Bayshore Beautification MSTU Agenda 05/05/2021
Bayshore CRA Offices: 3299 Tamiami Trail E, Unit 103, Naples, Florida 34112
Phone: 239-252-8844
Online: www.bayshorecra.com
Collier County Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA)
Bayshore Gateway Triangle Local Redevelopment Advisory Board
and
Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee
AGENDA
Government Center- Administration Building F,
3299 Tamiami Trail E, Suite 103, Naples, FL 34112
May 5, 2021
Time: 5:30 PM to 7:30 PM
1. Call to order – Maurice Gutierrez, Chairman CRA Advisory Board/MSTU
Chairman. Motion for virtual attendance for board members:
2. Introductions – CRA -Chairman Maurice Gutierrez, Vice Chair, Al Schantzen,
Karen Beatty, Larry Ingram, David Slobodien, Steve Main, Michael Sherman,
Camille Kielty. MSTU – Chairman Maurice Gutierrez, Vice Chair, Sandra Arafet,
George Douglas, John Smith, Susan Crum, Bob Messmer, and Jim Bixler
3. Pledge of Allegiance
4. Approval of the Agenda
5. Meeting Minutes:
a. CRA minutes for April 6, 2021 (CRA Action Item)
b. MSTU minutes for April 7, 2021 (MSTU Action Item)
6. Old Business:
a. Thomasson Drive – Roundabout Design (Michael Wallrock) Attachment
b. Hamilton Ave Update- Barry Williams
c. Fire Suppression Phase 3 – Road Closure Attachment
d. Access Management Plan- Status Update
e. Holly Avenue – May 8 Clean Up Attachment
7. New Business:
a. CRA- First Quarter 2021 Building Permits Attachment
b. Residential Grant Application Requests (CRA Action Item)
c. MSTU- Mileage Neutral or Tax Neutral (MSTU Action Item)
d. FRA Conference – Downtown Fort Myers – October 27-29 (CRA Board
Members interested in attending)
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 30 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
Bayshore CRA Offices: 3299 Tamiami Trail E, Unit 103, Naples, Florida 34112
Phone: 239-252-8844
Online: www.bayshorecra.com
REGISTRATION WILL OPEN ON JULY 26TH. Keep an eye on the website for
the most up-to-date information at www.redevelopment.net.
8. Work Plans 2021/2022 - Attachment
a. Redevelopment Plan FY21 Second Quarter Review - Attachment
b. CRA
c. MSTU
9. Staff Reports
a. Directors Report
b. Project Managers Report
c. Maintenance
d. CRA Financials
e. MSTU Financials
10. Other Agencies:
a. Code Enforcement- Attachment
11. Communications-
a. A new Dawn for East Naples
b. In the Know- Gulfshore Playhouse
c. In the Know-2435 Pine St
d. $10.5 M Pump House
12. Public Comment
13. Staff Comments
14. Advisory Board General Communications
15. Next Meeting Dates:
a. CRA - Monday, June 7, 2021 @ 6pm
b. MSTU – Wednesday, June 9, 2021 @ 5pm
16. Adjournment
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 31 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
April 6, 2021 Meeting Minutes Item 5a
BAYSHORE/GATEWAY TRIANGLE COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT LOCAL ADVISORY
BOARD MINUTES OF THE APRIL 06, 2021 MEETING
The meeting of the Bayshore/Gateway Triangle Community Redevelopment Advisory Board
was called to order by Chairman, Maurice Gutierrez at 6:00 p.m.
I.Roll Call: Advisory Board Members Present: Maurice Gutierrez, Al Schantzen,
Mike Sherman, Camille Kielty, and Karen Beatty. Larry Ingram and Steve Main
had an unexcused absence.
CRA Staff Present: Debrah Forester, CRA Director, Ellen Summers, Principal
Redevelopment Specialist, Tami Scott, Project Manager and Shirley Garcia,
Operations Coordinator.
II.Pledge of Allegiance
III.Adoption of Agenda: Ms. Forester noted the changes to the agenda as Dwight
Oakley withdrew his advisory board application for reappointment. Karen Beatty
made a motion to adopt the agenda as amended, Al Schantzen seconded the
motion. Motion passed unanimously.
IV.Approval of Minutes: Al Schantzen made a motion to approve the minutes,
Camille Kielty seconded the motion. Approved unanimously.
V.Community / Business - Presentations
VI.Old Business:
a.Recap of Joint Workshop/Discussion – Ms. Forester wanted to thank
everyone for attending the Joint Workshop with the BCC this morning and
asked if anyone had any comments or wanted to discuss anything from
earlier. There was no discussion.
b.Revised 2021 Meeting Calendar- Ms. Forester provided the two changes
with the revision dated on the top of the calendar for the board members.
c.2020 Annual Report- https://www.bayshorecra.com/ can access online -
Ms. Forester provided the link to the 2020 annual report and noted staff is
working on quotes for printing and mailing.
VII. New Business:
a.Jeanne Harvey Memorial, Real Macaw - Ms. Forester mentioned the
memorial of Jeanne Harvey the owner of Real Macaw added at the request
of Karen Beatty for discussion. Ms. Beatty asked if the CRA/MSTU could
contribute a plaque or some sort of memorial since Ms. Harvey was one of
the first businesses that opened within the CRA District and because of how
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 32 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
much she has contributed to the community she felt it would be a good way
to honor Ms. Harvey for all she has done. There was a consensus of the
Board for staff to look into a plaque, Ms. Scott will work on the plaque and
placement within the CRA Parking lot.
b.David Slobodien, Applicant for the Advisory Board- Mr. Slobodien
provided a brief history of his experiences and his desire to serve on the
CRA advisory board. After some brief discussion from the advisory board,
Maurice Gutierrez made a motion to appoint Mr. Slobodien to the advisory
board to serve as at-large member, second by Mike Sherman. Passed
unanimously.
c.Reappointments for Advisory Board Members-
i. Maurice Gutierrez- Al Schantzen made a motion to reappoint Mr.
Gutierrez, second by Karen Beatty. Passed unanimously
ii.Mike Sherman- Maurice Gutierrez made a motion to reappoint
Mr. Sherman as Bayshore Business Owner, Second by Karen
Beatty. Passed unanimously.
VIII.Staff Report:
a.CRA Directors Report- Ms. Forester provided the CRA report and
asked if anyone had any questions.
b.Project Manager Report- Tami Scott provided her list of projects starting
with Thomasson Drive there is 12 weeks before they finish. They just
started the curbing for the roundabout. Paving Thomasson Drive will start
around the week of the 12th east and west side of Thomasson Drive. Fire
Suppression 3 is waiting for the dewatering permit from the State and
hooking into Bayshore Drive since the pipe is not located where originally
identified. Al Schantzen mentioned the heavy trucks ran over all of the
County sewer caps and busted them, Ms. Scott said she will mention it to
the Contractor and let him know they need to repair the caps. Fire
Suppression 4 was not successful in getting the grant awarded this year but
the Director and Ms. Scott will schedule a meeting with the City of Naples
to discuss options to continue the partnership. Staff will continue to
improve Bayshore Drive and the Bridge with more plantings.
c.Private Development Update- It was noted that Ellen Summers was
leaving the County and this would be her last report. She provided the
current updates starting with Naples Boat Yard, the rezone is just starting
up with their submittal so there will be some time for the staff to send
comments back, the boat lift is still under review the comments should be
back in the next couple of weeks. The Bayshore Wine and Food venue has
Item 5a
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 33 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
been approved for the alcohol distance waiver with emphasis on some
amplified sound and time frames. Al Schantzen asked about St. Matthews
and Ms. Summers said they came in for pre application meeting, but nothing
has moved forward on that yet.
d.Maintenance Report: Ms. Forester provided the current maintenance report.
No questions.
e.Financial Report: Ms. Forester provided the current financial report. No
questions.
IX.Other Agency’s:
a.Collier County Sheriff’s Office: No attendance from the Sheriff’s Office
b.Collier County Code Enforcement: John Johnson, presented the Code
enforcement report attached to the agenda packet. He noted the open case
report that reflects all the open cases within the district. Al Schantzen asked
about the fence under the bridge on Sawyers Marina side that it is down
again. Mr. Johnson said he will turn it into Road Maintenance, Ms. Forester
mentioned that if necessary the CRA may be able to partner with Road
Maintenance to use a heavier fence that would provide better security if
necessary.
X.Communications and Correspondence:
a.Gateway Triangle Mixed-Use project- Ms. Forester provided the article
on the mixed-use project in the gateway triangle.
b.Bayshore Arts-Things I like by Catherine- Ms. Forester provided the
article from the Naples Daily News highlighting our new business on
Bayshore Drive and Commercial Improvement Grant recipient.
XI.Public Comments:
XII.Staff Comments:
XIII.Advisory Board General Communications:
XIV.Next Meeting Date:
a. May 5, 2021 CRA/MSTU Joint Meeting @ 5:30pm
XV.Adjournment – The meeting adjourned at 8:05 p.m.
________________________________________
Chairman Maurice Gutierrez
Item 5a
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 34 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
1
April 7, 2021 Meeting Minutes
BAYSHORE BEAUTIFICATION MSTU MINUTES OF THE APRIL 7, 2021 MEETING
The meeting of the Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee was called to order by
Maurice Gutierrez at 5:00 p.m. located on the 3rd floor of the Administration Building.
I.Roll Call: Advisory Board Members Present: George Douglas, James Bixler,
Maurice Gutierrez, Sandra Arafet, John Smith and Robert Messmer attended in
person. Excused absence Susan Crum.
MSTU Staff Present: Debrah Forester, CRA Director; Tami Scott, Project Manager;
and Shirley Garcia, Operations Coordinator.
II.Pledge of Allegiance: Led by Maurice Gutierrez.
III.Adoption of Agenda: Sandra Arafet made a motion to accept the Agenda, second by
Bob Messmer. Motion passed unanimously.
IV.Adoption of Minutes: George Douglas made a motion to approve the meeting minutes
as written, Sandra Arafet seconded. Passed Unanimously.
V.Landscape Report:
a.Update on Landscaping—Aaron Gross, Ground Zero Landscaping— Aaron
Gross presented his landscape report. The landscape crew have been out doing
their weekly maintenance on Bayshore Drive. The crews have been continuing
to repair irrigation breaks, they cleaned up Lunar Street weeds in the triangles at
Ms. Scott’s request. They have been pruning the palms and cleaning up the
medians. Maurice Gutierrez asked Mr. Gross if they should consider changing
out the irrigation system or does he think it’s just due to the roots and sand. Mr.
Gross noted the water pressure surges contributes to main line breaks especially
where there are T’s in the pvc pipes. He thinks the system should be evaluated
but the main reason for the breaks in his opinion is due to the water pressure
surges that adds stress on the pipes and valves.
VI.Community / Business Presentations:
VII.Old Business:
a.Recap BCC/CRA/MSTU Joint Workshop/Discussion- Ms. Forester wanted to
thank everyone for attending the Joint Workshop with the BCC this morning and
asked if anyone had any comments or wanted to discuss anything from earlier.
Discussion surrounded Hamilton Avenue project and the need to move forward
Item 5b
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 35 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
2
to complete the MSTU portion with the pedestrian and bicycle improvements.
Ms. Arafet noted the concerns from the Danford Street residents and the need
for traffic calming.
b.2020 Annual Report- https://www.bayshorecra.com/ can access online - Ms.
Forester provided the link to the 2020 annual report and noted staff is working on
quotes for printing and mailing.
VIII.New Business:
IX.Staff Reports:
a.CRA Directors Report- Ms. Forester provided the report and highlighted
some of the projects. The Mini-Triangle has received demolition permits
and should start some activity in the next month. Del’s – the former boat
yard site is being used for MSTU landscaping storage for right now.
b.Project Manager Report- Tami Scott highlighted the following projects:
•Thomasson Drive project is moving along, the roundabout has been
started, and there were some barrels put around it and it’s been going
well. Paving is scheduled for next week on the east and west side of
Thomasson Drive.
•Fire Suppression IV grant was not chosen for this year, but staff will
start discussions with the City of Naples to partner and the CRA will
fund this phase.
•The landscaping around the pickle ball entrance will have some
landscaping work done, Jim Bixler and staff will try and spruce up
around the entrance.
•The landscaping contract has gone out to bid and there were 6 bids
receive with a range of prices. Staff is evaluating for lowest bidder.
c.Maintenance Report: Ms. Forester provided the current maintenance report. No
questions.
d.Financials: The financial reports were presented and noted the FY22 budget
process will begin in March and the MSTU will confirm the milage rate at the
May meeting.
X.Correspondence and Communications:
a.Gateway Triangle Mixed-Use project- Ms. Forester provided the article on the
mixed-use project in the gateway triangle.
Item 5b
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 36 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
3
b.Bayshore Arts-Things I like by Catherine- Ms. Forester provided the article from
the Naples Daily News highlighting our new business on Bayshore Drive and
Commercial Improvement Grant recipient.
