Agenda 06/08/2021 Item #16A12 (Release of Code Enforcement Liens for Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Landings Property Owners Assn, Inc.)06/08/2021
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to approve the release of code enforcement liens with a value of $30,915.00 for
payment of $4,745.00 in the code enforcement actions titled Board of County Commissioners v.
Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Landings
Property Owners Assn Inc., Code Enforcement Special Magistrate Case Nos. CEEX20090003795,
CEEX20110000460, and CEEX20110009481, relating to property located at 201 Santa Clara Drive,
Collier County, Florida.
OBJECTIVE: For the Board of County Commissioners to accept an offer to release three code
enforcement liens, with an accrued value of $30,915.00, for payment of $4,745.00 in relation to Code
Enforcement Special Magistrate Case Nos. CEEX20090003795, CEEX20110009481, and
CEEX20110000460.
CONSIDERATIONS: As a result of code violations at 201 Santa Clara Drive, consisting of litter, wood,
glass, plastic, and other putrescible waste, the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate imposed three liens
on the property due to the underlying health, safety, and welfare issues.
The lien in Case No. CEEX20090003795, for putrescible waste on the ground, including used diapers and
non-containerized food, was recorded in the Official Records on April 30, 2009, at O.R. Book 4448, P age
0932. The lien amount of $5,055.00 is based on $5,000.00 imposition of fines, plus $50.00 in operational
costs, and $5 administrative fee, totaling $5,055.00.
The lien in Case No. CEEX20110009481, for putrescible waste on the ground, including but n ot limited
to: used diapers, food, cardboard, glass, plastic, soiled clothing, wood, toilets, tv’s, and other furniture
items, was recorded in the Official Records on August 19, 2011, at O.R. Book 4712, Page 399. The lien
amount of $25,055.00 was based on $25,000.00 imposition of fines, $50.00 in operational costs, and
$5.00 administrative fee.
The lien in Case No. CEEX20110000460, for putrescible waste in front of the building, causing a health,
safety, and welfare issue, was recorded in the Official Records on October 21, 2008, at O.R. Book 4402,
Page 1200. The lien amount of $805.00 is based on $750.00 imposition of fines, plus $50.00 in
operational costs, and $5.00 administrative fee, totaling $805.00.
Pursuant to Resolution No. 2012-46, a request for waiver of fines may be considered when full payment
of the full lien amount would impose a severe financial hardship on the property owner. Fines accrued by
an existing owner would be considered for a waiver as long as the existing owner has diligently pursued
abatement and compliance has been achieved. In 2012, the homeowners of Santa Barbara Garden Lakes
and Santa Barbara Landing filed legal action to gain control of both homeowners’ associations. They
were unaware of the extensive debt and liens that were incurred and ignored by the developer during the
recession. The associations have spent a significant amount of time, money, and resources to pay
outstanding bills, defend lawsuits left by the developer, avoid foreclosure, abate the violations, maintain,
repair, and oversee common areas of the property, while spending time raising funds to make deferred
property repairs. The property is being actively maintained and $4,745.00 has been paid in settlement of
fines. Granada Lakes Villas Condominium Association, Inc., and Santa Barbara Landings Property
Owners Association, Inc., are requesting a waiver of $26,170.00 in accrued fines. There are currently no
known violations.
FISCAL IMPACT: Payment of $4,745.00 in settlement of fines and costs has been made. If approved
by the Board, accrued fines in the amount of $26,170.00 would be waived.
16.A.12
Packet Pg. 661
06/08/2021
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There is no growth management impact associated with this
action.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: The County Attorney’s Office has reviewed this item and approved it
as to form and legality. Majority support is required for approval. This item conforms to the Board’s
policy contained in Resolution 2012-46. -CAK
RECOMMENDATION: To waive the fines in the amount of $26,170.00, accept payment amount of
$4,745.00, release the liens, and authorize the Chairman to sign the attached releases and satisfaction of
liens for recording in the Official Public Records.
Prepared by: Michael Ossorio, Director, Code Enforcement Division
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. Owner Letter (PDF)
2. Backup documents (PDF)
3. Lien Orders (PDF)
4. Executed releases (PDF)
16.A.12
Packet Pg. 662
06/08/2021
COLLIER COUNTY
Board of County Commissioners
Item Number: 16.A.12
Doc ID: 15777
Item Summary: Recommendation to approve the release of code enforcement liens with a value
of $30,915.00 for payment of $4,745.00 in the code enforcement actions titled Board of County
Commissioners v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC, Santa Barbara
Landings Property Owners Assn Inc., Code Enforcement Special Magistrate Case Nos.
CEEX20090003795, CEEX20110000460, and CEEX20110009481, relating to property located at 201
Santa Clara Drive, Collier County, Florida.
Meeting Date: 06/08/2021
Prepared by:
Title: – Code Enforcement
Name: Dana Rarey
05/04/2021 10:19 AM
Submitted by:
Title: Division Director - Code Enforcement – Code Enforcement
Name: Michael Ossorio
05/04/2021 10:19 AM
Approved By:
Review:
Code Enforcement Michael Ossorio Additional Reviewer Completed 05/07/2021 12:55 PM
Code Enforcement Colleen Davidson Additional Reviewer Completed 05/11/2021 12:37 PM
County Attorney's Office Colleen Kerins Level 2 Attorney Review Completed 05/11/2021 3:47 PM
Growth Management Department James C French Additional Reviewer Completed 05/11/2021 7:57 PM
County Attorney's Office Jeffrey A. Klatzkow Level 3 County Attorney's Office Review Completed 05/12/2021 9:19 AM
Office of Management and Budget Debra Windsor Level 3 OMB Gatekeeper Review Completed 05/12/2021 11:00 AM
Office of Management and Budget Laura Zautcke Additional Reviewer Completed 05/21/2021 4:05 PM
County Manager's Office Sean Callahan Level 4 County Manager Review Completed 05/28/2021 2:04 PM
Board of County Commissioners Geoffrey Willig Meeting Pending 06/08/2021 9:00 AM
16.A.12
Packet Pg. 663
GRANADA LAKES VILLAS CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, INC.
AND
SANTA BARBARA LANDINGS PROPERTY OWNERS
ASSOCIATION, INC.
January 29,2021
Iliana Burgos
Collier County Code Enforcement
And
Board of County Commissioners
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
RE: Code Enforcement Citations & Liens: PU4438, 4435,3834, 3838, 4730 for Trash Issues
Santa Barbara Garden Villas, LLC
Santa Barbara Landings Property Owners Association, Inc.
Dcar Ms. Burgos and Commissioners:
During this past year we were made aware of several outstanding Collier County Code
Enforcement Liens against Santa Barbara Landings and subsequently Granada Lakes Villas
Condominium during the sale and title search process of several condominium units at Granada
Lakes Villas. Granada Lakes Villas is located at the SE corner of Radio Road and Santa Barbara
Blvd and is comprised of 248 condominium units in l6 buildings. The community provides work
force housing for its owners or tenants in one or two bedroom condominium uniti.
The property was originally developed as Santa Barbara Landings Apartments in 1987 and in
2005 it was sold to a Developer from Miami, who subsequently converted the apartments to
condominiums in 2006. Santa Barbara Garden Villas became the Developer of record and
fot:med Granada Lakes Villas Condominiums to own the actual condominium units and Santa
Barbara Landings Property Owners Association to act as the Homeowner Association and
oversee the common elements - clubhouse, pools, trash, landscaping, etc. During the ensuing
recession, the unit sales collapsed and the Developer failed to accept responsibitity for the
financial affairs of the Associations, while maintaining control over the Associations. Eventually
by 2012 the Homeowners were able to force the Developer to turnover control of the property tt
the them, which gave them control of both Associations. At the same time the Developeris Bank
was foreclosing on their remaining units. During this period prior to the 2Ol2 turnover, bills
were not paid, the grass was not cut and the pools were closed. The homeowners at Granada
Lakes and Santa Barbara Landings spent the next 4 years under the financial burdens of paying
outstanding bills and defending a lawsuit against the Developer. while at the same time raising
funds to make the deferred repairs to the property.
