Haldeman Creek MSTU Agenda 01/09/202321.A.2
tlp�>(/2Pi vl� zn. B&Vyw
Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA •Bayshore Beautification MSTU
Haldeman Creek MSTU
Haldeman Creek MSTU Advisory Committee Meeting
AGENDA
January 9, 2023
3:30 PM
3299 Tamiami Trail E 3rd Floor BCC Chambers, Naples, Florida 34112
Acting Chairman Roy Wilson
Jacob Dutry van Haeften, James King, Bill Robbins, Robert Wopperer
1. Call to order and Roll Call
2. Pledge of Allegiance
3. Adoption of Agenda
4. Approval of Minutes
a. April 4, 2022 Minutes (Attachment)
5. Community / Business — Presentations
6. Old Business
7. New Business
a. Election of Officers Chair and Vice Chair (Action Item)
b. State Scan of the Creek- Pawel Brzsky, Capital Project Planning/Impact
Fees/Program Management
c. Bay Days Clean Up April 1, 2023
d. HC Meeting Calendar 2023
8. Staff Report
a. Priority Project Report — (Attachment)
b. Financials- (Attachment)
9. Correspondence and Communication
a. Quality of Place Award — Florida Planning Association
10. Public Comment
11. Staff Comments:
12. Advisory Board General Communications
13. Next meeting date:
a. February 6ti', 2023 3:30pm BCC Board Room
14. Adjournment
Packet Pg. 460
21.A.2
-B 4 V 7w
Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA •Bayshore Beautification MSTU
Haldeman Creek MSTU
April 4, 2022 meeting minutes
Item 4a
HALDEMAN CREEK MSTU MINUTES OF THE APRIL 4, 2022 MEETING
The meeting of the Haldeman Creek MSTU Advisory Committee was called to order by
Roy Wilson at 3:30 p.m. at 3299 Tamiami Trail E, 3rd Floor BCC Chambers, Naples, FL
34112.
I. Roll Call: Advisory Board Members Present: Chair, Roy Wilson, Robert
Wopperer, Bill Robbins and Jim King Jacob Dutry van Haeften.
MSTU Staff Present: Debrah Forester, CRA Director, and Shirley Garcia,
Operations Coordinator
II. Pledge of Allegiance- Was led by Roy Wilson
III. Adoption of Agenda: Robert Wopperer made a motion to approve the agenda as
amended, Jim King second. Approved unanimously.
IV. Adoption of Minutes: Robert Wopperer made a motion to approve the minutes, Jim
King second, approved unanimously.
V. Community / Business — Presentations
a. PL20220000731 - Regatta Landings, Turrell, Hall & Associates, - Joshua
Maxwell presented the dock extension amendment that was being requested to the
County to amend the boat size requirement. The community is at the point where they
need some nicer boats with amenities, but the width requirement is so restrictive that
would discourage people from buying into their community. The current agreement
was for a maximum width of the boat to be 10.5 and they would like to have that
modified. The request is to remove the 10.5 maximum beam width and The proposed
modifications are the BDE's per boat dock accordingly to the chart below:
1 19ft
14
14.9ft
2 16.3ft
15
14.9ft
3 14.5ft
16
15.4ft
4 12.2ft
17
16.2ft
5 10.6ft
18
16.3ft
6 11.6ft
19
15.2ft
7 12ft
20
12.3ft
8 12.5ft
21
12.3ft
9 12.5ft
22
17.7ft
10 14.6ft
23
18.3ft
11 14.7ft
24
18.3ft
12 12.2ft
25
17.7ft
13 12.2ft
26
16.1ft
Packet Pg. 461
21.A.2
-B4 V 7w
Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA •Bayshore Beautification MSTU
Haldeman Creek MSTU
After much discussion, Bill Robbins made a motion to support the modification to
amend their application to limit max beam width up to 13ft. and no slip should stick
beyond the pre -approved boat extension line. Jim King, second. Jaap Dutry van
Haeften and Robert Wopperer both abstained from the motion due to conflict.
Approved unanimously.
VI. Old Business:
a. Bay Days Haldeman Creek Clean up- Ms. Forester noted the attached power
point of the clean up at Haldeman Creek for the bay days
VII. New Business:
a. Mileage Neutral or Tax Neutral- Roy Wilson explained to the committee the
difference between Mileage Neutral and Tax Neutral. Jim King made a motion to
remain Mileage Neutral, second by Bill Robbins approved unanimously.
b. FY23 Priorities- Ms. Forester noted their budget for any priorities the committee
wanted to discuss now, Roy Wilson recommended continuing to save money and
come back to the priority list later. Mr. Robbins asked if homeowners could piggy-
back the dredging permit the CRA acquired, and Ms. Forester noted the home
owners could piggy back the permit to pull their own individual permit from the
County to dredge. Jaap Dutry van Haeften asked for a copy of the priority list the
committee received. Mr. Wilson asked staff to send the last priority list so the
committee could look it over and update it.
VIII. Staff Report:
a. CRA Directors Report- Ms. Forester provided the report and asked if anyone
had any questions.
b. Project Manager Report- Ms. Forester provided the project managers report
if anyone had any questions.
c. Financials- Ms. Forester noted the tax revenues generated and reminded the
committee of the expansion of the boundary to include the Courthouse Shadows
Development.
IX. Correspondence and Communications:
a. Signage email response boating and waterways- Mr. Wilson had emailed
numerous photos of the damaged signage in the creek, some were needing
replacement, some just needed to be straightened out. The staff will send it to
Coastal Zone Mgmt in the County to request new signs and set some of the pilings
upright again. Mr. Wilson also spoke about the manatee signs and would like to
request these manatee signs be put on the same poles as the other signage. The signs
are free from the Manatee Club, folks could pick up the signs and put it on their
docks as well.
