CCLAAC Agenda 01/03/2024AGENDA
CONSERVATION COLLIER
LAND ACQUISITION ADVISORY COMMITTEE
January 3, 2024, 1:00 P.M.
Commission Boardroom
W. Harmon Turner Building (Bldg F), Third Floor
All interested parties are invited to attend, and to register to speak. Individuals who would like to participate in
person must complete and submit a speaker form. Members of the public who would like to participate
remotely should register HERE to complete the online speaker registration form. Remote participation is
provided as a courtesy and is at the user's risk. The County is not responsible for technical issues. Individuals
who register online will receive an email in advance of the public hearing detailing how they can participate
remotely in this meeting. For additional information about the meeting, please call 239-252-2961 or email
conservationcollier@colliercountyfl.gov
1. Roll Call
A. Approval of CCLAAC members attending the meeting remotely
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Approval of December 6, 2023, Meeting Minutes
4. Old Business
A. Acquisition Updates
Current Acquisition Status Report is updated monthly in advance of CCLAAC
meeting and provided as part of meeting packet. The report is posted online under
Acquisition News at: www.conservationcollier.com
B. Purchase Agreements
No purchase agreements are currently ready for review as of printing of this
agenda. Other purchase agreements ready before the meeting will be posted
online and presented to the committee:
https://www.colliercountyfl.gov/qovernment/public-services/divisions/conservation-
collier/agendas-minutes/2023-meeting-packets
C. Caracara Land Management Plan update
5. New Business
A. Railhead Scrub Preserve Land Management Plan 10-year update
B. Conservation Collier Ordinance Revisions
C. Cycle 12B Initial Screening Criteria (ISC)
1. NGGE TPMA — McIntosh Family Trust
2. Marco Island TPMA — Ramoski Trust
D. Cycle 12B Initial Criteria Screening Report (ICSR)
1. Sarry Trust
2. Marco Island TPMA
a. HK Investment
b. Van Cleef
6. Subcommittee Reports
A. Lands Evaluation & Management —Chair, Ron Clark— last meeting September 21, 2023
B. Outreach — Chair, Brittany Patterson -Weber -last meeting January 20, 2023
C. Ordinance, Policy & Rules— Chair, Michele Lenhard -last meeting December 18, 2023
7. Coordinator Communications
A. BCC Items Related to Conservation Collier
1. Previously Heard 12/12/23 (all approved on consent)
a. North Belle Meade Preserve FWC Funding Assistance Application
b. Dr. Robert H. Gore III Preserve Final Management Plan
2. Upcoming 1/9/24
a. Florida Wildlife Corridor Foundation MOU
b. Ordinance 2002-63 revisions
c. Pepper Ranch Funding Assistance application
B. Miscellaneous
8. Chair and Committee Member Comments
9. Public Comments
10. Staff Comments
11. Next Meeting February 7, 2024
12. Adjourn
. ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■
Committee Members: Please notify Summer Araque at 239-252-2979 no later than noon Friday,
December 29, 2023, if you cannot attend this meeting or if you have a conflict and will abstain from
voting on an agenda topic.
December 6, 2023
MINUTES OF THE CONSERVATION COLLIER LAND ACQUISITION
ADVISORY COMMITTEE MEETING
Naples, Florida, December 6, 2023
LET IT BE REMEMBERED, the Conservation Collier Land Acquisition Advisory
Committee in and for the County of Collier, having conducted business herein, met on this
date at 1:00 P.M. in REGULAR SESSION at Administrative Building "F", 3'
Floor, Collier County Government Complex Naples, Florida with the following
members present:
CHAIR: Michele Lenhard
VICE CHAIR: Brittany Patterson -Weber
Gary Bromley
Ron Clark
Karyn Allman
Rhys Watkins
John Courtright
Corey McCloskey (Excused)
Nick Pearson
ALSO PRESENT: Summer Araque, Conservation Collier Program Coordinator
Sally Ashkar, Assistant County Attorney
Melissa Hennig, Environmental Specialist I
Jaime Cook, Development Review Division Director
December 6, 2023
1. Roll Call
Chair Lenhard called the meeting to order at 1:OOP.M. Roll call was taken and a quorum was established
with 8 Members present.
A. Approval of CCLAAC Members attending the meeting remotely
All Members were present in the Board room.
2. Approval of Agenda
Mr. Bromley moved to approve the Agenda subject to hearing Item S.D after Item S.A. Second by M.s.
Allman. Carried unanimously 8 — 0.
3. Approval of November 1, 2023 Meeting Minutes
Mr. Bromley moved to approve the minutes of the November 1, 2023 meeting as presented. Second by
Ms. Allman. Carried unanimously 8 — 0.
4. Old Business
A. Acquisition Updates - Current Acquisition Status report updated monthly in advance of CCLAAC
meeting provided as part of meeting packet and under Acquisition News at
www.conservationcollier.com for information purposes. The report will be updated monthly (last
updated November 27, 2023) including parcels the County has acquired to date, offers made by the
County, pending acquisitions and those properties where the owner withdrew the application.
Ms. Araque provided the following updates:
Cycle 10 — 47 properties acquired totaling 454 acres.
Cycle I IA — 8 properties acquired totaling 17.62 acres.
Cycle I IB — 9 properties pending closing totaling 118 acres.
Cycle 12A — Due diligence phase for properties.
Multi Parcel Projects Target Letters Distribution
• Panther Walk Preserve — 1st batch November; 2nd batch January 2024.
• Robert H. Gore, III — February/March 2024.
• Winchester Head - April/May 2024.
Based on a market study, offers for the property are included with the solicitation letter.
Cycle 12B — 20 applications received for 30 parcels totaling 768 acres. 16 move forward to the ICSR
phase with ranking by the Committee slated for March of 2024 and Board of County Commissioners
review in April of 2024.
B. Purchase Agreements
Ms. Araque provided the following Purchase and Sale agreement for consideration - (The Committee
approved the Purchase and Sale Agreements listed below in one motion but were listed separately for
recording purposes).
1. Kleinberger Rev. Trust — Dr. Robert H. Gore III Preserve
Mr. Bromley moved to recommend the Board of County Commissioners approve the Purchase
and Sale Agreement for the Kleinberger Rev. Trust Property. Second by Ms. Patterson -Weber.
Carried unanimously 8 — 0.
5. New Business
2
December 6, 2023
A. Budget Presentation
Chris Johnson, Director, Corporate Financial & Management Services presented the PowerPoint
"Conservation Collier Budget" and provided an update on the programs budget for information
purposes. The presentation included an overview of the Conservation Collier Adopted FY24
Budgets, changes made to the FY24 Adopted Budgets from the FY24 Tentative Budgets, and pending
Budget Amendments. He highlighted the following:
FY 2024 Adopted Budget
• Acquisition Fund 1061 Operating Budget (excluding Land Acquisitions) - $800,000.
• Acquisition Fund 1061 Capital Outlay (Land Acquisitions) - $26,908,600
• Maintenance Fund 1062 Operating Budget - $1,454,900
• Maintenance Fund 1062 Endowment - $10,091,900
• Capital Project Fund 1063 Operating Budget - $675,000
Changes to Adopted Budget from Tentative Budget
• A decrease in millage rate, resulting in an ad valorem tax revenue decrease of $3,577,600
• Reduced Capital Outlay (Land Acquisitions) by $17,525,900
• Reduced transfer from Acquisition Fund to Maintenance Fund by $849,800
• New transfers to General Fund and Unincorporated Fund out of Fund 1061 totaling $14,980,900
• No changes to Capital Project Fund
• Reduced Maintenance Endowment by $39,395,200
• New transfers to General Fund and Water Pollution Control Fund out of Fund 1062 totaling
$38,545,400
• Budget Amendments for December 12, 2023, BCC meeting
• Carry forward in Fund 1061 of $8,800,000, resulting in an increased Land Acquisition Capital
Outlay budget of $35,649,400.
• Carry forward in Fund 1062 of $515,000 resulting in and increased Maintenance Endowment of
$10,606,900.
D. Ordinance Revisions Overview
Jamie Cook, Director, Development Review Division presented the PowerPoint "Update on
Proposed Ordinance Changes — December 6, 2023" for information purposes. She noted the BCC
directed Staff to propose revisions to the Ordinance governing the Program and recommend avenues to
expedite the acquisition process. The proposed changes were prepared by the County Attorney's office
and Staff which include.
• Combine Section 6 "Acquisition Fund" and Section 7 "Maintenance Fund" into one Section
"Funding of the Conservation Collier Program"
• BCC will establish millage rate annually (not to exceed .25 mills)
• BCC will set the percentage of revenues each Fund will receive each fiscal year (Removes the
75%/25% split)
• Properties will be added to Active Acquisition List after the Initial Screening Report is reviewed
by CCLAAC.
• Properties will be evaluated as they are received instead of holding for a ranking list with a
group of properties.
• Forwarding any properties meeting the Program's 5 screening criteria directly to the BCC for
consideration.
• Eliminating the requirement for a Conservation Collier Land Acquisition Advisory Committee
recommendation for Purchase and Sales Agreements.
3
December 6, 2023
• Acquisition through fee -simple or conservation easements
• If conservation easement is acquired, development rights would be negotiated
• For Rural Fringe Mixed Use District Sending Lands, the parties may negotiate a Transfer of
Development Rights to Receiving Lands.
• Non consideration of properties designated as Sending lands in the Rural Lands Stewardship
Areas.
• Properties must meet 3 initial screening criteria to be evaluated
• If a property only meets 2 screening criteria, a vote of at least 5 Committee Members be
required to move the property forward in the process.
• Interim Management Plans will be completed within 6 months of acquisition
• The tax revenue will sunset in FY2031 (instead of "after 10 years")
During Committee discussion, the following was noted:
• The County Attorney's office drafted the changes and due to timing, the Ordinance, Policy and
Rules (OPR) Subcommittee did not review or provide recommendations on the proposed
changes.
• Ms. Ashkar clarified the Ordinance change process. Required to request Board approval to an
ordinance change prior to ordinance change.
• The ordinance changes are anticipated to be heard by the BCC in January 2024 and it may be
beneficial to convene a Subcommittee meeting to provide comments on the proposed changes.
• The concept for streamlining the process is favorable, but concern for those properties meeting
the threshold of 5 screening criteria being forwarded directly to the BCC. There may be other
issues impacting the decision on whether to purchase the property.
Speaker
Brad Cornell, Audubon of Southwest Florida supports streamlining the acquisition process but
recommended a review by the OPR Subcommittee would be beneficial given public input could be
provided by those who have closely followed the program over the past 20 years. Additionally, a
review of the screening criteria may be advantageous to determine any revisions necessary given some
are general in nature and could be refined to help meet the goals of the program.
B. Cycle 12B Initial Screening Criteria (ISC)
1. Panther Walk Preserve TPMA - Gonzalez
Ms. Hennig presented the "Initial Screening Criteria Form" for the above referenced parcel. It is
in NGGE Unit 44, west of Everglades Blvd. N and south off 56th Ave. NE; just south of Panther
Walk Preserve project area within the Panther Walk Preserve TPMA and 1.14 acres in size.
It satisfies 3 of the Initial Screening Criteria.
Ms. Patterson -Weber moved to move the parcel forward in the acquisition process and for Staff
to prepare an Initial Criteria Screening Report. Second by Mr. Clark. Carried unanimously 8 —
0.
2. Marco Island TMPA
a. HK Investment
Ms. Hennig presented the "Initial Screening Criteria Form" for the above referenced parcel. It
is just south of San Marco Rd off S. Barfield Dr. - 363 S. Barfield Dr., Marco Island, FL 34145;
Marco Island TPMA and 0.38 acres in size.
It satisfies 3 of the Initial Screening Criteria.
El
December 6, 2023
The item was combined with Item 5.B.2.b (Van Cleefi given they are within the Target Mailing
Protection Area.
b. Van Cleef
Ms. Hennig presented the "Initial Screening Criteria Form" for the above referenced parcel. It
is just south of San Marco Rd off S. Barfield Dr. - 383 S. Barfield Dr., Marco Island, FL 34145;
Marco Island TPMA and 0.43 acres in size.
It satisfies 2 of the Initial Screening Criteria.
Committee discussion occurred with some expressing concern on the potential expenditure of
funds given the small size of the parcels, proximity to developed lands and the whether the
Gopher Tortoises and Burrowing Owls will survive on the parcels over the long term.
Others noted the species have resided in the area a long time and will continue to thrive on the
small parcels as they adapt to urban environments. Although there is adequate habitat on the
sites, they will tend to move between parcels during daily activities.
Speaker
Brad Cornell, Audubon of Southwest Florida noted the species can survive on smaller
parcels in urban environments evidenced by their long term survival in the area. The parcels on
Marco Island are elevated and the species survived Hurricane Ian while there was decimation in
other areas of the County such as Wiggins Pass due to storm surge. The habitat could be
enhanced on these properties and potentially adjacent lands with the assistance of private
owners providing plant habitat.
Mr. Bromley moved to move the HKInvestment and Van Cleef parcels forward in the
acquisition process and for Staff to prepare an Initial Criteria Screening Report. Second by
Mr. Courtright. Carried unanimously 8 — 0.
3. Dr. Robert H. Gore III Preserve TPMA
a. Parraga
Ms. Hennig presented the "Initial Screening Criteria Form" for the above referenced parcel. It
is in NGGE Unit 91, south of 34th Ave SE, off Desoto Blvd. S; north of Dr. Robert H. Gore
Preserve project area and 2.73 acres in size.
It satisfies 3 of the Initial Screening Criteria.
The vote on this item was combined with Item 5.B.3.b (Seepersad) given they are within the
Target Mailing Protection Area.
b. Seepersad
Ms. Hennig presented the "Initial Screening Criteria Form" for the above referenced parcel. It
is in NGGE Unit 91, north off 36th Ave SE, west of Desoto Blvd. S; just north of Dr. Robert H.
Gore Preserve project area and 1.14 acres in size.
It satisfies 3 of the Initial Screening Criteria.
Mr. Watkins moved to move the Parraga and Seepersad parcels forward in the acquisition
process and for Staff to prepare an Initial Criteria Screening Report. Second by Ms. Allman.
Carried unanimously 8 — 0.
4. Sarry Trust
December 6, 2023
Ms. Hennig presented the "Initial Screening Criteria Form" for the above referenced parcel. It is
approximately'/2 mile east of North Belle Meade Preserve, north off Blackburn Rd., just north of I-
75; RFMUD-NRPA-NBMO-Sending and 13.1 acres in size.
It satisfies 4 of the Initial Screening Criteria.
During Committee discussion it was noted the property is designated as Sending Lands in the
RFMUD (Rural Fringe Mixed Use District) surrounded by other properties where development
credits have been severed which remain in private ownership.
Speaker
Brad Cornell, Audubon of Southwest Florida supported acquisition of the parcel given it is
surrounded by sending lands with severed development credits. Based on BCC consideration for
the upcoming Ordinance change, there is an opportunity to acquire the lots with severed
development credits which would enhance the RFMUD program as currently there is no entity
willing to acquire these lands so the owner cannot sever the 41h credit. The area is close to other
Conservation lands.
Mr. Courtright moved to move the parcel forward in the acquisition process and for Staff to
prepare an Initial Criteria Screening Report. Second by Ms. Patterson -Weber. Carried
unanimously 8 — 0.
5. Bonawitz Trust
Ms. Hennig presented the "Initial Screening Criteria Form" for the above referenced parcel. It is
approximately 385 ft. west of Smith Road and 1.5 miles northwest of Conservation Collier's North
Belle Meade Preserve — RFMUD — NBMO — Sending and 5 acres in size.
It satisfies 3 of the Initial Screening Criteria.
During Committee discussion it was noted the parcel is only 5 acres in size, designated as Sending
Lands in the RFMUD and isolated from other conservation parcels.
Mr. Courtright moved to move the parcel forward in the acquisition process and for Staff to
prepare an Initial Criteria Screening Report. Without a second, the motion failed.
C. Cycle 12B Initial Criteria Screening Report (ICSR)
1. Wildcat Acres
Ms. Hennig presented the "Conservation Collier Land Acquisition Program Initial Criteria Screening
Report for Wildcat Acres." It is just south of the Hendry County line and just east of the Lee County
line off SR 82, 70 acres in size, received a score of 276 out of 400 and has an assessed value of
$420,463.
6. Subcommittee Reports
A. Lands Evaluation & Management — Chair, Ron Clark — Meeting September 21, 2023
Mr. Clark reported the next Subcommittee meeting will be held in March of 2024.
B. Outreach — Chair, Brittany Patterson -Weber —last meeting January 20, 2023
No update necessary.
C. Ordinance Policy and Rules — Chair, Michele Lenhard - last meeting June 1, 2022
No update necessary.
0
December 6, 2023
7. Coordinator Communications
A. Upcoming Member Vacancies
Ms. Araque reported"
• Some Members terms are expiring the second week of February, 2024.
• Assignment to the Committee requires BCC approval and current members with terms expiring
interested in re -applying should undertake the necessary measures to be considered.
• The application process is also available to any interested individual meeting the qualifications
to be seated on the Committee.
B. BCC Items Related to Conservation Collier
1. Previously Heard
a. 11/14 — Purchase Agreements — Dredge Management (Shell Island Preserve), Williams
(Nancy Payton Preserve), Bailey (WH), Mooney (WH) - APPROVED
2. Upcoming
a. 12/12 — Ordinance Revision
b. 12/12 — North Belle Meade Preserve FWC Funding Assistance Application
c. 12/12 — Florida Wildlife Corridor Foundation M
Brad Cornell, Audubon of the Southwest Florida requested a copy of the MOU for
information purposes.
d. 12/12 — Dr. Robert H. Gore III Preserve Final Management Plan
C. Conservation Collier Updates (as needed)
None
8. Chair/Committee Member Comments
Mr. Watkins recognized Staff efforts administering the program.
Chair Lenhard requested Staff to determine the number of recent applications meeting the 5 screening
criteria given the BCC's proposal for changes in the Ordinance.
9. Public General Comments
None
10. Staff Comments
None
13. Next Meeting — January 3, 2024
There being no further business for the good of the County, the meeting was adjourned by order of
the chair at 3:10P.M.
Conservation Collier Land Acquisition Advisory Committee
Michele Lenhard, Chair
December 6, 2023
These minutes approved by the Committee on as presented or as amended
Conservation Collier Cycle 10, 11, and 12 Property Status Updated December 26, 2023
SUMMARY PAGE
ACQUISITION SUMMARY OF ALL CYCLE 10, 11A, 1113, and 12A PROPERTIES
Appraised or
Purchase Price
Total number of
Total Acres
Estimate
or Estimated
Value*
Value*
properties
ACQUIRED PROPERTIES
517.60
$6,859,295
$6,720,750
63
(CYCLE 10, 11A, 11B, and 12A)
PROPERTIES PENDING ACQUISITION*
284.56
$14,859,800F$14,612,195
18
(CYCLE 10, 11A, 11B, and 12A)
*Estimated value used in calculations until Purchase Agreements are signed by Seller and scheduled for Conservation Collier
Land Acquisition Advisory Committee meeting
Conservation Collier Cycle 10, 11, and 12 Property Status Updated December 26, 2023
CYCLE 10 AAL APPROVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ON JANUARY 25, 2022
CYCLE 10 ACQUIRED PROPERTIES
Property Name
Preserve
Size (ac)
Appraised Value
Closing Amount
Acquisition Status
Aguilar, Jorge
Panther Walk
1.14
$40,000
$40,000
Closed 2/13/23
Preserve
Arias, Eladio
Dr. Robert H. Gore
3.16
$63,000
$52,900
Closed 9/22/23
III Preserve
Arias, Eladio
Dr. Robert H. Gore
3.78
$66,000
$63,200
Closed 9/22/23
III Preserve
Arnay, Henrietta
Panther Walk
1.14
$30,000
$30,000
Closed 6/16/23
Preserve
Bailey, Charles E
Dr. Robert H. Gore
1.14
$25,000
$25,000
Closed 9/20/23
III Preserve
Behnke, Lois
Panther Walk
1.14
$57,000
$57,000
Closed 6/16/23
Preserve
Blocker, Brian
Pepper Ranch
24.50
$220,000
$220,000
Closed 7/7/23
Preserve
Burns, Sandra
Panther Walk
1.14
$30,000
$30,000
Closed 1/30/23
Preserve
Caberera, Mercedes
Red Maple Swamp
9.16
$114,500
$114,500
Closed 3/21/22
Preserve
Castillo, Jose
Red Maple Swamp
5.41
$89,300
$84,835
Closed 7/14/23
Preserve
Charles, Paulette
Dr. Robert H. Gore
1.14
$25,100
$22,500
Closed 6/30/23
III Preserve
Craparo, Stephen
Dr. Robert H. Gore
1.64
$44,000
$39,600
Closed 9/15/23
III Preserve
D & J Investors
Panther Walk
1.14
$40,000
$40,000
Closed 6/9/23
Preserve
Dessing, Carol A.
Winchester Head
1.14
$18,810
$18,810
Closed 3/28/22
Preserve
Fesser, Ivan
Winchester Head
2.27
$56,800
$53,960
Closed 9/1/23
Preserve
Fleming, Albert
Dr. Robert H. Gore
1.64
$39,000
$37,500
Closed 9/15/23
III Preserve
Gonzalez, Isabel
Panther Walk
1.14
$50,000
$50,000
Closed 6/16/22
Preserve
Gorman, Herman and Alice
Winchester Head
1.14
$18,810
$18,810
Closed 9/26/22
Preserve
Grossman, Barry
Panther Walk
2.73
$63,000
$63,000
Closed 6/16/23
Preserve
Guerra, Sigrid
Red Maple Swamp
1.14
$20,500
$20,500
Closed 7/7/23
Preserve
Hackmann, Charles
Panther Walk
2.73
$70,000
$63,000
Closed 12/15/23
Preserve
Hofmann, Adelaida
Dr. Robert H. Gore
1.59
$36,000
$36,000
Closed 2/27/23
III Preserve
Hussey Trust
North Belle Meade
256.00
$2,072,500
$2,072,500
Closed 11/14/22
Preserve
Johnson, Tim R
Panther Walk
1.14
$30,000
$30,000
Closed 1/30/23
Preserve
Joyce, David
Panther Walk
2.27
$52,000
$52,000
Closed 6/9/23
Preserve
Joyce, Martin and Elizabeth
Panther Walk
2.27
$61,300
$55,170
Closed 8/17/23
Preserve
Martinez, Abel Chavez
Red Maple Swamp
2.27
$40,900
$36,000
Closed 8/17/23
Preserve
Conservation Collier Cycle 10, 11, and 12 Property Status Updated December 26, 2023
CYCLE 10 AAL APPROVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ON JANUARY 25, 2022
CYCLE 10 ACQUIRED PROPERTIES, cont'd
Property Name
Preserve
Size (ac)
Appraised Value
Closing Amount
Acquisition Status
McLaughlin Trust, Geraldine
Red Maple Swamp
4.61
$57,625
$57,625
Closed 3/21/22
Preserve
Meyer Trust
Panther Walk
1.59
$72,000
$72,000
Closed 1/30/23
Preserve
Moody Crawford, Jim H
Pepper Ranch
59.79
$505,000
$505,000
Closed 9/22/23
Preserve
Pena, John
Panther Walk
2.27
$52,000
$52,000
Closed 2/13/23
Preserve
Popp, Joe
Rivers Road
19.40
$630,000
$630,000
Closed 9/26/22
Preserve
Quevedo, Odalys
Dr. Robert H. Gore
1.14
$28,000
$26,600
Closed 7/14/23
III Preserve
Rodriguez (f.k.a. Lopez), Terri
Panther Walk
1.59
$42,900
$38,610
Closed 8/17/23
Preserve
Ruben Trust
Winchester Head
1.59
$39,800
$39,800
Closed 7/7/23
Preserve
Rudnick, Carol -Donation
Dr. Robert H. Gore
1.59
N/A
N/A
Closed 6/30/22
III Preserve
Salgado, Julio
Panther Walk
2.73
$73,700
$70,110
Closed 8/17/23
Preserve
Sanchez, PS & NE
Panther Walk
2.73
$63,000
$63,000
Closed 1/30/23
Preserve
Selvig, Maribeth - Donation
Panther Walk
1.14
N/A
N/A
Closed 9/26/22
Preserve
Setser, Carrie, Larry, and Ruby
Red Maple Swamp
5.00
$62,500
$62,500
Closed 3/21/22
Preserve
Sparkman Tamara Gibson
Panther Walk
1.14
$33,000
$33,000
Closed 7/14/23
Preserve
Thommen, William F
Panther Walk
5.00
$100,000
$100,000
Closed 1/30/23
Preserve
Toro, Michael
Winchester Head
1.59
$39,800
$35,820
Closed 6/30/23
Preserve
Trofatter, Frederick
Winchester Head
1.14
$28,000
$25,650
Closed 9/7/23
Preserve
Varney, Gail
Red Maple Swamp
1.14
$14,250
$14,250
Closed 2/14/22
Preserve
Wright, David
Panther Walk
1.14
$30,000
$30,000
Closed 1/30/23
Preserve
Zani, Paul
Dr. Robert H. Gore
2.27
$49,900
$49,900
Closed 7/7/23
III Preserve
Zhuang, Joseph
Panther Walk
2.73
$63,000
$63,000
Closed 1/30/23
Preserve
TOTAL CYCLE 10 ACQUIRED PROPERTIES
456.42
$5,457,995
$5,395,650
Total number of properties = 48
CYCLE 10 PROPERTIES PENDING ACQUISITION
Property Name
Preserve
Size (ac)
Appraised Value
Purchase Price
Acquisition Status
Higdon Trust, Garey D
Winchester Head
Preserve
1.59
$39,800
$35,820
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on
9/26/23; closing pending
TOTAL CYCLE 10 PROPERTIES PENDING ACQUISITION
1.59
$39,800
$35,820
Total number of properties = 1
Conservation Collier Cycle 10, 11, and 12 Property Status Updated December 26, 2023
CYCLE 10 AAL APPROVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ON JANUARY 25, 2022
CYCLE 10 A -LIST PROPERTIES THAT WILL NOT BE ACQUIRED
Property Name
Preserve
Size (ac)
Appraised Value
Offer Amount
Acquisition Status
Amaranth Trust, Forrest G
N/A
71.16
N/A
N/A
Property withdrawn
Anderson, Charles
Panther Walk
2.27
$64,000
$64,000
Offer not accepted
Preserve
Anderson, Charles
Panther Walk
1.14
N/A
N/A
Sold to another
Preserve
Argay, Lorraine ID
Dr. Robert H. Gore
Dr.
$81,000
$81,000
Offer not accepted
III Preserve
Arnold, Emily
Pepper Ranch
5.00
N/A
N/A
Property withdrawn
Preserve
Arnold, Vanette
Panther Walk
1.14
$30,000
$30,000
Offer not accepted
Preserve
Big Hammock - Area I (Barron
Pepper Ranch
257.3
$900,000
$900,000
Offer not accepted
Collier Partnership)
Preserve
Casasierra Realty LLC
Winchester Head
1.14
$25,650
$25,650
Property withdrawn 3/23/23
Preserve
Cedeno, Kenneth
Dr. Robert H. Gore
2.81
$56,000
$56,000
Offer not accepted
III Preserve
Dahche, Ahmand
Panther Walk
5.00
$130,000
$130,000
Offer not accepted
Preserve
D'Angelo, Eugene
Dr. Robert H. Gore
5.00
$100,000
$100,000
Offer not accepted
III Preserve
Erjavec, Eugene
Rivers Road
4.92
$200,000
$200,000
Offer not accepted
Preserve
Eschuk, Shari
Rivers Road
4.78
$180,000
$180,000
Offer not accepted
Preserve
Fernandez, Erik
Winchester Head
1.59
$39,800
$39,800
Offer not accepted
Preserve
Fischer Trust, Addison
Marco Island
0.63
N/A
N/A
Property withdrawn
Naughton, Veronica
Panther Walk
2.73
N/A
N/A
Sold to another
Preserve
Macrina, Kathleen
Panther Walk
1.14
N/A
N/A
Sold to another
Preserve
Magdalener, Josef
Shell Island
18.73
N/A
N/A
Property withdrawn
Preserve
Moylan, Paul E
Panther Walk
2.73
$63,000
$63,000
Offer not accepted
Preserve
Ortega, Gerardo
Panther Walk
1.14
$30,000
$30,000
Property withdrawn
Preserve
Three Brothers
Panther Walk
2.73
$63,000
$63,000
Offer not accepted
Preserve
WISC Investment - Inlet Dr
Marco Island
0.39
$429,000
$429,000
Purchase Agreement not approved by BCC
TOTAL CYCLE 10 A -LIST PROPERTIES THAT WILL NOT BE
400.52
$2,391,450
$2,391,450
Total number of properties = 22
ACQUIRED
Conservation Collier Cycle 10, 11, and 12 Property Status
Updated December 26, 2023
CYCLE 11A AAL APPROVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ON DECEMBER 13, 2022
CYCLE 11A ACQUIRED PROPERTIES
Size (ac)
Appraised Value
Closing Amount
Berman Trust, R F
Dr. Robert H. Gore III
1.14
$30,000
$28,500
Closed 9/15/23
Preserve
Fontela, Maricel Aleu
Dr. Robert H. Gore III
1.14
$25,700
$25,700
Closed 12/8/23
Preserve
McGinnis, Patricia
Panther Walk Preserve
1.14
$45,000
$42,800
Closed 11/17/23
Perona, Barbara
Winchester Head
1.59
$39,800
$39,800
Closed 12/1/23
Preserve
Repola, Andrea
Panther Walk Preserve
1.14
$45,000
$42,800
Closed 9/15/23
Scalley, William J and Martha
Panther Walk Preserve
1.14
$45,000
$42,800
Closed 11/17/23
Scotti, Mary
North Belle Meade
8.74
$135,500
$128,700
Closed 12/1/23
Preserve
Sponseller, Robert
North Belle Meade
5.00
$90,000
$90,000
Closed 12/8/23
Preserve
Trigoura, Delsma
Dr. Robert H. Gore III
1.14
$30,000
$30,000
Closed 11/17/23
Preserve
VanCleave, Matthew
Rivers Road Preserve
0.50
$52,500
$52,500
Closed 12/8/23
Vaz, Maurice 1
Panther Walk Preserve
1.59
$57,500
$57,000
Closed 9/15/23
TOTAL CYCLE 11A ACQUIRED PROPERTIES
24.26
$596,000
$580,600
Total number of properties = 11
CYCLE 11A PROPERTIES PENDING ACQUISITION
Property Name
Preserve
Size (ac)
Appraised Value
Purchase Price
Acquisition Status
Annecy Marco LLC / Barfield
Marco Island
2.13
$3,140,000
$3,140,000
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 10/24/23;
closing scheduled for 1/5/24
Geren, Jonathan
North Belle Meade
7.84
$129,500
$129,500
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 9/12/23;
Preserve
closing scheduled for 1/12/24
Gutierrez, Michael
North Belle Meade
4.88
$85,400
$81,100
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 9/12/23;
Preserve
closing scheduled for 1/12/24
Perez Castro, Pedro
Dr. Robert H. Gore III
1.17
$29,000
$27,600
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 9/26/23;
Preserve
closing scheduled for 1/5/24
South Terra Corp
Marco Island
0.56
$1,720,000
$1,620,000
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 10/24/23;
closing scheduled for 1/5/24
TOTAL CYCLE 11A PROPERTIES PENDING ACQUISITION
16.58
$5,103,900
$4,998,200
Total number of properties = 5
CYCLE 11A A -LIST PROPERTIES THAT WILL NOT BE ACQUIRED
Size (ac)
Appraised Value
Offer Amount
Agua Colina
Marco Island
0.63
$1,120,000
$1,120,000
Purchase Agreement not approved by Board
Berman Rev Trust, R F
Panther Walk Preserve
1.17
$46,000
$43,700
No longer interested in selling
Chestnut, Diane
Marco Island
0.53
$627,500
$627,500
Offer not accepted
Colon, Donna &Patricia Mack
Dr. Robert H. Gore III
Preserve
2.27
$39,500
$37,500
Selling to another
S & B Properties of Marco LLC
Marco Island
0.50
$570,000
$570,000
Offer not accepted
Starnes, Hugh
Caracara Prairie Preserve
4.54
$250,000
$250,000
Offer not accepted
TOTAL CYCLE 11A A -LIST PROPERTIES THAT WILL NOT BE
ACQUIRED
9.64
$2,653,000
$2,648,700
Total number of properties = 6
Conservation Collier Cycle 10, 11, and 12 Property Status
Updated December 26, 2023
CYCLE 11B AAL APPROVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ON FEBRUARY 28, 2023
CYCLE 11B ACQUIRED PROPERTIES
Size (ac) Appraised Value Closing Amount
Brewer, Richard
N/A
14.78
$451,000
$405,900
Closed 12/15/23
Dibala Wood Trust
Dr. Robert H. Gore III
18.28
$275,000
$261,300
Closed 12/15/23
Preserve
Weir Trust, Celine
Dr. Robert H. Gore III
2.27
$39,500
$37,500
Closed 12/8/23
Preserve
Wilson Trust
Winchester Head
1.59
$39,800
$39,800
Closed 12/8/23
Preserve
TOTAL CYCLE 116 ACQUIRED PROPERTIES a
36.92
$805,300
$744,500
Total number of properties = 4
CYCLE 11B PROPERTIES PENDING ACQUISITION
Appraised/Estimated
Purchase
Property Name
Preserve
Size (ac)
Value
Price/Estimated Value
Acquisition Status
Bailey, Scott and Christopher
Winchester Head
1.59
$39,800
$38,500
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 11/14/23;
Preserve
closing scheduled for 1/19/24
Dredge Management Assoc LLC
Shell Island Preserve
18.73
$1,592,500
$1,512,875
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 11/14/23;
closing pending
English Trust
Pepper Ranch Preserve
59.01
$515,000
$463,500
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 9/26/23;
closing scheduled for 1/19/24
Mooney/Hankins-Colon
Winchester Head
1.59
$39,800
$39,800
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 11/14/23;
Preserve
closing scheduled for 1/26/24
Williams
ancy Payton Preserve
0.50
$60,000
$60,000
Purchase Agreement approved by BCC on 11/14/23;
closing pending
Subtotal - Properties with Board Approved Purchase
81.42
$2,247,100
$2,114,675
Subtotal number of properties = 5
Agreements
Descoteau, Donn & Donna*
Dr. Robert H. Gore III
1.14
$25,100
$25,100
Offer accepted; Purchase Agreement pending
Preserve
Relevant Radio, Inc.*
Mcllvane Marsh
10.46
$133,000
$133,000
In Negotiation
Preserve
Subtotal - Properties with Board Approval of Purchase
11.60
$158,100
$158,100
Subtotal number of properties = 2
Agreements Pending
TOTAL CYCLE 11B PROPERTIES PENDING ACQUISITION
93.02
$2,405,200
$2,272,775
Total number of properties = 7
CYCLE 11B A -LIST PROPERTIES THAT WILL NOT BE ACQUIRED
Property Name
Preserve
Size (ac)
Appraised Value
Offer Amount
Acquisition Status
Buckley Enterprises*
Nancy Payton Preserve
80.00
$640,000
$640,000
Under contract to another
Khoury
Otter Mound Preserve
0.43
N/A
N/A
Sold to another
Lie, Run He
Nancy Payton Preserve
0.50
$80,000
$80,000
Offer not accepted
Owl Hammock
N/A
7,378.00
TBD
TBD
On -hold pending State of Florida acquisition
Sit/Chew
Nancy Payton Preserve
3.00
$390,000
$390,000
Offer not accepted
Smith & Montgomery
Dr. Robert H. Gore III
Preserve
2.73
N/A
N/A
Property withdrawn
TOTAL CYCLE 11B A -LIST PROPERTIES THAT WILL NOT BE
ACQUIRED
7,464.66
$1,110,000
$1,110,000
Total number of properties = 6
* Estimated Value used in calculations until Purchase Agreement is signed by Seller and scheduled for Conservation Collier Land Acquisition Advisory Committee meeting
Conservation Collier Cycle 10,11, and 12 Property Status Updated December 26, 2023
CYCLE 12A AAL APPROVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ON OCTOBER 10, 2023
CYCLE 12A ACQUIRED PROPERTIES
Size (ac)
Appraised Value
Closing Amount
TOTAL CYCLE 12A ACQUIRED PROPERTIES
0.00
$0
$0
Total number of properties = 0
CYCLE 12A PROPERTIES PENDING ACQUISITION
Appraised/Estimated
Purchase
Property Name
Preserve
Size (ac)
Value
Price/Estimated
Acquisition Status
A & T Kleinberger Rev
Dr. Robert H. Gore
5.00
$110,000
$104,500
Offer accepted; Purchase Agreement
Trust*
III Preserve
scheduled for BCC 1/9/24
Aristizabal*
Mcllvane Marsh
5.00
$26,500
$26,500
Appraisal under review
Preserve
Murawski Trust*
North Belle Meade
4.87
$24,400
$24,400
Appraisal under review
Preserve
Symphony Properties*
N/A
150.00
$7,100,000
$7,100,000
Appraisal ordered
Volpe Trust*
North Belle Meade
8.50
$50,000
$50,000
Appraisal under review
Preserve
TOTAL CYCLE 12A PROPERTIES PENDING
173.37
$7,310,900
$7,305,400
Total number of properties = 5
ACQUISITION
CYCLE 12A A -LIST PROPERTIES THAT WILL NOT BE ACQUIRED
Size (ac)
Appraised Value
Offer Amount
TOTAL CYCLE 12A A -LIST PROPERTIES
0.00
$0
$0
Total number of properties = 0
THAT WILL NOT BE ACQUIRED
* Estimated Value used in calculations until Purchase Agreement is signed by Seller and scheduled for Conservation Collier Land
Acquisition Advisory Committee meeting
Pra
1re.q.
ire
Management Update 2024,
W01
vV'"7
Tqj M.-v -
- - - - - - - - - - -
� 7�v
71
Aa -'A sa.
. VVNir'1 Oar. 'V' � yyue.�• .Y'nJ
L•j ,. I.. y rr —
" '�.y;,� ��'. 1.5 '�,.4� Y: � ya'�'.' tit. '�•� i
Az
NO
Arl
rt raw �y A��' ,�.�.,; S 1 'F:• -
lk t� • 1'` T� • 4, � �} � } }�.� �- -;T .ram
IN
h � Y
57R
�wy
•aC n:w �
r . I : ' . 1, 1� F I - . .
V
71 IP" -I
1 -7
idiot
u; =*Cattle Ranching
Cattle have been grazed on the site since 2007 via
lease agreement
• Previous lessee: 120+ AU per 200 acres
pasture, no revenue, one annual mowing service
Current lessee: 35 AU, $7875.35 revenue,
annual mowing service
Feasibility: Lessees run cattle companies and need to be able
to make a profit on beef and stock at a higher rate than is
17
compatible for smaller sites like Caracara Prairie to make the
. . . . . . . venture profitable and worthwhile for the annual
investment/input to get calves to auction.
When applied at appropriate intensity and duration
for a site,, cattle grazing is highly effective for
achieving management goals of large grassland
sites and compatible with wildlife and habitat
conservation.
Current Management
Concerns/Compatibility at
Caracara Prairie Preserve
Despite 70% reduction
Intensive grazing in
attle spread of
Overgrazed understory
of AU in latest lease,
wetlands reduces
nuisance/exotic
impacts successful
pastures are
application of
over razed-su ort less
listed species nesting vegetation challenging
g pp
wildlife/plant species success and reduces
than they should= loss wetland habitat
of valuable acreage quality
exotics control and
increases management
costs
prescribed fire across
landscape- multiple
burns unable to
achieve objectives
Public access trail
impacts from
cattle fencing &
cow pats along
walking paths
Upcoming Management Approach'
Existing 5 year cattle lease expires in March 2024
• staff recommending against renewal for a trial period of 2-5 years r
• provide opportunity for historically overgrazed habitat to recover
• provide opportunity for exotics control without extensive seed source
spread
• monitor for improvements in nesting success for imperiled sandhi[[ crane
• rotational mowing of pastures 1-2x per year during recommended seasons
to support ground nesting species and maintain grassland features
• fuel reduction and continued habitat management through prescribed burns
• investigate opportunities for native ground cover restoration to support
wildlife and plant diversity
• Condition assessment and review within 2 years to determine
future need for reintroduction of grazing
• Staff recommend if grazing is considered for subsequent
leasing in the future, no more than 5-8 cattle be utilized
on the site per the acreage requiring management.
In -House Mowing
$1200 annually
• opportunity to apply mowing
during season to benefit wildlife
management goals of preserve
• opportunity to apply for funding
assistance through wild turkey
program to cover costs
Anticipated
Fiscal Impact A,�'
Revenue Reduction
• Reduction of $7875.35 annually for cattle lease
Consideration: 75% of revenue collected throughout
duration of lease was spent maintaining infrastructure
to support compatibility of site with cattle lease
Fencing: $20,487
Fence crossings for public visitors/repairs: $3000
4 •
Exotic Control Cost Reduction
• Anticipated reduction in
exotics control cost and
density overtime and
improved capacity to remove
exotics from site and restore
native habitat
Railhead Scrub Preserve
Land Management Plan
CONSERVATION
g'`' COLLIER
Conservation Collier Program
Collier County
2023 -2033
10 Year Plan
Table of Contents
VV4
or
k
t,
r' LAND MANAGEMENT PLAN EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ...... 3
PROPERTY DESCRIPTION...............................................4
0 LOCATION AND SITE DESCRIPTION........................................4
NATURAL RESOURCES........................................................4
1 Physical Resources...................................................4
BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES.....................................................5
9
Vegetation Communities..........................................5
Wildlife Communities...............................................6
CULTURAL RESOURCES.......................................................6
i■ MANAGEMENT PLAN....................................................7
GOALS............................................................................7
Vegetation Management.........................................7
Wildlife Management..............................................8
Public Access Management.....................................9
Resource Protection Management ........................10
ACQUISITION..................................................................12
ACQUISITION HISTORY AND PLAN UPDATES FOR RAILHEAD SCRUB
PRESERVE......................................................................12
IMPLEMENTATION AND COSTS...........................................13
Table 3: Implementation Timetable .......................13
Table 4: Projected Costs.........................................13
APPENDIX...................................................................14
APPENDIX 1: LEGAL DESCRIPTION.......................................14
APPENDIX 2: PHOTOSET- REPRESENTATIVE COMMUNITIES ......
15
APPENDIX 3: PHOTOSET- REPRESENTATIVE GROUNDCOVER ....16
APPENDIX4: PHOTOSET-NOTABLE WILDLIFE ........................17
APPENDIX 5: PHOTOSET- RESOURCE PROTECTION CONCERNS..
18
APPENDIX 6: SPECIES TABLES............................................19
Conservation Collier 2 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Land Management Plan Executive Summary
Lead Agency: Conservation Collier Program, Development Review Division, Growth
Management Department
Folios: 00143120009, 00152600002
Total Acreage: 135 Acres
Management Authority: The Conservation Collier Program manages this parcel under
authority granted by the Conservation Collier Ordinance 2002-63, as amended. Lands
acquired with Conservation Collier funds are titled to 'COLLIER COUNTY, a political
subdivision of the State of Florida, by and through its Conservation Collier Program." The
Board of County Commissioners of Collier County (BCC) established the Conservation Collier
Program to implement the program and manage acquired lands. Conservation Collier holds
management authority for the Railhead Scrub Preserve.
Designated Land Use: Preservation, restoration, and future passive public recreation.
Management activities allowed are those necessary to preserve and maintain this
environmentally sensitive land for the benefit of present and future generations.
Unique Features: Preservation of highly imperiled endemic oak scrub habitat within Collier
County, dense populations of Florida gopher tortoise, rare plant species not found elsewhere
in the County, urban large mammal populations.
Management Goals:
Vegetation: Maintain a preserve with a mosaic of high -quality flatwoods, wet prairies,
hardwood forests, and endemic scrub with minimal fragmentation and less than 10%
infestation of non-native vegetation.
