The URL can be used to link to this page

CESM Agenda 03/28/2024 Code Enforcement Board Nuisance Abatement Board AGENDA Board of County Commission Chambers Collier County Government Center 3299 Tamiami Trail East, 3rd Floor Naples, FL 34112 March 28, 2024 9:00 AM Robert Kaufman, Chair Kathleen Elrod, Member Sue Curley, Member John Fuentes, Member Lee Rubenstein, Member Tarik N. Ayasun, Member Manmohan “Bart” N. Bhatla, Member James York, Alternate Kevin Johnson, Alternate Notice: Respondents may be limited to twenty (20) minutes for case presentation unless additional time is granted by the Board. Persons wishing to speak on any agenda item will receive up to five (5) minutes unless the time is adjusted by the Chairman. All parties participating in the public hearing are asked to observe Roberts Rules of Ord er and speak one at a time so that the court reporter can record all statements being made. Any person who decides to appeal a decision of this Board will need a record of the proceedings pertaining thereto, and therefore may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. Neither Collier County nor the Code Enforcement Board shall be responsible for providing this record. I. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. ROLL CALL III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES IV. APPROVAL OF AGENDA V. PUBLIC HEARINGS/MOTIONS A. MOTIONS MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE OF IMPOSITION OF FINES HEARING 1. CASE NO: CESD20230003899 OWNER: Debbie Bello Lopez and Ramon Lopez OFFICER: Craig Cooper VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a), 10.02.06(B)(1)(e) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e)(i). Multiple structures erected prior to obtaining a Collier County Building permit(s) consisting of, but not limited to, a front carport with 2 light poles with receptable connections, barn/carport/storage structure in the rear, metal shed structure, and an electrical receptable connection pole in the rear of the property. FOLIO NO: 38970400003 PROPERTY 2960 56th Ave NE, Naples, FL 34120 ADDRESS: 2. CASE NO: CESD20230003212 OWNER: BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST OFFICER: Doug Williams VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e)(i). Carport converted into living space, and lanai addition without valid Collier County building permit. FOLIO NO: 60780600003 PROPERTY 5340 Myrtle Ln, Naples, FL 34113 ADDRESS: MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF COMPLIANCE DEADLINE 3. CASE NO: CESD20230003711 OWNER: Maria Isabel Reyes OFFICER: Craig Cooper VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a), 10.02.06(B)(1)(e) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e)(i). An addition added to the rear of the home prior to obtaining a Collier County Building Permit. FOLIO NO: 39777040005 PROPERTY 3451 41st Ave NE, Naples, FL 34120 ADDRESS: MOTION FOR RE-HEARING B. STIPULATIONS (NON-CONTESTED CASES AND PRESENT AT THE HEARING) C. EMERGENCY CASES D. HEARINGS 1. CASE NO: CEA20230008937 OWNER: Ramiro Trevino OFFICER: Jason Packard VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 4.02.07. Over allowable limit of 2 hooved animals per acre. FOLIO NO: 758840004 PROPERTY 11175 Tomato Rd, Naples, FL 34114 ADDRESS: 2. CASE NO: CESD20230008967 OWNER: Ramiro Trevino OFFICER: Jason Packard VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a), 10.02.06(B)(1)(e) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e)(i). Horse stalls, chicken coops and other accessory structures constructed without Collier County Permits and/or Approvals. FOLIO NO: 758840004 PROPERTY 11175 Tomato Rd, Naples, FL 34114 ADDRESS: 3. CASE NO: CESD20230007550 OWNER: Roxana Socarras and Jorge Armando Martinez OFFICER: Maria Rodriguez VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 10.02.06(B)(1)(a). A barn, water fountain with electric, outside lights with electric and shed all erected without first obtaining the authorization of the required permit(s), inspections and certificate(s) of occupancy as required by the Collier County Building Department. FOLIO NO: 41280440009 PROPERTY 2630 18th Ave SE, Naples, FL 34117 ADDRESS: 4. CASE NO: CESD20230007241 OWNER: Richard Brian Peterman and Cynthia Marie Eddy OFFICER: Jason Packard VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a), 10.02.06(B)(1)(e) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e)(i). Interior renovations including but not limited to plumbing and electrical work completed prior to issuance of appropriate Collier County permits/approvals. FOLIO NO: 76775001724 PROPERTY 6900 Anthurium LN, Naples, FL 34113 ADDRESS: 5. CASE NO: CEVR20230008759 OWNER: EDINGTON PLACE LLC OFFICER: Doug Williams VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 3.05.01(B). Mechanical clearing vegetation on a vacant lot without a permit. FOLIO NO: 727400006 PROPERTY 1095 Barefoot Williams Rd, Naples, FL 34113 ADDRESS: 6. CASE NO: CEVR20220010806 OWNER: Luc Goemaere and Liping Wu OFFICER: Jason Packard VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 3.05.01(B), 3.05.07(C)(3)(b), 3.05.07(F)(3)(a) and 3.05.07(F)(3)(g)(i)(b). Trees and vegetation removed from lot and fill brought into lot without issuance of appropriate Collier County Permits or other approvals. FOLIO NO: 437560003 PROPERTY 306 Sabal Palm Rd, Naples, FL 34114 ADDRESS: 7. CASE NO: CESD20230007552 OWNER: Robert Lee Smith Jr and Denise H Smith OFFICER: Doug Williams VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e). Installed a new vanity without a permit in a condo. FOLIO NO: 76460280009 PROPERTY 330 Kon Tiki Dr A7, Naples, FL 34113 ADDRESS: 8. CASE NO: CESD20240000553 OWNER: Peggy Raymond OFFICER: Brian Owen VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a), 10.02.06(B)(1)(e) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e)(i). Unpermitted screened in lanai and garage conversion to include but not limited to plumbing, framing and drywall. FOLIO NO: 36317560003 PROPERTY 5341 25th Ave SW, Naples, FL 34116 ADDRESS: VI. OLD BUSINESS A. MOTION FOR REDUCTION/ABATEMENT OF FINES/LIENS B. MOTION FOR IMPOSITION OF FINES/LIENS 1. CASE NO: CESD20210001490 OWNER: Cecilio Martinez Resendiz and Maricela Valerio Martinez OFFICER: Raul Mendez VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a), 10.02.06(B)(1)(e) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e)(i). Unpermitted carport and other accessory structures. FOLIO NO: 41040200007 PROPERTY 3371 14th Ave SE, Naples, FL 34117 ADDRESS: 2. CASE NO: CENA20230008527 OWNER: BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST OFFICER: Jason Packard VIOLATIONS: Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances, Chapter 54, Article VI, Section 54-185(a). Repeat violation of weeds and grass growth in excess of 18” throughout this entire improved residential lot, including the swale. FOLIO NO: 60780600003 PROPERTY 5340 Myrtle Ln, Naples, FL 34113 ADDRESS: 3. CASE NO: CESD20230003212 OWNER: BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST OFFICER: Doug Williams VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e)(i). Carport converted into living space, and lanai addition without valid Collier County building permit. FOLIO NO: 60780600003 PROPERTY 5340 Myrtle Ln, Naples, FL 34113 ADDRESS: 4. CASE NO: CEAU20220010097 OWNER: BEST HOMES BUILDER AT GG LLC OFFICER: Joseph Marino VIOLATIONS: Florida Building Code 7th Edition (2020), Chapter 1, Section 105.1. Fence built without a valid Collier County permit. FOLIO NO: 302800005 PROPERTY 1190 Ivy Way, Naples, FL 34117 ADDRESS: 5. CASE NO: CESD20220008207 OWNER: Walter A Navarro, Krissia I Palacios, Graciela E Hughes and John Hughes OFFICER: Jason Packard VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e). Interior conversion of garage to livable space, complete with bathroom, kitchen, and AC unit. FOLIO NO: 54901960004 PROPERTY 103 Warwick Hills Dr, Naples, FL 34113 ADDRESS: 6. CASE NO: CEAU20220006876 OWNER: PSB LAND TRUST OFFICER: Jonathan Musse VIOLATIONS: Florida Building Code 7th Edition (2020), Chapter 1, Section 105.1. Vinyl fence installed on the left side and right rear of the dwelling without first obtaining a valid Collier County permit. FOLIO NO: 62205480007 PROPERTY 5373 Holland St, Naples, FL 34113 ADDRESS: 7. CASE NO: CELU20180013990 OWNER: Vladimir Portal and Caridad Paz OFFICER: Charles Marinos VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 10.02.06(B)(1)(a). Unpermitted improvements/structures: a converted garage, an aluminum porch, an entry addition, a large warehouse, a swimming pool, and ground level addition to the permitted pigeon coop. FOLIO NO: 36914160000 PROPERTY 2035 Golden Gate Blvd W, Naples, FL 34120 ADDRESS: 8. CASE NO: CESD20220008382 OWNER: Anthony Mattei, Karol Lucila Teresita Mattei and Lilia Mercedes Machado OFFICER: Jason Packard VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e). Improvements to property prior to issuance of Collier County Building Permits. FOLIO NO: 51590080000 PROPERTY 164 Panther Pass Cir, Naples, FL 34114 ADDRESS: 9. CASE NO: CESD20220003245 OWNER: NAPLES-DAVIS BLVD LLC CO BENDERSON DEVELOPMENT CO LLC OFFICER: Rickey Migal VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a) and 5.06.06(A)(8). Unpermitted sign alterations. FOLIO NO: 34690080008 PROPERTY 8760 Davis Blvd, Naples, FL 34112 ADDRESS: 10. CASE NO: CESD20140006223 OWNER: Henry Perez OFFICER: Craig Cooper VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 10.02.06(B)(1)(a). A vacant unfinished home with an expired permit. FOLIO NO: 39895880008 PROPERTY 2665 Oil Well Rd, Naples, FL 34120 ADDRESS: 11. CASE NO: CEROW20230002007 OWNER: Santiago Zavala Jr and Santiago Zavala OFFICER: Rickey Migal VIOLATIONS: Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances, Chapter 110, Article II, Section 110-31(a). Asphalt driveway installed over County right of way without a permit. FOLIO NO: 36439520002 PROPERTY 3077 52nd St SW, Naples, FL 34116 ADDRESS: 12. CASE NO: CESD20220010706 OWNER: Christa Benoit OFFICER: Jason Packard VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a), 10.02.06(B)(1)(e) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e)(i). Conversion of garage to living space without Collier County Building Permits. FOLIO NO: 63100240008 PROPERTY 4848 Catalina Dr, Naples, FL 34112 ADDRESS: 13. CASE NO: CESD20200006363 OWNER: Miguel Arroyo OFFICER: Doug Williams VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 10.02.06(B)(1)(a). Enclosed the porch/entryway and built a 16ft x 12ft detached garage without first obtaining a valid Collier County permit. FOLIO NO: 62091600004 PROPERTY 5217 Martin St, Naples, FL 34113 ADDRESS: 14. CASE NO: CESD20200009039 OWNER: Kurt Clapper and Tricia Clapper OFFICER: Rickey Migal VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 10.02.06(B)(1)(a). Constructed shed without permit. FOLIO NO: 38228440003 PROPERTY 5720 Sea Grass Ln, Naples, FL 34116 ADDRESS: 15. CASE NO: CESD20230003899 OWNER: Debbie Bello Lopez and Ramon Lopez OFFICER: Craig Cooper VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a), 10.02.06(B)(1)(e) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e)(i). Multiple structures erected prior to obtaining a Collier County Building permit(s) consisting of but not limited to a front carport with 2 light poles with receptable connections, barn/carport/storage structure in the rear, metal shed structure, and an electrical receptable connection pole in the rear of the property. FOLIO NO: 38970400003 PROPERTY 2960 56th Ave NE, Naples, FL 34120 ADDRESS: 16. CASE NO: CELU20220011318 OWNER: Yohenis Martinez OFFICER: Charles Marinos VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 1.04.01(A) and 2.02.03. An improved estates zoned property with multiple inoperable boats on blocks in the yard and no registration numbers. FOLIO NO: 45847880008 PROPERTY 1311 11th St SW, Naples, FL 34117 ADDRESS: 17. CASE NO: CESD20210002415 OWNER: Melva Padilla and Nazaria Angelica Nunez OFFICER: Rickey Migal VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a), 10.02.06(B)(1)(e) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e)(i). Alterations to garage area without a required Collier County building permit. FOLIO NO: 56324013549 PROPERTY 8322 Valiant Dr, Naples, FL 34104 ADDRESS: C. MOTION TO RESCIND PREVIOUSLY ISSUED ORDER D. MOTION TO AMEND PREVIOUSLY ISSUED ORDER VII. NEW BUSINESS VIII. CONSENT AGENDA A. REQUEST TO FORWARD CASES TO COUNTY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE IX. REPORTS 9.1. Nomination for Board Chairman and Vice-Chairman X. COMMENTS XI. ADJOURN XII. NUISANCE ABATEMENT BOARD A. HEARINGS XIII. NEXT MEETING DATE THURSDAY - MARCH 28, 2024 AT 9:00AM XIV.ADJOURN Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28256) DOC ID: 28256 Updated: 3/7/2024 10:30 AM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CESD20230003899 Lopez CASE NO: CESD20230003899 OWNER: Debbie Bello Lopez and Ramon Lopez OFFICER: Craig Cooper VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a), 10.02.06(B)(1)(e) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e)(i). Multiple structures erected prior to obtaining a Collier County Building permit(s) consisting of, but not limited to, a front carport with 2 light poles with receptable connections, barn/carport/storage structure in the rear, metal shed structure, and an electrical receptable connection pole in the rear of the property. FOLIO NO: 38970400003 PROPERTY 2960 56th Ave NE, Naples, FL 34120 ADDRESS: 5.A.1 Packet Pg. 10 CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLLIER COUNTY,FLOR:DA Code Enforcement Board 80ARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS, COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,Pla ntiff, VS DFRRIF RFH O1 0pFア ANn RAMON:OPF7.Respondent(S) Case:CESD20230003899 TIME: NOT:CE OF HEAR:NG RE:MOT:ON FOR A CONT:NUANCE PLEASE TAKE NOT:CE that Pursuantto Section 162 06 and 162 12,Florida Statutes,and Co∥ier County Ordinance No 07‐44, as amended,you are hereby ordered to appear at a pub∥c hearng before the Code Enforcement Board on the fo∥owing date,time,and place forthe violat on belowi DATE: 03/28′2024 09 00 AM PLACE: 3299 Tamiaml Tra∥East Bu∥dng F,Naples,FL 34112 V10LAT:ON: CO Requ「ed ATF Permls 10 02 06(B)(1)(a),100206(B)(1)(e)and 10 02 06(Bxl)(e)o) LOCAT:ON OFV:OLAT:ON: 2960 56th AVE NE,Naples,FL 34120 SERVED: DEBBIE BELLO LOPEZ AND RAMON LOPEZ,Respondent Cra g Cooper, lssu ng Officer RESPONDENTS ARE REQU:RED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEAR:NG CONFERENCE HEARINGS TO BECIN AT 9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTiCE thatthe a∥eged violator may produce any and a∥documents,w tnesses andノ o「 evidence to be relied upon forthe test mony given atthe hear ng Documents w∥ consist ofthe original and three copies A∥eged vlolators have the rightto be represented by an attorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOT:CE that Requests for Continuances w∥l not be considered if not received by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board atleastfive(5)business days priorto the date set forthe hear ng iT:S FURTHER ADVISED that Ordinance No 07‐44,as amended,be reviewed plorto your attendance atthe hea百 ng to include emphasls on Section Eight relating to the appeal process Helen Buch∥on COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe Dttve Naples,Florida 341 04 (239)252‐5892 Telephone 蝋 I蹴『朧絶酬 γ臨 i瑞轟辮鵠∬躙 =t樅癬難測輌li勲[欄熟よ贔、he8380.as soon as possible,but no laterthan 48い ours before the scheduled e individual NOTIFICAC10N:Esta audiencia sera conducida en elidioma lngles Servicios the traduccion no seran disponibles en la audiencia y usted sera 欝:71鍬鳥193:}雷 ιttf∬ぽ評:l馳篤:::∬P棚「器飩鴨肥す:ll劉せn″ :1:蹴 :Li器 111置す∥%|::濯 ::∫:]|:Э ::]::I∝ 5.A.1.a Packet Pg. 11 Attachment: CESD20230003899 Lopez (28256 : CESD20230003899 Lopez) INSTR 64561■9 oR 6290 PC 4■■CLERK OF THE CIRCu工 T CouRT AND REC S■8.50 RECORDED 9/22/2023 9:54 AM PAGES 2COMPTROLLER, COLLIER COuNTY FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT 30ARD COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA 30ARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Pctitioncr, VS DEBBIE BELLO RAMON LOPEZ, Casc No CESD20230003899 ()RDE( CIF THE CODE ENFORCEI\IENT AOARD THIS CAUSE "o*" b"for"d" Codc Enforccmcnt Board (thc "Board") for public hcaring on August 24, 2023, and thc Board, having hcard tcstirp6-ny rinder oath, reccivcd cvidcncc and hcard argumcnt rcspcctivc to all appropriate maflcrs, hcrcupon issucs ils FindinE{.of Facr, Conclusions of Law, and Ordcr of thc Board as follorvs: f,frvortrgs or nacr )(.l. Rcspondcnr(s), Dcbble Bcllo Lopez .ndRr_qin Lopez, is/arc thc owncr(s) of thc subject ptoperty (the "Propcny"). / .z.l2. Rcspondcnl(s), having bccn notificd of thc da6 oflzaring by ccrlificd mail and posting, appcarcd al the public hcaring via Dcbbic Bcllo Lopcz. //' /,/ ,a.3. Thc Propcny at 2960 56th Ave. NE, Naplcs, FL 3412-Q'folio No. 38970400003 (Legal Dcscription: GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 44 W l50FI OF TR 106)is in.violation of Collicr County Land Developmcnt Codc 04-41, as amendcd, Scctions 10.02.06(8)( t )(a), tO.02.06(BXl Xc), and 10.02.06(BX I )(cXi) in thc following paniculars: '. I ' 'a') Multlplc structures crecicd prior lo oblaining ! Collicr Coun$rfuilding pcrmit(s) consisting ot' but not limltcd ao, ! fronl corporl rvi(h 2 light polcs lvith rcccptoble conEcctlons, brrn/carport/storagc "ru“ urc h mc rcar,m“∥shcd"rudurヽ andandcdHcttrcicⅢ口 'C° nncdbn pdo m mcrcarOr the propcrty. 4 Thc Rcspondcnt(S)has/havc admhtcd thatthc viola S Thc violation(s)has/havc not bccn abatcd as ofthc CONCI´US10NS OF LAヽ V ′ :/Based upon the foregoing facts, thc Board makes the following Conclusions ofLaw: l. All noticcs wcre propcrly and rimely issucd, and rhc Board has jurisdiction pursuant to Chaptcr 162, Florida Statutcs, and Chapter 2, Articlc IX, Codc ofLaws and Ordinanccs ofCollicr County, Florida. 2. Thc preponderancc ofthc cvidencc shows that violatior(s) ofCollicr County Land Dcvclopmcnt Codc 04- 41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(lXa), 10.02.06(B)(l Xe), and 10.02.06(8)( I )(c)(i) do/docs cxist, and that Respondenr(s) committcd, and was/wcre rcsponsible for mrinlaining or allowing thc violation(s) to continuc as ofthc dxte ofthis hcaring, ORDER Pagc l●f2 Rcspondcnt(s). 5.A.1.a Packet Pg. 12 Attachment: CESD20230003899 Lopez (28256 : CESD20230003899 Lopez) 十十★ OR 6290 PG 4■2 '■十 Bascd upon thc forcgoing Findings ofFact and Conclusions ofLaw, ond pursuant to thc authority grantcd in Chaptcr 162, Flo;ida Statutcs, and Chapter 2, Aniclc IX, Code ofLaws and Ordinances ofCollicr County, Florida, it is hereby ORDERED that: A. Rcspondcnr(s) iVarc found guilty ofviolating Collicr County Land Dcvclopmcnt Codc 04-41, as amcnded, Scctions 10.02.06(8)( I )(a), t 0.02.06(BXl )(e), and 10.02.06@)( I )(e)(i). abatc thc violation(s) by obtaining all requircd Collicr County Building pcrmit(s) or s), inspcctions, and Certincalc of Completion/Occupancy to cither kccp or rcmove thc :暇。1糀絆:爛鴨出 l」F電ごL出ぞ:C::liボ写寧器器協議粗繁1鶏鳴「;i:朧累llttR¶温紺utty 2■202 ora nnc J S35000 pr dayC ../ Rcspondcnt is ordcrod-to pay operational costs for thc proseculion ofthis casc in thc amount ofs59.28 on or STATE OF FLORIDA COUN「Y OF COLLIER IS' 1/ Thc forcgoing instrumept was, acknowlcdgcd bcforc rhis +Lday of Board Collicr Countr, Florida. ".t::r-4,^ HELEN BUCHILION - r/'\.-7 Coiim.ss.oli lt.j 1031t9;i):# -"e,;fi;;;;;;" commissiqncd Namc orNotary Pubric ',.oir!o+' Bd{od Thto rur,d \oh.y s!u:6! /. qrin/Typc/Stamp) -}.,.PAYMENT OF FINES: Any fines ordered to bc paid pursuant lo this Ordcr may bc piid at rhe Collier County Codc Enforccmcnt Dcpanment, 2800 Nonh Horscshoe Drivc, Naplcs, FL 34104, Phohc: f39) 252-2440, Wcbsire: lvww.collicrcorntyfl,Eov. Any rclcasc oflicn or confirmation ofcompliance or confirmation ofth6 salisfqction ofthc obligations ofthi. Or&rrnuy also b" obraincd ar this location. , _.) , /.!!!p![ Any aggricvcd party may appcal a final ordcr ofthe Board to thc Circuit Coun within thirry (3o]dap ofrhc cxccurion of Ihe Order appcalcd, An appcal shall not bc a hearing dc novo, but shall bc limitcd lo appcllatc rcvdrv of thc rccord crcalcd fllPcrsonally Known OR O Produccd Idcntification T,?c of Idcntifi cation Produccd within thc orlgina!hcaring it is thc rcsponsibility o「thc appcaling party to obtain a transcribcd rccord o「thc hcaring rrom thc Clcrk or Couns Filing an appcal will not automaticaly stay this Ordcr CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE l HEREBY CERTry価誠 a tШ c and cOrcct copy Or血、o〕墨粧勉墜じ弘 lち llMall・ :DcbЫ c Bdb Lopcz andRamonLopcll聖」崚 ::ザ 'Nap應 ,FL 3420,on=黎 i,zf dphysicol prcscncc or E online nolarization, Chair ofthc Collicr County Codc Enforccmcnt Dept,CI献 Pagc 2 of2 5.A.1.a Packet Pg. 13 Attachment: CESD20230003899 Lopez (28256 : CESD20230003899 Lopez) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28257) DOC ID: 28257 Updated: 3/7/2024 10:33 AM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CESD20230003212 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST CASE NO: CESD20230003212 OWNER: BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST OFFICER: Doug Williams VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e)(i). Carport converted into living space, and lanai addition without valid Collier County building permit. FOLIO NO: 60780600003 PROPERTY 5340 Myrtle Ln, Naples, FL 34113 ADDRESS: 5.A.2 Packet Pg. 14 TIME: CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLL:ER COUNTY,FLOR:DA Code Enforcement Board BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS, COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,PlainlfF, VS BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST,Respondent(S) Case:CESD20230003212 NOTICE OF HEAR:NG RE:MOT:ON FOR A CONTINUANCE PLEASE TAKE NOT:CE that Pursuantto Section 162 06 and 162 12,Flo百 da Statutes,and Co∥ier County Ordinance No 07-44, as amended,you are hereby ordered to appear at a pub∥c hearing before the Code Enforcement Board on the fo∥owing date,time,and place forthe violation below: DATE: 03/28′2024 09:00 AM PLACE: 3299 Tamiaml Tra∥East Bu∥ding F,Naples,FL 34112 V10LAT10N: CO Requ「ed ATF Permls 10 02 06(B)(1)(a)and 10 02 06(B)(1)(e)o) LOCAT:ON OF ViOLAT10N: 5340 Myrte LN,Naples,FL 34113 SERVED: BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST,Respondent Doug 1/r∥iams,Issuing Of「cer RESPONDENTS ARE REQUIRED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEARING CONFERENCE HEARINGS TO BECiN AT 9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOT:CE thatthe a∥eged violator may produce any and a∥documents,wttnesses and′or evidence to be re∥ed upon forthe testimony given atthe hearing Documents w∥l consist ofthe o「iginal and three copies A∥eged violators have the rightto be represented by an attorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOT:CE that Requests for Conlnuances w∥l not be cons dered r not recelved by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board atleast five(5)business days priorto the date set forthe hearing :T:S FURTHER ADV:SED that Ordinance No 07 44,as amended,be reviewed p百 orto your attendance atthe heanng to include emphasis on Section Eight relat ng to the appeal process Helen Buch∥lon COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples,Flor da 34104 (239)252‐5892 Telephone 鶉脚鼎祠絣鶉諫舅鶉鼈鶉陽 i随欝:T鍬黒:〕器議s::f熙 :ttr」離《:;:器 P棚調『ほ鴨服:す :i窓写廿1『:場 :■:li鶏 ili∥ζ梶lす I%[譜 ::∫榔。吉:ず :『。 5.A.2.a Packet Pg. 15 Attachment: CESD20230003212 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST (28257 : CESD20230003212 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST) 工NSTR 6433■67 oR 627■ PCCLERK OF THE CIRCuIT CouRT REC S■8 50 3876 RECORDED 7/26/2023 AND COMPTROLLER, COLL工 ER 4:36 PM PAGESCOuNTY FLORIDA COLLIER COUNTy cODE ENFORCEMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD Case No.―CESD20230003212 BOARD OF COUNrY COMMISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Petitlorler, THIS CAUSE camc bcrorcthc Board (the "Board") for public hearing on lnne 22,2023, evidencc and heard orgument respective to all appropriatcand thc Board, having heald lestimony matters, hcreupol issues its Findings ofLaw, and Order ofthe Board as follows: l. Respondents, Robert P. aod Loulse L. by certilied mail and posting, did not appcar at the 3. The Property locatcd at 5340 MYRTLE LN., Naplef,, Folio No.60780600003 (Lcgal D€scription: MYRTLE COVE ACRES BLK A COMヽ 4AT NW OF E 200「r OF LOT 14,S170F,E 100「,N170Fr,W10oFF TO POB OR l174 PC of Sections 10.02.06(8)(l)(a) and 10.02.06(B)(1)←)(i),Ord No 04‐41,as amcndcd,ColMcr particulars: ■nd Developmcnt Codc,in thc rollowing Csrport conyerted lnto livlng spscc, alld lrnai sdditlott valld Collier County buildlng permlt. 4 The●d“おns havc nd beenめ ●cdぃ oFhcdmeonhshc頷 n■ 11‐).、 CONCLUЫ ONS OF LAW Iィ ´)Bascd upon thc Fo"going racts,thc Board makcsl !. All notices wcrc propcrly and timcly issued,o Statutcs,and Chaptcr 2,Articlc Ⅸ,Codc orL 162,Florida 2. The preponderance of the evidence shows that violations of Scctions 10.02.06(8)(lXa) and I 0.02.06(BX I XeXi), Ord. No.04-41, as amcndcd, Collier County Land Development Code, do exist, and that Respondents committed, and wers responsible for maintaining or allowing the violations to continue as ofthe date ofthis hearing. @EB Based upon the foregoing Findings ofFact and Conclusions ofLaw, and pursuant to the authority granred in Chaptcr 162, Florida Statutes, 8nd Chapter 2, Anicle IX, Code ofLaws and Ordinances ofCollier County, Florida, ir is her€by ORDERED that: Respo]ldetlas. Page I of2 1夕)5.A.2.a Packet Pg. 16 Attachment: CESD20230003212 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST (28257 : CESD20230003212 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST) tキ t OR 6271 Pc 3877 ★★★ A. Respondents are found guilty ofviolatinS S.ctions 10.02.06(8)( I )(a) and 10.02.06(8)(l Xe)(i)' Ord. No. M- 41, as amcnded, Collicr County Land Development Code. B. Rcspondcns musi abare all violations by obtaining all required Collier County Building Pcrmit(s) or Demolition pelmit(s) and lequesr all iosp€ctions through Cenificatc ofCompletion/Occupancy for thc carpon conversion ind lanai addition on or before November 19,2023, ot a fine of $175.00 per day will be imposed for each day the violations rcmain thereafler.CIrRcspondents Fan to comply with this Ordcr,Co∥ier County may abate thc violations using any mcthod to into c;mpliancc and may use thc assistance of thc Collier County SherifT's Office to ofthis Order and all cosG ofabatemenl shall be assessed to Rcspondents.Em覧咄脅 111:;Il:pay° pCrat10nal∞StS fOrttt prosCCut10n of編 S Cascin thc amount OFS59'8o■ ~｀ _ン /1 ｀'1霧 :lli:お躍認ツ畜認 l黒 :電 :Tl:淵 r::1:l:↑。:l働 “ Cmcm oF山 c宙 dttons and“quc“山c DONE AND ORDERED STATE OF FLORIDA COUN「Y OF COLLIER ∥:2ロギ肝S堅払選型翌里電謝鵠 Board Collier County, Florida. ,flPersonally Known OR E Produced Identification T)Te of Identifi cation Produced ,2023, at Colller County, Florlds. BOARD physical Presence or E onlinc notarization, Chair ofthe Collier County Code Enforcement ψ ^ ご畢測∬侃||1翻"鵠 PAYMENT OF Π Nお Any■二潟 ld蕊 ∥胤 mithsoⅢ高 bま pま d“市e Colll∝Counv C“c申総;t毬霊l蹴胤淵 ξ賤:盤 n°tth」L盤脱鵠 1鮮 :お m■i牌鷺 1°n i´´/ . UYI4EIII-OE-EINES Any fines ordered to be paid pursuant to this Order wrvw.collicrcounwfl.cov. Any release oflien or confirmation ofcompliance or APPEAL:Any aggricved pa●may appcal a rlna1 0rdcr oFthc Board to thc Circuit(ガ urt of thc rccord crcatcd"1■■n the oHglnal hcain3 1tls thc responslbi■tyoFthifl聞 1,露賭よti::Inatrttnscibcdrccord oFthc hca∥ng from thc Clcrk orCouns Fi:ing an appcal wili not autor CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE a, AE!&!f.! Any aggrieved party may sppeal a final order ofthe Board to the Circuit Cdurr ryiihin thirty (30) dcys of thc cxecution ofthe Order appealed. An appeal shall not be a hcaring de novo, but shall be limitgd to appellate revicw ofthe record created within the orieinal hearinE. It is the resDonsibility ofthe aDDealins Darty,lo-obtain a transcribed ′ ヽヽ￢イ. =′ ′ `・イ鼻ノ、 |ノ F「´ ub∥c―Statc orFlorida missioned Name of Notary Public 0●●ty CIα+PaEe 2 of 2 5.A.2.a Packet Pg. 17 Attachment: CESD20230003212 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST (28257 : CESD20230003212 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28258) DOC ID: 28258 Updated: 3/7/2024 10:36 AM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CESD20230003711 Reyes CASE NO: CESD20230003711 OWNER: Maria Isabel Reyes OFFICER: Craig Cooper VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a), 10.02.06(B)(1)(e) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e)(i). An addition added to the rear of the home prior to obtaining a Collier County Building Permit. FOLIO NO: 39777040005 PROPERTY 3451 41st Ave NE, Naples, FL 34120 ADDRESS: 5.A.3 Packet Pg. 18 CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLLIER COUNTY,FLOR:DA Code Enforcement Board BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS, COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,Pla ntiff, VS MARIA ISABEL REYES,Respondent(S) Case:CESD20230003711 NOTICE OF HEARING RE:MOT10N FOR AN EXTENS:ON OF TIME PLEASE TAKE NOT:CE that Pursuantto Section 162 06 and 162 12,Flonda statutes,and Co∥er County Ordinance No 07-44,as amended,you are hereby ordered to appear at a pub∥c hearng before the Code Enforcement Board on the fo∥owing date,time,and place forthe violation below: DATE: 03/28/2024 TIME: 09:00 AM PLACE: 3299 Tamiami Tra∥East Bu∥ding F,Naples,FL 34112 V:OLAT:ON: CO Requred ATF Permls 10 02 06(Bxl)(a),100206(B)(1)(e)and 10 02 06(B)(1)(e)(り LOCAT:ON OFV:OLAT10N: 3451 41st AVE NE,Naples,34120 SERVED: MARIA ISABEL REYES,Respondent Craig Cooper, Issuing Officer RESPONDENTS ARE REQU:RED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE・ HEAR:NG CONFERENCE HEAR:NGS TO BECiN AT 9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE thatthe a∥eged violator may produce any and a∥documents,wlnesses and/or evidence to be relied upon forthe testimony given atthe hearing Documents w∥l consist ofthe or ginal and three copies A∥eged violators have the rightto be represented by an atto「ney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOT:CE that Requests for Coninuances w∥l not be considered r nOt received by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board atleast ive(5)business days p“orto the date setforthe heanng :T:S FURTHER ADViSED that Ordinance No 0744,as amended,be reviewed pttorto your atlendance atthe hea市 ng to include emphasis on section Eight relating to the appeal process Helen Buch∥on COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Ho「seshoe Drive Naples,Florda 34104 (239)252‐5892 Telephone AnyOne whO requires an auxllary ald or service for effect ve communication or other reasonable accommodat ons to participate in this prOceeding, should contactthe cOn er cOunly Fac“t es Management Division,located at 3335 Tamiami Tra]E,Suite 1 01,Naples Florda 34112,o「(239)252‐8380 as soon as possible but no late「than 48 hours before the scheduled event Such reasOnable accommodat ons Ⅷ∥be provided at no costtO the individual NOTIFICAC10N:Esta audiencia sera conducida en elidioma lngles Servicios the traduccion no seran dispOnibles en la audiencia y usted sera responsable de provee「su prOpio traduclo「,para un mel。「entend miento con las comunicaciOnes de este evento Po「favo「traiga su p「oplo traductor AVETISMAN: Tout odisyon yo f01 an anglё Nou pan gin mOun pou re tiadiksyon Sl ou pa palё anglё tanpr vini avek yOn intё prё t pOu palё pou_Ou 5.A.3.a Packet Pg. 19 Attachment: CESD20230003711 Reyes (28258 : CESD20230003711 Reyes) 工NSTR 6484028 0R 63■■ PCCLERK OF THE CIRCuIT CouRTREC S27 00 ■460 RECORDED ■2/6/2023 ■:0■ PM PACES AND COMPTROLLER, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY.FLORIDA BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Pctitioner, Casc No CESD20230003711 ORDER THE CODE ENFORCEMEN RD Board (the "Board") for public hcaring on Novembcr 17, 2023, and the Board, having heard oath, reccived evidcnce and hcard argumcnt respective lo all appropriate matiers, hereupon issues its ofFact, conclusions ofLaw, and order ofthe Board as follows: l Rcspondem●),MaHa lsabd Rcyes,is/arp4h19,■S)Ofぬ C Suttea prOpctt lthc“PrOpcげ ') THISCAUSEcamcbcro17 2 1i:i:1馘 ∥liha宙 ngbeennOIncdofthe`う ||ゥリ ibyCCrtlttdmallandpOS・ ng・ dld・ Ot appCar atthC~puttc hcarlお ξ ~ /ク.'PHγ 儡上梅語:i鷺器:瞥 :総羅穏島漱鰍l器 ■FR:::∥思黒帯:婚 :1朋『け柵 4. The Propcrty locatcd at 3451 4l'' Ave' NE, NaPles,ゆlio No 39777040005(Lcgal Dcscription: GOLDEN CATE EST UNIIT 62 W 75Fr OF TR 58)is tion of Collier County Land DeveloPmcnt Code,Ord No 04イ :,as amcndcd,Sec"ons 10.0206(3x )(C),and lo 02 06(B)(1)(e)(1), in the following paniculars: A.r addialon added to the resr of the home prior to oblslnhg s Ca ar qounty Bulldlng Permit' 5. The violation(s) has/havc not been abated as ofthe date ofthis hcaring;J 7^ ,,) CONCLUSIONS OF LAW -/ Based upon the foregoiog facts, the Board makes the following Conclusions of L#;1All notices were properly and timely issued, and thc Board hasjurisdiction pursuagxcichlpter 162, Florida Surutes, and Chaptci 2, Anicle IX, Code ofLaws and Ordinanccs ofCollier County, Florida' The preponderance ofthe evidence shows that violalion(s) ofcolliff county Lsnd Development code, ord. No. ol-ar, as amended, Sections I 0'02.06(8)( I Xa), lO.O2.O6(BXl)(c), and 10'02'06(8)( I )(exi), do/docs exist, snd that Respondent(s) commined, and was/wcre rcsponsiblc for maintaining or allowinS thc violation(s) to continue as ofthc date ofthis hcaring. ORDER Page I of2 5.A.3.a Packet Pg. 20 Attachment: CESD20230003711 Reyes (28258 : CESD20230003711 Reyes) OR 63■■ PC ■46■ Based upon the foregoing Findings ofFact and Conclusions ofLaw, and pursuanl lo the authority $anted in Chapler 162, Flo;ida Sututcs, and Chaptei 2, lni"l" Ix, Cod" ofLaws and Ordinances ofCollier County, Florida, it is hcrcby ORDERED that: A, Respondenr(s) is/8re found guilty ofviolating Collier County Laod Developmetrt Codc, Ord. No. 04-41, as am;nded, Sectioos lO.O2.06(8)( l)(a), 10.02.06(8)(l)(c), and 10.02.06(BX I XeXD. B. Respondent(s) must abate all violations by obtaining all required Collier County Building Permit(s), Demolition -iermir(s), Inspections, 8nd Cenificate of Completion/Occupancy to keep or remove the to thsrcar ofthe homc on or before Mry 15, 2024, or s line ofS250.00 per day will day the violation(s) remain thcrcafler. cOmply with this Ordcr,Collicr County may abatc thc violatlon(s)using any mcthod to bring thc enforce thc fl Personally Known oR 0 Produced Identificatior Type of Identification ProducedD 聯膨徊 ofNotary Public)l\ PAYMENT OF FINES: Any fines ordered to be paid pursuant to this Ord-er lav be paidi{ rhe 99t]i:t- 9:"iY Sgd" WWW COlliCrcountvn口 ov Any rclease oflicn or confl●llation ofcompliancc or confI口 nation or ofthis Order may also be obtained at this location. AEE&!Li Any aggrieved party may appeal a final ordcrofthe Board to thc Circuit Court within thirty @ffis of the exccution iiiilfria-", uip.i'i.d. en'appeal sirait not bc a hcaring de novo, but shall bc limited to appcllate review ofthc rccord created wirhio rhe orijinal hearing. iiis the responsibility ofthe appcaling party to obtain a lranscribed record ofthc hearing from the Clerk ofCouns. Filing 6n appeal will not automatically stay this Order' CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE l HEREBY CERTIFY thata m,a,d cottβ tCOpy oFtヽ ORDER has becn scntby U S Mailto:MaHa lsabcl Rcycs,345141“ Ave. NE, Naples, FL 3412'g,ot* \WAbE1L--Z/1- 2023. unpermitted Rcsp●ndentisordcrcd16payOpcrationalcostsincurcd inthcprosccu■on ofthis casc in thc amount orS59.28 :LIi鷲 8:濡罵IttT瀾黒を憩漱犠罵常illi器 iTttt漱鵠毬A;1選 n::fb・ CmC“°負hc DONE AND ORDEREDl日 ζノ 'dny Or A/2,ガふ ` .2023■ Ctttr Counり ,日 oH砿ぼ篤霧鳳I Page 2 of2C‐ 3 5.A.3.a Packet Pg. 21 Attachment: CESD20230003711 Reyes (28258 : CESD20230003711 Reyes) ☆オlt OR 63■■ PG ■462 '■'BOARD OF COUNTY COMMiSS10NERS Co∥ier County,Flo膚 da Pettioner, VS MAR:A:SABEL REYES RespOndent(S), Before me, lhe Case No CESD20230003711 lsabel Reyes, on behalf of herself, enters into this Stipulation and Agreement 翼∫詔Fl::」:HN晟量1'1:り bl',デ I∥ °n of Nolces ofヽ ■olat on h reference lcase)number(〕ESD20230003711 u`ιじu“口u●yu M`"`υ f:レ /｀、 This agreementis sublectto the,静めVal ofthe Code Enforcement Board,I relected,case w∥l be presented at nrst insゃ nce∥iS highly recom品 ende,ttatthe Respondent(S)。「Authorセ ed Representative be present forthe Proceedings. - / ln consideration of the disposition andfsotution of the matters outlined in said Notice(s) of Molation for which a Hearing is cunently scheduled for NovempeI '17, 2O23i to promote efliciency in the administration of the Code Enforcement process; and to obtain a quick andexpeditious resolution ofthe matters outlined therein lhe parties hereto agree as follows: 1) The violations noted in the referenced lptfce of Molation are of the Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sectiott 10.02.06(BX1Xa), Seclion 10.02.00(BXlXe) and Section190206(Bx 'T'T'釧 Code 04‐41, as amended, Section 19 o2 06(Bxlxa), SeCtiOn 10 02 06(Bxlxe) and Section ltl:∫ま鷺〈|∬ d ttpulateわ訥ёで声,T'md hdl陥 "been proptty ttlfed凶にmtt b THEREFORE, it is agreed between the parties that )Sha∥;2) 3) 4) .,. Pay operational costs in the amount of $59.28 inec days of lhis headng. be imposed unlil the violation is abated. and made during the workweek. lf the violation is abated 24 hours pri-df tP.a Sqturday, Sunday or legal holiday, then the notification must be made on the next day that is not a Saturday,or legal holiday.) That rthe RespOndent(S)falに tO abate the宙 dalonthe CoЧ nw mayF"短輛 ,シリ a101燿 inqTy"Pth9d RespondentlSl must nOtfy Code Enforcement w l■ 1241腸獣激1:]鷲 :lTI:l::ζ ∥:l℃」llil:Iξ :サ iまthe investigator perfo∥:l a site inspection to conlrr That itthe Respondent(s) fails to abate lhe violation the County may abale the Violation ttsing any metnod to bring the violation into compliance and may use the assislance of the Colliir pounty Sheriff s Office to enforcE the provisions of this agreement anil all costs of abatement shall be 59-gessed to the property pondeirtbr Repre for Thomas landimarino, Director Code Enforcement Division `ι 玉 Rbspondeht or Repre ntative (print) Date REV l1706/2018 Building Permit(s) or Demolition 5.A.3.a Packet Pg. 22 Attachment: CESD20230003711 Reyes (28258 : CESD20230003711 Reyes) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28261) DOC ID: 28261 Updated: 3/7/2024 10:51 AM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CEA20230008937 Trevino CASE NO: CEA20230008937 OWNER: Ramiro Trevino OFFICER: Jason Packard VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 4.02.07. Over allowable limit of 2 hooved animals per acre. FOLIO NO: 758840004 PROPERTY 11175 Tomato Rd, Naples, FL 34114 ADDRESS: 5.D.1 Packet Pg. 23 CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLLIER COUNTY,FLOR:DA Code Enforcement Board Case:CEA20230008937BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS, COLL ER COUNTY,FLORIDA,P a nlff, VS RAMIRO TREVINO,RespOndent(S) NOTICE OF HEARING PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that Pursuantto Secton 162 06 and 162 12,Flonda statutes,and Co er County Ordinance No 07‐44, as amended, you are hereby ordered to appear at a pub∥c hearng before the Code Enforcement Board on the fo∥ow ng date,tme,and place forthe violat on belowi DATE: 03/28′2024 TIME: 09:00 AM PLACE: 3299 Tamiaml Tra∥East Bu∥dng F,Naples,FL 34112 V10LAT10N: An mals‐Ag 4 02 07 LOCAT:ON OF ViOLAT10N: 11175 Tomato RD,Nap es,FL 34114 SERVED: RAMIRO TREVINO,Respondent 」ason Packard, lssuing Ofrcer RESPONDENTS ARE REQUIRED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEARINC CONFERENCE HEARINGS TO BEG:N AT9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTiCE thatthe a∥eged violator may produce any and a∥documents,wttnesses and/or evidence to be re ied upon forthe testimony given atthe hearing Documents w∥l consist ofthe original and three copies A∥eged violators have the rightto be represented by an attorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTiCE that Requests for Conunuances w∥l not be considered r nOt received by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board atleast ive(5)bus neSS days p“orto the date set forthe heattng iT IS FURTHER ADViSED that Ordlnance No 0744,as amended,be reviewed pnorto your attendance atthe heanng to include emphasis on Sect on Eight relating to the appeal process Helen Buch∥on COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe D百 ve Naples,Florda 34104 (239)252-5892 Telephone Anyone who requ res an auxilary ald or service for effective communical on.o「other reasonable accommodat ons to partlcipate in this proceeding should contactthe Co ler County FaCilt es Management Division,located at 3335 Tamiami Tral E Suite 101,Naples Flo「da 34112.o『(239)252- 8380 as soon as possible but no laterthan 48い ours befo「e the scheduled event Such「easonable accommodations w∥lbe p「ovided at no costto the individual NOTIFICAC10N:Esta audiencia sera conducida en elidioma lngies Serviclos the traduccion no seran dispOnibles en la audiencia y usted sera responsable de proveer su prop,o traducto「,para un melo「entendimiento con las cclmunicaciones de este evento Po「rav。「t「aiga su p「Opio lraductor AVETISMAN: Toul odisyon yO fё t an anglё Nou pan gin moun pou rё tradiksyon Sl ou pa palё angle tanp「 vini avOk yon intё pret pOu pa10 pou―ou 5.D.1.a Packet Pg. 24 Attachment: CEA20230008937 Trevino (28261 : CEA20230008937 Trevino) Case Number: CEA20230008937 Date: November 08, 2023 lnvestigator: Jason Packard Phone:2393803777 COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT NOTICE OF VIOLATION Owner: TREVINO, RAMIRO 1 1175 TOMATO RD NAPLES, FL 34114 Location: '11175 Tomato RD, Naples Unincorporated Collier County Zoning Dist: A Property Legal Description: 16 51 27 SE1/4 OF SE1/4 OF NE'l/4 OF NE1l421l2 AC Folio:758840004 NOTICE Pursuant to Collier County Consolidated Code Enforcement Regulations, Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances, Chapter 2, Article lX, you are notified that a violation(s) of the following Collier County Ordinance(s) and or PUD Regulation(s) exists at the above-described location. Ordinance/Code: Standards for keeping animals. Collier County Land Development Code 0441 , as amended. Section 4.02.07 AZoning District (lndividual Property Owner) Poultry or fowl--Total of25 Horses and livestock-2 peracre Hogs- None: Violation Status - lnitial DESCRIPTION OF CONDTTTONS CONSTTTUTTNG THE VTOLATTON(S). Oid Witness: Over allowable limit of 2 hooved animals per acre ORDER TO CORRECT VIOLATION(S): You are directed by this Notice to take the following corrective action(s): 1 . Remove poultry or fowl in excess of the permissible 25 or less from property by the date specified on this notice AND / OR Remove horses and/or livestock in excess of the permissible 2 per acre or less from property by the date specified on this notice AND / OR Remove all hogs from property by the date specified on this notice. ON OR BEFORE: '1112112023 Failure to correct violations may result in: 1) Mandatory notice to appear or issuance of a citation that may result in fines up lo $500 and costs of prosecution. OR 2) Code Enforcement Board review that may result in fines up to $1000 per day per violation, as long as the violation remains, and costs of prosecution. SERVED BY:INQUIRIES AND COMMENTS SHOULD BE 5.D.1.a Packet Pg. 25 Attachment: CEA20230008937 Trevino (28261 : CEA20230008937 Trevino) ″‐2妨ノ DIRECTED TO CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe Dr,Naples,FL 34104 Phone:239252-2440 FAX:239252‐2343lnvestigator Signature Jason Packard Case Number: CEA20230008937 Signature and Title of Recipient Printed Name of Recipient Oate *This violatioh may require additional compliance and approval from other departments which may be required under local, stale and federal regulations, including, but not limited to: right-of-way permit, building permit, demolition of structure, Site Development Plan, lnsubstantial Change to Site Development Plan, and Vadances along with, payment of impact fees, and any new or outstanding tees required for approval. 5.D.1.a Packet Pg. 26 Attachment: CEA20230008937 Trevino (28261 : CEA20230008937 Trevino) Agricu ltural On parcels less than 20 acres Poultry or fowl-Total of 25 Horses and livestock-2 per acre Poultry or fowl-Total of 251 Horses and livestock-2 per acrel 4.O2.O7 Standards for Keeping Animals l Enclosures sha∥be a minimum ofthirty(30)feet frOm any:ot iine,and a minimum of one hundred(100) feet from any residence on an adiacent parcei 2see LDC section 2 03 01 A l a 2 1.b.i 3see LDC section 2.03.01B.1.b.4.1. (Ord.No.14-40′§28) (Supp No 27) Page 1 of 1 created: 2023-08-31 09:40:15 [EST] Zoning District Maximum Number of Animals Estates 5.D.1.a Packet Pg. 27 Attachment: CEA20230008937 Trevino (28261 : CEA20230008937 Trevino) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28269) DOC ID: 28269 Updated: 3/7/2024 10:54 AM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CESD20230008967 Trevino CASE NO: CESD20230008967 OWNER: Ramiro Trevino OFFICER: Jason Packard VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a), 10.02.06(B)(1)(e) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e)(i). Horse stalls, chicken coops and other accessory structures constructed without Collier County Permits and/or Approvals. FOLIO NO: 758840004 PROPERTY 11175 Tomato Rd, Naples, FL 34114 ADDRESS: 5.D.2 Packet Pg. 28 CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLL:ER COUNTY,FLOR:DA Code Enforcement Board BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS, COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,Plainlff, VS RAMIRO TREVINO,Respondent(S) Case:CESD20230008967 NOTICE OF HEARING PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that Pursuant to Section 162.06 and 162.12, Florida Statutes, and Collier County Ordinance No. 0744, as amended, you are hereby ordered to appear at a public hearing before the Code Enforcement Board on the following date, time, and place for the violation below: DATE: 0312812024 TIME: 09:00 AM PLACE: 3299 Tamiami Trail East Building F, Naples, FL 34'112 VIOLATION: CO Required ATF Permits 10.02.06(BXl Xa), 10.02.06(8Xl )(e) and 10.02.06(8)(1Xe)(i) LOCATION OF VIOLATION: 1 1175 Tomato RD, Naples, FL 34114 SERVED: RAMIRO TREVINO, Respondent Jason Packard, lssuing Officer RESPONDENTS ARE REQUIRED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE-HEARING CONFERENCE HEARINGS TO BEGIN AT 9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that the alleged violator may produce any and all documents, witnesses and/or evidence to be relied upon for the testimony given at the hearing. Documents will consist of the original and three copies. Alleged violators have the right to be represented by an attorney. PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that Requests for Continuances will not be considered if not received by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board at least five (5) business days prior to the date set for the hearing. tT lS FURTHER ADVISED that Ordinance No. 0744, as amended, be reviewed prior to your attendance at the hearing to include emphasis on Section Eight relating to the appeal process. Helen Buchillon COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, Florida 34104 (239) 252-5892 Telephone Anyone who requires an auxiliary aid or service for effective communicalion. or other reasonable accommodations to parlicipate in this proceeding, should contact the Collier Counly Facilities Managemenl Division, located at 3335 Tamiami Trail E., Suite 101, Naples. Flotida 34112. ot \2391252- 8380, as soon as possible, but no later than 48 hours before the scheduled evenl. Such reasonable accommodations will be provided at no cost to the individual. NOTIFICACION: Esta audiencia sera conducida en el idioma lngles. Servicios the traduccion no seran disponibles en la audiencia y usled sera responsable de proveer su propio traductor, para un mejor entendimiento con las comunicaciones de este evenlo. Por favor traiga su propio kaductor. AVETISMAN: Tout odisyon yo fet an angle. Nou pan gin moun pou fe tadiksyon. Si ou pa pale angB tanpri vini avek yon intdpret pou pale pou-ou. 5.D.2.a Packet Pg. 29 Attachment: CESD20230008967 Trevino (28269 : CESD20230008967 Trevino) Case Number: C8SD20230008967 Date: November 08, 2023 lnvestigator: Jason Packard Phone:2393803777 COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT NOTIGE OF VIOLATION Owner: TREVINO, RAMIRO 11,175 TOMATO RD NAPLES. FL 34114 Location: 1 'l 175 Tomato RD, Naples Unincorporated Collier County Zoning Dist: A Property Legal Description: '16 51 27 SE1/4 OF SE1/4 OF NE1/4 OF NE1l421l2AC Folio:758840004 NOTICE Pursuant to Collier County Consolidated Code Enforcement Regulations, Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances, Chapter 2, Article lX, you are notified that a violation(s) of the following Collier County Ordinance(s) and or PUD Regulation(s) exists at the abovedescribed location. Ordinance/Code: Building and Land Alteration Permits. (Permits, lnspections, Certificate of Occupancy Required) Collier County Land Development Code 04-41 , as amended, Section 10.02.06(8)( l )(a) The County Manager or his designee shall be responsible for determining whether applacations for building or land alteration permits, as required by the Collier County Building code or this Code are in accord with the requirements of this Code, and no building or land alteration permit shall be issued without written approval that plans submitted conform to applicable zoning regulations, and other land development regulations. For purposes of this section a land alteration permit shall mean any written authorization to alter land and for which a building permit may not be required. Examples include but are not limited to clearing and excavation permits, site development plan approvals, agricultural clearing permits, and blasting permits. No building or structure shall be erected, moved, added to, altered, utilized or allowed to exist and/or no land alteration shall be permitted without first obtaining the authorization of the required permit(s), inspections and c€rtificate(s) of occupancy as required by the Collier County Building Code or this Code: Submittal Requirements for Permits. Building or Land Alteration Permits. lmprovement of property prohibited prior to issuance of building permit. Collier County Land Development Code 04-41 as amended, Section 10.02.06(BXl Xe) lmprovement of property prohibited prior to issuance of building permit. No site work, removal of protected vegetation, grading, improvement of property or construction of any type may be commenced prior to the issuance of a building permit where the development proposed requires a building permit under this Land development Code or other applicable county regulations... : Submittal Requirements for Permits. Building or Land Alteration Permits. lmprovement of property prohibited prior to issuance of building permit. Collier County Land Development Code 04-41 as amended, Section 10.02.06(B)(1XeXi) Must obtain all required inspections and certificate of occupancy/completion within 60 days of permit issuance.: Violation Status - lnitial DESCRTPTTON OF CONDTTlONS CONSTITUTING THE VIOLATION(S). Did Witness: Horse stalls, chicken coops and other accessory structures constructed without Collier County Permits and/or Approvals. ORDER TO CORRECT VIOLATION(S): You are directed by this Notice to take the following corrective action(s): 5.D.2.a Packet Pg. 30 Attachment: CESD20230008967 Trevino (28269 : CESD20230008967 Trevino) 1. Must obtain all required Collier County Building Permit(s) or Demolition permit(s) and request all inspections through Certificate of Completion/Occupancy for described structure/ alteration. 