Bayshore Gateway CRA Agenda 02/09/20233299 Tamiami Trail E, Unit 103, Naples, Florida 34112
Phone: 239-252-8844
www.bayshorecra.com
Bayshore Gateway Triangle Local Redevelopment Advisory Board
Collier County Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA) AGENDA
Hybrid Virtual Zoom Meeting
4870 Bayshore Dr, FGCU Buehler Auditorium Naples, FL 34112
February 9, 2023
6:00 PM
Chairwoman Karen Beatty
Maurice Gutierrez, Steve Main, Michael Sherman,
Al Schantzen, Camille Kielty, Steve Rigsbee, Kathi Kilburn, Sam Saad, Jr.
1. Call to order and Roll Call
2.Pledge of Allegiance
3.Approval of Agenda
4.Approval of Minutes -
a. January 17, 2023 (Attachment 1)
5.Community Agencies/ Business Presentations
a. Appreciation and Recognition Award Hurricane Ian Volunteers
b. 2400 Kirkwood –Drainage Easement Vacation Request – Joe Arciere (Attachment 2)
Action Item
c. Collier County Sheriff Department
i.Speeding – (Attachment 3- December 2019 Study Results)
ii.Speed limit posting -Transportation Operations
d.Advisory Boards in the Sunshine - Colleen Greene, Assistant County Attorney
(Attachment 4)
6.Reports:
a.Development Report- Laura DeJohn, Johnson Engineering (Attachment 5)
7. Old Business
a. Branding
i. Survey Update- Draft Survey (Attachment 6)
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 33 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
3299 Tamiami Trail E, Unit 103, Naples, Florida 34112
Phone: 239-252-8844
www.bayshorecra.com
ii. Survey Method – Discussion and Action Item
b. Redevelopment Plan – Quarterly Update (Attachment 7)
8.New Business
a.Goals/Priorities – 2023/2024 (Special Meeting Option) – Action Item
Topics to Cover (Attachment 8a)
i.Special Events- Tabled from 1/17 Meeting (Attachment 8b)
ii.Public Art
iii. Newsletter- Constant Contact
iv. Agenda Format
v.Staffing
vi.Other
b.Use of Ackerman- Del’s Corner Property
i.Use of Property Rates and Request Process - Action Item
ii.Special Event Request - Amanda Jaron (Attachment 9) – Action Item
c.Gateway Triangle – (Attachment 10a)
i.Update from February 7 Community Meeting
ii.Master Plan Process- Tabled from 1/17 Meeting – (Attachment 10b) Action Item
d.Del’s Visioning Update – February 25, 2023
e.Draft Annual report (Attachment delivered separately)
9.Staff Report
a.CRA program Manager Position
b.Priority Project Report – (Attachment 11)
c.Insurance Claims Report - (Attachment 12)
d.Financials – (Attachment 13)
10.Other Agencies -
a.Collier County Code Enforcement (Attachment 14)
11.Communication and Correspondence
a.What’s New in the Gateway Triangle Article (Attachment 15)
b.Holly Ave Neighborhood Gathering – February 11 @ 9:00 a.m. (Attachment 16)
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 34 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
3299 Tamiami Trail E, Unit 103, Naples, Florida 34112
Phone: 239-252-8844
www.bayshorecra.com
c.FRA Conference 2023 Oct. 24-27 (Attachment 17)
d.Naples Cinematheque Naples Daily News Article (Attachment 18)
12. Public Comment
13.Staff Comments
a.Public Art Donation – BCC Meeting - February 14
14.Advisory Board General Communication
15.Kathi Kilburn Map (Attachment 19)
16.Next Meeting
a.Wednesday, March 8, 2023 @ 5:30 p.m. Joint Meeting with Bayshore Beautification
MSTU
17.Adjournment
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 35 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
1
January 17, 2023 Meeting Minutes Attachment 1 - Item 4a
BAYSHORE/GATEWAY TRIANGLE LOCAL REDEVELOPMENT ADVISORY BOARD MINUTES
OF THE JANUARY 17, 2023 MEETING
The meeting of the Bayshore/Gateway Triangle Local Redevelopment Advisory Board was
called to order by Chairwoman, Karen Beatty at 6:00 p.m.
I.Roll Call: Advisory Board Members Present: Maurice Gutierrez, Al Schantzen,
Steve Rigsbee, Karen Beatty, Steve Main, Sam Saad, Jr. Kathi Kilburn, Mike
Sherman and Camille Kielty.
CRA Staff Present: Debrah Forester, CRA Director, Tami Scott, Project
Manager, Cristina Perez, Program Manager, and Shirley Garcia, Support Staff I.
II.Pledge of Allegiance: Led by Karen Beatty.
III.Adoption of Agenda: Maurice Gutierrez made a motion to accept the agenda as
written, Al Schantzen second. Approved unanimously.
IV.Election of Officers:
i.Chair- Maurice Gutierrez made a motion to nominate Karen
Beatty as Chair, second by Steve Main approved unanimously.
ii.Vice Chair- Karen Beatty made a motion to nominate Maurice
Gutierrez as Vice Chair second by Steve Main approved
unanimously.
V.Approval of Minutes:
a.December 06, 2022 – Al Schantzen made a motion to approve the minutes,
second by Maurice Gutierrez. Approved unanimously.
VI.Community / Business - Presentations
a.Collier County Sheriff’s Office– Corporal Allyn Tuff gave a brief overview
of the statistics in the area. There were 2 crashes, one fatal injury, 0 burglaries
and a couple of trespassing warnings to remove homeless off of vacant lots.
b.Letter of Interest for Dels Property-David Garonzik provided some
information on his intended purpose for the property by opening up a three-
screen theater venue for revival and repertory cinema, special events and post-
production services. The Venue will also have standard concessions and a full
bar. The Naples Cinematheque will tap into the nostalgia market that
showcases different vintage film title every night, celebrating each screening
as if it’s a new release without competing for first run new releases like the
multiplex theatres do. The purposed purchase will be 2.5 Million with 20%
deposit after acceptance of a binding purchase agreement and pay remaining
balance at closing.
Attachement 1
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 36 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
2
VII. Reports:
a. Development Report Update- Laura DeJohn, Johnson Engineering
provided current updates to the new and existing developments, if anyone
had any questions, she is available to answer.
VIII. Old Business:
a. Branding update -Chairwoman Beatty noted changes for limiting speakers on
this agenda item and future agenda speakers, to 3 minutes, as the room is only
reserved until 9pm. There were many speakers in attendance who supported
the arts district for Bayshore. Concerns were expressed about the use of an
acronym with the name, if the area is a true arts district or would a broader
name be appropriate. Mr. Rodriguez stated there is a process the County has
for designating a name to an area of Naples. The process requires a survey of
residents and businesses, performed by the County. Ultimately the Board of
County Commissioners gives the final approval, based on the results of the
professional survey. The Advisory Board discussed the option of supporting a
survey to determine what the majority of residents and business owners in the
Bayshore district think the area should be named for branding purposes. The
Advisory Board agreed to support a survey. Al Schantzen made a motion to
approve vacating last month’s vote and go through the process of creating a
survey, sending it to the advisory board for review, then to the Bayshore area
residents and business owners. Steve Main second the motion and the board
approved unanimously.
b. 17 Acres Pedestrian Connection Plan Update – Kevin Mangan, Stantec-
Mr. Mangan provided some conceptual plans with additional options that the
board could include such as trash cans, bike racks as well as benches if this is
something, they wanted to spend additional money on. The options provided
in the conceptual plan for the type of materials to use for constructing the
boardwalk is something they would need to think about for longevity,
maintenance, and construction cost. He will provide for cost each material type
after the CRA Staff presents to the BCC and obtain the thumbs up to proceed
with the boardwalk as presented. Steve Rigsbee recommended Plastic or
Concrete pilings, so it lasts longer and is less continual on maintenance costs,
Karen Beatty agrees with the type of material and will need to make
considerations to that.
c. Special Events Report-The Advisory Board tabled this item until the
February 9th meeting.
d. Holly Ave – Community Outreach Update – February 11th Flyer attached if
anyone wanted to attend.
e. Del’s Corner Visioning and & Public Engagement – The Advisory Board
tabled this item until the February 9th meeting.
Attachement 1
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 37 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
3
f. Gateway Triangle Master Plan Update – The Advisory Board tabled this
item until the February 9th meeting.
g. Preliminary Draft Annual Report- The Advisory Board tabled this item until
the February 9th meeting.
h. Revised 2023 Meeting Calendar – The consensus of the board agreed with
the revised version submitted.
IX. New Business:
a. Bus Shelter Gulf Gate Plaza – Ms. Scott provided a photo describing the type
of bus shelter Public Transportation Neighborhood Enhancement Division
recommended for the area near Gulf Gate Plaza with the price for the CRA
Board to approve, and after much discussion Sam Saad, Jr. asked why the
shelter was open on both sides because that would not protect the riders from
rain and if staff could find out if there was another option to enclose it to protect
from inclement weather. Ms. Scott would ask the division that question and
get back to them on that answer. Al Schantzen made a motion to pay for the
bus shelter, second by Steve Main, approved unanimously.
X. Staff Report:
a. Agenda Format- The Advisory Board tabled this item until the February 9th
meeting.
b. Priority Project Report – Ms. Forester noted the attachment if anyone had
any questions.
a. Insurance Claims Report: Ms. Forester provided the current insurance
claims report with the reimbursements to date.
b. Financial Report: Ms. Forester provided the current financials if anyone had
any questions.
XI. Other Agency’s:
a. Collier County Code Enforcement: Ms. Forester noted John Johnson from
Code Enforcement and the code report attached if anyone had any questions.
XII. Communications and Correspondence:
a. CRA Staff Salaries and Positions – This item was attached for the Boards
review if anyone had any questions.
b. IFS Master Gardening Program - Ms. Forester noted the attached if
anyone wanted to attend the programs
c. Adopt the Road Program - Ms. Forested noted that the adopt a road
program has been resumed and Road Maintenance will be in charge of
running the program
Attachement 1
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 38 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
4
d. FRA – 2022 Great Places in Florida People’s Choice Award, Marketing
Publication- Ms. Forester noted the attachment from the FRA highlighting
Bayshore’s Accomplishment.
e. Quality of Life – New Marketing Bulletin from Johnson Engineering- Ms.
Forester provided the marketing attachment from Johnson Engineering.
XIII. Public Comments:
XIII. Staff Comments:
XIV. Advisory Board General Communications:
XV. Next Meeting Date:
a. February 9, 2023 @ 6:00pm Botanical Garden FGCU Buehler Auditorium
XIV. Adjournment – The meeting adjourned at 9:15 p.m.
________________________________________
Chairwoman, Karen Beatty
Attachement 1
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 39 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
Richard Orth
Stormwater Project Manager
CRA Staff recommendation is for CRA Board to support the 6 ft wide drainage easement
vacation so the property owner can redevelop and improve his commercial properties while
increasing the value of his property and to further support the CRA Redevelopment Plan.
Attachment 2 - Item 5b
CRA Operation’s Memo 5b
February 9, 2023
TO: CRA-AB
SUBJECT: Drainage vacation request 2400 Kirkwood Avenue
Dear CRA-AB Members,
The proposed drainage easement is 3 feet wide totaling 6-foot-wide drainage easements and is an
old component of the previous drainage system for that plat. Since that platted time, the County
has filled in the pond, vacated the pond drainage easement and developed over the stormwater
water pond, and installed a completely new stormwater management system that in no way relies
on these two drainage easements. The drainage easements also fracture the two parcels from
property consolidation thus restricting its ability to be redeveloped under current design
standards and reduces its property values. With support of the CRA for vacations the public
benefit portion/component of the vacation process can be met by a letter of support by the
Bayshore CRA Local Advisory Board.
Attachment 2 - Page 1
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 40 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
1
ForesterDebrah
From:OrthRichard
Sent:Tuesday, January 31, 2023 2:17 PM
To:ForesterDebrah
Cc:RomanDaniel; GarciaShirley; JohnssenBeth
Subject:FW: Drainage easement at 2400 Kirkwood Ave
Attachments:Zoningverificationletter.pdf
Debrah,
This CRA property owner has requested a drainage easement(DE) vacation between two adjacent lots he owns. Each DE
is 3 feet wide totaling a 6-foot wide DE and is an old component of the previous drainage system for that plat. Since that
platted time, the County has filled in the pond, vacated the pond DE, developed over the stormwater water pond, and
installed a completely new stormwater management system that in no way relies on these two DEs. The DEs also
fracture the two parcels from property consolidation thus restricting its ability to be redeveloped under current design
standards and reduces its property values. With support of the CRA for vacations the public benefit portion/component
of the DE vacation process can be met by a letter of support by the Bayshore CRA. Please let me know if any additional
documents or information is needed.
Sincerely,
Rick Orth
From: JOSEPH ARCIERE <tacojoe1@comcast.net>
Sent: Tuesday, January 24, 2023 1:15 PM
To: OrthRichard <Richard.Orth@colliercountyfl.gov>
Subject: Drainage easement at 2400 Kirkwood Ave
EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when
opening attachments or clicking links.
Mr.Orth:
I am interested in vacating the no longer used drainage easement at my property, I would like to
discuss it with you. I have attached the Zoning Verification Letter and plat for you to review.
Please contact me by email or 239-825-7606 to discuss this.
Thank You,
Joe Arciere
Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a
public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing.
Attachment 2 - Page 2
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 41 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
Attachment 2 - Page 35.A.2Packet Pg. 42Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
Attachment 2 - Page 45.A.2Packet Pg. 43Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
Attachment 2 - Page 55.A.2Packet Pg. 44Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
Attachment 2 - Page 65.A.2Packet Pg. 45Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
Time of Study ~ 3 weeks Direction of Travel Summary volume for each day of the week for the Report Period. In this case 3 Fridays volumes in total as noted. Summary volume for the 17th, 24th and 31st of December ~ 17,053 /3 = 5,685 vehicles per day northbound only Attachment 3 - Item 5c.i5.A.2Packet Pg. 46Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
Government
in the Sunshine
Office of the County Attorney
Jeffrey A. Klatzkow, County Attorney
Attachment 4- Item 5d
Attachment 4 - Page 1
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 47 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
Sunshine Law
Protects the public from “closed door”
decision making and provides a right of
access to governmental meetings.
(F.S. 286.011 (“Sunshine Law”) and
Fl. Constitution Art. I, Sec. 24)
Attachment 4 - Page 2
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 48 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
Attachment 4 - Page 3
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 49 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
What is Florida's Government-in-the-
Sunshine Law?
Enacted in 1967
Found in Chapter 286, Florida Statutes
Establishes a basic right of access to
most meetings of boards, commissions
and other governing bodies of state and
local governmental agencies or
authorities
Attachment 4 - Page 4
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 50 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
The Sunshine Law gives the public access to
meetings of “any board or commission of any
state agency or authority or of any agency or
authority of any county,municipal corporation,
or political subdivision”AND
Allows the public to observe each preliminary
step leading to the final decision.
Prevents the Board from creating closed
committees that narrow the Board’s decisions.
Applies to Board appointed committees.
Attachment 4 - Page 5
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 51 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
The Three Basic Requirements of
the Sunshine Law,
286.011, Florida Statutes
Meetings of public boards, commissions or
committees (“boards”) must be open to
the public.
Reasonable notice of such meetings
must be given.
Minutes of the meeting must be
taken.
Attachment 4 - Page 6
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 52 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
I
Meetings of public boards,
commissions or committees
(“boards”) must be open to the public.
Attachment 4 - Page 7
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 53 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
Committee type determines
the applicability of these laws
There are two types of committees:
1.Decision Making Committees
2.Fact finding/Focus Group Committees
Attachment 4 - Page 8
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 54 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
Decision Making Committees become
part of the Board’s decision making
process AND
Choose alternatives and direction; narrow or
eliminate options for the Board’s consideration.
Make decisions by voting.
Make recommendation to the Board directly or
through staff.
Create bylaws.
Attachment 4 - Page 9
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 55 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
Fact Finding Groups provide a source
of community input and factual
resources AND
Have no characteristics of a Decision
making committee.
Do not need bylaws.
Provide individual input, data and factual
findings to staff,as part of staff’s
development in its advisement to the
Board.
Do not take votes.
Maintain a brainstorming focus.
Attachment 4 - Page 10
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 56 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
The Sunshine Law
applies when --
Two or more members of a governing
board (such as the BCC) discuss a
matter that may foreseeably come
before the governing board.
Attachment 4 - Page 11
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 57 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
E-Mails
E-mails of factual background information
from one board member to other board
members are permitted if there is no
exchange of board members’comments
or responses on subjects requiring board
action. The e-mails become a public
record.
Attachment 4 - Page 12
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 58 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
ADVISORY BOARD GUIDELINES FOR PUBLIC RECORDS AND
EMAILS
While you are serving on an advisory board, correspondence and
emails to or from anyone,on any computer (private or government
owned), relating to County business is a public record.
Public records must be maintained pursuant to State guidelines. You
may save them on the computer, a disk,or as a hard copy.If leaving
your position on an advisory board, please provide a copy of all public
records in your possession to the County Staff Liaison.
One-way communications by email should be directed to the County
Staff Liaison. Pursuant to the Sunshine Law,no two-way
communications between members (except during publicly noticed
meetings)is permitted.
If you choose to communicate with members of the public concerning
County business via email, please be aware that your name and email
address,as well as the name and email address of the public person,
becomes a public record.Attachment 4 - Page 13
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 59 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
Attachment 4 - Page 14
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 60 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
Written Correspondence
A board member may send documents on
matters coming before the board for official
action to other board members, PROVIDED
there are no responses from,or interaction
related to documents among, the board
members prior to the public meeting. The
written correspondence becomes a public
record.
Attachment 4 - Page 15
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 61 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
The Sunshine Law
does not apply when --
Committees or groups appointed to engage
only in fact-finding activities.
Board created focus groups or other such
committees that:
Only provide individual input, data and facts as
part of staff’s development in its advisement to
the Board.
Do not narrow options.
The Sunshine Law is broadly construed
Exemptions are narrowly construed
Attachment 4 - Page 16
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 62 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
Meetings Must be Open
to the Public
The public must be allowed to attend meetings;
however, there is no obligation to allow the
public to participate. The location:
Must be accessible
Sufficient size for turnout
Facility cannot discriminate based on age, race, etc.
Public access not unreasonably restricted
Be within Collier County with few exceptions
Attachment 4 - Page 17
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 63 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
II
Reasonable notice of such meetings
must be given.
The public must be given
reasonable and timely notice so
they can decide whether to attend.
What is “reasonable”or “timely”
depends on the circumstance.It
does not necessarily require a
newspaper advertisement; contact
the County Attorney Office for
guidance.
Attachment 4 - Page 18
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 64 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
Attachment 4 - Page 19
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 65 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
III
Minutes of the meeting are required.
Written minutes must be taken and made
available promptly.