145 SANTA CLARA DR NAPLES, FL 34104
HeatherK@cam brid geswf l.com
(239) 206-2678
16.A.12.a
Packet Pg. 664 Attachment: Owner Letter (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
Four of the five above outstanding code enforcement liens occurred during 200g and 2009 and
were filed directly against the development entity, santa Barbara Garden Villas, LLC, located in
coral Gables (Miami), FL. I cannot even tell you if Granada Lakes villas or santa Barbara
Landing were aware of the legal action of the liens. obviously, the actual trash issues were
rectified. The fifth lien was filed in 201I against Santa Barbara Landings, but again this was
while the Developer still maintained control over the Association. Further, the actual trash issue
was again ultimately resolved. Both Granada and Santa Barbara today remain controlled by the
homeowners who are very diligent about resolving any issues within the community and
continue to make improvements as needed.
We request Collier County to consider accepting a settlement and satisfaction ofthe outstanding
Code Enforcement Liens in consideration of$5,000 in total for all operational and administrative
costs incurred and reduced fine amounts. This is just another left over liability from the
Developer and it truly shouldn't be charged to the homeowners at Granada Lakes villas. They
have already paid enough to repair the damages done by the Developer and should not be
penalized further.
Thank you for your consideration and we look forward to your response and will be available to
answer your questions or comments.
Sincerely,
Frank W. Cooper, President
Granada Lakes Villas Condominium Association Inc.
Santa Barbara Landings Property Owners Association, Inc.
16.A.12.a
Packet Pg. 665 Attachment: Owner Letter (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
a^
Santa Barbara Villas LLC. Santa Barbara Garden Vil las LLC.
Senfa Rqrh araLendinoq (-)rrrncrq A ccn Inr.
201 Santa Clara Drive, Naples FL
Folio # 00400200002
Litter Citations
CE8X20090003795 - PU3834 BCC vs. Santa Barbara Granada Villas, LLC
Waste on ground
Order Items: $5,000.00 fine, plus $50 operational costs, plus administrative fee of $5.00
Total Fines: $5,055.00
FOF Order OR 4448/PG 0932 recorded on 4/30/09
Total Fines Owed: $5.055.00
CEEX20f 10000460 - PU4438 BCC vs. Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC
Waste in front of building
Order ltems: $750.00 fine, plus $50.00 operational costs, plus administrative fee of $5.00
Total Fines: $805.00
FOF Order OR 4402lPG 1200 recorded on I 0121108
Total Fines Owed: $805.00
CEEX20f 10009481 - PU4730 BCC vs. Santa Barbara Landings Property Owners Assn Inc
Waste on ground
Order ltems: $25,000.00 fine, plus operational costs of $50.00, plus administrative fee of $5.00
Total Fines: $25,055.00
FOF Order OR 47l2lPG 399 recorded on 8/19/ll
Total Fines Owed: 525.055.00
Deed recorded on I 1l0ll05
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 666 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
Fines for owner: $30.915.00 [$30.750 fine + 165 costs)
Offer of settlement: $4,745.00 ($4,580 + $165 operational costs)
OWNER with Hardship
ACCRUED VALUE:
PAYMENT OF:
TOTAL FINES TO BE WAIVED:
$0,9rs.00
$4.745.00
$26.170.00
AIso paid ($255), for a total of$5,000.00 (no Iien/order):
CE8X20090015361 - PU4435 issued 9/2/08 to Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC
Waste on ground
Citation amount: $255.00 (No lien)
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 667 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
Collier County
Growth Management Division
2800 Horseshoe Drive N.
Naples, FL 34104
239-2s2-2400
RECEIPT OF PAYMENT
Receipt Number:
Transaction Number:
Date Paidr
Amount Due:
Payment Details:
Amount Paid:
Change / Overage:
Contact:
FEE DETAILS:
Fee Description
PU Citation Fee
Administrative Fee (5)
Operational Costs (SM)
Citation Fee
Administrative Fee (5)
Administrative Fee (5)
Operational Costs (SM)
Administrative Fee (5)
Operational Costs (SM)
2027434002
2021-031935
04/75/2O2t
$s,420.00
Pavment Method
check
Reference Number
AlinaHarris
9982
jenniferwaldron
Amount Paid
$s,000.00
check Number
ool773
$s,000.00
$0.00
SANTA BARBARA LANDINGS PROPERTY OWNER'S ASSN INC
145 SANTA CLARA DR
NAPLES , FL 34104
cEEX20090003795
cEEX20090003795
cEEX20090003795
cEEX20090015361
cEEX20090015361
cEEX20110009481
cE8X20110009481
cEEX20110000460
cEEX20110000460
473-7734L6-35r473
111-138911-354207
111-138911-343922
111- 138911-354201
111- 138911-354207
111- 138911-354207
111- 138911-343922
111- 138911-354207
111- 138911-343922
Orioinal
Fee
$ 5,000.0 0
$s.00
$ s0.0 0
$2s0.00
$s.00
$s.00
$ s0.00
$s.00
$ s0.00
Amount
Paid
$4,580.00
$ s.00
$ s0.00
$250.00
$s.00
$s.00
$ s0.00
$s.00
$ s0.00
GL Account
Cashier Name:
Batch Number:
Entered By:
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 668 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
GRANADA LAKES VILLAS CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, INC.
AND
SANTA BARBARA LANDINGS PROPERTY OWNERS
ASSOCIATION, INC.
January 29,2021
Iliana Burgos
Collier County Code Enforcement
And
Board of County Commissioners
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
RE: Code Enforcement Citations & Liens: PU4438, 4435,3834, 3838, 4730 for Trash Issues
Santa Barbara Garden Villas, LLC
Santa Barbara Landings Property Owners Association, Inc.
Dcar Ms. Burgos and Commissioners:
During this past year we were made aware of several outstanding Collier County Code
Enforcement Liens against Santa Barbara Landings and subsequently Granada Lakes Villas
Condominium during the sale and title search process of several condominium units at Granada
Lakes Villas. Granada Lakes Villas is located at the SE corner of Radio Road and Santa Barbara
Blvd and is comprised of 248 condominium units in l6 buildings. The community provides work
force housing for its owners or tenants in one or two bedroom condominium uniti.
The property was originally developed as Santa Barbara Landings Apartments in 1987 and in
2005 it was sold to a Developer from Miami, who subsequently convefted the apartments to
condominiums in 2006. Santa Barbara Garden Villas became the Developer of record and
formed Granada Lakes Villas Condominiums to own the actual condominium units and Santa
Barbara Landings Property Owners Association to act as the Homeowner Association and
oversee the common elements - clubhouse, pools, trash, landscaping, etc. During the ensuing
recession, the unit sales collapsed and the Developer failed to accept responsibility for thi
financial affairs of the Associations, while maintaining control over the Associations. Eventually
by 2012 the Homeowners were able to force the Developer to turnover control of the property to
the them, which gave them control of both Associations. At the same time the Developer;s Bank
was foreclosing on their remaining units. During this period prior to the 2012 turnover, bills
were not paid, the grass was not cut and the pools were closed. The homeowners at Granada
Lakes and Santa Barbara Landings spent the next 4 years under the financial burdens ofpaying
outstanding bills and defending a lawsuit against the Developer, while at the same time raising
funds to make the deferred repairs to the property.
145 SANTA CLARA DR NAPLES, FL34104 (2391206-2678
HeatherK@cambrid geswfl.com
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 669 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
Four of the five above outstanding code enforcement liens occurred during 200g and 2009 and
were filed directly against the development entity, santa Barbara Garden villas, LLC, located in
coral Gables (Miami), FL. I cannot even tell you ifl Granada Lakes villas or Santa Barbara
Landing were aware of the legal action of the liens. obviously, the actual trash issues were
rectified. The fifth lien was filed in 20ll against Santa Barbara Landings, but again this was
while the Developer still maintained control over the Association. Further, the actuil trash issue
was again ultimately resolved. Both Granada and Santa Barbara today remain controlled by the
homeowners who are very diligent about resolving any issues within the community and
continue to make improvements as needed.
Thank you for your consideration and we look forward to your response and will be available to
answer your questions or comments.
Sincerely,
Frank W. Cooper, President
Granada Lakes Villas Condominium Association Inc.
