Loading...
CR Documents 01/25/2022 R CAD fl) CD D O -G O 'a 3 = CO 0 mCD r- co r m cD = � � 0 w C -<I3j 00 5• FIT CL C D z c an a) 5G) Z -0 r m � m � o E `r' CD > 5 — < o o j 0 co E =i — = 1" m cn -4 -I cm„ D n Z 0 z cn m z ./, 0 0 mz D zm �� E nO -1 Pz ( ■ -o -1 O c0 o N m oo x c) c V 0 Z m m c_w m r0 m --ID Z cn 73 E W W O - " Z m Z 0 al 0z 0 � T M 0 � m = o � a Cl. --� 0 D m mm> 73 cn 0 o hia 00 = � OODZ cn xi xi - M I- w o z 0 2 2J D Z Z N O7:1 . —1 Cc0o N F o ,� Op 7 � mM O � � O . O1 C) Q r Wo W x0 n -I � 2 m n088 0 -Ti 0mr -Z-1xiOm � —1 0o o0 m oO D mzm z � Z m 0 0 K OD � c � m 70 in rzi D -100m 73 1 co C m / m -D m Z --1 cp _ ram- ccnnD D. 71 S m ern O OD Z r- c o � > mr <� m o = 0 cno J 11 mO W D m m rn -< Z < Z Cl) G) '&3 --1 m G) (/) v) --I r m 73ymZ ,C Dzr D� o = 0° (/' m -< � m = = 0 Pzi m m m ci) 0 I- m 0 > "AGz) D z _ � mz SU 'a CCD , CD_ CD CO cn-G o, CD m73 `C • ,I... Q m c S )_D '''1 = 0 m o m r- 0-'- F 2 3 m � m Omm o r. CD 0 -2 -5 m w oo .c�D O m om' p w m Z z � -I 0 zOz 1► O m0 ., -mi 7 m '•1 O fb 11.1 C1 zoo m � D II G� zz .....__IDm M TI r o m C5 > 0 O D I Z m O °m° m * 0 O O oD z __ m z = � W CO zo C � = OC ,, mmw QCD m � T 0) P0w o cn co mcci) �` --C-Im N a m7, m 73 0 m zz �► c, Maim mT wm 0 rF O xix O mz 000 -- 00c 0c0= oo zmT0 xo - —il r Co O o0z 0 m ., ZmmO Co z si O 1— cp O CD , 0 CO oo _ �C� C m o Z o � a D � m zoo 1 W � xi mpc O • m m T cn > , ram' cnD z • 1111 > oxi D mco2, rn 0 0z � 0 = v 005 r 73 m0 o = U) 2 < Z Cl) 0mm m m o --i r m 0 O D D m Z -I0 m vz r r- xi oD -< mm1O r' C < I 0 co (J" -< m _ 70 m z � ,I.: z = 0 D 55 XI Z in � = CO -G Cl)c O = CD . o CO C • =' o O. n D co cn DJ r m t— n r r0 rt CD m a n z (7) m cnm � Z c(n 0 — O - m z-1 0 m - O r" ADO L__ m 7, —zi —I cn073 z = � �._ 4...rn CO xz zo m — D Dmm czz T r- 0 m Cn D O 00 C m -< m z r CO "--' r o -rm * O O 0 D = —I W o ) -- r^ Z zO Z = _mow �� CO —I o73 C = zu, D CD = oc t1 mpca - Q. m 'U Cn n cD/) Q o —I o m -1D N - Q. D --1 , m 73 < Cl) a 03 = O =1 m 1 FC r" zm t7 --1mz ...... rift IT7 71 o co o ' o(-i "< m O xxO 0 C� aen Cmco — 30 oor �� 73 O O (- CD _ op no -m m0 > z N m m0 �0, > + o O �5' .mme m = z C)Or° Zm 0 oN -n n ooO-I 0 Cn Dr � 3 dv o Z z D D ,- m O z � � r" '' ^^ inrr -1 D-- -z Cho O Al V' oo cn m o C`"— my m v' ory cD C m c O omJ rn . * 0 ozc o = p oom r'� m O 0o --i cn ` Z < z COm v' m = —I m0 Cn mo °:' y 0 = 0 O D D D D " (Fpz O r0 VoD ".< m -n co -< _ W-< m = o -<_ 1 m z73 cn C) - z = o D pa -a CD CD , m Ct2 -‹ CD `o CD r nn SU D = o m ou Do c. -I , ►• D • • r- 0a, r- �; CD 0 Corn M � m � = rn ccnn -z-i -I KOc7 cD Ni O z 5 m c�nm0 : V /V .Z z C i -0o o zmGc 3 I. 0 ill , -zi -1 ccnn xTrn 073 - 1 &) m = - zg oz z nmmm m Gz ''N..i-n 1--• 0 m c- Do O 7:3Om0 i m -< z m ___I-- co .... � r0 =1 m _� * 0 iv Z Z = -<83 � O CO 2 22 -C-I mew c > (D -� 0 cn r- 0 cn v Q. O TI m =1D cn c EU w = � O � -C-im cn _a r XM -imz 0 IMMim -1 0 7' -< _= m N 0 CD O 70x O m0Co )i`-' g 3 -I cn 0 C ou r- - — CD 2 rn m � n x) zo I-- co 0 O 0 0 z rt O rn z -Di Co z 1 ` -a -O xjc IMTI = gym C7� xj Z z C TO Con omo4 /G rrl z0 Z D 0 D * m 200 to � -i D zo0 0 n U i m o •-4- y m m y 0 ,—J r. D --i z o_ \./ MT O 0mm AIo D — M -I *Cn cn 0 0zc Z < Z Cn Cr) m = m 0 (q m mcoD o -a r- mm O x, za 1 Z o r- r D o z r � o 73 0D '-< mmO r c < —I -zio -< -< � m zE5 cn 0 -< z = o D Xi X Z D 0A CD cD CD CO , CD 3 CC -GO CD CD S CD -< o m CAD m O oo 70 = o r > z c , fD SW 0 0 z -v = 0 m a -< m * , > � � r � x \ CD aC7 vom =10 = \ 3 m c -zi =1 ( > 0 zc„ m z • Z c� O cmz p zm 0 - 0 = z C O (� 'U � r— mz O ON C --I U' z = 0 w ) ' Z m m Co_W \ �',�' m —+ D O m -1 z cn i(7 0 c000O O D --1m warm D Z o f z o A La 070Ca0I` D --TiCD—I —i0 m o m = 0 -< -i. cr � m m- 0 �� p D oIx) Togo u) 0 tv CO zm 77 � 73n .QQ. 2 —1 OT "N � n ,J N CD O XX Ozzn' ..- = —I ci� 0 CiOo cn IT1 mOLp O amca)p O I— cn 0 O z W D m rn z 0 0 z r ". m 0 Ni 0 () DC7N (76 fmTl O ° Zoom D * m py ‹ c \ r- z Xnm7 PO Ofn r mC 1 co CI n m z � CZ7 m � 65 = � > � am m O OD ~ mill m �CCn op m 0 * p � 0 m m 0 ZI v CO - D m m m -< —Im 0 r CCjj O� —1 —I D —Icn r mm O z = n , Z a D 0 z P- * , xj 0 D '-< --10, 0 _i _ -< m = = o xi m m co0 n m _ z D ma 73 o 0 _ G mz ,� k D 0 CD �Xi Z. CD -< o m CD r C toDa -< O m CD m Q � X = 0 - oco C 0° 0 E r- D z O �? 0 z ,on Sy — mO m n � _CDDImimmi D � � r" _{ 0 = �' CD 0 w m < 0 =. m � � mz x) 3 0 z cn m z ( Z O rnz v zm a' O --I 0 z 0 r no -1 O c0 = z � CDm Ozm w c.._ v Z wDm �0 DO � -I co ...3 zu) 0O ,W O=Im zO 0> ZR Z _. T1 Z O - 0 m � K � mp �< �a�. ace- co - m � � z m ,, ; gym„ z e-f- O xco CD x Qzzm 0 C coo _ 0g Zm -i � m Q % 0 Imo o m ci)m 0 O Z 0 -i ;0 c m M N.) 00 oW Zo0o n % C3n --I p ( .mno0 0 ° o z � •Zmzm D * m v › . rZ XC� - 0) r- -I n -I O rrri O 1 WC/) XIKKcn rt 1:1 Dm m --ICn = _ - m � O cn � > oX D OD Zr-- 0 cno r , z < Z -• � 0ill m -< , c� r m0 O m = m Z ; y m 0 z I.-, - � m = = 0 x m mx, , co 0 m Z = mz 0 n 0 Xi -IC) 0z m 0 z fl -a al ER CD Y CS2 -G Cr, co CD c rt • = CO c C2. cCl) `� A) rm 0 m D 0 c_rtD ,' (7`S CD 0aom Vim - C.,) 2 ccn -zI I � 00 .ccv z v, 0 5 m T• � oz 0z O 0D ( Or mz70 O m � � -I w 0 x —I 0z = zo e � - 0 0 � z �� z TI r0 m (7) > 0 O 00 C m -z< z I-- CC/ � r0 0 1 m m * Q7 N Z Z = °°Gw CO z0 c -I= 0c _i m0 ``' an T CD m m 0 � Dow CDo 0 0 m M C D N c Q7 m �' O =i m .. a- Sy r x m �7 --1 m z c) m m r 0 OM o 00 O X O m 0 m cp --1 cm0 C o� r- -< = = Xi 0 0 0 ‘ HI m mm - n Xzo -- yO I"'- cn p 0 0 G� z '"' "mil � z DAD o"w O -0W m = zm -0. 0. cp —I O n CA 0 O R vm Za 9 y � m 0 zoo cn � —zi xi moo O G m m O omm �m D CA cnmcn °c w m -1 _ 0z 007 0 01110 r xi 0m 73m 0 p _ _ ,... Z < z m CO 0 = 0 C7 = D ADD lio r- m ,m 0 r Z o r C7 D -C m m W Z 0 co - m m �' C iA��� z = 0 > XI 1 C) C.. 34 C Z CD ID cn . CD CD 3 CO -� co ' " CD c Cl) `� ca r- = O m D O y' D z � r ocom o �� mco _ _ mom 2 cn --i --I O c� c. C z � mgmo " N ZO m c czornz - C• 70- U, o —I zz -r x ��1 D Om z --I u, m = - z oL'-...\ oz z v com z O - --I m -I z m N pa OO GJ m -< z r co _rim r O ZD T Z = -< w zo C -iz CD D G _� mc;,= o 0 =n m ° K cmn 0 » -, o ^ � T CD ii --1 o 0 m -+ D cn c "k Co = O � m cn a r z m �7 -1 m z m owD n ri- O x mC7m 3 _ coC Dir < 00 � o � —i r cno O o0z �- O m i z g D W z v � W m mmz �.. � 0 -1 p n cn DO r _ o o I'T7 O Z D D V D * m v z O Dom/ cn P- -i x, si moo O fWi'I m CD IV CD (_ , rr- � y -i zD " > mm O Om 73 m D D cn mcn 0 o * v � zz, v o0 _m mo o = � Z < z fn cm = —I M0 cn mDOmD C) EG O > DD ={.. r mm �770r Z D r > 0 Z I" K o r xj OD -< mT0 CrJ I— E CI m = z O -Wt � m � z = o > XI CD 3 co D CD = CQ CD -G `o CD C O o = 03 c = Q r C7 D = C- '0 = p m D p e-- -71 rn p m Al co m - m O z m cn -� � CD 3 n mU' mv) O G O cn m e J- Z � oz pmz O r ni mz O > o m zO > m oz 1-1�m Pa 0 -< z O 0 m N r OD r O ! Z -O � Z = _< o CO zO c -i z �, CD m x, cn ,- ncctt Q o -n o � < CD • 13 CI. z K _cn a Sly _ 00 O -{ rn = r x m --I m z m O � m --n -C 0 0 m O - 7 mow = co O Z7 O7 C 0 = 1 O O r Op O OGC) z O m z D D o73 v c m = _ m - C) TOor_ --I CD o --I O n Cn O D r -;�R1 I ) O Z o -1D D * m C� mz 200 C Cn xim O co (,) o my m cnoti CD m mm O 0mm (1 oX D - Cn � m co m o * p 802 -% xi m0 XI o = crnn a Z c z CO 0 — m 7 -4 m0 Cn moOcoD r m m 73 7J D •` Z 0 r > oz I- Or p:j OD -< mm ° E5 0 z = c) D . Xi CD SW CD CD CO CD �' CO c O v = =� 0 Cn c a, _ -� c� D0 ram" m O r- r O .74: \ C) wm m Kmm 1 m v -i m u--i73o -• .... Z 0 z C7 Cnmc o — 2zz O -I z Imo' mZ � , x > 0 �\ m xj -I --I cn G7 73 —I CnZ = - Z0 \ 0 zm° m G_m) zz 0 r- O 171 Cn D n ` M 0 '1 0 C m - z z M r p� .... G r 0 -I m n * 0 ^' D D Z -11 Z = -< o CQ z 0 C __I z �n D CD = G� c _ m 0-`'' CI. -:"-Ti M Sup Km cn r- c' Cn Q 00 = O _1 mcn r- m Z • .