Sound recordings may also be used, but only in
addition to written minutes.
Minutes may be a brief summary of meeting’s
events.
Minutes are public records.
Minutes must record the votes.
Attachment 4 - Page 20
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 66 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
Inspection Trips
Members of a public board or commission
may conduct inspection trips.
If discussion relating to the business of the
board will occur between board members
during an inspection trip,
SUNSHINE LAW APPLIES
All requirements of §286.011, F.S. must be
met.
Attachment 4 - Page 21
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 67 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
Electronic Meetings
Local Governments
Absent member may participate by
telephone conference if:
Absence is due to extraordinary
circumstances
A quorum of local board must be
physically present
Attachment 4 - Page 22
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 68 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
The Sunshine Law and Staff
When a staff member is appointed to a
board, the staff member loses his or her
identity as staff while working on the
board and the Sunshine law applies to the
board.
It is the nature of the act performed, not
the makeup of the board or the proximity
of the act to the final decision, which
determines whether a board composed of
staff is subject to the Sunshine Law.
Attachment 4 - Page 23
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 69 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
Sunshine Law Applications
Does not apply to members of different boards
Applies to non-voting members as well as voting members
Social events are fine –but do not discuss County business
Does not apply to private organizations, such as
homeowners’associations
Does not apply to a meeting between a Commissioner and
a private citizen
Does not apply to staff so long as staff is in a fact-finding
mode
Applies to staff once staff become part of the decision-
making process
Attachment 4 - Page 24
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 70 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
Validity of Action Taken in Violation of
The Sunshine Law/Subsequent
Corrective Action
Section 286.011, F.S., provides that no
resolution, rule, regulation or formal action shall
be considered binding except as taken or made
at an open meeting.
Recognizing that the Sunshine Law should be
construed so as to frustrate all evasive devices,
the courts have held that action taken in
violation of the law is void ab initio.
Within limitations, some case law exists holding
that Sunshine Law violations can be cured by
independent, final action taken completely in
the Sunshine.Attachment 4 - Page 25
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 71 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
What are the Consequences if a Public
Board or Commission Fails to Comply
with the Sunshine Law?
Criminal Penalties:
It is a second degree misdemeanor to knowingly violate
the Sunshine law.
Punishable with a fine of up to $500 and/or up to 60 days
imprisonment.
Other Penalties Include:
Removal from position.
Payment of attorney’s fees incurred by the challenging
party,as well as declaratory and injunctive relief.
Attachment 4 - Page 26
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 72 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
Sentenced to Jail for Sunshine Law Violations:Suspended
Escambia County Commissioner W.D. Childers was
sentenced to 60 days in jail for discussing redistricting in a
telephone conversation while fellow commissioner listened
on a speaker phone, and pleaded no contest for talking
with two fellow commissioners about county building
projects in front of a staffer.
A Penalty Example
Attachment 4 - Page 27
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 73 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
The Headlines We
Don’t Want!
“Judge Finds Marco Councilor Guilty of Sunshine Law
Violation!!” Naples Daily News 2/7/08
“Planning Member’s Lunch Clouds Florida in Sunshine
Law” Naples Daily News 2/7/07
Grand Jury OKs City Sunshine Law Investigation 7/12/07
Jacksonville News
“A Times-Union Investigation Finds Evidence of
Florida Sunshine Law Violations” Florida Times-Union 6/14/07
Attachment 4 - Page 28
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 74 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
Questions??
?????????
Attachment 4 - Page 29
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 75 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
Resources/Contacts
OFFICE OF THE COUNTY ATTORNEY
Jeffrey A. Klatzkow, County Attorney
Scott R. Teach, Deputy County Attorney
Colleen M. Greene, Assistant County Attorney
3301 East Tamiami Trail, 8th Floor
Naples, FL 34112
Phone: (239) 252-8400
Fax: (239) 252-6300
Attachment 4 - Page 30
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 76 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
Page 1 of 14
February 2023
Development Update
Please Note: Projects with *and highlight have been updated since the last report
Yellow highlight indicates old project with recent activity; Green highlight indicates new project
Zoning Petitions
2595 & 2631 Becca
Ave (ZLTR):
PL20230000846*
Location: 2595 & 2631
Becca Avenue Unit 1
Owner: Weston J. Bayes
& William J. Bayes
Status: Application
submitted on 1/12/2023.
Applicant wants to
confirm the permitted
uses, development
regulations, and how
many residential units
can be constructed on
the properties.
2201 Spruce Street (ZLTR): PL20230000200*
Location: 2201 Spruce Street
Owner: FLROY HOLDINGS, LLC
Status: Application submitted on 12/29/2022.
Request that the County specifically
verify: whether or not the subject
property located at 2201 Spruce
Street (Parcel No. 51690240009)
may be legally combined with the
adjacent parcel of land owned by our
client, 2364 Tamiami Trail E. (Parcel
No. 51690200007), for purposes of
developing all parcels of land into
one, contiguous, parcel, and used for
such purposes as are permitted
within the General Commercial (C-4)
zoning district and the Gateway
Triangle Mixed Use Overlay District
(GTMUD-MXD).
Attachment 5- Item 6a
Attachment 5
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 77 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9, 2023)
Page 2 of 14
3010 Tamiamai Trl E (MUP): PL20220006931*
Location: 3010 Tamiami Trail E.
Owner: D&D Retirement Trust, LLC
Status: Pre-app meeting held 11/22/2022.
First applicant submittal on 1/23/2023. First
Staff reviews will be complete 3/3/2023.
Application for a Mixed-Use Project (MUP).
The 0.6-acre parcel is zoned C-3-GTZO-
MXD and is in an Activity Center. The pre-
existing building (former Pizza Hut) will
house commercial business. Applicant
seeks to construct 8 live-work units with
working space at ground level and living
space on the second floor. Requires
allocation from the density bonus pool.
Davis Place Parking Exemption (PE): PL20220006085
Location: north side of Terrace Avenue west of
La Petite Court (Folio No. 61833400007 and
61833401103)
Owner: Central Pk Prop of Naples, Inc.
Status: Pre-app meeting held 10/26/2022. First
applicant submittal on 11/30/2022. Staff issued
incomplete submittal letter on 12/2/2022.
Additional documents submitted on 12/13/2022.
The project entails constructing 20 space offsite
parking area to accommodate the existing
“Davis Place” retail building (former Greyhound
station) located at 2669 Davis Blvd. The retail
building was built under PL20180002510. The
tenants have found they do not have enough
parking for their employees and customers in
the onsite parking lot.
Higher Ground Education (CU): PL20220006074
Location: NE corner of Bayshore Drive and Colonial Drive
Owner: Fortis I, LLC
Status: Pre-application meeting held on 10/5/2022.
(SDP- PL20220003954 Pre-application meeting was held on 6/28/2022.) Request for
conditional use on two parcels with residential zoning for day care use. The project will
serve as an expansion of the services provided by Higher Ground education on the
adjacent parcel; it will provide the care of toddlers to elementary level students. There
will be parking provided on site as well as recreational area for the students.
Attachment 5
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 78 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9, 2023)
Page 3 of 14
2360 Shadowlawn Dr (CU):
PL20220005927
Location: 2360 Shadowland Drive (corner of Lois St)
Owner: 2360 Shadowland LLC
Status: Pre-app meeting held 11/1/2022.
Property is zoned C-4-GTZO-MXD. Request for a
Minor Conditional Use change to be heard by the
hearing examiner to allow ZCCR, a Classic
Automobile Restoration company to relocate their
business to 2360 Shadowland Dr.
Justin’s Village Phase 2 (RZ):
PL20220003739
Location: 3163 Justins Way
Applicant: SMH PROPERTIES OF SWFL INC (St.
Matthews House)
Status: First staff review issued 10/20/2022. Second
applicant submittal on 10/25/2022. Neighborhood
Information Meeting held on 12/15/2022, Salvation
Army Church, 3170 Estey Avenue.
Request to rezone 2.33 acres from RMF-6 GTZO-R
to RMF-12 GTZO-R. 28 units are proposed.
Promenade at the Boat Yard Rezone: PL20210000020*
Location: 2736, 2754, and 2772 Bayview Drive
Status: NIM held May 11, 2021. Fourth applicant
submittal on 12/23/2021. Staff issued fifth
comment letter on 2/3/2022. County Planner
indicates this rezone has been abandoned. New
request is for PUD Rezone (see
PL20220006784 on following page).
The subject properties are currently zoned RSF-
4-BMUD-R4 and are proposed to be rezoned to
RSF-4-BMUD-NC (neighborhood commercial) to
construct a 3-story building with ground level
parking, second floor of retail, and third floor
residential along the south side of Bayview Drive.
Attachment 5
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 79 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9, 2023)
Page 4 of 14
The Promenade (PUDZ): PL20220006784
Location: 2836, 2800, 2772, 2754 Bayview Drive
Applicant/Owners: Gregory L Orick II REV Trust, 2754
Bayview LLC & Bayview Inn LLC
Status: Pre-app meeting held 11/9/2022.
Rezone five parcels (0.8 acres) from RMF-4-BZO-R4,
RMF-6-BZO-R2 to C-4-BZO-NC with companion MUP.
Naples Boat Yard Variance:
PL20200000007
Location: 2775 Bayview Drive
Status: Originally a PUD Rezone,
applicants have changed the request
to a Variance. NIM meeting held
May 11, 2021. Staff issued fourth
comment review letter on 2/3/2022.
Applicant requested six-month
extension, granted through 2/2/2023.
The applicant is proposing a
complete site renovation to construct
a boat storage facility along the
north side of Bayview Dr. This petition requests a variance from the 20-foot rear yard
waterfront setback to allow for a building to be 10 feet from the waterfront, and for a
small office on the NE corner of the site to be setback back 0 feet from the waterfront.
Viage Bayshore Marina (DR): PL20220000558*
Owner: Viage Marinas LLC
Status: Pre-application meeting held 2/7/2022. First
applicant submittal on 9/2/2022. Staff issued comment
letter on 10/10/2022. Second applicant submittal on
12/6/2022. Staff issued second comment letter on
1/9/2023. Applicant’s third submittal was on 2/1/2023.
(See also SDPI-PL20220004489 on page 8)
Request includes deviations to required screening of the
on-site boat racks (for dry boat storage), to permit the
existing chain link fence along the ROWs with additional
landscaping and/or slats, to permit a reduction in the
landscape buffer width along Bayshore Drive, and to
permit boat parking/storage within the Accessory Parking Zone area of the site.
Attachment 5
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 80 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9, 2023)
Page 5 of 14
Brookside Marina Rezone: PL20190001540*
Location: 2015 and 2025 Davis Blvd.
Owner: Naples Marina Holdings, LLC
Status: Applicant’s first submittal was 7/22/2020. Staff’s first review comments issued
8/24/2020. Applicant’s second submittal was 9/13/2021. Staff’s second review
comments issued 10/20/2021. NIM held on 1/6/2022. Second NIM held on 7/19/2022.
Applicant’s third submittal was 10/12/2022. Staff issued third review comments on
11/10/2022. Applicant’s fourth submittal was on 1/9/2023.
Rezone of the submerged lands only from RSF-4 to C-4. Notwithstanding the straight C-
4 zoning and to ensure GMP consistency, the permitted uses for the submerged lands
will be limited to water-related or water-dependent uses associated with a marina. Uses
include wet boat slips (with or without lifts/davits), boat lift canopies, boat ramps (one
ramp exists already), small recreational boat rentals, operation of charter or party fishing
boats, canoe/kayak/rowboat rentals, houseboat rentals, and tourist guide boat
operations. Jet ski rentals are excluded but requesting ability to rent a wet slip to a
private jet ski owner. Live-aboard vessels also excluded.
Attachment 5
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 81 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9, 2023)
Page 6 of 14
Development Review Petitions
Beyderman (VAC): PL20220005685*
Location: Parcel #50890840103 (at end of Holly
Ave, last lot on south side)
Owner: Irina & Yury Beyderman
Status: First incomplete submittal letter issued on
9/2/2022. First applicant submittal on 9/6/2022.
Second incomplete submittal letter issued on
9/15/2022. Additional materials submitted on
9/26/2022. Staff issued first comment letter on
10/14/2022. Second applicant submittal on
1/4/2023. Staff issued second comment letter on
1/30/2023.
Vacating an easement on parcel #50890840103.
Porsche Interim DC Charger Install (SDPI): PL20230000899*
Location: 3147 Davis Blvd.
Owner: TT of Tamiami, Inc.
Status: First applicant submittal on 1/19/2023. Additional materials submitted on
1/26/2023. Incomplete submittal letter issued on 1/31/2023.
Installing new electric vehicle (EV) chargers and supporting infrastructure at Porsche of
Naples.
Bayshore Mixed Use Development (SDP):
PL20220006723
Location: Parcel #’s 61841600006, 71580260001, &
71580250008 (at 2924 &2974 Bayshore Dr.)
Owner: Thomas Burgess GST Trust
Status: Pre-application meeting held on 11/22/2022.
A 3-story building is proposed on ±2.16 acres at 2924
& 2974 Bayshore Drive. The proposed building is
mixed-use with commercial and restaurant uses on
the first floor and a total of 30 condos are proposed on
the second and third floors, which will require a
companion request for density bonus pool allocation.
Vehicular access to the site will be provided from
Bayshore Drive via a shared access driveway with
2955 Bayshore Drive.
Attachment 5
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 82 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9, 2023)
Page 7 of 14
The Grove Bayshore (PPL): PL20210002029*
Location: Parcel 61841080008 (on Bayshore Dr. between Barrett Ave. & Van Buren
Ave.)
Owner: Gulfview Development, LLC
Status: Pre-application meeting held on 9/2/2021. First applicant submittal on 3/29/2022.
Additional documents submitted on 5/23/2022. Staff issued first comment letter on
6/17/2022. Applicant submitted response on 10/5/2022. Additional documents submitted
on 11/16 & 12/12/2022. Staff
issued second comment letter
on 1/11/2023.
10-acre Mixed Use
Development located along
Bayshore Drive. Single family
subdivision with two
commercial parcels fronting
Bayshore Drive. Application
type changed from SDP to
PPL. Previous Project Name:
GULFVIEW AND BAYSHORE
MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT
Ybor Mixed Use Development (SDP): PL20220007412
Location: Parcel 61841080008 (on Bayshore Dr.
between Barrett Ave. & Van Buren Ave.)
Owner: Naples Groves Lot 113, LLC
Status: Pre-application meeting held on
12/13/2022.
The property is 0.86-acres and will include a new
three (3) story building (7,540 S.F.), a parking lot,
and associated site improvements. The first floor
will include a covered outdoor dining area,
restaurant, two offices, and retail stores. The
second and third floors will be hotel rooms and the
roof (terrace) will include a pool and bar.
Attachment 5
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 83 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9, 2023)
Page 8 of 14
Autospace Naples (SDPA): PL20220006331
Location: 3045 Davis Blvd.
Owner: Davis Terrace Realty LLC
Status: First applicant submittal on
10/5/2022 with additional items on
10/12/2022. Staff issued first comment letter
11/9/2022.
Formerly known as Naples Classic Car. This
is a vintage car restoration business with two
existing buildings sitting on ±1.10 acres of
previously developed land at physical
address 3045 Davis Boulevard and 3084
Terrace Avenue in Naples, Florida. Only the
southern parcel was included in the original
SDP (PL20160001805). The Autospace
Naples development proposes the
construction of a new three-story building
with a footprint of ±13,748 sf. The new development will provide a total of 30 car
condominium units varying in size. The existing paint and bodyshop (light industrial)
building on the northeast will be replaced by a ±4,000 sf storage building. The existing
building on the southern parcel will be used for a combination of used auto sales,
warehouse, and office. The replacement ±4,000 sf building will be constructed right up
against the proposed three-story building, per the deviations approved under HEX No.
2022-23.
Shadowlawn Dr Multi-Fam Development (SDP): PL20220005562
Location: 1795 Shadowlawn Drive
Owner: East Naples Baptist Church Inc
Status: Pre-application meeting held on 9/13/2022.
Request for a multi-family development of 9 units at
1795 Shadowlawn Dr, currently occupied by parking lot
and a home. Project to include site improvements such
as utility connections, a stormwater system, a parking
lot, landscaping & site lighting. Per discussion at pre-
app meeting, this will require a companion petition for
allocation of 2 Limited Density Bonus Pool units.
3063 Connecticut Ave (LS): PL20220005465
Location: 3063 Connecticut Ave.
Owner: Robert David Shepherd
Status: Applicant submittal on 8/12/2022. Incomplete applicant submittal on 8/17/2022.
Staff issued comment letter 9/7/2022.
Applicant requests to split Parcel 61430480006 into 2 separate parcels.
(Note: PL20210002448 was the same request; it has been withdrawn.)
Attachment 5
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 84 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9, 2023)
Page 9 of 14
Compass Point South at Windstar A Condominium (SDPI):
PL20220004888
Location: 3554 Haldeman Creek Drive, Building 2
Owner: Compass Point South at Windstar A Condominium
Status: Applicant submittal on 7/18/2022. Incomplete submittal letters issued on
7/21/2022 and 8/19/2022. Additional materials submitted on 8/25/2022. Staff issued
comment letter 9/8/2022. Applicant’s second submittal on 11/10/2022. Staff issued
second comment letter 11/18/2022.
Remove ten trees within the condominiums. Three of the trees have roots, which are
interfering with buildings and water mains. The remaining trees have matured over the
years and are now blocking entire views of third floor residents, who purchased their
residences with views.
Viage Bayshore Marina (SDPI): PL20220004489
Location: 3470 Bayshore Drive
Owner: Viage Marinas, LLC
Status: Applicant first submittal on 6/23/2022. Staff comment letter issued on 7/15/2022.
Applicant second submittal on 8/8/2022. Staff issued second comment letter on
8/12/2022.
(see also Viage Bayshore Marina DR-PL20220000558 on page 4)
Applicant proposes to replace boat racks from 4-racks high to 2-racks high, and to
update fencing and buffering to screen the racks from adjacent properties. Note, there is
not an increase in the number of boats being stored on the marina property. All marina
operations will be contained within the C-4-BMUD-W zoned properties. Vehicular
parking only will occur within the residentially zoned lots.
The MED Restaurant of Bayshore (SIP):
PL20220003989
Location: 3929 Bayshore Drive
Owner: Antonio Miceli
Status: Pre-application meeting held on 6/29/2022.
Applicant first submittal on 9/16/2022. Incomplete
submittal letter issued on 9/21/2022. Applicant
submitted additional information on 11/21/2022.
Staff issued comment letter on 12/29/2022.
New owner requests outdoor improvements and
addition of up to 136 outdoor seats to the existing
restaurant.
Attachment 5
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 85 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9, 2023)
Page 10 of 14
KRB Naples (SDP): PL20220003647
Location: 3230 Tamiami Trail E. (at Peters
Ave.)
