Loading...
Inbox - TaylorFrom: Buzz Victor To: TavlorPenny Subject: Accepted: Buzz Victor (Save Vanderbilt Beach) - One Naples to discuss the structure of the Board meeting Start: Friday, February 12, 2021 1:00:00 PM End: Friday, February 12, 2021 1:30:00 PM Location: please call 239-252-8604 EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. From: Buzz Victor To: TavlorPenny Subject: Accepted: Buzz Victor (Save Vanderbilt Beach) - One Naples to discuss the structure of the Board meeting Start: Friday, February 12, 2021 1:00:00 PM End: Friday, February 12, 2021 1:30:00 PM Location: please call 239-252-8604 EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. From: TrochessettAimee To: CoxMichael Cc: CurryDeborah; DeLaRosaLissett; TavlorPenny Subject: Agenda Reformatting Project Date: Monday, December 21, 2020 10:28:50 AM Attachments: AAaendaReformatInstructions.Ddf 2020-12-08 Raw Data.docx 2020-12-08 Raw Data.docx Website Agenda.pdf Per your request, I have attached the Agenda Reformat Instructions forwarded to me from Oscar Nieves on September 17, 2019 ("Agenda Instructions"). Please note that the "reformatting" does not apply to the items in the Consent and Summary sections. Oscar told us that Items in these sections are not sorted into GROWTH MANAGEMENT (16A), COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AGENDA (16B), PUBLIC UTILITIES (16C), etc. through 16K. I have attached the Word document that is produced as a result of the reformatting set forth above ("Raw Data"). From this document, Commissioner Taylor requests an easily readable agenda where ALL items are sorted by Commission district. ("Reformatted Agenda"). Next, every item is copied onto Commissioner Taylor's website, and then I link the backup data to each item ("Website Agenda"). Shortly after Debbie Curry started, I showed and explained to her what this project entails. Respectfully, Aimee Trochessett Customer Service Specialist Aimee.Trochessett(d)CollierCountyFL.goov o r County Communication & Customer Relations Division 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 303, Naples FL 34112 Phone: 239.252.8075 Under Florida Law, a-maiL addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: TrochessettAimee To: CoxMichael Cc: CurryDeborah; DeLaRosaLissett; TavlorPenny Subject: Agenda Reformatting Project Date: Monday, December 21, 2020 10:28:50 AM Attachments: AAaendaReformatInstructions.Ddf 2020-12-08 Raw Data.docx 2020-12-08 Raw Data.docx Website Agenda.pdf Per your request, I have attached the Agenda Reformat Instructions forwarded to me from Oscar Nieves on September 17, 2019 ("Agenda Instructions"). Please note that the "reformatting" does not apply to the items in the Consent and Summary sections. Oscar told us that Items in these sections are not sorted into GROWTH MANAGEMENT (16A), COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AGENDA (16B), PUBLIC UTILITIES (16C), etc. through 16K. I have attached the Word document that is produced as a result of the reformatting set forth above ("Raw Data"). From this document, Commissioner Taylor requests an easily readable agenda where ALL items are sorted by Commission district. ("Reformatted Agenda"). Next, every item is copied onto Commissioner Taylor's website, and then I link the backup data to each item ("Website Agenda"). Shortly after Debbie Curry started, I showed and explained to her what this project entails. Respectfully, Aimee Trochessett Customer Service Specialist Aimee.Trochessett(d)CollierCountyFL.goov o r County Communication & Customer Relations Division 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 303, Naples FL 34112 Phone: 239.252.8075 Under Florida Law, a-maiL addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: OchsLeo To: DLCOMM; CaoizziAixa; Fil n e; GoodnerAnaela; GrecoSherrv; LvkinsDave Cc: RodriguezDan; KlatzkowJeff; DL-DepartmentHeads; WilligGeoffrey; BrockMarvJo Subject: Alternative Venue Analysis for One Naples Hearing Date: Monday, January 25, 2021 9:40:16 AM Attachments: Alternate venue analvsis.docx Alternate meeting sites.xlsx Importance: High This is a one-way communication. Commissioners, Attached please find a detailed memorandum regarding potential alternative meeting locations for the One Naples public hearing scheduled for March 1, 2021. Alternative locations evaluated included Artis-Naples, St. John's Church, Naples High School, Covenant Presbyterian Church, Collier County Veteran's Park and Collier County North Regional Park. In summary, staff was informed that none of the non -county owned facilities were available on the requested date and/or were not hosting large groups due to ongoing COVID -19 pandemic concerns. The two County park locations offered no appreciable advantages over the Boardroom location and did present some technology challenges as well. Finally, the North Regional Park is the state designated DOH COVID vaccination site, so it would be advisable to avoid any conflicts with that schedule. I will bring present this information tomorrow during the Communications portion of the agenda for further discussion. VR, Leo Leo E. Ochs, Jr. Collier County Manager Ieo.ochs(@colIiercountyf1.gov 3299 East Tamiami Trail Naples FL 34112 239.252.8383 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Steve Valdivia To: Steve Valdivia Subject: Appeal to please change venue of March 1 meeting - One Naples Date: Friday, December 18, 2020 4:15:49 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. PLEASE CHANGE THE MEETING VENUE! This subject is much too important to so many to be held in a small county building. By all citizen's rights, it is large enough an issue and affects so many Collier residents now and in the future that it should be in a space large enough so that all persons wanting to be heard and seen can be. This is a one-time decision that affects long-time homeowners and