� M --. 00 o; 00) m O 3O � xmco O C cm r- M0 73om � n z r � o O 00z v O -mn ; Z --1 - z -0 'V Z z O 0 � WOo 2 O0n ( 5rb m 0 z 04a mz c ) P -i > c:ci o o 0 mm M Cno , cn I- UDrn i D -I z c • m mm O omm . cn o � D mmc m 0 = 0 O0rn xm0 0 = Cn Z < z CI) 0m = -I m0 U) � O -DI C) c O DDD r mm 73 - r �. Z p r > p z I- � O r 73 0 D -% m m 03 rTh -< x Im zc7) 0 } z 2 o D X 73 Z CD S CD CD3 Ct2 0 CD O o CO A) '0 m0 m xi D0 � irF r r" n` r' = (D D �-, Doom o mco _ , -mri 'n A 3 cn -I -1 � 0 0 c2D O mz p cnm � �. Z E cv'n 0 --1 zz z f N, 0 --1 cn m = - z 0 0 00 m Mzz r�, N -ri r 0 m c7 D 0 £ N Pa 0 0 C m � z (�t g r- W r- O K. -=-Im E * ON r 1� 2 CD z __ � Z = -< o CC2 = c c --4 = c_W Q CD D --I 73 m x < Cl) a ma co = O ' R m r- mmm po -+ mz _ AMEN m r OCn0 0 1.+ ---1 0 ?' bG ±= o 1 o m x � O = z - 0 c W rn- --G o oo xm7On zo y `� Or Co 002 m rnz n D` D 4"0 � c m = -Im 9 n� Z z O - r —I co � 0 2 OnC-13 CA Dro rn O ° Z o -Iy k � oz D * m z o Cn rr- -i D Co O xi I co cnm O o �; rn -a m cn 0N cD i> m � m__A * O 0mm cr) m _ m 0 = 0 00 73 x m Z < z Cn 0m = —i rn 0 Cn rn°3 > 0 = G) 0 D D D I rn Z E9oF >r 0 m z f'- O ►- co r c � —1 -z-10 � cn n z = O D 73 CCD Z) cC a 2 �° CQ -<1- o C •CD • CO CD -< o m CD v O Co X = w co c -< On = L-.._10 CI. `- D zc c� PI"' SU ci 0z m 00 m 0 � 2. �-�- r- m r- -H o xi: CD > 55C) oom C O• Jv a cz � � � � 0 z -� m -- z � z woz v nm C•kl � O -I r z N . 1'- mz o � N OM Oz 2 - cam., D o m c_co >6' TI r0 m -ID Z7 00 C. 000 > ' 0 -Im M DIm Z0m> Z 0 = 0 'AO z O c D m m o —I 0a 03 Z, Cn m11 O0 m oO mo c Ma D -1TJ 0o co co = O0 - o m 73 r 0 z 3 CD CD s65---I Om -o Q - ` m 7. 2 O 70 O 73 C C0o cn Ill O O n > m o �`l - Q r- � o � zWD I v v•a m i z 5 0 O z T -n m 0 �. --I � � m 0 m0N Q 0 oc Z o o O o T = 0 � � 0 0 R') O) 0 v zo Z imp (T' D * m lb nco� mo� O s� m m GI Eii -1 m m O 0D m ow Zr- - 0 � p � o l` m 0 7 - Co M Z < z V) 0 - --I -m D (n -I (- 0 mm ma' �O � Z X D > 0z r * r p3 0 D -< - 1 co r- c < -I = m -< m 2 IIT m m m cn � m z 2 mz c) > U D oz _ � mz CDCD CD � rt v = OJ c . = r. R r_ D Cn ca, 'U 1. = O m D O pi- T' 0 oom 5. Kq = 2 m e -z-1 -I - O 0 c21 Z n z (7) m cn m c , • E ccpo 0 zz Q..... I r_3 -I-- vz � Do fi m --1 ---I cn 2 t1 m -I ccnm = � zo (C D zo m ozz �� -f1 r 0 m cn > (x0 m 00C m -< zo� W E * W D O ° D =I CID g Z -n Z = -< wCOz0 C -Iza, D GC � mow QrTI= CD T _J 'I 00 m - D cn c co = � O � -C-im •• a- r- mm X -Imz C m 'n r o Cn 0 C7 e-�1- --I o -mD 0 =zo 0 CD O � C W � � , CD0 Pa O = O M O _p n zzo .1 0 r- wo O o0z rt O m � z M aco � "11 � m m •• cn ( --_. O Pome m mzN 1 n m K r co 0 0 0 _ 0n Cn Ors ^ m O � Z o -3 > 0 p z JD C D � m c- C r- - D - o - xj m- o `11 I mrn D m om'U m m O omm C, D D myCi o w 0 C O z F--, -o r = 0 7' o m . Z7 m O o = Cn Dm m cnm --1 -ZI m o CCjj o 00 D rr mm Z � 6D D 0 z r- 0 5 oD ..0 mmw Th 7<r0 cm = _ no < %. 7J m z U' ccnn C) z = O D 73 7 CD W m D 'V B a CO N CO•`° CD -0p CD 0= -' W C = r 0D = _O n cD..o = o m D o = r-F r m r- o r = CD > 0 ooJ Fri or ncz �� m -1 Oc sn ZmV' 0ocnmc nz omz N0 g cn0 --1 zz c� -1O mo c , rjm —z _1ci v zm m 0 2 z • � i O -oO ^ 'mzm N O A. zO � rs r- O .Z � -n Z = --<< oo . 20 C --1z6., D CD = 0 --I m 0 ) ,b - o O m D D CL —I OD m 1D can SU co = Au O i m N a- r Xm CD — OOcnO t� o "' „ T m -Irmo 9 CD —1 cn o c O Cj = O O 0D z ,3 I- Oco NO cno o` m m M D-TI � m , m n- I � m = zc O � _jCUoo f —I On Cl) yC � Ill O , Z 0 =-ID cF.) v coo f • cn r -iXi m0 � O I DmDoP cD D - n I— cn z m mf,T, 0 0mm tDi� o m > m o v -0 R' o 71 o = CD Dm m wm = --I m 0 CO o 0 D m 0 m 0 O y D D � o r r- mm Z r- m Oz r � Oo 0 D -< m m co n m z __I z Z G) D X1 r CD DODD CD r° CO cn CD CO CD -o o C et o = r ' Ry= 0 _ 0 U D , •N l , -. r CDD oca0 corn rn o . cn --i ---1 : : : - v(0 z cnr, c Z z � 0 .� zz �<: N 0 r- mz > O m -1 -I v `� .-.I cn m = z 0 7. m oo m _ D 4 ym M ozz m r 0 Ill cn a 0 r Xi 000 W _Tim - z N, r-- 1:1 3 " - r 0 -- Z zM Z = --< 8 ,- -I OZ7 C = z � �-- D CD m Oc ii o > > 0_ o = m m (A r- o cn c ,J CCDD -0 Q. D -I 'n 33 < � �- cn a LU CO m o m 0' mm cn 0 o eol• '-1 0 -0 O o z o , 9 "D O o C Wig E<cl j \ cD m 2 -I Cr) Z7 rt 2 00 0yoX m „ -1 C) X z o cn m � z a� a -013 O 0W Z mzN n T 0 - ov 0O o \ 2 00 n C/) a r o rnz D * m C zoo c vi r -z-1 D coo O I m m Fill ap N CD 0 ?N. 1— co a z �' :� ,- m �T' r, o omm o- m 0 = 0 0 0 m "0 rN m 0 �7 0 --1 cn • - am nl cnm -i -I m0 Cn mammy O -I ° _ 0 O Daa r-- mm Z � o � . 73m 0z 1— Or oa -.< Z T, Eo r- CJ -i L' o -Q7< -< � m zcn ccnn C) z = C D X1 7 D0 CAD O CO CD 0 = W �m 2o C c 000 = P. Q. Et z 0 c= _ 0 D G) z -D = O m 0 %�: ,� e--f r- m r -I o = _\ CD D co < o ' 5U 2 m n w m - cCn --I --1 al) a Z Om � v zz . Fl \_ 0 M 65 0 -1 P z ■ -p --1 O C O I- mz o ^, -1 m m = 0 o v oo m C_WN 0-n -0o m zci ^ ) O -0 -I z cn 1" 73 oO a ° c� oo > -r-_im m DCm Z „ Zo o g (D 2 0 a > m ,rn F > __. 07„= C � � p3 c rn 0 K � m O -G • Q D ox � o0o CD o MINIM 70 m 0 m D 2 Irk mm71 mK cn o - 2O � 0C ' K 0c w -1 cn X m --IAA. 6 — IT1 Om p� C.) y m �. Q cn 0 O z w 1 m Pz m 0ODo % =■ -0 -0 m noo P n O o _ OOo = o ° on .w OI n D 0 = O D Cn r- - D m 8 m O ;'s 1 m m 1MT1 z -I C r > m __I --i � D -t m mm ° oy coc Zr- -cn v, m m o * o j z m 70 CO Z < o V) G) CT) I rmmO xD D oz r §r r. cg. iW -< � m = I' O' m m Cn 0 m � m z = mz 0 > 0 xi o G) -i z _ � mz CD CD 13 3 rt' CO 73 c• 0 CD -D .O =, - r D CO n cn � _ CV 0 DO : �= m . I I— m - o P = CD 0 vim m w -zi =-I o c� �. n z ( m cn ; o n Z O cm„ z 0 omz r - 0 M cn0 -I zz � 5 r mz W0X _ --I cn m 2 z o r \,. D zm Im o2z U'- -n r0 rn (7) > 0 X00 o CA) m -< z 1- po r 0 >m m * 0 N Z -n Z = -< � CO zo C -I2c, - D (D = 0 C M m 0_co> Q o = m � T "° a tZ 00 'n m D (I) c coo = CU � O 7 ` m (�`+� `•"• a _ r, mm X -1mz ° � ) -I o m -< o"' o - � ) 3 cD � -0 O = z 2 mo C 03r- -G �co 4 Li = I . 2 0o a2 X � �-'� r- � 0 0 XI c rt O m rm- z M � o, z �1- : � O � c m = Zm 1 0• 2 0 > ro ' Z' 0n v - c zz Zmz C> * mz C/) rr- --I-I D -- O o 0 I W � m j > � = c rn mm O oc CD tc. m ,�,, ' ccnn ov D mom = e " cn m Om 0 _ > m m CI) m -1 _ -I z--I mGi CO m0 • O —I 0 _ 0 O yaa W r m m Z 0 ,-- m p z r p r -G m 0 2 � m z U' z 2 o D X Dc� CD W . CD C.0 1- or CD •CD CO CD r r m CD = -p p W P P o crir Cl. r_ 0Z f _ -In D CD mr " rt CDr K --IO ► - D 55 < 73 O 3 0 W m , - = ,-- ► 0 zU, m z J, Z cnz D zm 0 -I OII O �` `iJ r mZ Div m o z 3 r, 0 D Om m c_w E . r - T rD m -iD O 2 --I Z Cn xj O ° W poOD O- --Im mD r- m Zm m Z O � oo 7 -i O 73 -I p QmK0m = -< , a Cl. .c0 71 O p > 77 N n Aao xo00 ' 303 _ O D 2 — X �7 <r. m 0m r z (D m-4 020 O zZ 2 3C OO cG) v X � -H M TO0O C7 0) mb X-, a D cI r Cn0 Q zooD 'mTI TZ � � Z .. 