Owner: 3230 Tamiami LLC
Status: Pre-application meeting held on
6/16/2022. Incomplete applicant submittal on
11/4/2022. Applicant submitted additional
materials on 11/11 and 11/17/2022. Staff issued
comment letter on 12/9/2022.
Request for KRB (Kelley's Roast Beef) Naples
construction of 2 restaurants & applicable
parking.
17-acre Boardwalk CNST: PL20220001869
Location: 4315 Bayshore Drive
Owner: COLLIER CNTY BGT CRA
Status: Pre-application meeting held on 3/24/2022.
Request to build a boardwalk to connect the 17-acre
site to Sugden Park.
Mangrove Row (aka Arbutus Landing)
(LDBPA): PL20220004927
Location: 2766 Arbutus Street
Owner: Arbutus Landing LLC
Status: Pre-application meeting held on 8/3/2022.
Applicant is requesting Limited Density Bonus
Pool Allocation (2 units) for property located at
2766 Arbutus Street.
Attachment 5
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 86 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9, 2023)
Page 11 of 14
Approved Projects/Letters Issued
The 239 Bayshore & Areca Hotel/Restaurant (SDP): PL20210001360*
Location: 3467 Bayshore Drive
Owner/Applicant: Michael J. Whalen, 3467 Bayshore Drive, LLC
Status: Pre-application meeting held on 6/16/2021. First applicant submittal on
11/30/2021. Staff issued first comment letter on 12/30/2021. Second applicant submittal
on 7/8/2022. Staff issued second comment letter on 8/9/2022. Third applicant submittal
on 10/5/2022. Staff issued third comment letter on 11/14/2022. Fourth applicant
submittal on 12/19/2022. Staff issued fourth comment letter on 1/19/2023. Fifth applicant
submittal on 1/23/2023. SDP Approval letter issued on 1/31/2023.
The proposed vehicular access to the
site will be provided from Areca
Avenue. Alcohol Distance Waiver
required if sale of alcoholic beverage
for on-site consumption. New three
(3) story building (6,300 S.F.), a
parking lot, and associated site
improvements. The first floor will
include a covered outdoor dining
area, restaurant, two offices, and
retail stores. The second and third
floors will be hotel rooms (8 total) and
the roof (terrace) will include a pool
and bar. 22 parking spaces total
proposed.
3400 Canal St (ZLTR): PL20230000014*
Location: 3400 Canal Street
Owner: John F. Hughes
Status: Application submitted on
1/3/2023. Staff issued Zoning
Verification Letter on 1/25/2023.
Applicant seeks to tear down the
home on property located at 3400
Canal St AKA Sabal Shores Block
F Lots 28 & 29. Property ID/Folio
Number: 71800000462 comprising
of +/- 0.28 acres. The property is
zoned RMF-6-BZO-R1. The staff
verified that a single home may be
constructed on each platted lot.
Attachment 5
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 87 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9, 2023)
Page 12 of 14
Porsche Naples Expansion (SDPA): PL20220003796*
Location: 3147 Davis Blvd.
Owner: TT of Tamiami, Inc.
Status: Pre-application meeting held on 6/23/2022. First applicant submittal on
9/27/2022, additional material submitted on 10/17 and 10/24. Staff issued first comment
letter on 11/15/2022. Staff reviews complete/approved as of 12/27/2022; approval letter
pending. SDPA Approval letter issued on 1/9/2023.
Request for expansion for existing Porsche Naples dealership to add three new detail
bays located adjacent to existing bays. New bays will be partially under the parking
structure on-site as well as extending into the exist landscaping island and parking
located south of the structure. Displaced landscaping will be replaced at the new south
extent of the building. Existing ADS stormwater pipes under asphalt in the vicinity of the
proposed expansion will be removed and replaced elsewhere on site. Project will not
result in additional impervious area or loss of landscaping.
Metropolitan Naples Lot 2 (Aura at
Metropolitan Naples) - Luxury Condominium
(SDP): PL20210003215*
Location: 1936 Davis Blvd.
Owner/Applicant: Metropolitan Naples, LLC
Status: Pre-application meeting on 1/4/2022. Staff issued
comment letter on 3/3/2022. Applicant second submittal on
5/10/2022. Staff issued second comment letter on
6/2/2022. Applicant third submittal on 8/10/2022. Staff
issued third comment letter on 10/3/2022. Applicant
submitted FAA approval letter on 11/25/2022. Applicant
submitted Site Plan on 12/30/2022. SDP Approval letter
issued on 1/9/2023.
SDP for a 15-story structure with rooftop pool deck,
including 56 multi-family units and 6,500 sf retail/restaurant
on ground floor. Floors 2-4 are parking.
LaCoe Administative Variance (AVA): PL20220007186
Location: 3228 Lakeview Drive
Owner: Cindy Lou LaCoe
Status: First applicant submittal on 11/17/2022. Staff issued incomplete submittal letter
on 11/22/2022. Approval letter issued on 12/28/2022, with condition that an “After-the-
Fact” Building Permit will be applied for by the owner or applicant for the screen
enclosure.
Administrative Variance Application to allow an 8.8-foot rear yard setback (instead of 10
feet) for the accessory structure screen enclosure constructed in 1988.
Attachment 5
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 88 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9, 2023)
Page 13 of 14
60135010060 (ZLTR) – Hotel Build:
PL20220007725
Location: 2054 Davis Blvd. (Mini Triangle MPUD)
Owner: Naples Triangle Development JV-Propco,
LLC
Status: Application submitted on 12/1/2022. Staff
issued Zoning Verification Letter on 12/13/2022.
Request to verify zoning designation and allowable
uses within the Metropolitan Naples Plat.
Dunkin (SDPI): PL20220006665
Location: 3400 Tamiami Trail E.
Owner: G&C Shadows LLC
Status: First applicant submittal on 10/25/2022. Staff issued comment letter on
11/18/2022, and applicant entered second submittal on 11/18/2022. SDPI approval letter
issued 12/9/2022.
A building permit was issued for minor updates to the existing Dunkin Donuts without an
SDPI for the exterior building changes. No site changes were constructed other than
cleanup of the asphalt and refreshing the striping and signage.
61842000003 (ZLTR): PL20220006641
Location: 2650 Airport Road S. Suite# A (across from East Naples Methodist Church &
Government Complex)
Owner: Warwick Florida Properties Airport LLC / Arc Point Labs
Status: Application submitted on 10/24/2022. Staff issued Zoning Verification Letter on
11/7/2022.
Property is zoned C-3-GTZO-MXD. Applicant seeks to allow a lab that collects samples
for lab tests and to perform Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendments (CLIA)
waived lab tests. Per the GTZO, a “Laboratory – Medical, analytical, research” is a
permitted use in the GTZO-MXD.
Gulf Coast Realty Building (SDPI): PL20220006451
Location: 3010 Tamiami Trail East
Owner: D&D Retirement Trust LLC
Status: First applicant submittal on 10/12/2022. Staff issued first comment letter
10/27/2022. Second applicant submittal on 10/28/2022. SDPI approval letter issued
11/8/2022.
Insubstantial change to add a roofed entrance area to an existing structure.
Attachment 5
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 89 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9, 2023)
Page 14 of 14
Mini-Triangle MPUD (PUDA): PL20210001100
Location: 1991 and 1911 Tamiami Trail; 2000 and 2054 Davis Blvd.
Owner: Metropolitan Naples LLC
Status: Pre-application meeting held 6/9/2021. Second applicant submittal on 5/9/2022.
NIM held on 5/25/2022. CCPC held on
8/4/2022. BCC approved Planned Unit
Development Amendment on 9/27/2022.
Amend Mini Triangle Mixed Use Subdistrict
[companion item Mini-Triangle Small Scale
GMPA (PL-20210001101)] to allow for the
conversion of hotel units to multifamily
residential units (a sliding scale of a max of
377-491sf MF to 0-228sf hotel rooms) and to
amend the min./max. retail and office square
footage for a combined minimum of 40k and
max 130k, with a min of 15k reserved for office.
Applicant must also include 2 different commercial or office uses in the project and a
maximum of 130,000 SF of commercial/office/retail.
Mini-Triangle (Small Scale GMPA): PL20210001101
Location: 1991 and 1911 Tamiami Trail; 2000 and 2054 Davis Blvd.
Owner: Metropolitan Naples LLC
Status: Pre-application meeting held 6/9/2021. Second applicant submittal on 5/9/2022.
NIM held on 5/25/2022. CCPC held on 8/4/2022. BCC approved Growth Management
Plan Amendment on 9/27/2022.
Amend the Mini-Triangle MPUD-GTMUD-MXD (Ordinance 2018-025) and companion
item Mini-Triangle Mixed Use Subdistrict to allow for the conversion of hotel units to
multifamily residential units (sliding scale 1:2 ratio for max MF/Hotel uses) and to amend
the min./max. retail and office square footage for a combined minimum of 40k and max
130k, with a min of 15k reserved for office. Applicant must also include 2 different
commercial or office uses in the project and a maximum of 130,000 SF of
commercial/office/ retail. The change is to allow for 1 additional multifamily unit above
the 377 units (up to 491 total dwelling units) for every 2 hotel rooms removed from the
228-room maximum.
Naples Boat Yard Site Improvement Plan (SIP): PL20210000148
Location: 2775 Bayview Dr.
Status: First GMD Review Letter sent out on 11/1/2021. Applicant resubmittal on
7/1/2022. Staff comment letter issued 7/25/2022. Applicant’s fourth submittal on
8/24/2022. SIP Site Improvement Plan Approval issued 9/26/2022.
The Naples Boat Yard is proposing to renovate the concrete dock to accommodate their
traveling boat lift.
Attachment 5
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 90 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9, 2023)
Survey – Bayshore Area – Branding Public Input request:
In 2019, the Board of County Commissioners adopted an amendment to the Community Redevelopment
Area Plan for the Bayshore Gateway Triangle Community Redevelopment Area (CRA). The Plan includes
the following Vision Statement:
Promote quality of life and economic vitality with a mixed-income, urban, multi-modal community
that welcomes visitors, cultivates the area’s artistic and cultural identity, uplifts unique local
destinations, and finds balance with the natural environment.
One of the many identified projects in the plan is the development a Branding Strategy to further
implement the redevelopment vision.
In 2022, the first step in initiating the branding strategy was through an ad agency and included the
concept that Bayshore and the Gateway Triangle were two distinct communities that should have their
own brand. Based on input received from the Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Advisory Board the
following map was created to define the two areas.
This survey is focused on the Bayshore Area : Add Map
Your input is needed to assist with determining the name of the district. The results of this survey will be
presented to the Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Advisory Board for recommendation and then to the
Board of County Commissioners for review and consideration. After the Board of Commissioners makes
a final decision on the name, that is what will be used on all marketing and branding materials.
Survey:
Do you live or own property in the Bayshore Area: Yes No ( Add Map)
Please check the following boxes that apply to you:
Resident
Business Owner
Property Owner
Please rank in order of preference the name you want to be used for branding the community
Bayshore
Bayshore District
Bayshore Drive
Bayshore Arts District
Bayshore Arts and Cultural District
Bayshore Cultural District
Bayshore Garden District
The Bayshore Arts District
Other:________________________________
Attachment 6 - Item 7a.i
Attachment 6 - Page 1
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 91 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
Should an acronym be used to reference the district?
Yes
No
Which tagline do you prefer?
Creativity in Bloom
Where Creativity Blooms
Comments Received from Advisory Board members:
Karen: Shared comment from Siobhan Cleveland A broad survey will be a big help. I would also consider
using survey monkey and putting one online for people to access and put the instructions for finding in
the letter. I think you will get much better/faster responses to have it available online too.
Kathi: Regarding Acronym question - Maybe it should be drafted as
If an acronym was used for the name would it be offensive if it happen to end up with: BAD
My only thoughts.. Lets put this where it belongs, because it does have to do with BAD
Or… maybe best to show the acronym along with the name?
Bayshore B
Bayshore Drive BD
Bayshore Arts District BAD
Bayshore Arts & Cultural District BACD
Bayshore Garden District BGD
Bayshore Cultural District BCD
The Bayshore Arts District TBAD
Just my thoughts, I think whom ever this is going to needs to understand both apply.
Sam: Perhaps add another blank line under tagline for a write in.
Attachment 6 - Page 2
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 92 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
Project Name/Location Description First Quarter (October-December)Second Quarter (Januray-March)Third Quarter (April-June)Fourth Quarter (July-September)Tentative Completion Date Funding*
Beginning of the year project status Status update from prior quarter Status update from Status 2 End of FY23 project status
Linwood Complete Streets Phase I
Safe Routes to School - Linwood Way to
Airport. FDOT Grant funded and managed by
CPP/GMD
Design FY23 -$89,943 and Construction FY25-
$761,516. FY22 begin coordination with
Capital Improvements to design additional
complete street elements.
Safe Routes to School PE 2022/2023 and
Construction 2024/2025. Michael Tisch
Project Manager. On schedule. Negotiating
with KCA for design services.
Linwood Way to Commercial Opera Naples Streetlights installed. Funds
Budgeted in FY21 for design.
Project will be coordinated with Gateway
Triangle Master Plan $800,000
Thomasson Dr. and Hamilton Ave
Thomasson Drive completed June 2021. A
portion of the bike signage and markings to
be installed with Hamilton Project. Hamilton
Ave joint project with Parks & Rec
Completed and operational. Pending
signage installation from Parks and
Recreation. Coordinating Maintenance with
NBG and RM
Republic Drive - Complete Streets/Park
Connection
East Naples Community Park Master Plan
approved
Welcome Center opened. Tracking other
master plan improvements
General Complete Streets Allocation for funds to implement specific
projects $100,000
Danford St. Complete Streets
Parks and Recreation designing sidewalk part
of Hamilton Ave Project.
Transporation schedule to present updated
plans at April Beautification MSTU Advisory
Board meeting
General Parks Improvements- 17
Acres/Sugden Park
Master Plan and Boardwalk Connection.
Consultant selected through RFP Process
60% Design Plans presented to BCC in
December. Additional analysis
requested. January 21 Community
Meeting scheduled.
Central and Southern options for
boardwalk location and parking
reviewed and presented at January 17
Advisory Board meeting and January 21
meeting. Options and
recommendations to be presented to
BCC on February 28.$2,628,276
Future Direction
Options for the remaining site will be
discussed at a future date.
Options for the remaining site will be
discussed at a future date.
Acquisition Completed in November 2020 Exotic Removal Contract awarded to clear
RMF site. Scheduled to be completed in
second quarter.
Site Work/Maintenance Survey Completed. ROW/Easement
issue. Quick Claim Deed to BCC in
September to solve item.
Existing Building is not available for
public use. Water leak issue. Staff is
locating plumber to resolve.
$619,696
Del's Corner Dedication Recognition of Del Ackerman Hurricane Ian damage - fence. PO opened for fence replacement. Pending
installation.
Special Events Site Used for Hurricane Ian Distribution of
goods. Site to be used for Special Event -
Tree Lighting Ceremony on November 18
Request from public to rent space for
events received. Process and criteria being
developed for BCC consideration.
Capital
REDEVELOPMENT PLAN IMPLEMENTATION - SHORT TERM PROJECTS (1 to 5 YEARS)
FY 2023 QUARTERLY UPDATES -Febuary 3, 2023
Complete Streets Phase I
17 Acre Site
Del's Corner - Add after Plan Adoption
Page 1
Attachment 7- Item 7b 5.A.2
Packet Pg. 93 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
Project Name/Location Description First Quarter (October-December)Second Quarter (Januray-March)Third Quarter (April-June)Fourth Quarter (July-September)Tentative Completion Date Funding*
REDEVELOPMENT PLAN IMPLEMENTATION - SHORT TERM PROJECTS (1 to 5 YEARS)
FY 2023 QUARTERLY UPDATES -Febuary 3, 2023
Future Direction
BCC received unsolicited offer to purchase
the property December 12 2022
LOI presented to Advisory Board at
January 11 Advisory Board meeting.
Pending direction from BCC/CRA.
Highest and Best Use Study Stantec Consulting hired to conducted
community out reach and visioning
study on future uses.
Community Meeting scheduled for
Feburary 25
Sabal Shores Fire Suppression Phase 3 Completion July
2021
Streetlights installed
Holly Avenue Comprehensive Street Study in FY22 Community meeting scheduled for
February 11
Surface Parking Lot Construction completion August 2021 EV Charger pending contract agreement
with operator.
General Road Engineering Improvements
Pine Tree and Andrews
Discussion with Road Maintenance and
Stormwater regarding Limited
Maintenance Roads
Continue to discuss with RM.
Project Total $320,000
GatewayTriangle Master Plan Scope of Work drafted Selection of consultant for discussion at
February 9 Advisory Board Meeting
US41/Shadowlawn/Bayshore Access Management Plan scope of work
under review.
Access Management study continue
analysis with Transporation and County
Manager's Office. Opportunity to start
Phase 1 improvements- US41 to Bridge.
To be discussed at CRA/MSTU Advisory
Board joint meeting March 8, 2023.
$1,017,946
Street Sign/Wayfinding Improvements To be incorporated into North Bayshore
Enhancement Project.
Will be incorporated into roadway design
project.
Sidewalk/Bicycle Infrastructure Program Incorporated into North Bayshore
Beautification Project.
Stormwater and Transportation
coordinating installation of sidewalk on
Pine Street. Construction scheduled for
2024/2025.
Landscape and Hardscape Update Sabal Bay PUD expansion approved by
BCC in January 2021. Once SDP is
approved, proceed with expansion of
MSTU boundary.
Boundary expansion completed. Isle of
Collier/Stock Development new home
construction underway. New private
entrance from Bayshore under
construction
Stormwater Infrastructure Upgrades Two Project Areas identified - Becca,
Weeks, and Pine & Triangle Area
Becca, Weeks and Pine NTP Issued to Bolt Engineering Design
FY21/FY22
Change order approved. Design plans will
incorporate the new alignment. 60% plans
due in second quarter.
Gateway Triangle Area 4 Design FY22 - Scope of Work being
negotiated
Work Order approval NTP proceed issued
Gateway Triangle Stormwater Pond
Improvements
Stormwater improving Commercial Drive
and Alleyway
Pending further analysis with stormwater
to determine expansion needs to assist
with redevelopment efforts. Will be
Pending further analysis with stormwater
to determine expansion needs to assist
with redevelopment efforts. Will be
Neighborhood Initiative
Community Safety/Clean Up
Stormwater Infrastructure Upgrades
South Bayshore Renovation Project
Page 2
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 94 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
Project Name/Location Description First Quarter (October-December)Second Quarter (Januray-March)Third Quarter (April-June)Fourth Quarter (July-September)Tentative Completion Date Funding*
REDEVELOPMENT PLAN IMPLEMENTATION - SHORT TERM PROJECTS (1 to 5 YEARS)
FY 2023 QUARTERLY UPDATES -Febuary 3, 2023
Sanitary Sewer Line Upgrades in Triangle
Area
Mini Triangle Property sold November
2020
Grounding breaking for Metropolitian
Naples -Aura in December. Draingage
improvements completed
Phase 3
Phase 4 Didn't receive CDBG grant award. Will
reapply in FY22. Discuss options with the
City of Naples.
on hold until City of Naples provides
update on needs analysis
Future Phases
Ongoing Operations Budget Approved FY22 On-going operations
Land Development Code updates BCC approved direction to move forward
on several key items. Developing scope
of services for consultant services.
