CSRM Agenda 11/08/2023i
Co ter C0-ynty
Growth Management
Community Development Department
Collier County Coastal Storm Risk Management Feasibility Study Advisory
Motion to Ajourn:
Committee
Wednesday, November 8, 2023
2:30 PM
Collier County GMCDD Building — Room 609/610
AGENDA
1. Approval of previous meeting minutes from July 26, 2023
2. Open discussion regarding the status of the CSRM Feasibility Study
Time Ajourned:
9.A.2
Packet Pg. 282
cu
E
0
V
i
N
Q
3
.N
Li
W
w
f50
N
R
E
L
0
Ln
N
f�
V
;uawOftueW ASIU WJO;S le;seOO : L8ZLZ) ul u6IS a8};IwwO3 £ZOZ'8'66 QOH pad UYUSO :;uawLiOe;;d
O
rl
�D
M
O
�D
E
0
0
c�
L
0
V
I
i
Q%
E
m
0.
C
G1
N
00
m
Y
Cm
G
s
a..
O
L.
s`
i
dA
wA
W
a-+
E
E
V
W
0
�
v
J
J
_�
3
of
ho
C
c
G1
H
L
QC
C1
7-�
`
~
�
t
�
3
m
Z
y
v
vi
M
00
N
a
Y
V
m
c a (Q L
L D
41 mM a) Y
E E GJ
O u
t u
c O O
O L c
s y O
O. .
vi E O
t C
GJ N t+ i+
O > E
L m L
m Q• M o
E v } m
� v
m L
L
0 L Q
Q Q Gl
a! > C of
-O r O n
3 E >.
n o ,o c
c c c c
O t u
y u G/
E 3 r
u T oa OD
w c c
=p _Y
Q. >L v
u u
� � C U
m E f0
O
c v c 3
m E Z,
U c m
v d d u
>
O O O
Q. to m O
o m u Q
o r
-ca > v � o
L y O N
M
L ci m
7 u '^ O-
o c 3
Y 0 o c
m ° m
C Ou u O
3 t'
0 u a O
m 3
3 VA O
+' Q w L
41 > 7
t 'y O
m u >
K H ` c
v
> Q N
O m u +>+
41 +, 41 i C
� m E a.+
7
w E O `- u
`Q s O C1
C •C C
a M m
* a v
H u 3
E
O
L
0
a
N
m
w
to
5m
G
N
CC
E
O
CA
m
V
Al!llglsea=l }ueme6eueW )jsib uaao;S le;seOO : L8ZLZ) ul uBiS ollgnd £ZOZ'8U ooH PV WUSO WOLuyoelIV
i�
0
a-i
lD
0
O
E
0
0
w
cu
u
C
G1
L
C
0
u
I
44
C
t
m
B.
a,
4-0
G1
w
QA
m
44
0
V
l
o
J
J
Q
W
V
0
✓
�
S
3
`'
_
`J
�
J
V?
to
i
LA
7
AO
J
ZLu
La
2
V
00
N
Cb
IL
� N �
IL
i
N m Y
E a) 0 G1
u
t w
N L O
C O C
O L o
L GJ
fl.
Vf E O
c'r o
LA
v o E
a s ,0
Vj 3 C
E v >- r,
y C
O
C
LA m
L
L v Y O
O ` � aH
�So�
r
3 E Y
00 O ,° C
C C C 3
N o O
E oo (mA
u T 00 to
v C C
O =p Y
a �? y
W Cu C u
wo
m E
c ,2 v
E 3
N
U i L f0
N N v u
p > L G1
- O O
O. OD f6 O
n l6 u O.
r n o
sa
� O 41 � �
bn y Q r
Gl ` (6
3 u O_
o c
T O o c
+r H u
o u p
0 L -0 O
7
O u O. C
N -0 m 3
3 H O
Q. G1 L
QJ > 3
t i y O
H f0 v T
O
G/
r+ N r
C � coi Y
O C
•' OE'
E E w ou
L O ou
O t Gl
• ca ca
® a
;ueweBeueW )ISIN WJ04S IeMOD : L8ZLZ) EZOZ, L, L 6 sn3e3S Apn3S WMS3 :;uauayoej4V
lu
M
U
a
L U)
v > O
cn
U
0
a
a�
� W
0
U
�' o O,
Ln
W
0
N
O O
o,C/)
ui
N
i
O
=cn
cn
L
X
4 "O
FD
O
V
cA
U
Cl)O
N
a
W
_�
to
O y
O
�a�a
'N
0
_O
00co
�3
as
_c°
mm.�a
E��o�
O
cn
Q
cam
�a
°Nam
C
MU)
�--�
.��
L.