Packet Pg. 462
21.A.2
-B 4 V 7w
Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA •Bayshore Beautification MSTU
Haldeman Creek MSTU
X. Public Comments: There was a question about dredging the drainage canal and Ms.
Forester noted the County had gone in there and cleaned it all out. Mr. Wilson noted
that the drainage canals is under their purview to dredge it out. He also asked about if a
weir was going in at Harvest Ct. and Ms. Forester responded that it was a county project
and she would email him a contact in the County to ask about their project.
XI. Staff Comments: Ms. Forester noted the joint workshop and the MSTU Chair
would sit at the table with the CRA and MSTU Chair but all is welcome to attend in the
audience. She also noted the next meeting as October 3, but can be changed. Mr. Wilson
would not be in town on October 3 but will be available in November. The next meeting
will be November 6th.
XIL Advisory Committee Comments:
XIII. Next Meeting Date:
a. BCC/CRA/MSTU Joint Workshop May 3, 2022 9am BCC Boardroom
b. October 3, 2022 @ 3:30pm TBD
XIV. Adjournment: 5:00 pm
Roy Wilson, Chairman
Packet Pg. 463
21.A.2
Item 7b
Collier County Waterway Debris Summary
Project Overview
The tidal waterway debris removal in Collier County is being performed by the State of Florida through
the Florida Department of Emergency Management (FDEM) for potential reimbursement by FEMA.
These areas fall under Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) jurisdiction for
maintenance, but they have deferred that responsibility to FDEM. This State run project benefits Collier
County tremendously as there is no up -front payment for this nor lengthy application and eligibility
process, nor is there a County managed project stretching our recovery resources. The tidal waterways
effort includes the collection of wet debris consisting of vegetation, C&D materials and white goods, as
well as vehicles and vessels. Each has specific handling requirements and disposal protocols which are
being handled by AshBritt Inc. with a transfer site in Collier.
The inland waterways normally managed by Stormwater Management and Road Maintenance fall under a
different category and reimbursement funding has been requested through the Natural Resources
Conservation Service (NRCS) under their Emergency Watershed Protection program. While that program
may take a few more weeks to secure funding ahead of mobilization, it is well advanced with our
application first in line for Hurricane Ian requests.
Displaced or derelict vessels traditionally handled by FWC, are under an extended adjudication period to
enable owners more time to make their own arrangements for recovery or provide waivers so they may be
removed under the derelict vessels guidelines. Due to the lengthy processing, they will be released to the
contractor one at a time for removal with the first batch of 5 under way. Vehicles are following a similar
path, but need a dedicated site for staging with very particular requirements that is still in the procurement
and approval phase that we expect to be quickly completed.
Stormwater Management has provided highly detailed surface mapping of debris throughout County
waters, while City of Naples and Marco Island have done their own assessments to augment the database.
Coastal Zone Management has also provided extensive drone footage that helps pinpoint debris,
particularly in the mangrove preserves to assist with mechanical and hand removal as required; FDEP
Field Authorizations for this work are already in place. We requested a WebEOC Mission for sub -surface
sonar scanning of our tidal waterways for which FDEM responded by facilitating numerous other
Counties' agencies to respond with their marine units under reciprocal agreements throughout the State.
The subsurface data is linked here: Collier Sonar Survey. All in all, we have an extensive and
comprehensive debris map for the contractors to follow, supplanted daily by reports from our citizens.
The volume of debris involved indicates the SW Florida effort will take a very long time during which we
will need patience as this is an expensive and painstaking process. Progress may be monitored through the
Waterway Debris Dashboard which currently includes a map of the tri-county impact area collection
points, but is being modified just for Collier County with a Google Earth based submerged debris map
available here: Ian Submerged Debris Map. Currently, 2 barges are deployed in Collier County waters,
working North to South with a third just come on-line in the City of Naples in Venetian Bay. We are
working to mobilize in Marco Island and Isles of Capri in the coming weeks; Everglades City and
Plantation Island will follow.
Packet Pg. 464
21.A.2
We also have our own mailbox for residents to apprise us of concerns where we document all comments
and photographs as well as respond to all questions: WaterwayDebrisgCollierCountyFL.gov Debris
type and location information is shared with the debris contactor.
Finally, it should be restated that while the Capital Project Planning Division is the Collier County
Waterway Debris Project Manager, supporting the interests of the incorporated areas under the interlocal
agreements, this is a State run project paid for by the State of Florida. We have been exhaustive in our
efforts to accelerate mobilization and response, championing the needs of our community. The work
performed to date has radiated out from the areas most severely affected, and while individual efforts
have been highly productive, the overall scale is mind -boggling by every metric.
Current Status 6th January 2023
Derelict Vessels 5 removed with additional 9 pending FWC approval.
Vehicles Identified 3 in the City of Naples and one in Water Turkey Bay. Removal in a couple or three
of weeks with delays due to regulatory issues now resolved.
Wet Debris Staging in the north of the County with 2 barges recommenced as a 7 day a week operation
after the holidays. City of Naples work commenced today with access through Doctors Pass into Venetian
Bay and possible mobilization into Naples Bay from Naples Landing coming soon.
NRCS reimbursement funding for the inland waterways is not yet confirmed. Contractor is standing by. It
is our expectation that any flooding concerns are mitigated prior to the onset of rainy season in mid May.
Haldeman Creek
Bayshore Drive is the dividing line between the eastern Inland and western Tidal areas. An emergency
mangrove field authorization has been obtained from the FDEP to permit debris recovery.
Westward, all debris will be removed by the Florida Department of Emergency Management run
operation and includes all wet debris, vessels, and vehicles if any are found, extending into the mangrove
fringe. Initially, what is recoverable by barge with a hydraulic arm will be collected in the first run, while
manual efforts will be employed beyond. This is complicated by the shallow depths, oyster bars and
physical limitations of walking into the mangroves as Hurricane Irma cleanup volunteers will attest.
Submerged debris, to the extent it is found, will also be removed. Work extends to Naples Bay.
Eastward, all wet debris will be removed to the high water mark and will also address wind blown
vegetation and leaning trees considered eligible as potential flood hazards, extending into the mangrove
fringe. Work extends to the north of US 41 along Palm Dr and also into the Glades Country Club.
