PSCC Minutes 10/01/2007 R
October 1, 2007
MINUTES OF THE COLLIER COUNTY PUBLIC SAFETY
COORDINA TING COUNCIL MEETING
Naples, Florida, October 1,2007
LET IT BE REMEMBERED, that the Collier County Public Safety
Coordinating Council, in and for the County of Collier, having conducted
business herein, met on this date at 2:00 P.M., at the Human Resources
Conference Room, Building B, 3301 East Tamiami Trail, in Naples, Florida,
with the following members present:
Members Present: Commissioner Fred Coyle
Chief Judge Keith Cary (Excused)
Judge Cynthia Ellis (Excused)
Stephen Russell
Rich Montecalvo
Robert R. Jacobs, II (Excused)
Mike Orlando
Judge Ramiro Mafialich
Sheriff Don Hunter (Excused)
Chief Greg Smith
James Wynn
Charles Rice
David Schimmel (Excused)
Bonnie Fredeen (Excused)
Christine Holmes
Others Present:
Jim Mudd, County Manager
Mike Sheffield, Assistant to County Manager
Scott Teach, Chief Assistant County Attorney
Chief Scott Salley, Sheriffs Office
Skip Camp, Facilities Management Director
Marcy Krumbine, Director, Housing & Human Services Dept.
Collier County
Public Safety Coordinating Council
October 1,2007,2:00 P.M.
Human Resources Conference Room, Building B
3301 E. Tamiami Trail, Naples, Florida
I. Introduction
A. Welcome
B. Introduction of new statutory member James Wynn
(State Probation Administrator)
C. Mark Lennon to be recognized as the desianee for State Probation
Administrator James Wynn
D. Judge Cynthia Ellis to be recognized as the desianee for Chief
Circuit Judge Keith Cary
E. Approval of June 18, 2007 PSCC Meeting minutes
F. Acceptance of June 18, 2007 Work-Restitution Release
Subcommittee meeting minutes
II. Old Business
A. Update on the Mental Health Court Concept
B. Inmate "snap-shot" Report-Chief Scott Salley
C. Update on plans for the circuit-wide Public Safety Coordinating
Council Symposium-Mike Sheffield
III. New Business
A. Discussion on the Criminal Justice. Mental Health and Substance
Abuse Reinvestment Grant-Marcy Krumbine and Christine Holmes
IV. Comments/Suggestions
V. Public Comment
VI. Adjourn
October 1, 2007
I. Introduction
A. Welcome - Commissioner Fred Coyle
Kathy Ray and George We1ch, Citizens, were also in attendance.
B. Introduction of new statutory member: JAMES WYNN, State Probation
Circuit Administrator
C. MARK LENNON was recognized as designee for State Probation Circuit
Administrator, James Wynn
D. JUDGE CYNTHIA ELLIS was recognized as designee for Chief Circuit
Judge Keith Cary
E. Approval of June 18,2007 Public Safety Coordinating Council meeting
Minutes:
Judge Ramiro Maiialich moved to approve the June 18, 2007 Meeting
Minutes. Second by Mr. Russell. Carried unanimously, 8-0.
F. Acceptance of June 18,2007 Work-Restitution Release Subcommittee
Meeting Minutes:
Christine Holmes moved to accept the June 18,2007 Work-Restitution
Release Subcommittee Meeting Minutes. Second by Judge Ramiro
Maiialich. Carried unanimously, 8-0.
II. Old Business
A. Update on the Mental Health Court Concept - Christine Holmes
Mike Sheffield stated a letter from Circuit Court Judge Daniel H. Monaco
dated August 18,2007 was attached (Item 2-A).
Christine Holmes stated the Mental Health Court Program began accepting
referrals on September 4,2007.
. Eligibility: Anyone who has been arrested for a non-violent
misdemeanor and is suspected of having mental health problems
. Referrals to: Katie Burrows at the David Lawrence Center (263-4250)
The Court hearings will commence on October 3,2007. The purpose is:
. To reduce jail time, recidivism, and convictions for the severely
and persistently mentally ill population arrested for non-violent
misdemeanors, and
. To provide appropriate alternatives within the legal system to meet the
needs of that specific population
2
October 1, 2007
This is a cooperative effort through the Court, the State Attorney's Office, the
Public Defender's Office, the Probation Department, and the David Lawrence
Center.
Commissioner Coyle noted Judge Monaco's letter stated, in part, "In order to
accomplish our goals for this program there is a necessity to have dedicated
staff from our Puhlic Defender's Office and State Attorney's Office. "
He asked Mr. Russell for comments regarding actions by his office to assist in
accomplishing this goal.
Stephen Russell stated his staff is evaluating the availability of current staff
members. He further stated Lee County has a dedicated Mental Health staff
member and that this position is funded by Lee County.
