AHAC Backup 03/18/2024Cottttty
Growtfr Managernent Communrty Development
Affordable Housing Advisory Committee
Attendance Roster - Date: March 19. 2024
AHAC Members
*"Must have (6) members for a
(
Arol
Excused
Staff Members
James French
Department Head, GMCD
Sarah Hanington
Manager, Planning, Housing Policy & Economic
Development, GMCD
Derek Perry
Assistant iounty Attomey, County Attorney's Office
Present
Excused
Present
Jaime Cook
Director, DeveloPment Review, GMCD
Michael Bosi
Director, Planning & Zoning, GMCD
Present
Present
ioner Chris Hall:Gary
Thomas Felke:
'.+t
J
Waller:
Excused
Paul Shea:Todd
Present
Cormac Giblin
Director, Housing Policy & Economic Development'
GMCD
Coutrt!
G rcn^dh Management Communrty
Sign-in Sheet (Public)
March 19.2024. AHAC Meetinq
Please Print
Dh{n
NAME REPRESENTING PHONE NO.k. )M,4s,.,fu AA\YI vle +"F"y
to/t4f14 hwlu/,At)/48 lfuvff \
611Ac- Clunrq I
U
SESrot r J- t{fklB/
{Iu l4n/1. n /)s oc (r tutc*.th{-
Aor \aLln^,,n"11 231- 707 14 o?itls;.o {ue n(r
,31-^k*-$.'nCG\nsan
ifli cLnn\T,,^. va\\.)\€,Lr / cccLT )2,,_ ri S.\_AaT(
erf-'
CCF<a\
Lt'idSC.{ \Cu61.r0"6,
OrqD
1 "'' 1.i L-L*
U
Td<.rta
}"So.1,\ND\$"
237 2;2 r 707ftU-l@ ro*x7t1liruftln /,k14_
4^t*"st
Agenda ltem No.- A-qt$a ltem. Jopic(For Publlc Comment, llet toplc)
Meeting Date:a')'Zp"?-
Name nQ-hnso s:z
'd\n
\1 -{}} /
--T #r
F,J ).
5nRepresenti ng/Petitioner r^tSr;n Other:
COLLIEB COUNTY ORDINANCE NO,2003.53, AS AMENDED BY OFOINANCE 20()+05 AND 2OO7'24, FEOUIRESTHATALL LOBBYIST SHALL, BEFORE ENGAGING IN
II.Ii uoesvlNc ecT|vmEs (NCLUDING, BUT NoI LIMITED TO, ADDRESSING THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONEBS), BEGISTEB WTH TTE CLERKTO THE
BOAHOATTHE SOARD MINUTES AND FECOBDS DEPAHTMEIVT
you ARE L|M|TED TO THBEE (3) MTNUTES FOR YoUB COMMENTS AND ARE TO ADDBESS ONLY THE CHAIH
pUBLtC COM|!,IENT tS NOT INTENDEo TO BE A FOBUll,l FOB SELF-PnOMOTION. PUBLIC COM|\,IENT SPEAKERS WHo ENGAGE lN ADVEBTISING
THEIR EUSINESS, PERSONAL POLITICKING OR OTHER FORMS OF SELF.PBOMOTION WLL BE ASKEDTO LEAVE THE PODIUM,
PLACE COMPLETED FOBM ON THE TABLE TO THE LEFT OF THE DAIS - PLEASE PRINT CLEABLY
J,-thn (-
Aoenda ltem No.- --r-Agenda ltem Topic
(For Public Comment, list topic)
Meeting Date:tq )-i
Name:(SS,(o. Tur 6x/Address: 2c>3t )aLlcsovr Sl t-
V\ o r-J.--
'j ({, J
Hepresenting/Petitioner . [o x.R_Other:
COLLIER COUNTY ORDINANCE NO.2OO3-53, AS AMENDED BY OROINANCE 2OO4.O5 AND 2007.24, REOUIBESTHATALL LOBBYIST SHALI", BEFORE ENGAGING IN
ANY LOSBYING ACTIVITIES (INCLUDING, BUT NOT LTMITED TO, ADDFESSING THE BOABO OF COUNW COMMISSIONEBS), REGISTEF WITH THE CLERKTO THE
BOAHD AT THE BOARD MINUTES AND BECOBDS DEPABTMEM
you ARE LIMITED T0 THHEE (3) MTNUTES FOR YOUR COMMENTS AND ARE TO ADDRESS 0NLY THE CHAIR
PUBLIC COMMEIIT IS NOT INTENOED TO BE A FORUM FOB SELF.PBOMOTION. PUBLIC COMMENT SPEAKEBS WHO ENGAGE IN AOVEFTISING
THEIR BUSINESS, PEBSONAL POLITICKING OB OTHEH FOBMS OF SELF.PROITIOTION WILL BE ASKEOTO LEAVE THE PODIUM.