There is no dredging activity associated with either of the efforts.
Post Hurricane Ian surveys found sufficient debris in the Inland Waters to warrant removal to reduce
potential flooding risks as defined in the Emergency Watershed Protection Program administered by
NRCS, while all emergency work has already been completed Countywide. The reimbursement program
requires a 25% participation by Collier County upon approval by the BCC of an award with the process
taking a number of months to complete. Should funding not be available, FEMA reimbursement will be
sought in order that work be completed before rainy season.
Packet Pg. 465
lw�E r
III
�'r/r*F-`�`���""'� � ' ' Yr[\� ' je, , . � :.,a 1 ,ii� �,#+-£•n "� i !, }'Ya'flf�A;'a0c'�
4 T
Ell
Al
A �5 It C° -
�.:
di
it JtlFtgri ,wf ;
,y.
'1 :'�, ° �. �1 1 a, raaa s�1.$j�� �- �y4°..l• p�� � - � ' 3".'�"r. '� �'+��
• a�.Vn� I Qalp�SB
o _ ii! f "�5�,{Y� •rn y 35 r 6^5 y �'dl µ' I a yp�
�� It-
K Yl'. ,yam y3a�
f ar. J.S.1 .: ^,alfi�i -"''L b rim ' ''� E • - r
c J
yn��'I►F'
r a !s d
.y �Yf r .�r" ,r.M,a emmma,Ai 1Z f��1 YSl .Al
!,� � E"�iii+^'� j , ✓ � I "_,<y/ '—a` � °?JR y y� '' �}" � �p tads
w `�'S' p+�� �:� .\ k �'� � P..0 ` °d.� �%y..�!M�fs. , `fa✓'..,,�4Z�S.n' �7. �`Ifr
gj„12
.xS a Wes �
rm w.w ixY�ka • i.
.41
"x 5 ,yRFT
t1
C
kA
6 ai
� C
co U
co =
cra �
•
L
0
co di
m I
ra ua
CO 4O
ro -0
co
i
Ln
w
Ln
Ln
w
C
O
4-1
V
O
J
�Ly
W
M
4-0
CD
J
cu
1
0
E
W
h
w
❑
tn
4/yyV
LEI
V
z
L4-
r
�
, weaopmAaign-aIm°1
L
CL W
0 4-
M
L`
O
C
u
ZH CL
z
O
L +�
� +r
C
L
EL
:��+.
z 0
■
10
co
L
a
M
0
4may
f 1 J
r
4-
aL--
r
�
9uiWjedpe�ztnj1 Itn°1
21
7
0
E
V
1�
V0►Y
m
4-1
CN
E
:;
o
0
qqr
r�
zV
AJOSIApv n.Lsw 400jo uemopleH W;K) EZOZ-6-6104Oed epu06y MOOJO ueuaOpleH :;u0uay3L'jjV 00
to
ice. in
F { be
CNN
Ln
N 1
Ln
Mynii o� :
� n
1� M,�. 0 Ill
ko
cn
Woo 0
in k
I N .. F• n 00 I ..
�F N`H� A
•, inLF
at
M N OQ OQ 00.00 * I
Goo 4W co. r v+ ao
y
th
-� o s
_ 7Lnrl t
a '� a7 N �D 1 L.L r
7 a TA
ID ri
L f J
D to p
❑ 1
m r
a ni 0
M 47 E x0 i Q{ » 1
x E {p r
a x Q D rl
cc
a E o Q, CD
a g 0 a as ° —'' co
CL 41 ro �
Gcu Q N itr
i E ~
to `n
•� �' f4 a 1. N N N
r m of to D
IL
VIA
21.A.2
Point 35: Windblown vegetation.
M
N
O
N
C
L
3
R
as
r
LO
It
N
M
N
O
N
r
d
IL
c
a�
a�
a
L
U
c
E
d
R
2
r
c
d
E
t
R
r
w
Q
Packet Pg. 471
Lit
All
Oil
c .f 1t A 4
:{a s
21.A.2
Point 53: Submerged vegetation.
M
N
O
N
C
L
3
R
as
r
LO
It
N
M
N
O
N
r
d
IL
c
a�
a�
a
L
U
c
E
d
R
2
r
c
d
E
t
R
r
w
Q
Packet Pg. 473
21.A.2
Point 103: Submerged debris.
M
N
O
N
C
L
3
R
E
E
0
U
L
0
Q
U)
G
0
0
L
U
c
E
d
R
2
as
r
LO
N
M
N
O
N
r
d
Y
V
R
IL
c
a�
a�
a
a�
a�
L
U
c
E
0
R
2
c
m
E
t
R
r
w
Q
Packet Pg. 474
w
� a
V
t. lb- w
ur
• � _ � v •r
r
r, ~ 1 t
~'
few so
o , "I
Y li
4
�AssNam jr I �,
...slow V
i. •1aw1 a-.• -
t Iasi a { IV sera, M - �� 1 � � •�.�'� �� ,
goal a
IF
�� , moo' �, • '� � ��
L to
rm .a A►•� •100
N►NJ•af� , ,i Q ..
AWN IL
Via-=--1; �+'� +"' 4) � ` � •
s Q
1��e • _ L
� �v O � �' � �.. • ��' .-, w,u ... a �� 0. �� �•-
21.A.2
Item 7d
�2__1*1irrvP-jo-�
Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA ■Bayshore Beautification MSTU
Haldeman Creek MSTU
Haldeman Creek MSTU Advisory Committee 2023 Calendar
Meetings are held on the first Monday of each month at 3:30 PM unless otherwise notified.
Meeting Agendas will be posted online at www.bayshorecra.com at least one week prior to the meeting.