73 o 'oc m0oo C'� --I o -, (/) � o? P. m o D� mzm p * m 0 D -< c - Fz > � om p X cn I- -I KKU) I my m z -I CD rc> m -H � D w m m O O D coD - ccn 0 mrr- _' m o = 0 Cno �� T m O W m mW Z < z cn 07) -I mD Cr) v, - r mm O M72 D z - S> o §2 00 co � = m m2X m m cn 0 m , z 2 mz 0 D 73 D Z --i 2 mz CD D3 CD D BCO CD •`° cra CD 0 = o -n O - C = Q co C • n cn CO sU -i0 M D0 -D-13 d - m O m %' ert r 1- 0_ r Z CD mm> 55 E 0 co� � 5.14 2 0 z � m cmo ' Z O crp) z 0 omz 0 g cn00 --1 zGz� � N O r T m -z-i —1 m 0 73 �' ' M OD xi m0D f 0 zm m G) zz TI r- 0 m (7) > 0 70 0o m -z< z I- po � � r0 m ry o (Q m -n Z = •-<< w -2 0 C --IzU, D CD O mew-I c 10 R � m � � Ct- o Cr) � ' CL -i p p m m cn cr csuD --ice < n _ co = O = m C' r 7jm o „ o _ m m -< -{= o fl 70 a m0o -�oo 2co —I cn 73 0 c 0 m oo n Zo W _I a7J p b+73m m' zE �Dco �D � � �� � m = mc z O 01- Apo -I 0n Cn yr' o _ =I 0 D :O cn Ill 0 Z 0 =I D 0 z mz D * m 0 2Do i=" z > c Cn r --I --IO o P3 m "0 Dm m Dp � 77. r cn D z m mm 0 cmm � o � Dm � p mo * 00G) p0 X) cn Z m m = D m = • < z Cl) 0WD T -ZI m 0 Cn m 0 -I ' , 1I n G 0 9�' rmm Z 1f01- m - II ► D 0z I< 0 73 oD - m -nW '; -< m = cET, m z 1 EE 0z v 1,, CDSD CD CO NCD • •CDCO CD .� 0 CD o - '� 0 W c = CD E D CO nR ) "0 n On 0 -p = p l ,f, r omo D D � 00 V► 3 m m z -- � 441 0 zcn m rmoc - \ lb Z cmnz 0 Om --ZI 0 - cn 0 m G) r` m m � O w � X m z = � 0 o iti o m - > CI zm m G� zz -n nr o m cn > 0 xi 00 -00 O ^ m -< z O 1- po r0 m g s` 0 i.) o Z � m Z = -< o _I G Czw D N CD u -1 = 0 = c m o 0 � Ill0 > > - O� 7, 'n <_ _ ra = O -1 m • • C> ... I— ,0 m Xi 0 � o m m rrl ..� -1^ m 2 CD -° O m oo —I 0 = z \1/4K1 —1 cn 0 c 0 _I m oo n 73zo O ✓ (i) o O ' oz o m mz g DAD -ate -71 -I --,n I 'o c o m _ -1 m n m O 7303 Z mzry � -n E � 00 -1 r_ , _- � o D 5J- R. os, rn Oz � Z omD D * m 0 zcN ‘\\ � r -1 D poi• 0 XI01 m' = D m mm o73 cmm . It: o � D mcn Cn -1 o nz - M 0 * 0 0 0 m X m0 M o73 = � v > m m wm = R C Z ( ) o UJ D j -Z-1 m0 co m0 --1 1-- mm Z 11oD 1 : D 0 r r 0 0 ` V 3 m m - r o D ^� m n �, z co 1- Cm = -10cn ET-) C) �r n 73 �� t►_� CD" CD CD D Co C fD cQ c .0 � o = 0o C • I•- - ) cn SZ r 0— , cn Sa ---I 0 ei.1 _ -0 17 2 0 m D O �- rt n co m r 0 m r 7-7 � CD m C z m g 3 n cn ---I m cn ._CO700 • / `v zcn m cnmc Z ciio � z , 0 r 73 — 0 xi > 0 x' x N rn "' —zi —I cn0x v Si —I c0nZ 2 � Zg 4 C Zo m Mzz -ii r 0 m Cn > X zm 00w m -< zoEim * 0 Z __ o Z = -WGFca C z 1 = G� c ---I m O w � n T co v SZ D ox m x < > ccn _a- SU 00 = 0 � =im 9. r 73 rn Z7 —I m Z n AM=M m m -n -� 0 (n Om N o eh cD 0 XX C mow g 2 = Cr) 0 0c 0 = r o0 0 00z b '� - 0 m � z M � ooz -ate � c m = zm v n■ TO 0 W --I co �O o _ OIn Dro Q m o azz D C Zoo m cn rr- -zi D COo 0 17 --I o = • m y m U' o N cDJ r D •� Z p, 7 rW rn cn mm 0 omm r. co — cnn D map m --I 0 nzc 0 = 0 00m _XI TI m0 m 0 = CD Z < Z fn pm = --I m G) 0) M S _H> r m m Z7 X r— Z 0 r > 0 z r' K O r xi 0 > -< mm0 E: c —i - o� mco z � c D_ �r 73 -a a� CD2 a. D CO -� CD " ca c . O v = al • �' Q. r D SD C7 TJ = 17 fm' = 0 m r' 0 'xi' rig► D - � r- 0Wrn mco - , mom co -i m cn 0 " 4' Z n z � m cnm � ()1 z I' g 650 O-i zZ � �, 0 M —I —i (n —1 cnz ,_ - zo -,) 'k p o Ci m m Gzz m rO m CnDo L 70 00 CA.) m -< z r' 03 "" r0 -_Im * mN -( Z -- -Dn Z = -< a CO m 0 � m mDD o = xl --1-1 r0LO^ C O.-0—I o -1 > xOxm U a CO - cn • co = n XI =Ii r- �m --I m Z n .�. m r0m o -n -< � m o (D —1 cct 0 C CO C 0 = 2 K " O C 0 r O p O o 0 z �1 - 0 m r- z g D- D o -° c m = gym a .• C7� O � m z mzry �' m r co 0 0 --1 0 n OD r o 70 t1'I OK Z 53 -ID —1 p 00 \,JD * mz CrZ1 co co 73 m r- -I oo O 12 ym m Dom n . D � O � cmnM m m cn co D m cn -1 n7 m o * p 80x, r xi m0 'v o = cn z < z Cn 0m = --1 mG) V) om � D mm 0 > 6 �rI z - CD o��, / Z7 oD -s mTtW v1 r C < _..I --I n W CI "< m = O c cn w 1 z = il XI CDso, ccD D -' 3 2- CO -< m 91. z' r r Ci) cQ (D -D 0 C � = v D:ic ZS o tZ. `= > z C cQ DJ L) G0 z -v = o m c0, � m k � r' rn r-- --r O r.: l CD nco m C O , v) 3 m cz - =� Z el 1 w -i =� Cnz �q` Z 0 z m 0 mz 0 zm OM c„ o _.1 0 z V1 O o P z ° " . m m z \'' ---Ii m = o �l o Z u' v a o m CO_w 1 r 0 m --I D O -0 --1 _ Z (I) m O0 wco0D - EZ im S' Drm �. z m Zoho F „cs2 -I 0X c -D-Ioo D o CD -o -m-I � � V) mP0 - Q D. --I x m OO co p J Cl) 0 A) co = ODo - o z 00 70x DZZN) o =- � --I w C El O o d u m oo nDm � 72 O r- WO O Z Ill ? S' 00z '� 13 --I .� -n m o N n O Z O0o4 _ �- On73 Iv DOA v> m Oz5 Z ozm D � m 0 D � = - rZ -10M i my mz --i CD mCOm m 0 D v m Ir- 0 � 0 cn 0 o m O ;p Co D m m m -G �� -I mG0,� � G) - -I D (b n = 0 0 m = r— mm Z � D D m Z r r :U oD -< =m � Em --I -� -mn X m rn77 c5 0 0m Z = mz a o _G.) Z _ � m 2 CD C - 2 CO -< c FR CO CD -0 . p rt o r CA C . 9 r sZ 17 = -0O DO .-= 1 \ rF D Cz r Kmx = 2 rn cn ---I 1 O 0 CD SP, C� n z � m can J OO ) Z 0 cc oo �v zzmZ r 0 'U _ z m73 > o • m r'' -I —1 ccnn 0 73 ,� h.. , z = com o 70 q-� Dm M G) zz /�-' 71 r 0 m ET) > m ' pa 00 C m -< z m g * 0 • 0 Z - Z = < o 0 -1 z0 C -Iz6_co ,\ D CD = O M m D Dl1/4 o r co2 � 0 x =1im ` a m CD Z , �' m ; -G O 0) 0 N a co r-t� O xix c mnoo CD 3 2 O C co r -G c C -I cn oU O C 0 �..., = OO 0Dom 1- cn O C O z v.- - 0 -° C T = gym ". n� :C7 Z z \ 0 0W '� WOo -1 On Cn ' r ' 0 zK Z c a � m D 2Do r \ Cnn r- --I D TI moo I m` 1 CO m Doi � yD 0 Rr,1 mm O zoom t cn - m D m � p ` rT1 0 = ID O O m mO m o = � Z < z CO 0 = -1 m 0 Cn m O -D-I C) m0 0 D D D0z r" � Or r- oo - z ° W I E 0 -< z = 0 > XI > 0 3 (> 0 - •`° cra CD Fri- cn = c O co o = 0aT Q. co C W O =• -, 5D 0 z co 23 -o T -v mo m 0 � `r°. t r'+' 1"' m 1-- —1O .-t 9J CD D � m < X o CD n CO m M = m cn —_zi --1 cm„ z n . Q, 0o ZE5 m "_ � �' oZ cmnz zmI. M Cn O --I � Z -1 O c O 6 r- mz oN 4- m oo 0 `i r crl y m m c_w TI r 0 m --1 y 77 O0 W WO > - -_Im m DCm w 0 Z o = o •, oCL2 —I 07J C -1oo C- D -0 CD m oK cn mom (° �- cr• Cl.. w CD c-1 op .n ma cn � co xOo0 `n_ OD •• o3r 9j m Z m rl, m -ri ; -< ccii n 0 (D 0- 7373 C CozNo o y —1 cn O o K ,� m -1 -p. E M 0 -O O W m a P 72• 0 1- m 0 O Z o > - v� m rz g 0DZ c■ TI -Ti M �7 Z7 9, C) --I , c m n08 OT pco ZO0 (D n -I � nry P' = 0 n c) O CP m O >" Zmzm D `=-rz D -1om O cn I- can 7J Cr)m m - est M Z-1 Cn3. = D m � O ozD t; M t Al m 0 M e- Z- < z CA 0c—n I • mG) 0 m cn _ Z D D oz r- * � -< m = = TO m m mm cn 0rn--- m mz 0 > m o X o 0 z -1 0 _ _ mz 70 CD SD C CD Co = cn co GO -o 0 Cl) o C 0 _iiD cn o = 0 m D 0 :+ --- -. > � � r- 00C ME o • CD n oom � m � = �� 2 m m v -I -1 - 0 O Sii n z � m Z omcn z v O v 0 cn _� Q mGz) • m mz 0 cnGnu2 .