PLACE COMPLETED FORM ON THE TABLE TO THE LEFT OF THE DAIS - PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY
I
169r0
Collier County
Affordable Housing Advisory Committee (AHAC)
AGENDA
Growth Management Community Development Department
Conference Rooms 609/610
28OO N. Horseshoe Dr., Naples, FL 34104
March 19,2024, 9:0o AM
Steve HrubY, Chair
Jennifer Faron, Mce Chair
Mary Waller, Member
Gary Hains, Member
Hannah Roberts, Member
Andrew Terhune, Member
commissioner chris Hall, BcC Liaison
Arol Buntzman, Member
Todd Lyon, Member
Paulshea, Member
Thomas Felke, Member
co ER CO UNTY STAFF
Jamie French, DePartment Head, GMCD
Michael Bosi, Director, Planning & Zoning
Jaime Cook, Director, Development Review
Cormac Giblin, Director, Housing Policy & Economic Development
Sarah Harrington, Planning Manager, Housing Polic'y & Economic Development
Oeret O. p.rw, lstistant County Attorney' County Attorney's Office
Donna Guitard, Management AnalYst l, GMCD
NOTE, ALL PERSONS wlSHlNG TO SPEAK ON ANY AGENDA ITEM MUST REGISTER PRIOR TO SPEAKING' AtL
REGISTERED SPEAKERS WtLL RECEIVE UP TO THREE (3) MINU'tES UNLESS THE TIME IS ADjU5TED BY THE CHAIRMAN'
DURINGcoMMITTEEDIscusSIoN,coMMITTEEMEMBERSMAYAsI(DIRECTQUESTIoNSToINDIVIDUALS'PLEASE
WA|TToBEREcoGNIzEDBYTHECHAIRMANANDSTATEYoURNAMEANDAFFILIATIoNFoRTHEREcoRDSEFoRE
COMMENTING,
IFYoUAREAPERSoNWITHADIsABILITYwHoNEEDSAccoMMooATIoNINoRoERToPARTICIPATEINTHIS
Vr,i.*E,"OUONI ENTITI.ED,ATNO COSr TO YOU, THE PROVISION OF CERTAIN ASSISTANCE. PI"EASE CONTACI
THEcotLIERcoUNTYFACIIITIESMANAGEMENTDEPARTMENT'ASS|STEDI-ISTENINGDEVICESFoRTHEHEARING
IMPAIRED ARE AVAILABTE tN THE COUNTY COMMISSIONER,S OFFICE'
AHAC MEMBERS
CALLTO ORDER & PLEDGE OFALLEGIANCE
ROLI CALL OF COMMITTEE MEMBERS AND STAFF
APPROVAT OF AGENDA AND MINUTES
Approval of today'5 agenda
Approval ofJanuary 16, 2024, AHAC Meeting m r utes.
Approval of February 20, 2024, AHAC Subcommitiee Meeting minutes
a. Land Trust Presentation (M. Puchalla)
5. PUBI.IC COMMENT
a.
b
c.
4.INFORMATIONAL ITEMS AND PRESENTATION
a Persons wishing to speak must register prior to peakinS. All
registered speakers will receive up to three (3) n r nutes unless the time
is adjusted by the Chairman.
