LAB Minutes 04/21/2021Naples, Florida, April2l , 2021
LET lT BE KNOWN that the LIBRARY ADVISORY BOARD met on this date in session via
hybrid in-person and video conference attendance at 10:00 a.m. in the Headquarters Library
with the following members present.
CHAIR:
VICE-CHAIR:
SECRETARY:
Connie Bettinger - District 3 (via Zoom)
Joan Hochschild - District 1
Joy White - District 4
Marjorie H. Gagnon - District 5 (absent)
Carla Grieve - District 2
Tanya Williams, Library Director
Catherine Cowser, Assistant Library Director
Karen Tibbetts, Library Administrative Assistant
Connie Kindsvater, President, Friends of the Library (via Zoom)
Louise Franck, Secretary, Friends of the Library
Dan Martin, Collier County Resident
CALL TO ORDER
1) Grant LAB Member remote attendance (Motion & Approval). Quorum was met for this meeting. Dr. Hochschild moved to approve Connie
Bettinger to remotely attend the LAB meeting via Zoom. Ms. Grieve seconded and
the motion was carried unanimously.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Ms. Beftinger asked for additions or corrections to the minutes of March 17,2021. Dr.
Hochschild moved to approve the minutes as written. Ms. Grieve seconded and the motion was
carried unanimously.
REPORT OF OFFICERS - None
REPORT OF COMMITTEES - None
REPORT OF THE FRIENDS. Mrs. Franck reported that the authors for the Nick Linn Lecture Series have been confirmed
and the event will be held at the Ritz-Carlton, Naples for those attending in-person, and will
also be available for others to attend virtually.o The Friends of the Library have sold many tickets for the Nick Linn Lecture Series.. The Non-Fiction Series is looking for a new venue for their events. The authors should be
confirmed by next month.. The Friends of the Library have been working with the Marco lsland Friends of the Library to
support the Collier County Public Library.. Mrs. Kindsvater shared images ofthe new "Be a Friend" brochure and Mrs. Franck brought
some to be distributed to each Library location.. Ms. Bettinger thanked the FOL for providing postage for the Library's Mail-a-Book program.
1
ALSO PRESENT:
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
28.A.4
Packet Pg. 836 Attachment: LAB Meeting Minutes (signed) - April 21, 2021 (15938 : Library Advisory Board - May 19, 2021)
Mrs. Franck added that Dana Abernethy, who handles the Mail-a-Book requests, has
created a new MAB bookmark with FOL information on the back side.
Discussion ensued regarding other locations in the community, such as senior service
organizations, where the bookmarks could be distributed.
PUBLIC COMMENTSo Mr. Martin suggested the FOL to send notifications of Library Advisory Board meetings to its
members.o Discussion ensued, and Mrs. Franck will look into providing this information to members.. She added that the FOL meetings are also open to the public.. Ms. Bettinger asked if the Library would be able to accommodate more people attending the
LAB meetings, while observing social distancing protocols. Ms. Williams replied that the
Sugden Theater at Headquarters should be avarlable. Another option would be to request
the use of the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) Chambers.
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
1l FY 202112022 State Budget & Advocacyo Ms. Williams reported that the House and Senate put in the same funding for
FY202112022 State Aid ($17.3 million).r Both the House and Senate added back $2 million for funding local consortiums,
such as SWFLN, which would receive $200k.. The State's budget year runs from July 1 - June 30. The FY202112022 budget needs
to be approved, however, the Library will not be affected by the budget cuts until
FY2023. The budget cuts will have an impact on funding electronic resources.. Mr. Martin asked if there were any grant opportunities for the Library to pursue.o Ms. Williams replied that State Aid for Libraries is a grant, however, many corporate
or private grants offer funding for non-profit organizations that are not associated
with a government entity. Therefore, the Library would not be eligible for funding.o For example, the local annual Wine Festival raises money for children's programs,
however, the Library is not eligible to receive funds due to being associated with a
government entity.