-- m � -I ---I o •—. O O o m � D y m m c Z z (� -n r 0 m Cn > 71 -< m o 00j TmZ I- Co % r0g � m g `* 0 0 i.) Z 5rr Z = -< ED CO z0 C -126, D CD _ � c --i M ' Q o = m 0 m C7 0 D - O O cn m = > ccn t D = � TO x < m to r- m -+ • n' 1" m cm 0 r-I. O ZJ 33 CC m0O7 CCD 2 C r m mm O� J z p rt Dz 0 m D - D o 73 0 0 j m z N m E -1 W o -I O n CO > r , _ O o m O Z c --I D D * m v zoo Cn rr- -z-I D ---I O oo �7I CO Cn hi m -0y m --I D p 4•• n V) m �' c m p * v oz - v o Cxi m "uo = ym m cnm -1 c. -ZI m cn m , D r mm 0 > oD Z 0 r D o z r 0 3 o > -< r r W r-< E ci m Z � o � 70 m z z = 0 D 73 /j', Good morning, Commissioners. My name is Jayne Kim. I am here with other volunteers from Domestic Animal Services to thank you and the county for all the good work, dedication to and support of our county shelter. We hope you are as proud of Domestic Animal Services as we are. You can ask any DAS volunteer why they support DAS. The answer is always the same because of the animals and the people there. There is a reason why people in neighboring counties, in other jurisdictions, and other states share our animal stories and looks to Collier County's shelter as one that does more than most for its animals. If you follow the DAS or volunteer-run social media pages, you can see how frequently posts are shared by people who want others to see what Collier County is doing and how often comments are made by people asking the question —why can't other shelters be like this? Every week, we hear from applicants and adopters who tell us how refreshing it is to see the animals at DAS so happy and so clearly loved. Many adopters keep in touch with the volunteer who assisted them with their adoption and that volunteer shares the happy tail with the rest of the group. So, we are constantly reminded of all the good that DAS does and how appreciative people have been. We are proud of the animal care services that Collier County provides to our community. We hope you are too. I am not only a proud volunteer and foster with Domestic Animal Services. I am also a proud foster for the Humane Society of Naples and have been involved with the Humane Society for as long as I have been involved with Domestic Animal Services (since 2018). But, I am here today representing the many passionate and compassionate volunteers of DAS. I also have been given the authority to speak on behalf of many charitable and non-profit animal organizations in our county. Many people involved with DAS and these organizations could not be here in person because of work or other daily commitments, but they wanted me to assure you that we are united in our opposition to a takeover of DAS functions by the Humane Society of Naples (HSN). These local animal organizations include: • SNIP Collier • For the Love of Cats • Camp Many Paws • Volunteer Services for Animals • QT Kittens • Naples Cat Alliance • Animal Compassion Project • Hopeful Hearts Rescue Inc., and • Animal Task Force of SWFL While many could not be here this morning, I would like to take moment to recognize those who are and were able to take time of out of day to be here and show support for Collier County and its shelter. DAS Volunteers, supporters and friends, please stand. Members of our local rescue partners, please stand. r "k\ 7 arc 02_5I2Z These are the people with their boots on the ground, donating their time, devoting their hearts to the betterment of our community. We are united in a common purpose -- we welcome collaboration, assistance and synergy with each other. Working together, in our respective roles, we are helping our county move forward. In short, we believe that privatizing the county's operation of animal care services and/or enforcement would be an injustice to the animals and to the citizens of this county. I will not reiterate the details of the Humane Society's proposal in which the Humane Society wants the new $6M shelter facility for its own use and the county to pay the Humane Society for services now performed by Domestic Animal Services. That takeover proposal is already public record by memo to this Board dated November 29, 2021. And, we are well aware that this Board did not approve a takeover but, instead, directed that the two organizations explore areas for collaboration and synergy. I don't think there is any animal advocate out there who opposes collaboration, assistance and synergy with others. We are or should be all working towards the same goal. So, we thank you, we thank this board, for that good direction. I am here to report to you, however, that despite this board's direction, the message on the ground has been something quite different. The Humane Society has not re-directed its efforts away from a "takeover" and, instead, towards assistance and collaboration as this board wanted. To the contrary, Humane Society representatives have continue to expressly and directly advocate their takeover proposal even after this board gave direction otherwise. That's why we are here today. We were hoping to see and hear a redirection by the Humane Society at the last DAS advisory board meeting where each agency was to present on areas for and ways to collaborate. The executive director of the Humane Society was unable to attend and, although the Humane Society sent two high-level employees to be at the meeting, the Humane Society said it could not present information without the ED and then asked county staff to also not present. So, there was no presentation made to the board and, consequently, none to the public. The Humane Society further asked that no one on the board even discuss the matter at last week's meeting simply because the ED wasn't available even though members of the public were in attendance and expecting answers. This scenario highlights one of the many troubling concerns about a private organization taking over essential govt run operations. Collier County proudly serves its citizens every day. You know that because you serve every day. The county doesn't get to take sick days. If a county executive is sick, her assistant or her next in line picks up the baton and runs with it. Operations don't come to a halt. The public isn't denied information or delayed in receiving information because one person isn't feeling well. The buck also doesn't stop with one county executive. At Domestic Animal Services, for example, if a member of the public has an issue or concern and the ED is unavailable, the shelter manager or a supervisor or other staff is there to respond. The public can also go above the county ED at any time by directly contacting the Dept Head, the DAS Advisory Board, this Board, County Counsel, or make Public Records Requests to obtain information. One of the many benefits of a county-run shelter is that, like all government agencies, it has a system of checks and balances in place to ensure (1) transparency, (2) consistency, and (3) accountability. People have asked representatives from the Humane Society for basic information and posed very simple questions. For example: Would the Humane Society operate as an open admissions shelter? Would the Humane Society open its records to the public to same degree that Domestic Animal Services does currently? Simple requests for the Humane Society's euthanasia numbers and data related to its behavior & rehabilitation program have gone unanswered. If anyone wants to know how the Humane Society would operate under contract with the County—just take a look at how it operates now. And then, in contrast, think of what this county has and continues to accomplish every day. Our county shelter is operating at a 97% live release rate. That is amazing considering that the county shelter takes in more than 5000 animals annually. As a county run organization, DAS follows county