Completed and public information flyers
posted
Mini-Triangle Development- incentives
and support
Incentive Program Option to consider Established annual funding schedule to
fund Gateway Triangle TIF Rebate
Agreement
17 Acre Development - incentives and
support
Pending Master Plan Pending Direction from BCC
Gateway Property Development- potential
incentives for apex of Davis Blvd and US41
Incentive Program Option to consider On-need basis
Stormwater Master Plan Update $100,000 allocated in FY20 to match with
Capital Projects/Stormwater.
Stormwater Subcommittee meeting to
identify priorities
See Capital Projects
Arts and Culture Plan for CRA Public Art Pilot Plan - Approved by Board
July 13, 2021
Public Art Donation received. Process
established with Public Art Committee.
Aprpoved by Advisory Board and PAC
BCC consideration to accept donation
scheduled for Feburay 14
$200,000
Complete Streets Implementation Plan Access Management Plan for Bayshore
initiated in FY22
Principals to be incorporated into any
new projects when feasible
Bayview Parking Study Hamilton Ave Construction Plans pending
BCC approval on 09.28.21.
Hamilton Avenue parking opened and will
be monitored.
Community Safety and Clean Up Strategy-
code enforcement issues and safety
Sabal Shores - streetlights FY22 Holly Avenue meeting scheduled for
Febuary 11 to discuss needs. Gateway
Triangle Neighorhood meeting scheduled
for Feburary 7 to discuss needs.
$135,899
Branding Strategy On -hold pending Advisory Board
discussion. Survey option being reviewed.
Marketing and Communication Strategy -
to communicate outcome of branding
effort
Follows Branding Strategy Development Follows Branding Strategy
Development
$125,000
Market Study and Economic Profile FY22 To discuss during goals and priorites
meeting tentatively scheduled for second
quarter
Fire Suppression
Non-Capital
Page 3
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 95 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
Project Name/Location Description First Quarter (October-December)Second Quarter (Januray-March)Third Quarter (April-June)Fourth Quarter (July-September)Tentative Completion Date Funding*
REDEVELOPMENT PLAN IMPLEMENTATION - SHORT TERM PROJECTS (1 to 5 YEARS)
FY 2023 QUARTERLY UPDATES -Febuary 3, 2023
Bayshore Drive Pilot project - Complete
Streets
Part of North Bayshore Enhancement
Project. Outcome from both may lead to
Pilot project.
Part of Access Management Plan. Will be
incorporated into North Bayshore
Enhancement Project when feasible.
Water and Fire Update Strategy -
documentation of what mains and
hydrants will be updated and phasing
Fire Suppression Phase 3 completion July
2021. Coordination with the City of
Naples.
Continued coordination with the City of
Naples.
Triangle Retention Pond Feasibility Study-
passive park improvements
Most neighbors have voiced their
oppositon to the concept of passive part
improvments. Will be confirmed during
Gateway Triangle neighborhood master
plan deveopment.
Other General Multi-Modal Improvements
Other General Multi-Modal Improvements Bus Shelters Joint project with Transit and
Bayshore Beuatification MSTU to
install three shelters
CRA to fund one shelter on
Bayshore near Gulf Gate Plaza
$15,000
Other General Multi-Modal Improvements Circuit Rider Survey distributed Shuttle Service draft proposal with
Procurment. Confirm project during
goals/priorities meeting.
$135,000
CRA Parking Lot Electric Charger and other capital needs as
identified
$64,266
Residential Need review and update as necessary Coordinating with CHS on Roof program
grant.
$196,422
Commercial Need review and update as necessary On-hold until GT Master Plan completed.
Discuss at goals and priorites meeting.
$319,001
Wall and Fencing- for transitional
structures between incompatible uses
Currently not available. Currently not available. Discuss at goals
and priorities meeting.
Public Art Funding- art pieces and events FY22 Budget Grant criteria needs to be drafted and
approved by BCC. Funds are avaiable for
CRA funded projects.
Economic Development Incentives
Program
On-hold until GT Master Plan completed.
Discuss at goals and priorites meeting.
Gateway Triangle TIF Rebate Agreement Annual allocation begin in FY23 budget to
assure payment is available when due
$250,000
Bayshore Bicycle/Pedestrian Feasibility
Study
Access Management plan for Bayshore
Drive will provide concept plan for
Bayshore. Gateway Triangle Plan will
evaluate.
Mobile Home Replacement Fund - for
transition of mobile homes to modular
homes or other appropriate structures
Program opportunity for Holly Ave On-hold for further discussion with
Housing Department. Options to be
discussed at Holly Neighborhood Meeting.
Community Land Trust Housing
Construction
County selected HELP to create County-
wide CLT. Artist CLT may be an option
pending outcome of Cultural Arts
Strategic Plan
Discuss options during goals and piority
meeting. Need to bring in Housing
Department and CLT for future discussions.
Other Non-Capital Operations and Study expenditures-
Grants and Programs
Page 4
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 96 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
Project Name/Location Description First Quarter (October-December)Second Quarter (Januray-March)Third Quarter (April-June)Fourth Quarter (July-September)Tentative Completion Date Funding*
REDEVELOPMENT PLAN IMPLEMENTATION - SHORT TERM PROJECTS (1 to 5 YEARS)
FY 2023 QUARTERLY UPDATES -Febuary 3, 2023
Other Affordable Housing/Workforce
Housing Investments
Assisted with ROOF acquisition of lot
within Gateway Triangle
Discuss options during goals and piority
meeting. Need to bring in Housing
Department and CLT for future discussions.
$295,000
*Funding is based on Project Fund balances as of October 1 2022 or as allocated by PO
Page 5
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 97 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
CRA Operation’s Item 8a
February 9, 2023
TO: CRA-AB
SUBJECT: Goals/Priorities 2023/2024 Special Meeting Option
CRA Staff is recommending a Special Meeting to cover topics listed below:
i.Special Events (Attachment 8b)
ii.Public Art
iii. Newsletter – Constant Contact
iv.Agenda Format
v. Staffing
vi. Other
Staff would need a motion including the date, time and location.
1.Meeting Date: Monday-Thursday or a Saturday
2. Meeting Time: Day or Evening
3.Location: BCC Board Room or Botanical Garden FGCU Buehler Auditorium
Attachment 8a - Item 8a
Attachment 8a - Page1
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 98 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
EVENT END TIME
Food 300 Holiday Cookies $252
T-Shirts Walmart T-shirts for team $30
Wood Tree Supplies Home Depot Wood/supplies and paint $506
6:30 p.m.EVENT DATE & TIME
LIGHT-UP BAYSHORE 2022! 1ST Tree Lighting Celebration
EVENT TITLE
EVENT ORGANIZER
VENUE / LOCATION
Supplies
Publix
$12
Drinks
Venue Decorations $169
$99
Thank You Cards Amazon Thank You Cards
Disposable gloves: Kids and Adult Sizes - Amazon $28
COST
Amazon
Hobby Lobby
Paint Home Depot Paint: 3 shades for The Community Tree $92
Venue Light/Tents Taylor Rentals Tower light 4000 Watt Towable and 2-10x20 tents $1,411
Home Depot
$309
Event Restroom
Lulus
Banner Light-Up Bayshore! Tree Lighting Celebration 2022 Customized Banner 16'x5'
Balloons
TOTAL
Balloons $12
$3,202
ACTUAL EXPENSES
Light-Up Bayshore! 1st Tree Lighting Celebration
Kellie Cipperman
Del's Corner at "The Lawn"
November 18 at 5:00 p.m.
Bottled Water, Hot Cocoa, milk, marshmellows
One Porta-Potty $209
$73
Inflatable Tree
DESCRIPTION
Signs Now
Amazon
J.W. Craft Inc.
Inflatable Holiday Tree to position next to 5x16 Event Banner
ITEM
Decorations
Attachment 8b - Item 8a.i
Attachment 8b - Page 1
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 99 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
$2,286
DONATED MATERIALS
DJ/Photos/Drone/Video DJ, Drone to video event, photos and video editing $500
Propane Cooker/Tank for Hot Cocoa Cooker and propane tank for hot cocoa $85
Linens Table cloths, sheer for tents, chair covers, red and green sashes $615
$5,488
ITEM DESCRIPTION COST
Actual Expenses $3,202
Donated Materials $2,286
TOTAL EVENT COST
TOTAL EVENT COST
TOTAL
Walmart Lights to go around the banner and batteries
Balloon Décor Holiday balloon tree, Balloon Garland and Sheer Décor, Gold circle ring for photo op $275
Signage Custom Vinyl and Cardstock Lettering for signs and staff shirts $50
Amazon Wooden tree ornaments $56
Equipment High top tables and extra generator $160
ITEM DESCRIPTION COST
Supplies Dollar Tree
30 - Xmas Light-Up Bulb Necklaces for volunteers and children, Xmas headbands and glasses, flashing string
lights, Cookie napkins, holiday trays, flannel back tablecovers, round platters, chargers, paint pans, bowls,
cocoa cups, garland, coffee mugs and glue
$134
Hobby Lobby Decorations, craft supplies and Signage: Tropical leaves, festive ribbon, garland, floral, art, Letters to Santa
and Holiday cards to the Troops $315
$90
Homegoods Bags $6
Attachment 8b - Page 2
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 100 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
Cristina Perez
EMPLOYEE TOTAL HOURS WORKED
DESCRIPTION
TOTAL HOURS WORKED
Debrah Forester
NAME TOTAL HOURS
Tami Scott
12.0
171.5Kellie Cipperman
18.5
163.5
Shirley Garcia 11.0
376.5
Attachment 8b - Page 3
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 101 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
2023 PROPOSED BAYSHORE SPECIAL EVENTS
FEBRUARY – APRIL: BAYSHORE MARKET – HOLD UNTIL NEXT SEASON
APRIL OR MAY - BAYSHORE’S TAMALE AND TACO FESTIVAL and NOCHE EN BAYSHORE
•Bayshore’s Taco and Tamale Festival: Saturday, 4/29 OR 5/6/23 from 11 a.m. - 4 p.m.
at the “Lawn” at Del’s Corner or 17 Acres
o Tie-in with Arte Viva/Naples Botanical Garden
o We’re searching for the “BEST TAMALE ON BAYSHORE!”/Amateur Tamale Cook-
Off
▪Festival guest or judges panel will vote on the best tamale – winner gets
the TROPHY!
▪Tamale contestants will sell their tamales and tacos
▪Mexican Aguas Frescas and bottled water sponsored by the CRA
▪Entertainment - Mexican dancers/guitar players
▪Mexican culture-inspired kid activities - Break the Pinata
▪Bayshore Informational Booth with Bayshore Business
Information/Map/Coupons
NOVEMBER 2023 – APRIL 2024: BAYSHORE MARKET
•Launch in Fall on Fridays from 9 am – 1:30 pm at the “Lawn” at Del’s Corner
•More than 25+ vendors offering local fresh produce, organic foods, cold-pressed juices,
flowers, pastas, seafood, baked goods, prepared foods, honey, jams, fresh roasted
coffee, and pet treats. Jewelry and artisan boutique stands.
•Enjoy hand-made pastries, fresh brewed coffee and entertainment by local musicians
•
NOVEMBER: LIGHT-UP BAYSHORE! 2nd ANNUAL HOLIDAY TREE LIGHTING CELEBRATION AND
HOLIDAY BAZAAR
•One week before Botanical Gardens Johnsonville Night Lights in the Garden, Saturday,
November 18th (before Thanksgiving)
•Celebration from 5-6:30 p.m. at Del’s Corner
o Local arts/crafts for sale
o Festive activities for all ages
o Hot cocoa and cookies
o Visit from Santa before he leaves for the North Pole
o Bazaar selling unique holiday items
DECEMBER: LIGHT UP BAYSHORE HOLIDAY GOLF CART PARADE
Attachment 8b - Page 4
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 102 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
•Elaborately decked out holiday golf carts/electric bikes of all shapes and sizes strut
down Bayshore Drive to holiday music
2024 JANUARY OR APRIL: TASTE OF BAYSHORE or TASTE OF BAYSHORE LIFE!
•End of January or April at Del’s Corner or 17 Acres
•Fun, family-friendly community festival showcasing Bayshore’s local businesses,
restaurants and music
•Stage set-up for band performances
______________________________________________________________________________
EVENTS ORGANIZED BY OTHER SPONSORS
APRIL – BAY DAYS - Haldeman Creek Advisory Board - Recommended not participating this year.
SEPTEMBER OR OCTOBER: OPEN STREET ON BAYSHORE – Organized and Led by Blue Zones
Project by Sharecare (Megan Greer)
•Partner with Blue Zones Project – 17 Acres from 10 am – 3 pm on a Saturday or Sunday
•Bayshore Business Passport Program – Participating Bayshore businesses
discounts/specials
•Bike safety education (bike on the right side of the road, wear a helmet)
•Bike rodeo
•Fun & Games
YOGA AND FITNESS CLASSES
•Yoga Week – March 19 -26
o Partner with Unity/Blue Zones Project SWFL
•Yoga Classes or Goat Yoga
o Goat Yoga hosted by Lazy Day Farm Petting Zoo
•Take Action Fitness
o Reoccurring/Group fitness classes for 20-25 people for profit/possible rental fee
Attachment 8b - Page 5
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 103 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
BAYSHORE MARKET 2023 - PROPOSAL
DESCRIPTION
The Bayshore Outdoor Market is an eclectic, open-air market with “Old Florida” charm that offers many
food items, unique, artisan goods and locally made products.
Enjoy fresh brewed coffee and home-made pastries while a local musician keeps market goers
entertained with styles from rock and pop to jazz, island and blues. Attendees can bring their friendly,
leashed dogs, too!
Weekly, every Friday, mid-February through April. Walk, bike or drive. Limited, free parking is available
behind the market.
LOCATION
The “Lawn” at Del’s Corner - 4825 Bayshore Drive, Naples, FL 34112
DATE/TIME
Year 2023: Mid-February – April (10 weeks) on Fridays from 9 am – 1:30 pm
*Avalon Elementary School starts at 8:00 a.m. and ends at 2:55 p.m.
VENDOR FEES
We carefully evaluate all Market vendor applicants, choosing first from the Bayshore Triangle and
Naples Area vendors
Farmer’s Markets in the area are charging $140 - $200/month
Bayshore Market Proposed Inaugural Vendor Fees for 10x10 Space:
•Introductory 10-Week Season
o Bayshore Resident/Vendor: $325
o Non-Bayshore Resident/Vendor: $350
•Introductory 4-Week Monthly Rate - If monthly spaces are offered based on availability (Season
vendors receive priority)
o Vendor $150 per space
FRIDAYS 9 AM – 1:30 PM
Item 8.c.iii Page 1Attachment 8b - Page 6
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 104 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
BAYSHORE MARKET 2023 - PROPOSAL
Payment processing would be potentially through the program used by Parks & Recs, Activenet –
Compensation for use of their system and Parks and Recreation staff time would be required. Parks and
Recreation Staff advised that seeking out a vendor to handle the event would be a better option.
Request for quotes to manage the market would be advertised and we would select the highest bidder.
ESTIMATED COSTS/REVENUE
START-UP COSTS - ITEMS NEEDED COST
16’ x 5’ Farmer’s Market Banner $350
24 x 36” Easel Sign $130
10X20 Bayshore Customized Tent $500
2 Round white plastic tables $200
8 white plastic chairs $200
2 9 ft. outdoor umbrellas $150
2 outdoor umbrella stands $90
1 rectangular table for tent $50
2 chairs for tent $50
Tablecloth for tent $10
Dog waste station sign/holder/bags $170
Market Bags – 75 $140
ONE TIME START-UP EXPENSE TOTAL $2,040
Porta Potty Rental Per Week $250/wk x 10 weeks $2,500
Temporary Employee – Assist with set-up/parking/clean-up (8 hours x $18 x 10
wks)
$1,440
Replenish Market Bags/materials $250
TOTAL REOCCURING EXPENSES FOR THE MARKET SEASON – 10 WEEKS $4,190
Estimated Vendor Fees Collected: 25 Vendors @ $325 x 10 weeks=$8,125 $8,125
Minus one time start-up expense total -$2,040
Minus reoccurring expenses -$4,190
REVENUE – CARRY OVER TO NEXT EVENT $1,895
SIZE/LAYOUT OF THE “LAWN” AT DEL’S CORNER
Lot Size 192’ x 100’ (grassy area)
10x10 Vendor Tents: 25 minimum – 41 maximum
1 – 10 x 20 Tent: Bayshore Triangle/Local Non-Profit Organization/Bayshore Businesses Information in
the middle of the lawn with two tables/chairs/umbrellas on each side for patrons
Minimal parking available behind the lawn and proposed overflow parking at Naples Botanical Garden
or Haitian Church
NEXT SEASON 2023/2024
Evaluate what worked/what didn’t/market competition/etc.
Proposed Timing: Mid-November 2023 – April 2024 on Fridays from 9 am – 1:30 pm (22 weeks)
Attachment 8b - Page 7
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 105 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
BAYSHORE MARKET 2023 - PROPOSAL
BACKGROUND
MARKET COMPETITION
8 Farmer’s Markets in the Naples Area
PROPOSED CATEGORY/VENDORS
CATEGORY BUSINESS CONTACT DESCRIPTION
1 Coffee, Breakfast
Pastries
Bean To Cup
Coffee Shop
Melody
Teague
239-316-
7819
Bayshore Business – Serve hot/cold coffee
and breakfast pastries
2 Fruits & Veggies Farmer
Mike’s/Organic
Farmers
239-498-
4576
Family-owned farm selling locally grown,
seasonal vegetables and fruits. *Oakes
Farms or Market 360 or Food For Thought
Organic Farm
3 Seafood Mike’s Bait
House
239-775-
2248
Bayshore Business – Smoked fish and fish
dip. Smoked jerky and ribs. *Still closed ask
Oakes Farms or Market 360
4 Guacamole, Chips &
Salsa
Molcajetes or
Taqueria San
Julian
239-234-
5027 or
239-775-
6480
Bayshore Business -
5 Cookies Lulu’s 239-774-
5858
Bayshore Triangle Business -
6 Cakes/Bars/Pies Peace of Cake
Kitchen
Katy 239-
984-6666
Bayshore Business -
7 Bread Epiphany
Bakery –
Gluten Free or
Naples Bread
and Pastries
Bayshore Triangle Business – Bistro La
Baguette on US 41
8 Cheese Stamper
Cheese
Oakes Farms or Market 360
9 Nuts Scott’s Nuts A variety of nuts
Marco Island Farmers Market Dec-May Wednesday 7:30 am-1 pm
St. Paul’s Farmers Market Mid Nov – Mid April Saturday 8 am-Noon
Third Street South Farmers Market Year Round Saturday 7:30 am-11:30 am
Vanderbilt Farmers Market Year Round Saturday 8 am-1 pm
Golden Gate Community Market Year Round Saturday 9 am-2 pm
Golden Gate Farmers Market Year Round Sunday 9 am-2 pm
Pine Ridge Road Farmers Market Mid Nov – Mid April Sunday 9 am-1 pm
Sudgen Park Plaza Farmers Market Dec-April Sunday 9 am-2 pm
Attachment 8b - Page 8
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 106 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
BAYSHORE MARKET 2023 - PROPOSAL
10 Popcorn Naples Best
Popcorn
Sharon
239-571-
3761
Bayshore Business – Tropical saltwater
taffy, flavors include key lime, banana,
mango and tangerine
11 Honey The Sensible
Bee
Ashley
Giannone
239-821-
2743
Bayshore Business – Ashley grew up in
Bayshore! Local honey. Carries an array of
sustainable beeswax skincare products
ranging from CBD infused-oil candles to
mineral-based sunscreen.
