent Order, hereby
waives its right to seek judicial imposition of damages or civil penalties fo::, alleged
violations outlined in this Consent Order.
24. Respondents acknowledge and waive their right to an administrative
hearing pursuant to Sections 120.569 and 120.57, Florida Statutes, on the terms of this
Consent Order. Respondents acknowledges their right to appeal the terms of this
Consent Order pursuant to Section 120.68, Florida Statutes, and waive that right upon
signing this Consent Order.
25. No modifications of the terms of this Consent Order shall be effective until
reduced to writing and executed by Respondents and the Department.
26. In the event of a sale or conveyance of the Property, if all of the
requirements of this Consent Order have not been fully satisfied, Respondents shall, at
least 30 days prior to the sale or conveyance of the Property, (1) notify the Department
t2
of such sale or conveyance, (2) provide the name and address of the purchaser, and (3)
provide a copy of this Consent Order with all attachments to the new owner. The sale
or conveyance of the Property shall not relieve the Respondents of the obligations
imposed in this Consent Order.
27. This Consent Order is a settlement of the Department's civil and
administrative authority arising under Florida law to resolve the matters addressed
herein. This Consent Order is not a settlement of any criminal liabilities that may arise
under Florida law, nor is it a settlement of any violation that may be prosecuted
Giminallv or civilly under federal law.
. .
28. Respondents shall use all reasonable efforts to obtain any necessary access
for work to be performed in the impiementation of this Co:;sent Order. If necessary
access cannot be obtained, or if obtained, is revoked by owners or entities controlling
access to the properties to which access is necessary, Respondents shall notify the
Department within five (5) business days of such refusal or revocation. The
Department may at any time seek to obtain access as is necessary to implement the
terms of this Consent Order. The Respondents shall reimburse the Department for any
damages, costs, or expenses, including expert and attorneys fees, that the Department is
ordered to pay, or that the Department incurs in connection with its efforts to obtain
access as is necessary to implement thc tcrms of this Consent Order. Respondents shall
pay these sums to the Department or arrange a payment schedule with the Department
within 30 days of written demand by the Department.
13
',i
',':',~-;!'\:;.,'
29. This Consent Order is a final order of the Department pursuant to Section
120.52(7), Florida Statutes, and it is final and effective on the date filed with the Clerk of
the Department unless a Petition for Administrative Hearing is filed in accordance
with Chapter 120, Florida Statutes. Upon the timely filing of a petition this Consent
Order will not be effective until further order of the Department.
/-, ....J-
ROBERT HUDGlNS (~-,,4,.'
DATE
Title:
DORSEY CURTIS RATLFF TRUST
DATE
Title:
JERRY BLOCKER
DATE
KIMBERLEA BLOCKER
DATE
DONE AND ORDERED this
day of
200~
in Fort Myers, Florida.
STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT
14
OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
Jon M. Iglehart
Director of
District Management
FILING AND ACKNOWLEDGEMENT FILED, on this date, pursuant to
S120.52 Florida Statutes, with the designated Department Clerk, receipt of which is
hereby acknowledged.
Clerk
Date
I'
I.'
QUITCLAIM DEED
THIS QUITCLAIM DEED, executed this _ day of 2007, by the
Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, a political subdivision of the State
of Florida, whose address is 3301 E. Tamiami Trail, Naples, FL, Grantor, to The Dorsey Curtis
Ratliff Trust dated February 2,1995, whose address is 106 Dixie Avenue, Immokalee, Florida
34 I 42, Grantee.
(Vv'herever used herein the terms "Grantor" and "Grantee" shall include singular and
plural, heirs, legal representatives, and assigns of individuals, and the successors and
assigns of corporations, wherever the context so admits or requires.)
WITNESSETH. that Grantor, for and in consideration of the SUITI of ($10.00) and other
good and valuable considerations, the receipt and sufficiency whereof is hereby acknowledged,
having neither utilized the below described propeny for a public purpose nor exercised control
over said propcrty, doc:: hereby r~n1ise. release and quit-clairn, pursuant to s. 255.22, Fla. Stat..
unto Grantee forever. all the right title, interest, claim and dema.'1d which the said Grantor has in
and to the following described property situate.. lying and being in Collier County, Florida, to
VI'it:
See Exhibit "A," attached hereto and incorporated herein by reference
Subject to reservations, restrictions and easements of record, and taxes for the current year.
TO HAVE AND TO HOLD the SaITIe together with all the tenements, hereditaments,
and appurtenances thereto belonging or in anywise appertaining, and all the estate, right, title,
interest, lien, equity and claim whatsoever of the said Grantor, for the benefit of Grantee forever.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the said Grantor has signed and sealed this deed on the day
and year first above \vritten.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, Chairman
NAPLES!3JOJI4v02
EXHIBIT "A"
10f2
Legsl Description
PARCEL "A"
Commencing at the westerly corner of Block 47, NEWMARKET SUBDIVISION;
thence N. 44'05'70" E. along the easterly Right-of-way of Charlotte Street,
o distance of 375.39 feet to 0 point of intersection with the westerly
right-of-way of Broword Street;
thence S. 15"15'10" W. along the westerly right-of-way of BToword Street,
a distance of 428.55 feet, to the southeasterly corner of Block 47;
thence S. 74'45'20 E. 0 distance of 40.00 feet, to the centerline of
Sroword Street; 6 . .
thence Iv. 75.75'10"~. along the centerline of Sroward Street, a distance
of 494.72 feet, to the nortner/y DIOt b:Juncfo."y of IvEWMAR.~~~T SUBDI\~ISION;
then:.-'s N. 74 '45'20" V1< along the northerly bouno'ory of N~Wtv:ARKtT
SUBDIVISION, 0 distance of 75.25 feet,'
thence S. 44"05'10" 1-'1< a/ong the wesle,rly plat boundary of NEWMARKET
SUBDIVISION, 0 distance ::d 400.15 feet;
thence S. 45054'50" E o:::ross the right-or-way of Charlotte Street, 0
disiance of 80.0C feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING.
Containing 7.21 acres. mace or iess.
Prepared by:
P.S.&M.
Certificate No. 2982
ovember 20, 2007
C 07. 0244.1
--~,
,il ~
;! I
i
.Ii
~
.I~
.II ~
1m
:!~I
!iI!
~!II
Iq
Hi
Iii
~
I
/
q /
/
~ /
~ /
~ /
~ /
/
~ /
~ /
~
/ ~
~
/
/
/
/
~
i I
~ i
I
J!
~J
- ~'::j~-S 20 c'i /
:!r
I"
EXHIBIT
20f2
IIA"
"$-
~
is'
!
'"
',,- ..:........ ~
',- q,.~-lo..
~ .......
~+ ~~~!>+ ~~
~~~ ~~.,~
~~:, ., '''~
,If 't\:~~ '""-,
40- m ''\.~ ."
/ I "J "~''''''-''''
~ /J ~~ "-
I ~! ~ ';~::;/:"--.....
'" 'I -....,'. . ..-:." ~ ,''.
,...:,;...; '<":' ',. '... I ,-,..... '.
'~,.,"'.", ....~'" ,. ..... '" .....
~ -.,~ "'~ .....".....
'~"..J : ,......:.. /, ..... II't
~..,,-,::."~/.. .. :, " ",'.
I '__~,~&llO" "< ~...~, '. !/.~..
=.~ I "~ ~ ,,;-4
/ "''''/~ ~.,~,.:. j.'.1
/ '~,~ i<:
_ !OJ
/~' '
/,.. 'E ~/---~ I~n
/ '" 0 ~ / ~,I''''
~ ~ / / ~ ~ 'i~'
/ ~ /
/ ~ /
/ /
/ /
/ /
/
/
~
~
/.~
'~,
/
/
/
/
~
~
i5
"I
!,
~~~~t~l;;:!~j:-_.
illH"l,tii~i~i~1
'1'11'1 '/111'111
1" III l':'1 '
~~ i:1
~~
lffiW;!f!(m!1 Jl~;!
lll~f'~*l i~~f!l' fjl [I,'
I'l .fIl.S...... iif iI'
!'li11:t ':i!if H,
'c" 'I: f" i'l III If I
l! lil i~ ,'Ii q/d. ·
I' I hi ~l t, < l:ill [
, ,;:.. III 'f j .
11'~ !!i nil iff! =
! hi!}! ili
, I
THIS INSTRUMt:NT PREPARED
WITHOUT OPINION OF TITLE BY:
Patrick G, While. Esq.
Poner V./right Morris & Arthur, LLP
5801 Pelican Bay Blvd.. Suite 300
Naples. FL 34108-2709
QUITCLAIM DEED
THIS QUITCLAIM DEED, executed this day of 2007, by the
Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, a political subdivision of the State
of Florida, whose address is 3301 E. Tamiami TraiL Naples, FL, Grantor, to Jerry and
Kirnberlea Blocker. a married couple, whose address is 1830 16TH Street NE, Naples, Florida
34120-5446, Grantees.
(\\!herever used herein the terms "Grantor" and "Grantee" shall include singular
anC: plural. heirs, i~gal r~pr~s~ntaljves, and assigns of indi\'iduals, and the
succ~ssors and assigns of corporations, whercver the context so admits or
requires. )
WIP,ESSETH. tha: Grantor. for and in consideration of the sum of ($1 (1.00) and other
good and valuahle considerations, the receipt and sufficiency wher~of is hereby acknowledged.
having neither utilized the below described propcrty for a public purpose nor cxerciscd control
over said property, does hereby remise, release and quit-claim, pursuant to s. 255.22, Fla. Stat..
unto Grantee forever, all the right. title, interest, claim and demand which the said Grantor has in
and to the following described property situate, lying and being in Collier County, Florida, to
wit:
THE EASTERLY MOST TWENTY FEET OF THE EASTERLY FORTY FEET OF
THE BROWARD STREET RIGHT-OF-WAY LYING ADJACENT TO LOTS 6 THROUGH
10 OF BLOCK 48 OF THE NEWMARKET SUBDIVISION, AS RECORDED IN PLAT
BOOK 1, PAGES 104 & 105, OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF COLLIER COUNTY,
FLORDlA.
. and subject to all other reservations, restrictions and easements of record, and
taxes for the current year.
which property is not the homestead of Grantor, Grantor's spouse or any minor children of
Grantor.
TO HA YE AND TO HOLD the san1e together with all the tenements, hereditaments,
and appurtenances thereto belonging or in anywise appertaining, and all the estate, right, title,
interest, lien, equity and claim whatsoever of the said Grantor, either in law or equity, to the
profit, use, benefit and advantage of the said Grantee forever.
NAI'LES/JJO:;14 vU:
.;C;.,
, :ce. '''''\ ') ~:~ '
::' ~>;)c =:; ~T ='~'
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the said Grantor has signed and sealed this deed on the day
and year first above written.
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIO:-.iERS
OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, Chairman
NAPLES/33m 14 \' 02
2
THIS INSTRUM[NT PREPARED
WITHOUT OPINION OF TITLE BY
Patrick G. White, Esq
Pcmer Wright Morris & Arthur, LLP
5801 Pelican Bay Blvd" Suite 300
Naples, FL 34108.2709
QUITCLAIM DEED
THIS QUITCLAIM DEED, executed this _ day of 2007, by the
Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, a political subdivision of the State
of Florida, whose address is 3301 E. Tamiami Trail, Naples, FL, Grantor, to Jerry and
Kimberlea Blocker, a married couple. whose address is 1830 16TH Street "iE, Naples, Florida
34120-5446, Grantees,
(Wherever used herein the terms "Grantor" and "Grantee" shall include singular
and pluraL heirs. legal representatives. and assigns of individuals. and the
successors and assigns of corporations. wherever the context so admits or
requIres, )
WITNESSETH. that Grantor, for and in consideration of the sum of ($10,00) and other
good and valuable considerations. the receipt and sufficiency whereof is hereby acknowledged.
having neither utilized the below described property for a public purpose nor exercised control
over said property, does hereby remise. release and quit-claim, pursuant to s, 255,22, Fla, Stat,
unto Grantee forever, all the right, title, interest, claim and demand which the said Grantor has in
and to the following described property situate. lying and being in Collier County, Florida, to
wit:
THE WESTERLY MOST TWENTY FEET OF THE EASTERLY FORTY FEET OF
THE BROWARD STREET RIGHT-OF-WAY LYING ADJACENT TO LOTS 6 THROUGH
10 OF BLOCK 48 OF THE "iEWMARKET SUBDIVISION, AS RECORDED IN PLAT
BOOK I, PAGES 104 & 105, OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF COLLIER COUNTY,
FLORDIA,
. and subject to all other reservations, restrictions and easements of record, and
taxes for the current year.
which property is not the homestead of Grantor, Grantor's spouse or any minor children of
Grantor,
TO HAVE AND TO HOLD the same together with all the tenements, hereditaments,
and appurtenances thereto belonging or in anywise appertaining, and all the estate, right, title,
interest, licn, equity and claim whatsoever of the said Grantor, either in law or equity, to the
profit, use, benefit and advantage of the said Grantee forever,
Page] of2
/'"iU "
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the said Grantor has signed and sealed this deed on the day
and year first above written,
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E, BROCK, CLERK
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
, Deputy Clerk
JAMES COLETTA, Chairman
NAPLES-#33I 802~v2
!~sn: ;'.1:.;, 1Gf<~
:-"J0\''?m;J0)~ :27. 20U7
~. of 12
-
EXECl1TIVE SUMMARY
Request by the Housing Finance Authority of Collier County for approval ofresolution
authorizing the Authority to issue single family housing revenue bonds to be used to finance a
qualifying single family project to provide affordable workforce housing,
OBJECTIVE:
To accomplish the necessary approvals to authorize a proposed single family revenuc
bond issue by the Housing Finance Authority to bc utilized for financing a single family project
to provide affordable workforce housing,
CONSIDER,^>. TlONS:
Fountain Lakes Residential Coop~rmivc Corporation (the "applical11"), a non-profit
corporation organized as a residential coop~rativc under Flonda Statutes. has applied to the
Housing Finance Authority for the is:..:;uancc of tax-CXCll1pt bonds to finance the construction of a
qualifying single family housing project. The projcct consists of the construction of 147 single
- family residential units to be constructed in seven threc-s1<11')' buildings. The units are priced to
be affordable to. and will be marketed to, persons whose income does not exceed 140% of area
median income (AMI), It is expected that at least half ofthe units will bc purchased by persons
who are employees of the entities that comprise the Essential Services Pcrsonnel Coalition of
Collier County (ESPCC), whose members are:
School District of Collier County
Sheriff's Office of Collier County
NCH Healthcare
Physicians Regional Medical Center
Anchor Health Centers
City of Naples
In order to create housing at the desired affordable levels, the project will be financed
with a combination of some or all of the following loans, grants or deferrals:
*Tax-exempt bonds to be issued by Housing Finance Authority of Collier County
*Community Workforce Housing Innovation Pilot Program (CWHIP) loan or grant
*State Housing Initiatives Partnership (SHIP) loan
*Collier County Impact Fee deferral
.-
The applicant has been selected by the ESPCC as the private partner to apply for funds
under the CWHIP program, which provides low interest loans or grants for eligible and selected
C:\JI,1yhle,\docllmcn1'Jl0F A-Fountain Lakes\BCC. E.xec summary,d,),
workforce housing projects. The CWHIP program was created by legislation enacted by the
State under the guidance or the late Mike Davis,
The project is located on the east side of Collier Boulevard, south of 1-75 and north of
U.S, 41, It is part of the First Assemblies Ministries Education and Rehabilitation Campus ruo.
and an application is pending to amcnd the PUD to permit the single family housing project in
lieu of the mobile homes and 400 bed ALF that are euncntly the pcnnillcd uses under the PLiO,
Notc there is no connection between the project and thc First Assemblies Church within the
reo,
The creator of the applicant cooperative co!voration, and the devcloper. is MOG Capital
Corporation. an experienced developer of am,rdablc housing projects in Collier County.
including Arrowhead Reserve at Lake Tram,rd, a project in Immokalce that will provide 1.245
aiTordablc units at buildout and is cUITently about 25% completc,
On l\ovemOcr 14. the Authority held a public hearing on the financing application, The
developer had filed a detailed financing application, and presented the projecI to the Authority,
The bonds wi]] be secured hy a direct-pm letter o!' credit proposed to be issued hv BB&T BanL.
and will CatTY an inVeSl111cnt t:rud:;.' raling. l\Cl l11;:I11b~rs o;'th:: public COmlllen1ecL either befort'
or at the meeting. .,\1 the cnnc]usio!1 (iflL:;: l1leclin~. the Authority adopted its resolution
rrdiminarily approving tbe issuanc;: of ti)(' hond;;;, subject in the prcs~nlatj()ll of acceptable
fInancing agreements. and the receipt or an allocation of slat::: privale activity' volume cap.
In addition to AuthoriIy appro\'aL federal tax law requires that the County Commission.
as the local govcming body, must also approvc thc issuance ofthc tax-exempt bonds, This docs
not have to be a specially advenised hearing. but must be done at a regularly noticcd and held
meeting, A Resolution for the Board to adopt is attached,
As are all revenue bonds of this type, the bonds arc based on revenues ofthe project and
arc not obligations of the County. therefore therc is no pledgc or any taxes. nor a pledge of any
revenues except the revenues of the project. l"either the County, the Board, nor any officer or
the County is liable for their payment. Further. the Resolution cxpressly provides that this
approval by the Board does not abrogate any County regulations, including land use regulations,
FISCAL I\1PACT: There is no adverse fiscal impact from the issuance of these bonds. Thc
bond program docs not requirc any contribution ii'omthc Board of County Commissioners or
any other County agcncy (notc that impact fee dcfclTals arc available pursuant to county
regulations rcgardless of the bonding status), Thesc bonds arc not liabilities of the County. and
the County is not liable illr payment in any way, The issuancc ofthcse Bonds will havc no
impact on the ability of the Count)' to issue "bank qualiiied" debt. On the othcr hand, the
provision of adequate alTordable and work-brce housing docs have a positive fiscal impact on
the community.
GROWTH MANAGEMEl\T IMPACT: The adoption ofthc attached resolution will have no
(' \h'hie,-.dOCLJ"'<:TL: H(lj'/\-I-'HJlIl;lllI :.JI;e,'-,!:l('('.I'"oc- 'lImm"",_,I,,,
adverse growth management imp"cl. On the other hand, it will assist in providing affordable
housing in Collier County. and the County is committed to "ssist in the creation of affordable
housing by its Growth Management Plan, Note that the Board Resolution specifically provides
that the approval of the bond issue by the AuthOlity does not abrogate any County regulations
including but not limited to the Growth Management Plan, the Land Development Code and all
concurrency regulations.
RECOMMENDATION:
That the Board of County Commissioners adopt the attached resolution,
Prepared by:
Don"ld A. Pickworth. Counsel
Housing Finance .Authority' o/'ColJicr Coun!)
/\pprc)\'ccl by:
Du\'id C. \f\7eigcL COUllly Attorney
COLLIER CO[l~TY
r~:n :l'
Item Number:
IlemSummary:
""J 1'0"'''' ""-'.'11"':'
"U'I'.:1c-
:'wr;n u:')
-':)1'-
Meeting Date:
.r,_;
PreJlared lIy
[J,lV,,;.:'I',"'-IJ0'
CAin; "nn,.,-,
;:.13'"
CUU"II\(,,,,;(,,,
C:,,,,.,. {.[lurw- UihG'
Apprnn'dtJ)
,,,,,,,-
'-'~'.(
f.,no',j('
"-tt."rl1' -,,'In;;
I~"'::(j")- ;- c- PI"
ApI.rnn'd Ih
'.H'"-,, ~.f,';""'..'n~-
",
;:;.,.
''','!n,,'''' 1[-:-'
",.',':,("- ";D"
'\Pllrun.t1111
,-,,"'j '(.'
";"",,',0"
'\pprn\~d II.'
I~l.>_ ,'i(' A ,,,,.,,4..T,,,,,\, L,,~,,~,\(l, }..,C', <>,~,I~_~"._ '1rn"7 Q: ")In'"17\ 1/. 0 'l1\(,(\I.1<.'L"'TU '11." r,r;"T
)'agc I o( 1
UO'>! l' . ",_ L'.
1 I ,'"){j.'")fllY"7
";r.'
DONALD i\.. PICKWORTH, EA.
ATTORNEY AT LAW
SUITE 502 NEWGATE TOWER
fi150 NORTH TAMIAMI TRAIL
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34103
e-mail: pick1aw@ellrUilink.nel
(239) 263 - 8060
FA.X (239) 598 -1161
November 14, 2007
David C. Weigel, Esquire
Collier County Attorney
Collier County Courthouse/Bldg F
Naples, FL 34112
Re: Novemher 27,2007 Agenda
Dear David:
I am enclosing the following documents for inclusion in the November 27, 2007
Agenda:
1, Executive Summary reiating to approval of Housing Finance Authority Single
Family Revenue Bonds for affordable housing facilities,
"
Resolution to be adopted by the Board of County Commissioners at the Board
meeting of November 27, 2007 approving the Bonds,
3.
Exhibit A to County Resolution consisting of the Inducement Resolution
adopted hy the Authority at its meeting on November 14, and including as an
exhibit to the Inducement Resolution, the Affidavit of Publication for the
required TEFRA hearing conducted by the Authority,
Since we have been placing these items on the Consent Agenda recently, I would
request that this also be on Consent. Thank you for your assistance in this, and if you have
any questions or need further information, please contact me.
Very truly yours,
Ji1f
Donald A, Pickworth
Enclosures
~, ::-:-::;
RESOLUTION 2007-
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, APPROVING THE ISSUAC'lCE BY THE
HOUSING FINANCE AUTHORITY OF COLLIER COUNTY TAX-
EXEMPT SINGLE-F AMIL Y MORTGAGE REVENUE BONDS,
(FOUNTAIN LAKES PROJECT) PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 159, PART
IV, FLORIDA STATUTES, AS AMENDED.
WHEREAS. the Housing Finance Authority of Collier County (the "Issuer") is a
public corporation of the State of Florida, was duly created by Ordinance No, 80-66 of the Board
of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida. and is a body corporate and politic duly
created and existing as a local governmental body and a public instrumentality for the PUlvose of
assisting qualifying housing projects situated in Collier County. Florida (the "County"). under
and by vil1ue of Chapter 159. Part IV. Florida Statutes. (the "Act"), to provide for the issuance of
and to issue and sell its obligations for lawful purposes under the Act: and
'VHEREAS, as set f0l1h in the resolution ofthc Authority described below. Fountain
Lakes Residential Coopcrative COlvoration, a Florida non-proiit cOll)()ration. Ic)r and on behalr
of itself and/or its related emilies (the "Company"). has requesIcd the Authority to issue its
Single Family Mortgage Revcnue Bonds ill an initial principal amountnoI to exceed
$25.000.000 (the "Bonds") iClr the bencJit of the Company and to loan all or a pOJ1ion of the
pmcecds thereoftothc Companv to iinancc the costs orthe Project. as defined hcrein: and
WHEREAS, the "Project" shall consist of the acquisition. construction and equipping or
approximately 150 single family residential housing units to be occupied by pcrsons oflow and
moderate income or who are otherwise "eligible persons" as defincd by applicable regulations:
and
WHEREAS, the Authority caused notice of a public hearing to consider approval of the
Bonds and the location and nature of the Project to be financed with the proceeds of the Bonds to
be published on October 29. 2007 in the Naples Daily News. a newspaper of general circulation
in the County, and a copy of said notice is attached as Exhibit A (the "Notice") to thc AuthOlity
Resolution described below: and
WHEREAS, the Authority held a public hearing on November 14,2007, pursuant to the
Notice and has adopted its Resolution 2007-] (the "Authority Resolution"). a copy of which is
attached hercto as Exhibit A. approving the issuance of the Bonds and recommending and
requesting that the Board or County Commissioners approve the issuancc of the Bonds so that
the interest on the Bonds will be exempt from federal income taxation under applicable
provisions of Section 147(a) of the Internal Rcyenue Codc of 1986. as amended: and
WHEREAS, Section 147(t) of the Internal Revenuc Code of 1986. as amended (the
"Code"), provides that the elected legislativc body of the governmental unit which has
jurisdiction over the arca in which the facility financed with the proceeds of tax exempt bonds is
located is to approve the issuance of such bonds aftcr a public hewing; and
CC', ~ h' File.' ,,j(KUn,en!', 1101"..,_(; \\'Car\',r'., lice R (':;, wpd
V./HEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners of Collicr County. Florida (the
"Board") is the elccted legislativc body of thc County: and
\VHEREAS, for the reasons sct forth above. the Board desires to approve the issuance of
such Bonds for the purposes of Section 147(1) of the Code,
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLYED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that:
Section 1. Approval (If [s.,uallce (~f the BOllds. This Board hereby approves the
issuance of the Bonds by the Authority ]e,r the purposcs of Section] 47(f) ofthc Code,
The Bonds shall not constitute a debt. liability or obligation of Collier County. its Board
of County Commissioners. officers. agcnts or employees. or the State of Florida or any political
subdivision therco[ but shall be payable solely from tbe rc\'enues pro\'ided tbercJ'or. and neither
the faith and erediI nor an\' laxing powcr of Collier CounIy or the State of Florida or any political
subdi\'ision thereof is pledged lothe p"yment of the' principal (d: premium. if an\'. and interest on
the Bonds. ~0 mC111her of the Board or County Commission:::rs of Collier County or an)' of1iccr
Of enlployee thereof shaH be liable p:..TSOl1;tliy on the Bl)Ild~ by reason or their issuance.
This apprmal shall in no way be (leemcd lo abrogate a11\ regulaIions of Collier County
applicable tel the project and the projccI sball be subjecI tel all such regulations. including. but not
limited to. the Growth J\1anag:..:mcn1 Pian. tll;:.' land cle\"(']opm:::nt n:gulalil)n~:. and 2lJ COl1CUnenl'Y
requirements of the appropriate .IurisdieIion,
Section 2. Effccti\'e Datc. This Resolution shall take elTeet immediately upon its
adoption,
PASSED AND ADOPTED THIS 27th day of November, 2007,
(SEAL)
ATTEST:
Dwight E, Brock, Clerk
COLLIER COLNTY. FLORIDA
By:
By:
Deputy Clerk
James Coletta. Chainnan
Board of County Commissioners or
Colli"r County. Florida
Approvcd as to form and legal sutIiciency:
David C. Weigcl
(:'\1\ FIi""..,I<luunCTll1IUI::,_(;\\ ( 'm""T 1FT Ite:"wl'"
County Attorney
(' :'..~1y F "'" ..1ocLJm~nr,H OF.;" - (, \\'( - '''' Tr'-IlCC K ,.,.. wpd
"_I'
~,
o
RESOLUTION 2007-1
RESOLUTION REGARDING THE OFFICIAL ACTION OF THE
HOUSING FINANCE AUTHORITY OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA,
RELATIVE TO THE ISSUANCE OF NOTTO EXCEED $25,000,000 TAX-
EXEMPT SINGLE FAMILY MORTGAGE REVENUE BONDS FOR THE
PURPOSE OF ACQUIRI~G, CO"iSTRUCTING AND EQUIPPING
RESIDENTIAL HOUSING FACILITIES FOR PERSONS OR FAMILIES
OF LOW, MIDDLE OR MODERATE INCOME; OR WHO ARE
OTHERWISE ELIGIBLE PERSONS UNDER APPLICABLE
REGULATIONS; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, Fountain Lakes Residential Cooperative Corporation (the "Company") has
applied to the Housing Finan~e Authority of Collier County, Florida (the" Authority"), to (i)
issue its tax-exem;:>t single family mortgage revenue honds in a principal amount not to exceed
$25,000,000 (thc "Bonds") for the purpos~ of finan~ing the acquisition, construction. equipping
and development of single famtl:' residential housing faciiities for persons or families of low.
middle or moderate income or wilD are otilerwis~ eligible pcrsons undcr applicable rcgulations
to be located in Collie" COllnty (tile "Project"), and (ii) to loan the proceeds of the Bonds to the
Company pursuant to Chapter 159, Pan IV, Florida Statutes, or such other provisions of
Florida iaw as the Authority may determine advisable (the "Act"); and
WHEREAS, a determination by the Authority to issue the Bonds under the Act, if so
requested hy the Company, in one or more issues or series not exceeding an aggregate principal
amount of $25,000,000 and to loan the proceeds thereof available to finance the Project under a
loan agreement or other financing agreement which will provide that payments thereunder be at
least sufficient to pay the principal of and interest and redemption premium, if any, on such
Bonds and such other costs in connection therewith as may be incurred by the Authority, will
assist the Company and promote the purposes provided in the Act; and
WHEREAS, the Authority held a public hearing on the proposed issuance of the Bonds
for the purposes herein stated on November 14, 2007, pursuant to a notice of such hearing
being published at least 14 days prior to the hearing in the Naples Daily News, a newspaper of
general circulation published in ColJier County, a copy of said notice being attached hereto as
Exhibit A, which public hearing was conducted in a manner that provided a reasonable
opportunity for persons with differing views to be heard, both oralJy and in writing, on both the
issuance of such Bonds and the location and nature of the portion of the Project to be financed
with the proceeds therefrom; and
WHEREAS, it is intended that this Resolution shall constitute official action toward the
issuance of the Bonds within the meaning of the applicable United States Treasury Regulations,
EXHIBIT A TO COUNTY
RESOLUTION
r),,:-:;-::"';:.:".
IT IS, THEREFORE, DETERMINED AND RESOLVED BY THE HOUSING
FINANCE AUTHORITY OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, THAT:
1. Approval of the Project. The acquisition, construction, equipping and development of
the Project and the financing thereof by the Authority through the issuance of the Bonds,
pursuant to the Act, will promote the health and welfare of the citizens of Collier County and
will thereby serve the public purposes of the Act.
2. Authorization of the Bonds, There is hereby authorized to be issued and the Authority
hereby determines to issue the Bonds, if so requested by the Company and subject to the
conditions set forth in the Preliminary Agreement for the Issuance of Bonds (the "Preliminary
Agreement") to be entered into subsequently. in one or more issues or series in an aggregate
principal amount not to exceed $25,000,000 for the purpose of financing the Project. The
Bonds ,shall be designated "Housing Finance Authority of Collier County Single Family
Mortgage Revenue Bonds Series 2007 (Fountain Lakes Project)" or such designation as the
AUIhority may deem advisable, The rate of interest payable on the Bonds shall not exceed the
rate permitted by law,
3. Recommendation for Approval to Board of County Commissioners. The AuthoriIv
herebv recommends the issuance of the Bonds and the financing of the Project for approval to
the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County (the "Board"). The Authority hereby
directs the Chairman, Vice-Chairman or Ic:suer's CClunsel, either alone or jointly, at the
expense of the Company, to seek approval for the issuance of the Bonds and the financing of
the Project by the Board as the applicable elected representatives of Collier County under and
pursuant to the Act and Section 147(1) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended,
4. AfI1rmative Action. This resolution is an affirmative action of the Authority toward
the issuance of the Bonds, as contemplated in said Preliminary Agreement, in accordance with
the purposes of the laws of the State of Florida and the applicable United States Treasury
Regulations.
5. Approval of Notice of Public Hearing, The form of notice of public hearing attached
hereto as Exhibit "A" is hereby approved and the publishing thereof ratified by the Authority,
6. Limited Obligations. The Bonds and the interest thereon shall not constitute an
indebtedness or pledge of the general credit or taxing power of Collier County, the State of
Florida or any political subdivision or agency thereof but shall be payable solely from the
revenue pledged therefore pursuant to a loan agreement or other financing agreement entered
into by and between the Authority and the Company prior to or contemporaneously with the
issuance of the Bonds,
7. Limited Approval. The approval given herein shall not be construed as an approval of
any necessary zoning applications nor for any other regulatory permits relating to the Project
and the Authority shall not be construed by reason of its adoption of this resolution to have
waived any right of the County or to have estopped the County from asserting any rights or
responsibilities it may have in that regard,
This Resolution shall take effect immediately,
ADOPTED this 14th day of November, 2007,
, 'I.
~ ;, ~:~~
HOUSING FINANCE AUTHORITY OF
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
~tSEAf;)"
~_. ...; .-
. '
>---., ~~ :..
~~ ~jJ
/Gary D, t:ind~'
By:
ATTEST:
, Jrgz:~, Mohlke . \'
Sc TetJ '"
1a~
11/23/2087
80:29
2292534854
NAPLESDAILV
'.!::.....:'1,~)2. :.,'
Notice or Pucllc HellrlnQ and SpeClaJ Me(lUng
HOtlslM fiin:lT\lli.' Authar!~y of colllt!r CO\IOty
NotIce l~ hereby olv@n that the Houslnol;l Flnanct
AuthOrIty of CoJ1l~r -County (tilt' "AuthoritY") w~[t
contluct II P.~DjJC he;)rlng 10 accordt\l'lce wIth tne
1/1); EquIty al1t'! rll:eal ResponSibility Act of Hlf!,] ITE.
FRN am! !l}?eCIJlI meetlnll on Nov~f'I1b~f 1.4, 2C107, at
B'30 am (Ioesl tIme) In th~ MedlWContcrence
f:toom '5ccon~ Flom, NBpt<,:S City lo/all, 7JS Elqhth
street 50t.rt'h N8DI~s, Florld.!! for the pUr~Ose ot (1:-
celvlng pUblIc cort'lml!nts co~~mlnQ the craoosCd
Issu~nce Of thl'l Authorlty'S Single tl\mlh MOrttlll.. g.
R.evcmue Gor.d~, In an ftCJgrel;ja~ Ptlnc:/p.;)J amount
<l1 not to e){!::e€ld S2S,OO~.O~O. )n CIne or mtl~ S~rH!S,
to be u5eC to finance owner-ot:tupleod unlt~ In " CD.
onero.tllle houSlno development to be Known as
"Founte.tn l.B.kel:" to consist of opproxlm;ttclv 150
unIts located at 3681 Mlrac\e Wlly, Nl'lple5, Florldu
34114, as 'i'lftorClablll "workfOrCf!"l1oul:mg fot pcr.
soJ'is tJr' tilmlHeS Df low ~nd moClcrate \nC:9me Ot
who BI1I" otlHlrwlsc "eligible p(lr!on~" as Cle1lned ))y
lloplJcable repuJEltlons. 1M name and addres~ of
th~ co.op Is Fount-'In l..!!Ike& ReSldeflttol Cooperative
COrJ)oratlon, clo MDG. C!!Icltl'll Corporl'l.tlon. 1180 jm-
mok41ee R(lad.Sultc 309, Naples, FlorIda,
If Issu('.d, tn~ bondS wlli be pl'\,yable solely from
the f'!-vel'lut!!i Oerlvr!d l:ly the Al1thomy frolll ~he
]oil,n~ extr::nOet! to the owners or tile cooperative
units, The bonds .....lIt flct eonstlruu~ .!H1 lndebtetl-
r\loSS ot Collier Countv, tl'e. Stnte of Florid.:! Dr ~n\l
J:lolltle.nl J;;ubdlvllt)on or ogene> tnereof wJtn!r\ tM
lTIe<\l'llng or any C(jnstltutlcl'I.li.1 or st~tlJtory ONH
\lmlt~Uon or r~strlc:t\on, The ild v<llo~m t~)(]t'lQ
,..ow~r o~ Colll~r County J~ not plil'dl,lfld and may not
be eomptlJed ,to b~ excr!::l!.ctl tc m:lk~ i\ny p~y-
menU 01 prIncipal, premIum or ilny) or Interest on
the bonds, No prOMrty of th~ County or th~ StC'lte
or flfIl,I POlltiCill 5ubCllvhlon or ag:(lt'lc)' therao1 wlll
be p\~dped tor pl'lym~nts of P~If\CIPII.L .I:1rf:mlum (If
:lny) or Interest on the DOflds, ex.cr.ptlo; only 111~
revenues, >lltaQNi by the Autnorlty ~!l desc( Itled In
thl~ pt\l'lprilph, Trw Authorlt'). h"$ no tllClno pDwtr"
All htcrcst'O'<:I oen;ons llre IlWltM to ~lJtlm)~ wrot1:I'!\
,ommM't~ or nhlJnd tht! hearing. eIther personally
nr trlrotJgh ~helr rt;ore,~~ntatiV€, and will !J~ give,.,
or: opportlJnlW ro exoress me~r \lltW~ con:::errlll)>J
the pNl/N:l (lr tile IlnJU1clng. Anvon{, dt"'1r~mr. to
m.:llkl: Wtlt1t>1i cnmment!l Irt adv"flc~ 01 thf' m.'rln~
m,w ;e,1d 5u~n C"ommen~~ to:
Housinr:: f"IMn"t::c AlJtl1ortt~ of CoW~r County
- cia Qeoerill <:ounsel
SlSD NoMl1 T~ml8mj1 f<ll\" Suttr. SC2
N~plij~,FiorICla 3-<l1O:l
f:'crsor.:: ate 4cvl::er! thd If they decld~ to ElP~
pc~1 ~ny der:is!or", mtlC1e ut t\ll$ he.<Ir~t'lo. tney wI(:
need a record 01 tfle proc{!edlngs. <lind, lor :;Jch
PiJTPOSo, they Inoy n~eC to ensute th~t e verf)~tlm
record of the procMdlnC/:: Is mads, whleJl record m.
clu~es thf: t/?:.t.lmoW ilnu e"i:3eflC~ up()n which. the
l1PP~~1 ~c~~~d~~~e with t/1e AmerlCMs wltl1 DlsttbHl-
tles. Act person!. nt'E.'o]ng E specl~1 ncccmmodE\t\on
to Ilortlr:lpatll In this I'rcc-eeulng should contact
I Delnald A. I']:::K. WoNt!, Qe"er<\1 CO\J!'I!l:eol. at (~Jg) 21>3-
AD SPACE: 145.0:>0 :NCH. S06Dnol"terthil.n'ev,m(7)claYs~r!ortothchcar.
,ILED ON; lO/2~/O' In".
-- -- - - ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~-- - - -,- -;;-.- w -)- - '-;, (_ ~ _ _ _~ __ _ __ _+__ _ ~_ ....c.'~~~;!~~FINANCEAuTHMtTVorCOl.l..IE~~O,~,~~l'<!
Sj.gnat--.lre of l\f::iant C ~_
J:fu. doy of.. _ Y\~}
Q...D\~ 0,,0
~
Naples CaiJ.y ~€.vr5
Naples, FL 34102
~.ffic1i,3vie o:f. PlJ.blicat.ion
Naples Daily .New~
- - - - - - - - - .' - - ,. - - - - - ,. - - ., ~ - - - - ~ - - + - -"
PICKWORTH, DO~A.LrO P.A.
5159 TAMIAMI TRL N #502
r-TP.PT...ES Fr., 3~: 1 0 3
REFERENCE~
Ol078?
59(~450.33
NOTICE OF PtTBLIC EEP,
State of FJ.or:.da
County of Co:lier "
Eef~re th~ undersigned authority! personally
appear~d E. Lamb, who on oath says that she Serves
as ASslstant Cor~orate Secr.etary of t.he Na.ples
JCl,ily News, a da~ly newspaper published at' Na.pl€:s,
in Col:ier County, Florida: that the attached
copy of advert:i~lng was published in said
newspaper on dat~s lis~ed.
A:fiant further says Lha~ the said Naples
News ~s a newGpaper ~ublished at Naples, ir.
Collier C'OU:1ty, Flo:t':l.da~ and ':.hat :he said
neVfGpaper. has ~e~etoforE:: been continuousl v
pu.blu:lhed i:1 Sctid Collier County I Flc:::ida: ea~h
da:l cu~d has bee!", ~::::e:::-e-::i as se=ond- class m,::).il
ma~t~= at the p08~ o~;ic~ in Naple~, in said
C0~1:e~ Coun:y, F~o~~~a, fo~ a Per~od of 1 vear
nex: pre=ed~nq ~~e ~ir5: public~~ioL of the-
G~~22h~d copv-of adv~rtiQem~~t. and af~~an~
:Ul-'.:.~.e.= say:;- ths.t she bas n~'it;er 'p2.id-~o:':-
p1:om:c,;;;ej, any pel~son, firm or ::o::-po:::-a'.::.on ar:y
c.::.;;count, rebate, com:r,iss:.on O~ r€fund fo~ ::.h~
p1J_'::F?,?ge '7"f .s~cu~~ng t1:is adve:::r:.se1'1en': .::::;:-
;;___t.o..L~:::a':.J.c~ ;1.,r.. tn~ sa~d new;;;pape:-.
DZ'.ily
said
::lJ"1:F....ISHED Ot!;
10/:9
:'D/29
5wQJ~n to and St:.b:::cribed
before me this
U"\I)I'l,()
?erson;;;'7..1y known :Oy me
f:'1F.~g~~~~
~i.~~~'~~
'"I;:i!r;,~:..I;f:-\'
8HANEL-!\. MCDUNALU
Cammission 00650475
Expires Jun" 29, 2011
O"MM tn", Tlt>,o F~II\ ~''''III<\ I\1(I.M5.1Io1!.