Santa Barbara Landings Property Owners Association, Inc
We request Collier County to consider accepting a settlement and satisfaction ofthe outstanding
Code Enforcement Liens in consideration of$5,000 in total for all operational and administrative
costs incurred and reduced fine amounts. This is just another left over liability from the
Developer and it truly shouldn't be charged to the homeowners at Granada Lakes villas. They
have already paid enough to repair the damages done by the Developer and should not be
penalized further.
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 670 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
Burgoslliana
Sent:
To:
Cc:
From:Burgoslliana
Wednesday, April7,2021 9:22 AM
'fcproperties@comcast.net'
DavidsonColleen; KeeganThomas; SanchezAlberto; 'HeatherK@cambridgeswfl.com'
RE: Santa Barbara Landings - Granada Lakes Villas - Trash Liens - Update
Good morning Mr. Cooper,
The offer of settlement in the amount of 55,000.00 had been accepted as the recommendation for BCC approval
($4,745.00 to release the liens for citations PU 3834, PU 4438, & PU 4730, + 5255 for unpaid PU 4435).
Once the payment is received, we will continue to move forward with seeking BCC approval to reduce the fines and
release the liens. ltems that are added to the Board of County Commissioners' meetings are reviewed by 5 levels
including the County Attorney's Office and the County Manager's Office. Any item can be pulled from an agenda at any
time.
Please forward the payment at your earliest convenience.
Checks are made payable to Collier County Board of County Commissioners {CCBCC) and sent to address below.
Please contact me if you have any questions.
Respectfully,
lliana Burgos
Operations Supervisor
s&"m
Collier County Code Enforcement Division
Growth Management Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
239-252-6865
I liana. Burgos@colliercou ntvfl.eov
NOTE: Email Addrers Hos Chonged
'HOW ARE WE DOING?" Pleose CLICK-AERE to fill out a CUSTOMER SURVEY,
we appreoiate gour feedback!
Code Inforcenrent Mlssion Statenrent: "Ta pratect thr: heulth, safvty, and wtlfarc of Collier Counly residents ond vlsifors thraugh
educatictn, caoperatian, ond complionce"
Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public recoriis. lf you do not want your e-rnarl adclress rtleetsed in response tr: a pul:lic
records reque$t, do not serrd electronic rnail to this entity. lnstead. contact this ollice *y tel*phone or irr writittg.
From: Burgoslliana
Sent: Thursday, March 25,2O2'J' t2:27 PM
Subject:
1
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 671 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
Burgoslliana
From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Attachments:
Burgoslliana
Tuesday, April 6, 2021 2:43 PM
OssorioMichael
DavidsonColleen
FW: Santa Barbara Landings Settlement offer
Code Enforcement Letter 1 -29-21.pdt
Good afternoon Mike,
PU agrees with the settlement.
Thanks
Respectfully,
lliana Burgos
Operations Supervisor
Sxffit"gyry
Collier County Code Enforcement Division
Growth Management Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
239-2s2-5865
"HOW AnE WE DOTNG?" Please CLICK HERE to fill out a CUSTOMER SURVEY. We oppreciate your feedback!
ccfi p?rd tiln, a nd c* ri ys i ia n *:* "
Under Fiorida Law, *-maii addresses are public rscoru$ l{ you do not want yoirr e+narl addre ss rele*sed in response to * priblic r€conis request do nat
send eieclronic maii to thi$ enlily. lnstead. cintact tilis oftJce by lelephotte or in writing.
From: SanchezAlberto <Alberto,Sanchez@colliercountyfl.gov>
Sent: Tuesday, April 6,202t 1:57 PM
To: Bu rgosl I ia na < I I ia na. Bu rgos@ col I ie rcou ntyfl.gov>
Cc: KeeganThomas <Thomas. Keega n @col liercountyfl.gov>
Subject: RE: Santa Barbara Landings Settlement offer
Hello,
Please below,
Hello Al,
1
W
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 672 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
I have no concerns with Mr. Ossorio accepting. I have also discussed with PUD Financial Support Director, who concurs
with the acceptance by the Code Director.
Res.pectfully,
KARI
Kari Ann Hodgson, P.E.
Division Director
Respectfully,
jW/o,rr,, &YD Q/,*,, r/u,
Face Certified Level 1,2,3 and 4, B. S., S.C'
Solid & Hazardous Waste Management Division
Collection Manager
C,,ov*tty
Public Utilities Department
Solid & Hazardous Waste Management Division
Mission Stotement: "To protect the heolth, safety, and welfare of Collier County residents ond visitors through education,
coope ration, ond comPl io nce."
3339 TamiamiTrail E, Suite 302
239-252-5539
Alberto.sanchez@colliercountvfl.sov
w@m
From : Burgosl I ia na <l I ia n.a. Burgos @col I ielcou ntyf l. gov>
Sent: Monday, April 5,202111:38 AM
To: Sa nchezAl berto <Al bg_fto. Sa nchez @ co I I ie rco u ntvf l.eov>
Subject: Santa Barbara Landings Settlement offer
Good morning Al,
As per Resolution 2012-46, which allows the Code Enforcement Director to recommend settlement of code enforcement
liens, for Board of County Commissioners approval, Mike Ossorio has reviewed and agreed to move forward with the
settlement as offered by Mr. Cooper in the attached letter. Our director is requesting to have your director review as
well, and approve before we continue the process.
Please contact me if you have any questions
2
Respectfully,
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 673 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
lliana Burgos
Operations Supervisor
*&.*xr
Collier County Code Enforcement Division
Growth Management Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
239-2s2-686s
l liana. Bursos@colliercou ntvf l.gov
NOIE: Emqil Address Hos Chonged
'HOW ARE WE DOING?" Pleose CL!9-K.I!FS-E to fill out o CUSTOMER SURVEY.
we appreciate gour feedbackt
Code Enforcement Mission Statement: "Ta protect the health, sofety, *nd welfare of Callier County residents and visitors through
education, cooperatictn, and campliance"
Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. lf you do nol warrt your e-mail address released in response to a public
records request. do not send electronic mail to this enttty. lnstead, contact this office hy teiephorre crr rn writing.
3
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 674 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
letn:
u?t0-0t t tnil c0
It0l ?oict Dt Ltfl ILYD
eoru qtilt tt 3il3t
3724tlg 0R: 3920 pG: l{D
..ffenlcororo la the oltlcru n!cotr,8 of c0r[Itt coux?t, tr,l0t ll/0t/2005 ar tt:3eu orrem i, BiociIiid-'
uc nt 69.50
3598744 0R: 3777 PG: 3934
RtcoRDtD ir onIcIAt RXcotI}s of c(IllIBt couxil, p[
0Ul9/2005 at ll:28ilt DIIcffi E. BR0Ctr, CIXRI
c0[$ 25750000. 00
Rtc tBt 69,50
Doc- . ?0 t802t0.00coll[s 16,00
Re,o: lllsc 3'oo
t{lllo DDt IIlI,t CoilPtm
l{01 Poic! Dt LtoI EtvD l{01
comt $ttt$ !t 331il
April, 2005, by Btue Bett-
address is I156 Dimock Lane,
1.3
IJ
'<o
fr)
Fl
H
Fi
zo
&o&#
E]
v)
g,rl2
f!:
H&Ua
d
E<U
E]&&oU
o
tJ
o
!5xc)Dor){tE{a&yEl
A9()ZN-rA
4DrlE
nEa{
f&aO
a2to
)H
JE<)Al)Hil
OU1A
: frlr4J
Prepared by and return to:
Matthew J. Swett, Esquire
Pepper Hamilton LLP
3000 Two Logan Square
Eighteenth and Arch Streets
Philadelphi4 P A 19103 -2799
Grantee EIN No:
THIS WARRANTY
Meridlan Partners, Ltd., a
I
I Property Appraiser's Parcel ID #:0400200002
(part o0
Naples, Florida 33 I l0 a limited liability company,whose post office address is 401, Coral Gables, Florida
33 134("Grantee"). (Where shall be construed as singular orplural as the context requires.)