2) Expansion of Operating Hours & Days Recommendationso Ms. Williams reported that the Library will be expanding hours of operation at the
Regional Library locations to pre-pandemrc hours beginning on Monday.. These locations will be open Monday-Thursday from 9:00am to 8:00pm and Friday &
Saturday from 9:00am to 5:00pm. Sunday hours will not be added at this time due to
staffing contingency needs.. Ms. Williams added that the branch locations will have their hours expanded to some
form of pre-pandemic hours based on slaffing.o Ms. Williams explained that the Library lost many part{ime Library Assistants during
the pandemic. Some new hires realized after being brought on board that they were
not ready to get back into the work place and did not stay for long. Also, some new
hires were offered better positions elsewhere.e East Naples and Vanderbilt Beach branches will most likely be open for 40 hours a
week between Tuesday and Saturday.. Marco lsland, Estates, lmmokalee and Golden Gate branches serve specific
geographical areas of the County and are not close to a regional location; therefore,
the will be open for 52 hours a week between Monday and Saturday.. A press release will be sent out once the hours have been confirmed.3l FY 2022 Library Budget Request
2
28.A.4
Packet Pg. 837 Attachment: LAB Meeting Minutes (signed) - April 21, 2021 (15938 : Library Advisory Board - May 19, 2021)
. Ms. Williams reported that the preliminary budget estimates have been completed;
however, in order to meet compliance of the budget, over $300k was cut.r Ms. Williams anticipates a $280k offset from lT expenses; however, if not, the Library
will be almost $600k out of budget for its general fund.o Ms. Williams shifted $322k from the General Fund (00'l) to the Shreve donation in
Fund 129. The $322k includes costs for Hoopla streaming, Mango Languages,
Brainfuse, Mergent and other public databases.o She added that it would not be sustainable to use the finite amount of money to fund
core services. At this rate, the Shreve money would be gone in two years.o Jared Del Re's lT budget within the Library was cut from $60k to $15k.. The Library recouped $136k in personnel money when two FTEs were given up to
the Public Services Department.. Ms. Williams is working with the Office of Management and Budget to offset the
rising lT costs that currently are $1 million annually.o The new County Manager will be presented with the budget on May 14; however, the
centralized financial team will present on behalf of Ms. Williams.o Ms. Williams will provide updates on the budget at the May LAB meeting.o Ms. Williams reported that all County staff will receive a flat rate of $1 ,000 to their
salary instead of a cost of living adjustment.o The County is making incremental salary increases, working towards the $1S/hour
minimum wage.o The mileage rates will be advertised and set at the June BCC meeting. The tax
collector will provide estimated revenue numbers in July.o There will be two public hearings in September to ratify the FY2022 budget.
NEW BUSINESS
1) Updated Fines & Fees Schedule (Motion & Approval)o Ms. Williams provided handouts on the proposed updated fines & fees schedule.. ltems denoted in red are the ones being updated.. Ms. Williams is focusing on adding the hot spot devices and faxing services.. ln response to the pandemic, the Library has not been collecting $5 for computer
usage fees to those without a Library card. She expects this fee will be permanently
removed as it is more of a cost deterrent than a resource.. Public access to computers is a core service of libraries, and few public libraries have
a fee for these services.. Ms. Williams stated that no one has ever reserved the computer labs, and therefore
this item will be removed from the fines and fees schedule.
. Ms. Williams reported that the library began to offer fax services last month, without
any advertising, and has faxed an average of ten pages each day.
. Ms. Grieve moved to approve the Library's updated fines and fees schedule as
presented. Dr. Hochschild second and the motion was carried unanimously.
2) Pandemic Response & Next Steps (Discussion Only)
. As per the Governor's Executive Order and the Florida Department of Health, the
Library is now operating at 100% capacity.