EXHIBIT A TO AUTHORITY
RESOLUTION
7'n::;
F:I~G~
BUBl
2o()l
,~ ' '
27 2(107'
~ of 3'1
-
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
PE-2007-AR-12164, Patrick White, Esquire, of Porter, Wright, Morris, & Arthur, LLP
representing Naples Big Cypress Market Place, LLLP, is requesting a Parking Exemption
to permit an off-site parking lot for overflow parking in excess of the minimum Land
Development Code (LDC) requirement for property zoned Rural Agricultural (A) and
located at the northwest corner of Tamiami Trail East (US-41) and Basik Drive, in Section
17, Township 51 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida
OBJECTIVE:
To have the Board of Zoning Appeals (EZA) consicler an application for a parking exemption to
pertnit an off-site parking lot to provide overflow parking in excess of the minimum LDC
requirements for property within the Rural Agricultural (A) Zoning District. and to ensure the
project is in hanl1ClIlY with all the applicable code, and regulations in order to makc certain thaI
the community's interests are maintained.
~-
CONSIDERA nONS:
The applicant states that the requested 055-space of1~site parking lot will provide overflow
parking to support the Naples Big Cypress Flea Market that is presently under construction, The
subject site, for which the parking exemption is being sought. is zoned Rural Agricultural (Al
and is contiguous to the flea market on its east side. The flea market, associated with SDP-
2002-AR-2330. consists of 34,750 square fcct or retail space including 278 vendor booths served
by a total of 348 spaces, as provided in the originally approved Site Development Plan, and is
zoned General Commercial (C-4). The existing approved parking area across Basik Drive is
zoned C-5,
The site of the proposed parking area was previously cultivated as fann land. Presently, it is
vacant and undeveloped and includes a 230-acre lake. As depicted on the conceptual site plan,
the proposed off-site parking lot will provide 1,09 acres of paved vehicular use aTca, 4.45 acres
of green area, and 1.65 acres of graveL The 2,3 acre lake would remain. Access shall be
provided from Basik Drive via US-41 (East Tamiami Trail), Three-hundred-thirty-eight (338)
regular size spaces and 17 oversize spaces are proposed for a total of 355 spaces,
--
The propeliy abutting the off-site parking lot to the nOlih is vacant land zoned Rural Agricultural
(A), which requires a Type-B IS-foot buffer. To the south, across US-41, is undeveloped
agricultural land and land used as row crops, A Type D, IS-foot wide buffer shall be provided
along USA!. East of the site, across Trinity Placc, is a single-family dwelling on a 5-acre tract
zoned Rural Agricultural. A Type-D, IO-foot wide bufTer shall be provided along this property
line, West of the site is the Naples Big Cypress Market Place, currently under construction,
AR-12164, Naples Big Cypress Market Place Page 1 of 5
zoned C-4, which adjoins the flea market and proposed parking area, No walls are proposed
because there arc no abutting residential zoning districts.
The LDC specifies criteria upon which parking excmptions may he approved, This criteria is
outlined in Section 4,05,02k.3a(2) of the LDC. Staffs asscssment. as noted in the statTreport, is
that the proposal is consistent with this criteria, There would he minimal impact. if any. on the
character and quality of the existing sUlTOunding neighborhood, These properties are zoned
Agricultural with lot sizes of 5 acres or more. huffers sufficient in size arc proposed along the
perimeter of the site abutting the existing properties north and cast of the site whcre there are
dwellings, and traffic is dirccted oif of US-41 to thc site via Basik Olive away !i'om local
abutting roadways,
It should be noted that Section 4,05,04,C of thc Land Development Code (LDC). requires
developers of commercial projects locatcd within commercial zoning districts. busincss park
districts. or a commercial component of a PUO Zoning District. which require a minimum of
eighty (8(1! parking spaces. I)!'o,iding paved on~street sur!ace parking in excess of 120 pcrcen! of
the requircments of this LOC shall requcst a Valiance in accordance with Chaptcr 9, The
devcloper shall .,lso be required to pwvidc double the landscaping within interior vchicular use
areas. as required by Section 4.()().()(l urthe LDC for those projects requesting such a variance. If
at the time of SOP review of the l\aplcs Big Cvprcss Mal-j:,c!. the parl:il1)C provided exceeds! 20
percsnt of the LDC required parking. then the l1rCl\'isions of Section 4.05.04.C as noted abo\'~
shall applv,
FrSCAL IMPACT:
The parking exemption. by and of itselL will have no fiscal impacI on Collicr County, There is
no guaranke that the project. at build out. will maximize its authorized level of development.
however. if the parking exemption is approved. a portion of the land could be developed,
The County collects impact fees prior to the issuance of building pennits to help otTset the
impacts of each new development on public facilities, These impact fees are used to fund
projects identified in the Capital Improvement Element (CIE) of the Growth Management Plan
(GMP) as needed to maintain adopted Lcvcl of Service (LOS) for public facilities. Additionally.
in ordcr to meet the requirements of concUlTency management, the developer of every local
developmcnt order approved by Collier County is required to pay 50 percent of the estimated
Transp0l1ation Impact Fees associated with the project. Othcr fees collected prior to issuance of
a building pen11i! include building penl1it rcviev.." fees and utility fees associated with connecting
to the County's water and sewer syslcm.
Please note that the inclusion of impact fees and taxcs collected arc for informational purposes
only; they arc not included in the critcria used by Staff and the Planning Commission to analyze
this petition,
AR~ 12164. Naples Big Cypress Markel Place Page 7. or 5
GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN (GMP) IMPACT:
The property for this proposcd Parking Exemption is desi,;nated Urban Residcntial Frin,;e
District on the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) of thc County's Growth Management Plan
(GMP), The GMP is silcnt as it relates to parking exemptions, Therefore. approval of this
parking excmption would not affcct or chan,;e thc requirements of the GMP,
AFFORDABLE HOUSING IMPACT:
Approval of this parking cxemption will have no impact on a!1(,rdable housing in the County,
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES:
Environmental Services staff has revicwed this petition. and detennined that the proposcd
parking exemption will not have an impact on the environment. The Environmcntal Advisory
Council did not review this petition hccausc the proposed excmption was previously impacted. is
l~s~ than 1 (} acres. and will not h<J\'c cll\'ironmcntal consequenc'2s.
COLLIER COUI\TV PLA'\l\'ING COM\USSJON ICO'Cl RECOMMENDA TlON;
The cepe heard petition PE<~()(J7-AR-12]()4 on Novemher 1. 2(l()7 and hy a vote of6l0 (i (with
the Chaimla!; abstaining) recommended that this petition be iC1l'wardcd to the Board of Zoning
.".npeals (GZA) with 3 rccommendation of apprc1\'al subjecI \() the j()lIowing conditions:
Conditions of Approva!:
I, The Parking Exemption is limited to what is shown on the conceptual site plan. identified
as "Naplcs Big Cyprcss Parking Excmption." prepared hy Landy Enginccring and datcd
September. 2007, The sitc plan noted is conceptual in naturc fClr parking cxemption
application approval only, The final site design and dcvelopment ordcr plans shall be in
compliance with all applicable Fedcral, Statc. and County Laws and Regulations; and
1
The Parking Exemption is limitcd to a maximum of 355 parkin,; spaccs that shall be
restricted to use by the Naples Big Cypress Market Place only; and
3, Access from TriniIy Place Road shall be gated and limited as cmergency access for
emergency vchicles only, At no time shall the driveway be opened for Public access,
4, A IS-foot wide TY11c-D Landscapc bufTer shall be install cd along Trinity Place, The
bufTer will bc reviewed at the time 0 f thc Site Development Plan revicw and installed and
completed concurrent with thc construction of the ofT-site parking lot.
~, Thc site plan shall bc revised to shm, 17 ovcrsized spaces in the Ie,;end box. which is
consistcnt with the number of spaces shown on the site plan drawing: not thc 34 spaces
cUITcntly shown in the legend box,
AR-121 04, J\aples Big Cypress Market Pbce Page 3 of 5
6, Tractor trailers. semi-trucks. and oversize vchicles similar in nature to thcse are
prohibited Ii'om utilizing the proposed 17 oversized parking spaces situated along thc
northern boundaJ)' of the site, Buses. RVs and vehicles similru- to thesc are pernlitted,
7, The words "exccss parking" shall be strickcn from the application, and replaced with the
words "ofT-site parking,"
Becausc the CCPC approval recommcndal ion was unanimous and no letters of objection have
been received. this pctition has hccn placed on the Summary Agenda,
LEGAL CONSIDER-\T10NS:
The petitioner is seeking a Parking Exemption pursuant to LDC Section 4,05,02,K,3, A Parking
Exemption ij-omthe BZA is needed because the lot proposed for off-site parking is not zoned for
c0111mercial use.
The attached StafT Rep0l1 and rccommendation of the Planning Commission are ad\'isory only
and are 110t binding. D.:cisions regarding Parking Exemptions arc quasi-judiciaL and all
testimony must h::: g!\'CIl under oa1h. The Petitioner has 1he hurden to prove that the proposed
request is consistent with the criteria set forth helo\\'. and the. Board may question the Petitioner,
or Stail. to ensure that the necessary critcT:a have been satisiied. Should tile Board consiekr
denying this petition. to a~:sure that the decision is not ]a1::r round 10 be arbitrary. discrinlinal()~'y
or unreasonable: the deniall1luSI be hased upon compelcn:, substantial cvidence that the proposal
docs not meet (me or 1110re of111e follovv'ing criteria:
( I ) Whether the amount oC ofl:site parking is required by Sections 4,05,04 G, and 4,05,09. or
is in excess of these requirements:
(2) Thc distance ofthc fm1hest parking space from the facility to be servcd;
(3) Pedestrian safety if the lots arc sepaJ'ated hy a collector or arterial roadway;
(4) Pedestrian and vehicular safely;
(5) The character and quality of the neighborhood and the future development ofsun'ounding
propenies;
(6) Potential parking problems for neighboring propenies;
(7) Whether the internal trai1ic flow is required to leavc the site to reach the proposed of1:site
parking:
(8) Whether vehicular access shall be ii'om or onto rcsidential streets;
(9) Whether bujfers adjacent to the propel1y zoned residential are 15 feel in width and
includc a wall in addition to requircd landscaping;
(10) Whether the ofT-site parking area will be used for valet parking;
(II) Whether the off:site parking area will be uscd f()r employec parking: and
(12) Whcther there are more viablc alternatives available.
Approval of this request requires three afllrmative votes of the BZA, The proposed Resolution
was prepared by thc County Attorney's Oi1ice and is suffieient for Board action, -JAK
/\R-l::::] 64. Napk:" Big Cypress !\1arkcl Place Page 4 or.5
RECOMMENDA TlOI\:
Stafl recommends that the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) approve Petition PE-2007-AR-
12164 subject to the j()l1owing conditions of approval:
Conditions of AOOl'oval:
I, The Parking Exemption is limited to what is shown on fhe conceptual site plan. identified
as "Naples Big Cypress Parking Exemption," prepared by Landy Engineering and dated
September. 2007, The site plan noted is conceptual in nature for parking exemption
application approval only, The final site design and development order plans shall be
compliance with all applicable Federal, State. and County Laws and Regulations: and
o
The Parking Exemption is limited to a maximum of 355 parking spaces that shall be
restricted to use by the 'Japles Big Cypress Market Place only: and
3, Access from Trinity Place Road shall be gated and limited as emergency access for
emergcnc)' vehicles only, At no time shall the driveway be opened j(lr Public access,
The Zonill~ staif d()e~: n01 object 1U or h<1\'(' C0l11ments on the lC)Jlo\,,'ing cepe reco111111cnd'.:',d
slipulations:
1.
A ] )-I(\ot wide T)l)C-D Landscape bufler shall be installed along Trinity Place, The
buffer will be r,cviewcd aIthe timc of the Sitc DevelopmenI Plan JTview and installed and
completed concurrent with the construction of the ofj~site parking lot.
.,
The site plan shall be revised to show 17 oversized spaces in the legend box. which is
consistent with the number of spaces shown on the site plan drawing: not the 34 spaces
cUlTently shown in the legcnd box,
.,
.J,
The 17 oversized parking spaces shall be used for any oversized vehicles such as buses.
and RVs, but not for tractor trailers. semi-trucks, and oversize vehicles similar in nature
to thesc,
4,
The words "excess parking" shall be stricken from the application, and replaced with the
words "of1~si(e parking,"
PREPARED BY:
Willie Brown. AICP. Principal Planner
Dcpariment of Zoning and Land Development Rcview
AR-12164. Naples Big Cypress Markel Place Page.5 or.5
!'d!ll.: ! of]
COLLIER COUr-iTY
Item Number:
Item Summary:
"""r;
'I';;'
";1 II"'" ~'H, fOe .:::;~,
", ':;-: ",;':11'1 ~:"
',"Ho'
',. ,." .", ~'rI'~ ld "'1""
~, ('.l-
:f, "Ir 1'';(1.1'1''
".r '--1 ~-, (J:W~I\-- '-I~dlh;
"' :11':.1;( 'I,I''''''P
1""':;1
,':'1:;"
F..i.,r/l'
'"1'''
ur1..
Meeting Date:
I'r.,pu red Jl~
'-'",
"';""""."
L..'i'
~ C.,I:!" "',,t..' [j'" '"''''''1'''''' '
"."\'Irc"'l"""rll~ Sr.-r'.'lef)
;;"''-:IW /; ~"tlt' [Ii '-'1,-, ''I""n' '"____..-,,(,,.:
" " '7: 2~' 7 ~,.:.. f,e': A'}
Appn,,'{,d B~
,;:::
~V"t'
"'''IJIC'::''''''l1 ;--,i:or'l"-
''',,,I,
'ne-',
Ap["''''ell H~
'\PI,rn,'('dll_,
Al'IlI'O'NJ H)
APl'l'u,.'d II,
.cu,"
Appro,'cd H)
i,:'
''':'''1''
"t,'
ie,
'1':"'1~: '
'n~ ~ I,,,,, :'\"""__1'-"""" r:' ";P'"
1(;"-",,
A['prll\'cd fly
';{;
':.u;)
'u>n~r; '(__.IIL''' c:,lI,,:..H;, "',,,," "-:,.,,,,,,
_,~te
-,-,.:;'1;;:;,";;:;[,,-,
,; e~
,C.:",I"
''''-:Zit.._ --;"f/
-\ppru\'edll)
';;,"'<1<:."
:;".';'n
- - "";' ~L"'''
"I'''''",
:.-q!,
Appr"n:ll B~
(Jr.'t
"I~'i-'I :;;:;IIC"" i.'.,,;,lv,'
."",;;,
-"n(' ,
"'-':?Y
'!(,'r.f.
''\.pprn\'('dll)
~-,nl'" r..".,."."
r:"-rr;',,,,,,,,,,.";)
'.'V'~
.,,;'=V"' ('C'P
ApprH,'cd B~
l~l" i!(~ ^ ""n,l"T~~,' r: vn".-t\()':! ~I,,,-'omh.,~" ;")(n7 (l..: "nl\n.-,'.. , -,,, ")('0\..:1 T~ ~~ ~ ^ p \.'(\.:.")1\ ^ r:r:
11n(\I")III1'7
f
'"
--':;;'_fi~
1-"';'''''<t~~:
cOHiErr County
~:, ~" ---
c:;:;:;:::: \tZ- - \t.,r-v~
STAFF REPORT
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
FROM:
DEPARTMENT OF ZOl\'NG & LAND DEVELOPMEKT REVIEW
CO]vLML't\'ITY DEVELOP}'fENT & El\vIRO]\}'fENT AL SERVICES DIVISION
HEARL~G DATE: NOVB1BER 1,2007
SUBJECT: PETITION: PE-2007-AR-I2164. NAPLES BIG CYPRESS IvLARKET PLACE
PARKING EXEMPTION
APPLICA.J\T/ AGE1'\TS:
.4..pplicant:
Agen::
Naples Big Cypress J\1.arket Pla~e, LLLP
3012 .t\irport-Pulling Road~ Suite 202
'\aples,. FL 34105
Patrick \'\1:ite. Esquire
Porter. Wright, Morris, & ArthU!', LLP
5801 Pdb:n Bay Blvd," Suite 300
)iaples. FL 34] 08
REOL'ESTED ACTION:
The applicant seeks approval of a parking exemption to allow an off-site overflow parking lot In excess
of the minimum Land Development Code requirement in an Agricultural (A) Zoning District. The
proposed 355-space parking lot would serve the :'\Iaples Big Cypress Market Place that is zoned General
Commercial (C-4),
GEOGRAPHIC LOCATION:
The subject property consisting of =9.79 acres ofland is located at the northwest comer ofUS-4l (East
Tamiami Trail) and Trinity Place in Section 17, Township 51 South, Range 27 East, of Collier County,
Fiorida, (See location map on follOwing page)
PURPOSEIDESCRlPTION OF PROJECT:
The applicant states that the requested 355-space off-site parking lot that would provide overflow
parking to support the Naples Big Cypress Flea Market that is presently under construction on an
adjacent lot to the west in the General Commercial (C-4) Zoning District. The flea market. associated
"ith SDP-2002-iill,-2330. consists of 34,750 square feet of retail space including 278 flea market booths
served by 34 on-site parking spaces adjacent to the flea market building and 439 spaces across Basik
Drive. The on-site parking lot is separated from the proposed off. site parking area by an internal aecess
Staff Report for November 1, 2007 ccpe Parking Exemption, P=--2007 K-i 2164
Page 1 of7
I 9
1 I
i
':)l\!i_U ..
(,)
'"
"
:i
--;::: '::
_ ,':1.'
i;:5
--=.....(..
,c' -
::;: :)
.2,2
,
I ,
i
I
I ,
I
i
!
" I
i
I
!
"
I
I
, ,
~
1
- -
..,~--
-
'"
!J'<l'O~ Nlli~l"VH
r:il
J ~ ~ I
000
o
~
~ ~
8 <3
<::( '::i;;;
'" 8
~ ~
'"
5
" "
[ ~ ~
n=;~1C~ /
- Z
,
,
~
: j' ,
,If I' W
T" \ a
,/ ,~,: ~~..
I ~\ ~C':
\\1
~
,
,
O::W
Wf-
::::;<
>;. ...J I- ..
),1 oC/)"
',I t)
.\\
ill,
"
.
. I ./
if! l~ ~I
I 'I .~~~~
I
I /" 11
'~.' I ; ,
"lO~ ~~ t ....
I J",~ 1,
,. V' ,I
g fl- -I
.
~~
~g-
i~; ,",
,. I
'\
,
"~
,
,
"
! -.J(
I ',,~r"'r
'~_I YQr;.c
-1="'7gJ6dJ
I ~ ('
, \.
. =-/~
~'
"),
0..
<(
:::2
(9
z
z
o
N
i
.,.1
~I
'"
:1
;;1
Ni
"'I
0..
."
z
~I
wi
"'I
0..
<(
~
z
o
f-
<(
()
o
..J
roadway that extends North and South along a shared boundary line. Access to the overflow parking
area would be provided by Basik Drive via US-41 (East Tamiami Trail),
The agriculturally-zoned site for which the parking exemption is being sought is presently vacant and
cleared and includes a 2,30-acre Jake. The site was prcviously cultivated as fann land, North of the site
is vacant land zoned agricultural (A), which would be buffered by a Type-B 15-foot buffer. South of the
site across US-41 is vacant land and row CTOpS zoned Agricultural (A), which would be blli"fered by a
Type D 15-foot wide buffer adjacent to US-4!. East ofthc site across Trinity Place is a single-family
dwelling on a 5-acre tract zoned Agricultural (A). which would bc buffered by a Type D, 10-foot buffer
adjacent to Trinity Place. Volest of the site is the "iaples Big Cypress Market Place, currently under
construction. zoned C-4. No walls are proposed because there are no abutting rcsidential zoning
districts.
It should be noted that Section 4.05,04,C of the Land Development Code (LDC), requires developers of
commercial projects located within commercial zoning districts, business park districts, or a commercial
component of a PUD Zarung District, which require a minimum of eighty (80) parking spaces,
providing paved off-street sunace parking in excess of 120 percent of the requirements of this LDC shall
request a variance in accordance with Chapter 9, The developer shall also be required to provide double
the lan6.scaping \\.ithin inte:-ior vehicular 'J.5;e an.:cs; as required by Section 4.06.00 (~fth_e LDC for those
projects requesting such a \'arianct, If at the time of SDP review of the Naples Big Cypress Market, the
parbng p~ovided exceeds 120 percent of the LDC required parking. then L"Je provisions of Section
4.05.04.C 2.5 noted abcl\'e shaD apply.
SURROCNDING LA_ '\'D t'SE A,ND ZO"iL'IG (refer to the Zoom!! Map):
North:
South:
East:
v,' est:
Vacant, undeveloped land: zoned Agricultural IA)
Across US-41 (East Tamiami Trail) are row crops and vacant land; zoned Agricultural (A)
Across Trinity Place Road is a single family dwelling on 5 acres: zoned Agricultural (A)
Naples Big Cypress Market Place (under construction); zoned General Commercial (C-4)
Staff Report for November 1, 2007, 2006 ccpe
Parking Exemption, PE-2006-AR-12164
Page 2 of 7
,
/
I
,
/
,
.
,
/
I
/
I
,
/
I
/
I
,/
/
If
I
j
I
I i
j~, , u (
, L
~~
iG ",'
:\ ~.
"':-. 1 ~'R ;.
c !;~ ["'"
,:;.
,-
r
I~t
I- ,-_
!:J ~~
~t-
.:;r;
il
!
, ;
tl [
1",<,', "
I 'Ii
"
~~~ ~':il ~~ ,,"" ~W,.~ ~~g~~ ~
ii: ;;:;1.; 15
"' iW .. ~;;g~~S; ~;l~",~
~, . L "~ p"''''~l'<E ."g I:::: ,
;; ~"' ~
t~ "~ "~ E;~~~~ "a e. "
C ~~;~"'~ ~!o ~ ~
0;", , . FJ51 to: ~3fi
I ~ . I' z.." ~~ i ,
. fi ~~~ , 0
" .. ., ,
, - . ~
, I ~ ,. "
, , ~ " ,
~ , ,
" 'I"" ,
, lO\'o,..M!< ~
~:'~,':::'6
~ ~b " ""
g~~~ ~r
~ ~;E~~ ~,!.';:i>;;::.::;
~ "';Uz'"'f" ~M~
~~i~
~ ,
~
~.:::l). ~~
,UI.- ,,"",-
;:'.1:.. e=
';'._~l'Z.=. ~;_=,
.=
t:!
I Fort. lfI1~I~r.e3 m:rr C1~~ i1Ji!;.s'1Jt~ .~..AW, I I
~~2tl.a;; fl.ifiJJ f!:JJr~~ /i~1Fif 1JYJJJ.~t;! H---+-
Farbg E...~:l:!ptioll Application. . .
P,~2jMfI..f;:'.C;'( SI!!:. PUN I i OAT~ I
~>t;
:T.'.lC
,'_.:c'
=
'1'
,
'-
i":
~ ~ ~I<
fl E~
~ E ~Fi
1j;S,,[W:
I i ~~
~ ~ ~~
n I'
~
,
, , ~
, ~ ~
, ,
~,
,
'..~
31
<',
i@~
"'-
~~~
~~~
S~
!!;i
~~
'"
~~
"';;;
~*
:E
f;
~~
';
~~
0;;:.,
;~
1;,,,
r
Pi;:ii;
~;:;~
-,:::;~
~~~
,"'
~~~.
l,~
"-
~~'"
~~~
;:j;~
~;;!'a
~""n
~~~
~I{:
g"
:m
<t'"
.;;:1
;:."i
;;~
g
.,~
,.
M
'0
~. "
~~~
~~::;
12'=~
:;;~~
~~~
:!!::~
~~..
---
o;;~'"
ii!
;:;.:,;
~,
'&
~~
~!i',
:!j;.,,,,
::::;ih
~~~
;'"~
,,~~
~gl;
~W~
...::;;..:
z;<:
~~~
",ili"
'~I
~9"
'5~~
i'i~~
:!!.~...
~i~
i'''''>:
; ~ !;
,~
~
.f.le;?,"'G\.
~b~~ ~
";P;;, ~ .~ I-
~"~,~ 1€1';"I'
"i~~~ ~ ~,~>-
~;~i~ I ~-- % I
.~;." tl "
g;~;]g ~~ "~~
;~~~ < :~~ L., !
"1"~ :ll"' I,~
.;;~~~ ~ g~~ lW I>
~~~~;q ~;; ~:; i
ffi;~~ ~~ II
~,,~;;: iF I '
a~~~ ,~I ,
f;l;::.:~\~ i' : '~;I I
,,' 1'1"" I;;".
""'::- ~1. I~;
-..,~ "Ii, " 1_ I
I I' "II ".
I V I I
~-=----~
F.:~VISroNS
!
II
,i
,
11
,
i I,
'Ii"j, 'II
I : ~ I
I,Tfi:;,
L._r:='::!! ~ - --'
1
,
I
'"
"
;
,
"",
",,-
S .~
,*""
" f' ,'''-
N
~ i~~
U~
,
.
,
:1
.-1
+rl
~f9!,..:r~
~B,r,;~1r11't7 ~iNi@J~ i~~tr'l.\1l4---
m,~.~t~:J{~~~~~,~~
f'~' (=)~'"J...-".~
""""".._~.
"'::':li
lil
A'
diil.t
'---li
II
u0 11
~ /', I
i'):' / 111
i~_;,.J !~
,
I~
i ~
I
(\
\v I
"\ I
\i
~.J
AS8
.~
"-,
~\,
\\.
r--~ JL
~1~"
\
\
GRO\VTH MA.'\'AGEMENT PL.hJ\. (GMP) CO"SISTE!\CY:
Future Land Use Element (FLUE): The propel~" for this proposeci parling exemption is designated
Urban Residential Fringe District on the Future Land Cse Map (FLCM) of the County's Growth
Management Plan (GMP), FLUE Policy 5,4 requires new developments to be compatible \\ith the
surrounding land area, Because the GMP is silent regarding parking exemptions, Comprehensive
Planning leaves this determination to Zoning and Land Development Review as part of their review
related to the conformity of the project \vith the Land Development Code (LDC), The LDC addresses
parking exemptions in LDC Section 4,05.02 K.3, and establishes criteria for their review and approval.
Please see detailed zoning analysis below,
ANALYSIS:
Transportation Review: Staff from the Transportation Department has noted a concern regarding the
driveway to Trinity Place. The following stipulation has been recommended:
".c" :he time of SDP review, the drive-way connection to Trinity Place may remain
if it is limited to emergency access only, OR if a Traffic Impact Statement (TIS)
demonstrating the new access is submitted and approved, At no time shall the
driveway be opened for public access "ithout having satisfied either of the two
aforementioned stipulations,"
The applicant has ind;c3.ted that the drive would be used as access for emergency vehicles
only,
Staff Report for November 1,2007,2006 eepe
Parking Exemption, PE-2006-AR-12154
Page 3 of7
,\, .~
.'J\"7
:= ~j:- :;-;
Zoning Review: Section 4,05,02,K.3.a(2) of the LDC allows a parking exemption to be sought when a
lot proposed for off-site parking is not zoned for commercial uses. As part of its review of this
application, staff has completed a comprehensive evaluation of the parking exemption criteria outlined
in Section 4,05.02.K.3,b of the LDC, upon which a determination for any parking exemption must be
based. (These criteria are italicized below, followed by staffs comments.) This evaluation "ill form the
foundation of the Collier County Planning Commission's (CCPC) recommendation, which is then
forwarded to the Board of Zoning Appeals Board (BZA) for a final decision.
(1) 'fVhether the amount of off-site parking is required by LDC Section 4.05.04 G. and 4.05.09,
or is in excess of these requirements.
The minimum parking requirements for tl1e flea market are as follows:
Approved Parking Tabnlations for tbe Original SDP
SDP-2002-AR-2330
Parkin~Calcnlations
,
I
I
348 snaces
278 sDaces
348 spaces
i
I
I
Flea Market:
T ota! retail are" in f1 ea market = 34.750 SF la, ]: I 00
;; Booths (27S ,(1' I per booth)
. Parking Reauired (flea marketl
i Chickee:
12.33S Sf ,a' 1: 250 SF
I Industria!
, 07000 SF 'a ] '500 SF
10 spaces
, _..- .
I I
,
Office (industrial): I
6.800 SF (a) I :275 SF 25 snaces
,
! T ota! Parking Req uired 438 spaces I
Total Parkim>' Provided 477 SDaces
I
Total Loading SDaces Reauired , 7 sDaces
Total Loading Spaces Provided I 7 snaces
55 spaces
As shovm in the table above, the approved parking for tl1e flea market in the original SDP requires
a minimum of 348 parking spaces. Total parking provided on site is on both t..'te C-4 and C-5 lots.
Three-hundred-fifty-five spaces (355) spaces are proposed on the contiguous off-site parking lot in
the Agricultural Zoning District totaling 703 spaces.
(2) The distance of the farthest parking space from the facility to be served. The petitioner's
development plan (see Exb.ibit A) clearly illustrates me spatial relationship between the flea
market and the proposed off-site parking lot. The wheel-stop of the farthest parking space
is shov.TI approximately 480 feet to the flea market's nearest entrance.
(3) Pedestrian safety if the lots are separated by a collector or arterial roadway. The lots are
not separated by a collector or alterial road. However, tlle on-site parking area is separated
Staff Report for November 1,2007, 2006 ccpe
Parking Exemption. PE.2006-AR-12164
Page 4 of7
<.: "--
':::: -,
;::Zi=
-.,.',-
~ ~: ~
~~-
9'.....
c_
-~:~ ,,~,,:J.
~ 4:E-.".: ~ ' I
: ::' J-" ~"""'-"lt I : ~
I ,1.~ ! '"' ~.- Of,
i U:lT/S:.:::~'~;; ;~\t~;: : ~
I. ""8l1J'''';'' :: "'b1:?"'c:{ ~'-'"
,~";jfY-:3~:,.,:'.,.d"i-'-~" -"" ,I
:,j ;'n~-n"?:~\~-.~,' :~-" 'oj:i I
",Ir....""",p:+'-" I
ii' iC::~~~~';:li ' ,. I
:/:1_ 5'~C:; -,r;':..:
",; 'I'P ""1':
~~ ~~;~..c,' '; - : ',...,- -j? r':
~. ~;l':- ji-;) '.::" r;. ~:::~~,; ::
f~i~~~,II:} If
i ii- ~ ~ -':~~~i:<\i ! ~
.'f~'~7.lf
. -'- ;:-,
~ -~~>~~~';~- -';.
,- ---:'--','~'. " -\
= ---f.--- - -:":-';, i~ \: ~\
;;. ::::::~: :i";"-..,.;..
.-~; ---.:.:-~ .
~-,,'-',
~. ~~ ~~~\ '~""
::::= ~=:....: ; ;'r~y '.~
;:'""';-.- ." '
". -:::::=J _';-- ~~., :::?'::t,:. :,',\
>~-- =-J ~! :::.C~- ~,\~~ U [j :,-,
~=:~::::;.::. ~I'.: = ~J !~ ~:: !
~? ~~.;:,-f1..:; /~~..;'~_i;__._H" -,
~~ Efu~ ~: jl~'.' _~~~~~;~ !~f .,
',_ I,'
~ ;. l~
-
, "'-'-'
~~~
, ~: I r
-, ',--
.. 5 '_'~
. .l' ~
:;':::
;.:...;~
~'~.::':: I
~~::]
,{tl i
-:; .1
,
~. .' ,'" ~~./"",-,/ ... ,- -~~;"',.....~_/.
':Z':-~],~~;~~~~6V,"\~ ' i, "~
, ~;~;~~I, :
'>:~::;~~...
'"
~~~~5~~~
~ ~~~~l!~ :fl~ c:.
; ~;;~~t ~.~:,~:
~ ~
, .
~ ~ s
~ ~L~~ ~ ~~::t
i'~~l
I S'
'~
:;'~(,
~~, !
" ::;~J
'~,
'"
"
II : ,
~ i~if~:~~ : \ "I:i i
! ~j I I i
"" - 1 !!
1~t,l[l;
.,
g
~: ~~ ~ ;~1~!~,l:
,
,
~ -
!'I\~d~~, ,.
~ ~}~:~tf~~!~:t:~i
~ I l~'n~;~'H~U
~-
-...:~<...,..;,-
~<:...~~-.....~. " .....
<,~~-~~:::~~~.. / >
.::~. '-....... ....-...
o
("j
('1'),
e-.t
I
~
I::cl
I
e-.t
o
o
e-.t
I
lJ.c
Q
~
-<';~:;~::'.- .
,
"
'.
"
-"~' -..
,::~:-;~
o;,.....,~
~t'~?~;~
1 ,.
~ ~~g~
. . .
. . .
~ ~ -
,.,
.. .. ..
. . .
::;: = ~
- :l:
~ ~
u
=
=
-
.:.<
is\
=
=
-
;!
-
.
-"
~
~
,.,
.
-
...
,
.,
.
.
"
':: '"
-" ]
~ .
~ "
-
,., .::
.
- .
... ...
:-
.
-5~
:~
.. ~
~;
- ...
.
~'il
- ..
~ .
-"
~ ..
~ -8
. -
=- ~
"'...
. . . . .
.
. . . - .
- - 0 ,., ~
,., ,., ,., ..
e- e- o. . ..
. .
::: = ~ = -
~ ~ :;: ::;
" " "
...
~
=
=
~
.;.;
(;9
;; ...
. '"
:a -
~
~ ~"
;;,
.~
o
,.,
'S
~
-
'"
-
i:'
1=i-I
"''''
'"'I;...,
"'-
-~ eo..::
I.'l..:.i
"'S
32:
~:;
=
-; :.
- ~
=
=
~
l ,[, ~ "I
:;";;1
,
, ~
I ~:~
!:l;j!
I
~:,h- _;~ '"
:,.."
,
, --<
.I
",'1
~-!
oI:l..;..o
.~ ~ ....
~.~ "
. -
",::
.. .,
..El ....1
;S;;ili
~ ~ I
"''''I
-;; -;;1\
~ -= i '
E-ol E-o ~ .
Ir~
I,:~ .
;'~,:, '-
!~;.~:-1 ~
o
...
""
:::.
" =:::
"
\
"'1
~I
<:;
I
.....
~c;:
., =
~:
]~
--
.'"
-
S
o
"!
.i'J-
I
1'=
:::::r.-:::
~
'Ie
;J~
~:G
;' I ~
.t::
-";-
.:"
",
:--"
,
,
-
.',
'~:;..<;> -....
~~~~
.>
.;:,
"
.........."'.
\
i
i
r ~,:'~
~ ..~
""
-
-
.-
... -
In
,,,, q; -
,,<,:r.>
""' ,~" -
~i~ ~I
:;1- ~li
*1 ~,
<:;,
,:'1
,~I
I
I
l~,,;~ i
Jllli,;1['
1'- '
LJ
.-
'"'
>-l
;:..:~
~
;.~,c" i ,;:
,,..; Ci
by an internal access roadway running North South of the flea market building along a
shared boundary line, which interconnects the proposed flea market "vith the overflow
parking area.
(4) Pedestrian and vehicular safety. There are no safety issues foreseen as long as condition
#3 is approved as stipulated by the Transportation Division which states, "The drivewav to
Trinitl' Place shall be limited to emer!!encv access onlv". According to the applicant, the
Trinity Place entrance ",'ill be gated and closed to public traffic. No internal sidewalks are
proposed, however, pavement markings outlining pedestrian walkways may be stipulated
during the SDP process.
(5) The character and quality of the neighborhood and the future development of
surrounding properties. Zoning staff does not foresee that the parking exemption would
present a problem related to character and quality of the existing neighborhood. The
abutting lots are zoned agricultural ,,~th large lots of at least 5 acres in size, In addition,
IS-foot wide buffers ",~ll be provided along the edges of the project boundmies adjacent to
areas near single-family dwellings,
(6) Potencial parking problems for neighboring properties. There are no potential parking
pro blems foreseen for neighboring properties, Staff recommends that access from Trinity
Place Road be liIllited (() emergency vehicles only. Adequate parking is being provided by
way of the parld.."lg exemption for fiea market patrons which wouid alleviate t.~e potential
for improper customer parking on-site, Trini!'j Pi ace is a two-lane residential road abutting
off-site parking area, which leads to the nearby neighboring community to the nolt"',
(7) Whether the internal trafJic flow is required to leaJ'e the site to reach the proposed off-
site parking. The proposed lot would be directly accessible from Basik Drive for ingress
and egress, Internal traffic flow is not required to leave the site to reach the proposed off-
site parking area.
(8) Whether vehicular access shall be from or onto residential streets. Trinity Place is a
residential road which leads to existing single-family dwellings ",ithin an Agricultural
. Zoning District. Access from this roadwould be limited by a gate to emergency vehicles
only.
(9) Jf11ether buffers adjacent to the propert)' zoned residential are 15 feet in width and
include a wall in addition to required landscaping. The development plan indicates that
the agriculturally-zoned lots with single-family dwellings to the North and East would be
separated from the proposed off-site parking lot by a I5-foot wide, type B buffer. Ten (10)
foot ",ide, type-D buffers are proposed along the southern and western boundaries of the
site across from vacant lots and/or row crops. No walls are proposed as there are no
adjacent residential zones.
(10) 1t11ether the off-site parking area will be used for valet parking. Valet parking ",~ll not be
pro,~ded on an on-going permanent basis, Valet parking ",ill be provided, however, on
occasion for certain seasonal special events,
(11) Whether the off-site parking area will be used for emplo)'ee parking.
Staff Report for November 1,2007,2006 CCPC
Parking Exemption, PE-2006-AR-12164
Page 5 of 7
The applicant has indicated that the off-site parking ar~a is to be utilized by patroni:.iLq.lfe01'l:0ye_e~..-
only, Employees would utilize ti,e most distant spaces. -
(12) Whether there are more viable alternatives available.
Staff concurs \vith the applicant that the proposed site is the best alternative for the proposed
parking area. Previously, the land was cultivated for row crops.
(13) Off-street parking areas I1Ulst be accessible from a street, alley or other public right-of-
way and all off-street parking facilities must be so arranged that no motor vehicle shall
have to back onto any street, excluding single-family and two-family residential
dwellings and churches approved under section 2.3.16.
The parking lot has been designed so that motor vehicles would not be required to back imo any
abutting public right-of-way,
1\'EIGHBORHOOD INFOR\1A nON REOUREMENTS:
For parking exemptions. the LDC requires petitioners to notif}' neighboring property ov>ners by maiL
but no meeting is required. The petitio!ler provided documentation to show t.fJ.at the required letter was
sent on September 28. 2007,
STAFF RECO!\l1VI:E";nArIO!\:
Tne Zoning 2.:1d Land De\'2iopnent Reyiey,\ St8:1' n:,~m1L'112njs mat tll~ Collier C:or:rr:y Pi3.11D.ing
Commission (Cepe) fOr\\Tud Petition PE-2007-AR-l: 164 to th:: BDard of CCH.lfl"ty CO~.missioners
(3CC) \;I/ith a reCOllli112::1datic1fL of approyal subiect to:
1. The Parking E~ s:r.cplion is li...rnited to "vhat is snov/n OD- the, pr~liITjDl1.ry sjte pj2L.~, identified as
"'Japles Big C. press Parking Exemption Applicaiion,-' prepared by Landy Engineering and
dated July 20C . The site plan noted is concepwal in nature for parking exemption application
approval only. The final site design and devdopment order plans shall be complia.Tlce "iili all
applicable feo":3!, state, and county laws and regulations; and
2. The Parking E:;~mption is limited to a maximum of 355 parking spaces that shall be resrricted to
'Japles Big Cypress !-"Iarket Place only: and
3, Access from Trinity Place shall be limited to emergency access only, At no timc shall the
drivcway be opened for Public access,
PREPARED BY:
'v<,~ -\'ll.t~ (~~-' I ~ ,,,,},,,~:
:; \) , .
,'-,1--:
\\'lLLIE BRO\VN, AICP, PRL"iCIPAL PLAl..I<ER
DEP.".RTMENT OF ZOND<G & LAND DEYELOPllIEKT REVIE\V
DATE'
REVIEWED BY:
Staff Reportror November 1,2007,2006 cepe
Perking Exemptior-: ~. c.~2006-AR.-12164
Page 6 of7
~ '"i;'E::;'
'J :)~ '--" I
\
JEFF~Y. ,ATZKOW
CHIEF\fS ~ST~t"KT CUL1\TY ATTOM'EY
, , I\,.,~,
~. .
I d (r<;j' 7
c ), ,
DATE
..-1
-~ ^ ";:' ;.
RA '{M01\l) V, BELLOWS, M..ANAGER
DEP AR TMEKT OF ZOND\G & L""-''JD DEVELOP!\1ENT REVIEW
DATE
" L' a'/j,~ I "
/"'jl/~ II}- j/'"''
0L'~/ I. . "~>...::.--'~--<_/'--{/i/?i__{.r{i.---
SBS,t"K MURRA. Y ISTE'~'ES, AICP, DIRECTOR
DEPARTMENT OF ZOND\G & LA...'N'D DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
.