XI.Public Comments:
XII.Staff Comments
XIII.Advisory Committee Comments:
XIV.Next Meeting Date:
a. May 5
th CRA/MSTU Joint Meeting @ 5:30pm
XV.Adjournment: 6:18 pm
______________________________________
Chairman Maurice Gutierrez
Item 5b
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 37 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
Why is the wall so high at the Thomasson Drive and Bayshore
Roundabout?
One reason for landscaping/walls roundabout central islands of roundabouts is to limit a
driver’s view of any traffic on the other side of the roundabout to encourage incoming drivers
to focus on the traffic to their left, which is the major threat to them.
Lines of sight are important but seeing directly across/through the roundabout’s central island
is not necessary and can be misleading as the driver focuses on the other side of the central
island and less on the real threat to their left. Once completed, the pedestrian crosswalks will
be set further back than where they were prior to the construction to facilitate safe pedestrian
access.
The roundabout will be completed in June 2021. During construction, intersection stop
controls are being implemented by the contractor to lower the operating speed and drivers
need to adjust to the conditions created by the construction operations.
Driving instructions when approaching a roundabout, the driver should first be aware of any
vehicles in front of you and any pedestrians, or bicyclists that may be crossing the marked
sidewalk in your lane. If so that you will yield to them, where necessary as applicable. Once you
are past the crosswalk at the entry yield point about to enter the roundabout, your clear line of
sight should be is to your left, so that you can see any oncoming vehicles that could hit/collide
conflict with you if you continue into within the roundabout circle that you need to yield to. If
so, you YIELD to them, then enter the roundabout when it is safe. Once circulating in the
roundabout, your line of sight should be immediately straight ahead of traffic within the
circulating lane you are in while keeping an eye on your travel through the roundabout to your
exit while being aware of approaching vehicles on your right who may enter without stopping
to yield.
Below are examples of other roundabouts with vegetation or other improvements in the center
island. Appendix A illustrates required lines of sight within the roundabout at Thomasson Dr
and Bayshore Drive. Please note there are no required lines of sight over the central island.
Item 6a
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 38 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
Page 2 of 8
Item 6a
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 39 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
Page 3 of 8
Two different landscaped Central Islands with lots of trees
Item 6a
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 40 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
Page 4 of 8
Mounded Central Island with an Eagles nest on top
Welcoming Wall at Gateway to Downtown South Bend, IN
Item 6a 4.A.2
Packet Pg. 41 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
Page 5 of 8
Heavily treed Central Island Item 6a
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 42 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
Page 6 of 8
Roundabout Combined Lines of Sight
Item 6a
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 43 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
Page 7 of 8
Circulating Lines of Sight Item 6a
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 44 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
Page 8 of 8
Pedestrian Lines of Sight Item 6a
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 45 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
SPEEDING FINES DOUBLEDWHEN WORKERS PRESENT*MOT SHALL COMPLY WITH THE FDOT DESIGN STANDARDS AND THE MUTCD*
OVERVIEW REFERENCE INDEXES 102-620 & 613
THIS MAINTENANCE OF TRAFFIC PLAN (“MOT PLAN”) IS THE
EXCLUSIVE PROPERTY OF ACME BARRICADES, LC, AND IS
PROVIDED SOLELY FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES. THE
MOT PLAN HAS BEEN PREPARED FOR THE EXCLUSIVE
AUTHORIZED INTERPRETATION, IMPLEMENTATION AND
NECESSARY MODIFICATION BY ACME BARRICADES, LC ONLY.
THE MOT PLAN HAS NOT BEEN PREPARED FOR DISTRIBUTION
TO OR INTERPRETATION, IMPLEMENTATION OR RELIANCE BY
ANY OTHER PARTY. ACME BARRICADES, LC DOES NOT MAKE
ANY WARRANTIES OR REPRESENTATIONS OF ANY KIND
RELATED TO THIS MOT PLAN. IN EXCHANGE FOR THE RECEIPT
OF THIS INFORMATIONAL ONLY MOT PLAN, THE RECIPIENT
HEREBY AGREES TO INDEMNIFY, DEFEND AND HOLD HARMELESS
ACME BARRICADES, LC AND ITS EMPLOYEES FROM ANY AND ALL
CLAIMS ARISING FROM THE RECIPIENT’S USE OF THIS
INFORMATIONAL ONLY MOT PLAN. STORTER AVEBARRETT AVELAKEVIEW DRRIVERVIEW DRGILFVIEW DRSHOREVIEW DRARECA AVECOCO AVESABAL CTSTANDARD LANE SHIFT ON
BAYSHORE DR WORK
IN THE RIGHT OF WAY SET-UPN ROADWORKAHEADROADWORKAHEADROADWORKAHEADROADWORKAHEADROADWORKAHEADROADWORKAHEADROAD
WORK
AHEAD
ROAD
WORK
AHEAD ROAD
WORK
AHEAD
ROAD
WORK
AHEAD
ROAD
WORK
AHEAD
ACME OR
BAYSHORE DR LEFT LANECLOSEDAHEADROADWORKAHEADSPEEDING FINES DOUBLEDWHEN WORKERS PRESENTRIGHT LANECLOSEDAHEADBAYSHORE DR
NAPLES, FLAONLYONLY
ONLYONLY DETOURDETOURNOTE:
A FLAG MEN WILL BE
PRESENT TO ASSIST
WITH PEDESTRIAN & RESIDENTIAL
TRAFFIC ALONE WORK
AREA AS NEEDED
SLOW
WORK AREA
DETOUR
ROAD
CLOSED
PHASE 1
Item 6 c4.A.2
Packet Pg. 46 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
*MOT SHALL COMPLY WITH THE FDOT DESIGN STANDARDS AND THE MUTCD*
OVERVIEW REFERENCE INDEXES 102-620 & 613
BAYSHORE DR
NAPLES, FLA
STANDARD LANE SHIFT ON
BAYSHORE DR WORK
IN THE RIGHT OF WAY SET-UP
Item 6 c4.A.2
Packet Pg. 47 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
*MOT SHALL COMPLY WITH THE FDOT DESIGN STANDARDS AND THE MUTCD*
OVERVIEW REFERENCE INDEXES 102-620 & 613
BAYSHORE DR
NAPLES, FLA
STANDARD LANE SHIFT ON
BAYSHORE DR WORK
IN THE RIGHT OF WAY SET-UP
Item 6 c4.A.2
Packet Pg. 48 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
South Bayshore Clean Up
Andrews Ave, Holly Ave, Pine Tree Dr., Woodside Ave
NEIGHBORHOOD CLEANUP
SATURDAY, MAY 8, 2021
8:00 a.m. –11:00 a.m.Dumpsters located along West and East side of Bayshore Dr. past Woodside Ave.
Collier County’s Code Enforcement and Solid and Hazardous Waste Management Departments,in cooperation with the
Collier County Bayshore CRA and Waste Management Inc.,of Florida,have organized a neighborhood cleanup for
residents of South Bayshore.Residents are encouraged to take advantage of this one-day opportunity to dispose of
unwanted items free of charge.For more information call 239-252-8844.To file a Code Enforcement complaint,call Code
Enforcement at 239-252-2440.
Dispose of all these things
free of charge –
Household Hazardous Waste
Furniture
Appliances
Electronic Waste
Small Construction Debris
Yard Waste
Item 6e
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 49 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification
Permit Type Number of Permits Total Value
Aluminum Structure 4 39,630.00$
Building 14 2,166,482.00$
Carport/Shed 2 15,500.00$
Demolition 3 4,300.00$
Electrical 7 31,655.44$
Fence 12 30,867.00$
Gas 1 9,000.00$
Marine 3 52,780.00$
Mechanical 9 84,552.00$
Plumbing 2 4,023.00$
Pool 2 70,000.00$
Roof 19 676,119.33$
Shutters/Doors/Windows 11 142,506.98$
Solar 1 19,420.00$
Water Feature 1 150.00$
91 3,346,985.75$
Residential Permits Item 7a
Commercial Permits
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 50 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
Offices: 3299 Tamiami Trail E., Unit 103, Naples, Florida 34112
Phone: 239-252-8844
Online: www.BGTCRA.com
Item 7b
April 28, 2021
Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA
Residential Site Improvement Grant (CBIG)
Site Improvement Grant Applications
Current Balance: $163,781.24
Applicant One:
Mike VanderStel
2500 Lee Street
Naples, Fl 34112
Project Location:
2500 Lee Street
Project Scope:
Replace asphalt roof with metal roof
Estimates:
Crowther Roofing: $25,830.00
King Roofing - $19,850.00
Kelly Roofing - $19,262.00
Total exterior (lowest bidder) = $19,262.00
Owner Contribution: 67%= $12,905.54
Total CRA contribution: $6,356.46
Applicant Two:
Ozlyn Garden Villas Condominium
2850 Arbutus Street
Naples, FL 34112
Project Scope:
Resurface parking lot, laying new parking lines and wheel stops. Applicant will also be
improving the dumpster enclosure area.
Estimates:
Estimate A: S and R Sealcoating and Paving - $24,424
Estimate B: DMI Paving and Sealcoating - $24,105
Owner Contribution: 67% = $16150.35) with a maximum of $8,000 dollars
CRA Contribution for this SIG is $7,954.65
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 51 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
4.A.2Packet Pg. 52Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
4.A.2Packet Pg. 53Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
4.A.2Packet Pg. 54Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
4.A.2Packet Pg. 55Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
4.A.2Packet Pg. 56Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
4.A.2Packet Pg. 57Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
4.A.2Packet Pg. 58Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
4.A.2Packet Pg. 59Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
4.A.2Packet Pg. 60Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
4.A.2Packet Pg. 61Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
4.A.2Packet Pg. 62Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
ITEM 9a
CRA PROJECT UPDATES – May 2021
1.MINI-TRIANGLE
Gateway Mini Triangle PPL: PL20200001193
Metropolitan Naples - 5.27 ACRE CATALYST SITE - The closing of this site took place on November 13,
2020. Subdivision Split proposed to create three parcels with the intent to have separate Site
Development Plans for each one. One parcel -totaling approximately 1.6 acres sold to Naples Triangle
Development on November 13 (simultaneous closing).
Application submitted on Dec. 22 for Subdivision Construction Plans and Plat. This project proposes to
create 3 separate parcels with the intent to have separate SDP’s for each parcel. Drainage Easement is
being processed through GMD. Demolition of buildings is almost complete.
Cell Tower Relocation Agreement – The new cell tower at the Kirkwood site was fully
operational. The old tower was demolished on January 21. Final payment to Crown Castle will be
paid within 60 days of final completion notice is received. Final inspection pending.
Parcel 1 – Naples
Naples Triangle Development (NTD) is submitting for Site Development Plan approval to construct. 240
luxury apartments. Construction anticipated to commence in January 2022.
NTD
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 63 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
2.DEL’S PROPERTY ACQUISITION - Closed on November 20, 2020. Notice to vacate by January
19, 2021 issued. Survey of property should be completed by mid-May. Following survey,
demolition of the warehouse and retail store will begin. Bids to complete minor renovations to
Boatyard building in process. Staff will use facility for storage. Following demolition, highest and
best use analysis to be conducted.
3.PUBLIC ART PLAN – Draft Plan is complete and approved by CRA Advisory Board and is
pending BCC approval. It is on hold until the BCC considers implementation strategy for
the Collier County Arts & Cultural Strategic Plan. Tentative date for adoption Summer
2021.
4.17 AC BOARDWALK - Five proposals were received to develop a master plan for the site and
design and permit and develop construction drawings for the boardwalk on a 17+/- acre parcel
connecting the site to Sugden Regional Park. Short list of 3 proposals will be presented to the
Selection Committee in May. Ranking will be presented to the BCC/CRA to approve to negotiate
a contract. BCC direction anticipated in June.
5.BRANDING - Paradise Advertising and Marketing, Inc. – Phase 1 will begin after Public Art Plan
has been considered by BCC.
6.BAYSHORE ACCESS MANAGEMENT PLAN – Staff is negotiating with Stantec to develop a
scope of work that will do the sub-area modeling of the district as requested by Collier
County Growth Management Department (GMD). GMD is reviewing scope of work.
7.COASTERS/SHUTTLE SERVICE – Coasters and Posters were distributed the week of
November 23 and will continue through the end summer. Results as of April 4, 2021: 285
responses. 221 responded in favor of the shuttle. Those that voted against the shuttle
sited waste of tax payer money and it would become a “drunk bus.” Next step is to reach
out to business owners to get their interest and comments.
8.LAND USE REGULATIONS – Revision were presented to Growth Management staff to
determine review and public hearing schedule. Review in progress with anticipated
presentation to Planning Commission in November 2021. Johnson Engineering will
continue to facilitate the process. Their contract deadline is December 31, 2021.
9.US41 FDOT Safety Improvement Project – Construction is anticipated to begin in August
2021 and there are 300 calendar days of contract time. Tentative completion May 2022.
