The URL can be used to link to this page

Agenda 04/27/2021 Item # 8A (Resolution: CU Communication Tower)8.A 04/27/2021 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve a Resolution of the Board of Zoning Appeals of Collier County, Florida providing for the establishment of a conditional use to allow a communications tower on lands zoned Rural Agricultural (A) within the Mobile Home Overlay (MHO) and designated Rural Fringe Mixed Use - Sending Lands within the Natural Resource Protection Area Overlay and North Belle Meade Overlay in the Collier County Growth Management Plan pursuant to Sections 2.01.03.G.4.a and 2.03.08.A.4.a(3)(a) of the Collier County Land Development Code on .95f acres of a 5.0+/- acre tract located on the east side of the north -south extension of Benton Road, in Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. [PL20180002327] OBJECTIVE: To have the Board of County Commissioners (Board) review staffs findings and recommendations along with the recommendations of the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) regarding the above -referenced petition and render a decision regarding the petition; and ensure the project is in harmony with all the applicable codes and regulations in order to ensure that the community's interests are maintained. CONSIDERATIONS: The subject property is .95 acres of a 5-acre tract located on the east side of the north -south extension of Benton Road in Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. The petitioner requests a conditional use to allow a communications tower on lands zoned Rural Agricultural (A) within the Mobile Home Overlay (MHO) and designated Rural Fringe Mixed Use - Sending Lands within the Natural Resource Protection Area Overlay and North Belle Meade Overlay in the Collier County Growth Management Plan, pursuant to Sections 2.01.03.G.4.a and 2.03.08.A.4.a(3)(a) of the Collier County Land Development Code (LDC). The petitioner seeks a Conditional Use for an essential service telecommunications tower as identified in Section 2.01.03.G.4.a and 2.03.08.A.4.a(3)(a), subject to LDC Section 5.05.09. The application is proposing the construction of a 220-foot AGL Guyed Tower with associated walled compound (60-feet x 60-feet) at the towers base to accommodate equipment for Verizon and future users. The tower is designed to accommodate three additional future users for a total of four (4) colocations. The parent parcel is a +5 acre undeveloped site, east of Benton Road, with a zoning designation of Agriculture and within the Rural Fringe Mixed Use Sending Zoning Overlay (RFMUO-Sending), the North Belle Meade Overlay (NBMO) and designated as a Natural Resources Protection Area (NRPA). The property owner, Tafara Lodge, LLC, of the proposed tower site also owns four of the seven parcels that directly abut the proposed site. The tower is designed to accommodate Verizon's antenna and equipment that the existing tower located to the north and west of the property could not accommodate due to loading capacity. The proposed tower will be able to accommodate the Verizon antenna's, as well as three additional sets of antennas for a total of 4 colocations, as required by LDC section 5.05.09.D. The compound at the base of the tower is proposed to be 60-feet x 60-feet to accommodate Verizon's ground equipment, as well as the additional users the tower can accommodate. The compound area will be screened by a solid concrete wall, as required by the LDC. The tower will be setback from the parent parcel lines North - 506-feet, South - 150-feet, East - 570-feet, and West - 128-feet. The tower has been designed to collapse within a radius equal to 120-feet. All guyed wires will be required to be equipped with Bird Diverter devices to reduce the probability of injury to migratory birds. The tower will be equipped with FAA "med dual" lights, the minimum required by state or federal law. For a complete set of drawings, aerials, site plans, and elevations (See Attachment A - Proposed Resolution) Packet Pg. 34 8.A 04/27/2021 The proposed tower is expected to typically generate no more than one (1) trip per coloration per month. As such there is not anticipated to be meaningful impact to the surrounding area related to automotive or pedestrian traffic. Access to the site will be to the north through property owned by Tafara Lodge LLC to Benton Road, a road right-of-way designated for public use (See Attachment B - Unrecorded Lease Agreement). This unrecorded lease agreement shows the approximate location of the revised driveway. The lease will be amended one more time after zoning approval to incorporate the county approved survey and plans and then it will be recorded. FISCAL IMPACT: The Conditional Use (CU) by and of itself will have no fiscal impact on Collier County. There is no guarantee that the project, at build -out, will maximize its authorized level of development. However, if the CU is approved, a portion of the land could be developed, and the new development will result in an impact on Collier County public facilities. The County collects impact fees prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy to help offset the impacts of each new development on public facilities. These impact fees are used to fund projects identified in the Capital Improvement Element of the Growth Management Plan as needed to maintain the adopted Level of Service (LOS) for public facilities. Additionally, in order to meet the requirements of concurrency management, the developer of every local development order approved by Collier County is required to pay a portion of the estimated Transportation Impact Fees associated with the project in accordance with Chapter 74 of the Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances. Other fees collected prior to issuance of a building permit include building permit review fees. Please note that impact fees and taxes collected were not included in the criteria used by staff and the Planning Commission to analyze this petition. GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: The +5 acres subject site is designated Rural Fringe Mixed Use District Sending Lands (RFMUD), North Belle Meade Overlay, and the North Belle Meade Natural Resource Preservation Area (NRPA), as identified in the Future Land Use Element of the Growth Management Plan. The site is zoned Agriculture Zoning District within a Mobile Home Overlay (A - MHO) and is also within the Rural Fringe Mixed Use Overlay - Natural Resource Protection Area - North Belle Meade Overlay - Sending area. (See Attachment C - FLUE Consistency review) In a recent LDC Amendment, approved Ordinance #2019-08 on June 11, 2019, it specifically states the unincorporated area of Collier County allows communications towers as a conditional use in the Rural Fringe Mixed Use Sending Lands and Conservation District. (See Attachment D - Ordinance 2019-08) Ord. #19-08 states under Section G. Conditional Uses (4.) Additional conditional uses in the RFMU sending lands and CON districts. The following essential services shall be allowed as conditional uses: a. Communications towers, subject to all applicable provisions of LDC section 5.05.09. Transportation Element: The project is consistent with Policy 5.1 of the Transportation Element of the Growth Management Plan, which states, "The County Commission shall review all rezone petitions, SRA designation applications, conditional use petitions, and proposed amendments to the Future Land Use Element (FLUE) affecting the overall countywide density or intensity of permissible development, with consideration of their impact on the overall County transportation system, and shall not approve any petition or application that would directly access a deficient roadway segment as identified in the current AUIR or if it impacts an adjacent roadway segment that is deficient as identified in the current AUIR, or which significantly impacts a roadway segment or adjacent roadway segment that is currently operating and/or is projected to operate below an adopted Level of Service Packet Pg. 35 8.A 04/27/2021 Standard within the five year AUIR planning period, unless specific mitigating stipulations are also approved. A petition or application has significant impacts if the traffic impact statement reveals that any of the following occur: a. For links (roadway segments) directly accessed by the project where project traffic is equal to or exceeds 2% of the adopted LOS standard service volume; b. For links adjacent to links directly accessed by the project where project traffic is equal to or exceeds 2% of the adopted LOS standard service volume; and C. For all other links, the project traffic is considered to be significant up to the point where it is equal to or exceeds 3% of the adopted LOS standard service volume. Mitigating stipulations shall be based upon a mitigation plan prepared by the applicant and submitted as part of the traffic impact statement that addresses the project's significant impacts on all roadways. " This proposed communication tower is similar to other un-maned tower facilities that generate a deminimis number of maintenance related trips monthly. Normally this can be +/- 6 trips per month depending on the facility. Therefore, the subject Conditional Use is found consistent with Policy 5.1 of the Transportation Element of the Growth Management Plan. Transportation Review: Transportation Planning staff has reviewed the petition request and is recommending approval. Environmental Review: Environmental Planning staff has reviewed the Conditional Use petition to address environmental concerns. The preserve requirement is 4.58 acres (90% of 5.09 acres). The Master Plan provides a 4.58-acre preserve, which meets the minimum 90 percent native preservation requirement in accordance with LDC 3.05.07. No listed plant or animal species were observed on the property; however, the property has suitable habitat for various listed species. The existing onsite vegetation is potential habitat for Eastern indigo snake (Drymarchon corais couperi); the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) has recommended implementation of the Standard Protection Measures for the Eastern Indigo Snake. The proposed project is located within the FWS consultation area for Bonneted Bat (Eumops floridanus); however, no evidence was founding indicating the trees onsite were being utilized. The Environmental Data indicates the subject property falls within FWS Primary Florida Panther (Felis concolor coryi) habitat. There were no observations of panther onsite; consultation with FWS revealed the proposed project is not likely to adversely affect the panther. (See Attachment E - FWS Consultation) Conservation & Coastal Management Element (COME): Environmental review staff has found this project to be consistent with the Conservation & Coastal Management Element (CCME). The project is located within Rural Fringe Mixed -Use Sending NBMO - NRPA lands and consists of 5.09 acres of native vegetation. A minimum of 4.58 acres (90%) of the existing native vegetation shall be placed under preservation and dedicated to Collier County. COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION (CCPC): The CCPC, heard Petition CU- PL20180002327, Benton Road - Communication Tower on March 18, 2021, and voted 6-1 to forward this petition to the Board with a recommendation of approval. Moreover, the CCPC acted as the Environmental Advisory Council (EAC) and voted 6-1 with a recommendation of approval to the Board. There was moderate opposition. As such, this petition will be placed on Board of Zoning Appeals. Planning Commissioner Paul Shea denied the petition for two reasons: 1) Both cell tower companies were not communicating thereby resulting in the residents being victims. Packet Pg. 36 04/27/2021 8.A 2) The existing tower (Alpine tower) could be renovated to carry the new equipment. At the March 18, 2021 CCPC meeting, the planning commissioners added three additional conditions of approval. Subsequent to this hearing, staff edited the conditions for clarification and applicant agreed to the revisions. These revised conditions of approval are outlined in the strikethrough/underline below and were added to the Resolution. 1. The Benton Road - Communication Tower Conditional Use, shall be limited to that which is depicted on the "Benton Road Relo (Naples Park) Drawings - Revised 01-04-21," prepared by SMW Engineering Group, Inc. 2. The petitioner will take care of complete maintenance during construction by grading and compacting new ruts that form on Benton Road from the bridge over the canal to petitioner's driveway as needed to keep the roadway in the pre -construction condition. Capital will provide photo documentation and a video of existing conditions prior to the pre -construction meeting. The video documentation shall cover the length of the road from the bridge t�pital's driveway. 3. The petitioner will do a complete repair of any damage caused to the road after construction and grade and compact Benton Road with a 1-2 ton, 36", double roller, ride -on, vibratory compactor from the bridge over the canal to petitioner's driveway. 4. After construction, the petitioner will pay its fair share of road maintenance of Benton Road from the bridge over the canal to Capital's driveway based on usage of the road, whether an Association is formed or not. On April 20, 2021, staff received a Letter of Concern (See Attachment P) and a Structural Analysis Review (See Attachment Q). Both documents were submitted by Forsyth and Brugger, P.A. and relate to the Alpine Tower located to the northwest of the subject tower. LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: Before you is a recommendation by the Planning Commission for approval of a conditional use authorizing a communications tower in the Rural Agricultural (A) zoning district within the Mobile Home Overlay (MHO). A conditional use is a use that is permitted in a particular zoning district subject to certain restrictions. All testimony given must be under oath. The attached report and recommendations of the Planning Commission are advisory only and are not binding on you. Petitioner has the burden of demonstrating that the necessary requirements have been met, and you may question Petitioner, or staff, to satisfy yourself that the necessary criteria has been satisfied. In addition to meeting the necessary criteria, you may place such conditions and safeguards as you deem appropriate to allow the use, provided that there is competent, substantial evidence that these additional conditions and safeguards are necessary to promote the public health, safety, welfare, morals, order, comfort, convenience, appearance, or the general welfare of the neighborhood. As a further condition of approval of the conditional use, you may require that suitable areas for streets, public rights -of -way, schools, parks, and other public facilities be set aside, improved, and/or dedicated for public use, subject to appropriate impact fee credits. Approval or denial of the Petition is by Resolution. This item has been approved as to form and legality, and requires an affirmative vote of four for Board approval. (HFAC) RECOMMENDATION: Staff concurs with the recommendation of the CCPC and further recommends that the Board of County Commissioners approves the request for Petition CU-PL20180002327, Benton Road - Communications Tower. Prepared by: Timothy Finn, AICP, Principal Planner, Zoning Division ATTACHMENT(S) 1. Staff Report - Benton Road Communication Tower (PDF) Packet Pg. 37 8.A 04/27/2021 2. Attachment A - Proposed Resolution - 040121 (PDF) 3. Attachment B - Unrecorded lease agreement (PDF) 4. Attachment C - FLUE Consistency Review dated 12-22-20 (PDF) 5. Attachment D - Ordinance 2019-08 (PDF) 6. [Linked] Attachment E - FWS Consultation (PDF) 7. Attachment F - 47 USC 332, prohibition language on page 4 (PDF) 8. Attachment G - NIM 7-10-19 (PDF) 9. [Linked] Attachment H - NIM 11-23-20 (PDF) 10. Attachment I - Opposition Letters (PDF) 11. Attachment J - Hybrid Hearing Waiver(PDF) 12. [Linked] Attachment K - Application -Backup Materials (PDF) 13. Attachment L - Hearing Property Signs (PDF) 14. Attachment M - Access & Utilities Easement Kuszlyk (RECORDED) (PDF) 15. Attachment N - Public Access Utilities Easement Beddoe (RECORDED) 16. Attachment O - Intent to Collocate Letters (PDF) 17. Attachment P - Letter of Concern - Forsyth and Brugger, P.A. (PDF) 18. Attachment Q - Structural Analysis Review - Electronics Research, Inc. 19. legal ad - Agenda ID 14881 (PDF) (PDF) (PDF) Packet Pg. 38 8.A 04/27/2021 COLLIER COUNTY Board of County Commissioners Item Number: 8.A Doe ID: 14881 Item Summary: This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve a Resolution of the Board of Zoning Appeals of Collier County, Florida providing for the establishment of a conditional use to allow a communications tower on lands zoned Rural Agricultural (A) within the Mobile Home Overlay (MHO) and designated Rural Fringe Mixed Use -Sending Lands within the Natural Resource Protection Area Overlay and North Belle Meade Overlay in the Collier County Growth Management Plan pursuant to Sections 2.01.03.G.4.a and 2.03.08.A.4.a(3)(a) of the Collier County Land Development Code on .95± acres of a 5.0+/- acre tract located on the east side of the north -south extension of Benton Road, in Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. [PL20180002327] Meeting Date: 04/27/2021 Prepared by: Title: — Zoning Name: Tim Finn 03/23/2021 3:35 PM Submitted by: Title: Manager - Planning — Zoning Name: Ray Bellows 03/23/2021 3:35 PM Approved By: Review: Growth Management Department Jeanne Marcella Level 1 Reviewer Completed 03/29/2021 8:51 AM Zoning Ray Bellows Additional Reviewer Completed 03/31/2021 3:48 PM Zoning Anita Jenkins Additional Reviewer Completed 04/06/2021 1:18 PM Growth Management Department Jeanne Marcella Department Head Review Completed 04/07/2021 2:45 PM County Attorney's Office Heidi Ashton-Cicko Level 2 Attorney of Record Review Completed 04/09/2021 10:24 AM Office of Management and Budget Debra Windsor Level 3 OMB Gatekeeper Review Completed 04/09/2021 10:35 AM County Attorney's Office Jeffrey A. Klatzkow Level 3 County Attorney's Office Review Completed 04/09/2021 2:11 PM Office of Management and Budget Laura Zautcke Additional Reviewer Completed 04/14/2021 9:15 AM County Manager's Office Board of County Commissioners Dan Rodriguez Level 4 County Manager Review MaryJo Brock Meeting Pending Completed 04/15/2021 11:51 AM 04/27/2021 9:00 AM Packet Pg. 39 8.A.1 CofMr County STAFF REPORT TO: COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FROM: ZONING DIVISION — ZONING SERVICES SECTION GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT HEARING DATE: MARCH 18, 2021 SUBJECT: CU- PL20180002327; BENTON ROAD — COMMUNICATION TOWER PROPERTY OWNER/AGENT: Owner: Tafara Lodge LLC Agent(s): Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. 3585 41st Avenue NE Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, P.A. Naples, FL 34120 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Applicant: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC 820 Morris Turnpike, STE. 104 Short Hills, NJ 07078 REQUESTED ACTION: To have the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) consider an application for a Conditional Use to allow a communications tower on lands zoned Rural Agricultural (A) within the Mobile Home Overlay (MHO) and designated Rural Fringe Mixed Use -Sending Lands within the Natural Resource Protection Area Overlay and North Belle Meade Overlay in the Collier County Growth Management Plan, pursuant to Sections 2.01.03.G.4.a and 2.03.08.A.4.a(3)(a) of the Collier County Land Development Code (LDC). GEOGRAPHIC LOCATION: The subject property is .95 acres of a 5-acre tract located on the east side of the north -south extension of Benton Road in Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. (See location map on the following page) CU-PL20180002327; BENTON RD — COMMUNICATION TOWER Page 1 of 10 March 10, 2021 Packet Pg. 40 uoijeoiummoo - peoll uolua8 : �ggt,�) aamol uoijeoiunw=3 peoll uo}ua8 - podall }IeIg :juauayoe;jd T T d � a a� U e O v le000e I N O;ua$ z � � d C J e Milo MGM N=— INS INS Mmm OR ZZ INE MOM HIM r— {�J CD 00 CD J n L Q) E C CL J fC a CU-PL20180002327; BENTON RD — COMMUNICATION TOWER Page 2 of 10 March 10, 2021 8.A.1 PURPOSE/DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT: The petitioner seeks a Conditional Use for an essential service telecommunications tower as identified in Section 2.01.03.G.4.a and 2.03.08.A.4.a(3)(a), subject to LDC Section 5.05.09. The application is proposing the construction of a 220-foot AGL Guyed Tower with associated walled compound (60-feet x 60-feet) at the towers base to accommodate equipment for Verizon and future users. The tower is designed to accommodate three additional future users for a total of four (4) colocations. The parent parcel is a +5 acre undeveloped site, east of Benton Road, with a zoning designation of Agriculture and within the Rural Fringe Mixed Use Sending Zoning Overlay (RFMUO-Sending), the North Belle Meade Overlay (NBMO) and designated as a Natural Resources Protection Area (NRPA). The property owner, Tafara Lodge, LLC, of the proposed tower site also owns four of the seven parcels that directly abut the proposed site. The tower is designed to accommodate Verizon's antenna and equipment that the existing tower located to the north and west of the property could not accommodate due to loading capacity. The proposed tower will be able to accommodate the Verizon antenna's, as well as three additional sets of antennas for a total of 4 colocations, as required by LDC section 5.05.09.D. The compound at the base of the tower is proposed to be 60-feet x 60-feet to accommodate Verizon's ground equipment, as well as the additional users the tower can accommodate. The compound area will be screened by a solid concrete wall, as required by the LDC. The tower will be setback from the parent parcel lines North - 506-feet, South — 150-feet, East — 570-feet, and West — 128-feet. The tower has been designed to collapse within a radius equal to 120-feet. All guyed wires will be required to be equipped with Bird Diverter devices to reduce the probability of injury to migratory birds. The tower will be equipped with FAA "med dual" lights, the minimum required by state or federal law. For a complete set of drawings, aerials, site plans, and elevations (See Attachment A — Proposed Resolution) The proposed tower is expected to typically generate no more than one (1) trip per colocation per month. As such there is not anticipated to be meaningful impact to the surrounding area related to automotive or pedestrian traffic. Access to the site will be to the north through property owned by Tafara Lodge LLC to Benton Road, a road right-of-way designated for public use (See Attachment B — Unrecorded Lease Agreement). This unrecorded lease agreement shows the approximate location of the revised driveway. The lease will be amended one more time after zoning approval to incorporate the county approved survey and plans and then it will be recorded. Intentionally blank CU-PL20180002327; BENTON RD — COMMUNICATION TOWER Page 3 of 10 March 10, 2021 Packet Pg. 42 8.A.1 SURROUNDING LAND USE AND ZONING: This section of the staff report identifies the land uses and zoning classifications for properties surrounding the boundaries of the subject property, which is undeveloped and zoned Agricultural - Mobile Home Overlay -Rural Fringe Mixed Use Overlay- Sending- Natural Resource Protection Area -North Belle Meade Overlay- (A-MHO-RFMUO-S-NRPA-NBMO) with a flood zone of AH with a base flood elevation (BFE) of 12' North American Vertical Datum (NAVD): North: Developed with two mobile homes and various accessory buildings with a zoning designation of A-MHO-RFMUO-S-NRPA-NBMO East: Undeveloped, with a zoning designation of A-MHO-RFMUO-S-NRPA-NBMO South: Undeveloped with a zoning designation of A-MHO-RFMUO-S-NRPA-NBMO West: Benton Road Right -of -Way and undeveloped parcel, with a zoning designation of A- MHO-RFMUO-S-NRPA-NBMO Collier County Property Appraiser CU-PL20180002327; BENTON RD — COMMUNICATION TOWER Page 4 of 10 March 10, 2021 Packet Pg. 43 8.A.1 GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN (GMP) CONSISTENCY: Comprehensive Planning staff has reviewed this request and offered the following comments: Future Land Use Element (FLUE): The +5 acres subject site is designated Rural Fringe Mixed Use District Sending Lands (RFMUD), North Belle Meade Overlay, and the North Belle Meade Natural Resource Preservation Area (NRPA), as identified in the Future Land Use Element of the Growth Management Plan. The site is zoned Agriculture Zoning District within a Mobile Home Overlay (A -MHO) and is also within the Rural Fringe Mixed Use Overlay — Natural Resource Protection Area — North Belle Meade Overlay — Sending area. (See Attachment C — FLUE Consistency review) In a recent LDC Amendment, approved Ordinance #2019-08 on June 11, 2019, it specifically states the unincorporated area of Collier County allows communications towers as a conditional use in the Rural Fringe Mixed Use Sending Lands and Conservation District. (See Attachment D — Ordinance 2019-08) Ord. #19-08 states under Section G. Conditional Uses (4.) Additional conditional uses in the RFMU sending lands and CON districts. The following essential services shall be allowed as conditional uses: a. Communications towers, subject to all applicable provisions of LDC section 5.05.09. Transportation Element: The project is consistent with Policy 5.1 of the Transportation Element of the Growth Management Plan, which states, "The County Commission shall review all rezone petitions, SRA designation applications, conditional use petitions, and proposed amendments to the Future Land Use Element (FLUE) affecting the overall countywide density or intensity of permissible development, with consideration of their impact on the overall County transportation system, and shall not approve any petition or application that would directly access a deficient roadway segment as identified in the current AUIR or if it impacts an adjacent roadway segment that is deficient as identified in the current AUIR, or which significantly impacts a roadway segment or adjacent roadway segment that is currently operating and/or is projected to operate below an adopted Level of Service Standard within the five year AUIR planning period, unless specific mitigating stipulations are also approved. A petition or application has significant impacts if the traffic impact statement reveals that any of the following occur: a. For links (roadway segments) directly accessed by the project where project traffic is equal to or exceeds 2% of the adopted LOS standard service volume; b. For links adjacent to links directly accessed by the project where project traffic is equal to or exceeds 2% of the adopted LOS standard service volume; and C. For all other links the project traffic is considered to be significant up to the point where it is equal to or exceeds 3% of the adopted LOS standard service volume. CU-PL20180002327; BENTON RD — COMMUNICATION TOWER Page 5 of 10 March 10, 2021 Packet Pg. 44 8.A.1 Mitigating stipulations shall be based upon a mitigation plan prepared by the applicant and submitted as part of the traffic impact statement that addresses the project's significant impacts on all roadways. " This proposed communication tower is similar to other un-maned tower facilities that generate a deminimis number of maintenance related trips monthly. Normally this can be +/- 6 trips per month depending on the facility. Therefore, the subject Conditional Use is found consistent with Policy 5.1 of the Transportation Element of the Growth Management Plan. Transportation Review: Transportation Planning staff has reviewed the petition request and is recommending approval. Environmental Review: Environmental Planning staff has reviewed the Conditional Use petition to address environmental concerns. The preserve requirement is 4.58 acres (90% of 5.09 acres). The Master Plan provides a 4.58-acre preserve, which meets the minimum 90 percent native preservation requirement in accordance with LDC 3.05.07. No listed plant or animal species were observed on the property; however, the property has suitable habitat for various listed species. The existing onsite vegetation is potential habitat for Eastern indigo snake (Drymarchon corais couperi); the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) has recommended implementation of the Standard Protection Measures for the Eastern Indigo Snake. The proposed project is located within the FWS consultation area for Bonneted Bat (Eumops floridanus); however, no evidence was founding indicating the trees onsite were being utilized. The Environmental Data indicates the subject property falls within FWS Primary Florida Panther (Felis concolor coryi) habitat. There were no observations of panther onsite; consultation with FWS revealed the proposed project is not likely to adversely affect the panther. (See Attachment E — FWS Consultation) Conservation & Coastal Management Element (CCME): Environmental review staff has found this project to be consistent with the Conservation & Coastal Management Element (CCME). The project is located within Rural Fringe Mixed -Use Sending NBMO — NRPA lands and consists of 5.09 acres of native vegetation. A minimum of 4.58 acres (90%) of the existing native vegetation shall be placed under preservation and dedicated to Collier County. Federal Law It should be noted that Section 704 of the US Telecommunications Act of 1996, codified at 47 USC 332(c)(7)(B)(iv), prohibits environmental concerns (or health concerns) as a reason for denial of cell towers by a local jurisdiction (See Attachment F — 47 USC 332, prohibition language on page 4) If the CCPC recommends denial of the petition it should not be based on health affect, but rather one of the five below areas of analysis for conditional Uses. STAFF ANALYSIS: When considering a Conditional Use petition, the CCPC must make findings that: 1) approval of the Conditional Use will not adversely affect the public interest and will not adversely affect other property of uses in the same district of neighborhood; and 2) all specific requirements for the individual Conditional Use will be met; and 3) satisfactory provisions have been made concerning CU-PL20180002327; BENTON RD — COMMUNICATION TOWER Page 6 of 10 March 10, 2021 Packet Pg. 45 8.A.1 the following matters, where applicable: 1. Section 2.03.08.A.4.(3).(a), of the LDC permits conditional uses in the RFMUD-Sending zoning district. The requested use for an essential service telecommunications tower is allowed as conditional uses in the RFMUD Sending zoning district, subject to the standards and procedures established in section 10.08.00, conditional uses procedures, of the LDC. The tower qualifies as an essential service tower due to each service provider utilizing the tower is required by the federal government to provide for E-911 service. It should be noted that for FY2016/17 wireless calls were 78 percent of the total 911 calls and FY 2017/18 wireless calls were 80 percent of the total 911 calls. 2. Consistency with the Land Development Code (LDC) and the Growth Management Plan (GMP). This request is consistent with the Growth Management Plan (GMP) and as a conditional use that does not permit deviations from the LDC, this project will be in compliance with the applicable provisions of the Land Development Code (LDC). 3. Ingress and egress to the property and proposed structures thereon, with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe. Ingress and egress to the subject property would be limited to access easement on the eastern edge of the parent parcel off Benton Road. The application indicates that approximately one trip per month will be associated with each tower position for a total of up to 4 monthly trips if the full capacity of the tower is realized. The site compound will be required to provide for two parking spaces within the access drive. 4. The effect the Conditional Use would have on neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor effects. The tower is not anticipated to create noise, odor, or glare. The tower will be required to be illuminated to the minimum amount required to satisfy FAA safety regulations, which will be red at night. The tower is anticipated to have a positive economic effect for the surrounding area with improved wireless communication in the area, which not only positively affect economic opportunities, but also increase safety within the area with improved coverage and call stability related emergency situations. The applicant has provided documentation that in fiscal year 17/18, that 80 percent of all 911 calls received by the Collier County Sheriff's Office arrived via wireless phones. 5. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district. The proposed setbacks for the tower will exceed the required 110-foot — One half of the tower height setback required by Section 5.05.09. The projected fall zone radius for the tower is CU-PL20180002327; BENTON RD — COMMUNICATION TOWER Page 7 of 10 March 10, 2021 Packet Pg. 46 8.A.1 completely contained within the boundaries of the parent parcel. The project is proposing to a preserve of +4.50 acers satisfying the 90 percent preserve requirement for lands zoning RFMUO-Sending. This set aside will allow for the parcel to have a similar characteristic to the surrounding undeveloped parcels. Additionally, the tower will only require limited trips, estimated at 1 trip per carrier or tower position per month. This limited interaction will ensure compatibility with the surrounding properties. Based on the above findings, this conditional use should, with stipulations as outlined in this staff report should be recommended for approval. ENVIRONMENTAL ADVISORY COUNCIL (EAC) RECOMMENDATION: This project does require Environmental Advisor Council (EAC) review, as this project does meet the EAC scope of land development project reviews as identified in Section 2-1193 of the Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances. Specifically, the project is located within the Rural Fringe Mixed -Use District Sending Lands. Environmental Planning staff recommends approval of the proposed petition. JULY 10, 2019 NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING (NIM): The applicant conducted the NIM on July 10, 2019, at VFW located at 13131 Collier Blvd. The meeting commenced at approximately 5:30 p.m. and ended at 6:03 p.m. The applicant's agent explained the request for the conditional use. Mattaniah Jahn, representative of Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC, gave a presentation and answered questions from attendees. Ms. Jahn gave a review of the proposed communications tower. Verizon Wireless is requesting to relocate from an existing tower to the northwest of the subject property to a new site. Verizon will be going on this new tower with modern specifications. Ms. Jahn then gave tower specifics which will have required landscaping. After the presentation of the petition ended, the meeting was opened to questions and answers to the public in which many issues and concerns were discussed such as: • Proposed tower location and construction • Infringing on resident's property rights • Tower intruding into farmlands and private property • Environmental and landscaping concerns • Road maintenance and existing driveways • Egress/Ingress onto Benton Road • Clearing trees • The road to the proposed tower is unstable • Trucks damaging Benton Road • Potential for residents living within an antennae farm • No need for Verizon to build another tower when they are already on an existing tower • Cancer risks A copy of the NIM materials are included in Attachment G. CU-PL20180002327; BENTON RD — COMMUNICATION TOWER Page 8 of 10 March 10, 2021 Packet Pg. 47 8.A.1 NOVEMBER 23, 2020 NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING (NIM): Because this petition had exceeded the one-year anniversary date of the first NIM, the agent was required to hold a second NIM. The agent conducted the second NIM on November 23, 2020, at Springhill Suites located at 3798 White Lake Blvd. The meeting commenced at approximately 5:30 p.m. and ended at 6:22 p.m. The applicant's agent, Mattaniah Jahn, gave an introduction of her team and county staff. The agent then gave a PowerPoint presentation. Ms. Jahn explained that Verizon is currently on the Alpine tower located to the northwest of the proposed new tower off Benton Rd. Verizon is relocating onto this new tower and will be the anchor carrier. There will be an additional three spaces available on this new tower to the open market. Ms. Jahn then explained that the driveway was relocated to avoid the north south portion of Benton Rd which is sandy. Ms. Jahn then explained the easement issues and the new relocated driveway. The meeting was then opened to the attendees and many issues and concerns were discussed such as: • Easements on Benton Rd • Fall zone radius • Road maintenance for Benton Rd • Animal safety and litigation of endangered species • Additional carriers on the new tower • Transfer Development Rights off the property • Oil rights • FP&L power poles and upgrades • The Benton Rd tower is not needed as there is plenty of capacity on the existing Alpine tower • Radiation effects A copy of the NIM materials are included in Attachment H. COUNTY ATTORNEY OFFICE REVIEW: The County Attorney Office has reviewed the staff report for PL20180002327 on February 24, 2021 and March 3, 2021. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) approve Petition CU- 20180002327; Benton Road — Communication Tower; subject to the following conditions: 1. The Benton Road — Communication Tower Conditional Use, shall be limited to that which is depicted on the "Benton Road Relo (Naples Park) Drawings — Revised 01-04-21," prepared by SMW Engineering Group, Inc. Attachments: A) Proposed Resolution B) Unrecorded lease agreement C) FLUE Consistency Review dated 12-22-20 D) Ordinance 2019-08 E) FWS Consultation CU-PL20180002327; BENTON RD — COMMUNICATION TOWER Page 9 of 10 March 10, 2021 Packet Pg. 48 8.A.1 F) 47 USC 332, prohibition language on page 4 G) NIM 7-10-19 H) NIM 11-23-20 I) Opposition Letters J) Hybrid Hearing Waiver K) Application -Backup Materials L) Hearing Property Signs M) Access & Utilities Easement Kuszlyk (Recorded) N) Public Access Utilities Easement Beddoe (Recorded) CU-PL20180002327; BENTON RD — COMMUNICATION TOWER Page 10 of 10 March 10, 2021 Packet Pg. 49 8.A.2 RESOLUTION NO.2021- A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA PROVIDING FOR THE ESTABLISHMENT OF A CONDITIONAL USE TO ALLOW A COMMUNICATIONS TOWER ON LANDS ZONED RURAL AGRICULTURAL (A) WITHIN THE MOBILE HOME OVERLAY (MHO) AND DESIGNATED RURAL FRINGE MIXED USE -SENDING LANDS WITHIN THE NATURAL RESOURCE PROTECTION AREA OVERLAY AND NORTH BELLE MEADE OVERLAY IN THE COLLIER COUNTY GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN PURSUANT TO SECTIONS 2.01.03.G.4.a AND 2.03.08.A.4.a(3)(a) OF THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE ON .95f ACRES OF A 5.0+/- ACRE TRACT LOCATED ON THE EAST SIDE OF THE NORTH- c r SOUTH EXTENSION OF BENTON ROAD, IN SECTION 25, TOWNSHIP 49 SOUTH, RANGE 27 EAST, COLLIER 00 COUNTY, FLORIDA. (PL20180002327) 00 00 r WHEREAS, the Legislature of the State of Florida in Chapter 67-1246, Laws of Florida, and Chapter 125, Florida Statutes, has conferred on Collier County the power to establish, coordinate and enforce zoning and such business regulations as are necessary for the protection of the public; and WHEREAS, the County pursuant thereto has adopted a Land Development Code (Ordinance No. 2004-41, as amended) which includes a Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance establishing regulations for the zoning of particular geographic divisions of the County, among which is the granting of Conditional Uses; and WHEREAS, the Board of Zoning Appeals (Board), being the duly appointed and constituted planning board for the area hereby affected, has held a public hearing after notice as in said regulations made and provided, and has considered the advisability of a Conditional Use to allow a communications tower on lands zoned Rural Agricultural (A) within the Mobile Home Overlay (MHO) and designated Rural Fringe Mixed Use -Sending Lands within the Natural Resource Protection Area Overlay and North Belle Meade Overlay in the Collier County Growth Management Plan pursuant to sections 2.01.03.G.4.a and 2.03.08.A.4.a(3)(a) of the Collier County Land Development Code on the property hereinafter described, and the Collier County Planning Commission has made findings that the granting of the Conditional Use will not adversely affect the public interest and the specific requirements governing the Conditional Use have been met and that satisfactory provision and arrangement have been made concerning all applicable matters required by said regulations and in accordance with Subsection 10.08.00.D. of the Land Development Code; and [I 9-CPS-0 1858/1618629/ 1 ] 191 Capital Naples Park CT / PL20180002327 4/1/21 Page 1 of 2 Packet Pg. 50 8.A.2 WHEREAS, all interested parties have been given opportunity to be heard by this Board in a public meeting assembled and the Board having considered all matters presented. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA that: Petition Number PL20180002327 filed by Capital Telecon Holdings, LLC, with respect to the property hereinafter described in Exhibit A, be and the same is hereby approved for a Conditional Use to allow a communications tower on lands zoned Rural Agricultural (A) within the Mobile Home Overlay (MHO) and designated Rural Fringe Mixed Use -Sending Lands within the Natural Resource Protection Area Overlay and North Belle Meade Overlay in the Collier County Growth Management Plan pursuant to Sections 2.01.03.G.4.a and 2.03.08.A.4.a(3)(a) of the Collier County Land Development Code, in accordance with the Conceptual Site Plan described in Exhibit B, and subject to the conditions in Exhibit C. Exhibits A, B, and C are attached hereto and incorporated herein by reference. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Resolution be recorded in the minutes of this This Resolution adopted after motion, second, and super -majority vote, this day of , 2021. ATTEST: BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS CRYSTAL K. KINZEL, CLERK COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA am , Deputy Clerk Approved as to form and legality: Heidi Ashton-Cicko Managing Assistant County Attorney Attachments: Exhibit A - Legal Description Exhibit B - Conceptual Site Plan Exhibit C - Conditions of Approval [I 9-CPS-0 1858/1618629/1 ] 191 Capital Naples Park CT / PL20180002327 4/1/21 Page 2 of 2 Penny Taylor, Chairman T co 00 Packet Pg. 51 8.A.2 EXHIBIT A Project Name: PL20180002327 Benton Road Relo Total Acreage: 0.94 Acres PARENT TRACT: (TITLE) Situated in the County of Collier, State of Florida Tract 122, Floridian Farm Sites, According to Map or Plat thereof as recorded in Plat Book 4, Page 33, Public Records of Collier County, Florida. 60' X 60' LEASE AREA: (AS SURVEYED) E An lease area being a portion of Tafara Lodge, LLC, A Florida Limited Liability Company tract o described as Tract 122 in Plat Book 4, Page 33 recorded in the Public Records Office in Collier County, Florida situated in the Northwest 1/4 of Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East in said County and being more particularly described as follows; COMMENCE at a 5/8" rebar found marking the Southwest corner of said Tract 122; Thence o along West line of said Tract 122, N 00°52'46" E a distance of 122.87 feet to a point; Thence leaving said West line, N 90°00'00" E a distance of 100.00 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING; m Thence N 00°00'00" W a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 90000'00" E aeo co distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence S 00100'00" E a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 90°00'00" W a distance of 60.00 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING. Containing 3,600 square feet (0.08 acres) of land more or less. N INGRESS/EGRESS AND UTILITY EASEMENT "A": (AS SURVEYED An easement being a portion of Tafara Lodge, LLC, A Florida Limited Liability Company tract described as Tract 122 in Plat Book 4, Page 33 recorded in the Public Records Office in Collier County, Florida situated in the Northwest 1/4 of Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East in said County and being more particularly described as follows; COMMENCE at a 5/8" rebar found marking the Southwest corner of said Tract 122; Thence along said West line of said Tract 122, N 00052,46" E a distance of 122.87 feet to a point; Thence leaving said West line, N 90100'00" E a distance of 100.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 00°00'00" W a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar and the POINT OF BEGINNING; Thence N 00°00'00" W a distance of 20.00 feet to a point; Thence N 90°00'00" E a distance of 238.01 feet to a point on the East line of said Tract 122; Thence along said East line, S 00°20'55" W a distance of 20.00 feet to a point; Thence leaving said East line, N 90°00'00" W a distance of 177.89 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 90°00'00" W a distance of 60.00 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING. Containing 4,759.00 square feet (0.11 acres) of land more or less. INGRESS/EGRESS AND UTILITY EASEMENT "B": (AS SURVEYED) An easement being a portion of Tafara Lodge, LLC, A Florida Limited Liability Company tract described as Tract 119 in Plat Book 4, Page 33 recorded in the Public Records Office in Collier County, Florida situated in the Northwest 1/4 of Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East in said County and being more particularly described as follows; COMMENCE at a 5/8" rebar found marking the Southwest corner of Tract 122 in Plat Book 4, 2/ 18/2021 Page 1 of 3 Packet Pg. 52 8.A.2 EXHIBIT A Page 33; Thence along said West line of said Tract 122, N 00°52'46" E a distance of 122.87 feet to a point; Thence leaving said West line, N 90°00'00" E a distance of 100.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 00°00'00" W a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 00°00'00" W a distance of 20.00 feet to a point; Thence N 90°00'00" E a distance of 238.01 feet to a point on the East line of said Tract 122 and the POINT OF BEGINNING; Thence N 90°00'00" E a distance of 5.33 feet to a point; Thence N 00°43'54" E a distance of 446.61 feet to a point on the North line of said Tract 119; Thence along said North line, S 88°02'49" E a distance of 20.00 feet to a point; Thence leaving said North line, S 00°43'54" W a distance of 465.93 feet to a point; Thence N 90°00'00" W a distance of 25.20 feet to a point; Thence N 00°20'55" E a distance of 40.00 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING. Containing 9,538.51 square feet (0.22 acres) of land more or less.. INGRESS/EGRESS AND UTILITY EASEMENT "C": (AS SURVEYED An easement being a portion of Tafara Lodge, LLC, A Florida Limited Liability Company tract c described as Tract 120 in Plat Book 4, Page 33 recorded in the Public Records Office in Collier W County, Florida situated in the Northwest 1/4 of Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East in said County and being more particularly described as follows; m COMMENCE at a 5/8" rebar found marking the Southwest corner of Tract 122 in Plat Book 4, Page 33; Thence along said West line of said Tract 122, N 00°52'46" E a distance of 122.87 feet co to a point; Thence leaving said West line, N 90100'00" E a distance of 100.00 feet to a set 5/8" co rebar; Thence N 00°00'00" W a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 00°00'00" W a distance of 20.00 feet to a point; Thence N 90°00'00" E a distance of 238.01 feet to a point on the East line of said Tract 122; Thence N 90°00'00" E a distance of 5.33 feet to a point; Thence o N 00043154" E a distance of 446.61 feet to a point on the North line of said Tract 119 and the POINT OF BEGINNING; thence N 00°43'54" E a distance of 662.53 feet to a point on the South line of a 30 foot easement as recorded in ORB 1159, Page 1954; Thence along said South line, S 89'16'06" E a distance of a°, 20.00 feet to a point; Thence leaving said South line, S 00°43'54" W a distance of 662.96 feet to a point; Thence N 88002'48" W a distance of 20.00 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING. N Containing 13,253.29 square feet, (0.30 acres) of land more or less. a 30' GUY EASEMENT "A": (AS SURVEYED) An easement being a portion of Tafara Lodge, LLC, A Florida Limited Liability Company tract described as Tract 122 in Plat Book 4, Page 33 recorded in the Public Records Office in Collier County, Florida situated in the Northwest 1/4 of Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East in said County and being more particularly described as follows; COMMENCE at a 5/8" rebar found marking the Southwest corner of said Tract 122; Thence along said West line of said Tract 122, N 00°52'46" E a distance of 122.87 feet to a point; Thence leaving said West line, N 90°00'00" E a distance of 100.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 00°00'00" W a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 90°00'00" E a distance of 12.68 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING of an easement being 30 feet wide and lying 15 feet on each side of the following described centerline; Thence N 30°00'00" W a distance of 101.22 feet to the POINT OF ENDING. Containing 3,078.08 square feet (0.07 acres) of land more or less. 2/18/2021 Page 2 of 3 Packet Pg. 53 8.A.2 EXHIBIT A 30' GUY EASEMENT "B": (AS SURVEYED) An easement being a portion of Tafara Lodge, LLC, A Florida Limited Liability Company tract described as Tract 122 in Plat Book 4, Page 33 recorded in the Public Records Office in Collier County, Florida situated in the Northwest 1/4 of Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East in said County and being more particularly described as follows; COMMENCE at a 5/8" rebar found marking the Southwest corner of said Tract 122; Thence along said West line of said Tract 122, N 00°52'46" E a distance of 122.87 feet to a point; Thence leaving said West line, N 90°00'00" E a distance of 100.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 00°00'00" W a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 90°00'00" E a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence S 00°00'00" E a distance of 30.00 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING of an easement being 30 feet wide and lying 15 feet on each side of the following described centerline; Thence N 90°00'00" E a distance of 106.04 feet to the POINT OF ENDING. Containing 3,180.00 square feet (0.07 acres) of land more or less. 30' GUY EASEMENT "C": (AS SURVEYED) An easement being a portion of Tafara Lodge, LLC, A Florida Limited Liability Company tract described as Tract 122 in Plat Book 4, Page 33 recorded in the Public Records Office in Collier 00 County, Florida situated in the Northwest 1/4 of Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 Eastco co in said County and being more particularly described as follows; COMMENCE at a 5/8" rebar found marking the Southwest corner of said Tract 122; Thence along said West line of said Tract 122, N 00052'46" E a distance of 122.87 feet to a point; cm Thence leaving said West line, N 90°00'00" E a distance of 100.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; CD Thence N 00°00'00" W a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 90°00'00" E a , distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence S 00100'00" E a distance of 60.00 feet to a set o 5/8" rebar; Thence N 90°00'00" W a distance of 47.32 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING of an = easement being 30 feet wide and lying 15 feet on each side of the following described centerline; Thence S 30000'00" W a distance of 101.23 feet to the POINT OF ENDING. Containing 3,059.25 square feet (0.07 acres) of land more or less. y 10' UTILITY EASEMENT: (AS SURVEYED) An lease area being a portion of Tafara Lodge, LLC, A Florida Limited Liability Company tract described as Tract 122 in Plat Book 4, Page 33 recorded in the Public Records Office in Collier County, Florida situated in the Northwest 1/4 of Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East in said County and being more particularly described as follows; COMMENCE at a 5/8" rebar found marking the Southwest corner of said Tract 122; Thence along West line of said Tract 122, N 00°52'46" E a distance of 122.87 feet to a point; Thence leaving said West line, N 90100'00" E a distance of 100.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 00°00'00" W a distance of 55.00 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING of an utility easement being 10 feet wide and lying 5 feet on each side of the following described centerline, Thence N 90°00'00" W a distance of 99.17 feet to a point on the West line of said Tract 122 and the POINT OF ENDING. Containing 991.67 square feet (0.02 acres) of land more or less. 2/ 18/2021 Page 3 of 3 Packet Pg. 54 Z_ D ' O 0 0 p0 N m y Fu_ mN zm; co ANOXZC2- y OfOnj;Op �i/IF� T o- z�oU��g Fd I n11 m�0 y SL"� NZZ_m-IpOz Z D y A ti0� y�0 OG=y OO.D.Om mNN lO�r '^A 9O m0 OmNjO ]1�� D iyN zn A-n ozi� ziam io4v DNS nN Oi�z �OnNOK � O Z z Z Z Z O N O n m p O z F N A h Zp-�m 4Z')�y�v yZm AJ� AO Zn VN pp�� NS O0 DyDyti� yA. uN O�f�m p�00pO- O m m D- m 0 m� N Z Z D O n ZZ �.. NO Az ZOO 00 m0 -z15A z so F N O D � m OA m0 h m y x.p Z��ypy O S p Z Z s Z Z L) O Z ��AZO O ` F n �mm _z. O ^ A m .. UDC G D mK A 9 p O �s O .. Z A O n D - owe N O m m � ; 22 Z fTl 3c o i- Ci a n mN uuu TJ r a � c p�o Wig N C 0 zm r Fq + �88 o wN O . g88� D oo O p Fz NC v D D C S DZs DJiaoC OuN^ zOA>p>DmOO O o� Z<rprmmO mNOnD�NpxinC ONOO'F$O� VAnO ntiz�+vODyp9_m IFy=yyOiOT W-Dr_~N rmm<m<om VZNAF�FmmAi �N�ZNOp <OZr�m NvNyyZnF-g0i z ms mmNmAO�mOsZmZf__y DpA- r ozS Ox m ZlOO imNm OOZmmm pD-$�yom mp mCnn�mo; N-Oim mApmC fZOyzNm�/I ONm W<w D Z D i ; m Om2mUV DnNOAo N-VAi D C 0- CmC ,z O~N O mIAN�1mrSS'Oy^ 2mDNSppS- mOm�oDi _ pm U., �mmO T Olr O -Ni FmA'N O mz CmZNpOmpT < �[ a mzzg O"ANApz O N m a om mnp —Rom g g�-zimx$c OR2V mr2p mg p O p m; Z D O N N pFCyF> g mZ K2Zmm i� m N N p R O y D > ZOg o��; Kq�n�� 'y m p m oC m0 O- m Z m 0 00 - z nKopvo m o ? N mv0yy O op zj<�Do p Z O m A I O K s m m �Noimmaii m 0 N� y� NON O o go z- uNSr'o ZO CnOG]Om �� N g�CCACCC�nn i C � 2 a�1Z�ppo2�m Z ��r�DOoz _ zp N-1 9Sn mn Z- ��Vl�m �VN A A O O n J 0 m y50 �O W A m 1 Z Z < z. >O 2 Z r z (n . g n 8g g N O a:i m _ -� p D V 1-1 l �o 0 D N xDOT. Z m m Z O m m r 2 O O p O jo O N D 0�- m 0 m tt; N A Q O S y C N N O o O O O ti s 9 m Z z z s 70 O a O m Q � � N o N OC = O m cn m Z -a m O O 0 K � n D -n 0 D OZ � r C cn mD O Z _ --A z O m m X 70 O ml 0 CD C_ Z c� Exhibit B co FTI D D O O r O TI Cl)r T v � r Z O � O Z oon CA T /lJ C7 X O CD 0 Oo"J C D O O N D Z D J \/ FTI F- 0 c) m w m z m AA 8 2 6 m Z A A N l/� 1y- O O O < D< 0 O C Z m N; m 2 K� F Z O N m Of2lm C g N OAF O O r m Z m Z A r m A A �_ m Z O O O m Z A O A A j O m A O p O m D IO m 2 2 Z p O O Z A R O A A Z m m A A X D O A D O a 8 Z O A 0 m Z ZZZ A m- AyZC y 0 A C N 0 yy m�n�mmZU)Zm 9 12.Im ,y,a A O O yAmA H S O �Xmzx m O O OTC OOa O O c D r M>Z� m m O COOPyy Off,— m 0 m F 2 A D D Z Z A p N NZD 2mm2 D 8o�1 8 -y O ZO D AA m f m2DZ6. DO s y ; O O D O F 2b y OZ Af O A m UIZO.OF OI. A D O D o A A p2N O O A D O f� O Z y 02 C A A ps�1/I my I I D pCC N O m m ZO m 0 j O Z A p m C Z 2 2 O y O m a m 1 O m O 0 m D A O m m N m mm a UIF O r� O 0 A< 01r A O A V 2 O T yy D Z Z 2 N OA A Z A K O O.N. O m ZD Cp F 9 2 O O N A O �R O Z it j D N r Z m A Z Z A FFFFFFSS p O m f r A A�mO A O S O F Dlr/1 O C ZN P 8 2 O N A y 22%S m O (�) C OAO NTn Omer 2m om�yZ✓� �D�mAOO ZOmmgA>iND AZOZ yU JAC OymO AmN AaON UI ZZOZD aDO> nOSmg CA S'yZ AC Zm>a> < Am Z�m. y MOI No OZtn O 0. Oj NN;;�;Y ODm Z f2r �pAC 9O m 9 OZN �m� G)ti 2 2 KmN AZZ Oy Z a Ulmer 9OZ mna0 O;D AnmA mU;jAO D .2m2 FOmm _y�FNC �Fm AAf/1 �.H BOA'^ Z DNZUI N rA~� a p�2 DmZy Oirai ZS0- 8.R% Dm ppD yA Sim O�� OZFI m m Sr�r1 . �O 2 3; O �-i~ZFOO-1 DmDm D m O > r F2�� Z� +y� A r Symg m A Oyr Sm NApm,y yyH mm� a Am�UI S m? 2 Ag. 0 r -a mFA D � 9 OO N O R m O OaD N r ti mZ m y C Dm �4 1 _Ap NAm nZ� A O Z C m A nOn m ADA n Z D N O D D m m O Z 0 _LZ�ZO A r O m O 0 N m C Z m r 2 Z^ Ulm -A D 1-m'! y O O r D r r N p O N A_ Z N A g U D r r F m m s 2 m y Z m O O N C j m m0 A. A y O 2_ Z O �y�y11 -mil m 2 9 m O>> ti Z Z 2 A O Za, A O I 9 ti Z < O = y mm0 -� AACO m Af�1..0,y il m A oOm K m K o~y r yN m m Am Z F m ym A Z m r O 8 2 << O Z C O m0�� n a N1/)mp2 m y m y 8 yy O Z- A .-. N UlZ 2ymyyy -Di C m A Q. 11252.0 < N O C Z 8 z.>S 2Xp7ti2y yytm, Z y 0 Am- m<r8 vAi D O y ti $Nf2.lm N N Z 2 , �..z y j A 0 2- 2 y O <Z m' 5 y N N< yZ N m O O O m z mN O Z O�J' m m m mrmi Nrt102m D Z V NA 2 0 A F N ZS m 2 �rn0ry K Op a m 0 ;�D Ns A a Osy nANO A m A S Z X m sy OCR ZZOm FA O 9 y y - ZO y D Am>� " _ m mn p `L 9 8p p ODA K O g O m m OOZ�K m.p m m A 0 D Cpp^o m Z �Im/Im OmpR 9 FtC'1~ OmD<O y Z 2 D m �- O Z m�lUn1 O Or Z�ZA � Om = m O 2r m y m �K 2 2 C C Z SOOm m A 0D N Z D m DN 2 m02 m O D - nmA 1mD OA m0>�*mp O_OD�DZm>> DOm, pD O.O (2(]] DNO S-I OOOZn>m>2 ~>> Op8 mmZ� m� zz;m AP. -I �ZN OOx9p On 20 py0y Z��>>11 DVI .. n2.. �m- mrm Z F FNm yyOcy 2SS 9 ZA 20 zDa OmrZ `2 A�OD pa A�Za r O mm O N DOO f � D m m 0 m A m a N 0 Opyy O a�a < CO N N Z Z N m m Z 2 0 0...o Z A Z A Z Z S GD - O A O O !�- ZO N I O OOM D Z m O o m 01N 2 8 O y T 2 O EayA x s -iZ A m Z m>Z y OCy p A m mZ C A~ 2 m N O; Z A 8 0 Z 8 p A p p 2 - Z i A; Z Z m D [C[]] O KQ p Ap A A�< n >> 0 Z mZyp p ti r o~ < m =.� v mv r t m m 2 ti a Z - 2 O Z $r O Y OF. ORt H y mm F Zy<= 0~ <C�OZZD y 2 mNN O p ODti 2 y O m N m Q ZOOD m m y; n m m pNI I y t y ZOmm Z Om m O N Z p m O oO m�nm Fm y n m N�< n,-NN o y a A pS �y2 A N N 905 y11z < m" O w mA Ngmo81n ; Oy m A Z c .v`c"'�ys O< 2 O C a m $0 ~ H O oA i z< F S F 69011 Z A abm ¢ Z Z Gi O O G, z > 2 O m m Wn A A; Z~ Z Ulm 2 yy 2 Z m o ZO A 29Z O Z ., m p 0 p-I O L y�y A 2KZ ^ Al y N O y N p O D -M,R F 96 Z < 2 82 2 2 D m m m y NIZ;n2�Uy,fC i A< Z m m NZD Z x A O- 81M G; D g A L D yal,r (>�am ti a A Am N R A m mN� Z O _p �N ZN Z 8 D y Z D - ZmO p� U� y 2 DA O Nm O r 0 m m N 2 mZ a ZD �Om Dr CAA 4GZ�, vgimmrNai �yA mZyvon OND mC S'0 m �g OZti Am ;Om �yA A�� y NC Ay mI.A2 po ANAL in A Z;90 mz ='i F Dm.a �A_ r��-zng2�A� N O m a N N Q m Z r n C < m Zyy m D i F ti ; A m y O O Z A O Zyy FtO D O ~O N y m n m Z Z Z iA ti mnl�^n9n O m p O mD r C; pA m S C Z N O D PU� Z D m Z O 60 O< m Z N m A y Z Z O C m m A O a N m O Omm O Z< Z yy Z 2 Z m O p ME 2Ay �U1 p UjN yl y2 9�KAO00 N A8y SNZ y2> pCim20 Zm 2-11ynn C.Z;Z UIC m C n�m0� ;� 2 NCA>Z> O p X 1� m mO D2<Sm nVIN<N O02 12n Zpm NgmNN mUl :ADD Sm0 2LZS Z�<N mm <�r m m12.10 mO>yZpyZA m y> 2000Na,OAm 2ZyOm Ztim Z m NOm OZ m ON mpm m Pnm 0 =O y D I 8o<\Aro<�Aa1 m m mACA Om Sm�A3D0 NUc=_ Am ? 8A8Z(mo 2 y y1 C0 Og p ;Z �C)ZO r P A2 m� Z 2 Z I'M _ ZA , Z � O O m0 AU AD r O-Om op II r 1. m O Z C A OA AF �L D O m m Oy>AD 10 mAD O ��O-mZ mpCO Zm /I N C Om m C C O ANpNy D MIAcyC my Z I OymA� m 200m ^ A ym Cy3 g NmND m o rNp0pB mC m N mFO. �``"timp��DrAfm Z. om n Z a m �O On� P $NNzym�02- Nm�OA0mNCOCSa) 2-aAOaN_Cr,�e m Z �ZmNUOr NzZz amp C nn N T s mS %Z. x Z. m m < AoA o OO25 pm 4 PO yAsZO1 Z1m<V O m y m2Z Z Am y Z 2 D O m yZ N Zy ZAZ OA Z 0$ ANyy /OZOfn Z O0NAr m F O I. O 2 D N ?A O OOZ� y mO 2 M-rO m r m m A O r yp y zw y 2 Z O 0 m mF m oFC ZoA C Z O Am �FO OU0 o %m FA(O2OOOp ZS O y h yO ~ A O mAS ZA A0 N O . imO OOZm 8 D APy OG O ymO Z m OAm - N r D O 28 2 Z mF 2 C5y O ZA y mLC O m mA .n OZ m r0pD CpA ma2m Om ZO OZ Z 04 F p m p D O O Zp2 S=y2D _-�mZmOmaO AODOO DA Z 2 ti Cp O S Z z m O O Z Z m Z i2 A AN ym 5A V O ~ A C O A m'. Nm2Z yNO "m mp m D D - O y Z Z. FArxOZ. ti O- A 0 O a Z U. j m 2 y OZA m O.m O Z I A,or 8 a N ZO ZF S m Z O1-A N 1. O NA p m ;O Zm A m2 2 CO ryy a~ ZZ 8 m F. N< ' Z yy z N 0 g m F z %8 NZ8 m A 0. nA C O; D O Z 8 m p zS K2D D O< Z1. % O N G- A O 0 Z Z m0 m A y2A mZ O m'�n P c c z 0 za Z 0m O T A mON ZymO Am�I IT Z mm D . mZO my 2 O zD m mOA m O I ?I N iFoZ, ilI 8.A.2 _fTl �ym' O�yyO-1a-1AmOmNaNAti O Z02ASmZ-D('Im 2 � aAONNONmCnnym�ym N �A ` ' p i yo �n�i A Y� T z Z < D O "r N v y "-zzAa�m J o.I F>n,' m_ <�A S r IV q m . f gAo�: m Nla G� r nmasg U) zAamm a<y A - An NO "a� ` Y N-y .r7N �$ � o> Z g .N. O Sig 8> 3Y D� a �morDAiog�NCApoi�^_ mm �cooepo 8 Woo furl � m mf>o10 k voN Hm O`mf i1 �_ 9 Dz�im� �i 3 i N N o Packet Pg. 56 �O pxm y' oZ 5mm oNF ! D=*, 3r 8 :.. I�YY/�� Asp ^ — < 00 00 m D D zzoz V) OoD om1 OI ��oOm - >-ZD' F D�_{po DO - rO � m S > C Z U O z NKO m o AC m �*v>A ayO D omD f Z O o <OD Z«A Z oop Z y2C A ANmN D> N 2 � m > o am mm 0 S N Z y0 Z n Z A O = m m A O m y 2 9 o Z lino m Z < N r�i �iNo� m Z zx�n or>n A O z DN 00 Apo Oo� A$> '.m4 ioym v �z OOm'y�� O m m Z O r G. >$� nm FANy�o a "sgm�m 2 z N 0 A Z Z n O pCA C - g D Z n Z vmA > N Om; C mm� Q m S~ �i!^m�Q DO m r N N A N m 0 o r;O2m2ti C Z F 9 m m O N Z A> O D r > A >1 O A m y y 2 D O Hz tiDA 3C0 I; uAim ZZT'�10/1 OAN D- ��O N-IIm +�z 55 CANmZZA N;OA�OS > Z m O 0 N A ? O m A r OAS y; m y� D O Zq. N m ym0 N 2 oyF2� D2 Zm*~rZC O O 1 0Dy O 0 y ,Cy m2 >= IA zm <aZNG VO tiNm2r"�y K > AD OI�m ZO A-_Z�ZMF� DO <A��S A> m ryy C A DD A/1 F0> N]1 NAD mZ mrAIA yyA < ZC>�OP OmmNAm Z X Z O > O �Zm Zm > x Z C N m D 0. Z O y 2 N p m m ig2 O Z Z y Z aog �? O A 1 r mg soAo zo m0 mO�Zi1DN <- Z mm O A 4� Z . N O O N Z O ;�zcAoc D m r Z m r F N 0 o O z N n AjD iy/1 NZ1 jAZ N0., Z ;Oy mZC00 nN g()pOC pm m m mz yAN >0 11,0 ND _ O A - 2^ T<O<� m m4l l-Oo/IZC l y DOm N� A O m D> D Sti H mA O m O O Z D CgZ> m 2 1~Z Cmm>N ;m Z > S1 mm r0 CC > O O N K yZi mm A S K n A A> A r g m Z Z O< m O Zy O Z Z O VI O I T p 0 y Z O T Z m > D r y D O o m < O D; m 0 m O Z O m A A o < Z D 9 Z z l^z m z moA o:5 ym n<o Fo m Nk �0 a som 2O Z<ZN- NZ >> OZm nr O O oN0 NN ps oo r5i r�sNOZ Zm mmI MO O OK m <K Zm N-00 A� Z m Z Aym - M. 8^ m 0 I y ~O~ NsO Amp Z m m N0 �- M Zp C m n S Ar-b mIm OD C Cry >A ZOO Z<~ O D Z K yN O v N C m 0 AA ZO m�ti Dr m mom rZ m^ ON m�0 me SN Arm �V Dm Z� O g� o9� n > ODO>o mmr� Am Nmo �v N D y O A my0 Om0 NSA 00> zmU� �A m> WN �fC/IC ra 010 rl� NA f OC 0 OOP 22 F> O 0Nx ��r5 Nrr �> m m or1m" mzm > o K=> A ti giN yYz y C o SS m t/i D A O p > Z OOm oz Z O O< Zm S m mm D Z Z A - m N 2 A m O mm r0 OO r0 Mrm OI> zm Zy; zo Ncs zo Sm 00-A �z Or m> om i N iA K o AAZ 30 AO IN/IN =y ZO F z c>m>� ~ m Z » <� N O timo ai m C C O< o Z N O �1 C y m NAS Z. m Om �Om KS Am Om Km Um100 00 KO K ~ y0 O m 0 AN H S<A DDm .. CQ >n gm N0 Z 2 N -Z-11N p N C t ppZ A N Z^ 2 0 DZ Cp A A D Z mDm A� Z Mo. o Z m< mn �p 0. N o Ay > ADO 9N R., Z 2. n 9v y ym 2 Z-1m mil Z^ Of m Zp D O C_ N imp A A DOm ry N Z _O j a A A S m y ~1 y N >- Z 0 _ r > F O N m - 2 m2 0 y ON z 00. Mo OO 9rm 05, N= m mn y mmm >m P zy Z x m ~ "ZO Z O O C CZ 2 m 2 D 2 p 0 N N m O,Im O ;Ag _ oK m �> Ol ;�o px C 12 r Z N m Z AZ O.pO Z m A Al C m C y0 i C ; m O m m y y A K - Z}�n ~ > O OyCIN ZA *>zo �KC .1 g O > Ao> m r0 OZ m M. ASO � 01 Clt iA0 W N 8.A.2 W ; 0.20=gmmmomN�NmiamN y� o = Nod a _rT1 �zozN 'IAc'bi�a goI a g � g rT1 Z? p 1"omm oo oN-c-y>oi-mcim w��C 2z G) O Aoq U) 0 m Z4Amm�nw�vcrA<zZ. N z "Tt Soa O mAmAz Yz `�rmooz;Nx 0 8 R v O �Ao V D m J Om �p ysm 0p~N otiCmfZO"NOm >ZOoZmyZzOipAmzm< 0 opoo'> ;ouPi _ eFP =O 0Packet Pg.57 m N A 'Vi' y A N y C A o c O I.1 p" 2 S x A M y r m m� m v I O g g .� g 00 I ` x N o _ m om �v aCo ' ,. o 0 0 o m W G N o Z Z o o Z o- S n 0 0 0 0 Oc O , 0 0 9 p O, 0 0 0 LOmI v suinyg ;$�y �no '_� cm o� 050 a o �m > Ng pp O pp pzp Arai OC A 02m0 DSZA pOpn D;Ap AOOFA�Z N C - A1 m/� " y y A y C A " OQ D;C yAD-m CAS- �A4j_ Am KCO C AOr y �OD1P1ww" �AOpn D10�O `O'4 50 om o <RI O m�I 0 C�jO O" \z. zN CDAC Z04 Cm31+ N N O ZOJ U! 1 O W N tNp• rzi W O O 0• IOZO �zmro DDm mrI -jo >'�gO �, �, o o ; o: b, b "o o b C jo ZpON OAb;AO Om IF v V H � M v v M N v V Ih FFFC mz. I;y" Cm Op min OZ0 Z < Cm 02� Np Z� z� Z�Z. xT 010 k40, 0o i• ti+s z0 K f oomo r; o �Sol. =IN �zI c c r .t h +`+, '�.,P,� � y5.c :� �^ 3,�'�k � ' ; Y y ,* ♦ +.,, �arr} � c� ZZ ZZ _ }R��,. .. rk"5,;. ♦ "'IK R .�9..y*e f D 0 z 0 ✓ Y z.. yy IDO IDO r09 mm ZOO 'C f'>>O Iffyy jOA Dp >�za DEz' m;. O Oz0 9 f A Om� AOAn DON O� Cm0 O mz CA"_ CA"_ QO "AG z2 c CyyTO riCyy�iO �FNO zyp0 o0 IODOWNi IODN O OG Z� N "'. ASOa AAOOo> SZO C" Z�>O �1 D� DGO]" yDmm w0 N y�•j r' m ." n?F� FZm D O� A N '{�: .. ,.. c�m0 s `9R 200i$y4+.i4..DOZE OZ Off' ZZ ti Ap> 2 Z mOy O 4. pDyT AO z20 NNm m (� >- N tt, O N Z<� �m y� 0 n-O 0 O Z 'ORH o y min N Y D D Z N Z z_ 100 1110 O Z O 0 Cz. mZ cIDZ, m o0 Am �Opn ODD "i D �N D OODCA0 00.omo 'a- I Km - r0 •'00r19 ...-. yCVO �Apr> DIO I.Im Am( NS<AN OA -0'' ;D ZTOm A;AO AZ mNn 7goro Hm Aa£ of ozl v�oiv y 0 �N mxc� m g c sc m z o�o NNC10n �� iy-°S ac aSma•Im'".I AA SZ'� �� ,orS ��mg �I`>g o y >�z> Psi z zz ziFm mzo '§O Ao2 �Gn min cN0 0 Z NomN -i Nmb A I z Z2 N '�Z0t1 AAA p0 �0 _ www j 10� W ; OA OSCm TZy L�DE'im�cS N N v _ITl VTO�(N AanZ.. nN yy Z o NI�1 OOm�m EJOAO S 6 2 s DOommSmc'zm�AN iS m�+�� s o �' iN a z4m c�mu�-e nx mm D R>^ •`�. r Z X m m m £ fig N<m�ge >9 oogyoo.--u o sY D R ys>zynm MRAo .ZJ A O OAO NO Sin mm�pIRO^o Fi T. Im,1 a�< oimyxb>� 0 �r nmS' �^_m yFaA0 8 io 7^03 8.A.2 Packet Pg. 58 \ 0- m ® ®G�\ §_ }§qz \§ ;( / � , -pr 2 §]7«§ \\} \\ | )6 (PRESERVE , B ( � / Oj )) k! � f »� \\\\ � B.A.2 0 \/ |/e \§\ \)k \�) � � ..cJ��,2222 .�....... �....... ) -2. SETBACK) .. . ` .cPO± mom`/zz2zz. � �.`.`.`.`.`,`.`. .` `` �� ....... ..... . . .` ___ — — — — — — — — — — — — — — ; § , ) � § !~ \ , , � l;: �*`;z �m;§§ ~�* ao " ))��9�`!, GGo ` o §mm:�}\!&r§�\�4RR4�/mOU ;es, §§eese to;GAG ;w !§�� ;� �qlE§§ ;§ 0q!/§§ °° )$ ,o t 2,q 2!� \;m �kk((\/�zi -C c§°`§ ncsae �Q)T n&Gae a G7e6= -- — -- — -- — --�-- I 8.A.2 I i�lis — is —r is eS — es — J' T 's — es —is r " —is —is ------}y 2'-0" Co n O m zZ o a D O O p e Z C) C v z o� A$ m 0 9 N o £ b �D a A mo m sY y > Z vm 0 60'-0* pp yC f 9 2 O OI.pi0 OA p cOo S NO Of c A m O m A'° O m O m 0_ NNy �nm ti a po L 0Amz � a _ pmm z o y' p m N � m �9�11tiAm0 rl/9N�-� pmmjy Gl DG)m� I �0 a z namza"rn��z� ? r _ _• •� Pr`ammupp cpi."Wan o ,m T� J>=" • �-aonoolno� FAAdz O c Fi oln m 8R. m35 oimyAiz O v�f mns D_ p u 3r 8 e A Im (7) O u--------------------1 O C Z y S � ^60 X ADm N S F SF — SF SF ODO ^00 <0 ^p0' OZO NO O.O nWip mn�Q {aQA OD N. N> ODm pDy r�0 'ip0p .'�D O o r O O O A�Oc AO AYd G N�pgw oAaNO00 WD CI nwi zp n o n o; JD Z m z nzm ny p.. - N M II• N N o 8o o r z m N C N N Z o A cn O m n -< T � T7 TI — SF — SF — SF SF — SF I zo �� 1 �z� z$ I N O p A I 1.FAIN N 'o. �o Nmgo f.Mm I _ d N A O c p Z Z O p W y/ =Rug8 _ 3oo`m,m ZZ. A X I I I II >mmAp Am I I � I _ I I I I1 I I I i I I 1� I I II I I I I I I 1 I I I Cl LO r c.i 3 E O m O d' O w� W m Co Co Packet Pg. 60 1 n CA u0 0 Z I A g 0 0 aim o y �� gm.. 7j z y=' ayN II 112 om0 � � gmg� a�,N $Nz� o > Nn�N � �7z�mmy0. o >� m� �zsk�e aN Om�ym ;a �yymym 0� I'inA 0mAZ. �mzn�oo xNxmmmr O XJm OIOAVQ�O �y�r / r 1 1 II 1 \ \ / 1 \ v 0 \` 1 1 \\ \ \\ \ F \ A o 1 \ \ 1 1 1 \ r \ \ 1 �1 1 1 1 A A �U O y y D.A9 oA y1 aaL O O O O O .0 D O O 0� O O O ROM Z" 24 Z" O A m O MG y O p A O p m p m p c m m y m < ` 7II g m mm Z II 'tl O O II O O D p D N A N F p A 8 A 0. O m I n IO p p 10N O O MZ HI Mz HD �I m p2 8Z, r r r r s D z N N J �00 AADC < mOm m m A m O O C AOF 0 x0 N"m A A O$ A O O O Sm m0 p� 0 n-i i "m no Nic cl < A A s Z F ozzz k D N O W Hf ZOtip-1 M^"MTlC�rO?OrZZUI—om�- 5S :• �$n$ympi�n�NzG o D0 00 zm'fm_ `-zz ag O n ruz L. vau a�g`m-l�mociz;u'xb rod Y� • 3gga�.R Z Sk D �mom00�6AmOo" A z;6"20 vo ems � "�f �Ao I I �'F�" ;r P .2z Packet Pg. 61 T— oo co r 8.A.2 m z n m n 7 m m I'� D m D z n m m z m 0 D U) G n 0 D m 0 m D r RnMg'lilt t°� e in s N n s x g�� 3 �4 s8 s 8 - o v m . c� LO r o' w i i i � e��Q o• t --- i is m v ^m• � o rt • Y 8 0 X II 1 I Q n$ 0 �=o mom 'CA m ysm y I ZA S V � i LAOZf/lOm+�i-�i 4]DCYm Serf/ yk, � Y - � min A�tY�iFly � � 0 _ N$8o goo > c OZ g [ zNm� ym_AnrAn�„�zc 0 $ Rn r hoc. cN��Ni.:;� m HA ' ■ $ �F� $:�$$�;a m ��mm �nu�Nmi »gym mom/ •a� ° $�`� �$ r r S$ D �momog�_�'moA�<zmN 0-mazo -.m ` sAr.i z1 N000_Ao ^oNmm m im�mNloo z� m myAg� z.m N 3< of g r •, �mS' N msF?__o 2r z� i P Y=r's qao 0 41 .N* '� i u Packet Pg. 62 3 0 0 v 0 V 0 0 M� W r oo co r c N �� - A �y mop 2 m ��mqu; op �3F v0 y ftl r�i Zym i 0-ip �m o�� rein �" mmF O mm �� "- w pv m z N m 5 o m ZAmA�ZZ o1D� m my2 moa ZND zzF n O DO oa Oa �� NC?Nm �p zymio D r m yN mm m<.Q;'" D ozs� Snpmom nzv zmA �v A? z z iN z om O 0 5 o v fTl O r Dm0 ;cz>iA omy Rm." .DAmZ"D mCx�A 'p�,yW—N�A zOA 1m Z ZQ Oa> -yU FDma ��>OO Zx m0xA O 2o 001 om8o0 D8.m omm Cl) oZA T F5W4�3 O pm / NNAO G �2 O ? D OR4A m �Ao was Ny m 00CU O 0 \ i2moA "�zmn m m ;} cn m D O O 00 nmzy An Sc �p� m`Om ;K N ��\ O O \ AyO \\00 O 00 pVlOm� mA-0 iFo ZtA/.2 i sm O oAma- O Ng> mp A oy FrD of mew aln N O O 00 :.00 Dxs`^'A ox'gzc - a Fi A -DI Tag oZOm i�� AcEm 4imm D41, / mz00 P�+ iN��-' z -�A F r zoz O-m' pm 8!i p0 ny mein aD� , c+ O \ / %\ to OAy OAASA D, ViD OmK mK�yy OA yy2 y5F i'yo m00 �f Gn Oi on \\ mo �0900 xTOFz OCy �.mi -E &m'- r0 ym -vim '0y o o b. �' 6"3 IZmDD o�n<vm > A DZZ mom 2 9 9 mmn 0 o omz oC yo AN mrNO �iumi A AO OWN C ZZ2 Om NATmo 5z'*z gM oDi OZO fr f O �a^2~'G >< 0° OI z 9 i DK 22" MIN. Zy 0 N O� VF m 092 ZAm Z =y m0 po om n mn Zo yZ _y Z> N o a K G7 - u G m A m 00 p o 0 O D C) oom ZOO m D O Moo n 0�0K D —vl?o—__—__—N___.�___ r5 (n (n oro� N�mo NO O AO O ;CF U. _ O Z ZJ m m D r BE N 9 o0 -� ------' r- (n } f--.w I I y o00 oy o I O O uzi .O 60 rcT 0 mzO aA 1 g ZV D Ozc o'bo z N �9 r DQ om8mv mmO O N O` Z r O O r� O N N0 8.A.2 D 'k OGDOti mmOm0 .�� • yi ^� in�i v �o O m ; omzo2Ai zc�'s�m�rx 'z awn O _Z �AVNin�InAc v a •Epp 2 g\ o !n y Z o2 vmo Ac�z-`"i�mc '000 g m� C "•.�h:'o : ' R (n r A D O '3 NONmOm�bm_m�m �c _g5 r � q - � '< � 0omga^M a+ ls; 44yy R wF m o m D V 29p2' N gm > : nag NT7 "v y�m (n < z Sa= o mmo�?g��n m' o�<x EEz N� - •�'m�.s m E b D a r o +A ozL' rI �Y .. DSO R �c 000 A� cfn�v,vm S J 38 �,D�lRoo \ A i�wt �� oxm�nzi �� 8 _ Aa$s^mv o i y yr F5mF '^- 2 a _' u it P �'� mAa D o 0 o�* 2 - - Packet Pg. 63 T- oo CO 36X2 { - 30, 2020. 1017 l FLp 11. F,lK 8. A .2 IN j'�So� o ^n o " Sao �g� „'� AA �I �� $ S g oza O cc C n ??FF M H N o cnD � g IICn R yg gg $ 33 8 05 �.._ Pic .mr5its. 9'R9g� A�_Eg 83�555 $ xgFa�aS $As%.g� p�q > Fr d �.'m g�3g3 Rzg—Fr 's€ a Ry.gsA R�9g�°o 9g 91 i1€gk A, 2.1 Ij F.Z. EGA �3-YR6 33¢R a "A •3`% P.� tv z Hn m < �m 4, z98�F g & ;ewa4Hs' rg�F� j; s€� g g 3ggz H •s�3 gssgi¢'=E 3 nag- z 9U =o�n o sg "frx @E £tw"p�AsgEsRs z O 'goo S e ggss go s� Eg' s€ agT °�a6� 3 Q 9 <or�zn 's yzS� R f. 3,w.q �€ e ® a �n6 g3 ^"] �m 3Af A g=§�€ g gF '�}�¢¢}"aeng g�, � �5¢ -� ijg5 Q� S�i $ �^�3 A6 g it % is O z RZ ^Hp a�; aff g� a Its 98.9 sIt <2 3A0 wgN S i° ?li 3 a� f 33 9 d p_3 a M —Z nOn C s3d.ie�' i 2 295 4 � 1 � � 8.A.2 C� axa y Ev��um�aB�CC Mv I i €S \J -m s e�N\R>E»91RWo:NB I TIMM PARCEL ID: Sx6N790001 I PARCEL 10: 32831]x0009 I OWNER: TKAM LODGE OWNER: TKPPA LODGE LLC C 'A ROPoONN FARM sREsl i LECI SITES RIDMN fARM L 1MCT t22 s AC N _q AC OR 1865 RUCT IPC Res _ PARCEL q: 32834800008 u ! OWNER: iK C LOOCE LLC ? u Tpp a LCG T 11. 1 M slits I A $� RQ Ao a all: Z D r m U) -o D m Z O zT N O D 0 11 met 3� fMlg-, PARCEL I0,. 328N12000) ^y�� OWNER: MENDEZ, NAN o+� ECAL: I DARN FARM III .norm QxL uuagu 0�9 RACr OS 5 AC I �F'" �Ri 8888 -E.E lo: OY"Cooae aj' OWNER: NURDMN IAR&NA LYNN �¢Zi LE CK: FLOPoDMN FARM SAES o Piu RACI 10A 5 PARCEL IID 32658OW6 �51u OWNER. ER«oxn,3J ARGEuru n �j A� ENICNELE AERMONR I CAL: ROPoDWI FARM SIZES y r" �� TRACT 89 5 M v��nf t—. A -4 PARCEL �/ ID: 32633520006 u R N�ua I OWNER: CPMPBELL, CHARLES B h CAMPBELL, AWtGAREi J y �+ PJ3 $$$ LECKMFL0�00WARFARM SIE6 mv� �&$9V pp o I �asN z ha! N� xm 5 o q: 3263xA60008 N OWNER: R—. CLORW I IECAL: ROIt— 'ARM SITES R 5] OR 932 PC ]x) PARCEL 0 32632— OWNER: WEST, DE RA J 8 LECAL: RIDWI FARM o SITES R I " �iMCT 58— o RO"- z PARCEL ID: 326318R0005 JAI OWNER: NALOES, FRAHN �Y Qi I LECK: a RO .N ORM sRES k 1PACT i]' O OR — Po ��_ {A' $o H C $ �g8 QI PARCEL ID: 3xE. —000J Errt, rRAIII\Rg4 4� Sa O I OWNER: LIRF . . �o LEGAL: FAPoA - u EAR I rtEs mAcT s40 Ao k�q oo a - C) PARCEL ID: 3263112000D SAE OWNER: MARIROtUROT, JOSE➢NFL I— ? LEGAL: T 25 FARM vR m LO \qp - sRES TRACT 25 � nm iN C. 4' gnu Wg �1 El ID: 12631080001 OWNER: WONGPINICN " NEXUS, AM'o' NIEw51W �^ i h BWNNAM WONGASRORN a I mo (a yII---1111 1 —OS10MN FARM PARCEL IN: 326bN0006 1. OWNER: sz- EOUEI— 4 S I RRORC— FARM V m g 8o iiii NNE �D8 —EL ID. 32630W0006 y� k OWNER: NUSZLYK. JFANEs 1 g O-E RO Z— FIRM BRES o u O 1R5) 6. -I OR 53A S PG )15 R LE55 OR 693 PG 4. WOODLAND ESTATES ROAD co co Packet Pg. 66 gI cI 6LZy p CA R Vie ml @@. oBENTON ROAD Sya pKA CRAVE$DRIVE NZ ogs�N 00 '46' E-ua el lars9--- 122.97' m� m m o i p\ <tpC`r mL20rvE � � m ! II IIS r. so m So 9� o OI puu == p mo x�p a m o0 $�$� pup4pS90 op$�vk7Fa p ppx ol m bm-�� I sTr 8x g n N m � _ NoI m\ s n N7� Al I I u2 � I _ — — a srw, W li N 00�43'S4• E 946.6t' S 00.43'S4 y 465.93' ! I -S� / 5 1;o Y. c �g ml ua N_e�om�m., mdrn ul i c r, [" 3'4«.ho•°•d'8`oa z pq c m c go �2 o f%$sa8g- Mo; aiNBp ISi m b m Rg�; �a3;$e_ d Ha 9 - p� cis tl3a �za-.g3v ^ dnovua,° ;"age �' Or 11 I' 93 3R ;sa �83°sus oa > o ND 64RBED E - to _ m o " N 00.43'S4' E 662.53' D O�? s 3? °' t o 0 �$ 00'43'54' W 662.96"" m m m o d .. \ z 8 8ag a°OSt F a� o 0 o O }. _ n3a tj�ape �v I o $co OI v i z2 D 9 a � O 0 Z az m 0? Fm m >a P33�90 (Di7tfJ' I.mom•0 ^N 0) o2 g c a^,�y��CJ EM�IpI p1yE II CpC 4�'A '.I N < ;O�IMH 2- Of al z za 0U9 m 30 _ WpS o moo;�a o mzmD 4 ; D N O 0 2 2 p gi gi yy ~ m Z O rn SMW Engineering Group, Inc. RAWLAND TOWER SURVEY cNECREo�er arw9 pp, REVISION DATE er ®� TSe ingha , Alabama 352 nE1D CREW: NM O 1. POOEO RpLM TREE$ to/5/IS JR Birmingham, Alabama 352a4 CAPITAL TELECOM .rRRo9Eo m: JLE HITT` x. 9mEo R4LMErro NOTE 12io i5 M Pn: z0&z5z6995 1500 MT. REV— 4VENUE MITE ZOJ0.1/IS/iJ ' y J. uPMiEO 4CCE55 FASFMFNf 10 16/RO J 6mWe-6985 MORRISTOWN, NJ 07960 ''� SNGWN �ZO 4 ADEED UTILItt E4$EMENT 1 /09/20 J ENGIAAff2RI�YR dR®UP, OHM www ISNEET1 oRz Packet Pg. 67 8.A.2 a 2� R °3ao$N N goa�ai o'Fooz� o � o m �8'° < z _$s^$o 10. s'm�ms �`60,00$oc.E. aogaN+t a °oN:3 =e_ o �'Fno og8aN £a so N�aB m$ho °F3 bo § no «R §os$ o FO`,'T Fx z $ sa qv a� o io�°Q. ---- go- 3 6-1— E 0 o 3 z 3 d O o aaR s, 8q� i 5s�ag S- o �nNgoN3 t"moNm3S No pgl ao nR�xa o $a°s5. SkSas" \F7 - �z$fzu £u ^;gmMo NRa Z!gxAgjc z8mT(s s'z S•�lmmsar�ii "K ' 3K ° pp S o3, 3a F-; Fwm $n8°sF" .',g. Q�n 3a .3��° '°"n.m �sAaa°\o a z Fo'°°'$oy mszo 8-az a Nxm s "zy a _ "yo i^z. P'az oa $O;Toaa S�g.oni'�'°E?, is rsn 9a .5elm i.,^4.B-H otu"o.' �° ii 88 'aw - 8 - Z. s z"8s$a'°8a8" $im^maao� 4_ 8La9."saa�o ad g.-N 3 93 o,r4.3 mo�zav_e$ 3 0° u cm « ^s$os �,83Q a^"�a6 mz.°°_ -ems as 80 'g�8 ^$..a w3 s��a fo 9gg 2.a�o n £o o gs3Mww ° saoa - 388" "zRam c �o�pa"�ennl�il y _" zgmb"Q3 m zpn g$S'm`Ft; T °zo - a u - 34 - "zo _os _o -_ iOFan_ot "m$°a3n3ms o-nnoK zrvn�c. iim ds ° edsgzo°oa 4- M8zom 8F8°}�c .9423 Az gQ5: o 8^qso sT ' s a eo °m5^ &All °ID O rD ^''o _ o _-c 0 0" ° 3.K 88�8.8a �c o00 3.< as io a$Tno3 0 sp5ma�gm� m z"L88PI "KI ssgs192 tff ^ 8o g�o S28K8c $ ? $ a°8a^ate'°8a'3 a4 ao.Z a 3o 3 _ o d - n zo�auoo a�m4ero°"o =no u g9gma - Iz a imam "Fma o£oo - Soo«z3. mo$gr o. 3a ==03� ° ,Ras on a$ z8$sa$ gaa ^ Fol ^soa" a$w o ogoga 3 J sA i 3 BENTON ROAD N 00.10'22' V 665.47' m - � i" " n um$ o =�$m� x «E I >>" =o^gym III 0g =N m m'2 v $ ^ 'o ®�a -oon v�l a 3 O �� _ ID 0 z m s 2 S O O W s 00.44.18' V 699.63' C y Z�Z b� $oS L�L sa s3s sa . 3 3 .ZDI Ain .zl �g�N8B >gumCmi Dr.+z Z O o 3 m SMW Engineering Group, Inc. RAVAMD TOWER SURVEY pUwN rn: JP CNECKCO 8f: IAI( no. �veloN G MTE er ]58 Bucine88 Caller Drive EtELD CPEW: NM FUR: ' MDEo TPEE9 to/5/re I2/10/re .m JP Birmingham. Alabama Ph. 205-252-6985 35244 CAPITAL TELECOM nPPR°VE° ev: JEE MIE: °]/55/12 N In 2. ]. .wEo PAEUETi°9 NOTE IFYOTEO ACCE55 FASEMENi 10 26/20 JP wlww —wengoom 130g Yi. KEumE AVEWIE SURE 201 ,EOPR5TOM1. ul g996g o-u r: AS SK°wN �O 4 .mg6p U14,tt EA9EMENT tt/0a/20 snEn 2 OF2 6?Po®IPo@@WIPo® GROUP, IPoG Packet Pg. 68 8.A.2 Exhibit C Conditions of Approval The Benton Road — Communication Tower Conditional Use, shall be limited to that which is depicted on the "Benton Road Relo (Naples Park) Drawings — Revised 01-04-21," prepared by SMW Engineering Group, Inc. 2. The petitioner will take care of complete maintenance during construction by grading and compacting new ruts that form on Benton Road from the bridge over the canal to petitioner's driveway as needed to keep the roadway in the pre -construction condition. Capital will provide photo documentation and a video of existing conditions prior to the pre -construction meeting. The video documentation shall cover the length of the road from the bridge to Capital's driveway. 3. The petitioner will do a complete repair of any damage caused to the road after construction r and grade and compact Benton Road with a 1-2 ton, 36", double roller, ride -on, vibratory CO compactor from the bridge over the canal to petitioner's driveway. 4. After construction, the petitioner will pay its fair share of road maintenance of Benton Road from the bridge over the canal to Capital's driveway based on usage of the road, whether an Association is formed or not. [19-CPS-01858/1601311/1] Packet Pg. 69 8.A.3 FIRST AMENDMENT TO OPTION AND TELECOMMUNICATIONS FACILITY LEASE AGREEMENT THIS FIRST AMENDMENT TO OPTION AND TELECOMMUNICATIONS FACILITY LEASE AGREEMENT ("First Amendment") effective as of the date of the last signature, (the "First Amendment Effective Date") is by and between Capital Telecom Holdings LLC ("Tenant"), a Delaware limited liability company and Tafara Lodge LLC ("Landlord"). WITNESSETH: WHEREAS, Landlord and Tenant entered into that certain Option and Telecommunications 2 Facility Lease Agreement dated January 18, 2018 ("Ground Lease'); and 'c WHEREAS, Landlord and Tenant desire to extend the Option period of the Ground Lease, and to E E make certain other modifications to the Ground Lease. G t� NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the forgoing promises and other valuable consideration coo contained herein, the receipt, adequacy, and sufficiency of which are hereby expressly acknowledged, the parties agree to amend the Ground Lease as follows: c c m 1. Signing Bonus. Within thirty (30) days of the Effective Date of this First Amendment, 00 Tenant shall pay Landlord a one-time signing bonus in the amount of oo 00 T �r 2. Notwithstanding any provisions contained within the Ground Lease, the annual base rent as set forth in the second sentence of subsection 5(b) "Amount of Rent" shall now read as follows: "Annual base rent in the amount of , payable in equal monthly installments of (the "Rent"). 2. Notwithstanding any provisions contained within the Ground Lease, the option period set forth in the Ground Lease is extended for an additional eighteen (18) months, commencing one (1) year from the First Amendment Effective Date. 3. Exhibit B of the Ground Lease is deleted in its entirety and replaced by Exhibit B (First Amendment) attached hereto and made a part hereof. Except as otherwise expressly set forth herein and amended by this First Amendment, all terms of the Ground Lease shall remain in full force and effect. All capitalized terms not otherwise defined herein shall have the meanings ascribed to them in the Ground Lease. If there is any conflict between the terms and conditions of this First Amendment and the terms and conditions of the Ground Lease or any prior addendum to the Ground Lease, the terms and conditions of this First Amendment shall prevail. [remainder of page intentionally left blank] Naples Park North FL114 Amend I to Lease Agt EXE Packet Pg. 70 8.A.3 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this First Amendment as of the date First Amendment Effecte.IIal<e. TENANT Capital Teleco H ldings LLCM � - By: Michael G. Brett Title: COO Date: 20 T- oo 00 T Naples Park North FL114 Amend I to Lease Agt EXE Packet Pg. 71 EXHIBIT B (First Amendment) -H rt igLMEIZVE SEMWO FALL ZONE RADIUS 7 (cohIPOUNT) SETIJACK) 20d'± MAYER SMACK'. �10VOEH :ETEIACVC) (03MFOL (FRESEMC. �E SEMK) —7-7717 N I IND SMACK) OE GC I �j 4 ♦ it I y A. IY 1, IF 11, 1 0 + Cl as 0 0 C E E 0 0 w C 0 oo CO Naples Park North FL 114 Amend I to Lease Agt EXE I Packet Pg. 72 \\ � � : � � � � � I Q 11.11%,3 8.A.4 CO�BY �iOTilYlty Growth Management Department Zoning Division Comprehensive Planning Section MEMORANDUM To: Tim Finn, AICP, Principal Planner Zoning Services Section, Zoning Division From: Sue Faulkner, Principal Planner Comprehensive Planning Section, Zoning Division Date: December 22, 2020 Subject: Future Land Use Element Consistency Review r ao 00 PETITION NUMBER: PL20180002327 -REV 4 PETITION NAME: Capital Telcom Holdings — Benton Road Relo (fka Naples Park) CU REQUEST: The petitioner is requesting a conditional use to construct a replacement wireless communication tower for an existing Guyed communication tower structure (CU #1 Essential Services). Submittal 2 revised several documents in response to staff comments including changing name of project, legal description, site plan set with preserve area management plan, affidavit of authorization, and agent of record. Submittal 3 modified the Preserve, added calculations for the Preserve requirement on the Master Concept Plan, and deleted landscape buffers from under the guy wires. LOCATION: The subject site is located on the Floridian Farm Sites Tract 122 on the east side of Benton Road N-S and 660' south of Benton Road E-W; f1.65 miles west of Everglades Blvd.; in Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East. COMPREHENSIVE PLANNING COMMENTS: The +5 acres subject site is designated Rural Fringe Mixed Use District Sending Lands (RFMUD), North Belle Meade Overlay, and the North Belle Meade Natural Resource Preservation Area (NRPA), as identified in the Future Land Use Element of the Growth Management Plan. The site is zoned Agriculture Zoning District within a Mobile Home Overlay (A -MHO) and is also within the Rural Fringe Mixed Use Overlay — Natural Resource Protection Area — North Belle Meade Overlay — Sending area. In a recent LDC Amendment, approved Ordinance #2019-08 on June 11, 2019, it specifically states the unincorporated area of Collier County allows communications towers as a conditional use in the Rural Fringe Mixed Use Sending Lands and Conservation District. Ord. #19-08 states under Section G. Conditional Uses (4.) Additional conditional uses in the RFMU sending lands and CON districts. The following essential services shall be allowed as conditional uses: a. Communications towers, subject to all applicable provisions of LDC section 5. 05. 09. Zoning Division • 2800 North Horseshoe Drive • Naples, FL 341040239-252-2400 Paget of 2 Packet Pg. 74 8.A.4 Select FLUE Policies are shown below (in italics), followed by staff analysis in [bracketed bold text]. FLUE Policy 5.6: New developments shall be compatible with, and complementary to, the surrounding land uses, as set forth in the Land Development Code (Ordinance 04-41, adopted June 22, 2004 and effective October 18, 2004, as amended). [Comprehensive Planning staff leaves this determination to Zoning Services staff as part of their review of the petition in its entirety.] FLUE Objective 7 and Relevant Policies: Due to the proposed single use (communications tower), staff is of the opinion that an evaluation of FLUE policies under Objective 7 (pertaining to access, interconnections, walkability, etc.) is not necessary. CONCLUSION Based upon the above analysis, staff concludes the proposed Conditional Use may be deemed consistent with the Future Land Use Element (FLUE). 19ZVIII14WEGIM4011"/IMIA cc: Anita Jenkins, AICP, Director of Zoning Division w Raymond V. Bellows, Manager, Zoning Division, Zoning Services Section 00 CU-PL2018-2327 Capital Telcom - Benton Road Relo R4.docx Zoning Division • 2800 North Horseshoe Drive • Naples, FL 341040239-252-2400 Page 2 of 2 Packet Pg. 75 8.A.5 ORDINANCE NO. 19 — 08 AN ORDINANCE OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, AMENDING ORDINANCE NUMBER 04- 41, AS AMENDED, THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, WHICH INCLUDES THE COMPREHENSIVE LAND REGULATIONS FOR THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, TO ALLOW COMMUNICATIONS TOWERS AS A CONDITIONAL USE IN THE RURAL FRINGE MIXED USE SENDING LANDS AND CONSERVATION DISTRICT; BY PROVIDING FOR: SECTION ONE, RECITALS; SECTION TWO, FINDINGS OF FACT; SECTION THREE, ADOPTION OF AMENDMENTS TO THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, MORE SPECIFICALLY AMENDING THE FOLLOWING: CHAPTER TWO — ZONING DISTRICTS AND USES, INCLUDING SECTION 2.01.03 ESSENTIAL SERVICES AND SECTION 2.03.08 RURAL FRINGE ZONING DISTRICTS, AND SECTION 2.03.09 OPEN SPACE DISTRICT; SECTION FOUR, CONFLICT AND SEVERABILITY; SECTION FIVE, INCLUSION IN THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE; AND SECTION SIX, EFFECTIVE DATE. [PL20180003474] Recitals WHEREAS, on October 30, 1991, the Collier County Board of County Commissioners adopted Ordinance No. 91-102, the Collier County Land Development Code (hereinafter LDC), which was subsequently amended; and WHEREAS, the Collier County Board of County Commissioners (Board) on June 22, 2004, adopted Ordinance No. 04-41, which repealed and superseded Ordinance No. 91-102, as amended, the Collier County Land Development Code, which had an effective date of October 18, 2004; and WHEREAS, on March 18, 1997, the Board adopted Resolution 97-177 establishing local requirements and procedures for amending the LDC; and WHEREAS, all requirements of Resolution 97-177 have been met; and WHEREAS, the Collier County Planning Commission, sitting as the land planning agency, did hold an advertised public hearing on February 28, 2019, and reviewed the proposed amendments for consistency with the Comprehensive Plan and did recommend approval; and Page 1 of 11 Words struck thf ough are deleted, words underlined are added Packet Pg. 76 8.A.5 WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners, in a manner prescribed by law, did hold advertised public hearings on May 14, 2019, and June 11, 2019, and did take action concerning these amendments to the LDC; and WHEREAS, the subject amendments to the LDC are hereby determined by this Board to be consistent with and to implement the Collier County Growth Management Plan as required by Subsections 163.3194 (1) and 163.3202 (1), Florida Statutes; and WHEREAS, this ordinance is adopted in compliance with and pursuant to the Community Planning Act (F.S. § 163.3161 etseq.), and F.S. § 125.01(1)(t) and (1)(w); and ° c WHEREAS, this ordinance is adopted pursuant to the constitutional and home rule g powers of Fla. Const. Art. VIII, § 1(g); and WHEREAS, all applicable substantive and procedural requirements of the law have E otherwise been met. c i CU NOW, THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED by the Board of County Commissioners of c Collier County, Florida, that: r a� m co co SECTION ONE: RECITALS co The foregoing Recitals are true and correct and incorporated by reference herein as if fully set forth. N SECTION TWO: FINDINGS OF FACT The Board of Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, hereby makes the following findings of fact: 1. Collier County, pursuant to § 163.3161, et seq., F.S., the Florida Community Planning Act (herein after the "Act"), is required to prepare and adopt a comprehensive plan. 2. After adoption of the Comprehensive Plan, the Act and in particular § 163.3202(1). F.S., mandates that Collier County adopt land development regulations that are consistent with and implement the adopted comprehensive plan. 3. Section 163.3201, F.S., provides that it is the intent of the Act that the adoption and enforcement by Collier County of land development regulations for the total unincorporated area shall be based on, be related to, and be a means of implementation for, the adopted comprehensive plan. 4. Section 163.3194(1)(b), F.S., requires that all land development regulations enacted or amended by Collier County be consistent with the adopted comprehensive plan, or Page 2of11 Words stfuek thr-oug are deleted, words underlined are added Packet Pg. 77 8.A.5 element or portion thereof, and any land regulations existing at the time of adoption which are not consistent with the adopted comprehensive plan, or element or portion thereof, shall be amended so as to be consistent. 5. Section 163.3202(3), F.S., states that the Act shall be construed to encourage the use of innovative land development regulations. 6. On January 10, 1989, Collier County adopted the Collier County Growth Management Plan (hereinafter the "Growth Management Plan" or "GMP") as its comprehensive plan pursuant to the requirements of § 163.3161 et seq., F.S. 7. Section 163.3194(1)(a), F.S., mandates that after a comprehensive plan, or element or portion thereof, has been adopted in conformity with the Act, all development undertaken by, and all actions taken in regard to development orders by, governmental agencies in regard to land covered by such comprehensive plan or element shall be consistent with such comprehensive plan or element as adopted. 8. Pursuant to § 163.3194(3)(a), F.S., a development order or land development regulation shall be consistent with the comprehensive plan if the land uses, densities or intensities, and other aspects of development are compatible with, and further the objectives, policies, land uses, densities, or intensities in the comprehensive plan and if it meets all other criteria enumerated by the local government. 9. Section 163.3194(3)(b), F.S., states that a development approved or undertaken by a local government shall be consistent with the comprehensive plan if the land uses, densities or intensities, capacity or size, timing, and other aspects of development are compatible with, and further the objectives, policies, land uses, densities, or intensities in the comprehensive plan and if it meets all other criteria enumerated by the local government. 10. On October 30, 1991, Collier County adopted the Collier County Land Development Code, which became effective on November 13, 1991. The Land Development Code adopted in Ordinance 91-102 was recodified and superseded by Ordinance 04-41. 11. Collier County finds that the Land Development Code is intended and necessary to preserve and enhance the present advantages that exist in Collier County; to encourage the most appropriate use of land, water and resources consistent with the public interest; to overcome present handicaps; and to deal effectively with future problems that may result from the use and development of land within the total unincorporated area of Collier County and it is intended that this Land Development Code preserve, promote, protect and improve the public health, safety, comfort, good order, appearance, convenience and general welfare of Collier County; to prevent the overcrowding of land and avoid the undue concentration of population; to facilitate the adequate and efficient provision of transportation, water, sewerage, schools, Page 3 of 11 Words struok throug are deleted, words underlined are added Packet Pg. 78 8.A.5 parks, recreational facilities, housing and other requirements and services; to conserve, develop, utilize and protect natural resources within the jurisdiction of Collier County; to protect human, environmental, social and economic resources; and to maintain through orderly growth and development, the character and stability of present and future land uses and development in Collier County. 12. It is the intent of the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County to implement the Land Development Code in accordance with the provisions of the Collier County Comprehensive Plan, Chapter 125, Fla. Stat., and Chapter 163, Fla. Stat., and through these F- r- amendments to the Code. .E SECTION THREE: ADOPTION OF AMENDMENTS TO THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE E 0 U CU 0 W SUBSECTION 3.A. AMENDMENTS TO SECTION 2.01.03 ESSENTIAL SERVICES o r c a� m Section 2.01.03 Essential Services, of Ordinance 04-41, as amended, the Collier County Land co Development Code, is hereby amended to read as follows: Section 2.01.03 Essential Services Essential services are hereby defined as services designed and operated to provide water, sewer, gas, telephone, electricity, cable television or communications to the general public by providers which have been approved and authorized according to laws having appropriate jurisdiction, and government facilities. Essential services are allowed in any zoning district subject to the following conditions: G. Conditional uses. The following uses require approval pursuant to section 10.08.00 conditional uses: Page 4 of 11 Words stfuek thfough are deleted, words underlined are added Packet Pg. 79 8.A.5 2. Conditional essential services in RFMU sending lands, NRPAs, CON districts, and RLSA designated HSAs and FSAs. Within RFMU District Sending Lands, NRPAs, CON districts, and the RFLA designated HSAs and FSAs subject to the limitations set forth in LDC section . 4.08.05 H.3, On addlotmen to the essential seFViGes identified as allowed Genditional uses in subseGteen 2.01.03 G.I. abov, the following additional essential services are allowed as conditional uses: a. Sewer lines and lift stations necessary to serve a publicly owned or privately owned central sewer system providing service to urban areas; or the Rural Transition Water and Sewer District, as delineated on the Urban -Rural Fringe Transition Zone Overlay Map in the Future Land Use Element of the GMP, when not located within already cleared portions of existing rights -of -way or easements; b. Safety Services limited to law enforcement, fire, and emergency medical services; and C. Oil and gas field development and production, as defined and regulated in this Code, remains a conditional use on or beneath Conservation Collier lands established in the CON zoning district subject to subsection 2.03.09 B.1.c.i. 3. Additional conditional uses in residential, and estate zoned districts, and in RFMU receiving and neutral lands. In residential, agricultural, and estate zoned districts and in RFMU Receiving and neutral lands, in addition to those essential Page 5 of 11 Words struck oug are deleted, words underlined are added Packet Pg. 80 8.A.5 services identified as conditional uses in section 2.01.03 G.1. above, the following essential services shall also be allowed as conditional uses: a. Regional parks and community parks; b. Public parks and public library facilities; C. Safety service facilities; d. Other similar facilities, except as otherwise specified herein. 4. Additional conditional uses in the RFMU sending lands and CON districts. The following essential services shall be allowed as conditional uses: a. Communications towers, subiect to all applicable provisions of LDC section 5.05.09. 4. 5. Conditional uses that include the installation of structures: a. Where structures are involved other than structures supporting lines or cables, such structures shall comply with the regulations for the district in which they are located, or as may be required on an approved site development plan under section 10.02.03. In addition, the structures shall conform insofar as possible to the character of the district in which they are located as to development standards, as well as architecture and Page 6 of 11 Words stmek dwough are deleted, words underlined are added Packet Pg. 81 8.A.5 landscaping, with utilization of screening and buffering to ensure compatible with the surrounding and nearby existing and future uses. b. Within the RFMU district sending lands, NRPAs, Conservation Districts, and the RLSA HSAs and FSAs, structures supporting the conditional use L d shall be located so as to minimize any impacts on native vegetation and 0 c on wildlife and wildlife habitat. ° .E E C. Essential services shall not be deemed to include the erection of 0 U structures for commercial activities such as sales or the collection of bills CU W in districts from which such activities would otherwise be barred. 0 c Unstaffed billing services, which are accessory uses to the normal m operations of the essential service, may be permitted. co r co O O SUBSECTION 3.B. AMENDMENTS TO SECTION 2.03.08 RURAL FRINGE ZONING DISTRICTS Section 2.03.08 Rural Fringe Zoning Districts, of Ordinance 04-41, as amended, the Collier County Land Development Code, is hereby amended to read as follows: 2.03.08 Rural Fringe Zoning Districts A. Rural Fringe Mixed -Use District (RFMU District). Page 7 of 11 Words strttek thfough are deleted, words underlined are added Packet Pg. 82 8.A.5 4. RFMU sending lands. RFMU sending lands are those lands that have the highest degree of environmental value and sensitivity and generally include significant wetlands, uplands, and habitat for listed species. RFMU sending lands are the principal target for preservation and conservation. Density may be transferred from RFMU sending lands as provided in LDC section 2.03.07 DA.c. All NRPAs within the RFMU district are also RFMU sending lands. With the exception of specific provisions applicable only to NBMO neutral lands, the following standards shall apply within all RFMU sending lands: * * * * * * * * * * * * * a. Allowable uses where TDR credits have not been severed. * * * * * * * * * * * * * (3) Conditional Uses. (a) Those essential services identified in LDC section 2.01.03 G.2 and 4. b. Uses allowed where TDR credits have been severed. (2) Conditional uses: (a) Those Essential Uses identified in LDC section 2.01.03 G.2 and 4. SUBSECTION 3.C. AMENDMENTS TO SECTION 2.03.09 OPEN SPACE ZONING DISTRICTS Page 8 of 11 Words struck t4eugh are deleted, words underlined are added Packet Pg. 83 L d O c 0 .E E E 0 U R O c 0 r c m m 00 co r 8.A.5 Section 2.03.09 Open Space Zoning Districts, of Ordinance 04-41, as amended, the Collier County Land Development Code, is hereby amended to read as follows: 2.03.09 Open Space Zoning Districts B. Conservation District "CON". The purpose and intent of the conservation district "CON" is to conserve, protect and maintain vital natural resource lands within unincorporated Collier County that are owned primarily by the public. All native habitats possess ecological and physical characteristics that justify attempts to maintain these important natural resources. Barrier islands, coastal bays, wetlands, and habitat for listed species deserve particular attention because of their ecological value and their sensitivity to perturbation. All proposals for development in the CON district must be subject to rigorous review to ensure that the impacts of the development do not destroy or unacceptably degrade the inherent functional values. The CON District includes such public lands as Everglades National Park, Big Cypress National Preserve, Florida Panther National Wildlife Refuge, portions of the Big Cypress Area of Critical State Concern, Fakahatchee Strand State Preserve, Collier -Seminole State Park, Rookery Bay National Estuarine Sanctuary Research Reserve, Delnor-Wiggins State Park, and the National Audubon's Corkscrew Swamp Sanctuary (privately owned), and C.R.E.W. It is the intent of the CON District to require review of all development proposed within the CON District to ensure that the inherent value of the County's natural resources is not destroyed or unacceptably altered. The CON District corresponds to and implements the conservation land use designation on the future land use map of the Collier County GMP. 1. Allowable uses. The following uses are allowed in the CON District Page 9 of 11 Words st,.,,^v throug are deleted, words underlined are added Packet Pg. 84 8.A.5 C. Conditional uses. The following uses are permitted as conditional uses in the CON, subject to the standards and procedures established in section 10.08.00 and further subject to: 1) submission of a plan for development as part of the required EIS that demonstrates that wetlands , listed species and their habitat are adequately protected; and 2) conditions which may be imposed by the Board of County Commissioners, as deemed appropriate, to limit the size, location, and access to the conditional use. * * * * * * * * * * * * * 2. Those essential services set forth in subsection 2.01.03 G.2. and 4. L d O F- r- 0 .E E E O U R O C O r C d m 00 co r SECTION FOUR: CONFLICT AND SEVERABILITY CU c In the event that any provisions of this ordinance should result in an unresolved conflict 0 with the provisions of the Land Development Code (LDC) or Growth Management Plan (GMP), o the applicable provisions of the LDC or GMP shall prevail. In the event this Ordinance conflicts with any other Ordinance of Collier County or other applicable law, the more restrictive shall apply. If any phrase or portion of this Ordinance is held invalid or unconstitutional by any court Q of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be deemed a separate, distinct and independent a� provision and such holding shall not affect the validity of the remaining portion. E r SECTION FIVE: INCLUSION IN THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE a The provisions of this Ordinance shall become and be made a part of the Land Development Code of Collier County, Florida. The sections of the Ordinance may be renumbered or re -lettered to accomplish such, and the word 'ordinance" may be changed to "section," "article," or any other appropriate word. Page 10 of 11 Words struok thfough are deleted, words underlined are added Packet Pg. 85 8.A.5 SECTION SIX: EFFECTIVE DATE This Ordinance shall become effective upon filing with the Florida Department of State. PASSED AND DULY ADOPTED by the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, this 11th day of June, 2019. ATTEST: BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS CRYSTA,E NZEL, CLERK OF COLLIER Cg4NTY, FLORIDA c= By: ..,. U C By: a p ty Clerk WI IAM L. MCDANIEL, JR., "Chairman 'ABest ils t 0� signature only. Approved as to form and legality: iJ He[di F. Ashton-Cicko Managing Assistant County Attorney 04-CMD-01077/1805 (6/11/19) 18-LDS-00061 Thi, ordirtar,ce r r tQry of 5��••.-.1 's office 1,1C� ��ay of'1--ur�, - as �+ �� and cc know Iedc c-n .;��'=`o filingreceived this ay of By oeor!c Page 11 of 11 Words struok thfougn are deleted, words underlined are added Packet Pg. 86 8.A.5 � tiiic _Siyv f 1 FLORIDA DEPARTMENT Of STATE �. _ _--____I______'____________ -.. _ . __I RON DESANTIS Governor June 12, 2019 Ms. Ann Jennejohn, Senior Deputy Clerk Office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court & Comptroller of Collier County 3299 Tamiami Trail, Suite 4401 Naples, Florida 34112-5324 Dear Ms. Jennejohn: LAUREL M. LEE Secretary of State Pursuant to the provisions of Section 125.66, Florida Statutes, this will acknowledge receipt of your electronic copy of Collier County Ordinance No. 19-08, which was filed in this office on June 12, 2019. Sincerely, Ernest L. Reddick Program Administrator ELR/lb R. A. Gray Building • 500 South Bronough Street • Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0250 Telephone: (850) 245-6270 www.dos.state.fl.us Packet Pg. 87 00 00 § 332. Mobile services, 47 USCA § 332 8.A.7 . KeyCite Yellow Flag - Negative Treatment Proposed Legislation United States Code Annotated Title 47. Telecommunications (Refs & Annos) Chapter 5. Wire or Radio Communication (Refs & Annos) Subchapter III. Special Provisions Relating to Radio (Refs & Annos) Part I. General Provisions 47 U.S.C.A. § 332 § 332. Mobile services Effective: March 23, 2018 Currentness (a) Factors which Commission must consider 00 00 In taking actions to manage the spectrum to be made available for use by the private mobile services, the Commission shall consider, consistent with section 151 of this title, whether such actions will-- d' (1) promote the safety of life and property; (2) improve the efficiency of spectrum use and reduce the regulatory burden upon spectrum users, based upon sound engineering principles, user operational requirements, and marketplace demands; (3) encourage competition and provide services to the largest feasible number of users; or (4) increase interservice sharing opportunities between private mobile services and other services. (b) Advisory coordinating committees (1) The Commission, in coordinating the assignment of frequencies to stations in the private mobile services and in the fixed services (as defined by the Commission by rule), shall have authority to utilize assistance furnished by advisory coordinating committees consisting of individuals who are not officers or employees of the Federal Government. (2) The authority of the Commission established in this subsection shall not be subject to or affected by the provisions of part III of Title 5 or section 1342 of Title 31. (3) Any person who provides assistance to the Commission under this subsection shall not be considered, by reason of having provided such assistance, a Federal employee. VVESTLAW © 2021 Thomson Reuters. No claim to original U.S. Government Works. Packet Pg. 88 8.A.7 § 332. Mobile services, 47 USCA § 332 (4) Any advisory coordinating committee which furnishes assistance to the Commission under this subsection shall not be subject to the provisions of the Federal Advisory Committee Act. (c) Regulatory treatment of mobile services (1) Common carrier treatment of commercial mobile services (A) A person engaged in the provision of a service that is a commercial mobile service shall, insofar as such person is so engaged, be treated as a common carrier for purposes of this chapter, except for such provisions of subchapter II as the Commission may specify by regulation as inapplicable to that service or person. In prescribing or amending any such regulation, the Commission may not specify any provision of section 201, 202, or 208 of this title, and may specify any other provision only if the Commission determines that-- (i) enforcement of such provision is not necessary in order to ensure that the charges, practices, classifications, m or regulations for or in connection with that service are just and reasonable and are not unjustly or unreasonably 00 discriminatory; 00 (ii) enforcement of such provision is not necessary for the protection of consumers; and (iii) specifying such provision is consistent with the public interest. (B) Upon reasonable request of any person providing commercial mobile service, the Commission shall order a common carrier to establish physical connections with such service pursuant to the provisions of section 201 of this title. Except to the extent that the Commission is required to respond to such a request, this subparagraph shall not be construed as a limitation or expansion of the Commission's authority to order interconnection pursuant to this chapter. (C) As a part of making a determination with respect to the public interest under subparagraph (A)(iii), the Commission shall consider whether the proposed regulation (or amendment thereof) will promote competitive market conditions, including the extent to which such regulation (or amendment) will enhance competition among providers of commercial mobile services. If the Commission determines that such regulation (or amendment) will promote competition among providers of commercial mobile services, such determination may be the basis for a Commission finding that such regulation (or amendment) is in the public interest. (D) The Commission shall, not later than 180 days after August 10, 1993, complete a rulemaking required to implement this paragraph with respect to the licensing of personal communications services, including making any determinations required by subparagraph (C). (2) Non -common carrier treatment of private mobile services A person engaged in the provision of a service that is a private mobile service shall not, insofar as such person is so engaged, be treated as a common carrier for any purpose under this chapter. A common carrier (other than a person that was treated as VVESTLAW © 2021 Thomson Reuters. No claim to original U.S. Government Works. Packet Pg. 89 8.A.7 § 332. Mobile services, 47 USCA § 332 a provider of a private land mobile service prior to August 10, 1993) shall not provide any dispatch service on any frequency allocated for common carrier service, except to the extent such dispatch service is provided on stations licensed in the domestic public land mobile radio service before January 1, 1982. The Commission may by regulation terminate, in whole or in part, the prohibition contained in the preceding sentence if the Commission determines that such termination will serve the public interest. (3) State preemption (A) Notwithstanding sections 152(b) and 221(b) of this title, no State or local government shall have any authority to regulate E the entry of or the rates charged by any commercial mobile service or any private mobile service, except that this paragraph O shall not prohibit a State from regulating the other terms and conditions of commercial mobile services. Nothing in this U subparagraph shall exempt providers of commercial mobile services (where such services are a substitute for land line telephone exchange service for a substantial portion of the communications within such State) from requirements imposed 0 tY by a State commission on all providers of telecommunications services necessary to ensure the universal availability of o telecommunications service at affordable rates. Notwithstanding the first sentence of this subparagraph, a State may petition the Commission for authority to regulate the rates for any commercial mobile service and the Commission shall grant such M petition if such State demonstrates that-- 00 00 (i) market conditions with respect to such services fail to protect subscribers adequately from unjust and unreasonable rates Iq or rates that are unjustly or unreasonably discriminatory; or m (ii) such market conditions exist and such service is a replacement for land line telephone exchange service for a substantial portion of the telephone land line exchange service within such State. The Commission shall provide reasonable opportunity for public comment in response to such petition, and shall, within 9 months after the date of its submission, grant or deny such petition. If the Commission grants such petition, the Commission shall authorize the State to exercise under State law such authority over rates, for such periods of time, as the Commission deems necessary to ensure that such rates are just and reasonable and not unjustly or unreasonably discriminatory. (B) If a State has in effect on June 1, 1993, any regulation concerning the rates for any commercial mobile service offered in such State on such date, such State may, no later than 1 year after August 10, 1993, petition the Commission requesting that the State be authorized to continue exercising authority over such rates. If a State files such a petition, the State's existing regulation shall, notwithstanding subparagraph (A), remain in effect until the Commission completes all action (including any reconsideration) on such petition. The Commission shall review such petition in accordance with the procedures established in such subparagraph, shall complete all action (including any reconsideration) within 12 months after such petition is fled, and shall grant such petition if the State satisfies the showing required under subparagraph (A)(i) or (A)(ii). If the Commission grants such petition, the Commission shall authorize the State to exercise under State law such authority over rates, for such period of time, as the Commission deems necessary to ensure that such rates are just and reasonable and not unjustly or unreasonably discriminatory. After a reasonable period of time, as determined by the Commission, has elapsed from the issuance of an order under subparagraph (A) or this subparagraph, any interested party may petition the Commission for an order that the exercise of authority by a State pursuant to such subparagraph is no longer necessary to ensure that the rates for commercial mobile services are just and reasonable and not unjustly or unreasonably discriminatory. The Commission shall provide reasonable opportunity for public comment in response to such petition, and shall, within 9 months after the date of its submission, grant or deny such petition in whole or in part. V1IESTLAW © 2021 Thomson Reuters. No claim to original U.S. Government Works. Packet Pg. 90 8.A.7 § 332. Mobile services, 47 USCA § 332 (4) Regulatory treatment of communications satellite corporation Nothing in this subsection shall be construed to alter or affect the regulatory treatment required by title IV of the Communications Satellite Act of 1962 of the corporation authorized by title III of such Act. (5) Space segment capacity Nothing in this section shall prohibit the Commission from continuing to determine whether the provision of space segment capacity by satellite systems to providers of commercial mobile services shall be treated as common carriage. (6) Foreign ownership The Commission, upon a petition for waiver filed within 6 months after August 10,1993, may waive the application of section 310(b) of this title to any foreign ownership that lawfully existed before May 24, 1993, of any provider of a private land mobile service that will be treated as a common carrier as a result of the enactment of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1993, but only upon the following conditions: 00 00 (A) The extent of foreign ownership interest shall not be increased above the extent which existed on May 24, 1993. (B) Such waiver shall not permit the subsequent transfer of ownership to any other person in violation of section 310(b) of this title. (7) Preservation of local zoning authority (A) General authority Except as provided in this paragraph, nothing in this chapter shall limit or affect the authority of a State or local government or instrumentality thereof over decisions regarding the placement, construction, and modification of personal wireless service facilities. (B) Limitations (i) The regulation of the placement, construction, and modification of personal wireless service facilities by any State or local government or instrumentality thereof -- (I) shall not unreasonably discriminate among providers of functionally equivalent services; and (II) shall not prohibit or have the effect of prohibiting the provision of personal wireless services. V1IESTLAW © 2021 Thomson Reuters. No claim to original U.S. Government Works. Packet Pg. 91 8.A.7 § 332. Mobile services, 47 USCA § 332 (ii) A State or local government or instrumentality thereof shall act on any request for authorization to place, construct, or modify personal wireless service facilities within a reasonable period of time after the request is duly filed with such government or instrumentality, taking into account the nature and scope of such request. (iii) Any decision by a State or local government or instrumentality thereof to deny a request to place, construct, or modify personal wireless service facilities shall be in writing and supported by substantial evidence contained in a written record. (iv) No State or local government or instrumentality thereof may regulate the placement, construction, and modification of personal wireless service facilities on the basis of the environmental effects of radio frequency emissions to the extent that such facilities comply with the Commission's regulations concerning such emissions. (v) Any person adversely affected by any final action or failure to act by a State or local government or any instrumentality LE thereof that is inconsistent with this subparagraph may, within 30 days after such action or failure to act, commence an o action in any court of competent jurisdiction. The court shall hear and decide such action on an expedited basis. Any m person adversely affected by an act or failure to act by a State or local government or any instrumentality thereof that is M inconsistent with clause (iv) may petition the Commission for relief. 00 00 (C) Definitions For purposes of this paragraph— (i) the term "personal wireless services" means commercial mobile services, unlicensed wireless services, and common carrier wireless exchange access services; (ii) the term "personal wireless service facilities" means facilities for the provision of personal wireless services; and (iii) the term "unlicensed wireless service" means the offering of telecommunications services using duly authorized devices which do not require individual licenses, but does not mean the provision of direct -to -home satellite services (as defined in section 303(v) of this title). (8) Mobile services access A person engaged in the provision of commercial mobile services, insofar as such person is so engaged, shall not be required to provide equal access to common carriers for the provision of telephone toll services. If the Commission determines that subscribers to such services are denied access to the provider of telephone toll services of the subscribers' choice, and that such denial is contrary to the public interest, convenience, and necessity, then the Commission shall prescribe regulations to afford subscribers unblocked access to the provider of telephone toll services of the subscribers' choice through the use of a carrier identification code assigned to such provider or other mechanism. The requirements for unblocking shall not apply to mobile satellite services unless the Commission finds it to be in the public interest to apply such requirements to such services. (d) Definitions VVESTLAW © 2021 Thomson Reuters. No claim to original U.S. Government Works. Packet Pg. 92 § 332. Mobile services, 47 USCA § 332 8.A.7 For purposes of this section- (1) the term "commercial mobile service" means any mobile service (as defined in section 153 of this title) that is provided for profit and makes interconnected service available (A) to the public or (B) to such classes of eligible users as to be effectively available to a substantial portion of the public, as specified by regulation by the Commission; (2) the term "interconnected service" means service that is interconnected with the public switched network (as such terms are defined by regulation by the Commission) or service for which a request for interconnection is pending pursuant to subsection (c)(1)(B); and (3) the term "private mobile service" means any mobile service (as defined in section 153 of this title) that is not a commercial mobile service or the functional equivalent of a commercial mobile service, as specified by regulation by the Commission. CREDIT(S) (June 19, 1934, c. 652, Title III, § 332, formerly § 331, as added Pub.L. 97-259, Title I, § 120(a), Sept. 13, 1982, 96 Stat. 1096; renumbered § 332, Pub.L. 102-385, § 25(b), Oct. 5, 1992, 106 Stat. 1502; amended Pub.L. 103-66, Title VI, § 6002(b)(2)(A), 00 Aug. 10, 1993, 107 Stat. 393; Pub.L. 104-104, § 3(d)(2), Title VII, §§ 704(a), 705, Feb. 8, 1996, 110 Stat. 61, 151, 153; Pub.L. 115-141, Div. P, Title IV, § 402(g), Mar. 23, 2018, 132 Stat. 1089.) d' Notes of Decisions (404) 47 U.S.C.A. § 332,47 USCA § 332 Current through P.L. 116-259. Some statute sections may be more current, see credits for details. End of Document C 2021 Thomson Reuters. No claim to original U.S. Government Works. VVESTLAW © 2021 Thomson Reuters. No claim to original U.S. Government Works. Packet Pg. 93 8.A.8 AFFIDAVIT OF COMPLIANCE I hereby certify that pursuant to Ordinance 2004-41, of the Collier County Land Development Code, I did cause the attached newspaper advertisement to appear and I did give notice by mail to the following property owners and/or condominium and civic associations whose members may be affected by the ro osed use changes of an application request for a rezoning, PUD amendment, conditional use t le 15 days prior to the scheduled Neighborhood Information Meeting. For the purposes of this requirement, the names and addresses of property owners shall be deemed those appearing on the latest tax rolls of -Collier County and any other persons or entities who have made a formal request of the county to be notified. The said notice contained the laymen's description of the site property of proposed change and the date, time, and place of a Neighborhood Information Meeting. Per the attached letters, property owner's list, and copy of newspaper adver$sement which are hereby made a part of this Affidavit of Compliance w --4`-.1-1 . ignature of Applicant) State of Florida County of C-eHier Iv The foregoing Affidavit of compliance was acknowledged before me this day of 2011 by % S, G'll'k , who is personally 44,-&- known to me or who has produced. 1�4t I / // /�� (Signature of otary Public) Printed Name of Notary G:\NIM Procedures/Affidavit Of Compliance - NIM Oct2010.Doc as identification. Y NotaryPublic State of Florida Vicki Lynn ClarisMy Commission GG 285454 Expires 12/18/2022 (Notary Seal) Packet Pg. 94 '� N' PART OF T14E USA TODAY NETWORK Published Daily Naples, FL 34110 LAW OFFICE OF MATTANIAH S. JAHN, P. 935 MAIN ST # D 1 SAFETY HARBOR, FL 34695 Affidavit of Publication STATE OF WISCONSIN COUNTY OF BROWN Before the undersigned they serve as the authority, personally appeared Vicky Felty who on oath says that she serves as legal clerk of the Naples Daily News, a daily newspaper published at Naples, in Collier County, Florida; distributed in Collier and Lee counties of Florida; that the attached copy of the advertising was published in said newspaper on dates listed. Affiant further says that the said Naples Daily News is a newspaper published at Naples, in said Collier County, Florida, and that the said newspaper has heretofore been continuously published in said Collier County, Florida; distributed in Collier and Lee counties of Florida, each day and has been entered as second class mail matter at the post office in Naples, in said Collier County, Florida , for a period of one year next preceding the first publication of the attached copy of advertisement and affiant further says that he has neither paid nor promised any person, or corporation any discount , rebate, commission or refund for the purpose of securing this advertisement for publication in the said newspaper. June 24, 2019 r k� j - - -j - Subscribed and sworn to before on June 24, 2019: 1'Vl. fnn. Notary, State of WI, County of Brown —1 TAIGA MONDLOCH Notary Public State of Wisconsin My commission expires: August 6, 2021 Publication Cost: $na Ad No: GC10217889 Customer No: 1344563 PO#: 7/10 Meeting oo 00 Packet Pg. 95 NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING 8.A.8 The public is invited to attend a neighborhood meeting held by Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. of the Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, P.A., representing Capital Telecom Holdings II, LLC on Wednesday, July 10, 2019 at 5:30p.m. at VFW, 13131 Collier Blvd., Naples, FL 34119 Subject Property: No address assigned — Parcel No. 3263472-0009 Capital is requesting Collier County to consider a Conditional Use to allow a communications tower on lands zoned Rural Agricultural (A) within the Mobile Home Overlay (MHO) and designated Rural Fringe Mixed Use -Sending Lands within the Natural Resource Protection Area Overlay and North Belle Meade Overlay in the Collier County Growth Management Plan. The subject property is .34 acres of a 5-acre tract located on the east side of the north -south extension of Benton Road in Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. WE VALUE YOUR INPUT Business and property owners, residents and visitors are welcome to attend the presentation and discuss the project with Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. and Collier County staff. If you are unable to attend this meeting, but have questions or comments, they can be directed by mail, phone, fax or e-mail to: Gil Martinez, Principal Planner gilbert.martinez@colliercountyfl.gov Collier County Growth Management Department Planning and Zoning Division 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, Florida 34104 Fax: (239)-252-6358 ND-GC10217889-01 Packet Pg. 96 8.A.8 NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING ADVERTISEMENT Newspaper Advertisement Layout: Ad must be at least 1/4 page and no less than 12-point type, except the county staff contact information, which may be less as long as it is clearly legible: NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING The public is invited to attend a neighborhood meeting held by Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. of the Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, P.A., representing Capital Telecom Holdings II, LLC on: Wednesday, July 10, 2019 at 5:30p.m. at VFW, 13131 Collier Blvd., Naples, FL 34119 Subject Property: No address assigned — Parcel No. 3263472-0009 Capital is requesting Collier County to consider a Conditional Use to allow a communications tower on lands zoned Rural Agricultural (A) within the Mobile Home Overlay (MHO) and designated Rural Fringe Mixed Use -Sending Lands within the Natural Resource Protection Area Overlay and North Belle Meade Overlay in the Collier County Growth Management Plan. The subject property is .34 acres of a 5 acre tract located on the east side of the north -south extension of Benton Road in Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. WE VALUE YOUR INPUT Business and property owners, residents and visitors are welcome to attend the presentation and discuss the project with Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. and Collier County staff. If you are unable to attend this meeting, but have questions or comments, they can be directed by mail, phone, fax or e-mail by July 1, 2019 to: Gil Martinez Collier County Department of Land Development Services oo 00 T �r Packet Pg. 97 8.A.8 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, Florida 34104 Fax: (239)-252-6358 gilbert.martinezkcolliercountyfl.gov — 239-252-4211 r 00 Packet Pg. 98 8.A.8 Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 07-10-2019 Mattaniah Jahn - Good evening. I am Mattaniah Jahn. It is Wednesday, July the 10a' 2019. It is 5:32pm. This is a community meeting or a neighborhood informational meeting. That is what Collier County calls it. Uhh, for an application to construct a communication tower on Parcel 3263472-009. I apologize for using the parcel number; an address hasn't been assigned to this. It is off of Benton Road. When you go to the end and it turns South. Speaker # 1 — we're right at my back yard. Mattaniah Jahn— Alright. Uhh, this communication tower is going to be 220' tall, Speaker # 1 — that's nice Mattaniah Jahn - minimum height necessary for Verizon Wireless. They are the ones who are requiring this communication tower. Uhh, they are relocating from a communication tower to the Northwest. They are going on to a tower built to modern specifications. We will be located on the Southern end of the parent parcel. And I'll start handing these out. It's a semi -wooded parcel, it has --- on it. The majority of the rest of the parcel is going to placed under a Preserve as the County requires. It is going to meet all required setbacks, separations from residential structures, and from other communication towers. These are ... what I just handed out ... are selected sheets from the plans that are already submitted on file. And what you're seeing right now is an aerial sheet. If you turn to the next sheet you'll m see the design of the guyed tower. When I say a guyed tower, I mean a communication toweroo with a thin lattice in the middle and guyed wires helping to support it. It has a relatively slendor CO profile compared to something like a lattice tower that expands out at the base and goes up. Because of its height, it will require lighting. It will only be medium intensity red light so that's c the dimmest that the FAA will let them put out there. Those lights are pointed out and up ti towards aircraft. This is an environmentally sensitive area and Capital has already performed all their compliance work. It is not going to have any impact on natural resources, they comply with Z all federal law regulations regarding that. Uhh, the base of the communication tower is going to have required landscaping. I know you are thinking well there is already plantings on site that meets that requirement of the code. Umm, and it will be designed to collocate additional antennas should anyone need to collocate on in the future. So, if you have another carrier that comes along and need to locate a deployment out there, locate antennas out there instead of having to construct a tower, they could collocate their antennas instead. Uhh,so once it is up, it will be there for that. That's the thumbnail sketch of what is going on with this site, umm, this is as I just as I said before, this is just a question and answer session. The application itself is a Conditional Use application uhh, which means it will come before your County, uhh, with two hearings. The first one will be a Planning Commission Hearing. The second, the date hasn't been set yet but Mr. Martinez, over here, is the Planner assigned to this. And if you contact the County or contact him at the County, I ... I will... can give your phone number to them. Gil Martinez — My number is 239-252-4211 for the record. Page 1 of 13 Packet Pg. 99 8.A.8 Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 07-10-2019 Mattaniah Jahn — He can keep you up to date, also if anyone would like copies of any of the application materials, I will be happy to send you a copy. Uhh, and then there will be a second hearing where it will come before the Board of County Commissioners, uhh, to vote based upon the Planning Commission's recommendation at their hearing. Uhh, I am not asking for any variances. It is a clean, straight forwards application. We are proceeding with this. The reason your County requires this is because this types of structure, they encourage a dialogue with the neighbors, with the community and that's the purpose of this. So, at this time, if you have any questions for me, I will be happy to answer them. Mattaniah Jahn - What is your name Sir? Vito Congine — Vito Congine, 1704 Benton Road, okay, umm, let's see, I don't see any addresses here so it's really not useful to tell us where this is going to be located. Is this an existing driveway that's about 3/4 of the way down Benton Road? Mattaniah Jahn — Let me see if I can pull it... Speaker #2 — no it goes straight and then makes a sharp right turn. Irene Herring — Okay, I am on that corner right there. This tract is directly behind me. Vito Congine - So, it is going to be right behind your home there? Donald Herring - You know where the drug dealer is at? Speaker #3 — Who? Donald Herring - The call box with the camera up there, that gate, okay. It's that ... his property ends, that's his driveway you see that line going across left to right. That's his driveway going back to his place and uhh its approximately 100 feet or so north of that location. Speaker #4 — So this is kiddie corner to your property? Donald Herring — No, no, no. Mattaniah Jahn — It is down the road. Donald Herring — It's, it's, on that section that goes South from the section line. The corner of my property is the section line, the four sections come together. 24, 25 or I forget the other two. And, uhh, from that marker down to your place, that was a road put in by my sister and her husband, by a fellow by the name of Lance Witton, and it was for, uhh, property was landlocked down there with Belle Meade and he was having the uhh, a tropical fruit orchard put in. So, he put that in but it was never put in with permits and it was never okayed. And technically, that road is on their property. Speaker #4 — Okay so this is Mattaniah Jahn — I have an aerial here which is not the largest but Donald Herring — This is coming North to South, okay, Page 2 of 13 oo 00 Packet Pg. 100 8.A.8 Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 07-10-2019 Speaker #4 - So it is actually — this would be my mother's property here. This is the property next door ... Donald Herring — No, she is further. There is one property between her and this Speaker #4 — Okay, alright. Donald Herring - There is a 6 foot chain link fence Speaker #4 - Yes Donald Herring — Tony and Bertha.... that's where they have their property South of that another 600, 650 feet South. Speaker #4 — Okay, so, my question is you are giving a 225 foot aerial put up there.....has this passed yet? Mattaniah Jahn — No, Sir. Speaker #4 — Okay, 2nd question - this is a commercial device going in farmlands... designated farmland area, so obviously it hasn't been approved yet. Now we are going to the board meetings which we can voice our opinions Mattaniah Jahn — Yes, Sir. Speaker #4 —Without insulting you, telling you we don't want this here. We already have one a 00 quarter mile away right on the corner of this gentlemen's property so we don't need another one. So, what we are looking at is blinking red lights all night long. People have spent heavy amounts of money on their properties, my mother alone a quarter of a million dollars, so she could live in a rural area farmland, not a commercial area. Third question, are you requiring them to remove all of the, if this goes through, will you require them to remove all of the brazillian pepper plants Z off of that property? c� c Gil Martinez — We will have to confer with our landscape architect E Speaker #4 — You are making every other person who applies for a permit to get a permit to do so, so, a r c Gil Martinez — yep, that is a question I will bring up with both our environmental and landscape architect team to look at. Donald Herring - Technically, before anything can be sealed, that's technically where we are at a as a gated community Speaker #4 — Yes. Donald Herring — And before you can get a certificate of occupancy, you have to remove all exotic plants ... that's how it's worded in the ... Speaker #4 — Exactly. Page 3 of 13 Packet Pg. 101 8.A.8 Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 07-10-2019 Speaker #4 - Umm, next, last question really, if this goes through who will maintain that road? Gill Martinez — Uhhh Mattaniah Jahn — If Capital causes any damage to the road, then they would have to maintain it. The actual impact that they would have on it, uhhh, is one vehicle, typically no more than one vehicle per carrier, per month. And usually it's a pickup truck size vehicle. So you are looking at less traffic on that road than if a single family house had been built on there, which that can be placed on that parcel. So, you are looking at walking out traffic that would be on that road. 3 Donald Herring — Technically, this is not a lime -rock road. 00 c 0 Speaker #4 — No, it's not. M Donald Herring - What this is, it was wooded land, a bulldoze was put in there and they pushed it down. Whatever dirt, whatever they could gather from wherever they got it from, they put it on E top of it, leveled it out, flattened it down, and it became an extended driveway that was c°� approximately one half mile along that went from the corner of my property down to Bill Hughes property which is on the South end of your property where that fence is M o Speaker #4 — Yes... c Donald Herring - ... where his orchard farm was....on the other side of that fence that goes as 00 across East to West. So, that is where he was located. After a year of planting and whatever, and oo losing all his product there because the animals he found out it was not feasible and he sold the 00 T place and we are stuck with the road. Speaker #4 — And it's been there ever since. Okay. ti Irene Herring - Okay my question z Mattaniah Jahn — Yes, Ma'am. c� Irene Herring — is there, c E Mattaniah Jahn — Can I have your name? a Irene Herring — My name is Irene Herring. Umm, my question is, is there areas available on your tower? E Walter Tiburski — Yes z a Irene Herring — Okay, so why do we need to have another tower when he has room on his, on the tower way back, from the wave FM radio station which originally was put in there with the spaces available on the tower. Mattaniah Jahn — So, the way this works is that Verizon drives the need for the tower. Verizon is requesting this. That means that according to them, they've exhausted the ability to collocate on that site. That the details of that is not something that I am privy to. I know that you are shaking your head Sir. However, Verizon's requesting this so that is why this is even happening. Page 4 of 13 Packet Pg. 102 8.A.8 Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 07-10-2019 Irene Herring - ....it's cheaper and easier. This is why ....to build than it is to rent. Donald Herring — My next question is, when Norman built his tower, they had, I don't know, about 6-7 inch layer of lime rock put from the bridge all the way out to the tower. This road in rainy season is not going to support anything better, bigger than a pickup truck. Irene Harring — My concern right now is the construction. You're gonna have all this big equipment coming through, you have to clear the land, you've gotta pull the crap out of there or... a, 3 Speaker #5 — No, one pickup a month. o c 0 Irene Harring — Huh? M Speaker #5 — One pickup a month. Irene Harring — That's after the tower is built, after the tower is built, and everything is v established and it's hunky dory, maybe once a month. But, before that, the construction requires trucks and a lot of traffic, that is not, that road is not like the original Benton Road. c Donald Herring - No c c Irene Harring — That's just plain dirt. And, we have filled that in several times. m Mattaniah Jahn- And that's a situation where if Capital causes damage to the road from oo construction, they're obligated to repair it. r Irene Harring — So you say. 0 Speaker #4 — May I ask who Capital is? ti Mattaniah Jahn — Capital Telecom is the tower operator. They're headquartered in New Jersey. Z They offer towers, across Florida and across the United States. They have a lot of experience in c� owning and operating communication towers... E Irene Herring — I get that the home owner, because my five acres, it's part of that 15 acres originally. a r Mattaniah Jahn — Okay E Irene Herring - so yah, I get it that that home owner is trying to make that property pay for itself because he's doing nothing with it. I really don't have a problem, so to speak, but when you're putting up a tower, when you got a tower ...why? Mattaniah Jahn — That is a situation where Verizon has a need and Irene Herring — Yeah I have Verizon as a carrier. Mattaniah Jahn — And Page 5 of 13 Packet Pg. 103 8.A.8 Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 07-10-2019 Irene Herring - And believe me I know what it is like because I'm lucky if I get anything out of Pembroke. You know, if I get anything out of the east coast. I rarely get anything out of the gulf coast here. ... and Pembroke. That is what I am looking at. Yeah I know ... I know him. I appreciate it. Why can't you just take well space off that tower? Higher up? The job is already done. Mattaniah Jahn — That is something that the tower, that is something that Verizon usually prefers. It is easier for them to collocate. It doesn't hit my desk until their options to collocate L are exhausted. So, ... 3 0 Speaker #6 — The wind tunnel, basically cheat me out of ...?? So, I come here and now I have c another tower? Come on! W Donald Herring - But, the LLC, the corporation that owns this particular piece of land also owns approximately 25 acres in that area? E 0 Mattaniah Jahn — I don't have a total of their acreage but I know..... v 0 Donald Herring — They also own egress to ...if you go its an L shaped piece of property that 0 W goes back to the North end of that property it is located on Benton Road between 1818 and 1760 c Benton Road, and that would put egress out on Benton Road which is much more suitable for egress to that tower than to come down this trail. So, if they come in the North end of the CO property that's part of that corporation and come down, they will be coming in the back door.00 Yes. It won't be right on Benton Road but it will be a road more suitable for heavy traffic. CO Mattaniah Jahn — Uhh... one moment ... let me... Irene Herring — It will be a lot easier to have it cleared once. Donald Herring - Yeah they own the property located between 1818 Benton Road and 1860 Benton Road. And, that is a uhh, hard back lime rock road which is capable of supporting tractor trailers. Mattaniah Jahn — As far as that goes, I will take that back to my project team. It might be a situation where they won't be able to, they would not be able to obtain the rights to access that route. I don't know what the parent, the property owner... Donald Herring — You don't have access to it comes out to that part of Benton Road is on my property. Mattaniah Jahn — I understand. But what I am saying is the landlord may not let them go that way. Donald Herring — What landlord? He owns that property. The fellow who owns this property, owns this property, he owns that property. He owns approximately 25 acres and he owns that piece of property between 1818 and 1860. He owns that also. Mattaniah Jahn — I understand. Page 6 of 13 Packet Pg. 104 8.A.8 Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 07-10-2019 Donald Herring — I don't want to mention the person's name. I guess he is ... Mattaniah Jahn — I understand but that doesn't mean that Capital will have a, will be given permission to access that way. Capital's a ... Donald Herring — Well you have to speak to the person who is leasing that. Mattaniah Jahn — Absolutely. They can.... Donald Herring — Because he would he would more than likely if it were easier to come in this way and not go around all this other because getting around those corners, I know he is going to have to bring in a good sized tractor trailer. You going to bring in sections of what, 25, 30 foot sections of tower in order to assemble it? Mattaniah Jahn — Roughly, yes. E Donald Herring — Yeah. 0 Irene Herring — Going around that corner is not going to be fun. Couple of speakers in the back — cannot make out any of it. 0 c 0 Irene Herring - ... instead of coming in on the West end, come in on the North end CO Donald Herring — Well the north end is just straight in. Irene Herring — Yeah, exactly. oo CO Mattaniah Jahn - The problem with that, however, is that you have to come down through uncleared land so I don't know if they will, I don't know if that will be a viable access route. ti Donald Herring — The fellow who, the fellow who, owns that 25 acres put a road in. I'm pretty z sure he cleared, what you see this clearing coming down here. He cleared that with his machine in order to get access, egress back to that location. Mattaniah Jahn — As far as as Donald Herring — And he has, see this has been, this was all woods. This has been cleared since he purchased that land. These two what you see here on that map, on that aerial field. Mattaniah Jahn — The access that is needed for, the access that is needed for the Guyed Tower is an actual driveway that is properly stabilized that ... Donald Herring — This section of Benton Road is, they brought in Mattaniah Jahn — So a clearing of the trees... Donald Herring - ...How many tons on those trucks? Speaker #? — I can't even tell you. I don't even know. Donald Herring — Well they brought in ... I watched that Page 7 of 13 Packet Pg. 105 8.A.8 Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 07-10-2019 Speaker #? - ....that road that your intending on coming down is unstable. And that's their point. That road that you're intending on coming down to get to it, it's unstable. Donald Herring — it's mud. Irene Herring — it's sugar sand Mattaniah Jahn — okay Donald Herring — it's whatever they could... 3 0 Irene Herring — Right now it's rainy season and we've got potholes like that and you start bringing in equipment like that and it's going to turn it up. Once that sugar sand dries up, it's c going to cut up even more. Mattaniah Jahn — okay 0 E Irene Herring — You're not doing us any favors. c0� Donald Herring — if they come up that north end of Benton Road. c Speaker #? - .... Come in off of his side.... our world 0 Irene Herring — left or right c m Mattaniah Jahn — I'll take that back to my project team so they can discuss it with the landlord. oo Uhh..it doesn't change the fact that if they come during construction the Benton Road were to be v damaged from trucks passing, they would still have to repair it back to the status that it was. a� Irene Harring - ....you're just trying to camouflage what we're trying to tell you. Okay. ti Mattaniah Jahn — forgive me if I'm missing it, but you're concern was that the large... z Irene Harring — I don't want a tower there in the first place! You know, you've got one up there ... rent space off of it. We don't need that but if you're gonna do it then think a little bit past what your blinders allow you to see. Come in off of Benton. The original Benton. Donald Herring — from that section line, that corner that joins the four sections together down to 0 0 a the bridge, we have a road grader and a driver who maintains that part of Benton Road. And this area's not touched. But that road is maintained. It's crowned and the water comes, drains off properly and everything. Right now it's in good shape. Speaker #? — Yes, it is. a Donald Herring - This is just ... it's going to be tearing up drive way for people to have to get to their homes and so on, and it's going to be a problem. It's like a private driveway. It's an extended driveway. That's what it is. Mattaniah Jahn — I will definitely take that back to Page 8 of 13 Packet Pg. 106 8.A.8 Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 07-10-2019 Speaker #? — The County does not maintain that road. Period. That is up to the homeowners. So that's an expense that they have to incur at this point. I've contacted the County and they will not touch that road. That road to them does not exist. Donald Herring — If you talk to Jim Coletta, Jim Coletta will tell you that we are technically a gated community. We have to establish a master association. We have to float bonds. We have to build our own roads and everything in there. That's the only way we're going to get those roads paved and in there. Now when you talk, as you see how many of our thirty-five families are gathered here, this is about how many people you can get together and sit down to agree on anything. So we'll never get a master association, never get a paved road, never get anything done. Speaker #? - Not gonna happen. Donald Herring - It's not gonna happen. I've been there 30, well since '87. Speaker #4 — Are there any Plan B's for Verizon? Other locations that they've put forward? Because obviously, this is going to be a struggle for them. Mattaniah Jahn — this is the only site that's been submitted. Speaker #4 — So they went to somebody who really doesn't live there to rent this property. Donald Herring — No... oo 00 le Mattaniah Jahn — well, the way the process works is they have a search area that they're trying to stay in. They can't go move several miles or even a mile... Speaker #4 — Are they restricted from using state parks? Mattaniah Jahn — Generally yes, generally. And two miles away would be too far. The search radius for this site is half mile in radius. Donald Herring — this 25-acre parcel has just been purchased within the last 5 years, 6 years ... Speaker #? - 5 years. Donald Herring - About five years. All of this land was bought up here ... it was done in, I believe two or three transactions Irene Herring — I only know about the fifteen around me. Speaker #4 — I hate to say it... it comes down to, we don't want to live in an antenna farm. Irene Herring — exactly. Speaker #4 — and that's what is starting here. We have one on the corner that we all see throughout the days and night and now we're going to have another one. And now this guy — does he live here or no? Page 9 of 13 Packet Pg. 107 8.A.8 Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 07-10-2019 Irene Herring — No Speaker #4 - So he's going to try to sale, not sale, but rent his and another one and another one. And if we don't stop this now that's what will happen. Irene Herring — We'll look like a porcupine. Mattaniah Jahn — The first step of that logic is that there's a tower separation requirement. I haven't run the radius recently but I would imagine that most of that parent parcel is within that radius. The second problem is that code prefers collocation. So you can't just build one tower and build another one along side it. There has to be outside of separation. Speaker #4 — Which, that's our point. Mattaniah Jahn — and there has to be an availability issue. One of the requirements of the approval of this, and it's already in the file is that Capital will make this site available at market rates. So that's a, if it's available at market rate there's not even an economic incentive for a carrier to build their own site. Again, as I was saying, going this route is hard. It's easier to collocate. That's just a building permit. They're up and they're on air and they're providing service which is increasingly important as we go along. Speaker #? — Isn't that counter -intuitive? m Al Baxa — Yeah, why doesn't Verizon give me a call? oo Mattaniah Jahn — I don't know what the nature of your relationship is with Verizon but a� Al Baxa — they're already on the tower c Mattaniah Jahn — I understand that much. Speaker#? — how many years? z Irene Herring — Verizon is on a tower? E Al Baxa - yes, they're already on our tower Irene Herring — Then why can't I get any reception? They know where I live. a r Al Baxa — You have to talk to Verizon about that. c Mattaniah Jahn — They need to update their.... z 2 a Multiple Speakers - .... Verizon has Al Baxa — Verizon has been on our tower, started out as Altela actually. But Verizon has been on our tower for at least a decade. Speaker #4 — That's evidence that there's absolutely no need for an additional tower if they're already renting space. Page 10 of 13 Packet Pg. 108 8.A.8 Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 07-10-2019 Mattaniah Jahn — I understand. Irene Harring — But not only that, but when you think about it they're bringing up five ... and the emissions are going to get even worse. You know, and, I've already dealt with two cancers. I can deal with another one, but I shouldn't have to. Along with everything else that comes along. Two men speaking — Is it a business decision or an engineering one? Speaker #? — It's a business decision because they don't like our rent. L Speaker #? — Yes. a� 0 Mattaniah Jahn — I appreciate that's your opinion. Ummm... the orders that I'm getting from c c Verizon is that they need to go onto a new tower. Al Baxa — Have someone from Verizon give me a call, will you please. E Mattaniah Jahn — Absolutely c°� Al Baxa - Okay? .... It's you against a large corporation, that's all it is. c Mattaniah Jahn — Do we have any other questions about this site? c Irene Herring — What is the expected time for erecting? c m Donald Herring — My question.... let's take....how many people here are for it? oo le Irene Harring — I've already stated, I'm not. But, you know, that and a nickle gets you nothing. a� Donald Herring — Well, you can see that everybody I know is in opposition of it. o Speaker #4 — So the community that's effected has zero approval. ti z Speaker #? — Hell, I'll knock on doors if I have to. Irene Herring — Well you have to understand that people that live along over by the canal, it doesn't effect them. What happens over here... down the road... M Donald Herring — Well, the next thing is a Irene Herring - ....that doesn't effect them what's over here.... r E Speaker #3 — My next question is, what happens with regulations pertaining to a gated community, can you take and put a tower up in a gated community? Now my wife, she's got a a cam -light, she deals with home owners associations and so on and it's supposed to be anytime anything takes place in a gated community it's gotta go before our architectural review committee and there's a whole procedure and the attendants and residents and everybody gets to approve it — approves it. This is coming in and there's thirty families not here that are going to see this thing going up whether they want it or not and why they're not here is beyond me. Page 11 of 13 Packet Pg. 109 8.A.8 Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 07-10-2019 Speaker #4 — Work. People have lives. I'd love to go to all the meetings too but I don't have the time. You're getting the representation of all those families right here. You have somebody who owns a tower, right there and renting space, that's already renting to Verizon. Mattaniah Jahn — I appreciate that. Donald Herring — I sealed my property in 1987. I've been there over thirty years. Speaker #? - ...it's like Crown Castle. I know Crown. Mattaniah Jahn — Is there any other questions I can answer? I would hate to take up anymore of your evening. Donald Herring — I know that they're preferring this particular area for some reason. Is there a reason they're particular? I mean we've got from alligator alley for the toll booth over to Ft. Lauderdale all on the south side of the .... Mattaniah Jahn — most of that is on the south side of their search area. Again, the nature of a cellular network is that they have to be located within certain places in order to be able to cover Donald Herring - to receive it and... Mattaniah Jahn - and to talk with the other towers. So, there's a specific geographic radius. It's a mile in diameter, a half mile radius and that informs a lot of where this goes. The other things 00 you run into are things such as access to roads... Donald Herring — Then what you're saying — the current wave FM radio tower that's located there would be ideal Mattaniah Jahn — I'm sure if Verizon could stay on there, they would. Al Baxa — Then have them talk to me. They haven't reached out to me. I manage the tower. Donald Herring — He's the engineer in charge of wave FM radio station. Speaker #7 — I'm general manager. We could renegotiate. Donald Herring — Absolutely. Mattaniah Jahn — Okay. Well, that's something I will take back to Verizon. Donald Herring — Thank you. Speaker #7 - They need to talk to us though and not just go out and threaten to go out and build a tower. Mattaniah Jahn — Well, as far as this goes this is a full application. So, Donald Herring — I understand that. But if they aren't happy with the rates they're paying, they need to talk to us. Page 12 of 13 Packet Pg. 110 8.A.8 Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 07-10-2019 Mattaniah Jahn — I understand. And if you like we can discuss that a little further afterwards so that way I can make sure I get your contact information over. Donald Herring — Sure. Mattaniah Jahn — Anyone else? I would hate to take up anymore of your night. I know you're ... are we good? Irene Herring — No, but it'll have to do. Mattaniah Jahn — Other than this just going away is there anything I can do to the design of this tower. Irene Herring — Yay, you can give me an ... if Verizon already has a ... on the tower. Why are 0 we having so much problems getting reception? Mattaniah Jahn — They need to update to the modern technology. v Irene Herring — So what's wrong with sending a truck out and doing that? You've already got cc the dish up. Put another one up. �° c Mattaniah Jahn — Verizon is telling me that they need to go on to a new tower to do it. ° c as Irene Herring — Bull shit. 00 Donald Herring - No. 00 T Irene Herring - Honey, I already own swamp land. a� Speaker #? — I hate to say it, I do the plan reviews for that. They update their equipment monthly. We get AT&T and Verizon monthly at the county. They're updating it all the time. There's no reason for that. Z Mattaniah Jahn — Alright, if that's everything. I won't hold you here any longer. Donald Herring — Thank you. I suggest whoever is engineering this project comes down and takes samples along that roadway because they're gonna find that it's not stable enough for heavy equipment ... Mattaniah Jahn — I understand and the planner here, Mr. Martinez, is aware of that and I'm sure it'll be relayed back to county staff regarding to, if I may. Speaker #3 - .... I've got two years of engineering under my belt from college. I worked with the common engineers, we built bridges ... I know what it takes to put up a piece of heavy equipment. In fact I even parachuted them out of the back of an airplane. Discussion ended. Mattaniah Jahn — Alright, the time is 6:03pm and concluding the Neighborhood Information Meeting. Page 13 of 13 Packet Pg. 111 8.A.8 June 19, 2019 ALPERT, NORMAN R 11800 TAMIAMI TRL E NAPLES, FL 34113-7909 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: Description: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' m AGL telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. oo 00 In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The o Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on July 10, 2019 at 5:30pm at VFW, 13131 ti Collier Blvd., Naples, FL 34119. At this meeting the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc Packet Pg. 112 8.A.8 June 19, 2019 BACCAM, SANG & SOUNITTA JANET LIEMTHONG ET AL 2280 EVERGLADES BLVD S NAPLES, FL 34117-6808 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: Description: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' AGL telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. 00 T �r In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on July 10, 2019 at 5:30pm at VFW, 13131 Collier Blvd., Naples, FL 34119. At this meeting the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc Packet Pg. 113 8.A.8 June 19, 2019 BROWN JR TR, JAMES A 1051 CLARK ST ABINGDON, VA 24210-2052 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: Description: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' m AGL telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. oo 00 In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The o Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on July 10, 2019 at 5:30pm at VFW, 13131 ti Collier Blvd., Naples, FL 34119. At this meeting the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc Packet Pg. 114 8.A.8 June 19, 2019 CONGINE, BETTY MAE 1704 BENTON RD NAPLES, FL 34117 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: Description: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' m AGL telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. oo 00 In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The o Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on July 10, 2019 at 5:30pm at VFW, 13131 ti Collier Blvd., Naples, FL 34119. At this meeting the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc Packet Pg. 115 8.A.8 June 19, 2019 FOLINO, KRYSTAL WILLIAM W MEE JR 4778 STONO LINKS DR HOLLYWOOD, SC 29449-5984 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: Description: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' AGL telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. 00 T �r In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on July 10, 2019 at 5:30pm at VFW, 13131 Collier Blvd., Naples, FL 34119. At this meeting the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc Packet Pg. 116 8.A.8 June 19, 2019 HARRING, DONALD R & IRENE H 1751 BENTON RD NAPLES, FL 34117-8864 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: Description: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' m AGL telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. oo 00 In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The o Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on July 10, 2019 at 5:30pm at VFW, 13131 ti Collier Blvd., Naples, FL 34119. At this meeting the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc Packet Pg. 117 8.A.8 June 19, 2019 KOGER-SCOTT, SHIRLEY 1750 BENTON RD NAPLES, FL 34117-8863 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: Description: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' m AGL telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. oo 00 In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The o Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on July 10, 2019 at 5:30pm at VFW, 13131 ti Collier Blvd., Naples, FL 34119. At this meeting the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc Packet Pg. 118 8.A.8 June 19, 2019 MENDEZ, IVAN 1818 BENTON RD NAPLES, FL 34117-7853 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: Description: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' m AGL telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. oo 00 In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The o Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on July 10, 2019 at 5:30pm at VFW, 13131 ti Collier Blvd., Naples, FL 34119. At this meeting the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc Packet Pg. 119 8.A.8 June 19, 2019 MUNRO, JAMES 1850 BENTON RD NAPLES, FL 34117-7853 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: Description: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' m AGL telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. oo 00 In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The o Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on July 10, 2019 at 5:30pm at VFW, 13131 ti Collier Blvd., Naples, FL 34119. At this meeting the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc Packet Pg. 120 8.A.8 June 19, 2019 MURRAY, BARBARA LYNN 2650 WARDLOW AVE SAN DIEGO, CA 92154-4235 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: Description: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' m AGL telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. oo 00 In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The o Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on July 10, 2019 at 5:30pm at VFW, 13131 ti Collier Blvd., Naples, FL 34119. At this meeting the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc Packet Pg. 121 8.A.8 June 19, 2019 RESOURCE CONSERVATION PROP INC 9990 COCONUT RD # 200 BONITA SPRINGS, FL 34135-8488 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: Description: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' m AGL telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. oo 00 In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The o Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on July 10, 2019 at 5:30pm at VFW, 13131 ti Collier Blvd., Naples, FL 34119. At this meeting the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc Packet Pg. 122 8.A.8 June 19, 2019 SIT, ANITA 108 SAINT MICHAELS CT DALY CITY, CA 94015-2162 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: Description: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' m AGL telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. oo 00 In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The o Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on July 10, 2019 at 5:30pm at VFW, 13131 ti Collier Blvd., Naples, FL 34119. At this meeting the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc Packet Pg. 123 8.A.8 June 19, 2019 TAFARA LODGE LLC 3585 41 ST AVE NE NAPLES, FL 34120 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: Description: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' m AGL telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. oo 00 In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The o Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on July 10, 2019 at 5:30pm at VFW, 13131 ti Collier Blvd., Naples, FL 34119. At this meeting the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc Packet Pg. 124 8.A.8 AME1 ALPERT, NORMAN R 11800 TAMIAMI TRL E ALPERT, NORMAN R 11800 TAMIAMI TRL E BACCAM, SANG & SOUNITTA JANET LIEMTHONG ET AL BROWN JR TR, JAMES A LAND TRUST CONGINE, BETTY MAE 1704 BENTON RD FOLINO, KRYSTAL WILLIAM W MEE JR HARRING, DONALD R & IRENE H 1751 BENTON RD KOGER-SCOTT, SHIRLEY 1750 BENTON RD MENDEZ, IVAN 1818 BENTON RD MENDEZ, IVAN 1818 BENTON RD MUNRO, JAMES 1850 BENTON RD MURRAY, BARBARA LYNN 2650 WARDLOW AVE MURRAY, BARBARA LYNN 2650 WARDLOW AVE MURRAY, BARBARA LYNN 2650 WARDLOW AVE MURRAY, BARBARA LYNN 2650 WARDLOW AVE MURRAY, BARBARA LYNN 2650 WARDLOW AVE RESOURCE CONSERVATION PROP INC 9990 COCONUT RD # 200 SIT, ANITA 108 SAINT MICHAELS CT TAFARA LODGE LLC 3585 41 ST AVE NE TAFARA LODGE LLC 3585 41 ST AVE NE TAFARA LODGE LLC 3585 41 ST AVE NE TAFARA LODGE LLC 3585 41 ST AVE NE TAFARA LODGE LLC 3585 41 ST AVE NE NAME3 2280 EVERGLADES BLVD S UTD 09/15/88 4778 STONO LINKS DR 00 00 v Property Owners List for 7-10-19 NIM Packet Pg. 125 8.A.8 NAM E4 1051 CLARK ST NAME5 NAME6 NAPLES, FL 34113--- 7909 NAPLES, FL 34113--- 7909 NAPLES, FL 34117--- 6808 ABINGDON, VA 24210--- 2052 NAPLES, FL 34117 --- 0 HOLLYWOOD, SC 29449--- 5984 NAPLES, FL 34117--- 8864 NAPLES, FL 34117--- 8863 NAPLES, FL 34117--- 7853 NAPLES, FL 34117--- 7853 NAPLES, FL 34117--- 7853 SAN DIEGO, CA 92154--- 4235 SAN DIEGO, CA 92154--- 4235 SAN DIEGO, CA 92154--- 4235 SAN DIEGO, CA 92154--- 4235 SAN DIEGO, CA 92154--- 4235 BONITA SPRINGS, FL 34135--- 8488 DALY CITY, CA 94015--- 2162 NAPLES, FL 34120 --- 0 NAPLES, FL 34120 --- 0 NAPLES, FL 34120 --- 0 NAPLES, FL 34120 --- 0 NAPLES, FL 34120 --- 0 r 00 00 Property Owners List for 7-10-19 NIM I Packet Pg. 126 8.A.8 Date: July 10, 2019 Benton Road Relo/Naples Park: NEIGHBORHOOD MEETING SIGN -IN SHEET Name Address Email Address 2. de a(b c 3. e 0 4. ,. r,-in_. r ' 0 U 6. 0 7. w c 0 r c m 9. r 00 00 10. r O 11. ti 12. Z 13. 0) E 14. a 15. E 16. a 17. Packet Pg. 127 8.A.8 Date: July 10, 2019 Benton Road Relo/Naples Park: NEIGHBORHOOD MEETING SIGN -IN SHEET Name Address Email Address \ �Lc�►t �.� 1. �.J�L.. b r� n e %�O rn� i 2. V t 0 " ?♦ N ` '( 6 _ ,P. 1 7iZ- I�tTD�C©/� j o�9 Cl I iOi 3 3. 0 4. r R 5. E E 6. 0 U 0 7. 0 0 r c as m 9. r 00 10. CD r O 11. ti 12. Z U 13. w 14. a 15. 0 E 16. a 17. Packet Pg. 128 Date: July 10, 2019 Benton Road Relo/Naples Park: 8.A.8 NEIGHBORHOOD MEETING SIGN -IN SHEET Name Address Email Address 2. 3. c 10 C 0 4. C 5. E E 0 U 6. 0 7. w C 0 r c m r 9. °° 00 10. r O 11. ti z 12. 13. 0 E 14. a 15. E 16. a 17. Packet Pg. 129 8.A.10 Opposition Letters0 00 00 L J C O y O Q u Packet Pg. 130 8.A.10 FORSYTH & BR UGGER, P.A. Attorneys at Law John N. Bruggu• Master of Laws in Taxation John N. Bragger IIIfi Master of Laws in Taxation *Also Admitted in Michigan f Also Admitted in Kentucky John F. Forsyth 1921 — 2000 July 23, 2019 Via Email and US Mail to: gilbertmartinez(acolliercountxfly Mr. Gilbert Martinez Principal Planner Collier County Development Services 2800 Horseshoe Dr. Naples, FL 34104 Re: Application by James Munro to Install a Telecommunications Tower Dear Mr. Martinez: 600 Fifth Avenue South; Suite 207 Naples, FL 34102 Phone: (239) 263-M Fax: (239)263.6757 Email jbrugger@forsythbtugger.vom Forsyth & Bragger, P. A. represents Alpine Broadcasting Corporation (WAVV 101.1 on the FM Dial) ("Alpine") and the Alpert family having ownership thereof. Alpine and the Alpert family recently received a notice concerning a proposal to construct a new 225 foot telecommunications tower (the "Munro Tower") on Tract 107 of Floridan Farms Sites, Inc, according to Plat thereof recorded in Plat Book 4, page 33 of the Public Records of Collier County, lying and being within Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County Florida (the "Munro Property"). A copy of this notice it attached as Exhibit A. Alpine and the Alpert family strongly object to approval of a telecommunications tower on the Munro Property. Please be informed of the following information. Alpine and the Alpert family currently own and operate a 1000-foot telecommunications tower (the "Alpert Tower") on their 131 acre property located in Sections 23 and 26 of Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County Florida (the "Alpert Property") which tower is located approximately 2,500 feet, as the crow flies, from the proposed location of the Munro Tower. I have attached hereto as Exhibit B an aerial photo showing the location of the Alpert property on which the location of the Alpert Tower can be clearly seen. The Munro Property is also highlighted in yellow southeast of the Alpert property. r 00 00 Packet Pg. 131 8.A.10 Attached as Exhibit C, is a diagram, identifying the location of existing telecommunication equipment installed on the Alpert Tower. According to Al Baxa, the engineer responsible for placement and maintenance of equipment on the Alpert Tower, significant space is available for additional installation of equipment, including at the levels of 225 feet and below negating the need for the Munro Tower in such close proximity. Depending on the location and frequency of transmission equipment which might be located on the Munro Tower there is a possibility that the Munro Tower could interfere with reception and transmission from the lower levels of the Alpert Tower. 3 0 When Alpert Tower was constructed, despite the fact that Alpert Tower is a self -collapsing tower, 0 Collier County required that the Alpert family acquire sufficient property so that if the tower were to fall straight out without collapse Alpert Tower would fall on vacant land owned by the Alpert family. E E If you note the location of the Alpert Tower on the Alpert Property you will find Alpert owns over E 1000 feet in any direction from the base of the1000 foot Alpert Tower, The Munro property is not of sufficient width to result in the proposed Munro Tower to remain on e 0 Munro Property in the event it was to fall straight over instead of collapsing. c c Further, the proposed entrance to the Munro Property is by way of Benton Road. Please seethe m attached Exhibit D, an email response from Samantha Roe, Operation Coordinator. Road co co Maintenance Division, Collier County, Florida. Benton Road is a private road. It is not owned or maintained by the public or Collier County. In fact, Benton Road was filled and is maintained by the Alpert family under an agreement with the multiple property owners across whose land the roadway passes. The Munro Property has no legal access to the Munro Property. Statements were made at a public hearing to discuss the proposed Munro Tower that the tower was to be constructed to provide Verizon with tower access in this area of eastern Collier County, when ,in fact, Exhibit C attached shows that Verizon already has telecommunication equipment installed on the Alpert Tower and according to the tower engineer, Al Baxa, there is sufficient capacity on the Alpert Tower for any increased installation of telecommunication equipment desired by Verizon or any other carrier, whether such need is below or above the proposed height of the Munro Tower. Based upon the facts set forth above, Alpine Broadcasting Corporation and the Alpert family are strongly opposed to approval of the proposed Munro Tower. Please contact me with any additional questions or concerns. Slncer le y; r �r John N.,$rugger Cc: Mark Strain Packet Pg. 132 8.A.10 LAW OFFICI--' OF 935 Main. Street, Suite D1 Safetv Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 June 19, 2019 MUNRO, JAMES 1850 BENTON RD NAPLES, FL 34117-7853 Dear Property Owner: E E Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking v approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: 0 Description: Of/ of'Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28"' Avenue SE. Make u right on 6Voodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed doticn Benton Road approximately o 1 mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the m left. 00 00 The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' AGL telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. N In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become frilly aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on July 10, 2019 at 5:30pm at VFW, 13131 Collier Blvd., Naples, FL 34119. At this meeting the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely. Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc Packet Pg. 133 8.A.10 Page 1 of I r co co ,. _.. nn, n . A.0z11 '75')1 F14475R2.iniz Packet Pg. 134 WAVV TOWER TENANTS 1/201.8 `_`"WAVV - S BAY ERI 968 FT - WAVVHID 4BAY ANTENNA 92IFT WAVY- MARTI REC. ANT. 775 FT 750FT COLLIER COUNTY SCHOOLS 730 FT 500FT —COLLIER COUNTY PAGING 700 FT --COLLIER COUNTY PAGING 675 FT �`�COLLIER COUNTY SCHOOLS 675 FT DEA 2 WAY 430 FT NOAA WEATHER SERVICE 400 FT ___"WAVV - STL AND TSL LINK 325 FT 25OFT —~ " COLL ER COUNTY 2WAY ^ COUNTY WIDE SYSTEM 3 - 2 WAY ANT. Pa 300 FT �____'VERIZON 6 ANTENNAS 220 FT Collier COUNTY IDISH 185 FT Collier COUNTY DISH 140 FT L a� 3 0 c O U E E O U m O 0' C 0 c m m 00 00 L J 0 y O CL 0. 0 c 0 u m r a c a� E u a Packet Pg. 135 8.A.10 E1.F-Sl Jack Bruqqer From: RoeSamantha <Samantha.Roe@colliercountyfl.gov> on behalf of Road Maintenance <roadmaintenance@colliercou ntyfl.gov> Sent: Thursday, July 11, 2019 12:02 PM To: Jack Brugger; Road Maintenance Subject: RE: Benton Road John, Benton Road is not County Maintained. You may check the Collier County Property Appraiser to see ownership of individual parcels: http://www.colliel appraiser.com . Thank you, Samantha Roe Operations Coordinator o 0 co ter Coufity Road Maintenance Division Exceeding Expectations, Every Day! 00 00 4800 Davis Blvd, Naples Florida 34104 1 Phone: 239.252.8924 Fax: 239.774.6406 -- Email: Roadmainienance qo iercoun fl. ov to Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public recordSL If you do not want your a -mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic, mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. J c O w O Q Q Frorn: Jack Brugger <jbrugger@forsythbrugger,com> 0 Sent: Thursday, July 11, 2019 11:41 AM }, To: Road Maintenance <roadmaintenance @colliercountyfl.gov> a� Subject: Benton Road t R w r Dear Sir or Madam; a Please provide me with information as to whether Benton Road, which runs easterly from Woodlands Estates E Road in Collier County is: 1) a public road, and ii) maintained by Collier County? r r a Thanks, John N. Brugger Forsyth & Brugger, P.A. does not send nor receive wire instructions via email without confirming information via reciprocating telephone calls or direct person to person contact. Under no circumstances should you send any funds to any party without first calling Forsyth_&_Brugger, P.A. at 239-263-6000 and verifying the accuracy of wire instructions provided to you. Thank you for your patience and understanding as we make every effort we can to protect your interests. Packet Pg. 136 8.A.10 935 Main Street, Suite D: Safety Harbor, FL 3469! Telephone: (727) 773-222' Facsimile: (727) 773-2611 SENT VIA CITY VIEW UPLOAD ONLY November 19, 2020 Laura DeJohn Collier County Growth Management Department 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 RE: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC — Benton Road/Naples Park Conditional Use Request PL#20180002327 Response to Staff Comments Dated July 10, 2019, Response to Objection Letter Dated July 23, 2019, and Supplement to Application Dear Ms. DeJohn: On behalf of my client, Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC (Capital) please find the included response oo to comments dated July 10, 2019, response to objection letter dated July 23, 2019, and r supplemental documents for application PL#20180002327 along with supporting documentation: Supporting Documentation: • Colocation Application from AT&T • Non -Interference Letter from Verizon • Revised Set of Plans • Kimley-Horn Opinion Letter Supplemental Documents: • Access & Utilities Easement from Kuszlyk • Access & Utilities Easement from Beddoe • Revised Survey • Benton Road Access Easements (12 Documents) Summary of Response Capital respectfully responds to comments dated July 10, 2019 and responds to objection letter dated July 23, 2019. For clarity, comments are italicized while Capital's responses are bolded. Additionally, Capital respectfully amends the application to provide access to the North over Parcels #32634600006, and 32634640008 instead of to the West. Page 1 of 6 Capital — Naples Park Packet Pg. 137 8.A.10 Response to Staff Comments Dated July 10, 2019 Rejected Review: Environmental Review Reviewed By: Craig Brown Email. Craig. Brown@colliercountyfl.gov Phone #: (239) 252-2548 Correction comment 1: Principle structures must be setback a minimum of 25 feet from the boundary of preserves and accessory structures, a minimum of 10 feet from the boundary of preserves. No site alteration, placement of fill, grading, plant alteration or removal, or similar activity shall be permitted within 10 feet of preserves except where swales are provided in accordance with LDC 4.06.05 J. or untreated stormwater is directed away from preserves (LDC 3. 05. 07 H.3.). (Provide a note or illustrate the setback on Master Plan). Review 2: Please clam that propose structures will meet the setback requirements; Update the setback table and illustrate the setbacks on exhibit sheet Cl. The compound area shown on sheet 00 C2 needs to be setback 25 feet from the preserve area. The extended guy wires will need to be oo setback 10 feet from the preserve; please show this on sheet Cl and update the setbacks on the 14 setback tables. Review 3: Please add a note to plans showing the guy wires will meet 10 foot back from the preserve. Please see the Guy Wire Setback Note on Sheet Cl. Correction comment 2: Exhibit A-1 indicates a trail/road within the proposed preserve area. Is this trail/road proposed please clarify. If so has the area been subtracted from the preserve calculations? If this is not proposed please remove the trail/road from the plans. The trail/road is not proposed in the preserve area and has been removed from the plans. Please see Sheet Al. The following comments are information and/or may include stipulations Applicants who are converting a paper submittal to E-Permitting must resubmit complete sets of all plans, signed and sealed, even if they were previously approved on an earlier review. As a reminder, all documents that are required to be signed and sealed must be digitally signed and sealed when submitting through our E-Permitting process. On the cover letter please identify that previous submittals were done through paper and that this Page 2 of 6 Capital — Naples Park Packet Pg. 138 8.A.10 submittal is by E-Permitting. Also, identification of the changes in cover letter (ex. See note #23 Civil Plan Sheet 4) improves the efficiency of the resubmittal review. When addressing review comments, please provide a cover letter outlining your response to each comment. Include a response to completed reviews with stipulations. Please be advised that Sections 10.02.03.H.1, and 10.02.04.B.3c requi4ee that a re - submittal must be made within 270 days of this letter. Noted. Stipulations: • The 20'x20' wide buffer shown around the guy anchors shall be removed from the final conceptual plan to avoid confession. There is no minimum buffer width required around the guy anchors. Just a 3' high hedge with shrubs spaced 3' o.c. A 20' wide landscape buffer is shown around the compound. The 20'x20' wide buffers shown m around the guy anchors have been removed from the plans. Capital will provide the required hedges during Site Plan review. Please see Sheet L1. 00 T Response to Obiection Letter Dated July 23, 2019 Forsyth & Brugger, P. A. represents Alpine Broadcasting Corporation (WAW 101. I on the FM Dial) ("Alpine') and the Alpert family having ownership thereof Alpine and the Alpert family recently received a notice concerning a proposal to construct a new 225 foot telecommunications tower (the "Munro Tower') on Tract 107 of Floridan Farms Sites, Inc, according to Plat thereof recorded in Plat Book 4, page 33 of the Public Records of Collier County, lying and being within Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County Florida (the "Munro Property'). A copy of this notice it attached as Exhibit A. Alpine and the Alpert family strongly object to approval of a telecommunications tower on the Munro Property. Capital has not and is not currently requesting a Conditional Use, or any other Land Development application, on tract 107 of the Floridan Farms Sites. Page 3 of 6 Capital — Naples Park Packet Pg. 139 8.A.10 Please be informed of the following information. Attached as Exhibit C, is a diagram, identifying the location of existing telecommunication equipment installed on the Alpen Tower. According to Al Baxa, the engineer responsible for placement and maintenance of equipment on the Alpert Tower, significant space is available for additional installation of equipment, including at the levels of 225 feet and below negating the need for the Munro Tower in such close proximity. The Alpert Tower does not have the structural capacity to support Verizon's updated antennas, therefore, the Alpert Tower would not meet Verizon's RF objectives. Further, Capital now has an additional carriers with interest in the Guyed Tower. Please see the RF Package on file, Colocation Application from AT&T, and the Kimley Horn Opinion Letter. Depending on the location and frequency of transmission equipment which might be located on the Munro Tower there is a possibility that the Munro Tower could interfere with reception and transmission from the lower levels of the Alpert Tower. The Guyed Tower will not interfere with reception and transmission of the Alpert Tower. Please see the enclosed Non -Interference Letter from Pavitra Jaiswal, an RF engineer with Verizon. When Alpert Tower was constructed, despite the fact that Alpert Tower is a self -collapsing tower, Collier County required that the Alpert family acquire sufficient property so that if the tower were to fall straight out without collapse Alpert Tower would fall on vacant land owned by the Alpert family. If you note the location of the Alpert Tower on the Alpert Property you will find Alpert owns over 1000 feet in any direction from the base of the 1000 foot Alpert Tower, The Munro property is not of sufficient width to result in the proposed Munro Tower to remain on the Munro Property in the event it was to fall straight over instead of collapsing. The Guyed Tower will be compliant with the Collier County Code and will be designed with a 120' Fall Zone Radius. In the unlikely event of structural failure, the Guyed Tower will not collapse. Rather, it will fold over upon itself and be completely contained within the Fall Zone Radius on the Parent Parcel. Please see Sheet Al. Page 4 of 6 Capital — Naples Park Packet Pg. 140 8.A.10 To the extent Alpine contends that it was required to provide specific separations, the requirements placed upon a different tower, on a different parcel, at a distant time in the past, is not competent substantial evidence when considering the Conditional Use for the tower at bar. Further, the proposed entrance to the Munro Property is by way of Benton Road Please see the attached Exhibit D, an email response from Samantha Roe, Operation Coordinator. Road Maintenance Division, Collier County, Florida. Benton Road is a private road. It is not owned or maintained by the public or Collier County. In fact, Benton Road was filled and is maintained by the Alpert family under an agreement with the multiple property owners across whose land the roadway passes. The Munro Property has no legal access to the Munro Property. The Guyed Tower now possesses legal access from the parent parcel to 28' Avenue SE, a public Right of Way. Please see the Easement and Road Exhibit, which is found on page 12 of the Revised Site Plan Set, as well as the enclosed Beddoe Easement, Kuszlyk Easement, and Benton Road Access Easements. Statements were made at a public hearing to discuss the proposed Munro Tower that the tower was to be constructed to provide Verizon with tower access in this area of eastern Collier County, when, in fact, Exhibit C attached shows that Verizon already has telecommunication equipment installed on the Alpert Tower and according to the tower engineer, Al Baxa, there is sufficient capacity on the Alpert Tower for any increased installation of telecommunication equipment desired by Verizon or any other carrier, whether such need is below or above the proposed height of the Munro Tower. Verizon is currently collocated on the Alpert Tower, however, no public hearings have been held for the Guyed Tower. The Alpert Tower does not have the structural capacity for Verizon's new modernized deployment, therefore, it would not meet Verizon's RF objectives. Further, Capital now has an additional carrier and other wireless providers with interest in the Guyed Tower. Please see the enclosed Colocation Application from AT&T, as well as the RF Package on file and the Kimley Horn Opinion Letter. Page 5 of 6 Capital - Naples Park Packet Pg. 141 8.A.10 Thank you in advance for your assistance in this matter. Please do not hesitate to contact me if I am able to provide you with additional information. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. ✓ r MSJ/vlc Enclosures Page 6 of 6 T- oo 00 T Capital — Naples Park Packet Pg. 142 8.A.10 FinnTimoth From: Sr Moose <srmoose@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, December 21, 2020 6:55 PM To: FinnTimothy Subject: Benton Rd Cell Tower Attachments: Capital 04 Revised Set of Plans.pdf EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. 3 0 Hello a #1 Opposition c� I wanted to voice my opposition to the Benton rd cell phone tower for the following reasons. U The project plans for the use of Woodland Estates Rd (a private road) as access but the company will not commit to any form of maintenance of this private road. Residents along Benton Rd use 28th Ave SE Ext for access to their properties E (except 2661 Benton). This is also the shortest distance from the proposed cell phone tower to the public bridge at 28th 0 0 Ave SE. Without any sort of commitment to do some sort of road maintenance on the portion of Woodland Estates Rd they plan to use then I and other neighbors do not want them using it. 0 The access to the road had been part of the 3rd amended agreement between Collier County and SFWMD and the BCC ° Executive summary from Jan 2012. We had been in litigation regarding access to Woodland Estates. It was our ° c understanding that the residents on Woodland Estates Rd could control access to the road. The commercial cell phone m tower would seriously complicate this issue. #2 Opposition 00 00 The Benton Rd Cell phone tower project has prescribed fires as a means of forest management. My and 11 of my neighbors in this same neighborhood lost our homes to fire earlier this year in a "wildfire". We have known of prescribed i burns that have gotten out of control nearby. We all greatly fear this means of management especially on such a small parcel. We do not want any fires in our neighborhood even if prescribed. Thi should never be done without the resources in o place at homes that the fire department was not able to save in the May fires or at all of the remaining homes that did N not burn. See page 12 of proposed plan, attached. 0 #3 Opposition Q- O Most of the neighbors who will be affected by this project were not notified of this project via any means including the "NIM". Only property owners within 1000ft were notified in an area where a large portion of the parcels are longer than 1000ft and where they plan to use over 1 mile of private roads. All persons affected and any persons who have interests E in the private easements they plan to use should be notified. Woodland Estates Rd is not the nearest access and should not be part of this. Q thank you Dan McMahon 2311 Woodland Estates Rd s Naples FL 34117 239-353-8544 Q i Packet Pg. 143 8.A.10 BENTON ROAD RELO (NAPLES PARK) (PL20180002327) ROAD NAPLES, FLORIDA 34117CAPITAT (COLLIER COUNTY) T E L E C O M PROPOSED 220' GUYED COMMUNICATION TOWER WITH SUPPORT FACILITIES LOCAL MAP PROPERTY SUMMARY PROJECT INFORMATION INDEX OF DRAWINGS PARCEL /: 328N220009 32634600006 326N640008 1. CONTRACTOR'S SHALL VERIFv ALL PLS AND EXISTING PLANS I EASO S AND CONDITIONS ON THE JOB —GANG SHALL DESCRIPTION . NO. PEP. NO. ."UM: 26 10' AS—, N LONGITUDE: 1' N' 16.98T' W MEDIATELY NOTIFY THE ENGNEER IN WRONG Or ANY DISCREPANCIES BEFGRE ROCEEDNC WIN THE WORK OR BE RESPONSIBLE FOR SAVE. LIRE SIiEET 0 GI GENERAL NOTES (I OF 2) 0 G2 GENERA NOTES (2 OF 2) O ZONING JUR60CrION: COWER COUN_ ZONING CLASSIFMATION: _Cu__ 2. 2 THIS IS AN UNWNNED FACIUN AND WILL BE USED FOR THE OF RAGIO SIGNALS FOR ME PURPOSE OF AERIA IXHR3rt 0 PRONDING PUBLIC CELLULAR SEIAICf. C1 SETBACK DETNL 0 DESIGN CRITERIA 3. CAPTAL TELECOM CERTIFIES MAT THIS EWIPMENT FACEUTY cz PROPOSED COVPWND RAN o e LocA,1o� DESIGN MND SPEED: 159 4PH (ULnWTE. ]-SECOND GUST) t23 MPH (NgN1NA, J-SECOND GUST) IUPDInANCE FACTOR 1.0 EXPOSURE: C PoSK CATEGORY; OPEN STRUCTURE um In CUSiWERS�AANo T�NAATPATHEEDWOORK AS9ocuTED IW—M ANY EWIPMENi CANNOT BE PEPo"ORMED Br HANDICAPPED PERSONS. THISCADILm WLL BE FREOUENTED GILT 8r SERGE PERSONNEL FOR REPAR PURPOSES ONLv. ♦. NO POTABLE WATER SUPPLY IS TO BE PRCNDEO AT THIS LOCATION. C3 TOIN£R EIENATKN CA WALL OETAUS 0 0 CS SILT FENCE/ACCESS DRW DETAIL 0 I WELL FIELD OVERUr 4AP 0 I PRESERVE WNAGEMENT PLAN 0 5. NO WASTEWATER WILL BE GENERATED AT MIS LOCATION. LLI BENTON ROAD E.-IT o APPLICABLE CODES 6. NO SOuO WAS E WLL BE GENERA ED AL THIS COCAION. S1 SURVEY (1 OF 2) D VICINITY MAP Mn CONTACTOR WORK S ALL COMPLY WITH ALL BY THE NATIONAL. STATE AND LOCAL CODES AS FR THE O THE LOCAL AUTHOR, HANNG JURISGTED (AU) OVER AN RDS IN . THE THE D OF C NT CONTRACT CODS AND STANDARDS SI EFFECT ON THE DATE DF CONTRACT AWARD SHALL GOVERN THE DESIGN. CONTRACTOR SHALL NOTIFY DA++ER FOR ACCscc r0 SITE. 8. THE SCOPE OF CAPITAL'S WORK 15 LIMITED TO THE TOWER, CWPOUND. DC LINTY, UnLm AND TELCO SEANCE SUPPLANTENNAS AND COWER COULTER EMERGENCY SERVICES' .WRNHIS AND AID CABINET. ALL SHELTERS M SHALL BE EQUIPPED THEY INOEPENDfNi FlRE SUPPRESSION TENS AS LHEY ARE 52 SURGE (1 O 2) 0 BUILDING COOS: FLORIDA BUILDING CODE (FBC) 6TH EDRpN (2017). INSTALLED. EACH TENANT SHALL PROVIDE INFpRMATION ON THEIR SHELTERS FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEM WHEN THEY ELECTRICAL COOS: NATKNAL RITE PROTECTION AS50CLATION (NFPA) TO APPI FOR A BUILDING PERMIT TO ADD THERL SHELTER AND ANTENNAS TO THE TOWER. NATIONAL ELECTRICAL CODE: 2014 EDITION. CONTACTS IOCATpN MECHANICAL CODE: MECHANICAL COOS 6TH EDITION. 613 FIRE CODE: FLORIDA FIRE PREVENTION CODE. 8TH EDITION. CAPITALl_ TT ELECOM UGHTHING SAEtt CODE: NNA-101-2D15 IS. T. E.E.NAPE. MORRISTOW NJ OnHO THE CONTRACTOR'S WORK SH COMPLY IN THE LATEST EDITION OF THE FOLLOWING STANDARDS. AMERICAN CONCRETE INSFRUTE PROPERtt OWNCONTACT (ACT) 318-08, BUILDING CODE REQUIREMENTS FOR STRUCTURAL CONCRETE, AMERICA INSTITUTE OF STEEL CONSTRUCTION (ASC). MANUAL OF --D: TA'ARA LODGE LLC STEEL CONSTRUCTION, LRFD I3M EDITION. TELECOMMUNICATIONS INWSTRY ASSOCIATION (TA) 222-G. STRUCTURAL STANDARDS FOR 'iFECT ONS STEEL ANTENNA S07. COMUERCULOB LDING CROUNDNG WER AND ANT N. UAND BONDING REGUTREMENTS ADDRESS: J585 41ST AVENUE NE CITY, STATE. ZIP: NAPLES. FLORIDA 34120 CONTACT: ERIK HAMIL _ZONES FOR TELECOMMUNICATIONS. M COLLIER COU—. HEAP SOUNEAST ON JAPES MEMGNAL SCENIC GENE TOWARD E (973) 425-0606 EM. I I G MAN TRA4 (DATE 12) TRAIL CONTNUE ON FL-29 N. TAKE GL WELL RD TO INBnTUTE FOR ELECFNH A AND ELECTRONICS ENGINEERS (IEEE) S1, EVERCIADES BUN) S. CONTINUE ON EVERGLADES BLVO S. DRIVE TO BENTON ROAD. SITE GUIDE FOR MEASURING EARTH RESIST—. GROUND IMPEDANCE. AND 's LOCATED ON THE LEFT HAND SIDE OF THE ROAD. EARTH SURFACE POTENTIALS OF A GROUND SSTEM. IEEE 11OD (1999) RECOMMENCED PRACTICE FOR POWERING AND CRWIOING OF MANNAT KHAN NA 239-315-9151 ELECTRONIC EQUIPMENT. =111 MSNAMP, PSN 202-212-T891 THIS DXU._ HAS BEEN ELECTIKNICALY SIGNED AND SEALED BY JEREMY D. SIWRIT, PE (/2513]) A DIGITAL SIGNATURE IN ACCORDANCE WITH RAC. 61C15-23.004. IN A DGITA CERTIFICATE ISSUED ENTRUST, INC. PLEASE REFERENCE SHEET T1 TO NEW USING BY IEEE C62.41, RECOMMENDED PRACTICES ON SURGE —ES IN LOW VOLTAGE AC POWER CIRCUITS (FOR LOCATION CATEGORY -C3- AND I.H SYSTEM EXPOSURE-). BMW' ENGNFFNNG GROUP CURTIS WHOVA 813-610-5732 FC TELCORDR GR-1225, GENERAL INSTAUATION REQUIREMENTS, TELc_ GR-IS03, CPAKIAL CABLE CORN—S.. ANSI TI.311. FOR TELECOM MATTANIAH S. JAHN, ESO. 722-223-2221 BOO TARPON WOODS BLVD. SUITE E-1 THE SIGNATURE AND GEPoFY ITS PROPERTIES. PRINTED COPIES OF MIS DOCUMENT ARE NOT CONSIDERED - X POWER SSTEUS - ELECOA, E ONMENTA OTECTON, LM HARBOR, FL 34fiB5 SIGNED AND SEXED AND ME SIGNATURE OUST BE VERIFlED ON ANY ELECTRONIC COPES. l r D BENTON 3CAJ (NAPLES PA (a]Ins'bo] (C S. I FaN. !LE SHEI T"I co co �I Q Packet Pg. 144 8.A.10 FOR THE PURPOSES OF THESE CONSTRUCTION DWWNGS. THE FOLLOWING DEDNTIONS SHALL APPLY: 1. THE APPROPRIATE UTILM LOCATING SEANCES SMALL BE CONTACTED PRIOR TO THE START OF CONSTRUCTION IN ORDER TO VEWBFY ME _v..' OWNER - CAPITAL TELEGGI LOCATION OF ALL EXISTING UNDERGROUND UTILITIES. ENGINEER - SAIw ENGINEERING GROUP INC. 2 THE IN UI ON OF NEW UHUTIES SHALL BE COORDINATED WIN LOCAL AUNDRMES. CONTRACTOR - GENERAL CONTRACTOR (CONSTRUCTION) 3. ALL EXISTING ACTNE SEWER. WATER, GAS. ELECTRIC AND OTHER UTUTRM WHERE ENCOUNTERED IN THE WORK. SHALL BE PROTECTED AT ALL 2. PRIOR TO SUBMITTING HIS BID, THE CONTRACTOR SHALL VISIT THE JOB SITE IN ORDER TO (I) VERRY ALL EXISTING CONDITIONS. (2) CONFIRM WHETHER ALL DIMENSIONS ARE AS SHOWN ON THE PLANS AND (3) CONFIRM WHETHER ME TIMES. WHERE REQUIRED FOR ME PROPER EXECUnDN OF THE WORK. SUCH IRIMES SHALL BE REU)CATED AS DIRECTED BY ME WNSTRlOT10N MANAGER, EXTREME CAUnON SHALL BE USED WHEN EXCAVATING OR DRILLING PIERS AROUND M NEAR UTILInES. WORN MAT BE ACCOYPLSHEO AS SHOWN. ANY D15CREPANOFS SHALL BE BROUGHT Tp THE ATTENMIN Cl THE CONSTRUCTION MANAGER. A RUBBISH. STUMPS, DORIS. STICKS, STONES AND OTHER REFUSE SHALL BE REMOVED FROM THE SHE AND DISPOSED OF LEGALLY. 3. A 20-FWT HORIZO CLEARANCE DISTANCE SHALL BE MANTANED FROM NL EXISTING POWER UNES. 5, ALL EXISTNG NACTNE SEWER. WATER, GAS, ELECTRIC AND OTHER U LMES MAT INTERFERE WITH THE EXECUTION OF THE MIRK SIWL BE REMOVED ANUPPE D. PD. PLUGGED OR OTHERWSE DISCONnNUED AT POINTS MAT WILL NOT INTERFERE WITH THE EXECUTION OF THE WINK. THE CONTRACTOR'S USE O A CONSTRUCTION STAGING ARU SIWL BE COORDNATEp WIN ME OWNER WELL IN ADVANCE OF ME CONSTRUCTION START UTE. SUB.IECT TO THE XRRN µ O ME UNOLORO AND/DR LOCAL UMfflES. 6. DISTURBANCE TO ME EXISTING SITE WRING GONSTRUCMN SHALL BE MINMZED, 5. LABOR. MATERIAL. TOOLS, EOU- M. TRANSPORTATION AND N MPORARY POWER SERVICES NECESSARY FOR AND INCO AL 0 COMPLETION O< NL WINK SHALL BE RQNOED AS INDICATED W E DRAWINGS AND/OR AS SPECIFIED OWEIN, Z' NN µRA OF NE CONSMUCnON SITE pSNRBEO BY ME WORK AND NOT COhPEO BY THE TONER, EOUPUEM OR DRNE\VAv, SHALL BE GRACED LABOR AND MAIERIAL5 SHALL BE Fl1RNGHED N REWIRED FOR COMFITE MR15, INCLUDING ALL ELEMENTS OBNOUSLT M REASONABLY INCIDENTµ TO A COMPLETE INSTALLATION. WHETHER OR NOT SPECIFICALLY NDKCAEW ON ME PLAN,. TO A UNIfOR4 SLOPE. SUCH CRApNG SHALL CAUSE SURFACE WATER i0 FLOW AWAY iA04 ANY EWIPYEM SHELTER AND TpWQR AREAS AND NE SQL SHALL BE STABILIZED TO P NT E-1- EROSION CONTROL MEASURES. IF REWIRED DUNK CONSTRUCT—, SHALL SE IN CONFORMANCE WHH ME LOCAL GUIDELINES FOR EROSION AND SEDIMENT CONTROL FOR TASKS REWIRED TO BE PERFORMED BUT NET CLEARLY DEFINED OR OEWTFIED BY THE CONTRACT DOCUMENTS, ME CONTIU4TER SHALL NOT START WORK W SUCH TASKS WMOUT HANNG RECENED WRTTEN ALLIMORIUTION FRO, ME B THE SUB -GRADE SHALL BE CCYPACTED AND BRpIIGM i0 A UNIFORM GRADE PRIDR TO DN5HE0 SURFACE APPLOATON. CONSWUCTXMI YANACEP TO PROCEED. 9. BACK SHALL CONSIST OF CLEAN SAND FILL APPROVED FOR USE BY ME ENGINEER. NO UNAPPRWI]1 MATERYL MALL BE µLIMED. tt SAND ME DRAWINGS AFE DMLRAUMATG AND INDICATE ME GENERAL ARRANGEMENT OF M1EWA5 AND EQUIPMENT UNLESS FILL SHALL BE FREE U ALL RDOTS. BOULDERS. OR OTHER DELETERIOUS MATERIAL OCTLIA. E AURA BY DF THE E IETNLS. EXACT EOUIPMEM LO ST L.S Y BE 4 ON AS REQUIRED BY ACTUAL ELD CONAUL PRO E SPECIFIED E CANNOT BE AS SHOWN ON MESS DRAW— ID. ME CONTRACTOR SHALL RESTORE ALL DISTURBED AREAS TO EQUAL. TO OR BETTER CONDIMN MAN DI,gNAL. ALLAEM BY THE CWTRACTOR SHALL PROPOSE AN µTERNAIN£ INSTALLATION FOR APPRQVµ BY THE ExOxEER MIDI ME CDISTRUCnON MAN GER. SHE SIGWLE SHALL BE FRONDED IN ACCORDANCE MAIM ME TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS FOR SUCH VGNACE AS MAY BE CWTMNED IN MESS oHAWNcs. B. THE CWNNNIE SHALL OBTNN, PAT FOR AND OELNER ALL REWIRED PERMITS. INSPECTION. INCLUDING CECWGHON AKJ D DOCUMENTSNTO THE CINDER Pwoa TO FINAL ACCEPTANCE OF MV ME MEETIES WORN,ANNG aLRlsperxN AND sNAu oEwER sucH SITE WORK NOTES 2 1. MA¢gMLL A. µL STRUCTURAL STEEL WORK SHALL CONFORM TO ME LATEST EDITION OF ME INK "STEEL CONSTRUCTION MANUµ". 9. THE CONTRACTOR'S OPERATIONS SHALL BE CONINED TO ARMS OF NEW CONSTRUCTION, f0. ALL NECESSARY NS SHALL BE MADE PROTECT EXISTING MPROVE4ENT5, PAVING. CURBS LROM AND TH MO SURFACES ETC. AND THE CONTPADIOR SHALL BE R PONSIBE F RE QED TO EIRE RESULTING FROM NE E CONSTRUCTION WORK. DISTURBED AND AREAS SHALL BE RESTORED LD AGEIR ORIGINAL CONDITION OR TELL STEEL WF BEAMS SHALL BE ASM A992 AND "HOT DIPPED" ULVANIZLD IN ACCORDANCE WM ASDI Al2J AND AS1M AI53 B. µ1 STANDARDS 51ANCARDS. ON ESAT BETTER UPON COMPLETION OF µL WORK TO ME SATISFACTION OF ME CONSTRUCTION MANAGER. C. ALL STRUCTU PLATES. ANGLES. AND CHANNELS SHALL BE MTN A36 AND 'HOT DIPPED" GALVANIZED IN ACCORDANCE WIN ASTM A123 AND I THE FOLLOWING CLEANUP TASKS SHALL BE PERFORMED AS FOLLOWS: (I) ON A CNLY BASIS, KEEP ME GENERALAREA A514 A153 STANDARDS. CLEAN AND HAZARD FREE. REMWNCDIPLEG µL WASTE. D®R5 AND TRASH FROM THE SITE AND DISPOSING OF SAME IN A MANNER. (2) UPON COMPLETION. IFAVE E PREMBES CLEAN CONOInON AND EE ON SPOTS. D. ALL TS MEMBERS SHALL BE ASTM 1500 GRADE B (F Afiki). AND "HOT DIPPED" GALVANIZED IN ACCORDANCE MAIM ASTY A123 AND ASTM Y' DUST. MAST. DR SMUDGES OF ANY NATURE. A153 STANDARDS. 12. ALL EQUIPMENT AND MATERIALS SHALL BE STµLEO IN ACCORDANCE MATH THE RESPECTNE UAC EEL'S L µL STRUCTURAL PIPE MEMBERS SHALL BE ASTM A500 GRADE B (Fy= kli), AND 'HOT DIPPED" GALVANIZED IN ACCORDANCE MATH ASTM A123 REWU ENUTONS EXCEPT W RE IT IS SPECIFFULLY Np TEO OTHERAIM IN ME CONTRACT DOCUMENTS OR WERE LOCAL CODES OR REGULATIONS TAKE PRECEDENCE AND ASTA A153 STANDARDS. F. ML NW_SMUCNRµ PIPE MEMBERS SHALL SE ASTM A53 GRADE B. AND "HOT DIPPED" GAVANRED IN ACCORDANCE MATH ASTM AT23 AND 13. ML WORK PERFORMED AND MATE M S INSTALLED LED SBE IN STRICT ACCORDANCE WM ALL APPLICABE CODES. ASM A'" ST'ANEARDS, REWU ICAlS D ORDINANCES. ME COMRACTM SHALL GALE ALL NOMN AND COMPLY WM TM CAWS. ORDINANCES, W RULES, EUKNLA TS AND WA FUL ORDERS OF ANY PUBLIC ALING Y NG JURR ON OVER WE PERFORMANCE OF THE WINK. MECHANICAL AND ELECTRICµ SYSTEMS SHALL BE KSTALLJED 1. ACCOtONICE MATH ALL APPLICABLE YUMCIPµ AND UFLHY COMPANY SPECIDCATIWS AS WELL AS LOCAL AND STATE CODES, ORDINANCES AND ARPUCASLE REGULATIONS. 2 DESIGN, FABR—A . AND CONSTRUCTION OF ALL CONNECTIONS SHALL CWFONM TO — STEEL CONSTRUCTION MANUAL ME CONTACTOR SHALL SUPE,MSE AND DIRECT TM WORK AT Ay TINES, USING ME BEST SKILLS AND ATTENTION. HE A SIMILL BE SO RESPONSIBLE FDIt J WFINNG. 1 ALL pF E WNSTRUCIION MEANS. MEMOOS, TEEC AWES, SEQUENCES AND PROCEDURES AND FOR COURDINARK ALL PORTIONS OF NE WALK, INCLUDING COMACT AND COORDlWXK, WM ME NL WELDS, WELDERS. AND WELD INSPECTXM SHALL CONFORM TO ME REQUIREMENTS U An D 1.1. LATEST RLVMpIt CWS1RtFCTON MANAGER AND WM ME OWNER'S AUNICRIZED REARESENTATNE. B. µ1 WELM SNA_. BE MADE WIN E2DXX LOW .vOROGEN ELECTRODES. 15. W N TEN (10) WORKING DAYSINTER PROUECi COMPLETION, ME CON- SHALL PRONOE A COMPLETE SET OF C. — STEEL SHALL BE SPRAY -CD AFTER WELDING. AS -BUILT DRAWR L , SIWEEP TEST, CYLINDER TESTS. UEN RELEASES. AND OTHER CLOSEOUT DOCUMENTATION AS REWIRED BY ME OWNER. SYSTEMS SHALL BE COMPLETELY ASSEMBLED, TESTED ADJUSTED AND DEMONSTRATED TO BE READY A ALL BOLTS SHALL BE GALVANIZED 3/4" DIAMETER. A325-N, UNLESS NOTED -SE AND TIONTENED TO A -SNUG T CONOmW AS OE-EO OR OPERATION REAR 0 ME OWNER'S ACCEPTANCE. BY NW. SECURE NUT WHIN LOCKING WA41ER. 16. ABANDONMENT NOTE: ANY TOWER THAT IS NOT OCCUPIED SY A FUNCTIONING ANTENNA FOR WNTNLOUS PERIOD OF 12 MONTHS AND HAS NO APPLICATION OR LEASE AGREEMENt TO PUCE AN TENNA ON E POWER BEING ACTNELY I ANCHOR BOLTS SHALL CONFORM i0 ASN AlOT, UNLESS NOTED OMERWSE PURSUED SHALL BE CONSIDERED ABANDONED, AND ME OWNER OF SUCH TOWER SMALL REMOVE SARIWTHIN 90 UYS OF WRITTEN NOTICE FROM ME WASHIN`i0N COUNTY DMWPMENT ADMINISTRATOR OR DESIGNEE THATWTIM ME TOWER HAS 6. ME CCTOR/STEEL FABRICATOR SHALL LOCATE ANY REINFORCEMENT IN ME STRUCTURAL TH MEMBERS IN SUCH A MANNER SO AT MERE WILL BEEN DETERMINED TO BE ABANDONED. SUCH TOWER IS NOT REM- WITHIN SAID 90 DAYS, WASHINGTON COUNTY MAv HAVE ME TOWER REMOVED AT ME OWNER'S EXPENSE. APPEALS OF ME CQUN DEVELOPMENT AOMINIST TOYS NOT BE CONFLICT WHH THE REINFORCEMENT WISH INSTALLING ANCHORS. ME ANCHORS SHALL BE INSTALLED PER ME IMNUFACIURER'S INSTRUCTION, DETER 41 TTON OF ABANDONMENT SHALL BE REVIEWED BY ME BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AND THE APPEAL QLS ME DEADLINE FOR REMOAAL. 2. ME COMPACTOR/STEEL FABRICATOR SHALL CONFORM 10 ME MINIMUM EWE 06TANCE REQUIREMENTS IN ACCORDANCE WM ME NSC MANUAL OF 2. ALL NEW METAL. TOWERS, INCLUDING ROOFTOP TOWERS, EXCEPT AIMTEUR RADIO TOWERS. SHALL COMPLY MATH ME STEEL CONSTRUCTION. STANDARDS OF THE MEN LATEST EDFON PUBLISHED BY ME ELECTRIC INDUSTRIES ASKICMTIW (CURRENTLY EIA/TIA 222-E) OR THE PUBLOATION'S SUCCESSOR FUNCTIONµ EWNALENT. UNLESS AMENDED MR LOCAL MPLU ON BY _ B SMUCTLJ µ STEEL SHALL BE OAT BRED TO FH AT BOLTED COHNEOONS WITHAL BA INC. M.—CE STR m— STEEL SHALL NOT BE RESOWDON OF ME BCC. EACH NEW NNTEUR RADIO TOWER WITH A HEIGHT OF SEVENTY -ENE (25) FEET OR LESS S_ FUME CUT UNDER AM CIRCUMSTANCES WNWT ARPROlµ OF ME ENGINEER. REWIRE A BUILDING PERMIT SPEC— ME EXACT H AND LOCATION O THE TOWER EXCLUSNE OF ANTENNAS. EACH OU5H TYPE NEW GROUND -MOUNTED D1ANTENNA MAT DOES NOT EXCEED A HEKWT O' TWE n (N) FEET SHµL REOURRE A WILONL PERMIT, 9. ME CONTRACTOR/STEEL FABRCATOR SMALL CAP OR SELL ALL PIPES AS REWIRED TO PREVENT RANWATER INMUSON. 10, TTIE CONTRACTOR/STEEL FABRICATOR SHALL SU®IIT SHOP DRAWINGS FOR REVIEW MOR TO ANY STEEL. FABRICATION. AT ME CONTRACTOR'S LLB. NO COAIMUNKATIW TONER SHALL BE?OUIID W ANY UWO OR ALTER IF SUCH LOCATION MEREDN CREATES. OR NITS ME POTEWRU. TO CREATE. NARY O ME SITE AS A SOURCE O MOLOGM PRWUCTNHW, A5 INDISPENSABLE OPnN. ELD SPECES MAY BE USED FOR ERECTION PURPOSES. 1 F SPLICES ARE USED. ME SHOP DIUWNGS SHALL INCWDE ALL DETALS FOR TIE PROPOSE. DEL➢ SPLICES_ COIAPONENfS OF VMRWS H lN)LOGIC REOMENS, OR AS IRREPUYFABLE AND CRITICAL HABITAT OR NATICE SPECIES OF FLORA OR i tt. AT ME CONTRACTOR'S OPTION, SHOP WELDS MT BE IED INSTEAD OF DEW WELDS. 19 WAL ME TOWER MALL BE xORuµLY SERNCED BY ONE (1) N9T PER GRPoER PER uOIM. t3. HU U ORONµ SHOP pR,AWNGS, INCLUDING COMPLETE DAND HEREWILi 1 FA9,LUTION AND ASSEMBLY, PROCEDURES, AND ANDRA INCLUDE DEMID S OF CUTS. CONNECTIONS, CAMBER, HOLE AND OVER oDRA UTA INDICATE WELDS STANDARDINAn A2.1 ,AND IO S DIIONS. TEMPLATES. AND DIRECTIONS FOR INSTALLATION OF ANCHOR HOR SYMBOLS. AND SNOW SIZE, IFJVGIH, AND TYPE OF WELD. PROPOSE OTHERS' BOLTS AND OVER ,ANCHORAGES 10 BE IN51µLID AS WOPoc O' DINERS' SECTIONS. GENERAL NOTES 11 1 STRUCTURAL STEEL NOTES 3 a Packet Pg. 145 8.A.10 1. ALL OWNERS OF APPROVED TOWERS ARE JOINTLY AND 5DWRALLY LABILE AND RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY DAMALE CAUSED TO OFF -SITE PROPERTY AS A RESULT OF A COW➢SE OF ANY TOWER OWNED BY THEM. LIABILITY 1. TOWERS AND ANTENNAS WIH A HEIGHT GREATER THAN 150 FEET SHALL BE REWIRED TO HAVE RED BEACON OR DUAL MORE UGHTS UNLESS EXEMPTED. IN WRITING. BY THE GGLLIOR COUNTY MDSIUITO CONTROL DISTRICT. SUCH LIGHTS SHALL MEET THE THEN EXISTING FEDERAL NATION ADMINISTRATOR (-FAA-) TECHNICAL STANDARDS. NO OTHER TOWERS OR ANTENNAS SHALL BE ARTIFICIALLY LIGHTED. EXCEPT AS REWIRED BY THE FAA THE FEDERAL OM COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION. OR OTHER APPLICABLE LAWS. ORDINANCES. DR REWLATONS. IF THE A RULES REWIRE LIGHTING. THEN THE A PUCANT SHALL CWPHAW A HEIGHT IN EXCESS OF ONE HUNDRED AND NINETYLY TN SUCH RULES. 2. NEW TOWERS EXCEEDING 1W FEE EACH NEW TOWER MAT WLL-NINE (IN) FEET ABOVEGROUND. EXCLUSIVE OF ANTENNAS. AND SUCH TOWER SHALL BE LIGHTED NO MORE THAN IS OTHERWSE REWIRED BY STATE AND OR FED RAL LAW, RULE. OR REGULATION. UNLESS OTHERWISE THEN REWIRED BY LAW, RULE OR REGULATION, ONLY WHI1E STROBE LIGHTS SHALL BE USED AT NIGHT, UNLESS DTHERWK REWIRED BY THE FAA, IN WHICH CASE RED STROBE -TYPE UGHTS STALL BE USED. SIGH LIGHTS SHALL NOT EXCEED THE MINIMUM NUMB. MINIMUM INTENSITY, AND MINIMUM UGHT FLASHES PER INTERVAL Or TIME (REWIRING THE LONGEST ALLOWABLE DURATION BETWEEN LIGHT RASHES) REQUIRED BY STATE CH FEDERAL LAW, RULE, DR REGULATION. SOLID RED (OR PULSATING RED) WARNING LIGHTS SHALL NOT BE USED AT NIGHT, TOWER LIGHTING 2 1. EFFECTIVE JANUARY I. 1992. ALL WYED TOWERS. INCLUDING OLD TOWERS. EM£EDING IBS FEET IN HEIGHT SHALL BE INSPECTED EVERY TWO (2) YEARS SUCH SELF-SUPPORTNG TOWERS SHALL BE INSPECTED EVERY FOUR (A) YEARS, EACH INSPECTION SHALL BE BY A QUALIFIED PROFEONFESSONAL SSIAL ENGINEER OR OTHER OUAUFIED PRCINSPECTOR. AND ANY INSPECTOR -RECOMMENDED REPAIRS AND/OP MAINTENANCE SHOULD BE COMPLETED WITHOUT UNNECESSARY DE AT A MINIMUM, EACH INSPECTION SHALL INCLUDE THE —WING: A TOWER STRUCTURE: INCLUDING BOLTS. LOOSE OR DAMAGED MEMBERS AND SIGNS OF UNUSUAL SIRESS OR VIBRATION_ B. WY WKS AND FITTWUS CHECK FOR AM STRENGTH, RUST. WEAR, GENERAL CONDITION. AND ANY OTHER SIGNS OF POSSIBLE FAILURE, C. WY ANCHORS ANO FOUNDATIONS ASSESS FOR CRACXS IN CONCRETE. SIGNS OF CORROSION, ER—. MOVEMENT, SECURE HARDWARE. AND GENERAL STE COHDITON. D. CONDITION OF ANTENNAS TRANSMISSION LINES. UGHTNG. PANTING. INSULATORS, FENGNG. GROUNDING, AND ELEVATOR. IF ANY. E FOR GUYED TOWERS: TOWER VERTICAL ALIONMENT AND GUY WRE TENSION (BOTH REWIRED TENSION AND PRESENT TENSION). 2. A COPY O EAOH INSPECTION REPORT SHALL BE FILED WIN THE COUNTY MANAGER NOT LATER THAN DECEMBER I OF THE RESPECTIVE INSPECTION YEAR- IF THE REPORT RECOMMENDS THAT REPAIRS OR MAINTENANCE ARE REWIRED. A LE TIER SHALL BE SUBMITTED TD THE COUNTY MANAGER TO VENrY THAT SUCH REPAIRS AND/GH MAINTENANCE HAVE BEEN COMPLETED. THE COUNTY SHALL NAYS NO RESPORSIBUTY UNDER THIS SECTION REGARDING SUCH REPAIRS AND/OR MAINTENANCE INSPECTION 13 ANY TOWER THAT IS VOLUNTARILY NOT USED FOR COMMUNICATIONS FEW A PEWW OF ONE (1) YEAR SHALL BE REMOWD Ai THE TOWER OMNER'S EXPENSE IF A TOURER IS MDT REMOVED WTHN THREE (3) MONTHS AFTER ONE (I) YEAR GH SUCH VOLUNTARY NON-USE. THE COUNTY MAY OBTAIN AUTHORIZATON, FROM A COURT OF COMPETENT JURISDIREMOVE TH CTION, TO E TOTER AND ACCESSORY ITEMS AND. AFTER REMOVAL, SHALL PLACE A LIEN W THE SUBJECT PROPERTY FOR ALL DIRECT AND INDIRECT COSTS INCURRED IN DISIAAI AND DISPOSAL OF THE TOWER AND ACCESSORY ISMS. PLUS COURT COSTS AND ATTORNEYS FEES ABANDONMENT 14 ALL EXISTING AND PROPOSED GROUNDOU MNOOFTOP TED AND RTOWERS AND ANTENNAS W A HEIGHT GREATER THAN 150 FEET SHALL BE REWIREVE D TO HAA SOLID RED BEACON COLLIER OR DUAL MODE LIGHTS UNLESS EXEMPTED IN WRING BY THE MOSDUTO CONTROL 1 DISTRICT. SUCH LIGHTS SHALL MEET THE THEN EXISTING FEDERAL AWATION ADMINISTRATION (FAA) TECHNICAL STANDARDS THE TOTAL STRUCTURE HEIGHT SHALL INCLUDE ALL APPENDAGES AND ATTACHMENTS, SUCH AS ANTENNAS, UNITS, LIGHTNING RWS OR ANY OTHER ACCESSORY DEMCE THAT MOUTA EXTEND THE HEIGHT OF THE TOWER. ALL EXISTING TOWERS SHALL HAVE SIX MONTHS (180 DAYS) FROM JUNE 16, 20M TO COMPLY WIN THE REQUIREMENT. IF THE FAA RULES REWIRE LIGHTING. THEN THE APPUCANT SHALL COMPLY WTH SUCH RULES. MOSQUITO CONTROL DISTRICT 15 1. TEMPORARY SIGNS IDENTIFYING ANY PRESERVES SHALL BE PLACED AROUND THE PERIMETER DURING CONSTRUCTION. PRESERVE SIGNAGE g mm omM�� ICAPIT, T ■ L [ C THS DOCUMENT HAS I E TPONICALLY SIGNE SEALED BY JEREMY D. PE (/""" USING A SIGNATURE IN ACCORD FAC. "G15-23.... DIGITAL CERTIFICATE IS ENTRUST, INC. PLEASE REFERENCE SHEET T1 THE -NATURE AND PV PROPERTIES. ANTED S DOCUMENT ARE N CONSIDERED SIGNED A AND THE SIGNATURE M VERIFIED ON ANY EL" COPIES. BENTON ROAD (NAPLES PA (_NXPlRazPl GENERAL NO (2 OF 2; G2 r co co Packet Pg. 146 8.A.10 T- oo 00 T Packet Pg. 147 8.A.10 ------------- IE CLOSEST UNIUnON -N IS APPROKIIMTELY I -------- In � ---------------- I I Su FT NORTHWEST OF THE ROPOSED GUTED TOWER. S INFORWDON WAS PRWDED BY AN'TENNASEARCH.CON I I tt,II,2D I I I I e�iLgFRWIBIRO IXOM VEGETATKKI SHALL BE RENOrID fROu SDL MID IT SNALL BE I I 1 I I ANNTMNED TREE OF IXOTICS W PERPm- II I I I 11 I 1 I I I 1 I II I I I I I II I I I I II I I I II I I I I - I I :► PROPOSED TOWER SETBACKS NOLE _ (POWER EDL4 TO MOPERx LNE) ALL GUT WNES MID NICJ" vRESERVE uANALENENT MtFA REgAgm PRONOEp BE SET BOCK 10' FRpI PRESERVE BWNDVNES. +• •:II I NORTH—lA'-0• Ngt1N —SDI'-0• (4) uo I I SOIL. -tap'-0' SWM -ISO'-0' (4) BO4 (vRESERVE AR EAST --1U'- 570 '-0• (4)EA) s O- FAST01 WT 118'-0• (4) PROPOSED COMPOUND SETBACKS W C IC PLO NO ONLY. THE SUBIECT PROPERtt IZB 4 • • ' . I I (EDGE OF COYPg1ND LO PROPEIttt UNE) APPEARS i0 LIE IN ZONE •AM' OG THE FLAOo (LOWER SETBACK) i- . •I I REwm INiOMpED NSURANCE M1E WP CONNUNRv PANEL N0. • • • • • • • •' • I 553'4 NORM >D'-0• AM. —HG'-0• (4) WY tN. 12 MIDD 6 WW SPEC"FLOOD`AATE OF (CCMPWND SETBACK) SOUiH — O• W ARFw ZONE 'AK: FLOOD DEPTHS OF t TO 3 FEET I _ 5)0'3 EAST—SO'_0• FAST 55y-0• (4) (U51ALLY ARCS OF PONOING): B/SE ROOD Iaa': _ _ (TOWER sETaACK) WEST WEST ELEVA1gN5 DETER o. (LOUPoIMD SETBACK) •r Q _ J •.7 _ Ewt) PROPOSED PRESERVE SETBACKS ( {p n 5 • �^ • (EOGE OF COMPI ND TO PIESERVE Bp1NDARY) NORTH ss'-0• Am. PROV m-w (S) .V. .« .'.'.'.'. .I I SW1N—ZS'-0' Sd11N—ZS'-0' (4) -------------=----------- - - EAST—25'-0• FAST—JS'-0• (4) 'REST—Z5'-0• WEST SETBACK DETAIL S Packet Pg. 148 8.A.10 FOR 2A136" NUWNGS CRAPIxC SCALE: J/- � 1'-0"____________________ Fqt tt'.I )' DRAWNGS GRAPHIC SCALE: }/tfi - I'-0" ________________________________-___________________________________ NON-EYCING — PROPOSED 20'-0' WIDE UUSNE ACCESS k PNOPOSEO 12'-0" CIN.YEL Utt EASEwENr PPARxINL SPAC—EE ACCESS ORNE SEE SHEEP TI 000 NOTE �.-0• I- OF 2) CZI I GRAILS fiY GRAPHIC PLOTTING ONLY, THE EUILEET OF THE APPEARS TO LIE IN ZONE PROPOSED 12' I OF THE FL000 EL NO. RATE 3H 1 COMMUNItt PANEL N0. 202,CONO1 WHICH 2A. D. ACCESS GTE 12'-O" -0" REARS AN IS IN NE GTE OF OD 16, I 20t2 AND IS W A SFECML FLOOD HAI TO I I AREA. ZONE 'PH': FLOOD DEPTHS OF I TO J I _ .I T-T—NANDT -D. L FEET (US— NS D OF NED. ; GSE L--_-_ _ __ ___________ UTUtt H-FRAME'_______g _ __s � ____ u _ _ ROOD EIEVAT10N5 OEIERMINED. 1ir0' 12.00 —Y-4—Y—M'—y— 6f— I I I PROPOSED A" /57 STONE I I TMN/n-U E6 FA&TC b PROPOSED 220' GUTEO i01NER � n I ROUDHOur COMPoUND ______________ i------------- _}r ____ PROPOSED 10'-D" WIDE- ON-EICWENE UTUtt EASEMENT PROPOSED RUNOFF, COMPOUND: (25 YR) Toro LEASE AREA .. F. OR D AC TOTAL C—DUND AREA: 25M S.F. OR 0.057 AC NrAL CON—D IMPERNOUS AREA C — FU—E AREAS) OW S.F. ON D.D21 AC FOR EVETNG 9TE OONNT10NS (o.ssX-)(D.o63) - D.232 - DEW:LOPED —TONS, (0rt6EX&O)(O.W) - 0132 CFS 0 32 O'SS-a0.232 OFS - 0.200 C S : - PROPOSED 20' WIDE UNDSGPE RUi1TR. SEE SHEET LI FON DETNIS 11.J3 x 1,Rk1 (FEE I' ABCiNE PROPOSED GWE). COONDINATE TOWER FOUNGTION I I CONSTRUCTION WITH FOUNGTION ' DRAWINGS RY OTHERS It.66 yi I n I IO'x20' RIUNE I I PROPoSED A'%10' YERION WIRELESS LFASE� I CARRIER LEASE I n I y I I PROPOSED R' FENCECRETE n I - _ I I AYERIG INE, ARCHRECTURAL FINISHED WALL II 19'-A" I c S I.){ tIr •xW n I PROPOSED SILT FENCE 0'R9 p5TUwCE. -y I I n I SEE SHEET C5 F.DETNLS SEE I I I NERi11 "ISLEE 9 I LfASE AREA I PROPOSED fi0'x60' I.FASE MG I I I FUN C WPoER I 11012.E CWRIER I I I I L� E I LFARE II.� x I I I R OSED 50'%50' FENCED COwPoUND n i 1 I I 1 I I n �{¢ —v—�—v—v—v—�—s—�—s—v—si—�—y� �" PROPOSED ELEVATION }O•_O' tzoD E _ E 0 5 W E NE LL 0 mmurt slwmmu. r ' Co Co CAPITH T 6 L E C N THIS DOCUMENT Iy5 ELECiRONIC.LLIY S— J SE-0 fir- D E (/75132) UANO F r. SKMxTURE IN ACCORC C. fiIC15-23.001. 0 T. CETTFIGiE ERNTRIST, INC. PEASE TMFERENCE SHEET TI E SIGNArLIRE AND I �% THHOPS DOCUERTES. w PRIMENT ARE /� NSIDERED D.E.9. i4 D THE SIONANRE I A MDF`ED ON ANY ELEI 0 CEP9uW, P.F. FL L E BENTON ROAD (NAPLES PP _ Ium— 0 I— Carr S v¢TNNNE PROPOSE +�+ COMPOUND I C2 c� E L V r-F Q Packet Pg. 149 8.A.10 FOR 24%M' NUW,NGS GRAPHIC SCAIE: ,- _ IS' GRAPHIC SCALE: ,• _ JO' TOP OF TD _ no, AGL i. - _ PROPOSE➢ —ON M,RELE55 ANTENNAS C D2 L ,- PROPOSED FUTURE TRIER ANTENNAS L PROPOSED NIGHT VSKN FRIENDLY LED OBSiRUCDON LIGHT - T-E L-B6a ICAO MEDUM INT[NSm —E B 3 C ETL CERTIFIED TO PROPOSED FUURE CMRIER ANTENNAS FM AC150 ' _ t c µ EIX i♦ /=--�� PROPOSED FUURE LMfeER ANTENNAS CAN4D14N CAR 62T.19 OGAC OF MEXICO PROPOSED NIGHT NSION CONPADBIE L-810 LED " OBSTRLIGDOH LIGHT FM ttPE: L-e,o sTUDr-BURNING oesmucTXN _--�" CAD 1rPE: LOW INTENSITY OBSTACLE LIGHT COIPLYNT TO: W AC ISO/5.N5-43F; EB-67 ICAO ANNEX IA' MR-C-J989: IX✓IG O< " PROPOSED GALVANIZED (TYP. Dc ) -- OF 3 GREY GD iDWLR UYETo COORWNATE LUT FARES .0 ANCHOR OUNOATUNS WITH TOWER 1 II DMWNGS w OTHERS. I 1 1 I tlQIC T� S GTIJRE 5 TO BE L4R—/LIGHTED N \ S 70 ♦50-IN CHANCE 2, OBSTUCTION MARKING AND UCHDNO. RED LIGNTS - CHAPTERS 4,5 (RED) k I2 2. BIRD p TERS TO BE —ED ON GUY WIRES. TOWER _EVATION scuE As No ED L 3 0 c 0 r �a 2- E 0 is m I N0 1.1. +0+ w�,.. � 00 00 CAPII'*T, T I L I C fn WF THIS DOCUMENT HAS ELECIRDNItlLLY SON. SEALED 8r JEREMT O. USING A SIGNATURE IN ACCORC .AC. 61G15-23.004, 0 WGITAL . 'K. AlE R REFERENCE INC. PLEASE THE SHEEP TT THE SIGIUTURE AND 1 �% PR VITIES. PRIMED 0 THI'S OGG MENT ARE DFRED 51GNED A C J AND THE SIGNATURE L A VERIFIED ON ANY ELEI O COPIES. SH BENTON ROAD (NAPLES PP w' C EFUPlamma:F c� G i1X� mN� t sm NRNe V TOWER r ELEVATIOI AQ s,a. NAe1W S V l4 w Q Packet Pg. 150 8.A.10 Coprail Elevation i=+ > ,- $ i .I Caproil Section g k . Typical Panel Section Corner Post Cap g g s. g Running Post Cap Stop Post Cap .mc r . i•-m Oar 3- 58 m�.�n�wiwtlw aam�"ni na`y..�w+ntM rsn�iwn�i �wR.'m. FENCECRETE AMERICA INC. FENCE DETAILS �■I■I■I■I■I■I■I■I■I■I■I■I■I■I■I■I■I■� ME ON Nrs 1 1 1 PVC CATE DETAIL ua u*cN Roaosm a- �NCECREIE MOWA INC PACNnECMiaL nNeNEO TRU-alaSE ~ p (.Ow-f TC 2.-NN]) (ttp. W a) NS 2 Packet Pg. 151 8.A.10 J� 9 PROMGE I' 1. WITH ROPE IN THE NEAP. FENCE POSTS SHALL BE ROUCH OR f CONSTTN m N SHED 2' X 2' (NOMINAL) OR 2' DIAMETER WOOD OR SCHEDULE 40 METAL PIPE OR 1.33 —RJUM STANDARD T OR U SECTION STEEL 5' MNIMUMLNNGTH. DRIVEN 10" MINIMUM INTO GROUND. y- H UMITS 0< SOD UMITS OF SOD �co (£OTE%illE f0.A55 h OMB' c � � � �_ J:1 aaPE ro To BE ON ro BE INsrAucD DN AL Pu \k aoPES TOP OF E%ISING I 12' of UME ROCK OVER SUBGRAOE COMPIDno (APPROXIMATE) 0 95S MAXIMUM DENSITY EMBED APPROX. G` I \ok X TRENCHGEonRW.AEAR" COMPACT THOROUGHLY. TRENCH APPROX. `' DEEP x V WIDE GRAVEL ACCESS DRIVE DETAILS Mrs 3 t. CEOIE%RLE fABRK RT BE FASTENED SECURELY TO FENCE POST BY 3. THIS DEMCE 5 INTENDED To CONTROL SHEET FLOW ONLY. IT WIRE TIES OR HOG qI - (3 FASTENERS PER POST) NOT E AqE OR�MAS a GONCENTRATEO FLOW WITH A DRAwAGGE ARE2. ENDURELI OLORO—I-A FAASTSEMEU TO AA COOMMON POST ED 3' MNMUM. ML SILT FENDNG SHALL BE INS— PRIOi To COMMENCwG ANY RENAN IN PUCE UNDL caysrmicna :cnHncs :RE caolEiED. 29'-S' BENTON ROAD (PR)VATEROVO EROSION CONTROL NOTES: 1. A.I. WORN SWILL CONFORM TO THE FLORIOA WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT CVIOEUNFS REGARDING PREVENTION OF ANY OFF -SITE RUNOFF. EROSION/SEDIMENTATION BARRIERS SHALL BE PUCE➢ AT ALL LOCATIONS OF ANY POSSRRR— OF iM11NOFF THAT GOUID OCCUR 0 THE ADJOINING PROPERDES. 11HESE BARRIERS SHALL BE BARRICADED AS SHOWN ON THE DETAIL - // 2 PREVENT TAT ONTOF IAOMACENTOPROOP—. GAM' SRSTREES. STORM SEMOERSNAANDOWATERWRAE'S.( SHOULD SILµTp1WNp�CURNTTo OFF E ABOVE, THE SITE CONTWTGTOR SHALL REMDYE SAR) SEOMEN7AH0N AND RESTORE ANY DAMAGED AREAS AS REWIRED. 3.IN ADDIDON, THE SITE CONTRACTOR SHAL PI -ACE STRAW. MULCH. OR OTHER SUITABLE MATERIAL ON THE GROUND IN AREAS WHERE RELATED TRAFFIC TO CONSTRVCMN IS ENTER AND EXIT THE SITE THE SHE CONTRACTOR SHALL SWEEP Al STREETS WITHIN PUBUC RXGN-DFfn AS NECESSARY. TO REMOVE ORT BUNG TRANS— FROM SITE BY CONSTRUCT- VEHICLES. IF. THE OP.- OF PROPOSED GMVELIAPRON E ENGINEER ANR L_ ADTHONRES. IXCESSNE DUW1— OF EARTH ARE T—SPORTED OFT-SOE ETHER BY NATURAL DRANAGE OR BY VCnTMIM TRAFFIC, THE SHE CONTRACTOR IS TO REMWE AND CLEAN SAID EARTH TO THE SATISFACTION OF THE ENONEER ANO/OR ORMES. I 135._0. �T1TT I I I T11 II x - - % �R2s-o• 1 _ I � SILT FENCE DETAIL Mrs 1 Y.' CRUSHED STONE ASTIR C33, SZE /SJ, MIN A iHICN _--_- __ - A00 FILL CND AND DUDE TOO LEVEL MADE r GRWND MORE THAN ,OS 00 00000000000000//�\ « \% (NO O O O O O O O �� \� / PROPOSED 20' WIDE oN-ExauslNc 'II ACCESS CKSEMENT WEEP BARRIER 'TYPAR' SCARIFY AND COMPARED lOP I LANDSCAPE FABRIC OR EQUAL 6' OF EXISTING GRACE I I I PROPOSED Access G Gw,vEL SS DRIVE GRAVEL DETAIL (COMPOUND AREA) NTS 2 DRIVEWAY DETAIL —3 SILT FENCE, ACCESS DRIVE E C5 00 00 v Packet Pg. 152 8.A.10 '��' ' PROPOSED iO' vnOE �I.WOSCME BUFFER �y F-;------------------- - — - — - — - — - — - — - — - I PROPOSED 20' WIDE I UNDSCAPE BUFER I I I � I I _—_—_—_—. I 1 I I I _J I 1 I PBOPOBEO 310 —_—_—_—_—_ I OUYED TOWER i I I I p I I I R __ L7---- r---------------� PROPOSED 20' WOE I lM1DBC/iPE BUFFER y/ / j��` PROPOSED ZO'vn0f / ` / LWOSCWE BUFFER LANDSCAPING PLAN a 1 r 00 00 v Packet Pg. 153 n1i Collier County Well Field P Miles 0 2 4 B Rr Ali t ti .47 "" �wRRoxlwrE Focnnw OF PRDRDSm taM£R AND CONPDUND al%1;Fa Y s ',ELL FIELD OVERLAY MAP L d 3 0 DxtE OFIP. 0 ea N. v 0 1 Dm M w� m NNO L7� 0 co Co "APITi E L [ C N Iwo mil .aww'" w r �R WCIIYENf NAS BF tcmaNlGur vwm J XID In' JEREUT D . AF) N UAHD I DNNTAE ILCOR6V AG 6RI Dx O ci", v5, Imsr, W. TERENCE SHEEP rt r E ERFMI IHD VD 0 isVFR1IFS Mm p 5 DDCUxEHf IAf N( Q H6IDEREO SIGNm JD MY EIE"U T1E SI E rU Q XNESON INDi .1D'swa*..Enu¢ O 1 'ENTON ROAD (NAPLES PAR (.umeaoona� 1 near xuaM ci WELL FIELC m OVERLAY MA Q w i 4) t V R r+ r Q Packet Pg. 154 8.A.10 ow.np.m c.e.ILOCI / m.iepm.e. 1rs��.m�.wT.Y�I ee nn . L G 61r.�mW nammryme. saa'.i S.enae V..d�m..w1 P.m h. v� .«mNetiwe.agbom en .N.vR. m r.S.mm n mNamml wall aoe.....Ib m P.P..iH. D.vx 0msm. w.a lo.em.l my p.el®.d.b eel otomwv.e ...o. I.Fn p..r. w5..dmm.m mmme.w.miml. rMd q'rh tPPC.nntle Loci m q/N P.°" �ve� vagmm P.mPnm �W b p.t b...4 mN.tlp..W.Cpuom.�s �/p.medmq.wgfa..EW .a.m.oq q�r ..... pT• � .v_ve.e loe m� bl.r d�m. Pn.15M W�.�n11 oak. m anlsm me �tlq' naNm kv1 N ue.uvmm. tle ..a.r.Vpu.f .S.em... aoamP.m'o i.ednN(<gm. _ S.P�m...Pm...m. Te. m.,.:.mpT nn 5m�m �usw a ec Er..Yly.l.Y w+�fi Pm.PM' N m mm..v e. giwud m vmmna m .... m �vr .ne. ., m_L.�e�ye�� ..a.o mtfi�.Pl�4 gm�xavOWnm Np„S. w�zmue wnepmm�a. / O. Rmrinm e.t v. tnm Wmvpw..Nm P�P.Aw..I m..rsm Mw.pF�.,a wom�N c.�,rm n.. �.P� � Des •elm' em.smal mr..0 e. P..�e.a n.m...vm.e e.� PeN.. .. ree mm.w .rsv� no wiee oumeen Pwmmp anmp.e emP.Nne ry w..cp me inpmm�mm,.r,e. R..vevw�p. E PRESERVE FLUCFCS MAX--+ : T�--2' 7 LURE PRESERVE 0.11DIC� I,� AREA I L COO6� ApiEt ONCIIIR1gN AgllROl CNMoePAIAI dYfUP!®fom dOTlUI xYAxx LLLO�' LEGEND NOTES. A ®O CMMZRNM DYlU1MmIdD SRE OTCSI 12 Aex 4' MA% PRESERVE AREA PHOTOGRAPHS WERE ACQUIRED TH—GH TIE �. CAEFIALOUIE OFFICE IT (4 SO Ac i7 COLLIER COWTY PROPERTY APPNAISER'S OFFICE WITH NATIVE VEGETATION CALCULATION FLIGHT DATES OF NOVENSER - OECEMSER 2011 INGRESG/EGRESS ^ U NAB VEOETATON NDRESS�EDRE594¢ 0.92 Ae.x T RCA ® PROPERTY SIXRCARv PER SMW ENGINEERING 4RO,N, IrvC 1 GPPRO%IMATE LOCATION OP AWING NO IS-5157DWG OA . TED NOVEMSER 1. NN PRESERVE TOTAL NATVE VEOETATON PRESENT SSt A x SI4NAGE iCALL•1�.100' 3 S MSEERVATONREOUIREI T aaGAci PRESER MN ACREAC>E FRONDED a.50.. e $ ,. P.. �� D.B� snw19 136mMnmw�R^`•^°r BENTON ROAD RELO Ie�Tnw s 5/_L' yAWm ® 5 fi.Mxw, 394 PASSARELLA (F.KA CAPITALNAPLES PARK COMMUNICATION TOWER) ! bmd.n..d a0,... IVIt/2J /1A/19 Nmw1239)27400G7 �& SS�OCIATESS .. 5 AWm snA7tp 1;: ad; z7RDo59 PRESERVE AREA MANAGEMENT PIAN Co Co �r r J C O .y O Q Q d c.i W r C t V fC a� t+ a Packet Pg. 155 8.A.10 rn :. �gi:�i• Hann° I �nT".nray.m. Hanna 12 ,awa q � a ��I'c n��Wna':nr n 2 A s `i.a:i+nr I nb lip61 PARCEL MAP CAPITAL I I I I 1 q"v nR v' 10. BEMON Rnw I I I gg I o o p �NI5�g NAPLES PARK - BENTON ROAD ,N. 0 � >a. r•. ,K � 6 L Q 3 O c O ,a u E 0 U fC O C O C d m Co Co L a� a J O N O a a O +r c 2 E t V — r C d E t rJ R r Q Packet Pg. 156 8.A.10 SURVEYOR'S NOTES TOWER 1MFQ i 5 R 1. 1hY h m Rpaek Twv Survy, medr m Ve erpuk uM« er wpeapbn a m x«Yo Rpehre.e IcnO Svwpr. 111111E R0.10'a0.RX' NGRiN SCALE: 1' a 100' I _' � „- � 2 iM MY �^q b flerls]G. 1010. a MY W[ � abpeq wiwy4q .� owe a Urw NYen NPL-JJ2 Tad 5lelbn Naloaon� wp« � � erJa•la.aer wsr FZEMIIGPG 11.1' � � _ I J. � «.�'eewetm N«lm is, see. PYw cewaYaw wn eJ M cPs oe.w.euer. a. Ne enevyena amh.. pmryeme .nvoecnmmY « wnauN redaeGple .«. nnwna « Yeebe w e Per, a iW A9o.E 1Fix 9FA 1E,Ei (NA`A1m) _. _ s �Axo snN2T %ocrn JxJrt<m000 21 Fl31eGVN irRY 9f6 M TAfAM uw¢ uu P1nmw uwrto ulalm caP,wr APM: 3t0.NR1000e 1N.Cf eP..r. mr om..b. awn. Trr ene .A„m. M apa.a. mr eeraw awn. s Tnh wn�.y w Ppeapa.e r« a. P«Pew a w Rwbna Tw« s%•w my. ens Y M Yhrm.e ro e.bwY n. na��l.alaa� a pm r.a.a. aaa nvY�d « Ym po...>. eo«e. ow.— 0. elna.e m tlr lea Mvt mY wlwy mq eo« Eri nauwe a wxryM ti a« dw ro npe0.ctbn. THP PUT 9`O% a. PAGE JS I 1M P1DIiGL1r1 iAler 916 PIAT WGf a, PILS JJ awN 4 mlwi Me earNee,bn a.