12 Fresh Pressed Juices Juicelation Organic, cold-pressed juice company,
working with local organic farmers
13 Coffee and Pastries Bean To Cup Melody
Teague
239-316-
7819
Will provide fresh hot and iced – coffee and
pastries
14 Gelato Birdie’s Gelato 716-866-
4137
Mobile gelato cart locally owned and
operated in Naples
15 Dog Biscuits Wholesome
Hound
239-228-
5282
Wholesome Hound Natural Pet Market
www.wholesomehound.com *at Third St.
Market
16 Acai Bowl The Bowl Prepared-to-order Acai bowls, using
organic, vegan ingredients
17 Art Things I like by
Catherine
Catherine Bayshore Business – 239-778-4665
18 Kayaks, Paddleboard
Adventures
Naples
Outfitters
Bayshore Business-
19 Tumblers/Bamboo
Boxes
Cole Bekko Cole 612-
422-9244
Bayshore Business – Eco
20 Fresh Cut
Flowers/Orchids/Plants
Beautiful
Bubbles by
Mel
Mel 239-
298-6477
Bayshore Business – Custom Gift
Balloon/Floral Bouquets for all Occasions
OR Green Door Nursery
21 Jewelry Amanda
Jaron?
22 Handmade Clothing Boho Palace Yesim Bayshore Business – Turkish/boho clothing
Yesim 239-603-9802
23 Handmade Coffee
Mugs
Handmade
Mugs
Amanda
Tessarsik
Bayshore Business – Amanda Tessarsik 518-
929-5194
24 Beeswax Candles The Candle
Beeswax Lady
Bayshore Business – 617-697-4226
25 Soaps & Lotions The Sensible
Bee
Ashley
Giannone
Bayshore Business - Creams and Soaps 239-
821-2743. Ashley grew up on Bayshore!
Bayshore Business Info
Tent/Bayshore
Featured Non-Profit
Coupons, Farmers Market Bags, Information
Musician Local Bayshore Musician
Attachment 8b - Page 9
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 107 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
THE BAYSHORE ART DISTRICT SIGNATURE EVENT
1sa
TSDISTRIC
KER'S MARKET
ARTisan -BAYSHORE"S Maker"s Market
SHOP THE BAYSHORE ARTS DISTRICT's HIGHLY CURATED MAKER'S MARKET
Event Name : '"ARTisan"' Bayshore's Handmade Maker's Market
Contact Name/Event Director
Board Member;
THE GLITTER FOUNDATION. INC.
Owner, Photography By Lane
Date of Event - z In order of greatest Interest
1 at Choice. Once a Month
second Saturday of Each Month
IN SEASON: OCT. NOV. DEC.
JAN. FEB. MAR, APRIL
2nd Choice: Any other Saturday ol the month
Time Needed to Set-Up and Clean-Up
2 HOURS TO SET UP
1 HOUR TO BREAKDOWN
Contact Information
tan9 wlw QL.ae!!l£&2!!!
(239) 82:2-6704
3784 Bayshore Or
Naples. FL 34112
Description of Event
Farmly & Pet•Frtendly EvM'l1
OUTDOOR "Farmer's Market" CONCEPT UNLIKE
ANY OTHER MARKET IN COLLIER COUNTY
SHOP BAYSHORE'S HIGHLY CURATED
ARTisan MAKER'S MARKET
GOODS SUCH AS;
JEWELRY. HANDBAGS. CERAMICS,
GLASSWARE. SOAPS, UPCYCLEO FURNITURE.
SUCCULENTS. CANDLES FOOD & MORE!
ENJOY LIVE MUSIC FROM ONE FEATURED
MUSICIAN -DIFFERENT EACH MONTH
SHOP ONE BOOTH FOR ONE FEATURED
EmergiSTUDENT ARTls.an
THE BOOTH WILL BE AT NO COST
TO THE STUDENT
STOP INTO THE BAYSHORE SHOPS, GALLERIES
& RESTAURANTS
1 5% of all proceeds wil benefit.
The GLITTER Foundation. Inc.
Supporting Art Education & Art Therapy Programs for
Children In SWFL
Anticipated Attendance
ISLES OF COLLIER
ARBORETUM
WINOSTAR
PATRONS TO BOTANICAL GARDENS
MEMBERS: HAMILTON HARBOR
BAYSHORE RESIDENTS
Fans. Friends & Family of Alllsts
Entity Sponsoring the Event
The GLITTE R Foundation. Inc. 501 (c)3
WWW.THfGI ITTFRFQIJNQATIQN QRG
Actual Time of Event
10AM-2PM
Fr-Parlung
Anticipated Car-County
WOULD ENCOURAGE WALKING. BIKING & GOLF
CARTS TO ATTEND.
COULD SHUTTLE VENDOR CARS FROM
A JARON STUDIO TO ALLOW FOR MORE PATRON
PARKING.
FROM 10-2 WOULD HOPE TO SEE 100 CARS
IN AND OUT THOUGHOUI THE DAY.
TYPICALLY. PEOPLE SPENO ABOUT 30 MINUTES
AT EVENTS LIKE THIS
Attachment 9- Item 8b.ii
Attachment 9 - Page 1
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 108 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
ARTisan -BAVSHORE"S Maker"s Market
SHOP THE BAVSHORE ARTS DISTRICT's HIGHLY CURATED MAKER'S MARKET
With over 25 small businesses, you are sure to go home with arms full of one-of-a-kind finds.
We'll have vintage vendors, artists, jewelers, bakers, and so much more.
You can only expect the best curation when visiting ARTisan!
FROM MERCHANT'S HANDCRAFTED GOODS SUCH AS;
JEWELRY, HANDBAGS, CERAMICS, GLASSWARE, SOAPS, SUCCULENTS, CANDLES & MORE!
ENJOY LIVE MUSIC & STOP INTO THE BAYSHORE SHOPS, GALLERIES & RESTAURANTS
SECOND SATURDAY OF EACH MONTH
10:00 AM -2:00 PM
Amanda Jaron & Miss Pearl Bug
FOUNDER: Bayshore ARTisan Mar-ker's Market
OWNER: A Jaron Fine Jewelry
FOUNDERr: The GLITTER Foundation. Inc.
Lane Wilkinson
Bayshor-e ARTisan Marker's Market
Event Director & Curator: Lane Wilkinson
BOARD MEMBER:
The GLITTER Foundation, Inc.
OWNER: Photography By Lane
EDUCATION: Fashion lnshtue of Technology -New York City
BAVSHORE ARTisan Makers
Market
Venue: Del's Corner
Hosted Monthly: Second Saturday
Feature
•Jewelry
•Upcycle Jewelry
•Vintage Jewelry
•Sterling Jewelry
•Textile Art
Wall Art-Paintings, Photography,
Sculpture
Textiles
•Knits
Body Products •Embroidery
•Soap •Loom
•Lotion
Food
•Canned/Packaged Food
•Candy Kids & Pet Products
•Veggie Stand
•Food Vendors •Plushies
•Learning and/or Toy
•Puzzles / Games
•Dog Pet Products
Attachment 9 - Page 2
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 109 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
The GLITTER Foundation, Inc. 501 (C) 3 www.theglitterfoundation.org Founded 2014
Attachment 9 - Page 3
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 110 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
CRA Operation’s Item 8c
February 9, 2023
TO: CRA-AB
SUBJECT: Gateway Triangle Master Plan Process
CRA staff is recommending a motion to approve one of the 3 options and to
proceed with the Gateway Triangle Master Plan scope of services to bring back for
review and approval.
Option 1 – Direct Select a design professional to put together a scope of services
Option 2 – Request for Proposals from design professionals to choose a scope of
services for a neighborhood master plan for the Gateway Triangle
Option 3 – Choose a design professional based on the next rotation from the list of
contracted design professionals, note; if this option is chosen staff will not know
who will be next in the rotation until staff in procurement division advises.
Attachment 10a - Item 8c5.A.2
Packet Pg. 111 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
Background and the processes for using our Professional Services Library contracts.
Rotation and Direct Selection Processes
The County currently has continuing contracts procured for architectural, engineering and
surveying/mapping services, whereby multiple firms were qualified for categories of work under our
Professional Services Library. Firms were formally solicited for such services and evaluated based on
criteria such as ability of professional personnel, past performance (including references from client for
previous projects), location of the firm, and recent, current and projected workloads of the firm.
Professional Services Library Rotation
Overall process from start to approval can take 7-10 days
•Under Professional Services Agreements, the firms were placed on a rotational list for
professional services in each category
•The division creates the scope of work and completes the required documentation and sends to
Procurement Services for processing
•The rotation assignment process usually happens within the same business day
•Work assignments within each service category are awarded on a rotational basis by the
Procurement Division.
•For each service category, the Procurement Service Division will place qualifying firms in the
Professional Services Library in the order they are ranked, with the highest scoring firm placed in
the first position in the rotation
•As each work assignment is identified the next firm in the rotation will be offered the
opportunity to negotiate that work assignment with the COUNTY’s Contract Administrative
Agent/Project Manager (There is no opportunity for the PM to decline negotiating with the firm
next inline for through the rotation process.)
•Should a firm decline a work assignment, the COUNTY will contact the next firm on the list until
the work assignment is successfully negotiated
•Once a full rotation through all firms in a service category is complete, a method that attempts
to impart an equitable distribution of work among selected firms will be based on prior dollars
awarded; with the firm having received the least amount of dollars being considered for the
next work assignment.
Professional Services Library – Direct Selection.
Overall process from start to approval can take 2-3 weeks
•Work assignments requiring unique experience or knowledge in the subject matter or area,
including past experience on another phase of the project, the County’s Contract Administrative
Agent/Project Manager may formally request permission to forego the rotation process and
select a specific firm.
•Firms that are directly selected for a work assignment as a result of this process shall be passed
on their next scheduled turn in the rotation.
•Application is completed and sent to Procurement Services for processing. The direct select may
take several days to process.
•Once firm is selected, the Division will then negotiate a proposal for the scope and fees and
enter into a Work Order with the firm.
•Once the Division has a fully approved Work Order, a purchase requisition can be created, and a
purchase order is issued once approved.
Attachment 10b - Item 8c.ii
Attachment 10b - Page 1
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 112 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
Steps and general timeline for a Request for Professional Services
Overall process from start to approval can take from 9-12 months.
•Solicitation Worksheet is completed and signed by the Project Manager and Division Director,
and submitted to Procurement Services, along with a Scope of Services.
•Solicitation is assigned to a Procurement Strategist within 24 business hours.
•Solicitation package is drafted and sent to the Project Manager/Division for review generally
within 5 business days.
•Once the Division has reviewed and approved the draft documents, the Procurement Director
will appoint a Selection Committee to review and evaluate the proposals. This generally takes 2-
3 business days.
•Note: The Authorization to Advertise will then route to OMB if the project is grant-funded, this
could take several weeks to review and will continue the process until approved
Once the ATA routes back to Procurement, the Procurement Strategist and Director will sign the
ATA and the Strategist will then post to our bidding platform which should happen within 1
business day of receiving the ATA.
•The solicitation must be advertised for a minimum of 30 days, and extended at least 2-3 weeks if
the County does not receive at minimum 3 proposals by the proposal due date.
•The Procurement Strategist must review the proposals received, which is generally completed
within 3 business days.
•After review of the proposals, the Procurement Strategist will schedule an Organizational
meeting with Selection Committee to discuss the procedure for evaluation and set the next date
for the publicly noticed Selection Committee Meeting which generally occurs within 7-10
business days after review of the proposals.
•After the Meeting, the Selection Committee members are given time to review and score each
proposal and prepare comments for discussion at the next meeting. The Selection Committee
Meeting generally occurs 2-3 weeks after the Organizational Meeting.
•At the publicly noticed Selection Committee Meeting, the members will present their
independent findings / conclusions / comments based on their reading and interpretation of the
materials presented. The committee will decide which firms are invited to give an oral
presentation, minimum of three (3) firms.
•If presentations are required, the firms will be invited back to present generally 2 weeks after
the Selection Committee Meeting has concluded.
•A Notice of Recommended Award is prepared Strategist within 1-2 business days. After Project
Manager has approved, it’s route back to Procurement for their approval and posted to bidding
platform within 24 business hours. Staff then must allow for a 3-day protest period.
•Staff will take item to the Board for approval of the Selection Committee’s ranking and for
permission to commence negotiations with the top ranked firm. This generally can take 6-8
weeks depending on each Division’s agenda workflow, additional reviews, Advisory Board
recommendations, etc.
•Once Board approved, the Procurement Strategist will schedule an initial negotiation meeting
with the top ranked firm, generally within 5 business days of the Board approval date.
•The Procurement Strategist will facilitate all scheduling of subsequent negotiations meetings
and correspondence until staff and the firm have reached an agreement for services.
Negotiations is obviously dependent on many factors, and therefore we cannot establish a
definitive timeline to this part of the process. For planning purposes, it is safe to assume that
negotiations will take at least 2-3 months or more to complete.
•Once negotiations have concluded, the Procurement contracts team will develop a Professional
Services Agreement. The draft agreement generally takes 1-2 weeks. Once draft is approved,
the contracts team will route to the County Attorney’s Office (CAO) for review and approval.
This takes 2-3 business days.
Attachment 10b - Page 2
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 113 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
•Approved contract is sent to the firm for signature, to be returned by the firm along with their
Certificate of Insurance for the project. This can take 2-3 weeks or more depending on how
quickly the firm is able to respond with the documentation. Certificate of Insurance must be
approved by Risk Management, the documents are returned to Project Manager so item can be
brought before the Board to award the Request for Professional Services and execution of the
Professional Services Agreement. Again, this can take 6-8 weeks depending on the Division’s
agenda workflow, additional reviews, Advisory Board recommendations, etc.
•Once Board approved, the contract generally takes 2-3 weeks to be routed for all signatures,
recorded with Board Minutes and Records, and returned to Procurement. Division can then
submit their purchase requisition for a Purchase Order to be issued, and then a Notice to
Proceed can be sent to the firm for commencement of work.
Attachment 10b - Page 3
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 114 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
Attachment 10b - Page 4
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 115 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
Attachment 10b - Page 5
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 116 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
Gateway Triangle Master Plan
The Collier County Community Redevelopment Agency (Agency) is seeking proposals from a qualified
consultant for planning support services for the CRA staff’s effort to prepare a Gateway Triangle Master
Plan. The Gateway Triangle area is generally defined as the area along and between the corridors of US
41, Davis Boulevard, and Airport Road within the CRA. The focus on this area for master planning purposes
is to identify goals, objectives, and priorities outlined in the 2019 Bayshore Gateway Triangle (BGT)
Redevelopment Plan.
SCOPE OF SERVICES
TASK 1 – PAST PLANS REVIEW & GOAL VALIDATION
Consultant will review the BGT Redevelopment Plan as adopted in 2019 to identify the key policies that
will impact the redevelopment of the Gateway Triangle area. Consultant will also review current and
programed capital projects for the area and previous plans/studies as directed and provided by the CRA
staff. Consultant will summarize key policies and outcomes from past efforts to evaluate with the
community through public involvement (Task 5 below) to identify and confirm issues/themes that are still
relevant and any new issues/themes.
Consultant will participate in a kickoff meeting with CRA staff to identify and verify project team, roles,
stakeholders, data sources, and timeline.
Using outcomes of the validation of issues through public involvement (Task 5 below), CONSULTANT will
summarize findings impacting the Gateway Triangle Master Plan in a Summary Memo including
recommendations for goals, land planning concepts, and improvement initiatives.
TASK 2 – BASELINE INVENTORY & FUTURE CONDITIONS ANALYSIS
Consultant will gather available data from public sources and from CRA staff to prepare baseline mapping
in GIS format including:
•Land Use Maps.
(a)Open space
(b)Street layout
(c)Non-residential uses
(d)The approximate number of dwelling units and homestead status
(e)Property as is intended for use as public parks, recreation areas, streets, public utilities, and
public improvements of any nature.
•Sidewalks (existing). Consultant will coordinate with CRA staff and the community to identify and
generate mapping of potential future sidewalk projects. These maps may be broken down by
neighborhood or sections of the Gateway Triangle area.
•Neighborhood Map(s). Mapping will be provided to identify neighborhoods and determine their
limits within the Gateway Triangle area, to be confirmed with the public through the process
outlined in Task 5 below. Multiple residential neighborhoods may be identified based on
community input. These maps will display capital projects based on information provided by CRA
staff.
A Design Consultant will coordinate with CRA staff to identify locations and develop concept
improvements at key locations, entrance features, or corridors within the Gateway Triangle area to
Attachment 10b - Page 6
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 117 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
further implement the goals and strategies to implement the master plan. Development potential for up
to three (3) locations will be shown in illustrative sketches, diagrams, plan view or perspective drawings.
Consultant will develop a Linwood Avenue/Commercial Drive Streetscape improvement concept plan that
will show typical placement of sidewalk, landscaping, lighting, and branding opportunities on Linwood
Avenue and Commercial Drive based on community input and identify potential constraints. The
Streetscape concept will be preliminary for discussion and visioning; this scope does not include traffic
analysis, engineering design or drainage strategies. This project is included in the BGTCRA Capital Project
list.
Consultant will identify any land development regulatory or comprehensive plan amendments necessary
to implement the Gateway Triangle Master Plan.
Consultant will coordinate with CRA staff to identify programs that will be referenced as
recommendations to further implement the master plan such as resiliency strategies, housing and
commercial improvement programs.