TYITITESSETE that the of the sum of TEN AND 00/100DOLLARS ($10.00) and other good and to Grantor in hand paid by Grantee, thercceipt whereof is hereby aoknowledged, has granted,bargained and sold to the said Grantee andGrantee's heirs and assigns forever, the following described land, situate, lying and being in the Countyof Collier, State of Florida, to wit:
SEE E)fiIBIT (A'AT"TACITED IIERETO AND MADE A PART
HEREOF (the sProperry,).
Property Appraiser's Parcel ID #:0400200002
Subject to: (a) ad valorem real properly taxes for the year 2005 and subsequent years; and
(b) those matters set forth on Exhibit *B'attached hereto and made a part hereof.
TOGETI{ER with all t}e tenements, hereditaments and appurtenances thereto belonging or inanywise appertaining.
TO HAVE AND TO HOLD, the same in fee simple forever.
AND this conveyance is,further subject to those certain easements, covenants, restrictions,
roseryations, and conditions as set forth on Exhibit "C" attached hereto and made a part hereof.
AND the Grantor hereby covenants with the Grantee that the Grantor is lawfully seized of saidIand in fee simple; that the Grantor has good right and lawful authority to sell and conlrey this lanJ; that
Y FORM-
Ponce de Leon
the terms
PHLEGAIT #17t6276 v2 (l0s@cO2!.DOCl 129623-2 I
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 675 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
0R: 3777 PG: 3935
the Grantor hereby fully warrants the title to the land and will defend the same against the lawful claimsof all persons whomsoever.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Grantor has hereunto set his or her hands and seal the day andyear first above written.
Signed, sealed and delivered
in the presence of:
STATE OF FLORIDA
COI.INTY OF COLLIER
The
by
limited liability
partnership, who
evidence of identifi cation.
(SEAL)
My Commission Expires:
GRANTOR:
BLUE BELL-MERIDIAN PARTNERS, LTD.,
a Florida limited partnership , General partner
By: BBMP, LLC, a Florida limited liability
company
f, I 2005,
FloridaLLC, A
IJ.ID., a Florida limited
o
=
rrOt7
(^,
r.C,lvo
f€6)
nr.q 4 lJ
(Type or Print)
as
..,:'"'k
r l.::,:
l"*r$lj
Aflnette N. Brennan
Commission #DDl9l986
Expircs: Apr 25,2007
Bonded Thru
Atlantic Bonding Co., lnc.
2
meor( )has
of
PHLEGAT: f 1716276 v2 (lG@c02!.DOC) I 2!]623-2
/
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 676 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
t*t gp. 3777 PG: 3941 ii*
STATE OF FLORJDA
coLNrY op*{}{kP"a"
)
)
)
ss,
Garden a
(sEAL)
My Commission Expires:
NOTARY
Prin0
t
of,
;\CDt\,e>.€
9.)
rFo7
E
MY coMlflSsoN
8drd.d Pllh
PHLEGAL: #l?16276 v2 (lOs@O2t.DOCl t2g6l3-2
SOCORRO
) has
1 3th of April
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 677 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
0R: 3920 PG: 1{06
EXHIBIT ''A',
gffifftr':fffi,l*mrr*u.ffi '
)
3H$+ESLPrrirrr-[ri3{_liT^lxrT.ar^#?ficR€ss EASEMENT Lyn{c 12 FEEr EAc$ spE or nE
tegal Description
curvc.concove Northeost,from;thence run North
West holf of
to o poht on o cbcrfor
dhtancc of ,3.t0 f..t
through
55'11',og"
o centrcl ongle of o rodlur of 7J.16
of North
run tlatr 00!O'00Tast
ot ?257 fcct to o
o
thoncc run
thcrc
foct
poht on
65.22
West,for o distoncefor g distonce of 125.77
run
o circulor curve, concoveleet there from; thence r o dbtoncc of
horhg o rodur of
fcct ot o boctrg oft{*th 6937t7F
of 104.54 frct to o
dlrtoncotoo rodius
ol 6t.73 fcct ot o bcorhgcrr$ lhcrcc run l{orthlfrrt hr o datoncc of llJ.0S,t thsrcc run South 01!2'59'o drltsrc! of {ir9.3a f.Gt to
56rfi)'{2' llcrt. o
tttc rlght, hovlng
n+-rygltl 88'+9't4' Eosr. otongof 65&08 fcct to thc poht of
chord
NorthtrGst
(or o dlstoncc of
North 5'4{34'
thc
47.81
4, Tomdrb 50 South,
of Scctbn ,t
lxc.t , dong thc
drtcrcc ofll.toro
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 678 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
0R: 3777 PG: 393?
E)CIIBIT'B'
PER]VIITTED EXCEPTIONS
l. Right-of-Way Easement in favor of Collier County, a political subdivision of the State of Florida,
as set forth in instrument recorded in Official Records Book I 136, Page 2334.
2. Easement(s) in favor of Collier County, a political subdivision of the State of Florid4 as set forth
in instrument(s) recorded in Official Records Book I 153, Page 1378.
3. Restrictions, covenants, easements and conditions contained in Riglrt-of-Way Map, recorded in
Official Records Book 12 I 4, Page I 533 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida.
4. Easement(s) in favor of Florida Power & Light Company as set forth in instrument(s) recorded in
Official Records Book 1229, Page 1786.
5. Easement(s) in favor of Board of Collier County, Florida Ex-Officio
the Governing Board of County County, Florida and Collier County,
Florida a political suMivision
Records Book 1264, Page 1642.
instrumen(s) recorded in Official
6. Easement(s) in favor County, Florida Ex-Offrcio
of , Florida and Collier County,
recorded in Offrcial
Records Book 1264, Page I
7. Easement(s) in favor
Official Records Book 1293,
in instrument(s) recorded in
8. Tcrms, conditions and and Reciprocal Easement and
Maintenance Agreement by and between Partnership and Wildwood Estates Joint
Venture and Eastridge Partners, LTD., recorded Records Book 1436, Page 14, as affected by
that certain Partial Cancellation of Mutual and Reciprocal Easement and Maintenance Agreement
recorded in Official Records Book 1845, Page 1237.
9. Terms, conditions and provisions of that certain Utility Facilities Warranty Deed by and between
Santa Barbara Landings Partnership, a Florida general partrership and the Board of County
Commissioners of Collier County, Florida" as the Governing Body of Collier County and Ex-OfIicio the
Governing Board of County Water-Sewer District, recorded in Official Records Book 1794, Page 1010,
together with Bill of Sale recorded in Official Records Book I 794, Page l 007.
NOTE: AII of the recording information contained herein refers to the Public Records of Collier County,
Florida, unless otherwise indicated, and does not intend to reimpose same.
/
oF
;(t,N'e
;E
9-:
rFo€
/
4
of Florida
Power & Light
PHLEGAL: 11716276 vZ (l0s@c02l.DOC) 129621-2
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 679 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
0R: 3777 PG: 3938
EXHIBTT 6C'
EASEMENTS, COVENAiITS, RESTRICTIONS, RESERVATIONS, AllD CONDITIONS
Grantor hereby declares and Grantee agrees for itself, its successors and assigns, that title to the
Property is subject to the following easements, covenants, restrictions, reservations, and conditions
subsequent which shall run with the Property and shall be binding upon all parties having any right, title
or interest in and to the ProperQr, or any portion thereof, their successors and assiglts and shall inure to the
benefit of Grantor, its successors and assigns, The title to the Property conveyed under this deed is
conveyed subject to, and shall be held, sold and subsequently conveyed subject to, the following
casements, covenants, restrictions, reservations, and conditions subsequent.