Wildlife: Maintain a preserve with low -risk,
contiguous access to a diversity of high -quality
habitats by local and migratory common and
imperiled wildlife species.
Public Access: Maintain a preserve that offers
compatible, passive recreation and education
opportunities to the public while preventing
potential negative impacts to erosion -prone
scrub habitat and listed species.
Resource Protection: Maintain a preserve
without unauthorized access or activity through
implementation of designated entrances,
posted and secured preserve boundaries,
regular law enforcement monitoring, and
security enhancements that support existing
wildlife movement requirements.
Public Input Opportunities:
A public meeting to review the plan was held on
December 18, 2023 in online and in -person format
and attended by several preserve neighbors.
Feel
Preserve Aerial 2023
�°�C(JLLltlt
Figure 2. Railhead Scrub Preserve.
Conservation Collier
3 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Property Description
Location and Site Description
The Railhead Scrub Preserve is an approximately
135-acre natural area located in the northwest
corner of Collier County, south of the Railhead
-"u-E2, Industrial Park and East of Old US 41 (Section 10
Township 48 Range 25 and Section 30 Township
51 Range 27). The preserve protects some of
the last remaining endemic rosemary scrub in
- 49#1 Southwest Florida. Adjacent to the preserve is
_Y the Gulf Seminole Rail Line, industrial and
commercial developments to the west, north and
�., south, residential communities to the east, and
the Aubrey Rogers Highschool to the Southeast.
�- The current physical access to the preserve is
---------- from Old US 41 through Sun Century Road, a
--°------sh,°n'� private road.
Figure 1. Conservation Collier Preserves 2023
Natural Resources
Physical Resources
Physiography: The Railhead Scrub
physiographic province, characterized
by low elevations and poor drainage.
The landforms that make up these
coastal lowlands include coastal and
sand dune ridges and relic spits and
bars with intervening coast -parallel
valleys consisting of poorly drained
swampy areas with little recharge.
Relic coastal dune ridges are the most
prominent geographic feature in the
general vicinity of this site.
Topography: Railhead Scrub is in the
Southwestern Slope region of the
South Florida Water Management
District (SFWMD). The topography of
the area is relatively flat with an
average elevation of 15 feet above sea
level and slopes gently westward
toward the Gulf of Mexico. Surface
water percolates directly into the
uncovered ground or it collects in
natural depressions and manmade
ponds on adjacent properties.
Soils: According to the Soil Survey of
the Collier County Area 1990, soils Figure 3. Railhead Scrub Soils
Preserve lies within the Gulf Coastal Lowlands
Conservation Collier
4 Railhead Scrub Preserve
mapped at the Railhead Scrub Preserve include Satellite Fine Sand; Basinger Fine Sand;
Immokalee Fine Sand; Riviera Fine Sand, Limestone Substratum; Urban Land Holopaw
Basinger Complex; and Boca, Riviera, Limestone Substratum and Copeland Fine Sand,
Depressional. Satellite Fine Sand units are situated on low-lying coastal ridges and
correspond to the Xeric Uplands. Basinger and Riviera Fine Sands are hydric soils typical of
slightly depressional drainage -ways with poorly defined outlets such as flats and sloughs.
Immokalee Fine Sand units are associated with pine flatwoods communities.
Hydrology/Water Management: Near the surface, the aquifer is highly permeable and the
groundwater flows toward the west. Groundwater levels have gone down during the recent
decades due to drainage on a regional scale and water management for development
purposes. This trend may be very difficult to control and will gradually reduce the extent
of the preserve that floods during the summer months and reduce the duration the preserve
wetlands are flooded during the year.
Climate: The average annual temperature for the coastal portion of Collier County is
approximately 750 Fahrenheit, warmest in July and August. Two-thirds of the annual rainfall
occurs in the wet season from May to October. Thunderstorms are frequent during the wet
season occurring every two out of three days between June and September. The hurricane
season extends from June through November with peak activity occurring in September and
October when ocean temperatures are highest.
Biological Resources
Vegetation Communities
Table 1. Vegetation Communities, Acreage, % Cover
Railhead Scrub Plant Communities and Cover
FLCC Community
Acreage
0/0Representative
Species Common Name
Cover
Full Species Name Can Be Found in Table #
Sand -live oak, Chapman's oak, Florida
rosemary, Florida slash pine, saw palmetto,
Oak Scrub
51.3
38.0%
hog plum, Coastalplain goldenaster, prickly
pear, Southern wiregrass, cardinal airplant,
deer lichen
Florida slash pine, saw palmetto, rusty
Scrubby Flatwoods
34.7
25.7%
lyonia, tarflower, wild pennyroyal, Southern
wiregrass
Mesic Flatwoods
19.3
14.3%
Florida slash pine, saw palmetto, cabbage
palm, Southern wiregrass, broomsedge
Wet Prairie
9.6
7.1%
Bushy bluestem, broomsedge, Florida slash
pine, blue maidencane, yellow -eyed grass
Florida slash pine, cabbage palm, wax
Wet Flatwoods
9.4
7.0%
myrtle, saw palmetto, live oak, red root,
maidencane, dollarweed
Mowed Grass
1.7
1.3%
Mixed grasses and forbs in maintained
clearings
Mixed Wetland
4.3
o
3.2 /o
Live oak, laurel oak, cabbage palm, myrsine,
Hardwoods
dollarweed, milkwort
Cypress
2.7
2 0%
Bald cypress, cabbage palm, dahoon holly,
myrsine, swamp fern, tillandsia spp.
Slash Pine Swamp
1.0
o
0.8 /o
Florida slash pine, bald cypress, myrsine,
Forest
wax myrtle, dahoon holly
Ditch
0.4
0.3%
Stormwater management
Shrub and
0.3
o
0.2 /o
Carolina willow, grapevine, cabbage palm,
Brushland
saw palmetto, Florida slash pine, laurel oak
Bare Soil
0.1
0.1%
N/A
Conservation Collier 5 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Four hundred nine (497) plant species have been
recorded at Railhead Scrub Preserve
(Appendix 2). Of these 497 species,
385 (77.4%) are native to the site
and 112 are exotic (22.5%). 6
species are considered Imperiled or
very rare/restricted according to
Florida Natural Areas Inventory
(FNAI) while 13 species are
considered state endangered or
threatened.
II" k9 a; Slas Pl-S...pF.- Wildlife Communities
L° -t ;i „ Wet Prelrie
Y,Railhead Scrub Preserve supports a
significant population of upland
dependent wildlife species. Wildlife
4 sightings include observations by
Conservation Collier staff, remote
camera studies, and data collected
through partnership with Florida
Gulf Coast University FGCU
' rrk: research students and faculty.
Wildlife species observed utilizing
- the preserve are listed in Appendix
6. servations of wildlife tracks
and remote camera photos indicate
wildlife species move regularly
0 230 500 1,000 1,500 2.000 Feet 2,500 3,000 3,500 4,000 4,500 between the three separately
N CONSERVATION fenced parcels of the preserve,
Railhead Scrub Preserve Land Cover �� COLLIER
A crossing private property and field
fencing along the way. Tracks are
Figure 4. Railhead Scrub Preserve Land Cover routinely observed of Florida black
bear with cubs as well as adult
bobcats with kittens travelling through the preserve, as well as photos collected of new
white-tailed deer fawns indicating these species likely use the preserve or immediate
surrounding area for denning and\or raising young. Florida gopher tortoise tracks observed
between the North and South units of the preserve indicate preserve tortoises use seasonal
burrows throughout the separately fenced units and travel beneath the fencing to reach
them.
Rare scrub habitat like the type found within Railhead Scrub Preserve can provide habitat
for a diversity of rare and endemic species that specialize in scrub habitat such as the Florida
scrub lizard, Eastern Indigo snake, Florida scrub jay. Staff will continue to seek out
partnerships and research opportunities to monitor for the presence of these species as well
as other federally and state -imperiled species.
Cultural Resources
Archaeological Resources: There are no known archaeological "finds" on this site. The
property is not within an area of historical and archaeological probability, and no historical
or archaeological sites appear to be present in the property.
The County will notify the Division of Historical Resources immediately if evidence is found
to suggest any archaeological or historic resources are present at the Railhead Scrub
Preserve. If any artifacts are observed on -site, staff shall cordon off the area, and a
Conservation Collier
6 Railhead Scrub Preserve
professional survey and assessment shall be instituted. The archaeologist shall prepare a
report outlining results of the assessments and issue recommendations to County staff
about management of any sites discovered, per provisions of the Land Development Code
Section 2.2.25. This report shall be sent to the Division of Historical Resources. The County
shall cooperate fully with direction from the Division of Historical Resources on the
protection and management of archaeological and historical resources. The management
of these resources will comply with the provisions of Chapter 267, Florida Statutes,
specifically Sections 267.061 2 (a) and (b). The collection of artifacts or the disturbance of
archaeological and historic sites within the Railhead Scrub Preserve is prohibited unless
prior authorization has been obtained from the Collier County Board of County
Commissioners and the Department of State, Division of Historical Resources.
Management Plan
Goals
Vegetation Management
Goal: Maintain a preserve with a mosaic of high -quality flatwoods, wet prairies, hardwood
forests, and endemic scrub with minimal fragmentation and less than 10% infestation of
non-native vegetation.
Invasive Plant Removal: A list of exotic plant species within the preserve is located in
Appendix 6. Initial exotics removal projects in the early 2000s targeted species ranked
within Category I and II on the FISC List of Invasive Plant Species including control of exotic
melaleuca (Meiaieuca quinquenervia) and old-world climbing fern (Lygodium microphyiium)
from preserve wetlands, and downy rose -myrtle (Rhodomyrtus tomentose), earleaf acacia
(Acacia auricuiiformis), and Brazilian pepper (Schinus terebinthifoiia) from preserve
uplands. Management of exotics will continue in maintenance phase with regular mechanical
and herbicidal treatments of the preserve to enhance restoration of native plant species
diversity. Measures will be taken to work with adjacent property owners to reduce seed and
spore source of exotics along the preserve boundary.
Native Plant Restoration: Railhead Scrub Preserve protects some of the last remaining local
genetics of endemic scrub and upland species in Collier County. In an effort to support plant
diversity on site and preservation of endemic scrub species genetics, Conservation Collier
partnered with the Naples Botanical Garden in 2021 to initiate a multi -year Scrub
Restoration and Seed Collection project to research the specific diversity and needs of the
site, collect plant material for conservation seed -banking as well as in -situ growing trials for
eventual replanting at the site to restore areas of habitat lost to historic illegal off -road
vehicle access. Collections occur throughout the year for foundational species that offer
initial soil stabilization and encourage regrowth of bare soil areas through the natural
seedbank. This project is phased to include initial collections and growth trials, followed by
restoration planting on -site. In addition to native plantings and restoration, efforts will be
made to repair the effects of rutting and elevation changes to the site as a result of illegal
vehicle access that alter the hydrology of the scrub and plant species found within the area
of historic impact.
Prescribed Fire and Mechanical Reduction: Railhead Scrub Preserve is located within the
Urban lands of North Naples. Plant communities and wildlife within the preserve are fire -
dependent for survival and prescribed fire applied by trained personnel is the most effective
and cost-efficient management tool for preserving the rare plant communities at this site.
Conservation Collier 7 Railhead Scrub Preserve
The urban location of this preserve and proximity to smoke -sensitive areas requires
additional coordination, planning, and adjacent landowner education to apply fire within the
managed units of the preserve. Mechanical reduction of heavy fuels as a result of historic
fire suppression, installation of small acreage defensible burn unit fire lines, and boundary
line clearing will be carried out to assist with the application of fire at the site. Trained fire
personnel along with interagency partners will conduct small acreage prescribed burns at
the site in accordance with the regulations and authorizations set forth by the Florida Forest
Service.
Hydrologic Restoration
Natural hydrology plays a critical role in defining plant and animal species that persist within
the preserve. Alterations in water table levels, unintentional ponding, and introduction of
novel sources of water flow or loss to the site as a result of surrounding development and
land use changes can pose detrimental effects to imperiled burrowing species like the Florida
gopher tortoise, and rare endemic scrub plants that rely on specific water conditions to
flourish. Water management at the site should seek to preserve natural conditions that have
defined this imperiled scrub habitat to support its persistence and implement infrastructure
accordingly.
Wildlife Management
Goal: Maintain a preserve with low -risk, contiguous
access to a diversity of high -quality habitats by local
and migratory common and imperiled wildlife species.
Habitat Improvement: Railhead Scrub Preserve
supports a large diversity of wildlife species due to the
presence of rare scrub habitat, xeric and wetland soils,
and a matrix of wetland and upland plant communities
throughout. The preserve also sustains isolated
pockets of rare scrub that could serve as future
stopover habitat to promote range expansion of scrub
endemic species travelling between remnant habitat in
central Florida and the Rookery Bay National Estuarine
Research Reserve. The preserve will be managed to
support wildlife populations through the protection and
enhancement of forage availability and quality, denning
and nesting habitat, historic hydroperiods, parcel
connectivity and habitat access, and the reduction of
negative impacts resulting from incompatible use of the
site.
connectivity ana Movement: i ne preserve proviaes Figure 5. Railhead Scrub Preserve Habitat
urban refugia for large and small mammals, birds,
reptiles, amphibians, and insects. Increasing
development, land use changes surrounding this site, future transportation development
projects, fencing, light and sound disturbance can impact the imperiled and common species
that rely on the preserve and alter wildlife movement or activity within the site. Efforts will
be taken to reduce land use change impacts to the preserve in the coming years including
heightened security and enforcement of non -sanctioned activities, wildlife -friendly fencing
installation, preservation of existing wildlife corridors through infrastructure enhancements
like underpasses, culverts, and crossings, and positioning public use trails in areas that limit
Conservation Collier 8 Railhead Scrub Preserve
soil erosion and listed species impacts.
Wildlife Mortality Reduction: Plans for
an extension of the existing Veteran's
Memorial Boulevard from the Audrey
Rogers High School west to US 41 are
included in the Collier MPO 2045 Long
Range Transportation Plan. This
roadway extension is set to bisect the
northern and southern parcels of the
Railhead Scrub Preserve which
currently provide continuous habitat
access for wildlife through undeveloped
oak scrub community. Fencing in
conjunction with a wildlife underpass,
suitable for large mammals like white-
tailed deer and Florida black bear with
a raised shelf design for wet season
inundation is recommended to be
incorporated into the design plans for
the Veteran's Memorial Blvd extension
to preserve the connectivity for wildlife
between preserve parcels and
significantly reduce wildlife -collision
risks to the public utilizing the road
expansion area. Adjacent to the
western preserve boundary, and within
the footprint of the planned roadway
extension project is the Gulf Seminole
Rail Line. In conjunction with a
vehicular railway crossing to
accommodate the road expansion
project, infrastructure to avoid mortality of state -imperiled Florida gopher tortoise and other
wildlife travelling between the northern and southern parcels of the preserve via the rail
crossing should be considered and implemented.
Figure 6. Conceptual Footprint -Veteran's Memorial Blvd Extension
Monitorina: Conservation Collier staff deploy a network of remote cameras to monitor the
site for wildlife utilization and threats to natural resource protection like illegal offroad
vehicle access. Staff partner with research institutions such as the Florida Gulf Coast
University and Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission Research Institute to conduct
regular monitoring for imperiled species at the site. Wildlife Surveys for common and
migratory species will continue to be carried out by preserve staff on a regular basis.
Baseline monitoring with cameras and track surveys will be conducted to assist with
planning for future impact reduction to wildlife in light of planned transportation
infrastructure development. Monitoring for wildlife at the preserve will continue throughout
construction and post -construction to assess for and respond to any future, unanticipated
impacts.
Public Access Management
Goal: Maintain a preserve that offers compatible, passive recreation and education
opportunities to the public while preventing potential negative impacts to erosion -prone
scrub habitat and listed species.
Conservation Collier 9 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Recreation Opportunities: Conservation Collier preserves provide nature -based recreation
opportunities to the community where compatible with resource protection goals for
individual sites. Currently without a suitable site to provide to public infrastructure such as
a parking lot or sidewalk access, Railhead Scrub Preserve public access is compatible with
pre -approved staff -led small group educational tours and researcher access with a permit.
Following partnership or acquisition of a location suitable for public parking development
and preserve boundary access, Railhead Scrub Preserve may be compatible with low -impact
nature -based activities such as hiking, wildlife viewing, nature photography, education
tours, and research. Large group events or sports activities are deemed incompatible with
the resource protection goals within the preserve. Public access infrastructure will be
incorporated only within areas of the preserve deemed less sensitive to erosion, without
listed species impacts, and compatible with the natural resource management goals of the
property.
Transportation: The Veteran's Memorial Blvd Extension transportation project and
construction of the Aubrey Rogers High School located 1/4 mile to the east of the preserve
boundary offer opportunities to incorporate enhanced public access to the future
management plan of the site. In partnership with the Collier County Public Schools, a future
parking area with limited spaces designated preserve access use will be provided once
roadway construction is complete. Once complete, sidewalk access along the Veteran's
Memorial Boulevard Extension will provide greater feasibility for foot traffic access to the
site.
Amenity Installation and Enhancement:
Future public access enhancements will be
completed once construction of the roadway
extension and parking area are constructed
and may include a trail network, designated
entrance gate and maintenance access
infrastructure, pedestrian fence crossings,
educational kiosk, entrance sign, educational
signage, benches, and shade structures.
Areas of planned trail that cross over
sensitive scrub soils with Florida rosemary
and imperiled Florida gopher tortoise
burrows may incorporate raised boardwalk -
style design to reduce erosion impacts from
pedestrian access. Raised trail designs will
aim to mitigate negative impacts to ungulate
access to the site, impacts to burrowing and
listed scrub species and be compatible with
the prescribed fire management goals at the
preserve.
Resource Protection Management
Goal: Maintain a preserve without
unauthorized access or activity through
implementation of designated
entrances, posted and secured preserve Figure 7. Conceptual Public Access
boundaries, regular law enforcement
monitoring, and security enhancements
requirements.
that support existing wildlife movement
Conservation Collier
10 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Illegal Trespass and Dumping: Railhead Scrub Preserve today protects lands in a region of
the county that has historically experienced heavy pressure from off -road vehicle access,
illegal nighttime gathering, swimming, and unsanctioned target practicing with firearms.
County ordinance 2011-38 regulates and specifies legal utilization of the Railhead Scrub
Preserve lands and provides an enforcement mechanism to prevent illegal trespass,
property damage, off -road vehicle trespass, illegal fires, dumping, illegal use of firearms,
harm to the plant, wildlife, and natural resources at the site. Security camera monitoring,
no trespassing sign posting, boundary fence line maintenance and repairs, and on -site
inspections are carried out regularly by Conservation Collier staff working in partnership
with the Collier County Sheriff's Office and Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation
Commission to reduce, prevent, and curtail historic illegal access at the site from continuing.
Illegal trespass activities at the site pose significant risk to the preservation of rare and
sensitive natural resources that the preserve was purchased to protect.
Infrastructure Damage: Infrastructure damage repair continues to be one of the staff -
intensive maintenance efforts at the site. Historically, law enforcement capabilities at the
site have been hampered by lack of off -road vehicles to navigate the scrub sugar sand for
enforcement, lack of clarity on land ownership and enforcement rights, and lack of no -
trespassing sign or boundary delineation fencing in the right-of-way (ROW) are between
the Railhead Scrub Preserve. Staff will continue to seek opportunities to enhance law
enforcement access to the site for monitoring and enforcement, regulation and boundary
posting, and partnership with adjacent landowners where illegal trespass activities are
initiating. In addition, the program will replace existing sub -standard security fencing with
more effective infrastructure while making effort to avoid impacts to wildlife through design
and implementation in 2024.
Soil Disturbance/Erosion Prevention: Soil
disturbance and erosion from incompatible
illegal site access, along with historic
exclusion of a natural fire regime from the
site, continues to be one of the greatest
threats to the preservation of the
imperiled scrub habitat within Railhead
i
Scrub Preserve. Rare, endemic scrub
vegetation is slow -growing and loss of
410
plant cover in sites as a result of soil
disturbance poses restoration challenges #
for recovery. Ruts caused by non -lb
- ,«
sanctioned tire tread at the site alters the
elevation and hydrology and the plant
species that grow within the area. Outside _.
of the boundary and within the ROW Figure 8. Erosion of Scrub Habitat and Resulting Bare
between the North and South preserve Soil
parcels, off -road vehicle disturbance has
contributed to a loss of over 65% coverage of scrub vegetation and suitable habitat for
scrub -dependent species. Staff will continue to consider soil erosion threats and avoidance
measures when planning bare soil restoration plantings, future public access compatibility,
and security enhancement needs at the site.
Enforcement and Monitoring: Currently, the program relies heavily on monitoring and
Conservation Collier 11 Railhead Scrub Preserve
support from the Collier County Sherriff's Office Agriculture and Mounted Patrol and Aviation
Unit for enforcing illegal activity at the site as a result of access limitations caused by the
scrub soil type. Staff will continue to seek opportunities to enhance security and monitoring
at the site to safeguard the preserve resources.
Acquisition
Table 2: Acquisition History and Plan Updates for Railhead Scrub Preserve
Acquisition History and Plan Updates for Railhead Scrub Preserve
Year
Benchmark
2003
Appraisal and Assessment to Determine Compliance with Initial
Screening Criteria, including Biological and Hydrological
Characteristics
2004
Railhead Scrub Preserve property (northern 80 acres) purchased
by Conservation Collier
2006
RR Land Trust (55 acres) property initially assessed
2007
RR Land Trust parcel purchased and incorporated into Railhead
Scrub Preserve
No additional parcel acquisitions have been completed within the Railhead Scrub Preserve
complex since 2007. Conservation Collier is a land buying program that purchases
undeveloped, ecologically important lands throughout the County at risk from development
to establish community nature preserves. The program has been in existence since 2003
and currently protects over 22 nature preserves from Marco Island to Immokalee. Following
a voter referendum in 2020 that received 77% approval, the program resumed land
purchasing at the direction of the Board of County Commissioners and is actively accepting
applications from willing sellers and nominations from members of the public through an
online form located at www.ConservationCollier.com.
Conservation Collier 12 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Implementation and Costs
Table 3: Implementation Timetable
Manage ent Activity Timetable
Activity
2023/
2025
2026
2027
2028
2029
2030
2031
2032
2033
2034
2024
Exotic Plant
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Maintenance
Mechanical
X
X
Reduction
Prescribed Fire
X
X
X
X
X
Management
Restoration Planting
X
X
X
X
X
Wildlife Monitoring
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
and Research
Fence Replacement
X
X
*On -Site Tortoise
x
Relocation
Boundary Sign Install
x
& Maintenance
*Wildlife Underpass
Maintenance &
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Monitoring
*Public Access
X
X
Amenity Installation
Trail/Amenity
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Maintenance
Site Access Equipment
x
ATV winches
Debris Removal
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Fencing Repair/
Security Barrier
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Repair
*Activity Implementation Dependent on Veteran's Memorial Blvd Extension Construction Timeline
Table 4: Projected Costs
Item
Funding
Projected
Occurrences
Source
Cost
Exotic Plant Maintenance (contract)
CC, FWC
$27,000
10
*Mechanical
CC
$91,437.50
1
Mowing (contract)
Site Access Equipment
CC
$11,000
1
(ATV, Equipment Winches)
Prescribed Burns (In -House)
CC
$3,125
13
*Fireline Discing (contract)
CC
$1900
5
Restoration Planting (contract, in -kind)
USF ,
$1,500
5
Wildlife Monitoring and Research (contract,
CC
$1500
10
in-house FGCU
Surveys and Fence Replacement (contract)
CC
$67,000
2
On -Site Tortoise Relocation
CC
$9435
1
Boundary Sign Install & Maintenance
CC
$50
50
Wildlife Underpass Maintenance & Monitoring
CC
$250
10
In -House
*Public Access Trail Installation (contract)
CC
$5000
1
*Public Access Amenity Installation (gates,
CC
$15,000
1
benches kiosk education signs) contract
*Trail/Amenity Maintenance (In -House)
CC
$2211.52
4
*Debris Removal/Cleanups (contract)
CC
$5000
5
*Fencing Repair/ Security Barrier Repair (In-
CC
$2500
50
house contract
Total Projected Costs Over 10 Years
$789,844
*Costs subject to increase/decrease upon market changes. Cost projection factoring in current management
equipment assets- future acquisition of in-house management equipment would decrease contracted cost projection
Conservation Collier 13 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Appendix
Appendix 1: Legal Description
PROPERTY TAX IDENTIF,CATION NUMB R OD15292COD9
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
THE SOUTH200 FEET OF THE NORTH 2 D FEET OF THE WEV
RkLF JW 1 r.Z) OF THE NORTHEAST CLIARTEJF (NE Y.) OF SECTION 1 S.
TOWNSHIP 46 SOLITH, RANGE 25 FAST, OF -COLLIER COUNTY
FLOMA; LYING WEST OF THE ATLANTIC CAAST LINE RAILROAD
FRIGHT CF-WAY-
2.36 acres n*m or lea*,
AND
PROERW TAX IDENTIRCA7JON NUMBER. 00152800006
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
THE NTH W FEET OF THE NORT#� 'T OF THE VVE$T
HALF (W 1M OF THE #� Tx � _ � OF SECTION 15,
TOV4NSW 41!� SOUM. RAWEi=84ST, OF C7TE
COUNTY
FLCNUD . LYING EAST OF TLANT6C CASAI 1�LRCAD
RIQHT-OF-WAY- iL 1
5 " ams mare of lea$,
AND
QROPERTYTAi[ IDFr#iI to N11UI1ER: R1 21-
LEGAL aESr,.RIPTION; ���. T !
714E T-i M FEET OF THIS NORTH- "T OF rHE WEST
HALF (W 4 ) OF THE NORTHEAST 0UAR7ER {HE Y.} OF SECTION 15.
TCAN43HIP 48 SOUTH, RANGE ?5 EAST, OF COL UER COUNTY
FLORIDA: LYING EAST OF THE ATIANTO COAST LINE RWLRCAD
RIGHT-OF-WAY,
6.89 owes more of ices.
AND
PROPERTY TAX IDENTIFICATION NUMBER: 001-526MCO2
LEGAL DESCRIPTION;
THE NoRrH 49* FIEET Of THAT PORTIOIN OF THE NORTH 750 FEI(=T
OF THEi NQF?T VOZSTQLIARTER (kW Y,) OF THE NORTHEA$T
OLJARTER (NE %f oIF SECTION 75, TOMSHIP46 SOUTMI, RANGE 25
EAST, OF COWER COUNTY FLORID LYING EAST OF THE
ATLANTIC COAST LIFE RAI LRQAD ftjGmT-0r-vYAY; LESS AMID
EXCEPTING! THE EAST 34 FEET THEREOF, AND LESZ AND
EXCEPTIIIG THE NORTH 60 FEAT TI-IEFEQF.
4 A3 BCM It10fs or kn9.
r
Conservation Collier 14 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Appendix 2: Photoset- Representative Communities
Oak Scrub
Scrubby Flatwoods
Hydric Flatwoods
Oak Scrub
Cypress
Mesic Flatwood
Scrubby Flatwoods
Wet Prairie
k
psi
�.y
Bare Soil
Conservation Collier
15
Railhead Scrub Preserve
Appendix 3: Photoset- Representative Groundcover
r �r
I� �
Chapman's Blazing Star
-It
Tarflower
Gopher Apple
Florida Rosemary
Curtiss' Milkweed
Prickly Pear Cactus
T�
Spikemoss
Whitemouth Dayflower Yellow -eyed grass
Conservation Collier
16 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Appendix 4: Photoset-Notable Wildlife
Florida gopher tortoise- ST
Coyote
Southern bald eagle
White-tailed deer Florida black bear
At
Cottontail rabbit
Eastern bluebird
Bobcat
Swallow-tailed Kite
Conservation Collier
17 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Appendix 5: Photoset- Resource Protection Concerns
6-6
4s�w
r +'�
4 W
,
Illegal Trespass Via Railroad Boundary Fence Damage Rare Habitat Soil Erosion
3li_ wn r -
kf
It
w
Illegal Dumping
Vehicle Wildlife Mortalities
Off -Road Trespass Damage Habitat Fragmentation
Wildlife Crossings Illegal Brush Fires
Conservation Collier
18 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Appendix 6: Species Tables
Table S. Bird Species Observed at Railhead Scrub Preserve
Common Name
Scientific Name
Common Name
Scientific Name
American crow
Corvus brachyrhynchos
house sparrow
Passer domesticus
American kestrel
Falco sparverius
house wren
Troglodytes aedon
barn swallow
Hirundo rustica
killdeer
Charadrius vociferus
belted kingfisher
Megaceryle alcyon
laughing gull
Leucophaeus atricilla
black vulture
Coragyps atratus
least bittern
Ixobrychus exilis
black -bellied whistling
duck
Dendrocygna
autumnalis
least tern
Sternula antillarum
black -whiskered vireo
Vireo altiloquus
limpkin
Aramus guarauna
blue jay
Cyanocitta cristata
little blue heron
Egretta caerulea
blue -gray gnatcatcher
Polioptilia caerulea
loggerhead shrike
Lanius ludovicianus
boat -tailed grackle
Quiscalus major
mottled duck
Anas fulvigula
broad -winged hawk
Buteo platypterus
mourning dove
Zenaida macroura
brown thrasher
Toxostoma rufum
muscovy duck
Cairina moschata
carolina wren
Thryothorus
ludovicianus
Northern cardinal
Cardinalis
cattle egret
Bubulcus ibis
Northern flicker
Colaptes auratus
chimney swift
Chaetura pelagica
Northern mockingbird
Mimus polyglottos
chuck-will's-widow
Caprimulgus
carolinensis
Northern parula
Setophaga americana
common grackle
Quiscalus quiscula
osprey
Pandion haliaetus
common ground dove
Columbina passerine
palm warbler
Setophaga palmarum
common moorhen
Gallinula chloropus
pileated woodpecker
Dryocopus pileatus
common nighthawk
Chordeiles minor
pine warbler
Setophaga pinus
common yellowthroat
Geothlypis trichas
prairie warbler
Setophaga discolor
cooper's hawk
Accipiter cooperii
purple martin
Progne subis
double -crested
cormorant
Phalacrocorax auritus
red -bellied woodpecker
Melanerpes carolinus
downy woodpecker
Picoides pubescens
red -shouldered hawk
Buteo lineatus
Eastern bluebird
Sialia sialis
red-tailed hawk
Buteo jamafcensis
Eastern phoebe
Sayornis phoebe
red -winged blackbird
Agelaius phoeniceus
Eastern screech owl
Megascops asio
roseate spoonbill
Platalea ajaja
Eastern towhee
Pipilo
er thro hthalmus
sharp -shinned hawk
Accipiter striatus
Eurasian collared-
dove
Streptopelia decaocto
Southern bald eagle
Haliaeetus leucocephalus
European starling
Sturnus vulgaris
swallow-tailed kite
Elanoides forficatus
fish crow
Corvus ossifragus
tricolored heron
Egretta tricolor
glossy ibis
Plegadis falcinellus
tufted titmouse
Baeolophis bicolor
gray catbird
Dumetella carolinensis
turkey vulture
Cathartes aura
great blue heron
Ardea herodias
white ibis
Eudocimus albus
great crested
flycatcher
Myiarchus crinitus
white -eyed vireo
Vireo griseus
great egret
Ardea albs
wood stork
Mycteria americana
green heron
Butorides virescens
yellow -bellied sapsucker
Sphyrapicus varius
hairy woodpecker
Leuconotopicus villosus
Conservation Collier 19 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Table 6. Wildlife Species Observed at Railhead Scrub Preserve
Mammals
Scientific Name
Designation
bobcat
Lynx rufus
Eastern cottontail
Sylvilagus floridanus
Eastern gray squirrel
Sciurus carolinensis
Eastern mole
Scalopus aquaticus
Florida black bear
Ursus americanus floridanus
gray fox
Urocyon cinereoargenteus
hispid cotton rat
Sigmodon hispidus
marsh rabbit
Sylvilagus palustris
nine -banded armadillo
Dasypus novemcinctus
raccoon
Procyon lotor
Virginia opossum
Didelphis virginiana
white-tailed deer
Odocoileus virginianus
Reptiles
black racer
Coluber constrictor
brown anole
Anolis sagrei
*non-native
common five -lined skink
Plestiodon fasciatus
corn snake
Pantherophis guttatus
Eastern coachwhip
Masticophis flagellum
Eastern diamondback rattlesnake
Crotalus adamanteus
Eastern ratsnake
Pantherophis alleghaniensis
Florida box turtle
Terrapene caroling
Florida gopher tortoise
Gopherus polyphemus
*State -threatened
Florida red -bellied cooter
Pseudemys nelsoni
Florida softshell turtle
Apalone ferox
six -lined racerunner
Aspidoscelis sexlineatus
Amphibians
cane toad
Rhinella marina
*non-native
Cuban treefrog
Osteopilus septentrionalis
*non-native
greenhouse treefrog
Eleutherodactylus planirostris
*non-native
oak toad
Anaxyrus quercicus
pinewoods treefrog
Hyla femoralis
Southern toad
Anaxyrus terrestris
squirrel treefrog
Hyla squirrella
Conservation Collier 20 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Table 7. Imperiled Plant Species at Railhead Scrub Preserve
Scientific Name
Common Names
IRC
State
FNAI
Asclepias curtissii
Curtiss' milkweed
E
S3
Chamaesyce cumulicola
Sand -dune spurge; Coastal dune
sandmat
E
S2
Enc clia tam ensis
Florida butterfly orchid
C
Lechea cernua
Nodding inweed
T
S3
Lilium catesbaei
Cateb 's lily
T
Li ocar ha maculata
American halfchaff sedge
SF1
O hio lossum nudicaule
Slender adder's tongue
SF1
Orthochilus ecristatus
Giant orchid non -crested Eulophia
T
S2
Scleria ciliata var. curtissii
Curtiss' nutrush
SF1
St lisma abdita
Showy dawnflower
SF1
E
S2S3
Swietenia maha oni
West Indian mahogany
T
S3
Tillandsia balbisiana
Reflexed wild -pine,
Northern needleleaf
T
Tillandsia fasciculata var.
densis ica
Stiff -leaved wild -pine, Cardinal airplant
E
Tillandsia flexuosa
Banded wild -pine, Twisted airplant
T
S3
Tillandsia utriculata
Giant wild -pine, Giant airplant
I E
E: Endangered, T: Threatened, C: Commercially Exploited, SF1: Critically Imperiled, S2: Critically
Imperiled, S3: Imperiled
Table S. Exotic Plant Species at Railhead Scrub Preserve
Scientific Name
Common Names
Category
Scientific
Common
Category
Name
Names
Abrus precatorius
rosary -pea, crab -eyes
I
Momordica
balsam
II
charantia
apple
Acacia auriculiformis
earleaf acacia
I
Nephrolepis
Asian sword
I
multiFlora
fern
Albizia lebbeck
woman's tongue
I
Panicum
Guineagrass
II
maximum
Ardisia elliptica
shoebutton ardesia
I
Panicum
torpedo
I
re ens
grass
Bauhinia variegata
mountain ebony, orchidtree
I
Psidium
strawberry
I
cattleianum
guava
Bischofia javanica
Bisho wood
I
Pteris vittata
China brake
II
Rhodomyrtus
downy
Casuarina equisetifolia
Australian pine
I
myrtle,
I
tomentosa
rose -myrtle
Cupaniopsis anacardioides
Carrotwood
I
Rhynchelytrum
rose
I
re ens
natalgrass
Dioscorea alata
white yam
I
Ricinus
Castor -bean
II
communis
bowstring-
Dioscorea bulbifera
air potato
I
Sansevieria
hemp,
II
hyacinthoides
mother -in-
laws tongue
Ficus microcarpa
laurel fig, Indian laurel
I
Schinus
Brazilian
I
terebinthifolius
pepper
Hymenachne amplexicaulis
west Indian marsh grass
I
Schefflera
Australian
I
actino h lla
umbrellatree
Lantana Camara
Shrubverbena
I
Solanum
tropicalI
viarum
so a -apple
Leucaena leucoce hala
white leadtree
II
Urena lobata
Caesarweed
I
Lygodium microphyllum
old world climbing fern
I
Wedelia
creeping
II
trilobata
oxeye
Melaieuca quinquenervia
Melaleuca
I
Conservation Collier 21 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Table 9. Railhead Scrub Preserve Plant Inventory
Railhead Scrub Preserve Plant List 2020
Railhead Scrub Preserve
by Maureen S. Bonness, with assistance from Jean McCollom and Michael J. Barry
November 28, 2020
2006
2009
2020
Scientific Name
prior name
Common Names
m
>
Lp a
z
a
>
o Lp R
z z
v
.. M
N
a
z
LL
a-
w
LL
x
x
x
Abrus precatorius
Rosary -pea, Crab -eyes
1
x
x
x
Acacia auriculiformis
Earleaf acacia
d
1
x
Acalypha arvensis
Field copperleaf
x
x
x
Acer rubrum
Red maple
N
x
Agalinis purpurea
Purple false foxglove
N
x
Agave angustifolia
Century plant
d
x
Ageratum houstonianum
Bluemink
d
x
x
Albizia lebbeck
Woman's tongue, Rattlepod
d
1
x
x
Aletris lutea
Yellow colicroot
N
x
Allamanda cathartics
Golden trumpet
d
x
x
Amaranth ushybridus
Common pigweed, Slim amaranth
✓
x
Amaranthus spinosus
Spiny amaranth
d
x
x
x
Ambrosia artemisOolia
Common ragweed
N
x
x
x
Amphicarpum muhlenbergianum
Blue-maidencane
N
x
x
x
Andropogon brachystachyus
Shortspike bluestem
N
x
x
Andropogon flondanus
Florida bluestem
N
x
x
x
Andropogon glomeratus var.
lauco sis
Purple bluestem
N
x
x
x
Andropogon glomeratus var. pumilus
Common bushy bluestem
N
x
x
Andropogon gyrans
Elliott's bluestem
N
x
x
x
Andropogon virginicus
Broomsedge bluestem
N
x
x
x
Andropogon virginicus var. glaucus
Chalky bluestem
N
x
Anemia adiantlfolia
Pine fern, Maidenhair pineland fern
N
x
x
Annona glabra
Pond -apple
N
x
Ardisia elliptica
Shoe -button ardisia
1
x
x
x
lAristida gyrans
Corkscrew threeawn
N
x
x
Aristida palustris
Longleaf threeawn
N
x
Aristida patula
Tall threeawn
N
x
x
Aristida purpurascens
Arrowfeather threeawn
N
x
x
x
Aristida spiciformis
Bottlebrush threeawn
N
x
x
x
Aristida stricta (=A. beyrichiana)
Southern wiregrass
N
x
x
1 Asclepias curassavica
Scarlet milkweed, Bloodflower
d
x
x
Asclepias curtissii
Curtiss' milkweed
N
E
x
x
Asclepias pedicellata
Savannah milkweed
N
x
x
x
Asemeia violacea (=Polygala
gran diflora, P violacea
Candyweed, Showy milkwort
N
x
x
x
Asimina reticulata
Common pawpaw, Netted pawpaw
N
x
x
x
Axonopus fissifolius
Common carpetgrass
N
x
x
x
Axonopus furcatus
Big carpetgrass
N
x
x
Azolla fficuloides (=A. caroliniana)
Waterfern
N
x
Baccharis glomeruliflora
Saltbush
N
x
x
x
Baccharis halimifolia
Saltbush, Groundsel tree
N
x
x
x
Bacopa monnien
Water hyssop, Herb -of -grace
N
x
x
x
Balduina angustifolia
Yellow -buttons, Coastalplain
honeycombhead
N
x
1
1 x
Bauhinia variegata
l0rchid tree
Conservation Collier 22 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Railhead Scrub Preserve Plant List 2020
2006
2009
2020
Scientific Name
(prior name)
Common Names
m
>
R
Z
a
>
o R
Z Z
v
°
N
z
LL
a.
a -
W
LL
x
x
x
Bejaria racemosa
Tayfower
N
x
x
x
Bidens alba
Spanish -needles
N
x
x
x
Bigelowia nudata subsp. australis
Pineland rayless goldenrod
N
x
Bischofra javanica
Javanese bishopwood
1
x
x
x
Boehmeria cylindrica
False nettle, Bog hemp
N
x
Bougainvillea sp.