7 existing light decorative poles are called out be removed as well as the “porkchop” at
the corner of Bayshore and US41.
10.Linwood Sidewalk – Safe Routes to School Project – PE – 2022/2023 and Construction
2024/2025
ITEM 9a
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 64 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
11.Peters Avenue – five-foot sidewalk from Collee Court to US41. $389,000 CDBG grant
awarded and managed by Transportation Planning department. Project will begin
following the US 41 FDOT project is completed. The sidewalk will be placed on the
residential side of the street. Laurie Beard (GMD) is project manager
12.Pine Street – FDOT Funded Becca to US41 – PE 2022/2023. Construction 2024/2025. Will
coordinate with stormwater study.
13.Palm Street and Washington Avenue - Stormwater/Capital Projects: Addressing
complaints about tidal water backflowing into the swales. Main objective is to install 2
catch basins with backflow preventers inside and piping to provide flow connectivity:
and regarding the swales. Kyle Construction awarded the contract. Expect construction
to start in early April. Total duration is 40 days. (Attachment 1)
14.Lake Kelly Ditch Maintenance - The scope is to remove vegetation and trees from the channel
and the banks. The intended outcome is to get the trees, vegetation, and debris out of the ditch
to improve flow. Project Schedule – June 1 start date and finish date December 2021. Ditch
banks not included in this project, might Capital Improvements Division is open for future
discussion once this project is completed. Contact is Dawn Wolfe, 252-5736.
15.April 13, 2021 BCC approved construction contract for the East Naples Community Park Welcome
Center,” to Curran Young Construction, LLC, in the amount of $2,965,622.28,
ITEM 9a
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 65 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA • Bayshore Beautification MSTU
Haldeman Creek MSTU
PROJECT UPDATES
Tami Scott, May 05, 2021
Thomasson Drive: Progress Meeting No. 47 April 21, 2021
CONTRACT STATUS
Time:
April 21, 2021:
Original Contract Time:
Time Extensions Weather:
Time Extensions Holidays:
Time Extensions Other:
Allowable Contract Time:
Remaining Contract Days:
Percent Complete:
Original Completion Date:
Current Adj. Completion Date:
Sched. Substantial Completion Date:
Sched. Final Completion Date:
Money:
Original Contract Amount:
Current Contract Amount:
Amount Earned to Date (as of2/28/21):
% Paid to Date:
Next Cut-Off Date:
Fire Suppression System-Phase 3:
Day 351 of417
335/365
3 Days ( 4/20/21 Pending)
18 Days
31 Days (CO #2)
417
66
84.17%
04;0512021 I 05/05/2021
0512112021 I 06/26/2021
05/07/2021
06/07/2021
$6,022,618.68 Approved Change Orders: co #01 $5,591.16 co #02 $257,631.16 co #03 $29,462.70
CO #04 -$566,125.00 (credit)
$5,456,493.68
$2,770,427.35
50.77%
4/30/2021
Item 9b
Fire Suppression Phase 3 has been approved and the contract with Andrews Siteworks, LLC in the amount of $658,560.00
has been executed. This project will commence on Januaiy 27, 2020, the contractor will start the project at the intersection
of Areca A venue and Basin Street. This project included Areca A venue, Coco A venue, Basin Street, Canal Street and
Captains Cove. The contract schedule requires a 150-day substantial completion and a 180-day final completion. The
construction team Identified a glitch, and we expect a small delay in obtaining additional permits.
The final step in construction is to connect the new waterlines to the existing 18" watermain, this step will require additional
work as the existing watermain is lower in the ground than anticipated. Additional Maintenance of Traffic and dewatering
methods will be needed.
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 66 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
TENTATIVE SCHEDULE
Major items of work required to start construction; work will begin at the i�tersection of @ Bayshore & Ai·eca Ave .
April 28th -ACME Deliver (2) Message Boards for Bayshore work.
May 3rd -Notify Collier County Road Watch ( Hand Deliver Fire/ EMS notice of construction)
May 5th -Update Locates / White line Bayshore
May 10th -Mobilize equipment
May 11th -12th -ACME setup lane shift MOT
May 13th-14th-Install Dewatering & begin dewatering over weekend.
May 16th-Begin connection@Bayshore & Areca Ave.
CRA Parking Lot:
CRA parking lot has been approved and the contract with Fo1t Construction Group of Naples Inc in the amount of
$472,772.25 has been executed. This project will commence on January 4, 2021, the contract schedule requires a 150-day
substantial completion and a 180-day final completion. Stormwater chamber system has been installed and ·inspected.
The importation and exportation of fill has been complete, the site has been graded. The surveyors have laid out the entire
parking lot. Parking lot areas has been backfilled, graded, and compacted. Concrete curbing schedule for week of
April 26, 2020. We have scheduling delays with some of the key products, decorative concrete blo·ck, light poles, PM will
prepare a no cost change order for additional time. Delay in products will delay the substantial comple tion date by 30 days.
Bayshore landscaping and Bridge:
Staff is continuing its efforts with landscape beautification.
Bridge Baskets will be changed out the first week in May.
MSTU Landscape Contract:
We received six bids; the bids ranged in price from $64,400. To $148,980. Staff is meeting with the procurement department
on 4-26-2021 to select a Contractor.
Moorhead Manor:
Item was approved.
Storm water:
CRA staff is working with Collier County GMD Capital Project Planning, Impact Fees, & Program Management,
St01mwater Management Section on a new project titled CRA Bayshore Gateway Triangle Area 4 and Pine, Becca, and
Weeks Stormwater Improvements. Blot Engineering, Inc of Cape Coral, FL 33904 has been selected as the engineer of
record and is waiting to review their proposal.
South Bayshore renovation:
Staff has been tasked with revisiting this project, additional information from Isles of Collier is needed to access how to
move forward. A community meeting will be scheduled for discu ssion.
Sabal Shores street lighting:
Staff has been tasked with evaluating the existing street lighting in the sabal Shores community, a community meeting will be
scheduled for discussion.
Linwood Way:
PO has been opened; staff has contracted Hannula Landscaping to schedule the work.
4825 Bayshore Drive:
General cleanup of the building has been completed, new gate installed and landscaping out front has started. 2 Item 9b
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 67 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
Locations Activity Description/Issues Date Results Status completion date
Paver
Maintenance
Quarterly Safety Check
need to walk Bayshore
Drive Paver safety checks
Paver check
on March
29th
identified 4 areas for
repairs
Contractor will
schedule repair
week of 4/27/21
Light Pole
#45 due to
accident
In front of San Julians
taqueria
Light pole bent appears
truck hit 1/25/2021 No police report found
Waiting for
reimbursement from
insurance
Light Pole
#35 due to
accident
Tami got the insurance
and drive information
Completely knocked
down pole need to use
replacements from
Thomasson Drive project 4/12/2021
Filed claim and
waiting for police
report
waiting for Insurance
reimbursement
04/30/2021 Maintenance Report Item 9c
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 68 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt
Budget
Tot Adopt
Budget
CarryF
Amendme Amendments Tot Amend
Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total-Fund/ CI
*** 187 BAYSHORE/GATEWAY TR 726,747.29 3,084,833.98-2,358,086.69
** REVENUE Sub Total 9,111,900.00-9,111,900.00-621,999.00-9,403,899.00-9,030,975.21-702,923.79-
*REVENUE - OPERATING Su 6,437,900.00-6,437,900.00-6,437,900.00-6,471,575.21-33,675.21
361170 OVERNIGHT INT 2,581.64-2,581.64
361180 INVESTMENT IN 40,000.00-40,000.00-40,000.00-6,231.59-33,768.41-
362190 LEASE FACILITIES 3,577.76-3,577.76
364220 SURPLUS LAND 6,397,900.00-6,397,900.00-6,397,900.00-6,459,184.22-61,284.22
*CONTRIBUTION AND TRANS 2,674,000.00-2,674,000.00-621,999.00-2,965,999.00-2,559,400.00-736,599.00-
481001 TRANS FRM 001 1,915,000.00-1,915,000.00-1,915,000.00-1,915,000.00-
481111 TRANS FRM 111 433,500.00-433,500.00-433,500.00-433,500.00-
481163 TRANS FRM 163 125,500.00-125,500.00-125,500.00-125,500.00-
481164 TRANS FRM 164 11,300.00-11,300.00-11,300.00-11,300.00-
481186 TRANS FRM 186 74,100.00-74,100.00-74,100.00-74,100.00-
481287 TRANS FRM 287 330,000.00 330,000.00-
489200 CARRY FORWARD 436,500.00-436,500.00-436,500.00-436,500.00-
489201 CARRY FORWARD 621,999.00-621,999.00-621,999.00-
489900 NEG 5% EST RE 321,900.00 321,900.00 321,900.00 321,900.00
** EXPENSE Sub Total 9,111,900.00 9,111,900.00 621,999.00 10,063,899.00 726,747.29 5,946,141.23 702,923.79-
*PERSONAL SERVICE 446,200.00 446,200.00 446,200.00 14,628.25 247,252.72 184319.03.44
*OPERATING EXPENSE 406,400.00 406,400.00 21,999.00 428,399.00 112,119.04 173,588.51 142,691.45
631400 ENG FEES 50,000.00 50,000.00 50,000.00 7,999.00 14,279.12 27,721.88
631600 APPRAISAL FEE 7,500.00 7,500.00 7,500.00 7,500.00
634207 IT CAP ALLOCA 2,400.00 2,400.00 2,400.00 600.00 1,800.00
634210 IT OFFICE AUT 13,300.00 13,300.00 13,300.00 3,325.00 9,975.00
634970 INDIRECT COST 60,500.00 60,500.00 60,500.00 60,500.00
634980 INTERDEPT PAY 6,000.00 6,000.00 6,000.00 13,899.00 2,030.00 9,929.00-
634999 OTHER CONTRAC 207,100.00 207,100.00 21,999.00 229,099.00 72,701.69 48,970.59 107,426.72
640300 TRAVEL PROF D 6,000.00 6,000.00 6,000.00 6,000.00
641230 TELEPHONE ACC 1,800.00 1,800.00 1,800.00 1,800.00
Fund 187 Bayshore/Gateway Triangle Item 9d
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 69 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt
Budget
Tot Adopt
Budget
CarryF
Amendme Amendments Tot Amend
Budget Commitment Actual Available
641700 CELLULAR TELE 1,300.00 1,300.00 1,300.00 767.80 532.20
641900 TELEPHONE SYS 4.54 4.54-
641950 POST FREIGHT 1,000.00 1,000.00 1,000.00 165.78 834.22
641952 FREIGHT 40.18 40.18-
643100 ELECTRICITY 415.69 984.31 1,400.00-
643400 WATER AND SEW 4,502.47 614.81 5,117.28-
644620 LEASE EQUIPME 2,000.00 2,000.00 2,000.00 1,489.22 2,207.62 1,696.84-
645100 INSURANCE GEN 3,300.00 3,300.00 3,300.00 825.00 2,475.00
645260 AUTO INSURANC 500.00 500.00 500.00 125.00 375.00
646180 BUILDING RM I 45.38 45.38-
646360 MAINT OF GROU 4,510.95 20,694.01 25,204.96-
646430 FLEET MAINT I 200.00 200.00 200.00 96.00 104.00
646445 FLEET NON MAI 300.00 300.00 300.00 18.30 281.70
647110 PRINTING AND 5,000.00 5,000.00 5,000.00 1,250.00 3,750.00
648170 MARKETING AND 5,000.00 5,000.00 5,000.00 2,200.00 2,800.00
649030 CLERKS RECORD 192.50 192.50-
649100 LEGAL ADVERTI 4,500.00 4,500.00 4,500.00 1,633.02 166.00 2,700.98
651110 OFFICE SUPPLI 3,000.00 3,000.00 3,000.00 368.28 2,631.72
651210 COPYING CHARG 7,000.00 7,000.00 7,000.00 7,000.00
651910 MINOR OFFICE E 1,500.00 1,500.00 1,500.00 1,500.00
651930 MINOR OFFICE F 1,500.00 1,500.00 1,500.00 1,500.00
651950 MINOR DATA PR 1,000.00 1,000.00 1,000.00 1,000.00