. Ms. Williams stated that the Library is no longer quarantining returned materials;
however, staff are continuing to use pandemic protocols when handling library
materials.. Tables and chairs have been moved back into public areas, and public meeting rooms
will become available soon under limited social distancing protocols'
3
28.A.4
Packet Pg. 838 Attachment: LAB Meeting Minutes (signed) - April 21, 2021 (15938 : Library Advisory Board - May 19, 2021)
. The County's mask mandate expired, however staff will continue to wear masks in
public areas if social distancing cannot be maintatned.. The Sugden Theater is being measured for its new room capacity under limited social
distancing protocols.. Ms. Williams is hoping to reinstate local events for groups beginning late this summer.. Ms. Williams stated that as long as the BCC meetings continue to be held in hybrid
format, the Library will operate under the local county's directive for its May LAB
meeting.. Ms. Williams reported that the County has offered the COVID-19 vaccine to employees
and their spouses that want to be vaccinated.o Ms. Williams converses each month with the Lee County Library Director, and the
libraries are currently in line with each other and ahead of other locations across the
state.. The Library is set for its Summer Reading Program, and the FOL has provided funding
for prizes and supplies.
DIRECTOR'S REPORT
1) Naples Woman's Club $2,500 Donation. Ms. Williams reported that the Library received a $2,500 donation from the Naples
Woman's CIub to support the Pee Wee portion of the Summer Reading Program.. This money will be used to purchase and provide board books to the participants.. Ms. Williams added that the Library is in existence because of the Naples Woman's
Club, and Bobbi Skaggs, FOL Board Member, was instrumental in renewing this
collaboration.. The acceptance of this donation is tentatively slated to go before the BCC at the June
8th meeting.
2) Naples Chapter of the Sons of the American Revolution Flag Awardo Ms. Williams reported that the Library recently received a flag award from the Naples
Chapter of the Sons of the American Revolution. The certificate recognizes five Library
locations for exemplary patriotism in the display of the Flag of the United States of
America.. Ms. Williams will distribute copies of this certificate to the five locations and the
Library's drivers, as they are the ones who maintain the flags for the Library.. She added that the Daughters of the American Revolution frequently use the
Genealogy department at the Naples Regional Library, which is funded by the FOL.
3) Staffing Update. Ms. Williams reported that no new staff members have indicated that they will be
retiring.. As discussed earlier, the Library has been working toward getting all open Library
Assistant positions filled.. Mrs. Franck asked when the LEAP program would resume.o Ms. Williams replied that she is hoping to do so in the fall. At this time, she wants to
allow students to volunteer at the Library, as they need community service hours for
graduation.
4) Capital Projects Updateo Ms. Williams reported the Naples Regional Library will be closed for the month of June
for HVAC and lighting updates.. This project is slated to be completed within ten months, however, the work will be
done in phases. Ms. Williams will be meeting with the contractor to determine the
phases and areas to determine a timeline.
4
28.A.4
Packet Pg. 839 Attachment: LAB Meeting Minutes (signed) - April 21, 2021 (15938 : Library Advisory Board - May 19, 2021)
. Naples Regional staff will be reassigned to other locations during June.. There are no updates on the parking lot in lmmokalee.. The replacement of Marco lsland's HVAC is moving forward.. The fiber project will be completed once East Naples and Marco lsland branch libraries
are connected.
5) TBS Copy/PrinUScan/Fax Services. Ms. Williams reported that everyone is thrilled with the ease of use and quality of the
new prinucopy/scan/fax services provided by TBS.o ln the first two to three weeks, the Library sent 79 faxes. 313 total pages were faxed
during the first month of service.. Over 20,000 pages were printed during the first month of service.. Ms. Williams is anxious to try the photo restoration features.. A press release will be sent out once all the "kinks" are worked out.
ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business to come before the Library Advisory Board, the meeting was
adjourned at 11:15 a.m.
Ms. Williams will update LAB members as to the format of the Library Advisory Board meeting
scheduled to be held on Wednesday, May 19,2021 at the Headquarters Library, 2385 Orange
Blossom Drive, Naples, FL 34109, (239) 252-7350.
proved by:
onnie Bettinge , Chair
Library Advisory Board
5
28.A.4
Packet Pg. 840 Attachment: LAB Meeting Minutes (signed) - April 21, 2021 (15938 : Library Advisory Board - May 19, 2021)