2. Must be in compliance with all Collier County Codes and Ordinances. Apply for and obtain ali permits required for described structure/improvements AND / OR Must remove said structure/improvements, including materials from property and restore to a permitted state. ON OR BEFORE: 't210812023 Failure to correct violations may result in: 1) Mandatory notice to appear or issuance of a citation that may result in fines up to $500 and costs of prosecution. OR 2) Code Enforcement Board review that may result in fines up to $1000 per day per violation, as long as the violation remains, and costs of prosecution. SERVED BY: INQUIRIES AND COMMENTS SHOULD BE DIRECTED TO CODE ENFORCEI\iIENT 1444,.?6.lz.4d2800NorthHorseshoeDr'Naples'FL341O4 lnvestigator Signature Jason Packard Case Number: cESD20230008967 Signature and Title of Recipient Printed Name of Recipient Date tThis violaiion may require addilional compliance and approval from oiher departments which may be required under local, state and federal regulations, including, but not limited to: right-of-way permit, building permit, demolition of structure, Site Developmeni Plan, lnsubstantial Change to Site Oevelopment Plan, and Variances along with, payment of impact fees, and any new or outstanding fees requi.ed for approval. Phonei 239 252-2440 FAX:239252-2343 5.D.2.a Packet Pg. 31 Attachment: CESD20230008967 Trevino (28269 : CESD20230008967 Trevino) The Collier County Land Development Code, 2004-41, As Amended 10.02.06 - Requirements for Permits B. Building Permit or Land Alteration Permit. Building or land alteration permit and certificate of occupancy compliance process. a. Zoning action on building or land slteration permits. The County Manager or his designee shall be responsible for determining whether applications for building or land alteration permits, as required by the Collier County Building code or this Code are in accord with the requirements of this Code, and no building or land alteration permit shall be issued without written approval that plans submitted conform to applicable zoning regulations, and other land development regulations. For purposes of this section a land alteration permit shall mean any written authorization to alter land and for which a building permit may not be required. Examples include but are not limited to clearing and excavation permits, site development plan approvals, agricultural clearing permits, and blasting permits. No building or structure shall be erected, moved, added to, altered, utilized or allowed to exist and/or no land alteration shall be permitted without first obtaining the authorization of the required permit(s), inspections and certificate(s) of occupancy as required by the Collier County Building Code or this Code and no building or land alteration permit application shall be approved by the County Manager or his designee for the erection, moving, addition to, or alteration ofany building, structure, or land except in conformity with the provisions of this Code unless he shall receive a written order from the Board of Zoning Appeals in the form of an administrative review of the interpretation, or variances as provided by this Code, or unless he shall receive a written order from a court or tribunal of competent jurisdiction. B.Building Permil or Land Alterqtion Permit. Building or land alteration permit and certificate of occupancy compliance process. Improvement of property prohibited prior to issuance of building pernil. No site work, removal of protected vegetation, grading, improvement of property or construction of any type may be commenced prior to the issuance of a building permit where the development proposed requires a building permit under this Land development Code or other applicable county regulations. Exceptions to this requirement may be granted by the County Manager or his designee for an approved subdivision or site development plan to provide for distribution of fill excavated on- site or to permit construction of an approved water management system, to minimize stockpiles and hauling off-site or to protect the public health, safety and welfare where clearing, grading and filling plans have been submitted and approved meeting the warrants of section 4.06.04 A. of this Code; removal of exotic vegetation shall be exempted upon receipt of a vegetation removal permit for exotics pursuant to Chapters 3 and 10. In the event the improvement of property, construction of any type, repairs or remodeling of any type that requires a building permit has been completed, all required inspection(s) and certificate(s) of occupancy must be obtained within 60 days after the issuance of after the fact permit(s). l. 5.D.2.a Packet Pg. 32 Attachment: CESD20230008967 Trevino (28269 : CESD20230008967 Trevino) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28263) DOC ID: 28263 Updated: 3/7/2024 11:00 AM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CESD20230007550 Socarras and Martinez CASE NO: CESD20230007550 OWNER: Roxana Socarras and Jorge Armando Martinez OFFICER: Maria Rodriguez VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 10.02.06(B)(1)(a). A barn, water fountain with electric, outside lights with electric and shed all erected without first obtaining the authorization of the required permit(s), inspections and certificate(s) of occupancy as required by the Collier County Building Department. FOLIO NO: 41280440009 PROPERTY 2630 18th Ave SE, Naples, FL 34117 ADDRESS: 5.D.3 Packet Pg. 33 TIME: CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLL:ER COUNTY,FLOR:DA Code Enforcement Board 80ARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS, COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,P ainuff, VS Case:CESD20230007550 ROXANA SOCARRAS AND JORGE ARMANDO MARTINEZ,Respondent(S) NOTICE OF HEAR:NG PLEASE TAKE NOTiCE that Pursuantto Seclon 162 06 and 162 12,Flonda statutes,and Co∥ier County ordinance No 0744,as amended, you are hereby ordered to appear at a pub∥c hearng before the Code Enforcement Board on the fo∥owlng date,∥me,and place forthe violation below: DATE: 03/28/2024 09 00 AM PLACE: 3299 Tamlami Tra∥East Bulding F,Naples,FL 34112 ViOLAT10N: Bu∥d ng Perml LDC 10 02 06(B)(1)(a) LOCAT10N OF V:OLAT:ON: 2630 18th AVE SE,Naples,FL 34117 SERVED: ROXANA SOCARRAS AND」ORGE ARMANDO MARTINEZ,Respondent Ma“a Rodnguez,lssuing Ofrcer RESPONDENTS ARE REQUIRED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEARING CONFERENCE HEARINGS TO BECiN AT 9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTiCE thatthe a∥eged violator may produce any and a∥documents,wlnesses and′o「 evidence tO be relied upon fOrthe testimony given atthe hear ng Documents wi∥consist ofthe original and three copies Alleged violators have the rightto be represented by an attorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that Requests for Con∥nuances w∥l not be considered if not recelved by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board atleastfive(5)business days priorto the date setforthe hearing :TiS FURTHER ADV:SED that Ordinance No 0744,as amended,be reviewed priorto your attendance atthe hearing to lnclude emphasis on Section Elght relat ng to the appeal process Helen Buch∥lon COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples,Florida 341 04 (239)252-5892 Telephone AnyOne whO requ res an auxllary aid or service ro「ereclive cOmmunicat on or other reasonable accommOdatiOns to paiticipate in this proceeding, should contaclthe Col er County Fac lles Management Div sion located at 3335 Tamiami Tra∥E,Sune lol Naples,Flo「ida 34112,o「(239)252‐8380 as soon as possible bui nO late「than 48 hours before the scheduled event Such reasonable accommodat ons m∥be provided at no cOstto the individual NOTlFiCAC10N:Esta audiencia sera conducida en elidioma lngles Servicios the traducdon no seran disponibles en la audiencia y usled sera 欝:ギ l識躍Чま器 ′器:1卵 ∬踏寵::馬 Pttlittr裾鴨服:サ :lT]Ul:『:'F:黒撚 =11ぶ鴨羊%|::湾 1::∫翼翼:'° に 5.D.3.a Packet Pg. 34 Attachment: CESD20230007550 Socarras and Martinez (28263 : CESD20230007550 Socarras and Martinez) Case Number:CESD20230007550 0ate:November 28,2023 investigator:Maria Rodriguez Phone:239-877‐8112 COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT NOTiCE OF V:OLAT:ON Owner SOCARRAS,ROXANA JORGE ARMANDO MAR丁 INEZ 263018TH AVE SE NAPLES,FL 34117 Location:2630 18th AVE SE,Naples unincOrpOrated Co∥:er County Zoning Dist:E Propery Legal Descriptlon:GOLDEN GATE EStt UNI丁 87 TR 10 Folio:41280440009 NOT]CE Pursuant to Collier County Consolidated Code Enforcement Regulations, Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances, Chapter 2, Article lX, you are notified that a violation(s) of the following Collier County Ordinance(s) and or PUD Regulation(s) exists at the abovedescribed location. Ordinance/Code: Building and Land Alteration Permits. (Permits, lnspections, Certificate of Occupancy Required) Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 10.02.06(BX1)(a) The County Manager or his designee shall be responsible for determining whether applications for building or land alteration permits, as required by the Collier County Building code or this Code are in accord with the requirements of this Code, and no building or land alteration permit shall be issued without written approval that plans submitted conform to applicable zoning regulations, and other land development regulations. For purposes of this section a land alteration permit shall mean any written authorization to alter land and for which a building permit may not be required. Examples include but are not limited to clearing and excavation permits, site development plan approvals, agricultural clearing permits, and blasting permits. No building or structure shall be erected, moved, added to, altered, utilized or allowed to exist and/or no land alteration shall be permitted without first obtaining the authorization of the required permit(s), inspections and certificate(s) of occupancy as required by the Collier County Building Code or this Code : Violation Status - lnitial DESCRTPTTON OF CONDITTONS CONSTTTUTTNG THE V|OLAT|ON(S). Did Witness: A barn, water fountain with electric, outside lights with electric and shed all erected without first obtaining the authorization of the required permit(s), inspections and certificate(s) of occupancy as required by the Collier County Building Department. ORDER TO CORRECT VIOLATION(S): You are directed by this Notice to take the following corrective action(s):1. Must obtain all required Collier County Building Permit(s) or Demolition permit(s) and request all inspections through Certificate of Completion/Occupancy for described structure/ alteration. ON OR BEFORE: 1A2A2023 Failure to correct violations may result in: 1) Mandatory notice to appear or issuance of a citation that may result in fines up to $500 and costs of prosecution. OR 5.D.3.a Packet Pg. 35 Attachment: CESD20230007550 Socarras and Martinez (28263 : CESD20230007550 Socarras and Martinez) t・ 2) Code Enforcement Board review that may result in fines up to ilO00 per day per violation, as long as the violation remains, and costs of prosecution SERVED 8YI 笏 … INQUIRIES AND COMMENTS SHOuLD 8E DIRECTED TO CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe Dr,Naples,FL 34104 2440 FAX1239 252‐2343,nvestigator Signature Maria Rodriguez Case Numb€r: Si 'Thls violatlon lnay r.quiro addltlonal cornpllanco and approval from other depa.tmenb which may tg raqulred under local, ctlte and tederal rogultlion3, lncludlng, but not lirtited to: raght-of'way permit, bulldlng poihit, dsmolilion ot atructure, Sito Dsvolopmonl Pl.n, lnsubslantlal Chango to Sllo Dovolopmont Plan, and Varlancos along wiih, paym€nl ol lmpacl teea, end any now or oubtanding fee. rsquired foi approval. PIWl.め mepf Recipienl さ \ /.)1'.t > 5.D.3.a Packet Pg. 36 Attachment: CESD20230007550 Socarras and Martinez (28263 : CESD20230007550 Socarras and Martinez) The Collier County Land Development Code, 200441, As Amended '10.02.06 - Requirements for Permits B. Building Pemit or Land Alteration Permit. 1. Building or land alteration permit and certificate of occupancy compliance process. a. Zoning action on buitding or land alteration petmits. The County Manager or his designee shall be responsible for determining whether applications for building or land alteration permits, as required by the Collier County Building code or this Code are in accord with the requirements of this Code, and no building or land alteration permit shall be issued without written approval that plans submifted conform to applicable zoning regulations, and other land development regulations. For purposes of this section a land alteration permit shall mean any written authorization to alter land and for which a building permit may not be required. Examples include but are not limited to clearing and excavation permats, site development plan approvals, agricultural clearing permits, and blasting permits. No building or structure shall be erected, moved, added to, altered , utilized or allowed to exist and/or no land alteration shall be permitted without first obtaining the authorization of the required permit(s), inspections and certiflcate(s) of occupancy as required by the Collier County Building Code or this Code and no building or land alteration permit application shall be approved by the County Manager or his designee for the erection, moving, addition to, or alteration of any building , structure , or land except in conformity with the provisions of this Code unless he shall receive a wriften order from the Board of Zoning Appeals in the form of an administrative review of the interpretation, or variances as provided by this Code, or unless he shall receive a written order from a court or tribunal of competent jurisdiction. 5.D.3.a Packet Pg. 37 Attachment: CESD20230007550 Socarras and Martinez (28263 : CESD20230007550 Socarras and Martinez) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28266) DOC ID: 28266 Updated: 3/7/2024 11:04 AM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CESD20230007241 Peterman and Eddy CASE NO: CESD20230007241 OWNER: Richard Brian Peterman and Cynthia Marie Eddy OFFICER: Jason Packard VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a), 10.02.06(B)(1)(e) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e)(i). Interior renovations including but not limited to plumbing and electrical work completed prior to issuance of appropriate Collier County permits/approvals. FOLIO NO: 76775001724 PROPERTY 6900 Anthurium LN, Naples, FL 34113 ADDRESS: 5.D.4 Packet Pg. 38 CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLL:ER COUNTY,FLORIDA Code Enforcement Board BOARD OF COUNTY COMMiSS10NERS, COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,P ainlfF, Casei CESD20230007241 VS RICHARD BRIAN PETERMAN AND CYNTHlA MARIE EDDY,Respondent(S) NOT:CE OF HEARING PLEASE TAKE NOT:CE that Pursuantto Section 162 06 and 162 12,Flonda statutes,and Co er County ordinance No 0744, as amended,you are hereby ordered to appear at a pub∥c hearng before the Code Enforcement Board on the fo∥owing date,time,and place forthe violation below: DATE: 03/28/2024 TIME: 09:00 AM PLACE: 3299 Tam ami Tra∥East Bu ding F,Naples,FL 34112 V:OLAT!ON: CO Requred ATF Permts 10 02 06(B)(1)(a),100206(B)(1)(e)and 10 02 06(B)(1)(e)0) LOCAT10N OF ViOLAT10N: 6900 Anthu百 um LN,Naples,FL 34113 SERVED: RICHARD BRIAN PETERMAN AND CYNTHIA MARIE EDDY,RespOndent 」ason Packard, lssuing Officer RESPONDENTS ARE REQU:RED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEARING CONFERENCE HEAR:NCS TO BEG:N AT9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOT:CE thatthe a∥eged violator may produce any and a∥documents,wttnesses and/or evidence to be relied upon forthe testimony given atthe hearing Documents w∥l consist ofthe original and three copies A∥eged violators have the rightto be represented by an atto「ney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOT:CE that Requests for Conlnuances w∥l not be considered if not received by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board atleast five(5)business days priorto the date setforthe hearing iTiS FURTHER ADV:SED that Ordinance No 0744,as amended,be reviewed pHo「to your attendance atthe heattng to include emphasis on Section Eight relat ng to the appeal process Helen Buch∥lon COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe Dttve Naples,Florida 341 04 (239)252‐5892 Telephone Anyone who requires an auxi“ary ald or service for ereclive communicat on o「other reasonable accommodations lo participate in this p「。ceeding, should contactthe Col er County FaCllies Management Div sion,located at 3335 Tamiami Tra∥E Sume lol Naples Flolda 34112.or(239)252- 8380 as soon as possible,but no laterthan 48 hou「s berore the scheduled event Such「easonable accommodations u∥be p「ovided at no costto the individual NOTIFICAC10N:Esta audiencia sera conducida en elidioma lngles Serviclos the traduccion no seran dispOnibles en la audiencia y usted sera responsable de provee「su prOpio t「aducto「,para un melor entendimiento con las comunicaciones de este evento Porfavo「tra,9a su proplo traducto「 AVETiSMAN: Tout odisyon yo fet an ang10 Nou pan gin moun pou Fe tradiksyOn Si ou pa paiё anglё tanpri vini aVё k yon intOpret pOu pa10 pOu―ou 5.D.4.a Packet Pg. 39 Attachment: CESD20230007241 Peterman and Eddy (28266 : CESD20230007241 Peterman and Eddy) Caso Num5or:CES●2●230007241 Date:Augllst 25,2023 inV03tlgato「」ason Packard Pい one:2393803777 COLLIER COuNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT NOTICC OF V10LAT:ON Owner:PETERMAN.RICHARD 8R:AN CYNTHIA MAR:E EDDY 6900 ANTHURIUM LN NAPLES FL 34113 Locatlon:6900 Anthudum LN,Naples uninc●rp●rated Co∥lo7 COunty 2●nl●90,st:PUD P′opedy Lega!Descriptio■:TICER ISLAND ESTATES LOT 62 Fo::o:7677500,724 Pursuant lo Colller County Consolldat€d Cod€ Enfor€emonl Regulailons, Cqlller County Code ol Laws ard Ordlnancoa, Chapter 2, Arllcls lX, you are noillled that a vlolatlon(s) of lhe lollowlng Colllor County Ordlnanqe(s) and o. PUD Rogulaiion(s) oxlsts at the abovedescrlbod locatlon. Ordlnanca/Code: guilding and Land Alteration Permils. (Permits, lnspections, Certificate of Occupancy Required) Colli€r County Land Development Code 04'41, as am€nded, Section 10.02.06(8)(1Xa) The Counly Managoror his designoe shallbe responsible fordetermining whether appllcations for buildlng or laad altordtion poamils. as roquired by lho Co,lasr County Building code or lhis Code are in acctrd with the requiGments of this fue. and no building or land alleralion pormit 6hall b€ issued without writlan app.oval lhat plans submitted confom lo appicablo zoning rogulalions, and olher land development regulallons. For pu.poses ol this seclion a ,and alteralion pomil shallmoan any writon author'Ealjon lo alld land and for which I building p6rmit may nol bo raquirec,. Examples includg bul aro not limlted lo deadng and e)rcavation pelmils, sito d6volopment plan appaovals, &gricuttural doanng psrmits, and blasting p6rmil5. No building o. sltuciure shallbe erecled, movod, sdded to. allsred. ulilizod or allowed to exist and/or no land alleration shallbe pormltlod wilhoul firsi obtaining ths authorization ofthe required psrmit{s). inspoctions and c4rtificato{s)ot oclupanc} as rcqukod by lhe Collier Couniy Eullding Cods or lhls Codo : Suborittal Requirements tor Permils. Building or Land Alteralion Permits. lmprovement oI property prohibited prior to issuanca of burlding permil Collier County Land Development Code 04-41 as amended. Section 10.02 06(8)(1 )(e) lmprovement ol prop€rly prohibited pnor lo issuance ot building permit. No sile wglk, aomoval of prolected vegetation, qmdrng. rmprovemsnl ot propedy or canslruc{on of any rpe may be commonced paior lo lho lssuance ol a building formrt wheae ths dovelopmonl poposod requites I bualdtng p€rmil under thls Lend dovelopmgnt Codo oa olh6r apphcablo county roglhlions... : Submittal Rsquirements tor Permits. Building or Land Alleration Permits. lmprovement ot properg Drohibrted pnor to issuance ot building permil. Collier County Land Development Code 0441 as amended. Section 1 0.02.06(BXl XeXi) Must obtain all reqlred rnsp€clons and ccrtificale ot ocqJpancJ/completion wilhln 60 days of permlt issuance.: vI●latio口 Status DESCRIPT!0"OF CONO:T:ONS COltST:TUTING THE ViOLAT10N(S) ●ld Wittless: lntorl●r ranovati●●9 inc:udlng but not∥mlted to plllmblng and electr!ca:work comploted pr10「t●138uanCe of approprlata C●∥ter C●unty perrnit3rapprOva18 霧褥舌器器麗語澪響腎調器発説輛.ldbwhc corOd"O ac●o"→:5.D.4.a Packet Pg. 40 Attachment: CESD20230007241 Peterman and Eddy (28266 : CESD20230007241 Peterman and Eddy) 1. iytust obtain all required Collier County Building Permit(s) or Demolition permit(s) and request all inspections through Certificate of Completlon/Occupancy for described structure/ alteratlon. 2. Must be in mmpliance with all Collier County Codes and Ordinances. Apply for and obtain all permits required for described struclure/improvements: OR remove said structurefimprovements, including materials from property and restore to a permitted state AND / OR Must cease all improvement activitiei until suctr ltme that any and all required permits are oblained from Community Developmant and Environmental SeMces. Otl OR BEFORE: Agt24i2A23 Fallure to corroct vlolatlons may result ln: 1) Mandatory notis€ to appear or i"ru"n". ot a citation that may result in fines up to $500 and costs of proseculon.OR 2)Code Enforcement Board review that may result the violalon remainst and costs of pЮ sectltion. SERVED BY: ル“ 簿 ″ in fines up to t1000 ger day per violation' as long as lnvestigator Signature Jason Packard *ase Number. C8SD202300072'll q_受璽二丞塁 INQU:R!ES AND COMMENTS SHOuLD BE DiRECttED TO CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe Dri Nap:es,FL 34104 Date 摯薗脚撤鮮 1轟獣構測塾:馘構 of Recipient 5.D.4.a Packet Pg. 41 Attachment: CESD20230007241 Peterman and Eddy (28266 : CESD20230007241 Peterman and Eddy) The Collier County Land Development Code, 2004-41, As Amended 10.02.06 - Requirements for Permits B. Building Permit or Land Alteration Permit. l.Building or land alteration permit and certificate of occupancy compliance process. Zoning action on building or land alteration permits. The County Manager or his designee shall be responsible for determining whether applications for building or land alteration permits, as required by the Collier Counfy Building code or this Code are in accord with the requirements of this Code, and no building or land alteration permit shall be issued without written approval that plans submitted conform to applicable zoning regulations, and other land development regulations. For purposes of this section a land alteration permit shall mean any written authorization to alter land and for which a building permit may not be required. Examples include but are not limited to clearing and excavation permits, site development plan approvals, agricultural clearing permits, and blasting permits. No building or structure shall be erected, moved, added to, altered, utilized or allowed to exist and/or no land alteration shall be permitted without first obtaining the authorization of the required permit(s), inspections and certificate(s) of occupancy as required by the Collier County Building Code or this Code and no building or land alteration permit application shall be approved by the County Manager or his designee for the erection, moving, addition to, or alteration ofany truilding, structure, or land except in conformity with the provisions of this Code unless he shall receive a written order from the Board of Zoning Appeals in the form of an administrative review of the interpretation, or variances as provided by this Code, or unless he shall receive a written order from a court or tribunal of competent j urisdiction. B.Building Permit or Land Alteration Permit. l.Building or land alteration permit and certificate of occupancy compliance process. l. Improvement of property prohibited prior to issuance of building permit. No site work, removal of protected vegetation, grading, improvement of property or construction of any type may be commenced prior to the issuance of a building permit where the development proposed requires a building permit under this Land development Code or other applicable county regulations. Exceptions to this requirement may be granted by the County Manager or his designee for an approved subdivision or site development plan to provide for distribution of fill excavated on- site or to permit construction of an approved water management system, to minimize stockpiles and hauling off-site or to protect the public health, safety and welfare where clearing, grading and filling plans have been submifted and approved meeting the warrants of section 4.06.04 A. of this Code; removal of exotic vegetation shall be exempted upon receipt of a vegetation removal permit for exotics pursuant to Chapters 3 and 10. ln the event the improvement of property, construction of any type, repairs or remodeling of any type that requires a building permit has been completed, all required inspection(s) and certificate(s) of occupancy must be obtained within 60 days after the issuance of after the fact permit(s). 5.D.4.a Packet Pg. 42 Attachment: CESD20230007241 Peterman and Eddy (28266 : CESD20230007241 Peterman and Eddy) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28268) DOC ID: 28268 Updated: 3/7/2024 11:18 AM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CEVR20230008759 EDINGTON PLACE LLC CASE NO: CEVR20230008759 OWNER: EDINGTON PLACE LLC OFFICER: Doug Williams VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 3.05.01(B). Mechanical clearing vegetation on a vacant lot without a permit. FOLIO NO: 727400006 PROPERTY 1095 Barefoot Williams Rd, Naples, FL 34113 ADDRESS: 5.D.5 Packet Pg. 43 CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLL:ER COUNTY,FLOR:DA Code Enforcement Boa“d80ARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS, COLL ER COUNTY,FLORIDA,Pan∥ff, VS EDINGTON PLACE LLC,RespOndent(S) Case:CEVR20230008759 NOT:CE OF HEARING PLEASE TAKE NOTiCE that Pursuantto Section 162 06 and 162 12,Florida Statutes,and Co er County Ordinance No 07‐44, as amended,you are hereby ordered to appear at a pub∥c hearing before the Code Enforcement Board on the fo∥owing date,time,and place forthe violat on belowi DATE: 03/28/2024 T:ME: 09 00 AM PLACE: 3299 Tamiami Tra∥East Bu ding F,Nap es,FL 34112 ViOLAT10N: Vegeta∥on Remova 3 05 01(B) LOCAT:ON OFV:OLAT:ON: 1 095 BarefootllV∥iams RD,Naples,FL 34113 SERVED: EDINGTON PLACE LLC,Respondent Doug VV∥ams, lssuing officer RESPONDENTS ARE REQU:RED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEARING CONFERENCE HEARINGS TO BEGIN AT 9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTiCE thatthe a∥eged violator may produce any and a∥documents,wlnesses and′or evidence to be relied upon forthe testimony given atthe hear ng Documents w∥l consist ofthe original and three copies AIleged violators have the rightto be represented by an attorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTiCE that Requests fo「Con∥nuances w∥ not be considered if not recelved by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board atleast ive(5)bus neSS days pnorto the date setforthe heanng iT:S FURTHER ADV:SED that Ordinance No 0744,as amended,be reviewed pHorto your attendance atthe healng to include emphasis on sect on Eight relating to the appeal process Helen Buch∥on COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe Dttve Naples,Flo百 da 34104 (239)252‐5892 Telephone AnyOne vvho「equires an auxliary ald or service for efFect ve communication,。「other reasonable accommodat ons tO participate in this proceeding should contaclthe Co∥ier COunty Facl ties Management Division,located at 3335 Tamiami Tra∥E Sute lol,Naples Florda 34112,o「(239)252-8380,as soon as pOssible but no laterthan 48 hours before the scheduled event such reasonable accommodations、v∥l be provided at nO costto the individual NOTIF:CAC10N:Esta audiencia sera conducida en elidloma lngles Servicios the traducclon nO seran dispOnibles en la audiencia y usted sera responsable de proveer su p「Opio traduclor para un melor entendimiento con las cOmunicaciones de este evento PO「favor traiga su prOp10 traduclo「 AVET!SMAN: Tout odisyon yo fet an anglo Nou pan gin moun pOuた tradiksyOn Si ou pa pa16 ang10 tanp「 vini avё k yon intё p「ёt pou palё pou―ou 5.D.5.a Packet Pg. 44 Attachment: CEVR20230008759 EDINGTON PLACE LLC (28268 : CEVR20230008759 EDINGTON PLACE LLC) Case Number:CEVR20230008759 Date:October 25,2023 investigator:Doug w∥iams Phone:2398778427 COLL:ER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT NOTiCE OF V10LAT10N Owner:EDINGTON PLACE LLC PO BOX 516 MARCO ISLAND,FL 34145 Registered Agent:Hamocinc 886 Park Ave,Sune 202 MARCO ISLAND,FL 34145 Location:1095 Barefoot VV∥ams RD,(ROVり ,Nap es unincOrporated Co∥ier County Zoning Dist: Property Legal Description:4 51 26 NEl′4 0F NE1/4 0F SE1/4 0F NWl′4+THAT PART OF NllV1/4 0F NW1/4 0F SVVl′4 0F NEl′4 LYINGllV OF ROAD 3 62 Folio:727400006 NOTiCE Pursuant to Co∥ier County consolidated Code Enforcement Regu:ations,Co∥ier County Code of Laws and Ordinances, Chapter 2,Article:X,you are notined that a violation(s)of the fo∥owing Co∥ier County Ordinance(s)and Or PUD Regulation(S)exiStS atthe abovedescribed:ocation Ordinance′Code: Vegetalon RemovaL ProteCtion&Preserva∥on Vegeta∥on Removal′Landi∥ Requred Co∥ier County Land Development Code 04-41,as amended,Secton 3 05 01(B) n sha∥be un awfulfo「any ndiv dual,輌 rm,assoc alon,,。int venture,partnersh p.estate,trust,syndicate,nduciary, corporat on,grOup,0「unit Offedera state,County,or municipal governmentto remove,or othei～vise dest「oy, vegetat on,which includes placing of add tional輌 ∥,w thout nrst obtaining a vegetation removal or vegetation removal and輌 ∥permitfrom the County Manager or designee,except as hereinaner exempted i Violation status― lnllal DESCRIPT:ON OF COND:T:ONS CONST:TUT:NG THE V:OLAT10N(S) Did Witness: Mechanica:●learing vegetation on a vacant:ot withOut a permit ORDER TO CORRECT V:OLAT10N(Si: You are directed by this Notice to take the fo∥owing cOrrective action(s): l Must cease a∥land clearing,excavation,and/orland f∥l operations AND/OR Must obtain any and a∥app∥cable permits to include Vegetation Removal or Vegetation Removal and Land F∥l permits pursuantto 04‐41,as amended,Section 10 02 06(B)(1)(a)AND/OR Mustobtain any and a∥app∥cable permits to include Vegetat on Removal or Vegetation Removal and Land F∥l permits pursuantto 0441, as amended,Seclon 10 02 06(Bxlxa) ON OR BEFORE:11′25′2023 Failure to correct violations may result in: 1)MandatOry notice to appear orissuance of a citat on that may resultin fines up to s500 and costs of 5.D.5.a Packet Pg. 45 Attachment: CEVR20230008759 EDINGTON PLACE LLC (28268 : CEVR20230008759 EDINGTON PLACE LLC) prosecution. OR 2) Code Enforcement Board review that may result in fines up to $1000 per day per violation, as long as the violation remains, and costs of prosecution. SERVED BY: INQUIRIES AND COMMENTS SHOULD BE DIRECTED TO CODE ENFORCEMENT Doaj ?t*l/.:a*z 2800 North Horseshoe Dr, Naples, FL 34104 lnvestigator Signature Doug Williams Case Number: CEVR20230008759 Phone:239252-2440 FAX:239252-2343 Signature and Title of Recipient Printed Name of Recipient Date tThis violalion may require additional compliance and approval from other departments which may be required under local, stale and federal regulations, including, but not limited to: right-of-way permit, building permit, demolition of structure, Site Oevelopment Plan, lnsubslantial Change to Site Oevelopment Plan, and Vaaiances along with, payment of impact fees, and any new or outstanding fees required Ior approval. 5.D.5.a Packet Pg. 46 Attachment: CEVR20230008759 EDINGTON PLACE LLC (28268 : CEVR20230008759 EDINGTON PLACE LLC) 3.05.01 Generally B. lt shall be unlawful for any individual, firm, association, joint venture, partnership, estate, trust, syndicate, fiduciary, corporation, group, or unit of federal, state, County, or municipal governmentto remove, or otherwise destroy, vegetation, which includes placing of additional fill, without first obtaining a vegetation removal or vegetation removal and fill permit from the County Manager or designee, except as hereinafter exempted. (Supp. No. 27) Page 1 of 1 Created: 2023-08-31 09:40:13 [EST] 5.D.5.a Packet Pg. 47 Attachment: CEVR20230008759 EDINGTON PLACE LLC (28268 : CEVR20230008759 EDINGTON PLACE LLC) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28270) DOC ID: 28270 Updated: 3/8/2024 11:24 AM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CEVR20220010806 Goemaere and Wu CASE NO: CEVR20220010806 OWNER: Luc Goemaere and Liping Wu OFFICER: Jason Packard VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 3.05.01(B), 3.05.07(C)(3)(b), 3.05.07(F)(3)(a) and 3.05.07(F)(3)(g)(i)(b). Trees and vegetation removed from lot and fill brought into lot without issuance of appropriate Collier County Permits or other approvals. FOLIO NO: 437560003 PROPERTY 306 Sabal Palm Rd, Naples, FL 34114 ADDRESS: 5.D.6 Packet Pg. 48 TIM E: CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLL:ER COUNTY,FLOR:DA Code Enforcement Board BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS, COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,Plain∥ff, VS LUC GOEMAERE AND LIPING llVU,Respondent(S) Case:CEVR20220010806 NOT:CE OF HEARING PLEASE TAKE NOTiCE that Pursuantto Section 162 06 and 162 12,Florida Statutes,and co∥ier County Ordinance No 07‐44, as amended,you are hereby ordered to appear at a public hearing before the Code Enforcement Board on the fo∥owing date,time,and place forthe violat on below: DATE: 03/28/2024 09 00 AM PLACE: 3299 Tamiami Tra∥East Bu∥ding F,Naples,FL 34112 V:OLATiON: Vegeta∥on Remova13 05 01(B),30507(C)(3xb),30507(F)(3)(a)and 30507(F)(3xg)()(b) LOCAT10N OF ViOLAT10N: 306 SabalPa m RD,Nap es,FL 34114 SERVED: LUC GOEMAERE ANS LIPING VVU,RespOndent 」ason Packard, lssuing Ofrcer RESPONDENTS ARE REQU:RED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEAR:NG CONFERENCE HEAR:NGS TO BEG:N AT9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE thatthe a∥eged violator may produce any and a∥documents,wlnesses and/or evidence to be relied upon forthe test mony given atthe hear ng Documents w consist ofthe original and three coples A∥eged violators have the rightto be represented by an attorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTiCE that Requests for Con∥nuances w∥l not be considered if not rece ved by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board at east ive(5)bus neSS days pttOrto the date setForthe heanng :TiS FURTHER ADV:SED that Ordinance No 0744,as amended,be rev ewed pttorto your attendance atthe heaHng to lnclude emphasis on sect on Eight relating to the appeal process Helen 3uch∥lon COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples,Florda 34104 (239)252-5892 Telephone ∬:!l::ti:lilittli:β 8」li:β 1lii::%:i書 lililil幕『11[i]盤 ::|ll:1弱 ,鶏 11讐 ;fl習 [lT::]|1驚 |:ξ 省馴::::11り lillii!|を iheindividual };:i蝋弩]li議聯j聯舅∬鳴恥i∬暢∥暫感嘉iよ iよ難発∬稚器爾#]i:lii∥曇[i藷 1]観シ:『 ¨ 5.D.6.a Packet Pg. 49 Attachment: CEVR20220010806 Goemaere and Wu (28270 : CEVR20220010806 Goemaere and Wu) Case Number: CEVR20220010806 Date: January 13,2023 lnvestigator: Jason Packard Phone: 2393803777 COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT NOTICE OF VIOLATION Owner: GOEMAERE, LUC LIPING WtJ 3355 19TH AVE SW NAPLES, FL 34117 Location: 306 Sabal Palm RD, Naples Unincorporated Collier county Zoning Dist: Agricultural - RFMUO-NRPA-SENDING Overlay Property Logal Doscription: 24 50 26 W1l2 OF W1l2 OF SWl/4 OF SW'l/4 10.73 AC Folio:437560003 NOTICE Pursuant to Collier County Consolidated Code Enforcement Regulations, Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances, Chapter 2, Article lX, you are notified that a violation(s) of the following Collier County Ordinance(s) and or PUD Regulation(s) exists at the abovedescribed location. Ordinance/Code: Vegetation Removal, Protection & Preservation. Vegetation Removal / Landfill Required. Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 3.05.01(B) It shall be unlaMul for any individual, firm, association, joint venture, partnership, estate, trust, syndicate, fiduciary, corporation, group, or unit of federal, state, County, or municipal govemment to remove, or otheMise destroy, vegetation, which includes placing of additional fill, without first obtaining a vegetation removal or vegetation removal and fll permit from the County Manager or designee, except as hereinafter exempted.: Vegetation Removal, Protection & Preservation. Collier County Land Development Code 04-4'1, as amended, Section 3.05.07(C)(3Xb) ln RFMU sending lands that are within a NRPA, 90% of the native vegetation present shall be preserved or such other amount as may be permitted under the Density Blending provisions of LOC section 2.05.02. Off-site preservation shall not be credited toward satisfaclion of any of the vegetative retention requirement applicable in such NRPAS, Vegetation Removal, Protection & Preservation. Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 3.05.07(F)(3)(a) ln order to assess the values and functions of wetlands at the time of project review, applicants shall rate the functionality of wetlands using the Unified Wetland Mitigation Assessment Method set forth in F.A.C. 62-345. Fot projects that have already been issued an Environmental Resource Permit by the state, the County will accept wetlands functionality assessments that are based upon the South Florida Water Management District's Wetland Rapid Assessment Procedures (WRAP), as described in Technical Publication Reg 001 (September 1997, as update August 1999). The applicant shall submit to County staff these respective assessments and the scores accepted by either the South Florida Water Management District or Florida Department of Environmental Protection. Vegetation Removal, Protection & Preservation. Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 3.05.07(F)(3XgXi)(b) Prior to issuance of any final development order that authorizes site alteration, the applicant shall demonstrate compliance with a) and d) of this subsection. lf agency permits have not provided mitigation consistent with this Section, Collier County will require mitigation exceeding that of the jurisdictional agenaies. Violation Status - lnitial DESCRTPTTON OF CONDTTTONS cONST|TUT|NG THE VtOLAT|ON(S). Did Witness: Trees and vegetation removed from lot and fill brought into lot without issuance of appropriate Collier County Permits or other approvals 5.D.6.a Packet Pg. 50 Attachment: CEVR20220010806 Goemaere and Wu (28270 : CEVR20220010806 Goemaere and Wu) ORDER TO CORRECT V10LAT:ON(SL You are directed by this Notice to take the fo∥owing corrective act:on(s): l Must cease a∥land clearing,excava∥on,and/orland f∥l operations AND/OR Must obtain any and a∥applicable permits to include Vegetation Removal o「Vegetat on Removaland Land F∥l perllnls pursuantto 0441,as amended,Seclon 10 02 06(Bxlxa)AND/OR Mustobtain any and a∥app∥cab e permits to include Vegetation Removal or Vegetation Removal and Land F∥l permits pursuantto 0441, as amended,Section 10 02 06(B)(1)(a)OR must restore sne tO OHginal state ON OR BEFORE:02r13′2023 Fa∥ure to correct violations may resu!t in: 1)Mandatory notice to appear o「issuance of a citat on that may resu tin fines up to S500 and costs Of prosecution OR 2)Code Enforcement Board review that may resun n ines up to S1000 per day per violauon,as long as INQUIRIES AND COMMENTS SHOULD BE DlRECTED TO CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe Dr,Naples,FL 34104 Phonei 239 252-2440 FAXi239 252-2343 Signature and Title of Recipient Printed Name of Recipient Date *Thls vlolatlon may requlro addltional compliancE and approval t,om other deparlmsnts which may b€ rgqulrod undor local, stale and federal regulations, lncluding, bul not llmltod to: rlght-oI-way pormit, buildlng permit, domolition o, structure, Site Oevelopment Plan, lnsubstantial Ghange to Site Oovelopment Plan, and Variances along with, payment of lmpact foes, and any nEw or outstanding fqgs rgqulrod for approval. Sig natu re Case Number CEVR20220010806 5.D.6.a Packet Pg. 51 Attachment: CEVR20220010806 Goemaere and Wu (28270 : CEVR20220010806 Goemaere and Wu) 3.05.01 Generally B. lt shall be unlawful for any individual, firm, association, joint venture, partnership, estate, trust, syndicate, fiduciary, corporation, group, or unit of federal, state, County, or municipal government to remove, or otherwise destroy, vegetation, which includes placing of additional fill, without first obtaining a vegetation removal or vegetation removal and fill permit from the County Manager or designee, except as hereinafter exempted. 3.05.07 Preservation Standards All development not specifically exempted by this ordinance shall incorporate, at a minimum, the preservation standards contained within this section. C. Specific standards for the RFMU district. For Lands within the RFMU district, native vegetation shall be preserved through the application of the following preservation and vegetation retention standards and criteria, in addition to the generally applicable standards and criteria set forth in LDC section 3.05.07 A (above). Further, for the portion of the Lake Trafford/Camp Keais Strand System located within the lmmokalee Urban Designated Area, native vegetation shall be preserved on site throu8h the application of the Neutral Lands standards established in LDC section 3.05.07 C.2 (below). 3. RfMU sending lands. b. ln RFMU sendint lands that are within a NRPA, 90% of the native vegetation present shall be preserved or such other amount as may be permitted under the Density Blending provisions of LDC section 2.05.02. Off-site preservation shall not be credited toward satisfaction of any of the F. Wetland preservation and conservation. 3. RFMU district. Direct impacts of development within wetlands shall be limited by directing such impacts away from high quality wetlands having functionality scores of at least 0.65 WRAP or 0.7 UMAM. This shall be accomplished by adherence to the vegetation retention requirements of LDC section 3.05.07 C above and the following standards: a. ln order to assess the values and functions of wetlands at the time of project review, applicants shall rate the functionality of wetlands using the Unified Wetland Mitigation Assessment Method set forth in F.A.C. 62-345. For projects that have already been issued an Environmental Resource Permit by the state, the County will accept wetlands functionality assessments that are based upon the South Florida Water Management District's Wetland Rapid Assessment Procedures (WRAP), as described in Technical Publication Reg 001 (September 1997, as update August 1999). The applicant shall submit to County staff these respective assessments and the scores accepted by either the South Florida Water Management District or Florida Department of Environmental Protection. Mitigation. Miti8ation shall be required for direct impacts to wetlands in order to result in no net loss of wetland functions, in adherence with the following requirements and conditions: i. MitigationRequirements: b) Prior to issuance of any final development order that authorizes site alteration, the applicant shall demonstrate compliance with a) and d) of this subsection. lf agency permits have not provided mitigation consistent with this Section, Collier County will require mitigation exceeding that of the jurisdictional agencies. (5upp. No.27) Page 1 of 1 c.eated: 2023-08-31 69:40:13 [EsT] 5.D.6.a Packet Pg. 52 Attachment: CEVR20220010806 Goemaere and Wu (28270 : CEVR20220010806 Goemaere and Wu) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28271) DOC ID: 28271 Updated: 3/7/2024 11:27 AM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CESD20230007552 Smith CASE NO: CESD20230007552 OWNER: Robert Lee Smith Jr and Denise H Smith OFFICER: Doug Williams VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e). Installed a new vanity without a permit in a condo. FOLIO NO: 76460280009 PROPERTY 330 Kon Tiki Dr A7, Naples, FL 34113 ADDRESS: 5.D.7 Packet Pg. 53 CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA Code Enforcement Board BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS, COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,Plainlff, VS ROBERT LEE SMITH JR AND DENISE H SMITH,Respondent(S) Casei CESD20230007552 NOTICE OF HEARING PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that Pursuant to Section 162.06 and 162.12, Florida Statutes, and Collier County Ordinance No. 07-44, as amended, you are hereby ordered to appear at a public hearing before the Code Enforcement Board on the following date, time, and place for the violation below: DATE : 0312812024 TIME: 09:00 AM PLACE: 3299 Tamiami Trail East Building F, Naples, FL 34'l'12 VIOLATION: lmprovement Priorto Building Permit '10.02.06(B)(1)(a) and 10.02.06(BX1)(e) LOCATION OFVIOLATION: 330 Kon Tikj DRA7, Naples, FL 34113 SERVED: ROBERT LEE SMITH JR AND DENISE H SMITH, Respondent Doug Williams, lssuing Offlcer RESPONDENTS ARE REQUIRED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE-HEARING CONFERENCE HEARINGS TO BEGIN AT 9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that the alleged violator may produce any and all documents, witnesses and/or evidence to be relied upon for the testimony given at the hearing. Documents will consist of the original and three copies. Alleged violators have the right to be represented by an attorney. PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that Requests for Continuances will not be considered if not received by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board at least five (5) business days prior to the date set for the hearing. lT lS FURTHER ADVISED that Ordinance No. 07-44, as amended, be reviewed prior to your attendance at the hearing to include emphasis on Section Eight relating to the appeal process. Helen Buchillon COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, Florida 34'104 (239\ 252-5892 Telephone Anyone who requires an auxiliary aid or service for effective communicalion, or other reasonable accommodations to parlicipale in this proceeding, should contact the Collier County Facilities Managemenl Division, located at 3335 Tamaami Trail E.. Suite 101, Naples, Flotida 34112, ot (2391252- 8380, as soon as possible, but no later than 48 hours before the scheduled event. Such reasonable accommodalions will be provided at no cost to the individual. NOTIFICACION: Esta audiencia sera conducida en el idioma lngles. Servicios lhe traduccion no seran disponibles en la audiencia y usled sera responsable de proveer su propio traductor, para un mejor entendimienio con las comunicaciones de este evenlo. Por favor kaiga su propio lraduclor. AVETISMAN: Tout odisyon yo fet an angle. Nou pan gin moun pou fe lradaksyon. Si ou pa pal6 angE tanpri vini avek yon inldprdt pou pa16 pou-ou. 5.D.7.a Packet Pg. 54 Attachment: CESD20230007552 Smith (28271 : CESD20230007552 Smith) case Number: CESD20230007552 Date: October 13, 2023 lnvestigalor: Doug Williams Phonei 2398778127 COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT NOTICE OF VIOLATION Owner: SMITH JR, ROBERT LEE DENISE H SMITH 330 KON TIKI DRIVE #A7 NAPLES, FL 34113 Location: 330 Kon Tiki DR A7, (Unit) , Naples Unincorporated Collier County Zoning Dist: RMF-16 Property Legal Description: TARPON VILLAGE APTS CONDO UNIT A-7 Folio: 76460280009 NOTICE Pursuant to Collier County Consolidated Code Enforcement Regulations, Collier county Code of Laws and Ordinances, Chapter 2, Article lX, you are notified that a violation(s) of the following Collier County Ordinance(s) and or PUD Regulation(s) exists at the above4escribed location. Ordinance/Code: Building and Land Alteration Permits. (Permits, lnspections, Certificate of Occupancy Required) Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 10.02.06(8)(1)(a) Submittal Requirements for Permits. Building or Land Alteration Permits. lmprovement of property prohibited prior to issuance of building permit. Collier County Land Development Code 04-41 as amended, Section 1 0.02.06(B)(1 Xe) The County Manager or his designee shall be responsible for determining whether applications for building or land alteration permits, as required by the Collier County Building code or this Code are in accord with the requirements of this Code, and no building or land alteration permit shall be issued wathout written approval that plans submitted conform to applicable zoning regulations, and other land development regulations. For purposes of this section a land alteration permit shall mean any written authorization to alter land and for which a building permit may not be required. Examples include but are not limited to clearing and excavation permits, site development plan approvals, agricultural clearing permits, and blasting permits. No bualding or structure shall be erected, moved, added to, altered, utilized or allowed to exist and/or no land alteration shall be permitted without first obtaining the authorization of the required permit(s), inspections and certificate(s) of occupancy as required by the Collier County Building Code or this Code : lmprovement of property prohibited prior to issuance of building permit. No site work, removal of protected vegetation, grading, improvement of property or construction of any type may be commenced prior to the issuance of a building permit where the development proposed requires a building permit under this Land development Code or other applacable county regulations... : Violation Status - lnitial DESCRTPTTON OF CONDTTTONS CONSTTTUTTNG THE VtOLATtON(S). Did Witness: lnstalled a new vanity without a permit in a condo. ORDER TO GORRECT VIOLATION(S): You are directed by this Notice to take the following corrective action(s): 1. Must obtain all required Collier County Building Permit(s) or Demolition permit(s) and request all inspections through Certificate of Completion/Occupancy for described structure/ alleration. 