652210 FOOD OPERATIN 1,000.00 1,000.00 1,000.00 1,000.00
652490 FUEL AND LUB 200.00 200.00 200.00 140.82 59.18
652920 COMPUTER SOFT 3,000.00 3,000.00 3,000.00 3,000.00
652990 OTHER OPERATI 2,000.00 2,000.00 2,000.00 93.00 867.47 1,039.53
654110 BOOKS PUB SUB 500.00 500.00 500.00 500.00
654210 DUES AND MEMB 4,000.00 4,000.00 4,000.00 2,360.00 1,640.00
654360 OTHER TRAININ 4,000.00 4,000.00 4,000.00 4,000.00
*CAPITAL OUTLAY 1,500.00 1,500.00 600,000.00 601,500.00 600,000.00 1,500.00
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 600,000.00 600,000.00 600,000.00
764900 DATA PROCESSI 1,500.00 1,500.00 1,500.00 1,500.00
*TRANSFERS 7,207,300.00 7,207,300.00 7,207,300.00 5,525,300.00 1,682,000.00
Item 9d 4.A.2
Packet Pg. 70 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
910010 TRANS TO 001 53,800.00 53,800.00 53,800.00 53,800.00
912870 TRANS TO 287 3,253,000.00 3,253,000.00 3,253,000.00 3,071,500.00 181,500.00
Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt
Budget
Tot Adopt
Budget
CarryF
Amendme Amendments Tot Amend
Budget Commitment Actual Available
917870 TRANS TO 787 3,200,000.00 3,200,000.00 3,200,000.00 2,400,000.00 800,000.00
921600 ADV/REPAY TO 700,500.00 700,500.00 700,500.00 700,500.00
*RESERVES 1,050,500.00 1,050,500.00 1,380,500.00 1,380,500.00
991000 RESV FOR CONT 85,000.00 85,000.00 85,000.00 85,000.00
993000 RESV FOR CAPI 965,500.00 965,500.00 1,295,500.00 1,295,500.00
Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt
Budget
Tot Adopt
Budget
CarryF
Amendme Amendments Tot Amend
Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total-Fund/ CI
*** 787 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 330,281.25 7,984.44 338,265.69-
** REVENUE Sub Total 3,200,000.00-3,200,000.00-2,998,515.53-6,198,515.53-2,402,814.76-3,795,700.77-
*REVENUE - OPERATING Su 2,814.76-2,814.76
361170 OVERNIGHT INT 1,327.49-1,327.49
361180 INVESTMENT IN 1,487.27-1,487.27
369300 REIMB FOR PY EXPE 5,000.00-5,000.00
*CONTRIBUTION AND TRANS 3,200,000.00-3,200,000.00-2,998,515.53-6,198,515.53-2,400,000.00-3,798,515.53-
481187 TRANS FRM 187 3,200,000.00-3,200,000.00-3,200,000.00-2,400,000.00-800,000.00-
489201 CARRY FORWARD 2,998,515.53-2,998,515.53-2,998,515.53-
** EXPENSE Sub Total 3,200,000.00 3,200,000.00 2,998,515.53 6,198,515.53 303,632.25 2,415,799.20 3,452,435.08
*OPERATING EXPENSE 100,000.00 100,000.00 133,400.00 200.00 233,600.00 7,051.50 199,899.50
631650 ABSTRACT FEES 7,600.00 7,600.00 37.50 7,562.50
631800 ENVIRONMENTAL 25,000.00 25,000.00 25,000.00
634980 INTERDEPT PAYMENT 476.00 476.00-
634999 OTHER CONTRAC 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00
639990 OTHER CONTRAC 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 6,538.00 66,813.00
649030 CLERKS RECORD 800.00 200.00 1,000.00 1,000.00
*CAPITAL OUTLAY 1,400,000.00 1,400,000.00 2,618,000.00 4,018,000.00 303,632.25 2,295,201.94 1,419,165.81
761100 LAND CAPITAL 2,118,000.00 2,118,000.00 2,118,020.50 20.50-
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 1,400,000.00 1,400,000.00 500,000.00 1,900,000.00 303,632.25 177,181.44 1,419,186.31
Fund 787 Bayshore CRA Projects
Item 9d 4.A.2
Packet Pg. 71 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
*GRANTS AND DEBT SERVIC 200,000.00 200,000.00 247,115.53 200.00-446,915.53 113,545.76 333,369.77
884200 RESIDENTIAL R 200,000.00 200,000.00 247,115.53 200.00-446,915.53 113,545.76 333,369.77
*RESERVES 1,500,000.00 1,500,000.00 1,500,000.00 1,500,000.00
993000 RESV FOR CAPI 1,500,000.00 1,500,000.00 1,500,000.00 1,500,000.00
Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt
Budget
Tot Adopt
Budget
CarryF
Amendme Amendment Tot Amend
Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total-Fund/ CI
*** 50197 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 100,000.00 100,000.00 77,327.00 177,327.00 8,545.76 168,781.24
** EXPENSE Sub Total 100,000.00 100,000.00 77,327.00 177,327.00 13,545.76 163,781.24
*OPERATING EXPENSE 173.00-173.00
369300 REIMB FOR PY EXPE 5,000.00-5,000.00
649030 CLERKS RECORD 173.00-173.00
*GRANTS AND DEBT SERVIC 100,000.00 100,000.00 77,500.00 173.00-177,327.00 13,545.76 163,781.24
884200 RESIDENTIAL R 100,000.00 100,000.00 77,500.00 173.00-177,327.00 13,545.76 163,781.24
Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt
Budget
Tot Adopt
Budget
CarryF
Amendme Amendment Tot Amend
Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total-Fund/ CI
*** 50198 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 100,000.00 100,000.00 169,588.53 269,588.43 100,000.00 169,588.53
** EXPENSE Sub Total 100,000.00 100,000.00 169,588.53 269,588.43 100,000.00 169,588.53
*OPERATING EXPENSE 27.00-27.00
649030 CLERKS RECORD 27.00-27.00
*GRANTS AND DEBT SERVIC 100,000.00 100,000.00 169,615.53 27.00-269,588.43 100,000.00 169,588.53
884200 RESIDENTIAL R 100,000.00 100,000.00 169,615.53 27.00-269,588.43 100,000.00 169,588.53
Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt
Budget
Tot Adopt
Budget
Tot Amend
Budget Commitment Actual Available
Fund 787 Project 50197 Residential Grants
Fund 787 Project 50198 Commercial Grants
Fund 787 Project 50203 Stormwater
Item 9d 4.A.2
Packet Pg. 72 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
**** Grand Total-Fund/ CI
*** 50203 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 550,000.00 550,000.00 550,000.00 550,000.00
** EXPENSE Sub Total 550,000.00 550,000.00 550,000.00 550,000.00
*CAPITAL OUTLAY 550,000.00 550,000.00 550,000.00 550,000.00
634980 INTERDEPT PAYMENT 476.00 476.00-
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 550,000.00 550,000.00 550,000.00 550,000.00
Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt
Budget
Tot Adopt
Budget
Tot Amend
Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total-Fund/ CI
*** 50204 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00
** EXPENSE Sub Total 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00
*CAPITAL OUTLAY 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00
Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt
Budget
Tot Adopt
Budget
CarryF
Amendme
Tot Amend
Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total-Fund/ CI
*** 50206 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 600,000.00 600,000.00 2,151,600.00 2,751,600.00 26,649.00 2,124,596.00 600,355.00
** EXPENSE Sub Total 600,000.00 600,000.00 2,151,600.00 2,751,600.00 26,649.00 2,124,596.00 600,355.00
*OPERATING EXPENSE 100,000.00 100,000.00 33,600.00 133,600.00 26,649.00 6,575.50 100,375.50
631650 ABSTRACT FEES 7,600.00 7,600.00 37.50 7,562.50
631800 ENVIRONMENTAL 25,000.00 25,000.00 25,000.00
639990 OTHER CONTRAC 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 26,649.00 6,538.00 66,813.00
649030 CLERKS RECORD 1,000.00 1,000.00 1,000.00
*CAPITAL OUTLAY 500,000.00 500,000.00 2,118,000.00 2,618,000.00 2,118,020.50 499,979.50
761100 LAND CAPITAL 2,118,000.00 2,118,000.00 2,118,020.50 20.50-
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 500,000.00 500,000.00 500,000.00 500,000.00
Fund 787 Project 50204 Linwood
Fund 787 Project 50206 Ackerman-Dells
Fund 787 Project 50207 Bayshore Parking Lot
Item 9d 4.A.2
Packet Pg. 73 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt
Budget
CarryF
Amendme Amendment Tot Amend
Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total-Fund/ CI
*** 50207 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 500,000.00 500,000.00 303,632.25 177,181.44 19,186.31
** EXPENSE Sub Total 500,000.00 500,000.00 303,632.25 177,181.44 19,186.31
*CAPITAL OUTLAY 500,000.00 500,000.00 303,632.25 177,181.44 19,186.31
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 500,000.00 500,000.00 303,632.25 177,181.44 19,186.31
Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt
Budget
Tot Adopt
Budget
CarryF
Amendme
Tot Amend
Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total-Fund/ CI
*** 50208 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 250,000.00 250,000.00 100,000.00 350,000.00 350,000.00
** EXPENSE Sub Total 250,000.00 250,000.00 100,000.00 350,000.00 350,000.00
*OPERATING EXPENSE 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00
639999 OTHER CONTRAC 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00
*CAPITAL OUTLAY 250,000.00 250,000.00 250,000.00 250,000.00
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 250,000.00 250,000.00 250,000.00 250,000.00
Fund 787 Project 50208 17 Acre Site
Item 9d
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 74 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt
Budget
Tot Adopt
Budget
Tot Amend
Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total-Fund/ CI
*** 163 BAYSHORE/AVALON MST 114,137.97 287,762.60-173,624.63
** REVENUE Sub Total 1,347,700.00-1,347,700.00-1,347,700.00-1,207,139.86-140,560.14-
*REVENUE - OPERATING Su 1,295,300.00-1,295,300.00-1,295,300.00-1,207,139.86-88,160.14-
311100 CUR AD VALORE 1,285,300.00-1,285,300.00-1,285,300.00-1,205,603.74-79,696.26-
311200 DEL AD VALORE 1.54-1.54
361170 OVERNIGHT INT 422.28-422.28
361180 INVESTMENT IN 10,000.00-10,000.00-10,000.00-985.83-9,014.17-
361320 INTEREST TAX 126.47-126.47
*CONTRIBUTION AND TRANS 52,400.00-52,400.00-52,400.00-52,400.00-
486600 TRANS FROM PR
486700 TRANS FROM TA
489200 CARRY FORWARD 117,200.00-117,200.00-117,200.00-117,200.00-
489900 NEG 5% EST RE 64,800.00 64,800.00 64,800.00 64,800.00
** EXPENSE Sub Total 1,342,700.00 1,347,700.00 1,347,700.00 114,137.97 919,245.65 309,934.77
*OPERATING EXPENSE 325,100.00 330,100.00 330,100.00 114,137.97 167,334.08 44,246.34
631400 ENG FEES 37,974.00 37,974.00-
634970 INDIRECT COST 5,200.00 5,200.00 5,200.00 5,200.00
634980 INTERDEPT PAYMENT 500.00 500.00-
634990 LANDSCAPE INC 102,000.00 102,000.00 102,000.00 862.18 2,137.82 99,000.00
634999 OTHER CONTRAC 102,000.00 102,000.00 102,000.00 34,005.75 20,406.50 47,587.75
643100 ELECTRICITY 25,000.00 25,000.00 25,000.00 17,031.08 9,802.93 1,834.01-
645100 INSURANCE GEN 900.00 900.00 900.00 225.00 675.00
645260 AUTO INSURANC 900.00 900.00 900.00 225.00 675.00
646311 SPRINKLER SYS 10,000.00 10,000.00 10,000.00 180.57-10,180.57
646318 MULCH 15,000.00 15,000.00 15,000.00 829.70 7,670.30 6,500.00
646360 MAINT OF GROU 20,000.00 20,000.00 20,000.00 20,000.00
646430 FLEET MAINT I 5,000.00 5,000.00 5,000.00 2,496.00 2,504.00
646440 FLEET MAINT P 2,200.00 2,200.00 2,200.00 90.75 2,109.25
646445 FLEET NON MAI 300.00 300.00 300.00 34.67 265.33
Fund 163 Bayshore MSTU Item 9e
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 75 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
646451 LIGHTING MAIN 35,000.00 35,000.00 35,000.00 59,340.87 69,298.59 93,639.46-
649100 LEGAL ADVERTI 1,200.00 1,200.00 1,200.00 1,500.00 300.00-
Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt
Budget
Tot Adopt
Budget
Tot Amend
Budget Commitment Actual Available
652310 FERT HERB CHEM $5,000.00 $5,000.00 118.39 131.61 4750.00
652490 FUEL AND LUB 400.00 400.00 400.00 37.66 362.34
652990 OTHER OPERATI 10,515.43 10,515.43-
*TRANSFERS 917,100.00 917,100.00 917,100.00 719,200.00 197,900.00
911600 TRANS TO 160 791,600.00 791,600.00 791,600.00 593,700.00 197,900.00
911870 TRANS TO 187 125,500.00 125,500.00 125,500.00 125,500.00
