Loading...
CESM Agenda 01/19/2024 (DD)Co ler County Growth Management Department Code Enforcement Division Special Magistrate Hearing AGENDA Board of County Commission Chambers Collier County Government Center 3299 Tamiami Trail East, 3rd Floor Naples, FL 34112 January 19, 2024 9:00 AM NOTE: ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL A DECISION OF THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS PERTAINING THERETO, AND THEREFORE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. NEITHER COLLIER COUNTY NOR THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE SHALL BE RESPONSIBLE FOR PROVIDING THIS RECORD. I. CALL TO ORDER -SPECIAL MAGISTRATE PATRICK H. NEALE PRESIDING II. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES V. MOTIONS A. MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE OF IMPOSITION OF FINES HEARING B. MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF COMPLIANCE DEADLINE C. MOTION FOR RE -HEARING VI. STIPULATIONS VII. PUBLIC HEARINGS A. HEARINGS • CASE NO: CEEX20230010561 OWNER: Zachary Waldstein OFFICER: Danielle Jersey VIOLATIONS: Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances, Chapter 14, Article II, Section 14-38. Collier County Domestic Animal Services (CCDAS) has determined that there exists sufficient cause to make the initial determination that the dog is a "Dangerous Dog", `Balashi". FOLIO NO: PROPERTY 9143 Trivoli Terrace, Naples, FL 34119 ADDRESS: B. EMERGENCY CASES VIII. NEW BUSINESS A. MOTION FOR REDUCTION/ABATEMENT OF FINES B. MOTION FOR IMPOSITION OF FINES AND LIENS IX. OLD BUSINESS A. MOTION TO AMEND PREVIOUSLY ISSUED ORDER B. MOTION TO RESCIND PREVIOUSLY ISSUED ORDER X. CONSENT AGENDA A. REQUEST FOR SPECIAL MAGISTRATE TO IMPOSE NUISANCE ABATEMENT LIENS ON CASES REFERENCED IN SUBMITTED EXECUTIVE SUMMARY. B. REQUEST TO FORWARD CASES TO COUNTY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE AS REFERENCED IN SUBMITTED EXECUTIVE SUMMARY. C. REQUEST FOR SPECIAL MAGISTRATE TO IMPOSE DAS CITATION LIENS ON CASES REFERENCED IN SUBMITTEDEXECUTIVE SUMMARY. XI. REPORTS XII. NEXT MEETING DATE- FRIDAY, FEBRUARY 16, 2024 AT 9:00 A.M. XIII.ADJOURN to ¢ o c z 0 � (1) s 0 o U � ` D C mLcli O o a Z3 o N D O _0 O O L m a^ ° o d" o LU o N Q (a L O o C14 O� Z W (n�' 0 v L n� 0 CO En a ao O N C V 7 (D � W N (U O O O N U m Y�� E v b �• �' a Q K W o Q U U) LL zLLI c to _ c p io cc Q Z -m a ��° •:: � U Q7 U y 0 N Ul D LL s 73 > Q U? U Z @ IL O 7 p Q N N�.N wpm ❑ U (0 a 0 UON C-0 pL O LlJ gym° o?