.
" I" 1--/
//,: -":- ..,
/ l,,- / / '--;- /(-/
'DATE /
Al'PROVED BY:
!~ ~ / ' I
A ~. ~ ,~~i7
r_ I/.;/~':'- 1,-'1
~t= 1:0. .110 --: i_ . / I......,.,.........../~ - . v, /....
.I\}SEPH K. SCHlvlITT. i\DME'lISTR.-HOR I'lATE
C'OjvL~fL1'-.TJTY DEVELOPME!\iT & E~'JVIRONME>JTAL SERVICES DIVISIO"l
~
Tentarivezl' schedulcdfor the },'ovcmber 27,2007 Eoard o.fCounty Commissioners Jfeering.
COLLIER COLl\'TY PU....!\1\T\G C01V1.MISSION:
"
.=-"-
.. ,1"" .
j..'-)'.I',-- j.':~"\/"'.::o
~,~,
v
lVL4RK P, STRA..Il\l. CHAIRl'vL"-"
DATE
.'-
Staff Report for November 1. 2007, 2006 CCPC
Parking Exemption, PE-2006-AR-12164
Page 7 of 7
. o:ORt611Al
-= :c,g8 . " 01 ;.',
(i)
", 0.' c ~
2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104
(239) 403-2400 FAX (239) 643-6968
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
WWW.COLLlERGOV.NET
APPLICATION FOR PUBLIC HEARING FOR
PARKING EXEMPTION (LDC 4.05.02.K)
PETITION NO (AR)
PROJECT NAME
PROJECT NUMBER
DATE PROCESSED
ASSIGNED PLANNER
PE-2007-AR-12164 REV: 1
NAPLES BIG CYPRESS
PROJECT: 19990758
8/14/07 DUE: 8/28/07
l
--.J
Above to be completed by Staff
r
GENERAL INFORMATION
CO-APPLICANTS: NAPLES BIG CYPRESS MARKET PLACE, LLLP
ADDRESS: 3012 AIRPORT-PULUNG ROAD, SUITE 202
CITY: NAPLES STATE: FL ZIP: 34 J 05
TELEPHONE #: 239-262-3210 CELL #: 239-272-4643 FAX #: 239-262-8594
E-MAIL: KEITH@BASlKDEVELOPMENT.COM
AGENT: PATRICK WHITE
FIRM: PORTER, WRlGHT, MORRlS AND ARTHUR
ADDRESS: 5801 PEUCAN BA Y BL VD., SUITE 300
CITY: NAPLES STATE: FL ZIP: 34108
TELEPHONE #: 239-593-2963 FAX#: 239.593-2990
i BE AWARE THAT COLLIER COUNTY HAS LOBBYIST REG~lATIONS, ADDITIONAllY, THIS Ii
PETITION IS SUBJECT TO COMPLIANCE WITH CERTAIN NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION AND"
"SIGN REQUIREMENTS OF THE lAND DEVELOPMENT CODE (lDC). GUIDE YOURSELF'.
I ACCORDINGLY AND ENSURE THAT YOU ARE IN COMPLIANCE WITH THESE REGULATIONS.
Last revised 10/18/2006 Page 1 of 10
,.";c, ol.,::;;Ti h.~
Last revised 10/18/2006
Page 2 of 10
". ,
~
"..j.
I
.oWN.E.F??tl!P'INPGB:MAnON
NAME OF OWNER(S)
I
PRINCIPAL SITE: (C-4. MARKET PLACE)
MANAGING MEMBERS:
ADDRESS:
CITY: NAPLES
NAPLES BIG CYPRESS MARKET PLACE
KEiTH BASlK, LARRY BAS/K, JEFF BASlK
OWNER:
TELEPHONE #:
30/2 AIRPORT-PULLING ROAD, SUITE 202
STATE; FL ZIP: 34105
239-262-3210 CELL #: 239-272-4643 FAX #: 239-262-8594
E-MAIL:
KEITH@BASIKDEfELOPME1\T.COM
SUBJECT PARKING SITE: (AGRICULTURAL. OVERFLOW PARKING)
OWNER: NAPLES BIG CYPRESS MARKET PLACE
MANAGING MEMBERS: KEITH BASIK, LARRY BASIK, JEFF BASIK
ADDR:SS : 3012 AIRPORT-PULLING ROAD, SUITE 202
ClTY : NAPLES
STAT:: FL
ZIP: 341 OS
T:L:PHON:: #: 239-262-::210 CELL #: 239.272-4643 FAX #: 239-262-8,94
E-MAIL:
KEITH@EASIKDElELOPl,fEJ\T.COM
PROPERTY LOCATION
Detailed leaal descriotion of the orooerty covered by the aoolication: (If space is inadequate,
attach on separate page.) Applicant shall submit four (4) copies of a recent suryey (completed
within the last six months, maximum 1" to 400' scale) if required to do so at the pre-application
meeting.
NOTE: The applicant is responsible for supplying the correct legal description. If questions arise
concerning the legol descriptionl an engineer's certification or sealed survey may be required.
PRINCIPAL SITE:
SectionjTownship/Range: 18 I 51 Southl 27 East
Pial Book 1860 Page #: 1225
Address: 220 Sasik Drive
Folio Number(s): 00763880305 (Market Place)-(The majority of the required parking is located to
the west on Folio # 00763880402--approximately 4.3, as part of the SOP).
Legal Description: (See Attached Legal)
Size of properly: 4.4 +J- Acres
Total Sq.Ft.: 191,664 sq. ft. +1-
Last revised 10118/2006
Page 3 of 10
_n ',~ ,-. )
=c()~~.~
General Location: Northeast Corner of Basik Drive and US 41 (East Tamiami Trail).
NOTE: THE PRINCIPAL SITE ALREADY HAS 4.3 ACRES OF PARKING (LOCATED TO THE WEST) THAT /5 PART OF
THE SDP AND SATlFlES THE PARKING REQUIREMENT. THE OFF-SITE PARKING IS IN ADDITION TO THE
REQUIREMENT OF THE COUNTY, WHICH THE CLIENT WOULD LIKE IN THE EVENT OF OVERFLOW NEEDS.
OFF"siTEI'ARKINGAREAISOBJECT SITE\:
Section/Township/Range: 17 / 51 South/ 27 East
Plat Book 801 Page #: 1079
Folio Number(s):_0076/680002
Legal Description: (See Attached Legal Description)
Size of property: 9.79 +/- Acres
Total Sq.Ft.: 434,293 sq. ft. +/-
General Location: Northwest Corner of US 41 (East Tramiami Trail) & Trinity Place.
Address:
ASSOCIATIONS
.1
Complete the Following For all Assodotion(s) affiliated with this petition. Provide additional sheets if
necessary. If there are NO associations, please indicate N/A For EACH item.
NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: N/A
MAILING ADDRESS
CITY
STATE
ZIP
NAME OF MASTER ASSOCIATION: NAPLES BIG CYPRESS PROPERTY OWNERS ASSOCIATION
MAILING ADDRESS: 720 GOODLETTE ROAD, SUITE 305
CITY: NAPLES STATE: FLORIDA ZIP: 34102
NAME OF CIVIC ASSOCIATION: EAST NAPLES CIVIC ASSOCIATION
MAILING ADDRESS: 3B23 TAMIAMI TRIAL CITY: NAPLES STATE: FL ZIP: 34112
t
DISCLOSURE OF INTEREST INFORMATION
a.
IF the property is owned fee simple by an INDIVIDUAL, tenancy by the entirety,
tenancy in common, or joint tenancy, lisf all parties with an ownership interest as
well as the percentage of such interest. (Use additional sheets if necessary).
Last revised 1011812006
Page 4 of 10
Name and Address
Percentage of Ownership
N/A
b. If the properly is owned by a CORPORATION, list the officers and stockholders and
the percentage of stack owned by each.
Name and Address
Perceniaae of Ownershio
N/A
c. if the properly is in the nome of Q TRUST::, list the beneficiaries of the trust with the
percentage of interest.
N/A
d. If the property is in the name of a G:NERAL or LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, irst the
name of the general and/or limited partners.
Naples Big Cypress Market Place, LLLP (Sub;ect; Prop""ed Off-Site Parking)
Name and Address
Keith Basik
Larry tlasik
Jeff tlasik
Percentaoe of Ownershio
33%
33%
33%
Address; 3021 Airport-Pulliog Road, Suite 202, Naples, FL 34105
e. If there is a CONTRACT FOR PURCHASE, with an individual or individuals, a
Corporation, Trustee, or a Partnership, list the names of the contract purchasers
below, including the officers, stockholders, beneficiaries, or partners.
Name and Address
Per .:entage of Ownership
N/A
Last revised 10/18/2006
Page 5 of 10
Date of Contract:
f. If any contingency clause or contract terms involve additional parties, list all
individuals or officers, if a corporation, parinership, or trust.
Nome and Address
N/A
Last revised 10/18/2006
Page 6 of 10
:-.,
PROJi;CTllIIFORMATlON
Zoning of proposed off-site parking lot: Agricultural
Zoning of commercial tract the Parking Exemption is proposed to serve: C-4, C-5
Type of land use that the parking exemption is proposed to serve:
Total number of parking spaces required for project: 438 Required, 477 Provided
Number of Parking Spaces Proposed Off-Site: 159 Spaces
This parcel would serve as overflow parking.
Is the proposed parking lot separated from the permitted use by a colledor or arterial roadway?
o YES X NO
If yes, please name the roadway:
Does the permitted use propese to share required parking v.~ith another permitted use?
o YES X NO
E:VALUATION GRITE:RIA
Pursuant to Se::tion 10.02.13 of the Col:ier County LO:ld Devebpment Code, staffs cnalysi5 and
recommendation to the Planning Commission, cnd the Planning Commission's recommendation to the Doard of
Zoning Adiustments shall be based upon consideration of the applicable criteria noted in LDC Section
4.05.02.K.3.b. Please provide a narrative statement describing the reques1 with specific: reference to the
criteria noled in the cited section of the LDC. Include any backup materials and documentation
that you wish to have considered in support of the request.
SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS
GENERAL INSTRUCTIONS
Application must be clearly printed or typed. All material must be legible and completed in full. All
requirem:=:-nt5 must be submitted as indicated below, unless otherwise determined during the pre-
appiic::ljjvn meeting.
PRE-APPLICATION MEETING NOTES
Provide copies of no1es taken at pre.opplico1ion meeting, jf one was held.
ADDRESSING CHECKLIST FORM
Must be completed and approved by the Addressing Department, 2800 North Horseshoe Drive,
Naples, Florida 34104. Phone (239) 403-2482, FAX (239) 659-5724
DIGITAL REQUIREMENTS
Last revised 10/18/2006
Page 7 of 10
An electronic version of all plans (in pdf format) and documents (in Word format) on CDROM must
be submitted os part of the original submittal package.
BOUNDARY SURVEY. if required
Boundary Survey, no more than six months old, abstracted, signed, sealed and prepared by a
Florida registered land surveyor, showing the location and dimensions of all property lines, existing
streets or roads, easements, rights-of-way, and areas dedicated to the public. The Survey sholl be
accompanied either by an Attorney's Opinion of Title, or by 0 sworn statement from the property
owner(sl stating that he or she has provided sufficient information to the surveyor to allow the
accurate depiction of the information on the survey.
CONCEPTUAL SITE PLAN
20 copies of a 24" x 36" conceptual site plan drown to a maximum scale of 1 inch equals 400 feet
1 reduced 8%" x 11" copy of site plan. A copy of the 8.5 inch by 11 inch copy must be included in
the CDROM in pdf format. Additional copies of the plan may be requested upon completion
of staff evaluation for distribution to the Boord and various advisory boards.
The site plan sholl show the following information:
. all existing and proposed structures and the dimensions thereof,
. provisions for existing and/or proposed ingress and egress (including pedestrbn ingress and
egress to the she and the structure(s) on siteL
e all existing and/or proposec parking and loading areas [include matrix indicating required
and provided parking and loading, including required parking for the disabled]t
. required yards/open space and preserve area~(
. proposed and/or existing landscaping and buffering as may be required by the County
OWNER/AGENT AFFIDAVIT
Affidavit signed by owner authorizing agent and applicant to act as representative,
signed and notarized.
Must be
WARRANTY DEED
A copy of the last recorded deed, contract for sole or agreement for sale, or a notarized statement
of ownership dearly demonstrating ownership and control of the subject lot or parcel of land.
FEES
Required fees in accordance with the adopted Fee Schedule effective on the dote the application is
accepted by Collier County. Check sholl be mode payable to: Collier County Board of
Commissioners.
Application Fee
~ $1,500.00
Legal Advertising Fees
~ BCC =:: $363
~ ccpe =:: $760
NOTE: In accordance with adopted Fee Schedule~ when land use petitions ore continued, additional fees
payments may be required.
Last revised 10/18/2006
Page 8 of 10
PARKING EXEMPTION
(PE) APPLICATION
SUBMITTAL CHECKLIST
THIS COMPLETED CHECKLIST IS TO BE SUBMITTED WITH APPLICATION PACKET IN THE EXACT
ORDER LISTED BELOW WjCOVER SHEETS ATTACHED TO EACH SECTION.
NOTE: INCOMPLETE SUMBITTALS WILL NOT BE ACCEPTED.
REQUIREMENTS I #OF ;1 NOT
COPIES REQUIRED REQUIRED
Completed Application 20 I
Pre-Application meetinq notes 20 !
Conceptual Site Plan 24" x 36" I 20 I
roo e:. P , 0 " '" I
, ;:,IL , Ian 8 ~ x 1 I 1
I Narrative Statement (based upon LDC ::'valuation
Criteria) 20
: Vvarrantv Deed 2
: Owner/A ent Affidavit, sianed & se8lso 1
, Boundary Survey, no more than 6 months aid (24" x 36'''1 4
: Elestronic copies of at! document & Plans 1
I Addressinq Checklist 2
I Location MaD 2
11 O-Year Lease A;1reement (see LDC 4.05,02K2,a) 2
Fee:;;: The following are current; however the fee schedule is subject to change. The petitioner will be required to pay
fees in compliance with the adopted Collier County Fee Scheduled in effect when the petition is accepted by Collier
County.
o $1,500 Public Heoring Applicotion fee
~ $500.00 Pre-application fee credit (Applications submitted 9 months ar more after the date of the
last pre--application meeting shall not be credited towards application fees; a new pre-application
meeting may be required.
o $729.00 LegtIl Advertising Fee for cepe meeting (to be reconciled upon receipt Naples Doily News
lnvoice ).
o $363.00 Legal Advertising Fee for BCC meeting
o Property Owner Norification Fees. Property Owner Notifications $ r .00 Non-certified; $3.00 Certified
return receipt mail ( to be paid aner receipt or invoice from Dept. of Zoning & Development Review)
As the authorized agent'applicant for this petition, I attest that all of the information
indicated on this checklist is included in this submittal package. I understand that
failure to include all necessary submittal information may result in the delay of
processing this petition.
Last revised 10/18/2006
Page 9 of 10
~.~
Agentl~J.>plicant IGNATURE
((I (\2jCJl
Date
AfFIDAVIT
,,,:,,,,-,.
,-'''-''
';;.:::';
............'..,.".1
'-."',.:'''''':
,
:':\;;.'
". . ~
We/I, ~/) ~s r / being first duly sworn, depose and say that we/I
am/are the ownerso the property described herein and which is the subject matter of the proposed
hearing; that all the answers to the questions in this application, including the disclosure of interest
information, all sketches, data, and other supplementary matter attached to and made a part of this
application, are honest and true to the best of our knowledge and belief. We/I understand that the
information requested on this application must be complete and accurate and that the content of this
form, whether computer generated or County printed shall not be altered. Public hearings will not be
advertised until this application is deemed complete, ond all required information has been
submitted.
As property owner We/I further outhorize /-:::;:::'-/rr r,/c' /rV'/ .,Ie-
os our/my representative in any matters regarding this Petition.
to oct
~~/
~~. ~/
SlgA<{~~ert{ O;ner
L/A~S.I:::'
Typ~d or Prjnt~me of Owner
Signature of Property Owner
Typed or Printed Name of Owner
The foregoing ,]Pltryment.-,was acknowledged before me this ~ day of ~ .
200~ by ht1A"\~l L who is personally known to me or has produced
as identification.
State of Florida
County of Collier
U11 ~ ~~r\.e .J
(Signature of Notary Public - State of
Florida)
,.~<)fF.~. REBECcA PARATORE
It.!' a."~ MY COMMJSSION # DD 417346
,~~# EXPIRES:JL!y4,2C09
;q,.'tr..f;," BonDadThruNOlaryPubieUndmlriters
'\b..b:1' t.lL ~ ~VCJ-CJ K.-J
(Print, Type, or Stamp Commissioned
Name of Notary Public)
Last revised 10/18/2006
Page 10 of 10
RESOLUTION NO, 07
A RESOLUTION BY THE BOARD OF ZONL'iG APPEALS OF
COLLIER COUNTY, FLURIDA, GRANTING PARKING
EXEMPTION PETITION I'c-21J07.AR,12Ji>4, IN ORDER TO
PlCRMIT OFF-SITE P ARKlNG ON A CONTIGUOUS LOT
ZONED AGRICULTURE (A), LOCATED AT c20 BlISH,
DRIVE,
WHEREAS, the Ll~gislaturc of tbe Slate of rlorida in ChapLCJ 125, Plorida SlfnUlt~S, has
cOllfern~d on nil counties in Florida the POWC,j 10 establish, coordinate and enforce ;',onitlg um!
sllch businc:\s regulation;; w; are necessary for lill~ protection 0[- tbe public; and
WHEREAS, the County pursuant thereto adopted H La11d Development Code, (Ordinance
No. O'1-.1l, llS mncndcd) \I'hkh establishes regtllations fo: tile i',olling of [lillliculilr I.l"l~uel'flpl1ic
di\'ision~ of the County; lInd
\J;/HEREAS, S{:cliull '1.05,00 or tbe Land Development Cocie "et~ tOl'tll requirements and
;,t<tndanls fOI on-stred pmtillg alld IOHdillg ff1dlitlG~ lind DcrJllil~ an cxemptio!; from th(':sc
sliIlldanls 111ld~1' certain (;il'cumstall~:C-';; awl
'VIT1ERE/\.S, aIle: prop",t' Iwtice lile B\l,mi III 7.01lillf ApI)['al~ ll:::l(~ ,I !"lllbilc hc'mjt1j,' Le,
C0I1sidC,I- !';uting b;empuOlJ l'elitioll rF 2U07-/I.L-l '21 (~c: iLlH~ lml!ll; tilil', the', c['ilcl'J.~ ~ct furth IE
S::clioll t\.05.0:2..K.3, ot tile- L::mG Dc\'dt)p!ll~1lt Cod..: ha" ilt:~'~n tllei illld lil~ hlilll1[1 shollld ill
apl)['(l\'ed; Hnd
Vv'l-IEREAS, at! illlere.<;l::.(] punies have b:::ell ~~j\'Ctl OjWOrlllllity to be: hearc1 hy this Board
in n pl.lblic lm:cting and the Board h~yillg con:;ide-red idllllJltteTs pre~l~llied.
NOW, THEllliFOlzE, BE IT RESOLVED BY 'II-IE BOARD or ZONING APPEAL,)
OF COLLiER COUNTY, FLORIDA, Ilwt:
Petition Ph 2007-AI{-12J()4 fiied by Patr'iek Wl1jlt;, Esq., of Porll'T, Wright, tvlonis &
Anhur, representing Naples Big Cypress iv1arkel Place Limited Pmlnertibip, LLLP (Owner), is
ilpprovcd to permit off-site palling 011 contiguous lalld zoned AL:rkllllurc (A) at 220 IJ,lslk
Drive, morc pal,tieulady described in Exhibit A.
Tlw orr-slreel pm'king sh;.l[l comply witb the Site Plan t.lated ]Llly 21, 2007, :me! prcpared
hy Lundy Ell[;inccring 11ll,IChcd [)crc,to as Exhibit B, i1nd shall be subject lo tile l~(llldilium
attaclwd in Exhibit Co
nE IT FURTHER RES01.YED that tbis li..csolulion be recorded in the lllillllte~ of Oli:'.
Board.
1;;lg~ l of'~
day of
PASSED AND DULY ADOPTED by the Bomd of Zoning Appeals of Collie!' COllnty,
u_, 2007.
;--'
Florida, thj~
ATTEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK
By:
, Deputy Clerk
Approved as W form
ClllJ 1 ga ,'; 1fT piDllCY;
Jeffrey atzkow
Chief s~is, nt COHnt)' Attorney
Exhibits: A Legal Description
B Sile JJhm
C CDllclillom; of Appn.wat
IlOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:,_~_,
JAMES COLETTA. CHAIRMAI,
Page 20f2
- c' ~.:'::; ~
:J~'
"
Legal DescJ'iption
"
Pm-cd in West. 1/2 of the South l/~ of Section 17...i.-beginning at Souib..-vest comer, Section'
n go North 0 50'20" Easl1,271.72 feet to concrete monument on Soulhrigbt-of-wuy
H,V)'. 41 tilenc::: North 0 37'45" East 245.4& feet to concrete monument on north rightwof.
way ofHwy. 41, being }loinl of Beginning, thenc:.; South S3 55'40" Ellst c.1ong North
right~of~way line j12.45 feet to point in center line propDsed road, thcn::.c. North 36
04 '20" East 40:2.6 fee.t to point in c~n.t:r Un: ofroud, thence North 0 36'32" East 497.03
ieet 10 point in c-=nter jjn~ of road, thence :;";ort1-, 88 44'00" Vle~t 557.56 feet to point
thence Souti: () 37'-<5" West to point ofb~gi.nnjDg. .All the above being in Section 17,
Tov,m-hip 51 South, R.ant~ 27 E~t, Collie~ Count]', Florida, Le::s and Ex:::ept the Ellst 30
fc~l c.oI:lv~yd to C:oIE::r Count]' in O.K. BaaL 80~, Parr.:. 1079 for r03c rlght-o{-\vuy.
Exhibit "A"
E _.,-"-"= ., ._WtOJ:;;lA;~lL '":::'F- NV".Ic-J JilS ~ Y'r'N/YfIT:JHd '"
"",...s.". (oIT! '.~.. UOl1><t:lllrldV :luP!..il'td ~- =
"",.-.nl.r<] """., -- .' - rt"ndw;:,xlI
OU\t< ~~~ ~~.]I~n";."';J ic~~':.'~ ~lt~, 0'''' , -.-. (>,""'9\,1' ;:OO~'t'J.W 1"-.\
Y<,I/n\lTlIl<U - rlJ:j}a~ ..E5JJYJ&!/irflm $~J11!MJi~;;~ ,~jIJJ) ;':l5~)'1tdf\9'/JI!! :!:.;r= =
~W"""."U"'I~~ - - ~
~, ~lM!m~J~I~~~if~fN]"~J~'f}.((j]rMl\~'~TI -- ,--....- ..--- "" ..,-t.... =
- -- :,i=-- .w.Jl\,(J'tll,.~ J!EJl1'..Yi'Ml\Y $if;:ifWJ!!(l"~ ~~ S~aJWlM :UOl
. ._~~. -- ~.~ -= ~
--
~,~ ~~
~! !~
~ ~ ~g j~
~ ;1,1 l~,!~: !~lli ii !I ii
l 1 <., !.' ~,!~ ~,~~"
1 & I~~ ~bie;~ ~~ ~~ :;:~;;~..
,~ 1 ~li" ' ,b li"~ ",I,~
, ~ '~"I "~;!i:1:: i!' <l!b k\'ll:l !?l
~" ' ""0 '!, h, 1,/ "
- ~ -- - Il - ..~i:!Oi ;;!t"'Q "'=:,t: dO:, ii~
J 'Hi',- -~ ~~- ~~ 2~
h~r ': i ~ ~!;! ~!! m m !~~
. ..." II I ' ,b. I~~ ~!~ ~!! !~!
IrJ?J~,~JJ.~~,,, I; i ! ~g;l ~~~ ~~~ ~~: !~;
~ ' q
., I ,t ,I
o I.' I ,II; i! ,
" L' ',. ~~ , I
I" I L ~ - I
IJ i A r'---------------l ..------!---------------- ......... --'1 I
'1'.IW0:~1 : r-1-<"'-:(-?'Z,~:.::?'..<:./<,~:~(-r,y7":~7'-~.-."/--rc;::/.-~~7".:::7,~~r~?~~ '~-'.;.' '~~/..<~(~.\.'~ --. ~-r~-=:;Jl. T-.:!
. Jr"''::" I " ", '., ._~-' " ''\.. '~ '" '" " '-, " ~ ',--I!~~, ne I I '
I! I \ ""-, ",'" '-', '-".......-.~i.~=~,-..< "" ''\, ""'J/",,,,\..,- '-....... ~t~ '-', ~ ~ - t/
j! ! i " " , , . _:c...:, '. .... ' ,~.\ .[ "'-'..-'\ir'--------~+ I 'i-I
I~! i: r-, C1 (~ iIJJJ.fT'TITl l.illll,l uJl:n III':;. i
J'..! i I R ~ ~.I.-' ~~ r-'I1_'i'~ rl ~'r /(-- - -- - - --- ~~, ., 1'1:
J I 1 -- 1=1 R -, ,-' i'! I " I' ,
1 _"=juu' L:.. ", I'
"1''': ! I ~ .. I ,
~';J"ir'- (--- I 1 I
'I:I',':;: h.' ,-' ,I 1.1 i '
\l T'~' l I ~~ I I ~ ~ '~i :
j I ,-!! . ,~ 1 I ,
'll 'Id ..:.,' -- II, I, " I L~~, i i
!J'~ -!It i I ! I :
I , . , 'h I I'
""" " ..., ~ ! Ii I (Ii 'l'l'
"1''''1:'' li", 'c..L,_ i! ! I: 'I' ~l :,
- ~ ~~~..~ ~ h.
, ,~;,. ! , , .. i ',',;! I
1 ~!lt , ! ) : -I ,
-' _ ! i i :
I :
,
~. .~ i I i
, '",... ~ ) ) j I I
~~ "~'" , !
:.. .......~'" "". ,) ~[ ) / j i
' ~' """ ') i! 1/ ' / I ~
",,' " C::::;./ (' 'l "'!/0 ....., './ ,J / .. / J
'<:'0 ~"""'t :~~" "i' ... " ' / " II " /
.~'-.......:: ...."t\"I?l ''':'~, I>.... '....,' ........___ / I / / / /
>..... '~'''-~'f~" --'" -:</~ ", I / I I
'\...... ... 1-";":"~ '~, "-_ "'"_ _~/ ~ / / ' I
" 'k.... ,.... '\, ". '. \~., e, ,,/ J
'''"',,-. :I~''''' "-.",' ! !l ;' / / /
..,.......~-......::~ ". , ( ,11/ I
N '",." -"':;~,._./r,' " , , I! / / ' /
~~ I ''c~. :::,~~'<~ ...., """;1 11 ' / / / /
VI -- ,:' ", ~:."""'<:,:,-, "'.... "\,,, ' ,>" / I
I'I~,,: ", "(:'................"::", '-"" .~. ,;It 1/ / J'
I ""'" -....::,'" v '''"'''. I' '/ I
..... S , c, .""'...<1::::;-.....:"'-.." '<"'''' I ;' , I ,:
" I :r0"'--~. ""''' ~',~ ,>~. '" ,~ / / I /
.........' ":,;-,.",,, -.Il:::~0.~c";'''''':~", . /':
....... : .,;;:... '''''~-......:,''~::'c '~.....'" / / / I
, "1, .~~~~~~~... -'-~ 'J I
',~ ;bf~ '-~"'" "~~~~ "'~~ / / ,/;/
, '....... ' "~ "'~~. '",?"',' / / I
, " "'1io,,, ....'" I , I
I '" '-'::::... ~" ,'.....::, ,/ / ,.I
=-~"S
':0
.~ ::,')
::: ..... Q)
;:t,:1:' :;,
...:::....::.' CD
- ~n
.1' ~.-
~ j
~~
::1)':;;"
<:
II H II l!q!qx:tl
j'-"
~~'C
Ii!;
'''./>
~,H
n~
~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~
. , , ~
~ ' '~
j::1{; !
,~" ~
,."",~~
.....'" 10"
~:i~ ~
~",
'''~'
.."'".
"",,,,~ ~
N...... 0;
.",.
.
!'~ ~i
< l,
b ~~
.'
, ,~~~,
~:;'-:\lm~
H
il,~
'l.~
iT',
, ~"
!!,i
i
.
!
1
~ '
"! ,
." ,
I ~ ~
i,~"' ~
".! ! ~ !
I!!hi ~~ I' ~ i. ~
:'~'~ ~~ !" !i
::ll't !go~;J', ill" I
.,,~!, ~l.r ,~"
,
,
,
,
,
~ ,~:;:-", '.:.. ,,':,,: ""
-'-:':.)S':'_
CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL
Naples Big Cypress Market Place
J.
The Parking Exemption is limited to what is shown on the conceptual site plan,
identified as "Naples Big Cyprcss Parking Exemption," prepared by SDC and dated
September 2007. The sitc plan noted is conceptual in nature for parking exemption
application approval only, The final site design and development order plans shall be
compliance with all applicable federal, state, and county laws and regulations; and
~
The Parking Excmp!ion is limild to a maximum of 355 parking spaces that shall be
restricted to use by the Naples Big Cypress Markct Place only; and
3,
l\~cess from Trinity Place Road shall be, gated and limited as elnergency access t~Jr
emergency' vehicles O!;]y. .'\l nu time shall tlK cirivc\\.'ay be openeci for Public access.
,
.."
A 1 S - foot wide type n Landscape buffer shall be installed aio'lg Trinity Place, The
buffer will be revi"wed at the time ur the Site Development PIall review and instalied
acei compieted l'Ol1current wiIh the' construction Dr the off.site pa:king lol.
5.
The site plan shall be rcvisedto show 17 oversized spaces in the legemi box, which is
consistent with the number of spaces shown on the site plan drawing; not the 34
spaccs currently shown in the legend box,
6.
The 17 oversized parking spaces shall be used {(}r any oversized vehicles such as
buses, and RVs, but not for tractor trailers, semi-trucks. and oversize vehicles similar
in nature to these.
7.
The words "excess parking" shall be stricken, and rcplaccd with the words "off-site
parking,"
EXHIBIT C
PE-2007-AR-12164
,-.
,-
.-.
2807
of 9E
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
PUDEX-2007-AR-12I77: Hammock Woods, LLC, represented by David R. Underhill, Jr.,
of Banks Engineering, and Richard D. Yovanovich, Esquire, of Goodlette, Coleman, and
Johnson, P.A., are requesting a two-year extension for the Sierra Meadows Planned Unit
Development (PUD) from December 14, 2007 to December 14, 2009 in accordance with
LDC Section 10.02.13.D.5(a). The subject property consists of 90.8 acres and is located on
the southwest corner of the intersection of Rattlesnake-Hammock Road (CR 864) and
Collier Boulevard (CR 951), in Section 22, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, Collier
County, Florida
OBJECTIVE:
To have the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) consider a request for a two-year extension
of the development tinle limit of the Siel1'a Meadows PLJD, Furthert110re, to ensure that this
project is consistent with all the applicahle County regulations and that the community's interest
is maintained,
CONSIDER;\' TlONS:
Section 1O,02,13,D, of the Land Development Code (LDC) requires the Planned Unit
Development (PUD) propel1y owner to submit an annual rep0l1 outlining the progress of
development one year from the dale the PUD zoning was adopted by the BCe. and every year
thereafter based on the anniversary or its adoption, For those PUD zoned projects approved Plior
to October 24,2001. as the Sierra Meadows PUD was, ifonthe fifth year of their adoption the
authorized development has not commenced to the thresholds established by the LDC, then the
PUD is "sunsetled," which means that no development approvals can be granted until the PUD is
extended, amended or rezoned, This procedure is commonly refen'ed to as the "sunsetting"
provision of the LDC. The LDC allows PUO projects to be considered for up to two, 2-year
extensions. On November 15, 2005 the SielTa Grande PUD received its first 2-year PUD
extension from December 14, 2005 until December 14, 2007 (Resolution No. 05-402). This
petition seeks approval of a second extension for a term of two years from December 14, 2007
until December 14, 2009. The requestcd extension would allow the applicant to develop under
the direction of the existing PUD document.
The 90,8 acre project was originally rezoned from the Agricultural (A) zoning district to Planned
Unit Development (PUD) Zoning District on Dcccmber 20, 1994 (Ordinance Number 94-64) to
allow development of both commercial and residcntial uses. On December 14, 1999 (Ordinance
No. 99-91), the subject site was rezoned from PUD to PUD to allow an incrcase of the
commercial use, from 26.5 acre to 30,2 acres. and a rcduction in the residential use, from 25.7 to
18.7 acres, The multi-residential use portion allows a maximum density of 5.27 units per acre
and a maximum of 300 dwelling units, The 30,2 acre commercial area allows up to 260,000
square feet of retail or office developmcnt. The remaining 38.8 acres of site was set aside as
preserve and surface water area, Thcse uses arc consistent with the Future Land Use Element
(FLUE) and the Growth Management Plan (GMP) and the Land Development Code,
Sierra Meadows PUD X.2007-12177
November 27,2007 Bee
Page 1 of 5
1,'::',:;;-"-
,to;;T~D::;. ~7 :2~',"~,,-1
'- :): :.~
A Preliminary Subdivision Plat (AR-717) was approved for Sierra Meadows on March 19, 2002,
The Final Plat (AR-2340) for Sierra Meadows was approved on September 9, 2002. A Site
Development Plan (SOP) (AR-36l9) for the residential tract. Sierra Grande Condominiums was
approved on September 4, 2003. The first Sierra Meadows PUD extension (AR-7832) was
approved on November 15, 2005, The SDP (AR-8924) for Carillion Parke is currently
undergoing review.
The residential tract is currently undergoing development and approximately 35 building pem1its
have been issued, The sanitary sewers. potable water infrastructure and water management
systems have been constructed, The following Property Owner's Associations have been
created: Sien'a Meadows Property Association, Inc.. and Sien'a Grande Master PropeJ1y
Owner's /\.ssociation. Inc,
The applicant wishes to develop the commercial portion of this propeJ1y. and the extension of
this PUO is necessary in order to do so, Approval of the SDP is required for development of the
commercial site, but this approval cannot bc given without the PUO zoning in placc,
Synopsis of Approved Land Uses:
The PUO document that was adopted as pan of the previous rczoning approval (Ordinance No,
'1'1-() ] ) contains the list of uses approved le)r this project. For this extension request. no changes
are propos cd to the PUO nor are any changes proposed to the Master Plan. No changcs can he
made to a PUD as part of a request 10 extend the sunsctting datc, The PUO. if extcnded. would
retain the approved development intensities that were granted in 1'199: any changes would
require a separate amendment petition request.
This PUO is located on the south west comer of the intersection of Collier Boulevard (CR (51)
and Rattlesnake Hammock Road (CR 8(4) and is sUJ1'ClUnded by several types of land uses, To
the nOJ1h of the subject site is Rattlesnake Hammock Road (CR 864) and then Naples Lakes
Country Club PUD, To the east of the subject site is Collier Boulevard (CR (51) and then
Collier Regional Medical Center PUD and Agricultural zoned land with the proposed Toll-
Rattlesnake Development of Regional Impact (ORI). To the south of the subject sitc is Edison
Village PUD, and Lely Res0l1 COR!), To the west of the subject site is undeveloped, agricultural
zoned land,
Consistency with the Collier County Growth Managemcnt Plan (GMP):
The subject propeJ1y is designated Urban Residential Subdistrict, and is within a Residential
Density Band, Additionally, 4(H acres are designated Mixed-Use Activity Center Subdistrict
(#7), as identified on the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) ofthe GMP,
Residential density tor the Urban Residential Subdistrict is detcnnined by the Density Rating
System (ORS), The DRS allows for a base density of4 dwelling units per acre; a density bonus
of 3 dwelling units per acre for its proximity to a Mixed-Use Activity Ccnter; and a density
bonus of I dwelling unit per acre for having dircct access to at least 2 arterial or collector roads;
thus, allowing for a maximum of 8 dwelling units pcr acre for this designation, Additionally, thc
Mixed-Usc Activity Center SubdistJict pennits up to 16 dwelling units per gross acre for that
Sierra Meadows PUD X-2007.12177
November 27,2007 Bee
Page 2 of 5
portion orthc project not slated for commercial uses, This dcnsity may be distributed throughout
the project. including any portion locatcd outside thc Mixed-Cse Activity Center boundary,
No changes are proposed to this rUD and thcre have bc;cn no amendments to the Growth
Management Plan since the time that the PUD was approved that would allcctthe approved uses
or density, The Statement of Compliance. #9, contains some conflicting density figures. though
it does clearly state the total number of dwelling units will not exceed 300,
Commercial usage in Mixed-Use Activity Center #7 is proposed at 260.000 square feet and can
include the full aITay or commercial uses. rcsidential uses, institutional uses, and hoteVmotel
uses, Unified and consistent architectural standards should be considered throughout the
commercial project, and particular etTort should be made to the design the common boundary
shared with the residential portion to be compatible,
FLUE Policy 5,4 requires new developmcnts to he compatible with surrounding land uses,
Comprehcnsive Planning leaves this detelll1ination to Zoning and Land Development Review as
paIi ofthcir revie\\ ofthe petition in its entirety,
Based on thc above analysis. the proposed extension m<l\ be deemed consistent with the Future
Land Lise Element or the Growth Managcmcnt Pian,
Transportation Element:
The Siell'a Mcadows PUD Extension is eonsislenI with Polieics 5, I and ),2 of the Transp0l1atiol1
Element or the Growth Management Plan (GMP), The adjacent roadway network has sufficicl1t
capacity to accommodate the project throughout the five-year planning period, Rattlesnake
Hammock Road (CR 8(4) is cUlTently under construction and has a service volume of 3.200 trips
with a remaining capacity of approximately 2,437 trips hetwccn Polly Avenue and CR-95 I , It is
cUlTently at LOS "B" as stated by the Draft 2007 Annual Update and Inventory RepOli (ACIR),
Improvements to the Rattlesnakc Hammock Road (CR 8(4) are scheduled for completion in
.January, 2008, Collier Boulevard (CR 951) is also under construction and has a service volume
of 3.330 trips, with a remaining capacity of approximatcly 1.243 trips hetween Rattlesnake
Hammock Road (CR 8(4) and Tamiami Trail East (US 41), It is cun'ently at LOS "E" as stated
by the Draft 2007 AUIR, The proposed extcnsion does not produce any additional PM peak
hour/peak direction trips, and the adjacent roadway network is shown to have adjacent capacity
throughout the five-year planning period,
ConsIstency with the Collier County Land Development Code (LDC):
Section 10,02, 13,D, of the LDC requires the Board of County Commissioners to make formal
findings to suppOli approval of a PUD extcnsion request. Stafl offers the following findings for
consideration by the Board of County Commissioners:
1. The PUD and lhe Master Plan arc consistent ,,,ilh lhe elllTml GrOlj,th Management Plan,
including, hUT not limited to, demit\', inlellSitv and eonellrrenev requirements (LDC
,\\'11U!2.13,D,(',h,i,).
Sierra Meadows PUD X-2007-12177
November 27,2007 Bee
Page 3 of 5
-'
",',
J_
No changes have been adopted to the GMP that would make the previously approved PUD
inconsistent. thereforc the PUD rcmains consistent with the GMP,
2. The approved development has nor hccol11c incompatible H-ilh existing and proposed llses
in the surrounding area as the resulT of dCTelopment approvals issued suhsequem To the
original approval o{'the pUD ~01,ing ILDC ,U (), ()], J 3,D,6,b,ii,),' and
No changes have occun'ed in this arca that raisc compatibility issues, The projcct was
deemed consistent with the overall Growth Managcment Plan. and thcrefore in compliance
with specific goals, objectives. and policies of that Plan that require compatible develop-
ment. Therefore. the uses approved in this PUD remain compatible with proposed uses in the
area.
3, Tile approved developmenT wil! not, bl' iTselfor in coniuncTion with other developmenT
Place an unreasonable burden on essential puhlic .facilities (LDC ,U (), Ii), J 3,D'{i,h,iii, ),
The PUD document contains language that adequately addrcsses proVIsIons jell' public
facilities,
FISCAL fMPACT:
Extension ofthc PUD will have no ncw fiscal impact upon Collier County.
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION (CCPC) RECOMMENDATION:
PUD extensions are not hc,lrd by the cepe.
AFFORDABLE HOlJSING IMPACT:
Thc existing PUD does not contain any provIsions fell' affordable housing units or financial
contribution for such, The applicant has not offered contribution to offset tbe dcvelopment's
impact on affordable housing; furthcr, to include such a commitmcnt would require a PUD
amendment.