Bougainvillea
x
x
x
Buchnera americana
American bluehearts
N
x
x
x
Bulbostylis ciliatifolia
Densetuft hairsedge
N
x
Bulbostylis stenophylla
Sandyfield hairsedge
N
x
Bulbostylis warei
Ware's hairsedge
N
x
Bursera simaruba
Gumbo limbo
N
x
x
Callicarpa americana
American beautyberry
N
x
CaNisia ornata
Florida scrub roseling
N
x
Campyloneurum phyffi idis
Long strap fern
N
x
Cantinoa americana (=Hyptis
s cig era
Marubio
d
x
Caperonia castaneifolia
Chestnutleaf falsecroton
N
x
Carex longii
Long's sedge
N
x
Carex vexans
Florida hammock sedge
N
x
x
x
Carphephorus corymbosus
Florida paintbrush, Coastalplain
chaffhead
N
x
x
x
Carphephorus odoratissimus var.
subtro icanus
Pineland purple, False vanillaleaf
N
x
x
x
Cassytha filiformis
Lovevine, Devil's gut
N
x
x
Casuarina equisetifolia
Australian -pine, Horsetail casuarina
d
I
x
Catharanthus roseus
Madagascar periwinkle
x
Cenchrus polystachios (=Pennisetum
o! stachion)
West Indian pennisetum,
Missiongrass
d
II
x
x
x
Cenchrus s inifex =C. incertus
Coastal sandbur
N
x
x
Centella asiatica
Coinwort S adeleaf
N
x
x
Centrosema vir inianum
Spurred butterfly -pea
N
x
Ce halanthus occidentalis
Buttonbush
N
x
x
x
Ceratiola encoides
Florida rosemary,Sand heath
N
x
x
x
Chamaecrista fasciculata
Partridge pea
N
x
Chamaecrista nictitans var. as era
Hairy sensitive -pea
N
x
Cha talia tomentosa
Woolly sunbonnets Pineland daisy
N
x
Chiococca alba =C. atvifolia
Pineland snowberry
N
x
Chromolaena odorata
Jack -in -the -bush
N
x
Chr sobalanus icaco
Coco plum
N
x
Chr so 0 on pauciflorus
Florida false beardgrass
N
x
x
x
Chr so sis scabrella
Coastal lain goldenaster
N
x
x
Cirsium horridulum
Purple thistle
N
x
x
Cirsium nuttallii
Nuttall's thistle
N
x
Cissus verticillata =C. sic oides
ossu-mg rape
N
x
x
x
Cladium jamaicense
Sawgrass
N
x
x
x
Cnidoscolus stimulosus
Tread-softly,Finger-rot, 7-minute-itch
N
x
Coleataenia rigidula (=Panicum
ri idulum
Redtop panicum
N
x
x
x
Coleataenia tenera (=Panicum
tenerum
Bluejoint panicum
N
x
x
x
Commelina diffusa
lCommon dayflower
d
Conservation Collier 23 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Railhead Scrub Preserve Plant List 2020
2006
2009
2020
Scientific Name
(prior name)
Common Names
m
>
a
Z
v
>
o R
Z Z
v
:°
N
z
U-
a-
a -
w
U-
x
x
Commelina erecta
Whitemouth dayflower
N
x
x
x
Coreopsis leavenworthu
Leavenworth's tickseed
N
x
Crocanthemum corymbosum
=Helianthemum cor mbosum
Pinebarren frostweed
N
x
x
x
Crocanthemum nashii
=Helianthemum nashii
Florida scrub frostweed
N
x
x
x
Crotalaria pallida var. obovata
Smooth rattlebox
x
x
x
Crotalaria rotundifolia
Rabbitbells
N
x
Crotalaria spectabilis
Showy rattlebox
x
x
Croton glandulosus var.
se tentrionalis =varr qlandulosus
Vente conmigo
N
x
Cupaniopsis anacardioides
Carrotwood
d
1
x
x
Cuphea carthagenensis
Colombian waxweed
x
Cyanthillium cinereum (=Vernonia
cinerea)
Little ironweed
d
x
x
x
I Cynodon dactylon
Bermuda grass
x
Cyperus compressus
Poorland flatsedge
N
x
x
Cyperus croceus
Baldwin's flatsedge
N
x
Cyperus distans
Piedmont fltsedge
x
Cyperus esculentus
Yellow nutsedge
x
x
x
Cyperus haspan
Haspan flatsedge
N
x
1 Cyperus hortensis (=Kyllinga pumila)
Low spikesedge
N
x
x
x
Cyperus ligulans
Swamp flatsedge
N
x
Cyperus neochinensis (=Lipocarpha
aristulata)
Awned halfchaff sedge
x
Cyperus neotropicalis (=Lipocarpha
maculata)
American halfchaff sedge
N
x
x
Cyperus odoratus
Fragrant flatsedge
N
x
x
x
Cyperus ovatus (=C. retrorsus)
Pinebarren flatsedge
N
x
x
x
Cyperus polystachyos
Manyspike flatsedge, Texas sedge
N
x
x
Cyperus pumilus
Low flatsedge
d
x
x
x
Cyperus sun .namensis
Tropical flatsedge
N
x
x
x
Dactyloctenium aegyptium
Crow's-foot grass
d
11
x
jDalbergia ecastaphyllum
Coinvine
N
x
Delonix regia
Royal poinciana
d
x
Dendrophylax porrectus (=Harrisella
orrecta
Needleroot airplant orchid
N
T
x
Descurainia pinnata
Western tansymustard
N
x
x
x
Desmodium incanum
Beggar's -ticks
x
x
Desmodium tortuosum
Dixie ticktrefoiI
d
x
Desmodium triflorum
Threeflower ticktrefoil
x
x
x
Dichanthelium aciculare
Needleleaf witchgrass
N
x
x
x
Dichanthelium ensifolium
Cypress witchgrass
N
x
x
Dichanthelium erectifolium
Erect witchgrass
N
x
x
Dichanthelium leucothrix
Rough witchgrass
N
x
Dichanthelium ovale
Eggleaf witchgrass
N
x
x
x
Dichanthelium portoricense
Hemlock witchgrass
N
x
x
x
Dichanthelium strigosum var.
labrescens
Roughhair witchgrass
N
x
x
Digitaria bicornis
lAsia crabgrass
Conservation Collier 24 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Railhead Scrub Preserve Plant List 2020
2006
2009
2020
Scientific Name
(prior name)
Common Names
m
>
a
Z
v
>
o R
Z Z
v
:°
N
z
rL
a-
a -
w
rL
x
Digitaria ciliaris
Southern crabgrass
N
x
x
Digitaria filiformis var. filiformis
Slender crabgrass
N
x
x
x
Digitaria longiflora
Indian crabgrass
x
x
x
Diodia virginiana
Buttonweed, Virginia buttonweed
N
x
Dioscorea alata
White yam
1
x
Dioscorea bulbifera
Air potato
d
1
x
Diplachne fusca subsp. fascicularis
=Le tochloa fascicularis
Bearded spangletop
N
x
Dracaena hyacinthoides
=Sansevieria h acinthoides
Mother-in-law's tonge
d
11
x
x
x
Drosera brevifolia
Dwarf sundew
N
x
Drym aria cordata
Drymary, West Indian chickweed
x
Dyschoriste angusta
Pineland twinflower, Pineland
snakeherb
N
x
Echinochloa walteri
Coast cockspur
N
x
x
Eclipta prostrata
False daisy
N
x
x
x
Edrastima uniflora (=Hedyotis
uniflora, Oldenlandia uniflora
Clustered mille graine
N
x
x
Eleocharis baldwinii
Baldwin's spikerush, Roadgrass,
Hairsedge
N
x
Eleocharis geniculata
Canada spikerush
N
x
Eleocharis interstincta
Knotted spikerush
N
x
Eleocharis nigrescens
Black spikerush
d
x
Elephantopus elatus
Tall elephantsfoot
N
x
Elionurus tripsacoides
Pan-American balsamscale
N
x
x
Emilia fosbergii
Florida tasselflower
d
x
x
x
Emilia sonchifolia
Lilac tassleflower
d
x
x
x
Encyclia tampensis
Florida butterfly orchid
N
x
x
x
Eragrostis atrovirens
Thalia lovegrass
d
x
Eragrostis bahiensis
Bahia lovegrass
d
x
x
Eragrostis ciliaris
Gophertail lovegrass
d
x
x
x
Eragrostis elliottii
Elliott's lovegrass
N
x
x
Eragrostis gangetica
Slimflower lovegrass
d
x
x
x
Eragrostis refracta (=E. virginica)
Coastal lovegrass
N
x
Eragrostis secundiflora subsp.
oxleis
Red lovegrass
N
x
Eragrostis spectabilis
Purple lovegrass
N
x
x
x
Erechtites hieraciifolius
Fireweed, American burnweed
N
x
x
Erigeron quercifolius
Southern -fleabane, Oakleaf fleabane
N
x
Erigeron vernus
Early whitetop fleabane
N
x
x
x
Enocaulon decangulare
Tenangle pipewort
N
x
x
x
Eryngium aromaticum
Fragrant eryngium, Fragrant Eryngo
N
x
x
x
lEryngium baldwinii
Baldwin's eryngo
N
x
I x
x
Eulophia alta
Wild-coco
N
x
x
x
Eupatorium capillifolium
Dogfennel
N
x
x
x
Eupatorium leptophyllum
Falsefennel
N
x
x
x
Eupatorium mikanioldes
Semaphore thoroughwort
N
x
x
Eupatorium mohni
Mohr's thoroughwort
N
Conservation Collier 25 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Railhead Scrub Preserve Plant List 2020
2006
2009
2020
Scientific Name
(prior name)
Common Names
m
>
a
Z
v
>
o R
Z Z
v
:°
N
z
1L
a-
a -
w
1L
x
Euphorbia blodgettii (=Chamaesyce
blod ettii
Limestone sandmap
N
x
x
x
Euphorbia cumulicola (=Chamaesyce
cumulicola)
Sand -dune spurge, Coastal dune
sandmat
N
E
S2
x
x
Euphorbia cyathophora (--Poinsettia
c atho hora
Painted leaf, Fire -on -the -mountain
N
x
Euphorbia graminea
Grassleaf spurge
x
x
x
Euphorbia heterophylla (=Poinsettia
hetero h lla
Fiddler's spurge, Mexican fireplant
N
x
x
lEuphorbia hirta (=Chamaesyce hirta)
Hairy spurge, Pillpod sandmat
N
x
x
Euphorbia hypencifolia
=Chamaes ce h encifolia
Eyebane, Graceful sandmat
N
x
x
x
Euphorbia hyssopifolia
=Chamaes ce h sso ifolia
Eyebane, Hyssopleaf sandmat
N
x
x
x
Euphorbia polyphylla
Lesser Florida spurge
N
x
x
x
Euploca polyphylla (=Heliotropium
of h llum
Pineland heliotrope
N
x
x
x
Eustachys glauca
Prairie fingergrass
N
x
x
x
Eustachys petraea
Pinewoods fingergrass
N
x
x
x
Euthamia carohniana
Slender flattop goldenrod
N
x
Evolvulus sericeus
Silver dwarf morningglory
N
x
x
Ficus aurea
Strangler fig, Golden fig
N
x
x
x
Ficus citrifolia
Short -leaf fig, Wild banyan tree
N
x
x
x
Ficus microcarpa
Laurel fig, Indian laurel
x
x
x
Fimbristylis autumnalis
Slender fimbry
N
x
x
Fimbristylis caroliniana
Carolina fimbry
N
x
x
x
Fimbristylis cymosa
Hurricanegrass
d
x
x
Fimbristylis puberula
Hairy fimbry
N
x
x
Fuirena breviseta
Saltmarsh umbrellasedge
N
x
x
x
Fuirena scirpoidea
Southern umbrellasedge
N
x
x
x
Funastrum clausum (=Sarcostemma
clausum
Whitevine, White twinevine
N
x
x
Galactia elGottii
Elliott's milkpea
N
x
x
x
Galactia regulars
Downy milkpea
N
x
Galactia volubilis
Eastern milkpea
N
x
Gamochaeta antillana (=Gnaphalium
falcatum)
Cudweed, Narrowleaf purple
everlasting
N
x
x
x
Geobalanus oblongifolius (=Licania
michauxii
Gopher -apple
N
x
x
Gratiola ramosa
Branched hedgehyssop
N
x
Grevillea robusta
Silk -oak
d
x
Gymnopogon chapmanianus
Chapman's skeletongrass
N
x
Hamelia patens
Firebush
N
x
Helenium amarum
Spanish daisy, Bitterweed
N
x
Heliotropium angiospermum
Scorpionstail
N
x
x
Heteropogon contortus
Tanglehead
N
x
x
x
I Heterotheca subaxillaris
Camphorweed
N
x
x
I x
lHexasepalum teres (=Diodia teres)
Poorjoe, Rough buttonweed
N
x
x
I
lHieracium megacephalon
Coastal plain hawkweed
N
Conservation Collier 26 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Railhead Scrub Preserve Plant List 2020
2006
2009
2020
Scientific Name
(prior name)
Common Names
m
>
a
Z
v
>
o R
Z Z
v
:°
N
z
1L
a-
a -
w
1L
x
x
Houstonia procumbens (=Hedyotis
rocumbens
Innocence, Roundleaf bluet
N
x
x
Hydrocotyle umbellata
Manyflower marshpennywort
N
x
Hydrocotyle verticillata
Whorled marshpennywort
N
x
Hymenachne amplexicaulis
West Indian marshgrass, Trompetilla
✓
1
x
x
Hypericum brachyphyllum
Coastalplain St. John's -wort
N
x
x
x
Hypericum cistifolium
Roundpod St. John's -wort
N
x
Hypericum fasciculatum
Peelbark St. John's -wort
N
x
x
Hypericum gentlanoides
Pineweeds, Orangegrass
N
x
x
x
Hypericum hypericoides
St. Andrew's -cross
N
x
x
Hypericum mutilum
Dwarf St. John's -wort
N
x
x
x
Hypericum tenuifolium (=Hypericum
reductum
Atlantic St. John's -wort
N
x
x
Hypericum tetrapetalum
Fourpetal St. John's -wort
N
x
x
x
Hypoxis juncea
Fringed Yellow stargrass
N
x
x
Hyptis alata
Musky mint, Clustered bushmint
N
x
x
x
flex cassine
Dahoon holly, Dahoon
N
x
x
x
Ilex glabra
Gallberry, Inkberry
N
x
x
x
Indigofera hirsuta
Hairy indigo
x
1pomoea hederifolia
Scarletcreeper
N
x
1pomcea guamoclit
Cypressvine
x
x
x
1pomoea sagittata
Everglades morningglory
N
x
1pomoea triloba
Littlebell
x
x
lresine diffusa
Bloodleaf, Juba's bush
N
x
1 Iva microcephala
Piedmont marshelder
N
x
Juncus effuses subsp. solutes
Soft rush
N
x
x
Juncus marginatus
Shore rush, Grassleaf rush
N
x
x
x
Juncus megacephalus
Bighead rush
N
x
Juncus roemerianus
Needle rush, Black rush
N
x
Juncus scirpoides
Needlepod rush
N
x
lJuniperus virginiana
Red cedar
?
x
x
x
Lachnanthes caroliana
Bloodroot, Carolina redroot
N
x
x
x
Lachnocaulon anceps
Whitehead bogbutton
N
x
Landoltia punctata
Dotted duckweed
x
x
Lantana strigocamara (=L. camara)
Shrubverbena
1
x
x
x
Lechea cernua
Nodding pinweed
N
T
S3
x
x
x
lLechea torreyi
Piedmont pinweed
N
x
Lemna obscura
Duckweed
N
x
Lemna valdiviana
Duckweed
N
x
x
Lepidium virginicum
Virginia pepperweed
N
x
Leucaena leucocephala
White leadtree
11
x
x
x
Liatris chapmanii
Chapman's gayfeather
N
x
x
x
lLiatris tenuifolia
Shortleaf gayfeather
N
x
Lilium catesbaei
Catesby's Lily
N
T
x
Linaria canadensis
Canadian toadflax
N
x
Lobelia glandulosa
Glade lobelia
N
x
x
Lobelia paludosa
White lobelia
N
x
x
x
Ludwigia curtissii
Curtiss's primrosewillow
N
x
x
x
1 Ludwigia maritima
ISeaside primrosewillow
N
Conservation Collier 27 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Railhead Scrub Preserve Plant List 2020
2006
2009
2020
Scientific Name
(prior name)
Common Names
m
>
a
Z
v
>
o R
Z Z
v
:°
N
¢
z
1L
a-
a-
w
1L
x
x
Ludwigia microcarpa
Smallfruit primrosewillow
N
x
x
x
Ludwigia octovalvis
Mexican primrosewillow
N
x
x
Ludwigia peruviana
Peruvian primrosewillow
x
Ludwigia repens
Creeping primrosewillow
N
x
x
x
Lygodesmia aphylla
Roserush
N
x
x
Lygodium microphyllum
Small -leaf climbing fern
d
1
x
x
x
Lyonia fruticosa
Coastalplain staggerbush
N
x
Lysimachia arvensis (=Anagallis
arvensis
Scarlet pimpernel
d
x
x
x
Lythrum alatum var. lanceolatum
Winged loosestrife
N
x
x
x
Macroptilium lathyroides
Wild bushbean
11
x
x
Mecardonia acuminata subsp.
eninsularis
Axilflower
N
x
Medicago lupulina
Black medic
x
x
x
Melaleuca quinquenervia
Punktree
1
x
x
x
Mehnis repens (=Rhynchelytrum
repens)
Rose Natalgrass
1
x
x
x
Melochla spicata
Bretonica peluda
N
x
x
x
Melothria pendula
Creeping -cucumber
N
x
Mesosphaerum pectinatum (=Hyptis
ectinata
Comb bushmint
d
x
Microsorum scolopendria
(=Phymatosorus scolopendria)
Serpent fern, Wart fern
x
x
x
Mikania scandens
Climbing hempweed, Climbing
hem vine
N
x
x
Mitreola petiolata
Miterwort, Lax hornpod
N
x
Mollugo vetticillata
Indian -chickweed, Green carpetweed
d
x
x
x
Momordica charantia
Balsampear
d
I I
x
x
x
Morella cerifera (=Myrica cerifera)
Wax myrtle, Southern bayberry
N
x
x
x
Muhlenbergia capillans
Muhlygrass, Hairawnmuhly
N
x
Murdannia nudiflora
Nakedstem dewflower
d
x
x
x
Myrsine cabana (=Rapanea punctata)
Myrsine, Colicwood
N
x
Nekemias arborea (=Ampelopsis
arborea
Peppervine
N
x
x
Nephrolepis brownii (=N. multiflora)
Asian sword fern
d
1
x
x
x
Nephrolepis exaltata
Wild Boston fern
N
x
x
x
Nymphaea cdorata
American white waterlily
N
x
Oeceoclades maculata
African ground orchid, Monk orchid
x
Oenothera simulans (=Gaura
ang ustifolia
Southern beeblossom
N
x
x
Oldenlandia corymbosa (=Hedyotis
cor mbosa
Flattop mille graines
d
x
Ophioglossum nudicaule
Slender adder's tongue
N
x
Opuntia cochenI ifera
Cochineal cactus
x
x
x
Opuntia humifusa
Pricklypear
N
x
Opuntia stricta
Pricklypear
N
T
x
Orthochilus ecristatus
=Ptero lossas is ecristata
Giant orchid, Non -crested Eulophia
N
T
I S2
Conservation Collier 28 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Railhead Scrub Preserve Plant List 2020
2006
2009
2020
Scientific Name
(prior name)
Common Names
m
>
a
Z
v
>
o R
Z Z
v
:°
N
¢
z
U-
a-
a-
w
U-
x
x
Osmunda regalis var. spectabilis
Royal fern
N
x
x
x
Palafoxia feayi
Feay's palafox
N
x
x
x
Panicum hemitomon
Maidencane
N
x
x
x
Panicum repens
Torpedo grass
d
1
x
Parietana flondana
Florida pellitory
N
x
x
Parthenocissus quinquefolia
Virginia -creeper, Woodbine
N
x
Paspalum caespitosum
Blue paspalum, Blue crowngrass
N
x
x
Paspalum conjugatum
Sour paspalum, Hilograss
N
x
Paspalum floridanum
Florida paspalum
N
x
x
x
Paspalum monostachyum
Gulfdune paspalum
N
x
x
x
Paspalum notatum
Bahia grass
✓
x
x
x
Paspalum setaceum
Thin paspalum
N
x
Paspalum urvillei
Vaseygrass
d
x
x
Paspalum vaginatum
Seashore paspalum
N
x
x
x
Passiflora suberosa
Corkystem passionflower
N
x
x
Peltophorum pterocarpum
Yellow poinciana
x
Pentalinon luteum
Wild allamanda, Hammock viperstail
N
x
Pentodon pentandrus
Hale's pentodon
N
x
x
x
Persea palustris
Swamp bay
N
x
Persicaria glabra (=Polygonum
densiflorum
Denseflower knotweed
N
x
Persicaria hydropiperoides
(=Polygonum hydropiperoides)
Mild waterpepper, Swamp smartweed
N
x
x
Persicaria punctata (=Polygonum
unctatum
Dotted smartweed
N
x
x
x
Phlebodium aureum
Golden polypody
N
x
x
x
Phyla nodlflora
Frogfruit, Turkey tangle fogfruit,
Ca eweed
N
x
x
Phyllanthus amarus
Gale -of -wind, Carry -me -seed
d
x
x
Phyllanthus caroliniensis subsp.
saxicola
Rock Carolina Ieafflower
N
x
Phyllanthus tenellus
Mascarene Island Ieafflower
d
x
Physalis angulata
Cutleaf groundcherry
N
x
Physalis cordata
Heartleaf groundcherry
N
x
x
x
Physalis walten
Walter's groundcherry
N
x
x
Phytolacca americana
American pokeweed
N
x
x
x
Piloblephis rigida
Wild pennyroyal
N
x
x
x
Pinus elliottii var. densa
South Florida slash pine
N
x
x
x
Piriqueta cistoides subsp. carohniana
= Piri ueta caroliniana
Pitted stripeseed
N
x
x
x
Pityopsis graminifolia
Narrowleaf silkgrass
N
x
Plantago virginica
Southern plantain, Virginia plantain
N
x
x
x
Pleopeltis michauxiana (=Polypodium
o! odioides
Resurrection fern
N
x
x
x
Pluchea baccharis (=Pluchea rosea)
Rosy camphorweed
N
x
x
Pluchea carolinensis
Cure -for -all
N
x
x
Pluchea foetida
Stinking camphorweed
N
x
x
x
Pluchea odorata
Sweetscent
N
x
x
x
Polanisia tenuifolia
Slenderleaf clammyweed
N
Conservation Collier 29 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Railhead Scrub Preserve Plant List 2020
2006
2009
2020
Scientific Name
(prior name)
Common Names
m
>
a
z
v
>
o R
z z
v
:°
N
z
U-
a-
a -
w
U-
x
Polygala lutea
Orange milkwort
N
x
x
x
Polygala nana
Candyroot
N
x
x
Polygala rugelii
Yellow milkwort
N
x
x
x
Polygala setacea
Coastalplain milkwort
N
x
Polygonum delopyrum (=P. ciliata)
Hairy jointweed
N
x
x
x
Polygonum polygamum var
brachystachyum (=Polygonella
o!VQama var. brach stack a
Thinleaf October flower
N
x
x
x
Polypremum procumbens
Rustweed, Juniperleaf
N
x
Pontedena cordata
Pickerelweed
N
x
Portulaca pilosa
Pink purselane, Kiss -me -quick
N
x
Pouzolzia zeylanica
Poulzolz's bush
d
x
Psidium cattleianum
Strawberry guava
d
1
x
lRendium aquilinum var. caudatum
Tailed bracken fern
N
x
x
x
Pteridium aquilinum var.
seudocaudatum
Tailed bracken fern
N
x
x
Pteris vittata
China brake
d
x
x
x
Pterocaulon pycnostachyum
Blackroot
N
x
x
Ptillmnium capillaceum
Mock bishopsweed, Herbwilliam
N
x
Quercus chapmanii
Chapman's oak
N
x
x
x
Quercus geminata
Sand live oak
N
x
x
x
Quercus laurifolia
Laurel oak, Diamond oak
N
x
x
x
Quercus minima
Dwarf live oak
N
x
x
x
Quercus myrtifolia
Myrtle oak
N
x
x
x
Quercus virginiana
Virginia live oak
N
x
x
Rhexia cubensis
West Indian meadowbeauty
N
x
x
x
Rhexia manana
Pale meadowbeauty
N
x
Rhexia nuttallii
Nuttall's meadowbeauty
N
x
x
x
Rhodomyrtus tomentosa
Downy rose myrtle
d
T—
x
x
x
Rhus copallinum
Winged sumac
N
x
Rhynchospora cilians
Fringed beaksedge
N
x
x
Rhynchospora colorata
Starrush whitetop
N
x
x
x
Rhynchospora divergens
Spreading beaksedge
N
x
x
x
Rhynchospora fascicularis
Fascicled Beaksedge
N
x
Rhynchospora fernaldii
Fernald's beaksedge
N
x
Rhynchospora fllifolia
Threadleaf beaksedge
N
x
Rhynchospora globularis
Globe beaksedge
N
x
x
x
Rhynchospora intermedia
Pinebarren beaksedge
N
x
Rhynchospora inundata
Narrowfruit horned beaksedge
N
x
Rhynchospora latifolia
Giant whitetop
N
x
x
x
Rhynchospora megalocarpa
Sandyfield beaksedge
N
x
x
x
Rhynchospora microcarpa
Southern beaksedge
N
x
x
x
Rhynchospora nitens
Shortbeak beaksedge
N
x
x
x
Rhynchospora plum osa
Plumed beaksedge
N
x
x
x
Rhynchospora tracyi
Tracy's beaksedge
N
x
x
Richardia brasiliensis
Tropical Mexican clover
d
x
x
x
Richardia grandiflora
Largeflower Mexican clover
d
II
x
x
Richardia scabra
Rough Mexican clover
x
x
Ricinus communis
Castor -bean
d
Conservation Collier 30 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Railhead Scrub Preserve Plant List 2020
2006
2009
2020
Scientific Name
(prior name)
Common Names
m
>
a
z
v
>
o R
z z
v
:°
N
z
U-
a-
a -
w
U-
x
Polygala lutea
Orange milkwort
N
x
x
x
Polygala nana
Candyroot
N
x
x
Polygala rugelii
Yellow milkwort
N
x
x
x
Polygala setacea
Coastalplain milkwort
N
x
Polygonum delopyrum (=P. ciliata)
Hairy jointweed
N
x
x
x
Polygonum polygamum var
brachystachyum (=Polygonella
o!VQama var. brach stack a
Thinleaf October flower
N
x
x
x
Polypremum procumbens
Rustweed, Juniperleaf
N
x
Pontedena cordata
Pickerelweed
N
x
Portulaca pilosa
Pink purselane, Kiss -me -quick
N
x
Pouzolzia zeylanica
Poulzolz's bush
d
x
Psidium cattleianum
Strawberry guava
d
1
x
lRendium aquilinum var. caudatum
Tailed bracken fern
N
x
x
x
Pteridium aquilinum var.
seudocaudatum
Tailed bracken fern
N
x
x
Pteris vittata
China brake
d
x
x
x
Pterocaulon pycnostachyum
Blackroot
N
x
x
Ptillmnium capillaceum
Mock bishopsweed, Herbwilliam
N
x
Quercus chapmanii
Chapman's oak
N
x
x
x
Quercus geminata
Sand live oak
N
x
x
x
Quercus laurifolia
Laurel oak, Diamond oak
N
x
x
x
Quercus minima
Dwarf live oak
N
x
x
x
Quercus myrtifolia
Myrtle oak
N
x
x
x
Quercus virginiana
Virginia live oak
N
x
x
Rhexia cubensis
West Indian meadowbeauty
N
x
x
x
Rhexia manana
Pale meadowbeauty
N
x
Rhexia nuttallii
Nuttall's meadowbeauty
N
x
x
x
Rhodomyrtus tomentosa
Downy rose myrtle
d
T—
x
x
x
Rhus copallinum
Winged sumac
N
x
Rhynchospora cilians
Fringed beaksedge
N
x
x
Rhynchospora colorata
Starrush whitetop
N
x
x
x
Rhynchospora divergens
Spreading beaksedge
N
x
x
x
Rhynchospora fascicularis
Fascicled Beaksedge
N
x
Rhynchospora fernaldii
Fernald's beaksedge
N
x
Rhynchospora fllifolia
Threadleaf beaksedge
N
x
Rhynchospora globularis
Globe beaksedge
N
x
x
x
Rhynchospora intermedia
Pinebarren beaksedge
N
x
Rhynchospora inundata
Narrowfruit horned beaksedge
N
x
Rhynchospora latifolia
Giant whitetop
N
x
x
x
Rhynchospora megalocarpa
Sandyfield beaksedge
N
x
x
x
Rhynchospora microcarpa
Southern beaksedge
N
x
x
x
Rhynchospora nitens
Shortbeak beaksedge
N
x
x
x
Rhynchospora plum osa
Plumed beaksedge
N
x
x
x
Rhynchospora tracyi
Tracy's beaksedge
N
x
x
Richardia brasiliensis
Tropical Mexican clover
d
x
x
x
Richardia grandiflora
Largeflower Mexican clover
d
II
x
x
Richardia scabra
Rough Mexican clover
x
x
Ricinus communis
Castor -bean
d
Conservation Collier 31 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Railhead Scrub Preserve Plant List 2020
2006
2009
2020
Scientific Name
(prior name)
Common Names
m
>
a
Z
v
>
o R
Z Z
v
:°
N
z
1L
a-
a -
w
1L
x
x
x
Sphagneticola trilobata (=Wedelia
trilobata
Creeping wedelia, Creeping oxeye
11
x
x
x
Sporobolus jacquemonth (=S. indicus
var. ramidalis
Smutgrass, West Indian dropseed
d
I
x
x
Sporobolus junceus
Pineywoods dropseed
N
x
x
x
Steinchisma hians (=Panicum hians)
Gaping panicum
N
x
Stenandrium dulce
Pinklet
N
x
x
Stenotaphrum secundatum
St. Augustine grass
x
Stillingia aquatica
Corkwood, water toothleaf
N
x
x
x
Stillingia sylvatica
Queensdelight
N
x
x
x
Stipulicida setacea
Pineland scalypink
N
x
x
x
Stylisma abdita
Showy dawnflower
N
E
S3
x
Swietenia mahagoni
West Indian mahogany
N
T
S3
x
Syagrus romanzoffiana
Queen palm
11
x
Symphyotrichum sebulatum (=Aster
subulatus)
Annual saltmarsh aster
N
x
x
x
Syngonanthus flavidulus
Yellow hatpins
N
x
Syngonium podophyllum
American evergreen
d
1
x
Syzygium cumini
Java plum
d
1
x
x
x
Taxodium ascenders
Pond cypress
N
x
x
x
Telmatoblechnum serrulatum
=Blechnum serrulatum
Swamp fern
N
x
Tephrosia rugeth
Rugel's hoarypea
N
x
Tephrosia sp.
Hoaypea
N
x
Thalia geniculata
Alligatorflag, Fireflag
N
x
Thelypteris dentata
Downy maiden fern
N
x
x
Thelypteris interrupts
Interrupted maiden fern, Hottentot
fern
N
x
x
x
Thelypteris kunthii
Southern shield fern
N
x
Tiedemannia filiformis subsp.
filiformis (=Oxypolis filiformis
Water cowbane
N
x
x
x
Tillandsia balbisiana
Reflexed wild -pine
N
T
x
x
x
Tillandsia fasciculata
Stiff -leaved wild -pine, Cardinal
airplant
N
E
x
x
x
Tillandsia flexuosa
Banded wild -pine, Twisted airplant
N
T
S3
x
x
x
Tillandsia paucifolia
Potbelly airplant
N
x
x
x
Tillandsia recurvata
Ball -moss
N
x
x
x
Tillandsia setacea
Thin -leaved wild -pine
N
x
x
x
Tillandsia usneoides
Spanish -moss
N
x
x
x
Tillandsia utriculata
Giant wild -pine, Giant airplant
N
E
x
x
x
Torenia crustacea (=Lindernia
crustacea)
Malaysian false pimpernel
d
x
x
x
Toxicodendron radicans
Eastern poison -ivy
N
x
Trichostema dichotomum
Forked blue -curls
N
x
Triplasis purpurea
Purple sandgrass
N
x
Tripsacum dactyloides
Fakahatcheegrass, Eastern
ama rass
N
x
Typha domingensis
Southern cat -tail
N
x
x
x
Urena lobata
Caesarweed
ISignalgrass
�#
I I
I
x
Urochloa arrecta
I
Conservation Collier 32 Railhead Scrub Preserve
Railhead Scrub Preserve Plant List 2020
2006
2009
2020
Scientific Name
(prior name)
Common Names
m
>
a
z
v
>
o R
z z
v
M
N
z
1L
a-
a -
w
1L
x
Urochloa distachya (=U.
sub uadri ara
Signalgrass
x
x
x
Urochloa maxima (=Panicum
maximum
Guineagrass
d
I I
x
Urochloa mutica
Paragrass
1
x
Utricularia cornuta
Horned bladderwort
N
x
Utricularia gibba
Cone -spur bladderwort, Humped
bladderwort
N
x
Utricularia simulans
Fringed bladderwort
N
x
x
x
Utricularia subulata
Zigzag bladderwort
N
x
x
x
Vaccinium myrsinites
Shiny blueberry
N
x
x
x
Vicia acutifolia
Sand vetch, Fourleaf vetch
N
x
x
Vigna Oteola
Cow -pea, Hairypod cowpea
N
x
x
Viola lanceolata
Bog white violet
N
x
x
x
Vitis rotundifolia
Muscadine, Muscadine grape
N
x
x
Vittaria lineata
Shoestring fern
N
x
x
Walthena indica
Sleepy morning
N
x
x
x
Woodwardia virginlca
Virginia chain fern
N
x
x
x
Ximenia amencana
Hog -plum, Tallowwood
N
x
x
x
Xyris am bigua
Coastalplain yelloweyed grass
N
x
x
x
lXyris brevifolia
Shortleaf yelloweyed grass
N
x
x
x
Xyris caroliniana
Carolina yelloweyed grass
N
x
x
x
Xyris elliottii
Elliott's yelloweyed grass
N
x
x
x
Xyris flabelliformis
Savannah yelloweyed grass
N
x
x
Xyris jupicai
Richard's yelloweyed grass
d
x
Xyris smalliana
Small's yelloweyed grass
N
x
Youngia japonica
Rocketweed, Oriental false
hawksbeard
d
x
1 Yucca aloifolia
Spanish bayonet, Aloe yucca
N
[-+X
I
lZoysia matrella (=Zo sia tenuifolia)
Manilla tem Ie rass
d
Count
302 1 330 1 400 1 497 138511121 13 6 43
State Codes: E=Endangered; T=Threatened
FNAI Codes: S1=critically imperiled; S2=imperiled because of rarity, S3=very rare in Florida or restricted range
FLEPPC Codes: Category I = species has altered native plant communities, Category II = species with increasing
abundance or frequency
Sources. Scentific plant names and Native/Not-Native status is according to the Atlas of Florida Plants website as of
July 2020. State status is from Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services 2018 list. FNAI category is
from Florida Natural Areas Inventory April 2019 list. FLEPPC category is from the Florida Exotic Pest Plant Council 2019
list.
Conservation Collier 33 Railhead Scrub Preserve
CO Ter C014 ty
Growth Management
Community Development Department
Development Review Division
Railhead Scrub Preserve 10 Year Land Management Plan Update Public Meeting Summary
A public meeting was held on December 18, 2023 from 5:30-6:30pm at the Sugden Theatre located within the Collier
County Library Headquarters Branch. The meeting was provided in hybrid fashion allowing for both in -person and zoom
participation. Five neighbors of the preserve were in attendance. The following details a summary of questions and
feedback provided to Conservation Collier staff.
Veteran's Memorial Blvd Comments: Meeting participants indicated interest in attending this meeting to learn about
updates and information regarding the future Veteran's Memorial Blvd Extension project. Participants requested
information regarding the conceptual project footprint and timeline for engineering and construction. Staff conveyed
information provided by the Transportation Department and informed participants of upcoming opportunities to
participate in public meetings directly related to the road construction project.
Trespass/Security Comments: Meeting participants shared feedback with trespass/security concerns in the area of the
Railhead Scrub Preserve, noting observations of off -road vehicle trespass and historic burglary/theft incidents in the
residential developments east of the preserve. Staff outlined the current and future efforts to reduce and respond to
regional security issues and provided context for the current challenges of securing the site. Residents along the eastern
boundary noted that instances of burglaries and late -night noise complaints of off -road trespassers have reduced
following the completion of the Phase 1 Veteran's Memorial Blvd Extension. Participants who manage property within the
industrial complex along the western boundary of the preserve expressed concerns about trespassers parking at their
workplace. Staff provided an update on the recent law enforcement arrests and observations of significant reduction in
trespass activity within the previous 4-months following enhanced monitoring and fencing investment.
Wildlife Management Comments: Meeting participants shared awareness and appreciation for most wildlife observations
within the area surrounding the preserve and noted their value. One member of the public expressed experiencing on-
going conflict with Florida black bear and interest in securing a bear -resistant dumpster to assist with the individuals
existing efforts to secure the attractant. Staff provided contact information and will be following up with the regional FWC
bear biologist to provide resources and support to the preserve neighbor.
Conceptual Public Access Comments: Meeting participants inquired about the type of public access that will be provided
in future years at the preserve and confirmed that the timeline would coincide with road extensions development and
completion. Staff provided information about conceptual trail design and amenities.
Prescribed Fire Comments: Staff provided presentation materials about the Prescribed fire program and the upcoming
plans to complete small acreage prescribed burns at the site. Staff provided information that additional public
presentations and meetings would be available for preserve neighbors along with additional mailing notifications of
upcoming burns. Participants were familiar with prescribed burning and indicated interest in having public meetings at
their communities to increase education and awareness of the upcoming management activities.
Development Review Division • 2800 North Horseshoe Drive - Naples, Florida 34104.239-252-2400 • mum oollierownV.gov
ORDINANCE NO.2024 -
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING ORDINANCE NO.2002-63, AS AMENDED,
WHICH ESTABLISHED THE CONSERVATION COLLIER PROGRAM,
BY AMENDING SECTION 6, CREATION OF THE CONSERVATION
COLLIER ACQUISITION TRUST FUND, SECTION 7: CREATION OF
THE CONSERVATION COLLIER MANAGEMENT TRUST FUND;
SECTION 9: PROPERTY ELIGIBLE FOR ACQUISITION AND
MANAGEMENT; SECTION 10: CRITERIA FOR EVALUATING LANDS
FOR ACQUISITION AND MANAGEMENT; SECTION 11: ACQUISITION
LIST; SECTION 12: NOMINATION FOR ACQUISITION PROPOSALS
AND CANDIDATE SITES; SECTION 13: PROCEDURE FOR SELECTION
OF ACQUISITION PROPOSALS FOR PLACEMENT ON THE ACTIVE
ACQUISITION LIST AND SUBSEQUENT PURCHASE PROCEDURES;
SECTION 14: MANAGEMENT PLANS AND USE OF
ENVIRONMENTALLY SENSITIVE LANDS; AND SECTION 16: SUNSET
OF THE CONSERVATION COLLIER AD VALOREM TAX; PROVIDING
FOR CONFLICT AND SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR INCLUSION
IN THE CODE OF LAWS AND ORDINANCES; AND PROVIDING FOR
AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, On December 3, 2002, the Board of County Commissioners ("Board")
adopted Ordinance No. 2002-63, establishing the Conservation Collier Program, which Ordinance
has been amended from time to time; and
WHEREAS, the Board desires to further amend Ordinance 2002-63, as provided herein.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that Ordinance No. 2002-63, as
amended, is hereby further amended as follows:
SECTION ONE: Name.
This ordinance shall be known as Conservation Collier Implementation Ordinance.
SECTION TWO: Objectives.
Conservation Collier is therefore hereby established to acquire, preserve, restore, and
maintain vital and significant threatened natural lands, forest, upland and wetland communities
located in Collier County, for the benefit of present and future generations.
Words underlined are added; Words struck throng k are deleted.
Page 1 of 17
SECTION THREE: Findings.
1. The foregoing recitals are true and correct and incorporated herein by reference.
2. All ad valorem funds generated hereby shall be collected by the Collier County Tax
Collector.
3. The County Manager, or his or her designee, shall administer this program in accordance
with the procedures and criteria provided for herein.
SECTION FOUR: Purpose and Intent.
1. To acquire, protect and manage environmentally sensitive lands that contain natural upland
or wetland communities, native plant communities, rare and endangered flora and fauna,
endemic species, endangered species habitat, a diversity of species, significant water
resources, or outstanding aesthetic or other natural features, maximizing protection of
Collier County's rarest, most unique and endangered habitats;
2. To acquire, protect and manage environmentally sensitive lands that offer the best human
social value, including equitable geographic distribution, natural resource -based
recreation, and protection of water resources, local ecological awareness, and enhancement
of the aesthetic setting of Collier County;
3. To acquire, protect and manage environmentally sensitive lands that serve to recharge the
County's aquifers and protect its wetlands and surface water resources to ensure the
delivery of clean and plentiful water supplies and provide flood control;
4. To acquire, protect and manage environmentally sensitive lands containing the most
biological value, including biodiversity, listed species habitat, connectivity, restoration
potential, and ecological quality;
5. To protect present conservation lands by acquiring, protecting and managing adjacent
properties which, if not acquired, would threaten the environmental integrity of the existing
resource, or which, if acquired, would enhance and buffer the environmental integrity of
the resource, and add to resource connectivity;
6. To restore the natural functions, as necessary, to any impacted and vulnerable habitats
which would then contribute significantly to fulfilling this program's goals;
7. To help implement the objectives and policies of the Collier County Growth Management
Plan which have been promulgated to preserve and protect environmental protection areas
designated in the Plan and other natural forest resources, wetlands, endangered species
habitat, and vulnerable rare habitats;
8. Upon recommendation by staff or the Board, to utilize a qualified third -party entity to
identify Collier County's best and most endangered environmental lands for acquisition,
protection and management by evaluating the biological and hydrological characteristics
and viability of the resource, the vulnerability of the resource to degradation or destruction,
and the feasibility of managing the resource to maintain its natural attributes;
9. To manage acquired environmentally sensitive lands with the primary objectives of
maintaining and preserving their natural resource values, and providing appropriate natural
resource -based recreational and educational opportunities, by employing management
Words underlined are added; Words struck throng k are deleted.
Page 2 of 17
techniques that are most appropriate for each native community so that our natural heritage
may be preserved and appreciated by and for present and fixture generations;
10. To have the acquired sites available, with minimal risk to the environmental integrity of
the site, to educate Collier County's school -age population and the general public about the
uniqueness and importance of Collier County's subtropical ecosystems and natural
communities;
11. To protect natural resources which lie within the boundaries of other conservation land
acquisition programs, where Conservation Collier funds would leverage significant other
matching sources of funding for other agency acquisition projects that would not be
available without such a local match, or which would result in considerably higher funding
rank in another program, however, Collier County shall exclude Municipalities within the
County from any requirement to provide matching funds; and,
12. To cooperate actively with other acquisition, conservation, and resource management
programs that operate within the County's Area, including, but not limited to, such
programs as the State of Florida, the Land Acquisition Trust Fund, Florida Forever, Florida
Communities Trust, and Save Our Rivers program, where the purposes of such programs
are consistent with the purposes of Conservation Collier as stated hereinabove.
SECTION FIVE: Definitions.
The following words and phrases, when used in this article, shall have the meanings ascribed
to them in this section:
Acquisition project shall mean (a) parcel(s) of land approved by the Board of County
Commissioners for conservation by the county in accordance with procedures provided for herein.
Acquisition proposal shall mean (a) parcel(s) of land which has/have been nominated or
recommended for conservation in accordance with the procedures provided for herein.
Authorized Purpose means expenditures authorized herein.
Buffer land shall mean that land which is adjacent to publicly -owned environmental land, or
privately held land permanently dedicated to conservation, or that land which is an in -holding
within publicly -owned environmental land, and which, if not acquired, would threaten the
environmental integrity of the existing resource, or if acquired, would enhance the environmental
integrity and connectivity of the resource.
Formatted: Font: Italic
Environmentally sensitive land shall mean that land which contains natural upland or wetland
communities, native plant communities, rare and endangered flora and fauna, endemic species,
endangered species habitat, a diversity of species, significant water resources, or outstanding
aesthetic or other natural features.
Management shall mean the preservation, enhancement, restoration, conservation,
monitoring, or maintenance of the natural resource values of environmentally sensitive lands
which have been acquired or approved for management under Conservation Collier in perpetui,
including provision of appropriate public access.
Words underlined are added; Words struck throng k are deleted.
Page 3 of 17
Natural resource -based recreation shall mean all forms of uses which are consistent with the
goals of this program, and are compatible with the specific parcel. Such uses shall include, but not
be limited to, hiking, nature photography, bird -watching, kayaking, canoeing, swimming, hunting
and fishing.
Non-profit organization shall mean an organization as defined in section 501 of the United
States Internal Revenue Code, operating in Collier County, which includes among its primary
goals the conservation of natural resources and the protection of the environment.
Target Protection Areas shall mean larger areas of environmentally sensitive land within
which are located specific sites which generally satisfy the initial screening criteria and meet the
goals of Conservation Collier.
Urban Area shall mean those areas designated as Urban on the Collier County Future Land
Use Map.
SECTION SIX. Creation of the Conservation Collier- Acquisition Trust Fund.
Funding of the Conservation Collier Program.
Collier County has established and will maintain (1) the Conservation Collier Acquisition
Trust Fund for use in acquiring environmentally sensitive lands in Collier Coun , , and (2) the
Conservation Collier Management Trust Fund for the preservation, enhancement, restoration,
conservation and maintenance of environmentally sensitive lands that either have been purchased
with monies from the Lands Acquisition Trust Fund, or have otherwise been approved for
management. Each year through Fiscal Year 2031, the Board will set the millage rate for the
Conservation Collier Program, which may not exceed .25 mills, and Iset the percentage of revenues
each Fund will receive for that fiscalyeai. At the direction of the Board, funds ma_y be transferred commented pc11: ML - Percentages part of referendum - What
voters voted upon.
between the two funds, or used for any other County puMose, if found to be in the best interest of sc - What's the formula to restore maintenance fund?
the public by super majority vote of the Board of County Commissioners.
1. The Conservation Collier AeEfaisi-tiei3 Trust Funds shall receive monies from the following
sources:
a. All monies accepted by Collier County in the form of federal, State, or other
governmental grants, reimbursements, allocations, or appropriations, foundation or
private grants, donations for acquisition of environmentally sensitive lands and
payments provided for mitigation activity associated with such acquisition activity.
b. Such additional allocations as may be made by the Board of County Commissioners
from time to time for the purposes set forth herein.
c. All interest generated from the sources identified herein except where monies received
have been otherwise designated or restricted.
Words underlined are added; Words struck throng k are deleted.