0—
N M
O
m
Z'm
s°
O
V
U
Z
0
i
L
Q O
N
Oa
O
Z2z0
M
m O
m
m
0
W
z
z
O
u
LU
a.
4u8w96euelN Is21 LUJ04S le;seOD : L8ZLZ) £ZOZ'L'LL sn;e3S Apn3S VyNSO :;uewgoel4V
�0/� \
c�
E
X
O O
0-
0
N
c6
N
N —
U C:
m
a
Z
O
L.L E
4-0
0
E
Q O
O O
U O
E
a) 4-
c
a)
> U
= EF
j
C
N a)
O >
O
O Q
o
O
U �
O �
U) O
N _0
~ .O
CDo
s
a)
CO c�
co
i
(�
_\
W
^�
O
O
U
o
uj
O
co
0
O
cn�
SO)
�_
ti
0
Q M
Qi d
�
Q) Z , a) y
CO
`— O N
O N a
a' 7:z co
CL
+�+
Z
a�
L
w
a)
�
i+
•>
C:
�
N
CD
N
>+
>1
•>
C: �
�
CD04 m
'
Q
�cn
0
O
L
a
-
H
O
w
i
U
Q
^^O
L
�
0
a
-
c cn
a)
cn
0
Qo
o
�
� U
cn
tm
w
0) O
— 0)
U
��
•v
Q
o
mmo
E
as
U5
LU
J
0
W
Z
oowft%
In
LU
a.
M
%%M/
Q
v5
J
Ln (n >% a)
4u9w86eueW )Islb wao;S le;seOO : LOZLZ) EZOZ•4.66 sn;e;S Apn3S WN
�U o
• Q N li U
000
r-
O
N a) N
CD N �_ U_ cu
LL d ry
a�
M
le o m
o a) ry
N O U
In M
N 0 0-
C
co
CD> a) CO
Q
m � _
(6
C (U-
O C
"= O
` O O m
L
Q
O O (6
N Q C
C N (6 O 'T
N U O
V 4
Q 0— c'M EF} i/i
CD
Z
W
W
2
Q
F—
x
W
Z
4u9wGBL'ueW Mslb wJo;S ILIMOO : L8ZLZ) £ZOZ-L-64 sn3e;S Apn3S WNSO :;u
O
LL
Z
L•J
M
V*
N
(a
r
•
M
N
N
5
co
C:
N
�
E
^WU^11
u7
N
i
N
-0
co
a)
N
0
-0
E
o
Z
>,
-0
a)
4u8w96euelN Is21 wJ04S le;seOD : L8ZLZ) £ZOZ•L•LL sn3e3S Apn4S VyMSO :4uewgoel4v
m
Q
T
w
w
O: 0
a) o
Q °
�.. Q 0 cn
.� (3)U _ow
(o +r U
ftft% _ °
° a) �� `� cod' C: � N E
a) _
.. E�ca'� �o 0
y o o M a) —
cz o CO 4-
Lu
cn 4-0
> -
�oa)> 4�
V a)
Z 4-0 L ,
7 o o a) ° can
Z
WW
I.+ ° E � N
00 U) 0N ��, y
o c�
�o�
a) o a) O
ZZ �Oc�� Q�
W W o}, �'� �� O
W �+
-0 CD
a E (�
� Q O
E3
_ 0 o =0 Lu a) as
ph
�.
9.A.7
Collier County Government
Communications, Government & Public Affairs
3299 Tamiami Trail E., Suite 102
Naples, Florida 34112-5746
July 11, 2023
zl�
colliergov.net
twitter.com/CollierPIO
facebook.com/CollierGov
youtube.com/CollierGov
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Notice of Public Meeting
Collier County Coastal Storm Risk Management Feasibility Study Advisory Committee
Collier County, Florida
July 26, 2023
1:00 P.M.