6. DTSCUSSTON mMS
Subcommittee Recap
AHAC Policy Statement
7. STAFF AND COMMITTEE GENERAL COMMUNICATIONS
Timeline for 2024 SHlP Incentives Report (C. Giir rn)
DSAC Update (H. Roberts)
2024 Apartment Survey (C. Giblin)
Collier County Developments Approved Since 2 )17 (C. Giblin)
lntroduction DSAC member (C. Giblin)
Upcoming Public Meetings (c . Giblin & M. Bosir
NEXT AHAC MEETING DATE AND LoCAnON; May 21r, 2024, at 9:00 AM
Conference Room 509/510 - Growth ManaBement Community Development
Department
a
b
NEW BUSINESS
AOJOURN
a-
b.
c.
d.
e.
f.
8.
9.
10.
1,
2.
3.
SHIP lncentive Strategies Report 2024 Timeline
February 20 - AHAC Subcommittee Meeting: Layout lncentive Strategies Report schedule
March 19 - AHAC Meeting: Layout lncentive strategies Report schedule to AHAC
May 21 * AHAC Meeting: Bring 2023 lncentive Strategies Report to AHAC
tuly 16 - AHAC Meeting: Bring 2O24 First Droft lncentive Strategies Report to AHAC
september 7 - AHAC Meeting; Review/Approyai of lncentive strateSies Report
October 8 - Staff Deadline to Upload lncentive Strategies Report into County's Agenda system for Nov'
12 BCC Meeting
November 12 - BCC Meeting Approval of lncentive Strategies Report
December 31 -lncentive Strategies Report Due to State
Collier County Community and Human Services Division
Quarterly Rental APartment lnventory Survey January, 2024
vqlaffiMt! .{.ldffiffi ElSai-EE.
blqlrl5. d-ta El*gdG J- EbE
iau
:0 oEffi&\h.tr-l:9,
srir;!51#&x1615s.*t-tr6. liIi:t o
airt9!5r.{E 3&rEd'.i@.tLlrB
5 :.E g
$l\
:855:l a ,Jt?bdlct@-SElbl
9 Ult s :,al:*,s :.€?!{:9l.EthO,f,*.IX::9
:Eah o3 r.o:,3 l.r!t , l.&t 3t,tr9:9 qtuk id.tB t!x!:t ':!9 g.:@
0
5 3 tDr : r:i 15,ot.91t.ttlwrd l*4xlltEar9\ffib
o!19,l*l1rl lu{5 r.rr,&9@tu(,,h,4*!A
03 r@
'
!e 5 :4{!9jt5t-&
5J1':gq3.raXS
o:a9ia.r:rt 5
I !.6
5Uq t la
2
s l!;r 3 ljs s i4 H.r!99 HS$wdt-x*! dllarlgE-#tlga!
3Ln t It
0
0
t@.a1
:-!:'::.1-|rMs!d{i.F,f:}:9 NE 0
lr3 l.d 3W g t,oilrjS5,&m!Taa &.nlla
o3 la ,1lu
oI l-o;l 9tfi , r,s.:99.:i.n!
16rrsrukr& n.Ylo
ilqsiF Cekr.&E.Xllt
3LS t I,g 2A
lS l_r
ilit rr+*s(4rE@.B,flxir!
o9 :I'3u,3 r.!r :{t&!1&3*'rerylb,,i*.t.ll€iffil*l.M@@
03r,:3:at 2ts rr7isqi!r"enXl6ffil&x-&*tE
t !.s s l.l:.t!.'rr6i 6rr!$5 lJllts:sgl w,Il.y!@krrEiar6ryA
JE 3 r.B *ffik16.6tlE
0,!!t l.!$litrarg4r€5@ra \E.F-qiic
3 t i.ntiE '8fr]5$ Ad!bH, B.rgt-XtU
os r.s I t9'5 1.'allc6'* t&' iYg
u 0i l.rre .sd r{3. ln. uF. t, !i it lE"
aEiatE*19 t t5lt& w Bi6 h t+s. r! x::l
:EJrs**-.** t ,-,*
14 9:\3 r.E 3E€:rt!t \E P XiQ
lg aa itE 3 I1E 3:Fiitqt97.4r!, r4 H Hrrt, n llro*dadlffi :,a z)9 s t.gt irr:EWH&da.ubk*lB:*l
7&!:l.t r.E ! lztS&I4&IFr.X!q I
:asD83 !.e p tr.1t{rr)ix.m I rrrtlr!!d g, bE.f( vlgTArFIq.ta{.71
lr t9:e 3uq$ .d.'d 4 r.# ., X::6
Tlaaliv.|c*h SRYllt&av'c*fry
:16 !! l{oi !,s0 I r,rur&Esf &.Mrlq tlxl6 1rr9,s*g
&lltuEt :-!ISHO W.tlX115
a3 'JD
]Q 9r.'.:rrrre!!, t:rlmUkk.a.r6.RX:SrclFldlh.arrAqdbl
3rg 3 1tr 5rlt$gt-82
t lalH*heb*qX:1. Iri6tti*r&r)
r6I t rJ!r*l@tol!:&} trF.t x:6 1B1B-89&1{{&.rlloh
9 r.r77 3&F
n
a
tr,
g.'