l. Expression of Intent. Following the conveyance by Grantor to Grantee, Grantee will retain
ownership ofan approximately 7.0 acre parcel ofreal property located adjacent to and to the south ofthe
Property. The real property retained by Grantor is legally described as follows:
That portion of the West half of the West half of the Northwest quarter of Section 4,
Township 50 South, Range 26 East,Florida being more particularly described as
follows: Beginning at the of the West half of the Northwest
quarter of Section 4,County, Florida; thence run
North 0l'00'26" West,
quarter ofsaid Section ,
West half of the Northwest
South 76"l3'5l" West for a
distance of 82.23 feet
North 5o44'34" East,
whose radius point bears
Northwesteily along the arc
of a curve to the right,angle of38"0E'34",
subtended by a chord
feet to the end ofsaid
thence run south 35o3
West, for a distance of 48.70
a distance of 125.77 feet;
on a circular curve,
concave Northwest a distance of 65.22 feet
there from; thence run to the right, having a radius of
65.22 feet through a a chord of 54.63 feet at a bearing
of South 85o37'14 West, for end of said curve; thence run North
run Westerly, along the arc of said56'29'42" West, a distance of 52
curve to the right, having a radius of 52.77 feet, through a central angle of I 0 I o32' I 8", subtended
by a chord of 8l .75 feet at a bearing of South 84"16'27" West, for a distance of 93.5 I feet to the
end of said curve; tlence run North 48"37'36" West for a distance of 88.05 feet thence run South
8857'22" West for a distance of I 13.05 feet to a point on the West line of the Northwest Quarter
of said Section 4; thence run South 01"02'39" East, along the West line of the Northwest quarter
of said Section 4, for a distance of 439.34 feet to the Southwest corner of the Northwest quarter of
said Section 4; thence run North 8Eo49'14" East, along the South line of the Northwest quarter of
said Section 4, for a distance of 658.08 feet to the point of beginning; containing6.T4 acres, more
or less (the "Retained Property").
The easements, covenants, restrictions, reservations, and conditions set forth herein are intendgd to
preserve legal and practical access to the Retained Property and to also allow for utility connections
necessary to serve future development of the property. Grantor intends for future development of the
Retained Property, which future development would utilize all easements referenced herein.
2. Access Easement. Grantor hereby reserves for the benefit of the Retained Property a
perpetual, appurtenant, non-exclusive access easement for vehicular and pedes&ian ingress and egress to,
from, and between the Retained Property and the public rights-of-way of Santa Barbara Boulevard and
/
o
=(^t10N'e
?ct
9.)
.fo*/
5
,724E0.
line of the
for a distance
point bears
along the arc
54",
PIil.EGN-: tl? 16276 v2 (t0s@o02!.DOC\ 129623.2
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 680 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
0R: 3777 PG: 3939
Radio Road on, over, upon and across any and all driveways, access ways, entrances, exits and curb cuts,
together with all sidewalks and walkways which may, from time to time, be located on the Property to be
used in common witl Grantee, its successors and assigrs (the "Access Easement"). Further, Grantor
nos€ryes the righg at its sole cost and exponse, to connect, tie and/orjoin in to any driveways, access
ways, sidewalks and wallsrays existing on the Property to provide the vehicular and pedestrian access
contemplated herein. Grantee shall grant and convey to Grantor, upon the request of Grantor, any
temporary construction easements reasonably necessary to complete the forgoing connections. Grantor,
as well as Grantor's employees, tenants, invitees, licensees, agents, and/or successors in title shall have
the right to cause pedestrians and motorized and non-motorized vehicles to use the Access Easement.
Grantee, its successors, assigns and successors in title, agre€ not to build, conshuct or place, nor permit
others to buil{ constuct or place, any buildings or other structur€s or improvements in such a manner that
the same may interfert with the exercise by Grantor of the rights resenired hereunder.
3. Relocation of Driveways. Subsequent to the recording of this Deed, Grantee shall not
hereinafter relocate, remove, obstruct, close or modi! the location of any driveways, access ways,
entrances, exits and curb cuts now or hereinafter existing or serving the Property without the prior written
consent of Grantee, which consent may be withheld in the sole and exclusive discretion of Grantee.
4. Utility Easement.the benefit of the Retained Property a
perpetual, appurtenant,
easements (both public and
including, without limitation,
shall have the right, at its sole
television. Further, Grantee
in to or expand any utility lines
now or hereinafter located on convey to Grantor, upon the
request of Grantor, any to complete the forgoing
connections or expansions.in title, agree not to build,
consbuct or place, nor permit or other structures or
improvements in such a by Grantor of the rights
reserved hereunder including the
5. Maintenance.to maintain any and all utility and
access improvements installed on tlre shall have the sole responsibility to
through all utility lines and utility
' on the Property for all utilities
constnrcted on the Property; provided that
utility improvements installed or made by
maintain any and all access and utility
Grantor shall have the responsibility r
/
o
=(-,
\C)T\,e
FrctI
rfe\o
/
to maintain any access or
Grantor on the Property to connecf join or tie in to the Grantor's improvements and which improvements
solely beneFrt the Retained Property.
If Grantee fails to perform in a timely manner the maintenance obligation imposed by this
Agreemertt Crantor shall be entitted to noti! Grantee in writing speci$ing the deficiency and the action
required in order to eliminate the deficiency. Except in the event of an emergency as hereafter provided,
Grantee shall have a period of twenty (20) days after receipt of said writtcn notice in whioh to conect the
alleged deficiency, or such longer period of time, not exceeding sixty (60) days, as may reasonably be
necessaty ifthe deficiency is not reasonably suscepfible to cur€ within said twenty (20) day period and
provided that Grantee commences corrective action within ten (10) days after receipt of said written
notice from Grantor and thereafter diligently pursues corrective action to completion in a diligent and
continuous manner. If Grantee fails to commence and diligently pursue and complete the required
corrective action as hereinabove set fortfu then Grantor shall have, and Grantee hercby grants and
conveys, in addition to all other availablc rights and rcmedies, the right and authority and easement for
such purposes on the part of Grantor and Crantor's employees, aontractors and subcontractors to enter
upon the Property (if necessary) in order to perform appropriate corrective action to eliminate the
deficiencies specified in the written notice from Grantor. The costs incurred by Grantor shall be due and
6
now and in
electricity,
of utility
the sole
the same may
PHLEGAL: #l 7 16276 v2 ( I0s@c{2l.DOC) 129621-2
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 681 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
' 0R: 3TT7 pG: 3940
payable by Grantee'
Y:ltll-t*d-ingrhe foregoing in the event of ary oncrgcocy affecting the any;'.::Tfi*11?" I[:lr:l': on ttre-rropertv"'ilt a;;iffiff ud* ;; *;il,a;sewices,o."*;.,"r;i'i.ll"Iff*lilJ'#f,*Iffi il:H:rffiabate such damage ot iolury
"t to "'oiarr "i#;*r, interference; provlled tiar (i) Gr,rtor shatt anemptto give Grantee such otioinotl"t * " p,"",""ule under trre circuisail (which notice may bc orar);fii$']fit##|;: m xi;x';i*": #"'**,,*,, ;;;;;;;-to p,revcnt such damage or
"r",,J.*rffi ;ffiJi:,ffi i,:tffi,mcontained in this Exhibit 'c- orttrls Sffio-ir"o. Granree,s rcocprancc ofrhb wananty tlcd shall beconclusive evidence of said.agrccmeni'u"ii"-i" t p"ni*. c*rt* .iE r,r"r"s sroqsors or assigns shart*::r1" right to enforce tJ**i"-"-t",;;;", nsrictions rcscrwriom, rnd conditions comained
not be
assigrs,
E.
of competent
provisions, all of which shall
in wholc or in part by any court
6e validity of the remaining
v , LLC;comPany
If invalid
SIGNEDSEALEDAND
IN THE PRESENCE OF:
/
r+
'C'Co
=(4,\oF\.,o
t
5.)