■ January 9, 2023 — 2nd Monday of the month due to New Year's Holiday TBD
■ February 6, 2023 TBD
■ March 6, 2023 — TBD
■ April 3, 2023 - TBD
■ May 1, 2023- TBD
■ May 2, 2023 — BCC/CRA/MSTU Workshop @ 9:00 a.m. TBD
■ June 5, 2023 — Summer Break
■ July 10 ,2023 —Summer Break
■ August 7, 2023 - Summer Break
■ September 11, 2023- Summer Break
■ October 2, 2023 —TBD
■ November 6, 2023 TBD
■ December 4, 2023 TBD
BCC Holiday Schedule 2023
The Board of County Commissioners recognizes the following holidays in 2023, observed on the dates listed below:
• New Year's Day
• Martin Luther King, Jr. Day
• President's Day
• Memorial Day
• Independence Day
• Labor Day
• Veteran's Day
• Thanksgiving Day
• Day After Thanksgiving
Monday, January 2, 2023(observed)
Monday, January 16, 2023
Monday, February 20, 2023
Monday, May 29, 2023
Tuesday, July 4, 2023
Monday, September 4, 2023
Friday, November 10, 2023(Observed)
Thursday, November 23, 2023
Friday, November 24, 2023
• Christmas Eve Friday, December 23, 2023
• Christmas Day Monday, December 25, 2022
Offices: 3299 Tamiami Trail E, Unit 103, Naples, Florida 34112
Phone: 239-252-884
Packet Pg. 477
N
d
r
CV
I
AJOSIApv n-Lsw meejo ueWapIEH : MK) £ZOZ-6-6 IOMOBd epu86d 1408JO ueuaapIBH :IUOWL13e}}d
.N
G
Q
U
(1)
d
'o
L
a
,1
AJOSIApv n-Lsw meejo ueWapIEH : MK) £ZOZ-6-6 IOMOBd epu86d 1408JO ueuaapIBH :IUOWL13844V
N
d
r
N
H
Z
LU
H
Z
O
U
LL
O
LU
J
m
Q
H
m
Ln
�o
I�l
00
a)
ca
ca
s=
o
�
'bn
'o
v
Of
L
a
N
>
U
�
—
a-'
U
N
S✓
Ca
o
N
�
�
c
S✓
'(6
C:
0
Q1
�--+
Q)
V
0
bn
-
m
z
m
aA
�
Q
_0
o
v
v
Ln
Q
C�
o
0
v
ro
ru
dJ
N
a)Q)
N
'E
N
�'
rl
Q
co
C7
C7
0
2
m
2
1 J
x
I
AJOSInpv nlgw Maaa0 ueuaapleH : 6 M Z) CZOZ-6- 6 10313ed epua6)y Maaa3 ueuaapleH :;uOwt43e;;d
I
CT
IN,
Wid
if
Bsyshora DR 0
I
z vi
C �0
O C
O
3 t
r
(4
N
i
O T
6
Un
7
OA C
C
•7
N � �`p
C
T
O '�
(•Ij OU LL
N C col-
C_
E u
0 COa v
F o t
C
v c F
o
o o ^
o
uu i N
an vi O
u >. �6 C-
C C m
m 7E
i O i
L Y Ov
C_ o O
N
-O p c a,
O
Y O >
C a,
-0 -
3 Q
a,
T o
t U
coL
N ai
O CC0 of
s
KI E m i
N aj Q o aJ
aJ .N
s co
�
N a
N
a v
N
o
O - a
a
- a
o
00
O -1
O - C
A) coQ O
- C-
-O i >.cc—
a)M�n
L.J
a nn
O o 0
L LL
a
CA v a, 3 am
s -6
-6 u
CAa > en C—m
_ u a,
C +o v c L M
GJ a
3 a, n
Op
is -o -o aJ a
• o t
C N C Y
u
a Y
C
ci.c
a a a
c E co
n i
C
+
O a t O �_ o
f— N
to
M o �o Y U
E aJ
O O L
l0 V, ++ am ++
O
U m a
E
O
a,
..
E
c
v
Q
o
o
V
V
u
C
C
u
H N
C
of
i
W U_
O
i i
cn
O >
~
CC:
o
i
>
O N
Y
z
O CA
<+'
U
QJ
C�0
Z
p
N
O
L
L
N
N
a)
t/
a-C
+'
ti
�
r 4
Co
C
�
Q
i
N
C
in
co
N
r0+ u
N
\
O
c-1
ca
2
GJ
++
Ou
L
Q�
cl�
U
Ln
V
O
E +�+
cV
l\O
G
N
�
-0
O
(0
f6
VI
>
M
N
C
++ f0
\
Ln
cu
E
v�f
O
W
C
Q
N
u
O
N
LU N
aJ
M
c I
O
OC
O
CA
O
i
L
Y
a-'
U
..
N
QJ
V)
a)
N
+'
+'
N
N
++ CU
M
to
L
c
a,
a
M
O
Q-
3
Lh
Cp
O%
U
y
N
N
i
f�0
GJ
>
CA
>
G
RT
O
1n
3
o
C
co
4J
Q
o
L
0
O
0)
L
O
to
o
L3
N
+�+
�n
O C
c\
O
Q
L
a
U
�#
p
c
U
m
O
U
o
bb
C
U
Q
i
Q1
Al
u
y
` I
N
M
111
N }'
-a
V
Q
i
O
L.
O
O
0.co
M
cB
cB
cB
cB
cB
O
�u<coZuLu
O L-
O
O
O
0
1L0.
��
O
co
a
i
U
M
a
W
AJOSIApv nisw mOOJO UBWOPIEH : M-W £ZOZ-6-6 IOMOBd epu86d MOOJO UBWOPIBH :}UOWL138}4d
N
d
r
N
� I
-
L
•�j -
-
4-1
-
r�
Y
a
1
•
0
•.,,��
Y`
r
-
tom[
'
dk
T
AMC
•
•
•
A•
-"�'�
CU
LL
r•
�..
•
• •
,�T
+..�- •ti.'f�,.
.-
w of
•
Y
Y Y
ram'{•
S
�S - �
rn
Y Y
(i
■* •
Y.
Y
1. �r ,. s.�
*a
re .�'-...