Page 4 of 17
e. Up to Seventy five pereea4 d. S"plementation from the Conservation Collier Management Tmst Rind, but only wit
d. Revenues venerated by the annual millave set for Conservation Collier by the Board,
not to exceed .25 mills.
e_The proceeds of any property acquired with funds from the Conservation Collier
Acquisition Trust Fund that is leased or sold by the County, said proceeds, as
determined by the Board of County Commissioners, to be committed either to the
Conservation Collier Acquisition Trust Fund or to the Conservation Collier
Management Trust Fund for the purposes provided for herein. Any such sale or lease
shall only be in accordance with the goals of this Program.
f. Prior to acquiring land located within a Municipality's boundaries, approval must first
be obtained from the governing body of that Municipality.
2. The two Conservation Collier Aequisitio Trust Funds shall be maintained in a separate
and segregated trust fund of the County to be used solely for the authorized purposes set
forth herein, and for any other County purpose deemed to be in the best interest of the
public by super majority vote of the Board of County Commissioners.
Disbursements from the Conservation Collier Acquisition Trust Fund shall be made only
for the following authorized purposes:
a. Acquisition of properties which have been approved for purchase by the Board of
County Commissioners.
b. Costs associated with each acquisition including, but not limited to, appraisals, surveys,
environmental reports, title commitments and insurance policies, real property taxes,
documentary stamps and surtax fees, and other transaction costs.
c. Costs of administering Conservation Collier, including any loans from the General
Fund for funding start-up costs until such time as the fund is closed. Administration of
the program may be conducted by County staff or by contract with a private or not for
profit entity subject to meeting all County and Conservation Collier purchasing
policies. Administrative costs shall be limited to the greatest extent possible.
d. Costs to acquire and dispose of real and personal property or any interest therein when
necessary or appropriate to protect the natural environment, provide public access or
public recreational facilities, preserve wildlife habitat areas or provide access to
management of acquired lands; to acquire interests in land by means of land exchanges;
and to enter into alternatives to the acquisition of fee interests in land, including, the
acquisition of easements, life estates, leases, and leaseback arrangements.
e. Acquisitions consistent with Collier County Land Development Code and the Growth
Management Plan.
f. To cooperate with other local, regional, state, or federal public land acquisition
programs. In such cases, the County may enter into contractual or other agreements to
acquire lands jointly or for eventual resale to other public land acquisition programs in
Collier County.
Words underlined are added; Words struck throng k are deleted.
Page 5 of 17
g. All lands acquired and titled solely in the name of Collier County shall be managed by
Collier County, wherever located, unless by mutual written agreement management
arrangements and responsibilities are undertaken with other local, regional, state, or
federal agencies. All lands jointly acquired with other local, regional, state, or federal
agencies, including Municipalities, shall include, as part of the acquisition process,
some mutual written agreement regarding the responsibilities of the joint owners for
maintenance.
h. To borrow money through the issuance of bonds for the purposes provided herein, to
provide for and secure the payment thereof, and to provide for the rights of the holders
thereof.
i. To invest any funds held in reserves or sinking funds, or any funds not required for
immediate disbursement, in such investments as may be authorized for trust funds
under Florida Statutes, Section 215.47 as amended.
j. To insure and procure insurance against any loss in connection with any of the trust's
operations, including without limitation:
1. The repayment of any loans to mortgage lenders or mortgage loans;
2. Any project;
3. Any bonds of the County;
Insurance may be procured in such amounts and from such insurers, including the
Federal Government, as may be deemed necessary or desirable by Collier County.
k. To engage the services of private consultants on a contract basis for rendering
professional and technical assistance and advice.
1. To identify parcels of land that would be appropriate acquisitions.
m. To do any and all things necessary or convenient to carry out the purposes of, and
exercise the powers given and granted herein to the full extent of the law.
n. Funds may be transferred out of the Conservation Collier Acquisition Trust Fund for
any other County purpose if found to be in the best interest of the public by super
majority vote of the Board of County Commissioners.
Words underlined are added; Words struck throng k are deleted.
Page 6 of 17
34. Disbursements from the Conservation Collier Management Trust Fund shall be made by the
County Manager or his or her designee to manage Conservation Collier prepeiies lands eni
..f.tanee f « tr.e ... tbe«..e.t .. rpeses
set c i4h he,.ei and as approved by the Board of County
Commissioners.) Commented []C2]: BC - is the goal that management will be
done through the general fund? If so, add to Ordinance.
45. Funds may be transferred out of the Conservation Collier Management Trust Fund for any
other County purpose if found to be in the best interest of the public by super majority vote of I
e
Board of County Commissioners.
Commented []C3]: Does this belong in Section 15 "Sunset..."
SECTION ITT SEVEN: Land Acquisition Advisory Committee.
1. Creation and Purpose: The Land Acquisition Advisory Committee is hereby established to
assist the Board of County Commissioners in establishing an Active Properties Acquisition
List with qualified purchase recommendations consistent with the goals of Conservation
Collier. When active acquisition phases are not in place, the Land Acquisition Committee's
role shall be to review and make recommendations to the Board on the management and
programs of the preserved land.
2. Appointment and Composition: The Land Acquisition Advisory Committee shall be
composed of nine (9) members who are appointed by and will serve at the pleasure of the
Board of County Commissioners in accordance with Ordinance No. 2001-55, as amended.
Membership of the Land Acquisition Advisory Committee shall comprise broad and balanced
representation of the interests of Collier County citizens, including:
a. Environmental, land management and conservation interests in Collier County;
Words underlined are added; Words struck tkrougk are deleted.
Page 7 of 17
b. Agricultural and business interests in Collier County;
c. Educational interests in Collier County; and
d. General civic and citizen interests from throughout the county.
Individual members of the Land Acquisition Advisory Committee shall have expertise,
knowledge or interest in ecology, conservation of natural resources, real estate or land
acquisition, land appraisal, land management, eco-tourism or environmental education. A
nominee shall submit to the Board of County Commissioners written evidence of his or her
expertise, knowledge or interest in any of the above. The members of this committee should
include representatives from different areas of Collier County.
3. Terms of Office: The initial terms of office of the members shall be staggered between the
individual interests, for balance purposes, and be set as follows:
a. Three (3) members shall serve three (3) years.
b. Three (3) members shall serve two (2) years.
c. Three (3) members shall serve one (1) year.
Thereafter, all appointments shall be for a term of three (3) years. The process for
appointments and terms of office shall be governed by Collier County Ordinance No. 2001-
55, as amended.
4. Officers, Quorum and Rules of Procedure: At its earliest opportunity, the membership of the
Committee shall elect a chairperson and vice chairperson from among the members. Officers'
terms shall be for a period of one (1) year, with eligibility for reelection.
The presence of five (5) or more members shall constitute a quorum of the Committee
necessary to take action and transact business, unless active acquisition phases are not in
place in which case four (4) or more members shall constitute a quorum. The Committee
shall, by majority vote of the entire membership, adopt rules of procedure for the transaction
of business. The Land Acquisition Advisory Committee shall comply with the applicable
requirements of the Florida Sunshine Law, and shall keep a written record of meetings,
resolutions, findings and determinations in accordance with F.S. ch. 112. Copies of all
Committee minutes, resolutions, reports, and exhibits shall be submitted to the Board of
County Commissioners.
5. Attendance and Vacancies: Committee member attendance requirements, including failure to
attend meetings and member removal from office are governed by Collier County Ordinance
No. 2001-55, as amended.
6. Functions, Powers and Duties of the Land Acquisition Advisory Committee: The Land
Acquisition Advisory Committee shall have the following duties and responsibilities:
a. The Land Acquisition Advisory Committee's primary responsibility is to recommend to
the Board of County Commissioners an Active Properties Acquisition List with qualified
purchase recommendations consistent with the goals of Conservation Collier and
pursuant to the policies outlined herein below.
b. The Land Acquisition Advisory Committee may, from time to time, recommend to the
Board of County Commissioners proposed expenditures from the Conservation Collier
Words underlined are added; Words struck throng k are deleted.
Page 8 of 17
Trust Funds; additional selection or acquisition policies, procedures, and programs; and
other such matters as may be necessary to fulfill the purposes of Conservation Collier.
However, the goals and primary criteria of Conservation Collier may not be modified
except by countywide referendum vote.
c. The Land Acquisition Advisory Committee shall have no power or authority to commit
Collier County to any policies, to incur any financial obligations or to create any liability
on the part of the County. The actions and recommendations of the Land Acquisition
Advisory Committee are advisory only and shall not be binding upon the County unless
approved or adopted by the Board of County Commissioners.
d. At such time as there are insufficient uncommitted funds in the Conservation Collier
Acquisition Trust Fund to conclude another acquisition and all acquisition projects have
been closed, the Land Acquisition Advisory Committee shall report to the County
Commission and revert to a land management oversight function. If funds remain in the
Conservation Collier Acquisition Trust Fund these funds shall then be reviewed for
recommendation of transfer to the Conservation Collier Management Trust Fund and
transferred upon approval of the Board of County Commissioners. Thereafter, unless
and until additional funds are appropriated by the Board for the purpose of acquiring
additional Conservation Collier Program acquisitions, the Land Acquisition Advisory
Committee shall generally meet on a quarterly basis to review and make
recommendations to the Board as warranted regarding the management and programs of
the preserved land.
SECTION NINE EIGHT: Property Eligible for Acquisition and Maintenance.
1. Properties eligible to be considered for acquisition and management under Conservation
Collier shall be only environmentally sensitive lands available from willing and voluntary
participants, with acquisition priority given to those properties located within, but not limited
to, the Urban Area of Collier County, with the exception of lands currently designated
Stewardship Sending Areas within the Rural Lands Stewardship Area program.
2. Acquisition of property shall not be constrained based on the immediate availability of
management money.
3. Any environmentally sensitive land not on the acquisition list which is offered for conveyance
or donation to Collier County and is proposed for management by Conservation Collier shall
be evaluated as provided for herein below and may only be accepted and approved for
management by the Board of County Commissioners. Any lands with legal managemelit
obligations must be conveyed with adequate management endowment funds.
4. Acquisition of property can be in fee or by a conservation easement in a form approved by
the Board. If acquired by a conservation easement, the property will retain those development
rights as negotiated by the parties, including but not limited to agriculture and single-family
development. Additionally, for properties within the Rural Fringe Mixed Use District
Words underlined are added; Words struck throng k are deleted.
Page 9 of 17
Commented []C4]: Needs companion policy. TDRs
(Purchasing Policy needs updating) and management of CE.
Also CE doesn't give public access.
Recommendation: Needs a policy, questions availability for
accessibility, maintenance ofproperty (within 1 year of adoption)
CCLAAC raises concerns with retaining development credits.
5. The Board may sell Conservation Collier lands provided that the proceeds of the sale are put
back into the Conservation Collier Program. The proceeds may only be used for additional
purchases of environmentally sensitive land or for the maintenance of existing Conservation
Collier parcels. Commented []CS]: CCLAAC does not recommend inclusion of
#5. How is a parcel eligible for sale?
If it remains, CCLAAC would recommend that property no longer
�+�EN.�� fits the purpose AND criteria of the program. Super -majority of
TE
N NINE: Criteria for evaluating lands for acquisition and management. Board vote.
1. The evaluation of each acquisition proposal shall be based on satisfying at least' e three
four of the initial screening criteria below. Qualified sites shall then be further prioritized by
secondary evaluative criteria listed below under Subsection (b). The initial screening criteria
are:
a.--Jand with the most rare, unique and endangered habitats found in Collier County, order
of preference: tropical hardwood hammocks, xeric oak scrub, coastal strand, native
beach, xeric pine, riverine oak, high marsh (saline), tidal freshwater marsh, ore
a.b. Lands comprised of native habitats.
b:c_Lands offering the best human social values, including equitable geographic
distribution, appropriate access for natural resource -based recreation, and the
enhancement of the aesthetic setting of Collier County.
Ed_Land which protects the most water resource values, including aquifer recharge, water
quality, wetland dependent species habitat, and flood control.
d-e_Land containing the most biological value, including biodiversity, listed species,
habitat, connectivity, restoration potential, and ecological quality.
f. Land which enhances and/or protects the environmental value of current conservation
lands through function as a buffer, ecological link, or habitat corridor.
e-.g. Lands which provide climate resilience to drought, flooding and wildfire risks.
h_Any qualified land which meets at least *����e four of the above criteria and has
matching funds available and/or which Conservation Collier funds availability would
leverage a significantly higher funding rank in another acquisition program.
2. Those proposed acquisition proposals which are initially qualified under the screening
criteria shall be evaluated affd-faak-ed-by the staff and Land Acquisition Advisory Committee
using Secondary Ranking Criteria, based on site visit information which confirms or refutes
the initial screening criteria evaluation, and based on comparative size (to prefer larger or
similar parcels), vulnerability to destruction (to prefer most threatened of qualified parcels),
overall resource ecological quality (to prefer highest quality of similar parcels) and the
estimated feasibility and costs of management (to prefer the most manageable parcels).
3. The Board of County Commissioners hereby shall approve and make a part hereof the
attached initial list of Target Protection Areas within which are located specific sites which
generally satisfy the initial screening criteria and meet the goals of Conservation Collier. The
County Manager, or their designee, will provide the Board of County Commissioners with a
map and list of the target protection mailing areas on an annual basis. Inclusion on this list is
not a guarantee of any specific purchase. All specific proposals will be evaluated and
Words underlined are added; Words struck throng k are deleted.
Page 10 of 17
Commented []C6]: Update to match Florida Natural Areas
Inventory.
by staff and the Land Acquisition Advisory Committee for a recommendation of approval to
the Board of County Commissioners.
In accordance with the goals, policies and procedures of this Conservation Collier
Implementation Ordinance, the following list is the f-ifst Target Protection Areas adopted by
consideration by the Land Acquisition Advisory Committee, County Manager or their
designee, Staff and the Board of County Commissioners.
a. All designated Urban lands with predominantly native vegetative cover.
b. All Collier County Natural Resource Protection Areas and Sending Lands, as shown
on the Future Land Use Map of the Collier County Growth Management Plan.
C. All undeveloped lands with predominantly native vegetative cover in the Northern
Golden Gate Estates, as shown on the Future Land Use Map of the Collier County
Growth Management Plan.
d. The Flow -way and Habitat Stewardship Areas as depicted on the Future Land Use Map
of the Collier County Growth Management Plan, except for those areas currently
designated etpfepesec:as Stewardship Sending Areas.
4. The County Manager, or their designee, shall prepare and periodically update for
presentation to the Board of County Commissioners, a Conservation Collier Program
Manual, developed by staff and the Land Acquisition Advisory Committee, which, upon
approval by the Board of County Commissioners, shall be used as a guide for implementing
the provisions of this ordinance, and shall also include the initial and secondary criteria listed
herein above for evaluating Conservation Collier Acquisition Proposals. C enee ffle t of
Advisory lam. ff ff ittoo ^ if the mai+u,1 has net been e pleted
SECTION ELEAN TEN: Acquisition List.
The over-all Censer.,.tion Collie A ,.,.uisition List shall , ist of Conservation Collier Program
shall generate two specific lists: the Target Protections Areas List and the Active Acquisition List.
The Land Acquisition Advisory Committee and Board of County Commissioners shall approve
both in accordance with the procedures set forth below:
1. The Target Protection Areas List shall consist of lands representing the highest natural
resource values (such as Natural Resource Protection Areas), btA gene_all y of ..peel fie
pafeels is initially approved by Board of and shall be
updated periodically by the Board of County Commissioners and the Land Acquisition
Advisory Committee. It is established and updated in accordance with Conservation Collier
goals, procedures and criteria.
2. The Active Acquisition List shall consist of criteria -qualified sites that have been selected
from Target Protection Areas, as well as qualified acquisition proposals submitted to the
Land Acquisition Advisory Committee by the public, all of which have had applications
submitted by property owners. The Active Acquisition List shall separate proposals into three
(3) categories: A (pursue acquisition); B (hold for re -fig evaluation in the next cycle;
Words underlined are added; Words struck throng h are deleted.
Page 11 of 17
and C (no interest in acquiring). The A -category parcels/projects shall be further categorized
as 1 (high priority), 2 (medium priority), and 3 (low priority), in order to give County staff
direction as to priority for acquisition tasks. The n e five n ,.,., isitie List shall be .,plate
periodically aeeor-ding to Conservation Collier preeediff es and er-iteria. Site aequisitie
proposals that reeeive the highest evaluations pthrstiant to the Conservation Collier eriterial
and for whieh aequisition is feasible will be plaeed an this list, pending reeommendation b
Properties shall be added to the Active Acquisition List after the Initial
Criteria Screening Report (ICSR) is reviewed by the Land Acquisition Advisory Committee.
The Committee will then recommend the Active Acquisition List to the Board of County
Commissioners.
3. Once approved by the Board of County Commissioners, the County shall actively pursue
acquisition of A -category projects on the Active Acquisition List. All sites shall be pursued
on a voluntary "willing participant" basis only, without the use of the County's eminent
domain powers.
4. Pr-ejeets—EEqRerty will only be removed from the Active Acquisition List by successful
purchase of the site, approval of the next succeeding list, withdrawal of positive interest by
the property owner, or by resolution of the Board of County Commissioners. PrOjeets
Pro e removed may still be considered at a later time.
SECTION TWELVE ELEVEN: Nomination of acquisition proposals and candidate sites.
1. Nominations for the Conservation Collier Program may be made by any person or
organization, including Collier County, regional, State or Federal agencies, by contacting
program staff in writing and providing positive identification of the parcel/project through a
map or folio number(s). Staff will send an inquiry to the owner in the form of an interest
letter advising of the nomination and asking if the owner wishes to submit an application for
consideration to the Conservation Collier Program.
2. An owner may nominate his or her own property by submitting an application.
3. County staff will send letters of interest to property owners within Target Protection Areas
as directed by the Land Acquisition Advisory Committee asking if the owner wishes to
submit an application for consideration to the Conservation Collier Program.
4. An application submitted by the property owner to the County Manager, or his -their designee,
shall be evidence of a willing seller.
5. mile Public and landowner applications nominating properties for acquisition may
be submitted at any time, during or after the first annual public solicitation meeting
(described below), applications shall be
evaluated as they are
received.
6. There will be an annual public meeting for the purpose of updating the Board of County
Commissioners and the public for soliciting proposals and applications if the program is in
Words underlined are added; Words struck throng k are deleted.
Page 12 of 17
a buying cycle. The first such meeting will take place at the end of the first year of
implementation of Conservation Collier.
7. Owner interest shall be disclosed in applications in the same manner as required of zoning
applicants by the Collier County Land Development Code.
SECTION BEN TWELVE: Procedure for selection of acquisition proposals for
placement on the active acquisition list and subsequent purchase procedures.
Acquisition proposals for which applications have been received shall be prescreened using
the initial screening criteria. These. sr.,,f watt', fy .we "` eu4 of six (6) of the lnit M Ser-eeffin .
Critefia shall be fb�arded to the Land Aequisition Advisory Cenunittee for a vote for
eemplete Ac uisition j2rgposals which do not satisfy four 3 out of
seven (67) of the Initial Screening Criteria or which satisfy initial screening criteria but f
other reasons may not fulfill the purposes of Conservation Collier will be reported to the
Land Acquisition Advisory Committee, but will not be evaluated further unless at least five
[51 members of the Land Acquisition Advisory Committee vote for a complete evaluation.
2. Aequisition proposals whieh do not satisfy the initial sereening eriteria or- w-hieh satisfy initial
f4fther unless at least 4—A r ] membefs of the Land Aequisitien Advisory Committee vete
Acquisition ro osals which satisfy €iy-e—six 36 out of siyseve
(76) of the Initial Screening Criteria and fulfill the purposes of Conservation Collier will
forego the Land acquisition Advisory Committee and be placed on a Board of County
Commissioners agenda for consideration by the Board to move forward with the acquisition
process.
Proposals which satisfy four out of six --seven the -initial screening criteria will be further
evaluated for presentation to the Land Acquisition Advisory Committee for review and
ranking by staff or a qualified third -party. Evaluation shall include a site visit, which staff
shall coordinate with the property owner, and which may include one advisory committee
member, review of information about the parcel(s) available in the county's electronic
databases and research into any other records retained by the county about the parcel(s). Using
both observed and gathered data staff or a qualified third party shall prepare an Initial Criteria
Screening Report (ICSR) which will include boundary and location maps for each site,
descriptions of the biological and hydrological characteristics, including initial criteria
satisfied, a summary of its potential for appropriate use, development potential of the site and
adjacent land, an assessment of the management needs and costs, the assessed and estimated
value, and any potentially available matching funds.
4. Upon completion of the ICSR, the Land Acquisition Advisory Committee shall hold a public
hearing where staff will present information contained in the ICSR regarding each site, the
applicants' and/or landowners' comments, and comments from the public. A courtesy notice
Words underlined are added; Words struck throng k are deleted.
Page 13 of 17
Commented []C7]: CCLAAC allows for public comments /
more due diligence. Work out the concerns at the meeting, not BCC.
How many parcels within last 20 years would have met this change?
Recommendation: Given all other changes to expedite the process,
this isn't necessarv. Public visibility is achieved at CCLAAC.
shall be provided to the owners of properties which are the subject of the hearing, although
failure to notify said owners shall not invalidate these proceedings.
5. , The Land
Acquisition Advisory Committee shall evaluate all qualified proposals using criteria; as
documented in the ICSR, along with; public comments, and their own experience and
judgments, and then rank the par-eelss rn op= according to the A, B and C ranking categories
to or-eate-a and place it on the recommended Active Acquisition List at a public hearing.
Additional meetings may be called to complete this task.
6. The recommended Active Acquisition List shall be forwarded to the Board of County
Commissioners, who, in a public meeting, shall vote on whether to approve all or part of the
proposed Active Acquisition List. Properties may be added but any additional properties must
be subjected to the entire evaluation process.
7. County Staff shall notify property owners and the public of the final approved Active
Acquisition List.
8. After approval of the Active Acquisition List, Real Property Management Es'"'�s�se Services
staff will arrange for appraisals for A -category parcels/projects and when appraisals are
received make an offer to the owner(s) pursuant to the approved Conservation Collier Land
Acquisition Purchase Policy (Resolution No. 2003-195, or as superseded). Parcels located
within the Rural Fringe Mixed Use District "Sending" lands are subject to additional
requirements regarding Transfer of Development Rights (TDR) credits, as specified in the
Conservation Collier Land Acquisition Purchase Policy, Resolution 2003-195, or as
superseded. Once an offer is accepted, Real Estate Services staff will prepare a contract and
request the owner sign. This signed contract will be presented to the Board of County
Commissioners at a public hearing for the Board's review and consideration.I
Aequisition A&isofy Committee at a p4lie meeting to deeide, by majority vote, whether- to
Along with the
contract, staff will provide a Project Design Report for each parcel/project, including cost,
history, purpose of project, and program qualifications.
1-1 th
will b e pr-e s en *e d tee th te B ne ar-d e f G etw�y G em-m-iss i e- 4; ews -A* a pub 1i e hearing fef their- review
and appr-eva4.
4-0 9. The Board of County Commissioners shall have final approval authority of the contract
terms for each proposed project and shall authorize any and all purchases.
44 10. Once a contract has been approved and executive by the Board of County Commissioners
in accordance with County policies, Real Property Management Est4e Sefviees shall proceed
to close on the purchase of property in accordance with County policies.
SECTION FOURTEEN THIRTEEN: Management Plans and Use of Environmentally
Sensitive Lands.
Words underlined are added; Words struck throng k are deleted.
Page 14 of 17
1. No later than ninety six months from the date of acquisition, an interim management
plan for any property acquired shall be submitted by County staff to the Land Acquisition
Advisory Committee for approval. Upon approval, the plan shall be submitted to the Board
of County Commissioners for final approval and shall be implemented by the County
Manager, or their designee, pursuant to the Board's direction. Any such interim management
plan(s) shall not be implemented for more than two (2) years after acquisition of the property,
prior to the expiration of two (2) years, either a new management plan shall be implemented,
or, by affirmative action of the Board, the interim plan shall continue.
2. A final management plan, with required review and updating every ten years, shall be
prepared, with review and input of the Land Acquisition Advisory Committee, for each
property acquired by Conservation Collier which shall:
a. Identify such management activities as are necessary to preserve, enhance, restore,
conserve, maintain, or monitor the resource, as appropriate; and
b. Identify such uses as are consistent with the preservation, enhancement, restoration,
conservation, and maintenance of the resource; and
c. Estimate the annual costs of managing the project.
3. Annually, the ten-year management plans prepared during the preceding year shall be
submitted to the Board of County Commissioners for its approval. Each ten-year
management plan shall be
approval, and may be amended as often as required. Management plan updates and
amendments shall be reviewed by the Land Acquisition Advisory Committee for their input
and recommendations and then submitted to the Board of County Commissioners for
approval.
4. All management plans shall be consistent with the purposes set forth herein. All properties
acquired or managed through Conservation Collier shall be managed in accordance with the
approved management plan for that property.
5. No use, infrastructure, or improvement shall be permitted on any property acquired or
managed under Conservation Collier that is inconsistent with the purposes of the program or
that is not provided by an approved management plan for the property.
6. The County will seek cooperative management arrangements with other agencies and entities,
in keeping with the approved management plan for the property.
7. Purchasing land using Conservation Collier program funds permanently extinguishes all
development rights except those strictly compatible with the purposes and goals of
Conservation Collier, unless such lands are exchanged for similar lands within and between
multi -parcel projects that have been previously recommended by the Conservation Collier
Land Acquisition Advisory Committee and approved by the Board of County
Commissioners in accordance with the goals and purposes of the Program. In case of these
land exchanges, development rights are restored to those properties exchanged out of County
ownership.
8. Public access is an important element of management and this Program. Examples of
permitted uses, subject to compatibility with specific parcels, include: hiking, nature
photography, bird watching, kayaking, canoeing, swimming, hunting, and fishing. The
program will also make the acquired sites available, with minimal risk to the environmental
integrity of the site, to educate Collier County's school -age population and the general public
Words underlined are added; Words struck throng k are deleted.
Page 15 of 17
about the uniqueness and importance of Collier County's subtropical ecosystems and natural
communities.
SECTION BEN FOURTEEN: Responsibilities of the County Manager.
The County Manager shall facilitate such activities, designate such staff, and assign such
responsibilities as are necessary to fulfill the purposes of this Ordinance.
SECTION SIXTEEN FIFTEEN: Sunset of the Conservation Collier ad valorem tax.
special g pooi
1. The Conservation less reauthorized through a ax esimilar voter venue will �referenduset in smp la erov ar 0or by Board of -commented [Ica]: noes the referendum support 10 years or
County Commissioners super majority ayproval. within 10 years (i.e., 12 years, with some years of no funding).
2. The Management Trust Fund continues in perpetuity, as long as Conservation Collier lands
remain in County hands.
Commented [7C9]: Satne as Section 6 (6) - where does it
belong?
SECTION SEVENTEEN SIXTEEN: CONFLICT AND SEVERABILITY.
In the event this Ordinance conflicts with any other ordinance of Collier County or other
applicable law, the more restrictive shall apply. If any phrase or portion of the Ordinance is held
invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be deemed a
separate, distinct and independent provision and such holding shall not affect the validity of the
remaining portion.
SECTION EIG14TEEN SEVENTEEN: INCLUSION IN THE CODE OF LAWS AND
ORDINANCES.
The provisions of this Ordinance shall become and be made a part of the Code of Laws and
Ordinances of Collier County, Florida. The sections of the Ordinances may be renumbered or
relettered to accomplish such, and the word "ordinance" may be changed to "section," "article," or
any other appropriate word.
SECTION NINETEEN EIGHTEEN: EFFECTIVE DATE.
This Ordinance shall be effective upon filing with the Secretary of State.
Words underlined are added; Words struck throng k are deleted.
Page 16 of 17
PASSED AND DULY ADOPTED by the Board of County Commissioners of Collier
County, Florida, this _day of 12024.
ATTEST: BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
CRYSTAL K. KINZEL, CLERK COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
Ltm
By:
, Deputy Clerk Chris Hall, Chairman
Approved as to form and legality:
Jeffrey A. Klatzkow
County Attorney
Words underlined are added; Words struck throng h are deleted.
Page 17 of 17
Conservation Collier Land Acquisition Program
Initial Screening Criteria Form
Location Description: North off 501" Ave. NE, south of Immokalee Rd. and east of Everglades Blvd. N within the
NGGE Scrub Target Protection Mailing Area (TPMA).
Property Description
Owner
Address and/or Folio
Acreage
MCINTOSH FAMILY TRUST
38664720002
2.73
Nominations to the Conservation Collier Program are based on satisfying at least two of the initial screening
criteria below. Qualified sites shall then be further prioritized by secondary evaluative criteria.
1. Does the property contain native plant communities? If yes, are any of the following unique and
endangered plant communities present on the property? (Ord. 2002-63, Sec 10(1)(a)
Yes ® No ❑ (If yes, briefly describe how parcel meets the above criteria):
Mapped as Scrubby Flatwoods, Mixed Scrub -Shrub Wetland, Cypress
Ordinance Plant Community
Corresponding Priority Natural Community
(Florida Cooperative Land Cover System)
Presence
Tropical Hardwood Hammock
Upland Hardwood Forest
❑
Xeric Oak Scrub
Scrub
❑
Coastal Strand
Coastal Upland
❑
Native Beach
Coastal Upland
❑
Xeric Pine
Scrub/Pine Flatwood
Riverine Oak
-
❑
High Marsh (Saline)
Coastal Wetland
❑
Tidal Freshwater Marsh
Coastal Wetland
❑
Other Native Habitats
2. Does the property offer significant human social values, such as equitable geographic distribution,
appropriate access for nature -based recreation, and enhancement of the aesthetic setting of Collier
County? Ord. 2002-63, Sec. 10 (1)(b)
Yes ® No ❑ (If yes, briefly describe how parcel meets the above criteria):
The property is accessible from 501" Ave. The parcel offers land -based opportunities for natural resource -
based recreation, including but not limited to, environmental education, hiking, and nature photography.
Does the property offer opportunities for protection of water resource values, including aquifer recharge,
water quality enhancement, protection of wetland dependent species habitat, and flood control? Ord.
2002-63, Sec. 10 (1)(c)
Yes ® No ❑ (If yes, briefly describe how parcel meets the above criteria):
The entire parcel is mapped as containing 100% hydric soils and the southern half of the parcel contains
wetlands that would hold water during the wet season. The parcel is also mapped as contributing
moderately to aquifer recharge.
Does the property offer significant biological values, including biodiversity, listed species habitat,
connectivity, restoration potential and ecological quality? Ord. 2002-63, Sec. 10 (1)(d)
Yes ® No ❑ (If yes, briefly describe how parcel meets the above criteria):
The native plant communities present within the parcel provide habitat for a suite of both upland and
wetland dependent species and wildlife including gopher tortoise and listed wading birds.
3. Does the property enhance and/or protect the environmental value of current conservation lands through
function as a buffer, ecological link or habitat corridor? Ord. 2002-63, Sec. 10 (1)(e)
Yes ❑ No ❑ (If yes, briefly describe how parcel meets the above criteria):
Parcels are not adjacent to conservation lands and do not provide an ecological link to conservation lands.
Any qualified land which meets at least two of the above criteria and has matching funds available and/or
which Conservation Collier funds availability would leverage a significantly higher funding rank in another
acquisition program. Ord. 2002-63, Sec. 10 (1)(f)
Is the property within the boundary of another agency's acquisition project?
Yes ❑ No ❑
If yes, will use of Conservation Collier funds significantly increase the rank or funding priority of the parcel
for the other agency's acquisition program?
Yes ❑ No ❑
MEETS INITIAL SCREENING CRITERIA ❑Yes ❑No
The properties satisfy 4 initial screening criteria
Figure 1: McIntosh Family Trust Location Map
Miles
MCINTOSH FAMILY TRUST
Northern Golden Gate Estates Scrub TPMA
Conservation Collier Preserve
CONSLR ,AT' ON
r LLIER
Cc+1[rer Couvtt�' � �'`-
Figure 2: NGGE Scrub TPMA Parcels Overview Map
1 0 0.75
Miles
MCINTOSH FAMILY TRUST
DOMBROWISKI, BARBARA J (B-list parcel)
NGGE Scrub TPMA -
CON •Efb AT10N
C LLIER
Coen County �v'`=.
Figure 3: McIntosh Family Trust Aerial Map
o 0.1
Miles
- 1
x
Conservation Collier Land Acquisition Program
Initial Screening Criteria Form
Location Description: The intersection of S. Barfield Dr. and Inlet Dr. - 511 S. Barfield Dr., Marco Island, FL
34145; Marco Island TPMA
Property Description
Owner
Address and/or Folio
Acreage
W L RAMOSKI REV LIVING TRUST
57800240000
0.40
Nominations to the Conservation Collier Program are based on satisfying at least two of the initial screening
criteria below. Qualified sites shall then be further prioritized by secondary evaluative criteria.
1. Does the property contain native plant communities? If yes, are any of the following unique and
endangered plant communities present on the property? (Ord. 2002-63, Sec 10(1)(a)
Yes ® No ❑ (If yes, briefly describe how parcel meets the above criteria):
Mapped as Residential, Medium Density. Appears to be a mowed lot with some shrubs and trees in the
northeast corner that consist of a combination of coastal scrub and tropical hardwood hammock.
Ordinance Plant Community
Corresponding Priority Natural Community
(Florida Cooperative Land Cover System)
Presence
Tropical Hardwood Hammock
Upland Hardwood Forest
Xeric Oak Scrub
Scrub
❑
Coastal Strand
Coastal Upland
❑
Native Beach
Coastal Upland
❑
Xeric Pine
Scrub/Pine Flatwood
❑
Riverine Oak
-
❑
High Marsh (Saline)
Coastal Wetland
❑
Tidal Freshwater Marsh
Coastal Wetland
❑
Other Native Habitats
❑
2. Does the property offer significant human social values, such as equitable geographic distribution,
appropriate access for nature -based recreation, and enhancement of the aesthetic setting of Collier
County? Ord. 2002-63, Sec. 10 (1)(b)
Yes ❑ No ❑ (If yes, briefly describe how parcel meets the above criteria):
The parcel is accessible from a sidewalk off S. Barfield Dr. and off Inlet Dr. along the City of Marco Island's
mixed -use pathway.
3. Does the property offer opportunities for protection of water resource values, including aquifer recharge,
water quality enhancement, protection of wetland dependent species habitat, and flood control? Ord.
2002-63, Sec. 10 (1)(c)
Yes ❑ No ❑ (If yes, briefly describe how parcel meets the above criteria):
The parcel contains no wetlands and is mapped as contributing minimally to aquifer recharge.
4. Does the property offer significant biological values, including biodiversity, listed species habitat,
connectivity, restoration potential and ecological quality? Ord. 2002-63, Sec. 10 (1)(d)
Yes ❑ No ❑ (If yes, briefly describe how parcel meets the above criteria):
Based on the property's location, it most likely contains burrowing owls and gopher tortoise.
5. Does the property enhance and/or protect the environmental value of current conservation lands through
function as a buffer, ecological link or habitat corridor? Ord. 2002-63, Sec. 10 (1)(e)
Yes ❑ No ❑ (If yes, briefly describe how parcel meets the above criteria):
The parcel is not adjacent to other conservation lands.
Any qualified land which meets at least two of the above criteria and has matching funds available and/or
which Conservation Collier funds availability would leverage a significantly higher funding rank in another
acquisition program. Ord. 2002-63, Sec. 10 (1)(f)
Is the property within the boundary of another agency's acquisition project?
Yes ❑ No ❑
If yes, will use of Conservation Collier funds significantly increase the rank or funding priority of the parcel
for the other agency's acquisition program?
Yes ❑ No ❑
MEETS INITIAL SCREENING CRITERIA ❑Yes ❑No
The property satisfies 3 initial screening criteria
Figure 1: Ramoski Trust Location Map
&4RBAROSACT
ens
c4yNF
NA�Al
�Ry
ORLEANS CT i CT
HK Investment
Van Cleef
.�
GALLEON AVE
F. GALLEON CT MEDEIRA CT p
J o
ALMERIA CT MACAO CT
U
v
z
9
_
z
R
a
<
L�
a
V
WINTERBERRY DR
x F
G�
Pe��L
Ramoskit Trust
2'm�
OPa
2DG
v
Oa
n
T�VlDA rER
DEVON CT
n
r-
w
z
NCOPE44Np p%2
OLbS CT
D
O 2y
O,p
u� LuDLGtN RD
J�
MCILV"NkF CT
w
z_
�R
a
CAXAM84S CT a
�
W
m
NE GHrs CT
U
SHORES CT 2
ADDISON CT
m
Z
r
OSCEDLA CT �'
d
A
S INLET DR
Legend
Cycle 12 TPhriA
Closing Pending
Application Received
� Conservation Collier Preserve
N
CON AT10N
LLIER
Co er County
0 0.5 1
Miles
Figure 2: Ramoski Trust Surrounding Lands Aerial Map
�; t..
1414
Y A
fi �V I
ORLEANS *CT� # E 4 C7 l ,'
e
%
°BEGONIA
G�ALLEOCTo- ':, i N'IEDEIRACT
Q U
�,�,� Q
ALM ERI/a(GT " MA A0'CT 0 .
yWill NTERBE16
7.
RRY DR Y
� a
INLET DR, R �- /
'APCT
0
Mims
Ramoski Trust
H K Investment Inc
Gary Van Cleef
Annecy Marco LLC
® Cycle 12 TPMA parcel
0.45
CON E-R ATION
C LLIEii
Co ev County %L]
Figure 3. Ramoski Trust Aerial Map
Miles
0.03
CON ATION
LLIER
Co ev County
Figure 4. Google Streetview photo of Ramoski Trust parcel looking east from S. Barfield Dr.
Figure 5. Google Streetview photo of Ramoski Trustparcel looking north from Inlet Dr.
Conservation Collier Initial Criteria Screening Report
Sarry Trust
Acreage: 13.3 ac
Folios: 00348160000, 00348200009
Staff Report Date: January 3, 2024
Total Score: 186/400
180 160
160
140
120
100 80 80 80
80 63 64
60 33
40 27
20
0
1 - Ecological 2 - Human Value 3 - Restoration 4 - Vulnerability
Value and Management
■ Awarded Points 0 Possible Points
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
Table of Contents
Tableof Contents......................................................................................................................................... 2
1. Introduction........................................................................................................................................... 4
2. Summary of Property............................................................................................................................ 5
Figure 1 - Parcel Location Overview...........................................................................................5
Figure2 - Parcel Close-up.........................................................................................................................6
2.1 Summary of Property Information....................................................................................................7
Table 1— Summary of Property Information.....................................................................................7
Figure 3 - Secondary Criteria Score....................................................................................................8
Table 2 - Secondary Criteria Score Summary.....................................................................................8
2.2 Summary of Assessed Value and Property Cost Estimates..............................................................9
Table 3. Assessed & Estimated Value................................................................................................9
2.2.1 Zoning, Growth Management and Conservation Overlays....................................................9
2.3 Summary of Initial Screening Criteria Satisfaction (Ord. 2002-63, Sec. 10).................................
10
3. Initial Screening Criteria......................................................................................................................12
3.1 Ecological Values.............................................................................................................................
12
3.1.1 Vegetative Communities.......................................................................................................
12
Figure 4 - CLIP4 Priority Natural Communities........................................................................
13
Figure 5 - Florida Cooperative Land Cover Classification System ............................................
14
Figure 6 — Cypress/Pine/Cabbage Palm...................................................................................
15
Figure 7 — Cypress/Pine Cabbage Palm with pines killed by fire ..............................................
15
3.1.2 Wildlife Communities............................................................................................................
16
Table 4— Listed Wildlife Detected...........................................................................................
16
Figure 8 - Wildlife Spatial Data (i.e., telemetry, roosts, etc) ....................................................
17
Figure 9 - CLIP4 Potential Habitat Richness.............................................................................
18
3.1.3 Water Resources...................................................................................................................
19
Figure 10 - CLIP Aquifer Recharge Priority and Wellfield Protection Zones ............................
20
Figure 11 - Collier County Soil Survey......................................................................................
21
Figure 12 LIDAR Elevation Map...............................................................................................
22
3.1.4 Ecosystem Connectivity........................................................................................................
23
Figure 13 - Conservation Lands...............................................................................................
24
3.2 Human Values.................................................................................................................................
25
3.2.1 Recreation.............................................................................................................................
25
2
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
3.2.2 Accessibility........................................................................................................................... 25
3.2.3 Aesthetic/Cultural Enhancement......................................................................................... 25
Figure 14 — View of property showing proximity to 1-75......................................................... 25
3.3 Restoration and Management....................................................................................................... 26
3.3.1 Vegetation Management...................................................................................................... 26
3.3.1.1 Invasive Vegetation..................................................................................................... 26
3.3.1.2 Prescribed Fire............................................................................................................ 26
3.3.2 Remediation and Site Security.............................................................................................. 26
3.3.3 Assistance.............................................................................................................................. 26
3.4 Vulnerability.................................................................................................................................... 26
3.4.1 Zoning and Land Use............................................................................................................. 26
Figure15 - Zoning.................................................................................................................... 28
Figure 16 - Zoning Overlays..................................................................................................... 29
Figure 17 — Future Land Use................................................................................................... 30
3.4.2 Development Plans............................................................................................................... 31
4. Acquisition Considerations.................................................................................................................. 31
5. Management Needs and Costs..............................................................................................................31
Table 5 - Estimated Costs of Site Remediation, Improvements, and Management ................ 31
5. Potential for Matching Funds..............................................................................................................31
6. Secondary Criteria Scoring Form.........................................................................................................32
7. Additional Site Photos.........................................................................................................................38
APPENDIX 1— Critical Lands and Water Identification Maps (CLIP) Definitions......................................43
3
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
1. Introduction
The Conservation Collier Program (Program) is an environmentally sensitive land acquisition and
management program approved by the Collier County Board of County Commissioners (Board) in 2002
and by Collier County Voters in 2002 and 2006. The Program was active in acquisition between 2003 and
2011, under the terms of the referendum. Between 2011 and 2016, the Program was in management
mode. In 2017, the Collier County Board reauthorized Conservation Collier to seek additional lands
(2/14/17, Agenda Item 11B). On November 3, 2020, the Collier County electors approved the
Conservation Collier Re-establishment referendum with a 76.5% majority.
This Initial Criteria Screening Report (ICSR) has been prepared for the Conservation Collier Program in its
12th acquisition cycle to meet requirements specified in the Conservation Collier Implementation
Ordinance, 2002-63, as amended, and for purposes of the Conservation Collier Program. The sole
purpose of this report is to provide objective data to demonstrate how properties meet the criteria
defined by the ordinance.
The following sections characterize the property location and assessed value, elaborate on the initial and
secondary screening criteria scoring, and describe potential funding sources, appropriate use, site
improvements, and estimated management costs.
