Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Commissioner Hall
Ex parte Items - Commissioner Chris Hall COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AGENDA January 10, 2023 ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS 9A *** This Item to be heard following the completion of items under sections 11 and 12. *** This item requires that all participants be sworn in, and ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Recommendation to deny an Ordinance amending Ordinance Number 2004-41, as amended, the Collier County Land Development Code, by changing the zoning classification of the herein described real property from a Commercial Intermediate District (C-3) Zoning District to a Mixed Use Planned Unit Development (MPUD) Zoning District for the project to be known as Isles Of Capri MPUD, to allow construction of mixed -use development up to 168 feet in actual height including a maximum of 108 multi- family dwelling units, up to 10,000 square feet and 200 seats of restaurant and membership clubs, a marina including up to 64 wet slips, a 258-unit dry boat storage facility, and a ships store and dockmaster's office limited to 1,000 square feet, and 6,000 square feet of general offices, plus accessory indoor and outdoor recreation uses and parking structures without limitation. The subject property is located on the Isles of Capri on both north and south of Capri Boulevard, consisting of 5.32t acres; providing for repeal of Resolution No. 92-588 relating to setback variances and Resolution No. 93-370 relating to a parking variance for boat slips; and by providing an effective date. [PL20210002314] (This is a companion item to Item 9B, GMPA-PL20200002313 Isle of Capri Mixed Use Infill Subdistrict Growth Management Plan Amendment.) (District 1) ®Meetings ®Correspondence ®e-mails ®Calls All information has been filed electronically with Minutes and Records CONSENT AGENDA 16A9 This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve for recording the amended final plat of Maple Ridge at Ave Maria Phase 7B Replat, (Application Number PL20220003332) approval of the standard form Construction and Maintenance Agreement, and approval of the performance security in the total amount of $249,615.49. (District 5) ® NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SUMMARY AGENDA - NONE JarvisLouise Subject: Location: Start: End: Recurrence: Meeting Status: Organizer: Meeting w/Commissioner Hall re: Isle of Capri @Orange Blossom Office Thu 1/5/2023 9:00 AM Thu 1/5/2023 9:30 AM (none) Accepted Richard Yovanovich EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. JarvisLouise Subject: Location: Start: End: Recurrence: Meeting Status: Organizer: Required Attendees: Directions to Downtown Office: Commissioner Hall mtg Joan Coyne (SaveCapri.org) re: FCC applications PL20210002313 and PL20210002314 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 303 - BCC Conference Room Mon 12/12/2022 11:00 AM Mon 12/12/2022 11:30 AM (none) Accepted JarvisLouise HallChris The Board of County Commissioners offices are located in the Government Complex at 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 303, at the corner of Airport and Tamiami Trail East. HERE is a link to a map of the complex. If you're coming from the North or West, use the entrance off Airport (where the ROAD in Airport Road is on the map) and drive through the complex; if you're coming from the South/East, the entrance from the East Trail is the easiest (near U.S. 41 on the map). For most, it's best to use Parking Garage #2; there are handicapped spaces near Human Resources, Building B. Our offices are in Building F — County Admin on the map. You'll pass through a metal detector at the entrance to the building, and they'll direct you to the elevators to the 3rd floor from there. Be sure to allow time to park, walk to the building, and pass through security. Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. Capri Community Inc. 338 Capri Blvd, Fr MYE S FL, 3 Isles of Capri Naples, FL 34113 .22 Dom. 20 �A 22i . Commissioner Hall 3299 Tamiami Trail E, # 303 Naples, FL 341012 iii.. ,##..'�i tiii. fi it•7:i� •i!•°•� •:;i F.. i.�i.ii iii iii aii ?iii Ffi i i -J • it {••{°: iiiie•i• ii:rF:i! ir•• i t1 �. Is 3: f.t Deaf %'0r,,111lrj sivnel I r3r11.Uvriiin to'fOi[:. il?�/ UP{10$ttiC'i7':il l- ; �.:) G)l)sat:.�n'c l� c7Fi t:' rezone their propP_11y .on Isles-,v)f. C ap: i front C to a P ;tD. S;i%O-h ;; ;:h�„l e ,�;c;; ld 3!'nCt'it only the developer, not the Isles of Lapri cc,nr, luniry. "IL I.S to rr;itha;i to uOd me. ling, Please vo�,e's'?J` to .nis rezonir, ,i_i�:. � ^' ; ,e!;eve our Colliver County Impr�.:se,ita ives SITOUId bl'O:iC tO praiect ti it tostjtt1C�;.,s and place our interests above. Corporetp Profits. Signed: I'�arr.� and Address : _ v _:- Dear Commissioner: am writingto voice m .1 y opposition to FCC Corporation's plan to, rezone on Isles of Capri from C-3 to a PUD, Such a change would benefit only not the Isles of Capri community, their Property y the developer, it is better to build NOTHING than build the WRONG thing I" to Please vote 'NO' to this rezonin should work to protect their co n tpetition, I ituents, andieve our Placeour Collier County representatives profits, interests above corporate Signed: _ 1OA U d 1 1 i li Name and Address: IDear Commissioner: I am writing to voice my opposition to FCC Corporation's on Isles of Capri from G3 to a Opposition Plan to rezo not the Isles of Capri community, Such a change would benefit onl ne their property y the developer, "It is better to build NOTHING than build the WRONG thing, to Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning should work to protect their constituents, tpituents, abedlieve our Cc „_, profits. place our interestsNabovere entatives corporate Signed: Name and Dear Commissioner: i am writing to voice m on Isles of Capri from C 3 to PUoon to FCC, Corporation's not the Isles of Capri community. ,,DI Such a change would benefit only the de'velPlan to rezone o eerty p , "It is better to build NOTHING than build the WRONG an to thing! Please vote `NO' to this rezoning7. should work to protect their co etition. l believe our Collier Count re profits, t►tuents, an I,place our interests above corporate Signed: / A r' /-f/•, Name and Address: Y 3✓/ Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice my opposition to FCC Corporation on Isles of Capri from to a Pup s plan to rezone their pro not the Isles of Capri community, Such a change would benefit only the developperty er, "It is better to build NOTHING build the WRONG than thingi�� to Please Vote 'NO' to this rezoning rotect their co petition, I believe our Collier County representatives should work to p profits. ,and place our interests above corporate porate Name and Address: Dear C,omrriissioncr•: I arrr writing to voice ;ry opposition to FCC Corporation's la on Isles of Capri fron, C-.3 to a pip Such a chap not the Isles of C plan to rezone their proper Capri corr;:r•unity, ge Would benefit only the ye veloper it iS helter tot build NO buila the AIR�it�G j'Hif ltl,< n to Fiease votof `"C' to this rezoriing Petition, I �,Plieve our Coli; r shoulc wor:< to protect their Constitr2ents, and lace profits. e `-eur'rty representatives p our interests above, corporate Sgned• Mn r A i r•Iarna and Hddress: LA { A i 1p,4:,tii Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice my opposition to FCC I a Isles writing Capri from y to a Ptio Corporation'suld plan to rezone their property notthe Isles of Capri community. Such a change would benefit only the developer "It is better to build NOTHING than to g build the WRONG thin l„ 0 Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning should work to protect their co constituents/ I believe our Collier Count Profits, place our interests above pcorporate Name and Address: `r C�I—yi Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice my ii to to FCC Corporation's on Isles of Capri from to a tPlan to rezone their pro not the isles of Capri community, Such a change would benefit only the developeerty r, IT is better to build NOTHING than build the WRONG thing►II to Please Vote 'NO' to this rezoning petition. I believe our Collier County representatives should work to protect their constituents, and place our interest profits. s above corporate Signed; Name and Address: t Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice my opposition to FCC Corporation's y on Isles writing Capri from to a Pio g Such a change would benefit only the developerr, not the Isles of Capri community. plan to rezone their prop it is better to build NOTHING than to build the WRONG thin , g• Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning petition. I believe our Collier Count ect their constituents, and place our interests above corporate profits. y representatives p rate Signed: iii , Name and Address: -� ?� Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice my opposition to FCC Corporation's on Isles of Capri from to a Pio Such a change not the Isles of Capri community, plan to rezone their prope�y would benefit only the developer, "It is better to build NOTHING than build the WRONG thing, to Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning should work to protect their constituents, tpieuents, I believe our Collier Count Profits, place our interests above pcor or representatives corporate Signed:�� Name and Address: J Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice my opposition to FCC Cor on Isles of Capri from G3 to a PUD. Such a change poration'sPlan to rezone not the Isles of Capri co ge would benefit only the develo r prop erty r, p community, per, is better to build NOTHING t build the WRONG thin , than to g• Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning petition. I believe our Collier County representatives should work to protect their constituents, and place our interests above cor profits, ogned: porate lame and Address: � r -� Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice rn on Isles of Capri from C 3 to PUDn to FCC Corporation's not the Isles of Capri community, Such a change would benefit nne their property to roIy the developer, IT is better to build NOTHING than build the WRONG thingl,01 to Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning should work to protect their constituents, tpetition. I ituents, andieve our Collier Placeour interests rep resentatives presentatives above corporate Signed: ✓ ;�%`�L�/� vame and Address: %7 ��� Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice my opposition to FCC Cor on Isles of Capri from to a Pio Such a change po eationIs Plan to rezone their Property not the Isles of Capri Munity, would to only the developer, "It is better to build NOTHING than build the WRONG thing, to Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning should work to prot their constituents, tpietition I believe our our Collier County representatives porpOr atives interest, above corporate Signed: ivame and Address: �40) a c :,. Dear Commissioner: I am wrLiting to voice My tsl� i of Caprfrom C 3 ioPa Ption to FCC Corporation's plan to rezone their property not the Isles of Capri co UD, Such a change would benefit only the developer, it is better to build NOTHING t build the WRONG thin ,han to g• Please Vote'NO'tothis rezoning petition, I believe our Collier Count re presentatives profits, their constituents, and place our interests above should work to protect corporate Signed: A ZI _ I Name and AddressLop : ----- - %DLI 1 c �Y //3 Dear Commissioner: f am writing to voice my opposition to FCC Corporation's plan to rezone their on Isles of Capri fr6benefit only the de 6C-3 to a PUD, Such a change would bve not the Isles of Capri„community, propey toper, "It IS better to build NOTHING than to build the WRONG thing," Please vote IVOto this should work to protect profits, Signed Name and Address: n petition, I believe our Collier County representatives tituents, and place our interests above corporate n Dear Commissioner: I am writin to voice"m g y opposition to FCC Corporation's on ISI of Cap 'ri�frorn C_3 poration s not th Isles of Ca to a PUD. Such a chan a plan to rezone their pri community, g would benefit onl property y the developer, it is better to build NOTHING than to buildg the WRONG thingill Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning petition, I believe our Collier Count re profits, protect their c nstituents, and place our interests above corporaterepresentatives Signed: Name and Address: L �.�/ �0 U4t Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice my Oppositionwriting to FCC Corporation's not the Isles Of Capri co 3 to a PUD, Such a than plan to rezone their p mmunity, change would benefit onl Property y the developer, It is better to build NOTHIN build the G than to WRONG thing!' Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning should work to protect their constituents, tpieuents, I believe our Collier Count profits, and place our interests above corporate representatives corporate Signed: Jame and Address: Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice my o on Isles of Capri from C.3Opposition to FCC Corporation's not the Isles of Capri Community, tO a PUD. Such a change would benefit onlythe propery developer, It is better to build NOTHING G than to G thi build tWRONG ng►" Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning petition. I believe our Collier Count profits. protect their constituents, and pace our interests above corporate Signed: Name and Address: / r `eL s Dear Commissioner: rY T. y �y`f,�m +6h to -voice on Isles of Ca my Opposition to FCC Corporation , not the Isles OfCapri G3 to a PUD, such a change s plan to rezone their pri community. would benefit o property my the developer, It is better to build NOTHING build the WRONG thingl,) than to Please vote 'NO' to this rezonin should work to protect their co � Petition, I believe our Collier Count profits, ,and lace y representatives /j p our interests above corporate Signed: Name and Address: Deart,80.r jissioner: I am writing to voice my opposition to FCC Corporation's plan to rezone their property on Isles of Capri from G3 to a PUD. Such a change would benefit only the developer, not the Isles of Capri community. It is better to build NOTHING than to build the WRONG thing!" Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning petition. I believe our Collier County representatives should work to protect their constituents, and place our interests above corporate profits. Signed: d.• g Name and Address: Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice m on Isles i Ca y opposition to FCC Cor not the Isles pri from C-3 to a PUD. Such a cha po wouations plan to rezone Capri community, change would benefit only their property y the developer, IT IS better to build NOTHING than to build the WRONG thingl„ Please vote 'NO' to this rezonin should work to protect their constituents, Petition, I believe our Collier Count profits. ,and place our interests above representatives Signed: corporate Name and Address:(] gear l o:nrr;sS;c)j' !r: I am'vL•J'itir;� to voice ' on ISIeS of Capri my °ppcstion to FCC C Cor not the I fr.} r, C-3 to a PUn. po; a`i°;,'; plat? .� re °les of Capri `Omr,�tn„�y 5u,:h c+�arg< �e;;. ,. <<:►;e.their prope1ty Ic. kj' criy the dex;elopPr, . ►i ' better to a �u�id ;1NG tc �lI the 1t aONG tr'ingt-. "'�r� to (Vt�' e v..te Should work to o this r0>°Wing petition. I p ts. protCCt tileir CO!7St Petition, belieVe Ot7r ; {,Tier , {i a CLGn;'y J/J and puce our ioLerests �h corl� gate"Ies Signed: 11 % i Marge and gddress: FLU(( __ Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice my Oppositionwriting to FCC Corporation's Plan to not the Isles Capri from C-3 to a PUD. Such a change would benefit oonl rezone their Capri community, property y the developer, It is better to build NOTHING build the WRONG thin g•,than to Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning petition. I believe our Collier County representatives Profits, protect their constituents, and place our interests above co &/7/ rporatSigned: �,1JA e Name and`Address: I Dear'Commissioner: I am writing to voice rn on Isles writing Ca y opposition to FCC Corporation's plan to rezone their community, change would benefit only Propertyy the developer, It is better to build NOTHING build the WRONG thing, than to , Please vote `NO' to this rezoning Petition. I believe our Collier Count y representatives profits, their constituents, and place our interests above should work to protect corporate Signed: Name and Address: [Jeai' ells. ;i'i�S nriC `Joke 1J1i lSl , pt; 1 -3 �or, ;S+_ Ga:c mC c not etc a PGD '� Cork;>; etlo,Z's pl n tfcit r�:r:tzlo� ri;escr Capri con achai he; � !? c,;oUld develonpeFrr y ob � €iUIJrs b1l;;C1 Nlease vot ~ •NU tc this ; e i should yG,`,r,, t onit oet!iaion• o prc*act ; 11eir ` ►believe our . r , . prorits. onstit(.� Irc r Coup ,, Si and pr,nce o lr erests abcv�erorporatey�s fined: s" Name and /address: i at rt wrjting tCt !'t'ice _,sfes of rl prfrc,1 "ositiot? to l!, �rporatien's ��a:, t the isies cif C t`' a ° r' St;;:h a c{tar � •;� t o rr'or;e their propea , ap;; comrr;urr'ty. �= �o !d wz,.n: fit on!v , the devetop`1', C` �0 1 H1Nv h!l� the �r�'t��VC; ihrn��,ttar, to U 'NCil t flis 1'99 sheUiC� l^,'t f i� ,c._F ' J j1:`r f r�r r fi cf f 'etr ie{leve our C CfjLS• )n.g+irua 5; and +l;ace Oi'r intCrP�OU; ` Y r"!?Y.,serltijveS tS Buove CUrporate Signed: A _ /> A A Name and .address: Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice m orn,lsles of Ca Capri from y opposition to FCC Cor , not`the:lsj' ' el o Ca m C-3 to a PUD. Such a change poration s Plan to rez Capri community, ge would benefit only their Property y the developer, It is better to build NOTHI build the WRONG NG than to NG thingl'*, Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning Petition. I believe Profits, protect their constituents our Collier Count and place our interests y representatives �.' above corporate Signed: Name and Address: 1' IDear Commissioner: am writing to vdi,e on Isles of Ca my Opposition to FCC Cor , not the Isles Capri from C-3 to a PUp, Such p°ration s plan to rezone their Capri community, a change would benefit only property y the developer, It is better to build NOTHING build the WRONG than to thingl„ Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning should work to protect their constituents titUents I believe our Collier Count Profits, ,and lace y representatives n p our interests above corporate Signed: Jame and Address: W ii 3 Dear Commissioner: ► am writing to voice on Isles of Ca my Opposition to FCC Cor not the Isles o Capri from C-3 to a PUp. Such a CorporationisPlan to change would benefit o rezone their Capri community, Property Only the developer, It is better to build NOTHING than to build the WRONG thingl„ Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning should work to protect their constituents tpituents I believe Profits, our Collier County representatives and place our interests above C //� ,1 corporate Signed: D Name and Address: Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice my opposition to FCC Corporation's plan to re on Isles of Capri from C-3 to a PUD. Such a change would benefit onl not the Isles of Capri community, zone their Property the developer, It is better to build NOTHING than build the WRONG thingll� to Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning petition. I believe our Collier County representatives should work to protect their constituents, and place our interests above corporate Signed: Jame and Address: lZ C Dear Commissioner: i I am writing to voice on Isles of Capri fro my opposition to FCC not the Isles of m C. to a PUo. Such Corporation's Capri co a chan Plan to rezone their unity, ge would benefit only property y the developer, it is better to build build the NUrHlNG than to WRONG thingl•, Please vote 'No' to this rezo should work to protect their ni g petition, profits. constituents abde►ieve our Collier Cou place our interests my representatives Signed: above corporate Name and Address: v 4 Dear Commissioner: I a%mriting to voice my o on f�'1�s:of Ca pposition to FCC Cor , not the Isles ofrCarom y to a itio Such a cha poration s plan to rezone pri community, ge would benefit o their eloper, y my the developer, It is better to build NOTHING than to build the WRONG thingl„ Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning petition, I believe our Collier Count y representatives profits, Protect their constituents, and place our interests above corporate Signed: Vame and Address: c Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice my o on Isles of Capri from C-3 s Opposition to FCC Corporation' not the Isles of Ca to a PUD• Such a change plan to rezone their Capri community. ge would benefit onlyproperty, the developer, It is better to build NOTHING than to build the WRONG thing,I, Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning petition. I believe our Collier Count protect their constituents, and place our interests above c Profits. Y representatives corporate iigned: r— T FV4 Jame and Address: 'U b p Y p .� ov, '�� Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice m on Isles of Ca y Opposition to FCC Corporation , not the Isles Of Capri from C-3 to a PUD poration s plan to rezone their Capri com Such a change would benefit only property y the developer, It is better to build NOTHING build the than to WRONG thingl" Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning should work to protect their constituents, Petition, I believe our Collier Count profits. , and o representatives ., place our interests above corporate Signed: Jame and Address: Dear Corn, i n ssior:er: I am -writing on Isles of Capri voice my Qopposition to F,. ri from C_3 to a PUp. -C not the `Orf'Ot-ation's Isles of Caori co Such a than, plan to reZo mMu„ity, be would benefit onl ne their property y the developer, It cs Delter to hc�lid tVnTf-f build the ING than to et0N(a thi WngI lease vo►e 'No' t;� this rezoning should v✓ork to p`�atect theirn,in petition. I p ja l ,.ve our Collier Count profit;, tituents, a,� d n1. ce our interp y eepresentativeS sts above corporate Signed:_ --IL f*'n"' 3nd.4ddress: !- - C, Dear CO mmissdnerf I am writing to voice on Isles Writing Ca my Opposition to FCC Cor not the Isles Capri from C_3 to a PUD. Such pOratou sPlan to Of Ca h a change would benefit o zone their Capri community, property my the developer, It is better to build MOTH build the wR0 LNG than to NG thingl.l Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning petition, believe our Collier County representatives Profits, nstituents, and place our int z erests above cor Signed: j ( � &1 . /; porate dame and Ac ddress: �7a Dear Commissioner; l am writing to voice on Isles of Ca my Opposition to FCC Cor ,s plan to rezone their property not the Isles OfCapri C-3 to a PUD. Suchp°ration a change pri community, would benefit only the developer, "It is better to build MOTH build the WRONG ING than to thing, Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning should work to protect their constituents) Petition, I believe profits, our Collier County representatives and place our interests above corporate Signed. Name and dress: _ . . _Gear Commissioner: ng to voice im a I m writa Isles Capri from y opposition to FCC Cor not the Isles of m C-3 to a PUp, Such p°ration s plan to rezone Capri community, a change would benefit rez their property y the developer "It is better to build NOTHING than to build the WRONG t hingl-, Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning should work to g petition. I believe profits. protect their constituents our Collier. and County representative /� �+ place our in above s "0`1 Signed: corporate Vame and Address: �I Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice on Isles of Cafrom my Opposition to FCC Corporation's not the Isles Capri fro community, Om to a PUD, Such a change Plan to rezone their property mua P would benefit onlythe developer, "It is better to build NOTHING than to build the WRONG t hingl„ Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning should work to protect their constituents, Petition, I believe Profits, and our Collier County representatives Place our interests above corporate Signed: Name and Address: Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice my opposition to FCC Corporation's e� on Isles of Capri from C-3 to a PUD, y not the Isles of Capri community. Such a chan plan to rezone their prop ge would benefit only the developer, it is better to build NOTHING t build the WRONG thig•n i„ than to Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning petition. I believe our Collier Count protect their constituents, and place our interests above corporate profits. y representatives Signed: Name and Address: Dear Commissioner: I am writging to Voice . on Isles of. , my opposition to FCC Cor not the Isles of Ca om C.3 to a p po�tlon s Plan to Capri community. Such a change would benefit onl rezone their mmunity, Property y the developer, It is better to build NpT build the WRONG tHING than to hingl-, Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning should work to protect their constituents, Petition, and profits. believe our Collier County place our interests aboverepresentatives >igned: V 1 ✓� corporate lame and � // Address: 7 Q 7 ` n Dear Commissioner: I arr► writing to voice on Isles of Capri from my Opposition to FCC not the Isles m C"3 to a PUp Such Corporation's plan to rezone their Of Capri community, a change Would benefit only the Property developer, It is better to build build NOTHING the WRONG thingl th Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning should work to protect their co constituents, abelieve profits, d place our Collier County representatives our interests above corporate Signed, �,. vame and Address: Dear Cbmmissjoner: I am writing to voice on Isles of Capri fro my opposition to FCC Cor not the Isles Of f m C-3 to a PUD, Such Corporationis Capri co a change plan to rezone their mmunity, ge would benefit o Property Only the developer, it is better to build NOTHING than t build the WRONG thing• go*, o Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning should work to g petition, I believe profits, protect their constituents our Collier and place ° County representatives <�)ur interests above corporate Signed: � Dv , Vame a�dre ss: Dear Co.rnmissioner: kA [am 1691d Voice on Isles of Ca my Opposition to FCC Cor Property not the Isles Of from C-3 to a PUD, Such poration s Capri com a chan Plan to rezone their munity, ge would benefit only the developer, It is better to build NOT build the HIND than to WRONG thinglll Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning should work to protect their co Petition I believe profits. our Collier County representatives and place our interests above corporate Signed: Name and Address: �`-# f �+ ri Dear Commissioner: am wntmg,to v.oice�my Opposition �-o�t_� ` on to n Isles of Capri from Cy to a itioUD@ FCC Corporation's Plan to rezone not the Isles of Capri community. Such a change would benefit only the developer, eerty p , "It is better to build NOTHING than build the WRONG thing)*41 to Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning should work to protect their constituents, tpituents, aetition, I ndPlaceour nieve our lterestslier unt profits, o representatives above corporate Signed: Vame and Address: Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice m on Isles of Ca y °pposition to FCC Cor Capri from C_3 to a PUp: Such a Corporationis not the Isles of Capri co plan to rezone mmua P change would benefit o their property my the developer, it is better to build NOTHING build the WRONG tthan to hingl-, Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning should work to protect their constituents, Petition, I believe Profits, and our Collier County representatives Place our Signed: interests above corporate Vame and Address: Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice my opposition to FCC Corporation's on Isles of Capri from C-3 to a PUD, Such a change would benefit o not the Isles of Capri community, plan to rezone their property my the developer, IT is better to build NOTHING than build the WRONG thingl" to Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning should work to protect their co tpieuents, tition,I beelieve our Collier Count re profits. / and place our interests abovecorporate Signed: /1 lv,14, a n . Name and Address: Gr N /f rl 7F_aY r� mri:f.5lonei'; Iamvv I D on Isles of a`G v= ice my °position to F not the Isles nrl arom C_3 to a P(iD `C Corp;,;•ation °' Capri co , ; uc1' a change s plan to rezone their pro ''� nunit;�. �e would benefit only the perty developer, ` ��� i �s � re►- to buiIQl bUlId the A, �OTHI�1G than to �'l ! thing/,. P!�Ise Voter; to this re�ollin `bouid work to prot rip .r)Jn. j ,'* profits, ect their corstituents a ba';eve our Collier L'oui}t l� t ►ace our interests y representatives Signed:.2.1 above corporate C,and AddrESS. /t Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice on Isles of Ca my °pposition to FCC Corporation , not the Isles Of Capri from to a PUD. Such p°ration s d benefit a change plan to rezone their munity, ge woulonl y the property developer, It is better to build NOT HANG than to build the WRONG thingl'*4 Please vote 'No' to this rezoning should work to protect their constituents Petition I believe profits, our Collier County re rese � and place our interests above p ntatives Signed: JC e corporate u� ✓ l 1 *0 Jame and qdd Dear Comm61sioner: l am writing to voice my opposition to FCC Corporation's la on Isles of Capri from C-3 to a PUD, Such a change would benefit only the de not the Isles of Capri community, Plan to rezone their property veloper, IT IS better to build NOTHING than to build the WRONG thing," Please vote NO to this rezoning petition. I believe our Collier Count re should work to protect their constituents, and place our interests above profits. y representatives corporate Signed: Name and Address: Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice i on Isles of Capri fro my opposition to FCC Cor , not the Isles of Ca m C-3 to a PUD. Such a chan oration s rezone their Capri co plan to mmunity, g would benefit onl property .;.. e y the developer, It is better to build NO build the WRONG THING than to thingl" Please vote 'lV0' to this rezoning should work to g petition. Protect their constituents I believe our Profits, Collier County and place our interests above representative, Signed:7j e corporate Jame and Address: ��'e w kled(jlt Dear Comrr�issioer; �;A'., I am writing to voice on Isles of Capri fro my °pp°sition to not the Isles Of m C-3 to a POD, FCC Corporation's Capri co Such a change would plan to rezone community, their property benefit only the developer, It Please vote 'NO' should work to, profits. ( /// ►gned is better to build build the NUTHING It WRONG thingl•, han to this rezoning petition, Z onsPetiti is I believe our Collier and I County representatives Place our interests above corporate ame and Address; oil �-C! �eA Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice on Isles of Capri from my Opposition to FCC m Cor , not the Isles of C-3 to a POD, p°ration s Capri co Such a chan plan to rezone their mmunity, ge would benefit onl property y the developer, It is better build t build NOTHING e WRONG than to thingl,i Please vote 'NO' to this rezonin should work to protect their ni g petition. Profits, nstituents, abdl1eve our Collier Place County representatives our interests above corporate Signed:_ lame and duress: Dear Commissioner: I am writing to voice m °n Isles of Capri from y °PP°sition to FCC Cor , not the Isles of m C-3 to a PUD, Such a poration s plan to Capri co change Would rezone their property community, benefit only the developer, It is better to build NOTHihtG build the WRONG thin 1�� g than to Please vote 'NO' to this rezoning Petition, ► should work to Profits, Protect their constituents believe our Collier County representatives and place our interests Signed.. �_ : A Aabove corporate Vame and Address:_-(, r1 ) kLL RECEIVED a,o 23 To the Collier County Commissioners, »N - �.l;j>i z n,- rj� �•�-,ir ME Y We are Capri STRONG, we are truly family. Our grandchildren treasure this unique island For the past few years, our little island has been under un-ending attack. Irma devastated our paradise in September 2017. It took years to rebuild, but we came together in crisis. Capri was tested again when the Fiddler's Creek developer, who purchased C-3 zoned property in our business district over a decade ago leaving it in disrepair changed gears and instead of building a club house /restaurant for their FC residents, pursued a change in zoning which if approved would open the flood gates to development & destroy the Capri "life style". Capri residents unified & rallied to protect our community's identity. Our stamina & determination in this David/Goliath battle has been difficult to sustain, BUT we have not let up. Once again, Mother Nature has ravaged Capri which looks &feels like a war zone post -Ian. We are in a fight for survival. Now we need your help. Please DENY FCC's request for a zoning change. They bought the property C-3, now build it C-3. The Collier County Planning Board after thorough research voted 6-1 against the FCC plan. They, as we, believe that the plan is completely inconsistent with this community. Three 1684eet tall towers would destroy Capri forever for generations of its residents . Our grandchildren love the Capri tiki-hut feel. None of us want towers . Please vote against greed!!!! PLEASE PROTECT US. Help us in this tragic time. Thank you, Kendra Maxwell, children &grandchildren 194 Tahiti Circle, Naples 34113 �� January 3, 2023 I ne upcoming clecisions oy Collier County officials regarding the REZO E equest by Fiddler's Creek developers will negatively affect generations of it a esidents on Isles of Capri and countless visitors from surrounding communi ies, from / ' variety of states and even countries,• of these people common belief that they frequent Capri because it is UNIQUE, with a charm nol asi found elsewhere. •ur recommendations an• decisionseitherf Capri lifestyle to flourish or negatively alter its singular charm forever. f ! • • !. i •.• • it. f - a IF arduous search all over the west coast of Florida, they truly felt they had found 3 piece of heaven when they became Capri residents. They discovered an incredible "time -warp" in this little fishing village. Am as you exit Collier Blvd, into Capri. This REZONE request is proposing a ity of condos and high rises smack dab in our lowIIIIIkey, t1kFhut oestaurant area. - • - •t couldNOT • - more foreign to the Capri :haracter. In your terril the ii DEVELOPMENT IS NOT A COHESIVE FIT' and lifemblood of this island and those who have chosen to embrace a life mor n harmony with nature and simplicity. We want to give this bit of Capri heave me f `` our • • Mose wno rea Inis message. Please, please do Flu I allow this AELGAVE happen. There are too few communitiesCapri KENDRA "MIMI" MAXWELL, 194 Tahiti Circle, Naples, FL 34113 Reagan, 10, Wyatt 8,-and . Rhett 5 O'Neal Why We Like The By: Ragan (10), 1Nyat# �s� l�les of Capri , and Rhett fs Wyatt- 'l life going to the island because of the park. When 1 go to the park it is not crowded, When l kayak, I love to see dolphins and go over to the beach. We cannot do that in Troy, Ohio, Rhett- I like the park because it has fun stuff. Bocce is super fun to play with my Mimi and brother and sister. I also like kayaking to see dolphins and fish. I also like to see my grandparents dog ©elanie. I kind of just li ake going to see my grandparents, Reagan- I like the island because we can walk to dinner or lunch. I love that it is not crowded so when we go to the park it is not busy. 1 also like seeing dolphins and feeding the fish. Everyone there is friendly. or a U l y � Orel! xc f: apri 'Why e Isles of C By. Benson (10), Collin (7), and Savannah (4) Benson-- I like going kayaking and riding my scooter all over the island. Can't do that in Allentown , PA Collin-- Capri is fun because we can walk everywhere. I like ice cream sandwiches on Mimi & DeDa's dock while we look for dolphin Savannah-- I like having DeDa carry me on his shoulders to the restaurants and stopping at the playground on the way home IRFMKEDWIRED JAN 112023 COU RCOUP BOARD OFCOUPCOI. DSIONERS Dear Commissioner Hall, January 5, 2023 Thank you for serving Collier County. As a Michigan resident, I am repeatedly impressed by how your team collaborates and maintains timely forward motion. Our state could learn a lot from you. My husband and I own a home on Isle Capri and are building one next door to it on W Pago Pago Drive. We have been watching and weighing in on the rezoning proposal and the fight against it. I sent an email on behalf of my husband, Mike and myself back in late August/early September supporting the proposal, but after getting harassed, literally, by the SaveCapri team I am opting for snail mail to render one last opinion. We are in favor of the rezoning efforts on Isle Capri, however we would have preferred the residents of the island had not taken such a hard line and had been willing to negotiate with the developer. My husband owns a construction and development company in Michigan with an office in Estero. We are very familiar with how this works and feel that the residents opposing this are not grasping that 'the devil you know is better than the devil you don't know'. In other words, we don't think they are acting in their own best interests. We didn't get involved earlier as we are new to the community. If we had been able to, [am sure that my husband would have at least tried to educate the SaveCapri group on how to negotiate a "plea deal" with the developer and the county. We believe that a quality developer like Fiddlers Creek will bring solid construction and site design that will draw in new, invested residents to the community. Yes, it would be a change. But as newcomers ourselves, we firmly believe new residents will fall in love with, invest in and care for the Capri community much more than when (not if) an inferior project goes in there bringing with it a transient and touristy crowd. Thank you for your time and best wishes for more good work in 20231 Gayle and Mike VanGessel 616-560-3818 �3:740 Cao L't < -i GRAND 4937., Couv r�� Sor,,e--i H.CL( 1 �2-9 G -T,--a \ ECCs-F From: ioillatsch(Wrontier.com To: Chris Hall Subject: Dave Isles of Capri Date: Monday, January 2, 2023 5:59:02 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Collier County Board of Commissioners: As concerned citizens of the Isles of Capri, we are requesting your support on the case referenced above which will come before you very soon. The citizens of the Isles of Capri wish to thank the Planning Commissioners for their wisdom and understanding of the many aspects as to why the rezoning application should be denied. Paraphrasing some of the Commissioners' comments, they stated the proposal was "inconsistent, incompatible and not complimentary with the Isles of Capri." We couldn't agree more! Just look at our lovely community and how everyone pulled together to help one another and bring our tiny island back after Hurricane Ian. Commissioner LoCastro, you were a big player in the restoration Isles of Capri, and your help and direction was invaluable. Those who live on Capri and those who enjoy visiting feel that it is a unique and special place, and any attempt to rezone should be closely scrutinized in efforts to keep it that way. The developers knew the way the land was zoned when it was purchased, so why would the County Board of Commissioners even consider the change? The community has worked tirelessly, and so far successfully, to ensure we were heard by our elected officials. We now ask you for your support to ensure the Isles of Capri maintains what is so distinctly "Capri." Thank you in advance for your support on this important vote. Respectfully, Craig & JoAnn Pillatsch 424 LaPeninsula Blvd Naples, FL 34113 Sent from Frontier Yahoo Mail for iPhone Sent from Frontier Yahoo Mail for iPhone Sent from Frontier Yahoo Mail for iPhone From: Joan Coyne To: HallChris; JarvisLouise Subject: FCC applications PL20210002313 and PL20210002314 Date: Thursday, December 1, 2022 11:22:44 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Hello Commissioner Hall, I would like to set up a meeting with you in regards to the above PL numbers. I along with 5 other residents of the Isle of Capri have formed an organization (savecaspri.org) stickley to fight the rezone of our business Isle to mixed use. We have a petition signed by 900 residents of the Isles, who do not want this project to go forward. This project does not fit in with the rest of the Isles. Please meet with us at your convenience. We would probably be only 3 or 4 at the meeting. We would like to meet you and share with you the concerns of the residents prior to the Commissioners meeting on January 10. Thank you very much. Joan Coyne 109 W. Pago Pago Dr. Naples, F134113 239-272-0327 From: pdon199.poagmaiLcom To: Rick LoCastro; Burt Saunders; Bill McDaniel; Chris Hall; Louise Jarvis; Dan Kowal; sarina.francis(c colIiercounty..gov Subject: FCC Beach & Yacht LLC Rezoning request on Isles of Capri Date: Wednesday, January 4, 2023 3:09:46 PM Attachments: LoCastro IOC.docx EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Collier County Board of Commissioners: I am a property owner in Tarpon Village, Isles of Capri (IOC) and seasonal resident of same. Attached is a letter to Commissioner LoCastro on 8/21/22 regarding this matter and in response to his concern of what the IOC residents would like to see on the property in question zoned as C-3. Please note that the statements in that letter are my opinion and I do not speak for the IOC. Since the County Board of Commissioners were originally copied I have attached it primarily as a reminder of my objection to the proposed rezoning request and for the new Commissioners' review. I object and oppose development of three (3) high-rise buildings —168 feet - consisting of 108 muti- family dwelling units. That kind of development is not compatible nor consistent with other development on IOC. There is no public benefit associated with the requested growth management plan amendment. County Planning Commission staff recommended denial of the rezoning applications for two main reasons: density in the Urban Coastal Fringe High Hazard Area; and height—C-3 is zoned for 50-foot height. The Planning Commission ultimately denied the application. Former Commissioner Taylor once said "Developers have an eye to profit, instead of an eye to what our community values ..." "Collier County is not here to support a developer making a profit from his assets. That is not our job. Our job is to preserve the quality of life and our community and ensure that people who have invested their life savings in their home have a continuing strong investment." I ask you to consider the residents of IOC and their investments. I ask you to consider the location of IOC in a nature preserve. I ask you to deny this application to rezone — it is inconsistent, incompatible with past and present development. Keep IOC C-3 Sincerely, Margaret O'Neill January 4, 2023 Sent from Mail for Windows From: 1ost1234 To: Rick LoCastro; Chris Hall; Dan Kowal; Burt Saunders; Bill McDaniel Subject: FCC Zoning change Isles of Capri Tues Jan 10 Date: Saturday, January 7, 2023 11:24:09 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Honorable Commissioner, I respectfully ask you to vote no on the FCC application for zoning change on Isles of Capri. As a resident of Capri I look forward to the restoration of the marina property owned by FCC. I know they will build a beautiful clubhouse, and I hope they will build a place for businesses that will attract boaters and visitors to Capri, to enjoy the waterfront, shop and dine. However, I believe our isles will forever be changed if they are allowed to build high-rise, high density condominiums on this property. We are a community of people who enjoy a lifestyle of mostly single family and low profile homes and great neighbors. We are people who come together to work, play, and care for one another, especially after a tragedy like Hurricanes Irma and Ian. The proposed condominium complex will be isolated from us by design, and I believe the residents will be a community all their own. If this project is approved I believe every existing waterfront business will follow suit and apply for the same zoning change, to tear down the small business buildings to make room for new mixed use development, and the community we have now will go into the scrapbooks of history. Thank you for your consideration. Sheryl Braun 168 E Hilo St. From: cJnnyhogp(@aol.com To: Chris Hall Cc: Louise Jarvis Subject: Fiddler"s Creek proposal Date: Friday, January 6, 2023 4:38:25 PM Attachments: Letter to Commissioner Chris Ha112.odf EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Enclosed please find my letter of opposition to the zoning change for Isles of Capri From: mdhbminkler(ftambura.de To: Chris Hall Subject: FW: Isles of Capri - Rezoning Date: Saturday, December 31, 2022 2:18:06 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Subject: Isles of Capri - Rezoning Dear Mr Hall As property owners on the Isles of Capri we are deeply concerned about FCC's rezoning request. Their plans are utterly incompatible with the neighborhood and detrimental to the people of the isles, socially, aesthetically and environmentally. We ask you : Do not chance the zoning. Leave it C-3. Sincerely, Karl Heinz Winkler Ingrid Winkler 409 La Peninsula Blvd Naples 34113 Virus-free.www.avast.com From: George Merkling To: Rick LoCastro; Bill McDaniel; Chris Hall; Dan Kowal; Burt Saunders Subject: Fwd: ccpc 9-1-2022 and 9-15-2022 Date: Tuesday, January 3, 2023 4:23:36 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. hello commissioners - to save you a little time reviewing your agenda package for the 1-10-2023 bcc meeting regarding the hot -button project proposal for isles of capri , i pulled out some direct quotes from the ccpc hearings regarding this issue . naturally , they all support only excerpts which agree with our opposition cause . thank you . George J. Merkling III , 109 W. Pago Pago Dr. , Naples FL 34113 , 716-818-2886 , summer address 2699 W. Lake Rd. , Wilson NY 14172 ---------- Forwarded message --------- From: George Merkling < georgeal2ollo steel& gmail.com> Date: Tue, Jan 3, 2023 at 4:12 PM Subject: ccpc 9-1-2022 and 9-15-2022 To: mcox1932 <mcox1932 cni comcast.net>, Jeff O. <beachatocna gm� ail.corn>, John MUELLER <jmuels412&gma,� il.com>, Deborah Ersland <dersland cniokeycomre.com>, Nicole Esch <nicoleeschl l.com>, Joan Coyne <lordcal109na gmail.com>, Connie Sofo- Koelsch <connkoegme.com> in the reading of every word - except public response - the following DIRECT quotable quotes that may support our opposition to capri rezone are as follows " 9-1-22 , pg 15 , top : yovanovich - "this will be kind of a private grill restaurant for residents [sic - members ] 16 , shea - " is this a gated community ? " . yovanovich " yes , the residences will be " . 17 , top : yovanovich - " the property just has too much value with the current zoning 21 , top : yovanovich - " gating will be at the parking 58 , bot : yovanovich - " marco island did not mandate that we oversize the [ sic sewer ] pipe to accommodate the whole island ' pinocchio to the max! 9-15-22 , pg 58 Shea - " i don't see the benefit ... and i would vote NO on it " [ sic the whole project ] 58 fry - " the neighbors are more united in opposition to this than in any of my 4 years " 59 ,bot : fry - " you , as residents , without joining the yacht club , lose any benefit from that property ... it is not complementary " 60 fry - " you capriers - i see no benefit ... i vote no , i agree with staff " . 62 vernon - " it just seemed very out of place [ sic the development ] ... inconsistent;;;incompatible . " 62 chair fryer - " compatible , complementary ... falls way short ...... i will be voting no George J. Merkling III , 109 W. Pago Pago Dr. , Naples FL 34113 , 716-818-2886 , summer address 2699 W. Lake Rd. , Wilson NY 14172 From: Joan Coyne To: Amy. patterson(cbcolliercounty.aov; Rick LoCastro; Bill. McDaniel (bcolliercountfl.aov; Dan Kowal; Chris Hall; Burt Saunders Cc: GoodnerAnaela; Sue Filson; Cristina Tiberia; Sue Filson; Aixa Capizzi; Louise Jarvis Subject: How a Developer buys additional density....... Date: Thursday, December 1, 2022 7:16:27 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Please respect me enough to read this e-mail completely. This is an email I sent to Mr LaRow-Director — Economic Development and Housing Division I have several questions regarding affordability density bonuses I live on the Isles of Capri. At the CCPC it was stated a developer could pay a fee to the county to get around providing affordable housing units in their proposed luxury project on the Isles of Capri and get additional density bonus. Can you explain how that works? I would like to know how the fee is determined, to whom it is paid? Please advise where in the code this is stated. I look forward to hearing from you, Joan Coyne Answer I received from Mr LaRow Director — Economic Development and Housing Division To answer your question, there's nothing in the Land Development Code that speaks to or provides for a payment calculation where an applicant can contribute a Local Housing Trust Fund to support the development of housing that is affordable. The comment was intended to convey Board of County Commissioner direction to staff that projects requesting density above what is currently allowed in the Comprehensive Plan to provide some public benefit in exchange for the additional density. That public benefit has been manifested in approximately 20% of the units developed to be set aside and made affordable for 30 years. For this particular project, the number of units would have stood at 21 to be reserved as affordable. Since the applicant appeared to be resistant to that exchange the comment was made for the purposes of discussion for the applicant to consider as a potential to consider if they were interested. To be clear, the Board hasn't broached the subject of a payment in lieu of providing units. It was more of a reminder to the applicant that with the density requested staff would recommend some public benefit as a result This is my response to Mr LaRow It sounds to me like an auction. If they agree to provide dollars to Affordable housing for public benefit. Then the Isles of Capri has to live with something that is incompatible and doesn't compliment the existing homes in the area. What about their public benefit? If the area is in High coastal hazard area and Urban Coastal Fringe Subdistrict how does giving dollars to the Affordable housing protect the safety of the residents in the community from these designated areas? It seems to me it is just putting more people in harm's way. It gives the applicant a way to go around rules that are set aside to protect people. It also sounds to me like discrimination not wanting to have service people in their luxury buildings. I know I am ranting to you when I am just upset about how the government always allows money to buy whatever they want at the cost of the safety of the residents. I am going to forward this note to the board of county commissioners also. Thank you for your time. Joan Coyne 109 W. Pago Pago Dr. Naples, F134113 239-272-0327 From: it48430(abaol.com To: rick.castro(cicolliercountyfl.gov; bert.saunders(acolliercountyfl.aov; Chris Hall; Dan Kowal; bill. mcdaniel0)collierocuntyf1.00v Subject: isle of capri (meeting jan. 10, 2023) Date: Monday, January 9, 2023 10:30:17 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. dear collier county commissioners: please vote NOT to rezone the isle of capri. it does not need higher buildings there. the ambience of the isle is enjoyable the way that it is. please vote NO to rezoning the isle. we appreciate your consideration in keeping the isle as it is. thank you. john and karen thornton, 6650 bech resort drive, #7, naples, fl. 34114 From: jt48430Ccbaol.com To: Rick LoCastro; Chris Hall; bert.saunders(c colliercountvfl.aov; Dan Kowal; Bill McDaniel Subject: isle of capri Date: Monday, January 9, 2023 11:14:49 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. dear collier county commissioners: please vote NOT to rezone the isle of capri. we appreciate your leaving the zoning on the isle of capri the way that it is. we enjoy the ambience of the isle and hope that it remains without high buildings. it is a pleasant place to spend time. thank you. john and karen thornton, 6650 beach resort drive, #7, naples, fl. 34114 From: steve.heilCalheilauction.com To: HallChris Subject: Isles of Capri Date: Friday, December 2, 2022 6:14:19 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Mr. Hall, please cast a no vote on the rezoning on our island. We purchased here because of the natural beauty and the fantastic sunsets we experience almost every evening. This will change all of that. No more sunset views only big out of place buildings blocking them from us. Please don't let us be like the East coast. Thank you, Steve and Cindy Heil 422 Samar Ave. .I r. -gig f . 2M-10-21 19.14.57 ►+�r�irr_ A 4T 1 I 'i�• ' 1 N! From: George Merkling To: Chris Hall Subject: isles of capri big condos Date: Monday, December 19, 2022 9:12:47 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. I followed your campaign and liked what I read . the section about the will of the majority of the people caught my attention in particular . it is 180 degrees about face from what our district commissioner wrote to me in several emails . he said , regarding the fiddler's creek proposed condo project on the isles of capri " this is NOT a popularity contest ! " . the comment came after I informed him of the overwhelming majority [ more than 100-t0-1 ] who said 'no to rezone, no to 3 big condos ' . if it weren't for current zoning laws , I would not have an argument . but , our law says the proposed project site is zoned C3 . that law does NOT allow tall buildings or dense DUPA [ dwelling units per acre ] . the developers desire to REPEAL that law . during consideration of repealing a law , I'd hope that the super -majority voice of the local community would carry a lot of weight. Additionally ,when one ignores the negative impacts of a rezone, one actually would need to disregard the reason for the C3 law . that law protects the idea a safety hazard would be caused by overpopulation of a zone designated as ' high hazard — coastal fringe area ' . the evac time would be increased beyond the legal limit . I do not believe this law should be weakened since up to 108 additional families would need to evac ahead of my family. our curvy, low lying singular road is already a severe impediment . Thanks for reading my personal slant on this issue . there are a great number of other reasons to deny rezone . I'm sure that other safety -minded families will be contacting you soon . please read the agenda packet before you vote on jan 10 2023 . THANK YOU Sent from Mail for Windows From: Sheela Reasoner To: Rick LoCastro; Chris Hall; Burt Saunders; Dan Kowal; Bill McDaniel Subject: Isles of Capri Density Rating System Date: Monday, January 9, 2023 1:24:04 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Gentlemen, I just wanted to comment on the proposed benefits made by the devloper to the residents of IOC and send you a condensed version of the staff s density rating system for the proposed developement. False benefit claims to the community. Sewer: The developer is MANDATED TO improve the sewer system in order for them to hook up to it. "No connections are allowed to Marco's force main until a gravity sanitary sewer collection system is constructed". (As stated to the developer in a letter from Marco Island Utilities) Culverts: IOC already has a committee working on the culvert project. Grants are available and the process takes time. House Prices: Not sure how house prices will increase. Would you buy a house 100ft across the bay from this development? Summary of Staff's Density Rating System. (Please note the developer has confirmed that the marina to the south of the vacant lots will stay as a marina so the red indicates the actual land available for development. Staff uses the total acreage of 5.32.) Urban Coastal Fringe Subdistrict (UCFS) = 4 DU's/A 258 dry slip facility consumes approx. 1.2 acres Applicant proposing 20.3 DU's/A. 108 / 5.32 = 20.3 Coastal High Hazard Area (CHHA) = 3 DU's/A Actual land available = 4.12 acres. Should be 26 DU's/A based on 4.12 acres. 108/4.12=26 Ways to increase density through the Future Land Use Element (FLUE). Density Rating System (Density Bonus) 1) Conversion of Commercial Zoning Bonus Allows 1 DU/A for every acre converted from commercial to residential use. But there's a cap of 4DU's/A because the site lies within the UCFS. Max. allowed is 4 x 5.32 = 21.28 or 21 DU's but should be 4 x 4.12 = 16.48 or 16 DU's 2) Transfer of Development Rights (TDR's) No bonus allowed. In no case shall density be transferred into the CHHA from outside the CHHA. The transfer of TDR's is not permitted into the UCFS. These provisions address hurricane evacuation and protect the adjacent environmentally sensitive conservation area. i.e. Rookery Bay Aquatic Preserve. 3) Affordable Housing Density Bonus (AHDB) No bonus allowed. Max. of 12 DU's/A may be added to the base density if the project meets the requirements of the AHDB Program by providing AH within the development. This increase is not an entitlement and the bonus must be requested through the formal process. The applicant has not submitted a request for AHDB for this development so no bonus is allowed. Max. allowable DU's/A for this site = 4 DU'/A under the provisions allowed in the FLUE. Clearly nowhere near the proposed 20.3 DU's/A Therefore, this small-scale amendment is NOT CONSISTENT with the FLUE of the Growth Management Plan (GMP) and should be denied for approval. Sincerely, Sheela Reasoner From: Sheryl Braun To: Rick LoCastro; Bill McDaniel; Burt Saunders; Chris Hall; Dan Kowal Subject: Isles of Capri FCC rezoning Date: Wednesday, January 11, 2023 11:35:31 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner, Does this bad medicine come with a little sugar? Right now it tastes really bitter. Or was the sugar the phony show of compassion and concern for the Capri residents? We were allowed time to speak, but surely you knew what we were going to say, that we would reiterate the same concerns you heard before, the same concerns that prompted 900+ of us to sign a petition to save our small neighborhood life. You knew that the majority of residents were fighting to keep our community low profile and small neighborhood, but in the end money won. That wasn't sugar, it was a blindfold. • In the end FCC chopped off'/4 of the towers height and your approval launched the urbanization of Isles of Capri. <!--[if !supportLists]-->• <!--[endif]-->We will have a private tower community that bifurcates the isles. <!--[if !supportLists]-->• <!--[endif]-->We will have a private community of 108 condominium households in the center of our community. <!--[if !supportLists]-->• <!--[endif]-->We will have a new marina that outsiders cannot see because it will be hidden behind landscape. <!--[if !supportLists]-->• <!--[endif]-->My morning walk will pass between a 75 ft. boat barn and a multi -story parking garage, my daily drive will pass by this property, and I will remember the beautiful view. <!--[if !supportLists]-->• <!--[endif]-->The view from my temporary home (displaced by Ian) is the boat barn, and the towers will rise above it. I am hopeful we can rebuild on Hilo so we will face away from it. The value of the current restaurant properties will skyrocket in value and the 3 families that own them would be foolish to not cash in. The undeveloped properties will ask for the same zoning change for the same purpose. I don't need a crystal ball to see that. Any intelligent owner would do the same. I was foolish enough to believe we had a chance. The vote of 5-0 clearly sends a message that it was a foolish thought. Heartsick resident of Capri, Sheryl Braun 168 E Hilo From: Jeff Oh To: Chris Hall Subject: Isles of Capri Date: Thursday, January 5, 2023 11:04:50 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. CONGRATULATIONS ON YOUR ELECTION COMMISSIONER HALL!!! I am writing to plea to you and urge you to vote against the rezoning of the Isles of Capri, for the betterment of the island, surrounding water quality, wildlife, and preservation of our beautiful County. We are not opposed to any development allowable under the C-3 zoning. We are only opposed to the owner's unreasonable attempt to change the zoning, without any regard for the surrounding homes, people, and nature. It is extremely unethical for the owners to build 3 high-rise towers, in the middle of a very small residential island, surrounded by our ocean water, adjacent to Rookery Bay. If this is allowed, this rezoning will surely bring additional high-rise towers, which will definitely destroy one of the last few remaining wildlife sanctuary areas in Collier County, which can not be undone. It is SO OBVIOUS that this rezoning request is WRONG FOR THE AREA and it would be a BAD INVESTIMENT FOR THE FUTURE for the county's land use. The county's planning staff and the planning commission already concluded that these high-rise towers would not be compatible with the surrounding areas and rejected this outrageous building proposal. Our country was built on a foundation of brave people like yourself, who evaluated the issues fairly and stood up for what is RIGHT and WRONG, for the BETTERMENT OF THE PEOPLE. Please, do not be persuaded by political influence, big money, corporate greed, or highly skilled attorneys' attempts to cloud your impartial, honest judgment in this matter. We know that you personally hold tremendous power to change people's lives forever in a positive way and preserve our unique natural resources in Collier County. I am one of those conservative people who fled to our beautiful State of Florida from one of the decaying, poorly run large cities. Please deliver the correct, impartial decision, by rejecting this unreasonable rezoning request and save this small waterfront sanctuary for the future generation to enjoy. Thank you for your time and I hope you stand with the people, to set a positive appropriate land use for Collier County's future. Sincerely, Jeff Oh Isles of Capri Collier Resident From: Debora Shumaker To: Chris Hall Subject: Isles of Capri Date: Thursday, January 5, 2023 12:59:23 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Chris, Last year my husband and I picked Isles of Capri to retire at for the laid back homey feel. Please do not let development change the island. Thank you, Debbie & Paul Shumaker From: Matt Crowder To: Chris Hall Cc: ieri(obislesofcapri.com Subject: January 10 BCC Agenda Item - FCC Petitions PL20210002313, PL20210002314 Date: Wednesday, January 4, 2023 11:27:05 AM Attachments: Commissioner Hall Packet January 4.Ddf EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Hi Commissioner Hall: My name is Matt Crowder, I am a resident of Isles of Capri of almost 30 years, and current President of Capri Community, Inc. Our organization, and the majority of Capri residents, oppose FCC's rezone petitions PL20210002313 and PL20210002314. We oppose the rezone on the grounds that FCC's proposed site plan is incompatible and inconsistent with the surrounding area. We are pleading with all County Commissioners to vote 'No' on these petitions on January 10. Our opposition is supported by County Planning Staff and the Collier County Planning Commission. County Staff recommended denial of the rezone on the grounds that the project site plan is incompatible with the surrounding neighborhood. Collier County Planning Commission voted 6-1 to deny the rezone on September 15, 2022 on the same grounds. I've attached a brief overview of our opposition and the rationale for it. If you have the time prior to your vote on January 10, we ask that you take a minute review this document. We do not deny that FCC has the right to develop their property. We accept that. We simply ask that they develop it under the rules of the existing C-3 zone, and not be granted the right to rezone the area in the heart of our small community to a PUD. Many comparisons have been made between this project and the recently -approved One Naples development. We believe there are significant differences between the two. The primary difference is that the One Naples project is being developed in an area of Naples that is surrounded by relatively tall commercial and residential buildings, with cross streets, through -traffic, stop lights, etc. By comparison, Isles of Capri is a tiny waterfront residential community with mostly one -to -two story buildings. Capri has one road on and one road off. We are not equipped for the development of three 168-foot residential towers. It will transform our small island community forever. Thank you, Commissioner Hall. We know you're very busy in this new year, and we hope you can find the time to review the document. Please feel free to contact me with any questions or comments you might have. Sincerely, Matt Crowder President, Capri Community, Inc. cc: Jeri Neuhaus, Treasurer, Capri Community, Inc. From: George Merkling To: Chris Hall; Bill.McDaniel(d)colliercountfl.gov; Burt Saunders; Dan Kowal Subject: last night : capri Date: Wednesday, January 11, 2023 9:17:25 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. thank you for your patience last night. i realize you made ad if ficult decision . li willingly accept the result of due process . however , i was informed that there are further hurdles , at the state level , that are required to give final approval to the proposed GMP amendment . i only ask that you will openly and promptly inform me as each ensuing phase of this approval is about to occur . I'm not 'lawyering-up' here' ; i just want to stay abreast [ or ahead ] of this project until the FINAL go-ahead from Tallahassee [ as I'm sure you all are ] . thanks again for your forbearance . george merkling . George J. Merkling III , 109 W. Pago Pago Dr. , Naples FL 34113 , 716-818-2886 , summer address 2699 W. Lake Rd. , Wilson NY 14172 From: Dianna Quintanilla To: Louise Jarvis Subject: Meeting Request: Isle of Capri Date: Thursday, December 15, 2022 1:48:25 PM Attachments: image001.onna EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Good afternoon, Rich, along with Aubrey F., would like to meet with the Commissioner on the Isles of Capri project that is scheduled for the January loth BCC. AvailabilitT. Thursday, January 5th anytime Friday, January 6th 1:00 - 4:00 Monday, January 9th 11:30, 3:00, 3:30 Please let me know which date you prefer. Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla Administrative Assistant The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P:239.435.35351 F:239.435.1218 dauintanilla ancyklawfirm.com Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. CYK COLEMAN I TOW AN0vaCR I KOESTEq Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman, Yovanovich & Koester, P.A., intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged, confidential, and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at douintanilloPcvklowfirm.com or call (239) 435-3535, and permanently dispose of the original message. From: Joan Coyne To: Chris Hall Cc: Louise Jarvis Subject: Meeting Today Date: Monday, December 12, 2022 5:53:15 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Hello Commissioner Hall Thank you for the meeting with us today. We appreciate you listening to us. Something we failed to mention but you probably realized without us saying, we do not want to compromise. It has to be C-3. Good luck in your new endeavor. If you have any questions we did not answer please let me know. Again, Thank you very much Joan Coyne SaveCapri.org 109 W. Pago Pago Dr. Naples, F134113 239-272-0327 From: Tanya Glass To: Bill McDaniel; Burt Saunders; Chris Hall; Dan Kowal; Rick LoCastro Subject: Population Growth CONTROL Date: Saturday, January 14, 2023 10:34:00 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioners: I have been very, very disappointed in your actions to approve the Isles of Capris high rise against all the local residents wishes for many good reasons. I have written before against it. The locals wrote more letters than you have probably ever gotten - aren't they/we your constituents? (See if you get don't get voted out of office as you ruin our county!) We don't need more high-rises. We don't need more people or cars. We are quickly losing charm. Don't you all think enough about the local impact? The traffic, the water use, the views blotted by tall high-rises. Oh, whoopdeedo that this one will only be 168 feet instead of 122. That is so high you can't even see those top feet (but thank goodness you/they reduced the size). The developers did that on purpose, you know. Go for too much and be happy with what you originally hoped for - a common bargaining ploy across the world. You have to STOP letting these developers invade our lands and increase our population beyond control. Where is the water coming from? Where is the traffic control? WHEN WILL YOU SAY "NO!!!!„? JUST SAY NO!! Change zoning right away if that is necessary. That is what saved Rookery Bay - did you know about that? in the 1960s? Housing — Where is the housing for all the help? These 80 condos each are giving $5000 toward housing. Cheap! These developers don't have to do a darned thing!!! And that is Nothing! That is hardly a month's rent for anyone these days with rents $2000-$3000 a month. Why don't you mandate they have their own housing for staff? Some places do that, you know. They buy condos for staff who work at their establishment. Places in New England have been doing that for years and years (Chatham Bars Inn for one of many). Why can't we do that here!? Why are you so slow at `getting it'? Be tough! Stop giving in to these developers who only want to make money and don't care about the locals and their towns. They build and leave. Why should they care? Why don't you???? The County has to make new developers supply housing, just like you make them pay for roads and services for new developments. ***The County needs to buy up affordable housing NOW. Do something! ***And save land - put a 1 % tax on all of us to ONLY buy up farm land VERY, VERY Disappointingly, Tanya T. Glass 388 5th ST. North Naples, FL 34102 239-248-8586 From: Joan Coyne To: Louise Jarvis Cc: Chris Hall Subject: Re: FCC applications PL20210002313 and PL20210002314 Date: Monday, December 5, 2022 5:58:14 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Hello Ms Jarvis, Thank you for your response. I understand Commissioner Hall is not in our district however, we need his no vote to help us defeat the rezone request by FCC inc.. I am in the process of setting up meetings with all 5 Commissioners on the Board to share with them our stand on this very important issue. We would like to schedule a meeting with Commissioner Hall. Please get back to me with dates and times at his convenience. thank you Joan Coyne On Mon, Dec 5, 2022 at 9:26 AM HallChris <Chris.Hallna.colliercountyfl.gov> wrote: Commissioner Hall appreciates your concern. Although this issue does not involve an area within District 2, all Commissioners will vote on this issue when it comes before them. Rest assured that Commissioner Hall aims to be an involved Commissioner for Collier County, considering all aspects before making an informed decision. As such, he is following this topic closely. Thank you for being a concerned citizen. Louise Jarvis, Executive Coordinator Commissioner Chris Hall, District 2 Collier County Board of County Commissioners Phone 239.252.8602 Sign up for the District 2 newsletter HERE! Under Florida Law, e-mails are public records. If you do not want these released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. From: Joan Coyne <lordca1109&gmail.com> Sent: Thursday, December 1, 2022 11:23 AM To: HallChris<Chris.Hall&colliercountyfl.gov>; JarvisLouise <Louise.Jarvisncolliercountyfl. gov> Subject: FCC applications PL20210002313 and PL20210002314 EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Hello Commissioner Hall, I would like to set up a meeting with you in regards to the above PL numbers. I along with 5 other residents of the Isle of Capri have formed an organization (savecas rn i.org) stickley to fight the rezone of our business Isle to mixed use. We have a petition signed by 900 residents of the Isles, who do not want this project to go forward. This project does not fit in with the rest of the Isles. Please meet with us at your convenience. We would probably be only 3 or 4 at the meeting. We would like to meet you and share with you the concerns of the residents prior to the Commissioners meeting on January 10. Thank you very much. Joan Coyne 109 W. Pago Pago Dr. Naples, F134113 239-272-0327 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. Joan Coyne 109 W. Pago Pago Dr. Naples, F134113 239-272-0327 From: Joan Coyne To: Chris Hall; Louise Jarvis Subject: Re: FCC applications PL20210002313 and PL20210002314 Date: Thursday, December 8, 2022 5:53:24 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Hello Ms Jarvis, Monday works for us. I am not sure if it will be two or three or us. I am waiting to hear from one of our other board members. Please let me know the location of the meeting. I want you and Commissioner Hall to know how much we appreciate this opportunity. I know this is a very busy time for Commissioner Hall. Looking forward to hearing from you soon. Sincerely, Joan Coyne SaveCapri.org 239-272-03278 On Thu, Dec 8, 2022 at 4:36 PM HallChris <Chris.HalI&colliercountyfl.gov> wrote: Commissioner Hall currently has availability on Monday December 12th at 1 lam. Please let me know if this will work. Thank you, Louise Jarvis, Executive Coordinator Commissioner Chris Hall, District 2 Collier County Board of County Commissioners Phone 239.252.8602 Sign up for the District 2 newsletter HERE! Under Florida Law, e-mails are public records. If you do not want these released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. From: Joan Coyne <lordca1109&gmail.com> Sent: Monday, December 5, 2022 5:59 PM To: JarvisLouise <Louise. Jarvis&colliercountyfl.gov> Cc: HallChris <Chris.HallQcolliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Re: FCC applications PL20210002313 and PL20210002314 EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Hello Ms Jarvis, Thank you for your response. I understand Commissioner Hall is not in our district however, we need his no vote to help us defeat the rezone request by FCC inc.. I am in the process of setting up meetings with all 5 Commissioners on the Board to share with them our stand on this very important issue. We would like to schedule a meeting with Commissioner Hall. Please get back to me with dates and times at his convenience. thank you Joan Coyne On Mon, Dec 5, 2022 at 9:26 AM HallChris <Chris.Hall cnre colliercountyfl.gov> wrote: Commissioner Hall appreciates your concern. Although this issue does not involve an area within District 2, all Commissioners will vote on this issue when it comes before them. Rest assured that Commissioner Hall aims to be an involved Commissioner for Collier County, considering all aspects before making an informed decision. As such, he is following this topic closely. Thank you for being a concerned citizen. Louise Jarvis, Executive Coordinator Commissioner Chris Hall, District 2 Collier County Board of County Commissioners Phone 239.252.8602 Sign up for the District 2 newsletter HERE! Under Florida Law, e-mails are public records. If you do not want these released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. From: Joan Coyne <lordca1109ngmail.com> Sent: Thursday, December 1, 2022 11:23 AM To: HallChris<Chris.Hallgcolliercountyfl.gov>; JarvisLouise <Louise.Jarvisna.colliercountyfl. gov> Subject: FCC applications PL20210002313 and PL20210002314 EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Hello Commissioner Hall, I would like to set up a meeting with you in regards to the above PL numbers. I along with 5 other residents of the Isle of Capri have formed an organization (savecaspri.org) stickley to fight the rezone of our business Isle to mixed use. We have a petition signed by 900 residents of the Isles, who do not want this project to go forward. This project does not fit in with the rest of the Isles. Please meet with us at your convenience. We would probably be only 3 or 4 at the meeting. We would like to meet you and share with you the concerns of the residents prior to the Commissioners meeting on January 10. Thank you very much. Joan Coyne 109 W. Pago Pago Dr. Naples, F134113 239-272-0327 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. Joan Coyne 109 W. Pago Pago Dr. Naples, F134113 239-272-0327 Joan Coyne 109 W. Pago Pago Dr. Naples, F134113 239-272-0327 From: HallChris To: steve.heil(c)heilauction.com Subject: RE: Isles of Capri Date: Monday, December 5, 2022 9:48:00 AM Commissioner Hall appreciates your concern. Although this issue does not involve an area within District 2, all Commissioners will vote on this issue when it comes before them. Rest assured that Commissioner Hall aims to be an involved Commissioner for Collier County, considering all aspects before making an informed decision. As such, he is following this topic closely. Thank you for being a concerned citizen. Louise Jarvis, Executive Coordinator Commissioner Chris Hall, District 2 Collier County Board of County Commissioners Phone 239.252.8602 Sign up for the District 2 newsletter HERE! Under Florida Law, e-mails are public records. If you do not want these released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. From: steve.heil@heilauction.com <steve.heil@heilauction.com> Sent: Friday, December 2, 2022 6:15 PM To: HallChris <Chris.Hall@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Isles of Capri EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Mr. Hall, please cast a no vote on the rezoning on our island. We purchased here because of the natural beauty and the fantastic sunsets we experience almost every evening. This will change all of that. No more sunset views only big out of place buildings blocking them from us. Please don't let us be like the East coast. Thank you, Steve and Cindy Heil 422 Samar Ave. =2 Ilk wow r 4f 2022-10-21 19-14,-57 -dil Please don't take this away from us! Sent from my iPhone From: JarvisLouise To: Dianna Quintanilla Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Isle of Capri Date: Friday, December 16, 2022 10:24:00 AM Attachments: imaoe001.png Commissioner Hall is available at gam on January 5th at the District 2 office on Orange Blossom and Airport Roads. Will that work? Louise Jarvis, Executive Coordinator Commissioner Chris Hall, District 2 Collier County Board of County Commissioners Phone 239.252.8602 Sign up for the District 2 newsletter HERE! Under Florida Law, e-mails are public records. If you do not want these released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent: Thursday, December 15, 2022 1:48 PM To: JarvisLouise <Louise.Jarvis@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Meeting Request: Isle of Capri EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Good afternoon, Rich, along with Aubrey F., would like to meet with the Commissioner on the Isles of Capri project that is scheduled for the January loth BCC. Availability Thursday, January 5th anytime Friday, January 6th 1:00 — 4:00 Monday, January 9th 11:30, 3:00, 3:30 Please let me know which date you prefer. Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla Administrative Assistant CYK The Northern Trust Building COIEMAN 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P:239.435.35351 F:239.435.1218 dauintaniIlana cvklawfirm.com Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman, Yovanovich & Koester, P.A., intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged, confidential, and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dauintanilicA) Iawfirm.com or call (239) 435-3535, and permanently dispose of the original message. From: HallChris To: Joan Coyne Subject: Re: Meeting Today Date: Monday, December 12, 2022 7:25:04 PM Enjoyed meeting y'all as well. I understand about C-3. Warmly, Chris Sent from my iPhone On Dec 12, 2022, at 5:53 PM, Joan Coyne <lordca1109@gmail.com> wrote: EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Hello Commissioner Hall Thank you for the meeting with us today. We appreciate you listening to us. Something we failed to mention but you probably realized without us saying, we do not want to compromise. It has to be C-3. Good luck in your new endeavor. If you have any questions we did not answer please let me know. Again, Thank you very much Joan Coyne SaveCapri.org 109 W. Pago Pago Dr. Naples, F134113 239-272-0327 From: John MUELLER To: Chris Hall Subject: Thank you Date: Tuesday, December 13, 2022 5:05:01 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Chris, Congratulations again on winning the District 2 Commissioners position in the recent elections. Thank you for meeting with with our group yesterday and allowing us to share our concerns regarding the reZoning proposal by Fiddlers Brach and Yacht LLC for Isles of Capri. As we discussed, Save Capri.Org was formed exclusively to fight this reZoning. The following is our Mission Statement. We the people are not opposed to development on Isles of Capri. We are opposed to any change or variance that will allow Mid or high rise residential towers to be build in the C-3 business zone on the Isles of Capri. We strive to protect the delicate environment of Rookery Bay National Estuarine Research Preserve. Our mission is to insure that no harm be done to the Isles of Capri community, it's environment, waterways or surrounding Rookery Bay Reserve waters and wetlands by the building of structures that are not compatible with the C-3 zoning or the Isles of Capri. Chris, Thank you again for your time yesterday and should you have any questions please feel free to contact us. Good luck managing the fire hose! John Mueller President, Save Capri.Org 239-206-6751 Sent from John's iPad From: Kathy Kurtz To: Rick LoCastro; Aixa Capizzi; Burt Saunders; Bill McDaniel; Sue Filson; Chris Hall; Louise Jarvis; Dan Kowal; Sarina Francis Subject: Tuesdays vote re: Isles of Capri Date: Sunday, January 8, 2023 1:47:09 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Hi. I am writing in regards to this coming Tuesday's Board of Commissioner's meeting and your vote on the rezoning on Isles of Capri. The planning commission found this project to be not compatible with the surrounding area and I ask you to please take their advice. Buildings of the size that is being requested is completely out of sync with the rest of Capri. They in no way, shape or form will fit in with the feel of the rest of the island. The residents on Capri are asking you to please vote NO to rezoning on our business island. We would like to keep the business island business. We don't want a private community that Capriers can not use, we don't want giant buildings destroying the views of the island, we don't want something that will make our island feel like Marco or Naples. We moved to Capri because of the smallness, because of the nature, because it's out of the way of the giant structures. We are a down to earth neighborhood. Yes, there are some big beautiful homes and likely more to come. But it's still very limited in size. These proposed huge structures and gated area will take away from the community's beauty and peace. We would like to be able to enjoy the businesses on our business island. If this rezoning is approved, other businesses on that island will do the same. And then what do we have?... a bunch of huge residential towers and no restaurants or shops to serve the Isles of Capri residents... and no restaurants or shops to bring visitors from Marco or Naples. What a huge disappointment Capri could become... How very sad! Please help save our island life. Vote NO to rezoning. Thank you. Kathy Kurtz 239-289-9211