.�
ywlc'�
_
a
� .. "'Y' ;•.' "dye
^ '-" r. '� •
. .� y
_
.
•
-
� a
'
r _
Pt
ff4 / i
Ai
•
•■
�
Y
• .
1-4
•' a!
Q
�
N
c
C
U
C
O
[B
u
>
L
GA
C
U
V�
�
:55
m
U
F
.�
O
O
L
N
Q
N
4 -+
a1
V)
O
N
V)
(Z
rn
co
m
m
[B
ro
m
c
N
_0
C
C
0
V
v
�I
—u
s
E
a)
>
C
O
C
(-J
U
++
n
aJ
>
•L
U
bA
•V)
N
co
L
2
>,
4--+
CiA
cB
Q
U
aJ
O
N
C
/
GJ
Q
O�
N
O
O
O c Q
�
0
l0
V)
cn
O ate+ \
z
4Z
i
v
Ln Ul
`�
m cn
ro
-O
a�
O
G1
C�j
~LL
v
a1
O
0
v
n
dJro
Q
N
O
Q
O
i
dA
L
L
Q
O
aJ
{/) .O m
L
N
U
C
L
E
_0
V
Ln
O
(6
p
O
C�
Lu O
d
aJ
i
x*
2
L
(A
C
o
v
v v
°
v
v
to
U
Oaro
U
Ln
>
°i
Cof
> 75
m
ON
bo
C
OU
C
A
�
C
u
Z-
O
-
U
m
Q
O
L
L
o
L
(n
m
w L w
i
0-(A
a
LL
a
a
Y°
�
Lu
O Q C7
Z
Y
u
m
uw
N
d
N
E
O
cn
O
V`♦
m
co
UOSIApv n-Lsw )iaaao uuwOPIBH 6MPZ) £ZOZ-6-6 M
�jI.
i
_ Aw
mrW au � nn �' yr eou •
I I �
VAPI,
3ed epu86d 3408JO ueuaapIBH :}uauiy3844V
O
�
U
>
o
N
O
�
�
M
O
O
+,
O
O
O
O
O
O
t10
Q
o
�
N
}
O
M
o
�
O
O
N
M
4-
-0
bA
C
to
-a
O
—
cB
ri
c
O
0
w
L
m
O
Q
O
"0
m
O
O
4+
O
O
O
O
QU
0
.`^
v>
O
C
L
4-1
�
N
X
E
�
-0
L
N
bA
O
N
cB
t
E
GJ
Ln
�
O
0
w
U
U
m
C
ca
Ln
Ln
N
4
v
E
>vi
i
C
O
n
kh
C
C
Q
N
N
N
Ut.DO
N
GJ
'a
pp
O
?
O
N
Q
O
i
H
cn
U
LA
C
3
°
+�
o
N
Ln
N
L
�
m
c>
O
>
O
z
O
N
+`+
b00
N
oa
i
"
a
-
4
o
M
D
CO
r
`�
°
a°Ji
a
�
ri
M
v
tCo
cn
3
0
+O+
to
ca
I
i
0
V
G
CC
m
i
-W
�
0
�
O
N
GJ
\
o
u0
0
O
L:
L
3
u
z
O
O
U
C^
U
d
d�
U
'
c
b
p,p
u
i
C
C
N
U
w
W
Vf
dA
.N
++
G
0
c
tea
Q
0
c
U
m
c
O
3
v
a_
O
v
t
o
0
U
d
LL
J
U
a
a s
U
Q
U
H
U
0
O
CD
o�
Om
o
O
•
O
E
L
i
i
ba
�
c.i
H
do
VIhi
N
co
a
a
U
m
a
W
Ell
Ell
N
d
r
N
AJOSInpv n1SW M00aO UeWOpleH : W;VZ) £ZOZ-6-� 10M0ed epu06V M00aO UeWOpleH :;UGWL43eI4V
oil
Ln
rn
N
a�
U
�
O
N
Q
O
0
�
r-I
�
cc
a)
m
Om
0
'
o
L
Q
Qv
L
v
,
v
.N
m
mo
O
c
a)
c
v
cn
C
m
t
E
Q
v
U
L
w
L
O
L
a
LnO
a0o
o
Q
i
LAo
O
O
U
o
�
N
w
cn
a
_
Ln
C
L
C�
C
Q
L
E
L
U
E
O
O
—
+
N
N
Q
Q
O
U
O
C
�
�
C
J
QC
0
L
C
m
Q
O
co
UG1
N
v
L
U
b
bp
L
(�
W
(n
CO
++
U
-I--
i~
N
N
N
n
Y
C
41
U
in
L
LLn
4a
m
c
M
LL
a)
v
a
f°
00
,�
3 r�
o
c
v
L
�
Co
O
N
O
L
++
Q
C
iii
C
Y
U
O
u1
O
O
v
0
+'
,�
O uw
L
O
++
CA4J
U
0
4a
0
0
L
CAU
v u
Z
V
a
O
O
V
>
O
C
L 4-1{�
c
E
U
N
3
Q
iO0-
C
V<L
NG1
OO
Q
0
u
a
LL—j
U
k'ateA•''
0
0
0
C)
0
CD
4-0
O
O
E
V
V
to
H
a
0
V
W
Ell
Ell
q
¥
C14
O@Apv n1Sm Ma JQ ueWameH:GL5 Z EZ Z 6 � 9MDed epueBV Mae
I I
10UeWemeH:ueWL43q;
e
/
»
w
>
4.1
\
/
b
LL
2
o
4-
\
\
2
�
m
Z
\
u
/
\
-
2
o
E
2
e 0
E
w
/ o
g
e
§
/
\
=5
3 2
>
=
a
'/
0
°
\
�
\
#
u
n o
#
§
/
[
\
/ Q)
2
a
o
%
±
§
%
o./
)
u
§
_
$ 2
o
e
®
\
o
LL
® _
-
c
C: ®
±
®
LLJ
\
) /
\
\
/:
CU
% _
*
0
k
0
g
o
<
/
E
f
§ §
0
®_
E
2
I</
u
k
u
y
�
. .
