02/20/2024 Draft February 20, 2024
1
MINUTES OF THE COLLIER COUNTY
EAST OF 951 AD HOC COMMITTEE MEETING
Naples, Florida, February 20, 2024
LET IT BE REMEMBERED, the Collier County East of 951 in and for the County of Collier,
having conducted business herein, met on this date at 7:00 PM in REGULAR SESSION at the
Heritage Bay Government Services Center, 15450 Collier Blvd., Naples, Florida, with the
following members present:
Mark Teaters, Sr., Chairman
Robert Raines, Vice Chair
Michael Ramsey
Christina Aguilera (via Zoom)
Rae Ann Burton (alternate)
Kim Ellis
Aaron Zwiefel (not present)
February 20, 2024
2
1. Pledge of Allegiance: Led by Parker Klopf.
2. Roll Call: Quorum established.
3. Approval of the Minutes from Previous Meeting:
Mark Teaters: Motion made to approve the minutes; Robert Raines seconds.
Approved unanimously.
4. Approval of the Agenda:
Amendment to the agenda–Adding Justin Damiano, Director, Government Affairs,
Comcast, as Item 5.B.
Kim Ellis: Approval of the agenda with the amendment; Mark Teaters seconds.
Approved unanimously.
Comment from Kim Ellis about the 911 calls that are being dropped. Parker will give
Kim the packet, presentation, and minutes to her. An amendment to the cell phone
towers is in process.
5. (A) Greater Naples Fire District Presentation and Discussion
Nolan Sapp, Fire Chief
Retiring as Fire Chief
Cell towers plague the fire department as well; it is amazing how much the
technology drives what we do in the fire service – reduces response time; gives us
information; real time data; and information that needs to be discreet such as medical
information which must be transmitted through the MDP’s; constantly looking for
ways to enhance.
Transitioning away from Verizon to AT&T
The fire district owns the tower at Station 71 – which we lease out. To drive to the
Estates, the average time is 18-20 minutes.
A new fire station is being built at the corner of DeSota Blvd S in Golden Gate
Estates and it is being built for the future with growth in mind. In an average year, the
call volume is about 18-19 hundred calls in a five-mile driving radius of that
intersection and will continue to grow as the population moves to the east. The
potential for wildfire to occur is more dramatic today.
All the apparatus has been purchased out of impact fees –the engine, water tenders,
brush truck, EMS/ambulance, etc. The station to be built is about $12M and breaking
ground will be soon.
Staff will be about 12 total.
A cell tower is slated to go on site which will provide enhanced communication for
the county but the community as well.
We will have fuel tank capability which will reduce the trips coming back into town
or at least to Wilson Blvd.
February 20, 2024
3
Emergency Management will be able to work out of the station for instances such as a
hurricane; move our resources further inland to protect them from flood/water
damage.
Once this station is built, people that live in the Estates may now be in the five-mile
range requirement for homeowners’ insurance.
We continue to look for an avenue to have fire hydrants in the Estates and that has
been for the last 20 years; due to national security (terrorism – putting poison in the
system) we have not been successful. We need a secure hydrant system. Putting in a
loop is not cost conducive.
We use forestry helicopters. The Sheriff’s Department has a helicopter, a Huey from
the Vietnam War era. They outfitted it with a Bambi bucket. Their source of water is
any canal that has water deep enough.
Brush trucks carry between 100 to 700 gallons of water.
Mark Teaters: To help us with our program, can you get us a list of where water is
available for the fire department? This will help when we move forward with a hydrant
system. (Yes – will send to Parker.)
We are currently in the middle of heart attack season when all the tourists come
down; then we roll in to the brush fire season; then hurricane season.
The Forestry is enhancing and adding some additional equipment. The new station
has a new brush truck and is ready for an inspection on Monday.
We purchased land in the White Lake area to build a training center, logistics and
fleet facility. That is slated for the near future.
A roadway that the county is proposing will run off Blackburn Road down below the
landfill and will hook up to Wilson Blvd.
We're excited for the county to build a bridge on 10th off Everglades Blvd. between
DeSoto and Everglades. That will increase our response time significantly.