� �cc ONO 70 U ,, O J 2= +--. W co n 0 p U CC °�E E y mn (D`O U) , J ¢ (� 3 C a -O Z � as m rn rr 0 LL � �, _ to 0? M W Q " N C � 6. rn m Oo M 3 ca m Lu °�o co A °o•� H o._ O= •� q LLO N p cA 0 � c ❑❑ O 0 H in -(a 'I) a 4m U U LL N 6] Ci O 7 U UJ O p y E a W� rL LL v -0 a❑ M } N� a> gym: ccF= ¢ CV .V cn C o¢ M Z C C H (V a) ~ � H US r - D W J J u W 2 CD 0) LL a p 00 (} co 0) 7 C� 47 � m z N ❑ p (U (D Lo _> ° co � m c m Q 0CL C n vi (A 0HW L C Uv O=� Cl) aci ooY U N 0 M c m a) af ¢ m O O a) E O U p N o am V o (o z 0) Q° m� m o a ww o�� ai M � �� z ram+ H N (6 L101 °DCc) z LJJ LU O y a7 +� (6 N J O � o c-a m E W p O {Q an - N a ° �^ aNi a cLnOa m('> E �' r a W Z C a O C O r- (U n J ¢Z QICL a) C io h C C QUNZ� OOP U a c V a'- p N Q a Da F'W a7 � a) Q) O y ,> Em E C7 O ❑ y L ❑ �c a) O _o ) oac N 00 �n�; � N W - •a , = W Q) N C �� Z 0 �p CD a� c LL o70 a E 4 ro p o 0 - +a) p a 0 O W L) c ° E 0 m� = a r aci LU Z C O - a) c� Q C ❑ W `� a) U [6 c N U 0 a z ❑ O UW C Q7 O O M ❑ N ❑ (j "r W L) a c o } U)Q O CQU O W ( mLE oUcu>' L cv ns'a cL O0 c�M O H way' w w ��� � 2 U O LL Z w w 7 T ~ Z W 2 C F o O (D al U) - 5 Xo c Q T mac O p a0 0U_ z 0�� z `! Z ��� LL O a �°'� `°�) ❑ Z 0❑ 0 Q -p a7 (Vp 0 LL Ye W y O w mUo `a N o En>� Uci ¢Ma Z 0 N w Y� 0 o WL 7 D W ao LL� Z Ix apf° im- - POL � oa~ O� w 3 O o W m� w Z aa) =°=S-a�a ❑ W Q Uy a L) Q F W Q Q an (D° @ U m Q J I U a o LU v W W U a a W � (D w u o U)� as o H 0 W 00 ui J ti N ¢ � J O O W _J '> J (D U c Q co 0 0 �n 7 fn U > d O i 0 F- d > J fA d a) Q d U) .c ¢ m Z 2 Q a m O V1 Q V A V � O p E c C ao LL m O O 0 3 c m m w O c oa m C O ❑ m -0 C c O co a Q > U - m E ro L > LM .n O u C �; �'� Y L o 0 c "' p �O O r LA o o c O O > C r > d rq O a+ O u c vri a ` Ln ti m 'L E O 'C i CL -C N u E c C Y r D m a N Y L i.J Ccli U m C n o m, o � `m EO 61 'O '+., =LA Y cn a `7 m Y C > U C) O O Cl a OD w u I-- C 0 r`p U C C - gym,, U r j VI c � N a t L O L.) w r CL O in +�+ a � 3 o �r o `a a ` v CL cu m L v a -� a C v O Y •� � m C a mLA� O m a s o f m a > u �- a a m Cq a+ U a Y M O o E m m c C Ct c D C r > O d C O m u' . ry a t: O > m C L c S C N u - O D to E 0 u v mU c m �' o a C m.n O p -0 c L o" go- a O E C 3 •� d 0 0 c m a y �; m a}+ > ,� O m m m m y a 7 2O to E LL u m u r Q tco a ❑❑ m ` 3 a cr L a L cn ❑ vi m m mF- U u E ;n -C ❑ E N L 10 O v O C r m E O qD '� C O L.L O o � W aj -C r L > V `a U c a � W CD M m Q L �,y C 0 CL O -a a Q CL w C D cJ c . c O u a CL CL � a � c u o r a,+ e OD of cr to a 0 O O m m m m O X/9 ❑ C,m � O O - E 