TASK 3 – FUTURE OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS
Consultant will assist with review of the BGT Redevelopment Plan priorities in the Gateway Triangle,
current CIP and listing of proposed Short Term CIP projects (1-5 year timeframe) and Long Term CIP
projects (beyond 5 years); identifying those that focus on the Gateway Triangle area. CONSULTANT will
review Section 5.4 of the redevelopment plan and refining planned Future Opportunities and
Improvement Priorities based on CRA staff and public input; develop a revised list of CRA projects,
initiatives, and capital projects. Opportunities are expected to be privately owned property where future
projects (i.e., industrial arts zone, pedestrian node, or vista terminating feature) are envisioned.
Improvement Priorities are expected to be CRA or other publicly funded improvements (i.e., complete
street project, public art, or decorative lighting). Consultant will provide rough order of magnitude costs
for anticipated public projects. CONSULTANT will provide map exhibit(s) showing the locations of Future
Opportunities both of the private sector and public investment Capital Improvement Priorities.
TASK 4 – GATEWAY TRIANGLE MASTER PLAN
The Gateway Triangle Master Plan is envisioned to be a 10-20 page document outlining the planning
process and community involvement; findings; recommendations; Opportunities and Improvement
Priorities summary identifying specific goals and projects as referenced in the neighborhood outreach of
Task 5, map and diagrams; and action plan. Consultant will provide professional planning assistance:
•Draft content and review with CRA staff
•Meetings with CRA staff
•Summary of Consistency with BGT Redevelopment Plan and County’s Comprehensive Plan
•Summary of the review of current Project priorities and Capital Projects as provided by CRA
staff and determined during the planning process, identifying any needed changes to the
redevelopment plan and other constraints that may be identified.
•Neighborhood Opportunities – each neighborhood as identified in Task 2 will be identified on
the neighborhood Maps.
•Map of the potential project location and rough estimate of costs for public sector projects
•Map of private sector opportunities
Attachment 10b - Page 7
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 118 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
The Design Consultant will prepare diagrams to address redevelopment Opportunities and Improvement
Priorities (up to six).
Maps will be provided in .pdf printable format at 8.5 x 11; 11x 17 and 24 x 36 format.
All documents will be provided in native file format (Word or Excel).
TASK 5 – PUBLIC INVOLVEMENT
Consultant and Design Consultant will prepare presentation materials for display and comment and
attend and present at up to eight (8) community meetings as directed by the CRA staff. This scope
assumes CRA staff will arrange venues and advertising for the meetings, and CONSULTANT will attend,
present and deliver summaries to document the meetings.
•Online survey: This scope assumes CRA staff will lead the preparation of an online survey of
questions and images meant to facilitate public comment on proposed goals and policies.
Consultant will assist by reviewing proposed questions and providing example images as
requested by CRA staff. CRA will provide the survey in English, Spanish and Creole.
•Up to eight (8) community meetings are assumed:
#1 - Community Kickoff meeting. At this meeting, Consultant and Design Consultant will facilitate
validation of issues/themes for the Gateway Triangle Area.
#2,3,4 - Stakeholder Group charrettes. This scope assumes up to three (3) stakeholder group
meetings to convene community members associated with different areas (i.e. groups to
be determined, such as heavy commercial area group, Shadowlawn area group, and
commercial corridors, etc.). These meetings will be charrette-style meetings with DESIGN
Consultant assisting with graphic representation of the areas and redevelopment
concepts.
#5 - One workshop with the CRA Advisory Board to review and discuss before the final drafting
of the Gateway Triangle Master Plan.
#6,7 - Consultant will provide support to CRA staff to hold up to two bi-lingual (Spanish & English)
community meetings to review Preliminary Draft Master Plan.
#8 - Presentation of final Draft Master Plan to CRA Advisory Board for recommendation to bring
forward to the Agency Board for adoption.
Note: This scope assumes the County’s online survey tool will be used to seek public input via appropriate
languages. This scope assumes meetings will be held in a physical location, and they may be hybrid
meetings with both a physical location and virtual attendance capability. If virtual attendance capability
is desired, this will be accomplished using County resources, such as Zoom conferencing.
Consultant will provide summary memos to document all the meetings.
TASK 6 – ADOPTION HEARING
One set of revisions from the Preliminary Draft to Final Draft is included in scope. Any revisions necessary
between presentation of final to Advisory Board and Agency Approval is assumed to be minor text changes
and/or graphic edits. If significant revisions are required, such as drafting of new language or creation of
new exhibits or graphics, additional scope and fee will be negotiated.
Consultant will assist with presentation at one (1) Agency meeting, and final minor text edits and/or minor
graphic edits as necessary following Agency review. If additional hearing presentations are required, or if
additional revisions are required to the Master Plan, additional scope and fee will be negotiated.
Attachment 10b - Page 8
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 119 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
LOCATION MAP OF GATEWAY TRIANGE
The Gateway Triangle area is generally defined as the area along and between the corridors of US 41,
Davis Boulevard, and Airport Road within the CRA.
Attachment 10b - Page 9
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 120 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
1Exceeding Expectations, Every Day!
Bayshore Gateway
Triangle
CRA Division
Priority Projects Update
District 4
February 3, 2023
Attachment 11- Item 9b
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 121 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
2Exceeding Expectations, Every Day!
TABLE OF CONTENTS
District 4-Priority Projects
Project Slide #
17 acres Pedestrian Connection to Sugden Regional Park 3
Access Management Plan 4
Bayshore Stormwater Phase I 5
Gateway Triangle Stormwater Phase I 6
Gateway Triangle Neighborhood Initiative 7
Del’s Corner 8
Hamilton Avenue Beautification Project 9
Bayshore MSTU Short Term Maintenance 10
Holly Avenue Assessment 11
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 122 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
3Exceeding Expectations, Every Day!
District #: 4
Project #: 50208
Funding Source: CRA
Project Manager: Tami Scott
Director:Debrah Forester, Director CRA
Project Scope: Design & permit pedestrian connection from
Bayshore Drive to Sugden Regional Park. Tasks include:
Task 1 -Development of Conceptual Plan/Site Development
Plan
Task 2 -Stormwater Analysis/Investigative Services
Task 3 -Construction Plans and Permitting
Task 4 -Bidding Services
Task 5 –Post Design Services
Design Costs: $344,932.30
Construction Costs (Estimated): $2,000,000 EST
Architect/Engineer: Stantec Consulting Services, Inc.
Board Approval Date: 5/24/22
Notice to Proceed Date: 6/10/22
Completion of Tasks 1-4 –May 16, 2023
Estimated Construction Date: 60% OPC provided 12-26-22
Milestones/Challenges to date: 2-3-2023
•60% Plans presented to the Advisory Board on December 6 and the BCC on December 13, 2022.
•Staff has prepared overview of the option to build pathway along south side of Kelly Court at the request of the
BCC. EOR presented concept to the CRA on 1-17-2023.
•Parking –draft sketch requested by the BCC on parking options has been completed–The proposed parking is
shown at the corner of Jeepers and Bayshore and on parcel A.
•EOR has provided an OPC for 60% drawings and south side of Kelly Court.
•Community meeting held on January 21,2023 to review the concept plan and alternative southern pathway and
parking.
•Bring item back to the BCC in February 2023 prior to finalizing the 100% plans.
•Presentation was given on January 18,2023 to the Parks and Rec Advisory Board, who supported the
project.
17 Acre Pedestrian Connection to Sugden Regional Park
DESCRIPTION OF WORK % COMPLETE
Procurement 100%
Design 60%
Construction 0%
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 123 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
4Exceeding Expectations, Every Day!
District #: 4
Project #: 50174
Funding Source: CRA and Bayshore Beautification MSTU
Project Manager: Tami Scott
Director: Debrah Forester
Project Scope: Access Management and Traffic Calming
for Bayshore Drive.
US41 down to Thomasson Drive on Bayshore Drive
East/West sides of the roadway.
Design Costs: $165,350.00
Architect/Engineer: Stantec Consulting Services, Inc.
General Contractor: N/A
Notice to Proceed Date: Design 11/29/2021 and
Kick off meeting held 1-20-2022
Change Order #1 approved.
Change order #2 pending approval.
Estimated Completion Date with CO#1: 3-6-2023
Change order #2 is being prepared to allow for an
addition 60 days.
New Completion Date with CO#2-6-3-2023
Milestones/Challenges to date: 2-3-2023
•Meeting is scheduled for January 11 with Collier Transportation staff to review data and
analysis and roundabout options.
•Transportation department has requested a meeting with CMO to discuss project,
meeting has been scheduled for February XXXX
•Presentation to Advisory Board tentatively scheduled for March 2023
•Presentation to BCC tentatively scheduled for April 2023
Access Management Plan
DESCRIPTION OF WORK % COMPLETE
Procurement 100%
Design 80%
Construction 0%
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 124 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
5Exceeding Expectations, Every Day!
Commissioner District: 4
Project #: 50203
Funding Source: Bayshore CRA
Lead Project Manager: Richard Orth, Capital Improvements
CRA Project Manager: Tami Scott
Director:Debrah Forester
Project Scope: Stormwater study and design for Becca, Weeks, Pine.
Construction Budget: TBD
Architect/Engineer: Blot Engineer
Design Notice to Proceed Date: 11/16/21
Change Order approved -CO#1
Total Contract as of November 28, 2022: $337,132
Contract Days –1,320 includes post design services.
CRA Gateway Area 1 Pine Becca Week
Task -1 Utility Locates & Soft Digs-336 days
Task-2 Survey-336 days
Task-3 Site Assessment-189 days
Task-4 Design (& Task 5 Conflict Res.)-392 days
Task-6 Permitting-266 days
Task -7 Bidding and Construction-364 days
Task-8 Project Closeout-84 days
Milestones/Challenges to date: 2-3-2023
•Change order #1 has been approved for the realignment of Weeks Avenue.
•Blot Engineering has provided for review the 30% drawings for the ROW
alignment issue.
•Documents have been distributed to stormwater committee
•Review comments due back 1-20-2023
•General comment on realign weeks is that it is a much better design,
however, will likely cost more to realign road and bury the 18” RCP.
Bayshore Stormwater
Phase 1
DESCRIPTION OF WORK % COMPLETE
Procurement 100%
Design 30%
Construction 0%
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 125 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
6Exceeding Expectations, Every Day!
Commissioner District: 4
Project #: 50203
Funding Source: Bayshore CRA
Lead Project Manager: Richard Orth, Capital Improvements
CRA Project Manager: Tami Scott
Director: Debrah Forester
Project Scope: Bayside Street and Linwood Stormwater
Improvements
Design Costs: $257,542
Construction Budget: TBD
Architect/Engineer: Kissinger, Campo and Assoc
Status:work order and PO has been opened 1-13-2023
Design Notice to Proceed Date: January 16, 2023
Milestones/Challenges to date: 2-3-2023
•Engineer Firm Selection via Rotation process
•Work order completed and PO opened
Gateway Triangle Stormwater
Phase 1
DESCRIPTION OF WORK % COMPLETE
Procurement 100%
Design 0%
Construction 0%
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 126 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
7Exceeding Expectations, Every Day!
Commissioner District: 4
Project #: 50203
Funding Source: Bayshore CRA
CRA Project Manager: Cristina Perez
Director: Debrah Forester
Project Scope: Develop master plan for the Gateway Triangle
neighborhood to further implement the BGTCRA Redevelopment
Plan.
Design Costs: $170,000 (estimate)
Architect/Engineer: Pending approval
Status:Drafting scope of work
Design Notice to Proceed Date: TBD
Milestones/Challenges to date: 2-3-2023
•Hurricane Ian severely impacted this area
•Area will be subdivided into neighborhoods/districts
•Scope of work drafted.
•CRA Advisory Board requested evaluation of Direct Select vs RFP process. Item
will be brought forward at the February 9th meeting.
•Community Engagement process with residential neighborhood is scheduled
for February 7th at the East Naples Baptist Church, 1697 Shadowlawn Drive.
Gateway Triangle
Master Plan
DESCRIPTION OF WORK % COMPLETE
Procurement 10%
Design 0%
Construction 0%
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 127 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
8Exceeding Expectations, Every Day!
Commissioner District: 4
Project #: 50206
Funding Source: Bayshore CRA
Project Manager: Debrah Forester
Director: Debrah Forester
Phase 1A-Demolition Completed
Demolition Budget:$142,600
Final Completion: 10-6-2022
Phase 1B –Clearing
Project Scope: Remove exotics on Lot 4
Budget: $17,325
Purchase Order opened January 24, 2023
Phase 2-Future Use Analysis
Project Scope-Public Input and site analysis –development of
alternative development site plans based on public input.
Purchase Order: $24,673
Design Notice to Proceed Date: February 1
Letter of Intent to Purchase Received December 12, 2022
CRA Advisory Board Presentation –January 12, 2003
Milestones/Challenges to date: 2-3-2023
Maintenance
•Lot 4 of the Del’s purchase –vacant RMF-4 parcel has been hand cleared as
allowed by code. Staff has received quotes for the removal of all exotics on that
lot. and will proceed. Purchase Order was opened January 24, 2023. Vegetation
Removal Permit was applied for on January 30th.
•New hose bib to be to be installed on the vacant grass area on Lot 3. Quote to
replace fence due to Hurricane Ian damage pending.
Phase 2 -Community Engagement and Assessment –Stantec Consulting Scope of
work approved by Advisory Board on December 6. Notice to Proceed pending
approval from Procurement. Community visioning charette tentatively scheduled for
mid-February.
Charette: February 25, 2023, Location: Naples Botanical Garden
Del’s Corner –Phase 2
DESCRIPTION OF WORK % COMPLETE
Procurement 10%
Design 0%
Construction 0%
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 128 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
9Exceeding Expectations, Every Day!
Commissioner District: 4
Project #: 50171
Funding Source:Bayshore MSTU/Parks & Recreation
Project Manager: Olivier Surreau
Project Scope: Construct 34 boat trailer parking spaces, multi-use
path, streetlighting and landscape, new roadway, and sidewalks
along Hamilton Avenue.
Construction Budget: $3,246.304.75
Architect/Engineer: RWA
Design Notice to Proceed Date: 1-10-2022
Contractor : Haskins Construction
CEI Services: Johnson Engineering
Milestones/Challenges to date: 2-3-2023
•Project coming close to final completion, ROW inspection provided by Collier
County, Haskins is wrapping up the punch list.
•Presentation was given on January 18 to the Parks & Rec Advisory Board.
•Parks and Recreation in the process of installing signage and trash cans along
parking area.
•January 20 walking tour of area held to discuss landscape maintenance with
contractor and Naples Botanical Garden.
Hamilton Avenue Beautification
DESCRIPTION OF WORK % COMPLETE
Procurement 100%
Design 100%
Construction 95%
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 129 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
10Exceeding Expectations, Every Day!
District #: 4
Project #: Bayshore MSTU
Funding Source: Bayshore Beautification MSTU
Project Manager: Tami Scott
Director: Debrah Forester
Project Scope: Coordinated maintenance and repairs within the
Thomasson Drive, Bayshore Drive and Hamilton Avenue
right-of-ways.
Landscape contractor –A&M
FY23 Annual Maintenance Contract: $153,220.82
FY23 Annual Maintenance Incidentals Budget: $70,000
Notice to Proceed Date: Nov. 12, 2019 (3-year contract)
Milestones/Challenges to date: 2-3-2023
•Median 23 -Staff received a quote for new ground cover in Median on Bayshore
Drive $8,000. MSTU approved the quote on 12-14-2022. Waiting on FDOT project
to be completed prior to replanting, staff is working on PO.
•Royal Palm trimming schedule for 2-2-2023
•Large section of sidewalk to be replaced by RM on Bayshore, damaged from
canopy Trees. MSTU staff met with RM on 1-11-2023 repairs are scheduled.
•January 11 MSTU Advisory Board approved the expenditure to remove the trees.
Bayshore MSTU On-Going Maintenance
DESCRIPTION OF WORK % COMPLETE
Procurement 100%
Ongoing Maintenance 25%
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 130 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
11Exceeding Expectations, Every Day! 11
Holly Avenue Assessment
Commissioner District: 4
Project #: 50203
Funding Source: Bayshore CRA
CRA Project Manager: Cristina Perez
Director: Debrah Forester
Project Scope: Neighborhood assessment of potential
opportunities for life quality enhancement to further implement
the BGTCRA Redevelopment Plan.
Design Costs: TBD
Architect/Engineer: TBD
Status:Coordination of meetings to initiate assessment
Design Notice to Proceed Date: TBD
Milestones/Challenges to date: 2-3-2023
•Hurricane Ian severely impacted this area
•Resident requested a community meeting be held to gather input on needs
and opportunities.
•County and Agency Staff met on January 19th to prepare for community
meeting.