2. Must be in compliance with all Collier County Codes and Ordinances. Apply for and obtain all 5.D.7.a Packet Pg. 55 Attachment: CESD20230007552 Smith (28271 : CESD20230007552 Smith) permits required for described structure/improvements: OR remove said structure/improvements, including materials from properly and restore to a permitted state AND / OR lvlust cease all improvement activities until such time that any and all required permits are obtained from Community Development and Environmental Services. ON OR BEFORE: 1'111212023 Failure to correct violations may result in: 1) Mandatory notice to appear or issuance of a citation that may result in fines up to $500 and costs of prosecution. OR 2) Code Enforcement Board review that may result in fines up to $1000 per day per violation, as long as the violation remains, and costs of prosecution. SERVED BY: INQUIRIES AND COMMENTS SHOULD BE DIRECTED TO CODE ENFORCEMENT _D*l7,,,/,2.no2S00NorthHorseshoeDr,Naples,FL34l04 lnvestigator Signature Doug Williams Case Number: CESD20230007552 Phone1 239 252-2440 FAX1239 252‐2343 Signature and Title of Recipient Printed Name of Recipient Date 'This violation may require additional compliance and approval from other deparlmenls which may be required und€r local, state and federal regulations, including, but not limited to: right-of-way permit, building permit, demolilion of structure, Site Developmenl Plan, lnsubstantial Change to Site Development Plan, and Variances along with, payment of impact fees, and any new or outstanding fees .equired for approval. 5.D.7.a Packet Pg. 56 Attachment: CESD20230007552 Smith (28271 : CESD20230007552 Smith) 10.02.06 Requirements for Permits B. Building Permit ot Lond Alterotion Permit. 1. Building or land alteration permit and certificate ofoccupancy compliance process. a. zoning oction onbuildingor londalterutionpermits. The County Manager or his designee shall be responsible for determining whether applications for building or land alteration permits, as required by the Collier County Building code or this Code are in accord with the requirements of this Code, and no building or land alteration permit shall be issued without written approval that plans submitted conform to applicable zoning regulations, and other land development regulations. For purposes of this section a land alteration permit shall mean any written authorization to alter land and for which a building permit may not be required. Examples include but are not limited to clearing and excavation permits, site development plan approvals, agricultural clearing permits, and blasting permits. No building or structure shall be erected, moved, added to, altered, utilized or allowed to exist and/or no land alteration shall be permitted without first obtaining the authorization of the required permit(s), inspections and certificate(s) of occupancy as required by the Collier County Building Code or this Code and no building or land alteration permit application shall be approved by the County Manager or his designee for the erection, moving, addition to, or alteration of any building, structure, or land except in conformity with the provisions of this Code unless he shall receive a written order from the Board of Zoning Appeals in the form of an administrative review of the interpretation, or variances as provided by this Code, or unless he shall receive a written order from a court or tribunal of competent jurisdiction. e- lmprovement of property prohibited prior to issuonce oJbuildingpermit. No site work, removal of protected vegetation, grading, improvement of property or construction of any type may be commenced prior to the issuance of a building permit where the development proposed requires a building permit under this Land development Code or other applicable county regulations. Exceptions to this requirement may be granted by the County Manager or his designee for an approved subdivision or site development plan to provide for distribution of fill excavated on-site or to permit construction of an approved water management system, to minimize stockpiles and hauling off-site or to protect the public health, safety and welfare where clearing, grading and filling plans have been submitted and approved meeting the warrants of section 4.06.04 A. of this Code; removal of exotic vegetation shall be exempted upon receipt of a vegetation removal permit for exotics pursuant to Chapters 3 and L0. 5.D.7.a Packet Pg. 57 Attachment: CESD20230007552 Smith (28271 : CESD20230007552 Smith) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28298) DOC ID: 28298 Updated: 3/8/2024 7:27 AM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CESD20240000553 Raymond CASE NO: CESD20240000553 OWNER: Peggy Raymond OFFICER: Brian Owen VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a), 10.02.06(B)(1)(e) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e)(i). Unpermitted screened in lanai and garage conversion to include but not limited to plumbing, framing and drywall. FOLIO NO: 36317560003 PROPERTY 5341 25th Ave SW, Naples, FL 34116 ADDRESS: 5.D.8 Packet Pg. 58 CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLLiER COUNTY,FLOR:DA Code Enforcement Board BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS, COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,P ainlff, VS PEGGY RAYMOND,Respondent(S) Case:CESD20240000553 NOT:CE OF HEAR:NG PLEASE TAKE NOT:CE that Pursuantto Section 162 06 and 162 12,Flonda statutes,and Co∥ier County Ordinance No 07‐44, as amended,you are hereby ordered to appear at a pub∥c hearing before the Code Enforcement Board on the fo∥owing date,time,and place forthe violation below: DATE: 03/28/2024 T:ME: 09:00 AM PLACE: 3299 Tamiami Tra∥East Bu∥dng F,Naples,FL 34112 V10LAT10N: CO Requred ATF Permls 10 02 06(B)(1)(a),100206(B)(1)(e)and 10 02 06(B)(1)(e)(ゥ LOCAT10N OF ViOLAT10N: 5341 25th AVE SW,Naples,FL 34116 SERVED: PEGGY RAYMOND,Respondent B百 an Owen, Issuing Off cer RESPONDENTS ARE REQUIRED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEAR:NG CONFERENCE HEAR:NGS TO BEGIN AT 9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE thatthe a∥eged violator may produce any and a∥documents,wlnesses and/or evidence to be relied upon forthe test mony given atthe hearing Documents w∥l consist ofthe original and three copies A∥eged vlolators have the right to be represented by an attorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOT:CE that Requests for Con籠 nuances w∥l not be considered if not received by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board a∥east ive(5)bus neSS days p面 orto the date set forthe heattng lT iS FURTHER ADViSED that Ordinance No 0744,as amended,be reviewed pnorto your atendance atthe heattng to include emphasis on Section Elght relating to the appeal process Helen Buch∥on COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples,Florida 34104 (239)252-5892 Telephone AnyOne who requires an auxilary ald or service for erective communicat on,o「other reasonable accommodations to participate in this proceeding should contactthe Col er County FaC lles Management Div slon located at 3335 Tamiami T「a∥E Sute 101 Naples Florda 34112 or(239)252‐ 8380,as soon as possible but no laterthan 48 hours before the scheduled event such reasonabie accommodat ons wi∥be p「ovided at no costto the individual NOT!F!CAC:ON:Esta audiencia sera conducida en elidioma lngles Serv cios the traduccion nO seran dispOnibles en la audiencia y usted sera responsable de proveer su proplo traduclor`para un melor entend lnienlo con las comunicaciones de este eventO Porfavo「traiga su proplo traduclor AVET:SMAN: Tout odisyon yo fet an ang!o Nou pan gin mOun pouた tradiksyon Si ou pa pal●angiё tanp「 vini avek yOn intё prё t pou pal●pOu‐ou 5.D.8.a Packet Pg. 59 Attachment: CESD20240000553 Raymond (28298 : CESD20240000553 Raymond) Case Number: CESD20240000553 Date: January 26,2024 lnvestigator: Brian Owen Phone: 239-944-8253 COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT NOTICE OF VIOLATION Owner: RAYMOND, PEGGY 3360 52ND AVE NE NAPLES, FL 34120 Location: 5341 25th AVE SW, Naples Unincorporated Collier County Zoning Dist: RMF-6 Property Legal Descriplion: GOLDEN GATE UNIT 6 BLK 202 LOT 17 Folio:36317560003 NOTICE Pursuant to Collier County Consolidated Code Enforcement Regulations, Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances, Chapter 2, Article lX, you are notified that a violation(s) of the following Collier County Ordinance(s) and or PUD Regulation(s) exists at the above-described location. Ordinance/Code: Building and Land Alteration Permits. (Permits, lnspeclions, Cerlificate of Occupancy Required) Collier County Land Development Code 0441, as amended, Section 10.02.06(BX1Xa) The County Manager or his designee shall be responsible for determining whether applications for building or land alteration permits, as required by the Collier County Building code or this Code are in accord with the requirements of this Code, and no building or land alteration permit shall be issued without written approval that plans submitted conform to applicable zoning regulations, and other land development regulations. For purposes of this section a land alterataon permit shall mean any written authorization to alter land and for which a building permit may not be required. Examples include but are not limited to clearing and excavation permits, site development plan approvals, agricultural clearing permits, and blasting permits. No building or structure shall be erected, moved, added to, altered, utilazed or allowed to exist and/or no land alteration shall be permitted without first obtaaning the authorization of the required permit(s), inspections and certificate(s) of occupancy as required by the Collier County Building Code or this Code : Submittal Requirements for Permits. Building or Land Alteration Permits. lmprovement of property prohibited prior to issuance of building permit. Collie. County Land Development Code 04.41 as amended, secrion 10.02.06(BX1Xe) lmprovement of property prohiblted prior to issuance of building permit. No site work, removal of protected vegetation, grading, improvement of property or construction of any type may be commenced prior to the issuance of a building permit where the development proposed requires a building permit under this Land development Code or other applicable county regulations... : Submittal Requirements for Permits, Building or Land Alteration Permits. lmprovement of property prohibited prior lo issuance of building permit. Collier County Land Development Code 04{1 as amended, Section 10.02.06(BXlXeXi) lVust obtain all required inspections and certificate of occupancy/completion within 60 days of permit issuance : Violation Status - lnitial DESCRTPTTON OF CONDTTTONS CONSTTTUTTNG THE VtOLAT|ON(S). Did Witness: Unpermitted screened in lanai and garage conversion to include but not limited to plumbing, framing and drywall. ORDER TO CORRECT VIOLATION(S): You are directed by this Notice to take the following corrective action(s): 1. Must obtain all required Collier County Building Permit(s) or Demolition permit(s) and request all inspections through Certificate of Completion/Occupancy for described structure/ alteration. 2. Must be in compliance with all Collier County Codes and Ordinances. Apply for and obtain all permits required for described structure/improvements: OR remove said slructure/improvements, including materials from property and restore to a permitted state AND / OR lvlust cease all improvement activities until such time that any and all required permits are obtained from Community Development and 5.D.8.a Packet Pg. 60 Attachment: CESD20240000553 Raymond (28298 : CESD20240000553 Raymond) Environmental Services. 3. Must be in compliance with all Collier County Codes and Ordinances. Apply for and obtain all permits required for described structure/improvements AND / OR Must remove said structure/improvements, including materials from property and restore to a permitted state. ON OR BEFORE: 0212512024 Failure to correct violations may result in: 1) Mandatory notice to appear or issuance of a citation that may result in fines up to $500 and costs of prosecution. OR 2) Code Enforcement Board review that may result in flnes up to $'1000 per day per violation, as long as the violation remains, and costs of prosecution. SERVED BY: INOUIRIES AND COMMENTS SHOULD BE DIRECTED TO CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe Dr, Naples, FL 34104 Ezran Oarea lnvestigator Signature Brian Owen Case Number CESD20240000553 Phone1 239 252‐2440 FAX:239252-2343 Signature and Title of Recipient Printed Name of Recipient Date 'This violation may require additional compliance and approval ftom other departments which may be required under local, slate and federal regulations, including, but not limited to: right-ot-way permit, building permit, demolition of slructure, Site Development Plan, lnsubstantial Change to Site Oevelopment Plan, and Va ances along wiih, payment of impact lees, and any new or outstanding fees required tor approval. 5.D.8.a Packet Pg. 61 Attachment: CESD20240000553 Raymond (28298 : CESD20240000553 Raymond) The Collier County Land Development Co de,2004-41, As Amended 10.02.06 - Requirements for Permits B. Bailding Pemit or Land Alterurion pemil l. Building or land alteration p€rmit and certificate ofoccupancy compliance process. a. Zoning oction on building or land alteration permits. The County Manager or his designee shall be responsible for det€rmining whether applications for building or land alteration peimits, as required by the Collier County Building code or this Code are in accord with the requirements of this Code, and no building or land alteration permit shall be issued without written approval that plans submitted conform to applicable zoning regulations, and other land developmenf regulations. For purposes ofthis section a land alteration permit shall mean any wriften authorization to alter land and for which a building permit may not be required. Examples include but are not limited to clearing and excavation permits, site deveropment pian approvars, agricultural clearing permits, and blasting permits. No building oi structure shiil be erected, moved, added to, altered, utilized or allowed to exist and/or no land alteration shall be permitted without first obtaining the authorization ofthe required permit(s), inspections and certificate(s) of occupancy as required by the Collier County Buitding Code or this Code and no building or land alteration permit application shall be approved by the County Manager or his designee for the erection, moving, addition to, or alteration ofany building, structure, or land excipt in conformity with the provisions ofthis Code unless he shall receive a written order llom the Board ofZoning Appeals in the form ofan administrative review ofthe interpretation, or variances as provided by this Code, or unless he shall receive a written order from a court or tribunal of comperenl jurisdiction. B. Building Permit or Land Alleration pemil l.Building or land alteration permit and certificate ofoccupancy compliance process. lmprovement ofproperty prohibited prior to issuance of buildingpernrt No sile work, removal of protected vegetation, grading, improvement ofproperty or construction of any type may be commenced prior to the issuance ofa building permit where the development proposed requires a building permit under this Land deyelopment code or other applicable county regulations. Exceptions to this requirement may be granted by the county Manager or his designee for an approved subdivision or site development plan to provide for distribution offill ixcavated on- site or to permit construction ofan approved water management system, to minimize stockpiles and hauling off-site or to protect the public health, safety and welfare where clearing, grading and filling plans have been submitted and approyed meeting the warrants ofsection 4.04.04 A. oithis code; removal ofexotic vegetation shall be exempted upon receipt ofa vegetation removal permit for exotics pursuant to Chapters 3 and 10. In the event the improvement ofproperty, construction ofany type, repairs or remodeling ofany type that requires a building permit has been completed, all required inspection(sj and certificate(s) ofoccupancy must be obtained within 60 days after the issuance ofafter the fact permit(s). 5.D.8.a Packet Pg. 62 Attachment: CESD20240000553 Raymond (28298 : CESD20240000553 Raymond) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28272) DOC ID: 28272 Updated: 3/7/2024 2:41 PM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CESD20210001490 Resendiz and Martinez CASE NO: CESD20210001490 OWNER: Cecilio Martinez Resendiz and Maricela Valerio Martinez OFFICER: Raul Mendez VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a), 10.02.06(B)(1)(e) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e)(i). Unpermitted carport and other accessory structures. FOLIO NO: 41040200007 PROPERTY 3371 14th Ave SE, Naples, FL 34117 ADDRESS: 6.B.1 Packet Pg. 63 CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLLiER COUNTY,FLOR:DA Code Enforcement Board BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS, Case:cESD20210001490 COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,Plaintiff, VS ― ARTINEZ RESENDIZ AND MARICELA VALER10 MARTINEZ,RespOndent(S) NOTICE OF HEARING RE:MOT:ON FOR:MPOS:T:ON OF FINES′L:ENS PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that Pursuantto Seclon 162 06 and 162 12,Flonda statutes,and Co∥ler County Ordinance No 07-44,as amended,you are hereby ordered to appear at a pub∥c hearing before the Code Enforcement Board on the fo∥owing date,time,and place forthe violat on below: DATE: o3/23/2024 TIME: 09:00 AM PLACE: 3299 Tamlami Tra∥East 8u∥ding F,Naples,FL 34112 V10LAT:ON: CO Required ATF Permts 10 02 06(B)(1)(a),100206(B)(1)(e)and 10 02 06(Bxl)(e)o) LOCAT10N OF ViOLAT:ON: 3371 14th AVE SE,Naples,FL 34117 SERVED: CECIL10 MARTINEZ RESENDIZ AND MARICELA VALERIO MARTINEZ,Respondent Raul Mendez, lssuing ofrcer RESPONDENTS ARE REQUIRED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEAR:NC CONFERENCE HEARINCS TO BEGIN AT 9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE thatthe a∥eged violator may produce any and a∥documents,wlnesses and/or evidence to be rel ed upOn forthe testimony given atthe hearing Documents w∥l cOnslst ofthe original and three copies AIleged violators have the right to be represented by an attorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that Requests for Conlnuances w∥l not be considered if not received by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board atleast ive(5)business days priorto the date setforthe hearing :TiS FURTHER ADVISED that()rdinance No 0744,as amended,be reviewed p∥Orto your attendance atthe heaHng to include emphasis on Section Eight relating to the appeal process Ashley Eoff COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples,Florida 341 04 (239)252-2496 Telephone AnyOne who requires an auxl,ary ald o「service for efFect ve communicat on,o「other reasonable accommodat ons to participate in this proceeding, should contactthe Co∥er County FaC∥ties Management Division,located at 3335 Tamiami Tra∥E,Su te 101,Naples,Flo百 da 34112,o「(239)252-8380,as soon as possible,but nO laterthan 48 hours before the scheduled event Such reasonable accommodatiOns wll be provided at no∞st to the individual NOTIF:CAC10N:Esta audiencia sera αЭnducida en elidioma lngles Servicios the traduocion no seran dispOnibles en la audiencia y usted sera responsable de proveer su propio traductor,para un melor entend m ento con as comun caciones de este evento Porfavortra ga su prop o traducto「 AVETlSMAN: Tout odisyon yo et an anglo Nou pan gin moun pOu e tradiksyon siOu pa palo anglё tanpl viniavё k yon intOpret pou pa16 pou―ou 6.B.1.a Packet Pg. 64 Attachment: CESD20210001490 Resendiz and Martinez (28272 : CESD20210001490 Resendiz and Martinez) INSTR 63■7692 oR 6■8■ PGCLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COUR丁 REC S■8.50 454 RECORDED ■0/■4/2022 AND COMPttROLLER, COLLIER 8:57 AM PAGESCOUNTY FLORIDA COLLIER COIINTY CODE ENFORCEDIENT CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD Case No.―CESD20210001490 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Martinez, Respondents. ―夕)./-' i THIS CAUSE came before the Cdde Euforyement Board (the "Board") for public hearing on September 22, 2022, and the Board, having heard testimoei uqddi.oath, received evidence and heard argument respective to all appropriate matters, hereupon issues its FindingS of.Eact, Conclusions of Law, and Order of the Board as follows: ■淋盤Ilitti鍔ぶ鋤糀柵 :栃轍 1‐おiⅢ:∥鍵l∬蔦∬“ イ‐‐)「the date ofthis hearl_ngF _ 、ィ√11‐Btted19面 ell鰤亀二t申詭btt nsi713).L憮歯1週暮軍ず燎1」聟奮脳摯鶴鼎鵠燎選響糧躍u:lΨ 蹴瞥H'H°H& 2. The preponderance ofthe evidence shows that violatiOns of C01lier County Land Development cOde Ord. No.04‐41,as amendedi Sections 10.02.06σ 3)(1)(り ,10.02.06∈〕)(lXC),and 10.02.0`(B)(1)(C)(1)dO exist,andthat Respondents cohmi"ed,and were responsible for maintaining or allowintt the violations tO cOndnuc as ofthe date ofthis hearing. ORDER Based upon thc fOregoing Findings ofFact and Conclusion,OfLaw,ald pЧ rsuant to the authority granted in Chapter 162,Flo五 da Statutes,and Chapter 2,Article Ⅸ,Code ofLaws and OrdilanceS OfC01lier County,FloHda,itis hereby ORDERED that: /1 ｀、 Page I of2 Valerio Martihez,are the owners ofthe suttect 2. Respondents, having been notified of the testified through their interpreter, Ivia Garcia" 6.B.1.a Packet Pg. 65 Attachment: CESD20210001490 Resendiz and Martinez (28272 : CESD20210001490 Resendiz and Martinez) '・ ' OR 6■8■ PG 455 tt=BRespondens are found guilty of violafi.g Collier County Land DevelopmeDt Code Ord. No. 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06@X1)(a), 10.02.06(8)(lXe), and 10.02.06(BXlXe)(i). Respondents must abate all violations by obtainirg all required Coltier County Builditlg Permit(s) or Demolitio[ Permit, inspections, and Certificat€ ofCompletion/Occupancy for the Unpermitted Carport^{etal Structure and all other unpermitted accessory skuctures on or before Jaluary 20,2023, or a Iine of$100.00 per day will be imposed for each day the yiolations remain tbereafter. IfRespondents fail to compty with this Order, Collier County may abate the violations using any method to brins the into compliance and may use the assistance of the Collier County SherifPs Oftice to enforce ofthis Order and all costs of abatement shall be assessed to Respondents. to pay operational costs for the proseculion ofthis case in the amount of$59.28 on or beforeC E鷺酬蜜:鷲樫誡腑駆膜i:iTl誦乳li祐 ]∬.:lお凛Cmc厳 of ttc宙 ohions md“que"ぬe Board Collier County, Florida" ! Personally Known OR D Produccd Identification Type of Identification Produced 騰登g讐簾現躍ぶ准kn°mCt:厳瞥蕪膨徊 PAYMENT OF FINEST Any fines ordered to be paid pursuant to tt i, Ora". 116! U"|uid at the Collier Courty Code Enforcement DE artment, 2800 North Horseshoe Dive, Naples, FL 34lo4.+hoIe: (239) 252-2440, Websi]€: www.colliercountvfl.gov, Any release oflien or coofirmation ofcompliance or conffimatiln of rhe satisfaction ofthe obligations ofthis Order may also be obtained at this locatio". J /.I APPEAL: Any aggrieved party may appeal a final order ofthe Board to the Circuit Cdurt-y1hi9 ttriny (30) days of the oxecution ofthe order appealed. An appeal shall not be a hearing de novo, bur shall be limitei ro appeilate review ofthe record created within the original hearing. It is the responsibility ofthe appealing parry;o-eb*ain a transcribed record ofthe hearing from the Clerk ofCourts. Filing an appeal will not automatically stay #is Ordcr. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY thata mc and cOrectcopy ofthis ORDER has bccn scnt by u s MJltO:Cccilio Maricela Valerlo Martlncz, 3371 14TH AVE SE, Naples, FL 34117, on 2022 ′cdlerCounγ batueanlc ed physical Presence or E online notarization, Chair ofthe Collier County Code Enforcemert DONEIDODEREDI■ぬyoC摯盤也 42022酎 Cmα Cmn,,n酬中.STATE OF FLORIDA COUbrrY OF COLLIER Name of Notary Public Code Enforcement Offi cial ∝押けClek Page 2 of 2 6.B.1.a Packet Pg. 66 Attachment: CESD20210001490 Resendiz and Martinez (28272 : CESD20210001490 Resendiz and Martinez) COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT 30ARD COLLIER COUNTヽ ′ 30ARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS,Petitioncr ヽS 順SEND:Z.CECILiO MARTINEZ MARICELA VALER10 MART:NE2.Dc・ rt・ ndant(s) CEB CASEヽ ()(にヽI)20210()O1490 AFFIDAVIT OF NON(OMPL:ANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLL】ER BEFORE ME,thc undcぃ igncd authority,pcrsonally appcarcd Adam Co∥icr,Codc Enforccmcnt Ottcial lorthc Codc Enforccmcnt Board ofConicr county,who ancr bcing Ful:y swom、dcPoscS and says: l That on Scptcinbcr 22,2022,thc Codc EnfoEcmcnt Board hcld a hcarlng and issucd an Ordcr in thc abovc・ stylcd mattct and statcd that DefcndanuS)was to labatC thC Viola“onl as Statcd hl thc Ordcr rccordcd in thc public rccords orcollicr County,Florida in OR B∞k6181 PG 454 2 That thc rcspondcnt did contact thc invcstigat(〕r3 That a“■nsPcclon was pcrfomcd on Panua,232023ト 4 That thc rc_inspcction rcvcalcd that thc co口 cctiV●・action ordcrd by thc Codc Enforccmcnt Board was llot in compliancc wlh thc rollowing condmions:〔ViolatiOn RcmainsI FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT DATED this r23rdl day oF〔Januaryl,2023 Code Enlbrccmcnt Ol'hcial -( physical prcsorct'or - onlinc norarizalion, COLLIER COUNTY FL()RIDA CODE ENpRCEMENT BOARD STATE()ドドL()RIDA me by mcans ol' Adam Collicr Pcrsona∥v knOwnヽ ()F(()LLIER Publ c) 6.B.1.a Packet Pg. 67 Attachment: CESD20210001490 Resendiz and Martinez (28272 : CESD20210001490 Resendiz and Martinez) COLLiER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT 30ARD Case No―CESD20210001490 30ARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Pe●tioner, VS Cec∥io Martinez Resendiz and Maricela Valerio Martinez, Respondent(S). ′ ORDER OF THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARI) THIS CAUSE came bcfore the Code Enforcement Board (the "Board") for public hcaring on February 23, 2023, upon Respondent's Motion for Extension of Time, and the Board having heard testimony under oath, reccivcd evidence and heard argument respective to all appropriate matters, hereby issues its Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Order ofthe Board as follows: FINDINGS OF FACT l. On September 22,2022, Rcspondenrs, Cecilio Mrrtinez R€sendiz and Marlcela Vslerio Martinez, were found to have violated Collier County Land Development Code, Ord. No, 04-41, as amended, Scctions 10.02.06(BX I )(a), 10.02.06(BX I )(e), and 10.02.06(8)( I )(e)(i) on the subject property locatcd at 337t l4'h Ave. SE, Naples, FL 341 17, Folio No.41040200007 (Legal Description: GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 83 E l80FT OF TR 4), hereinafter referred to as the "Propeny"), in the following parriculars: Unpermitled carport and oih€r rccessory structures. 2. On the samc date as above, the Board issued an Order ordering Respondents to abate thc violations on or before January 20, 2023, or a fine of$ 100.00 per day would bc assessed for each day the violations rcmained thereafter (A copy of the Order is recorded at OR 6 I 8 I PG 454). 3. Respondents, having been notified of the date of hearing on said motion by certified mail, posting and,/or personal service, had Circe Ruiz, their architect and authorized agent appear at the public hearing to provide testimony in suppon of the request for an extension of time. 4. OPerational costs in the amount of559.28 that have been previously incurred by Pctitioner in the prosccution of this case were timely paid. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW Based upon the foregoing facts, the Board makes thc following Conclusions ofLaw: l. All noticcs were properly and timely issued, and the Board has jurisdiction pursuant to Chapter 162, Florida statutes, and chapter 2, Anicre IX, code of Laws and ordinances of Colriei county, Floriia. 2. The Board extended the time to comply before fines could be imposcd for one-hundred-eighty (lg0) days. ORDER ^. P_ased upon thc foregoing Findings ofFact and Conclusions ofLaw, and pursuant to the authoriry grantcd inchapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 2, Anicle IX, Code ofLaws and Ordinances or cotti"i-ority, iloriaa, ltis hereby ORDERED that: Page I of 2 6.B.1.a Packet Pg. 68 Attachment: CESD20210001490 Resendiz and Martinez (28272 : CESD20210001490 Resendiz and Martinez) DoNE AND oRDERED thh ,'?cld .v otll-ebu.yt, ( ,2023 rr Collter County, Ftoride. STATE OF FLORIDA) COUNTY OF COLLIER) 騰翌銘:;:囃BIn lieu of an extcnsion of time. Respoodent is GRANTED a continuanc!. of rhc rime to comply with rhc Board's prior Order finding violations until Augusr 22. 2023. during which fines will conrinue ro accrue unless and until Respondent has come into compliance. All panies shall bc re-noticed for the subsequent hearing dai€ on or about August 24, 2023. cknowledged before me by means of{ physical prcsencc or D online norarization. . 2023. by Robcn Kaufman, Chair ofrhc Collicr County Code Entbrccmcnr Board Collier County, Florida. Pcrsonally Known OR D Produccd ldcntilication Typc of Identification Produced Commissionr.d Namc of Notary Public (Print/Type/Stamp) PAYMENT OF FINES: Any fincs ordcrcd to be paid pusuant to this Order may be paid at thc Collicr County Codc Enforccment Dcpanmcnt,2EO0 Nonh Horscshoc Drive, Naples, FL 34104, Phone: (239) 252-2440, Wcbsilc: www.colliercountyfl.sov. Any release of licn or confirmotion of compliancc or conlirmation of lhe satisfaction of the obligations of this Order may also bc obtaincd at this location. APPEAL: Any aggrieved party may appeal a final order ofthe Board tothe Circuir Coun within thirry (30)daysof the executioo of the Order appealed. An appcal shall not be a hearing de novo, but shall bc limited to appellate review ofthe record created within the original hearing. It is the responsibility ofthe appealing party ro obtain a transcribcd record ofthe hearing from the Clerk ofCouns. Filing an Appeal will not automatically sray thc Board's Order. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 鰹回型空買1デ aゝ肥:鳴 ∬躍洲ll静 11ぜ為:mS冨 1キ羊,鷺墜冒撃蕪淵蠍/Code Enforcement Offi cial Page 2 of2 6.B.1.a Packet Pg. 69 Attachment: CESD20210001490 Resendiz and Martinez (28272 : CESD20210001490 Resendiz and Martinez) CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY.FLORIDA BOARD OF COliNTY COMMISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Petitioncr, VS CECILIO MARTINEZ RESENDIZ AND MARICEL0 VALER10, Respondcnt(S)/Casc No CESD20210001490 ORDER OF THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARI) THIS CAUSE came before the Code Enforcement Board (the "Board") for public hearing on October 26, 2023, upon Pelitioner's Motion lor Imposition of Fines/Liens, and the Board having heard testimony under oath, received evidence and heard argument r€spective to all appropriate maners, hereby issues its Findings of Fact, Conclusions ofLaw, and Order ofthe Board as follows: FTNDINGS OF FACT l. On September 22, 2022, Responden(s)was/were found guilty ofviolating Collier County Land Development Code, Ord. No.04{1, as amended, Section 10.02.06(8)( I )(a), 10.02.05(8)( I )(e), and 10.02.06(8)( I )(e)(i) on lhe subject property located at 3371 l4'L Ave. SE, Naples, FL 34117, Folio No. 41040200007 (Legal Description: COLDEN GATE EST UNIT 83 E IE0FT OF TR 4), hereinafter referred to as the "Property", in the following paniculars' Unpermitted csrport snd other accessory structures. 2. The Board's written Order of September 22,2022, odered Respondent(s) to abate the violation(s) on or before January 20, 2023, or a fine of$ 100.00 per day would be assessed for each day the violation(s) remained th€reafter until abatement was coofirmed. (A copy ofthe Order is recorded at OR 6l8l PG 454.) 3. On February 23,2023, this Board granted Respondent(s) a continuance of the Pctitioner's Motion for Imposition of Fines as the Respondent(s) was not in compliance but continued to diligently pursue abatement ofthe violation(s). 4. Respondent(s), having been notified ofrhe date ofhearing on today's Motion for Imposirion ofFines/Liens by certified mail, posting and/or personal service, appeared at the public hearing, via a representative authorized to speak on Respondent(s) behalf, Maria F. Villegas, and has requested a second continuance as Respondent(s) continue(s) to pursue abatement of the violation(s). 5. Previously assessed operation costs of559.28 have been paid. 6. The Petitioner has incurred 559.42 in operational cosls for today's hearing. 7. The violation(s) haVhave not b€en fully abated as of the date of this hearing, but Respondent(s) has demonstrated continued, diligent effons to abate fie violation(s). CONCLUSIONS OF LAW Based upon the foregoing facs, the Board makes the following Conclusions of Law: Page I of3 6.B.1.a Packet Pg. 70 Attachment: CESD20210001490 Resendiz and Martinez (28272 : CESD20210001490 Resendiz and Martinez) l. All notices were properly a.ld timely issued, and the Board has jurisdiction pursuant to Chaptcr 162, Florida Statutes, and Chaptcr 2. Anicle IX, Code ofLaws and Ordinances of Collicr County, Florida. 2. Pursuant to Secrion 162.09, Florida Statutes, Petitioner has demonstratcd by a prepondcrance of the evidence that accrued fines and costs could now lawfully bc imposed against Respondent(s). howevcr, that in the bcst intcrcsts of the administrative efficiency Respondent(s) continucd abarement eflbns to datc warrant a second continuance ofPelitioner's Motion for lmposition ofFincVLicns for a rcasonable period of time for Respondent(s) to completc abatement cfforts and come into full compliancc. @B Based upon thc foregoing Findings ofFact and Conclusions of Law. and pursuant to the authority granted in Chapter 162, Florida Smrutes, and Chapter 2, Anicle IX, Code ofLaws and Ordinances of Collier County. Florida, it is hereby ORDERED that: A. Pctitioncr's Motion for Imposition of Fines is continued for a period of I20 days, which would otherwise be no sooner than the rext regularly scheduled mecting ofthis Board on or rftcr Februrry 23,2024, to allow the Respondent additional time for abatement ofthe violation(s). B. Respondent shall pry current opcrrtlonrl costs ofS59.42 on or bcfore November 25,2023. C. Delly llner of$100.00 per dry shrll continue lo rccrue until abatement ofthe violation(s) haVhavc becn confirmed by a Collier County Code Enforcement Invcstigator. 忍lξ:讐 [gl:;:llEttEEILEil』[[llllII電 1■、1サ if:&lymeansoじ ζ(phySlcal prescncc or□onllnc notarlzatloL n Kauman,chair oFthe Col∥cr COunり COdC Enforccmcnt Board Collier Counry, Florida. 蕪淵徊Commissioncd Namc of Notary Public (Print/Typci Stamp) PAYMENT OF FINES: Any fincs ordcred to bc paid pursuant to this Order may bc paid at thc Collicr County Codc Enforcemcnt Dcpanment,2800 Nonh Horseshoe Drive, Naples, FL 14104. Phonc: (239) 252-2,140. Wcbsitc; www.colliercountyfl.qov. Any releasc of lien or confirmation of compliance or confirmation ofthc satisfaction of the obligations ofthis Order may also bc obtained at this location. APPEAL: Any aggricved party may appeal a final order ofthe Board to the Circuit Coun \.'/ithin thiny (30) days of the cxecution ofthe Order appealcd. An appeal shall not be a hearing de novo, but shall be limited to appcllatc ro icw of the rccord creared wirhin the original hearing. h is the responsibility of thc appealing party to obtain a transcribcd record ofrhe hearing from the Clcrk ofCouns. Filing an Appeal will not automatically stay the Board's Order. DONE AND ORDERED ms九仏d.y Of/扉去″_2023■Cd∥er Cou耐卜Πonda STATE OF FLORIDA) COUNTY OF COLLIER) fPersonally Known OR tr Produccd Identification Type of ldcntifi cation Produccd CODE ENFORCEMENT 80ARD Page 2 of3 6.B.1.a Packet Pg. 71 Attachment: CESD20210001490 Resendiz and Martinez (28272 : CESD20210001490 Resendiz and Martinez) CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY that I true and correct copy of this ORDER has bcen scnt by U.S. Mail lo: Cccilio Manincz Resendiz and Maricela Valerio Martinez, 3371 l4s Ave. SE, Naples, FL 34117 on this f day of l\fxq,tb,-L ,2023. Codc Enforcemcnt Official Page 3 of3 6.B.1.a Packet Pg. 72 Attachment: CESD20210001490 Resendiz and Martinez (28272 : CESD20210001490 Resendiz and Martinez) COLLIER COUNTY,FLOR:DA CODE ENFORCEMENT 30ARD COLLIER COUN「YBOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS,Pctitioner CEB CASE N(》CESD20210001■90 VS CECIL:O MARTINEZ RESENDiZ AND MARICELA VALERIO MARTINEZ.DcFendant(s) AFFIDAVIT OF NON‐COMPLIANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLiER BEFORE ME,thc undersigncd autho●ty,pc、onally appcarcd Cnstina Pcrc2,COdC Enforccmcnt Offlcial forthc Codc Enforccmcnt Board ofCo∥icr COunty,who aftcr bclng fully swom,dcposcs and says: 1 ■at on Scptcmbcr 22,2022,thc Codc Enforccmcnt Board hcld a hcaHng and issucd an Ordcrin thc abovc― styled mattcr and statcd that Dcfcndant(s)Was tO Obtain thc rcquircd bu∥ding or dcmolition pcrrnit to kccP or rcmovcd thc unPcnrlittcd carpomノ mctal stmcturc, inspcction and ccrtiflcatc oF completiOn as statcd in thc Ordcr rccorded in thc public rccords ofCo∥icr County,Flo●dainOR3ook6181 PG454 2 That thc rcspondcnt did not contact thc invcstigator 3 That a rc‐inspcction was pcrfonllcd on March l,2024 4 That thc re‐inspcction rcvcalcd that thc corcctivc action ordcrcd by thc Codc EnftDrccmcnt Board was not in compliancc wnh thc fO∥。wing conditio“:rcquircd building7dc・ molmion Pcrrnl h、not bccn obtaincd, buildlng pcmi applに ation rcnlains ln r●cC10n satus FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT DATED this lst day of March,2024 COLLIER COUNTY,FLOR:DA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD ″物 Cnstina Pcrez Code Enforcement Offi cial STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER Υlt° (::翻 bSCrtbidbeForcmcbymcansofzι PhysicalpresenceOr__。n:inc notarlzation, 2024 by Chstina Perez (SignatuFe orNo饉 ::llllξ (Print/Type/Stamp Conrmissioned Name of Notary Public) HELEII BUCH:LLON C―t690n'HH 106119 巨170S May 15 2025 D―m Bt_|… … Personalll'knorvrr r 6.B.1.a Packet Pg. 73 Attachment: CESD20210001490 Resendiz and Martinez (28272 : CESD20210001490 Resendiz and Martinez) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28273) DOC ID: 28273 Updated: 3/7/2024 2:45 PM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CENA20230008527 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST CASE NO: CENA20230008527 OWNER: BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST OFFICER: Jason Packard VIOLATIONS: Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances, Chapter 54, Article VI, Section 54-185(a). Repeat violation of weeds and grass growth in excess of 18” throughout this entire improved residential lot, including the swale. FOLIO NO: 60780600003 PROPERTY 5340 Myrtle Ln, Naples, FL 34113 ADDRESS: 6.B.2 Packet Pg. 74 CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLLiER COUNTY,FLORIDA Code Enforcement Board BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS, COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,Plainiff, VS BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST,Respondent(S) Case:CENA20230008527 NOT:CE OF HEAR!NG RE:MOT:ON FORIMPOS:T10N OFF:NES′LIENS PLEASE TAKE NOT:CE that Pursuantto Secton 162 06 and 162 12,Flonda statutes,and Co∥ier County Ordinance No 0744,as amended,you are hereby ordered to appear at a pub∥c hearing before the Code Enforcement Board on the fo∥owing date,time,and place for the vlolation belowi DATE: 03/23/2024 T:ME: 09:00 AM PLACE: 3299 Tamlami Tra∥East Bu∥ding F,Naples,FL 34112 V10LAT:ON: Weeds―Mowable Lot 54-185(a) LOCAT10N OF V10LAT:ON: 5340 Myrtle LN,Naples,FL 34113 SERVED: BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST,Respondent 」ason Packard, Issuing Ofrcer RESPONDENTS ARE REQUIRED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEARING CONFERENCE HEARINGS TO BEG:N AT9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTiCEthatthe a∥eged violator may produce any and a∥documents,wlnesses and/or evidence to be re∥ed upon forthe testimony given atthe hearing Documents w∥l consist ofthe original and three coples Alleged violators have the right to be represented by an attorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that Requests for Continuances w∥I not be considered if not received by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board atleast nve(5)business days prio「to the date setforthe hear ng lT iS FURTHER ADViSED that Ordinance No 0744,as amended,be reviewed p∥orto your attendance atthe hearing to include emphasis on Section Eight relating to the appeal process Ashiey Eoff COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe Dttve Naples,Florida 34104 (239)252-2496 Telephone AnyOne who requires an auxliary aid or service for effective communication,or other reasonable accommodations to participate in this proceeding, should contactthe Conier cOunty Faclit es Management Division,located at 3335 Tamiami Tra∥E,Su te 101,Naples,Flonda 34112.or(239)252- 8380,as sclon as possible,but no laterthan 48 hours before the scheduled event such「easonable accommodations will be provided at no costto the individual NOTIFiCACiON:Esta audiencia sera conducida en elidioma lngles Servicios the traduccion no seran dispOnibles en ia audiencia y usted sera responsab e de proveer su propio traductor,para un melo「entend m ento conlas comunicaciones de este evento Po「favortraiga su propio traductor AVET:SMAN: Tout odisyon yO fOt an anglo Nou pan gin moun pou re lradiksyon Si ou pa pa16 anglё tanptt vini avё k yon intё pret pou pat6 pou―ou 6.B.2.a Packet Pg. 75 Attachment: CENA20230008527 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST (28273 : CENA20230008527 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST) INSTR 6479399 0R 6307 PCCLERK OF THE CIRCu工 T CouRT REC S■8_50 3338 RECORDED ■■/22/2023AND COMPTROLLER, COLLIER 8:42 AM PAGESCOuNTY FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARn COLLIER COUド TY.FLORIDA BOARD OF COUNTY COMⅣIISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Pctitioncr・ VS ROBERT P.Y Casc No CENA20230008527 AND LOUISE L.YARDLEY, 靴戚紺i淋専辮I搬畿撚蠍讐脚欄樅鴇 f… L R“pondcnも a“hcoⅦcs orti高野 IⅢc“y←hC“PЮ ,C“y〕 ′ ■ i 繋[IIIIIIlililIIIllI IIIIIIII:il:|:: 4 Thc Prop●●y locatcd at 5340 Myrtic Ln,Napl MYRTLE COVE ACRES BLK A COMM ATl 100FT,N170日 ,W i00FT TO POB OR l174 PI Ordinanccs,Chaptcr 54,A“icic VI,Scction S4‐1Ropcnt violation ofwocds●nd grass growth ln( lot,including thc swaic. 5 Thc violations havc not bccn abatcd as orthc dal CONCLU鉗 ONS OFI´AWイ｀ 1' Bascd u,on thc rorcgoillg facts,thc Board makcs thc : Ali noticcs v√crc propcrly and tincly issucd,and Statutcs,and Chaptcr 2,Articic IX,Codc orLaw 23:』暇安繋雷↓it認 1器 :署盤t凛 :需 l緊誕::な黒焦諸篇肌1。電思胤 ror maintaining or a∥owing thc violations to con:inuc as ofthc d口 tc orthis hcaring,and that this is a rcpcat violation ORDER _ Based upon thc forcgoing Findings ofFact and Conclusions oflarv, and pursulnt to thc authority grantcd in Chaptcr 162, Florida Stalutcs, and Chaptcr 2, Aniclc IX, Codc ofLaws and Ordininccs ofCollicr County, Florida, it is hcrcby ORDERED thar: A. RcsJ,ondcnts_arc found guihy ofa repcat violation ofCollicr Counry Codc ofLarvs and Ordinanccs, Chaptcr 54, Aniclc VI, Scction 54.185(a). Pagc I of2 6.B.2.a Packet Pg. 76 Attachment: CENA20230008527 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST (28273 : CENA20230008527 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST) '・ ' OR 6307 PG 3339 ■・I=DRcspondcnts must abatc thc violation by rnowing. or causing to bc morvcd, all wccds glass or othcr similar non-prolcctivc overgrowth in cxccss of 18" in hcight, down to a height oflcss than 6", on thc propcny on or beforc Novcmber 2, 2023 or a dsily fine of 5500.00 will bc imposcd for cach day thc violation rcmains thcrcaflcr, Rcspondents shall pry o ciril pcnally ,or lhe rcpeat riolrtion of $5,000.00 on or before Novcmber 25, 2023. IfRcspondcnts flil to comply with this Ordcr, Collicr County may abate thc violations using any mcthod to bring thc violations into compliancc and may usc thc assistancc of thc Collicr County ShcrilT's Ofl'icc to cnforcc thc proyisions oflhis Ordcr and all costs ofabalcmcnt shall bc asscsscd to Rcspondcnts. ncsponads Jr;lrOcrcd to pay opcrational costs for fic prosccution ofthis casc in thc amount of359.28 on or bcforc Ne(cr)rber ?5, 2023.,i Rcspondcnts shql.lrpfify'Code Enforcement within 24 hours ofabalcmcnt ofthc violations and rcqucst lhc invcstigator to pcrformjlsilc inspcclion to conlirm compliancc. DoNE AND oRD;iuo,n " ,6(l o^, *Dt&U-,2023, at couier counry, Frorida. 1/ Board Collicr County, Florida. PAYNIENT OF FINEST Any fincs ordcrcd to bc paid pursuant to this OrdcrEF BOARD STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER イiノ鷲四器農酬躙翌螂輩嗽熱蹴嗽鍔買i電和籠鵠胤 3出 :獣出駄 `:鷺 ::l::∥需::漱 :λ ttllduCilldCnlttcallon /1,, 瓢灘豊 Enforccmcnt Dcpanmcnt, 2800 Nonh Horscshoc Drivc, Naplcs, FL 341 N.rvw.collicrcountvfl .eov. Anv rclcasc of lien or confirmation of comnliance obligations ofthis Ordcr may also bc obtaincd at this location. APPEAI,: Any aggricvcd pany may appeal a final ordcr ofthc Board to thc thc cxccution ofrhc Ordcr appcalcd, An appcal shall not bc a hcaring de novo, but shalllrc tら l.・ "'P r, Cdxc, Ca$f, '6 a n\lc srd c.,Itcl 1還澪1鮮鸞搬織静難イ~‐ヽ lhirty (30) days of to appcllatc rcvicrv a lranscribcdofthc rccord crcatcd within thc original hcaring. It is thc rcsponsibility ofthc appcaling pr rccord oflhc hcaring fiom rhc Clcrk ofCourrs. Filing an appcal rvill nor automatically sray CERTIFiCATE OF SERVICE and Lぶこ｀翻●1鷺 IRttll罵 11:lttf:L官 :S開酔:?n““場ゝ:闘。Ro腱 “R′′ゞ′´F) DepuvO“ Pagc 2 of2 6.B.2.a Packet Pg. 77 Attachment: CENA20230008527 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST (28273 : CENA20230008527 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST) COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMEヽ T BOARD COLL:ER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMヽイ:SSiONERS.Pctiloner VS YARDLEY、ROBERT P&LOUISE L、DeFendant(s) CEB CASE NO CENA20230008527 AFFIDAVIT OF NON‐COMPLIANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER BEFORE ME,thc undcrsigncd authonty,pcrsona∥y appcared JasOn Packard,Code Enforccmcnt Offlcial fOr thc Codc Enforccmcnt Board oFColucr county,who ancr bcing fu∥y swom,dcpOscs and says: l That on Octobcr 26,2023,thc Codc Enforcemcnt Boad hcld a hcaring and issucd an Ordcr in thc abovc‐ styied rater and statcd that Defcndant(s)Was tO abtc thc violatiOn by mowing,or causing to bc mowed,a∥ wccds,grass or othcr similar non‐protcctivc ovcrgrowlh in cxccss of 18" in hcight down to a hcight oficss than 6"as statcd in thc Ordcr rccordcd in thc public rccords of Collicr County,Florida in OR B∞k6307 PG ヽ1lR 2 That thc rcspondcnt did not contact thc invcstigator 3 That a rc―inspcction was pcrforlllcd on Novcmbcr 3rd.2023 4 That thc rc‐inspcction rcvcalcd that thc corcctivc action ordercd by thc Codc Enforccmcnt Board was not in compliancc with the fo1lowing conditions:ヽ Vccds and grass rcmain abovc 18''in swalc at front ofparccl FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT DATED this 25th day oFJanuaり ,2024 COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD 舛″ Jason Packard Code Enforccmcnt Official STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER Swom to 1or aflinlqd) and subscribed before me by means of f physical presence or- onlinc nota zation. 蕪淵欲(Prinυ Type/Stamp Commlssioncd Name o「Notaヮ Public) Personaly known V (Signature of Notary Public) 6.B.2.a Packet Pg. 78 Attachment: CENA20230008527 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST (28273 : CENA20230008527 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST) COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OFCOUMY COMM:SS10NERS,Pe● “ oner VS YARDLEY,ROBERT P&LOUISE L.DeFendant(s) CEB CASE NO_CENA20230008527 AFFIDAVIT OF COMPLIANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER BEFORE ME,thc undcrsigncd authonty,Pcrsonally appcard Jason Packard,Codc Enforccmcnt Ottcial forthc Codc Enforccmcnt Board ofCoHicr COunty,who aftcr bcing fully swom,dcposcs and says: l That on Octobcr 26, 2023,thc Codc Enforccmcnt Board held a hcaring and issucd an Ordcr in thc abovc‐ stylcd matter and statcd that Dcfcndant(s)Was tO abatc all violations as statcd in thc Ordcr rccordcd in thc p●blic""ords oFCollier County,Florl&in()RB∞k 6307 PG 3338,ct scq 2 That the respondent did not contact the invcstigator 3 That a rc―inspcction was pcrfonncd on Fcbruary 5th、2024 4 That the rc‐inspcc籠 on(S)rcvCalcd that thc corrcctivc action ordcrcd by thc Codc Enbrccmcnt Board was in compliancc by a∥wccds and grass on parccirnowcd to bclow 6",including thc swalc arca FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT DATED this 5th day ofFcbruary,2024 COLLlER COUNTY.FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD 舛 P― Jason Packard Code Enforcement Oflicial STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER Swom to (or affirmcd) and subscribed before me by means of,f,physical presence or - online notarization. this S- day of Ftbt -*tl . !0"(yby Jason Packard 蕪淵鶉(Print/Typeistsmp Commissioncd Name of Notary Public) Pcnonally known I/(Sgnaturc of N前嚢戸向blic) 6.B.2.a Packet Pg. 79 Attachment: CENA20230008527 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST (28273 : CENA20230008527 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28294) DOC ID: 28294 Updated: 3/7/2024 3:45 PM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CESD20230003212 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST CASE NO: CESD20230003212 OWNER: BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST OFFICER: Doug Williams VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e)(i). Carport converted into living space, and lanai addition without valid Collier County building permit. FOLIO NO: 60780600003 PROPERTY 5340 Myrtle Ln, Naples, FL 34113 ADDRESS: 6.B.3 Packet Pg. 80 CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLLiER COUNTY,FLORIDA Code Enforcement Board BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS, COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,Plaint ff. VS BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST,Respondent(S) Case:CESD20230003212 NOTiCE OF HEAR:NG RE:MOT:ON FOR:MPOS:T10N OF FINES′LIENS PLEASE TAKE NOTiCE that Pursuantto Sec∥on 162 06 and 162 12,Florida Statutes,and Co∥ier County Ordinance No 07‐44, as amended,you are hereby ordered to appear at a pub∥c hearing before the Code Enforcement Board on the fo∥owing date,time,and place forthe violation belowi DATE: 03′28/2024 T:ME: 09:00 AM PLACE: 3299 Tamiami Tra∥East Bu ding F,Naples,FL 34112 ViOLAT:ON: CO Requred ATF Permns lo o2 06(B)(1)(a)and 10 02 06(B)(1)(e)(り LOCAT:ON OF V10LAT:ON: 5340 Myrtle LN,Naples,FL 34113 SERVED: BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST,Respondent Doug VV∥∥ams, lssuing Off cer RESPONDENTS ARE REQUIRED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEAR!NG CONFERENCE HEAR:NGS TO BEGIN AT 9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTiCE thatthe a∥eged violator may produce any and a∥documents,wlnesses and/or evidence to be rehed upon forthe test mony given atthe hearng Documents w∥I consist ofthe original and three coples AIleged violators have the rightto be represented by an attorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOT:CE that Requests for Conlnuances w∥ not be cons dered r not received by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board atleast ive(5)business days pttorto the date setforthe hea百 ng lT:S FURTHER ADViSED that Ordlnance No 0744,as amended,be rev ewed pnorto your atendance atthe heanng t。 