« oaeHq PwYe eem. ). tAh Sow/ v coritlueme am ue ewrlt a m Nebxl LIGr reM 0. Svreryr Gcealc ,, .Mli aelw tle CmaMw m! tlx pinollw awn Iw (i(I M Pwewe CeeeM1IA Vn lew en apelap m /-AIM Iro"xeaeM vb m aqb /- J IM wremy AwNrpry ReP IA). 1'r � 5�/ awn Iron mnMw m Un YlNmun Ryue«eM. w M IorN q tM 9W aped M e Ga •A' Survry. u eae .wn .Awn uh moP « get h pw� Iw a swan wedam a wl h. mee we-rM h u.000 IM (1':15.W0 wM on �b «rw tM 5� M metl ,e wew�b anw tM goon reef a 1M nuni« a orgw mrw6 lIJ M') w,wy .ona ,n. a iwl .gwmn wq "r purl w a o a Re..a r�mlw ob V C N MAP f00. �M �«e I on from'�ugWM McMmmrb�n aM ^wY M a INI'�wfarleim' Po1—Nry Pw«" fr 1 pnp«lr 1d T IJ. NI pry a utl endrpn ✓qr M %Ptee i 1G' fivm al pnwrh OeuMelle PROJECTiZ Ile tJ.'Jm'JR E0. iT! 0.J0 ACRlk s eerorae• E eSte) a sNwo RtRe 0 100' 200' SITE 712!11 R SCALE: 1' - 100' art xwz TRAM -E - A —W uralm 1Hanr cowurc I ( LYAM ILGGE ULA R1MIM ��%7 APR. RWa>ZGGGw eax sJos PAGE ese tIVCf to uutm arson cohPAxr �Jassramooae WD TG 1RUE MORIX �� a,s' �N O� rtllreelW i, SAES r ' eoGrt JJ I C�3J roC V� I (PEA TA% CIRG) I � ( PNT�BGO1t IM GELIIINMW See' • m J -_. - I. CQ9NtD g,c iActoR C �J1: y i I 31 ly awwetaa O I I � I I I IY 1, }- � fAIY VRE RfO1NTld ilml W,TER 61CVFA o _ �- REaw sEr � a I « ,T- I � � J I txNa I� f�. I• 1uo¢ uc A rnww Wlm Welm cowwrc xv ox K ILY x oomm' v N 9Pb01• E ,mee• IODI' Aron a nv NGW EL ]ID' . _ Pt%.TO sApPERn rN11fW � Q i I lYVGOFD/clwa/PNNETto 1 _ I MIkIJ]GJI'E'GpDG08 5V fiW S �0'O'00' V PEx ,. 1`0 ,.eo I 1 I nnreGNx rARx srtJ PUT..PJ r .« - PcnE a� cAuec \ i 1 PE! II" aPEn S s9'O'2L E 6leS l� . - cunlAnn Wont � � pGAE1P PqE eq�/EIJ� NN IIIO16t/F➢RESS NO UlM' USFeprf b• \ �� 1 Jp IFR pei 1,_ 1Wa _ � GW .NIJ' Yt m - !f)fFMYC PEOESpI u 111NY U19Olf 'A' 1'OE eArTG.e3 56 iT2 ♦.) am 5G. iT2 4zz ACgES1T 1 � Ztl1 \ JG' Grn EAtiTJo,t �• ,,,� I JA)e.OB JG3TS I 1 J 27 G,E 1 \ / `}' d n ,v ,m1m iA5Pe1PNf ao> ncx6V w,.e> xi Pre M 9e'eROp' on¢ M 1sneslaea000wGEx / c 13 q �� vwoo koTE� a JC G1!! FA4eldf 'B• \\ By -0 PbUw -1, Uu wejrel t1 r{ C9IIFR J.IR0.00 ]V.PTS \ ( ZyeS % eo' lEl4 IAF 33$€ s,aao sa n a om ragas o.oe A / TUNFR � / i1mJYrn«s Rph Wpµ• owmwdb Pmd xe. ,mx,mrwl. - I ��, �,I JG' PX uSEIENf Y Y � / ee]J 903Ti: n O SNm �G' �enmaMN.M.axo 1��Iz eia 6 In a y«Zol xooe e� 'Ax': I N Sf �� Zew twee erglu a t m J Bw% • �/ 7, IFr fbeG(Flw�tiws M«m1ro'�em9} I —A �mV Gc,vAxy — : g Ie' NAPLES PARK RELO e Aa3.4 FAaE1E1lf e/e' IRMR I I APIS 1:WTeeGetr—. __— '- iPAf.T ,zJ PUTPIAT �iAIY 9NR -�--pP_ UNE � I IIVW NW 1/4, SEC. 25, T-49S, R-27{ CIXLER COINfY, RORIW •� s fi Packet Pg. 157 8.A.10 PARENT TRACT; (TITLE) Tract .a f wWen Eargm 9 r ---bp b MM « Pml mots « nest.! In PM B«e s, P p U. RI— q WW Cwnly. 1— BO' X SO' LEASE AREA: (AS SURVEYED) M Iraw arw 0eF9 a patbn d Tdea lodes, IJL, A Florida t1nSN Ildtily Lanpvw Vaal eeeenpee a Tad 1R3 F Pbl 6oek x. Pope ]] reraraea b w PoeFa RegN Orllw b CqM Courts. F1oEda eXudeE in w NNDa«t 1/x d Swtlen ]S, T—p . Sadl4 Rerye ]] F«t b and Cant' ad ptlry mac wdadaM E�R.e w IeNaM LOYEIX£ d a S/S' My IwM meMp w Saume«t rotor d na Tad In, Tlrery abrp r«t Era d eatl Tecl In. N W53'4S' E e Ebbw d 1SlJf] tool b a Pets: lAwra 4aarp wa Waal Its, N 90m'm' E e dalorp d lm.m I«t b w I'ONf OF HdNNNG llnna M OODD'W w o Mac d m.m I..t b a r S/S' r.aer, Tlrery N 9p00'00' E a Marls q mm AM b a eq !/e' rdar. Tlrrw a Wm'W E a Maw d e0m M b a ..t S/e' Met T1ry H Wm'm' W e dbbly d MOO - b w I-T OF —N- —`, 3,em peso leq (om aa«) d Ice man N 4 ING�E/EGRESS AND UTILITY EASEMENT •A•: (AS SURVEYED) M Irp a podia d Tdsa ladOa tit; A Marta Uml1tl lapely Campem lrwl eeRW a Trod 1R2 F Pbt R>aI a. ve9e ss nraaa In w pWk Xm.e. Dire F caF. Dwell, Flerbo dlwmd F� NarmNq 1/d q s.dlen a Twrrw4 . sods. Raw n Ea.l b .eid leant' ad Iwp mwe INdbdvy dM..Ne.d w raRo7 1 rnlARa][ d a s/e' near IwnE nary w serdr.«t caw q wa Tad 1zx The eery and weq Ea d odd Tract u N WSG•.• E e Rya] r«t b e ipav Ieoalry wb w«I Its, x OOI E a de4 M d iDam Ir m o wl S/e' rw XI ' E x W Wm' • a debt/ q cam 1wt m o M !de" seer ew w BmINNG: Tnwe N Wm'm' W e alemrca d ... M m a print Terra N .v - F a Mwree d .0. fr b a pets a w Ead Nr rncl 102 Tnwae�ary d' Gq Ra. S W00'Y' w a Maw d Sa.m I«t b e po0t TIrNa bvMN ctl F«I Poe. N Wm'm' w e Maw d 1))JM rr m e .e1 The N 9om'm' W e ebmrc. d e9m r..t m w Parr ff aTadlrc. 0wMbF9 d,]zm yes. r..t (all a Xu INGE/EGRESS AND UTILITY EASEMENT "B (AS SURVEYED) Inn t, deE ;I —, a w �yrwd lbd A Rwaa U-I! Ory 0w , w Tad 119 m PM B- 4. Pa W —1 1,,w 1— RII— 0- CeMv . 1/4 d Saea M T-.". Scum. Raw . - In rtl Cosy vd beVa patbxay — w Ig mIwENLE q a 5/9' - f-Il moddp w S—I cones d Tad In b Pbt 8-, a, Paw A The awry eda r Ra d wtl Tract 1]], N WSG'W E a dl— d ta2Q7 rep b a WW T1rWe -`,; wtl r«t Its, N 9Oo0b0" E e III q 1Wm 1«1 m a «t 5/6' Mar loom N OOm'W w a dPtae q cam led m a eq S/e" Mom, Tbov N GdO r a duets d Gam 1«t to a P K Theses N —'W E a drao d 2T601 led b a I,- a w E«l Ew d cold TrM 1ID are w M. OF BEptNNG TMv N Wm'W E a dbmry q SS] 1. m a print T— N WNY54' E a Mercy d —I feat b a pets a w Mom Ea d eaa Tract 112; 1pere carp odd - G- S -0Z.' E e Mary d ..m teat m o Petit Aare Ieaaep rob xvq Rrle. S ZZM' Maw q d6Su r..t m a Print Tlry N OPdm'm' W el` ro q RSSD fwl b a qrR Tlry M WID's5' E a Maw d 30.m leq b w POM OF -N- Cadebhq 9.AMaT yuon feq (0- INGRESS/EGRESS AND UTILITY EASEMENT •C•: (AS SURVEYED) M swot bAV a qua d T-,, Lad9N IIG, A E-I ll-d WNRy001-1 d—II,1 « TM 13O In Plat Bed d, Paw W newded F w l I R,,M Owe b CdEw Crony. ikdda dpabl F w Xormeed 1/4 d Sera 03, Twrdr4 . 5am, Rope 3] E-I b ra Cwdy -1 biq rive pvmabiy devbd a boat COYOICE d a S/e' rdar IwM --. w Sa4Newt cerar q I- In 1,,PM Beex 4, Paw SY, Tlra« alerp ca w«t pro q otl Tod IM N WSYN' E a dgaw d 102w] Iwt m a pets; Tparri bmpp ra W«t Its, N —`00' E a Mara d Im.m led m e w1 S/e Mar; Ore X W W W r a- d e0.m Iwt m e t S/e' Mar, TNaa N WWm''W a ddwwn d 0Om lest b e print nrn0. N 9PWW E a dbtava d da ^1 Iwt m o pad a w - Ibe d wtl Trad In: T1rra N WDG'W E a dYaiv d 5- Its b e pdq; Tl- N WN3'Sd' E e Mane d -161 M b a qd a w 11or1N Its RI wtl Tad 119 are w Pats OF EfANN.; N W.'N' E o Moe d ee W I«t b e pdM a w Baits Ra d e NI rest still m —1 F ORB 11M. Pop 1 W; TM ebry rid Seam One, S eWt 'E a detaca d -00 I«t b I,Print T— bdary wW S Ma S W4,T•SF M a debt« d eeRSe bet b a «NIt Tlry N W02W IF d ablga d 3om M b w POFdT W --- Legeiniry 131OS339 yav9 I«L M. 00«) q toe mwe a lea 30' GUY EASEMENT "A•: (AS SURVEYED) Fsad beta a I— q Tdva lades• t1G, A Florae UndleO llopOey Cwrpary bap derRM w Tract tII a Plat Beet !. Prye 11 remrdM in w PWk Rwwb Ofrlae Cella Cant'. El -I eRrgeI b w Now! 1/4 d SeNor 03. Twnlrlp . S-U,. Rage n Fat F wM Cagy mE b*j rive paluday d—,1 « rwwN COINE]¢ q a S/Y rear IwM noMp w sanN.r mn. d sb Tad IZIG TNwrP abry as weq M q m Tad 1b, N W50'W E e dean q 1-7 I«t b e peFt Tlrr 4exVp cots w«t Rr N 9Om'W E a Mery d fmm leq b a «t S/S" rep:, ipwv N WWW W o EEbry d m.m 1. b o M S/B' Mer. 1NeIv p0o'W E e dMav q t2. Its a w — ff 6EIOaed: d a srrd b... Iek Nine ell MN 15 Its a wN qEe d w ry dwaRee vNerDnN Try N ]Om m' N e dblerrw d 1G- Irr m w PDrrr K EXmG. Cmi ].O]6Oe pays Mt (GO, m«> q bM rme o Ir b� 30- UT GEASEMENT •B•: (AS SUREY VED) M — -V a porOa d Tales Lodes. = A I —I UMIw Wb ty Cw Y mxt dwolM 1 w Tact III F Pill 9mx 4, Pepe W —1In w I— R— G- b 0a Cw V. FiarlOo dpaW F w Nv1Ne«t 1/4 q Sella ]3, Twralpp . SadN. Rope T Foot F wtl Crony artl eh19 �e pvtlarMy devitl w Idloet m1BE L q a s/Y repay IwM maMq w eeMaaq mnr q atl Tad 11x 1Mry clop w1d Wed Me d add Trml 11L X W51'M' E a Mac q tt}Jf] M b a WDDbO'q�eaGO r.Nd m..t s%e" r�.pa�Tl.0 s l 00' E Sm �w d -GAO Ir m tlWie wlrU or BEmlNlrlc a en srrd p+w io r..l nipe e^d BM9 S rib d w —W d—IId aWrtNlNy The N 9O01Ym E e Maw d tOpA4 1- b w POINT OF 0— Car V ;IWM pave Iwt (0m ea«j q are ma. o b� 30' GUY EASEMENT •C•: (AS SURVEYED) M paw«nt birp a PM d Tdao laEge. 11G A fbrbv llndted WMIly Carrlpaa Sad —1 w Tad 1a In Pat Sow A. Pye W r—Id M w 1— ft— G- Is Cdlw LeuM. fbtda enuaW b w Nama«t 1/4 d SdM 25. T-N, 49 Sall, Rope R] Eat b wtl 1-* ae pepp men pvlbby d—d « Nli m1RQlE£ d a S/e' rMr I M rrwppp w SM I eenwr d wa Tap 171: The aaq eats — Ia d - Trvet In. N wm'w' E e opus d 10}dT M b a pots Tire IroNq wtl w«t Its, N -GG'm" E a Manes q loam Ied b a rq 5/e' Met• Them N Wm'W W e Maya V cam Its m a eq 5/S' roper. Tlry 9000'W E e dlPbly d cam Ire b e rl 5/9' Mm: txwv S OPWm' E a dYbv d cam loot m I w S/e" Met, Tl- N WWW w o Melt/ q 4)�O feel b w POM OF IIEQIddIIC d en swot Nry ]O feet aide as yeN 15 i«I a eeeN alEe q w rdbeep d«vipM ewWrr 1Mrw S WWW r a d4mry q 101 ]3 Nat b w PdNt Di ODING fmbnbp J.m pyre Its (OA) an«) q Imd mwe v boa TO- UTILITY EASEMENT; (AS SURVEYED) M Now Dori peFO a —, d Tdan L-G , lit, A F Ulnsed UPdpy 0 trod d—Id! « Trad In b Pal BM 4, Paw M r—d In w NM Res I pncW M 0- Corey. FII- dmgpd In w I—d I/4 d SI-, M. T-1p AP Se , Rerye GT EM In wa Cevdy art wiry moo wrwNdeM dwPdped « I.- COlr1pP2 q a V.,M« I- --`. w ewmeal ceror d wtl Tact In,1Mrae nary west Ra d «a tad IT7. N DOSE'.' E a dbbve d tOIA) feel b a peat 71ry b^arId ra R RW, N 9OW00' E a Mara R' Im.m lap m e rot S/Y Mar, Tlry N OOm'W W a Mery d 5am 1W m w MW m HANNNG d Fryern— erdl w PGWdr Of QQXa5 ICadddrp W1.6 a ft Iw! (I1JL ea�iwJ cal Ord men ar INN 90mb0' w a Mary q 99.1) test b e qM a w west SURVEYOR'S OERDEICATION I «Ny Orel d q mb wavy art Iw lWa mrlPlrled F wmNev ell w evrwA nwYwgb d w 5lvevee d Path« a s.en.Arr9 b ales a Maas m w e�. d my aa.Ndw. Idaalwn. arty p.e.l. N se•a raw. �i-- �._',. Mvtle Ilwv Na 0008141 PLO LE EXCEPTIONS _ Old RTy.blic NOlioml MI. Inwanq Compony �1T Commkment Icr THIa 1-- CEmmRment Nu Ot-i _ Opt. Jonoary 01. M10 O 7:OD am S.1,W.W B, SCUon II 1-9-bill. i166meol [b�l 1-e SbeaN peylbd CenbF w curry naNae. p 9 BOON it%. PAFE 1.0 Dew M eXect PorwR PorwE W« ores ve E«errwE. 10 ao5x moo P < em nN.q wr.rl Parar awxq F wn... 11 sbewa «woua.. LeIMF ro wexey natlaa a g 9 a 5 4 3 9 p.ae+ PROJECT" RENT TRACT OVERVIEW NOT TO SCALE 15-5157 Po141�'r +E�Eai PER aRs IIWs9, Y OPEII TOP S 99'15'B2' E 6Npb gp5 i OPEN _ _ _ T OX IdD _ - �SS�b� PEA ORB ]0' Et�f 1150, PO 19N �I �I V > 0 API! ]G5He54ee5DDD (I N w 6 J RG 1S1 fAle1� i I O wV b APN:�e3MGnm) �uj; NBQIf + J b I RAT PI�SI O Q� 5/S" N mLODGE OGMl- RAGE OON S PIn eSe RGREAW FISi16 ) BDaX .. Or O IXMfAdN w \ \\ � PI.�NTRI1m001(a Pu�is w � �/"F t I I �TPKT ii9 MJNm9J1 FARM sms �� PIAT IIGON .. PNY 3 TAFAM IJ)OQ. lu A FIDaaA tarlm WBIBY Cd1PN1Y NAPLES PARK RELO APrA ]2ua]e00o1 P p srrEs NW' 14, SEC. 25, T-09-S, R-27.E PUT EKG G ST I COLDER-1 FLORIDA Packet Pg. 158 8.A.10 FinnTimvth From: 2311woodland <2311woodland@gmail.com> Sent: Friday, December 25, 2020 10:53 AM To: FinnTimothy; 2311woodland@gmail.com Subject: Verizon tower project concerns EXTFRNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. L as 3 Dear Timothy Finn, am writing about the installation of the Verizon cell tower proposed for the neighborhood off of Everglades Blvd S and o 28th Ave SE. 1 would oppose brush burning due to unnecessary DANGER and pollution. Collier code allows owners to lay felled trees and brush on the lot to decompose, and that is the local custom. E Please ensure there is a vegetation removal permit for this clearing. E 0 Erecting a new tower will involve lots of site prep. It is not unreasonable for the corporations involved to grade our v private sand roads upon completion of the installation. Currently, neighbors maintain the road contributing what they can. Erosion and irresponsible 0 ATV use damage our roadways. c Thank you for considering my concerns. A tower is a nice idea here; neighbors here must maintain sand roads for 0 emergency and utility access, so help is requested from the tower project coordinator. m Sincerely yours, r Carolyn Stepp 000 2311 Woodland Estates Rd Naples, FL 34117 ;n Packet Pg. 159 8.A.10 FinnTimoth From: Al Baxa <albaxa@wavv101.com> Sent: Monday, January 4, 2021 4:03 PM To: FinnTimothy Cc: Donna Alpert Subject: Proposed Benton Road Tower EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when L opening attachments or clicking links. 3 0 Dear Mr. Finn, o o I am writing in opposition to the proposed tower on Benton Road in Golden Gate Estates, E being proposed to handle telecommunications for wireless carriers. E The existing tower on Benton Road, owned by Alpert Tower formerly Alpine Broadcasting, is c less than % mile from the proposed tower, and is more than capable of handling any and all � carriers that may wish to locate there, making the proposed tower unnecessary. The Alpert tower is the current location for Verizon Wireless, and in the past was used by Alltel and 0° Nextel, and is currently used by several government agencies as well. 00 Many of our Benton Road neighbors also object to the tower, due to the location being very close to their properties, and reducing their property values. J 0 I thank you for your consideration. y Sincerely, 0 a a ° Al Boxa E Chief Engineer/afternoon Host Manager Alpert Tower a r c m I:m;m WAVVAlpine Broadcasting Corp. Q 11800 Tamiami Trail East Naples, FI 34113 239-793-1011 CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This email message including attachments, if any, is intended for the person or entity to which it is addressed and may contain confidential and/or privileged material. Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure or distribution is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender by reply email and destroy all copies of the original message. 1 Packet Pg. 160 8.A.10 FinnTimothy From: Mattaniah Jahn <mjahn@thelawmpowered.com> Sent: Monday, January 4, 2021 5:31 PM To: FinnTimothy Cc: Vicki Clark Subject: FW: Benton Rd cell tower Project EXTERNAL EMA' This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Tim, Here's my latest email to Dan McMahon about the Benton Rd. project. Thanks, M Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. I 111 I I 1 li i Itl Miltlti mall S. ' Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, PA 935 Main Street., Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 T: 727.773.2221 F: 727.773.2616 C: 941.685.3770 E: m ahn thelawm owered.com NOTICE- This is privileged and confidential and intended only for those named to receive it, If you are not one of them, then any use, dissemination, distribution, reading, forwarding. printing. or copying of this is strictly prohibited. and you are requested to notify ME immediately by calling me collect at the number above or emailing me at the address above. DISCLAIMERAlthough this email and any attachments are believed to be free of any VIRUS or other defect that might affect any computer system into which it is received and opened, it is the responsibility of the recipient to ensure that it is virus free and i accept no responsibility for any loss or damage, From: Mattaniah Jahn Sent: January 4, 2021 5:29 PM To: dan@japan4wd.com Subject: RE: Benton Rd cell tower Project Da n, Happy New Year, I hope all is well. Capital is revising the plans to remove the controlled burning tool from the preserve management plan. 3 0 t— c 0 0 U E E 0 U R O CIO CIO m J c 0 rn 0 a a O r c aD E t U CU a C d E t U R r a i Packet Pg. 161 8.A.10 My progress on the access route is taking time. At this point all have to report is that Capital is willing to commit to repairing the road for any damage they cause from construction or operation of the tower and they are willing to have that placed on the zoning approval so that the weight of the county is in place to enforce it if ever necessary. Capital is looking to see if there is any way they can participate in the ongoing maintenance efforts, but the lack of organization is still a stumbling block for them. They are continuing to look into this, I hope to have an update for you in a couple wee ks. Thanks, WA Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. Nlaflaniah Si. Jahn. P.A. Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, PA 935 Main Street., Suite D1 0 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 T: 727.773.2221 m F: 727.773.2616 r C: 941.685.3770 rb 00 E: mjahn@thelawmpowered.com NOTICE: This is privileged and confidential and intended only for those named to receive it. If you are not one of them, then any use, dissemination, distribution, m reading, forwarding. printing, or copying of this is strictly prohibited. and you are requested to notify ME immediately by calling me collect at the number above or d J emailing me at the address above. � DISCLAIMER: Although this email and any attachments are believed to be free of any VIRUS or other defect that might affect any computer system into which it is O received and opened, it is the responsibility of the recipient to ensure that it is virus free and I accept no responsibility for any loss or damage- y 0 From; Japal <dan@japan4wd.com> CL 0. O Sent: December 28, 2020 9:08 AM To: Mattaniah Jahn <mjahn@thelawmpowered.com> c Subject: RE: Benton Rd cell tower Project E Hello, I hope you are well. Q I have not received any response about any of Capital's intentions to help maintain the roads they use. a (no matter how little they claim the use will be) m Again if they have any plans to do anything to help with the roads please let me know. t Or in the alternative, if they want the maintenance to be done thru a road association or committee of any sort and M since it is their suggestion, how are they going to organize such a committee? Q Without the above information, we can only go by the facts as of now that Capital has no intention the help maintain the roads and plans on using them in perceptuality at our expense. I do not have any interests in Benton Rd and only have rights in and on Woodland Estates Rd, If Capital does not have any plans on maintaining the portion of Woodland Estates Rd they want to use, I kindly ask you to cease any plans to use Woodland Estates Rd. Please adjust your plans to the closest access via 28th Ave SE Ext. {via tract 7 & 10 easement, etc) Packet Pg. 162 8.A.10 The ingress egress easement over Ms Hobson's property is only for the use of certain properties which do not include the property Capital plans to use. This easement across Ms Hobson's was extinguished from Ms Kuslyak property in favor of the easement over the northside of tract 410. Further the turning radius onto Woodland Estates Rd is not wide enough for a semi truck to make a 90 degree right turn from 28th Ave SE. From the guardrail to Ms Hobson's property is 22 feet wide, a semi truck would need at least 27 feet clearance to safely make a right turn and then it would have to be done from the wrong side of the road on the bridge. Your input and response is appreciated, thank you Dan McMahon Dan@Japan4WD.com 1-305-320-6175 On December 20, 2020 at 6:00:21 pm -05:00, Mattaniah Jahn <mjahn@thelawmpowered.com> wrote: Thank you for sending this over, I will begin researching the suit and SFWMD agreement. i appreciate that concern and I will speak with staff soon about the preserve management plan. Have a good evening. Thanks, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. 111 1 11 1 11 11 H aniah S. P.A. Law Office of Mattaniah 5, Jahn, PA 935 Main Street., Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 3 Packet Pg. 163 T: 727.773.2221 8.A.10 727.773.2616 C: 941.685,3770 miahnOthelawmpowered.com NOTICE This is privileged and confidential and intended only for those named to receive it. If you are not one of them, then any use, dissemination, distribution_ reading, forwarding, printing, or copying of this is strictly prohibited, and you are requested to notify ME immediately by calling me collect at the number above or emaiiing me at the address above, DISCLAIMER: Although this email and any attachments are believed to be free of any VIRUS or other defect that might affect any computer system into which it is received and opened, it is the responsibility of the recipient to ensure that it is virus free and I accept no responsibility for any loss or damage. From: Japai <danejapan4wd.com> Sent: December 19, 2020 11:03 AM To: Mattaniah Jahn <mjahn@thelawmpowered.com> Subject: RE: Benton Rd cell tower Project Hello I had just been preparing another email. All of my records were lost in the fire, along with most of my files on computer and back ups. I believe the lawsuit was in 2011 with BBT as the plaintiff, the defendants were SFWMD, Collier County, the school board, myself and all property owners along the G4 canal east of 22nd St SE and all of the owners along the Miller canal from the C-4 canal to the bridge at 28th Ave SE. It also became part of the 3rd amended agreement between Collier County and SFWMD. It was on the BCC agenda for late 2011 and early 2012, an executive summary was issued regarding Woodland Estates Rd and it usage, which did not include the general public, but does allow us to gate the road as we have done in the past. So far it is my understanding that Capital plans on using the roads in perceptuality without any commitment to participate in anyway in their maintenance. If they plan on doing anything at all to maintain the road please let me know asap. 00 00 Packet Pg. 164 8.A.10 We do not care what forestry management standard plans are, our properties and some homes in this neighborhood have been burned by prescribed burns. Most recently our homes burned earlier this year, we have had 4 major fires in the last 5 years. Even the thought of it here brings up some post traumatic stress from barely escaping the fire in May, my wife and I were injured, my wife was hospitalized for 8 days and I was unable to visit due to COVID. I will send my other email shortly. thanks Dan McMahon Dan Ja an4WD.com 1-305-320-6175 On December 19, 2020 at 10:05:56 am-05:00, Mattaniah Jahn <mjahn@thelawmpowered.com> wrote Dan, Thank you for your insights. Do you have anything to identify the lawsuit and the BCC petition? Even just having the year is helpful. That way I can look it up and get with my project team at Capital about that. I assume that you're referring to the attached note on the preserve management plan, am I correct? Those burns are there to help reduce naturally occurring fuel should a forest fire approach the area in the future. They're also a standard condition on most preserve management plans in Collier County. Let me get with County staff and Capital on that to see if there's a work around for that management tool. If there isn't a viable work around, I'm sure Capital would be willing to send out a courtesy letter to neighbors in the area before conducting any burns. Thanks, ;V 00 00 Iq Packet Pg. 165 8.A.10 Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. ZMattaniah S. Jahn, P. Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, PA 935 Main Street., Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 T: 727.773.2221 F: 727.773.2616 C: 941.685.3770 E: mjahn@thelawmpowered.com NOTICE: This is privileged and confidential and intended only for those named to receive it. If you are not one of them. then any use, dissemination. distribution, reading, forwarding, printing, or copying of this is strictly prohibited, and you are requested to notify ME immediately by calling me collect at the number above or emailing me at the address above, DISCLAIMER Although this email and any attachments are believed to be free of any VIRUS or other defect that might affect any computer system into which it is received and opened, it is the responsibility of the recipient to ensure that it is virus free and I accept no responsibility for any loss or damage. From: Japan4wd <dan@japan4wd.com> Sent: December 17, 2020 10:14 AM To: Mattaniah Jahn <mjahn@thelawmpowered.com> Subject: RE: Benton Rd cell tower Project Hi I appreciate the reply. FYI m 3 0 rr c 0 ca E E 0 U 0 c 0 c m m 00 00 r i d O J C O N O Q Q 0 C m E t �a w Q c a� E t c� Q 6 Packet Pg. 166 8.A.10 We had settled who has usage of Woodland Estates Rd thru litigation with all the property owners along Woodland Estates Rd, South Florida Water Management District(SFWMD), Collier County, and the School Board as defendants. Thru the litigation it was determined that Woodland Estates Rd was for the exclusive use of those along Woodland Estates Rd. The easement does not extend to the residents along Benton Rd or Woodland Grade Rd. This was reaffirmed by the Collier Board of Commissioners (BCC). thru a petition resulting out of the litigation. As for the easement you mentioned from the Kuzylak`s that would still require the other property owners permission since we all have access control as determined by the county, including the right to gate the road. It is a bit unclear why this is such an issue for Capital, it would seem they have the resources to provide the minimal maintenance that is needed. For example, just guarantee you could send out a grader once every 2 years. We are not asking a lot other than to do their share. If Capital cannot contribute, then do not use Woodland Estates Rd for access to property over a mile off of Woodland Estates Rd. Please use the guidance from FL Statute 704 and use the "nearest" access to the public road instead of Woodland Estates Rd. That access would be via 28th Ave SE Ext. Lastly the plan presented includes prescribed burning (Fire). Without the cooperation of everyone in this area this is not acceptable, it will cause too much fear and neighbors would be evacuating due to the visible smoke nearby. When smoke is seen in the area we all call each other and begin our fire emergency plans. We have not had prescribed burning anywhere in the area and are aware of the prescribed burns that have got out of control. Residents live here, your property is too small and you could use other safer methods of doing the same, Please let me know what considerations were made for the provisions of those along Woodland Estates Rd having exclusive control over it's usage. Also please let me know of an alternative to setting fires in the neighborhood. thank you Dan McMahon L 3 0 00 00 Packet Pg. 167 8.A.10 Dan@Japan4WD.com 1-424-666-7322 On December 15, 2020 at 5:38:25 pm-05:00, Mattaniah Jahn <mjahn@thelawmpowered .com> wrote: Dan, Happy Tuesday, I hope all is well. Verizon requested this tower so that they can install modernized equipment to serve the area. The immediate result is that they'll be better able to take care of the 4G need in the area. Since it will be new equipment, I imagine it will be 5G ready. 00 00 The tower will have backup power, Verizon is planning to use a propane generator. The typical trip count that I mentioned earlier assumes that each carrier would have their own generator. Tower maintenance and lights will be handled by Capital, since they will own the tower. That type of maintenance is very minimal, there aren't even light bulbs to change on the tower because they use LEDs. I am not surprised that your experience with the Alpine Tower is different from what I am describing. I grew up in an AM/FM radio station in Sarasota. An FM radio station has very different maintenance and monitoring requirements than a cell tower, especially if the FM radio station has older equipment. I am attaching the revised plans that I recently submitted for review. The access map is on PDF page 13. There were two gaps in the easements, one along Benton Rd. and one along Woodlands Estates Rd. Capital has fixed those gaps and will be recording the two easements soon. The remaining easements are all recorded and called out on the map. Packet Pg. 168 8.A.10 Capital is willing to participate as a neighbor member in a road organization or committee and contribute on a pro-rata basis. They're willing discuss either dues or supplies, the stumbling block on my end is that there needs to be someone who can speak for the entire route from the 28th Ave SE bridge to their driveway. Again, their usage is going to be less than a single family home. That means that their usage is going to be less than most of the owners in the area. Notice for the NIM was sent out based on the requirements in state and local law. Your property is a roughly mile away from the project, that is why you did not receive a notice letter. I am sorry that the fire took your house. Capital, like any other neighbor in the area, cannot guarantee what the fire department will or will not do. What they can say is that they will repair any damage they cause from constructing, maintaining, or using the tower. Capital is willing to have that placed on the face of the zoning approval for their tower to show that they are serious about that commitment. Thanks, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. Mimiilliah S. } .Zahn. RA. • , Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, PA 935 Main Street., Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 T: 727.773.2221 F: 727.773.2616 9 Packet Pg. 169 941.685,3770 8.A.10 miahn thelawm owered.com NOTICE, This is privileged and confidential and intended only for those named to receive it. If you are not one of them, then any use, dissemination, distribution, reading, forwarding, printing, or copying of this is strictly prohibited, and you are requested to notify ME immediately by calling me collect at the number above or emailing me at the address above. DISCLAIMER: Although this email and any attachments are believed to be free of any VIRUS or other defect that might affect any computer system into which it is received and opened, it is the responsibility of the recipient to ensure that it is virus free and I accept no responsibility for any loss or damage_ From: Japan4wd <dan@iapan4wd.com> Sent: December 11, 2020 8:36 AM To: Mattaniah Jahn <miahn@thelawmpowered.coi Cc: McDaniel Bill <bill.mcdaniel@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Benton Rd cell tower Project Hello cc to Bill McDaniel Some questions we had from Woodland Estates Rd. Will this be for 5g service? or will it have to be updated for 5g at some later time thus requiring additional construction? Will the tower ever be upgraded? Will the tower have a back up power source? and if so will there be 1 for each carrier or just 1 for the tower? Will the tower have a single back up power source? Will it be maintained by the carriers during their regular maintenance? or will it be done by a separate company? Will the tower itself be maintained by the carriers or will it be some other entity? Will any back up power require fuel and or any fuel delivery? Who will maintain the lights on the tower or will they also be maintained by the carriers? We ask these questions because from experience, the current tower needs more than 1 trip per month per client served, it is more complex than you have represented to us. 00 00 10 Packet Pg. 170 8.A.10 Also, those of us along Woodland Estates Rd want to make it clear that Woodland Estates Rd is not the access to your property, it would be via 28th Ave Ext, to Benton. Please show the recorded easement on Woodland Estates Rd. that you plan to use. The only home on Benton Rd who uses Woodland Estates has property at the corner of Woodland Estates Rd and Benton Rd. As for a road fund, we would be willing to start a road fund, but as neighbors here trade for services, it would cost more for your client unless there would be something in kind they could contribute. Commercial traffic causes more damage than residential traffic especially when the resident has a stake in the road whereas the the worker sent out to do anything for the tower does not. Since you are planning to use the roads for 2 different areas how would each road association be connected since we do not use the same roads as you plan? (residents along Benton Rd use 28th Ave Ext., not Woodland Estates Rd.) At this point in time we are very worried about this project, 12 homes burned to the ground this year including mine and the majority of homes of Woodland Estates. How will you guarantee fire department access to your site so that any fire would not affect our homes as happened earlier this year? We would like some clarity on all of this, We would also like to know why all of those affected by the project were not informed of the meeting or the project. We do not know any property owners on Woodland Estates Rd, that were notified of this project, we found out thru neighbors. Dan McMahon Dan@Japan4WD.com 1-305-320-6175 11 Packet Pg. 171 8.A.10 On December 10, 2020 at 12:20:57 pm-05:00, Mattaniah Jahn <miahn@thelawmpowered.com> wrote: Dan, I hope all is well. I spoke with Vince Casiero, one of the principals of Capital, about Benton Rd. and Woodland Estates Rd. They are willing to commit to repairing damage caused to those roads by construction work and usage of the tower. Capital's usage of the roads will be minimal. The tower is designed for 4 carriers, cellular installations are so automated that they typically need no more than 1 trip per month. Many times, a monthly trip is not needed if the systems report back to the carriers that everything is ok. So, even if it gets fully leased out with 4 carriers, you're looking at 4 trips per month. That is far less than even a single family home, which could be built on the parcel today. Capital is willing to contribute on a pro rata basis to a road fund. The owners along Benton Rd. and Woodland Estates Rd. would need to organize somehow, such as a road association, Capital will be happy to join as a neighbor member. I know that this is not a simple answer but, since the roads cross multiple properties, Capital needs someone who can speak for the entirety of the route in order to be able to contribute to a fund. Please take some time to talk this over with your neighbors and then let me know where you want to go from here. Thanks, 12 Packet Pg. 172 Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. 1. k11 tliiIII .i.. ()i 11attanialt S. Jahn. RA. Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, PA 935 Main Street., Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 T: 727.773.2221 F: 727.773.2616 C: 941.685.3770 E: miahn@theiawmpowered.com NOTICE_ This is privileged and confidential and intended only for those named to receive it. If you are not one of them. then any use, dissemination, distribution, reading, forwarding, printing, or copying of this is strictly prohibited, and you are requested to notify ME immediately by calling me collect at the number above or emailing me at the address above. DISCLAIMER. Although this email and any attachments are believed to be free of any VIRUS or other defect that might affect any computer system into which it is received and opened. it is the responsibility of the recipient to ensure that it is virus free and I accept no responsibility for any loss or damage. From: Japal <dan@lapan4wd.com> Sent: December 5, 2020 9:37 AM To: Mattaniah Jahn <m ahn thelawm owered.com> Subject: Re: Automatic reply: Benton Rd Project 13 Packet Pg. 173 8.A.10 Hello Are you able to provide any information regarding my previous email? Also please note that the use of Woodland Estates Rd would not be the "nearest" access to the public road, 28th Ave SE. The nearest access would be via 28th Ave SE Ext. Awaiting your reply thank you Dan McMahon Dan@Japan4WD.com 1-305-320-6175 On November 29, 2020 at 3:44:16 pm-05:00, Mattaniah Jahn <mjahn@thelawmpowered.com> wrote: Thank you for your email. Please note that the Law Office will close for the Thanksgiving holiday at noon on Wednesday, 11/25/20 and will re -open on Monday, 11/30/20. 1 will begin responding to emails on Monday, 11/30/20. Once again, thank you for your email, and have a Happy Thanksgiving! Thanks, M za Packet Pg. 174 8.A.10 FinnTimothy From: Donald Harring <DHarringNYCTPD@msn.com> Sent: Wednesday, January 13, 2021 2:59 PM To: FinnTimothy Subject: Tower located in the community Woodland Estates on Benton Road (proposed construction project ) EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme L caution when opening attachments or clicking links. 3 0 Hi , Timothy Finn c 0 Meeting February 25 , 2021 @ 9:00 am located in the Growth Management Building 2800 North Horseshoe Drive , Naples Florida , 34104 . 3 E All letters of opposition to be e mailed to you @ Timothy. Fi nncolliercount fl. ov Please verify o and return . Dharrinanvctod(&msn.com . v Dear Sir I have surveyed the community of Woodland Estates and all but one family have objected to M �° this project . We already have a Radio/cell phone Tower that is over 1,000 feet tall and the Station c Engineer Mr. Al Baxa has assured me that the Verizon Corp (already on that tower) Has more than enough room to expand and fill their needs . His business Manager at WAVV Corporation is more than willing to m adjust rates and come up with an arrangement to suite all parties . I was told at the meeting that the southbound section of Benton Road was a public Easement . I know that it was a private easement for o land egress only because it was placed on WAVV Corporation property and a dirt road was built without I* Mr. Norman Alpert's consent . Could I receive a copy of that Easement record if in fact it does exist . V Please note that we are a rural community and most families do not have computers . There is one L family , Mrs. Sterling that does not have electric and uses solar power for her home . We have 35-40 families . Five of those families are from Laos , One is from the Philippines . Since I am a retired New York City Police Sgt. #675 ID. 3393 I am often asked to assist in helping people to Understand . I moved here o in January 1987 my date of c.o. for the house. y Once before a cell phone tower was proposed of Benton Rd /28th Ave over 20 years ago the 0 a a O property owner was and still is Chuck Campbell . The Collier County Commissioners turned it down because a tower was already within 1/4 mile and had plenty of room for expansion of additional units . d I know that this location is a prime area for towers and transmissions because it is elevated and the Ease/West I-75 passes within 2 miles . All of the residents here came for the privacy and the nature that "North Bell Meade" help us to maintain a by restricting clearing and development . We have Cattle and Horses and Native Habitat . That is the way we want to keep it . Thank You Donald R. Harring 239-455- 0763 a Packet Pg. 175 8.A.11 Cov County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT www.colliercountvfl.gov 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX: (239) 252-6358 Hybrid Virtual Quasi -Judicial Public Hearing Waiver For Petition Number(s): Emergency/Executive Order 2020-04 Hearing of the Collier County Planning Commission and Board of County Commissioners PL20180002327 Regarding the above subject petition number(s), Capital Telecom Holdings ll, LL1C (Name of Applicant) elects to proceed during the declared emergency with hybrid virtual public hearings of the Collier County Planning Commission and Board of Co ty Commissioners, and waives the right to contest any procedural irregularity due to the hybrid vir ual nature of the public hearing. Mattaniah S. Jahn as Agent of Rec I 02/18/2021 Name: Date: Signature ❑ Applicant 0 Legal Counsel to Applicant * This form must be signed by either the Applicant (if the applicant is a corporate entity, this must be an officer of the corporate entity) or the legal counsel to the Applicant. Packet Pg. 176 8.A.13 (CHAPTER 8, COLLIER COUNTY ADMINISTRATIVE CODE FOR LAND DEVELOPMENT) A zoning sign(s) must be posted by the petitioner or the petitioner's agent on the parcel for a minimum of fifteen (15) calendar days in advance of the first public hearing and said sign(s) must be maintained by the petitioner or the petitioner's agent through the Board of County Commissioners Hearing. Below are general guidelines for signs, however these guidelines should not be construed to supersede any requirement of the LDC. For specific sign requirements, please refer to the Administrative Code, Chapter 8 E. 1. The sign(s) must be erected in full view of the public, not more than five (5) feet from the nearest street right-of-way or easement. 2. The sign(s) must be securely affixed by nails, staples, or other means to a wood frame or to a wood panel and then fastened securely to a post, or other structure. The sign may not be affixed to a tree or other foliage. 3. The petitioner or the petitioner's agent must maintain the sign(s) in place, and readable condition until the requested action has been heard and a final decision rendered. If the sign(s) is destroyed, lost, or rendered unreadable, the petitioner or the petitioner's agent must replace the sign(s NOTE: AFTER THE SIGN HAS BEEN POSTED, THIS AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING NOTICE SHOULD BE RETURNED NO LATER THAN TEN (10) WORKING DAYS BEFORE THE FIRST HEARING DATE TO THE ASSIGNED PLANNER AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING NOTICE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER BEFORE THE UNDERSIGNED AUTHORITY, P RSONALLY APPEARED WHO ON OATH SAYS THAT HE/SiM-JiAS PO D PROPER NOTICE AS REQUIRED BY SECTION 10.03.00 OF THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPME CODE ON THE PARCEL COVERED IN PETITION NUMBER OF /�. i i/L. /�I NA 1M{• �. .. 0� STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER STREET OR P.O. BOX The foregoing instrurpent was sworn to and subscribed before me this_ c ' day of 20ow by t I1 personally known to me or who produced as identification and who did/did not take an oath. ,,.►• Notary Public State of Florida Signature of Notary Public aQ Vicki Lynn Clark My Commission GG 285454 ate ' Expires 12/1812022 My Commission Expires: /. 0/d (Stamp with serial number) Rev. 3/4/2015 Printed Name of Notary Public w w v Packet Pg. 177 m 3 0 F- c 0 :r 0 0 E E 0 U c� 0 c 0 w c d 00 r oo co r iL p *alp Packet Pg. 178 i e M T Q 06 (.iomol uogeoiunwwoo - peob uo)uo8 : b881V6) suit A:pedoad 6uPeoH - -14uGwt43e4lV :;u8w43eUV o C O� OR F- j 2- a U Z Z I N m O Z Om Z uyl� H �'z Z Z O w K J Z 1 W oo� K � 1 a I Z 2 0. 4 ri "`7L: �'dc W �' ' ` • 'i[�.T p' ,� ' s'`-", "tr'�. .•y`` fix;.` Z m d � a - a,. a�;� 1 �.� �!'+,,;� 0 Z Iz K •_, p I ZZ Ix U2 z &w d WO m 2 O wm Z I Y Y8xm b V o Y> V > l 81 �� .o I 8= wm o0 g��l z Q g m J wJ ,WI dJ �¢�zi� JSVrca aa3 �ni �c�m1 (Jm zo Lu oJow' �0�,ZwJZN?�zoZ h �Om 0 Za i W F 0 wz w 'D0 �irc I 3 OQ' ae"w0iq2Uqi T8 wom O Z Q.2. 0I w Oa 1 zi N NZ3 i i zwU N W 0 Oo WO IL O dUw Ow �w n zyww (L z�w a Nm .m Z aoa� h�z e�z- d W 2 i L 2z< wz� 8, a a l zi1 . � Z W isO - ow 0 co T a. r V a. INSTR 6009712 OR 5899 PG 3814 E--RECORDED 3/1/2021 2.10 PM PAGES 8 CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT AND COMPTROLLER, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA 8.A.14 DOC@.70 $0.70 REC $69.50 Prepared by and Return to; Capital Telet ocn Holdings 11 LLC Attention: Legal Department 820 Mon -is Urnpike. Suite 104 Short Hills, New Jersey 07078 Site Nsanie: maples Park North FLI14 Parcel: 32630400006 ACCEss AND UTILITIES EASEMENT AGREEMENT This Access and Utilities Easement Agreerent (the "Agreement") dated November 11., 2020 ("Effective Date") is among Jeanette Kuszlyk, a Single woman ("Grantor"), and CAPITAL TELECOM HOLDINGS II .L.LC, a Delaware limited liability company ("Grantee") WHEREAS, the Grantor is the fee simple owner of certain property located as Parcel ID #32630400006 in the County of Collier, State of Florida which property is more particularly described on Exhibit "A" hereto ("Grantor's Property"). Grantee is leasing a portion of that certain property known as Tracts 119, 120 and 123 oil the plat filed as Floridian Farm Estates in Plat Book 4, Page 33, Public Records of Collier County Florida ("Grantee's Leased Property"). Grantor acid Grantee desire to enter into this Agrecmen.t for the purpose of creating certain easements to benefit the Grantee's Leased Property, as more particularly described hereinafter. For and in consideration of Ten and No/100 Dollars (S 10.00), and other good and valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which, are hereby acknowledged, Grantor and Grantee, intending to be legally bound, hereby agree as follows: I . Grantor hereby grants, transfers and conveys to Grantee a nonexclusive easement ; (the "Access Easement"), for the benefit of the Grantee's Leased Property, over and across a portion of Grantor's Property (the "Easement Area"), to and froth Grantee's Leased Property � and a public right of way, for the purpose of providing access, ingress and egress to Grantee's Leased Property to and from a public right of way. The Easement Area is in the location shown U Y on Exhibit "B". The casement rights granted hereunder by Grantor to Grantee shall expressly Q include, without lirn.itation, the right to free and unencumbered ingress and egress over and c across the Easement Area. E U 2. Grantor hereby grants, transfers and conveys to Grantee a nonexclusive casement (the `Utilities Easement", and together with the Access Easement, collectively, the Q "Easements"), for the benefit of Grantee's Leased Property, over and across the Easement Area, for the purpose of installing, operating, maintaining and repairing roadway, communication, and Na hea Park North FLI 14 Access & Utilities Easement KttszlykEXE Packet Pg. 181 OR 5899 PG 3815 power utility lines and other such necessary improvements (the "Facilities") to service Grantee's Leased Property. The easement rights granted hereunder by Grantor to Grantee shall expressly include, without limitation, the right to unencumbered ingress and egress over and across Grantor's Property to access the Facilities and the right to use, repair, replace, and maintain all Facilities hereafter placed in the Easement Area. 3. The Term of this Agreement shall be continuous, uninterrupted, and shall only expire: (a) upon notification from Grantee of termination of the Agreement, or (b) one (1) year after the Grantee, or its successors or assigns: (1) fails to have an interest in Grantee's Leased Property-, (11'.) does not have facilities or equipment located within Grantee's Leased Property, and (Iii) no longer conducts operations within the Grantee's Leased Property. 4. Any notice sent pursuant to this Agreement shall be in writing and sent by telecopy, personal delivery or by reputable courier, or by depositing it with the United States Postal Set -vice, certified or registered snail, return receipt requested, with adequate postage prepaid, addressed to the appropriate party. The initial addresses of the parties shall be as set forth below: To Grantor: Jeanette Kuszlyk 2320 Moulder Drive #A Naples, FL 34120 To Grantee: Capital Telecom Holdings 11 LLC Attention: Legal Department 820 Morris Turnpike Suite 104 Short Hills, New Jersey 07078 S. The Easements granted herein shall be appurtenant to and shall run with Grantee's U) (n W Leased Property, and shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit of each party hereto, its UU successors, assigns, mortgagees, tenants, lessees, licensees, contractors, subcontractors, agents, representatives and invitees. 6. This Agreement shall be subject to and subordinate to any mortgage or deed to E secure debt (collectively referred to as a "Mortgage") made by Grantor which may encumber the U Grantor's Property as of the Effective Date, the holder of every such Mortgage shall in a separate agreement with Grantee agree that in. the event of a foreclosure, or conveyance in ficu of r- foreclosure of Grantor's Interest in. the Grantor's Property, or such other similar transaction, such W E holder shall recognize and confirm the validity and existence of this Agreement and that Grantee shall have the right to continue its use and occupancy of the Easement Area in accordance with U the provisions of this Agreement as long as Grantee is not in default of this Agreement beyond < applicable notice and cure periods. Grantee shall execute in timely fashion such instruments in recordable forin as may reasonably be requested to evidence the provisions of this paragraph, Naphea Park North FL I 14 Access & Utilities Easement Kttszlyk EXE I Packet Pg. 182 OR 5899 PG 3816 8.A.14 7. This Agreement shall he governed by and enforced in accordance with the laws of the state in which the Grantor's Property is located. {Signatures on following pages} c a� E u �a Y Y Q E u m Q Na hea Park Noah FLI 14 Access & Utilities Easement KuszlykEXE Packet Pg. 183 OR 5899 PG 3817 8.A.14 <' k.k.'\I::INS W i H_R H If the e�:h la C. CW U[01 01il .'� �"Ii ""f;RAVIOR I, Texas I Dallas Nt anne:.1callim #<.t -Avk, miic. November 11, 2020 (ha 111V3 tkai m Nov, Fil91 4 +L'ztl �il�(!1'� ta[� I'!t. floe iill{k�l ! !1 c. at E1u1:4iS lllsa?9 fil and 101 :'aid stale_ poi-tarialk appemed ,ie.mclto KkIS vk . po""oi ilk khot tIl to Me of d [o file on Ow >19yiti 6t1 yu2it ltK'.`it4'o C% uli ocQ io alit' 0w mit4 BCIt@uh s) 15-kYtsti;' fak1712i°(° } Pd (;r{'e; Stlh'i.°nhed; to ib ',i'.i]1I11 ol, 3t.: 's�a'i€ •. fxfs.=h„'; er i�ij i,i8a ,s:. =Pli; tt t :. -ifL _�ti il:csu,d dt'+s i. Yr d,a�'sC°; .t1-; si ibZYti iic�tdl �`f oa 't{;g{ 0w ind"%tih7 '.'. ;- '\o1:n loll})itc:' ennifer�q az�e lV _--�jj fib` (,�t3a2131iS;Vt�i1 -' ,(11ie,'y ar 16i_2t//yy 22 i Notary l'UNW. Stela ut''l`c\GIs Mrs'- y"ssl v',a';r k i i`-i t �;•..�t o =r.;,y P ,b�::nt�su�t t 7 1P i �3,.i�!, i,19 Packet Pg. 184 OR 5899 PG 3818 8.A.14 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have execrated this Agreement as of the Effective Date. Witness: "GRANTEE" �A?1 Nance: J n axis STATE OF NEW JERSEY } } ss: COUNTY OF ESSEX ) Capital Telecom Holdings lI LLC Name: Michael G. re" Title: COO Date: November 11, 2020 On the 11'll day of November in the year 2020, before me, the undersigned, a notary public in and for said state, personalty appeared Michael C . Brett, personally known to me or proved to nee on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the individual(s) whose name(s) is (are) subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/she/they executed the same in his/her/their capacity(ies), and that by his/her/their signature(s) on the instrument, the individual(s) or the person upon behalf of which the individual(s) acted, executed the instrument. Notary Public:: _ My Commission •o*+a. 1 ��» sW..`•G 4 t�ir ��0.f°.'tYt.�v�d4 !ai'��lfi��i..N� Naples Park North FL 114 ,4c:cess & Utilities Easement Kuszlyk EXE Kuszlyk FXE Packet Pg. 185 OR 5899 PG 3819 EXHIBIT "A" Description of Grantor's Property Tract No. 8 of the Subdivision of Section 25, T49S, R27F, according to the plat thereof recorded in Plat Book 4, Page 33, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, and portion of Tract No, 7 of the Subdivision of Section 25. T49S, R27E, according to the plate thereof recording in Plat Book 4, Page 33, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida. more particularly described as follows: A strip of land 17.83 feet in width, the northeasterly boundary line of which is described as follows: Commence at the Northeast corner of said Tract No. 7; thence run west along the north line of Tract 7 a distance of 204.73 feet to the Point of Beginning', thence run S 34'32' East 324,40 feet to a point in a line 30 feet to the west and parallel to the easterly boundary line of said Tract No. 7. CD E M U E M U M Naphea Park North FL I 14 Access & Utilities Easement Kttszlyk EXE I Packet Pg. 186 OR 5899 PG 3820 UEMUNWAN Easement Area ,W,' 1/4. SE'C. s25, T 49 S, H ?7 K COLLIL.,J? COUNTK FLORIDA 21�1 4. 53 Ali x, - 2 z, di C 01 Vi &C, PA6C�, 1�eO 0 Ofi6 0 5, 0—i N Kij"": 1, "1 VICINITY MAP T T�' I I .. .. .. .. .. 2�0— AVi CA, CUT ACE D, '11�� VC 0A �1 V 01 fl4(� r��,11:1NC V, �10�tl 1Y 11 1 VT11' : SMVV Engineering Group, I SB EusinZ Center Drive Girm,n9ha m Alabama 36244 Ph 206-252-6986 www.5rMwhg com C t i F; VIC CAPITAL TELECOM P'llou W `<�Mb�f 14W4 "'Vol ;,0,3 1,11 0"96C Naphea Park North FL I 14 Access & Utilities Easement Kttszlyk EXE Best Avai Packet Pg. *** OR 5899 PG 3821 *** 30' Access Easement: An casement being a portion of Tract 7 and 8 of Floridan Fann Sites described in Plat Book 4, Page 33 recorded in the Public Records Office in Collier County, FL situated in NE 1/40f Section 25, T49S, R27E in said ocunty and being more particularly described as follows: Commence at a 2" open top found marking the NE corner of Tract 120 in siad Floridian Farrn Sites described in Plat Book 4, Page 33, thence S 88038'5 1 " E a distance of 4766,93 feet to a point on the West right of way line of Woodland Estates Road and the POINT OF BEGINNING, thence along said West right of way line S 00'50'12" W a distance of 1.000.40 feet to a point; thence along said West right of way line, N 89"39'-72" W a distance of 30.00 fcct to a point; thence N 00'50'12" E a distance of 1000.40 feet to a point, thence S 89'39'22- E a distance of 30-00 feet to a POINT OF BEGINNING. Containing 30,012.04 square feet, (0.69) of land more or less. E M U E M U M Naphea Park North FL I 14 Access & Utilities Easement Kttszlyk EXE I Packet Pg. 188 INSTR 6009713 OR 5899 PG 3822 E--RECORDED 3/1/2021 2.10 PM PAGES 6 CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT AND COMPTROLLER, COLDER COUNTY FLORIDA 8.A.15 DOC@.70 $0.70 REC $52.50 Prepared. b and Return to; Capital "Telecom Holdings It LLB' Attention: Legal Department 820 Mon -is "Turnpike. Suite 104 Short hills, New Jersey 07078 Site Name: Naples Park North FL 1.1.4 parcel: 00324160008 rernainder EASEMENT FORPUBLIC ROADWAY ACCESS AND UTILITIES00 THIS EASEMENT AGREEMENT (hereinafter the "Agreement"), made this .I 8`" day of November, o 2020 by and between JEREMY BEDDOE, a Single man, (hereinafter referred to as "Grantor"), and o CAPITAL TELECOM HOLDINGS 1.1. LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, (hereinafter W O referred to as "Grantee"), y RECITALS WHEREAS, Jeremy Beddoe, hereinaer referred to as Grantor, with a postal address at 3880 Quails Walk., Bonita Springs, Florida 34.134, is the fee simple owner of certain property in the County of Collier, State of Florida which property is more particularly described on Exhibit "A" hereto ("Grantor's Property") which property is the unconveyed remainder of parcel 00324160008 granted by Grantor to Run Le Hie and Anita May Woon Sit in a Deed dated April 21, 2004 and recorded on June 7, 2004 in the office of the Collier County Clerk at Book 3581, Page 1475; and WHEREAS, the Grantor desires to establish for the benefit of the public an easement for public roadway access and utilities over and through such property, to and in favor of the general public; and WHEREAS, the Grantee wishes to obtain legal access for a right of way across the Grantor's Property, NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the premises hereof and other good and valuable consideration in the amount of Two Thousand Five Hundred Dollars ($2,500.00), the receipt and sufficiency of which is hereby acknowledged, the Parties to hereby agree as follows: L The above -referenced recitals are true and correct and constitute a material part of this Agreement. 2. Grantor hereby declares and grants to Grantee and the general public full authority and right to enter upon and use said easement described on Exhibit "B" for all public roadway and utility rights -of -way purposes, at the sole cost and expense and at the sole risk of the general public. Naples Park North TLl 14 Public Access Utilities Easement Beddoe FXP Packet Pg. 189 OR 5899 PG 3823 8.A.15 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Grantor has executed this Easement as of the Effective Date. Witness: ,h i Name: STATE OF F COUNTY OF ss: "GRANTOR" Name: Jeremy Beddoe Date: On the "day of in the year 2020 before me, the undersigned, a notary public in and for said state, personally appeared Jeremy Beddoe, personally known to me or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the individual(s)'whose name(s) is (ate) subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/shekhey executed the same ih his/herltheir- capacity(ies), and that b�is /iitchr--signature4�on the instrument, the individuai(s�or the person upon behalf of which the individual(s) acted, executed the instrument. EMMA A HICAS Notasy Puhiic - Stale o1 D)20 Commission # GG 04 My Comm. Expires Noy 2Bonded thtougit NaE€Qna1 Hoin Notary Public. My Commission Expire Naples park Norlh V1.1 14 public Access Utilities Easement Dedtlhc f X.I; s: Packet Pg. 190 OR 5899 PG 3824 8.A.15 Witness: a Name: n Paris STATE OF NEW JERSEY COUNTY OF ESSEX "GRANTEE" a � 1 Nance: Michael G. Brett Date: November 18, 2020 On the f 8`h day of November in the year 2020 before me, the undersigned, a notary public in and for said state, personally appeared Michael G. Brett, personally known to itte or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the individual(s) whose name(s) is (are) subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to ine that he/she/they executed the saute in his/her/their capacity(ies), and that by his/her/their signature(s) on the instrument. the individual(s) or the person upon behalf of which the individual(s) acted, executed the instrument Notary Pub ic-: My Coin sision Expires: tlrYyq;;:Y Naples Park North Ff.t 14 Pitblic access lttiliiie% Easement Beddoe EXE 00 00 Packet Pg. 191 OR 5899 PG 3825 EXHIBIT "A" Description of Grantor's Property The South 30 feet as described as an. exception in the property conveyed by Grantor to Run Le Hie and Anita May Woon Sit in a Deed dated April 21, 2004 and recorded on June 7, 2004 in the office of the Collier County Clerk at Book 3581, Page 1475 which exception is the unconveyed remainder of parcel 00324160008. co co Naples Park North FL I 14 Public Access Utilities Easement Beddoe EXE I Packet Pg. 192 OR 5899 PG 3826 8.A.15 Easement Area NE 114, SEC. 25, T-49—S, R-27—E COLLMR COUNTY FLORIDA I I I I II If [ I ��'S I �OE4TiE@!r It 5fr� [ I �J t I LY2 3L➢[S Pi: 3774 [ I I I I I I I SERA PC 10 _ �i� dt3Ci5Y EAYEi1CM7 � 1➢430P.H2 44.FTf I 9,45 r,�rs* POO i 30' AMMS E*& MEM i t'MMO 2' OPEM TOP PARCEL 321163ii CM ] PARCEL Ilk ONNERT l LNEtrk'R: Y I 1C2 TH RJOR DIAN FAM S TES FL9HEIYII I I FLkr aooK ,% Fwx M PtAr eaw VICINITY ILidP N fMM SITE SCALE I* = tba" A' 90, too' -V0, SMW Engineering Group, I ISrbsin�-A CenYeEDrive Birr ffkghamn, PJahima 35244 Ph_ 20-252-0985 vrwsr. srrnresll�. r+an i l COI 7E I_I T . cj� I I I 3FB,3d[DOifQS 66ARFlEPo6 LYFit r 184 FMIf 5FIE3 I 4 FMV, al S. PARCEL 13, 32ussmUOR OWNER! TAFAPA LOWE € Z 1r.w in iltlgi7[Wi FAM 'SCE PLAT BMK 4. RPM w FAKEL Lk DPW4120006 dXSi M HAMM, A(IFt51.A R k RERE H 1311 Iaee P@ MS a FUUN© PROPERTY MARKER ♦ CALCVLATEO POW PO®= EOAri OF BEGINNING POC— DINT OF COMMENCEMENT PROJECT IdD. 13-5153 PAgE i OF 2 EXJ- Oir CLIENT CAPITAL T L CO44 1590 MT MtWE rt4lDf W SGVM 20J MQRffST0W au 07ara9 DATE! E9PWM! I CHKO: :~rC&E 00 00 Naples Park North FLI 14 Public Access Utilities Easement Beddoe FXE Packet Pg. 193 *** OR 5899 PG 3827 *** 8.A.15 30' ACCESS EASEMENT: An easement being a portion of Tract 104 and 105 of Floridian Farm Sites described in Plat Book 4, Page 33 recorded in the Public Records Office in Collier County, Florida situated in the Northeast 1/4 of Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East in said County and being more particularly described as fellows; COMMENCE at a 2" open top found marking the Northeast corner of Tract 120 in said Floridian � Fare Sites described in flat Book 4, Page 33, thence N 37°05'33" E a distance of47.63 feet to a o POINT OF BEGINNING; thence N 00°20'38" E a distance of 30.00 :feet to a point; thence S W M° 10'54" E a distance of 656.75 feet to a point; thence S OO'l 8' 10" W a distance of 30.00 feet to 0 a point; thence N fi8°10'S4" W a distance of 65G,77 feet to the PAINT QF BEGINNING, CD Containing 19,702.82 square feet, (0.45 acres) of land more or less. co co Naples Park North FLI 14 Public Access Utilities Easement Beddoe EXE Packet Pg. 194 8.A.16 a t & t February 18, 2021 Vincent Casiero Senior Vice President, Development Diamond Communications 820 Morris Turnpike, Suite 104 Short Hills, NJ 07078 AT&T Mobility 8601 W Sunrise Blvd Plantation, FL 33322 Re: Letter of intent to collocate on your planned cell tower development site FL114 (AT&T site FCL04592, GG Blvd E), located at 26.17939 /-80.57139 in Collier County. Sir: This letter of intent is provided as evidence that AT&T Mobility is in support of your effort to secure zoning approval and building permit for a new cell tower in Collier County. That we intend to enter a long-term agreement and place equipment at the 200' elevation on your planned multi -carrier cell tower, to serve our customers operating on both AT&T Mobility and FirstNet CO networks. o CO The following RF coverage prediction plots are provided as a general depiction of the need for 12 coverage/service improvement and resulting coverage/service improvement the tower location °) will provide. Plot 1: Existing AT&T Mobility cellular network coverage prediction Packet Pg. 195 8.A.16 a t & t February 18, 2021 AT&T Mobility 8601 W Sunrise Blvd Plantation, FL 33322 Plot 2: AT&T Mobility cellular network coverage prediction, with planned Diamond site FL114 (AT&T site FCL04592, GG Blvd E) We look forward to supporting you as needed and in deploying a site as soon as possible, for the benefit of AT&T's Mobility and FirstNet customers needing to operate in the area. Sincerely, George Brosseau Principal RF Engineer AT&T Mobility — Florida (561) 312-3000 T- oo CO Packet Pg. 196 8.A.16 ALTIUS r- S ROAD BAN 0 17 Hunt Valley View Phoenix MD 21131 Ph# 410-667-1638 To Whom It May Concern: Altius Broadband is a wireless internet provider to the underserved markets of Florida and we are interested in collocating on the proposed 220' cell tower to be located at 1710 Benton Road Naples FL 34117 in Collier County. Altius will require a RAD center height of 175 feet to meet our coverage objective for the wireless connectivity needed in the area. We will provide a collocation application directly to Capital Telecom when ready. I am asking for Capital Telecom to advise as to the status of the zoning process and timeline for full entitlements timeline. We are eager to move forward with this colocation. Please let me know if you have any questions. Thank you Jim Connor CEO Packet Pg. 197 8.A.17 FORSYTH & BR UGGR, P.A. Attorneys at Law John N. Brugger* Master of Laws in Taxation John N. Brugger IIIt Master of Laws in Taxation Linda Fink Emaii:jbrugger@forsythbrugger.com *Also Admitted in Michigan tAlso Admitted in Kentucky John F. Forsyth 1921 — 2000 April 20, 2021 WAVV-FM 1016' Guyed Tower Naples, Florida FCC ASR #1020484 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS Andy Solis Burt L. Saunders Penny Taylor Rick LoCastro William L. McDaniel, Jr. 600 Fifth Avenue South; Suite 207 Naples, FL 34102 Phone: (239) 263-6000 Fax: (239) 263-6757 RE: Application PL20180002327 Seeking Approval of a Conditional Use to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the following described property: Parcel No. 32-63-47-2-0009 Dear Commissioners: On behalf of the WAVV-FM/Alpert Tower in Collier County, Florida, we have prepared this letter to express our concerns, make corrections to misinformation presented at the March 18, 2021 Meeting of the Collier County Planning Commission by Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC, and to object to the development of the 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower as applied for in Application PL20180002327 which seeks approval of the Conditional Use and would allow the development of the 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound. Let this letter serve as evidence to the contrary regarding statements made during the March hearing. Page numbers of the Transcript of the Meeting of co co r Packet Pg. 198 8.A.17 the Collier County Planning Commission, March 18, 2021 (the "Transcript") are cited for reference. We respectfully ask for your review and consideration of our responses to the issues addressed below as to why an additional tower located only several hundred feet from the existing tower is unnecessary. Most importantly, as noted in the application submitted by Capital Telecom Holdings, pursuant to the applicable Land Development Code section 5.05.09 Communications Towers "[a] tower with a height in excess of 185 feet above natural grade shall not be approved on a new tower site unless the applicant demonstrates that the proposed tower, antennas, and accessory structures or used cannot be located on any conforming old site or approved site situated within the effective radius." See Exhibit A. In addition, the application goes on to state that for purposes of discovering availability for use of towers within the effective T- oo Go radius, the applicant shall contact the owner of all old and approved towers ... that can possibly r accommodate the needs of the applicant." Exhibit A. No one from Capital Telecom Holdings, Q LLC, the applicant in this instance, has contacted WAVV-FM/Alpert Tower to inquire. This inquiry is a prerequisite to obtaining approval. ISSUE I Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Contends the WAW-FM/Alpert Tower is not Built to Modern Specifications See Page 43 of Transcript The existing tower has been analyzed under the applicable version of the ANSI/TIA-222 Standard and Florida Building Code for every equipment change proposed since the tower was built in 1986. When necessary, the tower capacity has been upgraded with reinforcements to maintain compliance with the applicable design standards at the time of the equipment change. To state that the WAVV-FM Tower is not built to modern specifications is false. Kimley-Horn's review - dated November 11, 2020 - of the Structural Analysis on the WAVV-FM Tower conducted by EBI Consulting in July of 2018, was based upon references to a previous structural analysis by Electronics Research, Inc. ("ERI") dated March 2011 and calculations dated April 2011. These resources were the sole basis of Kimley-Horn's conclusion that the WAVV-FM Tower does NOT have adequate capacity to support the design loading pursuant to the 2017 Florida Building Code and ANSI/TIA-222-G Standard. However, the review states that Kimley- 2 Packet Pg. 199 8.A.17 Horn "cannot confirm the accuracy of the ERI analysis, only that the EBI Consulting analysis is appropriate based on available information." See Exhibit B. ISSUE 2 Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Contends that the Proposed Telecommunications Tower will be Providing Coverage to an Area that did not have Coverage Before Page 43 of Transcript A new tower a few hundred feet from an existing site is highly unlikely to provide coverage to a currently un-serviced area. One may assume this reference is to an upgrade in service, Le "5G" by this statement. Upgrades to 5G service have been accomplished at several existing Verizon sites that ERI has analyzed without the construction of a new tower. To clarify, it is an upgrade. in the equipment mounted on the tower that provides the service upgrade, not the tower itself. oo Go ISSUE 3 Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Contends that the WAVV-FMIAlpert Tower does not have the Capacity to Serve Coverage Needs Page 43 of Transcript We assume this statement is based on the faulty Kimley-Horn review of EBI Consulting Structural Analysis Report that was submitted to Collier County as part of Attachment K — Application -Backup Materials (Exhibit B). The WAVV-FM Tower has not been analyzed by ERI for Verizon since 2011, at which time a small amount of bracing reinforcements were required to bring the tower into compliance with the applicable design standard at the time, which Verizon agreed to have fabricated and installed by ERI. The tower has a fair amount of reserve capacity remaining in it, but the impact of any equipment changes has to be assessed on a case by case basis to determine if there are structural issues that require modifications to the tower. Changes in loading at one elevation on a guyed tower will affect member stresses throughout most, if not all, of such a structure. This is standard practice in the industry. 3 Packet Pg. 200 8.A.17 ISSUE 4 Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Contends that the WAVV-FM/Alpert Tower is not using Modern Antennas that Have a Higher Traffic Capacity Page 44 of Transcript Each tenant supplies their own antenna for use on the tower. Given the structural integrity of the existing tower, WAVV-FM is confident that the choice of antenna Verizon desires to deploy could be supported by the existing WAVV-FM Tower with minimal reinforcements. To date, ERI has not been provided with a list of Verizon's proposed equipment or an order for a structural analysis to assess the new equipment's impact on the tower, therefore further comment cannot be made on this issue, and it is misleading to say otherwise. ISSUE 5 eo Go Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Contends that the WAVV-FM/Alpert Tower Lacks the r Structural Capacity for Verizon's New Deployment d Page 44 of Transcript a i N Again, each tenant supplies their own antenna for use on the tower. Given the structural integrity of the existing tower, WAVV-FM is confident that the choice of antenna Verizon desires to °0 deploy could be supported by the existing WAVV-FM Tower with minimal reinforcements. To 5 date, ERI has not been provided with a list of Verizon's proposed equipment or an order for a i 0 structural analysis to assess the new equipment's impact on the tower, therefore further comment _ cannot be made on this issue, and it is misleading to say otherwise. _ While it may be correct that the tower does not have the capacity to support Verizon's new w deployment without reinforcements of some kind, WAVV-FM is very certain that the overstresses reported in the EBI report are incorrect and an extreme overstatement of the work J that would be required. The location of the reported overstresses is a strong indicator of this. a _ The overstresses reported in EBI's analysis are near the top of the main tower, not at the 220' E level where Verizon's equipment is to be located. It cannot be stated enough times: This tower a r has been reinforced to meet the applicable code at the time of every tenant's equipment change a _ or addition and at this point WAVV-FM has no reason to believe the tower could not be E reinforced to support Verizon's loading, whatever that may be. a 9 Packet Pg. 201 8.A.17 ISSUE 6 Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC's Statement that Red, Pink or Magenta Shown on the Map is Unreliable Coverage is Misleading as it infers that WAW-FM/Alpert Tower does not provide reliable coverage Page 44 of Transcript While a change to the equipment proposed by Verizon to deploy may fill in coverage issues, adding a site a few hundred feet away, in an area as devoid of topographic features as this area of South Florida, is unlikely to result in a large gain in coverage. More likely, this is an equipment issue which could be easily addressed by choice of antennae to be deployed on the existing WAVV-FM Tower. See Map Exhibit C which is part of the applicant's RF Facility Justification report included in its Attachment K to its Application. ISSUE 7 Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Contends that the WAW-FM/Alpert Tower Structurally Fails from a Code Standpoint Page 46 of Transcript See Exhibit D, Collier County Communication Tower Inspection Checklist dated March 14, 2019, which speaks for itself. This tower checklist is performed by Collier County every three (3) years for guyed towers, to ensure that the tower is in good repair. The next inspection would be performed in March of 2022. We assume this statement is based on the faulty Kimley-Horn review of EBI Consulting Structural Analysis Report that was submitted to Collier County as part of Attachment K — Application -Backup Materials. Moreover, ERI had performed a structural analysis for Verizon in 2011 in which reinforcements were designed and installed to accommodate their proposed loading changes, all of which conformed to the then current code standards. ISSUE 8 Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Contends that it will Provide Improved Coverage for Verizon over WAVV-FM/Alpert Tower Page 47 of Transcript Again, each tenant supplies their own antenna for use on the tower. Given the structural integrity of the existing tower, WAVV-FM is confident that the choice of antenna Verizon desires to 5 eo Go r Packet Pg. 202 8.A.17 deploy could be supported by the existing WAVV-FM Tower with minimal reinforcements. To date, ERI has not been provided with a list of Verizon's proposed equipment or an order for a structural analysis to assess the new equipment's impact on the tower, therefore further comment cannot be made on this issue, and it is misleading to say otherwise. In addition, unless Capital Telecom is proposing a replacement structure designed to a higher risk category designation than Risk Category II, which is the current designation of the WAVV- FM Tower, the reference to 911 service and improved coverage is misleading as there is no gain in coverage by adding a new tower that the existing tower could not handle. ISSUE 9 Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC's statement that the proposed tower would improve m coverage capacity and compatibility for Verizon, and provide new coverage for AT&T, as r well as providing wireless broad band serve, is misleading in that the WAVV-FM/Alpert CO Tower could service all of these needs r Page 49 of Transcript Verizon is currently on the WAVV-FM Tower. ERI completed a structural analysis for AT&T to perform an equipment upgrade on the WAVV Tower. A small amount of reinforcements would be required to allow the installation of AT&T's equipment, however, this is standard practice and similar reinforcements to the WAVY structure have been performed throughout the tower's lifespan. Small amounts of reinforcement have been required fairly regularly whenever a tenant increases their loading significantly or when major changes to the tower design standard come into effect. ISSUE 10 Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Contends that the WAVV-FM/Alpert Tower would not be able to support the proposed load shown in Mr. Kelly Shanahan's Report, specifically the tower legs in several sections would become overstressed Page 56 of Transcript We assume this statement is based on the faulty Kimley-Horn review of EBI Consulting Structural Analysis Report that was submitted to Collier County as part of Attachment K — Application -Backup Materials (Exhibit B). The WAVV-FM Tower has not been analyzed for Verizon since 2011, at which time a small amount of bracing reinforcements were required to bring the tower into compliance with the applicable design standard at the time, which Verizon Packet Pg. 203 8.A.17 agreed to have fabricated and installed by ERI. The existing tower has a fair amount of reserve capacity remaining in it, but the impact of any equipment changes has to be assessed on a case by case basis to determine if there are structural issues that require modifications to the tower. Changes in loading at one elevation on a guyed tower will affect member stresses throughout most, if not all, of such a structure. This is standard practice in the industry. To specifically address the misstatement that the existing tower would not be able to support the proposed load in Mr. Shanahan's Report, there are no tower leg issues in the area pointed out in that report, and any overstresses that they report are due to an improper application of the 222-G or 222-H Standard in their analysis. Further, the EBI analysis from 2018 is outdated in that the 222-G Standard is no longer the correct design standard, nor is the Florida Building Code c ("FBC") 6" Edition the correct version of the Florida Building Code. As of January 1 st of this m year, the 222-H Standard and FBC 7th edition are the applicable design standards for this site. oo W Lastly, the loading in the EBI report is not correct and there have been several equipment le changes since 2018. Design standards change as steel design methodology and wind engineering increase in knowledge. The 2018 structural analysis completed for Sprint under the 222-G standard, passed (Exhibit E), and was compliant under the 2017 FBC. The structural analysis of the tower completed for AT&T revealed a need to add reinforcement pursuant to their loading modifications and the current Florida Building Code, however, this would be taken care of with an order for a reinforcement design, and once performed, the new loading capacity would be met as well as compliance with the current code. The overstresses are minor and readily fixed. Updating is standard practice in the industry. ISSUE 11 Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Contends that the WAW-FM/Alpert Tower is over 40 years old, built to older codes, and thus outdated, therefore there is a need for a new tower versus the existing WAVV-FM/Alpert Tower Pages 51, 52 of the Transcript The WAVV-FM/Alpert Tower was built in 1986. It is currently 35 years old. While it is true the tower was built to an older version of the design standard, the tower owner and the various tenants over the years have done an excellent job of keeping the structure up to current standards by installing reinforcements as needed to accommodate loading changes as they occur. This is 7 Packet Pg. 204 8.A.17 standard practice in the industry. The tower was built by one of the most reputable tower designers and fabricators of that time, providing a structure that has met the needs of many different tenants and types of service over the years while generally requiring only minimal reinforcements. The tower is fairly easy to reinforce, when necessary, since all the bracing members are bolt -on and thus able to be fairly easily changed out when needed. IN CONCLUSION Collier County Land Development Code Chapter 5, section 5.05.09(D) states in pertinent part (emphasis added): Shared use of towers . A tower with a height in excess of 185 feet above natural grade shall not be approved, unless the applicant demonstrates that no old or m approved tower within the effective radius can accommodate the applicant's proposed r co co antenna and ancillary equipment. r M For the purpose of discovering availability for use of towers within the effective radius, the applicant shall contact the owner of all old and approved towers, within the effective radius, that can possibly accommodate the needs of the applicant .... A list of all owners contacted, the date of each contact, the form and content of each contact, and all responses shall be a part of the conditional use application If an approved tower within the applicant's approved effective radius may have capacity available for the antenna proposed by the applicant, the application for a new tower shall not be complete without the following information regarding each such possibly available approved tower. Such information shall also be provided for old towers to the extent it can be obtained. Identification of the site of each possibly available tower by coordinates, street address or legal description, existing uses, and tower height. Whether shared use by the applicant of the tower is prohibited (or is not feasible) for any reason If it has been determined that the tower owner will allow structural changes, whether the tower can accommodate the proposed antenna if reasonable structural changes are made. If so, the applicant shall specify what structural changes would be required and an Packet Pg. 205 8.A.17 approximation of the costs of such changes. If the costs of the required changes are financially impracticable, such tower shall be deemed unavailable to the applicant. 4. The applicant shall contact the owner of each possibly available approved tower to request the needed information. To enable the tower owner to respond, the applicant shall provide the following information regarding the applicant's proposed antenna and equipment: a. All output frequencies of transmitter. a Type of modulation, polarization of radiation, and proposed use of antenna. C. Manufacturer, type, manufacturer's model number, a diagram of the antenna's °J radiation pattern, and the manufacturer's specifications. CO d. le r Power input to antenna and gain of antenna in decibels with respect to an isotopic radiator. Q e. H Range in feet of maximum and minimum height of antenna above base of tower A list of necessary ancillary equipment and description of the type of transmission cable to be used. Any other pertinent information needed to enable the owner to respond in full to the inquiry. As noted on page 62 of the Transcript, stated by Mr. Klatzkow, the key issue to be determined for approval pursuant to the Florida Land Development Code turns on whether or not the proposed equipment could be put onto an existing tower - as a prerequisite to approval, the "applicant must demonstrate that no old or approved tower within the effective radius can accommodate the applicant's proposed antenna and ancillary equipment." Mr. Finn conceded that staff has not looked into this issue at all. Furthermore, the applicant in the instant case has not complied with 5.05.09(D)(1), requiring the applicant contact the owner of all old and approved towers, within the effective radius, that can possibly accommodate the needs of the applicant. WAVV-FM has never been contacted to see if it could accommodate the applicant's needs, and Section 5.05.09(D)(3) of the Code takes into account structural changes that may be necessary to accommodate a proposed I Packet Pg. 206 8.A.17 antenna. Then, only if financially impracticable would the existing tower be deemed "unavailable" to the applicant. As well, it should be noted that in the instant case, the applicant is not a cell phone service provider looking to accommodate its antenna, rather, the applicant is a proposed cell tower itself, hoping to lease space to potential cellular service tenants. The aforementioned points outlined under each "Issue" substantiate that no new tower is necessary, and to approve the Conditional Use application would be in direct contravention with existing Florida Land Development Code. We therefore respectfully request that Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC's Application PL20180002327 seeking approval of a Conditional Use to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound, be denied. We have also attached an Environmental Comments report prepared by Synecological Analysts, CO CO Environmental Evaluation and Advocacy, for your review regarding the proposed location of the new tower. Amongst other environmental issues, of special note is the significant activity of d Florida panthers in the vicinity, as shown on the included panther location from telemetry data. This identifies only those panthers with radio collars. The activity created by increased traffic to service a new tower would certainly add further increased disruption to panther habitat. Sincerely, i , s . cc: Mr. Al Baxa, Chief Engineer Dr. Donna L. Alpert, Stockholder and Director David E. Alpert, Vice President Kenneth Lamparyk, Treasurer Laura Lamparyk, President Doug Alpert, Vice President Packet Pg. 207 8.A.17 EXHIBIT -k- g. Any other pertinent information needed to enable the owner to respond in full to the inquiry. The Relocation Tower will be designed to accommodate Verizon's antennas as well as up to 3 additional set of antennas. Additionally, Capital has committed to make the 3 colocations available to wireless providers at market rates. Please see the Sheets C2 and C3 as well as the enclosed Colocation Affidavit. E. Shared use of tower sites. A tower with a height in excess of 185 feet above natural grade shall not be approved on a new tower site unless the applicant demonstrates that the proposed tower, antennas, and accessory structures or uses cannot be located on any conforming old site or approved site situated within the effective radius. Sites owned by any government or leased to any government are exempt from these shared use provisions except to other governments. 1. Except as to each old site or approved site determined by the County Manager or designee, or in a shared use plan to be unavailable to the applicant , the applicant shall contact the owner of all other conforming old sites and approved tower sites, within the effective radius, containing sufficient land area to possibly accommodate the needs of the applicant . 2. For each such possibly available tower site, the application for anew tower site shall not be complete without the following information: a. Identification of the proposed new tower site by coordinates, street address or legal description, area, existing uses, topography, and significant natural features. b. Evidence that no old and no approved tower site within the effective radius can accommodate the applicant's needs.. c. If the owner of an old tower site does not respond to the applicant's simple letter of interest inquiry within thirty (30) days, or the owner of an old tower site will not rent land to accommodate the applicant's needs for a reasonable period of time at reasonable rentals, such old tower site shall be deemed unavailable to the applicant. d. The applicant is not required to supply this information to owners of conforming old sites unless the old site appears to be available to the applicant by a shared use plan or the site's owner has responded positively to the applicant's initial letter of inquiry. To enable the site owner to respond, the applicant shall provide the site owner (and the owner of any tower on the site) with the dimensional characteristics and other relevant data about the tower, and a report from a professional engineer licensed in the State of Florida, or other qualified expert, documenting the following: 00 00 Page 7 of 21 Capital — Naples Park Packet Pg. 208 EXHIBIT KJO, mlloyl* 4214, tyeffoAe S#64141 — (0116 2 W Fl,Fi`iat� Ear P0(466 'It' -11do 9 m m A (U44 t� 61 lit" bi. w 4WMft We 0 IF lit, klon 6,k�*iimy bood -i*. th&: i .. " --# i ep burp actft-ihc9fu ti cfesicrftpadikx pumentothIC ul or. ma n se-ooloame-viaphano 6 itsho d 0616f ol rr;r got 11. Cl 0 F- a 0 E E 0 0 0 eo Go FPacket Pg. 209 8.A.17 _. p O � (Q -nm N Q CO 7Z m X m v- cc n O m CQ m -0m o O (D 3 0 �a 0 E E 0 t� �a 0 a 0 m m 00 co aCl) W X acket Pg. 211 EXHIBIT 8•A.17 11 Collier County J,.J Communication Tower Inspection Checklist Location of tower: Address.. 102 BQ>1tOr1 ROa-__---------- ID: -- - ------ - - owner Name: —Al n arVad stir r L A1/ Owner Address: 1 1 R- OO Tamia=i -Trail Ea Owner or Manager phone number and email address: (21q)7A3-1 01 alhaxa(q)wavV1 n1.rn — 1) Is this a guyed tower? Yes © No ❑ For All Towers 2) Is the tower structure showing any signs of unusual stress or vibrations? Yes ❑ No © If yes, please describe: 3) Are any bolts or tower members loose or darriaged? Yes ❑ No ® if yes, please describe: 4) Are any antennas, transmission lines, lighting, insulators, fencing, grounding, elevators or other structures and devices associated with the tower site in need of repair and/or maintenance? Yes ❑ No ® If yes, please descn be: 5) Is anything at the site in need of painting? Yes ❑ No® If yes, please describe: 6) Is the tower in use? YesEL-] No❑ If no, please enter the date of deactivation: For Guyed Towers Only 7) Are any guy wires and/or fittings showing any signs of failure due to age, strength, rust, wear, general conditions, or any other conditions? Yes ❑ No ® If yes, please describe: 8) Are any guy anchors and/or foundations showing any sign of failure due to cracks, corrosion, erosion, movement, unsecure hardware, or any other conditions? Yes ❑ No ® If yes, please describe 9) Is the tower vertical alignment and/or guy wire tension (both required tension and present tension) in need of adjustment and/or repair? Yes ❑ No FC] If yes, please describe: If this inspection finds that any repairs, replacements, and/or maintenance is required for any of these items, they E shall be done in a timely manner. After all repairs, replacements, and/or maintenance are completed, another s �a inspection shall b ne confirming there are no other repairs, replacements, and/or maintenance required, Q Name and Tit of p rs n who prepared this document: Doff Barber Manager, Universal Tower Servic Signature: _,�/_ -- - ----- - Date: Ctq ---- Packet Pg. 213 8.A.17 �1 EXHIBIT CERTIFJ,EQ FAW UR a STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS REPORT AUGUST 10, 2018 Prepared For: Mr. Jason Schopke TelAcq Consulting, Inc. 1015 US Highway 19 Holiday, FL 34691 Phone: (8.13) 817-5664 Email: ischopke@telacg.com Prepared By: Doug Lampert Staff Engineer — Structural Division Electronics Research, Inc. 7777 Gardner Road Chandler, IN 47610 Phone: (812) 925-6000 Extension 324 >>%Iti I I I II/ EmaU:dlg=ert@eriinc.com ¢Q H;, VA �,�i Reviewed by: w Le WO rn No. 51779 STATE OF 60. � Buford H. Evans, Jr., PE, SE�.'O".'. Q !Q G\a``'��, Consulting Engineer *Vier j10 t 1 ��*� /O A 00lP 00 00 Packet Pg. 214 8.A.17 8.A.17 A. RESULTS This analysis was performed by ERI to determine the capability of the present structure to meet the requirements of the ANSI/TIA-222-G, Structural Standard for Antenna Supporting Structures and Antennas, with loading as specified by the customer. This report details the tower history, the present design code history and application, and the impact of the design wind speed and appurtenances on the structure. The ERI analysis finds: Under the investigated loading scenario, the tower complies with the 2017 Florida State Building Code 6th Edition (Section 1609.1.1, Exception 5, Risk Category II, Wind Map Figure 1609A, Section 1609.3.1 Equation 16-33) ASCE7-10, and the ANSI/TIA-222-G, Structural Standard for Antenna Supporting Structures and Antennas, for a nominal (Vasa) no -ice wind speed of 124 mph (equivalent to an ultimate wind speed (V lt) of 160 mph) while utilizing the following site -specific parameters: Risk Category II, Exposure Category C, and Topographic Category 1 (see Section D for complete parameters utilized). r 2. Because of a lack of data on the steel reinforcement of the guy anchor foundations, all co guy anchors are assumed to have a minimum steel reinforcement ratio (p) of 0.005 (see `Recommendations'). I d B. METHOD OF ANALYSIS We have analyzed this tower based upon the following information: 1. Engineering inspection of the structure by ERI in October 2005 and subsequent pre - construction and post -construction inspections for the installation of tower reinforcements in 2011. 2. Previous ERI analysis and reinforcement projects on this structure (ERI Projects #34473, 28104, 27703A, 27703, 16361A-B-C, and 15706). 3. Analysis of the structure by Consolidated Engineering in May 2010. 4. Geotechnical investigation and foundation mapping by FDH in 2006. 5. Written and oral communication with Jason Schopke of TelAcq, Inc. 6. Published and calculated data for appurtenance loading. Packet Pg. 216 1 8.A.17 sYNF-Co�Lo�cicAL ikNALYSTS, Environmental Evaluation and Advocacy www.synecol.com 20 April 2021 Mr. Jack Brugger 600 Fifth Avenue South Suite 207 Naples, FL 34102 RE: BENTON ROAD RELO - Collier Co. PL 20180002327 Environmental Comments Dear Mr. Brugger 00 This correspondence transmits Synecological Analysts@ Inc.'s comments based on our review of the referenced project/application. This review process is ongoing. Our a review is based your guidance to identify and briefly describe items that based on our experience and opinion are not be fully addressed by the applicant from an environmental standpoint. These comments are presented as bullet points in the L interest of brevity. 00 a • No Federal Jurisdictional Determination, Exemption, Approval, No Permit Required Letter, General Permit Notice or Wetland Jurisdictional Determination was applied for to the Corps of Engineers on this site. Lots of paperwork lacking specificity but no Federal Agency onsite to evaluate. No relevant Federal Wetland Jurisdictional determination form(s) for this site are in the record. Submitting a NEPA report does not obviate the requirement to comply with the Federal Clean Water Act. • State Wetland Approval done by engineer proxy with only a 5%- 10% probability the site was actually evaluated. There is no state Jurisdictional Form or paper trail. • Beyond Archaeology, the lack of environmental documentation is striking. A FLUCCS map and description along with a floristic list were prepared. The lack of an ecological evaluation of this site or its impacts in such a voluminous record is unusual. • There is considerable evidence the much of this site was recently cleared. For example, there is a stack of Cabbage palm near the 2159 Morning Sun Lane, Naples, FL 34119 239-514-3998 Fax: 305-907-6034 brown synecol.com Packet Pg. 217 8.A.17 pad site. The downed trees show significant scarring. This site has burned multiple times in recent years. To our knowledge a Vegetation Removal Permit was not issued for this activity. • As evidenced by the tree scarring shown on the photo above and documented at the time by local observers the recent fire(s) is/were very hot. This extreme heat allowed the fire to spread to the Pine tree canopy resulting in a crown fire. It is likely this sort of fire has occurred on the site in question in recent years and could have both killed and consumed the trees. Some of these fires were so hot that even the tree stumps were burned to below ground level. The absence a discussion of pyrrhic influence on the ecology of this site is critical, particularly from a Jurisdictional wetlands standpoint. • This lack of any altered state of this site discussion is critical. Slash pines have historically dominated much of this portion of Collier County and this species is still evident on a majority of land near the proposed site. Historically, the proposed site has not been very different from the area as a whole from a vegetational standpoint. The current absence of Slash pine on this site makes a consequential difference from a wetlands evaluation standpoint. Slash pine are considered as Facultative Wet Species on the National Plant List. This means it usually it usually occurs in wetlands (estimated probability 67%-99%), but is occasionally found in non -wetlands. Several other FACW species were observed on the site. A site with a Slash pine canopy might well be considered wetlands. Monodominant Cabbage palm would likely be identified as uplands. The applicant presented a floristic list of the site along with a few photos but we found no ecological discussion. 00 00 Packet Pg. 218 8.A.17 • This site has burned at least three times since Jan. of 2017. In April of 2017 it was burned in the 301h Ave SW fire and again a week later by the Lee Williams Road fire. The 361h Ave fire burned the site again in 2020. • Some of these fires had flames reaching 150' in height. Placing communication equipment in such a fire prone area with no discussion of planning for such events is problematic. For comparison, pls note the fire lane constructed by the landowner across Benton Road to the west to protect their property. • The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service published Proposed Critical Habitat Unit Areas (CHU's) for the Florida Bonneted Bat in the Federal Register on 10 June of this year. The applicant noted that this site could be within this designation, but to our knowledge, the current status of the proposed site in the Proposed Critical Habitat Unit Areas was not done. The location of this proposed tower within a proposed Critical Habitat Unit Area is relevant and worthy of your consideration. • There was a discussion of the Florida Panther in the Applicants NEPA study. No graphics were presented re Panther data points near the proposed tower site. Such a graphic is attached for your consideration. • Part of a Federal "Needs Evaluation" for a project is alternatives. Among the necessary options to discuss is the No Project option. We observed no Needs or Alternatives Evaluations in supporting material submitted to Collier County. There is an existing tower within 1500' of the proposed site that still has considerable availability of space yet to lease on the tower would make it difficult to justify the project impact and carbon footprint of the proposed tower. 00 00 Packet Pg. 219 8.A.17 As noted initially our review of the information and community status relative to the referenced project is ongoing. Your consideration of these comments is appreciated. Thank you. Very ruly ours, Brown Collins Principal Ecologist CO CO Packet Pg. 220 "Y CSY �L�oc�icAL ikNALYSTS Environmental Evaluation and Advocacy BROWN COLLINS EDUCATION B.S., Range Science, Texas A&M University, 1969 M.S. Range Science (Plant Ecology/Soils), Texas A&M University, 1972 AWARDS/CERTIFICATIONS Ecologist - Ecological Society of America 1981 CPSS - Soil Sci. Soc. Of America 1982 Armaud Bayou Awd. - The Nature Conservancy 1974 681mi 00 Brown Collins has a graduate degree in ecology and more than 48 years of southwest 00 Florida experience. He brings realism founded on a firm technical base to the process of environmental evaluation and permitting. He has permitted hundreds of projects with d many degrees of ecological complexity. a Recent projects relevant to this proposal include RMC South Florida Materials Corkscrew Road Mine, University Lakes, University Lakes West, Southwest Florida Rock and Corkscrew Woods. All these projects are in the Alico-Corkscrew corridor. Historic projects include the Turkey Point Nuclear Generating Station, Miami Jetport and IMC Phosphate Mine, Phase I. Other projects of interest include mapping several thousand acres in the STA 3/4 Area of the Everglades Restoration Project, State Road 29 improvements from 1-75 to Copeland and all Florida Department of Transportation mitigation site monitoring from Polk County to Collier County. Mr. Collins has following accomplishments. • Obtained over 400 permits and approvals for projects impacting wetlands. • Mapped more than 250,000 acres of Florida plant communities, primarily wetlands. • Sampled and quantitatively analyzed more than 50,000 acres. • Mapped more than 100,000 acres of soils and technically edited NRCS county Soil Surveys As president and founder of Synecological Analysts, Inc., his focus has been primarily with wetland determinations, project permitting and wetland mitigation and enhancement. 2159 Morning Sun Lane, Naples, FL 34119 239-514-3998 Fax: 239-514-0955 brown@synecol.com Packet Pg. 221 8.A.17 Project location o Panther location from telemetry data K I SYNECCL� AL �NALYSTS ENVIPONNEMAL EVALIAIIDN AND ADPDDADY 2189 Morning Sun Lana NAPLES, FLORIDA M19 PHONE:'239) 514.1998 V .synecol.com Benton Rd PROJECT: Tower Benton Road, Naples, FL 34117 DATE: 4/16/2021 �:$U�I►11-yM►1►JI L 3 0 0 �a U 0 E E 0 U R 0 _ 0 r _ m 00 00 00 Rt a .. N '<.wcom H'h s 0 500 1,000 1,500 ft Packet Pg. 222 I 8.A.18 I ' uCERTIFIED Q FABRICATOR STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS REVIEW APRIL 19, 2021 WAVV-FM 1016' Guyed Tower Naples, FL FCC ASR #1020484 Prepared For: Mr. Al B axa Chief Engineer — WAW-FM 11800 Tamiami Trail East Naples, FL 34113 Phone: (239) 793-1011 Email: albaxa(a,waw101.com Prepared By: Doug Lampert Staff Engineer — Structural Division Electronics Research, Inc. 7777 Gardner Road Chandler, IN 47610 Phone: (812) 925-6000 Ext. 324 Email: dlampert(aDeriincxom �-"j c as E a E M a Packet Pg. 223 I 8.A.18 I TABLE OF CONTENTS A........................................................................................................................ SUMMARY B....................................................................................... SOURCES OF INFORMATION C............................................................................................................ TOWER HISTORY D..................DESIGN CRITERIA AND EQUIPMENT LOADING CONSIDERATIONS E...................................................................................... ASSUMPTIONS/LIMITATIONS F...................................................................LOADING CONDITIONS INVESTIGATED G.................................................................................................ASSESSMENT RESULTS H.................................................................................................................CONCLUSIONS I......................................................................................................................... SUMMARY a 2 Packet Pg. 224 I 8.A.18 I A. SUMMARY At the request of Al Baxa of WAW-FM, Electronics Research, Incorporated (ERI) performed an independent review of another firm's July 2018 structural analysis of the 1016' WAW-FM tower in Collier County, FL. The other firm's analysis reported multiple major overstresses in the tower legs between 910' — 700' AGL based upon a tower loading scenario that was present in 2011. Electronics Research has performed multiple structural analysis studies on this particular structure over the past sixteen years and has provided reinforcement materials three times over that period to allow the tower to maintain compliance with applicable design standards while accommodating equipment changes by various tenants. Additionally, ERI has performed studies and reinforcing materials on numerous other communication towers ranging from 20' tall to 2000' tall and is thus well -qualified for this assessment. It is important to note early in this letter that the EBI analysis was performed to the ANSI/TIA- CO 222-G Standard, which was the applicable design standard for communications towers in Florida r oo until the end of 2020. As of January 1, 2021, the design of communication towers is dictated by Go the 2020 Florida Building Code 7th Edition and by the ANSI/TIA-222-H, Structural Standard for Antenna Supporting Structures, Antennas and Small Wind Turbine Support Structures. The 222- H Standard is the latest revision of the tower design standard. 222-H became the effective ANSI — standard for this application on January 1, 2018, with gradual subsequent adoption by various states' building codes continuing today. For the sake of an equal comparison between EBI's y analysis and ERI's analysis, all calculations that were performed by ERI and noted in this letter were done to the 222-G Standard. An important component of the 222-H Standard, which was also a component of previous revisions of the 222 Standard, is the design of cantilevered structures mounted on a supporting structure. The current and previous revisions of the 222-Standard all realized that the wind stresses on the cantilevered portion of the tower will be much different than the stresses on the main supporting tower because of the generally more slender elements that compose the supporting structure. That slenderness will result in different vibration or swaying of the cantilever than the main support structure. The 222-Standard thus provides different "gust effect factors" (Gh) to be applied to the structure, depending on whether the tower is guyed, self- supporting, a hollow pole structure, or a cantilevered structure supported on another structure, such as the case of the WAW tower. Incorrect application of these gust effect factors can greatly affect the results of a tower structural analysis, possibly making a tower that actually passes easily or can pass with minimal reinforcements if the correct gust effect factors had been used, instead appear to fail miserably. We are fairly certain that incorrect application of the gust effect factor in the EBI analysis has resulted in the supposed overstresses shown in their report. The EBI analysis of the WAW tower that was provided to the commissioners as supporting evidence of the need construct a new tower nearby was provided to ERI roughly one month ago for review and commentary. According to page 1 of the EBI analysis, their tower loading and structural information was based on our company's March 11, 2021 analysis of the structure. The EBI analysis includes most, but not all, of the relevant tower analysis computer program output and from this information, I was able to put together a tower model with input that is nearly identical to the tower model that EBI's failing analysis report is based upon. Packet Pg. 225 I 8.A.18 I The only way that I can achieve similar overstresses in the WAVV tower to those shown in the EBI analysis report submitted to the commissioners to support the need for a new structure is to utilize an incorrect value for the gust effect factor that is applied to the top cantilevered portion of the WAVV tower. When the correct value of the gust effect factor is used, the tower is well within capacity to support the loading considered in EBI's analysis. If the incorrect gust effect factor is used on this structure, the wind pressure on the cantilevered portion is increased by nearly 30%, which thus imparts significant additional stresses on the main tower in the top two guy spans, which is exactly what is reported in the EBI analysis. The gust effect factors utilized in a tower analysis are part of the output of the computer program that EBI and ERI both utilize. However, EBI's analysis report left out the part of the output that states the utilized gust effect factor, so we cannot state unequivocally that this is the mistake in EBI's analysis, but the evidence is strong that this is the case. In Section G of this report, we provide a chart comparing the other firm's program output for leg c capacity utilization to our output when the incorrect Gh value is applied. The rightmost column m of this chart provides our output when the correct Gh is applied to the cantilever. A scan of this oo chart shows the obvious similarities between EBI's calculated leg stresses and ERI's calculated 00 leg stresses when the incorrect gust effect factor is used, and also the stark contrast in leg stresses when the correct gust effect factor is used. As you can see, the tower legs all pass when the correct gust effect factor is utilized. B. SOURCES OF INFORMATION We have performed this review tower based upon the following information: 1. Engineering inspection of the structure by Electronics Research Inc. in October 2005 and subsequent pre -construction and post -construction inspections for the installation of tower reinforcements in 2011. 2. EBI analysis report of the structure dated July 17, 2018 (EBI Project 8117000785), which was provided to ERI by the tower owner. 3. Previous Electronics Research Incorporated analysis and reinforcement projects on this structure (ERI Projects #38655, 36425, 34473, 28104, 27703A, 27703, 16361A-B-C, and 15706). ERI analysis project 27703A was utilized as the comparative ERI project for this review because the completion date of that ERI project coincides well with the completion date of the EBI analysis and because ERI project 27703A also considered the proposed loading changes by Verizon that the EBI analysis considered. 4. Kline design and analysis documents for the structure (Kline Project #3256). 5. Written and oral communication Al Baxa of Alpine Broadcasting and representatives of the various companies seeking to co -locate on this tower over the years that ERI has been the engineer of record on this structure. 6. TNX Tower version 7.0.8.5 was utilized for the EBI analysis project. Therefore, Electronics Research Inc. utilized the same version of this program for the review, in order to ensure comparable results that do not result from using a newer update of this software. M Packet Pg. 226 I 8.A.18 I C. TOWER HISTORY The tower was originally designed and manufactured by the Kline Iron and Steel Company in 1986 (Kline Project #3256). The structure was originally designed under the EIA-RS-222-C design code (effective from March of 1976 to May of 1987) for a constant wind pressure of 100 pounds per square foot. The EIA-RS-222-C design code based the wind force as a uniform pressure according to the location's Wind Loading Zone per section 2.2.1 and Chart I of the standard with step functions occurring between 0 to 300 feet and between 301 to 650 feet to account for increased wind forces with respect to elevation and rarely gave any consideration to the effects of ice accumulation on the structure. Towers 651 feet and higher were designed to an increased constant uniform wind pressure for their entire height. Kline Towers performed several analyses on the structure that were supplied to ERI for analysis #15706. Following is a brief synopsis of the reinforcements recommended in the supplied Kline analysis reports, which were verified during ERI's engineering inspection of the tower in 2005, and ERI's reinforcement of the tower in 2011. T oo 1. August 1995: Kline recommended the reinforcement of tower legs in two sections, Go replacement of diagonal bracing in seven bays, and replacement of horizontal struts at three elevations. 6 2. October 1996: Kline recommended the replacement of horizontal struts at three elevations to accommodate the addition of panel antennas for Alltel. 3. March 3, 1997: Kline recommended the replacement of diagonal bracing in five bays and the replacement of horizontal struts at five elevations to accommodate the addition of equipment for Novaline. 4. March 21, 1997: Kline recommended the replacement of horizontal struts at three elevations to accommodate the addition of panel antennas for Alltel. 5. September 1998: Three tower sections above the top guy level were removed and replaced with freestanding ERI Lambda sections and a transition section to accommodate the addition of an ERI SHPX-8AC FM antenna for Alpine Broadcasting. 6. April 2011: At the recommendation of ERI, diagonal members in five (5) bays were replaced with new diagonals made from higher strength steel. Bays where the diagonals were changed are: Section 1 (I V - 41') Bays 2 & 3 Section 4 (101' - 13l') Bay 6 Section 8 (221' - 251') Bays 1 & 2 5 Packet Pg. 227 I 8.A.18 I D. DESIGN CRITERIA AND EQUIPMENT LOADING CONSIDERATIONS EBI's 2018 analysis was performed under the ANSI/TIA-222-G, Structural Standard for Antenna Supporting Structures and Antennas and the applicable Florida Building Code at the time using an ultimate wind speed of 159 mph, as required for Risk Category II structures at the time of the analysis, Exposure Category C, and Topographic Category 1. Electronics Research's assessment of the site -specific parameters of this tower agree with EBI's, and thus, identical design parameters were used in the review analysis of the provided EBI report. The effective projected areas and weights of the equipment used in the EBI analysis were F= 0 matched in Electronics Research's review analysis, with the exception of the Verizon equipment, v which was treated as a proposed loading addition to the tower in the EBI analysis. Because ERI was provided with the same proposed loading changes as EBI was for project 27703A, ERI's 0 calculated values for the Verizon equipment changes were utilized rather than EBI's. There are c several different ways to consider cellular loading changes in a tower structural analysis, with c different levels of conservatism applied, which will lead to slightly different results in the m analysis. Because the difference between ERI's analysis results and EBI's analysis results are s000 r significant and because of the locations of the reported overstresses in the EBI analysis, we Go believe that any relatively small differences in the amount of conservatism applied to the Verizon 77 equipment loading are not the cause of the discrepancies between the two firms' analysis results. E. ASSUMPTIONS/LIMITATIONS We have assumed that the provided EBI report contains the actual TNX Tower input and output data used in their analysis. Without having the actual TNX Tower model file, we cannot confirm that is the case, but that is the case in most every tower structural analysis performed. The following assumptions are typical of all tower structural analysis projects performed by any firm without the benefit of a recent engineering inspection of the tower. Tower mast assumed plumb with no twist. As -built plumb and twist should be checked and corrected as necessary to within the tolerances designated in Section 13.0 of the ANSI/TIA-222-G Standard. 2. Guy wires assumed properly tensioned to the values specified in this report. Please note, the initial tension settings have a significant impact on the overall stability and distributed stresses within the main lattice mast under design wind and ice loads. As -built guy tensions must be verified and adjusted as needed to validate the results of this study. Initial guy tension settings shall be within ::L10% of the specified values for guy cables up to and including 1" 0, and f5% of the specified values for cables greater than 1" 0. 3. This analysis assumes the structure was erected and maintained in accordance with the manufacturer's plans and specifications and those contained in the latest version of the ANSI/TIA standard. The tower and foundations are assumed to be in good condition and without defect. 4. This study assumes there has been no damage or modifications to the original design and materials either by man or nature, either gradual or sudden, except where may be disclosed elsewhere in this report. Loose bolts, bent members, cracked welds, corrosion, and other tower defects have not been considered. 0 Packet Pg. 228 I 8.A.18 I F. LOADING CONDITIONS INVESTIGATED The following tower loads were used in ERI'S analysis. Most of the EBI values were exactly what ERI used in our 2011 tower analysis, but there were a couple of relatively small discrepancies. In order to assess the EBI analysis results versus ERI'S results, the loading in ERI'S assessment analysis tower model was changed to match EBI's where necessary, in order to have comparative results, with the exception of the Verizon equipment, as noted in Section D above. F1. Antenna Design Data Discrete Tower Loads Description Face Offset Offsets: Azimuth Placement CAAA CAAA Weight or Type Horizontal Adjustment Front Side Leg Lateral Vertical oft z z K Beacon C None 0.0000 1016.000 No Ice 2.500 2.500 0.085 1" Conduit Crow's Nest Lightning Dissipater C None 0.0000 1016.000 No Ice 8.000 8.000 0.075 SHPX-8AC C From Leg 1.500 0.0000 944.150 - No Ice 38.000 38.000 0.930 (WAVV-FM 101.1 MHz, #05328A) 0.000 1012.000 3-1/8" Rigid) 0.000 A/R brackets for SHPX-8AC C From Face 0.500 0.0000 944.150 - No Ice 4.300 4.300 0.052 0.000 1012.000 0.000 A/R brackets for SHPX-8AC A From Face 0.500 0.0000 944.150 - No Ice 4.300 4.300 0.052 0.000 1012.000 0.000 Index Plate Ass'y A None 0.0000 943.188 No Ice 0.000 0.000 2.800 ERI LP-lE-SP C From Leg 1.500 0.0000 921.000 No Ice 3.000 3.100 0.075 (WAVV-HDFM, 101.1 MHz, #21223) 0.000 1-5/8" Coax 0.000 Red Lights C None 0.0000 878.000 No Ice 2.000 2.000 0.050 (1" Conduit) (3) Stati-Cats C None 0.0000 794.000 No Ice 1.500 1.500 1 0.035 Empty Tic Back C From Face 0.250 0.0000 754.500 No Ice 3.000 3.000 0.085 0.000 0.000 2-way ASP C Stand -Off Right 3.500 0.0000 735.000 No Ice 6.500 6.500 0.050 (2-1/4" Coax) 0.000 0.000 2-way ASP Mount C From Face 0.250 0.0000 735.000 No Ice 11.000 3.500 0.250 1.000 0.000 Red Lights C None 0.0000 727.000 No Ice 2.000 2.000 0.050 DB228 C Stand -Off Left 7.000 0.0000 685.750 - No Ice 13.000 13.000 0.072 (1-1/4" Coax) 0.000 726.000 0.000 DB228 C Stand -Off Right 7.000 0.0000 685.750 - No Ice 13.000 13.000 0.072 (1-1/4" Coax) 0.000 726.000 0.000 DB228 Mounts C From Face 0.250 0.0000 685.750 - No Ice 20.500 1.000 0.500 0.000 726.000 0.000 TxRx 101-68-10-X-03N (#16361) C From Leg 5.750 0.0000 675.000 No Ice 5.600 5.600 0.070 (2-1/4" Coax) 0.000 0.000 TxRx 101-68-10-X-03N Mount C From Leg 2.875 0.0000 675.000 No Ice 7.000 7.000 0.135 0.000 0.000 12' whip w/ Mount C From Leg 1.000 0.0000 651.500 No Ice 3.000 3.000 0.050 (1/2" Coax) 0.000 0.000 (3) Stati-Cats C None 0.0000 591.000 No Ice 1.500 1 1.500 1 0.035 Beacon C None 0.0000 584.500 No Ice 2.500 2.500 0.085 (1" Conduit) T_ oo 00 7 Packet Pg. 229 I 8.A.18 I Description Face Offset Offsets: Azimuth Placement CAAA CAAA Weight or Type Horizontal Adjustment Front Side Leg Lateral Vertical ft 0ft ft, ft, K Celwave PD458 B From Leg 5.000 0.0000 458.000 No Ice 4.000 4.000 0.025 (7/8" Coax) 0.000 0.000 Celwave Mount B From Leg 2.500 0.0000 458.000 No Ice 0.500 3.000 0.080 0.000 0.000 Red Lights C None 0.0000 437.500 No Ice 2.000 2.000 0.050 1" Conduit DB264 w/ Mount B From Leg 2.000 60.0000 412.000 - No Ice 6.500 7.000 0.075 (7/8"Coax) 0.000 422.000 0.000 3 Stati-Cats C None 0.0000 405.000 No Ice 1.500 1.500 0.035 (2) DB858HV90 (Alltel) B From Leg 0.333 -40.0000 342.000 - No Ice 35.000 12.500 0.120 ((2) 7/8" Coax, (1) 1-5/8" Coax) 0.000 359.500 0.000 (2) DB858HV90 (Alltel) C From Leg 0.333 40.0000 342.000 - No Ice 35.000 12.500 0.120 ((2) 7/8" Coax, (1) 1-5/8" Coax) 0.000 359.500 0.000 DB436 Yagi (on 6' grid rim) B From Leg 3.000 20.0000 321.000 No Ice 1.000 1.000 0.010 (7/8" Coax) 0.000 0.000 DB812 C From Leg 6.000 0.0000 295.000 No Ice 6.750 6.750 0.065 (7/8" Coax) 0.000 0.000 DB812 Mount C From Leg 3.000 0.0000 295.000 No Ice 2.500 5.500 0.100 0.000 0.000 BCR12 A From Leg 6.000 0.0000 318.500 - No Ice 13.250 13.250 0.100 (1-518" Coax) 0.000 295.500 0.000 BCR12 B From Leg 6.000 0.0000 313.500 - No Ice 13.250 13.250 0.100 (1-5/8" Coax) 0.000 290.500 0.000 BCR12 Antenna Mount A From Leg 3.000 0.0000 318.500 - No Ice 2.500 7.500 0.115 0.000 295.500 0.000 BCR12 Antenna Mount B From Leg 3.000 0.0000 313.500 - No Ice 2.500 7.500 0.115 0.000 290.500 0.000 Beacon C None 0.0000 289.500 No Ice 2.500 2.500 0.085 1" Conduit (3) Stati-Cats C None 1 0.0000 199.500 No Ice 1.500 1.500 0.035 Red Lights C None 0.0000 148.250 No Ice 2.000 2.000 0.050 (1-1/4" Conduit) Verizon Sector A: (2) CSS X7CAP-880-22i-bot j3, (3) A From Leg 3.500 0.0000 220.000 No Ice 29.000 28.000 0.190 2" Sch. 40 x 72" mounting pipes, (2) 1/2" coax jumpers 0.000 ((2) 1-5/8" Coax) 0.000 Verizon Sector B: (2) CSS X7CAP-880-22i-bot j3, (3) B From Leg 3.500 0.0000 220.000 No Ice 29.000 28.000 0.190 2" Sch. 40 x 72" mounting pipes, (2) 1 /2" coax jumpers 0.000 2 1-5/8" Coax 0.000 Verizon Sector C: (2) CSS X7CAP-880-22i-bot j3, (3) C From Leg 3.500 0.0000 220.000 No Ice 29.000 28.000 0.190 2" Sch. 40 x 72" mounting pipes, (2) 1 /2" coax jumpers 0.000 2 1-5/8" Coax 0.000 Verizon Sector A Frame Mount A From Leg 2.500 0.0000 220.000 No Ice 18.000 10.250 0.405 0.000 0.000 Verizon Sector B Frame Mount B From Leg 2.500 0.0000 220.000 No Ice 18.000 10.250 0.405 0.000 0.000 Verizon Sector C Frame Mount C From Leg 2.500 0.0000 220.000 No Ice 18.000 10.250 0.405 0.000 0.000 Nextel Sector A: (3) DB848H90 Panels, (4) 2" Sch.40 x A From Leg 3.500 0.0000 130.000 No Ice 24.500 33.500 0.225 96" mount pipes (#16361B) -2.000 ((3) 7/8" Coax) 0.000 w 3 d jj .r Q Packet Pg. 230 I 8.A.18 I Description Face Offset Offsets: Azimuth Placement CAAA CAAA Weight or Type Horizontal Adjustment Front Side Leg Lateral Vertical ft 0 ft ft, ft, K Nextel Sector B: (3) D138481-190 Panels, (4) 2" Sch.40 x B From Leg 3.500 0.0000 130.000 No Ice 24.500 33.500 0.225 96" mount pipes (#1636113) -2.000 3 7/8" Coax 0.000 Nextel Sector C: (3) D138481-190 Panels, (4) 2" Sch.40 x C From Leg 3.500 0.0000 130.000 No Ice 24.500 33.500 0.225 96" mount pipes (#1636113) -2.000 3 7/8" Coax 0.000 Nextel Sector A Frame Mount A From Leg 1.750 0.0000 130.000 No Ice 18.500 12.500 0.460 0.000 0.000 Nextel Sector B Frame Mount B From Leg 1.750 0.0000 130.000 No Ice 18.500 12.500 0.460 0.000 0.000 Nextel Sector C Frame Mount C From Leg 1.750 0.0000 130.000 No Ice 18.500 12.500 0.460 0.000 0.000 Dishes Description Face Dish Offset Offsets: Azimuth 3 dB Elevation Outside Aperture Weight or Type Type Horizontal Adjustment Beam Diameter Area Leg Lateral Width Vertical ft o o ft ft ft K 6' Grid B Grid From 1.000 20.0000 321.000 6.000 No Ice 28.274 0.130 (1-1/4"Coax) Leg 0.000 0.000 6' Solid Dish A Paraboloid From 1.500 -60.0000 230.000 6.000 No Ice 28.274 0.285 (EW63) w/Radome Leg 0.000 0.000 4' Solid Dish A Paraboloid From 1.000 -60.0000 185.000 4.000 No Ice 12.566 0.170 (EW63) w/Radome Leg 0.000 0.000 6' Solid Dish B Paraboloid From 1.500 30.0000 140.000 6.000 No Ice 28.274 0.285 (EW63) w/Radome Leg 0.000 0.000 T- oo 00 Packet Pg. 231 I 8.A.18 I F2. Transmission Line Design Data Feed Line/Linear Appurtenances Description Face Allow Component Placement Total Number Clear Width or Weight or Shield Type Number Per Row Spacing Diameter Leg ft in in Plf 1 1/4" Coax B No Ar (CaAa) 706.000 - 10.000 2 2 1.550 1.550 0.700 ((2) DB228) 1/2" Coax A No Ar (CaAa) 651.500 - 10.000 1 1 0.600 0.600 0.250 (12' Whip) 7/8" Coax B No Ar (CaAa) 412.000 - 10.000 1 1 1.150 1.150 0.550 B264 7/8" Coax C No Ar (CaAa) 351.000 - 10.000 4 4 1.150 1.150 0.550 4 DB858HV90 1 5/8" Coax A No At (CaAa) 355.000 - 10.000 2 2 2.000 2.000 1.050 4 DB858HV90 1 1/4" Coax A No Ar (CaAa) 321.000 - 10.000 1 1 1.550 1.550 0.700 6' Grid 7/8" Coax A No Ar (CaAa) 324.000 - 10.000 1 1 1.150 1.150 0.550 B436 1 5/8" Coax C No Ar (CaAa) 290.500 - 10.000 2 2 2.000 2.000 1.050 (BCR12) 1 5/8" Coax C No Ar (CaAa) 295.500 - 290.500 1 1 2.000 2.000 1.050 CR12 7/8" Coax C No Ar (CaAa) 295.000 - 10.000 1 1 1.150 1.150 0.550 B812 EW63 C No Ar (CaAa) 230.000 - 10.000 1 1 2.010 2.010 0.510 (6' Solid Dish) 1 5/8" Coax A No Ar (CaAa) 220.000 - 10.000 6 6 1.500 2.000 1.050 (Verizon Array) 2.000 EW63 C No Ar (CaAa) 185.000 - 10.000 1 1 2.010 2.010 0.510 4' Solid Dish EW63 C No Ar (CaAa) 140.000 - 10.000 1 1 2.010 2.010 0.510 6' Solid Dish 7/8" Coax C No Ar (CaAa) 130.000 - 10.000 9 3 2.750 1.150 0.550 (Nextel/S rint DB848H90 Panels) I 1 1.500 Description Face Allow Component Placement Total CAAA Weight or Shield Type Number Leg %t ftIft A( V (nominal) Conduit A No CaAa (In Face) 1016.000 - 10.000 1 No Ice 0.131 2.200 (Lighting) Climbing Ladder B No CaAa In Face 943.188 - 10.000 1 No Ice 0.245 5.400 Safety Line 3/8 B No CaAa In Face 943.188 - 10.000 1 No Ice 0.037 0.220 3 1/8" Rigid A No CaAa (In Face) 932.000 - 10.000 1 No Ice 0.315 2.800 SHPX-8AC 3 1/8" Rigid A No CaAa (Out Of 972.100 - 932.000 1 No Ice 0.315 2.800 (SHPX-8AC) Face) 1 5/8" Coax A No CaAa (In Face) 915.000 - 10.000 1 No Ice 0.200 1.050 RI LP-lE-SP 2 1/4" Coax C No CaAa (In Face) 735.000 - 10.000 1 No Ice 0.240 1.200 (2-Way ASP 2 1/4" Coax A No CaAa (In Face) 675.000 - 10.000 1 No Ice 0.240 1.200 TxRx 101-68-10-X-03N(Location Unknown 7/8" Coax A No CaAa (In Face) 458.000 - 10.000 1 No Ice 0.115 0.550 Celwave PD458 Verizon Tx Line Ladder A No CaAa (In Face) 220.000 - 10.000 1 No Ice 0.680 4.000 erizon Array) Leg Reinforcement Weight C No CaAa In Face 219.500 - 254.500 1 No Ice 0.000 16.410 oo 00 10 Packet Pg. 232 I 8.A.18 I G. ASSESSMENT RESULTS The chart below summarizes the results of ERI's testing models of the structure that were performed to determine the reason for the reported overstresses and compares the results with the output of the EBI analysis report. The leftmost orange -headed column provides the percent of leg capacity utilization percentage calculated by EBI, while the green -headed column provides the leg capacity utilization percentage calculated by ERI when the incorrect gust effect factor (Gh) is used on the cantilevered portion of the tower. The yellow -headed column provides the results calculated by ERI when the correct gust effect factor is used. Comparison of the orange and green -headed columns shows that the leg loads calculated with the incorrect gust effect factor are very similar throughout the entire structure except between 254.5' - 219.5'. This area of the tower has tower legs with welded on reinforcement. EBI did not have any information on the method of reinforcement of these legs so they apparently used their own parameters in the calculations on this section, thus the large difference in utilized leg capacity in this location. Comparing either the orange -headed or green -headed columns with the yellow -headed column on the right illustrate the large differences in leg stresses that result when the incorrect gust effect factor is used. Section No. Section Elevation (feet) EBI Analysis Leg Percent Capacity ERI Analysis Incorrect Gh Leg Percent Ca acit ERI Analysis Correct Gh Leg Percent Ca acit Li 1016 - 996.615 17.9 17.4 14.4 L2 996.615 - 977.229 58.2 58.8 47.4 L3 977.229 - 957.844 53.0 53.4 42.8 L4 957.844 - 943.188 60.9 61.3 48.9 T1 943.188 - 939.5 44.4 44.8 34.9 T2 939.5 - 909.5 90.6 90.9 72.6 T3 909.5 - 894.5 105.4 105.6 82.0 T4 894.5 - 879.5 98.8 98.4 73.3 T5 879.5 - 859.5 117.6 117.4 84.2 T6 859.5 - 849.5 112.2 111.7 76.9 T7 849.5 - 819.5 112.7 112.1 74.9 T8 819.5 - 789.5 104.3 103.7 74.8 T9 789.5 - 774.5 116.0 115.0 87.0 T10 774.5 - 759.5 123.7 122.7 95.3 T11 759.5 - 729.5 117.3 116.2 89.5 T12 729.5 - 699.5 102.7 101.1 97.6 T13 699.5 - 679.5 79.1 77.1 78.3 T14 679.5 - 669.5 80.6 78.5 69.3 T15 669.5 - 664.5 82.3 80.2 65.4 T16 664.5 - 659.5 83.2 80.9 66.9 T17 659.5 - 639.5 90.8 88.3 77.6 T18 639.5 - 629.5 95.8 93.1 84.2 T19 629.5 - 609.5 96.6 93.9 85.3 T20 609.5 - 579.5 77.5 74.6 67.3 T21 579.5 - 549.5 69.6 69.3 67.5 T22 549.5 - 519.5 66.9 65.3 63.8 T23 519.5 - 499.5 84.2 81.4 82.0 T24 499.5 - 489.5 91.8 89.3 90.2 T25 489.5 - 474.5 88.6 85.6 86.6 T26 474.5 - 459.5 82.7 80.9 82.1 T 00 00 r 11 Packet Pg. 233 1 I 8.A.18 I T27 459.5 - 449.5 78.5 77.1 78.5 T28 449.5 - 429.5 79.3 79.0 80.5 T29 429.5 - 409.5 85.5 85.8 87.3 T30 409.5 - 399.5 90.6 91.2 92.8 T31 399.5 - 379.5 86.9 87.9 89.1 T32 379.5 - 369.5 93.9 95.1 96.2 T33 369.5 - 349.5 97.6 99.1 100.1 T34 349.5 - 339.5 83.7 86.1 87.1 T35 339.5 - 329.5 76.8 79.4 80.3 T36 329.5 - 309.5 75.6 73.9 74.7 T37 309.5 - 279.5 75.5 73.1 71.2 T38 279.5 - 264.5 75.8 77.7 77.6 T39 264.5 - 254.5 82.9 84.3 83.9 T40 254.5 - 249.5 75.2 65.9 65.5 T41 249.5 - 239.5 84.1 72.5 71.9 T42 239.5 - 229.5 81.8 70.2 69.5 T43 229.5 - 219.5 72.0 60.9 60.4 T44 219.5 - 194.5 88.7 87.2 86.8 T45 194.5 - 189.5 90.7 89.4 89.0 T46 189.5 - 179.5 94.9 93.7 93.3 T47 179.5 - 159.5 97.7 97.3 96.9 T48 159.5 - 129.5 97.1 97.0 96.6 T49 129.5 - 124.5 85.9 86.9 86.5 T50 124.5 - 119.5 82.6 83.7 83.3 T51 119.5 - 114.5 85.5 87.0 86.6 T52 114.5 - 99.5 95.4 96.1 95.6 T53 99.5 - 79.5 88.8 89.2 88.7 T54 79.5 - 69.5 90.1 90.6 90.3 T55 69.5 - 59.5 89.9 90.7 90.4 T56 59.5 - 39.5 89.1 89.9 89.6 T57 39.5 - 29.5 83.8 83.9 83.6 T58 29.5 - 19.5 79.2 79.2 78.7 T59 19.5 - 11 71.1 68.1 68.2 T60 11 - 0 61.5 58.2 59.9 H. CONCLUSIONS It is our opinion that the EBI analysis utilized the incorrect gust effect factor on the cantilevered portion of the tower, resulting in the overstresses reported in their analysis report. I. SUMMARY ERI has a 75-year history of providing superior products and engineering services to broadcasters. We are pleased to be able to extend the benefits of our experience to your company. Please contact ERI if you have any questions or comments concerning this analysis and report. T- oo ao 12 Packet Pg. 234 8.A.19 it E F C E NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING Notice is hereby given that a public hearing will be held by the Collier County Board of Counf Commissioners on April 27th, 2021, in the Board of County Commissioners MBeting Roon Third Floor, Collier Government Center, 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Naples, FL, to consider th enactment of a County Resolution. The meeting will commence at 9:00 A.M. The title of th proposed Resolution is as follows: , A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA PROVIDING FOR THE ESTABLISHMENT OF A CONDITIONAL USE TO ALLOW A COMMUNICATIONS TOWER ON LANDS ZONED RURAL AGRICULTURAL (A) WITHIN THE MOBILE HOME OVERLAY (MHO) AND DESIGNATED RURAL FRINGE MIXED USE -SENDING LANDS WITHIN THE NATURAL RESOURCE PROTECTION AREA OVERLAY AND NORTH BELLE MEADE OVERLAY IN THE COLLIER COUNTY GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN PURSUANT TO SECTIONS 2.01.03.G.4.a AND 2.03.08.A.4.a(3)(a) OF THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE ON .95t ACRES OF A 5.0+/- ACRE TRACT LOCATED ON THE EAST SIDE OF THE NORTH - SOUTH EXTENSION OF BENTON ROAD, IN SECTION 25, TOWNSHIP 49 SOUTH, RANGE 27 EAST, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA. [PL201800023271 Project Location A copy of the proposed Resolution is on file with the Clerk to the Board and is available for inspection. All interested parties are invited to attend and be heard. NOTE: All persons wishing to speak on any agenda item must register with the County manager prior to presentation of the agenda item to be addressed. Individual speakers will be limited to 3 minutes on any item. The selection of any individual to speak on behalf of an organization or group is encouraged. If recognized by the Chairman, a spokesperson for a group or organization maybe allotted 10 minutes to speak on an item. Persons wishing to have written or graphic materials included in the Board agenda packets must submit said material a minimum of 3 weeks prior to the respective public hearing. In any case, written materials intended to be considered by the Board shall be submitted to the appropriate County staff a minimum of seven days prior to the public hearing. All materials used in presentations before the Board will become a permanent part of the record. 4s part of an ongoing initiative to promote social distancing during the COVID-19 pandemic, the Dublic will have the opportunity to provide public comments remotely, as well as in person, during :his proceeding. Individuals who would like to participate remotely, should register any time after he agenda is posted on the County website which is 6 days before the meeting through the link provided on the front page of the'County website at www.colliercotinWI.gov. Individuals who egister will receive an email in advance of the public hearing detailing how they can participate emotely in this meeting. For additional information about the meeting, please call Geoffrey Willig it 252-8369 or email to Geoffrey.Willig@colliercountdl aov. lny person who decides to appeal any decision of the Board will need a record of the proceedings )ertaining thereto and therefore, may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is nade, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based. you are a person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding, you are entitled, at no cost to you, to the provision of certain assistance: Please contact ne Collier County Facilities. Management Division, located at 3335 Tamiami Trail East, Suite contact 01, laples, FL 34112-5356, (239) 252-8380, at least two days prior to the meeting. Assisted listening evices for the hearing impaired are available in the Board of County Commissioners Office. ;OARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS -OLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA ENNY TAYLOR, CHAIRMAN RYSTAL K. KINZEL, CLERK y: Martha Vergara, Deputy Clerk (SEAL) Z D r 00 r 00 m to Zoo a Z r M Packet Pg. 235 F7iitO - N'WIHIJfti - United States Department of the Interior �"""' FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE South Florida Ecological Services Field Office 1339 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960-3559 Phone: (772) 562-3909 Fax: (772) 562-4288 h1W://fws.,gov/verobeach In Reply Refer To: March 26, 2018 Consultation Code: 04EF2000-2018-SLI-0461 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Subject: List of threatened and endangered species that may occur in your proposed project location, and/or may be affected by your proposed project To Whom It May Concern: The enclosed species list identifies threatened, endangered, proposed and candidate species, as well as proposed and final designated critical habitat, that may occur within the boundary of your proposed project and/or may be affected by your proposed project. The species list fulfills the requirements of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (Service) under section 7(c) of the Endangered Species Act (Act) of 1973, as amended (16 U.S.C. 1531 et seq.). New information based on updated surveys, changes in the abundance and distribution of species, changed habitat conditions, or other factors could change this list. Please feel free to contact us if you need more current information or assistance regarding the potential impacts to federally proposed, listed, and candidate species and federally designated and proposed critical habitat. Please note that under 50 CFR 402.12(e) of the regulations implementing section 7 of the Act, the accuracy of this species list should be verified after 90 days. This verification can be completed formally or informally as desired. The Service recommends that verification be completed by visiting the ECOS-IPaC website at regular intervals during project planning and implementation for updates to species lists and information. An updated list may be requested through the ECOS-IPaC system by completing the same process used to receive the enclosed list. The purpose of the Act is to provide a means whereby threatened and endangered species and the ecosystems upon which they depend may be conserved. Under sections 7(a)(1) and 7(a)(2) of the Act and its implementing regulations (50 CFR 402 et seq.), Federal agencies are required to utilize their authorities to carry out programs for the conservation of threatened and endangered species and to determine whether projects may affect threatened and endangered species and/or designated critical habitat. 03/26/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 2 A Biological Assessment is required for construction projects (or other undertakings having similar physical impacts) that are major Federal actions significantly affecting the quality of the human environment as defined in the National Environmental Policy Act (42 U.S.C. 4332(2) (c)). For projects other than major construction activities, the Service suggests that a biological evaluation similar to a Biological Assessment be prepared to determine whether the project may affect listed or proposed species and/or designated or proposed critical habitat. Recommended contents of a Biological Assessment are described at 50 CFR 402.12. If a Federal agency determines, based on the Biological Assessment or biological evaluation, that listed species and/or designated critical habitat may be affected by the proposed project, the agency is required to consult with the Service pursuant to 50 CFR 402. In addition, the Service recommends that candidate species, proposed species and proposed critical habitat be addressed within the consultation. More information on the regulations and procedures for section 7 consultation, including the role of permit or license applicants, can be found in the 'Endangered Species Consultation Handbook" at: http://www.fws.gov/endangered/esa-library/Pdf/TOC-GLOS.PDF Please be aware that bald and golden eagles are protected under the Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act (16 U.S.C. 668 et seq.), and projects affecting these species may require development of an eagle conservation plan (http://www.fws.gov/windenergy/ eagle_guidance.html). Additionally, wind energy projects should follow the wind energy guidelines (http://www.fws.gov/windenergy/) for minimizing impacts to migratory birds and bats. Guidance for minimizing impacts to migratory birds for projects including communications towers (e.g., cellular, digital television, radio, and emergency broadcast) can be found at: http:// www.fws.gov/migratorybirds/CurrentBirdlssues/Hazards/towers/towers.htm; http:// www.towerkill.com; and http://www.fws.gov/migratorybirds/CurrentBirdIssues/Hazards/towers/ comtow.html. We appreciate your concern for threatened and endangered species. The Service encourages Federal agencies to include conservation of threatened and endangered species into their project planning to further the purposes of the Act. Please include the Consultation Tracking Number in the header of this letter with any request for consultation or correspondence about your project that you submit to our office. Attachment(s): • Official Species List 03/26/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 Official Species List This list is provided pursuant to Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act, and fulfills the requirement for Federal agencies to "request of the Secretary of the Interior information whether any species which is listed or proposed to be listed may be present in the area of a proposed action". This species list is provided by: South Florida Ecological Services Field Office 1339 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960-3559 (772) 562-3909 03/26/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 Project Summary Consultation Code: 04EF2000-2018-SLI-0461 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Project Type: COMMUNICATIONS TOWER Project Description: Construction of a 220' guyed communications tower and all associated equipment within a 3,600-square-foot lease area. A 20' wide access/utility easement extends west away from the lease area to connect with Benton Road. Project Location: Approximate location of the project can be viewed in Google Maps: https: www.google.com/maps/place/26.179267702439347N81.57164340399791 W 6o ryln Counties: Collier, FL 03/26/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 3 Endangered Species Act Species There is a total of 25 threatened, endangered, or candidate species on this species list. Species on this list should be considered in an effects analysis for your project and could include species that exist in another geographic area. For example, certain fish may appear on the species list because a project could affect downstream species. IPaC does not display listed species or critical habitats under the sole jurisdiction of NOAA Fisheriesl, as USFWS does not have the authority to speak on behalf of NOAA and the Department of Commerce. See the "Critical habitats" section below for those critical habitats that lie wholly or partially within your project area under this office's jurisdiction. Please contact the designated FWS office if you have questions. NOAA Fisheries, also known as the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS), is an office of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration within the Department of Commerce. Mammals NAME Florida Bonneted Bat Eumops floridanus No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/8630 Florida Panther Puma (=Felis) concolor coryi No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https:Hecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/1763 Habitat assessment guidelines: https://ecos. fws. gov/ipac/guideline/assessment/population/8/office/41420.pdf Puma (=mountain Lion) Puma (=Felis) concolor (all subsp. except coryi) Population: FL No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws.2_ov/ecp/species/6049 West Indian Manatee Trichechus manatus There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. This species is also protected by the Marine Mammal Protection Act, and may have additional consultation requirements. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/4469 STATUS Endangered Endangered Similarity of Appearance (Threatened) Threatened 03/26/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 Birds NAME STATUS Audubon's Crested Caracara Polyborus plancus audubonii Threatened Population: FL pop. No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8250 Cape Sable Seaside Sparrow Ammodramus maritimus mirabilis Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. ov/ecp/species/6584 Everglade Snail Kite Rostrhamus sociabilis plumbeus Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: https:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/7713 Species survey guidelines: https:Hecos.fws. gov/ipac/guideline/survey//population/1221/office/41420.pdf Florida Grasshopper Sparrow Ammodramus savannarum floridanus Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/32 Florida Scrub jay Aphelocoma coerulescens Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6174 Ivory -billed Woodpecker Campephilus principalis Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: hiips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8230 Kirtland's Warbler Setophaga kirtlandii (= Dendroica kirtlandii) Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8078 Piping Plover Charadrius melodus Threatened Population: [Atlantic Coast and Northern Great Plains populations] - Wherever found, except those areas where listed as endangered. There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6039 Red Knot Calidris canutus rufa Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/1864 Red -cockaded Woodpecker Picoides borealis Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: hiips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/7614 Wood Stork Mycteria americana Threatened 03/26/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 NAME Population: AL, FL, GA, MS, NC, SC No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https:Hecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/8477 Habitat assessment guidelines: https://ecos.fws. gov/ipac/guideline/assessment/population/124/office/41420.pdf Reptiles STATUS NAME STATUS American Alligator Alligator mississippiensis Similarity of No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Appearance Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/776 (Threatened) American Crocodile Crocodylus acutus Threatened Population: U.S.A. (FL) There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6604 Eastern Indigo Snake Drymarchon corais couperi Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/646 Loggerhead Sea Turtle Caretta caretta Threatened Population: Northwest Atlantic Ocean DPS There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. ov/ecp/species/1110 Fishes NAME STATUS Atlantic Sturgeon (gulf Subspecies) Acipenser oxyrinchus (=oxyrhynchus) Threatened desotoi There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/651 5 03/26/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 6 Insects NAME STATUS Bartram's Hairstreak Butterfly Strymon acis bartrami Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/4837 Florida Leafwing Butterfly Anaea troglodyta floridalis Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6652 Miami Blue Butterfly Cyclargus (=Hemiargus) thomasi bethunebakeri Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/3797 Flowering Plants NAML STATUS Florida Prairie -clover Dalea carthagenensis floridana No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/2300 Endangered Garber's Spurge Chamaesyce garberi Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8229 Critical habitats THERE ARE NO CRITICAL HABITATS WITHIN YOUR PROJECT AREA UNDER THIS OFFICE'S JURISDICTION. F7iitO - N'WIHIJfti - United States Department of the Interior �"""' FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE South Florida Ecological Services Field Office 1339 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960-3559 Phone: (772) 562-3909 Fax: (772) 562-4288 h1W://fws.,gov/verobeach In Reply Refer To: August 02, 2018 Consultation Code: 04EF2000-2018-SLI-0461 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Subject: Updated list of threatened and endangered species that may occur in your proposed project location, and/or may be affected by your proposed project To Whom It May Concern: The enclosed species list identifies threatened, endangered, proposed and candidate species, as well as proposed and final designated critical habitat, that may occur within the boundary of your proposed project and/or may be affected by your proposed project. The species list fulfills the requirements of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (Service) under section 7(c) of the Endangered Species Act (Act) of 1973, as amended (16 U.S.C. 1531 et seq.). New information based on updated surveys, changes in the abundance and distribution of species, changed habitat conditions, or other factors could change this list. Please feel free to contact us if you need more current information or assistance regarding the potential impacts to federally proposed, listed, and candidate species and federally designated and proposed critical habitat. Please note that under 50 CFR 402.12(e) of the regulations implementing section 7 of the Act, the accuracy of this species list should be verified after 90 days. This verification can be completed formally or informally as desired. The Service recommends that verification be completed by visiting the ECOS-IPaC website at regular intervals during project planning and implementation for updates to species lists and information. An updated list may be requested through the ECOS-IPaC system by completing the same process used to receive the enclosed list. The purpose of the Act is to provide a means whereby threatened and endangered species and the ecosystems upon which they depend may be conserved. Under sections 7(a)(1) and 7(a)(2) of the Act and its implementing regulations (50 CFR 402 et seq.), Federal agencies are required to utilize their authorities to carry out programs for the conservation of threatened and endangered species and to determine whether projects may affect threatened and endangered species and/or designated critical habitat. 08/02/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 2 A Biological Assessment is required for construction projects (or other undertakings having similar physical impacts) that are major Federal actions significantly affecting the quality of the human environment as defined in the National Environmental Policy Act (42 U.S.C. 4332(2) (c)). For projects other than major construction activities, the Service suggests that a biological evaluation similar to a Biological Assessment be prepared to determine whether the project may affect listed or proposed species and/or designated or proposed critical habitat. Recommended contents of a Biological Assessment are described at 50 CFR 402.12. If a Federal agency determines, based on the Biological Assessment or biological evaluation, that listed species and/or designated critical habitat may be affected by the proposed project, the agency is required to consult with the Service pursuant to 50 CFR 402. In addition, the Service recommends that candidate species, proposed species and proposed critical habitat be addressed within the consultation. More information on the regulations and procedures for section 7 consultation, including the role of permit or license applicants, can be found in the 'Endangered Species Consultation Handbook" at: http://www.fws.gov/endangered/esa-library/Pdf/TOC-GLOS.PDF Please be aware that bald and golden eagles are protected under the Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act (16 U.S.C. 668 et seq.), and projects affecting these species may require development of an eagle conservation plan (http://www.fws.gov/windenergy/ eagle_guidance.html). Additionally, wind energy projects should follow the wind energy guidelines (http://www.fws.gov/windenergy/) for minimizing impacts to migratory birds and bats. Guidance for minimizing impacts to migratory birds for projects including communications towers (e.g., cellular, digital television, radio, and emergency broadcast) can be found at: http:// www.fws.gov/migratorybirds/CurrentBirdlssues/Hazards/towers/towers.htm; http:// www.towerkill.com; and http://www.fws.gov/migratorybirds/CurrentBirdIssues/Hazards/towers/ comtow.html. We appreciate your concern for threatened and endangered species. The Service encourages Federal agencies to include conservation of threatened and endangered species into their project planning to further the purposes of the Act. Please include the Consultation Tracking Number in the header of this letter with any request for consultation or correspondence about your project that you submit to our office. Attachment(s): • Official Species List 08/02/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 Official Species List This list is provided pursuant to Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act, and fulfills the requirement for Federal agencies to "request of the Secretary of the Interior information whether any species which is listed or proposed to be listed may be present in the area of a proposed action". This species list is provided by: South Florida Ecological Services Field Office 1339 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960-3559 (772) 562-3909 08/02/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 Project Summary Consultation Code: 04EF2000-2018-SLI-0461 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Project Type: COMMUNICATIONS TOWER Project Description: Construction of a 220' guyed communications tower and all associated equipment within a 3,600-square-foot lease area. A 20' wide access/utility easement extends west away from the lease area to connect with Benton Road. Project Location: Approximate location of the project can be viewed in Google Maps: https: www.google.com/maps/place/26.179267702439347N81.57164340399791 W 6o ryln Counties: Collier, FL 2 08/02/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 3 Endangered Species Act Species There is a total of 25 threatened, endangered, or candidate species on this species list. Species on this list should be considered in an effects analysis for your project and could include species that exist in another geographic area. For example, certain fish may appear on the species list because a project could affect downstream species. IPaC does not display listed species or critical habitats under the sole jurisdiction of NOAA Fisheriesl, as USFWS does not have the authority to speak on behalf of NOAA and the Department of Commerce. See the "Critical habitats" section below for those critical habitats that lie wholly or partially within your project area under this office's jurisdiction. Please contact the designated FWS office if you have questions. NOAA Fisheries, also known as the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS), is an office of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration within the Department of Commerce. Mammals NAME Florida Bonneted Bat Eumops floridanus No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/8630 Florida Panther Puma (=Felis) concolor coryi No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https:Hecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/1763 Habitat assessment guidelines: https://ecos. fws. gov/ipac/guideline/assessment/population/8/office/41420.pdf Puma (=mountain Lion) Puma (=Felis) concolor (all subsp. except coryi) Population: FL No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws.2_ov/ecp/species/6049 West Indian Manatee Trichechus manatus There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. This species is also protected by the Marine Mammal Protection Act, and may have additional consultation requirements. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/4469 STATUS Endangered Endangered Similarity of Appearance (Threatened) Threatened 08/02/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 Birds NAME STATUS Audubon's Crested Caracara Polyborus plancus audubonii Threatened Population: FL pop. No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8250 Cape Sable Seaside Sparrow Ammodramus maritimus mirabilis Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. ov/ecp/species/6584 Everglade Snail Kite Rostrhamus sociabilis plumbeus Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: https:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/7713 Species survey guidelines: https:Hecos.fws. gov/ipac/guideline/survey//population/1221/office/41420.pdf Florida Grasshopper Sparrow Ammodramus savannarum floridanus Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/32 Florida Scrub jay Aphelocoma coerulescens Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6174 Ivory -billed Woodpecker Campephilus principalis Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: hiips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8230 Kirtland's Warbler Setophaga kirtlandii (= Dendroica kirtlandii) Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8078 Piping Plover Charadrius melodus Threatened Population: [Atlantic Coast and Northern Great Plains populations] - Wherever found, except those areas where listed as endangered. There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6039 Red Knot Calidris canutus rufa Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/1864 Red -cockaded Woodpecker Picoides borealis Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: hiips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/7614 Wood Stork Mycteria americana Threatened 08/02/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 NAME Population: AL, FL, GA, MS, NC, SC No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https:Hecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/8477 Habitat assessment guidelines: https://ecos.fws. gov/ipac/guideline/assessment/population/124/office/41420.pdf Reptiles STATUS NAME STATUS American Alligator Alligator mississippiensis Similarity of No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Appearance Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/776 (Threatened) American Crocodile Crocodylus acutus Threatened Population: U.S.A. (FL) There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6604 Eastern Indigo Snake Drymarchon corais couperi Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/646 Loggerhead Sea Turtle Caretta caretta Threatened Population: Northwest Atlantic Ocean DPS There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. ov/ecp/species/1110 Fishes NAME STATUS Atlantic Sturgeon (gulf Subspecies) Acipenser oxyrinchus (=oxyrhynchus) Threatened desotoi There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/651 5 08/02/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 6 Insects NAME STATUS Bartram's Hairstreak Butterfly Strymon acis bartrami Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/4837 Florida Leafwing Butterfly Anaea troglodyta floridalis Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6652 Miami Blue Butterfly Cyclargus (=Hemiargus) thomasi bethunebakeri Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/3797 Flowering Plants NAML STATUS Florida Prairie -clover Dalea carthagenensis floridana No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/2300 Endangered Garber's Spurge Chamaesyce garberi Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8229 Critical habitats THERE ARE NO CRITICAL HABITATS WITHIN YOUR PROJECT AREA UNDER THIS OFFICE'S JURISDICTION. 4/26/2018 www.fnai.org/FieldGuide/search-002.cfm ---> 49 Matches Found Plant Dicot - Aeschynomene pratensis - meadow joint -vetch Dicot - Indigofera mucronata var keyensis - decumbent indigo Dicot - Jacquemontia pentanthos - skyblue clustervine Dicot - Passiflora pallens - pineland passion -flower Dicot - Peperomia humilis - terrestrial peperomia Dicot - Peperomia obtusifolia - blunt -leaved peperomia Fern (Pteridophytes) - Asplenium serratum -bird's nest spleenwort Fern (Pteridophytes) - Campyloneurum angustifolium - narrow -leaved strap fern Fern (Pteridophytes) - Pecluma ptilodon -swamp plume polypoda fern Fern (Pteridophytes) - Thely_pteris serrata - Monocot - Campylocentrum pachyrrhizum - ribbon orchid Monocot - Catopsis floribunda - many -flowered catopsis Monocot - Cyrtopodium punctatum - cow horn orchid Monocot - Encyclia cochleata var triandra - clamshell orchid Monocot - Epidendrum nocturnum - night -scented orchid Monocot - Guzmania monostachia - Fakahatchee Guzmania Monocot - Maxillaria crassifolia - hidden orchid Monocot - Oncidium floridanum - Florida dancing -lady orchid Monocot - Pleurothallis gelida - frost -flower orchid Monocot - Pteroglossaspis ecristata - giant orchid Monocot - Sacoila lanceolata var paludicola - Fahkahatchee ladies' -tresses Monocot - Spiranthes torta - southern ladies' -tresses Monocot - Tillandsia pruinosa - fuzzy-wuzzy air -plant Vertebrate Bird - Aphelocoma coerulescens - Florida scrub -jay_ Bird - Caracara cheriway - crested caracara Bird - Charadrius alexandrinus - snowy plover Bird - Charadrius melodus - piping_plover Bird - Grus canadensis pratensis - Florida sandhill crane Bird - Haliaeetus leucocephalus - bald eagle Bird - Mycteria americana - wood stork Bird - Picoides borealis - red -cockaded woodpecker Bird - Rostrhamus sociabilis plumbeus - snail kite Bird - Sterna dougallii - roseate tern Bird - Sternula antillarum - least tern Mammal - Eumops glaucinus floridanus - Florida mastiff bat Mammal - Mustela vison mink pop 1 - southern mink (s. Florida pop.). Mammal - Puma concolor coryi - Florida panther Mammal - Sciurus niger avicennia - mangrove fox squirrel Mammal - Trichechus manatus - manatee Mammal - Ursus americanus floridanus - Florida black bear Reptile - Caretta caretta - loggerhead Reptile - Chelonia mydas - green turtle Reptile - Crocodylus acutus - American crocodile Reptile - Dermochelys coriacea - leatherback Reptile - Drymarchon couperi - eastern indigo snake Reptile - Eretmochelys imbricata - hawksbill turtle Reptile - Gopherus poly_phemus - gopher tortoise Reptile - Lepidochelys kempii - Kemp's ridley_ http://www.fnai.org/FieldGuide/search_002.cfm 1 /1 From: Hitt, Heather To: Jackson Reagan Subject: Naples Park North Tower 2018-TA-0461 Date: Friday, May 18, 2018 3:37:46 PM Attachments: 20130812 EIS Standard Protection Measures final.odf Draft Protocol for Florida Bonneted Bat Roost Surveys.PDF 04 E F 2000-2018-TA-0461 Mr. Reagan: This email acknowledges the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service's (Service) April 27, 2018 receipt of your concurrently dated request for information under section 7 of the Endangered Species Act of 1973, as amended (Act) (87 Stat. 884; 16 U.S.C. 1531 et seq.). We have assigned log number 04EF2000-2018-TA-0461 to this request. We understand the proposed Project incorporates the construction of a 220-foot guyed communication tower and associated communication equipment in an undeveloped grass and tree -covered area. Work would include 100-foot by 20-foot wide access/utility easement extending west to Benton Road. The site is located at Benton Road, Naples, Collier County, Florida (26°10'44.98"N, 81034'17.21"W). THREATENED AND ENDANGERED SPECIES The Service has reviewed its Geographic Information System (GIS) database for recorded locations of federally listed threatened and endangered species and critical habitats on or adjacent to the parcel. The GIS database is a compilation of data received from several sources. According to our review, the Project area is located within the consultation area of the federally threatened eastern indigo snake (Drymarchon corgis couperi; indigo snake), federally endangered Florida bonneted bat (Eumops floridanus; FBB), federally endangered Florida panther, and federally threatened wood stork (Mycteria americana). Eastern indigo snake Suitable habitat for the indigo snake consists of a mosaic of habitat types where snakes establish mean home ranges of 46 ac and 184 ac for females and males, respectively. Project activities are expected to have minimal impact on upland habitat resulting in negligible habitat loss. Therefore, the proposed Project is not likely to adversely affect this species. The Service recommends the implementation of the Standard Protection Measures for the Eastern Indigo Snake (attached) to diminish the likelihood of adversely affecting indigo snakes if any are present on site. Florida bonneted bat The FBB uses a variety of habitat types ranging from forested to urban environments for foraging and roosting areas. Project activities are expected to have minimal impact on foraging habitat and a minimal number of palm trees are expected to be removed. Since the Service is not sure on the value of palm frond roosts, the Service is not recommending roost surveys in palm habitat, unless the palm tree contains a cavity. The Service recommends the applicant survey the palm trees to be removed for cavities prior to removal using the Draft Protocol for Florida Bonneted Bat Roost Surveys (attached). Unless a FBB roost is found, the proposed Project is not likely to adversely affect this species. Florida panther The Project area is located within the primary focus area for the Florida panther and suitable habitat is present. However, the actin area is small and is expected to have minimal impact on upland habitat resulting in negligible habitat loss. Therefore, the proposed Project is not likely to adversely affect this species. Wood stork According to our GIS database, the Project area is contained within multiple Core Foraging Areas (CFA), defined as the area within 29.9 kilometer (km) (18.6 miles), of a wood stork colonies. Loss of suitable wetlands within CFAs may reduce foraging opportunities for the wood stork. The Proposed project would not impact suitable foraging habitat; therefore, the proposed Project is not likely to adversely affect this species. Federally listed plant species According to our GIS database, no federally listed plant species are known to occur within the Project area. Therefore, the proposed Project is not likely to affect these species. If modifications are made to the Project, if additional information involving potential effects to listed species becomes available, or if a new species is listed, reinitiation of consultation may be necessary. Thank you for the opportunity to comment and for your cooperation and effort in protecting natural resources of South Florida. If you have any questions, please contact me at 772-469-4267. Sincerely, Heather Hitt Fish and Wildlife Biologist US Fish and Wildlife Service 1339 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 Phone: 772-469-4267 Fax: 772-562-4288 Email: heather hittnfws.gov NOTE: This email correspondence and any attachments to and from this sender is subject to the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) and may be disclosed to third parties. %40 TRI AF ENVIRONMENTAL - ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING Florida Bonneted Bat Roost Survey August 30, 2018 Capital Telecom — Naples Park North FL Capital Telecom # FL114 Benton Road Naples, Florida 34117 Trileaf # 637639 Prepared For: Prepared By: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Trileaf Corporation 820 Morris Turnpike 1051 Winderley Place, Suite 201 Short Hills, New Jersey 07078 Maitland, Florida 32751 Introduction Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC (Capital Telecom) proposes to construct a 220-foot guyed communications tower and associated compound at Benton Road, Naples, Collier County, Florida 34117. The proposed tower will be within a 60-foot by 60-foot (3,600-square-foot) lease area. The project includes an access/utility easement, measuring approximately 20- foot wide, which extends approximately 100 feet west away from the lease area to connect with Benton Road. The proposed tower will be supported by three (3) anchored guy wires that extend approximately 122 feet northwest, east, and southwest from the tower center. The tower, compound, access road, and guywire anchors (tower footprint) are proposed to be located in a Cabbage Palm (Sabal palmetto) dominated, xeric palm flatwoods. As such, the proposed construction will include the removal of several trees, primarily Cabbage Palms. The Florida Bonneted Bat (FBB) (Eumops floridanus) species is a known resident of Collier County, and therefore, the removal of trees within Collier County can potentially impact FBB habitat. According to the Florida Wildlife and Conservation Commission's (FWC) A Species Action Plan for the Florida Bonneted Bat (Eumops floridanus) the state of Florida has had the FBB listed on the Florida Endangered and Threatened Species List since 1992, and in 2013 the U. S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) designated the FBB as a threatened species under the Endangered Species Act of 1973. Therefore, Capital Telecom has contracted Trileaf to survey the tower footprint (5,600-square feet) plus a 50- foot buffer beyond the tower footprint for the presence of FBBs. See Appendix Site Plans and Aerials for a map of the survey area. Site and Surrounding Habitat According to the United States Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) Ecoregion database, the Site is located near the border between the Southwestern Florida Flatwoods and Big Cypress ecoregions of Florida. The Site is currently located within a Cabbage Palm dominated, xeric palm flatwoods. During a site reconnaissance conducted by Trileaf on February 22, 2018, several trees along the access road, and generally throughout the area were identified to be removed. A tree survey was not conducted; however, based on site observations and the provided photographs, the stand consists predominantly of Cabbage Palm trees with an average diameter at breast height (DBH) of 10 inches. The trees are relatively widely spaced, and canopy cover is mostly open in the action area. Ground cover is dominated by various grass species, Saw Palmetto (Serenoa repens), and other low - growing shrub species. The current habitat is not mapped as critical habitat. Methods On August 27, 2018, Trileaf dispatched Mr. Tyler Brown and Mr. Jackson Reagan, qualified biologists, to the proposed tower site to conduct a ground -based survey of the tower footprint for the presence of FBBs. Equipped with binoculars, a cavity peeper camera, and 35-foot telescoping pole, Mr. Brown and Mr. Reagan conducted a Florida Bonneted Bat Roost Survey per the guidelines set forth in the USFWS Draft Protocol for Florida Bonneted Bat Roost Surveys — February 3, 2015 by walking north to south and south to north transects at no more than 30 meters apart searching for roost cavities or crevices and guano. Findings Trileaf found no cavities of a suitable size for FBBs, crevices containing roosting FBBs, or guano droppings in or around the crevices or trees. In addition, Trileaf found no old growth Cabbage Palm palm fronds suitable for FBB roosts. Conclusions Based on the findings of this survey, it is the opinion of Trileaf that the removal of trees (primarily Cabbage Palms) within the tower footprint (including a 50-foot buffer zone) should not impact FBB roosting habitat. Referenced Material Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission A species Action Plan for the Florida Bonneted Bat (Eumops floridanus) http ://myfwc.com/media/2738262/Florida-Bonneted-Bat-Species-Action-Plan-Final- Draft.pdf Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission Draft Protocol for Florida Bonneted Bat Roost Surveys — February 3, 2015 (attached) United States Environmental Protection Agency Ecoregion Database hgps://www.epa.gov/eco-research/ecoregion-download-files-state-re ig on-4 Qualifications Jackson Reagan, Project Scientist Mr. Reagan holds a B.S degree in Biology from the University of Central Florida. His previous work experience includes Phase I Environmental Site Assessments, National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 reviews (NEPA), Environmental Assessments, migratory bird evaluations, and Sand Skink surveys. Tyler Brown, Assistant Project Manager Mr. Brown holds a B.S. degree in Biology from Indiana Wesleyan University. Mr. Brown's work experience includes Migratory Bird Evaluations, Phase I Environmental Site Assessments, Gopher Tortoise surveys, beach nesting turtle surveys, Red -cockaded Woodpecker surveys, Florida Scrub Jay surveys, raptor banding and monitoring, vegetation surveys, shorebird banding and monitoring, shorebird habitat assessments, and shorebird habitat restoration. Caitlin Young, Project Manager Ms. Young holds a B.A. in Environmental Studies and a Minor in French from the University of California at Santa Barbara. Ms. Young has seven (7) years' experience with the investigation and management of environmental due diligence pursuant to EPA All Appropriate Inquiries (AAI) and the American Society of Testing and Materials (ASTM), as well as National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and environmental permitting projects. Ms. Young operates as a corporate point -of -contact for clients over a large geography, specializing in the Midwest and South regions of the United States. Respectfully Submitted, TRILEAF Corporation Jackson Reagan Project Scientist Tyler Brown Assistant Project Manager Caitlin Young Project Manager Site Plans and Aerials p Z n ~ w� p Of a ZdO L133HS NMOHS SY 31Y05 WaL/£O 31v0 SNM 03'`=u MN 'M3ao 0131! M03H0 ar ae Nmvaq 09810 3 'NMO151aa0N cOZ 3Ln5 3nN3Atl 319N3N '1W OOSI W003131 �vildvo :mOJ °'JH0 lane eDHOM33HUGHM W00'6uamwS'MMM SB69-ZSZ-SOZ 4d bbZSE ewege1V'wey6ww�lg anud �a]uap ssaulsng ESL ou dnoi Bui 99U16U I `J 3 MWS .kBAmns N3MOi dNVIMVN IB 3LY0 NOIsV 'ON o Z f y W F p W U g O Y= 4 K Wj Z t(zss kk� O J O O O O j W K= = 2 Z W W d J 2 O Q x ti N �� Z W Z O 0 i a a 4 rc a (Q' i ®B ® U W 0 x x I �X N Q- m O 0 O r a o X O j Y m<moE z= _ o m Q.Er U m E` m° m m + m °oE7.5 T I Emu Pam' I o2"o.mm.B -16 i o m i,o o _= C£mZ }O - pomm MNv cm U' \ W rc eo?O c �mzm Zomtm��v�i9€€,: f N + rib m 6 w 16 Fl ` cd f"rno =I I I I � I I I I � � I I I p I ¢a / . e ,z\ II \ I 'lover I Ic \ F\ �� \ I iI '� i I II \/ I0 I 1 /la 1 1 x /° I 1 -------- — Na, a —OP— — — — — — — —._.__. _ , —Va--�---- F----=P- — — — — — — — — — — amag ian�ao— — -F (AVM-do-iHo1a onend) ______________ 4 N — -------------- V / J O ry Q ir'sw �r 4m Z O W F y y ? d x O U a w Wa a z cZ d.) V) N O U N Z LL W 'F- V / 0 J LU a_ co J Z Regulatory Documentation Draft Protocol for Florida Bonneted Bat Roost Surveys — February 3, 201S The protocols below ca-e drafi guidance. Prior to ally implementation the U.S Fish and lVildlife Serviee should be contacted to ensure proper Ilse of the most recent protocols. Ilrrplernctrtatiorr of outt ofdate protocols tirgl- irmalidctte I•esults. This protocol is designed to be implemented prior to potential impacts from construction or development projects and should be performed by personnel experienced in management and monitoring of bat species. The purpose of this roost survey protocol is to identify potential roosts and determine if they are currently occupied by the Florida bonneted bat. Roosting habitat includes forest and osier areas with large or mature trees or other areas with suitable roost structures. Florida bonneted bats are known to roost in both natural and artificial structures. Natural roosting structure primarily includes mature or large live or dead trees, tree snags, and trees with cavities, hollows, and crevices but may include rock crevices and other structure, as well. Forest is defined as all types (all age classes) including: pine flatwoods, scrubby flatwoods, pine rocklands, royal palm hammocks, mixed or hardwood hammocks, cypress, sand pine scrub, or other forest types. Artificial roost structures include buildings, bridges, and bat houses. Roost usage and dynamics are not well understood. Although the Florida bonneted bat has exhibited high site fidelity, roost switching is also suspected. Roosting habitat may include sites for day and night roosts to support colonies (e.g., harem, maternity, bachelor, and potential seasonal changes). Because of the difficulty in detecting the Florida bonneted bat and other bat species, negative roost survey results will not equate to a determination that the species is absent from the site. Instead, the results of the surveys will provide information that can help guide the consultation process and appropriate conservation measures. SURVEYING NATURAL STRUCTURES (Iive trees, snags, rock crevices) Areas that contain potential natural roosting structures (e.g., hollows, woodpecker cavities, loose 1 exfoliating bark, rock crevices) should be surveyed following similar methodology as transects used for red -cockaded woodpeckers (RCW) (Service 2004). Conduct systematic roost searches' in suitable Florida bonneted bat habitat (see above) using the methodology listed below: Run line transects through roosting habitat, visually inspecting all trees and snags for evidence of cavities. 1 Projects within the RCW consultation area must identify all active RCW cavity trees prior to conducting bat roost surveys. Any biologist conducting visual inspections of RCW cavity trees must have a current USFWS 10(a)(1)(A) permit that authorizes such activities for the RCW. All active RCW cavity trees will be avoided during bat roost surveys. M • Transects must be spaced so that all trees and snags are inspected. • Transect spacing will vary with habitat structure and season from a maximum of 91 re (300 ft) between transects in very open pine stands to 46 in (150 ft) or less in areas with dense midstory. • Transects should be oriented north to south, to optimize cavity detectability. • When cavities, hollows, or other suitable structure are found, record their locations in the field using a Global Positioning System (GPS) unit. • Visually inspect all cavities, hollows, or other suitable structure (except cavities in active RCW trees) using a video camera probe (peeper) and assess the cavity contents. The cam era should be oriented in such a way as to obtain views of both the top and bottom portions of the cavity, • If bats are suspected or if contents cannot be determined, follow methods to Deternzil7e Roost Usage (below) within 2 days of identification/peeping. If the agency or applicant does not wish to conduct acoustic roost surveys, an assumption of presence of Florida bonneted bats can be made. • Record tree species or type of roosting structure, tree diameter and height, cavity height, cavity orientation, and cavity contents. SURVEYING ARTIFICIAL STRUCTURES To assess artificial structures (including barrel tile roofs) for roosting potential: Conduct a visual and auditory inspection for evidence of bats including the following: cavities, crevices, staining at the entrance to a cavity or crevice, guano, or auditory chirping sounds. If roosting structures or evidence of bats are identified during visual surveys, conduct acoustic surveys, following methods to Deterinining Roost Usage with Acoustic Equipment to confine species of bat present. Positive detection of Florida hnnneted bats precludes the need to continuc additional Surveys.` SURVEYING PALM TREES Florida bonneted bats have been found in the shafts of palm fronds (Belwood 1992). Currently, the Service has limited information on how the Florida bonneted bat is using palm frond roosts and whether they are providing only short-tene roosting habitat, which would not be conducive to long-term, colony, or maternity roosting. Until additional information is collected on the Z However, state regulation for removal of bat roosts may apply. F.A.C. chapter 68A— 9.010; and consistent with protective provisions specified in F.A.C. chapter 68A-27 (68A-27.0011 and 68A-27.003) value of palm frond roosts, the Service is not recommending roost surveys for palm habitat, UNLESS the palm tree contains a cavity. In that case, follow the protocol described for natural cavities. SURVEYING OTHER STRUCTURES Other unique roosting opportunities will be handled on a case -by -case basis through coordination with the South Florida Ecological Services Office. DETERMINING ROOST USAGE WITH ACOUSTIC EQUIPMENT Deploy detector/microphones 15 m (49 ft) from the suspected roost with the microphone orientated in the direction of the suspected roost. Potential roost cavities that are < 15 in (49 ft) apart can be simultaneously sampled if microphones can be appropriately placed to capture any vocalizations of bats departing from both locations. Record all bat echolocations for four nights (sunset to sunrise). Follow the equipment and weather parameters identified below. • Observation of the potential roost at sunset, using a human observer with a detector, could also be used to confirm species. • Detection of Florida bonneted bats on any night precludes the need to continue additional surveys at that potential roost site. Equipment Detectors and microphones suitable for use in this survey protocol include: • Full -spectrum and/or zero -crossing detectors. • Directional and omni-directional microphones. • Microphones attached to detectors via a cable permitting that the cable Iength does not exceed manufacturer recommendations. Microphones should be mounted on grounded or metal poles to avoid build-up of electrostatic charges that may interfere with acoustic sampling. Ensure acoustic detectors are functioning properly and conduct tests on microphone sensitivity to factory specifications before and after deployment, at a minimum. It is recommended that tests be conducted throughout the survey period. Weather Conditions At a minimum, nightly weather conditions for survey sites should be checked using the nearest NOAA National Weather Service station and summarized in the survey reports. If any of the following weather conditions exist at a survey site during acoustic sampling, note the time and duration of such conditions, and repeat the acoustic sampling effort on a different night with suitable weather conditions. temperatures fall below 60°F during the night; precipitation, including rain and/or fog, that exceeds 30 minutes or continues intermittently during the night; and sustained wind speeds greater than 9 miles/hour (4 meters/second; 3 on Beaufort scale) during the night. REPORTING REQUIREMENTS Submit survey results to the Service well in advance of clearing and/or construction. Contact the Service immediately upon locating a roost site occupied by Florida bonneted bats. At a minimum., survey results should include the following: aerial maps of area examined, locations of transect lines, survey results (dates and times of surveys, weather conditions, roosting structures identified, equipment verification information, etc.), GPS locations, physical characteristics, and photographs of roosting structures found, copies of all echolocation files with Florida bonneted bat calls specifically tagged, and names and qualifications of surveyors. LITERATURE CITED Belwood, J. J. 1992. Florida mastiff bat Eumops glaucinus. loridmius. Pages 216-223 in S. R. Humphrey, editor. Rare and endangered biota of Florida. Vol. I. Mammals. University Press of Florida, Gainesville. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 2004. Draft Species Conservation Guidelines South Florida Red -cockaded Woodpecker. South Florida Ecological Services Office; Vero Beach, Florida. A Species Action Plan for the Florida Bonneted Bat Eumops floridanus Final Draft November 1, 2013 Q Ralph, ArwQQd' s ram;. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 620 South Meridian Street Tallahassee, FL 32399-1600 Visit us at MyFWC.com FLORIDA BONNETED BAT ACTION PLAN TEAM FLORIDA BONNETED BAT ACTION PLAN TEAM Team Leader: Jennifer Myers, Division of Habitat and Species Conservation Team Members: Jeff Gore, Fish and Wildlife Research Institute Kathleen Smith, Division of Habitat and Species Conservation Acknowledgements: Laura Barrett, Division of Habitat and Species Conservation Claire Sunquist Blunden, Office of Policy and Accountability Brie Ochoa, Division of Habitat and Species Conservation Mary Ann Poole, Office of Conservation Planning Services Melissa Tucker, Division of Habitat and Species Conservation George and Cyndi Marks, Florida Bat Conservancy Cover photograph by Ralph Arwood Recommended citation: Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission. 2013. A species action plan for the Florida bonneted bat. Tallahassee, Florida. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission ii EXECUTIVE SUMMARY EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) created this plan based on the determination of the Biological Review Group that the Florida bonneted bat (Eumops floridanus) should remain listed as Threatened in the State of Florida. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service proposed to list the Florida bonneted bat in 2012, and the listing was accepted in 2013, adding the Florida bonneted bat to the list of Endangered Species under the Endangered Species Act of 1973. Critical habitat was not designated with the listing, but is expected to be proposed by 2014. The goal of this plan is to improve the conservation status of the Florida bonneted bat so the species is secure within its historical range. The objective of the plan is to initiate research to fill data gaps in current knowledge of the Florida bonneted bat. Since the range of the Florida bonneted bat is limited to southern Florida, some factors related to extent of occurrence or area of occupancy may always meet the listing criteria. The primary actions of this plan focus on collecting information to inform management and collaborating with other entities conducting research on Florida bonneted bats. Because little is known about this species, achieving the objective and completing the actions will require substantial research and monitoring efforts by FWC and other entities on both public and private lands. This plan details the actions necessary to improve the conservation status of the Florida bonneted bat. A summary of this plan will be included in the Imperiled Species Management Plan (ISMP), in satisfaction of the management plan requirements in Chapter 68A-27, Florida Administrative Code, Rules Relating to Endangered or Threatened Species. The ISMP will address comprehensive management needs for 60 of Florida's imperiled species and will include an implementation plan; rule recommendations; permitting standards and exempt activities; anticipated economic, ecological, and social impacts; projected costs of implementation and identification of funding sources; and a revision schedule. The imperiled species management planning process relies heavily on stakeholder input and partner support. This level of involvement and support is also critical to the successful implementation of the ISMP. Any significant changes to this plan will be made with the continued involvement of stakeholders. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission iii TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS FLORIDA BONNETED BAT ACTION PLAN TEAM................................................................ ii EXECUTIVE SUMMARY........................................................................................................... iii LISTOF TABLES.......................................................................................................................... v LISTOF FIGURES....................................................................................................................... vi GLOSSARY OF TERMS AND ACRONYMS............................................................................ vii INTRODUCTION.......................................................................................................................... 1 BiologicalBackground................................................................................................................ 1 ConservationHistory................................................................................................................... 5 Threats and Recommended Listing Status.................................................................................. 6 CONSERVATION GOALS AND OBJECTIVES......................................................................... 8 CONSERVATIONACTIONS....................................................................................................... 9 Habitat Conservation and Management...................................................................................... 9 PopulationManagement............................................................................................................ 13 Monitoringand Research.......................................................................................................... 14 Ruleand Permitting Intent........................................................................................................ 18 LawEnforcement...................................................................................................................... 21 Incentivesand Influencing........................................................................................................ 21 Educationand Outreach............................................................................................................ 22 Coordination with Other Entities.............................................................................................. 23 LITERATURE CITED................................................................................................................. 27 APPENDICES.............................................................................................................................. 30 Appendix 1. Instructions for building a single -chambered bat house ....................................... 30 Appendix 2. Instructions for building a triple -chambered bat house ........................................ 31 Appendix 3. FWC bat house occupancy assessment protocol .................................................. 33 Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission iv LIST OF TABLES LIST OF TABLES Table 1. Conservation Action Table............................................................................................. 24 Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission v LIST OF FIGURES LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1. Florida bonneted bat house at Fred C. Babcock/Cecil M. Webb Wildlife Management Area................................................................................................................................................. 1 Figure 2. Facial features that distinguish the Florida bonneted bat (top) from the Brazilian free - tailedbat (bottom)........................................................................................................................... 3 Figure 3. Florida bonneted bat and Brazilian free -tailed bat, illustrating the size difference betweenthe species......................................................................................................................... 4 Figure 4. Suspected range (extent of occurrence) of the Florida bonneted bat. The species likely occupies only a portion of the delineated range.............................................................................. 4 Figure 5. Projected increase in area of developed land in Florida ................................................ 12 Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission vi GLOSSARY OF TERMS AND ACRONYMS GLOSSARY OF TERMS AND ACRONYMS Acoustic surveys: Monitoring technique that uses specialized equipment and software to detect the presence of bats based upon their echolocation calls. Area of Occupancy: The area within its extent of occurrence (see Extent of Occurrence), which is occupied by a taxon, excluding cases of vagrancy. This reflects the fact that a taxon will not usually occur throughout the area of its extent of occurrence, which may contain unsuitable or unoccupied habitats (as defined by International Union for Conservation of Nature [IUCN]). BRG: Biological Review Group, a group of taxa experts convened to assess the biological status of taxa using criteria specified in Rule 68A-27.001, Florida Administrative Code, and following the protocols in the Guidelines for Application of the IUCN Red List Criteria at Regional Levels (Version 3.0) and Guidelines for Using the IUCN Red List Categories and Criteria (Version 8.1). BSR: Biological status review report, the summary of the biological review group's findings. Includes a Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) staff recommendation on whether or not the species status meets the listing criteria in Rule 68A-27.001, Florida Administrative Code. These criteria, based on IUCN criteria and IUCN guidelines, are used to help decide if a species should be added or removed from the Florida Endangered and Threatened Species List. In addition, FWC staff may provide within the report a biologically justified opinion that differs from the criteria -based finding. BWWMA: Fred C. Babcock/Cecil M. Webb Wildlife Management Area DOACS: Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services ESA: Endangered Species Act of 1973 Exclusion: Legally required method for removing unwanted bats from a structure. Exclusion involves the use of a 1-way device that allows the bats to leave the structure but prevents them from returning. Holes are sealed after the bats are gone and the device is removed. Exclusions are prohibited between 15 April and 15 August because that is when young are likely to be present and remain in the roost while adults forage for food. Extent of Occurrence: The geographic area encompassing all observations of individuals of a species, including intervening areas of unoccupied habitat. Synonymous with range. See also Area of Occupancy (as defined by IUCN). F.A.C.: Florida Administrative Code, the Department of State's Administrative Code, Register and Laws Section is the filing point for rules promulgated by state regulatory agencies. Agency rulemaking is governed by Rule 120, Florida Statutes, the Administrative Procedures Act. Rules are published in the Florida Administrative Code. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission vii GLOSSARY OF TERMS AND ACRONYMS FBC: The Florida Bat Conservancy, a private, non-profit organization established to protect and preserve Florida's bats through education, conservation projects, consultation and bat rescue. Forage: To search for, acquire, and ingest food. F.S.: Florida Statutes Fragmentation: A process of environmental change, commonly caused by human -related land conversion, where once -connected habitats become divided into separate fragments. FWC: The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, the state agency constitutionally mandated to protect and manage Florida's native fish and wildlife resources. Habitat: The area used for any part of the life cycle of a species (including foraging, breeding, and sheltering). Hibernation: A state of inactivity and metabolic depression to conserve energy during periods when food is unavailable. Incidental Take: Incidental Take (as defined in Rule 68A-27.001(5), F.A.C.): Any taking otherwise prohibited, if such taking is incidental to, and not the purpose of the carrying out of an otherwise lawful activity. ISMP: Imperiled Species Management Plan IUCN: International Union for Conservation of Nature, a professional global conservation network. IUCN Red List: (IUCN Red List of Threatened Species) An objective, global approach for evaluating the conservation status of plant and animal species, the goals of which are to: Identify and document those species most in need of conservation attention if global extinction rates are to be reduced; and provide a global index of the state of change of biodiversity. NWCO: Nuisance Wildlife Control Operators, individuals licensed by the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services to address nuisance wildlife concerns according to state rules and regulations. PIT Tags: Passive Integrated Transponders, small devices inserted under the skin with a unique identification number that can be read using an external scanning device. Polyestrous: Having more than 1 season each year in which reproduction can occur. Roost: Artificial or natural structure used by bats for shelter. Roosts can be temporary or permanent. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission viii GLOSSARY OF TERMS AND ACRONYMS Scientific Collection Permit: A permit issued for activities that include salvage, voucher, bird banding, wildlife possession, or special purpose. Applications must demonstrate a scientific or educational benefit for the species, and must identify the purpose, scope, objective, methodology, location, and duration of the project. SWG: State Wildlife Grant Take: As defined in Chapter 68A-27.001(4), F.A.C. "To harass, harm, pursue, hunt, shoot, wound, kill, trap, capture, or collect, or to attempt to engage in such conduct." Torpor: A state of decreased physiological activity in an animal, usually by a reduced metabolism, heart rate, respiration, and body temperature. USFWS: United States Fish and Wildlife Service, the federal agency mandated to protect and manage the nation's native wildlife and freshwater fish resources. WMA: Wildlife Management Area Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission ix INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION Biological Background The Florida bonneted bat (Eumops floridanus) is found only in Florida and is the largest bat in the state (Timm and Genoways 2004, McDonough et al. 2008). Wagner's bonneted, or mastiff, bat (E. glaucinus) is a closely related, but more widespread species found in Central and South America. Until recently, bonneted bats in Florida were considered to be a subspecies of E. glaucinus and known as E. g. floridanus. E. floridanus is distinguished from E. glaucinus by having a significantly larger body size as well as unique morphological features of the face, mouth, and ears (Timm and Genoways 2004). Other common names for the Florida bonneted bat have included Florida mastiff bat, mastiff bat, and Wagner's mastiff bat (Belwood 1981, 1992; United States Fish and Wildlife Service [USFWS] 2012). Life History Relatively little is known about the life history, behavior, and biology of the Florida bonneted bat. Individuals are seldom encountered and most historical and current information is based on collected specimens, a small number of observations of roosting, bats and rangewide acoustic surveys that detect the Figure 1. Florida bonneted bat house at Fred C. Babcock/Cecil M. Webb Wildlife Management Area. Photograph by Jennifer Myers, FWC. presence of bats based upon their echolocation calls. Florida bonneted bats have a distinctive echolocation call that is a lower frequency that other bat species in Florida (Marks and Marks 2012). Bats roost in a variety of structures, both natural and artificial. Tree cavities, caves, rock crevices, and foliage are examples of natural roosts. Buildings, bridges, and bat houses constructed specifically to attract roosting bats are examples of artificial roosts (Kunz and Lumsden 2003). Roosts provide bats with a resting place protected from predators and the elements (Marks and Marks 2006). Roosts also provide shelter for bats to socialize, mate, and rear their young (Kunz and Lumsden 2003). Bats may occupy a roost for only a short period of time, or they may establish a permanent colony within a roost (Marks and Marks 2006). While habitat associations and natural roost site preferences of Florida bonneted bats are poorly understood, Florida bonneted bats have been documented in several roost types. In 1979, a colony of 7 females and 1 male were found roosting in an enlarged red -cockaded woodpecker (Picoides borealis) cavity in a longleaf pine (Pinus palustris) near Punta Gorda (Belwood 1981). Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission INTRODUCTION Florida bonneted bats have been found in the shafts of palm fronds in Coral Gables, as well as under Spanish -style barrel tiles on roofs in Coral Gables and Miami. A roosting colony was found in a in fissures in a limestone outcropping in Coral Gables (Belwood 1992, Timm and Genoways 2004, USFWS 2012). Detailed information on documented or suspected roosts is provided in the Habitat, Use of Forests and Other Natural Areas, Use of Parks, Residential, and Other Urban Areas sections of the Proposed Endangered Species Status for the Florida Bonneted Bat (USFWS 2012). The only current known Florida bonneted bat roosts are in bat houses located on Fred C. Babcock/Cecil M. Webb Wildlife Management Area (BWWMA) (Figure 1) and in bat houses at a private residence in North Fort Myers (USFWS 2012). Florida bonneted bats are consistently present in 1 bat house on BWWMA and the houses at the private residence. Use of the remaining bat houses on BWWMA fluctuates throughout the year (J. Myers, Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission [FWC], personal communication). Florida bonneted bats do not hibernate or typically experience periods of torpor. They are active year-round, as are most bats in Florida, although during extended cold weather events, many bats, including bonneted bats, will become torpid (Marks and Marks 2006, USFWS 2012). Florida bonneted bats feed strictly on insects and they use echolocation to detect and capture their prey year-round. They forage in flight and at night, typically returning to the roost periodically during the night (Marks and Marks 2008a). Fecal droppings from the roost in a longleaf pine tree in Punta Gorda primarily contained flying insects from orders Coleoptera, Diptera, and Hemiptera (Belwood 1981, 1992). Florida bonneted bats are fast flyers and have been observed flying at heights of 10 in (33 ft) or more over open areas (Marks and Marks 2008a). Females give birth to a single pup, and pregnant females and pups have been documented from June through September. Unlike most bats in Florida, Florida bonneted bats may be polyestrous (i.e., they have more than 1 period in which they may reproduce) with the first breeding season occurring June through July and a second occurring later in the year (Marks and Marks 2006, 2008a; Timm and Genoways 2004). Mating behaviors, gestation period, age at weaning, and other reproductive behaviors are poorly understood. Description The Florida bonneted bat is the largest bat species in Florida. Total length for adults typically ranges from 126 to 165 min (4.96 to 6.5 in), forearm length ranges between 61 and 66 mm (2.4 to 2.6 in), and body weight ranges from 30 to 47 grams (1.1 to 1.7 oz) with a pregnant female documented weighing 55 g (2 oz) (Belwood 1981, 1992; Timm and Genoways 2004, Marks and Marks 2006). Fur color varies from dark gray to brown on the dorsal (back) side of the bat, with lighter, grayish fur underneath. Individual hairs are bicolored and lighter at the base. Ears are large and broad and slant forward over the eyes, and, unlike in some similar species found in Florida, the bases of the ears are joined at the midline of the head (Marks and Marks 2006; Figure 2). Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 2 INTRODUCTION 1 Upper lip not wrinkled : 6 Ear edge thin and W not far over eye • k. Upper lip wrinkled Ears join at base Aral g 1_1 Ear edge thick and extends over eye A A Florida Bonneted Bat Ears separate at base Brazilian Free -tailed Bat Figure 2. Facial features that distinguish the Florida bonneted bat (top) from the Brazilian free - tailed bat (bottom). Photographs by Kathleen Smith, FWC. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 3 INTRODUCTION The Florida bonneted bat is among a family of bats often known as free - tailed bats because, unlike most bats, their tails extend well free of the tail membrane that stretches between their legs. Two other free -tailed bats occur in Florida, the Brazilian free -tailed bat (Tadarida brasiliensis) and Pallas' mastiff bat (Molossus molossus), but Florida bonneted bats are much larger than the other free -tailed bats in Florida (Marks and Marks 2006). Figure 3 illustrates the relative difference in size between an adult [70florida bonneted bat 'at Brazilian free -tailed bat Florida bonneted bat and an adult Figure 3. Florida bonneted bat and Brazilian free - Brazilian free -tailed bat. The Florida tailed bat, illustrating the size difference between the bonneted bat is easily distinguished species. Photograph by Chris Burney, FWC. from any other species in Florida by its free tail, large size, and ears that join at the base. Geographic Range and Distribution A survey conducted by the Florida Bat Conservancy (FBC) in 2006 and 2007 estimated the Florida bonneted bat range (FiFiVre 4). A follow-up FBC survey in 2011 and 2012 focused on the Figure 4. Suspected range (extent of occurrence) of the Florida bonneted bat. The species likely occupies only a portion of the delineated range. Source: Marks and Marks 2012. northern and southern extents of the range, but did not result in a significant change to the range map (Marks and Marks 2012, USFWS 2012). The current range includes Charlotte, Collier, Lee, Miami -Dade, and Monroe counties (Timm and Genoways 2004, Marks and Marks 2012). The area occupied within these counties is unknown, but likely is much smaller than the total area encompassed by county boundaries (Marks and Marks 2012, USFWS 2012). Fossil remains suggest the range historically included Brevard, Broward, and Indian River counties (Belwood 1992, Timm and Genoways 2004, USFWS 2012), in addition to the previously listed counties included in the current range. Acoustic surveys documented Florida bonneted bat calls at 2 locations along the Kissimmee River in Polk and Okeechobee counties in 2008 (Marks and Marks 2008b). The occurrence of the species in these counties remains uncertain (Marks and Marks 2012); however, subsequent surveys through 2013 have recorded them intermittently. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 4 INTRODUCTION Conservation History In 1992, the Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission (predecessor to the FWC) listed the Florida mastiff bat (since re-classified as the Florida bonneted bat; see Biological Background) as Endangered. In 2010, the FWC adopted a revised listing classification that combined the Endangered and Threatened categories into a single Threatened status. As a result of the Biological Review Group (BRG) status review and the revised listing classification, the Florida bonneted bat became a Threatened species on the Florida Endangered and Threatened Species List. The change to Threatened status represents a change in the classification system, and not a change in the conservation status for the species. In 1985, the USFWS included the Florida mastiff bat as a category 2 candidate species, since listing might be warranted, but data were limited. Subsequent reviews continued to consider the species as a candidate, but it was removed from the candidate list in 1996 because the taxon was considered a subspecies of E. glaucinus, was deemed more abundant than previously known, and was not in danger of identifiable threats (USFWS 2012). In 2009, after the taxonomy was reevaluated and E.g. floridanus was elevated to E. floridanus, the USFWS recognized the Florida bonneted bat as a federal candidate species in its annual Candidate Notice or Review with a Listing Priority Number of 2 (threats high in magnitude and imminent). At that time federal listing was warranted but was precluded by other higher priority listing actions. In October 2012, the USFWS proposed to list the Florida bonneted bat as a federally Endangered species under the Endangered Species Act of 1973 (ESA); this listing was accepting in 2013, extending the ESA's protections to this species (USFWS 2012). The FWC species -ranking database gave a score of 33.3 to the Florida bonneted bat (scores based on Millsap et al. 1990). A species ranking above 27 is considered potentially at risk of extinction and warrants biological status review (Rule 68A-27.0012(2)(c) I a, Florida Administrative Code [F.A.C.]). In addition, the Florida Committee on Rare and Endangered Plants and Animals included the Florida bonneted bat in the 1978 and 1992 editions of Rare and Endangered Biota of Florida (Belwood 1992). The Florida's Natural Area Inventory considers the Florida bonneted bat to have a global status of G1 (critically imperiled), due to habitat loss and restricted range (Florida Natural Areas Inventory 2012). Florida's State Wildlife Action Plan recognizes the Florida bonneted bat as a Species of Greatest Conservation Need (FWC 2011), and the International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN) currently lists the Florida bonneted bat as Critically Endangered due to small population size, very small subpopulations, and apparent continuing population decline (Timm and Arroyo-Cabrales 2008). Land acquisition specifically to protect Florida bonneted bats has not been initiated. Florida bonneted bat roosting and foraging habitat requirements are poorly understood, making it difficult to assess the amount or type of habitat that should be protected, or if currently protected lands are those most valuable for Florida bonneted bat conservation. The USFWS is expected to designate critical habitat for this species in 2014. During the FBC's 2006 through 2007 rangewide surveys, Florida bonneted bats were documented near BWWMA. In response, FWC contracted with FBC to conduct surveys on BWWMA and installed bat houses in 2007 and 2008. Surveys were conducted over 3 nights and included recording bat calls while driving slowly across the wildlife management area (WMA), Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission INTRODUCTION as well as stationary recording sites. Florida bonneted bat calls were recorded at 3 sites on BWWMA during these surveys (Marks and Marks 2008c). FWC staff at BWWMA installed 15 bat houses, comprising 8 roosts, on the WMA. Each roost consists of 1 to 2 bat houses mounted on a utility pole (Figure 1). To date, 5 roosts have been occupied by Florida bonneted bats. In 2012, FWC staff installed 5 additional roosts near existing roosts to provide additional habitat for Florida bonneted bats. The new roosts are not yet occupied. Monitoring of these bat houses is ongoing (J. Myers, personal communication). The longest -monitored colony of Florida bonneted bats is located on private property in Lee County. In the backyard of a private residence, the homeowner has 3 bat houses that are used by Florida bonneted bats. This is an example of cooperative efforts between a private landowner, conservation group, and wildlife agency. In 2012, the Florida Bonneted Bat Working Group was formed to address the conservation needs of this species across its range. Members include the FWC, USFWS, National Park Service, Zoo Miami, FBC, and several other private and public entities. Many members are also stakeholders referenced in this plan. Members of this working group are involved in conservation activities such as acoustical surveys, bat house monitoring, species education and outreach activities, as well as ongoing research projects. Threats and Recommended Listing Status In 2010, the FWC directed staff to evaluate the status of all species listed as Threatened or Species of Special Concern that had not undergone a status review in the past decade. To address this charge, staff conducted a literature review and solicited information from the public on the status of the Florida bonneted bat. The FWC convened a BRG of experts on the Florida bonneted bat to assess the biological status of the species using criteria specified in Rule 68A-27.001, F.A.C., following the protocols in the Guidelines for Application of the IUCN Red List Criteria at Regional Levels (Version 3.0) and Guidelines for Using the IUCN Red List Categories and Criteria (Version 8.1). FWC staff developed an initial draft of a Biological Status Review (BSR) report, which included the BRG's findings and a preliminary listing recommendation from staff. FWC distributed the draft for peer review, and the reviewers' input was incorporated into a final report. Threats The BRG identified the following threats to the Florida bonneted bat: 1) small population size and restricted extent of occurrence, which increases vulnerability; 2) continued loss of forested habitat; 3) potential limited roost availability; and 4) pesticides from mosquito -control operations. Additional threats identified by the BRG include low fecundity (females produce only 1 pup per year), human disturbance (persecution and removal of roosting bats in trees, buildings, or other manmade structures), prolonged or repeated episodes of cold temperature, disease, and wind farms. Recommended Listing Status The Florida bonneted bat BRG concluded from the biological assessment that the Florida bonneted bat met criteria necessary to warrant its continued listing as Threatened on the Florida Endangered and Threatened Species List. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 6 INTRODUCTION The Florida bonneted bat met the following criteria for listing: • Criterion B, Geographic Range: the extent of occurrence <20,000 km' (7,722 mil) and the population may exist in fewer than 10 locations; a continuing decline is inferred in the extent of occurrence, as well as area, extent, or quality of habitat; • Criterion D, Population Very Small or Restricted: the current population size in Florida is estimated to be fewer than 1,000 mature individuals and the population has a very restricted area of occupancy and number of locations. Other threats include stochastic events such as hurricanes, which may destroy old trees with roosting cavities (Timm and Genoways 2004, NatureServe 2010). For more information on potential threats, including climate change and disease, see the Summary of Factors Affecting the Species section of USFWS (2012). Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 7 CONSERVATION GOALS AND OBJECTIVES CONSERVATION GOALS AND OBJECTIVES The BRG found that the Florida bonneted bat met the criteria for listing as a Threatened species on the Florida Endangered and Threatened Species List. As such, the conservation goal and objective for the Florida bonneted bat are: Goal Conservation status of the Florida bonneted bat is improved such to a point that the species is secure within its historical range. Objective Initiate research to fill data gaps in current knowledge of the Florida bonneted bat and use existing information and results to promote Florida bonneted bat conservation. Rationale Many aspects of Florida bonneted bat ecology are unknown or poorly understood. The BRG identified several threats to the species, but the extent to which these threats impact Florida bonneted bats is not well understood given the lack of scientific information available for this species. The objective of this plan is to identify opportunities to fill in the gaps of what is known about Florida bonneted bats. Effective conservation of the Florida bonneted bat will depend on the support and involvement of partners and stakeholders. Developing conservation recommendations for land management or permitting guidance without a good understanding of the biology of the Florida bonneted bat is not likely to improve the status of the species, and may limit future involvement of partners. Data gathered as a result of actions outlined in this plan will be used to develop and implement conservation strategies to improve the status of the species. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission CONSERVATION ACTIONS CONSERVATION ACTIONS The following sections describe the conservation actions that will make the greatest contribution toward achieving the conservation objectives. Actions are grouped by category (e.g., Habitat Conservation and Management, Population Management). The Conservation Action Table (Table 1) identifies action priority, urgency, potential funding sources, likely effectiveness, identified partners and leads for implementation. The conservation actions are intended to conserve and expand the existing population and increase what is known about the species' range, distribution, habitat requirements, and population size. Several actions also attempt to better our understanding of Florida bonneted bat life history and ecology in order to improve conservation of the species. Completing these actions will allow us to measure progress toward the conservation goal and objective for the Florida bonneted bat. Habitat Conservation and Management General habitat management recommendations for bats include maintaining and protecting open freshwater and wetland habitat as foraging habitat (Marks and Marks 2008c). Habitat management recommendations specific to Florida bonneted bats are not currently available. Action 3 identifies the need to determine the habitat requirements of Florida bonneted bats in order to address impacts of landscape -scale changes across their range. Action 8 describes research to identify Florida bonneted bat habitat types, and Action 9 describes the need to identify what types of roosts are available, and how they are used by Florida bonneted bats. Species -specific habitat management recommendations should be developed based on the outcome of these research actions. Florida bonneted bats are known to roost in both natural and artificial structures, including tree cavities, rock outcroppings, buildings, and bat houses (see Life History) (Marks and Marks 2008a), though the only currently known roosts are in bat houses. Florida bonneted bats have been documented in urban, rural, and native landscapes. Both natural and artificial roosts could be impacted by land -management activities and stochastic events, as well as human presence and the loss of habitat due to development. Colony -roosting species like the Florida bonneted bat roost in relatively permanent and uncommon roosts (i.e., tree cavities and bat houses). They typically remain faithful to their roosts and are unlikely to switch to new roosts (Humphrey 1975, Lewis 1995). If Florida bonneted bats depend on relatively few roosts as suspected, and given their small population size and the uncertainty about availability of suitable roosts, they may well have difficulty finding and occupying new roosts. Therefore, protecting existing roosts is very important to conserving the species. The following section identifies potential threats to roosts and provides recommendations for roost protection. Roost Threats The potential impact of land -management activities such as timber management and prescribed fire on roosts is poorly understood. Timber -management activities (i.e., thinning and removal of old or live trees with cavities) may benefit bats by reducing clutter and increasing the sustainability of pine stands for foraging and commuting (Loeb and Waldrop 2008) or increasing the basal diameter of surrounding trees. However, thinning may also reduce the number of roosts available to bats. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 9 CONSERVATION ACTIONS Presumably, many bat species in the southeastern United States have evolved in ecosystems dominated by fire, and their roosting strategies may limit their vulnerability to fire (Carter et al. 2000). The effects of fire on bats can depend on a variety of characteristics such as seasonality of the burn, fire intensity, residence time (the length of time it takes flame to move over the ground), and overstory mortality (Carter et al. 2000). Fire can create snags, which can eventually become suitable for use by tree -roosting bats (Carter et al. 2000). Fire during the season when most vegetation is dormant may impact the survival of tree- or foliage -roosting bats during colder temperatures and during periods of torpor for certain species, including the Florida bonneted bat. Growing -season burns may impact the survival of non-volant (flightless) young (Carter et al. 2000). Florida bonneted bats may be polyestrous (Marks and Marks 2008a), and flightless young could be affected by fire during either the dormant or growing season. Regardless of fire season, smoke and heat from fire could impact the microclimate of the bat box. On BWWMA, prescribed burning is conducted near Florida bonneted bat houses on a 2- year rotation, on average, with no observed negative effects (J. Birchfield, FWC, personal communication); however, this determination is based on observations, not on systematic assessment. To our knowledge, no research on the Florida bonneted bat's response to prescribed fire exists, though other species' responses have been studied. Studies showed that prescribed burning may initially reduce insect availability (Lacki et al. 2009) but may increase long-term prey availability (Dickinson et al. 2009). Additionally, fire was shown to reduce canopy clutter (Boyles and Aubrey 2006, Dickinson et al. 2009) and create or restore available roost trees or snags (Boyles and Aubrey 2006, Dickinson et al. 2009, Lacki et al. 2009). Any information gained from future research on fire effects to natural and artificial roosts of the Florida bonneted bat (Action 9) should be incorporated into roost protection guidelines. Urban development can also impact Florida bonneted bat roosts. This species has been suspected of roosting in man-made structures such as the shingles of Spanish -style barrel tile roofs in Miami and Coral Gables (Belwood 1992), attics, fireplaces, and brick chimneys (NatureServe 2010). Florida bonneted bats may be killed or injured when dwellings are demolished (Robson 1989) or when they take up residence in structures where they are not wanted. Pest control companies unaware of or non -compliant with the regulations (Rule 68A-9.010, F.A.C.) that apply to bats have been known to remove them through methods other than legal exclusions (see Rule and PermittingIntent, information on Florida Administrative Code number Rule 68A- 4.001. F.A.C., General Prohibitions, and Rule 68A-9.010, F.A.C., Taking Nuisance Wildlife, and Roost -Protection Guidelines). Across the southern United States, bats roost in an estimated 3,600 highway structures such as bridges and overpasses (Keeley and Tuttle 1999). Repair and maintenance of these structures can be detrimental to roosting bats, as can road construction such as road -widening projects. Other Eumops species (i.e., E. underwoodi and E. perotis) are not known to roost in bridges or overpasses (Keeley and Tuttle 1999). Florida bonneted bats have not been documented roosting in highway structures, though their presence has been documented near bridges and overpasses that could be suitable roost sites (Keeley and Tuttle 1999, USFWS 2012; C. Marks, FBC, personal communication) and their potential use of highway structures cannot be ruled out given the few documented occurrences of the species across its range. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 10 CONSERVATION ACTIONS Action 1 Develop recommendations for protecting the roosts of Florida bonneted bats. Although more research should be conducted to determine which specific land -management activities can create or preserve Florida bonneted bat roosts (Action 9), the following list of recommendations should be incorporated into land management and nuisance bat technical assistance (Action 1). This list should be revisited as results of research become available. Roost -Protection Guidelines: Old trees and snags with hollows and cavities should be retained in natural areas such as Everglades National Park, Big Cypress National Preserve, Fakahatchee Strand Preserve State Park, and BWWMA (Belwood 1992). If dead or old trees must be felled, they should be examined for bat roosts and occupation by other imperiled species prior to felling (Marks and Marks 2008b), especially since no locations of natural Florida bonneted bat roost sites or roost selection preferences are currently known. If bats are found, managers are encouraged to consult with the FWC to accurately identify the species and discuss an appropriate course of action. Nuisance wildlife control operators (NWCOs), biologists, and law enforcement personnel within the range of the Florida bonneted bat should be informed that the breeding season of the Florida bonneted bat is uncertain, and that the bats may have young in the roost outside of the typical maternity season. Until more information on the breeding season is obtained and the exclusion rule modified (Actions 15 and 16), we recommend consultation with FWC before excluding Florida bonneted bats from a roost at any time of the year. Increase public land acquisition within the range of the Florida bonneted bat. Land acquisition can assist with protecting roosts, breeding, and foraging areas. Publically managed lands allow for more oversight of land management activities through the required development of state -approved management plans and provide general protections from development. Increase conservation easements and other voluntary conservation efforts on private lands. Educate pest control companies, NWCOs, homeowners and homeowners associations, and local government staff to minimize injury and fatality of Florida bonneted bats in urban areas (Actions 17 and 19). This applies to bats that are roosting in buildings or vegetation such as palm trees that may be managed as landscaping. Take steps to prevent vandalism at known roosts. Vandalism can be a threat to roost cavities and artificial roosts of Florida bonneted bats. At this time, it has not been a main concern at BWWMA, but adequate law enforcement presence and frequent roost checks by biological staff on publically managed lands may deter vandals. Action 2 Develop and implement guidelines for building, installing, and monitoring bat houses for Florida bonneted bats. Bat houses can be useful tools in the conservation and promotion of bats on public and private land because they provide roosting habitat that may otherwise be lacking. Florida bonneted bats are among the species that use bat houses (Marks and Marks 2006). At BWWMA, Florida bonneted bats inhabit single -chamber and triple -chambered bat houses (J. Birchfield, personal communication). More research on the role of bat houses in Florida bonneted bat conservation Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 11 CONSERVATION ACTIONS should be conducted (Action 9). Specific recommendations regarding Florida bonneted bat houses are not available, though species experts provide general suggestions to consider when installing bat houses within the Florida bonneted bat's range. These general recommendations should be evaluated to ensure they address the needs of Florida bonneted bats roosting in bat houses. New recommendations should incorporate research results on natural and artificial roosts (Action 9). Until further research is conducted on the role of bat houses for Florida bonneted bats, general recommendations for building and installing bat houses can be found in the Bat Conservation International's Criteria for Successful Bat Houses, Appendices 1 and 2 (Marks and Marks 2006). FWC bat house monitoring protocols should be followed for bat houses installed within the Florida bonneted bat range (Appendix 3 and Actions 3, 5, 9, 17, and 18). If Florida bonneted bats are suspected in an occupied bat house, managers are encouraged to coordinate with FWC. Action 3 Develop landscape -level recommendations for the conservation of the Florida bonneted bat using information from research on rate of habitat loss, conversion, and alteration. Habitat loss and reduction of forested areas are serious threats to the Florida bonneted bat's survival, according to the BSR. Florida's human population is predicted to increase to 36 million by 2060 and about 28,300 km2 (11,000 mil) of land may be converted from rural and natural to urban uses (Zwick and Carr 2006, Fi ure 5). The projected loss and fragmentation of natural habitat may adversely affect Projected land use in 2060 Current land use or. 0 Developed land Conservation land Vndevekpped land Figure 5. Projected increase in area of developed land in Florida. Source: Zwick and Carr 2006. Florida bonneted bats; however, this species occurs in urban areas and uses structures such as chimneys and roofs for roosting (Belwood 1992). Because the survival and productivity rates of Florida bonneted bats in urban areas are unknown, it is not possible to accurately predict the impact of increasing urbanization on Florida bonneted bat populations. One adverse impact of more urban roosts is increasing human interaction and associated increase in exclusions. Expanded bat education programs (Action 7) and installation of alternate roosts may help offset adverse impacts. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 12 CONSERVATION ACTIONS The Florida bonneted bat population may number less than a few hundred individuals (Marks and Marks 2008a). Restricted range and low fecundity may make it vulnerable to extinction due to inbreeding depression, random environmental changes, or genetic drift (USFWS 2012). Almost 50% of the 12 known occurrences of the Florida bonneted bat are on private property (Marks and Marks 2008a, 2008d). Florida bonneted bat use of private or public lands are not well understood and it would be imprudent to make management recommendations to address these threats at this time. The Monitoring and Research section describes actions that, when implemented, will aid in identifying species -specific management recommendations. Increased urbanization also increases the Florida bonneted bat's risk for removal, exclusion, or persecution due to human —wildlife conflict as discussed in Action 1. Establishment of wind turbines is a concern in some areas because they obstruct existing bat flight corridors and can be sources of bat mortality (Kunz et al. 2007). Some research suggests that bats may even be attracted to the wind turbines out of curiosity, misperception, or as potential feeding, roosting, flocking, and mating opportunities (Cryan and Barclay 2009). Wind farms have been proposed in southern Florida near Loxahatchee National Wildlife Refuge and on the west side of Lake Okeechobee near Fisheating Creek (Melissa Tucker, FWC, personal communication). Adherence to the USFWS Land -Based Wind Energy Guidelines for siting wind farms, along with consultation with FWC, is recommended to wind farm developers, as is more research to determine impacts of these installations on Florida bonneted bat populations. Habitat changes and landscape alterations will occur, but how they will affect the Florida bonneted bat is unknown, as we do not yet know what habitat components and landscape features Florida bonneted bats require. More research should be conducted to determine the rate of loss, conversion, and alteration of the habitat of Florida bonneted bats. Specific research that would assist with these findings are habitat preferences (Action 8), population size and distribution (Action 11), and roost selection characteristics (Action 9). Results of this research can be incorporated in habitat management recommendations for public and private lands (Action 3). Population Management Action 4 Assess the need for potential management actions for Florida bonneted bats roosting in bat houses during extreme weather events, such as hurricanes or freezes, and develop guidelines if appropriate. Severe weather events may affect the survival of the small, fragmented population of Florida bonneted bats. On BWWMA, all occupied Florida bonneted bat houses are located within 16 km (10 mi) of each other. The occupied bat houses in North Fort Myers are within 26 km (16 mi) of BWWMA (J. Myers, personal communication). If a hurricane significantly impacted Charlotte or Lee counties, the occupied bat houses would likely be damaged. Bats in the family Molossidae, including Florida bonneted bats, appear to be physiologically intermediate between temperate- and tropical -zone bats (Arlettaz et al. 2000). They can tolerate moderately cold temperatures but may die following prolonged exposure to cold. During a severe freeze throughout much of southern Florida in 2010, at least 8 Florida bonneted bats died in a bat Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 13 CONSERVATION ACTIONS house in North Fort Myers (S. Trokey, private land owner, personal communication). Natural roosts may be better insulated than bat houses and thus provide better shelter and survival during cold temperatures, but this is merely speculation. Action 4 relates specifically to determining whether bats roosting in bat houses need additional protection during extremely cold weather. Appropriate response to potential severe weather events should be determined. Short-term relocation of individuals from bat houses may prevent their immediate demise, but long-term effects to the bats are unknown. Management guidelines for bat houses should be developed based on current knowledge. Guidelines may change following results of research proposed in Monitoring and Research. Interventions such as insulating or heating a bat house during severe cold weather, or physically bringing bats indoors need to be studied further to determine if they are necessary or if they could be detrimental (Action 9). Factors that may initiate intervention (duration of cold weather, low -temperature threshold) need to be further studied before guidelines can be developed. If Florida bonneted bats are using a bat house, we recommend consultation with FWC before taking action in advance of a severe weather event or if dead or cold -stunned bats are found below the bat house. Monitoring and Research As noted in the BSR and a recent federal assessment, information on population size and geographic range of Florida bonneted bats is quite limited (USFWS 2012). The available information was sufficient to determine that the Florida bonneted bat warrants the highest level of imperiled status in Florida (listing as Threatened on the Florida Endangered and Threatened Species List), but more specific and local information is needed. Several conservation actions listed here will generate needed information on geographic range, habitat use, population size, productivity and survival, and roost use. This information will greatly increase our understanding of the Florida bonneted bat and thereby improve our ability to conserve the species. Action 5 Develop a database of occurrence information and research findings. Because the Florida bonneted bat is rare and difficult to detect, information about the species has come from incidental sightings or irregular monitoring and is not readily available. Compiling occurrence and location information into a database would help researchers know what data is available; but just as importantly, it helps identify what data need to be collected. In particular, a data repository for information about roost sites would be useful in determining the types of roosts used and their location (Action 9). Currently, incidental observations of roosts are largely unavailable to most biologists. Results from long-term monitoring of roost use or large-scale acoustic surveys could be compiled in a central location and made available for subsequent analysis or review by anyone interested in conservation of Florida bonneted bats (see Coordination with Other Entities). Having a central repository might also help in setting standards or examples of the types of data that need to be collected (Action 6). A functional and useful central database for Florida bonneted bats will require planning to determine what information needs to be included, the types of assistance from partners who can provide information (Action 18), and the level of commitment from database managers to keep the database current and readily accessible. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 14 CONSERVATION ACTIONS Action 6 Develop standard methods for detecting presence of Florida bonneted bats. Action 7 Determine the current geographic range (i.e., extent of occurrence and area of occupancy) for Florida bonneted bats. Action 8 Identify Florida bonneted bat roosting and foraging habitat. Florida bonneted bats range over a small area of southern Florida, but that area includes a wide variety of habitats, and their distribution across those habitats is poorly known (USFWS 2012). Recent acoustic surveys have detected Florida bonneted bats repeatedly in only 4 counties and infrequently at a few sites in 3 other counties (Geographic Range and Distribution; Marks and Marks 2012). Because monitoring has been restricted to areas accessible by roads and relatively few bats have been detected, the distribution of the Florida bonneted bats and their use of different habitat types both for roosting and foraging remains poorly known (Marks and Marks 2012, USFWS 2012). As a consequence, the extent of occurrence of the Florida bonneted bat remains only coarsely known (extrapolated to counties) and the area occupied is largely undetermined. Better defining the geographic range of the Florida bonneted bat and identifying habitat types used for roosting and foraging are important steps in conserving this species in Florida (Action 7 and this action). Acoustic monitoring of the echolocation calls of Florida bonneted bats is the most efficient means of detecting these fast, high -flying animals. Before extensive monitoring is implemented, research is needed to determine how detection probability is affected by the survey methods, including type of monitoring equipment and the height and orientation of detectors. Survey methods should also be developed in conjunction with statisticians and species experts prior to implementing an acoustic monitoring program (Action 6). An acoustic monitoring program could be implemented to determine the geographic range and foraging habitats of the Florida bonneted bat by identifying areas where bats are present (Action 7). Analysis of data from the acoustic monitoring, particularly a multiple -scale approach using occupancy modeling, could provide useful information on the landscape features and habitat types used most often by Florida bonneted bats (Action 8). It is important to not only identify specific habitat components that are used by Florida bonneted bats for roosting and foraging on a local scale, but to also identify which factors influence selection of habitat on a landscape scale. On areas where land - management information is readily available, it should be incorporated into analyses to assess potential impacts of activities such as prescribed fire or mechanical vegetation treatments on Florida bonneted bats (Actions 1, 2, and 3). This information would be useful in helping to better map and monitor Florida bonneted bat distribution and to manage habitats for the species. In 2012, FWC awarded a grant to researchers at the University of Florida titled "Closing Data Gaps for the Florida Bonneted Bat (Eumops floridanus)." Funding came from Florida's State Wildlife Grants (SWG) Program. The objectives included in this grant are: 1) to develop a protocol that can be used for monitoring bonneted bats to determine population trends; 2) to determine habitat associations of the bonneted bat for foraging and roosting, surveying a minimum of 7 habitat types and 10 locations in southern Florida; and 3) to provide recommendations for additional conservation measures for bonneted bats. This grant was funded and work began in July 2013. Funding of the SWG grant, implementation of projects to meet the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 15 CONSERVATION ACTIONS grant objectives, and results from data collected will begin the implementation of Actions 6, 7, 8, and 9. Action 9 Determine what kinds of roost sites are available and how they are used. Florida bonneted bats use natural roost sites in cavities of trees, but they also utilize artificial structures including buildings and bat houses (Life History; Belwood 1981, 1992; USFWS 2012). Because Florida bonneted bats roost in small colonies, their roosts are typically small in size and difficult to detect. Currently, the only known roosts are in a few bat houses in Charlotte and Lee counties (Conservation History; USFWS 2012). The availability of roosts and disturbance of roosts are important factors in the conservation of colonial bats, but little is known about the availability of potential natural roost sites for Florida bonneted bats or how frequently roosts are disturbed (e.g., by humans, predators, storms, or fire) (USFWS 2012). We know that Florida bonneted bats will use bat houses, but we do not know to what extent the presence of bat houses may impact their use of natural roosts, or if their use of bat houses indicates that natural roost sites may be lacking. We also know little about how many roosts Florida bonneted bats typically use, how often they switch among roosts, whether certain habitats are preferred for roosting, or the characteristics that make a tree or other structure suitable as a roost. All this information would help managers most effectively and efficiently provide and protect suitable roosts for Florida bonneted bats (Actions 1 and 2) and should be addressed in future research. Artificial Roosts We do not know how important bat houses are to the conservation of Florida bonneted bats. Research should aid in identifying the appropriate style, number, density, and placement of bat houses that may be beneficial (Action 2). Occupied bat houses on BWWMA could be used to study roost switching, seasonal use of roosts, and preferences between artificial and natural roosts. They could also be used to evaluate potential effects of land -management practices such as prescribed fire and tree thinning (Action 1). Information gained from regular observations of the occupied houses and records of the number of bats present before and after land -management treatments will be useful. Even more useful information could be obtained if individual bats were marked with passive integrated transponder (PIT) tags and houses were fitted with PIT readers. In this way, detailed information about roost use could be collected for many individuals, and use of different styles or locations of bat house could be identified. Regardless of the method used to collect data on use of bat houses, it is critically important that research questions, study objectives, details of methods, and analysis techniques all be determined prior to collecting data and in conjunction with species experts and statisticians. Otherwise, it may be difficult to gain useful information from the data collected. Any research at bat houses on BWWMA will be supervised by the FWC, and will require a scientific collection permit (Rule and Permitting) to ensure protection of the roosts. Researchers may also require permits from the USFWS. Natural Roosts Natural roost sites are most efficiently located by tracking bats back to roosts, typically by following bats that have been captured, fitted with a radio transmitter, and released. Unfortunately, Florida bonneted bats are difficult to capture and the few that have been fitted Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 16 CONSERVATION ACTIONS with radios have not tolerated the devices (J. Gore, personal communication). A first step in finding roosts and learning more about them will be determining how to keep radio transmitters attached without harming the bats. Trials could be conducted using bats occupying bat houses at BWWMA; any research at those sites will be supervised by the FWC and require a scientific collection permit (Rule and PermittingIntent) to ensure protection of the roosts. Action 10 Assess genetic diversity across the population. Most aspects of Florida bonneted bat genetics are unknown (Timm and Genoways 2004). Because the population is believed to be quite small and may have gone through genetic bottlenecks following hurricanes or other environmental perturbations, genetic diversity may be low and be limiting population viability (USFWS 2012). Furthermore, it is not known whether subpopulations exist across the species' range and whether these are genetically isolated. For example, if the absence of records of Florida bonneted bats in the open expanses of the Everglades (Marks and Marks 2012) is more than a sampling limitation, then Florida bonneted bat populations in southeastern Florida are reproductively isolated and may be genetically distinct from those in southwestern Florida. It is important to assess genetic diversity across the population so that steps can be taken to improve diversity, especially if associated effects upon population viability are identified. Action 11 Develop and implement range -wide surveys to estimate population size. Because bats are highly mobile and difficult to detect, counting individuals and accurately assessing population size is very difficult (Kunz 2003). Most population estimates have been for species that roost in colonies where individuals can be counted consistently over time. Unfortunately, Florida bonneted bats roost only in relatively small colonies, few of which are known (Timm and Genoways 2004); therefore, population estimates are limited to small portions of the total populations. Although it may not be possible to accurately estimate population size, occupancy modeling (Action 8), analysis of genetic diversity (Action 10), or other approaches may provide useful information about population size. These methods and others should be evaluated with a goal of developing surveys to estimate population size. If numerous roosts are identified (Action 9), the number of bats using the roosts could be monitored and a trend of bat numbers (colony size) potentially could be used as an indicator of a correlated trend in the size of the overall population (Kunz 2003). This information would be useful in assessing changes in population size and would be especially useful if it closely correlated with any observed change in geographic range (Action 7). However, accurately estimating population size may not be practical or possible, and completing Actions 7, 8, 9, and 10 are of higher priority. Action 12 Determine Florida bonneted bat breeding biology, productivity, and survival rates. Action 13 Determine specifically what Florida bonneted bats eat and how their diet varies across their range and over time. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 17 CONSERVATION ACTIONS Action 14 Determine effects of environmental toxins, including pesticides, on Florida bonneted bats. Little is known about Florida bonneted bat reproduction and diet. The breeding season remains poorly determined, except that pregnant females have been found in July, August, and September, and young have been found in all seasons (Belwood 1992, Timm and Genoways 2004). It is possible that females are polyestrous and may form breeding harems in small colonies with a dominant male (Belwood 1981). Females are known to produce a single young, but gestation period, age at reproduction, number of young produced, and survival rates are not known. Knowing this basic information (Action 12) would allow managers to make better decisions about the timing of management activities near roost sites (Action 1) and would allow biologists to make better estimates of population viability. Florida bonneted bats are insectivorous but specific components of their diet are not well understood, and current knowledge is based on a single study with a small sample size (see Life History) (Belwood 1981, 1992). Presumably, they feed primarily upon flying insects, but, unlike most bats, they can take off readily from the ground, so it is possible that they also feed upon ground -dwelling invertebrates or even small vertebrates. Analysis of fecal droppings from known roosts, particularly advanced analysis of genetic material in feces, should provide a clear picture of the diet of Florida bonneted bats (Action 13). However, fecal collection at occupied bat houses can be difficult. On BWWMA, occupied bat houses are in areas that are inundated seasonally with water and almost daily rains during the summer and early fall make fecal collection very difficult. Collecting viable samples can be time consuming and requires daily visits to occupied bat houses Q. Myers, personal communication). Much of the range of the Florida bonneted bat is along urban or agricultural areas where the bats might be exposed to environmental toxins (particularly pesticides) which could adversely affect their health (Clark 1988). The effect of environmental toxins on Florida bonneted bats could be determined by measuring contaminant levels in bats or their insect prey and identifying any association between those levels and productivity and survival of bats (Action 14). If adverse effects are identified, managers could take steps to curtail the exposure of the bats. Rule and Permitting Intent The Florida bonneted bat is to be retained as a Threatened species in Florida, using the currently accepted scientific name (Eumops floridanus) and common name (Florida bonneted bat). Action 15 provides recommendations to incorporate research into protective measures specifically for the Florida bonneted bat. Action 15 Use results of research on Florida bonneted bat life history to develop needed protections. Existing Regulations It is illegal to take bats in Florida in accordance with the general prohibitions in Rule 68A-4.001, F.A.C., but enforcement of this rule is challenging. Colonial -roosting bats that occupy manmade structures are at increased risk of roost destruction and are particularly vulnerable during the maternity season, when bats gather to give birth and raise young. To address these risks, Rule Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 18 CONSERVATION ACTIONS 68A-9.010, F.A.C., provides protections for bats when they take up temporary or permanent residence in dwellings or other manmade structures, such as bridges and overpasses, where human —wildlife conflict may occur. These protections regulate how and when bats may be removed from structures. Exclusion devices (physical barriers that allow bats to exit a structure but not re-enter) are the only legal means of removing bats; the rule requires the use of an exclusion device prior to building repairs if bats are present, and describes the appropriate methods for the use of the exclusion device during the timeframe outside of the maternity season. The FWC provides information and technical assistance on excluding bats online and through regional Wildlife Assistance Biologists. As a Threatened species, the Florida bonneted bat is also protected under Chapter 68A-27, F.A.C., Rules Relating to Endangered or Threatened Species, specifically Rule 68A- 27.003(2)(a), F.A.C., for state -designated Threatened species. This rule states that: • No person shall take, possess, or sell any of the Endangered or Threatened species included in this subsection, or parts thereof or their nests or eggs except as allowed by specific federal or state permit or authorization. • Permit requirements for intentional take and incidental take are currently defined in Rule 68A-27.007(2), F.A.C., and are applicable to the Florida bonneted bat. The intent of protections should include protection of roosting sites, which are different from nesting sites as described in current rule, and should be in accordance with the objectives outlined in this action plan or other recovery plans. These additional considerations are discussed in detail in the Additional Protection Needed section. • Permit requirements for intentional take and incidental take are currently defined in Rule 68A-27.007(2), F.A.C., and are applicable to the Florida bonneted bat. Any research that requires handling Florida bonneted bats will require a scientific collection permit. On BWWMA, individuals who want to collect data on the occupied bat houses without disturbing occupied bat houses or handling bats have been granted access to the WMA through a Special Use Permit issued by FWC. This permit allows for access to closed areas on WMAs and provides conditions for conducting activities. Due to increasing requests for access specifically to collect echolocation calls at occupied bat houses, and in anticipation of future research projects that may result in an increase in requests for access with the potential for cumulative disturbance impacts to Florida bonneted bats, a scientific collection permit will now be required to collect Florida bonneted bat data on BWWMA, unless such work is done in conjunction with ongoing FWC activities or FWC staff. The application for the scientific collection permit is available online. Applications are reviewed by FWC's Mammal Taxa Coordinator, Biologists in the Species Conservation Planning Section, internal species experts, and regional and local staff. Anyone conducting research on the Florida bonneted bat should be aware that additional permits for research activities that involve handling bonneted bats may be needed from the USFWS or from the agencies that manage properties accessed for research (e.g., Water Management Districts, National Park Service). The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service proposed to list the Florida bonneted bat in 2012, and the listing was accepted in 2013, adding the Florida bonneted bat to the list of Endangered Species protected under the Endangered Species Act of 1973. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 19 CONSERVATION ACTIONS Additional Protections Needed As discussed in the Introduction and Actions I and 12, Florida bonneted bats are suspected to have 2 breeding seasons each year. Action 12 describes research needs regarding Florida bonneted bat reproduction. If this research indicates that Florida bonneted bats have a different maternity season than other bat species in Florida, additional protections will be needed (Action 15). Current protective measures contained in Rule 68A-9.010, F.A.C., prevent bat exclusions from taking place between 15 April and 15 August. However, these measures do not require individuals conducting an exclusion to first determine what bat species or group of species would be affected by the exclusion. If a bat roost includes Florida bonneted bats and exclusion is conducted pursuant to the current guidelines, it could still result in take by death of young remaining in the roost after the exclusion, if Florida bonneted bats are found to have a maternity season that falls in the window for allowed exclusions. To prevent take of Florida bonneted bats during exclusions, the following additional protections need to be addressed: 1. Identification of bat species roosting in structures. Visual inspections may be possible in some cases, but roosts are often located in inaccessible areas of a structure (e.g., behind walls, under tiles, or above soffits). Acoustic surveys may be another method to identify what species or group of species are using the roost prior to exclusion (Action 15). 2. Identification of the breeding and maternity seasons for the Florida bonneted bat. This may require reducing the season in which exclusions may be conducted within the range of the Florida bonneted bat. The FWC recommends using only qualified and experienced NWCOs to exclude bats, and provides technical assistance for dealing with bats when they create human —wildlife conflicts. While very few violations of Rule 68A-9.010, F.A.C., are reported to FWC, it is not clear how often exclusions occur that are inconsistent with regulations. It is also not known if most individuals conducting nuisance wildlife work can distinguish between Florida bonneted bats and other bat species. Despite the protections provided to bats in general and to Florida bonneted bats via Rule 68A-9.010 and Chapter 68A-27, F.A.C., there is still concern that Florida bonneted bats may be excluded during sensitive time periods or are being removed from roosts using prohibited methods (C. Marks, personal communication). An additional issue to consider in roost protection during exclusions is that removal of pest species "in, on, or under" a structure is regulated by the Structural Pest Control Act (Chapter 482, Florida Statues [F.S.] and Rule 5E-14, F.A.C.) through the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services (DOACS). This act primarily focuses on the regulation of pesticide use; however, many NWCOs that remove animals from attics or crawl spaces are also regulated by this act. Full licensing as a pest -control operator requires extensive knowledge of pesticides, and this requirement is not applicable to most NWCOs. To address this, DOACS amended Chapter 482, F.S., to include a limited certification for commercial wildlife management personnel (s. 482.157, F.S.), which is required for anyone removing rats and mice, but is encouraged for those removing other species from buildings. DOACS training materials do not include specific recommendations for Florida bonneted bats, and are not adequate to assure conservation of bats in general. Action 19 addresses these concerns through coordination with DOACS. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 20 CONSERVATION ACTIONS To improve conservation of bats roosting in structures, we recommend implementing Actions 15, 16, 17, and 19 to improve compliance with existing rules and knowledge about the Florida bonneted bat. Threats to the Florida bonneted bat were identified by the BRG, but research is needed to understand how these threats may be impacting populations. New regulations or permitting related to habitat loss and roost protection in natural areas are not recommended at this time because of the lack of information about the life history of the Florida bonneted bat. As research actions are implemented and new information is acquired, additional protections or permitting requirements may be suggested in the future (Action 15). Law Enforcement Action 16 Develop and implement an FWC Law Enforcement training module for Florida bonneted bats. In conjunction with federal, state, and local partners, the FWC's Division of Law Enforcement is responsible for enforcing Florida's wildlife and fisheries laws. FWC biologists and other bat experts can educate law enforcement officers through the development, circulation, and interpretation of identification tools, distribution maps, handling, and other approved methods for dealing with unwanted bats (Action 16). Since the Florida bonneted bat can be mistaken for other bat species, proper identification tools will be important for documenting violations of Florida's wildlife laws. In turn, an important component of the enforcement strategy is ensuring compliance through public education (Action 17). FWC law enforcement officers understand the importance of explaining wildlife laws to the public to avoid unintentional violations. However, FWC law enforcement officers actively pursue and recommend prosecution for those who intentionally violate wildlife laws. FWC law enforcement officers also educate the public on how to identify and report violations. The Division of Law Enforcement administers the Wildlife Alert program, which receives information via a toll -free number (1-888-404-3922) answered 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Incentives and Influencing Influencing The BSR and this plan identify the threats to the Florida bonneted bat that have warranted state listing, as well as regulatory recommendations that may afford them protection from take. The FWC is working to develop recommendations for protecting Florida bonneted bat roosts (Action 1) and landscape -level recommendations for the conservation of the Florida bonneted bat (Action 1). Existing efforts to influence county and city governments, private landowners, and other state and private entities should incorporate these recommendations wherever possible. Incentive Programs The FWC's Landowner Assistance Program advances species conservation objectives through public -private conservation partnerships. FWC also takes advantage of several programs that promote conservation by providing technical and financial assistance to private landowners. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 21 CONSERVATION ACTIONS FWC partners with other state and federal agencies to administer the Forest Stewardship Program, Wildlife Habitat Incentives Program, Wetlands Reserve Program, Environmental Quality Incentives Program, Partners for Fish and Wildlife Program, and the Cooperative Conservation Blueprint. Florida also provides tax incentives, including property tax exemptions for landowners that put a perpetual conservation easement on their land. Additional incentives may include exemption from permits for activities that enhance wildlife activities such as mowing, roller -chopping, and tree stand thinning, as long as they are not a precursor to development or negatively impacting imperiled species. Any number of these incentive programs may be applicable for working with private landowners to identify, protect, and manage existing and potential habitat for the Florida bonneted bat. Education and Outreach Bats are often misunderstood by the public. Misinformation can often lead to persecution of bats. Because the Florida bonneted bat is so rare, most people are not aware of the existence of this species. Education and outreach is critical to develop awareness of the needs of Florida bonneted bats (Action 17), and all bat species. Within FWC, education for staff responding to public requests for assistance with bats within the range of the Florida bonneted bat is also critical. Support from stakeholders and conservation partners will be an important component in implementation of conservation actions listed in this plan (Action 18). Action 17 Develop and implement an education and outreach program on the Florida bonneted bat, including development of a Florida bonneted bat webpage for public use. Target audiences for this program include, but are not limited to: • Land managers • Conservation planners • City and county governments • Pesticide applicators • Licensed NWCOs • Homeowners and homeowners associations • Developers and environmental consultants Educational materials will have greater impact if tailored to the target audience. The following key messages should be included: • The Florida bonneted bat is listed by the FWC as a Threatened species, and is also listed by USFWS as Endangered; they are therefore protected by state and federal regulations. • Bats in general are beneficial to have in nature, and the presence of this rare species in south Florida contributes to the uniqueness of that region of the state. • Bats in buildings or in other situations where they could create human —wildlife conflicts are still protected, and resources are available to help address any potential problems. • Because Florida bonneted bats are so rare, actions taken to conserve the species and learn more about their natural history are very important. • Bat houses have the potential to be an important conservation tool for Florida bonneted bats (Action 2). • Roost protection guidelines and general habitat management guidelines will be provided if they become available. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 22 CONSERVATION ACTIONS Coordination with Other Entities A number of partners, including other state agencies, federal and county governments, universities, research and consulting groups, and private individuals take an interest in the conservation of Florida bonneted bats. Research and monitoring are high -priority actions for Florida bonneted bats, and many other entities are currently pursuing projects involving this species across its range. In addition to the information outlined in the plan, the Conservation Action Table (Table 1) identifies priorities for research actions, and suggests specific information that should be included in ongoing and future Florida bonneted bat research. Action 5 recommends development of a database of research and occurrence information, which will require coordination with other entities to complete. This should include coordinating with the Department of Health to ensure that agency is aware of FWC's interest in any bat specimen that may be a Florida bonneted bat. FWC maintains a bat mortality database for reporting sick or dead bats. Anyone who finds a bat that appears sick, is acting in an unusual manner, or is dead is encouraged to report that information by calling FWC's Wildlife Alert phone number (1-888- 404-3922) or completing the FWC's form for reporting sick, unusually behaving, or dead bats. Action 18 describes an opportunity for continued coordination among conservation partners. Action 18 Maintain FWC involvement in the Florida Bonneted Bat Working Group. In 2012, the Florida Bonneted Bat Working Group formed to address the conservation needs of this species across its range. Members include the FWC, USFWS, National Park Service, Zoo Miami, FBC, and several other private and public entities. Many members are also stakeholders referenced in this plan. Continuation of this working group will aid in communication among conservation partners for Florida bonneted bats and will aid in implementation of many conservations actions outlined in this plan. Action 19 Work with DOACS to improve educational materials provided to NWCOs through the limited commercial wildlife management certification. The limited certification for commercial wildlife control operators requires that an applicant pass a test that includes acceptable methods for removal of wildlife from structures. The current set of documents that serve as study material does not provide any information about the Florida bonneted bat and provides a very limited set of guidelines for conducting exclusions. Incorporating the expertise of bat biologists and partners to improve the study material will benefit the Florida bonneted bat and bats in general (Action 19). The module developed in Action 16 could be an appropriate model for the information to include in reference material for DOACS. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 23 -d " a - o� oz - v _ o. - ° ffif ;; oE m w m - - - _ 3 EK Ea - - - E oE'w'2 _-fir > o - -- i m m i a m = c `o_ t v C v E S Iw - g a a 3 E 3 - _F - - vz v - 3 ° -_ - a_ 1cc °3 - - - - o `w - - - ` - - - m E.� - - o30 3'E - -oc vo'� - _- - - o E - - mw E c -_ - - -_ a E - - - - _o. E rs a 3 3 n c E o v o 3 -- a - - _- or- o ---- o --- -a3 E o' 23° 3 'L 3 -o o_ E o =0 a o E o _ s >, E o 3 c E 3 o _ 2 c 'xm t 'xm n t w° 3 01 w n E n 'xm v 3 3 �°, 'xm 3 m 12 o m A m E °1 E °1 E °1 E °1 E °1 E av� m° m° m° m° m° m° LL 3 LL 3 LL 3 LL 3 LL"IZ LL 3 `o w E i c _- = J v LL i LL i LL i t t - E 3 A 3 " 3 �_ ° 3 ° 3 ° 3 �_ ° 3 wg ° 3 Y V .f V .r^ V LL N 3-_ 8� W m W m W m W m W m W m g m o c _ E o E �_ E "- z5t o f m iz a= AL r r r r r ° o Q >3Epgo SE 8 �- _dim •`-°aw 3 z 3 3 3 3 9 z i z z z z ° w i c u W ° o o c o a t a.2 w E m z L z - - - o a E E a E w °,y' a E w c c72w c o - °o t - E _ w E w _ o - c o a q o>_ 1O ° E -wE-°° - °0 3 v m E 0 0 q_ - - m E _ Eoo �- zEvvd- o n o a' o- ¢ E a w 0 w n jagwnN wail u°pay - sai i E a PassaJPPV (s)anlyialg0 d3 o _ E o c E v a C m_ c a o o ;2 o s `o E z° i o `m t°n - n E — - ` _ g oo '' w E m a - _ c3i — w _ _ _ __ -go m 6 Eo 6 o V n E —o 2= U D `mR RLL a w -� w _ -_ a 3 w c a -` Nj. � o _ -_ °- 0 2` E 3 �- t 3 zo- t o A 3go a ' o t o t o ° - n E 3 ma - 5 3 5 3 5 3 - - o Z m a v w w_ a r o f a E� , - - Y 3 0 - v - v _ o n 3 ° i o t �.i o° f E°° 3 w s E m _ s° o i$ i$ o= v m E m E m E m E m E m E m E m E E $ m° t� 'o t� m° t� m° m° t� 2 m° 2 _ _ _ _ _ _ - LL3 LL3 LL3 LL3 LL3 LL3 LL3 LL3 o^1Z - m•� z� 3 � � 3 3 3 3 3 01 E JE39 3`A 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 r� "= it c ° 3 c_ ° 3 c o 3 " 3 c ° 3 o" 3 _ _ LLN "� 38 y`3 v o ` r~ E oko_ m m m m m m m m E r r r r r r r r �uE _s ` i s Y m- 0 z 0 z 0 z 0 z 0 z 0 z 0 z 0 z ° �- > > > > > > > > Q i3E c SE 8 to •`o v" w k` --- p z ❑ z p z 3 3 3 3 3 -A. a a a z z z z z O 'oi= w z o w w w o a z o lo lo c. w E _ 3 N o E o E ow ° m 3 a 3 r _ ` c 3 'Ewo — o o m E o 3 c ow _ E v ;2' o E a _ _ E` E w E N o a o a n o? o a' o a o jagwnN wail uopay > s� _ ig - F passa,ppv (s)anpialg0 .3 - - {$!;! ��) $\( , - --\ _ :2!<± - {\\\}} \\/ }\\\\ \\\\\ \}\/k o 1. ! \� /ko : \ \oc \\$ \/ � }o \ \ ! \\_\ �\ )\\\\ 2�o \- —_ _o - _$))\ §_ _ \\\\\\4o :\j, -. § ��s \}\}k \\\}( ))f\!){\/ \\))()) \.lo IS 12 : \j! !| !| !| $E ))i ))i _ \{ \{ \{ <\, § /\ ($; §3. `It \ 2:# ¥ ( )lu La` | ! E5! 2f : };\! k | o!!;! !`! R E \� m § § § § )f )}.{;{ \/ -!k - o 7 \, ,\ o }� \ \ \/ \o f )i ! ) 2 )ƒ )o .2 :- k( )) E k \- -` - 2 )! /f)| \\} }\\ }\\\j \\ \\�\ s!! !:2 !!!.a ,: !!!, __ _ _- ' - E� __-( _o og4Ee (%!\ LITERATURE CITED LITERATURE CITED Arlettaz, R., Ruchet, C., Aeschimann, J., Brun, E., Genoud, M., and Vogel, P. 2000. Physiological traits affecting the distribution and wintering strategy of the bat Tadarida teniotis. Ecology 81:1004-1014. Belwood, J. J. 1981. Wagner's mastiff bat, Eumops glaucinus floridanus (Molossidae) in southwestern Florida. Journal of Mammalogy 62:411-413 Belwood, J. J. 1992. Florida mastiff bat Eumops glaucinus floridanus. Pages 216-223 in S. R. Humphrey, editor. Rare and endangered biota of Florida. Vol. I. Mammals. University Press of Florida, Gainesville. Boyles, J .G., and D. P. Aubrey. 2006. Managing forests with prescribed fire: implications for a cavity -dwelling bat species. Forest Ecology and Management 222:108-115. Carter, T. C., W. M. Ford, and M. A. Menzel. 2000. Fire and bats in the southeast and mid - Atlantic: more questions than answers? Pages 139-143 in W. M. Ford, K. R. Russell, and C. E. Moorman, editors. Proceedings of a special workshop on the role of fire in nongame wildlife management and community restoration: traditional uses and new directions. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Nashville, Tennessee. Clark, Jr. D. R. 1988. How sensitive are bats to insecticides? Wildlife Society Bulletin 16:399- 403. Cryan, P. M., and R. M. Barclay. 2009. Causes of bat fatalities at wind turbines: hypotheses and predictions. Journal of Mammalogy 90:1330-1340. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission [FWC]. 2011. Florida's Wildlife Legacy Initiative. Florida's draft state wildlife action plan. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, Tallahassee. Florida's Natural Area Inventory. 2012. FNAI Element Tracking List. Updated June 2012. Florida's Natural Area Inventory Tallahassee. Humphrey, S. R. 1975. Nursery roosts and community diversity of Nearctic bats. Journal of Mammalogy 56:321-346. Keeley, B. W., and M. D. Tuttle. 1999. Bats in American bridges. Resource Publication No. 4. Bat Conservation International, Austin, Texas. Kunz, T. H. 2003. Censusing bats: challenges, solutions, and sampling biases. Pages 9-19 in T. J. O'Shea and M. A. Bogan, editors. Monitoring trends in bat populations of the United States and territories: problems and prospects. U.S. Geological Survey, Information and Technology Report USGSBRD/ITR-2003-0003, Ft. Belvoir, Virginia. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 27 LITERATURE CITED Kunz, T. H., and L. F. Lumsden. 2003. Ecology of cavity and foliage roosting bats. Pages 3-89 in T. H. Kunz and M. B. Fenton, editors. Bat ecology. The University of Chicago Press. Chicago, Illinois. Kunz, T. H., E. B. Arnett, W. P. Erickson, A. R. Hoar, G. D. Johnson, R. P. Larkin, R. W. Strickland, and M. D. Tuttle. 2007. Ecological impacts of wind energy development on bats: questions, research needs, and hypotheses. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 5:315-324. Lacki, M. J., D. R. Cox, L. E. Dodd, and M. B. Dickinson. 2009. Response of northern bats (Myotis septentrionalis) to prescribed fires in eastern Kentucky forests. Journal of Mammalogy 90:1165-1175. Lewis, S. E. 1995. Roost fidelity of bats: a review. Journal of Mammalogy 76:481-496. Loeb, S. C., and T. A.Waldrop. 2008. Bat activity in relation to fire and fire surrogate treatments in southern pine stands. Forest Ecology and Management 255:3185-3192. Marks, C. S., and G. E. Marks. 2006. Bats of Florida. University Press of Florida. Gainesville. Marks, G. E., and C. S. Marks. 2008a. Status of the Florida bonneted bat (Eumops floridanus). Final report submitted to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service by the Florida Bat Conservancy under grant agreement number 401815G192, Florida Bat Conservancy, Bay Pines. Marks, G. E., and C. S. Marks. 2008b. Bat conservation and land management Kissimmee River WMA. Report submitted to the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission by the Florida Bat Conservancy, Bay Pines. Marks, G. E., and C. S. Marks. 2008c. Bat conservation and land management Babcock Webb WMA. Report submitted to the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission by the Florida Bat Conservancy, Bay Pines. Marks, G.E. and C.S. Marks. 2008d. Status of the Florida bonneted bat (Eumops floridanus). Supplemental report submitted to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service by the Florida Bat Conservancy under grant agreement number 401815G192, Florida Bat Conservancy, Bay Pines. Marks, G. E., and C. S. Marks. 2012. Status of the Florida bonneted bat (Eumops floridanus). Final report to U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service by the Florida Bat Conservancy under grant agreement number 40181AG121, Florida Bat Conservancy, Bay Pines. McDonough, M. M., L. K. Ammerman, R. M. Timm, H. H. Genoways, P. A. Larsen, and R. J. Baker. 2008. Speciation within bonneted bats (Genus Eumops): the complexity of Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 28 LITERATURE CITED morphological, mitochondrial, and nuclear data sets in systematic. Journal of Mammalogy 90:1306-1315. Millsap, B. A., J. A. Gore, D. E. Runde, and S. I. Cerulean. 1990. Setting priorities for the conservation of fish and wildlife species in Florida. Wildlife Monographs 111:1-57. NatureServe. 2010. NatureServe Explorer: An online encyclopedia of life [web application]. Version 7.1. NatureServe, Arlington, Virginia. http://www.natureserve.org/explorer. Accessed: 6 May 2011). Robson, M. 1989. Status survey of the Florida mastiff bat. Final performance report. Nongame Wildlife Section, Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission, Tallahassee. Timm, R. M., and H. H. Genoways. 2004. The Florida bonneted bat, Eumops floridanus (Chiroptera: Molossidae): distribution, morphometrics, systematic, and ecology. Journal of Mammalogy 85:852-865. Timm, R., and J. Arroyo-Cabrales. 2008. Eumops floridanus. In: IUCN 2010. IUCN Red List of Threatened Species. Version 2012.2 www.iucnredlist.or . Accessed 12 December 2012. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service [USFWS]. 2012. Proposed endangered species status for the Florida bonneted bat. Federal Register 77(193):60750-60776. Zwick, P. D., and M. H. Carr. 2006. Florida 2060: A population distribution scenario for the State of Florida. Prepared by the Geoplan Center at the University of Florida for 1000 Friends of Florida, Gainesville. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 29 APPENDICES APPENDICES Appendix 1. Instructions for building a single -chambered bat house. (These are general plans for a single -chambered bat house but this design has not been tested for use by Florida bonneted bats.) http://www.batcon.org/pdfs/bathouses/SingleChamberBHPlans.pdf BAT C*NSERVAAJ0t www.batcon.org Single -chamber Bat House (wall mounted) Mareriah (makes one !muse) ti sheet (2' x 4') k" AC, BC or T1-11 (outdoor grade) plywood One piece 1" x 2" ('k" x IM" finished) x 8' pine (furring strip) 20 to 30 exterior -grade screws, 1" One pint dark, water -based stain, exterior grade One pint water -based primer, exterior grade One quart flat, water -based paint or stain, exterior grade One tube paintable latex caulk 1" x 4" x 28" board for roof (optional, but highly recommended) Black asphalt shingles or galvan i zed metal (optional) 6 to10 roofing nails, X" (if using shingles or metal roofing) Recommended tools Table saw or handsaw Caulking gun Variable -speed re versing drill Paintbrushes Screwdriver bit for drill Hammer (optional) Tape measure or yardstick Tin snips (optional) More bat -house plans and additional information can be found in BCI's Bat House Builder's Handbook, available at wwvbatcatolog.com. Construction 1. Measure and cut plywood into three pieces: 26%" x 24" 16Y" x 24" 5" x 24" 2. Roughen inside of backboard and landing area by cutting horzzmtal grooves with sharp object or saw. Space grooves Y.." to T apart, cutting Yu" to Sf." deep. 3. Apply two coats of dark, water -based stain to interior maces. Do not use paint, as it will fill grooves. 4. Cut furring strip into one 24" and two 209" pieces. 5. Attach furring strips to back, caulking first. Start with 24" piece at top. Roost chamber spacing is g". 6. Attach front to furring strips, top piece first (caulk first). Leave %" vent space between top and bottom front pieces. 7. Caulk all outside joints to further seal roost chamber. 8. Attach a 1" x 4" x 28" board to the top as a roof (optional, but highly recommended). 9. Apply three coats of paint or stain to the exterior (use primer for first coat). 10. Cover roof with shingles or gahanized metal (optional). 11. Mount on building (south or east sides usually best). Optional modifications to the single -chamber bat house 1. Wider bat houses can be built for larger colonies. Be sure to adjust dimensions for back and front pieces and ceiling strip. A X" support spacer may be needed in the center of the roost- ing chamber for bat houses over 24" wide to prevent warping. 2. To make a taller version for additional temperature diversity, use these modifications: From a 2' x 8' piece of plywood, cut t h we pieces: 51" x 24", 33" x 24" and 12" x 24". Cut two 8' furring strips into one 24" and two 44" pieces. Follow assem- bly procedure above. 3. Two bat houses can be placed back-to-back, mounted between two poles, to create a three -chamber nursery house. Before assembly, cut a horizontal X" slot in the back of each house about 9" from the bottom edge of the back piece to permit movement of bats between houses. Two pieces of wood, 1" x 4" x 4V, screwed horizontally to each side, will join the two boxes. Leave a Y" space between the two houses, and roughen the wood surfaces or cover the back of each with plastic mesh (see item 5 below). Do not cover the rear exit slots with mesh. One 1 " x 4" x 34" vertical piece, attached to each side over the horizontal pieces, blocks light but allows bats and air to enter. A galvanized metal roof, covering both houses, protects the center roosting area from rain. Eaves should be about 3" in southern areas and about 1i4" in the torch. 4. Ventilation may not be necessary in cold climates. In this case, the front should be a single piece 23" long. Smaller bat houses like this one will be less successful in cool climates. However, those mounted on buildings maintain thermal stability better and are more likely to attract bats. 5. Durable plastic mesh can be substituted to provide footholds for bats. Attach one 20" x 2432piece to backboard after stain- ing interior, but prior to assembly. © copyright Bat Conservation International, Inc. All rights reserved. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 30 APPENDICES Appendix 2. Instructions for building a triple -chambered bat house. http://www.floridabats.org/ImagesBHs/Bat—House—Plans.pdf Vent Triple -chambered Bat House Plans Front View 8„ :al■ .1 u Side View 6" Board Partition Spacer Bottom View MATERIALS One 3' foot long 1" X 8" (7'/4") One 2' X 2' sheet of T-111 exterior siding or rough sided plywood. One 8' foot long 1" X 6" ( 5'/2') One 4' by 4' sheet'/4" plastic mesh (Optional).' One 6' foot long 1" X 4" (3'/i') 46 - 1 5/8" #8 galvanized wood screws. Two 3' foot long 1" X 1" ('/4') "Plastic mesh is only necessary if the interior of the bat house is constructed with smooth -sided wood. A better approach is to use T-111 siding for the partitions and rough -sided lumber for the back wall. If smooth -sided wood or plywood is used, it can be grooved at '/2" intervals to provide a rough surface for the bats to grasp onto. See also the note at bottom of page 2. INSTRUCTIONS Step 1. From the 1 X6, cut six 14" sections for the front and back panels of the bat house. From the 1 X8, cut one 16" section for the roof and one 14" section for the back. From the 1X1's cut four 17" sections. These will be used as spacers to secure the partitions. From the 1X4, cut one additional 14" section for the back. From the remaining piece of the 1X4 cut two sections for the sides. One end of each piece will be cut at a 30-degree angle for the roof. This can be done by cutting each piece with a front length of 21'/i' and a back length of 23'/i'. © Florida Bat Conservancy, P.O. Box 516, Bay Pines, FL 33744. Ph: (727) 710-BATS Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 31 APPENDICES L continued. Step 2. From the T-111 or plywood sheet, cut a 17X12" section for the back partition, and a 16"X12" section for the front partition. Note: If a larger piece of plywood is available, these two pieces can be cut 12'/z" in width to provide a flush fit at either side. Step 3. Bevel the back of the 16" roof section at 30 degrees. The roof will look best if the top (widest side) is made 6'/i' wide when the bevel is cut. Bevel one of the 14" X 6" pieces at 30 degrees. This piece will be used at the top of the front and the bevel is necessary to match the roof. Step 4. Begin assembly of the bat house by placing the two side pieces on a table with the long sides up and 14" apart (outside to outside). It is recommended that glue or caulking be used as the bat house is assembled to strengthen and weatherproof it. Place one of the 14" X 6" pieces on top and align it with the bottom of the two side pieces. Fasten it with two 1-5/8" wood screws on each side. Drilling 3/32" pilot holes for all screws will help prevent the wood from splitting. Repeat the process with a 6", 4", 6" and 8" piece, in that order. This will place the 8" piece at the top of the bat house. Now turn the bat house over so it is laying on its back. Drill one 5/16" hole at the top, and one 5/16" hole bottom. These will be used for mounting the bat house to a post or building. The holes should be located in the center and 2" from the edge. Step 5. If plastic mesh is being used, cut two sections of plastic mesh the same dimensions as the plywood partitions. Staple the mesh to the plywood using vertical rows of staples about 2-3" apart. The side with the mesh All face the front of the bat house. Cut a section of plastic mesh 12" wide and 23" long and place it on the back wall of the bat house. Fasten the mesh with vertical rows of staples about 2-3" apart. Step 6. Position the 1X1's in the left and right-hand corners with the bottom ends located 4'/2' from the bottom of the bat house. This will create a 41/2' landing pad. Place the 17" partition with the rough or mesh covered side up on top of the two 1X1's already in position. Use three 1-5/8" wood screws in each; one in the center and the other two about from each end. Make sure the top wood screw securely attaches the 1X1 to the 8" board on the back wall. This will add strength to the bat house Step 7. Position the remaining two 1X1's on each side of the partition directly above the previous two. Place the 16" partition on top (rough or mesh side up); allowing 1" of the previous 1X1's to show at the bottom. This open space makes it easier for bats to crawl into the forward crevices. Now fasten the plywood section and 1X1's using two 1-5/8" screws on each side. Locate them about 1'/s" from the top and bottom of the plywood partition to avoid the screws underneath. Step 8. Place the beveled 14" X 6" board at the top of the front, aligning the beveled edge with the 30 degree angle of the two side pieces. Fasten it using two 1-5/8" screws on each side. Repeat using a second 14" X 6" board. Locate the third and final 14" X 6" board about''/2' down from the previous one to form a'/z" gap for the vent. Step 9. Center the roof section such that there is equal overhang on each side. Fasten it to the side pieces using two 1-5/8" screws on each side. The roof should be caulked where it meets the back wall. Adding roofing material and painting the bat house will greatly extend its life. A light brown color works well in Florida. Step 10. The bat house can be mounted on a 4'X4" post or the side of a building using the holes drilled in step 4 and three-inch long, 5/16" lag bolts. A large galvanized or stainless steel washer (fender washer) is recommended to protect the wood. Mounting on trees is not recommended because they have proven to be the least successful location for bat houses. Bat houses should be located at least ten feet above ground. Experience indicates the higher the bat house is mounted the more likely it will get bats. Note 1: There are photographs of this bat house during various stages of construction on the web at: http://www.floridabats.org/BatHousePIan Photos.htm. Note 2: If you choose to use '/a" plastic mesh please contact the Florida Bat Conservancy since it is not readily available from local suppliers. We can mail you the required amount of mesh for this bat house design for the cost of the material and shipping. © Florida Bat Conservancy. Email: floridabats@aol.com. Phone: (727) 710-2287 Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 32 APPENDICES Appendix 3. FWC bat house occupancy assessment protocol. Protocol current as of May 2013. 0Bat House Occupancy Assessment Bat houses provide roosting sites for several species of bats in Florida and can be an important tool in bat conservation. Better information is needed on where and when bats are using but houses on conservation lands, and if land management activities have the potential to impact bat house use. Participating in bat house occupancy assessments will lead to better recommendations on bat house siting, and over many years may provide trend information on bat house use. Assessment Objective - Estimate number of bats and seasonality of use of bat houses in Florida. 0 Bat houses should be checked THREE times every year. Checks should be conducted once during each of the following time periods: May -July September -November 15th December -February 0 If staff resources allow, information is also needed relative to land management activities. These o t� ional visits should be conducted ithin a week be ore and a ter land management activities within 100 ft of houses. Land management activities include prescribed burning, extensive timber removal, or other activities that substantially alter the immediate environment. 0 Bat house checks fall into two categories: daytime checks and evening emergence counts. • Daytime Checks are completed to determine if bat houses are occupied and to estimate number of bats for each house according to the instructions below. • Evening Emergence Counts are optional and are best conducted at occupied houses in which number of bats cannot be estimated (ie. large condo houses, reduced visibility). Daytime Checks - Visit each house during the day and look for signs that bats are using the house. For occupied houses, estimate number of bats, if possible. 0 Bat sign includes: • Staining near the opening of the house chambers. • Small pellets scattered on the ground at the base of the house. Bat guano is a similar size to mouse or rat droppings, but is composed primarily of insect parts and can be easily crumbled. Pellets are also rather shiny in appearance. • Sounds of bats (chirping, chattering) 0 Binoculars, mirrors, and flashlights can be used to look into house chambers for bats. 0 Record date, presence/absence, type of bat sign, and estimated number of bats on datasheet. • Estimated number of bats — Count or estimate the number of bats in the bat house, if possible. In most cases bats cannot be individually counted, but an estimate of the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 33 APPENDICES Appendix 3 continued. proportion of space within each house that is filled by resting bats may be possible, using increments of 25% (ie. 0-25%, 26-50%, 51-75%, 76-100%). If neither a count nor estimate of proportion of space can be confidently determined, simply indicate whether the house is occupied. If conducting the daytime visit as part of a land management activity, please include the type of land management and the date of the activity in the data sheet. Multiple visits can be included on a single data sheet. Evenin¢ Emereence Count - Conduct at houses known or suspected to be occupied and in which number of bats cannot be accurately determined. Technical and staff assistance can be provided if needed. 0 Count should take place on a clear evening when the temperature is warmer than 451 F. 0 Arrive at least 15 minutes prior to sunset; choose a location at least 25 feet from the house, with a clear view of the opening. Limit disturbance (noise, lights) that could prevent emergence. 0 Bats should emerge shortly after sunset. The observer should remain at the house for at least 30 minutes after civil twilight, or until no more bats emerge from the house. If bonneted bats are suspected, the observer should remain at the house for at least 45 minutes after civil twilight. 0 For sunset and civil twilight times, see http://aa.tisno.nayy.mil/data/docs/RS_OneDayphp 0 Record date, number of bats, and other observations on datasheet. 0 Near -infrared equipment can be used to record an emergence and can be particularly useful at large bat condos. 0 Fill out Bat House Information form only once for each bat house. 0 Record all data from Daytime Checks and Evening Emergence Counts using the Bat House Occupancy Datasheet below. 0 Send all forms to Mehssa.Tucker(&mvfwc.com FWC's Mammal Taxa Coordinator Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 34 APPENDICES Appendix 3 continued. 0 Bat House Information Send forms to Mehssa.Tucker(&inyfwc.com FWC's Mammal Taxa Coordinator Please complete one forni for each bat house on WMA/WEA. General Information VVIAA/WEA: Contact Name: Contact Phone Nuumber: Total Number of Bat Houses: Bat House Information Bat House Name: (Name is for WMA/WEA staff reference only. Choose a name that uniquely identifies the bat house for staff purposes. Ex: Check station house, pond house, Burn Unit 12 house, etc.) Latitude: _ Longitude: (Decimal degrees preferred) Installation Date (estimated monthlyear): Bat House Size: Single _ Double _ Triple Condo Estimated number of bats when full (if known): If size is unknown, estimated dimensions: Bat House Mount Setup Estimated Height of House (from ground) (Ex. Attached to tree, pole, 4x4, building) Photo provided? ( Y / N ) If possible, please attach a photo of this house, labeled with Bat House Name. Brief description of habitat within sight of bat house: Other continents regarding bat house: Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 35 APPENDICES Appendix ]Continued ( B z 2 § ) } 2 0 ne „„ate �@,■ \ z'2. -!2, Z;ƒ3oo # _ ID _ //$CL a %0, §�V� �. Florida Bonneted Bat Species Action Plan STANDARD PROTECTION MEASURES FOR THE EASTERN INDIGO SNAKE U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service August 12, 2013 The eastern indigo snake protection/education plan (Plan) below has been developed by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) in Florida for use by applicants and their construction personnel. At least 30 days prior to any clearing/land alteration activities, the applicant shall notify the appropriate USFWS Field Office via e-mail that the Plan will be implemented as described below (North Florida Field Office: jaxre sg`(&,,fws.gov; South Florida Field Office: verobeachkfws.gov; Panama City Field Office: panamacity&fws.gov). As long as the signatory of the e-mail certifies compliance with the below Plan (including use of the attached poster and brochure), no further written confirmation or "approval" from the USFWS is needed and the applicant may move forward with the project. If the applicant decides to use an eastern indigo snake protection/education plan other than the approved Plan below, written confirmation or "approval" from the USFWS that the plan is adequate must be obtained. At least 30 days prior to any clearing/land alteration activities, the applicant shall submit their unique plan for review and approval. The USFWS will respond via e- mail, typically within 30 days of receiving the plan, either concurring that the plan is adequate or requesting additional information. A concurrence e-mail from the appropriate USFWS Field Office will fulfill approval requirements. The Plan materials should consist of: 1) a combination of posters and pamphlets (see Poster Information section below); and 2) verbal educational instructions to construction personnel by supervisory or management personnel before any clearing/land alteration activities are initiated (see Pre -Construction Activities and During Construction Activities sections below). POSTER INFORMATION Posters with the following information shall be placed at strategic locations on the construction site and along any proposed access roads (a final poster for Plan compliance, to be printed on I I" x 17" or larger paper and laminated, is attached): DESCRIPTION: The eastern indigo snake is one of the largest non -venomous snakes in North America, with individuals often reaching up to 8 feet in length. They derive their name from the glossy, blue -black color of their scales above and uniformly slate blue below. Frequently, they have orange to coral reddish coloration in the throat area, yet some specimens have been reported to only have cream coloration on the throat. These snakes are not typically aggressive and will attempt to crawl away when disturbed. Though indigo snakes rarely bite, they should NOT be handled. SIMILAR SNAKES: The black racer is the only other solid black snake resembling the eastern indigo snake. However, black racers have a white or cream chin, thinner bodies, and WILL BITE if handled. LIFE HISTORY: The eastern indigo snake occurs in a wide variety of terrestrial habitat types throughout Florida. Although they have a preference for uplands, they also utilize some wetlands and agricultural areas. Eastern indigo snakes will often seek shelter inside gopher tortoise burrows and other below- and above -ground refugia, such as other animal burrows, stumps, roots, and debris piles. Females may lay from 4 - 12 white eggs as early as April through June, with young hatching in late July through October. PROTECTION UNDER FEDERAL AND STATE LAW: The eastern indigo snake is classified as a Threatened species by both the USFWS and the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission. "Taking" of eastern indigo snakes is prohibited by the Endangered Species Act without a permit. "Take" is defined by the USFWS as an attempt to kill, harm, harass, pursue, hunt, shoot, wound, trap, capture, collect, or engage in any such conduct. Penalties include a maximum fine of $25,000 for civil violations and up to $50,000 and/or imprisonment for criminal offenses, if convicted. Only individuals currently authorized through an issued Incidental Take Statement in association with a USFWS Biological Opinion, or by a Section 10(a)(1)(A) permit issued by the USFWS, to handle an eastern indigo snake are allowed to do so. IF YOU SEE A LIVE EASTERN INDIGO SNAKE ON THE SITE: • Cease clearing activities and allow the live eastern indigo snake sufficient time to move away from the site without interference; • Personnel must NOT attempt to touch or handle snake due to protected status. • Take photographs of the snake, if possible, for identification and documentation purposes. • Immediately notify supervisor or the applicant's designated agent, and the appropriate USFWS office, with the location information and condition of the snake. • If the snake is located in a vicinity where continuation of the clearing or construction activities will cause harm to the snake, the activities must halt until such time that a representative of the USFWS returns the call (within one day) with further guidance as to when activities may resume. IF YOU SEE A DEAD EASTERN INDIGO SNAKE ON THE SITE: • Cease clearing activities and immediately notify supervisor or the applicant's designated agent, and the appropriate USFWS office, with the location information and condition of the snake. • Take photographs of the snake, if possible, for identification and documentation purposes. • Thoroughly soak the dead snake in water and then freeze the specimen. The appropriate wildlife agency will retrieve the dead snake. Telephone numbers of USFWS Florida Field Offices to be contacted if a live or dead eastern indigo snake is encountered: North Florida Field Office — (904) 731-3336 Panama City Field Office — (850) 769-0552 South Florida Field Office — (772) 562-3909 PA PRE -CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES 1. The applicant or designated agent will post educational posters in the construction office and throughout the construction site, including any access roads. The posters must be clearly visible to all construction staff. A sample poster is attached. 2. Prior to the onset of construction activities, the applicant/designated agent will conduct a meeting with all construction staff (annually for multi -year projects) to discuss identification of the snake, its protected status, what to do if a snake is observed within the project area, and applicable penalties that may be imposed if state and/or federal regulations are violated. An educational brochure including color photographs of the snake will be given to each staff member in attendance and additional copies will be provided to the construction superintendent to make available in the onsite construction office (a final brochure for Plan compliance, to be printed double -sided on 8.5" x 11" paper and then properly folded, is attached). Photos of eastern indigo snakes may be accessed on USFWS and/or FWC websites. 3. Construction staff will be informed that in the event that an eastern indigo snake (live or dead) is observed on the project site during construction activities, all such activities are to cease until the established procedures are implemented according to the Plan, which includes notification of the appropriate USFWS Field Office. The contact information for the USFWS is provided on the referenced posters and brochures. DURING CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES 1. During initial site clearing activities, an onsite observer may be utilized to determine whether habitat conditions suggest a reasonable probability of an eastern indigo snake sighting (example: discovery of snake sheds, tracks, lots of refugia and cavities present in the area of clearing activities, and presence of gopher tortoises and burrows). 2. If an eastern indigo snake is discovered during gopher tortoise relocation activities (i.e. burrow excavation), the USFWS shall be contacted within one business day to obtain further guidance which may result in further project consultation. 3. Periodically during construction activities, the applicant's designated agent should visit the project area to observe the condition of the posters and Plan materials, and replace them as needed. Construction personnel should be reminded of the instructions (above) as to what is expected if any eastern indigo snakes are seen. POST CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES Whether or not eastern indigo snakes are observed during construction activities, a monitoring report should be submitted to the appropriate USFWS Field Office within 60 days of project completion. The report can be sent electronically to the appropriate USFWS e-mail address listed on page one of this Plan. From: Hitt, Heather To: Sarah Morales Cc: Jackson Reaoan Subject: Re: [EXTERNAL] RE: Naples Park North Tower 2018-TA-0461 (637639) Date: Tuesday, September 04, 2018 1:16:22 PM Hi Sarah, Based on the results of the survey (no cavities or FBB roosts identified) there is no further consultation necessary. Thanks, Heather Hitt Fish and Wildlife Biologist US Fish and Wildlife Service 1339 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 Phone: 772-469-4267 Fax: 772-562-4288 Email: heather_hittn,fws.gov NOTE: This email correspondence and any attachments to and from this sender is subject to the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) and may be disclosed to third parties. On Tue, Sep 4, 2018 at 11:40 AM, Sarah Morales <S.Morales&trileaf.com> wrote: Thank you, Heather! Do you know about when a response may be expected? Thanks, Sarah N. Morales Senior Project Manager Health and Safety Officer Licensed Mold Assessor MRSA# 665 %$jFTRILEAF ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING 1051 Winderley Place, Suite 201 AFFIDAVIT OF COMPLIANCE I hereby certify that pursuant to Ordinance 2004-41, of the Collier County Land Development Code, I did cause the attached newspaper advertisement to appear and I did give notice by mail to the following property owners and/or condominium and civic associations whose members may be affected by the proposed land use changes of an application request for a rezoning, PUD amendment, or conditional use, at least 15 days prior to the scheduled Neighborhood Information Meeting. For the purposes of this requirement, the names and addresses of property owners shall be deemed those appearing on the latest tax rolls of Collier County and any other persons or entities who have made a formal request of the county to be notified. The said notice contained the laymen's description of the site property of proposed change and the date, time, and place of a Neighborhood Information Meeting. Per the attached letters, property owner's list, and copy of newspaper hereby made a part of this Affidavit of Compliance '1v `60, � , r�/� (Signature of Applicant) State of Florida County of Collier isement which are The foregoing Affidavit of compliance was acknowledged before me this /&*daY of 20A0 by (, who is personally know^ mP ^r who has produced (Signature of otary Public) Printed Name of Notary G:\NIM Procedures/Affidavit Of Compliance - NIM Oct2010.Doc as identification. 00- iaW te of Florida k G 285454 X 22 r N�-a 4Dj� PARTCAETHEUSATO AYNETWOR Published Daily Naples, FL 34110 LAW OFFICE OF MATTANIAH S JAHN PA 935 MAIN ST #D1 SAFETY HARBOR, FL 34695 Affidavit of Publication STATE OF WISCONSIN COUNTY OF BROWN Before the undersigned they serve as the authority, personally appeared who on oath says that they serve as legal clerk of the Naples Daily News, a daily newspaper published at Naples, in Collier County, Florida; distributed in Collier and Lee counties of Florida; that the attached copy of the advertising was published in said newspaper on dates listed. Affiant further says that the said Naples Daily News is a newspaper published at Naples, in said Collier County, Florida, and that the said newspaper has heretofore been continuously published in said Collier County, Florida; distributed in Collier and Lee counties of Florida, each day and has been entered as second class mail matter at the post office in Naples, in said Collier County, Florida , for a period of one year next preceding the first publication of the attached copy of advertisement and affiant further says that he has neither paid nor promised any person, or corporation any discount, rebate, commission or refund for the purpose of securing this advertisement for publication in the said newspaper. 11 /8/2020 Subscribed and sworn to before on November Sth, 2020: _ Yyk vyve.:.l.rx-.j—_3 Notary, State of WI, County of Brown TAHA MONDLOCH Notary Public State of Wisconsin My commission expires: August 6, 2021 Publication Cost: S1.404.26 Ad No GC10529778 Customer No: 346954 PO#: NEIGHBORHOOD INFO MEETING NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING The public is invited to attend a neighborhood meeting held by Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. of the Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, P.A., representing Capital Telecom Holdings II, LLC on: Monday, November 23, 2020 at 5:30p.m. at Springhill Suites, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117 The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28th Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. Capital is requesting Collier County to consider a Conditional Use to allow a communications tower on lands zoned Rural Agricultural (A) within the Mobile Home Overlay (MHO) and designated Rural Fringe Mixed Use -Sending Lands within the Natural Resource Protection Area Overlay and North Belle Meade Overlay in the Collier County Growth Management Plan. The site of the tower is approximately .93 acres of impervious coverage, consisting of 3 parcels, located on the east side of the north -south extension of Benton Road in Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. WE VALUE YOUR INPUT Business and property owners, residents and visitors are welcome to attend the presentation and discuss the project with Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. and Collier County staff. You may also attend remotely using Zoom. If you would like to participate remotely, please contact Vicki Clark for the link information. If you are unable to attend this meeting in person or by Zoom, but have questions or comments, they can be directed by mail, phone, or e-mail to: Vicki Clark, Planner Mattaniah S. Jahn, P.A. 935 Main Street, Suite DI Safety Harbor, FL 34695 727-773-2221 ND-60052977a.01 vc1ark @ the1awrnpowered,coin NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING ADVERTISEMENT Newspaper Advertisement Layout: Ad must be at least 1/4 page and no less than 12-point type, except the county staff contact information, which may be less as long as it is clearly legible: NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING The public is invited to attend a neighborhood meeting held by Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. of the Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, P.A., representing Capital Telecom Holdings II, LLC on: Monday, November 23, 2020 at 5:30p.m. at Springhill Suites, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117 The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. Capital is requesting Collier County to consider a Conditional Use to allow a communications tower on lands zoned Rural Agricultural (A) within the Mobile Home Overlay (MHO) and designated Rural Fringe Mixed Use -Sending Lands within the Natural Resource Protection Area Overlay and North Belle Meade Overlay in the Collier County Growth Management Plan. The site of the tower is approximately .93 acres of impervious coverage, consisting of 3 parcels, located on the east side of the north -south extension of Benton Road in Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. WE VALUE YOUR INPUT Business and property owners, residents and visitors are welcome to attend the presentation and discuss the project with Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. and Collier County staff. You may also attend remotely using Zoom. If you would like to participate remotely, please contact Vicki Clark for the link information. If you are unable to attend this meeting in person or by Zoom, but have questions or comments, they can be directed by mail, phone, or e-mail to: Vicki Clark, Planner Mattaniah S. Jahn, P.A. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 727-773-2221 vclark@thelawmpowered.com Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 11-23-2020 Mattaniah Jahn: Good evening, everyone. Can you all hear me? Alright. Alright, good evening everyone, I am Mattaniah Jahn and I represent Capital Telecom. I have Tom Waniewski with Capital Telecom here today. This is Isachi Halphen. She is helping me with the display today. We are doing a hybrid format community meeting because of COVID. And, in the back is Laura DeJohn. She is the Planner with Collier County. She is here to answer any questions about the process and also to just keep an eye on things. The way this is going to work is I am going to give a short presentation and then we are going to take turns asking questions. So, we will work our way through the room, if anyone has questions and then we will work our way through Zoom. We will go one question at a time and then to the next person. Laura, do you have any introductions from the County's end? Laura DeJohn: Sure. Good evening everyone all I ask is that you realize this meeting is recorded because this recording of the neighborhood meeting is a requirement for the applicant to have a meeting and the recording becomes available to the decision makers who are going to decide this item. So, when asking a question, please state your name and ask your question. It's for the record keeping purposes. Okay? Thank you. Unknown voice: I've got a question. Who are the decision makers? Ms. DeJohn: So, if you state your name and then ask the question, I will be glad to answer it. Henry Lowry: I wanted to know who are the decision makers making this decision? Ms. DeJohn: So, what we are here for tonight is called a Conditional Use application. The Conditional Use application can take one of two different tracks and that has not been determined yet. One is to go to the Hearing Examiner, the Collier County Hearing Examiner. Everyone within 1000 feet of the property gets a letter when that Hearing Examiner hearing is going to be. It is not scheduled yet and a sign goes up on the property when that meeting is scheduled. It could alternatively go to the Planning Commission and the Board of County Commissioners. Again, it has not been determined yet and once it is, those letters go to everyone within 1000 feet announcing the meeting and a sign goes up on the property. Ms. Jahn: No hearing or decisions made today by Hearing Examiner or Board of County Commissioners. Reintroduced herself. Project called Benton Road Relocation and Naples Park. Izzy to proceed I slide. 225" Tall Guyed Style Communication Tower, located at the western end of Benton Road. No address assigned yet, so the Parcel number is 32-63-47-2-0009. Green marker on screen in white circle. Alpine existing tower is yellow marker. Verizon is currently on that tower and they are relocating to the new tower. Next slide. Closer view showing New Benton Road tower that Capital will construct. Alpine is not part of the existing tower or this application and from my understanding it will stay in place. Green marker is Capital Telecoms tower in Southwest corner of the main parcel it is located on. There are 3 parcels surrounded by green box. Benton Road was brought to a previous Community Meeting and it was modified and details about that will be later in the presentation. Tower design and location of the tower have not changed. Next slide. Tower will be galvanized gray. Next slide. Designed to hold 4 carriers with Verizon being the anchor carrier. This tower is being constructed for them and the remaining 3 spaces will be Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 11-23-2020 available to the open market at market rates. Next slide. Main thing changed since last time is that the driveway has been relocated and there has been a lot of research on Benton Road. One of the things brought up was that Benton Road was a private road so Capital researched the title on it. There were also concerns about the North/South portion of Benton Road being sandy and that Capital's construction vehicles and maintenance vehicles would damage that road. This is the result of our research. The back end of Benton Road running from 28th Avenue on the right-hand side, North along Woodland Estates Road and then West along Benton Road. Everything "staffed" is an easement along Benton Road and has been publicly recorded. The tower is located in the lower right-hand side. Correction, lower left-hand side. Someone asked a question — no name — Ms. Jahn asked them to wait but he proceeded and asked if they would be able to see the slides after. Ms. Jahn explained that it would be part of the record and they could ask for a copy. Ms. Jahn asked him not to get Ms. Halphen in the picture. Next slide. Next slide. 2 red spots on this map with 2 green arrows. Those are breaks in the easements that existed as of our last Community Meeting. So, in those two spaces, there was no easement for anyone to pass over. On the Eastern side there was an easement for parcels immediately around that parcel on the right-hand side but the one to the West did not have an easement at all. There was just a gap. Since that time, Capital has obtained easements for passage over those. Those will be included in the application file as well. Now the road is unbroken from the bridge all the way to the end of the road. What you don't see here is there is additional linework showing a connection, so the road legally exists all the way down at least to the old location. Ms. Jahn asked someone to hold their question again. Next slide. Next slide. Blue line proceeding from the tower West with an arrow. That was the original driveway. In the last Community Meeting when we were all together and discussing this, there were concerns that the North/South portion of Benton Road was sandy and would not be able to support pickup trucks or construction equipment. Capital has since revised the design of access to the East/West portion of Benton Road. Since it is an issue and a concern for the neighbors, we know we can't go away but at the very least we can revise the driveway and remove that concern. Next slide. (Someone starts talking about the fact that Ms. Jahn said, "continuous from the bridge". Ms. Jahn asks him to wait.) Ms. Jahn: The new driveway is shown by the green line going from compound North to Benton Road. Again, this hashed line is all Benton Road. The North/South portion is Woodlands Estates and Same individual asks another question. Ms. Jahn asks him to please hold his question once again. Ms. Jahn: We are trying to get a recording and if we have multiple people talking at the same time, things will not get recorded. Next slide. Next slide. Now there is legal access from the Communication Tower all the way back to the bridge, which is a public bridge. Additionally, the road itself has been repaired so that it has been legally connected so that way there is legal access Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 11-23-2020 for everyone as they proceed along this road. Next slide. This shows the layout of the project now with the revised driveway. In the lower left-hand corner is the original parent parcel that the tower was proposed on. It has not changed its location, it meets all the Code required setbacks, it has a fall zone radius so that it will be completely contained on the parent parcel in the event of a failure, and you will notice hash marks all over the parcel where the tower will not be. It is going to be covered with a native preservation preserve. So, it will never be able to be developed as anything other than the tower so long as the tower is on there. There will be one use and that will be it. The driveway will go East onto neighboring property owned by Capital's landlord, Tafara Lodge, and then proceed North up to Benton Road. Next slide. This is just an extra from the Site Plan Sheet showing the exact same thing. Since there isn't a picture on there, it is a little easier to see where the preserve will be. Again, it is this hashed area and again you can see the driveway proceeding East and then North up to Benton Road. Next slide. This is the elevation view of the tower from the plans on file. Again, Verizon will be located at the top. Next slide. Once this presentation is finished, and we answer your questions, Staff will continue to review the application. Next slide. There is a Conditional Use application that is on file with Collier County. This Community Meeting's question and answer portion is part of that process. Next slide. County Staff will continue their review of the plans on file and then they will ultimately issue a Staff Report. That Staff Report will go to either the Hearing Examiner or the Planning Commission depending on which route is selected by the County and a public hearing will be set. When a public hearing is set, public notice will be sent out to neighboring property owners like this Community Meeting and I believe a sign is placed on the property. And, a notice is put in the newspaper. You'll be able to participate and speak at the hearing, whether it is one or multiple hearings, depending on the track in order to express your thoughts. Next slide. Ms. DeJohn's contact information is shown as the current County Planner assigned to this. I believe the County will be assigning a new Planner in the near future. My contact information is below and my business cards are out front if anyone needs to contact me for more information, I am more than happy to give it to them. That completes my presentation. Ms. Jahn: We are now going to move into question and answer. We are basically going to move around the room for anyone who has questions. We will answer one question at a time and then we will move on to the next and work around way around. That way we can get you on with your night. Please state your name before you speak. Donald Harring: I live at the end of Benton Road before it makes the turn. I am the furthest Western property along the straight part of Benton Road. When Norman was getting ready to build that tower, unable to figure out what he says for a bit, I got quite familiar with Norman and he told me the process he was going through in order to build that tower. He said in order to get permitting to build the tower he had to remove the old easements from the property because by law the tower could not fall across any existing easements but Mr. Mataige who was a real estate person and owned 20 acres on the Southern part of the tower property would have butted right up against him. In order for Mataige to sell the property, he talked to Norman about leaving that easement there long enough for him to sell the property. So, that easement was the only easement not removed for the permitting process. The road itself was put in by my sister Marlene and her husband John Boyd. Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 11-23-2020 They did it for a fellow by the name of Bill Lee who wanted to build a tropical fruit orchard just South of where the Community ended. There was a chain link fence going across there South of where Woodland Estates community exists so it would be approximately a mile and a quarter South of Benton Road. He put the thing in there and they had a fellow by the name of Lance Whitten came in and put that road in well that is what they called it but it was a driveway. The bulldozer never got permission to do so and never pulled a permit to do so. And then after the building was there for about a year and a half, all the animals were eating his tropical fruit and he bailed out and is no longer there. So that easement was left there for that real estate person and should have been removed for the permitting process. That tower cannot fall across that easement. Ms. Jahn: Thank you for sharing that. You are talking about the North/South portion of Benton Road. Mr. Harring: Starting at the North end of that where it makes the turn going South and going down approximately 1/2 mile. Ms. Jahn: Izzy would you please back up to the road map? So, this is the road portion? Mr. Harring: My house was on that corner just North of it and my sister and her husband were on the other side of Benton Road, on the South side of Benton Road. They had that first piece of property going South. It is now owned by this lady. Ms. Jahn: So, thank you again for sharing that. The way that this tower is cited, and the way it is designed, it would not fall across any public easements or even leave the parent parcel. It would be completely contained. It uses something called fall zone technology which basically means there is a predesigned crumple point which allows it to fall over on itself and this is proven technology that has been used by the tower industry for at least 20 years. As far as the separation, to the North and the East, you have multiple times tower height. I don't have the exact number handy. I can look it up real quick. As far as to the South and the West, the fall zone radius is shorter than the distance to the edge of the property. The other thing to keep in mind is that the parcels to the South of the one we are on are also owned by Tafara Lodge, so they are basically under the same ownership. Let me see if someone else has a question. Mr. Harring: One more thing about the easement. The tower that Alpine built is I believe 1320' tall. Al Baxa: 1022' Ms. Jahn: I am sorry what is your name? Mr. Baxa: I'm Al Baxa. Mr. Harring: So, if that falls, it still can almost reach across that piece of property. That first piece of property. Ms. Jahn: I do not know how the Alpine Tower is designed, what its engineering requirements are or what happened back in zoning when it was approved. What I can tell you is that the tower that Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 11-23-2020 Capital is proposing meets and exceeds the Code requirements and also meets and exceeds the Florida Building Code requirement and that is the modern 2017 Florida Building Code. Thank you so much again. Sir, you have a question? Kenny Lowry: Yes, my first question is what is your plan on that road because when they first put that other tower in, people made an agreement that they people along that road would maintain that road and it has never been done. That has never been done. It is all broken. What is your plan for Benton Road? Ms. Jahn: As far as the access itself goes, the initial construction, Capital would repair any damage that were caused by the construction process. Capital would be willing to agree to have that actually stated on the face of the zoning approval so that way there is County enforcement if you felt it was necessary. As far as maintenance goes, the amount of traffic that goes down that road is usually a pickup truck per month per carrier. Candidly, the towers are so automated now that if the diagnostics come back okay it can sometimes be 2 or 3 months in between trips. So, the amount of traffic you see from a modern communication tower is less than a single-family home. Izzy if you would proceed a slide. If you look again, you will see that this entire parcel, which today could legally be constructed as a house under the Code, is being taken up by the preserve area. So, there will be no additional traffic. So, the potential traffic which could be put on Benton Road today will be reduced from a single-family home to that one pickup truck per carrier. Mr. Lowry: You are saying preserve. A ten -foot -high barb wire fence so no animals will be able to get in or out? Ms. Jahn: No, the point of the preserve is actually to serve as a native habitat so it will continue to be fenced I believe by a barbed wire fence around the perimeter. But, as far as fencing of the preserve itself, there wouldn't be additional fencing. The County code does require it to be maintained so that things like exotic vegetation, things like Brazilian peppers, have to be kept out of it. So, it will actually be kept in a better state than it currently is as unmanaged land. Mr. Lowry: You said no animals could come and go. It is just whatever is in there when you construct it. Ms. Jahn: Again, animals can and would be able to enter and exit the preserve. Mr. Lowry: Bears, panthers, deer and what about the lighting? Is there going to be a lighting generator that kicks on and off all the time like at the other tower? Ms. Jahn: So, this tower will be designed with red lights that point up because the FAA requires it. It's the minimum amount necessary to meet the FAA safety regulations. They are not pointed down. As far as generators go, it's possible that Verizon would place a generator on their carrier location at the base with the equipment. That will have to meet the County noise regulations and again, it is separated from neighboring property owners. The nearest house is a multiple of tower height so not only is it going to be compliant with the noise ordinance, which establishes the Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 11-23-2020 requirements for the house that the property that is the next lot over, it's going to be very far away just due to the physical layout. Mr. Lowry: Okay, because we have a pair of owls that have been around there for years and years you know. Ms. Jahn: Before I answer that, does anyone else in the room have questions? Ms. Shirley Kager: Why put a tower there in the first place when Verizon already has a dish upon the other tower? Ms. Jahn: So, Verizon is in the process of upgrading their antennas and their deployments throughout the state of Florida and they need a new tower to support those new larger antennas. Ms. Kager: So, they can't just attach them to the other tower? They need to go ahead and build a new one? Ms. Jahn: That is correct. Alright, one moment Sir. I believe you have a question Sir. Were you raising your hand? Dana Alvarez: I am going to translate for him what he would like to say. He was saying like you were saying earlier. The road if it has any problems, I know you guys aren't fixing it, we are the ones fixing it. We are the machines. We are the ones who have to put in the gas. Our machine is broken right now and no gives us anything. We do it out of our pocket. You say that when something breaks it gets dumped in. We have an RV. She has an RV on her property. It is hard when there are people that go back there to fix it but you say to call them when we have an issue. We are not going to go and call people because I have a life. What am I going to call the County and it is a pain in the butt to call when? So, I do my own stuff. My pay my own diesel, I fix my own machine. I do that stuff myself. So, when you guys start to build it, the road gets messed up because a truck will eventually, he is a truck driver, they do break the road. So, I'm asking you, you guys say when something break or when something is happening, but I am not going to be calling you. When those go to build it, they are going to mess up the road. The road gets messed up eventually all the time. Its already as bad as it is right now. Ms. Jahn: Tom, do you want to answer that? Tom Waniewski: Yes, my name is Tom Waniewski with Capital Telecom. First of all, the contractors cannot close out until that site is completely clean, including the road. So, the contractor will leave the site or the road in any disrepair. We wouldn't pay them if that were the case. If there are things we would have to do with the County in order to get our CO, so we could not leave that site without that road being pristine before we left. And then, after we leave, as stated, it is only a truck or SW about once a month. So, I completely understand what you are saying, but there will be contractors. We have other sites where people expressed their concern about silt fences or things like that and we take care of everything at that time. So, we will make sure that you have any contact information for the contractor and you will see them while they are there on site. Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 11-23-2020 Ms. Jahn: And, I am sure that Tom will be happy to take down your contact information and stay in contact with you through the construction process should this be approved. Alright, so I am going to have Mr. Herring wait and take Mr. Baxa. Mr. Baxa: I am here to state there is capacity on the current tower. We could do any upgrades Verizon needs to do. They have never contacted us during any of this. The tower does have capacity for any upgrade they would need. Ms. Jahn: Okay, well thank you for stating that. I appreciate that you made that. Mr. Harring: When they do build this tower and they have all these antennas on there, is Verizon going to be the only user of the tower? Every antenna on that tower will be transmitting for Verizon? Or will they be subletting space on that tower for other entities that come in and if so, those other entities have to have access to that tower, which means that traffic will be coming in also. Ms. Jahn: Okay, so thank you for that question. Izzy would you please get us the elevation sheet. I'm afraid for the recording that the background conversation will need to be held down, otherwise the recording will not be clear. So, when we look at the elevation of this tower, it is designed for up to 4 users to use it. The initial user will be Verizon and they will be located at the top because they are the ones who need the tower. The additional spots will be made available for collocation by say AT&T or Dish Network. Sir, when you take that picture please ensure you do not get Ms. Halphen in the picture. So, the number that I gave you when I said you were talking per carrier, per month, the maximum is based on this. So, let's say it was fully leased out, right? That's 4 pickups based on those carriers and compare that to a single-family home, that may have a trip every day or every other day, looking at 30-60 trips a month as opposed to possibly 4. Let me just see if the room has other questions. Cannot make out this gentleman's name: When he said they are going to clean the whole site up; does that mean you are going to level the whole thing? Ms. Jahn: So, what he meant is they are going to clean up the work area. The preserve area will not be modified other than to remove invasive, exotic plants. So, areas such as the base of the tower, the access driveway and also making sure that Benton Road, if there is any damage to it, is repaired. Same gentleman: Is anyone else allowed to put a tower there? And, I have a question for her. Have they done TDR's on that? Ms. DeJohn: Transfer Development Rights is a system for residential use so I'm not aware of any severance of any development rights off of the property. It is a voluntary program and I am not aware that they severed any rights to the property nor would they be receiving development rights for any residential use. Ms. Jahn: I will be happy to touch on that. I was involved with this project back to its pre - application in 2018. When the county staff performed their initial research on the property, they Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 11-23-2020 were not able to find any severance of developmental rights either and we are not receiving any development rights. This is just talking in terms of what can be legally be built in this case is a public hearing conditional use process. To answer your other question, if somebody else were to want to construct a tower out here, they would have to come back through the conditional use process. And, go through public hearing with neighborhood meetings and hand out public notice. Same gentleman: So, they couldn't build an oil well or fracking thing right there? Ms. Jahn: I'm not aware of any oil rights out there. It's not Capitals intent to place a well out there. There wouldn't be physical space on the parcel to do that. And, I'm not aware of the landlord having an intent of putting a well. Same gentleman: So, things won't change midstream they will not change and put a well in instead. Ms. Jahn: That would require, that is going back to Laura DeJohn. Ms. DeJohn: So, as part of this conditional use process, they are applying for this specific use with that specific site plan. So, the things like the preserve, the position of the tower, the driveway, all being formally considered and if their formally approved then that site plan must be adhered to. There wouldn't be any other changes or activities... Same gentleman: Have they also gotten any litigation on endangered species on that? Ms. Jahn: They have performed a NEPA review. The NEPA came back that there wouldn't be an environmental impact. Part of their plan is that if any bats are found in the area there are provisions to add bat houses but there is no impact shown to be had. There is no impact on listed species to protect their safety. Same gentleman: Not even the signal from Verizon on the bees? Or anything like that? Ms. Jahn: I am going to answer this question and then I need to move on. Same gentleman: Okay. That is my last question. Ms. Jahn: There is no evidence that our emissions cause that. What also is going on is that there is federal regulations so the County cannot consider any of that information either. Now, Mr. Herring, you had a question. Mr. Harring: Yes, two things. Because of the situation with our electric out there, our electric is out sometimes a day, a week and our electric has to sometimes be supplied by a generator and they have to be supplied by fuel trucks bringing fuel to those generators by the people who service the generators. You said one pickup truck, now you have a support team to keep that tower going. You said something about oil. When "Merin Tire" (18:03) acquired this from Collier County, he sold mineral rights underneath the building that powered part of that cell. I have an abstract. It's about that thick. Sheet after sheet of oil companies buying up mineral rights. They can come in and they can put a road on your property and build whatever infrastructure is needed in order to remove oil and restore it. But they still have access to your property. Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 11-23-2020 Ms. Jahn: So, just to circle back up, I know there is a history of oil rights. That has nothing to do with Capital Telecom and they cannot, they would have to go back through the public hearing process if the property owner wanted to put some type of a well on the property. If there is some other entity that has rights or has something protected under state law, that is a completely different question that goes back in the history books. As far as serving the tower site, what I imagine you would likely see, and I am going to have Tom step in on this. Mr. Waniewski: Tom Waniewski again with Capital. It is a propane generator. There are no fuel tanks on the property. There are no chemicals on site. Rambling from multiple people Mr. Waniewski: Understood. It is not like they are coming out once a week to fill these diesel generators, it's propane. And, we will obviously be installing new service to the tower and the site is going to need that so I'm not sure what Florida Power would do but I would hope that they would not be coming out on a consistent basis. Ms. Jahn: Alright, I'm going to hold your question and take this gentleman's question here. Sir, please state your name before asking your question. Bobby Mireli: My question is do you feel like this tower will impact our property values negatively or positively? Ms. Jahn: Having worked around the state, I have worked on probably a couple hundred tower projects since 2013. No, there is not going to be any effect up or down and that just goes back to the hard numbers. I've worked with a lot of property appraisal reports. At the end of the day, when people hear about these projects, they are something that, since it is changed, people do worry about that. But, in reality there are a very boring piece of essential infrastructure. So, and again, when you look at the property values around communication towers, they don't go down or particularly up because up in the Pan Handle they worry that a communication tower will come in and raise their property values sky high and at the end of the day it just leaves things where they are. Next question. Mr. Mireli: He brought up a point that they have to run electric to there. Are they going to be using existing poles or will they have to put in bigger poles, larger electric? Ms. Jahn: So that goes back to FP&L. At the end of the day, the type of service that is provided to a communication tower isn't particularly extraordinary. FP&L may come out and say oh we need to do maintenance anyways and so we are going to replace these poles and put new ones in or they might not. That is a decision that their engineers will have to make when they start performing the load calculations but they don't require anything like a high voltage line or anything like that, if that is what you are asking. Mr. Mireli: I was hoping that we could all get hooked up to theirs and then it wouldn't go out. Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 11-23-2020 Ms. Jahn: Again, it goes back to FP&L and whether they decide the current poles can support the tower or whether they will need to perform upgrades. And, what they feel on the maintenance cycle of power lines anyways. So, those are just questions unfortunately I cannot answer for you. Mr. Harring, do you have a question? Mr. Harring: I have a thing pertaining to FP&L's power poles. The last fire we had come to 3800 acres and it took them most of the poles in our neighborhood. A lot of the power lines that are out there are new and recently replaced. FP&L had to come out and replace like 3 or 4 poles on your property, alone? So, they replaced dozens of poles out there plus the power lines. So, it is all new, newly done. Ms. Jahn: Thank you for sharing that. Sir, you have a question. Mr. Mireli: When you were talking about the new location of the driveway, I believe you said you can't go away but we could reroute. So, does that mean you are already in the neighborhood? You are already here? I think I heard that. Ms. Jahn: No. What I'm saying is that Capital is proceeding with this project because Verizon continues to have the need in the area. So, in that respect, a tower is going to be needed regardless. So, that is why I can't go away. I have to come back and continue with this application. Sir, you have a question. Mr. Baxa: Once again I would like to state that the new tower is not needed because there is plenty of capacity on the existing tower. Ms. Jahn: Again, thank you for sharing your thoughts on that. Next question. Dana: I'm Dana and I will be translating for him. He says for you guys not to put that there, how many signatures from all the neighbors do you need for you guys not to do that there? Ms. Jahn: So, as far as that goes that is not how zoning works. Zoning is not a popularity contest. It's a question of law. So, I don't have a number for you. Dana: He wants me to ask you, I already told him but, he wants to know that it has no radiation effect towards, because we have kids that live out there. Ms. Jahn: Correct. When you do look at, as far as that works, the energy that comes off of a cell tower is less than your average fluorescent light panel that is above your head in an office. Or less than that cell phone that you might keep on your person. Or less than your WiFi router. The energy that you see from that is far less. That is why the federal communications commission regulates that and they require Verizon to stay in compliance. Mr. Mireli?: Does this, this is a question for her again, she said there was no way to stop this, but does this allow other zoning projects in this area once this zoning is passed? (Mumbling) Oil wells, whatever. Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 11-23-2020 Ms. DeJohn: No, each application is on its own merit. So, by definition, the conditional use is conditional to that situation and that property and that site plan. Mr. Mireli?: But, what I am saying is once they put that in there, does that allow other people then to say well now that we've gotten that, so why can't we have this? Ms. DeJohn: The answer is no. Mr. Mireli?: It is industrial you know? It says residential area, farm area, agricultural area. Ms. DeJohn: The framework of zoning has a list of permanent uses and then a list of conditional uses. So, every zoning district has been given permitted uses, where a home is permitted. A tower is a conditional use. It is just the way it is drawn up. Mr. Mireli?: And you are with? Ms. DeJohn: I am with Collier County. I'm writing the staff reviews... Mr. Mireli?: What part of Collier County? Ms. DeJohn: Growth Management. Mr. Mireli?: So, as a person with Growth Management, do you have a 7-year plan that we can look at and see what you are doing in this area? Ms. DeJohn: There is actually a 20-year plan called the Growth Management Plan. That is available online yes. Mr. Mireli?: I have tried to get that and I have never been able to get that. Ms. DeJohn: Well, my contact information was up there. You can contact me and I'll connect you to the Growth Management Plan. I'll give you a heads up, it's a lengthy document. Mr. Mireli?: I just want to see what you have drawn up for that area right in this picture. Ms. DeJohn: There is a whole map Mr. Mireli?: You know, any parks, any preserves. Thank you. Ms. Jahn: Thank you. Mr. Herring, do you have a question? Mr. Harring: 2 things. When they started the reworking of the South Collier Alley park, they call this South Belmeade and they decided to remove people from the area in order to turn that into a reservation. Then they classified our area as North Belmeade. Then they told us that it was restrictions on how much land we could clear in order to put in a house, how many trees we could, basically what would have to remain standing in order to keep it as basically it is a sanctuary for the wildlife. That is what that North Belmeade project was. It has limited us to what we can do. If you're a cattle person and own a ranch you can remove almost all the trees on that property. If you are homeowner, you are restricted to adhering to the area around where you putting your house Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 11-23-2020 and you are limited to what you can do. So, there are 2 things there. One question I have is will you take a show of hands on who wants it and who doesn't, before you leave? A count? Ms. Jahn: Let me circle back. So, as far as coverage and allowable uses, there is a lot of that area which is preserve for native vegetation and as a wildlife preserve. This is on land that is disturbed that is serving other properties in the area. So, that is why this project is here. As far as whether you want to raise hands, you can do it, but at the end of the day, I will be presenting the law to the County for them to consider. Mr. Mireli?: Last question. I have Verizon. Ever since Hurricane Irma, it has sucked. Is this going to help their transmission? Ms. Jahn: That is the point! Mr. Mireli?: Ever since the hurricane I have had a very bad... Unknown female: mumbles Ms. Jahn: That is the point. To modernize Verizon's... Unknown female: Mumbling. What we have here is someone who went and bought a lot of land. They can't make a dime off of it. Now he's got this here idea that he is going to put a radio tower up to help pay for his property. We don't need it. We just got one a little over 4 miles away. This is totally unnecessary. This is somebody's poor business planning. And, they are coming to you, wanting you to cover for them. No, it don't work that way. We are a community. You don't live out here. You don't associate with us. We are just nothing. It don't work that way. Ms. Jahn: Thank you for sharing your thoughts on that. Unknown female: It's not my thoughts. It's just the way it is. Ms. Jahn: As far as the need for this tower, that is based on Verizon's engineering need. Unknown female: And, I already own swamp land here. Everyone else is in the same way. Ms. Jahn: I have questions, so we need to go back to taking turns. This gentleman has a question. Mr. Harring: I would like to ask Allen a question. Would you be willing to (mumbling). Mr. Baxa: I'm Chief Engineer of Alpine Broadcasting. I'm also the manager of Alpine Tower who owns the tower. Verizon has never approached us about increasing their capacity on our tower. Verizon wants to build the tower so they can make money to pay for their own site. As opposed to paying us rent on our site. Now, our tower has all the capacity that is needed for anything Verizon wants to do, or any other carrier. Ms. Jahn: Okay. Thank you for your thoughts on that and I appreciate that those are your thoughts. Mr. Baxa: It is not thoughts. It is fact. Neighborhood Information Meeting — Audio Summary Capital — Naples Park 11-23-2020 Ms. Jahn: But what I have on record disagrees with that in the application file. And, I understand that is your thoughts and I'm sure there will be further discussion on that. But, for today, I think that you have clearly made your point. Okay, does anyone have any other questions before I let you go back home? Mr. Mireli?: Where can I get the information on the study of the endangered species that could possibly be there? Ms. Jahn: That is all in the application file so when you get in contact with Ms. DeJohn, she'll be able to give you a copy. Mr. Mireli?: So, it has been done? It passed? They found nothing there? Ms. DeJohn: The Environmental Studies are a requirement of every application within Collier County including this one and that material is on file and you can request it. Mr. Mireli?: So, they never found anything out there? Ms. DeJohn: I have (mumbling) Ms. Jahn: Okay, so, I am going to take and have Ms. Halphen check one more time to see if there is anyone on Zoom. Please state your name again. Ms. Halphen: No one is active on Zoom. Ms. Jahn: Are there any participants on Zoom? Ms. Halphen: So far we had 2 and 1 just left. Ms. Jahn: Okay. Alright, thank you very much. Again, if you have any follow up questions for me, you have my business cards up front. I'll be happy to stay behind. I'm sure Ms. DeJohn is able to stay behind as well. Otherwise, please feel free to email me at miahnkthelawmpowered.com or give me a call on my cell at 941-685-3770. Would you please go back to the contact information for Ms. DeJohn? Ms. DeJohn is, if I may finish my statement, laura.dejohnkcolliercountyfl.gov. And, her phone number is 239-252-4324. Again, thank you so much, yes, please just don't get Ms. Halphen in it. Thank you all for coming. Mr. Mireli?: Have you checked any other sites to put this other than that place? Ms. Jahn: There was a research process performed prior to it coming to my desk but it was limited because they are geographically limited due to the fact that this is a network architecture. The towers have to be spaced in certain proximities to other towers and they also have to be located basically where the usage is. Again, so I hope you all have a wonderful evening. Mumbling and various voices. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 ALPERT, NORMAN R 11800 TAMIAMI TRL E NAPLES, FL 34113-7909 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 ALPERT, NORMAN R 11800 TAMIAMI TRL E NAPLES, FL 34113-7909 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 ALVAREZ,DANA 1945 BENTON RD NAPLES, FL 34117-8856 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 ARNOLD, TREVOR DEAN HYE SHIN PAK-ARNOLD 12955 WHITE VIOLET DRIVE NAPLES, FL 34119 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 BACCAM, SANG & SOUNITTA JANET LIEMTHONG ET AL 2280 EVERGLADES BLVD S NAPLES, FL 34117-6808 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 CAMPBELL, CHARLES B CAMPBELL, MARGARET J 2005 28TH AVE SE NAPLES, FL 34117-8812 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 CONGINE, BETTY MAE 1704 BENTON RD NAPLES, FL 34117 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 FIERMONTI, ANGELINA c/o MICHELE FIERMONTI 2401 W SOUTHERN AVE #51 TEMPE, AZ 85282 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 FIERMONTI, ANGELINA c/o MICHELE FIERMONTI 2401 W SOUTHERN AVE #51 TEMPE, AZ 85282 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 FOLINO, KRYSTAL WILLIAM W MEE JR 4778 STONO LINKS DR HOLLYWOOD, SC 29449-5984 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 HARRING, DONALD R & IRENE H 1751 BENTON RD NAPLES, FL 34117-8864 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 J & M MANCARI REV TRUST 16 1ST PL BROOKLYN, NY 11231-3408 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 JAMES BELL PAVING INC 4650 3RD AVENUE NW NAPLES, FL 34119-0 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 KOGER-SCOTT, SHIRLEY 1750 BENTON RD NAPLES, FL 34117-8863 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 LO, INH ETIENNE & SEUAY SUE 3618 SE 19TH ST DES MOINES, IA 50320 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 MENDEZ, IVAN 1818 BENTON RD NAPLES, FL 34117-7853 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 MENDEZ, IVAN 1818 BENTON RD NAPLES, FL 34117-7853 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 MURRAY, BARBARA LYNN 2650 WARDLOW AVE SAN DIEGO, CA 92154-4235 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 MURRAY, BARBARA LYNN 2650 WARDLOW AVE SAN DIEGO, CA 92154-4235 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 MURRAY, BARBARA LYNN 2650 WARDLOW AVE SAN DIEGO, CA 92154-4235 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 MURRAY, BARBARA LYNN 2650 WARDLOW AVE SAN DIEGO, CA 92154-4235 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 MURRAY, BARBARA LYNN 2650 WARDLOW AVE SAN DIEGO, CA 92154-4235 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 NGUYEN, YEN MY THANH QUANG NGUYEN THU NHUT NGUYEN 107 E MELBOURNE ST SILVER SPRINGS, MD 20901 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 PREFERRED MATERIALS INC 4636 SCARBOROUGH DRIVE LUTZ, FL 33559 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 PREFERRED MATERIALS INC 4636 SCARBOROUGH DRIVE LUTZ, FL 33559 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 PREFERRED MATERIALS INC 4636 SCARBOROUGH DRIVE LUTZ, FL 33559 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 PREFERRED MATERIALS INC 4636 SCARBOROUGH DRIVE LUTZ, FL 33559 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 RESOURCE CONSERVATION PROP INC 9990 COCONUT RD # 200 BONITA SPRINGS, FL 34135-8488 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 RESOURCE CONSERVATION PROP INC 9990 COCONUT RD # 200 BONITA SPRINGS, FL 34135-8488 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 SIT, ANITA 108 SAINT MICHAELS CT DALY CITY, CA 94015-2162 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 TAFARA LODGE LLC 3585 41ST AVE NE NAPLES, FL 34120 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 TAFARA LODGE LLC 3585 41ST AVE NE NAPLES, FL 34120 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 TAFARA LODGE LLC 3585 41ST AVE NE NAPLES, FL 34120 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 TAFARA LODGE LLC 3585 41ST AVE NE NAPLES, FL 34120 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 November 5, 2020 TAFARA LODGE LLC 3585 41ST AVE NE NAPLES, FL 34120 Dear Property Owner: Please be advised that a formal application has been submitted to Collier County seeking approval of a Conditional Use for the following described property: The subject site is on the East side of Benton Road. The site can be reached as follows: Off of Everglades Blvd. S., make a left onto 28`h Avenue SE. Make a right on Woodland Estate Road. Make a left on Benton Road. Proceed down Benton Road approximately I mile and turn left, staying on Benton Road. The site will be approximately .23 miles on the left. (A site map is on the back of this letter) The petitioner is asking the County to approve this application to allow development of a 225' Above Ground Level telecommunications tower and related compound on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements, a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of our development intentions and to give you an opportunity to influence the form of development. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on November 23, at 5:30pm at Springhill Suites by Marriott, 3798 White Lake Blvd., Naples, FL 34117. You may also choose to attend the meeting by Zoom. The meeting ID is 834 3787 7516 and the passcode is SVuDJu. At this meeting, the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting, please contact me. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/vlc l 3 Benton -Road SUBJECT SITE 1 _.� ♦ -----.-- _ 28th Ave. SE Capital - Benton Road.�Q i • it. Fttk�-Ave-SE ] Bath-Rve-SE--2S Everglades Blvd. � N a) 0 a--+ Q Z � 0 L a LU .9 G. r N � •� r d) Q 7 E � :. Y t_ P�-satel53.puelP V 0 0) ., 0 v � 4 Z 77 m C CL r ? Z Z M n 1 .y ICA* * i i. � • r" 1 1 ! J U-J C o a � ' LLL -_._� �r) Y_ 1 d i N d ca r Q cil OP Ez i r � ? N r o p N 9 N _ . k � � b ID S 4- O N L � Q� 'L O L a-J L U O Q O a-J Q � � N L O >+ LA a- J Q O O N U > a- J O i N O O Z O N c Q 4-- = v-6 +J Q O fig .O v L > > fa a O }, DA O fC O O a% •N L a ° u E 4-1 Vi Q 4- L N I o p L an 4 � 3 v OQ L }' M c � 76 0 ~ 3 ru C7 -v c E N v a a > v N_ fV A A L N N 0 m A A QYOd 5IL715] (34"041:.0 g�{{ R $ age OP I I �1 �+ 1a >1 31Ca �! K'�KPrmulrn� m u I.Ir I +v&�ax rcn�ml 's.�r3�. _g Yv%Wl:I- II a vs.+n� gS? om — — — KKx C� HU��T A 11 m I 8 I �5Iyy i I 9sS I 9[ L:.d i3ns r tl aMn mvnae-- m�x 'uV-4�.L;rrt xavno- I ` :ax-�cazr � BMnd� 4+ LWA UU5 y�aa +euua'v �7 J 3= GUM amdw I �l.k 'rtl +rAJww .7r"31 I lmmi 3clx. .a3s y , �o0riisatr r1 8.n K lYk•1 53Lf.I LMK ' ai Tg31 �7 li3� i6+0 I aouo.+ac9ir � swrJ W 6� — m :ves wlna� s o � m I Yvmla: a e s miornzms�ol va�m I wow 3 13 WMP9f gm al-Gz 'd I f K0= L'.wl In �31Y +GN! "CPCL 1 w.•l �IJi4 'AtiaPo'�� J I B�`i�IF9TF IZ33H'a �u� �rl a lv d� S31G �4tl �la»3'a Tr31 m 3 mli L ' �07P>dKB:F IM1 FtxfcTL�xrn I I iiMJ N�ui1Ql 4p I '41 ,I L � • (��s rrrr ,Yi�wix x3Y.�1) f>lYPH135 . �,Ab a Z 'fi H Em F: N to v tj 3 v u c c� a E O u L O _O -61 M u d Q v O v .j N L N N f� C ai 4-J O L/) u 4-J 4-d u u v N c a� N v �i c� N L (U a-J a) u O O N N Q� 3 a� u a-J O u I..L > O ° an •r— a--J o u v L O u 4— _u Q N M 1 0 O N N V u � to N .. (V O N � U �, +�+ C J d W � � a p u° a u O u O O 3 O 0- E � 3 M N N M � N � � cV ^ � N m d W E a--J 4— Ln LL w u v 4-J O u Ln \ N � 4-J O +� N vor c� +J � o N v C i 3 4-, }' Ln M 3 5 w N� 3 3 v 0cE v u \ v E cn Q +� 62 O O o v o=a or 4-J O O U 3 c u on •• v Cl 4 cn = v l 4 4-1 � a� v i� 0 0 O LL-m �4,-n N u u > O N U N (aU u N 3 a �� 0 v c� 4-J =3 0 .61 c� .61 N � O L a-1 av u u c� U can 0 0 Z a� v � a Notice: This data belongs to the Collier County Property Appraiser's Office (CCPA). Therefore, the recipii provided data. The recipient may not transfer this data to others without consent from the CCPA. Petition: PL20180002327 I Buffer: 1000' 1 Date: 10/30/2020 1 Site Location: Parcels 32 i NAME1 NAME2 NAME3 ALPERT, NORMAN R 11800 TAMIAMI TRL E ALPERT, NORMAN R 11800 TAM IAMI TRL E ALVAREZ, DANA 1945 BENTON RD ARNOLD, TREVOR DEAN HYE SHIN PAK-ARNOLD 12955 WHITE VIOLET DRIVE BACCAM, SANG & SOUNITTA JANET LIEMTHONG ET AL 2280 EVERGLADES BLVD S CAMPBELL, CHARLES B CAMPBELL, MARGARET J 2005 28TH AVE SE CONGINE, BETTY MAE 1704 BENTON RD FIERMONTI, ANGELINA % MICHELE FIERMONTI 2401 W SOUTHERN AVE #51 FIERMONTI, ANGELINA % MICHELE FIERMONTI 2401 W SOUTHERN AVE #51 FOLINO, KRYSTAL WILLIAM W MEE JR 4778 STONO LINKS DR HARRING, DONALD R & IRENE H 1751 BENTON RD J & M MANCARI REV TRUST 16 1ST PL JAMES BELL PAVING INC 4650 3RD AVENUE NW KOGER-SCOTT, SHIRLEY 1750 BENTON RD LO, INH ETIENNE & SEUAY SUE 3618 SE 19TH ST MENDEZ, IVAN 1818 BENTON RD MENDEZ, IVAN 1818 BENTON RD MURRAY, BARBARA LYNN 2650 WARDLOW AVE MURRAY, BARBARA LYNN 2650 WARDLOW AVE MURRAY, BARBARA LYNN 2650 WARDLOW AVE MURRAY, BARBARA LYNN 2650 WARDLOW AVE MURRAY, BARBARA LYNN 2650 WARDLOW AVE NGUYEN, YEN MY THANH QUANG NGUYEN THU NHUT NGUYEN PREFERRED MATERIALS INC 4636 SCARBOROUGH DRIVE PREFERRED MATERIALS INC 4636 SCARBOROUGH DRIVE PREFERRED MATERIALS INC 4636 SCARBOROUGH DRIVE PREFERRED MATERIALS INC 4636 SCARBOROUGH DRIVE RESOURCE CONSERVATION PROP INC 9990 COCONUT RD # 200 RESOURCE CONSERVATION PROP INC 9990 COCONUT RD # 200 SIT, ANITA 108 SAINT MICHAELS CT TAFARA LODGE LLC 3585 41 ST AVE NE TAFARA LODGE LLC 3585 41 ST AVE NE TAFARA LODGE LLC 3585 41 ST AVE NE TAFARA LODGE LLC 3585 41 ST AVE NE TAFARA LODGE LLC 3585 41 ST AVE NE Property Owners List for 11-23-20 NIM mt agrees not to represent this data to anyone as other than CCPA 634720009, 32634600006 and 32634640008 NAME4 NAMES NAME6 FOLIO NAPLES, FL 34113--- 7909 00319400003 NAPLES, FL 34113--- 7909 00324800009 NAPLES, FL 34117--- 8856 00323640008 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 00324200007 NAPLES, FL 34117--- 6808 00324880003 NAPLES, FL 34117--- 8812 32633520006 NAPLES, FL 34117 --- 0 32634800000 TEMPE, AZ 85282 --- 0 32633560008 TEMPE, AZ 85282 --- 0 32633600007 HOLLYWOOD, SC 29449--- 5984 32634520005 NAPLES, FL 34117--- 8864 00324120006 BROOKLYN, NY 11231--- 3408 32633680001 NAPLES, FL 34119 --- 0 32634200008 NAPLES, FL 34117--- 8863 32634680000 DES MOINES, IA 50320 --- 0 00324000003 NAPLES, FL 34117--- 7853 32634120007 NAPLES, FL 34117--- 7853 32634160009 SAN DIEGO, CA 92154--- 4235 32633960006 SAN DIEGO, CA 92154--- 4235 32634000004 SAN DIEGO, CA 92154--- 4235 32634040006 SAN DIEGO, CA 92154--- 4235 32634080008 SAN DIEGO, CA 92154--- 4235 32634240000 107 E MELBOURNE ST SILVER SPRINGS, MD 20901 --- 0 00324040005 LUTZ, FL 33559 --- 0 00322920004 LUTZ, FL 33559 --- 0 00323560007 LUTZ, FL 33559 --- 0 00323600006 LUTZ, FL 33559 --- 0 00324080007 BONITA SPRINGS, FL 34135--- 8488 00324840001 BONITA SPRINGS, FL 34135--- 8488 32633640009 DALY CITY, CA 94015--- 2162 00324160008 NAPLES, FL 34120 --- 0 32634560007 NAPLES, FL 34120 --- 0 32634600006 NAPLES, FL 34120 --- 0 32634640008 NAPLES, FL 34120 --- 0 32634760001 NAPLES, FL 34120 --- 0 32634720009 Property Owners List for 11-23-20 NIM Date: November 23, 2020 Benton Road Relo/Naples Park: Name 2.'lJ 3. NEIGHBORHOOD MEETING SIGN -IN SHEET Address Email Address �CvnAc,4- c a►� 4. �17s1 /:3.,4- at Y 5. Ho"k-, QAwWs k, !R?.y Rojuv5 iye S-jj- LA SKVrt Ktu-SE 0`1 c< <c �►'w.� �urvt�vl s C,U✓H \ 2 6. An `\ (t " HVI .`� \ k=' l e i��,j ci 10. A 11. Org 12. Der,, C14 Cif �c1c�.� f C? I 2 1 13. L A--j,( 14. 1 I �t c;(, ( 16. 17. CrJ l � ►� �' CQt.i✓L� Date: November 23, 2020 Name 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. Benton Road Relo/Naples Park: NEIGHBORHOOD MEETING SIGN -IN SHEET Address ;9 Email Address rz , 14 This Application is subject to the Co er County expedited timelines specified in Chapter 365.172, Florida Statutes. COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 www.colliereov.net (239) 252-2400 FAX: (239) 252-6358 APPLICATION FOR PUBLIC HEARING FOR: CONDITIONAL USE LDC Section 10.08.00 & Code of Laws section 2-83 — 2-90 Chapter 3 C.1 of the Administrative Code PETITION NO (PL) PROJECT NAME To be completed by staff DATE PROCESSED ❑E A CONDITIONAL USE TO BE HEARD BY THE PLANNING COMMISSION AND BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS A MINOR CONDITIONAL USE TO BE HEARD BY THE OFFICE OF THE HEARING EXAMINER APPLICANT CONTACT INFORMATION Name of Property Owner(s): Tafara Lodge LLC c/o Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq, Address: 800 Tarpon Woods Blvd. Suite E-1 City: Palm Harbor state: FL ZIP:34685 Telephone: 727-773-2221 cell: 941-685-3770 Fax: 727-773-2616 E-Mail Address: mjahn@thelawmpowered.com Name of Applicant/Agent: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC c/o Mattaniah S Firm: the Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, P.A. Jahn, Esq. Address: 800 Tarpon Woods Blvd. Suite E-1 City: Palm Harbor State: FL ZIP: 34685 Telephone: 727-773-2221 Cell: 941-685-3770 Fax: 727-773-2616 E-Mail Address: mjahn@thelawmpowered.com BE AWARE THAT COLLIER COUNTY HAS LOBBYIST REGULATIONS. GUIDE YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY AND ENSURE THAT YOU ARE IN COMPLIANCE WITH THESE REGULATIONS. 10/14/2017 Page 1 of 12 Co er County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT www.colliergov.net ASSOCIATIONS 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX: (239) 252-6358 Required: List all registered Home Owner Association(s) that could be affected by this petition. Provide additional sheets if necessary. Information can be found on the Board of County Commissioner's website at http://www.colliergov.net/Index.aspx?page=774. Name of Homeowner Association: Mailing Address: Name of Homeowner Association: Mailing Address: Name of Homeowner Association: Mailing Address: Name of Homeowner Association: Mailing Address: Name of Homeowner Association: Mailing Address: City: State: ZIP: City: State: ZIP: City: State: ZIP: City: State: ZIP: City: PROPERTY INFORMATION State: ZIP: On separate page, provide a detailed legal description of the property covered by the application: • If the request involves changes to more than one zoning district, the applicant shall include separate legal description for property involved in each district; • The applicant shall submit 4 copies of a recent survey (completed within the last six months, maximum 1" to 400' scale), if required to do so at the pre -application meeting; and • The applicant is responsible for supplying the correct legal description. If questions arise concerning the legal description, an engineer's certification or sealed survey may be required. Property I.D. Number: 3263472-0009 Section/Township/Range: 25 Subdivision: Floridian Farm Sites / 49S / 27E Metes & Bounds Description: N/A Size of Property: ft. X ft. _ Address/ General Location of Subject Property: None Assigned Benton Rd Plat Book: 4 Page #: 33 Lot: 122 Block: N/A Total Sq. Ft. Acres: 5AC-Parent - 34 Ac-Tower 10/14/2017 Page 2 of 12 Coder County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT www.colliergov.net 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX: (239) 252-6358 ADJACENT ZONING AND LAND USE Zoning Land Use N A -MHO — RFMUO-NRPA-NBMO Sending Sending — Agricultural/Rural — NBMO — NRPA S A -MHO — RFMUO-NRPA-NBMO Sending Sending —Agricultural/Rural — NBMO — NRPA E A -MHO — RFMUO-NRPA-NBMO Sending Sending — Agricultural/Rural — NBMO — NRPA W A -MHO — RFMUO-NRPA-NBMO Sending Sending — Agricultural/Rural — NBMO — NRPA If the owner of the subject property owns contiguous property please provide a detailed legal description of the entire contiguous property: (If space is inadequate, attach on a separate page) Section/Township/Range: Lot: Block: Subdivision: Plat Book: Page #: Property I.D. Number: Metes & Bounds Description: See Enclosed CONDITIONAL USE REQUEST DETAIL Type of Conditional Use: This application is requesting a conditional use as allowed, pursuant to LDC section 2.03.00, of the A -MHO — RFMUO-NRPA-NBMO Sending zoning district for a 220' AGL communication tower (type of use). Present Use of the Property: vacant 10/14/2017 Page 3 of 12 Coder County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT www.colliergov.net 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX: (239) 252-6358 EVALUATION CRITERIA Pursuant to LDC section 10.08.00 and Chapter 3 CA of the Administrative Code, staff's recommendation to the reviewing body shall be based upon a finding that the granting of the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and that the specific requirements governing the individual conditional use, if any, have been met. Further, satisfactory provision and arrangement have been made concerning the following matters, where applicable. On a separate page, provide a narrative statement describing a request for a conditional use and a detailed response to the criteria listed below. Specify how and why the request is consistent with each of the criteria. a. Describe how the project is consistent with the Collier County Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan. Include information on how the request is consistent with the applicable section or portions of the Future Land Use Element. b. Describe the existing or planned means of ingress and egress to the property and proposed structure thereon with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe. c. Describe the effect the conditional use will have on neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic impact, and odor. d. Describe the site's and the proposed use's compatibility with adjacent properties and other properties in the district. e. Please provide any additional information which you may feel is relevant to this request. Deed Restrictions: The County is legally precluded from enforcing deed restrictions; however, many communities have adopted such restrictions. You may wish to contact the civic or property owners association in the area for which this use is being requested in order to ascertain whether or not the request is affected by existing deed restrictions. Previous land use petitions on the subject property: To your knowledge, has a public hearing been held on this property within the last year? If so, what was the nature of that hearing? None known Official Interpretations or Zoning Verifications: To your knowledge, has there been an official interpretation or zoning verification rendered on this property within the last year? E No ❑ Yes (If yes please provide copies.) 10/14/2017 Page 4 of 12 CAY County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT www.colliergov.net 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX: (239) 252-6358 STATEMENT OF UTILITY PROVISIONS FOR CONDITIONAL USE REQUEST APPLICANT INFORMATION Name of Applicant(s): Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC c/o Mattaniah S Address: 800 Tarpon Woods Blvd. Suite E-1 City: Palm Harbor State: FL Telephone: 727-773-2221 Cell: 941-685-3770 E-Mail Address: mjahn@thelawmpowered.com Address of Subject Property (If available): City: State: ZIP: LEGAL DESCRIPTION Section/Township/Range: Lot: Block: Subdivision: Plat Book: Page #: Property I.D. Number: Metes & Bounds Description: Jahn, Esq. ZIP: 34685 Fax: 727-773-2616 Please see enclosed TYPE OF SEWAGE DISPOSAL TO BE PROVIDED Check applicable system: a. County Utility System ❑ b. City Utility System C. Franchised Utility System ❑ d. Package Treatment Plant ❑ e. Septic System ❑ Provide Name: N/A - Communication Tower (GPD Capacity): TYPE OF WATER SERVICE TO BE PROVIDED a. County Utility System b. City Utility System C. Franchised Utility System d. Private System (Well) ❑ PROVIDE NAME a Total Population to be served: Irrigation for landscaping only Peak and Average Daily Demands: A. Water -Peak: _Average Daily: B. Sewer -Peak: Average Daily: 10/14/2017 Page 5 of 12 Coder County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT www.collierxov.net 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX: (239) 252-6358 If proposing to be connected to Collier County Regional Water System, please provide the date service is expected to be required: N/A - Communication Tower Narrative statement: Provide a brief and concise narrative statement and schematic drawing of sewage treatment process to be used as well as a specific statement regarding the method of affluent and sludge disposal. If percolation ponds are to be used, then percolation data and soil involved shall be provided from tests prepared and certified by a professional engineer. N/A - Communication Tower County Utility Dedication Statement: If the project is located within the service boundaries of Collier County's utility service system, a notarized statement shall be provided agreeing to dedicate the water distribution and sewage collection facilities within the project area to the Collier County Utilities. This shall occur upon completion of the construction of these facilities in accordance with all applicable County ordinances in effect at that time. This statement shall also include an agreement that the applicable system development charges and connection fees will be paid to the County Utilities Division prior to the issuance of building permits by the County. If applicable, the statement shall contain an agreement to dedicate the appropriate utility easements for serving the water and sewer systems. N/A - Communication Tower Statement of Availability Capacity from other Providers: Unless waived or otherwise provided for at the pre -application meeting, if the project is to receive sewer or potable water services from any provider other than the County, a statement from that provider indicating adequate capacity to serve the project shall be provided. 10/14/2017 Page 6 of 12 C0 er County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT www.colliergov.net 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX: (239) 252-6358 RECORDING OF DEVELOPER COMMITMENTS Within 30 days of adoption of the Ordinance, the owner or developer at their expense shall record in the Public Records of Collier County a Memorandum of Understanding of Developer Commitments or Notice of Developer Commitments that contains the legal description of the property that is the subject of the land use petition and contains each and every commitment of the owner or developer specified in the Ordinance. The Memorandum or Notice shall be in form acceptable to the County and shall comply with the recording requirements of F.S. §695. A recorded copy of the Memorandum or Notice shall be provided to the assigned Principal Planner, Zoning Services Department, within 15 days of recording of said Memorandum or Notice. Chapter 8 of the Administrative Code requires that the applicant must remove their public hearing advertising sign(s) after final action is taken by the Board of County Commissioners. Based on the Board's final action on this item, please remove all public hearing advertising sign(s) immediately. 10/14/2017 Page 7 of 12 Coajj r County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT www, col I ie rgov.net 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX: (239) 252-6358 Pre -Application Meeting and Final Submittal Requirement Checklist for: A Conditional Use to be heard by the Planning Commission and Board of Zoning Appeals ❑ A Minor Conditional Use to be heard by the Office of the Hearing Examiner Chapter 3 C.1, of the Administrative Code The following Submittal Requirement Checklist is to be utilized during the Pre -Application Meeting, and at time of application submittal. At time of submittal, the checklist is to be completed and submitted with the application packet. Please provide the submittal items in the exact order listed below, with cover sheets attached to each section. Incomplete submittals will not be accepted. Requirements for Review Completed Application (download current form from County website) # Of Copies Required Not Required 1 Cover letter briefly explaining the project 1 Pre -Application Notes 1 Affidavit of Authorization, signed and notarized i ® ❑ Completed Addressing Checklist 1 Property Ownership Disclosure Form i ❑ Warranty Deed(s) 1 Boundary Survey 1 Conceptual Site Plan 24' X 36" plus (one 8 % X 11 copy) Plans showing proposed location for utilities, if required Plans for screening and buffering the use with reference as to type, dimensions, and character, if required ❑ Plans showing the proposed landscaping and provisions for trees protected by County regulations, if required ❑ ❑ Plans showing the proposed signs and lighting, including type, dimensions, and if required ❑ Elcharacter, Architectural Rendering of Proposed Structure(s), if applicable 1 Current aerial photographs (available from Property Appraiser) with project boundary and, if vegetated, FLUCFCS Codes with legend included on aerial. 1 ❑ Statement of utility provisions (with all required attachments & sketches) 1El Environmental Data Requirements, pursuant to LDC section 3.08.00 1 Environmental Data Requirements collated into a single Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) at time of public hearings. Coordinate with project planner at time of public hearing. ❑ ❑ Listed Species Survey; less than 12 months old. Include copies of previous surveys. 1 Traffic Impact Study (TIS) o gA Historical and Archeological Survey, or waiver 1 1 _ Electronic copy of all documents and plans * Please advise: The Office of the Hearing Examiner requires all materials to be 1 t ❑ submitted electronically in PDF format. _ * If located in the Bays hore/Gateway Triangle Redevelopment Area, include an additional set of each submittal requirement 5/08/2018 Page 8 of 12 Collier County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT www.colliergov.net 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX: (239) 252-6358 ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENTS FOR THE PUBLIC HEARING PROCESS: • Following the completion of the review process by County review staff, the applicant shall submit all materials electronically to the designated project manager. • Please contact the project manager to confirm the number of additional copies required. Planners: Indicate if the petition needs to be routed to the following additional reviewers: Bays hore/Gateway Triangle Redevelopment: Emergency Management: Dan Summers; and/or Executive Director EMS: Artie Bay ❑ Conservancy of SWFL: Nichole Johnson GMD Graphics ❑ City of Naples: Robin Singer, Planning Director Utilities Engineering: Eric Fey E Parks and Recreation: Barry Williams ❑ Immokalee Water/Sewer District: ❑ Other: 1 ❑ School District (Residential Components): Amy Lockheart Communication Towers: Control Naples Airport Authority Commercial Mining: ` ❑ 1 Impact Fees Collier County Airport Authority 5/08/2018 Page 9 of 12 CoUfe' T County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 www.colliergov.net (239) 252-2400 FAX: (239) 252-6358 FEE REQUIREMENTS All clitcks payable to: Board of County Commissioners re -Application Meeting: $500.00 (to be credited towards the application fee if the application is filed within 9 months of pre -application meeting) Conditional Use Application Fee: $4,000.00 o When filed with Rezone Petition: $1,500.00 o Additional fee for 51h and subsequent reviews: 20% of original fee X Comprehensive Planning Consistency Review: $300.00 1/ Environmental Data Requirements -EIS Packet (submittal determined at pre -application meeting): $2,500.00 � Listed or Protected Species survey review fee (when an EIS is not required): $1.000.00 A Transportation Fee ur d: i JNV Methodolowi Fee: 5500.0 Minor Study Review Fee: S o r Major Study Review fee 500.00 �( Estimated Legal Advertising a for the Hearing Examiner or CCPC: $1,125.00 ❑ Estimated Legal Advertising Fee for the BZA, if required: S500.00.-' �? Fire Code Plans Review Fees are collected at the time of application submission and those fees are set forth by the Authority having jurisdiction. The Land Development Code requires Neighborhood Notification mailers for Applications headed to hearing, and this fee is collected prior to hearing. As the authorized agent/applicant for this petition, I attest that all of the information indicated on this checklist is included in this submittal package. I understand that failure to include all necessary submittal information may result in the delay of processing this petition. All checks payable to: Board of County Commissioners. The completed application, all required submittal materials, and fees shall be submitted to: Growth Management Department ATTN: Busines Center 2800 North Hors hoe Drive __,:a JNles,fL 4104 Agent/Owner Signature 44$ Agent/Owner Name (please print) 5/08/2018 Page 10 of 12 Coder County „1 COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 www.colliereov.net (239) 252-2400 FAX: (239) 252-6358 Public Participation Requirements LDC Section 10.03.06 B. or C. Chapter 8 of the Administrative Code Notice for Minor Conditional Use Petitions Neighborhood Information Meeting (NIM) Requirements: Applicant must conduct a NIM at least 15 days prior to the Hearing Examiner's receipt of the staff report and application materials in accordance with the applicable sections of the Administrative Code. The NIM shall be advertised and a mailed written notice shall be given to the property owners in the notification area at least 15 days prior to the NIM meeting. Mailed Notice: Written notice shall be sent to property owners in the notification area at least 15 days before the advertised Hearing Examiner hearing. Newspaper Advertisements: The legal advertisement shall be published at least 15 days before the advertised Hearing Examiner hearing in a newspaper of general circulation. The advertisement shall include at a minimum: • Date, time, and location of the hearing; • Description of the proposed land uses; and • 2 in. x 3 in. map of the project location. Sign: A sign shall be posted at least 15 days before the advertised Hearing Examiner hearing date. Public Hearing for Minor Conditional Use Petitions Hearing Examiner: The Hearing Examiner shall hold at least 1 advertised public hearing. See Chapter 9 of the Administrative Code for the Office of the Hearing Examiner procedures. Notice for Conditional Use Petitions Neighborhood Information Meeting (NIM) Requirements: Applicant must conduct a NIM at least 15 days prior to the advertised public hearing. The NIM shall be advertised and a mailed written notice shall be given to the property owners in the notification area at least 15 days prior to the NIM meeting. 10/14/2017 Page 11 of 12 Cai[ier County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT www.colliereov.net 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX: (239) 252-6358 Mailed Notice: Written notice shall be sent to property owners in the notification area at least 15 days before the advertised public hearing. Newspaper Advertisements: The legal advertisement shall be published at least 15 days before the advertised public hearing in a newspaper of general circulation. The advertisement shall include at a minimum: • Date, time, and location of the hearing; • Description of the proposed land uses; and 2 in. x 3 in. map of the project location. Sign: A sign shall be posted at least 15 days before the advertised public hearing date. Public Hearing for Conditional Use Petitions Environmental Advisory Committee (EAQ The EAC shall hold at least 1 advertised public hearing, if required. Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC): The CCPC shall hold at least 1 public hearing. Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA): The BZA shall hold at least 1 advertised public hearing. 10/14/2017 Page 12 of 12 AFFIDAVIT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR PETITION NUMBERS(S) PL20180002327 1, CynlhiaATatum (print name), as Manager (title, if applicable) of Tarara Lodge, LLC (company, If applicable), swear or affirm under oath, that I am the (choose one) owner0 applicant=contract purchaserF]and that: 1. 1 have full authority to secure the approval(s) requested and to impose covenants and restrictions on the referenced property as a result of any action approved by the County in accordance with this application and the Land Development Code; 2. All answers to the questions in this application and any sketches, data or other supplementary matter attached hereto and made a part of this application are honest and true; 3. 1 have authorized the staff of Collier County to enter upon the property during normal working hours for the purpose of investigating and evaluating the request made through this application; and that 4. The property will be transferred, conveyed, sold or subdivided subject to the conditions and restrictions imposed by the approved action. 5. We/I authorize Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. and/or Mattaniah S. Jahn, P.A to act as our/my representative in any matters regarding this petition including 1 through 2 above. *Notes: • If the applicant is a corporation, then it is usually executed by the corp. pres. or v. pres. • If the applicant is a Limited Liability Company (L.L.C.) or Limited Company (L.C.), then the documents should typically be signed by the Company's "Managing Member." • If the applicant is a partnership, then typically a partner can sign on behalf of the partnership. • If the applicant is a limited partnership, then the general partner must sign and be identified as the "general partner" of the named partnership. • If the applicant is a trust, then they must include the trustee's name and the words "as trustee". • In each instance, first determine the applicant's status, e.g., individual, corporate, trust, partnership, and then use the appropriate format for that ownership. Under pen I ies of e.oury, I declare that I have read the foregoing Affidavit of Authorization and that the facts Ia ed in it re true. Signature STATE OF FLORIDA la k as 16 D to COUNTY OF COLLIER The foregoing instrument was sworn to (or affirmed) and subscribed before me on Z (date) by GYNliAtA (name of person providing oath d1r affirmation), as who is personally known to me or who has produced (type of identification) as identification. STAMP/SEAL Si e t P �ti" "�% TODD ALLEN Notary Public - State of Florida ;' �; Commission M GG 188162 'Q°rfr ` My Comm. Expires Jun 15, 2022 "Bonded through National Notary Assn. CP\08-COA-00115\155 REV 3/24/14 AFFIDAVIT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR PETITION NUMBERS(S) PL20180002327 1, Vincent Cascerio (print name), as an Authorized Signatory (title, if applicable) of Capital Telecom Holdings 11 LLC (company, If applicable), swear or affirm under oath, that I am the (choose one) owner= applicantcontract purchaser=and that: 1. I have full authority to secure the approval(s) requested and to impose covenants and restrictions on the referenced property as a result of any action approved by the County in accordance with this application and the Land Development Code; 2. All answers to the questions in this application and any sketches, data or other supplementary matter attached hereto and made a part of this application are honest and true; 3. 1 have authorized the staff of Collier County to enter upon the property during normal working hours for the purpose of investigating and evaluating the request made through this application; and that 4. The property will be transferred, conveyed, sold or subdivided subject to the conditions and restrictions imposed by the approved action. 5. Well authorize Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. and/or Mattaniah S. Jahn, P.A. to act as our/my representative in any matters regarding this petition including 1 through 2 above. 'Notes: • If the applicant is a corporation, then it is usually executed by the corp. pres. or v. pres. • If the applicant is a Limited Liability Company (L.L.C.) or Limited Company (L.C.), then the documents should typically be signed by the Company's "Managing Member." • If the applicant is a partnership, then typically a partner can sign on behalf of the partnership. • If the applicant is a limited partnership, then the general partner must sign and be identified as the "general partner" of the named partnership. • If the applicant is a trust, then they must include the trustee's name and the words "as trustee". • In each instance, first determine the applicant's status, e.g., individual, corporate, trust, partnership, and then use the appropriate format for that ownership. Under penalties of perjury, I declare that I have read the foregoing Affidavit of Authorization and that the facts stated in it are true. Signature Date STATE OF FLORtDA 1\1'e W. V ers(-F- COUNTY OF COtttER C 5 S FK The foreyping instr ent was swo to (or affirmed) and subscribed before me on r (date) by �l "�I`E - G` - ES s (name of person providing oath or affirmation), as nC-ey-17j who is personally known to me or who has produced (type of identification) as identification STAMP/SEAL Sign re of Notary blic JENNIFERA. RESSA NOTARY PUBLIC OF NEW JERSEY My Commission Expires September 10, 2022 CP\08-COA-00115\155 REV 3/24/14 AGENT OF RECORD LETTER I, Vincent Casiero, as Authorized Signor for Capital Telecom Holdings II, LLC. ("Capital") have the authority to execute this document. Capital leases the property located in Collier County, Florida; identified by Parcel # 32634720009; and hereby designate and appoint the Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, P.A. and/or Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esquire, 935 Main Street, Suite D1, Safety Harbor, Florida 34695, Phone 727-773-2221, Facsimile 727-773-2616, Email mjahn@thelawmpowered.com, as my Agent of Record for the purpose of any and all permitting, zoning, and/or land use applications, hearings, or processes in association with the development of a communication facility on the aforementioned property. My Agent of Record is hereby vested with authority to make any representations, agreements, or promises which are necessary or desirable in conjunction with any of the aforementioned processes. My Agent of Record is also authorized to accept or reject any conditions imposed by any reviewing board or entity. My Agent of Record has the authority to execute documents relating to any of the above described processes on my behalf. Signature Vincent Casiero Printed Name As Authorized Signor Title Date STATE OF M tw 16M COUNTY OF The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this3 day of, 2019, by eY-P who is personally known to me or who has produced as identifca ion. (SEAL) JENNIFERA. RESSA NOTARY PUBLIC OF NEW JERSEY My Commission Expires September 10, 2021 N r Public n . ,'L- P�*nted Name of Notary COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT www.calliergov.net Goer County 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX: (239) 252-6358 PROPERTY OWNERSHIP DISCLOSURE FORM This is a required form with all land use petitions, except for Appeals and Zoning Verification Letters. Should any changes of ownership or changes in contracts for purchase occur subsequent to the date of application, but prior to the date of the final public hearing, it is the responsibility of the applicant, or agent on his behalf, to submit a supplemental disclosure of interest form. Please complete the following, use additional sheets if necessary. a. If the property is owned fee simple by an INDIVIDUAL, tenancy by the entirety, tenancy in common, or joint tenancy, list all parties with an ownership interest as well as the 0 Er eILCfIWKt! vl �puLF1 {IILCICSL. Name and Address I % of Ownership I If the property is owned by a CORPORATION list the officers and stockholders and the tMEreriLage vt 5LVLK Owned by each: Name and Address % of Ownership If the property is in the name of a TRUSTEE, list the beneficiaries of the trust with the iercentage of interest: Name and Address % of Ownership Created 9/28/2017 Page 1 of 3 Coder County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 www.coiliergov.net (239) 252-2400 FAX: (239) 252-6353 d. If the property is in the name of a GENERAL or LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, list the name of the general and/or limited partners: Name and Address % of Ownership I -A FACA U0 D Q G �C - O e. If there is a CONTRACT FOR PURCHASE, with an individual or individuals, a Corporation, Trustee, or a Partnership, list the names of the contract purchasers below, including the c 11 FLCI S, SLULKI IU1UVF a, lJC11C11LIdI IC], OF LIdI LI It!] S. Name and Address °% of Ownershho Date of Contract: f. If any contingency clause or contract terms involve additional parties, list all individuals or of titers, it a corporation, partnership, or trust: Name and Address g. Date subject property acquired ❑ Leased: Term of lease years /months If, Petitioner has option to buy, indicate the following: Created 9/29/2017 Page 2 of 3 Colter Count COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT www,colliergov.net Date of option: Date option terminates: Anticipated closing date: 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX. (239) 252-6358 .•N AFFIRM PROPERTY OWNERSHIP INFORMATION Any petition required to have Property Ownership Disclosure, will not be accepted without this form. Requirements for petition types are located on the associated application form. Any change in ownership whether individually or with a Trustee, Company or other interest -holding party, must be disclosed to Collier County immediately if such change occurs prior to the petition's final public hearing. As the authorized agent/applicant for this petition, I attest that all of the information indicated on this checklist is included in this submittal package. I understand thatfailure to include all necessary submittal information may result in the delay of processing this petition. The completed applicat4)e,-afi-f d submittal materials, and fees shall be submitted to: Growth Management Department ATTN: Business Center 2800 North Horseshoe Drive -Naples, FL 34104 SiOatu �cu Agentyowner Name (please print) Date Created 9/28/2017 Page 3 of 3 COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT www.colliereov.net CAA County 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX: (239) 252-6358 PROPERTY OWNERSHIP DISCLOSURE FORM This is a required form with all land use petitions, except for Appeals and Zoning Verification Letters. Should any changes of ownership or changes in contracts for purchase occur subsequent to the date of application, but prior to the date of the final public hearing, it is the responsibility of the applicant, or agent on his behalf, to submit a supplemental disclosure of interest form. Please complete the following, use additional sheets if necessary. a. If the property is owned fee simple by an INDIVIDUAL, tenancy by the entirety, tenancy in common, or joint tenancy, list all parties with an ownership interest as well as the percentage of such interest: Name and Address % of Ownership If the property is owned by a CORPORATION, list the officers and stockholders and the ercentaRe of StOCK owned by eacn: Name and Address I % of Ownership C. If the property is in the name of a TRUSTEE, list the beneficiaries of the trust with the percentage of interest: Name and Address % of Ownership Created 9/28/2017 Page 1 of 3 COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT www.colliergov.net i e f 9. Co*.r County 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX: (239) 252-6358 If the property is in the name of a GENERAL or LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, list the name of the g enerai and/or Hmitea partners: Name and Address % of Ownership If there is a CONTRACT FOR PURCHASE, with an individual or individuals, a Corporation, Trustee, or a Partnership, list the names of the contract purchasers below, including the C �I III,CIZ�, bLUI.RI I UIUCIZk, UCI IC IR.Id I I CJ, UI I.JdI UICIJ: Name and Address % of Ownership Date of Contract: If any contingency clause or contract terms involve additional parties, list all individuals or of Date subject property acquired �, U1 uuaL: Name and Address ❑ Leased: Term of lease years /months If, Petitioner has option to buy, indicate the following: Created 9/28/2017 Page 2 of 3 COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT www.colliereov.net Date of option: Co*r County 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX: (239) 252-6358 Date option terminates: , or Anticipated closing date: AFFIRM PROPERTY OWNERSHIP INFORMATION Any petition required to have Property Ownership Disclosure, will not be accepted without this form. Requirements for petition types are located on the associated application form. Any change in ownership whether individually or with a Trustee, Company or other interest -holding party, must be disclosed to Collier County immediately if such change occurs prior to the petition's final public hearing. As the authorized agent/applicant for this petition, I attest that all of the information indicated on this checklist is included in this submittal package. I understand that failure to include all necessary submittal information may result in the delay of processing this petition. The completed application, all required submittal materials, and fees shall be submitted to: Growth Management Department ATTN: Business Center 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 3 Agent/Owner Signature Date V/ t,JCF_j,I CA-5 i BIZ U Agent/Owner Name (please print) Created 9/28/2017 Page 3 of 3 Ownership of Capital Telecom Holdings II LLC The following individuals comprise more than 51% of the ownership (directly or indirectly) of Capital Telecom Holdings II LLC: Edward A. Farscht 820 Morris Turnpike, Suite 104 Short Hills, New Jersey 07078 Michael G. Brett 820 Morris Turnpike, Suite 104 Short Hills, New Jersey 07078 Peter M. Woodbury 820 Morris Turnpike, Suite 104 Short Hills, New Jersey 07078 Orazio Russo 820 Morris Turnpike, Suite 104 Short Hills, New Jersey 07078 John D. Thomas 820 Morris Turnpike, Suite 104 Short Hills, New Jersey 07078 David C. Sullivan 820 Morris Turnpike, Suite 104 Short Hills, New Jersey 07078 Gene Grieco 820 Morris Turnpike, Suite 104 Short Hills, New Jersey 07078 AFFIDAVIT OF VINCENT CASIERO BEFORE ME, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Vincent Casiero, who being by me first duly sworn, under oath, deposes and states as follows: 1. I am over eighteen (18) years of age and have personal knowledge of the matters contained herein. 2. I am the Authorized Signatory of Capital Telecom Holdings II, LLC ("Capital") and have the authority to sign this affidavit. 3. The following individuals comprise more than 5 1 % of the ownership (directly or indirectly) of Capital: a. Edward A. Farscht, 820 Morris Turnpike, Suite 104, Short Hills, New Jersey 07078 b. Michael G. Brett, 820 Morris Turnpike, Suite 104, Short Hills, New Jersey 07078 c. Peter M. Woodbury, 820 Morris Turnpike, Suite 104, Short Hills, New Jersey 07078 d. Orazio Russo, 820 Morris Turnpike, Suite 104, Short Hills, New Jersey 07078 e. John D. Thomas, 820 Morris Turnpike, Suite 104, Short Hills, New Jersey 07078 f. David C. Sullivan, 820 Morris Turnpike, Suite 104, Short Hills, New Jersey 07078 g. Gene Grieco, 820 Morris Turnpike, Suite 104, Short Hills, New Jersey 07078 4. The remaining ownership ("Minority Owners") consists of numerous individuals and multiple institutional investors. 5. The Minority Owners possess limited rights, are remote from the daily operations of Capital, and cannot exercise direct input or control over the operational managerial functions of Capital. FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT. // cam_- - Vincent Casiero, as A..,-n cxz i Capital Telecom Holdings H, LLC STATE OF COUNTY OF _ S, Sworn to (or affirmed) and subscribed before me this 3 day of , 2019, by (Seal) Printed Name of Notary Personally Known 6R Produced Identification Type of Identification Produced V 1I�CeCigkCJO JENNIFER A. RESSA NOTARY PUBLIC OF NEW JERSEY My Commission Expires September 10, 2022 Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, P.A. 800 Tarpon Woods Boulevard, Suite E-1 Palm Harbor, Florida 34685 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 SENT VIA ELECTRONIC UPLOAD December 18, 2018 Gilbert Martinez Collier County Growth Management Department 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 Gilbert.Martinez@colliercountyfl.gov RE: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC — Naples Park Parcel 4 3263472-0009 / PL#20180002327 Conditional Use Request for 225' AGL Guyed Telecommunication Tower - This Application is subject to the expedited timelines specified in Chapter 365.172, Florida Statutes. - Dear Mr. Martinez: On behalf of my client, Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC (Capital) please find the included Conditional Use application to allow a 225' AGL Guyed Telecommunication Tower and support facility on parcel #3263472-0009 along with supporting documentation: • Filing Fee Check o Conditional Use Fee: $7,425.00 • Conditional Use Application • Agent of Record Affidavits: o Tafara Lodge LLC to Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. — County Form o Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC to Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. — County Form • Property Ownership Disclosure Forms o Tafara Lodge, LLC o Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC • Pre -application Notes • Approved Addressing Checklist • Trustee's Deed • List of contiguous parcel under common ownership • Ground Lease • FAA Determination of No Hazard to Air Navigation • Collier Mosquito Control District Approval Email • NEPA Report • SHPO Letter — bound with NEPA at page 228 Page 1 of 21 Capital — Naples Park • Colocation Affidavit • RF Package o Verizon Statement of Need and Propagation Maps 0 911 Call Statistics o Search Ring o Alpine Tower Failing Structural Report • Fall Zone letter — 1 electronically signed and sealed • Legal Descriptions on 8.5 x 11 — 1 copy in word • Boundary, and Topographic Survey — 1 electronically signed and sealed set • Preserve Management Plan with FLUCFCS Aerial — 1 set, bound with site plan • Site Plan — 1 electronically signed and sealed set Summary of Request Capital respectfully requests a Conditional Use Approval for Parcel 3263472-0009 to allow the construction of a 225' AGL Guyed Telecommunication Tower ("Relocation Tower") and related walled compound and power meter/telco rack, serving as a replacement for Verizon Wireless deployment on an existing guyed tower located on parcel 31940-0003 ("Existing Tower"). The Relocation tower will be able to accommodate an updated modern deployment for Verizon Wireless as well as up to 3 additional sets of antennas for a total of 4 colocations. The 5 Acre parent property is currently undeveloped palmetto coverage that is not preserved. The Relocation Tower's compound will be 60' x 60'. The parent parcel currently carries an A -MHO — RFMUO- NRPA-NBMO Sending zoning designation and Sending — Agricultural/Rural — NBMO — NRPA future land use designation. The Relocation Tower will be set back from the property lines North: 506', South: 150', East: 206', and West: 128'. Applicable Ordinance The following underlined language was approved by the Collier County BOCC on November 13, 2018, at consent agenda item 16.A.3 La, as zoning in progress for vetting. 2.01.03 - Essential Services Essential services are hereby defined as services designed and operated to provide water, sewer, gas, telephone, electricity, cable television or communications to the general public by providers which have been approved and authorized according to laws having appropriate jurisdiction, and government facilities. Essential services are allowed in any zoning district subject to the following conditions: G. Conditional uses. The following uses require approval pursuant to section 10.08.00 conditional uses: Page 2 of 21 Capital —Naples Park 4. Additional conditional uses in the RFMU sendiniz lands. The following essential services shall be allowed as conditional uses: a. Communications towers, subject to all applicable provisions of LDC section 5.05.09. Capital respectfully proposes to construct a 225' AGL communication tower on parcel 3263472-0009, which is located within the RFMU sending lands. Please see Sheet Al Applicable Land Development Code 5.05.09 - Communications Towers A. Purpose and intent. This section applies to specified communication towers that support any antenna designed to receive or transmit electromagnetic energy, such as, but not limited to, telephone, television, radio, or microwave transmissions. This section sets standards for construction and facilities siting; and is intended to minimize, where applicable, adverse visual impacts of towers and antennas through careful design, siting, and vegetation screening; to avoid potential damage to adjacent properties from tower failure; to maximize the use of specified new communication towers and, thereby, to minimize the need to construct new towers; to maximize the shared use of specified tower sites to minimize the need for additional tower sites; to lessen impacts new ground mounted towers could have on migratory and other species of birds; to prevent unnecessary habitat fragmentation and/or disturbance in siting and designing new towers ; and to consider the concerns of the Collier Mosquito Control District as to low flying mosquito control aircraft safety. B. Definitions unique to communications towers , section 5.05.09. 1. As used herein " antenna " does not include (a) wire antennas or (b) "receive only" dishes that have an outside diameter of less than 40 inches. 2. Effective radius means a radius of 6 miles from the respective tower unless a lesser radius is approved. Capital respectfully submits Verizon's search ring as a lesser effective radius for the Relocation Tower. The network nature of cellular coverage limits the area where the Relocation Tower can be located and still achieve Verizon's RF objectives of emulating the Exiting Tower's coverage. Please see the enclosed RF Package. 3. Lesser effective radius means an approved radius of less than 6 miles. Page 3 of 21 Capital —Naples Park Capital respectfully submits Verizon's search ring as a lesser effective radius for the Relocation Tower. The network nature of cellular coverage limits the area where the Relocation Tower can be located and still achieve Verizon's RF objectives of emulating the Exiting Tower's coverage. Please see the enclosed RF Package. 4. " Unavailable to the applicant "means a tower that cannot accommodate the applicant's proposed antenna or a site that cannot accommodate the applicant's tower, antenna, and related facilities. The only communication tower within Verizon's search ring is the Existing tower. It is unavailable to Verizon for the purposes of it's updated antenna deployment. Please see the enclosed Alpine Tower Structural Analysis. 5. ... C. Migratory Birds and other Wildlife Considerations. . Ground Mounted towers. Except to the extent not feasible for the respective new ground mounted tower's intended purpose(s), each new ground mounted tower that will exceed a height of 75 feet (above ground), exclusive of antennas, but will not exceed a height of 199 feet above natural grade , exclusive of antennas, should not be guyed. If the applicant proposes that a new ground mounted tower within this height range be guyed, the applicant shall have the burden of proving the necessity of guying the tower. N/A — the Relocation Tower will be 225' AGL. 2. Bird Diverter Devices. Each new ground mounted guyed tower installed on or after February 20, 2004, greater then 75 feet in height above natural grade , exclusive of antennas, shall have installed and maintained bird diverter devices on each guy wire (to reduce injuries to flying birds). Capital will comply. Page 4 of 21 Capital —Naples Park Habitat Loss. In addition to the requirements in Chapters 3 and 10, towers and other on - site facilities shall be designed, sited, and constructed to minimize habitat loss within the tower footprint. At such sites, road access and fencing, to the extent feasible, shall be utilized to minimize on -site and adjacent habitat fragmentation and/or disturbances. The Relocation Tower will have no adverse effect on neighboring habitat. While some clearing will occur, the Relocation Tower will minimize impact to onsite habitat both through its siting; which minimizes driveway length and leaves a North/South vegetative corridor on the east side of the parent parcel; and through preserving 90% of the existing native vegetative communities on the parent parcel. Please see the enclosed NEPA, Sheet Al, and Preserve Management Plan. 4. Security Lighting . When feasible, security lighting to protect on -ground facilities/equipment shall be down -shielded to try to keep such light within the outermost geographic boundaries of the tower's footprint. Noted. D. Shared use of towers . A tower with a height in excess of 185 feet above natural grade shall not be approved, unless the applicant demonstrates that no old or approved tower within the effective radius can accommodate the applicant's proposed antenna and ancillary equipment. Towers owned by or leased to any government are exempt from these shared use provisions, except as to sharing with other governments. l . For the purpose of discovering availability for use of towers within the effective radius, the applicant shall contact the owner of all old and approved towers , within the effective radius, that can possibly accommodate the needs of the applicant . The county manager or designee may preapprove the minimum allowable height to determine which towers may be available for use by the applicant. A list of all owners contacted, the date of each contact, the form and content of each contact, and all responses shall be a part of the conditional use application. As an accommodation to applicants , the county manager or designee shall retain all shared use plans, records of past responses, and a list of old and approved towers . If the owner of an old tower does not respond to the applicant's inquiry within a reasonable time, generally 30 days or less, or the owner of an old tower will not rent space to the applicant at a reasonable rental for a reasonable time period, such old tower shall be deemed unavailable to that applicant . If the old tower is a nonconforming structure , additional antennas may be installed thereon in accordance with an approved shared use plan, provided however, no structural alterations may be made to the tower , and the height of the tower inclusive of its antennas may not be increased. 2. Lesser effective radius. If the applicant asserts that the effective radius for the intended use is less than 6 miles, the applicant shall provide evidence that the asserted lesser Page 5 of 21 Capital — Naples Park effective radius is based on physical and/or electrical characteristics. Based on the evidence submitted by the applicant , the County Manager or designee may establish a lesser effective radius. If a radius can be increased by signal amplification or other means, such means must be considered in determining the lesser effective radius. The antenna manufacturer's specifications shall be conclusive, unless the applicant can prove they are incorrect in the specific case. If an approved tower within the applicant's approved effective radius may have capacity available for the antenna proposed by the applicant , the application for a new tower shall not be complete without the following information regarding each such possibly available approved tower . Such information shall also be provided for old towers to the extent it can be obtained. Identification of the site of each possibly available tower by coordinates, street address or legal description, existing uses, and tower height. Whether shared use by the applicant of the tower is prohibited (or is not feasible) for any reason. If it has been determined that the lower owner will a]low structural changes, whether the tower can accommodate the proposed antenna if reasonable structural changes are made. If so, the applicant shall specify what structural changes would be required and an approximation of the costs of such changes. If the costs of the required changes are financially impracticable, such tower shall be deemed unavailable to the applicant . 4. The applicant shall contact the owner of each possibly available approved tower to request the needed information. To enable the tower owner to respond, the applicant shall provide the following information regarding the applicant's proposed antenna and equipment: All output frequencies of transmitter. b. Type of modulation, polarization of radiation, and proposed use of antenna. Manufacturer, type, manufacturer's model number, a diagram of the antenna's radiation pattern, and the manufacturer's specifications. d. Power input to antenna and gain of antenna in decibels with respect to an isotopic radiator. e. Range in feet of maximum and minimum height of antenna above base of tower. A list of necessary ancillary equipment and description of the type of transmission cable to be used. Page 6 of 21 Capital —Naples Park g. Any other pertinent information needed to enable the owner to respond in full to the inquiry. The Relocation Tower will be designed to accommodate Verizon's antennas as well as up to 3 additional set of antennas. Additionally, Capital has committed to make the 3 colocations available to wireless providers at market rates. Please see the Sheets C2 and C3 as well as the enclosed Colocation Affidavit. E. Shared use of tower sites. A tower with a height in excess of 185 feet above natural grade shall not be approved on a new tower site unless the applicant demonstrates that the proposed tower, antennas, and accessory structures or uses cannot be located on any conforming old site or approved site situated within the effective radius. Sites owned by any government or leased to any government are exempt from these shared use provisions except to other governments. Except as to each old site or approved site determined by the County Manager or designee, or in a shared use plan to be unavailable to the applicant , the applicant shall contact the owner of all other conforming old sites and approved tower sites, within the effective radius, containing sufficient land area to possibly accommodate the needs of the applicant . 2. For each such possibly available tower site, the application for a new tower site shall not be complete without the following information: a. Identification of the proposed new tower site by coordinates, street address or legal description, area, existing uses, topography, and significant natural features. b. Evidence that no old and no approved tower site within the effective radius can accommodate the applicant's needs. c. If the owner of an old tower site does not respond to the applicant's simple letter of interest inquiry within thirty (30) days, or the owner of an old tower site will not rent land to accommodate the applicant's needs for a reasonable period of time at reasonable rentals, such old tower site shall be deemed unavailable to the applicant . d. The applicant is not required to supply this information to owners of conforming old sites unless the old site appears to be available to the applicant by a shared use plan or the site's owner has responded positively to the applicant's initial letter of inquiry. To enable the site owner to respond, the applicant shall provide the site owner (and the owner of any tower on the site) with the dimensional characteristics and other relevant data about the tower , and a report from a professional engineer licensed in the State of Florida, or other qualified expert, documenting the following: Page 7 of 21 Capital —Naples Park e. tower height and design, including technical, engineering, and other pertinent factors governing the intended uses and selection of the proposed design. An elevation and a cross section of the tower structure shall be included. f. Total anticipated capacity of the tower, including number and types of antennas and needed transmission lines, accessory use needs including specification of all required ancillary equipment, and required building and parking space to accommodate same. g. Evidence of structural integrity of the proposed tower as required by the building official and, for metal towers , a statement promising full compliance with the then latest edition of the standards published by the Electronic Industries Association (currently EIA/TIA 222-E), or its successor functional equivalent, as may be amended for local application. If the site owner, or owner of a tower on the respective site, asserts that the site cannot accommodate the applicant's needs, the respective owner shall specify in meaningful detail reasons why the site cannot accommodate the applicant. To the extent information is current and correct in the respective tower site's approved shared use plan, the site owner or tower owner can refer the applicant to the respective shared use plan. If the shared use plan is not then up-to-date, the plan shall be brought up-to-date immediately by the owner and the written reply to the applicant shall specify to what extent the shared use plan is incorrect, incomplete, or otherwise not up-to-date. 4. No provision in a shared use plan, land lease, mortgage, option to purchase, lease -option, contract for deed, or other controlling document shall provide, or have the effect, that the site is exclusive to one (I) tower , unless there is good reason for such restriction, other than the prevention of competition or a desire or inclination not to cooperate in good faith. If the site size is physically and electrically compatible with the installation on -site of any other tower , no such document shall prevent other towers , except for reasons approved by the County Manager or designee. An unapproved document provision of tower exclusivity shall be grounds to disapprove an application for tower site approval. The Relocation Tower will be designed to accommodate Verizon's antennas as well as up to 3 additional set of antennas. Additionally, Capital has committed to make the 3 colocations available to wireless providers at market rates. Please see the Sheets C2 and C3 as well as the enclosed Colocation Affidavit. F. Required sharing. Each new tower in excess of 185 feet in height (shared use tower ), except towers that are approved to be perpetually unavailable, shall be designed to structurally accommodate the maximum amount of additional antenna capacity reasonably practicable. Although it is not required that a new tower be constructed at additional expense to accommodate antennas owned by others, no new tower shall be designed to accommodate only the tower owner's proposed antennas when, without additional expense, antenna space for other owners can be made available on the tower . Page 8 of 21 Capital —Naples Park Shared use plans. Each shared use plan shall be in a standard format that has been approved by the County Manager or designee. Each shared use plan shall specify in detai I to what extent there exists tower and/or site capacity to accommodate additional antennas and/or additional towers , ancillary equipment, and accessory uses . Available antenna capacity on a tower shall be stated in detailed clearly understandable terms, and may be stated in equivalent flat plate area and total additional available transmission line capacity. The tower owner (as to tower shared use plans) and the landowner (as to site shared use plans) shall update its respective approved shared use plans by promptly filing pertinent update information with the County Manager or designee. Owners of old towers and/or old sites may file shared use plans in accord with this section. 2. Reservation of capacity. If an applicant for a shared use tower does not plan to install all of its proposed antennas during initial construction of the tower , the applicant must specify the planned schedule of installing such later added antennas as part of the shared use plan. An applicant cannot indefinitely prevent the use of unused available antenna space on a tower by reserving to itself such space. No available space can be reserved for the owner or anyone else, unless approved in the shared use plan. If an antenna is not installed by the scheduled deadline, the reserved space shall automatically be rendered available for use by others, unless the shared use plan has, by the deadline, been amended with the approval of the County Manager or designee. Deadlines may be extended even if the tower is a nonconforming structure . If space has been reserved in a shared use plan for future additional antenna use by the tower owner and it becomes clear that such space will not be utilized by the owner, the shared use plan shall be amended promptly to reflect the availability of such space. 3. Reservation of site capacity. The policy stated above applies also to additional tower space on an approved tower site to prevent indefinite reservation of available site space. 4. Height bonus for sharing.... 5. Filing shared use plans. Each approved shared use plan shall be filed and recorded in the Office of the Collier County Clerk of Court prior to any site development plan approval. A copy of the initial shared use plan shall be filed with, and approved by, the County Manager or designee prior to conditional use approval. 6. Shared use plans for old towers and old tower sites. Initial shared use plans and amendments for old towers require approval of the County Manager or designee. Initial shared use plans and amendments for old tower sites require approval of the BCC, except where an amendment reduces site and/or antenna capacity. 7. Transmitting and receiving equipment serving similar kinds of uses shall, to the extent reasonable and commercially practicable, be placed on a shared use tower in such a manner that any of the users in a group can operate approximately equal to other users in the group utilizing substantially similar equipment. Page 9 of 21 Capital —Naples Park Once a shared use plan for a tower is approved, additional antennas may be added to that tower in accordance with the approved shared use plan without additional conditional use approval even if the tower is then a nonconforming structure . The shared use plan shall be immediately updated to reflect each such change. Likewise, once a new shared use plan for a tower site is approved, additional towers and accessory buildings and uses may be added to that site in accordance with the plan without additional conditional use approval, even if the site is then nonconforming . The shared use plan shall be immediately updated to reflect each change. 9. For each tower with a height in excess of 185 feet that is approved, the tower owner shall be required, as a condition of approval, to file an approved shared use plan, except when a government tower is approved to be perpetually unavailable. To the extent that there is capacity for other antennas on the tower , the plan shall commit the tower owner and all successor owners to allow shared use of the tower in accordance with the shared use plan for antennas of others at reasonable rates. The initial proposed rates (or a range of reasonable rates) shall be specified in the shared use plan, and shall be amended each time the rates are changed. When antenna space on a tower is rented to others, each rental agreement shall be filed with the shared use plan. Any agreement that purports to reserve antenna space for future use must be approved by the County Manager or designee. 10. For each new shared use tower site that is approved, the owner shall be required, as a condition of approval, to file an approved shared use plan, except as to a government site that is approved to be perpetually unavailable. If there is land available on the site to accommodate additional towers and accessory facilities, the plan shall commit the landowner and successor owners to accommodate such additional facilities on the site at reasonable rents (or a range of reasonable rents) which shall be specified in the shared use plan. When land is rented for facilities on the site, the rental agreement shall be filed with the shared use plan. Any agreement that purports to reserve land for future use of a tower and other facility space must be approved by the County Manager or designee. 11. Each new tower owner or site owner, as the case may be, shall agree, as a condition of approval, to respond, in writing, in a comprehensive manner within thirty (30 days) to each request for information from a potential shared use applicant . Government owners need to reply only to requests from another government. To the extent that correct and up-to-date information is contained in an approved shared use plan, the owner may refer the applicant to the shared use plan for the information. If the shared use plan is incorrect, incomplete, or otherwise not up-to-date, the respective owner shall, in the response, specify, in detail, such information, and shall immediately bring the shared use plan up- to-date. 12. The tower owner or site owner, as the case may be, shall, as a condition of approval, negotiate in good faith for shared use of tower space and/or site space by applicants in accordance with its shared use plan. Page 10 of 21 Capital — Naples Park 13. All conditions of approval regarding a tower shall run with the ownership of the tower and be binding on all subsequent owners of the tower . All conditions of approval regarding an approved tower site shall run with the land and be binding on all subsequent owners of the tower site. The Relocation Tower will be designed to accommodate Verizon's antennas as well as up to 3 additional set of antennas. Additionally, Capital has committed to make the 3 colocations available to wireless providers at market rates. Please see the Sheets C2 and C3 as well as the enclosed Colocation Affidavit. G. Development standards for communication towers . Except to the extent that amateur radio towers , and ground -mounted antennas with a height not to exceed twenty (20) feet, are exempted by subsection 5.05.09 herein, no new tower of any height shall be permitted in the RSF-1 through RSF-6, RMF-6, VR, MH, TTRVC, and E zoning districts. However, notwithstanding other provisions of this section, including the separation requirements of subsection5.05.09(F)(7) below, towers may be allowed to any height as a conditional use in the E zoning district only on sites approved for a specified essential service listed in subsection 5.05.09((F)(3) below. There shall be no exception to this subsection except for conditional use applications by a government for a governmental use. The Relocation Tower will be located on a parcel zoned A -MHO — RFMUO-NRPA-NBMO Sending. Please see Sheet Al. 7. With the exception of rooftop towers and towers on essential services sites, each new communication tower shall meet the following separation requirements: a. Each new tower that exceeds 185 feet in height shall be located not less than two and one-half (2.5) times the height of the tower from all RSF-1 through RSF-6, and RMF- 6 zoning districts, including PUDs where the adjacent use(s) is/are, or comparable to, the RSF-1 through RSF-6 and RMF-6 zoning districts. If a part of a PUD is not developed, and it is inconclusive whether the part of a PUD area within such minimum separation distance from the proposed tower site may be developed with a density of six (6) units per acre or less, it shall be presumed that the PUD area nearest to the proposed site will be developed at the lowest density possible under the respective PUD. All parcels neighboring the parent parcel are zoned A -MHO — RFMUO-NRPA-NBMO Sending. Therefore, this separation requirement is not applicable in this instance. Please see Sheet Al. Page 11 of 21 Capital — Naples Park 8. All owners of approved towers are jointly and severally liable and responsible for any damage caused to off -site property as a result of a collapse of any tower owned by them. Noted. Please see Sheet G2 Liability Note. 9. ... 10. Any accessory buildings or structures shall meet the minimum yard requirements for the respective zoning district. accessory uses shall not include offices, long-term vehicle storage, outdoor storage, broadcast studios except for temporary emergency purposes, or other structures and/or uses that are not needed to send or receive transmissions, and in no event shall such uses exceed twenty-five (25) percent of the floor area used for transmission or reception equipment and functions. Transmission equipment shall be automated, to the greatest extent economically feasible, to reduce traffic and congestion. Where the site abuts , or has access to, a collector street , access for motor vehicles shall be limited to the collector street . All equipment shall comply with the then applicable noise standards. The Relocation Tower's equipment compound will be set back as follows: Required: Provided: North: 30' 479' South: 30' 122' East: 50' 180, West: 50' 100, Therefore, the equipment compound will exceed the required setbacks. Any equipment collocated within the compound will comply with the noise ordinance. Please see Sheet Al. 11. For new commercial towers exceeding 185 feet in height, a minimum of two (2) parking spaces shall be provided on each site. An additional parking space for each two (2) employees shall be provided at facilities which require on -site personnel. Facilities which do not require on -site personnel may utilize impervious parking. Capital will comply. Please see Sheets Al and C2. Page 12 of 21 Capital —Naples Park 12. All new tower bases, guy anchors, outdoor equipment, accessory buildings , and accessory structures shall be fenced. This provision does not apply to amateur radio towers , or to ground -mounted antennas that do not exceed twenty (20) feet above grade. Please see Sheets C1 and C2. 13. Tower lighting. Towers and antennas with a height greater than 150 feet shall be required to have red beacon or dual mode lights, unless exempted, in writing, by the Collier County Mosquito Control District. Such lights shall meet the then existing Federal Aviation Administration ("FAA") technical standards. No other towers or antennas shall be artificially lighted, except as required by the FAA, the Federal Communications Commission, or other applicable laws, ordinances, or regulations. If the FAA rules require lighting, then the applicant shall comply with such rules. New towers exceeding 199 feet. Each new tower that will have a height in excess of one hundred and ninety-nine (199) feet above ground, exclusive of antennas, and such tower shall be lighted no more than is otherwise required by state and/or federal law, rule, or regulation. Unless otherwise then required by law, rule or regulation, only white strobe lights shall be used at night, unless otherwise required by the FAA, in which case red strobe -type lights shall be used. Such lights shall not exceed the minimum number, minimum intensity, and minimum light flashes per interval of time (requiring the longest allowable duration between light flashes) required by state or federal law, rule, or regulation. Solid red (or pulsating red) warning lights shall not be used at night. The Relocation Tower will be equipped with FAA "med dual" lights. Please see the enclosed Determination of No Hazard to Air Navigation. 14. Effective January 1, 1992, all guyed towers , including old towers , exceeding 185 feet in height shall be inspected every two (2) years. Such self-supporting towers shall be inspected every four (4) years. Each inspection shall be by a qualified professional engineer or other qualified professional inspector, and any inspector -recommended repairs and/or maintenance should be completed without unnecessary delay. At a minimum, each inspection shall include the following: a. Tower structure : Including bolts, loose or damaged members, and signs of unusual stress or vibration. b. Guy wires and fittings: Check for age, strength, rust, wear, general condition, and any other signs of possible failure. c. Guy anchors and foundations: Assess for cracks in concrete, signs of corrosion, erosion, movement, secure hardware, and general site condition. Page 13 of 21 Capital —Naples Park d. Condition of antennas, transmission lines, lighting, painting, insulators, fencing, grounding, and elevator, if any. e. For guyed towers : Tower vertical alignment and guy wire tension (both required tension and present tension). Noted. Please see Sheet G2, Inspection Note. 15. A copy of each inspection report shall be filed with the County Manager not later than December 1 of the respective inspection year. If the report recommends that repairs or maintenance are required, a letter shall be submitted to the County Manager to verify that such repairs and/or maintenance have been completed. The County shall have no responsibility under this section regarding such repairs and/or maintenance. Noted. Please see Sheet G2, Inspection Note. 16. Any tower that is voluntarily not used for communications for a period of one (1) year shall be removed at the tower owner's expense. If a tower is not removed within three (3) months after one (1) year of such voluntary non-use, the County may obtain authorization, from a court of competent jurisdiction, to remove the tower and accessory items, and, after removal, shall place a lien on the subject property for all direct and indirect costs incurred in dismantling and disposal of the tower and accessory items, plus court costs and attorney's fees. Noted. Please see Sheet G2, Abandonment Note. 17. For all ground -mounted guyed towers in excess of seventy-five (75) feet in height, the site shall be of a size and shape sufficient to provide the minimum yard requirements of that zoning district between each guy anchor and all property lines. Capital will comply. Please see Sheet C1. 18. All new metal towers , including rooftop towers , except amateur radio towers , shall comply with the standards of the then latest edition published by the Electric Industries Association (currently EIA/TIA 222-E) or the publication's successor functional equivalent, unless amended for local application by resolution of the BCC. Each new amateur radio tower with a height of seventy-five (75) feet or less shall require a building permit specifying the exact location and the height of the tower exclusive of antennas. Each new ground -mounted dish type antenna that does not exceed a height of twenty (20) feet shall require a building permit. Capital will comply. Please see Sheet T1, Applicable Codes Panel. Page 14 of 21 Capital — Naples Park 19. Within the proposed tower's effective radius , information that specifies the tower's physical location, in respect to public parks, designated historic buildings or districts, areas of critical concern, and conservation areas, shall be submitted as part of the conditional use application. This shall also apply to site plan applications and/or permit applications for rooftop installations that do not require conditional use approval. Please see Sheet Al, the enclosed NEPA, and the enclosed SHPO letter. 20. No communication tower shall be located on any land or water if such location thereon creates, or has the potential to create, harm to the site as a source of biological productivity, as indispensable components of various hydrologic regimes, or as irreplaceable and critical habitat for native species of flora or fauna. The Relocation Tower will not create harm to the biological productivity of the parent parcel, nor will it impact indispensable components of hydraulic regimes, or critical habitat for flora or fauna. The opposite is true, the Relocation Tower will place 90% of the native vegetative communities under preserve protection. Please see the enclosed NEPA Report and Preserve Management Plan. 21. Any existing native vegetation on the site shall be preserved and used to meet the minimum landscape requirements as required by section 4.06.00. The site plan shall show existing significant vegetation to be removed and vegetation to be replanted to replace that lost. native vegetation may constitute part or all of the required buffer area if its opacity exceeds eighty (80) percent. Capital will comply. Please see the enclosed Preserve management Plan. 22. As to communications towers and antennas, including rooftop towers, antenna structures , and antennas, the height provisions of this section supersede all other height limitations specified in this Code. Noted. 23. All existing and proposed ground mounted and rooftop towers and antennas with a height greater than 150 feet shall be required to have a solid red beacon or dual mode lights unless exempted in writing by the Collier Mosquito Control District. Such lights shall meet the then existing Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) technical standards. The total structure height shall include all appendages and attachments, such as antennas, lights, lightening rods, or any other accessory device that would extend the height of the tower. All existingtowers shall have six months (180 days) from June 16, 2005, to comply Page 15 of 21 Capital —Naples Park with the requirement. If the FAA rules require lighting, then the applicant shall comply with such rules. The Relocation Tower will be equipped with FAA "med dual" lights. Please see the enclosed Determination of No Hazard to Air Navigation. 24. A copy of each application for a tower in excess of 150 feet shall be supplied by the applicant to the Collier Mosquito Control District or designee. Please see the enclosed Collier Mosquito Control District approval email. H. Alligator Alley communication towers . Wireless emergency telephone service. Notwithstanding any other provisions of this section 5.05.09, the following provisions shall apply to communications towers that provide wireless emergency telephone service. These facilities are essential services . 2. Each applicant for these permits is required to clearly inform County staff by means of an emboldened "notice" in a cover letter or on the first page of the permit application, substantially as follows: This Application is subject to the expedited timelines specified in Chapter 365.172, Florida Statutes. Please see the enclosed conditional use petition application and page 1 of this narrative. 3. Applicants for these permits need not provide staff with evidence that a proposed wireless communications facility complies with federal regulations, but staff may require from such applicant proof of proper FCC licensure, and staff may request the FCC to provide information as to the provider's compliance with federal regulations to the extent then authorized by federal law. The County has no permitting jurisdiction with regard to wireless communications facilities located (or to be located) on property owned by the State of Florida, including State-owned rights -of -way . 4. Co -located facilities. Provided the then existing zoning applicable to the proposed site allows E911 facilities without a need to rezone, a need to obtain conditional use approval, or any other required process (such as, for example, having an agreement amended), the County shall grant or deny a properly completed application requesting co -location of E911 Service, or co -location for wireless telephone service, not later then forty-five (45) business days after the date that a properly completed application is initially submitted to staff in accordance with all applicable permit application requirements in this section 5.05.09. Co -location of such facilities on a then existing above -ground tower or other Page 16 of 21 Capital —Naples Park above -ground structure shall not be subject to the land development regulations pursuant to Section 163.3202, Florida Statutes, provided the height of the then existing tower or structure is not thereby increased. Co -location of such antenna, or co -location of related equipment, shall be subject to applicable building regulations, and with all then existing permits or agreements applicable to that tower or to the underlying property. Nothing herein, including the forty-five (45) business days timeline, shall relieve the permit holder for, or owner of, the then existing tower or structure from complying with applicable permit requirements, or applicable agreement(s), or with applicable land development regulation (including aesthetic requirement), or compliance with any other then applicable law(s). 5. New towers or antennas. Pursuant to Section 365.172, Florida Statutes, the County shall grant or deny an application requesting location of a new wireless telephone service tower , or for location of antenna(s) for wireless telephone service, not later then ninety (90) business days after the date that an application that fully complies with the requirements of this section 5.05.09 is submitted, provided the then existing zoning applicable to the proposed site allows the E911 facilities without need to rezone, the need to apply for conditional use approval, or other required procedures. Provided further that nothing herein shall affect permit compliance of such facilities with applicable federal regulations, applicable zoning and/or land development regulations (including aesthetic requirements), or with applicable building regulations. 6. Sufficiency notice. Within twenty (20) business days of receiving the permit application for any facility listed above in paragraphs (4) and (5) above, staff shall in writing notify the permit applicant whether the application is, or is not, properly completed. If such permit application is not properly completed, staff shall with specificity notify the applicant of any and all deficiencies, which if cured will thereby render the application being properly completed. Staff should also notify the applicant whether the applicable zoning classification allows the applied -for use(s) without rezoning, without conditional use approval, or without any other related ancillary approval process or permission. 7. Default approval. a. An application for E91 l service, co -location of wireless telephone service, or new location for wireless telephone service or antennae shall be deemed to have been automatically granted provided that: i. Such service or facility is allowed in the applicable zoning district without a rezone, without the need to apply for a conditional use , or without the need to apply for some other permit; ii. The County fails to either grant or deny the applied -for permit within the time frames set forth in paragraphs (4) and (5) above, as applicable; and Page 17 of 21 Capital — Naples Park iii. The applicant has not agreed to an extension of time, as provided in paragraph (8) below. b. However, the applied -for permit shall not be deemed granted if final action requires action by the BCC, but such action is prevented due to emergency conditions beyond the County's control. In such instance, the time for final action on the application shall be extended until the next regularly scheduled meeting of the BCC. The permit shall be deemed to be granted if the BCC fails to take final action at that time. Waiver. Extensions of the above -described applicable timelines (deadlines) shall not be effective except to the extent voluntarily agreed to by the permit applicant . Narrow exception: a one-time timeline waiver may be required if there then exists an emergency that directly affects the administration of all of the County's communications tower permitting activities which had been formally declared by the County, by the State of Florida, or by the federal government. Noted. 4.06.05 - General Landscaping Requirements B. Landscaping requirements for industrial and commercial development . For projects subject to architectural design standards, see LDC section 5.05.08 F. for related provisions. l . ... 2. Communication towers. An 8-foot high, 100 percent architecturally finished opaque wall must screen the security fencing that surrounds a tower base. In addition, landscaping must be located on the outside of such wall. The hedge requirement must also be planted around any ground level guy anchors. The entire perimeter of this wall shall be landscaped in at least one of the following ways so as to provide the equivalent of minimum code size trees located 25 feet on center and a 3-foot high hedge planted 3-feet on center. a. If native vegetation is present within the parcel , a minimum 20 foot wide buffer strip must be preserved and used toward meeting the tree and hedge planting requirement. Noted. Please see Sheets Al and C1. b. If native vegetation is present, but not dense enough to meet the equivalent of the tree and hedge requirements, it must be supplemented with plantings to meet the tree and hedge requirements. Page 18 of 21 Capital —Naples Park At the discretion of the county landscape architect, some or all of these landscape buffering requirements may be displaced to a right-of-way landscape buffer located within the parcel when it better serves the public interest of screening the communication tower. 10.08.00 - CONDITIONAL USE PROCEDURES D. Findings. The Planning Commission shall make a recommendation of approval, approval with conditions, or denial of the conditional use to the Board of Zoning Appeals. The Planning Commission's recommendation of approval or approval with conditions shall find that the granting of the conditional use will not adversely affect the public and any specific requirements pertaining to the conditional use have been met by the petitioner. Further, that satisfactory provision and arrangement has been made for the following matters, where applicable: Consistency with the LDC and Growth Management Plan As shown above, the Relocation Tower meets or exceed all applicable requirements of the LDC. Additionally, communication towers are allowable on lands with the parent parcel's zoning and future land use designations, subject to conditional use review. Finally, the LDC is the expression of the Growth Management Plan relative to communication towers; as the Relocation Tower meets and exceeds all of the LDC's objective standards, it is consistent with the Growth Management Plan. 2. Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe. The Relocation Tower will typically generate no more than 1 trip per carrier per month, typically in a pickup truck sized vehicle. As such there will be no meaningful impact to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience. The Relocation Tower will be accessed by a 12' wide gravel driveway, which will provide adequate access in the unlikely event of fire or catastrophe. Please see Sheets Al, C2, and C5. 3. The effect the conditional use would have on neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor effects. Page 19 of 21 Capital — Naples Park The Relocation Tower will not create noise, odor, or glare. While FAA regulations required lighting, it will be illuminated to the minimum amount necessary to meet FAA safety regulations. All lighting will be red at night. The Relocation Tower will have positive economic effect on the neighboring properties by allowing Verizon to bring its deployment up to current standards, allowing Verizon to provide reliable high-speed wireless coverage to the area. In Fiscal 17/18, 80% of all 911 calls received by the Collier County Sheriffs Office were made via wireless phones, this shows that reliable wireless coverage is no longer a luxury, it is a necessity. Please see the enclosed RF Package and 911 Call Statistics. 4. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district. The relocation tower will be set back as follows: Required Provided North: 112.5' 506' South: 112.5' 150' East: 112.5' 206' West: 112.5' 128' Therefore, the Relocation Tower exceeds the code's objective standard for compatibility to neighboring properties. Additionally, dense existing vegetation both on the parent parcel and on neighboring properties in the area help to partially buffer the Relocation Tower over and above the separation requirements. While the Relocation Tower will be illuminated, it will only be lighted to the minimum amount necessary to meet FAA safety regulations. The Relocation Tower will also show compatibility with neighboring properties in the area and the Sending district by placing 90% of the natural vegetative communities on the parent parcel under active preserve protection, furthering the district's environmental goals while economic utility to the parcel. Finally, the Relocation Tower will support neighboring properties by providing reliable, modernized, wireless coverage to them. As stated above, 80% of all 911 calls received by the Collier County Sheriffs office in fiscal 17/18 were received via wireless numbers. This underscores the essential infrastructure nature of reliable wireless coverage as we progress further into the 21s' century. Please see Sheets Al and C1 and the enclosed 911 call statistics. Page 20 of 21 Capital —Naples Park Thank you in advance for your assistance in this matter. Please do not hesitate to contact me if I am able to provide you with additional information. Sincerely, 1 Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. enclosures Page 21 of 21 Capital —Naples Park Coer County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 www.colliereov.net (239) 252-2400 Pre -Application Meeting Notes Petition Type: Conditional Use (CU) Date and Time: Wednesday 8/8/18 3 : 00 PM Assigned Planner: Gilbert Martinez Engineering Manager (for PPL's and FP's): Project Information Project Name: Capital Naples Park Communication Tower (CU) PL#: 20180002327 PropertylD#: 32634720009 Project Address: Applicant: Jahn Mattaniah Current Zoning: A -MHO - RFMUO-NRPA-NBMO Sending City: Naples State• FL Zip: Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, P.A. Agent Name: Phone: 727-773-2221 (C) 941-685-3770 Ste E-1 Palm Harbor Agent/Firm Address:800 Tarpon Woods B1vdCity: State• FL Zip• 34685 Property Owner: Tafara Lodqe LLC, 3585 41st St Ave NE, Naples FL 34120 Please provide the following, if applicable: Total Acreage: 5 ii. Proposed # of Residential Units: iv. V. Proposed Commercial Square Footage: For Amendments, indicate the original petition number: If there is an Ordinance or Resolution associated with this project, please indicate the type and number: vi. If the project is within a Plat, provide the name and AR#/PL#: Updated 7/24/2018 Page 1 1 of 5 COtit7er County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 www.collieroov.net (239) 252-2400 Meeting Notes As of 10/16/2017 all Zoning applications have revised applications, and your associated Application is included in your notes; additionally a *new Property Ownership Disclosure Form is required for all applications. A copy of this new form is included in your pre-app Note — link is https://www.collieroov.net/Home/ShowDocument?id=75093. Disclaimer: Information provided by staff to applicant during the Pre -Application Meeting is based on the best available data at the time of the meeting and may not fully inform the applicant of issues that could arise during the process. The Administrative Code and LDC dictates the regulations which all applications must satisfy. Any checklists provided of required data for an application may not fully outline what is needed. It is the applicant's responsibility to provide all required data. Z* Updated 7/24/2018 Page IZof 5 Co*,r County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 www.colliergov.net (239) 252-2400 Meeting Notes As of 10/16/2017 all Zoning applications have revised applications, and your associated Application is included in your notes; additionally a *new Property Ownership Disclosure Form is required for all applications. A copy of this new form is included in your pre-app Note — link is https://"w.colliergov.net/Home/ShowDocument?id=75093. ��n �-t-r 1�✓�,�-n �,.,,�t-tom, `,/� ��-� � �+'��f�'► � Disclaimer.• Information provided by staff to applicant during the Pre -Application Meeting is based on the best available data at the time of the meeting and may not fully inform the applicant of issues that could arise during the process. The Administrative Code and LDC dictates the regulations which all applications must satisfy. Any checklists provided of required data for an application may not fully outline what is needed. It is the applicant's responsibility to provide all required data. 2.6 Updated 7/24/2018 Page jXof 5 Colper County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 www.colliergov.net (239) 252-2400 Meeting Notes �' Y�J�-k,. %, a L • %f-Vr Gy- Z�:•!, r CYar+�b.. � d1A (, es 5, 4,„� `7,!