LEGAL CONSIDERA TlONS:
Under the provisions of Section 10,02, l3,D, of the Land Development Code (LDC), Time limits
/11/- approl'ed PUDs, the applicant is seeking a second (and final) two-year extension of this
PUD, which is schcduled to sunset Deccmber 14. 2007, Thc Board of County Commissioners
has the following choices in this matter:
I, Extend the current PUD approval for a period of two ycars, or December 14. 2009; or
2, Requirc the owncr to submit an amendcd PUD, The existing PUD would remain in
effect until subsequent action by the Board on the submitted amendment to the PUD, however no
further development order applications could be processed by the County until the PUD is
oJ1icially amended,
Sierra Meadows PUD X-2007.12177
November 27.2007 BCC
Page 4 of 5
:s'ni 1\:.:"
:: 2.'),')->
~, 93
Should the Board wish to approve an extension. approval must be based on the following
conditions being met:
I. The Board finds that the PUD and the master plan is consistent with the current
Growth Management Plan including, but not limited to, density, intensity and concurrcncy
requirements;
2, The Board finds that the approved development has not become incompatible with
existing and proposed uses in the sUJT()Unding area as the result of development approvals issued
subsequent to the original approval of the PUD zoning; and
3. The Board finds that approved development will not. by itself or in conjunction with
other development. place an unreasonable burden on essential public facilities,
This proceeding is quasi-judicial, and all testimony given must be under oath, The
attached material is advisory only and is not binding on you, The Petitioner has the burden of
demonstrating that the necessary requirements have been met. and you may question Petitioners,
or staff to satisfy yourself that thc necessary criteria has been satisfied, Approval or denial of
the Application is by Resolution. with approval of the Extension Request requiring four
af1innative votes of the Board,
RECOMME"iDA TJON:
Staff rccommends that the Board of County Commissioners approve the proposed two-year
extension of the Sien'a Meadows PUD,
PREPARED BY:
Nancy Gundlach. Principal Planner
Department of Zoning & Land Development Review
Sierra Meadows PUD X-2007-12177
November 27,2007 BCC
Page 5 of 5
IlemNumber:
IlemSummary:
Meeting Dale:
COLLIER COCNTY
:,;;UL,', ::c):,.lf,;i:;C;:
, ~T
't'uu:!(
r ,','~T:C' r:. 3' l;' ",'J,:" ',H'" P :;:, I '," ,- II SC,(; ;: J' (
~!,' Ie. ~
;11 ~<;()"
rl,,,llmuCF r,'(GU
I',' ";,~V'
~: I ~)'
(' T: ~
~1;: '-~ I ~'
To , J;:"t' '~:Ir'
"''''I'!W,p:: ;:;:r,:w' '1 T~l" "lwr,' C-,:',
I ,'X' l,'t,iHld
'",,'~11::"
- 'W.Cllr ~." ""1:1'
',';S' _."'i",'
',I',
[;n",
I'H'lHlrNI By
I"",c" :_,~ndl"c'
C;0r;1ml:'1" [j{> ~:J"ntc:~
Eo n 'J ,en 'If''''' 11:01 ~,pn;:"p'
~""',.W" h,wnu
:'."I""~: i, C","" L"J'Jd"p""''''' Fw",t.,
,i2DP
f\ri
L'.1"
Approllell By
.H'" hue
',(""""'"
,;"""':'''''',,,''
:.,'n','
i:."';, p,'
-"'1:."1:'
:",~'r"H"n' )'r,AI"
,_,;'n'~'L1r;:l
... , "
_I" "'" DI1:e 'l t.
Arll'~(lVN! II.,
'\pproH>dlll
Appron'd HI
ApprOH'd B~
=''','IC''''''''
['.-H'
Approvcll By
"',J""tjl"'L,n;l'"RI';
C; :';:, n "" ,,1'. ~ '''''c''
"!lVI"'l"''''''''':''''''
,""V"
i':[ ;..1'
L ....7"" :-", ""ICmr.l"~,1 i :r'-,~\('
L'"
(;."'H1ct:,,,,,,,"o::;!l)cnth
1 '11 ~.:~()O~ 1~: ," ...\.
',"<'\ r.}lre~1O'
Apllrl>"ed II)
Ltc; '-,"jl~r,"L1,c
1,"O:"Jt"" ~,.,
-"""~,p,,C:;XO;' ""10;"10""
~:':\;i'
pr.:
"',,,nu1Olt,':,m'.'CY'.:"I'-,n,,1).
Allprovt,ll B)
";O{j::'" 'en"";
,,'," ;,'>v'+:lpm'n
n"I'.-''''''''''F;'
t'-"''''''',-,(,,:S','r''J< ,,-(,'nmel '!1()'
r..""c
;';C "",ernn-, ,)o"'",<;p",, ~ "
'on' ;cC'n',;r'lllJ' ~,(, ,.'V':' ""'I"""
:c<.,"
c::w.,
AplII'o"ell Uy
or,IL r ~ord"I~W'
H",,, 'r,~nv,' ,.,
'\1 "" 2'" -' ;-11)<",""
q.,Cl" ", .0c"'<''''''1'
.\',r'"
:"11'
Appro"t'tl Hy
I:,"">' ",,,,~,<.,,.
',',tn,' '- ""'~.
,':hIdq~.
,~ ,'_w"",,"
, :;-(;,~'
I',,:,c''',
"
Aprrtl\Td R~
~;0"r" C' ':"n-""
:''''',rr,
'':''''in"r,'""" :'!'fI::c-
Page I of 1
:,-,'
'A,' ~~,' ec! ~:\'
'r,
":1"
'''mln'
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
WWW.COLLlERGOV.NET
Ci)
2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRJyt=~ 7 '.'
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 .
(239) 403-2400 FAX (239) 643-6968
APPLICATION FOR PUBLIC HEARING FOR:
PUD MASTER PLAN EXTENSION
--'j
PETITION NO (AR)
PROJECT NAME
PROJECT NUMBER
DATE PROCESSED
ASSIGNED PLANNER
To be completed by staff
)-
~
APPLICANT fNFORMA.TION
I
i
-,
NAME OF APPLICANT~S)
HAMMOCK WOODS, LLC.
ADDRESS 42 BAI!KLEY CIRCLE, SUITE #3 ::ITY FORT MYERS
TELEPHONE # 277-//01 CELL # NIA
33907
STATE FL ZIP
FAX # 278-1101
E-MAIL ADDRESS
JESS/CA(ciJINNOV A nVEDEV,NET
NAME OF AGENT DA VID R. UNDERHILL JR, -BANKS ENGINEERING
ADDRESS 2515 NORTHBROOKE PLAZA OR" SUITE 200 CITY NAPLES STATE-El",ZIP 34/19
TELEPHONE # 239-597-206 I CELL # 239.940-8687 FAX # 239-597-3082
E-MAIL ADDRESS DUNDERHILLIqJBANKSENG.COM
NAME OF AGENT RICHARD D. YOVANOVICH - GOODLETTE, COLEMAN & JOHNSON, P.A.
ADDRESS 4001 TAMIAMI TRAIL N. SUITE # 300 CITY NAPLES STATE FL ZIP 34/03
TELEPHONE # 239-435-3535 CELL # FAX # 239-435-12/8
E-MAIL ADDRESSRYOVANOVICH@GCJLAW.COM
BE AWARE THAT COLLIER COUNTY HAS LOBBYIST REGULATIONS. GUIDE YOURSELF
ACCORDINGL Y AND ENSURE THAT YOU ARE IN COMPLIANCE WITH THESE REGULA nONS.
S :Vnhs\t 'lxx\ I 437\DllCUnlcnls\Znoing\PUDRxLt:nsion2007'1 1437 _PUDhtcllsionPetilion.doc
PUD Extension Application
[~,.
--'::-1':.:;: I~'C ~~,'nl
ASSOCIATIONS
..~3.~."
,"'-" t' (' '
. .':;---.
Complete the following For all Association(s) affiliated with this petition, Provide additional
sheets if necessary.
NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION:
SIERRA MEADOWS PROPERTY OWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC.
MAILING ADDRESS
42 BARKLEY CIRCLE, SUITE #3 CITY FT. MYERS
STATE FL
ZIP ~1!lQl
NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION:
MAILING ADDRESS
CITY
STATE
ZIP
NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION:
MAILING ADDRESS
CITY
STATE
ZIP
NAME OF MASTER ASSOCIATION:
SIERRA GRANDE MASTER PROPERTY OWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC.
MAILING ADDRESS
5975 SIERRA CLUB DRIVE
C~TY NAPLES ST A TO FL
ZIP
34113
NAME OF CIVIC ASSOCIATION:
MAILING ADDRESS
CITY
STATE
ZIP
Disclosure ofInter~st Information
a. IF the property is owned fee simple by an INDIVIDUAL, tenancy by the entirely,
tenancy in common, or joint tenancy, list all parties with an ownership interest as
well as the percentage of such interest. (Use additional sheets if necessary),
Name and Address
Percentage of Ownership
NIA
:) :Vobs\14x.xi 143 7\Documents\2oni ng\PUDExtension2007\143 7 PlJDExtens iOI1Pctition.doc
PUD Extension Application -
b. If the property is owned by a CORPORATION, list the officers and sto~kh'~lcl~~:~nd ,-
the percentage of stock owned by each.
Name and Address
Percentage of Ownership
NIA
c. If the property is in the name of a TRUSTEE, list the beneficiaries of the trust with the
percentage of interest.
Name and Address
Percentage of Ownership
NIA
d. If the property is in the name of a GENERAL or LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, list the name
of the general and/or limited partners.
Name and Address
Percentage of Ownership
Hammock Woods. LLC
Ronald L. Davis & Robert L. D'Andrea
42 Barklev Circle. Suite 3
Fort Mvers. Florida 33907
50% each
S:\Jobs\ 14xx\ l43 7\Documems\Zoning\PLJDExtcnsion2007\ 1437 _rUDExtcn.<;jonP~tillon.Jot:
pun Extens.ion Application
e. if there is a CONTRACT FOR PURCHASE, with an individual or indiv,tl~dlS:; to' Jc
Corporation, Trustee, or a Partnership, list the names of the contract purchasers
below, including the officers, stockholders, beneficiaries, or partners.
Name and Address
Percentage of Ownership
NIA
Date of Contract:
f. If any contingency dause or contract terms involve additional parties, list all
individuals or officers, if a corporation, partnership, or trust.
Name and Address
NIA
g, Dafe subject property acquired C3:J leased 0 Term of lease
June 30, 2003
ff, Petitioner has option to buy, indicate the following: N/ A
yrs./mos.
Date of option:
Date option terminates:
Anticipated dosing date
, or
h. Should any changes of ownership or changes in contracts for purchase occur
subsequent to the date of application, but prior to the date of the final public hearing, it
is the responsibility of the applicant, or agent on his behalf, to submit a supplemental
disdosure of interest form.
S:\Jobs\l4xx\1437\Documellls\Zoning\PUDExtension2007\l43 7 ~PUDExtcllSiotlPetitioll.doc
rUD Extension Application
I
1'1{Ol'lcRTY LOCATION
Ile!aile,d le!!al deserip!ion of the Jll'Oller!v covered bv the ,,"plication: (If space is inadequate, atlach
on separate page.) If request involves c:hange to more than one zoning district, include separate legal
description far property involved in each district. Applicant shall submit four (4) copies of a recenl survey
(completed within the last six months, maximum 1" to 400' scale) if required to do so at the pre-
application meefing.
NOTE: The applicant is responsible for supplying the carreellegal description. If questions arise concerning
the legal description, an engineer's certification or sealed survey may be required.
Section/Township/Range
22
/
50
/
26
lot:
Plat Book
39
Block:
Page # 11-13
Subdivision:
Sierra Meadows
Property 1.0, #
See Attachecl
Metes & Bounds Description: See attacheclleaal clescriation
Size of property:
ft. X
ft. = Total Sq. Ft.
90.81 Acres
Address/general location of subied orooertv; Sovtnwesf corner of Rafl/esnake Hammock Road & Comer
Boulevard.
PUD District (lDC 2.03.06): 1ZJ Residentic:! 0 Community Faciiities
[2J Commerda!
o industrial
l
ADJACENT ZONING AND LAND USE
Zoning
land use
N
S
E
W
PUD
PUD
PUD
A
Naales lakes Countrv Club
Lelv Resor' PUD & Eclison ViIlaae PUD
Collier Reaional Mecllcal Cenler
Vaeanf
Does the owner of Ihe subjecf properly own properly contiguous to Ihe subject property? If so,
give complete legcd description of entire contiguous property. (If space is inadequate! attach on
separate page).
Plat Book 43 Page # 76-77 Property 1.0. #
30806000067,30806000180,&30806000083
30806000025,
SeelianlT ownship/Range
22
/
50
26
lot:
Block:
Subdivision:
Eclison ViIlaoe
Meles & Bounds Description:
S:Vobs\14xx\ 143 7\Doculllents\Zoning\PUDExtension2007\ 143 7_ PUDExlcnsionPctltiOll.doc
PUD Extension Application
___l!::l(~rENSION REQUEST DETAIL
--::;,
r,~,,'C,~E:.:~' ,or ,:-)~,?
- - c:; f'"
1--
Has this Master Plan received any previous extension(s)? 1Z1 Ves
If YeS, please indicale the date of approval(s) November 15, 2005
Board of County Commissioners' approval.
DNo
and submit a copy of the
Was the planned development proposed for two or more phases? 0 Yes [2J No
If YES, please provide a copy of the approved phasing schedule.
Has the Master Plan sunselled? 0 Yes [2J No
If NO, please indicate the date that it will be sunselted:
the Master Plan will be allowed to sunset:
December' 4, 2007
and explain why
If YES, please explain why the Master Plan was allowed to sunset:
Please provide a ~hronofogy of the original zoning approvals and amendment approvals as well as any
development approval and any sHe development improvements that occurred before the master plan was
vacated. *Pleose see attaclled list of building permits issued for the residenfial portion of tile site.
Preliminarv Subclivi,ion Plat -March /9,2002 IAR-717J
Plans and Pial Aeeroval- Seelember 9, 2002 I AR.2340J
SOP - Commercial Area - IAR.8924)
PUO Extension - Aeerovecl November' 5.2005 IAR-7832)
SOP - Re,iclenlial Area - Aeerovecl Auaus' 2003 (AR.3619J
Is the extension requested lor: [2J the entire original development, or 0 phase(s)?
II for phases, please indicate the phase number(s):
Please explain how the Master Plan remains consistent with the current Comprehensive Plan, including
density, intensity and concurrency requirements.
The erolecl has been subdivided in accordance with Ihe MCP and ,ubseauent aDerovals. All infrastrue/ure, for ,he
entire subdivision is comDlete and in service. The currenl PUDIMCP and subdivision ;s consistent wUh current tDe
ana ComD Plan reauiremenls. The oroiecf is considenl with current density allowances and does nof cause DubUc
;nfraslructure 10 ooerafe below aaootecJ levels of service.
S:Vobs\14xx\1 437\Docurnel\ls\Zonillg\PIJDExtension2007\ 143 7 _PUDExtcnsionPctition.doc
rUD Extension Application
H "., ,..
Please explain how the development proposed by the Master Pian remains compatible with exisl,~~:'citllcl
proposed Uses in the surrounding area in view of development approvals issued subsequent to the
original approval 01 the Master Plan.
The oro;ecf is bordered by public roads on the east and north by oreserve on the west and DubHe facilities to the
south. No new oDProvals or ac/iaeenf properties have been GrJDrovea s;nce .the subdivision was created. Currenf
perimeter buffers exceed LDC requirements.
Does the development shown on the Master Plan place an unreasonable burden on essential public
facilities? Please explain.
NO
EVALUA nON CRITERIA
Evaluation Cr: -eria: Provide a written narrative s.tarement ae$cdbing tn-;:; reques; to shov." compii::mce with tne
criteria founc in the Collier County LDC noted for the proposed action, Include any additional materials and
do::umentation in support or the request.
Deed Restrictions:: The County is legally precluded from enforcing deed restrictions; however, many
communities have adopted such restrictions. You may wIsh to contact the civic or property owners association in
the area for which this use is being requested in order to ascertain whether or not the request is affected by
existing deed restrictions.
Previous land use I>efilions on the subiect I>,ol>ert,,: To your knowledge, has a public hearing been held on
this property within the last year? 0 Yes [8'] No
If so, what was the nature 01 that hearing?
NOTICE:
This application will be considered Llopen" when the determination of "sufficiency" has been made and
the application is assigned a petition processing number, The application will be considered "closed"
when the petitioner withdraws the application through written notice or ceases to supolv necessary
information to continue orocessina or otherwise activelv oursue the rezonina for a period of six t61
months. An application deemed "closed" will not receive further processing and on application
"clased" through inactivity shall be deemed withdrawn. An application deemed "closed" may be re-
opened by submitting a new a pplication, repayment of all application lees and granting of a
determination of llsufficiency". Further review of the proiect wiil be subject to the then current code.
(LDC Section lO.03.05.Q.)
S:lJobs\14xx\ 143 7\DllcumenL<>V.oni ng\PUDExtcnsion2007\ 14J 7 _rUDExtensionPetitiOll.Ui.1-C
P(JD Extension Application
PUD EXTENSION
SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS
GENERAL INSTRUCTIONS
Application information must be clearly printed or typed. All material must be legible and completed
in full. All requirements must be submitted as indicated below, unless otherwise determined during the
pre-application meeting.
GENERAL APPLICATION
To be completed in full.
PRE-APPLICATION MEETING NOTES
Provide copies of notes taken at pre-application meeting
PROJECT NARRATIVE
Provide a written statement describing how the criteria listed in subsection 10.02.12 of the Land
Development Code have been met.
ADDRESSING CHECKLIST FORM
Must be completed and approved by the Addressing Department, 2800 North Horseshoe Drive,
Naples, Florida 34104. Phone (239) 403.2482, FAX (239) 659-5724.
PUD DOCUMENT
Original PUD approval ordinance.
FEES
Required fee in the amount of $1,000.00 per current fee Schedule. Check shall be made payable to:
Collier County Board of Commissioners.
AERIAL PHOTO
Whether or not an EIS is required, two copies of a recent aerial photograph, (taken within the previous
twelve months), minimum scale of one inch equals 400 feet, shall be submitted. Said aerial shall
identify plan! and/or wildlife habltots and their boundaries. Such identification shall be consistent with
Florida Department of Transportation Land Use Cover and Forms Classification System. Additionally,
a calculation of the acreage (or square feet) of native vegetation on site, by area, and a calculation
and location(s) of the required portion of native vegeiatian to be preserved (per LDC Section
3.05,07).
OWNER/AGENT AFFIDAVIT
Affidavit signed by owner authorizing agent to oct 05 representative. Must be signed and notarized.
WARRANTY DEED
A copy of the lost recorded deed, contract for sale or agreement for sale, or a notarized statement of
ownership clearly demonstrating ownership and control of the subject lot or parcel of land.
S:Vous\ 14xJ(\143 7\Documcnts\Zoning\I'UI)f<:xlcns ion2007\143 7 _PUDcxtcnsionPcl ition.doc
I'UD Extension Application
MASTER PLAN
Master plan no larger than 24" x 36", drawn to a maximum scale of
reduced 8V2' x 11" copy] depicting the following:
,:j;
inch equals 400 feel, [and one
.
all existing and proposed struclures and the dimensions Ihereof
.
provisions for existing and/or proposed ingress and egress (including pedestrian
ingress ond egress to the site and the structure(sl on site)
.
all exisling and/or proposed parking and ioading areas [include matrix indicating
required and provided parking and ioading, including required parking for the
disabled]
.
required yards, open space and preserve areas
.
proposed localions for utililies (as well as localion of exisling ulility services to Ihe site)
.
proposed and/or existing landscaping and buffering as may be required by the
Counly
OTHER
After initial review of tne request, staff wi!; determine who1 if any additional information may be
required to substantiate tne request. The appli.:an~t~ agent will be notified.
CONTINUANCE FEES
in accordance with Collier County Community Development and Environmental Services ree Schedule,
when land use petitions are continued, the foHowing fees will appiy:
Two days or less prior to meeting::;: $500
Requested at the meeting = $750
Additional required advertising charged in addition to continuance fees
S:Vobs\14xx\ 143 7\Documcntsl2.onillg\PU!)Exlcnsion2007\ 143 7 _PUDExLensillnPetitioll, dOG
PUD Extension ApplJcation
'-,,::::"1, <;i i ,,_
L
PUD EXTENSION APPlICATION
SUBMITT Al CHECKlIST
,''';,''.
"':1C"'~:~~l
r" ;>",,:..-, ", ::, ,-', , C~'
_'__-"d- ',U, "J"':
THIS COMPLETED CHECKlIST IS TO BE SUBMITTED WITH APPLICATION PACKET IN THE EXACT ORDER LISTED BELOW
W /COVER SHEETS ATTACHED TO EACH SECTION.
NOTE: INCOMPLETE SUMBITTALS WILL NOT BE ACCEPTED.
#OF NOT
REQUIREMENTS COPIES REQUIRED REQUIRED
Completed Application {download from website for current form} 12 X
Cooy of Aooroved PUD Ordinance 12 X
list ldentifvlna Owner(5) and all Parties if c Corporation 2 X
Completed Owner/Aqent Affidavit - Notarized 2 X
Moster Plans full~size and one B.S" x 11" 12 X
Aerial Photoqroph . current with FlUCFCS code 2 X
Listed Species Survey; less thon 1 2 months old. Include copies of previous 2 X
surveys:
Approved wetland furisdictionol Jines (less than 3 years old) I 1 X
Complete legal description I 1 X
Addressing Checklisf I 1 X
8~tS" x 11" graphfc location map of site I 1 X I
Fossible Other Requirements, depending upon the specific: pro,ec:t;
! Traffic impoct Starement
I Environmental Jmpoct Statement (E!S) ana diQitaVeiectronk copy OT EiS or
i exemption lustffication
Fees:
7
4
x
x
Review fee $1,000.00
Legal Advertising Fee. acc $363.00
EIS Review Fee - $2,500.00 [If applicable)
ransportaHon Fees (if applicable)
D Methodology Review. $500.00
D Minor Study Review. $750.00
D Molor Study Review. $1.500.00
OTHER REQUIREMENTS:
~ud
A pli nf/ Ag Signature
~/llfID'1
Date
S:\lobs\ l4xx\14J 7\Documenls\Zoning\1437 f"UDExtensionPcrltion.doc
POD Extension Ap~lication -
:::;1:'-;'-
.-~, r.>(
I
1i\.IFF~Ii)A Vnf
Wet., l2.o~ l. ~~...,- t~ \...~\S being first duly sworn, depose and soy that
we/10m/ore the owners of the property described herein and which is the subject matter of the
proposed hearing; that 011 the answers to the questions in this application, including the disclosure of
interest information, 011 sketches, data, and other supplementary matter attached to and mode 0 port
of this application, ore honest and true to the best of our knowledge and belief. We/I understand
that the information requested on this application must be complete and accurate and that the content
of fhis form, whether computer generated or County printed sholl not be altered, Public hearings will
not be advertised until this application is deemed complete, and 011 required Information has been
submitted.
As property owner We/I further authorize Banks Ena;neer;no & Richard Yovanovich
our/my representative in any matters regarding this Petition.
to oct CIS
~/' (j;>1U
\,CU /V~
Signature of Propert)' Owner
0~,j~
Signature of Property Owner
!?olxv+ bAJre0
Typed or Printed Nome of Owner
1?l"lAiJ L. D.v;s
Typed or Printed Nome of Owner
The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this \o.\\. day of -:st.)LL.~ 2007,
by ~\ "b'""""..,,,,,,,, \ ~~ L.~\S who.ppersona y known to me._
heD l:)1~..I.. ( 'f . L..riri Ilhllll. ~
State of Florida
County of QlIllF
u=e,
<i!c\l~~.'f.:~,~ S. DAWN lAMATRfCE
..W. MYCOMllI6SIOHIDD3876t4
~ EXPIAES:FtblU"Y11,2009
4)....'tOFf\.rJ~'~... BMI,:ftjThruBtdgetNolarjlSItvI:cs
'SD ?ft~c~.
(Signature of Notary Public - State of
Florida)
(Print, Type, or Stomp Commissioned
Name of Notary Public)
S:Vohs\! 4xx\ ] 437\Documents\ZrnlingI.14J7 _l'UDExtensionPt:titiol'l-Sib'Tlarurepagc.doc
}IUD Extonslon AppJ icarion
;e,T, !--J::- - r
. ~,_.-~.,
'~', 'y" ::;.c'
SIERRA MEADOWS l'UD OWNERSIDI'
Tract A . #73620100029
Ownership: Sima Meadows Property Owners Association, lnc" 42 Barkley Circle, Suite 3, F0l1 Myers, Florida
33907,
Tract B - #73620100087
Ownership: Sierra Grandc Master Property Owners Association, Inc., 6975 Sierra Club Circle, Naples, Florida
34113,
Tract C - #73620100281
Ownership: Sierra Meadows Property Owners Associalion, Inc" 42 Barkley Circle, Suite 3, Fort Myers, Florida
33907,
Tract H - #73620100469
Ownership: Sierra Meadows Property Owners Association, lnc" 42 Barkley Circle, Suite 3, Fort Myers, Florida
33907,
Lot I - #73620100524
Ownership: Hammock Woods, LLC, 42 Barkley Circle, Suite 3, Fort Myers, Florida 33907,
Lot 2 - #736201 00540
Ownership: Hammock Woods, LLC, 42 Barkley Circle, Suite 3, Fort Myers, Florida 33907,
Lot 3 . #73620100566
Ownership: Hammock Woods, LLC, 42 Rarkiey Circle, Suite 3, FOlt Myers, Florida 33907,
Lot 4 - #73620100595
Ownership: Pelican Bay/Hammock Woods Il, LLC, 26811 S, Bay Drive, Suile 350, Bonita Springs, Florid"
34134,
Lot 5. #73620100605
Ownership: Colonial Bank c/o CBIZ Property Tax Solutions, 4287 Belt Line Road, PMB #360, Addison, Texas
75001.
Lot 6 - #73620100621
Ownership: Hammock Woods, LLC, 42 Barkley Circle, Suite 3, Fort Myers, Florida 33907,
Lot 7 . #73620100647
Ownership: Hammock Woods, LLC, 42 Barkley Circle, Suite 3, Fort Myers, Florida 33907,
Lot 8 . #73620100663
Ownership: Hammock Woods, LLC, 42 Barkley Circle, Suite 3, Fort Myers, Florida 33907,
Lot 9 - #73620100689
Ownership: Hammock Woods, LLC,42 Barkley Circle, Suite 3, Fort Myers, Florida 33907,
Breakdown of tbe Sierra Meadows Prooertv Owners Association. Inc. (Owner of Tracts A, C & ED
Ronald L. Davis is President of Siena Meadows Property Owners Association, Inc., 42 Barkley Circle, Suite 3, Fort Myers,
Florida 33907,
Breakdown of the Sierra Grande Master Prooertv Owners Association. Inc. (Owner of Tract B)
Michael J, Stein is President, Steve Seifert is Secretary and Denise Gloer is Treasurer ofthe Sierra Grande Master Property
Owners Association, Inc.
Breakdown of Pelican Bav/Hammock Woods II, LLC (Owner of Lot 4)
Freida Lauer is Manager, James A. Nashman is Manager, & Clifford Wieland, Manager of Pelican Bay/Hammock Woods
ll, LLC, 26381 South Tamiami Trail, Suite 300, Bonita Springs, Florida 34134.
S:Vobsil4xx\1437\Documems\Zoniog\1437..0wrlelship_doc
Breakdown of Hammock Woods, LLC (Owner of Lots 1.2,3,6,7.8 & 9)
Ronald L Davis is Manager and Robert L. D'Andrea is Manager of Hammock Woods, LLC, 42 Barkley Circle, Suite 3,
Fort Myers, Florida 33907,
Breakdown of Colonial Balik (Owner of Lot S)
CBIZ Property Tax Solutions is Agent for Colonial Bank, 4287 Belt Line Road, PMB #360, Addison, Texas 7500 I,
S:\Jobs\J 4/(1(\.1 43T\Documen.ls\Zofling\1-137 _OWIH:rship.doc
::.-::;:,; ,,:.
')",".~
2() J:::JE
SIERH..A GRAI"mE PERMiT NlfMBERS
PERMIT NUMBER BUILDING TYPE ADDRESS
2005094296 ~1 Master
--"- --_.-"- -~--
2005094301 Type 2 Master
2005094305 Type 3 Master
2005094342 Maintenance/Car Wash Master
2005094323 Trash Compactor Master
2005094320 12 space crarage Master
2005094314 4 space garage Master
2005094309 6 space garage Master
2005094402 Type 1 - Building #9 6995 Sierra Club Cir.
2005094433 Type 2 - Building #4 7045 Sierra Club Cir.
2005094405 Type 2 - Building #7 7015 Sierra Club Cir.
I 2005094434 Type 2 - Building #8 I 70 1 0 Sierra Club Cir.
I 2005094413 I Tvpe 3 - BuildinQ; # 1 I 7065 Sierra Club Cir.
2005094411 Type 3 - Building #2 I 7055 Sierra Club Cir.
2005094408 Type 3 - Building #3 I 7060 Sierra Club Cir.
2005094419 Type 3 - Building #5 I 7035 Sierra Club Cir.
2005094415 Type 3 - Building #6 7025 Sierra Club Cir.
2005094417 Type 3 - Building # 1 0 6985 Sierra Club Cir.
2005094385 Maintenance/Car Wash 7056 Sierra Club Cir.
2005094399 Trash Compactor 7074 Sierra Club Cir.
2005094351 12 space garage 7050 SielTa Club Cir.
2005094355 4 space garage 6998 Sierra Club Cir.
2005094356 4 space garage 6980 Sierra Club Cir.
2005094359 4 space garage 6984 Sierra Club Cir.
2005094360 4 space garage 7066 Sierra Club Cir.
2005094361 4 space garage 7030 Sierra Club Cir.
2005094386 6 space garage 7002 Sierra Club Cir.
2005094389 6 space garage 7034 Sierra Club Cir.
2005094392 6 space garage 7020 Sierra Club Cir.
2005094393 6 space garage 7024 Sierra Club Cir.
, 2005094395 6 space garage 6990 Sierra Club Cir.
I 2005112975 Construction Trailer 8411 Sierra Club Cir.
2005123320 Club House 6975 Sierra Club Cir.
2006120535 Sales Trailer 6985 Sierra Club Cir.
I
i
11
Ii IIli ii ~ jl!! ~ Ii 1111 ~
! 'bl ;11 B IIII i II III! i
I IIII ,II ,I!
I ! Iii Ii
: III Ii I I
1,'11 i I I:;;
, 'I . . I
: III I i !-I!
i lill ,; i
, I, '
. . !
II ·
m
ei
~~
Ii" ------nrr-
, ,,__, ..I Iii I
'\ ,/;,.:" '1\1':
, , . 1:1.!1? ~~m I; I\\I\!
,\ Ic>-v ~.,<,: I' i '..
, e~' ~ 11,11"
, II' '0~" I" u., ,. ~
! I! ,(/:0:'~" ,,\~ ~ !! IllIjl ',l!
. . L \;:::,:-:.:r'-" ,'( ~;, i h 1,1,1, ,,{
, "'(h, V 'I" ~"I,I
i -l, 11). <;>~-}c~ ~I' '~Ii 1 :l~
f, li'i'- jt '-' ".',','.','.' .",..... J I ~ ,Elp;
H ",I ,i ),;.:-:,;.>,' '-:-:-:'"0 ~. I l't
\ I': 5' /;:::::::::;I~' ;:::;:::"'1 ~ 1 It~
/-~, 1 ~~ \':;:.",',',' ~&.'.'.',' J 'I,
'j/ I! \' \ II \',,::}:;":';;;,' J~,I~ 1""-.'"
,R,' ~ ~..,~rr"-i \
: ~~ t ~>';. r III I
,~\,i''/ Vi,eJ ! 11\\'1 ~~
lfi ,j 1\ . 'I("
'~ l I m Iff i': ~
~ !i," \ ,;j E~ Ii' ri', IiI ! i
/ ! II----il ;~ i ---] - It-h ~
! 111_ " It '" 'IIW I II ::! ~
.. r ,--,,' 'IlIa
.. I Ii ~iill II: 'i
! J L ~ !! \i:l~~~~ ,\ \ .
i.' i ~!~i B Ir Il!'I~'
'I~' . '~! -.. - --~' 1<11'l'\
J"i~L' I!' - llt:""I! Ilii.I; liJ:
, __.::'=~= _ I i I~l_ .JUL
..J_ ==..",,,,,,.~= ~~~~=~= =-=-:
--------- -itu:":::'-'~;; ~:<=~"':-;;-'\_C=-~=
, I!
1I',.\S>l[S VJIJ ffiUST; 3318 00. FAIOO IU.~ r:m COfl.'l. ItOOO^ Jjm~
" "',."
~
~
~~~ jV
~~
~~o
, 8"
;>~'"
~i:~
~~~
~
"
!:!
'\
~~-
I
l
r
!
!.
~:'-- i..
got.:fJ!lh'l
s<..~- " "' 21>>'
SOUTHWE8! J:NGlNEE~t~Go
~='~~"=
;~....;::=-,..,
~=="~'".
.oJ& NO.' QI,OI~
SIERRA MEADOWS P.U.D.
MASTER PLAN
........_........--..,.....
,..,-....-..-
....................--
Sl:CTlOO Z2. TO\\+ISlHf> 50 ~OUTl1. RoIJlaE 26 OSf
fl."""'-, 1l/'./~'
Sh_tt 10li
- ~
c
o
~
"
~ .
~+
3494538 OR: 3664 PGf.~Tb4i~;,':~c
RRCORDRDinomcmRICORDsnfcDLmlco'RIf,"~J;:0'
IOmllODCIt DUiP!DNIGRIR,RROCI,CLlI!
COR5 1915000.00
IIrIRl IUD
00C-,10 13815,00
"
()7
,) ~..;)
Tins INSTRUMENT PREPARED BY AND RETURN TO:
J. Jeffrey Rice, Esquire
GOLDSTEIN. BUCKLEY, CECHMAN, RlCE & PURE, P,A,
15t5 Broadway
Fort Myers, Florida 3390 I
Property Appraisers ?llJccl Identification (Folio) Numbers:
9.etn:
COiRO! COLilAl 11 II
mlO!
__ SplICe Above This Line For Recording Daln__
,UT'I
THIS WARRANTY DEED, I1li:t.de the _~ day of October, 201)4 by Hammock Woods, I.LC, a F10rida
Umlteel liability company, whose post office addIus is 42 Barkley Circle, Suite J, Fort Myers, Fl 33907-4$113,
herein called the grantors, to Pelicall Day IlIammAck WOAd~ II, LLC:. a Florida irni~ed Illlb!lIty cO)'lpany,
w~ols~.rglGfficcaddreS!liS dh'gll l'fO....l-\'(.... ~___~p \\::... r(
~ hereinafter ca.lled the Grantees: (JWie~r used l1er",jfl the lerms HgrQlllOr~ and "granlt't W induJl! 01 the parties
to this in1'ro~n' CJnd lhe heIrs, legal represenUttil'cs and u.rsiglls a/individuals, and Ihc successors and assil(7lSoj curporalions)
W [ T N E SSE T 8: ThaI the grantors, for and in consideration of the sum of TEN AND 001100'8 (SIO.OO)
OGUIll'S and other valllil.ble cansiderations, receipt wherc:of is hereby acknowledged, hereby grants, bargains, &ells.
aliens, remiscs, releases, conveys aod confirms untO the grant<:e all that <:CTUlrnland situate in CoUier County, State
of Florida, viz.:
A ti"ael or pllrcel.or IlIl:Id situated in the State or Florld'Jt CObDty of ColUer. 'rinb in Sttlion 22, Township SO
South. Range 26 Eut, bdo&: a part ofLot4 or SIERRA MEADOWS, a subdivision recorded in PIli' Rook 39,
a1 pilges t 1,12 and 13 io the Public Retords or Collier County, and beillt;: further des['rlbed as follo""'.~:
Cll-mmeDtln~ at Ibe Nonbeul eorner of Lot J of sliljj &ubdlvislrm; thenec N 88003'44"E along Ibe South line
of Tnct "G" of 5aid 5ubdivisillD for 5.01 feet to tbr point of beginn~llg; thenCf S 01Ct06'09"W .long a line
paratlel ttt and 8.00 feet East (IS measured~lh:C:-iicr~ciPJteula!) of the Last line of said Lot 3 for 275..19 feet;
thence 8 8RO(}3'44"W ror 8.01 f~f t<l thc;~o~~,il..!$~t~~(~~.l.~t 3, alld an illtersutiDn witb Ibe Ea~leri"
rlgbt-of-way line -oC Siern, Meado~'~~YlltQ {50: feel .~~)0~Wte E 01 "06'09""" .~oni: said Ellli1erl~'
rie'bto()r~wSlY line for 4'1.5& feet to )b(!1,Ptthwestcoroer or LoCS"'o!~.a1,d SUbdLvislon; tbenee N 8~OJ'.g"E
alooe the North liDe of said Lot S,for Zr~tbenee N 010 06'O!J~E f~ 3:2.97 feet.o a. point on toe Soulb
[ine oru.id: Tract "G", thence S 8"8<' ot44!}M!.,t.l(tne~ltS"OUtn.nne (0164.'3'1 feet to Ibe Polnl ofBeg1nolnE.
:p~=~ ,"lli .1' lli, tf~rf:@11)~ft~ \"'''0 beloo,wg m w aoywu'
TO HAVE AND TO HOLD, lli",~ ~s""p" [m"er \'~. / ~w.
\"""~ }\c /~J
AND. the gnm10rs hereby cove~~ said grantees that ~ t~ lawfully seIZed of saId land III fee
GUJll'le; that the grantors have good ~Iawful authority to se llL'C1hvey saId land, and hereby wammt the
btle to said land and WIll defend the sa ~the lawful cia itll ersollS whomsoever. aDd that said land 1$
free of all encumbrances, except taxes acc :~~~~~~ 31,2003.
[N WITNESS WHEREOF, the &aid grantors hav~llod and sealed these presen1s the day a.mI year fm;1 above
wnnen.
Signed, sealed and delivered in the presence of:
~~((t,.., j~/o('i1
Witness #1 Signature
ELL ENS S To ~J F
Witness #J Printed NB.me
J..llIYJJ1 IVi .b-u.J.1f.U< 10...10
Witness fl.2 Signature
:5U:S<<n Iv1 blA nO wtlV
WjblCl6 #2 Printed Name (
HAMMOCK WOODS, LLC,
i Florida limited liability eompllny
,..-;'- ~-
BY, i/O. ':?:_2~
RONALD L. DAVIS, Co.Manager
~ eLl n, J ..-D tJ ru
Witness Nl Signature
ELL ~ ",I S .,..~ TCl ",j G
Witness 'III Printed Name
HAMMOCK WOODS, LLC,
II Flt:trldllllmlted liability company
,Ii JlIJQn rY1 ,~.l.(yY}jA )(}1J
W,mess #2 Signature
:Su:san i\.1 bib,Q(J..!().V
Witness #2 Printed Name I
1f:~j~ /
BY; ti~
RO ERT L. D' ANDREA, Co-Manager
PUOEX: 2007-AIl 12177 ItE\': 2
SIEltltA ~mADOWS I'[:n
Proj{.{:t: 19990059
!laic: 9/20107 nUE: 10/4107
File Nc; (l4U70
'"
, :~i ;:.
*u OR: 3664 PG: 1646tt*-= _
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF LEE
The foregoing im~nt was acknow[~dgc:d before me this ~_. day of O~lobcr, 2004 by Ronald L Davis,
as Co--Manager of HatnIDOcll: Woods, L-LC, l'l Florida Iimiled liability compuny, who is perwnall}' knowtJlo me or
nave produced as identification.
SEAL
j({,,,~~
Notary Public
.,.P'r' />/J QFRCI.O.lNOTA,RYSEJlL
0" il'( E1.J..9,'$moNF.
~l<;; ca.lWSS:CNNUUBEn
~ <( 0007:i224
"'1<- R loIY O::ll,aussON EXPIRES
OF F~O DEe \HO~
ECL2 '.....1 -S, ""','rt"'^/~
Prinled Notary Name
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF LEE
The foregoing InstrumeDt was acknowledged before me this I ~."tJ... day of October, 2004 by Roix:n L.
D'Andrea, as Co-Manager of HlIlDIIlOCk WGOw;, LLC, a Florida limited liability company, who is p!;rsanallv
iaJ.own to me or have produc,;:d _~ as idemiflcation.