Mike Orlando stated the Public Defender's Office has met with the Mental
Health Court team. He stated Judge Monaco would like, ideally, to have an
individual from the State Attorney's Office and from the Public Defender's
Office to serve as coordinators for each office. He stated Mr. Jacobs has
requested to address the BCC to discuss this matter.
Commissioner Coyle asked about current funding sources.
Stephen Russell stated the State is not responsible for funding and money
would need to be found at the local level.
Jim Mudd stated there is a Chief Judges' Initiative Fund which he would
investigate to determine whether funds are available to use for this mental
health position.
B. Inmate "Snap-Shot" Report - Chief Scott Salley
Chief Salley provided a report of the jail data:
. Habitat is increasing which necessitates adding new beds in the near future
. Transported three mentally ill inmates to mental health facilities
. Arrests of gang members has declined
. Immigration & Customs Enforcement ("ICE") had 27 holds in June,
35 in July, and 32 in August, and 69 in September
(Copies of these figures will be suhmitted for the record hy Chief Sally.)
. The next quarterly update will detail the number of inmates who have
been detained for a year or longer
. Figures for the percentage of self admitted illegal category were not
available since April through June was the transition period with ICE
. There are 4 inmates awaiting trial on murder charges
3
October 1, 2007
C. Update: Circuit-wide Public Safety Coordinating Council Symposium
Mike Sheffield stated the Symposium would be held on December 3, 2007 at
the Edison College Campus in For Myers from II :00 AM to 2:00 PM.
. Participation is anticipated from Lee, Charlotte, and Henry Counties
. He provided a copy of a memorandum from County Attorney David Weigel
to Commissioner Fred Coyle regarding out-of-County meetings (Item 2-C)
- Mr. Weigel mentioned a "balancing of interests test"
Commissioner Coyle suggested the possibility of providing transportation for
Collier County residents to the Symposium site in order to comply with the
"Sunshine Law" requirements.
Scott Teach stated he would review Commissioner Coyle's suggestion with the
County Attorney's Office as a mitigating factor to deflect concerns regarding
the Sunshine Law.
III. New Business
A. Discussion: Criminal Justice, Mental Health and Substance Abuse
Reinvestment Grant - Marcy Krumbine and Christine Holmes
A copy of the grant application package was provided (Item 3-A).
Marcy Krumbine stated she was notified approximately two months earlier
that the State made some money available for use in the area of mental health.
A formal grant application process is required. There are two different grants
available: (I) Planning Grant for $100,000 which has to be matched by each
County, and (2) an Implementation Grant of $1 Million which would be distributed
at $333,333 a year for three years.
Before applying for a grant, the Committee should:
. Approve serving as planning council/committee for the grant;
. Agree to add several new members (8) to the Committee;
. Agree on the agency to be responsible for staff members or to hire a consulting
firm.
The Substance Abuse Mental Health Corporation has recommended all counties
apply for a Planning Grant, which is not a recurring grant. The purpose of the
Planning Grant is to allow a county to develop a strategic plan which would, in turn,
allow a county to qualify for an Implementation Grant.
Ms. Krumbine stated this is the first year that these grants are being offered, and it
is hoped that the Implementation Grant will be a recurring grant.
Commissioner Coyle stated there was no guarantee the Implementation Grant
would be continued beyond the initial three-year period. He stated his concern
about the lack of budget analysis. He stated the BCC would need to review and
4
October 1, 2007
approve the application. He was also concerned about the short turnaround time to
apply for this grant.
Stephen Russell stated he thought this was a County budget issue.
Scott Teach asked for an opportunity to review the By-Laws concerning the
addition of members to the Committee.
Commissioner Coyle asked if the Committee could make a determination with
such little information.
Scott Teach replied that he would not suggest it.
Christine Holmes stated the deadline to apply is November I, 2007.
Commissioner Coyle recommended not applying for this grant until the next grant
period in order to obtain all required information and to be able to prepare a
presentation for the BCC. He requested the County Manager and the County
Attorney review the application process, together with the requirement for matching
funding, and to suggest alternatives for pursuing additional funding.
IV. Comments/Suggestions
Mike Sheffield stated he was in the process of setting the meetings for next year
and would inform all members via email of the dates at a later time.
V. Public Comment
None
The next meeting of the Collier County Public Safety Coordinating Council will be the
Public Safety Coordinating Council Symposium on December 3, 2007.
*****
There being no further business for the good of the County, the meeting was
adjourned by order of the Chair at 2:55 PM.
COLLIER COUNTY PUBLIC SAFETY
COORDINATING COUNCIL
Commissioner Fred Coyle
These Minutes approved by the Board/Committee on
as presented or as amended
5