COVID guidelines and has safely operated through the pandemic. DAS didn't close its doors to the public. As a county run organization, DAS continues to provide affordable adoption fees, unlike the private non-profit which currently charges $475 to adopt a puppy. As a county run organization, DAS records are subject to the sunshine law and, therefore, the public is entitled to and assured a level of transparency and accountability. Moreover, as a county run agency, Domestic Animal Services must put the animals of Collier County first. That means that DAS doesn't import animals from other states, from Puerto Rico, or otherwise seek to increase the animal population here for the sake of donations or media attention. If anyone tells you that Collier County needs to import animals because there aren't enough adoptable animals here (importing animals, some of which are under-socialized, escape their homes and end up increasing our homeless population), you should seriously question their motives and then come to the shelter, take a ride with SNIP or go for a ride along with an ACO, check out one of the local rescues groups here who have many adoptable animals in needs of homes. In sum, the Humane Society operates very differently. Now, different isn't bad. The Humane Society does good work, they have good people fighting the good fight. And doing things differently may work well for the Humane Society. Kudos to them for what they do. Because different organizations working together towards a common purpose is a good thing. That kind of collaborative diversity can be extremely helpful and productive but when we are talking about ceding county operations to a private non-profit—the very survival of which depends on big money donors and special interests -- proceed with caution. Take a look at other jurisdictions which have tried a public-private contract with the local humane society. Look at how those jurisdictions experienced the higher costs involved in that kind of contract relationship. With your permission, I have not only prepared my statement in writing but attached a clear and simple information request sent to the Humane Society on January 9th (more than two weeks ago) and articles reporting on the failure of county-humane society contracts in other jurisdictions. (READ ST. LUCIE Quote) We submit that our county is also better off continuing to run its own shop. The County has put in place a new management team at its shelter. The County has been making improvements to the existing shelter while moving forward to build a new shelter facility. It's an exciting time for all of us in Collier County and we, your county volunteers, can't wait to see what more the County will accomplish with these new resources. We sincerely hope that you will let your newly selected shelter team move this county forward and continue to do us all proud. Because the bottom line is that we can never have too many resources or organizations tackling the very real community problem of pet overpopulation. And, it will be county citizens and the animals who lose out if either the Humane Society or Domestic Animal Services takes over functions of the other. There is enough need to keep both agencies very busy and operating well. Collier County is better served with both working together, not one assuming the other. We heard this board say something similar -- that the two agencies should explore areas for collaboration and syngery (not a takeover). We heard that but it appears that some did not. And that is why we are here taking up your time today. Thank you very much for your time and consideration. St. Lucie County backs out of Sunrise Humane Society 1/24/22, 5:06 PM 630 West Paim Beach,FL Le, News Weather Hurricane Guide Traffic Sports Calendar South Florida Weekend A Child's Home Watch Live Ck, High Surf Advisory Is In Effect X ADVERTISEMENT St. Lucie County backs out of Sunrise ADVERTISEMENT Humane Society .,- __ v , ..! ... . ., .0.,,,, • , ,----„, 0/161.111$1°' . . .....00---:. i * r.• s 41 a• ik d: si 01410.,? rr ...., '1v- ,,,,041,c•e,,,.., I° • ...:. , : ,,'4,.7:',:-•0 ., 4 . 4 "• ' .04. ; . ••,... .•ft..• ...".‘-. ' .), , .,..,..i„ ,...-....- .. , . , '._240•:"._ -s.-,:-_;_l_1:;-__ 1 ' ___ .-, By Meghan McRoberts Published:Nov. 15,2021 at 10:56 PM EST ° avec, There's some shakeup in the animal welfare world in St. Lucie County. The county is backing out of its contract with the new Sunrise Humane Society in Fort Pierce.The partnership was between the county,city and shelter. County leaders said they no longer felt the shelter's plan for the future was sustainable. https://www.wflx.com/2021/11/16/st-lucie-county-backs-out-sunrise-humane-society/ Page 1 of 8 St. Lucie County backs out of Sunrise Humane Society . 1/24/22, 5:06 PM Now,at least two Sunrise Humane Society board members have resigned following the failed negotiation. ADVERTISEMENT The Sunrise Humane Society opened to the public over the summer as a much-needed reset from previous turmoil by a previous shelter. The previous Humane Society of St. Lucie County was ousted amid code violations,animal welfare concerns and the death of a volunteer. The Sunrise Humane Society was formed as a fresh start for the city,with new leadership,a newly updated and upgraded building,and a promise of better management and transparency. County officials said during the negotiation for the 2021-22 budget,the shelter asked for a budget increase of$275,000. ADVERTISEMENT The county said it was willing to pay more money, but only if the city of Fort Pierce would match the Most Read same contribution. Fort Pierce was willing to pay about$15,000 more,but not enough to meet the county's contribution. "At the same time,a local veterinarian who has worked with the county through 4-H and a number of other projects,the temporary shelter at the airport,said he was looking to scale back his business," Frost Advisory in effect St.Lucie County spokesman Erick Gill said. for inland areas early. Monday morning In scaling back,the veterinarian offered to sell his property at the Midway Veterinary Hospital.The county now plans to purchase that property,hire new employees and add upgrades to the property Woman,child found for sheltering animals at a cost of$1.3 million. dead at Port St.Lucie ••,ttt. hotel ADVERTISEMENT Person pulled from canal near Palm Beach International Airport Woman shot and killed �•••"•• 4-year-old,h4301EMl$ffMEN � "We just realized I think it's time for St. Lucie County to manage its own shelter,"Gill said. "We control it.We don't rely on a third-party vendor to come in and say we can do it for this price,and they realize six months,a year down the road,they realize it's going to cost more." Following the failed negotiation,at least two board members for the Sunrise Humane Society turned in their resignation. Susan Parry,founder of United for Animals,said in her letter, in part: https://www.wflx.com/2021/11/16/st-lucie-county-backs-out-sunrise-humane-society/ Page 2 of 8 St. Lucie County backs out of Sunrise Humane Society 1/24/22, 5:06 PM 'We have also taken into consideration the obviously failed contract negotiations that has resulted in the ending of any hopes of a united community set on a path ;of potentially becoming no kKill. Our community is now divided and now precious Iresources that could've funded SHS operations is lost. As current board members, it was very uncomfortable to say the least sitting in the St. Lucie County Commission chambers and having to listen to the failures of 1SHS representatives not providing answers to reasonable questions as well as being accused of not providing critical responsible statistical information needed to aide in contract negotiations. 