SEAL
FUe No: 0011270
/fu"-,, J
Notary Public
"-
"U 0 l1...L.
o...,..Il~ ~v~c- O~At~iN",;?=~
bV~"'7 0
~ .01.. CO;,U.lISSrON NlJMllliR
? '>>''; OOOni224
1-0 cQ: lIV CONl,IlSSlON EXPlI1~s
f'H Gre tb.2005
~ L( ,_~ i'-I ':
Printed Notary Name
"S -'-0 r...J r_~
,,--';<C~~:E-~Qi=!-~~~>- ,
/,\)...-/ -'-:~~I,>
(;>,/ -",.)_.-,
, \
/ i '1.1_.......'" '------J\, \,
,( L.r'\ 1\\
! (ry~ui Illf'~f') !
l,-i~.Y\~j)J!f L ,"'I
\~\ ~ 'I ,~
\ '<" \ :&\, i.::.;,/
\1;;,:." '\VG')
'-P f.;....______-<:.)~
"..:[l{ E C ll'~/
----
[6'~---
I~ ~ \ ~ r,
\S/ ~, '\)\ '
!1;~1
1\)./~0-}'
\~},
-->~._'-- --
,- 'Y~:"':.':3<:i;'" ~~~: '=~; ~>' i -] C. 7
10.. lnslnlln<:nl was prepared by
0"'8l! 5, Truxlcn, Esqu,",
Bolaft.. Truxlon. P ^
121lOO Univmily Drive, Suite N340
Fort Mym. Florida 33907
3212664 OR: 3330 Ptrf~26f3
moun II Gillem UCQUI of CWolll COIIfI, r~
01/01/1111 It 01:1111111" I. 1lOCI, CUU
COlt 11111111."
DC III 15,01
DOC-.1O 7mUD
COPUS I.OD
It It I."
Parcelldentlficltlnn Nns:
00(32960404
.,ta:
IOIUOI !lR1Ol
Ilm GIInm" II UlO
POrt 11111 PL 11111 51ll
[Space above this line for re--...ordingJ
~PErlA.l, W.ARRAl\1T'V n~J.".n
THIS SPECrAL W A.RRAN1Y DEED is made this 30 day of June, 2003, by AlanDa,
Ltd., a Florida limited pal1nership (hereinafter ca1ICld the Granlor), to Hammock Woods, L.L.c., a
Florial!. Iimiled IiRbiiity company (h~~~~,wh:lse address is 28331 S, Tamiami Trail.
Suite 15. Bonita Springs. Florida 14;L11l.~/~--:::2\;/'~',
/ ..Cj-"/ '< J '
/ ( . /' , ~ \
WITNESSETH ~t i~s~tor. for and in corisid~on of the sum of Tell (~I(HKl)
DoUm and other valuable fonsidenifion:s;,~ wQe.of is ~ acknowledged, hereby grants.
bargains. sells, aliens, remies. I I~~~~~to the grantee, rill that certain lam!
situateinCollierCounty,Fl ~i (t't~~~) rf' ~l ).f-'~
S\ ~~) .~
Lots ] through 4 an :1>. ough 9 of SIB , " S, according 10 the Plat
thereof, as recorded i 1'Ia ook 39 al page 1,J (ffi Public Records of Collier
County, Florida, 8;' F' . ,,\..\\,.
....liE" C1\~C/
~~......
and this conveyance is subject 10: (i) real estale taxes and assessments for the year 2003 and
subsequent years; (ti) zoning, restrictions, prohibitions and other requirements imposed by
governmental authority; and (ill) those specific exceptions to title set forth on ExhIbit "A" hemo,
TOGETHER, with all the tenements, hereditaments and appurtenances thereto belonging or
in anywise appertaining
TO HAVE AND TO HOLD, the same in tee simple forever,
AND the Grantor hereby covenants with said Gran~ that the Gnntor is lawfully seizled of
said land in fee simple; lhat the Grantor has good right and lawful authority to sell and convey said
land, and hereby warrants the title to said land and w\lI defend the same against the lawful claims of all
persons claiming by, through or under the said Grantor,
OR: 3330 PG: 0202
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, Grantor has hereunto set Grantor's hand and seal the day
and year lirst above written,
Signed, sealed and delivered
in our presence:
~H'~'-Ph r .
I'rint Name: m \ e(lt:., A" ~I.S..S
By:
M, S,
Executive Vi President
12800 University Dri~ Suite 275
(J./';:';;- c--::--', Fort Myers, Florida 33907
Uv,,- / \ W,h.O( r;:.,
L .)>~---_.~.... J, \l,,"'~
. 01,(;;;0.:.5'-' -'",/"L'"'\.
',........,.'/.... '.,........ \\
, 1,- \ \
/ , J~~<..." '--,J'\ '\ \
/ f \_.....r--\ \
STATE OF FLORIDA) (I ~'(' '(~(~!J )~)\\?)~\
)SS n ~~Lr =.1, I~,
- \...-' "[,. I 1:-<
COUNTY OF LEt; ) \~fI .i~ } /,..::'
\1- '\"\j .0
The foregoing in fl' cknowledged~~)'s 3D day of June, 2003, by
Gregory M, Moms, as ElCecutive' . rp, a Florida corporation, as Genend
I'artner of Aland&, LId" a Florida limit ;I1!!lP,~(~ is perwnally known to me or ( ) has
produced l) 1 q as iden ali5il.
~~~,: ":.~:l~f~~' 1
l" ',' ,)1'''''1''
Aj . '" I" ,
~Q,<..j)N-.
Notary Public, State of Florida at large f) .
Print Notary Name: m l~ (lc A - t"fe(!,S
My conunission eKpires: I a. -OS -OS
'(',
j
J
tt* OR: 3330 PG: 0203 *tt
F..hihlt "4"
Title Exceptions
1. Subject land lies within the boundaries for Solid Waste Collection, Collier County, and will be
subject to future assessments by Collier County,
2, Any lien provided by chapter 159 Florida Statutes, in favor of any municipality or authority
for unpaid charges for services by any water, sewer or gas system to the land described herein,
3, Sidewalk Easement in favor of Collier County recorded August 6, 1997, in Official Records
Book 2336, page 1786,
4, Reciprocal Access Easement Agreement recorded October 16, 200 1, in Official Records
Book 2909, page IS3!.
5, Restrictive Covenant recorded October 16,2001 in Official Records Book 2909, page 1563.
------
6, Sign Easement and Agreement rytf~~~)~~;al!~ Wallace R. Devlin, Sr recorded in
OffiCIal Records Book 3070,,!('~t);''i'S-:- .........,,,l.r>.
/L,I/' .....".....,- \
7, Notice ofTr,.!'arty Agree&ent{e.;urde:N!LQfftCillL\Reco~'tis B\ok 3I12, page 501.
I I w-. , -vI \ \
8, Easements, Restrictioni, D~I i&t1'mry!~rs;-:a\1lJ:[)~t~s ~Jted.. and shown on Plat of Sierra
Meadows recorded at ,at 00\; 3 P 8 s tihinl.g!,
l"" W J If_-- f-.
J_ ~~ .-v
9, Terms, provisions, cove~~eondilions, restn~'di ns, k~. ~~. s and other mailers, including
provisions for assessmeWfl ainsl the insu J,/~~J ished by the Declaration of
Covenants, Restrictions a'n\tfE)~ents for Sierra's recorded at Official Records
Book3135,page802. ~:::--- '{J\Y
,,,rIlE CW..S~
Note: All references contained herein r~o'1iti-]lll61ic records of Collier County, Florida,
I
(i,
"'-^'
'Y ,J~ ;:;'(',
., ~~ f!." 0 c-
~'f ~ D
\~5~
.~I~I ).
h..
r .~" _. _
"
~ "~',"-
2872466 OR: 2909 1G~ :1526'
UCOQU 11 omclll UCOU. 01 eoUUl eoan "
It/ll/lO'lat u:mll DlI=n' I. '1Ga. euu '
eoa 125m....
ue fII 24.11
ooe. , II 1111.5.
Thh !nIuwnonl WlIS prq>;<rro by
Oreu $, TN.lOIl. Esqui",
IlolaIioo TnulOll, P,A,
12800 Vlllvcnll)' Dri,., S.,I. #340
Fan Mye", FIoridlt 33907
IftJ:
IOwa. ftmG,l IT 11
11.0. fllfI.SlfI DI Il.I
IT filiI .1 llltl
Parcel JdmtifK&liun Nus:
00432960404
ISp.ace MOO'iie this line for rt'(,:uruiJl~1
SPF.r.JAL WARRANTY llF:F:O
THfS SPECIAL WARRANTY DEED is made thb Iv , da)' of October. 2001. by
Al2ndtt, LId., a Florida limited parm::rship (hereinaher clIlled !he Gr-<lmor), to Colonial Bank
(he~inafter .caIled Grantee) who!>:: ad/d/~s~3~a/e,o:~w C~mer Boulevard, BoniUl S;>rings,
Florida :>,41.\4, /, '\' ,,>_,--._<j)\/.,>,
/ '-, // ~ .("
/ .4 ~_., ./ -"",,- 1.... ''\
WrTNESSETH: Tha,iih~-.c{.ram.ol~,or and in consic1erati~n of the sum of Ten (S 10.00)
Dallars and o~r valuable COfsid : dcns.~_ ~lprWirer.alf is heltby acl:nowledged. hereby grants,
bargains. sells, aliens, remiiieS. .l::ai::$. <C~Qntl~mo\ the grantee, all that cer.ain
land siwate in Collier count;ct,wO / J J~, . \\f J,f-.<,;i
~'....:::;/~ ~ , IV
~', Exhibit. A. Atla~~ IJrel S /
"? \ -'\'\.. ,,0/1
f''' V
and Ibis conveyance is subject ~ ~--eslallUaJ\-.~~ents for the year 2001 and
subsequem years; (ii) zoning. '~~~;;;:;ri~}afil&mJ "and other requirements imposed by
govermnental authority; and (iii) those specific'cxcepilons to tide set forth on Exitibit "B" hereto.
TOGETHER. with all the tenements. hereditaments and llJIpurtenances thereto belonging
or in anywise appenaining.
TO HAVE AND TO HOLD, the same in fee simple forever.
AND the Grantor hereby covenants with said Grantee that the Grantor is lawfully seized of
said land in fee simple; that the Grantor has good right and lawful au!horily to selland convey said
land. and hereby warrants the tiUe 10 said land and will defend the same against the Jawfi1l claims
of all persons claiming by. through or under the said Grantor,
~I
,:';':0;r('~c; l'::11, i ,:""
1
OR: 2909 PGtn4l~--,~'
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, Grantor has hereunto s~t Grantor's hand and seal the day and
year first above wrillcn.
Signed, sealed and dclivered
in our presence:
Gruntor:
Abmda. LId"
a Florida Iimitat partnllrship
By: Alanda Co .. a Florida corporation.
As Genen r
~~"1S'"Trd\- By:
Print Name, Gee".") ~ 'T~""""w-J
12800 Umversity Drive, Suite 240
~~~ ~/:::--__;;::-_._..... Fort Myers. Florida 33907
Prin! ~: tTtI C1a..eD~~'Y c:,uC:,..>::....
J rJ . L'l "/ --.::.....' r, "
/u" /,/ -"-: J- '\
.. .~.
/ / \---~ \ "\
/ ;' l.:c-~ ----'01 \ \
I ( ./"\ \ \ \
STATE OF FLORIDA) I ) ~C\ (O~.)\ ;j"1D )~V()
COUNTY OF LEE) r:c\~\:.~. ~~.~ 1/ ~ )Iji
The foregoing InsUU ~\as acknowledged ~~e n ~ '/2 - day of October. 2001,
by O. J. Buigas. as Presiden ~\ landa Corp.~: c' ration. as General Partner of
AIanda. Lid" a Florida limited i . He ( y 1(~IlY !:nown \0 me or ( ) has
produced iiT;/Ifl-; Cy
~.>/
/'::
My conunission expires:
PA Tn' GAR!lNU
NarAllY I'IIHLIC STA'lli Of FJ..OQIOA
COMNIS6JON NO. DDOOM3t
NY COMMISSION EXP. MAR. 1
EXHIBIT "A"
OR: 2909PG~,jl28-
iNllulw fEugiilcrriilU, lhu.:.
ProfessIonal Engineers, Planners & La,1d Surveyors
DESCRIPTION OF A I'AR( 'Fl.
OF l.AND LYING
IN
SFCTION 22. TOWNSHIP 50 SOUTH, RANLiE 2ll EAST
COI.LlER COUNTY, FI.ORIDA
(SIF,RRA MEADOWS)
(PIWPOSF.Jl LOT 5)
A TRACT OR PARCEL OF LAND SITUATED IN TilE STATE OF F!.ORIIlA. COUNTY OF
COLLIER, LYIN(i IN SECTION 22. TOWNSfIIP 50 SOUTII, RANUE 26 EAST AND BEING
FURTIIER BOUNI>EIl ANI> DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS
COMMENCING AT NORTHEAST CORNER OF SAID SECTION 22; THENCE
S.8&003'44"W ALONG TilE NORTH LINE OF SAID SECTION FOR [25,17 FEET TO TilE
WEST RIGHT-OF.WA Y LINE OF COUNT.UOAD 951; TIIENCE S,OI006'09"W, ALONG
SAID WEST LINE FOR 398.D7 FEp:;-{Rf~~clG(~9~':lf'W FOR 75.11 FEET TO TilE
POINT OF 8~:G[NN[NG; THE}>l,Q~'If?.oNTJNUE S:~f>~.~:y4)!~W, FOR 212.,8 FEET;
THENCE 5,01 O{)6'09"W, FOR 1'8~S2TEET; FEET TO T!flYB'E!GlNNING OF A CURVE 'I'D
, , ~. .
-mE LEFT flA VING A P~WIUS Of-J6:tlb-EEEL TlWNCE SOUfllfASTERLY ALOI>K;
I I It!c.-<'i> ---"1 , \ 1\
SAID CURVE TilIWUG!l A q~NTKAI~,\E OF \)~002'2S\ FU,R 58.46 FEET TO A
POINT OF l' ANGENCY: 'rjlEI)'l,er;::*\F~il>\'i1~lN3~tfEE[I; TIIENCE
N.01006'09''E, FOR 224,78 FEB~'Iio 'I l!3 1')1/>1 [' t>>jB~G lIN<;
I~, \ \ '" \,! j 1[' f-, I
\1,) \..... ~c.:....-':b ~,..""I
BEARINGS ARE BASED ~r('~E N ORT!! LINE ~SEJ'T1q..y..tt1. TOWNSHIP 50 SOUTll.
RANGE 26 EAST, AS BEAR~ ,g8003'44"W,~(~ ~O
~' ~~'
~' ';;;- __,;}. ),\0\/
PARCEL SUBJECT TO EASEME "'Pf~~fW~.~<KESERVATlONS AND RIGHTS-
OF-WAY OF RECORD, c::::..:::.---
SUBJECT TO FACTS THAT MA Y BE REVEALED BY AN ACCURATE ~()UNDARY
SURVEY.
NOTE: PROPOSED LOT S IS BASED ON THE PRELIMINARY SUBDIVISION PLAT OF
SIERRA MEADOWS. AS PREPARED BY TillS FIRM. TO BE RECORDED IN THE
PUBLIC RECORDS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA.
SIIEET 1 OF ',>
~!
t.
"\JOIiMtu.lltl'~~IIOttSlI.OI !Io....WlOlllttl,l!:..N.C'.hl&~
UlC ~.- / .ll'~'
':./"" .--.- -- - -.. --~--, - .~- -- -I'. - --~.; - ~~ -- ...__1
I I ,
I I I I
I- l \
I ~ \ I
\ iI. I I
I , I
I , ,
I I I
- 1- - if ~I i i i
.:. ! I ~ I
~' '5 '
. ---- .---- t\ it- : ~
_1-.....',,(1 l:l t~ j
,-...ltt I ... . -It:! 1_...1
N 1.1\ I ~ I "
';\ A I I
"'\1 'I I I
J i /.~/S:\~~Q1~/~;. ri 1<1 1 i
~ \ ,/~() // ~'" '_" '.~ t-'~!
Cl /11 " /" '" ,[, I I .~
~ B le!I L 'r ),j~=.:::-=-~,---- - -:"- - _c,\ "\\-.-- Ii --;- ---
I ~ III ' I V -~,~, ,,,' \ I I
! i ~mu~~';O~I?I;,iiii~m"....."...."'..Jil
" :i : il ""'/WI Ilh~ I ·
h~~ ~
~ >-3
i. @
~~
r~l~ ~
~~Iil:a~~
k .~~Il UJ
" Il.~~ n
~-I!! ~
.s ~
H
H
~~
it
II
~!
i Iii II
I I 1'-
f I:! d!
i il 'i t
II II;
~ &
-
Ci;j!
~ Vj~
;: ~&>>~
~ S!~=c:.:
~ ~!~~
~ ~U'"
~ ~f
~~
~=~FI r~~b
mn IU~~
.U!I "'.
Ih'
81
;,snl hg;.
fit' - '
,"'" '...J :::
~
h~j
tit OR: 2909 PG: 'i~3r:f,t
I
F.t:hihU "R"
Title Exceptions
I.
Ordinan~e No. 75.20 regulating the installation of any watcr distribotion and
wastewater colle~tion system; Ordinance No. 7:;.21 protecting certain trees within
Collier County, and Ordinance No. 75-24, the "Collier County Zoning Ordinance for
the Coastal Area "Janning District", all rc~ol'dcd in Official Records Book 619, pagcs
1177 through 1381, inclusivc.
2,
Collier County Resolulion No. CWS-85-4 recorded in o flicia I Records Book 1142,
page 1796.
3,
Drainage and SenTI Easement Agreement dated March 30, 200 I, and recorded April
3, 200 I. in Official Records Book 2800, Page 1319, and Ihat certain mortgag...,
consent to Drainage and Ber~asemcnl.-i'greement recorded in Official Records
Book 2892. Page 1647. /;/;'"\~ CQ/(\>>
/ '",)/ -""~
Access ::asemcnl A'~G~m;nt between AI;;;i1;')-Ull,. and Colonial Bani: bcing
recorded comempor;llIeG~~fv-kre",ith. f' \\ \
I I i.tJ.-~ ._--'"" .\ \
" ~'I /\ \ \
~eclprocal Accds E~~~,~~n~\ . e{~9,7/\and~, LId, and Colomal Bank
aCing recorded e~tc ~ran'QoU~JY17he!'jW ) \\ Y i il
(J 1:1\2~" J if-<
Restrictive Cove t between Alanda. ?- uind Q'\rial Bunk being recorded
contemporaneousl\~T -(Ih, --~t.,)~J5'
\..O~ .<.,'-.
NOle: All of the aDO\1!, r?~eem iB~~ public records of Collier County,
Florida, unless ot1le~~/
4,
s.
6.
\0/
t-oc;t;F--'(7\ ..,--
\ A,O
\ /;0
\\\/
l_
.S:TlliS'. :;::'~):J7
3212673 OR: 3330 'PG: :utjf2
UCOIllID ia omcw. IICOIN of CO~UII conn, r.
Ol/OI/IOtlll 01:11" MIIlIf I. 110:1, CUD
lie ru 10.51
~',70 .11
This Instrument was p<epared by:
Otog S, TNXlDII, &qui..
80111I01 TruxtDII, P.A.
12800 Un....lty Drive, Suite J40
Fort Mym, Florida 33907
Ilta:
IOWOI nmGI
Ill" .mum II .m
rorr ifill 'L 31'11 ~131
PaJcelldentification Nos:
0043%960404
[Space above this line for recording]
QJITT..rr.AIM nEl":n
Thls Quil-Claim Deed, made this ..30 day of June, 2003, Between Allndl, Ud., a
Florida limited partnership, party of the first part, in favor of Sierra Meadows Property Ownen
Anociallon. lnc" party of the second part, whose mailing address is 2K331 S, Tamiami Trail,
Suite 16, Bornta Springs, Aonda 34134,
WITl'I:'ESSETH, That the said ~,ef.tM-first part, for and in consideration of the sum of
TEN DOLLARS and other valuabl~~riS;'~~':--'il'hand paid, by said party of the se:l:lnd part,
the re:eipt whereof is h.."!1lby ackll.~ . ,does ~~^ . relecse and quit-cl&im unto the said
seoond party forever, any interysf ~ parl}' may have in. ,to't)le following described Imd
~ /<;. \. \ \
''''-~' ----,)\ \
T"ct' A "'" H of i M......._~.. _ ~t t~f, lIS =oroe:l in Piat
Book 39, at Page I f' of ~rr~'t:' ~ .:' florick,
To Hive and to ~o)it t ~. ~ar the appurtenances th:P.unto
belonging or in anywise ap >' Ding, and all the }to' t/~ I interest, lien, equity and claim
second party forever, rO A LJ
~... ,:-:."
,(' . . "'-.l
IN WITNESS WHEREO ~r(l,i)/>1lt~nto set Grantor's band and seal tbe day
--,--
and year first above written,
Signed, sealed and delivered
in our presence:
Grantor:
Aland.. Ltd"
a Florida limited
By: AI
A3
'p
'0 a Ao' corporation,
~~ Q ..j)f,,,' By:
Print Name: m \Jt\e.llc. 1+ . Pre.t,s5
~Q.~
Print Name c.w ~ 4 ~ J..J'S
iit OR: 3330 PG: 0232 ttt
51 ATE OF FLORIDA}
) 5S:
COUN1Y OF LEE )
The foregoing instrument was acl:nowledged before me this 30 day of June, 2003, by
Gregory M, Morris, as Ex.ecutive Vice President of Alanda Corp, a Florida corporation, as GeneraJ
PlIltner of A1anda, Ltd" a Florida limited partnership, He (j;; is personally known to me or ( ) has
produced f) I Dt as identlfication,
My conunission exp
Ia. <>5-oS
~.,~ ',.,l"~4"~~11
l. '.r' ,'A
.
':, ).')' ','
, . ~.
~ Q,-PI--....
Notary Public, State of Florida at Large ,
Print Notary Name: m l d\::.tlc A . Pre.LS s
~-------
/'~"\\-:R coD!:'"
,/ .~, ,\<..--..-----~.~ '... \I". ,-,,".
'/,,-4'~~";:'-'/ '..... -(hr '.
/,/ ,....-./ "" ~. ",
/ '1,...'/ '",\' \
/ // ~"---''---'~ /,-
/ / '~"'='V. ,-\ \ \
i I "L__"'-'\ \,
( / ('Y']' 'j ro)~:V7') \
! ,)\(y\L/ Lf, ~ ~JI
\C" ' ) / Cr.:
\;:~ ~\ ~\..j /67
\1~ 0.. /" U/
'\ Of> ...... /" \,\^' /
~y " ----.-..- ..,\) Y
..... I '{fE" {'n~L/
--.....:..<.._:.2::.:..c.~
J
I o:?,~~,,~
This InSlnlment """ pr<pan:d by;
Greas S, TruxIO!\. Esquire
Dol8ftos Tnixton, (l,A.
12800 Unvrnlty Drive. Sui.e 340
Foil Myers. Flnrld. 3l9!17
3123092 OR: 3212 PG'~;1511 c,
IlCOlDlD In DIIICI~ IICOlDI of COL~lll CDOIf!, II
Il/Oi/IOOl It tt:llAM DIIG!r I. IRDCl, CLlII
IIC III IUo
W.',1O ,11
leIII:
IOIUDI !lUnal
UUG mnum DI mo
!lilT mD !L mil
Pm:elldentlficat;on Nos:
OlUJZ5Z0006
[Space above this line for recording}
OlJTT.,..' AIM hFJi'h
Tbis Quit-Claim Deed, made this 2.f~ day of June, 2002. Between Greg W. Eagle,
individually IIDd IS Trustee, party of the first part. in favor of Siern Meadows Propert).
Owners Association, I.nc., party of the secoJuLIlIl!'!>- whose mailing address is 12800 University
Drive, Suite 340, Fort Myers, Floridl'.}~R CO'C.r''-,
/, \"---'-'-'~"^.! "'.
/ ,'-", 'Y' ,/ -...', \ }' .,
WrTNESSETH, That tlre~t~' of the first part;Jb~and in consideration of th-~ srun of
TEN DOLLARS and other vljl"uab16 considenltions. t~,~t in hand Paid, by said party of the second
part, the re;:eipt whereof is herebf aclfkowl~~ doos hereby l-emi\e, release and quit-claim unto
the said =and party foreve1 aniG'~CWU TIt.), ma \ in and to the following described
land. I II l (C"'" \
~J0 ~~~ f-<
Tract "C" of Siemt~, WlI. ' according to th~")..~:U tile~€i recorded in Plat Book
~ at Pages IH~, 0 ~, bUc Records of Cotr~ ' l): Florida;
\fU
To Have and to Hold th~ . ther wi , _ ~ngular the appurtelllUlCeS thereunto
belonging or in lIrtywise appertaining;"llO!,llILthu,liltj;: gill, title. interest, lien, equity IIrtd claim
whatsoever the said first party, either in lawllrequitf, to the only proper use IIrtd benefit of the said
second party forever,
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the said first part}' has signed and sealed these
presents the day and year first above written,
Signed, sealed and delivered in our presence:
C~~~--+l
Print Name: G ~ ~ C;. 'i'1t.....I'".,..,
~~~~
By:
{J IJ L-f
Greg W. Eagle,
Individually and a! Tru!tee
3818 Del Prado Boulevard
Cape Coral, Florida 33904
L
. .
*u OR: 3212PG~;1518>~t*
Stale of Florida
County of Lc 0(
)
) S8:
)
The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this ;2 ~ ~ day of June, 2002, by
Greg W, Eagle, Individually Wld as Trustee. He (v) is personally known to me or ( ) has
produced ,.1 I JI\ os identification.
My conunission expires:
~~~);?._pL
Notary Public. ate of Florida at LDI'l!e
Print Notary Name:
.---~----~-,-
// q:JZ COr ~'''''''
CRliG::S'IRur.ToN...... / < \~';";--'~-(.I.\' '",
NorAl!Y!'Ullu:sr"'TliOF~ 0\> --<,'/';"
COMM!SSJON NO. DOO2t3Q3:1 ~.. ,~// "<- '\
. lit\' COMMlSS10~H'xr, MA l'21...... "-'--, \ \
""'v;.r;'. ~-_ r--, \'
! / '-:'-~/," "-" \ \ \
! it \r1(/ (J1JW\\\ f\. \)1
\'"',\ . /J \..i / r~ L !..~
.' ;'\....:::::-' '..:::::../ ~ ~ =-'" '/
r'" \~ J' /e:.:
'\'-c.'\~ }f,: . /. ,::J
.-<J -,,"'- "i-I
\,/,:' / .~/
d'" / ,t/
""Op;-"~__<' \'/
~JJ.!ES;t!:S:~
,Cj
j: :::;^
.
Prenored bv and return to:
Henry Paul Johnson, Esq.
3734588 OR: 3930 PG: 3054
mORDID 1n omClAL RlCOiDS of COLLIn coum, rL
11/1'/2551 at 03:12PK DiIGB! I. BiOCE, CLliI
COIS 3600000,00
DC m 11,50
DOC-.TO moo,oo
Law Offices of Henry Paul Johnson, P.A.
6640 Willow Pork Drive
Naples, FL 34109
239-591-0133
File Number: Sierra Grande
Will Call No.:
utn:
HliRY PAUL JOBiSOI
"10 KILLOi PAil D1IVI
RAPLIS IL 3UO!
(Space Above: This. Line For Recording Data]
Warranty Deed
This Warranty Deed made tbiS~ day of !JtJ~, 200S between Cambr Company,ine., a New York
corporation whose post office address is 414) Ocean Ave~~ Lynbrook1 NY II563~ grantor, and Sierra Club Condominium
Associates, a Florida Joint Venture whose post office a.Q.dr=.i<j97S Sierra Club Circle, 34113, granlee:
(Whenever used herein the terms .grMtQr~ and ~granl"!:'''~~~~4~~m~t and the hei!'i. legal repres.enUl1jv~, am! ~signs of
individuals. and tile successors Md assigns of corporatjon~lti.-iliid trustee!:) ".~ .(, r~'\.
/(1// "r' ,
/ '/ ~-: \
Witnesseth. that said grantor, for ani in c6n.riderariot1--!,fthe sUJU,ofTE~ AN!;> NO/lOa DOLLARS ($10,00) and olher
good and valuable considerations 10 s;;nd gr..lntoi-'nr;,W. p , bysaid grantee\lhe l.eceiPt whereof is hereby acknowledged,
has granted, barga~ed, ,and sold to ~e '.aJtEd g~lllf7r , "r~'''' .!l.~~n 'sign \ forever, the following described land,
situate, Iymg and bemg m CollIer COjnty! icirid'fo'f'itl Q) ~ \
A tract or pareeJ of land ~1U,~t \, :l~t rida~ n ~q:f Collier, lying in Section 22,
Township 50 South, Range ~~ and being further ' ~nde an ribed as follows:
COMMENCING at the Nort 'W:..llt1rner of said Seetio.:121;.)1' ~t'r outh 88' 03'44" West, along Ihe
North line of said Section for ZS.p,'ie.1 to the Wesl rig!ll1flwli1 line of County Road 9SI; Ihente
South 01' OS'19" West, along sai ~ ~....1or 50.11~~' Soulh right of way line of County
Road 864 (Rattlesnake Hammock Ro {~P . e 1\1\t1m!",,' outh 88' 03'44" We'l, along said right
of way line for 1370.00 feet to Ihe POIN NNtNG; thence contine South 88' 03'44" West,
along said right of way (ine for 678.83 feetj thence South 00. OO'OOtl East, for 303.29 feet; them~e
South 7('50'51" East, for 145.09 feet; thence South 00'00'00" East, for 504.37 feet; thence North 88'
3S'28" East for 400.63 feet; thence South 01' 17'01" East, for 398.29 feet to lhe South line of lhe
North 1/2 of the North Ir2 of said Section and the North line of Lely Resort Subdivision Phase Two,
as re<orded in Plat Book 18, al pages 43 through 45, of the Puhlie Reeords of Collier County,
Florida; thenee North 88' 17'13" East, along said North and said South line for 398.64 feet; Ihenee
North 01' OS'19" East, for 904.62 feet; thence South 88' 03'44" West, for 275.00 feel; Ihence North
01' 56'16" West, 350.00 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING.
Bearings .re based on the South right of way line of Cnunty Road 864 (Rattle Snake Hammock
Road) as Bearing Soulh 88' 03'44" West.
Also known as:
Tracl B, SIERRA MEADOWS, according to Ibe map or plat thereof as recorded in Pial Book 39,
Pagt(s) II, Public Records of Collier County, Florida
Pareelldentificatlon Number: 73620100087
Together with all the renements, hereditaments and appurtenances thereto belonging or in anywise appertaining.
DoubleTtmeol>
*** OR: 3930 PG:3055 ***
To Have and to Hold, the same in ree simple forever.
And the grantor hereby covenants with said grantee that the grantor is lawfully seized of said land in fee simple; that the
grantor has good right and lawful authority to sell and convey said land; that the granlor hereby fully warrants the tille to said
land and will defend the same against the lawful claims of all persons whomsoever; and that said land is free of all
enclJmbrances, except taxes accruing subsequent to December 31, 2004.
In Witness Vl'bereof, grantor has hereunto set grantor's hand and seal the day and year first above written,
Signed, sealed and deiiyered in our presence:
olnick, President
"
el.J
----~(~------.
// \ph _O[il:'~,
" "" \~ --- rc". -...!G:,l\
/ -~..\,., >~. , orpGr:a~ to'eit....
/'kL1 /"- ~'.~-~ r "-\
/1 ,>./ "'. ../--. \
I '-:/ '"'-
I /'(--'" , ,\
I I lk__--:;W~'\!,. ----.;......\ \ \
StJlleof NfUJ~'X.I'-. I 1(1 ~(~\i ''--:=U':~:V'\[) )~Jf\ \
Count)' of N J<->"''' ! I ~) I 'r--' \\ I,
5- \..;:)./'~ j ,-
The foregoing instrument was ackn ~~gOtHiefore C thli-tl-! d1'S';of '~ "" Ic><r' , 2005 by Allen Skolnick,
President of Cambr Company, inc" a l~. \Xork corpor.tion, on ~t[ of e t. ~." ation, He/she Ll is personally known to
me or {XI has produced a driver's licen C~i\lemj.ficatio.n., ~~\'I:.. (j
~C~~ :(1.; Q~
-)p~ -,
[Notary Seal] , filE Cl 'l;U)ilic ,
~-::'-'-:'~Name: \J.,Jen~A,~
My Commission Expires: -Jv I., \ (; 2.eJ().f
Witq6ss Name:
,
c::..
VALERIE A, DREW
Notary Public, Slate of New York
No. 01 DR5027469
Qualified in Nassau County 02tx:>6
Commission Expires July 18.
Wa1'ranty rMtd. Pa~e 2
DoubleTrme-
;3 ,~
~anltE fEnllinc.erinu
ProfessIonal Engineers, Planners & Land Surveyors
2515 Northbrooke Plaza Drive - Suite 200
Naples, Florida 34119
(239) 597-206 I
Fax (239) 597-3082
Engineering License No, EB 6469
Survc)'ing Liccnsc No, LB 6690
LEGAL DESCRIFTIOI~:
l, Pt,;~C~1. OH TR/ICT OF LMID $ITlJATEO IN THE SlATE or flCHIDA, COUNTY OF CCI.I.lER, LYI',H; IN SEc.TION 22, TOV.NSH~fl 50 SOLrH,
RANCE 7.G [AST M'lD 8Eff\:G rURIHm DESCRIBED /'.5 FOU..O\'lS:
COt..llvlrt~CII'-lG A"f THe t--:OH1HEAsr CORN[!~ or Sf,ID Sl<.:lION 22: THENCE ~;.Bfl'O:r~I\"W, AI.ONe THE NO;:m'l LINE or SA!O SCCTlO,\j -12 rcr~
1?~i.~7 FH':T TO THI: w::ST RIGj'lT-O,:'-WIIY LINt: cr COU,"!fY [WAO 9~)1; T.,f.NCE S,Ol'Oo'Og"W AlONG SAID wEST u.w rOR 5U.07 FCE! 10
THE ~;OUTH 1?IGH'y..or,-wl\\ LlI'lE or CO'JNTY r<(lAO 8li<1 {R/dTL[SN'~I{E H^MMD~K ROAD-loa FE~T 'tiIDF) ANf) TO THf. 1)(Jlh'l 01 Ut.c;it'IN:r\lG;
TH[HCE ~;,8DTIJ",4"W. ALOHG SAID SOUTH RIGHT-.OF-WAY liNE rOl{ Y<\S.2' f[U TO TtiE (t,::n L1f'It. cr THE weST 400 n.r:1 Or 11";[
No,nl'll:ASI QUMnl]'~ (/'J:::: 1/';) or I'Hl I-iORTHWEST CUM\H~P (Ny.' )/4) OF :,/dD S[(;TIOhJ 22; 1t'll'\icE S.OJ":U'jJ"\N. {,LONG SJ,ID ::"".3T LINE
"-or, 1:2S0,G,1 rUT TO TH[ :;oun, L1NC or THe NorU11 H/,U' (,'.; 1/2) 'Or' lHE NORTH HALF (N 1/2) OF SAID SECTlD.\l n !\I'm TO 'fHr~
~18PTI-1 Ui"~[ 0,::- IJ:i.Y R[SORT ~H/\SL TWO, 1\ SUBDIVISIC"': RCCORDfC,) IN PI A'i noo" 18 ,,1 H\GL~~ ,UI,tlWUGH <1~t 0;- TH~: CDI.liER COUNT",
rI.DI~J(lil, F'UI3L1C !<[COHUS: n'-I[I~cr ,\.eB'll'lY'[, i\LDr~G l.~~r rWI\TH Ltl~t: 0'" ;;A!fJ SU(lDIV1SI0\'1 ANU n.j[ SOliT~1 ~.II';[ or 5/110 rr\l\CTION
l'{m .~1t.\G.07 FE, '):) THL A"O:;.~:~-)AI[' W[SI f~I(;H'I'.'OI'-Wi"Y '~II<L 01' CO'.J~~TY IWAO O~)I; Tlin~cc rJ,Ol'oG'()9'T. /\LNW S/,Il) 1<1(;111" 01 1'1/','(
U.-,Jf: FOR I ~:SS.Y:. I"I:Tl T:') THr. 1'0:,,11 0;: B(:GINt-JtI~(;
PM-;'CU, CQQTldNS 9D,81 A:::::RES ~.\OF't:: OR LESS
PUOEX: 2007~AR 12177
SIERRA MICADOWS I'(lD
ProJect: J l)~t90059
Date: 9/20/07
ru;v~ 2
0(1[;; IOWIJ7
S :\fohs\ I <l xx\] 4 ]7\1 )nCUl11CIlI:.;V.llllilll.'.\Pl )] )F.'(tcl1 ,;0117.007\ 14:~ 7 _I .cgal D~scril't iOIl.doe
Ji.Jn 15 2DOi 11:iJl
[11
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
ADDRESSING DEPARTMENT
(i)
2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104.
".~1I~!=_~_<m.
Plealle complete tne following and f... to the Addres.I09 Department at 239.659-5724 or submn In person to the
Addressing Deperlmant at tno abaY& add",..,
Form must be signed by Addressing pe",onnel prior to pre-application maellnc. Not all nems wiI opplV to eveI}' project.
Itams In bold type are required, Forms 0100' than 6 monl"" will ",quire addllional "'view and approval by lh. Add",sslng
Department.
PETITION TYPE (ch9C/< petition /ype below, complete 8 ""pam'e Addressing Cheoklisl for 00011 Pelilion 7)1pe)
8 8t. (8lasling P91T1lrt)
BD (80al Dock Ext<;nsion)
o Gamw.VQ~sP~rt
o CU (Conditional Use)
o EY.P (&.cavalion Perm II)
o FP (Flnal Plat
R LLA (La:: Line Adjustment)
L.J PNC (Proje:-t Name Change>)
o PPL (Plans & Piat ReView)
o PSo (Prsliminary SubdlvlBron Pi.t)
o PUD Rezone
o RZ (Standard Rezone)
o sop (3rte Development Plan)
o SDPA (SOP Amendmont)
o SOPI (In.ubstantJaI Change to SDP)
o SIP (Site Improvement Plan)
o SIPI (InsubgtanlIaI Change to SIP)
8 S",R (51",.! Name Chenpe)
SNC (Stroat Name ChSrl;J6 - Urlp~atted)
; IDR (Tr.enstftr o~ DP.lveloplT)Gi'tt Righti:)
o VA (Vanan",,)
o VRP [Veg"''''''or. Ramova' Permit)
o VRSFP ~"ila(atlon Ramoval Ii. 9lte Fill ~alT1lll)
[2] OTHER UD ~nSiQn I ~ PUD-:J:;j
LEGAL DESCRIPTION of SUbject propeny or properties (oopy of lengthy de6Crlption may be attached)
Sierra Meadows ~ot:3 ", ,J VI !l,G1 fc"t <.if N >:75,39 Ie.;! Ilf Lot ~ ) Lo!5 1- 9 ~ T~ A - H r ~ ~ L
c:.."L. - >0 - z.., c....
FOLIo (Proporty 10) /'IUMBER(.) of abov.. (att.ch 10, or 8SSOCJaJe WI'Ih, legs' descnption If more f/len one)
73620100566
STREET ADDRESS e, ADDRESSES (eG appliClibfo, if .I",ady '$.i~d)
8414 Coyote Drive
. J"OCA TION MAF" mu>1 b. ~ttached shewing ex.ctlecolion of pruJecVsde in ,.,lalion 10 n.~resl pUblic road right,of-way
. SURVEY (copy - """de<! anry for unplatted properu..&)
PROPOSED PROJECT NAME (1Iepplieeble)
Sierra Meadows
PROPOSED STREET NAMES (ilapp/ioBb/a)
SITE DEVELOPMENT PLAN NUMBER (fat eXi~ng projecr.;.iles only)
SDP arAR 1/
Pege' 0/2
Jun 15 ,007 11;42
P.
...., , ~ ',; '-'
F,:;:,"
..::.~" ,
2~! :yr
AODRE.SSING CHECKLIST - PAGE 1WO
ProJect or development name!; proposed' tor I or already appearing in. condominium documents (if o.pplicatlol'l: indicate
whelher proposed or exiGling)
Please Check One:
o Check'i~t IS to be FQXed beck
o Personolly Picked Up
^""UCANT NAME: Richard Yovanovlch, Esq.
PHONE: 239--435-3535
FAX: 239--435-1218
SiQnature on Addressing Checklist does not conslituw Project and/or Street Name approval and is
subject to further revi'.!w by the Addressing Department
FOR STAFF USE ONLY
Primary Number
\..OD4'2..
3.~4 \ qq
?>~"''Z..l~
::.SO'<-l'+-
3> 1......'1" I
3.~c..Z-\1
"3.'\'>c..'l"l'"
"3-~t,,"l-,9
...,.."'~~ "l.
3""-'Z...'t>'>
3'bt...~ ~ \t
:,"il,--z..,& ,;
~...<-t-<:.c't-
3.~'+"L06
>4-4-<.-DI
Addrsgs Number '34- ~"Z--O I '>4.-4- ~ 0 "l
:.l.oo'Z-30 ~~9,a
3<+'+ -z... <:> 3. :l.'l (.. -z., ")
ApproVed by: \) l". V\', " \V\..tSf...o...VY')
Address Numher
Addre~Q Number :;. L;-<.\.- "Z-DD
Date:
<:0- lq-Di
Updated by:
D.te:
IF OLDER THAN 6 MONTHS, FORM MUST ElE
UPDATED OR NEW FORNI SUBMITTED
Peg" 2 of 2
G.\CL1rrel1t\Ar;lpli~Oon Fomt&\Ad.d~"rng ChecklfSl rn... 020207.doc:
1:. TRANSPORTATION
K CONSULTANTS, INC.
i3i1g PLAt<TATIOY.nU}i\~S,hH:.