Notice is hereby given that the Collier County Coastal Storm Risk Management Feasibility Study
Advisory Committee will meet on Wednesday, July 26, 2023, at 1:00 p.m. in Conference Room 609/610 of
the Growth Management Department building, 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr, Naples, Florida.
About the public meeting:
Two or more members of the Board of County Commissioners may be present and may participate at the
meeting. The subject matter of this meeting may be an item for discussion and action at a future Board of
County Commissioners meeting.
All interested parties are invited to attend, and to register to speak. All registered public speakers will be limited
to three minutes unless changed by the chairman.
Collier County Ordinance No. 2004-05 requires that all lobbyists shall, before engaging in any lobbying
activities (including, but not limited to, addressing the Board of County Commissioners, an advisory board or
quasi-judicial board), register with the Clerk to the Board at the Board Minutes and Records Department.
Anyone who requires an auxiliary aid or service for effective communication, or other reasonable
accommodations in order to participate in this proceeding, should contact the Collier County Facilities
Management Division, located at 3335 Tamiami Trail E., Suite 101, Naples, Florida 34112, or (239) 252-8380,
as soon as possible, but no later than 48 hours before the scheduled event. Such reasonable accommodations
will be provided at no cost to the individual.
For more information, call Christopher Mason at (239) 252-2932.
Packet Pg. 311
Apn;S Al!llglsea=l;uawa6eueW Ms21 w-101S MSeOO : L8ZLZ) ul uBIS 0011lu wOO WUS:D :;uauayae;;V
S
fib
CL
4A
E
E
V
A./ t
Q
I
r
v
vi
�1
W
Q
J
bn
V
O
+�
J
N
h
M
�1
Q
J
E
c
J
Q
3
4d
m
Z
,
^•
\9
V
N
M
8�
a
m
ra
L a
� � Y
E OU1
O O u
c t r
N L O
c 0 c
O L 0
L G!
a M +_
vi E O
N i
m
6 m L
m O. t �O
0�
3 ai
m y «�
m - ' v
N aL. O
LL 7 O 41
L O �•
i� 0
f0 m 3
3 E T
ao o ,0
a a C u
o
m
0
v
E p (mA
u T OA w
= 5 c
� � Y
O. u3 U
U
to
3 y�
7 m E
H
w
p O c N
a m m o
to m U Q
r o r
ea
-a
o
L
OQ wu ti M
` L Li m
13
n.
o c 3
T O 0 c
1A U •
m L m
C O
d 0
7 ♦+
O U CL c
O
T
G/ O
M � y
m 4J L
E ° w �
0 s v
c .5 I
a i v
Apn;S A;lllglsea=l;ueme6eueW 31sib uaao;S le;seoo
,Q N
N �
LL �'
� C
W
tw
Sm
G
N
OC
E
S—
o
Ln
fa
N
V
O
ri
tD
O
l�
E
O
O
v
u
C
C �
O S
V
C
a
E
t O
M
s
= a
G1
w
to
m
C
Sm
G
s
L
LBZLZ) ollgnd ul uBIS a;;;luauao3 WUSO :;uauayoe;;y
c
v
,
>
v
S
L
V
W
�
V
((^�^
V J
�w
W/
N
,J
O
l
J
\
V
Tik
CQA
J
L
'I
6
Z
V
`�
M
r-
M
a
a�
c v d
m L
v
O1 f0 Y
E E N
C O u
s ,�
GJ L O
C O O
O O
t G1
vi E CL
N c t o
a a Y
a o > E
m s s ,o
m c
E �+
N m
m E m
L
i Qi Y O
O V
4J T C •Vf
c Y
� m m
3 E T
ao o
c c 0
GYi O t u
a
E 0 3 s
u T bD Oo
m
O u
a �? v
u
O C u
r0 to �n
7 m E f0
O w 41
E Oo
3
U a
N
O d N u
L QJ
O O
CL M
0 m u a
3
at+ � O •_
c 0� p
1 ++ c
.O .d
pOp y ITaj
a0+
N L Cl f0
U H Q-
O C 3
Y 'A u
U .0 Y
C u O
u d O
u a c
O
a a
01 >
r " Z O
* y m u T
iF of c
2 r T
dY VI Y
coo o to u y
w E O u
w
O t 'O N
C � as+
a � m
v v r
14
Al!l!giseod ;ueweBLuew ilsiN uaao;S le;seoo : L8ZLZ) ssa3oad ApnjS a:ovs 1 :;uewt4oLuv
•
6 1 M=
L
•
.�m V.
s �
_ W
•
Ln
M
a
d
Ad
a
Al!l!giseod ;ueweBLuew ilsiN uaao;S le;seoo : L8ZLZ)
ssa°oad ApnIS a:ovs 1 :;uauay°euv
o
ca
M
Q
�
Y
Cc
O
y
y
..........