1 Much more could be said as reasons for our resignations, but the most impactful 'reason is the fact that SHS representatives accepted a contract proposal from the city of Fort Pierce that we believe is unsustainable leaving no hope of being capable of responsible shelter operations. SHS representatives accepted a city 1$150,000 contract proposal and didn't support the county's offer to the city of ;sharing and splitting a$500,000 contract proposal stating also that the county was expecting too much in services. We believe we will better serve shelter animals and community animals by putting energy and resources elsewhere." ADVERTISEMENT Current shelter leadership said they remain committed to serving homeless animals in Fort Pierce.The city said it will also look for more ways to help the shelter be successful. Scripps Only Content 2021 Latest News https://www.wflx.cam/2021/11/16/st-Iucie-county-backs-out-sunrise-humane-society/ Page 3 of 8 From: Subject: Exp ora ion o a ners ip Opportunities(HSN-DAS) ` • Date: January 9,2022 at 10:29 PM To: Sarah Baeckler Davis sarah@hsnaples.org Hello, Ms.Baeckler Davis, I recently read your memo to the Board of County Commissioners,dated November 29,2021, and am requesting additional information to better understand your proposal and to form an opinion as a tax-paying resident of Collier County. I am a proud dog foster for both HSN and DAS. I have always believed that our community is better served with both organizations (and others)working together towards the common good of addressing the homeless pet population because,as you know,the overpopulation of homeless animals is a serious problem and we are fighting a never-ending battle.So, I'm interested in understanding how your proposal would serve our county better than HSN&DAS supplementing and co-existing with each other. I hope you will answer the following questions to better enlighten me and the public. 1. If HSN assumed all current DAS functions,would HSN operate as an open admissions shelter? 2. Would HSN provide the same public access to data/information as CCDAS currently does under the Sunshine Law? 3. You've stated that HSN would provide a lower euthanasia rate.What was HSN's euthanasia rate for the past four years(2018- 2021)? 4. I've heard that HSN dramatically reduced the number of animals it pulled from CCDAS over the last four years. Is that true?If so, why? 5. You've stated that HSN would provide behavioral training and rehabilitation. I am an advocate of such training and rehabilitation. How many animals are currently housed at the Oaks Campus?Of those animals,what its the average length of stay they have been with HSN?Has HSN ever transferred a"behavioral training"animal to another shelter,rescue or organization?If so,how many and why? Answers to these questions would be very helpful and I hope to hear back from you soon.Thank you for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Jayne Kim 1/24/22, 5:01 PM Clermont Animal CARE Humane Society Has Concerns After County Takes Back Shelter Operations Starting Jan. 1,the county will take back operations of its animal shelter after commissioners rejected a bid to renew a contract with Clermont Animal CARE Humane Society,the animal welfare organization that has been managing the facility since 2018. By Maiia Zummo IIIt .t: I ` - .� •..,„_ t't- , . ,..,.,11, L . ..„,,, ,...: . . ,.., .. , . .- : f 4. r +fit ,te e J E / j'L'Z 7 L ' t . itiV p + 4-0 ..-. -." 3 • -,..icil • • t 1 • 'y 4`- r ^gin Photo:Clermont Animal CARE Humane Society In what has become an emotionally charged story,for obvious reasons,the public—and a local humane society—have major concerns about the future of animal welfare in Clermont County. Starting Jan. 1,the county will take back operations of its animal shelter after commissioners rejected a bid to renew a contract with Clermont Animal CARE Humane Society,the animal welfare organization that has been managing the facility since 2018. https://www.citybeat.com/cincinnati/Print?oid=12165779 Page 1 of 8 1/24/22, 5:01 PM That means Clermont Animal CARE has until Jan. 1 to clear the shelter of its remaining animals—currently 20 dogs;all cats have been adopted.The group will also be responsible for any animals that come to the shelter before Dec.29.(See the adoptable doggos on their site.) Clermont County Commissioner Ed Humphrey says all remaining dogs on Jan. 1 are"officially the property of Clermont Animal CARE.We will ask them to take them and failing that,keep them and try to adopt them out or get them to a rescue, humane society or foster home." Clermont County says they were unable to negotiate a contract Clermont Animal CARE—the sole bidder for the job—after the humane society asked for$848,726 to continue operations.That is more than double their current contract of$419,000. "Clermont County countered with a$500,604 proposal for the first year(with 3%more in the second and third years),based on research of what neighboring counties pay for animal services and the fact that Clermont Animal CARE Humane Society was able to provide excellent services with contracts of$310,000,$310,000 and $419,000 in the three-year agreement that expires at the end of 2020,"says Mike Boehmer,Clermont County Communications Coordinator. Boehmer says the humane society rejected that offer.And since no other agency besides Clermont Animal CARE submitted a bid and an agreement couldn't be reached,operations go back to the county. w, M "We are currently in the budgeting process for 2021,"says Commissioner "".""" " " " Humphrey."As it stands,we will need to draw on our reserve balance by approximately$700,000.We simply can't add that much additional to our budget" '-- -- ,,. %. -w _: But Meaghan Colville,director of lifesaving programs at Clermont Animal CARE, '"" argues their request was fair. "--"":41—= "Clermont County offered us$500,000 for the contract.They did not produce a Financials provided by Clermont County budget or how they came up with that number;unlike us,who produced a budget to Commissioners justify our$844,000 budget(vou can find it on our Facebook page);'she says via email."It seems they want to pay what they want to pay,rather than what it actually costs.What's important to remember is that we are unlike any other vendor they work with;we are not trying to maximize profit but instead