FORI ~\'IYFRS. :=: :;3ll1?4JJS
JF::ICF 2:m 2iS J09D
FAX 13\).278 190'}
TRAr~ Ie ENGINEE?II\'G
TRANSPORTATION PLANNING
:;IGNAL SYSTEMS/DESIGN
1
I
I
I
j
1I1EMORANDUM
TO:
Mr. ])av,,] Underhill, P.E.
Banks rngineering, Inc.
['ROM:
David L. Wbeeler
TranspOitatioll Consultant
'ied B. Treesh
Pl'esid~nt
fJ AT:H~:
.'\ugu::;t!,2007
RE:
Sierra Meadows PUD Extellsion
CoDicr COllnty) l:'jorida
TR Transpurtatiun Consultants, Inc. bas curnplctcd an analysis lor the extension of the.
existing Sierra Mc"dows PUD in order to determine if the Sierra Ivleadows development
is Consistent with Section 5.1 of the Collier County Growth Management Plan. The
subject site is located in the southwest comer of Collier Boulevard (c:.R. 951) and
Rattlesnake Hammock Road in Collier County, Florida. The subject sile as eurrelltly
zoned could be developed with up to appro)oll11ately 300 multi-j~1mily dwelling units and
up to appro)Oimalely 260.000 s'iu"rc feet of commercial us~s. To date all of the approved
re.sldential uses have been constructed and none of the approved cammerclal uses have
been constructed. Therefore, this PUD extension would only apply to the commercial
portion of tile existing Sierra Meadows PUD.
Access to the overall PUD IS provided via two "ccess drives to Rattlesnake Hammock
Road, two access drives to Collier Buulevard (C.R. 951), and one site access dnve to
Lely Cultural Parkway. The western site access on Rattlesnake Hammock Road will
provide full access to the site and the. eastern site access on Rattlesnake Hammock Road
will provide rightMin/l'ight-out only acc.ess to the subject site. The northern site access on
Collier Boulevard WIll provide northbound clireelJonal left-in and right-in/nght-out access
to tbc subject site and the southern site access on Collier Boulevard \vill provide right-
inlright-out only access to the suhJect site. The sIte access Ol] Lely Cultural Parkway will
provide full "ceess to the oubjcct site.
..e!. ~
~ --, "~~'.-'
,.::',J'_;
1: TRANSPORTATION
K CONSULTANTS, INC.
Mr. David Underhill. PE
Banks Enr,inecring, Inc.
August 7. 2007
Page 2
The overall Sierra Meadows PUD is currently approved for the construction of up to
approximately 300 multi. family dwelling uruts and up to approximately 260,000 square
feet of commercial uses. As the residential portion of the PUD has already been
constructed, the trip generation of the residential portion of the Sierra Meadows PUD was
not considered. None of the commercial uses on the subject site have been developed to
date. Tahle 1 indicates the trip generation of the commercial uses that have yet to he
developed within the Sierra Meadows PUD,
Table 1
Land V se
Sierra Meadows PUD
.. . '-j
Lllnd Use -T .' Size
Remaining Com111erc1[\1 Uses '. ~"O CICiO' '" .c'.'t..1
(LUC 820) . ~", sCIuate JCC
The trip gen(jratioll was calculated hased on the informat.ion contained \.vitbin t11(; lnsiitutc
ofTmnsporration Engincc/s (ITE) report. titk,J Trip Genel'lltio/!, 7tb Fdition. Land Use
Cod::; 820 (Shopping Center) \va~ utilized for the trip generaliun purposes of the
e0111lnelcial uses wllhlll the SierrL lVIeadows PUD, The equations tClr tlus Land Use Code
are attached to the end of Ihis document TtJr rc!'ercnec, Table 2 indicates the trip
generation of the remaining commc.rcial uses \vltbin lhe overall SiC1T8 f'vieadows PUD,
.....------..-.~_.."._.- ....--.
Status Weel,dav A.M. Peal, Hour Weekday P.M. Peak Hour Daily
I In I Out I Total In I Out I Tutlll (2-way)
: Shopping Center J 170 I 110 J 280 l~J 6\0 r 1,175 12,640
(260.000 ~ll~l~l'e feep..._=_ ."'"
Table 2
Trip Generation
Sierra Meadows PUD
However, not all of the trips shown in Table 2 will utilize the public roadway system.
Some of' the trips will travel to/from the land uses located within the overall Sierra
Meadows PUD, Therefore, an internal capture rale of nine percent (9%) was calculated
for this development by utilizing the methodulogies presented in the ITE Trip Generation
Handbook March 200], which calculates the internal capture rates of multi-use
developments. The summary sheet utilized to calculate this internal capture rate is
lllclncled in the Appendix of' this report for reference, Tahle 3 indicates the numher of
trips added to the public roadway network by the commercial portion of tbe Sierra
Meadows put),
c
~ ::
1: TRANSPORTATION
K COr~5ULTANT5, INC
Ivlr. David Lnderhill, 1'1::
Rank.';; Enginecring\ Inc.
Augusl 7, 2007
Page 1
Tllble 3
Total Trips to the Public ROlldwllY Network
Sierra Meadows PUD
Total Trips
Less 9'% Internal Capture
Tutll] Trips J
fUtil!zl.lU! the PubliC' R~:Hlw:l:'J~J(!~\'1"'(l_t:.!sl
"--- ...-.....--
155
]00
I
255
nJ
- I ])llil?l
Weekday P.M. PeaklJour
In Out I Tofa] 2-way
- I
565 610 1,175 12.640
- I
-50 -55 -105 -1.140
515 J 555 I 1,070 11,500
--
.'C..
Land Use
.- . -
Weekdll\,Xi\1, PeakH(Jrii' ...
In lOll! Total
170 110 280
1----
-15 -1 (J -25
The tl'lpS shown in Table 3 willnol all be new trip' 10 the' adjacent roadway system. ITE
estimates that a shopping eenler of comparable size may allract anywhere from 1 (I to 90
percent of it~ traffic from vehicles already traveling the- adjoining roadway :-:ystem. This
traffic, called "pass-by" traffic, reduces the Jevclopl1lenfs ovenlll impact on tl10
SLlJTOUllCimg rU,l(hvay ,~Y31 :',H: hut do::.: 5 not deGrease the. act~ml driveway vohnl1cs,
/\ccorJing to nH..~ ITE :"CiJOt't iitlcd ii'ir C;cne,"niion IJcndix)o/:, lv!ar;:;h 1001, for Land Use
Code ~QO (Shopplng C~!ltcrl the: rel:ltio!1ship h~1'vvccn the S~7:;-:' or the development and tbe
percent of pass-b;' t"ip;, is:
Ln (T, '-'. -(J,2() 1 :.n (X) -i 5.U01, \vhcrc
T =A vcr:IF(: p,I~:i.I>~: trip r'erccJ1tage
X=- 000 squ<Il"e (';:ct of grus:.; b:as,iblt:: me,1
Using this formula (he pcrccnt8gc (I r pass-hy trips for theshoppmg center use was
calculated as follows:
Ln (T) = -0.291 I,n (260) + 5.001
T = 30%
However, the maximum pess-by percentage allowed by the Collier County Depm1menl of
Transportation for Land Use Code S20 (Shopping Center) is Iwenly five percent (25%)
dming the A.M. end P.M. peak hours end fifteen percent (15'~/o) for the daily pass-by
reduction. Therefore, the Collier Counly maximum oftwenly five percent (25%) paso-hy
was utilized for the AM. end P.M. peak hours and the Collier County maximum of
iifleen percenl (l5%) was utilized ['or the daily trip generation.
For Ihis analysis, the "pass-by" traffic was accounted for 10 determine Ihe number of
"new" trips the development will add 10 tbe surrounding roadways. Table 4 summarizes
the pass-by percentages utilized for each time period. Table 5 summarizes Ihe
development traffic and the breakdown between Ihe new trips the development is
anticipaled (0 generate ancl the "pass-by" trips the developmenl is antiCIpated to allract.
It should he noted tbat the driveway volumes arc not reduced as a result of the "pass-by"
reduction, only the traffic: added to the slllTounding slreets and intersections.
'.1"
'\',) -'
-',;, " ~i~
-...,. ',j ;1';:>
1: TRANSPORTATION
K CONSULTANTS, INC.
Mr. David UnderhilL PE
Banks Engineering, Inc.
August 7, 2007
Page 4
TlIhle 4
Pass-by Trip Reduction Factol's
Sicna Meadows pUD
" -- ---.-...-...---
Time Period PereeittageTl'ip II
Reductiun
A.M. Peak Hour 25%
P.M. Peak Hour 25%
II Daily (2-way) 15% ~~-...,....
Tahlc 5
Trip Gcncration .. New Trips
Sierra Meadows pUD
I' Land Use IWeckdlll' A.M. Peak Hour
rI;~ru Total
,
I Total Trips-l. 155 I 100 I
f__UJtilj;,.ill~til(;' j;'ublic: Roadwnv Nctwlil-k) .
I Less Retail Pas:;-,,\, I -40 I .25 I
~ (Utai,j"~lh, ~~~:t~<I~~~~V") N",,'''jIL_.::~1 i5 I
W~ekda.'.' P.M. Pellk I:Io~.iJ DlIilY.]'
1n-'1" Out I T otlll I (2,wll~')
i 5]5J 555l 1,(170 II1,soo
r-130 I -!40' -2701 -1.725
I 385 415 8(1;)J.~9,i75
255
-65
1<)0
The. neVi trips shown in Table 5 V./CIT then assigned to the surrounding roadway system
based upon [be approved prolcel traffic. distribution for the Stcrm Meadows 1'1.11). A
copy of the proJect trame distribution is attached to the end of this documcnt for
reference. Table I A attached 10 tbe end of this document indicates which roadway links
will be significantly impacted based upon the Coliier County 1%-3%-5% Significance
Test The existing capacity and remaining capacity for each roadway segment analyzed
was obtained from the Collier County 2006 Annual Inventory Update Report (AUlR).
In addition to the significant impact criLeria, Table 1 A also includes a build-out
Consistency analysis on all roadway links anticipated to be significantly impacted on the
Collier County roadway network. For the purposes of this analysis it was assumed that
the Sierru Meadows peD would be completed by 20] 2, tllCreforc, the Collier County
roadway network was analyzed under the projected 2011 build-out traffic conditions.
The growth rates utilizeJ to project the 2011 background traffic conditions were
calculated based on historical tramc count data obtained 1;'om the 2006 Collicr County
Average Daily Trafflc Report.
Based upon the results of the Consistency unalysls, all roadway segments anticipated to
be significantly impacted as a result of the proposed Sierra Meadows PUD are shown to
have sufficient capacity to accommodate [he additional trips anticipated to bc gencrated
by the proposed development. Therefore, the proposed extension of the existing Sierra
Meadows PlID is Consistent with Section 5.1 of the Collier County Growth Management
Plan.
"
oc-
r" ::1
-7<S~
;::
Q S'
;::
". ,.,
:: ?
~,=
~
(f)
>-
..J
<(
Z
<(
>-
o
z
W
a::
a::
z::!
o~
o
u u
W
~ ~,
Q<(
<.: ;;;
~~m
W<(f-
i6~1t'
<( .0
f-a::f-
::Jo
0<(
:Co..
><::!;
<(-
Wf-
o..Z
<(
o
u::
Z
S2
(f)
,0
0'
'"
.
""
o
M
.
""
o
M
I~
o
o
~
1
,
"
>
@
" ,
o 0
s: u:
,{ ->:
g: g:
1- f-
U U
w w
~ ~
. ^
" <<
o 0
o 0
:r: "I:
yo y
o ~
~
~ &-
:t -zt
2 B
"'
"
N
,n
"
"
o
"
~
"
"
~
;1:
"
>
o
:i;
'_ t
3 ~
~ "
\!1 ;}
"
7-
,-
~
;>.'
W
"
~
u
~
~
v
ffi ~I
~ ~I
"'
~
o
7-
'"
!i!
o
~
ID
HI
"
~
N
"
5
~
^
n[
2 ~
~ 0
~
~
.-
z
w
'"
~
u
HI
'0
o
o
N
"
0;
"
"
o
V
~ '~I
z u' ,~,
~ g;1 :~'
:i! ;51
,,'
~
ii>
5
'i
>
.
0',
w
0'
w
,
n 0
{jj
'"
~3
~
~I
~
o
"'
"
~
.
8 ~ ~ ~
N' ,"
.'
"'
,.
N
a m
N N
,"
,"
"
~
~ <
~ ~- ~ ~
N
ro
h
'"
~
o.
~ ~
~
b
o
[f, ~ ili
M ,.;
12 ~~ ~: ~_
1-. 0':> ~, .
,"
"
n
0'
"
,"
"'
0'
0,
"'
N
c
"
"
m
o
~I' "G: t]" ~ ,: C
;.: " .,. III w 'I- 'P
:iii
"
o
~
o
"
"
u
"
~~
0,
~
w
u
"
w
^
o
"
a
"
^
"
o
~
HI~
h
Z
~ QI '" ;J, ~
w
"
~I '"
.-...:
e,
~
:ii ~,
~t
;1
:; ~
,.
"
"
'0
"
~ ~ ~
~ ..,- ""
h
~
~1
<
"
"
-,
"
~
I
"
>
.
~i ~
II ~
~
"
E
fi
-.
~l ~
~i ~
01
i?l {;
"'
w
~ ;r::
"
~.,
;,;
~> or'
"'
"
N
~ g
"
"
"'
"
~
{';
g~.~.r~
fry I"
9
"'
s g
'0 "
" 0
~ ./
~~~~~
','
o
X
G
~
I
~
;;
"
E
"
"
,
"
~ ~
. ~
~ ~
"" 15 8
'8 <;> ""
II. U '.)
(, '5 '0
?
,
il'l
,.
'6
.~
-.
,
;;
"
,
~
>
3=
c
'"
u
"
C
E
ro
I
.~
*
0;
"
'I)
",
,
o
"
J;
,.
"
"
0'
Co
*-
n
"
"
;::
u
"
g
.
~
r
"
ro
~
.
'"
;;
Z
"
"
r.
D
>
C
"
"
U
o
.
;}~
':'
-,
is
g
11 ~
r'; '"
~
'0
,;
"
u
g
E
,
r
','
~
To
"
,
>
:;
m
o
c
m
"'
o
~.
~
"
,
m "
:::
~
,
f
~
~
"
,
,
"
o
,
~L 3
~
~
~ ~
<', g
Ii
,
o
.
.
,
i
Q
~
! ~
{ 'f
, '
~ e
o ~
to
j
9
"
,"
.
.
"
.
m
"
~
,
~
J
b
,
"
,
~
Ii
e
<
'0
:;
if;
o
"
~
z
o
"
m
..
,
"
C
o
"
"
~,,~
ANNUAL GROWTH RATE CALCULATIONS
2006 ANNUAL
BASE YR TRAFFIC YRS OF GROWTH
ROADWAY SEGMENT TRAFFIC VOLUME GROWTH RATE'
Collier Blvd N_ of Ralllesnal<8 Hammock Rd 38,709 39,767 2.73%
S of Rattlesnake Hammock Rd. 34,013 34,168 100%
Rattlesnake J-iammock Rd W of Collier Blvd 9,087 10,091 3 3,56%
W of Polly Ave 15,717 15,'1-78 4 1.00%
'.^.I of c.ounty 82.rd Rd 14.078 16,275 4 3.69%
'l\l. of Ch~Hlemag/l~ Blvd 15,682 19,139 4 5.'i1%
I ^ minimunli .00'% growlh rate Vias uSl;'Jmed for all roadwoy ~cgmonl~ ClIKllvzod
;' AlllrnHic volumes were tClken 1rom the 20(;(-;, Colliflr COllnt}' A'.'erngn Daily Tmffic Rupor\
} TI16 annu<:ll groWlh Hlte~ alo,'lg Collier 80uievara were UlIlmll\inmJ ba~ud on one ye<:w: worth of
1'.iswric,,1 data duc~ to recent CO/"ls,lr\Jc1ion in the vicini!\, oll",e site
SAMPLE GROWTH RATE CALCULATION
Annllal Growth Rate (AGR) .
2006 AD T
Base Year ADT
t'(llYrs of Growth)
-1
AGR (Collier Blvd) .
39,767
38,709
'(1/1)
-1
AGI'< (Collier Blvd) =
2.73%
l_
-
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
,
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
0 01
'" "'I
'- (~ I
Z Zl
;;: << ::11
IY --'I
,,; ~ ii:1
I
=> I- ,l
w
--' '"
0 '"
0 il.
C' '"
(') '"
GOLDEN GAIT P\<WY.
R/IIl:(\ IIll
un 18
i'INE RiDGE Re.
"'
"-
l
D
>
--'
ill
<(
IY
<<
a;
'"
<(
m
<<
~
:;;
"
GREEN BLVD.
-,.---'..
"
w+,
:n
m
Ii
o
~~,
','
I
:~
I
DAVIS OL\'D,
I I
: .o!
~-:~
I
I
<0-%
'-..~
LEGEND
PROJECT TRAFFIC DISTRIBUTION
BY PERCENTAGE
Two Lane RD.way
~~ur Lane Divided RD.woy
~I)( Lane DiVided RO,way
0
'"
Z
IY
<(
.,t OJ
0'
U) ~
:3
0
C)
30%
--
45%
--
RATTLES~AKE. 11AMMOCK RD.
Us:
'1
.----
/
/
/
~
.ot
0'
U)
<0
~sj TC0
/.LL"
,ot
U'
o
N
PROJECT TRAFFIC DISTRIBUTION
SIERRA Ivl:::ADOWS
990113
JULY 99
FIGURE 2A
""', 1", :::~.'
~'~, ~:'
, - ---
~: ::.'
, .~:!
li~
.::;;' Q)
;::;. ;>
~):f
..
~
00
"
!
if,
c
.~
"
.,
u
1i
u
.
';
C.
ro
U
;;;
c
Iii
:5
-~ "-- ,<'
~~;;;;:-~~
w
~
l' _
~ g I',
- ,', "I
~I
~
<: - If' ~'"
41 [\' U1 0 ,- C
~ ~:Ii m;:-;::,
~
c
<
~
..... cc ~'"
."-';'u,
$'';=i ~ '{,'"
tit III ~_
i~, il ~ ~l
~(O lOW
o E
:.: g
IB ~
w
o-
N
o
c
"
E
i11'~
-0 In
Q' i
U ,
~ C
N~ ~
"''E jj
'W6
fir :1
;/MM
~ c
M ro
.
ro
i-2
g
ro
c
"
_,,0
?-!
::
~~
~
g
.
Q
n
"
u
om
"
"'
~
\~\ 1
\r
~ :\:~
. .~~
i18 ~\~\
III '\
10 g
~
I ~ ~
I
,
L
n
c
-~
00
O'
;:;
"
o
"
~ ~'~
~~'> t' (~\ :Bi
... l'l ,I ~
~. I c:
;B w
~ OJ (') ~ ~
to) W l'l v' IV
IDJj
.
~
! TiI r- C();f.:
;. ~ MN >;1 ~
"tl C
'Vi -
.
~
, - <:'1 ~
0!'18~~8
~ ~ ~ ~
::>
"
.
...J .~~ ~"i;'"
J)Wi-
u
~H1
~~J,I
''1'1
'::'>Ir"
"m
~ 010
.n
00:
n
c
ro
E
~ ?f'?- <;~
ON
il
c;j ;,,0,
~ooo8
~ ~
W
*
='~ ;,'!
,~ 20oo~
5~
~~ 3'-
$~ooo8
~,.. ~
~
o
ro
~
~''';:i 19;;,~
ill UI ~
"DD /\ DJ'
E 1'1 Ii>
110 Ii r 0 jj
~ ;' tJ E
::: ,g
JJ ~
c
W
o
;;
'"
o
;;
io
~U
0) In
~:;8~~
i-W""t"'",..-
U
~O'H")l'l g
'U U> l'l ", ~
3
~
E
~
0",
~ ~
Q);::)oooa
Ou
. r.
o ro
~ .j
..
~
J;
1["
'C 'l' 1'-- L0
i-~?,i;~:::::,
'2 ~ <.rlIO...-:,--"
lij
"
w
~
z
~
w
r:
u
"
~ .'= 'lii ,g
.... >< 0 i-
In WI- %
~
"'
.",
c
in
TRIP GENERA nON EQUATIONS
SIERRA MEADOWS PUD EXTENSION
ITE TRIP GENERATION REPORT, 7th EDITION
r-=- Land Use Weekday AM Peak Hour WcekdR)' PM-'~'~-~-~~~m Weekday
,
II,~ Re,,,dcnIIaI [1,,'] 11') = 0,80 Ln(;.:l' 0,26~ IT) 0, O,!2 Ln (XI + 0,32 I
(;olldomil1ium/Townhou:-;~ ] I Ln (T)::.c 0.85 l~1l (X)! 2.55
i..._____JI ,~~C 210) 17D/j, (:JlLeflng ~n'j;, tx.iling (~7r~i~_entCl'j~_g t. ~3<:-;1 exiting. __~______
I T Trirs, X co, Numlx:r of dwcliiug llnit" _._ __._.._ .____ .__~ ~------ _______.----'
, Shoppil"lg Center I Ln (T) = G.on LH (Xl .,- ~.:,~9__'I__J'li, ,'Tl CU;C.Lll (X,) -i 3, Au I 1, "~I') 0' II
I (' II . 0'0 l" - I -, - - I ' ,ll \ - '()5 1.11 (X:...j 5.R3 :,'
1,_,_ _~ ,__ ,~,__) () 1 '~" CtltcmlJ~ i 39'>rJ ~i~~~.~~g _4.s'\. e:~11[~1t1)Q. I .\~r;." cx:tinr:
,!~~.l~il~~__=__.?~ 1,OOO-sofsG It. (:;Ll,. __ -----.-:-=--~]!
"
:7;
- "
~'1: i?,'
-~
~\~
<
!!l
<II
>-
...J
<:
z
<:
>-
o
z
w
a::
a::
~::>
o~
.-0
uu
~oI:
-<:
<(0_
,!,"""vo.:::
w:;:~
11i~ii:'
<( .()
1--0::1--
::>()
0<:
:ell.
~2
<:-
wI--
Il.Z
<:
()
u:
Z
CJ
Vi
';!!.
'<i
';!!.
M
,
';!!.
M
;'?
"
,
e,
'-'
'0
"
,
I
~
~
II It
{) 0
[ it
< .,
'" ~
~ ~
~ ~
V "
w w
{3 3
'" ~
" "
'" '"
~ ~
o 0
I I
~ ~
" "
0;;: ...
~ il:
~, -I
S ~
~
o
"
"
"
,-
~
o
~
~
"
,
I
O.
>
<:
~
"
"
J
~
~
~
U
<
"
.,
U
ill
z
Z
"
>
W
'"
~
U
~
u
"I
'" U
~ ~
"
~
o
z
"
ill
,
u
.,
~
G
Z
Z
"
~
W
'"
M
;
N
"
5
,
"
"
<
~
Z
Z
<
.
o
o
N
~
ffi
"
"
~
U
"
B
,
"
&
!;
W
r..~
"
o
u
~ ',-' I
~ .- ~,
~ ~I r
ri
"
"
s ~I "G:: '"
~ ,.., ..f f'J
~I
~
U
w
a
"
"
tf ~I ~
"
<
e: ~I ~
~
z
w
U
"
W
"
~
~ "I ~
[ ~
'6
"
2 ~ ~ ~
.J Z ri M"
~
~
~ ~I ~
~
z
~ 91 ~
w
~
'.'1
~I
~~
"
II
II
~I
2
ill
II
~I ~
> 0
~ 'i5
~ ",
II ~
" ~
m
w
>
M
W
ro
"
N
"
~
M
~~
r~
N
~
N
fi
w
~
o
.,
,
~{
9
w
~
"
2
ro
u
'"
"
"
o
E
o
.
I
.
.
ro
"
~
i'
~
z
'0
'!'
w
'!;
~
w
,-
N
"
~j
o.
?:
"
M
,-
m "
~ u.;
:J) U)
w w
)- ';--
% (I, Ll) N
~ ~! ~ ~
~ ~. 0, w
N g:
.
00
.
~
~ l.
,
:Ii
M
,-
8, 'ill
'" w
"
Ie
~ ~
.
w
C-
M
".
~. ~ ~
. -
1,(; ([;
t,; ~~
l{) ~,
C'
"
w W
N N
~
.-
;;-~
c,
"
'0
'"
o
--'
w
~
u
"
g
o
~
I
.
~
B
.
'"
<;
m
,-. t-
Oo ro
,.
"
o
,',
.
"
o
o
'g
g
~ ~ ~ ~.
("i N
~ ~ ~ ~
:!.!
"
,-
r2 ~
u
ii
~
"
u
u
-0 ffi
'" ro
E a.
ro ro
'" E
f -~
u u
~
<
,
"
'0 '3 '0 15
:::: ?i ~ ?
"
~
j\
~
E
ro
I
~
t
,
'"
~
",
(',
"
g
c.
w
"
N
W
~~
G
w,
9
"
~
~
g
E
E
ro
I
.
ro
.
"
E
~
~
i
"
"
o
~
.~
g
u
ft'
",
W
N
ro,
C.
g
8 ,'jJ
N 0,
M ...,i
" "
<P ta
<-
"
"
"
"
o
E
E
o
I
]
o
~
"
<;
~
"
,~
-'
"'
C'
"'
,
.,
<"
~
~
o
"
.?
,
"
~
;;
.
~
0'
0'
",
'.'
"
,.
1;
,.
<
c
"
"'
w
.
~
.f
~
"
;;.
"
.
.
!t
o
M
N
'"
:;;
!
o
"~
8
.-,
~,
"
~
o.
N
,
~
.
-E
~
11
.
]
"
~
,
9
~
,
~
~
"
,
~
e
"
~
~
,
rD
o
:;
w
o
.
~
~
~
.~
,
J
}:
!
,
o
"
g'
B
~
e
8-
;;
N
:.::
"'
'"
<--
c
;;0
2>
..;;
:0
'"
co
r--;:J
"''''
;::;'"
-;..
0:00-.
<e;Vl
,-'-- ~ g
g\.lJO\r--
N:;~S;:
..-....0
~ ~ .. ~
..J=::::to-.
9 t3.*, E
;.J_l..(!:j
~cnQ..Q
-
SIERR4. MEADOWS PUD
Protected Species Survey
PUDEX : 20117-AR 12177 REV:
SlERRA MEADOWS PUD
Project: 19990059
O"lc: 8/16/117 DUE: 8/30/117
Boylan 7/"
Environmb~0
Consultants, ,~lC.
We(lalld &: Wildlife Strn.t?Y~01II11f!/JI{1r f'rrmWJlIg,
Jmj1nc/,i;;!!sslIll!JJ!S
1 TOOO Metro Parkway, Suite 4
Fort Myers, Florid._ 33966
Phone: (239) 418-0671 Fax: (239) 4] 8-0672
August 9, 2007
i'<u. =.,
",,;::. -'
>~,-'~) ;:',:,
INTRODUCTION
Two environmental scientists from Boylan Environmental Consultants, Inc conducted a field
investigation on the Sierra Meadows PUD 90.80 acre property over the course of several days.
See table below that shows the time, conditions and areas surveyed.
The purpose of the field investigations were to identify the presence of protected species, and
species habitat. These surveys are listed in the table providcd below.
The site is located in portions of Section 22, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, in Collier
Count)', Florida. Specifically, it is located some distance south of Rattlesnake Hammock and
west of CR 951. This property lies within the permitted portions of the Sierra Meadows property
SFWMD permit number 36-00678-1'.
Date Time Weather Area Surveyed and Survey
--_.~~ Conditions !Yfle.
March 13.2006 1 :00 p.m. to 3:00 p.m. Partly cloudy- Carillon Parke SDP-AR-8924-
4 man hours upper 70's Standard protected species
I Cloudy survey.
I February 13, 2007 9:30 a.m. to 12:00 p.m. Carillon Parke SDP-AR-8924-
I 5 man hours ! - UDDer 70's Tree-to-tr~~_.~_l:J.rY.~Y_ .. ".-------
June 29. 2007 : 9:30 a.m. to 12:3(; p.m. : Partiy cioudy . Three outparcels
I 6 man hours i -Lower 80's Standard protected species
I survev
, '--.'
I July 19. ~:O7 0:30 a.m. 10 3:30 p.m. Partly cloudy Westeriy preserve area
6.5 man "ours - mid 80's Standard protected spec;9s
slIrvev
Prior to the PUD approval the project limits were surveyed by Kevln J, Erwin Consulting
Ecologist, Inc. (KLECE). They identified the presence of two potential red-cockaded
woodpecker (Picoides borealis) cavities locnted within slash pine trees which are situated within
the PUD preserve. No red eoekaded woodpeckers were observed 011 the project site, and the
cavities were determined to be inactive. Through formal consultation, the U.S Fish and Wildlife
Service (FWS) determined that the project could negatively impact but would not jcopardize the
continued existence of the red-cockade woodpecker, subsequently permits ti'om SFWMD, permit
number 36-00678-P, and the US Army Corps of Engineers, 199102025, were issued.
Follow-up surveys for red-cockaded woodpecker cavity trees were conducted by Passarella and
Associates, Inc, on May 5 and 6, 1999. They observed the RCW cavities previously identified
by KLECE, however noted that the cavities appearcd cnlarged, with no fresh sap was obscrved
around the cavity, ,md no red-eockadcd woodpecker were observed on the project site.
2
SURVEY METHODOLOGY
The property was surveyed for the presence oflisted species via overlapping helt transects. This
meulOd is comprised of a several step process. First, vegetation corrununitics or land-uscs on the
propcJ1y 01' study area are delineated on an aerial photograph based on nomenclature of the
Florida Land Use, Covel' and Forms Classification System (FLUCFCS). Next, the FLUCFCS
codes 01' land-use types found on the property are cross-referenced with statc and fcdcrally listed
spceies that can be found in Collier County. The list of protected species was derived from
several sources lIl~iUding; the Official List of Endangered and Potentially Endangcred Falma and
Flora in Florida (Florida Natural Areas Inventory FNAl; 1995), Florida's Endangercd
Threatened and Species of Special Concern (Florida Fish and Wildlife Comervation
Commission (2004) and the Endangered and Threatened Species of thc Southeastcrn Unitcd
States (US Fish and Wildlife Service).
i I
Then, each community is scarched in the field for the species which havc the potential to occur
in that pal'[i(;ular FLUCFCS type. /I.n intcnsiw p~dcstriar. survey is conducted using belt
transccts as a means of scarching for plants and animals. In addition, periodic "stop-look-listen"
and quiet stalking mcthods are conducted for animals. Signs or sightings oftbese species are
thenreeorded and marked in the ficld with flagging tape. The tablc u: the end of this report :ists
the FLUCFCS communities found on (he propert)' and the corresponding species that have n
probahiii:y of occmring in :hem. Transects were waILed approximatel)' as shown on the
attached protected species survc)' map.
SITE CONDITIONS
Listed below are the vegetation communities or land-uses identified on the site as shown on thc
a1tacl1ed FLUCCS map. See Florida Land Use, Cover and Forms Classification System
(Departmcnt ofTransportalion 1999) for definitions.
133 Multiple Dwelling Units, Low Rise (approximately 18.57 acres)
This land-use designation describes multi-family buildings.
193 Urban Land in Tl'3nsitioll (approximately 7.73 acres)
This land-use description shows areas that have been previously cleared and filled
as part of permitted activities. This community was generally devoid of
vegetation except for grasses.
411 Pine Flatwoods (approximately 14.17 acres)
This uplund community was dominated by an overstOJ)' of slash pine trees with an
understory of wax m)'11!e, saw palmetto, staggerbush, broom sedge, and
grapevine.
618 Willow and Pop Ash (approximately 0.51 acres)
This area was overwhelmingly dominatcd by Carolina willow and pop ash.
Widely scattcred cypress und melaleuca could also bc found throughout this area.
3
,,'.;'';;1 ,-' .-'
'...,.'; .,",.0-;
619 Melalenca Wetland (approximalely 3.42 acres)
This wetiand eommunity was dominatcd by mclalcuca. The undcrstory, where
pre~en(, contained swamp fem, myrsine, hydrocotyle, and saw grass.
624 Cypt'essfPinefCabbage Palm (approximately 3.77 acres)
Thi~ community was dominated by cypress and slash pine with scattered cabbage
palms. The understory was composed of camphor weed, ru,h furiena, swamp
fern and saw grass,
625 Hydric Pine Flatwoods (approximately 17.66 acres)
This wctland community was dominated by a canopy of slash pine with scattered
cabbage palm. Thc understory was composed of rush furiena and wire grass.
625E2 Hydric Pine Fllltwoods with Melaleuell (approximately 17.58 acres)
This wetland community's canopy contained slash pine, with varying degrees of
mclaleuca. The under-story contained swamp fern hydl'OcotyJe, saw grass,
pluchea rosea. blue maidencane, danoon holly, wa>: myrtle, and myrsine_
641 Freshwater MurslI (approximlltely 0.35 aer'es)
This wetland cOInmunity is donlina1cd by say,' grass, swamp fern, pickerel \veed)
fireflag ami ruaid::ncane. Scattered cypress trees were aiso present.
740 Disturhed Lands (appruximateiy 2.91 ael'cs)
This land-use designation describes previously disturbed lands which are either
composed of sodded bahia grass or weedy herbaceous plants.
814 Roads (approximlltely 4.13 acrcs)
This land-nse designation dcseribes roadways constructed as part of permitted
activities.
Table. FLUCFCS Communities by l'ereentage.
FL.UCCS DESCRIPTION ACRES PERCENT
133 Multlole Dwellino- Units, L.ow Rise 18.57 20.45
193 Urban Lend in Transition -.'..-..-.'.... 7.73
~c.._.._.._ 8.51
411 Pine Flatwoods 14.17 15.61
618 Willow and pan Ash 0.51 0.56
619 Malaleuca Wetland 3.42 3.77
624 CVDress/Pine/Cabbaae Palm 3.77 4.15
625 _i:iY!!ri.."- Pine Flatwoods 17.66 19.45
625 E2 Hvdric Pine Fletwoods (25-49% exotics) 1.L58 ..
19.36
641 Freshwater Marsh 0.35 0.39
740 Disturbed lands 2.91 3.20
814 I Roads ~-_.~ 4.13 4.55
Total I 90.80 100 ..----_...
~~_..
4
SPECIES PRESENCE
During our field survey for protected species on the Sierra Meadow PUD property, we identified
the presence of two stick nests, those lhat resemble ones constructed by squirrels, howcvcr,
neither gray squirrels or Big Cypress fox squirrels were observed on the property.
During the early species work for the properly, two inactive red-eockadcd woodpecker cavities
were located within the preserve in the western p0l1ion of the property. These are located on the
attached protected species survey map. No tOltoise burrows were identified, or other listed
species or evidence thereof were identified.
Based on a review of the latest GIS mapping information for protected species, no eagle nests
were doewnenled to occur close enough to impact thc properly. The nearest documented eaglc
nest was approximately situated OVcr three miles from the pmperty.
DrSCtlSSWN
The lack oftol'to!se burr()\~,rs was likely due to lh~, relatively high water tables in the area and lhe
lack of habitat. Much of the undeveloped out parcels were heavily invaded by exotics including
melaleuca, and Brazilian pepper and were situated near Collier Boulevard and Rattlesnake
Hammock, consequently, these areas do not provioe ideal habitat for protected species. The Big
Cypress fox squincJ has the highest likelihood of occurring on the property, but none were
identified on the property during this field investigation. The Sierra Meadows PUD, has been
permitted by SFWMD, permit number 36-00678-P, and tbe US Army Corps of Engineers,
199102025. Under that permit a large preserve was established in the western portion afthe
PUD. Exotic control efforts have been under way for some time.
5
'l'
Tuble. Protected species list according to FLUCCS category obtained from Collier County with
corresponding field survey results.
FLUCCS Potential Listed Species % Present Absent Density Visibility
Cover"~e (ft)
133 NONE -- -- -- -- 100+
-- -..----..----
193 NONE -- -- .. .. 100+
----.,
411 Beautiful Pa.wpaw 100 X 20
Big Cypress Fox Squirrel 100 X 20
Eas.tern Illdig.o Snake 100 X -
20
Fakahatchcc Burmannia 100 X 20
Florida Blaok Be.r 100 X 20
Florida Coon tie 100 X -- 20
Florida Panther 100 --,-
X 20
Gopher Froo 100 I X __.J___,~~__ 20
-~'-
Gopher T0l1otse 100 X I 20
Red-Cock.ded 100 I~.x I I 20
Woodpecker ,
.-
Salin leaf I J 00 X I 20
Southenstel1l /unericun I ---" !
100 X 20
Kestr-el I
!_---. .-- ---~ - ----- -----i--.c-
Twisted Ail' Plant 100 i I X , I 20
1_ 618 Am~ri.:;cm Alligator 90 I I I -~---,.-
X 20
Everglades Mink 90 I I X I I 20
I f10rlda Black !lear 90 I , ---
X 20
1619 ~_l.i~fori-da-Piint1ler 90 I X .- -. ,.-----
._.~.~- ....---- 20
NONE -- -. -. -- --
(,24 .0~~_e!.~~!n Alligator .--.- ... -...
90 X 20
Everglades Mink 90 X - ------
20
Florida Black Bear 90 X 20___
Florida Panther .U'.._
90 X 20
740 Burrowinrr Owl 95 X 20
(,24 Amcriclln A!ligator 90 X --
20
Everglades Mink 90 X 20
Florida Black Bear 90 X --
20
Florida Panther 90 -----
X 20
Gopher Fro~ _ ".. 90 X 20
-,-----
Little RIoo Heron 90 X 20
Snowy Egret -~------ 90 X 20
Tricolored Heron ~ ----.---
90 X 20
W oud Stork - - 90 X 20
...~.. ..------
G25 Beautiful paweaw 100 X 20
Big Cypress Fox SQuirrel 100 X 20
Eastern Indigo Snake 100 X 20
Pakahatchee Burmanniil 100 X 20
---.-.-. Florid. Black Bear 100 X 20
Florida Coontje 100 X 20
Florida Panther 100 X 20
Gopher Fro. 100 X ..---...-----
20
Gopher Tortoise 100 X -....
--}Q.- .....
6
Red-Cock.clod 100 X 20
Woodpecker
Satin leaf 100 X 2S_
~--, --
Southcl:l.:ltern American 100 X 20
--- Kestrel
Twisted Air Plant 100 ___
X 20
641 American Alligator 90 X 20
Evcr~lades Mink 90 - ---._"
1--- X 20
Florida Sandhill Crane 90 -- -~.-
X 20
Lilltle Blue Heron 90 X 20
Limnki'l". 90 X ---
20
.._ Reddish Egret 90 X 20
Snail Kite 90 X 20
Snowy E~ 90 I X I 20
u --- -
-- Tricolored Heron 90 J X 20
Wood Slork 90 I X 20
BurrO\\'ing Owl - 1 I i
740 95 X 20
1--'--'----- I Gopher Tortoise - 100 I X L 20
-- --
R!4 I NONE I -- I -- I -- I -- 100+
----
7
" llll Ll~ .l~' . jl;;-';:'~--~~-
II~{" q l"',/!'I' ",~'llf,I'J~~-'7~~TI-
, . I {,\ ~, jr,S /1 ',~J.. :,,,~J/I~l.hl:t "If"" ----
, '~~J,/lj"'.).f 1J1u~'
, I'!: '" I: I " 'J ~ jl~h%:Jr.I"ti~~~t~ ~ Ii .
d I~f "<;i ;..., !.:";;!I<:I.~f;l .l",t ~ ~ ; % f:
l ,,1' . ,~i\ h/~' 'J <,>>.;.\lfl''t, ~ It .", a'"
~ll~"":'''''';'''' Ji~~ .nil
, . "'4.I;!~~r~-..r:ill"/~:~h ~ ~ ~ .g ~ c
,_", """ "'~"'4 .'. <,"
.~"""____,_:-_" ,,_ ,__~" ,~, f,~
_ ,.:,",.__;,'oo,-",,;'r/'''' ,,0' i: .' 0
.' .~.;.:L 11 K" ,~~~
b~! ~ sE"
:3 J' n g ~ Jl
ll......!' ttg~
r
.'
en. '
'";::>11>
-g .~'~,fi'
;~tr:~
g~Gg
~~:k
;tZ,
.~q
~!h
~ ~ gl
:. B . a~
U!~ ~ -'f
~ '.. 1
.. !""
g-" Ii 8
.-. ,
H'
0<1"
t.~!
~ a!'
. ,"
<I,s;:::
"
"
ill
0
:J
CL Q.
ill
(fJ 2;
~ (fJ
...
0 u
v u...
ro u
(J) ::)
...J
2 lL
~ .~
ill
.~ <:
(f)
~ (II
U ~ ~
, 0
'"
~~
0"
'"
ill
'"
&
o
!!!