'tt o a c a a Q 3 d ° o ► F a Q p Avai O mra v E O m c m n U m a 3 o L.mti c c `.t %. C O a N U m m u V — C Epp OI N 0 cu >- ,E to a E o a O I c a m � u 3 v c 00 C a ¢ o C y m !0 N L w+ tl0 L fb C 4y T a a a L O - a IV c O C C O r G in a% a a C ,y c y C D a D a; v�cc E � rEo O � w > t m o n E C m EO IS m i o o c ° a a m ¢ z m C C a 0 Q r tb O O m OCo MNA 4 w Y m � a r m +-+ v Y a m a C m a 3Qj p a c O � 3 O o El m G tl� n ' o 4- 0 cu n° W) Q mo W �' �• A c O C y u VJ u 6> L L3 as 6J F c� w� �� � ACJ� c ' �':o L•�U c �� • o a� � cU ice' c C c�. a o _ o ,_ 0 5 o�0oU :o O > O QU a> C- Q O O U �.>'. ti C O C Q b v t O O 0.2 Q L U !O� G CC O Cd mo � ('� v > � 'O a u o 4. .� +- • U ' C� r 1 �ii L" a 4tu G_y� J O G j'.�r • N O W rb1 --, E u Clu p ¢! O D U O CA o v o vi G 00 tn Rom. Q` o o v " ' p `' ° `� ° o O V -� C iC L U• N LY : v 7 a� n o °^ .o a, ro 3= c ° a o 'U A 'c� `" +. a •S y b .� C �11 oq ++ ►. ? y O 0 L .I L7 y CL E j U � � § § 0 2'%/ � § 2 c u± k% CL$ 0 § \ k 0 $ « w u m zi j � ? ° cm \ \ \ 7� u ( J k o/§ 2 CD ° `� 2c A k U • u u 0 �' 2§ S o d U > q u u O c C-A w�� \ & %��G n &30o G n Un2 d u Q 00 m d .i v LA m C ro v L a1 v r 3 0 N V) Qf "C3 ro au L C d V N N _ro U CO 0 v N 0 a bo C ro aw O v al ro d N uo c v c ro q,0 D N 0 Qj qA c ro ro 0 v C aS ro taD O a O Z N u N ro 0 QJ �s d CZ �a N L C ro O a 0 u O a, bA C_ C ai CZ di a) c C1 N L- aU c 0 4 d w 0 Q) w ro C d ro ar C C o u N N v 0 '0 N O c ro ° C p ro CtA N �W Q! .c � al pfnp C G G ro L ro hD `i C1 N c o L O d a 00 O C 0 a ~ LAL v O 'o ro ro Y w u (J w n f «L. as C = C LO ro j L c 0 O N ±~ C O }, LAN � C L al �° ro C O 7, ro E N °; a) c Q E m E o �- u o C C 3 C p Z ro 6p `n j a 0 .L 70 0 .r 4 u O1 G a", O 0 'p w C -ro y d E w O an N Cl 4 DA 0 j d W u u ro G C E CC 3vG3 W u Q7 u N E O C L E o -° a +�+ N Ou L o in C1 N Ln L a 0 E i a� b4 C aU C O a vi 0 ro -0 -0 Q! d O C w O w -0 c Lf ro Q/ al E a. O (U n E O ro N N a ro ro C � a-+ v . KU � o a, _0 u U1 Uw o ro N o0 0 Q i L W C- '� o 7 `- m � p o C1 O Q -Cp G ° o_ _ro C E u ro o 0° LA Q 0- ro E CU O -0 p 2 '� E w m ro o QV C o N p -D GJ 00 :IE N O vy O 0A c Qj L +-' C t ~ ado c .w C ro O � -0L C d L a00 C �, " N ° 0 6! ff-+ 7 D L cu 00 C�L V w O p �.+ y v` N 7 D bA + w.. O Z, C° u O cu E j oro CMG C fp c kn "- 0 -o o ro w- L w 0 C a� � aJ 3 a) �+ w L :1-+ C L ro C L ro N N Y X C ro a a; w w ,C c �- C D O Q)CL 0 > N _ ° E ° c a3 u /L C LJ ° �, Y Vi a` -0 O �. _0 oa C v C L ro Q1 -C ' ro on o W o -0 = '' cr M a 0 w y C L7 G Q1 _O o C � an u H W N QJ a W .