minimize loss." Colville also says the reason for the jump in pricing is that the shelter and its operations have been"historically,woefully underfunded." "If we were starting at a fairer rate,the jump to$844,000 wouldn't appear to be so high.Our budget has been posted online and the biggest increase has been to payroll.Currently,the majority of our staff makes minimum wage(starting at$9/hour) and no one receives benefits for providing this essential county service,"she says."In our proposed 2021 budget,we have increased salaries to fair,livable wages(averaging what is still a low$16/hour)and added modest benefits for the first time in county history.We feel strongly that working in animal welfare is heartbreaking,backbreaking work and our people deserve to be able to make a living providing this county service." https://www.citybeat.com/cincinnati/Print?oid=12165779 Page 2 of 8 1/24/22, 5:01 PM Starting in the new year,Clermont County will operate the shelter under Ohio Revised Code 955,a bare minimum which only requires them to keep,house and feed stray dogs for three days.Cats are not included and will not be housed/taken in at the shelter. Per the ORC(which is mildly concerning and worth a read),any untagged dog left after three days can be"donated to any nonprofit special agency that is engaged in the training of any type of assistance dogs,"sold for$3 to"any nonprofit Ohio institution or organization that is certified by the director of health as being engaged in teaching or research concerning the prevention and treatment of diseases of human beings or animals,"sold in general or,failing those options,"be humanely destroyed:' "The county has made clear they are only committed to what they are required by law.That is ORC 955 stray dogs,"says Clermont Animal CARE's Colville."This means that the county will not be providing services for owned pets that need to be rehomed or cats.At Clermont Animal CARE,we provide full-service animal sheltering.We have a robust cat program that in 2020 included a county-wide community cat spay/neuter program.We also have programming that helps people who have fallen on hard times keep their pets.All programming beyond stray dog pick up and housing for three days will go away when the county takes over:' As for any stray dogs that come to the shelter within that three-day hold period of Jan.1,Clermont Animal CARE responded to a viral post claiming any dogs left would be euthanized. https://www.citybeat.com/cincinnati/Print?oid=12165779 Page 3 of 8 1/24/22, 5:01 PM o a fureverhome.cinci I I View profile > Crrmni .. . ouni n1 i► Sidi-,... (Alo Kill htt5 . 05 orth --:'.: , , And --hci. Coutliii +s laki 1)5 .. 4 '` Kill Shtl{�.r>. 0ucr .jn• /,2a/05n _..: ad a P li 1 •,, , by DeL 31 o r At y GUi ll .. Q,u/MN2ed. yaa. a a. :,,, . b� 2.„.., Kau) an enrz .. di y 1 577. 732 .8851 • a ar _ r f r c C ltrtnon an W� i View more on Instagram 3,563 likes fureverhome.cinci GUYS THIS IS SERIOUS!try If you've been wanting a furry friend NOW IS YOUR CHANCE TO MAKE A DIFFERENCE!!!Please scroll to the next page to see some of the faces of these innocent pups who deserve an amazing life!@clermontanimalcare by,, '_11:3 resit:; ... ,,,� "We do not know what will happen to strays that come in after December 29 as they must be held for 72 hours and will be the county's responsibility when their stray hold expires.The county still has not provided a detailed plan for keeping the shelter no-kill or how they will handle any animals besides stray dogs,"the organization wrote on Facebook. https://www.citybeat.com/cincinnati/Print?oid=12165779 Page 4 of 8 1/24/22,5:01 PM Commissioner Humphrey says,"Clermont County is committed to a clean and well-maintained animal shelter that maintains a low euthanasia rate.The county is not moving to a'kill shelter." He also says they have"made tremendous progress since 2015,with the euthanasia rate dropping by 90%." Part of that progress has been directly overseen by Clermont Animal CARE. Since they took over operations from the county in 2018,they've"increased dog intake by 32%,increased dog adoptions by 42%,reduced dog euthanasia by 41%and maintained a 98%Live Release Rate since day one,"they say. They county did not provide a specific number or percentage of dogs they would find acceptable to euthanize under their"no kill"policy,but Commissioner Humphrey says,"We will only euthanize animals that are not medically viable or so vicious in nature that they cannot be retrained." It should be noted that even Clermont Animal CARE has had to euthanize animals.A transparent list of the dogs and cats taken in since 2018 and their outcomes is on their website. In 2020,14 dogs were euthanized for medical or temperamental reasons or died in care as well as 50 cats— but that's a 98.4%and 94.8%live release rate,respectively. "Our top concerns are that the county claims to be committed to no-kill but they are cutting the budget in half and cutting staffing in half,"says Colville."There is absolutely no way to keep no-kill with that budget and staffing model.Most concerning is that they do not plan to hire any veterinary staff,which is a huge aspect of not only no-kill services but basic,humane animal care.Our medical team at Clermont Animal CARE provides vaccines,exams and emergency care to animals in our care every day,especially stray dogs." https://www.citybeat.com/cincinnati/Print?oid=12165779 Page 5 of 8 1/24/22, 5:01 PM Clermont Animal CARE Humane Society Just 18 DAYS TO GO and the county has some serious questions to answer and some big shoes to fill. Consider that it's taken us 3 years to get the right team in place,implement best-practice protocols,build a strong foster and volunteer base*AND*we started with a vast rescue partner network built from 2 decades of leadership in the field and$200K in donations from our generous board members to get us started. Consider their timing. Despite our efforts urging them since...See more • LOCAL12.COM Clermont Animal CARE Humane Society cuts ties with county BATAVIA,Ohio(WKRC)—There's a look of uncertainty in a shelter dog's... County Communications Coordinator Boehmer says they will be partnering with outside agencies"to make sure dogs receive the care they need.We will also be seeking partnerships with other agencies where needed."He says funding will be appropriated for animal care. The county also says it aims to leave the care of cats up the three humane societies in Clermont County,which Humphrey listed as Clermont Humane Society,Clermont to the Rescue Humane Society and Clermont(Animal)CARE Humane Society.And hope to remand care of any dogs left after their three-day hold to adopters or"animal rescue organizations, individual foster folks and humane societies." "Partnering with humane societies isn't as easy as they make it seem,"says Colville."The humane societies in Clermont County already run their operations and to ask them to take on the additional load of all county cats is a tall task;not impossible but not a slam dunk like the county might imply.We will not be able to help them because we will no longer exist.Clermont Animal CARE was formed to run the county shelter.We will not be in existence as a private humane society if we don't have the county contract.Clermont Animal CARE will dissolve on Jan.1 if we aren't running the shelter." https://www.citybeat.com/cincinnati/Print?oid=12165779 Page 6 of 8 1/24/22, 5:01 PM 1, K4 k w v.