There's also talk that the county commissioners are going to Washington DC to
petition the Department of Transportation to open the Everglades Blvd. exchange so
that the residents out there can have access on and off the Interstate. This will give
them another avenue for escape during the wildfire and additional relief from traffic
conditions.
There were five bridges approved; Forestry bought two new helicopters but those are
subject to anywhere in the state.
District-wide we have a lot of projects going on; 1,512 square miles, which is the
largest special fire district in the state of Florida. We run 16 stations – 17 with the new
station ready to be built. We average 30-31,000 calls a year out of those 16 stations;
68% medical call load –unlike north Collier that runs at 85-90%. The remainder is
commercial brush fire, interstate incidents, etc.
We are fighting with the state of Florida to revamp the way we are reimbursed for the
station on I-75 at the 63-mile marker. They reimbursed them to a certain threshold of
$1.4 million. That does not cover the cost of that station today. In June of 2027, they
are not going to pay us anything – stop funding – and we must come up with the
funding mechanism.
We are not allowed to go north or south of the interstate into the National Park
because you must have certain credentials to step foot in there; you can’t use any
February 20, 2024
4
machinery; there is no tax base to pay for that station. They expect Greater Naples to
pay a $2M annual budget. We are trying to get that changed.
Wildland firefighting is a unique craft, and it all must be run through what's called the
National Wildfire Coordinating Group, which is housed in Boise, ID, and the local
agency that has jurisdiction by statute; overall wildland fires is the Florida Forestry
Service. They govern a lot of the regulations, and the National Wildfire Coordinating
Group in conjunction with the Florida Forestry Service put in strict guidelines on
what courses you must take and the ability for you to teach those courses is highly
restricted and governed, for various reasons, mostly because of liability.
When we had the last large wildfire incident, we had fire departments that wanted to
come into the area but because they were not trained in wildland firefighting, they
could not assist due to liability. We must pull from agencies throughout the state, and
we pull some from South Carolina and Georgia that meet the criteria. I had over 200
firefighters in the district fighting wildfires spread across 80 different fire agencies. I
had trucks here from Jacksonville, Manatee County, Orange County, a couple from
the East Coast, but Miami-Dade, which is like the premier department, are not
wildfire trained. It takes a particular skill set and the proper protective equipment to
do what we do.
The Golden Gate Estates is the largest Wildland-Urban Interface community in
Collier; Lehigh is second.
We just hired a public information officer named Tiffany and she is going to be
instrumental in getting the word out to people. She's going to be visiting meetings like
this in the future. We're going to strive to enhance our social media.
Every morning we get our daily weather forecast from Forestry. You'd be surprised
how much weather plays in fire behavior. It addresses the relative humidity for the
day, the wind speed which is measured at a 20 foot level, not at the ground level,
thermal layering, inversions and where the clouds and everything mixes. It is
forecasted in six different locations and we pay attention. Plus you have the National
Park Service that does the same thing.
(B) Comcast, Justin Damiano, Director of Government Affairs
PowerPoint Presentation provided.
Mark Teaters asked Mr. Damiano for another map of the service area currently
covered, but with a deeper dive of our entire area that we are responsible for and find
out how much they cover. There are areas that are not covered.
6. Public Comment:
Mark Teaters: Next month the Sheriff is going to be here, the New Director for Code
Enforcement; the Superintendent of Schools; President of the Optima Foundation. That
will be on March 19.
Future topics remaining: Storm water, economic development, parks and recreation,
libraries, life of the landfill, affordable housing; re-visit transportation.
Kim Ellis made a motion to move the topic of Affordable Housing to the April 16
meeting – asking Comm. Kowal to speak; Robert Raines seconds.
Approved unanimously.
February 20, 2024
5
7. Adjourn
Robert Raines made a motion to adjourn the meeting; Kim Ellis seconds.
Approved unanimously.
The meeting was adjourned at 8:45 p.m.
Collier County East of 951 Ad Hoc Advisory Committee
_______________________________________
Mark Teaters, Sr., Chairman
These minutes were approved by the Chairman of the East of 951 Committee
on _______________________________, (check one) as submitted _______ or as
amended ______.