4
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust
2. Summary of Property
PINE RIDGE RD
J
m
to
StV D
Date: January 3, 2024
Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
1-75
C]
J
m
z
0
M
J
T I I 1 1 I I 1 1 I I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I
0 0.5 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Miles
Conservation Collier Preserve
SARRY TR, GABRIEL
Managed Conservation Areas
Other Conservation Areas
CON 5-E-R VATI ON
J C LLIER
Co er County `- I-4
Figure 1 - Parcel Location Overview
5
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
0 0.1 0.2
Miles
Figure 2 - Parcel Close-up
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust
2.1 Summary of Property Information
Table 1 — Summary of Property Information
Date: January 3, 2024
Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
Characteristic
Value
Comments
Name
Sarry Trust
Folio Number
Two
00348160000, 00348200009
Target Protection Area
RFMUD-Sending
Not within a TPMA
Size
13.3 acres
Section, Township, and
Range
534, Twn 49, R27
Base Zoning is Agricultural; Sending Lands within Rural
Zoning Category/TDRs
A— RFMUD-NRPA-
Fringe Mixed Use District within a Natural Resource
NBMO-Sending
Protection Area and with a North Belle Meade Overlay;
Allowable use is 1 residential dwelling per parcel
Existing structures
None
Residential,
Single Family Residence adjacent to the west; private
Adjoining properties
Conservation Easements to the north and east; 1-75
and their Uses
Conservation,
directly adjacent to the south; Picayune Strand State
Transportation
Forest south of 1-75
Development Plans
Submitted
None
Known Property
None known
Irregularities
Other County Dept
Transportation
Potential Wilson corridor extension
Interest
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
Total Score: 186/400
180
160
160
140
120
100
80 80 80
80 63 64
60
40 33 27
20
0
1 - Ecological Value 2 - Human Value 3 - Restoration and 4 - Vulnerability
Management
■ Awarded Points ❑ Possible Points
Figure 3 - Secondary Criteria Score
Table 2 - Secondary Criteria Score Summary
Criteria
Awarded
Weighted Points
Possible
Weighted Points
Awarded/Possible
Points
1 - Ecological Value
63
160
39%
1.1 - Vegetative Communities
13
53
25%
1.2 - Wildlife Communities
24
27
90%
1.3 - Water Resources
8
27
30%
1.4 - Ecosystem Connectivity
17
53
33%
2 - Human Values
33
80
41%
2.1 - Recreation
11
34
33%
2.2 - Accessibility
19
34
54%
2.3 - Aesthetics/Cultural Enhancement
3
11
25%
3 - Restoration and Management
64
80
80%
3.1 - Vegetation Management
55
55
100%
3.2 - Remediation and Site Security
9
23
40%
3.3 - Assistance
0
2
0%
4 - Vulnerability
27
80
33%
4.1 - Zoning and Land Use
24
58
42%
4.2 - Development Plans
2
22
10%
Total
186
400
47%
n.
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
2.2 Summary of Assessed Value and Property Cost Estimates
The interest being appraised is fee simple "as is" for the purchase of the site. A value of the property was
estimated using only one of the three traditional approaches to value, the sales comparison approach.
It is based on the principal of substitution that an informed purchaser would pay no more for the rights
in acquiring a particular real property than the cost of acquiring, without undue delay, an equally
desirable one. Three properties were selected for comparison, each with similar site characteristics,
utility availability, zoning classification and road access. No inspection was made of the property or
comparables used in this report and the Real Estate Services Department staff relied upon information
solely provided by program staff. The valuation conclusion is limited only by the reported assumptions
and conditions that no other known or unknown adverse conditions exist.
If the Board of County Commissioners choose to acquire this property, an appraisal by an independent
Real Estate Appraiser will be obtained at that time. Pursuant to the Conservation Collier Purchase Policy,
one appraisal is required for the Sarry Trust property, which has an initial valuation less than $500,000;
1 independent Real Estate Appraiser will value the subject property and that appraisal report will be
used to determine the offer made on the subject property.
Table 3. Assessed & Estimated Value
Property owner
Address
Acreage
Assessed Value*
Estimated Value**
Gabriel Sarry Trust
No address
13.3
$168,245
TBD
* Assessed Value is obtained from the Property Appraiser's Website. The Assessed Value is based off
the current use of the property.
**The Estimated Market Value for the parcels will be obtained from the Collier County Real Estate
Services Department prior to the March 2024 CCLAAC ranking.
2.2.1 Zoning, Growth Management and Conservation Overlays
Zoning, growth management and conservation overlays will affect the value of a parcel. These parcels
are in the Rural Fringe Mixed Use Overlay (RFMUO) Sending Lands within a Natural Resource
Protection Area (NRPA), with a North Belle Meade Overlay. RFMUO Sending Lands designation allows
for 1 dwelling unit per 40 acres, or 1 dwelling unit per parcel if parcel is under 40 acres. Therefore, one
dwelling unit could be developed on each of the Sarry Trust parcels.
9
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
2.3 Summary of Initial Screening Criteria Satisfaction (Ord. 2002-63, Sec. 10)
Criteria 1: Native Habitats
Are any of the following unique and endangered plant communities found on the property?
Order of preference as follows:
i.
Hardwood hammocks
No
ii.
Xeric oak scrub
No
iii.
Coastal strand
No
iv.
Native beach
No
V.
Xeric pine
No
vi.
Riverine Oak
No
vii.
High marsh (saline)
No
viii.
Tidal freshwater marsh
No
ix.
Other native habitats
YES
Statement for Satisfaction of Criteria 1: Parcels contain Mixed Scrub -Shrub Wetland and
Cypress/Pine/Cabbage Palm
Criteria 2: Human Social Values
Does land offer significant human social values, such as equitable geographic distribution,
appropriate access for nature -based recreation, and enhancement of the aesthetic setting of
Collier County? NO
Statement for Satisfaction of Criteria 2: The property is accessible via the private Blackburn road
with no connection to other County owned property that could provide access in the future.
Criteria 3: Water Resources
Does the property offer opportunities for protection of water resource values, including aquifer
recharge, water quality enhancement, protection of wetland dependent species habitat, and
flood control? YES
Statement for Satisfaction of Criteria 3: The property is mapped as containing 100% hydric soils
and most likely holds water during the wet season.
10
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust
Criteria 4: Biological and Ecological Value
Date: January 3, 2024
Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
Does the property offer significant biological values, including biodiversity, listed species habitat,
connectivity, restoration potential and ecological quality? YES
Statement for Satisfaction of Criteria 4: The parcels provide FL panther habitat, FL black bear
habitat and potential Big Cypress fox squirrel, red -cockaded woodpecker, and gopher tortoise
habitat.
Criteria 5: Enhancement of Current Conservation Lands
Does the property enhance and/or protect the environmental value of current conservation lands
through function as a buffer, ecological link or habitat corridor? YES
Is this property within the boundary of another agency's acquisition project? NO
Statement for Satisfaction of Criteria 5: The parcels to the north and east of the property are
protected under private U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service conservation easements.
The property satisfies 4 initial screening criteria
11
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust
3. Initial Screening Criteria
3.1 Ecological Values
Date: January 3, 2024
Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
3.1.1 Vegetative Communities
The vegetative communities found on the Sarry Trust property are similar to those found on the North
Belle Meade Preserve to the west. The wildfire that recently passed through the area caused severe
canopy and mid -story mortality within the Sarry property, and the hydrology of the area has been
affected by the 1-75 canal to the south. Throughout the property, many slash pine (Pinus elliotti var.
densa) trees were lost in the fire and much of the groundcover appears to have been severely
impacted.
The primary plant community present within the Sarry Trust property can best be described as
Cypress/Pine/Cabbage Palm. Areas of Mixed Scrub -Shrub Wetland are also present. The midstory in
both plant communities is dominated by cabbage palm (Saba) palmetto). Canopy within the
Cypress/Pine/Cabbage Palm includes slash pine and some small cypress (Taxodium spp.) along with
cabbage palm. Saw palmetto (Serenoa repens) and cabbage palm are also present in the groundcover
of the Cypress/Pine/Cabbage Palm. Both communities contain a mix of grasses, sedges, and
herbaceous plants in the groundcover including sawgrass (Cladium jamaicense), blue maidencane
(Amphicarpum muehlenbergianum), swamp fern (Telmatoblechnum serrulatum), and southern
dewberry (Rubus trivialis).
Invasive plants encountered include cogon grass (Imperata cylindrica), Caesar weed (Urena lobata),
melaleuca (Melaleuca quinquenervia), Brazilian pepper (Schinus terebinthifolia), small -leaf climbing
fern (Lygodium microphyllum), and shrubby false buttonwood (Spermacoce verticillata).
No listed plant species were observed on the property during the site visit.
12
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
BLACKBURN RD
175
175
0 0A 0.2
Miles
SARRY TR, GABRIEL
CLIP4 Priority Natural
Communities
Priority 1 (highest)
Priority 2
Priority 3
Priority 4
Figure 4 - CLIP4 Priority Natural Communities
CON , ., f ATION
LLIER
CHIN., County -lw t
13
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
I_ 0 0.1 0.2
Miles
SARRY TR, GABRIEL
Florida Cooperative Land Cover Classification System
Canal
Hydric Pine Flatwoods
Mixed Scrub -Shrub Wetland
Rural Open
Transportation
Figure 5 - Florida Cooperative Land Cover Classification System
14
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
Figure 6 — Cypress/Pine/Cabbage Palm
Figure 7 — Cypress/Pine Cabbage Palm with pines killed by fire
15
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
3.1.2 Wildlife Communities
CLIP4 Species Richness Maps show potential for 5-6 focal species to utilize the properties including federally
endangered Florida panther, red -cockaded woodpecker, Florida bonneted bat, and state -threatened Florida
gopher tortoise and Big Cypress fox squirrel. A radio collared panther was tracked on the property in 2016, and
panther telemetry from 1986-2020 shows consistent utilization of the surrounding area by radio -collared
individuals, most recently a breeding female with kittens. FWC panther road mortality data along Interstate 75
indicates there is movement of Florida panther between the site, the surrounding lands and the Picayune Strand
State Forest, with the most recent road mortalities occurring in March 2020. The property is included within
known historic nesting/foraging habitat for endangered red -cockaded woodpeckers.
Table 4 — Listed Wildlife Detected
State
Federal
Common Name
Scientific Name
Mode of Detection
Status
Status
Florida Panther
Puma concolar coryi
Endangered
Endangered
FWC Telemetry
16
�L
L A �
AL A L
AA
t� t� At_� t�� t�
�,
_
-r T ate.
A
_
t
' r _�—__,.
•V�� eat—•�= -
r}i
- -
A
t
-�r�
®`-
Sol/.•
-
Rl
=L : A,&
AAL
A
A
A
1
i
Ali
Al A
Ai
a� A
A
AA
ILA_
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
I1
I
6
BLACKBURNI RD —
175
175
0 0.1
Miles
SARRY TR, GABRIEL
VALUE
1 species
2-4 species
5-6 species
7 species
8-13 species
Figure 9 - CLIP4 Potential Habitat Richness
0.2
CON; - ATION
LLILR
18
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
3.1.3 Water Resources
The property holds shallow surface water during the wet season. This provides seasonal habitat for wetland
dependent species, especially wading birds. The entire property is mapped as containing depressional soils,
primarily Pineda fine sand, limestone substratum which is associated with sloughs and poorly defined
drainageways. These parcels do not provide significant aquifer recharge capacity.
19
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
BLACKBURN RD
175
175
0 0.1 0.2
Miles
SARRY TR, GABRIEL
'
Wellfield Protection Zones
1-YEAR
1
2-YEAR
5-YEAR
=_ = 20-YEAR
CLIP4 Aquifer Recharge
Priority 1- HIGHEST
Priority 2
Priority 3
CONWWATION
F Priority 4
Priority 5
Priority 6
LL1ER
Co er County
Figure 10 - CLIP Aquifer Recharge Priority and Wellfield Protection Zones
20
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
0 0.1 0.2
Miles
SARRY TR, GABRIEL
Collier County Soil Survey
BOCA FINE SAND
PINEDA FINE SAND, LIMESTONE
SUBSTRATUM
RIVIERA FINE SAND, LIMESTONE
SUBSTRATUM
Figure 11 - Collier County Soil Survey
CON; ATION
LLILR
21
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
BLACKBURN RD
175
175
0 0.1
Miles
Q SARRY TR, GABRIEL
LIDAR 2020
Value
High : 104.644
Low: -4.11745
Figure 12 LIDAR Elevation Map
•�J
CON ATION
LLIER
C.o es^ (aunty `" a N
22
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
3.1.4 Ecosystem Connectivity
These parcels directly connect to conservation easements to the north and east, the Picayune Strand State Forest
via wildlife underpasses to the south, and to the remaining undeveloped portions of the Golden Gate Estates to
the north, east, and west. Both conservation easements are held by the US Fish and Wildlife Service for
preservation related to the Estates of Twin Eagles and the Section 20 Mine. Telemetry data shows Florida panther
use this area to cross between the Nancy Payton Preserve in the Golden Gate Estates and larger conservation
areas to the south and the east. These parcels also provide an ecological link to the northern range expansion
goals of the Red -Cockaded Woodpecker Recovery Plan. Protecting habitat on both sides of 1-75 may provide
opportunities to install additional wildlife crossings.
23
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
`I FL Panther
NWR
■
■
Picayune Strand State Forest
0 2 4 6 8 10
Miles
r
Conservation Collier Preserve
WE SARRY TR, GABRIEL
Managed Conservation Areas
Other Conservation Areas )
Figure 13 - Conservation Lands
CONSERVATION
C LLIER
Co*er County
24
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust
3.2 Human Values
Date: January 3, 2024
Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
3.2.1 Recreation
These parcels could provide year-round access for recreational activities including but not limited to
fishing and hiking. The open landscape provides opportunities for wildlife viewing.
3.2.2 Accessibility
The property is accessed through a gate on Blackburn Rd which is closed to the public.
3.2.3 Aesthetic/Cultural Enhancement
These parcels currently provide green space along 1-75
Figure 14 — View of property showing proximity to 1-75
25
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust
3.3 Restoration and Management
Date: January 3, 2024
Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
3.3.1 Vegetation Management
3.3.1.1 Invasive Vegetation
Invasive vegetation infestation is not terribly high in these parcels, at approximately 25%. There are a few thick
patches of cogon grass (Imperata cylindrica), which appears to be the most widespread invasive plant
encountered. Other invasives present include Caesar weed (Urena lobata), melaleuca (Melaleuca
quinquenervia), Brazilian pepper (Schinus terebinthifolia), small -leaf climbing fern (Lygodium microphyllum),
and shrubby false buttonwood (Spermacoce verticillata). The disturbed nature of the site makes it vulnerable to
additional infestations, especially cogon grass and climbing fern.
3.3.1.2 Prescribed Fire
Despite a recent history of stand replacing wildfire, these parcels would still benefit from regular
prescribed burning. The proximity to 1-75 limits, but does not bar, the application of prescribed fire.
Although native, the high density of cabbage palms creates an obstacle to restoration by overcrowding more
desirable species and creating fuel loads that other species cannot tolerate when burned. When occurring at
sufficient density, cabbage palms burn at high temperatures that kill the overstory trees. This reduction
in canopy cover creates desirable conditions for cabbage palm recruitment which in turn increases
intensity of subsequent fires. Cabbage palms will have to be chemically or mechanically thinned and
then burned on a short return interval in order the restore the slash pine and cypress canopy.
Firebreaks would need to be installed along the west, north, and east boundary lines.
3.3.2 Remediation and Site Security
Some areas of the site require canopy rehabilitation in the form of replanting due to past wildfires.
Invasive species and cabbage palms will need to be controlled before planting occurs. The remoteness
of the parcels and existing entrance gate on Blackburn Rd. limits trespass. Most off -road traffic within
the surrounding parcels is suspected to be done by those accessing private property; however, there
have been reports of poaching on lands to the west in the recent past.
3.3.3 Assistance
Assistance is not predicted.
3.4 Vulnerability
3.4.1 Zoning and Land Use
These parcels are designated as Sending Lands in the Rural Fringe Mixed Use Overlay (RFMUO) within a Natural
Resource Protection Area (NRPA), with a North Belle Meade Overlay. RFMUO Sending Lands designation allows
for 1 dwelling unit per 40 acres, or 1 dwelling unit per parcel if the parcel is under 40 acres. Therefore, one dwelling
unit could be developed on each of the Sarry Trust parcels.
LDC section 2.03.08.A provide the description of Sending Lands:
RFMU sending lands are those lands that have the highest degree of environmental value and sensitivity
and generally include significant wetlands, uplands, and habitat for listed species. RFMU sending lands
are the principal target for preservation and conservation. Density may be transferred from RFMU sending
26
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
lands as provided in section 2.03.07 D.4.c. All NRPAs within the RFMU district are also RFMU sending
lands.
LDC section 2.03.08.B provide the description of NRPAs:
The purpose and intent of the Natural Resource Protection Area Overlay District (NRPA) is to: protect
endangered or potentially endangered species by directing incompatible land uses away from their
habitats; to identify large, connected, intact, and relatively unfragmented habitats, which may be
important for these listed species; and to support State and Federal agencies' efforts to protect
endangered or potentially endangered species and their habitats. NRPAs may include major wetland
systems and regional flow -ways. These lands generally should be the focus of any federal, state, County,
or private acquisition efforts. Accordingly, allowable land uses, vegetation preservation standards,
development standards, and listed species protection criteria within NRPAs set forth herein are more
restrictive than would otherwise be permitted in the underlying zoning district and shall to be applicable
in addition to any standards that apply tin the underlying zoning district.
27
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
BLgCKBURN RD
175
175
0 0A
Miles
SARRY TR, GABRIEL
Zoning General
A
Figure 15 - Zoning
0.2
28
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
0 0.1 0.2
Miles
SARRY TR, GABRIEL
Zoning Overlay
RFMUO-NRPA-NBMO-SENDING
Figure 16 - Zoning Overlays
29
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
0 0.1 0.2
Miles
SARRY TR, GABRIEL
Future Land Use
Agricultural I Rural Designation
RF-Sending
Figure 17— Future Land Use
CON ATION
LLILR
C.A." County
30
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust
3.4.2 Development Plans
Date: January 3, 2024
Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
No development plans currently exist on the property. Although the zoning of the property favors agricultural
use and low -density residential dwellings, the Wilson Corridor Extension may be aligned through this area. Once
the corridor is constructed surrounding lands may transition from agricultural to more intensive forms of use.
4. Acquisition Considerations
Staff would like to bring the following items to the attention of the Advisory Committee during the review of this
property. The following does not affect the scoring. The following are items that will be addressed in the
Executive Summary to the Board of County Commissioners if this property moves forward for ranking.
These properties could be within the alignment of the future Wilson Benfield Road Extension. If these properties
are approved for the A -List, staff will take this information into consideration when planning amenities and
public access on the site. Additionally, when applicable, language will be memorialized in the Purchase
Agreements and related closing documents to ensure Collier County Transportation will be able to purchase a
portion of the properties from Conservation Collier for future right-of-way, if and when needed, at the original
per -acre acquisition cost.
5. Management Needs and Costs
Table S - Estimated Costs of Site Remediation, Improvements, and Management
Management
Initial
Annual
Comments
Element
Cost
Recurring Cost
Invasive Vegetation
$5,300
$2,000
$400/acre initial, $150/acre recurring. 13.3-acres
Removal
Cabbage Palm
$5,300
N/A
$400/acre
Treatment
Native Plant
$800
N/A
$70/1000 slash pine seedlings, $225/1000 cypress
Installation
seedlings. $1/tree installation. 500 pines, 200 cypress
Trail/Firebreak
Installation and
$5,000
$1,000
Installing firebreaks along property boundaries
Maintenance
Total
$16,400
$3,000
5. Potential for Matching Funds
There are no known matching funds or partnership opportunities for acquisition in this area.
31
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust
6. Secondary Criteria Scoring Form
Date: January 3, 2024
Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
Property Name: Sarry Trust
Target Protection Mailing Area: N/A
Folio(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
Secondary Criteria Scoring
Possible
Points
Awarded
Points
percentage
1- Ecological Value
160
63
39
2 - Human Value
80
33
41
3 - Restoration and Management
80
64
80
4 - Vulnerability
80
27
33
TOTAL SCORE
400
186
47
1 - ECOLOGICAL VALUES (40% of total)
Possible
Awarded
Comments
Points
Points
1.1 VEGETATIVE COMMUNITIES
200
50
1.1.1- Priority natural communities (Select highest score)
a. Parcel contains CLIP4 Priority 1 communities (1130 -
Rockland Hammock, 1210 - Scrub, 1213 - Sand Pine Scrub,
1214 - Coastal Scrub, 1312 - Scrubby Flatwoods, 1610 -
100
Beach Dune, 1620 - Coastal Berm, 1630 - Coastal
Grasslands, 1640 - Coastal Strand, or 1650 - Maritime
Hammock)
b. Parcel contains CLIP4 Priority 2 communities (22211 -
Hydric Pine Flatwoods, 2221 - Wet Flatwoods, or 1311 -
60
Mesic Flatwoods)
c. Parcel contains CLIP4 Priority 3 communities (5250 -
Mangrove Swamp, or 5240 - Salt Marsh)
50
d. Parcel contains CLIP4 Priority 4 communities (5250 -
Mangrove Swamp)
25
1.1.2 - Plant community diversity (Select the highest
score)
a. Parcel has >_ 3 CLC native plant communities (Florida
Cooperative Land Cover Classification System native plant
20
communities)
Cypress/Pine/Cabbage
b. Parcel has <_ 2 CLC native plant communities
10
10
Palm, Mixed Scrub -
Shrub Wetlands
c. Parcel has 0 CLC native plant communities
0
1.1.3 - Listed plant species (excluding commercially
exploited species) (Select the highest score)
a. Parcel has >_5 CLC listed plant species
30
b. Parcel has 3-4 CLC listed plant species
20
c. Parcel has <_ 2 CLC listed plant species
10
d. Parcel has 0 CLC listed plant species
0
0
32
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust
Date: January 3, 2024
Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
1.1.4 - Invasive Plant Infestation (Select highest score)
a. 0 - 10% infestation
50
b. 10 - 25% infestation
40
40
cogon; melaleuca;lygodium
c. 25 - 50% infestation
30
d. 50 - 75% infestation
20
e. >_75% infestation
10
1.2 - WILDLIFE COMMUNITIES
100
90
1.2.1- Listed wildlife species (Select the highest score)
a. Listed wildlife species documented on the parcel
80
80
Florida Panther
b. Listed wildlife species documented on adjacent property
60
c CLIP Potential Habitat Richness >_5 species
40
d. No listed wildlife documented near parcel
0
1.2.2 - Significant wildlife habitat (Rookeries, roosts,
denning sites, nesting grounds, high population densities,
etc) (Select highest score)
a. Parcel protects significant wildlife habitat (Please
describe)
20
b. Parcel enhances adjacent to significant wildlife habitat
(Please describe)
10
10
adjacent to hundreds of
undeveloped acres
c. Parcel does not enhance significant wildlife habitat
0
1.3 - WATER RESOURCES
100
30
1.3.1- Aquifer recharge (Select the highest score)
a. Parcel is located within a wellfield protection zone or
within a CLIP4 Aquifer Recharge Priority 1 area
40
b. Parcel is located within a CLIP4 Aquifer Recharge Priority
2 or 3 area
30
c. Parcel is located within a CLIP4 Aquifer Recharge Priority
4 or 5 area
20
d. Parcel is located within a CLIP4 Aquifer Recharge Priority
6 area
0
0
1.3.2 - Surface Water Protection (Select the highest score)
a. Parcel is contiguous with and provides buffering for an
Outstanding Florida Waterbody
30
b. Parcel is contiguous with and provides buffering for a
creek, river, lake, canal or other surface water body
20
c. Parcel is contiguous with and provides buffering for an
identified flowway
15
d. Wetlands exist on site
10
10
e. Parcel does not provide opportunities for surface water
quality enhancement
0
1.3.3 - Floodplain Management (Select all that apply)
a. Parcel has depressional or slough soils
10
10
33
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust
Date: January 3, 2024
Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
b. Parcel has known history of flooding and is likely to
provide onsite water attenuation
10
10
c. Parcel provides storm surge buffering
10
d. Parcel does not provide floodplain management benefits
0
1.4 - ECOSYSTEM CONNECTIVITY
200
65
1.4.1 - Acreage (Select Highest Score)
a. Parcel is >_ 300 acres
150
b. Parcel is >_ 100 acres
100
b. Parcel is >_ 50 acres
75
c. Parcel is >_ 25 acres
25
d. Parcel is >_ 10 acres
15
15
e. Parcel is < 10 acres
0
1.4.2 - Connectivity (Select highest score)
a. Parcel is immediately contiguous with conservation
lands
50
50
b. Parcel is not immediately contiguous, but parcels
between it and nearby conservation lands are undeveloped
25
c. Parcel is isolated from conservation land
0
ECOLOGICAL VALUES TOTAL POINTS
600
235
ECOLOGICAL VALUES WEIGHTED SCORE (Awarded
Points/Possible Points*160)
160
63
2 - HUMAN VALUES (20%)
Possible
Points
Awarded
Points
Comments
2.1 - RECREATION
120
40
2.1.1- Compatible recreation activities (Select all that
apply)
a. Hunting
20
b. Fishing
20
20
c. Water -based recreation (paddling, swimming, etc)
20
d. Biking
20
e. Equestrian
20
f. Passive natural -resource based recreation (Hiking,
photography, wildlife watching, environmental education,
etc)
20
20
g. Parcel is incompatible with nature -based recreation
0
2.2 - ACCESSIBILITY
120
65
2.2.1- Seasonality (Select the highest score)
a. Parcel accessible for land -based recreation year round
20
20
b. Parcel accessible for land -based recreation seasonally
10
c. Parcel is inaccessible for land -based recreation
0
2.2.2 - Vehicle access (Select the highest score)
a. Public access via paved road
50
34
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust
Date: January 3, 2024
Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
b. Public access via unpaved road
30
c. Public access via private road
20
20
d. No public access
0
2.2.3 - Parking Availability (Select the highest score)
a. Minor improvements necessary to provide on -site
parking
40
b. Major improvements necessary to provide on -site
parking (Requires site development plan)
25
25
b. Public parking available nearby or on adjacent preserve
20
c. Street parking available
10
d. No public parking available
0
2.2.4 - Pedestrian access (Select the highest score)
a. Parcel is easily accessible to pedestrians (within walking
distance of housing development)
10
b. Parcel is not easily accessible to pedestrians
0
0
2.3 - AESTHETICS/CULTURAL ENHANCEMENT
40
10
2.3.1- Aesthetic/cultural value (Choose all that apply)
a. Mature/outstanding native vegetation
5
b. Scenic vistas
5
C. Frontage enhances aesthetics of public thoroughfare
10
10
Improves aesthetics
from 1-75
d. Archaeological/historical structures present
15
e. Other (Please describe)
5
f. None
0
HUMAN VALUES TOTAL SCORE
280
115
HUMAN VALUES WEIGHTED SCORE (Awarded
Points/Possible Points*80)
80
33
3 - RESTORATION AND MANAGEMENT (20%)
Possible
Awarded
Comments
Points
Points
3.1- VEGETATION MANAGEMENT
120
120
3.1.1- Invasive plant management needs (Select the
highest score)
a. Minimal invasive/nuisance plant management necessary
to restore and maintain native plant communities (<30%)
100
100
b. Moderate invasive/nuisance plant management
necessary to restore and maintain native plant
75
communities (30-65%)
c. Major invasive/nuisance plant management necessary
to restore and maintain native plant communities (>65%)
50
d. Major invasive/nuisance plant management and
replanting necessary to restore and maintain native plant
25
communities (>65%)
e. Restoration of native plant community not feasible
0
35
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust
Date: January 3, 2024
Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
3.1.2 - Prescribed fire necessity and compatibility (Select
the highest score)
a. Parcel contains fire dependent plant communities and is
compatible with prescribed fire or parcel does not contain
20
20
fire dependent plant communities
b. Parcel contains fire dependent plant communities and is
0
incompatible with prescribed fire
3.2 - REMEDIATION AND SITE SECURITY
50
20
3.2.1- Site remediation and human conflict potential
(Dumping, contamination, trespassing, vandalism, other)
(Select the highest score)
a. Minimal site remediation or human conflict issues
50
predicted
b. Moderate site remediation or human conflict issues
20
20
ATV trespass issues
predicted (Please describe)
predicted
c. Major site remediation or human conflict issues
5
predicted (Please describe)
d. Resolving site remediation or human conflict issues not
0
feasible
3.3 - ASSISTANCE
5
0
3.4.1- Management assistance by other entity
a. Management assistance by other entity likely
5
b. Management assistance by other entity unlikely
0
0
RESTORATION AND MANAGEMENT TOTAL SCORE
175
140
RESTORATION AND MANAGEMENT WEIGHTED SCORE
80
64
(Awarded Points/Possible Points*80)
4 - VULNERABILITY (20%)
Possible
Awarded
Comments
Points
Points
4.1 - ZONING AND LAND USE
130
55
4.1.1- Zoning and land use designation (Select the highest
score)
a. Zoning allows for Single Family, Multifamily, industrial or
commercial
100
b. Zoning allows for density of no greater than 1 unit per 5
75
acres
c. Zoning allows for agricultural use /density of no greater
than 1 unit per 40 acres
50
50
d. Zoning favors stewardship or conservation
0
4.1.2 - Future Land Use Type (Select the highest score)
a. Parcel designated Urban
30
b. Parcel designated Estates, Rural Fringe Receiving and
Neutral, Agriculture
25
c. Parcel designated Rural Fringe Sending, Rural Lands
Stewardship Area
5
5
36
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust
Date: January 3, 2024
Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
d. Parcel is designated Conservation
0
4.2 - DEVELOPMENT PLANS
50
5
4.2.1- Development plans (Select the highest score)
a. Parcel has been approved for development
20
b. SFWMD and/or USACOE permit has been applied for or
SDP application has been submitted
15
c. Parcel has no current development plans
0
0
4.2.2 - Site characteristics amenable to development
(Select all that apply)
a. Parcel is primarily upland
10
b. Parcel is along a major roadway
10
c. Parcel is >10 acres
5
5
d. Parcel is within 1 mile of a current or planned
commercial or multi -unit residential development
5
VULNERABILITY TOTAL SCORE
180
60
VULNERABILITY WEIGHTED SCORE (Awarded
Points/Possible Points*80)
80
27
37
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust
7. Additional Site Photos
< £ ry
c
a
_ E fj R�gF�Y
Groundcover with melaleuca seedlings
Cogongrass patch
Date: January 3, 2024
Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
38
a
f-j s
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust
South edge of property
View looking east
Date: January 3, 2024
Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
40
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
View looking west
Interior of parcel
41
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
Looking southwest — light green is cogongrass
Looking southeast — light green is cogongrass
42
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
APPENDIX 1— Critical Lands and Water Identification Maps (CLIP) Definitions
This report makes use of data layers from the Florida Natural Areas Inventory and University of Florida
Critical Lands and Waters Identification Project (CLIP4). CLIP4 is a collection of spatial data that identify
statewide priorities for a broad range of natural resources in Florida. It was developed through a
collaborative effort between the Florida Areas Natural Inventory (FNAI), the University of Florida
GeoPlan Center and Center for Landscape Conservation Planning, and the Florida Fish and Wildlife
Conservation Commission (FWC). It is used in the Florida Forever Program to evaluate properties for
acquisition. CLIP4 is organized into a set of core natural resource data layers which are representative
of 5 resource categories: biodiversity, landscapes, surface water, groundwater and marine. The first 3
categories have also been combined into the Aggregated layer, which identifies 5 priority levels for
natural resource conservation.
Below is a description of each of the three CLIP4 data layers used in this report.
Figure 4 - CLIP4 Prioritv Natural Communities
Consists of 12 priority natural community types: upland glades, pine rocklands, seepage slopes, scrub,
sandhill, sandhill upland lakes, rockland hammock, coastal uplands, imperiled coastal lakes, dry prairie,
upland pine, pine flatwoods, upland hardwood forest, or coastal wetlands. These natural communities
are prioritized by a combination of their heritage global status rank (G-rank) and landscape context,
based on the Land Use Intensity Index (subset of CLIP Landscape Integrity Index) and FNAI Potential
Natural Areas. Priority 1 includes G1-G3 communities with Very High or High landscape context.
Priority 2 includes G1-G3 Medium and G4 Very High/High. Priority 3 includes G4 Medium and G5 Very
High/High. Priority 5 is G5 Medium.
This data layer was created by FNAI originally to inform the Florida Forever environmental land
acquisition program. The natural communities were mapped primarily based on the FNAI/FWC
Cooperative Land Cover (CLC) data layer, which is a compilation of best -available land cover data for
the entire state. The CLC is based on both remote -sensed (from aerial photography, primarily from
water management district FLUCCS data) and ground-truthed (from field surveys on many
conservation lands) data.
Fieure 9. Potential Habitat Richness CLIP4 Ma
This CLIP version 4.0 data layer is unchanged from CLIP v3.0. FWC Potential Habitat Richness. Because
SHCAs do not address species richness, FWC also developed the potential habitat richness layer to
identify areas of overlapping vertebrate species habitat. FWC created a statewide potential habitat
model for each species included in their analysis. In some cases, only a portion of the potential habitat
was ultimately designated as SHCA for each species. The Potential Habitat Richness layer includes the
entire potential habitat model for each species and provides a count of the number of species habitat
models occurring at each location. The highest number of focal species co-occurring at any location in
the model is 13.
43
Initial Criteria Screening Report — Sarry Trust Date: January 3, 2024
Owner Name: Gabriel Sarry Trust Folio Number(s): 00348160000, 00348200009
Figure 10: CLIP4 Aquifer Recharge Priority and Wellfield Protection Zones
High priorities indicate high potential for recharge to an underlying aquifer system (typically the
Floridan aquifer but could be intermediate or surficial aquifers in some portions of the state). The
highest priorities indicate high potential for recharge to springs or public water supplies. This figure
also includes Wellfield Protection Zones. Collier County Wellfield Protection Zones are referenced in
the Land Development Code and updated in 2010 by Pollution Control and Prevention Department
Staff. The public water supply wellfields, identified in section 3.06.06 and permitted by the SFWMD for
potable water to withdraw a minimum of 100,000 average gallons per day (GPD), are identified as
protected wellfields, around which specific land use and activity (regulated development) shall be
regulated under this section.
44
Conservation Collier
Initial Criteria Screening Report
HK Investment Parcel
0 05 1 2
Miles
Owner Name: HK Investment AG, Inc
Size: 0.38 acres
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Staff Report Date: January 3, 2024
Total Score: 228/400
200 160
100 85 80 80 6980
337n sp
0
1 - Ecological 2/al3iar tantV4Wi®n and Marlhgle lity
0 Awarded Points 0 Possible Points
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc Date: January 3, 2024
Table of Contents
Tableof Contents......................................................................................................................................... 2
1. Introduction........................................................................................................................................... 4
2. Summary of Property............................................................................................................................ 5
Figure 1 - Parcel Location Overview.........................................................................................................5
Figure 2 — Marco Island Cycle 12 TPMA...................................................................................................6
Figure3 - Parcel Close-up.........................................................................................................................7
2.1 Summary of Property Information....................................................................................................8
Table 1— Summary of Property Information.....................................................................................8
Figure 4 - Secondary Criteria Score....................................................................................................9
Table 2 - Secondary Criteria Score Summary.....................................................................................9
2.2 Summary of Assessed Value and Property Cost Estimates...........................................................
10
Table 3. Assessed & Estimated Value.............................................................................................
10
2.2.1 Zoning, Growth Management and Conservation Overlays .................................................
10
2.3 Initial Screening Criteria Satisfaction (Ord. 2002-63, Sec. 10)......................................................
11
3. Initial Screening Criteria......................................................................................................................13
3.1 Ecological Values.............................................................................................................................
13
3.1.1 Vegetative Communities.......................................................................................................
13
Table 4. Listed Plant Species....................................................................................................
13
Figure 5 - CLIP4 Priority Natural Communities........................................................................
14
Figure 6 - Florida Cooperative Land Cover Classification System ............................................
15
Figure 7— Disturbed coastal scrub community.......................................................................
16
Figure 8 — View of northeast corner of parcel.........................................................................
16
3.1.2 Wildlife Communities............................................................................................................
17
Table 5 - Wildlife Detected......................................................................................................
17
Figure 9 - Wildlife Spatial Data (i.e., telemetry, roosts, etc) ....................................................
18
Figure 10 - CLIP4 Potential Habitat Richness...........................................................................
19
Figure 11— Large potentially occupied gopher tortoise burrow .............................................
20
Figure 12 — Small potentially occupied gopher tortoise burrow .............................................
20
3.1.3 Water Resources...................................................................................................................
21
Figure 13 - CLIP Aquifer Recharge Priority and Wellfield Protection Zones ............................
22
Figure 14 - Collier County Soil Survey......................................................................................
23
Figure 15 LIDAR Elevation Map...............................................................................................
24
2
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
3.1.4 Ecosystem Connectivity........................................................................................................
25
Figure 16 - Conservation Lands...............................................................................................
25
Figure 17 - Trail on east side of adjacent property connecting Van Cleef parcel to HK
Investmentparcel...................................................................................................................
26
3.2 Human Values.................................................................................................................................
26
3.2.1 Recreation.............................................................................................................................
26
3.2.2 Accessibility...........................................................................................................................
26
3.2.3 Aesthetic/Cultural Enhancement.........................................................................................
26
3.3 Restoration and Management.......................................................................................................
26
3.3.1 Vegetation Management......................................................................................................
26
3.3.1.1 Invasive Vegetation.....................................................................................................
26
3.3.1.2 Prescribed Fire............................................................................................................
27
3.3.2 Remediation and Site Security..............................................................................................
27
3.3.3 Assistance..............................................................................................................................
27
3.4 Vulnerability....................................................................................................................................
27
3.4.1 Zoning and Land Use.............................................................................................................
27
3.4.2 Development Plans...............................................................................................................
27
Figure18 —Zoning ...................................................................................................................
28
Figure19 —Future Land Use....................................................................................................
29
4. Acquisition Considerations....................................................................................................................
30
5. Management Needs and Costs..............................................................................................................30
Table 6 - Estimated Costs of Site Remediation, Improvements, and Management ................
30
6. Potential for Matching Funds..............................................................................................................30
7. Secondary Criteria Scoring Form.........................................................................................................31
8. Additional Site Photos.........................................................................................................................37
APPENDIX 1— Critical Lands and Water Identification Maps (CLIP) Definitions......................................41
3
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
1. Introduction
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
The Conservation Collier Program (Program) is an environmentally sensitive land acquisition and
management program approved by the Collier County Board of County Commissioners (Board) in 2002
and by Collier County Voters in 2002 and 2006. The Program was active in acquisition between 2003 and
2011, under the terms of the referendum. Between 2011 and 2016, the Program was in management
mode. In 2017, the Collier County Board reauthorized Conservation Collier to seek additional lands
(2/14/17, Agenda Item 11B). On November 3, 2020, the Collier County electors approved the
Conservation Collier Re-establishment referendum with a 76.5% majority.
This Initial Criteria Screening Report (ICSR) has been prepared for the Conservation Collier Program in its
12th acquisition cycle to meet requirements specified in the Conservation Collier Implementation
Ordinance, 2002-63, as amended, and for purposes of the Conservation Collier Program. The sole
purpose of this report is to provide objective data to demonstrate how properties meet the criteria
defined by the ordinance.
The following sections characterize the property location and assessed value, elaborate on the initial and
secondary screening criteria scoring, and describe potential funding sources, appropriate use, site
improvements, and estimated management costs.
4
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
2. Summary of Property
EARBAROSA CT
j
JJJJ ap
ORLEANS CT RAWAr�CT
qy HK Investment Inc
Van Cleef
GALLEON AVE F GALLEON CT MEDEIRq CT O -
� Q V
= ALMERIA CT MACAO CT 00
F- t- ❑
a
V WI NTERSERRV DR
w
a
GS�OOp PEE o �pR`�O'(
CP
nO mO aP
2 9
OG
P
C�
DEVON CT
w
a
Z_
NCCpF�NDDR ,.Ot.DSCT _, c,
j f
�e-F _ LUDLOW Rb
Ir
�J
MCIWAINECT LU
Z �yy
Qf \ N4
C aMQAS CT Q �O
w.
ADDISON CT
�e _
HEIGHTSCr
OSCEOLA C M 0
U ..-1 A x
ti
SHORES C7 ✓i S INLETDR-
4
S SARFIELD CT
' 0 0!5
Miles
Figure 1 - Parcel Location Overview
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
Legend
- Closing Pending
- Application Received
Conservation Collier Preserve
CON ATION
LLIER
Co er County
5
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): S7190360001
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc Date: January 3, 2024
Miles
Figure 2 — Marco Island Cycle 12 TPMA
0.35
Cnl�t� CouNC.Y
C
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc Date: January 3, 2024
1
` L
J
Miles
Figure 3 - Porcel Close-up
0.03
Collier County
"
7
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
2.1 Summary of Property Information
Table 1 — Summary of Property Information
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
Characteristic
Value
Comments
Name
HK Investment
HK Investment AG, Inc
Folio Numbers
57190360001
363 S. Barfield Dr., Marco Island, FL 34145
Target Protection
Urban
Marco Island Target Mailing Area Cycle 12
Area
Size
0.38 acres
Section, Township,
and Range
S9, Twn 52, R26
C-1/T, commercial
C-1/T is intended to permit those uses which minimize
Zoning
professional/transitional
pedestrian and vehicular traffic, and is designed to be
Category/TDRs
compatible with all residential uses, as well as
district
residential uses located along arterials.
The western half of the parcel is in Flood Zone AE
(high -risk areas have at least a 1% annual chance of
FEMA Flood Map
AE, X, and X500
flooding); the eastern half of the parcel is in Flood
Category
Zone X (low flood risk); a small sliver in the center of
the parcel is in Flood Zone X500 (moderate flood risk)
Existing structures
None
Storage unit with asphalt parking (old fire station
Adjoining properties
Commercial, roadway,
building) to the south; paved roadway and sidewalk
and their Uses
residential
(South Barfield Dr.) to the west; single-family
residence to the east; Pending Conservation Collier
property to the north across Hawaii Circle
Development Plans
Submitted
None
Known Property
None
Irregularities
Other County Dept
None known
Parcel is within unincorporated Collier
Interest
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
Total Score: 228/400
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
200
160
150
100 85 80 80 69 80
50 37 37
0
1 - Ecological 2 - Human Value 3 - Restoration 4 - Vulnerability
Value and
Management
■ Awarded Points ❑ Possible Points
Figure 4 - Secondary Criteria Score
Table 2 - Secondary Criteria Score Summary
Criteria
Awarded Weighted
Points
Possible Weighted
Points
Awarded/Possible
Points
1- Ecological Value
85
160
53%
1.1 - Vegetative Communities
40
53
75%
1.2 - Wildlife Communities
27
27
100%
1.3 - Water Resources
5
27
20%
1.4 - Ecosystem Connectivity
13
53
25%
2 - Human Values
37
80
46%
2.1 - Recreation
6
34
17%
2.2 - Accessibility
29
34
83%
2.3 - Aesthetics/Cultural Enhancement
3
11
25%
3 - Restoration and Management
37
80
46%
3.1 - Vegetation Management
11
55
21%
3.2 - Remediation and Site Security
23
23
100%
3.3 - Assistance
2
2
100%
4 - Vulnerability
69
80
86%
4.1 - Zoning and Land Use
58
58
100%
4.2 - Development Plans
11
22
50%
Total
228
400
57%
A
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc Date: January 3, 2024
2.2 Summary of Assessed Value and Property Cost Estimates
The interest being appraised is fee simple "as is" for the purchase of the site(s). A value of the parcel was
estimated using only one of the three traditional approaches to value, the sales comparison approach.
Each is based on the principal of substitution that an informed purchaser would pay no more for the
rights in acquiring a particular real property than the cost of acquiring, without undue delay, an equally
desirable one. Three properties were selected for comparison, each with similar site characteristics,
utility availability, zoning classification and road access. No inspection was made of the property or
comparables used in this report and the Real Estate Services Department staff relied upon information
solely provided by program staff. The valuation conclusions are limited only bythe reported assumptions
and conditions that no other known or unknown adverse conditions exist.
If the Board of County Commissioners choose to acquire this property, appraisals by independent Real
Estate Appraisers will be obtained at that time. Pursuant to the Conservation Collier Purchase Policy,
two appraisals are required for the HK Investment parcel, which has an initial valuation greater than
$500,000; 2 independent Real Estate Appraisers will value the subject property and the average of the
two appraisal reports will be used to determine an offer for the subject property.
Table 3. Assessed & Estimated Value
Property owner
Address
Acreage
Assessed
EstimatedValue*
Value**
HK Investment AG, Inc
363 S. Barfield Dr.
0.38
$209,750
* Assessed Value is obtained from the Property Appraiser's Website. The Assessed Value is based off
the current use of the property.
**The Estimated Market Value for the HK Investment parcel will be obtained from the Collier County
Real Estate Services Department prior to the CCLAAC March 6, 2024, ranking meeting.