*TRANSFER CONST 41,300.00 41,300.00 41,300.00 32,711.57 8,588.43
930600 PA BUDGET TR 12,300.00 12,300.00 12,300.00 7,419.27 4,880.73
930700 TC BUDGET TR 29,000.00 29,000.00 29,000.00 25,292.30 3,707.70
*RESERVES 59,200.00 59,200.00 59,200.00 59,200.00
993000 RESV FOR CAPI 59,200.00 59,200.00 59,200.00 59,200.00
Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt
Budget
Tot Adopt
Budget
CarryF
Amendme Amendments Tot Amend
Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total-Fund/ CI
*** 160 BAYSHORE/AVALON PR 3,497,601.96 1,520,187.69 5,017,789.65-
** REVENUE Sub Total 1,575,000.00-1,575,000.00-5,637,295.80-7,212,295.80-607,325.83-6,604,969.97-
*REVENUE - OPERATING Su 13,625.83-13,625.83
361170 OVERNIGHT INT 3,467.56-3,467.56
361180 INVESTMENT IN 10,158.27-10,158.27
*CONTRIBUTION AND TRANS 1,575,000.00-1,575,000.00-5,637,295.80-7,212,295.80-593,700.00-6,618,595.80-
481163 TRANS FRM 163 791,600.00-791,600.00-791,600.00-593,700.00-197,900.00-
482187 ADV/REPAY FRM 700,500.00-700,500.00-700,500.00-700,500.00-
489200 CARRY FORWARD 82,900.00-82,900.00-82,900.00-82,900.00-
489201 CARRY FORWARD 5,637,295.80-5,637,295.80-5,637,295.80-
** EXPENSE Sub Total 1,575,000.00 1,575,000.00 5,637,295.80 7,212,295.80 3,497,601.96 2,127,513.52 1,587,180.32
*OPERATING EXPENSE 202,017.26 85,836.00 287,853.26 154,315.88 460,203.17 326,665.79-
631400 ENG FEES 287,853.26 287,853.26 154,315.88 460,203.17 326,665.79-
646451 LIGHTING MAIN 85,836.00-85,836.00
Fund 160 Bayshore Capital Projects
Item 9e 4.A.2
Packet Pg. 76 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
*CAPITAL OUTLAY 1,550,000.00 1,550,000.00 5,435,278.54 85,836.00-6,899,442.54 3,343,286.08 1,667,310.35 1,888,846.11
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 1,550,000.00 1,550,000.00 5,435,278.54 85,836.00-6,899,442.54 3,343,286.08 1,667,310.35 1,888,846.11
*RESERVES 25,000.00 25,000.00 25,000.00 25,000.00
993000 RESV FOR CAPI 25,000.00 25,000.00 25,000.00 25,000.00
Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt
Budget
Tot Adopt
Budget
CarryF
Amendme
Tot Amend
Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total-Fund/ CI
*** 50174 BAYSHORE/AVALON PR 250,000.00 250,000.00 90,416.00 340,416.00 90,416.00 250,000.00
** EXPENSE Sub Total 250,000.00 250,000.00 90,416.00 340,416.00 90,416.00 250,000.00
*CAPITAL OUTLAY 250,000.00 250,000.00 90,416.00 340,416.00 90,416.00 250,000.00
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 250,000.00 250,000.00 90,416.00 340,416.00 90,416.00 250,000.00
Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt
Budget
CarryF
Amendme Amendments Tot Amend
Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total-Fund/ CI
*** 50173 BAYSHORE/AVALON PR 11,635.00 11,635.00 11,635.00
** EXPENSE Sub Total 11,635.00 11,635.00 11,635.00
*OPERATING EXPENSE 11,635.00 11,635.00 11,635.00
631400 ENG FEES 11,635.00 11,635.00 11,635.00
Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt
Budget
CarryF
Amendme Amendments Tot Amend
Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total-Fund/ CI
*** 50154 FEMA BAYSHORE/AV 164.00 164.00 164.00
** EXPENSE Sub Total 164.00 164.00 164.00
*OPERATING EXPENSE 85,836.00-85,836.00
646451 LIGHTING MAIN 85,836.00-85,836.00
Fund 160 Project 50174 North Bayshore
Fund 160 Project 50173 South Bayshore
Fund 160 Project 50154 FEMA
Item 9e 4.A.2
Packet Pg. 77 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
*CAPITAL OUTLAY 86,000.00 85,836.00-164.00 164.00
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 86,000.00 85,836.00-164.00 164.00
Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt
Budget
CarryF
Amendme Amendments Tot Amend
Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total-Fund/ CI
*** 50172 BAYSHORE/AVALON PR 5,535,080.80 5,535,080.80 3,407,185.96 2,127,513.52 381.32
** EXPENSE Sub Total 5,535,080.80 5,535,080.80 3,407,185.96 2,127,513.52 381.32
*OPERATING EXPENSE 276,218.26 276,218.26 154,315.88 460,203.17 338,300.79-
631400 ENG FEES 276,218.26 276,218.26 154,315.88 460,203.17 338,300.79-
*CAPITAL OUTLAY 5,258,862.54 5,258,862.54 3,252,870.08 1,667,310.35 338,682.11
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 5,258,862.54 5,258,862.54 3,252,870.08 1,667,310.35 338,682.11
Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt
Budget
Tot Adopt
Budget
Tot Amend
Budget Commitment Actual Available
**** Grand Total-Fund/ CI
*** 50171 BAYSHORE/AVALON PR 599,500.00 599,500.00 599,500.00 599,500.00
** REVENUE Sub Total 700,500.00-700,500.00-700,500.00-700,500.00-
*CONTRIBUTION AND TRANS 700,500.00-700,500.00-700,500.00-700,500.00-
482187 ADV/REPAY FRM 700,500.00-700,500.00-700,500.00-700,500.00-
** EXPENSE Sub Total 1,300,000.00 1,300,000.00 1,300,000.00 1,300,000.00
*CAPITAL OUTLAY 1,300,000.00 1,300,000.00 1,300,000.00 1,300,000.00
763100 IMPROVEMENTS 1,300,000.00 1,300,000.00 1,300,000.00 1,300,000.00
Fund 160 Project 50172 Thomasson Drive
Fund 160 Project 50171 Hamilton Ave Parking
Item 9e 4.A.2
Packet Pg. 78 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
Bayshore CRA Open Cases
May 2021 Meeting
Case Number Case Type Description Date Entered Location Description Detailed Description
CEPM20180010632 PM Open 08/21/2018 End of Mangrove Street
Seawall is severely damaged and in need of repair
CESD20180010777 SD Open 08/24/2018 Interior renovations without a permit, see Contractor Licensing Case CECV20180010498.
CENA20190006751 NA Open 06/04/2019
No site address (Becca Ave), folio: 29831280009
lot is across from Pine St Exotics on unimproved lot within 200 ft of residential property
CENA20190006753 NA Open 06/04/2019
Off Becca Ave, Folio: 29831240007
Exotics on unimproved lot within 200 ft radius of residential property.
CEPM20190009270 PM Open 07/30/2019 2965 LUNAR ST - 53353080009 Complainant stated that the property has been vacant for over a year, overgrowth and debris throughout.
CEPM20190014027 PM Open 11/20/2019
2978 Poplar St - 29831080005
Structure with roof and siding damage.
CEPM20200000363 PM Open 01/10/2020
2862 Arbutus St - 81780360005 (note: CC Prop Appr. does not recognize these
"common area" address points)
permit number: PRBD20190522726. This permit is linked to 2862 Arbutus St - Docks that are failing and starting to fall into the water. Hazard for boats in the area.
CESD20200002597 SD Open 03/09/2020
327 Pier A
Folio #00388200001
Unpermitted deck and sliding glass doors, see Contractor Licensing Case .
CESD20200003700 SD Open 04/07/2020
3 Crooked Ln - 59980880003
Refurbished 3 weeks ago without permits. People had gone in and out since the order has been under effect.
CESD20200004287 SD Open 04/21/2020
Rear of house
2800 Riverview Dr.
Naples, FL un-permitted work being performed. Deck in rear of house being redone.
CENA20200004979 NA Open 05/08/2020 3015 Karen Dr High grass
CENA20200006121 NA Open 06/09/2020 61839440003 - 3175 KAREN DR grass & weeds in excess of 18". Also accumulation of vegetative debris.
CENA20200006128 NA Open 06/09/2020 61840320002 - 3155 KAREN DR Grass & weeds in excess of 18", and, vegetative debris on this unimproved lot.
CESD20200007077 SD Open 07/02/2020
2575 Barrett Ave - 81730600003
No permit for shed in rear, fence & awning in front of house. Also, it appears the back porch is falling apart.
CENA20200007348 NA Open 07/13/2020 Behind 122 Jeepers Dr - CRA Parcel - 61840960103 Easement between two fences has exotics, high grass & trees encroaching into callers property
CENA20200010414 NA Open 09/24/2020
50891000007 - 2596 HOLLY AVE
Prior cases : CENA
Grass & weeds in excess of 18". Also - vegetative debris.
Inclusion to Mandatory lot Mowing propgram as of today 10/8/2020
CEAU20200011144 AU Open 10/14/2020
69 River Drive
Harmony Shores (61841680000)
Unpermitted fence, see Contractor Licensing Case CECV20200010963.
CEPM20200011324 PM Open 10/19/2020 2715 Holly Ave - 50890360007
Tenant called her walls are coming apart form the water damnage, the a/c is leaking, mold in the carpet and the bathrooms, and she has
a rat problem. She is moving,m but doesnt want next tenant to suffer a she has.
CESD20200012115 SD Open 11/10/2020
2775, 2781, and 2815 Bayview Dr - Orick Marina
61835200001 - 2775 BAYVIEW DR Orick Marine on Bayview has built/installed additional boat lifts without permits.
CEAU20200012394 AU Open 11/19/2020 48170560005 - Parkinglot on Bayshore between Shoreview & Bayview Drives Fence in need of repair or replacement.
CELU20200013216 LU Open 12/10/2020
Vacant lot on east side of Bayshore Drive across from Weeks Ave - 71580220009
(****AIMs ??*****)Homeless camp on vacant land. (****AIMs ??*****)
CEPM20200013712 PM Open 12/23/2020 50890680004 - 2605 Holly Ave
Property has a mobile home on it that the owner feels should be condemned. He has occupants in the mobile home that will not leave
and that he is trying to evict. He would like to see if the County could inspect the mobile home and deem it unhabitable so the
occupants would have no choice but to move out. He then intends to demolish the mobile home.
CESD20210000333 SD Open 01/11/2021 48171880001 - 2672 GULFVIEW DR New dock and boat lift installed without the required permitting.
Item 10a 4.A.2
Packet Pg. 79 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
Bayshore CRA Open Cases
May 2021 Meeting
CENA20210000449 NA Open 01/14/2021
71580220009 (1st vacant parcel - Bayshore)
***** AIMs *****
Exotics on unimproved parcel.
***** AIMs *****
CENA20210000451 NA Open 01/14/2021
71580240005 (2nd vacant lot - Bayshore)
**** AIMs ****
Exotics on vacant parcel. (2nd lot - Bayshore)
**** AIMs ****
CENA20210000453 NA Open 01/14/2021
71580250008 (3rd vacant lot - Bayshore)
**** AIMs ****
Exotics on unimproved parcel.
**** AIMs ****
CENA20210000454 NA Open 01/14/2021
71580260001 (4th vacant lot on Bayshore)
**** AIMs ****
Exotics on unimproved lot.
**** AIMs ****
CENA20210000456 NA Open 01/14/2021
61841600006 (5th vacant lot Bayshore - triangle shape on creek)
**** AIMs ****
Exoitics on unimproved parcel.
**** AIMs ****
CENA20210000685 NA Open 01/21/2021 71780240009 - 3181 BAYSHORE Garbage & debris on the parcel, silt fence is falling over, exotics (pepper hedge) on parcel
CEPM20210000793 PM Open 01/25/2021 50890480000 - 2665 HOLLY AVE Mobile home has severe fire damage
CESD20210001113 SD Open 02/01/2021 81731640004 - 2528 BARRETT AVE Multiple sheds and accessory structures. (Bayshore CRA)
CESD20210001376 SD Open 02/07/2021
Celebration Park - 29830040004 - 2880 BECCA AVE
Greater Naples Fire Rescue District, Fire and Life Safety Section Celebration Park - food truck deliveries were witnessed to be blocking fire lane. Large propane tanks require permits and inspections.
CENA20210001924 NA Open 02/24/2021 81780240002 - Unimproved lot at the west end of Becca Ave High grass & weeds in excess of 18"
CEROW20210002017 ROW Open 02/27/2021
48173280007 - 3470 BAYSHORE DR
Pavement in the ROW without permits
CELU20210002281 LU Open 03/08/2021 71780600005 - 3241 SABAL CT Vacant lot being used as a staging area for materials not related to the scope of work for the existing permit.
CEPM20210002299 PM Open 03/09/2021 29280440005 - 2648 VAN BUREN AVE House has shed in backyard that is old and rusted with a bunch of rats in it.