include emphasis on Section Eight relating to the appeal process Helen Buch∥lon COLLIER COUNIY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples,Flo「ida 34104 (239)252‐5892 Telephone Anyone who requ res an auxliary aid or service for efFeclive communication,or other reasonable accommodat,ons to participate in this p「oceeding, should contactthe Co le「County Fac lties Management Division,located at 3335 Tamiami T「al E,Sute 101,Naples Florida 34112,or(239)252‐ 8380,as soon as pOssible but nO laterthan 48い ours before the scheduled event Such reasonable accommodat ons u∥be provided at no cosito the individual NOTlFiCAC:ON:Esta audiencia sera conducida en elidioma ingles Servicios the t「aduccion no seran dispOnibles en la audiencia y usted sera responsable de proveer su proplo traduclor pa「a un melo「entendimiento con las comunicaciones de este evento Por ravo「tra19a su p「op10 1「aduclor AVETISMAN: Tout odisyon yo fOt an angio Nou pan gin moun pou rO tradiksyon Si ou pa palё anglё tanp「 vini avё k yon intep「et pOu pa10 pOu―ou 6.B.3.a Packet Pg. 81 Attachment: CESD20230003212 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST (28294 : CESD20230003212 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST) INSTR 6433■67 oR 627■ Pc 3876 RECORDED 7/26/2023CLERK OF THE CIRCu工 T CouRT AND COMPTROLLER, COLLIER REC S■8.50 4:36 PM PACESCOuNTY FLORIDA COLLIER COUNTγ CODE ENFORCEMENTCODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD Case No.―CESD20230003212 BOARD OF COUNrY COMMISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Petitloner, vs. Robert P. 8nd Loulse L. Resporldettas. and thc Boald, having heard testimony malters, hereupor issucs its Findings Board (thc "Board") for public hearing on luoe 22,2023, evidence and heard argument respectivc to all appropriatc ofLaw, and Order ofthe Board as follows: l. Allnoticcs were propcrly and timely issucd, and thc Boald hasjurisdiction pursuafi/t to;bhapter 162, Florida Statutcs, and Chapter 2, Anicle IX, Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collicr Counry, Eldda../2. The preponderance of the evidencc shows that violations of Scctions l0.02.06(8)(lXa) and 10.02.06(8)( I )(c)(i), Ord. No.04-41, as amcnded, Collier County Land Developmeot Code, do cxist, and that Respondents committed, and were responsible for maintaining or allowing the violations to continue as ofthe date ofrhis hearing. ORDER Based upon the foregoing Findings ofFacl and Conclusions oflaw, and pursuant to thc authoriry granred in ChaPter 162, Florida Staiutes, and Chapter 2, Article IX, Code ofLaws and Ordinances ofCollier County, ito.iaa, it is hereby ORDERED that: L Resp¨ “ n、RめけtR mdLШ tt Lつ IT,,eOme、♂続ぃubJect「 "e● 0び ?Ю pcc) 2. Respondents, having been notificd of t tr" alr rtrrttry.qcenified mail8nd posting, did not sppcar st the public hcaring. ,/' , 3. The Property located at 5340 MYRTLE LN., NapleS,Folio No. 60780600003 (Legal Description: MYRTLE COVE ACRES BLK A COMM AT NW i00「,N170FT,W100Fr TO POB oR l174 PG OF E 200「F OF LOT 14,S170日 ,E of Sections I 0.02.06(8)( I )(a) and 10.02.06(8)(l )(e)(i), Ord. No. O4-41, as amendcd, Colliir palticulats: Iand Development Code, in the following Carport coryerled lnto livinB sp8cc, !nd lanrl additlon valid Collier County bulldlng permit. 4. The violations have not been abatcd ss ofthe date ofthis hearing. { ) Bascd upon ihe forcgoing fscts, the Board makes th€ following Conclusions o レ/) FTHECOD Pagc I of2 1/ワ 6.B.3.a Packet Pg. 82 Attachment: CESD20230003212 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST (28294 : CESD20230003212 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST) 十姜贅 OR 627■ PG 3877 ☆■十 A. Respondents are found guilty ofviolsting Scctions 10.02.06(8)( I )(a) and 10.02.06(8)( I )(e)(i)' Ord. No. (X- 41, as amcndcd, Collier County l,and DeveloPmenr Code. B. Rcspondents must abate all violstions by obtaining all rcquired Collier County Building Permit(s) or Demolition permit(s) and request all inspections rhrough Cenificale ofCompletioo/Occupancy for the carpon conversion ind lanai addition on or before November 19, 2023, or a line of $175.00 per d8y will bc imposed for each day the violations rcmain thcreafler.CIrRcspondcnts,∥to cOmply with this Ordcr,Couicr county may abatc the violations using any mcthod to bring the into compliancc and may use the assistance of thc Collier County Sherills Office to enforce ofthis Order and all costs ofabatemcnt shall bc assessed to Respondents. l職 :績 :二翠認烹窯嗅l駆鷺∬:認柵 c:labacmemofttc宙 d“ons and“qu‐■c10y OF｀スリ危 .2023,at Cd∥er County,Flo∥dn.DONE AND lo pay opcrational costs for thc proseculion of this case in thc amount of359.28 on physical Prcsence or O online nolarization, STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER 騰擁讐肥輩Ш2宣里多被鵠 Board ColHer County,F〕orida. Chair ofthe Collier County Code Enforcemcnt ,{Personally Known OR E Produccd Idcntification T)?e of Idcntifi cation Produccd and b●:∬ⅧX,'鷺 IR批置(l競露;T::出 1:lⅧ 「塊げ“byYλ 蟹甜。Robc“R11..::|: ‐ ■‐`CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE Codc Enforcement O繊 :: D可 x,Cie“ Page 2 of2 シリ '、レイ,| ′ 爛紳懲i撤 9′ 6.B.3.a Packet Pg. 83 Attachment: CESD20230003212 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST (28294 : CESD20230003212 BERNHARDT FAMILY TRUST) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28274) DOC ID: 28274 Updated: 3/7/2024 2:49 PM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CEAU20220010097 BEST HOMES BUILDER AT GG LLC CASE NO: CEAU20220010097 OWNER: BEST HOMES BUILDER AT GG LLC OFFICER: Joseph Marino VIOLATIONS: Florida Building Code 7th Edition (2020), Chapter 1, Section 105.1. Fence built without a valid Collier County permit. FOLIO NO: 302800005 PROPERTY 1190 Ivy Way, Naples, FL 34117 ADDRESS: 6.B.4 Packet Pg. 84 CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLLiER COUNTY,FLOR:DA Code Enforcement Board BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS, Case:CEAU20220010097 COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,P ain,ff, VS BEST HOMES BUILDER AT CG LLC,Respondent(S) NOTICE OF HEARING RE:MOT:ON FOR:MPOSiT:ON OF FINESノ LIENS PLEASE TAKE NOTiCE that Pursuantto Seclon 162 06 and 162 12,Flo「ida Statutes,and Co∥ier County Ordinance No 07‐44,as amended,you are hereby ordered to appear at a pub∥c hearing before the Code Enforcement Board on the fo∥owing date,time,and place forthe violation below: DATE: o3/28/2024 T:ME: 09:00 AM PLACE: 3299 Tamianni Tral East Bu∥ding F,Naples,FL 34112 V10LAT10N: Fence―Bu∥ding Pe「mI FBC 2020 105 1 LOCAT10N OF ViOLAT10N: 1190 1vy wAY,Naples,FL 34117 SERVED: BEST HOMES BU LDER AT CG LLC,Respondent 」oseph Marino, lssuing Of「cer RESPONDENTS ARE REQU!RED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEAR:NG CONFERENCE HEARINGS TO BEGIN AT 9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOT:CE thatthe a∥eged violator may produce any and a∥documents,witnesses and/or evidence to be reled upon forthe testimony given atthe hearing Documents wi∥consist ofthe or glnal and th「ee coples A∥eged violators have the rightto be represented by an attorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOT:CE that Requests for Conlnuances w∥I not be consldered if not received by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board atleast ive(5)business days pr orto the date setforthe hearing :TiS FURTHER ADViSED that()rdlnance No 0744,as amended,be reviewed p∥OrtO your attendance atthe heanng to include emphasls on Section Eight relat ng to the appeal process Ashley Eoff COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe Dttve Naples,Florida 34104 (239)252-2496 Telephone 薄暢瀞#1鞣製乱雷概11屠膵31i難簡蠍野響:鞠代瀾翼淵11驚[鼎警鷺掛輌:帯 he 爵J覇町醐篇輌群鶴1鼎 i舗灘癬珊鶏蠅織淵灘尉1蒻舗:舗濡F・ 6.B.4.a Packet Pg. 85 Attachment: CEAU20220010097 BEST HOMES BUILDER AT GG LLC (28274 : CEAU20220010097 BEST HOMES BUILDER AT GG LLC) CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COI´LIER COUヽ TY,FLORIDA 30ARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Pctitioncr, VS BEST HOMES BUILDER AT CG,LLC, Rcspondent(S〉 Casc No CEAU20220010097 ORDER OF THE CODE ENFORCENIf,NT BOARD THIS CAUSE came before rhe Code Enlbrcemcnt Board (the "Board") for public hcaring on July 31,2023, and the Board, having heard testimony under oath, receivcd evidence and heard argument respective to all appropriatc matters, hereupon issues its Findings of Fact, conclusions ofLaw, and order ofthe Board as follows: FINDINGS OF FACT l. Respondcnt, Best Homes Builder at GG LLC, is the orvncr of the subject propeny (hereinafter "Propeny"). 2. Respondent, having bccn notificd ofthe date ofthe hearing by cenified mail and posting. did appear at thc public hearing through autho zed reprcsentativc Michael Garcia. and admitrcd the unpermitted fence violation exists on the PropertY. 3. The Properry located at I l90Ivy Way, Naples, FL 34117, Folio No. 302800005 (Legal Description; 14 49 27 wt/2 OF Nl/2 OF Nl/2 OF Nl/2 OF Sl/2 OF NEI/4 LESS w 35FT) is in violation of Florida Building Code 7th Edition (2020), Chapter l, Part 2, Section 105.1, in the following pa.ticulars: Fence buil( without a v&lid Collier County permit. 4. The violation has not bcen abated as ofthc date of this hearing. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW Based upon the foregoing facts, the Board makcs the following Conclusions of Law: L All noticcs \,!'crc propcrly and timcly issued, and the Board has jurisdiction pursuant to Chapter 162. Florida Statutcs, and Chaptcr 2, Anicle lX, Code ofLarvs and Ordinanccs ofCollier County, Florida. 2. The preponderance ofthc cvidencc shows that violation ofFlorida Building Code 7th Edition (2020), Chapter l, Part 2, Section 105. I , does exist, and that Respondent committed. and was rcsponsitrle for maintaining or allowing the violations to continue as ofthe date of this hearing. ORDER Based upon the foregoing Findings ofFact and Conclusions ofLaw, and pursuant to the authority granted in Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 2, Article IX, Codc ofLaws and Ordinances ofCollier County, Florida, it is hereby ORDERED that: A. Respondcnts arc found guilry of violating Florida Building Code 7th Edition (2020), Chaplcr l, Parr 2, Section 105.1. B. Respondents must abatc all violations by obtaining all required Collier Counry Building Permit(s) or Demolition permit(s) and request all inspections through Cenificatc of CompletioniOccupancy for the Page I of2 6.B.4.a Packet Pg. 86 Attachment: CEAU20220010097 BEST HOMES BUILDER AT GG LLC (28274 : CEAU20220010097 BEST HOMES BUILDER AT GG LLC) Cunpermitted fence on or before September 29,2023, or a fine of S150.00 per day will be imposed for each day the violations rcmain thercaftcr. If Respondcnts fail to comply with this Order, Collier County may abate the violations using any method to bring the violations into c<lmpliance and may use the assistance of the Collier County SherifPs Office to enforce the provisions ofthis Order and all costs ofabatemcnt shall bc asscssed to Respondents. Respondents are ordered to pay operational costs for the prosecution ofthis case in the amount of$59.28 on or before August 30,2023. Respondents shall notify Code Enforcement within 24 hours of abatcment of thc violations and request the investigator to perform a site inspection to confirm compliancc. DONE AND ORDf,RED rhis { Js hy ot..,2023, at Collier County, Florida. STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER this lld day of 5古 .2023, by Robert Kaufman. Chair of the Collicr County Codc E,nforcement Board Collicr County, Flbrida. .E[Personally Known OR D Produccd ldentification Type of Identification Produced E. 蕪鶯鱗lCommissioned Name of Notary Public (Print/Type/Stamp) PAYIIIENT OF FINEST Any fines ordcrcd to be paid pursuant to this Order may be paid at the Collier County Code Enforcenrent Department, 2800 North Horseshoe Drive, Naples, FL 34 104. Phone: (239) 252-2440, Wcbsite: wrvw.colliercountyll.gov. Any release of lien or confirmation of compliance or conllrmation of the satisfaction of the obligations of this Order may also be obtaincd at this location. APPEAL: Any aggrieved p"rty may appeal a final ordcr of the Board to the Circuit Court within thirty (30) days of the execution of the Order appealed. An appeal shall not be a hcaring dc novo, but shall be limited to appellate review of the record crcated within the original hearing. It is thc responsibility of the appealing party to obtain a transcribed rccr.rrd o[the hearing lrom the Clerk of Courts. Filing an appeal rvill not aulontatically stay this Order. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY that a truc and correct copy ofthis ORDER has been sent by U.S.Mali to:BEST HOMES BUILDER AT GG, LLC, 5030 SW 170 AVE., SOUTHWEST RANCHES, FL, 33331, on ,202■ 脚 ∬含P Signature of Notary Public - State of Florida Code Enforccmcnt Offi cial Page 2 of2 physical Prcsencc or D online notarization, 6.B.4.a Packet Pg. 87 Attachment: CEAU20220010097 BEST HOMES BUILDER AT GG LLC (28274 : CEAU20220010097 BEST HOMES BUILDER AT GG LLC) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28275) DOC ID: 28275 Updated: 3/7/2024 2:55 PM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CESD20220008207 Navarro, Palacios and Hughes CASE NO: CESD20220008207 OWNER: Walter A Navarro, Krissia I Palacios, Graciela E Hughes and John Hughes OFFICER: Jason Packard VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e). Interior conversion of garage to livable space, complete with bathroom, kitchen, and AC unit. FOLIO NO: 54901960004 PROPERTY 103 Warwick Hills Dr, Naples, FL 34113 ADDRESS: 6.B.5 Packet Pg. 88 CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLLiER COUNTY,FLOR:DA Code Enforcement Board BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS, Case:CESD20220008207 COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,Plainttff, VS WALTER A NAVARRO KRISSIAIPALAC10S GRACIELA E HUGHES AND」OHN HUGHES,Respondent(S) NOTICE OF HEAR:NG RE:MOT10N FOR:MPOS:T:ON OF FINES′LIENS PLEASE TAKE NOT:CE that Pursuantto Section 162 06 and 162 12,Flonda statutes,and Co ner cOunty Ordinance No 0744,as amended,you are hereby ordered to appear at a pub∥c hearing before the Code Enforcement Board on the fo∥owing date,time,and place forthe violat on below: DATE: o3/23/2024 TIME: o91oO AM PLACE: 3299 Tamiami Tra∥East Bunding F,Naples,FL 34112 ViOLAT:ON: Bu∥ding Perml LDC 10 02 06(B)(1)(a)and 10 02 06(B)(lXe) LOCAT10N OF V10LAT:ON: 103 VVan″ck H∥ls DR,Naples,FL 34113 SERVED: WALTER A NAVARRO,KRISSIA I PALACIOS,GRACIELA E HUGHES AND 」OHN HUGHES,Respondent 」ason Packard, Issuing Of「cer RESPONDENTS ARE REQUIRED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEARING CONFERENCE HEARINCS TO BEGlN AT 9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTiCEthatthe a∥eged violator may produce any and a∥documents,wlnesses and/or evldence to be re∥ed upon fo「the testimony glven atthe hearing Documents w∥l consist ofthe origlnal and three coples AIleged violators have the right to be represented by an attorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that Requests for Conlnuances w∥ not be considered lf not received by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board atleast nve(5)business days pr orto the date setforthe hear ng :T iS FURTHER ADVISED that Ordinance No 0744,as amended,be reviewed priorto your attendance atthe hea∥ng to include emphasis on Section Eight relating to the appeal process Ashley Eoff COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples,Flor da 34104 (239)252-2496 Teiephone Anyone who requires an auxliary ald o「service for efFect Ve∞mmunication,or other reasonable accommodat,ons to participate in this prOceeding, should contactthe Co∥er County Fac∥it es Management Division,Iocated at 3335 Tamiami T「a]E.Su te 101,Naples,Flonda 34112 o「(239)252‐ 8380,as soon as possible,but no laterthan 48 hours before the scheduled event Such reasonable accommodatlons w∥ be provided at no costto the individual NOTlFiCACiON:Esta audiencia sera conducida en elidioma lngles Servioios the traduccion no seran disponibles en la audiencia y usted sera responsab e de proveer su prop o traductor,para un melor entend m ento con as comunicaciones de este evento Po「favortralga su propiO traducto「 AVET:SMANI Toutodisyon yO fet an anglё Nou pan gin moun pou Fe tradiksyon SIou pa pall anglё tanpn viniavё k yon intё pret pOu palё pou ou 6.B.5.a Packet Pg. 89 Attachment: CESD20220008207 Navarro, Palacios and Hughes (28275 : CESD20220008207 Navarro, Palacios and Hughes) INSTR 6404363 oR 6248 PC CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT REC S35.50 ■NDX S2.00 RECORDED 5/■7/2023 ■■:3■ AM PACES COMPTROLLER, COLL工 ER COuNTY FLORIDA COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD Cal●No.CESD20220008207 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Petitioner, VS. Walter A.Navarro,Kri`Jメ |五 Ldos,Crndela E. Respordent(s). TIIIS CAUSE came before ttre Cd eforcement Board (rhe "Board") for public hearing on April 27, 2023, and the Board, having heard testimony und*oattgreqeived evidence and heard argument rcspective to all appropriate matters, hereupon issues its Findings of Fact, @ooclurigns ofLaw, and Order ofthe Board as follows:1Respondent(s), Wrltcr A. Navarro, Krissiy' t. Paleci,os. Grsciels E, Hughes, and John Hugh€s, is/are the owner(s) ofthe subject property (the "Property;X ./ Respondenr(s), having been notified ofthe date of,frearlng by certificd mail and posting, did have Walter A. Navarro, and Krissia I. Palacios appear at the publiChcarli'gi, Prior to rhe hearing, Rcspondent(s) entered into a Stipu/atprf, which is attached hereto as Exhibit "A." The Stipulation is adopted and incorporated into rhis Order, an'd Rgy'onden(s) is/are ordered to comply. 4E豊霧器P滞糧TLttt常ザ話鷺燻蝋」設鰐盟1脚路譜柵 No 0441,as amended,Sc“ons 1002 06oXlXめ md100206oXI夕 |'nC ttbMng pattcma耐 Interlor conversion oF garage to l:vable space,complete with bat112'm,kit,hen,and AC unit 5. The violation(s) has/have not been abated as ofthe date ofthis hearing. ' CONCLUSIONS OF LAW ,' i I Ba5cdupontheforegoingfacts,theBoardmakesthefollowingConclusionsofLaw: l. All notices were properly and timely issued, and the Board hasjurisdiction pursuart to Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Chaprei 2, Article IX, Code ofLaws and Ordinances ofCollier County' Florida' 2. The preponderance ofthe evidence shows that violatioD(s) ofCollier Counry Land Development Code, Ord. No..04-4l,asamendd,Sectionsl0.02'06(8)(l)(a)and10.02.06(8)(l)(e)'do/doesexist,andthat Respondeni(s) committed, and waywere responsible for maintaining or allowing the violation(s) to continue as ofthe date ofthis hearing. ,BDEB BasedupontheforegoingFindingsofFactandconclusiolsofLaw,andpursuanttotheauthoritygrantedin Ct upt", iei, rtoliaa s1oaute; and-Chapt"iz, eni.t. tx, code of Laws and ordinances ofCollier Countv' Florida' it is hereby ORDERED that: Pag€ I of3 サ:6.B.5.a Packet Pg. 90 Attachment: CESD20220008207 Navarro, Palacios and Hughes (28275 : CESD20220008207 Navarro, Palacios and Hughes) OR 6248 PG 842A R€spondent(s) is/are found guilty ofviolating Collicr County Land Devclopmedt Codc, Ord. No. 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.05(B)(lXa) and 10.02.06(BXlXe). Respondent(s) must abate all violations byr l. ccasing and desisting the use ofthe unpermined garage convcrsion and disconnecting all unpermitted utililies until a valid pcmit, inspections and Ccnifictae ofCompletion/OccuPancy has been issued on or before Aprit 30, 2023, or a line of5200.00 per day will be imposed for each day lhe violation(s) remain thereafter; and 2. obtaininf all required Collie! County Building Permit(s), Demolition Permit, Inspections, and Cerfrfichtgrf Completior/occupancy for the unpermitted gatage conversion on or before August 25,20fior a flne of $200.00 per d.y will be imposed for each day the violation(s) remain tt'...{n.r- r) C. If Respondenr(s) Fad to comply with this Order, Collier County may abate the violalion(s) using any mcthod to bring the violarion(iffnre/compliance and may use the assistance ofthe Collier County Sherifls Office to enforce the provisioris ofthis Order and all costs ofabatement shall be assessed lo Respondent(s). D. Rcspondent is ordered topaf'oferational costs fo! the plosecution ofthis casc ir the amouot of$59.28 on or betore[ay 27,2023. ,/ DoNE AND oRDErtIjDthk ,rkidy of. STATE OF FLORIDA COUNrY OF COLLIER 騰堕盤;:l翌をだ翌型里電謝躙謝還器 Board Collier County, Fldrida. 2023 at Colller County, Floridr. cxccution I creaied rrOm thc 蕪膨蝙i PAYMENToFFINES:Anyfinesorderedtobepaidpursuanttothis.ordermaybePaidatthecolliercountycode it,rf#-""t -D"p"tt*.,rt, z'soo Nont Horseshoi Drive, Naples, FL 34104, Phone: (239) 252-2440, website: o rrw,colliercountyfl.gov. Any release oflien o! confirmation ofcomiliance orconfirmation ofthe satisfaction ofthe.obligations ofthir O.d"t.ry ulto be obtaired at this location. :; ' 1 " ' o cdier County .t Personally Known OR O Produced Identification Type of Identifi calion Produced APPEAL:Any aggricVcd Party may appcal a rlna1 0rder OFthe Board to the Circult Cou●within 『橋ち扇l‐昴躙 :百 Anl:二証二ai・ n゛ ■lheallg dC nor,butsial■ITitl■ψ,Ⅲ,‐V・ ‐‐.‐rr__……¨―rr【蕉 [ζ:gnslbnity Orttt appCa、vithin the original hearing it il _ .Itt Ra,y。°Ыan a tansci喫 ii"[ "ii"G. fif itg an-appeal will not automarically stay this Order' Page 2 of3 DGI●●Cle点ノ |だ 6.B.5.a Packet Pg. 91 Attachment: CESD20220008207 Navarro, Palacios and Hughes (28275 : CESD20220008207 Navarro, Palacios and Hughes) OR 6248 Pc 843 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY thatatruc and corrcctcopy ofthis ORDER has becn scntby u s Ma■,o:Wa:tcr A Navaro,Knssia I Code Enforcement Omcial Page 3 of 3 6.B.5.a Packet Pg. 92 Attachment: CESD20220008207 Navarro, Palacios and Hughes (28275 : CESD20220008207 Navarro, Palacios and Hughes) 十 '■ OR 6248 Pc 844 ■■■ 80ARD OF COUNTY COMMiSS:ONERS Coi∥er County,Flonda,Petitioner, VS Walter A Navaro,Knssia:.Pa!acios,Graciela E.Hughes,and John Hughes, inspections and hearing or a fine of owner‐ or Representative (sign) Case No CESD20220008207 Respondent(S), ST:PULAT:ONrAGREEMENT on behalf of Walter and Hughes, enters into this and Agreement of Notices of Vio!ation in reFerence(case)number cESD20220008207 ^l/';This agreement is subjec{ to theepproval of the Code Enforcement Board. lf it is not approved, the case may be heard on the scheduled Hearing date, therefore it is strongly recomm€nded that the respondent or representative attend the Hearing. enforcement process; and to obtain a hereto agree as follows: I stipulate to their existence, THEREFORE, il is agreed between the parties thaf the B sha∥:1) Pay operational costs in the amount of 1359.28 in the prosecution of this case within 30 days of this hearing. 2) Abate all violations by: (1) Cease and Desist the use of the oonversion and disconnect all unpermitted 淵lぼ Y∥ a首 :児誓¶Lvio:ation is abated. 製pttP:婦喘F翻舗鯖論寵 (2)Obtaining a∥required Co∥ier County Bu∥ding PerFniCOr Demol面 on Pe電 Jt,inSpe“i9n, end 3) 4) ―― ‐ , ´ ― ― 宙thh i20と ayξ Ofth、hea哺 ng譜権鵠鬱堅出β =拓馳MlR島寵盟器Iisabated.or a fine of $l-o O--per day will be imposed until the Violatpn is abated. Respondent must notiry Code Enforcement within 24 hoursd;tbatement of the violation and request the lnvestigator perform a site inspeciion to confirm c(npli?nce. ef liutc notce andtb. by pho; or tar dnd 6edc dunng ole $rortweei. llthe vlolalon ls ababd 2a hot,rs Fi62b S.tur&y, Sunday or l€gslholday, lheo th. noDic.ton mu3t tr mea,c on tt! ien day thet B ncl a Saturdrr, Sl,l(lay 6leg.l holday.) 1!lheo th. noDic.ton mu3ttl. mea,c on tt! ien day thet B ncl a Saturdry, S(I'day 6leg.lholday.) -- ,' , That if the Respondent fails to abate the violation the County may aba6 tnedigtation ' Lqing any method to bring the vioiation into compliance and may use the assistance of the Collier/Co,unty Sheriffs Office to enforcE lhq provisiogs/lhis agreement and all costs of abatement shall De-EiiSessed to the property θ名/どう7/20乙3 Date Date hearing is currently scheduled for April to promote efriciency in the of the code 6.B.5.a Packet Pg. 93 Attachment: CESD20220008207 Navarro, Palacios and Hughes (28275 : CESD20220008207 Navarro, Palacios and Hughes) COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY 30ARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS,Pcthioner CEB CASE NO.CESD20220008207 VS NAVARRO,WALIER A KRISS:A IPAl′ACIOS GRACIELA E&JOHN HUGHES,DeFendant(s) AFFIDAVIT OF NON‐CCDMPLIANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER BEFORE ME,thc undcrs:gned authority.persona∥y appcarcd Jason Packard,Codc Enforcement Offlcial forthe Code Enforcement Board ofCollicr County.who attr being fully swom.deposes and says: l That on Ap」127.2023,thc Codc Enforccment Board held a hcaring and issued an Ordcr in the above‐styled mater and statcd that DeFendant(s)waS tO Cease and desist thc usc ofthe unperrnittcd garage conversion and disconnecting a∥ unpennitted utilities until a valid pellllit, inspcctions and Ccrtiflcatc of Completion/Occupancy has been issued on or beforc Apri1 30,2023 or a inc of S200 per day will be imposed each day the violation(S)rcmain thercafter as stated in the Order recordcd in the public records of Co∥ier Counw.Fioridain OR B∞k6'4R PG■41 2 That the respondent did not contact the investigator 3 That a rc‐inspection was perfOlillCd On May lst,2023 4 That thc re‐inspeclon reveded that the corrective acJon ordered by the Code Enforcemcnt Board was not in compliance with the following conditions:Water and electricity were st∥lin operatiOn at time ofinspeclon FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT DATED this llth day ofJuiy,2023 COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT 30ARD 舛 %イ Jason Packard Code Enforcement Offi cial STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER online notarization. Public) ADAM FARINA Commissbn,HI12α Юη ExoiresAuqustl1 2026 Personally known 'vr 6.B.5.a Packet Pg. 94 Attachment: CESD20220008207 Navarro, Palacios and Hughes (28275 : CESD20220008207 Navarro, Palacios and Hughes) COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT 30ARD COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS,Pctittoncr VS CEB CASE NO CESD20220008207 NAVARRO,WALTER A KRISSlA IPALACIOS GRAC:ELA E&JOHN HUGHES,DcFcndant(s) AFFIDAVIT OF PARTIAL COMPL:ANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COし LIER BEFORE ME.thc undersigncd authoriり ,persOnal!y appeared Jason Packard、Codc Enforccmcnt Offlcial forthc Code Enforcemcnt Board ofCol:ier Counり ,WhO aner being fu∥y swOrn,dcposes and says: l That on Apri1 27,2023,thc Code Enforcemcnt Board held a hearing and issued an Order in thc above―styled mater and stated that Defendant(s)Was tO abate ail violations as stated in part B(l)。f the ordcr recorded in thc pub∥c records ofCol∥er COunty,FIoHdain OR Book 6248 PG 842.et seq 2. That the rcspondcnt did contact the investigator 3 That a re―inspcction was pcrfomed on May 2nd,2023 4 That the reinspccJon(s)rcvealed that thc corecttve actton ordercd by thc Codc Enforccment Board was in complね nce by ha宙 ng Jl utll面 cs shut offand area unoccu口 ed by tCnant FURTHER AFF:ANT SAYETH NOT DATED ths 24th day of口 ,2023 COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT 30ARD 舛脅 Jason Packard Code Enforcement Ottcial STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER 漁WttP岬げ“ HI:枇蹴獣 m¨fZp"壺 Jpい mm_酬 h¨d猜 abL ckard Personally known J 胤淵‰PErp ros August 11. m26 6.B.5.a Packet Pg. 95 Attachment: CESD20220008207 Navarro, Palacios and Hughes (28275 : CESD20220008207 Navarro, Palacios and Hughes) COLLIER COUNTγ ,FLORIDACODE ENFORCEMENT 30ARD COLLIER COUNTY 30ARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS,PcJtioner (,EB CASE NO CESD20220008207 VS NAVARRO,WALTER A KRISSIA IPALAC10S GRAC:ELA E&JOHN HUGHES,DcFcndant(s) AFFIDAV:T OFNON‐COMPLIANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER BEF()RE ME,the undcrsigned authodty,persOna∥y appeared Jason Packard,Code Enforcemcnt Offlcial forthe Code Enforcement Board ofCo∥ier County,who after bcing fu∥y swom,dcposes and says: l That on Apri1 27,2023,the Code Enforcemcnt Board held a hcaring and issucd an Order in thc abovc‐stylcd mattcr and stated that Dcfcndant(s)Was tO Obtain all rcquircd cOI:icr County Building Permit(s),Demolilon Pennit,Inspections and Certincate ofcompletion/Occupancy for thc unpc∥ilittcd garagc convcrsion as stated in the Order recorded in the public records o「Co∥ier County,Floridain OR B∞k 6248 PG 841 2 That the respondent did not contact thc investigator 3 That a re―inspection was perfonncd on August 28th.2023 4 Thatthc r←inspection rcvcaled that the corcctive action ordcred by the Code Enforccmcnt Board was not in compliance with the fo∥owing conditions:Perrnits have not been issued FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT DATED this 29th day ofAugust,2023 COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD 舛 %イ JasonPaffi Code Enforcement Oflicial STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER 滞1柑 VWi山 “∥懺忠蹴 d° tty並 Jpぃ m∝∝酬hc n面面¨,Commissbn″HH 2996211 ExpresAu9u●11.2026 Public) ′ (Signature of Notary public) Personally known i 6.B.5.a Packet Pg. 96 Attachment: CESD20220008207 Navarro, Palacios and Hughes (28275 : CESD20220008207 Navarro, Palacios and Hughes) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28281) DOC ID: 28281 Updated: 3/7/2024 3:00 PM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CEAU20220006876 PSB LAND TRUST CASE NO: CEAU20220006876 OWNER: PSB LAND TRUST OFFICER: Jonathan Musse VIOLATIONS: Florida Building Code 7th Edition (2020), Chapter 1, Section 105.1. Vinyl fence installed on the left side and right rear of the dwelling without first obtaining a valid Collier County permit. FOLIO NO: 62205480007 PROPERTY 5373 Holland St, Naples, FL 34113 ADDRESS: 6.B.6 Packet Pg. 97 CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLLiER COUNTY,FLOR:DA Code Enforcement Board BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS, COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,Plainlff, VS PSB LAND TRUST,Respondent(S) Case:CEAU20220006876 NOTiCE OF HEARING RE:MOT:ON FORIMPOSIT10N OF F:NES′LiENS PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that Pursuantto Section 162 06 and 162 12,Flo“da Statutes,and Co her County Ordinance No 0744,as amended,you are hereby ordered to appear at a public hearing before the Code Enforcement Board on the following date,time,and place forthe violation below: DATE: o3/28/2024 T:ME: o9:oO AM PLACE: 3299 Tamiami Tra∥East Bu∥ding F,Naples,FL 34112 ViOLAT10N: Fence‐Bu ding Perml FBC 2020 105 1 LOCAT:ON OFV:OLAT10N: 5373 Ho∥and ST,Nap es,FL 34113 SERVED: PSB LAND TRUST,RespOndent 」onathan Musse, lssuing Of「cer RESPONDENTS ARE REQU:RED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEAR:NG CONFERENCE HEAR:NGS TO BEG!N AT9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOT:CE thatthe a∥eged vlolator may produce any and a∥documents,wlnesses and/or evidence to be re∥ed upon forthe testimony glven atthe hearing Documents w∥ oonslst ofthe original and three copies A∥eged violators have the rightto be represented by an attorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTiCE that Requests for Conlnuances w∥l not be considered if not received by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board atleast ive(5)business days pr orto the date setforthe hearing iT:S FURTHER ADVISED that Ordinance No 0744,as amended,be reviewed p面 OrtO yOur attendance atthe hea∥ng tO lnclude emphasis on Section E19ht relating to the appeal process Ashley EofF COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe DHve Naples,Flo「ida 34104 (239)252-2496 Telephone AnyOne who requires an aux∥iary ald or service for effective communication,o「other reasonable accommodat ons to participate in this proceeding, should contaclthe Co∥er County FaC∥ "es Management D v s on,ocated at 3335 Tamiami Tra∥ E,Su te 101,Naples,Fo商 da 34112,or(239)252‐ 3380,as soon as possible.but no laterthan 48 hours before the scheduled event Such reasonable accommodat ons wll be provided at no cclstto the individual NOT!F:CAC:ON:Esta audiencia sera conducida en elidioma lngles Servicios the traduccion no seran disponibles en la audiencia y usted sera responsable de proveer su prop:o traductor,para un melor entendimiento con ias cc municaciones de este evento PorravOrtralga su proplo traductor AVETISMAN: Tout odisyon yo fet an anglё Nou pan gin moun pou e tradiksyOn Siou pa pale anglё tanpl viniavOk yonintepret pou pa10 pOu―ou 6.B.6.a Packet Pg. 98 Attachment: CEAU20220006876 PSB LAND TRUST (28281 : CEAU20220006876 PSB LAND TRUST) INSTR 6387893 oR 6235 PG 36■ CLERK OF THE C工 RCu工 T CouRT ANDREC S27.00 COLLIER COUNrY CODE ENTORCEMENT CODE ENFCDRCEMENT BOARD Cnse No.CEAU20220006876 BOARD OF COUNTY COMい gISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Petitioner9 VS. PSB LAND TRUS■ Resp●ndent(0・ RECORDED 4/■2/2023 ■0:52 AM PAGES COMPTROLLER, COLLIER COuNTY FLORIDA イ ′ …I Respondentcめ ,PSB LAND TRUS■iヱ t,高 Ⅲ,(→。Fふ e sⅢeCtpmperty Kthざ ?Ю pertyり 2 kspomentoハ avltt b∝n ttidご血cⅢイ辮 :詰鷺1響躍 mtt md"轟鴨ハ配 HarBm劇,owner,and Edg"Chara」卜に]i`bildetappel'タィ 3. Prior to the hcaring, Rcspondcnt(s) entcled into a The Property at 5373 Hollard St., Naples, FL 34113, Fo[rNa {ZZOSBOOOI 1t*gul Description: NAPLES MANOR EXT BLKT LOT29 OR I I I t PG 2283) is in violaliog"of Flprida Building Code 7e Edition (2020), Chapter l, Part 2, Section 105.1, in thc following panicularc: ,r' Vlnyl fence lBtslled oD the left slde rnd rlght r€rr ofthe dwellingyithout tirst obtslnlng s vslld Colller Count5r permlt. ' , , 5. The violation(s) has/have not bcen abated as ofthe dste ofOls learingl i" ] 9QNLU$I@ -.,'- )--,./ ' Based upon the foregoing f8cts, thc Board makcs thc following Conclusions ofLaw: l' All notices werc properly and timely issue4 and the Board has jurisOiction punua/t to*aiur,", 162, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 2, Articlc IX, Code ofLaws and Ordinances ofCollier County, Florida. The prepondcrance of thc cvidencc shows that violation(s) of Florida Building Code 76 Edition (2020), Chapter l, Pan 2, Section 105.t, do/docs €xist, and thst Respondent(s) c.mmined, and was/were responsible for maintaining or allowing rhc violation(s) to cortinue as ofthe date ofthis hearing. ORDER Based upon dle Forcgoing Findings oFFact and Con●lusions ofLw,and pursuantto the authoity gnmtcd in Chapter 162,Flodda Stamtes,and Chapter 2,A“icle IX,Code ofLaws and ordinances oFCollier County,FloHda,it ls hcrcby ORDERED that Stipulation is adopted and incorporated into rhis Order, which is attached hcreto as Exhibit“A"The s) is/are ordered to comply. THIS CAUSE came before the C,ede Enforcement Board (the "Board') for public hearing on January 26, 2023, 8nd thc Board, having heard testin{ony uhder oath, received evidence and heard argument respecrive to all appropriate matters, hereupon issues its Findings ofFact, Conclusions ofLaw, and Order ofthe Board as follows: THIS CAUSE calnc bcForc the Page I of2 /ジ 6.B.6.a Packet Pg. 99 Attachment: CEAU20220006876 PSB LAND TRUST (28281 : CEAU20220006876 PSB LAND TRUST) OR 6235 Pc 362CD Responden(s) is/are found guilty ofviolating Flori& Building Codc 76 Edition (2020), chapter I, Pan 2, Section 105.1. Respondent(s) must abate all violations by obtaining all requircd Collier County Building Permit(s) or Demolition Permit(s), Inspections, ard Cerrificate ofComplction for thc vinyl fence on or beforc M.rcb 27' 2023, or a line ofSI00.00 per day will be imposed for each day thc violation(s) remain thereaftsr. IfRespondent(s) faius to comply with this Order, CollierCounty may abate the violation(s) using any mcthod to bring the violation(s) into compliance and may usc thc assistance ofthe Collier County Sheriffs Office to enforcc the proysions of this Order and 8ll costs ofabatement shall be assessed to Respondent(s). -/,i,J Respondent isridcred to pay operarional cosG for the prosecution ofthis case in the amount of$59.21 on or before Febr(ary25, {23.') Respondent(s) 3h*!4ffy Code Enforcem€rt within 24 hours of abatement of the violation(s) and request the investigator to pe@rtri site inspection to confirm compliance. DoNE AND ORDE wo tl! $L*aey tnuA4 -"2023 at colller county, Ftorld8. // 99P_E!y4*9!Ir_E{r-B_qqD く1'、.イ .ィ ■、 STATE OF FLORIDA COUNrY OF COLLIER イ .タ、 / ● ノイ | /.:プ Board Collier County, Florida.濤需撫♂牛jυ・"of!/physical presence or E online notarization, Chair ofthe Collier County Code Enforcement $enonallf Known OR tl Produced Identification Type of Ideatifi cation Produced ofFlonda cOmmi劇 on,HH i05119 Elphes I'taY 1 5. 2025 ““ 哺 "BA●t鮨口 '~ www,colliercountvfl.eov. Any rclease oflien or confirmation ofcompliance or confirmation ofthis Ordcr may also be obtaincd at this locatior. obligations of ttr" Oraer uip."t.a. en appeat sirati not be a hearing de novo, but shall bc limited to appcllatc riviewfof-the record creatcd within the original hearing. ii is the responsibility ofthe appealing party to obtain a rranscribed rccor9.6,furc hearing from the Clcrk ofCouns. Filing an appeal will not automatically stay this Order. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 秘曙職 ∥捌皿翼躙ギ輛 IUi劇・1…TT颯2 Code Enforcement Offi cial Page 2 of 2 PAYMENT OF FINES: Any fines ordered to be paid pursuant to this paid at the collier County Code Enfolcement Department, 2800 North Horseshoe Drive,FL 34104,(?39) 252-2440, Website: ′ 6.B.6.a Packet Pg. 100 Attachment: CEAU20220006876 PSB LAND TRUST (28281 : CEAU20220006876 PSB LAND TRUST) 力十☆ OR 6235 PG 363 ■II十 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMiSS10NERS Co∥ier County,Flonda PetniOnet VS. PBS Land TnJst Resppndent(→,″み/Case No CEAU20220006876 Trusl, enters into this Stipulation and Molation in reference (case) number This agreement is subject to the approvfl'l of the Code Enforcement Board. lf il is not approved, the case may be heard on the scheduled Hearing/irate, therefore it is strongly recommended that the respondent or representalive attend ihe Hearing. , ,.., .. ln consideration of the disposition anO reJotrrtidn of the matters outlined in said Notice(s) of Violation for which a hearing is cunently schaduled for Januar! ?.6',2923i to promote efhciency in tne arjniinistration of the code enforcement process; end to obtein a quick and'expeditious resolution of the matters outlined therein the parties herelo agree as follours, " ,' ,1) The violations noted in the referenced No1icg ofl/iolation are accurate and I slipulate lo their exislence, and that Ihave been properly notified pursuar to Floridg Statute 162. THEREFORE, it is agreed between the parties tnat depdgondeni shatt; Pay operalional costs in the amount of $59.21 days of this hearing. Abate all violatlons by: ふ `Ⅲ ダLI,proSettion ofthis case哺 hln 30 / シ ,´ Obtaining all required Collier County Building Permit(s)"on Demolition Permit, inspec{ions, and Certificate of Completion for the vinyl fence within 60 days otthis hearing or a fine of $100.0O per day will be imposed until the violation is abated. Bradley Holmes, Supervisor for Michael Ossorio, Diredor Code Enforcement Division RespOndent o「Representative(plnt) 3) Respondent must notiry Code Enforcement within 24 hours ot a5alqnent of the violation and request the lnvestigator perform a site inspec{ion io con{irm compliance. (2.( houl! mdc6 lhen b. by phona or tar 6rd lrladc durino tha wortr*lcL I Uta vidilon b abat;;r24 lqiE pdor to r Saiudsy. Suraay o. t !!t holllsy. tnan tha rbtltcatdl murt !6 ma(b on th! n6rt day tnrt ts iol r 6strday, Suidry or t lEt holtday.i ,i4) That if the Respondent fails to abate the violaiion the County may abal-e th giolation using any method io bring the violation into compliance and may use the assislance of tlt'e Colliel County Sheriffs Ofiice to enforce lhe provisions of this agreement and all costs of abatement shall beSssessed to the propertyowner. ...-- . ' Respondent or Representetive (sign) REV 3‐29・ 16 6.B.6.a Packet Pg. 101 Attachment: CEAU20220006876 PSB LAND TRUST (28281 : CEAU20220006876 PSB LAND TRUST) (Ol.1.IER COUヽ Tヽ ′,FLOR:DACODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY 80ARD OF COUNTY COMMiSS10NERS Pcthioncr (EB(■ヽヽEヽ OCじ =ヽ L20220()06876 LAND TRUST DeFcndant(s) AFF:DAV:T OFNON‐COMPLIANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER BEFORE ME,thc undesigncd authority,pcrsona∥y appcarcd Jonathan Mus".Codc EnfoFcmcnt Offlcial for thc Codc Enlo“cmcnt Board orColllcr county,who aFtcr bcing fu!ly swom,dcPoscs and says: l That on Januaり 26 2023.thc Codc E●6orccmcnt Board hcld a hca五 ng and issucd an Ordcrin thc abovc‐stylcd mamcr and statcd that Dcfcndant(s)Was in ViOlation as statcd in thc Ordcr rccordcd in thc pub∥c rccords of Collicr County,Florlda in OR B∞k____PG_ 2 Thatthc respondcnt did not contactthc invぃ tigator 3 That a rc―inspcction was Pc面 onmcd on March 29,2023 4 1 hat thc rc‐inspcctiOn rcvcalcd that thc corcctivc action ordcrcd by thc Codc Enforccment Board w¨not in compliancc with thc fo∥owing conditions:Violation Rcmains FURTHER AFF:ANT SAYETH NOT DATED this 291h day oF March 2023 COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD STATE OF「LORIDA COUNTY O「COLLIER lbrcr,'rncnt Olliciul anrl subscri,-Ld hrfor(. mc b]- [rears of (Print T Publiゞ)Pcrsonalll knorvn r 6.B.6.a Packet Pg. 102 Attachment: CEAU20220006876 PSB LAND TRUST (28281 : CEAU20220006876 PSB LAND TRUST) COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS,Peltioner VS PSB LAND TRUST,DcFcndant(s) CEB CASE NO CEAU20220006876 AFFIDAVIT OF COMPL:ANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER BEFORE ME,thc undcrsigncd authority,pcrsona∥y appcarcd Jonathan Mussc,Codc Enforccmcn1 0fflcial ror thc Codc Enforccmcnt Board oFConicr county,who ancr being fu∥yswom.dcposcs and says: l That on January 26.2023,thc Codc Enforcclncnt Board hcld a hca●ng and issucd an Ordcrin thc abovc―stylcd mattcr and Ыatcd that Dcfcndant(s)Was tO abatc a∥violations as statcd in thc Ordcr rccordcd in thc public rccords ofCo■icr Counり ,Florlda in OR B∞k6235_PGュ ,ct sCq 2 That thc respondcnt did contact thc invcstigator 3 nat a rc_inspcction was pcrfo∥llcd on Dcccmbcr 20.2023(CompliCd On Dcccmbcr 15,2023) 4 That thc rc‐inspcction(s)rcVCalcd that thc corrcctivc action ordcrcd by thc Codc Enforccmcnt Board was in compliancc by obtaining a va!id Conicr county pcrmit,inspcctions,and ccrtiflcatc ofcomplction for thc Fcncc FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT DATED this 201h day of Dcccmbcr 2023 COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD …… Jonathan Mussc Code Enforcement O{Iicial STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER Swom to(or afrlmed)and subschbed bebr meby meansofXPhy●Ca:prcscnce or_o耐 hc notanzatbn 珠淵批(Print/Typ€/Stamp Commissioned Name of Notary Public) Personally known i 6.B.6.a Packet Pg. 103 Attachment: CEAU20220006876 PSB LAND TRUST (28281 : CEAU20220006876 PSB LAND TRUST) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28282) DOC ID: 28282 Updated: 3/7/2024 3:04 PM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz CASE NO: CELU20180013990 OWNER: Vladimir Portal and Caridad Paz OFFICER: Charles Marinos VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 10.02.06(B)(1)(a). Unpermitted improvements/structures: a converted garage, an aluminum porch, an entry addition, a large warehouse, a swimming pool, and ground level addition to the permitted pigeon coop. FOLIO NO: 36914160000 PROPERTY 2035 Golden Gate Blvd W, Naples, FL 34120 ADDRESS: 6.B.7 Packet Pg. 104 CODE ENFORCEMENT―COLL:ER COUNTY,FLORIDA Code Enforcement Board BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS, COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,Plaintiff, VS VLADlMIR PORTAL AND CAR:DAD PAZ,Respondent(S) Case:CELU20180013990 NOTICE OF HEARING RE:MOT10N FOR!MPOSiT10N OF FINES′LIENS PLEASE TAKE NOTiCE that Pursuantto Sec∥on 162 06 and 162 12,Florida Statutes,and Co er County Ordinance No 07‐44, as amended,you are hereby ordered to appear at a pub∥c hearing before the Code Enforcement Board on the fo∥owing date,time,and place forthe violation below: DATE: 03/28/2024 TIME: 09:00 AM PLACE: 3299 Tamiami Tra∥East Bu∥dlng F,Naples,FL 34112 V10LAT10N: Unpermlted Structures 10 02 06(B)(1)(a) LOCAT10N OF V10LAT10N: 2035 Golden Gate BLVD VV,Naples,FL 34120 SERVED: VLADIMIR PORTAL AND CARIDAD PAZ,Respondent Cha∥es Mannos, ssu ng officer RESPONDENTS ARE REQUIRED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEARING CONFERENCE HEAR:NGS TO BECIN AT 9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE thatthe a∥eged vlolato「may produce any and a∥documents,wLnesses and/or evidence to be relied upon forthe testimony given atthe hear ng Documents w∥l consist ofthe origlnal and three copies A∥eged violators have the rightto be represented by an attorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOT:CE that Requests for Conlnuances w∥l not be considered r nOt received by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board atleastfive(5)business days priorto the date setforthe hearing lT:S FURTHER ADVISED that Ordinance No 0744,as amended,be reviewed priorto your attendance atthe heattng to include emphasis on sect on Eight relating to the appeal process Mir am Lorenzo COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Ho「seshoe Drive Naples,Florida 34104 (239)252‐2998 Telephone :::;lla::A:,Iよ li:il:III]驚 Fl:1燎:∥当ri:itiょ『き'語 lt:R:]品 :『[:::lh:]器・ゝЛ]!ξ ざ,1,11:1営 fよ |:,↓『僣:(:1:[:』f(:i]!1lζ ihe ∥;:i熙弾J『::[lli篤予i継鶴恥]∬到1暫 i昴 !糠 ll税拙∬稚]器 |#]i:lii欄 !i藷 1稽 il:I∝ 6.B.7.a Packet Pg. 105 Attachment: CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz (28282 : CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz) INSTR 5845627 0R 5742 PG CLERK OF ttHE CIRCUItt COUR丁REC S27.00 24■ RECORDED 3/20/2020 ■:2■ PM PAGES 3AND COMPttROLLER, COLLIER COUNttY FLORIDA COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT CODE ENFORCEⅣIENT BOARD Case No。一CELU20180013990 BOARD OF COUNTY COplIMISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Petitioner, VS. VLADIPIIR PORTAL AND CARIDAD PAZ, RespOndents. THIS CAUSE carnc bcforc the 2020, and the Board, having heard appropriate matters, hereupon issues L Respondents, VLADIM "Property"). t Respondents, having hearing. 3. Prior to the hearing, {Board") for public hearing on February 27, and heard argument respective to all and Order of the Board as follows: ヽ OrerSOfthesttectlЮ peウ (ぬe into a posting, appeared at the public attached hereto as Exhibit``A"。ne Stipulation is adopted and incむくく(1おきヽlllll:I彗 1ゴリ:∫(寺〕 '妥んn"are ordё red to comply‐ / 14■lTP,ウ生聖二Ψtt■会暴ごhi亜軍ふ _Nα %"1“0∞O KLcgal D∝昴 "mGOLDEN GATE EST tJNIT 7 W 150計 .6「Tれれ ,そ富宙olation of Sec●On io.02.b66)そ 1'(5:高話[i County Land Development cOde,in tte following particulars: Unpermitted improvements/struetures: a converted garage, an aluminum porch, an entry addition, a large warehouse, a swimming pool and ground level addition to the permitted pigeon coop. The violations have not been abated as ofthe date ofthis hearing. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW Based upon the foregoing facts, the Board makes the following Conclusions of Law: All notices were properly and timely issued, and the Board has jurisdiction pursuant to Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 2, Article IX, Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collier County, Florida. The preponderance of the evidence shows that violations of Section 10.02.06(BXlXa), Collier County Land Development Code, do exist, and that Respondents committed, and were responsible for maintaining or allowing the violations to continue as of the date of this hearing. ORDER I ‐ Bascd upon the foregoing Findings ofFact and Concluslons OfLaw,and pursuant to the authority granted in 靴寓 ∫旅 gttЬ 溜に mdCh'裁 A面 dd、C“eぼ Laws md Odh…s」cOlltr Comサ ,H昴ぬ ■ ORDER OF THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD oath, 魯h 6.B.7.a Packet Pg. 106 Attachment: CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz (28282 : CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz) OR 5742 PG 242D Respondents are found guilty of violating Section 10.02.06(BXt)(a), Collier County Land Development Code. Respondents must abate all violations by obtaining all required Collier County building or demolition permits, inspectio[s and certificates of completior/occupancy for the unpermitted converted garage, aluminum porch, entry addition, warehouse building, swimming pool and pigeon coop addition, or the removal of such unpernitted improvements on or before August 25, 2020, or a line of S150.00 per day will be imposed for each day the violations remain thereafter. IfRespondents fail to comply with this Order, Collier County may abate the violations using any method to bring the violations into compliance and may use the assistance of the Collier County Sheriffs Office to enforce the provisions of this Order and all costs of abatement shall be assessed to Respondents. Respondents are ordered to pay operational costs for the prosecution oftlris case in the amount of S59.28 on or before March 28,2020. Respondents shall notiry Code Enforcement within 24 hours ofabatement ofthe violations and request the investigator to perform a site inspection to confirm compliance. . -l\DONE AND ORDERED this I C ds) of 2020 at Collier County, Florida. B0 COLLIER STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER0 胸棚貯」:l躙 Board Collier County, !,Personally Known OR tr Produced T)?e of Identification Produced .-{:}-6 ^ 5 }lYs Cotrml Commissioned Name of Notary public il$*: ml,",1t (Print'/rvPe/stamp) i"y niff"k&Amip#id pursuanr ro this order may be paid ar rhe Co ier counry Code Enforcement Department, 2800 Norrh Horseshoe Drive, Naples, FL 34104, phone: (239) zs2-2440, \iebsirel www.colliergov.net. Any release of lien or confirmation of compliance or confirmation of the satisfaction of the obligations ofthis Order may also be obtained at this Iocation. APPEAL: Any-a€grieved pady may appeal a final order ofthe Board to the circuit Court within thirty (30) days of theexecution ofthe Oder appealed. An appeal shall not be a hea.ing de novo, but shall be limited to appeilate leyiew ofthe.record created within the 6riginal headng. It is the responsibiliry ofthe appealing parry to obtain a transcribed record ofthe hearing from the clerk ofcouns. Filing an appeal will not automatically itay this order. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY thatatrueand corectcopy ofthis oRDER Vladimir Portal and Caridad Paろ 2035 Goldcn Cate BIvd W,Na,les,FL 341 or D online notarization, 2020, by Roben Collier County Plュblic‐Statc of Florida sent bY U.S. Mailto: C"-t*. . .' 6.B.7.a Packet Pg. 107 Attachment: CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz (28282 : CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz) '■★ OR 5742 PG 243 ☆★☆ BOARD OF COUNry COMMISSIONERS Collier County, Florida Petitioner, Vladimir Portal and Caridad paz Respondent(s), the parties hereto agree as f。