2.2.1 Zoning, Growth Management and Conservation Overlays
Zoning, growth management and conservation overlays will affect the value of a parcel. The parcel is
zoned C-1/T commercial professional/transitional district, which is intended to permit those uses
which minimize pedestrian and vehicular traffic and is designed to be compatible with all residential
uses, as well as residential uses located along arterials. The C-1/T commercial professional/transitional
district is intended to apply to those areas that are transitional, located between areas of higher and
lower intensity development that are no longer appropriate for residential development.
10
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
2.3 Initial Screening Criteria Satisfaction (Ord. 2002-63, Sec. 10)
Criteria 1: Native Habitats
Are any of the following unique and endangered plant communities found on the property?
Order of preference as follows:
i.
Hardwood hammocks
No
ii.
Xeric oak scrub
YES
iii.
Coastal strand
No
iv.
Native beach
No
V.
Xeric pine
No
vi.
Riverine Oak
No
vii.
High marsh (saline)
No
viii.
Tidal freshwater marsh
No
ix.
Other native habitats
No
Statement for Satisfaction of Criteria 1: Mapped as High Intensity Urban. Weedy bahiagrass lot
with a small area of Coastal Scrub.
Criteria 2: Human Social Values
Does land offer significant human social values, such as equitable geographic distribution,
appropriate access for nature -based recreation, and enhancement of the aesthetic setting of
Collier County? YES
Statement for Satisfaction of Criteria 2: The parcel is accessible from Hawaii Cir. And from a
sidewalk off S. Barfield Dr. It is also along the City of Marco Island's mixed -use pathway. The
parcel provides wildlife viewing and greenspace in a neighborhood where nearly every lot is
developed.
Criteria 3: Water Resources
Does the property offer opportunities for protection of water resource values, including aquifer
recharge, water quality enhancement, protection of wetland dependent species habitat, and
flood control? NO
Statement for Satisfaction of Criteria 3: The parcel contains no wetlands and is mapped as
contributing only very minimally to aquifer recharge.
Criteria 4: Biological and Ecological Value
Does the property offer significant biological values, including biodiversity, listed species habitat,
connectivity, restoration potential and ecological quality? YES
11
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
Statement for Satisfaction of Criteria 4: The property contains burrowing owls and gopher
tortoises.
Criteria 5: Enhancement of Current Conservation Lands
Does the property enhance and/or protect the environmental value of current conservation lands
through function as a buffer, ecological link or habitat corridor? Yes
Is this property within the boundary of another agency's acquisition project? No
Statement for Satisfaction of Criteria 5: This parcel is adjacent to Conservation Collier pending
acquisition Annecy/Barfield, which is scheduled to close on January 5, 2023.
MEETS INITIAL SCREENING CRITERIA
❑Yes ❑No
The property satisfies 4 initial screening criteria
12
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
3. Initial Screening Criteria
3.1 Ecological Values
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
3.1.1 Vegetative Communities
The southwestern quarter of the parcel contains disturbed coastal scrub. This scrub category
represents a wide variety of species found in the coastal zone. Some of the more common components
of this category that were observed in this area of the parcel include: sand live oak (Quercus geminata),
prickly pear (Opuntia mesacantha), gopher apple (Geobalanus oblongifolius), and partridge pea
(Chamaecrista fasciculata). The northeastern quarter of the parcel is dominated by guineagrass
(Urochloa maxima).
Groundcover on the remainder of the parcel is primarily patchy mowed Bahiagrass (Paspalum
notatum) mixed with largeflower Mexican clover (Richardia grandiflora). Areas of open, bare sand exist
throughout the parcel. Some small sand live oaks, small West Indian mahogony (Swietenia mahagoni),
and two sea grape (Coccoloba uvifera) are present within the parcel. One Brazilian pepper (Schinus
terebinthifolia) and several century plants (Agave angustifolia) are present in the southeastern corner.
Table 4. Listed Plant Species
Common Name
Scientific Name
State Status
Federal Status
West Indian mahogony
Swietenia mahagoni
State Threatened
n/a
13
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc Date: January 3, 2024
■
VILLA CT EOU/VTYC,r
2�
m�
■
■
MEDEIRA CT o
�i
w 0
LL
a x
I
WINTERBERRY DR
G�
P
/1
0 0.7
Miles
H K Investment Inc
Gary Van Cleef
Annecy Marco LLC
CLIP4 Priority Natural
Communities
Priority 1 (highest)
Priority 2
Priority 3
Priority 4
Figure 5 - CLIP4 Priority Natural Communities
CONJ
SEiRVATION
COLLIE
Ca er Couxty
b.
14
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc Date: January 3, 2024
0 0.1
Miles
H K Investment Inc
Gary Van Cleef
Land Cover
Residential, Med. Density - 2-5
Dwelling Units/AC
Transportation
Figure 6 - Florida Cooperative Land Cover Classification System
CONJ
SEiRVATION
COLLIE
Ca er Couxty
b.
15
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
Figure 7— Disturbed coastal scrub community
Figure 8 — View of northeast corner of parcel
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
16
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
3.1.2 Wildlife Communities
A high amount of gopher tortoise activity is present on this parcel, with many active burrows and
gopher tortoises observed by Program staff. Although most of the burrows were very large, a few
smaller burrows were observed. Additionally, a neighbor encountered by staff during the site visit
confirmed that several smaller, juvenile tortoises are present within his adjacent lot and often forage
within the HK Investment parcel. Therefore, it is possible that a breeding population of gopher tortoise
exists within this area of Marco Island. The preservation of this and other lots adjacent to preserved
lots in this area could aid in the survival of this species on Marco Island.
The neighbor also confirmed the presence of burrowing owls on the parcel. The open bahiagrass areas
within the parcel could continue to accommodate nesting burrowing owls.
Table S - Wildlife Detected
Common Name
Scientific Name
State
Status
Federal
Status
Mode of Detection
Florida burrowing
Athene cunicularia
Threatened
N/A
Observed by neighbor
owl
floridana
Gopher tortoise
GoGophe us
pherus
Threatened
N/A
Observed during site visit
p
17
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc Date: January 3, 2024
0 0.3
Miles
Ca er Couxty
Figure 9 - Wildlife Spatial Data (i.e., telemetry, roosts, etc)
18
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
80 Y c1
VILLA CT
"U
� p
_�3 I
2�
MEDEIRA CT
Q
O p Q U
I.0 8rm r° x
GO
WINTERBERRY DR
r
0
H K Investment Inc
Gary Van Cleef
Is Annecy Marco LLC
VALUE
1 species
2-4 species
5-6 species
_ 7 species
8-13 species
Figure 10 - CLIP4 Potential Habitat Richness
Miles
Folio Number(s): S7190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
0.7
COHSE-R- ATION
C LLIER
Ca er Couxty�
19
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
Figure 11 — Large potentially occupied gopher tortoise burrow
Figure 12 — Small potentially occupied gopher tortoise burrow
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
20
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
3.1.3 Water Resources
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
The parcel does not significantly protect water resources, aside from providing very minimal aquifer
recharge. The parcel and adjacent properties are comprised entirely of uplands. No wetlands exist on
site, and the parcel is not within a wellfield protection zone.
Soils data is based on the Soil Survey of Collier County Area, Florida (USDA/NRCS, 1990). Mapped soils
on this parcel show the western 0.11 acres of the parcel to be urban land — aquents complex, organic
substratum, which consists of materials that have been dug from different areas in the county and
spread over muck soils for coastal urban development. The eastern 0.27 acres of the site contains paola
fine sand, 1 to 8 pct slopes — an excessively drained soil found on coastal dunes on Marco Island.
21
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc Date: January 3, 2024
HAwprr CAR
0
0
u�
m�
a
0
0
c�
ID
0
r
0
z
1 ag
r1
1' 0
Miles
H K Investment Inc
QGary Van Cleef
Wellfield Protection Zones
1-YEAR
2-YEAR
5-YEAR
_ _ = 20-YEAR
CLIP4 Aquifer Recharge
Priority 1- HIGHEST
Priority 2
Priority 3
Priority 4
Priority 5
Priority 6
Figure 13 - CLIP Aquifer Recharge Priority and Wellfield Protection Zones
0.1
CONSEiRVATION
COLLIER
Collier Co..ty
22
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc Date: January 3, 2024
"I` 0 0.1
Miles
H K Investment Inc
Gary Van Cleef
Soil Type
PAOLA FINE SAND, 1 TO 8 PCT
SLOPES
URBAN LAND -AQUENTS COMPLEX,
ORGANIC SUBSTRATUM
— WATER
Figure 14 - Collier County Soil Survey
CONJ
SEiRVATION
COLLIE
Ca er Couxty
b.
23
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc Date: January 3, 2024
Nq wa�i ��R
0
0
w
m
0
Q
0
0
0
0
n
I
Miles
H K Investment Inc
QGary Van Cleef
LIDAR
Value
High : 104.644
- Low: -4.11745
Figure 15 LIDAR Elevation Mop
0.1
Rai
24
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
3.1.4 Ecosystem Connectivity
The parcel provides direct connectivity to pending Conservation Collier lands to the north across
Hawaii Circle. It is within an urban, residential area with a busy road (South Barfield Dr.) adjacent to the
west. The undeveloped Van Cleef lot to the south, which is also in application to Conservation Collier,
exists between the old fire district building and the HK Investment parcel. A sand trail behind the
building connects the HK Investment parcel to the Van Cleef parcel.
1
Miles
South Terra Corp
H K Investment Inc
Gary Van Cleef
Annecy Marco LLC
Otter Mound Preserve
Other Conservation Lands
Figure 16 - Conservation Lands
1
CONUMATION
ft
CA, Co..ty
25
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
Figure 17 - Trail on east side of adjacent property connecting Van Cleef parcel to HK Investment parcel
3.2 Human Values
3.2.1 Recreation
The parcel is bordered by a sidewalk along the entire west edge. Birdwatching and photography would
be encouraged from the sidewalk. Providing access to the parcel with a short trail would not be
recommended due to the high density of gopher tortoise burrows and the presence of burrowing owls.
3.2.2 Accessibility
The parcel would be visible from the sidewalk year-round. No pedestrian or vehicular access onto the
parcel would be recommended. The parcel is within walking distance of many residences and
commercial parking lots. Creating parking within the parcel would also not be recommended because
of its small size and wildlife utilization. If this parcel is acquired along with other parcels in the area,
Conservation Collier will coordinate with the City of Marco Island regarding parking. Depending on
location, the City of Marco Island has offered to assist in providing off-street parking on pervious
material and the installation of signage consistent with the City's Land Development Codes.
3.2.3 Aesthetic/Cultural Enhancement
This parcel is in the Urban Target Protection Area and has access from a public road. It provides wildlife
viewing and greenspace in a neighborhood where nearly every lot is developed. The parcel is too small
to accommodate trails but can be enjoyed from the sidewalk/road.
3.3 Restoration and Management
3.3.1 Vegetation Management
3.3.1.1 Invasive Vegetation
Approximately 25% of the parcel has been cleared and contains mowed bahiagrass and weeds. The
remaining un-mowed areas of the lot contain approximately 50% invasive/nuisance plant coverage
26
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc Date: January 3, 2024
including guineagrass and Brazilian pepper. Removal of the exotic plants and portions of the bahiagrass
field and extensive replanting of native plants will be necessary to restore native plant communities.
Removal of the invasive/nuisance plants must be executed without the use of heavy machinery within
25 feet of any of the gopher tortoise burrows. Management/restoration of the bahiagrass field must
take into consideration the effects any management/restoration will have on the gopher tortoises and
burrowing owls utilizing the parcel.
3.3.1.2 Prescribed Fire
Even if the parcel is restored, fire would not be a feasible management tool given its size and urban
location.
3.3.2 Remediation and Site Security
No major site security issues appear to exist within the parcel. "No dumping" signage and educational
signage regarding the importance of the parcel for native wildlife could be installed.
3.3.3 Assistance
Monitoring of, and some management assistance for, the listed wildlife on this parcel will be provided
by the Audubon of the Western Everglades. Funding assistance for invasive/nuisance plant removal
and native plantings may be sought from the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission and
the US Fish and Wildlife Service Partners for Fish and Wildlife Program.
3.4 Vulnerability
3.4.1 Zoning and Land Use
The parcel is zoned C-1/T commercial professional/transitional district, which is intended to permit
those uses which minimize pedestrian and vehicular traffic and is designed to be compatible with all
residential uses, as well as residential uses located along arterials. The C-1/T commercial
professional/transitional district is intended to apply to those areas that are transitional, located
between areas of higher and lower intensity development that are no longer appropriate for
residential development.
3.4.2 Development Plans
The parcel is not currently planned for development; however, its location near developed commercial
lots along a busy roadway and its zoning makes it vulnerable to development. Although the listed
species present on the parcel may make development cost prohibitive, development is still possible.
27
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
*8 1 -- / r - µ +} �.
tft ft, *8 :
�/,
A�hAm- t'!
ANN;--
Figure 18 —Zoning
The parcel is zoned C-1/T commercial professional/transitional district.
28
off "W
a■■■/ , # ►
M._
-
- ._
S # . .
.::::
: i
Rooms
�.■Ni■■SIS!'I
Jn■■■■att■:4
14
b note ■ s
rf-
INN 0
lg
Alit
!ig■l1■ .� !o ■
��■f■■� �� ft�■■■■its # it
also in" at
111111111W--�—� ► ■maple
M : 5 IL III■■I!■+ may WINMANMMM 7=T;,l ; ;
40
■�ii
■
Is
IF
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
4. Acquisition Considerations
Although individually they are small, acquisition of this parcel and the parcel to the south (Van Cleef)
would bring the area of contiguous, protected gopher tortoise, burrowing owl, and migratory bird
habitat along S. Barfield Dr. to 2.93 acres. This would amount to a larger preserved area than
Conservation Collier's existing 2.45-acre Otter Mound Preserve.
5. Management Needs and Costs
Table 6 - Estimated Costs of Site Remediation, Improvements, and Management
Management
Initial
Annual Recurring
Element
Cost
Cost
Comments
Invasive Vegetation
$250
$100
Initial estimate is $500/acre; annual is $200/acre
Removal
Native plantings
$2,000
$200
Cost may be greater if irrigation is required
Signage
$2,000
$100
Educational signage and signage denoting the
property as Conservation Collier preserve
TOTAL
$4,250
$400
6. Potential for Matching Funds
The primary partnering agencies for conservation acquisitions, and those identified in the ordinance are
the Florida Communities Trust (FCT), and The Florida Forever Program. The following highlights potential
for partnering funds, as communicated by agency staff.
Florida Communities Trust - Parks and Open Space Florida Forever grant program: The FCT
Parks and Open Space Florida Forever grant program provides grant funds to local governments and
nonprofit organizations to acquire conservation lands, urban open spaces, parks and greenways.
Application for this program is typically made for pre -acquired sites up to two years from the time of
acquisition. The Parks and Open Space Florida Forever grant program assists the Department of
Environmental Protection in helping communities meet the challenges of growth, supporting viable
community development and protecting natural resources and open space. The program receives 21
percent Florida Forever appropriation.
Florida Forever Program: Staff has been advised that the Florida Forever Program is concentrating
on funding parcels already included on its ranked priority list. This parcel is not inside a Florida Forever
priority project boundary. Additionally, the Conservation Collier Program has not been successful in
partnering with the Florida Forever Program due to conflicting acquisition policies and issues regarding
joint title between the programs.
Additional Funding Sources: There are no additional funding sources known at this time.
30
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
7. Secondary Criteria Scoring Form
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
Property Name: HK Investment
Target Protection Mailing Area: Marco Island
Fol io(s): 57190360001
Secondary Criteria Scoring
Possible
Points
Awarded
Points
percentage
1 - Ecological Value
160
85
53
2 - Human Value
80
37
46
3 - Restoration and Management
80
37
46
4 - Vulnerability
80
69
86
TOTAL SCORE
400
228
57
1 - ECOLOGICAL VALUES (40% of total)
Possible
Awarded
Comments
Points
Points
1.1 VEGETATIVE COMMUNITIES
200
150
1.1.1- Priority natural communities (Select highest score)
a. Parcel contains CLIP4 Priority 1 communities (1130 -
Rockland Hammock, 1210 - Scrub, 1213 - Sand Pine Scrub,
1214 - Coastal Scrub, 1312 - Scrubby Flatwoods, 1610 - Beach
100
100
Coastal scrub
Dune, 1620 - Coastal Berm, 1630 - Coastal Grasslands, 1640 -
Coastal Strand, or 1650 - Maritime Hammock)
b. Parcel contains CLIP4 Priority 2 communities (22211 - Hydric
Pine Flatwoods, 2221 - Wet Flatwoods, or 1311 - Mesic
60
Flatwoods)
c. Parcel contains CLIP4 Priority 3 communities (5250 -
Mangrove Swamp, or 5240 - Salt Marsh)
50
d. Parcel contains CLIP4 Priority 4 communities (5250 -
Mangrove Swamp)
25
1.1.2 - Plant community diversity (Select the highest score)
a. Parcel has >_ 3 CLC native plant communities (Florida
Cooperative Land Cover Classification System native plant
20
communities)
b. Parcel has <_ 2 CLC native plant communities
10
10
c. Parcel has 0 CLC native plant communities
0
0
1.1.3 - Listed plant species (excluding commercially exploited
species) (Select the highest score)
a. Parcel has >_5 CLC listed plant species
30
b. Parcel has 3-4 CLC listed plant species
20
c. Parcel has <_ 2 CLC listed plant species
10
10
mahogany
d. Parcel has 0 CLC listed plant species
0
1.1.4 - Invasive Plant Infestation (Select highest score)
a. 0 - 10% infestation
50
b. 10 - 25% infestation
40
31
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
c. 25 - 50% infestation
30
30
guineagrass;
Brazilian pepper
d. 50 - 75% infestation
20
e. >_75% infestation
10
1.2 - WILDLIFE COMMUNITIES
100
100
1.2.1- Listed wildlife species (Select the highest score)
a. Listed wildlife species documented on the parcel
80
80
gopher tortoise;
burrowing owl
b. Listed wildlife species documented on adjacent property
60
c CLIP Potential Habitat Richness >5 species
40
d. No listed wildlife documented near parcel
0
1.2.2 - Significant wildlife habitat (Rookeries, roosts, denning
sites, nesting grounds, high population densities, etc) (Select
highest score)
large density of
a. Parcel protects significant wildlife habitat (Please describe)
20
20
gopher tortoise
burrows
b. Parcel enhances adjacent to significant wildlife habitat
(Please describe)
10
c. Parcel does not enhance significant wildlife habitat
0
1.3 - WATER RESOURCES
100
20
1.3.1- Aquifer recharge (Select the highest score)
a. Parcel is located within a wellfield protection zone or within
a CLIP4 Aquifer Recharge Priority 1 area
40
b. Parcel is located within a CLIP4 Aquifer Recharge Priority 2
or 3 area
30
c. Parcel is located within a CLIP4 Aquifer Recharge Priority 4 or
5 area
20
20
Priority 5 area
d. Parcel is located within a CLIP4 Aquifer Recharge Priority 6
area
0
1.3.2 - Surface Water Protection (Select the highest score)
a. Parcel is contiguous with and provides buffering for an
Outstanding Florida Waterbody
30
b. Parcel is contiguous with and provides buffering for a creek,
river, lake, canal or other surface water body
20
c. Parcel is contiguous with and provides buffering for an
identified flowway
15
d. Wetlands exist on site
10
e. Parcel does not provide opportunities for surface water
quality enhancement
0
0
1.3.3 - Floodplain Management (Select all that apply)
a. Parcel has depressional or slough soils
10
b. Parcel has known history of flooding and is likely to provide
onsite water attenuation
10
32
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
c. Parcel provides storm surge buffering
10
d. Parcel does not provide floodplain management benefits
0
0
1.4 - ECOSYSTEM CONNECTIVITY
200
50
1.4.1 - Acreage (Select Highest Score)
a. Parcel is >_ 300 acres
150
b. Parcel is >_ 100 acres
100
b. Parcel is >_ 50 acres
75
c. Parcel is >_ 25 acres
25
d. Parcel is >_ 10 acres
15
e. Parcel is < 10 acres
0
0
1.4.2 - Connectivity (Select highest score)
a. Parcel is immediately contiguous with conservation lands
50
50
b. Parcel is not immediately contiguous, but parcels between it
and nearby conservation lands are undeveloped
25
c. Parcel is isolated from conservation land
0
ECOLOGICAL VALUES TOTAL POINTS
600
320
ECOLOGICAL VALUES WEIGHTED SCORE (Awarded
Points/Possible Points*160)
160
85
2 - HUMAN VALUES (20%)
Possible
Points
Awarded
Points
Comments
2.1 - RECREATION
120
20
2.1.1- Compatible recreation activities (Select all that apply)
a. Hunting
20
0
b. Fishing
20
0
c. Water -based recreation (paddling, swimming, etc)
20
0
d. Biking
20
0
e. Equestrian
20
0
f. Passive natural -resource based recreation (Hiking,
photography, wildlife watching, environmental education, etc)
20
20
g. Parcel is incompatible with nature -based recreation
0
2.2 - ACCESSIBILITY
120
100
2.2.1- Seasonality (Select the highest score)
a. Parcel accessible for land -based recreation year round
20
20
b. Parcel accessible for land -based recreation seasonally
10
c. Parcel is inaccessible for land -based recreation
0
2.2.2 - Vehicle access (Select the highest score)
a. Public access via paved road
50
50
b. Public access via unpaved road
30
c. Public access via private road
20
d. No public access
0
2.2.3 - Parking Availability (Select the highest score)
33
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
a. Minor improvements necessary to provide on -site parking
40
b. Major improvements necessary to provide on -site parking
(Requires site development plan)
25
b. Public parking available nearby or on adjacent preserve
20
20
c. Street parking available
10
d. No public parking available
0
2.2.4 - Pedestrian access (Select the highest score)
a. Parcel is easily accessible to pedestrians (within walking
distance of housing development)
10
10
b. Parcel is not easily accessible to pedestrians
0
2.3 - AESTHETICS/CULTURAL ENHANCEMENT
40
10
2.3.1- Aesthetic/cultural value (Choose all that apply)
a. Mature/outstanding native vegetation
5
b. Scenic vistas
5
c. Frontage enhances aesthetics of public thoroughfare
10
10
d. Archaeological/historical structures present
15
e. Other (Please describe)
5
f. None
0
HUMAN VALUES TOTAL SCORE
280
130
HUMAN VALUES WEIGHTED SCORE (Awarded Points/Possible
Points*80)
80
37
3 - RESTORATION AND MANAGEMENT (20%)
Possible
Awarded
Comments
Points
Points
3.1 - VEGETATION MANAGEMENT
120
25
3.1.1- Invasive plant management needs (Select the highest
score)
a. Minimal invasive/nuisance plant management necessary to
restore and maintain native plant communities (<30%)
100
b. Moderate invasive/nuisance plant management necessary
to restore and maintain native plant communities (30-65%)
75
c. Major invasive/nuisance plant management necessary to
restore and maintain native plant communities (>65%)
50
d. Major invasive/nuisance plant management and replanting
necessary to restore and maintain native plant communities
25
25
(>65%)
e. Restoration of native plant community not feasible
0
3.1.2 - Prescribed fire necessity and compatibility (Select the
highest score)
a. Parcel contains fire dependent plant communities and is
compatible with prescribed fire or parcel does not contain fire
20
dependent plant communities
34
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
b. Parcel contains fire dependent plant communities and is
coastal scrib present
incompatible with prescribed fire
0
0
to size and location
prohibit burning
3.2 - REMEDIATION AND SITE SECURITY
50
50
3.2.1- Site remediation and human conflict potential
(Dumping, contamination, trespassing, vandalism, other)
(Select the highest score)
Parcel is easily
accessible from
sidewalk and major
a. Minimal site remediation or human conflict issues predicted
50
50
road. May have
some limited human
conflict due to
dumping and litter
b. Moderate site remediation or human conflict issues
20
predicted (Please describe)
c. Major site remediation or human conflict issues predicted
(Please describe)
5
d. Resolving site remediation or human conflict issues not
feasible
0
3.3 - ASSISTANCE
5
5
3.3.1- Management assistance by other entity
a. Management assistance by other entity likely
5
5
AWE
b. Management assistance by other entity unlikely
0
RESTORATION AND MANAGEMENT TOTAL SCORE
175
80
RESTORATION AND MANAGEMENT WEIGHTED SCORE
80
37
(Awarded Points/Possible Points*80)
4 - VULNERABILITY (20%)
Possible
Awarded
Comments
Points
Points
4.1 - ZONING AND LAND USE
130
130
4.1.1- Zoning and land use designation (Select the highest
score)
a. Zoning allows for Single Family, Multifamily, industrial or
commercial
100
100
b. Zoning allows for density of no greater than 1 unit per 5
75
acres
c. Zoning allows for agricultural use /density of no greater than
50
1 unit per 40 acres
d. Zoning favors stewardship or conservation
0
4.1.2 - Future Land Use Type (Select the highest score)
a. Parcel designated Urban
30
30
35
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
b. Parcel designated Estates, Rural Fringe Receiving and
25
Neutral, Agriculture
c. Parcel designated Rural Fringe Sending, Rural Lands
5
Stewardship Area
d. Parcel is designated Conservation
0
4.2 - DEVELOPMENT PLANS
50
25
4.2.1- Development plans (Select the highest score)
a. Parcel has been approved for development
20
b. SFWMD and/or USACOE permit has been applied for or SDP
application has been submitted
15
c. Parcel has no current development plans
0
0
4.2.2 - Site characteristics amenable to development (Select
all that apply)
a. Parcel is primarily upland
10
10
b. Parcel is along a major roadway
10
10
c. Parcel is >10 acres
5
d. Parcel is within 1 mile of a current or planned commercial or
5
5
multi -unit residential development
VULNERABILITY TOTAL SCORE
180
155
VULNERABILITY WEIGHTED SCORE (Awarded Points/Possible
Points*80)
80
69
36
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
8. Additional Site Photos
Guineagrass in northeast corner
Eastern boundary
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
37
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
Southeast corner
View of property looking north
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
38
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
Disturbed coastal scrub with patchy bahiagrass in foreground
View of parcel looking north from adjacent parcel
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
39
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
II .y
y
.".. '�"_'.-.,... ?�.+e+.-i�.n-......�� wi .ya�r.w!�...rka....o.+... .. ._ .. M_ . _._.: �*...�.`�--i.eaese.- �.•i ..¢-T-.°-�dY.��..�c tsr..� ..,s.,�_.:.�.Y«t� �_ ..
Google Streetview photo of parcel looking east from S. Barfield Dr.
Google Streetview photo of parcel looking south from Hawaii Cir.
40
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc Date: January 3, 2024
APPENDIX 1— Critical Lands and Water Identification Maps (CLIP) Definitions
This report makes use of data layers from the Florida Natural Areas Inventory and University of Florida
Critical Lands and Waters Identification Project (CLIP4). CLIP4 is a collection of spatial data that identify
statewide priorities for a broad range of natural resources in Florida. It was developed through a
collaborative effort between the Florida Areas Natural Inventory (FNAI), the University of Florida
GeoPlan Center and Center for Landscape Conservation Planning, and the Florida Fish and Wildlife
Conservation Commission (FWC). It is used in the Florida Forever Program to evaluate properties for
acquisition. CLIP4 is organized into a set of core natural resource data layers which are representative
of 5 resource categories: biodiversity, landscapes, surface water, groundwater and marine. The first 3
categories have also been combined into the Aggregated layer, which identifies 5 priority levels for
natural resource conservation.
Below is a description of each of the three CLIP4 data layers used in this report.
Figure 4 - CLIP4 Prioritv Natural Communities
Consists of 12 priority natural community types: upland glades, pine rocklands, seepage slopes, scrub,
sandhill, sandhill upland lakes, rockland hammock, coastal uplands, imperiled coastal lakes, dry prairie,
upland pine, pine flatwoods, upland hardwood forest, or coastal wetlands. These natural communities
are prioritized by a combination of their heritage global status rank (G-rank) and landscape context,
based on the Land Use Intensity Index (subset of CLIP Landscape Integrity Index) and FNAI Potential
Natural Areas. Priority 1 includes G1-G3 communities with Very High or High landscape context.
Priority 2 includes G1-G3 Medium and G4 Very High/High. Priority 3 includes G4 Medium and G5 Very
High/High. Priority 5 is G5 Medium.
This data layer was created by FNAI originally to inform the Florida Forever environmental land
acquisition program. The natural communities were mapped primarily based on the FNAI/FWC
Cooperative Land Cover (CLC) data layer, which is a compilation of best -available land cover data for
the entire state. The CLC is based on both remote -sensed (from aerial photography, primarily from
water management district FLUCCS data) and ground-truthed (from field surveys on many
conservation lands) data.
Fieure 9 - Potential Habitat Richness CLIP4 Ma
This CLIP version 4.0 data layer is unchanged from CLIP v3.0. FWC Potential Habitat Richness. Because
SHCAs do not address species richness, FWC also developed the potential habitat richness layer to
identify areas of overlapping vertebrate species habitat. FWC created a statewide potential habitat
model for each species included in their analysis. In some cases, only a portion of the potential habitat
was ultimately designated as SHCA for each species. The Potential Habitat Richness layer includes the
entire potential habitat model for each species and provides a count of the number of species habitat
models occurring at each location. The highest number of focal species co-occurring at any location in
the model is 13.
41
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: HK Investment AG, Inc
Folio Number(s): 57190360001
Date: January 3, 2024
Figure 13 - CLIP4 Aquifer Recharge Priority and Wellfield Protection Zones
High priorities indicate high potential for recharge to an underlying aquifer system (typically the
Floridan aquifer but could be intermediate or surficial aquifers in some portions of the state). The
highest priorities indicate high potential for recharge to springs or public water supplies. This figure
also includes Wellfield Protection Zones. Collier County Wellfield Protection Zones are referenced in
the Land Development Code and updated in 2010 by Pollution Control and Prevention Department
Staff. The public water supply wellfields, identified in section 3.06.06 and permitted by the SFWMD for
potable water to withdraw a minimum of 100,000 average gallons per day (GPD), are identified as
protected wellfields, around which specific land use and activity (regulated development) shall be
regulated under this section.
42
Conservation Collier
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Van Cleef Parcel
Le nd
Closing Pending
'} .:. .. Application Received
Conserva5on Collier Preserve
Y.
r,.
x •.
L. xr e- 't - CU R%ATIUN
lUER
71
w �
0 05 1 2
Miles
Owner Name: Gary Van Cleef
Size: 0.43 acres
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Staff Report Date: January 3, 2024
Total Score: 189/400
200
160
150
100
80
80
69 80
50
37
37
46
0
1- Ecological
2 - Human Value
3 - Restoration 4
- Vulnerability
Value
and Management
0 Awarded Points
0 Possible Points
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef Date: January 3, 2024
Table of Contents
Tableof Contents......................................................................................................................................... 2
1. Introduction........................................................................................................................................... 4
2. Summary of Property............................................................................................................................ 5
Figure 1 - Parcel Location Overview.........................................................................................................5
Figure 2 — Marco Island Cycle 12 TPMA...................................................................................................6
Figure3 - Parcel Close-up.........................................................................................................................7
2.1 Summary of Property Information....................................................................................................8
Table 1— Summary of Property Information.....................................................................................8
Figure 4 - Secondary Criteria Score....................................................................................................9
Table 2 - Secondary Criteria Score Summary.....................................................................................9
2.2 Summary of Assessed Value and Property Cost Estimates...........................................................
10
Table 3. Assessed & Estimated Value.............................................................................................
10
2.2.1 Zoning, Growth Management and Conservation Overlays .................................................
10
2.3 Initial Screening Criteria Satisfaction (Ord. 2002-63, Sec. 10)......................................................
11
3. Initial Screening Criteria......................................................................................................................13
3.1 Ecological Values.............................................................................................................................
13
3.1.1 Vegetative Communities.......................................................................................................
13
Table4. Listed Plant Species...........................................................................................................
13
Figure 5 - CLIP4 Priority Natural Communities........................................................................
14
Figure 6 - Florida Cooperative Land Cover Classification System ............................................
15
Figure 7 — View of southeast corner of parcel.........................................................................
16
Figure 8 — View of northwest corner of parcel........................................................................
16
3.1.2 Wildlife Communities............................................................................................................
17
Table 5 - Wildlife Detected......................................................................................................
17
Figure 9 - Wildlife Spatial Data (i.e., telemetry, roosts, etc) ....................................................
18
Figure 10 - CLIP4 Potential Habitat Richness...........................................................................
19
Figure 11—Two potentially occupied gopher tortoise burrows .............................................
20
Figure 12 — Burrowing owl area..............................................................................................
20
3.1.3 Water Resources...................................................................................................................
21
Figure 13 - CLIP Aquifer Recharge Priority and Wellfield Protection Zones ............................
22
Figure 14 - Collier County Soil Survey......................................................................................
23
Figure 15 LIDAR Elevation Map...............................................................................................
24
2
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef Date: January 3, 2024
3.1.4 Ecosystem Connectivity........................................................................................................
25
Figure 16 - Conservation Lands...............................................................................................
25
Figure 17 - Trail on east side of adjacent property connecting Van Cleef parcel to HK
Investmentparcel...................................................................................................................
26
3.2 Human Values.................................................................................................................................
26
3.2.1 Recreation.............................................................................................................................
26
3.2.2 Accessibility...........................................................................................................................
26
3.2.3 Aesthetic/Cultural Enhancement.........................................................................................
26
3.3 Restoration and Management.......................................................................................................
26
3.3.1 Vegetation Management......................................................................................................
26
3.3.1.1 Invasive Vegetation.....................................................................................................
26
3.3.1.2 Prescribed Fire............................................................................................................
27
3.3.2 Remediation and Site Security..............................................................................................
27
3.3.3 Assistance..............................................................................................................................
27
3.4 Vulnerability....................................................................................................................................
27
3.4.1 Zoning and Land Use.............................................................................................................
27
3.4.2 Development Plans...............................................................................................................
27
Figure18 — Zoning...................................................................................................................
28
Figure19 —Future Land Use....................................................................................................
29
4. Acquisition Considerations....................................................................................................................
30
5. Management Needs and Costs..............................................................................................................30
Table 6 - Estimated Costs of Site Remediation, Improvements, and Management ................
30
6. Potential for Matching Funds..............................................................................................................30
7. Secondary Criteria Scoring Form.........................................................................................................31
8. Additional Site Photos.........................................................................................................................37
APPENDIX 1— Critical Lands and Water Identification Maps (CLIP) Definitions......................................42
3
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
1. Introduction
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
The Conservation Collier Program (Program) is an environmentally sensitive land acquisition and
management program approved by the Collier County Board of County Commissioners (Board) in 2002
and by Collier County Voters in 2002 and 2006. The Program was active in acquisition between 2003 and
2011, under the terms of the referendum. Between 2011 and 2016, the Program was in management
mode. In 2017, the Collier County Board reauthorized Conservation Collier to seek additional lands
(2/14/17, Agenda Item 11B). On November 3, 2020, the Collier County electors approved the
Conservation Collier Re-establishment referendum with a 76.5% majority.
This Initial Criteria Screening Report (ICSR) has been prepared for the Conservation Collier Program in its
12th acquisition cycle to meet requirements specified in the Conservation Collier Implementation
Ordinance, 2002-63, as amended, and for purposes of the Conservation Collier Program. The sole
purpose of this report is to provide objective data to demonstrate how properties meet the criteria
defined by the ordinance.
The following sections characterize the property location and assessed value, elaborate on the initial and
secondary screening criteria scoring, and describe potential funding sources, appropriate use, site
improvements, and estimated management costs.
4
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
2. Summary of Property
EARBAROSA CT 1
i
HAwAlI
yy
ORLEANS CT CT
qy
HK Investment Inc
GALLEON AVE
Van Cleef
GALLEON CT MEDEIRq CT O -
F
� Q V
F- t-
=
❑
ALMERIA CT MACAO CT 00
a
w V
a
WI NTERSERRV OR
�CpOP�E
CC
00 mO
2 9
OG
aP
P
C�
DEVON CT
NCOpeZlND DR
C
Cj
UIDLOW
J�
MCILVAIfyE CT
Q
CAXaMggS CT Q
w
me'
NEIGNTS CT
U.
ti
SHORES C7 a�.
S SARFIELD CT
T��IpR TER
Z
' 0 0!5
Miles
Figure 1 - Parcel Location Overview
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
Legend
- Closing Pending
- Application Received
Conservation Collier Preserve
CON ATION
LLIER
Co er County
5
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): S7190280000
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef Date: January 3, 2024
0 0.35
Miles
Figure 2 — Marco Island Cycle 12 TPMA
co " Couxty
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef Date: January 3, 2024
Miles
VAN CLEEF, GARY
CONlifMATION
LLIER
Co en Cototty
Figure 3 - Parcel Close-up
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
2.1 Summary of Property Information
Table 1 — Summary of Property Information
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
Characteristic
Value
Comments
Name
Van Cleef
Gary Van Cleef
Folio Numbers
57190280000
383 S. Barfield Dr., Marco Island, FL 34145
Target Protection
Urban
Marco Island Target Mailing Area Cycle 12
Area
Size
0.43 acres
Section, Township,
and Range
S9, Twn 52, R26
Commercial intermediate district (C-3) is intended to be
Zoning
C-3, Commercial
compatible with residential areas and is not intended to
Category/TDRs
Intermediate
permit wholesaling, or activities which require outside
storage of merchandise and equipment.
FEMA Flood Map
The parcel is in Flood Zone AE (high -risk areas have at least
Category
AE
a 1% annual chance of flooding)
Existing structures
None
Storage unit with asphalt parking (old fire station building)
Adjoining properties
Commercial,
to the north; paved roadway and sidewalk (South Barfield
and their Uses
roadway,
Dr.) to the west; single-family residences to the east and
residential
south
Development Plans
Submitted
None
Known Property
None
Irregularities
Other County Dept
None known
Parcel is within unincorporated Collier
Interest
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef Date: January 3, 2024
Total Score: 189/400
200
160
150
100 80 80 69 80
50 37 37 46
0
1 - Ecological 2 - Human Value 3 - Restoration and 4 - Vulnerability
Value Management
■ Awarded Points ❑ Possible Points
Figure 4 - Secondary Criteria Score
Table 2 - Secondary Criteria Score Summary
Criteria
Awarded Weighted
Points
Possible Weighted
Points
Awarded/Possible
Points
1 - Ecological Value
37
160
23%
1.1 - Vegetative Communities
11
53
20%
1.2 - Wildlife Communities
27
27
100%
1.3 - Water Resources
0
27
0%
1.4 - Ecosystem Connectivity
0
53
0%
2 - Human Values
37
80
46%
2.1 - Recreation
6
34
17%
2.2 - Accessibility
29
34
83%
2.3 - Aesthetics/Cultural Enhancement
3
11
25%
3 - Restoration and Management
46
80
57/
3.1 - Vegetation Management
21
55
38%
3.2 - Remediation and Site Security
23
23
100%
3.3 - Assistance
2
2
100%
4 - Vulnerability
69
80
86%
4.1 - Zoning and Land Use
58
58
100%
4.2 - Development Plans
11
22
50%
Total
189
400
47%
9
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef Date: January 3, 2024
2.2 Summary of Assessed Value and Property Cost Estimates
The interest being appraised is fee simple "as is" for the purchase of the site(s). A value of the parcel was
estimated using only one of the three traditional approaches to value, the sales comparison approach.
Each is based on the principal of substitution that an informed purchaser would pay no more for the
rights in acquiring a particular real property than the cost of acquiring, without undue delay, an equally
desirable one. Three properties were selected for comparison, each with similar site characteristics,
utility availability, zoning classification and road access. No inspection was made of the property or
comparables used in this report and the Real Estate Services Department staff relied upon information
solely provided by program staff. The valuation conclusions are limited only bythe reported assumptions
and conditions that no other known or unknown adverse conditions exist.
If the Board of County Commissioners choose to acquire this property, appraisals by independent Real
Estate Appraisers will be obtained at that time. Pursuant to the Conservation Collier Purchase Policy,
two appraisals are required forthe Van Cleef parcel, which has an initial valuation greaterthan $S00,000;
2 independent Real Estate Appraisers will value the subject property and the average of the two
appraisal reports will be used to determine an offer for the subject property.
Table 3. Assessed & Estimated Value
Property owner
Address
Acreage
Assessed
EstimatedValue*
Value**
Gary Van Cleef
383 S. Barfield Dr.
0.43
$187,310
* Assessed Value is obtained from the Property Appraiser's Website. The Assessed Value is based off
the current use of the property.
**The Estimated Market Value for the Van Cleef parcel will be obtained from the Collier County Real
Estate Services Department prior to the CCLAAC March 6, 2024, ranking meeting.
2.2.1 Zoning, Growth Management and Conservation Overlays
Zoning, growth management and conservation overlays will affect the value of a parcel. The parcel is
zoned Commercial intermediate district (C-3), which is intended to be compatible with residential
areas and is not intended to permit wholesaling, or activities which require outside storage of
merchandise and equipment.
10
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
2.3 Initial Screening Criteria Satisfaction (Ord. 2002-63, Sec. 10)
Criteria 1: Native Habitats
Are any of the following unique and endangered plant communities found on the property?
Order of preference as follows:
i.
Hardwood hammocks
No
ii.
Xeric oak scrub
No
iii.
Coastal strand
No
iv.
Native beach
No
V.
Xeric pine
No
vi.
Riverine Oak
No
vii.
High marsh (saline)
No
viii.
Tidal freshwater marsh
No
ix.
Other native habitats
No
Statement for Satisfaction of Criteria 1: Mapped as High Intensity Urban. Mowed lot with a few
large native trees, but no intact native plant communities.
Criteria 2: Human Social Values
Does land offer significant human social values, such as equitable geographic distribution,
appropriate access for nature -based recreation, and enhancement of the aesthetic setting of
Collier County? YES
Statement for Satisfaction of Criteria 2: The parcel is accessible from a sidewalk off S. Barfield
Dr. and is along the City of Marco Island's mixed -use pathway. The parcel provides wildlife
viewing and greenspace in a neighborhood where nearly every lot is developed.
Criteria 3: Water Resources
Does the property offer opportunities for protection of water resource values, including aquifer
recharge, water quality enhancement, protection of wetland dependent species habitat, and
flood control? NO
Statement for Satisfaction of Criteria 3: The parcel contains no wetlands and is mapped as
contributing only very minimally to aquifer recharge.
Criteria 4: Biological and Ecological Value
Does the property offer significant biological values, including biodiversity, listed species habitat,
connectivity, restoration potential and ecological quality? YES
Statement for Satisfaction of Criteria 4: Despite not containing intact native plant
communities, the property contains burrowing owls and gopher tortoises.
11
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef Date: January 3, 2024
Criteria 5: Enhancement of Current Conservation Lands
Does the property enhance and/or protect the environmental value of current conservation lands
through function as a buffer, ecological link or habitat corridor? No
Is this property within the boundary of another agency's acquisition project? No
Statement for Satisfaction of Criteria 5: This parcel is surrounded by development and
although not directly adjacent to conservation lands, a sandy pathway to the north connects
the parcel to the HK Investments parcel — an undeveloped parcel currently in application to
Conservation Collier and adjacent to parcels pending acquisition by Conservation Collier.
MEETS INITIAL SCREENING CRITERIA
❑Yes ❑No
The property satisfies 2 initial screening criteria
12
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
3. Initial Screening Criteria
3.1 Ecological Values
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
3.1.1 Vegetative Communities
The parcel does not contain any intact, native, vegetative communities. The parcel contains several
large gumbo limbos (Bursera simaruba), cabbage palms (Saba) palmetto), and oaks (Quercus sp.) and
one sea grape (Coccoloba uvifera), with some wild coffee (Psychotria nervosa) and a hoopvine
(Trichostigma octandrum) growing under the oaks. Although plantings could be installed to create a
maritime hammock in the southeast corner, nothing that could be considered an intact, native,
vegetative community currently exists on the parcel. Groundcover is primarily mowed Bahiagrass
(Paspalum notatum) lawn with largeflower Mexican clover (Richardia grandiflora), guineagrass
(Urochloa maxima), and muscadine (Vitis rotundifolia). Papaya (Carica papaya), cape honeysuckle
(Tecomaria capensis), Durban crowfootgrass (Dactyloctenium aegyptium), rosary pea (Abrus
precatorius), and carrotwood (Cupaniopsis anacardioides) are also present.