•Neighboring Gathering February 11th @ 9am-11am Location: CRA Property
4825 Bayshore Dr.
DESCRIPTION OF WORK % COMPLETE
Procurement 0%
Design 0%
Construction 0%
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 131 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
January
Status Insurance Claims Tracker
Stars Report #Invoice #
Date of
damage
Submit to Risk
Date Description of damage
Amount of repair &
Replacement
CCSO Incident
report number Total Paid
Reimbursement
Date Outstanding balance
5010192112266 10/19/2021 2/10/2022 Damage Trash Can/Bench, Fox Tail Palm $ 5,743.51 21-382379 $ 5,743.51
5005152212600 5/15/2022 5/23/2022
Light Pole damage at Roundabout
Botanical side $ 19,767.76 21-183526 $ 19,767.76
5006132212754 6/13/2022 7/6/2022
Vandalism to Roundabout directional
signage $ 870.00 no report filed $ 870.00
5006152212693 6/15/2022 6/16/2022
Damage landscaping, irrigation on
median 6 $ 2,200.00 22-223732 $ 2,200.00
5011012213571 11/1/2022 1/5/2023 Damage to pole #43 $ 1,336.50
researching
report $ 1,336.50
5001012313572 1/1/2023 1/5/2023 Damage to pole #52 Researching report
$47,036.03 $ 47,036.03
Total $ 31,326.65
Attachment 12-Item 9c 5.A.2
Packet Pg. 132 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
Fund Ctr / Comm Item
BCC Adopted
Budget
Tot Amend
Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total‐FC/CI
*** 138325 BAYSHORE/GATEWAY 188,726.39 1,993,774.03‐1,805,047.64‐
** REVENUE Sub Total 3,590,600.00‐3,590,600.00‐3,479,699.34‐94,125.00‐
* REVENUE ‐ OPERATING Su 20,000.00‐20,000.00‐ 3,224.34‐16,775.66‐
361170 OVERNIGHT INT 1,582‐1,581.56
361180 INVESTMENT IN 20,000.00‐20,000.00‐1,643‐18,357.22‐
* CONTRIBUTION AND TRANS 3,570,600.00‐3,570,600.00‐3,476,475.00‐130,801.95‐
481001 TRANS FRM 001 2,730,700.00‐2,730,700.00‐ 2,730,700‐
481111 TRANS FRM 111 618,200.00‐618,200.00‐ 618,200‐
481163 TRANS FRM 163 125,500.00‐125,500.00‐ 31,375‐94,125.00‐
481164 TRANS FRM 164 11,300.00‐11,300.00‐ 11,300‐
481186 TRANS FRM 186 84,900.00‐84,900.00‐ 84,900‐
489201 CARRY FORWARD 37,676.95‐ 37,676.95‐
489900 NEG 5% EST RE 1,000.00 1,000.00 1,000.00
** EXPENSE Sub Total 1,089,100.00 1,126,776.95 188,726.39 1,485,925.31 721,525.25
* PERSONAL SERVICE 539,800.00 539,800.00 44,240.25 136,770.19 358,789.56
* OPERATING EXPENSE 499,300.00 536,976.95 144,486.14 79,755.12 312,735.69
634210 IT OFFICE AUT 12,800.00 12,800.00 9,600 3,200
634970 INDIRECT COST 53,700.00 53,700.00 26,850 26,850
634980 INTERDEPT PAY 35,000.00 35,000.00 35,000.00
634990 LANDSCAPE INC 25,000.00 25,000.00 25,000.00
634999 OTHER CONTRAC 210,800.00 246,772.00 78,588 30,734 137,450.52
639967 TEMPORARY LAB 45,000.00 45,000.00 45,000.00
640300 TRAVEL PROF D 8,000.00 8,000.00 1,272‐9,271.60
641230 TELEPHONE ACC 1,800.00 1,800.00 1,800.00
641700 CELLULAR TELE 2,200.00 2,200.00 654 1,546.24
641950 POST FREIGHT 500.00 500.00 48 452.06
641951 POSTAGE 2,000.00 2,000.00 2,000.00
643100 ELECTRICITY 2,500.00 2,500.00 3,289 625 1,413.78‐
643400 WATER AND SEW 6,500.00 6,500.00 5,498 802 200.00
644620 LEASE EQUIPME 2,000.00 2,000.00 2,237 963 1,200.00‐
645100 INSURANCE GEN 3,400.00 3,400.00 2,550 850
645260 AUTO INSURANC 500.00 500.00 375 125
646180 BUILDING RM I 1,451 1,450.89‐
646311 SPRINKLER SYS 500.00 500.00 500.00
646320 LANDSCAPE MAT 162 162.21‐
646360 MAINT OF GROU 30,000.00 30,000.00 10,400 2,780 16,820.00
646430 FLEET MAINT I 300.00 300.00 48 252.00
646440 FLEET MAINT P 200.00 200.00 13 186.73
646445 FLEET NON MAI 198 197.97‐
646970 OTHER EQUIP R 25 24.72‐
647110 PRINTING AND 5,000.00 5,000.00 520 4,480.00
648170 MARKETING AND 7,500.00 7,500.00 3,600 5,584 1,683.96‐
648174 REGISTRATION 1,000.00 1,000.00 1,086 86.05‐
649000 SALES TAX EXP 133‐132.92
649030 CLERKS RECORD 2,500.00 2,500.00 2,500.00
649100 LEGAL ADVERTI 4,500.00 4,500.00 1,500 3,000.00
649990 OTHER MISCELL 500.00 500.00 563 62.50‐
651110 OFFICE SUPPLI 4,000.00 4,000.00 310 3,690.43
651210 COPYING CHARG 5,000.00 5,000.00 5,000.00
651910 MINOR OFFICE 1,500.00 1,500.00 1,500.00
651930 MINOR OFFICE 2,000.00 2,000.00 2,000.00
651950 MINOR DATA PR 2,500.00 4,204.95 4,204.95
652110 CLOTHING AND 1,000.00 1,000.00 1,000.00
652210 FOOD OPERATIN 1,000.00 1,000.00 342 658.00
652490 FUEL AND LUB 600.00 600.00 166 433.75
652920 COMPUTER SOFT 3,000.00 3,000.00 166 2,833.58
652990 OTHER OPERATI 4,500.00 4,500.00 636 3,864.04
652999 PAINTING SUPP 1,500.00 1,500.00 1,500.00
653710 TRAFFIC SIGNS 500.00 500.00 500.00
654110 BOOKS PUB SUB 500.00 500.00 500.00
654210 DUES AND MEMB 4,000.00 4,000.00 2,563 1,437.00
654360 OTHER TRAININ 4,000.00 4,000.00 304‐4,303.95
* CAPITAL OUTLAY 50,000.00 50,000.00 50,000.00
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 50,000.00 50,000.00 50,000.00
* TRANSFERS 2,485,000.00 2,485,000.00 1,269,400.00 1,215,600.00
910010 TRANS TO 001 53,800.00 53,800.00 53,800
917870 TRANS TO 787 2,431,200.00 2,431,200.00 1,215,600 1,215,600.00
* RESERVES 15,500.00 15,500.00 15,500.00
991000 RESV FOR CONT 15,500.00 15,500.00 15,500.00
Fund 187 Bayshore/Gateway Triangle
Attachment 13-Item 9d
Attachment 13 - Page 1
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 133 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
Fund / Comm Item
BCC Adopted
Budget Tot Amend Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total‐Fund/ CI 1,373,603.91 1,137,130.85‐236,473.06‐
*** 787 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 1,373,603.91 1,137,130.85‐236,473.06‐
** REVENUE Sub Total 2,454,600.00‐11,193,943.60‐1,250,199.50‐9,943,744.10‐
*REVENUE ‐ OPERATING Su 24,600.00‐24,600.00‐34,599.50‐9,999.50
361170 OVERNIGHT INT 23,130.22‐23,130.22
361180 INVESTMENT IN 24,600.00‐24,600.00‐11,469.28‐13,130.72‐
*CONTRIBUTION AND TRANS 2,430,000.00‐11,169,343.60‐1,215,600.00‐9,953,743.60‐
481187 TRANS FRM 187 2,431,200.00‐2,431,200.00‐1,215,600.00‐1,215,600.00‐
489201 CARRY FORWARD 8,739,343.60‐8,739,343.60‐
489900 NEG 5% EST RE 1,200.00 1,200.00 1,200.00
** EXPENSE Sub Total 2,454,600.00 11,193,943.60 1,373,603.91 113,068.65 9,707,271.04
* OPERATING EXPENSE 640,300.00 2,766,158.28 773,603.91 113,068.65 1,879,485.72
631401 ENG FEES DESI 257,542.00 257,542.00‐
631650 ABSTRACT FEES
631800 ENVIRONMENTAL
634980 INTERDEPT PAY 3,859.00 3,859.00‐
634999 OTHER CONTRAC 640,300.00 2,766,158.28 277,899.18 26,728.10 2,461,531.00
639990 OTHER CONTRAC 238,162.73 82,481.55 320,644.28‐
649030 CLERKS RECORD
* CAPITAL OUTLAY 1,564,300.00 7,662,361.29 600,000.00 7,062,361.29
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 1,564,300.00 7,662,361.29 600,000.00 7,062,361.29
* GRANTS AND DEBT SERVIC 250,000.00 765,424.03 765,424.03
882100 REMITT PRIVAT 250,000.00 250,000.00 250,000.00
884200 RESIDENTIAL R 515,424.03 515,424.03
Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt Budget Tot Amend Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total‐Fund/ CI 196,422.50 196,422.50
*** 50197 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 196,422.50 196,422.50
** EXPENSE Sub Total 196,422.50 196,422.50
* GRANTS AND DEBT SERVIC 196,422.50 196,422.50
884200 RESIDENTIAL R 196,422.50 196,422.50
Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt Budget Tot Amend Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total‐Fund/ CI 319,001.53 319,001.53
*** 50198 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 319,001.53 319,001.53
** EXPENSE Sub Total 319,001.53 319,001.53
* GRANTS AND DEBT SERVIC 319,001.53 319,001.53
884200 RESIDENTIAL R 319,001.53 319,001.53
Fund 787 Bayshore CRA Projects
Fund 787 Project 50197 Residential Grants
Fund 787 Project 50198 Commercial Grants
Attachment 13 - Page 2
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 134 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
Fund / Comm Item Adopted Budget Amended Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total‐Fund/ CI 838,000 2,504,664.82 478,491 12,824 2,013,350.00
*** 50203 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 838,000 2,504,664.82 478,491 12,824 2,013,350.00
** EXPENSE Sub Total 838,000 2,504,664.82 478,491 12,824 2,013,350.00
* OPERATING EXPENSE 279,285 478,491.22 12,824 212,030.00‐
631401 ENG FEES DESI 257,542 257,542.00‐
634980 INTERDEPT PAY 646 646.00‐
634999 OTHER CONTRAC 279,284.82 220,949 12,178 46,158.00
* CAPITAL OUTLAY 838,000 2,225,380.00 2,225,380.00
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 838,000 2,225,380.00 2,225,380.00
Fund / Comm Item Adopted Budget Amended Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total‐Fund/ CI 100,000 800,000.00 800,000.00
*** 50204 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 100,000 800,000.00 800,000.00
** EXPENSE Sub Total 100,000 800,000.00 800,000.00
* OPERATING EXPENSE 350,000.00 350,000.00
634999 OTHER CONTRAC 350,000.00 350,000.00
* CAPITAL OUTLAY 100,000 450,000.00 450,000.00
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 100,000 450,000.00 450,000.00
Fund / Comm Item Adopted Budget Amended Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total‐Fund/ CI 635,863.50 40,841 3,213 591,810.00
*** 50206 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 635,863.50 40,841 3,213 591,810.00
** EXPENSE Sub Total 635,863.50 40,841 3,213 591,810.00
* OPERATING EXPENSE 40,841 3,213 44,053.50‐
631650 ABSTRACT FEES
631800 ENVIRONMENTAL
634980 INTERDEPT PAY 3,213 3,213.00‐
634999 OTHER CONTRAC 39,673 39,673.00‐
639990 OTHER CONTRAC 1,168 1,167.50‐
649030 CLERKS RECORD
* CAPITAL OUTLAY 635,863.50 635,863.50
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 635,863.50 635,863.50
Fund 787 Project 50206 Ackerman‐Dells
Fund 787 Project 50203 Stormwater
Fund 787 Project 50204 Linwood
Fund 787 Project 50271 Neighborhood Initiative
Fund / Comm Item Adopted Budget Amended Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total‐Fund/ CI 250,000 850,000.00 600,000 250,000.00
250,000 850,000.00 600,000 250,000.00*** 50270 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC
** EXPENSE Sub Total 250,000 850,000.00 600,000 250,000.00
600,000.00 600,000
600,000.00 600,000
* CAPITAL OUTLAY 763100
IMPROVEMENTS
* GRANTS AND DEBT SERVIC 250,000 250,000.00 250,000.00
882100 REMITT PRIVAT 250,000 250,000.00 250,000.00
Fund / Comm Item Adopted Budget Amended Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total‐Fund/ CI 320,100 320,100.00 320,100.00
320,100 320,100.00 320,100.00*** 50271 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC
** EXPENSE Sub Total 320,100 320,100.00 320,100.00
*OPERATING EXPENSE 320,100 320,100.00 320,100.00
634999 OTHER CONTRAC 320,100 320,100.00 320,100.00
Fund 787 Project 50270 Mini‐Triangle TIF Agreement
Attachment 13 - Page 3
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 135 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
Fund / Comm Item Adopted Budget Amended Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total‐Fund/ CI 15,000 64,586.31 320 64,266.31
*** 50207 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 15,000 64,586.31 320 64,266.31
** EXPENSE Sub Total 15,000 64,586.31 320 64,266.31
* OPERATING EXPENSE 320 320.00‐
634999 OTHER CONTRAC 320 320.00‐
* CAPITAL OUTLAY 15,000 64,586.31 64,586.31
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 15,000 64,586.31 64,586.31
Fund / Comm Item Adopted Budget Amended Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total‐Fund/ CI 261,300 2,947,752.48 236,995 82,482 2,628,275.70
*** 50208 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 261,300 2,947,752.48 236,995 82,482 2,628,275.70
** EXPENSE Sub Total 261,300 2,947,752.48 236,995 82,482 2,628,275.70
* OPERATING EXPENSE 697,120.00 236,995 82,482 377,643.22
634980 INTERDEPT PAY
634999 OTHER CONTRAC 697,120.00 697,120.00
639990 OTHER CONTRAC 236,995 82,482 319,476.78‐
* CAPITAL OUTLAY 261,300 2,250,632.48 2,250,632.48
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 261,300 2,250,632.48 2,250,632.48
Fund / Comm Item Adopted Budget Amended Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total‐Fund/ CI 125,000 125,000.00 125,000.00
*** 50254 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 125,000 125,000.00 125,000.00
** EXPENSE Sub Total 125,000 125,000.00 125,000.00
* OPERATING EXPENSE 125,000 125,000.00 125,000.00
634999 OTHER CONTRAC 125,000 125,000.00 125,000.00
Fund / Comm Item Adopted Budget Amended Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total‐Fund/ CI 100,000 200,000.00 200,000.00
*** 50255 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 100,000 200,000.00 200,000.00
** EXPENSE Sub Total 100,000 200,000.00 200,000.00
* CAPITAL OUTLAY 100,000 200,000.00 200,000.00
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 100,000 200,000.00 200,000.00
Fund / Comm Item Adopted Budget Amended Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total‐Fund/ CI 50,000 135,899.00 135,899.00
*** 50256 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 50,000 135,899.00 135,899.00
** EXPENSE Sub Total 50,000 135,899.00 135,899.00
* CAPITAL OUTLAY 50,000 135,899.00 135,899.00
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 50,000 135,899.00 135,899.00
Fund 787 Project 50207 Bayshore Parking Lot
Fund 787 Project 50208 17 Acre Site
Fund 787 Project 50254 Commercial
Fund 787 Project 50255 Public Art
Fund 787 Project 50256 Commun. Safety Improve
Attachment 13 - Page 4
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 136 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
Fund / Comm Item Adopted Budget Amended Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total‐Fund/ CI 500,000.00 500,000.00
*** 50258 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 500,000.00 500,000.00
** EXPENSE Sub Total 500,000.00 500,000.00
* OPERATING EXPENSE 250,000.00 250,000.00
634999 OTHER CONTRAC 250,000.00 250,000.00
* CAPITAL OUTLAY 250,000.00 250,000.00
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 250,000.00 250,000.00
Fund / Comm Item Adopted Budget Amended Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total‐Fund/ CI 150,000.00 150,000.00
*** 50259 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 150,000.00 150,000.00
** EXPENSE Sub Total 150,000.00 150,000.00
* CAPITAL OUTLAY 150,000.00 150,000.00
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 150,000.00 150,000.00
Fund / Comm Item Adopted Budget Amended Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total‐Fund/ CI 195,200 295,200.00 295,200.00
*** 50261 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 195,200 295,200.00 295,200.00
** EXPENSE Sub Total 195,200 295,200.00 295,200.00
* OPERATING EXPENSE 195,200 295,200.00 295,200.00
634999 OTHER CONTRAC 195,200 295,200.00 295,200.00
Fund / Comm Item Adopted Budget Amended Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total‐Fund/ CI 200,000 1,049,453.46 16,957 14,551 1,017,946.00
*** 50262 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 200,000 1,049,453.46 16,957 14,551 1,017,946.00
** EXPENSE Sub Total 200,000 1,049,453.46 16,957 14,551 1,017,946.00
* OPERATING EXPENSE 449,453.46 16,957 14,551 417,946.00
634999 OTHER CONTRAC 449,453.46 16,957 14,551 417,946.00
* CAPITAL OUTLAY 200,000 600,000.00 600,000.00
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 200,000 600,000.00 600,000.00
Fund / Comm Item Adopted Budget Amended Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total‐Fund/ CI 100,000.00 100,000.00
*** 50263 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 100,000.00 100,000.00
** EXPENSE Sub Total 100,000.00 100,000.00
* CAPITAL OUTLAY 100,000.00 100,000.00
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 100,000.00 100,000.00
Fund 787 Project 50258 General Rd Improve
Fund 787 Project 50259 Multi‐Modal Improve
Fund 787 Project 50261 Housing
Fund 787 Project 50262 N Bayshore Enhance
Fund 787 Project 50263 Complete Streets
Attachment 13 - Page 5
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 137 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
Bayshore CRA
Open Cases
February 2023
Case Number Case Type Date Entered Location Description Detailed Description
CENA20180000203 NA 01/05/2018 3148 Van Buren Ave (52700280000)grass/weeds in excess of 18 inches
CENA20180000206 NA 01/05/2018 3140 Van Buren Ave. (52700320009)grass/weeds in excess of 18 inches in height
CESD20180006864 SD 05/02/2018 2579 Andrew Dr Installing an outside stairwell no permits
CENA20180008927 NA 06/29/2018 3085 Karen Dr, Naples, FL Weeds/grass over 18 inches
CESD20180010777 SD 08/24/2018 2727 Bayshore Drive, Unit 106 Interior renovations without a permit, see Contractor Licensing Case CECV20180010498.
CENA20180012136 NA 09/27/2018
2977 CYPRESS ST - 29830240008
End of Cypress St (Left offf of Becca)Grass and vegetation overgrown
CENA20190003644 NA 04/01/2019 2739 Holly Ave Litter/outside storage on property.
CEV20190003764 V 04/02/2019 2739 Holly - 50890320005 Unlicensed and inoperative vehicles.
CESD20190006401 SD 05/28/2019 2617 HOLLY AVE - 50890640002 Complainant stated that behind main house there is a small shack that has utilities hooked up to it and there are people living in there as a rental.
CESD20190008083 SD 07/03/2019 3061 Lunar St - 53352760003
Residental property being used as a hotel/motel and sober house. Multiple rooms being rented out in the home.
(Note: 11/6/19 changing to SD per Building Determination on 11/1/19)
CEPM20190008861 PM 07/22/2019 2739 Holly Broken windows in front of house
CEPM20190014027 PM 11/20/2019 2978 Poplar St - 29831080005 Structure with roof and siding damage.
CELU20190014156 LU 11/25/2019 2332 Tamiami Trail E, (Corner of Spruce and Tamiami Trail E)Parking on vacant unimproved lot.
CEPM20200000363 PM 01/10/2020 2862 Arbutus St - 81780360005 Docks that are failing and starting to fall into the water. Hazard for boats in the area.
CESD20200002113 SD 02/25/2020 Sunrise Motel - 2486 Tamiami Trail E, Naples, FL 34112 - 51690040005 Gazebo built at Sunrise hotel without a permit.
CENA20200004979 NA 05/08/2020 3015 Karen Dr High grass
CENA20200006121 NA 06/09/2020 61839440003 - 3175 KAREN DR grass & weeds in excess of 18". Also accumulation of vegetative debris.
CENA20200006128 NA 06/09/2020 61840320002
Grass & weeds in excess of 18", and, vegetative debris on this unimproved lot.