.f
o
'C'C7
PHLEOA!; I t ?t6276 v2 (!o.@2|.DOC ) t296:.l,A
7
holding shall in
conscnt of Granbr, its successorc and/or
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 682 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
a
(ULl,lE&..iUlNlY-PU&etrfjtr!!11ff $
c$&Hgai PU ':i
'l 'l
Ita s.d*drrrr{ {€Sk rd#{ r$tt }&}lr b* rryi$*i* N r lq4r.s rtf
'i!*tDrrffir{S s{r*rd} *s ffir*rd k rt$firry? !*x* ldtx
,}
I ji,..- &t ttr xil fort' dI .-.. qx ot l,..hr I Hi Er r-,*itrara
ttx rary( {rl3&r el&{ l0 !h|l ulte*$ qa rJr clrdc *d* d D* o{A*rrryil ir*l lf tll:q#rtrd*A a.r&tr l,* E *rBd l$*rlil
r. j iburfAtm r .'i'r'ir I t--:-'':-:--]-*-'*
? r,,l:i,!*, t xl*is m, idE t I qtrtq qfir3* I |*(S* ir$ff th fa{{rlU*r r$la lo&tt { ser rl frli ffitr
.s{rira
t,ls,t5 4 '! 4 ttrtxB\$ ||td*l
,(];r !F.{*!!st. *ff rtranrl E{faM aSfi
Sllil{*.tv:t! {tit['tt{K!*:i
i [."llf {&[c!fi [l\?'s {n"6Gt
_ _;{.I*}XS}!1
rffix$*s
.{ v&i$r I \.h l*s itqrcd *d docl *e ft{l**g
ri+ :h6 ll'qjfis 4}}!1t:;* E AnB&t:
lllEil r r{*y i# r!tf*r{ IBt"*,r{)It
^ -l.rff}!fiti
A$4r'*1f $f.
I lli Yi n (in}is. i
rel#r 6?ttt5111&a:49,3 |g,/$iu,
-i-rflm!}fk
fi*s*.{}d.nr&x*#}, qr';.bh$ier $?trrr-EEira..
tf, rrVtl.E ,tn $$n{tr:E!rtS
])t9
t
' 'i I
'1,1,'.'
ilrdi iftg. 1"r..
Lti
' ,"|
l1!hrrsis r& l hh rtltJatl{. rilr..lt *uJ, !t{,,Fli:ll}aljlr }w)ltltt$lj&lfr .rr}
I r}..lJr.l.t, r!tl!df?{rt xrt{i$it?! Sr dd, ;t$:t&fi 16, rX, {a.{ r r.!"rs.rxr$ (!!fi{lt
fi.I;'(tlDfli ?r{Ylltl;IrfE'tq]t{rTt& cr.t.I*}{}Uft SB E{,!Iit[.f?* X*r]tlSSt
A l{8*t-il*:i Wfttll\ l}i}- }1$r it,l{*B} iit:nrTirflril 8't rryftt:{* fi r E ?*i_iiftr.ti r
il I
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 683 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
SPECIAL MAGISTRATE
Case No. - PU,3&34 CEEX - 2009-0003795
4289{80 0R: 44{8 PG: 0932
RBCoRDBD u ol?IcIAL RIcoRDs of COtlItR CoUIfl, tt
0{/30/2009 at l0:0041{ DtIGEt I. BR0CI, CttR[
R8C lBt 18.50
Recn:
c0D8 iltt0RcBt$ilT
IIITBROP?ICB
ATTX: Jlll tAtI)R0t
who requested the hearing, was
Section 9, Subsection 4, in the
/
BOARD OF COUNTY COI}TMISSIONERS
CoLLIER COt NTY, FLORIDA,
Petitioner,
v3.
SAII:TA BARBARA GRANADA VILLAS, LLC,
Responrlent
THIS CAUSE came on for Magistrate on April 17, 2009, andthe Special Magistrate, having matters, hereupon issues itsFindings of Fact and Order of
l. The citation was Ray Addison, and isbeing contested by the
given proper notice but did not
2. Respondent is charged
following particulars :
Putrescible waste on ground
building.
and food not containerized in front of
The violation has not been abated as ofthe date ofthe hearing.
ORDER
Based upon the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, and pursuant to the au&orityqqt"d in Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Collier Counry ordinance ilo.0744, it is hereby
ORDERED:
A. Respondent is guilty of violating Ordinance No.2005-44, Section 9, Subsection 4.
B' Respondent shall pay a fine of $5,000.00, plus an administrative fee of $5.00 on or before May
17,2009.
C. Respondent is furtherordered to pay the operational costs incurred in prosecuting this case in ttre
amount $50.00 on or before May I 7,2009.
)
respective
as
Santa Barbara
at the hearing.
Ordinance N
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 684 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
IX)NE AI\'D ORDERED this E1L dAY Of
Any
itt 0R' {{48 PG: 0933 ttt
2fi)9 et Collier County, Floride.
SPECIAL MAGISTRATE
COLLIER COTM|TY CODE ENFORCEMEI{T
C.
order may be paid at the
Naples, FL 34104, fa(
of the satisfaction
#(239) 403-2343. Any retease
of the obligations of this order
LIEN RIGHTS: This order
montis from the filing of any
authorize the County Attorney
County. After three (3)
the Special Magistrate may
that outstanding frnes are
on unpaid claims. In the event
costs incurred by Collier County
will be responsibte for those
APPEAL: Any aggrieved party may Special Magistrate to the Circuit Courtwithin thirty (30) days of the execution of An appeal shall not be a hearing de novo,but shall be limited to appellate review of the record created within. It is the responsibility of theappealing party to obtain a transcribed record of the hearing from the Clerk of Courts. Filing an Appealwill not automaticslly stay the Special Magistrate's Order.
cc:Respondent * Santa Barbara Granada Viltas, LLC./
Collier Co. Code Enforcemen I Dept.4r
k'a*' o'l
)rart o: I r,O<lDA
hunty of @LLIER
I HEREBY CERTIFY THATtltc b:orrefi co Dyo?a oocumem
Eoard Minutes ?n,: Re/vl"{ESS mv
-49$oay or
,r,, u
I
to be paid
tance
R {le:
on the lien or
a collections
E.
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 685 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
,
I
c() l.t "}ffi { :ollNlt SuuIJ(tmLm.8S
em$*:tQht
11r ***rr!** ia*r+i}*y ,
frH, trtrh{rl $ qdry l*
t'u .,1,1 I i
<r*t .r tlEi t#r l*r rry.tit .BE ir Li!ry8 {r 6r
tufra &6 rirl*di rcd.d baka.
,..t
,{l,tl. $
-." |;i
,l
1 r, l l.i!
I I .', :1
i"j;
,'i
il
.t
\','., , r. -i '.
i.'t ..ri
Llrrqtbn
i.
lL
1,." ', .,,i
I'! ',i,
i . ,1,'ir,
,i
ri !.,,t,,l-,t
i.';i i ,' , .',-i,,, .,,.'i',
olrnarr$ !
| - . ,' 'a
i ','i '
,,4
!.
I tF. trb $r.d o(du nr...bd d.Lr I b"i B, deqid fd $f q. fqph|I@ar,,,:'.
l.-*-..lillrrys
;r* &t.dl*ssr ir
;-: &{rd *. ?]]lri}r. ed Hksr r ffrtsr tpwt *, . }.{Htt ?as,-*il* $eLl,Je Billt ,l {*r. ,, ,4.e / tb, .iud
f I -I{rntr**r nra {Sdkr.6$mrd
I 1$*1fr&3:rt!4tlTt{a"ti t#{ttr LlHSlrlw i$ 1}{r ${tlurltqqFHffi ls irlFtllrisu
t{} & lt[,a].!]r'J. [il:rrTs*IAi l,fiEi iJx
!lii\r'r":rt r\r'lf{\rt{i.
l,$1)$\' tlrlil$1fi }j'1"\1 XAHT:t
tt'rli'tlli\l:
9l;ii"{'r rr*. i}{\.1$ttialu&t
i'i: ij':'
t
rRBtl{6.\'gs'$1fi,,!3$I,3 x,\]&'
-"4.r rJ$,l,{!,* r ltNhjt'il'
$rlSld , L:rl. &lk?,:iffi i:*X! C!*9 t l}qetttu Cdfry ! A 1 . &er!a
st3 llrF&itr $llt ffi r$8fi ulh.t
y' t i1
'1,r,'l.,''
frtrr
,*,
{
tr
s bllh k!$At rfir Sik&&* *${}wd ${*tt}l
Ir* el ,ttetd i
"
i' I
" ";
"'
,li
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 686 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
4223886 0R: {{02 pG: 1200
!!!tnq[D in OnrcrAr, RIC0RDS ot c0t[Itt couxil, t[t0l2tl1.00s ar t0:urr{ Drrer? t. nioiiliiiii"'
Rtc tn 18.50
$PECIAL MAGISTBATE
Crse No.-PU-{43E
BOARD OF COIINTY COMIVIISSIOIiIERS
CoLLIER COI,NTY, FLI)RIDA,
Petitioner,
vs.