'I99l.6
!tu5$urt9eftq. 'r.E,,i !1ra I
5 r.S JU gB:Jra A t5. hHtl
3K
I t6:!
t to
$:.
a 385 100'Dtt.r,'-!p 3 !.Sli!t C'E !r r, i.pbr,4 Yril
x l653 r.q sLEaSPa.l&,\&r tr Y::l IkbGrtr@e
1I latr 518 g' p,oro lr t.rrBl6s4r&'\y::6 i 'l .
5
'..91
,;IOs 1i2!i 5*i5I s 1.6,7lt Ecd6 @. w tLxl:.
3UU 3 !t!5 3Eruki.&?.{&a.t.X:S
ta 5 g
*ea
15
::*
)t$
i3;aE:!&
a _ ear tsi ar.. r::tr*tc-(s6.rr.l
girfl ls.m 3
'.St
s 1.s71 5 ?92,.:5 d.Cd..u* tr}llt
l65 SE 5 lBe ,*::l' v. r- Jc,':i \&t- :- u:i-'
tut , ltrl u
,1
tlirDigr.l,3 tls-17itr!*, l.galglX,SEbAtsr6
t&3 :.16 saa.s^dO. s*.,1ar:t (lrlrtm
'
,G t ,r5 S l.E :s::r{ke,x a, \€, rl IIB#@-@E(LG
:t5 r.!6 3ar ! rrr!r!ll'6EsS:B:ld&h.r4na16
8(C(&(E!ffi(ded
)1I:.
,!.f l.
o
dtrda'&e@trS
o
o
rr{
,, ra
rA
v^
t(a
ItEh&6 &rlD, bg, R ylq
,llr
h@ffidq WaY:6
ncut
0
l
I
I
I
i
I
i
I
I
I
I
I
i_*t tla
tElS
3:rv*d.t^-:. ur.1 .. vira
l,*l**
t !a*l__
t2m t a.ra!I*-*nrr, I u-tr*tt lt ruhdrta*
5rqd+@It)
I 1rq
s
Ju&Mqg.s6r.xlto I
:::.i. r-n.a.,: . \!: - :.:l
ItrU1rdffiE .t
! 19 EI.5SrM.*rr-,a l:ia
a s3!X t$5
9t3!E I
l,
iB
:a
a6@!*rrx:rl
a.g t ..9 p
:x g;i r,-
aI'Mrrt6affif ffi
-I6L
-Dd-
-M-
--!sdr6--
xr:turrd16..uilldre
2v
l
.6*d@
u
't'*t*tq&
439
,J
314
:glJ*!$E8lm
a ctr3alrJt
5 3r1$gi.c",tsIXilii*O ffi,tltal.l
.t !t ,rl s *ttggSen cr.,l@*..1Xl.l
5 al7 l!otpg&rh.M.AI:a
:!6t 3et s
,l!
5 .,
x
(.t!9167.r9lSltffiugn. rlilt*, t( Xlo
t lm 6mM&Cr.dh.rLXiQ.e&r@
I 5I i ttl ll!Pel,tMUl'*,.tX!.2
t a.,s:':l r_--';'' r # __''"' r' i':':
: t65 t r.t6irt) 67-&lE&reb-.id.t.Yld
t55tl'l 3 IJD8@r*-,kd,.IlA
ttElal hlr *ri
ot !P!-iB)&!?ra! t !t69d. ta. Xlal
o!u!5 :,.rt t66tk^-.rFdk t!Xla,al!.!#@
t !J{:e
0ts!E{174 atr.8tOk@ @b tiY:',
Z3@D.M.tlXt.I lr ,L{**hliHfL.ILrart@l ,2' Crager. rdh tt v1a2
;t5g|qd.r&flX1{
0
o
56
0
J a,tlrw6e|#,trM2
eIuq
,:6
,aldd Ts,g
Collier County Community and Human Services Division
Quarterly Rental Apartment tnventory Survey January, 2024
at ti
qffi Urtb.ld.-, !tuEdsCtr.*e
t#G.rh5..b#a- rtrqdGj&hEE
&rc*r-orucrlbl
@Eoalh.!*' r"qtuDdGdrhEE
!