= y
cC y
.......................4)
..............
3... : .............................�
z.
Qa
C(10MM
O
V
L
________________
C
-0
....
1
0
V
0
V
V
•fq
i
i
Ui
•(Ii
i
L
in
�
�c/�)
LLI
�'.........
(1
Q
Q
J
N
N
ns
.. c� •••.
Vj
°
Q
Y
A;!I!gisea=l }uowoBeuew Isis{ wJO4S le}seo:: 18ZLZ) ssaDoad Apn}S 3ovsn :}uowLjoe}}d
o ti
Q - rf 7f'4i� f•..
a
o wO s ..
r Q
M
L
2 0 �
a� LC) -
a� too
N
A
�CL
W
E'
O � 1
4.0
O G� ,
C N J > --
Ln 0o Ln O
M N L •
00 �� •
s ��
V _O
Q � "
O-- M i i '
u04
CD
� a
cn a � V Ri : •
o a o
U O cn •
O .�
O t
'> K _
Al!liglsea=l }uauaa6euew Isib uaao}S lelseoo : L8ZLZ) ssaooad Apn}S 3ovsn wauayaeuv
•
Rj
d
Y
y
7
L
.4
14
�M
O y
0
M
a
d
Ad
a
o_
o
�-
co
o�
�
=3�
0
(n
•%
•L
�_
•cn
•%
•L
�_
N
z���0cn
�/��
W
woo
J
Q
e
w
!^.
w
a
4
0 1 CE-412
W �
c.� ,o
ao
(n N � O
N M __
= coo
z
Q�
y
.N
1\
'
L
06Uor`
w
06
lu-I 2
0
CD
a = >,oa
CD M
E co ++
aco�c.i
IMI
Al!l!giseod ;ueweBLuew ilsiN uaao;S le;seoo : L8ZLZ) ssa3oad ApnjS a:ovs 1 :;uewt4oLuv
O
d
V)
r
4+
u
0
LP
C
VJ
viF.
� C
L
o 0) wi
C Z
N Lw
� C C
Lo
a �
IA
a� (V
aj N
� G
4
u
N
41
C
U �
4
n-
N CL n.
cu M 111
6.
CIL
Lfl
N U)
LA
4 LL
U
L
a ++
w 4 �
aj CL 4-1
N
u
u
N
M
6)
IL
CL
La
C �
C e
a}
L1 Y
C�-
C v
m cu a 0
aEr
i
i
I
i
i
a
`i L u
M
--------------------------------------------------------------------
� c
�
L7
e �
a LL
0 t
.(u
a)
q E
0
LL
C 0
0
C C
d
m a t
L C 4
Cfl
}�
by
A0
0
t G 0
�
sD
D
3 0
W
U C� 0.
N vi
'� C
4J
0
`�
a p
C
ry
rj =
CC
O� +�
0
m
}. m
C �
4J
n
N
a�
H
�
rl
aai
c
`J
+, N
CLN C
'L
+� v. 4-1
G7 G7
m 4
G
*�'
C
[I�
G7 0 u
u C
�i
4 m
4J p
o
�7 L L
,�
}ti 4! yti 4I
G + - C 4 � a
,N a w i a ae ,0) a" a C ,� a 4 r LL
N LL. N � 6- C_ Q 0 C �
0 C G M fr G y ,2 N U�
u U u qj U � z � 2 p LL
V ;A i
y
V
O
O
Ow
CL r
4) O
L �
s�
�CL
�s
L �
� O
W
O
`~ O
s�
V .-
i
� O
CL
CD
V
-
O
m
ANNA
4�
E
E
r.
O
O
v.L
W
,>
O
•-
L
�
o
0
�
O
O
cn
_
i
L
m
a
,O
a
O
m
H
y
A
El
y
V
O
r.
•O
MEME
N
._
0�
0
p
O
0.