�fwY s ms r+�: ..ge Y i 4. Nyam. Photo:Clermont Animal CARE Humane Society Clermont County says they are currently hiring a dog warden and"assistants with experience running successful shelters" They also note that"employees from Clermont Animal CARE Humane Society are welcome to apply." Commissioner Humphrey also says,"The Clermont County Sheriff deputies will investigate cruelty to animal cases.We will care for the seized,mistreated animals at the shelter until trial.Once the trial is completed we will attempt to find good homes for the animals." "We are obviously crushed by the decision of the commissioners to opt out of a humane society partnership that has brought elite,nationally-recognized no-kill animal sheltering to Clermont County,"said Carolyn Evans,Clermont Animal CARE's Executive Director,in a release."The shelter has been underfunded for decades and the county has no plan to provide the level of service seen since 2018." Clermont County's animal shelter is located at 4025 Filager Road,Batavia. A previous version of this story said there were only three dogs left at the shelter. There are in fact 20 dogs left. ©2022 Cincinnati CityBeat Powered by Foundation https://www.citybeat.com/cincinnati/Print?oid=12165779 Page 7 of 8 Troy Council Discusses Mohawk Hudson Humane Society Contract Dilemma I WNYT.com 1/24/22, 5:02 PM • �f l� 1 com (/weather/) °''' ^ Feels like:23° (1) /3 O Humidity:50% L Wind:ESE 0 mph COVERAGE YOU CAN TRUST Latham,NY NEWS (Mews!) WEATHER(/weather!) SPORTS (!sports/) FEATURES—(Ilifestylel) PODCASTS—(/podcasts!) EVENTS-(/events/) WNYA MY4-(/My4/) PROGRAMMING-(/pages/programming/wnyt-program-guide.shtml) LINKS (!links/) CONTACT-(/pageslinformationlcontact-us.shtml) (/article/10098/) QUICK LINKS:Closings&Delays(/closings/)I Snow Emergencies(/snowemergencies/)I Contests(/contests/)I Commit to Kids(/committokids/)I We Salute You(/WeSaluteYou/) The Lesson Plan(/education/)I Top Teacher(/topteacher/)I Streaming Video(/live/)I WNYT Apps(/apps/) BREAKING NEWS>Former Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver dies at 77 CLOSINGS>1 Active Closing or Delay(Iclosings/) x LIVE VIDEO>Wive!)Watch NewsChannel 13 Live at 5(/live/) ADVERTISEMENT Troy Council Discusses Mohawk Hudson Humane Society Contract Dilemma Troy Council Discusses Mohawk Hudson Humane Society Contract Situation MOST READ STORIES 12-year-old child arrested r• ._ following Amsterdam school threat (lmontgomery-county-ny- (/montgomery- newslamsterdam- county-ny- ! montgomery-county- news/amsterdam- student-arrested-for- montgomery- allegedly-threatening-to- county-student- shoot-people-at-school- arrested-for- wilbur-h-lynch-literacy- allegedly- academy/6368128!) threatening-to- (/news/jonathan-hunter/6038200/)Jonathan Hunter(/news/jonathan-hunter/6038200/) shoot-people-at- Created:April 13,2021 11:30 PM schoolterac r-h- lynch-literacy- academy/6368128/) https://wnyt.com/troy-new-york-news/troy-council-discusses-mohawk-hudson-humane-society-contract-dilemma--/6074466/ Page 1 of 5 Troy Council Discusses Mohawk Hudson Humane Society Contract Dilemma I WNYT.com 1/24/22, 5:02 PM Troy City Council held a special meeting Tuesday to discuss the dilemma they have with Albany nv Investigating officer-Invooll e vedd shooting �.. 00' Mohawk Hudson Humane Society.The city has decided not to renew their contract with them (/albanynew-york-news/albany- police-Investigating-officer- (/albany- because of a proposed cost increase.The meeting lasted over an hour. involved-shooting-/63677641) new-york- news/albany- police- At Tuesday night's meeting,Troy Mayor Patrick Madden briefed the council on the situation investigating- with Mohawk Hudson Humane Society.Their proposed new contract with Troy jumped from officer- involved- $66,000 last year to$99,000 this year.Madden says the increase was too much for Troy,so shooting- they do not have an agreement. /6367764/) US puts 8,500 troops on ,,j •Vic--. ADVERTISEMENT r��, heightened alert amid Russia WI 4. WI I., 4., tension(/news/eu-set-for- show-of-unity-as-russia- (/news/eu-set- invasion-fears- for-show-of- mount163676731) unity-as-russia- invasion-fears- mount/6367673/) Sheldon Silver,NY power broker sent to prison,dead at 77(/politics/former-assembly- speaker-sheidon-silver- (/politics/former- dies163682981) assembly- speaker- sheldon-silver- dies/6368298/) WHO chief warns against talk of'endgame'In pandemic(!health/who- "We could not come to terms with them on a price that I thought was fair to the taxpayers to chief-warns-against-talk. (/health/who-chief- the city,"said Madden. pandem1c163 7 of-nd wams-ame in-alk- pandemic/63677571) 9 pandemic/6367757/) Much of the meeting was centered around what the city was going to do going forward. TOP STORIES> (/NEWS/) "We are now in the process of looking at alternatives.Alternatives could be a wide range of things,another shelter,kennel or could be us doing our own kenneling,"said Madden. Sheldon Silver,NY power broker sent to prison,dead at 77(/politics/former-assembly- And there's the question of what plan does the city have to pick up stray animals? speaker-sheldon-silver- 1•" dies/63682981?cat=10114) (/politics/former- y biggestgetphonepickup Updetetl am speaker- assemblwhere concern is that if wea call and our warden has to animals where are they going to go with them.That's my big concern right now,"said Kim Ashe Sheldon-silver- dies/6368298/7 Mcpherson," a member from the Troy City Council. cat=10114) The mayor says they reached out to the humane society for a temporary extension but says US puts 8,500 troops on • -_,, heightened alert amid a that the request was denied.At the moment Troy has the option of calling kennels to pick up Russia tension(/news/eu- IIII the stray animals.The council is going to continue to explore looking at other shelters. set-for-snow-of•unity-as- russla-invasion-fears- (/news/eu-set- mount/6367673/?cat=10114) for-show-of-unity- Updated 20m as-russia- invasion-fears- "Maybe some doors will open. I'm an optimist. I do wear my rose-colored glasses sometimes, mount/6367673/? so I've been told,"said Carmella Mantello,"Troy Council President. cat=10114) police Investigating officer-involved4b1t6tiidd§MENT 4 :$4;, (/albany-new-york-news/albany- Mohawk Hudson Humane Society in Menands shelters animals for many municipalities. police-investigatIng-officer- A spokesperson for Mohawk Hudson says they proposed increases across the board and Involved-shooting-/6367764/7 (/albany- notified everyone well in advance. date 4h new-york- notified p news/albany- police- investigating- Copyright 2021-WNYT-TV,LLC A Hubbard Broadcasting Company officer- involved- Page 2 of 5