I
E
riF- | aAI 'airc*r
-a:
1l
u
0
g.'r,. ^r'a. -- {..' .r:r {
r-*
t
A
vA
G 5rA2
fs
a6
ir^
IE
t. .:
Jan 2024 Apartment Survey' Fact Shect
l\ot indudins Immokalce
. The Median Rent for 1 bedroom decreased by 2.8% (51,953 to 51,898)
. The Median Renr for 2 bedrooms decreased by 3.4% (52,380 to 52,300)
. The Median Rent for 3 bedrooms decreased by 6.3% (52,855 to 52,680)
. Occupancy rate dropped to 97.9% from 98.3%. This is the first drop since luly 2022.
o ln the VLI section (Very Low-lncome) There are two units available. This section grew from two
applicable apartment complexes offering rent within the HUD rent limits to four.
. ln the Ll section (LowJncome) There are no units available. This section stayed the same, from
2023, at 16 apartment complexes offering rent within the HUD rent limits.
. ln the Mi section (Moderate Income)There are 385 units available- lhis section increased, from
2023, from 19 apartment complexes offering rent within the HUD rent limits to 34 apartment
complexes.
. Market rate apartments decreased in units available from 439 to 314.
. Apartments underway are labeled as 'under development.' A total of 8 will be online in the
future.
Immokelee
. The Median Rent for l bedroom increased 17.6% (56114 to 5768)
o The Median Rent for 2 bedrooms increased 24.9% (5781 to S1,0o3)
. The Median Rent for 3 bedrooms increased 23.5% (5870 to S1,1o0)
. lnventory of apartments rose from 916 to 1,454. A difference of 538 units.
. Occupancy rate stayed relativity the same, 99.6% from 99.5% in 2023.
. tn the VLI section (Very Low-lncome) There are 6 units available. This section decreased from 16
applicable apartment complexes offering rent within the HUD rent limits to 12'
. ln the Llsection (Low-lncome) There are no units available. This is the first time since october
2o2lthatapartmentcomplexesmovedintothissection.6apartmentcomplexesareoffering
rent within the HUD rent limits.
APAR-I TNT SURVEY FACT SHEET ] 2024
Collier County Developments Approved With Affordable Units Since 2017
Addr$t 2r, Fbt6 Total Untrt Allordrble Untu * Affordrbl!
B
!a4r
g :m
3s.I 0q(
l0l9 2t :@!{
SrBs
laa@ r{oAn'@rr :0?aiElrrtr oR $.sa
zr57&ara st 5445
:03:S r.t.nr(r
:6::iAr!'.4'S3.18
2S Arto wry 9r,123
Cr!tuJ* lrtu l&f..i l!6EToar.tc *s3,?OO 300
:.:
0*
&t0 k6n:lc Hrmmtt lt TBA 2CZo :65 10r(a(re.undd Drir'w{
r,*{a lqLa: tlr BI IBA ta?0 29fll c &U&laEwt
16|**radl@.t{i!fta ]032tffi r. b(nun&CIt TAA 1ctr4 ,@-J*rkrs+{
l8fr x .{ea lrfct LG5 Ratlt-ir. {r-€l l!16 100tr &u&kgEl:
!.4bdF I4 xry 6Saa DE.itl6r Sr":1,:gct-.r
ek Jet O*llQnrct&:ldr YIX Sil IEA IBA t0?1 2Trt 151
Bld h.llBaffiB r03s lrilrr way IBA ?021 234 3tr kk-UM o.Elopmct
IBT IBA 2021 1@1 &M.Und.r Ce{i@r:
1166 ln"Bk.i{ nD ]EA 2C21 :0o drGJ&06d#rt
:*-n r: Hdr Ll6 Ba;:3.tErr. ts.--er 'd .TBA :00ta aeiJ*D.*]ffi
:ol.r 516 rtdr ttt Ur:E l* lr.ffi$G &aA Pa{ !:52..93 2C2t 4ii
i.u &do . miits Sa2C $tftkr Ad tsA :c2l :09(A:lFlddkr@(
BirllfuG VJq. S fBr IBA 2472 2000 E.5X aft Jndrr **lope[
Xrm& D. 15 fB^IAA t12 23X mndlr !"*loprenr
5ds 6& 6.lt c*e el&6€1tu 6rk iq*laA 4@ &Und*kryeri
.ffi6DitoAB66E(tuit t7lccdi6 Sisd
'BA
ldN.r&rGa.@t
--Ea:ri !A&Pac?r 1678,sil.rfir 5r,5X ,r:!