Item 10a 4.A.2
Packet Pg. 80 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
Bayshore CRA
May 2021
Case Number Case Type Description Date Entered Location Description Detailed Description
CELU20210002753 LU Open 03/22/2021 Parcel # 29281140003 - 2733 Van Buren
A couple weeks bringing in fill by truck loads soil to property still sitting there and
elevating the property higher than neighboring property without any permits. No
building permits no ROW permit no permits.
CESD20210002756 SD Open 03/22/2021 50891160002 - 2650 HOLLY AVE
Unsafe half demolished structure taken down without any permits. Safety hazard.
Property is also not being maintained.
CENA20210002816 NA Closed 03/23/2021 66880840000 High weeds
CENA20210002836 NA Closed 03/24/2021 Becca Ave & Bayshore 2 abandoned shopping carts in the ROW
CENA20210002839 NA Closed 03/24/2021 Areca & Bayshore Abandoned shopping cart
CESS20210002875 SS Closed 03/24/2021 Bayshore Drive MosquitoNix snipe signs in the ROW on Bayshore
CEPM20210002950 PM Closed 03/26/2021
NW section of the intersection. Please have the vegetation /
hedge row trimmed so that sight triangle is maintained
Collier County Traffic Operations has altered the intersection of Palm St and
Marlin Dr to a multiway stop condition. Sight lines are impaired due to
vegetation.
CESD20210002972 SD Open 03/26/2021 60585160007 - 109 MOORHEAD MNR
Unpermitted kitchen/sink remodel, see Contractor Licensing case
CECV20210002286.
CESD20210003023 SD Open 03/29/2021 50891120000 - 2626 HOLLY AVE Right of way permit expired and never completed.
CEROW20210003096 ROW Closed 03/30/2021 52505119363 - 6248 MEGANS BAY DR
Front of garage window left side above side walk pipe (maybe water she is not
sure) box in ground is not level so top cover is not secure and is a tripping hazard
CEPM20210003116 PM Closed 03/30/2021
Along Commercial Dr
Behind 2300 Davis Blvd. Economy Body Shop
Graffiti on utility boxes
Between Davis Blvd. & Kirkwood Dr. in the alley on backwall of Economy Body
Shop
CELU20210003137 LU Open 03/30/2021 3056 Van Buren AVE, Building, Mobile/Modular, Naples
*Web-Complaint* Changed case type from CEPM to CESD-for permitting
case./KB
Place is a mess. Several structures in the back. owner is doing up the mobile home
without permits.
CELU20210003138 LU Open 03/30/2021 3064 Lunar ST, Building, Mobile/Modular, Naples
They have way too many cars They always park on the pavement. There are many
structures in the back. There are about 10 people living in this small Mobile home
and they make a lot of noise.
CELU20210003156 LU Open 03/31/2021
61835360006 - 2891 BAYVIEW DR
*** AIMs on 4/8 - 62701 ***
Possible land use violation - Jet ski rentals at 360Market
*** AIMs on 4/8 - 62701 ***
CESD20210003169 SD Closed 03/31/2021 It is at 2416 washington ave.
unpermitted construction they are turning the garaage into a guest house withput
permits.
CEV20210003230 V Closed 04/02/2021 81270960009 - 2595 BECCA AVE Bayshore CRA - a camper parked in front of apartments on right
CEVR20210003239 VR Closed 04/03/2021 1549 Sandpiper Street - ROYAL BAY VILLAS Neighbor behind her cut down trees on her property
CELU20210003296 LU Open 04/05/2021 3092 Coco - - actually 71781600004 - 3092 BASIN ST
CRA - A large refrigerator has been by the front door that has been there over a
month. Tenants, in the unit where the refrigerator is, may be operating their
business out of the back of this property. Reported to be actively loading,
unloaded, prepping materials or many other activities early mornings, so it may be
hard to catch them in the act.
Item 10a 4.A.2
Packet Pg. 81 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
Bayshore CRA
May 2021
CEV20210003305 V Open 04/06/2021
6025 Bayshore Drive
Naples Fl 34112
Chickens, Broken beer bottles, trash and bond fires (unfounded)
Processing Vehcile with no tag case..
CES20210003386 S Closed 04/07/2021 2959 Davis Blvd.Flutter flags / Prohibited signs displayed at Walker' Marine
CELU20210003392 LU Closed 04/07/2021 3178 Lakeview Dr.
Front yard on property line- wires are exposed from a box but can not tell where its
from. Called FP&L they said it seems like its probably some type of
communitcations. Not thiers. Concerned because exposed wires coming from a
box with panel off.
CES20210003470 S Closed 04/09/2021 Corner of Spruce & Washington Junk Cars sign nailed to a utility pole.
CEOCC20210003541 OCC Closed 04/12/2021 209 W Main St Immokalee
Code received a letter (letter attached to case) requesting whether or not the shoe
store at this location has a business license. Please see letter attached.
CEV20210003554 V Open 04/12/2021 2195 Palm St Motorhome in driveway w/ tarp on it. Been there for a while
CEV20210003582 V Open 04/13/2021 71781600004 - 3092 BASIN ST Commercial vehicles parked on a residence.
CEPM20210003587 PM Open 04/13/2021
Across from Shadownlawn school, near church. Shadowlawn
Dr Utility box with graffiti.
CESD20210003627 SD Open 04/14/2021 52505113686 - 5911 HAITI DR
Yard lights put in are very bright. The light is coming over into the callers unit
who lives in an adjacent community.
CEAU20210003655 AU Closed 04/15/2021 2464 Sunset Ave - 75761600004 Put 6 foot fence up around property.
CEV20210003656 V Closed 04/15/2021 52700640103 - 3056 Van Buren AVE
While investigating a Land Use complaint, I did witness a vehicle with no license
tag.
CELU20210003784 LU Closed 04/16/2021 GulfGate Parking Plaza - 61834960009 Food Truck selling in parking lot of GulfGate Plaza
CES20210003786 S Closed 04/16/2021 3954 Bayshore - 55701720003 Flutter flag observed on Bayshore
CEV20210003787 V Closed 04/16/2021 2919 Karen - 61840120008 Boat & trailer parked on the grass in the ROW
CEV20210003788 V Open 04/16/2021 3050 Karen - 61840160000 Vehicle (Audi) parked on the grass on the ROW
CEV20210003790 V Closed 04/16/2021 3135 Karen - 61839520004 Green VW parked on the grass.
CESS20210003808 SS Closed 04/18/2021 Shadowlawn & 41 "Junk Cars" snipe sign in the ROW
CEV20210003809 V Open 04/18/2021 48173800005 - 2605 LAKEVIEW DR White Transit Van parked on the grass in the ROW.
CEV20210003810 V Open 04/18/2021 81732480001 - 2742 STORTER AVE Blue 4-dr Versa parked on the grass in the ROW
CENA20210003841 NA Open 04/19/2021 71800000307 - 3339 CANAL ST Trash from the neighbor is being placed on the ROW of the complainant.
Item 10a 4.A.2
Packet Pg. 82 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
Bayshore CRA
May 2021
CEV20210003843 V Open 04/19/2021 71780920002 - 2965 COCO AVE Bayshore CRA - Boat & trailer parked in driveway @ 2965 Coco.
Item 10a 4.A.2
Packet Pg. 83 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory
1/11
April 5, 2021
A New Dawn for East Naples?
gulfshorebusiness.com/a-new-dawn-for-east-naples
TRIO OF TOWERS: Luxury condos, shops and restaurants are part of the Metropolitan Naples project
planned where Davis Boulevard meets at U.S. 41 East.
Across Naples Bay from Port Royal’s multimillion-dollar estates sits a long-neglected Collier
County community still struggling to overcome a legacy of squalor and slums.
Plenty of vacant lots, Old Florida fishing cottages and single-wide trailers remain scattered
throughout Bayshore, a former fishing community that sprouted more than half a century
ago on the east side of Naples Bay as a more affordable alternative for laborers and service
workers who helped build Collier County.
The community long ago shed the name of Kelly Road, the main north-south corridor once
known as Collier County’s red-light district because of its prostitutes, drug dealers and other
criminals. By changing the two-lane street’s name in the 1990s to Bayshore Drive, residents
hoped they could rid the area of its seedy reputation and rebuild like their neighbors to the
west in the city of Naples. But change is slow, Bayshore residents and Collier County leaders
have learned. The drive a mile east to Bayshore from Fifth Avenue South’s boutique shops,
Item 11a
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 84 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
2/11
Fred Pezeshkan
luxury condos and fine restaurants remains a jolting reminder of the development that never
came. As Fifth Avenue crosses over to Tamiami Trail East, the gateway to East Naples
transforms into abandoned parcels, repair shops and cheap motels.
For more than 20 years, county officials have flirted with developers, hoping to entice them
to Bayshore with taxpayer money if they build that showcase project needed to attract more
community investment. Now, two developers are promising to break ground soon on
separate projects that could serve as the catalysts to deliver Bayshore’s transformation.
Vision of new heights
After more than four years of delays, the county late last year sold 5 acres to developers Jerry
Starkey and Fred Pezeshkan, who have proposed a $250 million, three-tower complex of
luxury condos, shops and restaurants in the shadow of Fifth Avenue South. The county
offered the developers property tax rebates that could range from $3 million to $5 million to
complete their Metropolitan Naples project, in hopes it will bring more investment to East
Naples.
“I have lived in Naples for over 40 years, and believe this mixed-use community will indeed
stimulate high-quality redevelopment to the east and significantly increase property values,
just as the Andres Duany Plan stimulated high-quality redevelopment along Fifth Avenue
South over the last 30 years,” Pezeshkan says.
Another developer, David Parker, also is promising luxury condos, shops, a restaurant and a
hotel in a $100 million, nine-story project adjacent to Metropolitan Naples. After Parker
revealed his development plans last year, he asked county leaders for similar incentives given
to Starkey and Pezeshkan, vowing to finish his project first as Bayshore’s real catalyst for
growth.
Item 11a 4.A.2
Packet Pg. 85 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
3/11
“We’re going to be the first one out of the ground,” says Richard Yovanovich, Parker’s lawyer.
“We’re going to be taking the most risk.”
FUTURE OPPORTUNITIES: Amapofthe Community
Redevelopment Agency boundary shows the Bayshore and
Gateway Triangle mixed-use districts in East Naples.
How much is too much?
The request surprised Collier County commissioners, who aren’t accustomed to making such
deals with developers.
The agreement with Starkey and Pezeshkan was Collier’s first through a Community
Redevelopment Agency, a special entity used by hundreds of other jurisdictions across
Florida to stimulate growth in struggling areas. And some leaders argue it should be their last
Item 11a 4.A.2
Packet Pg. 86 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
4/11
Commissioner Penny Taylor
in Bayshore.
“The camel’s nose is in the tent,” says Commissioner Penny Taylor, who led her colleagues in
denying Parker’s request in January, arguing the $714,000 in incentives would serve as a
dangerous precedent. “I think it’s corporate welfare at its worst.
Collier leaders now are rethinking how they manage redevelopment. Should they offer
taxpayer money for private projects? Where do they draw the line between encouraging
growth and interfering with free enterprise? Should the county buy land for developers?
“There’s this theory that we’re Naples and you should just come here because we’re nice,”
says Collier County Commissioner William McDaniel Jr. Sure, Naples is nice, McDaniel said,
but the county should do more to encourage commercial development, including creating an
incentive program that provides public investment.
The promise of two major projects in the
Bayshore area also is expected to renew
discussions about the Community
Redevelopment Agency set up in 2000 to help
attract investors and businesses to East Naples.
The CRA, which keeps millions in property
taxes collected in the Bayshore area for
redevelopment, is scheduled to expire in 2030.
But county leaders could extend the life of the
CRA to manage ongoing development.
“There’s work to be done in Bayshore,” says
CRA Director Debrah Forester, noting the
agency’s success so far in providing
infrastructure, planning and growth for the
area.
But other development in recent years, while not as dramatic as the two major projects
proposed for the triangle area where Davis Boulevard and U.S. 41 meet, is proof to some that
it’s time for the county to step back and let growth occur naturally.
Builders and entrepreneurs have invested their own money in the community over the past
decade, gradually helping to diversify the economy, cultivate a cultural identity and increase
homeownership in an area scarred by transient renters and absentee landlords.
Porsche Naples opened at Davis Boulevard and Airport-Pulling. Bayshore Drive became
home to Ankrolab Brewing Company, Three60 Market and Celebration Park. More than 600
new homes are planned in subdivisions with names such as Camden Landing, Arboretum
Item 11a 4.A.2
Packet Pg. 87 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
5/11
and The Isles of Collier Preserve. Hundreds of new apartments are planned for Courthouse
Shadows. Three shopping centers on the East Trail sold separately last year for a total of
nearly $35 million.
All of this growth on top of the major developments proposed has some Bayshore residents
and business owners worried that too much gentrification will inflate property values and the
cost of doing business, taking away their livelihoods and affordable homes.
“They are picking on poor people,” says Frank Lacava, who has owned property in the
Gateway Triangle for more than 20 years where an auto shop and storage center now are
located. “They want all of us gone, but we’ll have no place to go.”