∥ows: 1) The violations noted in the and that I have been properly notified THEREFORE, it is agreed between 1) Pay operational costs in the days of this hearing. 2) Abate a∥ violations by: unpermitted garage pool and improvements to unpermitted Certificate of ノ∠ Case No CESD20180013990 and I stipulate to their existence, STIPULATION/AGREEMENT Before me, the undersigned, Vladimir Portal, on behalf of Vladimir Portal and Caridad paz, enters info thisStipulation and Agreement with Collier County as to the resolution of Notices of Violation in reference (case) number CESD20180013990 dated the 12th day of December, 2018. This agreement is subject to the approval of the Code Enforcement Board. lf it is not approved, the case maybe heard on the scheduled Hearing date, therefore it is strongly recommended that the respondent orrepresentative attend the Hearing. ln. consideration of the disposition and resolution of the matters outlined in said Notice(s) of Violation for whicha hearing is currently scheduled for the 27rh day of Februa ry 2O2O',lo promote efficiency in the administration ofthe code enforcement process; and to obtain a quick and expeditious resolution of the matters ouflined therein ofthis case within 30 Perml(s)for the bu∥ding,swimming Permit to remove all and issuance of a or a fine of 9150.00 per day 3) Respondent must notify Code of abatement of the violation and request聟1lY曽 1"19[甲叫。nn lSne h,p9■On b Conirm com口ぬnce●4 hoO「s ndce shal bざ b/phone∝拮x and maoも aun石ぶe襦。F昴 `:I ItttLも品むrぜ薔詰に。24 houに pl。子oaSましday suntay σ L9d hOlday,then the nouncatiOn musi be made on he next Oay thatis not a Saturday sunday。「le981 hol day) 4)That.if the Respondent fails to abate the violation the County may abate the violation using any method l: ::'lls-j?Jl"]3]l?1.if9 -"orpri"nce and.may. use tne assiitancL oili,"'C"riiJ', i"ijrii'si"r#" om""to enbrce the pЮ ∥Jons oftht ag“ement ariJ a∥costs Of ab:i品品ttttTttLまきよ詭ばI:品吊ど馬owner Code Enforcement Division 3. a-r.ad 認leM∞「 Date REV 3‐2916 6.B.7.a Packet Pg. 108 Attachment: CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz (28282 : CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz) COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT 30ARD COLLIER COじ NTY 30ARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS,Pctl“oncr VS PORTAL,VLADIMIR&CARIDAD PAZ,DcFcndant(s) CEB CASE NO CELU20180013990 AFFIDAVIT OF NON‐COMPLlANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER BEFORE ME,the undcrsigncd authority,pcrsonally appcarcd Bradley Holmcs,Codc Enforccmcnt Ofncial forthc Codc Enforcemcnt Board of Collicr County,who aner bcing fully swom,deposes and says: l That on Fcbruary 27,2020,thc Codc Enforccnncnt Board hcld a hearing and issucd an Ordcrin thc abovc―styled matter and statcd that Defcndant(s)NVas tO Obtain all rcquircd Collicr County building or dcmolition pc∥i`its, inspcctions and ccrtiflcatcs of complction7occupancy for thc unpell=littcd convcrtcd garagc,alurninum porch, entry addition, warehousc building, swimlning pool and pigcon c00p addition or thc rcrnoval of such unpcnnittcd improvcmcnts statcd in thc Order rccorded ill the public rccords of Collicr County,Florida in OR Book 5752 PG 241 2 That the respondcnt did not contact thc investigator 3 ■at a re―inspcction was pcrfo∥1lcd on August 26. 2020 4 That the re‐inspcctiOn rcvealed that thc correcti、c action ordcrcd by the COdc Enforccmcnt Board was,ot in connpliancc with the Following cOnditions:Violatlons Rcmaincd FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT DATED this 10th day of Scptcrnber 2020 COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEヽ〔ENT BOARD Bradley Holmcs Codc EnForccment Ottcial STATE OF FLORIDA COIJNTY OF COLLIER 滞ツ゛鼈∫叩鍛・T欝脱盤露…「∠いたJp""¨c∝耐ne n。●H痴 ¨,lolmcs 蕪 3』灘離[離lΨ 誘・mp COmm雨 ¨“、me J、●り Personally bOwn V (Signature of Norary Public) 6.B.7.a Packet Pg. 109 Attachment: CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz (28282 : CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz) COI′1′:ER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMEヽT CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD Cnse No―CELU20180013990 BOARD OF COUNTY CO■1ヽ lISS10NERS COLLlER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Petitioner, VS Vladimir l'ortal and Caridad Pa2, Rcspolldents ORDER OF THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARI) THIS CAUSE camc bcforc tlrc Codc Enforcemcnt Board (the "Board") fbr public hearing on February 25, 2021, upon the Petitioner's Motion lbr Imposition of Fines,{-iens, and the Board, having heard testimony under oath, rcccived cvidence and hcard argument respective to ail appropriate matters, hereupon issues its Findings of Facr, Conclusions of Law, and Order ofthe Board as follows: FI:\DINGS OF FACT L On Fcbruary 27. 2020. thc Codc Entbrcement Board issucd a Findings ofFact, Conclusion of Law and Ordcr. rccorded at OR BK 5742 PAGE 241. Thc Rcspondents, Vladimir Portal and Caridad Paz, wcrc found guilty of violating thc Collier County Land Dcvelopmcnt Codc, Ord. No. 04-41, as amended, Scction 10.02.06(BX I)(a) on the subject propcrty locatcd at 2035 Goldcn Cate Blvd W., Naples, FL 34120, Folio No. 36914160000 (Lcgal Dcscription: GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 7 W l50FT OF TR 64), hcrcinaftcr rcfcncd to as thc "Propc-ny." in thc follouing paniculars: Unpermitled improvements/structures: a converted garagei an aluminum porch, an enirl addition, a large narehouse, a slvimming pool, and ground lerel addition to thc permitted pigeoIl coop. 2. The violation has not been fully abated as of February 25,2021. 3. Rcspondcnts, having becn notified ofthe date ofhearing by cenified mail, posting and,br personal service, had Vladimir Portal appear at the public hearing, who lestified through an intcrprctcr and contractor, Aricl Gonzalcz, as lo the Respondents' diligent effons to pursue abatcment of thc riolations and rcquested additional lil,]lc to complctc abatcment. 4. All operational costs prcviously incurred by Pctitioncr in the prosecution of this case havc bcen pairi. CO]\iCLUSIONS OF LAW Based upon thc forcgoing l'acts, lhc Board makes lhe following Conclusions of Lau,: l. All noliccs wcrc propcrly and timely issued, and the Board hasjurisdicrion pursuanr ro Chapter 162. Florida Statutcs, rnd Chapter 2, Aniclc IX. Code ofLaws and Ordinances of Collicr County, Florida. 2. Rcspondcnts have dcmonslrated by the preponderancc ofthe evidence that mitigaling circumstances cxist under Seclion 162.09(2). Florida Statutes, lo allow additional time ro come inlo lull compliancc. ORDER Pagc l oF2 6.B.7.a Packet Pg. 110 Attachment: CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz (28282 : CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz) Bascd upon thc foregoing Findings ofFacl and Conclusions ofLaw, and pursuant to the aulhority gmnled in Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 2, Arlicle IX, Codc ofLaws and Ordinanccs ofCollier Couniy, Florida, il is hereby ORDERED that: A. Petilioner's Motion for lmposition of FineVLicns is DENIED. B. Respondents' Case is continued until thc Boatd's mceting on or about May 26,2O21. C. Fincs shall conrinue to accrue against Respond€nt at thc ratc of S 150.00 pcr day until fully abatcd. ∞い Dm…D thlsだ Ⅲo曇拠咋脚独釧 "cOuntЬ 恥劇■ 30ARD ,FL0 STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER The foFgoing instⅢpcnt wa,acknowkdgcd before rne by means ofJイ phyJCal Prcscncc or□onHnc notaizalon, tlis Y aay of1plg4fuyh ,ZOZ\, Uy nobo.t rcuufman, Chiirofthc Collier County Codc Enforcement Board Collier County, Florida. XPerSOnJ″Known OR□Produc測撼enl■cmOn Signature ofNotary Public - Statc ofFloridaTypc of Idcntilication Produccd Comnrissioned Namr,' of \otary Public (PrinuTypcrStamp) PAYMENT OF FINES; Any fines ordcred to be paid pursuant to this Order may be paid at the Collicr County Codc Enforccmcnl Departmcnt, 2800 Nonh Horseshoc Drive, Naples, FL 34104, Phonc: (239) 252-2440, Websile: wwu'.collicrcouniyll,sov. Any release oflicn or confirmalion ofcompliance or contirmalion oithe satisfaction of$e obligations oflhis Ordcr may also be obtained at rhis location. l!Eg&!U, Any aggrievcd party may appeal a final order ofthe Board to the Circuit Coun rvithin thiriy (30) days of thc cxecution ofthe Order appealed. An appeal shall not be a hearing de novo, but shall be limired to appcllatc rcview ofthe record created within the original hearing. It is the responsibiliry of the appealing party ro obtain a transcribed rccord ofth!'hcaring f-r'om the Clerk olCourts. Filing an appeal \eill not automalically stay this Order. CERTIFiCATE O「SERVICE I HEREBY CER爾 FY tta n truc and coFCO COpy of面 s ORDER塁盤盤L凶 =翌 l::ゝ radi品rPorlal and Caridad Pa2 2035 Goldcn Catc Blvdヽ V Naples,FL 34120 o●上 bde Entbrcement Olflcial Page 2 ol2 6.B.7.a Packet Pg. 111 Attachment: CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz (28282 : CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz) COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD Case No.―CELU20180013990 30ARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Iletitloller, VS. Vitditllir Portat and Caridad Paz, Rcspondents. ORDER OF THE CODE ENFORCE～IENT BOARD THIS CAUSE camc bcお rc thc Codc Enforccmcnt Board(the“BOard")お r publiC heallng on Apri1 28,2022, ttpon thc PctitiOncr's Motion for IInposition of Fincs/Licns, and thc BOard, having hcard tcstimony undcr oath, rcccived evidcncc and heard argumcnt rcspcctivc to an appropriate mattcrs, hereupon issucs its Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law,and Order ofthe Board as fo1lows: FINDINCS OF FACT l. On Fcbruary 27,2020,thc Codc Enforccmcnt Board issucd a Findings Of Fact,Concluslons of La、v,and Ordcr.The Respondents,Vladignir Portal and Caridad Paz,wcre found guilty ofviolating COHier County Land Devclopnlent Codc,Ordinancc No.04‐41,as amcndcd,ScctiOn 10_02_06(B)(1)(a),On the suttcCt propcny locatcd at 2035 Golden Cate BIvd. ヽV, Naplcs, FL 34120, Follo No 36914160000 (Lcgal Dcscription:601.DEN GATE EST UNIT 7ヽ V150FT OF TR 64),hcrCinaftcr rcrcrrcd to as thc t`Propcrty,'' in tllc Follotving Particulars: UnPcrmitted innprovements/structures:a converted garage,an a:uminum porch,an ent￢r additlon,a large tvaFehOuSe,a suド im■ling pool,and ground ievel addition to the permitted pigeon coop. 2. Thc Board's written Order of Fcbruaヮ 27,20201 ordcrcd Respondcnts to abatc thc violatiOns On or bcforc August 25,2020,or a rlnc oFS150_00 per day、〃oLlld bC asscssed for each day thc vlolation rcmaincd thercaftcr un61 abatemcnt was conflrmcd.(A copy of the Ordcr is rccorded at OR 5742,PAGE 241,お r mOrc inliDrlllation).On Fcbruaヮ 25,2021,thc Codc Enforcemcnt BOard Grantcd a Continuancc. 3. Respondcnts,having bcen notirled ofthe datc of hcaring by certirled mail,posting anヽ、r personal scぃ ricc, did havc Vladiinir POrtal appcar along、〆ith Cristina Pcrez,as interprctcr,and tcstincd as tO thc additional abatement cfFblts already coinpletcd and thosc bcing diligently pursucd by Rcspondcnts. 4. Prior opcratiOnal cOsts prcviously incurrcd by PctitiOner in thc prosecution of this casc in the amOunt of S59.28 havc becll pald. 5. Thc vlolatiOn has not bcen fully abatcd as ofthc datc orthis hearing,but bascd on RcspOndents'abatcmcnt cttorts demOnstratcd thus fhr Pctitioncr has stipulatcd to a continuance ofits MOtiOn hcrcill fbr a tirne certain CONCLUS10NS OF LAW Bascd upon the brcgOing facts,the 3oard nlakcs the fo110wing Conclusions oF Law: L鑑￡譜鳳yL:轟 :ず酬i鍛 |モ搬春〔:1:鷺 :織燎:∬暮糧w罵需1:Tr職 R“da Page I of2 6.B.7.a Packet Pg. 112 Attachment: CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz (28282 : CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz) 2. Pursuant to Scction 162.09, Florida Slarutes, Petirioner has demonstrared by the preponderance of the cvidence that accrucd fincs and costs could now Iawfully be imposed against Rcspondcnts, however, that in the best interests of administrative elficiency Respondents' abatement effons to date warrant a continuance ofPetitioner's Motion for a reasonahle period of time for Respondents to complete his abatcment elforts to come into full compliance. @EB Based upon thc foregoing l'indings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, and pursuant to the authority grantcd in Chapter I 62, Florida Slatutes, and Chapl€r 2, Anicle IX, Code of Laws and Ordinanccs o I Collicr County, Florida. ii is hcrcby ORDERED that: A. Petitioner's Motion tbr Imposition of Fin€s/'[.iens is CONTINUED for a pcriod of six (6) months, which would othenvise bc no sooncr than the next regularly scheduled mceting of rhis Board on October 25, 2022. B. Daily fines ofSl50.00 per day shall continue to accrue until abatement has been conflrmed by a Collicr County Code Enforccmcnl Invcstigator. this Y day oLElug/-.2022, by Roben Kaufman, Chair of the Collier Counry Code Enforccmenr Board Collicr County, Flolid . [Personalty Knurvn oR o produccd ttenrificnrron Ll L, I 'l Typc ofldentification produced Signature ofNo-ary Public - State ofFlorida 蕪HCLEN BuCHLLON Com鮨輸 `HH 105419Exp●s Maソ 15,2025 … n饉 “ ● “ 静向γ― Commissioned Name of Notary Public (Print/Type/Sramp) EA,YMENT OfilNEg. Any fines ordered to bc paid pursuant to this Ordcr nray bc paid at the Collier Counry Code Enforcement Depanment, 2800 Nonh Horseshoc Drive, Naples, FL 34104, phonc: (239) 252-2440, Website: www.colliercountvfl.gov, Any release of lien or conlirmation ofcompliance or confirmation ofthe satisfaction of the obligations ofrhis Ordcr may also be obrained at rhis Iocarion. ^PPEALi Any aggrievcd pariy may appeal a final ordcr ofthc Board to thc Circuir Coun wirhin rhirty (30) days of thcexecution ofthe Ordcr appealed. An appeal shall not be a hearing de novo, but shall bc limited ro app"ilui" r"ui"* of the record crcated within the original hearing. It is the responsibility of the appealing party to obtain a transcribed record ofthe hcaring from rhe clerk ofcouns. Filing an appeal will nor auromatically stay this order. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE l HEREBY CER■FYぬ “ a meand coFm COpy otths ORDER竪寧当 :∥l型 1場ウrad面rPortal and Caridad Paz,2035 Goldcn Gatc BIvd ヽV,Naplcs.FL 34120,on_さ DONE AND oRDEnno ttis f^/ oa,! "r-4 pt?:/ ,2022 at Cottier County, Ftorida. STATE OF FLORIDA COUNITY OF COLLIER Tl・ e fore8oing instrtlm,nt waS acknowlcdgcd bcforc me by nicans of″physical Prcscncc Or□onhnc nota`zation, BOARD Code En forccmcnr Offi iial Page 2 ol2 6.B.7.a Packet Pg. 113 Attachment: CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz (28282 : CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz) COLLEER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEシ lENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS.Pctiloncr PORTAL,VLADIMIR&CARIDAD PAZ,DeFcndant(s) CEB CASE NO.CEI´t120180013990 AFFIDAVIT OF NON‐COヽ lPI´EANCE ‐ STATE O「FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER BEFORE ME,thc ulldcrsigned autho五 ty,personally appcarcd Rickcy Migal,Codc Enforccillell1 0fflcial負 )rthe Codc Enお rcemcnt Board of Collicr County,who ancr bcing flllly swonl,dcposcs and saysI I l.That on Fcbrtlav 27,2020,thc Codc Enfoκ cmcnt Boarct hcld a hcaHng and issucd an Orderin thc above―stylld :1lattcF alld Stated that Dcfcndant(5)WaS t0 0btain and cOmplctc pcrmits as stated in thc Order ruoo赳 cd in tilc public rccords of Conicr county,Florida in OR Book 5742 P(〕241. ‐ 2. Thatthc rcspondcnt did■ot contact the invcstigator. 3. That a rc―inspcction vvas perfolll.cd on Novcnlbcr 2,2022. 4. That thc rc‐inspcction rcvcalcd that thc corrcctivc action ordcrcd by the(3odc Enforccincnt Board、vas■ot in colnpliancc with thc following conditions: PcIIIlits not completed/鋼 nalcd. | FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT. DATED lllis 2nd day of Novcmber,2022. STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COl´l.IER rn to (or aflirmcd) and subscribed before me by means of lphysical prcsence or _ ontine notarization,2r{aay ol-lW&< r .Z?aby Rickey Migat (Signaturc. of Notary COLLIER COUNTY、FLORIDA NFORCEMENT Rickey Migal Code Enforccmcnt (PrinuType/Stamp C Public) Pcrsonally knorvn rl 恥轟 “ ■ 6.B.7.a Packet Pg. 114 Attachment: CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz (28282 : CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz) CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY.FLORIDA BOARD OF COllNTY CO■41MISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Petitioncr, VS VLADIMIR PORTAL AND CARIDAD PAZ, Rcspondellt(s) Casc No CELU20180013990 ORDER OF TIIE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD THIS CAUSE came before the Code Enforcement Board (he "Board) for public hearing on February 22, 2024, lupon Petitioner's Motion for Imposition of Fines/Liens, and the Board having heard testimony under oath, received evidence and heard argument respective to all appropriate matters, hereby issues its Findings of Fact, Conclusions ofLaw, and Order ofthe Board as follows: FINDINGS OF FACT 1. On February 27, 2020, Respondent(s), Vladimir Portal and Caridad Paz, was/were found guilty ofviolating Section 10.02.06(B)(l )(a), Ord. No. 04-41, as amended, Collier County Land Development Code, on the subject property located at 2035 Golden Gate Blvd. W., Naples, FL 34120, Folio No. 36914160000 (Legal Description: GOLDEN GATE EST LINIT 7 W 150FT OF TR 64), hereinafter referred to as the "Property", in the following paniculars: Unpermitted improvements/structures: a converted garage, an aluminum porch, an entry addition, a large warehouse, a swimming pool, and ground level addition to the p€rmitted pigeon coop. 2. The Board's written Order ofFebruary 27,2020, ordered Respondent(s) to abate the violation(s) on or before August 25, 2020, or a fine of $150.00 per day would be assessed for each day the violation(s) remained thereafter until abatement was confirmed. (Acopyof the Order is recorded atOR5742PG24l.) 3. On February 25 ,2021 arLd Api128,2022, this Board granted Respondent(s)'s request to continue the hearing date on Petitioner's Motion for Imposition ofFines as Respondent was pursuing abatement ofthe violation(s). 4. Respondent(s), having been notified ofthe date oftoday's hearing on Petitioner's Motion for Imposition of Fines/Liens by certified mail, posting and/or personal service, appeared at the public hearing via Vladimir Portal, along with a tmnslator, Yudeisy Pedrozo, and requested a third continuance of the hearing on Petitioner's Motion for Imposition of Fine*/Liens. 5. Previously assessed operation costs of $59.28 have been paid and Petitioner incurred 559.77 in operational costs for today's headng. 6. The violation(s) has,4rave not been fully abated as of the date of this hearing, but Respondent(s) has demonstrated continued, diligent efforts to abate the violation(s). CONCLUS10NS OF LAヽV Based upon thc foregoing facts,the Board makes the following ConclusiOns of La、v: l All notices wcrc properly and timely issued,and thc BOard has jurisdiction pursuant to Chaptcr 162, Florida Statutcs,and Chapter 2,Article IX,Codc of Laws alld Ordinances Of Collier County,Florida Page 1 of 2 6.B.7.a Packet Pg. 115 Attachment: CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz (28282 : CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz) 2. Pursuant to Section 162.09, Ftorida Statutes, Petitioner has demonstrated by a preponderance of the evidence that accrued fines and costs could now lawfully be imposed against Respondent(s), however, that in the best interests of the administrative efficiency Respondent(s) continued abatement efforts to date warrant a second continuance of Petitioner's Motion for Imposition of Fines/Liens for a reasonable period of time for Respondent(s) to complete abatement efforts and come into fuIl compliance. ORDER Based upon the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, and pursuant to the authority granted in Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 2, Article IX, Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collier County, Florida, it is hereby ORDERED that: A. Respondent(s) shall pay operational costs of $59.77 on or before March 23,2024. B. Petitioner's Motion for Imposition of Fines is continued for the the next regularly scheduled meeting of this Board, on or after March 23,2024, to allow the Respondent additional time to abate the violation(s). C. Daily fines of $150.00 per day shall continue to accrue until abatement of the violation(s) has/have been confirmed by a Collier County Code Enforcement Investigator. DoNE AND oRDERED this A).. a^v "frr\AUA"4,2024 atcollier county, Florida. CODE E■lFORCEMENT BOARD 90L」ER99「T》FLOⅢDA 乙 The foregoing instrunTent wqs acknowledged before me by means offif,yrlrul presence or I online notarization, this Y daq of Hkt,O.,h ,2024,by Robert Kaufman, ihair of the Collier County Code Enforcement Board Collier County, Florida. I { Personally Known OR E Produced Identification …Ro Kaufman, Chair STATE OF FLORIDA) COUNTY OF COLLIER) Type of Identification Produced 蘊趾褥 Signature of Notary lic―State ofFlorida Commissioned Name of Notary Public (Print/Type/Stamp) PAYMENT OF FINES: Any fines ordered to be paid pursuant to this Order may be paid at the Collier County Code Enforcement Department, 2800 Nor-th Horseshoe Drive, Naples, FL 34104, Phone: (239) 252-2440, Website: www.colliercountJzfl.gov. Any release of lien or confirmation of compliance or confirmation of the satisfaction of the obligations of this Order may also be obtained at this location. APPEAL: Any aggrieved party may appeal a final order of the Board to the Circuit Court within thirry (30) days of the execution of the Order appealed. An appeal shall not be a hearing de novo, but shall be limited to appellate review of the record created within the original hearing. It is the responsibility of the appealing party to obtain a transcribed record of the hearing from the Clerk of Courts. Filing an Appeal will not automatically stay the Board's Order. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE Ⅷ鶴跳:踊燎8脂 3:1.嚇ヽ夏諸笠8Wll宝星rl;翌巡遡壁空空l概 Code Enforcement Offi cial Page 2 of2 6.B.7.a Packet Pg. 116 Attachment: CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz (28282 : CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz) COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEⅣIENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS,Pctitioner VS. PORTAL,VLADIMIR&CARIDAD PAZ,Defendant(s) CEB CASE NOo CELU20180013990 AFFIDAVIT OF COMPLIANCE STATE OF FLORIDA CO呻 OF COLLIER BEFORE NIIE,the undcrsigned authority,personally appeared Charles Ma五 nos,Code Enforcement Offlcial fbr the Codc Enforcement Board of Collier County,who after being nllly Swom,deposes and says: 1. That on February 27,2020,the Code Enforcement Board held a hcanng and issued an Orderin the abovc¨stylcd matter and stated that Defendant(s)Was tO abate all violations as stated in the Order recorded in the public records of Collier County,Flo五 dain OR Book 5742 PG 241,ct.seq. 2. Thatthe respondent did contact the investigator. 3. That a re―inspection was perfolllled on 02/29/2024. 4.That the re‐inspection(s)reVealed that the corrective action ordered by the Code Enforcclnent Board was in compliance by acquiring all required conier county pellllits or demolition pell.lits on.01/06/2023. FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT. DATED this lStday ofMarch,2024. COLLIER COLINTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD %笏 Charles Marinos Code Enforcement Offi cial COUNTY OF LIER physical presence or _ online notarization, (Signature Notary Public)commissbn#HH 379743 Expires June 8,2027 (Print/Type/Stamp Commissioned Name of Notary Public) Personally known ! STATE OF FLORIDA lI:場 ;増膠 6.B.7.a Packet Pg. 117 Attachment: CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz (28282 : CELU20180013990 Portal and Paz) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28283) DOC ID: 28283 Updated: 3/7/2024 3:08 PM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CESD20220008382 Mattei and Machado CASE NO: CESD20220008382 OWNER: Anthony Mattei, Karol Lucila Teresita Mattei and Lilia Mercedes Machado OFFICER: Jason Packard VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e). Improvements to property prior to issuance of Collier County Building Permits. FOLIO NO: 51590080000 PROPERTY 164 Panther Pass Cir, Naples, FL 34114 ADDRESS: 6.B.8 Packet Pg. 118 CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLLIER COUNTY,FLOR:DA Code Enforcement Board BOARD OF COUNTY COMMiSSiONERS, case:CESD20220008382 COLL!ER COUNTY,FLORIDA,P ainlff, VS ANTHONY MATTEI KAROL LUCILA TERESITA MATTEI AND LIL A MERCEDES MACHADO,Respondent(S) NOTiCE OF HEAR:NG RE:MOT:ON FORIMPOS:T:ON OFF:NES′LIENS PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that Pursuantto Section 462 06 and 162 12,Flonda statutes,and Co∥er County Ordinance No 07-44,as amended,you are hereby ordered to appear at a pub∥c hearing before the Code Enforcement Board on the fo∥owing date,time,and place for the violation belowi DATE: o3/28/2024 T:ME: 09:oO AM PLACE: 3299 Tamiami Tra∥East Bu∥ding F,Naples,FL 34112 V:OLAT10N: Bulding Perml LDC 10 02 06(B)(1)(a)and 10 02 06(Bxlxe) LOCAT10N OF V10LAT10N: 164 Panther Pass CIR,Nap es,FL 34114 SERVED: ANTHONY MAT「EI,KAROL LUCILA TERESITA MATTEI AND LILIA MERCEDES MACHADO,RespOndent 」ason Packard, Issuing Ofrcer RESPONDENTS ARE REQU:RED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEAR!NC CONFERENCE HEARINGS TO BEGIN AT 9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOT:CE thatthe a∥eged violator may produce any and a∥documents,wlnesses and/or evidence to be re∥ed upon forthe testimony given atthe hearing Documents w∥l consist ofthe or ginal and three coples A∥eged vio:ators have the rightto be represented by an attorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that Requests for Conlnuances w∥ not be cons dered if not received by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board atleast ive(5)business days priorto the date setforthe hearing :T iS FURTHER ADVISED that Ordlnance No 07●4,as amended,be revlewed p百 orto your attendance atthe hea百 ng to include emphasis on Section Eight relating to the appeal process Ashley Eoff COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe D∥ve Naples,Florida 34104 (239)252‐2496 Telephone Anyone who requ res an aux,liary ald or service for erOctive∞mmunicat on,or other reasonable accommodat ons to participate in this proceeding, should contactthe Co∥ier County Fac∥ties Management Divis on,Iocated at 3335 Tamiami Tra∥E,Su te 101,Naples,Flo「ida 34112,or(239)252- 8380,as soon as possible,but no laterthan 48 hou「s before the scheduled event such reasonable accommodations w∥l be prOvided at no costto the individual NOTIF:CAC10N:Esla audiencia sera oDnducida en elidioma lngles Serviclos the traduccion no seran disponibles en la audiencia y usted sera responsabie de proveer su propio traductor,para un melor entendim ento con as comunicac ones de este evento Po「favortra 9a su prop o traducto「 AVETISMAN: Tout odisyOn yo fet an anglo Nou pan gin moun pou fe tradiksyon Si ou pa pa10 anglё tanptt vini avё k yOn inteprё t pou pa16 pou‐ou 6.B.8.a Packet Pg. 119 Attachment: CESD20220008382 Mattei and Machado (28283 : CESD20220008382 Mattei and Machado) 工NSTR 64■6465 oR 6258 PCCLERK OF THE CIRCu工 T CouRTREC S35.50 1NDX S■.00 ■628 RECORDED 6/■4/2023 AND COMPTROLLER, COLL工 ER 5:0■ PM PACESCOuNTY FLORIDA COLLIER COUNrY CODE ENFORCEttNT CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD Case No.CESD20220008382 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERSCOLLIER COtt FLORIDA, Pctltloner, vs. Anihony Msttel,Msttel, ard Lili■Mercedes Machado; Respondent(s). mdthe棚棚:1器奮臆」1滅器蹴臓織出ごM'獅潔富盤聡誦鷺懲 maters,hereupon tsucs i“Hndhgs oFFact,り Ctus""OfLaw,and Ordcr ofthe Board as folbws l. Respondent(s), Anthony Mattel, Ksrol f,uluy'eresig trl8ttel, snd Lllis Mercedes Mrchsdo, ivarc the owncr(s) of the subjcct property (the "Propeq"). t .' , 2. Respondcnt(s), having been notified ofthe date ofh/aring (lenified appear at the public hearing. ,/- .. mail and posting, had Anthory Manei 躙:冊期l留瑞鷺｀皿灘il肌翌き拙ど器鶴嘱・ H∝C°unv Lmd Dcvdopme“ lQッ .06(B)(1)(C),inぬ cr。∥。wing particulars: 摯 Improvements to propett prior tO iSsunice orColller County Bu■d“gPⅢitSI ,ne宙 d面。nO haS/have na bem ttatd¨。ftte da●of面 shettn3 L l,'5.The宙 olalon(→haS/have na been abatd as ofthe da●0「ぬぉheanng ´ 、…′ノ coNCLUS10NS OF LAW ‐′/――‐■'Bascd upon the Forcgoing Facts,thc Bo肛 d makes thc following Conctusions oFLaw: l. Alt notices were properly and timely issued, and thc Board has jurisdiction pursuant to ChaPtcr t62' Florida Statutes, and Chaptci 2, Anicle tX, Code ofLaws and Ordinanccs ofCollier County, Florida' 2. Thc prcpond$ance ofrhe evidence shows that violation(s) ofcollier county Land Dcvelopment code, ord. No..o44l,asamendcd,sectiooslo.o2.06(B)(lXa)andlo.o2.o6(Bxlxe)'do/does.cxist,andthat il.rpora""it j""-.incd, and waVwere responsible for maintaining oratlowing $e violation(s) to co inue as ofthe date of this hearing. ORDER Page l of3 6.B.8.a Packet Pg. 120 Attachment: CESD20220008382 Mattei and Machado (28283 : CESD20220008382 Mattei and Machado) OR 6258 Pc ■629 Based upon the forcgoing Findings ofFact and Conclusions ofLaw, and pursuant to rhe authority granted in ChaPter 162, Florida Statutes, snd Chapter 2, Anicle IX, Code ofLaws and Ordinances ofCollier County, Florida, it is hereby ORDERED that: A. Respondent(s) is/are found guilty ofviolating Collier County Land Development Code, Ord. No. 0441, as amcnded,Sections 10.02.06(8)(lXa) and 10.02.06(8)(l)(e). B. Respondent(s) gust abate all violations by obtaining all requircd Collicr County Building Permit(s) or Demolitiog/edniq inspections, aod Csnificate of Completion/Occupancy for thc front porch, rcar deck, interior reiiovatjofs, and window replacements on or beforo September 22,2023, or a llne of$200.00 p€r dry wiU bc i iropld for each day the violation(s) remain thereaftcr.') C. IfRcspondent(s) faillto copply with this Order, Coltier County may abate the violation(s) using any method to bring the violation(s)jat-o,rompliance and may use the assistance ofthe Collier County Sherilr's Officc to enforce the provisions-ofthis Order and all costs ofabatcment shall bc assesscd to Rcspondent(s). Respondcnt is ordered to payoppiational costs for the prosecution ofthis case iI! thc amount of$59,28 on or before June 24,2023. // Respondent(s) shall notify Codc fdforcpment within 24 hours ofabatement ofthe violation(s) and request the investigator to pcrform a site inspecdon to confirm compliancc. D. DONE AND ORDEREDthi 2023 at Colller County, Florlda. BOARD :al presence or E online notarization the Collier Courtty Code Enforccmen'i STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER ヨl∫131]1」:;:IStrule〕rlザ :aCknowicdgcd bcrorc me by mcans′ ′ _2023,by Robcn Kaurman, Board Collier County, Florida. み ond,Known OR□PЮ duccd meminc面。nType of ldentification Produced. ∽mm“bn″HH 370743 PAYMENT OF FINES: Any fines ordered to be paid punuant to this Order may bc paid at fie Collier County Code Enforcement Depanment, 2800 North Horscshoe Drive, Naples, FL 34104, Phone: (239) 252-2440, Website: www.colliercountvfl.sov. Any release oflien orconfirmation ofcompliance orconfirmation ofthe satisfaction ofthe obligations ofthis Order may also be obhired at this location. APEE!!.: Any aggncved party may appeal a final orderof the Board to ole Circuit Coult within thirty (30) days of the execution ofthe Order appealed. An appeal shall not bc a hearing de novo, but shall be limited to appellate review oflhe record created within the original hearing. It is the rcsponsibility ofthe appealing pafty to obtain a lranscribcd record ofthe hearing from the Clcrk ofCourts. Filing an appeal will not automatically stay this Order. t' ―State ofFlo●da 剛RIAM LORE貶0デて Pagc 2 of3 |,だ 6.B.8.a Packet Pg. 121 Attachment: CESD20220008382 Mattei and Machado (28283 : CESD20220008382 Mattei and Machado) OR 6258 PG ■630 I HEttBY CERTIFYぬ試a truc ttd∞ “ ¨py″面s ODER hasbcm"■ "u,NIallttF●2翌軋夕 d Luclla Tcrcsita Mattei,and Lilia Mcrccdcs Machad。,22009 SEASHORE CIR,ESTERO,FL 339281 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE Page 3 of3 6.B.8.a Packet Pg. 122 Attachment: CESD20220008382 Mattei and Machado (28283 : CESD20220008382 Mattei and Machado) ・・ ★ OR 6258 Pc ■63■ ■姜姜 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMiSSiONERS Col∥er County,F!onda Pettioner, √ VS Case No CESD20220008382 Anthony Mattel,Karol Lucila Teresita Mattei and Lilia Mercedes Machado RespOndent(S), 澪諸y胤譜:儡1 ヌON冗フリ〆 on beha!f of Mattei L∥ia Mercedes Machado, enters into this and AgGement with Collier the reso:ution of Notices oF Septernbert 2022. of Molation in reference (case)number CESD20220008382 dated the ln consideration of the disposition and resolutidn.of the matters outlined in said Noiica(s) of Molation forwhich a hearing is cunen y scheduled for Mav 256. 2023; to promote eficienry in the administration of the code enforcement proceas; and to obtain a quick ahd e/$editious resolution of the matters outlined therein the parties hereto agree as follows: 緊脚:電耀ued H“肥潔璃暮:階 i招 t樫朧鼎縄織脚詔椒留留鳳 ∥需::』害瀧/繋漁認ξ ′/ ′,鼻dtti服臨県器艦留乱 R鵬率 ξ精穐ξ∝ude andl引岬 dd旧 "mm∝,/THEREFORR lls agreed betweenthe pa面 es that(lⅢPdentShJt l)Pay Operatbnal costs ln the amount of坦 28i``LIも IJhiheprosecutbnof廿 ls case within 30 days ofthis heanng :′ィ′ ′‐ヽ 2)Abate al:vio!ations br ′ ´ '・ノ Obtain all required Collier County Building Permit(s)/o76en;olition Permit, inspec'tions, and certificste of Completion/Oocupancy for lhe front porcfi, rg# deck, intgrior renovations, and window replacements within glg days of this hearing or a i-ne of 8200 per day witl be imposed Respondent must notiry Code Enforcement within 24 hodrs. of abatement of the violation and request the lnvestigatoi perform a site inspection to confinn-coniplience. O4 ibw! notic6 !ha[ b. by phoi6 o(r.x dnd mad. durinC ttre !o.l(v,!€i ff|! violauon b abatsd 24 hos6 p.i;r 9. S.!r{ay. Sunday o.legal no day, lhcn t|o nooTTcato.| mult bo nEdo dr ttro r).i dty that bnota Safutday, Sundry oa lcCat holrjry.) -'t, . That if the Respondent fails to abat6 the violation the County may abat'e tha!'otation using any method04)――――― ―・ le assbLnce Ofthe Co∥brCounty Shttfrdomce tO島躙 1峨覇ξ∥嗜31躇潔黒T諸尉よsts of abatement sha∥´ “ キ凛発essed to the property/6r Representatlve (sign)Josq!/ M uch'a, Supervisor for T6omas landimarino, Direc-tor 6.B.8.a Packet Pg. 123 Attachment: CESD20220008382 Mattei and Machado (28283 : CESD20220008382 Mattei and Machado) CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY.FLORIDA BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Pctitioncr, VS NHONY MAttEI,KAROL LUCILA TERESITA NIATTEI,AND LILIA MERCEDES MACHADO, Rcspondcnt(S)/Casc No CESD20220008382 ORDER OF THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD THIS CAUSE came before the Code Enforcement Board (the "Board") for public hearing on October 26, 2023, upon a Motion for Extension ofCompliance Deadline by Respondent(s), and th€ Boald having heard testimony under oath, received evidence and heard argument respective to all appropriate maners, hereby issues its Findings of Fact, Conclusions ofLaw, and Order ofthe Board as follows: FINDINGS OF FACT l. On May 25,2023, Respondent(s) waywere found to have violated Collier County Land Development Code Ord. No. 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(8)( l)(a) and 10.02.06(8)( I )(e), on the subject property located at 164 Panther Pass Cir., Naples, FL 341 14, Folio No. 51590080000 (Legal Description: IMPERIAL WLDERNESS CONDO SEC I LOT 164), in the following particulars: Improvements to prop€rty prior to issurnce of Collicr County Building Permits. 2. On the same date as above, the Board issued an Order ordering Respondent(s) to abate the violation(s) on or before September 22,2023, or a fine of $200.00 per day would be assessed for each day the violation(s) remained thereafter (A copy ofthe Order is recorded at OR 6258 PG 1628). 3. Respondent(s) has timely requested an extension ofthe deadline to abate the violation. 4. Respondent(s), having been notified of the date ofhearing on said motion by cenified mail, posting and./or personal service, had Respondent Anthony Mattei appeax at the public hearing to speak on behalf of all Respondents in funherance of the request to extend this Board's compliance deadline and to provide testimony in support thereof. 5. The initial compliance deadline of September 22, 2023, has expired. 6. Respondent(s) has taken, and continues to take, significant actions to abate the violation. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW Based upon tbe foregoing facs, the Board makes the following Conclusions ofLaw: l. All notices were properly and timely issued, and the Board has jurisdiction pursuant to Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 2, Anicle IX, Code ofLaws and Ordinances ofCollier County, FIorida. 2. The Board has subslantial, comp€tent evidence upon which to grant an extension of the initial compliance deadline in which Respondent(s) waVwere given to come into compliance. ORDER Page l of2 6.B.8.a Packet Pg. 124 Attachment: CESD20220008382 Mattei and Machado (28283 : CESD20220008382 Mattei and Machado) Based upon the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions ofLaw, and pursuanr to the authority granted in Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Ch8pier 2. Anicle IX, Code ofLaws and Ordinanccs of Collier County, Florida. it is hereby ORDERED that: A. The request to extcnd the iritial compliance deadline of Seplember 22,2023, is hereby GRANTED. B. The new compliance dcadline to abate the violation(s) is on or before Jrnurry 24,2024, ot the tine of 3200.00 per d.y wlll bc imposed for each day the violation(s) remain thereafter. C. This Board's previous order dated May 25. 2023, shall othcrwise remain in effect cxcept as specifically amended by this Order. The foregoing instrumcnt was acknowledged before me by means of (physical prescncc or E onlinc notarization, this f, day of-\14.g4!54:-- , 2023. by Roben Kaufman. Chair of thc Collicr County Codc Enforcement Board Collier County. Florida. frPersonally Known OR D Produced ldentification Type of Idcntification Produccd HELEN BuCH:LLON Coつ耐Lslon“HH 105119 Explres Maγ 15 2025 岬珈呻町… PAYMENT OF FINES: Any fines ordered to be paid pursuant to this Order may be paid ar thc Collicr County Code Enforccment Department,2800 Nonh Horseshoe Drive. Naples, FL 3410.1. Phonc: (239) 152-lrl40. Website: www.colliercountyfl.gov. Any rclcase of lien or confirmation ofcompliance or confirmation of lhc satisfaction of thc obligations ofthis Order may also be obtained at this location. APPEAL: Any aggrieved pany may appeal a final order of the Board to the Circuir Coun u irhin thiny (30) days of the execution ofthe Order appealed. An appeal shall not be a hearing de novo, bur shall be limitcd to appellare revicw ofthe rccord created within lhe original hearing. It is the responsibility ofrhe appcating pany to obtain a transcribed rccord ofthc hearing from the Clcrk ofCouns. Filing an Appeal $'ill not automatically stay the Board's Ordcr. CERT:FICATE OF SERViCE truc and corcct copy。「this ORDER h¨becn sent by U S A4a∥1。:Anthony Mattci, and Lnia Mcrccdcs Machado.2211119 Scashorc Ci,Estero,FL 33928 on thヽメ ,2023 Commissioncd Name of Notary Public (PrinvType/Sramp) DONE AND ORDERED this ttι tt d3yOFわら ,こ .2023 at Co∥ier COunty,Florid3. STATE OF FLORIDA) COUNTY OF COLLIER) l HEREBY CERTIFY thata Karol [-ucila Tcrcsita Manci, day of Lrcr-'l CODE ENFORCEMENT 30ARD Signature of Notary Public - State of Florida Code Enforcement Official Page 2 of2 6.B.8.a Packet Pg. 125 Attachment: CESD20220008382 Mattei and Machado (28283 : CESD20220008382 Mattei and Machado) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28285) DOC ID: 28285 Updated: 3/7/2024 3:11 PM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CESD20220003245 NAPLES-DAVIS BLVD LLC CO BENDERSON DEVELOPEMNT CO LLC CASE NO: CESD20220003245 OWNER: NAPLES-DAVIS BLVD LLC CO BENDERSON DEVELOPMENT CO LLC OFFICER: Rickey Migal VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a) and 5.06.06(A)(8). Unpermitted sign alterations. FOLIO NO: 34690080008 PROPERTY 8760 Davis Blvd, Naples, FL 34112 ADDRESS: 6.B.9 Packet Pg. 126 CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLLIER COUNTY,FLOR:DA Code Enforcement Board BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS, Case:CESD20220003245 COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,Plainlff, VS NAPLES―DAViS BLVD LLC CO BENDERSON DEVLOPMENT CO LLC,Respondent(S) NOTICE OF HEARING RE:MOT:ON FORIMPOSIT10N OF FINES′L:ENS PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that Pursuantto Seclon 162 06 and 162 12,Florida Statutes,and Collier County Ordinance No 0744,as amended,you are hereby ordered to appear at a pub∥c hearing before the Code Enforcement Board on the fo∥owing date,time,and place for the violation below: DATE: o3/28/2024 T:ME: 09:00 AM PLACE: 3299 Tamiami Tra∥East Bu∥ding F,Naples,FL 34112 V:OLAT10N: Sign Perml 10 02 06(B)(lXa)and 5 06 06(Ax8) LOCAT:ON OFV:OLAT10N: 8760 Davis BLVD,Naples,FL 34112 SERVED: NAPLES―DAVIS BLVD LLC CO BENDERSON DEVLOPMENT CO LLC,RespOndent Rickey M19al, lssuing Ofrcer RESPONDENTS ARE REQUIRED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEAR:NG CONFERENCE HEAR:NGS TO BEG:N AT9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE thatthe a∥eged violato「may produce any and a∥documents,wlnesses and/o「 evidence to be rel ed upon forthe testimony given atthe heanng Documents w∥l consist ofthe original and three copies AIleged vlolators have the right to be represented by an attorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that Requests for Conlnuances w∥l not be considered if not received by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board atleast ive(5)business days p∥orto the date setforthe hea百 ng lTIS FURTHER ADV:SED that Ordinance No 0744,as amended,be reviewed p∥OrtO yOur attendance atthe hea百 ng to include emphasis on Section Eight relating to the appeal process Ashley EofF COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe Dnve Naples,Florida 341 04 (239)252‐2496 Telephone AnyOne who requires an auxllary aid or service for effective∞mmunicat on.or other reasonable accommodat ons to participate in this proceeding, should∞ntactthe Co∥ier County Fac∥ues Management Divis on.located at 3335 Tamiami Tra∥E,Su te 101,Naples,Flonda 34112.o「(239)252‐ 8380,as sα on as possible,but no laterthan 48 hours before the scheduled event Such reasonable accommodatiOns will be provided at no costto the individual NOT:FiCAC10N:Esta audiencia sera conducida en etidioma lngles Servicios the traduccion no seran disponibles on la audiencia y usted sera responsable de proveer su propio traductor,para un melo「entendim ento con as comunicac ones de este evento Porfavortralga su proplo traductor AVETISMAN: Tout odisyon yo fet an angiё Nou pan gin moun pou fe tradiksyon Si ou pa palё ang10 tanptt vini avOk yon intё prё t pOu pa16 pou‐ou 6.B.9.a Packet Pg. 127 Attachment: CESD20220003245 NAPLES-DAVIS BLVD LLC CO BENDERSON DEVELOPMENT CO LLC (28285 : CESD20220003245 NAPLES- INSTR 634■6■8 0R 6■99 PcCLERK OF THE CIRCu工 T CouRTREC S35.50 ■730 RECORDED ■2/■6/2022AND COMPTROLLER, COLLIER ■:55 PM PACESCOUNTY FLORIDA COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD Case No CESD20220003245 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Petitioner,/｀ /1ンぶ銚 1満 χ癬証 ″79BENDE厖 ON RespOndent(S)・ “ ′´ ′ ・ lT:° ndコ st[琺き:littllll:勇シ[ξ l考 ::ENDERSON DEVELOPMENT CO"LLC,ls7are" ,/t a 2. Respondent(s), having been notifi€d ofthe dale of $dng by certified mail and posting, had its authorized agent, Paul Youog, appear at the public hearin$., ,/ . /.. ; 3. Prior to the hearing, Respondent(s) entered into a Sripuiatb( which is attached hereto as Exhibit "A." The Stipulation is adopted and incorporated into this Orderrdd Raspandent(s) is/are ordered to comply.4網轟轟灘蝉懇I卿 :重鱗牌楡醐 RTION FOR R7W AS DESCIN OR 5773 PC 518)is in vbttion of Colltr Counw Land Dcvaopmem cOdら ord Nα 04 4ィおサended,sectlons,06 061Al181 and 10 02 06(B)(1)(a),in the Following particulars 、イ′1｀昴"mttedslgn Jomms ねに。f ullt tcm鳴イうち5 Thc violation(s)has/havc nOt bccn abatcd as oFthc( CONCLUSIONS OF LAW / : /ダ ~~・ Bascd upon thc Forcgoing Facts,thc BOard makes the following Conclusions oF Law: l All notices wcrc propeny and timcly issucd,and thc Board hasjurlsdiction pursuant to Chaptcr 162,Flo∥da Statutcs,and Chapter 2,Article IX,Codc oFLaws and Ordinanccs oFCollier County,Flo●da 2 The preponderance ofthe evidencc shows that viOlation(s)。fCollier cOunty Land Dcvcloprnent cOdc,OrdNo “`1,as ancnded,Sections 5 06 06(A)(8)and 10 02 06(B)(1)(a),dO/dOcs exist,and that RespOnden(s)commitcd,and was/wcrc responsible For maintaining or allowing thc viOlatlon(s)to COntinue as of the date oFthis hearing 蜃鸞聯艇騒孵熊∬[灘 '鮒職欄柵塩 Page I of3 6.B.9.a Packet Pg. 128 Attachment: CESD20220003245 NAPLES-DAVIS BLVD LLC CO BENDERSON DEVELOPMENT CO LLC (28285 : CESD20220003245 NAPLES- OR 6■99 Pc ■73■ ORDER Based upolr the foregoing Findings ofFact and Conclusions ofLaw, and pursuant to the authority gmnted in Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 2, Anicle lX, Code oflaws and Ordinances ofcollier County, Florida, it is hercby ORDERED that: A. Respondent(s) is/are found guilty ofviolatiog Collie! County Land DevelopDert Code, Ord. No. 04-41, as amended, Sections 5.06.06(A)(8) and 10.02.06(BXlXa). B. Respondent(s) must abate all violations by obtaining all required Collier County Building Permit(s) or Demolition Pe!Fit(s), pass all related Inspections, and be issued a Certificate ofCompletion/Occupancy for the unpcrryind a4d unapproved sign alterations; to include, but not be limited to: construction, installation, rebuildinjl recordtruction. relocation, alteration, or changes to the message ofthe sign on or before Mry I7, 2023, or r fi6e gPtl00.00 pcr day wiu be imposed for each day the violation(s) remain thereafte!.') C. lf Respondent(slfai#to iomply with this Order, Collier County may abate the violation(s) using any method to bring the violation(s).hticompliance and may use the assistance ofthe Collier County Sheriffs Office to enforce the provision(of this Order and all costs ofabatement shall be assessed to Respondent(s),D::出 ,:Feiず鷺ダ tlilalC°StS For the proseCutlon OfthlS CasC ln thC amount OFs5'28 on or 精肥:暦お:驚 :淵窯f輩翻 i出織鷺亀器穏:baemC“ °餞hc宙 daloЦ 9 and κqu" ―‐| ′ DONE AND ORDERED thヽど∠望∠ゝ″毒立し姥し堕」整辺望1__,2022 at Col■er Counり、Fl●■da. /ノ ´ブ ENFORCEMEIIT BOm STATE OF FLORIDA COUNrY OF COLLIER 錢鱗≫ダ哲∥11i ブ Lッ presence or E online notarization, Collier County Code Enforcement Public‐Statc oFFlorida II∫:書 :i]:;:l:こ I翼酬 21,2inowledgCdbcforcmcbymcans==____,2022,by Robcrt Kaun■1Board Collier County, Florida. {Personalty Known OR E Produced Identification Type of Identifi cation Produced PAYMENT OF FINES: Any fines ordered to be paid pursuant to this Order may be paid at tfe Collier County Code Enforcement Department, 2800 North Horseshoe Drive, Naples, FL 34104, Phone: (239) 252-2440, Websitel $nvw.colliercountvfl.qov. Any release oflien or confirmation ofcompliance or confirmation ofthe satisfaction ofthe obligations ofthis Order may also be obtained at this location. AEEEILi Any agg eved party may appeal a final order ofthe Board to the Circuit Court within thirty (30) days ofthe execution ofthe Orde! appealed. An appeal shall not be a hearing de novo, but shall be limited to appellate review of the record created within the original heariog. It is the responsibility of the appealing party to obtain a transcribed record ofthe hearing from the Clerk ofCouns. Filing an appeal v/ill not automatically stay this Order. Notary PubHc Pagc 2 of3 6.B.9.a Packet Pg. 129 Attachment: CESD20220003245 NAPLES-DAVIS BLVD LLC CO BENDERSON DEVELOPMENT CO LLC (28285 : CESD20220003245 NAPLES- OR 6■99 PG ■732 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY that atme and corrcctcopy Ofthis ORDER has bccn scnt by U S Mailto:NAPLES‐DAVIS BLVD, 駈 α 豚翠ツジ °N,霧 1:PMENT COっ LLC,570 DELAWARE AVEhTUE,3UFFALO,NY 14202 on Code Enforcement Offi cial Page 3 of3 /.ノ tt″ 6.B.9.a Packet Pg. 130 Attachment: CESD20220003245 NAPLES-DAVIS BLVD LLC CO BENDERSON DEVELOPMENT CO LLC (28285 : CESD20220003245 NAPLES- 十ナ= OR 6■99 PG ■733 ''' #3BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS Co∥ier county,Flonda Petltioner, VS NAPLES―DAVIS BLVD,LLC%BENDERSON DEVELOPMENT CO LLC Case No CESD20220003245 よ嘗 di仏。LⅧ躙 7ハ GREME:I :鶏 ξ計'選』:尉 :1寵職ぜ蹴〃滞儲鴇扇而誦'沢 8蓮思F悧 1鳴き滉譜ちよfi籠悪颯m%PRmy鑑誹1.“たにnttl翼則:柵 Ъ鑑錦躙 ∬h酬ぼC°unty as b he dated the 7th day of Apr∥,a2 ■ん This agreement is subject to the approvql of the Code Enforcement Board. lf it is not approved, the case may be heard on the scheduled Hearing qrte, therefore it is strongly recommended that the respondent or representative attend the Hearing. i- ln consideration of the disposition anj resptutiop of the matters outlined in said Notice(s) of Molation for which a hearing is cunently scheduled for Noverhber 48,2022, to promote efficiency in the administration of the code enforc€ment process; and to obtain a quick and expeditious resolution of the matters outlined therein the pafiies hereto agree as follows: ' . '1) The violations noted in the referenced l'.lstice'of Violation are accurate and I stipulate to their existence, and that I have been properly notified pursuant tdFl,orida Statute 162.! THEREFORE, it is agreed between the parties thai th?{e€pondent shall:'./ 1) Pay operational costs in the amount of $59.28 in6u^ned in the prosecution of this case within 30' days 6f this hearing. " )' ' 2) Must obtain all required Collier County Building Pgrdj(s) or Demolition permit(s), pass all related inspections, and be issued a Certificate of Conpletisn/Occupancy for the unpermitted and unapproved sign alterations; to include, but not bg'lirqited to: construction, installation, rebuilding, reconstruction, relocation, alteration, or chaiigd to )he message of the sign within 180 days of the hearing or a fine of $100.00 per day will be imSsed until the violation is abated. Respondent must notify Code Enforcement within 24 hours of alatefnent of the violation and request the lnvestigator perform a site inspection to confirm compliance. 1 ) (24 hours nooce shall bE by phone or fax and mad; during rh€ workweek ll lne vbdlon B aoatadz tuiuB pior lo a Satuday, Sunday or Legal holiday, th€n lhe nolifcation must be madeon the nen day tiat ls nota Satuday, Sunday or legd noliday.)/'- i That if the Respondent fails to abale the violation the County may abatejdre.violation using any method to bring the violation into compliance and may use the assisiance of-ihe, golliPr County Sheriffs Officeto brng the udatlon nto comptance and may use the asslstance oflne g。 [rI:::ζ ξ::RII』鴨濯l;腰 h7pr°宙J°ns′JJセ iS agreelnent and all oosts of abatement sF=ib oA」 3) 4) for Michael Ossorio, Director Code Enforcement Division Respondent or Repres Date REV 3-2916 ヽヽ´、ス・ 7_o27_ 6.B.9.a Packet Pg. 131 Attachment: CESD20220003245 NAPLES-DAVIS BLVD LLC CO BENDERSON DEVELOPMENT CO LLC (28285 : CESD20220003245 NAPLES- COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUN rY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS,Petitioncr NAPLES―DAVIS BLVD,LLC 9`BENDERSON DEVLOPMEhlr CO LLC,DcFendant(s) CEB CASE NO CESD20220003245 AFFIDAVlT OF NON(OMPLIANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER BEFORE ME,thc undersigncd authorlty.pcrsonany appCarcd Charics MaHnos,Codc Enforccmcnt Offlcial forthc Code Enforccmcnt Board ofCo∥icr County,who ancr bcing h∥yswom,dcposcs and says: l That on Novcmbcr 18,2022,thc Codc Enforccrncnt Board hcld a hcaHng and issucd an Ordcr in thc abovc― stylcd mattcr and statcd that Dctndant(s)Was tO acquire rcquircd sign pcmitting as statcd in thc Ordcr rccordcd in thc public rccords oF Collicr County,Florlda in OR B∞k6199 PG 1731 2 That thc rcspondcnt did contact thc invcstigator 3 That a rc‐inspcction was PcrfO∥::Cd On May 18th,2023 4 That thc rc‐inspcction rcvcalcd that thc correctivc action ordcrcd by thc Codc Enforccmcnt Board was not in compliancc with thc following conditionsi VaHancc and pcnnancnt pcllllit application incomplctc,tcmporary sign pcrllnit incomplctc Violation rcmains FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT DATED this 18th day of May,2023 COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD ″笏 Charles Marinos Code Enforcement Offi cial STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER 11写 lλ ′11::1lIPl,:lf]メ Sub;C・ :FdbCroremebymcansof´ 」 `phySlcal prescncc Or__onllnc notarlzallo■ 20β by Charlcs Marlnos 蕪淵批(P」nt7Typc′Stamp Commissioncd Namc Of Notaり Public) Persona∥y knownヾ 6.B.9.a Packet Pg. 132 Attachment: CESD20220003245 NAPLES-DAVIS BLVD LLC CO BENDERSON DEVELOPMENT CO LLC (28285 : CESD20220003245 NAPLES- CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY.FLORIDA BOARD OF COllNTY COMMISS10NERS COLLIER COIINTY,FLORIDA, Pctitioncr, VS NAPLES‐DAVIS BLVD LLC CO BENDERSON DEVELOPMENT CO.,LLC, RcsPondCnt/Casc No CESD20220003245 ORDER OF THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD THIS CAUSE came before the Code Enforcement Board (the "Board") for public hearing on July 31,2023, upon a Motion for Extension of Time by Responden(s), and the Board having heard testimony under oath, received evidence and heard argument respective to all appropriate matters, hereby issues its Findings ofFact, Conclusions of Law, and Order ofthe Board as follows: FINDINGS OF FACT L On November 18,2022, Responden(s) NAPLES-DAVIS BLVD LLC CO BENDERSON DEVELOPMENT CO., LLC, was found to have violated Collier County Land Development Code, Ord. No. 04-41, as amended, Sections 5.06.06(A)(8) and 10.02.06(8)( I Xa), on the subject property located at E760 Davis Blvd., Naples. Florida 34112, Folio No.34690080008 (Legal Description: GATOR GATE LINIT I AND GATOR GATE UMT 2, THAT PART OF TR I AND 2 AS DESC IN OR 2962 PG 22I, LESS THAT PORTION AS DESC IN OR 4026 PG 3583, LESS THAT PORTION FOR R,/W AS DESC IN OR 4360 PG 2653, LESS THAT PORTION FOR R/W AS DESC IN OR 5773 PG 518), in the following paniculars: Unpermitted sign alterations. 2. On the same date as above, the Board issucd an Order ordering Respondent(s) to abate the violation(s) on or before May l'l ,2023, or a {rne of S 100.00 per day would be assessed for each day the violation(s) remained thereaffer (A copy of the Order is recorded at OR BK 6199, PG 1730). 3. Respondent(s) sought an extension of time to impose fines, via an email dated May 19,2023, due to waiting on a related public hearing regarding the signage which is scheduled to occur on August 10, 2023. 4. Respondent(s), having been notified of the date ofhea ng on said motion by cenificd mail, posting aod/or pe$onal servic€, had Julie Daniel, its authorized agent, appear at the public hearing to speak in funherancc ofthe request or to provide lestimony in support ofthe extension of time needed to come into compliance. 5. Prior operational costs of$59.28 incurred by Petitioner in the prosecution ofthis case have been paid. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW Based upon the foregoing fac6, the Board makes the following Conclusions ofLaw: I . All notices were properly and timely issued, and the Board has jurisdiction pursuant to Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 2, Article lX, Code ofLaws and Ordinances of Collier Counry. Florida. 2. The Board had substantial, competent evidence upon which to extend and continue the time to imposc fines. Page I of2 6.B.9.a Packet Pg. 133 Attachment: CESD20220003245 NAPLES-DAVIS BLVD LLC CO BENDERSON DEVELOPMENT CO LLC (28285 : CESD20220003245 NAPLES- ORDER Based upon the foregoing Findings ofFact and Conclusions ofLaw, and pursuani to thc aulhority granted in Chapter 162, Florida Statuies, and Chaptcr 2, Anicle IX, Codc of Laws and Ordinances of Collicr County, Floride. it is hereby ORDERED that: A. Respondcn(s) Motion tbr Continuance of Time to imposc fines is GRANTED. B. Fines of S 100.00 pcr day shall continue to accrue daily until the violations have bcen abared but may not bc imposed until on oI after October 29. 2023. Commissioncd Narnc of Notary Public (Print/Typci Stamp) PAYMENT OF FINES: Any fincs ordered to be paid pursusnt to this Order may be paid at thc Collier County Codc Enforcemenl Department.2800 Nonh Horseshoe Drive, Naples. FL 34104, Phonc: (?39) 252-2,140, Website: www.collir.rcountvfl.sov. Any relcase of lien or confirmation of compliance or confirmation of the satisfaclion of thc obligations ofthis Order may also be obtained at this location. APPEAL: Any aggrieved party may appeal a final ordcr ofthe Board to the Circuit Coun \r'ithin thirty (30) days of the execulion ofthe Order appealed. An appeal shall not be a hearing dc novo. but shall bc limitcd to appellatc rcvicw ofthe record created within thc original hearing. It is the responsibility ofthe appealing pany to obtain a transcribed record ofthc hearing from the Clcrk ofCourts. Filing an Appeal will not automatically stay thc Board's Ordcr. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of this ORDER has bcen sent by U.S. Mail to: NAPLES-DAVIS BLVD.. LLC C/O BENDERSON CO.. LLC. 570 DELAWARE AVENUE, BUFFALO. NY t4?02 tltt, dav ot ,202■ DONE AND ORDERED ms`/ダ day Of―.2023"Cdher Counけ ,Fbnd“ CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD STATE OF FLORIDA) COUNTY OF COLLIER) Thc Foregolng hstrument was,cknoWに dged beforc mc bymcatt orttphy●Cal prescncc or□onllnc nomHzathn this ltq day af-, 2023. by Roben Kaufman, Chair ofthe Collier County Code Enforccmcnt Board Collicr County. dRersonatty Known OR E Produced ldenlification Type of Identification Produccd HELEN BuCHtLOil C-33310n'HH 105119 Exp e May15 20253-lⅢ I・‐由"… Signaturc ofNotary Public - State ofFlorida Page 2 of 2 6.B.9.a Packet Pg. 134 Attachment: CESD20220003245 NAPLES-DAVIS BLVD LLC CO BENDERSON DEVELOPMENT CO LLC (28285 : CESD20220003245 NAPLES- COLLIER COUNTγ ,FLOR:DA CODE ENFORCEMENT 30ARD COLLiER COUNTY 80ARD O「COUNTY COMMiSS10NERS Petitioncr VS NAPLES‐DAVIS BLVD LLC 9も BENDERSON DEVLOPMEヽ T CO LLC,Detendant(s) CEB CASEヽ O CESD2022α )()3215 AFF:DAVIT OF NON(OMPL:ANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER BEFORE ME,thc undersigned authori,,pCrsona∥y appearcd Rickc)Miga:.Code En6orccmcnt Offlcial ftDr the Codc Enbrccmcnt Board ofCo∥icr Coun、.whO ancr bcing fuli)swom.dcpOscs and sa)s: l That on October 27.2022.thc Code Enforcclncnt Board hc!d a hcaring and issued an Ordcrin thc ak,vc‐stylcd mater and“atcd that Derendan〈s,Was to日いStatcd h the Ordcr rccordcd h thc puЫ たrecords o「(｀o!∥cr Countv.Flo∥dain OR Book 6199 PG!730 2 Thatthe respondent did not contact thc invcstigator 3 That a re―inspcction was perForlned on October 27.2023 4 That thc re‐inspection rcvealed that thc co―tive action ordered b、′the Code Enforcement Board、as not in compliance with the following conditions:propcr pcrlnits or demo pcrllits、ere not obtained and CO was not obtained FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT DATED this 3仇 h dav ofOctober 2023 COLLIER COUNTY.FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD υη Rickel'Migal Code Enforcement Official STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF C01´LIER 滞ワ率∫器ワ棚拶ЩttT駆躍器「ハ壺d pttm∝∝online norarizatlon. o「NotaⅣ ″HH 379743 &pic,lunc e ZOlr ( P 'T)'pe Shmp Commissioned Nami of Norary, Public) Penonally kno*n r 6.B.9.a Packet Pg. 135 Attachment: CESD20220003245 NAPLES-DAVIS BLVD LLC CO BENDERSON DEVELOPMENT CO LLC (28285 : CESD20220003245 NAPLES- COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT 80ARD COLL:ER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMiSS10NERS、Pctttioner VS NAPLES‐DAViS BLVD.LLC 9`BENDERSOヽ DEVLOPMENT CO LLC.Dercndant(s) CEB C=ヽ SEヽ O CESD2022000324S AFF:DAV:T OF COMPL:ANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER BEFORE ME,thc undcrsigncd authority,pcrsona∥y appcarcd Rickcy Migal,Codc Enfo"cmcnt Omcia1 1)rthc Codc Enforccmcnt 3oard ofCo∥icr County,who aftcr bcing fu∥y swom.dcposcs and says: l That on Octobcr 27, 2022, thc Codc Enforccmcnt Board hcld a hcaring and issucd an Ordcr in thc abovc‐ sty:cd mattcr and statcd that Dcfcndant(s)Was tO abatc all、'iOlations as statcd in thc Ordcr rccordcd in thc PubliC rccords ofCo∥icr County.Florlda in()R Book 6199 PG二じロェL Ct SCq 2 That thc rcspondcnt did contact thc invcstigator 3 That a rc‐insPcctiOn was pcrfOnncd on Fcbruar/8 2024 4 That thc rc‐inspcction(s)rcVCalcd that thc corcctivc action ordcrcd bv thc Codc Enforccmcnt Board was in compliancc by pc===lit PRSG20230940175 bc・ ing inalcd on Fcbruaw 6,2024 FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT DATED this i4th day of Fcbruary,2024 COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD υη Rickcy Migal Codc Enforcemcnt Oflicial STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER lポ T畷電器あげ孵 d beぉ "mcby m““o「∠pぃ d pretencc or o∥hc ndahzatlo■ .2∝νby Rickey Migal 蕪麟撒(Print/TypeJStamp Commissioncd Name of Notary Public) Personallv knorvn { (Signature of Notarv Public) 6.B.9.a Packet Pg. 136 Attachment: CESD20220003245 NAPLES-DAVIS BLVD LLC CO BENDERSON DEVELOPMENT CO LLC (28285 : CESD20220003245 NAPLES- Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28286) DOC ID: 28286 Updated: 3/7/2024 3:15 PM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CESD20140006223 Perez CASE NO: CESD20140006223 OWNER: Henry Perez OFFICER: Craig Cooper VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 10.02.06(B)(1)(a). A vacant unfinished home with an expired permit. FOLIO NO: 39895880008 PROPERTY 2665 Oil Well Rd, Naples, FL 34120 ADDRESS: 6.B.10 Packet Pg. 137 CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLL:ER COUNTY,FLOR:DA Code Enforcement Board BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS, COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,Pla ntiff, VS HENRY PEREZ RespOndent(S) Case:CESD20140006223 NOTICE OF HEARING RE:MOT10N FOR:MPOSIT:ON OF FINES′LIENS PLEASE TAKE NOTiCE that Pursuantto Section 162 06 and 162 12,Flo百 da Statutes,and Co∥ier County ord nance No 07‐44, as amended,you are hereby ordered to appear at a pub∥c hearing before the Code Enforcement Board on the fo∥owing date,time,and place forthe violation belowi DATE: o3′28/2024 TIME: o9:oO AM PLACE: 3299 Tamiami Tra∥East Bullding F,Naples,FL 34112 V10LAT:ON: Bu∥ding Perml LDC 10 02 06(B)(1)(a) LOCAT10N OF V:OLAT10N: 26650∥We∥RD,Naples,FL 34120 SERVED: HENRY PEREZ, Respondent Cra g Cooper, lssu ng officer RESPONDENTS ARE REQUIRED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEAR:NG CONFERENCE HEARINGS TO BECIN AT 9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE thatthe a∥eged violator may produce any and a∥documents,wtnesses and/or evidence to be re∥ed upon forthe testimony given atthe hearing Documents w∥i consist ofthe original and three coples A∥eged violators have the rightto be represented by an attorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTiCE that Requests fo「Conunuances w∥l not be considered if not rece ved by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board atleast five(5)buslness days priorto the date set forthe hearing lT:S FURTHER ADV:SED that Ord nance No 0744,as amended,be reviewed p百 o「to your attendance atthe heanng to include emphasis on Sect on Eight relating to the appeal process Mi百 am Lorenzo COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe Dttve Naples,Florida 341 04 (239)252-2998 Telephone AnyOne l・ vい o「equ res an aux]iary a,d or service for erect ve communicat on,o「other reasonable accommodations to participate in this p「。ceeding should contaclthe Col ei County Facllies Management Division located at 3335 Tamiami Tra∥E Sute 101 Naples Florda 34112 o「(239)252‐ 8380 as soon as possible.bui nO laterthan 48い ours beFore the scheduled event Such「easonable accommodat ons、■l be provided at no costto the individual NOTIFlCAC10N:Esta audiencia sera conducida en elidioma lngles SeⅣicios the traduccion no seran disponibles en la audiencia y usted sera responsable de proveer su propio traduclo「 para un melor entendimiento con las comunicaciones de este evento Por faVortra19a su propi。lraduCtOr AVETISMAN: Tout odisyon yo fet an ang10 Nou pan gin moun pOu Fe tradiksyon Si ou pa palё ang10 tanpri vini avOk yon intOpret pOu pa10 pOu―ou 6.B.10.a Packet Pg. 138 Attachment: CESD20140006223 Perez (28286 : CESD20140006223 Perez) INSTR 5■99309 0R 52■7 Pc 2222 RECORDED ■■/24/20■5 4:37 PM PAGESOWIGHT E BROCK, CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COuRT, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIOAREC S27.0045 COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENTCODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD Casc No―CESD2014011C16223 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS COLLiER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Pctitioner, VS HENRY PEREZ, Rcspondent THIS CAUSE camc on for Board on November 20,2015,and the Code Enforcement Board,and heard argument respective Enforcement Board, as follows:to all appropriate matters, l. Respondent Henry Respondent was notified and the Code Enforcement Board has jurisdiction ofthis 3. Respoodent did not appear at the which is aftached hereto as Exhibit "A". The Stipulation is adopted as an to comply. Board and the Respondent is ordered The real property located at 2665 Oil Well Rd, Naples, FL, Folio #39895880008 (Legal Description: GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 64 TR 63 LESS S 50FT FOR R/w AS DESC INOR 4322 PG 664) is in violation ofCollier County Land Development Code 0441, AS AMENDED, Secrion 10.02.06(8)( IXA) in the following particulars: A vrcant unlinished home with an exPired permit. The violation has not been abated as ofthe date ofthe public hearing. ORDER Based upon the foregoing Findings ofFao and Conclusions ofLaw, and pursuant to the authority ganted in Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Collier County Ordinance No 200744, as amended, it is hereby ORDERED: A. Respondent is found guilty ofviolating Collier County Land Development Code 04-ll, AS AMENDED, Sections 10.02.06(8X I XA). B. Respondent must abare the violation by obtaining allrequired Collier County Building Permits, or Demolition permit, inspections and Cenificate ofCompletior/Occupancy on or before Febtuary 18,2016 or a fine of $200.00 per day will be imposed for each day the violation remains thereafter. 6.B.10.a Packet Pg. 139 Attachment: CESD20140006223 Perez (28286 : CESD20140006223 Perez) OR 52■7 ,G 2223E IfRespondent fails to comply with this Order, the Collier County Code Enforcement Department may abate the violation using any method to bring the violation into compliance. Ifnecessary, the County may request the services ofthe Collier County Sherifls Office for the purpose ofaccessing the propety for abatement. All costs ofabatement shall be assessed against the property. Respondent is ordered to pay operational costs for the prosccution of this case in lhe amount of$65.43 orl or before Decembcr 20,2015. Respondent shall noti$ the Code Enforcement Investigator of this case within 24 hours ofabatement or compliance so that a final inspection may bg performed to conhrm compliance. DONE AND oRDE ttto tnis ?UDo^yo1 SjOV , z0l5 at Collier County, Florida. STATE OF FLORIDA ) 華軋 PAYMENT OF FINES:Any incs be paid at the Collier County Code Enforcement Depanment, 2800 North 04, Phoner (239) 252-2440, website: www.colliergov.net. Any release of Iien or conlirmation of the satisfaction of the obligations ofthis Order may also be obtained κ]:Klnt,レ ´´ APPEAL: Any aggrieved party may appeala final order ofthe Board to th€ Circuit Court within thiny (30) days of the €xecution ofthe Order appealed. Ar appcal shall not be a hearing de novo, but shall be limited to appellate rcview of the rccord created within the original hearing. It is the responsibility of the appealing party to obtain a transcribed record ofthe hearing from the Clerk ofCourts. Filing an Appeal will not automatically stay the Boad's Order. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy ofthis ORDER has been s€nt by U. S. Mail to HeDry Perez, 2042 Mandarin Ln, Naples. FL 34120 thisz!: day ;f November, 2015. CLERK OF be paid pursuant to 6.B.10.a Packet Pg. 140 Attachment: CESD20140006223 Perez (28286 : CESD20140006223 Perez) ☆☆' OR 52■7 PC 2224 '★☆ 80ARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS Co∥ler County,Flonda Petitioner, VS Henry Perez Respondent(s), COMES NOW, the undersigned, ,fl^, Notices of Violation in reference (case) number CESD20140006223 dated the 28rh day of March, 2014. certricate of Com hours of abatement of the violation and to confirm compliance. 割61∂ Case No CESD20140006223 STIPULAT:ON′AGREEMENT a,。n behar of∥mse f or‐~aS represenl誠市e ln consideration of the disposition and resolution of the matters outlined in said Notice(s) of Violation for which a hearing is cunently scheduled Io( L/- 2.o -L" t {/to promote efficiency in the administration of the code enforcement process; and to obtain a parties hereto agree as follows: of the matters outlined therein the 1) The violations noted in the and I stipulate to their exislence. THEREFORE, it is agreed between Pay operational costs in 30 days of this hearing. Abate all violations by: of thas case within Obtaining a∥required Co∥ler Permit, inspections, and _gr a fine of $ ,?d4 ot' per day will be imposed until the violation is Respondent must notify Code En'fo(ce request the lnvestigator perform a site ル4'7ρ /1- zo '2o'\' (24 ho!6.olicc shatrb. by pho.e or lar snd made dirring the wkEek. rrn.eolal'on is.b.ted 2a hou.r prior toa Saluday, Sunday o/ r.galholiday,lhenlho noincaii$ nu3r bemsdeon lhe nen dsy lhal E nol a saturd3y, sunday or l6galholday.) 4) That if the Respondent fails to abate the violation the County may abate the violation using any method to bring the violation into compliance and may use the assistance of the County Sheriff's Office to enforce the pravisions of this agreement and all costs of abatement to the property owner (sign) じ｀｀、__ノイKO Date for Respondent and enters into 6.B.10.a Packet Pg. 141 Attachment: CESD20140006223 Perez (28286 : CESD20140006223 Perez) COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD :8麗 Ъ躍潟 YCOMMSЮ NER申 ●∞σ VS PEREZ,HE■lRY,DcFcndant(s) AFFlDAVIT OF NON―COMPLIANCE cEB CASE NO.CESD20140006223 STATE OF FLORIDA COLTNTY OF COLLIER BEFOREME,theundersignedauthority,personallyappearedEricShort'CodeEnforcementOfficialfortheCodepiior*.nt soura of collier county, *ho after being fully sworn. deposes and says: l.ThatonNovemberZO,z|ls,theCodeEnforcementBoardheldahearingandissuedanOrderinthe above-styled matter and r*"i,i"i O"f."Ornt(s) was to abate the violation(s)L stated in the Order recorded in it " pruti" ,""oras of Collier County' Florida in OR Book 521'l PG 2222' 2. Thal the respondent did contact the investigator' 3. That a re-inspection was Performed on February l9' 2016' 4.Thatthere-inspectionrevealedthatthecorrectiveactionordeledbytheCodeEnforcementBoaldwasnotin compliance with the conditions' FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT. DATED this 19th day of February,20l6 coLLtER coL,NTy, FLoRIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD W. Eric Short Code Enforcement Official STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER Personally known 'J , zfu by eric Short MY α編高麟、37● 議鼎鷺謂∥鶉 Sworn O(Or amancd)and subSCHbcd bCbrc mc●iS 14｀tayOf f`o 6.B.10.a Packet Pg. 142 Attachment: CESD20140006223 Perez (28286 : CESD20140006223 Perez) INSTR 5246820 0R 5257DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERKREC S■8 50 RECORDED 4/■/20■6 9:■5 AM PAGES 2CIRCUIT COURT, COLLIER COuNTY FLORIDAPC 9030F THE COLLlCR COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD Case No―CESD20140006223 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Petitioner, VS HENRY PEREZ, Respondent THIS CAUSE camc on for 3oard on March 24,2016,and thc Code Enforcement Board, having and being duly advised in the prcmises, hereupon issues its follows: Code Enforcement Board, as Respondent is charged Codc 04‐41,AS AMENDED, Scction 10 02 06(Bxl)(A) Based upon the foregoing, and pursuant to the authority granted in Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Collier County Ordinance No. 0744, as amended, it is hereby ORDERED: A. The Respondent's Motion for Continuance ofthis case is GRANTED until September 20, 2016. B. All parties shall be re-noticed for the subsequent hearing date. C. Fines shall accrue during the Continuance period DONE AND oRDERBp 11,1, ZOtsouy of fKArc+l , 2016 at Collier County, Florida. Slale ol Flcada 6.B.10.a Packet Pg. 143 Attachment: CESD20140006223 Perez (28286 : CESD20140006223 Perez) ■ナ, OR 5257 PG 904 '■■ STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER) review of the record created within the transcribed record ofthe hearing from Order. I HEREBY CERTIFY Perez, 2042 Mandarin Ln, The Foregohg instrumcnt was acknowledged beforc mc this■望may Of ,2012鷺 ilttψ 撃 lfttrff血 CCttf11li∥lil:霊 :fC酬たr counり ,日 Ondへ whoお .:月 .n":、′_.・ 'cI:´_..ぃ 0.´:"0..,:■^_))SS: u/ personally known to me or _ who has produced yFlorida Driver's License as identification. KEPRY ADAMS,MYttwtta My commission expires:3ondedlhru8uttNmry&燿 iい PAYMENT OF FINES:Any flnes ordered to bc paid pursuantto this Order may be paid atthe Collier County Code Enforccmcnt Department,2800 North Horseshoe Drive,Naples,FL 34104,Phone:(239)252‐2440,Website: WWW.COllier2ov.net.Any release oflien or con■mlation ofcompliance or conimlation ofthe satisfaction ofthc obligations ofthis(Drder rnay also be obtained at this iocation APPEAL: Any aggrieved party may appeal a to the Circuit Court within thirty(30)dayS Of the execution ofthe Order appealed. An but sha∥be limited to appellate ofthe appealing patt to Obtain a not automaticatly stay the Board's sent by U. S. Mail to Henry of Courts. Filing an 響 6.B.10.a Packet Pg. 144 Attachment: CESD20140006223 Perez (28286 : CESD20140006223 Perez) 工NSTR 53■7■58 0R 53■8 PG 736 RECORDED 9/28/20■6 2:■9 PM PACCS 2 DW工 GHT E BROCK, CLERK oF THE CIRCu工 T CouRT, COLL工 ER COUNTY FLORIDAREC S■8 50 COLLIER COUNTy cODE ENFORCEMENT CODE ENFORCE141ENT BOARD Case No―CESD20140006223 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Petitioner, VS. HENRY PEREz RespOndent. THIS CAUSE camc on for the Code Enforcement Board, the premises, hereupon issues its as follows: Respondent is charged Scctlon 10 02 06(B)(1)(A) Board on September 22,2016, and and being duly advised in ofthe Code Enforcement Board, Codc 04-41,AS AMEllDED, 低 Based upon the foregoing, and pursuant to the authority $anted in Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Collier County Ordinance No. 07-44, as amended, it is hereby ORDERED: A. The Code Enforcement Board has granted an Extensio[ ofTime to comply. B. The time for which Respondent is to comply has bccn exlcnded to Jun€ 22, 2017. C. No daily fines shall accrue during rhe extensioo period, DONE AND oRDEnro this A6 asr "r S?* , zolr at colller County, Floridr. 6.B.10.a Packet Pg. 145 Attachment: CESD20140006223 Perez (28286 : CESD20140006223 Perez) ★姜姜 OR 53■8 PG 737 ''' STATE OF FLORIDA ) )SS: COUTЛ Y OF COLLIERl Thc Forcgolng instrumcnt was acknowLdgcd before mc thls:コ生day oF20ッ l織獅棚f器臓httlifl盤 ll超跳:鴇喘:」胤3 as identification. PAYMENT OF FINES:Any incs ordcred to be paid pursuantto this Order may be paid atthe Conicr counり Codc Enforccmcnt Dcparmcnt,2800 North Horscshoc Drivc,Naplcs,FL 34104,PhOnc:(239)252‐2440,ヽ Vcbsitc: ヽい″W COniergov net Any relcase oflicn or conflnmation oF compliancc or conflmation oFthe satisFaction oFthc obligations o「this Ordcr may also bc obtaincd atthis locatiOn APPEAL: Any aggrieved party may appeal a to thc Circuit Com within thirty(30)dayS of the execution ofthe Order appealed. An novo, bul shall bc limitcd to appellate rcvicw oflhe record created within the tra$cribed record ofthe hearing from oflhe appealing party to obtain a not automatically stay thc Board's Order. I HEREBY CERTlFY sent by U. S. Mail to Henry Perez, 2042 Mandarin Ln, Naples,2016 ♂ミ ofCourts. Filing an ー 6.B.10.a Packet Pg. 146 Attachment: CESD20140006223 Perez (28286 : CESD20140006223 Perez) COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT 30ARD COLL:ER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS,Pcthioncr VS PEREZ,HENRY,DcFendant(s, CEB CASE NO.CESD20140006223 ▲FFIDAVIT OF NON―COMPLIANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER BEFORE ME,thc undcrsigned allthority,personally appeared Tony Asaro,Code Enforccmcnt Ofrlcial Forthc COde Enforcement 3oard of CO∥ier Counり ,whO aner bcillg fully swOrn,dcPOscs and says: l That on Novembcr 21. 2014, the Codc E:iforccmcnt Board hcld a hearing and issucd an Ordcr in the above‐s,led matcr and statcd that Defendan(s)Was tO口 as statcd in the Ordcr recOrdcd in the pubHc recOrtls Of Co∥ier cOunり ,Florida in OR Book 5217PG2222 2 That thc rcspOndent did contact the invcstigator 3 That a rc■ns卜 c10n lVas performed on〔Janua●12,2018] 4 That thc re‐inspectiOn revealcd that thc correcive actOn ordered by the COdc Enforccment Board was not in compliance with the f01lowhg cOnditions:[By obtaining all required Collier Coun″Building Pellllit(s),。rDemollion Perml,inspcctiOns alld ccrtincatc of COmpetiOn/Occupancy] before me this 181", "r ,Ln*rg , 2ofrby rony Asaro Danry B“田CO commslon`m84545 認臓溜樵織 FURTHER AFFIANT/FAYETH NOT. DArED this [[t' ] day of fTqO 1.201$ STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER (PrinrType/Stamp Commissioned Name;f Nrt",y p"bli.) COl´しlER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD ｀、イは _― -Ionv Asaro Code Enforcement Offi cial Pcrsonally knorvn I 6.B.10.a Packet Pg. 147 Attachment: CESD20140006223 Perez (28286 : CESD20140006223 Perez) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28289) DOC ID: 28289 Updated: 3/7/2024 3:34 PM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CEROW20230002007 Zavala CASE NO: CEROW20230002007 OWNER: Santiago Zavala Jr and Santiago Zavala OFFICER: Rickey Migal VIOLATIONS: Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances, Chapter 110, Article II, Section 110-31(a). Asphalt driveway installed over County right of way without a permit. FOLIO NO: 36439520002 PROPERTY 3077 52nd St SW, Naples, FL 34116 ADDRESS: 6.B.11 Packet Pg. 148 CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLL:ER COUNTY,FLORIDA Code Enforcement Board BOARD OF COUNTY COMM!SSiONERS, Case:CEROW20230002007 COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,Plain∥ff, VS SANTIAGO ZAVALA」R AND SANTIAGO ZAVALA,Respondent(S) NOTiCE OF HEARING RE:MOT:ON FOR:MPOSIT10N OF F:NESノ LiENS PLEASE TAKE NOTiCE that Pursuantto Sec∥on 162 06 and 162 12,Flonda statutes,and Co∥er County Ordinance No 0744,as amended,you are hereby o「dered to appear at a pub∥c hearing before the Code Enforcement Board on the fo∥owing date,time,and place forthe violation below: DATE: o3/28/2024 TIME: 09:00 AM PLACE: 3299 Tamiami Tra∥East Bu∥ding F,Naples,FL 34112 V:OLAT:ON: ROW l10-31(a) LOCAT10N OF V10LAT:ON: 3077 52nd ST SW,Naples,FL 34116 SERVED: SANTIAGO ZAVALA JR AND SANTIAGO ZAVALA,RespOndent Rickey Migal,issu ng Omcer RESPONDENTS ARE REQUIRED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEAR:NG CONFERENCE HEARINGS TO BECIN AT 9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTiCEthatthe a∥eged violato「may produce any and a∥documents,wlnesses and/or evidence to be reied upon forthe testimony glven atthe hearing Documents wi∥conslst ofthe original and three copies A∥eged violators have the rightto be represented by an attorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOT:CE that Requests for Conlnuances w∥ not be consldered if not received by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board atleast nve(5)business days plorto the date setforthe heanng :T IS FURTHER ADViSED that Ordinance No 07‐44,as amended,be reviewed priorto your attendance atthe hea百 ng tO include emphasis on Section Eight relating to the appeal process Ashley Eoff COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe D∥ve Naples,Florida 341 04 (239)252-2496 Telephone AnyOne who requ res an auxliary ald o「service for efFective communication,or other reasonable accommodat ons to participate in this proceeding, should∞ntaclthe Co∥er County Fac∥nies Management D v s on,located at 3335 Tamiami Tra∥E,Su te 101.Nap es,Flo間 da 34112,o「(239)252- 8380,as socln as pOssible,but no laterthan 48 hours before the scheduled event Such「easonable accommodat ons wll be provided at no costto the individuaL NOT:FiCACiON:Esta audiencia sera conducida en elldioma ingles Servicios the traduccion no seran disponibles en la audiencia y usted sera responsable de proveer su proplo traducto「,para un melor entend m ento con tas∞municac ones de este evento Porfavortraiga su propio traductor AVET:SMAN: Tout odisyOn y。たtan anglё Nou pan gin moun pouた tadiksyon Si ou pa pale angiё tanpH vini avё k yOn intё pret pOu pa16 pou―ou 6.B.11.a Packet Pg. 149 Attachment: CEROW20230002007 Zavala (28289 : CEROW20230002007 Zavala) 工NSTR 6484029 oR 63■■ PC CLERK OF THE CIRCU工 T COuRT REC S■8.50 ■463 RECORDED ■2/6/2023 AND COMPTROLLER, COLLIER 罰R AND SANTIAG0 ■:0■ PM PAG ESCOUNTY FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY.FLORIDA BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Pctitioncr・ VS SANTIACO ZAVALA, Casc No CEROW20230002007 ´|器λ淵紺聯鳳鰯鮮藤鷲薦穏拒警鷲騨鴛撚紺i監 Respondent(s). are the owners of the subject propcfty (the "Property"). 3 The Propett located at 3077 52nd st sW,Naples几 Folio No. 36439520002 (Legal Description: GOLDBN GATEIIMT7 BLK 240 LOT30)is in Collier County Code ofLaws and Ordioances, Chapter I l0 Roads and Bridges, Article II 墨igh,9FWay,D市ヽion l Cenerally,Sectton HO‐ 3!(a,) as amcnded, in thc following particulars: Asphslt drlvewry lnstalled ovcr County rlghl ofwsy The violations havc not been abated as ofthe date ofthis hearing. Based upon the forcgoing facts, the Board makes the following Conclusions of ayr: ( -7 . I . All notices wsre properly and timely issued, and thc Board has jurisdictior pursuant tdbta-ptcr I 62, Ftorida Statutes, and Chapter 2, Anicle IX,-Code ofLaws and Ordinanccs ofCollicr Couob(fliifiaa' 2. The prepondcmncc ofthe evidence shows that violation of Collier County Code of Laws-and Ordinance, Chajteit lO noads and Bridgcs, Aniclc II Constnrction in Right of way, Divisior I Geirerally, Section I l0' 3l(a,) as amended, does cxist, and that Rcspondcnts commincd, and were responsiblc for maintaining or allowing thc violatiors to contirue as ofthe date ofthis hcadng. ORDER Based upon the foregoing Findings ofFact and Conclusions ofLsw, and pursuant to 1!\: surhority glaoled in Ct "pt.r iO1, ftoiia" Statutesl ani6haptei 2, Article IX, Code of Laws and Ordinances ofCollier county, Florida, it is h€reby ORDERED that: I 2. Respoodcnts, having beeo rotified oftnc aJtc or.tdcticaring by cerrificd mail and posdng, did not appear at the iublic hearing. - /' "..,a a Page I of2 Respondents, Santiago Zavala Jr. ard 6.B.11.a Packet Pg. 150 Attachment: CEROW20230002007 Zavala (28289 : CEROW20230002007 Zavala) カオ■ OR 63■■ Pc ■464 !士=Respondents are found guilty ofviolating CollicI County Code of Laws and Ordinance, Chapter I t0 Roads and Bridgcs, Anicle ll Construction in Right of Way, Division I Generally, Section I l0-31(4,) as amerded. Respondents must abate all violations by obtairing all rcquired Collier County Right-of-Way pemits &nd pass oll required inspections for the unpcrmittcd work with the Right-of-Way or to restore the Right-of-Wsy to is originally permitted condirioo on or before Februrry 15, 2024, or r fire of S75.00 per day will bc imposed for each day the violations remain thcreafter. If Respondents fail to comply with this Order, Collier County may abste the violations using any method to bring the violatlrns into compliance and may use the assistance of the Collier County Sherilfs Office to cnforce (r;+rg{iryns of this Order and all costs ofabatement shall be assessed to Respondents. ,,. Respondentsdeprdcrqd to pay operational costs for thc prosecutio[ of this case in the amount of$59.28 on or before Decerhber fi,2023.j Respondents shall noti$t9de Enforccment within 24 hours ofabatement ofthe violations and request ihe investigator to perfon6 a site inspection to confirm compliance. STATE OF FLORIDA h])".is* a,,a.on euasdNot vs€rilc!' CERTIFICATE OF SERVICEBCDECOUbrrYOFCOШtt fノイ鷲四輩:電畔寧翌蹴憮鰍轟胤辮酬濯 ∥棚鰍 Board Collお r County,Fl●Jと ´´/じ |´ (Personally Known OR tr Produced tdentification Ъ :I:面 =ttttふ卜rttte: … 1ゝ … OFNotaッ ibHc―Sは e oFΠ odda APPEAL:Any aggneved party may appcal a inal order orthe BOard to the,1:辞 :1171!｀l者 |:『tょ ::I`iよ :留 ::%thc execution ofthe Order appealed An appeal sha■notbeahea1lFden9Y。 ^ . ¨ . oith" ,".ora "r"ut.a within'r'iie original d&ring. Ii is the responsibility ofthe appealing party,-tcobtain a transcribed record ofthe hearing from the ctcrk ofcourts. Filing an appeal will nol automatically stay 6is oIder. zvJaal認器慧M_、鵠り郡ミ熟』::だ ∬i:鷺 t:サ IISamag。 DONE AND ORDERED lMSノコい・ y吐 ■ね z」Lι _2023,at Cttler Counり ,Π onda. / ´ハnロロArr^D´■■′●Arrロハ△っ、CODE EN『ORCEMENT BOARD eb-de Enforcement Offi cial Pagc 2 of 2 6.B.11.a Packet Pg. 151 Attachment: CEROW20230002007 Zavala (28289 : CEROW20230002007 Zavala) COLLlER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT 30ARD COLLIER COUNTY 80ARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS,Peti"oncr VS Santiago Zavala Jr and Santiago Zavala.DcFcndants CEB(.ヽ SEヽ ()CEROW202300(,20()7 AFFIDAVIT OF NON‐COMPL:ANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER BEFORE ME,thc undcrsigncd authonty pcrsOna∥y appcarcd Ryan Cathcy.Codc Enftlrccmcn1 0mcial rtDrthc codc Enforccmcnt Board ofCo∥icr County,who aftcr bcing fu∥y swom.dcpo"s and says: l That on Novcmbcr 17.2023.thc Codc Enforccmcnt Board hc:d a hcaring and issucd an Ordcr in thc abovc‐ styicd mattcr and statcd that Dcfcndants wcrc to abatc a∥ violations as statcd in thc Ordcr rccordcd in thc public rccords ofConicr county Florida in OR 3ook 631l PC 1463 2 That thc rcspondcnt did not contact thc invcstigator That a rc-inspcction was performed on February 20,2024. That the re-inspection revealed that the coneclive aclion ordered by thc Codc Enforccmcnt Board was not in compliance with thc following conditions: Violation remains and pcrmir PRROW20230I10371 remains rejected. FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT DATED this 20th day ofFcbruaり 2024 COLLIER COUNTY.FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT 30ARD ン″ Ryan Cathcy Codc Enforccmcnt Ofrlcial STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER Swom to(or amrlncd)and Subsc●bcd bcrorc mc by means ofx phySiCal prcscnce or_on:inc notan2a●On, HELEN 8uCHに ■ON ComrnlSS10n"HH 10Sl19 Expres May 15 2025 “““ ｀側 “ ■ “ 摯n,… (PHnOη けpe′Stamp Commlssioned Namc o「Notaり Public) Persona∥y knownヾ 6.B.11.a Packet Pg. 152 Attachment: CEROW20230002007 Zavala (28289 : CEROW20230002007 Zavala) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28290) DOC ID: 28290 Updated: 3/7/2024 3:37 PM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CESD20220010706 Benoit CASE NO: CESD20220010706 OWNER: Christa Benoit OFFICER: Jason Packard VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a), 10.02.06(B)(1)(e) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e)(i). Conversion of garage to living space without Collier County Building Permits. FOLIO NO: 63100240008 PROPERTY 4848 Catalina Dr, Naples, FL 34112 ADDRESS: 6.B.12 Packet Pg. 153 CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLL:ER COUNTY,FLORIDA Code Enforcement Board BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS, COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,Plainlff, VS CHRISTA BENOIT,RespOndent(S) Case:CESD20220010706 NOT:CE OF HEARING RE:MOT:ON FORIMPOSIT:ON OF FINESノ L:ENS PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that Pursuantto Seclon 162 06 and 162 12,Flonda statutes,and Co∥ier County Ordlnance No 07-44,as amended,you are hereby ordered to appear at a pubic hearing before the Code Enforcement Board on the fo∥owing date,time,and place forthe violation below: DATE: 03/28/2024 TIME: 09:00 AM PLACE: 3299 Tamiami Tra∥East Bu∥ding F,Naples,FL 34112 V10LAT10N: CO Requred ATF Permts 10 02 06(Bxlxa),100206(Bxlxe)and 10 02 06(B)(lXe)0) LOCAT10N OF ViOLAT:ON: 4848 Cata∥na DR,Naples,FL 34112 SERVED: CHRISTA BENOIT,RespOndent 」ason Packard, issuing Of「cer RESPONDENTS ARE REQUIRED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEARING CONFERENCE HEARINGS TO BEG:N AT9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOT:CE thatthe a∥eged violator may produce any and a∥documents,wlnesses and/or evidence to be rehed upon forthe testimony glven atthe heattng Documents w∥l consist ofthe original and three coples AIleged violators have the rightto be represented by an atorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that Requests for Conlnuances w∥l not be considered lf not received by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board atleast nve(5)business days p∥ortO the date set forthe hea∥ng iT iS FURTHER ADVISED that Ordinance No 07‐44,as amended,be revlewed pnortO your attendance atthe heattng to include emphasis on Section Eight relating to the appeal process Ashley Eoff COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples,Florida 341 04 (239)252‐2496 Telephone Anyone who requires an auxliary ald o「service for effect ve communication,o「other reasonable accommodations to participate in this proceeding, should contactthe Co∥er County FaC∥it es Management Division,located at 3335 Tamiami T「al E,Sune lol,Naples,Flo百 da 34112,o「(239)252‐ 8380,as sα Dn as possible,but no laterthan 48 hours before the scheduled event Such「easonable accommodations w∥l be prOvided at no costto the individual NOTIFiCAC:ON:Esta audiencia sera∞nducida en elldioma ingles Servicios the traduccion no seran dispOnibles en la audiencia y usted sera responsable de proveer su propio traducto「,para un melor entendim ento ccln as comunicac ones de este evento Po「favo「tra ga su propio traductor AVETISMAN: Tout odisyon yoお t an anglё Nou pan gin moun pOu fe tradiksyon Si ou pa pa10 anglё tanpl vini avё k yon intё prё t pou pa16 pOu―ou 6.B.12.a Packet Pg. 154 Attachment: CESD20220010706 Benoit (28290 : CESD20220010706 Benoit) INSTR 6404364 0R 6248 Pc 845 CLERK OF THE C工 RCurT CouRT ANDREC S35.50 RECORDED 5/■7/2023 ■■:3■ AM PAG ES COMPTROLLER, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Respondent(3). ィ′´´´´ ′ 朧潤鱗盟爵珊翼il鐵樹Л鶴獅:鱗囃職i讐嘗謬胤艦l …■Rぃ pondentK9,ChH"a Bendtis/ar tぷ薇め,fhe ttea pmpCC←he“PЮ pc守)2. Respordent(s), having been notified of theialo.# t#ging by certilicd mail and posting, did appear at the public hearing along with her son, Joseph Betl.oit.,..,,' , 3. Prior to thc hearing, Respondent(s) entered into a Sfpujati6n which is attached hereto as Exhibit "A." The :1::憎 i∬ft11:講き∫:l:111:露 :譜 :』:露 111:311サ〕湯躍 ;11::::R〔 :昇 :λ i:::滉 1∫1∫まl醤 ∥」 iり B'耐 nは。6olcl¨赫 COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD C●se N●.CESD20220010706 following particulars: Conversion ofgsrage to llving space without Collier County Bulufig Plrmits. 5. The violation(s) has/have not been abared as of the datc of this hearinli .r''- 11 '! @NgtusloNs oF LAlu - .' , ) Based upon the foregoing facts, the Board makes the following Conclusions ofLaw: .-' 7' l. AII notices were properly and timely issued, and rhe Board has jurisdiction pursuantlothipter 162, Florida Starutes, and Chapter 2, Article IX, Code of Laws and Ordinances ofCollier County, Florida. 2. The preponderance ofthe evidence shows that violatior(s) ofCollier County Land Development Code, Ord. No.0441, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(BXl)(a), 10.02.06(B)(lXe), and 10.02.06(BX I )(e)(i), do/does exist, 8nd that Respondent(s) cornmittcd, and was/were responsible for maintaining or allowing the violation(s) to continuc as of the date ofthis hearing. ABDEB Based upon the foregoing Findings ofFact and Conclusions ofLaw, and pursuant to the authority granted io Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 2, Article IX, Code of [aws and Ordinances ofCollier County, Florida, it is hereby ORDERED that: Page I of3 6.B.12.a Packet Pg. 155 Attachment: CESD20220010706 Benoit (28290 : CESD20220010706 Benoit) OR 6248 Pc 846AB Respondent(s) iyare found guilty ofviolating Collier County Land Development Code, Ord. No.04-4t, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(BX lXa), 10.02.06(8)(lXe), and 10.02.06(BXlXeXi). Respondent(s) must abate all violations by: l. ceasing and desisting the use ofthe unpermitted garage conversion and disconnecting all unpermitted utilitics until a valid permi! inspections and Cenifictae ofCompletior/Occupancy has bccn issued on or beforE April 30, 2023, or a line oft200.00 per day will be imposed for each day the violation(s) remain tlereafter: and "lt2. obtainlg/att required Collier County Building Permit(s), Demolition Pcrmit, inspections, and Cenificatp6fCgmpletion/Occupancy for the unpermitted garage conversion on or before Sepaember 24, 2023, or a flne of$200.00 per dry will be imposed for each day the violation(s) remain thereafter. C. IfRespondent(s) faiVs,ptornply with this Order, Collier County may abate the violation(s) using any method to bring the violation(s) into compliance and may use thc assistance ofrhe Collier County Sherifls Omce to enforce the provisions ofrhis Or{er and all costs ofabatcment shall be assessed to Respondent(s). --,'/ D. Respondent is ordcred to pay lperatiooal costs for the prosecution ofthis case in rhe amount of$59.28 on or betore trlay 27 , 2023 . IE STATE OF FLORIDA COUN「Y OF COLLIER Board Collier County, Fldrida. j( Personally K-trown OR E Produced Identification Type of Identifi cation Produced PAYMENT OF FINES: Any fines ordered to be paid pursuant to this Order may be paid at 9s-C6mer Courty Code Enforcement Depanment, 2800 Nonh Horseshoe Drive, Naples, FL 34104, Phone: (239) 252-2440, Website: www.colliercountvfl.eov. Any release oflien or confirmation ofcompliance or confirmation ofthe satisfaction ofthe obligations ofthis Order may also be obtained at this location. 騰囲ギ:W堕翌二よn°u多繊1;℃:緊癬,AEEBILi Any aggrieved party may appcal a final orderofthe Board to the Circuk Coun within thirty (30) days ofthe execution of the Order appeated. An appeal shall not be a hcaring de novo, but shall be limited to appellale review ofthe record creatcd within the original hearing..I!iS the respoNibility ofthe appcaling party to obtain a ranscribed record ofthe hearing from the CICrklllill:illI}ll:〕 :そ |li:駆 llIllCallyStaythiSOrder 賦p赫 0劇面～品 C無 "颯山柿zh… … nt Ofth…ЩSl and r製゛ Wttl器驚淵 2¨er Count… 蕪膨馘 Notary Public Page 2 of3 6.B.12.a Packet Pg. 156 Attachment: CESD20220010706 Benoit (28290 : CESD20220010706 Benoit) ■■' OR 6248 Pc 848 '■贅メ|BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS Collier County, Florida Petitioner, vs. Case Christa Benoit Respondent(s), No CESD20220010706 STIPULAT:ON′AGREEMENT Bofore me, the on behalf of Christa Benoit, enters and Agreement with Collier County as to the resolution of Notices of Molation in reference (case)CESD20220010706 dated the llth day of」anuary,2023_ a heanng is Curently scheduled for Ap● "7● お2023i to promote erciency in the administration of the code enforcement procesi; and to obtain a quio&'arid expeditious resolution of the matters outlined therein the parties hereto agree as follows: This agreementis subied tO thetplrOVa1 0fthe Code Enforcement Board.lf l is not approved,the case may 鵠農黒a縄塩淋:糧謂:τ l]プ Q herefoに 1お獣Ю "け reCOmmend“ha he ЮspOnd酬 ∝ h∞ndderatbn ofthe dbpos面 ona14soぃ。n ofthe matte6 o■∥ned h sJd Nolcec)Of Ⅵoh∥On brw∥ch Pa[ι ]●●[`▼[●lV●9:―‐0:υ ∥VWO. ィン 1∥dttI孵選ぶ器 1:結 T胤躙黎器ξttf∝ umね mdi面岬e b harttsbn∞,THEREFORE,itに agreed ben″een the parties thattいび■ |,p9ndent shalli l)PayOpemlonttcostshtheamouttJS5928Ⅲ吟ⅢlthepЮ Secdbnofthscasewl∥n30' days of this hearing. - ' '' - --)2) Abaie all violations by: ,/' (1) Cease and Desist the use of the unpermitted gttraqeaonversion and disco_nnect all unpermitted 31 4) 閾i鮒鱚輔鼈∬1螢燐lY辮理P需澄■■13鳴輛P勝盟T酬麟:鷺闘″滅息ぉa sml“",smd"∝ |19al utilities uniil a yalid permit, inspe&ions and Cpdilpa'tPg Completion/Occupancy has been issued within 6 days oi this'hearing or a firie per day will be imposed until the violation is abated (2) Obtaining all required Collier County Building Permit(s) g-Dgmolition Permijrinspec,tions, and the hve獣 oat,「peⅢm lSl■mSpedio2 t9_"ゴ璽PT21,1生 “:El=."11};-d{!:;'L';'r1,il';'d'li'"uffi#e-;"';#l[";';;iifii"iil* z. r'",t,FFio,a ssrurd'v. sund', orr'ear holdly. l'lcn tha ndncat(m llrust ba ma.b on th6 ncrl dsy that l. nol . srrurdsy, sutnsy d brd hor'dty ) ' " ,l , Thatifthe Respondent fails to abate the violation the County may abate the vめ lation using any method to blng the宙 olation into comp∥anceandmayusethiξ lドよ薔:;昇 :IIIIT:,,ま :R「珈馬to enforce the provisions ofthis agreement and a∥C●7R-espondent or Representative (sign) mas landimarino, Director Fり暉Tttζ D輌望 REV 329・ 16 6.B.12.a Packet Pg. 157 Attachment: CESD20220010706 Benoit (28290 : CESD20220010706 Benoit) COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS,PeJ●oncr VS BEN011l CHRISTA,DcFendant(s) CEB CASE NO CESD20220010706 AFFIDAVIT OF NON‐COMPLIANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority,persona∥y appcarcd Jason Packard,Codc Enttorcemcnt Offlcial fbrthe Codc Enforccmcnt Board ofCollier County,who aner bcing fully swom,dcposcs and says: l That on Apri1 27,2023,the Code Enforcemcnt Board held a hcaring and issued an Order in the above―styled matter and stated that Defendant(s)Was tO Cease and desist the use ofthe unpennitted garage converJon and disconnocting a∥ unpennitted utilitics until a valid pennit, inspections and Ccrtiflcatc of Completion/Occupancy has becn issucd on or bcfore Apri1 30,2023.or a rlne Of S200 Pcr day w∥l imposcd cach day the宙 olation(s)remain thereaner as stated in the Order recorded in the pub∥c records of Co∥ier County,FIoridain OR B∞k6'4R PG 845 2 That the resPondcnt did not contact the investigator 3 That a re inspection was perfo::::ed on May ist.2023 4. That the re‐inspection revealed that the corrective action ordcrcd by thc Codc Enforcement Board was not in compliance with the following conditions:Utilities have not been disconnected/tumed ofi FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT DATED this llth day ofJuly,2023 COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD ″″ Jason Packard Code Enforcement Offi cial STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER 滞冒鶏 vIP総げ mb“H写蝿」げ勲胤 ∫ 必 ySICal pに "n∝∝_酬 hc面ぶab■ (Signature of Notary Public) ( Print/Typc/Stamp Commissioned Name of Notary Public) Personally known { 6.B.12.a Packet Pg. 158 Attachment: CESD20220010706 Benoit (28290 : CESD20220010706 Benoit) COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMiSS10NERS、Pctitloner VS BENOIT,CHRISTA,Dcrendani(s) CEB CASE NO CESD20220010706 AFF:DAVIT OF PART:AL COMPL:ANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority.personaly appeared Jason Packard.Code Enforcement Omcial forthe Code Enforcement Board ofCo∥icr COunty.who aner being Fully sworn,deposes and says: l That on Apri1 27,2023,thc Codc Enforcement Board held a hcaring and issued an Ordcr in thc above‐sヮ led matter and statcd that Defendant(s)Was tO abate all宙 o:ations as stated in scc」on B(l)ofthe order recorded in thc public records ofConier cOunty,Floridain OR B∞k 6248 PG」図臣_ct scq 2 That the respondcnt did contact thc investigator 3 That a re―inspcction was perfonned on May 2nd.2023 4 That the re‐inspcctiOn(s)reVCalcd that thc corrcctlve acJon ordercd by thc Code Enbrcemcnt Board w^in comphance by having a∥utilities shut ofrand no onc occupying thc unpennittcd living space in thc garage FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT DATED this 24th day ofAugust.2023 COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD ″“ %イ Jason Packard Code Enforcement Oflicial STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER 漁漱思ツリ耀繁賞ら諄聾糧 ∥出 rlrfrphySICJpも ∽∝∝¨he notarl刻 m, Personally known V 6.B.12.a Packet Pg. 159 Attachment: CESD20220010706 Benoit (28290 : CESD20220010706 Benoit) CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY、FLORIDA BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Petitioncr, VS CHRISTA BENOIT, Rcspondcnt(S) Casc No CESD20220010706 ORDER OF THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD THIS CAUSE came before the Code Enforcement Board (the "Board") for public hearing on October 26, 2023, upon a Motion for Extension ofCompliance Deadline by Respondent(s), and the Board having heard testimony under oath, received evidence and heard argument respective to all appropriate matters, hereby issues its Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Order ofthe Board as follows: FINDINGS OF FACT l. On April27,2023, Respondent(s) was/were found to have violated Collier County Land Development Code Ord. No. 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(BX I Xa), 10.02.06(BX I )(e), and 10.02.06(8)( I )(exi) on the subject property located at 4848 Catalina Dr., Naples, FL 341 12, Folio No. 63 100240008 (Legal Description: NAPLES SOUTH UNIT I BLK I LOT 6), in the following paniculars: Conyersion ofgrrage to living sprce without Collier Cortrty Building Permits. 2. On the same date as above, the Board issued an Order ordering Respondent(s) to abate the violation(s), in pan, by April 30,2023, by ceasing and desisting in the use of the unpermined garage conversion and disconnecting all unpermitted utilities until a valid permit, inspections and Certificate of Completion/Occupancy has been issued or a fine of $200.00 per day would be assessed for each day the violation(s) remained thereafter (A copy ofthe Order is recorded at OR 6248 PG 845). The Respondent(s) has/have complied with this deadline. 3. The Board's Order also ordered Respondent to completely abate the violation by obtaining all required Collier Counry Building Permit(s), Demolition Permit, inspections, and Cenificate of Completion/Occupancy for the unpermined garage conversion on or before September 24, 2023, or a fine of $200.00 per day will be imposed for each day the violation(s) remains thereafter. (A copy ofthe Order is recorded at OR 6248 PG 845). The Respondent(s) has,tave not completed this requirement but has/}rave limely requesled an extension of:he deadline to abate the violation. 