SAIITA BARBARA GARDEN VILLAS, LLC,
RcspondenL
THIS CAUSE came on for
the Special Magistrate, having
Findings of Fact and Order of
l. The citation was
contested by the Respondenl
proper notice and did not
2. Respondent is charged
3. Respondent violated the
containerized, causing a health, safety
4. This is Respondent's third violation.
Re ln:
c00t txlonctlxxt
IlllR0llIcl
Allll: l0lilflB S?tilm
has been abated.
Magistrate on October 3, 2008, and
matters, hereupon issues its
ike Andresky, and is being
the hearing was given
9.4.
in front of building that was not
/
ORDER
Based upon the-foregoing Findings of Fact and conclusions of [:w, and pursuant to the authoritygranted in Chapter 162' Florida Statutes, and Collier County Ordinance i1o.0744, it is herebyORDERED:
A. Respondent is guilty of viotating ordinance No. 200544, section 9.4.
-B Respondent shall pay a fine of $750.00, plus an administrative fee of $5.00 on or beforeNovember 3, 2008.
c' Respondent is further-ordered to pay the operational costs incurred in prosecuting this case in theamount $50.00 on or before November 3, 200g,
respective to
as
public hearing.
Ordinance
..4
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 687 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
t*tr gX: 4402 PG: 1201 tti
,2008 at Collier County, Florida.
SPECIAL MAGISTRATE
COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT
C.G
PAYMENT OF FINES: Any fines ordered to be pursuant to this order may be paid at the
Collier County Code Enforcement Drive, Naples, FL 34104, fax
#(239) 403-2343. Any release of lien or confirmation of the satisfaction
of the obligations of this order may
DONE AND oRDERED this J,.} day of of.
^
LIEN RIGHTS: This order r
months from the filing of any
authorize the County Attorney
that outstanding fines are
costs incurred by Collier
APPEAL: Any aggrieved
within thirty (30) days of the
but shall be limited to appellate
appealing party to obtain a
will not automatically stay the Special
cc:Respondent - Santa Barbara Garden Villas, LLC _ .
Collier Co. Utilities Office "
^( Collier Co. Code Enforcement Dept.,-/t'
Magistrate to the Circuit Court
shall not be a hearing de novo.
. It is the responsibility of the
Clerk of Courts. Filing an Appeal
Coll
on
jrdre 0t I r-orf tUa
Jounry ot COLLIER
ier Counry. After three (3)
the Special Magistrate may
unpaid claims. In the event
ill be responsible for those
.. 1Cc
which
at this
a
appeal a final
the Order
the record
:otrecl cooy or :
[ioard Minurilt ,::;:,.
i
,{'::fr;r::tt..i
.d'
-''/€r-<r
E. BROCK,
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 688 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
l
CITA'I'ION PU 4130
Th. qd..rrn.d invenisalor crnnc! 6.1 ft./3hi l$ (liordt l. .r$ilo lo b!ll6v. &rr $.
s.d p.'si(') or citiry hs .on;r&d i\li vlo,rtiifl rr.i;1 b.rl}w.
ht)4
D*ri.lla..tViohll.n
(r
OaL
Drt.otBlnh
-c
ll
ON
f)
J.)
(-,
/l
0'-5
bsul.g Inv.clg(or llu r.qucar€d a }LrinA b.for. U.S!.cl.l MrSktr(., A ktur
will lt lop rtrdnS dE d.t rd ttn6 6tllE R..rtn* to
OFTIONS
I hty. b&n lnfonn.d ofdl. viol.tion 6fw$dr I b.v. b!.n ch&g.d .nd .1..r lh.
follorvl;g outlo;l
l.)_P.rdE llvll p6{lty ors_+ colbofs_ ro(otol,l of i A}rl)cIfucrrh.rt,v. vlulsrlon wltrh 30 dgy. of Isuoo orfiiiGrion uitorr r D-lret Altto6..r
k s.t lmm.dilloly b.lov by tho lflvldl8.tinE Om... (.ot r. .rc..d 30 dryj).
2)-Cotrkd llE vlohdod.nd slbml(. wi&n Rqu.n for I h..rl.ghofo.! th. Sp!.1.1
Mtgltb.lo wlrhltr 20 drysofl!!urn6 orthk clhnon:
SG. r.r.no.ld6 for R.{ucrr h.H.!r,!gd.rrlb.
STCNATUR-8 GACTPIBNT)
PRINT(RBCTPIBNT'S NAME)
_--rsrorSsNsE --2xooPPENSE
OrlBi".l - Cod. p,ntom.;ont Cop/ I t.v.!ti8rio,
(lNyEsTrolIoRa NAJ!,IB)
{x9\ata-ztEo
(NVASnOITOR)
t7 ?otl
oaoo&
-lao
oSrENsB
Cop, 2& 3 R.oiplc
'i
i
i
i
I
I
I
I
i
I
I
I
I
I
lqp
I
I
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 689 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
INSTR 4598407 oR 471e PG 399 REcoRoED 8/19/20Lt 3:38 P|'l PAGE5 2
DWICHT E. BROCK, CLERK OF THE CTSCUIT COURT' COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA
REC $r.8. 50
goLLrER CpUI{ry coDE ENFQnCEMqIIT
SPECTALMAGT$3nATE
Case No. -PU473&CtrSX201 10009481
BOARD OT' COIINTY COMMISSIONERS
C0LLIER COUNTy, FLORTDA,
Petltioner,
Ys.
SANTA BANBAAA LANDINCS
PROPERTY OWNERS ASSN rNC,
Respondent
TI{IS CAUSE came on on August 5, 201 1, and
and being duly advisedthe Special Magistrate, having
in the premisos, hercupon
Magistrate, as follows:
and Order of the Special
Respondent is charged
following particulars :
2AA5-44, Section 9(4), in the
Putrescible waste on ground diapers, food, crrdboard, glrss,
plastic, solled and other furnihrre, etc.
ORDER
Based upon the foregoing, and pursuant 1o thc authority granted iu Chapter 162, Florida Stalutes,
and Collier County Ordinance No. A7 44, it is hereby ORDERED:
A. The Respondent's Motion for Continuance of this case is denied.
Respondeut is found guilty of violating Collier County Ordinanoe 200544, Section9 (4).
Respondenl is ordered to pay the operational costs incurred in prosecuting this oase in the
amount of $50.00.
Respondent is ordered to pay the administrative fee incurred in prosecuting this case in the
amourlt of $5.00.
Respondent is ordercd to pay the finc imposed by Collier Counly Ordinance in this case in
tbc amour( of $25,000.00.
B.
C.
D.
E.
bofors
of Collier
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 690 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
*** OR 4712 PG 400 ***
F. Respondent is ordered to pay in total $25,055.00 on or before September 5, 201 I
D9NE AND 6RDERED this $h a"y or 2011 at Collier Counfy, Florida.
COLLIER COTJNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT
SPECIAL MAGISTRATE
cc:Respondents - Santa
Collier Co. Code
mtil$
16.A.12.b
Packet Pg. 691 Attachment: Backup documents (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
SPECIAL MAGISTRATE
Case No. - PU-3&14 CEEX - 2009-0003795
4289{80 0R: 44{8 PG: 0932
RBC0RD8D u orrlclll RlcoRDs of COttlt[ CoUITI. tt
0{/30/2009 rt l0:004I DIIGEI X, BR0CI. CIIU
R8C mB 18.50
Rern:
c0Dt tilP0ncBlu{?
IIITXROITICE
AT?X: iBll IAt0R0t
who requested the hearing, was
Section 9, Subsection 4, in the
BOARD OF COUNTY COM}'ISSIONERS
COLLTER CO['NTY, FLORIDA,
Petitioner,
vs.
SAIYTA BARBARA GRANADA VILLAS, LLC,
RespondenL
THIS CAUSE came on for Magistrate on April 17, 2009, andthe Special Magistrate, having m&tters, hereupon issues itsFindings of Fact and Order of
The citation was Ray Addison, and isbeing contested by the
given proper notice but did not
2. Respondent is charged
following particulars :
Putrescible waste on ground
building.
and food not containerized in front of
The violation has not been abated as ofthe date ofthe hearing.