-�, `i /t• , �� /:Uf.r/ . Ut �."sI! ( .f1It f i>IC��J 6%m I A 1'i„bH en-"J ` v Jx- Scatia eii LV e~d - �i( h lu Q.4.Vs Other required documentation for submittal (not listed on application): Disclaimer., Information provided by staff to applicant during the Pre -Application Meeting is based on the best available data at the time of the meeting and may not fully inform the applicant of issues that could arise during the process. The Administrative Code and LDC dictates the regulations which all applications must satisfy. Any checklists provided of required data for an application may not fully outline what is needed. It is the applicant's responsibility to provide all required data. Updated 7/24/2018 Page 1 3 of 5 ?I-°V44. Co*r County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 www.collier-gov.net (239) 252-2400 Pre -Application Meeting Sign -In Sheet PL# 20180002327 Collier County Contact Information: Name Review Discipline Phone Email ❑ Pavid Anthony Environmental Review 252-2497 david.anthony@colliercountyfl.gov Summer Araque Environmental Review 252-6290 summer.brownaraque@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Claudine Auclair GMD Operations and Regulatory Management 252-5887 claudine.auclair@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Steve Baluch Transportation Planning 252-2361 stephen.baluch@colliercountyfl.gov Ray Bellows Zoning, Planning Manager 252-2463 raymond.bellows@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Laurie Beard PUD Monitoring 252-5782 laurie.beard@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Craig Brown Environmental Specialist 252-2548 craig.brown@colliercountyfl.gov C eidi Ashton Cicko Managing Asst. County Attorney 252-8773 heidi.ashton@colliercountyfl.gov Thomas Clarke Operations Coordinator 252-2584 thomas.clarke@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Kay Deselem Zoning Services 252-2586 kay.deselem@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Dale Fey North Collier Fire 597-9227 dfey@northcolIierfire.com El _Eric Fey, P.E. Utility Planning 252-1037 eric.fey@colliercountyfl.gov Tim Finn, AICP Zoning Division 252-4312 timothy.finn@colliercountyfl.gov Sue Faulkner Comprehensive Planning 252-5715 sue.faulkner@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Paula Fleishman Impact Fee Administration 252-2924 paula.fleishman@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ James French Growth Management Deputy Department Head 252-5717 james.french@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Michael Gibbons Structural/Residential Plan Review 252-2426 michael.gibbons@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Storm Gewirtz, P.E. Engineering Stormwater 252-2434 storm.gewirtz@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Nancy Gundlach,AICP, PLA Zoning Division 252-2484 nancy.gundlach@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Shar Hingson Greater Naples Fire District 774-2800 shingson@gnfire.org ❑ John Houldsworth Engineering Subdivision 252-5757 john.houldsworth@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Jodi Hughes Transportation Pathways 252-5744 jodi.hughes@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Alicia Humphries Right -Of -Way Permitting 252-2326 1 alicia.humphries@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Marcia Kendall Comprehensive Planning 252-2387 marcia.kendall@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ John Kelly Zoning Senior Planner 252-5719 john.kelly@colliercountyfl.gov �Z Gil Martinez Zoning Principal Planner 252-4211 gilbert.martinez@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Thomas Mastroberto Greater Naples Fire 252-7348 thomas.mastroberto@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Jack McKenna, P.E. Engineering Services 252-2911 jack.mckenna@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Matt McLean, P.E. Development Review Director 252-8279 matthew.mclean@colliercountyfl.gov Updated 7/24/2018 Page 1 4 of 5 Coder County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT www.colliergov.net 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 ❑ Michele Mosca, AICP Capital Project Planning 252-2466 michele.mosca@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Annis Moxam Addressing 252-5519 annis.moxam@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Stefanie Nawrocki Development Review - Zoning 252-2313 stefanie.nawrocki@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Richard Orth Stormwater Planning 252-5092 richard.orth@coiliercountyfLgov ❑ Brandy Otero Transit 252-5859 bran dy.otero@colliercountyfLgov ❑ Brandi Pollard Utility Impact fees 252-6237 brandi.pollard@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Todd Riggall North Collier Fire 597-9227 triggall@northcollierfire.com ❑ Daniel Roman, P.E. Engineering Utilities 252-2538 daniel.roman@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Brett Rosenblum, P.E. Development Review Principal Project Manager 252-2905 brett.rosenblum@colliercountyfl.gov ❑,James Sabo, AICP Zoning Principal Planner james.sabo@colliergo.net Michael Sawyer Transportation Planning 252-2926 michael.sawyer@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Corby Schmidt, AICP Comprehensive Planning 252-2944 corby.schmidt@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Chris Scott, AICP Development Review - Zoning 252-2460 chris.scott@coil iercountyfLgov ❑ Peter Shawinsky Architectural Review 252-8523 peter.shawinsky@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Camden Smith Zoning Division Operations 252-1042 camden.smith@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Scott Stone Assistant County Attorney 252-5740 scott.stone @colliercountyfLgov ❑ Mark Strain Hearing Examiner/CCPC 252-4446 mark.strain@colliercountyfl.gov Mark Templeton Landscape Review 252-2475 mark.templeton@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Jessica Velasco Zoning Division Operations 252-2584 jessica.velasco@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Jon Walsh, P.E. Building Review 252-2962 jonathan.walsh@coiliercountyfLgov David Weeks, AICP Comprehensive Planning Future Land Use Consistency 252-2306 david.weeks@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Kirsten Wilkie Environmental Review 252-5518 kirsten.wilkie@colliercountyfl.gov ❑ Christine Willoughby Development Review - Zoning 252-5748 christine.willoughby@colliercountyfl.gov Additional Attendee Contact Information: Name Re resenting Phone Email r - -7 Updated 7/24/2018 Page 1 5 of 5 WC-1-11- Environmental Checklist �r�c' AnP AJvTaS Conditional Use Project Name Capital Naples Park 1. Is the project is in compliance with the overlays, districts and/or zoning on the subject site and/or the surrounding properties? (CON, ST, PUD, RLSA, RFMU, etc.) (LDC 2.03.05-2.03.08; 4.08.00) Not in CV Library 2. Submit a current aerial photograph (available from the Property Appraiser's office) and clearly delineate the subject site boundary lines. If the site is vegetated, provide FLUCFCS overlay and vegetation inventory identifying upland, wetland and exotic vegetation (Admin. Code Ch. 3 G.1. Application Contents 424). FLUCFCS Overlay -P627 3. Clearly identify the location of all preserves and label each as "Preserve" on all plans. (LDC 3.05.07.A.2). Preserve Label- P546 4. Provide calculations on site plan showing the appropriate acreage of native vegetation to be retained, the max. amount and ratios permitted to be created on -site or mitigated off -site. Exclude vegetation located within utility and drainage easements from the preserve calculations (LDC 3.05.07.B-D; 3.05.07.F; 3.05,07.H.1.d-e). Preserve Calculation - P547 5. Created and retained preserve areas shall meet the minimum width requirements per LDC 3.05.07.H.1.b. Preserve Width - P603 6. Retained preservation areas shall be selected based on the criteria defined in LDC 3.05.07.A.3, include all 3 strata, be in the largest contiguous area possible and shall be interconnected within the site and to adjoining off -site preservation areas or wildlife corridors. (LDC 3.05.07.A. 1 -4) Preserve Selection- P550 7. Principle structures shall be located a minimum of 25' from the boundary of the preserve boundary. No accessory structures and other site alterations, fill placement, grading, plant alteration or removal, or similar activity shall be permitted within 10' of the boundary unless it can be shown that it will not affect the integrity of the preserve (i.e. stem wall or berm around wetland preserve). Provide cross -sections for each preserve boundary identifying all site alterations within 25'. (LDC 3.05.07.H.3; 6.01.02.C.) Preserve Setback —New 8. Wildlife survey required for sites where an EIS is not required, when so warranted. (LDC 10.02.02.A.2.f) Listed Species - P522 9. Provide Environmental Data identifying author credentials, consistency determination with the GMPs, off -site preserves, seasonal and historic high water levels, and analysis of water quality. For land previously used for farm fields or golf course, provide soil sampling/groundwater monitoring reports identifying any site contamination. (LDC 3.08.00) Environmental Data Required — P 522 10. Master Plan shall state the minimum acreage required to be preserved. (LDC 10.02.13.A.2) Master Plan Contents-P626 Environmental Data Checklist The Environmental Data requirements can be found in LDC Section 3.08.00 1. Provide the EIS fee if PUD or CU. 2. WHO AND WHAT COMPANY PREPARED THE ENVIRONMENTAL DATA REPORT? Preparation of Environmental Data. Environmental Data Submittal Requirements shall be prepared by an individual with academic credentials and experience in the area of environmental sciences or natural resource management. Academic credentials and experience shall be a bachelor's or higher degree in one of the biological sciences with at least two years of ecological or biological professional experience in the State of Florida. Please include revision dates on resubmittals. Identify on a current aerial, the location and acreage of all SFWMD jurisdictional wetlands according to the Florida Land Use Cover and Forms Classification System (FLUCFCS) and include this information on the SDP or final plat construction plans. Wetlands must be verified by the South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD) or Florida Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) prior to SDP or final plat construction plans approval. For sites in the RFMU district, provide an assessment in accordance with 3.05.07 F and identify on the FLUCFCS map the location of all high quality wetlands (wetlands having functionality scores of at least 0.65 WRAP or 0.7 UMAM) and their location within the proposed development plan. Sites with high quality wetlands must have their functionality scores verified by the SFWMD or DEP prior to first development order approval. Where functionality scores have not been verified by either the SFWMD or DEP, scores must be reviewed and accepted by County staff, consistent with State regulation. 4. Where treated stormwater is allowed to be directed into preserves, show how the criteria in 3.05.07 H have been met. 5. Where native vegetation is retained on site, provide a topographic map to a half foot and, where possible, provide elevations within each of the FLUCFCS Codes identified on site. For SDP or final plat construction plans, include this information on the site plans. Provide when treated stormwater is being directed into preserves (45 above). 6. Provide a wildlife survey for the nests of bald eagle and for listed species known to inhabit biological communities similar to those existing on site. The survey shall be conducted in accordance with the guidelines or recommendations of the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FFWCC) and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS). Survey times may be reduced or waived where an initial habitat assessment by the environmental consultant indicates that the likelihood of listed species occurrence is low, as determined by the FFWCC and USFWS. Where an initial habitat assessment by the environmental consultant indicates that the likelihood of listed species occurrence is low, the survey time may be reduced or waived by the County Manager or designee, when the project is not reviewed or technical assistance not provided by the FFWCC and USFWS. Additional survey time may be required if listed species are discovered Provide a survey for listed plants identified in 3.04.03 Wildlife habitat management and monitoring plans in accordance with 3.04.00 shall be required where listed species are utilizing the site or where wildlife habitat management and monitoring plans are required by the FFWCC or USFWS. These plans shall describe how the project directs incompatible land uses away from listed species and their habitats. Identify the location of listed species nests, burrows, dens, foraging areas, and the location of any bald eagle nests or nest protection zones on the native vegetation aerial with FLUCFCS overlay for the site. Wildlife habitat management plans shall be included on the SDP or final plat construction plans. Bald eagle management plans are required for sites containing bald eagle nests or nest protection zones, copies of which shall be included on the SDP or final plat construction plans. Note: Not required at time of Land use petitions except for Bald Eagle Management Plans. Staff requests management plans for other species are only provided at time of Plat or SDP. Identify on a current aerial the acreage, location and community types of all upland and wetland habitats on the project site, according to the Florida Land Use Cover and Forms Classification System (FLUCFCS), and provide a legend for each of the FLUCFCS Codes identified. Aerials and overlay information must be legible at the scale provided. a. Provide descriptions of each FLUCFCS code Provide calculations for the acreage of native vegetation required to be retained on -site. a. Demonstrate on map. b. Provide a companion chart. Include the above referenced calculations and aerials on the SDP or final plat construction plans. For SDP/Plat provide in a separate report; for land use petition provide in environmental data report the following: demonstrate how the preserve selection criteria pursuant to 3.05.07 have been met. Where applicable, include in this report an aerial showing the project boundaries along with any undeveloped land, preserves, natural flowways or other natural land features, located on abutting properties. 10. Include on a separate site plan, the project boundary and the land use designations and overlays for the RLSA, RFMU, ST and ACSC-ST districts. Include this information on the SDP or final plat construction plans. 11. Identify any Wellfield Risk Management Special Treatment Overlay Zones (WRM-ST) within the project area and provide an analysis for how the project design avoids the most intensive land uses within the most sensitive WRM-STs and will comply with the WRM-ST pursuant to 3.06.00. Indicate that the petition is in compliance with 3.06.00 and does not propose any prohibited uses per LDC 3.06.00. Include the location of the Wellfield Risk Management Special Treatment Overlay Zones on the SDP or final plat construction plans. For land use applications such as standard and PUD rezones and CUs, provide a separate site plan or zoning map with the project boundary and Wellfield Risk Management Special Treatment Overlay Zones identified. 12. For development orders within RFMU sending lands, show how the project is consistent with each of the applicable Objectives and Policies of the Conservation and Coastal Management Element of the GMP. 13. The County Manager or designee may require additional data or information necessary to evaluate the project's compliance with LDC and GMP requirements. (LDC 10.02.02.A.3 f) The following to be determined at preapplication meeting: (Choose those that apply) a. Provide overall description of project with respect to environmental and water management issues. b. Explain how project is consistent with each of the applicable objectives and policies in the CCME of the GMP. c. Explain how the project meets or exceeds the native vegetation preservation requirement in the CCME and LDC. d. Indicate wetlands to be impacted and the effects of the impact to their functions and how the project's design compensates for wetland impacts. e. Indicate how the project design minimizes impacts to listed species. Describe the measures that are proposed as mitigation for impacts to listed species. 14. PUD zoning and CU petitions. For PUD rezones and CU petitions, applicants shall collate and package applicable Environmental Data Submittal Requirements into a single Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) document, prior to public hearings and after all applicable staff reviews are complete. Copies of the EIS shall be provided to the County Manager or designee prior to public hearings. 15. Is EAC Review (by CCPC) required? YES — RFMU Sending Lands requires EAC review Communication Towers a. Ground mounted towers between 75'-199' above natural grade shall not be guyed. (LDC 5.05.09.C.1) guyed towers b. Towers greater than 75' shall require bird diverter devices on each guy wire. Provide details on the site plan of these devices. (LDC 5.05.09.C.2) ClarkeThomas 7t o 1. From: WeeksDavid — �R� Apt udTei �A6tS—N Sent: Thursday, August 09, 2018 12:26 PM To: ClarkeThomas Subject: PL20180002327 (Capital Naples Park CU) - DW pre-app notes Attachments: 818- U comm tower RFMUD Sending.pdf; GMPA std pre-app comments_general.pdf Tom, As we discussed, attached are my CU-GMPA pre-app notes, and a doc I stated in the meeting that I would provide to agent (pertains to GMP____ A_pro`ss). Thnx. David Weeks, AICP, Growth Management Manager Collier County Government, Growth Management Department Zoning Division, Comprehensive Planning Section 2800 North Horseshoe Drive, Naples, FL 34104 phone:239-252-2306; E-fax:239-252-6689 email: david.weeks@colliercountyfl.eov ; Collier County website: www.colliercountyfl.gov N07'E: New email address (above) as of December 9, 2017. "Tell us how we are doing by taking our Zoning Division Survey at http://bit.ly/CollierZonin " C, A er County Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Pre-app Meeting Notes: CU for communication tower (GMPA notes) PL20180002327 (Capital Naples Park CU) 8/8/18 @ 3:00 pm in Conf. Rm C Request: Conditional use for a 220' AGL guyed communication tower and associated 60' x 60' equipment compound. Verizon Wireless will be the anchor tenant. Location: E. side of Benton Rd. N-S and 660' S. of Benton Rd. E-W, ±1.65 mi. W. of Everglades Blvd., 1 % mi. N. of 1-75, in 25-49-27 (Floridian Farm Sites, Tract 122). Site is 5 acres & wooded. Owner: per PAO GIS, Tafara Lodge LLC FLUM: RFMUD Sending Lands, NRPA Overlay, NBMO Zoning: A-MHO-RFMUO Sending Lands-NRPA-NBMO Comprehensive Plan amendment a/k/a Growth Management Plan Amendment (GMPA) notes: • Site is small enough to qualify for a small scale GMPA as provided in Ch. 163.3187, F.S. Must include map amendment and any text amendment must be directly related. • Collier County allows small scale GMPA to be submitted and processed concurrent with companion CU; public notices for both petitions may be done jointly; and, the NIM and public hearings may be held jointly. If the petitions run concurrently, then the effective date of the CU petition would be linked to the effective date of the GMPA petition. • Large scale amendment required if no map amendment included or if text and map amendment but text is not directly related to map amendment (Ch. 163.3184, F.S.). Same allowance for concurrent processing, notices, etc, except the CU petition would be heard at the Adoption stage of the GMPA, not Transmittal stage. • Large scale GMPA subject to 3 amendment cycles per Collier County Resolution 12-234. The submittal deadline for the cycles is the last Friday in February, June and October. • IF the GMPA text specifically "dictates" that the communication tower is allowed by CU for this site, THEN the LDC would not need to be similarly amended (e.g. communication tower shall be allowed on the site subject to conditional use process provided in the LDC). • Data and analysis (D&A) needed to support the amendment. Typically, this includes a needs analysis/market study demonstrating the proposed amendment (uses, densities, intensities) is needed; and, demonstration that the subject site is the appropriate location to fulfill that need (site is within the identified market area, proposed uses are generally compatible with surrounding lands, infrastructure impacts are acceptable or mitigation provided, environmental and cultural impacts are acceptable, the amendment furthers and is not contrary to the goals, purposes and vision of the GMP, etc.). GMPA Possible Options include: • Text only amendment to RFMUD Sending Lands to allow communication tower by CU (applicable to all Sending Lands or could limit to sub -area, e.g. NBMO Sending Lands); large scale GMPA; D&A would need to address all Sending Lands; to avoid need for LDCA, the GMPA would need to include "dictation" language • Text only amendment to RFMUD Sending Lands to allow communication tower by CU only on the described subject site; large scale GMPA; D&A would need to address subject site only; to avoid need for LDCA, the GMPA would need to include "dictation" language • Text and map amendment to RFMUD Sending Lands to allow communication tower by CU only on the described subject site with reference to an inset map of the site; small scale GMPA; D&A would need to address subject site only; to avoid need for LDCA, the GMPA would need to include "dictation" language • Text and map amendment to remove site from RFMUD Sending Lands and create a new subdistrict to allow communication tower by CU in this subdistrict; small scale GMPA; D&A / oFY would need to address subject site only; to avoid need for LDCA, the GMPA would need to include "dictation" language Text and map amendment to remove site from RFMUD Sending Lands and re -designate to prior Agricultural/Rural Mixed Use District, which allows communication towers; small scale GMPA; D&A would need to address subject site only; this may necessitate a rezone of the site to remove RFMUO Sending Lands overlay (and possibly other overlays). [I think this would be the least desirable option from County perspective] Formal pre-app meeting not held and GMPA pre-app fee not paid. Therefore, full GMPA petition fee due at time of submittal (small scale - $9,000; large scale - $16,700; both subject to public notice costs). Notes prepared by: David Weeks, AICP, Growth Management Manager Collier County Government, Growth Management Department Zoning Division, Comprehensive Planning Section 2800 North Horseshoe Drive, Naples, FL 34104 phone:239-252-2306; E-fax:239-252-6689 email: david.weeks(&colliercountyfl.gov ; Collier County website: www.colliercount�fl.gov Collier COMP10- CU comm tower RFMUD Sending GAMES Planning Services\Comprehensive\PRE-APP. meeting noteMpre-app docs&notes 2018 dw/8-9-18 A orLI February 21, 2018 GMP Amendment Pre -application Meeting Standard Comments - General Info & Mostly Non -Commercial The Comprehensive Planning Section schedules all GMP amendment pre -application meetings, which are mandatory, and coordinates the review of all amendment petitions received. Per the current Fee Schedule (effective 1/1/18), the non-refundable pre -application meeting fee is $500.00; it is credited towards the petition fee — if the petition is submitted within nine months. The petition fee is $16,700.00 ($9,000.00 for a small-scale petition), which is non- refundable, plus a proportionate share of the legal advertising costs. For small-scale petitions, there are only two hearings — one each before the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) and Board of County Commissioners (BCC); one legal ad is placed in the Naples Daily News prior to CCPC hearing, and one prior to BCC hearing. For all other amendment petitions, a total of four public hearings are held - Transmittal hearing before CCPC and BCC, and Adoption hearing before same two bodies. The estimated legal advertising costs will be provided to each petitioner and payment will be required prior to advertising for any hearings; any refund due the petitioner after hearings are held will be provided at that time. In addition to the petition fee and legal ad costs noted above, payment must also be made for a Traffic Impact Study Review Fee. This fee should be submitted directly to the Transportation Planning Section. Please see their website at: http://www.colliergov.net/Index.aspx?page=566 and/or contact them for more details. There is cost to advertise for and conduct a Neighborhood Information Meeting, and to post a public hearing notice(s) (sign(s)). Chapter 10 of the Land Development Code (LDC) and requires the petitioner of a site -specific GMP amendment to hold a Neighborhood Information Meeting (NIM); this would occur after a finding of sufficiency of the petition submittal but prior to the first public hearing. The LDC also requires the petitioner of a site -specific GMP amendment to post a notice(s) of the public hearings on the property, for both Transmittal and Adoption hearings. The tri-annual amendment cycle is established by Resolution 12-234. The submittal deadline is 5:00 p.m. on the last Friday in the months established by the BCC (for 2013 — 2018, February. June. October). Some amendment petitions are exempt from the tri-annual cycle — may be submitted and processed at any time; these include, but are not limited to, DRI-related amendments and small-scale amendments. A small-scale amendment is limited to a parcel <10 acres, and is limited to a map amendment only and any directly -related text; the map amendment cannot result in a conflict between the map and text — there can be no internal inconsistency in the GMP. (Note: Notwithstanding the significant changes made in 2011 (HB7207) to Ch. 163, Florida Statutes, Collier County limits amendments to the tri-annual amendment cycle noted above, and continues to consider demonstration of need and reduction in greenhouse gas in evaluating GMP amendments.) For the most part, there is no guidance/criteria/standards provided in the GMP by which to review amendments for consistency; an exception is for significant impacts upon public facilities as provided for in Policy 1.1.2 of the CIE. However, Chapter 163, F.S., does provide guidance. Note particularly the requirement to provide appropriate data and analysis. Generally, staff reviews for, and an applicant should adequately address in the submittal: • Appropriateness of uses/compatibility with surrounding area. • Impact upon surrounding properties — will it make them less developable under their present FLUM designation? Will it create a domino effect leading to future designation changes on the surrounding properties? February 21, 2018 • Need for the designation change — data and analysis, e.g. market demand study for commercial uses, to demonstrate the change is warranted, that more inventory of the requested uses is needed. Too often, the data only demonstrates the petition site is viable for the proposed uses ("build it & they will come") rather than demonstrate there is a need for a new or expanded GMP provision to provide for the proposed uses, and that the need is at the subject location. The data should be specific to the proposed land uses, proposed trade service area, persons per household in subject area, etc. as applicable. It is recognized there is more than one acceptable methodology, e.g. radial distance from site (ULI standards for neighborhood/community/regional commercial centers), drive time, etc. Regardless of methodology, the raw data needs to be submitted to allow staff to review it for completeness and accuracy (sometimes parcels are omitted, double counted, included when shouldn't be, etc.). Also, as with all submitted documents, maps of trade service area need to be legible and include adequate identification features, e.g. major roads, Section- Township -Range. • Whether there is a specific or general community vision that the amendment addresses, e.g. a redevelopment area. • The proposed amendment should correlate to the results of the needs analysis. Too often a need is demonstrated for one set of uses but the amendment is for other uses or goes beyond those uses for which a need is demonstrated (e.g., need is for rental apartments but amendment allows multifamily uses generally). • LOSS (level of service standards) impacts upon public facilities — roads, potable water, sanitary sewer, drainage, solid waste, parks & recreation facilities, etc. • Within the above is consideration of site -specific impacts, e.g. impact upon wetlands and listed species habitats on -site and nearby; and, traffic impacts (operational/safety) from the traffic volume generated/attracted and/or the ingress/egress points - turning movements, median openings, traffic signals, etc. Included within this would be a comparison between impacts that would be expected under the existing zoning and/or FLUM designation vs. that which could be expected under the proposed amendment. • Consistency/conformity/harmony with other Goals, Objectives, Policies (GOPs) and provisions in the Element being amended and any other Element of the GMP relevant to the petition, as well as any other applicable regulations (e.g. Manatee Protection Plan, specific LDC provisions). • Furtherance of existing GOPs relevant to the petition. • Furtherance of any other plans or designations that is applicable or relevant to the petition (e.g. a redevelopment plan, Area of Critical State Concern, Rural Area of Opportunity). • Energy efficiency and conservation, reduction of greenhouse gases, reduction of vehicle miles travelled, etc., as [previously] required in HB 697 (2008). • GMP amendment provisions/requirements for a comprehensive plan and plan amendment in Ch. 163.3177(1)(f), and 163.3177(6)(a)2. and 8., F.S. It is important to carefully organize the amendment package; be sure all exhibits are consistently labeled, are in the proper order, and are correctly referenced on the pages of the application. For site -specific amendments, be sure to clearly identify the subject site, include North arrow and scale, and source. A petition narrative is often helpful. Collier County Comprehensive Planning Section 2800 North Horseshoe Drive // Naples, FL 34104 // Phone: 239-252-2400 website: https://www.colliercountvfl.gov/your-government/divisions-a-e/comprehensive-planning GMPA sid pre-app comments —general G:�CDDS Planning Services�Cmnprehensive�Comp Planning GMP DATA�Comp Plan Amendmenls�GMPA Pr -App Standard Comments dw/2-21.18 of 7 Co ter C014nty Growth Management Department Zoning Division Applicant/Agent may also send site plans or conceptual plans for review in advance if desired. PL20180002327 — Capital Naples Park Communications Tower(CU) - PRE-APP INFORMATION Assigned Ops Staff: Thomas Clarke Camden Smith,(Ops Staff) STAFF FORM FOR SUPPLEMENTAL PRE -APPLICATION MEETING INFORMATION • Name and Number of who submitted pre-app request Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. o/b/o Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC 800 Tarpon Woods Blvd. Suite E-1 Palm Harbor, FL 34685 941.685.3770 mjahn@thelawmpowered.com Agent to list for PL# Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. o/b/o Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC 800 Tarpon Woods Blvd. Suite E-1 Palm Harbor, FL 34685 941.685.3770 mjahn@thelawmpowered.com • Owner of property (all owners for all parcels) 32634720009 TAFARA LODGE LLC 3585 41ST AVE NE Naples, FL 34120 • Confirm Purpose of Pre-App: (Rezone, etc.) Conditional Use for communication tower Please list the density request of the project if applicable and number of homes/units/offices/docks (any that apply): Capital Telecom respectfully requests a pre -application meeting to discuss a proposed 220' AGL guyed communication tower and associated 60' x 60' equipment compound on parcel # 32634720009. Verizon wireless will be the anchor tenant. • Details about Project: Conditional Use (CU)- REQUIRED Supplemental Information provided by: Name: Mattaniah S. Jahn Title: Agent of Record Email: mjahn@thelawmpowered.com Phone: 941.685.3770 Created April 5, 2017 " Location: K:\CDES Planning Services\Current\Zoning Staff Information Zoning Division • 2800 North Horseshoe Drive • Naples; Florida 34104.239.252-2400 • w *..cdiergov net Colder County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT www.collierizov.net 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX: (239) 252-6358 Pre -Application Meeting and Final Submittal Requirement Checklist for: ❑ A Conditional Use to be heard by the Planning Commission and Board of Zoning Appeals ❑ A Minor Conditional Use to be heard by the Office of the Hearing Examiner Chapter 3 C.1. of the Administrative Code The following Submittal Requirement Checklist is to be utilized during the Pre -Application Meeting, and at time of application submittal. At time of submittal, the checklist is to be completed and submitted with the application packet. Please provide the submittal items in the exact order listed below, with cover sheets attached to each section. Incomplete submittals will not be accepted. Requirements for Review # Of Copies Required Not Required Completed Application (download current form from County website) 1 ZJ ❑ Cover letter briefly explaining the project 1 Pre -Application Notes 1 Affidavit of Authorization, signed and notarized 1 ® ❑ Completed Addressing Checklist 1 ® ❑ Property Ownership Disclosure Form 1 Warranty Deed(s) 1 Boundary Survey 1 Conceptual Site Plan 24" X 36" plus (one 8 Y2 X 11 copy) ❑ Plans showing proposed location for utilities, if required ❑ Plans for screening and buffering the use with reference as to type, dimensions, and character, if required ❑ ❑ Plans showing the proposed landscaping and provisions for trees protected by County regulations, if required ❑ ❑ Plans showing the proposed signs and lighting, including type, dimensions, and if required ❑j LL'�� Elcharacter, Architectural Rendering of Proposed Structure(s), if applicable 1 ❑ Current aerial photographs (available from Property Appraiser) with project boundary and, if vegetated, FLUCFCS Codes with legend included on aerial. 1 ❑ Statement of utility provisions (with all required attachments & sketches) 1Li Environmental Data Requirements, pursuant to LDC section 3.08.00 1 Environmental Data Requirements collated into a single Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) at time of public hearings. Coordinate with project planner at time of public hearing. ❑ IL�"JI/ �j D Listed Species Survey; less than 12 months old. Include copies of previous surveys. 1 Li Traffic Impact Study (TIS) o wai eA 1 Historical and Archeological Survey, or waiver 1 Electronic copy of all documents and plans * Please advise: The Office of the Hearing Examiner requires all materials to be submitted electronically in PDF format. 1 ❑ * If located in the Bayshore/Gateway Triangle Redevelopment Area, include an additional set of each submittal requirement 5/08/2018 Page 8 of 12 Coer County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT www.colliergov.net 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX: (239) 252-6358 ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENTS FOR THE PUBLIC HEARING PROCESS: • Following the completion of the review process by County review staff, the applicant shall submit all materials electronically to the designated project manager. • Please contact the project manager to confirm the number of additional copies required. Dhnnorc• InAirntu if thu nctitinn ncaflc to ho rnntad to the fnllnwinu additional reviewers: ❑ Bayshore/Gateway Triangle Redevelopment: Executive Director ❑ Emergency Management: Dan Summers; and/or EMS: Artie Bay ❑ Conservancy of SWFL: Nichole Johnson GMD Graphics ❑ City of Naples: Robin Singer, Planning Director Utilities Engineering: Eric Fey ❑ Parks and Recreation: Barry Williams ❑ Immokalee Water/Sewer District: ❑ Other: ❑ School District (Residential Components): Amy Lockheart .ommunlcavon I owers: Mosquito Control I ❑ I Collier County Airport Authority Naples Airport Authority Commercial Mining: ❑ 71mpact Fees 5/08/2018 Page 9 of 12 COAT County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 www.colliergov.net (239) 252-2400 FAX: (239) 252-6358 FEE REQUIREMENTS All clicks payable to: Board of County Commissioners Pre -Application Meeting: $500.00 (to be credited towards the application fee if the application is filed within 9 months of pre -application meeting) Conditional Use Application Fee: $4,000.00 o When filed with Rezone Petition: $1,500.00 o Additional fee for 511 and subsequent reviews: 20%of original fee X Comprehensive Planning Consistency Review: $300.00 A/ Environmental Data Requirements -EIS Packet (submittal determined at pre -application meeting): $2,500.00 Listed or Protected Species survey review fee (when an EIS is not required): $1,000.00 Transportation Fee ��ui- d: Methodolo ,i� Fee: $500 o Minor Study Review Fee: $7 0 o Major Study Review Fee• 1,500.00 Estimated Legal Advertising a for the Hearing Examiner or CCPC: $1,125.00 ❑ Estimated Legal Advertising Fee for the BZA, if required: $500.00,7 �7 4�5 /¢ Fire Code Plans Review Fees are collected at the time of application submission and those fees are set forth by the Authority having jurisdiction. The Land Development Code requires Neighborhood Notification mailers for Applications headed to hearing, and this fee is collected prior to hearing. As the authorized agent/applicant for this petition, I attest that all of the information indicated on this checklist is included in this submittal package. I understand that failure to include all necessary submittal information may result in the delay of processing this petition. All checks payable to: Board of County Commissioners. The completed application, all required submittal materials, and fees shall be submitted to: Growth Management Department ATTN: Business Center 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 Agent/Owner Signature Agent/Owner Name (please print) Date 5/08/2018 Page 10 of 12 Comer county COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT www.colliergov.net 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX (239) 252-5724 ADDRESSING CHECKLIST Please complete the following and email to GMD—Addressing@colliergov.net or fax to the Operations Division at 239-252-5724 or submit in person to the Addressing Section at the above address. Form must be signed by Addressing personnel prior to pre -application meeting, please allow 3 days for processing. Not all items will apply to every project. Items in bold type are required. FOLIO NUMBERS MUST BE PROVIDED. Forms older than 6 months will require additional review and approval by the Addressing Section. PETITION TYPE (Indicate type below, complete a separate Addressing Checklist for each Petition type) ❑ BL (Blasting Permit) ❑ SDP (Site Development Plan) ❑ BD (Boat Dock Extension) ❑ SDPA (SDP Amendment) ❑ Carnival/Circus Permit ❑ SDPI (Insubstantial Change to SDP) 0 CU (Conditional Use) ❑ SIP (Site Improvement Plan) ❑ EXP (Excavation Permit) ❑ SIPI (Insubstantial Change to SIP) ❑ FP (Final Plat ❑ SNR (Street Name Change) ❑ LLA (Lot Line Adjustment) ❑ SNC (Street Name Change — Unplatted) ❑ PNC (Project Name Change) ❑ TDR (Transfer of Development Rights) ❑ PPL (Plans & Plat Review) ❑ VA (Variance) ❑ PSP (Preliminary Subdivision Plat) ❑ VRP (Vegetation Removal Permit) ❑ PUD Rezone ❑ VRSFP (Vegetation Removal & Site Fill Permit) ❑ RZ (Standard Rezone) ❑ OTHER LEGAL DESCRIPTION of subject property or properties (copy of lengthy description may be attached) Please see enclosed survey Floridian Farm Sites Tract 122 S25 T49 R27 FOLIO (Property ID) NUMBER(s) of above (attach to, or associate with, legal description if more than one) 3263472-0009 STREET ADDRESS or ADDRESSES (as applicable, if already assigned) N/A • LOCATION MAP must be attached showing exact location of project/site in relation to nearest public road right- of-way • SURVEY (copy -needed only for unplatted properties) CURRENT PROJECT NAME (if applicable) Naples Park Relo Communication Tower PROPOSED PROJECT NAME (if applicable) N/A PROPOSED STREET NAMES (if applicable) N/A SITE DEVELOPMENT PLAN NUMBER (forexisting projects/sites only) SDP_- or AR or PL # 20180002327 Rev 6/9/2017 Page 1 of 2 CiOLl7EY C;014 .ty COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT www.collierizov.net 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX (239) 252-5724 Project or development names proposed for, or already appearing in, condominium documents (if application; indicate whether proposed or existing) N/A - Communication Tower Please Return Approved Checklist By: 0 Email ❑ Fax ❑ Personally picked up Applicant Name: Capital Telecom c/o Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, P.A. Phone: 727-773-2221 Email/Fax: mjahn@thelawmpowered.com Signature on Addressing Checklist does not constitute Project and/or Street Name approval and is subject to further review by the Operations Division. FOR STAFF USE ONLY Folio Number 32634720009 Folio Number Folio Number Folio Number Folio Number Folio Number Approved by: Date: 11/19/2018 Updated by: Date: IF OLDER THAN 6 MONTHS, FORM MUST BE UPDATED OR NEW FORM SUBMITTED Rev. 6/9/2017 Page 2 of 2 INSTR 5253717 OR 5262 PG 3738 RECORDED 4/15/2016 4:43 PM PAGES 2 DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA DOC@.70 $980.00 REC $18.50 CONS $140,000.00 Return to: Michael J. Snyder & Associates, PA 4000 Hollywood Blvd, Ste 455-S Hollywood, FL 33021 954-374-5678 File Number: 615072 Will Call No.: Above This Line For Recording Trustee's Deed This Trustee's Deed made this twee Individually and as Trustee of the Pair&- sentino Revocable Tr to ch ed address is 390 S.E. 28th Avenue, Pomp�ano ,Reach-+L,�3062, grantor, an Cy h Barry P. Winsor, a married man, as joint tendnts vrth fulri t$ of su vol* Indigo Lakes Circle, Naples, FL 341i9 grameeee,,, q = (Whenever used herein the terms grantor and giantee clride all the art s to iOnstrl"im t a the heir. and the successors and assigns of corporations, irk d 4stosk, U n Paul A. Cosentino, a married man, February 11, 2009, whose post office is A. Tantum, a married woman and hip whose post office address is 14583 legal representatives, and assigns of individuals, Wltnesseth, that said grantor, for ancnbtlnsideration of the sumNNII Ialia?/00 DOLLARS ($10.00) and other good \p and valuable considerations to said graantctt an paid by said gi^ I'tiee, the taipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, has granted, bargained, and sold to the said gr een, aid grantees heirs and as,� fprever, the following described land, situate, lying and being in Collier County, Florida, �i Tracts 119, 120 and 122, Floridian Farm' i,wcing to the map or plat therof as recorder in Plat Book 4, Page 33, Public Records of Collier County, Florida. Folio Number: 32634600006; 32634640008 and 32634720009 Together with all the tenements, hereditaments and appurtenances thereto belonging or in anywise appertaining. To Have and to Hold, the same in fee simple forever. And the grantor hereby covenants with said grantee that the grantor is lawfully seized of said land in fee simple; that the grantor has good right and lawful authority to sell and convey said land; that the grantor hereby fully warrants the title to said land and will defend the same against the lawful claims of all persons claiming by, through or under grantors. Subject to taxes for 2016 and subsequent years; covenants, conditions, restrictions, easements, reservations and limitations of record, if any. Grantor warrants that at the time of this conveyance, the subject property is not the Grantor's homestead within the meaning set forth in the constitution of the state of Florida, nor is it contiguous to or a part of homestead property. Grantor's residence and homestead address is: 390 S.E. 28th Avenue, Pompano Beach, FL 33062. In Witness Whereof, grantor has hereunto set grantor's hand and seal the day and year first above written. i DoubleTimee *** OR 5262 PG 3739 *** Signed, sealed and delivered in our presence: �0- State of Florida County of Broward Paul A. sp�itin�(i ev B )k Trust February 1 l , 2009 �i.� J Y: IA. C sentino, Trustee The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this q day of Trustee of Paul A. Cosentino Revocable Trust, dated 9, c or [X] has produced a driver's license as identifi ry t T A" T [Notary Seal] 6t by Paul A. Cosentino, of said firm. He L] is personally known ',,MIS , 0� S Notary PubqSta of Florida e * N' ecPIREs 1 me Name: J t : �. .. is on xvites: June 21. 2019 Trustee's Deed - Page 2 DoubleTime® PL#20180002327 Parcels contiguous to parcel # 3263472-0009 under common ownership: Parcel# S/T/R Legal Description • 3263460-0006 25/49S/27E Tract # 119 of Floridian Farm Estates, PB# 4 Pg. 33 • 3263476-0001 25/49S/27E Tract # 123 of Floridian Farm Estates, PB# 4 Pg. 33 • 3263456-0007 25/49S/27E Tract # 118 of Floridian Farm Estates, PB# 4 Pg. 33 INSTR 5306214 OR 5308 PG 869 RECORDED 8/29/2016 3:39 PM PAGES 2 DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA DOC@.70 $4,620.00 REC $18.50 CONS $660,000.00 Prepared by and return to: Feinstein & Sorota, P.A. 7901 S.W. 6 Court Suite 305 Plantation, FL 33324 954-617-1500 File Number: 16-Tarshish-GCT Will Call No.: Parcel Identification No. 39781080006 Above This Line For Recording Warranty Deed (STATUTORY FORM - SECTION 689.02, F.S.) This Indenture made this 19th day of August, 201,6_.between Tarshish Capital, LLC, a Connecticut corporation whose post office address is 7901 SW 6 Court , air Q foj Lj ale, FL 33324 County of Hillsbourough, State of Florida 33457, grantor*, and Tafara Lodger,a Florida corpo'ritl *'whose post office address is 3893 Mannix Dr, 505, Naples, FL 34114 of the County of Col is ,State of Florida, granted � Witnesseth that said grantor, for ante in !ion afthe sum of TEN ND"10/100 DOLLARS ($10.00) and other good and valuable considerations to said grantor m hart pa d, y said rantee, t e rei�eipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, has granted bargained, and sold to the s4dgf�e at��ib� designs orever, the following described land, situate, lying and being in Collier Co a yj latrtda,ito-wits THE WEST 75 FEET OF kI E`AS ' 50'A4- -'f ACT`*7-. (I� N GATE ESTATES, UNIT 62, ACCORDING TO THI PL;T THEREOF RECORbED I11 PLAT BOOK 5, PAGE 87 OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF CO`LW `2 COUNTY, FLORID and 11 ° tF fs THE EAST 180 FEET OF THE TRACT 1 A1�1Dg, "HE, 1~9P 180 FEET OF THE TRACT 87 AND THE EAST 75 FEET OF THE WEST I50'�tOF THE TRACT 74, UNIT 62, OF GOLDEN GATE ESTATES, ACCORDING TO THE PLAT THEREOF RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 5, PAGE 87 OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA. said grantor does hereby fully warrant the title to said land, and will defend the same against lawful claims of all persons whomsoever. "Grantor" and "Grantee" are used for singular or plural, as contest requires. In Witness Whereof, grantor has hereunto set grantor's hand and seal the day and year first above written. Signed, sealed and delivered in our presence: DoubleTimee *** OR 5308 PG 870 *** Tarshish Capital,�LLC, a Connecticut corporation By: ..�. Witness Name: John r ites, Jr. itness Name: (Corporate Seal) State ofk4eAda— (!tAl)C County of 4;Qwar4-- � V—' �—' a The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this 19th day of August, 2016 by John C Sites, Jr. of Tarshish Capital, LLC, a Florida corporation, on behalf of the co oration. e he [j is personally known to me or [X] has produced a driver's license as identification. PRI [Notary Seal] Not PU1 Name: C. NUNES LRYP,N EXPIRES M 1'A1'A 31, 2020 Warranty Deed (Statutory Form) - Page 2 DoubleTim" WRITTEN CONSENT IN LIEU OF A MEETING OF THE MEMBERS OF CAPITAL TELECOM HOLDINGS H, LLC (each, a "Company" and together, the "Companies") THE UNDERSIGNED, constituting all of the members of the Company (the "Members") hereby consent to, and adopt, the following resolutions by this instrument in lieu of a formal meeting: WHEREAS, the Company is in the business of the ownership of wireless communications facilities (including communications towers); and WHEREAS, from time to time it may be in the interests of the Company to execute and deliver applications for credit, certificates of insurance, contractor capability statements, proposals, customer contracts, construction contracts, subcontracts, payment and performance bonds, contractor license applications, business license applications, zoning applications, and similar instruments (the "Applicable Instruments") with third parties in connection with such business; r NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that, with respect solely and exclusively to the property located in Collier County, Florida; identified by Parcel # 32634720009, Vincent Casiero, authorized signor of the Company, is hereby authorized and directed, in the name and on behalf of the Company, to take or to cause to be taken, any and all actions necessary to sign, seal, deliver, negotiate, accept and perform any of the Applicable Instruments or assignments or any of the foregoing and any other instruments or documents consistent with the foregoing purposes (all of which are to be in such form and substance as the person executing the same may deem necessary or desirable, the execution thereof by such person to be conclusive evidence of the approval of such form and substance by such person), and to do any and all things necessary or appropriate in connection with or in furtherance of the foregoing resolution, and that the signature of Vincent Casiero on the foregoing documents or instruments shall be conclusive evidence of his authority to take or to cause to be taken any and all actions necessary to sign, seal deliver, negotiate, accept, and perform such documents and instruments; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the foregoing resolution shall remain in effect until revoked by the directors of the Company. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the undersigned hereby affix their hands and seal effective as of April 3, 2019 NAME OF MEMBER COMPANY 1: Diamond Communicati ns LLC B Printed Name: Gene Grieco Title: Secretary and General Counsel NAME OF MEMBER COMPANY 2 N/A Printed Name: Exhibit A 60' X 60' LEASE AREA: (AS SURVEYED) An lease area being a portion of Tafara Lodge, LLC, A Florida Limited Liability Company tract described as Tract 122 in Plat Book 4, Page 33 recorded in the Public Records Office in Collier County, Florida situated in the Northwest 1/4 of Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East in said County and being more particularly described as follows; COMMENCE at a 5/8" rebar found marking the Southwest corner of said Tract 122 and on the Easterly right-of-way line of Benton Road; Thence along said right-of-way line, N 00°52'46" E a distance of 122.87 feet to a point; Thence leaving said right-of-way line, N 90°00'00" E a distance of 100.00 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING; Thence N 00°00'00" W a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 90°00'00" E a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence S 00°00'00" E a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 90°00'00" W a distance of 60.00 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING. Containing 3,600 square feet (0.08 acres) of land more or less. 20' INGRESS/EGRESS AND UTILITY EASEMENT: (AS SURVEYED) An easement being a portion of Tafara Lodge, LLC, A Florida Limited Liability Company tract described as Tract 122 in Plat Book 4, Page 33 recorded in the Public Records Office in Collier County, Florida situated in the Northwest 1/4 of Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East in said County and being more particularly described as follows; COMMENCE at a 5/8" rebar found marking the Southwest corner of said Tract 122 and on the Easterly right-of-way line of Benton Road; Thence along said right-of-way line, N 00°52'46" E a distance of 122.87 feet to a point; Thence leaving said right-of-way line, N 90°00'00" E a distance of 100.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 00°00'00" W a distance of 30.00 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING of an easement being 20 feet wide and lying 10 feet on each side of the following described centerline; Thence N 90°00'00" W a distance of 99.55 feet more or less, to a point on the Easterly right-of-way line of Benton Road (public right-of-way) and the POINT OF ENDING. Containing 1,991.03 square feet (0.05 acres) of land more or less. 30' GUY EASEMENT "A": (AS SURVEYED) An easement being a portion of Tafara Lodge, LLC, A Florida Limited Liability Company tract described as Tract 122 in Plat Book 4, Page 33 recorded in the Public Records Office in Collier County, Florida situated in the Northwest 1/4 of Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East in said County and being more particularly described as follows; COMMENCE at a 5/8" rebar found marking the Southwest corner of said Tract 122 and on the Easterly right-of-way line of Benton Road; Thence along said right-of-way line, N 00°52'46" E a distance of 122.87 feet to a point; Thence leaving said right-of-way line, N 90°00'00" E a distance of 100.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 00°00'00" W a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 90°00'00" E a distance of 12.68 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING of an easement being 30 feet wide and lying 15 feet on each side of the following described centerline; Thence N 30°00'00" W a distance of 101.22 feet to the POINT OF ENDING. Containing 3,078.08 square feet (0.07 acres) of land more or less. 30' GUY EASEMENT "B": (AS SURVEYED) An easement being a portion of Tafara Lodge, LLC, A Florida Limited Liability Company tract described as Tract 122 in Plat Book 4, Page 33 recorded in the Public Records Office in Collier County, Florida situated in the Northwest 1/4 of Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East in said County and being more particularly described as follows; COMMENCE at a 5/8" rebar found marking the Southwest corner of said Tract 122 and on Exhibit A the Easterly right-of-way line of Benton Road; Thence along said right-of-way line, N 00°52'46" E a distance of 122.87 feet to a point; Thence leaving said right-of-way line, N 90°00'00" E a distance of 100.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 00°00'00" W a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 90°00'00" E a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence S 00°00'00" E a distance of 30.00 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING of an easement being 30 feet wide and lying 15 feet on each side of the following described centerline; Thence N 90°00'00" E a distance of 106.04 feet to the POINT OF ENDING. Containing 3,180.00 square feet (0.07 acres) of land more or less. 30' GUY EASEMENT "C": (AS SURVEYED) An easement being a portion of Tafara Lodge, LLC, A Florida Limited Liability Company tract described as Tract 122 in Plat Book 4, Page 33 recorded in the Public Records Office in Collier County, Florida situated in the Northwest 1/4 of Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East in said County and being more particularly described as follows; COMMENCE at a 5/8" rebar found marking the Southwest corner of said Tract 122 and on the Easterly right-of-way line of Benton Road; Thence along said right-of-way line, N 00°52'46" E a distance of 122.87 feet to a point; Thence leaving said right-of-way line, N 90°00'00" E a distance of 100.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 00°00'00" W a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 90°00'00" E a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence S 00°00'00" E a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 90°00'00" W a distance of 47.32 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING of an easement being 30 feet wide and lying 15 feet on each side of the following described centerline; Thence S 30°00'00" W a distance of 101.23 feet to the POINT OF ENDING. Containing 3,059.25 square feet (0.07 acres) of land more or less. I also confirmed that you can upload your documents when you have them by dropping down the conditions tab under this planning application. Please let me know if you run into any problems when submitting them. ■ cvportal.coliiercaurLO gov/Cit} cw VVeb/Planning/SlatusReferexe?referenceNumber4P12018=327 -[onditlon� i CAdi%hln*S Ftrr E*Wwlcally $uhnwiting Docurnents: 5fi"1060AS Wen t4n4SC4p# The 70ya, w4d* bolls Shame no D7xumenAs: rFJp�dalipns Olen COWAY +Lttwnwv Q%cr Nligt5p4ft+00G OGCn Inform iti4r! �9eeSinp �li111) Documentt #rpUlld C1w Ouy irrL#50l� ih irrl br riglpy*p #i4rr1 th! #1�iL �88ncelpkuiF prih to #YiGW 1`AYhiLSlM, Teri Is fnmknurn bsd`fer r�drh regn�lred araun� IIFe �uY ■ndlers. ]IrsL a 3' high Ire+dp,e t� sfinlhs spaced 3` -- q, � wOr+lnp IiCxLirsO a NN9hDOr6400 Inlo[mtLion �ieelinq {!Vi#�} I� rrpuked for this appliciHdn t!F*� To reserve 1-his randiCiarr, please uRkoad All supR4itln-p 1'�IN deeurnrnls #reel me�l�np La tllr GM8 9,.hlit Lkrrlal- Cm#aet WynneF pi fhi} yr4�eCC �9{ iddlt4pasrl qu�itinns- 11 k0� la�plrrirtnc! I�SulS uorp*dlnq, plrtssrt Coma Cert>r4 5#r+rkrtf rt . {7�4} 3S3. 1436, brl}prrpiG4+�il liprtn {arrlpirthrtnS�x. �ObIF'TIMk1 P�i�r+IhO p DMMrrrlMMJ% Lbd"M r Upland Dommerift Have a great weekend! Respectfully, c7ssica Velageo Client Services, Project Coordinator The sccess Ln0 w1ilClirtS s#i�*�nrt++t;grrt4mtnk lrpm leaftf t# xvi A. i f+hgr# 'WO Mltn to Q$it4t TflOrOrri r#atftys, LLC nerds s lrgal &-rAOD,n and execution and rrrwghw biome Lht puhlk heaT4.(lae woodland Estates oa,I SO@ Comp kl#eran0 {OeS $141%rY Rpvl�r 1410W In Of DKV-enlsfttzkm LWG" DDCWM:" 7 F—O it Ji O ammo ¢3w �O o Y lw ��oLLoz�o^� U LLLLa o� �0 3„� - ado O W rc ~ 'm "o a oo H a w�Wo w� 3 rc�oo�f0� 2 c W$ z z H >z m - 3m CD inM�N�amm f Z � W3�w�ow Q zo o ��wmNo�z- W p zz z wim zNwNo o z N gw o m- mamw�w~� W W W W z z- a o m �_ m "' o oz ? am a o 0 0 ��omow w x3a¢ c p w x m ¢ z a �rz mar 0 O z N< Z Z a m 0 a 3 Q_ 0 o g U 3 z U>> �� z<wzo M O¢ N 3 oo�NNN - x� _ o _ a o 3 w _o ci6 waIw rQ ¢<pwr OUN> Z O am Fa FO FO �Wm m �¢ y Q U) L� W U z J JQO N Z O O O Q r w d ro ZO O x¢ N 30 Z w O p _ ?o3 0o zao z_oz ¢ o of �oz�?�xN Q W c L z O Q cc Q G W O w~U= m aU¢ m0 m i- o�F N o cwi ovwi inoao3. wi o ¢ tt ¢ W p O O Q _ 'mzw ¢m x J ow �o s ��>aworm f ¢ a - s O O W U U �3 om'o a z 3 3�ow w o mF m< / n J v/ W W W O W O ai�c� moo ww °' w w w�wo ¢�n� aw��wm o p ��nw�oza w-^mzwm ado fn H w z ¢m �o o � W w W_ Z J W W W z aozw zw waama z o oa Joaw�� Q ~ 1. a o00 _> n k nN Z n W n W J m W O O U) U aNm _moww�3miwv,aw owa 5 °� ��w� m�J ��ao�o m m m I AWN o Fr jz=zo O .. m w �� a _ - o amm J Wcwio�z_w aaz � � F Eom o�oz_=� aw w � o>oN�aWm? > rn n w Jn w a m m zmn Z N W NQomw 3 w w m J < a of Nw"m gw�-'vwi i�a a w 3 uxi oQ�� w ao o Jaoo m o z na_' w_ 3 ¢ o 'ow o z z Y z¢ o Now a w o 30 LLI oo�<<n ¢'N^z mw az vro wa inNj Lwow p� 3 o > ¢ i� oz =wa Nooww�� JW Z i,i W .. a Y p m ¢ F E - Y om - " z o o awa F r Z¢Qx W O U) O os-oww M,1a amm rz ww zo z z o iozamNiaz r U�¢¢wm HU¢U??H¢¢ - ¢ N r Q a< o p O w m z z F w a¢ 3 p o f ¢o¢ M W O a n <o n m ¢ �s a 5¢ c� c� ws o asma 00 0 <� N J O no ¢zw w _. z Fz ovzOm vim 3 -mm O m0 N6oJ ZQ Fo F wOHw 6w O�Om�wtt wZ0 N. z3 ow OZ_N o_ O z ~ a m O w Q am o�w c> am 2r wF�6UDU0 _ r H gN� -�mmz z�a�4F� Zwo K m w Z Y K W- z W w�� o �z Q nM � a LLJ as �° m zzw. wo No wNz o W w. p PiIw m w W Q Z O r m o F OQo w w o =wm wm w 3 p w F~ w m �oN�oGN� Nc> = 0 m Q o 0 6 �Z zo oU gviz C� "� W �N �wi o o w w n m o a w = o o oUw. ao o wow Fo ¢ow - } W _= J m oQa-o u� _ c> Z ss Q wc>om� -- w a �o- O x¢oaa 'm a o U �wzwozz z w,. o, I w a i¢oW�Nao z NNww c� o 0 ww¢a a zz m=oa a�Jo oN w W O W J N�mo ¢ o s W W �Qo m 'zoo p .. D- iQ QM-- mo z Q a of "' Ym Nw vaz�i 0000� w-o a o 3N�wz0 o3mU m a¢aoz w zow z41j �zw z > om¢ w_aIm �rcNo mo owa W w N N Q Naz w - >Fo w $ o z� a��z O ozo��oap� wm as cram waw o taw �¢vri N O o?g 3 Uw wK a��N=�=w F N= O o U -ZOw O - = _ w N F 3 Z Q w o O OmZorz�w oo��,�,�w O K m U a Q W O K wO NwZ QU3 w �� wN o� J - oaNw �� w o < J wmw� o a O O O 5w o w wza'ww mm z naG? �w N�xww ?�w�w w> a � o o O U >�z zWm U�o m \ \ W W z Z O 6 O � owm «m Q Q w m�. J J W �iN w Q � z o o�s� o o <�ow W o > z > Z o- owo w y o <�,_ V U O =Qow Z N �N O J r H m ZO o H ti U o ZwO O - w J w ��1N i amino a3w oa�wSo 5:L' m 0 W Y W O w a N U H w vi =��a�ox3 0 i'n _ L'm Wmw m3N OKO�Z�� cV ago ivo-��oowW Qo<wmw O k$ - W —wE� z�w.a �awwazNza - W p Q O C.D r z dam o C J z,n�zuxiam�o� Z oo 3d�wowo� \ s�P o&m wU woow�o a w 3 "ooa Ox 2 - c m,m ~ O wUl oN - O - '� °u �w mwwazciQttwmaO m U3 WLA i L- L €�- / F um ain�ozawaw�¢>m m v x Qo U °'o U 3 xz f N a s a Q - 3a O Q m oa aaz U � ¢ 0 S o Z K ¢ H E N o N o ' w Z o O o Q 2 -= o m w0 U VI F s O O 2 mwo Q w - U z o - Q a o Q Q Q M N Q a E Q a Z j N J i ti w oa o 6 O o� ¢ Q O F J 3 w� S Z N3m 3o 3 o a 3 a 3 z 3 ao o o H Q ow �z aJ w¢a mQ J ow Wo m -. E cwi w o m o F 3 wQ- o o SV 0 oQm o m Y Q Q p ' 3 U m a Q Fp O�xil ¢m O0p aN'� z No 0 o f rc - o'. ¢ 3 x o ; m o z o aw o ttZ 0 s w 3a W, a IF ww w� F zw� a w "' a o z - ¢o mo Q U¢ N z o w 5 2 Q UI z z 3 o J YO wtt 0 o xa o aZm o�m a< z z w a> o a o z_ a - m mm a ut o o az - 3� o 30z a N o o f a = m o a U - > O 4 "'J z �x of 3¢ K }m aF ¢wa ca.� - o Iz mo ao OZo wao < o > - o �m = z o ~w oog 1. a 'oiz ? woa z o m - z _ o o ¢o o 'o x Zi �FE zmo a w z_3 w'o O o O o- - m _ ¢ z w W U Z = a aw ooa _ ~ w w_ Q m~m I o Q K wa o OU Q z O - a - o ~O a - 'o m U OF 3 ww a 3w ozz� 6zi z o 3'w ~z o �ow __ z� w m wa o Q o _ a o w o _ �n �� o _ mm woo Ko ¢ o �o a N w� Z z 0¢ S N o J 0 0 Q O p �i. m O U r m Oo N - Ox W U Z z x O o Z N I -so tt -_ m w QQ�w O U - Q Q V w m O Z wQ E OZ Q w - w0 U Z w r tUn2 Omx w tt3o xw- oF� Y3 a $ ow o �' o O w a m g m N IT 0 M S m ' o w o O UZ Z o� �� - a ¢w o Q000 wa00 OU' OwF ooQ 3�m0 0o F = O¢ O Z _F mo w W. ¢ ?Oo aN OJ rj0z O O of m x m a ¢ Z = O u� o Zz OF FO aw pJO 2 m U �ow i 7 Z o wxo w\ U tt mNoE mc¢ioo oo a cwi a o a w Z ow m w ¢ ro o m m < m aw w 3 o �a O F o �o w m F ',3o O m w _ m� 3 w is O mia a o m - o m UU x o x o o n w <wr, o U a a ow N - caiz o 0 o a �w w= N� < w Qoo c>oa� ttZ mo '� m mtt w xow o w -am Otto `og w mO zO W,o m aZiw Q w o0 - mm - m J U Q N m w ¢ a = W w m o w o x> _ O✓'1 "Y 2U S a mo m ow o K3 S 4w mn o x0 J ma ox Uooz za U pZ ~ OJZ J �' ~ - �00 3m wx O r m O x a O oa z a o U w w x o > Y o 3 3 Q wm "' mp �O am m OU 3 3 O '0 a } W. O � w K Ow wa - m U �mw tt m D m �Zx of 3 O Z.w aF O Z z z -- Now - mcai woo mao m w mm�J mw�m m OQ a F ¢ m W N ao m aN tta o a w >F �3 �M. ~ o Jx J w uxi- m J w¢m F woo 0 oUNz z W W Lj O w O o raw aaa =tea U z\i women O = oo < J o� i O Z tt a x< ' ' rco w m E x, wr o Q miw m o 3 Z mj w F3 i u~i0 \ U _ o� -a F F m K \ o Fw� (n -Jw o z m0=a H in ¢Q 00 5 oww zQo two o cwi oom� o Jw of m xm m Y o 0z� o N m m ¢ w en N < o ¢ a o o 3 3 uxiw N o� m �oz �� 00 �? �'"a �9a o zFoi c> zo J Q az0N3w as io wa Asa -ww wow �wm wa a �txnr a 'zoo z _ o �z w3 >O > �w wz w� wa ¢ ¢¢ wvMi ¢¢ wZ w1 as a¢ w w ?¢ ¢ o min w mN a a Qm? zm o a o F ttc'i o m� �g r� o .I U o� �o oow�< ��m`" moNo CJ aFm m aav'i _ o a��n3 I mo amp - W a and m 6 o w w o 3d m �m ti a xom ¢ _ �m aw wow a vz c� M a 6 co n m m H � N Ilia N <o n ro rn C/') Uww xx -�� w w w UzF 0 '} FzN x O> z xx O N}�jZ U2 00 zZ a Q tt U owm x0 > .O 6v; z_o m owtt tt ww j 3 - wmOa�j ozw�o U¢ Z Z F wow x aw o w w Y O�O tt� Iwn m N o }1 }¢¢�� =ao x�oa O Q O W Q wa }m �xa x =U �Q wa w w O m N b o<wo ¢wp xaw O w 0 t ¢ o a - z _ooa o� Z m 3w zaoz ?J o zw a ;tts wo <z �ma Qo ' w o�mp aowJa zz3 kwz w m �Qo �_ zo8Hw r O Z w r 32525. izw U w K �za'w- U w p N aEw -Kk a J �' Za azl �mw op FN attNU 00 bQ=Z w N �U "Z OOE Zen �Z j a3�Uw Q gadJ Q O�O Q a �o0 OFw a¢ mm3w060 CI Q O w Q Z �mQOQS mUw.riwm KZ- UQZ > Z w 3 w 0 ¢¢moo tea¢¢ �o �w O¢ 0 owoQ z <oz E3 Oo N 5 o -WmK - wow - w o0o NV w J w¢J aaK�d O W yam -- aza wiz o 0 z36x LZ Fam~� w 30o mwQZ �vU-U� =z_w 'n¢K�Jo o ado wFw ¢ oOOF 3 O z w xZ wa au¢iwm o wF xxj¢a 30xo o �Q >Uf REw, ¢rw-Yw- .0o o>xv wai a x Zo�z way} mmz� wK m3 }°'mz ao .0 z maa wo xU 3Jo3a U.-cwiw OF men 1.851 aF =pz tt o0o oow00�0 Qoiw� zz33 ooi ¢a m o Z a m - o a = awc' O oW O I/m1 - 30 o w Q o o 'Doom Jwo a m 0 xo 2 3z 1.O 2 m Z oo�ttoo O o 66, o o�� ¢ Z S O o O Z ~~3azw� O F w O~ <m��F� 9-6 O U P moo w o F en 00= Q O O tt N m w Z d o Z z�oy� W U Z m tt O Ow w>. a> Z Y w N OU a m O mU o- Z f w U� m w a m Z Q __= Z Q Nmc� v� O j Mi U Q o r 0'i a¢ N w r w Z< x z 3 O ZwUE00o ? j 0 5 w U U Z x m m Q w Z 3 w3U1 xow O 4 m w z x 'o o�ui o- ¢ -F �Fm z a also aaz¢ -"'� Y Z FOJZ wJr� �. U ..Qa o�z �2 ao tt 0 V�iZ�EE. Zoo .-Zz 7 w a�oa OOr UQF ~ w oaN¢jlnp oWwwm Q�wwz¢ w~xQ0 J'>iSi� wOw ¢ Q 3"g i� 0 I _mz a >att "' '^ z i ¢ w c¢i y wzoi ~ _w3 of 3 �5ao o~i wwoa mzr �Izo QQo O mmo a wmmz w oa�o oo`w wam ama zQ - awz� m >a'wo -0,.Q 3a aN=a o Y I� o�m ww az��ttax a ao�a� o mzo'z w wa3ow ¢0 w} w o ooa g¢tt — ' o <o w a m oz <aao wy �"�� xw~ ag a i� a awQ� o m� omtt az i�m�J msa$`a' 00 3"00 wttm Ewa ow oNzm _ i o aw vjm 3x tt oww rQa z oN Dina z o i zo o�5 �o a zj ww-a =?F w�oN Qaw_ o'm o-WQ m<�n - w��w .ow oww �� z6 �m wen mo w z �oawa =zi Fo, oo�W. -,Wm �F ��w Uaozow ow¢'o�in� o�Foxo Jj�x� awo F oNz .. w o ?zo o 1U ow ��3 m m 0 o oaaz m m ro uooz o - �a aw¢ cw.� a w QQo? m mm000 ay `~^z tt3w uz mao 9� Zrcovri3 woow 0� 3 wen mwm� ox' o2zo�'n 3m o`~'wo� omw oaowxz m0w��z o ~ww ooa 0 m o0 0�0 �m 00 ooa oSz m m ma- _a mow�m oaao ttzma - momxoxx o o m pmz� ¢ waz 'T cwi m Z0 zN'm att' azm� rao w3w ooia a ' ��om i iHa3 izo moa¢ a Nw< poaU¢ wwo�o ao Z_w v, ac}>-w .�3 woa3zFFQ ow.azz - mwow " mao o 0. zm m -<O otiw m3J mo ¢F asmF - Wow �o wFa �z a z60 Qo"w F a m mol,a moo o o ysoQ oz ¢m as w� w3z O �~'wtc om3 wgoLL mwS3 am ]moo Qom= meow ooaw>o 0,tt'. zE Oa�Nmozw 'winzw zgoam ~ Jim wl.ii m J 2 J w tt I ¢ o ca.�am 2 x ozmm ooa o '4 3= Z w oaJo o ¢ m m O F zw oJz tt 0 Vi0 O O m O - oFa iwo woott viz w w O I w Z a r Q 0 a ooyti o m a r a w O Q o 'o �oN Q r- W g oX.I za wa Q Z Z o a w oaa Q�n aomzz m 0 O Z J m U is m owz awF O w z_ O rNN� 3vi_o a j O tt Y¢ z 0 w O o K ao64mwmw .. wttaw uxi m w- U a o 3wmmaw oiaiz, tt w m Fcttio a z w (n LIJ w O III k U¢ 6 mNwE m zo NN N j - ott O m? QZH} boa Q WuxiE 6 Q V 0= �w ��om o O w o m a 3 00 x � wo U Q "w Z¢�o x wN m z00 Ow a Z O I a wo ag�� az� } 6 �Ow?� �o _ Z a a 03ttZ "awo Z i m F o w O w Joz3 4 w r- O Sa�E- r¢.105 oa o% O oz �a m J 3 O Z o w -Y- O tt �z o Zo O w UI ww�z �Qo m0� s F tt z- �zr LLD z avwi �Uz w w O UZj Om ¢ tt w 0 w"o O tt U zQ� 3 pOZ awo O aow awo U O� o4aw� O F 3jw3U a ino tt mom O UJU 03a mow - oiz�ozw z ooz�m4 amzm Kriwzx o= o H r o 3m0pQo0 Z a W j a m Z �owo pU aaa tt 3 O J Q `'�a z 0 3zo oz�z ¢000 o w wo mmmtt 0 SAo rm 00o wj�z x� oa woaos 'o �m"k ow av'iom Q�� 0¢ o a ao �o�wo aaawa v~i wiooz tto zOFO wi 0 3a}mw 3wwm� mzaLi o�ww¢wo olO�Oz 'aNwow wJ ainNttazm' 0mw owo w 3o a �w �o wo �ma aswomxo� Z W e �o m 0 a CJ arc€ aw s �� =Q3am WFO �mo �_ i Q mLno a3w p¢�wSp 5:L' N O W Y W O w¢ Uxl U H w vi =��a�ox3 0 i'n _OKO�Z�� U "oo o¢ -v_,w a- ago ivo_i�?oo�„w�a oazxw Q O CD > z J`m �J r� �U�.. z,��zuxiaN�p� Z a- 3d�wowo� \ s,P o&m w�U wzow�p a w 3 rc�oo� Ox 2 - c ,0 ; ~ O wL/j �w NWwazciQttwNaO �zOKa W LA i L- L i p RLiZwQ>OU m v N Ln CO p U O 6 0i� Z ~O m OU - �Jtt z 0 a O Q F N Q Y r O¢3 - m �a '.,0 m zw ttQ0 d w m g m3 m m io oo W 00m 0A �0 0 F = O ¢ J O N JO Z - wwK KJ w 0 z = Or to oU OZ ZF �¢ Q w f Q a W O 0 00 m J In¢ w Z w x OQN� m 0�w z ¢ wi Z m o lo ¢ O U Q_ yZ _ p "¢ ti � ti 3Nz z Qi - �z OZUK aU O UZ �1Uw a,0 4 LYZ U O wp w O w ¢ tt _ �3t~iL .0 z O U w Zw N¢ 00 O w p 0 0 2 K w < w a K Q r F Z O U tt m 0 w w ro 3mN p0 o w¢ O E _ a\ p w 0 a ~ w r� o¢ 3o r p Q 4 ¢ Q a U Z' x 6 Q ~ W w p 3 za 0oz QrnJ i� xa �N �Ln Z 3m >w o�z owe wo aww -0 zx Fz �" o� �o W ¢¢o w a o,03 0o ?x �z w o tt haw o w iw aWm mo ajo �� F� O of o a� Q NU BZF �Z pz0 o z� ». �w zo O QJ� 34 J Zo Nlw w U5 p- - 4-j za xLno 0io F i z wo x� �x wp �mN o m=o zx o 00 i 0 - wW 0� U� w N� ¢ _ a m 30¢ LD Z, a ~ o� r Q 3 > 3¢ 0 - N O �w wa sir. aw �. ~ Cx'JX Web NwQo w O ww w ~ ~ N Z r "-p o O O H �x Fw� -F ¢ J z 3 O OJ ZJ w F ZoMo, > _ 0¢ K K Z w Z oFo wN1 fQ Q O o U �¢ N Z x U O U Q O K �� OZ 5: ffi J K O Z w w N 2 tt O i E¢ p Y Vmi O-(&< QZ wp O m Q w� -'z w w Q x 0ZN O - 1. 4 Z ¢ ¢a Zia m 2�w J w O Ka UM -12 z8ZO O UI ¢ w F Q I Z W Z - K p x0 to a F rww �U> - 2 Q ¢.Qw.2 v~i O Ow OpN >N OJ I Oww UI¢OUp wi �O =O�ztt JJ "OLi F O m a F OZ WttS OZow OZU LOwitt O w�N } 0 z 3�tt ¢ 00 w p ~ w¢J �Q� �� w0�0 w ar 0 O r wz. K O O O r m Z KUUp� 7 _ �UIOm w Q p W N, v Q W m x ¢> wQ aO.NO m= w Z O Q w U p w�Q ¢ Q Z ¢ O W d r ¢ mOSQdQ ttwFwwiNz �iN� Z H K - W6ttZ� Zw r oap Mo omwZw¢� ¢- F 00U 0topra�E� 6 tnQ¢ ¢x- z 10a aJorU w- p¢m mNZJ-'� z w�Q ONZjQwZ ¢ Kf�Nw/l' Z za p�3 dO oj zBoa OO OOw�00 o ¢� o�yizFooa¢�a oo -� mW w zoo a.-p w p r z ofm, pNF iow �a�J�o33 z of T F oz za a o (� I?mm w Q �c¢iaz 2 U O 7 F 0Y..0F mj N Z tt r 0> x 0 w Q �wZ Z F V% 1. N - w¢ E N w~ w w U I d N U¢ F ~ Z 0 J F OZ F W w Q d 3 ¢a~w�wi ¢ 0 ¢ �vFmO 0Ll zoz~ or - rno 1pw Gi � ji w; o wa3 o�F O W z Y Q o Lno JW Ow3LJw.i�tx/L z F w� 7Lrwm¢ao3wzr >Q_ 0 a z CD . zoz Wp a o o W z OaFciQo o (ZnX0 aZ J a0 aap o1Zoo o r WQ 3 �o�op 3Qaw�o 5;< W mddL. c� ao¢ 1 JF W N Wo a Q J N O ¢' to Z m Q :E W' W arc€ aw s �� =Q3am WFp �mU 0J i a mmo a3w Oa�wSO 5:L' N O W Y O c��o LLp zro >nn moo �¢ -Nw > ¢mow Q Wwl aIa ivdi�zooW w~zm�apw�W Q k$ Q 0] V�J-=off° �2 - 6LLn \ E�On w¢MUa S wm z I ZQ (r w z Lj = Q ©�m `o \�W U z>OLAJ WaN�o� - Z oo Q � <W °c \_ oo W m d zow�o a 3 rc�oo� Ox Z - .. It a�opLLJ i L- L m v 0 0 ¢ +� +I z� p �as ? I U m a¢ � z o mz3 wono - <n ina o a vv �oz� mo mN wm �o � cnz wo�ri d'om O zmI woJm� X io g�zi ¢z p 0 ogQ\ U� o �� a J bw W N p j z m Q j O O 3 p N a m m N��m NaO uo r. min y, v� ✓ oi¢� 3Nw m wIQ �3 JAI Izm .� KEj OIO OwUU Ja S O U,=Z aO�p m� so d mow oo ma�o ¢c� a �I BE ? wOao maws01, d� 3a I 0 00 :. 1. o J zo z { o as mzo 3w� �o ooa w� F*'z > om '-�o a oraj a o zoa zz z �• azJ z bzo zo w� E �,r z <o�o 0 o zJ 'oo wuz 3 �a a' -am ua� �¢ w o,� o Mom\ vow 3¢ `oN aZ oww �� Ox� ��OK ntto1 wxOo p.: __ y wp Opw :4 p Owl ON �o� o ozo o� aa¢ �'z p �a m 0¢ d p 0 a 0 Q a 3p 4 1 z Z Zz O t� r; wpm a. eta N m < z - - - 000m _ _ � � F �z�� • , , • • , a ma O o? I le O O �Lu t I rr. oz �z dz m a d�ly� zo _ z m' �r..- zo 00 01 ¢ mom ws Y U v p Y� a az a md�z -I -I U ¢ el �I `� `� a o<m o ¢ m l ¢ Q mz mz - - - MUm J aoaw �noap om F F om w m J �o� W? o Cf) o o n�� pwom Mmo? 1p0� K O O d E Z 4 U J 4 (nZ po Ww Jdi- -<wp Wmaw� ¢ps >. (i W ti r H r Z m H r H w H ti r N U O m '-mom a W~ U I o tt 6 l i U I = tt Y Wz o o w' Oo 0 o w 3 Wm o o w 3 <w�a Q3�a w Q W z - p m3¢ dp a3� c. w(jo Qp Z Gaz Z � ZW. °..Z a aoa yl!y 3z C a z - z0 zo I .*00 OU I (L a -I 'I vl o ✓Wi O N �- W m s p rl o o NNW rr., O O K O W p w (n J m d Cn - m o O d O� b O a w w w a/ m a" m O a 0 O x w m d o w m rn w 3 arc€ aw s �� =Q3am WFO �mc> 0J i amino a3w �O WaUx1�O~� >L_ N O � Y - �g Q3� Ott Op Z�� - < ^ ��o Eo zoo Q ® mwoao > a�w ° Y �U z, I? a- �$ - Q J 6LLN \ W�aMOaxwd m I-- ©� dam \0. J r� �U)M�N�ZWaUj�O�O Z a- oNo zl O wUj z .. �W $ ,nWwazcia�w"a -��w Z Z _ iLA Lox a�ooz v * v Y^ o 'o b e� Q ,� [II elI U a -I -I -I -I z -o m z w m W F o a f o m o a ~_ 5 C') o W m o. W J o > �> a Z a a Lu N a W wK O o w w$ O o o w 3 W o o w w o 0-z U o O o z LU ofo z z �o O�o U O -I d 0 .I .I _I O oN 0 fn p W o o W o 0. K U) ILv b O LO b O O lw a d Q. o o w o o w 3 (L o o w 3 d I I I I I I a ' I I lw a U wl m N z * w N O O N o o N O _ _ i i i I i i i i i i i i i i f� • (NJVSAS 83M01) (NOV913S ON10dW0O) • il> i _ 0 i s,OSI :r . J li i i(>IOV9i 90S3M01) i li i i ONNOdWOO )� i (V3dV 3n213S3dd) - _ - s,00b I m J *� � z 0 3 w f 3 O o (V321V 3nd3S3dd) NN o f o o a �,LZ I i ao oz a- w wN o ai 3"¢w a000 wg w3 J wO �z FawW 'o'wa i pl�w'ow wa Fom O O w Q a ro w O Z O - -z NmW J: ZQN - z ao"' oaz ra..a oz a vxi- sQ io -�¢ .F_ Ozz w m- dOO o dro >pp O dxUl z w ~ a 0 - z- 0 0 O O K waw oww3¢ oNw Z w j OX w 0 O a 3 0?0 In Uo 00 ..a m mow wzLL ox w�N a�z H j - s3z o�w o, d�o> ovw W w» I W �Fo aoz maz z<w� i w m N f LJ 11�10. U) arc€ aw� s �� =Q3am WFO �mU � Z i amino a3w OQ�wS� >L- N �ZO OKOo Zo� Q a c��o LLo zro >nn moo �¢ -NW > ¢mow Q 0� W -..LLa o� �0 3n� - U ado iN�zooww a�<Z.w O kg - O N �awwazrnza W rc Z } "dam=o zwo ©s y'<m 0. WJ r"- 21��..z �,�zuwiaN�o� Z oo O ZO U �a oom�wo`w' wig owio Q a 3 rc�oo� Ox Z c K �O� ~ ® ! R �W $ �Wwazcia�w`"aw_��w Z Z m LA i L I €N i � ozw aiooz- my U I I 71 o ¢ o g a oo z wU oU�p w .N>o� �o w zoo w U n � N �r O� awm �z3 oU oo X oN� o ----------_o------- o__--- f - w-------- -_-- r-_--- �¢o woI 0 0 O w 7 O K N O o o a¢ a3� a¢z UE� o ow I I II II F— � to - - - - - - - - - - � o I I N I n Lf yJ S sF SF sF SF sF SF SF SF SF SF SF SF sF F I III I I I xaN wz I I ark e „ wQa pw Oa" <�a o�aw oPo� I I I I a> I I I I J$-- -Is Js Its Is Is Is Is ss ss Is ss Is ss Js o41z .I <� I ��Z I I� 3wo oxm w ow n oZz I w I ao o- 3 ao j I 3J ' ¢ m o�e'awoc� �x ~ztt Nw�`Qzw I II wawa oz OO -------------- z II Z II O� ga Z d 0 I -- a ---- ¢' n.. Uao waZi I nU^¢ Z Qzo jw U "ow dKNwvp oxo� m W �w< OUmN¢ � U I o�N f Q o�N a3 Z D -------------------- a_ 75 O U i amino a3w Ua�wSm 5:L' N O W Y c��oLLozro >nn moo Da -N w_> a�w Q Ld W iE� 7aMUaSwdZNZ< W z C� ©s y'm `o \�J Y'w_Uw.. z,zWaN"m. - Z oo H W < R.. �W $ NWwazcia�wNa _��w LLJ Zz Lfoz a,3 o a 0 ,Vro O p o d x p � YpOU a aNl a 3 m w� wzr m U w o N O F I Sow 3UJ w jao _ ym wZ1m � wom ?o$c o a N z - ooz on _ox I Ua y�y Na I zao 0 z a ¢ a zaa Fa Fa Fa NH <* <* <H wl wl 3o ao Qo am z11 UII UII UII o z O w w m w w � 03 O U O U O U O O O o K< K Q K Q I Q pU O� ao 11 1 \ 1 \ a \\ \ 1 1 11 1 1 m \ ♦ 3 \ \ 1 1 O \ \ \\ 11 1 I 1 \ / \ I 1 I 1 \ 1 o 2�nCrnO w0 JUJmrnx O wl3° i��U ymwomx ,s4wzN. � IOFaF�.. Nyo� -UIaUO ZO vao wU <OQ U _ Qo�Z n� Om CjnUQ� 5; QO NNW U j��Q H W Z z �m O Z mfaf o�Li L z wow nNxo w¢oa o �E Q W _ a o J W o <o� 0 � W W O H i amino a3w Oa�wS[] 5:L' N O W Y ltwl �O waUS1�UHw c��o LLp zro >nn 'goo Da -Nw > a�w Q U ado i�EZOoww��¢o�w Q a- - J J V�J-=off° �Z °LLN \ W s q �aM�axwaz`nza 0� W z W U <m y`o \�J Y'w_ zWaN�o� - Z a- oo p 3a�w°wow zz,ow�o a .. �W $ ,nWwazcia�w"a ILA i L- L a v�i os w aJ �o � wF� YI. uwmu ns �wwU Ojw Ow= O MM iI �Y O W U J w O w 6 3 If E -------- .......----------- ::::... ...._. _..b. ...... ...... ...... _... ............_................................... ....... ................._......... _ �ggPR EE� rv�yay RQ§ ............ ------------ U w J N w ............................ U W 4 o-,z W FTLLJ T-1, r. .o-.a a I ' 0 a a U s ' o g 02g i a- and Em . J: U aL l ;.I/l I .Yit 1 .HI I; .B/L 1 L o E %€ EL Pc2. 1 J O E vE Fii C� NE .q °T_d=Et W --- -- a &a , �� §MV W Y o0 0 � 9 � ad. la .Mfl m"i a,, UdU=� BLgl.p U d � � �<5 `b U o s _ U _ BgE 8�oa•. Z O' N a w T W L1 Q,� 0 d/111 'd N E23s-� ^uOaaE Q T Li W W U W CJ Z W L� arc€ aw s �� =Q3am WFo �mc> Q i az�'m iAo a3w wa�wSm >L- `i' Z W Y W O w¢ USI U H w vi =��a�ox3 0 i'n _ �m mW o3� OKO�Z�� - �^ W 0 c��o LLp zro >nn moo Da -NW > ¢mow Q �U z3a iv�iEz ooww~z�a��'J" Q k$ Z > E.�a"oaiwa z N z za W z Lw c_i w� dam \C J r� �U)MUZUa�j�"'Z Z a- oo J (n 3 3aoo=iprc Z c \�v QOm�j FZZKOw2p O Q z (n (n .. �W $ U ,nWwazcia�w"a ILA i L- L p II Noo Z I� Iz _ Q _ o 01 N III II I - a W IO& Lu z z „l-.bl I CI Oa �� m a g IIIIII � I I Q o W / �w W> Iz V) w wQ J O UU~XOoIwO�� 0w W zO �J� O Oa Q QQ z Q Qo W W W 0 W � 3Z aW_ O wFr o 02 mUO3 N Z. Fz. pZ,�o 'NIW zz JZm o �=Fz -,=<o Oww z<Z, O� wwQ Z��m ¢ttm pm w- p w w Na w� Z� N mom Jw 6y 2 �I „I. ,w pw �o Z<v z O � J w �Za ¢xF� d>NO pFN rW Zv:OO o Q % �wQ •� U�J O wviw OWl mF> m� Z_ ¢ w-� �¢ \ ¢K boo Boaoz F �¢ z0 UZ o'�zz w o .. \�, ¢N x / w JOZO o = ��¢ ¢�m�U a.Fw �ZW mo �O(/lam 0 01 /\ 0 0 Uo 00\ mQ p0 ZQ 50N UQN Z3 wOGFQ Z6m ~OW�WE - O O N(O O IQQ FO� oQ� z<� Ott¢ o��o �No wawa O O O O O 00 w wWm ¢am p�z �mz7 a �FFaa �o0 3F�oo O O i z MZFm O O Q �= ono�z i�Em ww� ro�w� a- wa owm wam iW�� aw i,i 3 Noaw_a mUO 4m pa=x�x wxwp p�3p W00 m� QOJ NOwmOr jza�= oy_�o¢m� of \\; rO �m_a i rw� UZ mw Z�zFzs r pwows a a 10 oa woWi�zo3 Z J OZW .Z pcwiZ Q m_ 75-w U0J N«az a w�,a oZoai' Q oQa Oa w�mgmc�iz"wwa,-�ZO�m? "�j , oO aoz HWUQJ Uaamg <00 �Z i" oU oz <ow mm ox�w LIJ QZ W5 z z w oo maZ W 39 oHp w zLLJ wtt zo0..- ¢ > Q N W n cn � i amino a3w p¢�wSp o-.lN ZW Y LL 0 W¢USI�UHw LL K�z��O - �^ c��oLLozro >nn moo �¢ -m w_> ¢mow < Q ado zN�zozww�p�Qm�w Q W k$ m V �J_=ffi�o �? _ `LLN w iq �a"'UdzwwzNza W z W J 3 3aoo=�o� \Ev Qom j zz,ow�p a o �w $ ,nLj Wwazcia�w"o ��w Z Z Z LA i L- L - �a� ozw1a�owz>l m v - o �y a zo p�3 - oo¢aLL s� iw wWWw�a U¢ - w m� w�3aJ3wN < zo z0� m �� < a ao z mo��~�aiaoa� o wwoF ¢rr3z o v,? zm - W m w�wpwap� om z¢o w wo J a�z m z _ �3 mo z m z zgw 3 go �Q�wowo row G �nw�m�z�nzpo(no rn 3 z0 W �¢z�w_��wz 'o�p oz x �� a awa mz - w� .. - S w i ��w3vi loiz�0 zpi Or t) ¢ - J Y� o -} �o o �=a a`� �� o� - o 3 oWO wow"n as " o aw��in- �a�ooQQ�W wo g' o00 ova wp 0 z p w3 m g¢z3Zm z0¢ Wfi_oF3 _� 3 "�ig3 ' a owi'nQ�F�o�f'nom Ji (�w0wrE3w0w0�0 a �U~ �a Uo�zz mwF �� _ 5 W wzo 'tea mwp o zwo 0w w3 aZ� r g\ om� - wNa> w ¢� moo �o w in m m� p z (n o pOo ¢z Umld E`�' w �a� w p ozmQ< Yip o- pm�w-�i�pw Ia Z pw�wYoaz�aF� Yp�, m W. a�x p �n vwi O c9z� am m p�KSK o wovi NJ wmzz!n w zQ III - Nw Paz o - �n a w a3w inU 'a 5 row= po aaaa p;>c'i Lazo¢ O U Z z W O ww 5 teffia« z o m Now m�� zo wIt <a":a wouwi� 2E�� —_ 4Wp Qo �a wo - a� ow wa r z — e ��ga Fo�3o w�zo^ 00�� <n�¢m im UwzwW�_¢ oa=m� °�®a �0mp-<�=m 3w WU 0 oww - 0�,FZozm3m FzW v,o II III N�f1i1121V31� NUazUpa OW N m�Z>S Q III- / >c��ggaa3p'=' ma3w oaop / J_ wma.n f0 - mitt ,:�azsoziao o~o za=oo¢ a�mpro a oo<oowoj aa��w�n��z z�a�z W aka z5-pzo�oowzo=w �i� `VOom,wi5 Q mmmm�QoWmoYs�ozz�Npa oFJmo O �m �oF mo oz �owoaa atza�p mom= WNW �oNgo�m U J 0 Z i-MwwNao ?aw'¢gppop v� �tn0 m¢w¢3c�z _Q Niaaa¢ NOxi~ 0r� Z ¢� Fz`"= J a Q U �wzaOU ern mm� U�UI UI UHIOQaQWp N�mtn d m O� x�Nrmmmm '� zU o p J Q p YZZ¢�J pew dada ��5zgw5�maamS��iww3 Q U JOm a FozJQoiw�3 m m JoJ�O� �w wF � s o�i��wi¢o��a¢�zJJ? a dada �'�oa�aaww�3raa�amrnaaaa (n E Z Foy a o8N� o- W 0z ¢wm Z J LJ Q zp 4 j a� job j � I a 0 o z. i r o = � i az <m F = — a 7 r---Die IDA 7 a a m p� Oz mcai �nm mom om wo¢ o0 w am N o)GO9090 I I \\ om I I mg ID 1®I II I I I` i ammo a3w �O WaU�1�0~� >L_ N O Y ado iNrc�ooww owww w Q JwQzao�z O m �a�c>awwa WNza _ W o: �oQo=wo m o , 0 w a- W m 3a�wO woN Y '� \ $gym opm��00FZ��p Qw� z z � O ,nwwazcia�w"aw_��w LL, ILA i L I o i l r _ '__ zs �w• emu <� .. a I;Ilil: .I i' _ §§ ul .V;V i r ii Tis f� Eft.' : LL CD +O c.i o -= gal., 1 3 ues Q Q w O w w a oN�oF�� - 2- No p =aka rm w�N Nmc� z U) wavxiop r w " W Y ~ a3� o�0z <�w m�oQo w_ J w U O �JWwQNUdwwKF�Q Za - U LLJ =<5w�1W-. wNo - zo ��7. Q o NWw�aw�o��o�a w W w I-- pU Q> OU w m N a �w apbf O O Ow p K o 'O O U Z ro O O W O p tt d wUZ N v 0 3 0 m o Q o O O aQao- a�a wo U W Q m z� z �Iz-z - N m m z z aw p pw u m o� aU oo�-��no wiz Sc�ozrc �w�o pJ�ow v owtt C)ml a uTUNU I 'n s a w� Y N O oN ttKtt oNwzFz- ONwpZO N r W o Y O a O O Zri w N d N 1� O� d ro Q O Q Z O S ¢x O O ~ Z _ Q O \M 0 3x w Z Of c'o p i ZUOo ttJ 31 _o QZz - oo > m 3 0 ww wo - o o - z za po m z as _- o o'ew zo w o m UW o a� 3 3a ¢m 4 - mpo o - a - z3 OZ U QK wK z-W z �dp�o �aU wZ O~Q KOUK � 6 Qwp U U � � W �� o F F O Q o �a O N O p Z �� N J U O O O UOUmO - rcJwwO w -z E, WZOappa >z ' za>O Y w.rj 32 w YZ QO O_ o Z O p 9 F Q D w a z d - m a Q p ¢ Z Q azz Z Z V Z z. Q Z w w a,w o w z a O .. z U K K U Z Q Q w U U w oK - Q O Q 0 Q za Iowa mo Ow zaw oDzw W U U U O 0 0 O olo d� J W z 0 NI O o - tt p Q N Q ¢ N o Q I 3 w N�' wj Nzz z - o w 5 wa x ~ w N zw m o d z !zgw w 3 o O p r Q w w�~ d O a wo z Q r a o o p F o E - E O- tt� tt p zz <ZO OF z LiO �a f �OUola Q zQOw� p Q K (� w o w O O Q U _ Op m - N �aZ N p 4x da Z VI Ewmw�p o z o w o a o = z w o�� Ob p a o F ao UIZ w 5 owmo�" 00 o - d N D O w O 70K O ZO Q N Z U QUQrvON o w W o w o Q O p ~ o o U a ti w o U w o w NQ G 'm op o OZw �Na - O vi w m �U xo '" N U z�rwdU �-zFQN >yvai�x `> w coo ? - o a w o uwi m c' wmo o p �z O ama w-a w z J '2 = Oz F�wNz�z w a=aaaa J p N o Q O m Q3 > x U O xE O O w o, 7 w W O O 1. o m w o 3 w a x es z a O 2 r- a ar a a p p 3 Oo a o U z J o N ¢ w o i �o N m Z U U 03¢ ¢moo ro0Q N O Z o O O p� wfwn �= -< zaoop "' z a Nc'i�� Z U m W Q¢ Z Z N 1/1 p ro ww J = >UOOFW i ~ m m o x ao ~oQ Q F am 3 i� X o z Qa i ow o ooz Qo w ro� �p w a =m��- w w �aoa arc o w mv, w o U 3 tt v; w z zx� tm 4 OU 0¢ of imzw�w NQcar 0 N w JW p - r �a a ws N wi wo �� J w w 3w o x o om p w a o _ N o z Q=m jzo p o oW _ �� pww aj xo oz _ om w �oN� ,n F Qm�zJo 00 w opo xx o o Np F & ~ as wo No w w 3 = o w ocai p'" tr w w oN ww �o No wo W ¢ a ow wj - a ww w) rw OO �� o o Q ml w w pwx az ow �W p mU a¢ 0 of x c�i�>�¢vai s a w Wpc,o O�Q�ZJ 2� NQ 3 6 w m oUw m Ow} QN sF w K CJ a� wp 30 pa w� wK .16Z �> UO 3a mH w - p N - ra z o a N wg z ¢ p a Nd mo <. Jw a� ax J ww ¢ ao of ttd w wo 3 'o Wo s wo uawio �� ao c>- oN w`� ww 3 > �oaawm a a p �a4 3z U w z -'? za = zW oa ao SF �N U of N zF ow OF o ins ¢ �� N� ¢w ¢oi U w w c'�om m,s U K� N U 3 ww p pc' 3? f/l ND ¢ o ooh NF o� U- ¢z ZU - U~ KO No o NOF o�y N� NO� w o O UmymjU Jo wo_ z - 3 z a zm 3a a� Sa ttz tto r� oa oz w� >� mo wo w o ¢Q Wo a " F tt� zU a U m ��w ow FN ow - �o >c> om z awm zoo w w <iIipm'oo w ¢o W z a' J J �i c9 ¢ a pN Jo o o� ¢p oN �z as 'o Iw Jo om J o 3z tt ¢F ¢ca.� � oa¢ d putt o0 oN a� 30� 3¢Q z c. a a a a 'a a ¢ a a a m Uow W Q W L J LJ arc€ aw s �� =Q3am WFO �m0 (n LLJ i a mmoa3w p¢�wSp 5:L' Ut O W Y O w¢ N D U H w _ vi =°�a�ox3 NraV _ �me mw O�'NWO>OZQ�� - o'er O zvo-imzowww�a oz ¢wmm 1=0 - N -W s z�wo¢ �awwazIz¢ lxl rc Z LLJ � a zw dam �J r� Uz �.. ,��zuxiaNw o� Z oo 3a�w°w�" s \� o&m w�U Wzow=o o a 3 rc�oo� Ox Ld LREL c ��m O wUl z VVWNwciaILA i L- L F-wOa��ozwwaw oo z>o COv" C� z gowo w N o o ao m oN mj fn zN mo wzam viZ �_ 2 Oz c� F o 3 a ozw o a oz ��z a9 o w w 0 om aw�Q oomz o o �M ao o � ow m� woo awZ Join utz o0 0 w zo o o,n w _ ¢ o U p 16t0 a w0 o - Z ww Qo �a oz �U ZZ Zo ZoU min4 ¢o� ow 2G2G �W a z z - O - O m Z V Z O X Z W O N K O N wO O o a E m w ¢ w w m Q d U O X w U U Z m 3 w O m w V Q o m N O �zgU a x 3 z O mm O oU wZ0 FFz< aw m �¢ Ut Add 5� owz NNN m I o - -- 2¢w2 E}N�w3 V w ¢ U) o O z - oa _ m� wz F ma ro3 w6O Ooz m U�10/1 zwm UI - Uo zw O N z O 4a m0 mo wpMo - ooa v,zo,z o o o O 00 o z 'o o U) �z zm ao aw ln¢ Inu ww 2 ozJ o3i mU o¢w N�cmi w woJ zoz oa w _m 3 x a OF S - az moo w o . mw poo �wi>�o o o�z z o �N o3 3m� woo aN -w o o� pO ago 'NE z Foa- z _ No 3� o o� w< zo c>m zo "' �s 58 zo m o- oo O?am zZ o w w 3a a P m _- z'a3 ;o mo Xm oQo ao 0 z¢o oN o w o �¢ m 3�Q UQQ zU p Umm �U Imp o oafz omoo& a - 2 �� my ow N mw p� �zz wa xw� wpa mF z 3z xo ooQ am owlo N �zz zS ¢ z 0 3 zVi o w� - m ow _ wZ om zoo wi z�xila u, o o zF OZ2 oawz 3 O wiw¢ z�zr mm J io z ~ 3 a o� �o zm 3z oNz pi or moo aw ¢c� o,o�c> U oz¢z z oa o o ¢o 3� or _ CEO O <c�F _ z�Qj mw N N N mNo w0 �m OOJ m w - �o� zw a w o f ~o w oa o Uj w �x N a N 90 o ro�'no w N 0 a 6Z ¢ w ¢wo zr p U -w o wow U w� wo mz oa & w woro 0 o ao 30 awm z¢zw pwNxo ..� zo Nw o� —o N iwoaw a ro o o mw zwo mz w z, zwm ao .o a �wz a aw <ooJ O oa Io NU oo m`" - ao azo m��z u wo3�3 wowNo� wo x� ~N¢ �w mw oa o> xwJ m -a= i»ow as omo z o< oz o� 03 oU 'mF az w wmz zo w p w p O r O a a O ¢w J F �o p U N p N mw0 zoo z O w = ow oNUt o f W - w U O O roZ iF� ¢ Ul ZaJ -wow w JI-w p m O = ww O a oz�z o w V oo wz oo Joo Z r u 0 u o w Z p ZOww?Z wr mom m U p z N w O m p w0 OZ om Ui w U o d UFU}j - O - z z - - X z - Z - ¢� m Fffi W= OF�w O O w w 0 wQ aZ U O Um _ z z w� QU Q�3 4 OW oy¢ V m Z E O 4 Z w U 0 growzwww I ;ww w w ow Q m w 3 0 m O w Q oW J _mow I N S m _in in¢ Z w w ISn tt I O U N o?r w w o0 Z O N w w w _ 3w 3rr 2 O 3 Z o m m- UW xr O - Owz w0 y w U tt 00 - i8N2- mQ4 wy a wma rc w 0 w< m �a m w S ~ Wx O ¢ Z Z w O Q f - - o Q O w p O 3 a J O H m r Q _ _ o p op� U g >Ko 2 r Z moo¢ m g wC�ww¢ - g "p Zo Lo w m w o ¢ woo o1 W z Ui zott 3 o ooa p -O ,� v -�1�, w w wZ� }� �3o w0 ao w0 mU Oo oZ JZ m W J S w ¢ w ¢ a w mU tt0 r O = ZWw o o woN U > _�jQZN ¢ O U - ZwU �a� bK V mQ - p O a avl w Ero g a o -- N Q `n m¢� z z 'pm mUQja o So owe o 6i o o� Qo -o 0o io z m - z3w zwQ o z wU� E a a O O w o o - im wv Xo �30 w0 2a 00 .T^ 3 ow O tt0 i om E o —w z o m iowz w t± a ¢ m w a F ut z w o Noi w oop o o 40 a o p Z a w U o zuZ ¢ UI >> UlmW O o ooa OW w i o o a �pU�z Uw 6U Q�Uw¢ ¢ U ow w w� mwz a O N Ho ao Up �� z o ¢m m do -o N 3 Jw ¢ QWO - O m O VI N o ¢ a m N U z ¢O ¢ NOZ moO a m wF ut U Z EZ S z Z w m 70 m ozo z ooa z od z awo z o a s J zwm jo Xo 0 ow pmw om oQ o �3 o¢ ooF a `n 2 Q UI w ¢m ZO w awe - m o �utp U 3 j z o p O O w w U o^ Q w a w ai ^o k w m� Z O tt z" oo-o w w V S U m� U= a a 4a Z\ OU o a a o 3 m x Ud aaz a Q U w m o i .riN z Q N o QZ aw¢ N�w oa V U Np w w¢ a aS U r a w roz w wo ow _z o <loanz wm oo �gz Eo mzm z m3 w o� U Qw - wo o wj ww i'il � zoo ? aoo a wN O z o 3 w of wm - `n w EU? o U= w 3 w �_ w wo .m low z� woo zmo ¢ mw a OVo. o i� o a� o ~ po J �^ l}ilpU w ¢ Q w > OOa w - a o o �0 0 o O o m-wra °'� 3zzUl �z ogz oo wOw oe w z¢ ox o= aoO pw zm oa z owo w z3 - wl zo z N ow ¢ z �¢ Z OV o OF - o z - I z w - - zwm z a O Ul o a-z is wowag fno O U U Z wu - oaw by -2G ooa F-`�' wZ Z a 03 o a ¢ O owl'n ao N o r Z O F Q d a �2 Iw Y w3 U O m V wo iw a K Z w �mN o m m mN o U o. Z ffi OU V a V 3z zoo z x w Z K m K - vo o of o - m w w z w 0 z mww 2 U 3 Z w ¢ N Z W W IVai ¢ OW ZO m o mwzUw z8 o0Q HE m¢ w WW E w m O N ow ilvo w o �wW O w a N z N Imo w m w Jaz o - H a� W - p ro O w mo oJx wm w m wo wo m ulo 3ttz mw J ciz J oN o0 o�i w z� p a f a o uZ� Qci o ¢ > - ip^-'� w z?'zo 00 _ 000w wJ< _ lnpo ..00 z zQ 0 0� is �3 �o -w. V= �¢ i oa z N zo vlQ ut o OU wlw zzo om Z�Z a w Nao So mu o Wmw-MUI - >o Nwo p O� am ¢a mz a OUP w m p w m m 1 vl x¢O� V oom w a o m o i In o?, ar ¢wow z wU zwmo� oa aVl Op mSZ �� ox _ oo o33e w-z wo SQg o3¢a Ew7 mom mo o ou, o oz� -N �mo aQ U�o Nm ut W ow U H UO �w O U m _ z Z o J�O o- V I OV 1� U J O o Zi > �UI V (� ut U w p jm s I o O Q m U mffi QZ a a o o Kp w 6 Uml O Z S Z�UI w 2 m 3 mo o O > o V mZm OU p O Om o U U n Z UN 2 H W U)SO O. U N J U N p Op O S U�� V w N o w Wp In O Z Om- fL w N ro w U Q 0 G QF�O .. KF O Q OU o m Z O 6 Up Or _r } w w 3. ^ w U)� w Z18 wz M.o Z Oz30W SJ pi o m m¢ OUm z <z_ VO po ON UU3� OZ o �3 JaF �� o� o c�c� Zj o c�i �N dai "oo O z o - w o UlO m-O mZ awa�w5 1 zw Qj Qo�O - �ma1 tt�Z "g� KOK wz azo ott F Fz OF Ul zo a W-w wa ozz Z 0 am wo w ow- wp ro apw ra of oo - o o¢ z o m w a mo wi g �a a- ap z �o ;w 6 ��w m o' �'�z Z za c�¢ m avxi cow ¢ oo c��o? ow mm ¢� .. offi a - ula oom? c�a w ¢ao� 0 maw awo om > m ¢a ¢ a a a a a 6 a a i amino a3w �Q�wS� 5:L' N O W Y Z O W a N D U H w O_>OOQ�� LLJ ILA i L- L LLJ 60 -----------------�+------------------ ------------------------ ®`em_---------------- I I II III O� IIII I j I I II II w I I I I o Q z o II z� c�aw�x Wo3o I I o��y mw�m II o= oaz aa.* Hol a o00 II III I II IIII I I I II'I'I IIII I 0 I I i� P I II I I II� I 5 I I o�z I I I 3�w � I o I oXw a I I I x I 00 Z ��x o ono I�-pJp w oa� oozo ma a (i F a a oo z Z =71 H w W\ awoo W o O o W x o w &a ao } o ao H wy a a H j § a �2§ »1\ V J ! . o - :I. \ !y ;;§ S e ! \;! _. \{ \ } \ / P / !i ° u >; - - 5 y 2 ! ``� � m )�` / \ mJ �( > » / }\\ \ �2§ »1\ J ! _ }\/ 'o `®J ` e !i \ �� u ))` - _ 5 §\ ) `` � m )�`\lz .- \\, \ / \ mJ :/ \ » }\\ \ , ` 2 ° , -m]§\ \ / \} \ \uu� \\\ y 7 �Q z \ _ - �/ - � 2} O U U ) 0 2 2 01 loll lz §! \$ Www 2 23 : le - Owi : - 0 \ \ 3 z z z z \ \ //$ z :I. _ \�®� z W_ -` _ - \, ( _ / : ,: , / ! Vi- I�z !}> !|rd z - \ �2§ »1\ J ! / . r:§: \ o __ _ : o :I. \ !y =:u 6 \;! _ . \{ - - _ \ } \ j\\\\ } © i !, u >; - _ 5 ``� m )�`\ \ \» LLJ z }\ ��\ ° if's" x c9 �: T.s xr a �_sW-� ;fir .g a`! U$a P5_§1a. �°og'" � sag, �a Jq� .s�W 1,1v 1 Pal 'gill, !I WHO c�qq aci Yp .a Mvill 0.-Z``IM °9guu� S s3 �.'a 5'+' HIM 33� e'4 � u aE°u .g s t 3g $.1 su ` €N u5gc�€ $S4 °' o.H Ek 'u Sx xd=s� �m5'xcEs €xjno Z Qc$5 3.`cmB3 cd EE°B sA § .. 33 xea G 9"Qf§ 1H1< a sA� mill €U < mm a I �eun!; c §_ §xo "t o ;• E ES a all, r 11 moo OV08 S30M 0NVlOOOM a0 S531 Od A SlG Od Y LL b53115 WaVd NMOlaold'%031 Sa d \' 3-1 'NA1 — tl3NM0 o� 9000090£9Zf :01 130atld w3 o Lai Nu¢ " n� io �OrcLLw °'d zo 3 � 6 a1 o f WaVd NVIOIa0lI 1 a:3sL3V03, -�= ANzs° n -&S3no3 N33 21 M8000L9of 13—d ~" _opnom WaVd NVIOIa0l1 bZ al s3131 15� mo J mo wNN wumi O NNo_ONOM WbNNnOB A tl01SM31N nOHN 'SnNsnN3A 13 HO—ONOM 113NMO 3 � - m \ 1000801f92f �01 130atl� a� n \ o�n Watld NVI 1JVa1 53L5 OIaO tlONN— :1tls31 nop Hd350f 'AoaVN0a1SVW i13NM0 dp OOOOZl lf9Zf01130N:d�IT aoom W o� atld Ntl101t101il 53L5 m o W 3JVa1 '3u3antla NM LOOOO8l—:al 13Jatld JO - - - - Src rc " o Hill Od 96Z1 a0 l4 10tla1 ..o In a 53115 Wald NVIOIa0ld 3NMO o~ma NNVtld 'S30lVA i3— �oo�N � - SOOOb8lf92f �OI 130atld F 53115 Watld Nliol d :1tl031 f tla930 '153M :a3NM0 h—ollZf9Z£ :ol 130— LZ£ Od Z£bl a0 LS 1Jtltl1 53LS WaV3 NVIOIa01d :1tl031 m I\MtlOI'J IN :E13NM0 'VV 800089ZL9ZL �01 l3Jatld o � $W= a n y a ow^� o -U _ ao�m m aoZW ~ 0 o LL JV S 8B 1Jtla1 o 0 53115 WaVd NV3O do.'d 1V031 TVO'11Hd4YtlJ H3l B A atlH3 3H 'lldWtl0 :a3NM0 < wN 9000Z£L — 01 13— S9sa N �� i �'^ 3 � JV S 68 1Jtla1 d o 93115 WaVd WON— :1tl031 y LLNOWa313 313HJI oP 3 � 30NY'I1NOWa311 S13NM0 800095ff92f �01 l3Jatld o Jtl S b04 1Jtla1 mu N53115W�a�Vde NVIOIaNWd: 3NM0 w rcw - z n�� A 3Jatld J- oHmo _ wQ ��UN e000HObf9Zf :0� ooQ goQo 4\\/ " /gym a 0tl S SOl lOtlal mm a o h h s3115 Wavd NVIOIa0ld :1V031 �� _ o' NVAI '—N3W :13110 w �r LOOOZlbf9Z£:0113Jabd X o� 09 0 „ tea - - - - Jtl S fill 1JVa1 wmo —S Watld Ntl OIa0l3 lM3l 11 300O1 —VI :a3NM0 J900009K9Z£ of —N. N Jtl S ZZl i � - m om�o� N 53115 WaVd NV OIa0ld :1V031 JT 30001 VaVdVI 'a3NM0 6000z—ozo of 130atld mo� 88W�Od N9Hl a0 JV S £Zl 1JVtl153115 Ola0ld Jll 30001 VYVdVl 'a31 10009Lbf92£ 91 l30 Um It =w gwmn Raa z ao ism Imil m S X W Q NO LL Z LO r Z MW W Y Q W J a z mo� 88W�Od N9Hl a0 JV S £Zl 1JVtl153115 Ola0ld Jll 30001 VYVdVl 'a31 10009Lbf92£ 91 l30 Um It =w gwmn Raa z ao ism Imil m S X W Q NO LL Z LO r Z MW W Y Q W J a z p Z r U� w O� a zdo I.— Cl/SL/CO 31tl0 NMOHS Stl d. nr : e a3 oadd yy AB303NO3H0 a ar :Aa NMtlaa fOZ 31105 3n— 319rv3N IN OOSI 096L0 rN 'NMO15 it W0731311t/lldt/7 'a0J *0HE %11,,,IFJ J"I I M G1 G1 Mu Km WOO'BUaMW4'MMM SB69'ZSZ'SOZ 4d 40ZSE ewegm -Z Z-gDZ: d 2N.141ejU2U 449UI.4flg SSL 'oul 'dno30 6ui399ul6u3 WS of OZ/60/II 1N3N35tl3 A 0300tl 'Z of OZ/9Z/01 1N3N— SS300tl 031tlOdN 'C ar of el/w/el SI/S/01 3 oN o uwltld a3aa 1. S3381 Nlbd 0300tl z 'l Ae 3ltla Nolsln3a 'ON 1.3A21f1S 213MOI ONMM` H w ¢ W 3 z 3 z 2eiH zz o d a Z & W p 0 0 0 W O W p W -E = W p 3 li. Z P z Kp p vox 2 K d> O Z _V z �z wz O _ — w_ - _ n a ~ d Op -' = z N O po ��" II II II II II II II II II a - c - U U W g �.�p�� p�iad�SniO C o O°' Lon co - Q Z O J O 30 Z z" N Fz « f �N azaoQa jl n� xI OE c O Ow¢m~ L O p ot ol ox o_ m s WJ J _� - ,96299 M .t9,E4.00 S� - O n V N N w 299 3 .65,£4.00 N ° ° Z �rrsN a j 3 03821V8 NV v E_ a S - \III -- _10 = « ow I vQ E. °E°+M° 15 _aE_�_ _ - c o3ww 3w 3ww33333w�"3w°+33 m"� L z _ _ EEO - N� - "3 Z.S� or --porn zl ___ <I n 4 .80. tt - - U � — d o e6s b 9 M ba J J I N OBNV �y 9bb 3 b`11 N — IlJ 2I1 mew \m ma O w m m �� _ ��oo �wlb w o - O 4 - U U o (n N Y 3 - w�q i / ii \ 1 -N� Plyl z dam W* ¢ L mh o\ dam 3 ¢pFQ< n rX III z - - 0 o daZnaF¢yKp - G r 0\Or W ZI K pumia Zm�i 2nvio _ OAS w N - O V - wp m II II III LJ W I I z ,� Vy4 3 02l �7 0 � 1 3= rc J J Q O 4 V n d L8221 o N * ,EI'I99 3 .W, .00 ly m m Z ^ 0 3AR10 13AV? O a6z — OV08 z - NO1N38 p Z r U w � � a^ I3. L133HS NMOHS Stl 3lWJs Cl/SL/CO 31tl0 nr : e a3 oadd N :M3d0 O1313 NWar ae3NMvea f 'n, 3N — —31 . OOSI O46L0 rN 'NMO15 it W073131 1t/lldt/7 :dOd 4 f,"', F, ", 1 J'aIMO®R731 SB68'ZSZ'SOZ yd 40ZSE eJ91UOo S—Sn ry 9 WOO'6UaMW4'MMM ��0�� 2nlld lejue� 449UI,4flg SSL 'ou�'dnaO 6uiJaau!Bu3 MWS dr OZ/40/II 1N3N35V3 —iin 'b dr OZ/9Z/01 1N3rv— SS—V 03LtlOdN 'f ar dr el/ol/zl 81/S/01 —IV oN Ni H— d 00V 533d1 rvltld 0300V z ae 3<tla NOIs— 'oN uA21f1S 213MOl ONMM`d21 w U _ W o O - ao�a ao Ow O z oan _o - Lu N man a o 2' p> u' E E Y Y =O Lu o J- W Q co 7 Z V o O c c w v Z �- ° x m i m m z O IO Z o..h- E CV c ui u c w _________________ — — — — — — — — — — — — V m m — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — o � J dom Dom m J_�ow��a I II I OZ s c M° oM - LL ¢�o�z0 - sg �m pN -00 w Q.. m \1° F�5 0 0am I p m m O ,Lb'989 A ,22,01.00 N avoa NoiN38 o E U O d U O w w a `o `oV15Z q`o vi �O'o o 03 oYY - - - - - _ -om"'� - -o _ nEw MYa - r`T�3w MYa MCa MCa �';Ew - - E z m E E° -- a E° _ a E z _ wEz w E z - _ _ _ vE - _ r3M3„ -o3v - -a3v~Tm _ r3v - �3z _ �3 - -30 cL _ - mooz cL O e _ _ _ « N _ E E ` -m°3Ln _ - vE° m3o -- E vE w o` « o° o a o a o a w a n a I E p _ o o o o E - - w - - - - - _ jm `o �E o wv E`oJ `o -J oJo _t%w b N. _ N. _ J _ _ - _ _ b ov - vast ° apt .-' apt ° apt ° apt °N �,$' - - v E Q V ° zw zwcsVmH _--' °EoT -o-z _ o o a..m3 - oo. vz K, rn _ rn °zQz w ° �E z- z z0- ° E ...rn Ev EvUEup6 —E Q-c o O o_ �3 v - O o_ 2 2 � o _ =' 0�3 �3`6 ^' o_ �3 oz_ vYLL°-_ - oE wYw°- ors _ -° orH - or« _ - aY"n_ ° - - -- _ o w`,; $E sc°' - -� Ili w� - o- Wa;«v °� of«°_ w� - z w� -wag w �v° u \dU �3 v \0. Eiwma EU dU — dUn -z a — LLv Ez-— zv x "o- w�= w�= �E w�= c>o= u pL._ uo_ _ T2 Ia o aG mao.a s z<._Iaa. a<._�°mom m_ _<._ %40TRILEAF' ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING NEPA Report September 5, 2018 Naples Park North, FL FL114 Benton Road Naples, FL 34117 Trileaf # 637639 Prepared For: Prepared By: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Trileaf Corporation 820 Morris Turnpike 10845 Olive Blvd, Suite 260 Short Hills, NJ 07078 St. Louis, MO 63141 1k$0TR1LEAF"' ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING Site Name/Location: Naples Park North, FL / FL114 / Trileaf # 637639 Benton Road, Naples, FL 34117 Latitude: 26° 10' 44.98" N, Longitude: 81' 34' 17.21" W Project Description: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC is proposing the construction of a 220-foot tall guyed communications tower, the placement of associated equipment within a 60- foot by 60-foot lease area, the installation of a 20-foot wide access/utility easement that extends west to connect with Benton Road, and the installation of three (3) guy wire easements that extend approximately 122 feet northwest, east, and southwest from the tower center. Yes No Data Sources: Site Reconnaissance ❑ ® Review of 7.5-Minute USGS Topographic Map (Appendix B) National Wilderness Preservation System Website (www.wilderness.net) F. r Yes No Data Sources: Site Reconnaissance ❑ ® Review of 7.5-Minute USGS Topographic Map (Appendix B) US Fish & Wildlife Service National Wildlife Refuge System Map (Appendix B) Yes No Data Sources: Site Reconnaissance ❑ ® Review of US Fish & Wildlife Service Critical Habitat and Federally Listed Endangered Species (Appendix D) Informal Biological Assessment (Appendix D) Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission Letter (Appendix D) Yes No Data Sources: Site Reconnaissance E] ® Cultural Resource Investigation (Appendix E) State Historic Preservation Office Section 106 Review (Appendix E) S. Will Yes the facility affect an No Indian religious site? [47 CIFIR Data Sources: 1.1307 (a)(5)] Site Reconnaissance ❑ ® Correspondence with Native American Tribes via FCC TCNS (Appendix F) "floodplain", Review of Bureau of Indian Affairs Indian Reservation Map (Appendix B) f. Will Yes the facility be located No in a and not Data Sources: be placed at least one (1) foot above the base flood elevation of the flood-,. Review of FEMA Flood Map (Appendix B) Yes No Data Sources: Site Reconnaissance ❑ ® Review of 7.5-Minute USGS Topographic Map (Appendix B) Review of US Fish & Wildlife Service National Wetlands Inventory Map (Appendix B) Review of USDA NRCS Web Soil Survey Map (Appendix B) ?pplicable Yes zoning law? No Data Sources: Construction Drawings (Appendix A) ❑ ❑ It is assumed that clients will not utilize high intensity white lights in residential areas )4�' IV -- Signature September 5, 2018 Date Jackson Name Trileaf Coi Company Trileaf Corporation (Trileaf) completed a NEPA Review for the above -referenced Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC (Capital Telecom Holdings) site. The purpose of a NEPA Review is to comply with the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) of 1969. Trileaf performed extensive research by consulting with appropriate state and federal agencies and reviewing readily available published lists, files, data, and maps to provide our clients with a complete NEPA document. The following summarizes the scope of work Trileaf performed in accordance with the Federal Communications Commission's (FCC's) rules implementing NEPA (47 CFR Section 1.1307 (a) (1) through (8) to determine whether any of the below listed FCC special interest items would be affected by the proposed action. Referenced materials are included as attachments, where applicable and available. Capital Telecom Holdings is proposing to construct a 220-foot guyed communications tower, place associated equipment within an approximately 3,600-square-foot lease area, install an approximately 20- foot wide and 100-foot long access/utility easement, and install three (3) guy wire easements. The proposed access/utility easement will extend west away from the lease area, connecting with Benton Road. The guy wire easements will extend approximately 122 feet northwest, east, and southwest from the tower center. The proposed project site is located at approximately Benton Road, Naples, FL 34117 at 26' 10' 44.98" North latitude and 81' 34' 17.21" West longitude. During Trileaf s site reconnaissance, it was observed that the site is currently located within a Cabbage Palm (Sabal palmetto) dominated, xeric palm flatwoods, and the areas surrounding the site consist predominantly of freshwater forested/shrub wetlands and sparse residential and agricultural development. Trileaf reviewed the USGS 7.5-minute topographic map titled "Belle Meade NE" Quadrangle, Florida, and information from the National Wilderness Preservation System (NWPS) (http://www.wilderness.net) to determine if the site is located within an officially designated wilderness area. There are currently seventeen (17) officially designated wilderness areas in the State of Florida. The closest wilderness area to the project site is the Marjory Stoneman Douglas Wilderness Area, which is located approximately 20 miles southeast of the project site. Based on this review, the project site is not located within an officially designated wilderness area. Trileaf reviewed the USGS 7.5-minute topographic map titled "Belle Meade NE" Quadrangle, Florida, and information from the National Wildlife Refuge (NWR) System (http: //www.f vs.gov/refuges) to determine if the site is located within an officially designated wildlife preserve or refuge. Based on this review, the project site is not located within an officially designated wildlife preserve or refuge. A copy of the NWR System map is located in Appendix B. 144/ TRILEAF ' 1 Capital Telecom Holdings — Naples Park North, FL The Endangered Species Act (ESA) of 1973 (16 U.S.C. §§ 1536), as amended, protects endangered and threatened species and the ecosystems upon which they depend. As interpreted and implemented by 50 CFR 402, Section 7 of the ESA directs Federal agencies, in consultation with and with the assistance of the Secretary of the Interior, to utilize their authorities to further the purposes of the ESA. It also requires every Federal agency to ensure that any action it authorizes, funds or carries out, is not likely to jeopardize the continued existence of any endangered or threatened species or results in the destruction or adverse modification of critical habitat. On February 22, 2018, a Trileaf representative visited and photographed the project site to conduct an Informal Biological Assessment (IBA). In addition, Trileaf reviewed the United States Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) critical habitat information and determined that the site is not located within designated critical habitat. Potential habitat was observed within the proposed project's action area for the Florida Bonneted Bat (Eumops floridanus), Florida Panther (Puma concolor coryi), Puma (Puma/Felis concolor), Eastern Indigo Snake (Drymarchon corais couperi), Mangrove Fox Squirrel (Sciurus niger avicennia), and Gopher Tortoise (Gopherus polyphemus). However, based on the results of our assessment, impacts to listed and/or proposed, threatened and endangered species or critical habitats resulting from the proposed action are not anticipated. Therefore, Trileaf determined that the proposed project site "may affect, but is not likely to adversely affect" these species or designated critical habitats. Copies of the IBA and critical habitat review are located in Appendix D. FEDERAL On April 27, 2018, Trileaf requested Section 7 Consultation guidance from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service's (USFWS) South Florida Ecological Services Field Office. Trileaf submitted project information to the USFWS with a determination of "may affect, but not likely to adversely affect" any listed or proposed, threatened or endangered species. On May 18, 2018, the USFWS responded, stating that a survey of any palm trees to be removed within the project site should be performed in order to determine if these trees contain a cavity that would serve as a suitable roost for the Florida Bonneted Bat (Eumops floridanus). "The Service is not recommending roost surveys in palm habitat, unless the palm tree contains a cavity. Unless a FBB roost is found, the proposed Project is not likely to adversely affect this species." On August 27, 2018, Trileaf dispatched Mr. Tyler Brown and Mr. Jackson Reagan, qualified biologists, to the proposed tower site to conduct a ground -based survey of the tower footprint for the presence of Florida Bonneted Bats (FBBs). Trileaf found no cavities of a suitable size for FBBs, crevices containing roosting FBBs, or guano droppings in or around the crevices or trees. In addition, Trileaf found no old growth Cabbage Palm fronds suitable for FBB roosts. Based on the findings of this survey, it is the opinion of Trileaf that the removal of trees (primarily Cabbage Palms) within the tower footprint (including a 50-foot buffer zone) should not have any impact on FBB roosting habitat. On August 30, 2018, Trileaf submitted these survey findings to the USFWS. The Service responded on September 4, 2018, stating "Based on the results of the survey (no cavities or FBB roosts identified) there is no further consultation necessary. Per the USFWS' Section 7 guidance, it is also recommended that project construction "implement the Standard Protection Measures for the Eastern Indigo Snake in order to diminish the likelihood of adversely affecting indigo snakes if any are present on site." A copy of the USFWS' Section 7 guidance and all associated documents are located in Appendix D. STATE In a letter dated January 29, 2014, the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) stated that they do not provide assessments of potential impact to threatened and/or endangered species. As a 144/ TRILEAF" 2 Capital Telecom Holdings — Naples Park North, FL result, Trileaf did not submit project information to the FWC, and the referenced letter serves as clearance documentation from this agency. A copy of the FWC letter is located in Appendix D. Trileaf referred to Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA) of 1966 as amended (16 U.S.C. §§ 470 et seq.), the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation (ACHP) implementing regulations (36 CFR Part 800) and the Nationwide Programmatic Agreement (NPA) for Review of Effects on Historic Properties for Certain Undertakings Approved by the Federal Communications Commission dated September 2004 to determine if the project site is contained in, on, or within the viewshed of a building, site, district, structure, or object, significant in American history, architecture, archaeology, engineering, or culture, that is listed, or eligible for listing on the National Registers of Historic Places, or located in or on an Indian Religious Site. A search of the National Historic Landmarks (NHL), National Register of Historic Places (NRHP), State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) files, and a field survey were conducted by Ms. Cori Rich and Mr. Zach Horne, Secretary of Interior -qualified Archaeologists employed by Trileaf, to identify any cultural resources within the area of direct effects and within a 0.75-mile radius for visual effects. It was determined that there are no historic properties within the Area of Potential Effects (APE) for Direct and Visual Effects. Additionally, the identification process did not locate archaeological materials that would be directly affected, or sites that are of cultural or religious significance to Tribes/NHOs. Documentation of these reviews was submitted to the SHPO via Form 620 on April 13, 2018. The SHPO concurred that the proposed undertaking will have no direct effects and no visual effects on historic properties in a response letter dated May 16, 2018. A copy of the SHPO concurrence letter, Form 620, and associated documents are located in Appendix E. On March 27, 2018, the City of Naples Planning Department and the Naples Historical Society were notified of the proposed project and invited to comment on the proposed project's potential effect on Historic Properties as well as indicate whether they are interested in consulting further on the proposed project. Additionally, a legal notice regarding the proposed telecommunications tower construction was posted in the Naples Daily News on March 30, 2018. No comments from the local government, historical society, or legal notice have been received by Trileaf. Copies of the correspondence and legal notice are located in Appendix E. NATIONAL SCENIC TRAILS On October 5, 1999, the Cellular Telecommunications Industry Association, Personal Communications Industry Association, Appalachian Trail Conference, American Hiking Society, and representative Managing and Supporting Trails Organizations (MSTOs) for the National Scenic Trails signed a resolution for the Siting of Wireless Telecommunications Facilities Near National Scenic Trails. This resolution states that if a wireless telecommunications or site management company plans a new or significantly expanded facility within one mile of a National Scenic Trail, it will notify the non-profit group that supports the trail. In order to determine if the site is located within one mile of a National Scenic Trail, Trileaf reviewed information from the National Park Service (NPS) National Trails System created by the National Trails System Act of 1968. Based on this review, the project site is not located within 1 mile of a National Scenic Trail. A copy of the trails map is located in Appendix B. 144/ TRILEAF' 3 Capital Telecom Holdings — Naples Park North, FL Trileaf referred to Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA) of 1966 as amended (16 U.S.C. §§ 470 et seq.), the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation (ACHP) implementing regulations (36 CFR Part 800) and the Nationwide Programmatic Agreement (NPA) for Review of Effects on Historic Properties for Certain Undertakings Approved by the Federal Communications Commission dated September 2004 to determine if the project site is located in or on an Indian Religious Site. On March 27, 2018, Trileaf submitted project information through the Tower Construction Notification System (TCNS) to the FCC who initiated contact with the tribes on March 30, 2018. As of June 19, 2018, all tribes have confirmed clearance either directly or by default via the FCC referral process. Trileaf determined that the subject Property is not located on or near a Native American Religious or Sacred Site. However, if archaeological remains or resources are unearthed during construction activities, Trileaf recommends that the client stop construction and notify our office immediately. Tribal consultation documentation and associated correspondence is located in Appendix F. Trileaf reviewed the relevant Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) Flood Insurance Rate Map (FIRM) Panel #12021 C0440H, dated May 16, 2012, to determine if the project was located within the 100- year floodplain. Trileaf determined that the property is located in Zone AH, a Special Flood Hazard Area subject to inundation by the 1-percent-annual-chance flood event, where the Base Flood Elevation (BFE) has been determined. The BFE for the project site is 11.5 feet above mean sea level (AMSL). The ground elevation at the project site is approximately 12 feet AMSL, and the facility and all associated equipment will be constructed more than one (1) foot above the BFE. A copy of the FEMA FIRM is located in Appendix B. Trileaf determined through site reconnaissance, review of the relevant USGS 7.5-minute topographic map titled "Belle Meade NE" Quadrangle, Florida, and review of the relevant USFWS National Wetlands Inventory Map (http://Www.fvs.gov/wetlands/DatalMapper.htmo that there are no federally designated wetlands on or in the proposed project site. A review of the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) Soil Survey (http://Websoilsurvey.sc.egov.usda.gov) indicated that the project site is underlain by hydric soils. However, Trileaf s site assessment did not reveal any evidence of potential wetlands or hydrophytic vegetation located on or in the immediate vicinity of the project site. The closest federally designated wetland is a freshwater forested/shrub wetland located approximately 92 feet south of the project site. Based on this review, no designated wetland areas were located within the project site and no significant changes in surface features resulting from the proposed undertaking are anticipated. Copies of the soil map and wetlands map are located in Appendix B. 144/ TRILEAF' 4 Capital Telecom Holdings — Naples Park North, FL As a standard practice, Capital Telecom Holdings does not construct facilities requiring high intensity white lights that are to be located in residentially zoned neighborhoods. According to Capital Telecom Holdings, high intensity white lights will not be used for towers less than 500 feet in height. A NEPA Review of the proposed undertaking was performed by Trileaf Corporation in conformance with the FCC rules and regulations for implementing NEPA; 47 CFR 1.1301 to 1.1319. Based on data obtained during the Site visit, consultation with government agencies, and a review of readily available information from other sources, the preparation and filing of an Environmental Assessment will not be required and no further NEPA-related action is required for the proposed undertaking. )4�-- L�3- Jackson Reagan Project Scientist II C�� Caitlin Young Project Manager II 144/ TRILEAF ' 5 Capital Telecom Holdings — Naples Park North, FL Appendix A Site Plans V / J Q W Z Z O W F y y ? d Y O U a w Wa a z cZ d.) V) N O U + T 4 U ZOU rn O Q JF w� U W Q Z I } :F0-,OOI } # a o I J T W Q tiLf) N LL 4 r W F 3c-iVQm .' N �J Iil w N 2j� Ob, a. r ' O 7d Z Z LL W 'F- V / O J LU a_ W J Q Z on Z X O O WO Wa RW W O Z ale — x x—x x x X O O -- — oM-- I OLLJ W 'C,4MK 7d I x X I a— 9� c� I -- -- oen I x I X q I x I Nu I Wz I N N &� I x U) x GL -- - 0 I x I a C9 x o C4 x ww x ' _IL _ --� I x � x X / \ N"m I: I O} x yN�W%I OJ x OORP W a9 a — — — — x .1 L. L-i x x x x x x x x x x T — F-F-- 8E!i o� W 3UW 3c N 6 N y o W� 0: & alo a i� r� w U) 0 0- 0 Of 0- w I R 0 z D O U <I� J�� TOP OF TOWER = 220' AGL PROPOSED 220' GUYED TOWER TOWER ELEVATION UNPOSED VERIZON WIRELESS ANTENNAS CENTER ELEV.= 220 -0 f AGL PROPOSED FUTURE CARRIER ANTENNAS RAD CENTER ELEV.= 210 -0 f AGL n PROPOSED FUTURE CARRIER ANTENNAS RAD CENTER ELEV.= 200'-0'f AGL PROPOSED FUTURE CARRIER ANTENNAS RAD CENTER ELEV.= 190 -0 t AGL A 02/19/18 3 OF 0. RIVERA I C. OCHOVA � 0WO N A P L E S PARK REV. DATE sN�EE< DRAFTED BY: APPROVE Ery.. D CAPITAL 'NeIN'EE PING C��7tin iNC R E L O SITE ADDRESS PROJECT NUMBER S, R3441117 T E L E C 0 M B RMIING—. ALL 35244 NAP FLON 18-5157 (205) 795-7385 COWER COUNTY Appendix B Site Maps Belle Meade NE Quadrangle, Florida (2015) Contour Interval = 5 Feet Scale 1 Inch = -2,000 Feet 0 Latitude: 26' 10' 44.98" N Longitude: 81' 34' 17.21" W Township: T49S Range: R27E Section: S25 North . _- � .Ju 0 tie• . +'+ T � c + C v +. o Ilk IT 'a DA 4 p �- +y • a '+e s an M al . i al � • ° � °r„� - e V V�' v is ° O � ❑ 6 #e p (� ' o �r/�y 1 a oa p I lJ dj T � 0 C .n 0 + p ° I p A F V a Site Location �. era, Q p a 4e� +y '•? jo In o ° 4D -� r Site Vicinity Map Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC - Naples Park North, FL 40 TRILEAF Benton Road ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING Naples, FL 34117 Site Location & Surrounding Properties Site Location — — — — Easement Aerial Photographs (2017) Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC — Naples Park North, FL Benton Road Naples, FL 34117 40 TRILEA.F ENVIRONMENTAL • AReRIT£CTIIR£ • ENOINEERINO m W w W f o Q 4 N 0 O C c t O d � o � Q 3NVl a Q 4 7 _ s c W C7 LLICL Q e Q n QJ CS cT x �iryry e a U LU LL,}I E Z 'I g z N w } o Q f'� o a 3�; Q N a s LLE J N w x zz , ` LL z zoE a ^. IL u7 z ❑ D o 2 r o e •�w Q a o �aq 4: i C2 W U c LL LL a N 'Mir r • � ■ • • .0 • � T •''.' • •.t.' •'.' ••••• . • .�Z �* •!• .•••• ■ •' O� 7; J H L 0 z _Ile 1 1 AU) W z L > Q 16 0 Z N >� (� 0, T E p N N C C C U U Z N a) y T LT (n U N l0 F N OO -O H N -C N O � a 6 O T N Z o m 3 > a3 L Q N O d E Y N ._ U N N Q C C c a o m 3 �N c � � � 3 o a 0 _ o a oL m� � c N c m c m o U 6 a) C N N i L 6 N > F- U) L L c� _0 L vJ �^ V) 0 U W LL d L L L M M M V) V) V) N N N L L L LL LL LL L Q) M C Q L L cM c G C C C M 00 C C CD r L L M cz CV 7 7 Cl) W W U � Z O N 099968Z M „ST,b£ .18 0 m a 0 LL O U V M „8T,b£ JS yZ V 0 �3 00 M M „ST ,b£ oT8 C. O N � � 0) N � � 01 a T 0) Z 3 � O � Z N o U) n U R� c O Z r9 Y3 a _ in 00 x R NC 0 L $ V I C a 43) 2 C v R � ~ U7 _N dS ad C C '•O_• 0 0 L H z� Z U M„8T,b£ .18 ❑ z a N m a 0 LL m LL d LL Q � 'T 0 3 Z U Y m a V) O a� U m �Z O U 0 Z /W V W J a a E O U m L CD Z 7 0 0O 7 L N H a O O � V) y @ U Ow-OO O O) N QCL @ EC y 0 O) N O w O f0 c0 O- O C 'O y m L E n I > w c > Q C O L a cna T 4LO.m O f4 y E 0 E ci a) m mm w E 0) y 0 'a .O (n w E o) Ea)U� m N C O U c O N Ch @ m m m r m m co a a) 0,0 3 o Q U U O to _m m O 30 c m E O .a O E a)a ywa O_ N O E _� N O .� O a) L` 0a U)E 0 Q O a w N CCO @ y= a) O Z� U Z 'a 0r 0 � L- w w C -(Do a�i C� 0 a co E co a O U) C Co LLo N 3 ° a om> a) E O W U cyp O O m fl L (n c0 N N m 3 'c m i Q a m @ O (D N N O y O N Q = C, c0 U m mt Y E a) = 3 T O 0) o O_ a vi C O O i co T O U Z a p a) N L O O US 0 Q E T m mco E a� w o o �_, O w-a O U o cn m m.0 a) m w 'O 2 CL:.. Q 3 > m N O_ V O m Q O O V> N 3 N N .a 30 aD a' Z E E 2 U a) EL cd m o a) y aai a) .. N m m 0 N O a .— (D( f0 O) Co mCOO @ E a T a 0,0 O C m 3 < j y 3 a U y O Q +y' c6 O a Q m >' � (/� +0+ 0—m E� m 7 0 7 'L �� 7 0 N m 0 Co a E - o N 0) In c U 'E ooa�ma� U N U oa) > ?Q O >, ao m O O n a) rn cy6 N m L O C L Q N 'm•' O U Q w O +O•' N N O N E M U E U) L) 2 a a Q m � 0 US U) U) 0 � F U y i y a c cc LL U m - t a a) O m N N m O Na Q C o CL J N m E m 0 N :3co O cot a CL O L_ y a) wo U) In > O _ m i m o 0 5 0 Q a ry� lW a) { (6 0 t* CL R + O V H m o 0 y w a m� o = 9 0 0 0_ co � U) y a w a N E Z w Y m ` E E d a a 3 m '0 a ° a ° a Q 1O n3 N t6 N m y 0 c O C 2 O 0 0 w � o CL co O LL 3 3 O T U N F, > N > = 'o LL N i O N COJ N U N >. 0 2 > O Y O O U N d Q .O '0 m m •0 m C O •o m 0 N m U O U ci0 0 T 0 N J > J co C_ n O a O a' N w - m a) 0 C m "O m O 0 m a c R❑ ■ R a 9 a x O x ° a� 'V K'� a 0 r� + 0) o❑ y Q fA 00 Cl) (o Z a) c) Soil Map —Collier County Area, Florida Naples Park North, FL Map Unit Legend Map Unit Symbol Map Unit Name Acres in AOI Percent of AOI 11 Hallandale fine sand, 0 to 2 percent slopes Totals for Area of Interest 0.9 0.9 100.0% 100.0% usDA Natural Resources Web Soil Survey 4/27/2018 Conservation Service National Cooperative Soil Survey Page 3 of 3 f MILES I-OMETERS ian 9fi0W U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service 0 National Wildlife Refuge System Map North v$ono wa"IV � 151a�►d l Vann* r j 0 I5;and Ok�e1�e c6af olso cr1 sta1 �wef 0 �,}}�553�OYJ1t�t�8� 5t1?6 ; - 01 F-Jne�a5 QasS�� vc�tiae5wte 00 c° 45 rd m D Q1 iO11 �1il�tlaCa55 Site Location is1a+�5 76` 75' 74- =' Navas5� 151and 30, o �c��ha�c�ee aGocz)� C�f�a��f�yt2�e�0p USFWS — Wildlife Refuge Map Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC — Naples Park North, FL 40 TRILEAF Benton Road ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING Naples, FL 34117 North American Migration Flyways North Tal IN_ e'er * �1T 1hD 13 4 � � ti rr � s � to Central Fty'Nay 4 L. i� ti w. sw Mls,,. issippi Flyv/ay "' � .. ' Fancy I*_ Site Location+*~ Ir Atlantic Fjp4y d, � � ,,•• � ~ Migratory Bird Flyways — Location Map Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC — Naples Park North, FL 40TRILEAF Benton Road ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING Naples, FL 34117 National Park Service 0 National Historic Trails and Scenic Routes North ID, TALLAHASSEE -fRAIL Nc eola JACK50NVILLF IVA /0A L V'\ Apalachicola St. Marks NR NF FLORIDA Oca la /VF C RLANDO 0 TAM PA 4} ST. PETERSBURG Lake Okeechobee NAPLES.0-- CYF Site Location N I oI MIAMI0 National Park Service — Trails and Routes Map Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC — Naples Park North, FL 40 TRILEAF Benton Road ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING Naples, FL 34117 M Bureau of Indian Affairs Indian Reservation Map Site Location �,J North 2 l73 �45 38 do Bureau of Indian Affairs — Reservation Map Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC — Naples Park North, FL 40TRILEAF Benton Road ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING Naples, FL 34117 Appendix C Site Photographs Site Photograph 1 — Looking north at the Site Site Photograph 2 — Looking south at the Site Site Photographs Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC — Naples Park North, FL Benton Road Naples, FL 34117 Photographed: February 22, 2018 Site Photograph 3 — Looking east at the Site Site Photograph 4 — Looking west at the Site Site Photographs Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC — Naples Park North, FL Benton Road Naples, FL 34117 Photographed: February 22, 2018 r� I Site Photograph 7 — Looking east away from the Site Site Photograph 8 — Looking west away from the Site Site Photographs Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC — Naples Park North, FL Benton Road Naples, FL 34117 Photographed: February 22, 2018 Site Photograph 13 — Proposed guyed wire easement looking east Site Photographs Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC — Naples Park North, FL Benton Road Naples, FL 34117 Photographed: February 22, 2018 Appendix D Documentation of Officially Designated Wilderness Areas, Wildlife Preserves and Endangered Species T440 TRILEAF ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING 1051 Winderley Place, Suite 201, Maitland, Florida 32751 - 407.660.7840 - www.trileaf corn April 27, 2018 U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service South Florida Ecological Services Field Office 1339 20' Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 Phone: 772-562-3909 Email: verobeach@fws.gov RE: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC — Naples Park North, FL Client #FL114 — Trileaf Project #637639 Benton Road, Naples, Florida 34117 Collier County, Belle Meade NE Quadrangle (USGS) Latitude: 260 10' 44.98" N, Longitude: 81 ° 34' 17.21" W To Whom It May Concern: Trileaf Corporation is in the process of completing a NEPA Review at the referenced property. Our client proposes to construct a 220-foot tall guyed communications tower and associated equipment within a 60-foot by 60-foot (3,600 square feet) lease area. The project includes a 20-foot wide proposed access/utility easement that extends approximately 100 feet west away from the lease area to connect with Benton Road. In addition, three (3) guy wire easements extend approximately 122 feet northwest, east, and southwest from the tower center. Currend the site is located within an undeveloped grass and tree -covered area. The antenna will be licensed by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC). Our investigation includes determining if any of the following special resource areas are located at the site. 1. Is the site located in or on a wilderness area or wildlife preserve? 2. Is the site located within a principal migratory bird flyway? 3. Is the site located in or on a designated critical habitat? 4. Does the site sustain any species of plant or animal life that is designated or proposed as threatened or endan eg red? As noted in the enclosed Informal Biological Assessment, potential habitat may be present within the proposed project's action area for the Florida Bonneted Bat (Eumops floridanus), Florida Panther (Puma concolor coryi), Puma (Puma/Felis concolor), Eastern Indigo Snake (Drymarchon corais couperi), Mangrove Fox Squirrel (Sciurus niger avicennia), and Gopher Tortoise (Gopherus polyphemus). However, due to the reasons outlined in the enclosed assessment, Trileaf has concluded that there is little potential for the proposed project to have a significant effect on any listed or proposed, threatened or endangered species. Therefore, Trileaf recommends a determination of "may affect, not likely to adversely affect" any listed or proposed, threatened or endangered species. Trileaf is requesting concurrence from the USFWS with the finding of "may affect, not likely to adversely affect" any listed or proposed, threatened or endangered species, their designated critical habitat, or other special resources. If you require additional information or have any questions you may reach me at (407) 660-7840 or j.reagan@trileaf.com. Thank you for your assistance in this regard. Sincerely, Jackson Reagan Project Scientist OPF'SH AIVp {e�< 0 LL m r n z x ° �r+aN G�� January • ' 14 Florida Fish Dear All: and Wildlife Conservation This letter is in response to your requests for information regarding FCC Commission NEPA screening. Our section (Information Science and Management within Fish and Wildlife Research Institute) of the Florida Fish and Wildlife Commissioners Richard A. Corbett Conservation Commission (FWC) does not provide assessments of potential Chairman impact to threatened and/or endangered species. The FWC Fish and Tampa Wildlife Research Institute, GIS and Mapping web page Brian S. Yablonski Vice Chairman (http://www.myfwc.com/research/gisD provides links and access to frequently Tallahassee requested data sets, species location data, as well as FWC project specific Ronald M. Bergeron data and base data layers. This web page provides downloads of the data in Fort Lauderdale Aliese P. "Liesa" Priddy both shapefile and KML format. The FWC Quick Map page Immokalee(http:Hatollatoll.floridamarine.or /Quickmaps/KMZ download.htm/KMZ download.htm) provides Bo Rivard easy access to many of our frequently requested data sets via a Google Earth Panama City viewer. You may also request a CD/DVD of the data by submitting a data Charles W. Roberts III Tallahassee request via GISrequests@myfwc.com. Ordinarily, if another agency wishes to get our input on the potential effects Executive Staff Nick Wiley of a proposed project on fish and wildlife resources, that request is sent to Executive Director the FWC's Office of Policy and Stakeholder Coordination. I've spoken with Eric Sutton the Director of that office, Ms. Mary Ann Poole, and she has indicated that Assistant Executive Director the number of such requests coming in far outweigh FWC's staff resources Karen Ventimiglia Chief of Staff to provide input. Consequently, it is likely that the only input that the FWC will be able to provide on requests such as yours will be the Fish and Wildlife information we have in our GIS system, as opposed to specific analyses of Research Institute Gil McRae potential impacts. Director (727) 896-8626 I hope you find this information useful. If you have any questions regarding (727) 823-0166 FAX the data, please feel free to contact me at 850-488-0588. Information Sciences And Management Sincerely, (850) 488-0588 Office (850) 410-5260 Fax Managing fish and wildlife resources for their long-term well-being and the benefit Jan Stearns of people. Staff Assistant/Records Tech. Fish and Wildlife Research Institute 620 South Meridian Street cc: Jennifer Goff, FWCC, Conservation PlanningServices Section Tallahassee, Florida 32399-1600 Scott Sanders, FWCC, HSC Voice: (850) 410-0656 Hearing/speech-impaired: (800) 955-8771(T) (800) 955-8770 (V) MyFWC.com/Research Informal Biological Assessment Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Project Name: Naples Park North, FL / Client #FL114 - Trileaf #637639 Latitude: 26-10-44.98 N; Longitude: 81-34-17.21 W Trileaf performed an Informal Biological Assessment for the subject site. The purpose is to document whether the proposed undertaking will affect listed or proposed threatened or endangered species, designated critical habitats, wetlands, and migratory birds. A project description, site photographs and topographical site location maps are included in this report. Proposed Project Description: The Site is located at Benton Road, Naples, Collier County, FL 34117, and consists of the construction of a 220-foot guyed communications tower. The proposed tower will be within a 60-foot by 60-foot (3,600-square-foot) lease area. The project includes an access/utility easement, measuring approximately 20 feet wide, which extends approximately 100 feet west away from the lease area to connect with Benton Road. In addition, the proposed tower will be supported by three (3) anchored guy wires that extend approximately 122 feet northwest, east, and southwest from the tower center. The proposed tower site is approximately 12 feet above mean sea level. Site and Surrounding Habitat: The Site is located near the border between the Southwestern Florida Flatwoods and Big Cypress ecoregions of Florida. The Site is currently located within an undeveloped grass and tree -covered area. During the area reconnaissance, several trees along the access road, and generally throughout the area were identified to be removed. A tree survey was not conducted; however, based on site observations and the provided photographs, the stand consists predominantly of Cabbage Palm (Sabal palmetto) trees with an average diameter at breast height (DBH) of 10 inches. The trees are relatively widely spaced, and canopy cover is mostly open in the action area. Ground cover is dominated by various grass species, Saw Palmetto (Serenoa repens), and other low -growing shrub species. The surrounding habitat within a 0.5 mile radius of the proposed site consists predominantly of freshwater forested/shrub wetlands and sparse residential and agricultural development. To the north is wooded land, followed by residential development, followed by Benton Road, followed by residential development, followed by wooded land. To the east is wooded land, followed by residential and agricultural development. To the south is wooded land, followed by Interstate 75. To the west is wooded land, followed by Benton Road, followed by wooded land. In every direction surrounding the Site, the undeveloped, wooded areas contain large sections of freshwater forested/shrub wetlands and some freshwater emergent wetlands. The current habitat is not mapped as critical habitat. Naples Park North, FL Trileaf# 637639 Wetlands: Trileaf has reviewed the topographic map, soil composition, as well as the National Wetlands Inventory Map to determine if the proposed lease area and easements would have an impact on any wetlands or require significant amounts of fill or grading. Trileaf determined that the site is not located in a recognized national wetland area. Trileaf performed a field visit and identified surface water bodies. Due to the close proximity of a mapped wetland to the proposed tower location, Trileaf recommends soil erosion control methods be placed to the south and west of the lease area to reduce the potential of incidental fill to the adjacent wetland. In addition, all activity during construction should avoid the wooded areas adjacent to the site to further eliminate potential impacts to mapped wetlands. Using local maps in combination with an area reconnaissance the following water bodies have been identified in the table below: istance fr m Water Body Type Name Tower Tower Freshwater Forested/Shrub Wetland Unnamed S 92 feet Freshwater Forested/Shrub Unnamed W 130 feet Wetland Freshwater Forested/Shrub Unnamed E 240 feet Wetland Freshwater Forested/Shrub Wetland Unnamed NNW 0.11 miles Freshwater Forested/Shrub Unnamed S 0.15 miles Wetland Freshwater Forested/Shrub Wetland Unnamed E 0.22 miles Freshwater Forested/Shrub Unnamed NE 0.23 miles Wetland Freshwater Forested/Shrub Wetland Unnamed NNE 0.27 miles Migratory Birds: The proposed Site and design process for this project could not conform to all the USFWS recommendations to decrease potential effects on migratory birds. Therefore, it has included mitigating factors such as tower placement within minimally sensitive areas and avoiding placement near large water bodies. While the proposed Site is located near the Mississippi, Central, and Atlantic flyways, our site investigation has determined that the project area is not located in an NWI mapped wetland, waterway, wildlife refuge, national wilderness area, native grassland, ridge -line, mountain top, coastline or area commonly known to have high incidences of fog or low clouds, where migratory birds may be found. Based upon the efforts undertaken during this IBA as well as the current data made available, we have concluded that this project will not have a significant effect on migratory birds; however, the presence of migratory birds cannot be ruled out. Naples Park North, FL Trileaf# 637639 Soils: According to the U.S. Soil Conservation Service Soil Survey of Collier County, Florida, the Site is underlain by Hallandale fine sand, 0 to 2 percent slopes. Hallandale fine sand consists of poorly drained soils that are formed from sandy marine deposits over limestone and are found in flatwoods and in sloughs and poorly defined drainageways. The depth to the most restrictive feature is 7 to 20 inches to lithic bedrock. The depth to the water table is about 6 to 18 inches. A typical profile of Hallandale fine sand consists of a surface layer of very dark gray fine sand extending from 0 to 3 inches, followed by grayish brown fine sand extending from 3 to 9 inches, followed by yellowish brown fine sand extending from 9 to 12 inches, followed by hard, fractured limestone that can be excavated with power equipment. Hallandale fine sand has no frequency of flooding or ponding. Hallandale fine sand, 0 to 2 percent slopes, is considered a hydric soil; however, no hydrophytic vegetation or surface water was observed. Threatened or Endangered Species: Trileaf has researched the listed or proposed threatened or endangered species and designated critical habitat for the project area. This includes any such species that have been reported to exist within the action area where the project is located. The list of federally threatened or endangered species was acquired through the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service's Information, Planning, and Consultation system (IPaC). The state list of threatened or endangered species was acquired from Florida Natural Areas Inventory (FNAI) and is broken down by county. The lease area is not located within an aquatic environment; therefore, any obligate aquatic species should not be directly impacted by this project and are not included in the table below. A list of remaining species and site observations are summarized in the following table: Species / Resource Name Federal / State Status Habitat Description Recommendation of Effect Notes / Documentation Semitropical forests Habitat assessment with tropical indicated potential hardwood, pineland, habitat present; Federal - and mangrove May affect, not however, nesting Florida Bonneted Bat Endangered habitats, as well as likely adversely sites are extremely (Eumops floridanus) State - man-made areas such a ffect a rare, and a minimal Endangered as golf courses and number of palm neighborhoods; trees are to be occasionally roost in removed within the foliage of palm trees action area Naples Park North, FL Trileaf# 637639 Species / Resource Federal / Habitat Description Recommendation Notes / Name State Status of Effect Documentation Habitat assessment Requires extensive indicated potential blocks of mostly habitat present; Federal - forested however, the action Florida Panther Endangered communities; large May affect, not area is very small, (Puma concolor coryi) State - wetlands that are likely to adversely and the Site is Endangered generally inaccessible affect located in close to humans are proximity to important for diurnal residential and refuge agricultural development Habitat assessment All forest types; indicated potential Puma Federal - prefer a habitat with May affect, not habitat present; (Puma/Felis concolor) Threatened dense understory likely to adversely however, the action vegetation affect area is very small, and no individuals were observed Open country, including dry prairie Audubon's Crested Federal - and pasture lands Habitat assessment Caracara Threatened with cabbage palm, No effect indicated no (Polyborus planus State - cabbage palm/live potential habitat audubonii) Threatened oak hammocks, and present shallow ponds and sloughs Currently inhabits Cape Sable Seaside seasonally inundated Habitat assessment Sparrow Federal - freshwater interior indicated no (Ammodramus Endangered marshes within No effect potential habitat maritimus mirabilis) Everglades National present Park and Big Cypress National Preserve Naples Park North, FL Trileaf# 637639 Species / Resource Federal / Habitat Description Recommendation Notes / Name State Status of Effect Documentation Large open freshwater marshes and lakes with Federal - shallow water, <4 Habitat assessment Everglade Snail Kite Endangered feet deep, and a low indicated no (Rostrhamus State - density of emergent No effect potential habitat sociabilis plumbeus) Endangered vegetation are present preferred foraging habitat; nest usually over water in a low tree or shrub Florida Grasshopper Dry open prairies that Habitat assessment Sparrow (Ammodramus Federal - contain bunch No effect indicated no Endangered grasses, low shrubs, potential habitat savannarum floridanus) and saw palmetto present Federal - Fire dominated low - Habitat assessment Florida Scrub jay Threatened growing, oak scrub indicated no (Aphelocoma State - habitat found on No effect potential habitat coerulescens) Threatened Fell -drained sandy present soils Ivory -billed Cypress swamps and Habitat assessment Woodpecker Federal - mature bottomland No effect indicated no (Campephilus Endangered forests potential habitat principalis) present Nest in Jack pine Kirtland's Warbler trees that are 5 to 20 Habitat assessment (Setophaga Federal - feet tall and 6 to 22 No effect indicated no kirtlandii/Dendroica Endangered years old, and inhabit potential habitat kirtlandii) dense scrub during present the winter Naples Park North, FL Trileaf# 637639 Species / Resource Federal / Habitat Description Recommendation Notes / Name State Status of Effect Documentation Federal - Open, sandy beaches Habitat assessment Piping Plover Threatened and on tidal mudflats No effect indicated no (Charadrius melodus) State - and sandflats along potential habitat Threatened both coasts present Breeds in drier tundra areas, such as sparsely vegetated Red Knot hillsides; outside of Habitat assessment (Calidris canutus Federal - breeding season, No effect indicated no rufa) Threatened found in intertidal, potential habitat marine habitats, present especially near coastal inlets, estuaries, and bays Federal - Open, mature pine Habitat assessment Red -cockaded Endangered woodlands that have indicated no Woodpecker State - a diversity of grass, No effect potential habitat (Picoides borealis) Threatened forb and shrub present species Freshwater and estuarine wetlands, Federal - primarily nesting in Habitat assessment Wood Stork Threatened cypress or mangrove No effect indicated no (Mycteria americana) State - swamps. Feed in potential habitat Endangered freshwater marshes, present narrow tidal creeks, or flooded tidal pools Broad range of Habitat assessment Federal - habitats, from scrub indicated potential Eastern Indigo Snake Threatened and sandhill to wet May affect, not habitat present; (Drymarchon corals State - prairies and likely to adversely however, the action couperi) Threatened mangrove swamps; affect area is very small, requires very large and no individuals tracts were observed Naples Park North, FL Trileaf# 637639 Species / Resource Federal / Habitat Description Recommendation Notes / Name State Status of Effect Documentation Pine rockland habitat Bartram's Hairstreak made up of exposed Habitat assessment Butterfly Federal - limestone that No effect indicated no (Strymon acis Endangered supports hardwood potential habitat bartrami) hammocks and saw present palmetto Florida Leafwing Pine rockland; Pine- Habitat assessment Butterfly Federal - palmetto scrub and No effect indicated no (Anaea troglodyta Endangered edges potential habitat floridalis) present Tropical hardwood Miami Blue Butterfly hammocks and their Habitat assessment (Cyclargus/Hemiargus Federal - associated margins, No effect indicated no thomasi Endangered beachside scrub, and potential habitat bethunebakeri) tropical pine present rocklands Florida Prairie -clover Pine rocklands, edges Habitat assessment (Dalea c agenesis Federal - or rockland No effect indicated no floridana) Endangered hammocks, coastal potential habitat uplands, marl prairie present Sandy soils over limestone in pine rocklands, hammock Habitat assessment Garber's Spurge Federal - edges, coastal rock No effect indicated no (Chamaesyce garberi) Threatened barrens, grass potential habitat prairies, salt flats, present beach ridges, and swales Meadow Jointvetch Habitat assessment (Aeschyn State - Marl prairie, cypress No effect indicated no pratensisis) Endangered domes, swales potential habitat present Naples Park North, FL Trileaf# 637639 Species / Resource Federal / Habitat Description Recommendation Notes / Name State Status of Effect Documentation Florida Keys Indigo Coastal berm, coastal Habitat assessment (IndigState ofera - rock barrens and No effect indicated no mucrocronata) Endangered sunny edges of potential habitat rockland hammocks present Pine rockland, edges Skyblue Clustervine of rockland Habitat assessment (Jacquemo State - hammock disturbed No effect indicated no pentanthos) Endangered openings in potential habitat hammocks, coastal present rock barren Rockland hammock, Habitat assessment Pale Passionflower State - coastal berm strand indicated no (Passiflora pallens) Endangered swamps, and roadside No effect potential habitat thickets in strand present swamps Shell mounds and limestone outcrops in mesic hammocks, Habitat assessment Low Peperomia State - coastal berms, No effect indicated no (Peperomia humilis) Endangered cypress swamps; potential habitat rarely on tree trunks, present branches, or rotting logs Florida Peperomia Rockland hammocks Habitat assessment (Peperomia State - hydric hammocks, No effect indicated no obtusifolia) Endangered strand swamps potential habitat present Fallen logs, stumps, Habitat assessment American Bird's Nest State - and tree trunks in indicated no Fern Endangered cypress swamps and No effect potential habitat (Asplenium serratum) tropical rockland hammocks present Naples Park North, FL Trileaf# 637639 Species / Resource Federal / Habitat Description Recommendation Notes / Name State Status of Effect Documentation Narrow Strap Fern Tree trunks and Habitat assessment (Cngusti State - branches in tropical No effect indicated no angustifolium) lium) Endangered hardwood hammocks potential habitat and cypress swamps present Rockland hammocks, Habitat assessment Swamp Plume State - strand swamps and indicated no Polypody Endangered wet woods; often on No effect potential habitat (Pecluma ptilodon) tree bases and fallen logs present Toothed Lattice -Vein Habitat assessment Fern State - Cypress swamps, No effect indicated no (Thelypteris serrata) Endangered sloughs, floodplains potential habitat present Leafless Bentspur Trunks and branches Habitat assessment Orchid State - of trees in cypress No effect indicated no (Campylocentrum Endangered potential habitat pachyrrhizum) swamps present Many -Flowered Grows on trees in Habitat assessment Catopsis State - tropical hammocks No effect indicated no (Catopsis floribunda) Endangered and cypress swamps potential habitat in south FL present Trunks and stumps o cypress trees in Cowhorn Orchid swamps, branches of Habitat assessment o ( dium State - buttonwood trees in No effect indicated no Curd unctatum) Endangered coastal hammocks, potential habitat and occasionally pine present rocklands and marl prairies Naples Park North, FL Trileaf# 637639 Species / Resource Federal / Habitat Description Recommendation Notes / Name State Status of Effect Documentation Trunks and branches of pond apple, Habitat assessment Clamshell Orchid State - cypress, live oak, No effect indicated no (Encyclia cochleata) Endangered buttonwood trees in potential habitat swamps and present hammocks Night -Scented Orchid Tree trunks, Habitat assessment (octur drum State - branches and stumps No effect indicated no n octurnum) Endangered in hammocks, potential habitat swamps, and sloughs present Branches and tree Bromeliad Fuchs' Bromeliad trunks in swamps and Habitat assessment uz (Guzm (G State - wet hammocks; will No effect indicated no achia) monosfor Endangered survive on the ground potential habitat a while if it falls present from tree Attach to trunks and Habitat assessment Hidden Orchid State - high branches in indicated no (Maxillaria Endangered cypress swamps and No effect potential habitat crassifolia) sloughs in Collier County present Hammocks cypress Habitat assessment Dancing -Lady Orchid State - swamps buttonwood No effect indicated no (Oncidium undulatum) Endangered forests potential habitat present Trunks and branches Habitat assessment Frost -Flower Orchid State - of pop -ash and pond No effect indicated no (Pleurothallis gelida) Endangered apple trees in cypress potential habitat strands and swamps present Naples Park North, FL Trileaf# 637639 Species / Resource Federal / Habitat Description Recommendation Notes / Name State Status of Effect Documentation Giant Orchid Sandhill, scrub, pine Habitat assessment (Pteroglossaspis State - flatwoods, pine No effect indicated no ecristata) Threatened rocklands potential habitat present Leafy Beaked Ladies'- Habitat assessment Tresses State - Swamps and hydric No effect indicated no (Sacoila lanceolate) Threatened hammocks potential habitat present Southern Ladies'- Pine rockland marl Habitat assessment Tresses State - prairie, edges of No effect indicated no (Spiranthes torta) Endangered rockland hammock potential habitat present Fuzzy-Wuzzy Habitat assessment Airplant State - Branches of trees in No effect indicated no (Tillandsia pruinosa) Endangered cypress swamps potential habitat present Restricted to dry, Snowy Plover sandy beaches, where Habitat assessment (Charadrius State - they nest in shallow No effect indicated no alexandrius) Threatened depressions, usually potential habitat near some vegetation present or debris Florida Sandhill Crane Prairies freshwater Habitat assessment (Gnus canadensis State - marshes, and pasture No effect indicated no pratensis) Threatened lands potential habitat present Naples Park North, FL Trileaf# 637639 Species / Resource Federal / Habitat Description Recommendation Notes / Name State Status of Effect Documentation Breed and winter in Habitat assessment forested areas indicated no Bald Eagle adjacent to large potential habitat (Haliaeetus State - bodies of water. No effect present; nearest leucocephalus) Threatened Prefer large, super- documented nest is canopy roost trees approximately 4.5 that are open and miles SW of the Site accessible Nest sites include bare limestone, shell - sand beaches, newly deposited rock and marl fill, dredge Habitat assessment Roseate Tern State - material, heaps of No effect indicated no (Sterna dougalld) Threatened broken coral potential habitat deposited by storm, present and rooftops, forage in open water over sandbars, reefs, and tidal channels Coastal areas throughout Florida, Habitat assessment Least Tern State - including beaches, indicated no (Sterna antillarum) Threatened lagoons, bays, and No effect potential habitat estuaries; increasingly use present artificial nesting sites A variety of wetland communities, Habitat assessment Southern Mink State - including salt marsh, No effect indicated no (Mustela vison) Threatened freshwater marsh, potential habitat cypress swamp, and present hardwood swamp Naples Park North, FL Trileaf# 637639 Species / Resource Name Federal / State Status Habitat Description Recommendation of Effect Notes / Documentation A variety of forested Habitat assessment habitats with open to indicated potential Mangrove Fox moderately dense May affect, not habitat present; Squirrel State - understory and shrub likely to adversely however, the action (Sciurus niger Threatened cover; mosaic of pine affect area is very small, avicennia) flatwoods, cypress and no individuals swamps, and were observed hardwood hammocks Dry upland habitats, including sandhills, Habitat assessment scrub, xeric oak indicated potential Gopher Tortoise hammock, and dry May affect not habitat present; (Gopherus State - pine flatwoods• also likely adversely however, no Polyphemus) Threatened commonly uses a affect individuals or disturbed habitats burrows were such as pastures, old observed within the fields, and road action area shoulders Conclusions: In conclusion, no individuals of any listed or proposed, threatened or endangered species were directly observed within the proposed project's action area. However, potential habitat may be present for the Florida Bonneted Bat (Eumops floridanus), Florida Panther (Puma concolor coryi), Puma (Puma/Felis concolor), Eastern Indigo Snake (Drymarchon corais couperi), Mangrove Fox Squirrel (Sciurus niger avicennia), and Gopher Tortoise (Gopherus Polyphemus). Trileaf does not recommend the Site as suitable primary habitat for the Florida Bonneted Bat. Although this species does occasionally roost in the foliage of palm trees, and several Cabbage Palm (Sabal palmetto) trees are located within the proposed project's action area, nesting sites for this species are extremely rare, and a minimal number of palm trees are to be removed within the action area. Therefore, Trileaf recommends a determination of "may affect, not likely to adversely affect" the Florida Bonneted Bat. Trileaf does not recommend the Site as suitable primary habitat for the Florida Panther or Puma. The Site is located in a forested area adjacent to large sections of wetland. However, these species prefer areas inaccessible to humans, and the Site is located in close proximity to residential and agricultural development. The area of impact for the proposed project is also very small and will not affect a significant portion of the environment. Therefore, Trileaf recommends a determination of "may affect, not likely to adversely affect" the Florida Panther or Puma. Naples Park North, FL Trileaf# 637639 While potential habitat may be present for the Eastern Indigo Snake, Mangrove Fox Squirrel, and Gopher Tortoise, no individuals of these species were directly observed, and the area of impact for the proposed project is very small and will not affect a significant portion of the environment. There were also no burrows identified within the action area that may provide shelter for the Eastern Indigo Snake or Gopher Tortoise. Therefore, Trileaf recommends a determination of "may affect, not likely to adversely affect' the Eastern Indigo Snake, Mangrove Fox Squirrel, and Gopher Tortoise. Based on the efforts undertaken during our IBA, project specifications and the current data made available, we have concluded that there is no potential for the proposed project to have a significant adverse effect on any listed or proposed, threatened or endangered species, their designated critical habitat, or migratory birds. Therefore, Trileaf recommends a determination of "may affect, not likely to adversely affect" any listed or proposed, threatened or endangered species, their designated critical habitat, or migratory birds. It should be noted that this informal biological assessment was conducted in accordance with the Scope of Work and does not constitute a Section 7 Biological Assessment under the Endangered Species Act (50 CFR Part 402.01). Jackson Reagan Natural Resource Specialist Please refer to Appendix B for Site Maps Please refer to Appendix C for Site Photographs F7iitO - N'WIHIJfti - United States Department of the Interior �"""' FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE South Florida Ecological Services Field Office 1339 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960-3559 Phone: (772) 562-3909 Fax: (772) 562-4288 h1W://fws.,gov/verobeach In Reply Refer To: March 26, 2018 Consultation Code: 04EF2000-2018-SLI-0461 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Subject: List of threatened and endangered species that may occur in your proposed project location, and/or may be affected by your proposed project To Whom It May Concern: The enclosed species list identifies threatened, endangered, proposed and candidate species, as well as proposed and final designated critical habitat, that may occur within the boundary of your proposed project and/or may be affected by your proposed project. The species list fulfills the requirements of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (Service) under section 7(c) of the Endangered Species Act (Act) of 1973, as amended (16 U.S.C. 1531 et seq.). New information based on updated surveys, changes in the abundance and distribution of species, changed habitat conditions, or other factors could change this list. Please feel free to contact us if you need more current information or assistance regarding the potential impacts to federally proposed, listed, and candidate species and federally designated and proposed critical habitat. Please note that under 50 CFR 402.12(e) of the regulations implementing section 7 of the Act, the accuracy of this species list should be verified after 90 days. This verification can be completed formally or informally as desired. The Service recommends that verification be completed by visiting the ECOS-IPaC website at regular intervals during project planning and implementation for updates to species lists and information. An updated list may be requested through the ECOS-IPaC system by completing the same process used to receive the enclosed list. The purpose of the Act is to provide a means whereby threatened and endangered species and the ecosystems upon which they depend may be conserved. Under sections 7(a)(1) and 7(a)(2) of the Act and its implementing regulations (50 CFR 402 et seq.), Federal agencies are required to utilize their authorities to carry out programs for the conservation of threatened and endangered species and to determine whether projects may affect threatened and endangered species and/or designated critical habitat. 03/26/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 2 A Biological Assessment is required for construction projects (or other undertakings having similar physical impacts) that are major Federal actions significantly affecting the quality of the human environment as defined in the National Environmental Policy Act (42 U.S.C. 4332(2) (c)). For projects other than major construction activities, the Service suggests that a biological evaluation similar to a Biological Assessment be prepared to determine whether the project may affect listed or proposed species and/or designated or proposed critical habitat. Recommended contents of a Biological Assessment are described at 50 CFR 402.12. If a Federal agency determines, based on the Biological Assessment or biological evaluation, that listed species and/or designated critical habitat may be affected by the proposed project, the agency is required to consult with the Service pursuant to 50 CFR 402. In addition, the Service recommends that candidate species, proposed species and proposed critical habitat be addressed within the consultation. More information on the regulations and procedures for section 7 consultation, including the role of permit or license applicants, can be found in the 'Endangered Species Consultation Handbook" at: http://www.fws.gov/endangered/esa-library/Pdf/TOC-GLOS.PDF Please be aware that bald and golden eagles are protected under the Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act (16 U.S.C. 668 et seq.), and projects affecting these species may require development of an eagle conservation plan (http://www.fws.gov/windenergy/ eagle_guidance.html). Additionally, wind energy projects should follow the wind energy guidelines (http://www.fws.gov/windenergy/) for minimizing impacts to migratory birds and bats. Guidance for minimizing impacts to migratory birds for projects including communications towers (e.g., cellular, digital television, radio, and emergency broadcast) can be found at: http:// www.fws.gov/migratorybirds/CurrentBirdlssues/Hazards/towers/towers.htm; http:// www.towerkill.com; and http://www.fws.gov/migratorybirds/CurrentBirdIssues/Hazards/towers/ comtow.html. We appreciate your concern for threatened and endangered species. The Service encourages Federal agencies to include conservation of threatened and endangered species into their project planning to further the purposes of the Act. Please include the Consultation Tracking Number in the header of this letter with any request for consultation or correspondence about your project that you submit to our office. Attachment(s): • Official Species List 03/26/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 Official Species List This list is provided pursuant to Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act, and fulfills the requirement for Federal agencies to "request of the Secretary of the Interior information whether any species which is listed or proposed to be listed may be present in the area of a proposed action". This species list is provided by: South Florida Ecological Services Field Office 1339 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960-3559 (772) 562-3909 03/26/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 Project Summary Consultation Code: 04EF2000-2018-SLI-0461 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Project Type: COMMUNICATIONS TOWER Project Description: Construction of a 220' guyed communications tower and all associated equipment within a 3,600-square-foot lease area. A 20' wide access/utility easement extends west away from the lease area to connect with Benton Road. Project Location: Approximate location of the project can be viewed in Google Maps: https: www.google.com/maps/place/26.179267702439347N81.57164340399791 W 6o ryln Counties: Collier, FL 03/26/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 3 Endangered Species Act Species There is a total of 25 threatened, endangered, or candidate species on this species list. Species on this list should be considered in an effects analysis for your project and could include species that exist in another geographic area. For example, certain fish may appear on the species list because a project could affect downstream species. IPaC does not display listed species or critical habitats under the sole jurisdiction of NOAA Fisheriesl, as USFWS does not have the authority to speak on behalf of NOAA and the Department of Commerce. See the "Critical habitats" section below for those critical habitats that lie wholly or partially within your project area under this office's jurisdiction. Please contact the designated FWS office if you have questions. NOAA Fisheries, also known as the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS), is an office of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration within the Department of Commerce. Mammals NAME Florida Bonneted Bat Eumops floridanus No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/8630 Florida Panther Puma (=Felis) concolor coryi No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https:Hecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/1763 Habitat assessment guidelines: https://ecos. fws. gov/ipac/guideline/assessment/population/8/office/41420.pdf Puma (=mountain Lion) Puma (=Felis) concolor (all subsp. except coryi) Population: FL No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws.2_ov/ecp/species/6049 West Indian Manatee Trichechus manatus There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. This species is also protected by the Marine Mammal Protection Act, and may have additional consultation requirements. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/4469 STATUS Endangered Endangered Similarity of Appearance (Threatened) Threatened 03/26/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 Birds NAME STATUS Audubon's Crested Caracara Polyborus plancus audubonii Threatened Population: FL pop. No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8250 Cape Sable Seaside Sparrow Ammodramus maritimus mirabilis Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. ov/ecp/species/6584 Everglade Snail Kite Rostrhamus sociabilis plumbeus Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: https:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/7713 Species survey guidelines: https:Hecos.fws. gov/ipac/guideline/survey//population/1221/office/41420.pdf Florida Grasshopper Sparrow Ammodramus savannarum floridanus Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/32 Florida Scrub jay Aphelocoma coerulescens Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6174 Ivory -billed Woodpecker Campephilus principalis Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: hiips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8230 Kirtland's Warbler Setophaga kirtlandii (= Dendroica kirtlandii) Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8078 Piping Plover Charadrius melodus Threatened Population: [Atlantic Coast and Northern Great Plains populations] - Wherever found, except those areas where listed as endangered. There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6039 Red Knot Calidris canutus rufa Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/1864 Red -cockaded Woodpecker Picoides borealis Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: hiips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/7614 Wood Stork Mycteria americana Threatened 03/26/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 NAME Population: AL, FL, GA, MS, NC, SC No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https:Hecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/8477 Habitat assessment guidelines: https://ecos.fws. gov/ipac/guideline/assessment/population/124/office/41420.pdf Reptiles STATUS NAME STATUS American Alligator Alligator mississippiensis Similarity of No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Appearance Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/776 (Threatened) American Crocodile Crocodylus acutus Threatened Population: U.S.A. (FL) There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6604 Eastern Indigo Snake Drymarchon corais couperi Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/646 Loggerhead Sea Turtle Caretta caretta Threatened Population: Northwest Atlantic Ocean DPS There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. ov/ecp/species/1110 Fishes NAME STATUS Atlantic Sturgeon (gulf Subspecies) Acipenser oxyrinchus (=oxyrhynchus) Threatened desotoi There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/651 5 03/26/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 6 Insects NAME STATUS Bartram's Hairstreak Butterfly Strymon acis bartrami Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/4837 Florida Leafwing Butterfly Anaea troglodyta floridalis Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6652 Miami Blue Butterfly Cyclargus (=Hemiargus) thomasi bethunebakeri Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/3797 Flowering Plants NAML STATUS Florida Prairie -clover Dalea carthagenensis floridana No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/2300 Endangered Garber's Spurge Chamaesyce garberi Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8229 Critical habitats THERE ARE NO CRITICAL HABITATS WITHIN YOUR PROJECT AREA UNDER THIS OFFICE'S JURISDICTION. F7iitO - N'WIHIJfti - United States Department of the Interior �"""' FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE South Florida Ecological Services Field Office 1339 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960-3559 Phone: (772) 562-3909 Fax: (772) 562-4288 h1W://fws.,gov/verobeach In Reply Refer To: August 02, 2018 Consultation Code: 04EF2000-2018-SLI-0461 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Subject: Updated list of threatened and endangered species that may occur in your proposed project location, and/or may be affected by your proposed project To Whom It May Concern: The enclosed species list identifies threatened, endangered, proposed and candidate species, as well as proposed and final designated critical habitat, that may occur within the boundary of your proposed project and/or may be affected by your proposed project. The species list fulfills the requirements of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (Service) under section 7(c) of the Endangered Species Act (Act) of 1973, as amended (16 U.S.C. 1531 et seq.). New information based on updated surveys, changes in the abundance and distribution of species, changed habitat conditions, or other factors could change this list. Please feel free to contact us if you need more current information or assistance regarding the potential impacts to federally proposed, listed, and candidate species and federally designated and proposed critical habitat. Please note that under 50 CFR 402.12(e) of the regulations implementing section 7 of the Act, the accuracy of this species list should be verified after 90 days. This verification can be completed formally or informally as desired. The Service recommends that verification be completed by visiting the ECOS-IPaC website at regular intervals during project planning and implementation for updates to species lists and information. An updated list may be requested through the ECOS-IPaC system by completing the same process used to receive the enclosed list. The purpose of the Act is to provide a means whereby threatened and endangered species and the ecosystems upon which they depend may be conserved. Under sections 7(a)(1) and 7(a)(2) of the Act and its implementing regulations (50 CFR 402 et seq.), Federal agencies are required to utilize their authorities to carry out programs for the conservation of threatened and endangered species and to determine whether projects may affect threatened and endangered species and/or designated critical habitat. 08/02/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 2 A Biological Assessment is required for construction projects (or other undertakings having similar physical impacts) that are major Federal actions significantly affecting the quality of the human environment as defined in the National Environmental Policy Act (42 U.S.C. 4332(2) (c)). For projects other than major construction activities, the Service suggests that a biological evaluation similar to a Biological Assessment be prepared to determine whether the project may affect listed or proposed species and/or designated or proposed critical habitat. Recommended contents of a Biological Assessment are described at 50 CFR 402.12. If a Federal agency determines, based on the Biological Assessment or biological evaluation, that listed species and/or designated critical habitat may be affected by the proposed project, the agency is required to consult with the Service pursuant to 50 CFR 402. In addition, the Service recommends that candidate species, proposed species and proposed critical habitat be addressed within the consultation. More information on the regulations and procedures for section 7 consultation, including the role of permit or license applicants, can be found in the 'Endangered Species Consultation Handbook" at: http://www.fws.gov/endangered/esa-library/Pdf/TOC-GLOS.PDF Please be aware that bald and golden eagles are protected under the Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act (16 U.S.C. 668 et seq.), and projects affecting these species may require development of an eagle conservation plan (http://www.fws.gov/windenergy/ eagle_guidance.html). Additionally, wind energy projects should follow the wind energy guidelines (http://www.fws.gov/windenergy/) for minimizing impacts to migratory birds and bats. Guidance for minimizing impacts to migratory birds for projects including communications towers (e.g., cellular, digital television, radio, and emergency broadcast) can be found at: http:// www.fws.gov/migratorybirds/CurrentBirdlssues/Hazards/towers/towers.htm; http:// www.towerkill.com; and http://www.fws.gov/migratorybirds/CurrentBirdIssues/Hazards/towers/ comtow.html. We appreciate your concern for threatened and endangered species. The Service encourages Federal agencies to include conservation of threatened and endangered species into their project planning to further the purposes of the Act. Please include the Consultation Tracking Number in the header of this letter with any request for consultation or correspondence about your project that you submit to our office. Attachment(s): • Official Species List 08/02/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 Official Species List This list is provided pursuant to Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act, and fulfills the requirement for Federal agencies to "request of the Secretary of the Interior information whether any species which is listed or proposed to be listed may be present in the area of a proposed action". This species list is provided by: South Florida Ecological Services Field Office 1339 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960-3559 (772) 562-3909 08/02/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 Project Summary Consultation Code: 04EF2000-2018-SLI-0461 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Project Type: COMMUNICATIONS TOWER Project Description: Construction of a 220' guyed communications tower and all associated equipment within a 3,600-square-foot lease area. A 20' wide access/utility easement extends west away from the lease area to connect with Benton Road. Project Location: Approximate location of the project can be viewed in Google Maps: https: www.google.com/maps/place/26.179267702439347N81.57164340399791 W 6o ryln Counties: Collier, FL 2 08/02/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 3 Endangered Species Act Species There is a total of 25 threatened, endangered, or candidate species on this species list. Species on this list should be considered in an effects analysis for your project and could include species that exist in another geographic area. For example, certain fish may appear on the species list because a project could affect downstream species. IPaC does not display listed species or critical habitats under the sole jurisdiction of NOAA Fisheriesl, as USFWS does not have the authority to speak on behalf of NOAA and the Department of Commerce. See the "Critical habitats" section below for those critical habitats that lie wholly or partially within your project area under this office's jurisdiction. Please contact the designated FWS office if you have questions. NOAA Fisheries, also known as the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS), is an office of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration within the Department of Commerce. Mammals NAME Florida Bonneted Bat Eumops floridanus No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/8630 Florida Panther Puma (=Felis) concolor coryi No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https:Hecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/1763 Habitat assessment guidelines: https://ecos. fws. gov/ipac/guideline/assessment/population/8/office/41420.pdf Puma (=mountain Lion) Puma (=Felis) concolor (all subsp. except coryi) Population: FL No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws.2_ov/ecp/species/6049 West Indian Manatee Trichechus manatus There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. This species is also protected by the Marine Mammal Protection Act, and may have additional consultation requirements. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/4469 STATUS Endangered Endangered Similarity of Appearance (Threatened) Threatened 08/02/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 Birds NAME STATUS Audubon's Crested Caracara Polyborus plancus audubonii Threatened Population: FL pop. No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8250 Cape Sable Seaside Sparrow Ammodramus maritimus mirabilis Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. ov/ecp/species/6584 Everglade Snail Kite Rostrhamus sociabilis plumbeus Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: https:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/7713 Species survey guidelines: https:Hecos.fws. gov/ipac/guideline/survey//population/1221/office/41420.pdf Florida Grasshopper Sparrow Ammodramus savannarum floridanus Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/32 Florida Scrub jay Aphelocoma coerulescens Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6174 Ivory -billed Woodpecker Campephilus principalis Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: hiips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8230 Kirtland's Warbler Setophaga kirtlandii (= Dendroica kirtlandii) Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8078 Piping Plover Charadrius melodus Threatened Population: [Atlantic Coast and Northern Great Plains populations] - Wherever found, except those areas where listed as endangered. There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6039 Red Knot Calidris canutus rufa Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/1864 Red -cockaded Woodpecker Picoides borealis Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: hiips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/7614 Wood Stork Mycteria americana Threatened 08/02/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 NAME Population: AL, FL, GA, MS, NC, SC No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https:Hecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/8477 Habitat assessment guidelines: https://ecos.fws. gov/ipac/guideline/assessment/population/124/office/41420.pdf Reptiles STATUS NAME STATUS American Alligator Alligator mississippiensis Similarity of No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Appearance Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/776 (Threatened) American Crocodile Crocodylus acutus Threatened Population: U.S.A. (FL) There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6604 Eastern Indigo Snake Drymarchon corais couperi Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/646 Loggerhead Sea Turtle Caretta caretta Threatened Population: Northwest Atlantic Ocean DPS There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. ov/ecp/species/1110 Fishes NAME STATUS Atlantic Sturgeon (gulf Subspecies) Acipenser oxyrinchus (=oxyrhynchus) Threatened desotoi There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/651 5 08/02/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 6 Insects NAME STATUS Bartram's Hairstreak Butterfly Strymon acis bartrami Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/4837 Florida Leafwing Butterfly Anaea troglodyta floridalis Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6652 Miami Blue Butterfly Cyclargus (=Hemiargus) thomasi bethunebakeri Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/3797 Flowering Plants NAML STATUS Florida Prairie -clover Dalea carthagenensis floridana No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/2300 Endangered Garber's Spurge Chamaesyce garberi Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8229 Critical habitats THERE ARE NO CRITICAL HABITATS WITHIN YOUR PROJECT AREA UNDER THIS OFFICE'S JURISDICTION. 4/26/2018 www.fnai.org/FieldGuide/search-002.cfm ---> 49 Matches Found Plant Dicot - Aeschynomene pratensis - meadow joint -vetch Dicot - Indigofera mucronata var keyensis - decumbent indigo Dicot - Jacquemontia pentanthos - skyblue clustervine Dicot - Passiflora pallens - pineland passion -flower Dicot - Peperomia humilis - terrestrial peperomia Dicot - Peperomia obtusifolia - blunt -leaved peperomia Fern (Pteridophytes) - Asplenium serratum -bird's nest spleenwort Fern (Pteridophytes) - Campyloneurum angustifolium - narrow -leaved strap fern Fern (Pteridophytes) - Pecluma ptilodon -swamp plume polypoda fern Fern (Pteridophytes) - Thely_pteris serrata - Monocot - Campylocentrum pachyrrhizum - ribbon orchid Monocot - Catopsis floribunda - many -flowered catopsis Monocot - Cyrtopodium punctatum - cow horn orchid Monocot - Encyclia cochleata var triandra - clamshell orchid Monocot - Epidendrum nocturnum - night -scented orchid Monocot - Guzmania monostachia - Fakahatchee Guzmania Monocot - Maxillaria crassifolia - hidden orchid Monocot - Oncidium floridanum - Florida dancing -lady orchid Monocot - Pleurothallis gelida - frost -flower orchid Monocot - Pteroglossaspis ecristata - giant orchid Monocot - Sacoila lanceolata var paludicola - Fahkahatchee ladies' -tresses Monocot - Spiranthes torta - southern ladies' -tresses Monocot - Tillandsia pruinosa - fuzzy-wuzzy air -plant Vertebrate Bird - Aphelocoma coerulescens - Florida scrub -jay_ Bird - Caracara cheriway - crested caracara Bird - Charadrius alexandrinus - snowy plover Bird - Charadrius melodus - piping_plover Bird - Grus canadensis pratensis - Florida sandhill crane Bird - Haliaeetus leucocephalus - bald eagle Bird - Mycteria americana - wood stork Bird - Picoides borealis - red -cockaded woodpecker Bird - Rostrhamus sociabilis plumbeus - snail kite Bird - Sterna dougallii - roseate tern Bird - Sternula antillarum - least tern Mammal - Eumops glaucinus floridanus - Florida mastiff bat Mammal - Mustela vison mink pop 1 - southern mink (s. Florida pop.). Mammal - Puma concolor coryi - Florida panther Mammal - Sciurus niger avicennia - mangrove fox squirrel Mammal - Trichechus manatus - manatee Mammal - Ursus americanus floridanus - Florida black bear Reptile - Caretta caretta - loggerhead Reptile - Chelonia mydas - green turtle Reptile - Crocodylus acutus - American crocodile Reptile - Dermochelys coriacea - leatherback Reptile - Drymarchon couperi - eastern indigo snake Reptile - Eretmochelys imbricata - hawksbill turtle Reptile - Gopherus poly_phemus - gopher tortoise Reptile - Lepidochelys kempii - Kemp's ridley_ http://www.fnai.org/FieldGuide/search_002.cfm 1 /1 From: Hitt, Heather To: Jackson Reagan Subject: Naples Park North Tower 2018-TA-0461 Date: Friday, May 18, 2018 3:37:46 PM Attachments: 20130812 EIS Standard Protection Measures final.odf Draft Protocol for Florida Bonneted Bat Roost Surveys.PDF 04 E F 2000-2018-TA-0461 Mr. Reagan: This email acknowledges the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service's (Service) April 27, 2018 receipt of your concurrently dated request for information under section 7 of the Endangered Species Act of 1973, as amended (Act) (87 Stat. 884; 16 U.S.C. 1531 et seq.). We have assigned log number 04EF2000-2018-TA-0461 to this request. We understand the proposed Project incorporates the construction of a 220-foot guyed communication tower and associated communication equipment in an undeveloped grass and tree -covered area. Work would include 100-foot by 20-foot wide access/utility easement extending west to Benton Road. The site is located at Benton Road, Naples, Collier County, Florida (26°10'44.98"N, 81034'17.21"W). THREATENED AND ENDANGERED SPECIES The Service has reviewed its Geographic Information System (GIS) database for recorded locations of federally listed threatened and endangered species and critical habitats on or adjacent to the parcel. The GIS database is a compilation of data received from several sources. According to our review, the Project area is located within the consultation area of the federally threatened eastern indigo snake (Drymarchon corgis couperi; indigo snake), federally endangered Florida bonneted bat (Eumops floridanus; FBB), federally endangered Florida panther, and federally threatened wood stork (Mycteria americana). Eastern indigo snake Suitable habitat for the indigo snake consists of a mosaic of habitat types where snakes establish mean home ranges of 46 ac and 184 ac for females and males, respectively. Project activities are expected to have minimal impact on upland habitat resulting in negligible habitat loss. Therefore, the proposed Project is not likely to adversely affect this species. The Service recommends the implementation of the Standard Protection Measures for the Eastern Indigo Snake (attached) to diminish the likelihood of adversely affecting indigo snakes if any are present on site. Florida bonneted bat The FBB uses a variety of habitat types ranging from forested to urban environments for foraging and roosting areas. Project activities are expected to have minimal impact on foraging habitat and a minimal number of palm trees are expected to be removed. Since the Service is not sure on the value of palm frond roosts, the Service is not recommending roost surveys in palm habitat, unless the palm tree contains a cavity. The Service recommends the applicant survey the palm trees to be removed for cavities prior to removal using the Draft Protocol for Florida Bonneted Bat Roost Surveys (attached). Unless a FBB roost is found, the proposed Project is not likely to adversely affect this species. Florida panther The Project area is located within the primary focus area for the Florida panther and suitable habitat is present. However, the actin area is small and is expected to have minimal impact on upland habitat resulting in negligible habitat loss. Therefore, the proposed Project is not likely to adversely affect this species. Wood stork According to our GIS database, the Project area is contained within multiple Core Foraging Areas (CFA), defined as the area within 29.9 kilometer (km) (18.6 miles), of a wood stork colonies. Loss of suitable wetlands within CFAs may reduce foraging opportunities for the wood stork. The Proposed project would not impact suitable foraging habitat; therefore, the proposed Project is not likely to adversely affect this species. Federally listed plant species According to our GIS database, no federally listed plant species are known to occur within the Project area. Therefore, the proposed Project is not likely to affect these species. If modifications are made to the Project, if additional information involving potential effects to listed species becomes available, or if a new species is listed, reinitiation of consultation may be necessary. Thank you for the opportunity to comment and for your cooperation and effort in protecting natural resources of South Florida. If you have any questions, please contact me at 772-469-4267. Sincerely, Heather Hitt Fish and Wildlife Biologist US Fish and Wildlife Service 1339 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 Phone: 772-469-4267 Fax: 772-562-4288 Email: heather hittnfws.gov NOTE: This email correspondence and any attachments to and from this sender is subject to the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) and may be disclosed to third parties. %40 TRI AF ENVIRONMENTAL - ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING Florida Bonneted Bat Roost Survey August 30, 2018 Capital Telecom — Naples Park North FL Capital Telecom # FL114 Benton Road Naples, Florida 34117 Trileaf # 637639 Prepared For: Prepared By: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Trileaf Corporation 820 Morris Turnpike 1051 Winderley Place, Suite 201 Short Hills, New Jersey 07078 Maitland, Florida 32751 Introduction Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC (Capital Telecom) proposes to construct a 220-foot guyed communications tower and associated compound at Benton Road, Naples, Collier County, Florida 34117. The proposed tower will be within a 60-foot by 60-foot (3,600-square-foot) lease area. The project includes an access/utility easement, measuring approximately 20- foot wide, which extends approximately 100 feet west away from the lease area to connect with Benton Road. The proposed tower will be supported by three (3) anchored guy wires that extend approximately 122 feet northwest, east, and southwest from the tower center. The tower, compound, access road, and guywire anchors (tower footprint) are proposed to be located in a Cabbage Palm (Sabal palmetto) dominated, xeric palm flatwoods. As such, the proposed construction will include the removal of several trees, primarily Cabbage Palms. The Florida Bonneted Bat (FBB) (Eumops floridanus) species is a known resident of Collier County, and therefore, the removal of trees within Collier County can potentially impact FBB habitat. According to the Florida Wildlife and Conservation Commission's (FWC) A Species Action Plan for the Florida Bonneted Bat (Eumops floridanus) the state of Florida has had the FBB listed on the Florida Endangered and Threatened Species List since 1992, and in 2013 the U. S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) designated the FBB as a threatened species under the Endangered Species Act of 1973. Therefore, Capital Telecom has contracted Trileaf to survey the tower footprint (5,600-square feet) plus a 50- foot buffer beyond the tower footprint for the presence of FBBs. See Appendix Site Plans and Aerials for a map of the survey area. Site and Surrounding Habitat According to the United States Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) Ecoregion database, the Site is located near the border between the Southwestern Florida Flatwoods and Big Cypress ecoregions of Florida. The Site is currently located within a Cabbage Palm dominated, xeric palm flatwoods. During a site reconnaissance conducted by Trileaf on February 22, 2018, several trees along the access road, and generally throughout the area were identified to be removed. A tree survey was not conducted; however, based on site observations and the provided photographs, the stand consists predominantly of Cabbage Palm trees with an average diameter at breast height (DBH) of 10 inches. The trees are relatively widely spaced, and canopy cover is mostly open in the action area. Ground cover is dominated by various grass species, Saw Palmetto (Serenoa repens), and other low - growing shrub species. The current habitat is not mapped as critical habitat. Methods On August 27, 2018, Trileaf dispatched Mr. Tyler Brown and Mr. Jackson Reagan, qualified biologists, to the proposed tower site to conduct a ground -based survey of the tower footprint for the presence of FBBs. Equipped with binoculars, a cavity peeper camera, and 35-foot telescoping pole, Mr. Brown and Mr. Reagan conducted a Florida Bonneted Bat Roost Survey per the guidelines set forth in the USFWS Draft Protocol for Florida Bonneted Bat Roost Surveys — February 3, 2015 by walking north to south and south to north transects at no more than 30 meters apart searching for roost cavities or crevices and guano. Findings Trileaf found no cavities of a suitable size for FBBs, crevices containing roosting FBBs, or guano droppings in or around the crevices or trees. In addition, Trileaf found no old growth Cabbage Palm palm fronds suitable for FBB roosts. Conclusions Based on the findings of this survey, it is the opinion of Trileaf that the removal of trees (primarily Cabbage Palms) within the tower footprint (including a 50-foot buffer zone) should not impact FBB roosting habitat. Referenced Material Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission A species Action Plan for the Florida Bonneted Bat (Eumops floridanus) http ://myfwc.com/media/2738262/Florida-Bonneted-Bat-Species-Action-Plan-Final- Draft.pdf Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission Draft Protocol for Florida Bonneted Bat Roost Surveys — February 3, 2015 (attached) United States Environmental Protection Agency Ecoregion Database hgps://www.epa.gov/eco-research/ecoregion-download-files-state-re ig on-4 Qualifications Jackson Reagan, Project Scientist Mr. Reagan holds a B.S degree in Biology from the University of Central Florida. His previous work experience includes Phase I Environmental Site Assessments, National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 reviews (NEPA), Environmental Assessments, migratory bird evaluations, and Sand Skink surveys. Tyler Brown, Assistant Project Manager Mr. Brown holds a B.S. degree in Biology from Indiana Wesleyan University. Mr. Brown's work experience includes Migratory Bird Evaluations, Phase I Environmental Site Assessments, Gopher Tortoise surveys, beach nesting turtle surveys, Red -cockaded Woodpecker surveys, Florida Scrub Jay surveys, raptor banding and monitoring, vegetation surveys, shorebird banding and monitoring, shorebird habitat assessments, and shorebird habitat restoration. Caitlin Young, Project Manager Ms. Young holds a B.A. in Environmental Studies and a Minor in French from the University of California at Santa Barbara. Ms. Young has seven (7) years' experience with the investigation and management of environmental due diligence pursuant to EPA All Appropriate Inquiries (AAI) and the American Society of Testing and Materials (ASTM), as well as National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and environmental permitting projects. Ms. Young operates as a corporate point -of -contact for clients over a large geography, specializing in the Midwest and South regions of the United States. Respectfully Submitted, TRILEAF Corporation Jackson Reagan Project Scientist Tyler Brown Assistant Project Manager Caitlin Young Project Manager Site Plans and Aerials p Z n ~ w� p Of a ZdO L133HS NMOHS SY 31Y05 WaL/£O 31v0 SNM 03'`=u MN 'M3ao 0131! M03H0 ar ae Nmvaq 09810 3 'NMO151aa0N cOZ 3Ln5 3nN3Atl 319N3N '1W OOSI W003131 �vildvo :mOJ °'JH0 lane eDHOM33HUGHM W00'6uamwS'MMM SB69-ZSZ-SOZ 4d bbZSE ewege1V'wey6ww�lg anud �a]uap ssaulsng ESL ou dnoi Bui 99U16U I `J 3 MWS .kBAmns N3MOi dNVIMVN IB 3LY0 NOIsV 'ON o Z f y W F p W U g O Y= 4 K Wj Z t(zss kk� O J O O O O j W K= = 2 Z W W d J 2 O Q x ti N �� Z W Z O 0 i a a 4 rc a (Q' i ®B ® U W 0 x x I �X N Q- m O 0 O r a o X O j Y m<moE z= _ o m Q.Er U m E` m° m m + m °oE7.5 T I Emu Pam' I o2"o.mm.B -16 i o m i,o o _= C£mZ }O - pomm MNv cm U' \ W rc eo?O c �mzm Zomtm��v�i9€€,: f N + rib m 6 w 16 Fl ` cd f"rno =I I I I � I I I I � � I I I p I ¢a / . e ,z\ II \ I 'lover I Ic \ F\ �� \ I iI '� i I II \/ I0 I 1 /la 1 1 x /° I 1 -------- — Na, a —OP— — — — — — — —._.__. _ , —Va--�---- F----=P- — — — — — — — — — — amag ian�ao— — -F (AVM-do-iHo1a onend) ______________ 4 N — -------------- V / J O ry Q ir'sw �r 4m Z O W F y y ? d x O U a w Wa a z cZ d.) V) N O U N Z LL W 'F- V / 0 J LU a_ co J Z Regulatory Documentation Draft Protocol for Florida Bonneted Bat Roost Surveys — February 3, 201S The protocols below ca-e drafi guidance. Prior to ally implementation the U.S Fish and lVildlife Serviee should be contacted to ensure proper Ilse of the most recent protocols. Ilrrplernctrtatiorr of outt ofdate protocols tirgl- irmalidctte I•esults. This protocol is designed to be implemented prior to potential impacts from construction or development projects and should be performed by personnel experienced in management and monitoring of bat species. The purpose of this roost survey protocol is to identify potential roosts and determine if they are currently occupied by the Florida bonneted bat. Roosting habitat includes forest and osier areas with large or mature trees or other areas with suitable roost structures. Florida bonneted bats are known to roost in both natural and artificial structures. Natural roosting structure primarily includes mature or large live or dead trees, tree snags, and trees with cavities, hollows, and crevices but may include rock crevices and other structure, as well. Forest is defined as all types (all age classes) including: pine flatwoods, scrubby flatwoods, pine rocklands, royal palm hammocks, mixed or hardwood hammocks, cypress, sand pine scrub, or other forest types. Artificial roost structures include buildings, bridges, and bat houses. Roost usage and dynamics are not well understood. Although the Florida bonneted bat has exhibited high site fidelity, roost switching is also suspected. Roosting habitat may include sites for day and night roosts to support colonies (e.g., harem, maternity, bachelor, and potential seasonal changes). Because of the difficulty in detecting the Florida bonneted bat and other bat species, negative roost survey results will not equate to a determination that the species is absent from the site. Instead, the results of the surveys will provide information that can help guide the consultation process and appropriate conservation measures. SURVEYING NATURAL STRUCTURES (Iive trees, snags, rock crevices) Areas that contain potential natural roosting structures (e.g., hollows, woodpecker cavities, loose 1 exfoliating bark, rock crevices) should be surveyed following similar methodology as transects used for red -cockaded woodpeckers (RCW) (Service 2004). Conduct systematic roost searches' in suitable Florida bonneted bat habitat (see above) using the methodology listed below: Run line transects through roosting habitat, visually inspecting all trees and snags for evidence of cavities. 1 Projects within the RCW consultation area must identify all active RCW cavity trees prior to conducting bat roost surveys. Any biologist conducting visual inspections of RCW cavity trees must have a current USFWS 10(a)(1)(A) permit that authorizes such activities for the RCW. All active RCW cavity trees will be avoided during bat roost surveys. M • Transects must be spaced so that all trees and snags are inspected. • Transect spacing will vary with habitat structure and season from a maximum of 91 re (300 ft) between transects in very open pine stands to 46 in (150 ft) or less in areas with dense midstory. • Transects should be oriented north to south, to optimize cavity detectability. • When cavities, hollows, or other suitable structure are found, record their locations in the field using a Global Positioning System (GPS) unit. • Visually inspect all cavities, hollows, or other suitable structure (except cavities in active RCW trees) using a video camera probe (peeper) and assess the cavity contents. The cam era should be oriented in such a way as to obtain views of both the top and bottom portions of the cavity, • If bats are suspected or if contents cannot be determined, follow methods to Deternzil7e Roost Usage (below) within 2 days of identification/peeping. If the agency or applicant does not wish to conduct acoustic roost surveys, an assumption of presence of Florida bonneted bats can be made. • Record tree species or type of roosting structure, tree diameter and height, cavity height, cavity orientation, and cavity contents. SURVEYING ARTIFICIAL STRUCTURES To assess artificial structures (including barrel tile roofs) for roosting potential: Conduct a visual and auditory inspection for evidence of bats including the following: cavities, crevices, staining at the entrance to a cavity or crevice, guano, or auditory chirping sounds. If roosting structures or evidence of bats are identified during visual surveys, conduct acoustic surveys, following methods to Deterinining Roost Usage with Acoustic Equipment to confine species of bat present. Positive detection of Florida hnnneted bats precludes the need to continuc additional Surveys.` SURVEYING PALM TREES Florida bonneted bats have been found in the shafts of palm fronds (Belwood 1992). Currently, the Service has limited information on how the Florida bonneted bat is using palm frond roosts and whether they are providing only short-tene roosting habitat, which would not be conducive to long-term, colony, or maternity roosting. Until additional information is collected on the Z However, state regulation for removal of bat roosts may apply. F.A.C. chapter 68A— 9.010; and consistent with protective provisions specified in F.A.C. chapter 68A-27 (68A-27.0011 and 68A-27.003) value of palm frond roosts, the Service is not recommending roost surveys for palm habitat, UNLESS the palm tree contains a cavity. In that case, follow the protocol described for natural cavities. SURVEYING OTHER STRUCTURES Other unique roosting opportunities will be handled on a case -by -case basis through coordination with the South Florida Ecological Services Office. DETERMINING ROOST USAGE WITH ACOUSTIC EQUIPMENT Deploy detector/microphones 15 m (49 ft) from the suspected roost with the microphone orientated in the direction of the suspected roost. Potential roost cavities that are < 15 in (49 ft) apart can be simultaneously sampled if microphones can be appropriately placed to capture any vocalizations of bats departing from both locations. Record all bat echolocations for four nights (sunset to sunrise). Follow the equipment and weather parameters identified below. • Observation of the potential roost at sunset, using a human observer with a detector, could also be used to confirm species. • Detection of Florida bonneted bats on any night precludes the need to continue additional surveys at that potential roost site. Equipment Detectors and microphones suitable for use in this survey protocol include: • Full -spectrum and/or zero -crossing detectors. • Directional and omni-directional microphones. • Microphones attached to detectors via a cable permitting that the cable Iength does not exceed manufacturer recommendations. Microphones should be mounted on grounded or metal poles to avoid build-up of electrostatic charges that may interfere with acoustic sampling. Ensure acoustic detectors are functioning properly and conduct tests on microphone sensitivity to factory specifications before and after deployment, at a minimum. It is recommended that tests be conducted throughout the survey period. Weather Conditions At a minimum, nightly weather conditions for survey sites should be checked using the nearest NOAA National Weather Service station and summarized in the survey reports. If any of the following weather conditions exist at a survey site during acoustic sampling, note the time and duration of such conditions, and repeat the acoustic sampling effort on a different night with suitable weather conditions. temperatures fall below 60°F during the night; precipitation, including rain and/or fog, that exceeds 30 minutes or continues intermittently during the night; and sustained wind speeds greater than 9 miles/hour (4 meters/second; 3 on Beaufort scale) during the night. REPORTING REQUIREMENTS Submit survey results to the Service well in advance of clearing and/or construction. Contact the Service immediately upon locating a roost site occupied by Florida bonneted bats. At a minimum., survey results should include the following: aerial maps of area examined, locations of transect lines, survey results (dates and times of surveys, weather conditions, roosting structures identified, equipment verification information, etc.), GPS locations, physical characteristics, and photographs of roosting structures found, copies of all echolocation files with Florida bonneted bat calls specifically tagged, and names and qualifications of surveyors. LITERATURE CITED Belwood, J. J. 1992. Florida mastiff bat Eumops glaucinus. loridmius. Pages 216-223 in S. R. Humphrey, editor. Rare and endangered biota of Florida. Vol. I. Mammals. University Press of Florida, Gainesville. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 2004. Draft Species Conservation Guidelines South Florida Red -cockaded Woodpecker. South Florida Ecological Services Office; Vero Beach, Florida. A Species Action Plan for the Florida Bonneted Bat Eumops floridanus Final Draft November 1, 2013 Q Ralph, ArwQQd' s ram;. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 620 South Meridian Street Tallahassee, FL 32399-1600 Visit us at MyFWC.com FLORIDA BONNETED BAT ACTION PLAN TEAM FLORIDA BONNETED BAT ACTION PLAN TEAM Team Leader: Jennifer Myers, Division of Habitat and Species Conservation Team Members: Jeff Gore, Fish and Wildlife Research Institute Kathleen Smith, Division of Habitat and Species Conservation Acknowledgements: Laura Barrett, Division of Habitat and Species Conservation Claire Sunquist Blunden, Office of Policy and Accountability Brie Ochoa, Division of Habitat and Species Conservation Mary Ann Poole, Office of Conservation Planning Services Melissa Tucker, Division of Habitat and Species Conservation George and Cyndi Marks, Florida Bat Conservancy Cover photograph by Ralph Arwood Recommended citation: Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission. 2013. A species action plan for the Florida bonneted bat. Tallahassee, Florida. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission ii EXECUTIVE SUMMARY EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) created this plan based on the determination of the Biological Review Group that the Florida bonneted bat (Eumops floridanus) should remain listed as Threatened in the State of Florida. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service proposed to list the Florida bonneted bat in 2012, and the listing was accepted in 2013, adding the Florida bonneted bat to the list of Endangered Species under the Endangered Species Act of 1973. Critical habitat was not designated with the listing, but is expected to be proposed by 2014. The goal of this plan is to improve the conservation status of the Florida bonneted bat so the species is secure within its historical range. The objective of the plan is to initiate research to fill data gaps in current knowledge of the Florida bonneted bat. Since the range of the Florida bonneted bat is limited to southern Florida, some factors related to extent of occurrence or area of occupancy may always meet the listing criteria. The primary actions of this plan focus on collecting information to inform management and collaborating with other entities conducting research on Florida bonneted bats. Because little is known about this species, achieving the objective and completing the actions will require substantial research and monitoring efforts by FWC and other entities on both public and private lands. This plan details the actions necessary to improve the conservation status of the Florida bonneted bat. A summary of this plan will be included in the Imperiled Species Management Plan (ISMP), in satisfaction of the management plan requirements in Chapter 68A-27, Florida Administrative Code, Rules Relating to Endangered or Threatened Species. The ISMP will address comprehensive management needs for 60 of Florida's imperiled species and will include an implementation plan; rule recommendations; permitting standards and exempt activities; anticipated economic, ecological, and social impacts; projected costs of implementation and identification of funding sources; and a revision schedule. The imperiled species management planning process relies heavily on stakeholder input and partner support. This level of involvement and support is also critical to the successful implementation of the ISMP. Any significant changes to this plan will be made with the continued involvement of stakeholders. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission iii TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS FLORIDA BONNETED BAT ACTION PLAN TEAM................................................................ ii EXECUTIVE SUMMARY........................................................................................................... iii LISTOF TABLES.......................................................................................................................... v LISTOF FIGURES....................................................................................................................... vi GLOSSARY OF TERMS AND ACRONYMS............................................................................ vii INTRODUCTION.......................................................................................................................... 1 BiologicalBackground................................................................................................................ 1 ConservationHistory................................................................................................................... 5 Threats and Recommended Listing Status.................................................................................. 6 CONSERVATION GOALS AND OBJECTIVES......................................................................... 8 CONSERVATIONACTIONS....................................................................................................... 9 Habitat Conservation and Management...................................................................................... 9 PopulationManagement............................................................................................................ 13 Monitoringand Research.......................................................................................................... 14 Ruleand Permitting Intent........................................................................................................ 18 LawEnforcement...................................................................................................................... 21 Incentivesand Influencing........................................................................................................ 21 Educationand Outreach............................................................................................................ 22 Coordination with Other Entities.............................................................................................. 23 LITERATURE CITED................................................................................................................. 27 APPENDICES.............................................................................................................................. 30 Appendix 1. Instructions for building a single -chambered bat house ....................................... 30 Appendix 2. Instructions for building a triple -chambered bat house ........................................ 31 Appendix 3. FWC bat house occupancy assessment protocol .................................................. 33 Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission iv LIST OF TABLES LIST OF TABLES Table 1. Conservation Action Table............................................................................................. 24 Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission v LIST OF FIGURES LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1. Florida bonneted bat house at Fred C. Babcock/Cecil M. Webb Wildlife Management Area................................................................................................................................................. 1 Figure 2. Facial features that distinguish the Florida bonneted bat (top) from the Brazilian free - tailedbat (bottom)........................................................................................................................... 3 Figure 3. Florida bonneted bat and Brazilian free -tailed bat, illustrating the size difference betweenthe species......................................................................................................................... 4 Figure 4. Suspected range (extent of occurrence) of the Florida bonneted bat. The species likely occupies only a portion of the delineated range.............................................................................. 4 Figure 5. Projected increase in area of developed land in Florida ................................................ 12 Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission vi GLOSSARY OF TERMS AND ACRONYMS GLOSSARY OF TERMS AND ACRONYMS Acoustic surveys: Monitoring technique that uses specialized equipment and software to detect the presence of bats based upon their echolocation calls. Area of Occupancy: The area within its extent of occurrence (see Extent of Occurrence), which is occupied by a taxon, excluding cases of vagrancy. This reflects the fact that a taxon will not usually occur throughout the area of its extent of occurrence, which may contain unsuitable or unoccupied habitats (as defined by International Union for Conservation of Nature [IUCN]). BRG: Biological Review Group, a group of taxa experts convened to assess the biological status of taxa using criteria specified in Rule 68A-27.001, Florida Administrative Code, and following the protocols in the Guidelines for Application of the IUCN Red List Criteria at Regional Levels (Version 3.0) and Guidelines for Using the IUCN Red List Categories and Criteria (Version 8.1). BSR: Biological status review report, the summary of the biological review group's findings. Includes a Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) staff recommendation on whether or not the species status meets the listing criteria in Rule 68A-27.001, Florida Administrative Code. These criteria, based on IUCN criteria and IUCN guidelines, are used to help decide if a species should be added or removed from the Florida Endangered and Threatened Species List. In addition, FWC staff may provide within the report a biologically justified opinion that differs from the criteria -based finding. BWWMA: Fred C. Babcock/Cecil M. Webb Wildlife Management Area DOACS: Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services ESA: Endangered Species Act of 1973 Exclusion: Legally required method for removing unwanted bats from a structure. Exclusion involves the use of a 1-way device that allows the bats to leave the structure but prevents them from returning. Holes are sealed after the bats are gone and the device is removed. Exclusions are prohibited between 15 April and 15 August because that is when young are likely to be present and remain in the roost while adults forage for food. Extent of Occurrence: The geographic area encompassing all observations of individuals of a species, including intervening areas of unoccupied habitat. Synonymous with range. See also Area of Occupancy (as defined by IUCN). F.A.C.: Florida Administrative Code, the Department of State's Administrative Code, Register and Laws Section is the filing point for rules promulgated by state regulatory agencies. Agency rulemaking is governed by Rule 120, Florida Statutes, the Administrative Procedures Act. Rules are published in the Florida Administrative Code. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission vii GLOSSARY OF TERMS AND ACRONYMS FBC: The Florida Bat Conservancy, a private, non-profit organization established to protect and preserve Florida's bats through education, conservation projects, consultation and bat rescue. Forage: To search for, acquire, and ingest food. F.S.: Florida Statutes Fragmentation: A process of environmental change, commonly caused by human -related land conversion, where once -connected habitats become divided into separate fragments. FWC: The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, the state agency constitutionally mandated to protect and manage Florida's native fish and wildlife resources. Habitat: The area used for any part of the life cycle of a species (including foraging, breeding, and sheltering). Hibernation: A state of inactivity and metabolic depression to conserve energy during periods when food is unavailable. Incidental Take: Incidental Take (as defined in Rule 68A-27.001(5), F.A.C.): Any taking otherwise prohibited, if such taking is incidental to, and not the purpose of the carrying out of an otherwise lawful activity. ISMP: Imperiled Species Management Plan IUCN: International Union for Conservation of Nature, a professional global conservation network. IUCN Red List: (IUCN Red List of Threatened Species) An objective, global approach for evaluating the conservation status of plant and animal species, the goals of which are to: Identify and document those species most in need of conservation attention if global extinction rates are to be reduced; and provide a global index of the state of change of biodiversity. NWCO: Nuisance Wildlife Control Operators, individuals licensed by the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services to address nuisance wildlife concerns according to state rules and regulations. PIT Tags: Passive Integrated Transponders, small devices inserted under the skin with a unique identification number that can be read using an external scanning device. Polyestrous: Having more than 1 season each year in which reproduction can occur. Roost: Artificial or natural structure used by bats for shelter. Roosts can be temporary or permanent. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission viii GLOSSARY OF TERMS AND ACRONYMS Scientific Collection Permit: A permit issued for activities that include salvage, voucher, bird banding, wildlife possession, or special purpose. Applications must demonstrate a scientific or educational benefit for the species, and must identify the purpose, scope, objective, methodology, location, and duration of the project. SWG: State Wildlife Grant Take: As defined in Chapter 68A-27.001(4), F.A.C. "To harass, harm, pursue, hunt, shoot, wound, kill, trap, capture, or collect, or to attempt to engage in such conduct." Torpor: A state of decreased physiological activity in an animal, usually by a reduced metabolism, heart rate, respiration, and body temperature. USFWS: United States Fish and Wildlife Service, the federal agency mandated to protect and manage the nation's native wildlife and freshwater fish resources. WMA: Wildlife Management Area Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission ix INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION Biological Background The Florida bonneted bat (Eumops floridanus) is found only in Florida and is the largest bat in the state (Timm and Genoways 2004, McDonough et al. 2008). Wagner's bonneted, or mastiff, bat (E. glaucinus) is a closely related, but more widespread species found in Central and South America. Until recently, bonneted bats in Florida were considered to be a subspecies of E. glaucinus and known as E. g. floridanus. E. floridanus is distinguished from E. glaucinus by having a significantly larger body size as well as unique morphological features of the face, mouth, and ears (Timm and Genoways 2004). Other common names for the Florida bonneted bat have included Florida mastiff bat, mastiff bat, and Wagner's mastiff bat (Belwood 1981, 1992; United States Fish and Wildlife Service [USFWS] 2012). Life History Relatively little is known about the life history, behavior, and biology of the Florida bonneted bat. Individuals are seldom encountered and most historical and current information is based on collected specimens, a small number of observations of roosting, bats and rangewide acoustic surveys that detect the Figure 1. Florida bonneted bat house at Fred C. Babcock/Cecil M. Webb Wildlife Management Area. Photograph by Jennifer Myers, FWC. presence of bats based upon their echolocation calls. Florida bonneted bats have a distinctive echolocation call that is a lower frequency that other bat species in Florida (Marks and Marks 2012). Bats roost in a variety of structures, both natural and artificial. Tree cavities, caves, rock crevices, and foliage are examples of natural roosts. Buildings, bridges, and bat houses constructed specifically to attract roosting bats are examples of artificial roosts (Kunz and Lumsden 2003). Roosts provide bats with a resting place protected from predators and the elements (Marks and Marks 2006). Roosts also provide shelter for bats to socialize, mate, and rear their young (Kunz and Lumsden 2003). Bats may occupy a roost for only a short period of time, or they may establish a permanent colony within a roost (Marks and Marks 2006). While habitat associations and natural roost site preferences of Florida bonneted bats are poorly understood, Florida bonneted bats have been documented in several roost types. In 1979, a colony of 7 females and 1 male were found roosting in an enlarged red -cockaded woodpecker (Picoides borealis) cavity in a longleaf pine (Pinus palustris) near Punta Gorda (Belwood 1981). Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission INTRODUCTION Florida bonneted bats have been found in the shafts of palm fronds in Coral Gables, as well as under Spanish -style barrel tiles on roofs in Coral Gables and Miami. A roosting colony was found in a in fissures in a limestone outcropping in Coral Gables (Belwood 1992, Timm and Genoways 2004, USFWS 2012). Detailed information on documented or suspected roosts is provided in the Habitat, Use of Forests and Other Natural Areas, Use of Parks, Residential, and Other Urban Areas sections of the Proposed Endangered Species Status for the Florida Bonneted Bat (USFWS 2012). The only current known Florida bonneted bat roosts are in bat houses located on Fred C. Babcock/Cecil M. Webb Wildlife Management Area (BWWMA) (Figure 1) and in bat houses at a private residence in North Fort Myers (USFWS 2012). Florida bonneted bats are consistently present in 1 bat house on BWWMA and the houses at the private residence. Use of the remaining bat houses on BWWMA fluctuates throughout the year (J. Myers, Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission [FWC], personal communication). Florida bonneted bats do not hibernate or typically experience periods of torpor. They are active year-round, as are most bats in Florida, although during extended cold weather events, many bats, including bonneted bats, will become torpid (Marks and Marks 2006, USFWS 2012). Florida bonneted bats feed strictly on insects and they use echolocation to detect and capture their prey year-round. They forage in flight and at night, typically returning to the roost periodically during the night (Marks and Marks 2008a). Fecal droppings from the roost in a longleaf pine tree in Punta Gorda primarily contained flying insects from orders Coleoptera, Diptera, and Hemiptera (Belwood 1981, 1992). Florida bonneted bats are fast flyers and have been observed flying at heights of 10 in (33 ft) or more over open areas (Marks and Marks 2008a). Females give birth to a single pup, and pregnant females and pups have been documented from June through September. Unlike most bats in Florida, Florida bonneted bats may be polyestrous (i.e., they have more than 1 period in which they may reproduce) with the first breeding season occurring June through July and a second occurring later in the year (Marks and Marks 2006, 2008a; Timm and Genoways 2004). Mating behaviors, gestation period, age at weaning, and other reproductive behaviors are poorly understood. Description The Florida bonneted bat is the largest bat species in Florida. Total length for adults typically ranges from 126 to 165 min (4.96 to 6.5 in), forearm length ranges between 61 and 66 mm (2.4 to 2.6 in), and body weight ranges from 30 to 47 grams (1.1 to 1.7 oz) with a pregnant female documented weighing 55 g (2 oz) (Belwood 1981, 1992; Timm and Genoways 2004, Marks and Marks 2006). Fur color varies from dark gray to brown on the dorsal (back) side of the bat, with lighter, grayish fur underneath. Individual hairs are bicolored and lighter at the base. Ears are large and broad and slant forward over the eyes, and, unlike in some similar species found in Florida, the bases of the ears are joined at the midline of the head (Marks and Marks 2006; Figure 2). Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 2 INTRODUCTION 1 Upper lip not wrinkled : 6 Ear edge thin and W not far over eye • k. Upper lip wrinkled Ears join at base Aral g 1_1 Ear edge thick and extends over eye A A Florida Bonneted Bat Ears separate at base Brazilian Free -tailed Bat Figure 2. Facial features that distinguish the Florida bonneted bat (top) from the Brazilian free - tailed bat (bottom). Photographs by Kathleen Smith, FWC. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 3 INTRODUCTION The Florida bonneted bat is among a family of bats often known as free - tailed bats because, unlike most bats, their tails extend well free of the tail membrane that stretches between their legs. Two other free -tailed bats occur in Florida, the Brazilian free -tailed bat (Tadarida brasiliensis) and Pallas' mastiff bat (Molossus molossus), but Florida bonneted bats are much larger than the other free -tailed bats in Florida (Marks and Marks 2006). Figure 3 illustrates the relative difference in size between an adult [70florida bonneted bat 'at Brazilian free -tailed bat Florida bonneted bat and an adult Figure 3. Florida bonneted bat and Brazilian free - Brazilian free -tailed bat. The Florida tailed bat, illustrating the size difference between the bonneted bat is easily distinguished species. Photograph by Chris Burney, FWC. from any other species in Florida by its free tail, large size, and ears that join at the base. Geographic Range and Distribution A survey conducted by the Florida Bat Conservancy (FBC) in 2006 and 2007 estimated the Florida bonneted bat range (FiFiVre 4). A follow-up FBC survey in 2011 and 2012 focused on the Figure 4. Suspected range (extent of occurrence) of the Florida bonneted bat. The species likely occupies only a portion of the delineated range. Source: Marks and Marks 2012. northern and southern extents of the range, but did not result in a significant change to the range map (Marks and Marks 2012, USFWS 2012). The current range includes Charlotte, Collier, Lee, Miami -Dade, and Monroe counties (Timm and Genoways 2004, Marks and Marks 2012). The area occupied within these counties is unknown, but likely is much smaller than the total area encompassed by county boundaries (Marks and Marks 2012, USFWS 2012). Fossil remains suggest the range historically included Brevard, Broward, and Indian River counties (Belwood 1992, Timm and Genoways 2004, USFWS 2012), in addition to the previously listed counties included in the current range. Acoustic surveys documented Florida bonneted bat calls at 2 locations along the Kissimmee River in Polk and Okeechobee counties in 2008 (Marks and Marks 2008b). The occurrence of the species in these counties remains uncertain (Marks and Marks 2012); however, subsequent surveys through 2013 have recorded them intermittently. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 4 INTRODUCTION Conservation History In 1992, the Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission (predecessor to the FWC) listed the Florida mastiff bat (since re-classified as the Florida bonneted bat; see Biological Background) as Endangered. In 2010, the FWC adopted a revised listing classification that combined the Endangered and Threatened categories into a single Threatened status. As a result of the Biological Review Group (BRG) status review and the revised listing classification, the Florida bonneted bat became a Threatened species on the Florida Endangered and Threatened Species List. The change to Threatened status represents a change in the classification system, and not a change in the conservation status for the species. In 1985, the USFWS included the Florida mastiff bat as a category 2 candidate species, since listing might be warranted, but data were limited. Subsequent reviews continued to consider the species as a candidate, but it was removed from the candidate list in 1996 because the taxon was considered a subspecies of E. glaucinus, was deemed more abundant than previously known, and was not in danger of identifiable threats (USFWS 2012). In 2009, after the taxonomy was reevaluated and E.g. floridanus was elevated to E. floridanus, the USFWS recognized the Florida bonneted bat as a federal candidate species in its annual Candidate Notice or Review with a Listing Priority Number of 2 (threats high in magnitude and imminent). At that time federal listing was warranted but was precluded by other higher priority listing actions. In October 2012, the USFWS proposed to list the Florida bonneted bat as a federally Endangered species under the Endangered Species Act of 1973 (ESA); this listing was accepting in 2013, extending the ESA's protections to this species (USFWS 2012). The FWC species -ranking database gave a score of 33.3 to the Florida bonneted bat (scores based on Millsap et al. 1990). A species ranking above 27 is considered potentially at risk of extinction and warrants biological status review (Rule 68A-27.0012(2)(c) I a, Florida Administrative Code [F.A.C.]). In addition, the Florida Committee on Rare and Endangered Plants and Animals included the Florida bonneted bat in the 1978 and 1992 editions of Rare and Endangered Biota of Florida (Belwood 1992). The Florida's Natural Area Inventory considers the Florida bonneted bat to have a global status of G1 (critically imperiled), due to habitat loss and restricted range (Florida Natural Areas Inventory 2012). Florida's State Wildlife Action Plan recognizes the Florida bonneted bat as a Species of Greatest Conservation Need (FWC 2011), and the International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN) currently lists the Florida bonneted bat as Critically Endangered due to small population size, very small subpopulations, and apparent continuing population decline (Timm and Arroyo-Cabrales 2008). Land acquisition specifically to protect Florida bonneted bats has not been initiated. Florida bonneted bat roosting and foraging habitat requirements are poorly understood, making it difficult to assess the amount or type of habitat that should be protected, or if currently protected lands are those most valuable for Florida bonneted bat conservation. The USFWS is expected to designate critical habitat for this species in 2014. During the FBC's 2006 through 2007 rangewide surveys, Florida bonneted bats were documented near BWWMA. In response, FWC contracted with FBC to conduct surveys on BWWMA and installed bat houses in 2007 and 2008. Surveys were conducted over 3 nights and included recording bat calls while driving slowly across the wildlife management area (WMA), Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission INTRODUCTION as well as stationary recording sites. Florida bonneted bat calls were recorded at 3 sites on BWWMA during these surveys (Marks and Marks 2008c). FWC staff at BWWMA installed 15 bat houses, comprising 8 roosts, on the WMA. Each roost consists of 1 to 2 bat houses mounted on a utility pole (Figure 1). To date, 5 roosts have been occupied by Florida bonneted bats. In 2012, FWC staff installed 5 additional roosts near existing roosts to provide additional habitat for Florida bonneted bats. The new roosts are not yet occupied. Monitoring of these bat houses is ongoing (J. Myers, personal communication). The longest -monitored colony of Florida bonneted bats is located on private property in Lee County. In the backyard of a private residence, the homeowner has 3 bat houses that are used by Florida bonneted bats. This is an example of cooperative efforts between a private landowner, conservation group, and wildlife agency. In 2012, the Florida Bonneted Bat Working Group was formed to address the conservation needs of this species across its range. Members include the FWC, USFWS, National Park Service, Zoo Miami, FBC, and several other private and public entities. Many members are also stakeholders referenced in this plan. Members of this working group are involved in conservation activities such as acoustical surveys, bat house monitoring, species education and outreach activities, as well as ongoing research projects. Threats and Recommended Listing Status In 2010, the FWC directed staff to evaluate the status of all species listed as Threatened or Species of Special Concern that had not undergone a status review in the past decade. To address this charge, staff conducted a literature review and solicited information from the public on the status of the Florida bonneted bat. The FWC convened a BRG of experts on the Florida bonneted bat to assess the biological status of the species using criteria specified in Rule 68A-27.001, F.A.C., following the protocols in the Guidelines for Application of the IUCN Red List Criteria at Regional Levels (Version 3.0) and Guidelines for Using the IUCN Red List Categories and Criteria (Version 8.1). FWC staff developed an initial draft of a Biological Status Review (BSR) report, which included the BRG's findings and a preliminary listing recommendation from staff. FWC distributed the draft for peer review, and the reviewers' input was incorporated into a final report. Threats The BRG identified the following threats to the Florida bonneted bat: 1) small population size and restricted extent of occurrence, which increases vulnerability; 2) continued loss of forested habitat; 3) potential limited roost availability; and 4) pesticides from mosquito -control operations. Additional threats identified by the BRG include low fecundity (females produce only 1 pup per year), human disturbance (persecution and removal of roosting bats in trees, buildings, or other manmade structures), prolonged or repeated episodes of cold temperature, disease, and wind farms. Recommended Listing Status The Florida bonneted bat BRG concluded from the biological assessment that the Florida bonneted bat met criteria necessary to warrant its continued listing as Threatened on the Florida Endangered and Threatened Species List. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 6 INTRODUCTION The Florida bonneted bat met the following criteria for listing: • Criterion B, Geographic Range: the extent of occurrence <20,000 km' (7,722 mil) and the population may exist in fewer than 10 locations; a continuing decline is inferred in the extent of occurrence, as well as area, extent, or quality of habitat; • Criterion D, Population Very Small or Restricted: the current population size in Florida is estimated to be fewer than 1,000 mature individuals and the population has a very restricted area of occupancy and number of locations. Other threats include stochastic events such as hurricanes, which may destroy old trees with roosting cavities (Timm and Genoways 2004, NatureServe 2010). For more information on potential threats, including climate change and disease, see the Summary of Factors Affecting the Species section of USFWS (2012). Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 7 CONSERVATION GOALS AND OBJECTIVES CONSERVATION GOALS AND OBJECTIVES The BRG found that the Florida bonneted bat met the criteria for listing as a Threatened species on the Florida Endangered and Threatened Species List. As such, the conservation goal and objective for the Florida bonneted bat are: Goal Conservation status of the Florida bonneted bat is improved such to a point that the species is secure within its historical range. Objective Initiate research to fill data gaps in current knowledge of the Florida bonneted bat and use existing information and results to promote Florida bonneted bat conservation. Rationale Many aspects of Florida bonneted bat ecology are unknown or poorly understood. The BRG identified several threats to the species, but the extent to which these threats impact Florida bonneted bats is not well understood given the lack of scientific information available for this species. The objective of this plan is to identify opportunities to fill in the gaps of what is known about Florida bonneted bats. Effective conservation of the Florida bonneted bat will depend on the support and involvement of partners and stakeholders. Developing conservation recommendations for land management or permitting guidance without a good understanding of the biology of the Florida bonneted bat is not likely to improve the status of the species, and may limit future involvement of partners. Data gathered as a result of actions outlined in this plan will be used to develop and implement conservation strategies to improve the status of the species. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission CONSERVATION ACTIONS CONSERVATION ACTIONS The following sections describe the conservation actions that will make the greatest contribution toward achieving the conservation objectives. Actions are grouped by category (e.g., Habitat Conservation and Management, Population Management). The Conservation Action Table (Table 1) identifies action priority, urgency, potential funding sources, likely effectiveness, identified partners and leads for implementation. The conservation actions are intended to conserve and expand the existing population and increase what is known about the species' range, distribution, habitat requirements, and population size. Several actions also attempt to better our understanding of Florida bonneted bat life history and ecology in order to improve conservation of the species. Completing these actions will allow us to measure progress toward the conservation goal and objective for the Florida bonneted bat. Habitat Conservation and Management General habitat management recommendations for bats include maintaining and protecting open freshwater and wetland habitat as foraging habitat (Marks and Marks 2008c). Habitat management recommendations specific to Florida bonneted bats are not currently available. Action 3 identifies the need to determine the habitat requirements of Florida bonneted bats in order to address impacts of landscape -scale changes across their range. Action 8 describes research to identify Florida bonneted bat habitat types, and Action 9 describes the need to identify what types of roosts are available, and how they are used by Florida bonneted bats. Species -specific habitat management recommendations should be developed based on the outcome of these research actions. Florida bonneted bats are known to roost in both natural and artificial structures, including tree cavities, rock outcroppings, buildings, and bat houses (see Life History) (Marks and Marks 2008a), though the only currently known roosts are in bat houses. Florida bonneted bats have been documented in urban, rural, and native landscapes. Both natural and artificial roosts could be impacted by land -management activities and stochastic events, as well as human presence and the loss of habitat due to development. Colony -roosting species like the Florida bonneted bat roost in relatively permanent and uncommon roosts (i.e., tree cavities and bat houses). They typically remain faithful to their roosts and are unlikely to switch to new roosts (Humphrey 1975, Lewis 1995). If Florida bonneted bats depend on relatively few roosts as suspected, and given their small population size and the uncertainty about availability of suitable roosts, they may well have difficulty finding and occupying new roosts. Therefore, protecting existing roosts is very important to conserving the species. The following section identifies potential threats to roosts and provides recommendations for roost protection. Roost Threats The potential impact of land -management activities such as timber management and prescribed fire on roosts is poorly understood. Timber -management activities (i.e., thinning and removal of old or live trees with cavities) may benefit bats by reducing clutter and increasing the sustainability of pine stands for foraging and commuting (Loeb and Waldrop 2008) or increasing the basal diameter of surrounding trees. However, thinning may also reduce the number of roosts available to bats. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 9 CONSERVATION ACTIONS Presumably, many bat species in the southeastern United States have evolved in ecosystems dominated by fire, and their roosting strategies may limit their vulnerability to fire (Carter et al. 2000). The effects of fire on bats can depend on a variety of characteristics such as seasonality of the burn, fire intensity, residence time (the length of time it takes flame to move over the ground), and overstory mortality (Carter et al. 2000). Fire can create snags, which can eventually become suitable for use by tree -roosting bats (Carter et al. 2000). Fire during the season when most vegetation is dormant may impact the survival of tree- or foliage -roosting bats during colder temperatures and during periods of torpor for certain species, including the Florida bonneted bat. Growing -season burns may impact the survival of non-volant (flightless) young (Carter et al. 2000). Florida bonneted bats may be polyestrous (Marks and Marks 2008a), and flightless young could be affected by fire during either the dormant or growing season. Regardless of fire season, smoke and heat from fire could impact the microclimate of the bat box. On BWWMA, prescribed burning is conducted near Florida bonneted bat houses on a 2- year rotation, on average, with no observed negative effects (J. Birchfield, FWC, personal communication); however, this determination is based on observations, not on systematic assessment. To our knowledge, no research on the Florida bonneted bat's response to prescribed fire exists, though other species' responses have been studied. Studies showed that prescribed burning may initially reduce insect availability (Lacki et al. 2009) but may increase long-term prey availability (Dickinson et al. 2009). Additionally, fire was shown to reduce canopy clutter (Boyles and Aubrey 2006, Dickinson et al. 2009) and create or restore available roost trees or snags (Boyles and Aubrey 2006, Dickinson et al. 2009, Lacki et al. 2009). Any information gained from future research on fire effects to natural and artificial roosts of the Florida bonneted bat (Action 9) should be incorporated into roost protection guidelines. Urban development can also impact Florida bonneted bat roosts. This species has been suspected of roosting in man-made structures such as the shingles of Spanish -style barrel tile roofs in Miami and Coral Gables (Belwood 1992), attics, fireplaces, and brick chimneys (NatureServe 2010). Florida bonneted bats may be killed or injured when dwellings are demolished (Robson 1989) or when they take up residence in structures where they are not wanted. Pest control companies unaware of or non -compliant with the regulations (Rule 68A-9.010, F.A.C.) that apply to bats have been known to remove them through methods other than legal exclusions (see Rule and PermittingIntent, information on Florida Administrative Code number Rule 68A- 4.001. F.A.C., General Prohibitions, and Rule 68A-9.010, F.A.C., Taking Nuisance Wildlife, and Roost -Protection Guidelines). Across the southern United States, bats roost in an estimated 3,600 highway structures such as bridges and overpasses (Keeley and Tuttle 1999). Repair and maintenance of these structures can be detrimental to roosting bats, as can road construction such as road -widening projects. Other Eumops species (i.e., E. underwoodi and E. perotis) are not known to roost in bridges or overpasses (Keeley and Tuttle 1999). Florida bonneted bats have not been documented roosting in highway structures, though their presence has been documented near bridges and overpasses that could be suitable roost sites (Keeley and Tuttle 1999, USFWS 2012; C. Marks, FBC, personal communication) and their potential use of highway structures cannot be ruled out given the few documented occurrences of the species across its range. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 10 CONSERVATION ACTIONS Action 1 Develop recommendations for protecting the roosts of Florida bonneted bats. Although more research should be conducted to determine which specific land -management activities can create or preserve Florida bonneted bat roosts (Action 9), the following list of recommendations should be incorporated into land management and nuisance bat technical assistance (Action 1). This list should be revisited as results of research become available. Roost -Protection Guidelines: Old trees and snags with hollows and cavities should be retained in natural areas such as Everglades National Park, Big Cypress National Preserve, Fakahatchee Strand Preserve State Park, and BWWMA (Belwood 1992). If dead or old trees must be felled, they should be examined for bat roosts and occupation by other imperiled species prior to felling (Marks and Marks 2008b), especially since no locations of natural Florida bonneted bat roost sites or roost selection preferences are currently known. If bats are found, managers are encouraged to consult with the FWC to accurately identify the species and discuss an appropriate course of action. Nuisance wildlife control operators (NWCOs), biologists, and law enforcement personnel within the range of the Florida bonneted bat should be informed that the breeding season of the Florida bonneted bat is uncertain, and that the bats may have young in the roost outside of the typical maternity season. Until more information on the breeding season is obtained and the exclusion rule modified (Actions 15 and 16), we recommend consultation with FWC before excluding Florida bonneted bats from a roost at any time of the year. Increase public land acquisition within the range of the Florida bonneted bat. Land acquisition can assist with protecting roosts, breeding, and foraging areas. Publically managed lands allow for more oversight of land management activities through the required development of state -approved management plans and provide general protections from development. Increase conservation easements and other voluntary conservation efforts on private lands. Educate pest control companies, NWCOs, homeowners and homeowners associations, and local government staff to minimize injury and fatality of Florida bonneted bats in urban areas (Actions 17 and 19). This applies to bats that are roosting in buildings or vegetation such as palm trees that may be managed as landscaping. Take steps to prevent vandalism at known roosts. Vandalism can be a threat to roost cavities and artificial roosts of Florida bonneted bats. At this time, it has not been a main concern at BWWMA, but adequate law enforcement presence and frequent roost checks by biological staff on publically managed lands may deter vandals. Action 2 Develop and implement guidelines for building, installing, and monitoring bat houses for Florida bonneted bats. Bat houses can be useful tools in the conservation and promotion of bats on public and private land because they provide roosting habitat that may otherwise be lacking. Florida bonneted bats are among the species that use bat houses (Marks and Marks 2006). At BWWMA, Florida bonneted bats inhabit single -chamber and triple -chambered bat houses (J. Birchfield, personal communication). More research on the role of bat houses in Florida bonneted bat conservation Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 11 CONSERVATION ACTIONS should be conducted (Action 9). Specific recommendations regarding Florida bonneted bat houses are not available, though species experts provide general suggestions to consider when installing bat houses within the Florida bonneted bat's range. These general recommendations should be evaluated to ensure they address the needs of Florida bonneted bats roosting in bat houses. New recommendations should incorporate research results on natural and artificial roosts (Action 9). Until further research is conducted on the role of bat houses for Florida bonneted bats, general recommendations for building and installing bat houses can be found in the Bat Conservation International's Criteria for Successful Bat Houses, Appendices 1 and 2 (Marks and Marks 2006). FWC bat house monitoring protocols should be followed for bat houses installed within the Florida bonneted bat range (Appendix 3 and Actions 3, 5, 9, 17, and 18). If Florida bonneted bats are suspected in an occupied bat house, managers are encouraged to coordinate with FWC. Action 3 Develop landscape -level recommendations for the conservation of the Florida bonneted bat using information from research on rate of habitat loss, conversion, and alteration. Habitat loss and reduction of forested areas are serious threats to the Florida bonneted bat's survival, according to the BSR. Florida's human population is predicted to increase to 36 million by 2060 and about 28,300 km2 (11,000 mil) of land may be converted from rural and natural to urban uses (Zwick and Carr 2006, Fi ure 5). The projected loss and fragmentation of natural habitat may adversely affect Projected land use in 2060 Current land use or. 0 Developed land Conservation land Vndevekpped land Figure 5. Projected increase in area of developed land in Florida. Source: Zwick and Carr 2006. Florida bonneted bats; however, this species occurs in urban areas and uses structures such as chimneys and roofs for roosting (Belwood 1992). Because the survival and productivity rates of Florida bonneted bats in urban areas are unknown, it is not possible to accurately predict the impact of increasing urbanization on Florida bonneted bat populations. One adverse impact of more urban roosts is increasing human interaction and associated increase in exclusions. Expanded bat education programs (Action 7) and installation of alternate roosts may help offset adverse impacts. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 12 CONSERVATION ACTIONS The Florida bonneted bat population may number less than a few hundred individuals (Marks and Marks 2008a). Restricted range and low fecundity may make it vulnerable to extinction due to inbreeding depression, random environmental changes, or genetic drift (USFWS 2012). Almost 50% of the 12 known occurrences of the Florida bonneted bat are on private property (Marks and Marks 2008a, 2008d). Florida bonneted bat use of private or public lands are not well understood and it would be imprudent to make management recommendations to address these threats at this time. The Monitoring and Research section describes actions that, when implemented, will aid in identifying species -specific management recommendations. Increased urbanization also increases the Florida bonneted bat's risk for removal, exclusion, or persecution due to human —wildlife conflict as discussed in Action 1. Establishment of wind turbines is a concern in some areas because they obstruct existing bat flight corridors and can be sources of bat mortality (Kunz et al. 2007). Some research suggests that bats may even be attracted to the wind turbines out of curiosity, misperception, or as potential feeding, roosting, flocking, and mating opportunities (Cryan and Barclay 2009). Wind farms have been proposed in southern Florida near Loxahatchee National Wildlife Refuge and on the west side of Lake Okeechobee near Fisheating Creek (Melissa Tucker, FWC, personal communication). Adherence to the USFWS Land -Based Wind Energy Guidelines for siting wind farms, along with consultation with FWC, is recommended to wind farm developers, as is more research to determine impacts of these installations on Florida bonneted bat populations. Habitat changes and landscape alterations will occur, but how they will affect the Florida bonneted bat is unknown, as we do not yet know what habitat components and landscape features Florida bonneted bats require. More research should be conducted to determine the rate of loss, conversion, and alteration of the habitat of Florida bonneted bats. Specific research that would assist with these findings are habitat preferences (Action 8), population size and distribution (Action 11), and roost selection characteristics (Action 9). Results of this research can be incorporated in habitat management recommendations for public and private lands (Action 3). Population Management Action 4 Assess the need for potential management actions for Florida bonneted bats roosting in bat houses during extreme weather events, such as hurricanes or freezes, and develop guidelines if appropriate. Severe weather events may affect the survival of the small, fragmented population of Florida bonneted bats. On BWWMA, all occupied Florida bonneted bat houses are located within 16 km (10 mi) of each other. The occupied bat houses in North Fort Myers are within 26 km (16 mi) of BWWMA (J. Myers, personal communication). If a hurricane significantly impacted Charlotte or Lee counties, the occupied bat houses would likely be damaged. Bats in the family Molossidae, including Florida bonneted bats, appear to be physiologically intermediate between temperate- and tropical -zone bats (Arlettaz et al. 2000). They can tolerate moderately cold temperatures but may die following prolonged exposure to cold. During a severe freeze throughout much of southern Florida in 2010, at least 8 Florida bonneted bats died in a bat Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 13 CONSERVATION ACTIONS house in North Fort Myers (S. Trokey, private land owner, personal communication). Natural roosts may be better insulated than bat houses and thus provide better shelter and survival during cold temperatures, but this is merely speculation. Action 4 relates specifically to determining whether bats roosting in bat houses need additional protection during extremely cold weather. Appropriate response to potential severe weather events should be determined. Short-term relocation of individuals from bat houses may prevent their immediate demise, but long-term effects to the bats are unknown. Management guidelines for bat houses should be developed based on current knowledge. Guidelines may change following results of research proposed in Monitoring and Research. Interventions such as insulating or heating a bat house during severe cold weather, or physically bringing bats indoors need to be studied further to determine if they are necessary or if they could be detrimental (Action 9). Factors that may initiate intervention (duration of cold weather, low -temperature threshold) need to be further studied before guidelines can be developed. If Florida bonneted bats are using a bat house, we recommend consultation with FWC before taking action in advance of a severe weather event or if dead or cold -stunned bats are found below the bat house. Monitoring and Research As noted in the BSR and a recent federal assessment, information on population size and geographic range of Florida bonneted bats is quite limited (USFWS 2012). The available information was sufficient to determine that the Florida bonneted bat warrants the highest level of imperiled status in Florida (listing as Threatened on the Florida Endangered and Threatened Species List), but more specific and local information is needed. Several conservation actions listed here will generate needed information on geographic range, habitat use, population size, productivity and survival, and roost use. This information will greatly increase our understanding of the Florida bonneted bat and thereby improve our ability to conserve the species. Action 5 Develop a database of occurrence information and research findings. Because the Florida bonneted bat is rare and difficult to detect, information about the species has come from incidental sightings or irregular monitoring and is not readily available. Compiling occurrence and location information into a database would help researchers know what data is available; but just as importantly, it helps identify what data need to be collected. In particular, a data repository for information about roost sites would be useful in determining the types of roosts used and their location (Action 9). Currently, incidental observations of roosts are largely unavailable to most biologists. Results from long-term monitoring of roost use or large-scale acoustic surveys could be compiled in a central location and made available for subsequent analysis or review by anyone interested in conservation of Florida bonneted bats (see Coordination with Other Entities). Having a central repository might also help in setting standards or examples of the types of data that need to be collected (Action 6). A functional and useful central database for Florida bonneted bats will require planning to determine what information needs to be included, the types of assistance from partners who can provide information (Action 18), and the level of commitment from database managers to keep the database current and readily accessible. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 14 CONSERVATION ACTIONS Action 6 Develop standard methods for detecting presence of Florida bonneted bats. Action 7 Determine the current geographic range (i.e., extent of occurrence and area of occupancy) for Florida bonneted bats. Action 8 Identify Florida bonneted bat roosting and foraging habitat. Florida bonneted bats range over a small area of southern Florida, but that area includes a wide variety of habitats, and their distribution across those habitats is poorly known (USFWS 2012). Recent acoustic surveys have detected Florida bonneted bats repeatedly in only 4 counties and infrequently at a few sites in 3 other counties (Geographic Range and Distribution; Marks and Marks 2012). Because monitoring has been restricted to areas accessible by roads and relatively few bats have been detected, the distribution of the Florida bonneted bats and their use of different habitat types both for roosting and foraging remains poorly known (Marks and Marks 2012, USFWS 2012). As a consequence, the extent of occurrence of the Florida bonneted bat remains only coarsely known (extrapolated to counties) and the area occupied is largely undetermined. Better defining the geographic range of the Florida bonneted bat and identifying habitat types used for roosting and foraging are important steps in conserving this species in Florida (Action 7 and this action). Acoustic monitoring of the echolocation calls of Florida bonneted bats is the most efficient means of detecting these fast, high -flying animals. Before extensive monitoring is implemented, research is needed to determine how detection probability is affected by the survey methods, including type of monitoring equipment and the height and orientation of detectors. Survey methods should also be developed in conjunction with statisticians and species experts prior to implementing an acoustic monitoring program (Action 6). An acoustic monitoring program could be implemented to determine the geographic range and foraging habitats of the Florida bonneted bat by identifying areas where bats are present (Action 7). Analysis of data from the acoustic monitoring, particularly a multiple -scale approach using occupancy modeling, could provide useful information on the landscape features and habitat types used most often by Florida bonneted bats (Action 8). It is important to not only identify specific habitat components that are used by Florida bonneted bats for roosting and foraging on a local scale, but to also identify which factors influence selection of habitat on a landscape scale. On areas where land - management information is readily available, it should be incorporated into analyses to assess potential impacts of activities such as prescribed fire or mechanical vegetation treatments on Florida bonneted bats (Actions 1, 2, and 3). This information would be useful in helping to better map and monitor Florida bonneted bat distribution and to manage habitats for the species. In 2012, FWC awarded a grant to researchers at the University of Florida titled "Closing Data Gaps for the Florida Bonneted Bat (Eumops floridanus)." Funding came from Florida's State Wildlife Grants (SWG) Program. The objectives included in this grant are: 1) to develop a protocol that can be used for monitoring bonneted bats to determine population trends; 2) to determine habitat associations of the bonneted bat for foraging and roosting, surveying a minimum of 7 habitat types and 10 locations in southern Florida; and 3) to provide recommendations for additional conservation measures for bonneted bats. This grant was funded and work began in July 2013. Funding of the SWG grant, implementation of projects to meet the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 15 CONSERVATION ACTIONS grant objectives, and results from data collected will begin the implementation of Actions 6, 7, 8, and 9. Action 9 Determine what kinds of roost sites are available and how they are used. Florida bonneted bats use natural roost sites in cavities of trees, but they also utilize artificial structures including buildings and bat houses (Life History; Belwood 1981, 1992; USFWS 2012). Because Florida bonneted bats roost in small colonies, their roosts are typically small in size and difficult to detect. Currently, the only known roosts are in a few bat houses in Charlotte and Lee counties (Conservation History; USFWS 2012). The availability of roosts and disturbance of roosts are important factors in the conservation of colonial bats, but little is known about the availability of potential natural roost sites for Florida bonneted bats or how frequently roosts are disturbed (e.g., by humans, predators, storms, or fire) (USFWS 2012). We know that Florida bonneted bats will use bat houses, but we do not know to what extent the presence of bat houses may impact their use of natural roosts, or if their use of bat houses indicates that natural roost sites may be lacking. We also know little about how many roosts Florida bonneted bats typically use, how often they switch among roosts, whether certain habitats are preferred for roosting, or the characteristics that make a tree or other structure suitable as a roost. All this information would help managers most effectively and efficiently provide and protect suitable roosts for Florida bonneted bats (Actions 1 and 2) and should be addressed in future research. Artificial Roosts We do not know how important bat houses are to the conservation of Florida bonneted bats. Research should aid in identifying the appropriate style, number, density, and placement of bat houses that may be beneficial (Action 2). Occupied bat houses on BWWMA could be used to study roost switching, seasonal use of roosts, and preferences between artificial and natural roosts. They could also be used to evaluate potential effects of land -management practices such as prescribed fire and tree thinning (Action 1). Information gained from regular observations of the occupied houses and records of the number of bats present before and after land -management treatments will be useful. Even more useful information could be obtained if individual bats were marked with passive integrated transponder (PIT) tags and houses were fitted with PIT readers. In this way, detailed information about roost use could be collected for many individuals, and use of different styles or locations of bat house could be identified. Regardless of the method used to collect data on use of bat houses, it is critically important that research questions, study objectives, details of methods, and analysis techniques all be determined prior to collecting data and in conjunction with species experts and statisticians. Otherwise, it may be difficult to gain useful information from the data collected. Any research at bat houses on BWWMA will be supervised by the FWC, and will require a scientific collection permit (Rule and Permitting) to ensure protection of the roosts. Researchers may also require permits from the USFWS. Natural Roosts Natural roost sites are most efficiently located by tracking bats back to roosts, typically by following bats that have been captured, fitted with a radio transmitter, and released. Unfortunately, Florida bonneted bats are difficult to capture and the few that have been fitted Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 16 CONSERVATION ACTIONS with radios have not tolerated the devices (J. Gore, personal communication). A first step in finding roosts and learning more about them will be determining how to keep radio transmitters attached without harming the bats. Trials could be conducted using bats occupying bat houses at BWWMA; any research at those sites will be supervised by the FWC and require a scientific collection permit (Rule and PermittingIntent) to ensure protection of the roosts. Action 10 Assess genetic diversity across the population. Most aspects of Florida bonneted bat genetics are unknown (Timm and Genoways 2004). Because the population is believed to be quite small and may have gone through genetic bottlenecks following hurricanes or other environmental perturbations, genetic diversity may be low and be limiting population viability (USFWS 2012). Furthermore, it is not known whether subpopulations exist across the species' range and whether these are genetically isolated. For example, if the absence of records of Florida bonneted bats in the open expanses of the Everglades (Marks and Marks 2012) is more than a sampling limitation, then Florida bonneted bat populations in southeastern Florida are reproductively isolated and may be genetically distinct from those in southwestern Florida. It is important to assess genetic diversity across the population so that steps can be taken to improve diversity, especially if associated effects upon population viability are identified. Action 11 Develop and implement range -wide surveys to estimate population size. Because bats are highly mobile and difficult to detect, counting individuals and accurately assessing population size is very difficult (Kunz 2003). Most population estimates have been for species that roost in colonies where individuals can be counted consistently over time. Unfortunately, Florida bonneted bats roost only in relatively small colonies, few of which are known (Timm and Genoways 2004); therefore, population estimates are limited to small portions of the total populations. Although it may not be possible to accurately estimate population size, occupancy modeling (Action 8), analysis of genetic diversity (Action 10), or other approaches may provide useful information about population size. These methods and others should be evaluated with a goal of developing surveys to estimate population size. If numerous roosts are identified (Action 9), the number of bats using the roosts could be monitored and a trend of bat numbers (colony size) potentially could be used as an indicator of a correlated trend in the size of the overall population (Kunz 2003). This information would be useful in assessing changes in population size and would be especially useful if it closely correlated with any observed change in geographic range (Action 7). However, accurately estimating population size may not be practical or possible, and completing Actions 7, 8, 9, and 10 are of higher priority. Action 12 Determine Florida bonneted bat breeding biology, productivity, and survival rates. Action 13 Determine specifically what Florida bonneted bats eat and how their diet varies across their range and over time. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 17 CONSERVATION ACTIONS Action 14 Determine effects of environmental toxins, including pesticides, on Florida bonneted bats. Little is known about Florida bonneted bat reproduction and diet. The breeding season remains poorly determined, except that pregnant females have been found in July, August, and September, and young have been found in all seasons (Belwood 1992, Timm and Genoways 2004). It is possible that females are polyestrous and may form breeding harems in small colonies with a dominant male (Belwood 1981). Females are known to produce a single young, but gestation period, age at reproduction, number of young produced, and survival rates are not known. Knowing this basic information (Action 12) would allow managers to make better decisions about the timing of management activities near roost sites (Action 1) and would allow biologists to make better estimates of population viability. Florida bonneted bats are insectivorous but specific components of their diet are not well understood, and current knowledge is based on a single study with a small sample size (see Life History) (Belwood 1981, 1992). Presumably, they feed primarily upon flying insects, but, unlike most bats, they can take off readily from the ground, so it is possible that they also feed upon ground -dwelling invertebrates or even small vertebrates. Analysis of fecal droppings from known roosts, particularly advanced analysis of genetic material in feces, should provide a clear picture of the diet of Florida bonneted bats (Action 13). However, fecal collection at occupied bat houses can be difficult. On BWWMA, occupied bat houses are in areas that are inundated seasonally with water and almost daily rains during the summer and early fall make fecal collection very difficult. Collecting viable samples can be time consuming and requires daily visits to occupied bat houses Q. Myers, personal communication). Much of the range of the Florida bonneted bat is along urban or agricultural areas where the bats might be exposed to environmental toxins (particularly pesticides) which could adversely affect their health (Clark 1988). The effect of environmental toxins on Florida bonneted bats could be determined by measuring contaminant levels in bats or their insect prey and identifying any association between those levels and productivity and survival of bats (Action 14). If adverse effects are identified, managers could take steps to curtail the exposure of the bats. Rule and Permitting Intent The Florida bonneted bat is to be retained as a Threatened species in Florida, using the currently accepted scientific name (Eumops floridanus) and common name (Florida bonneted bat). Action 15 provides recommendations to incorporate research into protective measures specifically for the Florida bonneted bat. Action 15 Use results of research on Florida bonneted bat life history to develop needed protections. Existing Regulations It is illegal to take bats in Florida in accordance with the general prohibitions in Rule 68A-4.001, F.A.C., but enforcement of this rule is challenging. Colonial -roosting bats that occupy manmade structures are at increased risk of roost destruction and are particularly vulnerable during the maternity season, when bats gather to give birth and raise young. To address these risks, Rule Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 18 CONSERVATION ACTIONS 68A-9.010, F.A.C., provides protections for bats when they take up temporary or permanent residence in dwellings or other manmade structures, such as bridges and overpasses, where human —wildlife conflict may occur. These protections regulate how and when bats may be removed from structures. Exclusion devices (physical barriers that allow bats to exit a structure but not re-enter) are the only legal means of removing bats; the rule requires the use of an exclusion device prior to building repairs if bats are present, and describes the appropriate methods for the use of the exclusion device during the timeframe outside of the maternity season. The FWC provides information and technical assistance on excluding bats online and through regional Wildlife Assistance Biologists. As a Threatened species, the Florida bonneted bat is also protected under Chapter 68A-27, F.A.C., Rules Relating to Endangered or Threatened Species, specifically Rule 68A- 27.003(2)(a), F.A.C., for state -designated Threatened species. This rule states that: • No person shall take, possess, or sell any of the Endangered or Threatened species included in this subsection, or parts thereof or their nests or eggs except as allowed by specific federal or state permit or authorization. • Permit requirements for intentional take and incidental take are currently defined in Rule 68A-27.007(2), F.A.C., and are applicable to the Florida bonneted bat. The intent of protections should include protection of roosting sites, which are different from nesting sites as described in current rule, and should be in accordance with the objectives outlined in this action plan or other recovery plans. These additional considerations are discussed in detail in the Additional Protection Needed section. • Permit requirements for intentional take and incidental take are currently defined in Rule 68A-27.007(2), F.A.C., and are applicable to the Florida bonneted bat. Any research that requires handling Florida bonneted bats will require a scientific collection permit. On BWWMA, individuals who want to collect data on the occupied bat houses without disturbing occupied bat houses or handling bats have been granted access to the WMA through a Special Use Permit issued by FWC. This permit allows for access to closed areas on WMAs and provides conditions for conducting activities. Due to increasing requests for access specifically to collect echolocation calls at occupied bat houses, and in anticipation of future research projects that may result in an increase in requests for access with the potential for cumulative disturbance impacts to Florida bonneted bats, a scientific collection permit will now be required to collect Florida bonneted bat data on BWWMA, unless such work is done in conjunction with ongoing FWC activities or FWC staff. The application for the scientific collection permit is available online. Applications are reviewed by FWC's Mammal Taxa Coordinator, Biologists in the Species Conservation Planning Section, internal species experts, and regional and local staff. Anyone conducting research on the Florida bonneted bat should be aware that additional permits for research activities that involve handling bonneted bats may be needed from the USFWS or from the agencies that manage properties accessed for research (e.g., Water Management Districts, National Park Service). The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service proposed to list the Florida bonneted bat in 2012, and the listing was accepted in 2013, adding the Florida bonneted bat to the list of Endangered Species protected under the Endangered Species Act of 1973. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 19 CONSERVATION ACTIONS Additional Protections Needed As discussed in the Introduction and Actions I and 12, Florida bonneted bats are suspected to have 2 breeding seasons each year. Action 12 describes research needs regarding Florida bonneted bat reproduction. If this research indicates that Florida bonneted bats have a different maternity season than other bat species in Florida, additional protections will be needed (Action 15). Current protective measures contained in Rule 68A-9.010, F.A.C., prevent bat exclusions from taking place between 15 April and 15 August. However, these measures do not require individuals conducting an exclusion to first determine what bat species or group of species would be affected by the exclusion. If a bat roost includes Florida bonneted bats and exclusion is conducted pursuant to the current guidelines, it could still result in take by death of young remaining in the roost after the exclusion, if Florida bonneted bats are found to have a maternity season that falls in the window for allowed exclusions. To prevent take of Florida bonneted bats during exclusions, the following additional protections need to be addressed: 1. Identification of bat species roosting in structures. Visual inspections may be possible in some cases, but roosts are often located in inaccessible areas of a structure (e.g., behind walls, under tiles, or above soffits). Acoustic surveys may be another method to identify what species or group of species are using the roost prior to exclusion (Action 15). 2. Identification of the breeding and maternity seasons for the Florida bonneted bat. This may require reducing the season in which exclusions may be conducted within the range of the Florida bonneted bat. The FWC recommends using only qualified and experienced NWCOs to exclude bats, and provides technical assistance for dealing with bats when they create human —wildlife conflicts. While very few violations of Rule 68A-9.010, F.A.C., are reported to FWC, it is not clear how often exclusions occur that are inconsistent with regulations. It is also not known if most individuals conducting nuisance wildlife work can distinguish between Florida bonneted bats and other bat species. Despite the protections provided to bats in general and to Florida bonneted bats via Rule 68A-9.010 and Chapter 68A-27, F.A.C., there is still concern that Florida bonneted bats may be excluded during sensitive time periods or are being removed from roosts using prohibited methods (C. Marks, personal communication). An additional issue to consider in roost protection during exclusions is that removal of pest species "in, on, or under" a structure is regulated by the Structural Pest Control Act (Chapter 482, Florida Statues [F.S.] and Rule 5E-14, F.A.C.) through the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services (DOACS). This act primarily focuses on the regulation of pesticide use; however, many NWCOs that remove animals from attics or crawl spaces are also regulated by this act. Full licensing as a pest -control operator requires extensive knowledge of pesticides, and this requirement is not applicable to most NWCOs. To address this, DOACS amended Chapter 482, F.S., to include a limited certification for commercial wildlife management personnel (s. 482.157, F.S.), which is required for anyone removing rats and mice, but is encouraged for those removing other species from buildings. DOACS training materials do not include specific recommendations for Florida bonneted bats, and are not adequate to assure conservation of bats in general. Action 19 addresses these concerns through coordination with DOACS. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 20 CONSERVATION ACTIONS To improve conservation of bats roosting in structures, we recommend implementing Actions 15, 16, 17, and 19 to improve compliance with existing rules and knowledge about the Florida bonneted bat. Threats to the Florida bonneted bat were identified by the BRG, but research is needed to understand how these threats may be impacting populations. New regulations or permitting related to habitat loss and roost protection in natural areas are not recommended at this time because of the lack of information about the life history of the Florida bonneted bat. As research actions are implemented and new information is acquired, additional protections or permitting requirements may be suggested in the future (Action 15). Law Enforcement Action 16 Develop and implement an FWC Law Enforcement training module for Florida bonneted bats. In conjunction with federal, state, and local partners, the FWC's Division of Law Enforcement is responsible for enforcing Florida's wildlife and fisheries laws. FWC biologists and other bat experts can educate law enforcement officers through the development, circulation, and interpretation of identification tools, distribution maps, handling, and other approved methods for dealing with unwanted bats (Action 16). Since the Florida bonneted bat can be mistaken for other bat species, proper identification tools will be important for documenting violations of Florida's wildlife laws. In turn, an important component of the enforcement strategy is ensuring compliance through public education (Action 17). FWC law enforcement officers understand the importance of explaining wildlife laws to the public to avoid unintentional violations. However, FWC law enforcement officers actively pursue and recommend prosecution for those who intentionally violate wildlife laws. FWC law enforcement officers also educate the public on how to identify and report violations. The Division of Law Enforcement administers the Wildlife Alert program, which receives information via a toll -free number (1-888-404-3922) answered 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Incentives and Influencing Influencing The BSR and this plan identify the threats to the Florida bonneted bat that have warranted state listing, as well as regulatory recommendations that may afford them protection from take. The FWC is working to develop recommendations for protecting Florida bonneted bat roosts (Action 1) and landscape -level recommendations for the conservation of the Florida bonneted bat (Action 1). Existing efforts to influence county and city governments, private landowners, and other state and private entities should incorporate these recommendations wherever possible. Incentive Programs The FWC's Landowner Assistance Program advances species conservation objectives through public -private conservation partnerships. FWC also takes advantage of several programs that promote conservation by providing technical and financial assistance to private landowners. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 21 CONSERVATION ACTIONS FWC partners with other state and federal agencies to administer the Forest Stewardship Program, Wildlife Habitat Incentives Program, Wetlands Reserve Program, Environmental Quality Incentives Program, Partners for Fish and Wildlife Program, and the Cooperative Conservation Blueprint. Florida also provides tax incentives, including property tax exemptions for landowners that put a perpetual conservation easement on their land. Additional incentives may include exemption from permits for activities that enhance wildlife activities such as mowing, roller -chopping, and tree stand thinning, as long as they are not a precursor to development or negatively impacting imperiled species. Any number of these incentive programs may be applicable for working with private landowners to identify, protect, and manage existing and potential habitat for the Florida bonneted bat. Education and Outreach Bats are often misunderstood by the public. Misinformation can often lead to persecution of bats. Because the Florida bonneted bat is so rare, most people are not aware of the existence of this species. Education and outreach is critical to develop awareness of the needs of Florida bonneted bats (Action 17), and all bat species. Within FWC, education for staff responding to public requests for assistance with bats within the range of the Florida bonneted bat is also critical. Support from stakeholders and conservation partners will be an important component in implementation of conservation actions listed in this plan (Action 18). Action 17 Develop and implement an education and outreach program on the Florida bonneted bat, including development of a Florida bonneted bat webpage for public use. Target audiences for this program include, but are not limited to: • Land managers • Conservation planners • City and county governments • Pesticide applicators • Licensed NWCOs • Homeowners and homeowners associations • Developers and environmental consultants Educational materials will have greater impact if tailored to the target audience. The following key messages should be included: • The Florida bonneted bat is listed by the FWC as a Threatened species, and is also listed by USFWS as Endangered; they are therefore protected by state and federal regulations. • Bats in general are beneficial to have in nature, and the presence of this rare species in south Florida contributes to the uniqueness of that region of the state. • Bats in buildings or in other situations where they could create human —wildlife conflicts are still protected, and resources are available to help address any potential problems. • Because Florida bonneted bats are so rare, actions taken to conserve the species and learn more about their natural history are very important. • Bat houses have the potential to be an important conservation tool for Florida bonneted bats (Action 2). • Roost protection guidelines and general habitat management guidelines will be provided if they become available. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 22 CONSERVATION ACTIONS Coordination with Other Entities A number of partners, including other state agencies, federal and county governments, universities, research and consulting groups, and private individuals take an interest in the conservation of Florida bonneted bats. Research and monitoring are high -priority actions for Florida bonneted bats, and many other entities are currently pursuing projects involving this species across its range. In addition to the information outlined in the plan, the Conservation Action Table (Table 1) identifies priorities for research actions, and suggests specific information that should be included in ongoing and future Florida bonneted bat research. Action 5 recommends development of a database of research and occurrence information, which will require coordination with other entities to complete. This should include coordinating with the Department of Health to ensure that agency is aware of FWC's interest in any bat specimen that may be a Florida bonneted bat. FWC maintains a bat mortality database for reporting sick or dead bats. Anyone who finds a bat that appears sick, is acting in an unusual manner, or is dead is encouraged to report that information by calling FWC's Wildlife Alert phone number (1-888- 404-3922) or completing the FWC's form for reporting sick, unusually behaving, or dead bats. Action 18 describes an opportunity for continued coordination among conservation partners. Action 18 Maintain FWC involvement in the Florida Bonneted Bat Working Group. In 2012, the Florida Bonneted Bat Working Group formed to address the conservation needs of this species across its range. Members include the FWC, USFWS, National Park Service, Zoo Miami, FBC, and several other private and public entities. Many members are also stakeholders referenced in this plan. Continuation of this working group will aid in communication among conservation partners for Florida bonneted bats and will aid in implementation of many conservations actions outlined in this plan. Action 19 Work with DOACS to improve educational materials provided to NWCOs through the limited commercial wildlife management certification. The limited certification for commercial wildlife control operators requires that an applicant pass a test that includes acceptable methods for removal of wildlife from structures. The current set of documents that serve as study material does not provide any information about the Florida bonneted bat and provides a very limited set of guidelines for conducting exclusions. Incorporating the expertise of bat biologists and partners to improve the study material will benefit the Florida bonneted bat and bats in general (Action 19). The module developed in Action 16 could be an appropriate model for the information to include in reference material for DOACS. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 23 - - e 3 v --- o" g"z - - - r" om o - i'i N a q - - ° E a- - °z o 'a ° E n E 3 q -o - `c r E o - _ - _ w m - w 3 y 3o - o E Z sz_ N,Z _. - m E ,' o t E C v E m i 3 'mlu _ - - 3 a a 3 E 3 - 2' v _ ' ° 4 - a - - - o - E `w - - m - c m y - - - E.- 3 - c.31. \� ° E - - o EEt o u- - w E c o -_ - o. - -_ n E - - - _ m gm E `m _ i 3 n t� Eol o rco' -- "sv or _ ---- :--Po -a32 E w L 3 m 3 'E m d 3 0 =� .E a o E = 0 v - - o _° E E o .� 3 3 q - _ _ >Z w 3 s 3m a r - _ - c 3 o _ 2 c o t w° 3 g m> n= E n° 'xm v 3 3° s 3 `m 12 �mv m E m E m E m E m E m E n Eve m° m° m° m° m° m° _ _ o" _ _ _ _ LL 3 3 LL 3 LL 3 LL" LL 3 `o"'if i w E a c Y E J 01 LL i t i t i t i t i Vl - E m Y m =V.1 "o le "o 0 3 le `0 3 le `0 3 le `0 3 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ LL N o c _ E o E E W E _s zit io Y m 3.n AL r r r r r °z ° z 3 3 3 3 °pn3 -�= z i z z z z Oc W Z ° o o- c o o 0 Z Z Z c- Z o E z w t z - - w- u - _ - - IE E a E a E w c c 6c xm a xm ¢ o xm ¢ ao u° O� o - - " - E _o m o w m o'_ m _ E v Ems° o - °0 3 v v E E `o E q _ - - m _ E°_ w s E v w �°„ - o n o a o m ¢ E o a o o o n jagwnN wail u°ipV - spa i E passa,ppv (s)an pafgo .. .. .. .. .. .. w - ti "-_- o — _ o o moo zEo - "`o Eva�� o o `o Eo o z° w ol m Qo - n E o _ o.E_ E IR q lo _ - _ N _ L - o _ c 3 wca So — go w� --o o — - E L - m __ o 3— — _ a E _ a of _ ?q_ ^av o = c j- - °- 0 2 E 3- `o_ 2 3- `o_ 2 E° a m q o 3 ngo z t t - _ — 0 - — - - Iwo — _ - s o \_ w n E 3 m L - 5 3 5 3 5 3 - - 0 2 w— _ f a E - - Y 3 0 - - s o n 3° i o f E°$ 3 w s E E m sQ o o o1. =v m E m E m E m E m E m E m E m E m°O m°° m° Q m° , m° , m° _ _ _ _ _ `- LL 3 LL o LL 3 LL 3 LL o LL 3 LL 3 LL 3 s N It S^c - m z 3 3 3 3 3 3 x 3lu 01 E u oV E JE3q `0 3 0 3 w 0 3 0 3 w 0 3 p _ 1n V _ _ 1n V ,Yn V — — m ' .tl �y m > y� m > �y m > �y > > > > > « o E E o r r r r r E s ` is Ym--� 0 z 0 z 0 z 0 z 0 z 0 z 0 z 0 z i o > > > > > > > > a y3Epgo2$sE •`-o m a a a z z z z z wz e 15 a r c c c c c c c c o w E — 3 N E o o E! °2 E o 3 r _ c E w o = - ?o: E E a E E w E o a o a> — a o. _o jagwnN wail uopay Faaz ry m m ry m passaJpptl (s)8np3alg0 w $ - - {}!§! � ,_ , - --\ _ : k2!!± - }\\\}} \\/ }\\\\ \\\}} \}/o // o o lo /koo : o iE \ \\ ! \\\� �/ :_ \ ) )\\\\ ;!| \- -_ _ Z._ $\){ § �- \\\\\\\\ j\)\ \ \�� § \\\/k \k\}( \\))()) \/\/\\SS ))f\!k{\§ 12 !!! o !| !- !| E }\ }} }} \�� §/\ (\); /) ` \ #w \] La| ! \\\lo o |o �� I 11 Im 11 !°! E �oo i)f )}.{;{ 7 /E - * ! , - - {{{ \ \ /\ » , » ( \ )! - - lo )i ! ) )) )o o z-- 2 mw_ k( \/ _ - 2 )f /f)| \\} }\\ }\o43 \\ \\zE s!! !:2 0o 1. ,: �} !!!, __ _ _- E __- _o - - - - k/2)(e(%)\ LITERATURE CITED LITERATURE CITED Arlettaz, R., Ruchet, C., Aeschimann, J., Brun, E., Genoud, M., and Vogel, P. 2000. Physiological traits affecting the distribution and wintering strategy of the bat Tadarida teniotis. Ecology 81:1004-1014. Belwood, J. J. 1981. Wagner's mastiff bat, Eumops glaucinus floridanus (Molossidae) in southwestern Florida. Journal of Mammalogy 62:411-413 Belwood, J. J. 1992. Florida mastiff bat Eumops glaucinus floridanus. Pages 216-223 in S. R. Humphrey, editor. Rare and endangered biota of Florida. Vol. I. Mammals. University Press of Florida, Gainesville. Boyles, J .G., and D. P. Aubrey. 2006. Managing forests with prescribed fire: implications for a cavity -dwelling bat species. Forest Ecology and Management 222:108-115. Carter, T. C., W. M. Ford, and M. A. Menzel. 2000. Fire and bats in the southeast and mid - Atlantic: more questions than answers? Pages 139-143 in W. M. Ford, K. R. Russell, and C. E. Moorman, editors. Proceedings of a special workshop on the role of fire in nongame wildlife management and community restoration: traditional uses and new directions. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Nashville, Tennessee. Clark, Jr. D. R. 1988. How sensitive are bats to insecticides? Wildlife Society Bulletin 16:399- 403. Cryan, P. M., and R. M. Barclay. 2009. Causes of bat fatalities at wind turbines: hypotheses and predictions. Journal of Mammalogy 90:1330-1340. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission [FWC]. 2011. Florida's Wildlife Legacy Initiative. Florida's draft state wildlife action plan. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, Tallahassee. Florida's Natural Area Inventory. 2012. FNAI Element Tracking List. Updated June 2012. Florida's Natural Area Inventory Tallahassee. Humphrey, S. R. 1975. Nursery roosts and community diversity of Nearctic bats. Journal of Mammalogy 56:321-346. Keeley, B. W., and M. D. Tuttle. 1999. Bats in American bridges. Resource Publication No. 4. Bat Conservation International, Austin, Texas. Kunz, T. H. 2003. Censusing bats: challenges, solutions, and sampling biases. Pages 9-19 in T. J. O'Shea and M. A. Bogan, editors. Monitoring trends in bat populations of the United States and territories: problems and prospects. U.S. Geological Survey, Information and Technology Report USGSBRD/ITR-2003-0003, Ft. Belvoir, Virginia. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 27 LITERATURE CITED Kunz, T. H., and L. F. Lumsden. 2003. Ecology of cavity and foliage roosting bats. Pages 3-89 in T. H. Kunz and M. B. Fenton, editors. Bat ecology. The University of Chicago Press. Chicago, Illinois. Kunz, T. H., E. B. Arnett, W. P. Erickson, A. R. Hoar, G. D. Johnson, R. P. Larkin, R. W. Strickland, and M. D. Tuttle. 2007. Ecological impacts of wind energy development on bats: questions, research needs, and hypotheses. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 5:315-324. Lacki, M. J., D. R. Cox, L. E. Dodd, and M. B. Dickinson. 2009. Response of northern bats (Myotis septentrionalis) to prescribed fires in eastern Kentucky forests. Journal of Mammalogy 90:1165-1175. Lewis, S. E. 1995. Roost fidelity of bats: a review. Journal of Mammalogy 76:481-496. Loeb, S. C., and T. A.Waldrop. 2008. Bat activity in relation to fire and fire surrogate treatments in southern pine stands. Forest Ecology and Management 255:3185-3192. Marks, C. S., and G. E. Marks. 2006. Bats of Florida. University Press of Florida. Gainesville. Marks, G. E., and C. S. Marks. 2008a. Status of the Florida bonneted bat (Eumops floridanus). Final report submitted to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service by the Florida Bat Conservancy under grant agreement number 401815G192, Florida Bat Conservancy, Bay Pines. Marks, G. E., and C. S. Marks. 2008b. Bat conservation and land management Kissimmee River WMA. Report submitted to the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission by the Florida Bat Conservancy, Bay Pines. Marks, G. E., and C. S. Marks. 2008c. Bat conservation and land management Babcock Webb WMA. Report submitted to the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission by the Florida Bat Conservancy, Bay Pines. Marks, G.E. and C.S. Marks. 2008d. Status of the Florida bonneted bat (Eumops floridanus). Supplemental report submitted to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service by the Florida Bat Conservancy under grant agreement number 401815G192, Florida Bat Conservancy, Bay Pines. Marks, G. E., and C. S. Marks. 2012. Status of the Florida bonneted bat (Eumops floridanus). Final report to U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service by the Florida Bat Conservancy under grant agreement number 40181AG121, Florida Bat Conservancy, Bay Pines. McDonough, M. M., L. K. Ammerman, R. M. Timm, H. H. Genoways, P. A. Larsen, and R. J. Baker. 2008. Speciation within bonneted bats (Genus Eumops): the complexity of Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 28 LITERATURE CITED morphological, mitochondrial, and nuclear data sets in systematic. Journal of Mammalogy 90:1306-1315. Millsap, B. A., J. A. Gore, D. E. Runde, and S. I. Cerulean. 1990. Setting priorities for the conservation of fish and wildlife species in Florida. Wildlife Monographs 111:1-57. NatureServe. 2010. NatureServe Explorer: An online encyclopedia of life [web application]. Version 7.1. NatureServe, Arlington, Virginia. http://www.natureserve.org/explorer. Accessed: 6 May 2011). Robson, M. 1989. Status survey of the Florida mastiff bat. Final performance report. Nongame Wildlife Section, Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission, Tallahassee. Timm, R. M., and H. H. Genoways. 2004. The Florida bonneted bat, Eumops floridanus (Chiroptera: Molossidae): distribution, morphometrics, systematic, and ecology. Journal of Mammalogy 85:852-865. Timm, R., and J. Arroyo-Cabrales. 2008. Eumops floridanus. In: IUCN 2010. IUCN Red List of Threatened Species. Version 2012.2 www.iucnredlist.or . Accessed 12 December 2012. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service [USFWS]. 2012. Proposed endangered species status for the Florida bonneted bat. Federal Register 77(193):60750-60776. Zwick, P. D., and M. H. Carr. 2006. Florida 2060: A population distribution scenario for the State of Florida. Prepared by the Geoplan Center at the University of Florida for 1000 Friends of Florida, Gainesville. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 29 APPENDICES APPENDICES Appendix 1. Instructions for building a single -chambered bat house. (These are general plans for a single -chambered bat house but this design has not been tested for use by Florida bonneted bats.) http://www.batcon.org/pdfs/bathouses/SingleChamberBHPlans.pdf BAT C*NSERVAAJ0t www.batcon.org Single -chamber Bat House (wall mounted) Mareriah (makes one !muse) ti sheet (2' x 4') k" AC, BC or T1-11 (outdoor grade) plywood One piece 1" x 2" ('k" x IM" finished) x 8' pine (furring strip) 20 to 30 exterior -grade screws, 1" One pint dark, water -based stain, exterior grade One pint water -based primer, exterior grade One quart flat, water -based paint or stain, exterior grade One tube paintable latex caulk 1" x 4" x 28" board for roof (optional, but highly recommended) Black asphalt shingles or galvan i zed metal (optional) 6 to10 roofing nails, X" (if using shingles or metal roofing) Recommended tools Table saw or handsaw Caulking gun Variable -speed re versing drill Paintbrushes Screwdriver bit for drill Hammer (optional) Tape measure or yardstick Tin snips (optional) More bat -house plans and additional information can be found in BCI's Bat House Builder's Handbook, available at wwvbatcatolog.com. Construction 1. Measure and cut plywood into three pieces: 26%" x 24" 16Y" x 24" 5" x 24" 2. Roughen inside of backboard and landing area by cutting horzzmtal grooves with sharp object or saw. Space grooves Y.." to T apart, cutting Yu" to Sf." deep. 3. Apply two coats of dark, water -based stain to interior maces. Do not use paint, as it will fill grooves. 4. Cut furring strip into one 24" and two 209" pieces. 5. Attach furring strips to back, caulking first. Start with 24" piece at top. Roost chamber spacing is g". 6. Attach front to furring strips, top piece first (caulk first). Leave %" vent space between top and bottom front pieces. 7. Caulk all outside joints to further seal roost chamber. 8. Attach a 1" x 4" x 28" board to the top as a roof (optional, but highly recommended). 9. Apply three coats of paint or stain to the exterior (use primer for first coat). 10. Cover roof with shingles or gahanized metal (optional). 11. Mount on building (south or east sides usually best). Optional modifications to the single -chamber bat house 1. Wider bat houses can be built for larger colonies. Be sure to adjust dimensions for back and front pieces and ceiling strip. A X" support spacer may be needed in the center of the roost- ing chamber for bat houses over 24" wide to prevent warping. 2. To make a taller version for additional temperature diversity, use these modifications: From a 2' x 8' piece of plywood, cut t h we pieces: 51" x 24", 33" x 24" and 12" x 24". Cut two 8' furring strips into one 24" and two 44" pieces. Follow assem- bly procedure above. 3. Two bat houses can be placed back-to-back, mounted between two poles, to create a three -chamber nursery house. Before assembly, cut a horizontal X" slot in the back of each house about 9" from the bottom edge of the back piece to permit movement of bats between houses. Two pieces of wood, 1" x 4" x 4V, screwed horizontally to each side, will join the two boxes. Leave a Y" space between the two houses, and roughen the wood surfaces or cover the back of each with plastic mesh (see item 5 below). Do not cover the rear exit slots with mesh. One 1 " x 4" x 34" vertical piece, attached to each side over the horizontal pieces, blocks light but allows bats and air to enter. A galvanized metal roof, covering both houses, protects the center roosting area from rain. Eaves should be about 3" in southern areas and about 1i4" in the torch. 4. Ventilation may not be necessary in cold climates. In this case, the front should be a single piece 23" long. Smaller bat houses like this one will be less successful in cool climates. However, those mounted on buildings maintain thermal stability better and are more likely to attract bats. 5. Durable plastic mesh can be substituted to provide footholds for bats. Attach one 20" x 2432piece to backboard after stain- ing interior, but prior to assembly. © copyright Bat Conservation International, Inc. All rights reserved. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 30 APPENDICES Appendix 2. Instructions for building a triple -chambered bat house. http://www.floridabats.org/ImagesBHs/Bat—House—Plans.pdf Vent Triple -chambered Bat House Plans Front View 8„ :al■ .1 u Side View 6" Board Partition Spacer Bottom View MATERIALS One 3' foot long 1" X 8" (7'/4") One 2' X 2' sheet of T-111 exterior siding or rough sided plywood. One 8' foot long 1" X 6" ( 5'/2') One 4' by 4' sheet'/4" plastic mesh (Optional).' One 6' foot long 1" X 4" (3'/i') 46 - 1 5/8" #8 galvanized wood screws. Two 3' foot long 1" X 1" ('/4') "Plastic mesh is only necessary if the interior of the bat house is constructed with smooth -sided wood. A better approach is to use T-111 siding for the partitions and rough -sided lumber for the back wall. If smooth -sided wood or plywood is used, it can be grooved at '/2" intervals to provide a rough surface for the bats to grasp onto. See also the note at bottom of page 2. INSTRUCTIONS Step 1. From the 1 X6, cut six 14" sections for the front and back panels of the bat house. From the 1 X8, cut one 16" section for the roof and one 14" section for the back. From the 1X1's cut four 17" sections. These will be used as spacers to secure the partitions. From the 1X4, cut one additional 14" section for the back. From the remaining piece of the 1X4 cut two sections for the sides. One end of each piece will be cut at a 30-degree angle for the roof. This can be done by cutting each piece with a front length of 21'/i' and a back length of 23'/i'. © Florida Bat Conservancy, P.O. Box 516, Bay Pines, FL 33744. Ph: (727) 710-BATS Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 31 APPENDICES L continued. Step 2. From the T-111 or plywood sheet, cut a 17X12" section for the back partition, and a 16"X12" section for the front partition. Note: If a larger piece of plywood is available, these two pieces can be cut 12'/z" in width to provide a flush fit at either side. Step 3. Bevel the back of the 16" roof section at 30 degrees. The roof will look best if the top (widest side) is made 6'/i' wide when the bevel is cut. Bevel one of the 14" X 6" pieces at 30 degrees. This piece will be used at the top of the front and the bevel is necessary to match the roof. Step 4. Begin assembly of the bat house by placing the two side pieces on a table with the long sides up and 14" apart (outside to outside). It is recommended that glue or caulking be used as the bat house is assembled to strengthen and weatherproof it. Place one of the 14" X 6" pieces on top and align it with the bottom of the two side pieces. Fasten it with two 1-5/8" wood screws on each side. Drilling 3/32" pilot holes for all screws will help prevent the wood from splitting. Repeat the process with a 6", 4", 6" and 8" piece, in that order. This will place the 8" piece at the top of the bat house. Now turn the bat house over so it is laying on its back. Drill one 5/16" hole at the top, and one 5/16" hole bottom. These will be used for mounting the bat house to a post or building. The holes should be located in the center and 2" from the edge. Step 5. If plastic mesh is being used, cut two sections of plastic mesh the same dimensions as the plywood partitions. Staple the mesh to the plywood using vertical rows of staples about 2-3" apart. The side with the mesh All face the front of the bat house. Cut a section of plastic mesh 12" wide and 23" long and place it on the back wall of the bat house. Fasten the mesh with vertical rows of staples about 2-3" apart. Step 6. Position the 1X1's in the left and right-hand corners with the bottom ends located 4'/2' from the bottom of the bat house. This will create a 41/2' landing pad. Place the 17" partition with the rough or mesh covered side up on top of the two 1X1's already in position. Use three 1-5/8" wood screws in each; one in the center and the other two about from each end. Make sure the top wood screw securely attaches the 1X1 to the 8" board on the back wall. This will add strength to the bat house Step 7. Position the remaining two 1X1's on each side of the partition directly above the previous two. Place the 16" partition on top (rough or mesh side up); allowing 1" of the previous 1X1's to show at the bottom. This open space makes it easier for bats to crawl into the forward crevices. Now fasten the plywood section and 1X1's using two 1-5/8" screws on each side. Locate them about 1'/s" from the top and bottom of the plywood partition to avoid the screws underneath. Step 8. Place the beveled 14" X 6" board at the top of the front, aligning the beveled edge with the 30 degree angle of the two side pieces. Fasten it using two 1-5/8" screws on each side. Repeat using a second 14" X 6" board. Locate the third and final 14" X 6" board about''/2' down from the previous one to form a'/z" gap for the vent. Step 9. Center the roof section such that there is equal overhang on each side. Fasten it to the side pieces using two 1-5/8" screws on each side. The roof should be caulked where it meets the back wall. Adding roofing material and painting the bat house will greatly extend its life. A light brown color works well in Florida. Step 10. The bat house can be mounted on a 4'X4" post or the side of a building using the holes drilled in step 4 and three-inch long, 5/16" lag bolts. A large galvanized or stainless steel washer (fender washer) is recommended to protect the wood. Mounting on trees is not recommended because they have proven to be the least successful location for bat houses. Bat houses should be located at least ten feet above ground. Experience indicates the higher the bat house is mounted the more likely it will get bats. Note 1: There are photographs of this bat house during various stages of construction on the web at: http://www.floridabats.org/BatHousePIan Photos.htm. Note 2: If you choose to use '/a" plastic mesh please contact the Florida Bat Conservancy since it is not readily available from local suppliers. We can mail you the required amount of mesh for this bat house design for the cost of the material and shipping. © Florida Bat Conservancy. Email: floridabats@aol.com. Phone: (727) 710-2287 Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 32 APPENDICES Appendix 3. FWC bat house occupancy assessment protocol. Protocol current as of May 2013. 0Bat House Occupancy Assessment Bat houses provide roosting sites for several species of bats in Florida and can be an important tool in bat conservation. Better information is needed on where and when bats are using but houses on conservation lands, and if land management activities have the potential to impact bat house use. Participating in bat house occupancy assessments will lead to better recommendations on bat house siting, and over many years may provide trend information on bat house use. Assessment Objective - Estimate number of bats and seasonality of use of bat houses in Florida. 0 Bat houses should be checked THREE times every year. Checks should be conducted once during each of the following time periods: May -July September -November 15th December -February 0 If staff resources allow, information is also needed relative to land management activities. These o t� ional visits should be conducted ithin a week be ore and a ter land management activities within 100 ft of houses. Land management activities include prescribed burning, extensive timber removal, or other activities that substantially alter the immediate environment. 0 Bat house checks fall into two categories: daytime checks and evening emergence counts. • Daytime Checks are completed to determine if bat houses are occupied and to estimate number of bats for each house according to the instructions below. • Evening Emergence Counts are optional and are best conducted at occupied houses in which number of bats cannot be estimated (ie. large condo houses, reduced visibility). Daytime Checks - Visit each house during the day and look for signs that bats are using the house. For occupied houses, estimate number of bats, if possible. 0 Bat sign includes: • Staining near the opening of the house chambers. • Small pellets scattered on the ground at the base of the house. Bat guano is a similar size to mouse or rat droppings, but is composed primarily of insect parts and can be easily crumbled. Pellets are also rather shiny in appearance. • Sounds of bats (chirping, chattering) 0 Binoculars, mirrors, and flashlights can be used to look into house chambers for bats. 0 Record date, presence/absence, type of bat sign, and estimated number of bats on datasheet. • Estimated number of bats — Count or estimate the number of bats in the bat house, if possible. In most cases bats cannot be individually counted, but an estimate of the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 33 APPENDICES Appendix 3 continued. proportion of space within each house that is filled by resting bats may be possible, using increments of 25% (ie. 0-25%, 26-50%, 51-75%, 76-100%). If neither a count nor estimate of proportion of space can be confidently determined, simply indicate whether the house is occupied. If conducting the daytime visit as part of a land management activity, please include the type of land management and the date of the activity in the data sheet. Multiple visits can be included on a single data sheet. Evenin¢ Emereence Count - Conduct at houses known or suspected to be occupied and in which number of bats cannot be accurately determined. Technical and staff assistance can be provided if needed. 0 Count should take place on a clear evening when the temperature is warmer than 451 F. 0 Arrive at least 15 minutes prior to sunset; choose a location at least 25 feet from the house, with a clear view of the opening. Limit disturbance (noise, lights) that could prevent emergence. 0 Bats should emerge shortly after sunset. The observer should remain at the house for at least 30 minutes after civil twilight, or until no more bats emerge from the house. If bonneted bats are suspected, the observer should remain at the house for at least 45 minutes after civil twilight. 0 For sunset and civil twilight times, see http://aa.tisno.nayy.mil/data/docs/RS_OneDayphp 0 Record date, number of bats, and other observations on datasheet. 0 Near -infrared equipment can be used to record an emergence and can be particularly useful at large bat condos. 0 Fill out Bat House Information form only once for each bat house. 0 Record all data from Daytime Checks and Evening Emergence Counts using the Bat House Occupancy Datasheet below. 0 Send all forms to Mehssa.Tucker(&mvfwc.com FWC's Mammal Taxa Coordinator Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 34 APPENDICES Appendix 3 continued. 0 Bat House Information Send forms to Mehssa.Tucker(&inyfwc.com FWC's Mammal Taxa Coordinator Please complete one forni for each bat house on WMA/WEA. General Information VVIAA/WEA: Contact Name: Contact Phone Nuumber: Total Number of Bat Houses: Bat House Information Bat House Name: (Name is for WMA/WEA staff reference only. Choose a name that uniquely identifies the bat house for staff purposes. Ex: Check station house, pond house, Burn Unit 12 house, etc.) Latitude: _ Longitude: (Decimal degrees preferred) Installation Date (estimated monthlyear): Bat House Size: Single _ Double _ Triple Condo Estimated number of bats when full (if known): If size is unknown, estimated dimensions: Bat House Mount Setup Estimated Height of House (from ground) (Ex. Attached to tree, pole, 4x4, building) Photo provided? ( Y / N ) If possible, please attach a photo of this house, labeled with Bat House Name. Brief description of habitat within sight of bat house: Other continents regarding bat house: Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 35 APPENDICES Appendix ]Continued ( B z 2 § ) } 2 0 ne „„ate �@,■ \ z'2. -!2, Z;ƒ3oo # _ ID _ //$CL a %0, §�V� �. Florida Bonneted Bat Species Action Plan STANDARD PROTECTION MEASURES FOR THE EASTERN INDIGO SNAKE U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service August 12, 2013 The eastern indigo snake protection/education plan (Plan) below has been developed by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) in Florida for use by applicants and their construction personnel. At least 30 days prior to any clearing/land alteration activities, the applicant shall notify the appropriate USFWS Field Office via e-mail that the Plan will be implemented as described below (North Florida Field Office: jaxre sg`(&,,fws.gov; South Florida Field Office: verobeachkfws.gov; Panama City Field Office: panamacity&fws.gov). As long as the signatory of the e-mail certifies compliance with the below Plan (including use of the attached poster and brochure), no further written confirmation or "approval" from the USFWS is needed and the applicant may move forward with the project. If the applicant decides to use an eastern indigo snake protection/education plan other than the approved Plan below, written confirmation or "approval" from the USFWS that the plan is adequate must be obtained. At least 30 days prior to any clearing/land alteration activities, the applicant shall submit their unique plan for review and approval. The USFWS will respond via e- mail, typically within 30 days of receiving the plan, either concurring that the plan is adequate or requesting additional information. A concurrence e-mail from the appropriate USFWS Field Office will fulfill approval requirements. The Plan materials should consist of: 1) a combination of posters and pamphlets (see Poster Information section below); and 2) verbal educational instructions to construction personnel by supervisory or management personnel before any clearing/land alteration activities are initiated (see Pre -Construction Activities and During Construction Activities sections below). POSTER INFORMATION Posters with the following information shall be placed at strategic locations on the construction site and along any proposed access roads (a final poster for Plan compliance, to be printed on I I" x 17" or larger paper and laminated, is attached): DESCRIPTION: The eastern indigo snake is one of the largest non -venomous snakes in North America, with individuals often reaching up to 8 feet in length. They derive their name from the glossy, blue -black color of their scales above and uniformly slate blue below. Frequently, they have orange to coral reddish coloration in the throat area, yet some specimens have been reported to only have cream coloration on the throat. These snakes are not typically aggressive and will attempt to crawl away when disturbed. Though indigo snakes rarely bite, they should NOT be handled. SIMILAR SNAKES: The black racer is the only other solid black snake resembling the eastern indigo snake. However, black racers have a white or cream chin, thinner bodies, and WILL BITE if handled. LIFE HISTORY: The eastern indigo snake occurs in a wide variety of terrestrial habitat types throughout Florida. Although they have a preference for uplands, they also utilize some wetlands and agricultural areas. Eastern indigo snakes will often seek shelter inside gopher tortoise burrows and other below- and above -ground refugia, such as other animal burrows, stumps, roots, and debris piles. Females may lay from 4 - 12 white eggs as early as April through June, with young hatching in late July through October. PROTECTION UNDER FEDERAL AND STATE LAW: The eastern indigo snake is classified as a Threatened species by both the USFWS and the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission. "Taking" of eastern indigo snakes is prohibited by the Endangered Species Act without a permit. "Take" is defined by the USFWS as an attempt to kill, harm, harass, pursue, hunt, shoot, wound, trap, capture, collect, or engage in any such conduct. Penalties include a maximum fine of $25,000 for civil violations and up to $50,000 and/or imprisonment for criminal offenses, if convicted. Only individuals currently authorized through an issued Incidental Take Statement in association with a USFWS Biological Opinion, or by a Section 10(a)(1)(A) permit issued by the USFWS, to handle an eastern indigo snake are allowed to do so. IF YOU SEE A LIVE EASTERN INDIGO SNAKE ON THE SITE: • Cease clearing activities and allow the live eastern indigo snake sufficient time to move away from the site without interference; • Personnel must NOT attempt to touch or handle snake due to protected status. • Take photographs of the snake, if possible, for identification and documentation purposes. • Immediately notify supervisor or the applicant's designated agent, and the appropriate USFWS office, with the location information and condition of the snake. • If the snake is located in a vicinity where continuation of the clearing or construction activities will cause harm to the snake, the activities must halt until such time that a representative of the USFWS returns the call (within one day) with further guidance as to when activities may resume. IF YOU SEE A DEAD EASTERN INDIGO SNAKE ON THE SITE: • Cease clearing activities and immediately notify supervisor or the applicant's designated agent, and the appropriate USFWS office, with the location information and condition of the snake. • Take photographs of the snake, if possible, for identification and documentation purposes. • Thoroughly soak the dead snake in water and then freeze the specimen. The appropriate wildlife agency will retrieve the dead snake. Telephone numbers of USFWS Florida Field Offices to be contacted if a live or dead eastern indigo snake is encountered: North Florida Field Office — (904) 731-3336 Panama City Field Office — (850) 769-0552 South Florida Field Office — (772) 562-3909 PA PRE -CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES 1. The applicant or designated agent will post educational posters in the construction office and throughout the construction site, including any access roads. The posters must be clearly visible to all construction staff. A sample poster is attached. 2. Prior to the onset of construction activities, the applicant/designated agent will conduct a meeting with all construction staff (annually for multi -year projects) to discuss identification of the snake, its protected status, what to do if a snake is observed within the project area, and applicable penalties that may be imposed if state and/or federal regulations are violated. An educational brochure including color photographs of the snake will be given to each staff member in attendance and additional copies will be provided to the construction superintendent to make available in the onsite construction office (a final brochure for Plan compliance, to be printed double -sided on 8.5" x 11" paper and then properly folded, is attached). Photos of eastern indigo snakes may be accessed on USFWS and/or FWC websites. 3. Construction staff will be informed that in the event that an eastern indigo snake (live or dead) is observed on the project site during construction activities, all such activities are to cease until the established procedures are implemented according to the Plan, which includes notification of the appropriate USFWS Field Office. The contact information for the USFWS is provided on the referenced posters and brochures. DURING CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES 1. During initial site clearing activities, an onsite observer may be utilized to determine whether habitat conditions suggest a reasonable probability of an eastern indigo snake sighting (example: discovery of snake sheds, tracks, lots of refugia and cavities present in the area of clearing activities, and presence of gopher tortoises and burrows). 2. If an eastern indigo snake is discovered during gopher tortoise relocation activities (i.e. burrow excavation), the USFWS shall be contacted within one business day to obtain further guidance which may result in further project consultation. 3. Periodically during construction activities, the applicant's designated agent should visit the project area to observe the condition of the posters and Plan materials, and replace them as needed. Construction personnel should be reminded of the instructions (above) as to what is expected if any eastern indigo snakes are seen. POST CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES Whether or not eastern indigo snakes are observed during construction activities, a monitoring report should be submitted to the appropriate USFWS Field Office within 60 days of project completion. The report can be sent electronically to the appropriate USFWS e-mail address listed on page one of this Plan. Appendix E Section 106 Review %40TRILEAF ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING 1051 Winderley Place, Suite 201, Maitland, Florida 32751 - 407.660.7840 - www.trileaf.com April 13, 2018 Florida Division of Historical Resources Dr. Timothy A. Parsons - Director and SHPO 500 South Bronough Street Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0250 RE: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC — Naples Park North, FL / Client #FL114 — Trileaf Project #637639 Benton Road, Naples, Florida 34117 Collier County, Belle Meade NE Quadrangle (USGS) Latitude: 26' 10' 44.98" N, Longitude: 81 ° 34' 17.21" W Dr. Parsons: Trileaf Corporation is in the process of completing a NEPA review at the referenced property. Our client proposes to construct a raw land -new build 220-foot dyed communications tower. The proposed tower will be located within a 3,600-square-foot lease area. The project includes an access/utility easement, measuring approximately 20 feet wide, which extends approximately 100 feet west away from the lease area to connect with Benton Road. hi addition, the proposed tower will be supported by three (3) guy anchors that extend approximately 122 feet northwest, east, and southwest from the tower center. Currently, the site habitat consists of a grass and tree -covered area. The antenna will be licensed by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC). In accordance with the Nationwide Programmatic Agreement for Review of Effects on Historic Properties for Certain Undertakings Approved by the Federal Communications Commission, dated September 2004, a cultural resource investigation has been conducted. Our investigation includes determining if the site is contained in, on, or within the view shed of a building, site, district, structure or object, significant in American history, architecture, archeology, engineering or culture, that is listed, or eligible for listing on the State or National Registers of Historic Places, or located in or on an Indian Religious Site. Summary reports of this investigation, maps, photographs and other information are provided in the attached Form 620. As noted in Attachment 5, there are No Historic Properties Present within the APE for Direct and Visual Effects. Therefore, it is recommended that the proposed undertaking proceed without further archaeological review. We appreciate your co-operation in this regard and anticipate your concurrence with these findings. Please call me at (407) 660-7840 or email j.reagan@trileaf.com if you need additional information or have any questions. Thank you for your assistance in this regard. Sincerely, Jackson Reagan Natural Resource Specialist FCC Form 620 FCC Wireless Telecommunications Bureau Notification Date: 7AM EST 04/16/2018 New Tower ("NT") Submission Packet File Number: 0008172792 General Information 1) (Select only one) ( NE ) NE — New UA — Update of Application WD — Withdrawal of Application 2) If this application is for an Update or Withdrawal, enter the file number of the pending application File Number: currently on file. IcanT InTOrmation 3) FCC Registration Number (FRN): 0019066661 4) Name: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Contact Name Approved by OMB 3060 — 1039 See instructions for public burden estimates 5) First Name: Scott 6) MI: 7) Last Name: Von Rein 8) Suffix: 9) Title: Contact Information 10) P.O. Box: AOnd 11) Street Address: 1500 Mt. Kemble, Suite 203 12) City: Morristown 13) State: NJ 14) Zip Code: 07960 15) Telephone Number: (973)425-0606 16) Fax Number: (973)425-1616 17) E-mail Address: svonrein@capitaltelecom.com Consultant Information 18) FCC Registration Number (FRN): 0011724176 19) Name: Trileaf Corporation Principal Investigator 20) First Name: Cori 21) MI: 22) Last Name: Rich 23) Suffix: 24) Title: Principal Investigator Principal Investiaator Contact Information 25) P.O. Box: AOnd 26) Street Address: 1205 Johnson Ferry Road Suite 136 27) City: Marietta 28) State: GA 29) Zip Code: 30068 30) Telephone Number: (314)997-6111 31)Nmber: 32) E-mail Address: j.reagan@trileaf.com 1 of 13 FCC Form 620 May 2014 Professional Qualification 33) Does the Principal Investigator satisfy the Secretary of the Interior's Professional Qualification Standards? I (X )Yes ( ) No 34) Areas of Professional Qualification: ( X ) Archaeologist ( ) Architectural Historian ( X ) Historian ( ) Architect ( ) Other (Specify) Additional Staff 35) Are there other staff involved who meet the Professional Qualification Standards of the Secretary of the Interior? ( X ) Yes ( ) No If "YES," complete the following: 36) First Name: Zach 1 37) MI: 1 38) Last Name: Horne 139) Suffix: 40) Title: Archaeologist 41) Areas of Professional Qualification: ( X ) Archaeologist ( ) Architectural Historian ( X ) Historian ( ) Architect ( ) Other (Specify) 2 of 13 FCC Form 620 May 2014 Site Information ower Construction Notification System 1) TCNS Notification Number: 169882 Site Information 2) Positive Train Control Filing Subject to Expedited Treatment Under Program Comment: ( ) Yes ( X ) No 3) Site Name: Naples Park North, FL 4) Site Address: Benton Road 5) Detailed Description of Project: Legal Description: S25 T49S R27E 6) City: Naples 7) State: FL 8) Zip Code: 34117 9) County/Borough/Parish: COLLIER 10) Nearest Crossroads: Benton Road & 28th Avenue SE 11) NAD 83 Latitude (DD-MM-SS.S): 26-10-45.0 ( X )Nor ( ) S 12) NAD 83 Longitude (DD-MM-SS.S): 081-34-17.2 ( ) E or ( X ) W Tower Information 13) Tower height above ground level (include top -mounted attachments such as lightning rods): 67.1 14) Tower Type (Select One): ( X ) Guyed lattice tower ( ) Self-supporting lattice ( ) Monopole ( ) Other (Describe): -roject atazus 15) Current Project Status (Select One): ( X ) Construction has not yet commenced ( ) Construction has commenced, but is not completed Construction commenced on: ( ) Construction has been completed Construction commenced on: Construction completed on: ( ) Feet ( X ) Meters 3 of 13 FCC Form 620 May 2014 Determination of Effect 14) Direct Effects (Select One): ( X ) No Historic Properties in Area of Potential Effects (APE) ( ) No Effect on Historic Properties in APE ( ) No Adverse Effect on Historic Properties in APE ( ) Adverse Effect on one or more Historic Properties in APE 15) Visual Effects (Select One): ( X ) No Historic Properties in Area of Potential Effects (APE) ( ) No Effect on Historic Properties in APE ( ) No Adverse Effect on Historic Properties in APE ( ) Adverse Effect on one or more Historic Properties in APE 4 of 13 FCC Form 620 May 2014 Tribal/NHO Involvement 1) Have Indian Tribes or Native Hawaiian Organizations (NHOs) been identified that may attach religious and cultural significance to historic properties which may be affected by the undertaking within the APEs for direct and visual ( X ) Yes ( ) No effects? 2a) Tribes/NHOs contacted through TCNS Notification Number: 169882 Number of Tribes/NHOs: 6 2b) Tribes/NHOs contacted through an alternate system: Number of Tribes/NHOs: 0 I I VCIII"%J VVI I IGIiICU I I I I VUy111VIYJ 3) Tribe/NHO FRN: 4) Tribe/NHO Name: Eastern Shawnee Tribe of Oklahoma Contact Name 5) First Name: Travis 6) MI: 7) Last Name: Patton 8) Suffix: 9) Title: TCNS Coordinator uates aI Kesponse 10) Date Contacted 03/29/2018 11) Date Replied 04/02/2018 ( ) No Reply ( ) Replied/No Interest ( ) Replied/Have Interest ( X ) Replied/Other 111JC/IV f7V VVI IIQI:ICU I I I I VUU II Il�1YJ 3) Tribe/NHO FRN: 4) Tribe/NHO Name: Miccosukee Tribe of Indians of Florida Contact Name 5) First Name: Fred 6) MI: 7) Last Name: Dayhoff 8) Suffix: 9) Title: NAGPRA & Section 106 Representative uates & Kesponse 10) Date Contacted 03/29/2018 11) Date Replied ( X ) No Reply ( ) Replied/No Interest ( ) Replied/Have Interest ( ) Replied/Other 5 of 13 FCC Form 620 May 2014 Tribal/NHO Involvement 1) Have Indian Tribes or Native Hawaiian Organizations (NHOs) been identified that may attach religious and cultural significance to historic properties which may be affected by the undertaking within the APEs for direct and visual ( X ) Yes ( ) No effects? 2a) Tribes/NHOs contacted through TCNS Notification Number: 169882 Number of Tribes/NHOs: 6 2b) Tribes/NHOs contacted through an alternate system: Number of Tribes/NHOs: 0 I I VCIII"%J VVI I IGIiICU I I I I VUUII IVIN%J 3) Tribe/NHO FRN: 4) Tribe/NHO Name: Muscogee (Creek) Nation Contact Name 5) First Name: Anne 6) MI: 7) Last Name: Edwards -Martel 8) Suffix: Ms 9) Title: TCNS Coordinator uates & Kesponse 10) Date Contacted 03/29/2018 11) Date Replied ( X ) No Reply ( ) Replied/No Interest ( ) Replied/Have Interest ( ) Replied/Other 111JC/IV f7V VVI IIQI:ICU I I I I VUU II 1%,1111J 3) Tribe/NHO FRN: 4) Tribe/NHO Name: Seminole Nation of Oklahoma Contact Name 5) First Name: Theodore 6) MI: 7) Last Name: Isham 8) Suffix: 9) Title: Historic Preservation Officer uates & rtesponse 10) Date Contacted 03/28/2018 11) Date Replied 04/04/2018 ( ) No Reply ( ) Replied/No Interest ( ) Replied/Have Interest ( X ) Replied/Other 6 of 13 FCC Form 620 May 2014 Tribal/NHO Involvement 1) Have Indian Tribes or Native Hawaiian Organizations (NHOs) been identified that may attach religious and cultural significance to historic properties which may be affected by the undertaking within the APEs for direct and visual ( X ) Yes ( ) No effects? 2a) Tribes/NHOs contacted through TCNS Notification Number: 169882 Number of Tribes/NHOs: 6 2b) Tribes/NHOs contacted through an alternate system: Number of Tribes/NHOs: 0 I I VCIII"%J VVI I IGIiICU I I I I VUy111VIYJ 3) Tribe/NHO FRN: 4) Tribe/NHO Name: Seminole Tribe of Florida Contact Name 5) First Name: Bradley 6) MI: M 7) Last Name: Mueller 8) Suffix: 9) Title: Compliance Review Supervisor uates aI Kesponse 10) Date Contacted 03/28/2018 11) Date Replied 03/28/2018 ( ) No Reply ( ) Replied/No Interest ( ) Replied/Have Interest ( X ) Replied/Other 111JC/IV f7V VVI IIQI:ICU I I I I VUU II Il�1YJ 3) Tribe/NHO FRN: 4) Tribe/NHO Name: Thlopthlocco Tribal Town Contact Name 5) First Name: Terry 6) MI: 7) Last Name: Clouthier 8) Suffix: 9) Title: THPO uates & rtesponse 10) Date Contacted 03/28/2018 11) Date Replied ( X ) No Reply ( ) Replied/No Interest ( ) Replied/Have Interest ( ) Replied/Other 7 of 13 FCC Form 620 May 2014 Other Tribes/NHOs Contacted Tribe/N HO Information 1) FCC Registration Number (FRN): 2) Name: Contact Name 3) First Name: 4) MI: 5) Last Name: 6) Suffix: 7) Title: Contact Information 8) P.O. Box: /AOnd 9) Street Address: 10) City: 11) State: 12) Zip Code: 13) Telephone Number: 14) Fax Number: 15) E-mail Address: 16) Preferred means of communication: ( ) E-mail ( ) Letter ( ) Both uaies & Kesponse 17) Date Contacted 18) Date Replied ( ) No Reply ( ) Replied/No Interest ( ) Replied/Have Interest ( ) Replied/Other 8 of 13 FCC Form 620 May 2014 Historic Properties Properties Identified 1) Have any historic properties been identified within the APEs for direct and visual effect? ( )yes ( X ) No 2) Has the identification process located archaeological materials that would be directly affected, or sites that are of ( )Yes (X ) No cultural or religious significance to Tribes/NHOs? 3) Are there more than 10 historic properties within the APES for direct and visual effect? "Yes", ( )Yes (X ) No If you are required to attach a Cultural Resources Report in lieu of adding the Historic Property below. listoric Property 4) Property Name: 5) SHPO Site Number: Property Address 6) Street Address: 7) City: 8) State: 9) Zip Code: 10) County/Borough/Parish: Status & Eliaibility 11) Is this property listed on the National Register? Source: ( ) Yes ( ) No 12) Is this property eligible for listing on the National Register? Source: ( ) Yes ( ) No 13) Is this property a National Historic Landmark? ( ) Yes ( ) No 14) Direct Effects (Select One): ( ) No Effect on this Historic Property in APE ( ) No Adverse Effect on this Historic Property in APE ( ) Adverse Effect on this Historic Property in APE 15) Visual Effects (Select One): ( ) No Effect on this Historic Property in APE ( ) No Adverse Effect on this Historic Property in APE ( ) Adverse Effect on this Historic Property in APE 9 of 13 FCC Form 620 May 2014 Local Government Involvement .ocai uovernment Agency 1) FCC Registration Number (FRN): 2) Name: City of Naples Planning Department Contact Name 3) First Name: To Whom 4) MI: 5) Last Name: It May Concern 6) Suffix: 7) Title: Contact Information 8) P.O. Box: AOnd 9) Street Address: 295 Riverside Circle 10) City: Naples 11) State: FL 12) Zip Code: 34102 13) Telephone Number: (239)213-1050 14) Fax Number: 15) E-mail Address: 16) Preferred means of communication: ( ) E-mail ( X ) Letter ( ) Both fates & 17) Date Contacted 03/27/2018 18) Date Replied ( X ) No Reply ( ) Replied/No Interest ( ) Replied/Have Interest ( ) Replied/Other Additional Information 19) Information on local government's role or interest (optional): 10 of 13 FCC Form 620 May 2014 Other Consulting Parties utner Consuning Parties Contacted 1) Has any other agency been contacted and invited to become a consulting party? (X ) Yes ( ) No Consulting Party 2) FCC Registration Number (FRN): 3) Name: Naples Historical Society Contact Name 4) First Name: To Whom 5) MI: 6) Last Name: It May Concern 7) Suffix: 8) Title: Contact Information 9) P.O. Box: 201 AAnd d 10) Street Address: 137 12th Avenue South 11) City: Naples 12) State: FL 13) Zip Code: 34102 14) Telephone Number: (239)261-8164 15) Fax Number: 16) E-mail Address: NHS@NaplesHistoricalSociety.org 17) Preferred means of communication: ( ) E-mail ( ) Letter ( X ) Both fates & rtesponse 18) Date Contacted 03/27/2018 19) Date Replied ( X ) No Reply ( ) Replied/No Interest ( ) Replied/Have Interest ( ) Replied/Other Additional Information 20) Information on other consulting parties' role or interest (optional): 11 of 13 FCC Form 620 May 2014 Designation of SHPO/THPO 1) Designate the Lead State Historic Preservation Officer (SHPO) or Tribal Historic Preservation Officer (THPO) based on the location of the tower. SHPO/THPO Name: Florida Division of Historical Resources 2) You may also designate up to three additional SHPOs/THPOs if the APEs include multiple states. If the APEs include other countries, enter the name of the National Historic Preservation Agency and any state and provincial Historic Preservation Agency. F9:11.7rraYU►F NMI SHPO/THPO Name: SHPO/THPO Name: Certification I certify that all representations on this FCC Form 620 Submission Packet and the accompanying attachments are true, correct, and complete. Party Authorized to Sign First Name: Jackson MI: K Last Name: Reagan Suffix: Signature: Jackson K Reagan Date: 04/13/2018 FAILURE TO SIGN THIS APPLICATION MAY RESULT IN DISMISSAL OF THE APPLICATION AND FORFEITURE OF ANY FEES PAID. WILLFUL FALSE STATEMENTS MADE ON THIS FORM OR ANY ATTACHMENTS ARE PUNISHABLE BY FINE AND/OR IMPRISONMENT (U.S. Code, Title 18, Section 1001) AND/OR REVOCATION OF ANY STATION LICENSE OR CONSTRUCTION PERMIT (U.S. Code, Title 47, Section 312(a)(1)), AND/OR FORFEITURE (U.S. Code, Title 47, Section 503). 12 of 13 FCC Form 620 May 2014 Attachments : Type Resumes/Vitae Photographs Map Documents Additional Site Information Area of Potential Effects Tribal/NHO Involvement Historic Properties for Direct Effects Historic Properties for Visual Effects Local Government Involvement Public Involvement State -Specific Forms Description Date Entered Resumes 04/13/2018 Photos 04/13/2018 Map Documents 04/13/2018 Additional Info 04/13/2018 Area of Potential Effects 04/13/2018 Tribal/NHO Involvement 04/13/2018 Direct Effects 04/13/2018 Visual Effects 04/13/2018 Local Government Involvement 04/13/2018 Public Involvement 04/13/2018 SHPO Form 04/13/2018 13 of 13 FCC Form 620 May 2014 NT SUBMISSION PACKET— FCC FORM 620 Approved by OMB 3060-1039 See instructions for Public burden estimates Attachment 1. Consultant Information Provide a current copy of the resume or curriculum vitae for the Principal Investigator and any researcher or other person who contributed to, reviewed, or provided significant input into the research, analysis, writing or conclusions presented in this filing. A current copy of the resume for the Principal Investigator and any researcher or other person who contributed to, reviewed, or provided significant input into the research, analysis, writing or conclusions presented in this filing. Applicant's Name: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Project Number: 637639 FCC Form 620 %40 TRILEAF PROFESSIONAL RESUME Education M.S. Historical Archaeology Illinois State University / Normal, IL B.A. Anthropology Adams State University / Alamosa, CO Areas of ExpertisM Ms. Rich is a Secretary of the Interior (SOI) qualified archaeologist and is a member of the Register of Professional Archaeologists (RPA). Ms. Rich specializes in managing and performing Phase I, II, and III historical and prehistoric archaeological investigation review and assessment. Ms. Rich has interest and experience in cultural resource management interpretation and implementation, and has a background in archaeology preservation, providing critical experience and knowledge in archaeological preservation considerations. Ms. Rich has extensive experience in both field and laboratory settings. Ms. Rich's field experience includes performing, under Section 106, background research, historical research, archaeological field survey, testing, and data recovery efforts, and report writing for sites throughout the Midwest. Ms. Rich's laboratory experience includes training and managing groups of veterans as they curated federally -owned archaeological and archival collections, with the goal of boosting basic transferable employment skills, applicable to the civilian workforce, as well as managing and processing artifact and archival collections per National Historic Preservation Act regulations. Ms. Rich also has experience communicating scientific research in professional environments, universitv classrooms, and at national conferences. LSelected Professional Employment and Positions Senior Project Archaeologist, TriLeaf Corporation, St. Louis, Missouri, January 2017-present Supporting Archivist, Defense POW/MIA Accounting Agency (DPAA) VCP Laboratory, St. Louis, Missouri, October 2016-January 2017 Laboratory Manager, Veterans Curation Program, St. Louis, Missouri, January 2015-January 2017 Adjunct Instructor, Lindenwood University, St. Charles, Missouri, August 2014-January 2017 Archaeology Field/Lab Technician, Archaeological Research Center, St. Louis, Missouri, June 2014- December 2014 Research Assistant, Illinois State University, Normal, Illinois, August 2012-May 2014 Hey Girl, I See You: Identifying Women Within Household Assemblages - Society for Historical Archaeology Conference, Fort Worth, Texas, January 2017 Putting Archaeology to Work in a Me Generation - Three Rivers Archaeology Meeting, St. Louis, April 2016 Historical Archaeology at Work: Rehabilitation Our Past and Present to Secure Our Future - Society for Historic Archaeology Conference, Washington, D.C, January 2016 Identifying the visible: A Look at How Economic Class and Ethnicity Influence Women's Visibility within a Household - Society for Historic Archaeology Conference, Seattle, Washington, January 2015 Small Things Remembered: A Look at Identity in the Nolichucky Valley Through Beads and other Small Items - Cherokee, North Carolina, August 2013 Register of Professional Archaeologists (RPA), member since 2014 Society for Historical Archaeology, member since 2011 Conducted public outreach and presented archaeological findings to Cherokee Tribal Elders and community members in Cherokee, North Carolina Participated in identifying and documenting historic petroglyphs as part of a public outreach project in Stone Mountain, Georgia Professional interests include Public Outreach, Public Archaeology, Preservation, Curation, Archives, Cultural Heritage, Historical Research, Museum Collections, and Museum Exhibit Construction. \I/TRILEAF PROFESSIONAL RESUME Education M AM M.A. Anthropology Georgia State University / Atlanta, GA B.S. Anthropology Kennesaw State University / Kennesaw, GA Areas of Expertis Mr. Horne is a Secretary of the Interior (SOI) qualified archaeologist and is a member of the Register of Professional Archaeologists (RPA). Mr. Horne specializes in managing and performing Phase I, II, and III historical and prehistoric archaeological investigation review and assessment. Mr. Horne has interest and experience in conducting archaeological, environmental, and historical research for site assessments for the Section 106 Review process. Mr. Horne has a background in prehistoric North and Central American archaeology with an emphasis on prehistoric ceramic and lithic artifact analysis and preservation in the Mid -Atlantic, Midwest, and Southeast regions of the United States. Mr. Horne has extensive experience in both field and laboratory settings. Mr. Horne's field experience includes performing, under Section 106, background research, historical research, archaeological field survey, testing, and data recovery efforts, and report writing for sites throughout the Mid -Atlantic, Midwest, and Southeast in 21 states. Mr. Horne's laboratory experience includes managing undergraduate student artifact analysis and interpretation in a university setting, as well as the analysis and processing of artifact collections for the US Forest Service and the Ceramoteca del Centro INAH, Yucatan, Mexico. Mr. Horne has experience performing site inspections and conducting environmental due diligence pursuant to EPA All Appropriate Inquiries (AAI) and the American Society of Testing and Materials (ASTM). Environmental service expertise includes the preparation and/or review of: Phase I Environmental Site Assessments National Wetlands Inventory Maps Field Reconnaissance Historical Topographic Maps and Aerial Imagery Land Use History Flood Insurance Rate Maps NEPA Environmental Assessments Form 620/621 Submittals Critical Habitat Maps Soil Characterization Archaeological and Architectural Impacts Local Government Consultation Additio ation and Professional Memberships Register of Professional Archaeologists (RPA), member since 2014 Society for Georgia Archaeology, member since 2014 Professional interests include Public Outreach, Public Archaeology, Preservation, Curation, Archives, Cultural Heritage, and Historical Research %40TRILEAF" PROFESSIONAL RESUME Educatioi B.S. in Biology University of Central Florida / Orlando, FL Mr. Reagan has experience performing site inspections and conducting environmental due diligence pursuant to EPA All Appropriate Inquiries (AAI) and the American Society of Testing and Materials (ASTM) and performing National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) reviews for wireless telecommunications projects. Environmental service expertise includes the preparation and/or review of: Phase I Environmental Site Assessments Historical City Directories Environmental Evaluation Summaries Informal Section 7 Consultation National Wetlands Inventory Maps Flood Insurance Rate Maps Critical Habitat Maps Migratory Bird Evaluations Soil Characterization ANSI/FCC RF Radiation Safety Competent Person Field Reconnaissance Historical Topographic Maps and Aerial Imagery Land Use History Section 106 Compliance NEPA Environmental Assessments Form 620/621 Submittals Local Government Consultation Native American Consultation NT SUBMISSION PACKET — FCC FORM 620 Approved by OMB 3060-1039 See instructions for Public burden estimates Attachment 2. Site Information — Photographs You are required to provide photographs and maps as part of this filing. Additional site information can be provided in an optional attachment. Photograph Requirements: Except in cases where no Historic Properties were identified within the Areas of Potential Effects, submit photographs as described below. Photographs should be in color, marked so as to identify the project, keyed to the relevant map or text, and dated; the focal length of the lens and the height of the camera should be noted. The source of any photograph included but not taken by the Applicant or its consultant (including copies of historic images) should be identified on the photograph. a. Photographs taken from the site should show views from the proposed location in all directions. The direction (e.g., north, south, etc.) should be indicated on each photograph, and, as a group, the photographs should present a complete (360 degree) view of the area around the proposed site. Please see attached Photographs, which were taken by Zach Horne of Trileaf Corporation on April 4, 2018, unless otherwise noted. b. Photographs of all listed in and eligible properties within the Areas of Potential Effects. N/A c. If any listed or eligible properties are visible from the proposed site, photographs looking at the site from each historic property. The approximate distance in feet (meters) between the site and the historic property should be included. If any listed or eligible properties are within the APE, photos looking at each historic property should be included. N/A Aerial photograph of the site was obtained by using Google Earth, imagery is dated 2017. Applicant's Name: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Project Number: 637639 FCC Form 620 Site Photograph 1— Looking north at the Site. Site Photograph 2 — Looking east at the Site. Site Photographs Photographed: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC - Naples Park North, FL Benton Road April 4, 2018 Naples, Florida 34117 Site Photograph 3 — Looking south at the Site. Site Photograph 4 — Looking west at the Site. Site Photographs Photographed: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC - Naples Park North, FL Benton Road April 4, 2018 Naples, Florida 34117 Site Photograph 5 — Looking north away from the Site. Site Photograph 6 — Looking east away from the Site. Site Photographs Photographed: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC - Naples Park North, FL Benton Road April 4, 2018 Naples, Florida 34117 Site Photograph 7 — Looking south away from the Site. Site Photograph 8 — Looking west away from the Site. Site Photographs Photographed: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC - Naples Park North, FL Benton Road April 4, 2018 Naples, Florida 34117 Site Photograph 9 — Looking east along the access and utility easement. Site Photograph 10 — Looking west along the access and utility easement. Site Photographs Photographed: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC - Naples Park North, FL Benton Road April 4, 2018 Naples, Florida 34117 Site Photograph 11— Proposed guyed wire easement looking northeast. Site Photograph 12 — Proposed guyed wire easement looking southeast. Site Photographs Photographed: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC - Naples Park North, FL Benton Road April 4, 2018 Naples, Florida 34117 Site Photograph 13 — Proposed guyed wire easement looking east. Site Photographs Photographed: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC - Naples Park North, FL Benton Road April 4, 2018 Naples, Florida 34117 Site Photograph 14 — Shovel Test Pit 1. Site Photograph 15 — Shovel Test Pit 1 profile. Site Photographs Photographed: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC - Naples Park North, FL Benton Road April 4, 2018 Naples, Florida 34117 Belle Meade NE Quadrangle, Florida (2015) Contour Interval = 5 Feet Scale 1 Inch = —2,000 Feet Latitude: 26' 10' 44.98" N Longitude: 81' 34' 17.21" W Township: T49S Range: R27E Section: S25 %-Mile APE for Visual Effects Site Location i North 2017 Google Earth Aerial — Location Map Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Naple Park North, FL 40 TRILEAF Benton Road ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING Naples, Florida 34117 Location of proposed cell tower site on modern Google Earth Map (2017). NT SUBMISSION PACKET — FCC FORM 620 Approved by OMB 3060-1039 See instructions for Public burden estimates Attachment 3. Site Information — Map Requirements Include one or more 7.5-minute quad USGS topographical maps that: a. Identify the Areas of Potential Effects for both Direct and Visual Effects. If a map is copied from the original, include a key with the name of quad and date. b. Show the location of the proposed site and any access roads or other easements including excavations. c. Show the locations of each property listed. d. Include keys for any symbols, colors, or other identifiers. e. Submit color maps whenever possible. The following map has been attached to this report: Topographic Maps % -Mile Area of Potential Effect Map Applicant's Name: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Project Number: 637639 FCC Form 620 Belle Meade NE Quadrangle, Florida (2015) Contour Interval = 5 Feet Scale 1 Inch = -2,000 Feet 0 Latitude: 26' 10' 44.98" N Longitude: 81' 34' 17.21" W Township: T49S Range: R27E Section: S25 North � I TSB I Q w• _ t I ` . co 1t t 7 O ` •I I LIb o i • Site Location e 13 @O ` II v � 9 • ' y,, " D O 13 4 I'�� 1 • 0 O OQp o m .ry D O O Y o• 1 V Ly 0 D P a e • p O Al - 4-- 0• l • v I — o .• q •A a �. ^� e O p Site Vicinity Map Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC - Naples Park North, FL 40 TRILEAF Benton Road ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING Naples, FL 34117 General location of proposed cell tower installation. Belle Meade NE Quadrangle, Florida (1958, p.r. 1973) Contour Interval = 5 Feet Scale 1 Inch = —2,000 Feet Latitude: 26° 10' 44.98" N Longitude: 81° 34' 17.21" W Township: T49S Range: R27E Section: S25 North _ - - %-Mile APE for Visual - •_ - - = '_ "_ - Effects - _'- .� r - _ _ •v --L - - �- Site Location _- - - 7. Site Vicinity Map Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC- Naples Park North, FL 40 TRILEAF Benton Road ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING Naples, FL 34117 Historic topographic map with proposed tower location and'/4-mile APE for visual effects. NT SUBMISSION PACKET— FCC FORM 620 Approved by OMB 3060-1039 See instructions for Public burden estimates Attachment 4. Site Information — Additional Site Information Describe any additional structures, access roads, utility lines, fences, easements, or other construction planned for the site. Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC proposes the construction of a new guyed tower with a total height of 220 feet (67.1 meters). The new tower and associated equipment will be located in a proposed approximate 60-foot by 60-foot (18.3-meter by 18.3-meter) cell tower lease area. A proposed approximate 20-foot by 100-foot (6.1-meter by 30.5-meter) access and utility easement will connect the proposed lease area to Benton Road to the west. Additionally, the tower will be supported by three (3) guy anchors extending approximately 122 feet (37.2 meters) from the tower center. The new tower will occupy 0.13 acres (0.05 hectares) of land. The construction drawings provided by Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC are included in this attachment. Applicant's Name: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Project Number: 637639 FCC Form 620 Please refer to Appendix A for Site Plans NT SUBMISSION PACKET— FCC FORM 620 Approved by OMB 3060-1039 See instructions for Public burden estimates Attachment S. Area of Potential Effects You are required to provide two attachments regarding the Determination of Effect: Areas of Potential Effect and Mitigation of Effect (if applicable). Areas of Potential Effect Guidelines: a. Describe the APE for direct effects and explain how this APE was determined. Total acreage of the project area is approximately 0.13 acres. As defined by the NPA, "the APE for direct effects is limited to the area of potential ground disturbance and any property, or any portion thereof that will be physically altered or destroyed by the Undertaking." The APE for direct effects is essentially the archaeological portion of the survey, which is the footprint of the construction activity. b. Describe the APE for visual effects and explain how this APE was determined. The APE for visual effects is the geographic area in which the Project has the potential to introduce visual elements that diminish or alter the setting, including the landscape, where the setting is a character -defining feature of a historic property that makes it eligible for listing on the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP). The presumed APE for visual effects for construction of new facilities is the area from which the tower will be visible. Due to the height of the proposed undertaking (220 feet), the presumed APE for visual effects for this project is a % -mile radius from the tower site. Applicant's Name: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Project Number: 637639 FCC Form 620 NT SUBMISSION PACKET— FCC FORM 620 Approved by OMB 3060-1039 See instructions for Public burden estimates Attachment 5. Continued Mitigation of Effect Guidelines: In the case of where an Adverse Visual Effect or Adverse Direct Effect has been determined you must provide the following: a. Copies of any correspondence and summaries of any oral communication with the SHPO/THPO and any consulting parties. N/A b. Describe any alternatives that have been considered that might avoid, minimize, or mitigate any adverse effects. Explain the Applicant's conclusion regarding the feasibility of each alternative. N/A For each property identified as a Historic Property in the online a-106 form: a. Indicate whether the Applicant believes the proposed undertaking would have a) no effect; b) no adverse effect; or, c) an adverse effect. Explain how each such assessment was made. Provide supporting documentation where necessary. There were no recorded Florida Division of Historical Resources, Florida Master Site File Inventory, NRHP or determined eligible resources located within the % -mile APE for visual effects within the project area or its study radius. Supporting documentation and justification for this finding is contained within the attachment. No archeological artifacts were encountered during the field survey. No further archaeological work is recommended. A finding of no historic properties, regarding both direct and visual effects, is recommended. No additional cultural resources work is deemed necessary. Please see the attached cultural resource assessment. Applicant's Name: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Project Number: 637639 FCC Form 620 Cultural Resource Survey Naples Park North, FL Trileaf # 637639 Benton Road Naples, FL 34117 April 10, 2018 Prepared For: Prepared By: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC 1500 Mt. Kemble, Suite 203 % / TRILEAF Morristown, New Jersey 07960 ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING CULTURAL RESOURCE SURVEY PROPOSED CELL TOWER SITE Trileaf # 637639 / "Naples Park North, FL" Naples, FL PREPARED AND WRITTEN BY: Trileaf Corporation 1205 Johnson Ferry Road Suite 136 Marietta, GA 30068 Zach Horne, M.A., RPA Project Archaeologist 314-997-6111 z.horne@trileaf.com Lead Agency: FCC Trileaf Job No. 637639 April 10, 2018 The opinions, findings, and conclusions expressed in this document are those of Trileaf Corporation. ABSTRACT AND MANAGEMENT SUMMARY In April 2018, Trileaf Corporation (Trileaf) performed a cultural resource inventory survey for a proposed raw land guyed tower site located at Benton Road, Naples, Collier County, Florida (Section S25, T49S, R27E). The proposed project is located within a grass and tree covered area. Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC proposes the construction of a new guyed tower with a total height of 220 feet (67.1 meters). The new tower and associated equipment will be located in a proposed approximate 60-foot by 60-foot (18.3-meter by 18.3-meter) cell tower lease area. A proposed approximate 20-foot by 100-foot (6.1-meter by 30.5-meter) access and utility easement will connect the proposed lease area to Benton Road to the west. Additionally, the tower will be supported by three (3) guy anchors extending approximately 122 feet (37.2 meters) from the tower center. The new tower will occupy 0.13 acres (0.05 hectares) of land. Under the direction of Trileaf, Project Archaeologist Zach Horne, MA, RPA performed this survey in response to the planned use of the above -described parcel and the potential impacts that such use might represent to archaeological and architectural cultural resources. The Phase I cultural resource survey was designed to discover all prehistoric and historical period cultural resources that might be present within the project area. The field survey of the project area, which included a pedestrian survey, shovel testing, and visual inspection, found no evidence for the presence of archaeological or architectural properties in relation to the current project area or within a 30-foot (9.1-meter) boundary within the Direct APE. Further, there were no NRHP-listed or eligible properties that have been previously identified within the 3/4-mile direct or visual APE. Based on these findings, Trileaf recommends No Historic Properties in both the direct and visual APE. It is therefore recommended that project clearance be granted with no further investigation or evaluation of the project area relative to those resources. TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract and Management Summary.................................................................... Listof Figures....................................................................................................... Listof Tables....................................................................................................... 1.0 Introduction................................................................................................ 1.1 Area of Potential Effect................................................................. 1.2 Site Plans and Photographs......................................................... 2.0 Project Setting.......................................................................................... 2.1 Soils.............................................................................................. 2.2 Elevations...................................................................................... 2.3 Cultural Setting...................................................................................... 3.0 Research.................................................................................................... 3.1 Background Research..................................................................... 3.2 Research Design........................................................................... 4.0 Field Methods and Results........................................................................ 4.1 Archaeological Survey.................................................................... 4.2 Architectural Survey..................................................................... 5.0 Conclusions and Recommendations............................................................ 5.1 Conclusion....................................................................................... 5.2 Recommendation............................................................................ ReferencesCited..................................................................................................... 11 1v 1v 1 1 2 6 6 6 6 10 10 12 12 12 14 14 14 14 15 LIST OF FIGURES 1. General location of proposed cell tower installation ............................ 3 2. Detailed plan view of proposed cell tower location andinstallation................................................................................ 4 3. Detailed plan view of proposed cell tower location and shovel test pit Locations........................................................................................... 5 4. Location of proposed cell tower site on modern Google Earth map (2017)................................................................................................. 9 5. Historic topographic map with proposed tower location ...................... 1 1 LIST OF TABLES 1. Shovel Test Descriptions............................................................... 13 Appendix 1. Site Photographs.......................................................................................... 16 2. Resumes................................................................................. 25 iv SECTION 1.0 - INTRODUCTION In April 2018, Trileaf Corporation (Trileaf) performed a cultural resource inventory survey for a proposed raw land guyed tower site located at Benton Road, Naples, Collier County, Florida (Section S25, T49S, R27E). The proposed project is located within a grass and tree covered area. Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC proposes the construction of a new guyed tower with a total height of 220 feet (67.1 meters). The new tower and associated equipment will be located in a proposed approximate 60-foot by 60-foot (18.3-meter by 18.3-meter) cell tower lease area. A proposed approximate 20-foot by 100-foot (6.1-meter by 30.5-meter) access and utility easement will connect the proposed lease area to Benton Road to the west. Additionally, the tower will be supported by three (3) guy anchors extending approximately 122 feet (37.2 meters) from the tower center. The new tower will occupy 0.13 acres (0.05 hectares) of land. Under the direction of Trileaf, Project Archaeologist Zach Horne, MA, RPA performed this survey in response to the planned use of the above -described parcel and the potential impacts that such use might represent to archaeological and architectural cultural resources. The Phase I cultural resource survey was designed to discover all prehistoric and historical period cultural resources that might be present within the project area. Pre -field archival research was conducted by Project Archaeologist, Zach Horne. Mr. Horne has been certified as meeting the Secretary of the Interior's Historic Preservation Professional Qualifications Standards for Archaeology and is currently certified by the Register of Professional Archaeologists. Additionally, Project Archaeologist Zach Horne completed the fieldwork and photography for this investigation and authored this report. All work on the current project was completed between March 26th-April loth, 2018. 1.1 Area of Potential Effects (APE) Per the Nationwide Programmatic Agreement (NPA), the APE for direct effects "is defined as the area of potential ground disturbance and any property, or any portion thereof that will be physically altered or destroyed by the undertaking [Federal Communications Commission (FCC)]." Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC proposes the construction of a new guyed tower with a total height of 220 feet (67.1 meters). The new tower and associated equipment will be located in a proposed approximate 60-foot by 60-foot (18.3-meter by 18.3-meter) cell tower lease area. A proposed approximate 20-foot by 100-foot (6.1-meter by 30.5-meter) access and utility easement will connect the proposed lease area to Benton Road to the west. Additionally, the tower will be supported by three (3) guy anchors extending approximately 122 feet (37.2 meters) from the tower center. The new tower will occupy 0.13 acres (0.05 hectares) of land. Per the NPA, the APE for visual effects is the "geographic area in which the project has the potential to introduce visual elements that diminish or alter the setting, including the landscape, where the setting is a character -defining feature of a historic property that makes 1 it eligible for listing on the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP) (FCC)". The presumed APE for visual effects for construction of new facilities is the area from which the tower will be visible. Due to the height of the proposed undertaking (220 feet total), the presumed APE for visual effects for this project is a 3/4- mile radius from the tower site (Figure 5). 1.2 Site Plans and Photographs Please reference Figure 2 to review the construction drawing provided by Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC. Also, please reference Appendix 1 to review photographs of the project area, which were taken by Project Archaeologist Zach Horne, MA, RPA on April 4, 2018, unless otherwise noted. 0) Belle Meade NE Quadrangle, Florida (2015) Contour Interval = 5 Feet Scale 1 Inch = -2,000 Feet 0 Latitude: 26' 10' 44.98" N Longitude: 81' 34' 17.21" W Township: T49S Range: R27E Section: S25 North ° � � I?S'� I • • P Q o • � • w p _ _ 1 0• — t - — --- I ` . 1t t 7 O o i • Site Location e @O ` II v � 9 • ' y,, " D O 13 4 I'�� 1 • 0 O OQp o m o• 1 V Ly 0 D P a e + • p O Cr f7 7-0 • �'� - 4-- i isAd • v I - o .• p •A a �. ^� e O p Site Vicinity Map Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC - Naples Park North, FL 40 TRILEAF Benton Road ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING Naples, FL 34117 Figure 1. General location of proposed cell tower installation. 3 Figure 2. Detailed plan view of proposed cell tower location and installation. I I FUJRIFAR. r--3TR— '22 � A�1.t- - rio ,RAT L E I S P 1 IFFQcio�ouPauNo PROPOSED 20 AOE STP 111 NOM—UCi�CCEsSTP TP1ea0o,:2rs—oo. 'Ft ) AND I rvE jLu r5j3 TPP7 TTP8 _ APPROVALS P9 PROREROWNERS> NF NtlNktR STPS STANCHOR P 13 or a) CMUCTIDN � STP 2 ZONING - N — N s♦ Negative Shovel Test Pit Locations SITE PLAN ��■ A 02/19/1e 1 OF,3 O.RNFM CV�0CH0a L NAPLES PARK RELO CAPITA .....�...... R,r�R,CoLoffy Figure 3. Detailed plan view of proposed cell tower location and installation with shovel test pit locations. 5 SECTION 2.0 - PROJECT SETTING 2.1 Soils Soils in the project area include the Hallandale series, 0 to 2 percent slope (11) (NRCS 2018). The Hallandale series consists of shallow and very shallow, poorly and very poorly drained soils that formed in thin deposits of sandy marine sediments over limestone (MRCS 2018). 2.2 Elevations Elevation ranges between 12-13 feet (3.7-4.0 meters) above mean sea level (AMSL) in the surrounding area, with the project area elevation at approximately 12 feet (3.7 meters) AMSL. Based on examination of the site topography and surface water drainage pattern apparent on the topographic map, shallow groundwater flow in the area is approximated to be generally southwest. No bedrock outcrops or sinkholes were noted in the area. 2.3 Cultural Setting The prehistoric traditions of Florida's inhabitants are briefly summarized below. Due to the lack of cultural material found in the direct APE of this site, this section only serves as a general summary and overview of the prehistory and history of this region. Readers are encouraged to seek larger reports with positive results that focus more extensively on this region. These traditions apply, in varying degrees, throughout the State and are considered the cultural context in which the interpretation of cultural information is assessed, specifically in terms of NRHP eligibility. These dates should be accepted as broad, chronological reference points for central and northwest Florida: Archaeological Time Periods and Cultures Paleoindian Period 10,000- 8,000 BC Archaic Period 8,000 - 500 BC Preceramic 3,000 - 2,000 BC Norwood 2,000 - 1,000 BC Woodland 1,000 BC- AD 750 Deptford 1,000 BC- AD 200 Santa Rosa -Swift Creek AD 200 - 500 Weeden Island AD 500 - 950 Wakulla AD 750 - 950 Mississippian AD 950 - 1513 Fort Walton AD 950 - 1513 Pensacola AD 1200 - 1513 Contact Period AD 1513 - 1700 Historic Period AD 1700 - resent Seminole AD 1715 - 1842 The Paleo-Indian Period (10000 — 8000 B.C.) is typically characterized as the Early Hunter tradition, characterized by small bands of migratory hunter gatherers. At this time, the sea levels made Florida twice the size it is today, resulting in many of these early sites being lost to rising sea levels. Northern Florida supported large forests of pine, oak, and hickory. Rivers and springs brought relief to these dry areas and created the ideal habitat for animals and diverse plant life. Freshwater resources coupled with the Atlantic and Gulf coasts provided stable and reliable sources of fish and shellfish. Today, artifacts from this time period are usually found within interior drainage basins, inundated river valleys, and relic river courses (Indian River Anthropologic Society N.D). Concentrations of Paleoindian sites are often found within the Northern Panhandle and central Gulf Coast regions of Florida. Sites are often located along the Suwannee and Santa Fe Rivers near areas of exposed Tertiary age limestone (Dunbar and Waller 1983). Stone tools from this period include Clovis, Folsom, Suwanee, and Simpson projectile points (Bullen 1975). The Archaic Period (8000 — 500 B.C.) is often divided into early (8000 — 5000 BC), middle (5000 — 3000), and late periods (3000 — 500 BC), and saw drastic environmental changes. The melting of ice sheets along the northern latitudes caused significant rises in the sea level and wetlands began developing along the Florida coastlines and rivers. People began to settle near these resources in larger groups than before, creating more permanent basecamps in conjunction with smaller foraging camps. Fluted projectile points utilized by Paleo-Indians were replaced with stemmed points with corner and side notching, suggesting changes in subsistence patterns. Large middens across the northeast coast suggest reliance on shellfish, marine fish, and terrestrial vertebrates. Evidence of human remains in muck lake -bog -ponds suggest this was a common type of burial practice for early Archaic peoples (Indian River Anthropologic Society N.D). Woodland Period (1000 — 500 BC) is noted by a change in substance and settlement patterns. During this complex populations increased resulting in more sedentary populations, use of intensive horticulture, and change in food production (Wescott 2016). It is also during this period that mound construction and burial practices become more elaborate. Ceramic styles and patterns begin to diversify and include Deptford, Swift Creek, and early Weeden Island pottery. Mississippian Period (AD 950 — AD 1513) is characterized by the emergence of large mound centers and chiefdom -level societies. It is during this time period that platform mounds are constructed, elaborate trade networks are utilized, and maize agriculture begins to intensify. Fort Walton and Lake Jackson are just two important sites that date to this time period (Wescott 2016). The Apalachee and the Timucuans are two tribes that occupied norther Florida during this period. The Apalachee occupied the Tallahassee Hills while the Timucuans held lands between the Aucilla River and the Atlantic Ocean, as far south as Tampa Bay (Florida History N.D.). Historic Overview It was in the year 1513 that the Spanish Exploration of what is now Florida began when Ponce de Leon arrived in the southern portion of the state. Not long after Ponce de Leon, Panfilo fe Narvaez arrived in 1528 and Hernando de Soto on 1539. By 1565 St. Augustine was established and is known as the first successful colony. These early Spanish sites include forts, towns, cattle ranches, and mission. These sites are marked by the presence 7 of Spanish metal, glass, and pottery such as majolica and course earthenware (Wescott 2016). Native tribes were threatened as a result of the arrival of the Spanish. In 1763 Florida would be ceded to England as a result of the First Treaty of Paris, this control would last for twenty years until Spain regained control as a result of the Second Treaty of Paris (Wescott 2016). By the 1700s Northern Florida and Southern Georgia native populations banned together in an attempt to fight European invaders. These native groups included the Creek, Hitchiti, Apalachee, MikisWi, Yamassee, Yuchi, Tequesta, Apalachicola, Choctaw, and Oconee tribes. This alliance would result in the creation of the Seminoles. It was during the 1830s that Andrew Jackson would push for the movement of native groups, in order to open up land for white settlement. The Indian Removal Act would be the catalyst for the Second Seminole War (1835) and inevitably the Third Seminole War (1856) (Seminole Tribe of Florida N.D.). Collier County was established in 1923 and its early economic growth were closely connected to Memphis -born businessman, Barron Gift Collier. With his fortune from streetcar advertising, Collier introduced paved roads, electric power, telegraphs, and countless new businesses and homeowners to Florida's last frontier. The completion of the Tamiami Trail in 1928 also unlocked the region's enormous agricultural and resort potential. Florida's first commercial oil well was brought in at Sunniland in 1943, and Collier County's cypress logging industry flourished at Copeland well into the 1950's (Collier County 2018). 8 Belle Meade NE Quadrangle, Florida (2015) Contour Interval = 5 Feet Scale 1 Inch = -2,000 Feet Latitude: 26' 10' 44.98" N Longitude: 81° 34' 17.21" W Township: T495 Range: R27E Section: S25 %-Mile APE for Visual Effects Site Location i North 2017 Google Earth Aerial — Location Map Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Naples Park North, FL 4 / TRILEAF Benton Road ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING Naples, Florida 34117 Figure 4. Location of proposed cell tower site on modern Google Earth Map (2017). A SECTION 3.0 - RESEARCH 3.1 Background Research Field investigations were preceded by a period of archival research to determine what, if anything, could be predictively said per prehistoric or historic archaeological and/or architectural sensitivities prior to the onset of fieldwork. To assess prehistoric research potentials, site files and holdings were reviewed through the Florida Master Site Files on March 26, 2018. There were no previously recorded archaeological sites, and one previously recorded archaeological survey (1108), no cemeteries, and no National Register of Historic Places (NRHP) eligible or listed historic resources located within the 3/4-mile APE for visual effects. Further, there were no previously recorded archaeological sites or archaeological surveys, cemeteries, or NRHP listed or eligible properties were identified within the APE for direct effect. 10 Belle Meade NE Quadrangle, Florida (1958, p.r. 1973) Contour Interval = 5 Feet Scale 1 Inch = —2,000 Feet Latitude: 26° 10' 44.98" N Longitude: 81° 34' 17.21" W Township: T49S Range: R27E Section: S25 North _ - - %-Mile APE for Visual - •_ - - = '_ "_ - Effects - _'- .� r - _ _ •v --L - - �- Site Location _- - - 7. Site Vicinity Map Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC- Naples Park North, FL 40 TRILEAF Benton Road ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING Naples, FL 34117 Figure 5. Historic topographic map with proposed tower location and'/4-mile APE for visual effects. 11 3.2 Research Design Trileaf designed the Phase I archaeological survey to locate and identify all archaeological resources within the direct APE, defined as the proposed approximate 60-foot by 60-foot (18.3- meter by 18.3-meter) lease area plus a 30-foot buffer, a new access road, three (3) guy anchors, and to evaluate the potential significance of any newly identified archaeological sites. A cultural resource is gauged to be significant if it meets at least one of four criteria for eligibility for listing in the National Register of Historic Places (National Register): A. Associated with significant events in the broad patterns of national history, B. Associated with the lives of persons significant in our past, C. Representative of a type, period, or method of construction, or the work of a master, D. Capable of yielding important information about the past. Criterion D typically applies to archaeological sites. In order to be capable of yielding important information about the past, generally a site must possess artifacts, soil strata, structural remains, or other cultural features that make it possible to test historical hypotheses, corroborate and amplify currently available information, or reconstruct the sequence of the local archaeological record. To be considered significant, archaeological sites must demonstrate sufficient integrity to answer important research questions. These questions are developed in association with temporally, regionally, and thematically defined historic contexts or study units (United States Department of the Interior 1981). SECTION 4.0 — FIELD METHODS AND RESULTS 4.1 Archaeology The field investigation at this location was conducted by Project Archaeologist Zach Horne, MA, RPA on April 4, 2018. Standard archaeological field equipment included shovels, trowels, and a 1/4-inch wire mesh sifting screen. The field survey techniques utilized were a combination of pedestrian and visual survey at 5-meter intervals and/or shovel -testing at 15-meter intervals, with a standard shovel test pit consisting of a hand -excavated hole, approximately 50 cm in diameter and/or deep enough to reach culturally sterile subsoils. Each shovel test was excavated in no greater than 10-centimeter (4-inches) levels to ensure any artifacts were plotted by depth. All shovel test fill was screened through a 1/4-inch wire mesh screen. Shovel testing was conducted within the proposed approximate 60-foot by 60-foot (18.3-meter by 18.3-meter) cell tower lease area, and along the proposed approximate 20-foot by 100-foot (6.1-meter by 30.5-meter) access and utility easement, and along the proposed approximate 122 feet (37.2 meters) three (3) guy anchors. Trileaf initially determined, based on dimensions of the project area, that five shovel tests within the proposed approximate 60-foot by 60-foot (18.3-meter by 18.3-meter) lease area, and two shovel tests within the proposed approximate 20-foot by 100-foot (6.1-meter by 30.5-meter) access and utility easement, and six shovel tests within the proposed approximate 122 feet (37.2 meters) three 12 (3) guy anchors would be an adequate representative sampling of the proposed project area (see Appendix 1). Soils within the project area generally consisted of a black (IOYR 2/1) fine sand with a light brownish graylOYR 6/2 fine sand matrix over a matrix of brown (lOYR 5/3) fine sand with a yellowish brown 1 OYR 5/6 fine sand. No archaeological materials were recovered as a result of this investigation. Total archaeological field time: 4 person -hours. STP N De Soil Description Artifacts Recovered Latitude Lo Black 10YR 2/1 fine sand mottled with light 260 10' 46.0"N 1 0-18 brownish gray 10YR 6/2 fine sand None 81' 34' 17.0"E Brown 10YR 5/3 fine sand with yellowish brown None 10YR 5/6 fine sand 18-36 *limestone bedrock at base of STP Black 10YR 2/1 fine sand mottled with light None 26' 10' 46.0"N 2 0-28 brownish gray 10YR 6/2 fine sand 810 34' 17.0"E Brown 10YR 5/3 fine sand with yellowish brown None 10YR 5/6 fine sand 28-71 *limestone bedrock at base of STP Black 10YR 2/1 fine sand mottled with light None 260 10' 46.0"N 3 0-15 brownish gray 10YR 6/2 fine sand 81' 34' 17.0"E Brown 10YR 5/3 fine sand with yellowish brown None 10YR 5/6 fine sand 15-28 *limestone bedrock at base of STP Black 10YR 2/1 fine sand mottled with light None 26' 10' 46.0"N 4 0-23 brownish gray 10YR 6/2 fine sand 81° 34' 17.0"E Brown 10YR 5/3 fine sand with yellowish brown None 10YR 5/6 fine sand 23-41 *limestone bedrock at base of STP Black 10YR 2/1 fine sand mottled with light None 26' 10' 46.0"N 5 0-18 brownish gray 10YR 6/2 fine sand 81' 34' 17.0"E Brown 10YR 5/3 fine sand with yellowish brown None 10YR 5/6 fine sand 18-38 *limestone bedrock at base of STP Black 10YR 2/1 fine sand mottled with light None 26° 10' 47.0"N 6 0-15 brownish gray 10YR 6/2 fine sand 81' 34' 17.0"E Brown 10YR 5/3 fine sand with yellowish brown None 10YR 5/6 fine sand 15-25 *limestone bedrock at base of STP Black 10YR 2/1 fine sand mottled with light None 26° 10' 46.0"N 7 0-30 brownish gray 10YR 6/2 fine sand 81° 34' 18.0"E Brown 10YR 5/3 fine sand with yellowish brown None 10YR 5/6 fine sand 30-48 *limestone bedrock at base of STP Black 10YR 2/1 fine sand mottled with light None 26° 10' 46.0"N 8 0-33 brownish gray 10YR 6/2 fine sand 81° 34' 18.0"E Brown 10YR 5/3 fine sand with yellowish brown None 10YR 5/6 fine sand 33-53 *limestone bedrock at base of STP Black 10YR 2/1 fine sand mottled with light None 26° 10' 46.0"N 9 0-15 brownish gray 10YR 6/2 fine sand 81° 34' 18.0"E Brown 10YR 5/3 fine sand with yellowish brown None 10YR 5/6 fine sand 15-31 *limestone bedrock at base of STP Black 10YR 2/1 fine sand mottled with light None 26° 10' 47.0"N 10 0-20 brownish gray 10YR 6/2 fine sand 81° 34' 17.0"E Brown 10YR 5/3 fine sand with yellowish brown None 10YR 5/6 fine sand 20-48 *limestone bedrock at base of STP Black 10YR 2/1 fine sand mottled with light None 26° 10' 47.0"N 11 0-15 brownish gray 10YR 6/2 fine sand 81° 34' 17.0"E Brown 10YR 5/3 fine sand with yellowish brown None 10YR 5/6 fine sand 15-48 *limestone bedrock at base of STP Black 10YR 2/1 fine sand mottled with light None 26° 10' 46.0"N 12 0-23 brownish gray 10YR 6/2 fine sand 81' 34' 17.0"E Brown 10YR 5/3 fine sand with yellowish brown None 23-51 10YR 5/6 fine sand 13 *limestone bedrock at base of STP 13 0-25 Black 10YR 2/1 fine sand mottled with light brownish gray 10YR 6/2 fine sand None 26' 10' 46.0"N 81° 34' 17.0"E 25-48 None Table 1. Shovel Test Descriptions. 4.2 Architecture As noted above, based on a map and survey form search through the Florida Master Site Files, no NRHP listed or eligible properties were identified within the direct or visual APE. Additionally, no new structures were recorded as a result of this survey. SECTION 5.0 - CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS 5.1 Conclusions No architectural or archaeological historic properties have been previously identified within the direct APE. The field survey of the project area, which included pedestrian survey, shovel testing, and visual inspection, yielded no archaeological materials. There were no previously recorded archaeological sites, and one previously recorded archaeological survey (1108), and no NRHP listed or eligible properties were identified within the 3/4-mile APE for visual effects. 5.2 Recommendations Based on these findings, Trileaf recommends No Historic Properties in the direct and visual APE. It is therefore recommended that project clearance be granted with no further investigation or evaluation of the project area relative to those resources. However, in the unlikely event that human remains are encountered during construction, all work should immediately stop and area authorities properly notified. 14 REFERENCES CITED Bullen, Ripley P. 1975 A Guide to the Identification of Florida Projectile Points. Kendall Books, Gainesville. Dunbar, James S. and Ben I. Waller 1983 A Distribution Analysis of the Clovis/Suwanee Paleoindian Sites of Florida: A Geographic Approach. Florida Anthropologist 36(1-2): 18-30. Collier County 2018 Collier County, Florida. Assessed April 10, 2018. Retrieved from www.colliercountyfl.gov/your-govemment/divisions-f- r/musuems/history. Federal Communications Commission 2004 Appendix B —Nationwide Programmatic Agreement for Review of Effects on Historic Properties for Certain Undertakings Approved by the Federal Communications Commission. Florida Department of State N.D. A Brief History Website http://dos.myflorida.com/florida-facts/florida-history/a-brief-history/. Accessed March 26, 2018. Google Earth 2017 Aerial photograph. Handley, Brent M. and Joshua Newman 2014 A Cultural Resource Assessment Survey of the Flecther Tower Tract Alachua County, Florida. Environmental Services Inc., Jacksonville, Florida. Historical/architectural survey of Collier County, Florida. 1986 Florida Preservation Services. Survey on file at Florida Master Site File. National Park Service 2017 National Register of Historic Places Website. www.nps.gov/nr/. Accessed March 26, 2018. Natural Resource Conservation Service 2017 United States Department of Agriculture Website. www.nres.usda.gov/. Accessed March 26, 2018. Natural Resources Conservation Service, Soil Survey (MRCS) 2017 Hallandale Series. Official series description. <https://soilseries.sc.egov.usda.gov/OSD—Docs/fl/Hallandale.html>. Accessed March 26, 2018. Seminole Tribe of Florida N.D. History Website. http://www.semtribe.com/History/. Accessed March 26, 2018. U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) 2014 Belle Meade NE FL 7.5-minute quadrangle map. Washington, D.C. Wescott, Kimberly 2016 Cultural Resources Assessment of the FSUMed Center 101836 Cellular Tower Leon County, Florida. Stone Point Services. 15 Appendix 1 Site Photographs 16 Site Photograph 1— Looking north at the Site. Site Photograph 2 — Looking east at the Site. Site Photographs Photographed: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC - Naples Park North, FL Benton Road April 4, 2018 Naples, Florida 34117 17 Site Photograph 3 — Looking south at the Site. Site Photograph 4 — Looking west at the Site. Site Photographs Photographed: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC - Naples Park North, FL Benton Road April 4, 2018 Naples, Florida 34117 Site Photograph 5 — Looking north away from the Site. Site Photograph 6 — Looking east away from the Site. Site Photographs Photographed: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC - Naples Park North, FL Benton Road April 4, 2018 Naples, Florida 34117 19 Site Photograph 7 — Looking south away from the Site. Site Photograph 8 — Looking west away from the Site. Site Photographs Photographed: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC - Naples Park North, FL Benton Road April 4, 2018 Naples, Florida 34117 20 Site Photograph 9 — Looking east along the access and utility easement. Site Photograph 10 — Looking west along the access and utility easement. Site Photographs Photographed: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC - Naples Park North, FL Benton Road April 4, 2018 Naples, Florida 34117 21 Site Photograph 11— Proposed guyed wire easement looking northeast. Site Photograph 12 — Proposed guyed wire easement looking southeast. Site Photographs Photographed: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC - Naples Park North, FL Benton Road April 4, 2018 Naples, Florida 34117 22 Site Photograph 13 — Proposed guyed wire easement looking east. Site Photographs Photographed: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC - Naples Park North, FL Benton Road April 4, 2018 Naples, Florida 34117 23 Site Photograph 14 — Shovel Test Pit 1. Site Photograph 15 — Shovel Test Pit 1 profile. Site Photographs Photographed: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC - Naples Park North, FL Benton Road April 4, 2018 Naples, Florida 34117 24 Appendix 2 Resumes 25 %40 TRILEAF PROFESSIONAL RESUME Education M.S. Historical Archaeology Illinois State University / Normal, IL B.A. Anthropology Adams State University / Alamosa, CO Areas of ExpertisM Ms. Rich is a Secretary of the Interior (SOI) qualified archaeologist and is a member of the Register of Professional Archaeologists (RPA). Ms. Rich specializes in managing and performing Phase I, II, and III historical and prehistoric archaeological investigation review and assessment. Ms. Rich has interest and experience in cultural resource management interpretation and implementation, and has a background in archaeology preservation, providing critical experience and knowledge in archaeological preservation considerations. Ms. Rich has extensive experience in both field and laboratory settings. Ms. Rich's field experience includes performing, under Section 106, background research, historical research, archaeological field survey, testing, and data recovery efforts, and report writing for sites throughout the Midwest. Ms. Rich's laboratory experience includes training and managing groups of veterans as they curated federally -owned archaeological and archival collections, with the goal of boosting basic transferable employment skills, applicable to the civilian workforce, as well as managing and processing artifact and archival collections per National Historic Preservation Act regulations. Ms. Rich also has experience communicating scientific research in professional environments, universitv classrooms, and at national conferences. LSelected Professional Employment and Positions Senior Project Archaeologist, TriLeaf Corporation, St. Louis, Missouri, January 2017-present Supporting Archivist, Defense POW/MIA Accounting Agency (DPAA) VCP Laboratory, St. Louis, Missouri, October 2016-January 2017 Laboratory Manager, Veterans Curation Program, St. Louis, Missouri, January 2015-January 2017 Adjunct Instructor, Lindenwood University, St. Charles, Missouri, August 2014-January 2017 Archaeology Field/Lab Technician, Archaeological Research Center, St. Louis, Missouri, June 2014- December 2014 Research Assistant, Illinois State University, Normal, Illinois, August 2012-May 2014 Hey Girl, I See You: Identifying Women Within Household Assemblages - Society for Historical Archaeology Conference, Fort Worth, Texas, January 2017 Putting Archaeology to Work in a Me Generation - Three Rivers Archaeology Meeting, St. Louis, April 2016 Historical Archaeology at Work: Rehabilitation Our Past and Present to Secure Our Future - Society for Historic Archaeology Conference, Washington, D.C, January 2016 Identifying the visible: A Look at How Economic Class and Ethnicity Influence Women's Visibility within a Household - Society for Historic Archaeology Conference, Seattle, Washington, January 2015 Small Things Remembered: A Look at Identity in the Nolichucky Valley Through Beads and other Small Items - Cherokee, North Carolina, August 2013 Register of Professional Archaeologists (RPA), member since 2014 Society for Historical Archaeology, member since 2011 Conducted public outreach and presented archaeological findings to Cherokee Tribal Elders and community members in Cherokee, North Carolina Participated in identifying and documenting historic petroglyphs as part of a public outreach project in Stone Mountain, Georgia Professional interests include Public Outreach, Public Archaeology, Preservation, Curation, Archives, Cultural Heritage, Historical Research, Museum Collections, and Museum Exhibit Construction. 27 \I/TRILEAF PROFESSIONAL RESUME Education M.A. Anthropology Georgia State University / Atlanta, GA B.S. Anthropology Kennesaw State University / Kennesaw, GA Areas of Expertis Mr. Horne is a Secretary of the Interior (SOI) qualified archaeologist and is a member of the Register of Professional Archaeologists (RPA). Mr. Horne specializes in managing and performing Phase I, II, and III historical and prehistoric archaeological investigation review and assessment. Mr. Horne has interest and experience in conducting archaeological, environmental, and historical research for site assessments for the Section 106 Review process. Mr. Horne has a background in prehistoric North and Central American archaeology with an emphasis on prehistoric ceramic and lithic artifact analysis and preservation in the Mid -Atlantic, Midwest, and Southeast regions of the United States. Mr. Horne has extensive experience in both field and laboratory settings. Mr. Horne's field experience includes performing, under Section 106, background research, historical research, archaeological field survey, testing, and data recovery efforts, and report writing for sites throughout the Mid -Atlantic, Midwest, and Southeast in 21 states. Mr. Horne's laboratory experience includes managing undergraduate student artifact analysis and interpretation in a university setting, as well as the analysis and processing of artifact collections for the US Forest Service and the Ceramoteca del Centro INAH, Yucatan, Mexico. Mr. Horne has experience performing site inspections and conducting environmental due diligence pursuant to EPA All Appropriate Inquiries (AAI) and the American Society of Testing and Materials (ASTM). Environmental service expertise includes the preparation and/or review of: Phase I Environmental Site Assessments 28 National Wetlands Inventory Maps Field Reconnaissance Historical Topographic Maps and Aerial Imagery Land Use History Flood Insurance Rate Maps NEPA Environmental Assessments Form 620/621 Submittals Critical Habitat Maps Soil Characterization Archaeological and Architectural Impacts Local Government Consultation Additio ation and Professional Memberships Register of Professional Archaeologists (RPA), member since 2014 Society for Georgia Archaeology, member since 2014 Professional interests include Public Outreach, Public Archaeology, Preservation, Curation, Archives, Cultural Heritage, and Historical Research 29 NT SUBMISSION PACKET — FCC FORM 620 Approved by OMB 3060-1039 See instructions for Public burden estimates Attachment 6. Tribal and NHO Involvement At an early stage in the planning process, the Nationwide Agreement requires the Applicant to gather information from appropriate Indian Tribes or Native Hawaiian Organizations ("NHOs") to assist in the identification of Historic Properties of religious and cultural significance to them. Describe measures taken to identify Indian tribes and NHOs that may attach religious and cultural significance to Historic Properties that may be affected by the construction within the Areas of Potential Effects ("APE") for direct and visual effects. If such Indian tribes or NHOs were identified, list them and provide a summary of contacts by either the FCC, the Applicant, or the Applicant's representative. Provide copies of relevant documents, including correspondence. If no such Indian tribes or NHOs were identified, please explain. Trileaf Corporation completed the Tower Construction Notification System (TCNS) on March 27, 2018 and received the notification of interested tribes on March 30, 2018. The attached FCC Notification email lists the Tribes identified through the TCNS process. A second notice will be sent to all interested tribes/organizations, after a period of 30 days and the consultation process will continue per the FCC's guidelines. Any relevant comments from Tribes received by Trileaf will be forwarded to your office. Applicant's Name: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Project Number: 637639 FCC Form 620 From: towernotifvinfo(5fcc.00v To: tribal Cc: tcnsweeklyCabfcc.aov Subject: NOTICE OF ORGANIZATION(S) WHICH WERE SENT PROPOSED TOWER CONSTRUCTION NOTIFICATION INFORMATION - Email ID #5701283 Date: Friday, March 30, 2018 2:03:18 AM Dear Sir or Madam: Thank you for using the Federal Communications Commission's (FCC) Tower Construction Notification System (TCNS). The purpose of this electronic mail message is to inform you that the following authorized persons were sent the information you provided through TCNS, which relates to your proposed antenna structure. The information was forwarded by the FCC to authorized TCNS users by electronic mail and/or regular mail (letter). Persons who have received the information that you provided include leaders or their designees of federally - recognized American Indian Tribes, including Alaska Native Villages (collectively "Tribal Nations"), Native Hawaiian Organizations (NHOs), and State Historic Preservation Officers (SHPOs). For your convenience in identifying the referenced Tribal Nations and NHOs and in making further contacts, the City and State of the Seat of Government for each Tribal Nation and NHO, as well as the designated contact person, is included in the listing below. We note that Tribal Nations may have Section 106 cultural interests in ancestral homelands or other locations that are far removed from their current Seat of Government. Pursuant to the Commission's rules as set forth in the Nationwide Programmatic Agreement for Review of Effects on Historic Properties for Certain Undertakings Approved by the Federal Communications Commission (NPA), all Tribal Nations and NHOs listed below must be afforded a reasonable opportunity to respond to this notification, consistent with the procedures set forth below, unless the proposed construction falls within an exclusion designated by the Tribal Nation or NHO. (NPA, Section IV.F.4). The information you provided was forwarded to the following Tribal Nations and NHOs. If a Tribal Nation or NHO does not respond within a reasonable time, you should make a reasonable effort at follow-up contact, unless the Tribal Nation or NHO has agreed to different procedures (NPA, Section IV.F.5). In the event a Tribal Nation or NHO does not respond to a follow-up inquiry, or if a substantive or procedural disagreement arises between you and a Tribal Nation or NHO, you must seek guidance from the Commission (NPA, Section IV.G). These procedures are further set forth in the FCC's Declaratory Ruling released on October 6, 2005 (FCC 05-176). 1. NAGPRA & Section 106 Representative Fred Dayhoff - Miccosukee Tribe of Indians of Florida - Tamiami Station (PO Box: 440021) Miami, FL - hopel@miccosukeetribe.com - 239-695-4360 Details: Please DO NOT contact me prior to the end of the 30-day period to inquire about the proposed site. I really need this time to review the TCNS notifications. If, however, the proposed site is on undisturbed land, and you are aware of something that may be of interest to our Tribe, please feel free to telephone me or send documentation to me prior to the end of the 30-day period. Please send this information to me via regular mail or via UPS. Please do not use Federal Express, since they deliver toa general mailbox for our Tribe. Please send via reg. mail or UPS to: Fred Dayhoff NAGPRA & Section 106 Representative Miccosukee Tribe of Indians of Florida P.O. Box 440021 Tamiami Station Miami, Florida 33144 At the end of the 30 days, ifthere is an inadvertent find during construction, IMMEDIATELY contact me at 239- 695-4360 (phone). If the number is busy, immediately send a Fax to my attention at 239-695-4344 (fax). If this is a POSITIVE TRAIN CONTROL project, please check the state master site file for any archaeological sites that may be present. If there are no archaeological sites present, you may proceed with construction immediately. If there are any archaeological sites present at the proposed site, please contact me assoon as possible. Thank you. Fred Dayhoff NAGPRA & Section 106 Representative Miccosukee Tribe of Indians of Florida (239)695-4360 If the applicant/tower builder receives no response from the Miccosukee Tribe of Indians of Florida within 30 days after notification through TCNS, the Miccosukee Tribe of Indians of Florida has no interest in participating in pre -construction review for the proposed site. The Applicant/tower builder, however, must immediately notify the Miccosukee Tribe of Indians of Florida in the event archaeological properties or human remains are discovered during construction, consistent with Section IX of the Nationwide Programmatic Agreement and applicable law. 2. Compliance Review Supervisor Bradley M Mueller - Seminole Tribe of Florida - 30290 Josie Billie Hwy PMB 1004 Clewiston, FL - bradleymueller@semtribe.com - 863-983-6549 (ext: 12245) Details: The Seminole Tribe of Florida - Tribal Historic Preservation Office has revised its FCC TCNS project assessment policy effective August 22, 2017. The full policy text does not fit within this sites allotted space but can be found at htip:Hstofthpo.com/STOF-FCC-TCNS-Policy_pd£ We strongly urge all contractors, consultants, and applicants to read the new policy since it includes changes to fees charged for some types of reviews and provides a new email address for contacting us. Thank you. If the applicant/tower builder receives no response from the Seminole Tribe of Florida within 30 days after notification through TCNS, the Seminole Tribe of Florida has no interest in participating in pre -construction review for the proposed site. The Applicant/tower builder, however, must immediately notify the Seminole Tribe of Florida in the event archaeological properties or human remains are discovered during construction, consistent with Section IX of the Nationwide Programmatic Agreement and applicable law. 3. Historic Preservation Officer Theodore Isham - Seminole Nation of Oklahoma - (PO Box: 1498) Wewoka, OK - isham.t@sno-nsn.gov - 405-234-5218 Details: If the Applicant/tower builder receives no response from the Seminole Nation of Oklahoma within 30 days after notification through TCNS, the Seminole Nation of Oklahoma has no interest in participating in pre - construction review for the site. The Applicant/tower builder, however, must IMMEDIATELY notify the Seminole Nation of Oklahoma in the event archaeological properties or human remains are discovered during construction, consistent with Section IX of the Nationwide Programmatic Agreement and applicable law. 4. TCNS Coordinator Anne Edwards -Martel Ms - Muscogee (Creek) Nation - Highway 75 & Loop 56 (PO Box: 580) Okmulgee, OK - mcntcns@mcn-nsn.gov; section106@mcn-nsn.gov - 918-732-7639 Details: PLEASE NOTE OUR NEW REQUIREMENTS: Because the TCNS Details do not provide enough information for us to conduct a proper assessment on behalf of the Muscogee (Creek) Nation, we, instead, require that you submit with your original notification via regular postal mail or other parcel carrier the following (E- MAILED DOCUMENTATION WILL NOT BE ACCEPTED, NO EXCEPTIONS): 1) 620/621 forms 2) Colored photographs (no thumbnails please) 3) Aerial Map and color USGS topographic maps that clearly show the proposed site location, area of potential effect, shovel tests, access roads, utility easements, list of previously known archaeological sites within one mile of site and any information pertaining to project 4) Copy of archaeological assessment/survey including site forms of all sites within 1 mile of the project area 5) All pages of project to be on 8 1/2 x 11 or larger, maps must be at minimum 8 1/2 x 11 or larger 6) Need to send copy of all information pertaining to project on CD as well as a hard copy 7) A copy of review letter from the State Historic Preservation Office 8) Submit payment along with project EFFECTIVE O1/01/2016 PLEASE NOTE OUR NEW REVIEW FEES: Our administrative review fee for 106 reviews is $800.00 for all new, collocations, addendums, and Positive Train Control. Please submit check with hard copyand CD copy. Upon receipt of all information outlined above, which requires the completed 620/621 form and receipt of the administrative review fee, the Section 106 30-day reviewprocess will begin. If you do not receive a response within 30 days from the date our office receives complete 620/621 packet and payment, please contact us by phone to confirm review status. Please submit required information and payment to address below: Muscogee (Creek) Nation Historic and Cultural PreservationDepartment Ms Corain Lowe-Zepeda, TCNS Coordinator P.O. Box 580 Hwy 75 & Loop 56 Okmulgee, OK 74447 For specific information regarding TCNS, please contact Ms. Corain Lowe-Zepeda, TCNS Coordinator, directly at 918-732-7835 or Ms. RaeLynn Butler, THPO at 918-732-7678. Thank you. Sincerely, Ms. Corain Lowe-Zepeda, TCNS Coordinator Muscogee (Creek) Nation 918-732-7835 clowe@mcn-nsn.gov 5. TCNS Coordinator Travis Patton - Eastern Shawnee Tribe of Oklahoma - 70500 East 128 Road Wyandotte, OK - tpatton@estoo.net - 918-666-2435 (ext: 1860) Details: The Cultural Preservation Office of the Eastern Shawnee Tribe of Oklahoma requires the following information and fees regarding all proposed FCC projects. Please do not email documentation; it will be deleted without being opened. Mail one printed color copy of all documentation to: 70500 E 128 Rd. Wyandotte, OK 74370 Please submit by US postal mail or other parcel carrier all of the following information for all FCC projects: 1. A 1-page cover letter with the following information: a) TCNS number b) Company name c) Project name, city, county, state d) Project type e) UTM coordinates using WGS84 (G1150) f) Total area surveyed in acres g) Contact information. 2. Professional cultural/archaeological resource survey report. 3. Aerial and color USGS topographic maps locating project area within the state, county, and local area. 4. Aerial, color USGS topographic, or planimetric maps locating tower site, APE, access road, utility easement,guy wire locations surveyed, surveyed staging areas, and known archaeological/historic sites. 5. Project site plan map depicting labeled shovel test locations. 6. Shovel test log. 7. Site photographs. 8. A copy of the review letter or TCNS e-response from the State Historic Preservation Office and all other state -mandated review offices for projects involving ground disturbance. 9. Please submit a fee of $550.00 per/TCNS project, for administration, data processing, handling, research and review. Make the check payable to the Eastern Shawnee Tribe of Oklahoma. On the memo line write all TCNS numbers. This includes new build towers, collocations, PTC poles, and projects in previously disturbed locations. 1 O.The Eastern Shawnee procedure document is available by email and is highly recommended for guidance. Send an email to Travis Patton at: tpatton@estoo.net. 6. THPO Terry Clouthier - Thlopthlocco Tribal Town - P.O. Box 188 Okemah, OK - thpo@tttown.org; thlopthloccotribaltowntowers@gmail.com - 918-560-6113 Details: Thlopthlocco Tribal Town is requesting consulting party status on any proposed projects, actions or undertakings that the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) undertakes in our Area of Historic Interest. All initial notifications for any actions, projects or undertakings must be sent through the Tower Construction Notification System (TCNS) as this is our preferred preference consistent with Section IV.D of the Nationwide Programmatic Agreement (NPA) of 2004 as an efficient and thorough means of making initial contact or notification and is to be considered "best practice" consistent with Section IV.J and that the FCC must encourage applicants to follow it and not attempt to circumvent it. While it is acceptable to submit the review material electronically, it is not acceptable to initially contact or notify Thlopthlocco Tribal Town independently of the TCNS program as our participation within that program through defining our areas of interest inherently implies that we wish to be notified using that same program and that implication is hereby confirmed with this statement. Any initial notifications for any actions, projects or undertakings submitted by the Federal Communications Commission or an applicant acting on their behalf consistent with the NPA which is not sent through the TCNS program to Thlopthlocco Tribal Town will be returned to sender and will not be considered submitted. Alternatively, Thlopthlocco Tribal Town reserves the right to inform the FCC or applicant to review our submission requirements through the TCNS program and that as the current submission did not follow those directions it is not considered submitted nor will it be considered a reasonable or good faith effort to contact or notify Thlopthlocco Tribal Town as required under Section 106 and the NPA. As a contractor, you are aware of expenses that are incurred to provide your professional services. The Thlopthlocco Tribal Town is also being asked to provide a professional service and therefore,should be compensatedfor their expertise. Our fee is $800.00 per site. You will receive an invoice, and review will commence upon receipt of both the payment and the review materials. Payments should include the TCNS number(s) on the memo, and should be mailed to Thlopthlocco Tribal Town, c/o Finley & Cook,Attn: Jeanie Willis, 601 N. Broadway, Shawnee,OK 74801 Airfare, mileage, per diem and lodging, plus any unanticipated costs must be paid for by the Cell Tower Contractor or applicant for any tribal representatives who have to travel to one or multiple site areas should it be deemed necessary by Thlopthlocco Tribal Town. Form 620 or 621 are required for reviews to be completed, as well as archeology reports. Any site maps, previous archeological surveys,findings, photographs,etc., are required for review, andsent via email to thlopthloccotribaltowntowers@gmail.com with a CC to thpo@tttown.org. Please indicate the TCNS number in the subject line of the email. DO NOT SEND PAPER COPIES WITH YOUR CHECK, as they will NOT be received by the THPO or TCNSconsultant. Documents sent directly to theTHPO via US mail will be returned to sender and are not considered to be submitted. Please follow the instructions in TCNS relating to accepted submissions. CO -LOCATIONS andall other undertakings being placed on EXISTING structures must include information regarding date and determination of previous Section 106 review for the structure as part of the requested review materials. In addition, co -locations must clearly indicate number of existing FCC undertakings (antennae, nodes, etc.) on the structure. Towers or structures being used for collocations that have not been subject to previous Section 106 review and concurrence will be treated as if it is a new tower construction and applicable fees and review time will be necessary. PLEASE refrain from checking on the status of projects which are NOT overdue (30 days per law). However, if projects reviews are believed to have not been received and it past the 30 day mark of receiving materials AND payment, please FIRST log into TCNS to check for response, and SECOND contact the tribe to work together to resolve the issue. If the project is NOT over 30 days, please refrain from checking on status UNLESS there is a public emergency or some extraordinary circumstance you feel may need special attention. The Applicant or construction personnel, must immediately notify the Thlopthlocco Tribal Town in the event historic properties or human remains are discovered before, during or after construction, consistent with Section IX of the Nationwide Programmatic Agreement and applicable law. Thlopthlocco Tribal Town can be reached at thpo@tttown.org in such an event. The information you provided was also forwarded to the following SHPOs in the State in which you propose to construct and neighboring States. The information was provided to these SHPOs as a courtesy for their information and planning. You need make no effort at this time to follow up with any SHPO that does not respond to this notification. Prior to construction, you must provide the SHPO of the State in which you propose to construct (or the Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, if the project will be located on certain Tribal lands), with a Submission Packet pursuant to Section VII.A of the NPA. 7. SHPO Lee Warner - Alabama Historical Commission - 468 South Perry Street Montgomery, AL - lwarner@mail.preserveala.org - 334-242-3184 8. Deputy SHPO Elizabeth Ann Brown - Alabama Historical Commission - 468 South Perry Street Montgomery, AL - ebrown@mail.preserveala.org - 334-242-3185 9. Deputy SHPO Compliance Review Laura A Kammerer - Div of Historical Resources, Dept of State - 500 S. Bronough St. Tallahassee, FL - lammerer@dos.state.fl.us - 850-245-6333 10. Historic Preservationist Robin Jackson - Florida Division of Historical Resources - 500 S. Bronough Street Tallahasse, FL - Robin.Jackson@DOS.myflorida.com - 850-245-6333 "Exclusions" above set forth language provided by the Tribal Nation or SHPO. These exclusions may indicate types of PTC wayside pole notifications that the Tribal Nation or SHPO does not wish to review. TCNS automatically forwards all notifications to all Tribal Nations and SHPOs that have an expressed interest in the geographic area of a proposal. However, if a proposal falls within a designated exclusion, you need not expect any response and need not pursue any additional process with that Tribal Nation or SHPO. Exclusions may also set forth policies or procedures of a particular Tribal Nation or SHPO (for example, types of information that a Tribal Nation routinely requests, or a policy that no response within 30 days indicates no interest in participating in pre -construction review). Please be advised that the FCC cannot guarantee that the contact(s) listed above opened and reviewed an electronic or regular mail notification. If you learn any of the above contact information is no longer valid, please contact the FCC. The following information relating to the proposed tower was forwarded to the person(s) listed above: Notification Received: 03/27/2018 Notification ID: 169882 Tower Owner Individual or Entity Name: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Consultant Name: Mindi L Okai Street Address: 10845 Olive Blvd. Suite 260 City: St. Louis State: MISSOURI Zip Code: 63141 Phone: 314-997-6111 Email: tribal@trileaf.com Structure Type: GTOWER - Guyed Structure Used for Communication Purposes Latitude: 26 deg 10 min 45.0 sec N Longitude: 81 deg 34 min 17.2 sec W Location Description: Benton Road City: Naples State: FLORIDA County: COLLIER Detailed Description of Project: Legal Description: S25 T49S R27E Ground Elevation: 3.7 meters Support Structure: 67.1 meters above ground level Overall Structure: 67.1 meters above ground level Overall Height AMSL: 70.8 meters above mean sea level If you have any questions or comments regarding this notice, please contact the FCC using the electronic mail form located on the FCC's website at: hM27//wireless.fcc.gov/outreach/notification/contact-fcc.htmi. You may also call the FCC Support Center at (877) 480-3201 (TTY 717-338-2824). Hours are from 8 a.m. to 7:00 p.m. Eastern Time, Monday through Friday (except Federal holidays). To provide quality service and ensure security, all telephone calls are recorded. Thank you, Federal Communications Commission NT SUBMISSION PACKET — FCC FORM 620 Approved by OMB 3060-1039 See instructions for Public burden estimates Attachment 7. Historic Properties Direct Effects a. List all properties within the APE for direct effects. No cultural materials or features were observed on the surface or subsurface of the direct APE. A finding of No Historic Properties in the APE for Direct Effects is recommended for this project. b. Provide the name and address (including U.S. Postal Service ZIP Code) of each property in the APE for direct effects, not listed in part "a" (above), that the Applicant considers to be eligible for listing in the National Register as a result of the Applicant's research. For each such property, describe how it satisfies the criteria of eligibility (36 C.F.R. Part 63). For each property that was specifically considered and determined not to be eligible, describe why it does not satisfy the criteria of eligibility. N/A Applicant's Name: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Project Number: 637639 FCC Form 620 NT SUBMISSION PACKET— FCC FORM 620 Approved by OMB 3060-1039 See instructions for Public burden estimates Attachment 7. Continued c. Describe the techniques and the methodology, including any field survey, used to identify Historic Properties within the APE for direct effects.' If no archeological field survey was performed, provide a report substantiating that: i) the depth of previous disturbance exceeds the proposed construction depth (excluding footings and other anchoring mechanisms) by at least 2 feet; or, ii) geomorphological evidence indicates that cultural resource -bearing soils do not occur within the project area or may occur but at depths that exceed 2 feet below the proposed construction depth.2 The field investigation at this location was conducted by Project Archaeologist Zach Horne, MA, RPA on April 4, 2018. Standard archaeological field equipment included shovels, trowels, and a %-inch wire mesh sifting screen. The field survey techniques utilized were a combination of pedestrian and visual survey at 5-meter intervals and/or shovel -testing at 15-meter intervals, with a standard shovel test pit consisting of a hand -excavated hole, approximately 50 cm in diameter and/or deep enough to reach culturally sterile subsoils. Each shovel test was excavated in no greater than 10-centimeter (4-inches) levels to ensure any artifacts were plotted by depth. All shovel test fill was screened through a %-inch wire mesh screen. Shovel testing was conducted within the proposed approximate 60-foot by 60-foot (18.3-meter by 18.3- meter) cell tower lease area, and along the proposed approximate 20-foot by 100-foot (6.1-meter by 30.5-meter) access and utility easement, and along the proposed approximate 122 feet (37.2 meters) three (3) guy anchors. Trileaf initially determined, based on dimensions of the project area, that five shovel tests within the proposed approximate 60-foot by 60-foot (18.3-meter by 18.3-meter) lease area, and two shovel tests within the proposed approximate 20-foot by 100-foot (6.1-meter by 30.5-meter) access and utility easement, and six shovel tests within the proposed approximate 122 feet (37.2 meters) three (3) guy anchors would be an adequate representative sampling of the proposed project area (see Appendix 1). Soils within the project area generally consisted of a black (10YR 2/1) fine sand with a light brownish 1 Pursuant to Section VI.D.2.a. of the Nationwide Agreement, Applicants shall make a reasonable and good faith effort to identify above ground and archeological Historic Properties, including buildings, structures, and historic districts, that lie within the APE for direct effects. Such reasonable and good faith efforts may include a field survey where appropriate. 2 Under Section VI.D.2.d. of the Nationwide Agreement, an archeological field survey is required even if none of these conditions applies, if an Indian tribe or NHO provides evidence that supports a high probability of the presence of intact archeological Historic Properties within the APE for direct effects. Applicant's Name: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Project Number: 637639 FCC Form 620 NT SUBMISSION PACKET— FCC FORM 620 Approved by OMB 3060-1039 See instructions for Public burden estimates gray10YR 6/2 fine sand matrix over a matrix of brown (10YR 5/3) fine sand with a yellowish brown 10YR 5/6 fine sand. Based on the information gathered, no previously -identified archaeological sites are located within the tower lease area or access road. No artifacts were recovered or any new archaeological resources within the APE for direct effects. Please refer to the Archaeological Survey in attachment 5. Applicant's Name: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Project Number: 637639 FCC Form 620 NT SUBMISSION PACKET — FCC FORM 620 Approved by OMB 3060-1039 See instructions for Public burden estimates Attachment 8. Historic Properties Visual Effects Historic Properties Identified for Visual Effects Guidelines a. Provide the name and address (including U.S. Postal Service ZIP Code) of each property in the APE for visual effects that is listed in the National Register, has been formally determined eligible for listing by the Keeper of the National Register, or is identified as considered eligible for listing in the records of the SHPO/THPO, pursuant to Section VI.D.I.a. of the Nationwide Agreement. N/A b. Provide the name and address (including U.S. Postal Service ZIP Code) of each Historic Property in the APE for visual effects, not listed in part "a", identified through the comments of Indian Tribes, NHOs, local governments, or members of the public. Identify each individual or group whose comments led to the inclusion of a Historic Property in this attachment. For each such property, describe how it satisfies the criteria of eligibility (36 C.F.R. Part 63). As of the date of this report, Trileaf Corporation has not received comments from Indian Tribes, NHOs, local governments, or members of the public that identify Historic Properties in the APE for visual effects. c. For any properties listed in the above Historic Properties list, that the Applicant considers no longer eligible for inclusion in the National Register, explain the basis for this recommendation. N/A Applicant's Name: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Project Number: 637639 FCC Form 620 NT SUBMISSION PACKET — FCC FORM 620 Approved by OMB 3060-1039 See instructions for Public burden estimates Attachment 9. Local Government a. If any local government has been contacted and invited to become a consulting party pursuant to Section V.A. of the Nationwide Programmatic Agreement, list the local government agencies contacted. Provide a summary of contacts and copies of any relevant documents (e.g., correspondence or notices). On March 27, 2018, the City of Naples Planning Department was notified of the proposed project and invited to comment on the proposed project's potential effect on Historic Properties as well as indicate whether they are interested in consulting further on the proposed project. A copy of Trileaf Corporation's correspondence with the City of Naples Planning Department is attached. As of this date, no response has been received from the City of Naples Planning Department. Should a response be received, a copy will be forwarded to all consulting parties as an addendum to this packet. b. If a local government agency will be contacted but has not been to date, explain why and when such contact will take place. N/A Applicant's Name: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Project Number: 637639 FCC Form 620 %40TRILEAF ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING 1051 Winderley Place, Suite 201, Maitland, Florida 32751 - 407.660.7840 - www.trileaf.com March 27, 2018 City of Naples Planning Department Community Development Building 295 Riverside Circle Naples, Florida 34102 Phone: 239-213-1050 RE: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC — Naples Park North, FL / Client #FL114 — Trileaf Project #637639 Benton Road, Naples, Florida 34117 Collier County, Belle Meade NE Quadrangle (USGS) Latitude: 260 10' 44.98" N, Longitude: 81 ° 34' 17.21" W To Whom It May Concern: Trileaf Corporation is in the process of completing a NEPA Review at the referenced property. Our client proposes to construct a 220-foot Med communications tower and associated equipment within a 60-foot by 60-foot(3,600 square feet) lease area. The project includes an access/utility easement, measuring approximately 20 feet wide, which extends west away from the lease area towards Benton Road. The proposed access & utility easement and the proposed tower compound lease area are located partially within an undeveloped palm tree and scrub -covered area. The antenna will be licensed by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC). Our investigation includes determining if the site is contained in, on or within the viewshed of a building, site, district, structure or object, significant in American history, architecture, archeology, engineering or culture, that is listed, or eligible for listing on the State or National Registers of Historic Places, or located in or on an Indian Religious Site. Trileaf is requesting information regarding this tower's potential effect on Historic Properties. All information received will be forwarded to the State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) as part of the Section 106 review process. Additionally, this invitation to comment is separate from any local planning/zoning process that may apply to this project. If you wish to comment or be considered a consulting party, please respond within thirty (30) days of the date of this letter. If a response is not received within thirty (30) days, it will be assumed that you have no objections to this undertaking. A site topography map and aerial photograph are enclosed for your reference. Please call me at (407) 660-7840 or email j.reagan@trileaf.com if you need additional information or have any questions. Thank you for your assistance in this regard. Sincerely, �"� Jackson Reagan Project Scientist NT SUBMISSION PACKET— FCC FORM 620 Approved by OMB 3060-1039 See instructions for Public burden estimates Attachment 10. Other Consulting Parties and Public Notice List additional consulting parties that were invited to participate by the Applicant, or independently requested to participate. Provide any relevant correspondence or other documents. On March 27, 2018, the Naples Historical Society was notified of the proposed project and invited to comment on the proposed project's potential effect on Historic Properties as well as indicate whether they are interested in consulting further on the proposed project. A copy of Trileaf Corporation's correspondence with the Naples Historical Society is attached. As of this date, no response has been received from the Naples Historical Society. Should a response be received, a copy will be forwarded to all consulting parties as an addendum to this packet. You are required to provide a Public Notice Attachment. Attached, please find a copy of a legal notice regarding the proposed telecommunications tower construction that was posted in the Naples Daily News on March 30, 2018. As of the date of this submission packet, no comments regarding this notice have been received by Trileaf Corporation. Should a response be received, copies will be forwarded to all consulting parties as an addendum to this submission packet. Applicant's Name: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Project Number: 637639 FCC Form 620 %40TRILEAF ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING 1051 Winderley Place, Suite 201, Maitland, Florida 32751 - 407.660.7840 - www.trileaf.com March 27, 2018 Naples Historical Society P.O. Box 201 137 12' Avenue South Naples, Florida 34102 Phone: 239-261-8164 Email: NHS@NaplesHistoricalSociety.org RE: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC — Naples Park North, FL / Client #FL114 — Trileaf Project #637639 Benton Road, Naples, Florida 34117 Collier County, Belle Meade NE Quadrangle (USGS) Latitude: 26' 10' 44.98" N, Longitude: 81' 34' 17.21" W To Whom It May Concern: Trileaf Corporation is in the process of completing a NEPA Review at the referenced property. Our client proposes to construct a 220-foot Med communications tower and associated equipment within a 60-foot by 60-foot (3,600 square feet) lease area. The project includes an access/utility easement, measuring approximately 20 feet wide, which extends west away from the lease area towards Benton Road. The proposed access & utility easement and the proposed tower compound lease area are located partially within an undeveloped palm tree and scrub -covered area. The antenna will be licensed by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC). Our investigation includes determining if the site is contained in, on or within the viewshed of a building, site, district, structure or object, significant in American history, architecture, archeology, engineering or culture, that is listed, or eligible for listing on the State or National Registers of Historic Places, or located in or on an Indian Religious Site. Trileaf is requesting information regarding this tower's potential effect on Historic Properties. All information received will be forwarded to the State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) as part of the Section 106 review process. Additionally, this invitation to comment is separate from any local planning/zoning process that may apply to this project. If you wish to comment or be considered a consulting party, please respond within thirty (30) days of the date of this letter. If a response is not received within thirty (30) days, it will be assumed that you have no objections to this undertaking. A site topography map and aerial photograph are enclosed for your reference. Please call me at (407) 660-7840 or email j.reagan@trileaf.com if you need additional information or have any questions. Thank you for your assistance in this regard. Sincerely, ,,,� Jackson Reagan Project Scientist NaPttS:4)a*ttil NtWS NaplesNews.com Published Daily Naples, FL 34110 Affidavit of Publication State of Florida Counties of Collier and Lee Before the undersigned they serve as the authority, personally appeared Natalie Zollar who on oath says that she serves as Inside Sales Manager of the Naples Daily News, a daily newspaper published at Naples, in Collier County, Florida; distributed in Collier and Lee counties of Florida; that the attached copy of the advertising was published in said newspaper on dates listed. Affiant further says that the said Naples Daily News is a newspaper published at Na- ples, in said Collier County, Florida, and that the said newspaper has heretofore been continuously published in said Collier County, Florida; distributed in Collier and Lee counties of Florida, each day and has been entered as second class mail matter at the post office in Naples, in said Collier County, Florida, for a period of one year next preceding the first publication of the attached copy of advertisement; and affiant further says that he has neither paid nor promised any person, or corporation any discount, rebate, commission or refund for the purpose of securing this advertisement for publication in the said newspaper. Customer Ad Number Copy ine TRILEAF Pub Dates March 30, 2018 (Sign ture of affiant) Sworn to and subscribed before me This March 30, 2018 �� WIVI f q� Q (Signature of affiant) 1971446 Capital Telecom Hold n� o '•••., KAROL E KANGAS Notary Public - State ofFloMa Commission It GG 126041 � = "°f1""• My Comm,Expires Jul 29,2021 Banded through NalkwWWOtsyAsm, P.O.# TCaptt6:43atI1J NPWS Sales Rep: Mereida Cardenas (N9103) Phone: Date: 03/28/18 Account Number: 504470 (N069820) Company Name: TRILEAF Contact Name: Email: j.powell@TRILEAF.COM Address: 1051 WINDERLEY PL #201, MAITLAND, FL, 32751 Phone: (407) 660-7840 Fax: (407) 660-7394 I agree this ad is accurate and as ordered. Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC proposes to build a 220- foot Guyed Communications Tower. Anticipated lighting application is medium intensity dual red/white strobes. The Site location is Benson Street, Naples, Collier County, FL 34117, Lat: [26-10- 44.98], Long: [-81-34-17.21]. The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) Antenna Structure Registration (ASR, Form 854) filing number is A1100236. ENVIRONMENTAL EFFECTS - Interested persons may review the application (www. fcc.gov/asr/applications) by entering the filing number. Environmental concerns may be raised by filing a Request for Environmental Review (www.fcc.gov/asr/ environmentalrequest) and online filings are strongly encouraged. The mailing address to file a paper copy is: FCC Requests for Environmental Review, Attn: Ramon Williams, 445 12th Street SW, Washington, DC 20554. HISTORIC PROPERTIES EFFECTS - Public comments regarding potential effects on historic properties may be submitted within 30 days from the date of this publication to: Trileaf Corp, Jackson Reagan, veagan@trileaf.com, 1051 Winder ley Place, Suite 201, Maitland, FL 32751, 407-660- 7840. March 30, 2018 No.1971446 Email: •n Information This is a proof of your ad scheduled to run on the dates indicated below. Please confirm placement prior to deadline by contacting your account rep at . Ad Id: 1971446 P.O. No.: Total Cost: Tag Line: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC propos Start Date: 03/30/18 Stop Date: 03/30/18 Number of Timess: 1 Class: 16250 -Public Notices Publications: ND -Naples Daily News, ND-Internet-naplesnews.com Thank you for your business. Our commitment to a quality product includes the advertising in our publications. As such, Gannett reserves the right to cat- egorize, edit and refuse certain classified ads. Your satisfaction is important. If you notice errors in your ad, please notify the classified department immedi- ately so that we can make corrections before the second print date. The number to call is 239-263-4700. Allowance may not be made for errors reported past the second print date. The Naples Daily News may not issue refunds for classified advertising purchased in a package rate; ads purchased on the open rate may be pro -rated for the remaining full days for which the ad did not run. NT SUBMISSION PACKET— FCC FORM 620 Approved by OMB 3060-1039 See instructions for Public burden estimates Attachment 11. SHPO Specific Forms Please see the attached Florida Master Site File Survey Log Sheet. Applicant's Name: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Project Number: 637639 FCC Form 620 Page 1 Ent D (FMSF only) - Survey Log Sheet Survey # (FMSF only) Florida Master Site File Version 4.1 1107 Consult Guide to the Survey Log Sheet for detailed instructions. Survey Project (name and project phase) Naples Park North FL Cultural Resource Survey Report Title (exactly as on title page) Cultural Resource Survey Naples Park North FL Report Authors (as on title page, last names first) 1. Horne, Zach 3. 2. 4. Publication Date (year) 2018 Total Number of Pages in Report (count text, figures, tables, not site forms) 35 Publication Information (Give series, number in series, publisher and city. For article or chapter, cite page numbers. Use the style of American Antiquity.) Supervisors of Fieldwork (even if same as author) Names Cori Rich Affiliation of Fieldworkers: organization Trileaf Corporation City Marietta, Georgia Key Words/Phrases (Don't use county name, or common words like archaeology, structure, survey, architecture, etc.) 1. Naples Park North FL3. 5. 7. 2. Cultural Resource Survey 4. 6. 8. Survey Sponsors (corporation, government unit, organization or person directly funding fieldwork) Name Trileaf Corporation Organization AddresslPhonel E-mail 1205 Johnson Ferry Rd,Marietta,GA/314-997-6111/z.horne@trileaf.com Recorder of Log Sheet Zach Horne Date Log Sheet Completed 4/10/18 Is this survey or project a continuation of a previous project? ❑x No ❑Yes: Previous survey #s (FMSF only) Counties (List each one in which field survey was done; attach additional sheet if necessary) 1. Collier 3. 5. 2. 4. 6. USGS 1:24,000 Map NameslYear of Latest Revision (attach additional sheet if necessary) 1. Name Belle Meade NE, FL Year 2015 4. Name Year 2. Name Year 5. Name Year 3. Name Year 6. Name Year Dates for Fieldwork: Start 4/4/18 End 4/4/18 Total Area Surveyed (fill in one) hectares 0.13 acres Number of Distinct Tracts or Areas Surveyed 1 If Corridor (fill in one for each) Width: meters feet Length: kilometers miles HR6E066R0107 Florida Master Site File, Division of Historical Resources, Gray Building, 500 South Bronough Street, Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0250 Phone 850-245-6440, FAX 850-245-6439, Email: SiteFile@dos.state.fl.us Page 2 Survey Log Sheet Survey # Types of Survey (check all that apply): x❑archaeological x❑architectural x❑historicallarchival ❑damage assessment ❑monitoring report ❑other(describe): ScopellntensitylProcedures Intensive Phase I Archaeology Survey/ Surface Survey Preliminary Methods (check as many as apply to the project as a whole) ❑Florida Archives (Gray Building) []library research- coca/public ❑Florida Photo Archives (Gray Building) []library -special collection - non/oca/ [@Site File property search ❑Public Lands Survey (maps at DEP) Mx Site File survey search []local informant(s) ❑other (describe): Archaeological Methods (check as many as apply to the project as a whole) ❑Check here if NO archaeological methods were used. ❑surface collection, controlled []shovel test -other screen size ❑surface collection, uncontrolled []water screen ®shovel test-114"screen ❑posthole tests ❑ shovel test-118" screen ❑ auger tests ❑shovel test 1116"screen ❑coring ❑shovel test-unscreened []test excavation (at least 1x2 m) El other (describe): ❑local property or tax records El newspaper files [@literature search ❑Sanborn Insurance maps HistoricallArchitectural Methods (check as many as apply to the project as a whole) ❑X Check here if NO historicallarchitectural methods were used. El building permits ❑demolition permits []neighbor interview ❑commercial permits ❑exposed ground inspected ❑occupant interview ❑interior documentation []local property records []occupation permits El other (describe): Site Significance Evaluated? []Yes Count of Previously Recorded Sites ONO ❑underwater bother historic maps [@soils maps or data ❑windshield survey [Elaerial photography ❑block excavation (at least 2x2 m) []soil resistivity ❑magnetometer ❑side scan sonar [@pedestrian survey ❑unknown Count of Newly Recorded Sites ❑subdivision maps ❑tax records []unknown Previously Recorded Site #'s with Site File Update Forms (List site #'s without "8". Attach additional pages if necessary.) None Newly Recorded Site #'s (Are all originals and not updates? List site #'s without "8". Attach additional pages if necessary.) None Site Forms Used: ❑Site File Paper Form ❑Site File Electronic Recording Form 'REQUIRED: ATTACH PLOT OF SURVEY AREA ON PHOTOCOPY OF USGS 1:24,000 MAPS)*** Origin of Report: ❑872 ❑CARL ❑UW Ell A32# ❑Grant Project # ❑Academic []Contract ❑Avocational []Compliance Review: CRAT # Type of Document: []Archaeological Survey ❑HistoricallArchitectural Survey []Marine Survey ❑Cell Tower CRAS ❑Monitoring Report ❑Overview ❑Excavation Report []Multi -Site Excavation Report ❑Structure Detailed Report ❑Library, Hist. or Archival Doc ❑MPS ❑MRA ❑TG ❑Other: Document Destination: Plotability: HR6E066R0107 Florida Master Site File, Division of Historical Resources, Gray Building, 500 South Bronough Street, Tallahassee, Florida 32399.0250 Phone 850-245-6440, FAX 850-245-6439, Email: SiteFile@dos.state.fl.us From: towernotifyinfo(cUcc.aov To: Jackson Reaaan Subject: Section 106 New Filing Submitted- Email ID #2834790 Date: Friday, April 13, 2018 10:15:55 AM The following new Section 106 filing has been submitted: File Number: 0008172792 TCNS Number: 169882 Purpose: New Tower Submission Packet Notification Date: 7AM EST 04/16/2018 Applicant: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Consultant: Trileaf Corporation Positive Train Control Filing Subject to Expedited Treatment Under Program Comment: No Site Name: Naples Park North, FL Site Address: Benton Road Detailed Description of Project: Legal Description: S25 T49S R27E Site Coordinates: 26-10-45.0 N, 81-34-17.2 W City: Naples County: COLLIER State:FL Lead SHPO/THPO: Florida Division of Historical Resources Consultant Contact Information: Name: Trileaf Corporation Title: Principal Investigator PO Box: Address: 1205 Johnson Ferry Road Suite 136 City: Marietta State: GA Zip: 30068 Phone:314-997-6111 Fax: Email: j.reagan@trileaf.com NOTICE OF FRAUDULENT USE OF SYSTEM, ABUSE OF PASSWORD AND RELATED MISUSE Use of the Section 106 system is intended to facilitate consultation under Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act and may contain information that is confidential, privileged or otherwise protected from disclosure under applicable laws. Any person having access to Section 106 information shall use it only for its intended purpose. Appropriate action will be taken with respect to any misuse of the system. FLORIDA DEPARTMENT Of STATE RICK SCOTT Governor Mr. Jackson Reagan Trileaf Corporation 1051 Winderley Place, Suite 201 Maitland, Florida 32751 RE: DHR Project File No.: 2018-1883 / Received by DHR: April 16, 2018 Federal Communication Commission / Trileaf # 637639 Naples Park North / Client #FL114 220 Foot Tall Guyed Communications Tower Benton Road, Naples, Collier County, Florida Mr. Reagan: KEN DETZNER Secretary of State May 16, 2018 Our office reviewed the referenced project for possible impact to historic properties listed, or eligible for listing, in the National Register of Historic Places. The review was conducted in accordance with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966, as amended, 36 CFR Part 800: Protection of Historic Properties, and the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969, as amended. Based on the information provided and a review of our records, this office concurs that the proposed undertakings will have no direct effects and no visual effects on historic properties. For any questions concerning our comments, please contact Robin Jackson, Historic Preservationist, Compliance and Review, by electronic mail at robin.iackson(i�dos.myflorida.com, or at 850.245.6496, or 800.847.7278. Sincerely, Timothy A. Parsons, Ph.D. Director, Division of Historical Resources and State Historic Preservation Officer Division of Historical Resources� R.A. Gray Building • 500 South Bronough Street- Tallahassee, Florida 32399�gy�/-4 850.245.6300 •850.245.6436 (Fax) FLHeritage.com Appendix F Native American Correspondence d w z z z z z z 8 0 ono N d' O M o � U i U � T a � w •°' o a > �° p W a° b °' ° Or, . U '6 b W y U ❑ VJ Z O asJ' U R� y a o t F a U y d � ° " � ' ° ; �� v c 3° w " � o got, — a z 0` z s ycc ° �g � a�oo ati N 3y°u'a°b � � W a N 3�0 � � W � � � CS � F4 ° ❑ U .� o 0.❑ o N z N 0 y Q y N m z.a .� V .� a°i 3 Aso oa O z.a °' N m d o 0 0 0 0 0 i o 0 o o o � 64 "d 'c� s. O a � as �n a v� a uo as i w R 0 N 0 N M 0 N M 0 N M 0 N M F p C i O W ,y e4 oo a a. O o v o s, � U U a U U O U U U w z a cc F3 0 N 0 N A N ? N N iO M M z� �F U U FL U ❑ r q T o >.14 r r 14 lag ti �C�yy 9 w 'FTy U O N Wy U O N W V� W U c�3 ' V� 4' C o O Fy O A WO F W° .: Z z a, a o. m zo. a w O yO M z a, a O, L, a�J a, O ° o B a o . b c��o 41 p F a vw z °cd C O F uo � O o U p bD O ? o ° ,U Cmm W 1 From: towernotifvinfo(5fcc.00v To: tribal Cc: tcnsweeklyCabfcc.aov Subject: NOTICE OF ORGANIZATION(S) WHICH WERE SENT PROPOSED TOWER CONSTRUCTION NOTIFICATION INFORMATION - Email ID #5701283 Date: Friday, March 30, 2018 2:03:18 AM Dear Sir or Madam: Thank you for using the Federal Communications Commission's (FCC) Tower Construction Notification System (TCNS). The purpose of this electronic mail message is to inform you that the following authorized persons were sent the information you provided through TCNS, which relates to your proposed antenna structure. The information was forwarded by the FCC to authorized TCNS users by electronic mail and/or regular mail (letter). Persons who have received the information that you provided include leaders or their designees of federally - recognized American Indian Tribes, including Alaska Native Villages (collectively "Tribal Nations"), Native Hawaiian Organizations (NHOs), and State Historic Preservation Officers (SHPOs). For your convenience in identifying the referenced Tribal Nations and NHOs and in making further contacts, the City and State of the Seat of Government for each Tribal Nation and NHO, as well as the designated contact person, is included in the listing below. We note that Tribal Nations may have Section 106 cultural interests in ancestral homelands or other locations that are far removed from their current Seat of Government. Pursuant to the Commission's rules as set forth in the Nationwide Programmatic Agreement for Review of Effects on Historic Properties for Certain Undertakings Approved by the Federal Communications Commission (NPA), all Tribal Nations and NHOs listed below must be afforded a reasonable opportunity to respond to this notification, consistent with the procedures set forth below, unless the proposed construction falls within an exclusion designated by the Tribal Nation or NHO. (NPA, Section IV.F.4). The information you provided was forwarded to the following Tribal Nations and NHOs. If a Tribal Nation or NHO does not respond within a reasonable time, you should make a reasonable effort at follow-up contact, unless the Tribal Nation or NHO has agreed to different procedures (NPA, Section IV.F.5). In the event a Tribal Nation or NHO does not respond to a follow-up inquiry, or if a substantive or procedural disagreement arises between you and a Tribal Nation or NHO, you must seek guidance from the Commission (NPA, Section IV.G). These procedures are further set forth in the FCC's Declaratory Ruling released on October 6, 2005 (FCC 05-176). 1. NAGPRA & Section 106 Representative Fred Dayhoff - Miccosukee Tribe of Indians of Florida - Tamiami Station (PO Box: 440021) Miami, FL - hopel@miccosukeetribe.com - 239-695-4360 Details: Please DO NOT contact me prior to the end of the 30-day period to inquire about the proposed site. I really need this time to review the TCNS notifications. If, however, the proposed site is on undisturbed land, and you are aware of something that may be of interest to our Tribe, please feel free to telephone me or send documentation to me prior to the end of the 30-day period. Please send this information to me via regular mail or via UPS. Please do not use Federal Express, since they deliver toa general mailbox for our Tribe. Please send via reg. mail or UPS to: Fred Dayhoff NAGPRA & Section 106 Representative Miccosukee Tribe of Indians of Florida P.O. Box 440021 Tamiami Station Miami, Florida 33144 At the end of the 30 days, ifthere is an inadvertent find during construction, IMMEDIATELY contact me at 239- 695-4360 (phone). If the number is busy, immediately send a Fax to my attention at 239-695-4344 (fax). If this is a POSITIVE TRAIN CONTROL project, please check the state master site file for any archaeological sites that may be present. If there are no archaeological sites present, you may proceed with construction immediately. If there are any archaeological sites present at the proposed site, please contact me assoon as possible. Thank you. Fred Dayhoff NAGPRA & Section 106 Representative Miccosukee Tribe of Indians of Florida (239)695-4360 If the applicant/tower builder receives no response from the Miccosukee Tribe of Indians of Florida within 30 days after notification through TCNS, the Miccosukee Tribe of Indians of Florida has no interest in participating in pre -construction review for the proposed site. The Applicant/tower builder, however, must immediately notify the Miccosukee Tribe of Indians of Florida in the event archaeological properties or human remains are discovered during construction, consistent with Section IX of the Nationwide Programmatic Agreement and applicable law. 2. Compliance Review Supervisor Bradley M Mueller - Seminole Tribe of Florida - 30290 Josie Billie Hwy PMB 1004 Clewiston, FL - bradleymueller@semtribe.com - 863-983-6549 (ext: 12245) Details: The Seminole Tribe of Florida - Tribal Historic Preservation Office has revised its FCC TCNS project assessment policy effective August 22, 2017. The full policy text does not fit within this sites allotted space but can be found at htip:Hstofthpo.com/STOF-FCC-TCNS-Policy_pd£ We strongly urge all contractors, consultants, and applicants to read the new policy since it includes changes to fees charged for some types of reviews and provides a new email address for contacting us. Thank you. If the applicant/tower builder receives no response from the Seminole Tribe of Florida within 30 days after notification through TCNS, the Seminole Tribe of Florida has no interest in participating in pre -construction review for the proposed site. The Applicant/tower builder, however, must immediately notify the Seminole Tribe of Florida in the event archaeological properties or human remains are discovered during construction, consistent with Section IX of the Nationwide Programmatic Agreement and applicable law. 3. Historic Preservation Officer Theodore Isham - Seminole Nation of Oklahoma - (PO Box: 1498) Wewoka, OK - isham.t@sno-nsn.gov - 405-234-5218 Details: If the Applicant/tower builder receives no response from the Seminole Nation of Oklahoma within 30 days after notification through TCNS, the Seminole Nation of Oklahoma has no interest in participating in pre - construction review for the site. The Applicant/tower builder, however, must IMMEDIATELY notify the Seminole Nation of Oklahoma in the event archaeological properties or human remains are discovered during construction, consistent with Section IX of the Nationwide Programmatic Agreement and applicable law. 4. TCNS Coordinator Anne Edwards -Martel Ms - Muscogee (Creek) Nation - Highway 75 & Loop 56 (PO Box: 580) Okmulgee, OK - mcntcns@mcn-nsn.gov; section106@mcn-nsn.gov - 918-732-7639 Details: PLEASE NOTE OUR NEW REQUIREMENTS: Because the TCNS Details do not provide enough information for us to conduct a proper assessment on behalf of the Muscogee (Creek) Nation, we, instead, require that you submit with your original notification via regular postal mail or other parcel carrier the following (E- MAILED DOCUMENTATION WILL NOT BE ACCEPTED, NO EXCEPTIONS): 1) 620/621 forms 2) Colored photographs (no thumbnails please) 3) Aerial Map and color USGS topographic maps that clearly show the proposed site location, area of potential effect, shovel tests, access roads, utility easements, list of previously known archaeological sites within one mile of site and any information pertaining to project 4) Copy of archaeological assessment/survey including site forms of all sites within 1 mile of the project area 5) All pages of project to be on 8 1/2 x 11 or larger, maps must be at minimum 8 1/2 x 11 or larger 6) Need to send copy of all information pertaining to project on CD as well as a hard copy 7) A copy of review letter from the State Historic Preservation Office 8) Submit payment along with project EFFECTIVE O1/01/2016 PLEASE NOTE OUR NEW REVIEW FEES: Our administrative review fee for 106 reviews is $800.00 for all new, collocations, addendums, and Positive Train Control. Please submit check with hard copyand CD copy. Upon receipt of all information outlined above, which requires the completed 620/621 form and receipt of the administrative review fee, the Section 106 30-day reviewprocess will begin. If you do not receive a response within 30 days from the date our office receives complete 620/621 packet and payment, please contact us by phone to confirm review status. Please submit required information and payment to address below: Muscogee (Creek) Nation Historic and Cultural PreservationDepartment Ms Corain Lowe-Zepeda, TCNS Coordinator P.O. Box 580 Hwy 75 & Loop 56 Okmulgee, OK 74447 For specific information regarding TCNS, please contact Ms. Corain Lowe-Zepeda, TCNS Coordinator, directly at 918-732-7835 or Ms. RaeLynn Butler, THPO at 918-732-7678. Thank you. Sincerely, Ms. Corain Lowe-Zepeda, TCNS Coordinator Muscogee (Creek) Nation 918-732-7835 clowe@mcn-nsn.gov 5. TCNS Coordinator Travis Patton - Eastern Shawnee Tribe of Oklahoma - 70500 East 128 Road Wyandotte, OK - tpatton@estoo.net - 918-666-2435 (ext: 1860) Details: The Cultural Preservation Office of the Eastern Shawnee Tribe of Oklahoma requires the following information and fees regarding all proposed FCC projects. Please do not email documentation; it will be deleted without being opened. Mail one printed color copy of all documentation to: 70500 E 128 Rd. Wyandotte, OK 74370 Please submit by US postal mail or other parcel carrier all of the following information for all FCC projects: 1. A 1-page cover letter with the following information: a) TCNS number b) Company name c) Project name, city, county, state d) Project type e) UTM coordinates using WGS84 (G1150) f) Total area surveyed in acres g) Contact information. 