O
�
O
ENEM
M
ca
m
0
O
M
.O
O
�
�
L
�
O
Cr
i
�
Cq
ma
O
=
N
E
•ENEM
�••+
}/
■ ENEM
V
• -
w \
W
•_
• 0
0
I-
.0
Q
0
R
r.
a
O
f+
yll
r.
E
0
cma
L
■ENEM
m
r.
.Q
ENEM
ma
ca
t
a
a�
� •o
L L
m
> i
o
M
E
O
L +�
ca
,0
ENEM
�+ MOOO'O ■
� L
v N
O 0 CD
V •- N
� � Q
•-
EMENEM
oC
V Q�
� v
MOMMEN r ,�
Ow
6 C
O L
Ua
e
a`�
W
no
1�t
yr,
�
y
Q
N
■A
y
OCc
IL
y..k.
N
a
.Lr)
LL
4-j
c
4uauaa6euew Isib W-104S le;seOO : L8ZLZ) £ZOZ'9Z'L u04e;uasa.ad WbgO :4uOwLl3el4V
4-+
N
N
`
E
•+-
.
N
�T
N
O
+-
N
N
O
i
O
�
M
j
+-j
k4-
a--+
O
(n
(%)
cMU��
U
+,
°
u
a)
E
o
U
LL
U
U
a_
o
o
>
,
,
w
0
s
00
�
0
N
M
U
�
°
Ln
N
c)
N
-0
N
O
nU
O
0
O
c
OC/-)
m
N
cn
"
N
m
N
c6
N
cn
Al
,as
Ir•,
U)
W
H
+-j
E
N
U)
i2
E
L
0
V)
m
U)
m
4uawa6euew Isib wJo;g MseoO : L8ZLZ) £ZOZ'9Z'L u04B4u8s9ad WbgO 4uOwLj3ej4v
ti
N
_ M
_ a
41
� � Y
3 !T d
J N �
0
N
�
�
v
v
m
ca
a
'a
m
a�
o
o
CD
CL
00
�
>1�
i ❑
cn
c
N
❑ I
C
C
N
m
T3
O
m N
�
CU
N
C[3
cn
-�
0
�
E
U]
0
U
o
`o
'O
�,
c
m
E
c�
m
°
_
N
i
U7
E
vw
O
c�
0-
cy
E
E
c3
❑
z
D
0
L
N
eY3
0
IN
L
Q
'M-
A
4uauaa6eueW Asib WJ04S le;seOO : L9ZLZ) £ZOZ'9Z'L u01MUOSOM WbSO :4u9wLl3el4V
•
•
ra,
.
• o
•
•
�J
•
r
• • r N.Ln
m
u
c
a�
E
m
0
a�
m a
E 70
o 2
� 0
m
aD
U O -0
C
47 m
m L E
L
.01
C V
mI
to
ca
�mE
� ro
U O E V
C C } O V,
m Q
(ts co
� LL
p �� , Z
U z J ro ED Z
l
L
U T
� � L
o z o
d ,
Q Q
m 0 z 0
c
Q
c
c
m
0-
cn
cn
m
a
E
m
x
m
U
0
7
O
co
m
4uauaa6euew Isib W-104S le;seOO : L8ZLZ) £ZOZ'9Z'L u04e;uasa.ad WbgO :4uOwLpej4v
c O
N E O
wo-
M7
A
A
EM
L
— N
n
m
>1
N
•+�
Ln
4
N
}' O
w
O �
•a-=�
E
N
c6
c4-ji�
X
s
N
O
cn +—j
O
p
N s
M
>
0
>
n
O
U
c6
M
p I-+-
V
N
O
4-j
s s
}' U
�
•_
�,
Q)
D
U
E
z
4uauaa6eueW Asib WJ04S le;seOO : L9ZLZ) £ZOZ'9Z'L u01MUOSOM WbSO :4u9wLl3el4V
0 `1
v I
O
E
-10
c
—
W
W
_
W
�nn,,
E
W
U
C/�
},
—
•+J
06
z�s
o
4-j
6 „
�
N
�X.1
•L
M
—0
O
L
m
M
73
zQ)u
M
c
—_
4
U)
c6
.