.
.
.
#
I
&
E
/
o
ƒ�
$
<
/u
w
/
q
0
2
\
\
c
$
c
E
I
E
2
w
/
/
/
E /
°
u
»
E
on
/
%
\
7
ƒ
*
#
2
/
/
-
g )
-0Ul
$
.
J
R /
\
§
m
LL
j
g g/
c
m
oc
2
2
g
F«
o
/
/
0
LA
4-
.
CA
011
Q a
c
2
41
W
k
c
o
o
v
o
2 .
g
%
§
:
E
'
2
c
«
g
« E
'
»
2
v
a
LL
v
a/
o«
C
o
0
CD
�
o
C')
4-0
�
-WO
t
u
_
.t
c
a-
D
V
W
1:1|
1:1|
N
d
r
N
V.
rig
L J
x
i
AJOSInpv nlgw Maaa0 UBWGPIeH : 6MPZ) CZOZ-6-6 10313ed ePUOBV 3,aaa3 UeWGPIeH :}UOWLI3elW
4-
0
o
"a
o
O
U
N
L
;—,
c
M
a)
U
N
Ox
M
Q
N
0
0
J
cB
C
O
U
O
a•:,
cB
O
o
U
L
4�
a
C:
f6
U
�
Q)
o
f6
+'
C
QJ
E
N
U
ate•+
N
O
cB
+
U
L
L
UA
Q4-
C
Q
C�C
b
U
C
0
>
Q)
(n
o
M
U-
+-,
C
QJ
bo
Lan)E
'�
a)m
N
OC
C
QJ
>
}'
-0
0
0
C:
O
a�
a,
c
o
i
U
'?
f
>
U
a)
ca
N
O
vI
+J
C
o
c0
O
N
c
•Qi
U
L
O
UO
O
U
O
m
L
7
L
i
�-•,
�
O
Q
N
v
�
-0
-
O
-a
(Q
Q)
-0L
+-,
o
L
p
O
Q
a)
a
U
0
3
Q)
a,
O
>
O
of
C_
U
O
co
O
i
0
'It(6
W
E�
u
N
Q-
Q
CO
-0
41
3
>
a)
v°
o
z
�'
o
f
a�
O
t
4-
N
O
N
+
O
N
Q!
M
Q Q
.N—I
O
O C
L
N
> .v
O
N
(U -0
a)
I
U
CD
LA c
a1
in O
C
-
ra
ra N
ru
o
CO
>
I
L
v
_0
�
t to
U
O
+O+
GJ
o
OC
i!
U 0
O
O
N
r4
U
of
in
0
C
(J
L t
L
Co
O
0
x
+ra
� in
M
ccu
-C
a1
o m
a)O
N
U�
,
lD
a!
cC
C
Q 4
C
U
L
L
a
N
O
v
a
4-0D
�
O
},
O
dA
C
O
E
QJ
V)-0
0.tNi�
O
co
m
pip
C
a)
o
O
t0
N O
(B
o _0
E
O
cC
CD
O
L
a v
>
O
OD
L
V
L
3
QJ m
�..,
Q1
QJ
U
Q �
Q-0
+0+
>`
LO
C
_
a)
0
O
Ln
Q#
O ccu
'
G
p
L
=
Q 2
Q-
E
wIn
W
O N
(
iy
,
O 0
(A
O
O
>
N
A
r-I
O
rl
N
N
w
w
+U
w O
HQJ
QV OOA
yN
QU C
t
L
a)
Q
Q
OO
COW
3 L
t O
M-
t
L 3
Mpv
t
+
U.
iE'
D
OC
c�
a
LL a
a s i
a
am
a0.
m
a
U
LO
co
a
m
U
m
IL
W
C�
�
C14
E�
AJomAp¥ nISW ma jo uememeH: M Z EZ Z 6 �I MOB d BPU86V 1408Jg uememeH:} eWL138 n¥
I
\�
a
7|�
2
4�
o
k
k /
§
� §
2
7
E
7
3
m
[
LID
.
\ �
ƒ
q
2
£
y
2
@ m
cr-
qLn
V,
06
O
£
o
u
§
4-1
2
-
/
2CLu
co
S
��
tD
%
4-0
E
2
01
/
o
Lr-
5
Cr ®
,
0
�
2
$
2
r
Ln
0
ofN
v
q
E
Ln
'
§
s
\
q
�
\
t
tA
t
o-
.- c
/
/
\
7
CA
a_
£
C
C:
a-
\
/
9
Q)
2
2
'§
°
�
/
ƒ
\
ƒ
«
ƒ
§
�
ƒ
06
§
N
Ln
N
f
%2
c
®
/
/
/
m
m
/
./
°
.§
k
2
k
/
/
#
^
bO
/
C
/
Lu
�
2
\
c
-
k
J
®
2®\
n
c
.,
0
7
2/
g
a)
a
J
3
¥
/
.g
4
G
0
±
/
§
k
=
m.
o
v¥
v
2
k
G
3
o
c
�
.g
—
—
§
/
k
k
S
4
�\\
v
J
«
L
$
m
°
E.
®
—
:
�.
.