+ -0 V ,C D A D N N G aj f9 u a! 'U D ro + p z ° a CL 0 Li m "Cf """ t..+ a+ � ro a) LL y L O y_ a) O a+ O ro N ro O L E -0 tlJ Q C1 ro y •C � aD C: Q, 00 '" G +K7 N G CU N E a, ; c L 'di Ir -0 C] V 0 ui w v .c w O v Qj "C7 v a W t Op C M a) r a) w C ro r u ro 0 U) v 7 Q 0) C a z 3 a a E ro M a a c 3 O N to Q N i N r Q a a ro ro E O u ai a r T N 0 O av op C ro W ro V a ro G r DA 0 ro 4- 0 C 0 a c a w uq ro c O d N v r r ro r Ln na E a� r LA r F- a1 ra ro u a) a c a� E u c w W O u W r a w C Q .V ar 0 a aLi C 0 M 0 W r r- c ate.+V c a u_ N ru v Q ro 0 c O u L- u C P4 a ro � O c Qj roVI 4 u a r w W w E c ro L o �, Q `) vs L h cu �! 0 C � GJ a L H ? in -0 an ro Q o- ro a° Q a! > a o. E w L c 3 N u N 'n ro E O w W -_a O o c 0 p u a1 � � a `~ O ai v +�' aJ CL 0- 0 -0 ate+ E = c, ro +' O > O C -0 C: -0 d C tip Ln w h ro n b v� Q T`C � u _ '•- '' Gl � % O C a YC5 C L " fl1 ro ,. O Z -0 � O CO -0° L a) E c O -0 r GO O a D ° ro p ro �, W w w C E L (U 'C d0 p0 a ,. ro w CD M a C. 4n rC '° -0 a Q v `^ C ro - w o ro _� C] ro CL Q l7 M C rwp w C aJ a, r9 �' t. ro w L w cu G �.+ ro ` v � 0 'C) c o v Q C' ro W r 00 -O VI d , on C N O �- C d .ro Q; .� a1 u w 4r E O L N E E o o ro d as w 0° CO L O d �' � �� r r Lm V -0 a+ ai u a W - w z7 G ro w Op C W y _ W — fp r �' ro d w O w v a1 u rt7 _C W O �- ro —_ a a 4 E �- w c a, E a O C u r J -0 c .� ro ro ° ° ro W6 O O Q o C r° Q v u ro _- Y Y �, a w _V a vti '° E Q C 0 u L d V r ,� C d "O -0 `0 -0 ro O C -O L' u @ � C_ U a ro "> -0 v w o >, w c w EZ. � Q C v g � L t]II al M +' O �" c Ga V 0 O 0 L (u L (V r o O _4, a, v a `° � C ro ti0 0 w °_' Q Vw1 '° C 0 ro > • °4,>, 'E QJro u d 7a w E C ro ro c ' > C7 aJ e y T 1] -0 0 a' C G L d rp Q- 4J -0 O w c p Ln CO ay r a) o a L al d v L v a O "d >, ro Q- 0 U pp d Li m-0 W Z p C �y a; > W c u _ ��', : U V- W -_ U 75 ro c 'L 3 �n v ro �_ v W �, in ro C O r V a ro ice,, _� � E O ro O v w O T 0 C w "� _� ` ro a3 iA in E a `+- d tap � -p N W � vCi d C N a O70 O _ro O � >d O d C a, d d +.. °; E C U Ln 0 a cr L d ) Y O w 0 N 1 -o ° LA `° � ,� a C w LJ p v L ° L = w o a `° 0 7V E to L ro E _ p N � �- ro > C E � ro C +� u Q � ` C ul O 0 u O v Q vCi C ro O a1 ac, °0 m 0 c Gb Q! C � C A ro v ° v d a 75 ro 4J O C ro E r L v cu a O r w �] �o ro � �r, �, M •� ro � � v m w N N C u ro V v ar O 4 O C p — C rcro Ln '0L L L jam_ R u 04, Q Cd r� a a tA 0 E C O Q a m m cu c a m c m U) a C O .{3C1 0 a� i W O a c a 0 c C L C� LA m O O a cu u w +'v 0 -D c a +° rp ,n c n a 0 cz a E v L a L .