M
O
�
�\
W
LL
N
N
N Q
U
—0
E
�
p
O
U—
°o
O
s
z��
�
•�
z
o
0
_
Q)
E
\
(6
c
O
O
N
O
cJ)
M
Q
v
O
C6
�
00
—
N
E
L
u
{
W
t�
O
CU aj
U -—"
D
Q\)
/
ZA
L
L
O
e
,c
N
U
—0
v
O
O F= O
N
O
00
U
cCr>1E
cu
Q
—
x
YS
�
L =
w a � y
GJ
Qi/--^�
Oai
�
u�
E,
Ln
•�
,F=
U
s=.__
L
+-j
o
=
a
O
Q0�_
sba [-d (U :�
L
nO
W
^X
W
0
O
O
u
o
O
U
QZ3
O
O-L
O
•—
CL
C
4uauaa6eueW Asib WJ04S le;seOO : L9ZLZ) £ZOZ'9Z'L u01MUOSOM WbSO :4u9wLl3el4V
Q)
�
a'
cn
U/
O
�
j
T
Q)
Q
cn
O
Q
O
+1
cn
0
�
N
V'
U
s
p
N
Q
p
U)
0
:3
4
p>
Q)
U)
s
0
Q
Q)
%4-
UU
L
Q)
+J
>
S
S
T
O
•�
Us��
TOE
��
U
U)
U
�
s
�'
U
U
O
�
}'
O
O
Q)
�Q)
�O
Q'M
�CQ
-t
Q
( `/
Q)
�
l l
u)
]L
V I
L
Q)
S
C6
U)
O
�
s
O
-
U)
a)
o
CD
o
: >
-
U
�
},
a)
�
4
�,
E
p
O
C6
U
W
O
0-
E
cn
O
W
w
(n
Q)
i
O
Q)
c-
Q)
S
Q)
O
(D
U
a)
O
o
,
4-1
O
E
N
-
U)
s
�
c6
O
O
O
U�
Q)
�cn<
N
L
0
LL
s
CL
4uauaa6eueW Asib WJ04S le;seOO : L9ZLZ) £ZOZ'9Z'L u01MUOSOM WbSO :4u9wLl3el4V
CD
O
N
4-j
Q
O
Q
O
NLO
Ocq
N
O
Z
O
O
N
Q
c�
O
E
E
E
E
Q
O
U
O
U
O
E
E
O
O
N
O
>1
>
Q
L
o
V
Q +%
oM
a�
V)
N
w
0
O 7
N
U
U
�N
N
-
n
E 2
c6
+,
i
WNCl-0
O�
N
0
O
—0
Q
Q
U
ilf
>
N
U
N
c
�
^
-a
i
c
-
4uauaa6eueW Asib WJ04S le;seOO : L9ZLZ) £ZOZ'9Z'L u01MUOSOM WbSO :4u9wLl3el4V
T
T
Q
6�
O
f6 E
•a--+
� L
�
�
� O
X
�
� N
�
N L
� O
+-
H
—
�
�
cU •
�
O
O
}' N
U
}'
O
O O
07
ry
U
9.A.12
Co Ter C01.11ty
Growth Management
Community Development Department
Collier County Coastal Storm Risk Management Feasibility Study Advisory
Committee
I have received the Sunshine Law information from Christopher Mason via email
on 7/19/2023:
Alex Garland Jr.
C-
Kenneth Humiston
Joshua Maxwell
Matthew Nolton 4 Ce-W a4 1 Tpe�7
Joseph Schmitt
Scott Schi
Miles Sco
Packet Pg. 334
Riiilrlino Plan RPviaw and Insnartion Divisinn 9 9800 North Horsashoa Drives 9 NanlPs R 141n4 • 93A-7.5�
i
Co ter CO-ynty
Growth Management
Community Development Department
Collier County Coastal Storm Risk Management Feasibility Study Advisory Committee
Wednesday, July 26, 2023
1:00 pm
Collier County GMD Building — Room 609/610
AGENDA
1. Introduction of Committee
2. Committee Roll Call — Member Introduction
3. Sunshine Law Requirements
4. Committee Chair/Vice Chair Selection
5. USACE Feasibility Study Process
6. Study Status — Staff Report
7. Future Meeting Scheduling
8. Public Comment
Motion to Ajourn:
Time Ajourned:
9.A.13
a)
E
c�
Q
Packet Pg. 335