GATEWAY TO NAPLES: A rendering of another major luxury condo-hotel project planned on the “Mini
Triangle” at U.S. 41 East and Davis Boulevard.
How we got here
A history of promises broken by developers makes Lacava and others doubt the big, towering
complexes will bring prosperity to Bayshore.
When Collier County launched its Community Redevelopment Agency more than 20 years
ago, the idea was to help areas like Immokalee and Bayshore that have been mostly ignored
by developers and businesses. With its prime location near the water and next door to the
city of Naples, Bayshore always offered great potential for growth. But mostly, there has been
disappointment as a number of developers who proposed big projects walked away when
their ideas fizzled.
Item 11a 4.A.2
Packet Pg. 88 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
6/11
The county created the CRA for the Bayshore area in 2000. Florida law allows creation of the
special entities to use property tax growth in targeted communities as a redevelopment tool
to remove blight and to attract investment. The CRA’s redevelopment corridor in East Naples
includes the Gateway Triangle and Davis Boulevard on the northern border; Haldeman Creek
along the west; Airport-Pulling Road and Peters Avenue on the east; and Naples Botanical
Garden toward the south.
The Bayshore CRA spent more than $11 million after it was created to buy land in the
corridor that could be used to encourage development and to improve neglected parcels.
McDaniel and other leaders argue the CRA shouldn’t be in the land speculation business,
noting the county paid too much and sat for too long without a clear plan to develop
Bayshore property.
“That’s not the government’s job,” McDaniel says. “It’s the private sector’s duty to do that.”
Starts and stops
In one case, a developer agreed to take 18 parcels scattered throughout the community off the
CRA’s hands in a purchase agreement that required delivery of new homes. After building
only three, the CRA spent years trying to either reclaim the property or strike another deal.
Last year, the county reached an agreement with a new builder in hopes of completing the
remaining 15 homes.
Two development plans for a cultural center that included a mix of residences and retail on
another 17 acres purchased by the CRA never got off the ground after years of discussion and
financing problems. The acreage now is planned for park use and a smaller version of the
cultural center, while smaller-scale residential and retail projects are still possible, Forester
said.
The Gateway Triangle site where the two mixed residential and commercial developments
are proposed also has seen its share of plans fall through.
The CRA’s agreement to sell 5 acres to Starkey and Pezeshkan for their Metropolitan Naples
project came after an earlier proposal to develop the land failed. And the nearly 2 acres
adjacent to that site now eyed by Parker for his Gateway to Naples development was the
location of another failed luxury condo-hotel proposal.
“The proof is in the pudding that the CRA shouldn’t be in the development business,”
McDaniel says.
Redevelopment takes time, Forester said. She notes other factors affected progress through
the years, including the Great Recession and the pandemic. “You can’t manage the market,
per se, but you have to work with the market,” she says.
Item 11a 4.A.2
Packet Pg. 89 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
7/11
The CRA also struggled at first to find strong leadership and acceptance by other county
leaders, said Donna Fiala, the former Collier County commissioner who championed efforts
for years to improve East Naples. “It took so long to get people to work with you and to let go
of purse strings,” she says.
The CRA recouped the $6.3 million spent on the triangle property in the sale to Starkey and
Pezeshkan, one of the developers who built the Naples Bay Resort just outside the northwest
corner of the special redevelopment district. The CRA used the proceeds to pay off debt and
to buy Del’s 24-hour store for $2.1 million in hopes of managing development at Bayshore
Drive and Thomasson Drive.
The run of bad luck in Bayshore that started long before the CRA’s involvement likely came
as a result of many factors, Taylor said. Investors focused their attention west on the city of
Naples. Bayshore still suffers a bad reputation,
and its physical appearance—with heavy commercial, industrial businesses and some old
trailers and homes— doesn’t help. “We’re still fighting that old mentality of Kelly Road,” says
Maurice Gutierrez, who moved to the area more than 40 years ago.
The CRA way
The CRA offered a laser focus to fix problems in the community, using property taxes
collected in the area that otherwise would go into the county’s general budget to invest
directly in Bayshore. With new businesses and development, the county helped change the
area’s image as “that place you go to engage in illegal activity,” Forester says.
Those tax dollars helped fix flooding problems in the area, expand fire hydrants and
complete other infrastructure improvements that made Bayshore more attractive to
residential and business development, she said.
New development in the corridor, including the triangle projects and more housing, is
expected to generate between $33.7 million and $35.1 million in property tax revenue for the
CRA through 2030, according to estimates from a 2019 redevelopment plan.
But some long-time landowners think the CRA and county leaders have gone too far in
pushing their own vision of what Bayshore should be.
“We want to be left alone,” says Lacava, whose property located in the Gateway Triangle sits
east of the two major complexes envisioned as Bayshore’s transformation. “They’re driving
around now telling us, ‘We don’t like the way it is.’
“Well, it’s not their neighborhood,” he says. “Somebody has a vision, but I don’t know who it
is. It’s not our vision.”
Item 11a 4.A.2
Packet Pg. 90 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
8/11
Richard Yovanovich
Given the history of failed development plans in the area, there’s no guarantee the developers
will keep their promises, Lacava said. “I’m not spending $1 million on a condo in there. If it
was such a good deal, developers would have jumped in 20 years ago.”
Other Bayshore residents are cheering on the new developments in the triangle, despite
concerns that the two complexes could bring more vehicles to an area still wrestling with
parking and traffic problems.
“I guess you have to take the good with the bad,” says Pasquale Razzano, who has lived in
Windstar since 1994, when it became Bayshore’s first major development. “That’s why God
made highway engineers.”
Decisions, decisions
As Windstar’s former homeowner association president, Razzano has clashed with the CRA
in the past over other development proposals. He criticized the CRA for not being
transparent about earlier plans that would have expanded rental and affordable housing in
the area, something many residents said contradicted promises to shift the focus to
homeownership.
“I don’t really understand the makeup of the CRA or who is in control,” Razzano says. “It’s
not an independent board of people who live here.”
Collier County commissioners make up the CRA board, a governing structure used by many
other Florida communities to run their local redevelopment agencies. Some state lawmakers
have unsuccessfully tried for years to change the state law authorizing CRAs, criticizing them
as unnecessary duplications of local government that can be abused by elected leaders to
pursue their own agendas.
Razzano and others credit much of the development that has come to Bayshore in recent
years not to the CRA, but to builders and innovators who brought their own money without
seeing big breaks or incentives.
“Third parties have been the reason for the success,” Razzano says.
Item 11a 4.A.2
Packet Pg. 91 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
9/11
But Forester said the CRA should receive credit for helping attract those investors. “If the
CRA hadn’t been around for the past 20 years, would that have happened? It’s hard to say.”
While CRAs in Lee and Broward counties have more experience, Collier County is relatively
new to the process. With its first incentive deal done on the Metropolitan Naples triangle
project, Collier commissioners now are considering how to move forward in their efforts to
attract development.
When Parker, the second triangle developer proposing the Gateway of Naples project, asked
for similar breaks from the CRA, Collier leaders realized they had no structured program
similar to those found in Lee County to offer developers tax exemptions or rebates.
Parker’s plan didn’t outline a public benefit other than developing the gateway property, so
commissioners argued it didn’t meet the criteria to receive CRA support. But some
commissioners said the county should find a way to help developers who are willing to invest
in Bayshore and other areas.
“It’s a process you can consider to encourage others to develop in this area,” says Yovanovich,
Parker’s lawyer.
McDaniel said the county must find a way to identify worthy commercial projects to support.
While he believes buying land for future development through a CRA is going too far, he
supports creating a program that offers taxpayer investment in commercial development if
certain criteria are met. “Government can have a role in investing in these projects,” he says.
Item 11a 4.A.2
Packet Pg. 92 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
10/11
PERSONAL INVESTMENT: Rebecca Maddox
has risked her own money to create unique
ventures promoting synergy along Bayshore
Drive.
BAYSHORE ATTRACTION: Local entrepreneur Rebecca Maddox plans an 18,000-square-foot wine bar,
restaurant and entertainment venue on green space across Bayshore Drive from her Celebra- tion Park
and Three60 Market.
A local voice
No other entrepreneur has done more to revitalize Bayshore than Rebecca Maddox.
“She hasn’t sought any assistance. She took the big risk,” says Maurice Gutierrez, the long-
time community resident who also chairs the Bayshore CRA advisory board.
Maddox transformed an old waterfront bar on Haldeman Creek she bought in 2010 to
Three60 Market, a restaurant and wine retailer. In 2018, she opened Celebration Park across
the creek, where an eclectic mix of food trucks anchor an open-air bar and dining area.
Now she’s developing a unique wine bar, restaurant, conference and entertainment venue on
Bayshore Drive that will offer up to 18,000 square feet of space for public and private
gatherings meant to attract crowds big and small. She also plans a sculpture garden honoring
history’s greatest thinkers as a peaceful escape for visitors.
Maddox said she’s made the investment
without big breaks from the CRA because she
believes in the community. “I really feel it’s one
of my gifts to Naples,” she says. “I still feel that
I have more I can contribute.”
She had her frustrations with the CRA and the
county, including problems approving a
parking area near Celebration Park and
Three60 Market. She sees the CRA less as an
asset for growth, more as “a government
bureaucracy posing as a redevelopment
agency” for Bayshore.
“They were not the driving force,” she says.
Instead of spending millions on property for development and tax breaks to builders,
Maddox said the CRA could do more for Bayshore by helping small business owners open
salons, art galleries and specialty shops that will cultivate the neighborhood’s unique cultural
appeal and distinguish it from the city of Naples.
“Philosophically, I do not think Bayshore is Fifth Avenue South. I don’t think it’s Third
Street. I view Bayshore as the SoHo of Naples,” she says.
Item 11a 4.A.2
Packet Pg. 93 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
11/11
Investment by Maddox and others in the area is evidence of the broader success the CRA has
helped nurture through the years, Donna Fiala said. The agency helped coordinate planning
efforts that led to the investments and helped eliminate blighted properties. “The CRA had
plenty to do with that success,” she says.
Gutierrez agrees, adding that the CRA gave residents a voice to correct county mistakes in
poor zoning made over
the decades that allowed blighted areas to fester. It also provided much-needed leverage
through land purchases to guide development.
He and other residents have seen their home values appreciate, thanks to decades of hard
work by residents, business owners and the CRA, he said. “We’re not trying to be Fifth
Avenue, but trying to be something else,” Gutierrez says. “I wouldn’t live in any other place
than Bayshore.”
Photo Credit: Courtesy Summit Management Group; Courtesy Collier County Florida Goverment,
Bayshore CRA Board; Courtesy CYK Law Firm; Brian Tietz, Courtesy Exit One Solution
Item 11a 4.A.2
Packet Pg. 94 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
Naples Daily News - 04/26/2021
April 29, 2021 11:28 am (GMT -4:00) Powered by TECNAVIA
+N APLESNEWS.COM |MONDAY, APRIL 26, 2021 |3ASWFLATODAYCollier County invested $10.5 millionin a new wastewater pump stationmeant to replace aging infrastructureand prepare part of the region for largestorm events that may knock out power.Tucked at the dead end of ThomassonLane just northwest of Lely, the two-sto-ry building houses three large pumps ca-pable of pushing 15 million gallons ofwastewater through the county’s system every day.Wastewater coming through the sta-tion stays within the pipes getting rid ofthe need for a wet well, which will helpkeep odors and spills at bay.The 6,000-square-foot building con-tains a backup diesel generator to keepthe pumps running during a power fail-ure. Workers can access the station re-motely, monitoring flow levels and ad-dressing issues if they arise.The concept for Master Pump Station306 started in 2014. Design took twoyears and construction took another twoyears, according to county staff. “There are very few utilities that dothis,” Principal Project Manager Craig$10.5M wastewaterpump station addedCollier County preparesfor large storms thatcould knock out powerKarl Schneider and Brittany CarloniNaples Daily NewsUSA TODAY NETWORK – FLORIDA Three electric chopper pumps and three diesel in-line booster pumps are housedat Master Pump Station 306 in East Naples, photographed on Tuesday. CollierCounty invested $10.5 million on the new wastewater booster pump station.ALEX DRIEHAUS/NAPLES DAILY NEWSSee STATION, Page 5A
No question arts and culture contribute to the quality of life in
a community.h But they can also mean big bucks in the
world of growth and development.h The arts and cultural
sector contributed $919.7 billion or 4.3% to the nation’s
gross domestic product (GDP) in 2019, according to a study last month
by the Bureau of Economic Analysis and the Office of Research & Analy-
sis at the National Endowment for the Arts. It was $38.3 billion in Flori-
da.h On top of the billions in terms of economic growth every year, a
UNESCO report found that cultural and creative industries create
29.5 million jobs globally.