Table 4. Listed Plant Species
Common Name
Scientific Name
State Status
Federal Status
Hoopvine
Trichostigma octandrum
Endangered
N/A
13
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): S7190280000
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef Date: January 3, 2024
■
801)/V �1
VILLA CT /
"U
p
72�
m� /16
■
■
■
MEDEIRA CT Ir
Q
O p Q U
LU C9
X O Jx x
� O
C*
WINTERBERRY DR
G�
Q�v
P
ti
F�
O,p
11
0 0.7
Miles
H K Investment Inc
Gary Van Cleef
13 Annecy Marco LLC
CLIP4 Priority Natural
Communities
Priority 1 (highest)
Priority 2
Priority 3
Priority 4
Figure 5 - CLIP4 Priority Natural Communities
CONSErY ATION
C LLIER
Ca er Couxty�
14
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef Date: January 3, 2024
0 0.1
Miles
H K Investment Inc
Gary Van Cleef
Land Cover
Residential, Med. Density - 2-5
Dwelling Units/AC
Transportation
Figure 6 - Florida Cooperative Land Cover Classification System
CONJ
SEiRVATION
COLLIE
Ca er Couxty
b.
15
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
Figure 7 — View of southeast corner of parcel
Figure 8 — View of northwest corner of parcel
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
16
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
3.1.2 Wildlife Communities
A high amount of gopher tortoise activity has been documented on this parcel, with many active
burrows and gopher tortoises observed by Program staff. A gopher tortoise survey conducted by
Audubon of the Western Everglades identified 19 potentially occupied burrows and 1 abandoned
burrow. Although most of the burrows found on this parcel were very large, a few smaller burrows
were observed within the connected HK Investment parcel. Additionally, a neighbor adjacent to the HK
Investment lot encountered by staff during the site visit confirmed that several smaller, juvenile
tortoises are present within his lot and often forage within the HK Investment parcel. Therefore, it is
possible that a breeding population of gopher tortoise exists within this area of Marco Island. The
preservation of this and other lots adjacent to preserved lots in this area could aid in the survival of this
species on Marco Island.
One area within the parcel was cordoned off with post and rope for burrowing owls and several other
areas had burrowing owl T-perches installed near burrows that appear to have been inhabited by
burrowing owls. Audubon of the Western Everglades staff relayed that a burrowing owl pair has nested
on the parcel successfully in the past. The open bahiagrass field within the parcel could continue to
accommodate nesting burrowing owls.
Table S - Wildlife Detected
Common Name
Scientific Name
State
Status
Federal
Status
Mode of Detection
Florida burrowing
Athene cunicularia
Threatened
N/A
Observed by Audubon staff
owl
floridana
Gopher tortoise
GoGophe us
pherus
Threatened
N/A
Observed during site visit
p
17
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef Date: January 3, 2024
0 0.3
Miles
Ca er Couxty
Figure 9 - Wildlife Spatial Data (i.e., telemetry, roosts, etc)
18
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): S7190280000
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef Date: January 3, 2024
B pUMrY c1
VILLA CT T
"U
2�
MEDEIRA CT
Q
O p Q U
I.0 C9
m rr° x
C*
WINTERBERRY DR
G�
Q�v
P
F�
O,p
11
0 0.7
Miles
H K Investment Inc
Gary Van Cleef
Is Annecy Marco LLC
VALUE
1 species
2-4 species
5-6 species
_ 7 species
8-13 species
Figure 10 - CLIP4 Potential Habitat Richness
CONSEfY ATION
C LLIER
Ca er Couxty�
19
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
Figure 11 — Two potentially occupied gopher tortoise burrows
Figure 12 — Burrowing owl area
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
20
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
3.1.3 Water Resources
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
The parcel does not significantly protect water resources. The parcel and adjacent properties are
comprised entirely of uplands. No wetlands exist on site, and the parcel is not within a wellfield
protection zone.
Soils data is based on the Soil Survey of Collier County Area, Florida (USDA/NRCS, 1990). Mapped soils
on this parcel show the southwest half of the site (0.22 ac.) to be urban land — aquents complex, organic
substratum, which consists of materials that have been dug from different areas in the county and
spread over muck soils for coastal urban development. The northeast half of the site (0.21 ac.) contains
paola fine sand, 1 to 8 pct slopes — an excessively drained soil found on coastal dunes on Marco Island.
21
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): S7190280000
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef Date: January 3, 2024
n
in
Npwpll crR
0
0
u
m�
0
0
0
0
c�
0
o
0
z
CD
Miles
H K Investment Inc
QGary Van Cleef
Wellfield Protection Zones
1-YEAR
2-YEAR
5-YEAR
_ _ = 20-YEAR
CLIP4 Aquifer Recharge
Priority 1- HIGHEST
Priority 2
Priority 3
Priority 4
Priority 5
.� Priority 6
Figure 13 - CLIP Aquifer Recharge Priority and Wellfield Protection Zones
0.1
CONSEfY ATION
C LLIER
Collier County
22
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef Date: January 3, 2024
"I` 0 0.1
Miles
H K Investment Inc
Gary Van Cleef
Soil Type
PAOLA FINE SAND, 1 TO 8 PCT
SLOPES
URBAN LAND -AQUENTS COMPLEX,
ORGANIC SUBSTRATUM
— WATER
Figure 14 - Collier County Soil Survey
CONJ
SEiRVATION
COLLIE
Ca er Couxty
b.
23
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef Date: January 3, 2024
Nq wa�i ��R
0
0
w
m
0
Q
0
0
0
0
n
I
Miles
H K Investment Inc
QGary Van Cleef
LIDAR
Value
High : 104.644
- Low: -4.11745
Figure 15 LIDAR Elevation Mop
0.1
Rai
24
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
3.1.4 Ecosystem Connectivity
The parcel does not provide direct connectivity to other conservation lands. It is within an urban,
residential area with a busy road (South Barfield Dr.) adjacent to the west. The undeveloped HK
Investment lot to the north, which is also in application to Conservation Collier and is adjacent to
pending Conservation Collier lands, exists between the old fire district building and the Van Cleef
parcel. A sand trail behind the building connects the Van Cleef parcel to the HK Investment parcel.
O U
Q
LU
�
w'00 ap m
E
LU
0
LU
J
Z C1y`yI�
7
LUoLoWgT
RD A
a 5
LU
1
Miles
South Terra Corp
H K Investment Inc
Gary Van Cleef
Annecy Marco LLC
Otter Mound Preserve
Other Conservation Lands
Figure 16 - Conservation Lands
1
CONUMATION
ft
CA, Co..ty
25
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
Figure 17 - Trail on east side of adjacent property connecting Van Cleef parcel to HK Investment parcel
3.2 Human Values
3.2.1 Recreation
The parcel is bordered by a sidewalk along the entire west edge. Birdwatching and photography would
be encouraged from the sidewalk. Providing access to the parcel with a short trail would not be
recommended due to the high density of gopher tortoise burrows and the presence of burrowing owls.
3.2.2 Accessibility
The parcel would be visible from the sidewalk year-round. No pedestrian or vehicular access onto the
parcel would be recommended. The parcel is within walking distance of many residences and
commercial parking lots. Creating parking within the parcel would also not be recommended because
of its small size and wildlife utilization. If this parcel is acquired along with other parcels in the area,
Conservation Collier will coordinate with the City of Marco Island regarding parking. Depending on
location, the City of Marco Island has offered to assist in providing off-street parking on pervious
material and the installation of signage consistent with the City's Land Development Codes.
3.2.3 Aesthetic/Cultural Enhancement
This parcel is in the Urban Target Protection Area and has access from a public road. It provides wildlife
viewing and greenspace in a neighborhood where nearly every lot is developed. The parcel is too small
to accommodate trails but can be enjoyed from the sidewalk/road.
3.3 Restoration and Management
3.3.1 Vegetation Management
3.3.1.1 Invasive Vegetation
Approximately 75% of the parcel has been cleared and contains mowed bahiagrass and weeds. The
remaining un-mowed areas of the lot contain approximately 50% invasive/nuisance plant coverage
26
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef Date: January 3, 2024
including: guinea grass, Durban crowfootgrass, and rosary pea. Removal of the exotic plants and
portions of the bahiagrass field and extensive replanting of native plants will be necessary to restore
native plant communities. Removal of the invasive/nuisance plants must be executed without the use
of heavy machinery within 25 feet of any of the gopher tortoise burrows. Management/restoration of
the bahiagrass field must take into consideration the effects any management/restoration will have on
the gopher tortoises and burrowing owls utilizing the parcel.
3.3.1.2 Prescribed Fire
Even if the parcel is restored, fire would not be a feasible management tool given its size and urban
location.
3.3.2 Remediation and Site Security
No major site security issues appear to exist within the parcel. "No dumping" signage and educational
signage regarding the importance of the parcel for native wildlife could be installed.
3.3.3 Assistance
Monitoring of, and some management assistance for, the listed wildlife on this parcel will be provided
by the Audubon of the Western Everglades. Funding assistance for invasive/nuisance plant removal
and native plantings may be sought from the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission and
the US Fish and Wildlife Service Partners for Fish and Wildlife Program.
3.4 Vulnerability
3.4.1 Zoning and Land Use
The parcel is zoned C-3 — Commercial Intermediate. A C-3 district is intended to be compatible with
residential areas and is not intended to permit wholesaling, or activities which require outside storage
of merchandise and equipment. The Future Land Use of the parcel is Community Commercial. Because
of the limited availability of commercially zoned property on Marco Island, this parcel is vulnerable to
development.
3.4.2 Development Plans
The parcel is not currently planned for development; however, its location near developed commercial
lots along a busy roadway and its zoning makes it vulnerable to development. Although the listed
species present on the parcel may make development cost prohibitive, development is still possible.
27
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
Figure 18 —Zoning
The parcel is zoned C-3 — Commercial, Intermediate.
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
µ+}qW.
40
A�h t'!
ANN;--
h.
fn
28
'!Nord
■lll�
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
4. Acquisition Considerations
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
Although individually they are small, acquisition of this parcel and the parcel directly adjacent to the
Annecy/Barfield property (HK Investment) would bring the area of contiguous, protected gopher
tortoise, burrowing owl, and migratory bird habitat along S. Barfield Dr. to 2.93 acres. This would
amount to a larger preserved area than Conservation Collier's existing 2.45-acre Otter Mound
Preserve.
5. Management Needs and Costs
Table 6 - Estimated Costs of Site Remediation, Improvements, and Management
Management
Initial
Annual Recurring
Element
Cost
Cost
Comments
Invasive Vegetation
$250
$100
Initial estimate is $500/acre; annual is $200/acre
Removal
Native plantings
$2,000
$200
Cost may be greater if irrigation is required
Signage
$2,000
$100
Educational signage and signage denoting the
property as Conservation Collier preserve
TOTAL
$4,250
$400
6. Potential for Matching Funds
The primary partnering agencies for conservation acquisitions, and those identified in the ordinance are
the Florida Communities Trust (FCT), and The Florida Forever Program. The following highlights potential
for partnering funds, as communicated by agency staff.
Florida Communities Trust - Parks and Open Space Florida Forever grant program: The FCT
Parks and Open Space Florida Forever grant program provides grant funds to local governments and
nonprofit organizations to acquire conservation lands, urban open spaces, parks and greenways.
Application for this program is typically made for pre -acquired sites up to two years from the time of
acquisition. The Parks and Open Space Florida Forever grant program assists the Department of
Environmental Protection in helping communities meet the challenges of growth, supporting viable
community development and protecting natural resources and open space. The program receives 21
percent Florida Forever appropriation.
Florida Forever Program: Staff has been advised that the Florida Forever Program is concentrating
on funding parcels already included on its ranked priority list. This parcel is not inside a Florida Forever
priority project boundary. Additionally, the Conservation Collier Program has not been successful in
partnering with the Florida Forever Program due to conflicting acquisition policies and issues regarding
joint title between the programs.
Additional Funding Sources: There are no additional funding sources known at this time.
30
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
7. Secondary Criteria Scoring Form
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
Property Name: Van Cleef
Target Protection Mailing Area: Marco Island
Fol io(s): 57190280000
Secondary Criteria Scoring
Possible
Points
Awarded
Points
percentage
1 - Ecological Value
160
37
23
2 - Human Value
80
37
46
3 - Restoration and Management
80
46
57
4 - Vulnerability
80
69
86
TOTAL SCORE
400
189
47
1 - ECOLOGICAL VALUES (40% of total)
Possible
Awarded
Comments
Points
Points
1.1 VEGETATIVE COMMUNITIES
200
40
1.1.1- Priority natural communities (Select highest score)
a. Parcel contains CLIP4 Priority 1 communities (1130 -
Rockland Hammock, 1210 - Scrub, 1213 - Sand Pine Scrub,
1214 - Coastal Scrub, 1312 - Scrubby Flatwoods, 1610 - Beach
100
Dune, 1620 - Coastal Berm, 1630 - Coastal Grasslands, 1640 -
Coastal Strand, or 1650 - Maritime Hammock)
b. Parcel contains CLIP4 Priority 2 communities (22211 - Hydric
Pine Flatwoods, 2221 - Wet Flatwoods, or 1311 - Mesic
60
Flatwoods)
c. Parcel contains CLIP4 Priority 3 communities (5250 -
Mangrove Swamp, or 5240 - Salt Marsh)
50
d. Parcel contains CLIP4 Priority 4 communities (5250 -
Mangrove Swamp)
25
1.1.2 - Plant community diversity (Select the highest score)
a. Parcel has >_ 3 CLC native plant communities (Florida
Cooperative Land Cover Classification System native plant
20
communities)
b. Parcel has <_ 2 CLC native plant communities
10
c. Parcel has 0 CLC native plant communities
0
0
1.1.3 - Listed plant species (excluding commercially exploited
species) (Select the highest score)
a. Parcel has >_5 CLC listed plant species
30
b. Parcel has 3-4 CLC listed plant species
20
c. Parcel has <_ 2 CLC listed plant species
10
10
hoopvine
d. Parcel has 0 CLC listed plant species
0
1.1.4 - Invasive Plant Infestation (Select highest score)
a. 0 - 10% infestation
50
b. 10 - 25% infestation
40
31
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
c. 25 - 50% infestation
30
30
guineagrass;
carrotwood
d. 50 - 75% infestation
20
e. >_75% infestation
10
1.2 - WILDLIFE COMMUNITIES
100
100
1.2.1- Listed wildlife species (Select the highest score)
a. Listed wildlife species documented on the parcel
80
80
gopher tortoise;
burrowing owl
b. Listed wildlife species documented on adjacent property
60
c CLIP Potential Habitat Richness >_5 species
40
d. No listed wildlife documented near parcel
0
1.2.2 - Significant wildlife habitat (Rookeries, roosts, denning
sites, nesting grounds, high population densities, etc) (Select
highest score)
large density of
a. Parcel protects significant wildlife habitat (Please describe)
20
20
gopher tortoise
burrows
b. Parcel enhances adjacent to significant wildlife habitat
(Please describe)
10
c. Parcel does not enhance significant wildlife habitat
0
1.3 - WATER RESOURCES
100
0
1.3.1- Aquifer recharge (Select the highest score)
a. Parcel is located within a wellfield protection zone or within
a CLIP4 Aquifer Recharge Priority 1 area
40
b. Parcel is located within a CLIP4 Aquifer Recharge Priority 2
or 3 area
30
c. Parcel is located within a CLIP4 Aquifer Recharge Priority 4
or 5 area
20
d. Parcel is located within a CLIP4 Aquifer Recharge Priority 6
0
Priority 6 area
area
1.3.2 - Surface Water Protection (Select the highest score)
a. Parcel is contiguous with and provides buffering for an
Outstanding Florida Waterbody
30
b. Parcel is contiguous with and provides buffering for a creek,
river, lake, canal or other surface water body
20
c. Parcel is contiguous with and provides buffering for an
identified flowway
15
d. Wetlands exist on site
10
e. Parcel does not provide opportunities for surface water
quality enhancement
0
0
1.3.3 - Floodplain Management (Select all that apply)
a. Parcel has depressional or slough soils
10
b. Parcel has known history of flooding and is likely to provide
onsite water attenuation
10
32
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
c. Parcel provides storm surge buffering
10
d. Parcel does not provide floodplain management benefits
0
0
1.4 - ECOSYSTEM CONNECTIVITY
200
0
1.4.1 - Acreage (Select Highest Score)
a. Parcel is >_ 300 acres
150
b. Parcel is >_ 100 acres
100
b. Parcel is >_ 50 acres
75
c. Parcel is >_ 25 acres
25
d. Parcel is >_ 10 acres
15
e. Parcel is < 10 acres
0
0
1.4.2 - Connectivity (Select highest score)
a. Parcel is immediately contiguous with conservation lands
50
b. Parcel is not immediately contiguous, but parcels between it
and nearby conservation lands are undeveloped
25
c. Parcel is isolated from conservation land
0
0
ECOLOGICAL VALUES TOTAL POINTS
600
140
ECOLOGICAL VALUES WEIGHTED SCORE (Awarded
Points/Possible Points*160)
160
37
2 - HUMAN VALUES (20%)
Possible
Points
Awarded
Points
Comments
2.1 - RECREATION
120
20
2.1.1- Compatible recreation activities (Select all that apply)
a. Hunting
20
0
b. Fishing
20
0
c. Water -based recreation (paddling, swimming, etc)
20
0
d. Biking
20
0
e. Equestrian
20
0
f. Passive natural -resource based recreation (Hiking,
photography, wildlife watching, environmental education, etc)
20
20
g. Parcel is incompatible with nature -based recreation
0
2.2 - ACCESSIBILITY
120
100
2.2.1- Seasonality (Select the highest score)
a. Parcel accessible for land -based recreation year round
20
20
b. Parcel accessible for land -based recreation seasonally
10
c. Parcel is inaccessible for land -based recreation
0
2.2.2 - Vehicle access (Select the highest score)
a. Public access via paved road
50
50
b. Public access via unpaved road
30
c. Public access via private road
20
d. No public access
0
2.2.3 - Parking Availability (Select the highest score)
33
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
a. Minor improvements necessary to provide on -site parking
40
b. Major improvements necessary to provide on -site parking
(Requires site development plan)
25
b. Public parking available nearby or on adjacent preserve
20
20
c. Street parking available
10
d. No public parking available
0
2.2.4 - Pedestrian access (Select the highest score)
a. Parcel is easily accessible to pedestrians (within walking
distance of housing development)
10
10
b. Parcel is not easily accessible to pedestrians
0
2.3 - AESTHETICS/CULTURAL ENHANCEMENT
40
10
2.3.1- Aesthetic/cultural value (Choose all that apply)
a. Mature/outstanding native vegetation
5
b. Scenic vistas
5
c. Frontage enhances aesthetics of public thoroughfare
10
10
d. Archaeological/historical structures present
15
e. Other (Please describe)
5
f. None
0
HUMAN VALUES TOTAL SCORE
280
130
HUMAN VALUES WEIGHTED SCORE (Awarded
Points/Possible Points*80)
80
37
3 - RESTORATION AND MANAGEMENT (20%)
Possible
Awarded
Comments
Points
Points
3.1 - VEGETATION MANAGEMENT
120
45
3.1.1- Invasive plant management needs (Select the highest
score)
a. Minimal invasive/nuisance plant management necessary to
restore and maintain native plant communities (<30%)
100
b. Moderate invasive/nuisance plant management necessary
to restore and maintain native plant communities (30-65%)
75
c. Major invasive/nuisance plant management necessary to
restore and maintain native plant communities (>65%)
50
d. Major invasive/nuisance plant management and replanting
necessary to restore and maintain native plant communities
25
25
(>65%)
e. Restoration of native plant community not feasible
0
3.1.2 - Prescribed fire necessity and compatibility (Select the
highest score)
a. Parcel contains fire dependent plant communities and is
does not contain fire
compatible with prescribed fire or parcel does not contain fire
20
20
dependent
dependent plant communities
communities
34
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
b. Parcel contains fire dependent plant communities and is
incompatible with prescribed fire
0
3.2 - REMEDIATION AND SITE SECURITY
50
50
3.2.1- Site remediation and human conflict potential
(Dumping, contamination, trespassing, vandalism, other)
(Select the highest score)
Parcel is easily
accessible from
sidewalk and major
a. Minimal site remediation or human conflict issues predicted
50
50
road. May have
some limited human
conflict due to
dumping and litter
b. Moderate site remediation or human conflict issues
20
predicted (Please describe)
c. Major site remediation or human conflict issues predicted
(Please describe)
5
d. Resolving site remediation or human conflict issues not
feasible
0
3.3 - ASSISTANCE
5
5
3.3.1- Management assistance by other entity
a. Management assistance by other entity likely
5
5
AWE
b. Management assistance by other entity unlikely
0
RESTORATION AND MANAGEMENT TOTAL SCORE
175
100
RESTORATION AND MANAGEMENT WEIGHTED SCORE
80
46
(Awarded Points/Possible Points*80)
4 - VULNERABILITY (20%)
Possible
Awarded
Comments
Points
Points
4.1- ZONING AND LAND USE
130
130
4.1.1- Zoning and land use designation (Select the highest
score)
a. Zoning allows for Single Family, Multifamily, industrial or
commercial
100
100
b. Zoning allows for density of no greater than 1 unit per 5
75
acres
c. Zoning allows for agricultural use /density of no greater than
50
1 unit per 40 acres
d. Zoning favors stewardship or conservation
0
4.1.2 - Future Land Use Type (Select the highest score)
a. Parcel designated Urban
30
30
b. Parcel designated Estates, Rural Fringe Receiving and
Neutral, Agriculture
25
35
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
c. Parcel designated Rural Fringe Sending, Rural Lands
Stewardship Area
5
d. Parcel is designated Conservation
0
4.2 - DEVELOPMENT PLANS
50
25
4.2.1- Development plans (Select the highest score)
a. Parcel has been approved for development
20
b. SFWMD and/or USACOE permit has been applied for or SDP
application has been submitted
15
c. Parcel has no current development plans
0
0
4.2.2 - Site characteristics amenable to development (Select
all that apply)
a. Parcel is primarily upland
10
10
b. Parcel is along a major roadway
10
10
c. Parcel is >10 acres
5
d. Parcel is within 1 mile of a current or planned commercial or
multi -unit residential development
5
5
VULNERABILITY TOTAL SCORE
180
155
VULNERABILITY WEIGHTED SCORE (Awarded Points/Possible
Points*80)
80
69
36
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
8. Additional Site Photos
Northwest corner of property
Eastern boundary of parcel in northeast corner
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
37
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
View looking southeast
Eastern boundary of parcel in southeast corner
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
38
ik��RR s
#^ s
'� is � ''+• � �
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
Wild coffee under oaks along northeast boundary
Western side of adjacent property north of parcel
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
40
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
Eastern side of adjacent property north of parcel
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
41
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef Date: January 3, 2024
APPENDIX 1— Critical Lands and Water Identification Maps (CLIP) Definitions
This report makes use of data layers from the Florida Natural Areas Inventory and University of Florida
Critical Lands and Waters Identification Project (CLIP4). CLIP4 is a collection of spatial data that identify
statewide priorities for a broad range of natural resources in Florida. It was developed through a
collaborative effort between the Florida Areas Natural Inventory (FNAI), the University of Florida
GeoPlan Center and Center for Landscape Conservation Planning, and the Florida Fish and Wildlife
Conservation Commission (FWC). It is used in the Florida Forever Program to evaluate properties for
acquisition. CLIP4 is organized into a set of core natural resource data layers which are representative
of 5 resource categories: biodiversity, landscapes, surface water, groundwater and marine. The first 3
categories have also been combined into the Aggregated layer, which identifies 5 priority levels for
natural resource conservation.
Below is a description of each of the three CLIP4 data layers used in this report.
Figure 4 - CLIP4 Prioritv Natural Communities
Consists of 12 priority natural community types: upland glades, pine rocklands, seepage slopes, scrub,
sandhill, sandhill upland lakes, rockland hammock, coastal uplands, imperiled coastal lakes, dry prairie,
upland pine, pine flatwoods, upland hardwood forest, or coastal wetlands. These natural communities
are prioritized by a combination of their heritage global status rank (G-rank) and landscape context,
based on the Land Use Intensity Index (subset of CLIP Landscape Integrity Index) and FNAI Potential
Natural Areas. Priority 1 includes G1-G3 communities with Very High or High landscape context.
Priority 2 includes G1-G3 Medium and G4 Very High/High. Priority 3 includes G4 Medium and G5 Very
High/High. Priority 5 is G5 Medium.
This data layer was created by FNAI originally to inform the Florida Forever environmental land
acquisition program. The natural communities were mapped primarily based on the FNAI/FWC
Cooperative Land Cover (CLC) data layer, which is a compilation of best -available land cover data for
the entire state. The CLC is based on both remote -sensed (from aerial photography, primarily from
water management district FLUCCS data) and ground-truthed (from field surveys on many
conservation lands) data.
Fieure 9 - Potential Habitat Richness CLIP4 Ma
This CLIP version 4.0 data layer is unchanged from CLIP v3.0. FWC Potential Habitat Richness. Because
SHCAs do not address species richness, FWC also developed the potential habitat richness layer to
identify areas of overlapping vertebrate species habitat. FWC created a statewide potential habitat
model for each species included in their analysis. In some cases, only a portion of the potential habitat
was ultimately designated as SHCA for each species. The Potential Habitat Richness layer includes the
entire potential habitat model for each species and provides a count of the number of species habitat
models occurring at each location. The highest number of focal species co-occurring at any location in
the model is 13.
42
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
Figure 13 - CLIP4 Aquifer Recharge Priority and Wellfield Protection Zones
High priorities indicate high potential for recharge to an underlying aquifer system (typically the
Floridan aquifer but could be intermediate or surficial aquifers in some portions of the state). The
highest priorities indicate high potential for recharge to springs or public water supplies. This figure
also includes Wellfield Protection Zones. Collier County Wellfield Protection Zones are referenced in
the Land Development Code and updated in 2010 by Pollution Control and Prevention Department
Staff. The public water supply wellfields, identified in section 3.06.06 and permitted by the SFWMD for
potable water to withdraw a minimum of 100,000 average gallons per day (GPD), are identified as
protected wellfields, around which specific land use and activity (regulated development) shall be
regulated under this section.
43
28.A.14
Initial Criteria Screening Report Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef Date: January 3, 2024
APPENDIX 1— Critical Lands and Water Identification Maps (CLIP) Definitions
This report makes use of data layers from the Florida Natural Areas Inventory and University of Florida
Critical Lands and Waters Identification Project (CLIP4). CLIP4 is a collection of spatial data that identify
statewide priorities for a broad range of natural resources in Florida. It was developed through a
collaborative effort between the Florida Areas Natural Inventory (FNAI), the University of Florida
GeoPlan Center and Center for Landscape Conservation Planning, and the Florida Fish and Wildlife
Conservation Commission (FWC). It is used in the Florida Forever Program to evaluate properties for
acquisition. CLIP4 is organized into a set of core natural resource data layers which are representative
of 5 resource categories: biodiversity, landscapes, surface water, groundwater and marine. The first 3
categories have also been combined into the Aggregated layer, which identifies 5 priority levels for
natural resource conservation.
Below is a description of each of the three CLIP4 data layers used in this report.
Fieure 4 - CLIP4 Prioritv Natural Communities
Consists of 12 priority natural community types: upland glades, pine rocklands, seepage slopes, scrub,
sandhill, sandhill upland lakes, rockland hammock, coastal uplands, imperiled coastal lakes, dry prairie,
upland pine, pine flatwoods, upland hardwood forest, or coastal wetlands. These natural communities
are prioritized by a combination of their heritage global status rank (G-rank) and landscape context,
based on the Land Use Intensity Index (subset of CLIP Landscape Integrity Index) and FNAI Potential
Natural Areas. Priority 1 includes G1-G3 communities with Very High or High landscape context.
Priority 2 includes G1-G3 Medium and G4 Very High/High. Priority 3 includes G4 Medium and G5 Very
High/High. Priority 5 is G5 Medium.
This data layer was created by FNAI originally to inform the Florida Forever environmental land
acquisition program. The natural communities were mapped primarily based on the FNAI/FWC
Cooperative Land Cover (CLC) data layer, which is a compilation of best -available land cover data for
the entire state. The CLC is based on both remote -sensed (from aerial photography, primarily from
water management district FLUCCS data) and ground-truthed (from field surveys on many
conservation lands) data.
Fieure 9 - Potential Habitat Richness CLIP4 Ma
This CLIP version 4.0 data layer is unchanged from CLIP v3.0. FWC Potential Habitat Richness. Because
SHCAs do not address species richness, FWC also developed the potential habitat richness layer to
identify areas of overlapping vertebrate species habitat. FWC created a statewide potential habitat
model for each species included in their analysis. In some cases, only a portion of the potential habitat
was ultimately designated as SHCA for each species. The Potential Habitat Richness layer includes the
entire potential habitat model for each species and provides a count of the number of species habitat
models occurring at each location. The highest number of focal species co-occurring at any location in
the model is 13.
42
Packet Pg. 512
28.A.14
Initial Criteria Screening Report
Owner Names: Gary Van Cleef
Folio Number(s): 57190280000
Date: January 3, 2024
Figure 13 - CLIP4 Aquifer Recharge Priority and Wellfield Protection Zones
High priorities indicate high potential for recharge to an underlying aquifer system (typically the
Floridan aquifer but could be intermediate or surficial aquifers in some portions of the state). The
highest priorities indicate high potential for recharge to springs or public water supplies. This figure
also includes Wellfield Protection Zones. Collier County Wellfield Protection Zones are referenced in
the Land Development Code and updated in 2010 by Pollution Control and Prevention Department
Staff. The public water supply wellfields, identified in section 3.06.06 and permitted by the SFWMD for
potable water to withdraw a minimum of 100,000 average gallons per day (GPD), are identified as
protected wellfields, around which specific land use and activity (regulated development) shall be
regulated under this section.
43
Packet Pg. 513
LO
Q
06
N
(tiZOZ `£ tienuer - aa}}iu WOW tiosinpbr uoi}isinboV pue-1 : 699LZ) s3SI •9.9 :;u8uay3e4lV
Q)
a�
(3)
.
,
N
O
oC
U
.0
A--j
E
0
m
.o
o
�
ro
v
U
:
-0
O
O
U
Q
r
a--J
N
C6
•U
N
Q
Ca
a--+
S✓
N
E
c
O
s`
w
tw
v
2
Ln
Ln
v
co
s`
cn
a
Q
N
(VZOZ `E Ajenuer - 0011!W OO AJOSIAPV uoi;isinboV pue-1 : 65;9LZ) sOSI -9.9 :;u0uay3elIV
r -
4J
W
r �'f ante 010s3o ll o
5Q
7/�
O
(6
N
L
C
C)
U
<
W
(a
r�
V
O L
E U
z
W
0(
�+
z
U)
o (D
- c
w�
z �-
>,
>
•
cn
a)
Q z
U
fu
`p -0
LJL
�
�-: m
N
O
i
c 70
U)
v'
o
O
Co
Q
J W
0
0
0
a�
s
L:
w
of
1-
� m
I I
LO
ON 33IH71OWWI
CIA19 NOSIIM
N
a 0f
M
Q
CL
a
r
F.
U
N
I
N d
N � m
7
w d
� ma
m
YLU
�
c a
a
r
co
a
LLcc
O
p
❑ m
N
Z L
U o a
p
�zU
1
I
(D
LC)
a)
d
d
Y
u
R
d
(tiZOZ `£ tienuer - aa}}iu WOW tiosinpbr uoi}isinboV pue-1 : 699LZ) s3SI -9.9 :;u8uay3e4lV
In
n
0
-1--i
5
\� p
•E
m i
LL U
�co
O LJJ
}' (7
U
Z
LO
6
a
d
V
m
a
LO
Q
06
N
(VZOZ `£ Ajenuer - 0011!W O:D AJOSInpV uol;lslnboV pue-1 : 699LZ) sOSI '8'S :;u9wLlOeUv
WE
•L
L
U
(6
LO
4-
0
0
a�
►-
70
LU �I m
E
�C/)
E
E
O
V co
ca a)
X
a�
as
0
Z 0
I _M
L.L
m u�i
•L � Q%
L
UUnU
CnIW
O
W
Ri Z
.O N
O
cn Q
ELO
o
E
= 0
N N
U
U Q
� U
i 0
L
O
_ .L 0
0
0 a E
0 0 .E
a o
�IW
C'•
Qi Co
U)
v
•� 0
O (D
O_
m �
0
C 0)
ca -0
0 �
a _0
N o
'I11
V
z
ZI 0
Co
0
0 0
tU -0
I v Q
� C �
Lo
co
L 0
U
y- L
U Z Un
n
,o (tiZOZ `E Ajenuer - oa;;iu WOO AJOSIAPV uoi;isinboV pue- : 65;9LZ) s3SI '8'9 :;UMW
Q �
N
zc
z
>_
F
so
rn m Z
p
Q
2 O
v
U
9ooaU
m 111
c
d
E
N
d
=
iiq lMMbN
r�
e wva'n�va�
�Ob
� o
d
��
.�.ba aoonn5oa
U r
6
N
K O
_ a
�
�
3
U
�
i
F
_
C
t0
rr,
Y
�
�
e
K
15llIH ONUS
IUdVH
GS
�,
1D
per'
G
O
(7
iO NVIS2dd
��y G j
�/
GONOJ
p
1
70
V!
O
U
L
1
L
O
E
'Arm
ry
spy
ti6jo
SCOTT DR
c
O� E INLET DR
'%
�Y a
u
a
T O 13lM O
U
0
210131N1M w a
O
0
j
101ry� y y
u
aOp�3ryy y
V
2
O
m
y
d7
In
O
m
- O
00
a
V
m
a
LO
Q
06
N
(tiZOZ `E /(aenuer - 0011!W OO i(aosinpV uoi;isinboV pue-1 : 65;9LZ) sOSI -9.9 :;u0uay3elIV
z
a
d v
a —
°
age c
c -
`v
a UC3¢[g
v
N
N
9
�-
alb IMM4H
J
'
aovavNra�
QO
�
ae raoOM�o
g
u
O Q
Y
U
Q
�
�
U
c
N
�
U
z
1 S 11,H pNvS
1� laesa
PAS
p�A�
c5
1V NtlIStl3d G
W
1•
vJ
1 1
LO
} _
ci
+�
N
VJ
(6
p
L
^�
LE 2
r\�
G
m I —
, ^
VJ
~
}�
O U
O O
i
W
U
O
i
C L
C
O
O
L
U
Co
q
o
Q
J Q
as Q�+�a,ra
s a
YS .)D
O,a
Xo� +d
Od E INLET 9R
2 �yQ p
q4� Na 131NI O V N
aaa3lNiM Q o
V
U �
0
� b00�3iya4,q �
N
2 N
4a
s,�ben3
O
O
O
Q
N
(tiZOZ `£ tienuer - aa}}lu WOW tioslnpbr uoi}IslnboV pue-1 : 699LZ) s3SI •9.9 :;u8LUL43B4lV
-1--+
cn
0
E
m
TA
WE
co _0
cI m
W Q�
Q �
C-cu
Q U
EAU
o 2
co
r.+ E U
E
OC
(a L E
d (6 E
co
Z �
O
CU
_0 E
Q U
CA O O
V
O Co
N
co
Q L
CZ
E_
m
O -0 co
O Co
C
Co
co E
a E
co
O
I 0 0)
*k Z cn
(o (-'• .�
U > U o
col
LU N
U)
U) V-
O
>
0-
0
o �
O (1)
m
U)
�6 N
V
E
_� co
I O
�I �
i
0
om
O
L
� O
c
O
O
V O
I �
LO a)
It U
co
T
L co
O
'i O
A
n
4
lo�o
a
Ao.
(VZOZ 1£ Ajenuer - 0011!W OO fdOSInpV uol;lslnboV pue-1 : 699LZ) NSOI 'a'S :;u8wLl3elIV
N
N
W
a
d
r+
d
Y
V
R
d
(VZOZ `£ Ajenuer - 0011!W OO fdOSInpV uol;lslnboV pue-1 : 699LZ) NSOI 'a'S :;u8wLl3elIV
L
E
E
':3
V^J,
�0
VJ
�L
�L
U
L
0
0
Q�
U)
- --j
cn
L
L
V
O
00
�
v
N
m
C
C
O
O
O
00
N
o_
O
p
�
:E
O
00
0-
v
0U
C
p
>
(n
00
C
O
co
o_
O
�
m
2
N
Q
v
■
>
o
m
�I
U
bn
cv)
O
O
U
W
c-I
O O
O O O
O O O O O
00 l0
I;t N O
00 l0 I;t N
(VZOZ `£ Ajenuer - 0011!W OO fdOSInpV uol;lslnboV pue-1 : 699LZ) NSOI 'a'S :;u8wLl3elIV
Q
06
N
O
O
O
CM
CO
O
U
U)
N
co
co
.O
0
w
L
F—
L
L
U)
r
L J
N o 0 0 0 0
+. rn Ln o o m
E M N m m m
O
a
v
Ln
N
0
a
v
3
Q
o m r- r- m
0 %D u1 N N u1
.o
a
v
s
ao
.v
3
a
�N
0
a
C
'o
a
v
s
ao
v
Q
N
v >-
+, N 4-
m •�—' U
aaj E N c
L 0 U C
V U O
V
> > U E
4-1 a) � a1
U
.O v O
0 > wU
O
_
O
(a
-
O
O
O
O
to
>
2
5
-0
U
N
+r
N
0
a) C
U cn
cn
�
O
o
>
Q
' fn
^
o)-o
O
i
N
O
O (n
LL L
M
w
o
O
U
O
O
N
U E
U
L
L
Q
_0 co
C:
E
LL
00
(�
>
o
a
I
�
U
•i
E O
�
00-U)00
m
>
�
c�
p �
>c:
z)c
UO
(a
m
arL
�_
00 _
a�
m
E
o
N
O
i 0- 0-
-r-
U)CN
-0W
N
Lf)
Cb
a
d
V
m
a
(VZOZ `£ Ajenuer - 0011!W OO f(aoslnpV uol;lslnboV pue-1 : 699LZ) NSOI 'a'S :;u8wLl3elIV
O
00
4-
0
O
co
co
a)
L
O
U
U)
U)
a)
E
D ,
J
°
m
'^
rl
�
m
c
-c:r
m
Ln
N
'o
a
ar
.N
0
a
a�
L
3
a
o
�
rH
+,
c
0
a1
41
s
aA
.v
3
0
a
c
'o
a
a)
s
an
Q)
ar
Q
c
v
aa)
U
C
(B
i
C
W
f0
(B
GJ
�
L
U
a
C
Ln
U
f6
'4-,
v
L
U
U
N
�
a
a
�
N
m
N
N
N
N
4'A
C
O U
0)
O
0)
5;
Q
� N
o
(�
i
L
L
N O
O N
L
0
•U)
i
W
Lf)
p—
U U_
—~
Q E
Q
O
L
W O
�..
C) .