§
0a\
k
0«
�
0
b
�
W
N
d
N
1_
1
Fm
i
O
s
AJOSInpv n1SW MGGJO ueWOPIeH : W;VZ) £ZOZ-6-� 10MOed er
ua6Vy MGOJO ueWGPIeH :IUGWL43eUV
°
>
o
U
O
O
M
C)
(1)
rl
16
O
N
LO
Q
Q
O
N
O
0
m
L.L
a)
ca
Q
co
C
O
0
L
O
a)
O
O
C
a)
N
O
O
+-
Ul
O
L
o
O
=
>
�
�
Oo
O
3
�
m
N
`�
0
Ol
O
L
L
O
O
�
N
_
L
V
L
a
'n3
i
>
L
N
E
Q
M
N
v
O
U
N
O
L
C
N
O
a)
U
a)
L
O
N
v
O
C
O
N
m
N
a)
ul
U
Q
O
�_
a)
�
O
9
O
+'
O
(B
(B
N
a)
L
a)
L
rl
U
>
O
N
U
L
>
h0
a)
41
(U
-�-
>
a)
w
bA
C
L
OM
C
o
O
L
O
L
a>
>tA
a
co
3
W
C
C
O
0tjo
r_
to
-
a)
�
Q
O
�--+
Q
to
)
N
C)
v�
to
O
to
a)
—
O
m
L
>
t
v
Q
v
0
O
U
In
O
>
N
�
>_
N
j
N
a)
2
(1)
(1)
Q
C
C
U
aJ
—
U
+�
u(1)
o
+�
��
O
0
Q
aAQao�
a)
Q
o06
E�
OU
N
�
U
c)
-(
L
u
aJ
4-
4-
C
O
cam.)
�n C
O
c�
L
O
L
Q Q
00
O
O {I}
L
C
1=
m bA
>
C
a)Lnm
O
c 2
.cn. m
C C
u
O
u
U
N
O
>
0
N
c6
L
—
m
+�
O
Q
v u
z
H
v1
O
N
a)
+'
+1
I
C
a�
5
L
0
Ln
>-
L
v
>
0
m
L�
O
m
O
U
'W
C
-a
t
Qj
O
U >
+L+
C ca
v
L
C
G—
U
L
m
q*
a0
c
to
a
00 �
m
3 C
a
�O
N
U
U
C1A
U
L
o
N
U m
O
N
i c
Q Q
O
L
v
:6
v
u
v E
4
M m
U
0
C
N N
G
D
a
3
�
a
bA
a 'L
J��
Z
W
O
k
W
V
W
C�
�
C14
e
■
I
O@Apv n1Sm Ma JQ ueWameH:GL5 Z [z0Z 6 � 9MDed epueBV Ma aQ ueWemeH:UGW L43q;
_0
0
/
0
4.1
.
s
u
E
E
Q
4-1
E
\
�
/
ƒ
Q
�
E
E
/
/
4.1
Ln
o
e
./
)
$
k
E
TA
)^
±
k
t
§
0
ƒ
�
0
�
0
o
\
w
w
°
$
«
g
=
q
V)
o
y
\
3
kƒ\/
�
0
0
0
k
\
�4-
0
.E
2
0
e
e
y
�
.
.
.
#
I
E
I
CL
\
c
/ 2
&
0)
\
[
0 2
\
2
§
o
\ /
f
[ %
/
\
/
2
\
2
I
n
e
w
04
c
°
g
&
/
ƒ
0.
4-
ƒ
o
0
\
u
\k
0
£ c-
0
CO
¥
0
u
/
0
/
v
.
E
o
I
E
m
s
)
$
2
/
a
o
m
2
c°
n
0
§
\
/
2
k
k
:
k
Ln
4
o
k
'
:
0
' /
/
v v
/
c
v
\q
g
u
§;
E
vOt
'
c
«
■
'
I
»
o«
2
o
a
LL
u
a 0
3
C
0
0
0
0
0
0
4-0
�
O
E
u
�
2
E
�
c
�
�
V
W
q
21.A.2
Fund 164 Haldeman Creek MSTU Item 8b
Fund / Comm Item
BCC Adopt Budget
Tot Amend Budget
Commitment
Actual
Available
**** Grand Total -Fund/ CI
8,962.50
146,509.56-
137,547.06
*** 164 HALDEMAN CREEK MSTU
8,962.50
146,509.56-
137,547.06
** REVENUE Sub Total
1,043,700.00-
1,052,112.50-
150,537.15-
901,575.35-
* REVENUE - OPERATING Su
192,000.00-
192,000.00-
150,444.42-
41,555.58-
311100 CUR AD VALORE
188,600.00-
188,600.00-
148,201.54-
40,398.46-
361170 OVERNIGHT INT
1,388.24-
1,388.24
361180 INVESTMENT IN
3,400.00-
3,400.00-
854.64-
2,545.36-
361320 INTEREST TAX
* CONTRIBUTION AND TRANS
851,700.00-
860,112.50-
92.73-
860,019.77-
486600 TRANS FROM PR
92.73-
92.73
486700 TRANS FROM TA
489200 CARRY FORWARD
861,300.00-
861,300.00-
861,300.00-
489201 CARRY FORWARD
8,412.50-
8,412.50-
489900 NEG 5% EST RE
9,600.00
9,600.00
9,600.00
** EXPENSE Sub Total
1,043,700.00
1,052,112.50
8,962.50
4,027.59
1,039,122.41
* OPERATING EXPENSE
21,300.00
29,712.50
8,962.50
250.00
20,500.00
631400 ENG FEES
8,412.50
8,412.50
634970 INDIRECT COST
500.00
500.00
250.00
250.00
634980 INTERDEPT PAY
500.00
500.00
500.00
634999 OTHER CONTRAC
20,000.00
20,000.00
20,000.00
645100 INSURANCE GEN
300.00
300.00
300.00
* TRANSFERS
11,300.00
11,300.00
11,300.00
911870 TRANS TO 187
11,300.00
11,300.00
11,300.00
* TRANSFER CONST
6,500.00
6,500.00
3,777.59
2,722.41
930600 PA BUDGETTRANS
1,800.00
1,800.00
313.56
1,486.44
930700 TC BUDGETTRANS
4,700.00
4,700.00
3,464.03
1,235.97
* RESERVES
1,004,600.00
1,004,600.00
1,004,600.00
993000 RESV FOR CAPI
1,004,600.00
1,004,600.00
1,004,600.00
a
Packet Pg. 489
N
d
N
f11SW 3190aO ueuaapleH : 66GVZ) £ZOZ-6-6 303hed epua6d laaJO ueuaapleH :;u9w43e4lV
L
C6
O
�.