~
t
~;.\ !'\~
I '
l~y-"";; "
f~' ,. ~
N' "1'
CJ Y.:
. ,,-
_ .-,]Jli.1
.:J ~ '" E r.
" .'!l .1-"
. · I:t.:--'
S !l 'i
" ~'
o c '3.H i1
M .!;: III ~ l
~ to r:l '" ~
c' l::u'" ';;
p::j~ ~!
" .
~~
~, .2
;~ ., ':;'~':;'~'~T.:'~:_~~,~'f:~~,~:\.',
'. f~~~~lll.1
"~.~'.r}lo4f-( rt.1J
~':~:~ ,; :"t(. ::1.,:,'1;:.. J:
:;.I'i,;,;' ,,<..; ./;.-.
~.( 'f,::~:,_:'d_f!/. ~;"t.':n'
"- ~"'V~~.' ~J'.' '~"~tl'~~. I~,
'=">""~jf )
=.!.",.::M..-.'y.... "'...... t.'....'
i rftr";L;:"1 ri' ";'.'.
; ~)i:i,\' . ~; b.'
'.,ill f",~_".I.9l ~..ui II
}~'"",,"j,~~,.:,: l';~> ,"
',"{;:',"
'1;~'<~'I:;; ~L<d ,;:.::r:jih,,-:~,:',~; J;~"j ;':~~i _::...
;..~- .,~I.,'. i;.i:;{ rl:.;I....d:_.:,~~,.\ ..-~.:,i~;},.i-~~,~.\~
>'" ~l(.I,:'.{,,:';;!(;},i(:ll?~.!~f~~Jtrl1"_I.
:1 ~,.. ".:\ -."r".,": ..,r-';'::1'f:j~'itil\; '.J,'~'\,
'_ill"'l""" .~".. ",:,-:,;"""'iJi,.,,,nl\.'i;'
l :l {-~}?1~~7i~;~~~?;:~,:;1721~}:
1".itir~;~I,".,. i/'
,;, -"._i~i:."~-"~"'-~"~"-''''-':''''^ .
,,:,..~".;'::.:.-;:::-:.:.-:.!.;,';';,t::.:{Ji..:'
,~
~ ~
1115. .
_o~
E e._
r.~g
'. .
J.l",tl
.s;:g2;
- 0 0
~tJ~
.00
~~~
tt~E:
~ g~'
~~~
~f,~
-g~if
':E~
li. t:>
~i[
""'
g~!::
~8~
---~--~~_r__'1
I ~, ~ !
~ ~ ~ <l n. lb
~E~ :>-'=
or oi:<~ i'i!,~
~" If! I-) P ~
~i~::' t: - l'J
?i,",P.:~ a!~
'QVt::g ('.....
g i1i ~"O ~---'
.2 Ll ~ e - ~ Q
~.cD\" ~4e
~ ~ '" ~ ~"i.g
fr~~"O ~~€
.l:.t::t;;::i <:l'iie:
~
o
'-
.R
I
o
:::>
Q..
Cf)
5:
::)
-;:::
t;l
0)
~
"
ro
~
(f)
(f)
CL
rr;
Ul
<(
t;l
...
'--
Q)
(f)
!!:.l.j
~
~ f? f,
II "5 --l
;..fJ
i'i
Ja
o
.
"
o
.g
'"
V>
n.
,
,
,0" W
~ Jl i ~ I
I r N
i "
~\~'1\~. I
~~ ]fl~
j ... ~,
" .::J.."
~ C' i;'''< "-
a :JHl
g '3 ('~ ~
~ " . ~ 1
- ";= 8'" E
;:.. nu' "
dl~~ ] ~
'- ;.
i'i
"
.'"
'gfl
01 ,iJ ~
= 0:/
~ ~-
jo
~
f--
Z.
'S
.
U
;::
"
<=
~
z
"
o
"
V>
.-iiiijii'f~--.P'"I.r~~-=ij';.?Niiil:~------
._--~,- r-;,--
~
i r & ~
fE ','"
;; ! !~~ If.l!~ul
~~ Iii ].i iti!,~ ;;
-. ~h .H" ~
it IiI .og l&~l
H3 h~1
.~.
" h~ r" ~; 1JI1O
"e
~ H ~'i;
0 "d " B ~ ~~ I
z
.
:Il
~
tl " lnmV1()m"'ij-.t "j
~ 0 M M~
u ~ 0>_
- 0 -v u;;o ~~ ;G$,,,-;;
~ u '" ~
... ~ ~ 3
g
,~ :- 8
;;
8 w
l1)E Ie
in
"'s; ~
~ ~
m
~
~ "
m ~l
;::. g ~
7J ~ .. m
~" 5 c
01 H . E ~ ~
z
1: .. >-- - ] I~
u (/)
Z .:7 u "' (/)
a: IJl 0. . ,
~D ~ . .
e :J It'
-* e ~ ] 1l
· 0 .. f f
l\J .~ a
-'0 '
~ ~ ~ ~
iIl~ I'
. ~
't., , :q. p-' .N 1;1~U:0Ct 6~1KX1~ ~ ""f f ''''1 ,,"\>SlitI'! '" I 11> IdJ:l> 3m;x
_-..1
-t~
i~ ':.:::;
;:;- b
=~
Ef,
::=. 10-
'f
;;
~~
-~
6
tI ti'
:!~ ~~
a)~ .. S_
"- -
\
. . , . , . .
.- -..--.-;- '-'J
C--'-~---
"
2-!S-l1-!..-~t
. . .<. . . J
[-~:;-.--,.--
...J_..1.... --e..1...... L-
. ..
:-r..... -r
, . . .
'-1-~"""''''''''-''''''
, fi t . '--!
c:i:'llr"-r..
l~":L-.-,.--,---.
. ~L....!-.:L-.L.-
c...........~. , . ,
;;
~ ~ L
.~ .
,;
;;
~~.
_m
~
-- -
....g
111~
~::,'-p
-~..
Ii'"
1-;- ---;- ---:-J:J,
1-,-,-7
;;
"
~.
-li
~
;;
~~
'fi
;;
::.:t
.~
r!-
-.I
~
Z _-l1I-t>-<<<: ~
"
~
<fi.*"$.***<F-~;F.*';J?
*-~~~~r:~~~~~:g
~ a:il~ D M -.f ;!: ~ 1;;5 0 '<t'
~ ~ ~TI~ ~ ~ :t .!i ~ ~ l~ ~
~ ~~I~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ * ~
1-~~:;!ciMM~~cir+l-q'
~:
!i'
o'
ot
~,
~,
I
u-"'
,,:
~!
""
g1
I
I~'
1"5
~ IJl
~ if g 1$
~ ~ {j 8: I:;:
; ~~ df~i
U>~ ~::;f,~~;;
c: r- u> 'C" U m !II l\I
'ji.EEm .~U:U:,,~
'l'o",~.-.~"-
OrD~e~Q:.;,_~~
<lJ...J.S2 l'J> III 0.. ll.l
-a ... LL :t (j l/) () C,} II)
.-' "--~:g:a''''
H~~~~n~~&
is:
0'
J-!
,
I
o
:::>
Cl..
en
~
o
"0
co
CD
:2
co
'-
'-
Q)
Cf)
n.
ro
:2
rn
rfJ
CL.
......"
::)
('\ :::;
i~- ;
i ~ _~)
~ ~~
~1-9
~.
<.
"
~~
..
"
"
"
=~
...~
:!.
\
"
~~
.~
"
T
"
~~
"~
"
i'li i 0 ^ W
~~ :ll~~ u
,,~-g ].Y.. .s ~ 1S
".81, -;]~ ~r"Edi
~t~ 1~ff ';i~'~
H~ ~g~ h~~
E" '"3 ,O..!
~ h.1 ~i" il~!
~ :;J"D'~ ot t i:m~~
~~~ ~&i .:~1
" tn.::5~
flit;. ,
11)(./' .
VI"l: ..
filla' ,
w::f.,' . I I"
.
. ,''':' ' . .
. . . . '1lj ~ . , ' " .
. n"l:' '
. . I '~;g; .', 1 .
\.' . ~'.' .'
" 5 '
.~ <: .
I -r;
> e.
"
S;~
.~
O.
;;
:;:~
..
i.
.. ,.,
.' , . '+i' ' "
. , {;j O' , ,
, , . ~~. l ,
wO
.ti,'
. .
, fe".
.~ "
. ,",C(
""'
, ''''a,
+:
,
:;;"1:
. ,-
..
.
"
. "
.<
'.
.
"
"
;;:.~
.~
"
\
"
~~
,.
.
'"
b
Z ..
----.m-W-lr<<< ~
J
I, _.
." I /'
Y,~~,'I .
. ,W1e / '
.::.' x'
. .
. ~
" .
':: ~
, ..
, ~(
~._<> ,,0
'6: ~ ~ ~ ~ * ~~ <.~ ~ ~~ si
~ ~ ~ ~ t: ~ ~ ~ 5) S * ~!
" "T" " '" a; '"! N :g gi
;i ';:1':11:-1 I..) UIUI'~I: 0';" ~i
I- ,01; ~ 1i <( <( 1<( <3.: <{ <.) ul U .~::,I
o "iIM~..;!!I;:I'"I" .," "" "'II
i- oj ", II.!). ,- ID co +I +I -t'
r....lr---:l......i6!"=: I_!t:-l. ll) !hr-l~ d
I I'. IIi'") ril~j~ ~I~j~. di
, I ' m,
i I idO
! "I
~Ii~ I! I~I
~ ~ ~ iEI!~ ~I
J: ;"-' ,g I~ 111 N -
:3 5~ ~1? g>1l ~ I~
!2J ~ .ol~ ~ 0 12
~~!8~d~H
o-g~ 3cLt..Lt..::E"E
oC'l~H!!:~O"
:g. l: u: ~ ~ CL 0:: ~ ~
:s~ ~~~ ~.g.gE~ ~
::::I=>O:;?' >( ~~'O k':..."
.;;> W 0 :I: X' u: .~ g
0,"
&l1g;;:COO'l'<t l\.l
.....j..... '<t' to..... N ~ UJ... 0
I (0 to CD \f) '<l" '<t '4'
IN"'.... ~
'" '"
. .
.' ~ \ ,
, . ~:' . . .
. .
. i.
ii
d
"'
6
~
:i
~ +1
jlU
D
w~rtlq t^lI "al~l~ _~
.C"t'lOOt WetlWS~HD
f\'J.:j;(.'10J''I....''.WSfiI\LOOZ\
\~t-9OOl.I~ ""
"'101""""'P'-
l'4 rJJ.lll\.l~i\O.,j .I.'\>
l
iJ
cl
.
o
II
"
o
::)
CL
(/)
~
::J
-:;I
(1j
CD
::2:
e
Q)
Ci5
Cl.
'"
2:
(/)
U
LL
U
::l
LL
~>-
~ ~ j
~
.
!
o
J.I\ n
1,.Jlf~M
'JjI, .
" '
... .s j" ~
;:J .. ,~,
~ "
4! ..... ~ ..:
S ~, .
~ ,,~i;\
~ 0 .l.'"
~H~ i
~~U i ~
;; ~
31h>:>>!
cr.
-:: ~ - - ~ '-. ;;:),.
~ l1r"'I?ib~~~~I\\\j /.
-, t'~:" "i.~'''':'J r 'I
<f j,;J.~~J:-:n<q! <\ J' ,
, t "
.,' '1,. i \ - 'J
;,.j'.'-,,!"..-.f,~,"",J-.t~: l ~
~~-'(,t~~;'-.:if~: . ~~' 1,
r;::r.~~j~i?'~~~1'~' l ;.
',. ~ftd,-~.;::;~'~:~' 1:'
-."'1''''\1''.''''''''.''11.--.. "
"I \1""', "," e,,"
"1 ~"'./H';l~i r" ',~
. .' ,rl!".",';";;; "
'i l~4',..~:n:,h~ ~~~r\.'"
.NNoIJ",'.-.i<,' i','
,,-,,..t~~-'j},j :J'
~>~"'...::;l~'
)~' ,
~
, , 'l' I ... ~~, 'l jLl~6~~\.-;lq-\,.'0'-"~-'-; --
" " . I"" ';'ll.t,i1~.'J'o'J.:JJ"Il\H '" I,V/( '::
"1' - '.JI' 1 ;':1.~I;:,lh""~f:'_.I,:.11\it'~ >'>~'~'.!}~
)1~.1'~~-,,r'..'\: <O'i:1.:~ r, '.011' ":j',,~.~~
Ll'j~:..,:t~i'<"'''': ~ r f.j (,.', .1o,\....,J\~,,< o/;~ ~
" ').1' . "-.' ,. ",'. - .,:" - , -.~.
. 0'-, ';J:~.,;~.,"
. .' "7,'~,:'~:;:;.~,~~:;:d~::~i~~' ',0
"
f,n
~f .
~,~
,,11 ~
~ e ~ t
~.al ~ !l
....!!...
g"!!'t'i
~~$
Cl..g,.g
~g~
:Ur5
,......~,.,.
.~
~.
~~~
1J2~(~
".~c
19~i
1l'5,,,",,,
"Ji:"'ii
~ ~ ~ ~
E~ g>~
~Eg-o
w.:>lSli
",
/,
is
?
.tl
,~
~' .5
o
~()
~ J' f f? \1i
i g~ ~
;;. ~ N ~
! ~-'
I g
~~"i\~
~]M
11 _H!<
5 ~ ~~ ~
<; . ",
Cl ..,J"'l"
; .~ ]~~-i'
h s~ Q... ~
p:Jrilu l f
loO ~~
- ..----.--
:: c----
'~J^:
=~)= ':'
~! ~
~f~
~^t
2:
b
~
.
Z _-<XH,H..f^,* ;.
.
jj
~
\
/
/
/
/
(~
~
~
!~
-.
Ez
q
H
~It
Iii il:i
* ~8~
z (/)...1Il
,--
. u
~ :g
:i :f.~
:~ ~ t;
;~:;::.f
z
,
~
1:iJ
"
, ""
- I ~
o is
'",;:I ~
;.S- I~
,.v, "31
I ~ ro .
~o (J) '12
i (l) i\i
, elf)
l1:' QI
()J .;:::;
,,"-
~
~~
" ..
=ll.
i~l~
;.~.'~
.~. -
~tel
i.-~
EiH
i .l~'
e-E i
~.g .
---
~ ~
~ ~
,
8
g
!
"
0
;:)
0-
W
s: 0-
0 '"
~
o
:: _''It
'6 .... ......
'"
U
ttl
I '"
(J) '0
~ (/)
ctl
...
...
(J)
I C/)
J ~ g n
.. .,
M .Jl 8
n~ w
'" '"
"II! OJ
~ ~t:. ili
z 0
if; ~ R D~ '0
l: ;_-' '" ~
j a
J;~
f]!i I:
· 11 I "
~ ~.p
~ Q '::.;, ~.
. ,~ n i
~ U '
~ c:l '\I ~
03i:;r.:l I;
.: ~
-.11 'x.
.uU<'i"q ,Aq P'1l9ld ut<Ictl'C' 100= 6(l Dill!' &tw .~g 'lliJ.IM<jI"UOfl'l 5[3\l~n\6NOlin6 pu. a UOl U'''pn~ ''''II>\'I5i1iiidi"Sl\O
~
~
N
-
<
I ~
-4 "
~
N
"
W
"
'"
"-
'"
~
3
l-
I-
W
0-
r.:
,
0..:
~I
21
I
Z!
I
01
-I
!-,
c::C
()
0
-l
>\
""'.
~!'
>
U
~
, . Ii \! h ,I
.--_c--.J~----=_:-m !~:--:~~ ~ ~ :[ ;" ~';~~~~_F~~J!~~:i
, _-- 71 m g II ! ',I ! \if--l 'I" I ,'-
/- "---,~/~--- --, r'I\\.. ..J! i '~_---L-.l~!._~_-;~J~~./'f 1 il
I ~ ,~\,~,> I: '\ ri-----i---- ;~---~~~-! i I
'=1' ('""i
, L!
I ic-------'-.----
t.__!,
I
I
LJ
,
d
-
::0
!
,'f
.,
:t
I'
.",1
;:c ~
I
"":r-.o_W"~:
'YiZ.I'-~-
,--.I
1--'
L~_;-,J
H
n
, I ~ \
t!::,\_J,- . ! ."
\ ""-;-r-0:rIL-,i,!W~ . Q,'- !!i~'_
cJ~~~:;i:~d~q~,,~::=,,=-,~.jJ?~~~;~t~~-~~:C~r~~-~ '~---'~':;~~.___
f! !'r.;f\.liF I t. !"
~i' Ii .Sf:J "~~_ "'_ :~
, .. ;,,1 ..
'~::--~------r110' l.k:".F ~..~-----.-
~! (E fir-,li~;;~~:~!7:.;f_(lL
,.r
I",
,
0..
c::C
2
(9
Z
Z
o
N
;::, -
,)
Aerial
I _ . - .
,~,;:S:-i:::;C; :lS:Ti i'L.
:T~::'2~' =~' 2C;~
ORDINANCE 99-_~
.LII""
':' '",' ,- ~
m,c 1~~~
RECE1'lf.ll
c\.r~ -A
01 Bo"V
'.}.C; 0: S'
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING ORDINANCE NUMBER
'JI-IO]. TilE COLLlER COllNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT
CODE. \\'111('11 INC'UIDES TilE COMPREHENSIVE ZONING
REGULATIONS FOR TilE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF
COIIWI{ ('(HINI-Y. FLORIDA, BY AMENDING TilE
(WFIC\AL 1.0NINl, ATlAS MAP NUMBERED 0(,22 RY
CIIANlilNC,1 I II' ZONINli Cl_ASSII''lCATION OF TilE
llFREIN DI'SC'RlllED REAL PROPERTY FROM "PlID" TO
"PUD" PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT KNOWN AS
SiERRA MEADOWS PUD, FOR PROPERTY LOCATED AT
THE SOUTHWEST QUADRANT OF THE INTERSECTION OF
RATTLESNAKE-HAMMOCK ROAD (CR. 864) AND CK 951,
IN SECTION 22, TOWNSH1p 50 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST,
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, CONSISTING OF 90.8+
. ACR ES; PROVIDING FOR THE REPEAL OF ORDINANCE
NUJv1BER 94-64, TilE FORMER SIERRA MEADOWS PUD;
.".ND BY PRIWID1NCi AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WI-!ERLt>.S, Bruce Anderson, Esq., of 'Young, Van Assenderp. Varnado,:: Dnd Anoerson
and Greg SluarL AICP, or Swan and AS$o:ia1.es, repre::;..::nting Land Trust Naples,-petitii:ioed th$j
B03rd of Counly COlllmissioner5 to change the zoning dassification of the herein described reat
propeny~
: .; ~
NOW TIIEREFORE BE iT ORDAINED BY THE BOARD OF- CmJ~
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY. FLORIDA;
SECTION ONE:
(.J
~;'I ,"i
The Zoning Classification of the herein described real property located in Section 22.
Township 50 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida. is changed from IIpUD" to "PUD"
Planned Unit Development in accordance with the pun Document, attached hereto as Exhibit
"A", which is incorporated herein and by reference made part hereof. The Official Zoning Atlas
Map numbcred 0622, as described in Ordinance Number 91- I 02, the Collier County Land
Development Code, is hereby amended accordingly.
SECTION TWO:
Ordinance Number 94-64, known .. the Sierra Meadow. PUD, adopted on Docember 20,
1994 by the Board of County Conuni..ioner. of Collier County, i. hereby repealed in itB
entirety.
-1-
~ ;'j~
SFCT!Q!'J.TJ:!RF);;
This ()rJin~n;::e shall become effective upon filing with Ihe Department or Slate.
PASSED AND III ILl' ADOPTED by
County, Floriu:l, this/tad:.!)' of ~..
Ihe Board of Coumy Commissioners of Collier
, ]999.
;,TTFST
DWI(il-fl E. HROCK. Clerk
" ~;:~'~~~~;ff
signature on]].
'Approved as to Fonn and
'Legal Sufficiency
/4?e
BOARD OF C011NTl' COMMISSIONERS
::'U;;/)J:;;;~~
pi~L/\ S. MACKIE, CHAiOMAN
This ordinance fil,.d with thf' /
Se..:retary of $totcc's Ollie/? lll~
.2~ay of~, 1m.
and iJckn(lw;,-'d~jemcnt of tl",t
tiling re,eivcd this~II'lY
Al.. ~~
ol~,. ~ ~
By ~"c" _
lJ<<['>.Jty..~
./
1~^'ln~
!'vialjmji 1\-1, Swdcnt
ASSlst~lll County AllOm!:y
()l~li:r; ',N: '1,.')'1 'J )-'I.I_{l1 f II~,M ,m
.2.
~;7 '::C,~_,
FUD-94- J (J)
Exhibit A
PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT DOCUMENT
FOR
The Sierra Meadows PUD
A Mixed Use Development
..- -~._".._,
Prepared by:
, ------~ -',':\
I"
'I t -----~-; t---~-:-.iTU
..~U--:. ~. :_.~., '..,J ,--,,---,
----------
___~____M___p -
Stuart and Assoclates
2180 West First Street, Suite 503
Fort Myers, Florida 33901
Date Reviewed by ccpe:
00'0 Approved by 8CC: /3,#1#'f'j'
Onllnonce Number. 7'?- '"
'.'_...-:
TABLE OF CONTENTS
S!':CTIOI\
STAT!':M::W 0;: COMPUANC!':
PAGE
3
SECTIC'
SEe,
SEe
,N IV
SE~
IN V
S-r
::.'
)N VI
F-'rooerty Ownership & Description
5
Project Development
6
III
Residential District
11
Community Commercial District
16
Conservation Reserve District
20
General Development Commitments
21
LIST OF EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT "A" PUD Ordinance
EXHIBIT "B" Master Concept Plan
2
'S,}, !-L :-J
;,-;:
-,."~..._,,. i
~! ,
~) ~'
STATEMENT OF COMPLIANCE
The development of 90.8+ acres of property in Section 22. Township 50 South. Range
26 East, Coliier County, as a Planned Unit Deveiopment to be known as The Sierra
Meadows PUD wili be in compilance with the planning goals and objectives of Coliier
County as set forth In the Coliier County Growth Management Pian. The commercIal.
resIdential and conservation reS8r\18 tracts of the Sierra Meadows PUD will be consistent
will'. the growth poilcles. land development regulalions. and appiicable comprehensive
planning objectives tor the foHowing reasons:
1. The subject property is iDeated at the southwest quadrant of the intersection
ot Rattiesnake Hammock Road and CR 951, and IS classified as the Urban
Commercial Mixed Use Actlvily Center on the Collier County Future Land
Use Map. The Mixed Use Activity Center permits up to 40-acres of
commercial and residential development at up to sixteen (16) dweliing units
per acre within the Activity Center. The Sierra Meadows PUD calls for a 30-
acre plus commercial tract with an integrated three-hundred (300) multi-
family dweliing unit tract. .
2. Activity Centers are the preferred locations for the concentration of mixed-
use residential and commercial development activities. The proposed
development Includes both residential and commercial uses which is entirely
consistent with the Urban Commercial District Objective and associated
Policies and Standards.
3. Provisions are included in the project to minimize the number of ingress and
egress points onto Rattlesnake Hammock Road and C.R. 951 so as to
coordinate on-site and off-site traffic movements and to provide
interconnections for pedestrians. bicycles and motor vehicles for existing and
future adjacent projects.
4. The project development promotes sound plenning and ensures land use
compatibility as required by Objective 5 of the Future Land Use Element.
The project development is compatible with and complementary to existing
and future surrounding commercial land uses to the north and east. existing
public community educational facilities to the south and future residential
land uses to west.
5. The subject property's Mixed Use Activity Center location in reiation to
existing or proposed community facilities and services permits the
developmsnt's intensity of land use as required in Objective 2 of the Future
Land Use Element. and the Collier County Density Rating System.
6. All final development orders for this project are subject to Division 3_15.
Adequate Public Facilities. of the Collier County Land Development Code as
3
set forth in Policy 2.3 of the Future Land Use Element. The development
project will be served by a full range of services and utilities provided by the
County and will result in an efficient and economical expansion of facilities as
required Policy 3.1 H of the Future Land Use Element.
7. The project shall be in compliance w"lh all applicable County regulations
inciudlng the Growth Management Plan.
8. The Sierra Meadows PUD is planned te incorporate open spaces. wetlands
and natural systems fOi water management in a:::cordance with their natural
functions and capabilities consistent with Objective 1.5 of the Drainage Sub-
Element of the Public Facilities Eiement and Goals One, Two and Six of the
Recreation and Open Space Element.
9. The entire subject property quaiifies for a maximum density of 498 dwelling
units per acre based upon Future Land Use Element Density Rating System.
The project development is consistent with the Density Rating System with a
project density of 5.27 dwelling units per acre, or 300 total maximum units.
Land lJ:;l'
-\reafll
Density
Dwelling Units
Total Site Area
Less Comrm:rclill Tract
Right-of-way
Multi.family ResIdential
Preserve and Surface Water
Managemenl Area
Net Gross Area For Residential
Density Calculations u
+ Mixed Use Activity Center
+ Residential Base Density
. Activity Center Density Band
+ .2 Direct Access Connections
90.8
30.2 ae.
).jac.
18.7 ae.
J8.8 ae
60.6 ae
5.1 ac,
55.5ac.
55.5ae.
55.5ac
@16DUSperac.
@4 DUS per ac.
@ 3 DUS per ae.
@IDUSperac
82 DUS
222 DUS
166 DUS
55DUS
Total Estimated Maximum Units
6O.6ac:.
&.66 DUS per ae.
525DUS
Sierra Meadows PUD Ameodmmt 60.9 ae. 4.93 DUS per BC. 300 DUS
(1) Righl-of-way, Conuncrciai and Residential Tract areas to be fmalized at Fin.1 Site Development
PlllD Review.
4
SECTION 1
PROPERTY OWNERSHIP AND DESCRIPTION
1.1 PURPQSE
The purpose of this Se:tion IS to set forth the location and ownership of the
property, and to describe the exislin9 conditions of the property proposed to be
developed under the name of The Sierra Meadows PUD
1.2 ~EGAL DESCBIPT19N
/\ parcel of land located in Se:tion 22. Township 50 South. Range 26 East, Collier
County. Florida, being more particularly described as follows:
The North one-half (9-1/2) of the North one-half (9-1/2). exceptthe
Northwest quarter (NW-V,) of the Northwest quarter (NW-V,) and road
right-ot-way and less the Westeriy 400 feet, Section 22. Township 50
South, Range 26 East. Collier County, Florida. Containing 90.8 acres.
more or less.
Subject to easements. reservations or restrictions of record.
1.3 PROPERTY OWNERSHIP
The subject property is currently owned by Land Trust Naples.
1.4 GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY AREA
A. The subject property is located at the southwest quadrant of the intersection
of Rattlesnake Hammock Roed and CR 951 of unincorporated Collier County,
Florida. The subject property Is located within an Urban Mixed Use Activity Center
as designated on the Future Land Use Map.
B. The property Is currently vacant. The entire she currently has PUD zoning_
1.5 PROJECT DESCRIPTION
Approximately 40-acres of the 90.8 acre property are located whhin the Mixed Use
Activity Center. The Sierra Meadows PUD will include a mixture of land uses for
commercial, residential and conservation reserve. The mixed-use project will
consist of a 30.2 plus acre commercial land use tract. approximately 3.1 acres of
internal right-of-way. a 18_7 -acre residential land use tract, and a 38.8-acre
conservation reserve tract The final size and configuration of the commercial,
5
right-of-way, residential and conservation reserve tracts will be determined during
final Site Development Plan approval process however. the final size shall not
deviale more Ihen five percent of the lotal acreage designated as such. up to five
acres In area. Access 10 Ihe site is provided trom both CR 951 and Rattlesnake
Hammock Road through eXisting and proposed median openings to provide <ngress
and egress to both artenal and collector roadways. The Sierra Meadows PUD
Access Management Plan is depicted within the Exhibit "A" , PUD Master Plan. A
maxImum number ot three hundred (300) dwelling units are proposed along with
two - hundred and sixty thousand (260,000) souare feet of gross commercial floor
area. The SIerra Meadows PUD intends to establish commercial development
guidelines and standards to ensure a high and consistent level of quality tor
proposed features and tacilities. Uniform guideiines and standards will be created
for landscaping, lighting, fences and buffers. The IAaster Plan is illuslrated
graplllcally on Exhibit "A", PUD Master Plan. indiVidual tract land uses are
Identified wIthin the '''''aster Plan.
1_6 SHORT TITLE
This Ordinance shall be known and Cited as the "Sierra Meadows Planned Unit
Development Ordinance."
SECTION II
PROJECT DEVELOPMENT
2,1 PURPOSE
The purpose of this Section is to delineate and generally describe the project plan
of development, relationships 10 applicable County ordinances, the respective land
uses of the tracts included in the project, as well as other project relationships.
2.2 GENERAL
A. Regulations for development of The Sierra Meadows PUD shall be in
accordance with the contents of this document. PUD-Planned Unit Development
District. applicable sections and parts of the Collier County Land Development
Code in effect at the time of Site Development Plan or Plat approval, as applicable
and as provided in the Land Development Code and Collier County Growth
Management Pian in effect at the time of local final development order or building
permit application. Where these regulations fail to provide developmental
standards. then the provisions of the most similar district in the Collier County Land
Development Code shall apply.
6
:t:~,rL '-J(:<
~ .- _: .
~- ::,~~E: .'.; c;
B. Unless otherwise noted. the definitions of all terms shall be the same as the
definitions set forth in the Collier County Land Development Code in effect at the
date of adoption of this PUD.
C_ All conditions imposed and graphic material presented depicting restrictions
for the deveiopment of The Sierra Meadows PUD shall become part of the
regulations that govern the manner In which the PUD site may be developed.
o Unfess specifically waived through any varian::::e or waiver provisions from
any other applicable regulations. the provisions of those regulations not otherwise
proVided tor this PUD remain in ful! force and effect.
~. Development permitted by the approval of this petition will be subjected to a
concurrency review under the provisions of Division 3.15, Adequate Public Facilities
ot the Coliler County Land Development Code at the earliest. or next. to occur of
either Final Site Development Pian approval. Final Plat approval. or building permit
Issuance applicable to this development.
2_3 PROJECT PLAN AND PROPOSED LAND USES
A. The project Master Plan is illustrated graphically by Exhibit "A", PUD Master
Plan.
B. Minor modifications to Exhibit "A" may be permitted at the time of Site
Development Plan approval. SUbject to the provisions of Section 2.7.3_5 of
the Collier County Land Development Code or as otherwise permitted by this
PUD Document.
C. In addition to the various areas and specific items shown in Exhibit "A",
easements (such as utility, private, semi-public, etc.) shall be established
andlor vacated within or along the property, as may be necessary.
2.4 LAND USE
A. Exhibll "A", PUD Mastar Plan, constitutes the required PUD Development
Plan. Except as otherwise provided within this PUD Document, any division
of the property and the development of the land shall be in compliance with
the Subdivision Regulations and the platting laws of the State of Florida.
B. The provisions of Division 3.3. Site Development Plans of the Land
Development Code. when applicable, shall apply to the development of all
platted tracts, or parcels of land as provided in said Division 3_3 prior to the
issuance of a building permit or other development order.
C. Appropriate instruments will be provided at the time of infrastructure
improvements regarding any dedications and provision for
7
j-
~, -
~) "'.:::
perpetual maintenance of common facilities.
2.5 AMENDMENTS TO PUD DOCUMENT OR PUD MASTER PLAN
Amendments may bs made to the PUD document and Master Plan as provided in
Section 2.7.3.5 of the Cullie~ County Land Development Code.
2.6 MODEL HOMES
Model Homes and Model Home Sales Centers shall be permitted as proVided for in
Section 2.6.33.4 of the Collier County Land Development Code.
2.7 LIMITATIONS OF PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT APPROVAL
This PUD is subject to the sunseltlng provisions as provided for within Article 2,
Division 2.7. Section 2.7.3.4 of the Collier County Land Development Code.
2_8 PUD MONITORING
An annual monitoring report shall be submitted pursuant te Article 2. Division 2.7,
Section 2.7.3.6 of the Collier County Land Development Code.
2.9 DEDICATION AND MAINTENANCE OF FACILITIES
The Developer shall create appropriate property ownership association(s), which
will be responsible for maintaining the roads, streets, drainage. common areas, and
water and sewer improvements where such systems are not dedicated to the
County.
2.10 OPEN SPACE REQUIREMENTS
A minimum of thirty percent (30%) of the project's gross area shall be devoted to
open space. pursuant to Article 2. Division 2_6, and Section 2.6.32 of the Collier
County Land Development Code. The total project Is 90.8 +/- acres. requiring a
minimum of 27.24 acres to be retained as open space throughout The Sierra
Meadows PUD. The 38.8-acre conservation reserve tract will comprehensively
meet the projects 30% open space requirement. The 30% open space requirement
shall not apply to individual development parcels.
2.11 NATIVE VEGETATION RETENTION REQUIREMENTS
Pursuant to Article 3, Division 3.9. Section 3_9_5.5.3 of the Collier County t.and
8
;l:;" =-
r.., :-::.(;~r '-- cJ' ,
Development Code. 25% of the viable naturally functioning native vegetation on
site, or approximately 22.7 acres. shall be retained. The 38.8-acre conservation
reserve tract will comprehensively meet the projects 25% native vegetation
requirement. The 25% native vegetation requirement shall not apply to individual
deveiopment parcels .
2.12 POLLING PLAC:S
Pursuant to Articie 3, Division 3.2, Section 3.2.8.3.14 of the Collier County Land
Development Code, accommodation shall be made for the future use ot building
space within common areas for the purposes cf accommodating the function of an
electorai polling piace.
2.13 SIGNS
Signs shall be in accordance with Article 2, Division 2.5 of the Collier County Land
Deveiopment Code.
2.14 LAKE SETBACK AND EXCAVATION
The lake setback requirements described in Article 3, Division 3.5. Section 3.5_7.1
of the Collier County Land Development Code may be reduced with the
administrative approval of the Collier County Engineering Review Manager. All
lakes greater than two (2) acres may be excavated to the maximum commercial
excavation depths set forth in Section 3.5.7.3.1; however, removal of fill from The
Sierra Meadcws PUD shall be limited to an amount up to 10 percent (to a maximum
ct 20.000 cubic yards) of the total volume excavated unless a commercial
excavation permit is received.
2.15 EXCAVATION AND VEGETATION REMOVAL
A. Improvement of property shall be prohibited prior to Issuance of a building
permit. No site work, removal of protec\sd vegetation. grading, Improvement of
property or construction of any type may be commenced prior to the issuance of a
building permit where the development proposed requires a building permit under
the Land Development Code or other applicable County regulations. Exceptions to
this requirement may be granted by the Community Development and
Environmental Services Administrator for an approved Subdivision or Site
Development Plan to provide for distribution of fill excavated on sile or to permit
construction of an approved water management system, to minimize stockpiles and
hauling off-site or to protect the public health, safety and welfare where clearing,
grading and filling plans have been submitted and approved meeting the standards
of Section 3.2.6.3.6. of the Code and a Clearing and Filling Permit has been issued.
9
Removal of exotic vegetation shall be exempted upon receipt of a vegetation
removal permit for exotics pursuant to Division 3.9 of the Land Development Code_
B. A site clearing. grading. filling and revegetation plan and a Clearing and
Filling Permit Application, where applicable. shall be submitted to the Communily
Development and Environmental Services Administrator or his designee for review
and approvai prior to any clearing. grading or filling on the property. This pian may
be submitted in phases to coincide with the development schedule. The site-
clearing pian snail clearly depict how the improvement plans incorporate and retain
native vegetation. The sne speCific Clearing, grading, and filling plan for a
Subdivislor, or Site Deveiopment Plan may be considered for review and approval
unaer the follOWing categones and subject to the following requirements:
1 . Removal of exotic vegetation is permitted upon receipt of a vegetation
removal permit pursuant to Division 3.9. Additional site alteration may
be permitted or required to stabilIze and deter reinfestation by exotics
subJeot to the follOWing:
a) ProviSion of a site filling and grading plan for review and approval
by the County:
b) Provision of a revegetation plan for review and approval by the
County;
2. Site filling exceeding 25 acres to properly utilize fill generated on site.
but Which does not require the removal of more than 25 acres of
protected vegetation, may be approved by the Community
Development and Environmental Services Administrator subject to
submission of the following:
a) A site-clearing plan shall be submitted for review and approval that
shows the acreage to be cleared. A minimum of 25% of the natural
functioning vegetation shall be retained.
b) The applicant shall submit a detailed description of the fill and site
work activity including a plan Indicating fill placement locations and
depths. grading pian and water management improvements.
c) The applicant shall submit a detailed revegetation plen including a
cost estimate. The cost estimate shall include the cost of grading,
revegetation and yearly maintenance cost and a time specific
schedule on completion ot the revegetation work.
d) The permittee shall post a surety bond or an Irrevocable standby
letter of credit in an amount of 110% of certified cost estimate as
previously detailed including the maintenance cost for 3 years. The
amount of the security may be reduced upon the issuance of a
JO
" .' ~0 F'
:l~;i-:-: !\lC;, I t:i
';[1"::;' ~(7 .2CiC7
~.. . ".-
c: 0::":;'
building permit A separate security will not be required if such
costs are included in the subdivision security.
2.16 ARCHITECTURE AND SITE DESIGN
All slgnage. fencing and landscaping shall be architecturally unif.ed tor all
development on the subject site. 1\11 commercial buildings shall comply with
Division 2.8 of the Collier County Land Development Code (Architectural and Site
DeSIgn Standards and Guidelines) prior to issuan:::e of a building permit
SECTION III
RESIDENTIAL DISTRICT
3_1 PURPOSE
The purpose of this section is to identity permitted uses and development standards
for areas within The Sierra Meadows PUD designated on Exhibit "A", PUD Master
Plan as ''Residential''.
3.2 MAXIMUM DWELLING UNITS
A maximum number of three hundred (300) Dwelling Units may be constructed on
lands designated "Residential" on the PUD Master Plan. For assisted living
facilities. the maximum gross floor area shall not exceed a factor of 0.45 (0.45 times
the area of the property excluding conseNalion tracts and commercial tracts).
3.3 GENERAL DESCRIPTION
A_ Arees designated as Residential on the PUD Master Plan are designed to
accommodate Multi-family and Group Housing, along with associated recreatlonel
facilities, essential seNices, and customary accessory uses.
B. The approximate acreage of the Residential District Is eighteen and seven-
tenth (18.7) acres. Actual acreage of all development tracts will be provided at the
time of SlIe Development Plan approval In accordance wllh Division 3.3 of the LDC_
The Residential tract is designed to accommodate internal roadways, open space,
parks. amenity areas. lakes and water management facilities. and other similar
uses.
1]
3.4 PERMITTED USES AND STRUCTURES
No building or structure. or part thereof. shall be erected, altered, or used, or land
or water used, in whole or part, for other than the following:
A. Principal Uses:
1) Multiple-family dwellings Including Garden Apartments.
2) Single-family Attached and Townhouse
3) ASSisted liVing Facilities (ALFs) pursuant to Section 2.6.26 of the Land
Development Code.
4) Group Care Facility (category I and category II) pursuant to Section 2.6.26 of
the Land Deveiopment Code, excluding Homeless Shelters.
5} Nursing home facility pursuant to Section 2.6.26 of the Land Development
Code.
6) Group Care units. except homeless shelters, pursuant to Section 2.6.26
CCLDC.
7) Guard houses and entrance gates.
8) Management offices and recreational facilities that serve the group housing
development including but not limrted to administrative offices, tennis courts,
pools, pool cabanas, clubhouses and gazebos.
9) Any other principal use. which is comparable in nature with the foregoing, uses.
B. Accessory Uses:
1) Uses and structures that are necasssry and Incldantal to usas permlttad as a
right including, but not limited to, garagas and carports.
2) Parks, passive recreational areas, boardwalks. observation platforms.
3) Biking, hiking. health and nature trails.
4) Water management facilities and lakes, including lakes with seawalls and other
types of architectural bank treatment. and essential services.
5) Recreational shelters. restrooms, off-street parking, lighting and signage.
12
"~y-_.
3.5 DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS
Table 1 sets forth the development standards for land uses within the Residential
District.
1. Standards for parking, landscaping. signs and other land uses where such
standards are not specified herein are to be in accordance with the Collier County
Land Deveiopment Code In efte:;t at the time of Site Development Plan aDproval.
Unless othervvise indicated, required yards, heights. and floor area standards apply
to princiDal structures.
2. Development standards for uses not specifically set forth in Tabie 1 shall be
established during the Site Development Plan approval as set forth in Division 3.3
of the Land Development Code in accordance with those standards of the zoning
distnct which IS most Similar to the proposed use_
3. Site development standards for single family attached and townhouses apply to
Individual residential iot boundaries. Multi-family standards apply to platted parcel
boundaries.