� Cl. U `° '� a n .n a c V p > m co — 'p C a LL m Li0 yr a O O L +� C a L ry n, aj v "p L ;_ '- E 0 O _ _ w '^ a u c c L L °cu �s ° 0 E o Q LA a °c° a o z%- o E °_' oo L v m� W r o N 0 cz a u Zs a m cr- c vs 1.1 E L u L V +--' L w O a -O �, a+ C c r6 C C O a1 m u m a (UU L m m 4-- ` > C C a Q E L ,Ln a O o x O V w C to CL '0 m m � V ai C ° s 4-0 O O u L O m a O C rn ° d i� ao c aJ -0L. W O O �+ 3 V vai 0 W 0 ate, -o E Cm a o IV VI m c oAM aa, r^ L cn w vs o E >, 41 0 m w «c m vt m c •D a ] C O L a _0 m a v< W > m O vi tA 0- a u v v >, tw vi a o m aco 0 v0i E-o °, �- -°o m ai U ro CU a Q o v 10 E C L m L ¢ O Q -Ci O c O L c m a �, `� C n a ra L n o CL 4. _a Vi t Ln yr E 0 m 0- c c "' a O EL a. 0 -a � d C E C)?, 'a.+ Zi ?+ m W m O O �O a c CL �. ¢ E a u c 0 c m a m 2:, a y c 0 v v a 0" c v E ?; a a c a c L m a crla CL ro V C t O VOi O vi ai � c a � a e Qj cu vi a C a a a x eq a t a w a m X_ cc qj c aCrm m vS u as L LA m -c to -a c N W a ra E C m 4' 77 a E E L a C: O a vi 0 0 (U C C w c 0 V C L ° a' o cn E c cu Z 0 V m +1 m L ° to m E C a Y +^ ro° L ° ru LA a ° �. rO 3 m C 7 ° sn vi Ln L L L " 0 c m Q -0 au 00 E v} a a O a (Ua..r 3 w C m 3 j L a vi b4 C O Ln 0 V CD ao -a m 0 O C O al c L ;o E M p c O (U O w- Q a C] E O a c ° � a +-' "O c m V o O -0 al Ors- o ►- C m C O a c a E v O cr a �, Q E C 0+- .L W %A s o ° } 0 .� as ° -0O L L L 3 m u, a W �o E C: w m a O Q CL Q m O a ° b0 ° L o ao n o L to c O m .- a C 0 C fl 3 ra to a m c O p (U a m vai '� m ru u Ln Lu C '° a, tv E a0 ° v Fn(U VI c 0 L 0 q u O a *' L a 0 L c . C N ° m 0 O aQj u a N a`� -o O C m aCD a N MCL pp V m O n a N O vi W ;a L C cu W L 1'� c V) m Q E ;a � >, C. > C ry o o a ° O in LA 0 a L cu w a 4-1 C C a m �n .E m L 0 c 0 LA a a m to C a N N 0 o ° a1 0_ a u C: aJ � L r 7 3 m � a c 3 a0 v'i O � �C3 E ay vi -C m a - W ° La "' v v ro L E a a O r � W m C L L m � a 0 c C: m ao m V m v-. C ro yr a Ln Ln w O L V c vi .d a O CL 0 C c0 C s� c a L C a N a O_ 0 h0 0 L c r a ut O u c a a v a O m a M a a u D CL 00 C .E ro nm Y a C O v C C C 0 C: m y1 E E u C O V a 0 uti O C 0 O O_ a C m yr a 0 O L O V) a� a W O 0 Ln tlef a U X a 0 d C a c m 1] a .ia m L •c a CL M v a rl u � � W � � v' �i �` w O `� ` a v a C ►L- `�° o o x Ln _a a a a C t' C '' ` d O ro O in V) c C: a a o O a°°/ E C j y' C a O d a -0 L.. - �CO .nC aG, O 1a j U v O ? C o in -0 LAN m Q) C a E 70 a) vi m .LJ r aLn Q a L rtS E yr w Do U C + O 71 � '� C L L' O� 0 Q M O �D C bL0 Ou 0 O �- O M0 Ln a .