2. Professional cultural/archaeological resource survey report. 3. Aerial and color USGS topographic maps locating project area within the state, county, and local area. 4. Aerial, color USGS topographic, or planimetric maps locating tower site, APE, access road, utility easement,guy wire locations surveyed, surveyed staging areas, and known archaeological/historic sites. 5. Project site plan map depicting labeled shovel test locations. 6. Shovel test log. 7. Site photographs. 8. A copy of the review letter or TCNS e-response from the State Historic Preservation Office and all other state -mandated review offices for projects involving ground disturbance. 9. Please submit a fee of $550.00 per/TCNS project, for administration, data processing, handling, research and review. Make the check payable to the Eastern Shawnee Tribe of Oklahoma. On the memo line write all TCNS numbers. This includes new build towers, collocations, PTC poles, and projects in previously disturbed locations. 1 O.The Eastern Shawnee procedure document is available by email and is highly recommended for guidance. Send an email to Travis Patton at: tpatton@estoo.net. 6. THPO Terry Clouthier - Thlopthlocco Tribal Town - P.O. Box 188 Okemah, OK - thpo@tttown.org; thlopthloccotribaltowntowers@gmail.com - 918-560-6113 Details: Thlopthlocco Tribal Town is requesting consulting party status on any proposed projects, actions or undertakings that the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) undertakes in our Area of Historic Interest. All initial notifications for any actions, projects or undertakings must be sent through the Tower Construction Notification System (TCNS) as this is our preferred preference consistent with Section IV.D of the Nationwide Programmatic Agreement (NPA) of 2004 as an efficient and thorough means of making initial contact or notification and is to be considered "best practice" consistent with Section IV.J and that the FCC must encourage applicants to follow it and not attempt to circumvent it. While it is acceptable to submit the review material electronically, it is not acceptable to initially contact or notify Thlopthlocco Tribal Town independently of the TCNS program as our participation within that program through defining our areas of interest inherently implies that we wish to be notified using that same program and that implication is hereby confirmed with this statement. Any initial notifications for any actions, projects or undertakings submitted by the Federal Communications Commission or an applicant acting on their behalf consistent with the NPA which is not sent through the TCNS program to Thlopthlocco Tribal Town will be returned to sender and will not be considered submitted. Alternatively, Thlopthlocco Tribal Town reserves the right to inform the FCC or applicant to review our submission requirements through the TCNS program and that as the current submission did not follow those directions it is not considered submitted nor will it be considered a reasonable or good faith effort to contact or notify Thlopthlocco Tribal Town as required under Section 106 and the NPA. As a contractor, you are aware of expenses that are incurred to provide your professional services. The Thlopthlocco Tribal Town is also being asked to provide a professional service and therefore,should be compensatedfor their expertise. Our fee is $800.00 per site. You will receive an invoice, and review will commence upon receipt of both the payment and the review materials. Payments should include the TCNS number(s) on the memo, and should be mailed to Thlopthlocco Tribal Town, c/o Finley & Cook,Attn: Jeanie Willis, 601 N. Broadway, Shawnee,OK 74801 Airfare, mileage, per diem and lodging, plus any unanticipated costs must be paid for by the Cell Tower Contractor or applicant for any tribal representatives who have to travel to one or multiple site areas should it be deemed necessary by Thlopthlocco Tribal Town. Form 620 or 621 are required for reviews to be completed, as well as archeology reports. Any site maps, previous archeological surveys,findings, photographs,etc., are required for review, andsent via email to thlopthloccotribaltowntowers@gmail.com with a CC to thpo@tttown.org. Please indicate the TCNS number in the subject line of the email. DO NOT SEND PAPER COPIES WITH YOUR CHECK, as they will NOT be received by the THPO or TCNSconsultant. Documents sent directly to theTHPO via US mail will be returned to sender and are not considered to be submitted. Please follow the instructions in TCNS relating to accepted submissions. CO -LOCATIONS andall other undertakings being placed on EXISTING structures must include information regarding date and determination of previous Section 106 review for the structure as part of the requested review materials. In addition, co -locations must clearly indicate number of existing FCC undertakings (antennae, nodes, etc.) on the structure. Towers or structures being used for collocations that have not been subject to previous Section 106 review and concurrence will be treated as if it is a new tower construction and applicable fees and review time will be necessary. PLEASE refrain from checking on the status of projects which are NOT overdue (30 days per law). However, if projects reviews are believed to have not been received and it past the 30 day mark of receiving materials AND payment, please FIRST log into TCNS to check for response, and SECOND contact the tribe to work together to resolve the issue. If the project is NOT over 30 days, please refrain from checking on status UNLESS there is a public emergency or some extraordinary circumstance you feel may need special attention. The Applicant or construction personnel, must immediately notify the Thlopthlocco Tribal Town in the event historic properties or human remains are discovered before, during or after construction, consistent with Section IX of the Nationwide Programmatic Agreement and applicable law. Thlopthlocco Tribal Town can be reached at thpo@tttown.org in such an event. The information you provided was also forwarded to the following SHPOs in the State in which you propose to construct and neighboring States. The information was provided to these SHPOs as a courtesy for their information and planning. You need make no effort at this time to follow up with any SHPO that does not respond to this notification. Prior to construction, you must provide the SHPO of the State in which you propose to construct (or the Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, if the project will be located on certain Tribal lands), with a Submission Packet pursuant to Section VII.A of the NPA. 7. SHPO Lee Warner - Alabama Historical Commission - 468 South Perry Street Montgomery, AL - lwarner@mail.preserveala.org - 334-242-3184 8. Deputy SHPO Elizabeth Ann Brown - Alabama Historical Commission - 468 South Perry Street Montgomery, AL - ebrown@mail.preserveala.org - 334-242-3185 9. Deputy SHPO Compliance Review Laura A Kammerer - Div of Historical Resources, Dept of State - 500 S. Bronough St. Tallahassee, FL - lammerer@dos.state.fl.us - 850-245-6333 10. Historic Preservationist Robin Jackson - Florida Division of Historical Resources - 500 S. Bronough Street Tallahasse, FL - Robin.Jackson@DOS.myflorida.com - 850-245-6333 "Exclusions" above set forth language provided by the Tribal Nation or SHPO. These exclusions may indicate types of PTC wayside pole notifications that the Tribal Nation or SHPO does not wish to review. TCNS automatically forwards all notifications to all Tribal Nations and SHPOs that have an expressed interest in the geographic area of a proposal. However, if a proposal falls within a designated exclusion, you need not expect any response and need not pursue any additional process with that Tribal Nation or SHPO. Exclusions may also set forth policies or procedures of a particular Tribal Nation or SHPO (for example, types of information that a Tribal Nation routinely requests, or a policy that no response within 30 days indicates no interest in participating in pre -construction review). Please be advised that the FCC cannot guarantee that the contact(s) listed above opened and reviewed an electronic or regular mail notification. If you learn any of the above contact information is no longer valid, please contact the FCC. The following information relating to the proposed tower was forwarded to the person(s) listed above: Notification Received: 03/27/2018 Notification ID: 169882 Tower Owner Individual or Entity Name: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Consultant Name: Mindi L Okai Street Address: 10845 Olive Blvd. Suite 260 City: St. Louis State: MISSOURI Zip Code: 63141 Phone: 314-997-6111 Email: tribal@trileaf.com Structure Type: GTOWER - Guyed Structure Used for Communication Purposes Latitude: 26 deg 10 min 45.0 sec N Longitude: 81 deg 34 min 17.2 sec W Location Description: Benton Road City: Naples State: FLORIDA County: COLLIER Detailed Description of Project: Legal Description: S25 T49S R27E Ground Elevation: 3.7 meters Support Structure: 67.1 meters above ground level Overall Structure: 67.1 meters above ground level Overall Height AMSL: 70.8 meters above mean sea level If you have any questions or comments regarding this notice, please contact the FCC using the electronic mail form located on the FCC's website at: hM27//wireless.fcc.gov/outreach/notification/contact-fcc.htmi. You may also call the FCC Support Center at (877) 480-3201 (TTY 717-338-2824). Hours are from 8 a.m. to 7:00 p.m. Eastern Time, Monday through Friday (except Federal holidays). To provide quality service and ensure security, all telephone calls are recorded. Thank you, Federal Communications Commission From: towernotifyinfoPfcc.gov To: tribal Subject: Reply to Proposed Tower Structure (Notification ID: 169882) - Email ID #5708753 Date: Monday, April 02, 2018 8:34:29 AM Dear Mindi L Okai, Thank you for using the Federal Communications Commission's (FCC) Tower Construction Notification System (TCNS). The purpose of this email is to inform you that an authorized user of the TCNS has replied to a proposed tower construction notification that you had submitted through the TONS. The following message has been sent to you from TCNS Coordinator Travis Patton of the Eastern Shawnee Tribe of Oklahoma in reference to Notification ID #169882: The Cultural Preservation Office of the Eastern Shawnee Tribe of Oklahoma requires the following information and fees regarding all proposed FCC projects. Please do not email documentation; it will be deleted without being opened. Mail one printed color copy of all documentation to address: 70500 E. 128 Rd. Wyandotte, OK 74370 Please submit by US postal mail or other parcel carrier all of the following information for all telecommunication projects: 1. Please provide a 1-page cover letter with the following information: a. TCNS Number b. Company Name c. Project Name, City, County, State d. Project type e. Project coordinates f. Total area surveyed in acres g. Contact information. 2. Professional cultural/archaeological resource survey report. 3. Aerial and/or USGS topographic maps showing general project location (small scale). 4. Aerial, color USGS topographic, or planimetric maps showing project area (large scale). 5. Project site plan map depicting labeled shovel test locations. 6. Shovel Test Log. 7. Site photographs. 8. A copy of the review letter or TCNS e-response from the State Historic Preservation Office and all other state -mandated review offices for projects involving ground disturbance. 9. Please submit a fee of $550.00 per TCNS project for administration, data processing, handling, research and review. Make the check payable to the Eastern Shawnee Tribe of Oklahoma. On the memo line write all TCNS numbers. The fee is $550 for all projects (new -builds, collocations, PTC poles, and projects in previously disturbed locations). We request the opportunity to review and comment on scopes of work for projects whose purpose is to evaluate or mitigate archaeological sites discovered during a telecom project survey, and we also request to review the final reports for those projects. NOTE: The 30 day review period begins when we, The Eastern Shawnee Tribe of Oklahoma, receive ALL required documentation for the TCNS submittal, not when it is sent out. If you have any question on a TCNS project and its review time please email Travis Patton at: tpatton@estoo.net. The Eastern Shawnee Procedures document is available by email and is highly recommended for guidance. Send an email to Travis Patton at: tpatton@estoo.net. For your convenience, the information you submitted for this notification is detailed below. Notification Received: 03/27/2018 Notification ID: 169882 Tower Owner Individual or Entity Name: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Consultant Name: Mindi L Okai Street Address: 10845 Olive Blvd. Suite 260 City: St. Louis State: MISSOURI Zip Code: 63141 Phone: 314-997-6111 Email: tribal@trileaf.com Structure Type: GTOWER - Guyed Structure Used for Communication Purposes Latitude: 26 deg 10 min 45.0 sec N Longitude: 81 deg 34 min 17.2 sec W Location Description: Benton Road City: Naples State: FLORIDA County: COLLIER Detailed Description of Project: Legal Description: S25 T49S R27E Ground Elevation: 3.7 meters Support Structure: 67.1 meters above ground level Overall Structure: 67.1 meters above ground level Overall Height AMSL: 70.8 meters above mean sea level T440 TRILEAF ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING 10845 Olive Boulevard, Suite 260, Saint Louis, Missouri 63141 •314.997.6111 www.trileafcom May 17, 2018 Eastern Shawnee Tribe of Oklahoma Mr. Travis Patton Cultural Preservation Department 70500 East 128 Road Wyandotte, OK 74370 RE: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC — Naples Park North, FL / Client #FL114 — Trileaf Project #637639 Benton Road, Naples, Florida 34117 Collier County, Belle Meade NE Quadrangle (USGS) Latitude: 26' 10' 44.98" N, Longitude: 81 ° 34' 17.21" W UTM Zone: 17R 442897mE 2895650mN Survey area: 0.13 acres TCNS# 169882; Legal Description: Section: 25, Township: 49S, Range: 27E Dear Mr. Patton: This project was originally submitted to your tribe via TCNS on March 30, 2018; TCNS #169882. Trileaf Corporation is in the process of completing a NEPA Review at the above referenced property. Our investigation includes determining if the site is contained in, on, or within the viewshed of a building, site, district, structure or object, significant in American history, architecture, archeology, engineering or culture, that is listed or eligible for listing on the State or National Registers of Historic Places, or located in or on, or within the viewshed of an Indian Religious Site. Trileaf has learned your tribe has an interest in property located within this County. Our client proposes to construct a raw land -new build 220-foot guyed communications tower. The proposed tower will be located within a 3,600-square-foot lease area. The project includes an access/utility easement, measuring_ approximately 20 feet wide, which extends approximately 100 feet west away from the lease area to connect with Benton Road. In addition, the proposed tower will be supported by three (3) M anchors that extend approximately 122 feet northwest, east, and southwest from the tower center. Currently, the site habitat consists of a grass and tree -covered area. The site location maps and photos are enclosed for your reference. The review fee and the SHPO response are also enclosed. Please let us know if you have any objections or comments on this project as soon as possible. Please call me at (314) 997-6111 or email m.okaigtrileaf.com or tribal(c-r�,trilea£com if you need additional information or have any questions. Thank you for your assistance in this regard. Sincerely, Mindi Okai Tribal Consultation Manager 2�P.0 O%VB TRIe4t EA TERN SHA TRIBE e� 9 h 4 OF OKLA A 12755 S. 705 Road, Wyandotte, OK 74370 17 Bluejacket Building (918) 666-2435, Fax: 888-971-3905 Trileaf ATTN: Mindi Okai 10845 Olive Boulevard, Suite 260 St. Louis, MO 63141 RE: Cell Tower Project Naples Park North, FL, Naples, Collier County, FL TCNS 169882 June 14, 2018 Dear Ms. Okai, The Cultural Preservation Department of the Eastern Shawnee Tribe of Oklahoma (ESTO) has received the documentation for Trileaf's proposed telecommunications project, Naples Park North, FL, located at UTM Zone 17, 442897 m E, 2895650 m N (WGS84) in/near Naples in Collier County, FL. ESTO has reviewed the project, TCNS 169882, in accordance with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA). Based on the information provided and a review of our records, we find that No Historic Properties of sacred and/or cultural significance to the Tribe will be impacted by this project. Therefore, ESTO has no objection to the project proceeding as described; however, please note that any future changes to this project may require additional consultation. In accordance with the NHPA of 1966 (16 U.S.C. § 470-470w-6), federally funded, licensed, or permitted undertakings that are subject to the Section 106 review process must determine effects to significant historic properties. As clarified in Section 101(d)(6)(A-B), historic properties may have religious and/or cultural significance to Indian Tribes. Section 106 of NHPA requires Federal agencies to consider the effects of their actions on all significant historic properties (36 CFR Part 800) as does the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (43 U.S.C. § 4321-4347 and 40 CFR § 1501.7(a). This letter evidences NHPA and NEPA historic properties compliance pertaining to consultation with this Tribe in regard to the proposed project referenced as Naples Park North, FL, TCNS 169882. However, if during construction cultural objects or human remains are inadvertently discovered, please stop work immediately and contact the Cultural Preservation Department of the Eastern Shawnee Tribe of Oklahoma. Thank you for consulting with the Eastern Shawnee Tribe of Oklahoma. 'O a..l.L..�' - &'� , Glenna J. Wallace Chief Eastern Shawnee Tribe of Oklahoma FOR QUESTIONS OR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION, PLEASE CONTACT: TRAVIS PATTON TPATTON @ ESTOO. N ET 918-666-5151 x1860 S T440 TRILEAF ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING 10845 Olive Boulevard, Suite 260, Saint Louis, Missouri 63141 •314.997.6111 www.trileafcom April 30, 2018 Muscogee Creek Nation Ms. Elizabeth Martel P.O. Box 580 Highway 75 and Loop 56 Okmulgee, OK 74447 RE: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC — Naples Park North, FL / Client #FL114 — Trileaf Project #637639 Benton Road, Naples, Florida 34117 Collier County, Belle Meade NE Quadrangle (USGS) Latitude: 26' 10' 44.98" N, Longitude: 81 ° 34' 17.21" W UTM Zone: 17R 442897mE 2895650mN Survey area: 0.13 acres TCNS# 169882; Legal Description: Section: 25, Township: 49S, Range: 27E Dear Ms. Martel: This project was originally submitted to your tribe via TCNS on March 30, 2018; TCNS #169882. Trileaf Corporation is in the process of completing a NEPA Review at the above referenced property. Our investigation includes determining if the site is contained in, on, or within the viewshed of a building, site, district, structure or object, significant in American history, architecture, archeology, engineering or culture, that is listed or eligible for listing on the State or National Registers of Historic Places, or located in or on, or within the viewshed of an Indian Religious Site. Trileaf has learned your tribe has an interest in property located within this County. Our client proposes to construct a raw land -new build 220-foot guyed communications tower. The proposed tower will be located within a 3,600-square-foot lease area. The project includes an access/utility easement, measuring approximately 20 feet wide, which extends approximately 100 feet west away from the lease area to connect with Benton Road. In addition, the proposed tower will be supported by three (3) gay anchors that extend approximately 122 feet northwest, east, and southwest from the tower center. Currently, the site habitat consists of a grass and tree -covered area. The Form 620/621, site location maps and photos are enclosed for your reference. The review fee along with a CD of the project is also enclosed. Please let us know if you have any objections or comments on this project as soon as possible. Please call me at (314) 997-6111 or email m.okaigtrileaf.com or tribal(c-r�,trilea£com if you need additional information or have any questions. Thank you for your assistance in this regard. Sincerely, -'d Mindi Okai Tribal Consultation Manager Muscogee (Creek) Nation of Oklahoma Historical and Cultural Preservation June 19, 2018 Mindi Okai Trileaf 10845 Olive Boulevard Suite 260 Saint Louis, MO 63141 RE: TCNS #169882 Capital Telecom Holdings Benton Road Naples, Collier County, FL Dear Ms. Okai, In keeping with the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA)d, and Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA), 36 CFR Part 800, this letter is to acknowledge that the Muscogee (Creek) Nation has received notice of the proposed construction of a 220 ft. guyed communications tower at the above referenced location. After reviewing all pertinent information and our records, at this time we are currently unaware of any historic cultural, religious or sacred sites at this exact location. Therefore, we recommend a finding of "No Historic Properties in APE" for the proposed undertaking. Furthermore, due to the historic presence of our people in the project area, inadvertent discoveries of human remains and related NAGPRA items may occur, even in areas of existing or prior development. Should this occur, we request all work cease and the Muscogee (Creek) Nation and other appropriate agencies be notified immediately. Should further information or comment be required please do not hesitate to contact me at (918) 732-7639, fax: (918) 758-0649, or by e-mail: emartel(kmcn-nsn.gov. Sincerely, Anne Edwards -Martel, TCNS Coordinator Muscogee (Creek) Nation Historic and Cultural Preservation Muscogee (Creek) Nation Tribal Complex Highway 75 & Loop 56 • P.O. Box 58o • Okmulgee, OK74447 Phone: 918-732-7733 • Fax: 918-758-o649 • Web: www.muscogeenation-nsn.gov From: towernotifyinfo@fcc.gov To: Idm Cc: tcns.fccarchive(o fcc.gov; isham.t(o sno-nsn.gov Subject: Reply to Proposed Tower Structure (Notification ID: 169882) - Email ID #5716481 Date: Wednesday, April 4, 2018 9:01:37 AM Dear Mindi L Okai, Thank you for using the Federal Communications Commission's (FCC) Tower Construction Notification System (TCNS). The purpose of this email is to inform you that an authorized user of the TCNS has replied to a proposed tower construction notification that you had submitted through the TONS. The following message has been sent to you from Historic Preservation Officer Theodore Isham of the Seminole Nation of Oklahoma in reference to Notification ID #169882: The Seminole Nation of Oklahoma has an interest in this site and would like the applicant to contact us to begin the review process. The SNO reserves the right to review this project. ****NEW***** Reply to the website at https://sno-nsn.tcnsportal.com and register your name. Once registered, you will be able to submit all of the documents there. If you have any question you can send an email to Theodore Isham at isham.t@sno-nsn.gov The Seminole Nation of Oklahoma would like at the very least these items sent to us via the website ht n - nsn.tcnsportal.com which will handle all aspects of the review. We would like to see via email, a map and something such as a an aerial view as taken using Google Earth, either the Form 620 or 621, a cultural resource report prepared by a CRM firm and that included a site visit or records review by a qualified archaeologist. Also, SNO requests the state's site file listing of not only the eligible sites nearby but also all other listed sites (even not -eligible) that are nearby the project. (0.5 mile radius) A review fee set forth by the Seminole Nation Tribal Council of $800.00 is due upon notice of intent to review a project and is to mailed separately. Review Fee will be Mailed to: Sherri D Little Seminole Nation of Oklahoma Treasurer 36645 Hwy 270, for fed ex or PO Box 1498 Wewoka, OK 74884 Thank you for your quick response and as soon as all items are received we will complete the review as timely as possible. hM2s:Hsno-nsn.tcnsl2ortal.com Theodore Isham SNO HPO 405-234-5218 For your convenience, the information you submitted for this notification is detailed below. Notification Received: 03/27/2018 Notification ID: 169882 Tower Owner Individual or Entity Name: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Consultant Name: Mindi L Okai Street Address: 10845 Olive Blvd. Suite 260 City: St. Louis State: MISSOURI Zip Code: 63141 Phone: 314-997-6111 Email: tribal@trileaf.com Structure Type: GTOWER - Guyed Structure Used for Communication Purposes Latitude: 26 deg 10 min 45.0 sec N Longitude: 81 deg 34 min 17.2 sec W Location Description: Benton Road City: Naples State: FLORIDA County: COLLIER Detailed Description of Project: Legal Description: S25 T49S R27E Ground Elevation: 3.7 meters Support Structure: 67.1 meters above ground level Overall Structure: 67.1 meters above ground level Overall Height AMSL: 70.8 meters above mean sea level T440 TRILEAF ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING 10845 Olive Boulevard, Suite 260, Saint Louis, Missouri 63141 •314.997.6111 www.trileafcom April 30, 2018 Seminole Nation of Oklahoma Mr. Theodore Isham P.O. Box 1498 Wewoka, OK 74884 RE: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC — Naples Park North, FL / Client #FL114 — Trileaf Project #637639 Benton Road, Naples, Florida 34117 Collier County, Belle Meade NE Quadrangle (USGS) Latitude: 26' 10' 44.98" N, Longitude: 81° 34' 17.21" W UTM Zone: 17R 442897mE 2895650mN Survey area: 0.13 acres TCNS# 169882; Legal Description: Section: 25, Township: 49S, Range: 27E Dear Mr. Isham: This project was originally submitted to your tribe via TCNS on March 30, 2018; TCNS #169882. Trileaf Corporation is in the process of completing a NEPA Review at the above referenced property. Our investigation includes determining if the site is contained in, on, or within the viewshed of a building, site, district, structure or object, significant in American history, architecture, archeology, engineering or culture, that is listed or eligible for listing on the State or National Registers of Historic Places, or located in or on, or within the viewshed of an Indian Religious Site. Trileaf has learned your tribe has an interest in property located within this County. Our client proposes to construct a raw land -new build 220-foot guyed communications tower. The proposed tower will be located within a 3,600-square-foot lease area. The project includes an access/utility easement, measuring approximately 20 feet wide, which extends approximately 100 feet west away from the lease area to connect with Benton Road. In addition, the proposed tower will be supported by three (3) M anchors that extend approximately 122 feet northwest, east, and southwest from the tower center. Currently, the site habitat consists of a grass and tree -covered area. The Form 620/621, site location maps and photos are enclosed for your reference. The review fee is in the mail. Please let us know if you have any objections or comments on this project as soon as possible. Please call me at (314) 997-6111 or email m.okaiktrilea£com or tribalktrilea£com if you need additional information or have any questions. Thank you for your assistance in this regard. Sincerely, '/U . 6 Mindi Okai Tribal Consultation Manager From: towernotifyinfo@fcc.gov To: tribal Cc: tcns.fccarchive(o fcc.gov; isham.t(o sno-nsn.gov Subject: Reply to Proposed Tower Structure (Notification ID: 169882) - Email ID #5731754 Date: Friday, April 13, 2018 4:11:00 PM Dear Mindi L Okai, Thank you for using the Federal Communications Commission's (FCC) Tower Construction Notification System (TCNS). The purpose of this email is to inform you that an authorized user of the TCNS has replied to a proposed tower construction notification that you had submitted through the TONS. The following message has been sent to you from Historic Preservation Officer Theodore Isham of the Seminole Nation of Oklahoma in reference to Notification ID #169882: This Opinion is being provided by Seminole Nation of Oklahoma's Cultural Advisor, pursuant to authority vested by the Seminole Nation of Oklahoma General Council. The Seminole Nation of Oklahoma is an independently Federally -Recognized Indian Nation headquartered in Wewoka, OK. In keeping with the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA)d, and Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA), 36 CFR Part 800, this letter is to acknowledge that the Seminole Nation of Oklahoma has received notice of the proposed construction of a wireless telecommunications tower and at the above mentioned location. After reviewing all pertinent information and our records, at this time we are unaware of any historic, cultural, religious or sacred sites at this exact location. Therefore, we recommend a finding of "No Historic Properties Affected" for the proposed undertaking. The Seminole Nation of Oklahoma has no objection to the proposed construction of: TCNS# 169882 Furthermore, due to the historic presence of our people in the project area, inadvertent discoveries of human remains and related NAGPRA items may occur, even in areas of existing or prior development. Should this occur we request all work cease and the Seminole Nation of Oklahoma and other appropriate agencies be immediately notified. It is the duty of the agency official to "acknowledge that Indian tribes and Native Hawaiian organizations possess special expertise in assessing the eligibility of historic properties that may possess religious and cultural significance to them." As a contractor, you are aware of expenses that are incurred to provide your professional services. The Seminole Nation of Oklahoma is also being asked to provide a professional service and therefore, should be compensated for their expertise. Our fee of $800.00 per site. If tribal representatives should have to travel to the site area, mileage, per diem and lodging, should be paid for by the Cell Tower Contractor. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me at (405) 234-5218 or by e-mail at isham.t@sno-nsn.gov. Thank you for your time and cooperation in this matter. Invoice By performing this preliminary cultural site assessment, The Seminole Nation of Oklahoma is providing a professional service, and therefore, must be compensated. As the contractor, you are cognizant of various expenses that are typically incurred in order to provide this type of professional service and opinion. Our review fee of $800.00 per Tower, per site for new construction and $800.00 for co -located construction will be sufficient to cover our time and expenses. Thank you for your cooperation. Should you have any questions about this opinion, release or invoice, please contact HPO Theodore Isham at Seminole Nation of Oklahoma (405)257-7203, or by e-mail isham.t@sno-nsn.gov . Payment of this invoice should be made by check and be addressed and sent to the following mailing address: Review Fee will be Mailed to: Sherri D Little Seminole Nation of Oklahoma Treasurer 36645 Hwy 270, for FedEx or PO Box 1498 Wewoka, OK 74884 For your convenience, the information you submitted for this notification is detailed below. Notification Received: 03/27/2018 Notification ID: 169882 Tower Owner Individual or Entity Name: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Consultant Name: Mindi L Okai Street Address: 10845 Olive Blvd. Suite 260 City: St. Louis State: MISSOURI Zip Code: 63141 Phone: 314-997-6111 Email: tribal@trileaf.com Structure Type: GTOWER - Guyed Structure Used for Communication Purposes Latitude: 26 deg 10 min 45.0 sec N Longitude: 81 deg 34 min 17.2 sec W Location Description: Benton Road City: Naples State: FLORIDA County: COLLIER Detailed Description of Project: Legal Description: S25 T49S R27E Ground Elevation: 3.7 meters Support Structure: 67.1 meters above ground level Overall Structure: 67.1 meters above ground level Overall Height AMSL: 70.8 meters above mean sea level From: towernotifyinfoCalfcc.gov To: tribal Cc: tcns.fccarchive(ofcc.gov; brad leymuellerCalsemtribe.com Subject: Reply to Proposed Tower Structure (Notification ID: 169882) - Email ID #5704761 Date: Wednesday, March 28, 2018 3:04:16 PM Dear Mindi L Okai, Thank you for using the Federal Communications Commission's (FCC) Tower Construction Notification System (TCNS). The purpose of this email is to inform you that an authorized user of the TCNS has replied to a proposed tower construction notification that you had submitted through the TONS. The following message has been sent to you from Compliance Review Supervisor Bradley M Mueller of the Seminole Tribe of Florida in reference to Notification ID #169882: The Seminole Tribe of Florida - Tribal Historic Preservation Office has revised its FCC TCNS project assessment policy effective January 23, 2018. The full policy text does not fit within this sites allotted space but can be found at hhU://stofthpo.com/STOF-FCC-TCNS-Policy_pdf. We strongly urge all contractors, consultants, and applicants to read the new policy since it includes changes to fees charged for some types of reviews and provides a new email address for contacting us. Thank you. For your convenience, the information you submitted for this notification is detailed below. Notification Received: 03/27/2018 Notification ID: 169882 Tower Owner Individual or Entity Name: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Consultant Name: Mindi L Okai Street Address: 10845 Olive Blvd. Suite 260 City: St. Louis State: MISSOURI Zip Code: 63141 Phone: 314-997-6111 Email: tribal@trileaf.com Structure Type: GTOWER - Guyed Structure Used for Communication Purposes Latitude: 26 deg 10 min 45.0 sec N Longitude: 81 deg 34 min 17.2 sec W Location Description: Benton Road City: Naples State: FLORIDA County: COLLIER Detailed Description of Project: Legal Description: S25 T49S R27E Ground Elevation: 3.7 meters T440 TRILEAF ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING 10845 Olive Boulevard, Suite 260, Saint Louis, Missouri 63141 •314.997.6111 www.trileafcom April 30, 2018 Seminole Tribe of Florida Mr. Bradley Mueller Accounts Receivable 6300 Stirling Road Hollywood, FL 33024 RE: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC — Naples Park North, FL / Client #FL114 — Trileaf Project #637639 Benton Road, Naples, Florida 34117 Collier County, Belle Meade NE Quadrangle (USGS) Latitude: 26' 10' 44.98" N, Longitude: 81 ° 34' 17.21" W UTM Zone: 17R 442897mE 2895650mN Survey area: 0.13 acres TONS# 169882; Legal Description: Section: 25, Township: 49S, Range: 27E Dear Mr. Mueller: This project was originally submitted to your tribe via TCNS on March 30, 2018; TCNS #169882. Trileaf Corporation is in the process of completing a NEPA Review at the above referenced property. Our investigation includes determining if the site is contained in, on, or within the viewshed of a building, site, district, structure or object, significant in American history, architecture, archeology, engineering or culture, that is listed or eligible for listing on the State or National Registers of Historic Places, or located in or on, or within the viewshed of an Indian Religious Site. Trileaf has learned your tribe has an interest in property located within this County. Our client proposes to construct a raw land -new build 220-foot guyed communications tower. The proposed tower will be located within a 3,600-square-foot lease area. The project includes an access/utility easement, measuring approximately 20 feet wide, which extends approximately 100 feet west away from the lease area to connect with Benton Road. In addition, the proposed tower will be supported by three (3) M anchors that extend approximately 122 feet northwest, east, and southwest from the tower center. Currently, the site habitat consists of a grass and tree -covered area. The Form 620/621, site location maps and photos are enclosed for your reference. The review fee is in the mail. Please let us know if you have any objections or comments on this project as soon as possible. Please call me at (314) 997-6111 or email m.okaigtrileaf.com or tribal(c-r�,trilea£com if you need additional information or have any questions. Thank you for your assistance in this regard. Sincerely, -'d Mindi Okai Tribal Consultation Manager From: Bernard Howard To: Mindi Okai Subject: TCNS # 169882 (Naples, Collier County, Florida) — Project Assessment Date: Thursday, May 31, 2018 12:58:32 PM Attachments: imaae005.rna SEMiNOLE TRIBE OF FLORIDA TRIBAL HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICE AH-T H-THt-KI MU$FUM 7 WMAk METOWC • pfES�NYhl 14N O&TI CIE 6t: V104t L T Rralt Or FibRipA ^r1.fAr+-Tw-RJ MU!lLdm 34r745 PhIC OILL1N r ONAVA• "a 7QW C.ktgY'11PTo0J. h{ 9190n 1141PG 1Fn9>%t iie3r 6" h"Ip aW-P1pQ11!*IL7h} L*sjIgot.I711 rAa -hn y, �68 Lri7 r l7ra wr4�ITr W+�'+4 w#art}u11G {iti1+ Ii115CLru beCbtlT< WWW 4WIAOT HFAI-COt1 May 31, 2018 Mindi Okai Tribal Consultation Manger Trileaf 10845 Olive Blvd, Suite 260 Saint Louis, MO 63141 Phone: (314) 997-6111 Email: m.okai@trileaf.com �jr' TPIEI,%L 9rFIC;FFV- y� PAARCELLUS W OSCEOLA JR f'IR!ti iY�j..f .-K MITCHELLCYPRIE5 � + ifi.,Srt1t LAVONNE ROSE N 5LGRE IAR4 Ah ATIO'L PETER A. MAHU '1 0±_ A RU REti Subject: TCNS # 169882 (Naples, Collier County, Florida) — Project Assessment (Tribal Research and Section 106 Evaluation) Y 11W11 EJ[1I17r111YILI Mr. Okai, Thank you for contacting the Seminole Tribe of Florida — Tribal Historic Preservation Office (STOF- THPO), regarding TCNS # 169882 (Collier County, FL.) The proposed undertaking does fall within the STOF Area of Interest. We have reviewed the documents you provided and completed our project assessment in order to determine if the undertaking would affect any areas important to the Tribe. We have determined that we have no objections at this time. Please notify us if any archaeological, historical, or burial resources are inadvertently discovered during the construction process. Thank you and feel free to contact us with any questions or concerns. Best Regards, Bernard J. Howard MA, RPA Project Coordinator Tribal Historic Preservation Office Seminole Tribe of Florida Thlopthlocco Tribal Town c/o Finley & Cook Attn: Jeanie Willis 601 N. Broadway Shawnee, OK 74801 Mindi Okai Various clients 10845 Olive Blvd. Suite 260 St. Louis, MO MISSOURI 63141 INVOICE Invoice # 169882 Invoice Date 03/28/2018 Due Date 03/28/2018 Item Description Unit Price Quantity Amount TCNS Review 800.00 1.00 800.00 NOTES: PLEASE SEND ARCHEOLOGICAL REPORTS, MAPS, ETC. IF YOU HAVE NOT ATTACHED IT TO THE TCNS LISTING ASAP to: thlopthloccotribaltowntowers@gmail.com with a CC to: thpo@tttown.org Documents sent directly to the THPO via US mail will be returned to sender and are not considered to be submitted. Please follow the instructions in TCNS relating to accepted submittals. All invoices are net 30, no exceptions. If a tower has been abandoned, PLEASE NOTIFY WITHIN 7 days of filing with TCNS to avoid review and review fee. If not notified of abandonment via email to thlopthloccotribaltowntowers@gmail, review MAY take place and fee will be due and owing. PLEASE refrain from checking on status of projects which are NOT overdue (30 days per law). However, if projects reviews are believed to have not been received and it past the 30 day mark of receiving materials AND payment, please FIRST log into TCNS to check for response, and SECOND contact the tribe to work together to resolve the issue. If the project is NOT over 30 days, please refrain from checking on status UNLESS there is a public emergency or some extraordinary circumstance you feel may need special attention. Thank you. Subtotal 800.00 Total 800.00 Amount Paid 0.00 Balance Due $800.00 T440 TRILEAF ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING 10845 Olive Boulevard, Suite 260, Saint Louis, Missouri 63141 •314.997.6111 www.trileafcom April 30, 2018 Thlopthlocco Tribal Town Mr. Emman Spain P.O. Box 188 Okemah, OK 74859 RE: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC — Naples Park North, FL / Client #FL114 — Trileaf Project #637639 Benton Road, Naples, Florida 34117 Collier County, Belle Meade NE Quadrangle (USGS) Latitude: 26' 10' 44.98" N, Longitude: 81 ° 34' 17.21" W UTM Zone: 17R 442897mE 2895650mN Survey area: 0.13 acres TONS# 169882; Legal Description: Section: 25, Township: 49S, Range: 27E Dear Mr. Spain: This project was originally submitted to your tribe via TCNS on March 30, 2018; TCNS #169882. Trileaf Corporation is in the process of completing a NEPA Review at the above referenced property. Our investigation includes determining if the site is contained in, on, or within the viewshed of a building, site, district, structure or object, significant in American history, architecture, archeology, engineering or culture, that is listed or eligible for listing on the State or National Registers of Historic Places, or located in or on, or within the viewshed of an Indian Religious Site. Trileaf has learned your tribe has an interest in property located within this County. Our client proposes to construct a raw land -new build 220-foot guyed communications tower. The proposed tower will be located within a 3,600-square-foot lease area. The project includes an access/utility easement, measuring approximately 20 feet wide, which extends approximately 100 feet west away from the lease area to connect with Benton Road. In addition, the proposed tower will be supported by three (3) M anchors that extend approximately 122 feet northwest, east, and southwest from the tower center. Currently, the site habitat consists of a grass and tree -covered area. The site location maps, photos, Form 620/621 and archeological report are enclosed for your reference. The review fee for this project is in the mail. Please let us know if you have any objections or comments on this project as soon as possible. Please call me at (314) 997-6111 or email m.okaiktrilea£com or tribalktrilea£com if you need additional information or have any questions. Thank you for your assistance in this regard. Sincerely, '/U . 6 Mindi Okai Tribal Consultation Manager From: towernotifyinfoCalfcc.gov To: tribal Cc: tcns.fccarchive(ofcc.gov; thoo(nbtttown.org; thlopthloccotribaltowntowers(obgmail.com Subject: Reply to Proposed Tower Structure (Notification ID: 169882) - Email ID #5808414 Date: Monday, May 28, 2018 10:50:12 PM Dear Mindi L Okai, Thank you for using the Federal Communications Commission's (FCC) Tower Construction Notification System (TCNS). The purpose of this email is to inform you that an authorized user of the TCNS has replied to a proposed tower construction notification that you had submitted through the TONS. The following message has been sent to you from THPO Terry Clouthier of the Thlopthlocco Tribal Town in reference to Notification ID #169882: Thlopthlocco Tribal Town has received your project. Upon review of information received and consulting our records, we are unaware of any culturally significant sites within the project APE. However, should any human remains or cultural resources be inadvertently discovered, please cease all work and contact our THPO at thpo@tttown.org immediately. Thank you. Lisa C Baker, Thlopthlocco Tribal Town, TCNS Consultant For your convenience, the information you submitted for this notification is detailed below. Notification Received: 03/27/2018 Notification ID: 169882 Tower Owner Individual or Entity Name: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Consultant Name: Mindi L Okai Street Address: 10845 Olive Blvd. Suite 260 City: St. Louis State: MISSOURI Zip Code: 63141 Phone: 314-997-6111 Email: tribal@trileaf.com Structure Type: GTOWER - Guyed Structure Used for Communication Purposes Latitude: 26 deg 10 min 45.0 sec N Longitude: 81 deg 34 min 17.2 sec W Location Description: Benton Road City: Naples State: FLORIDA County: COLLIER Detailed Description of Project: Legal Description: S25 T49S R27E Ground Elevation: 3.7 meters Support Structure: 67.1 meters above ground level Overall Structure: 67.1 meters above ground level Overall Height AMSL: 70.8 meters above mean sea level Appendix G Resumes %40TRILEAF" PROFESSIONAL RESUME Educatio B.S. in Biology University of Central Florida / Orlando, FL Mr. Reagan has experience performing site inspections and conducting environmental due diligence pursuant to EPA All Appropriate Inquiries (AAI) and the American Society of Testing and Materials (ASTM) and performing National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) reviews for wireless telecommunications projects. Environmental service expertise includes the preparation and/or review of: Phase I Environmental Site Assessments Historical City Directories Environmental Evaluation Summaries Informal Section 7 Consultation National Wetlands Inventory Maps Flood Insurance Rate Maps Critical Habitat Maps Migratory Bird Evaluations Soil Characterization ANSI/FCC RF Radiation Safety Competent Person Field Reconnaissance Historical Topographic Maps and Aerial Imagery Land Use History Section 106 Compliance NEPA Environmental Assessments Form 620/621 Submittals Local Government Consultation Native American Consultation T4I/ TRILEAF PROFESSIONAL RESUME Wr__ Education ir B.A. Environmental Studies / Minor in French University of California at Santa Barbara / Santa Barbara, CA Ms. Young has seven (7) years' experience with the investigation and management of environmental due diligence pursuant to EPA All Appropriate Inquiries (AAI) and the American Society of Testing and Materials (ASTM), as well as National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and environmental permitting projects. Ms. Young operates as a corporate point -of -contact for clients over a large geography, specializing in the Midwest and South regions of the United States. Environmental service expertise includes: Environmental Site Assessments Environmental Evaluation Summaries Asbestos Inspections Mold and Lead -Based Paint Surveys FCC Regulatory Compliance Vendor Management Construction Stormwater Planning and Oversight Wetland Survey and Delineations OSHA 40-Hour HAZWOPER Small Cell Solutions NEPA Environmental Assessments Critical Habitat and Species Review Nationwide Programmatic Agreement Review Underground Storage Tank Assessment/Removal Construction Environmental Oversight Soil Characterization Environmental Professional (EP) as defined by ASTM Standard E1527-13 (AAI) Certified Asbestos Building Inspector — MO (License #7118050418MOII19819) F7iitO - N'WIHIJfti - United States Department of the Interior �"""' FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE South Florida Ecological Services Field Office 1339 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960-3559 Phone: (772) 562-3909 Fax: (772) 562-4288 h1W://fws.,gov/verobeach In Reply Refer To: March 26, 2018 Consultation Code: 04EF2000-2018-SLI-0461 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Subject: List of threatened and endangered species that may occur in your proposed project location, and/or may be affected by your proposed project To Whom It May Concern: The enclosed species list identifies threatened, endangered, proposed and candidate species, as well as proposed and final designated critical habitat, that may occur within the boundary of your proposed project and/or may be affected by your proposed project. The species list fulfills the requirements of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (Service) under section 7(c) of the Endangered Species Act (Act) of 1973, as amended (16 U.S.C. 1531 et seq.). New information based on updated surveys, changes in the abundance and distribution of species, changed habitat conditions, or other factors could change this list. Please feel free to contact us if you need more current information or assistance regarding the potential impacts to federally proposed, listed, and candidate species and federally designated and proposed critical habitat. Please note that under 50 CFR 402.12(e) of the regulations implementing section 7 of the Act, the accuracy of this species list should be verified after 90 days. This verification can be completed formally or informally as desired. The Service recommends that verification be completed by visiting the ECOS-IPaC website at regular intervals during project planning and implementation for updates to species lists and information. An updated list may be requested through the ECOS-IPaC system by completing the same process used to receive the enclosed list. The purpose of the Act is to provide a means whereby threatened and endangered species and the ecosystems upon which they depend may be conserved. Under sections 7(a)(1) and 7(a)(2) of the Act and its implementing regulations (50 CFR 402 et seq.), Federal agencies are required to utilize their authorities to carry out programs for the conservation of threatened and endangered species and to determine whether projects may affect threatened and endangered species and/or designated critical habitat. 03/26/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 2 A Biological Assessment is required for construction projects (or other undertakings having similar physical impacts) that are major Federal actions significantly affecting the quality of the human environment as defined in the National Environmental Policy Act (42 U.S.C. 4332(2) (c)). For projects other than major construction activities, the Service suggests that a biological evaluation similar to a Biological Assessment be prepared to determine whether the project may affect listed or proposed species and/or designated or proposed critical habitat. Recommended contents of a Biological Assessment are described at 50 CFR 402.12. If a Federal agency determines, based on the Biological Assessment or biological evaluation, that listed species and/or designated critical habitat may be affected by the proposed project, the agency is required to consult with the Service pursuant to 50 CFR 402. In addition, the Service recommends that candidate species, proposed species and proposed critical habitat be addressed within the consultation. More information on the regulations and procedures for section 7 consultation, including the role of permit or license applicants, can be found in the 'Endangered Species Consultation Handbook" at: http://www.fws.gov/endangered/esa-library/Pdf/TOC-GLOS.PDF Please be aware that bald and golden eagles are protected under the Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act (16 U.S.C. 668 et seq.), and projects affecting these species may require development of an eagle conservation plan (http://www.fws.gov/windenergy/ eagle_guidance.html). Additionally, wind energy projects should follow the wind energy guidelines (http://www.fws.gov/windenergy/) for minimizing impacts to migratory birds and bats. Guidance for minimizing impacts to migratory birds for projects including communications towers (e.g., cellular, digital television, radio, and emergency broadcast) can be found at: http:// www.fws.gov/migratorybirds/CurrentBirdlssues/Hazards/towers/towers.htm; http:// www.towerkill.com; and http://www.fws.gov/migratorybirds/CurrentBirdIssues/Hazards/towers/ comtow.html. We appreciate your concern for threatened and endangered species. The Service encourages Federal agencies to include conservation of threatened and endangered species into their project planning to further the purposes of the Act. Please include the Consultation Tracking Number in the header of this letter with any request for consultation or correspondence about your project that you submit to our office. Attachment(s): • Official Species List 03/26/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 Official Species List This list is provided pursuant to Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act, and fulfills the requirement for Federal agencies to "request of the Secretary of the Interior information whether any species which is listed or proposed to be listed may be present in the area of a proposed action". This species list is provided by: South Florida Ecological Services Field Office 1339 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960-3559 (772) 562-3909 03/26/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 Project Summary Consultation Code: 04EF2000-2018-SLI-0461 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Project Type: COMMUNICATIONS TOWER Project Description: Construction of a 220' guyed communications tower and all associated equipment within a 3,600-square-foot lease area. A 20' wide access/utility easement extends west away from the lease area to connect with Benton Road. Project Location: Approximate location of the project can be viewed in Google Maps: https: www.google.com/maps/place/26.179267702439347N81.57164340399791 W 6o ryln Counties: Collier, FL 03/26/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 3 Endangered Species Act Species There is a total of 25 threatened, endangered, or candidate species on this species list. Species on this list should be considered in an effects analysis for your project and could include species that exist in another geographic area. For example, certain fish may appear on the species list because a project could affect downstream species. IPaC does not display listed species or critical habitats under the sole jurisdiction of NOAA Fisheriesl, as USFWS does not have the authority to speak on behalf of NOAA and the Department of Commerce. See the "Critical habitats" section below for those critical habitats that lie wholly or partially within your project area under this office's jurisdiction. Please contact the designated FWS office if you have questions. NOAA Fisheries, also known as the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS), is an office of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration within the Department of Commerce. Mammals NAME Florida Bonneted Bat Eumops floridanus No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/8630 Florida Panther Puma (=Felis) concolor coryi No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https:Hecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/1763 Habitat assessment guidelines: https://ecos. fws. gov/ipac/guideline/assessment/population/8/office/41420.pdf Puma (=mountain Lion) Puma (=Felis) concolor (all subsp. except coryi) Population: FL No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws.2_ov/ecp/species/6049 West Indian Manatee Trichechus manatus There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. This species is also protected by the Marine Mammal Protection Act, and may have additional consultation requirements. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/4469 STATUS Endangered Endangered Similarity of Appearance (Threatened) Threatened 03/26/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 Birds NAME STATUS Audubon's Crested Caracara Polyborus plancus audubonii Threatened Population: FL pop. No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8250 Cape Sable Seaside Sparrow Ammodramus maritimus mirabilis Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. ov/ecp/species/6584 Everglade Snail Kite Rostrhamus sociabilis plumbeus Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: https:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/7713 Species survey guidelines: https:Hecos.fws. gov/ipac/guideline/survey//population/1221/office/41420.pdf Florida Grasshopper Sparrow Ammodramus savannarum floridanus Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/32 Florida Scrub jay Aphelocoma coerulescens Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6174 Ivory -billed Woodpecker Campephilus principalis Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: hiips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8230 Kirtland's Warbler Setophaga kirtlandii (= Dendroica kirtlandii) Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8078 Piping Plover Charadrius melodus Threatened Population: [Atlantic Coast and Northern Great Plains populations] - Wherever found, except those areas where listed as endangered. There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6039 Red Knot Calidris canutus rufa Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/1864 Red -cockaded Woodpecker Picoides borealis Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: hiips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/7614 Wood Stork Mycteria americana Threatened 03/26/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 NAME Population: AL, FL, GA, MS, NC, SC No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https:Hecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/8477 Habitat assessment guidelines: https://ecos.fws. gov/ipac/guideline/assessment/population/124/office/41420.pdf Reptiles STATUS NAME STATUS American Alligator Alligator mississippiensis Similarity of No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Appearance Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/776 (Threatened) American Crocodile Crocodylus acutus Threatened Population: U.S.A. (FL) There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6604 Eastern Indigo Snake Drymarchon corais couperi Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/646 Loggerhead Sea Turtle Caretta caretta Threatened Population: Northwest Atlantic Ocean DPS There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. ov/ecp/species/1110 Fishes NAME STATUS Atlantic Sturgeon (gulf Subspecies) Acipenser oxyrinchus (=oxyrhynchus) Threatened desotoi There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/651 5 03/26/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-01415 6 Insects NAME STATUS Bartram's Hairstreak Butterfly Strymon acis bartrami Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/4837 Florida Leafwing Butterfly Anaea troglodyta floridalis Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6652 Miami Blue Butterfly Cyclargus (=Hemiargus) thomasi bethunebakeri Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/3797 Flowering Plants NAML STATUS Florida Prairie -clover Dalea carthagenensis floridana No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/2300 Endangered Garber's Spurge Chamaesyce garberi Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8229 Critical habitats THERE ARE NO CRITICAL HABITATS WITHIN YOUR PROJECT AREA UNDER THIS OFFICE'S JURISDICTION. F7iitO - N'WIHIJfti - United States Department of the Interior �"""' FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE South Florida Ecological Services Field Office 1339 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960-3559 Phone: (772) 562-3909 Fax: (772) 562-4288 h1W://fws.,gov/verobeach In Reply Refer To: August 02, 2018 Consultation Code: 04EF2000-2018-SLI-0461 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Subject: Updated list of threatened and endangered species that may occur in your proposed project location, and/or may be affected by your proposed project To Whom It May Concern: The enclosed species list identifies threatened, endangered, proposed and candidate species, as well as proposed and final designated critical habitat, that may occur within the boundary of your proposed project and/or may be affected by your proposed project. The species list fulfills the requirements of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (Service) under section 7(c) of the Endangered Species Act (Act) of 1973, as amended (16 U.S.C. 1531 et seq.). New information based on updated surveys, changes in the abundance and distribution of species, changed habitat conditions, or other factors could change this list. Please feel free to contact us if you need more current information or assistance regarding the potential impacts to federally proposed, listed, and candidate species and federally designated and proposed critical habitat. Please note that under 50 CFR 402.12(e) of the regulations implementing section 7 of the Act, the accuracy of this species list should be verified after 90 days. This verification can be completed formally or informally as desired. The Service recommends that verification be completed by visiting the ECOS-IPaC website at regular intervals during project planning and implementation for updates to species lists and information. An updated list may be requested through the ECOS-IPaC system by completing the same process used to receive the enclosed list. The purpose of the Act is to provide a means whereby threatened and endangered species and the ecosystems upon which they depend may be conserved. Under sections 7(a)(1) and 7(a)(2) of the Act and its implementing regulations (50 CFR 402 et seq.), Federal agencies are required to utilize their authorities to carry out programs for the conservation of threatened and endangered species and to determine whether projects may affect threatened and endangered species and/or designated critical habitat. 08/02/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 2 A Biological Assessment is required for construction projects (or other undertakings having similar physical impacts) that are major Federal actions significantly affecting the quality of the human environment as defined in the National Environmental Policy Act (42 U.S.C. 4332(2) (c)). For projects other than major construction activities, the Service suggests that a biological evaluation similar to a Biological Assessment be prepared to determine whether the project may affect listed or proposed species and/or designated or proposed critical habitat. Recommended contents of a Biological Assessment are described at 50 CFR 402.12. If a Federal agency determines, based on the Biological Assessment or biological evaluation, that listed species and/or designated critical habitat may be affected by the proposed project, the agency is required to consult with the Service pursuant to 50 CFR 402. In addition, the Service recommends that candidate species, proposed species and proposed critical habitat be addressed within the consultation. More information on the regulations and procedures for section 7 consultation, including the role of permit or license applicants, can be found in the 'Endangered Species Consultation Handbook" at: http://www.fws.gov/endangered/esa-library/Pdf/TOC-GLOS.PDF Please be aware that bald and golden eagles are protected under the Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act (16 U.S.C. 668 et seq.), and projects affecting these species may require development of an eagle conservation plan (http://www.fws.gov/windenergy/ eagle_guidance.html). Additionally, wind energy projects should follow the wind energy guidelines (http://www.fws.gov/windenergy/) for minimizing impacts to migratory birds and bats. Guidance for minimizing impacts to migratory birds for projects including communications towers (e.g., cellular, digital television, radio, and emergency broadcast) can be found at: http:// www.fws.gov/migratorybirds/CurrentBirdlssues/Hazards/towers/towers.htm; http:// www.towerkill.com; and http://www.fws.gov/migratorybirds/CurrentBirdIssues/Hazards/towers/ comtow.html. We appreciate your concern for threatened and endangered species. The Service encourages Federal agencies to include conservation of threatened and endangered species into their project planning to further the purposes of the Act. Please include the Consultation Tracking Number in the header of this letter with any request for consultation or correspondence about your project that you submit to our office. Attachment(s): • Official Species List 08/02/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 Official Species List This list is provided pursuant to Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act, and fulfills the requirement for Federal agencies to "request of the Secretary of the Interior information whether any species which is listed or proposed to be listed may be present in the area of a proposed action". This species list is provided by: South Florida Ecological Services Field Office 1339 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960-3559 (772) 562-3909 08/02/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 Project Summary Consultation Code: 04EF2000-2018-SLI-0461 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 Project Name: Naples Park North, FL Project Type: COMMUNICATIONS TOWER Project Description: Construction of a 220' guyed communications tower and all associated equipment within a 3,600-square-foot lease area. A 20' wide access/utility easement extends west away from the lease area to connect with Benton Road. Project Location: Approximate location of the project can be viewed in Google Maps: https: www.google.com/maps/place/26.179267702439347N81.57164340399791 W 6o ryln Counties: Collier, FL 2 08/02/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 3 Endangered Species Act Species There is a total of 25 threatened, endangered, or candidate species on this species list. Species on this list should be considered in an effects analysis for your project and could include species that exist in another geographic area. For example, certain fish may appear on the species list because a project could affect downstream species. IPaC does not display listed species or critical habitats under the sole jurisdiction of NOAA Fisheriesl, as USFWS does not have the authority to speak on behalf of NOAA and the Department of Commerce. See the "Critical habitats" section below for those critical habitats that lie wholly or partially within your project area under this office's jurisdiction. Please contact the designated FWS office if you have questions. NOAA Fisheries, also known as the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS), is an office of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration within the Department of Commerce. Mammals NAME Florida Bonneted Bat Eumops floridanus No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/8630 Florida Panther Puma (=Felis) concolor coryi No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https:Hecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/1763 Habitat assessment guidelines: https://ecos. fws. gov/ipac/guideline/assessment/population/8/office/41420.pdf Puma (=mountain Lion) Puma (=Felis) concolor (all subsp. except coryi) Population: FL No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws.2_ov/ecp/species/6049 West Indian Manatee Trichechus manatus There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. This species is also protected by the Marine Mammal Protection Act, and may have additional consultation requirements. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/4469 STATUS Endangered Endangered Similarity of Appearance (Threatened) Threatened 08/02/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 Birds NAME STATUS Audubon's Crested Caracara Polyborus plancus audubonii Threatened Population: FL pop. No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8250 Cape Sable Seaside Sparrow Ammodramus maritimus mirabilis Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. ov/ecp/species/6584 Everglade Snail Kite Rostrhamus sociabilis plumbeus Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: https:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/7713 Species survey guidelines: https:Hecos.fws. gov/ipac/guideline/survey//population/1221/office/41420.pdf Florida Grasshopper Sparrow Ammodramus savannarum floridanus Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/32 Florida Scrub jay Aphelocoma coerulescens Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6174 Ivory -billed Woodpecker Campephilus principalis Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: hiips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8230 Kirtland's Warbler Setophaga kirtlandii (= Dendroica kirtlandii) Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8078 Piping Plover Charadrius melodus Threatened Population: [Atlantic Coast and Northern Great Plains populations] - Wherever found, except those areas where listed as endangered. There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6039 Red Knot Calidris canutus rufa Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/1864 Red -cockaded Woodpecker Picoides borealis Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: hiips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/7614 Wood Stork Mycteria americana Threatened 08/02/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 NAME Population: AL, FL, GA, MS, NC, SC No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https:Hecos.fws. oe v/ecp/species/8477 Habitat assessment guidelines: https://ecos.fws. gov/ipac/guideline/assessment/population/124/office/41420.pdf Reptiles STATUS NAME STATUS American Alligator Alligator mississippiensis Similarity of No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Appearance Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/776 (Threatened) American Crocodile Crocodylus acutus Threatened Population: U.S.A. (FL) There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6604 Eastern Indigo Snake Drymarchon corais couperi Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/646 Loggerhead Sea Turtle Caretta caretta Threatened Population: Northwest Atlantic Ocean DPS There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. ov/ecp/species/1110 Fishes NAME STATUS Atlantic Sturgeon (gulf Subspecies) Acipenser oxyrinchus (=oxyrhynchus) Threatened desotoi There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/651 5 08/02/2018 Event Code: 04EF2000-2018-E-02962 6 Insects NAME STATUS Bartram's Hairstreak Butterfly Strymon acis bartrami Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/4837 Florida Leafwing Butterfly Anaea troglodyta floridalis Endangered There is final critical habitat for this species. Your location is outside the critical habitat. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/6652 Miami Blue Butterfly Cyclargus (=Hemiargus) thomasi bethunebakeri Endangered No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: htips:Hecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/3797 Flowering Plants NAML STATUS Florida Prairie -clover Dalea carthagenensis floridana No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/2300 Endangered Garber's Spurge Chamaesyce garberi Threatened No critical habitat has been designated for this species. Species profile: https://ecos.fws. og v/ecp/species/8229 Critical habitats THERE ARE NO CRITICAL HABITATS WITHIN YOUR PROJECT AREA UNDER THIS OFFICE'S JURISDICTION. 4/26/2018 www.fnai.org/FieldGuide/search-002.cfm ---> 49 Matches Found Plant Dicot - Aeschynomene pratensis - meadow joint -vetch Dicot - Indigofera mucronata var keyensis - decumbent indigo Dicot - Jacquemontia pentanthos - skyblue clustervine Dicot - Passiflora pallens - pineland passion -flower Dicot - Peperomia humilis - terrestrial peperomia Dicot - Peperomia obtusifolia - blunt -leaved peperomia Fern (Pteridophytes) - Asplenium serratum -bird's nest spleenwort Fern (Pteridophytes) - Campyloneurum angustifolium - narrow -leaved strap fern Fern (Pteridophytes) - Pecluma ptilodon -swamp plume polypoda fern Fern (Pteridophytes) - Thely_pteris serrata - Monocot - Campylocentrum pachyrrhizum - ribbon orchid Monocot - Catopsis floribunda - many -flowered catopsis Monocot - Cyrtopodium punctatum - cow horn orchid Monocot - Encyclia cochleata var triandra - clamshell orchid Monocot - Epidendrum nocturnum - night -scented orchid Monocot - Guzmania monostachia - Fakahatchee Guzmania Monocot - Maxillaria crassifolia - hidden orchid Monocot - Oncidium floridanum - Florida dancing -lady orchid Monocot - Pleurothallis gelida - frost -flower orchid Monocot - Pteroglossaspis ecristata - giant orchid Monocot - Sacoila lanceolata var paludicola - Fahkahatchee ladies' -tresses Monocot - Spiranthes torta - southern ladies' -tresses Monocot - Tillandsia pruinosa - fuzzy-wuzzy air -plant Vertebrate Bird - Aphelocoma coerulescens - Florida scrub -jay_ Bird - Caracara cheriway - crested caracara Bird - Charadrius alexandrinus - snowy plover Bird - Charadrius melodus - piping_plover Bird - Grus canadensis pratensis - Florida sandhill crane Bird - Haliaeetus leucocephalus - bald eagle Bird - Mycteria americana - wood stork Bird - Picoides borealis - red -cockaded woodpecker Bird - Rostrhamus sociabilis plumbeus - snail kite Bird - Sterna dougallii - roseate tern Bird - Sternula antillarum - least tern Mammal - Eumops glaucinus floridanus - Florida mastiff bat Mammal - Mustela vison mink pop 1 - southern mink (s. Florida pop.). Mammal - Puma concolor coryi - Florida panther Mammal - Sciurus niger avicennia - mangrove fox squirrel Mammal - Trichechus manatus - manatee Mammal - Ursus americanus floridanus - Florida black bear Reptile - Caretta caretta - loggerhead Reptile - Chelonia mydas - green turtle Reptile - Crocodylus acutus - American crocodile Reptile - Dermochelys coriacea - leatherback Reptile - Drymarchon couperi - eastern indigo snake Reptile - Eretmochelys imbricata - hawksbill turtle Reptile - Gopherus poly_phemus - gopher tortoise Reptile - Lepidochelys kempii - Kemp's ridley_ http://www.fnai.org/FieldGuide/search_002.cfm 1 /1 From: Hitt, Heather To: Jackson Reagan Subject: Naples Park North Tower 2018-TA-0461 Date: Friday, May 18, 2018 3:37:46 PM Attachments: 20130812 EIS Standard Protection Measures final.odf Draft Protocol for Florida Bonneted Bat Roost Surveys.PDF 04 E F 2000-2018-TA-0461 Mr. Reagan: This email acknowledges the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service's (Service) April 27, 2018 receipt of your concurrently dated request for information under section 7 of the Endangered Species Act of 1973, as amended (Act) (87 Stat. 884; 16 U.S.C. 1531 et seq.). We have assigned log number 04EF2000-2018-TA-0461 to this request. We understand the proposed Project incorporates the construction of a 220-foot guyed communication tower and associated communication equipment in an undeveloped grass and tree -covered area. Work would include 100-foot by 20-foot wide access/utility easement extending west to Benton Road. The site is located at Benton Road, Naples, Collier County, Florida (26°10'44.98"N, 81034'17.21"W). THREATENED AND ENDANGERED SPECIES The Service has reviewed its Geographic Information System (GIS) database for recorded locations of federally listed threatened and endangered species and critical habitats on or adjacent to the parcel. The GIS database is a compilation of data received from several sources. According to our review, the Project area is located within the consultation area of the federally threatened eastern indigo snake (Drymarchon corgis couperi; indigo snake), federally endangered Florida bonneted bat (Eumops floridanus; FBB), federally endangered Florida panther, and federally threatened wood stork (Mycteria americana). Eastern indigo snake Suitable habitat for the indigo snake consists of a mosaic of habitat types where snakes establish mean home ranges of 46 ac and 184 ac for females and males, respectively. Project activities are expected to have minimal impact on upland habitat resulting in negligible habitat loss. Therefore, the proposed Project is not likely to adversely affect this species. The Service recommends the implementation of the Standard Protection Measures for the Eastern Indigo Snake (attached) to diminish the likelihood of adversely affecting indigo snakes if any are present on site. Florida bonneted bat The FBB uses a variety of habitat types ranging from forested to urban environments for foraging and roosting areas. Project activities are expected to have minimal impact on foraging habitat and a minimal number of palm trees are expected to be removed. Since the Service is not sure on the value of palm frond roosts, the Service is not recommending roost surveys in palm habitat, unless the palm tree contains a cavity. The Service recommends the applicant survey the palm trees to be removed for cavities prior to removal using the Draft Protocol for Florida Bonneted Bat Roost Surveys (attached). Unless a FBB roost is found, the proposed Project is not likely to adversely affect this species. Florida panther The Project area is located within the primary focus area for the Florida panther and suitable habitat is present. However, the actin area is small and is expected to have minimal impact on upland habitat resulting in negligible habitat loss. Therefore, the proposed Project is not likely to adversely affect this species. Wood stork According to our GIS database, the Project area is contained within multiple Core Foraging Areas (CFA), defined as the area within 29.9 kilometer (km) (18.6 miles), of a wood stork colonies. Loss of suitable wetlands within CFAs may reduce foraging opportunities for the wood stork. The Proposed project would not impact suitable foraging habitat; therefore, the proposed Project is not likely to adversely affect this species. Federally listed plant species According to our GIS database, no federally listed plant species are known to occur within the Project area. Therefore, the proposed Project is not likely to affect these species. If modifications are made to the Project, if additional information involving potential effects to listed species becomes available, or if a new species is listed, reinitiation of consultation may be necessary. Thank you for the opportunity to comment and for your cooperation and effort in protecting natural resources of South Florida. If you have any questions, please contact me at 772-469-4267. Sincerely, Heather Hitt Fish and Wildlife Biologist US Fish and Wildlife Service 1339 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 Phone: 772-469-4267 Fax: 772-562-4288 Email: heather hittnfws.gov NOTE: This email correspondence and any attachments to and from this sender is subject to the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) and may be disclosed to third parties. %40 TRI AF ENVIRONMENTAL - ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING Florida Bonneted Bat Roost Survey August 30, 2018 Capital Telecom — Naples Park North FL Capital Telecom # FL114 Benton Road Naples, Florida 34117 Trileaf # 637639 Prepared For: Prepared By: Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC Trileaf Corporation 820 Morris Turnpike 1051 Winderley Place, Suite 201 Short Hills, New Jersey 07078 Maitland, Florida 32751 Introduction Capital Telecom Holdings, LLC (Capital Telecom) proposes to construct a 220-foot guyed communications tower and associated compound at Benton Road, Naples, Collier County, Florida 34117. The proposed tower will be within a 60-foot by 60-foot (3,600-square-foot) lease area. The project includes an access/utility easement, measuring approximately 20- foot wide, which extends approximately 100 feet west away from the lease area to connect with Benton Road. The proposed tower will be supported by three (3) anchored guy wires that extend approximately 122 feet northwest, east, and southwest from the tower center. The tower, compound, access road, and guywire anchors (tower footprint) are proposed to be located in a Cabbage Palm (Sabal palmetto) dominated, xeric palm flatwoods. As such, the proposed construction will include the removal of several trees, primarily Cabbage Palms. The Florida Bonneted Bat (FBB) (Eumops floridanus) species is a known resident of Collier County, and therefore, the removal of trees within Collier County can potentially impact FBB habitat. According to the Florida Wildlife and Conservation Commission's (FWC) A Species Action Plan for the Florida Bonneted Bat (Eumops floridanus) the state of Florida has had the FBB listed on the Florida Endangered and Threatened Species List since 1992, and in 2013 the U. S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) designated the FBB as a threatened species under the Endangered Species Act of 1973. Therefore, Capital Telecom has contracted Trileaf to survey the tower footprint (5,600-square feet) plus a 50- foot buffer beyond the tower footprint for the presence of FBBs. See Appendix Site Plans and Aerials for a map of the survey area. Site and Surrounding Habitat According to the United States Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) Ecoregion database, the Site is located near the border between the Southwestern Florida Flatwoods and Big Cypress ecoregions of Florida. The Site is currently located within a Cabbage Palm dominated, xeric palm flatwoods. During a site reconnaissance conducted by Trileaf on February 22, 2018, several trees along the access road, and generally throughout the area were identified to be removed. A tree survey was not conducted; however, based on site observations and the provided photographs, the stand consists predominantly of Cabbage Palm trees with an average diameter at breast height (DBH) of 10 inches. The trees are relatively widely spaced, and canopy cover is mostly open in the action area. Ground cover is dominated by various grass species, Saw Palmetto (Serenoa repens), and other low - growing shrub species. The current habitat is not mapped as critical habitat. Methods On August 27, 2018, Trileaf dispatched Mr. Tyler Brown and Mr. Jackson Reagan, qualified biologists, to the proposed tower site to conduct a ground -based survey of the tower footprint for the presence of FBBs. Equipped with binoculars, a cavity peeper camera, and 35-foot telescoping pole, Mr. Brown and Mr. Reagan conducted a Florida Bonneted Bat Roost Survey per the guidelines set forth in the USFWS Draft Protocol for Florida Bonneted Bat Roost Surveys — February 3, 2015 by walking north to south and south to north transects at no more than 30 meters apart searching for roost cavities or crevices and guano. Findings Trileaf found no cavities of a suitable size for FBBs, crevices containing roosting FBBs, or guano droppings in or around the crevices or trees. In addition, Trileaf found no old growth Cabbage Palm palm fronds suitable for FBB roosts. Conclusions Based on the findings of this survey, it is the opinion of Trileaf that the removal of trees (primarily Cabbage Palms) within the tower footprint (including a 50-foot buffer zone) should not impact FBB roosting habitat. Referenced Material Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission A species Action Plan for the Florida Bonneted Bat (Eumops floridanus) http ://myfwc.com/media/2738262/Florida-Bonneted-Bat-Species-Action-Plan-Final- Draft.pdf Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission Draft Protocol for Florida Bonneted Bat Roost Surveys — February 3, 2015 (attached) United States Environmental Protection Agency Ecoregion Database hgps://www.epa.gov/eco-research/ecoregion-download-files-state-re ig on-4 Qualifications Jackson Reagan, Project Scientist Mr. Reagan holds a B.S degree in Biology from the University of Central Florida. His previous work experience includes Phase I Environmental Site Assessments, National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 reviews (NEPA), Environmental Assessments, migratory bird evaluations, and Sand Skink surveys. Tyler Brown, Assistant Project Manager Mr. Brown holds a B.S. degree in Biology from Indiana Wesleyan University. Mr. Brown's work experience includes Migratory Bird Evaluations, Phase I Environmental Site Assessments, Gopher Tortoise surveys, beach nesting turtle surveys, Red -cockaded Woodpecker surveys, Florida Scrub Jay surveys, raptor banding and monitoring, vegetation surveys, shorebird banding and monitoring, shorebird habitat assessments, and shorebird habitat restoration. Caitlin Young, Project Manager Ms. Young holds a B.A. in Environmental Studies and a Minor in French from the University of California at Santa Barbara. Ms. Young has seven (7) years' experience with the investigation and management of environmental due diligence pursuant to EPA All Appropriate Inquiries (AAI) and the American Society of Testing and Materials (ASTM), as well as National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and environmental permitting projects. Ms. Young operates as a corporate point -of -contact for clients over a large geography, specializing in the Midwest and South regions of the United States. Respectfully Submitted, TRILEAF Corporation Jackson Reagan Project Scientist Tyler Brown Assistant Project Manager Caitlin Young Project Manager Site Plans and Aerials p Z n ~ w� p Of a ZdO L133HS NMOHS SY 31Y05 WaL/£O 31v0 SNM 03'`=u MN 'M3ao 0131! M03H0 ar ae Nmvaq 09810 3 'NMO151aa0N cOZ 3Ln5 3nN3Atl 319N3N '1W OOSI W003131 �vildvo :mOJ °'JH0 lane eDHOM33HUGHM W00'6uamwS'MMM SB69-ZSZ-SOZ 4d bbZSE ewege1V'wey6ww�lg anud �a]uap ssaulsng ESL ou dnoi Bui 99U16U I `J 3 MWS .kBAmns N3MOi dNVIMVN IB 3LY0 NOIsV 'ON o Z f y W F p W U g O Y= 4 K Wj Z t(zss kk� O J O O O O j W K= = 2 Z W W d J 2 O Q x ti N �� Z W Z O 0 i a a 4 rc a (Q' i ®B ® U W 0 x x I �X N Q- m O 0 O r a o X O j Y m<moE z= _ o m Q.Er U m E` m° m m + m °oE7.5 T I ate' I o2.mm.°E�u -16 i o m i,o o _= C£mZ }O - pomm MNv cm U' \ W rc eo?O c �mzm Zomtm��v�i9€€,: f N + rib m 6 w 16 Fl ` cd f"rno =I I I I � I I I I � � I I I p I ¢a / . e ,z\ II \ I 'lover I Ic \ F\ �� \ I iI '� i I II \/ I0 I 1 /la 1 1 x /° I 1 -------- — Na, a —OP— — — — — — — —._.__. _ , —Va--�---- F----=P- — — — — — — — — — — amag ian�ao— — -F (AVM-do-iHo1a onend) ______________ 4 N — -------------- V / J O ry Q ir'sw �r 4m Z O W F y y ? d x O U a w Wa a z cZ d.) V) N O U N Z LL W 'F- V / 0 J LU a_ co J Z Regulatory Documentation Draft Protocol for Florida Bonneted Bat Roost Surveys — February 3, 201S The protocols below ca-e drafi guidance. Prior to ally implementation the U.S Fish and lVildlife Serviee should be contacted to ensure proper Ilse of the most recent protocols. Ilrrplernctrtatiorr of outt ofdate protocols tirgl- irmalidctte I•esults. This protocol is designed to be implemented prior to potential impacts from construction or development projects and should be performed by personnel experienced in management and monitoring of bat species. The purpose of this roost survey protocol is to identify potential roosts and determine if they are currently occupied by the Florida bonneted bat. Roosting habitat includes forest and osier areas with large or mature trees or other areas with suitable roost structures. Florida bonneted bats are known to roost in both natural and artificial structures. Natural roosting structure primarily includes mature or large live or dead trees, tree snags, and trees with cavities, hollows, and crevices but may include rock crevices and other structure, as well. Forest is defined as all types (all age classes) including: pine flatwoods, scrubby flatwoods, pine rocklands, royal palm hammocks, mixed or hardwood hammocks, cypress, sand pine scrub, or other forest types. Artificial roost structures include buildings, bridges, and bat houses. Roost usage and dynamics are not well understood. Although the Florida bonneted bat has exhibited high site fidelity, roost switching is also suspected. Roosting habitat may include sites for day and night roosts to support colonies (e.g., harem, maternity, bachelor, and potential seasonal changes). Because of the difficulty in detecting the Florida bonneted bat and other bat species, negative roost survey results will not equate to a determination that the species is absent from the site. Instead, the results of the surveys will provide information that can help guide the consultation process and appropriate conservation measures. SURVEYING NATURAL STRUCTURES (Iive trees, snags, rock crevices) Areas that contain potential natural roosting structures (e.g., hollows, woodpecker cavities, loose 1 exfoliating bark, rock crevices) should be surveyed following similar methodology as transects used for red -cockaded woodpeckers (RCW) (Service 2004). Conduct systematic roost searches' in suitable Florida bonneted bat habitat (see above) using the methodology listed below: Run line transects through roosting habitat, visually inspecting all trees and snags for evidence of cavities. 1 Projects within the RCW consultation area must identify all active RCW cavity trees prior to conducting bat roost surveys. Any biologist conducting visual inspections of RCW cavity trees must have a current USFWS 10(a)(1)(A) permit that authorizes such activities for the RCW. All active RCW cavity trees will be avoided during bat roost surveys. M • Transects must be spaced so that all trees and snags are inspected. • Transect spacing will vary with habitat structure and season from a maximum of 91 re (300 ft) between transects in very open pine stands to 46 in (150 ft) or less in areas with dense midstory. • Transects should be oriented north to south, to optimize cavity detectability. • When cavities, hollows, or other suitable structure are found, record their locations in the field using a Global Positioning System (GPS) unit. • Visually inspect all cavities, hollows, or other suitable structure (except cavities in active RCW trees) using a video camera probe (peeper) and assess the cavity contents. The cam era should be oriented in such a way as to obtain views of both the top and bottom portions of the cavity, • If bats are suspected or if contents cannot be determined, follow methods to Deternzil7e Roost Usage (below) within 2 days of identification/peeping. If the agency or applicant does not wish to conduct acoustic roost surveys, an assumption of presence of Florida bonneted bats can be made. • Record tree species or type of roosting structure, tree diameter and height, cavity height, cavity orientation, and cavity contents. SURVEYING ARTIFICIAL STRUCTURES To assess artificial structures (including barrel tile roofs) for roosting potential: Conduct a visual and auditory inspection for evidence of bats including the following: cavities, crevices, staining at the entrance to a cavity or crevice, guano, or auditory chirping sounds. If roosting structures or evidence of bats are identified during visual surveys, conduct acoustic surveys, following methods to Deterinining Roost Usage with Acoustic Equipment to confine species of bat present. Positive detection of Florida hnnneted bats precludes the need to continuc additional Surveys.` SURVEYING PALM TREES Florida bonneted bats have been found in the shafts of palm fronds (Belwood 1992). Currently, the Service has limited information on how the Florida bonneted bat is using palm frond roosts and whether they are providing only short-tene roosting habitat, which would not be conducive to long-term, colony, or maternity roosting. Until additional information is collected on the Z However, state regulation for removal of bat roosts may apply. F.A.C. chapter 68A— 9.010; and consistent with protective provisions specified in F.A.C. chapter 68A-27 (68A-27.0011 and 68A-27.003) value of palm frond roosts, the Service is not recommending roost surveys for palm habitat, UNLESS the palm tree contains a cavity. In that case, follow the protocol described for natural cavities. SURVEYING OTHER STRUCTURES Other unique roosting opportunities will be handled on a case -by -case basis through coordination with the South Florida Ecological Services Office. DETERMINING ROOST USAGE WITH ACOUSTIC EQUIPMENT Deploy detector/microphones 15 m (49 ft) from the suspected roost with the microphone orientated in the direction of the suspected roost. Potential roost cavities that are < 15 in (49 ft) apart can be simultaneously sampled if microphones can be appropriately placed to capture any vocalizations of bats departing from both locations. Record all bat echolocations for four nights (sunset to sunrise). Follow the equipment and weather parameters identified below. • Observation of the potential roost at sunset, using a human observer with a detector, could also be used to confirm species. • Detection of Florida bonneted bats on any night precludes the need to continue additional surveys at that potential roost site. Equipment Detectors and microphones suitable for use in this survey protocol include: • Full -spectrum and/or zero -crossing detectors. • Directional and omni-directional microphones. • Microphones attached to detectors via a cable permitting that the cable Iength does not exceed manufacturer recommendations. Microphones should be mounted on grounded or metal poles to avoid build-up of electrostatic charges that may interfere with acoustic sampling. Ensure acoustic detectors are functioning properly and conduct tests on microphone sensitivity to factory specifications before and after deployment, at a minimum. It is recommended that tests be conducted throughout the survey period. Weather Conditions At a minimum, nightly weather conditions for survey sites should be checked using the nearest NOAA National Weather Service station and summarized in the survey reports. If any of the following weather conditions exist at a survey site during acoustic sampling, note the time and duration of such conditions, and repeat the acoustic sampling effort on a different night with suitable weather conditions. temperatures fall below 60°F during the night; precipitation, including rain and/or fog, that exceeds 30 minutes or continues intermittently during the night; and sustained wind speeds greater than 9 miles/hour (4 meters/second; 3 on Beaufort scale) during the night. REPORTING REQUIREMENTS Submit survey results to the Service well in advance of clearing and/or construction. Contact the Service immediately upon locating a roost site occupied by Florida bonneted bats. At a minimum., survey results should include the following: aerial maps of area examined, locations of transect lines, survey results (dates and times of surveys, weather conditions, roosting structures identified, equipment verification information, etc.), GPS locations, physical characteristics, and photographs of roosting structures found, copies of all echolocation files with Florida bonneted bat calls specifically tagged, and names and qualifications of surveyors. LITERATURE CITED Belwood, J. J. 1992. Florida mastiff bat Eumops glaucinus. loridmius. Pages 216-223 in S. R. Humphrey, editor. Rare and endangered biota of Florida. Vol. I. Mammals. University Press of Florida, Gainesville. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 2004. Draft Species Conservation Guidelines South Florida Red -cockaded Woodpecker. South Florida Ecological Services Office; Vero Beach, Florida. A Species Action Plan for the Florida Bonneted Bat Eumops floridanus Final Draft November 1, 2013 Q Ralph, ArwQQd' s ram;. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 620 South Meridian Street Tallahassee, FL 32399-1600 Visit us at MyFWC.com FLORIDA BONNETED BAT ACTION PLAN TEAM FLORIDA BONNETED BAT ACTION PLAN TEAM Team Leader: Jennifer Myers, Division of Habitat and Species Conservation Team Members: Jeff Gore, Fish and Wildlife Research Institute Kathleen Smith, Division of Habitat and Species Conservation Acknowledgements: Laura Barrett, Division of Habitat and Species Conservation Claire Sunquist Blunden, Office of Policy and Accountability Brie Ochoa, Division of Habitat and Species Conservation Mary Ann Poole, Office of Conservation Planning Services Melissa Tucker, Division of Habitat and Species Conservation George and Cyndi Marks, Florida Bat Conservancy Cover photograph by Ralph Arwood Recommended citation: Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission. 2013. A species action plan for the Florida bonneted bat. Tallahassee, Florida. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission ii EXECUTIVE SUMMARY EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) created this plan based on the determination of the Biological Review Group that the Florida bonneted bat (Eumops floridanus) should remain listed as Threatened in the State of Florida. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service proposed to list the Florida bonneted bat in 2012, and the listing was accepted in 2013, adding the Florida bonneted bat to the list of Endangered Species under the Endangered Species Act of 1973. Critical habitat was not designated with the listing, but is expected to be proposed by 2014. The goal of this plan is to improve the conservation status of the Florida bonneted bat so the species is secure within its historical range. The objective of the plan is to initiate research to fill data gaps in current knowledge of the Florida bonneted bat. Since the range of the Florida bonneted bat is limited to southern Florida, some factors related to extent of occurrence or area of occupancy may always meet the listing criteria. The primary actions of this plan focus on collecting information to inform management and collaborating with other entities conducting research on Florida bonneted bats. Because little is known about this species, achieving the objective and completing the actions will require substantial research and monitoring efforts by FWC and other entities on both public and private lands. This plan details the actions necessary to improve the conservation status of the Florida bonneted bat. A summary of this plan will be included in the Imperiled Species Management Plan (ISMP), in satisfaction of the management plan requirements in Chapter 68A-27, Florida Administrative Code, Rules Relating to Endangered or Threatened Species. The ISMP will address comprehensive management needs for 60 of Florida's imperiled species and will include an implementation plan; rule recommendations; permitting standards and exempt activities; anticipated economic, ecological, and social impacts; projected costs of implementation and identification of funding sources; and a revision schedule. The imperiled species management planning process relies heavily on stakeholder input and partner support. This level of involvement and support is also critical to the successful implementation of the ISMP. Any significant changes to this plan will be made with the continued involvement of stakeholders. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission iii TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS FLORIDA BONNETED BAT ACTION PLAN TEAM................................................................ ii EXECUTIVE SUMMARY........................................................................................................... iii LISTOF TABLES.......................................................................................................................... v LISTOF FIGURES....................................................................................................................... vi GLOSSARY OF TERMS AND ACRONYMS............................................................................ vii INTRODUCTION.......................................................................................................................... 1 BiologicalBackground................................................................................................................ 1 ConservationHistory................................................................................................................... 5 Threats and Recommended Listing Status.................................................................................. 6 CONSERVATION GOALS AND OBJECTIVES......................................................................... 8 CONSERVATIONACTIONS....................................................................................................... 9 Habitat Conservation and Management...................................................................................... 9 PopulationManagement............................................................................................................ 13 Monitoringand Research.......................................................................................................... 14 Ruleand Permitting Intent........................................................................................................ 18 LawEnforcement...................................................................................................................... 21 Incentivesand Influencing........................................................................................................ 21 Educationand Outreach............................................................................................................ 22 Coordination with Other Entities.............................................................................................. 23 LITERATURE CITED................................................................................................................. 27 APPENDICES.............................................................................................................................. 30 Appendix 1. Instructions for building a single -chambered bat house ....................................... 30 Appendix 2. Instructions for building a triple -chambered bat house ........................................ 31 Appendix 3. FWC bat house occupancy assessment protocol .................................................. 33 Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission iv LIST OF TABLES LIST OF TABLES Table 1. Conservation Action Table............................................................................................. 24 Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission v LIST OF FIGURES LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1. Florida bonneted bat house at Fred C. Babcock/Cecil M. Webb Wildlife Management Area................................................................................................................................................. 1 Figure 2. Facial features that distinguish the Florida bonneted bat (top) from the Brazilian free - tailedbat (bottom)........................................................................................................................... 3 Figure 3. Florida bonneted bat and Brazilian free -tailed bat, illustrating the size difference betweenthe species......................................................................................................................... 4 Figure 4. Suspected range (extent of occurrence) of the Florida bonneted bat. The species likely occupies only a portion of the delineated range.............................................................................. 4 Figure 5. Projected increase in area of developed land in Florida ................................................ 12 Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission vi GLOSSARY OF TERMS AND ACRONYMS GLOSSARY OF TERMS AND ACRONYMS Acoustic surveys: Monitoring technique that uses specialized equipment and software to detect the presence of bats based upon their echolocation calls. Area of Occupancy: The area within its extent of occurrence (see Extent of Occurrence), which is occupied by a taxon, excluding cases of vagrancy. This reflects the fact that a taxon will not usually occur throughout the area of its extent of occurrence, which may contain unsuitable or unoccupied habitats (as defined by International Union for Conservation of Nature [IUCN]). BRG: Biological Review Group, a group of taxa experts convened to assess the biological status of taxa using criteria specified in Rule 68A-27.001, Florida Administrative Code, and following the protocols in the Guidelines for Application of the IUCN Red List Criteria at Regional Levels (Version 3.0) and Guidelines for Using the IUCN Red List Categories and Criteria (Version 8.1). BSR: Biological status review report, the summary of the biological review group's findings. Includes a Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) staff recommendation on whether or not the species status meets the listing criteria in Rule 68A-27.001, Florida Administrative Code. These criteria, based on IUCN criteria and IUCN guidelines, are used to help decide if a species should be added or removed from the Florida Endangered and Threatened Species List. In addition, FWC staff may provide within the report a biologically justified opinion that differs from the criteria -based finding. BWWMA: Fred C. Babcock/Cecil M. Webb Wildlife Management Area DOACS: Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services ESA: Endangered Species Act of 1973 Exclusion: Legally required method for removing unwanted bats from a structure. Exclusion involves the use of a 1-way device that allows the bats to leave the structure but prevents them from returning. Holes are sealed after the bats are gone and the device is removed. Exclusions are prohibited between 15 April and 15 August because that is when young are likely to be present and remain in the roost while adults forage for food. Extent of Occurrence: The geographic area encompassing all observations of individuals of a species, including intervening areas of unoccupied habitat. Synonymous with range. See also Area of Occupancy (as defined by IUCN). F.A.C.: Florida Administrative Code, the Department of State's Administrative Code, Register and Laws Section is the filing point for rules promulgated by state regulatory agencies. Agency rulemaking is governed by Rule 120, Florida Statutes, the Administrative Procedures Act. Rules are published in the Florida Administrative Code. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission vii GLOSSARY OF TERMS AND ACRONYMS FBC: The Florida Bat Conservancy, a private, non-profit organization established to protect and preserve Florida's bats through education, conservation projects, consultation and bat rescue. Forage: To search for, acquire, and ingest food. F.S.: Florida Statutes Fragmentation: A process of environmental change, commonly caused by human -related land conversion, where once -connected habitats become divided into separate fragments. FWC: The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, the state agency constitutionally mandated to protect and manage Florida's native fish and wildlife resources. Habitat: The area used for any part of the life cycle of a species (including foraging, breeding, and sheltering). Hibernation: A state of inactivity and metabolic depression to conserve energy during periods when food is unavailable. Incidental Take: Incidental Take (as defined in Rule 68A-27.001(5), F.A.C.): Any taking otherwise prohibited, if such taking is incidental to, and not the purpose of the carrying out of an otherwise lawful activity. ISMP: Imperiled Species Management Plan IUCN: International Union for Conservation of Nature, a professional global conservation network. IUCN Red List: (IUCN Red List of Threatened Species) An objective, global approach for evaluating the conservation status of plant and animal species, the goals of which are to: Identify and document those species most in need of conservation attention if global extinction rates are to be reduced; and provide a global index of the state of change of biodiversity. NWCO: Nuisance Wildlife Control Operators, individuals licensed by the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services to address nuisance wildlife concerns according to state rules and regulations. PIT Tags: Passive Integrated Transponders, small devices inserted under the skin with a unique identification number that can be read using an external scanning device. Polyestrous: Having more than 1 season each year in which reproduction can occur. Roost: Artificial or natural structure used by bats for shelter. Roosts can be temporary or permanent. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission viii GLOSSARY OF TERMS AND ACRONYMS Scientific Collection Permit: A permit issued for activities that include salvage, voucher, bird banding, wildlife possession, or special purpose. Applications must demonstrate a scientific or educational benefit for the species, and must identify the purpose, scope, objective, methodology, location, and duration of the project. SWG: State Wildlife Grant Take: As defined in Chapter 68A-27.001(4), F.A.C. "To harass, harm, pursue, hunt, shoot, wound, kill, trap, capture, or collect, or to attempt to engage in such conduct." Torpor: A state of decreased physiological activity in an animal, usually by a reduced metabolism, heart rate, respiration, and body temperature. USFWS: United States Fish and Wildlife Service, the federal agency mandated to protect and manage the nation's native wildlife and freshwater fish resources. WMA: Wildlife Management Area Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission ix INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION Biological Background The Florida bonneted bat (Eumops floridanus) is found only in Florida and is the largest bat in the state (Timm and Genoways 2004, McDonough et al. 2008). Wagner's bonneted, or mastiff, bat (E. glaucinus) is a closely related, but more widespread species found in Central and South America. Until recently, bonneted bats in Florida were considered to be a subspecies of E. glaucinus and known as E. g. floridanus. E. floridanus is distinguished from E. glaucinus by having a significantly larger body size as well as unique morphological features of the face, mouth, and ears (Timm and Genoways 2004). Other common names for the Florida bonneted bat have included Florida mastiff bat, mastiff bat, and Wagner's mastiff bat (Belwood 1981, 1992; United States Fish and Wildlife Service [USFWS] 2012). Life History Relatively little is known about the life history, behavior, and biology of the Florida bonneted bat. Individuals are seldom encountered and most historical and current information is based on collected specimens, a small number of observations of roosting, bats and rangewide acoustic surveys that detect the Figure 1. Florida bonneted bat house at Fred C. Babcock/Cecil M. Webb Wildlife Management Area. Photograph by Jennifer Myers, FWC. presence of bats based upon their echolocation calls. Florida bonneted bats have a distinctive echolocation call that is a lower frequency that other bat species in Florida (Marks and Marks 2012). Bats roost in a variety of structures, both natural and artificial. Tree cavities, caves, rock crevices, and foliage are examples of natural roosts. Buildings, bridges, and bat houses constructed specifically to attract roosting bats are examples of artificial roosts (Kunz and Lumsden 2003). Roosts provide bats with a resting place protected from predators and the elements (Marks and Marks 2006). Roosts also provide shelter for bats to socialize, mate, and rear their young (Kunz and Lumsden 2003). Bats may occupy a roost for only a short period of time, or they may establish a permanent colony within a roost (Marks and Marks 2006). While habitat associations and natural roost site preferences of Florida bonneted bats are poorly understood, Florida bonneted bats have been documented in several roost types. In 1979, a colony of 7 females and 1 male were found roosting in an enlarged red -cockaded woodpecker (Picoides borealis) cavity in a longleaf pine (Pinus palustris) near Punta Gorda (Belwood 1981). Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission INTRODUCTION Florida bonneted bats have been found in the shafts of palm fronds in Coral Gables, as well as under Spanish -style barrel tiles on roofs in Coral Gables and Miami. A roosting colony was found in a in fissures in a limestone outcropping in Coral Gables (Belwood 1992, Timm and Genoways 2004, USFWS 2012). Detailed information on documented or suspected roosts is provided in the Habitat, Use of Forests and Other Natural Areas, Use of Parks, Residential, and Other Urban Areas sections of the Proposed Endangered Species Status for the Florida Bonneted Bat (USFWS 2012). The only current known Florida bonneted bat roosts are in bat houses located on Fred C. Babcock/Cecil M. Webb Wildlife Management Area (BWWMA) (Figure 1) and in bat houses at a private residence in North Fort Myers (USFWS 2012). Florida bonneted bats are consistently present in 1 bat house on BWWMA and the houses at the private residence. Use of the remaining bat houses on BWWMA fluctuates throughout the year (J. Myers, Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission [FWC], personal communication). Florida bonneted bats do not hibernate or typically experience periods of torpor. They are active year-round, as are most bats in Florida, although during extended cold weather events, many bats, including bonneted bats, will become torpid (Marks and Marks 2006, USFWS 2012). Florida bonneted bats feed strictly on insects and they use echolocation to detect and capture their prey year-round. They forage in flight and at night, typically returning to the roost periodically during the night (Marks and Marks 2008a). Fecal droppings from the roost in a longleaf pine tree in Punta Gorda primarily contained flying insects from orders Coleoptera, Diptera, and Hemiptera (Belwood 1981, 1992). Florida bonneted bats are fast flyers and have been observed flying at heights of 10 in (33 ft) or more over open areas (Marks and Marks 2008a). Females give birth to a single pup, and pregnant females and pups have been documented from June through September. Unlike most bats in Florida, Florida bonneted bats may be polyestrous (i.e., they have more than 1 period in which they may reproduce) with the first breeding season occurring June through July and a second occurring later in the year (Marks and Marks 2006, 2008a; Timm and Genoways 2004). Mating behaviors, gestation period, age at weaning, and other reproductive behaviors are poorly understood. Description The Florida bonneted bat is the largest bat species in Florida. Total length for adults typically ranges from 126 to 165 min (4.96 to 6.5 in), forearm length ranges between 61 and 66 mm (2.4 to 2.6 in), and body weight ranges from 30 to 47 grams (1.1 to 1.7 oz) with a pregnant female documented weighing 55 g (2 oz) (Belwood 1981, 1992; Timm and Genoways 2004, Marks and Marks 2006). Fur color varies from dark gray to brown on the dorsal (back) side of the bat, with lighter, grayish fur underneath. Individual hairs are bicolored and lighter at the base. Ears are large and broad and slant forward over the eyes, and, unlike in some similar species found in Florida, the bases of the ears are joined at the midline of the head (Marks and Marks 2006; Figure 2). Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 2 INTRODUCTION 1 Upper lip not wrinkled : 6 Ear edge thin and W not far over eye • k. Upper lip wrinkled Ears join at base Aral g 1_1 Ear edge thick and extends over eye A A Florida Bonneted Bat Ears separate at base Brazilian Free -tailed Bat Figure 2. Facial features that distinguish the Florida bonneted bat (top) from the Brazilian free - tailed bat (bottom). Photographs by Kathleen Smith, FWC. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 3 INTRODUCTION The Florida bonneted bat is among a family of bats often known as free - tailed bats because, unlike most bats, their tails extend well free of the tail membrane that stretches between their legs. Two other free -tailed bats occur in Florida, the Brazilian free -tailed bat (Tadarida brasiliensis) and Pallas' mastiff bat (Molossus molossus), but Florida bonneted bats are much larger than the other free -tailed bats in Florida (Marks and Marks 2006). Figure 3 illustrates the relative difference in size between an adult [70florida bonneted bat 'at Brazilian free -tailed bat Florida bonneted bat and an adult Figure 3. Florida bonneted bat and Brazilian free - Brazilian free -tailed bat. The Florida tailed bat, illustrating the size difference between the bonneted bat is easily distinguished species. Photograph by Chris Burney, FWC. from any other species in Florida by its free tail, large size, and ears that join at the base. Geographic Range and Distribution A survey conducted by the Florida Bat Conservancy (FBC) in 2006 and 2007 estimated the Florida bonneted bat range (FiFiVre 4). A follow-up FBC survey in 2011 and 2012 focused on the Figure 4. Suspected range (extent of occurrence) of the Florida bonneted bat. The species likely occupies only a portion of the delineated range. Source: Marks and Marks 2012. northern and southern extents of the range, but did not result in a significant change to the range map (Marks and Marks 2012, USFWS 2012). The current range includes Charlotte, Collier, Lee, Miami -Dade, and Monroe counties (Timm and Genoways 2004, Marks and Marks 2012). The area occupied within these counties is unknown, but likely is much smaller than the total area encompassed by county boundaries (Marks and Marks 2012, USFWS 2012). Fossil remains suggest the range historically included Brevard, Broward, and Indian River counties (Belwood 1992, Timm and Genoways 2004, USFWS 2012), in addition to the previously listed counties included in the current range. Acoustic surveys documented Florida bonneted bat calls at 2 locations along the Kissimmee River in Polk and Okeechobee counties in 2008 (Marks and Marks 2008b). The occurrence of the species in these counties remains uncertain (Marks and Marks 2012); however, subsequent surveys through 2013 have recorded them intermittently. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 4 INTRODUCTION Conservation History In 1992, the Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission (predecessor to the FWC) listed the Florida mastiff bat (since re-classified as the Florida bonneted bat; see Biological Background) as Endangered. In 2010, the FWC adopted a revised listing classification that combined the Endangered and Threatened categories into a single Threatened status. As a result of the Biological Review Group (BRG) status review and the revised listing classification, the Florida bonneted bat became a Threatened species on the Florida Endangered and Threatened Species List. The change to Threatened status represents a change in the classification system, and not a change in the conservation status for the species. In 1985, the USFWS included the Florida mastiff bat as a category 2 candidate species, since listing might be warranted, but data were limited. Subsequent reviews continued to consider the species as a candidate, but it was removed from the candidate list in 1996 because the taxon was considered a subspecies of E. glaucinus, was deemed more abundant than previously known, and was not in danger of identifiable threats (USFWS 2012). In 2009, after the taxonomy was reevaluated and E.g. floridanus was elevated to E. floridanus, the USFWS recognized the Florida bonneted bat as a federal candidate species in its annual Candidate Notice or Review with a Listing Priority Number of 2 (threats high in magnitude and imminent). At that time federal listing was warranted but was precluded by other higher priority listing actions. In October 2012, the USFWS proposed to list the Florida bonneted bat as a federally Endangered species under the Endangered Species Act of 1973 (ESA); this listing was accepting in 2013, extending the ESA's protections to this species (USFWS 2012). The FWC species -ranking database gave a score of 33.3 to the Florida bonneted bat (scores based on Millsap et al. 1990). A species ranking above 27 is considered potentially at risk of extinction and warrants biological status review (Rule 68A-27.0012(2)(c) I a, Florida Administrative Code [F.A.C.]). In addition, the Florida Committee on Rare and Endangered Plants and Animals included the Florida bonneted bat in the 1978 and 1992 editions of Rare and Endangered Biota of Florida (Belwood 1992). The Florida's Natural Area Inventory considers the Florida bonneted bat to have a global status of G1 (critically imperiled), due to habitat loss and restricted range (Florida Natural Areas Inventory 2012). Florida's State Wildlife Action Plan recognizes the Florida bonneted bat as a Species of Greatest Conservation Need (FWC 2011), and the International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN) currently lists the Florida bonneted bat as Critically Endangered due to small population size, very small subpopulations, and apparent continuing population decline (Timm and Arroyo-Cabrales 2008). Land acquisition specifically to protect Florida bonneted bats has not been initiated. Florida bonneted bat roosting and foraging habitat requirements are poorly understood, making it difficult to assess the amount or type of habitat that should be protected, or if currently protected lands are those most valuable for Florida bonneted bat conservation. The USFWS is expected to designate critical habitat for this species in 2014. During the FBC's 2006 through 2007 rangewide surveys, Florida bonneted bats were documented near BWWMA. In response, FWC contracted with FBC to conduct surveys on BWWMA and installed bat houses in 2007 and 2008. Surveys were conducted over 3 nights and included recording bat calls while driving slowly across the wildlife management area (WMA), Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission INTRODUCTION as well as stationary recording sites. Florida bonneted bat calls were recorded at 3 sites on BWWMA during these surveys (Marks and Marks 2008c). FWC staff at BWWMA installed 15 bat houses, comprising 8 roosts, on the WMA. Each roost consists of 1 to 2 bat houses mounted on a utility pole (Figure 1). To date, 5 roosts have been occupied by Florida bonneted bats. In 2012, FWC staff installed 5 additional roosts near existing roosts to provide additional habitat for Florida bonneted bats. The new roosts are not yet occupied. Monitoring of these bat houses is ongoing (J. Myers, personal communication). The longest -monitored colony of Florida bonneted bats is located on private property in Lee County. In the backyard of a private residence, the homeowner has 3 bat houses that are used by Florida bonneted bats. This is an example of cooperative efforts between a private landowner, conservation group, and wildlife agency. In 2012, the Florida Bonneted Bat Working Group was formed to address the conservation needs of this species across its range. Members include the FWC, USFWS, National Park Service, Zoo Miami, FBC, and several other private and public entities. Many members are also stakeholders referenced in this plan. Members of this working group are involved in conservation activities such as acoustical surveys, bat house monitoring, species education and outreach activities, as well as ongoing research projects. Threats and Recommended Listing Status In 2010, the FWC directed staff to evaluate the status of all species listed as Threatened or Species of Special Concern that had not undergone a status review in the past decade. To address this charge, staff conducted a literature review and solicited information from the public on the status of the Florida bonneted bat. The FWC convened a BRG of experts on the Florida bonneted bat to assess the biological status of the species using criteria specified in Rule 68A-27.001, F.A.C., following the protocols in the Guidelines for Application of the IUCN Red List Criteria at Regional Levels (Version 3.0) and Guidelines for Using the IUCN Red List Categories and Criteria (Version 8.1). FWC staff developed an initial draft of a Biological Status Review (BSR) report, which included the BRG's findings and a preliminary listing recommendation from staff. FWC distributed the draft for peer review, and the reviewers' input was incorporated into a final report. Threats The BRG identified the following threats to the Florida bonneted bat: 1) small population size and restricted extent of occurrence, which increases vulnerability; 2) continued loss of forested habitat; 3) potential limited roost availability; and 4) pesticides from mosquito -control operations. Additional threats identified by the BRG include low fecundity (females produce only 1 pup per year), human disturbance (persecution and removal of roosting bats in trees, buildings, or other manmade structures), prolonged or repeated episodes of cold temperature, disease, and wind farms. Recommended Listing Status The Florida bonneted bat BRG concluded from the biological assessment that the Florida bonneted bat met criteria necessary to warrant its continued listing as Threatened on the Florida Endangered and Threatened Species List. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 6 INTRODUCTION The Florida bonneted bat met the following criteria for listing: • Criterion B, Geographic Range: the extent of occurrence <20,000 km' (7,722 mil) and the population may exist in fewer than 10 locations; a continuing decline is inferred in the extent of occurrence, as well as area, extent, or quality of habitat; • Criterion D, Population Very Small or Restricted: the current population size in Florida is estimated to be fewer than 1,000 mature individuals and the population has a very restricted area of occupancy and number of locations. Other threats include stochastic events such as hurricanes, which may destroy old trees with roosting cavities (Timm and Genoways 2004, NatureServe 2010). For more information on potential threats, including climate change and disease, see the Summary of Factors Affecting the Species section of USFWS (2012). Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 7 CONSERVATION GOALS AND OBJECTIVES CONSERVATION GOALS AND OBJECTIVES The BRG found that the Florida bonneted bat met the criteria for listing as a Threatened species on the Florida Endangered and Threatened Species List. As such, the conservation goal and objective for the Florida bonneted bat are: Goal Conservation status of the Florida bonneted bat is improved such to a point that the species is secure within its historical range. Objective Initiate research to fill data gaps in current knowledge of the Florida bonneted bat and use existing information and results to promote Florida bonneted bat conservation. Rationale Many aspects of Florida bonneted bat ecology are unknown or poorly understood. The BRG identified several threats to the species, but the extent to which these threats impact Florida bonneted bats is not well understood given the lack of scientific information available for this species. The objective of this plan is to identify opportunities to fill in the gaps of what is known about Florida bonneted bats. Effective conservation of the Florida bonneted bat will depend on the support and involvement of partners and stakeholders. Developing conservation recommendations for land management or permitting guidance without a good understanding of the biology of the Florida bonneted bat is not likely to improve the status of the species, and may limit future involvement of partners. Data gathered as a result of actions outlined in this plan will be used to develop and implement conservation strategies to improve the status of the species. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission CONSERVATION ACTIONS CONSERVATION ACTIONS The following sections describe the conservation actions that will make the greatest contribution toward achieving the conservation objectives. Actions are grouped by category (e.g., Habitat Conservation and Management, Population Management). The Conservation Action Table (Table 1) identifies action priority, urgency, potential funding sources, likely effectiveness, identified partners and leads for implementation. The conservation actions are intended to conserve and expand the existing population and increase what is known about the species' range, distribution, habitat requirements, and population size. Several actions also attempt to better our understanding of Florida bonneted bat life history and ecology in order to improve conservation of the species. Completing these actions will allow us to measure progress toward the conservation goal and objective for the Florida bonneted bat. Habitat Conservation and Management General habitat management recommendations for bats include maintaining and protecting open freshwater and wetland habitat as foraging habitat (Marks and Marks 2008c). Habitat management recommendations specific to Florida bonneted bats are not currently available. Action 3 identifies the need to determine the habitat requirements of Florida bonneted bats in order to address impacts of landscape -scale changes across their range. Action 8 describes research to identify Florida bonneted bat habitat types, and Action 9 describes the need to identify what types of roosts are available, and how they are used by Florida bonneted bats. Species -specific habitat management recommendations should be developed based on the outcome of these research actions. Florida bonneted bats are known to roost in both natural and artificial structures, including tree cavities, rock outcroppings, buildings, and bat houses (see Life History) (Marks and Marks 2008a), though the only currently known roosts are in bat houses. Florida bonneted bats have been documented in urban, rural, and native landscapes. Both natural and artificial roosts could be impacted by land -management activities and stochastic events, as well as human presence and the loss of habitat due to development. Colony -roosting species like the Florida bonneted bat roost in relatively permanent and uncommon roosts (i.e., tree cavities and bat houses). They typically remain faithful to their roosts and are unlikely to switch to new roosts (Humphrey 1975, Lewis 1995). If Florida bonneted bats depend on relatively few roosts as suspected, and given their small population size and the uncertainty about availability of suitable roosts, they may well have difficulty finding and occupying new roosts. Therefore, protecting existing roosts is very important to conserving the species. The following section identifies potential threats to roosts and provides recommendations for roost protection. Roost Threats The potential impact of land -management activities such as timber management and prescribed fire on roosts is poorly understood. Timber -management activities (i.e., thinning and removal of old or live trees with cavities) may benefit bats by reducing clutter and increasing the sustainability of pine stands for foraging and commuting (Loeb and Waldrop 2008) or increasing the basal diameter of surrounding trees. However, thinning may also reduce the number of roosts available to bats. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 9 CONSERVATION ACTIONS Presumably, many bat species in the southeastern United States have evolved in ecosystems dominated by fire, and their roosting strategies may limit their vulnerability to fire (Carter et al. 2000). The effects of fire on bats can depend on a variety of characteristics such as seasonality of the burn, fire intensity, residence time (the length of time it takes flame to move over the ground), and overstory mortality (Carter et al. 2000). Fire can create snags, which can eventually become suitable for use by tree -roosting bats (Carter et al. 2000). Fire during the season when most vegetation is dormant may impact the survival of tree- or foliage -roosting bats during colder temperatures and during periods of torpor for certain species, including the Florida bonneted bat. Growing -season burns may impact the survival of non-volant (flightless) young (Carter et al. 2000). Florida bonneted bats may be polyestrous (Marks and Marks 2008a), and flightless young could be affected by fire during either the dormant or growing season. Regardless of fire season, smoke and heat from fire could impact the microclimate of the bat box. On BWWMA, prescribed burning is conducted near Florida bonneted bat houses on a 2- year rotation, on average, with no observed negative effects (J. Birchfield, FWC, personal communication); however, this determination is based on observations, not on systematic assessment. To our knowledge, no research on the Florida bonneted bat's response to prescribed fire exists, though other species' responses have been studied. Studies showed that prescribed burning may initially reduce insect availability (Lacki et al. 2009) but may increase long-term prey availability (Dickinson et al. 2009). Additionally, fire was shown to reduce canopy clutter (Boyles and Aubrey 2006, Dickinson et al. 2009) and create or restore available roost trees or snags (Boyles and Aubrey 2006, Dickinson et al. 2009, Lacki et al. 2009). Any information gained from future research on fire effects to natural and artificial roosts of the Florida bonneted bat (Action 9) should be incorporated into roost protection guidelines. Urban development can also impact Florida bonneted bat roosts. This species has been suspected of roosting in man-made structures such as the shingles of Spanish -style barrel tile roofs in Miami and Coral Gables (Belwood 1992), attics, fireplaces, and brick chimneys (NatureServe 2010). Florida bonneted bats may be killed or injured when dwellings are demolished (Robson 1989) or when they take up residence in structures where they are not wanted. Pest control companies unaware of or non -compliant with the regulations (Rule 68A-9.010, F.A.C.) that apply to bats have been known to remove them through methods other than legal exclusions (see Rule and PermittingIntent, information on Florida Administrative Code number Rule 68A- 4.001. F.A.C., General Prohibitions, and Rule 68A-9.010, F.A.C., Taking Nuisance Wildlife, and Roost -Protection Guidelines). Across the southern United States, bats roost in an estimated 3,600 highway structures such as bridges and overpasses (Keeley and Tuttle 1999). Repair and maintenance of these structures can be detrimental to roosting bats, as can road construction such as road -widening projects. Other Eumops species (i.e., E. underwoodi and E. perotis) are not known to roost in bridges or overpasses (Keeley and Tuttle 1999). Florida bonneted bats have not been documented roosting in highway structures, though their presence has been documented near bridges and overpasses that could be suitable roost sites (Keeley and Tuttle 1999, USFWS 2012; C. Marks, FBC, personal communication) and their potential use of highway structures cannot be ruled out given the few documented occurrences of the species across its range. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 10 CONSERVATION ACTIONS Action 1 Develop recommendations for protecting the roosts of Florida bonneted bats. Although more research should be conducted to determine which specific land -management activities can create or preserve Florida bonneted bat roosts (Action 9), the following list of recommendations should be incorporated into land management and nuisance bat technical assistance (Action 1). This list should be revisited as results of research become available. Roost -Protection Guidelines: Old trees and snags with hollows and cavities should be retained in natural areas such as Everglades National Park, Big Cypress National Preserve, Fakahatchee Strand Preserve State Park, and BWWMA (Belwood 1992). If dead or old trees must be felled, they should be examined for bat roosts and occupation by other imperiled species prior to felling (Marks and Marks 2008b), especially since no locations of natural Florida bonneted bat roost sites or roost selection preferences are currently known. If bats are found, managers are encouraged to consult with the FWC to accurately identify the species and discuss an appropriate course of action. Nuisance wildlife control operators (NWCOs), biologists, and law enforcement personnel within the range of the Florida bonneted bat should be informed that the breeding season of the Florida bonneted bat is uncertain, and that the bats may have young in the roost outside of the typical maternity season. Until more information on the breeding season is obtained and the exclusion rule modified (Actions 15 and 16), we recommend consultation with FWC before excluding Florida bonneted bats from a roost at any time of the year. Increase public land acquisition within the range of the Florida bonneted bat. Land acquisition can assist with protecting roosts, breeding, and foraging areas. Publically managed lands allow for more oversight of land management activities through the required development of state -approved management plans and provide general protections from development. Increase conservation easements and other voluntary conservation efforts on private lands. Educate pest control companies, NWCOs, homeowners and homeowners associations, and local government staff to minimize injury and fatality of Florida bonneted bats in urban areas (Actions 17 and 19). This applies to bats that are roosting in buildings or vegetation such as palm trees that may be managed as landscaping. Take steps to prevent vandalism at known roosts. Vandalism can be a threat to roost cavities and artificial roosts of Florida bonneted bats. At this time, it has not been a main concern at BWWMA, but adequate law enforcement presence and frequent roost checks by biological staff on publically managed lands may deter vandals. Action 2 Develop and implement guidelines for building, installing, and monitoring bat houses for Florida bonneted bats. Bat houses can be useful tools in the conservation and promotion of bats on public and private land because they provide roosting habitat that may otherwise be lacking. Florida bonneted bats are among the species that use bat houses (Marks and Marks 2006). At BWWMA, Florida bonneted bats inhabit single -chamber and triple -chambered bat houses (J. Birchfield, personal communication). More research on the role of bat houses in Florida bonneted bat conservation Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 11 CONSERVATION ACTIONS should be conducted (Action 9). Specific recommendations regarding Florida bonneted bat houses are not available, though species experts provide general suggestions to consider when installing bat houses within the Florida bonneted bat's range. These general recommendations should be evaluated to ensure they address the needs of Florida bonneted bats roosting in bat houses. New recommendations should incorporate research results on natural and artificial roosts (Action 9). Until further research is conducted on the role of bat houses for Florida bonneted bats, general recommendations for building and installing bat houses can be found in the Bat Conservation International's Criteria for Successful Bat Houses, Appendices 1 and 2 (Marks and Marks 2006). FWC bat house monitoring protocols should be followed for bat houses installed within the Florida bonneted bat range (Appendix 3 and Actions 3, 5, 9, 17, and 18). If Florida bonneted bats are suspected in an occupied bat house, managers are encouraged to coordinate with FWC. Action 3 Develop landscape -level recommendations for the conservation of the Florida bonneted bat using information from research on rate of habitat loss, conversion, and alteration. Habitat loss and reduction of forested areas are serious threats to the Florida bonneted bat's survival, according to the BSR. Florida's human population is predicted to increase to 36 million by 2060 and about 28,300 km2 (11,000 mil) of land may be converted from rural and natural to urban uses (Zwick and Carr 2006, Fi ure 5). The projected loss and fragmentation of natural habitat may adversely affect Projected land use in 2060 Current land use or. 0 Developed land Conservation land Vndevekpped land Figure 5. Projected increase in area of developed land in Florida. Source: Zwick and Carr 2006. Florida bonneted bats; however, this species occurs in urban areas and uses structures such as chimneys and roofs for roosting (Belwood 1992). Because the survival and productivity rates of Florida bonneted bats in urban areas are unknown, it is not possible to accurately predict the impact of increasing urbanization on Florida bonneted bat populations. One adverse impact of more urban roosts is increasing human interaction and associated increase in exclusions. Expanded bat education programs (Action 7) and installation of alternate roosts may help offset adverse impacts. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 12 CONSERVATION ACTIONS The Florida bonneted bat population may number less than a few hundred individuals (Marks and Marks 2008a). Restricted range and low fecundity may make it vulnerable to extinction due to inbreeding depression, random environmental changes, or genetic drift (USFWS 2012). Almost 50% of the 12 known occurrences of the Florida bonneted bat are on private property (Marks and Marks 2008a, 2008d). Florida bonneted bat use of private or public lands are not well understood and it would be imprudent to make management recommendations to address these threats at this time. The Monitoring and Research section describes actions that, when implemented, will aid in identifying species -specific management recommendations. Increased urbanization also increases the Florida bonneted bat's risk for removal, exclusion, or persecution due to human —wildlife conflict as discussed in Action 1. Establishment of wind turbines is a concern in some areas because they obstruct existing bat flight corridors and can be sources of bat mortality (Kunz et al. 2007). Some research suggests that bats may even be attracted to the wind turbines out of curiosity, misperception, or as potential feeding, roosting, flocking, and mating opportunities (Cryan and Barclay 2009). Wind farms have been proposed in southern Florida near Loxahatchee National Wildlife Refuge and on the west side of Lake Okeechobee near Fisheating Creek (Melissa Tucker, FWC, personal communication). Adherence to the USFWS Land -Based Wind Energy Guidelines for siting wind farms, along with consultation with FWC, is recommended to wind farm developers, as is more research to determine impacts of these installations on Florida bonneted bat populations. Habitat changes and landscape alterations will occur, but how they will affect the Florida bonneted bat is unknown, as we do not yet know what habitat components and landscape features Florida bonneted bats require. More research should be conducted to determine the rate of loss, conversion, and alteration of the habitat of Florida bonneted bats. Specific research that would assist with these findings are habitat preferences (Action 8), population size and distribution (Action 11), and roost selection characteristics (Action 9). Results of this research can be incorporated in habitat management recommendations for public and private lands (Action 3). Population Management Action 4 Assess the need for potential management actions for Florida bonneted bats roosting in bat houses during extreme weather events, such as hurricanes or freezes, and develop guidelines if appropriate. Severe weather events may affect the survival of the small, fragmented population of Florida bonneted bats. On BWWMA, all occupied Florida bonneted bat houses are located within 16 km (10 mi) of each other. The occupied bat houses in North Fort Myers are within 26 km (16 mi) of BWWMA (J. Myers, personal communication). If a hurricane significantly impacted Charlotte or Lee counties, the occupied bat houses would likely be damaged. Bats in the family Molossidae, including Florida bonneted bats, appear to be physiologically intermediate between temperate- and tropical -zone bats (Arlettaz et al. 2000). They can tolerate moderately cold temperatures but may die following prolonged exposure to cold. During a severe freeze throughout much of southern Florida in 2010, at least 8 Florida bonneted bats died in a bat Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 13 CONSERVATION ACTIONS house in North Fort Myers (S. Trokey, private land owner, personal communication). Natural roosts may be better insulated than bat houses and thus provide better shelter and survival during cold temperatures, but this is merely speculation. Action 4 relates specifically to determining whether bats roosting in bat houses need additional protection during extremely cold weather. Appropriate response to potential severe weather events should be determined. Short-term relocation of individuals from bat houses may prevent their immediate demise, but long-term effects to the bats are unknown. Management guidelines for bat houses should be developed based on current knowledge. Guidelines may change following results of research proposed in Monitoring and Research. Interventions such as insulating or heating a bat house during severe cold weather, or physically bringing bats indoors need to be studied further to determine if they are necessary or if they could be detrimental (Action 9). Factors that may initiate intervention (duration of cold weather, low -temperature threshold) need to be further studied before guidelines can be developed. If Florida bonneted bats are using a bat house, we recommend consultation with FWC before taking action in advance of a severe weather event or if dead or cold -stunned bats are found below the bat house. Monitoring and Research As noted in the BSR and a recent federal assessment, information on population size and geographic range of Florida bonneted bats is quite limited (USFWS 2012). The available information was sufficient to determine that the Florida bonneted bat warrants the highest level of imperiled status in Florida (listing as Threatened on the Florida Endangered and Threatened Species List), but more specific and local information is needed. Several conservation actions listed here will generate needed information on geographic range, habitat use, population size, productivity and survival, and roost use. This information will greatly increase our understanding of the Florida bonneted bat and thereby improve our ability to conserve the species. Action 5 Develop a database of occurrence information and research findings. Because the Florida bonneted bat is rare and difficult to detect, information about the species has come from incidental sightings or irregular monitoring and is not readily available. Compiling occurrence and location information into a database would help researchers know what data is available; but just as importantly, it helps identify what data need to be collected. In particular, a data repository for information about roost sites would be useful in determining the types of roosts used and their location (Action 9). Currently, incidental observations of roosts are largely unavailable to most biologists. Results from long-term monitoring of roost use or large-scale acoustic surveys could be compiled in a central location and made available for subsequent analysis or review by anyone interested in conservation of Florida bonneted bats (see Coordination with Other Entities). Having a central repository might also help in setting standards or examples of the types of data that need to be collected (Action 6). A functional and useful central database for Florida bonneted bats will require planning to determine what information needs to be included, the types of assistance from partners who can provide information (Action 18), and the level of commitment from database managers to keep the database current and readily accessible. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 14 CONSERVATION ACTIONS Action 6 Develop standard methods for detecting presence of Florida bonneted bats. Action 7 Determine the current geographic range (i.e., extent of occurrence and area of occupancy) for Florida bonneted bats. Action 8 Identify Florida bonneted bat roosting and foraging habitat. Florida bonneted bats range over a small area of southern Florida, but that area includes a wide variety of habitats, and their distribution across those habitats is poorly known (USFWS 2012). Recent acoustic surveys have detected Florida bonneted bats repeatedly in only 4 counties and infrequently at a few sites in 3 other counties (Geographic Range and Distribution; Marks and Marks 2012). Because monitoring has been restricted to areas accessible by roads and relatively few bats have been detected, the distribution of the Florida bonneted bats and their use of different habitat types both for roosting and foraging remains poorly known (Marks and Marks 2012, USFWS 2012). As a consequence, the extent of occurrence of the Florida bonneted bat remains only coarsely known (extrapolated to counties) and the area occupied is largely undetermined. Better defining the geographic range of the Florida bonneted bat and identifying habitat types used for roosting and foraging are important steps in conserving this species in Florida (Action 7 and this action). Acoustic monitoring of the echolocation calls of Florida bonneted bats is the most efficient means of detecting these fast, high -flying animals. Before extensive monitoring is implemented, research is needed to determine how detection probability is affected by the survey methods, including type of monitoring equipment and the height and orientation of detectors. Survey methods should also be developed in conjunction with statisticians and species experts prior to implementing an acoustic monitoring program (Action 6). An acoustic monitoring program could be implemented to determine the geographic range and foraging habitats of the Florida bonneted bat by identifying areas where bats are present (Action 7). Analysis of data from the acoustic monitoring, particularly a multiple -scale approach using occupancy modeling, could provide useful information on the landscape features and habitat types used most often by Florida bonneted bats (Action 8). It is important to not only identify specific habitat components that are used by Florida bonneted bats for roosting and foraging on a local scale, but to also identify which factors influence selection of habitat on a landscape scale. On areas where land - management information is readily available, it should be incorporated into analyses to assess potential impacts of activities such as prescribed fire or mechanical vegetation treatments on Florida bonneted bats (Actions 1, 2, and 3). This information would be useful in helping to better map and monitor Florida bonneted bat distribution and to manage habitats for the species. In 2012, FWC awarded a grant to researchers at the University of Florida titled "Closing Data Gaps for the Florida Bonneted Bat (Eumops floridanus)." Funding came from Florida's State Wildlife Grants (SWG) Program. The objectives included in this grant are: 1) to develop a protocol that can be used for monitoring bonneted bats to determine population trends; 2) to determine habitat associations of the bonneted bat for foraging and roosting, surveying a minimum of 7 habitat types and 10 locations in southern Florida; and 3) to provide recommendations for additional conservation measures for bonneted bats. This grant was funded and work began in July 2013. Funding of the SWG grant, implementation of projects to meet the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 15 CONSERVATION ACTIONS grant objectives, and results from data collected will begin the implementation of Actions 6, 7, 8, and 9. Action 9 Determine what kinds of roost sites are available and how they are used. Florida bonneted bats use natural roost sites in cavities of trees, but they also utilize artificial structures including buildings and bat houses (Life History; Belwood 1981, 1992; USFWS 2012). Because Florida bonneted bats roost in small colonies, their roosts are typically small in size and difficult to detect. Currently, the only known roosts are in a few bat houses in Charlotte and Lee counties (Conservation History; USFWS 2012). The availability of roosts and disturbance of roosts are important factors in the conservation of colonial bats, but little is known about the availability of potential natural roost sites for Florida bonneted bats or how frequently roosts are disturbed (e.g., by humans, predators, storms, or fire) (USFWS 2012). We know that Florida bonneted bats will use bat houses, but we do not know to what extent the presence of bat houses may impact their use of natural roosts, or if their use of bat houses indicates that natural roost sites may be lacking. We also know little about how many roosts Florida bonneted bats typically use, how often they switch among roosts, whether certain habitats are preferred for roosting, or the characteristics that make a tree or other structure suitable as a roost. All this information would help managers most effectively and efficiently provide and protect suitable roosts for Florida bonneted bats (Actions 1 and 2) and should be addressed in future research. Artificial Roosts We do not know how important bat houses are to the conservation of Florida bonneted bats. Research should aid in identifying the appropriate style, number, density, and placement of bat houses that may be beneficial (Action 2). Occupied bat houses on BWWMA could be used to study roost switching, seasonal use of roosts, and preferences between artificial and natural roosts. They could also be used to evaluate potential effects of land -management practices such as prescribed fire and tree thinning (Action 1). Information gained from regular observations of the occupied houses and records of the number of bats present before and after land -management treatments will be useful. Even more useful information could be obtained if individual bats were marked with passive integrated transponder (PIT) tags and houses were fitted with PIT readers. In this way, detailed information about roost use could be collected for many individuals, and use of different styles or locations of bat house could be identified. Regardless of the method used to collect data on use of bat houses, it is critically important that research questions, study objectives, details of methods, and analysis techniques all be determined prior to collecting data and in conjunction with species experts and statisticians. Otherwise, it may be difficult to gain useful information from the data collected. Any research at bat houses on BWWMA will be supervised by the FWC, and will require a scientific collection permit (Rule and Permitting) to ensure protection of the roosts. Researchers may also require permits from the USFWS. Natural Roosts Natural roost sites are most efficiently located by tracking bats back to roosts, typically by following bats that have been captured, fitted with a radio transmitter, and released. Unfortunately, Florida bonneted bats are difficult to capture and the few that have been fitted Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 16 CONSERVATION ACTIONS with radios have not tolerated the devices (J. Gore, personal communication). A first step in finding roosts and learning more about them will be determining how to keep radio transmitters attached without harming the bats. Trials could be conducted using bats occupying bat houses at BWWMA; any research at those sites will be supervised by the FWC and require a scientific collection permit (Rule and PermittingIntent) to ensure protection of the roosts. Action 10 Assess genetic diversity across the population. Most aspects of Florida bonneted bat genetics are unknown (Timm and Genoways 2004). Because the population is believed to be quite small and may have gone through genetic bottlenecks following hurricanes or other environmental perturbations, genetic diversity may be low and be limiting population viability (USFWS 2012). Furthermore, it is not known whether subpopulations exist across the species' range and whether these are genetically isolated. For example, if the absence of records of Florida bonneted bats in the open expanses of the Everglades (Marks and Marks 2012) is more than a sampling limitation, then Florida bonneted bat populations in southeastern Florida are reproductively isolated and may be genetically distinct from those in southwestern Florida. It is important to assess genetic diversity across the population so that steps can be taken to improve diversity, especially if associated effects upon population viability are identified. Action 11 Develop and implement range -wide surveys to estimate population size. Because bats are highly mobile and difficult to detect, counting individuals and accurately assessing population size is very difficult (Kunz 2003). Most population estimates have been for species that roost in colonies where individuals can be counted consistently over time. Unfortunately, Florida bonneted bats roost only in relatively small colonies, few of which are known (Timm and Genoways 2004); therefore, population estimates are limited to small portions of the total populations. Although it may not be possible to accurately estimate population size, occupancy modeling (Action 8), analysis of genetic diversity (Action 10), or other approaches may provide useful information about population size. These methods and others should be evaluated with a goal of developing surveys to estimate population size. If numerous roosts are identified (Action 9), the number of bats using the roosts could be monitored and a trend of bat numbers (colony size) potentially could be used as an indicator of a correlated trend in the size of the overall population (Kunz 2003). This information would be useful in assessing changes in population size and would be especially useful if it closely correlated with any observed change in geographic range (Action 7). However, accurately estimating population size may not be practical or possible, and completing Actions 7, 8, 9, and 10 are of higher priority. Action 12 Determine Florida bonneted bat breeding biology, productivity, and survival rates. Action 13 Determine specifically what Florida bonneted bats eat and how their diet varies across their range and over time. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 17 CONSERVATION ACTIONS Action 14 Determine effects of environmental toxins, including pesticides, on Florida bonneted bats. Little is known about Florida bonneted bat reproduction and diet. The breeding season remains poorly determined, except that pregnant females have been found in July, August, and September, and young have been found in all seasons (Belwood 1992, Timm and Genoways 2004). It is possible that females are polyestrous and may form breeding harems in small colonies with a dominant male (Belwood 1981). Females are known to produce a single young, but gestation period, age at reproduction, number of young produced, and survival rates are not known. Knowing this basic information (Action 12) would allow managers to make better decisions about the timing of management activities near roost sites (Action 1) and would allow biologists to make better estimates of population viability. Florida bonneted bats are insectivorous but specific components of their diet are not well understood, and current knowledge is based on a single study with a small sample size (see Life History) (Belwood 1981, 1992). Presumably, they feed primarily upon flying insects, but, unlike most bats, they can take off readily from the ground, so it is possible that they also feed upon ground -dwelling invertebrates or even small vertebrates. Analysis of fecal droppings from known roosts, particularly advanced analysis of genetic material in feces, should provide a clear picture of the diet of Florida bonneted bats (Action 13). However, fecal collection at occupied bat houses can be difficult. On BWWMA, occupied bat houses are in areas that are inundated seasonally with water and almost daily rains during the summer and early fall make fecal collection very difficult. Collecting viable samples can be time consuming and requires daily visits to occupied bat houses Q. Myers, personal communication). Much of the range of the Florida bonneted bat is along urban or agricultural areas where the bats might be exposed to environmental toxins (particularly pesticides) which could adversely affect their health (Clark 1988). The effect of environmental toxins on Florida bonneted bats could be determined by measuring contaminant levels in bats or their insect prey and identifying any association between those levels and productivity and survival of bats (Action 14). If adverse effects are identified, managers could take steps to curtail the exposure of the bats. Rule and Permitting Intent The Florida bonneted bat is to be retained as a Threatened species in Florida, using the currently accepted scientific name (Eumops floridanus) and common name (Florida bonneted bat). Action 15 provides recommendations to incorporate research into protective measures specifically for the Florida bonneted bat. Action 15 Use results of research on Florida bonneted bat life history to develop needed protections. Existing Regulations It is illegal to take bats in Florida in accordance with the general prohibitions in Rule 68A-4.001, F.A.C., but enforcement of this rule is challenging. Colonial -roosting bats that occupy manmade structures are at increased risk of roost destruction and are particularly vulnerable during the maternity season, when bats gather to give birth and raise young. To address these risks, Rule Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 18 CONSERVATION ACTIONS 68A-9.010, F.A.C., provides protections for bats when they take up temporary or permanent residence in dwellings or other manmade structures, such as bridges and overpasses, where human —wildlife conflict may occur. These protections regulate how and when bats may be removed from structures. Exclusion devices (physical barriers that allow bats to exit a structure but not re-enter) are the only legal means of removing bats; the rule requires the use of an exclusion device prior to building repairs if bats are present, and describes the appropriate methods for the use of the exclusion device during the timeframe outside of the maternity season. The FWC provides information and technical assistance on excluding bats online and through regional Wildlife Assistance Biologists. As a Threatened species, the Florida bonneted bat is also protected under Chapter 68A-27, F.A.C., Rules Relating to Endangered or Threatened Species, specifically Rule 68A- 27.003(2)(a), F.A.C., for state -designated Threatened species. This rule states that: • No person shall take, possess, or sell any of the Endangered or Threatened species included in this subsection, or parts thereof or their nests or eggs except as allowed by specific federal or state permit or authorization. • Permit requirements for intentional take and incidental take are currently defined in Rule 68A-27.007(2), F.A.C., and are applicable to the Florida bonneted bat. The intent of protections should include protection of roosting sites, which are different from nesting sites as described in current rule, and should be in accordance with the objectives outlined in this action plan or other recovery plans. These additional considerations are discussed in detail in the Additional Protection Needed section. • Permit requirements for intentional take and incidental take are currently defined in Rule 68A-27.007(2), F.A.C., and are applicable to the Florida bonneted bat. Any research that requires handling Florida bonneted bats will require a scientific collection permit. On BWWMA, individuals who want to collect data on the occupied bat houses without disturbing occupied bat houses or handling bats have been granted access to the WMA through a Special Use Permit issued by FWC. This permit allows for access to closed areas on WMAs and provides conditions for conducting activities. Due to increasing requests for access specifically to collect echolocation calls at occupied bat houses, and in anticipation of future research projects that may result in an increase in requests for access with the potential for cumulative disturbance impacts to Florida bonneted bats, a scientific collection permit will now be required to collect Florida bonneted bat data on BWWMA, unless such work is done in conjunction with ongoing FWC activities or FWC staff. The application for the scientific collection permit is available online. Applications are reviewed by FWC's Mammal Taxa Coordinator, Biologists in the Species Conservation Planning Section, internal species experts, and regional and local staff. Anyone conducting research on the Florida bonneted bat should be aware that additional permits for research activities that involve handling bonneted bats may be needed from the USFWS or from the agencies that manage properties accessed for research (e.g., Water Management Districts, National Park Service). The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service proposed to list the Florida bonneted bat in 2012, and the listing was accepted in 2013, adding the Florida bonneted bat to the list of Endangered Species protected under the Endangered Species Act of 1973. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 19 CONSERVATION ACTIONS Additional Protections Needed As discussed in the Introduction and Actions I and 12, Florida bonneted bats are suspected to have 2 breeding seasons each year. Action 12 describes research needs regarding Florida bonneted bat reproduction. If this research indicates that Florida bonneted bats have a different maternity season than other bat species in Florida, additional protections will be needed (Action 15). Current protective measures contained in Rule 68A-9.010, F.A.C., prevent bat exclusions from taking place between 15 April and 15 August. However, these measures do not require individuals conducting an exclusion to first determine what bat species or group of species would be affected by the exclusion. If a bat roost includes Florida bonneted bats and exclusion is conducted pursuant to the current guidelines, it could still result in take by death of young remaining in the roost after the exclusion, if Florida bonneted bats are found to have a maternity season that falls in the window for allowed exclusions. To prevent take of Florida bonneted bats during exclusions, the following additional protections need to be addressed: 1. Identification of bat species roosting in structures. Visual inspections may be possible in some cases, but roosts are often located in inaccessible areas of a structure (e.g., behind walls, under tiles, or above soffits). Acoustic surveys may be another method to identify what species or group of species are using the roost prior to exclusion (Action 15). 2. Identification of the breeding and maternity seasons for the Florida bonneted bat. This may require reducing the season in which exclusions may be conducted within the range of the Florida bonneted bat. The FWC recommends using only qualified and experienced NWCOs to exclude bats, and provides technical assistance for dealing with bats when they create human —wildlife conflicts. While very few violations of Rule 68A-9.010, F.A.C., are reported to FWC, it is not clear how often exclusions occur that are inconsistent with regulations. It is also not known if most individuals conducting nuisance wildlife work can distinguish between Florida bonneted bats and other bat species. Despite the protections provided to bats in general and to Florida bonneted bats via Rule 68A-9.010 and Chapter 68A-27, F.A.C., there is still concern that Florida bonneted bats may be excluded during sensitive time periods or are being removed from roosts using prohibited methods (C. Marks, personal communication). An additional issue to consider in roost protection during exclusions is that removal of pest species "in, on, or under" a structure is regulated by the Structural Pest Control Act (Chapter 482, Florida Statues [F.S.] and Rule 5E-14, F.A.C.) through the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services (DOACS). This act primarily focuses on the regulation of pesticide use; however, many NWCOs that remove animals from attics or crawl spaces are also regulated by this act. Full licensing as a pest -control operator requires extensive knowledge of pesticides, and this requirement is not applicable to most NWCOs. To address this, DOACS amended Chapter 482, F.S., to include a limited certification for commercial wildlife management personnel (s. 482.157, F.S.), which is required for anyone removing rats and mice, but is encouraged for those removing other species from buildings. DOACS training materials do not include specific recommendations for Florida bonneted bats, and are not adequate to assure conservation of bats in general. Action 19 addresses these concerns through coordination with DOACS. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 20 CONSERVATION ACTIONS To improve conservation of bats roosting in structures, we recommend implementing Actions 15, 16, 17, and 19 to improve compliance with existing rules and knowledge about the Florida bonneted bat. Threats to the Florida bonneted bat were identified by the BRG, but research is needed to understand how these threats may be impacting populations. New regulations or permitting related to habitat loss and roost protection in natural areas are not recommended at this time because of the lack of information about the life history of the Florida bonneted bat. As research actions are implemented and new information is acquired, additional protections or permitting requirements may be suggested in the future (Action 15). Law Enforcement Action 16 Develop and implement an FWC Law Enforcement training module for Florida bonneted bats. In conjunction with federal, state, and local partners, the FWC's Division of Law Enforcement is responsible for enforcing Florida's wildlife and fisheries laws. FWC biologists and other bat experts can educate law enforcement officers through the development, circulation, and interpretation of identification tools, distribution maps, handling, and other approved methods for dealing with unwanted bats (Action 16). Since the Florida bonneted bat can be mistaken for other bat species, proper identification tools will be important for documenting violations of Florida's wildlife laws. In turn, an important component of the enforcement strategy is ensuring compliance through public education (Action 17). FWC law enforcement officers understand the importance of explaining wildlife laws to the public to avoid unintentional violations. However, FWC law enforcement officers actively pursue and recommend prosecution for those who intentionally violate wildlife laws. FWC law enforcement officers also educate the public on how to identify and report violations. The Division of Law Enforcement administers the Wildlife Alert program, which receives information via a toll -free number (1-888-404-3922) answered 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Incentives and Influencing Influencing The BSR and this plan identify the threats to the Florida bonneted bat that have warranted state listing, as well as regulatory recommendations that may afford them protection from take. The FWC is working to develop recommendations for protecting Florida bonneted bat roosts (Action 1) and landscape -level recommendations for the conservation of the Florida bonneted bat (Action 1). Existing efforts to influence county and city governments, private landowners, and other state and private entities should incorporate these recommendations wherever possible. Incentive Programs The FWC's Landowner Assistance Program advances species conservation objectives through public -private conservation partnerships. FWC also takes advantage of several programs that promote conservation by providing technical and financial assistance to private landowners. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 21 CONSERVATION ACTIONS FWC partners with other state and federal agencies to administer the Forest Stewardship Program, Wildlife Habitat Incentives Program, Wetlands Reserve Program, Environmental Quality Incentives Program, Partners for Fish and Wildlife Program, and the Cooperative Conservation Blueprint. Florida also provides tax incentives, including property tax exemptions for landowners that put a perpetual conservation easement on their land. Additional incentives may include exemption from permits for activities that enhance wildlife activities such as mowing, roller -chopping, and tree stand thinning, as long as they are not a precursor to development or negatively impacting imperiled species. Any number of these incentive programs may be applicable for working with private landowners to identify, protect, and manage existing and potential habitat for the Florida bonneted bat. Education and Outreach Bats are often misunderstood by the public. Misinformation can often lead to persecution of bats. Because the Florida bonneted bat is so rare, most people are not aware of the existence of this species. Education and outreach is critical to develop awareness of the needs of Florida bonneted bats (Action 17), and all bat species. Within FWC, education for staff responding to public requests for assistance with bats within the range of the Florida bonneted bat is also critical. Support from stakeholders and conservation partners will be an important component in implementation of conservation actions listed in this plan (Action 18). Action 17 Develop and implement an education and outreach program on the Florida bonneted bat, including development of a Florida bonneted bat webpage for public use. Target audiences for this program include, but are not limited to: • Land managers • Conservation planners • City and county governments • Pesticide applicators • Licensed NWCOs • Homeowners and homeowners associations • Developers and environmental consultants Educational materials will have greater impact if tailored to the target audience. The following key messages should be included: • The Florida bonneted bat is listed by the FWC as a Threatened species, and is also listed by USFWS as Endangered; they are therefore protected by state and federal regulations. • Bats in general are beneficial to have in nature, and the presence of this rare species in south Florida contributes to the uniqueness of that region of the state. • Bats in buildings or in other situations where they could create human —wildlife conflicts are still protected, and resources are available to help address any potential problems. • Because Florida bonneted bats are so rare, actions taken to conserve the species and learn more about their natural history are very important. • Bat houses have the potential to be an important conservation tool for Florida bonneted bats (Action 2). • Roost protection guidelines and general habitat management guidelines will be provided if they become available. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 22 CONSERVATION ACTIONS Coordination with Other Entities A number of partners, including other state agencies, federal and county governments, universities, research and consulting groups, and private individuals take an interest in the conservation of Florida bonneted bats. Research and monitoring are high -priority actions for Florida bonneted bats, and many other entities are currently pursuing projects involving this species across its range. In addition to the information outlined in the plan, the Conservation Action Table (Table 1) identifies priorities for research actions, and suggests specific information that should be included in ongoing and future Florida bonneted bat research. Action 5 recommends development of a database of research and occurrence information, which will require coordination with other entities to complete. This should include coordinating with the Department of Health to ensure that agency is aware of FWC's interest in any bat specimen that may be a Florida bonneted bat. FWC maintains a bat mortality database for reporting sick or dead bats. Anyone who finds a bat that appears sick, is acting in an unusual manner, or is dead is encouraged to report that information by calling FWC's Wildlife Alert phone number (1-888- 404-3922) or completing the FWC's form for reporting sick, unusually behaving, or dead bats. Action 18 describes an opportunity for continued coordination among conservation partners. Action 18 Maintain FWC involvement in the Florida Bonneted Bat Working Group. In 2012, the Florida Bonneted Bat Working Group formed to address the conservation needs of this species across its range. Members include the FWC, USFWS, National Park Service, Zoo Miami, FBC, and several other private and public entities. Many members are also stakeholders referenced in this plan. Continuation of this working group will aid in communication among conservation partners for Florida bonneted bats and will aid in implementation of many conservations actions outlined in this plan. Action 19 Work with DOACS to improve educational materials provided to NWCOs through the limited commercial wildlife management certification. The limited certification for commercial wildlife control operators requires that an applicant pass a test that includes acceptable methods for removal of wildlife from structures. The current set of documents that serve as study material does not provide any information about the Florida bonneted bat and provides a very limited set of guidelines for conducting exclusions. Incorporating the expertise of bat biologists and partners to improve the study material will benefit the Florida bonneted bat and bats in general (Action 19). The module developed in Action 16 could be an appropriate model for the information to include in reference material for DOACS. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 23 -d " a - o� oz - v _ o. - ° ffif ;; oE m w m - - - _ 3 EK Ea - - - ° oE'w'2 _-fir > o - -- i m m i a m = c `o_ t v C v E S Iw - g a a 3 E 3 - _F - - vz v - 3 ° -_ - a_ 1cc °3 - - - - o `w - - - ` - - - m E.� - - o30 3'E - -oc vo'� - _- - - o E - - mw E c -_ - - -_ a E - - - - _o. E rs a 3 3 n c E o v o 3 -- a - - _- or- o ---- o --- -a3 E o' 23° 3 'L 3 -o o_ E o =0 a o E o _ s >, E o 3 c E 3 o _ 2 c 'xm t 'xm n t w° 3 01 w n E n 'xm v 3 3 �°, 'xm 3 m 12 o m A m E °1 E °1 E °1 E °1 E °1 E av� m° m° m° m° m° m° LL 3 LL 3 LL 3 LL 3 LL"IZ LL 3 `o w E i c _- = J v LL i LL i LL i t t - E 3 A 3 " 3 �_ ° 3 ° 3 ° 3 �_ ° 3 wg ° 3 Y V .f V .r^ V LL N 3-_ 8� W m W m W m W m W m W m g m o c _ E o E �_ E "- z5t o f m iz a= AL r r r r r ° o Q >3Epgo SE 8 �- _dim •`-°aw 3 z 3 3 3 3 9 z i z z z z ° w i c u W ° o o c o a t a.2 w E m z L z - - - o a E E a E w °,y' a E w c c72w c o - °o t - E _ w E w _ o - c o a q o>_ 1O ° E -wE-°° - °0 3 v m E 0 0 q_ - - m E _ Eoo �- zEvvd- o n o a' o- ¢ E a w 0 w n jagwnN wail u°pay - sai i E a PassaJPPV (s)anlyialg0 d3 o _ E o c E v a C m_ c a o o ;2 o s `o E z° i o `m t°n - n E — - ` _ g oo '' w E m a - _ c3i — _ __ -go m 6 Eo 6 o V n E —o 2= U D `mR RLL a w -� w _ -_ a 3 w c a -` Nj. � o _ -_ °- 0 2` E 3 �- t 3 zo- t o A 3go a ' o t o t o ° - n E 3 ma - 5 3 5 3 5 3 - - o Z m a v w w_ a r o f a E� , - - Y 3 0 - v - v _ o n 3 ° i o t �.i o° f E°° 3 w s E m _ s° o i$ i$ o= v m E m E m E m E m E m E m E m E E $ m° t� 'o t� m° t� m° m° t� 2 m° 2 _ _ _ _ _ _ - LL3 LL3 LL3 LL3 LL3 LL3 LL3 LL3 o^1Z - m•� z� 3 � � 3 3 3 3 3 01 E JE39 3`A 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 r� "= it c ° 3 c_ ° 3 c o 3 " 3 c ° 3 o" 3 _ _ LLN "� 38 y`3 v o ` r~ E oko_ m m m m m m m m E r r r r r r r r �uE _s ` i s Y m- 0 z 0 z 0 z 0 z 0 z 0 z 0 z 0 z ° �- > > > > > > > > Q i3E c SE 8 to •`o v" w k` --- p z ❑ z p z 3 3 3 3 3 -A. a a a z z z z z O 'oi= w z o w w w o a z o lo lo c. w E _ 3 N o E o E ow ° m 3 a 3 r _ ` c 3 'Ewo — o o m E o 3 c ow _ E v ;2' o E a _ _ E` E w E N o a o a n o? o a' o a o jagwnN wail uopay > s� _ ig - F passa,ppv (s)anpialg0 .3 - - {$!;! ��) $\( , - --\ _ :2!<± - {\\\}} \\/ }\\\\ \\\\\ \}\/k o 1. ! \� /ko : \ \oc \\$ \/ � }o \ \ ! \\_\ �\ )\\\\ 2�o \- —_ _o - _$))\ §_ _ \\\\\\4o :\j, -. § ��s \}\}k \\\}( ))f\!){\/ \\))()) \.lo IS 12 : \j! !| !| !| $E ))i ))i _ \{ \{ \{ <\, § /\ ($; §3. `It \ 2:# ¥ ( )lu La` | ! E5! 2f : };\! k | o!!;! !`! R E \� m § § § § )f )}.{;{ \/ -!k - o 7 \, ,\ o }� \ \ \/ \o f )i ! ) 2 )ƒ )o .2 :- k( )) E k \- -` - 2 )! /f)| \\} }\\ }\\\j \\ \\�\ s!! !:2 !!!.a ,: !!!, __ _ _- ' - E� __-( _o og4Ee (%!\ LITERATURE CITED LITERATURE CITED Arlettaz, R., Ruchet, C., Aeschimann, J., Brun, E., Genoud, M., and Vogel, P. 2000. Physiological traits affecting the distribution and wintering strategy of the bat Tadarida teniotis. Ecology 81:1004-1014. Belwood, J. J. 1981. Wagner's mastiff bat, Eumops glaucinus floridanus (Molossidae) in southwestern Florida. Journal of Mammalogy 62:411-413 Belwood, J. J. 1992. Florida mastiff bat Eumops glaucinus floridanus. Pages 216-223 in S. R. Humphrey, editor. Rare and endangered biota of Florida. Vol. I. Mammals. University Press of Florida, Gainesville. Boyles, J .G., and D. P. Aubrey. 2006. Managing forests with prescribed fire: implications for a cavity -dwelling bat species. Forest Ecology and Management 222:108-115. Carter, T. C., W. M. Ford, and M. A. Menzel. 2000. Fire and bats in the southeast and mid - Atlantic: more questions than answers? Pages 139-143 in W. M. Ford, K. R. Russell, and C. E. Moorman, editors. Proceedings of a special workshop on the role of fire in nongame wildlife management and community restoration: traditional uses and new directions. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Nashville, Tennessee. Clark, Jr. D. R. 1988. How sensitive are bats to insecticides? Wildlife Society Bulletin 16:399- 403. Cryan, P. M., and R. M. Barclay. 2009. Causes of bat fatalities at wind turbines: hypotheses and predictions. Journal of Mammalogy 90:1330-1340. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission [FWC]. 2011. Florida's Wildlife Legacy Initiative. Florida's draft state wildlife action plan. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, Tallahassee. Florida's Natural Area Inventory. 2012. FNAI Element Tracking List. Updated June 2012. Florida's Natural Area Inventory Tallahassee. Humphrey, S. R. 1975. Nursery roosts and community diversity of Nearctic bats. Journal of Mammalogy 56:321-346. Keeley, B. W., and M. D. Tuttle. 1999. Bats in American bridges. Resource Publication No. 4. Bat Conservation International, Austin, Texas. Kunz, T. H. 2003. Censusing bats: challenges, solutions, and sampling biases. Pages 9-19 in T. J. O'Shea and M. A. Bogan, editors. Monitoring trends in bat populations of the United States and territories: problems and prospects. U.S. Geological Survey, Information and Technology Report USGSBRD/ITR-2003-0003, Ft. Belvoir, Virginia. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 27 LITERATURE CITED Kunz, T. H., and L. F. Lumsden. 2003. Ecology of cavity and foliage roosting bats. Pages 3-89 in T. H. Kunz and M. B. Fenton, editors. Bat ecology. The University of Chicago Press. Chicago, Illinois. Kunz, T. H., E. B. Arnett, W. P. Erickson, A. R. Hoar, G. D. Johnson, R. P. Larkin, R. W. Strickland, and M. D. Tuttle. 2007. Ecological impacts of wind energy development on bats: questions, research needs, and hypotheses. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 5:315-324. Lacki, M. J., D. R. Cox, L. E. Dodd, and M. B. Dickinson. 2009. Response of northern bats (Myotis septentrionalis) to prescribed fires in eastern Kentucky forests. Journal of Mammalogy 90:1165-1175. Lewis, S. E. 1995. Roost fidelity of bats: a review. Journal of Mammalogy 76:481-496. Loeb, S. C., and T. A.Waldrop. 2008. Bat activity in relation to fire and fire surrogate treatments in southern pine stands. Forest Ecology and Management 255:3185-3192. Marks, C. S., and G. E. Marks. 2006. Bats of Florida. University Press of Florida. Gainesville. Marks, G. E., and C. S. Marks. 2008a. Status of the Florida bonneted bat (Eumops floridanus). Final report submitted to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service by the Florida Bat Conservancy under grant agreement number 401815G192, Florida Bat Conservancy, Bay Pines. Marks, G. E., and C. S. Marks. 2008b. Bat conservation and land management Kissimmee River WMA. Report submitted to the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission by the Florida Bat Conservancy, Bay Pines. Marks, G. E., and C. S. Marks. 2008c. Bat conservation and land management Babcock Webb WMA. Report submitted to the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission by the Florida Bat Conservancy, Bay Pines. Marks, G.E. and C.S. Marks. 2008d. Status of the Florida bonneted bat (Eumops floridanus). Supplemental report submitted to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service by the Florida Bat Conservancy under grant agreement number 401815G192, Florida Bat Conservancy, Bay Pines. Marks, G. E., and C. S. Marks. 2012. Status of the Florida bonneted bat (Eumops floridanus). Final report to U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service by the Florida Bat Conservancy under grant agreement number 40181AG121, Florida Bat Conservancy, Bay Pines. McDonough, M. M., L. K. Ammerman, R. M. Timm, H. H. Genoways, P. A. Larsen, and R. J. Baker. 2008. Speciation within bonneted bats (Genus Eumops): the complexity of Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 28 LITERATURE CITED morphological, mitochondrial, and nuclear data sets in systematic. Journal of Mammalogy 90:1306-1315. Millsap, B. A., J. A. Gore, D. E. Runde, and S. I. Cerulean. 1990. Setting priorities for the conservation of fish and wildlife species in Florida. Wildlife Monographs 111:1-57. NatureServe. 2010. NatureServe Explorer: An online encyclopedia of life [web application]. Version 7.1. NatureServe, Arlington, Virginia. http://www.natureserve.org/explorer. Accessed: 6 May 2011). Robson, M. 1989. Status survey of the Florida mastiff bat. Final performance report. Nongame Wildlife Section, Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission, Tallahassee. Timm, R. M., and H. H. Genoways. 2004. The Florida bonneted bat, Eumops floridanus (Chiroptera: Molossidae): distribution, morphometrics, systematic, and ecology. Journal of Mammalogy 85:852-865. Timm, R., and J. Arroyo-Cabrales. 2008. Eumops floridanus. In: IUCN 2010. IUCN Red List of Threatened Species. Version 2012.2 www.iucnredlist.or . Accessed 12 December 2012. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service [USFWS]. 2012. Proposed endangered species status for the Florida bonneted bat. Federal Register 77(193):60750-60776. Zwick, P. D., and M. H. Carr. 2006. Florida 2060: A population distribution scenario for the State of Florida. Prepared by the Geoplan Center at the University of Florida for 1000 Friends of Florida, Gainesville. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 29 APPENDICES APPENDICES Appendix 1. Instructions for building a single -chambered bat house. (These are general plans for a single -chambered bat house but this design has not been tested for use by Florida bonneted bats.) http://www.batcon.org/pdfs/bathouses/SingleChamberBHPlans.pdf BAT C*NSERVAAJ0t www.batcon.org Single -chamber Bat House (wall mounted) Mareriah (makes one !muse) ti sheet (2' x 4') k" AC, BC or T1-11 (outdoor grade) plywood One piece 1" x 2" ('k" x IM" finished) x 8' pine (furring strip) 20 to 30 exterior -grade screws, 1" One pint dark, water -based stain, exterior grade One pint water -based primer, exterior grade One quart flat, water -based paint or stain, exterior grade One tube paintable latex caulk 1" x 4" x 28" board for roof (optional, but highly recommended) Black asphalt shingles or galvan i zed metal (optional) 6 to10 roofing nails, X" (if using shingles or metal roofing) Recommended tools Table saw or handsaw Caulking gun Variable -speed re versing drill Paintbrushes Screwdriver bit for drill Hammer (optional) Tape measure or yardstick Tin snips (optional) More bat -house plans and additional information can be found in BCI's Bat House Builder's Handbook, available at wwvbatcatolog.com. Construction 1. Measure and cut plywood into three pieces: 26%" x 24" 16Y" x 24" 5" x 24" 2. Roughen inside of backboard and landing area by cutting horzzmtal grooves with sharp object or saw. Space grooves Y.." to T apart, cutting Yu" to Sf." deep. 3. Apply two coats of dark, water -based stain to interior maces. Do not use paint, as it will fill grooves. 4. Cut furring strip into one 24" and two 209" pieces. 5. Attach furring strips to back, caulking first. Start with 24" piece at top. Roost chamber spacing is g". 6. Attach front to furring strips, top piece first (caulk first). Leave %" vent space between top and bottom front pieces. 7. Caulk all outside joints to further seal roost chamber. 8. Attach a 1" x 4" x 28" board to the top as a roof (optional, but highly recommended). 9. Apply three coats of paint or stain to the exterior (use primer for first coat). 10. Cover roof with shingles or gahanized metal (optional). 11. Mount on building (south or east sides usually best). Optional modifications to the single -chamber bat house 1. Wider bat houses can be built for larger colonies. Be sure to adjust dimensions for back and front pieces and ceiling strip. A X" support spacer may be needed in the center of the roost- ing chamber for bat houses over 24" wide to prevent warping. 2. To make a taller version for additional temperature diversity, use these modifications: From a 2' x 8' piece of plywood, cut t h we pieces: 51" x 24", 33" x 24" and 12" x 24". Cut two 8' furring strips into one 24" and two 44" pieces. Follow assem- bly procedure above. 3. Two bat houses can be placed back-to-back, mounted between two poles, to create a three -chamber nursery house. Before assembly, cut a horizontal X" slot in the back of each house about 9" from the bottom edge of the back piece to permit movement of bats between houses. Two pieces of wood, 1" x 4" x 4V, screwed horizontally to each side, will join the two boxes. Leave a Y" space between the two houses, and roughen the wood surfaces or cover the back of each with plastic mesh (see item 5 below). Do not cover the rear exit slots with mesh. One 1 " x 4" x 34" vertical piece, attached to each side over the horizontal pieces, blocks light but allows bats and air to enter. A galvanized metal roof, covering both houses, protects the center roosting area from rain. Eaves should be about 3" in southern areas and about 1i4" in the torch. 4. Ventilation may not be necessary in cold climates. In this case, the front should be a single piece 23" long. Smaller bat houses like this one will be less successful in cool climates. However, those mounted on buildings maintain thermal stability better and are more likely to attract bats. 5. Durable plastic mesh can be substituted to provide footholds for bats. Attach one 20" x 2432piece to backboard after stain- ing interior, but prior to assembly. © copyright Bat Conservation International, Inc. All rights reserved. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 30 APPENDICES Appendix 2. Instructions for building a triple -chambered bat house. http://www.floridabats.org/ImagesBHs/Bat—House—Plans.pdf Vent Triple -chambered Bat House Plans Front View 8„ :al■ .1 u Side View 6" Board Partition Spacer Bottom View MATERIALS One 3' foot long 1" X 8" (7'/4") One 2' X 2' sheet of T-111 exterior siding or rough sided plywood. One 8' foot long 1" X 6" ( 5'/2') One 4' by 4' sheet'/4" plastic mesh (Optional).' One 6' foot long 1" X 4" (3'/i') 46 - 1 5/8" #8 galvanized wood screws. Two 3' foot long 1" X 1" ('/4') "Plastic mesh is only necessary if the interior of the bat house is constructed with smooth -sided wood. A better approach is to use T-111 siding for the partitions and rough -sided lumber for the back wall. If smooth -sided wood or plywood is used, it can be grooved at '/2" intervals to provide a rough surface for the bats to grasp onto. See also the note at bottom of page 2. INSTRUCTIONS Step 1. From the 1 X6, cut six 14" sections for the front and back panels of the bat house. From the 1 X8, cut one 16" section for the roof and one 14" section for the back. From the 1X1's cut four 17" sections. These will be used as spacers to secure the partitions. From the 1X4, cut one additional 14" section for the back. From the remaining piece of the 1X4 cut two sections for the sides. One end of each piece will be cut at a 30-degree angle for the roof. This can be done by cutting each piece with a front length of 21'/i' and a back length of 23'/i'. © Florida Bat Conservancy, P.O. Box 516, Bay Pines, FL 33744. Ph: (727) 710-BATS Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 31 APPENDICES L continued. Step 2. From the T-111 or plywood sheet, cut a 17X12" section for the back partition, and a 16"X12" section for the front partition. Note: If a larger piece of plywood is available, these two pieces can be cut 12'/z" in width to provide a flush fit at either side. Step 3. Bevel the back of the 16" roof section at 30 degrees. The roof will look best if the top (widest side) is made 6'/i' wide when the bevel is cut. Bevel one of the 14" X 6" pieces at 30 degrees. This piece will be used at the top of the front and the bevel is necessary to match the roof. Step 4. Begin assembly of the bat house by placing the two side pieces on a table with the long sides up and 14" apart (outside to outside). It is recommended that glue or caulking be used as the bat house is assembled to strengthen and weatherproof it. Place one of the 14" X 6" pieces on top and align it with the bottom of the two side pieces. Fasten it with two 1-5/8" wood screws on each side. Drilling 3/32" pilot holes for all screws will help prevent the wood from splitting. Repeat the process with a 6", 4", 6" and 8" piece, in that order. This will place the 8" piece at the top of the bat house. Now turn the bat house over so it is laying on its back. Drill one 5/16" hole at the top, and one 5/16" hole bottom. These will be used for mounting the bat house to a post or building. The holes should be located in the center and 2" from the edge. Step 5. If plastic mesh is being used, cut two sections of plastic mesh the same dimensions as the plywood partitions. Staple the mesh to the plywood using vertical rows of staples about 2-3" apart. The side with the mesh All face the front of the bat house. Cut a section of plastic mesh 12" wide and 23" long and place it on the back wall of the bat house. Fasten the mesh with vertical rows of staples about 2-3" apart. Step 6. Position the 1X1's in the left and right-hand corners with the bottom ends located 4'/2' from the bottom of the bat house. This will create a 41/2' landing pad. Place the 17" partition with the rough or mesh covered side up on top of the two 1X1's already in position. Use three 1-5/8" wood screws in each; one in the center and the other two about from each end. Make sure the top wood screw securely attaches the 1X1 to the 8" board on the back wall. This will add strength to the bat house Step 7. Position the remaining two 1X1's on each side of the partition directly above the previous two. Place the 16" partition on top (rough or mesh side up); allowing 1" of the previous 1X1's to show at the bottom. This open space makes it easier for bats to crawl into the forward crevices. Now fasten the plywood section and 1X1's using two 1-5/8" screws on each side. Locate them about 1'/s" from the top and bottom of the plywood partition to avoid the screws underneath. Step 8. Place the beveled 14" X 6" board at the top of the front, aligning the beveled edge with the 30 degree angle of the two side pieces. Fasten it using two 1-5/8" screws on each side. Repeat using a second 14" X 6" board. Locate the third and final 14" X 6" board about''/2' down from the previous one to form a'/z" gap for the vent. Step 9. Center the roof section such that there is equal overhang on each side. Fasten it to the side pieces using two 1-5/8" screws on each side. The roof should be caulked where it meets the back wall. Adding roofing material and painting the bat house will greatly extend its life. A light brown color works well in Florida. Step 10. The bat house can be mounted on a 4'X4" post or the side of a building using the holes drilled in step 4 and three-inch long, 5/16" lag bolts. A large galvanized or stainless steel washer (fender washer) is recommended to protect the wood. Mounting on trees is not recommended because they have proven to be the least successful location for bat houses. Bat houses should be located at least ten feet above ground. Experience indicates the higher the bat house is mounted the more likely it will get bats. Note 1: There are photographs of this bat house during various stages of construction on the web at: http://www.floridabats.org/BatHousePIan Photos.htm. Note 2: If you choose to use '/a" plastic mesh please contact the Florida Bat Conservancy since it is not readily available from local suppliers. We can mail you the required amount of mesh for this bat house design for the cost of the material and shipping. © Florida Bat Conservancy. Email: floridabats@aol.com. Phone: (727) 710-2287 Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 32 APPENDICES Appendix 3. FWC bat house occupancy assessment protocol. Protocol current as of May 2013. 0Bat House Occupancy Assessment Bat houses provide roosting sites for several species of bats in Florida and can be an important tool in bat conservation. Better information is needed on where and when bats are using but houses on conservation lands, and if land management activities have the potential to impact bat house use. Participating in bat house occupancy assessments will lead to better recommendations on bat house siting, and over many years may provide trend information on bat house use. Assessment Objective - Estimate number of bats and seasonality of use of bat houses in Florida. 0 Bat houses should be checked THREE times every year. Checks should be conducted once during each of the following time periods: May -July September -November 15th December -February 0 If staff resources allow, information is also needed relative to land management activities. These o t� ional visits should be conducted ithin a week be ore and a ter land management activities within 100 ft of houses. Land management activities include prescribed burning, extensive timber removal, or other activities that substantially alter the immediate environment. 0 Bat house checks fall into two categories: daytime checks and evening emergence counts. • Daytime Checks are completed to determine if bat houses are occupied and to estimate number of bats for each house according to the instructions below. • Evening Emergence Counts are optional and are best conducted at occupied houses in which number of bats cannot be estimated (ie. large condo houses, reduced visibility). Daytime Checks - Visit each house during the day and look for signs that bats are using the house. For occupied houses, estimate number of bats, if possible. 0 Bat sign includes: • Staining near the opening of the house chambers. • Small pellets scattered on the ground at the base of the house. Bat guano is a similar size to mouse or rat droppings, but is composed primarily of insect parts and can be easily crumbled. Pellets are also rather shiny in appearance. • Sounds of bats (chirping, chattering) 0 Binoculars, mirrors, and flashlights can be used to look into house chambers for bats. 0 Record date, presence/absence, type of bat sign, and estimated number of bats on datasheet. • Estimated number of bats — Count or estimate the number of bats in the bat house, if possible. In most cases bats cannot be individually counted, but an estimate of the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 33 APPENDICES Appendix 3 continued. proportion of space within each house that is filled by resting bats may be possible, using increments of 25% (ie. 0-25%, 26-50%, 51-75%, 76-100%). If neither a count nor estimate of proportion of space can be confidently determined, simply indicate whether the house is occupied. If conducting the daytime visit as part of a land management activity, please include the type of land management and the date of the activity in the data sheet. Multiple visits can be included on a single data sheet. Evenin¢ Emereence Count - Conduct at houses known or suspected to be occupied and in which number of bats cannot be accurately determined. Technical and staff assistance can be provided if needed. 0 Count should take place on a clear evening when the temperature is warmer than 451 F. 0 Arrive at least 15 minutes prior to sunset; choose a location at least 25 feet from the house, with a clear view of the opening. Limit disturbance (noise, lights) that could prevent emergence. 0 Bats should emerge shortly after sunset. The observer should remain at the house for at least 30 minutes after civil twilight, or until no more bats emerge from the house. If bonneted bats are suspected, the observer should remain at the house for at least 45 minutes after civil twilight. 0 For sunset and civil twilight times, see http://aa.tisno.nayy.mil/data/docs/RS_OneDayphp 0 Record date, number of bats, and other observations on datasheet. 0 Near -infrared equipment can be used to record an emergence and can be particularly useful at large bat condos. 0 Fill out Bat House Information form only once for each bat house. 0 Record all data from Daytime Checks and Evening Emergence Counts using the Bat House Occupancy Datasheet below. 0 Send all forms to Mehssa.Tucker(&mvfwc.com FWC's Mammal Taxa Coordinator Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 34 APPENDICES Appendix 3 continued. 0 Bat House Information Send forms to Mehssa.Tucker(&inyfwc.com FWC's Mammal Taxa Coordinator Please complete one forni for each bat house on WMA/WEA. General Information VVIAA/WEA: Contact Name: Contact Phone Nuumber: Total Number of Bat Houses: Bat House Information Bat House Name: (Name is for WMA/WEA staff reference only. Choose a name that uniquely identifies the bat house for staff purposes. Ex: Check station house, pond house, Burn Unit 12 house, etc.) Latitude: _ Longitude: (Decimal degrees preferred) Installation Date (estimated monthlyear): Bat House Size: Single _ Double _ Triple Condo Estimated number of bats when full (if known): If size is unknown, estimated dimensions: Bat House Mount Setup Estimated Height of House (from ground) (Ex. Attached to tree, pole, 4x4, building) Photo provided? ( Y / N ) If possible, please attach a photo of this house, labeled with Bat House Name. Brief description of habitat within sight of bat house: Other continents regarding bat house: Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission 35 APPENDICES Appendix ]Continued ( B z 2 § ) } 2 0 ne „„ate �@,■ \ z'2. -!2, Z;ƒ3oo # _ ID _ //$CL a %0, §�V� �. Florida Bonneted Bat Species Action Plan STANDARD PROTECTION MEASURES FOR THE EASTERN INDIGO SNAKE U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service August 12, 2013 The eastern indigo snake protection/education plan (Plan) below has been developed by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) in Florida for use by applicants and their construction personnel. At least 30 days prior to any clearing/land alteration activities, the applicant shall notify the appropriate USFWS Field Office via e-mail that the Plan will be implemented as described below (North Florida Field Office: jaxre sg`(&,,fws.gov; South Florida Field Office: verobeachkfws.gov; Panama City Field Office: panamacity&fws.gov). As long as the signatory of the e-mail certifies compliance with the below Plan (including use of the attached poster and brochure), no further written confirmation or "approval" from the USFWS is needed and the applicant may move forward with the project. If the applicant decides to use an eastern indigo snake protection/education plan other than the approved Plan below, written confirmation or "approval" from the USFWS that the plan is adequate must be obtained. At least 30 days prior to any clearing/land alteration activities, the applicant shall submit their unique plan for review and approval. The USFWS will respond via e- mail, typically within 30 days of receiving the plan, either concurring that the plan is adequate or requesting additional information. A concurrence e-mail from the appropriate USFWS Field Office will fulfill approval requirements. The Plan materials should consist of: 1) a combination of posters and pamphlets (see Poster Information section below); and 2) verbal educational instructions to construction personnel by supervisory or management personnel before any clearing/land alteration activities are initiated (see Pre -Construction Activities and During Construction Activities sections below). POSTER INFORMATION Posters with the following information shall be placed at strategic locations on the construction site and along any proposed access roads (a final poster for Plan compliance, to be printed on I I" x 17" or larger paper and laminated, is attached): DESCRIPTION: The eastern indigo snake is one of the largest non -venomous snakes in North America, with individuals often reaching up to 8 feet in length. They derive their name from the glossy, blue -black color of their scales above and uniformly slate blue below. Frequently, they have orange to coral reddish coloration in the throat area, yet some specimens have been reported to only have cream coloration on the throat. These snakes are not typically aggressive and will attempt to crawl away when disturbed. Though indigo snakes rarely bite, they should NOT be handled. SIMILAR SNAKES: The black racer is the only other solid black snake resembling the eastern indigo snake. However, black racers have a white or cream chin, thinner bodies, and WILL BITE if handled. LIFE HISTORY: The eastern indigo snake occurs in a wide variety of terrestrial habitat types throughout Florida. Although they have a preference for uplands, they also utilize some wetlands and agricultural areas. Eastern indigo snakes will often seek shelter inside gopher tortoise burrows and other below- and above -ground refugia, such as other animal burrows, stumps, roots, and debris piles. Females may lay from 4 - 12 white eggs as early as April through June, with young hatching in late July through October. PROTECTION UNDER FEDERAL AND STATE LAW: The eastern indigo snake is classified as a Threatened species by both the USFWS and the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission. "Taking" of eastern indigo snakes is prohibited by the Endangered Species Act without a permit. "Take" is defined by the USFWS as an attempt to kill, harm, harass, pursue, hunt, shoot, wound, trap, capture, collect, or engage in any such conduct. Penalties include a maximum fine of $25,000 for civil violations and up to $50,000 and/or imprisonment for criminal offenses, if convicted. Only individuals currently authorized through an issued Incidental Take Statement in association with a USFWS Biological Opinion, or by a Section 10(a)(1)(A) permit issued by the USFWS, to handle an eastern indigo snake are allowed to do so. IF YOU SEE A LIVE EASTERN INDIGO SNAKE ON THE SITE: • Cease clearing activities and allow the live eastern indigo snake sufficient time to move away from the site without interference; • Personnel must NOT attempt to touch or handle snake due to protected status. • Take photographs of the snake, if possible, for identification and documentation purposes. • Immediately notify supervisor or the applicant's designated agent, and the appropriate USFWS office, with the location information and condition of the snake. • If the snake is located in a vicinity where continuation of the clearing or construction activities will cause harm to the snake, the activities must halt until such time that a representative of the USFWS returns the call (within one day) with further guidance as to when activities may resume. IF YOU SEE A DEAD EASTERN INDIGO SNAKE ON THE SITE: • Cease clearing activities and immediately notify supervisor or the applicant's designated agent, and the appropriate USFWS office, with the location information and condition of the snake. • Take photographs of the snake, if possible, for identification and documentation purposes. • Thoroughly soak the dead snake in water and then freeze the specimen. The appropriate wildlife agency will retrieve the dead snake. Telephone numbers of USFWS Florida Field Offices to be contacted if a live or dead eastern indigo snake is encountered: North Florida Field Office — (904) 731-3336 Panama City Field Office — (850) 769-0552 South Florida Field Office — (772) 562-3909 PA PRE -CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES 1. The applicant or designated agent will post educational posters in the construction office and throughout the construction site, including any access roads. The posters must be clearly visible to all construction staff. A sample poster is attached. 2. Prior to the onset of construction activities, the applicant/designated agent will conduct a meeting with all construction staff (annually for multi -year projects) to discuss identification of the snake, its protected status, what to do if a snake is observed within the project area, and applicable penalties that may be imposed if state and/or federal regulations are violated. An educational brochure including color photographs of the snake will be given to each staff member in attendance and additional copies will be provided to the construction superintendent to make available in the onsite construction office (a final brochure for Plan compliance, to be printed double -sided on 8.5" x 11" paper and then properly folded, is attached). Photos of eastern indigo snakes may be accessed on USFWS and/or FWC websites. 3. Construction staff will be informed that in the event that an eastern indigo snake (live or dead) is observed on the project site during construction activities, all such activities are to cease until the established procedures are implemented according to the Plan, which includes notification of the appropriate USFWS Field Office. The contact information for the USFWS is provided on the referenced posters and brochures. DURING CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES 1. During initial site clearing activities, an onsite observer may be utilized to determine whether habitat conditions suggest a reasonable probability of an eastern indigo snake sighting (example: discovery of snake sheds, tracks, lots of refugia and cavities present in the area of clearing activities, and presence of gopher tortoises and burrows). 2. If an eastern indigo snake is discovered during gopher tortoise relocation activities (i.e. burrow excavation), the USFWS shall be contacted within one business day to obtain further guidance which may result in further project consultation. 3. Periodically during construction activities, the applicant's designated agent should visit the project area to observe the condition of the posters and Plan materials, and replace them as needed. Construction personnel should be reminded of the instructions (above) as to what is expected if any eastern indigo snakes are seen. POST CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES Whether or not eastern indigo snakes are observed during construction activities, a monitoring report should be submitted to the appropriate USFWS Field Office within 60 days of project completion. The report can be sent electronically to the appropriate USFWS e-mail address listed on page one of this Plan. From: Hitt, Heather To: Sarah Morales Cc: Jackson Reaoan Subject: Re: [EXTERNAL] RE: Naples Park North Tower 2018-TA-0461 (637639) Date: Tuesday, September 04, 2018 1:16:22 PM Hi Sarah, Based on the results of the survey (no cavities or FBB roosts identified) there is no further consultation necessary. Thanks, Heather Hitt Fish and Wildlife Biologist US Fish and Wildlife Service 1339 20th Street Vero Beach, FL 32960 Phone: 772-469-4267 Fax: 772-562-4288 Email: heather_hittn,fws.gov NOTE: This email correspondence and any attachments to and from this sender is subject to the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) and may be disclosed to third parties. On Tue, Sep 4, 2018 at 11:40 AM, Sarah Morales <S.Morales&trileaf.com> wrote: Thank you, Heather! Do you know about when a response may be expected? Thanks, Sarah N. Morales Senior Project Manager Health and Safety Officer Licensed Mold Assessor MRSA# 665 %$jFTRILEAF ENVIRONMENTAL • ARCHITECTURE • ENGINEERING 1051 Winderley Place, Suite 201 FLORIDA DEPARTMENT Of STATE RICK SCOTT Governor Mr. Jackson Reagan Trileaf Corporation 1051 Winderley Place, Suite 201 Maitland, Florida 32751 RE: DHR Project File No.: 2018-1883 / Received by DHR: April 16, 2018 Federal Communication Commission / Trileaf # 637639 Naples Park North / Client #FL114 220 Foot Tall Guyed Communications Tower Benton Road, Naples, Collier County, Florida Mr. Reagan: KEN DETZNER Secretary of State May 16, 2018 Our office reviewed the referenced project for possible impact to historic properties listed, or eligible for listing, in the National Register of Historic Places. The review was conducted in accordance with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966, as amended, 36 CFR Part 800: Protection of Historic Properties, and the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969, as amended. Based on the information provided and a review of our records, this office concurs that the proposed undertakings will have no direct effects and no visual effects on historic properties. For any questions concerning our comments, please contact Robin Jackson, Historic Preservationist, Compliance and Review, by electronic mail at robin.iackson(i�dos.myflorida.com, or at 850.245.6496, or 800.847.7278. Sincerely, Timothy A. Parsons, Ph.D. Director, Division of Historical Resources and State Historic Preservation Officer Division of Historical Resources� R.A. Gray Building • 500 South Bronough Street- Tallahassee, Florida 32399�gy�/-4 850.245.6300 •850.245.6436 (Fax) FLHeritage.com of OZ/60/l Q2W ^ z 3o L 133Hs NNMtlWtlON HAS0 M3a0J3NO0133H10J SHM/03n0aV ar Ma 10N96L30nNN3M191WaN01WW OOSI £OZ 3 W003131 lblldd3 a0d 'ONO 'dfl OHTI OHOUROMMOUNRI W00B02MWS'M 4ZS£ w8ry W-16-4 L �U enud le)ua� sSOU!Sn8 89 ��U'Q ��7 I 'dnOJO 6UIJ99ulBU3 AS of O9Z/O 3ll5300tl.31.Od1 of o 8L/OL/ZL /S/O 3103Wltld —0g_ 533awlv0300tl L A 3110 NOISI3a ON 3n1Sa3MOl4NbIMVN � 2 = 3 a o -0 N M z o o ¢ a g Z cWi Q o58_ - W r` F no n O Ko Z lY H OP� chi W r Q z Z Z o; p m U W O W 0 ti O W 4 ti a U 2 II = g W p N ° G 3 w °' J U W Q H w U_ > W H N O uL J - 7Om m j 2 2 2 3 0 0 0 O O J W M W- - O n = a J �j p UOU I ro'uNi Uo ° II II II II II II II II II - c - uJ U - o P r v E W0. U a o z - Q O « - - gr n a o a CE z o.N° _ Er O O��'¢~ - - `o oo Woa 0 o a J \ LL m o'c m m e `99 o a o _ 0 Too _ _ �ES'299 3 ,b S,E4.00 N 3 3?J 039NV9 ON ,1 `20 E m- o£oav__ o ml w E o c o Z� o 0ZW o n Q3ww3w3ww33333ww3ww33 N I a �LL< o 20. N xn o Eo3 5 ..°En 3 3 ¢zoom �E ro $ «Eo a koa oa L5. idhd Z3w-L N-0 T- L7 u w n o �z IE ¢` �z ¢p oo�a Nm 0 aka 0OF— zo I � E6'194T=i JNV IM s b 3 �a��w li�� ;^T�I ww�a —� � wCi - p a — �� a �i orba� = wlo C\IO o 3 rnM WI Ioa w�* 3 go°Nga o �jrn * y IZ o0 �dw �4y r a �a� w \ ��N� < o0 0� -Mam o a a �a�� a a�� w - LL�Q �_ �¢0. 0 �o1 ��a =� � a � 3d,�d o w= 0 << og II on om az�- rc �� i�no o� �i O N I z V6y 02l Ot, UI o 3 \ oiWG�M� r1 O wci z o ,1 �tO 0E7'T99 —qi. 5---- a� ,LB22T.00 — — -- �m — — — _ _. _ --- -- �a0o fo OtlOa 3N21013nVdO NOlN39 �¢wm adz w�� - J `wwN J a OZ/60/LL SO ALlVdiin 0300tl 'b o 2 ^ U W'Q a NMOHS Stl '3lVOS LL/SL/£0 :— SHM AB 03AOaddb WN M3a0 O1313 NVb AB 1310311 ar ae NMbaa 096L0 fN 'NMO1SItla0W £OZ Sins 3NN3A4 319W3N 'll 009L W003131 IVild`d0 a01 W969-Z Z- $$69-Z$Z90Z 4d "ZS£—geIV w g6u-9 9AN418lU8 8l6u3 M8Sl 'out 'dna0 6uilaaui6u3 MWS Mr OZ/9z/oL 1N .1— 55300tl 031 — '£ df W ar 9L/OL/Zl WVOL 31ON 310N SOL3Wltld 0300b S33a1 Wltld 0300tl 'Z L Ae 31v0 Noisin3a ON A3mns N3MOl ONVIMVa W U oz of o �< W E o�I ao0 �o sa <''msa ¢ 2�:4-1v Z OwZ<o�a O WO ¢¢m -M4¢a� ~oa p �an4a¢o w p)LL as w Qua og a r r N N E9'669 An,, ,1,b4.00 S - a z N O c J W W a _ Z n O oo 0 p v v 0 0� mo w a o p E m °z q_ z a E ` a a __—____ — — — — — — — — — ��_�� o p c c H CEO o N o ` v v c N o `a v� w _�� x Epp - z I I _ _ J oom� w III Im o0 J- om pZ3 a a a onga 4om U �a - mN0 III I �mN�a M ��aso O"L�Om �`o o p -m -o `mlo ° m m W ,Lb'S89 M ,22A1.00 N OVOa NO1N38 E U m o z W OfriJ N r vN� L m o _ = _ F a m - - - -m o mo o w E z v w E d E° __ d E° _ a E z m- a E z m a E z m - _ ro o z - 3 u _ - c E - 3° v 3 y v 3 y - o 0- - o t^ a v a - v N - v N m _ - f ._ - - E __ o3v ar 8o3v o3`v00 E - - � 3 —S- a -owE m�z- vNo vNovE - _ Me N°v mN% I ooN o< oa oaa oan oo m� E-- oa ooN = J _ W15 wa _ WJ wa - - - �N �E`o kEo aE`o E`o zo _ ut° rn° ut° _ _ 00 a v E - 3 0- w a° J z o - w.. Z y 3 v oa 2 3 y _ 0 Z 3 v W J 3 v a Q J 3 w ` °w- - 0, m 3 3 o W o W o m m - W o mvo _ Wa W m o Woo m J wJc� o - ¢° p o NF E� - W° s_- o v --Eo _ E� v W o rn o - ° v _ E° « K° v s �w E� K° v s 0 ar-E - ¢ p o r ��-E� > o ar a o �ooE- ° o « T - > r '- a c ~ _ y r_ v 3 0 - r _3 - r'- _ ac N r'- _ aa N r - o - .. - 3 9 w o 0 3? - - o`o '-^ o o° .ai`aa 0 3 `o p VI° v c o 3 Z O of n - o zn m o� N - zn �'ot o� N - ° z n m c oT" - - zu m m ate" - _ m ° _z m� N - - cl o - _ mo _ v mz ~ 0 - z �' U = wa - o�°�- v ao_, mr o3 <°-. rr°o' NmGN mOw N G�°vUz ao_e Nm4N° _- °U Zo-° 03 GN �_ z °-° v ° � �' Zo-` a G�a�hU _ w° o�rn 40. W L t_o _ W a W e -- _ w e --_ a W e _ E m- m-- " U v X o w NVU N N Z r 0° = w NE.'w�a N Z m 0° = w o f V\I F`w - V1 N Z m - w O XEU W OE Z r o (0 w O XEU 7 w Z C0 w YEU W Z r o (0 w o J _ Z r w - W r 2 S` w �vc°Jo c2 �vc°JO Z N. m �vUo�` ° 0= Uov_rnc 0_ NUO� 0_ Uovmo p a _ «�- N1A o a z¢. Una F� �¢. U`o u\iarm - z<. Uov\iz..ro� M¢. Unzr M¢._U - Mail Processing Center Federal Aviation Administration Southwest Regional Office Obstruction Evaluation Group 10101 Hillwood Parkway Fort Worth, TX 76177 Issued Date: 05/11/2018 Compliance Dept Capital Telecom Holdings II LLC 820 Morris Turnpike Suite 104 Short Hills, NJ 07078 Aeronautical Study No. 2018-ASO-6465-OE ** DETERMINATION OF NO HAZARD TO AIR NAVIGATION ** The Federal Aviation Administration has conducted an aeronautical study under the provisions of 49 U.S.C., Section 44718 and if applicable Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations, part 77, concerning: Structure: Antenna Tower Naples Park Relo Location: Naples, FL Latitude: 26-10-45.84N NAD 83 Longitude: 81-34-16.99W Heights: 11 feet site elevation (SE) 225 feet above ground level (AGL) 236 feet above mean sea level (AMSL) This aeronautical study revealed that the structure does not exceed obstruction standards and would not be a hazard to air navigation provided the following condition(s), if any, is(are) met: As a condition to this Determination, the structure is to be marked/lighted in accordance with FAA Advisory circular 70/7460-1 L Change 1, Obstruction Marking and Lighting, a med-dual system - Chapters 4,8(M- Dual),& 12. Any failure or malfunction that lasts more than thirty (30) minutes and affects a top light or flashing obstruction light, regardless of its position, should be reported immediately to (877) 487-6867 so a Notice to Airmen (NOTAM) can be issued. As soon as the normal operation is restored, notify the same number. It is required that FAA Form 7460-2, Notice of Actual Construction or Alteration, be e-filed any time the project is abandoned or: At least 10 days prior to start of construction (7460-2, Part 1) X_ Within 5 days after the construction reaches its greatest height (7460-2, Part 2) This determination expires on 1 l/11/2019 unless: (a) the construction is started (not necessarily completed) and FAA Form 7460-2, Notice of Actual Construction or Alteration, is received by this office. (b) extended, revised, or terminated by the issuing office. Page 1 of 4 (c) the construction is subject to the licensing authority of the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) and an application for a construction permit has been filed, as required by the FCC, within 6 months of the date of this determination. In such case, the determination expires on the date prescribed by the FCC for completion of construction, or the date the FCC denies the application. NOTE: REQUEST FOR EXTENSION OF THE EFFECTIVE PERIOD OF THIS DETERMINATION MUST BE E-FILED AT LEAST 15 DAYS PRIOR TO THE EXPIRATION DATE. AFTER RE-EVALUATION OF CURRENT OPERATIONS IN THE AREA OF THE STRUCTURE TO DETERMINE THAT NO SIGNIFICANT AERONAUTICAL CHANGES HAVE OCCURRED, YOUR DETERMINATION MAY BE ELIGIBLE FOR ONE EXTENSION OF THE EFFECTIVE PERIOD. This determination is based, in part, on the foregoing description which includes specific coordinates, heights, frequency(ies) and power. Any changes in coordinates, heights, and frequencies or use of greater power, except those frequencies specified in the Colo Void Clause Coalition; Antenna System Co -Location; Voluntary Best Practices, effective 21 Nov 2007, will void this determination. Any future construction or alteration, including increase to heights, power, or the addition of other transmitters, requires separate notice to the FAA.This determination includes all previously filed frequencies and power for this structure. If construction or alteration is dismantled or destroyed, you must submit notice to the FAA within 5 days after the construction or alteration is dismantled or destroyed. This determination does include temporary construction equipment such as cranes, derricks, etc., which may be used during actual construction of the structure. However, this equipment shall not exceed the overall heights as indicated above. Equipment which has a height greater than the studied structure requires separate notice to the FAA. This determination concerns the effect of this structure on the safe and efficient use of navigable airspace by aircraft and does not relieve the sponsor of compliance responsibilities relating to any law, ordinance, or regulation of any Federal, State, or local government body. A copy of this determination will be forwarded to the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) because the structure is subject to their licensing authority. If we can be of further assistance, please contact our office at (202) 267-0105, or j.garver@faa.gov. On any future correspondence concerning this matter, please refer to Aeronautical Study Number 2018-ASO-6465-OE. Signature Control No: 360787151-365005057 Jay Garver Specialist Attachment(s) Frequency Data Map(s) cc: FCC (DNE) Page 2 of 4 Frequency Data for ASN 2018-ASO-6465-OE LOW HIGH FREQUENCY ERP FREQUENCY FREQUENCY UNIT ERP UNIT 6 7 GHz 55 dBW 6 7 GHz 42 dBW 10 11.7 GHz 55 dBW 10 11.7 GHz 42 dBW 17.7 19.7 GHz 55 dBW 17.7 19.7 GHz 42 dBW 21.2 23.6 GHz 55 dBW 21.2 23.6 GHz 42 dBW 614 698 MHz 1000 W 614 698 MHz 2000 W 698 806 MHz 1000 W 806 901 MHz 500 W 806 824 MHz 500 W 824 849 MHz 500 W 851 866 MHz 500 W 869 894 MHz 500 W 896 901 MHz 500 W 901 902 MHz 7 W 929 932 MHz 3500 W 930 931 MHz 3500 W 931 932 MHz 3500 W 932 932.5 MHz 17 dBW 935 940 MHz 1000 W 940 941 MHz 3500 W 1670 1675 MHz 500 W 1710 1755 MHz 500 W 1850 1910 MHz 1640 W 1850 1990 MHz 1640 W 1930 1990 MHz 1640 W 1990 2025 MHz 500 W 2110 2200 MHz 500 W 2305 2360 MHz 2000 W 2305 2310 MHz 2000 W 2345 2360 MHz 2000 W 2496 2690 MHz 500 W Page 3 of 4 TOPO Map for ASN 2018-ASO-6465-OE Page 4 of 4 COLLIER COUNTY INTENT TO ALLOW COLLOCATION AFFIDAVIT BEFORE ME, the undersigned authority, personally appeared Vincent Casiero who being by me first duly sworn, under oath, deposes and states as follows: 1. I am over eighteen (18) years of age and have personal knowledge of the matters contained herein 2. I am an Authorized Signatory of Capital Telecom Holdings II and have the authority to sign this affidavit. 