So, it’s an understatement to say
there’s plenty of Southwest Florida en-
thusiasm about the September start of
construction for the Gulfshore Play-
house Cultural Campus in downtown
Naples. With the proposed AC Marriott
just about next door at high-profile Goo-
dlette-Frank Road and U.S. 41, both
should be ready by 2023.
“We know this project will create
transformational change in downtown
Naples and enhance the vibrant rede-
velopment occurring in the downtown
area,” said donor Jay Baker, co-founder
of national retail chain, Kohl’s, and full-
time local resident since 2000. “It’s time
to see this project come to life.”
My super smart sis in journalism,
Harriet Howard Heithaus, tells me this
will supplement what’s already been
helping draw folks to that region since
the 1990s: The Naples Players at Sugden
Community Theatre and Naples Art,
with their live theater, children and
adult classes and artist fairs.
Baker and wife, Patty, are long-time
contributors who kicked off the Next
Stage Capital Campaign for the play-
house with the first match gift. And
they’re not slowing down one bit, based
on their latest move this past week.
They’re committing to match all gifts
made by July 4, up to $10 million. So far,
the Bakers have pledged up to $20 mil-
lion.
“Jay and I have always believed in lay-
ing eggs where we nest, and we nest in
Naples,” said playhouse board member
Patty Baker, a Tony Award-winning pro-
ducer.
I guess those are golden eggs, and
those eggs are everywhere. Baker Park.
Baker Museum. Downtown Baker Hos-
pital.
And that’s around her serving on the
Cleveland Rock and Roll Hall of Fame
board and producing shows on Broad-
way and London’s West End including
The Carole King Musical and Fiddler on
the Roof, and most recently, To Kill a
Mockingbird and Diana.
Hence, the performances by Broad-
way’s John McDaniel and Jason D. Dan-
ieley at a gathering Wednesday night on
the property of the future playhouse,
marking the completion of the design
process.
Responding to the Bakers’ pledge,
Naples long-time philanthropists Patri-
cia and George Kraus stepped up as the
first match donors, dropping $1 million
into the hat for the $60 million arts com-
plex on about three acres at 1st Avenue
South and Goodlette.
The campus is expected to spur more
The latest rendering of the Gulfshore Playhouse. Construction is slated to begin in September, with targeted completion
of autumn 2023.PHOTOS PROVIDED TO IN THE KNOW
Excitement running highfor Gulfshore Playhouse
Cultural campus set to begin construction in September
In the Know
Phil Fernandez
Naples Daily News
USA TODAY NETWORK – FLORIDA
“It’s time to see this project
come to life.”
Jay Baker
Gulfshore Playhouse Cultural Campus donor
“We know this project will create transformational change in downtown Naples
and enhance the vibrant redevelopment occurring in the downtown area,” says
donor Jay Baker, co-founder of Kohl’s, of the project.
See IN THE KNOW, Page 4A
The CROWN Act bill, created to pro-
hibit discrimination against Black
men, women and children who choose
to wear their hair naturally, appears
poised to fail in the Florida Legislature
for the second year in a row.
“We are currently awaiting its first
committee hearing,” said District 45
state Rep. Kamia L. Brown, a Democrat
and the bill’s House sponsor. “Unfor-
tunately, just due to the time (left) in
session, it probably will not receive a
hearing and the bill won’t move over on
the House side. It’s unfortunate that
the House once again just does not
have an appetite to really hear the bill.”
The CROWN Act bill, or “CROWN,”
is an acronym for Creating a Respect-
ful and Open World for Natural Hair.
The CROWN Act is supported by the
CROWN Coalition, founded by Dove,
the National Urban League, Color Of
Change and Western Center on Law
and Poverty. The bill aims to eliminate
the stigma attached to natural Black
hair.
Similar bills have been enacted in
seven states: Washington, California,
Colorado, New York, New Jersey, Vir-
ginia and Maryland. Two municipal-
ities, Cincinnati and Montgomery
County, Maryland, also have passed
forms of the CROWN Act.
Should HB 179 pass, Florida’s ver-
sion of the CROWN Act would prohibit
hairstyle discrimination in housing,
employment and public education.
The bill would have taken effect July 1.
The bill can be reintroduced next ses-
sion in 2022.
Quanika Jefferson, a Daytona
Beach resident, said it’s heartbreaking
to her to learn that the CROWN Act bill
will likely fail again in Florida.
“It’s disheartening because this is
Protectionfor Blackhairstylesstalls again
CROWN Act bill would
help eliminate stigma
Erica Van Buren
Daytona Beach News-Journal
USA TODAY NETWORK
Tyesha Warren, 35, says she
embraces her natural hair. Florida’s
version of the CROWN Act would
prohibit hairstyle discrimination.
PROVIDED BY SHARON JACKSON
See HAIRSTYLES, Page 6A
Item 11b
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 95 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
Naples Daily News - 04/26/2021
April 29, 2021 11:28 am (GMT -4:00) Powered by TECNAVIA
4A |MONDAY, APRIL 26, 2021 |NAPLES DAILY NEWS +
than $20 million annually in economic
activity in Southwest Florida, accordingto studies by the playhouse, which plans
a yearly operational budget of $10 mil-
lion.And as far as jobs: The employment of
nearly 60 full timers, 10 interns/appren-
tices and more than 400 visiting artists
who it says will invest in the local econo-my during their stays.
The playhouse is also a player in
planned parking. Working with the Eastof 41 Coalition led by Sunshine Ace Hard-
ware CEO Michael Wynn,
it donated land for a
municipal garage near its
Design District locale.
The arts campus is
“perfectly positioned tocreate ripple effects that
will help broaden the
prosperity for the areaeast of 41.” said Wynn, whose grandpa is
a city founder and started historic
Wynn’s Market. “Because of Gulfshore
Playhouse, tourists will eat in our restau-
rants, stay in our hotels, shop in our
stores. This project will help businesses
compete for workers. Communities thathave a strong offering of arts and culture
have been shown to have a competitive
advantage in attracting workers.”
Here are some of the stats that stood
out to me as I researched federal data for
this column that would get the late John-
ny Carson or at least Saturday NightLive’s Dana Carvey as him exclaiming, “I
did not know that:”
h Arts and culture annually has beenadding nearly $60 billion more than con-
struction and $227 billion more than
transportation and warehousing to the
U.S. economy. Yes, more than construc-
tion.
h Not even counting the many, many
self-employed workers, arts and culturalindustries had 5.2 million employees on
payroll nationally with total compensa-
tion of $447 billion in 2019. Florida: $17.7billion.
h The average annual growth rate for
arts and culture outperforms the growth
rate of the total U.S. economy. From 2014
to 2016, the average annual growth rate
in the contribution of arts and culture
was 4.16%, nearly double the 2.22%growth rate of the total U.S. economy.
More local real estate records
New stats released Friday afternoon
by the Naples Area Board of Realtors
show yet more records in real estate.And broker analysts believe those will
continue, as the buy, buy, buy surge ex-
tends into 2021 for all of Southwest Flori-da.
March ended up as the highest per-
forming month on record over the last 13
years since NABOR began tracking key
metrics, according to the group.
Its historic activity includes 1,851
closed sales, up from 1,177 a year ago.In addition, March was the first
month in several years where there were
more reported price increases than de-
creases.
“Sellers are raising prices, and multi-
ple offers are still coming in,” said CEO
Budge Huskey of Premier Sotheby’s In-ternational Realty.
Median closed prices in March in-
creased 12.2% to $415,000 (the highestmedian price increase month/month on
record since 2008) from $370,000 in
March 2020.
The inventory’s down to 1,819 homes,
the lowest since 2014. A year ago: Whatmight sound like a crazy high 6,795
homes, but that was a strong market,
too.
Pending sales (homes under contract)
activity in March also broke records, as
seen in the 152.7% spike from a year ago
to 2,469 pending listings.Other all-time records, and check out
all the commas: $1,582,474,997 in total
sales volume and 60,147 showing ap-
pointments.
Lee County continued its remarkable
run as well.
Closed sales were up 34% comparedto the same month last year, according to
the Royal Palm Coast Realtor Associa-
tion. Prices also climbed in March, with a16.6% increase in median prices paid for
homes.
The median sale price of single-family
homes rose 24% in March to $345,000
versus $335,000 in March 2020. For con-dominiums and townhouses, median
sale price was up 10.5% for the month to
$226,500.
Meanwhile, housing inventory con-
tinues to be tight, with a nearly 80% drop
in homes for sale in March 2021 versus
the same period a year ago.A single-family home for sale in Lee
County in March was on the market just
42 days on average before an offer was
accepted.
March also was good to the Bonita
Springs-Estero Realtors group, known as
BER. Single family closed sales hopped41% from a year ago. Condominiums
were even better at 86.3%.
The single family median finished at$489,500. Condos: $297,000.
Here’s why some Realtors believe the
market will remain hot.
“Season was disrupted this year be-
cause many people elected to hold off re-
locating until they were fully vaccinat-
ed,” Huskey said. “Agents also report
that many seasonal visitors are staying
longer than in previous years, possibly
because they can afford to wait in antici-pation of more homes becoming avail-
able in the luxury market. I believe we’ll
continue to see more newcomers fromnorthern states looking for homes in the
high end in the coming months.”
Newest Waterside Shops addition
Kendra Scott fashion and jewelry
store is opening its first Southwest Flori-da venue on Friday.
Its eighth Sunshine State spot, the
nearest locations had been Sarasota,
Palm Beach County and the Brickell area
of Miami. The addition will bring the to-
tal number in the United States to about
110, according to the company.The Naples address for the cozy 1,062-
square-foot space is the Waterside
Shops, 5485 Tamiami Trail, D-5.Based at the Naples Daily News, Col-
umnist Phil Fernandez (pfernan-
dez@gannett.com) writes In the Know.
The latest rendering of the Gulfshore Playhouse is shown. Construction is slated to begin in September, with targeted completion of autumn 2023.
PROVIDED TO IN THE KNOW
In the Know
Continued from Page 3A
A rendering shows the Gulfshore Playhouse, which is expected to employ nearly 60 full timers, 10 interns/apprentices and
more than 400 visiting artists.PROVIDED TO IN THE KNOW
The campus is expected to spur more than $20 million annually in economic
activity in Southwest Florida, according to studies by the playhouse.
PROVIDED TO IN THE KNOW
Wynn
Broadway performers and St. Louis
natives John McDaniel and Jason D.
Danieley in Wednesday on the
property of the future Gulfshore
Playhouse.
PROVIDED BY ANGELA BELL
Item 11b4.A.2
Packet Pg. 96 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
In the Know: Luxury digs for cars, larger versions of Lake
Park Diner coming
Phil Fernandez, Naples Daily News Published 9:27 p.m. ET April 18, 2021
Ever-expanding downtown Naples seems to keep stretching its reach and impact beyond its historical Fifth Avenue South corridor and nearby monster
Gulf coast mansions, with developer Adam Smith's help.
Already a key player in the constantly evolving Design District to the north on the other side of U.S. 41, Smith is also working on a project about a half-
mile east past the Naples Bay Club.
That's where preliminary work has begun on Pine Street off Tamiami Trail of luxury accommodations for your car. But despite what the sign there had
been saying and what y'all had been wondering about, it won't be sharing the property with the resort for your pets that was designed and slated to go.
Smith's quietly behind the latest development of the acreage that prior to his involvement has had varied functions over the past seven decades including
an upholstery shop and what archived Collier public records termed a few years ago as an "abandoned travel trailer used as an apartment."
So, yes, sitting behind the relatively fresh Woodspring Suites Naples West and near other new construction, this spot's positioned for a big step up. And
pet lovers might have also liked the previously planned puppy palace, its VIP suites with TVs and the deluxe doggy pool that had just received
new approvals Wednesday from the county.
But the column near the end of the week, I received late word that the pooch project went poof. by the time I was wrapping up
Luxury digs for cars, larger versions of Lake Park Diner coming, new fancy condos near Fifth
4/20/2021https://www.naplesnews.com/story/news/columnists/in-the-know/2021/04/19/luxury-digs-for-cars-fancy...
And gee, I Had wanted to use this as an opportunity to drop in mention of American Humane's Society upcoming 106th annual “Be Kind to Animals
Week," known
Oh good. I got that in anyway, and it's May 2-8. But I still had to howl the words growling but rabies-vaccinated editors dread more than baths: "Hey boss,
I'm missing deadline again."
Well, that shift in plans serves as the latest example of the rapid movement of this frenzied market, with more stats and evidence to come later in this
column.
Preliminary work had begun on Pine Street off Tamiami Trail in Naples of a car condo complex, which is designed here, and an adjacent pet resort. But plans for the latter
have been scrapped. (Photo: Provided by Brian Ohlis)
Item 11c4.A.2
Packet Pg. 97 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
Item 11d
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 98 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)
4.A.2
Packet Pg. 99 Attachment: Agenda Packet Joint Meeting 5-5-2021 (2) (16013 : Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee - May 5, 2021)