� o m o `0 o rw bo o TQ 3 w 0 a aJ L 'Z C 0 +- of b0 V aa+ O ro 1] -0CL m C a y E w `t ro axi m 'n O c E Q 7 m y a Ln 5 O a D_ a ac LA u �, v o o c a c � s " c Z ro `an E Q O iJ m C i] a 7, " bU L vi D L a m c o o Q aai ao a L 4v bo O a -0 u O x -O D �' O a a •— C C CD a T a m i L L - a C a a to O_ C a a u. -O vt C: a A '� r0 — L u5 O c a `' y a aD, c v w to C y > ° c o u O a m L — a a v1 L } vi a a L Q t m .. a C a ut a S7 V1 v 13 L L a L C C v m , ?. C LL +� a 2, N -- in D C a L iS m Ln O C O m a O v c m io O t!] a! C O a0 a ra L O n L 0 c 7 O O m N LAL > a 2] g O a C aj u CL ° c -a r. .o 0 0 tA CL CL T 3 a v ro 0 Gi uGJ C - ro O CL a I.L O O ,� �, ro r° a a " L a�i m c D 0 a o o eo C tV!` O i N C O O a a ro a -O E E c y a m to a a c 3 E m E D o °c c m m m o A a o �- <o D_ u 'Z O ut w vai [] as fa a. Q 07 L O C ro .O C rG a L L E tw D v a C O u a t a .o C a O_ CL m C m aj a c O a Lei 107 v E a L_ ro v C E u ro a 00 ro to AC W 0 00 C C1 d ro 0 C a, nO ro bO C aJ .A 0 L C a N a CL ro Ln .C] 0 N Y V rC u ro tw a ro W- Ln C C 7 Ull as 0 L L v N T ro N a C a_ L O a r LO a E w O .c a v CL 0 C1 v L 0 w C r9 D L .0 c N 0 0 w CL x v c C_ v 0 N a L a ro Q`1 v L c rp �D V vi LL a, c O C 0 ro V v= 0 C v t C: O u v L c 0 00 C L N v O cr v 0 v C O v L _O ra L N 0 CL T ra Ln s N C c ro r a C O a tw C C Q1 C1 A ru a Q Ci ro a 4) a T 0 L Ln v a 0 C T r4 C ro a L a L vi C E w 0 a L O O v L v v N N Q! N 0 ro V 'O C m N V ro ate.+ ro N O 0 `a to C ro .c a _ro V a C v v L 0 c N ro m L 0O 0 -p ro m N 0 O 00 C ro in bo 0 .p a n a to '0 a 0 c Y -O L 0p 0 a O C 0 v r_ C m tr rD L 0 L a V v, u L O a E ro _ 3 00 O C o wtLAr+ O O v Y u ro v p a E _ v L a.+ +- V ro O L) t� c o m O o Ln tA v x v o Q/ _ mro C N W ro E O 411 N L w a c © > o L T c ro `' 3 2, a E O V 0 w L v � O v L V U _v' ro C E o w U O c t— L C a_ bb 0 QyVi 7 N v -CO O C 0 E ro O a -0 C O aJ �^ c O -C ,; c a O E O a N O a a 0 .— O0 -s a o N N a u 0 N �- E E -0 c 0 Q p a. rC N o v is n w a N L o v E a m o a o N c L O V) N N w O C 0 ._ ro .O �, C ro v 3 V 0 of �_ L C ro v N a ro E �, a Oro E QX L p Q i a C � 0 �- O a � IV � 0 .� �' v L 3 a c 3 0 a "a L c c Qj C M E L C an 0 _O N 0 a. w O T o v a �_ V o ?, LA LA .E 4- O C ra n > ra w` 0 v V C O v 0 C o N c 0 ro E c a0 o° o L L- v c O _�O a C O N — 0 -0 j a :p O N a aL+ O ,� C E C Q v -C 0 a � x L a C mW E v -CT0 c O -0C C O O CL _E C ra V 0 N � O O CL T ro E V av; L c c o C o a vl N 0 A E v cr a- w L E 0u O w O c O w w C M ro � O W C 3 O v }' a L u w C ro v CL v vi °' o N 0 Lac mL aJv " ra ni w km LL r... 0 LA c N E L cr Q1 L o fl L: