Agenda 12/13/2022 Item #16K11 (To reappoint a member to the Immokalee Beautification Advisory Committee)12/13/2022
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to reappoint a member to the Immokalee Beautification Advisory Committee.
OBJECTIVE: To reappoint a member to the Immokalee Beautification Advisory Committee, to a four -year term
expiring on September 23, 2026.
CONSIDERATIONS: This seven-member committee was established by Ordinance No. 11-39, as amended by
Ordinance No. 20-47, to assist the Board of County Commissioners in the business affairs of the Immokalee
Beautification Taxing District, and prepare and recommend an itemized budget to carry out the business of the
district for each fiscal year. Members must be electors of Collier County and qualify in one of the following
categories: Four members shall be permanent residents within the MSTU, and three members may be an owner of
a business or commercial property within the MSTU or may be an appointed representative of a non -profit entity
operating within the MSTU. Terms are 4 years. A list of the current membership is included in the backup.
There is a seat on this committee which expired in September 2022. The vacancy was advertised and the following
application was received:
APPLICANT CATEGORY DIST. VOTER ADVISORY COMM.
Ana Patricia Estrella* Appointed representative
of a non-profit
5 Yes Immokalee Beautification
Advisory Committee
(January-September 2022)
*reapplying
ATTENDANCE: Ms. Estrella has had four absences this year. Attendance records are included in the backup.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: At its meeting on November 16, 2022, the committee voted
unanimously to recommend that Ms. Estrella be reappointed to her seat on the committee. Recommendation memos
from the committee and from St. Matthew’s House are included in the backup.
FISCAL IMPACT: None.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: None.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This item is approved as to form and legality and requires majority vote for Board
approval. -JAK
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners adopts the Committee Recommendation, and
authorizes the Chair to execute the attached resolution confirming the reappointment.
PREPARED BY: Jeffrey A. Klatzkow, County Attorney
AGENDA DATE: December 13, 2022
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. IBMSTU Backup 12.13.22 (PDF)
2. IBMSTU Membership List 12.13.22 (PDF)
3. IBMSTU Resolution 12.13.22 (PDF)
16.K.11
Packet Pg. 2631
12/13/2022
COLLIER COUNTY
Board of County Commissioners
Item Number: 16.K.11
Doc ID: 24076
Item Summary: Recommendation to reappoint a member to the Immokalee Beautification Advisory Committee.
Meeting Date: 12/13/2022
Prepared by:
Title: Legal Assistant – County Attorney's Office
Name: Wanda Rodriguez
12/05/2022 2:02 PM
Submitted by:
Title: County Attorney – County Attorney's Office
Name: Jeffrey A. Klatzkow
12/05/2022 2:02 PM
Approved By:
Review:
Corporate Business Operations Debrah Forester Additional Reviewer Completed 12/05/2022 2:05 PM
County Manager's Office Geoffrey Willig Additional Reviewer Completed 12/05/2022 3:12 PM
Office of Management and Budget Debra Windsor Level 3 OMB Gatekeeper Review Completed 12/05/2022 3:15 PM
County Attorney's Office Jeffrey A. Klatzkow Level 3 County Attorney's Office Review Completed 12/05/2022 4:33 PM
Office of Management and Budget Susan Usher Additional Reviewer Completed 12/06/2022 12:13 PM
County Manager's Office Dan Rodriguez Level 4 County Manager Review Completed 12/06/2022 1:26 PM
Board of County Commissioners Geoffrey Willig Meeting Pending 12/13/2022 9:00 AM
16.K.11
Packet Pg. 2632
16.K.11.a
Packet Pg. 2633 Attachment: IBMSTU Backup 12.13.22 (24076 : Recommendation to reappoint a member to the Immokalee Beautification Advisory Committee.)
TO: Wanda Rodriguez, ACP, Advanced Certified Paralegal
Office of the County Attorney’s
FROM: Debrah Forester, AICP, Director
Collier County Community Redevelopment Agency
DATE: November 30, 2022
SUBJECT: Recommendation to the BOCC for filling its vacancy on the
Immokalee Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee
____________________________________________________________________________________
The Immokalee Beautification MSTU Advisory committee has reviewed one application by the prescribed
deadline for its vacancy. Applicant was evaluated by staff based on their potential contributions to the
Committee. The applicant meets the criteria required to be eligible for the committee and resides and
works within the MSTU’s district boundary.
At the November 16, 2022 advisory committee meeting the board voted unanimously 5-0 to re-appoint
Ana Estrella for the vacant term as indicated below. Please see Attendance Log for the past 2 years.
NAME
TYPE OF
APPOINTMENT
TERM
EXPIRES
FIELD OF EXPERTISE/CATEGORY
Ana Estrella
Appointment
Representative of Business or
Non-Profit in the MSTU.
09-23-2026 Resident of Collier County – District 5
15+ years, Current Director for Immokalee
Friendship House engaging with the community to
provide resources, referrals and services to the
community of Immokalee.
Background: 30 years experience working with the
community in one form or another.
16.K.11.a
Packet Pg. 2634 Attachment: IBMSTU Backup 12.13.22 (24076 : Recommendation to reappoint a member to the Immokalee Beautification Advisory Committee.)
Immokalee Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee Member Attendance Log FY 2020-2022
Committee Member Nov 20'Dec Jan 21'Feb Mar Apr May June July Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan 22'Feb Mar Apr May June July Aug Sep Oct Nov
Total
Absent
Bernardo Barnhart A NM X X A X X NM NM NM NM X X X X X X X A X NM NM X X X 3
Norma Garcia X NM A A X X A NM NM NM NM X X X A A A X A X NM NM X A A 9
Cherryle Thomas X NM X A A X X NM NM NM NM NB A A X X X A X X NM NM X X X 5
Andrea Halman X NM X X X X X NM NM NM NM X X X X X X X A X NM NM X X X 1
Peter Johnson X NM X X X A X NM NM NM NM NB NB NB NB NB NB NB NB NB NM NM NB NB NB 1
Christina Guerrero NB NM NB NB X X X NM NM NM NM X A X A A X A A A NM NM X X X 6
David Turrubiartez Jr.NB NM NB NB X X X NM NM NM NM X X X X X X X X X NM NM A X X 1
Ana Estrella NB NM NB NB NB NB NB NM NM NM NM NB NB NB X A X X A A NM NM A NB NB 4
X = Present in person or via Zoom
A = Absent/Excused
NM = No Meeting held
NB = Not on Board during this period
16.K.11.a
Packet Pg. 2635 Attachment: IBMSTU Backup 12.13.22 (24076 : Recommendation to reappoint a member to the Immokalee
16.K.11.a
Packet Pg. 2636 Attachment: IBMSTU Backup 12.13.22 (24076 : Recommendation to reappoint a member to the Immokalee Beautification Advisory Committee.)
16.K.11.a
Packet Pg. 2637 Attachment: IBMSTU Backup 12.13.22 (24076 : Recommendation to reappoint a member to the Immokalee Beautification Advisory Committee.)
16.K.11.a
Packet Pg. 2638 Attachment: IBMSTU Backup 12.13.22 (24076 : Recommendation to reappoint a member to the Immokalee Beautification Advisory Committee.)
Name Home Phone
Appt'd Exp. Date Term
DateRe-appt 2ndExpDate 2nd Term
Work Phone
Immokalee Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee
10/04/88 09/23/92
11/09/21 09/23/25
4 Years
5080 Annunciation Circle, Suite 201
Non-Profit rep. - Immokalee Chamber of Commerce
5
4 Years
District:
Category:
Ms. Cherryle Thomas
Ave Maria, FL 34143
657-5447
() 657-0080
E-Mail:CherryleThomas47@gmail.com
11/08/11 9/23/12
09/22/20 09/23/24
5 Years
809 Jefferson Avenue
Resident in MSTU
2
4 Years
District:
Category:
Ms. Norma Garcia
Immokalee, FL 34142
253-9042
() 658-3630
E-Mail:normagarcia@iw-sd.com
01/25/22 09/23/22 8 Mos.
1312 Christian Terrace
Representative of nonprofit in MSTU
5District:
Category:
Ms. Ana Patricia Estrella
Immokalee, FL 34142
( ) 451-8029
( ) 657-4090
E-Mail:Ana@stmatthewshouse.org
05/22/07 09/23/10
10/11/22 09/23/26
3 Years
1372 Lincoln Ct.
Resident in MSTU
5
4 Years
District:
Category:
Ms. Andrea Halman
Immokalee, FL 34143
657-3426
(443) 807-8997
E-Mail:andean09@me.com
02/27/18 09/23/20
09/22/20 09/23/24
2.5 Years
5198 Roma St.
Representative of business in MSTU
5
4 Years
District:
Category:
Mr. Bernardo Barnhart
Ave Maria, FL 34142
( ) 229-3697
E-Mail:bbarnhart@first1bank.com
Monday, December 5, 2022 Page 1 of 3
16.K.11.b
Packet Pg. 2639 Attachment: IBMSTU Membership List 12.13.22 (24076 : Recommendation to reappoint a member to the Immokalee Beautification Advisory
Name Home Phone
Appt'd Exp. Date Term
DateRe-appt 2ndExpDate 2nd Term
Work Phone
Immokalee Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee
02/23/21 02/23/25 4 Years
1411 N. Apple St.
Resident in MSTU
5District:
Category:
Ms. Christina M. Guerrero
Immokalee, FL 33935
( ) 289-8862
E-Mail:christinaflbys@gmail.com
02/23/21 02/23/25 4 Years
1014 Warden Lane
Resident in MSTU
5District:
Category:
Mr. David A. Turrubiartez, Jr.
Immokalee, FL 34142
( ) 938-4505
( ) 318-5548
E-Mail:dturrubiartez1@gmail.com
Monday, December 5, 2022 Page 2 of 3
16.K.11.b
Packet Pg. 2640 Attachment: IBMSTU Membership List 12.13.22 (24076 : Recommendation to reappoint a member to the Immokalee Beautification Advisory
Name Home Phone
Appt'd Exp. Date Term
DateRe-appt 2ndExpDate 2nd Term
Work Phone
Immokalee Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee
This 7 member committee was established by Ordinance No. 11-39, as amended by Ordinance
Nos. 20-47 and 21-30, to assist the Board of County Commissioners in the business affairs of the
Immokalee Beautification Taxing District, and prepare and recommend an itemized budget to
carry out the business of the district for each fiscal year. Members must be electors of Collier
County and qualify in one of the following categories: Four members shall be permanent
residents within the MSTU, and three members may be an owner of a business or commercial
property within the MSTU or may be an appointed representative of a non-profit entity operating
within the MSTU. Terms are 4 years.
cc: Christie Betancourt 867-0028
Debrah Forester, CRA Director: 867-0025Staff:
125.01FL STAT:
Monday, December 5, 2022 Page 3 of 3
16.K.11.b
Packet Pg. 2641 Attachment: IBMSTU Membership List 12.13.22 (24076 : Recommendation to reappoint a member to the Immokalee Beautification Advisory
RESOLUTION NO. 2022 – ___
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA REAPPOINTING ANA ESTRELLA TO THE
IMMOKALEE BEAUTIFICATION ADVISORY COMMITTEE.
WHEREAS, Collier County Ordinance No. 11-39, as amended by Ordinance No. 20-47,
established the Immokalee Beautification Advisory Committee to advise the Board of County
Commissioners (Board) on matters pertaining to the Immokalee Beautification Municipal
Service Taxing Unit (MSTU); and
WHEREAS, Ordinance No. 20-47 provides that the Advisory Committee shall be
composed of seven members, all electors in Collier County: four members shall be permanent
residents of the MSTU; three members may be an owner of a business or commercial property
within the MSTU or an appointed representative of a non-profit entity located within the MSTU;
and
WHEREAS, there is a vacant seat on this Committee which expired on September 23,
2022; and
WHEREAS, the Board previously provided public notice soliciting applications from
interested parties; and
WHEREAS, the Immokalee Beautification Advisory Committee has provided the Board
with its recommendation for reappointment.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that ANA ESTRELLA, as an
appointed representative of a non-profit entity, is hereby reappointed to the Immokalee
Beautification Advisory Committee to a four-year term expiring on September 23, 2026.
THIS RESOLUTION ADOPTED upon majority vote on this 13th day of December, 2022.
ATTEST: BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
CRYSTAL K. KINZEL, Clerk COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:_____________________________ By:_____________________________
, Deputy Clerk William L. McDaniel, Jr., Chairman
Approved as to form and legality:
___________________________
Jeffrey A. Klatzkow
County Attorney
16.K.11.c
Packet Pg. 2642 Attachment: IBMSTU Resolution 12.13.22 (24076 : Recommendation to reappoint a member to the Immokalee Beautification Advisory