4. Respondent(s), having been notified ofthe date ofhearing on said motion by cenified mail, postirg and/or personal service did appear at the public hearing, along with her son Joseph Benoit, to request this Board to extend the compliance deadline and to provide testimony in suppon thereof. 5. The compliance deadline ofSePtember 24,2023, has expired. 6. Respondent(s) has/have taken, and continues to take, significant actions to abaE the violation. CONCLUS10NS OF LAW Based upon the forcgoing facts,the Board makes thc following Concltlsions of Law: Page I of 2 6.B.12.a Packet Pg. 160 Attachment: CESD20220010706 Benoit (28290 : CESD20220010706 Benoit) l. All notices were prop€rly and timely issued, and the Board has jurisdiction pursuant to Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Chaprer 2, Anicle IX, Code ofLaws and Ordinances ofCollier County, Florida. 2. The Board has substantial, competent evidence upon which to grant an extcnsion ofthe September 24, 2023, compliance deadline in which Respond€ni(s) waywerc given to come into compliance. @B Bascd upon lhe foregoing Findings ofFsct and Conclusions of Law. and pursuant to lhe authority granted in Chsptcr 162, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 2, Article IX, Code of Laws and Ordinances ofCollier County, Florida, it is hercby ORDERED that: A. The request to extend th€ compliance deadline of Septcmber 24, 2023, is hercby GRANTED. B. The new compliance deadline to completely rbrte tbe violrtion(r) is on or before Jrnurry 24, 2024, or the line ofJ200.00 per dry will bc impos€d for each day the violation(s) remain thereafter. C. This Board's previous order datcd Apnl 27, 2023, shall otherwis€ remain in effect, except as specifically amended by this Order. DONE AND ORDEREDthis′多峰 day orれら負生 .2023 at Comier cOunty,Flo∥d■.BOARD STATE OF FLORIDA) COUNTY OF COLLIER) The foregoing inskument was acknowledged before me by ri'eans of.dphysical presence or E online notarization,∬盟g讐滞SRミユど °口罫:∬W還絆M、a詳側i:箇 i:ll:跳 T:]:::総胤鰍 Board Collier County, Florida. ! Personally Kno*m OR D Produced ldentification Type of ldentifi cation Produccd Commissioned Name of Notary Public (Print/Type/Stamp) PAYMENT OF FINES: Any fines ordered to be paid pursuant to this Order may be paid at the Collier County Code Enforcement Depanment, 2E00 North Horseshoe Drive, Naples, FL 34104. Phone: (239) 252-2440, Websire: www,colliercounNfl.gov. Any release of lien or confirmation ofcompliance or confirmation of the satisfaction of the obligations ofthis Order may also be oboined at this localion. APPEAL: Any aggriwed party may appeal a final order ofthe Board to the Circuit Coun within thirty (30) days of the execution ofthe Order appealed. An appeal shall not be a hearing de novo, but shall be limited to appellate rcvicw ofthe record created within the original hearing. lt is thc responsibiliry ofthe appealing party to obtain a transcribed record ofthe hearing from the Clerk ofCouns. Filing an Aprpral will not automatically stay the Board's Order. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and conec_t copy of this ORDER has been sent by U.S. Mail to: Christa Benoit, 4848 Catalina Dr., Naples, FL 34112 on this ( aay of lU.lt-r.l bt , ZOZI. Signature ofNotary Public - State ofFlorida|Code Enforcement Offi cial Page 2 of 2 蕪×i蜘 6.B.12.a Packet Pg. 161 Attachment: CESD20220010706 Benoit (28290 : CESD20220010706 Benoit) COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT 80ARD COLL:ER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS Pcti“oncr BENOIT,CHRISTA.DcFendant(s) CEB CASE NO CESD20220010706 AFFlDAVIT OF COMPLIANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER BEF()RE ME,thc undcrsigncd authorlty,pcrsona∥y appca"d Jason Packard,Codc Enforccmcnt Of「lcia:fbrthc Codc Enforccmcnt Board ofCollicr Counり ,WhO aftcr bcing fully swom,dcposcs and says: l That on Apri1 27,2023,thc Codc Enforccmcnt Board hcld a hcarlng and issucd an Ordcr in thc abovc‐stylcd mattcr and statcd that Dcfcndant(s)Was tO abatc an violations as statcd in thc Ordcr rccordcd in thc public rccords oFCollicr County,Flondain OR B∞k 6248 PG 845,ct scq 2 That thc rcspondcnt did not contact thc invcstigator 3 That a rcinspcction was pcrronllcd o●Fcbruary 27th,2024 4 That thc rc‐inspcction(s)rcVCalcd that thc corrcctivc action ordcrcd by thc Codc Enforccmcnt Board was in compliancc by obtaining Co∥icr County Dcmolition Pcn■it through Ccrtincatc ofcomplction ior thc rcmoval ofthc unPc:∥:ittcd garagc convcrsion FURTHER AFF】ANT SAYETH NOT DATED this 27th day ofFcbruaγ ,2024 COLLiER COUNTY.FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT 30ARD 舛″ Jason Packard Code Enforcement Official STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER (Print/Type'Stamp Commissioned Name of Notary Public) online赫 2atiOn, XLEN臥剛阻ON C―・ n'HH 105119 印res町 15昴 3-いい的 … (or affirmed) and subscribed before me by means oflfphys,cal prcscncc or -oav or d hu-*sr,l .30i{bvJason Packard 蕪(Signature of Notary Public) Pe、ona∥v knownヽ 6.B.12.a Packet Pg. 162 Attachment: CESD20220010706 Benoit (28290 : CESD20220010706 Benoit) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28291) DOC ID: 28291 Updated: 3/7/2024 3:39 PM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CESD20200006363 Arroyo CASE NO: CESD20200006363 OWNER: Miguel Arroyo OFFICER: Doug Williams VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 10.02.06(B)(1)(a). Enclosed the porch/entryway and built a 16ft x 12ft detached garage without first obtaining a valid Collier County permit. FOLIO NO: 62091600004 PROPERTY 5217 Martin St, Naples, FL 34113 ADDRESS: 6.B.13 Packet Pg. 163 CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLL:ER COUNTY,FLORIDA Code Enforcelllent Board 80ARD OF COUNTY COMMiSS10NERS, COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,Pla ntiff, VS MIGUEL ARROYO Respondent(S) Case:CESD20200006363 NOTiCE OF HEARING RE:MOT!ON FORIMPOSIT10N OF F:NES′L:ENS PLEASE TAKE NOT:CE that Pursuantto Sec∥on 162 06 and 162 12,Flo“da Statutes,and Co ler County Ordinance No 07‐44, as amended,you are hereby ordered to appear at a pub∥c hearing before the Code Enforcement Board on the fo∥owing date,time,and place forthe violation below: DATE: o3/28/2024 TIME: o9:oO AM PLACE: 3299 Tamiami Tra∥East Bu∥dng F,Naples,FL 34112 ViOLAT:ON: Bu∥ding Perml LDC 10 02 06(B)(1)(a) LOCAT:ON OFV:OLAT:ON: 5217 Martin ST,Naples,FL 34113 SERVED: MlGUEL ARROYO, Respondent Doug VV∥∥ams, lssuing OfFicer RESPONDENTS ARE REQUIRED TO APPEAR AT 8:30AM FOR A PRE‐HEAR:NC CONFERENCE HEAR:NCS TO BECIN AT 9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICEthatthe a∥eged violato「may produce any and a∥documents,wlnesses and′o「 evidence to be rehed upon fo「the test mony given atthe hearng Documents wi∥consist ofthe original and three copies A∥eged violators have the rightto be represented by an attorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that Requests for Conlnuances w∥ not be cons dered r not received by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board atleast ive(5)bus neSS days p面 orto the date setforthe heanng lT:S FURTHER ADV!SED that Ordinance No 0744,as amended,be reviewed pttOrto your attendance atthe hea面 ng to include emphasis on Section Eight relating to the appeal process Mirlam Lorenzo COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe DHve Naples,Florda 34104 (239)252-2998 Telephone Anyone who requ res an auxi∥ary ald or service for effect ve communicauon 。「Other reasonable accommodations to participate in this proceedin9 should contactthe Co ler County Faci∥t es Management DiviSion located at 3335 Tamiami TraI E,Suite 1 01,Naples Florida 34112.o「(239)252- 8380,as soon as possible,but no laterthan 48 hours before the scheduled evcnt such reasonable accommodations wi∥be p「ovided at no costto the individual NOTIFiCAC10N:Esta audiencia sera conducida en elidioma lngles Servic'os ihe traduccion no seran disponibles en ta audlencia y usted sera responsable de proveer su propio traduclo「,para un melo「entendimiento con laS Comunicaciones de este evento Porfavortiaiga su propio traductor AVETISMAN: Tout odisyOn yO fё t an anglё Nou pan gin moun pOu fe tradiksyon Si ou pa pall angiO tanpl vini avek yOnintepret pou pale pOu―ou 6.B.13.a Packet Pg. 164 Attachment: CESD20200006363 Arroyo (28291 : CESD20200006363 Arroyo) INSTR 6055860 oR 5944 PCCLERK OF THE CIRCu工 T CouRTREC S27.00 ■398 RECORDED 5/■0/202■ AND COMPTROLLER, COLLIER 4:46 PM PACESCOuNTY FLORIDA COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD Case No.―CESD20200006363 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Petitioner, vs. Miguel Arroyo, Respondent. 枷““織朧 l珊富蹴留 l譜ぶ剛鑑讐=躙な慧淵器器』L獅盤Lmattcrs,hereupon issucs its Findings ofFitrCOncluslons ofLaw,and Ordcr ofthc Board as follow● .ノイ｀ l RcspOndent,Mttud Arroy。,ヽぬ c ownclゾ苗さSIす゛ propery chC“PЮ pcry") 2. Respondent, having been notified of tie dare ofle#9g by cerrified majl and posring, appeared along with his son, Miguel Arroyo, who both testified at the public/hearing. ., ,/. Prior to the hearing, Respondent entered into a Stipulftioa/uhich is anached hereto as Exhibir "A." The Stipulation is adopted aod incorporated into this Order,iEna REspondenr is ordered to comply. a, ), The Property located at 5217 MARTIN ST., Naplcs, FL 34fi376)iolNo- 62091600004 (Legal Description: NAPLES MANOR ADD BLK 3 LOT 22) is in violation of Colllgtounty Land Development Code, Ord. No,04-41. as amended, Section 10.02.06(B)t I t(at. in the followifig particula6: /'I Enclosed the porch / entryway rlld built a l6ft x l2ft detachcd Blraer,{vittrout lirst obtaining a valid Coflier County permt . - {. ,, 6. The violations have not been abated as of the date of this hearing. /--" , , CONCLUSIONS OF LAW " J ,-/ Based upon the foregoing facts, the Board makes the following Conclusions of [,aw: ,-i 1. All notices were proporly and timely issued, and the Board has jurisdiction pursuant to Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 2, Article IX, Code ofLaws and Ordinances ofCollier County, Florida. 2, The preponderance of the evidence shows that violation of Collier County Land Development Code, Ord. No. 04-41, as amended, Seotion 10.02.06(8)( I Xa), does exist, and that Respondent co[unitted, and was responsible for maintaining or allowing the violations to continue as ofthe date of this hearing. ORDER Based upon the foregoing Findings ofFact and Conclusions ofLaw, and pursuant to the authority granted in Chapter 162, Florida Statutcs, and Chapter 2, Article IX, Code ofLaws and Ordinances ofCollier County, Florida, it is hereby ORDERED that: ` ‐′ Pagc I of2 6.B.13.a Packet Pg. 165 Attachment: CESD20200006363 Arroyo (28291 : CESD20200006363 Arroyo) OR 5944 PG ■399C STATE OF FLORIDA COtINTY OF COLLIER )p Persona)ly Knorvn OR E Produced Identification Type of Identifi cation Produccd RespoDdent is found guilty of violating Collier County Land Development Code, Ord. No. 04-41. as amended, Section 10.02.06(BX I )(a). Respondent must abate all violations by obtaining all required Colli€r County Building Permit(s) or Demolition Permit, inspections, and Ccrtificate ofCompletion for the enclosure ofthe porch / entryway and detachcd garage, on or before August 21, 2021, or a nne of $100.00 per day will be imposed for each day the violations remain thereaftcr. IfRespondeflt flils to comply with this Order, Collier County may abate the violations using any rnethod to bring fie l6taiio_1is into compliance and may use the assistance of the Collier County Sherifls Office to enforce the plw'rsions.of this Order and all costs of abatcment shall be assessed to Respondent.rt Respondent is ordere{,/to pay operarional costs for the prosecution ofthis casc in thc amount of$59.21 on or before May 231 ?ed. ,/' -, Respondent shall nolify Code Enforcement within 24 hours of abatement of the violations and request the invcstigator to perform a site inspeclion to confirm compliancc. DoNE AND oRDE rlED tf 23day $-Hn: I -}021 at coltter county, Ftorida.BDCODE ENTORCEヽ lENT 30ARD COLLIER ,FLORIDA ノ蕪l』li∥懲:‐Statc ofFlorida oned Name ofNotary Public |く｀ 9httpυ S●mの PAYMENT OF FINES: Any fines ordered to be paid pursuant to this Order ma#belaidat rhe Collier Counry Code f nfor"".ini o"pu.tn e"t, 2b00 North Horseshoe Diive, Naples, FL 34104,'Pl6ne: izfll zSz-z+no, w"U.it", www.coUiercounryfl,eoy, Any release oflien or colfirmation ofcompliance or confirmqdon ofthe satisfaction offie obligations ofthii Order may also be obtained at this location. t- t ., _), APPEAL: Any aggrieved pany may appeal a final order of the Board to the Circuit Court wittJn thirty (30) days of the execution ofthe Ordcr appealed. An appeal shall not be a hearing de novo, but shall be limlsd-roappellate review ofthe record created within the o ginal hearing. It is fic rcsponsibility ofthe appealing parf to obtain a transcribed record ofthe hearing from the Clerk ofCourts. Filing an appcal will not automatically stay this Order. CERTIFICATE()F SERVICE of this ORDER has been sent by U.S. Mail to: Miguel ´ _ヽ _′ ′騰抜劉:;:ど胃蹴ドiS¨ kn°胡Cd汚 :質 Tぶ P品 Ⅲ9fい hメ乙IP““n∝∝□o品 nc ndttzatlo、 Board Colltr Counり ,Fbida ・ uり～ phが r of me collお r Counけ CodC Enお rccmem ィンノ´ム4 ′ `=フ ′ ./ Cbde Enforcement Official Pagc 2 or2 6.B.13.a Packet Pg. 166 Attachment: CESD20200006363 Arroyo (28291 : CESD20200006363 Arroyo) '・・ OR 5944 Pc ■400 ■■■ BOARD OF COUNTY COMMiSS10NERS Co∥ler County,Flonda Petitioner, vs. Miguel Anoyo Case No CESD202000006363 ndent(s), wlh Co∥ier County as t。 ST:PULAT:ONノ AGREEMENT ,on behalf of Miguel Aroy。,enters into this Stipuiation and Agreement dated the 14tll day of of Nolces of Vioialon in reference(case)number cESD202000006363 1) Pay operational costs in the amount of $59.21 days of this hearing. 2) Abate all violations by: the prosecution of this case within 30 Obtaining all required Collier County Buitding permit(s) dr I Permit, inspections, and Certificate of Completion for the enclosure of the porch / (and 16ft x 12ft detached garage _Apr1 23d,2021 Date This agreement is subject to the qpproyjl ofthe code Enforcement Board. lf it is not approved, the case maybe heard on the scheduled Hearing/date, therefore it is strongly recommended that the respondent or representative attend lhe Hearing. / ln.consideration of the disposition ,nO ,.fyti'on of the mafters outlined in said Notice(s) of Violation for whicha hearing is cunently scheduled fo( Apnl23l,'2021; to promote efficiency in the administration of the code enforcement process; and to obtain a quicli..and expeditjous resolutlon of the matters ouflined therein theparties hereto agree as follows: / / il The violati6ns noted in the referenced Ndrce of Violation are accurate and I stipulate to their existence, and that I have been properly notified pursuant to FloaOa glatute 162. THEREFORE, it is agreed between the parties that the ne(ionOent shall. BefOre me,theundi〔liltil: 3) 4) nEspvr r(rrr r r utiir (J(lty Lroqe Enroroemenl wtlntn 24 nours ot aDatemenl of the violation and requestthelnVestigatorperformasiteinspectiontoconfirmcompliance.. (24 hours notc€ shall be by phone or tux and mada during ths workw€ek. tr the vbdoon is ebated 24rhours pr\o. to a saiuday, sunday or boal holldsy. lhen tne nomcation must De made ql $e nsxt day tnat is not a Satuday. Sunday or reg.l hotidsy.) -,-.' , That if the Respondent fails to abate the violation the County may abatdthg-Jidation using any methodto bring the violation inlo compliance and may use the assiitanca ot tne Coni€ir County Sierifls Officeto enforce the provisions of this agreement and all costs of abalemenl shallleasstssed to the propertyowner for tvlChael Ossorio, Director nit tr U{l A/?fro2/ Respondent or Representative lpring メ pr∥23に ,2021 Date REV 3 29‐16 abated 6.B.13.a Packet Pg. 167 Attachment: CESD20200006363 Arroyo (28291 : CESD20200006363 Arroyo) COLLIER COUヽ TY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEWIENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUttY COMMISS10NERS,Pctidoner ARROYO,MIGUEL,DcFendant(s) CEB CASE NO.CESD20200006363 AFFEDAVIT O「ヽON‐COMPLIANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER BEFORE ME,the undersigned authority,personaHy appcarcd Jonathan Mussc,Codc Ent)rccmcnt Ofrlcial for thc Codc Enforcemcnt Board ofConier county,who ancr bcillg fully swom,deposcs and says: 1. That on Apri1 23,2021,thc Code Enforcemcnt 3oard hcld a hearing and issucd an Ordcrin thc abovc‐styled matter and stated that Dcfcndant(s)Was in ViOlation as stated in thc Ordcr rccorded in the public records of Collicr County,Floridain OR Book 5944 PG 1398 2. Thatthc rcspondent did contact the investigator. 3. That a re―inspcction was perfolillcd on August 23.2021 4. That thc rc―inspcction rcvcalcd that thc corrcctivc action ordercd by the Codc Enforcemcnt Board was not in compliancc with the following conditions: Violを :tion Rcmains. No valid CoHicr County pcll“its have bccn issued forthc shcd and dcmo Ofthc cntγ way. FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT. DATED this 23rd day ofAugust 2021. COLlン IEIヽ COUNTY,FLORIDA L.nlorcement Oflicial STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER 潔賞響∬職翼般高り胃ぶ締庶きmmt tλ "■ 硼「s釧 …_o∥“nd面痴0■ (Print/TypeiStamp Commissioncd Name of Norary Public) Personally knonn { HELEN 8UCH:LLON cO―lmlHH 105119 Explres May 15,2025 BoM●d詢暉町 … (Signature of Notary tublicl 蕪 I'lusse 6.B.13.a Packet Pg. 168 Attachment: CESD20200006363 Arroyo (28291 : CESD20200006363 Arroyo) COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT CODE ttFORCERIIENT BOARD Case No.―CESD20200006363 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Petitioner, VS Miguel ArroyO, Respondent. ORDER OF THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD THIS CAUSE camc bcForc thc Codc Enforccinでぃi Board(the``BOard'')fOr pubHc hcarlng on Janualy 27, 2022,upon thc petitioncr's Motion for lmposition Of Finc、Licns and tllc Board,having hcard testimony under oath. rcccived cvidencc and heard argument respcctivc to nH oppropriat● mattcrs, hcrcupon isstles its Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law,and Ordcr ofulc Board as follo、.s: FINDINCS OF FACT 1 0n Ap●123,2021,thc Code Enforcemcnt Board iド、ucd u Findings OF Fact,Conclusions of Law,and Ordcr Thc Rcspondcnt,Migllel Arroyo,was found guiltゝ oi violating Collier County Land Devclopment Code, Ordinancc No 04‐41,as amendcd,Sec●on i0 02 06(3)(1)(a),On thC Subjcct propcrty located at 5217 Manin St,Naplcs,FL 34113,Folio No 62091600004 1Lognl Dcscriptlon:NAPLES MANOR ADD BLK 3 LOT 22),hereinaner rcFcrcd lo as thc“Prope9,''1l thc following paniculars:4635Enclosed th€ porch/eltryway ard buila a l6ft b! l2ft detsched gsrsge without first obtEining s valid Collier County permit. The Board's written Order of April ?3, 2021 . ordcLcd llespondent to abate the violations on or before n ugust 21, 2021, or a fine of$ 100.00 per day would bc ass.'ssed fqr each day the violations remained therealler until abatement was confirmed. (A copy ofthe Ordcr is lecorded at OR 5944, PAGE 1398, for more information). Respondent, having been notified ofthe datc ol h!' ring by cenified mail, posting and/or personal service, did appear and testified as to the abarement cft'trrts alrcady complctcd and those being diligcntly pursued by Respondent. Prior operational costs previously incurrcd bl l)el ilioner in thc prosecution of llris casc in lhc amouot of $59.21 have been paid. Operational costs in thc amount of559.35 have h!-en incurred by Petitioner for this hearing. Thc violations havc not been fully abaled as ofrht ciatc ofthis hearing, but based on Respondents' abatcment cfforts demonshated thus far Petitioner has stipr lited to a contjnuance of its Morion herein for a time cenain. CONCI´liS10ヽ S OFLAW Based upon the foregoing facも ,the Board makcs thc ib∥owing Conclusions of Law: l AH notices wcrc properly and timcly issucd,and thc 8oard has jurisdiction pursuantto Chaptcr 162,Florida Statutcs,and Chapter 2,Articlc IX,Codc oF Law、and Ordinanccs orConicr county,Flo●da Pagc Iof3 6.B.13.a Packet Pg. 169 Attachment: CESD20200006363 Arroyo (28291 : CESD20200006363 Arroyo) 2. pursuant to Section 162.09, Florida Starurcs. I'crirroner has demonstrated by the preponderancc of the evidence that accrued fines and costs could no$ l.r"vfully be imposed againsr Respondent, however, thar in the best interests of administrativc efficicncy llcspondent's abatement efforts to date warmnt a cofitinuance of Petitioner's Motion for a rcasonable period rrt tirne for Respondent to complele his abatement efforts to come into full compliance. oRl)llR Based upon the foregoing Findings of Fact ard CL\nclusions of Law, and pursuant to the authority granted in Chapter 162, Flo;ida Statutes, and Chapter 2, Anicle lX, Cotlc of Larvs and Ordinanccs ofCollier County, Florida, it is hereby ORDERED that: A. Peritioner's Motion for Imposition of Fines/Liens is CONTINUED for a period of thirty (30) days, which would otherwise be no sooner than the next regLrlrrlr, scheduled meeting ofthis Board on or about February 24,2022. B. Daily fines of $100.00 per day shall continu.- r(, x.crue until abatement has bcsn confirmed by a Collier County Code Enforcement Investigator. Conrmissioncd Name of Notary Public (Print/Type/Stamp) PAYMENT OF FINES: Any fines ordered to be paid plisurnt to this Order may be paid at the Collier County Codc Enforcement Department, 2800 North Horseshoe Dri\('. \aPles, FL 34104, Phonc: (239) 252-2440, Websire: www.colliercountvfl.eov. Any relcasc oflien or confirnrrtion ofcompliance or confirmation ofthe satisfaction ofthe obligations ofthis Order may also be obtained at lhis locarion. {!!!!!r; Any aggrieved party may appcal a firal ordcr i)i rhe Board to the Circuit Court within thirty (30) days of the execution ofthe Order app€aled. An appeal shall not hc r hearing de novo, but shall be limited to appellate review ofthe record created within the original heariog. It is thc rcsponsibility ofthe appealing pany to obtain a transcrib€d record ofthe hearing from the Clerk ofCourts. Filing ar. riI1r.-ai $'ill not automatically slay this Ordcr. CERTIFiCATE OF SERVICE Pagc 2 of3 DONE AftD ORDERED this ;1 7 day oilar. , r*tt-i-li , 2022 at Collier Counfy, Florida. CODE ENFORCEM ENT BOARD FLORID STATE OF FLORIDA COtlNTY OF COLLIER The foregoing instrument was acknowledged beforc mc b]' ,neans olSf Presence or O online notarization. 誡鯛訛r8:話語需力年一｀2022,by Robol Kauma■Chir J価 c Collに r Counり CodC Enお Кemcn $ Personally Known OR 0 Produced Identification Signaturc o「Notarv Public‐Statc ofFloridaType of ldcntification Produccd 蕪趙∥迦 6.B.13.a Packet Pg. 170 Attachment: CESD20200006363 Arroyo (28291 : CESD20200006363 Arroyo) l HEREBY CERTIFY thata truc and C Arroyo, 5217 Martin St., Naples, FL 341 I 3, on of rhis ORDER has been sent by U.S. Mail to: Miguel 、2022. Code Enforcement Official Page -1 of 3 6.B.13.a Packet Pg. 171 Attachment: CESD20200006363 Arroyo (28291 : CESD20200006363 Arroyo) COLLlER COしヽTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCI:MENT BOARD COLLIER COUprTY BOARD OF COWY COMMISS10blERS,Pedtioner VS ARROYO,MIGUEL,DcFendant(s) CEB CASE NO CESD20200006363 AFFIDAVIT OFヽ 0ヽ ‐COMPLIANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COll-OF COLLIER BEFORE ME,the undersigncd authority,pcrsonaly appcarcd Jonathanヽ 4ussc,COde Enforcement Offlcial fbr the Codc Enforccmcnt Board of Collicr County,who ancr bcing rtllly swom,dcposcs and saysi l That on Ap●123,2021,the Codc Enforccment B()ard held a hcanng and issucd an Ordcrin thc abovc‐stylcd matter and statcd that Defendant(s)Was tO[]asヽ 1■Cd in ttc Ordcr rccordcd h hc puЫ た rccords of Collにr County,Floridain OR Book 5944 PG 1398 2 Thatthc rcspondcnt did contact thc invcstigator 3 That a re‐inspection was pcrfoll=lCd On Fcbruary 2ヽ、2022 4 That the rc‐inspcction revcalcd that thc corrcctivc action ordercd by thc Codc Enforcemcnt Board、vas not in compliancc、vith thc following conditions:Violatioll Remains FURTIIER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT DATED this 28th,day ofFebruaッ 2022 COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE「ヽ「ORCEMENT BOARD STATE OF FLORIDA COUhlrY OF COLLIER 滞I[1:llill[:1『ll][じり]」]][]lllぢ ∫ ':ilデ ::∥:∥:為 ::ま PhySCal prcscncc or__oninc notaHza■ on. (Print/Type/Stamp Commi""ioned Nan e of Notury 蕪ぶ蠍Public) Pcrsonally knowr J (Signarurc of Notary Public) 6.B.13.a Packet Pg. 172 Attachment: CESD20200006363 Arroyo (28291 : CESD20200006363 Arroyo) COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT 30ARD Case No.―CESD20200006363 BOARD OF COUNTY COMル lISSiONERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Petitioner, VS. Migue:ArroyO, Respondent ORDER OF THE CODf, [\ }'ORCEITIENT BOARI) THIS CAUSE came before the Codc Enforcenrcnt Board (the "Board") for public hcaring on March 24, 2022, upon the Petitioner's Modon for Imposition of Fincs Licns. and the Board, having hcard tcstimony undcr oath, received evidence and heard argument respcctive to all appropriatc matters, hcrcupon issues its Findings of Fact, Conclusions ofLaw, and Order ofthc Board as follou's: FINDINCS OF FACT l. On April23,2021, the Codc Enforccment Board issuecl a Findings ofFact, Conclusions ofLaw, and Order. The Respondent, Miguel Arroyo, u'as found guillv of violating Collicr County Land Development Codc, Ordinance No. 04-41, as amendcd, Section 10.02.0ar(BX lXa), on the subject property located at 5217 Mafiin St., Naples, FL 34113, Folio No. 62091600004 1l-.'gal Dcscription: NAPLES MANOR ADD BLK 3 LOT 22), hcreinafter refcrrcd to as the "Property," in th. ii'llowing particulars: Enclosed the porch/entr''rv8y and built r l6ft hv l2ft deteched garage rvithout first obtaining a yelid Collier County permit. 2. The Board's wri(en OrderofApril 23, 2021 , ordercd llcspondent to abatc thc violations on or bcfore August 21, 2021, or a finc of $ 100.00 per day would be Iisicsscd for each day the violation remained thereaftet until abatement was confimcd. (A copy ofthe Order i: r ecor ded at OR 5944, PACE 1398. for rnore information). 3. On lanuary 21,2022, the Code Enforcement BoarC Cranted a Continuance. 4. Respondent, having been notified ofthc date of hcrring by cenified mail, posting and./or personal service, did appear and testified as to the additional abatcrDenl eflorts already completed and those being diligendy pursued by Respondent. 5. Prio, operational costs previously incurred by Pctitioncr in the proscrution of this case in the amount of $59.21 have been paid. 6. Opelational costs in the amount of559.35 havc btcr: incurrcd by Pctitioncr for rhis hcaring. 7. The violatio! has not been fully abatcd as oflhc (lrric ol'this hcaring, bul bascd on Rcspondcnts' abatcmenl effons dcmonstrated fius far Petitioner has stipulatrd lo a continuance of its Motion hcrcin for a time ccnain. CONCLTJSI0NS OF LAW Based upon the foregoing facts, thc Board makcs lhe lirllorving Conclusions of Law: Pagc I 1r{ -1 6.B.13.a Packet Pg. 173 Attachment: CESD20200006363 Arroyo (28291 : CESD20200006363 Arroyo) 1All notices were properly and timely issued, and thc Board has jurisdiction pursuant to Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 2, Article tX, Code ofLan's Irrcl Ordinances of Collier County, Florida. Pursuant to Section 162.09, Florida Statutes. I'clllioner has demonstrated by thc preponderance of the evidence that accrued fines and costs could nott lrK fully be imposed against Respondent, however, that in the best intcrcsts of administrative efficiency Rcspondcnt's abatemcnr effons to date waFant a continuance of Petitioner's Motion for a reasonabie p€riod of Irnre for Respondent to complete his abatement effons to come into full compliance. ORD T- R Based upon the foregoiog Findings ofFact and Cr.n.lusions ofLaw, and pursuant to thc authority ganted in Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 2, Anicle IX. Cr,ile of Laws and Ordinanccs ofCollier County, Florida, it is hercby ORDERED that: A. Petitioner's Motion for Imposition of Fines/Liens is CONTINUED for a period of ninety (90) days, which would otherwise be no sooner than the next reguLrr iv schcduled mccting of rhis Board on or about June 23, 2022. B. Daily fines of$100.00 per day shall continue 1(] accnrc until abatement has been confirmed by a Collier County Code Enforcemenl Invesligator. STATE OF FLORIDA COLIN「Y OF COLLIER The fOregoing instrument was acknowlcdgcd bcFOrc mc b、 this ´う dayoF npaP′ ,2022,by Robcrt Board Collicr COunty,Florlda 摯CrSO翻けbOWn OR□Produccd ldcn面 cabn Type of Idcltillcation Produced ..-f],i:: o HETENi:''-'ori Commissioncd Nameof Notary Public=\i!-Z' Csnniss,:':. -r1 :0ill! ;,=&ff'; iilil.,; ;.:i,'' (Priny'rvpc/Stamp) pAyMENT oF FINEs: eny nnes oraJrEd\% b" H.?'il,?',, ,iii-i iiiTi oro"r."y be paid at the collier counry code Enforcemcnt Department, 2800 Nonh Horscshoe Drivc. \lplcs, FL 34104, Phone: (239) 252-2440, Website: www.colliercountvfl.qov. Any release of lien or confirmaliur ,rf conrpliance or confirmation ofthe satisfaction of the obligations ofthis Order may also be obtained at this locatiorr. d!fp!! Any aggrieved party may appeal a finalordcr ol thc Board to the Circuit Coua within thirty (30) days of the execution ofthe Order appealed. An appeal shall not bc l hcaring de novo, but shall be limited to appellatc revicw ofthe record creatsd within rhe original hearing. I( is thc r r':lr.rnsibility ofthe appealing pany to obtain a transcribcd rccord ofthc hcaring from the Clcrk ofCouns. Filing an appral \r'ill not automatically slay this Order. DoNE AND oRDERED this ,. Y ds ! oLl44-&h-,2022 at collier county, Florida. nrcans ofQ physical Prcsencc or El onlinc notarization, Kruthan, Chair ofthe Collier County Code Enforccmenl C10DE ENFORCEMENT BOARD∞TC,EttΨ l´/Pagc 1ol3 6.B.13.a Packet Pg. 174 Attachment: CESD20200006363 Arroyo (28291 : CESD20200006363 Arroyo) CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY lhat a true and correct copr, trf this ORDER has been sent by U.S. Mail to: Miguel Arroyo, 5217 Martin St., Naples, FL 341 13, on NLP| lO ,2022. Code Enforcement Official Page 3 ol3 6.B.13.a Packet Pg. 175 Attachment: CESD20200006363 Arroyo (28291 : CESD20200006363 Arroyo) COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD Casc No―CESD20200006363 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Petitioner, VS. Migue:Arroyo, Respondent(S). ORDER OF THE CODE I.]\}'ORCEMENT BOARI) THIS CAUSE came before thc Code Enforcemcni lloard (the "Board") for public hearing on February 23, 2023, upon the Petitioncr's Motion for Imposition of Fincs, I icns, and the Board, having heard testimony under oath, rcceived evid€ncc and hcard argument rcspective to all appropriate matters, hereupon issues its Findings of Fact, Conclusions ofLaw, and Order ofthe Board as follows: FINDT^-GS ()t fi\CT l. On April 23,2021, the Code Enforcement Board :..rrcd a Findings ofFact, Conclusions ofLaw, and Order. The Respondent(s), Miguel Arroyo, was(were) fbLrrrrl guilry ofviolating Collier County Land Development Code, Ordinancc No. 04-41, as amended, Scction la) 01.06(BXlXa), on the subject property locatedat 52lT Manin St., Naplcs, FL 34113, Folio No. 620916000(r-1 (Lcgal Description: NAPLES MANOR ADD BLK 3 LOT 22), hereinafter refered to as the "Propeny." rn the following paniculars: Enclosed the porch/entrywsy ard built s l6ft ll! l2ft detsched garsge t ithout first obtaining a valid Colller County permii. 2. The Board's written Order of April 23, 2021, oldcr c,i Rcspondent(s) to abate the violation(s) on or bcfore August 21, 2021, or a fine of 5100.00 per day rr',rirl<i be assessed for cach day thc violation(s) rernained thereafter until abatement was confirmed. (A copl oi tht' Order is rccorded ar OR BK 5944, pAGE 1398, for moro information). 3. On January 27, 2022, the Board grantcd Rcspon(l('[l ir continuancc. Again, on March 24, 2022, the Board granted Rcspondent a sccond contiluance to conlc ;Dro compliance until Junc 22,2022. 4. Respondent(s), having been notified ofthc date ol Ic,rr:ng bv cenified mail, posting and/or pelsonal service, did have Respondent's son, Miguel Arroyo. Jr., ayr.-.rr r,,.he testified as to tirc add-itional abatcment effons alrcady complered and those being diligcnrly pursle,j h), Respondent(s). 5 Prior operational costs previously incuned by Pclrr:oncr in the proseculion of this case in the amount of$59.21 have becn paid. 6. The violation(s) has (have) not bcsn fully abatcd a: ot rhc datc of lhis hearing but based on Respondcnl(s),abatcment effons demonstrated thus far Pctitioncr ir:: sripulatcd to a continuance of irs Motion irercin lbr atime cenain. Based upon rhc rorcsoins facts, ,n" ,ouro o,ffi{l.lffiffions of Law: I All notices werc properly and.timely^issued, -and thc l)oard has jurisdiction pursuant to chapter 162, FloridaStatules, and Chapter 2, Anicle IX, Code ofLaws ard Ordinanccs ofCollier County, Florid'a. Page I ol 2 6.B.13.a Packet Pg. 176 Attachment: CESD20200006363 Arroyo (28291 : CESD20200006363 Arroyo) 2. PliFSuant to Scction 162.09, Florida Statutcs, I)ctitiollcr has dcmonstratcd by thc preponderancc of the evidence that accrued rlncs and costs could no、viょ、●:111ly bc imposcd against Rcspondcnt(S),hOWCVCr,that in thc best intcrcsts of administrat市 c cmcicnc, Rcspondcnt(S)' abatemcnt cfforts to datc warrant a continuance of Pctitioncr's Motion for a rcasonabic Pcriod oftimc for Respondent(S)tO COmpicte abatement ettrts to conle intoヽ 1l compliancc. ORI)卜 lR Bascd tlpon the forc80ing Findings of Fact and C()1,clu、lons of Law,and puFSuantto thc authoFity gFantCd in ChaptCF 162,FIorida Statutcs,and Chaptcr 2,Article I)(,(・ tx'ct)「La、vs and Ordinanccs ofConicr county,Florida,it is hereby ORDERED that: A. Pctitioner's Motion lbr lmposition ofFines/Lic:]、1ド (く ,NTI卜auEE)lor a pcriod offour rnonths,、vhich would othcrwise be no sooner than the ncxt regularly sc1lc(11:!cd lnccting Ofthis Board on or aboutJunc 23,2023. B, Daily fines of S100.00 per day shan continuc t()::ocluc until abatcment has becn con「lHned by a Conicr County Code Enforccmcntlnvcstigator. DONE AND ORDERED this'13亀勢ay。., 2023 at Collier County, Floridr, CODE ENT BOARD (()I´LIER CO l´ORI STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER 騰憮寡澪:壇螂出 2宣 ==「 ]:質 l試 l麟 3oard Collicr County,Florida. fiPersonally Known OR E Produced ldentification Type of Identifi cation Produced ぞl:|ミ :」lill(:[じ liiを 1::lilil:i鳥 1::::::総 1嵐 :ll 121Jせ l"″ ``く ″ Signature of Notary Public‐State ofFlorida 蕪 HELEN Bじ C卜 (t10∥ Commlssion r卜 H10う 119 邑暉歯es ttaソ :i231う ―枷決摯ヽド・.=:■● “ Commissioned Namc of Notary Public (Print/Type/Stamp) 。「lhiS ORDEli:i bCen scnt by U.S.Mail tO:Migucl PA,YMENT Of IINES: Any fincs ordcred to be paid pursrar)l to this Ordcr may be paitl at thc Collier County Codc Enforcement Depafiment, 2800 North Horseshoe Drivc. ),'lples, FL 34 104. Phone: (23g) 252-2440, V/ebsite; $'ww.colliercount.vfl.gov. Any release of lien or confinnatiirn oi-compliance or confirmation of thc sarisfaction of the obligations of this Order rnay also be obtained ar this locariori. APPE,{L; Any aggrieved party may appeal a final ordc'r oi i}rr lJoard to the Circuit Court within rhirty (30) days of the execution of the Order appealed. An appeal shall not bc :i hearing tle novo, but shall be linrited to appellate r.ui.*of the record created within the original hearing. It is the rcsir,rirsibility of the appealing party to obtain a transcribed record of the hearing from the Clerk of Courts. Filing an appcal u'ill not automitically rruy tt it Or,t"r. CERTIFICATE OIr sERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct cop、 Aroyo,5217 Manh St.,Napに s,FL 34H3,on埜豊L二 1、 Page 2 trf ? 6.B.13.a Packet Pg. 177 Attachment: CESD20200006363 Arroyo (28291 : CESD20200006363 Arroyo) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28292) DOC ID: 28292 Updated: 3/7/2024 3:43 PM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CESD20200009039 Clapper CASE NO: CESD20200009039 OWNER: Kurt Clapper and Tricia Clapper OFFICER: Rickey Migal VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 10.02.06(B)(1)(a). Constructed shed without permit. FOLIO NO: 38228440003 PROPERTY 5720 Sea Grass Ln, Naples, FL 34116 ADDRESS: 6.B.14 Packet Pg. 178 CODE ENFORCEMENT・ COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA Code Enforcement Board BOARD OF COUNTY COMMiSS10NERS, COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,P aintiff, VS KURT CLAPPER AND TRICIA CLAPPER,Respondent(S) Case:CESD20200009039 NOTiCE OF HEAR!NG RE:MOT10N FORIMPOS:T:ON OF FINES′LIENS PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that Pursuantto Seclon 162 06 and 162 12,Flo百 da Statutes,and Co ier County()rdinance No 07-44, as amended,you are hereby ordered to appear at a public hearing before the Code Enforcement Board on the fo∥owing date,tme,and place forthe vlolation below: DATE: 03/28′2024 T:ME: o9:oO AM PLACE: 3299 Tamlami Tra∥East Bu∥ding F,Naples,FL 34112 V10LAT:ON: Bu∥ding Perml LDC 10 02 06(B)(1)(a) LOCAT10N OF V:OLAT10N: 5720 Sea Crass LN,Naples,FL 34116 SERVED: KURT CLAPPER AND TRiCIA CLAPPER,RespOndent Rickey M gal, Issuing Ofrcer RESPONDENTS ARE REQU:RED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEARING CONFERENCE HEAR:NCS TO BEGIN AT 9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOT:CE thatthe a∥eged violato「may produce any and a∥documents,wlnesses and/o「 evidence to be relied upon forthe testimony glven atthe hea「ing Documents wl∥consist ofthe o「iginal and three copies Alleged violators have the rightto be represented by an attorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOT!CE that Requests for Coninuances w∥ nOt be considered if not received by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board atleast five(5)business days prio「to the date setforthe hear ng IT:S FURTHER ADV:SED that Ordinance No 0744,as amended,be reviewed p∥o「to your altendance atthe heaHng to include emphasls on Section Eight relating to the appeal process Mirlam Lorenzo COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe DHve Naples,Florida 341 04 (239)252‐2998 Telephone Anyone vvho requires an auxl ary aid or service ror eFFective oommunicat on,o「othe「reasonable accommodations to participate in this p「oceeding, should contactthe Co∥er County Faci∥t es Management Divislon,Iocated at 3335 Tamiami Tral E,Suite 101,Naples,Flo面 da 34112,or(239)252‐ 8380 as soon as possible but no laterthan 48い ours before the scheduled event Such reasonable accommodations wi∥be provided at no costto lhe individual NOT:F!CACiON:Esta audiencia sera conducida en elidioma lngles Servicios the traducclon no seran dispOnibles en ia audiencia y usted sera responsab e de proveer su propio traductor,para un melo「entend m ento con as comun caciones de este evento PorFavortra ga su proplo traductor AVETISmAN: Tout odisyOn yO fё t an anglo Nou pan gin moun pou fe tradiksyon Si ou pa palё ang10 tanpl vini avek yon intё pret pOu pale pOu‐Ou 6.B.14.a Packet Pg. 179 Attachment: CESD20200009039 Clapper (28292 : CESD20200009039 Clapper) 工NSTR 6■43854 oR 6027 PCCLERK OF THE C工 RCU工 T COURTREC S35.50 ■2■9 RECORDED ■0/■5/202■ ■2:40 AND COMPTROLLER, COLLIER COUNTY PM PACES FLOR工 DA Board (the "Board") for public hearing on Scptembcr 23, oath, reccived evidence and heard argutncnt respective to all Conclusions ofLaw, and Ordcr ofthe Board as follows: is arrached hcleto as Exhibit "A." The is ordered to comply. No 38228440003(Lcsal Dcscription: SecJon 10 02 06(B)(1)(a),Ord No particulars: COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD Casc No.―CESD20200009039 30ARD OF COUNTY COⅣIMISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, THIS CAUSE camc bcForcthe 2021, and the Board, having heard appropriate matters, hereupon issues its 3. Prior to the hearing, Respondents entered into a Stipulation is adopted and incorporated into lhis Order; 4. Thc Property located at 5720 Scc Grass Ln., Naples, FL . COLDEN CATE EST tlMT 31 W 150FT OF TR,9)is 04-41, as amended, Collicr Couoty Land Dcvelopment Code, Construclcd shed without permit. 5. Thc violations have not been abaled as ofthe date ofthis hearirg, CONCLUSIONS OF LAW Based upon the forcgoing facts, the Board makes the following Conctr"ion, of L.rr', /j ,/L All notices were properly and timely issued, and thc Board has jurisdiction punuant to Ch\'tcr 162, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 2, Article IX, Code ofLaws and Ordinanccs ofCollicr Counq(Florida. 2. Thc preponderance of thc cvidcnce shows thar violalions of Scction 10.02.06(BXtXa), Ord. No,0441, as amended, Collier County Land Dcvclopment Codc, do exisl, and that Respondents commined, and wcrc responsible for maintaining or allowing the violations to continue as ofthe date of this hearing. ORDER Based upon the foregoing Findings ofFact and Conclusions ofLaw, and pursuant to thc authority granted in Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 2, Anicle Ix, Code ofLaws and Ordinances ofCollicr County, Florida, it is hereby ORDERED that: Page 1 of2 Respondellts. 6.B.14.a Packet Pg. 180 Attachment: CESD20200009039 Clapper (28292 : CESD20200009039 Clapper) OR 6027 Pc ■220B Respondents are found guilty of violating section 10.02.06(8)( I Xa), ord. No. 04-41, as amendcd, collier Couoty Land Development Code. Respondents must abate all violations by; obtaining all rcquired Collier County Building Permit(s) or Demolition Permit, inspections, 8nd certificatc of completiodoccupancy for the unpcrmimed shed, on or before Jonuary 21, 20i2, or a line of $200.00 per day will be imposed for each day the violations remain thereafter. IfRespondents bring the enforce do hcady -!r,arar lhet- .6!$rum.r:t is}rn a a. .l conrd ΨOnTり彎Ч攣製ヵ｀γt民 ■ヤBr_■ツuェムハュュ鍼塾4ざ二L。・ptγ CI“ to comply with this Order, Collier County may abate fie violations using any method to into compliance and may usc the assistancc of the Collier County ShcrilT's Office toC ofthis Order and all costs ofabatement shall bc assessed to Respondent. STATE OF FLORIDA COUNrY OF COLLIER Thc Forcgoing instrumpnt was acknowlcdgcd bcrorc ,r'r' -:l-J.y "i-l}&84-Izozt. uv Rou.ri Board Collicr COttty,Florida f,Pcrsonally Known OR E Produced Identification T)?e of Idcnlifi cation Produced- APPEAI′:Any aggricvcd patt may appcal a rlnal ordcr oflhc Board to thc Circuit C●●●｀thirly(30)dayS Of tO apPcllatc lcvicwthe cxccution ofthe Order appealed. An appcal shall not be a hcaring de novo, but shall be ofthc record creakd within the original hearing. It is the responsibility ofthe appealing party a transcribed record ofthe hearing from the Clerk ofCouns. Filing an appeal will not sutomatically stal CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 0彎 rξ 翻獅蔵野:鷺 ∬隠留,繋轟,穏 ∬選lP軍嬰堪ギ写ちりY翻 il鎌響墜i亀面に3 Codc En「orccmcnt lⅢⅢ4だ事i?覆むt,kAnd●」はぃiけ ' 卜慧『:::lモi:Gミ tay° pCra・ Onal COStS rortllc prOSecut10n ofthlS Casc h the amOunt oFSS■28 tlll Prcscnce or E online notarization, Chair ofthc Collier County Code Enforcement of Notary~Public―Stat●of Florlda 鰍ド“N出 L6轟 II=Il,uΨ ,“PAYMENT OF FINES:Any flnes ordercd to bc paid pursuantto this Ordcr E"f-"".""t D.p"n..ttt,2800 Nonh Horseshoe Diive, Naples, FL 3410{-Ph6ne: ..(239) 252'2440, Websilc: www.collicrcountvfl.qov. Any release of licn or confirmation of compliancc or conffiatln of the satisfaction of the obligations ofthis Order may also bc obtained at this location J DalJt Page 2 of2 6.B.14.a Packet Pg. 181 Attachment: CESD20200009039 Clapper (28292 : CESD20200009039 Clapper) OR 6027 PG ■22■ BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS Co∥ier County,Flo∥da Petitioner, VS. KURT AND TRIC:A CLAPPER THEREFORE, it is agreed between the parties that 1) Pay operational costs in the amount of $ 59.28 days of this hearing. 2) Abate all violations by: Obtaining all required Collier Permit, inspections, and Certificate of Comp '120 days of this hearing or a fine of $200.00 per day abated. sha ll; the prosecution of this case within 30 Case No CESD20200009039 enters into this Stipulation and in reference (case) number ing Permit(s) or Demolition the unpermitted shed within until the violation is Cristina Perez, Supef{isor for Michael Ossorio, Director Code Enforcement oivision 催濡麒誇Mヽ・W17T釧 |「躍鼎調霧甲爛脚群 ln consideration of the disposition anO resdfiiofl of the matlers outlined in said Notice(s) of Violalion for which a hearing is currently scheduled for Septeghdr-23'd, 2021: to promote efficiency in the administration of the code enforcemenl process; and to obtain a qqpti.,a44 expeditious resolution of the matters outlined therein the parties hereto agree as follows: . .,. / _ \1) The violations noted in the referenced NdtFe'of yiolation are accurate and I stipulate to their existence, ´ 、 Date Q.zt.zozl REV 3‐29-16 Before me, the with Co∥er 2020 of the violation and us,ng any be Respondent must notify Code Enforcement within 24 hours of That if the Respondent fails to abate the violation the Sheriffs Office to enforce the provisions of this agreement and all coStC 6.B.14.a Packet Pg. 182 Attachment: CESD20200009039 Clapper (28292 : CESD20200009039 Clapper) === OR 6027 PC ■222 ☆'■ Case No CESD20200009039 REV 3‐29‐16 6.B.14.a Packet Pg. 183 Attachment: CESD20200009039 Clapper (28292 : CESD20200009039 Clapper) COLLER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COll―COMMISSIONERS,PetitiOner VS CLAPPER KURT&TRICIA,DcFendan(s) CEB CASE NO.CESD20200009039 AFFIDAVIT OF NON‐COMPLIANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COIINTY OF COLLER BEFORE ME,thc undersigned authority,pcrsonally appcared William Shanaban,Codc Enforccmcnt Ottcial forthc Codc Enforcment Board ofCollicr County,who after beillg illy swon、deposes and saysi l That on Septcmber 23,2021,thc Codc Enforcoment Board held a hcanng and issucd an Ordcr h thc above‐ stylcd lnatcr and stated that Dcfcndant(s)Was tO Obtaln a pemrlit or demolition pemut and all requttd inspecions fOr thc shcd as statcd in thc Order recorded in thc public rccords ofCouicr coullty,Ro五 dain OR Book 6027 PG 1219 That the respondent did contact the investigator, That a re-inspection was performed on January 24n,2021. That the re-inspection revealed that the corrective action ordered by the Code Enforcement Board was not in compliance with the following conditions: not obtaining all required Collier County Building Permit(s), or Demolition Permit, Inspections, and Certificate of Completion/Occupancy for the un-permitted shed on or before Jaorxy 21,2022. FURⅧR AFFIANTSAYETH NOT DATED this 241h day ofJanuary,2022 STATE OF FLORIDA COIJNrY OF COLLIER Swom t。(Orammcd)and subscribed before me by means of_X_physlcal presence or_Onlinc notarlzation,34蕪淵批(Print/Type/stamp Cornmissioned Name ofNotary Public) Personally knownヾ COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA COtt ENFpRCEME「Л BOARD th1 24●day OfJanuΨ ,2ッ 2,by Winね m Shanahan (Signatttrc of Nbtaり Pubhc) 6.B.14.a Packet Pg. 184 Attachment: CESD20200009039 Clapper (28292 : CESD20200009039 Clapper) CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY、FLORIDA BOARD OF COUNTY COⅣMISS10NERS COLLER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Pctitioner, VS KURT CLAPPER and TRICIA CLAPPEヽ Respondcnt(S) Casc No CESD2020041119039 ORDER OF THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARI) THIS CAUSE came before the Code Enfqrcemenl Board (the "Board") for public hearing on September 28, 2023, upon Petirioner's Motion for Imposition of FineVLiens, and the Board having heard testimony under oath, received evidence and heard argument respective to all appropriate matters, hereby issues its Findings of Fact, Conclusions ofLaw, and Order ofthe Board as follows: FINDINGS OF FACT I. On September 23, 2021, Respondent(s) was/wsre found guilty of violating Section 10.02,06(BX I Xa), Ord. No. 04-41, as amended, Collier County Land Development Code, on the subject property located at 5720 Sea Grass Ln., Naples, FL 341 16, Folio No. 38228440003 (Legal Description: GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 3l W l50FT OF TR 99) hereinafier referred to as the "Property", in the following particulars: Constructed shed wlthout permit. 2. The Board's written Order of September 23, 2021, ordered Respondent(s) to abate the violation(s) on or before January 21, 2022, or a fine ofS200.00 per day would be assessed for each day the violation(s) remained thereafter until abatement rvas confirmed. (A copy ofthe Order is recorded at OR 6027 PO 1219.) 3. Respondent(s), having been notified ofthe date of hearing on today's Motion for lmposition ofFineVLiens by cenified mail, posting and/or personal service, appeared at thc public hearing, via Kurt Clapper, and requested a co[tinuance as Respondent(s) continues to pursue abatement ofthe violation(s). 4. Previously assessed operational costs of $59.28 have been paid and the Petitioner has incurred $59.49 in operational costs for today's heariog. 5. The violation(s) has/have not bcen fully abated as of the date of this hearing, but Respondent(s) has demonstrated conlinued, diligent efforts to abate the violation(s). CONCLUSIONS OF LAW Based upon the foregoing facts, the Board makes the following Conclusions ofLaw: l. All notices were properly and timely issued, and thc Board has jurisdiction pursuant to Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 2, Anicle IX, Code ofLaws and Ordinances ofCollier County, Florida. 2. Pursuart to Section 162.09, Florida Statutes, Petitioner has demonstrated by a preponderance of the evidence that accrued fines and costs could now lawfully be imposed against Respondent(s), however, that in thc bcst interests of the adminiskative efficiency, Respondent(s) continued abatement efforts to date warrant a continuance ofPetitio[er's Motion for lmposition ofFines/Liens for a reasonable period of time for Respondent(s) to complete abatement effons and come into full compliance, Page I of2 6.B.14.a Packet Pg. 185 Attachment: CESD20200009039 Clapper (28292 : CESD20200009039 Clapper) ORDER Based upon the foregoing Findings ofFact and Conclusions ofLaw, and pursuant to lhe authority grantcd in Chapter 162, Florida Slarures, and Chapter 2, Anicle IX, Code of Laws and Ordinances ofCollier County, Flo da, it is hcreby ORDERED that: A. Petitioner's Morion for Imposition of Fines is cootioued to be heard on or after November 27, 2023. B. Daily fines of $200.00 per day shall continue to accnre until abatement of the violation(s) haVhave been confirmed by a Collier County Code Enforcement lnvestigaior. lξ 捌 ;:ISlをり〕ili】[】Lack,。 wlcdged bcrOrc me by mcans o「JphySCal prcscncc or□oninc nota“zatlo■ _,2023,by Robc●Kauhan,Chair ofthc Collicr County Code Enforcernent Board Collier County, Florida. I Personally IGown OR g hoduced Identification 蕪淵鶉Commissioncd Name of Notary Public (Print/Type/Stamp) Mail to: Kurt Clapper and 年 ,2023 PAYMENT OF FINES: Any fines ordered to be paid pursuant to this Order may be paid at the Collier Counry Code Enforcement Department, 2800 North Horsestroc Drive, Naples, FL 34104, Phone: (239) 252-2440, Website: www.colliercountyfl,sov. Any rclease of lien or confirmation ofcompliance or confirmation ofthe satisfaction of the obligations ofthis Order may also be obtained at this location. APPEAL; Any aggrieved parry may appcal a final order ofthc Board to the Circuit Coun within thirty (30) days of the execution ofthe Order appealed. An sppeal shall not be a hearing de novo, but shall be limited to appellate review ofthe record created within the original hearing. It is the responsibility ofthe appealing party to obtain a transcribed record ofthe hearing from the Clerk ofCoufis. Filing an Appeal rrill not automatically stay the Board's Order. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 器器葛::「:発 :習犠:∬∬til[:。I躍 1ltttRl嚇盤智ぶ社些 DoNE AND oRDERED thb J(*' oe y ot ,U|<.tb<l ,2023 rt Colller Courty, Florldr. STATE OF FLORIDA) COUNTY OF COLLIER) Type of ldentifi cation Produced Signature ofN tary Public - State ofFlorida Page 2 of 2 6.B.14.a Packet Pg. 186 Attachment: CESD20200009039 Clapper (28292 : CESD20200009039 Clapper) COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY 30ARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS,Pctitioner Vs CLAPPER,KURT&TRICIA,DeFendant(s) CEB CASE NO.CESD20200009039 AFF:DAVH・ OF NON‐COMPLIANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER BEFORE ME,the underslgned autholty,personally appeared Rickey Migal,Code Enforcement Ottcial forthc Codc Enforcemcnt Board ofCollicr County,who a■cr being Fully swom,deposes and says: l That on Scptember 23,2021,thc Codc Enforccmcnt Board held a hcaring alld issued an Order in thc abovc‐ styled mater and statcd that Defendant(s)Was tO口 as stated in the Ordcr rccorded in the public rccords of Collicr cOunty,Flo五 dain OR B∞k`n,7 PG 1219_ 2 That the respondent did not contact the invcstigator 3 That a re‐i“pection was pcrformcd on November 28,2023 4 That the re‐inspcction revcalcd that thc corrective action ordcrcd by thc Codc EnfOrccmcnt Board was not in compliancc with thc Following conditions: Pcnlnit PRBD20210840140 has not bcen flnaled FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT DATED this 28th day ofNovembcr,2023 COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD 影η Rickey Migal Code Enforcement Offi cial STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER ピツ ¶∫冨じ岬 ∵ d晩お “ meby m∽ “ o2ph"酬 p"“¨c∝。価ne no●H濃 oL 2唖 y Rickey Mignl HELEH BuCHILON Comfn sston,HH 105119 Exp res hlay 15,2025 3-m Btullt疇輛‐(Pinυ ηけⅣStamp Commお sioned Name ofNotary Public) PCFSOna:ly knownマ 6.B.14.a Packet Pg. 187 Attachment: CESD20200009039 Clapper (28292 : CESD20200009039 Clapper) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28295) DOC ID: 28295 Updated: 3/7/2024 3:48 PM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CESD20230003899 Lopez CASE NO: CESD20230003899 OWNER: Debbie Bello Lopez and Ramon Lopez OFFICER: Craig Cooper VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a), 10.02.06(B)(1)(e) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e)(i). Multiple structures erected prior to obtaining a Collier County Building permit(s) consisting of but not limited to a front carport with 2 light poles with receptable connections, barn/carport/storage structure in the rear, metal shed structure, and an electrical receptable connection pole in the rear of the property. FOLIO NO: 38970400003 PROPERTY 2960 56th Ave NE, Naples, FL 34120 ADDRESS: 6.B.15 Packet Pg. 188 T:ME: CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLLiER COUNTY,FLOR:DA Code Enforcement Board BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS, COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,P ainlfF, VS nFRRiF RFl:O10pF7 ANn RAMON10pF7,Respondent(S) Case:CESD20230003899 NOT:CE OF HEARING RE:MOT:ON FORIMPOS:T:ON OFF:NES′LIENS PLEASE TAKE NOT:CE that Pursuantto Sec∥on 162 06 and 162 12,Flonda statutes,and Co er County Ordinance No 07‐44, as amended,you are hereby ordered to appear at a pub∥c hearng before the Code Enforcement Board on the Fo∥owing date,time,and place forthe violation below: DATE: 03/28/2024 09 00 AM PLACE: 3299 Tamiami Tra∥East Bulding F,Naples,FL 34112 V10LAT10N: CO Requred ATF Permた s100206(B)(1)(a).100206(Bxl)(e)and 10 02 06(B)(1)(e)o) LOCAT10N OF ViOLAT:ON: 2960 56th AVE NE,Nap es,FL 34120 SERVED: DEBBIE BELLO LOPEZ AND RAMON LOPEZ,RespOndent Cra g Cooper, lssuing OfFicer RESPONDENTS ARE REQU:RED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEARINC CONFERENCE HEAR:NGS TO BEGIN AT 9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTiCE thatthe a∥eged violator may produce any and a∥documents,wlnesses and/or evidence to be relied upon forthe testimony given atthe hearing Documents w∥l consist ofthe original and three copies A∥eged violators have the rightto be represented by an attorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOT:CE that Requests for Con∥nuances w∥l not be considered r nOt received by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board at east ive(5)bus neSS days p百 orto the date setforthe heanng :TiS FURTHER ADV:SED that Ordinance No 0744,as amended,be reviewed p面 o「to your attendance atthe heanng to include emphasis on Sect on Eight relating to the appeal process Helen Buch∥lon COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe DHve Naples,Flo「ida 34104 (239)252-5892 Telephone Anyone who requ res an auxllary ald o「service ror efFect Ve communication,or other reasonable accclmmodations to participate in this proceeding should contactthe Co le「County Fac 11les Management Divis on,located at 3335 Tamiami T「a∥E Sune lol Naples Florda 34112.or(239)252- 8380,as soon as possible but no laterthan 48 hours befOre the scheduled event Such reasonable accommOdat ons Ⅵ41 be prOvided at no costto the individual NOT:F:CAC:ON:Esta audiencta sera conducida en elidioma ingles Servicios the traduccion no seran disponibles en la audiencia y usted sera responsable de proveer su p「opio traductor,para un melo「entendimiento con las comunicaciOnes de este evento Po「rav。「tra19a su prOpio tiaductor AVET:SMANi Tout odisyOn yO Fet an anglё Nou pan gin mOun pOu fe tradiksyon Siou pa pa10 ang10(anpl vini avOk yon intё pret pou pa16 pOu―ou 6.B.15.a Packet Pg. 189 Attachment: CESD20230003899 Lopez (28295 : CESD20230003899 Lopez) INSTR 6456■■9 0R 6290 PG 4■■CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT AND REC S■8 50 RECORDED 9/22/2023 9:54 AM PACES 2 COMPTROLLER, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY,FI.ORIDA BOARD OF COUNTY COⅣIMISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Pctitioncr, Casc No CESD20230003899 ,NFORCEⅣIENT 30ARD nt Board(thC“BOard'')rOr public hcaring on August 24, ,FCCCiVcd cvidcncc and hcard arsumcnt rcsPcctivc to an ,onclusions or Law,and Ordcr orthc BOard as ro∥。ws: …)i で｀ / ,.',2. Rcspondent(s), having bccn notificd of lhc da6 oflcnring by ccnilicd mail and posting, appcarcd al the public hcaring via Dcbbic Bcllo Lopcz. //'. , 3. The Properry at 2960 56'r' Ave. NE, Naples. fL l{tZ1f'fotio No. 38970400003 (Legal Dcscription: cOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 44 W l50FI OF TR 106).is-in yiolation ofCollicr County Land Dcvclopmcnt Code 04-41, as amendcd, Scctions 10.02.06(BXl Xa), 10.02.06(BX I )(c), and 100206(BXlXeXi) in thc following paniculars, "s' .r'' ,/') Multlplc structures crcctcd prior lo oblrinirg o Collicr Cougly,6uilding pcrmit(s) consisling of, but l. Rcspondcnt(s), Dcbbic Bcllo Lopez rnd'Ramd,n Lopcz" is/arc thc owncr(s) ofthc subject propctty (the "Propcny"). no( limltcd to, ! front corpori rvith 2 llShl polcs rvith rcccptrblc connecllons, barn/carpott/storagc structurc in the rcar, mcirl shed struclure, rnd an elcctrical reccp(iblc',connccaion polc ln thc rcar of the propcrty. 4, Thc Respondent(s) has'havc admittcd rhat thc violation(s) exist. 5 Thc violation(s)has/havc not bccn abatcd as ofthc datc o「this hcaring _/ CONCI´US10NS OFl´AヽV Bascd upon thc rorcgoing racts,thc Board mよ cs thc roHOwing Conclusions or Law: l. All noticcs wcre propcrly ond timcly issued, and thc Board hasjurisdiction pursuant to ChaJ,tcr I62, Florida Statutcs, and Chapter 2, Article Ix, Code ofLaws and Ordinances ofCollicr County, Florida. 2. Thc prcpondcrancc ofthc cvidcncc shows that violalion(s) ofCollicr County Land Dcvclopmcnt Codc 04- 41, as amcndcd, Sections 10.02.06(BXl)(a), 10.02.06(B)(l Xc), rnd 10.02.06(8Xl )(c)(i) do/docs cxist, and that Respondent(s) commiltcd, and was/werc rcsponsible for mninraining or allowing thc violation(s) to continuc as ofthc date ofthis hcaring, ORDER Pagc l or2 VS / 1イ 1ノ芯蔦 cilLO形 :電 11ド RAMON LOPEZ, 6.B.15.a Packet Pg. 190 Attachment: CESD20230003899 Lopez (28295 : CESD20230003899 Lopez) やや・t OR 6290 PC 4■2 1t'十 Bascd upon thc forcgoing Findings ofFact and Conclusions of Law, and purcuant to lhe authorily granted in Chaptcr 162, Flo;ida Statutcs, and Chaptcr 2, Aniclc IX, Code ofLaws and Ordinances ofCollicr County, Florida, il is hereby ORDERED that: A. Rcspondcnt(s) is/arc found guilty ofviolating Collier County Land Dcvclopment Codc 04-41, as amcnded, Scctions 10.02.06(BXl )(a), t 0.02.06(BXl )(c), and 10.02.06(BXlXc)(i). in the rear of the propeny, mctal shcd structurc and clcctrical reccptaclc conncction rcar of the propeny on or bcforc Fcbruary 20, 2024 or a linc of $350.00 per day will bc imposcd ilay thc violation(s) rcmain thercaller. C. Rcspondcnt is ordcrodio pay operational costs for thc prosecution ofthis casc in thc amount of$59.28 on or s), inspcctions, and Certilicalc of Complction/OccuPancy to cithcr keeP or rcmove lhc rvemcols of thc front carpon with 2 light polcs with rcccptaclc conncctions, … ぶD ORDER品夕黎的 0曇障 =2023 at… G耐 "恥出ヽ Cり、 ―, ′ abarc thc violation(s) by obtaining all requircd Collicr Counly Building Pcrmit(s) or #dphysical prcscncc or o online notarization, ,i, Chair ofthc Collicr County Codc Enforccmcnt STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER "^tL:y,.,^ HELEN BUcHll-LoN -./-\.-r_ cor.nl,ssron;ttil103t19;.tti# _*,#,#1iT:*",'"?*Jfi;l#:,pll*;;"n'0"")-... PAYMENT OF tr'INES: Any fines ordercd to be paid pursuant to this Order mey bc Afaid ai thc Collier County Codc E^f*"".c"t Dcp",1.""t, 2ilOO Nonh Horscshoc Drivc, Naplcs, FL 34104, nnonc: fl9) 252-2440, Wcbsite: wwrv.collicrcountvfl.eov. Any rclcasc oflien or confirmation ofcompliaoce or confirmation ofrh-c satisfqction ofthc obligtlions of this Ordcr may also bc obmincd at this location. ., .,J ,/ {Pcrsonally lGown OR O Produccd ldcntification Tne of Idcntification Produced 絣 ,II締 :F::l躍群∬猟∬ば謝常露吉:譜 l:卍 1:|:1:i諸轟鶴11麗 l∬噺料謙:霊 :∬:辮:within thc orlginal hcaring lt is thc rcsponsibility oFthc appca∥ng party to Obtain a transcribcd rccOrd orthc hcaring rrom thc Clcrk or Couns F∥ing an appcュ l wil not automatic4nily stay this Ordcr CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE l誦鷲二』畷「比蝋 iザ ,N"置 :1::冨 ::l導盟塁塁塁笙ち脇 lMalldDあ Ы cB胡。Lo"z ttd 樵驚螢二潔籠器鯉凛 Deputy CI“ Pagc 2 of2 6.B.15.a Packet Pg. 191 Attachment: CESD20230003899 Lopez (28295 : CESD20230003899 Lopez) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28296) DOC ID: 28296 Updated: 3/7/2024 3:52 PM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CELU202200011318 Martinez CASE NO: CELU20220011318 OWNER: Yohenis Martinez OFFICER: Charles Marinos VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 1.04.01(A) and 2.02.03. An improved estates zoned property with multiple inoperable boats on blocks in the yard and no registration numbers. FOLIO NO: 45847880008 PROPERTY 1311 11th St SW, Naples, FL 34117 ADDRESS: 6.B.16 Packet Pg. 192 CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLLiER COUNTY,FLORIDA Code Enforcement Board BOARD OF COUNTY COMMiSS10NERS, COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,Plainiff, VS YOHENIS MARTINEZ,Respondent(S) Case:CELU20220011318 NOTICE OF HEARING RE:MOT:ON FORiMPOS:T:ON OFF:NESノ LIENS PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that Pursuantto Section 162 06 and 162 12,Flo日 da Statutes,and Co her County Ordinance No 07‐44,as amended,you are hereby ordered to appear at a pub∥c hearing before the Code Enforcement Board on the followlng date,tme,and place forthe violation belowi DATE: 03/28/2024 T:ME: 09:00 AM PLACE: 3299 Tamiami Tral East Bu∥ding F,Naples,FL 34112 V10LAT:ON: Proh bned Uses l o4 01(A)and 2 02 03 LOCAT10N OF V10LAT10N: 1311 1lth ST SVV,Naples,FL 34117 SERVED: YOHENIS MARTINEZ,Respondent Cha∥es Ma∥nos, lssuing Omcer RESPONDENTS ARE REQUIRED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEAR:NG CONFERENCE HEARINGS TO BEGIN AT 9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTiCE thatthe aneged violator may produce any and a∥documents,wlnesses and/or evidence to be relied upon forthe testimony given atthe heanng Documents w∥l consist ofthe original and three copies Alleged violators have the rightto be represented by an attorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that Requests for Conlnuances wl∥not be cons dered if not received by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board atleast ive(5)business days priorto the date setforthe hearing lTIS FURTHER ADV:SED that Ordinance No 0744,as amended,be revlewed pttorto your attendance atthe heanng to lnclude emphasis on Sectlon Eight relating tO the appeal process Ashley Eoff COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples,Flor da 34104 (239)252-2496 Telephone 議」Tl:#轟 :趙 W驚秘1層膵書i:職 i巫、%盤編哨『J珊器躙 :ξ 晋盟蹴讐∫脳爛〕vent Such「easonable accommodations w∥l be provided at no costto the individual NOTIF:CACiON:Esta audiencia sera conducida en elidioma lngles Servicios the traduccion no seran dispOnibles en la audiencia y usted sera responsable de proveer su prop o traductor,para un melor entend m entO con as comun caciones de este evento Porfavortraiga su prop o traductor AVETISMAN: Tout odisyon yO fet an anglё Nou pan gin moun pou fe tradiksyon Si ou pa pa16 ang10 tanpr vini avё k yon intё pret pOu pale pOu_Ou 6.B.16.a Packet Pg. 193 Attachment: CELU20220011318 Martinez (28296 : CELU202200011318 Martinez) INSTR 64607■8 0R 6293 PCCLERK OF THE CIRCu工 T CouRTREC S27.00 3000 RECORDED ■0/4/2023 AND COMPTROLLER, COLLIER ■:08 PM PACESCOuNTY FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY.FLORIDA BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Pctitioncr, Casc No CELU20220011318 md由 c酬醤船蠅R淵 i鳳記THIS CAUSE camc bcforc t|6 Codc Enforccmcnt Board (thc "Board") for public hearing on Juty 31, 2023, ~・ FINDINCS OF FACI ′ l Rcspondcnt(S),Yohon“Mar“ne2,iダ arcttFoⅢer(s)Orぬ c suり ca prOpc"←hc“ProPc守 "),waS ndincd 師pJ籠おn t adoptd and hcoponcd撤 oザ孵 lRcspondcm③ Va“。rdcrcd b comメン織lぶ繋電l」評|]品 :::f賛11::trl串 11)1li:::1:t高 ::視lilT8:為::稽:電 ::IR:電 ∥:lFallapprop● 試c 2 :lli:ii:illil:こsi11:illcli〔:イ |:,j∥ili∥lllililllilllli[lli:xlЫ t“氣….hc 3. The Propcny at l3l I I I 'h St SW, Naples, FL 341lffiolc+Ig. 45847880008 (Lcgal Dcscription: GOLDEN GATE EST t NlT 193 N l05FT OF TR 76) is in violationpfCollicr County Land Dcvclopmcnr Codc, Ord. No. 04-41, as amcndcd, Scctions 1.04.01(A) and 2.02.Q{ in thc following particulars: '. . r/ An improved eslatcs zoned property wiih multiple lnopJr/blpb;ats on blocks tn ihe yard and no registr!lion numbcrs. .,/4. Thc violatior(s) has/havc not bcen abated as ofthe datc ofthis hearing. tt,. '.tcoNclustoNs oF LAw . , Based upon the forcgoing facts, thc Board makes the following Conclusions oiLawf l. All noticcs wcre properly and timcly issucd, and the Board has jurisdiction pgrsuant io Chaptcr 162, Florida Statutcs, and Chaptcr 2, Article IX, Codc ofLaws and Ordinanccs ofCollicr Couiif, $orida. 2. The prcpondcrance ofthc cvidence shows that violation(s) ofCotlier Counry LandS6vil6pmcnt Code, Ord. No. 04-4[, as amerdcd, Scclions 1.04.01(A) and 2.02.03 do/docs cxist, ond that Rcspondcnt(s) committed, and wavwere rcsponsible for maintaining or allowing thc violation(s) to continuo as of thc datc of this hearing. SBB Based upon thc forcgoing Findings ofFact and Conclusions of Law, and pursuant to the authority grantcd in Chapter 162, Florida Statutcs, and Chapter 2, Anicle IX, Code ofLaws and Ordinances ofCollicr County, Florida, ir is hercby ORDERED that: A. Rcspondcnt(s) iVarc found guilty of violating Collier Couoty Land Devclopment Codc, Ord. No. O4-41, as amendcd, Scctious L04.01(A) and 2,02.03. VS. / Page I of2 6.B.16.a Packet Pg. 194 Attachment: CELU20220011318 Martinez (28296 : CELU202200011318 Martinez) OR 6293 Pc 300■ X Personally Knorvn OR tr Produccd ldcntification Typc of Identifi cation Produccd Clcrk ofCouns. Filing an appcal will not automatically stay this Ordcr. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICECRcspondent(s) must abatc all violations by rcpairing and obtaining valid registrliion lo a legal occupant of the subject propeny for all boats in violation - including aflixing registration numbcrs to cach hull, or storc the boats in a complctcly cncloscd structure or upon a liccnsed and opcrable trailcr rcgistcred to a lcgal occupant ofthe subject propcrty, or rcmove the boats to a site authorized for such usc on or beforc August 30, 2023, or ! finc of$50.00 per d.y will be imposed for each day the violation(s) rcmain thercafter. IfRcspondcDt(s) faiys to comply with this Order, Collier County may abate thc violation(s) using any mcthod to bring the violation(s) into compliance and may usc thc assistance ofthe Collicr County SherifT's Office to enforcc the provisions ofthis Order and all costs ofabatcmcnt shall bc assessed to Rcspondcnt(s). I Respondefs frdged to pay opcrational costs for thc prosccution ofthis casc in lhc amount of$59.28 on or beforc Air gusl.ro, 2Q23.,/. Rcspondcnt(s) siall ndrify Cod" Enforcement within 24 hours of abatemcnr of thc violation(s) aod rcqucst thc investigatorlo+eform a sitc inspcction to confirm complioncc. DoNE AND oRDF,{fD it x ?/U ary *5uk!............. 2023 ar cotlie r coun.y, Ftorida. STATE OF FLORIDA COUN「Y OF COLLIER 鷲肥焉IS躙 P改 ∞口嘲書鸞臨 /ffilyri"ot pr"..nce or E online notarization, lζ 」!::1lay￡亀」 `114o`」 f:亡l―――――――」 2023,byttOb3,JK'μ 'man,chalr orthc cOmcr County Codc Enforccmcnt Board Collier County, F[orida. `ノ、DE1//ofNotary - Statc ofFlorida ,か CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD 蕪鯰1徊'EAYIIENI_AE_LINE& Any fines ordered to bc paid pursuant lo this Ordcr may]c peid at thc Collier County Code Fnf*"",*,,tD"pu,t,*,''t,2.8ooNorthHorseshocDrivc,Naplcs,FL341o4'/Phoq!:Q3g)252.244o,Wcbsitc: www,colliercountvfl.gov. Any rcleasc oflicn or confirmation ofcompliancc or confirmatiodof tlc satisfaction ofthe obligrtions rf lhl" ord*."y "lr" b. obtaincd at this location. { '; ,/ AEBEIId Any aggrieved pany may appeal a final order ofthe Board to thc Circuii Coun witt iirtf iny 1: q ) days ofthe execution of the Order appealed. An appcal shall not be a hcaring dc novo, but shall bc limitcd lo appcllad rc_v!9& gf thc rccord creatcd within rhe original hcaring. It is thc rcsponsibility ofthc appcaling party to obtain a tmnscribcd rccord ofthc hcaring from thc |げ毬器鍔:3ξ i猟 :,り hЫC :I:1:RI」鷲キIFIお ■]l,:f]基彗』場昌ピ旦22ビ」Elttl]:あ :ド bCCn SCnt by uS Mail匈 I Yohems Martlnca 1311 H・ l`｀.´、｀lK `^ D, 0.e Deputt Cle“ Pagc 2 of2 6.B.16.a Packet Pg. 195 Attachment: CELU20220011318 Martinez (28296 : CELU202200011318 Martinez) 青=t OR 6293 Pc 3002 ■■■ 80ARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS Co∥ier County,Flonda pelloner. o、vner or Representatrve (sign) vs. Yohenis Martrnez ク:Before me, the undersigified,:う t 71e on behalf enters into this Sti ent with Col|er County as to lhe resolution of reference lo case number CE 0011318 dated the 27th day of February,2023 STIPULAT!ONノ AGREEMENT Case No CELU20220011318 |=2, of Yohenis lvlartrnez, Notices of Vrolation rn This agreement is subject to the approugl of the Code Enforcement Board. lf it is not approved, the case may be heard on the scheduled HearirQ 7date, therefore it is strongly recommended that the respondent or representative attend the Hearing. / tn consideration of the disposition anO relotutipn of the matters outhned in said Notice(s) of Vtolation for u/hrch a hearing is currently scheduled for the 3 !:l,day of July 2023: to promote effrciency in the administratton of the code enforcement process: and to obtain a quick qnd expedrtrous resolution of the matters outlined lheretn the parlies hereto agree as follows: r 1) The violations noted in the referenced fbgcS oi,Vlotation are accurate and I stiputate to fheir existence, and that I have been properly notrfred pursuant'1o Torlda Statute 162. THEREFORE, it is agreed between the partres th; thlRdsfondent shatl' ,,?... Pay operational costs rn the amount of 559.28 (grieaanthe prosecution of this case within 30 days of this heanng ' " //Abate all violations by repairing and obtaining vaJrd registratron to a legat occupant of lhis property for all boats in violatron - including affrxing rdgistJatron numbers to each hutl, or store the boats in a completely enclosed structure or upon a;L6eqsed and operable trailer registered lo3^legal occupant of this property. or remove the boats t6 a Site intended for such use within,Q days of this hearing or a frne of S5O.OO per day wjlP6e imposed until the violation is abaled. 助RespOndenl must n山 "Code Enわ「cement輛 hn 24 hovtt γ “ 11昴 ent J he Mdtton and reque」 the lnvestigator perform a site inspection to confl「m comp∥ancё _ 、い…にe¨……mc α f3k 3●dm¨¨mⅢ…薇によl lh・ m…sめ 3軍 FFTお am“…“R/Or_ holdav thcn thc nol′Icat on inuζ !be m3da on tha nex!dav l卜 nt is●o,n Sahirdno S■nd●v^′l●●、,卜 ′ (24 hours not.ce shirr be by phonc or lsr Bnd m.dc dui.! lhe wo.I$c.k It rho v'orit.c^ ,s ab3rcd Zt di,rs rilcr r hol,dry,lhcn hc norrllcar,on mu3lbc n3cc on thc ncrrdayil.alrs rota saturday sunc.y cr te!.r ho: dly i ) That if the Respondent fai,s to abate the violation the Countv mav aOEdtfre4)That r the RespOndenlfa∥s to abale the口 ob∥on the County may a幌派チt腱 |。lalbn ugng any method to bnng the 釉t『滉躙:inl::」7:;跳ど諸罠蟹ζt乳器を駆 ;1:]滞デ鵠諦ξ8鴨 :: to enforce the of this agreement and all costs of abatement shall be 6ssessed to the property for Thomas landrmarino, Director Code Enforcement Division 昼eソ゛ndenl, RUspondent or Representative (pnnt)Date REV 3 29 16 6.B.16.a Packet Pg. 196 Attachment: CELU20220011318 Martinez (28296 : CELU202200011318 Martinez) COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS.Peti“oncr MARTINEZ,YOHENIS,DeFendant(s) (Signaturc of Notary Public) CEB CASE NO CELU202200113:8 AFFIDAVIT OF NON‐COMPLIANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COLIN「Y OF COLLIER BEFORE ME,thc undersigncd authority,Pcrsonaly appcarcd Charlcs Mannos.cOdc Enforccmcn1 0mcialfbrthc Codc Enforccmcnt Board ofConicr county,who ancr bcing fu∥yswom,dcPoscs and says: l That on July 31,2023,thc Codc Enforccmcnt Board hcld a hcaring and issucd an Ordcr in thc abovc―stylcd matcr and statcd that Dcfcndant(s)Was tO tt as Statcd in thc Ordcr rccordcd in thc pubHc rccords of Collicr County. Florida in OR Book PG 2 Thatthc rcspondcnt did contact thc invcstigator 3 That a rc‐inspection was perfo∥Ilcd On August 31St,2023 4 That thc re‐insPcction rcvcalcd that thc corcctivc action ordcrcd by thc Codc Enforccmcnt Board was not in compliance with thc following conditions:Unliccnscd/inopcrablc vchiclcs rcmain on sitc at this timc FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT DATED this 31“day ofAugust,2023 COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD "… Charles Marinos Codc Enforccmcnt Offi cial STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER 消ガ :投率騎ばゼf」場]「蹴酬穏X""dp“鸞ncc Or_酬 hc nOtarl測 m, 蕪淵蠍(Print/Type/Stamp Commissioncd Name of Noury Public) Personally known J 6.B.16.a Packet Pg. 197 Attachment: CELU20220011318 Martinez (28296 : CELU202200011318 Martinez) CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUNTY.FLORIDA BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA, PeitiOner, VS Casc No CELU20220011318 YOHEMS MARTINEZ, Respmdent(s)/ORDER OF THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARI) THIS CAUSE came before the Code Enforcement Board (the "Board") for public hcariog on lanuary 25, 2024, upon Petitioner's Motion for Imposition of FineVliens, and the Board having heard testimony under oath, received evidence and heard argument respective to all appropriate mafiers, hereby issues its Findings of Fact, Conclusions ofLaw, and Order ofthe Board as follows: FINDINGS OF TACT I. On July 31, 2023, Respondent(s) was/were found guilty of violating Sections 1.04.01(A) and 2.02.03, Collier County Land Development Code, Ord- No. 04-41, as amended, on the subject propeny located at 13l I I 16 St SW, Naples, FL 34117, Folio No.45847880008 (Legal Description: GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 193 N l05FT OF TR 76) hereinafter referred to as the "Property", in the following particulars: An improved estrt€s zoned property witb multiple inopersble bosts on blocks in the yard and no rogistrution numbers. 2. The Board's wrinen Order ofJuly 31. 2023, ordered Respondent(s) to abate the violation(s) on or before August 30, 2023, or a fine of 550.00 per day would be assessed for each day the violation(s) remained thereafter until abatement was confirmed. (A copy ofthe Order is rccorded at OR 6293 PG 3000.) 3. Respondent(s), having been notified ofthe date of hearing on today's Motion for lmposition ofFines/Licns by certified mail, posting and/or personal sen'ice, appeared at the public hearing. along with his designated translator Tracy Smith, and requested a continuance as Respondent(s) continues to pursue abatement ofthe violation(s). 4. Previously assessed operational costs of559.28 have not been paid. 5. The violation(s) has/have not b€en fully abated as of the date of this hcaring, but Respondent(s) has demonstrated continued, diligent effons to abate the violation(s). CONCLUSIONS OF LAW Based upon lhe foregoing facts, the Board makes the following Conclusions ofLaw: I . All notices were properly and timely issued, and the Board has jurisdiction pursuant to Chapter I62, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 2, Anicle IX, Code ofLaws and Ordinances of Collier Counry, Florida. 2. Pursuant to Section 162.09, Florida Statutcs, Petitioner has demonstraled by a prcpondcrance ofthc cvidcnce that accrued fines artd costs could now lawfully b€ imposed against Respondent(s), however, that in the bcst interests of the adminiskative efficiency, Respondent(s) continued abatement effons to datc warrant a conlinuance of Petitioner's Motion for Lnposition of Fines&iens for a reasonable period of time for Respondent(s) to complete abatement efforts and come into full compliance. Page I of2 6.B.16.a Packet Pg. 198 Attachment: CELU20220011318 Martinez (28296 : CELU202200011318 Martinez) ORDER Based upon the foregoing Findings ofFact and Conclusions ofLaw, and pursuant to thc authority $anted in Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 2, Anicle IX, Code ofLaws and Ordinances ofCollier County, Florida, it is hereby ORDERED that: A. Petitioner's Ntotion for Imposition ofFines is continued to be heard on or aftcr February 24, 2024. B. Rcspondent(s) shall pay previously assesscd operational costs of559.28 on or before January 25.2024. C. Any operational costs incuned for today's hearing will be considered at the next regularly scheduled hearing date. D. Daily fines of 550.00 per day shall continue to accrue until abatement of the violation(s) hashavc bcen confirmed by a Collier County Code Enforcement Invesligator. 驚号1郡゛躙 DONE AND oRDERED this ,(d ,t- "ifu-e!.202.t et Cottier Counr\', Ftorida. 30ARD FLORIDA STATE OF FLORIDA) COUNTY OF COLLIER) ・ fin911Cdttff」 "や rcⅢ `by.FCllSOtthySICalprcscnccor□ onhnc notar12at10n, Board Co∥icr County.Florida . 2024, by Roben Kaufman.-Chair ofthe Collier Couniy Codc Enforcemcnt Commissioncd Namc of Notary Public ., (Prin/Typc/Stamp) PAYMENT OF FINES: Any fines ordered to bc paid pursuant to this Order may be paid at thc' Collier County Codc Enforccment Departmcnt.2800 North Horseshoc Drive. Naples. FL 44104. Phonc: (249) 252-2440, Wcbsitc: www.colliercoun*fl.qov. Any releas€ of lien or confirmation ofcompliance or confirmation ofthe satisfaction oflhe obligations ofthis Order may also be obtained at this location. APPEAL: Any aggricved pany may appcal a final order ofthe Board to the Circuit Court within thiny (40) days of the execution ofthe Onder appealed. An appeal shall not be a hearing de novo. but shall bc limitcd ro appellatc ro icu ofthc record crcated within thc original hcaring. It is the responsibility ofthe appealing pany to obtain a transcribcd record ofthc hcaring from thc Clcrk ofCouns. Filing an Appeal will not automatically stay thc Board's Order. CERTI「ICATE OF SERViCE Signature ofNotary Public - Statc ofFlorida |」il;PIt鷲 F踊 1露宵猫愕tilTL翌翼'has bcen sent by U.S Mailto:Yohcnis Martincz、 2024 Page 2 of 2 礁 TttI胤糊継 C“除面驚mm 6.B.16.a Packet Pg. 199 Attachment: CELU20220011318 Martinez (28296 : CELU202200011318 Martinez) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28297) DOC ID: 28297 Updated: 3/7/2024 3:55 PM by Miriam Lorenzo Page 1 CESD20210002415 Padilla and Nunez CASE NO: CESD20210002415 OWNER: Melva Padilla and Nazaria Angelica Nunez OFFICER: Rickey Migal VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a), 10.02.06(B)(1)(e) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e)(i). Alterations to garage area without a required Collier County building permit. FOLIO NO: 56324013549 PROPERTY 8322 Valiant Dr, Naples, FL 34104 ADDRESS: 6.B.17 Packet Pg. 200 CODE ENFORCEMENT‐COLLiER COUNTY,FLOR:DA Code Enforcement Board BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS, COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,Plainlff, VS MELVA PADILLA AND NAZARIA ANCELICA NUNEZ,Respondent(S) Case:CESD20210002415 NOT!CE OF HEARING RE:MOT:ON FORIMPOSIT10N OF F:NES′L:ENS PLEASE TAKE NOTiCE that Pursuantto Seclon 162 06 and 162 12,Flo日 da Statutes,and Co∥ier County Ordlnance No 07-44,as amended,you are hereby ordered to appear at a pub∥c hearing before the Code Enforcement Board on the fo∥owing date,time,and place for the violation below: DATE: o3/23/2024 T:ME: 09:00 AM PLACE: 3299 Tamiami Tra∥East Bu∥ding F,Naples,FL 34112 V:OLAT10N: CO Requred ATF Permls 10 02 06(B)(1)(a),100206(Bxl)(e)and 40 02 06(Bxlxe)0) LOCAT:ON OFV:OLAT10N: 8322 Valant DR,Naples,FL 34104 SERVED: MELVA PADILLA AND NAZARIA ANGELICA NUNEZ,Respondent R ckey Migal,Issu ng Of「cer RESPONDENTS ARE REQU:RED TO APPEAR AT 8:30 AM FOR A PRE‐HEARING CONFERENCE HEARINGS TO BEGIN AT 9:00 AM PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICEthatthe a∥eged violato「may produce any and a∥documents,wlnesses and/or evidence to be rened upon forthe testimony glven atthe hearing Documents w∥l consist ofthe origlnal and three coples AIleged vlolators have the right to be represented by an attorney PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that Requests for Coninuances w∥i not be considered if not received by the Secretary to the Code Enforcement Board atleast ive(5)business days p∥orto the date setforthe heanng lT:S FURTHER ADV:SED that Ordinance No 0744,as amended,be reviewed pttortO yOur attendance atthe hea百 ng to include emphasis on Section Eight relating to the appeal process Ashley EofF COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT 2800 North Horseshoe D∥ve Naples,Flo「ida 34104 (239)252-2496 Telephone 辮聾殿畿il:1鮒 i猟驚瀬3i懸謙撃]]野提出綿哨『ど珊常1躙 ξ管朧肌ぼ群翻 event Such reasonable accommodations will be provided at no costto the individual NOTlF:CACiON:Esla audiencia sera cclnducida en elidioma lngles Servicios the traduccion no seran disponibles en la audiencia y usted sera 欝累僻'器 ξ:酬 f″思T:離昭;:蹴剛:鰐『裾鴨駅n hSC°mu前 ∽donesde eOe evemo POね vσ『aga su γ。10 mdud∝(syon Si ou pa pa10 anglё tanptt vini avё k yon intё pめ t pou pa16 pou‐ou 6.B.17.a Packet Pg. 201 Attachment: CESD20210002415 Padilla and Nunez (28297 : CESD20210002415 Padilla and Nunez) INSttR 630■632 0R 6■67 PGCLERK OF ttHE CIRCUIT COUR丁REC S35.50 3■07 RECORDED 8/26/2022AND COMPttROLLER, COLLIER 3:26 PM PAGESCOUNttY FLORIDA BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDヘ Pedtioner, ` ‐ ノhm為 ∵¨ RespOndents. ノ/‐″ THIS CAUSE came befFthe COde Enforcernent Bcard(the`BOard")For public hearing o■March 24, 魃 a踏器鳳鐵龍路器濡話ξ惚霊網肥淵翼蹴剰熙訓 !' COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENTCODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD Case Noo CESD20210002415 Prior to the hearing, Respondents entered into a L榔時ず ,剛 "h硼 "“Nッノ IM喝雄壷°Wnersご帳SubieCt""●仙e 2馬 S"1∬ 朧洲 lli螺 ∫“ 能d″巌Ⅲ禦摯 gり ∝面nd mail ad p囃睫,h“MdW Padma / 、 which is attachcd hereto as Exhibit "A." The 4]に恥p呻讐“22削社も,脚蹴』評:踊 iぬ蜆潔器盤路理P芭習じ1.鷺 :棚】掘蹴 F'S∝dms Ю020∝BrXO,Ю Ю20∝取収すィ】 }° 2°6ooxα )hぬ e db覇 ng Stipulation is adopted and incorporated into this Or{er, alid'$Ospondents are ordered to comply. 5. The violations have not been abated as ofthe date ofthis hearing. y'f- :coNcLUsIoNsoFLAW t . ..j . --l Based upon rhe foregoing fac6, the Board matces rhe foltowing Conclusions otldi,r, / j " _,-l i I . All notices werc propcrly and timely issued, and thc Board has jurisdiction pursuant to Ct'aper 162, Florida Staturcs, and Chapter 2, Article IX, Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collier Counry,rfhrida:, 2. The preponderance of the evidence shows that violations of Collier County Land Development Code, Ord. No. 04-41, as amended Sections 10.02.06(BXlXa), 10.02.06(8)(l[e), and 10.02.06(BXl)(e)(i), do exist, and that Respondents committed, and were responsible for maintaining or atlowing the violations to continue as ofthe date ofthis hearing. ORDER Page I of3 6.B.17.a Packet Pg. 202 Attachment: CESD20210002415 Padilla and Nunez (28297 : CESD20210002415 Padilla and Nunez) OR 6■67 PG 3■08 Based upon the foregoing Findings ofFact and Conclusions oflaw, and pursuanl to thc authority g.anted in Chaptcr 162, Floride Sratutcs, and Ch6prcr 2, Articlc lX, €odc of Laws and Ordinances ofCollier County, Florida, it is hercby OR-DERED that: A. Rcspondents are found guilty of violating Collier County Land Developmen! Code, Ord. No. 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(8)( I Xa), 10.02.06(B)( l)(e), and 10.02.06(B)( I )(eXi). B. Respondents must abate all violations by: l. ceasinq and dcsist thc use ofthe unpennined garage conversion into additional living space and poyeriirg pffany unpermilted electricity from the circuit brealer until alterarions are legally permined &fd iflspodtcd or or bcforc M$ch 27. 2022, or s llne of$200.00 per dry will be imposed for each day Jh6 vlglations remain thercafter: and f\ 2. obraining aJ)/required Collier County Building Permit(s). Demolition Permir, lnspections, and Cenificatr6fComf,lcriory'Occupancy to kccp the garage alrcration or retum il !o a pcrmitrcd stalc on or bcforc M!fr3,2022, or . llnc of 3150.00 pcr d.y will be imposed for each day rhe violadons remain th€rc6rler. C. IfRespondents failto comp$ $ith this Order. Collier County may.bate rhe violations using any method to bring the violations into corpdliance and may use the assistance of thc Collier Counry Sheriffs Office to enfolce thc provisions ofthi( Order,otrd all costs ofabat€ment shall be assessed to Respondenrs. D. Respondents arc ordered to pay $eratilnal cosls for lhe prosecution ofthis case in the amount of $59.28 on or b.for€ Aprll 23,2022. 淵∫]臨 61oo o Deputy C“ STATE OF FLORIDA , BOARD COUNTY OF COLLIER 騰冨茅:l場躍ザ¨h°mず出翡熙 ‐ Board Collier County. Florida. iE Personally Known OR E Produc.d ldcnrificalion Type of ldenaificaiion Produced イ/: Kaufman, Chair of ‐State ofFlorida 藤瘍蠍 (PHnt7TyP,m→=PAYMENT OF FINES: Any fines ordered !o be paid pursunt to this Ordcr may bc p.id at thc Collicr Counry Codc Enforcemcnt Dcp.nmenr. 2800 Nonh Horscshoe Drivc, Naples, FL 34104, Phone: (239) 252-2440, websitel www.colliercountvfl.gov. Any releasc oflien or conlirmation ofcompliance or confirmarion ofthe sarisfacrion ofthe obligations ofthis Order may also be obtoined al this locstion. AEEE/\I!. Any aggrieved party mey appeal s final order ofrhe Board lo the Circuit Court wilhin thiny (30) days oflhe execulion ofthe Order appealed. Arl appeal shall not bc a hea.ing de novo, but shall be limited to appellate review ofthe rccord cre3ted wirhin rhe original hearing. It is rhe responsibiliry ofthe appesling pany to oblsin a rranscribed record ofthe hcaring from rhe Clerk ofCourts. Filing an sppeal will not automatically sr.y this Order. Page 2 of3 6.B.17.a Packet Pg. 203 Attachment: CESD20210002415 Padilla and Nunez (28297 : CESD20210002415 Padilla and Nunez) OR 6■67 PG 3■09 CER■FICATE OF SERVICE ll譜 r話賢I踊棚∬営鷲:ぽ :概 J∬S脳機hり ∝n“讚by.号 ∴ダJЮ:MdVa Padna and Na“ra Pagc 3 of3 /ジ '/ ⊆ 'ォぐ、ン、 ,71■、 6.B.17.a Packet Pg. 204 Attachment: CESD20210002415 Padilla and Nunez (28297 : CESD20210002415 Padilla and Nunez) ★・ ' OR 6■67 Pc 3■■0 +奮十 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISS10NERS Col∥er County,Flonda Petitloner. VS MELVA PAD:LLA AND NAZAR:A ANGELICA NUNEZ RespOndent(S), 石 Case No CESD20210002415 シ/ST:PULAT:ONrAGREEttENT Bator€ ma, the into this stipulation and (CaSe)number cESD202 )nt wnh Co∥ier counly as to the reso!ulon of Notices of Vlolation in reference 10 1ated the 15・ day of」uly,2021 認ltte∥鷺ξ灘胤品鼈聴星ごt梶麗亀 representatlve attend the Heanng: ′´ /「麒ば憾膊 i甲じ博榊讐郡忘巽照鮒織1鮒:Padilla, on behalf of Melva Padilla and Nazaria Angelica Nunez, enlers Entorcement Board. lf it is not approved, the case may it is strongly recommended thal the respondent or sha∥be C"stina Pere2,Supervisor for Michao1 0sson。,Director Code Enforcement Division 3a平 33 h) The vi。latお nζ iotきなおlhe referencedi Molation are accurale and I stipulate lo their exislence, and that I have been properly notified pursuarit.to,Fforida StaMe 162. THEREFORE, it is agreed between the parties tMt tfre,Respondent shatl; I1) Pay operaiional costs in the amount of $5928 iD6s0€d in the prosecution of this case within 30 davs ol lhis hearinddays ofthis hearing. .' -, .2) Abale all violations by: C€asing and desist the jrsd gt'the unpermitted garage conversion into addilional living space and powering off any unpermrttg&electricity from the circuil breaker until alterations are l€gally permitted and insp€cted within S' O;rys of this hearing or a fine of $2OO.OO per day wilt be imposed unlil ihe violation is abated. ,, 3) Obtaining all required Collier County Building Permit(s)/or Fnolition Permit, inspections, and Certificate of Completion/Occupancy to keep the garagg Stqration or return it to a permined state within 60 days of this hearing or a fine of $150.00/per lay wilt be imposed until the 4) Respondenl must notify Code Enforcement within 24 hou6 of abgtement of the violation and request the lnvestigator perform a site inspeclion to confirm comdfancg. (2. hou6 notc€ 3h.r bs by phon6 o. l.r atrd ma,al6 during $a sortwa€l ll il. uoldio.r .. abar.d 2a hours pnor 6 a Slturd.y. Sun<tey o. reqJhoLoay ricn tne mricat'o. hult De md●on Ⅲ … day th●t●面3 SabⅢy Sunday o7“ "“ !hO day) ~ィオ |5) That if the Respondent fails lo abate the violation the County may aUie tryi viotation using any m€thod to bring the violation into compliance and may use the assidanc€ otthe Collier County Sheriffs OmceA enforce the provisions of this agreement aM all costs6f Representative (sign) Date REV 3‐29‐16 6.B.17.a Packet Pg. 205 Attachment: CESD20210002415 Padilla and Nunez (28297 : CESD20210002415 Padilla and Nunez) COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD COLLIER COUNrY BOARD OF CO…COMMISSIONERS,Petitioner VS PADILLA,MELVA NAZARIA ANGELICA NLNEZ.Defendant(s) CEB CASE NO.CESD20210002415 AFFIDAVIT OF PARTIAL COMPLIANCE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER BEFORE ME,thc underslgned authoHty,pcrsona∥y appeared Delicia Puisc.Codc Enforccmcnt Ofrlcial fOr the Codc Enforcelnent Board ofColicr County,who aner bcing ttlly swom,dcposcs and says: l That on March 24,2022,thc Codc Enforccment Board hcld a hcaHng and issucd an Ordcrin thc abovc―stylCd matter and statcd that Dcfendant(s)Was tO abate all violations as statcd in thc Ordcr rccordcd in thc public rccords ofCollier County,FloHda h OR B∞kttPGH,et scq 2 That the respondcnt did contact thc invcstigator 3 That a rc‐inspcction was pcrfo111lCd On〔Ap●14,2022] 4 ■at the re‐inspcction(S)rcvealcd that thc corrcct市 e action in PART I ordcrcd by thc Codc Enforccment Board was in compliancc by[CcaSing and dcsist thc usc ofthc unpcl.=littcd garagc convcrsion into additional living SPaCe and powc●ng ofFany unpermittcd clcctricity 6Ю m thc circuit brcakcrl FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT DATED this[4th〕day Of【Ap●ll,2022_ STATE OF FLORIDA COIINTY OF COLLIER ヽ T%宙 F叩駅 dt“ibl詭お “ meby mm¨JZphySIttp“"¨c∝。山 ne ndaH茄 oL ,20」by DelたねPJse 蕪 HELEN BuCHlttON Cm―On'HH 105119 ExplM May15 2025 螂い岬い …(Print/TypeJSlamp Commissioned Name of Norary Public) Pcnonally known i (Signature of Notary Public) 6.B.17.a Packet Pg. 206 Attachment: CESD20210002415 Padilla and Nunez (28297 : CESD20210002415 Padilla and Nunez) COLLEER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT CODE ENFORCEMttNT BOARD Case No.―CESD2021111102415 BOARD OF COIINTY COMMISS10NE間 COLLER COUNTY,FLORIDA, Petlticller, VS. M●iV8 P3diⅡユand N8zarin Angelic●Nune2, RespOndents. ORDER OF THE CODE ENTORCEMENT BOARI) TI{IS CAUSE came before the Code Enforcement Board (the "Board") for public hcaring on August 25, 2022, upon Respondents' Motion for Extension ofTime, and the Board having heard testimony under oath, received evidence and heard argument respectiye to all appropriate matters, hereby issues its Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Order ofthe Board as follows: FINDINGS OF FACT l. On March 24, 2022, Respondens, Melvs Prdillc .nd Nrzrrir Angelice Nunez were found to havc violated Collier County Land Development Code Ord. No. 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(BX I )(a). 10.02.06(8)( I )(e), and 10.02.06(BX I Xe)(i) on the subject property located at 8322 Valiant Dr-, Naples, FL 34104, Folio No. 56324013549 (Leeal Dcscription: MADISON PARK PHASE TWO LOT 135), hercinafter r€ferred to as the "Property"), in the following particulars; Alterstions to gsnge rres without c required Collier County building permit. 2. On the same date as above, the Board issued an Order ordering Respondents to abate the violations on or before May 23, 2022, or a fine of St50.00 per day would be assessed for each day the violarions remained thereafter (A copy ofthe Order is recorded at OR BK 6144 PG 3296). 3. Respondents timely filed this Motion for Extension ofTime. 4. Respondents, having been notified of the date of hearing on said motion by certified mail, posring and/or pesonal service, had Melva Padilla appear at the public hearing to provide testimony in support of the extension of time. 5. Operational costs in the amount of $59.28 have been incurred by Petitioner in the prosecution of this case were timely paid. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW Based upor the foregoing facts, the Board makes the following Conclusions ofLaw; l. All notices were properly and timely issued, and the Board has jurisdiction pursuant to Chapter 162, Florida Starutes, aod Chapter 2, Article IX, Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collier County, Florida. 2. The Board extended the time to comply for 60 days. ORDER Page l oF2 6.B.17.a Packet Pg. 207 Attachment: CESD20210002415 Padilla and Nunez (28297 : CESD20210002415 Padilla and Nunez) Based upon the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions ofLaw. and pursuant to the authority granted in Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 2. Articlc IX, Codc ofLaws and Ordinanccs ofCollier County, Florida, it is hereby ORDERED that: A. Respondents' Motion for Extension of Time is DENIED. B. Respondents are gmnred a Contifluance until Octobcr 24, 2022. C. All panies shall bc re-noticed for the subsequent hearing date on or sbout October 27,2022. BOARD STATE OF FLORIDA) COIJNTY OF COLLIER) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me by meani of^d ptrysical prcscnce or E) online rotarization, DONE AND ORDERED thls 25' OrV ot A ,qr 5,t . 2022 rt Colller Courty, Florids. Typc of Identification Produced 誡息 y81詰織驚■度L「2022.by Ro“I KauFmaL Chi「Ofhetttk ,r County Codc Enrorccmcnta ftersonally Known OR D Produced Id€'ntification 蕪灘撒Commissioncd Name of Notary Public ( Prinr/Type/Stamp) PAYMENT OF FINES: Any fines ordered to bc paid pursuant to this Order may be paid at thc Collicr County Code Enforccmcnt Department, 2800 North Horseshoe Drive, Naples, FL 34104. Phonc: (239) 252-22140, Website: www.colliercountyfl.gov. Any release of lien or confirmation ofcompliance or confirmation ofthe satisfaction offte obligations ofthis Order may also be obtained at this location. APPEAL: Any aggrievcd party may appeal a final order ofthe Board to the Circuit Coun *'irhin thiny(30)daysof the execution ofthe Order appcalcd. An appeal shall not be a hearing de novo, but shall bc limitcd to appellarc rs ic* ofthe record ueated within the original hearing. It is the responsibility ofthe appealing pany ro obtain a transcribed record ofthe hearing from the Clerk ofCouns. Filing an Appeal will not automatically stay the Board's Ordcr. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERIFYぬ a a true and correa copy of血ヽ ORDERhasttensemb7ml讐 and Na2arla Angehca Nuncz.8322 VJiant Dr.Naplcs,FL 34104,ths ユ day 2022 Signature of Notary-Public - Srate of Florida Code Enforcement Olficial Page 2 of 2/6.B.17.a Packet Pg. 208 Attachment: CESD20210002415 Padilla and Nunez (28297 : CESD20210002415 Padilla and Nunez) COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEⅣEヽT CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD Case No.―CESD20210002415 BOARD OF COT'NTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, Petltloner, vs. Melva Prdilla end Nazarir Angelicr Nunez, Respondent(s)./ORDER OF THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARI) THIS CAUSE came before the Code Enforcement Board (the "Board") for public hearing on November 18, 2022, upon the P€titioner's Motion for Imposition ofFines/Liens, and the Board, having heard testimony under oath, received evidence and heard argument respective to all appropriate maners, hereupon issues its Findings of Fact, Conclusions ofLaw, and Order ofthe Board as follows: FINDINGS OF FACT l. On March 24,2022, the Code Enforcement Board issued a Findings ofFact, Conclusions ofLaw, and Order. The Respondent(s), Mclva P.dilh snd Nazrris Angelica Nunez, was(were) found guilty of violating Collier County Land Development Code, Ordinance No. 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(8)( I )(a), 10.02.06(8)( lXe) and 10.02.06(BX t Xe)(i), on the subject property located at 8322 VALIANT DR., Naples, FL 34104, Folio No. 56324013549 (Legal Description: MADISON PARK PHASE TWO LOT 135), hereinafter referred to as the "Property," in the following particulars: Alterations to garrg€ ir€r without a required Collier County building p€rmit. 2. The Board's written Order of M arch 24,2022, ordered Respondcnt(s) to abate the violation(s) on or before May 23,2022, or a fine ofS 150.00 per day would be assessed for each day the violation(s) remained thereafter until abatement was confirmed. (A copy ofthe Order is recorded at OR BK 6167, PAGE 3107, for more information). 3. Respondent(s), having been notified ofthe date of hearing by cenified mail, posting and,/or personal service, did have Melva Padilla appear who testified as to the additional abatement cffons already completed and those being diligently pursued by Respondent(s). 4. Prior operaiional costs previously incurred by Petitioner in the prosecution of this case in the amount of 559.28 have been paid. 5. Operational costs in the amount of559.63 have been incurred by Petitioner for this hearing. 6. The violation(s) has (have) not been fully abated as ofthe date of this hearing but based on Respondenr(s)' abatement effons demonstrated thus far Pctitioner has stipulared to a continuance of its Motion herein for a time cenain. CONCLUSIONS OT LAW Based upon the foregoing facts, the Board makes the following Conclusions ofLaw: l. All notices were properly and timely issued, and the Board hasjurisdiction pursuant to Chapt€r 162, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 2, Anicle IX, Code ofLaws and Ordinances ofCollier County, Florid-a. Page I of 2 6.B.17.a Packet Pg. 209 Attachment: CESD20210002415 Padilla and Nunez (28297 : CESD20210002415 Padilla and Nunez) 2. Pursuant to Section 162.09, Florida Slatutes, Petitioner has demonstrated by the preponderance of the evidence that accrued fines and costs could now lawfully be imposed agairst Respondent(s), however, that in the best interests of administrative efficiency Respondent(s)'s abatement efforts to date warrant a continuance ofPetitioner's Motion for a reasonable period of time for Respondent(s) to complete abatement efforts to come into full compliance. ORDER Based upon the foregoing Fiodings ofFact and Conclusions ofLaw, and pursuant to the authority granted in Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Chapter 2, Anicle IX, Code ofLaws and Ordirances ofCollier County, Florida, it is hereby ORDERED that: A. Petitioner's Motion for Imposition ofFines{-iens is CONTINUED until the Board's next regularly scheduled meeting on or about lanutry 26,2023. B. Daily fines of$150.00 per day shall continue to accrue until abatement has been confirmed by a Collier County Code Enforcement lnyestigator. t\is 2S azy o1']\fu)jAfu1{_. Board Collier County, Florida. {'Personally fnown OR D Produced Identification Type of Identification Produced 2022, by Robert Ikufinan, Chair ofthe Collier County Code Enforcement 蕪B爛鶉Commissioned Name of Notary Public (Print/Type/Stamp) PAYMENT OF FINES: Any fines ordered to be paid pursuant to this Order may be paid ar rhe Collier County Code Enforcement Department,2800 Nonh Horseshoe Drive, Naples, FL 34104, Phone; (239) 252-2440. Website: www.colliercounwfl.gov. Any release oflien or confirmation ofcompliance or confirmation ofthe satisfaction ofthe obligations of this Order may also bc obtained at this location. APPEAL: Any aggrieved party may appeal a final order ofthe Board to rhe Circuir Court wirhin thirry (30) days of the execution ofthe Order appealed. An appeal shall not be a hearing de novo, but shall be limited to appellate review ofthe record created within the original hearing. It is the responsibiliry ofthe appealirg pany to obtain a transcribed record ofthe hearing from the clerk ofcouns. Filing an appeal will not automaiically stay this order. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY that a truc and corrcct copy Ofthis oRDER has bccn scnt by U S Man to:Mclva Padilla and N,ウ ,7ia Angelica Nuncz,8322 VALIANT DR,Naples,FL 34104,on Aょぅじし "ら 24`じ夕 ,2022 DONE AND oRDERED this /614 ary ot Lgir*!b{-, 2022 ar couier county, Ftorida. STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER The foregoing instrumert was acknowledged before me by means ofq physical Presence or D online notarizarion, CODE EhlFORCEMENT BOARD Signature of Notary Public - State ofFlorida Page 2 of 2 6.B.17.a Packet Pg. 210 Attachment: CESD20210002415 Padilla and Nunez (28297 : CESD20210002415 Padilla and Nunez) Code Enforcement Meeting: 03/28/24 09:00 AM Department: Code Enforcement Board and Special Magistrate , Category: Code Enforcement Meeting Item Prepared By: Helen Buchillon SCHEDULED Initiator: Thomas Iandimarino Sponsors: CODE ENFORCEMENT ACTION ITEM (ID # 28354) DOC ID: 28354 Updated: 3/14/2024 9:27 AM by Helen Buchillon Page 1 Nomination for Board Chairman and Vice-Chairman CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: FOLIO NO: PROPERTY ADDRESS: 9.1 Packet Pg. 211