3. It is the intent of Capital Telecom Holdings lI to construct a wireless communication tower on parcel 326347200009 in Collier County, Florida 4. It is the intent of Capital Telecom Holdings 11 and its successors to allow collocation of wireless communication antennas at a reasonable market rates or to allow a replacement tower to be erected within the leased area provided that the replacement is physically and contractually feasible and that the cost of modifying or replacing the wireless communication tower to accommodate the collocated equipment is borne by the collocating company. FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETYH NOT. STATE OF NEW JERSEY COUNTY OF Vincent Casiero, Authorized Signatory Capital Telecom Holdings II Sworn to (or affirmed) and subscribed before me this �e day of, , 018, by V UP-1 11 %AkN u'O (Seal) Printed Name of Notary Personally Known Type of Identification Produced I�l /� V OR Produced Identification JESSICA L, WEINBERG NCYTARY P1181.iC OF NEW JERSEY ID # 50000166 Nhr Un is lon B#m 7MM9 rm O ■� AW m ■ O � a LU a 'L W LL c� a 7D z N LL co N C 00 Q 7 O 0 ti LL � °r N U L E ■� Q '� G a 0 O ca L E 1 � (n — — O CT >O (6 U E U OU >, U O U 0 4 -, N •U) 0 E o •� V' V > U_ N N +� •p E Q C6 N O M cn (D U) -0 O U N p- N U- U) Q U .L 0 N U cn o L Ca U +� O Z a) U) -0 ._ a)+m O ) O LM O U U • - cn a N L O N O D U 4-0 N N O Q �� •(n U O O x NUJ O •� N O -Ci U '> ( U � •— Q -o N L p O O >, U CMN �E E N L O U U E•— O N N U �iF N OU Co4-0 U O N O O O N p m CO N > Co � co � — 0-0 N U N >> U_ C6 N U) (n 4-0 T O N O � N N � Q'X U N C6 m � N p (n > O N O (n O L U) •— Q4-0 'Q c6 N O N M 4-1 N •V N Q N � co (n O O (a �_ .� .� O N E O N — j 0-�5" m '� N O U r N N �+ +N V }' U U a)}' O� M M O � U o'i In U U Q 1 O� M_0 N L it _ a I- N � O N O T- 00 000 000 T- N U O O _M N O N O U LL Z 200 ~ O O CD O 00 O (D M 00 N L 0 Q L a) 73 L () J C7 0 J J J U7 C U LL -a 0 0 ~ 0 N4-1 0 m U op m (o U U (o U L 0 U 0 O Q 0 0 0 U a a U cD U M O O M O O 0 O co O N O M L6 Ln M O ti M 4 M O M O f�. co M 0 0 i 00 00 00 i 00 00 00 O O U') M N (.0 L6 O O O M IZI, C; ti N 0- 0-) m J (D N co N CO N co N CO N co N 0 Qo cz 4-1 Q m U m w LL 0 J Ong ,F.y 5, 5 - `C I II ti CD CD ` mk, H v 1 O 0 Z •t CD m L O .. . O V a) •� ca L z L v o > o •- v� Cl) CL 0 LU IL Mattaniah Jahn From: Sandi Chernoff - 1816 <Sandi.Chernoff@colt iersheriff.org> Sent: November 28, 2018 8:53 AM To: Mattaniah Jahn Subject: Collier County Wireless Statistics FY 2016/2017: Wireless calls were 78% of total 911 calls FY 2017/2018: Wireless calls were 80% of total 911 calls Sandi Chernoff ` FL NENA Treasurer 911 Coordinator Collier County Sheriff's Office (239) 252-9380 (ext 3380) This communication is confidential and may contain privileged information intended solely for the named addressee(s). It may not be used or disclosed except for the purpose for which it has been sent. If you are not the intended recipient, you must not copy, distribute or take any action induced by or in reliance on information contained in this message. Unless expressly stated, opinions in this message are those of the individual sender and not of the Collier County Sheriff's Office. If you have received this communication in error, please notify the Collier County Sheriff's Office by emailing helpdesk@colliersheriff.org quoting the sender and delete the message and any attached documents. The Collier County Sheriff's Office accepts no liability or responsibility for any onward transmission or use of emails and attachments having left the colliersheriff domain. .4_ owl CD ED • �' r U� y LL1 LU • 0•. � JN W Q � I • N y N • s p ooAA- , r sales 3 uelp MO� J• � F- i ;r t O C t ' Q O co `7 a� ' f z o cn l o� Q 1 J L L IR / ^^.V lV I L Z f • ''' M — ,1�__.. r Q c� O cB Q z z cu C) it ! cu K wr « R 1 I L r' w I EBI Consulting environmental I engineering I due diligence July 17, 2018 Site Name: Site Address: EBI Project Number: Carrier Name: STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS REPORT Alpine Broadcasting 1753 Benton Road, Naples, FL 8117000785 Verizon Wireless 21 B Street Burlington, MA 01 803 Tel: (781) 273-2500 Fax: (781)273-3311 www.ebiconsuItinq.com In accordance with your request, EBI Consulting engineers have reviewed the available documentation for the above site in order to determine its capability for supporting the structural loads from the proposed antennas, remote radio units, coaxial cables, and related equipment. This analysis is in accordance with the following design codes governing this project: • Florida Building Code 6th Edition (2017) • ANSI/TIA-222-G The following sources of information were considered in preparing this analysis: • Structural analysis report prepared by ERI, dated 3/11/2011 • Tower Design and Calculations report prepared by ERI, dated 4/12/2011 The tower was analyzed for an ultimate wind speed of 159 mph without ice (ASCE 7-10). The analysis provided herein by EBI Consulting includes the following existing and proposed Verizon Wireless equipment — refer to the analysis calculations for full tower loading: Carrier Elevation Manufacturer Model Qty. Coax JMA X7CQAP-86-865-VRO 6 Ericsson RRUs-2212 6 Verizon Wireless 220, (6) 1-5/8" Coax Ericsson RRUS-32 3 Raycap Ra ca RRFDC-3315-PF-48 OVP 2 Proposed equipment shown bolded. All existing Verizon wireless equipment (excluding mounts & cables) is to be removed prior to installation. No future equipment or reserved equipment by Verizon Wireless or other carriers is provided for in this analysis. Summary of Results: (Refer to attached TNX Tower Analysis for detailed analysis results) Section Capacity Table Section Elevation Component Size Critical P pPO— % Pass No. ft Type Element lb lb Capacity Fail L1 1016 - 996.615 Latticed Pole Leg 2 1 -21842.60 122252.00 17.9 Pass L2 996.615 - 977.23 Latticed Pole Leg 2 91 -73564.60 126314.00 58.2 Pass L3 977.23 - 957.845 Latticed Pole Leg 3 193 -159829.00 301795.00 53.0 Pass L4 957.845 - Latticed Pole Leg 3 1/2 295 -253458.00 416185.00 60.9 Pass 943.188 ENVIROBUSINESS, INC. LOCATIONS I ATLANTA, GA I BALTIMORE, MD I BURLINGTON, MA I CHICAGO, IL DALLAS, TX I DENVER, CO I HOUSTON, TX I LOS ANGELES, CA I NEW YORK, NY I PHOENIX, AZ PORTLAND, OR I SAN FRANCISCO, CA I SEATTLE, WA I YORK, PA ■ EBI Consulting 21 B Street Burlington, MA 01803 Tel: (781) 273 2500 Fax: (781) 273-3311 environmental I engineering I due diligence www.ebiconsultinq.com Section Elevation Component Size Critical p ppauow % pass No. ft Type Element lb lb Capacity Fail L1 1016 - 996.615 Latticed Pole 3/4 27 -2324.71 9310.66 25.0 Pass Diagonal L2 996.615 - 977.23 Latticed Pole 7/8 117 -4877.91 12999.20 37.5 Pass Diagonal L3 977.23 - 957.845 Latticed Pole 1 219 -8033.15 17747.30 45.3 Pass Diagonal L4 957.845- Latticed Pole 1 321 -10122.20 17820.90 56.8 Pass 943.188 Diagonal L1 1016-996.615 Latticed Pole K-Brace 3/4 17 -2975.69 8917.06 33.4 Pass L2 996.615 - 977.23 Latticed Pole K-Brace 7/8 107 -4750.15 13332.40 35.6 Pass L3 977.23 - 957.845 Latticed Pole K-Brace 1 209 -6886.91 17919.70 38.4 Pass L4 957.845- Latticed Pole K-Brace 1 312 -11025.50 17922.30 61.5 Pass 943.188 L1 1016 - 996.615 Latticed Pole Top Girt 2x1/2 6 -505.47 11766.30 4.3 Pass L2 996.615 - 977.23 Latticed Pole Top Girt 2x1/2 96 -2546.23 11766.30 21.6 Pass L3 977.23 - 957.845 Latticed Pole Top Girt 2x1/2 198 -4912.94 12377.40 39.7 Pass L4 957.845- Latticed Pole Top Girt 2x1/2 300 -7267.63 12702.20 57.2 Pass 943.188 L1 1016 - 996.615 Latticed Pole Bottom 2x1/2 9 -2422.71 11766.30 20.6 Pass Girt L2 996.615 - 977.23 Latticed Pole Bottom 2x1/2 99 -4538.75 11766.30 38.6 Pass Girt L3 977.23 - 957.845 Latticed Pole Bottom 2x1/2 201 -6595.75 12377.40 53.3 Pass Girt L4 957.845- Latticed Pole Bottom 12x1 301 -30054.60 307652.00 9.8 Pass 943.188 Girt L1 1016 - 996.615 Latticed Pole Mid 2x1/2 11 -74.06 2941.57 2.5 Pass Girt L2 996.615 - 977.23 Latticed Pole Mid 2x1/2 101 -459.93 2941.57 15.6 Pass Girt L3 977.23 - 957.845 Latticed Pole Mid 2x1/2 203 -789.46 3094.35 25.5 Pass Girt L4 957.845- Latticed Pole Mid 2x1/2 305 -1064.94 3175.24 33.5 Pass 943.188 Girt L1 1016-996.615 Latticed Pole Inner 5/8 20 -41.96 6237.81 0.7 Pass Bracing L2 996.615 - 977.23 Latticed Pole Inner 5/8 110 -78.61 6237.81 1.3 Pass Bracing L3 977.23 - 957.845 Latticed Pole Inner 5/8 212 -114.24 6237.81 1.8 Pass Bracing L4 957.845- Latticed Pole Inner 5/8 313 -520.56 6237.81 8.3 Pass 943.188 Bracing T1 943.188 - 939.5 Leg 3 1/2 378 -159453.00 359092.00 44.4 Pass T2 939.5 - 909.5 Leg 3 1/2 385 -278122.00 306993.00 90.6 Pass T3 909.5 - 894.5 Leg 3 1/4 424 -264054.00 250556.00 105.4 Fail T4 894.5 - 879.5 Leg 3 1/4 445 -247565.00 250556.00 98.8 Pass T5 879.5 - 859.5 Leg 3 466 -234248.00 199213.00 117.6 Fail T6 859.5 - 849.5 Leg 3 493 -223488.00 199213.00 112.2 Fail T7 849.5 - 819.5 Leg 3 508 -224591.00 199213.00 112.7 Fail + T8 819.5 - 789.5 Leg 3 1/4 547 -261434.00 250556.00 104.3 Fail T9 789.5 - 774.5 Leg 3 1/4 586 -290597.00 250556.00 116.0 Fail T10 774.5 - 759.5 Leg 3 1/4 607 -309814.00 250556.00 123.7 Fail T11 759.5 - 729.5 Leg 3 1/4 628 -294017.00 250556.00 117.3 Fail T12 729.5 - 699.5 Leg 3 1/4 667 -257401.00 250556.00 102.7 Fail T13 699.5 - 679.5 Leg 3 1/2 707 -242879.00 306993.00 79.1 Pass T14 679.5 - 669.5 Leg 3 1/2 733 -247536.00 306993.00 80.6 Pass T15 669.5 - 664.5 Leg 3 1/2 749 -252735.00 306993.00 82.3 Pass T16 664.5 - 659.5 Leg 3 1/2 757 -255505.00 306993.00 83.2 Pass ENVIROBUSINESS, INC. LOCATIONS I ATLANTA, GA I BALTIMORE, MD I BURLINGTON, MA I CHICAGO, IL DALLAS, TX I DENVER, CO I HOUSTON, TX I LOS ANGELES, CA I NEW YORK, NY I PHOENIX, AZ PORTLAND, OR I SAN FRANCISCO, CA I SEATTLE, WA I YORK, PA ■ EBI Consulting 21 B Street Burlington, MA 01803 Tel: (781) 273 2500 Fax: (781) 273-3311 environmental I engineering I due diligence www.ebiconsultinq.com Section Elevation Component Size Critical p op"/low % pass No. ft Type Element lb lb Capacity Fail T17 659.5 - 639.5 Leg 3 1/2 766 -278882.00 306993.00 90.8 Pass T18 639.5 - 629.5 Leg 3 1/2 794 -294206.00 306993.00 95.8 Pass T19 629.5 - 609.5 Leg 3 1/2 809 -296646.00 306993.00 96.6 Pass T20 609.5 - 579.5 Leg 3 1/2 836 -237802.00 306993.00 77.5 Pass T21 579.5 - 549.5 Leg 3 1/2 876 -213790.00 306993.00 69.6 Pass T22 549.5 - 519.5 Leg 3 1/2 915 -205349.00 306993.00 66.9 Pass T23 519.5 - 499.5 Leg 3 1/2 954 -258365.00 306993.00 84.2 Pass T24 499.5 - 489.5 Leg 3 1/2 981 -281843.00 306993.00 91.8 Pass T25 489.5 - 474.5 Leg 3 1/2 996 -272129.00 306993.00 88.6 Pass T26 474.5 - 459.5 Leg 3 1/2 1017 -253773.00 306993.00 82.7 Pass T27 459.5 - 449.5 Leg 3 1/2 1038 -240997.00 306993.00 78.5 Pass T28 449.5 - 429.5 Leg 3 1/2 1053 -243569.00 306993.00 79.3 Pass T29 429.5 - 409.5 Leg 3 1/2 1080 -262481.00 306993.00 85.5 Pass T30 409.5 - 399.5 Leg 3 1/2 1107 -278265.00 306993.00 90.6 Pass T31 399.5 - 379.5 Leg 3 3/4 1122 -320274.00 368382.00 86.9 Pass T32 379.5 - 369.5 Leg 3 3/4 1149 -346073.00 368382.00 93.9 Pass T33 369.5 - 349.5 Leg 3 3/4 1164 -359578.00 368382.00 97.6 Pass T34 349.5 - 339.5 Leg 3 3/4 1191 -308277.00 368382.00 83.7 Pass T35 339.5 - 329.5 Leg 3 3/4 1206 -282973.00 368382.00 76.8 Pass T36 329.5 - 309.5 Leg 3 3/4 1219 -278554.00 368382.00 75.6 Pass T37 309.5 - 279.5 Leg 3 3/4 1246 -278116.00 368382.00 75.5 Pass T38 279.5 - 264.5 Leg 3 3/4 1285 -279290.00 368382.00 75.8 Pass T39 264.5 - 254.5 Leg 3 3/4 1306 -305211.00 368382.00 82.9 Pass T40 254.5 - 249.5 Leg 3.75" SR with half pipe 1321 -324322.00 431239.00 75.2 Pass T41 249.5 - 239.5 Leg 3.75" SR with half pipe 1330 -362458.00 431239.00 84.1 Pass T42 239.5 - 229.5 Leg 3.75" SR with half pipe 1345 -352563.00 431239.00 81.8 Pass T43 229.5 - 219.5 Leg 3.75" SR with half pipe 1360 -310418.00 431239.00 72.0 Pass T44 219.5 - 194.5 Leg 4 1377 -385306.00 434617.00 88.7 Pass T45 194.5 - 189.5 Leg 4 1410 -394049.00 434617.00 90.7 Pass T46 189.5 - 179.5 Leg 4 1419 -412584.00 434617.00 94.9 Pass T47 179.5 - 159.5 Leg 4 1434 -424560.00 434617.00 97.7 Pass T48 159.5 - 129.5 Leg 4 1461 -421857.00 434617.00 97.1 Pass T49 129.5 - 124.5 Leg 4 1499 -373340.00 434617.00 85.9 Pass T50 124.5 - 119.5 Leg 4 1507 -359031.00 434617.00 82.6 Pass T51 119.5 - 114.5 Leg 4 1516 -371442.00 434617.00 85.5 Pass T52 114.5 - 99.5 Leg 4 1526 -414641.00 434617.00 95.4 Pass T53 99.5 - 79.5 Leg 4 1/4 1547 -449086.00 505612.00 88.8 Pass T54 79.5 - 69.5 Leg 4 1/4 1574 -455463.00 505612.00 90.1 Pass T55 69.5 - 59.5 Leg 4 1/4 1589 -454643.00 505612.00 89.9 Pass T56 59.5 - 39.5 Leg 4 1/4 1605 -450629.00 505612.00 89.1 Pass T57 39.5 - 29.5 Leg 4 1/4 1632 -423777.00 505612.00 83.8 Pass T58 29.5 - 19.5 Leg 4 1/4 1647 -400366.00 505612.00 79.2 Pass T59 19.5 - 11 Leg 4 1/4 1662 -380372.00 535079.00 71.1 Pass T60 11- 0 Leg 4 1/2 1686 -375836.00 610837.00 61.5 Pass T1 943.188 - 939.5 Diagonal 21-2 1/2x2x3/16x3/8 384 -19628.30 24212.80 81.1 Pass T2 939.5 - 909.5 Diagonal 2 405 -26093.20 44813.30 58.2 Pass T3 909.5 - 894.5 Diagonal 2 443 -13659.20 44545.20 30.7 Pass T4 894.5 - 879.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 465 -11415.20 26502.90 43.1 Pass T5 879.5 - 859.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 491 -8918.15 26311.20 33.9 Pass T6 859.5 - 849.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 506 -6151.15 26311.20 23.4 Pass T7 849.5 - 819.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 545 -4893.70 26311.20 18.6 Pass T8 819.5 - 789.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 555 -8547.80 26502.90 32.3 Pass T9 789.5 - 774.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 594 -10557.20 26502.90 39.8 Pass T10 774.5 - 759.5 Diagonal 2 621 -16559.60 44545.20 37.2 Pass T11 759.5 - 729.5 Diagonal 2 666 -15214.90 44545.20 34.2 Pass T12 729.5 - 699.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 704 -9580.04 26502.90 36.1 Pass T13 699.5 - 679.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 714 -8604.79 26696.70 32.2 Pass T14 679.5 - 669.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 741 -13123.90 26696.70 49.2 Pass T15 669.5 - 664.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 756 -14173.80 26696.70 53.1 Pass T16 664.5 - 659.5 Diagonal 2 765 -15353.60 44813.30 34.3 Pass ENVIROBUSINESS, INC. LOCATIONS I ATLANTA, GA I BALTIMORE, MD I BURLINGTON, MA I CHICAGO, IL DALLAS, TX I DENVER, CO I HOUSTON, TX I LOS ANGELES, CA I NEW YORK, NY I PHOENIX, AZ PORTLAND, OR I SAN FRANCISCO, CA I SEATTLE, WA I YORK, PA ■ EBI Consulting 21 B Street Burlington, MA 01803 Tel: (781) 273 2500 Fax: (781) 273-3311 environmental I engineering I due diligence www.ebiconsultinq.com Section Elevation Component Size Critical P oPauow % Pass No. ft Type Element lb lb Capacity Fail T17 659.5 - 639.5 Diagonal 2 774 -19942.30 44813.30 44.5 Pass T18 639.5 - 629.5 Diagonal 2 801 -21554.90 44813.30 48.1 Pass T19 629.5 - 609.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 833 -15747.20 26696.70 59.0 Pass T20 609.5 - 579.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 872 -12900.60 26696.70 48.3 Pass T21 579.5 - 549.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 911 -8103.58 26696.70 30.4 Pass T22 549.5 - 519.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 921 -12797.10 26696.70 47.9 Pass T23 519.5 - 499.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 960 -16167.70 26696.70 60.6 Pass T24 499.5 - 489.5 Diagonal 2 993 -17252.30 44813.30 38.5 Pass T25 489.5 - 474.5 Diagonal 2 1012 -12561.30 44813.30 28.0 Pass T26 474.5 - 459.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1033 -9774.03 26696.70 36.6 Pass T27 459.5 - 449.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1048 -6576.56 26696.70 24.6 Pass T28 449.5 - 429.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1059 -4474.05 26696.70 16.8 Pass T29 429.5 - 409.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1086 -8131.00 26696.70 30.5 Pass T30 409.5 - 399.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1113 -10218.30 26696.70 38.3 Pass T31 399.5 - 379.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1128 -14189.10 26892.60 52.8 Pass T32 379.5 - 369.5 Diagonal 2 1155 -15941.70 45081.90 35.4 Pass T33 369.5 - 349.5 Diagonal 2 1180 -21247.80 45081.90 47.1 Pass T34 349.5 - 339.5 Diagonal 2 1203 -15160.70 45081.90 33.6 Pass T35 339.5 - 329.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1218 -12740.80 26892.60 47.4 Pass T36 329.5 - 309.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1244 -10734.00 26892.60 39.9 Pass T37 309.5 - 279.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1252 -11628.50 26892.60 43.2 Pass T38 279.5 - 264.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1291 -15539.60 26892.60 57.8 Pass T39 264.5 - 254.5 Diagonal 2 1312 -17578.10 45081.90 39.0 Pass T40 254.5 - 249.5 Diagonal 2 1327 -18152.80 45283.90 40.1 Pass T41 249.5 - 239.5 Diagonal 2 1342 -19675.80 45486.10 43.3 Pass T42 239.5 - 229.5 Diagonal 2 1/4 1359 -37302.10 68171.40 54.7 Pass T43 229.5 - 219.5 Diagonal 2 1/4 1374 -34308.10 68171.40 50.3 Pass T44 219.5 - 194.5 Diagonal 2 1407 -25006.30 45351.20 55.1 Pass T45 194.5 - 189.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1414 -14286.50 27090.70 52.7 Pass T46 189.5 - 179.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1429 -13170.70 27090.70 48.6 Pass T47 179.5 - 159.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1456 -9553.27 27090.70 35.3 Pass T48 159.5 - 129.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1467 -15985.60 27090.70 59.0 Pass T49 129.5 - 124.5 Diagonal 2 1506 -24213.80 45351.20 53.4 Pass T50 124.5 - 119.5 Diagonal 2 1515 -24085.60 45351.20 53.1 Pass T51 119.5 - 114.5 Diagonal 2 1/4 1522 -22159.70 68011.60 32.6 Pass T52 114.5 - 99.5 Diagonal 2 1543 -19943.90 45351.20 44.0 Pass T53 99.5 - 79.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1570 -15403.00 27291.00 56.4 Pass T54 79.5 - 69.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1585 -8416.90 27291.00 30.8 Pass T55 69.5 - 59.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1602 -7607.21 27291.00 27.9 Pass T56 59.5 - 39.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1617 -14931.00 27291.00 54.7 Pass T57 39.5 - 29.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1644 -18407.10 27291.00 67.4 Pass T58 29.5 - 19.5 Diagonal 2 1659 -21352.80 45621.10 46.8 Pass T59 19.5 - 11 Diagonal 2L3x2x1/4x3/8 1678 -26651.80 27021.10 98.6 Pass T60 11- 0 Diagonal 1 1/2 1693 -17226.80 36035.10 47.8 Pass T2 939.5 - 909.5 Horizontal 2 396 -4817.22 62723.00 7.7 Pass T3 909.5 - 894.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 439 -4573.56 41216.10 11.1 Pass T4 894.5 - 879.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 454 -4287.95 41216.10 10.4 Pass T5 879.5 - 859.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 477 -4057.29 41025.20 9.9 Pass T6 859.5 - 849.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 502 -3870.92 23907.30 16.2 Pass T7 849.5 - 819.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 517 -3890.04 23907.30 16.3 Pass T8 819.5 - 789.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 556 -4528.17 24058.80 18.8 Pass T9 789.5 - 774.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 595 -5033.29 41216.10 12.2 Pass T10 774.5 - 759.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 616 -5366.13 41216.10 13.0 Pass T11 759.5 - 729.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 637 -5092.53 41216.10 12.4 Pass T12 729.5 - 699.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 678 -4458.31 24058.80 18.5 Pass T13 699.5 - 679.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 716 -4206.79 24210.70 17.4 Pass T14 679.5 - 669.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 742 -4287.44 41407.10 10.4 Pass T17 659.5 - 639.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 775 -4830.38 41407.10 11.7 Pass T18 639.5 - 629.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 802 -5095.79 41407.10 12.3 Pass T19 629.5 - 609.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 817 -5138.06 41407.10 12.4 Pass ENVIROBUSINESS, INC. LOCATIONS I ATLANTA, GA I BALTIMORE, MD I BURLINGTON, MA I CHICAGO, IL DALLAS, TX I DENVER, CO I HOUSTON, TX I LOS ANGELES, CA I NEW YORK, NY I PHOENIX, AZ PORTLAND, OR I SAN FRANCISCO, CA I SEATTLE, WA I YORK, PA ■ EBI Consulting 21 B Street Burlington, MA 01803 Tel: (781) 273 2500 Fax: (781) 273-3311 environmental I engineering I due diligence www.ebiconsultinq.com Section No. Elevation ft Component Type Size Critical Element p lb op./low lb % Capacity pass Fail T20 609.5 - 579.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 845 -4118.86 41407.10 9.9 Pass T21 579.5 - 549.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 884 -3702.95 24210.70 15.3 Pass T22 549.5 - 519.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 924 -3556.75 24210.70 14.7 Pass T23 519.5 - 499.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 968 -4475.01 41407.10 10.8 Pass T25 489.5 - 474.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1005 -4713.42 41407.10 11.4 Pass T26 474.5 - 459.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1025 -4395.48 41407.10 10.6 Pass T27 459.5 - 449.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1046 -4174.20 41407.10 10.1 Pass T28 449.5 - 429.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 1067 -4218.74 24210.70 17.4 Pass T29 429.5 - 409.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 1089 -4546.31 24210.70 18.8 Pass T30 409.5 - 399.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1115 -4819.69 41407.10 11.6 Pass T31 399.5 - 379.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1130 -5547.30 41598.30 13.3 Pass T32 379.5 - 369.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1158 -5994.16 41598.30 14.4 Pass T33 369.5 - 349.5 Horizontal 2 1172 -6228.07 62944.60 9.9 Pass T34 349.5 - 339.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1199 -5339.51 41598.30 12.8 Pass T35 339.5 - 329.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1214 -4901.23 41598.30 11.8 Pass T36 329.5 - 309.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 1228 -4824.70 24363.00 19.8 Pass T37 309.5 - 279.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 1261 -4817.11 24363.00 19.8 Pass T38 279.5 - 264.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1294 -4837.45 41598.30 11.6 Pass T39 264.5 - 254.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1317 -5286.40 41598.30 12.7 Pass T41 249.5 - 239.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1339 -6277.96 41885.50 15.0 Pass T42 239.5 - 229.5 Horizontal 2 1354 -6106.57 63277.00 9.7 Pass T43 229.5 - 219.5 Horizontal 2 1369 -5376.59 63277.00 8.5 Pass T44 219.5 - 194.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1385 -6673.69 41789.70 16.0 Pass T46 189.5 - 179.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1427 -7146.17 41789.70 17.1 Pass T47 179.5 - 159.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 1443 -7353.59 24515.70 30.0 Pass T48 159.5 - 129.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 1469 -7306.77 24515.70 29.8 Pass T52 114.5 - 99.5 Horizontal 2 1534 -7181.80 63166.20 11.4 Pass T53 99.5 - 79.5 Horizontal 2 1556 -7778.40 63387.80 12.3 Pass T54 79.5 - 69.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1582 -7888.86 41981.30 18.8 Pass T55 69.5 - 59.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1597 -7874.65 41981.30 18.8 Pass T56 59.5 - 39.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 1613 -7805.13 24668.80 31.6 Pass T57 39.5 - 29.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 1640 -7340.04 24668.80 29.8 Pass T58 29.5 - 19.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 1649 -7340.04 24668.80 29.8 Pass T60 11- 0 Horizontal 1 1/2 1689 63685.20 57255.50 111.2 Fail T1 943.188 - 939.5 Top Girt MC18x58 381 24529.80 554040.00 4.4 Pass T2 939.5 - 909.5 Top Girt 2 390 -1054.52 62723.00 1.7 Pass T3 909.5 - 894.5 Top Girt 2 429 652.82 101788.00 0.6 Pass T4 894.5 - 879.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 450 739.73 77931.10 0.9 Pass T5 879.5 - 859.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 471 797.08 77931.10 1.0 Pass T6 859.5 - 849.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 498 735.30 77931.10 0.9 Pass T7 849.5 - 819.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 513 741.29 57255.50 1.3 Pass T8 819.5 - 789.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 552 783.44 57255.50 1.4 Pass T9 789.5 - 774.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 591 817.41 77931.10 1.0 Pass T10 774.5 - 759.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 611 791.02 77931.10 1.0 Pass T11 759.5 - 729.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 633 1036.89 77931.10 1.3 Pass T12 729.5 - 699.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 671 1147.84 77931.10 1.5 Pass T13 699.5 - 679.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 710 1403.06 57255.50 2.5 Pass T14 679.5 - 669.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 736 1413.99 57255.50 2.5 Pass T15 669.5 - 664.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 752 1295.35 77931.10 1.7 Pass T16 664.5 - 659.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 762 1340.06 77931.10 1.7 Pass T17 659.5 - 639.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 771 1281.46 77931.10 1.6 Pass T18 639.5 - 629.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 798 1249.17 77931.10 1.6 Pass T20 609.5 - 579.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 840 1462.75 77931.10 1.9 Pass T21 579.5 - 549.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 879 1494.44 57255.50 2.6 Pass T22 549.5 - 519.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 918 1464.11 57255.50 2.6 Pass T23 519.5 - 499.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 957 1398.85 77931.10 1.8 Pass T24 499.5 - 489.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 984 1288.96 77931.10 1.7 Pass T25 489.5 - 474.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 999 1340.13 77931.10 1.7 Pass T26 474.5 - 459.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1020 1521.33 77931.10 2.0 Pass T27 459.5 - 449.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1040 1975.85 77931.10 2.5 Pass ENVIROBUSINESS, INC. LOCATIONS I ATLANTA, GA I BALTIMORE, MD I BURLINGTON, MA I CHICAGO, IL DALLAS, TX I DENVER, CO I HOUSTON, TX I LOS ANGELES, CA I NEW YORK, NY I PHOENIX, AZ PORTLAND, OR I SAN FRANCISCO, CA I SEATTLE, WA I YORK, PA ■ EBI Consulting 21 B Street Burlington, MA 01803 Tel: (781) 273 2500 Fax: (781) 273-3311 environmental I engineering I due diligence www.ebiconsultinq.com Section Elevation Component Size Critical P oPauow % Pass No. ft Type Element lb lb Capacity Fail T28 449.5 - 429.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1056 1601.37 77931.10 2.1 Pass T29 429.5 - 409.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 1083 1569.12 57255.50 2.7 Pass T30 409.5 - 399.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1110 1555.92 77931.10 2.0 Pass T31 399.5 - 379.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1125 1637.54 77931.10 2.1 Pass T32 379.5 - 369.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1152 1696.17 77931.10 2.2 Pass T33 369.5 - 349.5 Top Girt 2 1167 1552.52 101788.00 1.5 Pass T34 349.5 - 339.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1192 2714.75 77931.10 3.5 Pass T35 339.5 - 329.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1207 2051.86 77931.10 2.6 Pass T36 329.5 - 309.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1224 2058.03 77931.10 2.6 Pass T37 309.5 - 279.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 1250 2470.16 57255.50 4.3 Pass T38 279.5 - 264.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 1290 2042.65 57255.50 3.6 Pass T39 264.5 - 254.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1311 2023.95 77931.10 2.6 Pass T40 254.5 - 249.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1326 1901.20 77931.10 2.4 Pass T41 249.5 - 239.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1333 1870.41 77931.10 2.4 Pass T43 229.5 - 219.5 Top Girt 2 1365 3110.34 101788.00 3.1 Pass T44 219.5 - 194.5 Top Girt 2 1378 5309.42 101788.00 5.2 Pass T45 194.5 - 189.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1413 3019.61 77931.10 3.9 Pass T46 189.5 - 179.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1420 2930.62 77931.10 3.8 Pass T47 179.5 - 159.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 1435 2950.17 57255.50 5.2 Pass T48 159.5 - 129.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 1462 2968.25 57255.50 5.2 Pass T49 129.5 - 124.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1501 5087.96 77931.10 6.5 Pass T50 124.5 - 119.5 Top Girt 2 1512 2595.34 101788.00 2.5 Pass T52 114.5 - 99.5 Top Girt 2 1530 2796.50 101788.00 2.7 Pass T53 99.5 - 79.5 Top Girt 2 1549 3307.17 101788.00 3.2 Pass T54 79.5 - 69.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1576 3473.58 77931.10 4.5 Pass T55 69.5 - 59.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1591 3441.18 77931.10 4.4 Pass T56 59.5 - 39.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 1606 3371.38 57255.50 5.9 Pass T57 39.5 - 29.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 1633 3260.97 57255.50 5.7 Pass T59 19.5 - 11 Top Girt 2L3x2x1/4x3/8 1665 -15674.80 47218.90 33.2 Pass T59 19.5 - 11 Redund Horz 1 2L2x2x1/4x3/8 1676 -6588.24 55096.40 12.0 Pass Bracing T59 19.5 - 11 Redund Diag 1 2L2x2x1/4x3/8 1677 -10417.90 34491.10 30.2 Pass Bracing T2 939.5 - 909.5 Guy A@919.5 1 5/8 1704 157484.00 194400.00 81.0 Pass T10 774.5 - 759.5 Guy A@769.5 1 1/4 1707 90265.90 115200.00 78.4 Pass T19 629.5 - 609.5 Guy A@629.5 1 3/16 1710 86385.50 103200.00 83.7 Pass T24 499.5 - 489.5 Guy A@494.5 1 1/4 1713 77168.60 115200.00 67.0 Pass T33 369.5 - 349.5 Guy A@364.5 1 1/4 1716 68552.70 115200.00 59.5 Pass T42 239.5 - 229.5 Guy A@239.5 1 1/4 1719 86228.90 115200.00 74.9 Pass T51 119.5 - 114.5 Guy A@119.5 1 1722 62368.00 73200.00 85.2 Pass T2 939.5 - 909.5 Guy B@919.5 1 5/8 1703 157605.00 194400.00 81.1 Pass T10 774.5 - 759.5 Guy B@769.5 1 1/4 1706 88807.00 115200.00 77.1 Pass T19 629.5 - 609.5 Guy B@629.5 1 3/16 1709 85033.00 103200.00 82.4 Pass T24 499.5 - 489.5 Guy B@494.5 1 1/4 1712 77443.90 115200.00 67.2 Pass T33 369.5 - 349.5 Guy B@364.5 1 1/4 1715 70864.00 115200.00 61.5 Pass T42 239.5 - 229.5 Guy B@239.5 1 1/4 1718 86608.20 115200.00 75.2 Pass T51 119.5 - 114.5 Guy B@119.5 1 1721 62081.00 73200.00 84.8 Pass T2 939.5 - 909.5 Guy C@919.5 1 5/8 1702 157504.00 194400.00 81.0 Pass T10 774.5 - 759.5 Guy C@769.5 1 1/4 1705 88833.70 115200.00 77.1 Pass T19 629.5 - 609.5 Guy C@629.5 13/16 1708 85116.30 103200.00 82.5 Pass T24 499.5 - 489.5 Guy C@494.5 1 1/4 1711 77618.60 115200.00 67.4 Pass T33 369.5 - 349.5 Guy C@364.5 1 1/4 1714 70707.30 115200.00 61.4 Pass T42 239.5 - 229.5 Guy C@239.5 1 1/4 1717 87006.30 115200.00 75.5 Pass T51 119.5 - 114.5 Guy C@119.5 1 1720 61609.00 73200.00 84.2 Pass T2 939.5 - 909.5 Top Guy Pull- 2C6x8.2x0.375 402 55392.30 137025.00 40.4 Pass Off@919.5 T10 774.5 - 759.5 Top Guy Pull- 2C6x8.2x0.375 624 35153.70 137025.00 25.7 Pass Off@769.5 T19 629.5 - 609.5 Top Guy Pull- 2C6x8.2x0.375 813 37526.40 137025.00 27.4 Pass Off@629.5 ENVIROBUSINESS, INC. LOCATIONS I ATLANTA, GA I BALTIMORE, MD I BURLINGTON, MA I CHICAGO, IL DALLAS, TX I DENVER, CO I HOUSTON, TX I LOS ANGELES, CA I NEW YORK, NY I PHOENIX, AZ PORTLAND, OR I SAN FRANCISCO, CA I SEATTLE, WA I YORK, PA EBI 27 21 B Street Consulting Burlington, 01803 Tel: (781) 273 2500 Fax: (781)273-3311 environmental I engineering I due diligence www.ebiconsuItinq.com Section Elevation Component Size Critical P opa// w % Pass No. ft Type Element lb lb Capacity Fail T24 499.5 - 489.5 Top Guy Pull- 2C6x8.2x0.375 988 28994.40 137025.00 21.2 Pass Off@494.5 T33 369.5 - 349.5 Top Guy Pull- 2C6x8.2x0.375 1185 32020.10 137025.00 23.4 Pass Off@364.5 T42 239.5 - 229.5 Top Guy Pull- 2C6x8.2x0.375 1350 45581.00 137025.00 33.3 Pass Off@239.5 T51 119.5 - 114.5 Top Guy Pull- 2C6x8.2x0.375 1521 37847.80 137025.00 27.6 Pass Off @ 119.5 Summary Latticed 60.9 Pass Pole Leg (1-4) Latticed 56.8 Pass Pole Diagonal (L4) Latticed 61.5 Pass Pole K-Brace (L4) Latticed 57.2 Pass Pole Top Girt (L4) Latticed 53.3 Pass Pole Bottom Girt (L3) Latticed 33.5 Pass Pole Mid Girt (L4) Latticed 8.3 Pass Pole Inner Bracing (1-4) Leg (T10) 123.7 Fail Diagonal 98.6 Pass (T59) Horizontal 111.2 Fail (T60) Top Girt 33.2 Pass (T59) Redund 12.0 Pass Harz 1 Bracing (T59) Redund Diag 30.2 Pass 1 Bracing (T59) Guy A (T51) 85.2 Pass Guy B (T51) 84.8 Pass Guy C (T51) 84.2 Pass Top Guy 40.4 Pass Pull -Off (T2) Bolt Checks 55.7 Pass RATING = 123.7 Fail The maximum stress under the proposed conditions and configurations is 123.7% of the tower capacity, governed by the tower legs in tower section T10 (774..5' to 759.5' AGL). Therefore, the tower has inadequate structural capacity for the proposed equipment configurations. EBI recommends that the legs in the failing tower sections (section T3 at 894.5' to 909.5' AGL and sections T5 through T12 at 699.5' to ENVIROBUSINESS, INC. LOCATIONS I ATLANTA, GA I BALTIMORE, MD I BURLINGTON, MA I CHICAGO, IL DALLAS, TX I DENVER, CO I HOUSTON, TX I LOS ANGELES, CA I NEW YORK, NY I PHOENIX, AZ PORTLAND, OR I SAN FRANCISCO, CA I SEATTLE, WA I YORK, PA EBI 27 21 B Street Consulting Burlington, 01803 Tel: (781) 273 2500 Fax: (781) 273-3311 environmental I engineering I due diligence www.ebiconsuItinq.com 879.5' AGL) be reinforced, and that the failing horizontal members at tower section T60 (0' to 11' AGL) be reinforced or replaced. Additional analysis is required for a modification design. Foundations: Foundation and geotechnical information was not provided to EBI Consulting for this analysis, and EBI did not perform a rigorous analysis of the foundation. A comparison of tower reactions to the reactions of the previous analysis supplied to EBI is provided herein. Foundation reactions are as summarized: Load Current analysis reaction (TIA-222-G) Previous analysis reaction (TIA- 222-G)* Tower base shear (kips) 5.7 7 Tower base axial (kips) 955.6 952 Inner anchor shear (kips) (425' radius) 236.7 209 Inner anchor uplift (kips) (425' radius) 155.8 156 Outer anchor shear (kips) (715' radius) 216.5 214 exceeds previous by 1% exceeds previous by 1.1% exceeds previous by 1% Outer anchor uplift (kips) (715' radius) 219.2 215 exceeds previous by 1% *Tower reactions as reported in the Tower Design and Calculations report prepared by ERI, dated 411212011 The previous analysis by ERI notes that both the tower base foundation and outer anchor foundations were (under the loading considered in that report) very near their full allowable capacity. The tower reactions are found to exceed previous analysis reactions, and EBI is unable to determine if the existing structure is sufficient for the proposed loading due to lack of information. Limitations and Conditions: This report is based on the following assumptions. Please notify EBI Consulting immediately should any of these conditions be found not to exist: 1. Tower is properly installed and maintained. 2. All members are as specified in the original design documents and are in good condition. 3. All required members are in place. 4. All bolts are in place and are tightly fastened. 5. Tower is in plumb condition. 6. All member protective coatings are in good condition. 7. All tower members were properly designed, detailed, fabricated, and installed, and have been properly maintained since erection. 8. Foundations were properly designed, constructed, and analyzed to support original and previous analysis design loads. EBI is not responsible for any modifications prior to or hereafter in which EBI is not or was not directly involved. Modifications include but are not limited to: 1. Adding antennas 2. Removing/replacing antennas 3. Adding coaxial cables EBI hereby states that this document represents the entire report and that it assumes no liability for any factual changes that may occur after the date of this report. All representations, recommendations, and ENVIROBUSINESS, INC. LOCATIONS I ATLANTA, GA I BALTIMORE, MD I BURLINGTON, MA I CHICAGO, IL DALLAS, TX I DENVER, CO I HOUSTON, TX I LOS ANGELES, CA I NEW YORK, NY I PHOENIX, AZ PORTLAND, OR I SAN FRANCISCO, CA I SEATTLE, WA I YORK, PA EBI Consulting21 B Street Burlington, MA Ol 803 Tel: (781) 273 2500 Fax: (781) 273 - 331 1 A environmental I engineering I due diligence www.ebiconsultinq.com conclusions are based upon information contained and set forth herein. If any information conflicts with that which is contained herein, please disregard this report and contact EBI. EBI disclaims all liability for any representation, recommendation, or conclusion not expressly stated herein. Please feel free to contact our office should you have any questions. ��IIIII+�rrrrru�i,, RK Sincerely yours, \�,� •. 0 E N'S �] =* No 82581 *_ I STATE OF �= Kelly Shanahan, P.E. moo'•• :`'4'/ 0 R 1 0 • \ \�� ENVIROBUSINESS, INC. LOCATIONS I ATLANTA, GA I BALTIMORE, MD i BURLINGTON, MA I CHICAGO, IL DALLAS, TX I DENVER, CO I HOUSTON, TX I LOS ANGELES, CA I NEW YORK, NY I PHOENIX, AZ PORTLAND, OR I SAN FRANCISCO, CA I SEATTLE, WA I YORK, PA EBI Consulting environmental I engineering I due diligence STRUCTURAL DESIGN PARAMETERS BUILDING CODE: STRUCTURE CLASS (RISK CATEGORY): WIND LOADS: ULTIMATE WIND SPEED, V: EXPOSURE CATEGORY: IMPORTANCE FACTOR, I: SEE LETTER 159 MPH 1.0 21 B Street Burlington, MA 01803 Tel: (781) 273-2500 Fax: (781)273-3311 www.ebiconsuItinq.com ENVIROBUSINESS, INC. LOCATIONS I ATLANTA, GA I BALTIMORE, MD I BURLINGTON, MA I CHICAGO, IL DALLAS, TX I DENVER, CO I HOUSTON, TX I LOS ANGELES, CA I NEW YORK, NY I PHOENIX, AZ PORTLAND, OR I SAN FRANCISCO, CA I SEATTLE, WA I YORK, PA EBI Consulting environmental I engineering I due diligence APPENDIX A TNX Tower Results 21 B Street Burlington, MA 01803 Tel: (781) 273-2500 Fax: (781) 273-3311 www.ebiconsuItinq.com ENVIROBUSINESS, INC. LOCATIONS I ATLANTA, GA I BALTIMORE, MD I BURLINGTON, MA I CHICAGO, IL DALLAS, TX I DENVER, CO I HOUSTON, TX I LOS ANGELES, CA I NEW YORK, NY I PHOENIX, AZ PORTLAND, OR I SAN FRANCISCO, CA I SEATTLE, WA I YORK, PA g w U ❑ � ro d s " E N N fL N O N K N � K N � Q rc W m AZ tt in O ^ rn � d m y � N Q Zt O � � m N rc R m rc tt Q q � A 4 Q dd� d O i m� N � N a n rc ¢ a U �m rc C � C N m Y A 7< yJ Y O y w Y Y 4 F - n LL z a Zt a f Y Y � 8 2 2 K - Z Z - _ O 41 O na F� isdoa` ro 2� K� n� H LL mE it 5671 Ib---� 955560 lb (Axial) 16746 lb-ft (Torque) R=715.gg PLAN DESIGNED APPURTENANCE LOADING ft Crows nest lightning dissipator 1016 DB812 (7/8" coax) 295 8HPX-8AC(WAW-FM 101.1 MHz #05328A/3-1/8"rigid) 1012-944.15 Beacon f"conduit) 289.5 6'solid dish(EW63) 230 A/R brackets for SHPX-8AC 1012 - 944.15 (2) Ericsson RRUS-2212 (sideways) 220 AIR brackets for SHPX-8AC 1012 - 944.15 (2) Ericsson RRUS-2212 (sideways) 220 Index plate assembly 943.188 (2) Ericsson RRUS-2212 (sideways) 220 ERI LP-lE-SP (WAW-HDFM, 101.1 Mhz, #21223) 921 RRUS-32 220 RRUS-32 220 Red lights 878 (3)Stati-cats 794 RRUS-32 220 Rsycap RRFDC-3315-PF48 OVP w/ pipe mast 220 Emplytie-back 754 2-way ASP 735 Raycap RRFDC-3315-PF-48 OVP w/ pipe mast 220 2-way ASP mount 735 Red lights 727 (2)JMAX7COAP-86-865-Vw/pipe mast 220 DB228 726- 685.75 DB228 726-685.75 (2)JMAX7CDAP-86-865-Vw/pip. mast 220 DB228 mounts 726- 685 mas(MAX7COAP-86-865-V w/pipe t 220 TxRx 10068-10-X-03N(#16361) (2-1/4" coax) 675 TxRx 10068-10-X-03N mount 675 Veirmn sector frame mount 220 12'whip w/mount (1/2"coax) 651 Verzon sector frame mount 220 (3) Stati-Cats 591 Varzon sector frame mount 220 (3) Stati-Cats 199.5 Beacon (1" conduit) 584 4'lid dish(EW63) 185 Cewave PD458(7/8"coax) 458 Celwave mount 458 Red lights (1-1/4") 148.25 6'solid dish (EW63) 140 Red lights (1" conduit) 437 Nextel sector frame mount 130 DB264 w/ mount (7/8" coax) 422 - 412 (3) stab -cats 405 Nextel sector frame mount NexteI sectork'3)DB848H90 anels 130 130 (2) DB858HV09 (alltel) ((2) 7/8" coax, (1) 1-5/8" coax) 359.5 - 342 p (4) 2" Sch. 40 x 96" mount pipes (#16361 B) ((3) 7/8" coax) (2) DB858HV09 (alltel) ((2) 7/8" coax, (1) 1-5/8" coax) 359.5 - 342 Nextel sector C: (3) DB848H90 panels, (4) 2" Sch. 40 x 96" mount pipes (#16361B) ((3) 7/8" coax) 130 DB436 yagi (on 6' grid rim) (7/8" coax) 321 VOW (1-1/4" coax) 321 Nextel sector B: (3) DBI48H90 panels, (4) 2" Sch. 40 x 96" mount pipes (#16361S) ((3) 7/8" coax) 130 BCR12 antenna mount 318.5 - 295.5 BCR12 (1-5/8"coax) 318 - 295 BCR12(1-5/8"coax) 313.5-290.5 Nextel sector frame mount 130 BCR12 antenna mount 1313.5-290.5 LIST SYMBOL MARK SIZE MARK SIZE A 3.75" SR with haft pipe K SR 1 3/4 B SR 41/2 L N.A. C SR 3/4 M 12x1 D SR 7/8 N 2L2x2xl/4x3/8 E 212 1/2x2x3/16x3/8 O 2C6x8.2x0.375 F SR 2 1/4 P 11 Q 1.84028 G SR 2 O 1 @ 3.688 H 2L3x2xl/4x3/8 R 1 () 8.5 1 SR 1 1/2 S 3 (trJ 3.86687 Imo, I mo -o I \ \ \ MATERIAL STRENGTH TOWER DESIGN NOTE\\ I. Tower is located in Collier County, Florida. 2. Tower designed for Exposure C to the TIA-222-G Standard. 3. Tower designed for a 159 mph basic wind in accordance with the TIA-222-G Standard. 4. Deflections are based upon a 60 mph wind. \\ 5. Tower Risk Category II. 6. Topographic Category 1 with Crest Height of 0.00 ft 1. Weld together tower sections have flange connections. 8. Connections use galvanized A325 bolts, nuts and locking devices. Installation per TIA/EIA-222 and AISC Specifications. \\ 9. Tower members are "hot dipped" galvanized in accordance with ASTM A123 and ASTM At 53,86lb Standards. \\\\ 1 10. Welds are fabricated with ER-70S-6 electrodes. 2366821b 1 6 2164841b 6 R=715.00 R R-025.00 ft ALL REACTIONS ARE FACTORED EBI Consultinglob: 21 B Street Burlington, MA 01803 Consulting Engineers Phone: (781) 273-2500 FAX: 781 273-3311 Alpine Broadcasting Pmied:8117000785 Client Verizon Wireless n-n by kshanahan App'd: Code: TIA-222-1 Dare: 07/18/18 scale: NTS Path: Dwg No. E-1 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 1 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX. (781) 273-3311 Tower Input Data The main tower is a 3x guyed tower with an overall height of 1016.00 ft above the ground line. The base of the tower is set at an elevation of 0.00 ft above the ground line. The face width of the tower is 6.00 ft at the top and tapered at the base. An index plate is provided at the 3 sided -tower connection. There is a 3 sided latticed pole with a face width of 3.50 ft. This tower is designed using the TIA-222-G standard. The following design criteria apply: Tower is located in Collier County, Florida. ASCE 7-10 Wind Data is used. Basic wind speed of 159 mph. Risk Category II. Exposure Category C. Topographic Category 1. Crest Height 0.00 ft. Deflections calculated using a wind speed of 60 mph. Weld together tower sections have flange connections.. Connections use galvanized A325 bolts, nuts and locking devices. Installation per TIA/EIA-222 and AISC Specifications.. Tower members are "hot dipped" galvanized in accordance with ASTM A123 and ASTM A153 Standards.. Welds are fabricated with ER-70S-6 electrodes.. Pressures are calculated at each section. Stress ratio used in latticed pole member design is 1. Safety factor used in guy design is 1. Stress ratio used in tower member design is 1. Local bending stresses due to climbing loads, feed line supports, and appurtenance mounts are not considered. Consider Moments - Legs Consider Moments - Horizontals Consider Moments - Diagonals Use Moment Magnification Use Code Stress Ratios Use Code Safety Factors - Guys Escalate Ice Always Use Max Kz Use Special Wind Profile Include Bolts In Member Capacity Leg Bolts Are At Top Of Section Secondary Horizontal Braces Leg Use Diamond Inner Bracing (4 Sided) SR Members Have Cut Ends SR Members Are Concentric Options Distribute Leg Loads As Uniform Assume Legs Pinned Assume Rigid Index Plate Use Clear Spans For Wind Area Use Clear Spans For KL/r Retension Guys To Initial Tension Bypass Mast Stability Checks Use Azimuth Dish Coefficients Project Wind Area of Appurt. Autocalc Torque Arm Areas Add IBC .6D+W Combination Sort Capacity Reports By Component Triangulate Diamond Inner Bracing Treat Feed Line Bundles As Cylinder Use ASCE 10 X-Brace Ly Rules Calculate Redundant Bracing Forces Ignore Redundant Members in FEA SR Leg Bolts Resist Compression All Leg Panels Have Same Allowable Offset Girt At Foundation Consider Feed Line Torque Include Angle Block Shear Check Use TIA-222-G Bracing Resist. Exemption Use TIA-222-G Tension Splice Exemption Poles Include Shear -Torsion Interaction Always Use Sub -Critical Flow Use Top Mounted Sockets tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 2 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed by Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX- (781) 273-3311 Wind 180 Q T 7 0 gA Wind 90 o� Leg C Z Leg B GG Face C G4ye Wind 0 Corner & Starmount Guyed Tower 3 Sided Latticed Pole Section Geometry Assembly Description Section Number Section Tower Tower Section Elevation Database Width of Length Sections ft ft ft Ll 1016.00-996.62 3.50 1 19.39 L2 996.62-977.23 3.50 1 19.39 L3 977.23-957.85 3.50 1 19.39 L4 957.85-943.19 3.50 1 14.66 3 Sided Latticed Pole Section Geometry cont'd Bracing Has Has Top Girt Bottom Girt Tower Tower Diagonal Section Elevation Spacing Type K Brace Horizontals Offset Offset End ft it Panels in in Ll 1016.00-996.62 1.84 X Brace Yes No 0.0000 1.0000 L2 996.62-977.23 1.62 X Brace Yes No 1.0000 1.0000 L3 977.23-957.85 1.62 X Brace Yes No 1.0000 1.0000 L4 957.85-943.19 1.62 X Brace Yes No 1.0000 1.0000 tnxTower Job Page3 Alpine Broadcasting of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed by Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX- (781) 273-3311 Tower Leg Elevation Type Ll Solid Round 1016.00-996.62 L2 996.62-977.23 Solid Round L3 977.23-957.85 Solid Round L4 957.85-943.19 Solid Round 3 Sided Latticed Pole Section Geometry cont'd Leg Leg Diagonal Size Grade Type 2 A572-50 Solid Round (50 ksi) 2 A572-50 Solid Round (50 ksi) 3 A572-50 Solid Round (50 ksi) 3 1/2 A572-50 Solid Round (50 ksi) Diagonal Diagonal Size Grade 3/4 A36 (36 ksi) 7/8 A36 (36 ksi) 1 A36 (36 ksi) 1 A36 (36 ksi) 3 Sided Latticed Pole Section Geometry cont'd Tower Top Girt Top Girt Top Girt Bottom Girt Bottom Girt Bottom Girt Elevation Type Size Grade Type Size Grade ft Ll Flat Bar 2xl/2 A36 Flat Bar 2xl/2 A36 1016.00-996.62 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) L2996.62-977.23 Flat Bar 2xl/2 A36 Flat Bar 2xl/2 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) L3977.23-957.85 Flat Bar 2x1/2 A36 Flat Bar 2x1/2 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) L4 957.85-943.19 Flat Bar 2xl/2 A36 Flat Bar 12x1 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) 3 Sided Latticed Pole Section Geometry cont'd Tower No. Mid Girt Mid Girt Mid Girt Horizontal Horizontal Horizontal Elevation of Type Size Grade Type Size Grade Mid Ll 3 Flat Bar 2xl/2 A36 Flat Bar A36 1016.00-996.62 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) L2 996.62-977.23 3 Flat Bar 2x1/2 A36 Flat Bar A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) L3 977.23-957.85 3 Flat Bar 2x1 /2 A36 Flat Bar A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) L4 957.85-943.19 2 Flat Bar 2xl/2 A36 Flat Bar A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) 3 Sided Latticed Pole Section Geometry cont'd tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 4 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Secondary Secondary Horizontal Secondary Inner Bracing Inner Bracing Size Inner Bracing Elevation Horizontal Type Size Horizontal Type Grade Grade ft Ll Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 5/8 A36 1016.00-996.62 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) L2 996.62-977.23 Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 5/8 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) L3 977.23-957.85 Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 5/8 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) L4 957.85-943.19 Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 5/8 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) 3 Sided Latticed Pole Section Geometry cont'd Tower Gusset Gusset Gusset Grade Adjust. Factor Adjust. Elevation Area Thickness Af Factor (per face) Ar ft ft, in Ll 0.00 0.0000 A36 1 1 1016.00-996.6 (36 ksi) 2 L2 0.00 0.0000 A36 1 1 996.62-977.23 (36 ksi) L3 0.00 0.0000 A36 1 I 977.23-957.85 (36 ksi) L4 0.00 0.0000 A36 1 I 957.85-943.19 (36 ksi) Weight Mult. Double Angle Double Angle Double Angle Stitch Bolt Stitch Bolt Stitch Bolt Spacing Spacing Spacing Diagonals Horizontals Redundants in in in 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 3 Sided Latticed Pole Section Geometry cont'd K Factors' Tower Calc Calc Legs X K Single Girts Horiz. Sec. Inner Elevation K K Brace Brace Diags Horiz. Brace Single Solid Diags Diags Angles Rounds X X X X X X X ft Y Y Y Y Y Y Y L1 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1016.00-996.6 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 L2 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 996.62-977.23 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 L3 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 977.23-957.85 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 L4 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 957.85-943.19 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 'Note: K factors are applied to member segment lengths. K-braces without inner supporting members will have the K factor in the out -of -plane direction applied to the overall length 3 Sided Latticed Pole Section Geometry cont'd tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 5 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Elevation ft Leg Diagonal Top Girt Bottom Girt Mid Girt Long Horizontal Short Horizontal Net Width U Net Width U Net Width U Net U Net U Net U Net U Deduct Deduct Deduct Width Width Width Width in in in Deduct Deduct Deduct Deduct 0.0000 0.75 in in 0.0000 0.75 in 0.0000 0.75 in L1 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 1016.00-996.6 2 L2 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 996.62-977.23 U0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 977.23-957.85 L4 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 957.85-943.19 Tower Section Geometry Tower Tower Assembly Section Elevation Database fit Tl 943.19-939.50 T2 939.50-909.50 T3 909.50-894.50 T4 894.50-879.50 T5 879.50-859.50 T6 859.50-849.50 T7 849.50-819.50 T8 819.50-789.50 T9 789.50-774.50 T10 774.50-759.50 T 11 759.50-729.50 T12 729.50-699.50 T13 699.50-679.50 T14 679.50-669.50 T15 669.50-664.50 T16 664.50-659.50 T17 659.50-639.50 T18 639.50-629.50 T19 629.50-609.50 T20 609.50-579.50 T21 579.50-549.50 T22 549.50-519.50 T23 519.50-499.50 T24 499.50-489.50 T25 489.50-474.50 T26 474.50-459.50 T27 459.50-449.50 T28 449.50-429.50 T29 429.50-409.50 T30 409.50-399.50 T31 399.50-379.50 T32 379.50-369.50 T33 369.50-349.50 T34 349.50-339.50 T35 339.50-329.50 T36 329.50-309.50 Description Section Number Section Width of Length Sections fit fit 6.00 1 3.69 6.00 1 30.00 6.00 1 15.00 6.00 1 15.00 6.00 1 20.00 6.00 1 10.00 6.00 1 30.00 6.00 1 30.00 6.00 1 15.00 6.00 1 15.00 6.00 1 30.00 6.00 1 30.00 6.00 1 20.00 6.00 1 10.00 6.00 1 5.00 6.00 1 5.00 6.00 1 20.00 6.00 1 10.00 6.00 1 20.00 6.00 1 30.00 6.00 1 30.00 6.00 1 30.00 6.00 1 20.00 6.00 1 10.00 6.00 1 15.00 6.00 1 15.00 6.00 1 10.00 6.00 1 20.00 6.00 1 20.00 6.00 1 10.00 6.00 1 20.00 6.00 1 10.00 6.00 1 20.00 6.00 1 10.00 6.00 1 10.00 6.00 1 20.00 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 6 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Tower Assembly Description Section Number Section Section Elevation Database Width of Length Sections ft ft ft T37 309.50-279.50 6.00 1 30.00 T38 279.50-264.50 6.00 1 15.00 T39 264.50-254.50 6.00 1 10.00 T40 254.50-249.50 6.00 1 5.00 T41 249.50-239.50 6.00 1 10.00 T42 239.50-229.50 6.00 1 10.00 T43 229.50-219.50 6.00 1 10.00 T44 219.50-194.50 6.00 1 25.00 T45 194.50-189.50 6.00 1 5.00 T46 189.50-179.50 6.00 1 10.00 T47 179.50-159.50 6.00 1 20.00 T48 159.50-129.50 6.00 1 30.00 T49 129.50-124.50 6.00 1 5.00 T50 124.50-119.50 6.00 1 5.00 T51 119.50-114.50 6.00 1 5.00 T52 114.50-99.50 6.00 1 15.00 T53 99.50-79.50 6.00 1 20.00 T54 79.50-69.50 6.00 1 10.00 T55 69.50-59.50 6.00 1 10.00 T56 59.50-39.50 6.00 1 20.00 T57 39.50-29.50 6.00 1 10.00 T58 29.50-19.50 6.00 1 10.00 T59 19.50-11.00 6.00 1 8.50 T60 11.00-0.00 6.00 1 11.00 Tower Section Geometry cont'd Tower Tower Diagonal Bracing Has Has Top Girt Bottom Girt Section Elevation Spacing Type KBrace Horizontals Offset Offset End ft ft Panels in in Tl 943.19-939.50 3.69 Diag Down No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T2 939.50-909.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T3 909.50-894.50 5.00 K Brace Left No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T4 894.50-879.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T5 879.50-859.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T6 859.50-849.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T7 849.50-819.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T8 819.50-789.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T9 789.50-774.50 5.00 K Brace Left No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T10 774.50-759.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T11 759.50-729.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T12 729.50-699.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T13 699.50-679.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T14 679.50-669.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T15 669.50-664.50 5.00 Diag Up No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T16 664.50-659.50 5.00 Diag Down No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T17 659.50-639.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T18 639.50-629.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T19 629.50-609.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T20 609.50-579.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T21 579.50-549.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T22 549.50-519.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T23 519.50-499.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T24 499.50-489.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 7 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Tower Diagonal Bracing Has Has Top Girt Bottom Girt Section Elevation Spacing Type KBrace Horizontals Offset Offset End ft ft Panels in in T25 489.50-474.50 5.00 K Brace Left No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T26 474.50-459.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T27 459.50-449.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T28 449.50-429.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T29 429.50-409.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T30 409.50-399.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T31 399.50-379.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T32 379.50-369.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T33 369.50-349.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T34 349.50-339.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T35 339.50-329.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T36 329.50-309.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T37 309.50-279.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T38 279.50-264.50 5.00 K Brace Left No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T39 264.50-254.50 5.00 K Brace Left No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T40 254.50-249.50 5.00 Diag Down No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T41 249.50-239.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T42 239.50-229.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T43 229.50-219.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T44 219.50-194.50 5.00 K Brace Left No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T45 194.50-189.50 5.00 Diag Down No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T46 189.50-179.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T47 179.50-159.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T48 159.50-129.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T49 129.50-124.50 5.00 Diag Up No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T50 124.50-119.50 5.00 Diag Down No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T51 119.50-114.50 5.00 Diag Up No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T52 114.50-99.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T53 99.50-79.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T54 79.50-69.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T55 69.50-59.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T56 59.50-39.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T57 39.50-29.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T58 29.50-19.50 5.00 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T59 19.50-11.00 8.50 Kl Down No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 T60 11.00-0.00 3.67 K Brace Right No Yes 0.0000 0.0000 Tower Section Geometry cont'd Tower Leg Leg Leg Diagonal Diagonal Diagonal Elevation Type Size Grade Type Size Grade T1943.19-939.50 Solid Round 31/2 A572-50 Double Angle 2L21/2x2x3/16x3/8 A36 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T2 939.50-909.50 Solid Round 3 1/2 A572-50 Solid Round 2 A36 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T3 909.50-894.50 Solid Round 3 1/4 A572-50 Solid Round 2 A36 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T4 894.50-879.50 Solid Round 3 1/4 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T5 879.50-859.50 Solid Round 3 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T6 859.50-849.50 Solid Round 3 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T7 849.50-819.50 Solid Round 3 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T8 819.50-789.50 Solid Round 3 1/4 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 8 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Elevation ft Leg Type Leg Size Leg Grade Diagonal Type Diagonal Size Diagonal Grade (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T9 789.50-774.50 Solid Round 3 1/4 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T10 Solid Round 31/4 A572-50 Solid Round 2 A36 774.50-759.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) Tl l Solid Round 3 1/4 A572-50 Solid Round 2 A36 759.50-729.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T12 Solid Round 3 1/4 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 729.50-699.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T13 Solid Round 3 1/2 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 699.50-679.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T14 Solid Round 3 1/2 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 679.50-669.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T15 Solid Round 3 1/2 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 669.50-664.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T16 Solid Round 3 1/2 A572-50 Solid Round 2 A36 664.50-659.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T17 Solid Round 3 1/2 A572-50 Solid Round 2 A36 659.50-639.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T18 Solid Round 3 1/2 A572-50 Solid Round 2 A36 639.50-629.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T19 Solid Round 3 1/2 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 629.50-609.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T20 Solid Round 3 1/2 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 609.50-579.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T21 Solid Round 3 1/2 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 579.50-549.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T22 Solid Round 3 1/2 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 549.50-519.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T23 Solid Round 3 1/2 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 519.50-499.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T24 Solid Round 3 1/2 A572-50 Solid Round 2 A36 499.50-489.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T25 Solid Round 3 1/2 A572-50 Solid Round 2 A36 489.50-474.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T26 Solid Round 3 1/2 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 474.50-459.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T27 Solid Round 3 1/2 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 459.50-449.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T28 Solid Round 3 1/2 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 449.50-429.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T29 Solid Round 3 1/2 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 429.50-409.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T30 Solid Round 3 1/2 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 409.50-399.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T31 Solid Round 3 3/4 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 399.50-379.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T32 Solid Round 3 3/4 A572-50 Solid Round 2 A36 379.50-369.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T33 Solid Round 3 3/4 A572-50 Solid Round 2 A36 369.50-349.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T34 Solid Round 3 3/4 A572-50 Solid Round 2 A36 349.50-339.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T35 Solid Round 3 3/4 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 339.50-329.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T36 Solid Round 3 3/4 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 329.50-309.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T37 Solid Round 3 3/4 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 309.50-279.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T38 Solid Round 3 3/4 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 279.50-264.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 9 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Leg Leg Leg Diagonal Diagonal Diagonal Elevation Type Size Grade Type Size Grade T39 Solid Round 3 3/4 A572-50 Solid Round 2 A36 264.50-254.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T40 Arbitrary Shape 3.75" SR with half pipe A572-50 Solid Round 2 A36 254.50-249.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T41 Arbitrary Shape 3.75" SR with half pipe A572-50 Solid Round 2 A36 249.50-239.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T42 Arbitrary Shape 3.75" SR with half pipe A572-50 Solid Round 2 1 /4 A36 239.50-229.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T43 Arbitrary Shape 3.75" SR with half pipe A572-50 Solid Round 2 1/4 A36 229.50-219.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T44 Solid Round 4 A572-50 Solid Round 2 A36 219.50-194.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T45 Solid Round 4 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 194.50-189.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T46 Solid Round 4 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 189.50-179.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T47 Solid Round 4 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 179.50-159.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T48 Solid Round 4 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 159.50-129.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T49 Solid Round 4 A572-50 Solid Round 2 A36 129.50-124.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T50 Solid Round 4 A572-50 Solid Round 2 A36 124.50-119.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T51 Solid Round 4 A572-50 Solid Round 2 1/4 A36 119.50-114.50 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T52 114.50-99.50 Solid Round 4 A572-50 Solid Round 2 A36 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T53 99.50-79.50 Solid Round 4 1/4 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T54 79.50-69.50 Solid Round 4 1/4 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T55 69.50-59.50 Solid Round 4 1/4 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T56 59.50-39.50 Solid Round 4 1/4 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T57 39.50-29.50 Solid Round 4 1/4 A572-50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T58 29.50-19.50 Solid Round 4 1/4 A572-50 Solid Round 2 A36 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T59 19.50-11.00 Solid Round 4 1/4 A572-50 Double Angle 2L3x2xl/4x3/8 A36 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) T60 11.00-0.00 Solid Round 4 1/2 A572-50 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) Tower Section Geometry cont'd Tower Top Girt Top Girt Top Girt Bottom Girt Bottom Girt Bottom Girt Elevation Type Size Grade Type Size Grade fit T1943.19-939.50 Channel MC18x58 A36 Solid Round A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T2 939.50-909.50 Solid Round 2 A36 Solid Round A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T3 909.50-894.50 Solid Round 2 A36 Solid Round A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 10 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Elevation .t Top Girt Type Top Girt Size Top Girt Grade Bottom Girt Bottom Girt Type Size Bottom Girt Grade T4 894.50-879.50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T5 879.50-859.50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T6 859.50-849.50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T7 849.50-819.50 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 Solid Round A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T8 819.50-789.50 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 Solid Round A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T9 789.50-774.50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T10 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 774.50-759.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T11 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 759.50-729.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T12 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 729.50-699.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T13 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 Solid Round A36 699.50-679.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T14 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 Solid Round A36 679.50-669.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T15 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 669.50-664.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T16 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 664.50-659.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T17 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 659.50-639.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T18 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 639.50-629.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T19 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 629.50-609.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T20 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 609.50-579.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T21 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 Solid Round A36 579.50-549.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T22 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 Solid Round A36 549.50-519.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T23 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 519.50-499.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T24 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 499.50-489.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T25 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 489.50-474.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T26 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 474.50-459.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T27 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 459.50-449.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T28 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 449.50-429.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T29 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 Solid Round A36 429.50-409.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T30 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 409.50-399.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T31 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 399.50-379.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T32 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 379.50-369.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T33 Solid Round 2 A36 Solid Round A36 369.50-349.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T34 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 11 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Elevation ft Top Girt Type Top Girt Size Top Girt Grade Bottom Girt Bottom Girt Type Size Bottom Girt Grade 349.50-339.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T35 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 339.50-329.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 329.50-309.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T37 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 Solid Round A36 309.50-279.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T38 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 Solid Round A36 279.50-264.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T39 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 264.50-254.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T40 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 254.50-249.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T41 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 249.50-239.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T42 Solid Round 2 A36 Solid Round A36 239.50-229.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T43 Solid Round 2 A36 Solid Round A36 229.50-219.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T44 Solid Round 2 A36 Solid Round A36 219.50-194.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T45 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 194.50-189.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T46 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 189.50-179.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T47 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 Solid Round A36 179.50-159.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T48 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 Solid Round A36 159.50-129.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T49 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 129.50-124.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T50 Solid Round 2 A36 Solid Round A36 124.50-119.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T51 Solid Round 2 A36 Solid Round A36 119.50-114.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T52 114.50-99.50 Solid Round 2 A36 Solid Round A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T53 99.50-79.50 Solid Round 2 A36 Solid Round A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T54 79.50-69.50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T55 69.50-59.50 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 Solid Round A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T56 59.50-39.50 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 Solid Round A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T57 39.50-29.50 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 Solid Round A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T59 19.50-11.00 Double Angle 2L3x2xl/4x3/8 A36 Solid Round A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T60 11.00-0.00 Channel A36 Flat Bar 240/4 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) Tower Section Geometry cont'd tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 12 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower No. Mid Girt Mid Girt Mid Girt Horizontal Horizontal Horizontal Elevation of Type Size Grade Type Size Grade Mid ft Girts T1 943.19-939.50 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1/64 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T2 939.50-909.50 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 2 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T3 909.50-894.50 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T4 894.50-879.50 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T5 879.50-859.50 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T6 859.50-849.50 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T7 849.50-819.50 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T8 819.50-789.50 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T9 789.50-774.50 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T10 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 774.50-759.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) Tl l None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 759.50-729.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T12 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 729.50-699.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T13 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 699.50-679.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T14 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 679.50-669.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T15 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1/64 A36 669.50-664.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T16 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1/64 A36 664.50-659.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T17 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 659.50-639.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T18 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 639.50-629.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T19 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 629.50-609.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T20 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 609.50-579.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T21 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 579.50-549.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T22 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 549.50-519.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T23 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 519.50-499.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T24 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 499.50-489.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T25 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 489.50-474.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T26 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 474.50-459.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T27 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 459.50-449.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T28 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 449.50-429.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T29 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 429.50-409.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T30 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 409.50-399.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 13 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower No. Mid Girt Mid Girt Mid Girt Horizontal Horizontal Horizontal Elevation of Type Size Grade Type Size Grade Mid ft Girts T31 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 399.50-379.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T32 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 379.50-369.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T33 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 2 A36 369.50-349.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T34 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 349.50-339.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T35 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 339.50-329.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T36 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 329.50-309.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T37 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 309.50-279.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T38 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 279.50-264.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T39 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 264.50-254.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T40 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1/64 A36 254.50-249.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T41 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 249.50-239.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T42 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 2 A36 239.50-229.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T43 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 2 A36 229.50-219.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T44 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 219.50-194.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T45 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1/64 A36 194.50-189.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T46 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 189.50-179.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T47 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 179.50-159.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T48 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 159.50-129.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T49 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1/64 A36 129.50-124.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T50 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1/64 A36 124.50-119.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T51 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1/64 A36 119.50-114.50 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T52 114.50-99.50 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 2 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T53 99.50-79.50 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 2 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T54 79.50-69.50 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T55 69.50-59.50 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 3/4 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T56 59.50-39.50 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T57 39.50-29.50 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T58 29.50-19.50 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T59 19.50-11.00 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1/64 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) T60 11.00-0.00 None Flat Bar A36 Solid Round 1 1/2 A36 (36 ksi) (36 ksi) tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 14 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Geometry cont'd Redundant Redundant KFactor Tower Redundant Elevation Bracing Type Size Grade ft T59 A36 Horizontal (1) Double Equal Angle 2L2x2xl/4x3/8 1 19.50-11.00 (36 ksi) Diagonal (1) Double Angle 2L2x2xl/4x3/8 1 Tower Section Geometry cont'd Double Angle Double Angle Double Angle Tower Gusset Gusset Gusset Grade Adjust. Factor Adjust. Weight Mult. Elevation Area Thickness Af Factor Stitch Bolt Stitch Bolt Stitch Bolt (per face) Ar Spacing Spacing Spacing Diagonals Horizontals Redundants ft ft2 in in in in Tl 0.00 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 943.19-939.50 (36 ksi) T2 2.40 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 939.50-909.50 (36 ksi) T3 1.20 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 909.50-894.50 (36 ksi) T4 1.20 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 894.50-879.50 (36 ksi) T5 1.60 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 879.50-859.50 (36 ksi) T6 0.80 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 859.50-849.50 (36 ksi) T7 2.40 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 849.50-819.50 (36 ksi) T8 2.40 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 819.50-789.50 (36 ksi) T9 1.20 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 789.50-774.50 (36 ksi) T10 1.20 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 774.50-759.50 (36 ksi) Tll 2.40 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 759.50-729.50 (36 ksi) T12 2.40 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 729.50-699.50 (36 ksi) T13 1.60 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 699.50-679.50 (36 ksi) T14 1.60 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 679.50-669.50 (36 ksi) T15 0.40 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 669.50-664.50 (36 ksi) T16 0.40 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 664.50-659.50 (36 ksi) T17 1.60 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 659.50-639.50 (36 ksi) T18 0.40 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 639.50-629.50 (36 ksi) T19 1.60 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 629.50-609.50 (36 ksi) T20 2.40 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 609.50-579.50 (36 ksi) tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 15 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX. (781) 273-3311 Tower Elevation ft Gusset Area (per face) ft2 Gusset Thickness in Gusset Grade Adjust. Factor Af Adjust. Factor A, Weight Mult. Double Angle Double Angle Double Angle Stitch Bolt Stitch Bolt Stitch Bolt Spacing Spacing Spacing Diagonals Horizontals Redundants in in in T21 2.40 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 579.50-549.50 (36 ksi) T22 2.40 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 549.50-519.50 (36 ksi) T23 1.60 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 519.50-499.50 (36 ksi) T24 0.80 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 499.50-489.50 (36 ksi) T25 1.20 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 489.50-474.50 (36 ksi) T26 1.20 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 474.50-459.50 (36 ksi) T27 0.80 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 459.50-449.50 (36 ksi) T28 1.60 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 449.50-429.50 (36 ksi) T29 1.60 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 429.50-409.50 (36 ksi) T30 0.80 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 409.50-399.50 (36 ksi) T31 1.60 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 399.50-379.50 (36 ksi) T32 0.80 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 379.50-369.50 (36 ksi) T33 1.60 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 369.50-349.50 (36 ksi) T34 0.80 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 349.50-339.50 (36 ksi) T35 0.80 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 339.50-329.50 (36 ksi) T36 1.60 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 329.50-309.50 (36 ksi) T37 2.40 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 309.50-279.50 (36 ksi) T38 1.20 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 279.50-264.50 (36 ksi) T39 0.80 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 264.50-254.50 (36 ksi) T40 0.40 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 254.50-249.50 (36 ksi) T41 0.80 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 249.50-239.50 (36 ksi) T42 0.80 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 239.50-229.50 (36 ksi) T43 0.80 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 229.50-219.50 (36 ksi) T44 2.00 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 219.50-194.50 (36 ksi) T45 0.40 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 194.50-189.50 (36 ksi) T46 0.80 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 189.50-179.50 (36 ksi) T47 1.60 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 179.50-159.50 (36 ksi) T48 2.40 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 159.50-129.50 (36 ksi) T49 0.40 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 129.50-124.50 (36 ksi) T50 0.40 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 16 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Gusset Gusset Gusset Grade Adjust. Factor Adjust. Weight Mult. Double Angle Double Angle Double Angle Elevation Area Thickness Af Factor Stitch Bolt Stitch Bolt Stitch Bolt (per face) A, Spacing Spacing Spacing Diagonals Horizontals Redundants ft ft2 in in in in 124.50-119.50 (36 ksi) T51 0.40 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 119.50-114.50 (36 ksi) T52 1.20 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 114.50-99.50 (36 ksi) T53 1.60 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 99.50-79.50 (36 ksi) T54 0.80 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 79.50-69.50 (36 ksi) T55 0.80 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 69.50-59.50 (36 ksi) T56 0.80 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 59.50-39.50 (36 ksi) T57 0.80 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 39.50-29.50 (36 ksi) T58 0.80 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 29.50-19.50 (36 ksi) T59 1.50 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 19.50-11.00 (36 ksi) T6011.00-0.00 2.00 0.0000 A36 1 1 1.1 36.0000 36.0000 36.0000 (36 ksi) Tower Section Geometry cont'd K Factors' Tower Calc Calc Legs X K Single Girts Horiz. Sec. Inner Elevation K K Brace Brace Diags Horiz. Brace Single Solid Diags Diags Angles Rounds X X X X X X X ft Y Y Y Y Y Y Y T1 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 943.19-939.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T2 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 939.50-909.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T3 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 909.50-894.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T4 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 894.50-879.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T5 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 879.50-859.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T6 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 859.50-849.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T7 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 849.50-819.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T8 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 819.50-789.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T9 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 789.50-774.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T10 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 774.50-759.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Tll Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 759.50-729.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T12 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 729.50-699.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T13 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 17 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 K Factors' Tower Calc Calc Legs X K Single Girts Horiz. Sec. Inner Elevation K K Brace Brace Diags Horiz. Brace Single Solid Diags Diags Angles Rounds X X X X X X X ft Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 699.50-679.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T14 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 679.50-669.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T15 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 669.50-664.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T16 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 664.50-659.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T17 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 659.50-639.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T18 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 639.50-629.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T19 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 629.50-609.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T20 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 609.50-579.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T21 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 579.50-549.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T22 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 549.50-519.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T23 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 519.50-499.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T24 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 499.50-489.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T25 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 489.50-474.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T26 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 474.50-459.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T27 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 459.50-449.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T28 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 449.50-429.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T29 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 429.50-409.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T30 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 409.50-399.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T31 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 399.50-379.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T32 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 379.50-369.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T33 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 369.50-349.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T34 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 349.50-339.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T35 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 339.50-329.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T36 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 329.50-309.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T37 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 309.50-279.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T38 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 279.50-264.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T39 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 264.50-254.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T40 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 254.50-249.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T41 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 249.50-239.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T42 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 18 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 K Factors' Tower Calc Calc Legs X K Single Girts Horiz. Sec. Inner Elevation K K Brace Brace Diags Horiz. Brace Single Solid Diags Diags Angles Rounds X X X X X X X ft Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 239.50-229.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T43 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 229.50-219.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T44 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 219.50-194.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T45 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 194.50-189.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T46 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 189.50-179.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T47 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 179.50-159.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T48 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 159.50-129.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T49 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 129.50-124.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T50 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 124.50-119.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T51 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 119.50-114.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T52 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 114.50-99.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T53 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 99.50-79.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T54 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 79.50-69.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T55 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 69.50-59.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T56 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 59.50-39.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T57 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 39.50-29.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T58 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 29.50-19.50 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T59 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 19.50-11.00 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 T60 Yes Yes 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 11.00-0.00 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 'Note: K factors are applied to member segment lengths. K-braces without inner supporting members will have the K factor in the out -of -plane direction applied to the overall length Tower Section Geometry cont'd Tower Elevation ft Leg Diagonal Top Girt Bottom Girt Mid Girt Long Horizontal Short Horizontal Net Width U Net Width U Net Width U Net U Net U Net U Net U Deduct Deduct Deduct Width Width Width Width in in in Deduct Deduct Deduct Deduct in in in in T1 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 943.19-939.50 T2 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 939.50-909.50 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 19 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Elevation ft Leg Diagonal Top Girt Bottom Girt Mid Girt Long Horizontal Short Horizontal Net Width U Net Width U Net Width U Net U Net U Net U Net U Deduct Deduct Deduct Width Width Width Width in in in Deduct Deduct Deduct Deduct in in in in T3 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 909.50-894.50 T4 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 894.50-879.50 T5 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 879.50-859.50 T6 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 859.50-849.50 T7 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 849.50-819.50 T8 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 819.50-789.50 T9 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 789.50-774.50 T10 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 774.50-759.50 Tll 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 759.50-729.50 T12 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 729.50-699.50 T13 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 699.50-679.50 T14 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 679.50-669.50 T15 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 669.50-664.50 T16 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 664.50-659.50 T17 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 659.50-639.50 T18 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 639.50-629.50 T19 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 629.50-609.50 T20 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 609.50-579.50 T21 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 579.50-549.50 T22 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 549.50-519.50 T23 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 519.50-499.50 T24 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 499.50-489.50 T25 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 489.50-474.50 T26 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 474.50-459.50 T27 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 459.50-449.50 T28 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 449.50-429.50 T29 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 429.50-409.50 T30 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 409.50-399.50 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 20 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Elevation ft Leg Diagonal Top Girt Bottom Girt Mid Girt Long Horizontal Short Horizontal Net Width U Net Width U Net Width U Net U Net U Net U Net U Deduct Deduct Deduct Width Width Width Width in in in Deduct Deduct Deduct Deduct in in in in T31 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 399.50-379.50 T32 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 379.50-369.50 T33 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 369.50-349.50 T34 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 349.50-339.50 T35 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 339.50-329.50 T36 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 329.50-309.50 T37 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 309.50-279.50 T38 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 279.50-264.50 T39 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 264.50-254.50 T40 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 254.50-249.50 T41 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 249.50-239.50 T42 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 239.50-229.50 T43 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 229.50-219.50 T44 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 219.50-194.50 T45 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 194.50-189.50 T46 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 189.50-179.50 T47 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 179.50-159.50 T48 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 159.50-129.50 T49 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 129.50-124.50 T50 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 124.50-119.50 T51 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 119.50-114.50 T52 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 114.50-99.50 T53 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 99.50-79.50 T54 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 79.50-69.50 T55 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 69.50-59.50 T56 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 59.50-39.50 T57 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 39.50-29.50 T58 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 29.50-19.50 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 21 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Elevation ft Leg Diagonal Top Girt Bottom Girt Mid Girt Long Horizontal Short Horizontal Net Width U Net Width U Net Width U Net U Net U Net U Net U Deduct Deduct Deduct Width Width Width Width in in in Deduct Deduct Deduct Deduct 0.0000 0.75 in 0.0000 0.75 in 0.0000 0.75 in 0.0000 0.75 in T59 0.0000 1 0.0000 0.75 0.0000 0.75 19.50-11.00 T60 11.00-0.001 0.01 1 0.0000 0.75 1 0.0000 0.75 1 0.0000 0.75 1 0.0000 0.75 1 0.0000 0.75 1 0.0000 0.75 Guy Data Guy Guy Guy Initial % Guy Guy Lu Anchor Anchor Anchor End Elevation Grade Size Tension Modulus Weight Radius Azimuth Elevation Fitting Adj. Efficiency ft lb ksi plf ft ft o ft % 919.5 BS A 15/8 29160.00 9% 24000 5.550 1162.45 715.00 0.0000 0.00 100% B 15/8 29160.00 9% 24000 5.550 1162.45 715.00 0.0000 0.00 100% C 15/8 29160.00 9% 24000 5.550 1162.45 715.00 0.0000 0.00 100% 769.5 BS A 11/4 17760.00 9.25% 24000 3.280 1047.83 715.00 0.0000 0.00 100% B 11/4 17760.00 9.25% 24000 3.280 1047.83 715.00 0.0000 0.00 100% C 11/4 17760.00 9.25% 24000 3.280 1047.83 715.00 0.0000 0.00 100% 629.5 BS A 13/16 20640.00 12% 24000 2.960 949.40 715.00 0.0000 0.00 100% B 13/16 20640.00 12% 24000 2.960 949.40 715.00 0.0000 0.00 100% C 13/16 20640.00 12% 24000 2.960 949.40 715.00 0.0000 0.00 100% 494.5 BS A 11/4 17280.00 9% 24000 3.280 649.42 425.00 0.0000 0.00 100% B 11/4 17280.00 9% 24000 3.280 649.42 425.00 0.0000 0.00 100% C 11/4 17280.00 9% 24000 3.280 649.42 425.00 0.0000 0.00 100% 364.5 BS A 11/4 15360.00 8% 24000 3.280 557.05 425.00 0.0000 0.00 100% B 11/4 15360.00 8% 24000 3.280 557.05 425.00 0.0000 0.00 100% C 11/4 15360.00 8% 24000 3.280 557.05 425.00 0.0000 0.00 100% 239.5 BS A 11/4 20160.00 10.5% 24000 3.280 484.47 425.00 0.0000 0.00 100% B 11/4 20160.00 10.5% 24000 3.280 484.47 425.00 0.0000 0.00 100% C 11/4 20160.00 10.5% 24000 3.280 484.47 425.00 0.0000 0.00 100% 119.5 BS A 1 17080.00 14% 24000 2.100 437.67 425.00 0.0000 0.00 100% B 1 17080.00 14% 24000 2.100 437.67 425.00 0.0000 0.00 100% C 1 17080.00 14% 24000 2.100 437.67 425.00 0.0000 0.00 100% Guy Data cont'd Guy Mount Torque -Arm Torque -Arm Torque -Arm Torque -Arm Torque -Arm Torque -Arm Size Elevation Type Spread Leg Angle Style Grade Type ft 919.5 Comer 769.5 Corner 629.5 Corner 494.5 Corner 364.5 Corner 239.5 Corner 119.5 Comer tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 22 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Guy Data cont'd Guy Diagonal Diagonal Upper Diagonal Lower Diagonal Is Pull -Off Pull -Off Type Pull -Off Size Elevation Grade Type Size Size Strap. Grade ft 919.50 A572-50 Solid Round No A36 Double 2C6x8.2x0.375 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) Channel 769.50 A572-50 Solid Round No A36 Double 2C6x8.2x0.375 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) Channel 629.50 A572-50 Solid Round No A36 Double 2C6x8.2x0.375 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) Channel 494.50 A572-50 Solid Round No A36 Double 2C6x8.2x0.375 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) Channel 364.50 A572-50 Solid Round No A36 Double 2C6x8.2x0.375 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) Channel 239.50 A572-50 Solid Round No A36 Double 2C6x8.2x0.375 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) Channel 119.50 A572-50 Solid Round No A36 Double 2C6x8.2x0.375 (50 ksi) (36 ksi) Channel Guy Data cont'd Guy Elevation ft Cable Weight A lb Cable Weight B lb Cable Weight C lb Cable Weight D lb Tower Tower Intercept Intercept A B ft ft Tower Intercept C ft Tower Intercept D ft 919.5 6451.58 6451.58 6451.58 118.52 118.52 118.52 18.8 sec/pulse 18.8 sec/pulse 18.8 sec/pulse 769.5 3436.88 3436.88 3436.88 94.87 94.87 94.87 16.8 sec/pulse 16.8 sec/pulse 16.8 sec/pulse 629.5 2810.22 2810.22 2810.22 61.96 61.96 61.96 13.6 sec/pulse 13.6 sec/pulse 13.6 sec/pulse 494.5 2130.11 2130.11 2130.11 38.28 38.28 38.28 10.7 sec/pulse 10.7 sec/pulse 10.7 sec/pulse 364.5 1827.13 1827.13 1827.13 31.93 31.93 31.93 9.8 sec/pulse 9.8 sec/pulse 9.8 sec/pulse 239.5 1589.06 1589.06 1589.06 18.75 18.75 18.75 7.5 sec/pulse 7.5 sec/pulse 7.5 sec/pulse 119.5 919.11 919.11 919.11 11.71 11.71 11.71 5.9 sec/pulse 5.9 sec/pulse 5.9 sec/pulse Guy Data cont'd Torque Arm Pull Off Diagonal Guy Cale Cale K Ky K Ky K Ky Elevation K K ft Single Solid Angles Rounds 919.5 No No 1 1 1 1 769.5 No No 1 1 1 1 629.5 No No 1 1 1 1 494.5 No No 1 1 1 1 364.5 No No 1 I 1 1 239.5 No No 1 1 1 1 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 23 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Torque Arm Pull Off Diagonal Guy Calc Calc K Ky K Ky K Ky Elevation K K ft Single Solid Angles Rounds 119.5 No No 1 1 1 1 Guy Data cont'd Torque -Ann Pull Off Diagonal Guy Bolt Size Number Net Width U Bolt Size Number Net Width U Bolt Size Number Net Width U Elevation in Deduct in Deduct in Deduct t in in in 919.5 0.6250 0 0.0000 0.75 0.6250 4 1.5000 0.75 0.6250 0 0.0000 0.75 A325N A325N A325N 769.5 0.6250 0 0.0000 0.75 0.6250 4 1.5000 0.75 0.6250 0 0.0000 0.75 A325N A325N A325N 629.5 0.6250 0 0.0000 0.75 0.6250 4 1.5000 0.75 0.6250 0 0.0000 0.75 A325N A325N A325N 494.5 0.6250 0 0.0000 0.75 0.6250 4 1.5000 0.75 0.6250 0 0.0000 0.75 A325N A325N A325N 364.5 0.6250 0 0.0000 0.75 0.6250 4 1.5000 0.75 0.6250 0 0.0000 0.75 A325N A325N A325N 239.5 0.6250 0 0.0000 0.75 0.6250 4 1.5000 0.75 0.6250 0 0.0000 0.75 A325N A325N A325N 119.5 0.6250 0 0.0000 0.75 0.6250 4 1.5000 0.75 0.6250 0 0.0000 0.75 A325N A325N A325N Guy Pressures Guy Elevation ft Guy Location z ft q= q Ice he Thickness Psf i)sf in 919.5 A 459.75 96 B 459.75 96 C 459.75 96 769.5 A 384.75 92 B 384.75 92 C 384.75 92 629.5 A 314.75 89 B 314.75 89 C 314.75 89 494.5 A 247.25 84 B 247.25 84 C 247.25 84 364.5 A 182.25 79 B 182.25 79 C 182.25 79 239.5 A 119.75 72 B 119.75 72 C 119.75 72 119.5 A 59.75 62 B 59.75 62 C 59.75 62 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 24 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Feed Line/Linear Appurtenances - Entered As Round Or Flat Description Face Allow Component Placement Total Number Clear Width or Perimeter Weight or Shield Type Number Per Row Spacing Diameter Leg ft in in in plf LDF6-50A (1-1/4 B No Ar (CaAa) 706.00 - 10.00 2 2 1.5500 1.5500 0.70 FOAM) ((2) D13228) LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) A No Ar (CaAa) 651.00 - 10.00 1 1 0.6300 0.6300 0.25 (12' whip) LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) B No Ar (CaAa) 412.00 - 10.00 1 1 1.0900 1.0900 0.55 (DB264) LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) C No Ar (CaAa) 351.00 - 10.00 4 4 1.1500 1.1500 0.55 ((4) DB858HV90) LDF7-50A (1-5/8 A No Ar (CaAa) 355.00 - 10.00 2 2 2.0000 2.0000 1.05 FOAM) ((4) DB858HV90) LDF6-50A (1-1/4 A No Ar (CaAa) 321.00 - 10.00 1 1 1.5500 1.5500 0.70 FOAM) (6' grid) LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) A No Ar (CaAa) 324.00 - 10.00 1 1 1.1500 1.1500 0.55 (DB436) LDF7-50A (1-5/8 C No Ar (CaAa) 290.50 - 10.00 2 2 2.0000 2.0000 1.05 FOAM) (BCR12) LDF7-50A (1-5/8 C No Ar (CaAa) 295.50 - 290.50 1 1 2.0000 2.0000 1.05 FOAM) (BCR12) LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) C No Ar (CaAa) 295.00 - 10.00 1 1 1.1500 1.1500 0.55 (DB812) EW63 C No At (CaAa) 230.00 - 10.00 1 1 2.0100 2.0100 0.51 (6'solid dish) LDF7-50A (1-5/8 A No Ar (CaAa) 220.00 - 10.00 6 6 1.5000 2.0000 1.05 FOAM) 2.0000 (Verizon) EW63 C No Ar (CaAa) 185.00 -10.00 1 1 2.0100 2.0100 0.51 (4'solid dish) EW63 C No Ar (CaAa) 140.00 - 10.00 1 1 2.0100 2.0100 0.51 (6'solid dish) LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) C No At (CaAa) 130.00 - 10.00 9 3 2.7500 1.1500 0.55 (Sprint / Nextel) 1.5000 Feed Line/Linear Appurtenances - Entered As Area Description Face Allow Component Placement Total CAAA Weight or Shield Type Number Leg fit ft Ift plf 1" nominal conduit A No CaAa (In Face) 1016.00 - 10.00 1 No Ice 0.13 2.20 (lighting) climbing ladder B No CaAa (In Face) 943.19 - 10.00 1 No Ice 0.25 5.40 safety line 3/8 B No CaAa (In Face) 943.19 - 10.00 1 No Ice 0.04 0.22 3-1/8" rigid A No CaAa (In Face) 932.00 - 10.00 1 No Ice 0.32 2.80 (SHPX-8AC) 3-1/8" rigid A No CaAa (Out Of 972.10 - 932.00 1 No Ice 0.32 2.80 (SHPX-8AC) Face) 1-5/8" coax A No CaAa (In Face) 915.00 - 10.00 1 No Ice 0.20 1.05 (ERI LP-lE-SP) 2-1/4" coax C No CaAa (In Face) 735.00 - 10.00 1 No Ice 0.24 1.20 (2-way ASP) tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 25 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Description Face or Leg Allow Shield Component Type Placement ft Total Number CAAA ft2/ft Weight plf 2-1/4" coax A No CaAa (In Face) 675.00 - 10.00 1 No Ice 0.24 1.20 (TxRx 101-68-10-X-03N (location unknown)) 7/8" coax A No CaAa (In Face) 458.00 - 10.00 1 No Ice 0.12 0.55 (Celwave PD458) Verizon Tx line ladder A No CaAa (In Face) 220.00 - 10.00 1 No Ice 0.68 4.00 (Verizon) Feed Line/Linear Appurtenances Section Areas Tower Section Tower Elevation ft Face AR ft2 AF ft2 CAAA In Face ft2 CAAA Out Face ft2 Weight lb L1 1016.00-996.62 A 0.000 0.000 2.540 0.000 42.65 B 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.00 C 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.00 L2 996.62-977.23 A 0.000 0.000 2.540 0.000 42.65 B 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.00 C 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.00 L3 977.23-957.85 A 0.000 0.000 2.540 4.490 82.56 B 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.00 C 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.00 L4 957.85-943.19 A 0.000 0.000 1.920 4.617 73.28 B 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.00 C 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.00 T1 943.19-939.50 A 0.000 0.000 0.483 1.162 18.44 B 0.000 0.000 1.040 0.000 20.73 C 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.00 T2 939.50-909.50 A 0.000 0.000 12.118 2.362 155.78 B 0.000 0.000 8.460 0.000 168.60 C 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.00 T3 909.50-894.50 A 0.000 0.000 9.690 0.000 90.75 B 0.000 0.000 4.230 0.000 84.30 C 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.00 T4 894.50-879.50 A 0.000 0.000 9.690 0.000 90.75 B 0.000 0.000 4.230 0.000 84.30 C 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.00 T5 879.50-859.50 A 0.000 0.000 12.920 0.000 121.00 B 0.000 0.000 5.640 0.000 112.40 C 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.00 T6 859.50-849.50 A 0.000 0.000 6.460 0.000 60.50 B 0.000 0.000 2.820 0.000 56.20 C 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.00 T7 849.50-819.50 A 0.000 0.000 19.380 0.000 181.50 B 0.000 0.000 8.460 0.000 168.60 C 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.00 T8 819.50-789.50 A 0.000 0.000 19.380 0.000 181.50 B 0.000 0.000 8.460 0.000 168.60 C 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.00 T9 789.50-774.50 A 0.000 0.000 9.690 0.000 90.75 B 0.000 0.000 4.230 0.000 84.30 C 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.00 T10 774.50-759.50 A 0.000 0.000 9.690 0.000 90.75 B 0.000 0.000 4.230 0.000 84.30 C 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.00 Tll 759.50-729.50 A 0.000 0.000 19.380 0.000 181.50 B 0.000 0.000 8.460 0.000 168.60 C 0.000 0.000 1.320 0.000 6.60 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 26 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Tower Elevation ft Face AR ft, AF ftz CAAA In Face ftz CAAA Out Face ftz Weight lb T12 729.50-699.50 A 0.000 0.000 19.380 0.000 181.50 B 0.000 0.000 10.475 0.000 177.70 C 0.000 0.000 7.200 0.000 36.00 T13 699.50-679.50 A 0.000 0.000 12.920 0.000 121.00 B 0.000 0.000 11.840 0.000 140.40 C 0.000 0.000 4.800 0.000 24.00 T14 679.50-669.50 A 0.000 0.000 7.780 0.000 67.10 B 0.000 0.000 5.920 0.000 70.20 C 0.000 0.000 2.400 0.000 12.00 T15 669.50-664.50 A 0.000 0.000 4.430 0.000 36.25 B 0.000 0.000 2.960 0.000 35.10 C 0.000 0.000 1.200 0.000 6.00 T16 664.50-659.50 A 0.000 0.000 4.430 0.000 36.25 B 0.000 0.000 2.960 0.000 35.10 C 0.000 0.000 1.200 0.000 6.00 T17 659.50-639.50 A 0.000 0.000 18.445 0.000 147.88 B 0.000 0.000 11.840 0.000 140.40 C 0.000 0.000 4.800 0.000 24.00 T18 639.50-629.50 A 0.000 0.000 9.490 0.000 75.00 B 0.000 0.000 5.920 0.000 70.20 C 0.000 0.000 2.400 0.000 12.00 T19 629.50-609.50 A 0.000 0.000 18.980 0.000 150.00 B 0.000 0.000 11.840 0.000 140.40 C 0.000 0.000 4.800 0.000 24.00 T20 609.50-579.50 A 0.000 0.000 28.470 0.000 225.00 B 0.000 0.000 17.760 0.000 210.60 C 0.000 0.000 7.200 0.000 36.00 T21 579.50-549.50 A 0.000 0.000 28.470 0.000 225.00 B 0.000 0.000 17.760 0.000 210.60 C 0.000 0.000 7.200 0.000 36.00 T22 549.50-519.50 A 0.000 0.000 28.470 0.000 225.00 B 0.000 0.000 17.760 0.000 210.60 C 0.000 0.000 7.200 0.000 36.00 T23 519.50-499.50 A 0.000 0.000 18.980 0.000 150.00 B 0.000 0.000 11.840 0.000 140.40 C 0.000 0.000 4.800 0.000 24.00 T24 499.50-489.50 A 0.000 0.000 9.490 0.000 75.00 B 0.000 0.000 5.920 0.000 70.20 C 0.000 0.000 2.400 0.000 12.00 T25 489.50-474.50 A 0.000 0.000 14.235 0.000 112.50 B 0.000 0.000 8.880 0.000 105.30 C 0.000 0.000 3.600 0.000 18.00 T26 474.50-459.50 A 0.000 0.000 14.235 0.000 112.50 B 0.000 0.000 8.880 0.000 105.30 C 0.000 0.000 3.600 0.000 18.00 T27 459.50-449.50 A 0.000 0.000 10.468 0.000 79.67 B 0.000 0.000 5.920 0.000 70.20 C 0.000 0.000 2.400 0.000 12.00 T28 449.50-429.50 A 0.000 0.000 21.280 0.000 161.00 B 0.000 0.000 11.840 0.000 140.40 C 0.000 0.000 4.800 0.000 24.00 T29 429.50-409.50 A 0.000 0.000 21.280 0.000 161.00 B 0.000 0.000 12.113 0.000 141.78 C 0.000 0.000 4.800 0.000 24.00 T30 409.50-399.50 A 0.000 0.000 10.640 0.000 80.50 B 0.000 0.000 7.010 0.000 75.70 C 0.000 0.000 2.400 0.000 12.00 T31 399.50-379.50 A 0.000 0.000 21.280 0.000 161.00 B 0.000 0.000 14.020 0.000 151.40 C 0.000 0.000 4.800 0.000 24.00 T32 379.50-369.50 A 0.000 0.000 10.640 0.000 80.50 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 27 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Tower Elevation ft Face AR ft, AF ftz CAAA In Face ftz CAAA Out Face ftz Weight lb B 0.000 0.000 7.010 0.000 75.70 C 0.000 0.000 2.400 0.000 12.00 T33 369.50-349.50 A 0.000 0.000 23.348 0.000 172.55 B 0.000 0.000 14.020 0.000 151.40 C 0.000 0.000 5.490 0.000 27.30 T34 349.50-339.50 A 0.000 0.000 14.409 0.000 101.50 B 0.000 0.000 7.010 0.000 75.70 C 0.000 0.000 7.000 0.000 34.00 T35 339.50-329.50 A 0.000 0.000 14.421 0.000 101.50 B 0.000 0.000 7.010 0.000 75.70 C 0.000 0.000 7.000 0.000 34.00 T36 329.50-309.50 A 0.000 0.000 32.329 0.000 219.03 B 0.000 0.000 14.020 0.000 151.40 C 0.000 0.000 14.000 0.000 68.00 T37 309.50-279.50 A 0.000 0.000 51.516 0.000 342.00 B 0.000 0.000 21.030 0.000 227.10 C 0.000 0.000 27.971 0.000 138.88 T38 279.50-264.50 A 0.000 0.000 25.807 0.000 171.00 B 0.000 0.000 10.515 0.000 113.55 C 0.000 0.000 18.021 0.000 90.75 T39 264.50-254.50 A 0.000 0.000 17.224 0.000 114.00 B 0.000 0.000 7.010 0.000 75.70 C 0.000 0.000 12.033 0.000 60.50 T40 254.50-249.50 A 0.000 0.000 8.618 0.000 57.00 B 0.000 0.000 3.505 0.000 37.85 C 0.000 0.000 6.023 0.000 30.25 T41 249.50-239.50 A 0.000 0.000 17.248 0.000 114.00 B 0.000 0.000 7.010 0.000 75.70 C 0.000 0.000 12.058 0.000 60.50 T42 239.50-229.50 A 0.000 0.000 17.265 0.000 114.00 B 0.000 0.000 7.010 0.000 75.70 C 0.000 0.000 12.173 0.000 60.76 T43 229.50-219.50 A 0.000 0.000 18.216 0.000 119.15 B 0.000 0.000 7.010 0.000 75.70 C 0.000 0.000 14.065 0.000 65.60 T44 219.50-194.50 A 0.000 0.000 90.120 0.000 542.50 B 0.000 0.000 17.525 0.000 189.25 C 0.000 0.000 35.289 0.000 164.00 T45 194.50-189.50 A 0.000 0.000 18.070 0.000 108.50 B 0.000 0.000 3.505 0.000 37.85 C 0.000 0.000 7.077 0.000 32.80 T46 189.50-179.50 A 0.000 0.000 36.140 0.000 217.00 B 0.000 0.000 7.010 0.000 75.70 C 0.000 0.000 15.265 0.000 68.41 T47 179.50-159.50 A 0.000 0.000 72.280 0.000 434.00 B 0.000 0.000 14.020 0.000 151.40 C 0.000 0.000 32.340 0.000 141.40 T48 159.50-129.50 A 0.000 0.000 108.420 0.000 651.00 B 0.000 0.000 21.030 0.000 227.10 C 0.000 0.000 51.138 0.000 219.93 T49 129.50-124.50 A 0.000 0.000 18.070 0.000 108.50 B 0.000 0.000 3.505 0.000 37.85 C 0.000 0.000 14.265 0.000 62.65 T50 124.50-119.50 A 0.000 0.000 18.070 0.000 108.50 B 0.000 0.000 3.505 0.000 37.85 C 0.000 0.000 14.265 0.000 62.65 T51 119.50-114.50 A 0.000 0.000 18.070 0.000 108.50 B 0.000 0.000 3.505 0.000 37.85 C 0.000 0.000 14.265 0.000 62.65 T52 114.50-99.50 A 0.000 0.000 54.210 0.000 325.50 B 0.000 0.000 10.515 0.000 113.55 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 28 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Tower Elevation ft Face AR ft, AF ftz CAAA In Face ftz CAAA Out Face ftz Weight lb C 0.000 0.000 42.795 0.000 187.95 T53 99.50-79.50 A 0.000 0.000 72.280 0.000 434.00 B 0.000 0.000 14.020 0.000 151.40 C 0.000 0.000 57.060 0.000 250.60 T54 79.50-69.50 A 0.000 0.000 36.140 0.000 217.00 B 0.000 0.000 7.010 0.000 75.70 C 0.000 0.000 28.530 0.000 125.30 T55 69.50-59.50 A 0.000 0.000 36.140 0.000 217.00 B 0.000 0.000 7.010 0.000 75.70 C 0.000 0.000 28.530 0.000 125.30 T56 59.50-39.50 A 0.000 0.000 72.280 0.000 434.00 B 0.000 0.000 14.020 0.000 151.40 C 0.000 0.000 57.060 0.000 250.60 T57 39.50-29.50 A 0.000 0.000 36.140 0.000 217.00 B 0.000 0.000 7.010 0.000 75.70 C 0.000 0.000 28.530 0.000 125.30 T58 29.50-19.50 A 0.000 0.000 36.140 0.000 217.00 B 0.000 0.000 7.010 0.000 75.70 C 0.000 0.000 28.530 0.000 125.30 T59 19.50-11.00 A 0.000 0.000 30.719 0.000 184.45 B 0.000 0.000 5.959 0.000 64.34 C 0.000 0.000 24.250 0.000 106.51 T60 11.00-0.00 A 0.000 0.000 3.614 0.000 21.70 B 0.000 0.000 0.701 0.000 7.57 C 0.000 0.000 2.853 0.000 12.53 Feed Line Center of Pressure Section Elevation CPX CPz CPX CPz Ice Ice ft in in in in L1 1016.00-996.62 -0.6211 -0.3586 -0.6122 -0.3535 L2 996.62-977.23 -0.5775 -0.3334 -0.5706 -0.3294 L3 977.23-957.85 -0.4517 -3.3347 -0.4309 -3.1817 L4 957.85-943.19 -0.4698 -4.6188 -0.4524 -4.4480 T1 943.19-939.50 0.1909 -2.3179 0.1902 -2.3092 T2 939.50-909.50 -0.5834 -3.3454 -0.5294 -3.0357 T3 909.50-894.50 -1.8910 -2.7834 -1.7177 -2.5283 T4 894.50-879.50 -1.9247 -2.8330 -1.7566 -2.5855 T5 879.50-859.50 -1.9367 -2.8507 -1.7994 -2.6485 T6 859.50-849.50 -1.9514 -2.8724 -1.8124 -2.6678 T7 849.50-819.50 -1.9663 -2.8942 -1.8258 -2.6874 T8 819.50-789.50 -1.9510 -2.8718 -1.7815 -2.6222 T9 789.50-774.50 -1.9177 -2.8227 -1.7566 -2.5855 T10 774.50-759.50 -1.5756 -2.3192 -1.4700 -2.1638 Tll 759.50-729.50 -1.8639 -2.4833 -1.7057 -2.2726 T12 729.50-699.50 -1.4376 -1.4599 -1.3266 -1.3471 T13 699.50-679.50 -0.1939 -2.0294 -0.1770 -1.8529 T14 679.50-669.50 -0.7075 -2.1111 -0.6556 -1.9562 T15 669.50-664.50 -1.1988 -2.4739 -1.1033 -2.2769 T16 664.50-659.50 -1.1840 -2.4434 -1.0876 -2.2445 T17 659.50-639.50 -1.3264 -2.5101 -1.2198 -2.3084 T18 639.50-629.50 -1.4876 -2.6618 -1.3620 -2.4370 T19 629.50-609.50 -1.2903 -2.3087 -1.2064 -2.1585 T20 609.50-579.50 -1.4457 -2.5867 -1.3349 -2.3885 T21 579.50-549.50 -1.4638 -2.6192 -1.3498 -2.4152 T22 549.50-519.50 -1.4624 -2.6166 -1.3498 -2.4152 T23 519.50-499.50 -1.4418 -2.5797 -1.3349 -2.3885 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 29 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section Elevation ft CPX in CPZ in CPX Ice in CPZ Ice in T24 499.50-489.50 -1.1551 -2.0667 -1.0933 -1.9561 T25 489.50-474.50 -1.4214 -2.5433 -1.3162 -2.3550 T26 474.50-459.50 -1.4396 -2.5758 -1.3349 -2.3885 T27 459.50-449.50 -1.8043 -2.7471 -1.6765 -2.5526 T28 449.50-429.50 -1.8842 -2.8021 -1.7495 -2.6018 T29 429.50-409.50 -1.8259 -2.8333 -1.6962 -2.6321 T30 409.50-399.50 -1.3780 -2.9598 -1.2854 -2.7609 T31 399.50-379.50 -1.3692 -2.9409 -1.2629 -2.7126 T32 379.50-369.50 -1.3507 -2.9011 -1.2465 -2.6772 T33 369.50-349.50 -1.7618 -2.7054 -1.4637 -2.4448 T34 349.50-339.50 -3.1544 -1.8310 -2.3424 -1.3619 T35 339.50-329.50 -3.1943 -1.8540 -2.3688 -1.3772 T36 329.50-309.50 -3.6796 -2.1340 -2.8521 -1.6560 T37 309.50-279.50 -3.7256 -0.9562 -2.9934 -0.9133 T38 279.50-264.50 -3.4853 0.4284 -2.8532 0.0341 T39 264.50-254.50 -3.4441 0.4273 -2.8179 0.0337 T40 254.50-249.50 -3.3571 0.4190 -2.7172 0.0325 T41 249.50-239.50 -3.3604 0.4219 -2.7172 0.0325 T42 239.50-229.50 -2.9191 0.4136 -2.3704 0.0559 T43 229.50-219.50 -3.4437 1.1516 -2.8041 0.4897 T44 219.50-194.50 -7.4160 -1.8563 -6.0590 -1.7512 T45 194.50-189.50 -6.3024 -1.4816 -6.1108 -1.7662 T46 189.50-179.50 -6.3166 -1.5425 -6.0349 -1.4738 T47 179.50-159.50 -6.2867 -1.3047 -6.0080 -1.2468 T48 159.50-129.50 -6.2132 -1.0643 -5.9497 -1.0192 T49 129.50-124.50 -5.4074 1.8190 -5.2192 1.7557 T50 124.50-119.50 -5.3755 1.8083 -5.1941 1.7472 T51 119.50-114.50 -4.5146 1.5187 -4.4175 1.4860 T52 114.50-99.50 -5.3701 1.8064 -5.1941 1.7472 T53 99.50-79.50 -5.3876 1.8123 -5.1840 1.7438 T54 79.50-69.50 -5.4098 1.8198 -5.2090 1.7522 T55 69.50-59.50 -5.4032 1.8176 -5.2090 1.7522 T56 59.50-39.50 -5.5147 1.8551 -5.3157 1.7882 T57 39.50-29.50 -5.4061 1.8186 -5.2344 1.7608 T58 29.50-19.50 -5.3533 1.8008 -5.2014 1.7497 T59 19.50-11.00 -4.1384 1.3921 -4.0870 1.3748 T60 11.00-0.00 -1.3398 0.4545 -1.2884 0.4370 Shielding Factor Ka Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. K No Ice Ko Ice L1 16 1" nominal conduit 996.61 - 0.6000 0.6000 1016.00 L2 16 1" nominal conduit 977.23 - 0.6000 0.6000 996.61 L3 16 1" nominal conduit 957.84 - 0.6000 0.6000 977.23 L4 16 1" nominal conduit 943.19- 0.6000 0.6000 957.84 T1 16 1" nominal conduit 939.50 - 0.4562 0.4562 943.19 T1 17 climbing ladder 939.50 - 0.4562 0.4562 943.19 Tl 18 safety line 3/8 939.50 - 0.4562 0.4562 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 30 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. Ka No Ice Ka Ice 943.19 T2 16 1" nominal conduit 909.50- 0.6000 0.6000 939.50 T2 17 climbing ladder 909.50- 0.6000 0.6000 939.50 T2 18 safety line 3/8 909.50- 0.6000 0.6000 939.50 T2 19 3-1/8" rigid 909.50- 0.6000 0.6000 932.00 T2 21 1-5/8" coax 909.50- 0.6000 0.6000 915.00 T3 16 1" nominal conduit 894.50- 0.6000 0.6000 909.50 T3 17 climbing ladder 894.50- 0.6000 0.6000 909.50 T3 18 safety line 3/8 894.50- 0.6000 0.6000 909.50 T3 19 3-1/8" rigid 894.50- 0.6000 0.6000 909.50 T3 21 1-5/8" coax 894.50- 0.6000 0.6000 909.50 T4 16 1" nominal conduit 879.50- 0.6000 0.6000 894.50 T4 17 climbing ladder 879.50- 0.6000 0.6000 894.50 T4 18 safety line 3/8 879.50- 0.6000 0.6000 894.50 T4 19 3-1/8" rigid 879.50- 0.6000 0.6000 894.50 T4 21 1-5/8" coax 879.50- 0.6000 0.6000 894.50 T5 16 1" nominal conduit 859.50- 0.6000 0.6000 879.50 T5 17 climbing ladder 859.50- 0.6000 0.6000 879.50 T5 18 safety line 3/8 859.50- 0.6000 0.6000 879.50 T5 19 3-1/8" rigid 859.50- 0.6000 0.6000 879.50 T5 21 1-5/8" coax 859.50- 0.6000 0.6000 879.50 T6 16 1" nominal conduit 849.50- 0.6000 0.6000 859.50 T6 17 climbing ladder 849.50- 0.6000 0.6000 859.50 T6 is safety line 3/8 849.50- 0.6000 0.6000 859.50 T6 19 3-1/8" rigid 849.50- 0.6000 0.6000 859.50 T6 21 1-5/8" coax 849.50- 0.6000 0.6000 859.50 T7 16 1" nominal conduit 819.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 849.50 T7 17 climbing ladder 819.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 849.50 T7 18 safety line 3/8 819.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 849.50 T7 19 3-1/8" rigid 819.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 849.50 T7 21 1-5/8" coax 819.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 849.50 T8 16 1" nominal conduit 789.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 31 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. Ka No Ice Ka Ice 819.50 T8 17 climbing ladder 789.50- 0.6000 0.6000 819.50 T8 18 safety line 3/8 789.50- 0.6000 0.6000 819.50 T8 19 3-1/8" rigid 789.50- 0.6000 0.6000 819.50 T8 21 1-5/8" coax 789.50- 0.6000 0.6000 819.50 T9 16 1" nominal conduit 774.50- 0.6000 0.6000 789.50 T9 17 climbing ladder 774.50- 0.6000 0.6000 789.50 T9 18 safety line 3/8 774.50- 0.6000 0.6000 789.50 T9 19 3-1/8" rigid 774.50- 0.6000 0.6000 789.50 T9 21 1-5/8" coax 774.50- 0.6000 0.6000 789.50 T10 16 1" nominal conduit 759.50- 0.6000 0.6000 774.50 T10 17 climbing ladder 759.50- 0.6000 0.6000 774.50 T10 18 safety line 3/8 759.50- 0.6000 0.6000 774.50 T10 19 3-1/8" rigid 759.50- 0.6000 0.6000 774.50 T10 21 1-5/8" coax 759.50- 0.6000 0.6000 774.50 Tl l 16 1" nominal conduit 729.50- 0.6000 0.6000 759.50 Tl l 17 climbing ladder 729.50- 0.6000 0.6000 759.50 Tl 1 18 safety line 3/8 729.50- 0.6000 0.6000 759.50 Tl1 19 3-1/8" rigid 729.50- 0.6000 0.6000 759.50 Tl l 21 1-5/8" coax 729.50- 0.6000 0.6000 759.50 Tl l 22 2-1/4" coax 729.50- 0.6000 0.6000 735.00 T12 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 699.50- 0.6000 0.6000 706.00 T12 16 1" nominal conduit 699.50- 0.6000 0.6000 729.50 T12 17 climbing ladder 699.50- 0.6000 0.6000 729.50 T12 18 safety line 3/8 699.50- 0.6000 0.6000 729.50 T12 19 3-1/8" rigid 699.50- 0.6000 0.6000 729.50 T12 21 1-5/8" coax 699.50- 0.6000 0.6000 729.50 T12 22 2-1/4" coax 699.50- 0.6000 0.6000 729.50 T13 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 679.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 699.50 T13 16 1" nominal conduit 679.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 699.50 T13 17 climbing ladder 679.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 699.50 T13 18 safety line 3/8 679.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 32 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. Ka No Ice K. Ice 699.50 T13 19 3-1/8" rigid 679.50- 0.6000 0.6000 699.50 T13 21 1-5/8" coax 679.50- 0.6000 0.6000 699.50 T13 22 2-1/4" coax 679.50- 0.6000 0.6000 699.50 T14 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 669.50- 0.6000 0.6000 679.50 T14 16 1" nominal conduit 669.50- 0.6000 0.6000 679.50 T14 17 climbing ladder 669.50- 0.6000 0.6000 679.50 T14 18 safety line 3/8 669.50- 0.6000 0.6000 679.50 T14 19 3-1/8" rigid 669.50- 0.6000 0.6000 679.50 T14 21 1-5/8" coax 669.50- 0.6000 0.6000 679.50 T14 22 2-1/4" coax 669.50- 0.6000 0.6000 679.50 T14 23 2-1/4" coax 669.50- 0.6000 0.6000 675.00 T15 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 664.50- 0.6000 0.6000 669.50 T15 16 1" nominal conduit 664.50- 0.6000 0.6000 669.50 T15 17 climbing ladder 664.50- 0.6000 0.6000 669.50 T15 18 safety line 3/8 664.50- 0.6000 0.6000 669.50 T15 19 3-1/8" rigid 664.50- 0.6000 0.6000 669.50 T15 21 1-5/8" coax 664.50- 0.6000 0.6000 669.50 T15 22 2-1/4" coax 664.50- 0.6000 0.6000 669.50 T15 23 2-1/4" coax 664.50- 0.6000 0.6000 669.50 T16 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 659.50- 0.6000 0.6000 664.50 T16 16 1" nominal conduit 659.50- 0.6000 0.6000 664.50 T16 17 climbing ladder 659.50- 0.6000 0.6000 664.50 T16 18 safety line 3/8 659.50- 0.6000 0.6000 664.50 T16 19 3-1/8" rigid 659.50- 0.6000 0.6000 664.50 T16 21 1-5/8" coax 659.50- 0.6000 0.6000 664.50 T16 22 2-1/4" coax 659.50- 0.6000 0.6000 664.50 T16 23 2-1/4" coax 659.50- 0.6000 0.6000 664.50 T17 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 639.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 659.50 T17 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 639.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 651.00 T17 16 1" nominal conduit 639.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 659.50 T17 17 climbing ladder 639.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 33 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. Ka No Ice K. Ice 659.50 T17 18 safety line 3/8 639.50- 0.6000 0.6000 659.50 T17 19 3-1/8" rigid 639.50- 0.6000 0.6000 659.50 T17 21 1-5/8" coax 639.50- 0.6000 0.6000 659.50 T17 22 2-1/4" coax 639.50- 0.6000 0.6000 659.50 T17 23 2-1/4" coax 639.50- 0.6000 0.6000 659.50 T18 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 629.50- 0.6000 0.6000 639.50 T18 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 629.50- 0.6000 0.6000 639.50 T18 16 1" nominal conduit 629.50- 0.6000 0.6000 639.50 T18 17 climbing ladder 629.50- 0.6000 0.6000 639.50 T18 18 safety line 3/8 629.50- 0.6000 0.6000 639.50 T18 19 3-1/8" rigid 629.50- 0.6000 0.6000 639.50 T18 21 1-5/8" coax 629.50- 0.6000 0.6000 639.50 T18 22 2-1/4" coax 629.50- 0.6000 0.6000 639.50 T18 23 2-1/4" coax 629.50- 0.6000 0.6000 639.50 T19 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 609.50- 0.6000 0.6000 629.50 T19 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 609.50- 0.6000 0.6000 629.50 T19 16 1" nominal conduit 609.50- 0.6000 0.6000 629.50 T19 17 climbing ladder 609.50- 0.6000 0.6000 629.50 T19 18 safety line 3/8 609.50- 0.6000 0.6000 629.50 T19 19 3-1/8" rigid 609.50- 0.6000 0.6000 629.50 T19 21 1-5/8" coax 609.50- 0.6000 0.6000 629.50 T19 22 2-1/4" coax 609.50- 0.6000 0.6000 629.50 T19 23 2-1/4" coax 609.50- 0.6000 0.6000 629.50 T20 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 579.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 609.50 T20 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 579.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 609.50 T20 16 1" nominal conduit 579.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 609.50 T20 17 climbing ladder 579.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 609.50 T20 18 safety line 3/8 579.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 609.50 T20 19 3-1/8" rigid 579.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 609.50 T20 21 1-5/8" coax 579.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 609.50 T20 22 2-1/4" coax 579.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 34 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. Ka No Ice K. Ice 609.50 T20 23 2-1/4" coax 579.50- 0.6000 0.6000 609.50 T21 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 549.50- 0.6000 0.6000 579.50 T21 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 549.50- 0.6000 0.6000 579.50 T21 16 1" nominal conduit 549.50- 0.6000 0.6000 579.50 T21 17 climbing ladder 549.50- 0.6000 0.6000 579.50 T21 18 safety line 3/8 549.50- 0.6000 0.6000 579.50 T21 19 3-1/8" rigid 549.50- 0.6000 0.6000 579.50 T21 21 1-5/8" coax 549.50- 0.6000 0.6000 579.50 T21 22 2-1/4" coax 549.50- 0.6000 0.6000 579.50 T21 23 2-1/4" coax 549.50- 0.6000 0.6000 579.50 T22 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 519.50- 0.6000 0.6000 549.50 T22 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 519.50- 0.6000 0.6000 549.50 T22 16 1" nominal conduit 519.50- 0.6000 0.6000 549.50 T22 17 climbing ladder 519.50- 0.6000 0.6000 549.50 T22 18 safety line 3/8 519.50- 0.6000 0.6000 549.50 T22 19 3-1/8" rigid 519.50- 0.6000 0.6000 549.50 T22 21 1-5/8" coax 519.50- 0.6000 0.6000 549.50 T22 22 2-1/4" coax 519.50- 0.6000 0.6000 549.50 T22 23 2-1/4" coax 519.50- 0.6000 0.6000 549.50 T23 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 499.50- 0.6000 0.6000 519.50 T23 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 499.50- 0.6000 0.6000 519.50 T23 16 1" nominal conduit 499.50- 0.6000 0.6000 519.50 T23 17 climbing ladder 499.50- 0.6000 0.6000 519.50 T23 18 safety line 3/8 499.50- 0.6000 0.6000 519.50 T23 19 3-1/8" rigid 499.50- 0.6000 0.6000 519.50 T23 21 1-5/8" coax 499.50- 0.6000 0.6000 519.50 T23 22 2-1/4" coax 499.50- 0.6000 0.6000 519.50 T23 23 2-1/4" coax 499.50- 0.6000 0.6000 519.50 T24 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 489.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 499.50 T24 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 489.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 499.50 T24 16 1" nominal conduit 489.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 35 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. Ka No Ice K. Ice 499.50 T24 17 climbing ladder 489.50- 0.6000 0.6000 499.50 T24 18 safety line 3/8 489.50- 0.6000 0.6000 499.50 T24 19 3-1/8" rigid 489.50- 0.6000 0.6000 499.50 T24 21 1-5/8" coax 489.50- 0.6000 0.6000 499.50 T24 22 2-1/4" coax 489.50- 0.6000 0.6000 499.50 T24 23 2-1/4" coax 489.50- 0.6000 0.6000 499.50 T25 l LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 474.50- 0.6000 0.6000 489.50 T25 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 474.50- 0.6000 0.6000 489.50 T25 16 1" nominal conduit 474.50- 0.6000 0.6000 489.50 T25 17 climbing ladder 474.50- 0.6000 0.6000 489.50 T25 18 safety line 3/8 474.50- 0.6000 0.6000 489.50 T25 19 3-1/8" rigid 474.50- 0.6000 0.6000 489.50 T25 21 1-5/8" coax 474.50- 0.6000 0.6000 489.50 T25 22 2-1/4" coax 474.50- 0.6000 0.6000 489.50 T25 23 2-1/4" coax 474.50- 0.6000 0.6000 489.50 T26 l LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 459.50- 0.6000 0.6000 474.50 T26 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 459.50- 0.6000 0.6000 474.50 T26 16 1" nominal conduit 459.50- 0.6000 0.6000 474.50 T26 17 climbing ladder 459.50- 0.6000 0.6000 474.50 T26 18 safety line 3/8 459.50- 0.6000 0.6000 474.50 T26 19 3-1/8" rigid 459.50- 0.6000 0.6000 474.50 T26 21 1-5/8" coax 459.50- 0.6000 0.6000 474.50 T26 22 2-1/4" coax 459.50- 0.6000 0.6000 474.50 T26 23 2-1/4" coax 459.50- 0.6000 0.6000 474.50 T27 l LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 449.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 459.50 T27 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 449.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 459.50 T27 16 1" nominal conduit 449.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 459.50 T27 17 climbing ladder 449.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 459.50 T27 18 safety line 3/8 449.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 459.50 T27 19 3-1/8" rigid 449.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 459.50 T27 21 1-5/8" coax 449.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 36 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. Ka No Ice K. Ice 459.50 T27 22 2-1/4" coax 449.50- 0.6000 0.6000 459.50 T27 23 2-1/4" coax 449.50- 0.6000 0.6000 459.50 T27 24 7/8" coax 449.50- 0.6000 0.6000 458.00 T28 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 429.50- 0.6000 0.6000 449.50 T28 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 429.50- 0.6000 0.6000 449.50 T28 16 1" nominal conduit 429.50- 0.6000 0.6000 449.50 T28 17 climbing ladder 429.50- 0.6000 0.6000 449.50 T28 is safety line 3/8 429.50- 0.6000 0.6000 449.50 T28 19 3-1/8" rigid 429.50- 0.6000 0.6000 449.50 T28 21 1-5/8" coax 429.50- 0.6000 0.6000 449.50 T28 22 2-1/4" coax 429.50- 0.6000 0.6000 449.50 T28 23 2-1/4" coax 429.50- 0.6000 0.6000 449.50 T28 24 7/8" coax 429.50- 0.6000 0.6000 449.50 T29 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 409.50- 0.6000 0.6000 429.50 T29 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 409.50- 0.6000 0.6000 429.50 T29 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 409.50- 0.6000 0.6000 412.00 T29 16 1" nominal conduit 409.50- 0.6000 0.6000 429.50 T29 17 climbing ladder 409.50- 0.6000 0.6000 429.50 T29 18 safety line 3/8 409.50- 0.6000 0.6000 429.50 T29 19 3-1/8" rigid 409.50- 0.6000 0.6000 429.50 T29 21 1-5/8" coax 409.50- 0.6000 0.6000 429.50 T29 22 2-1/4" coax 409.50- 0.6000 0.6000 429.50 T29 23 2-1/4" coax 409.50- 0.6000 0.6000 429.50 T29 24 7/8" coax 409.50- 0.6000 0.6000 429.50 T30 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 399.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 409.50 T30 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 399.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 409.50 T30 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 399.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 409.50 T30 16 1" nominal conduit 399.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 409.50 T30 17 climbing ladder 399.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 409.50 T30 18 safety line 3/8 399.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 409.50 T30 19 3-1/8" rigid 399.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 37 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. Ka No Ice K. Ice 409.50 T30 21 1-5/8" coax 399.50- 0.6000 0.6000 409.50 T30 22 2-1/4" coax 399.50- 0.6000 0.6000 409.50 T30 23 2-1/4" coax 399.50- 0.6000 0.6000 409.50 T30 24 7/8" coax 399.50- 0.6000 0.6000 409.50 T31 I LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 379.50- 0.6000 0.6000 399.50 T31 2 LD174-50A (1/2 FOAM) 379.50- 0.6000 0.6000 399.50 T31 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 379.50- 0.6000 0.6000 399.50 T31 16 1" nominal conduit 379.50- 0.6000 0.6000 399.50 T31 17 climbing ladder 379.50- 0.6000 0.6000 399.50 T31 18 safety line 3/8 379.50- 0.6000 0.6000 399.50 T31 19 3-1/8" rigid 379.50- 0.6000 0.6000 399.50 T31 21 1-5/8" coax 379.50- 0.6000 0.6000 399.50 T31 22 2-1/4" coax 379.50- 0.6000 0.6000 399.50 T31 23 2-1/4" coax 379.50- 0.6000 0.6000 399.50 T31 24 7/8" coax 379.50- 0.6000 0.6000 399.50 T32 I LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 369.50- 0.6000 0.6000 379.50 T32 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 369.50- 0.6000 0.6000 379.50 T32 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 369.50- 0.6000 0.6000 379.50 T32 16 1" nominal conduit 369.50- 0.6000 0.6000 379.50 T32 17 climbing ladder 369.50- 0.6000 0.6000 379.50 T32 18 safety line 3/8 369.50- 0.6000 0.6000 379.50 T32 19 3-1/8" rigid 369.50- 0.6000 0.6000 379.50 T32 21 1-5/8" coax 369.50- 0.6000 0.6000 379.50 T32 22 2-1/4" coax 369.50- 0.6000 0.6000 379.50 T32 23 2-1/4" coax 369.50- 0.6000 0.6000 379.50 T32 24 7/8" coax 369.50- 0.6000 0.6000 379.50 T33 I LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 349.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 369.50 T33 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 349.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 369.50 T33 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 349.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 369.50 T33 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 349.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 351.00 T33 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 349.50 - 1.0000 0.6000 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 38 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. Ka No Ice K. Ice 355.00 T33 16 1" nominal conduit 349.50- 0.6000 0.6000 369.50 T33 17 climbing ladder 349.50- 0.6000 0.6000 369.50 T33 18 safety line 3/8 349.50- 0.6000 0.6000 369.50 T33 19 3-1/8" rigid 349.50- 0.6000 0.6000 369.50 T33 21 1-5/8" coax 349.50- 0.6000 0.6000 369.50 T33 22 2-1/4" coax 349.50- 0.6000 0.6000 369.50 T33 23 2-1/4" coax 349.50- 0.6000 0.6000 369.50 T33 24 7/8" coax 349.50- 0.6000 0.6000 369.50 T34 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 339.50- 0.6000 0.6000 349.50 T34 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 339.50- 0.6000 0.6000 349.50 T34 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 339.50- 0.6000 0.6000 349.50 T34 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 339.50- 0.6000 0.6000 349.50 T34 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 339.50- 1.0000 0.6000 349.50 T34 16 1" nominal conduit 339.50- 0.6000 0.6000 349.50 T34 17 climbing ladder 339.50- 0.6000 0.6000 349.50 T34 18 safety line 3/8 339.50- 0.6000 0.6000 349.50 T34 19 3-1/8" rigid 339.50- 0.6000 0.6000 349.50 T34 21 1-5/8" coax 339.50- 0.6000 0.6000 349.50 T34 22 2-1/4" coax 339.50- 0.6000 0.6000 349.50 T34 23 2-1/4" coax 339.50- 0.6000 0.6000 349.50 T34 24 7/8" coax 339.50- 0.6000 0.6000 349.50 T35 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 329.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 339.50 T35 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 329.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 339.50 T35 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 329.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 339.50 T35 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 329.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 339.50 T35 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 329.50 - 1.0000 0.6000 339.50 T35 16 1" nominal conduit 329.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 339.50 T35 17 climbing ladder 329.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 339.50 T35 18 safety line 3/8 329.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 339.50 T35 19 3-1/8" rigid 329.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 339.50 T35 21 1-5/8" coax 329.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 39 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. Ka No Ice K. Ice 339.50 T35 22 2-1/4" coax 329.50- 0.6000 0.6000 339.50 T35 23 2-1/4" coax 329.50- 0.6000 0.6000 339.50 T35 24 7/8" coax 329.50- 0.6000 0.6000 339.50 T36 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 309.50- 0.6000 0.6000 329.50 T36 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 309.50- 0.6000 0.6000 329.50 T36 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 309.50- 0.6000 0.6000 329.50 T36 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 309.50- 0.6000 0.6000 329.50 T36 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 309.50- 1.0000 0.6000 329.50 T36 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 309.50- 0.6000 0.6000 321.00 T36 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 309.50- 0.6000 0.6000 324.00 T36 16 1" nominal conduit 309.50- 0.6000 0.6000 329.50 T36 17 climbing ladder 309.50- 0.6000 0.6000 329.50 T36 18 safety line 3/8 309.50- 0.6000 0.6000 329.50 T36 19 3-1/8" rigid 309.50- 0.6000 0.6000 329.50 T36 21 1-5/8" coax 309.50- 0.6000 0.6000 329.50 T36 22 2-1/4" coax 309.50- 0.6000 0.6000 329.50 T36 23 2-1/4" coax 309.50- 0.6000 0.6000 329.50 T36 24 7/8" coax 309.50- 0.6000 0.6000 329.50 T37 l LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 279.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 309.50 T37 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 279.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 309.50 T37 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 279.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 309.50 T37 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 279.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 309.50 T37 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 279.50 - 1.0000 0.6000 309.50 T37 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 279.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 309.50 T37 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 279.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 309.50 T37 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 279.50 - 1.0000 0.6000 290.50 T37 9 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 290.50 - 1.0000 0.6000 295.50 T37 10 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 279.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 295.00 T37 16 1" nominal conduit 279.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 309.50 T37 17 climbing ladder 279.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 309.50 T37 l8 safety line 3/8 279.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 40 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. Ka No Ice K. Ice 309.50 T37 19 3-1/8" rigid 279.50- 0.6000 0.6000 309.50 T37 21 1-5/8" coax 279.50- 0.6000 0.6000 309.50 T37 22 2-1/4" coax 279.50- 0.6000 0.6000 309.50 T37 23 2-1/4" coax 279.50- 0.6000 0.6000 309.50 T37 24 7/8" coax 279.50- 0.6000 0.6000 309.50 T38 I LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 264.50- 0.6000 0.6000 279.50 T38 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 264.50- 0.6000 0.6000 279.50 T38 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 264.50- 0.6000 0.6000 279.50 T38 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 264.50- 0.6000 0.6000 279.50 T38 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 264.50- 1.0000 0.6000 279.50 T38 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 264.50- 0.6000 0.6000 279.50 T38 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 264.50- 0.6000 0.6000 279.50 T38 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 264.50- 1.0000 0.6000 279.50 T38 10 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 264.50- 0.6000 0.6000 279.50 T38 16 1" nominal conduit 264.50- 0.6000 0.6000 279.50 T38 17 climbing ladder 264.50- 0.6000 0.6000 279.50 T38 18 safety line 3/8 264.50- 0.6000 0.6000 279.50 T38 19 3-1/8" rigid 264.50- 0.6000 0.6000 279.50 T38 21 1-5/8" coax 264.50- 0.6000 0.6000 279.50 T38 22 2-1/4" coax 264.50- 0.6000 0.6000 279.50 T38 23 2-1/4" coax 264.50- 0.6000 0.6000 279.50 T38 24 7/8" coax 264.50- 0.6000 0.6000 279.50 T39 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 254.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 264.50 T39 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 254.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 264.50 T39 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 254.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 264.50 T39 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 254.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 264.50 T39 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 254.50 - 1.0000 0.6000 264.50 T39 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 254.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 264.50 T39 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 254.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 264.50 T39 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 254.50 - 1.0000 0.6000 264.50 T39 10 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 254.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 41 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. Ka No Ice K. Ice 264.50 T39 16 1" nominal conduit 254.50- 0.6000 0.6000 264.50 T39 17 climbing ladder 254.50- 0.6000 0.6000 264.50 T39 18 safety line 3/8 254.50- 0.6000 0.6000 264.50 T39 19 3-1/8" rigid 254.50- 0.6000 0.6000 264.50 T39 21 1-5/8" coax 254.50- 0.6000 0.6000 264.50 T39 22 2-1/4" coax 254.50- 0.6000 0.6000 264.50 T39 23 2-1/4" coax 254.50- 0.6000 0.6000 264.50 T39 24 7/8" coax 254.50- 0.6000 0.6000 264.50 T40 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 249.50- 0.6000 0.6000 254.50 T40 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 249.50- 0.6000 0.6000 254.50 T40 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 249.50- 0.6000 0.6000 254.50 T40 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 249.50- 0.6000 0.6000 254.50 T40 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 249.50- 1.0000 0.6000 254.50 T40 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 249.50- 0.6000 0.6000 254.50 T40 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 249.50- 0.6000 0.6000 254.50 T40 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 249.50- 1.0000 0.6000 254.50 T40 10 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 249.50- 0.6000 0.6000 254.50 T40 16 1" nominal conduit 249.50- 0.6000 0.6000 254.50 T40 17 climbing ladder 249.50- 0.6000 0.6000 254.50 T40 18 safety line 3/8 249.50- 0.6000 0.6000 254.50 T40 19 3-1/8" rigid 249.50- 0.6000 0.6000 254.50 T40 21 1-5/8" coax 249.50- 0.6000 0.6000 254.50 T40 22 2-1/4" coax 249.50- 0.6000 0.6000 254.50 T40 23 2-1/4" coax 249.50- 0.6000 0.6000 254.50 T40 24 7/8" coax 249.50- 0.6000 0.6000 254.50 T41 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 239.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 249.50 T41 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 239.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 249.50 T41 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 239.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 249.50 T41 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 239.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 249.50 T41 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 239.50 - 1.0000 0.6000 249.50 T41 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 239.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 42 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. Ka No Ice K. Ice 249.50 T41 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 239.50- 0.6000 0.6000 249.50 T41 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 239.50- 1.0000 0.6000 249.50 T41 10 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 239.50- 0.6000 0.6000 249.50 T41 16 1" nominal conduit 239.50- 0.6000 0.6000 249.50 T41 17 climbing ladder 239.50- 0.6000 0.6000 249.50 T41 18 safety line 3/8 239.50- 0.6000 0.6000 249.50 T41 19 3-1/8" rigid 239.50- 0.6000 0.6000 249.50 T41 21 1-5/8" coax 239.50- 0.6000 0.6000 249.50 T41 22 2-1/4" coax 239.50- 0.6000 0.6000 249.50 T41 23 2-1/4" coax 239.50- 0.6000 0.6000 249.50 T41 24 7/8" coax 239.50- 0.6000 0.6000 249.50 T42 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 229.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 239.50 T42 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 229.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 239.50 T42 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 229.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 239.50 T42 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 229.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 239.50 T42 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 229.50 - 1.0000 0.6000 239.50 T42 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 229.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 239.50 T42 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 229.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 239.50 T42 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 229.50 - 1.0000 0.6000 239.50 T42 10 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 229.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 239.50 T42 11 EW63 229.50 - 1.0000 0.6000 230.00 T42 16 1" nominal conduit 229.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 239.50 T42 17 climbing ladder 229.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 239.50 T42 18 safety line 3/8 229.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 239.50 T42 19 3-1/8" rigid 229.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 239.50 T42 21 1-5/8" coax 229.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 239.50 T42 22 2-1/4" coax 229.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 239.50 T42 23 2-1/4" coax 229.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 239.50 T42 24 7/8" coax 229.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 239.50 T43 I LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 219.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 229.50 T43 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 219.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 43 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. Ka No Ice K. Ice 229.50 T43 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 219.50- 0.6000 0.6000 229.50 T43 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 219.50- 0.6000 0.6000 229.50 T43 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 219.50- 1.0000 0.6000 229.50 T43 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 219.50- 0.6000 0.6000 229.50 T43 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 219.50- 0.6000 0.6000 229.50 T43 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 219.50- 1.0000 0.6000 229.50 T43 10 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 219.50- 0.6000 0.6000 229.50 T43 1 I EW63 219.50- 1.0000 0.6000 229.50 T43 12 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 219.50- 1.0000 0.6000 220.00 T43 16 1" nominal conduit 219.50- 0.6000 0.6000 229.50 T43 17 climbing ladder 219.50- 0.6000 0.6000 229.50 T43 18 safety line 3/8 219.50- 0.6000 0.6000 229.50 T43 19 3-1/8" rigid 219.50- 0.6000 0.6000 229.50 T43 21 1-5/8" coax 219.50- 0.6000 0.6000 229.50 T43 22 2-1/4" coax 219.50- 0.6000 0.6000 229.50 T43 23 2-1/4" coax 219.50- 0.6000 0.6000 229.50 T43 24 7/8" coax 219.50- 0.6000 0.6000 229.50 T43 25 Verizon Tx line ladder 219.50- 0.6000 0.6000 220.00 T44 I LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 194.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 219.50 T44 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 194.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 219.50 T44 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 194.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 219.50 T44 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 194.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 219.50 T44 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 194.50 - 1.0000 0.6000 219.50 T44 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 194.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 219.50 T44 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 194.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 219.50 T44 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 194.50 - 1.0000 0.6000 219.50 T44 10 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 194.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 219.50 T44 1 I EW63 194.50 - 1.0000 0.6000 219.50 T44 12 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 194.50 - 1.0000 0.6000 219.50 T44 16 1" nominal conduit 194.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 219.50 T44 17 climbing ladder 194.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 44 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. Ka No Ice K. Ice 219.50 T44 18 safety line 3/8 194.50- 0.6000 0.6000 219.50 T44 19 3-1/8" rigid 194.50- 0.6000 0.6000 219.50 T44 21 1-5/8" coax 194.50- 0.6000 0.6000 219.50 T44 22 2-1/4" coax 194.50- 0.6000 0.6000 219.50 T44 23 2-1/4" coax 194.50- 0.6000 0.6000 219.50 T44 24 7/8" coax 194.50- 0.6000 0.6000 219.50 T44 25 Verizon Tx line ladder 194.50- 0.6000 0.6000 219.50 T45 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 189.50- 0.6000 0.6000 194.50 T45 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 189.50- 0.6000 0.6000 194.50 T45 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 189.50- 0.6000 0.6000 194.50 T45 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 189.50- 0.6000 0.6000 194.50 T45 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 189.50- 0.6000 0.6000 194.50 T45 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 189.50- 0.6000 0.6000 194.50 T45 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 189.50- 0.6000 0.6000 194.50 T45 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 189.50- 0.6000 0.6000 194.50 T45 10 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 189.50- 0.6000 0.6000 194.50 T45 1 I EW63 189.50- 1.0000 0.6000 194.50 T45 12 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 189.50- 0.6000 0.6000 194.50 T45 16 1" nominal conduit 189.50- 0.6000 0.6000 194.50 T45 17 climbing ladder 189.50- 0.6000 0.6000 194.50 T45 18 safety line 3/8 189.50- 0.6000 0.6000 194.50 T45 19 3-1/8" rigid 189.50- 0.6000 0.6000 194.50 T45 21 1-5/8" coax 189.50- 0.6000 0.6000 194.50 T45 22 2-1/4" coax 189.50- 0.6000 0.6000 194.50 T45 23 2-1/4" coax 189.50- 0.6000 0.6000 194.50 T45 24 7/8" coax 189.50- 0.6000 0.6000 194.50 T45 25 Verizon Tx line ladder 189.50- 0.6000 0.6000 194.50 T46 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 179.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 189.50 T46 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 179.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 189.50 T46 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 179.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 189.50 T46 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 179.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 45 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. Ka No Ice K. Ice 189.50 T46 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 79.50- 0.6000 0.6000 189.50 :79.50 T46 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) - 0.6000 0.6000 189.50 T46 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 179.50- 0.6000 0.6000 189.50 T46 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 179.50- 0.6000 0.6000 189.50 T46 10 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 179.50- 0.6000 0.6000 189.50 T46 I I EW63 179.50- 0.6000 0.6000 189.50 T46 12 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 179.50- 0.6000 0.6000 189.50 T46 13 EW63 179.50- 0.6000 0.6000 185.00 T46 16 1" nominal conduit 179.50- 0.6000 0.6000 189.50 T46 17 climbing ladder 179.50- 0.6000 0.6000 189.50 T46 18 safety line 3/8 179.50- 0.6000 0.6000 189.50 T46 19 3-1/8" rigid 179.50- 0.6000 0.6000 189.50 T46 21 1-5/8" coax 179.50- 0.6000 0.6000 189.50 T46 22 2-1/4" coax 179.50- 0.6000 0.6000 189.50 T46 23 2-1/4" coax 179.50- 0.6000 0.6000 189.50 T46 24 7/8" coax 179.50- 0.6000 0.6000 189.50 T46 25 Verizon Tx line ladder 179.50- 0.6000 0.6000 189.50 T47 I LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 159.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 179.50 T47 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 159.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 179.50 T47 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 159.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 179.50 T47 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 159.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 179.50 T47 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 159.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 179.50 T47 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 159.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 179.50 T47 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 159.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 179.50 T47 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 159.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 179.50 T47 10 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 159.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 179.50 T47 I I EW63 159.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 179.50 T47 12 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 159.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 179.50 T47 13 EW63 159.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 179.50 T47 16 1" nominal conduit 159.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 179.50 T47 17 climbing ladder 159.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 46 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. Ka No Ice K. Ice 179.50 T47 18 safety line 3/8 159.50- 0.6000 0.6000 179.50 T47 19 3-1/8" rigid 159.50- 0.6000 0.6000 179.50 T47 21 1-5/8" coax 159.50- 0.6000 0.6000 179.50 T47 22 2-1/4" coax 159.50- 0.6000 0.6000 179.50 T47 23 2-1/4" coax 159.50- 0.6000 0.6000 179.50 T47 24 7/8" coax 159.50- 0.6000 0.6000 179.50 T47 25 Verizon Tx line ladder 159.50- 0.6000 0.6000 179.50 T48 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 129.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 159.50 T48 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 129.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 159.50 T48 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 129.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 159.50 T48 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 129.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 159.50 T48 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 129.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 159.50 T48 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 129.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 159.50 T48 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 129.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 159.50 T48 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 129.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 159.50 T48 10 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 129.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 159.50 T48 1 I EW63 129.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 159.50 T48 12 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 129.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 159.50 T48 13 EW63 129.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 159.50 T48 14 EW63 129.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 140.00 T48 15 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 129.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 130.00 T48 16 1" nominal conduit 129.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 159.50 T48 17 climbing ladder 129.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 159.50 T48 18 safety line 3/8 129.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 159.50 T48 19 3-1/8" rigid 129.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 159.50 T48 21 1-5/8" coax 129.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 159.50 T48 22 2-1/4" coax 129.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 159.50 T48 23 2-1/4" coax 129.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 159.50 T48 24 7/8" coax 129.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 159.50 T48 25 Verizon Tx line ladder 129.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 159.50 T49 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 124.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 47 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. Ka No Ice K. Ice 129.50 T49 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 124.50- 0.6000 0.6000 129.50 T49 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 124.50- 0.6000 0.6000 129.50 T49 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 124.50- 0.6000 0.6000 129.50 T49 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 124.50- 0.6000 0.6000 129.50 T49 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 124.50- 0.6000 0.6000 129.50 T49 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 124.50- 0.6000 0.6000 129.50 T49 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 124.50- 0.6000 0.6000 129.50 T49 10 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 124.50- 0.6000 0.6000 129.50 T49 1 1 EW63 124.50- 0.6000 0.6000 129.50 T49 12 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 124.50- 0.6000 0.6000 129.50 T49 13 EW63 124.50- 0.6000 0.6000 129.50 T49 14 EW63 124.50- 0.6000 0.6000 129.50 T49 15 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 124.50- 0.6000 0.6000 129.50 T49 16 1" nominal conduit 124.50- 0.6000 0.6000 129.50 T49 17 climbing ladder 124.50- 0.6000 0.6000 129.50 T49 18 safety line 3/8 124.50- 0.6000 0.6000 129.50 T49 19 3-1/8" rigid 124.50- 0.6000 0.6000 129.50 T49 21 1-5/8" coax 124.50- 0.6000 0.6000 129.50 T49 22 2-1/4" coax 124.50- 0.6000 0.6000 129.50 T49 23 2-1/4" coax 124.50- 0.6000 0.6000 129.50 T49 24 7/8" coax 124.50- 0.6000 0.6000 129.50 T49 25 Verizon Tx line ladder 124.50- 0.6000 0.6000 129.50 T50 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 119.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 124.50 T50 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 119.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 124.50 T50 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 119.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 124.50 T50 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 119.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 124.50 T50 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 119.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 124.50 T50 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 119.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 124.50 T50 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 119.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 124.50 T50 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 119.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 124.50 T50 10 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 119.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 48 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. Ka No Ice K. Ice 124.50 T50 11 EW63 119.50- 0.6000 0.6000 124.50 T50 12 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 119.50- 0.6000 0.6000 124.50 T50 13 EW63 119.50- 0.6000 0.6000 124.50 T50 14 EW63 119.50- 0.6000 0.6000 124.50 T50 15 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 119.50- 0.6000 0.6000 124.50 T50 16 1" nominal conduit 119.50- 0.6000 0.6000 124.50 T50 17 climbing ladder 119.50- 0.6000 0.6000 124.50 T50 18 safety line 3/8 119.50- 0.6000 0.6000 124.50 T50 19 3-1/8" rigid 119.50- 0.6000 0.6000 124.50 T50 21 1-5/8" coax 119.50- 0.6000 0.6000 124.50 T50 22 2-1/4" coax 119.50- 0.6000 0.6000 124.50 T50 23 2-1/4" coax 119.50- 0.6000 0.6000 124.50 T50 24 7/8" coax 119.50- 0.6000 0.6000 124.50 T50 25 Verizon Tx line ladder 119.50- 0.6000 0.6000 124.50 T51 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 114.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 119.50 T51 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 114.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 119.50 T51 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 114.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 119.50 T51 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 114.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 119.50 T51 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 114.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 119.50 T51 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 114.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 119.50 T51 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 114.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 119.50 T51 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 114.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 119.50 T51 10 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 114.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 119.50 T51 I I EW63 114.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 119.50 T51 12 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 114.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 119.50 T51 13 EW63 114.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 119.50 T51 14 EW63 114.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 119.50 T51 15 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 114.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 119.50 T51 16 1" nominal conduit 114.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 119.50 T51 17 climbing ladder 114.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 119.50 T51 18 safety line 3/8 114.50 - 0.6000 0.6000 tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 49 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. Ka No Ice K. Ice 119.50 T51 19 3-1/8" rigid 114.50- 0.6000 0.6000 119.50 T51 21 1-5/8" coax 114.50- 0.6000 0.6000 119.50 T51 22 2-1/4" coax 114.50- 0.6000 0.6000 119.50 T51 23 2-1/4" coax 114.50- 0.6000 0.6000 119.50 T51 24 7/8" coax 114.50- 0.6000 0.6000 119.50 T51 25 Verizon Tx line ladder 114.50- 0.6000 0.6000 119.50 T52 l LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 99.50 - 114.50 0.6000 0.6000 T52 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 99.50 - 114.50 0.6000 0.6000 T52 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 99.50 - 114.50 0.6000 0.6000 T52 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 99.50 - 114.50 0.6000 0.6000 T52 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 99.50 - 114.50 0.6000 0.6000 T52 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 99.50 - 114.50 0.6000 0.6000 T52 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 99.50 - 114.50 0.6000 0.6000 T52 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 99.50 - 114.50 0.6000 0.6000 T52 10 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 99.50 - 114.50 0.6000 0.6000 T52 11 EW63 99.50 - 114.50 0.6000 0.6000 T52 12 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 99.50 - 114.50 0.6000 0.6000 T52 13 EW63 99.50 - 114.50 0.6000 0.6000 T52 14 EW63 99.50 - 114.50 0.6000 0.6000 T52 15 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 99.50 - 114.50 0.6000 0.6000 T52 16 1" nominal conduit 99.50 - 114.50 0.6000 0.6000 T52 17 climbing ladder 99.50 - 114.50 0.6000 0.6000 T52 18 safety line 3/8 99.50 - 114.50 0.6000 0.6000 T52 19 3-1/8" rigid 99.50 - 114.50 0.6000 0.6000 T52 21 1-5/8" coax 99.50 - 114.50 0.6000 0.6000 T52 22 2-1/4" coax 99.50 - 114.50 0.6000 0.6000 T52 23 2-1/4" coax 99.50 - 114.50 0.6000 0.6000 T52 24 7/8" coax 99.50 - 114.50 0.6000 0.6000 T52 25 Verizon Tx line ladder 99.50 - 114.50 0.6000 0.6000 T53 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 79.50 - 99.50 0.6000 0.6000 T53 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 79.50 - 99.50 0.6000 0.6000 T53 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 79.50 - 99.50 0.6000 0.6000 T53 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 79.50 - 99.50 0.6000 0.6000 T53 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 79.50 - 99.50 0.6000 0.6000 T53 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 79.50 - 99.50 0.6000 0.6000 T53 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 79.50 - 99.50 0.6000 0.6000 T53 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 79.50 - 99.50 0.6000 0.6000 T53 10 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 79.50 - 99.50 0.6000 0.6000 T53 11 EW63 79.50 - 99.50 0.6000 0.6000 T53 12 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 79.50 - 99.50 0.6000 0.6000 T53 13 EW63 79.50 - 99.50 0.6000 0.6000 T53 14 EW63 79.50 - 99.50 0.6000 0.6000 T53 15 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 79.50 - 99.50 0.6000 0.6000 T53 16 1" nominal conduit 79.50 - 99.50 0.6000 0.6000 T53 17 climbing ladder 79.50 - 99.50 0.6000 0.6000 T53 18 safety line 3/8 79.50 - 99.50 0.6000 0.6000 T53 19 3-1/8" rigid 79.50 - 99.50 0.6000 0.6000 T53 21 1-5/8" coax 79.50 - 99.50 0.6000 0.6000 T53 22 2-1/4" coax 79.50 - 99.50 0.6000 0.6000 T53 23 2-1/4" coax 79.50 - 99.50 0.6000 0.6000 T53 24 7/8" coax 79.50 - 99.50 0.6000 0.6000 T53 25 Verizon Tx line ladder 79.50 - 99.50 0.6000 0.6000 T54 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 69.50 - 79.50 0.6000 0.6000 T54 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 69.50 - 79.50 0.6000 0.6000 T54 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 69.50 - 79.50 0.6000 0.6000 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 50 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. Ka No Ice K. Ice T54 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 69.50 - 79.50 0.6000 0.6000 T54 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 69.50 - 79.50 0.6000 0.6000 T54 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 69.50 - 79.50 0.6000 0.6000 T54 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 69.50 - 79.50 0.6000 0.6000 T54 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 69.50 - 79.50 0.6000 0.6000 T54 10 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 69.50 - 79.50 0.6000 0.6000 T54 11 EW63 69.50 - 79.50 0.6000 0.6000 T54 12 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 69.50 - 79.50 0.6000 0.6000 T54 13 EW63 69.50 - 79.50 0.6000 0.6000 T54 14 EW63 69.50 - 79.50 0.6000 0.6000 T54 15 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 69.50 - 79.50 0.6000 0.6000 T54 16 1" nominal conduit 69.50 - 79.50 0.6000 0.6000 T54 17 climbing ladder 69.50 - 79.50 0.6000 0.6000 T54 18 safety line 3/8 69.50 - 79.50 0.6000 0.6000 T54 19 3-1/8" rigid 69.50 - 79.50 0.6000 0.6000 T54 21 1-5/8" coax 69.50 - 79.50 0.6000 0.6000 T54 22 2-1/4" coax 69.50 - 79.50 0.6000 0.6000 T54 23 2-1/4" coax 69.50 - 79.50 0.6000 0.6000 T54 24 7/8" coax 69.50 - 79.50 0.6000 0.6000 T54 25 Verizon Tx line ladder 69.50 - 79.50 0.6000 0.6000 T55 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 59.50 - 69.50 0.6000 0.6000 T55 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 59.50 - 69.50 0.6000 0.6000 T55 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 59.50 - 69.50 0.6000 0.6000 T55 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 59.50 - 69.50 0.6000 0.6000 T55 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 59.50 - 69.50 0.6000 0.6000 T55 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 59.50 - 69.50 0.6000 0.6000 T55 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 59.50 - 69.50 0.6000 0.6000 T55 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 59.50 - 69.50 0.6000 0.6000 T55 10 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 59.50 - 69.50 0.6000 0.6000 T55 11 EW63 59.50 - 69.50 0.6000 0.6000 T55 12 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 59.50 - 69.50 0.6000 0.6000 T55 13 EW63 59.50 - 69.50 0.6000 0.6000 T55 14 EW63 59.50 - 69.50 0.6000 0.6000 T55 15 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 59.50 - 69.50 0.6000 0.6000 T55 16 1" nominal conduit 59.50 - 69.50 0.6000 0.6000 T55 17 climbing ladder 59.50 - 69.50 0.6000 0.6000 T55 18 safety line 3/8 59.50 - 69.50 0.6000 0.6000 T55 19 3-1/8" rigid 59.50 - 69.50 0.6000 0.6000 T55 21 1-5/8" coax 59.50 - 69.50 0.6000 0.6000 T55 22 2-1/4" coax 59.50 - 69.50 0.6000 0.6000 T55 23 2-1/4" coax 59.50 - 69.50 0.6000 0.6000 T55 24 7/8" coax 59.50 - 69.50 0.6000 0.6000 T55 25 Verizon Tx line ladder 59.50 - 69.50 0.6000 0.6000 T56 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 39.50 - 59.50 0.6000 0.6000 T56 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 39.50 - 59.50 0.6000 0.6000 T56 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 39.50 - 59.50 0.6000 0.6000 T56 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 39.50 - 59.50 0.6000 0.6000 T56 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 39.50 - 59.50 0.6000 0.6000 T56 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 39.50 - 59.50 0.6000 0.6000 T56 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 39.50 - 59.50 0.6000 0.6000 T56 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 39.50 - 59.50 0.6000 0.6000 T56 10 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 39.50 - 59.50 0.6000 0.6000 T56 11 EW63 39.50 - 59.50 0.6000 0.6000 T56 12 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 39.50 - 59.50 0.6000 0.6000 T56 13 EW63 39.50 - 59.50 0.6000 0.6000 T56 14 EW63 39.50 - 59.50 0.6000 0.6000 T56 15 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 39.50 - 59.50 0.6000 0.6000 T56 16 1" nominal conduit 39.50 - 59.50 0.6000 0.6000 T56 17 climbing ladder 39.50 - 59.50 0.6000 0.6000 T56 18 safety line 3/8 39.50 - 59.50 0.6000 0.6000 T56 19 3-1/8" rigid 39.50 - 59.50 0.6000 0.6000 T56 21 1-5/8" coax 39.50 - 59.50 0.6000 0.6000 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 51 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. Ka No Ice Ka Ice T56 22 2-1/4" coax 39.50 - 59.50 0.6000 0.6000 T56 23 2-1/4" coax 39.50 - 59.50 0.6000 0.6000 T56 24 7/8" coax 39.50 - 59.50 0.6000 0.6000 T56 25 Verizon Tx line ladder 39.50 - 59.50 0.6000 0.6000 T57 I LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 29.50 - 39.50 0.6000 0.6000 T57 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 29.50 - 39.50 0.6000 0.6000 T57 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 29.50 - 39.50 0.6000 0.6000 T57 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 29.50 - 39.50 0.6000 0.6000 T57 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 29.50 - 39.50 0.6000 0.6000 T57 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 29.50 - 39.50 0.6000 0.6000 T57 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 29.50 - 39.50 0.6000 0.6000 T57 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 29.50 - 39.50 0.6000 0.6000 T57 10 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 29.50 - 39.50 0.6000 0.6000 T57 11 EW63 29.50 - 39.50 0.6000 0.6000 T57 12 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 29.50 - 39.50 0.6000 0.6000 T57 13 EW63 29.50 - 39.50 0.6000 0.6000 T57 14 EW63 29.50 - 39.50 0.6000 0.6000 T57 15 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 29.50 - 39.50 0.6000 0.6000 T57 16 1" nominal conduit 29.50 - 39.50 0.6000 0.6000 T57 17 climbing ladder 29.50 - 39.50 0.6000 0.6000 T57 18 safety line 3/8 29.50 - 39.50 0.6000 0.6000 T57 19 3-1/8" rigid 29.50 - 39.50 0.6000 0.6000 T57 21 1-5/8" coax 29.50 - 39.50 0.6000 0.6000 T57 22 2-1/4" coax 29.50 - 39.50 0.6000 0.6000 T57 23 2-1/4" coax 29.50 - 39.50 0.6000 0.6000 T57 24 7/8" coax 29.50 - 39.50 0.6000 0.6000 T57 25 Verizon Tx line ladder 29.50 - 39.50 0.6000 0.6000 T58 I LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 19.50 - 29.50 0.6000 0.6000 T58 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 19.50 - 29.50 0.6000 0.6000 T58 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 19.50 - 29.50 0.6000 0.6000 T58 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 19.50 - 29.50 0.6000 0.6000 T58 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 19.50 - 29.50 0.6000 0.6000 T58 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 19.50 - 29.50 0.6000 0.6000 T58 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 19.50 - 29.50 0.6000 0.6000 T58 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 19.50 - 29.50 0.6000 0.6000 T58 10 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 19.50 - 29.50 0.6000 0.6000 T58 11 EW63 19.50 - 29.50 0.6000 0.6000 T58 12 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 19.50 - 29.50 0.6000 0.6000 T58 13 EW63 19.50 - 29.50 0.6000 0.6000 T58 14 EW63 19.50 - 29.50 0.6000 0.6000 T58 15 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 19.50 - 29.50 0.6000 0.6000 T58 16 1" nominal conduit 19.50 - 29.50 0.6000 0.6000 T58 17 climbing ladder 19.50 - 29.50 0.6000 0.6000 T58 18 safety line 3/8 19.50 - 29.50 0.6000 0.6000 T58 19 3-1/8" rigid 19.50 - 29.50 0.6000 0.6000 T58 21 1-5/8" coax 19.50 - 29.50 0.6000 0.6000 T58 22 2-1/4" coax 19.50 - 29.50 0.6000 0.6000 T58 23 2-1/4" coax 19.50 - 29.50 0.6000 0.6000 T58 24 7/8" coax 19.50 - 29.50 0.6000 0.6000 T58 25 Verizon Tx line ladder 19.50 - 29.50 0.6000 0.6000 T59 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 11.00 - 19.50 0.6000 0.6000 T59 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 11.00 - 19.50 0.6000 0.6000 T59 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 11.00 - 19.50 0.6000 0.6000 T59 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 11.00 - 19.50 0.6000 0.6000 T59 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 11.00 - 19.50 0.6000 0.6000 T59 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 11.00 - 19.50 0.6000 0.6000 T59 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 11.00 - 19.50 0.6000 0.6000 T59 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 11.00 - 19.50 0.6000 0.6000 T59 ] 0 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 11.00 - 19.50 0.6000 0.6000 T59 I I EW63 11.00 - 19.50 0.6000 0.6000 T59 12 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 11.00 - 19.50 0.6000 0.6000 T59 13 EW63 11.00 - 19.50 0.6000 0.6000 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 52 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Tower Section Feed Line Record No. Description Feed Line Segment Elev. Ka No Ice Ka Ice T59 14 EW63 11.00 - 19.50 0.6000 0.6000 T59 15 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 11.00 - 19.50 0.6000 0.6000 T59 16 1" nominal conduit 11.00 - 19.50 0.6000 0.6000 T59 17 climbing ladder 11.00 - 19.50 0.6000 0.6000 T59 18 safety line 3/8 11.00 - 19.50 0.6000 0.6000 T59 19 3-1/8" rigid 11.00 - 19.50 0.6000 0.6000 T59 21 1-5/8" coax 11.00 - 19.50 0.6000 0.6000 T59 22 2-1/4" coax 11.00 - 19.50 0.6000 0.6000 T59 23 2-1/4" coax 11.00 - 19.50 0.6000 0.6000 T59 24 7/8" coax 11.00 - 19.50 0.6000 0.6000 T59 25 Verizon Tx line ladder 11.00 - 19.50 0.6000 0.6000 T60 1 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 10.00 - 11.00 0.6000 0.6000 T60 2 LDF4-50A (1/2 FOAM) 10.00 - 11.00 0.6000 0.6000 T60 3 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 10.00 - 11.00 0.6000 0.6000 T60 4 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 10.00 - 11.00 0.6000 0.6000 T60 5 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 10.00 - 11.00 0.6000 0.6000 T60 6 LDF6-50A (1-1/4 FOAM) 10.00 - 11.00 0.6000 0.6000 T60 7 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 10.00 - 11.00 0.6000 0.6000 T60 8 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 10.00 - 11.00 0.6000 0.6000 T60 10 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 10.00 - 11.00 0.6000 0.6000 T60 11 EW63 10.00 - 11.00 0.6000 0.6000 T60 12 LDF7-50A (1-5/8 FOAM) 10.00 - 11.00 0.6000 0.6000 T60 13 EW63 10.00 - 11.00 0.6000 0.6000 T60 14 EW63 10.00 - 11.00 0.6000 0.6000 T60 15 LDF5-50A (7/8 FOAM) 10.00 - 11.00 0.6000 0.6000 T60 16 1" nominal conduit 10.00 - 11.00 0.6000 0.6000 T60 17 climbing ladder 10.00 - 11.00 0.6000 0.6000 T60 18 safety line 3/8 10.00 - 11.00 0.6000 0.6000 T60 19 3-1/8" rigid 10.00 - 11.00 0.6000 0.6000 T60 21 1-5/8" coax 10.00 - 11.00 0.6000 0.6000 T60 22 2-1/4" coax 10.00 - 11.00 0.6000 0.6000 T60 23 2-1/4" coax 10.00 - 11.00 0.6000 0.6000 T60 24 7/8" coax 10.00 - 11.00 0.6000 0.6000 T60 25 Verizon Tx line ladder, 10.00 - 11.00 0.6000 0.6000 Discrete Tower Loads Description Face Offset Offsets: Azimuth Placement CAAA CAAA Weight or Type Horz Adjustment Front Side Leg Lateral Vert ft 0 ft ft, ft, lb ft ft Beacon C None 0.0000 1016.00 No Ice 2.50 2.50 85.00 (1" conduit) Crow's nest lightning C None 0.0000 1016.00 No Ice 8.00 8.00 75.00 dissipator SHPX-8AC C From Leg 1.50 0.0000 1012.00 - No Ice 38.00 38.00 930.00 (WAVV-FM 101.1 MHz 0.00 944.15 #05328A / 3-1/8" rigid) 0.00 A/R brackets for SHPX-8AC C From Face 0.50 0.0000 1012.00 - No Ice 4.30 4.30 52.00 0.00 944.15 0.00 A/R brackets for SHPX-8AC A From Face 0.50 0.0000 1012.00 - No Ice 4.30 4.30 52.00 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 53 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Description Face or Leg Offset Type Offsets: Horz Lateral Vert ft ft ft Azimuth Adjustment 0 Placement ft CAAA Front ft2 CAAA Side ft2 Weight lb 0.00 944.15 0.00 Index plate assembly A None 0.0000 943.19 No Ice 0.00 0.00 2800.00 ERI LP-lE-SP C From Leg 1.50 0.0000 921.00 No Ice 3.00 3.10 75.00 (WAVV-HDFM, 101.1 Mhz, 0.00 #21223) 0.00 Red lights C None 0.0000 878.00 No Ice 2.00 2.00 50.00 (3) Stati-cats C None 0.0000 794.00 No Ice 1.50 1.50 35.00 Empty tic -back C From Face 0.25 0.0000 754.00 No Ice 3.00 3.00 85.00 0.00 0.00 2-way ASP C Stand -Off 3.50 0.0000 735.00 No Ice 6.50 6.50 50.00 Right 0.00 0.00 2-way ASP mount C From Face 0.25 0.0000 735.00 No Ice 11.00 3.50 250.00 1.00 0.00 Red lights C None 0.0000 727.00 No Ice 2.00 2.00 50.00 DB228 C Stand -Off 7.00 0.0000 726.00 - 685.75 No Ice 13.00 13.00 72.00 Left 0.00 0.00 DB228 C Stand -Off 7.00 0.0000 726.00 - 685.75 No Ice 13.00 13.00 72.00 Right 0.00 0.00 DB228 mounts C From Face 0.25 0.0000 726.00 - 685.00 No Ice 20.50 1.00 500.00 0.00 0.00 TxRx 100-68-10-X-03N C From Leg 5.75 0.0000 675.00 No Ice 5.60 5.60 70.00 (#16361) 0.00 (2-1/4" coax) 0.00 TxRx 100-68-10-X-03N C From Leg 2.88 0.0000 675.00 No Ice 7.00 7.00 135.00 mount 0.00 0.00 12' whip w/ mount C From Leg 1.00 0.0000 651.00 No Ice 3.00 3.00 50.00 (1/2" coax) 0.00 0.00 (3) Stati-Cats C None 0.0000 591.00 No Ice 1.50 1.50 35.00 Beacon C None 0.0000 584.00 No Ice 2.50 2.50 85.00 (1" conduit) Celwave PD458 B From Leg 5.00 0.0000 458.00 No Ice 4.00 4.00 25.00 (7/8" coax) 0.00 0.00 Celwave mount B From Leg 2.50 0.0000 458.00 No Ice 0.50 3.00 80.00 0.00 0.00 Red lights C None 0.0000 437.00 No Ice 2.00 2.00 50.00 (1" conduit) DB264 w/ mount B From Leg 2.00 60.0000 422.00 - 412.00 No Ice 6.50 7.00 75.00 (7/8" coax) 0.00 0.00 (3) Stati-cats C None 0.0000 405.00 No Ice 1.50 1.50 35.00 (2) DB858HV09 (alltel) B From Leg 0.33 -40.0000 359.50 - 342.00 No Ice 35.00 12.50 120.00 ((2) 7/8" coax, (1) 1-5/8" 0.00 coax) 0.00 (2) DB858HV09 (alltel) C From Leg 0.33 40.0000 359.50 - 342.00 No Ice 35.00 12.50 120.00 ((2) 7/8" coax, (1) 1-5/8" 0.00 coax) 0.00 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 54 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Description Face Offset Offsets: Azimuth Placement or Type Horz Adjustment Leg Lateral Vert CAAA Front ft o ft ft2 ft ft DB436 yagi (on 6' grid rim) B From Leg 3.00 20.0000 _ 321.00 No Ice 1.00 (7/8" coax) 0.00 0.00 DB812 C From Leg 6.00 0.0000 295.00 No Ice 6.75 (7/8" coax) 0.00 0.00 DB812 mount C From Leg 3.00 0.0000 295.00 No Ice 2.50 0.00 0.00 BCR12 A From Leg 6.00 0.0000 295.00 - 318.00 No Ice 13.25 (1-5/8" coax) 0.00 0.00 BCR12 B From Leg 6.00 0.0000 290.50 - 313.50 No Ice 13.25 (1-5/8" coax) 0.00 0.00 BCR12 antenna mount A From Leg 3.00 0.0000 295.50 - 318.50 No Ice 2.50 0.00 0.00 BCR12 antenna mount B From Leg 3.00 0.0000 290.50 - 313.50 No Ice 2.50 0.00 0.00 Beacon C None 0.0000 289.50 No Ice 2.50 (1" conduit) (3) Stati-Cats C None 0.0000 199.50 No Ice 1.50 Red lights C None 0.0000 148.25 No Ice 2.00 (1-1/4") (2) Ericsson RRUS-2212 A From Leg 3.00 0.0000 220.00 No Ice 0.87 (sideways) 0.00 0.00 (2) Ericsson RRUS-2212 B From Leg 3.00 0.0000 220.00 No Ice 0.87 (sideways) 0.00 0.00 (2) Ericsson RRUS-2212 C From Leg 3.00 0.0000 220.00 No Ice 0.87 CAAA Side ft2 1.00 6.75 5.50 13.25 13.25 7.50 7.50 2.50 1.50 2.00 1.86 1.86 1.86 Weight th 10.00 65.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 115.00 115.00 85.00 35.00 50.00 50.00 50.00 50.00 (sideways) 0.00 0.00 RRUS-32 A From Leg 3.00 0.0000 220.00 No Ice 2.74 1.67 60.00 0.00 0.00 RRUS-32 B From Leg 3.00 0.0000 220.00 No Ice 2.74 1.67 60.00 0.00 0.00 RRUS-32 C From Leg 3.00 0.0000 220.00 No Ice 2.74 1.67 60.00 0.00 0.00 Raycap RRFDC-3315-PF-48 B From Leg 2.00 0.0000 220.00 No Ice 4.08 3.24 58.16 OVP w/ pipe mast 0.00 0.00 Raycap RRFDC-3315-PF-48 C From Leg 2.00 0.0000 220.00 No Ice 4.08 3.24 58.16 OVP w/ pipe mast 0.00 0.00 (2) JMA X7CQAP-86-865-V A From Leg 3.00 0.0000 220.00 No Ice 13.44 9.39 111.32 w/ pipe mast 0.00 0.00 (2) JMA X7CQAP-86-865-V B From Leg 3.00 0.0000 220.00 No Ice 13.44 9.39 111.32 w/ pipe mast 0.00 0.00 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 55 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Description Face Offset Offsets: Azimuth Placement CAAA CAAA Weight or Type Horz Adjustment Front Side Leg Lateral Vert ft 0 ft ft2 ft2 lb ft ft (2) JMA X7CQAP-86-865-V C From Leg 3.00 0.0000 220.00 No Ice 13.44 9.39 111.32 w/ pipe mast 0.00 0.00 Verizon sector frame mount A From Leg 2.50 0.0000 220.00 No Ice 18.00 10.25 405.00 0.00 0.00 Verizon sector frame mount B From Leg 2.50 0.0000 220.00 No Ice 18.00 10.25 405.00 0.00 0.00 Verizon sector frame mount C From Leg 2.50 0.0000 220.00 No Ice 18.00 10.25 405.00 0.00 0.00 Nextel sector A: (3) A From Leg 3.50 0.0000 130.00 No Ice 24.50 24.50 225.00 D138481-190 panels, (4) 2" -2.00 Sch. 40 x 96" mount pipes 0.00 (#16361B) ((3) 7/8" coax) Nextel sector B: (3) B From Leg 3.50 0.0000 130.00 No Ice 24.50 24.50 225.00 D13848H90 panels, (4) 2" -2.00 Sch. 40 x 96" mount pipes 0.00 (#16361B) ((3) 7/8" coax) Nextel sector C: (3) C From Leg 3.50 0.0000 130.00 No Ice 24.50 24.50 225.00 D13848H90 panels, (4) 2" -2.00 Sch. 40 x 96" mount pipes 0.00 (#16361B) ((3) 7/8" coax) Nextel sector frame mount A From Leg 1.75 0.0000 130.00 No Ice 18.50 12.50 460.00 0.00 0.00 Nextel sector frame mount B From Leg 1.75 0.0000 130.00 No Ice 18.50 12.50 460.00 0.00 0.00 Nextel sector frame mount C From Leg 1.75 0.0000 130.00 No Ice 18.50 12.50 460.00 0.00 0.00 Dishes Description Face Dish Offset Offsets: Azimuth 3 dB Elevation Outside Aperture Weight or Type Type Harz Adjustment Beam Diameter Area Leg Lateral Width Vert ft o o ft ft ft2 lb 6' grid B Grid From 1.00 20.0000 321.00 6.00 No Ice 28.27 130.00 (1-1/4" coax) Leg 0.00 0.00 6' solid dish A Paraboloid From 1.50 -60.0000 230.00 6.00 No Ice 28.27 285.00 (EW63) w/Radome Leg 0.00 0.00 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 56 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Description Face Dish Offset Offsets: Azimuth 3 dB Elevation Outside Aperture Weight or Type Type Horz Adjustment Beam Diameter Area Leg Lateral Width Vert ft o o ft ft ft2 lb 4' solid dish A Paraboloid From 1.00 -60.0000 185.00 4.00 No Ice 12.57 170.00 (EW63) w/Radome Leg 0.00 0.00 6' solid dish B Paraboloid From 1.50 30.0000 140.00 6.00 No Ice 28.27 285.00 (EW63) w/Radome Leg 0.00 0.00 Bolt Design Data Section Elevation Component Bolt Bolt Size Number Maximum Allowable Ratio Allowable Criteria No. Type Grade Of Load per Load Load Ratio ft in Bolts Bolt lb Allowable lb T2 939.5 Top Guy A325N 0.6250 4 13848.10 24850.50 0.557 1 Bolt Shear Pull-Off@919.5 T10 774.5 Top Guy A325N 0.6250 4 8788.43 24850.50 1 Bolt Shear Pull-Off@769.5 0.354 T19 629.5 Top Guy A325N 0.6250 4 9381.59 24850.50 1 Bolt Shear Pull-Off@629.5 0.378 T24 499.5 Top Guy A325N 0.6250 4 7248.60 24850.50 1 Bolt Shear Pull-Off@494.5 0.292 Y T33 369.5 Top Guy A325N 0.6250 4 8005.03 24850.50 1 Bolt Shear Pull-Off@364.5 0.322 T42 239.5 Top Guy A325N 0.6250 4 11395.20 24850.50 1 Bolt Shear Pull-Off@239.5 0.459 T51 119.5 Top Guy A325N 0.6250 4 9461.94 24850.50 1 Bolt Shear Pull-Off@l 19.5 0.381 Guy Design Data Section Elevation Size Initial Breaking Actual Allowable Required Actual No. Tension Load T. OT„ S.F. S.F. ft lb lb lb lb T2 919.50 (A) 1 5/8 BS 29160.00 324000.66 157484.00 194400.00 1.000 1.234 (1704) 919.50 (B) 1 5/8 BS 29160.00 324000.66 157605.00 194400.00 1.000 1.233 (1703) 919.50 (C) 1 5/8 BS 29160.00 324000.66 157504.00 194400.00 1.000 (1702) 1.234 T10 769.50 (A) 1 1/4 BS 17760.00 192000.16 90265.90 115200.00 1.000 (1707) 1.276 769.50 (B) 1 1/4 BS 17760.00 192000.16 88807.00 115200.00 1.000 1.297 (1706) 769.50 (C) 1 1/4 BS 17760.00 192000.16 88833.70 115200.00 1.000 (1705) 1.297 T19 629.50 (A) 1 3/16 BS 20640.00 172000.27 86385.50 103200.00 1.000 1.195 (1710) 629.50 (B) 1 3/16 BS 20640.00 172000.27 85033.00 103200.00 1.000 1.214 (1709) 629.50 (C) 1 3/16 BS 20640.00 172000.27 85116.30 103200.00 1.000 1.212 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 57 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section Elevation Size Initial Breaking Actual Allowable Required Actual No. Tension Load T. OT S.F. S.F. ft lb lb lb lb (1708) T24 494.50 (A) 1 1/4 BS 17280.00 192000.16 77168.60 115200.00 1.000 1.493 (1713) 494.50 (B) 1 1/4 BS 17280.00 192000.16 77443.90 115200.00 1.000 1.488 (1712) 494.50 (C) 1 1/4 BS 17280.00 192000.16 77618.60 115200.00 1.000 (1711) 1.484 T33 364.50 (A) 1 1/4 BS 15360.00 192000.16 68552.70 115200.00 1.000 1.680 (1716) 364.50 (B) 1 1/4 BS 15360.00 192000.16 70864.00 115200.00 1.000 1.626 (1715) 364.50 (C) 1 1/4 BS 15360.00 192000.16 70707.30 115200.00 1.000 (1714) 1.629 T42 239.50 (A) 1 1/4 BS 20160.00 192000.16 86228.90 115200.00 1.000 (1719) 1.336 239.50 (B) 1 1/4 BS 20160.00 192000.16 86608.20 115200.00 1.000 (1718) 1.330 239.50 (C) 1 1/4 BS 20160.00 192000.16 87006.30 115200.00 1.000 (1717) 1.324 T51 119.50 (A) 1 BS 17080.00 121999.80 62368.00 73200.00 1.000 (1722) 1.174 119.50 (B) 1 BS 17080.00 121999.80 62081.00 73200.00 1.000 (1721) 1.179 119.50 (C) 1 BS 17080.00 121999.80 61609.00 73200.00 1.000 (1720) 1.188 Compression Checks Leg Design Data (Compression) Section No. Elevation ft Size L ft L ft K11r A in2 Mast Stability Index P. lb OP lb Ratio P. OPn Ll 1016 - 996.615 2 19.38 1.84 44.2 3.1416 1.00 -21842.60 122259 00 0._17/9' K=1.00 Y L2 996.615 - 2 19.38 1.62 38.8 3.1416 1.00 -73564.60 126314.00 0.582' 977.23 K=1.00 i L3 977.23 - 3 19.38 1.62 25.8 7.0686 1.00 -159829.00 301795.00 0.530' 957.845 K=1.00 Y L4 957.845 - 3 1/2 14.66 1.62 22.2 9.6211 1.00 -253458.00 416185.00 0._60/9' 943.188 K=1.00 Y Tl 943.188 - 3 1/2 3.69 3.69 50.6 9.6211 1.00 -159453.00 359092.00 0.444' 939.5 K=1.00 i T2 939.5 - 909.5 3 1/2 30.00 5.00 68.6 9.6211 1.00 -278122.00 306993.00 0.906' K=1.00 Y T3 909.5 - 894.5 3 1/4 15.00 5.00 73.8 8.2958 1.00 -264054.00 250556.00 1.054' K=1.00 4.8.1 (1.05 CR) - 424/2 T4 894.5 - 879.5 3 1/4 15.00 5.00 73.8 8.2958 1.00 -247565.00 250556.00 0.988' K=1.00 Y tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 58 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section Elevation Size L Ln K11r A Mast Pu OP„ Ratio No. Stability P. ft ft ft in' Index lb lb OPn T5 879.5 - 859.5 3 20.00 5.00 80.0 7.0686 1.00 -234248.00 199213.00 1.176 K=1.00 4.8.1 (1.18 CR) - 466/3 T6 859.5 - 849.5 3 10.00 5.00 80.0 7.0686 1.00 -223488.00 199213.00 1.122 K=1.00 4.8.1 (1.12 CR) - 493 T7 849.5 - 819.5 3 30.00 5.00 80.0 7.0686 1.00 -224591.00 199213.00 1.127 K=1.00 4.8.1 (1.13 CR) - 508 T8 819.5 - 789.5 3 1/4 30.00 5.00 73.8 8.2958 1.00 -261434.00 250556.00 1.043 K=1.00 4.8.1 (1.04 CR) - 547 T9 789.5 - 774.5 3 1/4 15.00 5.00 73.8 8.2958 1.00 -290597.00 250556.00 1.160 K=1.00 4.8.1 (1.16 CR) - 586 T10 774.5 - 759.5 3 1/4 15.00 5.00 73.8 8.2958 1.00 -309814.00 250556.00 1.237 ' K=1.00 4.8.1 (1.24 CR) - 607 T11 759.5 - 729.5 3 1/4 30.00 5.00 73.8 8.2958 1.00 -294017.00 250556.00 1.173 K=1.00 4.8.1 (1.17 CR) - 628/5 T12 729.5 - 699.5 3 1/4 30.00 5.00 73.8 8.2958 1.00 -257401.00 250556.00 1.027' K=1.00 4.8.1 (1.03 CR) - 667/5 T13 699.5 - 679.5 3 1/2 20.00 5.00 68.6 9.6211 1.00 -242879.00 306993.00 0.791 K=1.00 Y T14 679.5 - 669.5 3 1/2 10.00 5.00 68.6 9.6211 1.00 -247536.00 306993.00 0.J80�6 K=1.00 Y T15 669.5 - 664.5 3 1/2 5.00 5.00 68.6 9.6211 1.00 -252735.00 306993.00 0._82/3 K=1.00 Y T16 664.5 - 659.5 3 1/2 5.00 5.00 68.6 9.6211 1.00 -255505.00 306993.00 0.832 K=1.00 Y T17 659.5 - 639.5 3 1/2 20.00 5.00 68.6 9.6211 1.00 -278882.00 306993.00 0.J90�8' K=1.00 Y T18 639.5 - 629.5 3 1/2 10.00 5.00 68.6 9.6211 1.00 -294206.00 306993.00 0._9/58' K=1.00 Y T19 629.5 - 609.5 3 1/2 20.00 5.00 68.6 9.6211 1.00 -296646.00 306993.00 0.966 K=1.00 Y T20 609.5 - 579.5 3 1/2 30.00 5.00 68.6 9.6211 1.00 -237802.00 306993.00 0.J77�5' K=1.00 Y T21 579.5 - 549.5 3 1/2 30.00 5.00 68.6 9.6211 1.00 -213790.00 306993.00 0._69/6 K=1.00 Y T22 549.5 - 519.5 3 1/2 30.00 5.00 68.6 9.6211 1.00 -205349.00 306993.00 0.669 K=1.00 Y T23 519.5 - 499.5 3 1/2 20.00 5.00 68.6 9.6211 1.00 -258365.00 306993.00 0.J84�2 K=1.00 Y T24 499.5 - 489.5 3 1/2 10.00 5.00 68.6 9.6211 1.00 -281843.00 306993.00 0._9/18 K=1.00 Y tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 59 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section Elevation Size L Ln K11r A Mast Pu OP„ Ratio No. Stability Pn ft ft ft in' Index lb lb OPn T25 489.5 - 474.5 3 1/2 15.00 5.00 68.6 9.6211 1.00 -272129.00 306993.00 0.886' K=1.00 Y T26 474.5 - 459.5 3 1/2 15.00 5.00 68.6 9.6211 1.00 -253773.00 306993.00 0.J82�7' K=1.00 Y T27 459.5 - 449.5 3 1/2 10.00 5.00 68.6 9.6211 1.00 -240997.00 306993.00 0._7/85' K=1.00 Y T28 449.5 - 429.5 3 1/2 20.00 5.00 68.6 9.6211 1.00 -243569.00 306993.00 0.793 K=1.00 Y T29 429.5 - 409.5 3 1/2 20.00 5.00 68.6 9.6211 1.00 -262481.00 306993.00 0.J8�55' K=1.00 Y T30 409.5 - 399.5 3 1/2 10.00 5.00 68.6 9.6211 1.00 -278265.00 306993.00 0._90/6' K=1.00 Y T31 399.5 - 379.5 3 3/4 20.00 5.00 64.0 11.0447 1.00 -320274.00 368382.00 0.869' K=1.00 Y T32 379.5 - 369.5 3 3/4 10.00 5.00 64.0 11.0447 1.00 -346073.00 368382.00 0.J9�39' K=1.00 Y T33 369.5 - 349.5 3 3/4 20.00 5.00 64.0 11.0447 1.00 -359578.00 368382.00 0._97/6' K=1.00 Y T34 349.5 - 339.5 3 3/4 10.00 5.00 64.0 11.0447 1.00 -308277.00 368382.00 0.837 K=1.00 Y T35 339.5 - 329.5 3 3/4 10.00 5.00 64.0 11.0447 1.00 -282973.00 368382.00 0.J76�8' K=1.00 Y T36 329.5 - 309.5 3 3/4 20.00 5.00 64.0 11.0447 1.00 -278554.00 368382.00 0._7/56' K=1.00 Y T37 309.5 - 279.5 3 3/4 30.00 5.00 64.0 11.0447 1.00 -278116.00 368382.00 0.755 ' K=1.00 Y T38 279.5 - 264.5 3 3/4 15.00 5.00 64.0 11.0447 1.00 -279290.00 368382.00 0.J7�58 ' K=1.00 Y T39 264.5 - 254.5 3 3/4 10.00 5.00 64.0 11.0447 1.00 -305211.00 368382.00 0._82/9' K=1.00 Y T40 254.5 - 249.5 3.75" SR with half 5.00 5.00 67.1 13.3210 1.00 -324322.00 431239.00 0.752' pipe K=1.00 Y T41 249.5 - 239.5 3.75" SR with half 10.00 5.00 67.1 13.3210 1.00 -362458.00 431239.00 0.J84�1 ' pipe K=1.00 Y T42 239.5 - 229.5 3.75" SR with half 10.00 5.00 67.1 13.3210 1.00 -352563.00 431239.00 0._8/18 ' pipe K=1.00 Y T43 229.5 - 219.5 3.75" SR with half 10.00 5.00 67.1 13.3210 1.00 -310418.00 431239.00 0.720 ' pipe K=1.00 Y T44 219.5 - 194.5 4 25.00 5.00 60.0 12.5664 1.00 -385306.00 434617.00 0.J8�87' K=1.00 Y T45 194.5 - 189.5 4 5.00 5.00 60.0 12.5664 1.00 -394049.00 434617.00 0._90/7' K=1.00 Y T46 189.5 - 179.5 4 10.00 5.00 60.0 12.5664 1.00 -412584.00 434617.00 0.949' K=1.00 Y T47 179.5 - 159.5 4 20.00 5.00 60.0 12.5664 1.00 -424560.00 434617.00 0.J97�7 ' K=1.00 Y T48 159.5 - 129.5 4 30.00 5.00 60.0 12.5664 1.00 -421857.00 434617.00 0._97/1 ' K=1.00 Y T49 129.5 - 124.5 4 5.00 5.00 60.0 12.5664 1.00 -373340.00 434617.00 0.859' K=1.00 Y T50 124.5 - 119.5 4 5.00 5.00 60.0 12.5664 1.00 -359031.00 434617.00 0.J82�6' K=1.00 Y tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 60 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section Elevation Size L Lu K11r A Mast Pu OP„ Ratio No. Stability Pu ft ft ft in' Index lb lb Opn T51 119.5 - 114.5 4 5.00 5.00 60.0 12.5664 1.00 -371442.00 434617.00 0.855' K=1.00 Y T52 114.5 - 99.5 4 15.00 5.00 60.0 12.5664 1.00 -414641.00 434617.00 0.J9�54' K=1.00 Y T53 99.5 - 79.5 4 1/4 20.00 5.00 56.5 14.1863 1.00 -449086.00 505612.00 0._8/88' K=1.00 Y T54 79.5 - 69.5 4 1/4 10.00 5.00 56.5 14.1863 1.00 -455463.00 505612.00 0.901 ' K=1.00 Y T55 69.5 - 59.5 4 1/4 10.00 5.00 56.5 14.1863 1.00 -454643.00 505612.00 0.J89�9' K=1.00 Y T56 59.5 - 39.5 4 1/4 20.00 5.00 56.5 14.1863 1.00 -450629.00 505612.00 0._89/1 ' K=1.00 Y T57 39.5 - 29.5 4 1/4 10.00 5.00 56.5 14.1863 1.00 -423777.00 505612.00 0.838' K=1.00 Y T58 29.5 - 19.5 4 1/4 10.00 5.00 56.5 14.1863 1.00 -400366.00 505612.00 0.J79�2' K=1.00 Y T59 19.5 - 11 4 1/4 8.50 4.25 48.0 14.1863 0.99 -380372.00 535079.00 0._7/11 ' K=1.00 Y T60 11 - 0 4 1/2 11.53 3.84 41.0 15.9043 0.97 -375836.00 610837.00 0.615' K=1.00 Y 1 P u / �Pn controls Diagonal Design Data (Compression) Ratio Section Elevation Size L Lu K11r A Pu OP. No. Pu ft ft ft in2 lb lb opn Ll 1016 - 996.615 3/4 3.95 1.88 90.4 0.4418 -2324.71 9310.66 0._2/50' K=0.75 Y L2 996.615 - 7/8 3.85 1.84 87.7 0.6013 -4877.91 12999.20 0._37/5' 977.23 K=0.87 Y L3 977.23 - 1 3.85 1.79 82.7 0.7854 -8033.15 17747.30 0.453 ' 957.845 K=0.96 Y L4 957.845 - 1 3.85 1.77 82.3 0.7854 -10122.20 17820.90 0.568' 943.188 K=0.97 Tl 943.188 - 2L2 1/2x2x3/16x3/8 7.04 6.70 121.2 1.6200 -19628.30 24212.80 0.811 ' 939.5 K=1.00 2L 'a' > 32.4715 in - 384 T2 939.5 - 909.5 2 7.81 7.43 124.8 3.1416 -26093.20 44813.30 0._5/82 ' K=0.70 Y T3 909.5 - 894.5 2 7.81 7.46 125.3 3.1416 -13659.20 44545.20 0._30/7' K=0.70 Y T4 894.5 - 879.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.46 143.2 2.4053 -11415.20 26502.90 0.431 ' K=0.70 Y T5 879.5 - 859.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.48 143.7 2.4053 -8918.15 26311.20 0._33/9' K=0.70 Y T6 859.5 - 849.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.48 143.7 2.4053 -6151.15 26311.20 0._23/4' K=0.70 Y T7 849.5 - 819.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.48 143.7 2.4053 -4893.70 26311.20 0.186' tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 61 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section Elevation Size L L Kl/r A Pu OP Ratio No. P. ft ft ft in2 lb lb OPn K=0.70 Y T8 819.5 - 789.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.46 143.2 2.4053 -8547.80 26502.90 0.323 ' K=0.70 Y T9 789.5 - 774.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.46 143.2 2.4053 -10557.20 26502.90 0.J39�8' K=0.70 Y T10 774.5 - 759.5 2 7.81 7.46 125.3 3.1416 -16559.60 44545.20 0._37/2' K=0.70 Y T11 759.5 - 729.5 2 7.81 7.46 125.3 3.1416 -15214.90 44545.20 0.342' K=0.70 Y T12 729.5 - 699.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.46 143.2 2.4053 -9580.04 26502.90 0.J36�1 ' K=0.70 Y T13 699.5 - 679.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.43 142.7 2.4053 -8604.79 26696.70 0._32/2' K=0.70 Y T14 679.5 - 669.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.43 142.7 2.4053 -13123.90 26696.70 0.492' K=0.70 Y T15 669.5 - 664.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.43 142.7 2.4053 -14173.80 26696.70 0.J53�1 ' K=0.70 Y T16 664.5 - 659.5 2 7.81 7.43 124.8 3.1416 -15353.60 44813.30 0._34/3' K=0.70 Y T17 659.5 - 639.5 2 7.81 7.43 124.8 3.1416 -19942.30 44813.30 0.445 K=0.70 Y T18 639.5 - 629.5 2 7.81 7.43 124.8 3.1416 -21554.90 44813.30 0.J4�81 K=0.70 Y T19 629.5 - 609.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.43 142.7 2.4053 -15747.20 26696.70 0._59/0 K=0.70 Y T20 609.5 - 579.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.43 142.7 2.4053 -12900.60 26696.70 0.483' K=0.70 Y T21 579.5 - 549.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.43 142.7 2.4053 -8103.58 26696.70 0.J30�4' K=0.70 Y T22 549.5 - 519.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.43 142.7 2.4053 -12797.10 26696.70 0._47/9' K=0.70 Y T23 519.5 - 499.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.43 142.7 2.4053 -16167.70 26696.70 0.606' K=0.70 Y T24 499.5 - 489.5 2 7.81 7.43 124.8 3.1416 -17252.30 44813.30 0.J3�85' K=0.70 Y T25 489.5 - 474.5 2 7.81 7.43 124.8 3.1416 -12561.30 44813.30 0._2/80' K=0.70 Y T26 474.5 - 459.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.43 142.7 2.4053 -9774.03 26696.70 0.366' K=0.70 Y T27 459.5 - 449.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.43 142.7 2.4053 -6576.56 26696.70 0.J24�6' K=0.70 Y T28 449.5 - 429.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.43 142.7 2.4053 -4474.05 26696.70 0._1/68' K=0.70 Y T29 429.5 - 409.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.43 142.7 2.4053 -8131.00 26696.70 0.305' K=0.70 Y T30 409.5 - 399.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.43 142.7 2.4053 -10218.30 26696.70 0.J3�83' K=0.70 Y T31 399.5 - 379.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.40 142.1 2.4053 -14189.10 26892.60 0._52/8' K=0.70 Y T32 379.5 - 369.5 2 7.81 7.40 124.4 3.1416 -15941.70 45081.90 0.354 K=0.70 Y T33 369.5 - 349.5 2 7.81 7.40 124.4 3.1416 -21247.80 45081.90 0.4711 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 62 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section No. Elevation ft Size L ft L ft Kl/r A in2 Pu lb OP lb Ratio P. OPn K=0.70 Y T34 349.5 - 339.5 2 7.81 7.40 124.4 3.1416 -15160.70 45081.90 0.336' K=0.70 Y T35 339.5 - 329.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.40 142.1 2.4053 -12740.80 26892.60 0.J47�4 K=0.70 Y T36 329.5 - 309.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.40 142.1 2.4053 -10734.00 26892.60 0._39/9' K=0.70 Y T37 309.5 - 279.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.40 142.1 2.4053 -11628.50 26892.60 0.432' K=0.70 Y T38 279.5 - 264.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.40 142.1 2.4053 -15539.60 26892.60 0.J57�8' K=0.70 Y T39 264.5 - 254.5 2 7.81 7.40 124.4 3.1416 -17578.10 45081.90 0.390' K=0.70 T40 254.5 - 249.5 2 7.81 7.38 124.0 3.1416 -18152.80 45283.90 0.401 ' K=0.70 Y T41 249.5 - 239.5 2 7.81 7.36 123.7 3.1416 -19675.80 45486.10 0.J43�3 ' K=0.70 Y T42 239.5 - 229.5 2 1/4 7.81 7.36 110.0 3.9761 -37302.10 68171.40 0._54/7' K=0.70 Y T43 229.5 - 219.5 2 1/4 7.81 7.36 110.0 3.9761 -34308.10 68171.40 0.503' K=0.70 Y T44 219.5 - 194.5 2 7.81 7.38 123.9 3.1416 -25006.30 45351.20 0.J5�51 ' K=0.70 Y T45 194.5 - 189.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.38 141.6 2.4053 -14286.50 27090.70 0._52/7' K=0.70 Y T46 189.5 - 179.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.38 141.6 2.4053 -13170.70 27090.70 0.486' K=0.70 Y T47 179.5 - 159.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.38 141.6 2.4053 -9553.27 27090.70 0.J3�53' K=0.70 Y T48 159.5 - 129.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.38 141.6 2.4053 -15985.60 27090.70 0._59/0' K=0.70 Y T49 129.5 - 124.5 2 7.81 7.38 123.9 3.1416 -24213.80 45351.20 0.534' K=0.70 Y T50 124.5 - 119.5 2 7.81 7.38 123.9 3.1416 -24085.60 45351.20 0.J53�1 ' K=0.70 Y T51 119.5 - 114.5 2 1/4 7.81 7.38 110.2 3.9761 -22159.70 68011.60 0._32/6' K=0.70 Y T52 114.5 - 99.5 2 7.81 7.38 123.9 3.1416 -19943.90 45351.20 0.440' K=0.70 Y T53 99.5 - 79.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.35 141.1 2.4053 -15403.00 27291.00 0.J5�64' K=0.70 Y T54 79.5 - 69.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.35 141.1 2.4053 -8416.90 27291.00 0._30/8' K=0.70 Y T55 69.5 - 59.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.35 141.1 2.4053 -7607.21 27291.00 0.279' K=0.70 Y T56 59.5 - 39.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.35 141.1 2.4053 -14931.00 27291.00 0.J54�7' K=0.70 Y T57 39.5 - 29.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.35 141.1 2.4053 -18407.10 27291.00 0._67/4' K=0.70 Y T58 29.5 - 19.5 2 7.81 7.35 123.5 3.1416 -21352.80 45621.10 0.468' K=0.70 Y T59 19.5 - 11 2L3x2xl/4x3/8 9.01 8.48 141.1 2.3800 -26651.80 27021.10 0.986' tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 63 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section Elevation Size L Ln Kl/r A Pu OP Ratio No. P. ft ft ft in2 lb lb OPn K=1.00 Y T60 11 - 0 1 1/2 4.77 4.19 93.8 1.7672-17226.80 36035.10 0.478 K=0.70 Y 1 P u / �Pn controls K-Brace Design Data Compression Size L L„ Klir A P„ Ratio Section Elevation OPn No. Pn ft ft ft in2 lb lb OPn Ll 1016 - 996.615 3/4 2.22 2.12 94.8 0.4418-2975.69 8917.06 0.334 K=0.70 Y L2 996.615 - 7/8 1.89 1.80 84.9 0.6013-4750.15 13332.40 0.356' 977.23 K=0.86 i L3 977.23 - 1 1.89 1.76 81.6 0.7854-6886.91 17919.70 0.J3�84' 957.845 K=0.97 Y L4 957.845 - 1 1.92 1.76 81.6 0.7854-11025.50 17922.30 0.615' 943.188 K=0.97 1 P u / �P controls Horizontal Design Data Compression Section Elevation Size L Lu Kl/r A P OPn Ratio No. P ft ft ft in2 lb lb OPn T2 939.5 - 909.5 2 6.00 5.71 95.9 3.1416 -4817.22 62723.00 0.077' K=0.70 Y T3 909.5 - 894.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.73 110.0 2.4053 -4573.56 41216.10 0.J1�11 ' K=0.70 Y T4 894.5 - 879.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.73 110.0 2.4053 -4287.95 41216.10 0._10/4' K=0.70 Y T5 879.5 - 859.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.75 110.4 2.4053 -4057.29 41025.20 0.099' K=0.70 Y T6 859.5 - 849.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.75 128.8 1.7672 -3870.92 23907.30 0.J16�2' K=0.70 Y T7 849.5 - 819.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.75 128.8 1.7672 -3890.04 23907.30 0._16/3' K=0.70 Y T8 819.5 - 789.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.73 128.3 1.7672 -4528.17 24058.80 0.188' K=0.70 Y T9 789.5 - 774.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.73 110.0 2.4053 -5033.29 41216.10 0.J12�2 ' K=0.70 Y T10 774.5 - 759.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.73 110.0 2.4053 -5366.13 41216.10 0._13/0' K=0.70 Y T11 759.5 - 729.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.73 110.0 2.4053 -5092.53 41216.10 0.124' K=0.70 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 64 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section Elevation Size L Lu K11r A Pu OP Ratio No. P. ft ft ft in2 lb lb OPu V T12 729.5 - 699.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.73 128.3 1.7672 -4458.31 24058.80 0.185 K=0.70 Y TO 699.5 - 679.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.71 127.9 1.7672 -4206.79 24210.70 0.J17�4' K=0.70 Y T14 679.5 - 669.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 109.6 2.4053 -4287.44 41407.10 0._10/4' K=0.70 Y T17 659.5 - 639.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 109.6 2.4053 -4830.38 41407.10 0.117' K=0.70 Y T18 639.5 - 629.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 109.6 2.4053 -5095.79 41407.10 0.J12�3' K=0.70 Y T19 629.5 - 609.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 109.6 2.4053 -5138.06 41407.10 0._12/4' K=0.70 Y T20 609.5 - 579.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 109.6 2.4053 -4118.86 41407.10 0.099' K=0.70 Y T21 579.5 - 549.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.71 127.9 1.7672 -3702.95 24210.70 0.J1�53' K=0.70 Y T22 549.5 - 519.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.71 127.9 1.7672 -3556.75 24210.70 0._14/7' K=0.70 Y T23 519.5 - 499.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 109.6 2.4053 -4475.01 41407.10 0.108' K=0.70 Y T25 489.5 - 474.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 109.6 2.4053 -4713.42 41407.10 0.J1�14' K=0.70 Y T26 474.5 - 459.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 109.6 2.4053 -4395.48 41407.10 0._10/6' K=0.70 Y T27 459.5 - 449.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 109.6 2.4053 -4174.20 41407.10 0.101 ' K=0.70 Y T28 449.5 - 429.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.71 127.9 1.7672 -4218.74 24210.70 0.J17�4' K=0.70 Y T29 429.5 - 409.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.71 127.9 1.7672 -4546.31 24210.70 0._1/88' K=0.70 Y T30 409.5 - 399.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 109.6 2.4053 -4819.69 41407.10 0.116' K=0.70 Y T31 399.5 - 379.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.69 109.2 2.4053 -5547.30 41598.30 0.J1�33 ' K=0.70 Y T32 379.5 - 369.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.69 109.2 2.4053 -5994.16 41598.30 0._14/4' K=0.70 Y T33 369.5 - 349.5 2 6.00 5.69 95.6 3.1416 -6228.07 62944.60 0.099' K=0.70 Y T34 349.5 - 339.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.69 109.2 2.4053 -5339.51 41598.30 0.J12�8' K=0.70 Y T35 339.5 - 329.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.69 109.2 2.4053 -4901.23 41598.30 0._1/18 ' K=0.70 Y T36 329.5 - 309.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.69 127.4 1.7672 -4824.70 24363.00 0.198' K=0.70 Y T37 309.5 - 279.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.69 127.4 1.7672 -4817.11 24363.00 0.J19�8' K=0.70 Y T38 279.5 - 264.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.69 109.2 2.4053 -4837.45 41598.30 0._1/16' K=0.70 Y T39 264.5 - 254.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.69 109.2 2.4053 -5286.40 41598.30 0.127' K=0.70 Y T41 249.5 - 239.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.66 108.6 2.4053 -6277.96 41885.50 0.150' tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 65 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section Elevation Size L L KI1r A Pu OP Ratio No. P. ft ft ft in2 lb lb OPn K=0.70 Y T42 239.5 - 229.5 2 6.00 5.66 95.0 3.1416 -6106.57 63277.00 0.097 K=0.70 Y T43 229.5 - 219.5 2 6.00 5.66 95.0 3.1416 -5376.59 63277.00 0.J0�85' K=0.70 Y T44 219.5 - 194.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.67 108.8 2.4053 -6673.69 41789.70 0._16/0' K=0.70 Y T46 189.5 - 179.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.67 108.8 2.4053 -7146.17 41789.70 0.171 ' K=0.70 Y T47 179.5 - 159.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.67 126.9 1.7672 -7353.59 24515.70 0.J30�0' K=0.70 Y T48 159.5 - 129.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.67 126.9 1.7672 -7306.77 24515.70 0._29/8' K=0.70 Y T52 114.5 - 99.5 2 6.00 5.67 95.2 3.1416 -7181.80 63166.20 0.114' K=0.70 Y T53 99.5 - 79.5 2 6.00 5.65 94.8 3.1416 -7778.40 63387.80 0.J12�3 ' K=0.70 Y T54 79.5 - 69.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.65 108.4 2.4053 -7888.86 41981.30 0._1/88' K=0.70 Y T55 69.5 - 59.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.65 108.4 2.4053 -7874.65 41981.30 0.188' K=0.70 Y T56 59.5 - 39.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.65 126.5 1.7672 -7805.13 24668.80 0.J3�16' K=0.70 Y T57 39.5 - 29.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.65 126.5 1.7672 -7340.04 24668.80 0._29/8' K=0.70 Y T58 29.5 - 19.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.65 126.5 1.7672 -7340.04 24668.80 0.298' K=0.70 Y T60 11 - 0 1 1/2 6.00 5.65 126.5 1.7672 -6741.77 24668.80 0.J27�3' K=0.70 Y 1 P u / �P controls 4.8.1 (1.11 CR) - 1688 Top Girt Design Data (Compression) Section Elevation Size No. ft Ll 1016 - 996.615 2x1/2 L2 996.615 - 977.23 L3 977.23 - 957.845 L4 957.845 - 943.188 T1 943.188 - 939.5 T2 939.5 - 909.5 2x1/2 2x1/2 2x1/2 MC18x58 2 L Lu KI1r A Pu OP Ratio P f ft in2 lb lb OP. 3.50 1.67 138.6 1.0000 -505.47 11766.30 0.043' K=1.00 Y 3.50 1.67 138.6 1.0000 -2546.23 11766.30 0._2/16' K=1.00 Y 3.50 1.63 135.1 1.0000 -4912.94 12377.40 0._39/7 K=1.00 Y 3.50 1.60 133.4 1.0000 -7267.63 12702.20 0.572' K=1.00 Y 6.00 5.71 67.2 17.1000 -18824.40 436945.00 0._04/3 K=1.00 Y 6.00 5.71 95.9 3.1416 -1054.52 62723.00 0.017 K=0.70 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 66 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section Elevation Size L L K11r A Pu OP Ratio No. P ft ft ft in2 lb lb OPn V T3 909.5 - 894.5 2 6.00 5.71 95.9 3.1416 -199.34 62723.00 0.003 K=0.70 Y T5 879.5 - 859.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.73 110.0 2.4053 -46.47 41216.10 0.J00�1 ' K=0.70 Y T6 859.5 - 849.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.75 110.4 2.4053 -44.02 41025.20 0._00/1 ' K=0.70 Y T7 849.5 - 819.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.75 128.8 1.7672 -50.35 23907.30 0.002' K=0.70 Y T8 819.5 - 789.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.75 128.8 1.7672 -10.66 23907.30 0.J00�0' K=0.70 Y T13 699.5 - 679.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.73 128.3 1.7672 -93.87 24058.80 0.004' K=0.70 T44 219.5 - 194.5 2 6.00 5.66 95.0 3.1416 -1839.09 63277.00 0.029' K=0.70 Y T49 129.5 - 124.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.67 108.8 2.4053 -1427.80 41789.70 0.J03�4' K=0.70 Y T59 19.5 - 11 2L3x2x1/4x3/8 6.00 4.23 96.5 2.3800 -15674.80 47218.90 0.332' K=1.00 2L 'a' > 18.6056 in - 1665 1 P u / �Pn controls Bottom Girt Design Data (Compression) Ratio Section Elevation Size L L K11r A Pu OP No. Pn ft ft ft in2 lb lb OPn Ll 1016 - 996.615 2x1/2 3.50 1.67 138.6 1.0000 -2422.71 11766.30 0._20/6' K=1.00 Y L2 996.615- 2x1/2 3.50 1.67 138.6 1.0000 -4538.75 11766.30 0.386' 977.23 K=1.00 i L3 977.23 - 2x1/2 3.50 1.63 135.1 1.0000 -6595.75 12377.40 0.533' 957.845 K=1.00 Y L4 957.845 - 12x1 3.50 1.60 66.7 12.0000 -30054.60 307652.00 0.098 943.188 K=1.00 1 P n / op. controls Mid Girt Design Data (Compression) Section Elevation Size L Ln Kl/r A Pu OPn Ratio No. P ft ft ft in2 lb lb OPn Ll 1016 - 996.615 2x1/2 3.50 3.33 277.1 1.0000 -74.06 2941.57 0.025 K=1.00 KL/R > 200 (C) - 11 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 67 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed by Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX- (781) 273-3311 Section No. Elevation ft Size L ft L ft KI/r A in2 P lb OP lb Ratio P. Opn L2 996.615- 2x1/2 3.50 3.33 277.1 1.0000 -459.93 2941.57 0.156 977.23 K=1.00 KL/R > 200 (C) - 101 L3 977.23- 2x1/2 3.50 3.25 270.2 1.0000 -789.46 3094.35 0.255 957.845 K=1.00 KL/R > 200 (C) - 203 L4 957.845 - 2x1/2 3.50 3.21 266.7 1.0000 -1064.94 3175.24 0.335 943.188 K=1.00 KL/R > 200 (C) - 305 ' P u / Op, controls Redundant Horizontal 1 Design Data Compression Section Elevation Size L L,, Kl/r A P op Ratio No. P ft ft ft in2 lb lb Opn T59 19.5 - 11 2L2x2xl/4x3/8 1.50 1.32 43.7 1.8800 -6588.24 55096.40 0.J120' K=1.00 Y 2L'a' > 7.6442 in - 1676 ' P u / �P, controls Redundant Diagonal 1 Design Data Compression Section Elevation Size L L,, Kl/r A P OP Ratio No. P ft ft ft in2 lb lb opn T59 19.5 - 11 2L2x2xl/4x3/8 4.51 3.97 103.9 1.8800 -10417.90 34491.10 0.302' K=1.00 Y 2L 'a' > 22.9681 in - 1677 ' P„ / �P,, controls Inner Bracing Design Data Compression Size L L„ KI1r A P„ OP Ratio Section Elevation No. P ft ft ft in2 lb lb OP. Ll 1016 - 996.615 5/8 1.75 1.75 94.1 0.3068 -41.96 6237.81 0.007' K=0.70 L2 996.615- 5/8 1.75 1.75 94.1 0.3068 -78.61 6237.81 0.013' 977.23 K=0.70 Y L3 977.23- 5/8 1.75 1.75 94.1 0.3068-114.24 6237.81 0.018' tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 68 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section Elevation Size L Ln KI1r A Pu OP Ratio No. P. ft ft ft in2 lb lb OPn 957.845 K=0.70 Y L4 957.845- 5/8 1.75 1.75 94.1 0.3068-520.56 6237.81 0.083 943.188 K=0.70 Y 1 P n / �Pn controls Tension Checks Leg Design Data Tension Section Elevation Size L Ln K11r A Pn oPn Ratio No. P ft ft ft inz lb lb OPn Ll 1016 - 996.615 2 19.38 1.84 44.2 3.1416 21439.40 141372.00 0.152' Y L2 996.615 - 2 19.38 1.62 38.8 3.1416 74376.70 141372.00 0.526' 977.23 L3 977.23 - 3 19.38 1.62 25.8 7.0686 162582.00 318086.00 0._5/11 957.845 Y L4 957.845- 3 1/2 14.66 1.62 22.2 9.6211 257371.00 432951.00 0.J59�4' 943.188 Y Tl 943.188- 3 1/2 3.69 3.69 50.6 9.6211 156762.00 432951.00 0.362' 939.5 T2 939.5 - 909.5 3 1/2 30.00 5.00 68.6 9.6211 251902.00 432951.00 0.582' V T3 909.5 - 894.5 3 1/4 15.00 5.00 73.8 8.2958 110095.00 373310.00 0.295' 4.8.1 (1.05 CR) - 425/2 T4 894.5 - 879.5 3 1/4 15.00 5.00 73.8 8.2958 79695.60 373310.00 0.213' V T5 879.5 - 859.5 3 20.00 5.00 80.0 7.0686 56231.80 318086.00 0.177' 4.8.1 (1.17 CR) - 467/3 T6 859.5 - 849.5 3 10.00 5.00 80.0 7.0686 29963.90 318086.00 0.094 4.8.1 (1.12 CR) - 494 T7 849.5 - 819.5 3 30.00 5.00 80.0 7.0686 19674.30 318086.00 0._0662' Y 4.8.1 (1.12 CR) - 509/5 T8 819.5 - 789.5 3 1/4 30.00 5.00 73.8 8.2958 368.21 373310.00 0.001 ' 4.8.1 (1.04 CR) - 548/5 T9 789.5 - 774.5 3 1/4 15.00 5.00 73.8 8.2958 16266.90 373310.00 0.044' 4.8.1 (1.16 CR) - 587 T10 774.5 - 759.5 3 1/4 15.00 5.00 73.8 8.2958 17527.90 373310.00 0._0447' Y 4.8.1 (1.24 CR) - 607/2 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 69 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 1 P n / �Pn controls Diagonal Design Data Tension Size L L„ KlIr A P„ Ratio Section Elevation OPn No. Pn ft ft ft in2 lb lb OPn Ll 1016 - 996.615 3/4 3.95 1.88 120.5 0.4418 2377.71 14313.90 0._1666' Y L2 996.615 - 7/8 3.85 1.84 100.7 0.6013 4990.25 19482.80 0._2/56 977.23 Y L3 977.23 - 1 3.85 1.79 85.9 0.7854 8169.94 25446.90 0.321 ' 957.845 Y L4 957.845 - 1 3.85 1.77 84.8 0.7854 10471.30 25446.90 0.411 ' 943.188 Tl 943.188 - 2L2 1/2x2x3/16x3/8 7.04 6.70 101.4 1.6200 19627.90 52488.00 0.374 939.5 2L 'a' > 32.4715 in - 384 T2 939.5 - 909.5 2 7.81 7.43 178.3 3.1416 26368.50 101788.00 0._2559 Y T3 909.5 - 894.5 2 7.81 7.46 179.0 3.1416 12829.30 101788.00 0.126 T4 894.5 - 879.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.46 204.6 2.4053 10364.30 77931.10 0.133' T5 879.5 - 859.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.48 205.3 2.4053 7778.05 77931.10 0._1000' Y T6 859.5 - 849.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.48 205.3 2.4053 5095.54 77931.10 0.065 T7 849.5 - 819.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.48 205.3 2.4053 4059.91 77931.10 0.0552' Y T8 819.5 - 789.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.46 204.6 2.4053 7106.39 77931.10 0._0991 ' Y T9 789.5 - 774.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.46 204.6 2.4053 9398.83 77931.10 0.121 T10 774.5 - 759.5 2 7.81 7.46 179.0 3.1416 15438.30 101788.00 0.1552' Y T11 759.5 - 729.5 2 7.81 7.46 179.0 3.1416 13713.00 101788.00 0.135' Y T12 729.5 - 699.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.46 204.6 2.4053 7609.94 77931.10 0.098, Y T13 699.5 - 679.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.43 203.8 2.4053 6628.22 77931.10 0.085 T14 679.5 - 669.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.43 203.8 2.4053 11398.20 77931.10 0.146 Y T15 669.5 - 664.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.43 203.8 2.4053 12091.20 77931.10 0._1555 Y T16 664.5 - 659.5 2 7.81 7.43 178.3 3.1416 13341.60 101788.00 0.131' T17 659.5 - 639.5 2 7.81 7.43 178.3 3.1416 17965.40 101788.00 0.176' Y T18 639.5 - 629.5 2 7.81 7.43 178.3 3.1416 19648.00 101788.00 0._1993' Y T19 629.5 - 609.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.43 203.8 2.4053 13568.10 77931.10 0.174' tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 70 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section No. Elevation ft Size L ft T20 609.5 - 579.5 1 3/4 7.81 T21 579.5 - 549.5 1 3/4 7.81 T22 549.5 - 519.5 1 3/4 7.81 T23 519.5 - 499.5 1 3/4 7.81 T24 499.5 - 489.5 2 7.81 T25 489.5 - 474.5 2 7.81 T26 474.5 - 459.5 1 3/4 7.81 T27 459.5 - 449.5 1 3/4 7.81 T28 449.5 - 429.5 1 3/4 7.81 T29 429.5 - 409.5 1 3/4 7.81 T30 409.5 - 399.5 1 3/4 7.81 T31 399.5 - 379.5 1 3/4 7.81 T32 379.5 - 369.5 2 7.81 T33 369.5 - 349.5 2 7.81 T34 349.5 - 339.5 2 7.81 T35 339.5 - 329.5 1 3/4 7.81 T36 329.5 - 309.5 1 3/4 7.81 T37 309.5 - 279.5 1 3/4 7.81 T38 279.5 - 264.5 1 3/4 7.81 T39 264.5 - 254.5 2 7.81 T40 254.5 - 249.5 2 7.81 T41 249.5 - 239.5 2 7.81 T42 239.5 - 229.5 2 1 /4 7.81 T43 229.5 - 219.5 2 1 /4 7.81 T44 219.5 - 194.5 2 7.81 T45 194.5 - 189.5 1 3/4 7.81 L K11r A P OP Ratio P. ft in2 lb lb OP, Y 7.43 203.8 2.4053 9989.57 77931.10 0.1228' Y 7.43 203.8 2.4053 5092.34 77931.10 0.065' Y 7.43 203.8 2.4053 10539.40 77931.10 0._1335' Y 7.43 203.8 2.4053 14058.60 77931.10 0.180, Y 7.43 178.3 3.1416 14285.80 101788.00 0.140' Y 7.43 178.3 3.1416 9599.66 101788.00 0._0994' Y 7.43 203.8 2.4053 7078.61 77931.10 0.0991 ' Y 7.43 203.8 2.4053 3454.18 77931.10 0.044 Y 7.43 203.8 2.4053 1763.47 77931.10 0._0223 Y 7.43 203.8 2.4053 5224.18 77931.10 0.0667 Y 7.43 203.8 2.4053 7253.81 77931.10 0.093' Y 7.40 203.1 2.4053 10646.30 77931.10 0._1337' Y 7.40 177.7 3.1416 12414.50 101788.00 0.122' 7.40 177.7 3.1416 18080.20 101788.00 0.178' Y 7.40 177.7 3.1416 11264.40 101788.00 0._1111 ' Y 7.40 203.1 2.4053 8919.54 77931.10 0.114' 7.40 203.1 2.4053 6746.39 77931.10 0.087' Y 7.40 203.1 2.4053 8239.25 77931.10 0._1006' Y 7.40 203.1 2.4053 11073.20 77931.10 0.1442' Y 7.40 177.7 3.1416 13262.10 101788.00 0.130' Y 7.38 177.2 3.1416 14635.60 101788.00 0._1444' Y 7.36 176.7 3.1416 16091.20 101788.00 0.1558' Y 7.36 157.1 3.9761 33976.40 128825.00 0.264' Y 7.36 157.1 3.9761 29784.10 128825.00 0.2311 Y 7.38 177.0 3.1416 19794.70 101788.00 0.1994' Y 7.38 202.3 2.4053 9785.57 77931.10 0.126' tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 71 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section Elevation Size L L K11r A Pu OP Ratio No. P. ft ft ft in2 lb lb OPn T46 189.5 - 179.5 13,4 7.81 7.38 202.3 2.4053 7499.03 77931.10 0.096' T47 179.5 - 159.