aJ
0
Q
O
U
N
c
O
.�
U
.O
L
O
•p
0
r
O
N
+�
+,
as O
LL
-C
N
U
cvj
rl
7
O
U
Vl
E
c
a)
cn
'—
>
L
a)
-0
aJ
v
v
a
(n
U
Q
O
M
a)
U
O
U
cV
0
Q
N
O
Nn3
t
N
U
_
O
C6
m
_0
L
(�
�
O
Co
3
o '
a
E
H U
21.A.3
to
Wgshurc•Qatcway—Triangle CRA •I34ysEibre BcautifiOtiofi �..15TU
Haldr.man Crcok MSTU
April 4, 2022 meeting minutes Item 4a
HALDEMAN CREEK MSTU MINUTES OF THE APRIL 4, 2022 MEETING
The meeting of the Haldeman Creek MSTU Advisory Committee was called to order by
Roy Wilson at 3:30 p.m. at 3299 Tamiami Trail E, 3rd Floor BCC Chambers, Naples, FL
34112.
I. Roll Call: Advisory Board Members Present: Chair, Roy Wilson, Robert
Wopperer, Bill Robbins and Jim King Jacob Dutry van Haeften.
MSTU Staff Present: Debrah Forester, CRA Director, and Shirley Garcia,
Operations Coordinator
II. Pledge of Allegiance- Was led by Roy Wilson
III. Adoption of Agenda: Robert Wopperer made a motion to approve the agenda as
amended, Jim King second. Approved unanimously.
IV. Adoption of Minutes: Robert Wopperer made a motion to approve the minutes, Jim
King second, approved unanimously.
V. Community / Business -- Presentations
a. PL20220000731 - Regatta Landings, Turrell, Hall & Associates, - Joshua
Maxwell presented the dock extension amendment that was being requested to the
County to amend the boat size requirement. The community is at the point where they
need some nicer boats with amenities, but the width requirement is so restrictive that
would discourage people from buying into their community. The current agreement
was for a maximum width of the boat to be 10.5 and they would like to have that
modified. The request is to remove the 10.5 maximum beam width and The proposed
modifications are the BDE's per boat dock accordingly to the chart below:
1 19ft
14
14.9It
2 16.3ft
15
14.9ft
3 14Sf1
16
15.4ft
4 112ft
17
16.2ft
5 10.6ft
18
16.3ft
6 11.Gft
19
15.2ft
7 12R
2l1
123ft
8 12.5ft
21
12.3ft
9 USA
22
17.7ft
10 14.6(t
23
18.3ft
11 14.7ft
24
18.3ft
12 12.2ft
25
17.71t
13 12.2ft
26
16.1ft
Packet Pg. 4 1771
21.A.3
Diysh rc;Qateway Triangle CRA •BagshorcBcxntifcation MSTU
Haldeman Creek MSTU
After much discussion, Bill Robbins made a motion to support the modification to
amend their application to limit max beam width up to 13ft. and no slip should stick
beyond the pre -approved boat extension line. Jim King, second. Jaap Dutry van
Haeften and Robert Wopperer both abstained from the motion due to conflict.
Approved unanimously.
VI. Old Business:
a. Bay Days Haldeman Creek Clean up -'Ms. Forester noted the attached power
point of the clean up at Haldeman Creek for the bay days
VII. New Business:
a. Mileage Neutral or Tax Neutral- Roy Wilson explained to the committee the
difference between Mileage Neutral and Tax Neutral. Jim King made a motion to
remain Mileage Neutral, second by Bill Robbins approved unanimously.
b. FY23 Priorities- Ms. Forester noted their budget for any priorities the committee
wanted to discuss now, Roy Wilson recommended continuing to save money and
come back to the priority Iist later. Mr. Robbins asked if homeowners could piggy-
back the dredging permit the CRA acquired, and Ms. Forester noted the home
owners could piggy back the permit to pull their own individual permit from the
County to dredge. Jaap Dutry van Haeften asked for a copy of the priority list the
committee received. Mr. Wilson asked staff to send the last priority list so the
committee could look it over and update it.
VIH. Staff Report:_
a. CRA Directors Report- Ms. Forester provided the report and asked if anyone
had any questions.
b. Project Manager Report- Ms. Forester provided the project managers report
if anyone had any questions.
c. Financials- Ms. Forester noted the tax revenues generated and reminded the
committee of the expansion of the boundary to include the Courthouse Shadows
Development.
IX. Correspondence and Communications:
a. Signage email response boating and waterways- Mr. Wilson had emailed
numerous photos of the damaged Signage in the creek, some were needing
replacement, some just needed to be straightened out. The staff will send it to
Coastal Zone Mgmt in the County to request new signs and set some of the pilings
upright again. Mr. Wilson also spoke about the manatee signs and would like to
request these manatee signs be put on the same poles as the other signage. The signs
are free from the Manatee Club, folks could pick up the signs and put it on their
docks as well.
Packet Pg. 492
21.A.3
Bayshore Gatmiy Tri-mg1c C RA *Bayshow Beautification MSTU
Haldeman Creek ms,ru
X. Public Comments: There was a question about dredging the drainage canal and Ms.
Forester noted the County had gone in there and cleaned it all out. Mr. Wilson noted
that the drainage canals is under their purview to dredge it out. He also asked about if a
weir was going in at Harvest Ct. and Ms. Forester responded that it was a county project
and she would email him a contact in the County to ask about their project.
XI. taft' Comments: Ms. Forester noted the joint workshop and the MSTU Chair
would sit at the table with the CRA and MSTU Chair but all is welcome to attend in the
audience. She also noted the next meeting as October 3, but can be changed. Mr. Wilson
would not be in town on October 3 but will be available in November. The next meeting
will be November 6th.
XII.
XIII. Next Mcgting Date:
a. BCCICRAIMSTU Joint Workshop May 3, 2022 gam BCC Boardroom
b. October 3, 2022 g 3:30pm TBD
XIV. Adjournment: 5:00 pm
14 AV
Roy Wilson, Chairman
Packet Pg. 493