012
U U to
U
N
N
_0
LO
N
Lf)
a
Q)
V
m
a
(tiZOZ `£ Ajenuer - aa;;ivauao:) AJOSIApV uoil!slnboV pue-1 : 699LZ) MSOI '(3'S :4u8wLj3844d
M)
W
4-
0
O
Cfl
N
��0
VJ
- --+
C:
a)
E
a)
m
19
Dil
N
0
00
0
O
0
�
0
O
'O
a
a)
0
a
cu
ca
3
a
O
00
Lr)
Ln
M
N
(V
_
O
a
v
s
aJ
0
a
_
Un
`n
rn
o
0
a
a)
t
cu
c`a
3
a
W
U
E
a-
E
N
N
c6
C
w
bn
4-
in
4
f6
f6
U
c
m
=
o
a)
c
O
o
+,
c
-
a)
E
-
A
0
Vf
w
>
cc
`�
Q
M
M
M
M
N
L
_0
`P
o
a)
L
0
+
cU v
1 i/
N XX
o
Q
o
L
Lo O)
N
a X 0) E co
Cl) .S
_U
^'� 0
�+
(D 0- >, a)U
— 0) a),— (n
cn cn
0
m w co m C m
_
m. ��
m a) 0)
C U c
U
Z
Qc�+r-0
C U
I
C o 1 U m co
p �' o
Q F
co
W
> N '�
.N
d
iaLUUEE_5
d
WS-°aL
0
Q
Q
06
N
(VZOZ `£ Ajenuer - 0011!W OO fdOSInpV uol;lslnboV pue-1 : 699LZ) NSOI 'a'S :;u8wLl3elIV
C)
00
4-
0
0
CV
i
�0
V )
L
ca
V J
n
ry
z
c�
C)
Z)>
75; 0
LL 0)
tY �
a�
N
� � N
= m C^6
l L
J L W
0z
iz C:
ca • ^ 0
C
._ C
N CO 0
CD
0
z
N f
i
m
t '
IL
E
Q
0 ,
0
ti
N
Lf)
Cb
a
d
V
m
a
(VZOZ `£ Ajenuer - 0011!W OO fdOSInpV uol;lslnboV pue-1 : 699LZ) NSOI 'a'S :;u8wLl3elIV
Q
06
N
co
N
Lf)
a
d
V
m
a
(VZOZ `£
Ajenuer - 0011!W OO fdOSInpV uol;lslnboV pue- : 699LZ) NSOI 'a'S :;u8wLj3elly
�
N
N �a
z2
d
U
S ¢ o
+n V QU
d 111
U
SSA
=
y score ow
r
E 1Nl ET OR
m
Tr
P y
N m
L'IV INMVH rJ�,
P�
z
N0331NV
aQH � P
lf013'1HIM W.
ao OOoµ�pQ
i o
U
c
�
1Jllu�
'� J 5AH9 H1LL
5 s p a
W
C�
y
15111H VNtl5
� � �
�
5$
4
cP,�S
I'd
17 dt" M�
-
tos�4b
�8
� l7 MdlSiJ 3d a �,O°`-
(VZOZ `£ Ajenuer - 0011!W OO fdOSInpV uol;lslnboV pue-1 : 699LZ) NSOI 'a'S :;u8wLl3elIV
,_
O
00
aJ
C
Ql
CIO 4-
C ul
O O N 4'
00 E S
L
0to d
0 �O m a1
0 m
(O �
1r N
ONO m aO
N ❑
v N
O +'
U � �
Vi O O
00
fu
+, a,
m 3
3
N Q
a1
7
O
w
� v
L O
00 p
U
W
-i
00 w � NO O 00 w � O O
c-1 c-I c-I
Q
06
N
(VZOZ `£ Ajenuer - 0011!W OO fdOSInpbr uol;lslnboV pue-1 : 699LZ) NSOI 'a'S :;u8wLl3elIV
C)�
L�
0
0
'
L J
00
L
'0
V)
a)
U
.O
0
w
\_
■■
N
o
0
0
0
0
+'
M
Ln
O
O
Ln
s
Ln
F,
O
N
N
O
a
a�
.N
to
O
a
a�
3
Q
O
M
I-
r-
M
4a
%D
Ln
N
r V
Ln
C
'O
a
v
s
h,0
O
.N
O
a
Ln
MI
+'
00
d'
N
c
0
a
v
s
tiA
O
rya
a
v
T
s=
v
a_
U
E
=
N
+�
U
U
U
E
=
0
U
E
>
>
U
N
a)
+,
v
�
o
�>
o
O
>
>�
u
v
>
>
w
W
r-I
c-i
c-I
rl
r-I
N O C:
i p O
(� O
N
0 p OU)(N OU
U0 i U O U) O7
L- m O �
c) (a O
(B W E � -0
UC6�� �-�e.,,� O�
`� 0-. O)o
0
M O'er_ O)OX M,
0��}, O 3:=00 oN-
a�
I m �� m -0w O-0 1 —
UQ U
(Dc�o- 1 3 c-Ov� �:—
O Q-m
U � c '�
= X 0 M,
���� +�� INFO
MO cn a)0M� rU)<
mC:5 EL ilLz2: 00
V>
O� i
V' �E� =—c:E a)
a�d�� O•NU otn E�uJ
O Q
00 O �(am0 O
> 0Lb 0 � 3: = 2:=. LLI-0U
(VZOZ `£ Ajenuer - 0011!W OO fdOSInpV uol;lslnboV pue-1 : 699LZ) NSOI 'a'S :;u8wLl3elIV
o a o
w r m Ln
I:T -1 00 N
O
a
Qr
'N
O
CA
E
3
a
o
O
O
41
v
a,
O
a
O
a
a,
t
an
a�
�o
3
Q
c
v
aa)
U
c
co
t
a=
w
ro ra
41 +
L �
V C a--+ N
>
r s
f0 U U V)
a Q
N N N N
i
i
Q
06
N
(VZOZ `£ Ajenuer - 0011!W OO fdOSInp)y uol;lslnb0)y pue-1 : 699LZ) NSOI •a•S :;u8wLl3elIV
O
00
O
o
CT
a
N
o
O
a
O
4-
0
o
O
a
a,
CY)
E
3
O
Q
00
u)
N
N
L
O
U
'o
C
+-j
a;
o
a
N
O
M
N
O
7
a
C6
�
�
'a3
O
O
3
Q
U
4-041
N
aj
a
a)
U
N
^r
to
E
W
)
R3
L
L
C
tw
ro
C�
Ln
CO
n1
c
C
i
O
c
O
O
O
4
O
Z
a)
C
_
f0
0
+'
CO
4-
bn
(1)
>
a1
E
aJ
f0
4-
N
n
Q
M
M
M
M
> LP
L-
D
E
-0
�>
E
O
cB
O
E
Q
�
z.Q
o0
ono
E
`~o
O
Z3
U
��♦
v
f)
to <
Z
cl)E
(�
O
}�
rn
_/
t�
L
O
.� O
C }'
O
1
O
i
U
E
gy m-
m
Q W W
(VZOZ `£ Ajenuer - 0011!W OO fdOSInpV uol;lslnboV pue-1 : 699LZ) NSOI •a•S :;u8wLl3elIV
0-1 o 0
C 000 00 Ln
O
�O
CL
4J
O
a
ai
m
3
a
ao0 00 Ln N
C_
�O
CL
V
aJ
r.+
t
GO
3
a
O
M
C
w Ln �
'o
a
ar
t
do
3
V
m
3
a
(31 N
m IN
.` D
yc a
C 4.
u c
a,
*= E
�a n
an o
_ 0 N
� N �
CD 0)
L
c� U)
� X
O
U CD
Z)
" O
M i--
Q_ 4—
m
0
U J
�
a) a)
rn
E��
L
ULL a)
Q
c�
E
U
•L
L
S O
U
Ups
O�
O
}
Z
O
O
cn E
E
m 0
a
cn
O
M O
C U
cli! L
(n
i O
% (u E
O i a�
Nd-0
d ao
o :3 0
Q
06
N
(tiZOZ `£ Ajenuer - aa;;ivauao:) AJOSIApV uol;islnbabr pue-1 : 699LZ) MSOI '(3'S :4u8uay3e}}d
C
O
4-0
.En
C
O
U
O
CT
U
I
E
U)
C
no
— O
OO
co 4--'
>-0-0
O
:3 -0
4--' - a)
Q) - L
V O Lo
Y O cn�
N
�QvU)
O cn (a N
D i
O 0) � cn
C: C: N
O 0c: n
O
U
N o) O
QUc�i�
LO
li
O
(VZOZ `£ Ajenuer - 0011!W OO fdOSInpV uol;lslnboV pue- : 699LZ) NSOI 'a'S :;ua
Q �
0 i
N
. 4J
g�= x
_no
+n V QU
d 111
U S7A
� �OY
= y SCOTT C'i
L+
pd E VNSET 7,11
= 4 d a
Y ZZ
L'!� Ih'MVa fJJ" P N
O �. a0131NV _
aQH lf013'1HIM W.
ao o
Dog z
V V
P 2
O-
W
U 'z
11Qot4r,y$ y
y � w
� c� a SAty9 HILL G7 2 � rd � q
3 p w
15 i71H VNtl5
w 7t GZ p � T
� l7 MdlSiJ 3d
a
O
U
L
c�
G
U
70
C
C
Q Q
CO
X_ M
N
O
O m
= 73
(n =5
o i
O 0
L U)
ca i m
� co
I -0 U)
o _(n
� L)
U i
\� Q J Q
O
Cl)
Ul)
a1
a
m
a
(VZOZ `£ Ajenuer - 0011!W OO f(aoslnpV uol;lslnboV pue-1 : 699LZ) NSOI 'a'S :;u8wLl3elIV
4
O
00
L
a)
W \
ul
O o ai
00 E c
to a
L
0 a1
0 �, C
cr N
0 m a
� v N
O 4'
U 76 C
Ln O O
00
C6
a i a1
rM =
N Q
a1
7
O
w
� v
OD
m a
U
W
r-I
O O O O O O O O O O
00 w IZT N O 00 w �t N
c-1 c-I c-I c-I c-I
(VZOZ `£ Aaenue£ - 0011!W O:D AaoslnpV uol;isinb:)V pue-1 : 699LZ) NSOI 'a'S :;u9wLl3e;;d
o
0
0
0
0
N
N
O
00
O
0
'O
r-I
a
a,
tA
0
a
v
L
3
a
Ln
N
N
Ln
'O
a
ar
s
rw
ar
LA
Ln
0
a
O
0
+�
M
N
'o
a
ar
s
aj
Q
.+'
N
+
+,
u
°1
E
u
U
3
U
E
O
U
>
O
E.�
>
U
a,
t4�i1
O
to
�>
O
0
>�
U
>
>
>
WU
r-I
c-I
c-I
c-I
r-I
A
1 -0
U)
U N
_
Y
�00)
O—
E�
Oda)
>�00
O—
U) 0,
C:U)m
�m
�U�
� O
00
.O
O
0,0
0,
Z ocn
o)�
M
UFO
o
cn>
c�
I M M
U)O)m
J
L
>Ln>
+_0ca0
I O
U)�
�c�
'9�cn
QO
�0
=,VO
E
E O
co
(n0)
c�C;)
O�
0 U)�a
V
U
U 0)(n
EU) 07
0.�o
cB
U O
�.,�
�w0
c
°r0oom
}>—,a)cn0)a)
aM
'' ca >
i Q U
>%4-
0 0 0
0
_
Q) O
m0=
ai
in U)CM
0 o 0 0
>a)UO)L
2�
O
3-NU
'U>.U=
W-S�UQ
Q
06
N
(VZOZ `£ Ajenuer - 0011!W OO fdOSInpV uol;lslnboV pue-1 : 699LZ) NSOI 'a'S :;u8wLl3elIV
CO
W
4-
0
O
CM
N
L
O
CU
C/)
W
E
2
4 ,
W
TAI
O
Q�
U)
U)
N
U
U
(0
A
U)
m
(D
a
L
cu
Q
U
Q
L
a�
c
m
O
L
(a
N
N
ca
Q
E
O
L
U)
U)
U
U
0
L
CB
I
cn
N
N L
a
U 0
ci �
Q Q
21
Q
06
N
(VZOZ `£ Ajenuer - 0011!W OO f(aoslnpV uol;lslnboV pue-1 : 699LZ) NSOI 'a'S :;u8wLl3elIV
CD
00
4-
0
O
W
L
0
U
N
E
N
0)
m
i
o a o
., r-% 00 0 0
Ln M O O
'o
a
a,
.a
0
a
a�
E
L
3
Q
va 00 Ln N N
0
a
a,
to
3
a
M
vi
0
a
41
a
OJ
t
no
OJ
.a
[0
Q
+�
c �
N a V
E a)
Q1 a) (/ I
W F v
m aj
m CPI
�L
u o
c 0 +�
0 .�
c*o �j v +,
4, v Ln
'^ > Q
ar
� N m
M M. M M
FoO
>
E E
�>
Q O
O
m
E
Q
}, U
O
a-
E
z Q
O O
>
C�
cl)E
O
E
cn
N
ALE
O
O
—
—
O
�--
C C:
O
-0
p
U
\as
(�
i.�
Nay
N (�
Q W W
0
a
d
V
m
a
(VZOZ `£ Ajenuer - 0011!W OO fdOSInpV uol;lslnboV pue-1 : 699LZ) NSOI 'a'S :;u8wLl3elIV
_N
U
a o 0
e co 00 Ln
0
'o
a
ar
0
a
ai
m
3
a
coo Ln N
c_
'O
a
V
4J
r.+
t
00
3
a
0
a
c
�
L
'o
a
ar
r
do
3
V
0,
a
v
y � d
u J c
a a
*' E
m Q
nn o
L C
c 0 v
j N �
c�
c
c�
0
o
m
CO to
D
D
V
U
�o
z
o E
m
0
cm
_z5E
Cc
j
cL
X
i--
cc
CLM
CD
_EE
��a�
.O
1- o
N -S�U
0
o
C6 -0
CLm
(VZOZ `£ Ajenuer - 0011!W OO fdOSInpV uol;lslnboV pue-1 : 699LZ) NSOI 'a'S :;u8wLl3elIV
1=
O
co
N
U)
U
C
O
U
Q
N
O
C
— O
OO
co 4--'
>-0-0
O
:3 -0
4--' a)
Q] � L
�m Q�
V O u7
Y O cn�
N
�QvU)
cn
=3 L
O 0):
C: c N
O 0c: n
O
U
:34—N 0) O
<0N7>
LO
Ci
O
/Gosinpy uoi;isinboy pue- : 699LZ) bZOZ'£0'W sa6ue43 aoueuipaO ljVba :;uawyoe4ly M
� J �
N Q d
v d $
W Y
VN R
Z a
O a
u 8a�
t� O
ca c�
0 �
c O N
O (� CD
rn
0
O •-
4�
E
+� E
� O
V
� � s
C� V
�I
0
V
r RaosinpV uoi;isinboV pue- : 699LZ) bZOZ'£0'60 sa6ue43 93ueuipap ljVN(3 :4u8w43BllV
Q
It
"'
w
a
Y
U
l0
a
S�
G
cu
Q)
E
z
E
O
s
O
U
V
v�
r
4-J
O
>
v�
-0
O
a�
a
>
O
_0
°e
06
+,
(70
a)
buo
. V
' >
+J,
O
oC
�
�
CAA
CAA
EV
�
�
U
c
Q
,�
J
U
U
m
m
v
O
N
N
bz
O
N
O
N
�
O
O
.�
m
m
�
�
�
000
s
V
00
N
N
U
r-I
Lf)
°
U
RaosinpV uoipsinboV pue-1 : 65;9LZ) VZOZ'£0'60 sa6ue43 aoueuipap-L=IVN4 :4u8ua43e4lV
O
••
O
0
�
N
U
�
�
U
O
,O
O
�
a— j
C/i
�
O
�
U
M
ca
El
11y
r RaosinpV uoipsinboV pue- : 699LZ) bZOZ'£0'60 sa6ue43 aoueuipap-L=IVN4 :;uauayoe4lV
_ co
LO
Q "'
w a
a�
Y
U
l0
a
a--j
4-
0
4-J
O
Q
L
�
L
a--j
4—
O
LL
O
E
O
4-J
4-j
O
buo
aU
V
Q)
OL
•�
U
-a
aA
-0
+�
aA
�-
:3
0
U
..
�
U
O
aA
0
4-j
O
O
U
�
aA
E
"gin
4�
�
a)
�
U
ra
—
U
c�
o
>- U
Q
Q
cn
C�
Q
U
Q coQ
_0
s
O
p
O
U
U
z
r Raosinp�y uoipsinboV pue- : 699LZ) bZOZ'£0'60 sa6uey3 aoueuipap-L=IVN4 :;uauayoe4lV
_ ti
LO
Q "'
w a
a�
Y
U
l0
a
4--j
L _0
ate+ (a N u
(� DC C:v
+ O �
" Q cc
U a--j L
N C:
a� E U O
� o � o o tD.0
O
w b ,bn (U i
0
cn i
. U c a--+
U Oct C: O E
4- bp
�-0 row—
� U
.. E `- Qoc
O (U `r' .. 0
caM u�
O �� �� 0
4-' -C o - E M
cn -0 aA -0 0- O
0 CAA C
w_0 —j ro N
U Q LU
r RaosinpV uoipsinboV pue- : 699LZ) bZOZ'£0'60 sa6ue43 aoueuipap-L=IVN4 :4u8ua43e4lV 00
LO
Q "'
C
w a
(� a)
Y
O U
m
a
O
l—
I*
a- j
LOW
U
V/
4- j
s
W
�
�
�
o
QL
o
U
�
�
� V
C6 �
O �4--j
O V)
Q
N N
E
O �
L
4— N
W V)
E
O
V
/� 1
L V TC
W V
O
•� C
U O
CAA �
N �
L
V �
Ln >
_ oc
r RaosinpV uoi;isinboV pue- : 699LZ) bZOZ'£0' 60 sa6ue43 93ueuipap-L=IVN4 :4u8w43BllV
It
Q "'
w a
a�
Y
U
l0
a
N.
O
L()
n�
W
U
1
N
O
a--+
O
U
m
r
o
-
O'
4-j
(3)
.—
O
��
E�
._
.—
._
4j
W—
r
o
Ln
U
j
Q)
O
O
W
+-+
()
C:
O
O
E
O
4-J
E
4)
U
O
U
ca
a�
V)
Q
U
+z
O
—
LA
'—
O
O
_
0
hA
+-j
+j
O
.
E
'E
U
v
Ca
U
U
U
U
Q�
U
cn
cn
c/)
O
�
O
�
�
�
Q
0
U
U
J
s
O
U
o
U
/Gosinpy uoi;isinboy pue- : 699LZ) bZOZ'£0'W sa6ue43 aoueuipaO ljVba :;u8Wy3e4ly
v —
Q
c
uO
�
N Q O
d
� v
Y
W
V
a s
z
0
�a
0
U
WA
(vzoz'c
Q
ro
N
eeolwwoo
uoil!s!nboy puel
OVVIO Jo; uoileluesaJd dWl gnjos peegliea :luewgoeuy N
n
a
a
m
Y
fi
W
a
6
'
c
C:
+-)
ro
Q
_0
aj
i
u
-0
Qv
—
V1
vi
V
v
+�
roN
,
+�
o
-ro 0
N
' '
+�
Q
E
bA
C
L
O
a+
v
+,
-0
4J
a--J
r-o
iai
w
V
7;
�
+,
ro
m
0
N
a1
u
ro
�
r
N
_
�'
ro
c
�,
N
v
4-j
c
V
-0
v
N
l�
�_
C
O
v
+J
O
O
-0
co
m
D
co
"
c
r
a)
-0
+-J
v
O
-0
N
�
Q
v
N
4J
Q
Q
Q
O
E
QJ
C
.
O
a
Ln
N
eepl W W OO
uoil!s!nboy puel
OVVIO Jo; uoileluesaJd dWl gnjos pe.gliea :luewgoeutl
m
E
E
N
u
H
E
E
V
vi
u
m
Q
E
u
4J
4-0
°O
Ca
.m
i
O
E
ok
m
4-1
MO
L
i
CL
i
m
0
O
•i
V
Q)
CL
i
H
L
m
E
O
N
N
i
ow
4A
A
O
a�
m
Shoo
w
tw
i
m
G
N N
4-0 O
u
m so
0. 4-0
E m.
ow
� N
ow G�
m
Q
.0 4-+ 0
r. m =
i
.� ok
ow
ow Cr
aok
V..
Q �
V •—
•— LL
a �
i V
3 N
o i
•
(4ZOZ `£ tienue£- 0011!ww0O tios!npV u0171s!nboV puel : 699LZ) OVVI0 Jo; uo!leluesaJd dWl gnjog peag!!ea :luewyoellV
n
N
E
e
c
L
0
O O
'� p =
v6 CU CT
c � c
TU
cc -0
4--
c
v Co
Cl)cc CO)
�� a
c O
� 0 �
.Ecc V
2:+ r-
! Co
GJ
>
L.
GJ
Ln Ir.
i 4
S7
o
Annoon,
on-
rl L
(4ZOZ'E tienuep- eslllwwoo AGos,ApV uoil!sinboV Puel : 699LZ) OVVIO Jo; uoileluesaJd dWl gnjog peegliea :luewgoeuV
N
c
x
m N GA19 NV'JOl
CL
p
CL a
�
s�3lvlsa3lvi
a o
� � N
p
08 NOl `JNIAII w
R
a
U
@
ONI in'dodiYJ N
Ja
v
yU v
N
¢S°
/
d
°>■
zal
L U K
'a-
l
Nl
,
8011I9N30NVA
'p m
R F
d
� Z
(4ZOZ'E
a
N
eeuiwwoo
uoil!sinboV puel : 699LZ) OVVIO Jo; uoileluaseJd dWl gnjog peegliea :luewgoegV
ro
O
0
4--j
N
E
b..0
C
C�
G
V)
-J
O
0
r1
�)
(��
V
O
V
b
E
O
N
E
�
O
�--'
O
bA
D Q)
b-0 >
C
O
O
O
Vi
O
N
+
N
�
N Q)
>1
b0
O
+2
—
�
4?
V)
>
_0
O
V4-1
>
Q�
o
O
O
O b0
0
+�
O
O
Vi
V)
O
v
4-1
Q) v
O
>
V
Q)
U
M
O
X
O Q)
a>
V)
>
E
O
O
`�
Q)
Vl
Vim)
Q)
Q)
-
_0
V)
v
+ ,
V)
—
C
O
tap
OU
+�
Q)
C
V
M
Q
V)
Q)
C
-j
V) �
�
bA
O
+�
�6
—
�6
C
�
m
O
—
Q)
D
E
a--1
�
O
OV
E
V
E
C-0
p
Q
O
=
O
N V
tD-OO
Q)
�
4-'
O C
E
V)
Q
O
C
>
(-6
Q)
N Q)
V
C �
V
>
O
0
Ln
_0
Q)
EO
Q) C
v
�
V
1
c6
CD
U
Q)O
c�
0
0)
m
b.0 b-0
V)
Q)
u
V)
M
V
L-
�
.=
O
O
+-'
N
Q
C-0
E
-
�
4-1
O
C
C
m
M
a--'
�
_O
},
O
O
�'
1
O
V)
O
E
O
C
_0
Q)
-00
m
Q)
m
U
U
Q
Q)
M
Ln
>
dJ
m
�
4-1L
E Q)
V
Q)
a--+
4-,
V
Q)
V
O
U
•—
L-
O
M
+�
Q) L-
�
--
4J
�>—,
-0
Q�
O
Q O
>
C
0-
O
Ofv
(4ZOZ'E tienuep- eslllwwoo AGosinpV uoil!sinboV Puel : 699LZ) OVVIO Jo; uoileluesaJd dWl gnjog peegliea :;uewgoeuV
(4ZOZ'E tienuep- eeulwwoo rGosinpV uoilisinboV pue l : 699LZ) OVVIO Jo; uoilelu
Q
ro
N
L
(4ZOZ'£ tienuer - aall!wwoo tios!npV uo!3!a!nboV puel : 699LZ) 3VVI3 Jo; uo!leluasaJd dWl gnjog peag!!ea :luewgoeuV
m
ao a
n a
m
■
E w
O
u E
O
3-O
o_ u
N
> V
V
O O
4-J bQ
O
'
U,)
Q
�
In
Q 0-
In
E
�
�
4- J
N
O
O � ate.-
b�0
N m
w N u
ate--+
O E
to p
Q
rz,J� N N
= >
V)
a� L
N O
0
-0
Q
N ro
N �
••
O
o
W4-
4�
tom
��NO
O
_0
-0 ro
ONE
L
ro
•emu-O
�+
OO
O>,
aJ
—
cn
�
u E
��
u
u
•
Vi
ro
O
V
p� bQN N
i U
�
�
N
In
�n `~
.�
06 ro
N r6
N
_�
-
ro
C
0-
Ln m
Q
_0C
= �O in—
0
0
(4ZOZ'£ tienuer - ooll!wwoo ,jos!npV uo!3!a!nboV puel : 699LZ) 3VV-13 Jo; uo!leluasaJd dW-1 gnjog peag!!ea :luewgoeuV
N
VI
G%
ccu
•
IWI
m
y02'+J
�p )
U_
Zr
LEa_a
Eo -0N
•ram
Cc
LL���
�VJ uE
a
0fomV
O
'0
• r—
E7
O O
O N C
N;,
E O 0]
V w
c c� U c
O
fl.c rn m m
`
d m
fo •a N al
rnNt
c rn a fa
3 Q fo
>
O
��
aU
Ccf2oU
=�m�L
m0 m�
�_� fn�
V
way
Uf^��a�'i
3•; 3
d E
Y�� 3�'a�
0
cLq�
> a
Z
c
o `o o o
o ay
w 3 r
l+
o a
C w
N
jLLU�
•
L E
fa
N m o
f0 fA Ln
CL
`o=
I
Jam+
c
E
d
N w rno
o a�
o 0
o CL
LL
�
CC *o
EL a
>�
V
o
0 0
V
a
o
r� fh
a
U
m
rev V,
f_
d
7
�
M
Il M
• a
d
ti
In
V 01
L
a
M 11
th
}J
2 O
Gfo z
w ,
(VI/�
E
In
.2
V
f0
U
V
O
n '
W
L6
m
N
t N
N fn
[0 fo
x -
•O
N
__
'N
�.
�,
C
Y
E m
o
C6
O
N 01
-o 'O
3 O
-o
C
!
E
L Q
-
i
?
IS 0�7
I
v'
}'
L T
N
E 2
W_,
C
w
o Eq
Ln
E>,
_
o) 7
-fo
fo —
/�/'�7��[7
r y
N +^-j1
LL
a?o
[[pp
8. y
oo�
ip
a3
f0 o
��
N O
��
N
�'a
W
b^-cm
=,
O
N
N _
?
c
N to
m' Y
p
U p
w
f0
N N
l� W
>.
E
o c
E
f$ c
v m
c
c
>�
>
o m
ai a�i m
m-D
z O;
aEr
��
�3
o
�E
cT
m
o,'o
O
E
o)
t (1v
'A
m3m
o
m
��
V N
El
aE
yx
o
;LL
o
> 4-J
> C6
y E
`o
m
a�i
m 3
N
3
t
'ro->
x
Y
o
?
E
'�O
fo
C N
o a
ro
E e
LL E
o
0 3
O
!n a
co
LL
U m
VQ 1' T
.-�
O
M
N
O
o0
M
N
O
O
O " O
Q �--�
to
7
n
M
r,
O
V
M
O
H }J
O (^n1
fl
N
N
o
3
°o
m
E
3
N N
�_
fo 0
—
O o
m
C7
aDi o
u
0 0
y
LL
N
O
x=
V
aLL
L
O
N m
ca r
fn
3
N
ro
+J
i--' N
ro N
v
:3
CT-0
CL C—
,- O
O
Ln N
(6
� �yy
�' ro
L
3: E
0
�.
� •-
�-
Q
E
R
^^ll
r
D
Q
1�' I
T N
C V_
m
j
N
-
$
-
V
(4ZOZ `£ tienue£- 0011!ww0O tios!npV u0171s!nboV puel : 699LZ) OVVI0 J07 u0!le4uOsaid dWl gnjog peaq!!ea :luewyoellV
c
p
_{.
V
U
c�
O
O
V
�
N
+�
CO
N
4
Q
-aLn
L
Q
:3
N
N
O
ro
N
+.+
4-O
. u
Q
N
N
L
•-
N
C
m
>
LLL
O
>
2
O
C:
�
•`—'
v
Q
�
+-1
�
�-
v
Lnro(1)
ru
0
M
o
o
Q�
�
*
U
Q
U
c
a,
x
r
c
O
m
},
U
W
cm
N
O
ro
-
Qj
C:
.
Q
O
Q
v
Q
;
O
O
4
N
N
QJ
u
u
vi
a--'
O
V
C :
Q
Q
W
L
Q
Z)
T
O
c
.,1
a)W
>
N
O
D
O
N
�
�
O
O
�
ro
4-1
0-
c6
C
V
M
O
Ol/1
_
O
u
v1
C
r6
N
N
_0
ro
r
L-
—
>
+�ro
0
0
ro
Q.
v
+-
v
u
�
O
�
v
v
+,
v)
m
Q
ro
ro
O
ro
N
Q
>,
ro
O
�
E�
��
Qb-0
u_
�-
O
+�
Z
u
ra
In
>�
>
W
u
CL
Q•
•
(4ZOZ'E tienuep- ssuiwwoo AGosinpV uol;lsinboV puel : 699LZ) OVVIO Jo; uoilelueseJd dWl gnjog pesgjiea :;uswgoeuV N
Q
oa a
N a
w
u
n
a
l—
O
E
N
Q) O
O O
C U
O
+� a)
U a""'
m
Q)
-0 Q)
a�
O
+-)
C V)
OL-
N �
c
v a)
_0 X
� Cl)
u
V)
a)
L
CL
�_ V)
C E O
E QJ C
O
O to
V Q
N
4' M O
O U V
0Ln a) Ln
�E�°'
O. E
a� Q)
Q E -o
v
Q,_0
O C
Q1 O V
v�4
`F-- °-- 0
v �
O
E
v
Q V
O
v c °'
Ln M
V)
"c O
E
O
Ln Q) a QJ
V>
E > a
V
N V
Q- u
In by C
Q)Lp
u
O Ln
> E
u v
O L
(� Ln
(1) Q O
-0 u Q ()
V O vi
m QJ O W
-c u v >
EE�-00 CD
- Q
O-0 C
a� � O
4-1
O c�
O U U
> .(a)
N O C
V O U
u
O C "�
U b0 O
o
Ln
—_ 4�
QJ
QJ
a'
Q
U)
Q)
Nb�o
E
b0
o
LE
E
o
v<
m
O
N
Q�
O
u
o��.°J
(D
-
v
O
a--)
Q
+-' v
u
O
C
N
+�
0
>
E �-C
Q)
M
3:
o
4-
Q)
C
C
o
-0
Ln
u C
v
v
CD-
_0
a'
Q
V
(4ZOZ'£ tienuep- aauiwwoo tiosinpV uoulsinboV puel : 699LZ) 3VVI0 Jo; uoileluasaJd dWl gnjos peagiiea :luewgoeuV
N
S
L
s
c�
z Cd
O W
W ON
z V
O
M
r.-
LALL
r
JLA
LU
�UCe
m0LL
0
w :) Z
m 0 w
u z z
w
��a
azo
Q
:
L/, 0 w
m�0�
0 m Z
w Q Q Z
m = w J
w w
i
to 0LU
0
w
U
LU 0 z
j)G Y
LA
to
Z
=LUO
m — w
w
LU H
Z
2
�LU
,o (4Z9Z'E tienuep- ssuiwwoo AGosinpV uol;lsinboV puel : 699LZ) OVVI3 Jo; uOlMueseJd dW-1 gnjog pesgjiea :;uswgoeuV
Q
ro
N
r
n
_0
O
(1)
4-)
C
L O
O
U u
a--j
Q) >
4--
Q)
a- U)
u
Q)
Q)
Q)
++
-0 O
L N
In
Q) L L
U)L O
a-
O
Q)
4-J C
In
��-
u Q)m
O
Ul
-0 X
u
Ln
v v
m
C
v
O
C
c6 N
+�
a) +�
(n
u
(A
E Lm
iV)
i
4--J
C
Q)
Ln
a)
u
u
O
},
Q)
O
EL
O
a-�
u
O
a)
i%
u
a
CQ
°) N
c
c m
=
O
2
4-o
a)
3
-0
�
m
m
E
o
o
U)
Q)
Q
U- E
U�
V)N
O N
C Q)
N
C6 i—
V)
o
4-�
a)
-0
i
C
EQ
L.L -0
v
Av
U
Z3
N � �
L
Q Q
'N N
C6 •� �
oN L--
O
ro Q
+� E �
C 0)O
L C l/1
O � —
0—
a) E
V)
O
E
c Ln E
ro
m u 0)
L
u v
W Q I--
(4ZOZ `£ tienue£- 0011!ww0O tios!npV u0171s!nboV puel : 699LZ) OVVI0 J0; u0!lelu0s0Jd dWl gnjog peag!!ea :lu•wyoellV
^E
W
cn
I
vi
fa
E
f6
E
C
fa
a)
is
L
fo
L
O
f6
0)
a)
L
C
f6
L
V)
0
Q
L in
a) a-J
V
Ln a) a)
L (n
a) -0
� C
fu
L
a)
L
C
>
0
N
-0
•—
(n
Q
_
0
a--1
c
�
L
�
r�
L
a--i
L-
;
-W
L
0
-0
ate-+
C
UU
U—
V
V
M
Ln
fo
Q
L
—
a-J
0)
0)
fDLn
ul
—
O
O
Ln
U
fa
5.2
n
O
(6
L
a)
N
L
Q
-0
a)
0
L
(n
0
U
4,
C
C
=
Q
fa
a)
•L
fu
O
70
4-1
L
0
fu
4-'
a)
fn
O
C
m
a
w
-w
fo
Vfo
C
fn
—
(n
4-J
)
L
OU
01
Ln
—
C
O
fa
O
ateJ
N
Q
a)
Ln
fo
LCz
-0uE
a)
v,
�
-
�
(n
N
0
�
L
U
U
4
O-
O
O
L
0
(n
M
.X
L
N
cn
Q
0
C
%
N
0
0
0
QC
-
O
U
m
Ln
—
4-1
fu
fo
—
C
C
0
N
-0
O
(n
�
a
-0
a)
U
fo
>
f6
L
(n
C
f6
V)
x
Q)
-,
L
L
0-
C
C
Ufu
N
V
a)
.0
ra
L
�
a)
a)
cn
O
Ln
fu
0
4-J
Q_0
L
0
0
(n
a)
a)
C
C
Q)
•O
p
(n
0_
0
fo
M
U
0
-+
a
=
Ln
f6
E
�
a--+
a--+
(�
fn
N
0
C
a)
Ol
T
—
te.
a",
r—
. —
L
a
V
a+(n
—
Ln
O
_
--i
afo
Q
-W
fu
a--+
fa
Ln
L
-0
0)
C
U
C
a..+
a)�-0
u
�
�
fo
f6
fu
—
4--
C
L
-C
�
LU
w
f6
� L
Ln
+j
fz
+j
a-j
- F- U1
bA Q)
u
00-
>1N
� a)
(n
L —
N
ro -0
O�
-4--+
N
N Q
u
u•—
ro-0
ulC
D fo
0C
b-0 E
C E
00
V u
N i
7-0
�ro
O�
>-+ E
a) C
i ro
N �
N u
N 0
Q
C
ru
4-j
C
M
O
0
(4ZOZ `£ tienue£- 0011!ww0O tios!npV u0171s!nboV puel : 699LZ) OVVI0 Jo; uo!leluesaJd dWl gnjog peag!!ea :luewyoellV
O
Q)
O
cn
U—)
4— d
4--0
-
4-
c
O
0
O
O
m
u
v
Q
O
O
>
v
O
Q
v
U
�
4
v
w
�
—
to
=
=
O
m
��
��
Q)
b-0
LL
co
U�
O
O
0
ru
co
-0
_
(a)
�6
ro
t /)
—
l/1
0
—
N
U
0Q
N
:-
QJ0
L —T
ra —0
0�_
4- L
L
Lf) Q
a, E
V
U•-
In C
:3 ro
Dr—
o
S E
c E
00
V U
N i
L �
Ol--
-.w
+� E
�-0
aJ c
a, ro
LnU
�0
ro
ro
(4ZOZ `£ tienue£- 0011!ww0O tioS!npV u0171S!nboV puel : 699LZ) OVVI0 Jo; uo!leluesaJd dWl gnjoS peaq!!eM :luewyoeliV
0
V
C
c
0
u`
v
a,
a
E
m
x
w
m
a)
O
O
O
a--
l/1
�
Q=
v
E
O
O
c�
�_
0
4—
�
a--
�
QJ
bC-0
Q
U
Q
O
N
Q�
N
C
O
O
C
O
n
U
. E—
00-0
-0
N
� N
O Q
>1 N
---- a)
N
L —
a) _0
�-0
ON
-�-- 7-
to a)
Ln Q
aJ E
V
U•—
�-0
v1 C
:3 ru
Or-
�O
b-0 E
�E
00
V U
N i
�O
Ol--
E
�-0
Q) c
L ro
aJ U
a)O
Q
ro
O
(4ZOZ'£ tienuer - aall!wwoo tios!npV uo!3!a!nboV puel : 699LZ) DVVI0 Jo; uo!leluasaJd dWl gnjog peag!!ea :luewgoeuV
Q
ro L
N T
y
bA
c
O
N
:_
-0
O
^
W
QJ
O
ra
Oro
O :
.v
aJ
rr6
(A
W
�
N
-J
c
(�
>'
r6
O
lJ 1
In
O
M
Ln
N Q
N
L
:3
U
EJ
O
O0
a)N
N
E
v
�
�
O
O
Vi
N
N
N
1
to
>
Q
v
Ln
Ln
V
Lf)
Q
ro
(A
V
v
N
N
a)—
O
1
i
C
0
� V
Q
`��
N
�zro
o
O
ro
N
U��
ate-+
O
m
E
i
N
ate-+
E
E
7
ro
Ln
V
O
>
O
>
O
J
�
O
bA
N
U
V
U
Ln 0
m
(4ZOZ `£ tienue f, - aalllwwoo AjOsinpV u0141sinboV puel : 699LZ) OVVI0 Jo; uoileluesaJd dWl gnjog peagliea :luewyoellV
I
c
O
^V
W
O
L
r
Q
N
E
(1)
V
L
aJ
V
-0
p
C:
l/ I
O
>,
4
O
L
c6
N
O
c
U
r6
c
r6
V
E
E
O
a,
N
bNA �
a) vn
Ln N
c6 �
aJ �
L N
V
a)
L
V
a)
N
a)
V
C
a)
tw
E
V
O
4-J
N
4-
0
a)
L
4-
0
O
ro
O
V)
(1)
A
m
a
N
Y
U
A
a
m L +-+
E
L
E r
L
t ^ ro
1 �Z�3^
O
ul E
i--r �~
V U
O O-0 tw
N
Ln a) �
aJ > .
V X
ro N a)
aJ i
O
N_
0 LJ N
V
M a) 4-1
C: N Ln
D 4-j
Z3 C aJ
O ro E
4-j V
� r6
N
O O
i aJ
a,
Ln >1+
1 I^n1
W A
V V
O N
Ln
� C �
ro
� O
ra'LnO
O
l7 E
7Z `£ tienuer - aalilwwoo AjOslnpV uolllslnboV puel : 699LZ) OVVI0 JOl u011eluesaJd dWl gnjog peagllea :luew4oel7V
v
M X X X X X X
O
N
M
M
O
X
X
X
X
X
X
N
N
M
O
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
N
ti
X
X
X
X
X
X
N
O
M
O
X
X
X
X
X
X
N
cl
m
Q,
ao
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
N
H
O
N
O
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
�
a+
N
V
C
X
X
X
X X
X
X
X
V
N
C
ko
N
X
X
X
X
X
X
X X
X
X
X
C
ro
N
O
X
X
X
X
X
X
N
\ a,
M
NO
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
N
N
C�
C
N L9
Vl UJ
{mil 0
oZi V1 D
C
gJ
E
[O
i
[O C
tp
y
iz aJ
L
O"
pO�J
8
V O C c
gD V C� � [;
C C L
O
!1 L
d�
O
i=�
7
VLu
c N
O_
D _0) c
(n
C 'C QV H
�
O C ZT
ra
OL
Q
O
C
O
R
4J
w
V U �+
Cn N
C V
'
ce
01 Z'
�O(
I,J,J
c
c lY
[O d
2
0
2
C
-6�
0 7 a2S
iE
H Q Q
N
yVy
U- Cn
ce
U-
0
Q
Bul
H
d
u
C
In
Ln
N
•+
u1 Ln
fA
7
u
+R
V
O
rn
O
V 1~fl
O
O N
O
0
uI
O
O
m
IT
O
111
Ln O
O
O
.�
O O
O u1
N+A
.ti
fR
L
:R
^
V1
N
4A
.a
N
Vf /A
a
�
'R
o+ y
u
V,
3
L.0
LL
u u u
u
u
U
u
U
u
V
u
V
u u
U U
u
V
u
U
u u
U U
U
j
LL
01
VI a+
v
b
y^
r&rpp b
_
a
�
L
N
Y
O
C
rp
O O
O� O
O
a
W
v
b
u
u
c
m
c
°� c
O
a
.'c.
01
H FF c =
m 3
c
f0
b
v,
W
w
uN
v
F
u
c m
C
.�
W
c
3 ` u
�b
>
O
ub 5" ..
.�u.
w�
05
% m
c c
a
c
�
&c
.�
N
&
�Q
`�
c
��
a
��
U
c u.5
a
c
o
fN_�
1. uu
(g
f
*; u?
N
��
c C
H
c
�'
v
O 7
N
Gl
°� c
yy
v
c
O�
N�p"
Q
A
w
a
c
Q a
a
LL
m
f
m
p
m
c
a
u Y
Q
Q
av
a`
W
a
> uo
ui
u w
w c
m
a
L,
c
H
3
v)
Q.
*LL
F.
(4ZOZ'S tienuep- eewwwoo AGosinpV uoil!sinboV Puel : 699LZ) 3VVIO Jo; uoileluesaJd dWl gnjog peagliea :3uswgoe;IV
28.A.2
AGENDA
CONSERVATION COLLIER
LAND ACQUISITION ADVISORY COMMITTEE
January 3, 2024, 1:00 P.M.
Commission Boardroom
W. Harmon Turner Building (Bldg F), Third Floor
All interested parties are invited to attend, and to register to speak. Individuals who would like to participate in
person must complete and submit a speaker form. Members of the public who would like to participate
remotely should register HERE to complete the online speaker registration form. Remote participation is
provided as a courtesy and is at the user's risk. The County is not responsible for technical issues. Individuals
who register online will receive an email in advance of the public hearing detailing how they can participate
remotely in this meeting. For additional information about the meeting, please call 239-252-2961 or email
conservationcollier@colliercountyfl.gov
1. Roll Call
A. Approval of CCLAAC members attending the meeting remotely
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Approval of December 6, 2023, Meeting Minutes
4. Old Business
A. Acquisition Updates
Current Acquisition Status Report is updated monthly in advance of CCLAAC
meeting and provided as part of meeting packet. The report is posted online under
Acquisition News at: www.conservationcollier.com
B. Purchase Agreements
No purchase agreements are currently ready for review as of printing of this
agenda. Other purchase agreements ready before the meeting will be posted
online and presented to the committee:
https://www.colliercountyfl.gov/qovernment/public-services/divisions/conservation-
collier/agendas-minutes/2023-meeting-packets
C. Caracara Land Management Plan update
5. New Business
A. Railhead Scrub Preserve Land Management Plan 10-year update
B. Conservation Collier Ordinance Revisions
C. Cycle 12B Initial Screening Criteria (ISC)
1. NGGE TPMA — McIntosh Family Trust
2. Marco Island TPMA — Ramoski Trust
Packet Pg. 296
28.A.2
D. Cycle 12B Initial Criteria Screening Report (ICSR)
1. Sarry Trust
2. Marco Island TPMA
a. HK Investment
b. Van Cleef
6. Subcommittee Reports
A. Lands Evaluation & Management —Chair, Ron Clark— last meeting September 21, 2023
B. Outreach — Chair, Brittany Patterson -Weber -last meeting January 20, 2023
C. Ordinance, Policy & Rules— Chair, Michele Lenhard -last meeting December 18, 2023
7. Coordinator Communications
A. BCC Items Related to Conservation Collier
1. Previously Heard 12/12/23 (all approved on consent)
a. North Belle Meade Preserve FWC Funding Assistance Application
b. Dr. Robert H. Gore III Preserve Final Management Plan
2. Upcoming 1/9/24
a. Florida Wildlife Corridor Foundation MOU
b. Ordinance 2002-63 revisions
c. Pepper Ranch Funding Assistance application
B. Miscellaneous
8. Chair and Committee Member Comments
9. Public Comments
10. Staff Comments
11. Next Meeting February 7, 2024
12. Adjourn
. ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■
Committee Members: Please notify Summer Araque at 239-252-2979 no later than noon Friday,
December 29, 2023, if you cannot attend this meeting or if you have a conflict and will abstain from
voting on an agenda topic.
Packet Pg. 297
28.A.3
AGENDA
CONSERVATION COLLIER
LAND ACQUISITION ADVISORY COMMITTEE
January 3, 2024, 1:00 P.M.
Commission Boardroom
W. Harmon Turner Building (Bldg F), Third Floor
All interested parties are invited to attend, and to register to speak. Individuals who would like to participate in
person must complete and submit a speaker form. Members of the public who would like to participate
remotely should register HERE to complete the online speaker registration form. Remote participation is
provided as a courtesy and is at the user's risk. The County is not responsible for technical issues. Individuals
who register online will receive an email in advance of the public hearing detailing how they can participate
remotely in this meeting. For additional information about the meeting, please call 239-252-2961 or email
conservationcollier@colliercountyfl.gov
1. Roll Call
A. Approval of CCLAAC members attending the meeting remotely
2. Approval of Agenda
3. Approval of December 6, 2023, Meeting Minutes
4. Old Business
A. Acquisition Updates
Current Acquisition Status Report is updated monthly in advance of CCLAAC
meeting and provided as part of meeting packet. The report is posted online under
Acquisition News at: www.conservationcollier.com
B. Purchase Agreements
No purchase agreements are currently ready for review as of printing of this
agenda. Other purchase agreements ready before the meeting will be posted
online and presented to the committee:
https://www.colliercountyfl.gov/qovernment/public-services/divisions/conservation-
collier/agendas-minutes/2023-meeting-packets
C. Caracara Land Management Plan update
5. New Business
A. Railhead Scrub Preserve Land Management Plan 10-year update
B. Conservation Collier Ordinance Revisions
C. Cycle 12B Initial Screening Criteria (ISC)
1. NGGE TPMA — McIntosh Family Trust
2. Marco Island TPMA — Ramoski Trust
Packet Pg. 298
28.A.3
D. Cycle 12B Initial Criteria Screening Report (ICSR)
1. Sarry Trust
2. Marco Island TPMA
a. HK Investment
b. Van Cleef
E. Advisory Board vacancy application(s)
6. Subcommittee Reports
A. Lands Evaluation & Management —Chair, Ron Clark— last meeting September 21, 2023
B. Outreach — Chair, Brittany Patterson -Weber -last meeting January 20, 2023
C. Ordinance, Policy & Rules— Chair, Michele Lenhard -last meeting December 18, 2023
7. Coordinator Communications
A. BCC Items Related to Conservation Collier
1. Previously Heard 12/12/23 (all approved on consent)
a. North Belle Meade Preserve FWC Funding Assistance Application
b. Dr. Robert H. Gore III Preserve Final Management Plan
2. Upcoming 1/9/24
a. Florida Wildlife Corridor Foundation MOU
b. Ordinance 2002-63 revisions
c. Pepper Ranch Funding Assistance application
B. Miscellaneous
8. Chair and Committee Member Comments
9. Public Comments
10. Staff Comments
11. Next Meeting February 7, 2024
12. Adjourn
. ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■
Committee Members: Please notify Summer Araque at 239-252-2979 no later than noon Friday,
December 29, 2023, if you cannot attend this meeting or if you have a conflict and will abstain from
voting on an agenda topic.
Packet Pg. 299