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.38 202.3 2.4053 4025.69 77931.10 0.052 Y T48 159.5 - 129.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.38 202.3 2.4053 12001.20 77931.10 0._1554 Y T49 129.5 - 124.5 2 7.81 7.38 177.0 3.1416 17978.90 101788.00 0.1777' Y T50 124.5 - 119.5 2 7.81 7.38 177.0 3.1416 20027.10 101788.00 0.197' Y T51 119.5 - 114.5 2 1/4 7.81 7.38 157.4 3.9761 15948.00 128825.00 0._1224' Y T52 114.5 - 99.5 2 7.81 7.38 177.0 3.1416 15507.60 101788.00 0.1552' Y T53 99.5 - 79.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.35 201.6 2.4053 8316.75 77931.10 0.107' Y T54 79.5 - 69.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.35 201.6 2.4053 845.15 77931.10 0._0111 ' Y T55 69.5 - 59.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.35 201.6 2.4053 3747.40 77931.10 0.0448' Y T56 59.5 - 39.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.35 201.6 2.4053 10861.70 77931.10 0.139' Y T57 39.5 - 29.5 1 3/4 7.81 7.35 201.6 2.4053 13997.80 77931.10 0._1880' Y T58 29.5 - 19.5 2 7.81 7.35 176.4 3.1416 18449.30 101788.00 0.181 ' T59 19.5 - 11 2L3x2xl/4x3/8 9.01 8.48 114.2 2.3800 26056.30 77112.00 0.338' Y T60 11 - 0 1 1/2 4.77 4.19 134.0 1.7672 4806.96 57255.50 0._0884' Y ' P n / �Pn controls K-Brace Design Data Tension Section No. Elevation ft Size L ft Ln ft Kl/r A inz P. lb OP. lb Ratio P. OP. Ll 1016 - 996.615 3/4 2.22 2.12 135.4 0.4418 3009.90 14313.90 0.210' V L2 996.615 - 7/8 1.89 1.80 98.9 0.6013 4801.21 19482.80 0.246' 977.23 L3 977.23 - 1 1.89 1.76 84.4 0.7854 6945.48 25446.90 0._27/3 ' 957.845 Y L4 957.845 - 1 1.92 1.76 84.4 0.7854 11821.90 25446.90 0.465 ' 943.188 Y tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 72 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 ' P u / �P„ controls Horizontal Design Data Tension Size L G„ Kl/r A P. Ratio Section Elevation OP„ No. P ft it ft in2 lb lb opn T2 939.5 - 909.5 2 6.00 5.71 137.0 3.1416 4817.22 101788.00 0._0447' Y T3 909.5 - 894.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.73 157.1 2.4053 4573.56 77931.10 0.059 T4 894.5 - 879.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.73 157.1 2.4053 4287.95 77931.10 0.055' Y T5 879.5 - 859.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.75 157.7 2.4053 4057.29 77931.10 0._0552' Y T6 859.5 - 849.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.75 184.0 1.7672 3870.92 57255.50 0.068 T7 849.5 - 819.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.75 184.0 1.7672 3890.04 57255.50 0.068' Y T8 819.5 - 789.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.73 183.3 1.7672 4528.17 57255.50 0._0779 Y T9 789.5 - 774.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.73 157.1 2.4053 5033.29 77931.10 0.065 T10 774.5 - 759.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.73 157.1 2.4053 5366.13 77931.10 0.069 Y T11 759.5 - 729.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.73 157.1 2.4053 5092.53 77931.10 0._0665' Y T12 729.5 - 699.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.73 183.3 1.7672 4458.31 57255.50 0.078 T13 699.5 - 679.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.71 182.7 1.7672 4206.79 57255.50 0.073' Y T14 679.5 - 669.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 156.6 2.4053 4287.44 77931.10 0._0555' Y T17 659.5 - 639.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 156.6 2.4053 4830.38 77931.10 0.062 T18 639.5 - 629.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 156.6 2.4053 5095.79 77931.10 0.065' T19 629.5 - 609.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 156.6 2.4053 5138.06 77931.10 0._0666' Y T20 609.5 - 579.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 156.6 2.4053 4118.86 77931.10 0.053 T21 579.5 - 549.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.71 182.7 1.7672 3702.95 57255.50 0.0665' Y T22 549.5 - 519.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.71 182.7 1.7672 3556.75 57255.50 0._0662 Y T23 519.5 - 499.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 156.6 2.4053 4475.01 77931.10 0.057 T25 489.5 - 474.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 156.6 2.4053 4713.42 77931.10 0.0660' Y T26 474.5 - 459.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 156.6 2.4053 4395.48 77931.10 0._0556 Y T27 459.5 - 449.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 156.6 2.4053 4174.20 77931.10 0.054 T28 449.5 - 429.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.71 182.7 1.7672 4218.74 57255.50 0.074' tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 73 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section Elevation Size L Lu K11r A Pu OP Ratio No. P. ft ft ft in lb lb OPn T29 429.5 - 409.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.71 182.7 1.7672 4546.31 57255.50 0.0779 Y T30 409.5 - 399.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 156.6 2.4053 4819.69 77931.10 0.062' Y T31 399.5 - 379.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.69 156.0 2.4053 5547.30 77931.10 0.0711 Y T32 379.5 - 369.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.69 156.0 2.4053 5994.16 77931.10 0.077' T33 369.5 - 349.5 2 6.00 5.69 136.5 3.1416 6228.07 101788.00 0.061 Y T34 349.5 - 339.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.69 156.0 2.4053 5339.51 77931.10 0._06691 Y T35 339.5 - 329.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.69 156.0 2.4053 4901.23 77931.10 0.063 ' T36 329.5 - 309.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.69 182.0 1.7672 4824.70 57255.50 0.084 Y T37 309.5 - 279.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.69 182.0 1.7672 4817.11 57255.50 0._0884 Y T38 279.5 - 264.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.69 156.0 2.4053 4837.45 77931.10 0.0621 Y T39 264.5 - 254.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.69 156.0 2.4053 5286.40 77931.10 0.068' Y T41 249.5 - 239.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.66 155.1 2.4053 6277.96 77931.10 0._0881 Y T42 239.5 - 229.5 2 6.00 5.66 135.8 3.1416 6106.57 101788.00 0.060 T43 229.5 - 219.5 2 6.00 5.66 135.8 3.1416 5376.59 101788.00 0.053 Y T44 219.5 - 194.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.67 155.4 2.4053 6673.69 77931.10 0._0886 Y T46 189.5 - 179.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.67 155.4 2.4053 7146.17 77931.10 0.0921 Y T47 179.5 - 159.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.67 181.3 1.7672 7353.59 57255.50 0.128 Y T48 159.5 - 129.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.67 181.3 1.7672 7306.77 57255.50 0.1281 Y T52 114.5 - 99.5 2 6.00 5.67 136.0 3.1416 7181.80 101788.00 0.0711 T53 99.5 - 79.5 2 6.00 5.65 135.5 3.1416 7778.40 101788.00 0.076 Y T54 79.5 - 69.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.65 154.9 2.4053 7888.86 77931.10 0._1001 Y T55 69.5 - 59.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.65 154.9 2.4053 7874.65 77931.10 0.1001 ' Y T56 59.5 - 39.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.65 180.7 1.7672 7805.13 57255.50 0.136' Y T57 39.5 - 29.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.65 180.7 1.7672 7340.04 57255.50 0._1228 Y T58 29.5 - 19.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.65 180.7 1.7672 7340.04 57255.50 0.128 T60 11 - 0 1 1/2 6.00 5.65 180.7 1.7672 63685.20 57255.50 1.112' tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 74 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section Elevation Size L L, KI/r A Pu OPn Ratio No. P ft ft ft n' lb lb OPn 4.8.1 (1.11 CR) - 1689 1 P u / OP controls Top Girt Design Data Tension Size L Lu KI/r A P Ratio Section Elevation opn No. P ft ft ft inz lb lb OPn Ll 1016 - 996.615 2x1/2 3.50 1.67 138.6 1.0000 514.57 32400.00 0.016' V L2 996.615 - 2x1/2 3.50 1.67 138.6 1.0000 2709.52 32400.00 0.084' 977.23 L3 977.23 - 2x1/2 3.50 1.63 135.1 1.0000 4913.20 32400.00 0._1/52' 957.845 Y L4 957.845 - 2x1/2 3.50 1.60 133.4 1.0000 7078.40 32400.00 0.218' 943.188 Y T1 943.188 - MC18x58 6.00 5.71 67.2 17.1000 24529.80 554040.00 0.044' 939.5 T2 939.5 - 909.5 2 6.00 5.71 137.0 3.1416 753.85 101788.00 0.007' T3 909.5 - 894.5 2 6.00 5.71 137.0 3.1416 652.82 101788.00 0.006' T4 894.5 - 879.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.73 157.1 2.4053 739.73 77931.10 0.009, Y T5 879.5 - 859.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.73 157.1 2.4053 797.08 77931.10 0.010' T6 859.5 - 849.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.75 157.7 2.4053 735.30 77931.10 0.009' T7 849.5 - 819.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.75 184.0 1.7672 741.29 57255.50 0._0113' Y T8 819.5 - 789.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.75 184.0 1.7672 783.44 57255.50 0.014' T9 789.5 - 774.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.73 157.1 2.4053 817.41 77931.10 0.0110' Y T10 774.5 - 759.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.73 157.1 2.4053 791.02 77931.10 0._0110' Y T11 759.5 - 729.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.73 157.1 2.4053 1036.89 77931.10 0.013 ' T12 729.5 - 699.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.73 157.1 2.4053 1147.84 77931.10 0.0115' Y T13 699.5 - 679.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.73 183.3 1.7672 1403.06 57255.50 0._0225' Y T14 679.5-669.5 11/2 6.00 5.71 182.7 1.7672 1413.99 57255.50 0.025' T15 669.5 - 664.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 156.6 2.4053 1295.35 77931.10 0.017' T16 664.5 - 659.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 156.6 2.4053 1340.06 77931.10 0._0117' Y tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 75 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section Elevation Size L L, K11r A Pu OP Ratio No. P ft ft ft in2 lb lb OPn T17 659.5 - 639.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 156.6 2.4053 1281.46 77931.10 0.016 T18 639.5 - 629.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 156.6 2.4053 1249.17 77931.10 0.016 Y T20 609.5 - 579.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 156.6 2.4053 1462.75 77931.10 0.019, Y T21 579.5 - 549.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.71 182.7 1.7672 1494.44 57255.50 0.0226' Y T22 549.5 - 519.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.71 182.7 1.7672 1464.11 57255.50 0.026' Y T23 519.5 - 499.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 156.6 2.4053 1398.85 77931.10 0.018, Y T24 499.5 - 489.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 156.6 2.4053 1288.96 77931.10 0.0117' Y T25 489.5 - 474.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 156.6 2.4053 1340.13 77931.10 0.017' Y T26 474.5 - 459.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 156.6 2.4053 1521.33 77931.10 0._0220' Y T27 459.5 - 449.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 156.6 2.4053 1975.85 77931.10 0.0225' Y T28 449.5 - 429.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 156.6 2.4053 1601.37 77931.10 0.021 ' Y T29 429.5 - 409.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.71 182.7 1.7672 1569.12 57255.50 0._0227 ' Y T30 409.5 - 399.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 156.6 2.4053 1555.92 77931.10 0.020' T31 399.5 - 379.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.71 156.6 2.4053 1637.54 77931.10 0.0211 Y T32 379.5 - 369.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.69 156.0 2.4053 1696.17 77931.10 0._0222' Y T33 369.5 - 349.5 2 6.00 5.69 136.5 3.1416 1552.52 101788.00 0.015' T34 349.5 - 339.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.69 156.0 2.4053 2714.75 77931.10 0.035' Y T35 339.5 - 329.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.69 156.0 2.4053 2051.86 77931.10 0._0226' Y T36 329.5 - 309.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.69 156.0 2.4053 2058.03 77931.10 0.026' T37 309.5 - 279.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.69 182.0 1.7672 2470.16 57255.50 0.043' Y T38 279.5 - 264.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.69 182.0 1.7672 2042.65 57255.50 0._0336' Y T39 264.5 - 254.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.69 156.0 2.4053 2023.95 77931.10 0.0226' Y T40 254.5 - 249.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.69 156.0 2.4053 1901.20 77931.10 0.024' Y T41 249.5 - 239.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.66 155.1 2.4053 1870.41 77931.10 0._0224' Y T43 229.5 - 219.5 2 6.00 5.66 135.8 3.1416 3110.34 101788.00 0.031 ' T44 219.5 - 194.5 2 6.00 5.66 135.8 3.1416 5309.42 101788.00 0.052' Y tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 76 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section Elevation Size L L„ K11r A Pu OP Ratio No. Pu ft ft ft in2 lb lb Opu T45 194.5 - 189.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.67 155.4 2.4053 3019.61 77931.10 0.039 T46 189.5 - 179.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.67 155.4 2.4053 2930.62 77931.10 0.038' Y T47 179.5 - 159.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.67 181.3 1.7672 2950.17 57255.50 0._0552' Y T48 159.5 - 129.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.67 181.3 1.7672 2968.25 57255.50 0.0552' Y T49 129.5 - 124.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.67 155.4 2.4053 5087.96 77931.10 0.065' Y T50 124.5 - 119.5 2 6.00 5.67 136.0 3.1416 2595.34 101788.00 0._0225' Y T52 114.5 - 99.5 2 6.00 5.67 136.0 3.1416 2796.50 101788.00 0.0227' Y T53 99.5 - 79.5 2 6.00 5.67 136.0 3.1416 3307.17 101788.00 0.032 Y T54 79.5 - 69.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.65 154.9 2.4053 3473.58 77931.10 0._0445 Y T55 69.5 - 59.5 1 3/4 6.00 5.65 154.9 2.4053 3441.18 77931.10 0.0444 Y T56 59.5 - 39.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.65 180.7 1.7672 3371.38 57255.50 0.059 Y T57 39.5 - 29.5 1 1/2 6.00 5.65 180.7 1.7672 3260.97 57255.50 0._0557 Y T59 19.5 - 11 2L3x2xl/4x3/8 6.00 4.23 57.0 2.3800 14534.20 77112.00 0.188' V 2L 'a' > 18.6056 in - 1665 1 P u / op. controls Bottom Girt Design Data Tension Section Elevation Size L L,, Klh. A Pu OP. Ratio No. Pu ft ft ft inz lb lb op, Ll 1016 - 996.615 2x1/2 3.50 1.67 138.6 1.0000 2294.42 32400.00 0.071 L2 996.615 - 2x1/2 977.23 L3 977.23 - 2x1/2 957.845 L4 957.845 - 12xl 943.188 1 P u / �Pu controls V 3.50 1.67 138.6 1.0000 4308.23 32400.00 0.'1333 Y 3.50 1.63 135.1 1.0000 6350.51 32400.00 0._1996' Y 3.50 1.60 66.7 12.0000 35183.50 388800.00 0._0990 Y tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 77 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed by Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX- (781) 273-3311 Mid Girt Design Data Tension Size L L Kl/r A P Ratio Section Elevation OP No. P. ft ft ft in2 lb lb OPn Ll 1016 - 996.615 2x1/2 3.50 3.33 277.1 1.0000 78.36 32400.00 0.002 V L2 996.615- 2x1/2 3.50 3.33 277.1 1.0000 510.20 32400.00 0.016' 977.23 V L3 977.23 - 2xl/2 3.50 3.25 270.2 1.0000 877.45 32400.00 0.027' 957.845 V L4 957.845 - 2x1/2 3.50 3.21 266.7 1.0000 1190.40 32400.00 0.037' 943.188 i ' P u / �P„ controls Redundant Horizontal 1 Design Data Tension Section Elevation Size L Ln Kl/r A Pn op Ratio No. P. ft ft ft in2 lb lb opn T59 19.5 - 11 2L2x2xl/4x3/8 1.50 1.32 26.1 1.8800 6588.24 60912.00 0.108' Y 2L 'a' > 7.6442 in - 1676 ' P, / OPn controls Redundant Diagonal 1 Design Data Tension Section Elevation Size L L Kl/r A P +P Ratio No. P ft ft ft in2 lb lb OPn T59 19.5 - 11 2L2x2xl/4x3/8 4.51 3.97 78.3 1.8800 10417.90 60912.00 0.1771' Y 2L 'a' > 22.9681 in - 1680 ' P n / OPn controls Inner Bracing Design Data Tension Size L L Kl/r A P Ratio Section Elevation OPn No. P. ft ft ft in2 lb lb OPn Ll 1016 - 996.615 5/8 1.75 1.75 134.4 0.3068 41.96 9940.20 0.004' V L2 996.615- 5/8 1.75 1.75 134.4 0.3068 78.61 9940.20 0.008' tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 78 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section Elevation Size L L„ K11r A Pu OP Ratio No. Pu ft ft ft in lb lb Opn 977.23 Y L3 977.23- 5/8 1.75 1.75 134.4 0.3068 114.24 9940.20 0.011 957.845 Y L4 957.845- 5/8 1.75 1.75 134.4 0.3068 520.56 9940.20 0.J0�52 943.188 Y 1 P u / op. controls Top Guy Pull -Off Design Data Tension Size L L„ Kl/r A Pu Ratio OPn Section Elevation No. Pu ft ft ft in2 lb lb Opn T2 939.5 - 909.5 2C6x8.2x0.375 6.00 5.71 77.7 3.1500 55392.30 137025.00 0.404 T10 774.5 - 759.5 2C6x8.2x0.375 6.00 5.73 78.0 3.1500 35153.70 137025.00 0.257 Y T19 629.5 - 609.5 2C6x8.2x0.375 6.00 5.71 77.7 3.1500 37526.40 137025.00 0._2774' Y T24 499.5 - 489.5 2C6x8.2x0.375 6.00 5.71 77.7 3.1500 28994.40 137025.00 0.212 T33 369.5 - 349.5 2C6x8.2x0.375 6.00 5.69 77.4 3.1500 32020.10 137025.00 0.234' Y T42 239.5 - 229.5 2C6x8.2x0.375 6.00 5.66 77.0 3.1500 45581.00 137025.00 0._3333 ' Y T51 119.5 - 114.5 2C6x8.2x0.375 6.00 5.67 77.2 3.1500 37847.80 137025.00 0.276 V 1 P u / �Pn controls Section Capacity Table Section No. Elevation ft Component Type Size Critical Element P lb aP.11- lb % Capacity Pass Fail Ll 1016 - 996.615 Latticed Pole Leg 2 1 -21842.60 122252.00 17.9 Pass L2 996.615 - 977.23 Latticed Pole Leg 2 91 -73564.60 126314.00 58.2 Pass L3 977.23 - 957.845 Latticed Pole Leg 3 193 -159829.00 301795.00 53.0 Pass L4 957.845- Latticed Pole Leg 3 1/2 295 -253458.00 416185.00 60.9 Pass 943.188 Ll 1016 - 996.615 Latticed Pole 3/4 27 -2324.71 9310.66 25.0 Pass Diagonal L2 996.615 - 977.23 Latticed Pole 7/8 117 -4877.91 12999.20 37.5 Pass Diagonal L3 977.23 - 957.845 Latticed Pole 1 219 -8033.15 17747.30 45.3 Pass Diagonal L4 957.845- Latticed Pole 1 321 -10122.20 17820.90 56.8 Pass 943.188 Diagonal Ll 1016 - 996.615 Latticed Pole 3/4 17 -2975.69 8917.06 33.4 Pass tnxTower Job e Page Alpine Broadcasting 79 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b 5 y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section No. Elevation ft Component Type Size Critical Element P lb Opal- lb % Capacity Pass Fail K-Brace L2 996.615 - 977.23 Latticed Pole 7/8 107 -4750.15 13332.40 35.6 Pass K-Brace L3 977.23 - 957.845 Latticed Pole 1 209 -6886.91 17919.70 38.4 Pass K-Brace L4 957.845- Latticed Pole 1 312 -11025.50 17922.30 61.5 Pass 943.188 K-Brace Ll 1016 - 996.615 Latticed Pole Top 2xl/2 6 -505.47 11766.30 4.3 Pass Girt L2 996.615 - 977.23 Latticed Pole Top 2xl/2 96 -2546.23 11766.30 21.6 Pass Girt L3 977.23 - 957.845 Latticed Pole Top 2xl/2 198 -4912.94 12377.40 39.7 Pass Girt L4 957.845- Latticed Pole Top 2xl/2 300 -7267.63 12702.20 57.2 Pass 943.188 Girt L1 1016-996.615 Latticed Pole Bottom 2xl/2 9 -2422.71 11766.30 20.6 Pass Girt L2 996.615 - 977.23 Latticed Pole Bottom 2xl/2 99 -4538.75 11766.30 38.6 Pass Girt L3 977.23 - 957.845 Latticed Pole Bottom 2xl/2 201 -6595.75 12377.40 53.3 Pass Girt L4 957.845- Latticed Pole Bottom 12xl 301 -30054.60 307652.00 9.8 Pass 943.188 Girt Ll 1016 - 996.615 Latticed Pole Mid 2xl/2 11 -74.06 2941.57 2.5 Pass Girt L2 996.615 - 977.23 Latticed Pole Mid 2xl/2 101 -459.93 2941.57 15.6 Pass Girt L3 977.23 - 957.845 Latticed Pole Mid 2xl/2 203 -789.46 3094.35 25.5 Pass Girt L4 957.845- Latticed Pole Mid 2xl/2 305 -1064.94 3175.24 33.5 Pass 943.188 Girt L1 1016 - 996.615 Latticed Pole Inner 5/8 20 -41.96 6237.81 0.7 Pass Bracing L2 996.615 - 977.23 Latticed Pole Inner 5/8 110 -78.61 6237.81 1.3 Pass Bracing L3 977.23 - 957.845 Latticed Pole Inner 5/8 212 -114.24 6237.81 1.8 Pass Bracing L4 957.845- Latticed Pole Inner 5/8 313 -520.56 6237.81 8.3 Pass 943.188 Bracing Tl 943.188 - 939.5 Leg 3 1/2 378 -159453.00 359092.00 44.4 Pass T2 939.5 - 909.5 Leg 3 1/2 385 -278122.00 306993.00 90.6 Pass T3 909.5 - 894.5 Leg 3 1/4 424 -264054.00 250556.00 105.4 Fail K T4 894.5 - 879.5 Leg 3 1/4 445 -247565.00 250556.00 98.8 Pass T5 879.5 - 859.5 Leg 3 466 -234248.00 199213.00 117.6 Fail + T6 859.5 - 849.5 Leg 3 493 -223488.00 199213.00 112.2 Fail + T7 849.5 - 819.5 Leg 3 508 -224591.00 199213.00 112.7 Fail + T8 819.5 - 789.5 Leg 3 1/4 547 -261434.00 250556.00 104.3 Fail + T9 789.5 - 774.5 Leg 3 1/4 586 -290597.00 250556.00 116.0 Fail + T10 774.5 - 759.5 Leg 3 1/4 607 -309814.00 250556.00 123.7 Fail + Tl1 759.5 - 729.5 Leg 3 1/4 628 -294017.00 250556.00 117.3 Fail + T12 729.5 - 699.5 Leg 3 1/4 667 -257401.00 250556.00 102.7 Fail + T13 699.5 - 679.5 Leg 3 1/2 707 -242879.00 306993.00 79.1 Pass T14 679.5 - 669.5 Leg 3 1/2 733 -247536.00 306993.00 80.6 Pass T15 669.5 - 664.5 Leg 3 1/2 749 -252735.00 306993.00 82.3 Pass T16 664.5 - 659.5 Leg 3 1/2 757 -255505.00 306993.00 83.2 Pass T17 659.5 - 639.5 Leg 3 1/2 766 -278882.00 306993.00 90.8 Pass T18 639.5 - 629.5 Leg 3 1/2 794 -294206.00 306993.00 95.8 Pass T19 629.5 - 609.5 Leg 3 1/2 809 -296646.00 306993.00 96.6 Pass T20 609.5 - 579.5 Leg 3 1/2 836 -237802.00 306993.00 77.5 Pass tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 80 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section No. Elevation ft Component Type Size Critical Element P lb Opal- lb % Capacity Pass Fail T21 579.5 - 549.5 Leg 3 1/2 876 -213790.00 306993.00 69.6 Pass T22 549.5 - 519.5 Leg 3 1/2 915 -205349.00 306993.00 66.9 Pass T23 519.5 - 499.5 Leg 3 1/2 954 -258365.00 306993.00 84.2 Pass T24 499.5 - 489.5 Leg 3 1/2 981 -281843.00 306993.00 91.8 Pass T25 489.5 - 474.5 Leg 3 1/2 996 -272129.00 306993.00 88.6 Pass T26 474.5 - 459.5 Leg 3 1/2 1017 -253773.00 306993.00 82.7 Pass T27 459.5 - 449.5 Leg 3 1/2 1038 -240997.00 306993.00 78.5 Pass T28 449.5 - 429.5 Leg 3 1/2 1053 -243569.00 306993.00 79.3 Pass T29 429.5 - 409.5 Leg 3 1/2 1080 -262481.00 306993.00 85.5 Pass T30 409.5 - 399.5 Leg 3 1/2 1107 -278265.00 306993.00 90.6 Pass T31 399.5 - 379.5 Leg 3 3/4 1122 -320274.00 368382.00 86.9 Pass T32 379.5 - 369.5 Leg 3 3/4 1149 -346073.00 368382.00 93.9 Pass T33 369.5 - 349.5 Leg 3 3/4 1164 -359578.00 368382.00 97.6 Pass T34 349.5 - 339.5 Leg 3 3/4 1191 -308277.00 368382.00 83.7 Pass T35 339.5 - 329.5 Leg 3 3/4 1206 -282973.00 368382.00 76.8 Pass T36 329.5 - 309.5 Leg 3 3/4 1219 -278554.00 368382.00 75.6 Pass T37 309.5 - 279.5 Leg 3 3/4 1246 -278116.00 368382.00 75.5 Pass T38 279.5 - 264.5 Leg 3 3/4 1285 -279290.00 368382.00 75.8 Pass T39 264.5 - 254.5 Leg 3 3/4 1306 -305211.00 368382.00 82.9 Pass T40 254.5 - 249.5 Leg 3.75" SR with half pipe 1321 -324322.00 431239.00 75.2 Pass T41 249.5 - 239.5 Leg 3.75" SR with half pipe 1330 -362458.00 431239.00 84.1 Pass T42 239.5 - 229.5 Leg 3.75" SR with half pipe 1345 -352563.00 431239.00 81.8 Pass T43 229.5 - 219.5 Leg 3.75" SR with half pipe 1360 -310418.00 431239.00 72.0 Pass T44 219.5 - 194.5 Leg 4 1377 -385306.00 434617.00 88.7 Pass T45 194.5 - 189.5 Leg 4 1410 -394049.00 434617.00 90.7 Pass T46 189.5 - 179.5 Leg 4 1419 -412584.00 434617.00 94.9 Pass T47 179.5 - 159.5 Leg 4 1434 -424560.00 434617.00 97.7 Pass T48 159.5 - 129.5 Leg 4 1461 -421857.00 434617.00 97.1 Pass T49 129.5 - 124.5 Leg 4 1499 -373340.00 434617.00 85.9 Pass T50 124.5 - 119.5 Leg 4 1507 -359031.00 434617.00 82.6 Pass T51 119.5 - 114.5 Leg 4 1516 -371442.00 434617.00 85.5 Pass T52 114.5 - 99.5 Leg 4 1526 -414641.00 434617.00 95.4 Pass T53 99.5 - 79.5 Leg 4 1/4 1547 -449086.00 505612.00 88.8 Pass T54 79.5 - 69.5 Leg 4 1/4 1574 -455463.00 505612.00 90.1 Pass T55 69.5 - 59.5 Leg 4 1/4 1589 -454643.00 505612.00 89.9 Pass T56 59.5 - 39.5 Leg 4 1/4 1605 -450629.00 505612.00 89.1 Pass T57 39.5 - 29.5 Leg 4 1/4 1632 -423777.00 505612.00 83.8 Pass T58 29.5 - 19.5 Leg 4 1/4 1647 -400366.00 505612.00 79.2 Pass T59 19.5 - 11 Leg 4 1/4 1662 -380372.00 535079.00 71.1 Pass T60 11 - 0 Leg 4 1/2 1686 -375836.00 610837.00 61.5 Pass Tl 943.188 - 939.5 Diagonal 2L2 1/2x2x3/16x3/8 384 -19628.30 24212.80 81.1 Pass T2 939.5 - 909.5 Diagonal 2 405 -26093.20 44813.30 58.2 Pass T3 909.5 - 894.5 Diagonal 2 443 -13659.20 44545.20 30.7 Pass T4 894.5 - 879.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 465 -11415.20 26502.90 43.1 Pass T5 879.5 - 859.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 491 -8918.15 26311.20 33.9 Pass T6 859.5 - 849.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 506 -6151.15 26311.20 23.4 Pass T7 849.5 - 819.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 545 -4893.70 26311.20 18.6 Pass T8 819.5 - 789.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 555 -8547.80 26502.90 32.3 Pass T9 789.5 - 774.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 594 -10557.20 26502.90 39.8 Pass T10 774.5 - 759.5 Diagonal 2 621 -16559.60 44545.20 37.2 Pass T11 759.5 - 729.5 Diagonal 2 666 -15214.90 44545.20 34.2 Pass T12 729.5 - 699.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 704 -9580.04 26502.90 36.1 Pass T13 699.5 - 679.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 714 -8604.79 26696.70 32.2 Pass T14 679.5 - 669.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 741 -13123.90 26696.70 49.2 Pass T15 669.5 - 664.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 756 -14173.80 26696.70 53.1 Pass T16 664.5 - 659.5 Diagonal 2 765 -15353.60 44813.30 34.3 Pass T17 659.5 - 639.5 Diagonal 2 774 -19942.30 44813.30 44.5 Pass T18 639.5 - 629.5 Diagonal 2 801 -21554.90 44813.30 48.1 Pass T19 629.5 - 609.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 833 -15747.20 26696.70 59.0 Pass T20 609.5 - 579.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 872 -12900.60 26696.70 48.3 Pass T21 579.5 - 549.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 911 -8103.58 26696.70 30.4 Pass tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 81 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section No. Elevation ft Component Type Size Critical Element P lb Opal- lb % Capacity Pass Fail T22 549.5 - 519.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 921 -12797.10 26696.70 47.9 Pass T23 519.5 - 499.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 960 -16167.70 26696.70 60.6 Pass T24 499.5 - 489.5 Diagonal 2 993 -17252.30 44813.30 38.5 Pass T25 489.5 - 474.5 Diagonal 2 1012 -12561.30 44813.30 28.0 Pass T26 474.5 - 459.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1033 -9774.03 26696.70 36.6 Pass T27 459.5 - 449.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1048 -6576.56 26696.70 24.6 Pass T28 449.5 - 429.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1059 -4474.05 26696.70 16.8 Pass T29 429.5 - 409.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1086 -8131.00 26696.70 30.5 Pass T30 409.5 - 399.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1113 -10218.30 26696.70 38.3 Pass T31 399.5 - 379.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1128 -14189.10 26892.60 52.8 Pass T32 379.5 - 369.5 Diagonal 2 1155 -15941.70 45081.90 35.4 Pass T33 369.5 - 349.5 Diagonal 2 1180 -21247.80 45081.90 47.1 Pass T34 349.5 - 339.5 Diagonal 2 1203 -15160.70 45081.90 33.6 Pass T35 339.5 - 329.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1218 -12740.80 26892.60 47.4 Pass T36 329.5 - 309.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1244 -10734.00 26892.60 39.9 Pass T37 309.5 - 279.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1252 -11628.50 26892.60 43.2 Pass T38 279.5 - 264.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1291 -15539.60 26892.60 57.8 Pass T39 264.5 - 254.5 Diagonal 2 1312 -17578.10 45081.90 39.0 Pass T40 254.5 - 249.5 Diagonal 2 1327 -18152.80 45283.90 40.1 Pass T41 249.5 - 239.5 Diagonal 2 1342 -19675.80 45486.10 43.3 Pass T42 239.5 - 229.5 Diagonal 2 1/4 1359 -37302.10 68171.40 54.7 Pass T43 229.5 - 219.5 Diagonal 2 1/4 1374 -34308.10 68171.40 50.3 Pass T44 219.5 - 194.5 Diagonal 2 1407 -25006.30 45351.20 55.1 Pass T45 194.5 - 189.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1414 -14286.50 27090.70 52.7 Pass T46 189.5 - 179.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1429 -13170.70 27090.70 48.6 Pass T47 179.5 - 159.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1456 -9553.27 27090.70 35.3 Pass T48 159.5 - 129.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1467 -15985.60 27090.70 59.0 Pass T49 129.5 - 124.5 Diagonal 2 1506 -24213.80 45351.20 53.4 Pass T50 124.5 - 119.5 Diagonal 2 1515 -24085.60 45351.20 53.1 Pass T51 119.5 - 114.5 Diagonal 2 1/4 1522 -22159.70 68011.60 32.6 Pass T52 114.5 - 99.5 Diagonal 2 1543 -19943.90 45351.20 44.0 Pass T53 99.5 - 79.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1570 -15403.00 27291.00 56.4 Pass T54 79.5 - 69.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1585 -8416.90 27291.00 30.8 Pass T55 69.5 - 59.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1602 -7607.21 27291.00 27.9 Pass T56 59.5 - 39.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1617 -14931.00 27291.00 54.7 Pass T57 39.5 - 29.5 Diagonal 1 3/4 1644 -18407.10 27291.00 67.4 Pass T58 29.5 - 19.5 Diagonal 2 1659 -21352.80 45621.10 46.8 Pass T59 19.5 - 11 Diagonal 2L3x2xl/4x3/8 1678 -26651.80 27021.10 98.6 Pass T60 11 - 0 Diagonal 1 1/2 1693 -17226.80 36035.10 47.8 Pass T2 939.5 - 909.5 Horizontal 2 396 -4817.22 62723.00 7.7 Pass T3 909.5 - 894.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 439 -4573.56 41216.10 11.1 Pass T4 894.5 - 879.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 454 -4287.95 41216.10 10.4 Pass T5 879.5 - 859.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 477 -4057.29 41025.20 9.9 Pass T6 859.5 - 849.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 502 -3870.92 23907.30 16.2 Pass T7 849.5 - 819.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 517 -3890.04 23907.30 16.3 Pass T8 819.5 - 789.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 556 -4528.17 24058.80 18.8 Pass T9 789.5 - 774.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 595 -5033.29 41216.10 12.2 Pass T10 774.5 - 759.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 616 -5366.13 41216.10 13.0 Pass Tl 1 759.5 - 729.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 637 -5092.53 41216.10 12.4 Pass T12 729.5 - 699.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 678 -4458.31 24058.80 18.5 Pass T13 699.5 - 679.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 716 -4206.79 24210.70 17.4 Pass T14 679.5 - 669.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 742 -4287.44 41407.10 10.4 Pass T17 659.5 - 639.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 775 -4830.38 41407.10 11.7 Pass T18 639.5 - 629.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 802 -5095.79 41407.10 12.3 Pass T19 629.5 - 609.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 817 -5138.06 41407.10 12.4 Pass T20 609.5 - 579.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 845 -4118.86 41407.10 9.9 Pass T21 579.5 - 549.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 884 -3702.95 24210.70 15.3 Pass T22 549.5 - 519.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 924 -3556.75 24210.70 14.7 Pass T23 519.5 - 499.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 968 -4475.01 41407.10 10.8 Pass T25 489.5 - 474.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1005 -4713.42 41407.10 11.4 Pass T26 474.5 - 459.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1025 -4395.48 41407.10 10.6 Pass tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 82 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section No. Elevation ft Component Type Size Critical Element P lb Opal- lb % Capacity Pass Fail T27 459.5 - 449.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1046 -4174.20 41407.10 10.1 Pass T28 449.5 - 429.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 1067 -4218.74 24210.70 17.4 Pass T29 429.5 - 409.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 1089 -4546.31 24210.70 18.8 Pass T30 409.5 - 399.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1115 -4819.69 41407.10 11.6 Pass T31 399.5 - 379.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1130 -5547.30 41598.30 13.3 Pass T32 379.5 - 369.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1158 -5994.16 41598.30 14.4 Pass T33 369.5 - 349.5 Horizontal 2 1172 -6228.07 62944.60 9.9 Pass T34 349.5 - 339.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1199 -5339.51 41598.30 12.8 Pass T35 339.5 - 329.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1214 -4901.23 41598.30 11.8 Pass T36 329.5 - 309.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 1228 -4824.70 24363.00 19.8 Pass T37 309.5 - 279.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 1261 -4817.11 24363.00 19.8 Pass T38 279.5 - 264.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1294 -4837.45 41598.30 11.6 Pass T39 264.5 - 254.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1317 -5286.40 41598.30 12.7 Pass T41 249.5 - 239.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1339 -6277.96 41885.50 15.0 Pass T42 239.5 - 229.5 Horizontal 2 1354 -6106.57 63277.00 9.7 Pass T43 229.5 - 219.5 Horizontal 2 1369 -5376.59 63277.00 8.5 Pass T44 219.5 - 194.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1385 -6673.69 41789.70 16.0 Pass T46 189.5 - 179.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1427 -7146.17 41789.70 17.1 Pass T47 179.5 - 159.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 1443 -7353.59 24515.70 30.0 Pass T48 159.5 - 129.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 1469 -7306.77 24515.70 29.8 Pass T52 114.5 - 99.5 Horizontal 2 1534 -7181.80 63166.20 11.4 Pass T53 99.5 - 79.5 Horizontal 2 1556 -7778.40 63387.80 12.3 Pass T54 79.5 - 69.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1582 -7888.86 41981.30 18.8 Pass T55 69.5 - 59.5 Horizontal 1 3/4 1597 -7874.65 41981.30 18.8 Pass T56 59.5 - 39.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 1613 -7805.13 24668.80 31.6 Pass T57 39.5 - 29.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 1640 -7340.04 24668.80 29.8 Pass T58 29.5 - 19.5 Horizontal 1 1/2 1649 -7340.04 24668.80 29.8 Pass T60 11 - 0 Horizontal 1 1/2 1689 63685.20 57255.50 111.2 Fail Tl 943.188 - 939.5 Top Girt MC18x58 381 24529.80 554040.00 4.4 Pass T2 939.5 - 909.5 Top Girt 2 390 -1054.52 62723.00 1.7 Pass T3 909.5 - 894.5 Top Girt 2 429 652.82 101788.00 0.6 Pass T4 894.5 - 879.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 450 739.73 77931.10 0.9 Pass T5 879.5 - 859.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 471 797.08 77931.10 1.0 Pass T6 859.5 - 849.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 498 735.30 77931.10 0.9 Pass T7 849.5 - 819.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 513 741.29 57255.50 1.3 Pass T8 819.5 - 789.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 552 783.44 57255.50 1.4 Pass T9 789.5 - 774.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 591 817.41 77931.10 1.0 Pass T10 774.5 - 759.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 611 791.02 77931.10 1.0 Pass Tl1 759.5 - 729.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 633 1036.89 77931.10 1.3 Pass T12 729.5 - 699.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 671 1147.84 77931.10 1.5 Pass T13 699.5 - 679.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 710 1403.06 57255.50 2.5 Pass T14 679.5 - 669.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 736 1413.99 57255.50 2.5 Pass T15 669.5 - 664.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 752 1295.35 77931.10 1.7 Pass T16 664.5 - 659.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 762 1340.06 77931.10 1.7 Pass T17 659.5 - 639.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 771 1281.46 77931.10 1.6 Pass T18 639.5 - 629.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 798 1249.17 77931.10 1.6 Pass T20 609.5 - 579.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 840 1462.75 77931.10 1.9 Pass T21 579.5 - 549.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 879 1494.44 57255.50 2.6 Pass T22 549.5 - 519.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 918 1464.11 57255.50 2.6 Pass T23 519.5 - 499.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 957 1398.85 77931.10 1.8 Pass T24 499.5 - 489.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 984 1288.96 77931.10 1.7 Pass T25 489.5 - 474.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 999 1340.13 77931.10 1.7 Pass T26 474.5 - 459.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1020 1521.33 77931.10 2.0 Pass T27 459.5 - 449.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1040 1975.85 77931.10 2.5 Pass T28 449.5 - 429.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1056 1601.37 77931.10 2.1 Pass T29 429.5 - 409.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 1083 1569.12 57255.50 2.7 Pass T30 409.5 - 399.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1110 1555.92 77931.10 2.0 Pass T31 399.5 - 379.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1125 1637.54 77931.10 2.1 Pass T32 379.5 - 369.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1152 1696.17 77931.10 2.2 Pass T33 369.5 - 349.5 Top Girt 2 1167 1552.52 101788.00 1.5 Pass T34 349.5 - 339.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1192 2714.75 77931.10 3.5 Pass tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 83 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section No. Elevation ft Component Type Size Critical Element P lb Opal- lb % Capacity Pass Fail T35 339.5 - 329.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1207 2051.86 77931.10 2.6 Pass T36 329.5 - 309.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1224 2058.03 77931.10 2.6 Pass T37 309.5 - 279.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 1250 2470.16 57255.50 4.3 Pass T38 279.5 - 264.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 1290 2042.65 57255.50 3.6 Pass T39 264.5 - 254.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1311 2023.95 77931.10 2.6 Pass T40 254.5 - 249.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1326 1901.20 77931.10 2.4 Pass T41 249.5 - 239.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1333 1870.41 77931.10 2.4 Pass T43 229.5 - 219.5 Top Girt 2 1365 3110.34 101788.00 3.1 Pass T44 219.5 - 194.5 Top Girt 2 1378 5309.42 101788.00 5.2 Pass T45 194.5 - 189.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1413 3019.61 77931.10 3.9 Pass T46 189.5 - 179.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1420 2930.62 77931.10 3.8 Pass T47 179.5 - 159.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 1435 2950.17 57255.50 5.2 Pass T48 159.5 - 129.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 1462 2968.25 57255.50 5.2 Pass T49 129.5 - 124.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1501 5087.96 77931.10 6.5 Pass T50 124.5 - 119.5 Top Girt 2 1512 2595.34 101788.00 2.5 Pass T52 114.5 - 99.5 Top Girt 2 1530 2796.50 101788.00 2.7 Pass T53 99.5 - 79.5 Top Girt 2 1549 3307.17 101788.00 3.2 Pass T54 79.5 - 69.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1576 3473.58 77931.10 4.5 Pass T55 69.5 - 59.5 Top Girt 1 3/4 1591 3441.18 77931.10 4.4 Pass T56 59.5 - 39.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 1606 3371.38 57255.50 5.9 Pass T57 39.5 - 29.5 Top Girt 1 1/2 1633 3260.97 57255.50 5.7 Pass T59 19.5 - 11 Top Girt 2L3x2xl/4x3/8 1665 -15674.80 47218.90 33.2 Pass T59 19.5 - 11 Redund Horz 1 2L2x2xl/4x3/8 1676 -6588.24 55096.40 12.0 Pass Bracing T59 19.5 - 11 Redund Diag 1 2L2x2xl/4x3/8 1677 -10417.90 34491.10 30.2 Pass Bracing T2 939.5 - 909.5 Guy A@919.5 1 5/8 1704 157484.00 194400.00 81.0 Pass T10 774.5 - 759.5 Guy A@769.5 1 1/4 1707 90265.90 115200.00 78.4 Pass T19 629.5 - 609.5 Guy A@629.5 1 3/16 1710 86385.50 103200.00 83.7 Pass T24 499.5 - 489.5 Guy A@494.5 1 1/4 1713 77168.60 115200.00 67.0 Pass T33 369.5 - 349.5 Guy A@364.5 1 1/4 1716 68552.70 115200.00 59.5 Pass T42 239.5 - 229.5 Guy A@239.5 1 1/4 1719 86228.90 115200.00 74.9 Pass T51 119.5 - 114.5 Guy A@119.5 1 1722 62368.00 73200.00 85.2 Pass T2 939.5 - 909.5 Guy B@919.5 1 5/8 1703 157605.00 194400.00 81.1 Pass T10 774.5 - 759.5 Guy B@769.5 1 1/4 1706 88807.00 115200.00 77.1 Pass T19 629.5 - 609.5 Guy B@629.5 1 3/16 1709 85033.00 103200.00 82.4 Pass T24 499.5 - 489.5 Guy B@494.5 1 1/4 1712 77443.90 115200.00 67.2 Pass T33 369.5 - 349.5 Guy B@364.5 1 1/4 1715 70864.00 115200.00 61.5 Pass T42 239.5 - 229.5 Guy B@239.5 1 1/4 1718 86608.20 115200.00 75.2 Pass T51 119.5 - 114.5 Guy B@119.5 1 1721 62081.00 73200.00 84.8 Pass T2 939.5 - 909.5 Guy C@919.5 1 518 1702 157504.00 194400.00 81.0 Pass T10 774.5 - 759.5 Guy C@769.5 1 1/4 1705 88833.70 115200.00 77.1 Pass T19 629.5 - 609.5 Guy C@629.5 1 3/16 1708 85116.30 103200.00 82.5 Pass T24 499.5 - 489.5 Guy C@494.5 1 1/4 1711 77618.60 115200.00 67.4 Pass T33 369.5 - 349.5 Guy C@364.5 1 1/4 1714 70707.30 115200.00 61.4 Pass T42 239.5 - 229.5 Guy C@239.5 1 1/4 1717 87006.30 115200.00 75.5 Pass T51 119.5 - 114.5 Guy C@119.5 1 1720 61609.00 73200.00 84.2 Pass T2 939.5 - 909.5 Top Guy 2C6x8.2x0.375 402 55392.30 137025.00 40.4 Pass Pull-Off@919.5 T10 774.5 - 759.5 Top Guy 2C6x8.2x0.375 624 35153.70 137025.00 25.7 Pass Pull-Off@769.5 T19 629.5 - 609.5 Top Guy 2C6x8.2x0.375 813 37526.40 137025.00 27.4 Pass Pull-Off@629.5 T24 499.5 - 489.5 Top Guy 2C6x8.2x0.375 988 28994.40 137025.00 21.2 Pass Pull-Off@494.5 T33 369.5 - 349.5 Top Guy 2C6x8.2x0.375 1185 32020.10 137025.00 23.4 Pass Pull-Off@364.5 T42 239.5 - 229.5 Top Guy 2C6x8.2x0.375 1350 45581.00 137025.00 33.3 Pass Pull-Off@239.5 T51 119.5 - 114.5 Top Guy 2C6x8.2x0.375 1521 37847.80 137025.00 27.6 Pass Pull-Off@119.5 tnxTower Job Page Alpine Broadcasting 84 of 84 EBI Consulting Project Date 21 B Street 8117000785 09:46:18 07/18/18 Burlington, MA 01803 Client Designed b g y Phone: (781) 273-2500 Verizon Wireless 1 kshanahan FAX.- (781) 273-3311 Section Elevation Component Size Critical P Opal— % Pass No. ft Type Element lb lb Capacity Fail Summary Latticed 60.9 Pass Pole Leg (L4) Latticed 56.8 Pass Pole Diagonal (L4) Latticed 61.5 Pass Pole K-Brace (L4) Latticed 57.2 Pass Pole Top Girt (L4) Latticed 53.3 Pass Pole Bottom Girt (L3) Latticed 33.5 Pass Pole Mid Girt (L4) Latticed 8.3 Pass Pole Inner Bracing (L4) Leg (T10) 123.7 Fail + Diagonal 98.6 Pass (T59) Horizontal 111.2 Fail + (T60) Top Girt 33.2 Pass (T59) Redund 12.0 Pass Horz 1 Bracing (T59) Redund 30.2 Pass Diag 1 Bracing (T59) Guy A (T51) 85.2 Pass Guy B(T51) 84.8 Pass Guy C (T51) 84.2 Pass Top Guy 40.4 Pass Pull -Off (T2) Bolt Checks 55.7 Pass RATING = 123.7 Fail K Program Version 7.0.8.5 - 9/29/2017 File:C:/Users/kshanahan/Documents/@JobsNZWNzW FL antmod 2017-18/Alpine Broadcasting - 8117000785/Structural/Alpine Broadcasting - tower analysis.eri 0 Sabre Industr jeS; TM Towers and Poles September 29, 2018 Erik Hamilton -Jones CAPITAL TELECOM 820 Morris Turnpike Suite 104 Short Hills, NJ 07078 RE: Proposed 220 ft Sabre Guyed Tower for Naples Park, FL Dear Mr. Hamilton -Jones, Upon receipt of order, we propose to design and supply a 220 ft guyed tower for the above referenced project for a Basic Wind Speed of 122 mph (158 mph Ultimate) with no ice, Structure Class II, Exposure B, Topographic Category 1 in accordance with the Telecommunications Industry Association Standard ANSUTIA-222-G, "Structural Standard for Antenna Supporting Structures and Antennas". When designed according to this Standard, the wind pressures and steel strength capacities include several safety factors, resulting in an overall minimum safety factor of 25%. Therefore, it is highly unlikely that the tower will fail structurally in a wind event where the design wind speed is exceeded within the range of the built-in safety factors. Should the wind speed increase beyond the capacity of the built-in safety factors, to the point of failure of one or more structural elements, the most likely location of the failure would be within one or more of the tower legs. This would result in a buckling failure mode, where the steel legs would bend beyond their elastic limit (beyond the point where the legs would return to their original shape upon removal of the wind load). Assuming that the wind pressure profile is similar to that used to design the tower, it is likely that the overall effect of such an extreme wind event would be localized buckling of a tower section, leading to an accordion -like collapse to the ground. Please note that this letter applies only to a tower designed and manufactured by Sabre Towers & Poles. This in turn would result in collapse to the ground within a radius equal 120 ft. Sincerely, Robert E. Beacom, P.E., S.E. Engineering Supervisor Sabre Towers and Poles • 7101 Southbridge Drive • P.O. Box 658 • Sioux City, IA 51102-0658 P: 712-258-6690 F: 712-279-0814 W: wvvw.SabreTowersandPoles.com Site Name: Address: Horizontal Datum Source: ENGINEERING GROUP, INC. Naples Park Relo Benton Road Naples, FL 34117 Collier County Ground Survey X GPS Survey (NAD83) Vertical Datum Source X NAVD 88 NGVD29 Structure Type: Proposed Guyed Tower Ground Elevation: 11.1' (AMSL) Top of Tower: 220.0' (AGL) Rad Center: 220.0' (AGL) Highest Appurtenance (L-Rod): 225.0' (AGL) CERTIFICATION: I certify that the Latitude of 26' 10' 45.836" North and the longitude of 81° 34' 16.987" West is accurate to within +/- 20 feet horizontally; and that the site elevation of 11.1' is accurate to within +/- 3 feet vertically. The horizontal datum (coordinates) is in terms of the North America Datum of 1983 (NAD83) and is expressed in degrees, minutes and seconds. The vertical datum (heights) is in terms of the North American Vertical Datum of 1988 (NAVD88). Decimal Format Latitude: 26.179399 Longitude:-81.571385 PARENT TRACT: (TITLE) Situated in the County of Collier, State of Florida Tract 122, Floridian Farm Sites, According to Map or Plat thereof as recorded in Plat Book 4, Page 33, Public Records of Collier County, Florida. 60' X 60' LEASE AREA: (AS SURVEYED) An lease area being a portion of Tafara Lodge, LLC, A Florida Limited Liability Company tract described as Tract 122 in Plat Book 4, Page 33 recorded in the Public Records Office in Collier County, Florida situated in the Northwest 1/4 of Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East in said County and being more particularly described as follows; COMMENCE at a 5/8" rebar found marking the Southwest corner of said Tract 122 and on the Easterly right-of-way line of Benton Road; Thence along said right-of-way line, N 00'52'46" E a distance of 122.87 feet to a point; Thence leaving said right-of-way line, N 90°00'00" E a distance of 100.00 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING; Thence N 00°00'00" W a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 90°00'00" E a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence S 00'00'00" E a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 90°00'00" W a distance of 60.00 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING. Containing 3,600 square feet (0.08 acres) of land more or less. 158 Business Center Drive • Birmingham, Alabama 35244 •Telephone: (205) 252-6985 www.smwenL.com ENGINEERING GROUP, INC. 20' INGRESS/EGRESS AND UTILITY EASEMENT: (AS SURVEYED) An easement being a portion of Tafara Lodge, LLC, A Florida Limited Liability Company tract described as Tract 122 in Plat Book 4, Page 33 recorded in the Public Records Office in Collier County, Florida situated in the Northwest 1/4 of Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East in said County and being more particularly described as follows; COMMENCE at a 5/8" rebar found marking the Southwest corner of said Tract 122 and on the Easterly right-of-way line of Benton Road; Thence along said right-of-way line, N 00°52'46" E a distance of 122.87 feet to a point; Thence leaving said right-of-way line, N 90°00'00" E a distance of 100.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 00°00'00" W a distance of 30.00 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING of an easement being 20 feet wide and lying 10 feet on each side of the following described centerline; Thence N 90°00'00" W a distance of 99.55 feet more or less, to a point on the Easterly right-of-way line of Benton Road (public right-of-way) and the POINT OF ENDING. Containing 1,991.03 square feet (0.05 acres) of land more or less. 30' GUY EASEMENT "A": (AS SURVEYED) An easement being a portion of Tafara Lodge, LLC, A Florida Limited Liability Company tract described as Tract 122 in Plat Book 4, Page 33 recorded in the Public Records Office in Collier County, Florida situated in the Northwest 1/4 of Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East in said County and being more particularly described as follows; COMMENCE at a 5/8" rebar found marking the Southwest corner of said Tract 122 and on the Easterly right-of-way line of Benton Road; Thence along said right-of-way line, N 00°52'46" E a distance of 122.87 feet to a point; Thence leaving said right-of-way line, N 90°00'00" E a distance of 100.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 00°00'00" W a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 90°00'00" E a distance of 12.68 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING of an easement being 30 feet wide and lying 15 feet on each side of the following described centerline; Thence N 30°00'00" W a distance of 101.22 feet to the POINT OF ENDING. Containing 3,078.08 square feet (0.07 acres) of land more or less. 30' GUY EASEMENT "B": (AS SURVEYED) An easement being a portion of Tafara Lodge, LLC, A Florida Limited Liability Company tract described as Tract 122 in Plat Book 4, Page 33 recorded in the Public Records Office in Collier County, Florida situated in the Northwest 1/4 of Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East in said County and being more particularly described as follows; COMMENCE at a 5/8" rebar found marking the Southwest corner of said Tract 122 and on the Easterly right-of-way line of Benton Road; Thence along said right-of-way line, N 00°52'46" E a distance of 122.87 feet to a point; Thence leaving said right-of-way line, N 90°00'00" E a distance of 100.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 00°00'00" W a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 90°00'00" E a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence S 00°00'00" E a distance of 30.00 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING of an easement being 30 feet wide and lying 15 feet on each side of the following described centerline; Thence N 90°00'00" E a distance of 106.04 feet to the POINT OF ENDING. Containing 3,180.00 square feet (0.07 acres) of land more or less. 30' GUY EASEMENT "C": (AS SURVEYED An easement being a portion of Tafara Lodge, LLC, A Florida Limited Liability Company tract described as Tract 122 in Plat Book 4, Page 33 recorded in the Public Records Office in Collier County, Florida situated in the Northwest 1/4 of Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East in said County and being more particularly described as follows; 158 Business Center Drive • Birmingham, Alabama 35244 •Telephone: (205) 252-6985 www.smwenL.com ENGINEERING GROUP, INC. COMMENCE at a 5/8" rebar found marking the Southwest corner of said Tract 122 and on the Easterly right-of-way line of Benton Road; Thence along said right-of-way line, N 00°52'46" E a distance of 122.87 feet to a point; Thence leaving said right-of-way line, N 90°00'00" E a distance of 100.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 00°00'00" W a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 90°00'00" E a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence S 00°00'00" E a distance of 60.00 feet to a set 5/8" rebar; Thence N 90°00'00" W a distance of 47.32 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING of an easement being 30 feet wide and lying 15 feet on each side of the following described centerline; Thence S 30°00'00" W a distance of 101.23 feet to the POINT OF ENDING. Containing 3,059.25 square feet (0.07 acres) of land more or less. 158 Business Center Drive • Birmingham, Alabama 35244 •Telephone: (205) 252-6985 www.smwenL.com R } f ; } k o 2 § 2 Ic o ƒ 3 a ,.: � ��v < w —•� K.aw v; � . v,3: > I Vicki Clark From: Jacob Douglas Sent: Tuesday, June 23, 2020 2:15 PM To: laura.dejohn@colliercountyfl.gov Cc: Ray.Bellows@colliercountyfl.gov; Heidi.Ashton@colliercountyfl.gov; Gilbert.Martinez@colliercountyfl.gov; Mattaniah Jahn; Vicki Clark Subject: Benton Road aka Capital Naples Park Communications Tower CU PL20180002327 Attachments: D00062320.pdf Good Afternoon Laura, I hope this email finds you well. Please find attached Capital Telecom's request that the hold on application PL20180002327 be extended. Should you have any questions please feel free to reach out. Best, Jacob Douglas Clerk/ Research Assistant %1A ([i l lc I I ll- Nlil till11hill S. ri Jahn.P. A. Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, PA 935 Main Street., Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 T: 727.773.2221 F: 727.773.2616 E: jdoulas@thelawmpowered.com NOTICE: This is privileged and confidential and intended only for those named to receive it. If you are not one of them, then any use, dissemination, distribution, reading, forwarding, printing, or copying of this is strictly prohibited, and you are requested to notify ME immediately by calling me collect at the number above or emailing me at the address above. DISCLAIMER: Although this email and any attachments are believed to be free of any VIRUS or other defect that might affect any computer system into which it is received and opened, it is the responsibility of the recipient to ensure that it is virus free and I accept no responsibility for any loss or damage. 1 935 Main Street, Suite D1 Safety Harbor, FL 34695 Telephone: (727) 773-2221 Facsimile: (727) 773-2616 SENT VIA EMAIL DELIVERY ONLY June 23, 2020 Laura DeJohn Collier County Growth Management Department 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 RE: Capital Telecom Holdings II, LLC — Naples Park PL420180002327 Request for Extension of Application Dear Ms. DeJohn: On behalf of my client, Capital Telecom Holdings II, LLC (Capital), please find a request to extend holds on application PL#20180002327 through December 23, 2020. Capital's research and negotiation efforts regarding access via Benton Road are ongoing but have been delayed due to the Covid-19 pandemic. Should the resolution efforts be delayed further, Capital anticipates that it will request additional hold time. Thank you in advance for your help with this project. Pleasefo not hesitate to contact me if I may provide you with additional information or to discuss this m ter in more detail. Sincerely, Mattaniah S. Jahn, Esq. MSJ/jpd Capital — Naples Park Vor- Diamond Communications LLC New Colocation/Attachment Application Part 1: Entity and Contact Information CARRIER INFORMATION Application Date: 12/20/2019 Company Name: New Cingular Wireless PCS, LLC. Legal Entity Name: New Cingular Wireless PCS, LLC. State of Incorporation: DE Notice Address: 575 Morosgo Drive, Suite 13-F West Tower, Attn: Network Real Estate Administration, Atlanta„ GA 303243300 Carrier Contact Name: Dianna Palmer Contact Title: Sr. Real Estate & Constr Manager Carrier Contact Email: dt2lO8@att.com Contact Phone: 561.212.1682 Carrier Contact Address: 1117 NE 3rd Avenue, Pompano Beach, FL 33060 LEASING AGENCY INFORMATION Manager Real Estate Contact Name: Amy Meek Contact Title: Administration Contact Email: am7132@att.com Contact Phone: 407.496.8002 Contact Address: 3210 Lake Emma Rd, Lake Mary, Florida 32746 Mail Documents To: 3210 Lake Emma Rd, Lake Mary, Florida 32746 Part 2: Structure / Property Information Diamond Site Name: Naples Park North Diamond Site Number: �FL 114 Site Address: 1710 Benton Road, Naples, FL 34117 Municipality/County: Collier Lot/Bock or Parcel ID: Latitude/Longitude: 26.1793889 /-81.5713889 Zoning District: DIAMOND COMMUNICATIONS COLLOCATION APPLICATION (01/16) DIAMONDCOMM.COM Property Owner: Owner Phone/Email: Owner Address: Part 3: Carrier Site Information Carrier Site Name: GG BLVD E Carrier Site Number: 10579184 BTA Name / Number: Call Signs: 704-710, 710-716, 716-722, 734-740, 740-746, 788- 758-768, 869-880, 890-891.5, 798, 824-835, 845- 1970-1975, 1975- 846.5, 1755-1760, 1760- Tx Frequencies:1965-1970, 1990, 2155-2160, 2160-2165, Rx Frequencies: 1765, 1765-1770, 1885- 2165-2170, 2350-235, 2345- 1890, 1890-1895, 1895- 2350, 2350-2355, 2355-2360 1910, 2305-2310, 2310- 2315, 2315-2320 Technology Type: LTE Only 1 C + LTE 2C-6C Part 4: Carrier Equipment Information ANTENNAS, CABLES & DISHES Sector Type Qty RAD Make Model Dimensions Weight # of Ca- Cable ERP Height (Inches) (Ibs.) bles Size (Watts) 1 CMA- 96" x 16.2" x 1 4.4 Panel 3 200' Cellmax BTLBHH/6518/20 7.8" lbs /20/A 15 RET 4449 B5/B 12; 14.96" x 13.19" x 73 Ibs / 1 / 1 / 4415 B30. 8843 10.43" / 15" x 13.2" x 5" / 43.0 Ibs RRU's 1 / 1 200' Ericsson B2/B66A; 4478 14.96" x 13.19" x 75 Ibs / 594 B14 11.1" / 18.1"x Ibs 13.4" x 8.3" (1) Fi- „ „ 3/8 DC9-48-60-24- 26.2 ber; DC9 1 200' Raycap 10.24" x 8C-EV lbs (3) 3 L4" 7/8„ Power DIAMOND COMMUNICATIONS COLLOCATION APPLICATION (01/16) DIAMONDCOMM.COM 2 CMA- Panel 3 200' Cellmax BTLBHH/6518/20 x 16.2" x 1 04.4 7 lbs /20/A 15 RET .8" 4449 B5/13 12; 14.96" x 13.19" x 73 lbs / 1 / 1 / 4415 B30. 8843 10.43" / 15" x 13.2" x 5" / 43.0 lbs RRU's 1 / 1 200' Ericsson B2/B66A; 4478 ' 14.96" x 13.19" x / 75 lbs / 59.4 B 14 11.1" / 18.1" x lbs 13.4" x 8.3" (1) Fi- „ „ 3/8 DC9-48-60-24- 26.2 ber; DC9 1 200' Raycap 10.24" x 8C-EV lbs (3) 31.4" 7/8" Power 3 CMA- Panel 3 200' Cellmax BTLBHH/6518/20 96" x 16.2" x 1 4.4 7.8" lbs /20/A15 RET 4449 B5B 12; 14.96" x 13.19" x 73 lbs / 1 / 1 / 4415 B30. 8843 10.43" / 15" x 13.2" x 5" / lbs Ru, RRU's 1 / 1 200' Ericsson B2/B66A; 4478 14.96" x 13.19" x / 75 lbs / 94 S B14 11.1" / 18.1"x lbs 13.4" x 8.3" (1) Fi- „ „ 3/8 DC9-48-60-24- 26.2 ber; DC9 1 200' Raycap 10.24" x 8C-EV lbs (3) 31.4" 7/8" Power 4 TOTALS: (9) OTHER TOWER MOUNTED EQUIPMENT (TMAs, Diplexer's, RETs, GPS, Etc.) Equipment T e YP Qt Y Mounting Height Make Model Dimensions inches ) Wei Ibs. Weight (lbs.) DIAMOND COMMUNICATIONS COLLOCATION APPLICATION (01/16) DIAMONDCOMM.COM Sector Mount 3 200 Site Pro VFA12-H10-2120 12' 6" 739 lbs EQUIPMENT SHELTER / OUTDOOR CABINET AND GROUND SPACE (*Please list your desired footprint only! Diamond, in its sole discretion will provide a non-exclusive buffer between your installation and current/future tenants to allow for access and maintenance.) Equipment Type (Pre- Shelter / Cabinet Dimensions Number Base Station Base Station Power Foundation Type (concrete pad, Total Ground fab Shelter, Outdoor Cabinet, etc.) Quantity (L x W x H) t Base Stations Make Model Output (Watts) metal platform, Space (L x W) (Inches) etc) Prefab Vertiv 8' 2-1/2" x Concrete XTE-802 1 10' '/z" x 9' 15' x 20' d SWIC 7.65" GENERATOR & FUEL TANK Number of Generators Make Model Output (KVA) Fuel Type (Pro- pane, Diesel) Number of Fuel Tanks Tank Volume (gal.) Location Ground Space 1 Generac SD030 30 Diesel 1 200 gal On Sepa- 4' x 9' KW total tank rate Gener- capacity ator pad within pro- posed ground lease space ELECTRICAL & TELCO REQUIREMENTS Power Usage (customer meter, sub -meter or con- Electrical Service (Voltage Number of Circuits (inte- Duty Cycle (%) Telephone Requirements sumption) & Amps) rior Equipment) (POTS, T-1, Fiber etc...) Carrier Comments: DIAMOND COMMUNICATIONS COLLOCATION APPLICATION (01/16) DIAMONDCOMM.COM Part 5: Agreement Information (Diamond Use ONLY) Business Dev Mgr: Dominic BOuloy Use Template: Proposed Monthly Customer Type: Rental Amount: Proposed Commence- BTS/Anchor Ten- ment Date: ant (YIN): Initial Term Period: Number of Re- newal Terms: Annual Escalation: Site Prep or Structural Fee: Notes / Comments: APPROVALS: SVP Business Dev: Date: Legal Date: Sales Support Date: Engineering Date: Part 6: Diamond Contacts: Dominic Bouloy Business Development Manager Southeast 850-443-8488 (mobile) dbouloya,diamondcomm. com Part 7: Application Attachments: Please include the following attachments when submitting an application: ❑ Aerial Map ❑ Street Map DIAMOND COMMUNICATIONS COLLOCATION APPLICATION (01/16) DIAMONDCOMM.COM C Tax Map C Equipment Cut Sheets DIAMOND COMMUNICATIONS COLLOCATION APPLICATION (01/16) DIAMONDCOMM.COM 1,� verk2n Verizon Wireless 4700 Exchange Court, Suite 100 Boca Raton, FL 33431 To Whom It May Concern: Regarding NAPLES PARK NORTH: Verizon Wireless owns multiple FCC licenses, which entitles the company to operate within a number of assigned frequency ranges. This is turn, generally eliminates interference issues from CB radios, electronic appliances, pacemakers, fire and police equipment, as well as other carriers. Careful isolation studies have been performed to determine the ideal vertical and horizontal separation between Verizon Wireless antennas and any other communication service's antennas. The antenna isolation studies increase our ability to eliminate as many chances as possible of our transmitted frequencies from interfering with other's equipment. In the unlikely event that interference does occur, Verizon Wireless agrees to fully cooperate with the entity experiencing interference to identify and correct, to the extent reasonably possible, any issues caused by the Verizon Wireless installation. Respectfully submitted, Pavitra Jaiswal RF Design Engineer Kimley»>Horn Michael Oglesby, P.E. 421 Fayetteville Street, Suite 600 Raleigh, NC 27601 (p) (919) 677-2054 (e) michael.oglesby@kimley-horn.com November 11, 2020 Rich Huber Diamond Communications 820 Morris Turnpike, Suite 104 Short Hills, NJ 07078 RE: Review of Structural Analysis on Alpine Broadcasting tower in Naples, FL by EBI Consulting Mr. Huber, We have completed a review of the structural analysis completed by EBI Consulting in July of 2018 on the existing 1016 ft tall Alpine Broadcasting tower located in Naples, FL. We were provided a previous structural analysis by Electronics Research, Inc. (ERI), with report dated March 2011 and calculations dated April 2011. This was used as the sole reference for the EBI Consulting analysis. The ERI analysis references several other information sources which were not provided. We cannot confirm the accuracy of the ERI analysis, only that the EBI Consulting analysis is appropriate based on available information. Information on the existing foundations is unavailable. The 2011 ERI report states that "the base foundation and outer anchor foundations are loaded to near their full allowable capacity." The EBI Consulting analysis references this, adding that they are "unable to determine if the existing structure is sufficient for the proposed loading due to lack of information." Additionally, leg flange bolt information is not available. The scope of the analyses is therefore limited to what ANSI/TIA-222-G refers to as a "feasibility analysis," defined as "a preliminary review to determine the overall stability and the adequacy of the main structural members of an existing structure to accommodate a proposed changed condition." In our opinion, the EBI Consulting analysis considered the correct loading criteria, including wind speed, structure class, and exposure category. The finite elements model and loading were mirrored accurately from the previous ERI analysis and the proposed loading was incorporated correctly. We cannot identify a significant deficiency based on the limited information available. It is therefore our opinion that the conclusion of the EBI Consulting is correct and the tower does not have adequate capacity to support the design loading pursuant to the 2017 Florida Building Code and ANSI/TIA-222-G Standard. Please contact me via phone or email should you have any additional inquiries. Sincerely, Michael Oglesby, P.E. FL P.E. Lic. #77241 Michael L. Oglesby, P.E., State of Florida, Professional Engineer, License No. 77241. This item has been electronically signed and sealed by Michael L. Oglesby using a Digital Signature. Printed copies ofthis document are not considered signed and sealed and the signature must be verified on any electronic copies. Prepared by and Return to: Capital Telecom Holdings II LLC Attention: Legal Department 820 Morris Turnpike, Suite 104 Short Hills, New Jersey 07078 Site Name: Naples Park North FL114 Parcel: 32630400006 ACCESS AND UTILITIES EASEMENT AGREEMENT This Access and Utilities Easement Agreement (the "Agreement") dated November 11, 2020 ("Effective Date") is among Jeanette Kuszlyk, a Single woman ("Grantor"), and CAPITAL TELECOM HOLDINGS II LLC, a Delaware limited liability company ("Grantee"). WHEREAS, the Grantor is the fee simple owner of certain property located as Parcel ID #32630400006 in the County of Collier, State of Florida which property is more particularly described on Exhibit "A" hereto ("Grantor's Property"). Grantee is leasing a portion of that certain property known as Tracts 119, 120 and 123 on the plat filed as Floridian Farm Estates in Plat Book 4, Page 33, Public Records of Collier County Florida ("Grantee's Leased Property"). Grantor and Grantee desire to enter into this Agreement for the purpose of creating certain easements to benefit the Grantee's Leased Property, as more particularly described hereinafter. For and inconsideration of Ten and No/100 Dollars ($10.00), and other good and valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which are hereby acknowledged, Grantor and Grantee, intending to be legally bound, hereby agree as follows: 1. Grantor hereby grants, transfers and conveys to Grantee a nonexclusive easement (the "Access Easement"), for the benefit of the Grantee's Leased Property, over and across a portion of Grantor's Property (the "Easement Area"), to and from Grantee's Leased Property and a public right of way, for the purpose of providing access, ingress and egress to Grantee's Leased Property to and from a public right of way. The Easement Area is in the location shown on Exhibit `B". The easement rights granted hereunder by Grantor to Grantee shall expressly include, without limitation, the right to free and unencumbered ingress and egress over and across the Easement Area. 2. Grantor hereby grants, transfers and conveys to Grantee a nonexclusive easement (the "Utilities Easement", and together with the Access Easement, collectively, the "Easements"), for the benefit of Grantee's Leased Property, over and across the Easement Area, for the purpose of installing, operating, maintaining and repairing roadway, communication, and Naples Park North FL114 Access & Utilities Easement Kuszlyk EXE Kuszlyk EXE power utility lines and other such necessary improvements (the "Facilities") to service Grantee's Leased Property. The easement rights granted hereunder by Grantor to Grantee shall expressly include, without limitation, the right to unencumbered ingress and egress over and across Grantor's Property to access the Facilities and the right to use, repair, replace, and maintain all Facilities hereafter placed in the Easement Area. 3. The Term of this Agreement shall be continuous, uninterrupted, and shall only expire: (a) upon notification from Grantee of termination of the Agreement; or (b) one (1) year after the Grantee, or its successors or assigns: (i) fails to have an interest in Grantee's Leased Property; (ii) does not have facilities or equipment located within Grantee's Leased Property, and (iii) no longer conducts operations within the Grantee's Leased Property. 4. Any notice sent pursuant to this Agreement shall be in writing and sent by telecopy, personal delivery or by reputable courier, or by depositing it with the United States Postal Service, certified or registered mail, return receipt requested, with adequate postage prepaid, addressed to the appropriate party. The initial addresses of the parties shall be as set forth below: To Grantor: Jeanette Kuszlyk 2320 Moulder Drive #A Naples, FL 34120 To Grantee: Capital Telecom Holdings II LLC Attention: Legal Department 820 Morris Turnpike Suite 104 Short Hills, New Jersey 07078 5. The Easements granted herein shall be appurtenant to and shall run with Grantee's Leased Property, and shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit of each party hereto, its successors, assigns, mortgagees, tenants, lessees, licensees, contractors, subcontractors, agents, representatives and invitees. 6. This Agreement shall be subject to and subordinate to any mortgage or deed to secure debt (collectively referred to as a "Mortgage") made by Grantor which may encumber the Grantor's Property as of the Effective Date, the holder of every such Mortgage shall in a separate agreement with Grantee agree that in the event of a foreclosure, or conveyance in lieu of foreclosure of Grantor's interest in the Grantor's Property, or such other similar transaction, such holder shall recognize and confirm the validity and existence of this Agreement and that Grantee shall have the right to continue its use and occupancy of the Easement Area in accordance with the provisions of this Agreement as long as Grantee is not in default of this Agreement beyond applicable notice and cure periods. Grantee shall execute in timely fashion such instruments in recordable form as may reasonably be requested to evidence the provisions of this paragraph. Naples Park North FL 114 Access & Utilities Easement Kuszlyk EXE Kuszlyk EXE 7. This Agreement shall be governed by and enforced in accordance with the laws of the state in which the Grantor's Property is located. {Signatures on following pages} Naples Park North FL 114 Access & Utilities Easement Kuszlyk EXE Kuszlyk EXE IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have executed this Agreement as of the Effective Date. Witness: Name: STATE OF Texas ) ss: COUNTY OF Dallas ) "GRANTOR" Name: Jeanette Kuszl k Date: November 11, 2020 On the 11 day of N OV. in the year 2020 before me, the undersigned, a notary public in and for said state, personally appeared Jeanette Kuszlyk, personally known to me or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the individual(s) whose name(s) is (are) subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/she/they executed the same in his/her/their capacity(ies), and that by his/her/their signature(s) on the instrument, the individual(s) or the person upon behalf of which the individual(s) acted, executed the instrument. Notary Public: ennl er Frazier My Commission Expires: Mar 16, 2022 �"�PVtY P`6��''% Jennifer Frazier * * Notary Public, State of Texas Comm. Expires 03-16-2022 Notary ID 13149235-7 Notarized Online with NotaryLive.com Naples Park North FL 114 Access & Utilities Easement Kuszlyk EXE Kuszlyk EXE IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have executed this Agreement as of the Effective Date_ Witness: "GRANTEE" Name. STATE OF NEW JERSEY ) ss. COUNTY OF ESSEX Capital Telecom Holdings I1 LLC 2'Zhael G_ Brett — .-w.—_ Title. COO Date:. ! J / // 1 % Z on the � day of V ©l/' in the year 2020, {More me, the undersigned, a notary public in and for said state, personally appeared Michael G_ Brett, personally known to me or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the individual(s) whose names) is (are) subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that hefsheithey executed the saute in hisfherltheir capacity(ies), and that by his,iherttheir signature(s) on the instrument, the individual(s) or the person upon behalf of which the individual(s) acted, executed the instrument. Lary €'ubli . My Cora on Expires. _.. C12, MICHELLE ZAKALIKi�At �t9p�p�� n� tIR Y PUSLIC Qr i4 E JER I1 &V COMMISSION EXPIRES 6/12/2G23 Naples Park Borth Fl-l 14 Acrxss &c I"tilities F.ascnx%t KusAyk EXF Kuszlyk EXE EXHIBIT "A" Description of Grantor's Property TO BE INSERTED BY GRANTEE Naples Park North FL 114 Access & Utilities Easement Kuszlyk EXE Kuszlyk EXE EXHIBIT "B" Easement Area 30' EASEMENT PER ORB 1306. PG. 94B r� z i wwLn co C3 � o w w w � w cn J r r7z J J z 0 0CA LLJ n or!� D U �!c � -LiX r- F Q LL. r 0 LLJ 0 foot wide easement from Grantor Kuszlyk to Grantee Capital Telecom Holdings II LLC PARCEL ID: 32630320005 OWNER: 1-10550N, CHAFLE5 E & SMITH, ANDREA C LEGAL: LORIDIAN FARM SITES COMM AT NE COR OF LOT 7, W 30FT TO POB. W 174.73FT, S 34 DEG E 3 4,4FT, N 02 DEG W 67,3 FT TO POB TO BE REPLACED BY GRANTEE Naples Park North FL 114 Access & Utilities Easement Kuszlyk EXE Kuszlyk EXE Prepared by and Return to: Capital Telecom Holdings II LLC Attention: Legal Department 820 Morris Turnpike, Suite 104 Short Hills, New Jersey 07078 Site Name: Naples Park North FL114 Parcel: 00324160008 remainder EASEMENT FOR PUBLIC ROADWAY ACCESS AND UTILITIES THIS EASEMENT AGREEMENT (hereinafter the "Agreement"), made this 18th day of November, 2020 by and between JEREMY BEDDOE, a Single man, (hereinafter referred to as "Grantor"), and CAPITAL TELECOM HOLDINGS II LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, (hereinafter referred to as "Grantee"). RECITALS WHEREAS, Jeremy Beddoe, hereinafter referred to as Grantor, with a postal address at 3880 Quails Walk, Bonita Springs, Florida 34134, is the fee simple owner of certain property in the County of Collier, State of Florida which property is more particularly described on Exhibit "A" hereto ("Grantor's Property"), which property is the unconveyed remainder of parcel 00324160008 granted by Grantor to Run Le Hie and Anita May Woon Sit in a Deed dated April 21, 2004 and recorded on June 7, 2004 in the office of the Collier County Clerk at Book 3581, Page 1475; and WHEREAS, the Grantor desires to establish for the benefit of the public an easement for public roadway access and utilities over and through such property, to and in favor of the general public; and WHEREAS, the Grantee wishes to obtain legal access for a right of way across the Grantor's Property. NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the premises hereof and other good and valuable consideration in the amount of Two Thousand Five Hundred Dollars ($2,500.00), the receipt and sufficiency of which is hereby acknowledged, the Parties to hereby agree as follows: 1. The above -referenced recitals are true and correct and constitute a material part of this Agreement. 2. Grantor hereby declares and grants to Grantee and the general public full authority and right to enter upon and use said easement described on Exhibit `B" for all public roadway and utility rights -of -way purposes, at the sole cost and expense and at the sole risk of the general public. Naples Park North FL114 Public Access Utilities Easement Beddoe EXE IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Grantor has executed this Easement as of the Effective Date. Witness: r N e: f STATE OF '' U� i ) } ss: COUNTY OF "GRANTOR" Name: Jeremy JBWdop j Date: l' On the If'' of i 1` 9 `iin the year 2020 before me, the undersigned, a notary public in and for said state, personally appeared Jeremy Beddoe, personally known to me or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the in tvidual(Wwhose narne(s)' is ( subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me th t heXshe/they executed the saute ih sAierftheir- capacity(), and that b his ignatureWon the instrument, the individu-a (s'j or the person upon behalf of which the individual(s) acted, exec the instrument. +�"!;'R"Ir.• E#MA A HIERS Not Public: 7� s ` "i e, Notary Public State or Florida lyly Commission Expires. - My i ;,`'. Commission # GO 048809 =;, a Comm, Expires Nov 20, 2020 •• o: Fi i' gended througb National Notary Assn. Naples Park North FL114 Public Access Utilities Easement Reddoe E)CE Witness: Name: n Paris STATE OF NEW JERSEY j ss: COUNTY OF ESSEX ) "GRANTEE" Name: Michael G. Brett Date. November 1.8, 2020 On the 18`h day of November in the year 2020 before me, the undersigned, a notary public in and for said state, personally appeared Michael G. Brett, personally known to me or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the individual(s) whose name(s) is (are) subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that helshe/they executed the same in his/her/their capacity(ies), and that by his/her/their signature(s) on the instrument, the individual(s) or the person upon behalf of which the individual(s) acted, executed the instrument. Notary Pub My Comfigssion Expires: a®TARy MICHELLE ZAKALIK ^uea:c NOTARY PUBLIC of NE°N JE{ Si:Y Naples Paris North M 14 Public Access Utilities Easement Beddoe EXE EXHIBIT "A" Description of Grantor's Property The South 30 feet as described as an exception in the property conveyed by Grantor to Run Le Hie and Anita May Woon Sit in a Deed dated April 21, 2004 and recorded on June 7, 2004 in the office of the Collier County Clerk at Book 3581, Page 1475 which exception is the unconveyed remainder of parcel 00324160008. TO BE REPLACED BY A LEGAL DESCRIPTION Naples Park North FL114 Public Access Utilities Easement Beddoe EXE EXHIBIT "B" Easement Area PARCEL ID; 003241 0008 _ OWNER: ANITA SIT LEGAL: 24 49 27 S 1 2 OF 3WI 4 SE1 4 OF SW1 4 OF S 1 4 OR 5 AO. OR 3990 PG 3772 0 foot wide public right of way granted by Jeremy Bed oe ER 1948 307 EASEMENT PER / Z-7--r � \v ORB 1210, PG. 1196 TO BE REPLACED BY A LEGAL DESCRIPTION Naples Park North FL114 Public Access Utilities Easement Beddoe EXE SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT American Government Services Corporation 3812 W. Linebaugh Avenue Tampa, Florida 33618 813-933-3322 Contractor's Tax I.D. No.: 59-2346160 AGSC Search Number: 30170-1 Project Name: Benton Road THE UNDERSIGNED does hereby certify that a search has been made of the Public Records of Collier County, State of Florida through July 1, 2020 at 8:00 a.m. for Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, PA, for the specific purpose of researching ownership and easements to determine access for Benton Road. Legal Description: The East 1/2 of the North 1/2 of the NE 1/4, lying and being in Section 26, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. Current Owner(s): Estate of Norman R. Alpert, deceased Mailing Address on Deed: 4,404 Gulf Shore Blvd. N Naples, FL 33940 By: Warranty Deed From: John F. Rice and Phyllis A. Rice, husband and wife Dated: September 16, 1985 Filed and Recorded: September 26, 1985 In Official Records Book No.: 1157 Page: 459 Probate No. 2018-CP-2960, deceased December 3, 2018; Letters recorded in Official Records Book 5587, Page 2259; Certificate of Death recorded in Official Records Book 5582, Page 2225. (contains additional property) The following Easements were found of records affecting the subject property: 1. Reservation of an easement for access as set forth in Warranty Deed from James A. McTague, non -homestead, to Clyde C. Quinby, dated February 18, 1982 and recorded February 22, 1982 in Official Records Book 959, Page 1140. 2. Easement from Norman R. Alpert to Florida Power & Light Company recorded August 4, 1993 in Official Records Book 1851, Page 2026. NOTE: All of the above documents recorded in the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, unless otherwise noted. Parcel information: Parcel ID No.: 00324800009 (contains additional property) i CERTIFICATIOP:: AS TO THE ORIGINAL SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT: The undersigned hereby certifies that the foregoing SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT reflects a comprehensive search of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, showing only the ownership and easements affecting the lands as requested. American Government Services Corporation assumes no responsibility for any defects or omissions in or from the instruments appearing in the chain of title to the property described herein, which defects or omissions would render such instruments void. This report is furnished at your request for information only and is not to be construed as a title opinion or a guarantee of title. It is not a title insurance policy. The liability of American Government Services Corporation is limited to $1000.00 per report and shall not in any event exceed the maximum liability as set forth under F.S. 627.7843 (3). Searc d-through Ju 1, 2020 @ 8:00 a.m.: Tammy Mehl American Government Services Corporation 2 Llrinii.,,±Ta)S IrSt. t1 ➢i'L'SS Property Summary Property Det.,°!. 51,ketchr-= 'rim Notices Parcel No 00324800009 Site Address *Disclaimer Name / ALPERT, NORMAN R Address 11800 TAM IAM I TRL E site 'city City NAPLES State FL Site Zone *Note Zip 34113-7909 Map No. St -Tan No. Section Township Range Acres *Estimated 4C26 000100 004 4C26 26 49 27 70 Legal 26 49 27 E1/2 OF N1/2 OF NE 1/4, E1/2 OF W1/2 OF N1/2 OF NE1/4, AND E1/2 OF W1/2 OF W 1/2 OF N1/2 OF NE1/4 Millane Area 0 287 M*Ragge ...alter Caleulations Sub./Condo 100 - ACREAGE HEADER School Other Total Use Code 0 60 - GRAZING LAND SOIL CAPABILITY 5.083 6.3071 11.3901 CLASS I Latest Sales History 2019 Certified Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book -Page Aannount Land Value $ 175,000 09/26/85 1157-459 $ 0 Irnproved Value $ 0 Market Value $ 175,000 t-) Agriculture $ 164,850 (_) Assessed Value $ 10,150 (=) School Taxable Value $ 10,150 (=) Taxable Value $ 10,150 Rec. $5.00 stamps$ $350.00 5 g 2 g i98S SEPr�20 All k I0 14 WARRANTY onto RECOROED nAm"a roAN 01 INOIVIa. To sNo1Vta COLLIER COUNTY US warranty Peed Afaele the h day of Srfa`C'. A. fX if) 85 by JOHN F. RICE and PHYLLIS A. RICE, husband and wife, hereinafter called life grantor, to NOR14AN R. ALPERT, whoso postoffice addreaa is 4401 Gulf Shore Boulevard North, Naples, FL 33940 hereinafter called the grantee: Zhere.er uud herein the term. "aunNa" nd "I,ntee" fat Jude ail the y:rei.1 w fh;, iwfruceal and bet", It'.1 upreunwi.e. and o.<en. of inJi.dwb, and the .ottes"t and a,ita. of ewpo+aeiaml 10110'65e1b: Thu, Flee' grantor, for and it, consideration of the sum of S 10. 00----and other valuable nonsideratloos, receipt whereof is hereby ocknowledued, hereby grants, bargains, sells. aliens, re- p mites, releases, conveys and confirms unto the grantee, all that certain land situote in Collier �7 Courtly. Florida oix: tTJ The Northeast J of the Northeast }, less west I of the x Southwest } of the Northeast # of the Northeast I of Section 26, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. Subject to easements, reservations and restrictions of record, if any, and taxes for•,.ther' cuir-q-h"Par. THIS IS NOT HOMMSTED M to Q"{Q wilia„R^• emgnA� �tl . � new erelo b longing or to any- wise apperlainfng. To Made and to 11{otd t sa End the gGanlo �e n la ,Aad h.an that the an r is [str�yisetzed of said land in foe simple; gmnlor goo ri 1; and -T a I orily 3 ! n c g said land; that the grattlo hereby Y �1' ants the title to sold land and w efend Ih same Iqq lee lawful claims of all persons who see_; .hand that .aid land is free of all ere td�nbranc, etc p 1 e�accruing subsequent io December 31, � �, ��'� A !- !h� d ffec�ior tag. t ps�d "$e 3n DIMS high reolyated these presents the clay and year lips !"abdve written. Stoned, .sealed and delivered in our presence: ......................... ........................... ..................... ml P: STATE of ` Flori a { COUNTY OF Collier. } F HEREBY'CBRTIFY that on this day, before me, on officer duty -. authorued in. the; Statc.-aforesaid, and in the County aforesaid to take aeklowtedifienis, personally, appeared JOHN,.F: `RICE '.and PHYLLIS A. RICE, husband and wife; th 4face i`n tdf. Ih6 person described in and who executed The "nsudfi ITgd they acknowledged before me that they 4p jjl; sa f,.i�sy}]I:�'t� y ti' Sir te9aj SY my:.hand.and offectat sean e l ithCounty and . bir �r r; tale �pJ) aleixesaid this � "' day of D. 19 85 Receivedt�� [ .. Documentary Stamp Tax Collier County, Florida Will J.'Reogan, Clerk. ti�4.e31rerlr ry I........ AT "E .NOTARY PUBLIC. STATE OF FLORIDA 6 �dt��i3Ary Public , My Cottuni ss ion Expi e s .41y coh%iISSION EXPIRES AUG. 24. 1907 �' Sohn N. $rugger, P.A. BONOEDTHAOUGH►fUAO5x1•ASHTOtLINC. Thu:�nrirmilent'prepdiid; GV. Adda'u 600 Fifth Avenue south, #210, Naples, Florida 33940 a.eeweea « attlloco .' tm a C1 tJ7 to *** INSTR 5656638 OR 5587 PG 2259 E-RECORDED 1/7/2019 11:14 AM PAGES 1 CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT AND COMPTROLLER, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA REC S10.00 *** IN THE CIRCUIT COURT FOR COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA PROBATE DIVISION IN RE: ESTATE OF NORMAN R ALPERT Deceased. File No. 2018-CP-2960 Division Probate LETTERS OF ADMINISTRATION (multiple personal representatives) TO ALL WHOM IT MAY CONCERN WHEREAS, Norman R Alpert, a resident of Collier County, Florida died on December 3, 2018, owning assets in the State of Florida, and WHEREAS, Donna L. Alpert and Laura Lee Lamparyk have been appointed personal representatives of the estate of the decedent and have performed all acts prerequisite to issuance of Letters of Administration in the estate, NOW, THEREFORE, I, the undersigned circuit judge, declare Donna L. Alpert and Laura Lee Lamparyk duly qualified under the laws of the State of Florida to act as personal representatives of the estate of Norman R Alpert, deceased, with full power to administer the estate according to law; to ask, demand, sue for, recover and receive the property of the decedent; to pay the debts of the decedent as far as the assets of the estate will permit and the law directs; and to make distribution of the estate according to law. ORDERED on 0 19 "- Lauren L. Brodie Circuit Judge FIt OI/0 /'$9O1.35Ca11iarY - Bar Form No. P-3.0710 C Florida Lawyers Support Services, Inc. January 1, 2018 W 00747290 WFEB 22 Pre 321 COLUfrR GWY RECORDED I Ibis *IlAnuty &A Made the � JAMS A. 14CTAGUE hereinafter called the grantor. to CLYDE C. QUINBY "C459 041 i !l fl S 300K PAGE day of :,'t r. t., ,•. V A. 1). to 82 by whose posfuffice address is 4588 Tamiami Trail North, Naples, FL 33940 hereinafter called the grantee: flea.— wd herwa thr ter® wanuu" and -rramn' - iudr all the Partin w t61t 'mte.ment and ob. Cin. Meat apre.emaatn and —kin of in4iftWi hn. sad she wnemtua atd twittn of 1-10- tiou) lftllt": That the grardor, for and in consideration of the sum of t 10,00.....and other voluable considerations, rerefpt Whereof is hereby achnou.ledfleel. hereby grants, bargains. sets. aliens. re- ralses. releases. Conveys and confirms unto the grantee, all that certain land situate in Collier County Florida. vfz: The Northeast 1/4 of the Northeast 1/4 less the West 1/2 of the Southwest 1/4 of the Northeast 1/4 of the Northeast 1/4, Section 26, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. SUBJECT TO: Taxes for the year 1982 and subsequent years. Conditions, restrictions and limitations together with easements as appear among the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, and zoning ordinances applicable, if any. Property subject to, and t e re e� r excepts, grants and declares, an easement f ac s s le purchaser and their respective heirs, suc s s gns, aof all current owners of abutting ver and under the N Section 26, Township 49 South East, The West 30' of the o�lte t 114 of the Northwest 1/4 an The t 30' of the Northeast 114, Se ion 2 Township 49 South, Range 27 at. �°" �iTR�TS RON�Bl GD PRBPERTY �o�E�lfC wfill all fhe lenem"her ents and a purtenances erelo Longing or in any- wise aappaini g. To a Aso e t f e le re er. 'i11111 the granor here y cot•e ants u-il sat g n at The not r is l wfully eized of said land in fee simple: t h ran r igl w It uthorify sel and aid land: that the grantor hereby ull u rro a tilts and defers e a lawful claims of all persons wh oeve • and that said land is free of all urnbmnr exce ccruing subsequent 10 December S I. � A Wilms Wfld thei-i glrae, first abate written.+.�" Signed. sealed and dehrered in our prespr� rice, r r STATE t IF FLORID& 1 cot;%%-y or COLLIER 1 1 HEREBY CERTIFY that on this day, before me, an officer duly authorized in the State aforesaid and in the County aforesaid to take ackaowkdpmenu, personally appeared JAMS A. MCTAGUE wr 4W known to be the prnari dckrihed in and who exrcutrd the llik#pirs iagsrment and he acknowledged before me that he rsieeutrd•tlec tttitpe, t'- •. WITNESS my band and official seal in the Uounty and :•Srtate last aforesaid this dar of A. D. 19 82 r . My,C�, 6sion Expireg ((rit'lrt•tiuillerd f+rr�tdt J ('l'- James A. vcTague 4539 Tamiami 'trial N. :Naples, Florida 33940 these presents the day and year atcTAGUE = aEtaw of woolit; USE ceivcd $ tea-s.r ,cumentory Stcmp Tax ,f tits: C'%unty, Florida i{iio . P.ua leritr ny,�,.,��.y _ � a �' . %f � �- +.: .::ram.• �•., . .• .�.,�... .....:.,,i,:TM_.. v,, _ • r ;. ' '�iaWors'tltde'r No. 2645-01-54� fit• tmJy7 ------------ EASEMENT aeeelvd f• usentary St.wp PR 7MInSIMISMPraparedBy Received S 3ass 't' Intenytbl pRn')-26 Tv+P as S. Rge2� ersonai Pro9srt! r p0cVascoti a ^. (, FL0JuMP ftU HTOOMPANYYIGJIf E. 13 OCf, CLE Y OF CIRCUIT CWAf INT -- (MaI oanry ppra "r) P.O. Address 4105 SW 15 AY g2 IND.,___.�CplurlPyy �uJrirlJ t!4 G1rstr� `t%, � �k. f✓w.ca.� •�:l� � Has0es..-.F3.._21999 i The undersigned, in consideration of the payment of SIM and other good and valuable consideration, the adequacy an receipt eceipt of which Is hereby acknowledged, grant and give to Florida Power& Light Company, its licensees, agents, successors, and assigns, An easement forever for the construction, operation and maintenance of overheLd and underground electric utility facilities (including wires, poles, guys, cables, conduits and appurtenant equipment) to be installed from time to time: with the right to reconstruct, im,ppr�oove, add to, enlarge, change the voltage, as well us, the size of and remove such facilities or any of them within an easement tU feet in width described as follows: The East 10 ft. of the East 1/2 0. of the N 2/2 of the HE 1/4 of Section 26, Township 49S, Range 29E of Collier County, Florida. 01727071 1993AUG -4 All 7 45 1851 002026 COLLIER COUNTY RECORDED DR BOOK PAGE: Together with the right to permit any of conduit within the easement and to o at all times• the right to clear the Jan it cl to trim and cut and keep trimmed d cu I dead might interfere with or fail upon t Cline o ster to the fullest extent the undersig has e pUN aver. along, under anWaacross th roa , streets or 1N WITNESS WHEREOF, the e rF� Signed, sealed and delivered in the prose ice of t� A Print Name 100 1 Ms to any facilities hereunder and lay cable and unticat)ons a right of ingress and egress to said premises 1 trees, under as other obstructions within the easement area: tin; or dangerou s limbs outside of The easement area which can or pow trans ission or distribution: and further grants, t al . hts hereF v ranted on the land heretofore described, joining r through Id p rty. s t March 1 i9 93 , b ' rin R. Al ert 50 Tamiami Trail East Print Name Audrey L. Vossler Print Address: STATE OF Florida AND COUNTY OF Collier •. The foresgFirg.iristriimeht•was'acknowiedged before me this 1 day of March . 19, 93, by Norman R.:A1 and r' .. y . . who is(aFeiersdiraY�� owq to me or has(have) produced (personally known to me) `try 4k ttion. tand*Wdiifl(Ga aot)ttahe.a' oath. My Commission Expires: t rw v+ 1a fjfx.wf alb s� V %I- {' 1) NOTARY rtlEttCr SIAt! OF ft041eA At tASOE V� ton tip' MY COMMISSION txrlxts MAY1, 1"3�R SONOtO rNItu A"Ni'S NOTAxi U012 Aot L�•�, � �•' olary , f u; 51spiklufC., fl�� Print Name Michdl.' SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT American Government Services Corporation 3812 W. Linebaugh Avenue Tampa, Florida 33618 813-933-3322 Contractor's Tax I.D. No.: 59-2346160 AGSC Search Number: 30170-2 Project Name: Benton Road THE UNDERSIGNED does hereby certify that a search has been made of the Public Records of Collier County, State of Florida through July 1, 2020 at 8:00 a.m. for Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, PA, for the specific purpose of researching ownership and easements to determine access for Benton Road. Legal Description: The South 1/2 of the SW 1/4 of the SW 1/4 of the SW 1/4, lying and being in Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida, Current Owner(s): Donald R. Harring and Irene H. Harring, husband and wife Flailing Address on Deed: 202 Seacliff St. Islip Terrace, NY 11752 By: Warranty Deed From: Carrie V. Harring, a single person Dated: April 26, 1984 Filed and Recorded: June 7, 1984 In Official Records Book No.: 1086 Page: 826 The following Easements were found of records affecting the subject property: 1. Grant of Easement by John M. Andrews dated May 16, 1983 and recorded June 7, 1983 in Official Records Book 1025, Page 684. 2. Easement for Rights -of -Way and Roadway Purposes from Donald R. Harring, joined by spouse, Irene H. Harring, in favor of the general public, dated August 23, 1985 and recorded October 141 1985 in Official Records Book 1159, Page 1948. 3. Easement from Donald R. Harring and Irene H. Harring to Florida Power & Light Company recorded November 4, 1986 in Official Records Book 1229, Page 1796. NOTE: All of the above documents recorded in the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, unless otherwise noted. Parcel information: Parcel ID No.: 00324120006 CERTIFICATIOiN: AS TO THE ORIGINAL SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT: The undersigned hereby certifies that the foregoing SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT reflects a comprehensive search of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, showing only the ownership and easements affecting the lands as requested. American Government Services Corporation assumes no responsibility for any defects or omissions in or from the instruments appearing in the chain of title to the property described herein, which defects or omissions would render such instruments void. This report is furnished at your request for information only and is not to be construed as a title opinion or a guarantee of title. It is not a title insurance policy. The liability of American Government Services Corporation is limited to $1000.00 per report and shall not in any event exceed the maximum liability as set forth under F.S. 627.7843 (3). Searched-tfir6ug, July 1, 2020 @ 8:00 a.m.: Tammy4lehl American Government Services Corporation 2 Collier County Property Appraiser k_ Property Summary Parcel Site, 1751 ^ Site Site NO T 00324120006 Address BEN ON City NAPLES *Zone 34117 *Disclaimer RD Note Name ;I M_U"FRING, DONALD R=& IRENe H Address 1751 BENTON RD Cityn n� �-C NALrES State FL Zip 34117-8864 Map No. Strap No. Section Township Range Acres *Estimated ............. 4C24 000100 105 4C24 24 49 27 5 Legal 24 49 27 SIR/2 OF SW1/4 OF SW1/4 OF SW1/4 5 AC. OR i 0 6 . G 826 M llaye Area 62 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations ub./Condo 100 - ACREAGE HEADER School Other Total Use Code 0 1 - SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 5.083 6.3071 11.3901 Latest Sales History (Not all Sales are listed clue to Confidentiality) Date Book -Page Amount 06/01/84 1086-826 $ 4,500 W 04/01/84 1074-1766 $ 4,500 09/01 /80 881-1815 $ 0 -, (_) 2019 Certified Tax Roll (Subject to Change) Land Value $ 32,950 Improved Value $ 194,410 Market Value $ 227,360 Save our Home $ 52,245 Assessed Value $ 175,115 c-� Homestead $ 25,000 (_) School Taxable %Ialue $ 150,115 (-, Additional Homestead $ 25,000 (_) Taxable Value $ '1125,115 if all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roil OOITT35T makJUN-7 PMz:1:0 OCi!086 000826 COLLIER COUNTY RECOROEO OR BOOK PAGE WARRANTY DEED THIS INDENTURE, made this Z` day of April 19 84, iC. between �f CARRIE V. HARRINC, a single person grantor, and DONALD R. HARRINC and IRENE H. HARRING, Husband and Wife whose address is: 202 Seacliff St,, Islip Terrace, NY. 11752 grantee, WITNESSETH: That said grantor, for and in consideration of the sum of $10.00 and other good and valuable consideration to said grantor in hand paid by said grantee, the receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, has granted, bargained, and sold t,, the said grantee, and grantee's heirs and assigns, forever, the following described land, situated, lying and being in Collier County, Florida, to wit: The A of the SA of the SWk of the 3Wk of Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, lying, being and situated in Collier County, Florida, (Being five acres, more or less) Subject to easements and restrictions common to the subdivision; oil, Sao and mineral reservations of record; and taxes for 1984 and subsequent years. Received $ tqn.AS Documentary Stomp Tax Collier County, Florido William J. Reagan, Clerk bIY'11C-e-%4-m,*.A,,�k D.C. and said grantor does hereby fully warrant the title to said land, and will defend the same against the lawful claims of all persons whatsoever. (Note: "Grantor" and "Grantee" are used for singular or plural, as context requires) IN WITNESS WHEREOF, Grantor has hereunto set grantor's hand and seal the day and year first above written. Signed, se led and delivered in our met: 'fit r W es Witness STATE OF FLORIDA COLLIER COUNTY OF CARRIE V. HARRINC I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this day, before me, an officer duly qualified to take acknowledgments, personally appeared I. CARRIE V. XMING, a single person ::, 1kEo�m to be the parson described in and who executed the foregoing nt and she acknowledged before Toe that she executed the hand And official seal in the County and State last day o! Altj i l / !� , 1 4 f MY C W1181011 EXPIRES [ .' ,�+;•.,, '', ,. HDTARY PUOLIC STALE OF FLORIDA � IhP PREPARED BY: MYCOMMISSICHEYPIriSMAY t'1Io66 �y t10ll.ii1. HAMILTON, Attorney at Law sol.rcD IJ*) CUI[RAL INS. UNDEAN111V 1-103, 2661 Airport Road S., Naples, FL, 33962 ou�"i. f tr I "A RE�r' ;C:.L1CR COUNTY MT �" GRANT L* EASEMENT This easement is given this 1.4a day of m aq 1983. Grantor hereby reserves, excepts, grants and declares an easement for right of way in favor of grantor and ors respective heirs, successors and assigns, and also -in'^ favor or all current owners of abutting lands on, over�unde r a dFalong 'L the W(�T {5PT Am6 r�ONli4 30ft OF'f1tE 5!�� 1�+►`� _..�. .� S� This easement shall be appurtenant to the dominant estates and shall run with the land. I.^. "" tness Wh and seal, on the irJ KNF.55 �" _ v s . nt Collier County, • by1NiiiiCt R n L" STATE OF FL J COUNTY OF "''' I HEREBY G t on this day duly authorized or said to take ackno d MVe Pr*fTf eurto set his hand -EWS , and officer L e County afore- }c -e ;;^C;wr. to Le the perQon described in and who executed the +_regr± '::strur;er.t and ackr..w.edged to me that ;es ..e same. w IT??�sS my hand a)•� �3�' = i _ ia- seal in Lhe : of;r:tg anc State 'Last aforesaid this J"- dad of" , 1483. ary Public Commission Expires. This instrument �d 1 prepared by: 2102 ftAtAtcNaA dK. Arr ioa #APIES , FL. 331NP aw Relic. %be i ;;Cry : •..�,�•� .. S .r S . Record: $9.00 1995 OCT 14 RN $ 15 Stamps: .50 p 6$ 6 2 3 4 8 GILLIER COUNTY RECORDED EAMENT FOR.RIGHTS-OF-WAY AND ROADWAY PURPOSES DONALD R. HARRING, joined by his spouse, if any, hereinafter referred to as "Grantor", in consideration of TEN DOLLARS ($10.00), the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, does hereby declare and grant an easement for rights -of - way, road purposes, and utility right-of-way to and in favor of the general. public over the following described portions of said property. CD ." I CAD The South 30 feet of the South k of the Southwest 14 of the Southwest h of the Southwest 4 of Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. Grantor does hereby grant public full authority and right to enter upon and use utility rights -of -way, o ingress and egress and r oses at the cost and and at the sole o 'a �- risk of the general p lic. p 40 M .p- cs To have an to 1 th manner and for the uses and pu ose a re ti n IRENE H. DONALD R. HARRIYG IN WITNESS F, , d h s s HARRING, have set their and seals this y 1985., C� . 0 X - D J L IN IRENE H. HARRING THIS INSTRUMENT PREPARED BY: Donald R. Harring 202 Seacliff Street Islip Terrace, New York 11752 �, Forsyth, Swalm & Hrugger 00(159 OR BOOK STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER Do1949 'PAGE; I hereby certify that on this day; before me,. an officer -duly authorized in the State and County aforesaid to take acknowledgments, personally appeared DONALD R. HARRING & IRENE H. HARRING to me known to be the person(s) described in and who executed the above, instrument and he (they) acknowlc n T same in the presence of two subscribing witnesses freel 1/ Witness .nw and jid ficiai�seai..3. Count and Mate last ..^..•pl..... _'1 ar t� y c OTARY PUBLIC STATE Or TWO -� MY CONNISSION EV. MAY 23,3288 "�""" ".,••� My Comni n .E OONOEO TRIO GENERAL INS. M. ! Received Clac:r rcl`tar�' Strrnp Tax Coli'cr Cr.•u ,"r, Fl:,rid ask William 1.'ua �geyk D.C. 4 THIS INSTRUMENT PREPARED BY Donald R. Harring 202 Seacliff Street Islip Terrace, New York 11752 I1"alli r v,wl v.net.a Ilt 11f1K1.11 M.iuru. N W4 1K CAl1111 FLV1ilUA Cork laf C1iCM11 CQWt r ; . ,. - .al'9S-�i: -{ �' � ...- .... .- `'Sr• a .....' ... y''.4'.. �••� ��Ty.•.K'Il� '�lfry .. ' n 001229 001796 • MPREPARED BY: R. CRED W.J)/SIOMV0/ERAy1347 01E540 OR BOOK PAGE Scc..._2.4-, Twp. _49 _S, Rge_27 E EASEMENT Form 2722A (Slack,a) Rev. 2/e6 The undersigned, in consideration of the payment of S1.00 and other good and valuable considera- tion, the adequacy and receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, grant and give to Florida Power & (- Light Company, its licensees, agents, successors, and assigns, an casement forever for the construc- tion, operation and maintenance of overhead and underground electric utility facilities (including wires, poles, guys, cables, conduits and appurtenant equipment) to be installed from time to time. co with the right to reconstruct, improve, add to, enlarge, change the voltage, as well as, the size of and remove such facilities or any of them within an casement.ip_fect in width described as follows: � w The West 10 Feet of the South 150 Feet less the South 30 Feet of the + South 1/2 of the SW 1/4 of the SW 1/4 of the SW 1/4 of Section 24, a Township 49S, Range 27E,of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida. s3 to >- c*� Received R •� qrunientary Stamp Tax ►� Received $ ev a -%,' w COLLIE UNT C 1 BY © c3 Together with tl rig"' y r or to at ch wires to any fact lilies ltereundcr nd la cab a an on it It n h se c an o rate he same for commu- nications purpo s; th g of in re an egr t pre es all Imes; he right to clear the land and keep i of 11 u d t a otltcro t do n the easement area; the right to trim t cp an 1 dea ,1 r dangerous trees or limbs outside of a mcnt area which might into with r fail c lines or systems of communications transmission or distribution; fu er the fullest extent the undersigned has th a to grant, if at all, the righ na ov a on the land heretofore described, over, alo and across the roads, stye t )i djoining or through said property. IN WITNESS WHE _, jt , the rd ed this instrument on ` I �4Q -f � . Signed, sealed and delivered in the ,,•u+r::.:. presence of: 1 la tviT.vrrS ; �_T_��•�, f�„•, r„� bwar � � � • �5ealj, W /TA/ r.ft; � �,� IC�{1i V1 . h`�YZ fJl..tt•�l/`••� fiwNfR �$e8�)t) tt r � r • Jmt " STATE OF AND COUNTY OF, �n � The foregoing instrument was acknowledgedbeffo�re me thus/ day fo of v , 19�, by4'Jdg-1&sdQ-5� Y and -- %d 9" My Commission Expires: I>�- I -89 C ,64AL U Notary Public, State of ow. tiW� in �a�cc ulctY• SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT American Government Services Corporation 3812 W. Linebaugh Avenue Tampa, Florida 33618 813-933-3322 Contractor's Tax I.D. No.: 59-2346160 AGSC Search Number: 30170-3 Project Name: Benton Road THE UNDERSIGNED does hereby certify that a search has been made of the Public Records of Collier County, State of Florida through July 1, 2020 at 8:00 a.m. for Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, PA, for the specific purpose of researching ownership and easements to determine access for Benton Road. Legal Description: The South 1/2 of the SE 1/4 of the SW 1/4 of the SW 1/4, lying and being in Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. Current Owner(s): Anita Sit Mailing Address on Deed: 629 San Mateo San Bruno, CA 94066-3611 By: Warranty Deed From: Run He Lie, a single woman Dated: February 28, 2006 Filed and Recorded: March 2, 2006 In Official Records Book No.: 3990 Page: 3772 The following Easements were found of records affecting the subject property: 1. Easement for utility Rights -of -Way Purposes from Norman R. Alpert to Florida Power & Light Company dated July 24, 1986 and recorded August 6, 1986 in Official Records Book 1210, Page 1195. 2. Easement for Utility Rights -of -Way and Roadway Purposes Norman R. Alpert, in favor of the general public, dated July 24, 1986 and recorded August 6, 1986 in Official Records Book 1210, Page 1196. NOTE: All of the above documents recorded in the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, unless otherwise noted. Parcel information: Parcel ID No.: 00324160008 CERTIFICATION: AS TO THE ORIGINAL SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT: The undersigned hereby certifies that the foregoing SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT reflects a comprehensive search of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, showing only the ownership and easements affecting the lands as requested. American Government Services Corporation assumes no responsibility for any defects or omissions in or from the instruments appearing in the chain of title to the property described herein, which defects or omissions would render such instruments void. This report is furnished at your request for information only and is not to be construed as a title opinion or a guarantee of title. It is not a title insurance policy. The liability of American Government Services Corporation is limited to $1000.00 per report and shall not in any event exceed the maximum liability as set forth under F.S. 627.7843 (3). Searched through July 1, 2020 @ 8:00 a.m.: Tamm ehl American Government Services Corporation 2 Collier County Properly Appraiser Property Summary Site 1819 Site Parcel Site ; 00324160008 Address BENTON NAPLES Zone 34117 No *Disclaimer RD City t Name / SIT, ANITA Address 108 P% MiCi-IAELS CT City DALY CITE' State CA Zip 94015-2162 Map No. Strap No. Section Township Range ,Acres *estimated 4C24 000100 106 4C24 24 49 27 4- 34 Legal 24 49 27 S1/2 OF SE1/4 OF SW1/4 OF SW1/4 LESS S 81 E 3n Millage Area 62 Miilage Rates_ 0 *Calculations, Sub./Condo 100 -ACREAGE 'riEA,DER School Other Total Use Code 0 99 - ACREAGE NOT ZONED 5.083 6.3071 11.3901 AGRICULTURAL Latest Sales History (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) Date Book -Page Amount 03/02/016 3990-3772 $ 0 06/07/0-4 3581-1475 $ 67,000 04/17/03L68-11 6 $ 35,000 10/17/00 2733-439 $ 0 03/03/95 2027-992. $ 0 03/02/95 2027-990 $ 0 09/07/94 1982-1684 $ 16,500 10/01/92 1760-1590 $ 0 2019 Certified Tax Roll (Subject; to Change) Land Value $ 28,601 ( +-) Improved Value $ 0 (_) Market Value $ 28,601 (-) '`0% Cap $ 9,539 (_) Assessed Value $ 19,062 (_) School Taxable Value $ 28,601 i=) Taxable Value $ 19;062 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll THIS INSTRUMENT PREPARED BY AND RETURN TO: Timothy J. Cotter, Esq. Timothy J. Cotter, PA 599 9th Street North Naples, Florida 34102 Property Appraisers Parcel Identification (Folio) Numbers: 00324160008 Grantee SS #: PREPARED WITHOUT OPINION OF TITLE *** 3794141 OR: 3990 PG: 3772 RECORDED iD OFFICIAL RECORDS of COLLIER COUNTY, FL 03/02/2006 at 10:23AN DRIGET 1. BROCK, CLERK RIC Ell 10.00 DOC-.70 70 Retll: TINOTNY J COTTER 599 9TB ST R #313 NAPLES FL 31102 Space Above This Line For Recording Data THIS WARRANTY DEED, made the _ day of February, 2006 by Run He Lie, a single woman, herein called the grantors, to Anita Sit, whose post office address is: 629 San Mateo, San Bruno, CA 94066-3611, hereinafter called the Grantee: (Wherever used herein the terms "grantor" and 'grantee" include all the parties to this instrument and the heirs, legal representatives and assigns of individuals, and the successors and assigns ofcorporations) W I T N E S S E T H. That the grantors, for and in consideration of the sum of TEN AND 00/100'S ($10.00) Dollars and other valuable considerations, receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, hereby grants, bargains, sells, aliens, remises, releases, conveys and confirms unto the grantee all that certain land situate in COLLIER County, State of Florida, viz.: The West 150 feet of Tract 45, GOLDEN GATE ESTATES, Unit 92, according to the plat thereof recorded in Plat Book 5, Page 81, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida. The West %, of the South % of the North %: of the South %= of the North ''/z of the Southwest '/., Section 14, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida, less and except the West 35 feet thereof. The West '/: of the North %a of the South % of the North % of the Southwest '/., Section 14, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida, less and except the West 35 feet thereof. The South %: of the Southeast '/. of the Southwest '/. of the Southwest '/ of Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, lying and being in Collier County, Florida, less and excepting the East 30 feet of the South 30 feet thereof. Subject to easements, restrictions and reservations of record and to taxes for the year 2006 and thereafter. TOGETHER, with all the tenements, hereditaments and appurtenances thereto belonging or in anywise appertaining. TO HAVE AND TO HOLD, the same in fee simple forever AND, the grantors hereby covenant with said grantee that the grantors are lawfully seized of said land in fee simple; that the grantors have good right and lawful authority to sell and convey said land, and hereby warrant the title to said land and will defend the same against the lawful claims of all persons whomsoever; and that said land is free of all encumbrances, except taxes accruing subsequent to December 31, 2005. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the said grantors have signed and sealed these presents the day and year rust above written. Signed, sealed and delivered in the presence of: Witne s #1 Signature Witn I P ' N itne s # ign eJ / tai Witness #2 Printed Name Run4)7�� . He Lie STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this Z3 day of February, 2006 by Run He Lie who is personally known to me or have produced as identification. yet"•r8ts TIMOTHY J.00T7ER MY COMMISSION # DD 105195 EXPIRES: June 1 2006 Th.0 Notary Nbl Untlerwrilars My Commission Notar}rPubfic Printed Notary Name File No: .001Its oil 195 n 10 21 e 6 s ufs -s 5s ' �t�1.L�A ;CI�MC1751 ilFt?ORD1:D !., OR- BW DOG EASEMENT FOR UTILITY RiGFiTS-OF-'MAY PURPOSES 1?jT ..,. NORMAN R. ALPERT, hereinafter referred to as •Grantor', in consideration of TEN DOLLARS ($10.00), the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, does hereby declare and grant an easement for utility right -of -war to and in favor of Florida Power 1l Light Company, *Grantee', over the following described portions of said property. The South ten feet (10') of Tract 106 of Section 24, Township 49 South, Ran Mast~; er described as the Southeast 1/4 of hest Southwest 1/4, Collier County, o da Grantor does h r o the Grantee full right to enter upon and use sal ea for all proper utility rights rposes. To have aM to uses and pu ses IN WT k SS iiNFQ of RIINESSES: in the iianner Nand for the ra- STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY Of COLLIER I hereby certify t on # ar_ befar ff r duly authorized in the State and County afo id akd` ac W ' nts, personally appeared �.. NOMW R. ALPERT, to we known to n described in and who executed the above instrument and he acknowledged executing the same in the presence of two subscribing witnesses freely and voluntarily. witness my hand and official seal in the State and County last aforesaid this day of Od,441986. r NOTARY PUBLIC Ny Commission Expires: ;.�.«►^ - NOTARY PUBLIC STATE OF FL0116N,' This instrument prepared by: Mr COMMON EVIRES OCr 23 .1997. John N. Bragger, Esquire w nuu sew WsuPAwcF_.- : tt 0,tA��;2,n_: Forsyth, Swal■ fi Brugger, fe 600 Fifth Avenue South, Suite 210 R ceimi$ -,..d;rwn�eiri•r; ," :Alm! [ter r f, I Naples, Florida 33940 Y.:Givd $ • :•ur•':,4.'.7..�7.0 • `• • COLLIER COUNTY CLERK OF COURTS BYirL.t,.-saE� 3 v Zo 1021668 ws AUG -OKLIA :A Roy. etc' .- REC ' ram' EASEMENT FOR UTILITY RIGHTS-OF•MAY AND ROADWAY PURPOSES Doc NOWN R. ALPERT, hereinafter referred to as 46rantor", in consideration of TEN DOLLARS ($10.00), the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, does hereby declare and grant an easement for utility rights -of -way, road purposes, and utility right4f-way to and in favor of the general public, over the following described portions of said property. The South thirty feet (301), less and except the East thirty feet (301) of the South thirty feet (301), of Tract 106 of Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 27 East; further described as the Southeast 1/4 of the Southwest 1/4 of the Southwest 1/4, Collier County, Florida. Grantor does hereby t0�� ev%1 kut authority and right to enter upon and uses 4_#e�"al is -of -way, ingress and egress and ro at the cost and expen ad he sale risk of the general pub, . To have a d to ld a un ublic in he ma er and for, the uses and urpo s aforew.ntio ps IN WITH S WH EOF NO F R AL ER ' h s hi n a A th s '4:L.--4ay of , 9 SUG. WIT E55ES: R. 'a STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER I hereby certify t on P , a an fit°or duly authorized in the State and County afoac nts, personally appeared NORNAN R. ALPERT, to mik kno sm to b '"D arson described in and who executed the above instrument and he acknowledged executing the same in the presence of two subscribing witnesses freely and voluntarily. ritnest qV hand and official seal in the State and County last aforesaid this&5W_,46day of 1986. NOY PUBLIC Ny Commission Expires: ......... This This instrument prepared by: NOTARY DVNX STATE OF FLORIDA"" �•'�� O r,T [ L'•`''.: , MY COMMISSION WIRES OCI 23 1987 ; ' � � _ . ! }^ ; ',�,� a� J �• John N. Brugger, Esquire n. AONM IM CENR& INSURANCE lNO_:: y •s - , Forsyth, Swalm 6 Brugger, P.A. 600 Fifth Avenue South, Suite 210 " U� 1.i G;;•'-' Naples-. Florida 33940 :r.• .i »s.r1G.Q.. _�}�-..;;.t„I,,,v fi'.:j� ,. • �f ''[OiilCt- OWN .,/ au.s ct ura.� cnsi 3 SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT American Government Services Corporation 3812 W. Linebaugh Avenue Tampa, Florida 33618 813-933-3322 Contractor's Tax I.D. No.: 59-2346160 AGSC Search Number: 30170-4 Project Name: Benton Road THE UNDERSIGNED does hereby certify that a search has been made of the Public Records of Collier County, State of Florida through July 1, 2020 at 8:00 a.m. for Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, PA, for the specific purpose of researching ownership and easements to determine access for Benton Road. Legal Description: Tracts 119, 120 and 122, Floridian Farm Sites, according to map or plat thereof as recorded in Plat Book 4, Page 33, all lying and being in Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. Current Owner(s): Tafara Lodge LLC Mailing Address on Deed: 31393 Mannix Dr, #505 Naples, FL 34114 By: Warranty Deed From: Cynthia A. Tantum, a married woman Dated: February 28, 2006 Filed and Recorded: August 29, 2016 In Official Records Book No.: 5308 Page: 858 The following Easements were found of records affecting the subject aronerty: 1. Easement for Rights -of -Way and Roadway Purposes from Carol Jean S. Ellsworth, formerly, Carol Jean S. O'Shea, in favor of the general public, dated September 12, 1985 and recorded October 14, 1985 in Official Records Book 1159, Page 1950. 2. Matters as set forth on the Plat of Floridian Farms Sites, Plat Book 4, Page 33. NOTE: All of the above documents recorded in the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, unless otherwise noted. i Parcel information: Parcel ID No.: 32634600006; 32634640008; 32634720009 CERTIFICATION: AS TO THE ORIGINAL SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT: The undersigned hereby certifies that the foregoing SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT reflects a comprehensive search of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, showing only the ownership and easements affecting the lands as requested. American Government Services Corporation assumes no responsibility for any defects or omissions in or from the instruments appearing in the chain of title to the property described herein, which defects or omissions would render such instruments void. This report is furnished at your request for information only and is not to be construed as a title opinion or a guarantee of title. It is not a title insurance policy. The liability of American Government Services Corporation is limited to $1000.00 per report and shall not in any event exceed the maximum liability as set forth under F.S. 627.7843 (3). Searched thro July 1, 2020 @ 8:00 a.m.: TaiTmy Mehl American Government Services Corporation Pa Collier County Property Appraiser Ul Property Summary Parcel No 32634640008 Site Address 1780 BENTON Site City NAPLES *Disclaimer RD Name / Address TAFARA LODGE LLC 3585 41 STAVE NE City NAPLES Map No. Strap No. 4C25 296200 1204C25 State FL Section Township Range 25 49 27 Legal FLORIDIAN FARM SITES TRACT 120 5 AC Millage Area-0 62 Sub./Condo 296200 - FLORIDIAN FARM SITES Use CodeO 99 - ACREAGE NOT ZONED AGRICULTURAL Latest Sales History (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) Date Book -Page Amount 08/29/16 5308-858 $ 0 04/07/16 5262-3738 $140,000 04/08/09 4445-3143 $ 0 02/04/05 3729-308 $ 290,000 08/11/04 3624-2522 $ 0 08/11/04 3624-2521 $ 0 10/17/57 15-612 $ 0 Zip 34120 Page i of 1 Site Zone 34117 *Note Acres *Estimated 5 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations School Other Total 5.083 6.3071 11.3901 2019 Certified Tax Roll (Subject to Change) Land Value $ 42,500 (+) Improved Value $ 0 (_) Market Value $ 42,500 (-) 10% Cap $ 4,825 (_) Assessed Value $ 37,675 (_) School Taxable Value $ 42,500 (_) Taxable Value $ 37,675 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll http://www.collierappraiser.com/main_search/recorddetail.html?sid=568753283&Map=No&FolioNum=3263... 7/7/2020 Details Print Page 1 of 1 Tax Bills Change of Address Property Summary Property Detail Sketches 11Trim Notices Site Address Site Zone Parcel No 32634600006 *Disclaimer Site City *Note Name / Address TAFARA LODGE LLC 3585 41 ST AVE NE City NAPLES State FL Zip 34120 Map No. Strap No. Section Township Range Acres *Estimated 4C25 2962001194C25 25 49 27 5 Legal FLORIDIAN FARM SITES TRACT 119 5 AC Millage Area O 62 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 296200 - FLORIDIAN FARM SITES School Other Total ! f.- _ I. _ _1 ... S AA � I+T! A !! FIAT .RA�.lA A /.!•I+l l• Tl •w � l !• AA1 f.\A7! ! A tAA! V http://www. collierappraiser.comlmain_search/recorddetail.html?sid=924676885 &Map=No&FolioNum=3263... 7/9/2020 INSTR 5306210 OR 5308 PG 858 RECORDED 8/29/2016 3:39 PM PAGES 4 DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA DOC@.70 $0.70 REC $35.50 CONS $10.00 Douglas L. Rankin, Esq, 2335 Tamiami Trail North Suite 308 Naples, FL 34103 (Without Opinion) When recorded return to: Douglas L. Rankin, Esq. 2335 Tamiami Trail North Suite 308 Naples, FL 34103 (space above this line reserved for recording office use only) 1. IDENTIFICATION Grantor's name and acWresA woman 48 I g l 1 119., AND: Barry P. Winsor, a man The word "1" or "me" as hereafter used means the Grantors. 2. IDENTIFICATION OF GRANTEE Grantee's name and address is: Tafara Lodge, LLC, a Florida limited liability company 3893 Mannix Dr. #505 Naples, FL 34114 The word "you" as hereafter used means the Grantee. 3, MEANINGS OF TERMS The terms "I," "me," "you," "grantor," and "grants" shall be non -gender specific ((i) masculine, (ii) feminine, or (iii) neuter, such as corporations, partnerships or trusts), singular or LAW OFFICE DOUGLAS L. RANKIN MOORINGS PROFESSIONAL BUILDING 2335 TAMIAMI TRAIL NORTH SUITE 308 NAPLES, FL $4103 (239) 262-0061 wwwArankinlaw.own OR 5308 PG 859 plural, as the context permits or requires, and include hens, personal representatives, successors or assigns where applicable and permitted. 4. DESCRIPTION OF REAL PROPERTY CONVEYED Property hereby conveyed (the "Real Property") is described as follows: Tracts 119, 120 and 122, FLORIDIAN FARM SITES, according to map or plat thereof as recorded in Plat Book 4, Page 33, Public Records of Collier County, Florida. together with all tenements (property capable of being held with unconditional power of disposition), hereditaments (inheritable interest in property), easements (right to use land of another) and appurtenances (right used with land for its benefit) belonging to or benefiting such property. cow The Property Appraise ' Identi umbers are: 326346110006: 3263464OLS; and 3263 CONSIDERATION Good and valuable i of from you. �°` 6. CONVEYANCE OF ROPERTY For the consideration describR the Real Property to have and to hold i disposition and descendability) forever. 7. WARRANTY ($10.00) received by me FA 91 Li 9 granted, bargained and sold to you property unlimited as to duration, I fully warrant the title to the Real Property and will defend the same against the lawful claims of all persons whomsoever except for covenants, reservations, restrictions and easements of record, if any; and taxes subsequent to December 31, 2015. S. NOT HOMESTEAD I represent and warrant that the Real Property is neither the homestead or residence of myself or a member of my family, nor is the Real Property adjacent to the homestead or residence of myself or a member of my family. LAW OFFICE DOUGLAS L. RANKIN MOORINGS PROFESSIONAL BUILDING 2335 TAMIAMI TRAIL NORTH SUITE 308 NAPLES, FL 34103 (238) 262.0061 wwwArankinlew.com OR 5308 PG 860 9. EXCEPTIONS This conveyance is subject to taxes for year 2016 and subsequent years. Executed oSAUpst r.-syc.I, 2016. Cynjig . T f 145o es Cirt�t Nap34119 Signed in the presence of. Witness STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER The foregoing instrument was acknow 2016, by Cynthia A. Tantum, a married v as identification. i ALISAM.ACOWDI Commkft # FF OM91 Up(= 00Mf 21, 2019 unaathu tea wo �e�+e.ioe e0owa ro �o LAW OFFICE DOUGLAS L. RANKIN MOORINGS PROFESSIONAL BUILDING 2335 TAMIAMI TRAIL NORTH SUITE 308 NAPLES, FL 34103 (239) 262-0061 www.dranWnlaw.com Q) Signec 17, of- C, C1 , ,c� is — day of person ay cnow`n,to me or produced U A. .Lw'a' Notary Public - State of Florida *** OR 5308 PG 861 *** Executed on August GO& , 2016. L r` G� Barry P. Winsor Signed in the presence of: Signed in the presence of A,,. A - A =-. S � 1� Witness 'k)a . M. NU4C 1l STATE OF COUNTY OF The foregoing instrument v 2016, by Barry P. Winsor, as identiir M . kavL LAW OFFICE DOUGLAS L. RANKIN MOORINGS PROFESSIONAL BUILDING 2336 TAMIAMI TRAIL NORTH SUITE 308 NAPLES, FL 34103 (239) 262-Ml wwwArankinh w.00m -a3 -1(0 produced Record: $9.00 00962349 Stamps: .50 l985 OCT 14 PoY g: 15 COL41ER COUNTY RECORDED EASEMENT FOR RIGHTS -OF -WAY AND ROADWAY PURPOSES CAROL JEAN S: ELLSWORTH, (formerly CAROL JEAN S. O'SHEA), joined by her spouse, if any, hereinafter referred to as "Grantor", in consideration of TEN DOLLARS ($lo.00), the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, does hereby declare and grant an easement for rights -of -way, road purposes, and utility right-of-way to and in favor of the general public over the following described portions of said property. The North 30 feet of Section 25, Townsh Plat Book 4, at�71 g County, Florid . US h, Range z 13, of the Public Tract 126, of � as recorded in tcls r Collier Grantor doestand to e 1 is fu authority and right to enteus d en roper utility rights-ofss and egress d oa oses at the cost and expense sole risk of t e t public. To have and to hold the,- ntrf &N ral public in the manner and for the uses and purposes aforementioned. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, CAROL JEAN S. ELLSWORTH, and her'spouse, efdtpf Aso Gc/%_ w �, if any, has (have) set her (their) hand(s) and seal(s) this /JtA day of WITNESSES: CAROL JE S. ELLSWORTH `r PORSYTH. SWALM & BRUGGER, P.A.. Attorneys at Law. 600 Fifth Avenue South. Suite 210. Naple►, narlde 339411 10.1 f�9 OR BOOK STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER 001951 PAGE` I hereby certify that on this day, before me, an officer duly authorized in the State and County aforesaid to take acknowledgments, personally appeared CAROL JEAN S. ELLSWORTH, to me known to be the persons) described in and who executed the above instrument and she (they) acknowledged executing the same in the presence of two subscr and voluntarily. �freely Witness my han fficial seal in th ty and State last aforesaid this a of , 19 5. ise Not e S to o My Cam Ex Fos it Received $�.'� Dccur^erttary St^rnp TOY COi`i::r C.^:r-+fiv. r . ride WliilOrtl J. RC(oXCier D.C. U e In O"wt Kocan.A COLLIER Cq{JNTY fLl4Rlt)r y,ILLtAM !. Rf�ihN Ct.rk of Clrcult Cswt This instrument prepared by; John N. Srugger, Esq. FORSYTH, SWALM & BRUGGER, P.A.. Attorneys at Lew. 600 Fifth Avenuo South, Suite 210. Narks. FluiWa 33940 io JM Iy� S me 11 1.1.11 •- osv o►os ,o:c. oaas . Rex 7 9NYY ,wsa qsf/ ♦. y[ �.- � � 9' Li ,YYNYY ....._._.. �.--------- Q i -----------•-.--_-__•- .---_---_►-•--•-•-_- __•.- _'_�' It ---- -! --- --------�--- ---�---a -- --- --- ------�---- =----i a 4 -------- ------ --------W. -----•- ---- 't--- --- ____ ..---- IL it •Nos Asu ORir Psei Alos ,ova', ,. SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT American Government Services Corporation 3812 W. Linebaugh Avenue Tampa, Florida 33618 813-933-3322 Contractor's Tax I.D. No.: 59-2346160 AGSC Search Number: 30170-5 Project Name: Benton Road THE UNDERSIGNED does hereby certify that a search has been made of the Public Records of Collier County, State of Florida through July 1, 2020 at 8:00 a.m. for Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, PA, for the specific purpose of researching ownership and easements to determine access for Benton Road. Legal Description: The South 1/2 of the SW 1/4 of the SE 1/4 of the SW 1/4, lying and being in Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. Current Owner(s): Trevor Dean Arnold and Hye Shin Pak -Arnold, husband and wife P4ailing Address on Deed: 1.2955 White Violet Drive Naples, FL 34119 By: Warranty Deed From: Michael P. Openlander and Brenda Openlander, f/k/a Brenda Hanson, husband and wife Dated: November 16, 2016 Filed and Recorded: November 18, 2016 In Official Records Book No.: 5335 Page: 1662 The following Easements were found of records affecting the subject property: 1. Grant of Easement by Joseph Cunningham, dated May 24, 1983 and recorded June 7, 1983 in Official Records Book 1025, Page 683. 2. Easement for Rights -of -Way and Roadway Purposes from Joseph Cunningham, in favor of the general public, dated September 18, 1985 and recorded October 14, 1985 in Official Records Book 1159, Page 1956. 3. Easement from Brenda Hanson to Florida Power & Light Company, dated November 23, 2007 and recorded December 11, 2007 in Official Records Book 4310, Page 2504. !NOTE: All of the above documents recorded in the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, unless otherwise noted. Parcel information: Parcel ID No.: 00324200007 CERTIFICATION: AS TO THE ORIGINAL SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT: The undersigned hereby certifies that the foregoing SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT reflects a comprehensive search of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, showing only the ownership and easements affecting the lands as requested. American Government Services Corporation assumes no responsibility for any defects or omissions in or from the instruments appearing in the chain of title to the property described herein, which defects or omissions would render such instruments void. This report is furnished at your request for information only and is not to be construed as a title opinion or a guarantee of title. It is not a title insurance policy. The liability of American Government Services Corporation is limited to $1000.00 per report and shall not in any event exceed the maximum liability as set forth under F.S. 627.7843 (3). Searc .July 1, 2020 @ 8:00 a.m.: Tammy ehl American Government Services Corporation 2 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Site Site Site Parcel No 00324200007 Address Zone *Disclaimer City *Note Name / ARNOLD, 'TREVOR DEAN Ad d ress HYE SHIP' PAK-A.R... D 12955 WHITE VIOLET DRIVE City "iAPLES Map No. Strap No. 4C24 000100 107 4C24 State FL 'Zip 34119 Section Township Range * Acres Estimated 24 49 27 _ 5 Legal 24 49 27 S1/2 OF SW1/4 OF SE1/4 OF SW'1/4 5 AC. Millage Area 62 Millage Rates 0 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 100 - ACREAGE HEADER School Other Total Use Code 0 99 - ACREAGE NOT ZONED 5.083 &.3071 11.3901 AGRICULTURAL Latest Sales History (Not all Sales are (listed Blue to Confidentiality) Date Book -Page Amount 11/16/16 5340-2633 $ 0 11/16/16 5335-1662 $ 41,000 '11/11/16 ; 5335-1660 $ 0 06/15/06 4055-4090 $ 0 05/11/06 ' 4035-933 $ 0 01/31/05 3724-3823 $, 0 01/05/05 3709-4114 $ 0 12/29/04 3 705-1683 $ 67,000 07/03/01 ,2852-3390 $ 15,000 03/15/90 1512-2200 $ 0 2019 Certified Tax Roll (Subject to Change) Land Value $ 32,950 (+) Improved Value $ 0 (_) Market Value $ 32,950 (_) Assessed Value $ 32,950 (_) School Taxable Valve $ 32,950 (_) 'Taxable Value $ 32,950 if all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Ta:K R®1I INSTR 5336370 OR 5335 PG 1662 RECORDED 11/18/2016 2:56 PM PAGES 2 DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA DOC@.70 $287.00 REC $18.50 INDX $1.00 CONS $41,000.00 CONSIDERATION: $41,000.00 Prepared by and return to: Joshua D. Rudnick Attorney at Law Woods, Weidenmiller, Michetti, Rudnick & Galbraith, PLLC 9045 Strada Steil Court Fourth Floor Naples, FL 34109 239-325-4070 File Number: 16190-001 Will Call No.: Parcel Identification No. 00324200007 Above This Line For Recording Warranty Deed (STATUTORY FORM - SECTION 689.02, F.S.) This Indenture made this 16th day of November, 2016 between Michael P. Openlander and Brenda Openlander (Vk/a Brenda Hanson), husband and wife whose post office address is 4180 Golden Gate Boulevard E, Naples, FL 34120 of the County of Collier, State of Florida, grantor*, and Trevor Dean Arnold and Hye Shin Pak -Arnold, husband and wife whose post office address is 12955 White Violet Drive, Naples, FL 34119 of the County of Collier, State of Florida, grantee*, Witnesseth that said grantor, for and in consideration of the sum of TEN AND NO/100 DOLLARS ($10.00) and other good and valuable considerations to said grantor in hand paid by said grantee, the receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, has granted, bargained, and sold to the said grantee, and grantee's heirs and assigns forever, the following described land, situate, lying and being in Collier County, Florida, to -wit: South 1/2 of the Southwest 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of the Southwest 1/4 of Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. Subject to ad valorem taxes for the year 2016 and subsequent years; zoning, building code and other use restrictions imposed by governmental authority; outstanding oil, gas and mineral interests of record if any; and restrictions, reservations and easements common to the subdivision. TOGETHER WITH all the tenements, hereditaments and appurtenances thereto belonging or in anywise appertaining. TO HAVE AND TO HOLD the above described premises, with the appurtenances, unto the said grantee, its successors and assigns, in fee simple forever. and said grantor does hereby fully warrant the title to said land, and will defend the same against lawful claims of all persons whomsoever. * "Grantor" and "Grantee" are used for singular or plural, as content requires. DoubleTimee *** OR 5335 PG 1663 *** In Witness Whereof, grantor has hereunto set grantor's hand and seal the day and year first above written. Signed, se elivee our presence as to both%�� r� i —Tgea Alefiael P. enlander Witness Name: / (], Brenda Openlander State of Florida County of Collier The foregoing instrument was acknowledged and witnessed before me t}i s o mb016 by Michael P. Openlander and Brenda Openlander, who [j are personally known or [N' have pr ce riv 's licen as identification. [Notary Seal] 1,10""Nk4 JACOUIEANDREWS Nota �..me- rMY co.w.wiloN # FE 8448d8EXPIRES: December 22,2016 ry rs Prd/ L ' Gl-e Bonded PutiicUndenvdkrs My Commission Expires: Warranty Deed (Statutory Form) - Page 2 DoubleTime® • V U 8 5 C 1 ;.nn ,, f jP '. r. L[ra CTUNTY MOUND RLIC,600 D [got INT ,;Pat:';' 01 LA, ; :MP!'!! This easement is given thl:+ day Of 1983. Grantor hereby reserves, excepts. grants and declares an easement for right of way in favor of grantor and tits of respective heirs, successors and assigns, and also n avor- all current owners of abutting lands on, over, under and along the wp*r is Fr- AN* TOVVro 3oF r aF. MW a M or ros a W'* �C3 n 0 o CD N ul VFi,nf. r7O•lY f -=tea --- _+—" -.w-ti.� i - �� C7 . CM This easement shall be appurtenant to the dominant estates A C*, and shall run with the land. C! M CAP In Witness Whe , ` a � reunto set his hand 3n: r. seal, o`h w e Ste ' . "�.•.. AM W1xN�-SS �T E� CaNN/N N STATE OF FL COUNTY OF I HEREBY � duly authorized said to take ackn J. by t on this day, ®.te aforesa A- , and officer e County afore- ;c me xncwn to be.the person described in and who executed the :aregoi ng nstr ...er.t a.-.- ?crnc:.ledged tc ne t:^.at executed same. :I�• ::5: hard an ;,d,` '`-c-ai s��a� it •�.:v County .as-,as'orpsaid�this:f�„ sea �• :otar•: Public "r�Ot'"-?: - ;V ro ...aa sr rr•+r %k 4 trwR �+�11R ..... This instrument prepared by: nsepo commly6mm —�-5---,►'��-+�c�--rep 317-7 Rec: $9.00 Stamps .50 0 0 9 6 2 3 5 2 1985 OCT 14 ON & I8 CILLIER COUNTY RECORDED EASEMENT FOR RIGHTS -OF -WAY AND ROADWAY PURPOSES CD IM JOSEPH cUNNINGHAM, hereinafter referred to as "Grantor", in consideration of TEN DOLLARS ($10.00), the receipt of which is x r cc hereby acknowledged, does hereby declare and grant an easement for rights -of -way, road purposes, and utility right-of-way to and in favor of the general public over the following described portions of said property. d The West 15 feet and the South 30 feet of the South 1/2 of the „V o am Southwest 1/4 of the at ae -1�4 of the Southwest 1/4 of rn CM Section 24, Towns County, Florida. an Grantor does and right to utility rights a cost and expen To have and manner and for then the of Id the same unI5 nd purposes of W-E C1W full authority for all proper purposes at the public. nq;al public in the IN WITNESS WHEREOF, JOSEPH CUNNINGHAM has set his hand and seal this 1 4 -- day of WITNESSES: J PH INGHAM FORSYTH, SWALM & BRUGGER, P.A., Attorneys a) haw. 600 FUth Avenue South. Suite 210. Naples. MwWa 33%0 S E� 1 •I �'9 OR BOOK 00 195 7 PAGE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER I hereby certify that on this day, before I me, an officer duly authorized in the State and County aforesaid to take acknowledgments, personally appeared ri09EPH CUNNINGHm, to me known to be the person described in and who executed the above instrument and he acknowledged executing the same in the presence of two subscribing witnesses freely and voluntarily. Witness my hand and official seal in the County and state last aforesaid this day of 1985. ,. .. coux Notary Pub1 My Connie; o E rag: v;)'41,."I -��. IOTA Y PUBLIC STATE or rtWoot BY CO ISSIOM EXP. KC 16,1980 BOBDE i880 GEKM IBS. UID. , Received $ • rS'O Documentcry Sta�—rpTa—x Collier County, Florido William J: Rear, erk D.C. bY&4 ASIA7 This instrument prepared by: john.N. Brugger, Esq. Forsyth, Swalm & Brugger, .P.A. Rocoff%daim v„nt, 600 Fifth Avenue South, Suite 210 t0 4�r�rcpu�r R ►�ti� na Naples, Florida 33940 FM* o+0VA c«w FORSYTH. SWALM & SRUGGER. P.A.. Attorneys at Law. 600 Nth Avenue South. Suite 210. Naples. Flodda 33940 Work Order No. 2711744 Sec.24 , Twp 49 S, Rge 27 E Parcel I.D. #00324200007 (Maintained by County Appraiser) EASEMENT This Instrument Prepared By Name: "Mahmoud Abu-Hantash Co. Name: PPL Co. Address: 4105 le Ave SW *** 4105259 OR: 4310 PG: 2504 *** RICORDID ill OFFICIAL RBCOVS of COLLIER COUNTY, FL 12/11/2007 at 12:08P11 DWI2T R. SROCL, CLINK RSC 111 10.00 DOC-30 .70 Form 3722-A (Stocked) Rev, 7/94 Naples, FL 34116 Retn:FFL CO The undersigned, in consideration of the payment of $1.00 and other good A405 15l8 AVB SW valuable consideration, the adequacy and receipt of which is hereby acknowledgdWLIS FL 34116 grant and give to Florida Power & Light Company, its licensees, agents, successors, and assigns, an easement forever for the construction, operation and maintenance of overhead and underground electric utility facilities (including wires, poles, guys, cables, conduits and appurtenant egwpment) to be installed from time to time; with the right to reconstruct, improve, add to, enlarge, change the voltage, as well as, the size of and remove such facilities or any of them within an easement 10 feet in width described as follows: The West 15 feet of the South half of the Sout(west quarter of the Southeast quarter of the Southwest quarter, 5 AC, of Section 24 of Township 49 Range 27, of the Public Records of West Collier County, Florida, 1925 Benton Rd., Naples, FL 34117. To ether with the rigid to permit any other person, firm or corporation to attach wires to any facilities hereunder and lay cable and conduit within the easement and to operate the same for comnnmications purposes; the right of ingress and egress to said premises at all times; the right to clear the land and k it cleared of all trees, undergrowth and other obstructions within the easement area; to trim and cut and keep trimmed and cut all dead, we leaning or dangerous trees or limbs outside of the easement area which might interfere with or fall upon the lines or systems of commumications or power transmission or distribution; and fiuther grants, to the fullest extent the undersigned has the power to grant, if at all, the rights hereinabove ;led on described, over, along, under and across the roads, streets or highways adjoining or through said property. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the undersigned has �aledhis ins 20 d7 W and delivered of:(Witness'Signature) + S � X Ui4ed7 (witness) .n� (Witness' Signature) r pm —toes ta�ure) az, HAnStiaorl :0) Gotclo^ GoAv— S' r~fgi,► �1. t F-4, 3 �-J X o Print Name J-11 Print N ;all0,21 s. it signature) 0 joent Andt:r (lotdwA Qpzie.'6W - C (V'e__Z Nc�plas, fir! 3y 1Zo S�T�ATE OF _F'l d� AND COUNTY OF --. >s e c . The foregoing instrument was acknowledged befog 1� da�� of %i6YC'('n f , 20�, by t1(QAtGi1S6 t'1 d- M'<A ZA r who is(are) personally known to me or has(have) produced D r �V4 (- I�L� ±1 �e as identification, and who did (did not) rake an oath. My Commission Expires: (Type of Identification) Notary Public, Signature Print Name l auaawwt�z � � „ wYri ooliti4964 * EXPIRES: Jura 15,1010 ea*d Tft W NOY S 'A01 me this Le(and SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT American Government Services Corporation 3812 W. Linebaugh Avenue Tampa, Florida 33618 813-933-3322 Contractor's Tax I.D. No.: 59-2346160 AGSC Search Number: 30170-6 Project Name: Benton Road THE UNDERSIGNED does hereby certify that a search has been made of the Public Records of Collier County, State of Florida through July 1, 2020 at 8:00 a.m. for Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, PA, for the specific purpose of researching ownership and easements to determine access for Benton Road. Legal Description: The South 1/2 of the SE 1/4 of the SE 1/4 of the SW 1/4, lying and being in Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. Current Owner(s): Edward C. Templeton and Julie S. Templeton, husband and wife Mailing Address on Deed: 2150 Benton Road Naples, FL 34117 By: Warranty Deed From: Julie S. Templeton, a married woman, joined in by Edward C. Templeton, her husband Dated: August 4, 1997 Filed and Recorded: August 13, 1997 In Official Records Book No.: 2338 Page: 1353 The following Easements were found of records affecting the subject orooerty: 1. Easement from Julie T. Scannell and Susan Miller, to Florida Power & Light Company, dated recorded January 13, 1984 in Official Records Book 1061, Page 331. 2. Easement for Rights -of -Way and Roadway Purposes from Julie T. Scannell and Susan Miller, in favor of the general public, dated August 26, 1985 and recorded October 14, 1985 in Official Records Book 1159, Page 1952; as hereby revoked and recorded in Official Records Book 1186, Page 389. 3. Easement for Rights -of -Way and Roadway Purposes from Julie T. Scannell and Susan Miller, as Tenants in Common, in favor of the general public, dated October 24, 1985 and recorded March 31, 1986 in Official Records Book 1186, Page 391. NOTE: All of the above documents recorded in the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, unless otherwise noted. Parcel information: Parcel ID No.: 00324240009 CERTIFICATIOP:: AS TO THE ORIGINAL SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT: The undersigned hereby certifies that the foregoing SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT reflects a comprehensive search of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, showing only the ownership and easements affecting the lands as requested. American Government Services Corporation assumes no responsibility for any defects or omissions in or from the instruments appearing in the chain of title to the property described herein, which defects or omissions would render such instruments void. This report is furnished at your request for information only and is not to be construed as a title opinion or a guarantee of title. It is not a title insurance policy. The liability of American Government Services Corporation is limited to $1000.00 per report and shall not in any event exceed the maximum liability as set forth under F.S. 627.7843 (3). Searched thr ugli_July 1, 20 @ 8:00 a.m.: T American Government Services Corporation 2 Collier County Property Appraiser � Property Summary Parcel Site 2150 Site �Ji to No 00324240009 Address �stCit NTON NAPLES _ o.ne 34117 *Disclaimer RD y *Nt /may tA Name / TEMPLETON, EDWARD C Address J U L I E TEMPLET 0iV 2150 BENTON RD City N APLES State FL Z2P ' 34117-8891 Map No. Strap No. Section Township Range ` Acres Estimated ..._ .... . 4C24 000100 108 4C 24 24 49 27 5 Legal 24 49 27 S1/2 OF SE1/4 OF SE1/4 OF SW1/4 Millage Area 62 11�1_iilage Rates o *Calculations Sub./Condo 100 - ACREAGE HEADER School Other Total Use Code 0 1 - SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 5.083 6.3071 11.3901 Latest Sales History (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) Date Book -Page Amount 08/13/97 2338-1353 $ 0 05/01/90 1527-939 $ 25,000 04/01 /80 866-1606 $ 0 12/01/78 787-171 1. $ 4,000 2019 Certified Tax Roll (Subject to Change) Land Value $ 32,950 t+) Improved Value $ 19,703 (_) Market Value $ 52,653 (-) Save our Home $ 22,169 (_) Assessed Value $ 30,484. (-) Homestead $ 25,000 (_) School Taxable Value $ 5,484 (_) Taxable Value $ 5,484 If all Values shown above egpal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *** 2215152 OR; 2338 K: 1353 *** BCD DID 11 011IC111 HCORD1 of C061111 Con".., It ISM/11 at 11:11M DIIM- 19 IWK. CUB 'd I1C ni 6.00 n �o Doc-.10 .11 to' I1►t�: IICOBAI 01I1I1 1t 11 GD1D11 Gtl PM Mi rwod iD N..I' 0032 6240009 Oman in M: AREA WITHOUT THE BENEFIT OF TITLE EXAMINATION Warranty Deed 11& Indenture, Made thiui 4/ 4% - day of August, 1997 A.D., Hctween Julie S. Templeton, a married woman, joined in by Edgard C. Templeton, her husband, ofwcom.yof Collier , aw.ot Florida , grantor, W Edward C. Templeton and Julie S. Templeton, husband and wife, wbn - wnw L; 2150 Benton Road, Naples, Florida 34117 ofw w cowy,w Collier , saof Florida , gntntees. u �7 k *0 dw GRANTOR, for OW in COiYK styli al Of IIM sum Of — — - — — -► — — — — — — — — - - - - - - - - - - TEN it NO/ 100 I; 610. 00 j - - - - - - - - - - DOLLARS. W awr SW aai vaiwbae coaw&rsaioai w MU TOR Is bead p 6l by GiRAN ITEM. abe mcio i4ereof is busby acbaoariodrd, has VaMC bwp Wed W aid ao ON aid 4RANTIM aad GRANTEN' rein aad assisaf '"N-V ON Waowwl dse ftW Lad, Www. h,y «r baw jsw cawy of Collier u�orida to wit: 'rho South half of the S of the Southeast quarter of the Southw or o n 24, Township 490 South, Range 27 East sat of ingre d egress over and &cores the East 30 tee of, said la d ituate, lying and being in Collier Cqun , for Subject to restrii if any, and taxes su asements of record, W w psaw dose busby toy wuraw w trio do aid Lad. and wig defied lim, same osaiM LwL1 chic, ofell perean wbomwever. In Wknass Wbereof, dw gnaw ik" I..nwo w dru baoc *ad anal the at.y W you errs above w,;naa. swW and delivered in our pce: (sal) pt nt a /a: _ _ _- - n Jy i S. Temp eto /�lif itne s w P. IWdnar 214 Mao& Raad, Naples11. 341117 Printed Names .i!�'r�, k� V ,"' ` __�I Edward C. Templeton EASEMENT Font 3722 lSlaik,el R,•a. arao, Date 10,/20 ig 03 ER No.PW 9510-I-540 Pole Na. Sec. 24 Twp. 49S Rge• 27E By: 'John P: Krill t. FPL Naples, FL 33939 The undersigned, owner (s) of the premises described below, in consideration of the payment of s i m and other fj " . good and valuable consideration, the adequacy and receipt of which Is hereby acknowledged, grant and give to Florida Power } A Light Company, Its licensees, agents, successors, and assigns, an easement forever for the construction, operation and + maintenance of overhead and underground electric utility facilities (including wires, poles, guys, cables, condulis and appur- tenant equipment) to be installed from time to time; with the right to reconstruct, improve, add to, enlarge, change the size of ( and remove such faelliito a or any of them, on the property described as follows: LLI o r The best Ten (10) Feet of. the'East Thirty (30) Fast o and the North Ten (10) Feet of the East Sixty (60) CD wW Feet less the East Thirty (30) Feet of the South a 1*,. of the SE 14 of the SE ►a of the SW % of Section 24, � ;. ". Tkp 49S, Rye 27E of Collier County, Florida. i i Received $ .--c-'-- Tax Co >` Documentary Stomp .C" Collier County, Florida .tom witiiarrt J. Reagan, Clerk u� by cc' !�ogether with the right to permit any oth to able and conduit within rise right of t� c -and egress to said premises at all tl within Ulc easement area: to tri nd outside of the casement area w It ml mission or distribution, and f her gr I hereinabove granted on the la d her o(I through said property. ,. IN WITNESS agreement on Signed. sealed and delivered in the presence of: ;,.•t w to the same ror mtgtt se land and keep it cleareJ tr keep trimmed and cut ail dead, w or fall upon the lines or sy h ulkst hgned has lcri over,alona and un r the ror ti Co -0 0 7s w to any facilities hereunder and lay rn g,yl purposes with the right of ingress ndergrowUl or other obstroctlons to g or dangerous trees or limbs is o4ommunications or power trans- � powq to grant, If at an, the rights ptreet r highways adjoining or (SEAL) (SEAL) STATE OF FLORIDA AND COUNTY OF The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this day of by and respectively the President and Secretary of .a corporation, on behalf of the corporation • NOTARY PUBLIC. STATE OF FLORIDA MY COMMISSION eXPIRES, r . ti.�tgt•,.ljra,, •� STATE OFTLORIDA AND COUNTY OF !' w -S �.1,,..• The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this l day of Q,r.3�4yi ; s " •• 7 .t-i3t by ,;n.t Q 4: and Ilatary Milt, Stale of florlds at Will My Commission Esp':ms Jan. 14, 19a4 NOTARY PUBLIC, STATE OF FLOR WaN in,. in, tin t....... I... MY COMMISSION EXPIRESt r Rec: $9.00 Stamps:.50 00962350 1985 OCT 14 AN 8 !S CILLIER COUNTY RECORDED EASEMENT FOR RIGHTS -OF -WAY AND ROADWAY PURPOSES JULIE T. SCANNELL and SUSAN MILLER, tenants in common, hereinafter referred to as "Grantors", in consideration of TEN DOLLARS ($10.00), the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, do a o hereby declare and grant an easement for rights -of -way, road ; 00 „r purposes, and utility right-of-way to and in favor of the general CD vt public over the following described portions of said property. �K cm The East 30 feet, the North 30 feet, and the West 30 feet of the South 1/2 of the Southeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of the Southwest 1/4 of Section 24, Township 49, Range 27, Collier County, Florida.' -D cc 0 G) fT1 Ln Grantors do h e rant to the genera p is full authority sw and right to a to u an se d eas en for all proper utility rights- f-w r n ad purposes at the cost and expeno an th of k _ tl n al public. To have and 1 old the same manner and for th �e and purposes IN WITNESS WHEREOF, $C their hands and seals this i• WITNESSES% public in the SUSAN MILLER have set —, 1985. Ct.ti E T. JCANNELL USAx MILLE �.+ FORSYTH, SWAL.M & BRUGGER, P.A., Attorneys at Law. 600 Fifth Avenue South. Sure 210. Naples, Florida 33tM0 s 001159 OR BOOK STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER 001953 PAGE' I hereby certify that on this day, before me, an officer duly authorized in the State and County aforesaid to take acknowledgments, personally appeared JULIE T. SCANNELL and SUSAN MILLER to me known to be the persons described.in and who executed the above instrument and they acknowledged executing the same in the presence of two subscribing witnesses freely and voluntarily. witness my hand and official seal in the County and State last aforesaid this —1;—Oday of r 1985. 0% A✓ Notary Public ssion xpi as: :.'. 10. OW AT WIDE M is 90,1 Vo Received $ Docurr+e•itor/ Stamp Tax Cc,Mit,?r C Li^`%, Florida rf,.Eler D.C. J This instrument prepared by: John N. Brugger, Esq. Forsyth, Swalm & Brugger, P.A. 600 Fifth Avenue South, Suite 210 L°;�; Ro;r Naples, Florida 33940 4"Mµf Nryi1.—tM Sluk of Wh� FORSYTH, SWALM & BRUGGER, P.A.. Attorneys at Law. 600 FIOhAvenue South, Suite 210. Naples. Florida 3.3940 P Rec. $9.00 STamps .50 N REVOCATION OF EASEMENT o� Ln FOR RIGHTS -OF -WAY AND ROADWAY PURPOSES ab � o w M w JULIE T. SCANNELL and SUSAN MILLER, tenants in common, sUj °C hereinafter referred to as "Grantors", do hereby revoke the easement for rights -of -way, road purposes, and utility right-of-way to and in favor of the general public, as recorded on October 14, 1985, in O. R. Book 1159 at Pages 1952 and 1953, of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, over the following described property. N Cn w p co d ® The East 30 feet, the and the West 30 feet ce Cn o " the South 1/2 of J Southeast 1/4 of the Southwest 1/4 f ion 24, Township o th, Range 27 East, of Collier C nty, for da- r1% Grantors do he b r ok he' a t ge eral public the o -b o full authority ii i o n on d s id easement for eo all proper uti rights -of -way, gre s egress and rose to purposes at tht and expense sole risk of the general public. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, JULI ELL and SUSAN MILLER, tenants in common, have set their hands and seals this �o A- day of �� l , 1985. WITNESSES: 1 0(- 1166 000390 OR GOOK PAGE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER I hereby certify that on this day, before me, an officer duly authorized in the State and County aforesaid to take acknowledg- ments, personally appeared JULIE T. SCANNELL and SUSAN MILLER, to me known to be the persons described in and who executed the above instrument and they acknowledged executing the same in the presence of two subscribin spE� ly and voluntarily. Witness my han offic 1 seal in t my and State last aforesaid this r a o , 19 •�:= � Pub i M is E s: LIC STATE OF FLORID N A ••.....•... aY 1 .'y.; 510P1 E1:,ineS OCT 23 1797 UN0 �G1`�DFB °U MRAL INSURANCE d Received $ Documentary Stamp Tax Collier County, Florida ,. William J. Reagan, Clerk o_ by ^""" I ? D.C; This instrument prepared by: John N. Brugger, Esq. R.0 ;'4Uads -4 Forsyth, Swalm & Srugger, P.A. —4AMI "M ). F&A °N 60o Fifth Avenue South, Suite 210 �! " c Naples, Florida 33940 t ■ Rec. $9.00 ( f f P,6 flQ039 i Stamps .50 aoaK PAGE OR EASEMENT FOR RIGHTS -OF -WAY AND ROADWAY PURPOSES JULIE T. SCANNELL and SUSAN MILLER, tenants in common, hereinafter referred to as "Grantors", in consideration of TEN C] c3 DOLLARS ($10.00), the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, does w cr hereby declare and grant an easement for rights -of -way, road 93 purposes, and utility right-of-way to and in favor of the general public over the following described property. The South 30 feet the South 1/2 of the Southeast 1/4 of the to �' Southeast 1/4 of the Southwest 1/4 of Section 24, Township 49 N C South, Range 27 East Florida. d7 � rn 1 . 0 o o L' Grantors do h eb rant to the general ub 'c full authority and right to to u d use ease en t for all proper utility rights- f-w , e a ad urposes at the cost and expens an a th 1 t n al public. To have and old the same unt h g 1 public in the manner and for the u es and purposes afore '`.. d. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, nd SUSAN MILLER, tenants in common, have set their hands and seals this= day of ..li[�{�'� , 1985. t WITNESSES: a 6NM (1)-1 14o w +. w I z i FORSYTH. SWALM & BRUGGER. P.A.. Anomeys ai Law. 6W Fifth Avenue South. Suite 210, Napks. Florida M940 1 ■ HIM 000392 OR BOOK PAGE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER I hereby certify that on this day, before me, an officer duly authorized in the State and County aforesaid to take acknowledg- ments, personally appeared JULIE T. SCANNELL and SUSAN MILLER, to me known to be the persons described in and who executed the above instrument and they acknowledged executing the same in the presence of two subscribing_wit ss'" -rely and voluntarily. witness my han ''1 fficial seal in my and State last aforesaid this a o , 19 5. 'r o Pub ii - .r •, i 4r PU l E OF FLO%ZDA *C �ea�ived $ ..urnentary Stamp Tax Collier County, Florida wi''m-. 1. 1::e90n, Clerk �•-1i •t"' RRveC.i aM Y.rt(I.w �p�yl�nO I•�yM.f `c �•� 1pA --iViI.LILLUI pEAGj,N trit< p�tircun Cwr' This instrument prepared by: John N. Brugger, Esq. Forsyth, Swalm & Brugger, P.A. 600 Fifth Avenue South, Suite 210 Naples, Florida 33940 FORSYTH. SWALM & BRUGGER. P.A.. Attorneys 41 Lour. 600 Filth Avenue South. Suite 210. Naples. Florida 33940 SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT American Government Services Corporation 3812 W. Linebaugh Avenue Tampa, Florida 33618 813-933-3322 Contractor's Tax I.D. No.: 59-2346160 AGSC Search Number: 30170-7 Project Name: Benton Road THE UNDERSIGNED does hereby certify that a search has been made of the Public Records of Collier County, State of Florida through July 1, 2020 at 8:00 a.m. for Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, PA, for the specific purpose of researching ownership and easements to determine access for Benton Road. Legal Description: The South 1/2 of the SW 1/4 of the SW 1/4 of the SE 1/4, lying and being in Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. Current Owner(s): Linda Miceli, f/k/a Linda Valerie Brown Mailing Address on Deed: 2300 28th Ave SE Naples, FL 34964 By: Quit Claim Deed From: James Brown and Linda Brown, husband and wife Dated: April 20, 1990 Filed and Recorded: September 18, 1991 In Official Records Book No.: 1648 Page: 1145 Marriage Records recorded in Official Records Book 1597, Page 1075 The following Easements were found of records affecting the subject property: 1. Easement for Rights -of -Way and Roadway Purposes from Benton H. Owen, joined by his spouse, Helen D. Owen in favor of the general public, dated October 10, 1985 and recorded October 14, 1985 in Official Records Book 1159, Page 1944, as affected by Maintenance and Repair Agreement between Helen Owen, Debra Vantine, Kenneth Vantine, Charles Campbell and Margaret Campbell recorded October 28, 1986 in Official Records Book 1225, Page 1734. COTE: All of the above documents recorded in the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, unless otherwise noted. Parcel information: Parcel ID No.: 00324280001 i CERTIFICATION: AS TO THE ORIGINAL SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT: The undersigned hereby certifies that the foregoing SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT reflects a comprehensive search of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, showing only the ownership and easements affecting the lands as requested. American Government Services Corporation assumes no responsibility for any defects or omissions in or from the instruments appearing in the chain of title to the property described herein, which defects or omissions would render such instruments void. This report is furnished at your request for information only and is not to be construed as a title opinion or a guarantee of title. It is not a title insurance policy. The, liability of American Government Services Corporation is limited to $1000.00 per report and shall not in any event exceed the maximum liability as set forth under F.S. 627.7843 (3). Searche rough J ly 1, 2020 @ 8:00 a.m.: y t4ehl American Government Services Corporation ON Collier County Property Appraiser 7 Property Summary Parcel Site 2055 Site - `,Site No 00324280001 Address BENT ON City, NAPLES one 34117 *Disclaimer RD Note Name Address / M ICELI, LI N DA 2300 28TH AVE SE City NAPLES Map No. Strap No. 4C24 000100 109 4C24 State FL Zip 34117-8857 Section Township Range Acres Estimated 24 49 27 5 Legal 24 49 27 S1/2 OF SW1/4 OF SWV1/4 OF SE1/4 5 AC. OR 1648 g Pv i 145 Millage Area 6-� Millage Rates 0 0 'kCalculations Sub./Condo 100 - ACREAGE HEADER School Other Total Use Code 0 2 - MOBILE HOMES 5.083 6.3071 11.3901 Latest Sales History (loot all sales are listed due to Confidentiality) Date Book -Page Amount 09/18/911648-1145 $ 0 10/01/90 1576-446 $ 0 06/01/87 '1275-388 $ 39,900 10/01/86 '1225-1733 $ 0 2019 Certified Tax Roll (Subject to Change) Land Value $ 32,950 (+) Improved Value $ 59,508 (_) Market Value $ 92,458 (-) Save our Home $ 33,356 (_) Assessed Value $ 59,102 (-) Homestead $ 25,000 (_) School Taxable Value $ 34,102 (-) Additional Homestead $ 9,102 (-) Taxable Value $ 25,000 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Boll .a1- co ti to sttatf•tsa:atetsm td f5 �fasl L �rynpej ft Q6jjw(WM DO& f MNYMM -4-- 4—.0 Apr II % r) It 4)9 •V� p . ft tta *& 8r+wn and 14oda UO" a hueb oad and Vitt , (ill ft st "ft lo tsioda brown to 0,6",pti&& kir04ef„ I 2300 28th AV*- SA NOP1 ru, !►la. 33944 sarerMa pwTt •witrwr••wr Vve err.+... aw n»•.. ,,.... ....• .r..,,,f o,,,.• � •n.•n .wtuN H»annw wM.e«0a.« .ew+"► � wwt ww,x. ,f .fN. 1NIi� wN, •M nIr M.M fief ,.•MN w w►p,,,nl•n+ iM airltlttU .,•f NWgrN 1 r. itS�1l iir.r fhv.e..f first •,Nv inr rent t•t ronrnir•e wo of thd, sn►s of 't Tofu 40 its tN fMfld par4 by rite set4 srt:otuf pa,fT. tier hrrrf+f n•i•r,raf 1. t•rrrt., arttnent•trrfgrsf, d -t +.errfry remise• fir1 l?istrf0 note, lying rr, oft true nghr, sett, tnlffest, cfenn end ,n base first( qu11•cfnUrt nnM the ford second t•errr fR,rg dr rr6tt the Bahl first party bes in an4 to the foilnu.UH1 •frvrtfer,f 1.11. piece or paf wl of lend. off nand to the County of Col Tier Starr, of Florida , to rt• The South 1/2 of the Southwest 1/4 of the Southwest 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 27 Bast, less aright -of -way Easement over the South 30 feet and West 15 feet thereof, said land lying, being and situated in Collier County, Florida, together with a 1978 NE M 13.51 x 610 Mobile Rome, Serial #13002627, including all attachments and improvements thereto. This is an interspousal conveyance with the intent that all title of a the above described properties held Brown and Linda Brown shall inure to rown. uitclaim deed and conveyance is fcs ted to imple property settlement agreement be a arties in as No. 89-3116 20th Judicial Cir u llie C unty, Florida. The agreeme t t s(a e ial equity, and propert i t re t pe p r ies, except for those addi 0 $af to the agreement made a part the record i the ca tt This conveyance of any and a nterest to L a B is a property settlem for her. e^' %me and to tot � � e tnovf b rr Ir• a slnpular the appurtenances !hereunto belontffnt, or i,t Rnyu•Ixa npprrlapd,.� . n. r { h••R. interest. lien, equity and eferm what- soever of rite snid firsl porfv, eitfu•r • r u only prnfrr tuh t'. nnefir and behoof of the card X socond pttrfy )Rrt'rrr. Is witness whereof, r °°' ,/ hR • l.fl firs! pnrf�• 1.,Is slrflled nud ieRled !first pre=eats the day and y first above written. �rr ed, sensed and d-elivened.in p►ea,nee t _): . ........ ......PA.......................... a own (Witness to �+ • elks, c yr } LL fAUJ�1 lJS, CQLLI Witness , L. A'o'w-I �iieoYFtoTide Latgs i HEREE •' CL'R Y that this day. before au, am :asiott �x;uas triftroh28. t883 ,l ttoritcd in the State aferesud and in the County aforesaid t: take acknowledgments, peraonaily aPpe Raymond James Brown to V M •- tft ft *� des, ribry n and who exrru ud the kuve nict instrument and he arhtwwledr; 10"".7gC,•KMi°•n to be the person !tie nlr that he rites led the san.. n•t a{rCr:,t ., s... , • .... '. y ,nA c• • 1,.. 'r...• nW tit 0 ' ' ^•., April 1990. THIS INSTRUMENT PREPARED OR Nota;y ub - -•y My t�bmm scion ex?iG= ; s �,•�t...: ; WITHOUT EXAMINATION 9 OPI�t��AMND41�� itN� � -`� Attol:iby at lave • 2947 p40tsls Avt11f11/ Naples, 3!t394 Iri;ry ve,itieo ...an';'a: Recors or •�.Fbr_Cl!` �itT71%4+'aZ�1V� A' :';.:N TY. FLORIDA RM 24�� r. tlV..— ...,........ ..•..._r. --w"2�".+.�'+._rc_ ._�. ale Record: $9.00 O Q 9 6 2 3 4 6 1985 OCT 14 ON 8; ► 5 Stamps: .50 COLLIER COUNTY RECORDED EASEMENT FOR RIGHTS -OF -WAY AND ROADWAY PURPOSES BENTON H. OWEN,A hereinafter referred to as "Grantor", in � n consideration of TEN DOLLARS ($10.00), the receipt of which is C CD cr. hereby acknowledged, does hereby declare and grant an easement for :;c .fir rights -of -way, road purposes, and utility right-of-way to and in favor of the general public over the following described portions of said property. The South 90 feet of the South 1/2 of the Southwest 1/4 of the Southwest 1/4 of the > t Section 24, Township 49, -a Range 27, Collie or M t4 "s' Grantor doe he ebr� rants--th neral pub is full authority and right to an n a e an for all proper utility rights of a , i r s a r s; oad purposes at the cost and expen s of ewe ,tea public. To have and old the same un t e al public in the manner and for the al d purposes afor t nod. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, BENTON H. OWEN,nhae set *ft hand and seal +»oa- -0•a)ti this loth day of October , 1985. WITNESSES: HENTON H. OWEN )eke D ov✓eni. 11 .�� t°UfiSYiH,SYIALNti It71t1C,t;1:It,1�A., AmonoycrilaW 6M)FNthAvenuatinml1 5ui(r211). NVIL- lurWa:t3"' t0!II59 OR BOOK 001945 'PAGE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER. i hereby certify that on this day, before me, an officer duly authorized in the State .and County aforesaid to take b, owed acknowledgments, personally appeared BENTON H. OWEN,nto me known to be the persong described in and who executed the above instrument and he acknowledged executing the same in the presence of two subscribing witnesses freely and voluntarily. witness my hand and official seal in the County and State last aforesaid this loth day of _ er _., 1985. y` v ' • i Notark Publ E so: • . i �•�--�-- Ssio I��y�• J 4( , it. Fit" TLAME :i 1 is V j"t s+r..y' \a. • ., Je ar," it .It .1z 9tt •N. ING w•,ry%l f�:1i� � Received Docurrle^tory Starrlp TO ? ! Colliar Ccun y. Florida William J. Rca t1, ter D.C.by This instrument prepared by: John Na.Brugger, Esq. Forsyth, Swaim & Brugger, P.A. Goo Fifth'Avenue South, Suite 210 Naples, Florida 33940 F0R5yTt3, SWALM & HRUGGr:R, P.A.. Atltwnvy6 al Law. 61M1 Fl1titAvvttue Soutlt Su"w 2113 Naples, F[midn 33940 i MAINTENANCE AND REPAIR AGREEMENT We, HELEN OWEN. DEBRA VANTINE, KENNETH VANTINE, CHARLES M dd CAMPBELL, and MARGARET CAMPBELL, Grantees and owners of that certain land being more particularly described on the attached a: N Exhibits, in consideration of $10.00 and other good and valuable w o consideration, do hereby agree that Grantees, their heirs, m successors, and assigns, from time to time and at all times hereafter, at their own cost and expense, will repair and maintain in a proper, substantial, and workman -like manner, the cr) >* road right-of-way described in that certain Basement dated October 10, 1985, and recorded in O. R. Book 1159, Pape 2944, of O .rr g the Public Records of Collier County, Plorida. 32 c This duty to repair and maintain shall continue until such 0 C.3 time as, if, and when said g e -of-way is taken over by the County of Collie 11s"16i This duty t �+ and maintain shay in only to that part of the ro ri beginning at 28 Av ue SE, up to and along the pro rt elbe n 8 i it A. This A son t s a a a d owners to repairs and ain a ce t h r g e f n o era along said right of w only nd pro p e access to the land desc in Exhibit A attach her to ((, This Agreem intended to benef a parties to t this Agreement an intended to be t property owners along said right of w ..� CG IN WITNESS WHEREOF, we eunto set our hands this � r day of ©12-4061"' , 1986. (SEAL) �aAFIFJI RECORAINC RrMN r NV1LU01 SC111VIUKIIARD goo AIR*" 'PAY'-" II4P1.V11 t" LAW OFFICE OF WILLIAM SCHWEIXHAROT 900 SIXTH AVENUE. SOYTH, NAPLES, FL 33940 .+aanwo......:,.ena�sryfy:Stx ..• ,.i:`.i::r.::«.;�o.i .. .. :J1; o...cv�.•.-+.-...............w.........o.,H�c .:..t:.N.c:sti�ha:,;...... B»._--.. STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER &��C`?_�� (SEAL) CHARLES CAMP cmO (SEAL) o MAR Q ET CAM BELL Nrt los cA'e I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this day before as an officer duly qualified to take acknowledgments, personally appeared CHARLES CAMPBELL and mNrARLT CAMpBELL tome knownto be the persons described in and who executed the foregoing instrument and acknowledged before me that they executed the same. WITNESS MY HAND aad Official goal in the County and State last aforesaid, this ` day of �, 1986. m `'O p My Commission Expires: i•.. _ Notary Publial cad am. � wxn sTArE a T�caEPA CIO Qn JAR.(AFFIX IMPRESSION SEALI STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER I HEREBY CERTIFY thee qualified to take n w n e VANTINE and KENNETH -'^E0 me described in and xecuted tha acknowledged bef hat they executed th WITNESS my and a o c a i the last aforesaid thi of Commission Exp AN '"y (N a b c BOTANY PUBLIC VAT OF FL DA NY COMMISSION CIP. fft'i' RES • BONDED THAD OCDEAA C65: , STATE OF FLOR COUNTY OF COLL I HEREBY C that on this day bef qualified to take clfeLp edgments, person HELEN OWEN / to described in and w e acknowledged before as t e me, an officer '...:duly lly appeared DEBRA be the persons oinstrument and and State 1986. "4?-i n officer duly' '- • peared : - ; o be the person: g instrument' and same. WITNESS my hand and official eal in the County and State last aforesaid this 14 day of 1986. My Commission Expires: (Notary Public) ROTARY PUBLIC STATE DF TLCAmA ~ j' rrl emu•• - RY COMMISSION EAR, MAR INS. (AFFIX IMPRESSION SEAL) 80NpED iMAO GENERAL INS.. V&DUAO.' LAW OFFICE OF WILLIAM SCHWEIKHAAOT R00 SIXTH AVENUE, SOUTH, NAPLES. FL $3940 'tea•imaT.SwY:�;:�owitcr.''''+��a�`�.+i�#"'.w e'#nxw:;a-iti:s'. aL4.;,:s`S.;bn",Yrst�iust'�a� w...,.... _....-......» .,._�.:.ar.7N,sxtt».n •a::::....., _ ' 001-225 0 KID D 0 K EXHIBIT "A" The South 1/2 of the Southwest 1/4 of the Southwest 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of Section 24. Township 49 South. Range 27 East, Collier County. Florida, together with a 1978 NEWM 13.6'x 61' Mobile Rome, Serial #13002627, Including all attachments and Improvements thereto. EXHIBIT "B" :PAGE. Tracts 72 and 73, Floridian Farm Sites. Inc.. according to the plat thereof recorded In Plat Book 4, Page 30 of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida. ww U/ Win 01j.I01 Recol'R LAW OFFICE OF WILLIAM SCHWEIKHARDT COLUEA CQU14"',IM 000 SIXTH AVENUE, SOUTH, NAPLES, FL 33040 SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT American Government Services Corporation 3812 W. Linebaugh Avenue Tampa, Florida 33618 813-933-3322 Contractor's Tax I.D. No.: 59-2346160 AGSC Search Number: 30170-8 Project Name: Benton Road THE UNDERSIGNED does hereby certify that a search has been made of the Public Records of Collier County, State of Florida through July 1, 2020 at 8:00 a.m. for Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, PA, for the specific purpose of researching ownership and easements to determine access for Benton Road. Legal Description: The SE 1/4 of the SW 1/4 of the SE 1/4, lying and being in Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. Current Owner(s): Ines Torres and Pedro Torres Rivera, wife and husband Mailing Address on Deed: 2:155 Benton Rd Naples, FL 34117 By: Quit Claim Deed From: PFI Builders, Inc., a Florida corporation Dated: April 30, 2019 Filed and Recorded: May 15, 2019 In Official Records Book No.: 5630 Page: 1639 The following Easements were found of records affecting the subject property: 1. Grant of Easement by Little Hickory Shores, Inc., dated June 29, 1983 and recorded August 1, 1983 in Official Records Book 1034, Page 1090; as corrected on January 24, 1985 in Official Records Book 1118, Page 1430. 2. Easement for Rights -of -Way and Roadway Purposes from James L. Walker, President of Little Hickory Shores, Inc., in favor of the general public, dated September 12, 1985 and recorded October 14, 1985 in Official Records Book 1159, Page 1946. NOTE: All of the above documents recorded in the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, unless otherwise noted. Parcel information: Parcel ID No.: 00323880004 CERTIFICATION: AS TO THE ORIGINAL SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT: The undersigned hereby certifies that the foregoing SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT reflects a comprehensive search of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, showing only the ownership and easements affecting the lands as requested. American Government Services Corporation assumes no responsibility for any defects or omissions in or from the instruments appearing in the chain of title to the property described herein, which defects or omissions would render such instruments void. This report is furnished at your request for information only and is not to be construed as a title opinion or a guarantee of title. It is not a title insurance policy. The liability of American Government Services Corporation is limited to $1000.00 per report and shall not in any event exceed the maximum liability as set forth under F.S. 627.7843 (3). Searched thro Ott I, 2020 @ 8:00 a.m.: mmy Me I American Government Services Corporation 2 ro1111fier County Property Appraise' 1 Property Summary Site r2155 Parcel No I00323880004 Address BENTON i Site City NAPLES Site Zone 34117 1*Disclaimer RD Note I Name / Address T-ORRES, INES PEDRO TORRES RIVERA -^ `2155 BENTON RD -_ City I NAPLES . _ State: FL Zip ; 34117_ nAap No. i Strap No.�^ Sections Township Ranged _Acres *Estimated_ I _ 4C24 004100 099 4C24 ! 24 49 27 ? 10 Legal j 4 49.27 SE1/4 OF SWl/4 OF SE1/4 illage Area �62 _— - --f Rates *Calculatio_ns Sub./Condo 100ACREAGE FlEADER �_Mftge - b./C School Other Total 67 - POULTRY, BEES, TROPICAL FISH, _ — , Use Code 40 , 5.083 6.3071 11.3901 �9BITS, E � _._._ Latest Sales History (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) Date Book -Page ' _ Amount 04/30/19 5630 1639 04 04/23%14_ 5030 1526 _ _ _ . _ 07/07/034; 3333-2695L $ 60,000 ` 10/18/99 i 2602 1662 12%28%98� 2495 263 '� $ 0 ' 02®15/95 2030-1134 �-- 03/01/88 1337 850 - $ 0 ! 02%O1/88 1327-1460 $ 01 2019 Certified Tax Roll (Subject Land Value '- $ 65,900 1 (+� Improved Value $ 0' (_) Market Value $ 65,900 (-> Agriculture $ 58,900: (_) Assessed Value $ 7 000' (_) School Taxable Value $ 7,000- (_) Taxable Value _ $ 7,000I If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *** INSTR 5713299 OR 5630 PG 1639 E—RECORDED 5/15/2019 4:42 PM PAGES 1 *** CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT AND COMPTROLLER, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA DOC@.70 $0.70 REC $10.00 CONS $10.00 Prepared by: Ines & Pedro Torres 2155 Benton Rd, Naples, FL 34117 Purchase Price:$0 Quit Claim Deed Made this ApriX, 2019 A.D.by PFI Builders Inc., a Florida corporation, hereinafter called the grantor, to Ines Torres, and Pedro Torres Rivera, wife and husband, whose post office address is: 2155 Benton Rd Naples, FL 34117 hereinafter called the grantee: (Whenever used herein the team "grant° and 'granted include all the parties to this instruct and are heirs, legal rogmentatives and assigns of individuals, and the wceessm and snips of corporations) Witnesseth, that the grantor, for and in consideration of the sum of $ TEN AND N0/100 DOLLARS ($10.00) and other valuable considerations, receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, does hereby remise, release, and quit claim unto the grantee forever, all the right, title, interest, claim and demand which the said grantor has in and to, all that certain land situate in County, Florida, viz: PARCH l: The Southeast 1/4 of the Southwest 114 of the Southeast 1/4 of Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier A County, Florida Parcel ID Number. 003238800D4 PARCEL 2: The West 112 of the NE 114 of the SW 1 /4 of the SE 114 of Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida Parcel ID Number 00324600102 Together with all the tenements, hereditaments and appurtenances thereto belonging or in anywise appertaining. To Have and to Hold, the same together with all and singular the appurtenances thereunto belonging or in anywise appertaining, and all the estate, right, title, interest, lien, equity and claim whatsoever of the said grantor, either in law or equity, to the only proper use, benefit and beboof of the said grantee forever. In Witness Whereof the said grantor has signed and sealed these oresents the day and year first ahnve written Wtnees R� Name_ "/ 4.4 State of Florida County of Collier The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me th Inc. a Florida corporation, who is personally known to me F-711 Y L�5 LedZ.l'r�I:x.r�•.ii:x+alndarrT':wa l'hst Clain Heed Print My( day of Apti 19, by Pedro Torres, President of PFl Builders as identification. :. Q08 4259 1983AUG -I AM11:45 001034 OOi090 COLLIER COUNTY RECORDED OR'EIOOK' P'A6E GRANT OF EASEMENT REC This easement is given this 29th day of June 1983. Grantor hereby reserves, excepts, grants and declares an easement for right. of way in favor of grantor and respective heirs, successors and assigns, and over, also undernandvsron&. all currant owners of abutting lands on, t �.... � f the SE of th M the South 30ft of the SW o" This easement shall be appurtenant to the dominant` e•st,ates' `: Y;. and shall run with the land. In Witness Whereof, the Grantor has hereunto set his';fhand. •;;; and seal, on the date first above••written. .++1� ., LITTLE HICKORY SHORES, INC. I HEREBY CE% duly authorized i said to take ackno James L. Walker, me s L. Wa IK!$r:;. President h me, and officer h the County afore - eared to ,me known to be the pershe ndescribed in antowho execute hat the foregoing instrument and executed the same. WITNESS my hand and official seal in the County andte 1983 l„ ,as,t,aforesaid this 29th day of n"'d Notary Public, My Commission Expires: 4`rSPared Pudic, Siate of Ftosiva al s:+.V�~ptruent pAy Commission Expires ApM 12.1984 by. James L. Walker s.a.ark„u.r�•�+••�� P.G.,Box 475 Naples, Fl. 33939 ant vmtn,i w4llEP�CO�INY�V"O at W,lll.NA f t�gGANqy,K PROKtlp, p•q i e pr:E � tg !lOf�;30 D 0 914 $ 5 l 1985 JAN 24 FN 3: 04 OR BOOK PAGE SLIER COUNTY RECORDED Corrective Grant of Easement for OR 1034 PG 1090 Dated August 1 1983 at 11:45 A.M. This easement is given this otb4nday of: "`''f 1984. Grantor hereby reserves, excepts, grants and declares an easement for right of way in favor of grantor and respective heirs, successors and assigns, and also in favor of all current owners of abutting lands on, over, under and along the South 30 ft. of the BE 1/4 of the SW 1/4 of the SE 1/4 - Sec 24 Twp 49 Rge 27 Collier County, Fl. This easement shall be appurtenant to the dominant estates and shall run with the land. .'ij.f Witness Whereof, the Grantor has hereunto set his hand and s*41, on the date first above written. f c: LITTLE HICKORY SHORES, INC. zd _ 011,,��"' i Witness ,I" , ` times L. u®al.President 0 q, STATE OF F RID P�1 COUNTY OF OLL I HE BY RT FY t at on th.s d re I n o ficer duly auth .ize in the to a fo e a Iand t eunt afore- said to to o e n s, p s n ly ap ar d. .Tames 1t� lker, President of Li le Hi ory s, Inc. .rbb me know the person described d ho ed the foregoing in, t and he acknowledge o t executed the same. [' , WITNESS myofficial s 1 in o f and State last aforesaidth of 984 i C 1 Notary Public My Commission Expires y y This instrument Y time,y Slate o1 iiwida prepared by: James L. Walker My Commiuwn kweApl It 19M P. O. Box 475 Naples, F1. 33939 t t ' c •" OC! 159 001947 OR BOOK PAGE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER I hereby certify that on this day, before me, an officer duly authorized in the state and County aforesaid to take acknowledgments, personally appeared JAMES L: WALKER, President of Little Hickory Shores, Inc., to me known to be the person described in and who executed the above instrument and he acknowledged. executing the same in the presence of two subscribing witnesses freely and voluntarily. Witness my hand and office o��' ii the County and State last aforesaid this da • �' 88. ,•••`S. . may''•• tart' P lie — otr. • ....... 4it s : ty P;✓ ,..; G:V:� � tuYP ao y...~YT .. Ally of ✓,,�E Received $ • e DOCLIM- e-tCf1' Stomp lox Collier Ct-,unty, Florida William J. Reagan �k D,G. - U This instrument prepared by: Wd VNMlfdf John N. Brugger, Esq. 4MMER C-WR 1�r•ifu Forsyth; Swaim & Brugger, P.A. cl;i"c�"el'`" 600 Fifth Avenue South, Suits 210 Naples, Florida 33440 FORSYM. SWALM & BRUGGER. P.A.. Attain" el Lew. 6M tgllhAvenue Soulh. Suitt 210. rbplea. SWde 33'MO SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT American Government Services Corporation 3812 W. Linebaugh Avenue Tampa, Florida 33618 813-933-3322 Contractor's Tax I.D. No.: 59-2346160 AGSC Search Number: 30170-9 Project Name: Benton Road THE UNDERSIGNED does hereby certify that a search has been made of the Public Records of Collier County, State of Florida through July 1, 2020 at 8:00 a.m. for Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, PA, for the specific purpose of researching ownership and easements to determine access for Benton Road. Legal Description: The West 1/2 of the SW 1/4 of the SE 1/4 of the SE 1/4, lying and being in Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. Current Owner(s): Ines Torres and Pedro Torres Rivera, wife and husband Mailing Address on Deed: 2155 Benton Rd Naples, FL 34117 By: General Warranty Deed From: Renee Ann Look, non -homestead Dated: May 14, 2019 Filed and Recorded: May 18, 2019 In Official Records Book No.: 5274 Page: 1484 The following Easements were found of records affecting the subject property: 1. Grant of Easement by William M. Rizzi, dated November 26, 1984 and recorded December 5, 1984 in Official Records Book 1111, Page 2064. 2. Easement for Rights -of -Way and Roadway Purposes from William M. Rizzi, in favor of the general public, dated September 18, 1985 and recorded September 24, 1985 in Official Records Book 1156, Page 2195. MOTE: All of the above documents recorded in the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, unless otherwise noted. Parcel information: Parcel ID No.: 00324600005 CERTIFICATION: AS TO THE ORIGINAL SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT: The undersigned hereby certifies that the foregoing SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT reflects a comprehensive search of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, showing only the ownership and easements affecting the lands as requested. American Government Services Corporation assumes no responsibility for any defects or omissions in or from the instruments appearing in the chain of title to the property described herein, which defects or omissions would render such instruments void. This report is furnished at your request for information only and is not to be construed as a title opinion or a guarantee of title. It is not a title insurance policy. The liability of American Government Services Corporation is limited to $1000.00 per report and shall not in any event exceed the maximum liability as set forth under F.S. 627.7843 (3). Sea rched-thro gI )Jujy 1, 2020 @ 8:00 a.m.: Tammy Mehl American Government Services Corporation 2 Collier County Property Appraiser � Property Summary Parcel Site 2321 Site 'Re No 00324600005 Address BENTON City NAPLES Zone 34'117 *Disclaimer RD *Note Name, / TC'RRE�, INES Address PEDRO TORRES RIVERA 2155 BENTON RD City N APLES Map No. Strap No. 4C24 000100 117 4C'24 State FL Zip 34117 Section Township Range * Acres Estimated ........................... . 24 49 27 5 Legal 24 49 27 W/ 2- '.:F SW1/4 OF SE1/4 OF SE1/4 Miilage_ Area 62 Millage Rates o *Calculations ........... Sub./Condo 100 - ACREAGE HEADER School Other Total Use Code 0 67 - POULTRY, BEES, TROPICAL 5.083 6.3071 11.3901 FISH, RABBITS, E Latest Sales History (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) Date Book -Page Amount 05114-116 5274-1484 $ 40,000 03/20/02 3002-1019 $ 0 09/03/97 2343 -1441 $ 0 02/19/93 '1798-991 $ 0 '10/01/85 '1159-812 $ 12,000 2019 Certified Tax Roll (Subject to Change) Land Value $ 32,950 +) Improved Value $ 0 (_) Market Value $ 32,950 (-) Agriculture $ 29,450 (_) Assessed Value $ 3,500 (_) School 'Taxable Value $ 3,500 (_) Taxable Value $ 3,500 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll INSTR 5267359 OR 5274 PG 1484 RECORDED 5/18/2016 1:41 PM PAGES 2 DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA DOC@.70 $280.00 REC $18.50 CONS $40,000.00 Prepared by: Yomarie Fernandez -Jimenez Title Specialists of the Gulf Coast, Inc. 7370 College Parkway, Suite 201 Fort Myers, Florida 33907 16-0242 Sales Price: $40000 Doc Stamps: $280 General Warranty Deed Made this 4aday of I� A.D. By Renee Ann Look, whose address is: 1060 21st St SW, Naples, Florida 34117, herein er called the grantor, to Ines Torres and Pedro Torres Rivera, wife and husband, whose post office address is: 2155 Benton Rd, Naples, Florida 34117, hereinafter called the grantee: (Whenever used herein the term "grantor" and "grantee" include all the parties to this instrument and the heirs, legal representatives and assigns of individuals, and the successors and assigns of corporations) Witnesseth, that the grantor, for and in consideration of the sum of Ten Dollars, ($10.00) and other valuable considerations, receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, hereby grants, bargains, sells, aliens, remises, releases, conveys and confirms unto the grantee, all that certain land situate in Collier County, Florida, viz: The West 1/2 of the Southwest 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. Parcel ID Number: 00324600005 Together with all the tenements, hereditaments and appurtenances thereto belonging or in anywise appertaining. To Have and to Hold, the same in fee simple forever. And the grantor hereby covenants with said grantee that the grantor is lawfully seized of said land in fee simple; that the grantor has good right and lawful authority to sell and convey said land; that the grantor hereby fully warrants the title to said land and will defend the same against the lawful claims of all persons whomsoever•, and that said land is free of all encumbrances except taxes accruing subsequent to December 31, 2016. In Witness Whereof, the said grantor has signed and sealed these presents the day and year first above written. Said property is not the homestead of the Grantor under the laws and constitution of the State of Florida in that neither Grantor nor any members of the household of Grantor reside thereon. DEED Individual Warranty Deed - Legal on Face *** OR, 5274 PG 1485 *** Signed, sealed and delivered in our presence. •-- Witness # Signtre Witness # PrintName�� 1 6 ` i2 Witne #2 ignVatur/ e Witness #2 Printed Name jbf 1 �f V Y I State of County of mus Renee Look Address: 1060 21 st st sw, Naples, Florida 34117 The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this Look, who is/are personally known to me or who has produced (NOTARY SEAL) Notary PAblic t� Print Na _ My Com ssion Expires: Z by Renee as identification. .;„Y +� YCI6SNNiF JIMENU z+4'. MY CciPdMI5; ON A FF 216736 y; EXPIRES: danuaty 5, 2017 Rf„fi Bonded Thiu NoWy Pobllo undewtels DEED Individual Wananty Deed - Legal on Face • 0 0 9 0% 0 T 3 684 DEC -5 PH 3-, 14 6OLUeR COUNTY RECORDED �(1 GRANT OF EASEMENT 5�5 This easement is given this _ day of j1vf 6," Grantor hereby reserves, excepts, grants and declares an easement for right of way in favor of grantor and a13 respective heirs, successors and assigns, and alsoei` n`—d aloor ng all current owners of abutting lands on, over, under and along th�e�(,SrfT i1ND T71t Sou' 3"�T of TI[E S�iz4si_ sz�s. oit TRe sex, This easement shall be appurtenant to the dominant estates and shall run with the land. In Witness Whereof, t hereunto set his hand and seal,_on the date OR �r? �•,� JFW TM M. 1LlZZ I MprH�S3 �a e �i ccurnento;r County aorida i Mp Co!li.;r County, Florida J Re n, {erk STATE OF Fro y COUNTY OF 1 HEREBY C IFY hat on this day, befo m d officer duly authorized h ate aforesaid and a unty afore- said to take ackno e personal l r w Z I to me known to be the person descr a in and who execute f he foregoing instrument and � F acknowledged to me that executed the same. ldITNESS my hand and ficial seal in the County and State last aforesaid this day OF %19891, ,L Not y Public My Commission Expires: NOTARY Fu.UG $TATE OF ROAIDA Al VIVA 15 MA '!'i1S•5 4.fnstrument .A ttoVMIdwQF4"W5aVkQ%WAM&i `prepgrred by: W%LL 1AM rA.tR17-2 1055 µvNTM/¢ Logo E DR. MlAM! ISFAIW s ! FL. V 10, WO �., 00958958 .-005 SEP 24 PM 4-- 26 COLLIER COUNTY 1 11 RECORDED. EASEMENT FOR RIGHTS -OF -WAY AND ROADWAY PUPIPOSES m o cn WILLIAM M. RIZZI, hereinafter referred to as "Grantor", in ; rn consideration. of TEN DOLLARS ($10.00), the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, does hereby declare and grant an easement for rights -of -way, road purposes, and utility right-of-way to and in favor of the general public over the following described portions 0 of said property. to The West 15 feet and the south 30 feet of the Southwest 1/4 of M r-n the Southeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of Section 24, Township 491, Range 27, Coi3- y Grantor do and right to utility right cost and exp To have a) manner and for grant to the at hold the same :es and purposes C. full authority for all proper purposes at the public. public in the IN WITNESS WHEREOF, WI RIZZI has set his hand and seal this 1,r day of Sef� 1985. r ;..r4►fj- ory Stamp Tax F'f C�iumy, Florida �Jr• ' Fit J, �e�og(Jan Cler WITNESSES: �` C O ery,\ WILLIAM M. RIZZI FORSYTH. SWALM At MUGGER, P.A.. Aunnvys41 Law. NA M Avvnuv South 4uur 81i1 Nap1... Fkn1dn 33940 . � o z� o— t7 C n STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER 1 I hereby certify that on .this day, before me, an officer duly i authorized. in the State and County aforesaid to take acknowledgments, personally appeared WILLIAM M. .RIZZI, to me known r ' F to be the person described in and who executed the above instrument o and he acknowledged executing the same in the presence of two N S rn co subscribing witnesses freely and voluntarily. = Witness my hand and official seal in the County and -State last aforesaid this `k day of Sep--?-• 1985. -' •'x , YYY� �� `�\'�, ,.i :i.Nr..• .ram; '� ' ' '..+ ` Notary My Commis on ? r�'•. ireq FLONIOR' lrR4 PUNLIC Alt ••••I- t .- : RU AL IN UIM- S .: This instrument prepared by: John N. Brugger, Esq. Forsyth, Swalm & Brugger, P.A. 600 Fifth Avenue South, Suite 210 Naples, Florida 33940 R -gr a•rl V.1,1 w1 in4R' nk�loNTM r}oaiva y jrtf anuH�Cowft FORSYTH. SWALM & FSRUGGER. P.A.. Anorneys m Law 6(X)Fd1h Avenue South Sadv 210. NePW. F'btrla 33940 } SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT American Government Services Corporation 3812 W. Linebaugh Avenue Tampa; Florida 33618 813-933-3322 Contractor's Tax I.D. No.: 59-2346160 AGSC Search Number: 30170-10 Project Name: Benton Road THE UNDERSIGNED does hereby certify that a search has been made of the Public Records of Collier County, State of Florida through July 1, 2020 at 8:00 a.m. for Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, PA, for the specific purpose of researching ownership and easements to determine access for Benton Road. Legal Description: The East 1/2 of the SW 1/4 of the SE 1/4 of the SE 1/4, lying and being in Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. Current Owner(s): Eric C. Berson, Trustee under the Berson Revocable Trust Dated January 27, 2007 Mailing Address on Deed: 26454 Taaffe Lane Los Altos Hills, CA 94022 By: Warranty Deed From: Eric C. Berson, a married man Dated: February 8, 2011 Filed and Recorded: February 22, 2011 In Official Records Book No.: 4654 Page: 1423 The following Easements were found of records affecting the subiect property: 1. Grant of Easement by William M. Rizzi, dated November 26, 1984 and recorded December 5, 1984 in Official Records Book 1111, Page 2064. 2. Easement for Rights -of -Way and Roadway Purposes from William M. Rizzi, in favor of the general public, dated September 18, 1985 and recorded September 24, 1985 in Official Records Book 1156, Page 2195. NOTE: All of the above documents recorded in the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, unless otherwise noted. Parcel information: Parcel ID No.: 00323840002 CERTIFICATION: AS TO THE ORIGINAL SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT: The undersigned hereby certifies that the foregoing SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT reflects a comprehensive search of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, showing only the ownership and easements affecting the lands as requested. American Government Services Corporation assumes no responsibility for any defects or omissions in or from the instruments appearing in the chain of title to the property described herein, which defects or omissions would render such instruments void. This report is furnished at your request for information only and is not to be construed as a title opinion or a guarantee of title. It is not a title insurance policy. The liability of American Government Services Corporation is limited to $1000.00 per report and shall not in any event exceed the maximum liability as set forth under F.S. 627.7843 (3). Searched thwugft -duly 1, 2020 @ 8:00 a.m.: Kehl n Government Services Corporation 2 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Site Parcel No 00323840002 Address *Disclaimer Name Address BERSON TR, ERIC C BERSON REV TRUST 26454 TAA,FFE RD /v Site Site City *'Lone Note City LOS Pt 1OS HILLS State CA Zip; 94022-4427 Map No. Strap No. Section Township Range * Acres Estimated 4C24 000100 098 4C24 24 49 27 5 Legal 24 49 27 E1/2 OF SW1/4 OF SE1/4 OF SE1/4 5.00 AC OR 1565 PG 191 Millage Area 62 Millage Rates 0 0 " *Calculations Sub./Condo 100 - ACREAGE HEADER School Other Total Use Code 0 99 - ACREAGE NOT ZONED 5.083 6.3071 11.3901 AGRICULTURAL Latest Sales History (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) Date Book -Page Amount 02/08/11 = 4654-1423 $ 11) 10/12/90 ' 1565-191 $ 12,500 02/01/89 1416-464 $ 0 132/01/89 1416-391 $ 0 10/01/88 1386-2119 $ 11,000 2019 Certified Tax Roil (Subject to Change) Land Value $ 32,950 (+) Improved Value $ 0 (_) Market Value $ 32,950 (-) 10% Cap $ 10,988 (_) Assessed Value $ 21,962 (_) School Taxable Value $ 32,950 Taxable Value $ 21,962 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax doll INSTR 4528653 OR 4654 PG 1423 RECORDED 2/22/2011 3:16 PM PAGES 3 DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA DOC@.70 $0.70 REC $27.00 CONS $0.00 PREPARED BY: STEVEN A. WILLIAMS, ESQ. C/O U.S. DEEDS 213 BRENTSHIRE DRIVE BRANDON, FL 33511 WHEN RECORDED MAIL TO: DIANA GENDOTTI, ESQ. LAW OFFICES OF DIANA DEAN GENDOT 11 95 MAIN STREET, SUITE 7 LOS ALTOS, CA 94022 PARCEL ID NO.:00323840002 PURCHASE PRICE PAID: $0.00 OTHER CONSIDERATION: $0.00 DOCUMENTARY STAI•IP TAX: $0.70 Warranty Deed TIES WARRANTY DEED is made on February 8, 2011 by ERIC C. BERSON, a married man, whose address is 26454 Taaffe Lane, Los Altos Hills, CA 94022 (herein, "Grantor"), to ERIC C. BERSON, TRUSTEE, or any successors in trust, under the BERSON REVOCABLE TRUST dated January 27, 2007 and any amendments thereto, whose address is 26454 Taaffe Lane, Los Altos Hills, CA 94022 (herein, "Grantee"). GRANTOR, in consideration of Ten Dollars and other valuable consideration, receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, hereby conveys to Grantee, all of Grantor's interest in and to the following described real property located in the County of Collier, State of Florida: SEE EXHIBIT A ATTACHED HERETO. TOGETHER WITH all of the easements, rights, privileges and appurtenances thereto belonging and all of the estate, right, title, interest and claim, either at law or in equity, of Grantor of, in, to or out of such real property. TO HAVE AND TO HOLD the above -described real property in fee simple with all appurtenances and for the purposes set forth herein, subject to all matters of record, if any. Full power and authority is granted by this deed to the Trustee(s) and all successor trustees to protect, conserve, sell, lease, encumber, convey, transfer or otherwise manage and dispose of all or any portion of the property herein described without the consent or approval of any other party. Grantor hereby fully warrants title to said property and will defend the same against the lawful claims of all persons whomsoever. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, Grantor signed and sealed this Warranty Deed on the date first above written. EXEMPT TRANSFER - NO DOCUMENTARY STAMP TAX OR INTANGIBLE PERSONAL PROPERTY TAX 1S DUE OR PAYABLE IN CONNECTION WITH THE RECORDING HEREOF. OR 4654 PG 1424 Ynnted name of witness #Z This instrument was acknowledged before me on who is personally known to me or [ ] who has 1 identification. [Affix Notary Seal] i1fA1M ��1�� KRVI, NRISTA ANN CASTANEDA COMM. #1811029 = Notary Public- California Santa Clara County _Comm. Expires Aug 25, 2^t21 by Eric C. Berson, [,T- as SIGNATURE OF NOTARY PUBLIC My commission expires: 6V 'a S ap }a *** OR 4654 PG 1425 *** EXHIBIT A East 1/2 of the Southwest 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4, of Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. This property is not the homestead real property of Grantor. MAIL FUTURE TAX STATEMENT TO: ERIC C. BERSON, TRUSTEE 26454 Taaffe Lane Los Altos Hills, CA 94022 This instrument has been prepared solely from information given by the parties hereto. There are no express or implied guarantees as to marketability of title, accuracy of the description or quantity of land described, as no examination of title to the property was requested or conducted. The preparer has not been requested to provide, nor has the preparer provided, advice on the tax, legal or non -legal consequences that may arise as a result of the conveyance or verified the accuracy of the amount of consideration stated to have been paid in connection with the conveyance or upon which any tax may have been calculated. 11-21066 V11 00907073 404 DEC -5 PM 3: 14 BOLDER COUNTY RECORDEO `� GRANT OF EASEMENT This easement is given this rs-A-AL day of 110vrrn6A—. Grantor hereby reserves, excepts, grants and declares an easement for right of way in favor of grantor and 11f5 respective heirs, successors and assigns, and also n avor of all current owners of abutting lands on, over, under and along the y� i31x� AM THE 50(J7t' of 711E 3�J�F a �:'gam � C C This easement shall be appurtenant to the dominant estates r„t and shall run with the land. In Witness Whereof, t n hereunto set his hand and seal, on the date stt M Tkeo wt rNEs STATE OF FLO COUNTY OF ccum E � Co!liar 91V I HEREBY C IFY hat on this day, befoc d officer duly authorized h ate aforesaid and �jie —ty afore- said to take ackno e personallp r z I to me known to be the person des a in and who executed £ he foregoing instrument and IkL acknowledged to me that executed the same. WITNESS my hand and ficial seal in the County and State last aforesaid this day of 4 1u++��Q+ , 198 J Not y Public My Commission Expires: a(iTARY ✓Ulu'. STATE OF FLO.'IUA At LAUA . bit S.OMMIS51W EY..Iki WNd 15 tYCS t 'f'hi3 %nstrument ,w RoL+¢1t16useENkteLlNsLBwauEBf :PrePA�red by: �,Ii1.�.�Alwt r/1.1RlZZI 1055 AURTlr16 LOME DR. fA4AlAI ISTtU+14S + FL. wu. 0 00958958 ..sees SEP 24 PH 4: 2C :COLLIER COUNTY # .. RECOROEO. EASEMENT FOR RIGHTS -OF -WAY AND ROADWAY PURPOSES CD c r, — o Cn WILLIAM M. RIZZI, hereinafter referred to as "Grantor", in X w consideration. of TEN DOLLARS ($10.00), the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, does hereby declare and grant an easement for rights -of -way, road purposes, and utility right-of-way to and in favor of the general public over the following described portions co of said property. o � N C-) to The Weet 15 feet and .the mouth 30 foot of the southwest 1/4 of M t.n the Southeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of Section 24, Township 49, Range 27, Colli y Grantor doe h y grant to the gen al ublic full authority and right to an er nrd- aid Bem nt for all proper utility right -o i ro d purposes at the cost and exp as n at th of r t g no l public. To have a o hold the same to he �"ral public in the manner and •for es and purposes nod. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, WI RIZZI has set his hand and seal this I Y day of Sef�7' , 1985. tozia -ed L _ .sits ttttry Stamp Tax Fumy. Florida mogan Cle , WITNESSES:! 'C WILLIAM M. RIZZI FORSYTH, SWALM & RRUGGF.R, P.A.. Anurnvys al Law. UX1 F1hh Avvnuv Suuwh 5w1r 210 Haplaa. Florida Ci3940 I f /0 c-) Q = •-, a7 �' O :.n STATE OF Fionm � rn COUNTY OF COLLIER I hereby certify that on .this day, before me, an officer duly authorized in the State and County aforesaid to take } acknowledgments, personally appeared WILLIAM M. RIZZI, to me known 1 • 1 to be the person described in and who executed the above instrument o and he acknowledged executing.the same in the presence of two � N ; subscribing witnesses freely and voluntarily. M e�y Witness my hand and official seal in the County and;State last aforesaid this day of Se=- 1985. ` , (\..dn° .�+.,,.; •tit., _ �!. •1 �i' .....•..• ••..� .• Notary '+ ,i , My Commis on free' �, +► -- rA� ARY PUBLIC Alf FLOA:OA'{ •, :' �� P. 11 AY ti.1969 ^ (yc /--��o��yJ� I 1 9 ! 9 AL I11 UDC. .•$!. ' This instrument prepared by: John N. Brugger, Esq. Forsyth, Swalm & Brugger, P.A. 600 Fifth Avenue South, Suite 210 Naples, Florida 33940 UOCO[OM — —11 a i1nEER ttCik-101 410a W.� CJ.tk of 1. all c ult CNflt OI VicCAUL FORSYTH.SWALM&BRUGOER.P.A.. Attotneysai Law 101AMAvenueSoulll Sov210. Naples,Flonda 33940 1 SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT American Government Services Corporation 3812 W. Linebaugh Avenue Tampa, Florida 33618 813-933-3322 Contractor's Tax I. D. No.: 59-2346160 AGSC Search Number: 30170-11 Project Name: Benton Road THE UNDERSIGNED does hereby certify that a search has been made of the Public Records of Collier County, State of Florida through July 1, 2020 at 8:00 a.m. for Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, PA, for the specific purpose of researching ownership and easements to determine access for Benton Road. Legal Description: The South 1/2 of the SE 1/4 of the SE 1/4 of the SE 1/4, lying and being in Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. Current Owner(s): Patrick J. Krummen, a single man Mailing Address on Deed: 2,671 Benton Road Naples, FL 34117 By: General Warranty Deed From: BT Investments 01 LLC, a Florida limited liability company Dated: April 16, 2018 Filed and Recorded: April 17, 2018 In Official Records Book No.: 5498 Page: 2662 The following Easements were found of records affecting the subject property: 1. Easement for Rights -of -Way and Roadway Purposes from Norman R. Alpert in favor of the general public, dated October 31, 1987 and recorded November 3, 1987 in Official Records Book 1156, Page 2195. NOTE: All of the above documents recorded in the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, unless otherwise noted. Parcel information: Parcel ID No.: 00324320000 i CERTIFICATIOLN: AS TO THE ORIGINAL SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT: The undersigned hereby certifies that the foregoing SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT reflects a comprehensive search of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, showing only the ownership and easements affecting the lands as requested. American Government Services Corporation assumes no responsibility for any defects or omissions in or from the instruments appearing in the chain of title to the property described herein, which defects or omissions would render such instruments void. This report is furnished at your request for information only and is not to be construed as a title opinion or a guarantee of title. It is not a title insurance policy. The liability of American Government Services Corporation is limited to $1000.00 per report and shall not in any event exceed the maximum liability as set forth under F.S. 627.7843 (3). Searched throu h July 1, 2020 @ 8:00 a.m.: amm Mehl American Government Services Corporation Collier County Property pp Pro ert Appraiser rI Property Summary Parcel Site 2671 Site Site No 00324320000 Address UNION City NAPLES ,Zone 34117 *Disclaimer RD *Note Name, / KRUIV,109EN, P.QTRICK J Address 2671 BENTON ROAD City ivAPLES State FL Zip 34117 p Strap No. Section Township Range * . Acres Ma No. _Estimated 44C24 000100 110 4C24 24 49 27 5 Legal 24 49 27 S1/2 OF SE1/4 OF SE1/4 OF SE1/4 Miliage Area 62 Miliage Rates 0 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 100 -ACREAGE HEADER School Other iota! Use Code Q 1 - SINGLE FAI!/IIL:% REST DENTIAL 5.083 6.3071 11.3901 Latest Sales History (!Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) Date Book -Page Amount 04/116/18 5498-2662 $ 280,000 04/06/18 5498-2661 $ '0 12/22/16 5347-3685 $ 160,000 11/06/15 5211-3376 $ 100 11/21/08 4409-1325 $ 227,500 09/27/02 3118-1854 $ 255,000 1 06/17/88 '` 1 358-1130 $ '13,100 11/01/87 '1307-631 $ 12,000 10/01/85 1159-772 $ 10,000 11/01/76 667-1213 $ 0 2019 Certified Tax Roil (Subject to Change) Land Value $ 32,950 (+) Improved Value $ 204,534 Market Value (_) Assessed Value Homestead (_) School Taxable Value $ 237,484 $ 237,484 $ 25,000 $ 212,484 -) Additional Homestead $ 25,000 (_) Taxable Value $ 1007,484 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll INSTR 5541149 OR 5498 PG 2662 E—RECORDED 4/17/2018 9:32 AM PAGES DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA DOC@.70 $1,960.00 REC $18.50 CONS $280,000.00 Prepared by: COTTRELL TITLE & ESCROW 5147 Castello Drive Naples, FL 34103 File Number: 180141 Consideration: $280,000.00 General Warranty Deed Made this April 16, 2018 A.D. By BT Investments 01 LLC, a Florida Limited Liability Company, whose address is: 2400 Oil Well Rd, Naples, FL 34120, hereinafter called the grantor, to Patrick J. Krummen, a single man, whose post office address is: 2671 Benton Road, Naples, FL 34117, hereinafter called the grantee: ( Whenever used herein the term "grantor" and "grantee" include all the parties to this instrument and the heirs, legal representatives and assigns of individuals, and the successors and assigns of corporations) Witnesseth, that the grantor, for and in consideration of the sum of Ten Dollars, ($10.00) and other valuable considerations, receipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, hereby grants, bargains, sells, aliens, remises, releases, conveys and confirms unto the grantee, all that certain land situate in Collier County, Florida: Tract 110 in Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, further described as the South one-half (S 1/2) of the Southeast one -quarter (S 1/4) of the Southeast one -quarter (S 1/4) of the Southeast one -quarter (S 1/4), Collier County, Florida. Parcel ID Number: 00324320000 Subject to (a) ad valorem and non -ad valorem real property taxes for the year of closing and subsequent years; (b) zoning, building code and other use restrictions imposed by governmental authority; (c) outstanding oil, gas and mineral interest of record, if any; and (d) restrictions, reservations and easements common to the subdivision. Together with all the tenements, hereditaments and appurtenances thereto belonging or in anywise appertaining. To Have and to Hold, the same in fee simple forever. And the grantor hereby covenants with said grantee that the grantor is lawfully seized of said land in fee simple; that the grantor has good right and lawful authority to sell and convey said land; that the grantor hereby fully warrants the title to said land and will defend the same against the lawful claims of all persons whomsoever; and that said land is free of all encumbrances except taxes accruing subsequent to December 31, 2017. DEED Individual Warranty Deed - Legal on Face *** OR 5498 PG 2663 *** Prepared by: COTTRELL TITLE & ESCROW 5147 Castello Drive Naples, FL 34103 File Number: 180141 Consideration: $280,000.00 In Witness Whereof, the said Grantor has caused this instrument to be executed in its name by its duly authorized officer and caused its corporate seal to be affixed the day and year first above written. Signed.rus"'ggled in Our Presence: Witness Pr' t Name: , ie:7 Scarlett Guerrero Witness Print Name: State of Florida County of Collier BT Investments 01 LLC(( By: Bonnie Walsh, Managing Member of BT Investments 01 LLC (Corporate Seal) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this Ce day of April, 2018, by Bonnie Walsh, Managing Member of BT Investments 01 LLC. She is personally known to me or has produced .---as-identification. 4 (SEAL) Nosy ublic �T Printed Name: Pa ergo Kelly Porter My Commission Expires: Z(. I Z-Z� a ' NotaryPubliC-StateofFlorida COMMIS -Sion OFF 954226 yrFpF F�Oft Expires 01/26/2020 DEED Individual Warranty Deed - Legal on Face 01 13 1 278 Iset r(ou -s AM 91 43n � 13 0 G 0 0 0 9 118 COLLIER COUNTY RECORDED 0 t PAGE ,,. EASEMENT FOR UTILITY RIGHTS -OF -WAY AND ROADWAY PURPOSES NORMAN R. ALPERT, hereinafter referred to as "Grantor", in consideration of TEN DOLLARS ($10.00), the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, does hereby declare and grant an easement for ingress and egress purposes, road purposes, and.utility rights -of -way to and in favor of the general public, and to and for the benefit of and as an easement appurtenant to the land described in Exhibit A attached hereto; said Easement being over the following described property: The South thirty .(30) feet of Tract 110, in Section 24, Township 49 South, Range 27 East; further described as the South 1/2 ,of the. Southeast 1/4 of the Southeast .1/4 of the Southeast 1/4, Collier County, Florida. Grantor does hereby grant to the general' public full authority and right to enter upon and use said easement for all proper utility rights -of -way, ingress and egress and road purposes at the cost and expense and at the sole risk of the general public. To have and to hold the the uses and purposes aforem IN WITNESS WHEREOF, �0611 K:61�- day of October 19q'7. �� n 1 1 public in the manner and for and seal this STATE OF FLORIDA tJS_L is}; �' )U-1 " COUNTY OF COLLIER. E'i ._ .... _... _. ^ .... _. C I hereby certify that on this day, before me, an officer du authorized in the State and County aforesaid to take acknowledgements, personally appeared NOMAN.R. ALPERT, to me known to be the person described in and who executed the above instrument and he acknowledged executing the same in the presence of two subscribing witnesses freely and voluntarily. Witness my hand and official seal in the State and County last aforesaid this 3 day of October, 1987. Return To: Sk Forsyth, Swaim.& Brugger; P.A. 600 Fifth Avenue South,.#210 . Naples, Florida 33940 , t`sE Ate€ c1 NOTARY PUBLIC My Commission Expires: n0;''o':C%X i h SS•..,.+of Fhu Ida w.. Mq ro,n,n E:9. J.+n 1 ,41 d.Wa 00I306 0 BOOK 0009��9 PAGE EXHIBIT "A" The South 1/2 of the Southeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 and the South 1/2 of the North. 1/2 of the Southeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 and the South 1/2 of the North 1/2 of the North 1/2 of the Southeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 and the South 1/2 of the Southwest 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 and the South 1/2 of the North 1/2 of the Southwest 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of Section 23, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida; AND the Northeast 1/4 of the Northeast 1/4 and the East 1/2 of the Northwest 1/4 of the. Northeast 1/2 and the East 1/2 of the West 1/2 of the Northwest 1/4 of the Northeast 1/4 of Section 26, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County., Florida. (Tower Site) 1 � � 11t1iiF• Celt 1ik GUWIIE�i. �4t: Fv. a .s Iso t22 �« -FAGS fears• raver of Maele 114# _Ome" deg of October A 1) Iv 86 Iry LOMAS A. NICKEL and DONA C. NICKEL, Husband and Wife, h.eww.11.. raliwl the gmlw, I. W"Al A. ALPERT, w14Aw ffastelikv adfl,e,e U 4401 Gulf Shor: 'souiivied North, NapieS, Florida 33%0 hwMnell" now ohs oftnte.: �M1Mensr wf1 home �M New. "womb"', Bod 11 Wet dl As IMtw. I. ei- uatmio , and ka eq.walamr. and w.ya .d xifn . N� 1M M+.ea�. awd a "►°' d .' awr1 'i That Ifir l,ranlar. 1a► pan! in consid fation of the sere of s 10.00----•wv,nd other � f•alffa6lr .weosldnattotu, re,vipi whrrsK►1 tr hereby GAnou►irdlird. hereby gram,. baegalns. see%, gibes. Pa. Nam, releases, rnnenys and s'onli ms unto #6 grenhe. ail' i1►01 esetain hmd aNuate in Col liar ca mly. Flork!a, eels; Tract :I10 in Section 94, Tortnship 49 ;iouth„ Flange 29 East; further described as the South It of tie f0utheast Ir Of the SOuthaast 4 of the S.lutheast k, being approxisl WY five aFrps, adore or less. Subject to easenenta: reservations and restrictions of mord, if an#r, lrwdw Wilk all the Mnements, h.n dltamena and Wurlenanns (hereto 60104eplrN .f in only. wise apparlaint^e• To iim md to , the aerlfe to I" stmple formwr. iwthe traetoe her by cmenanis milk said emnbe that the grantor is lawfully wised of eatd Is" in Im etmp4il that 16e grantor has flood right and 6Ufni outharily to 0011 and 'ec" ey raid 16mm'I ILWI the prantor hereby lnludj awants the title to laid !and and will rlelend the SUM against the IaWffd ctot►we 01 ale presses 1.e6auesve►I and that sold l'artd is lree of all encueebraneee, except taxer accruing sulmogreni to Dmwbw 31, to 64. IS VbW UVANWo the said grantor Gas signed arm w+ial liws day awd year (Neff abet Iw111ew. w/� a awe{ fidba+d in y,rowsfcvs , _..., ..._...... ....................... .................... .... t WNWAS16 um ism me wwwm!m- eTATi Cl/ FLORIDA oovmctr OF COLLIER I d 0 M I MANY CUTI/Y drag as this day, betofe ass, fa Am Daly Y do eno stwenid sad Is the Cswey stWOW to 6*0 ay�eand . NICKEL and DOW C. NICKEL, ad and Wife, is rebW .,w;wwr e+e a less aM m ma»wad Wr. m ow the; AA6m dDil R . , A. D. is 85, Rece ve [,-.-tgnentary Stomp Tax C:c;I.! r County, Florida 110T/h�� MUIM STATE Of FICRtIfA my CR3mmeAlON Immis ou 23 TIM illiltCr MiY up Comission Expires: 0 TM� a i"ws"tact iV. jDhhn N. aruapr, MtSYTH, SMALN A SRUGGER, P.A. Avetwe South, Sujje 210. Naples, Florida 33940 fs L SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT American Government Services Corporation 3812 W. Linebaugh Avenue Tampa, Florida 33618 813-933-3322 Contractor's Tax I.D. No.: 59-2346160 AGSC Search Number: 30170-12 Project Name: Benton Road THE UNDERSIGNED does hereby certify that a search has been made of the Public Records of Collier County, State of Florida through July 1, 2020 at 8:00 a.m. for Law Office of Mattaniah S. Jahn, PA, for the specific purpose of researching ownership and easements to determine access for Benton Road. Legal Description: Tract 121 of Floridian Farm Sites, according to the plat thereof as recorded in Plat Book 4, Page 33, lying and being in Section 25, Township 49 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida. Current Owner(s): Shirley Koger-Scott, widow and surviving spouse of Eugen D. Scott, deceased Mailing Address on Deed: 5030 8t" Avenue SW Naples, FL 33999 By: Warranty Deed From: John C. Hoy and Arlene R. hoy, husband and wife Dated: January 31, 1995 Filed and Recorded: February 2, 1995 In Official Records Book No.: 2026 Page: 2203 Certificate of Death for Eugene Donald Scott, deceased October 2, 2010, recorded February 20, 2013 in Official Records Book 4887, Page 3720. The following Easements were found of records affecting the subject property: 1. Easement for Rights -of -Way and Roadway Purposes from John C. Hoy in favor of the general public, dated August 23, 1985 and recorded October 14, 1985 in Official Records Book 1159, Page 1954. NOTE: All of the above documents recorded in the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, unless otherwise noted. Parcel information: Parcel ID No.: 32634680000 i CERTIFICATI0.111: AS TO THE ORIGINAL SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT: The undersigned hereby certifies that the foregoing SPECIFIC PURPOSE REPORT reflects a comprehensive search of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, showing only the ownership and easements affecting the lands as requested. American Government Services Corporation assumes no responsibility for any defects or omissions in or from the instruments appearing in the chain of title to the property described herein, which defects or omissions would render such instruments void. This report is furnished at your request for information only and is not to be construed as a title opinion or a guarantee of title. It is not a title insurance policy. The liability of American Government Services Corporation is limited to $1000.00 per report and shall not in any event exceed the maximum liability as set forth under F.S. 627.7843 (3). Searched throu my 1, 020 @ 8:00 a.m.: a my Mehl American Government Services Corporation 2 Record: $ 9.00 stamps: $ .50 0 0 9 6 2 3 5( I9p5 OCT 14 F94 a IS COLLIER,COUNTY RECORDED EASEMENT FOR RIGHTS -OF -WAY AND ROADWAY PURPOSES JOHN C. HOY, and ARLENE R. HOY, husband and wife, hereinafter referred to as "Grantors", in consideration of TEN DOLLARS ($10.00), the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, does hereby declare and grant an easement for rights -of -way, road purposes, and utility right-of-way to and in favor of the general public over the following described portions of said property. The North 30 feet of Floridan Farms Sites, Tract 121, of Section 25, Township 49 So 27 East, as recorded in Plat Book 4, at Pag 3 ` rds for Collier County, Florida. 10 y , Grantors do r grant t goner I publ f 11 authority and right to ant r u n a d t f all proper utility rights-o a n s d e as a oa ?emu ones at the cost and expense at the sole risk the an ublic. A0 To have and to a same unto the ge aril� ublic in the manner and for the use k ned. iI 1 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, JOHN C. HOY and ARLENE R. HOY, have set their hands and seals this day of Avn L 57 , im. JOHN C. HOY 1 1 ' !Ai[� o C!' 10 ,' — Q cn 7,; cc ca c� m n FORSYTH. SWALM & BRUGGER. P.A.. Attorneys at Lew, 600FH1hAvenue 5omh. Suite 210. Neple., Florlde 33940 O C 1 1.51 OR BOOK STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER 001955 PAGE I hereby certify that on this day, before me, an officer duly authorized in the State and County aforesaid to take acknowledgments, personally appeared JOHN C. ROY to me known to be the person described in and who executed the above instrument and he, acknowledged executing the same in the presence of two subscribing witnesses freely and voluntarily. Witness my liand and official seal in the County and State last day of Ak4 k5 1985. Notary Publi •;,v j'•• .. N••''c`�- Co sion xpi es: JOT Y SLTO S14 1E fiOR A MY COMA slog ERP. Nd t3.19 a —lU u uc u ugwcxaf . peu. STATE OF \�*� COUNTY OF I hereby tj y that on this day, b are In , an er duly authorized in the Stan County aforesaid t ck gments, personally appeared Art oy, to me known to be son described in and who executed the ab ns k dged executing the same in the presence of two subsc w� reeiy and voluntarily. Witness my hand and official seal in the County and State last aforesaid this 30day ofQdA uQ.i 1985- ; �ary•Public ',, • is9ON— AM My Commission Expires:""'" xpires:. ' " lTyi6EYERLY rARti• QUStt 0S JERSEY `icy col Ex?)JOS"July 5, 1S31 41�yett�.. This instrument prepared by s John N. Srugger, Esq. Received $ %�_._G_—.---- u. w� � x ,' •.•n`r Documentary Stamp Tax w�Fa Cell*+r" !aa IDA Ccl'ier Ccunly, Florida C%fk f't�iw�� William J• Rea on, erk �J byliGd - D.C. FORSYTH. SWALM d BRUGGER. P.A.. Anwmrl* at Lew. 4W Fdlh Awnue sculh. Swu 210. Naples. F"a 33940 Collier County Property Appraiser Page 1 of 1 Property Summary Site Address 1750 BENTON Site Zone Parcel No 32634680Q00 *Disclaimer RD Site City NAPLES *Note 34117 Name / Address KOGER-SCOTT, SHIRLEY 1750 BENTON RD City NAPLES State FL Zip 34117-8863 Map No. Strap No. Section Township Range Acres *Estimated 4C25 2962001214C25 25 49 27 5 Legal FLORIDIAN FARM SITES TRACT 121 5 AC OR 2026 PG 2203 Millage Area 0 62 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 296200 - FLORIDIAN FARM SITES School Other Total Use Code 0 69 - ORNAMENTALS, MISC AGRICULTURAL 5.083 6.3071 11.3901 Latest Sales History 2019 Certified Tax Roil (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book -Page Amount Land Value $ 42,500 02/02/95 2026-2203 $ 90,000 {+) improved Value $ 47,461 06/01/84 1090-369 $ 6,000 {_) Market Value $ 89,961 (-) Save our Home $ 30,905 (-) Agriculture $ 1,574 {_) Assessed Value $ 57,482 { -) Homestead $ 25,000 {-) Widow(er) $ 500 {_) School Taxable Value $ 31,982 (=) Taxable Value $ 31,982 If all Values shown above equal o this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll http://www.collierappraiser.comlmain search/recorddetail.html?sid=568752761&Map=No&FolioNum=3263... 7/7/2020 dw THIS INSTRUMENT PREPARED BY: William Schweikhardt Attorney At Law 900 Sixth Avenue South Naples, Florida 33940 Parcel Identification Number is: 32634680000 Grantees Tax Identification Numbers are: 1904907 OR: 2026 PG; 2203 UCCUID in 0111CIAL UCOIDS of COU111 Cam?, it 02/02/55 at 08:47AN DVIGB! 1, IIOCC, CUR Calls 10000.00 lie 11111 10.50 DOC•.70 130.00 loth: NULLilklit 50-N- 1111kloy WARRANTY DEED MOVE SPACE RESERVED FOR RKOROM USE THIS INDENTURE made this 31st day of tween JOHN C. HOY and A:RIENE 1t. HOY, husband and wife, whose post office address i • — ap of the County of Collier, State of Florida 33962, Grantor, and EUGENE D. SCOTT and RL'E IK04 Ek=SC�, usband and wife as an estate by the entireties, whose post office address is: 5030 Sth A reu3'W., Naples, of the Co%Collier, State of Florida 33999, Grantee. WITNESSETH, that said Grant valuable considerations to said Grantor in bargained and sold to the said Grant , and being in Collier County, Florida, o-i Tract 121, FLORII 4, Page 33, of the SUBJECT TO restrictions. for the year I "S. sum 'r f T DOLLARS (510.00), and other good and w ae�of is hereby acknowledged, has granted, s r, the following described land, situate, lying TES, according t e pl the, ds of Collier Count lor' ments common to t 6disi4 recorded in Plat Book and ad valorem taxes and said Grantor does hereby fully warrant the tiiW-s&jAg lan d will defend the same against the lawful claims of all persons whomsoever. "Grantor" and "Grantee" are used for singular or plural, as context requires. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, Grantor has hereunto set Grantor's hand and seal the day and year first above written. Signed, sealed and delivered in our presence: 4ES NAME: ttober � .�, \sgy QVITNE*SAME: Virginia AE. Duggan APYri6 ttl:CUft'j1, to EE'RV TO% WILL1A%l 1, - • !ARiYr r oK,.1 E AT i %W fW all'III 1VL'':`•LE SO. NAYLM:S, Ir L 33446 JOHN C. 140Y ARL NE R. HOY *** OR: 2026 PG: 2204- '** STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this 31 s t day of January, 1 "S, by JOHN C. HOY, who has produced a valid FLORIDA drivers license as identification, and ARLENE R. HOY, who has produced a valid FLORIDA drivers license as identification, husband and wife, and who did not take an oath. (AFFIX SEAL) 10% NOTARY PUBLIC My Commission Expires: QF?+:1A1 \+?•�%t CiAL CVIAI�Al�D1� V V • 443:� My c)N a1Y NuY 11.190 ... � , 10it 4 ova o.n _ - ozc. -, wsa - .... j7 r ♦ t -41 $ R s C .R � R" � •i i � i � 9 4. t MW --------;------- — —t --—;------- - ------;-------- ---------;------- R = R aj• x R 1 R R � � � � �. --- -_--R-- ---;--- ------- ------- -- ----- -fir ------- 4-- a i , -- ----1 --- ----r ---- ---,- .-----. -- - -_-- =';--- -� ---i ---- ---, � R i ` 1 IL r / r iu 1 -' eO . wvsi ,Oval ii ,O�fs ,OQ iI ,OI1i p G ib t � � - a e�QAA by � e Ah � `}e •�� L .e >'a ��Y-M qs. $ O ti*4 ►,eamix el 3 I i • I— —