Paid in full mc
CEPM20200006626 PM 06/20/2020
2617 Holly Ave
off bayshore road can't miss it!house is occupied by drug addicts house is falling down and people are squatting in it building is dangerous
CENA20200010414 NA 09/24/2020 50891000007 - 2596 HOLLY AVE
Grass & weeds in excess of 18". Also - vegetative debris.
Inclusion to Mandatory lot Mowing propgram as of today 10/8/2020
CESD20200011642 SD 10/27/2020 23120120009 - 2248 CURTIS ST
Complaint of turning this single family home into a multi family unit with possible garage conversion, and now too many people living in them.
*RE: AIMS 311 Service Request 51854*
CENA20210001924 NA 02/24/2021 81780240002 - Unimproved lot at the west end of Becca Ave High grass & weeds in excess of 18"
CEPM20210002299 PM 03/09/2021 29280440005 - 2648 VAN BUREN AVE House has shed in backyard that is old and rusted with a bunch of rats in it.
CEV20210002337 V 03/10/2021 2311 Andrew Dr.Numerous unlicensed vehicles and all along the buffer hedge in a row all the way to the back of the property mostly trucks but all unlicensed
CEPM20210003116 PM 03/30/2021
Along Commercial Dr
Behind 2300 Davis Blvd. Economy Body Shop
Graffiti on utility boxes
Between Davis Blvd. & Kirkwood Dr. in the alley on backwall of Economy Body Shop
CESD20210003927 SD 04/20/2021
3056 Van Buren Ave
Van Buren and Bayshore.
Unpermitted modification to trailer ending it's original DOT certification. Structure must be removed as it is a hazard to occupants and neighboring structures.
Entire top of trailer and walls have been removed and replaced with site built materials without any permitting, engineering or inspection.
CESD20210004109 SD 04/23/2021 3470 Bayshore Dr
Bayshore CRA has received complaints regarding new boat racks being installed, noise and debris at the Marina located at the corner of Bayshore and
Riverview.
CENA20210005555 NA 05/27/2021 County owned property to the west of complainant's property @ 2500 Lee St Exotics encroaching on complainant's property
CESD20210005901 SD 06/08/2021 3240 Collee Ct - 48680200004 Unpermitted AC unit, carport enclosure, and interior remodeling, see Contractor Licensing Case CECV20210004960.
CEPM20210006514 PM 06/21/2021
4621 Bayshore behind Bldg Q - behind the wooden fence
21800001709 - 4629 BAYSHORE DR Really long sistern is in bad shape (rotted / trees growing out of it) to where someone could fall in & drown.
CENA20210006533 NA 06/22/2021 2617 holly Ave weeds and litter
CENA20210009227 NA 08/27/2021 75761920001 - 2332 SUNSET AVE Grass & weeds in excess of 18". ALso, dead vegetative debris piled up.
CESD20210011366 SD 11/02/2021
(incorrect) 71800000307 - 3339 CANAL ST (incorrect)
71800000242 - 3399 CANAL ST New carport that showed up over the weekend. Permits?
CESD20210011573 SD 11/05/2021 3212 Bayshore Dr. - 48171320008 - 3200 BAYSHORE DR Remodeling a room and adding a kitchen, adding walls and stairs ( no permits)
Attachment 14-Item 10a
Attachment 14 - Page 1
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 138 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
Bayshore CRA
Open Cases
February 2023
CESD20210011987 SD 11/18/2021
2564 Van Buren Ave
29280560309 - 2564 VAN BUREN AVE Home occupied without C/O on permit. Also check status of expired tank permit PRBD20210416602 & rejected pool enclosure permit PRBD20210840479
CEPM20210013352 PM 12/29/2021 48173680005 - 2649 LAKEVIEW DR
bulk head seems to be cut by the neighbor and is very concerned about his safety as the neighbor threatened him, and also he has a boat parked in the front of
the property half way into his property for weeks, there is a fence on the property that the neighbor has put a roof on which collects the rainwater and dumps it
on his property.
CEAU20220000580 AU 01/18/2022 48173680005 - 2649 LAKEVIEW DR Fence built without a permit (from case # CEPM20210013352)
CESD20220001491 SD 02/10/2022 2315 Andrew Drive Unpermitted addition, see Contractor Licensing Case CECV20220000863.
CEVR20220002751 VR 03/18/2022 71800000433 - 3370 CANAL ST An unimproved parcel was illegally cleared of vegetation.
CEPM20220003654 PM 04/12/2022 82640200000 - 2448 ANDREW DR Possible dangerous structure on this parcel.
CEPM20220003671 PM 04/13/2022
00388200001 - 301 PIER C - Main address for NAPLES LAND YACHT HARBOR
INC
Site Address: 103 Pier K, Naples Land Yacht Harbor
Mobile home that was crashed into by a stolen U-Haul box truck. The mobile home appears to have shifted off of its foundation and was declared a dangerous
structure.
CESD20220003822 SD 04/18/2022 2201 Paget Cir - 82840200606 Pool addition with exposed pipes coming out on Right side of home being performed without permits
CEAU20220004549 AU 05/09/2022
48173640003
2667 Lakeview Dr A fence was built that may be unpermitted.
CEPM20220005093 PM 05/25/2022 61841680000 - 1 Bamboo Drive Dumpsters @ Harmony Shores are not properly screened.
CEPM20220005317 PM 06/02/2022 See attached email for site adddress that will need to be confirmed.Failed culvert pipe
CEN20220005766 N 06/17/2022 3555 Bayshore Dr (Ankrolab Brewery) - 61841320001 Noise from something running day/night
CESD20220005870 SD 06/21/2022
Folio 81780360005 - Common area parcel @ 2862 Arbutus St
64770400002 Unpermitted parking lot in ROW, see Contractor Licensing Case CEMIS20220002239.
CENA20220005871 NA 06/21/2022
50890640002
2617 Holly Ave Grass and weeds in excess of 18"
CEPM20220006154 PM 07/01/2022 61841280002 - 3531 PLANTATION WAY
Caller states the staircases are in bad shape. The brackets are rusted & falling off, the bannisters shake & the foundation of the staircases are not good either.
Caller states all 9 buildings are like this.
CESD20220006564 SD 07/15/2022 48173280007 - 3470 BAYSHORE DR
Floating docks not being permitted behind the Viage Marina. The employees seem to party on them all night long and the complainant said they never seen a
permit for them in the portal. (Bayshore CRA)
CEPM20220007058 PM 07/28/2022 102 Jeepers Dr Squatters reported at this location. No power, no water, and trailer in poor condition. CEROW2022000711
5 ROW 08/01/2022 2519 Bayside St They have started some sort of site development, per the complainant. They have altered the culvert, possibly without permits.
CELU20220007287 LU 08/04/2022 2519 Bayside St Storing materials on the unimproved property. No active building permits.
CESD20220008132 SD 08/26/2022 50891080001 - 2620 HOLLY AVE Unpermitted mobile home rebuild, see Contractor Licensing Case CECV20220007979.
CESD20220008134 SD 08/26/2022 61330520008 - 1881 DANFORD ST Unpermitted addition & exterior door, see Contractor Licensing Case CECV20220008078.
CENA20220008235 NA 08/31/2022 48173680005 - 2649 LAKEVIEW DR Illegal outside storage of building materials
CENA20220008303 NA 09/01/2022 Corner of Bayshore and Van Buren Ave (NE corner)Overgrown weeds and litter on unimproved property.
CEPM20220008389 PM 09/06/2022 2996 Francis Ave #11 Rec'd call from a DAS officer. Converted shed w/ someone living in it. Looks like a a utility shed.
CELU20220008564 LU 09/12/2022
2303 Kirkwood - 22720720004
(this complaint has 3 separate addresses with the same alleged violation: 2303, 2348, &
2370 Kirkwood)
Unlicensed vehicles - caller states it was cleared up by code before, but they're back
(switched case to LU)
CEV20220008715 V 09/14/2022 2536 LEE ST - 76410080000 Multiple boats & trailers parked on the side of a residence
CEVR20220009888 VR 10/28/2022 Preserve that runs from west end of Sunset Ave to west end of Florida Ave
Exotic vegetation (Melaluca, Australian Pine, Areca Palms, Brazilian Pepper, etc.) overgrowing preserve area. This overgrowth is also affecting the drainage
on the north side of Sunset Ave.
CEVR20220009981 VR 11/01/2022 Where Sunset Ave and Pine St meet, across from the Windstar Community There is a lake with extremely overgrown vegetation, including many sea hibiscus
CEPM20220010218 PM 11/10/2022 1002 Tippins Terr.H2A Workers are moving into the unit approxiately 10 people and more dropped off today by bus overcrowding in the home.
CESD20220010484 SD 11/22/2022 3044 Coco Ave,
Unpermitted demolition of a garage on the back of the property and removal of cabinets and plumbing fixtures from inside the interior of the single family
residence.
Attachment 14 - Page 2
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 139 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
Case Number Case Type Description Date Entered Location Description Detailed Description
CESD20230000101 SD Open 01/04/2023 4040 Bayshore Dr. - 61836280004
Tent was constructed without a permit, food is being cooked and sold there without any sort of restaurant license.
Propane tanks are laying around the property and there is no ventilation system on the tent.
CEOCC20230000119 OCC Closed 01/05/2023 2780 Francis Ave.C & N Screen Enclosures is working on Sundays and late at night, cutting metal and making all sorts of loud noises.
CEV20230000161 V Closed 01/07/2023 8049 Bayshore Commercial vehicle and inoperable vehicle parked in front of property.
CELU20230000168 LU Open 01/09/2023
North side of 4069 Bayshore Dr in the
vacant lots behind the golf cart place off
of Lunar St
53353400003 Large homeless camp
CEPM20230000170 PM Open 01/09/2023 2777 Shoreview Dr
These apartments were ignored after Ian and I'm concerned about black mold as I've seen no remediation activity.
Continued debris deposited across the street in the ROW.
CEV20230000203 V Open 01/09/2023
Located next to my property 3251 Lunar
Street Naples FL 34112
Actual address of violation:
29430040006 - 3301 LUNAR ST
1998 White Ford Windstar NO TAG Packed with parts and personal items. VIN 2FTDA5447WBA88061. Vehicle is
abandoned on county ride away. It's located next to my property; the grass is so overgrown that is covering the wheels.
CESD20230000208 SD Open 01/10/2023 3085 Areca Ave – 71781920001
Unpermitted interior repairs in progress.
(referred from CESD20220009672)
CEAU20230000300 AU Open 01/12/2023
2898 Weeks Ave
Property line between 2898 Weeks Ave
and 2872 Weeks Ave.
The owner of 2898 Weeks Ave informed the owner of 2872 Weeks Ave he obtained a permit, with the aid of John
Johnson code enforcement inspector, to erect a wood fence on the property line between these addresses. The owner of
2898 Weeks Ave had the property line surveyed but has proceeded with self-installation of a wooden fence that is
encroaching on the property of 2872 Weeks Ave.
CEV20230000449 V Closed 01/18/2023 12055 Sittlerley ST I did witness a vehicle park on the grass.
Attachment 14 - Page 3
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 140 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local
A fter decades of dreaming—and hard
work by grassroots and governmental
groups—the future of the Bayshore
community southeast of Naples’ city
limits has arrived. A complex of four
mid- and high-rises and a public green space
with a boardwalk are taking shape while new
businesses are opening in the a hip, vibrant,
artsy neighborhood.
Twenty years ago, Bayshore was mostly a
place where motorists simply passed through
while they were headed someplace else. But
that’s no longer the case. e Naples Botanical
Garden draws visitors from throughout the
region and Celebration Park—with food
trucks, craft brews, and entertainment—
consistently buzzes with regulars and
good vibes. In addition to investors and
entrepreneurs, the community is attracting
young families and a glowing reputation.
Bayshore Drive Earns Accolades
e nearly two-mile-long Bayshore Drive
corridor recently won the ninth annual “Great
Places in Florida” competition sponsored by
the American Planning Association Florida
Chapter (APA FL). e theme of the contest
was “Great Healthy Places” and Bayshore
Drive bested three other innovative nalists.
In announcing the 2022 award, APA FL
noted: “Bayshore Drive has transformed from
an underutilized corridor to a complete street
and community asset, setting the standard for
other jurisdictions looking to bring health,
well-being and vibrancy to outdated roadways.
Bayshore Drive promotes healthy and active
lifestyles, advances the community’s quality
of life, and fosters social activity, while
protecting and enhancing appreciation for the
environment.”
Among other features, such as clearly marked
bike paths, APA FL cited these projects as
contributors to its “Great Healthy Places” status:
A pocket park created on the site of the
former Del’s store
New banners greeting visitors
A tra c-calming roundabout at omasson
and Bayshore drives
The Time is (Finally) Right
Residents and government o cials
recognized the immense potential of the
community, so in 2000, Collier County
established the Bayshore Gateway
TriangleCommunity Redevelopment Agency
(CRA). CRAs work to improve residents’
and business owners’ quality of life in targeted
communities through capital improvements
and coordination with other public and private
agencies.
For instance, CRAs coordinate sidewalks,
parking lots, and tra c improvements and
management, and o er grants to incentivize
improvements by property owners. In July,
a Public Art Pilot Plan was approved by
the CRA Executive Board, made up of the
Collier County Board of Commissioners, to
encourage the creation of murals.
e award-winning Bayshore Drive is one
section of the CRA. at’s where plans for a
17-acre park with restored vegetation and a
meandering boardwalk connecting to Sugden
Regional Park are underway. e green space
includes open lawn and patches of woods and
ponds. Collier County CRA Director Debrah
Forester says the agency is working with
Naples Botanical Garden on site-appropriate
plantings and the design is expected to be
nalized by the end of May.
e other section is the Gateway Triangle
area bounded by U.S. 41 East, Davis
Boulevard, and Airport-Pulling Road across
the street from Naples Bay Resort & Marina.
In 2009, the CRA purchased land there “as
a catalyst site” for redevelopment. e CRA
purchased it in 2009 but things moved slowly
due to the economic downturn, Forester
says, and a request for proposals for mixed-
use development “that allows people to live,
work, and play in the area and encourage
other people to invest in the area” was nally
issued in 2015. In November 2020, the CRA
sold three parcels totaling 10.4 acres to two
entities, which included Metropolitan Naples.
BY CATHY CHESTNUT
FOROPENERS
A NEW DAY FOR BAYSHORE GATEWAY TRIANGLE
Metropolitan Naples ‘will undoubtedly redefine’ the
eastern gateway into downtown
16 NAPLES REALTOR® Q1 2023
Attachment 15- Item 11a
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 141 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
Metropolitan Landmark Rising
Construction on the first high-rise at
Metropolitan Naples started in fall 2022.
Metropolitan Naples Realty Director of Sales
Ed Gonzalez says construction will begin on
the second high-rise, Aura, at the beginning
of this year. “The construction timeline for
Aura is about 18 months; the expectation
is for residents to move in during the third
quarter of 2024,” Gonzalez estimates.
Metropolitan Naples has a sales office at Fifth
Avenue South.
The Metropolitan Naples complex will
include four buildings:
∙ The Ellington, a 10-story luxury hotel with
two restaurants
∙ Aura, a 15-story luxury condo residence
with 56 residential units and 6,000 square
feet of retail space on the ground levels and
a rooftop infinity pool and fitness center
overlooking Naples Bay, downtown Naples,
and the Gulf of Mexico
∙ A 15-story tower with long-term, luxury
condo rentals and 10,000 to 12,000 square
feet of retail and office/professional space
∙ A condo development with 70 to 90
residences and 50,000 square feet of
restaurant and retail
“I think the impact in the community will be
huge,” says Gonzalez. “Metropolitan Naples will
undoubtedly redefine the entire area. As a mixed-
use community with restaurants, boutiques, and
office space and Aura as its signature building
with first-class amenities, Metropolitan Naples
will become a destination on its own.”
Metropolitan Naples is being developed
by two respected, long-time Naples residents
and veteran developers, Fred Pezeshkan and
Jerry Starkey.
Top: Two renderings of Aura at Metropolitan Naples illustrate
how this modern high-rise will reshape the urban landscape.
Above: The popular Celebration Park is a popular gathering
spot. Below: A bird’s-eye view of Haldeman Creek in the
Bayshore community. BORGES ARCHITECTSCOLLIER COUNTY NAPLES AREA BOARD OF REALTORS® 17
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 142 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
HOLLY AVE NEIGHBORHOOD GATHERING
Please join us on Saturday February 11, 2023 at 9:00am-
11:00am at the CRA property located at 4825 Bayshore Dr. Formerly
the Boat Yard
You will have the opportunity to discuss ways to improve your
neighborhood with local agencies. Agencies attending include:
Sheriff’s Department, Code Enforcement, Habitat for Humanity and
Solid Waste.
For more information, please call (239)-252-8844
PLEASE ATTEND
SATURDAY
February 11, 2023
────
OPEN HOUSE
9:00am - 11:00am
────
JOIN US FOR
COFFEE, DONUTS
& CONVERSATION
────
4825 Bayshore Dr
Naples, FL 34112
────
Holly Ave
Neighborhood
Meet and Greet
SPONSORED BY:
BAYSHORE/GATEWAY
TRIANGLE CRA
3299 Tamiami Trail E,
Suite 103
Naples, FL 34112
(239)-252-8844
www.bayshorecra.com
PARKING LIMITED
WALKING & BIKING
ENCOURAGED
Attachment 16- Item 11b 5.A.2
Packet Pg. 143 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
2023 Annual Conference
SAVE THE DATE!
Get ready for the 2023 Florida Redevelopment Association Annual Conference,
October 24-27, 2023 at the Sawgrass Marriott Golf Resort & Spa.
The exhibit hall will be open October 25-26, 2023.
Have questions regarding the FRA Annual Conference, including exhibiting and sponsorship opportunities?
Reach out to Heidi Hogarth at hhogarth@ cities.com.
Conference Information
Exhibitor/Corporate Participant
Check back for more details.
ACADEMY AWARDS MEMBERSHIP RESOURCES ANNUAL CONFERENCE
NEWS CONTACT US
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.
Ok
Attachment 17- Item 11c
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 144 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9,
Page 1 Page 2
Attachment 18 –Item 11d
Attachment 18
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 145 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
Page 3 Page 4Attachment 18
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 146 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
Page 5 Page 6Attachment 18
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 147 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway
Attachment 19
5.A.2
Packet Pg. 148 Attachment: BGTCRA Agenda Packet-2-9-2023 - FINAL (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9, 2023)
5.A.3Packet Pg. 149Attachment: Signed Meeting Minutes 1.17.23 (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9, 2023)
5.A.3Packet Pg. 150Attachment: Signed Meeting Minutes 1.17.23 (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9, 2023)
5.A.3Packet Pg. 151Attachment: Signed Meeting Minutes 1.17.23 (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9, 2023)
5.A.3Packet Pg. 152Attachment: Signed Meeting Minutes 1.17.23 (24774 : Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA Local Advisory Board Meeting- February 9, 2023)