ORDER
Based upon the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, and pursuant to the authorityq*t9d in Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Collier Counry Ordinance No.07-44, it is hereby
ORDERED:
A. Respondent is guilty of violating Ordinance No.2005-44, Section 9, Subsection 4.
B. Respondent shall pay a fine of $5,000.00, plus an administrative fee of $5.00 on or before May17,2409.
C' Respondent is firtherordered to pay the operational costs incurred in prosecuting this case in the
amount $50.00 on or before May 17,20A9.
I
t.
3
respective
as fol
Santa Barbara
at the hearing.
Ordinance
I
\
t
16.A.12.c
Packet Pg. 692 Attachment: Lien Orders (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
DoNE Ar{D ORDERED this EU day of
Any
**i 0R' 44{8 PG: 0933 ttt
2{XD at Collier Count5r, Floride.
SPECIAL MAGISTRATE
COLLIER COUNry CODE EIYFONCEMENT
C.
)tare o: I r,CiilUA
bunry of @LLIER
I HEREEY CERT'
:oTrect coDy ot a
Eoard Minutes ar:,;
order may be paid at the
Naples, FL 34104, fax
of the satisfaction
#(239) 403-2343. Any retease
of the obligations of this order
LIEN RIGIITS: This order
months from the filing of any
authorize the County Attorney
County. After three (3)
the Special Magistrare may
that outstanding fines are
on unpaid claims. ln the event
costs incurred by Collier County
will be responsible for those
APPEAL: Any aggrieved party may Special Magistrate to the Circuit Courtwithin thirty (30) days of the execution of An appeal shall not be a hearing de novo,but shall be limited to appellate review of the record created within. It is the responsibility of theappealingparty to obtain a transcribed record ofthe hearing from the Clerk of Courts. Filing an Appealwill not automatically stay the Special Magistrate's Order
cc:Respondent - Santa Barbara Granada Villas, LLC,,/
Collier Co. Code Enforcemen t Dept.4I
4,- av' o'l
FY IHAThlrb
JVIT{ESS mv
=Q,} oay ot
1,. t!',
a
to be paid
lance
on the lien or
a collections
I
E.
Collier County
16.A.12.c
Packet Pg. 693 Attachment: Lien Orders (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
4223885 0R: {{02 pG: 1200
ryq9ngm in 0nrCrA[ RtconDs of C0[[Itt couxil, t[t0l2V200s at l0:jill Drrcr? t. nnoii, ciiii"'
RXC nt 18,50
-C""Q,,I,I,IER COUNTY CODE EnIF,ORC rMENT
sPncrAL MAGTST.RATE
Crse No -PU-443E
BOARD OF COI'NTY COMIVIISSIONERS
COLLIER CO['NTY, FI,ORIDA,
Petitioner,
vs.
THIS CAUSE came on for
the Special Magisrrate,having
Findings of Fact and Order of
l. The citation was
contested by the Respondent,
proper notice and did not
2, Respondent is charged
3. Respondent violated the
containerized, causing a health, safety
4. This is Respondent's third violation.
Retn:
coDr tmoRctuxt
IltrR0ilIct
AlTll: flRilffi S?illl?
has been abated.
Magistrate on October 3, 2008, and
matters, hereupon issues its
ike Andresky, and is being
the hearing was given
9.4.
in front of building that was not
I
ORDER
Based upon the_fore8oing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of [:w, and pursuant to the authoritygranted in Chapter 162, Florida Statutes, and Collier County Ordinance No.0744, it is hereby.ORDERED:
A. Respondent is guilty of violating ordinance No. 2005-44, section 9.4.
q Respondent shall pay a fine of $750.00, plus an administrative fee of $5.00 on or beforeNovember 3, 2008.
c' Respondent is further ordered to pay the operational costs incurred in prosecuting this case in theamouot $50.00 on or before November 3, 200g.
respective to
as
public hearing.
Ordinance
SAIYTA BARBARA GARDEN VILLAS, LLC,
Respondent
16.A.12.c
Packet Pg. 694 Attachment: Lien Orders (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
**t gpt 4{02 PG: 1201 ttt
DONE AND oRDERED this J,.I day of od ,2008 at Collier Coun ty' Florida.
SPECIAL MAGISTRATE
COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMf,NT
C. GARRE
PAYMENT OF FINES: Any fines ordered to be pursuant to this order may be paid at the
Collier County Code Enforcement Drive, Naples, FL 34104, fax
#(239) 403-2343. Any release of lien or confirmation of the satisfaction
of the obligations of this order may
LIEN RIGHTS: This order
months from the filing of any
Collier County. After three (3)
the Special Magistrate may
authorize the County Attomey on unpaid claims. In the event
that outstanding fines are will be responsible for those
costs incurred by Collier
APPEAL: Any aggrieved Magistrate to the Circuit Coun
shall not be a hearing de novo.
It is the responsibility of the
within thirty (30) days of the
but shall be limited to appellate
appealing party to obtain a tran Clerk of Courts. Filing an Appeal
will not automatically stay the Special
cc Respondent - Santa Barbara Garden Villas, LLC _ .
Collier Co. Utilities Office .
Collier Co. Code Enforcement Dept.../A
.1C
/
c
irare or i r_LtnlUA
Jounty ot COLLIER
at this
appeal a final
the Order
the record c
:orrect coo)/ or :
Eoard Minurst i:;;,,
",-d'::,fr;n:,i.;
\a
-/iErIItr*
E. BROCI(,
16.A.12.c
Packet Pg. 695 Attachment: Lien Orders (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
INSTR 4598407 OR 4712 PG 399 RECORDED 8,/,
DWTGHT E. BROCK, CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT
REC $L8.50
l9/20LL 3:38 PM PAGES 2
, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA
coLLrER COUNTy qop$ ENTqRCEM$NT
SPECIAL MAGISTRATE
Case No. -PU4730-CEEX201 I 0009481
tsOARD O[' COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COI]NTY, FLORIDA,
Petltioner,
vs.
SANTA BANBANA LANDINGS
PROPERTY OWI\ERS ASSN INC,
Respondent
THIS CAUSE came on agistrete on August 5, 2011, and
the Special Magistratc, having and being duly advised
in the prcmiscs, hercupon
Magistrate, as follows:
, and Order of the Special
Rcspondcnl is charged
following padiculars:
2005-44, Section 9(4), in the
Putrescible wrste on ground diapers, food, cardboard, glnss,
plastlc, sollcd and other furniture, etc.
Based upon the foregoing, and pursuaut to thc authority grantcd iu Chapter 162, Florida Stalutes,
and Collier County Ordinance No. 0744, it is heretry OKDERED:
The Respondent's Motion for Continuance ol'this caso is denied.
Respondent is found guilty of violating Collier County Ordinance200544, Section9 (4).
Respondent is ordered to pay the operational costs incunrd in prosecuting this case in the
amount of $50.00.
Respondent is ordered to pay the adminislrative fee incurred in prosecuting this case in the
amount of $5.00.
Respondent is ordercd to pay the fine imposed by Collier County Ordinance in this case in
thc amount of $25,000.00.
A.
B.
c.
D.
E.
beforc
of Collierl,
ORDER
16.A.12.c
Packet Pg. 696 Attachment: Lien Orders (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
*** oR 4712 PG 400 ***
F. Respondent is ordered to pay in total $25,055.00 on or before September 5, 201 1.
DONE AND ORDERED this Slrln, ou,of 2011 at Collier County, Florida.
COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMBNT
SPECIAL MAGISTRATE
cc:Respondents - Santa
Collier Co. Code
i, i'
mr rnd
:,iii,. ..:i,
i
Inc.
'ia1
16.A.12.c
Packet Pg. 697 Attachment: Lien Orders (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
16.A.12.d
Packet Pg. 698 Attachment: Executed releases (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
16.A.12.d
Packet Pg. 699 Attachment: Executed releases (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)
16.A.12.d
Packet Pg. 700 Attachment: Executed releases (15777 : BCC v. Santa Barbara Granada Villas LLC, Santa Barbara Garden Villas LLC,)