4. During the platting process. the developer shall identify the specific housing type
intended for each platted tract
13
;.,,'
TABLE 1
DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS FOR
RESIDENTIAL TRACTS
, I
I : SINGLE FAMILY MilL TI-
PERMITTED USES I ATTACHED & FAMILY
AND STANDARDS I TOWNHOIlSE I DWELLINGS
I C2tet!ory I I 2
~[Jimum Lot Area I 3.000 SF pcr 0\1 I lAC
I \linimum 1,01 Vv'idrh "'I I 30 ! 150
I
Front Yard I 20 I 25
I Front Yanl for I 10 I 15
Side Entry (;ara~e
I, Side Yard I Oor ,5 RH l~:' i O.5I3H
I Rear Yard rrincipal T i 20 BH
Rear )'"ard Accessory 10 15
i\laximum Building Hei.ght "j 35 55
Oistance Between .5 SBH I .5 S8H
Principal Structures
Floor Area Min. IS.F.) 1200 425 "5
. BH: Building Height
. SBH: (Sum of Building Height): Combined height of lwo adjacent buudings for the purposes of
determining setback requirements.
. SF: Square feet
. All distances are in feet unless otherwise noted.
. Front yards shaU be measured 85 follows:
A, If the parcel is served by a public right-of.way, setback is measured from the adjacent right-
of-way linB.
B, If the parcells served by B private road. setback is measured from the beck of curb (If
curbad) or edge of pavement (If not curbed).
C. If the pareal is served by a platted private drive. the setback Is measured from the back of the
nearest easement or property line, whichever is more restrictive.
. -1 - Minimum lot width may be reduced by 20% for cul-de-sac lots provided minimum tot area
requirement is still maintained.
. .2 ~ Rear yards for principal 8!1d ecc8s90!)' structures on lots and tracts which abut a non-
jurisdictional open space or native vegetation preservation area may be zero (0') feet except that
when abutting a lake or water body; an architectural bank treatment shalf be incorporated into the
design.
14
. .3 ~ Building height shall be the vertical distance measured from the first habitable finished floor
elevation to the uppermost finished ceiling elevation of the structure.
. . 4~ The zero (0') foot provision does nol apply to any exterior wall of a structure, and is intended
to apply to the common wall or wall along interior lot lines within a series of townhouse or semi~
detached units
. ~5 ~ Group care facility (category 1 and category 1\ other than homeless) - 1,500 sq.ft. plus 200
sq,lt. per live~ln person, ueginnlng witn the seventh live~in person.
15
SECTION IV
COMMERCIAL DISTRICT
4.1 PURPOSi:;
The purpose of this sectl:::m is to identity permitted uses and development standards
for areas within The Sierra Meadows PUD aesignated on the :::xhibit "A". PUD
Master Pian as "CQmmer::::la:"
4.2 GE:NE:RAl DE:SCRIPTION
A Areas designated as "Commercial" on the Master Plan are designed to
accommodate a full range of commercial uses, hotel/motel, essential services.
and customary accessory uses.
B. The approximate acreage of the 'Commercial District that includes the project's
internal right-of-way will be thirty and three-tenths (33.3) acres of which
approximately three and one-tenth (3.1) acres will be for right-of-way_ Net
commercial land area will be thirty and two-tenth (30.2) acres. Actual areas of
all development tracts and outparceis will be provided at the time of Site
Development Plan or Preliminary Subdivision Plat approvals in accordance with
Article 3. Division 3.2 and Division 3.3 respectively. of the Collier County Land
Development Code. Commercial tracts are designed to acccmmodate internal
roadways. open spaces, lakes. water management facilities, and other similar
uses.
C. Up to two hundred and sixty thousand (260.000) square feet of retail or office
development is permitted within this Commercial area of the Planned Unil
Development
4.3 PERMITTED USES AND STRUCTURES
No building or structure or part thereof, shell be erectad, altered or used, or land
used. in whole or in part, for other than the following:
A. Permitted Principal Uses and Structures
Agricultural Services (Group 0742,0752. except for outdoor kenneling)
2. Amusements and Recreation Services - Indoor (7911 to 7933. 7991 and 7997)
16
~ -: ''.It -
,..::;; -
;.. ,_,J
,..., Ji ~
3. Apparel and Accessory Stores (Groups 5611-5699)
4. Auto and Home Supply Stores (5531)
5. Automotive Services, Car Washes. Supplies and Gasoline Station. subject to
Section 2.6.28 of the Land Development Code (Groups 5531 with primary
emphaSIS on Sale of Automotive Pans and their Installation. but not unrelated
Repairs; 5541 which may Include a Car Wash as defined oy 7542. with the
exception of Bus and Truck Washing and Ancillary Repairs normally a function
of a Full Service Automobile Gasoline Service Station. Car washes abutting
residential land uses subjec;t to Section 2.2.15.2.1.5 of the Land Development
Code)
6. Automotive Repair. Services and Parking (Groups 7514,7515,7521)
7. Building Matenals. Hardware and Garden Supplies (Groups 5211. 5231. 5251 -
OutSide Storage IS Itmited only to Garden Supplies).
8. Business Services (Groups 7311-7352, 7359. except airplane, industrial truck.
portable toilet and oil field equipment Renting and leasing, except armored car
and dog rental, 7389 except auctioning. bronzing. field warehousing, salvaging
of damaged merchandise).
9. Child Day Care Services (8351)
10. Communications (Groups 4812-4841. except principal transmission towers)
11. Depository Institutions (Groups 6011-6099)
12. Drug Stores and Proprietary Stores (5912)
13. Eating and Drinking Places (Groups 5812-5813. All establishments engaged in
the retail sale of alcoholic beverages are subject to the location requirements of
Sec. 2.6_10)
14. Hotels and motels (Groups _7011,7021,7041),
15_ Engineering, Accounting, Research, Management and Related Services
(Groups 8711-8748)
16. Food Stores (Groups 5411-5499)
17. General Merchandise Stores (Groups 5311-5399)
18. Group Care Facilities (Category I and II) Care Units and Nursing Homes, SUbject
to Sec. 2_6.26
17
19. Group Housing. excludmg Family Care Facilities. subject tc Sec. 2.6.26
20.Health Services (Groups 8011-8049. 8082)
21.Home Furniture. Furnishing. and Equipment Stores (Groups 5712-5736)
22. Insurance Carners. Agents and Brokers (Groups 6311-6399, 6411)
23. Legal Services (8111)
24. Libraries (8231)
25. Management and Pubiio Relations Services (Groups 8741-8743.8748)
26. rl,~embershfp Or~anizatjons (86"11-5699)
27. Miscellaneous Persona! ServIces (7281)
28. Miscellaneous Retail (Groups 5912.5963. 5992-5999)
29. Motion Picture Theaters (7832).
30. Museums and Art Galleries (8412)
31. Non-depository Credit Institutions (Groups 6111-6163)
32. Paint. Glass and Wallpaper Stores (5231)
33. Personal Services (Groups 7212. 7215. 7217. 7219-7299)
34. Public Administration (Groups 9111-9199, 9229. 9311, 9411-9451, 9511-9562,
9611-9661)
35.Real Estate (Groups 6512, 6531-6541)
36_ Retail Nurseries. Lawn and Garden Suppiy Stones (5261)
37. Security and Commodity Brokers, Dealer, Exchanges end Service (Groups
6211- 6289)
38.Video Tape Rental (7841)
39.Vocational Schools (Groups 8243-8299)
40. Any other general commercial use, which is comparable in nature with the C-4
General Commercial District in effect on the date of approval of this PUD
Ordinance and the foregoing uses.
18
iL~;n: 1\;
:J; :; ~',
4.4 ACCESSORY USES AND STRUCTURES
Any other general commercial use which is comparable in nature with the foregoing
uses including buildings for retail. service and office purposes consistent with the
permitted uses and purpose and Intent statement of the Mixed Use Activity Center
Subdistrict which the Planning Services Depanment Director determines to be
compatible.
4.5 DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS
A. Minimum lot area: Ten thousand (10,000) square feet.
B. Minimum lot width: Seventy-five (75) teet, as measured by the exterior
project lines.
c. Minimum yard requirements:
1. Front yard: Twenty-five (25) feet.
2. Front yard CR 951 and Rattlesnake Hammock Roads: The distance
equal to the height of the building. but no less than twenty-five (25)
feet.
3. Side yard: Fifteen (15) feet.
4. Rear yard: Fifteen (15) feet.
5. Any yard abutting a residential parcel and the southem property
boundary: Twenty-five (25) feet.
D. Distance between principal structures: The distance between any two
principal structures on the same parcel shall be fifteen (15) feet or a distance equal
to one-half the sum of their heights, whichever is greater.
E_ Minimum off-street parking and off-street loading: As required by Division
2.3. of the Land Development Code.
F. Minimum floor area of principal structure: Seven hundred (700) square feet
gross floor area for each building on the ground floor.
G. Maximum height: Fifty (50) feet above Mean Flood Elevation es measured
by the finished floor elavation to the building eave.
H. General application for setbacks: Front yard setbacks shall comply with the
following:
1. If the parcel is served by a public or private right-<lf-way. the setback is
measured from the adjacent right-<lf-way line.
19
2. If the parcel is served by a non-platted private drive, the setback is
measured from the back of curb or edge of pavement.
3_ If the parcel is served by a platted private drive, the setback is
measured from the road easement Dr property line, whichever is more
restrictive.
I. Architectural and site design standards: All commercial buildings and
projects shall be SUD\8Ct to the provisions of LDC Division 2.6 and any other
apDlt::::ab(e se::tions ,')f the Land Development Code_
J Me:-::handise storage and dispiay: Unless speGifi::::ally permitted for lJse,
outside storage or display of merchandise is prohibited.
K. Landscaping: ~.s required by DivIsion 2.4. of the Land Development Code.
L. Signs: As reqUIred by DivIsion 2.5. of the Land Development Code.
SECTION V
CONSERVATION RESERVE DISTRICT
5.1 PURPOSE
The purpose of this section is to identify permitted uses and development standards
for areas within The Sierra Meadows PUD designated on Exhibit "A", PUD Master
Plan as Conservation Reserve Tract.
5.2 GENERAL DESCRIPTION
The 38.8-acre tract designated as ConServation ReserVe on the PUD Master Plan ..
Is designed to accommodate a full ranga of conl.rvation and limnsd watar
management uses, functions and berms. The primery purpose of the Reserve
District is to conserve native on-site wetlands and uplands habitat, to allow tor the
restoration and enhancement of impacted or degraded wetlands, to provide a
native open space site amenity for the enjoyment of The Sierra Meadows PUD
residents, and to provide a native vegetative buffer for future adjoining residential
uses to the west. The Conservation Reserve Tract consists of 35_9 acres of
wetlands and uplands preserve, and 2.9 acres of a perimeter berm easement. The
final size and configuration of the commercial, residential and conservation reserve
tracts will be determined during final Site Development Plan approval process.
However, the final size shall not deviate more than five percent of the total acreage
designated as such, up to five acres in area.
20
,::;:r: i"v
'('\"'.c.'
,:-'C (,
5.3 PERMITTED USES AND STRUCTURES
No building or structure. or part thereof, shall be erected, altered or used. or land or
water used, in whole or in part. for other than the following:
Permitted Principal Uses and Structures:
A. Passive recreational areas, boardwalks, and recreational shelters.
B. Nature trails, excluding asphalt paved surfaces,
C. VVater management facilities, berms, structures and Jake bulkheads or other
structural treatments.
D. Mitigation areas.
E. Any other conservation and related open space activity or use which is
comparable In nature with the foregoing uses and which the Planning
Services Department Director determines to be compatible in the Reserve
District.
5.4 DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS
A. All structures shall set back a minimum of fifteen (15) feet landward from the
edge of wetland preserves In all places and averaging twenty.f,ve (25) feet
from the landward edge of reserve District boundaries and roads, except for
pathways. boardwalks and water management structures. which shall have
no required setback_
5.5 RESERVE DISTRICT CONSERVATION EASEMENT
A non-exclusive conservation easement or tract Is required by the Collier County
Land Development Code, Section 3.2..8.4.7.3 for preservation lands Included In the
Conservation Reserve District. In addition to Collier County. a conservation
easement may also be required by other regulatory agencies with jurisdiction over
Reserve District lands. In addition to complying with provisions of the Colllar County
Land Development Code, said easement shall be provided in accordance with the
terms set forth in the applicable permit granted by said agencies. The developer or
owners of The Sierra Meadows PUD shall be responsible for control and
maintenance of lands within the Reserve District.
21
SECTION VI
GENERAL DEVELOPMENT COMMITMENTS
6.1 PURPOSE
Tne purpose of this section IS to set forth the standards for development of the
project.
6.2 GENERAL
All facilities shall be constructed in accordance with the final site development
pians. the Final subdivIsion plats. and all applicable state and local laws. codes and
reguiatlons appiicable to thiS PUD. Except when specifically noted or otherwise set
forth in this document. the standards and specifications of Division 3.2 of the Land
Development Code shall apply to this project even if fhe iand within the PUD is not
to be platted. All state and federal Permits shall be e!fective according to the
stipulations and conditions of the permitting AgenCies. Final master plans. final site
development plans or final subdivision plats. and standards and specifications of
the Collier County Land Development Code relating to the same shall apply to this
project. except as otherwise set forth herein. The developer andlor his successor
shall agree to follow the Master Plan and the PUD regulations as adopted. along
with any other conditions or modifications as may be agreed to in the rezoning of
thiS property. In addition. the developer and the successors are bound by the
commitments within this agreement.
6.3 PUD MASTER PLAN
A. Exhibrt "A", PUD Master Plan illustrates proposed development and is
conceptual in nature. Proposed area, lot or land use boundaries or special
land use boundaries shall not be construed to be final and may be varied at
any subsequent approval phasa such as Final Platting or Site Development
Plan approval. Subject to the provisions of Section 2.7.3.5 of the Collier
County Land Development Coda, amendments may be made from time to
time.
B. All necessary easements, dedications or other Instruments shall be granted
to ensure the continued operation and maintenance of all service utilities and
all common areas in the project.
C. This PUD shall be subject to the Sunset Provisions of Section 2.7.3.4 of the
Land Development Code, Including development monitoring report
provisions.
22
i1:::ITl !\C. ~ "":'E;
- ",!':7;^i1Ue' _' =\'r
~1C' :).
6.4 WATER MANAGEMENT
A. Excavation permits will be required for the proposed lakes In accordance
with Division 3.5 of the Collier County Land Development Code. as
amended. Excavated material from the property is intended to be used
within the project site.
B. Detailed paving, grading and site drainage plans shall be submitted to
::ngineering Review Services tor review. No construction permits shall be
Issued unless and until approval of the proposed construction in accordance
with the submitted plans is granted by Engineering Review Services.
C. In accordance with the Rules of the South Florida Water Management
District (SFWlvlD). Chaplers 40E-4 and 40E-40. this project shall be
designed for a storm event of 3-day duration and 25-year frequency.
D. Design and construction of all improvements shall be subject to compliance
with the appropriate provisions of Division 3.2 of the Collier County Land
Development Code.
E. Prior to construction plans approval. the petitioner shall demonstrate legal
and physical evidence of a positive outfall for the water management
system.
F. The County reserves a 30 foot wide drainage easement along the western
property line for the future widening of Rattlesnake Hammock Road. to which
the developer does not object. Permit modifications or conditions, or
amendments or new permits required to accommodate the County's
drainage easement. including any mitigation, shall be the sole responsibility
of the County.
6.5 TRANSPORTATION
A. The developer shall provide a fair share contribution toward the capital cost
of a traffic signal at the intersection of CR 951 and the project entrance If and
when the County warrants the project. The signal will be owned, operated
and maintained by Collier County.
S. The developer shall provide arterial level street lighting at all project
entrances prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy.
C. Evidence of an FDOT Connection Permit or Notice of Intent to Issue a
Connection Permit shall be provided prior to the issuance of any
development permit for the project
23
["'-' : I ~
D.
The developer shall provide sidewalkslbikepaths along all PUD development
tract arterial roadway frontages at the time of final site development
permitting and construction for each phase and parcel of the PUD.
E.
At each development access driveway. an additional 12 feet is needed for
right turn lane facilities. Compensating right-of-way for turn lanes and
median areas shall be dedicated by the applicant to reimburse the County
lor the use of eXIsting nght-of-way prior to the issuance of the first
'permanent" Certificate of Occupancy. Sucn dedication shall be considered
site related, and there shall be no road impact fee credits to the appli::::am.
The applicant shall provide tc the County in fee simple ownership. a strip of
land 25 ieet in width along lhe entire length of the Rattlesnake Hammock
Road righI-ai-way for future four-lanlOg of Rattiesnake Hammock Road. In
excnange tor providing this additional right-at-way. the applicant shall be
eligible for road impact fee credits in accordance with the provisions of
Ordinance 92-22. as amended. The future right-of-way shall be made
available to the County either upon presentation of the plat for recording, or
within 120 days notice to the applicant by the County of the County's need
for the land. whichever occurs earlier. Road impact fee credits shall be
subject to a Developer Contribution Agreement approved by the Board of
County Commissioners. and shall be available tc the developer upon change
in title ownership of the subject contribulion.
6_6 UTILITIES
A. Water distribution. sewage collection and transmission facilnies to serve the
project are to be designed. constructed, conveyed, owned and maintained in
accordance with Collier County Ordinance 88-76, as amended, and other
applicable County rules and regulations.
6.7 ENGINEERING
A. Except as otherwise provided within this PUD document, this project shall be
required to meet all County Ordinances in effect at the time final construction
documents are submitted for development approval.
6.8 ENVIRONMENTAL
A. Environmental permitting shall be in accordance with the State of Florida
Environmental Resource Permit Rules and be subject to review and approval
by Current Planning Environmental Staff. Removal of exotic vegetation 8h811
not be counted towards mitigation for impacts to Collier County jurisdictlonel
wetlands.
24
-...';
B. All conservation areas shall be designated as conservation/preservation
tracts or easements on all construction plans and if the property is platted
shall be recorded on the plat with protective convenants per or similar to
Section 704.06 of the Florida Statutes. Buffers shall be provided in
accordance with Subsection 3.2.8.4.7.3 of the Land Development Code.
C. Buffers shall be provided around wetlands, extending at least fifteen (15) feet
landward from the edge of wetland preserves in all places and averaging
twenly-f1ve (25) teet from the landward edge of wetlands. Where natural
buffers are not possibie, stru::tural buffers shall be provided In ac~ordance
With the State of Flonda Environmental Resources Permit Ru~es and be
subject to review and approved b~i Current Planning environmental Staff.
D. Petitioner shall comply with the guidelines and recommendations of the U_S.
Fish & Wildlife Service (USFWS) and Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish
CommiSSion (FGFWFC) regarding potential Impacts to protected wildlife
species, Where protected species are observed on site. a Habitat
Management Plan for those protected species shall be submitted to Current
Planning Environmental Statffor review and approval prior to Final Site
Plan/Construction Plan approval.
E. An exotic vegetation removal, monitoring, and maintenance (exotic-free) plan
for the site. with emphasis on the conservation/preservation areas. shall be
submitted to Current Planning Environmental Staff for review and approval
prior to Final Site Plan/Construction Plan approval. This plan shall include
methods and time schedule for removal of exotic vegetation within the
conservation/preservation area.
F. The project shall comply with the environmental sections of the Land
Development Code and the Growth Management Plan in effect at the time of
final development order approval.
G. The 35_9-acre Consarvation Reserve Tract will serve to meet all Land
Development Code native open space requiremen18 for the Residential and
Commercial Tracts. A copy of the South Florida Weter Management District
Conservation Easement will be copied to Current Planning Environmental
Staff at the time of the first Site Development Plan approval.
25
EXHIBIT B
THE SIERRA MEADOWS PUD
MASTER PLAN
26
1.'-
.an_Dm1 "lUlUl1I'l--.r 'Il:lIat:DI
'.-_ ~J
-.,.... ~
"""'1/11- -----''--rt
~ -.' - ~...."'ij!lli.,...,
.""-
--
.=--=:--='_
f!)foIKDI!)~l~~'S1
NVid d3..LSVV\I
-O-n-d SMOO'v'3V>l 'v'<J<J3IS
::)-- S'
I'~, v''
"
ad: YmIN '1nCD:Jor.l W.WIllMld 1Jll... lUnll. lRr1 PlMI
-'....,.,
g; -S'
.;!: ~
~ >
~,~
~
.
0::. ::'::'~=':.-=T
! --~l:r
lit lift
(II f~'
~ ili
- IT
, ,~~'
';:~
~\
.,'
I
Ii
I
I
I
I
I
I
.'
II
Ii,
Ii
~ l i ill I
<iN ! ! II. I
~~~ Il-j I I III :
~E" I, . 1'1 .
!~~ j~ji I IIi. I
t~ I I It 1'1 :
~~s I I III ii II! '
~ ; "II Ii ; 111111 !! lib I
~ 111'11 u' 1111111
t I ul. !..h.1
STATE OF FLORIDA)
COUNTY OF COLLIER)
I I DWIG}.:T E, BRO::I:, Cle::-l~ of Court.s :..n and for ':he
Twentieth Jud.ic;.e.l Circuit, Collier County, Flo~ida, cia n'2re.bv
certif)" that :he foregoing is a true copy of:
ORDINW~CE NO. 99-91
Which was adopted by the Board of County Commissio~ekS 9f
:-r."; >..L.l
the 14th day of December, 1999, during Regular Session.
o
M
n
"'1
....,. r'0
WITNESS my hand and the official seal of the Board'6t ,~
~ 'r:; .._. ~'il
County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, this lSt:hdaii::of;..J
g~;? -
December, 1999. CI~ ~
>fTl
. J;;~ "~:'<';~'~:!>'~'~""""(' "\
DWIGHT E. BROCK~'::":>):;;~'~:_)~:_"':~>"I':"'.)( -""'~
Clerk of Courts and mil'lr)'iif'''''''', "'. _' \ :
Ex-officio ~o ~oaid[q~;'/~'~~t(;\~' ';~:" ~.- l',.
County Comml.sSl.Onerlil.;'~; t;::;,.::.;.'.~t: : i- ~ .'~
- 4"\ \{ ~~,:2~.j{ I i;~
r"ei.J",~ '4: 'i-..~..~<.."1~1''l'" <t!.~'(.'i":'I'
.,4." ....)..Iftr.'.:.;.r- ",(,,~;;::"_,~,':
':</', ,C),,),~',if.. "\')",,, ';.' ,
By: Ellie Hoffman, .~:. ':"" '""I i.-a.;;I...J~::".,:,." ,
1 ,\, "...",.."",
Deputy C erk ' .-':tti'
i,:,:';:-n [\Ie, -~
'\i(!\ .;::n-;:)::;";;,' ',1/
':,1':, c:-: ~,;:~;
RESOLUTION NO. 05 -402
A RESOLUTiON BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMiSSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA,
PURSUANT TO SECTION JO.02.i3.D. OF THE COLLIER
COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE AFFECTING
ORDINANCE NUMBER 99.91 KNOWN AS SIERRA
MEADOWS PUD, EXTENDING THE CURRENT PUD
APPROVAL TO DECEMBER 14, 2007; AND PROVIDiNG
AN EffECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, the Sierra Meadows PUD, Ordinance Number 99.91 adopted on December
14, 1999, is subject to the provisions of Section 10.02.13.0., of the Land Development Code
(LDC), Time Limits for Approved pun Zoning Districts, together with their respective Master
Plans; and
\VHEREAS, the pun was adopted consistent \'-lith and under the provisions of the Collier
County Growth Management Plan; and
V\.-THEREAS. the Board of County Commissioners has reviewed the PUD and has
determined to extend the current PUD Zoning for 2 years until Decemner 14. 2007; and
NOW. THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY. FLORIDA, that:
1, The above recitals are adopted herein by reference as if fully set forth herein.
') This Resolution shall constitute evidence of compliance with the review
requirements or Seclion I O.02.13.D. of the LDC.
3. Pursuant to said section of the LDC, the current PUD approval is hereby
extended to December 14, 2007; at the end of which time the owner shall
submit to the procedures in LDC Section lO.02.i3.D.
This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon its approval.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Resolution be recorded in the minutes of this
Board and in the records of the Petition for which the extension is granted.
This Resolution adopted after motion, second and majority vote.
,r; .
Done this /5' day of _ /\!(J'2,."d'(2005.
, ..",,::01;:,.; ".
ATl EST"".,~...,
..-~YfE". ...g~\, Cierk
~;',i. ~l~}L
~~ :;.... ~-,,6e'r. -yClerk
.,...(.,....". .....:........'
.~, /.;"''- '~~...~....~'\..."' ~~~
".",:,r~ (,:;'U~~, II"'"
Il/j'lljjillll,1
Approved as to Form and Legal Sufficiency:
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSiONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORlDA
By;
'1~w ~
FRED W. COYLE. CHA AN
~~Ih./);;;hd -/lUtb-,"<
Marj 'e M. Studen1~Stirling G
Assistant County Attorney
RESOLUTION 07-____.
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMNlISSIONGRS OF COLLIER COUNTY,
FLORIDA, PURSUANT TO SECTION 1O.02.13.D
OF THE COLLIER COUNTY LA-ND
DEVELOPMENT CODE, REQUESTING A TWO-
YEAR PUD EXTENSION FOR THE SIERRA
MEADOWS FUD (ORDINANCE NO. 99-91) WIIICH
IS SC!WDLJLED TO SUNSET ON DECEMBER 14,
2007, EXTENDING TIlE CURRENT PUD
APPROVAL TO DECEMBER 14, 2009; A.'ID
PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
\VHEREAS, the Sierra Mcadowfi PUD, Ordinance No. 99-91 adopted all Dcccmhc.r
14, 1 Sl9Y, is suhject In the provisions of Section lO,02.13.D., of the Land Development Corle
(LDC), Time limits/or approved PUDs; rmd
Wl-JEF~EAS, tbE: Sierr8 !vlr.~j(lows pun Vim: adaplcu consistent with and under lbe
pwvi~;ioll;'; of tile Coliier County Cimwth t\'l:mar'f:mem ?ian; and
\"'1.:sRE/'.S, l.lY hcsolution Nc. O.~-402, the Board of Call1lly CLlIIliIJissionen:
entJl(i~(l tile P'JL approval afkclillB CirulllamT I'h 99-91 until Dcc.cmb~r J4, 2007; and
"VllEREAS, the. Bonrd of County ComnJJ:';siol1~l's h<ls n-:Yl:",:vveci ilK-: PUD ;:md has
dcl~rrruIlCd il arpropriiJt~ to ilf'prnw ,1 tW(>-YC.HT PUT) cKtcnsjol1 fur the Sic.rm hkadows l'lJD
(OrdillllllC(', No, (l~L~)l), w]llch is Scllt:dubd to StlIlSI.:,[ on D~cem.bcr 14, 2007, until
Decemher )4, 2009.
NOW. THEREPORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY. FLORlIJ^, that:
1. The above recitals arc adopted herein by reference as if fully sct forth
hemin.
2. This Resolution shall C:OIl::titule evidence of compliance with (h~
review requirements of Seclion JO.02.1J.D. of the J ,DC.
3. Pur~uant to said section of the LDC, Ehe current PUD approval is
hereby eXEended to December 14, 2009; at the end of which time the
own-.:r shall tiubrnit to (hl~ procedures in LDC Se.ction 1O,02.13,D.
4. This ResoluEion shall he corne effective immediately upon it~ approval.
BE IT FURTHER H.ESOL VED that !hi~ Re.solmion hc recorded in the minutes of tbis
Board and in the record.:: of the Petition for which the extension is granll',d.
P<lg-e] 01'2
day of
,2007.
This Resolution arlopted after motion, second, and super-majority vote this
ATrEST:
DWIGHT E. BROCK. CLERK
By:
,D~pllty Clerk
Appr lved a.<; to fonn
andll:;aJ~ fi c':
~I' '
"
J dire J.ltA. iG.~tlJ w
Chief lssistant : unty Attorney
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY FLORlDA
ny:
JAMES COLETTA. CHAlRMAN
Page 2. of 2
.~
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Request that the Board of County Commissioners Adopt an Ordinance to
Regulate Security of Certain Convenience Store Businesses to Protect the
Physical Security of Convenience Business Retail Employees and
Individuals who Patronize such Businesses.
OBJECTIVE: That the Board of County Commissioners ("Board") consider and
adopt an Ordinance to authorize the Sheriff's Office personnel to enforce
specified security measures to try to protect the physical security of convenience
business retail employees and individuals who patronize such businesses,
including security measures and training of retail employees.
CONSIDERATIONS: Florida's "Convenience Business Security Act" requires
specified. security measures regarding convenience store businesses and
required training of convenience store retail employees. Although state
employees are authorized to enforce the Act, that staff has too few personnel to
adequately enforce the Act throughout Florida. Local enforcement is in the public
interest and will facilitate prompt eiimination of avoidable threats to the safety of
visitors to, and employees of, convenience stores.
~
On November 13, 2007, the Board of County Commissioners approved the
advertisement of the attached ordinance for consideration on 11/27/07. Similar
ordinances have been adopted in many Florida counties and municipalities. The
Ordinance authorizes Sheriff's Office personnel to locally enforce the Act's
provisions.
FISCAL IMPACT: The recommended Ordinance will have no fiscal impact.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There will be no growth management
impact associated with enactment of this Ordinance.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This Ordinance has been approved by the County
Attorney's Office and by the Sheriff's legal staff.
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners adopt the
attached Ordinance to authorize Sheriff's personnel to locally enforce Florida's
"Convenience Business Security Act" for the protection of patrons and retail
employees of convenience stores.
PREPARED BY: Michael Hedberg, Esquire, Captain, Legal Services, Collier
County Sheriff's Office
-
!'age 1 of J
COLLIER COl''ITV
C~j0m; -:!' ~(JU:_,', c,':,\!':-,I~:;,;:nr,~[r:;;
Item Number:
ItemSummilry:
H;;e",
,,' ;T'
. ")" J ~11 f' ", c' ,; I ,,1'1'
"'~'U' I:' ("'.: I" 'I~(
2r'(' ';;']11:',
Meeting Date:
ry;.V
Prepllrell R~
!'.:;".'
'::'cr""j('-"H",i,c,,','.-,wn'
::..,'"
;,0'.1'1;' ,1',(""rn
(" '!','/'.tTH""'"
'1,::::m"'1~j.;",f.'
ApprHH'd H~
,,,W,
Vc<,.(I(
I""
""ic
-.a,,'" U,wn',
. '''-'~! ~wc",.
; 'j ,'~0n
'-'~-
Apprnvell Hy
(~i ',' Cf,"""'..w"
i,.,p",',".,., !'.nJi>
'J,t(
i'. c.,," rw;:,-m,'.'C'o,[>rv'cr,,'
i''''''',.~i ' -...~cr'
"'.c. r_'~"
'\pprOHO II~
-'t_
Apl'r"""d 11\
ORDINANCE NO. 2007 -
AN ORDINANCE OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, CALLED THE COLLIER
COUNTY CONVENIENCE BUSINESS SECURITY ORDINANCE, PROVIDING
DEFINITIONS; SPECIFYING CONVENIENCE BUSINESS SECURITY
REQUIREMENTS; REQUIREMENTS TO TRAIN RETAIL EMPLOYEES;
ENFORCEMENT AND CIVIL FINES; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICT AND
SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR INCLUSION IN THE CODE OF LAWS
AND ORDINANCES; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, Section 812.1725. Florida Statutes, authorizes Florida counties to
adopt an ordinance regarding convenience business security provided the
ordinance does not differ from Section 812.173, Flonda Statutes. ("Convenience
Business Security Measures") and Section 812.174, Florida Statutes, ("Training
of Retail Employees"); and
WHEREAS, the Collier County Sheriffs Office IS recommending that this
Ordinance be adopted to authorize local enforcement of Florida's "Convenience
Business Security Act" (Sections 8~2.1701 through 812.175, Florida Statutes);
and
WHEREAS, this Ordinance complies with rlorida's "Convenience Busmess
Security4.ct:" and
WHEREAS, the Coliler County Board of County CommiSSioners agrees with the
Collier County Sheriffs Office recommendation that it will be In the best interests
of retail employees of convenience businesses in Collier County that Florida's
Convenience Business Security Act be enforced throughout Collier County
pursuant to this OrdInance.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA that a new Article VI in
Chapter 26 of the Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collier County is hereby
created to read as follows:
SECTION ONE. TITLE.
This Ordinance is and may be cited as the "Collier County Convenience
Business Security Ordinance."
SECTION TWO: DEFINITIONS.
"Convenience business" means any place of business that is pnmarily engaged
in the retail sale of groceries, or both groceries and gasoline, and that is open for
business at any time between the hours of 11 :00 p.m. and 5:00 a.m. The term
"Convenience Business" does not include:
(a) A business that is solely or primarily a restaurant.
(b) A business that always has at least five (5) employees on the premises after
11 :00 p.m. and before 5:00 a.m.
(c) A business that has at ieast -10,000 square feet of retaii tioor space.
':'::J:
(d) A business in which the owners or members of the owner's family work in
the respective business premises between the hours of 11 :00 p.m. and 5:00 a.m.
"CCSO" means the Collier County Sheriff's Office.
"CBI" means any individual employed by the CCSO who has been certified as a
"Convenience Business Inspector."
"Retail Employee" means an employee of a convenience business who in the
course of such employment can be exposed to assault, bodily injury or death
from any individual in a convenience business premises at any time.
SECTION THREE: Convenience Business Security Requirements.
(1) Every convenience business shall be equipped with the following security
devices and standards:
(a) A security camera system capable of recording and retrieving an image to
assist in offender identification and apprehension.
(b) A drop safe or cash management device for restricfed access to cash
receipts.
(c) A lighted parking lot illuminated at an intensity of at least two (2) foot-
candles per square foot at eighteen (18) inches above the surface
(d) A conspicuous notice at the entrance that stales the cash register contains
fifty dollars ($50) or less.
(e) Window signage that allows a clear. unobstructed view from outside the
building, including a clear line of sight of the cash register and the sales
transaction area.
(I) Height markers at the entrance of the convenience business that display
height measurements of individuals who enter the interior through the entrance.
(g) A cash management policy to limit the cash on hand at all times after 11 :00
p.m.
(2) A convenience business shall not have window tinting that reduces exterior or
interior view in a normal line of sight.
(3) Every convenience business shall be equipped with a silent alarm to law
enforcement or a private security agency, unless application for an exemption is
made to and granted by Florida's Attorney General. An application for exemption
must be in writing and must be accompanied by an administrative fee of twenty-
five dollars ($25) for each store for which the exemption would apply.
(4) If a murder. robbery, sexual battery, aggravated assault, aggravated battery,
kidnapping or false imprisonment. as those crimes are the identified and then
defined by Florida Statutes, occurs or has occurred at a convenience business
after July 1, 1989, and arises out of the operation of the convenience business,
such convenience business shall implement at least one (1) of the following extra
security measures:
(a) Provide at least two (2) empioyees on the premises at all times after 11 :00
p.m. and until 5:00 a.m.;
2
(b) Install for use by employees at all times after 11 :00 p.m. and until 5:00 a.m..
a secured safety enclosure of transparent polycarbonate or other material that
meets at least one (1) of the following minimum standards:
(i) American Society for Testing and Materials Standard 03935 (classification
PC110 B 3 0800700). has a thickness of at least 0.375 inches, and has an
impact strength of at least two hundred (200) foot pounds; or
(ii) Underwriters Laboratory Standard UL 752 for medium power small arms
(level one) Bullet Resisting Equipment;
(c) Provide a security guard on the premises at all times after 11 :00 p.m. and
until 5:00 am.;
(d) Lock the business premises throughout the hours from 11 :00 p.m. until 5:00
a.m., and transact business only through an indirect pass-through trough,
trapdoor, or window; or
(e) Close the business at all times after 11 :00 p.m and until 5:00 a.m.
(5) For purposes of this Section, any convenience business that by law has then
implemented any of the extra security measures set forth in paragraphs (4)(a)~
(e), above, and has maintained such extra measures without any Dccurren::::e or
incidence of any of the crimes identified by Subsection (4), above, for a period of
at least twenty-four (24) months immediately preceding the firing of a notice of
exemption, may file with a CBI employed by the CCSO. a notice of exemption
from the extra security measures. In no event shall this exemption be interpreted
to preclude full compliance with the security measures set forth in Subsection (4),
above, should any occurrence or incidence of any crimes Identified by
Subsection (4), above, cause that Subsection to again become applicable.
(6) For the mutual convenience of the business and each investigating officer,
each convenience business is encouraged to maintain and have readily available
in the transaction area a red three ring binder ("Red Book") to include the
foliowing items:
(a) Inspection Log, maintained for the immediate past two (2) years'
inspections, including the inspection results:
(b) A copy of the business' then current local BUSiness Tax Receipt (formerly
called an Occupational License);
(c) An annuai test photograph taken by the securrry camera system and that
shows an identifiable image (to assist in offender identification and
apprehension);
(d) A Maintenance Log of the security camera system that verifies the
maintenance performed not less than once every four (4) consecutive months.
Upon request. the CCSO will provide the requestor an example Camera Test and
Maintenance Log;
(e) The convenience business' written cash management policy that limits cash
on hand at all times from 11 :00 p.m. until 5:00 a.m. Upon request. the CCSO will
provide the requestor a copy of the CCSO's example Cash Management Policy;
3
w::,';.""J.., ,..
(I) Documented proof that confirms the training (specified below) has been
provided to and learned by each retail employee within sixty (60) days of the
initial employment of each such retail employee. including daters) of such training
for each such employee; and
(g) A copy of the then current Florida's Convenience Business Security Act
(currently Sections 812.1701 through 812.176. Florida Statutes).
SECTION FOUR: Required Training for all Convenience Business' Retail
Employees.
The owner or principal operator of each convenience business, applied to each
premises of the retail convenience business, shall provide to each retail
employee a proper robbery deterrence and safety training by Florida Attorney
General approved curriculum within sixty (60) days of the date of such
employee's initial employment. Upon request. the CCSO will provide a copy of
an example document titled "Robbery Prevention and Awareness Training
Handbook" that specifies a training program that has many times been
"approved" by the Attorney General. The convenience business' original training
curri::ulum shall be submitted in writing to the Attorney Genera: and shall be re-
submitted bienmally to the Attorney General for fe-approval. The application fee
shall be as then speCified in Section 812.174, Florida Statutes, or its successor.
SECTION FIVE: Enforcement; Civil fines.
(1) Any certified Convenience Business Inspector ("CBI") employed by the
Collier County Sheriffs Office (CCSO) is authOrized by this Ordinance to
investigate any alleged violation of this Ordinance. Violation of any provision of
this Ordinance by any owner or principal operator of a convenience business
shall result in a notice of violation from such CBI. The noticed violator shall have
thirty (30) days after receipt of such notice to provide proof to the CBI that the
violator has complied with all requirements stated in such notice. If the violation
continues after that thirty (30) day period, the CBI may refer the case to Collier
County Code Enforcement for enforcement. The Director of Code Enforcement,
or the assigned Code Enforcement Special Master, if applicable. may suspend
imposition of any fine in his/her discretion up until an order imposing a fine has
been issued. After an order imposing a fine has been issued, fine reductions
shall be controlled by Chapter 162. Florida Statutes, and applicable Coliier
County Ordinances. No such notice, fine. or fine reduction, shall be subject to
any provision of Chapter 120, Florida Statutes.
(2) The CCSO or Collier County's Code Enforcement Department personnel shall
have full power and authority to petition a court of law for an injunction if it is
determined by the CBI, the Director of Code Enforcement, or by the Code
Enforcement Special Master, if applicable. that the health, safety, or public
welfare is threatened by continued operation of a convenience business in
4
-,"1";:'
violation of this Ordinance. In any action for such an injunction, the petitioner
may seek a civil penalty not to exceed five thousand dollars ($ 5,000) per
violation, plus attorney's fees and costs.
SECTION SIX: CONFLICT AND SEVERABILITY
In the event this Ordinance conflicts with any other Ordinance of Collier
County or other applicable law, the more restrictive shall apply. If any phrase or
portion of this Ordinance is held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of
competent jurisdiction. such portion shall be deemed a separate. distinct and
independent provision and such holding shall not affect the validity of the
remaining portions.
SECTION SEVEN. INCLUSION IN THE CODE OF LAWS AND ORDINANCES.
This Ordinance shall be made a part of the Code of Laws and Ordinances
of Collier County, Florida. The sections of the Ordinance may be renumbered or
relettered to accomplish that result. and the word "Ordinance' may be changed to
"Section," "Arti::::Je" or any other appropriate word
SECTION EIGKT. EFC'ECTIV= OAT!:::
This Ordinance shall be effective upon filing with the Florida Department
of State.
PASSED AND DULY ADOPTED by the Board of County Commissioners
of Collier County, Fiorlda, thiS ~ day of ,2007.
ATTEST:
Dwight E. Brock, Clerk
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
Deputy Clerk
James Coletta, Chairman
APpr~s to fQ1nd legal sufficiency
BY:d""'^- ,~
Tho as C. Palmer,
Assistant County Attorney
5