'tc,
,g t try.HPJJ 6:Cor! i. ril!!._
;1
*M,*JlwkSff
ld;n r WLa. PtrD 3D ,BI 2Cr3 :{ 3!a kJnAk;ffi
Pfclitiv lfin Llx ruO IID IBA t0?3 250 68*&d*rOftlrytrt
IBO TBA ,&3 34.1*reJDdiccElq€il
6& Or 6o{Cd* tu},-al2- .n, 6*.1 61. h at@dtun 6.r. trq T3A :023 215 ::i 1}r!a a.t*Jnd.r Ddb9.r*tr
Cr.a3r loas llr lEnl*fi Fd TBA rs :c{eFJd.kM
s 16A 13!r &Je3*i@ffi
2:lc:l g;4s Ln IBI 2013 .m :sa lcc.und.rD*ffi
rMol&rCyrc lu 20:3 gt:i0i1 kurn.D.€rryid
Tool Ur*E Alltrdnu. Unl$x AftddrbL
Totals 18,965 4,512 23.7%
:.]
affi !f,r hrta B'8
t3
l0E
rB
Free 2024
Housing Expo
olfered b9...
-J;;,d\.HELP
$'NABOR
HOUSING. EDUCATION. LENDING PROCRAMS
Date: Saturday, April 6,2A24
Time: 8:30 a.m. - 71:45 a.m.
Where: Naples Area Board of Realtors (NABOR)
!455 Pine Ridge Rd, Naples, FL 34109
Join us for refreshments, networking and conversation regarding
Pre-Purchase Education, Housing Opportunities, & Down
Payment assistance. Come see what local lenders have to offer
you.
Realtors interested in learning more about housing affordability
programs and options are welcome.
NAPLES AREA BOARD OF REALTORS'
ril-k*--
HELP is a HUD-aPProvcd nonProfit
mendcd bY M.L-S.
locat housing counseling agency. Progfams. producls,. or serviccs ate not cndorsed or recom-
of Naples. Lic. or by thetiples Area Board of REALTORS'F ( ''\'{BOR" )'
-rT-T:..-87-
.-
#
a.
{org
23
To registff
x. 200
I
Presentation Schedule:
8:3oam - 9:OOam: Registration & Networking
9:OOam - 9:45am: Pre-Purchase Education &
Housing Opportunities
10:00am - 1o:45am State & Local Downpayment
assistance programs including SHIP, HOME'
Florida Bond, & Hometown Heroes
11:OOam- 1t45am: Realtofs What you need to know regarding
access to housing affordability programs and options '
We will provide a Community Update on The Housing Alliane
initiative starting at 72:00 Pm.
n,
!
Thank you to our event host, Naples Area Board of Realtors!
HELP
32OO Bailey Ln, Ste 109
Naples, FL 34105
Phone: 23943+2397
Far 88&900€O&3
www.floridahelp.org
IIELP exists to Ptornote
h ome ownership opPortunities
and financial stength through
education and t'ounseling.
EouAtltluslNG
OPPORIT'NIT Y
llELp is a HuD-approved nonprofit local housing counseling agcncy. Programs. producs, orser'. ice-r are not endorsed or rccom-
mendcd by V.L.S. ofNaples' Inc. or b1' t}e Naples Area Board ofRF.{LTORS i t'\ABOR")'