residents, forever. Steven and Bernice Valdivia Homesteaded property owners at Vanderbilt Beach From: Steve Valdivia To: Steve Valdivia Subject: Appeal to please change venue of March 1 meeting - One Naples Date: Friday, December 18, 2020 4:15:49 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. PLEASE CHANGE THE MEETING VENUE! This subject is much too important to so many to be held in a small county building. By all citizen's rights, it is large enough an issue and affects so many Collier residents now and in the future that it should be in a space large enough so that all persons wanting to be heard and seen can be. This is a one-time decision that affects long-time homeowners and residents, forever. Steven and Bernice Valdivia Homesteaded property owners at Vanderbilt Beach From: eoircio(abverizon.net To: TavlorPenny; SolisAndv; LoCastroRick; SaundersBurt; McDanielBill Subject: Barefoot Pelican Vote to approve Date: Sunday, February 14, 2021 4:01:05 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioners: I own a unit in Barefoot Pelican, which is adjacent to the One Naples Properties. Our owners were given the opportunity to vote their opposition/or favor to the One Naples Development. A positive vote of a majority was going to be rewarded with over $570,000.00 of perks to Barefoot Pelican paid for by an affiliate of Stock Development, according to the Board's letter. The vote came in at 32 owners in favor and 28 owners opposed (22 voted no and 6 refused to vote knowing their votes would count as a NO). This vote came in as such even after much solicitation and pressure from other owners as well as the Board. Commissioners, as you can well imagine, the shenanigans that have gone on between Stock Development and a few of the owners have caused a huge rift in our community. We now have people fighting with each other, law suits have been threatened, one owner was grabbed and almost assaulted by another. A couple of owners have told others they are planning on selling their units and buying into the One Naples development with hopes of a favorable deal from Stock Development in repayment for their efforts to swing the votes. One Naples as submitted will forever change Vanderbilt Beach. This will set the precedent for buying small tracts of land and building high-rises. I do not want this, nor does the rest of the Neighborhood. We do not want the Miami look at Vanderbilt Beach with stifling high rises build practically right on the sidewalks, shadows cast over everyone from the towers, and wind rushing down the street bringing sand, debris and trash with it. Our beloved Manatees in the Bay will be forever impacted by One Naples 99 boat docks with a fueling station and marine store. One Naples is a bad, bad idea for Vanderbilt Beach. There is nothing good for the Vanderbilt Beach neighborhood. Tell Brian Stock that we do not want his Legacy Buildings because they will not be good for us. They will not be good for him either because, if he succeeds with this, it will be because his game has been flawed by the lack of principles and ethics that have been employed to garner favor for One Naples at the expense of our neighborhood, at the expense of my neighbors as well as all of us who truly love Vanderbilt Beach. Respectfully submitted Elizabeth (Betty) Pircio 781-690-0486 271 Southbay Dr. Naples, FL epircio@verizon.net From: The SWFL 100 To: TavlorPennv Subject: Boost Well -Being, Stay Voter -Ready and Discover Naples" Booming Housing Market Date: Wednesday, January 27, 2021 9:52:55 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. View in Browser i Subscribe to The SWFL 100 1 Unsubscribe RESIDENTIAL REAL ESTATE Naples housing market demand continues to outpace inventory ®❑ During December, continued buyer interest was demonstrated with a 65% increase in showings. Enthusiastic homebuyers did not waste time making offers in December. Pending sales for homes in Naples increased 88.6% to 1,535 pending sales from 814 ®❑ Y i : Kelilrl : i i III =Ul III :Z+i Be an informed voter in 2021 Get ready for local elections. Visit CollierVotes.com to register to vote, update your voter information, and request your Vote -by -Mail ballot through 2022. It's a new year, and a fresh start to being a conversant and engaged member of your community. By being an informed voter and participating in elections, you are helping shape our country's and community's A=IirjremaKell zI&I Tammy Seyler named Employee of the Year Tammy Seyler not only stands out in her role as Nursing Supervisor, but also has stepped into the challenging role of Infection Control Officer during the pandemic. David Lawrence Centers for Behavioral Health has named Acute Care Nursing Supervisor Tammy Seyler their 2020 Employee of the Year for her sound pending sales in December 2019. While demand remains strong, the market's available inventory in December 2020 decreased 49.1 % to 3,140 homes, down from 6,163 homes during the same period in 2019. As a direct result of the effects of the pandemic, 2020 was one of the first years in history where we saw more buying activity during the second half of the year than the first half of the year. Read the NABOR Market Report here. — Mike Hughes, Downing -Frye Realty, Inc. WELLNESS Interested in Nursing? Al Hodges BSN students graduate a full semester faster, and they are ready for the licensing exam and providing exceptional patient care. Florence Nightingale is synonymous with nursing. This past year has raised the profile of the role nurses play in the health and wellbeing of government. Upcoming elections include local elections such as the Everglades City Election on Nov. 23, 2021, and the City of Naples Election on Feb. 2, 2022. Citizens must be registered to vote 29 days prior to each election and must be residents of each municipality in order to vote in their respective elections. Citizens can register to vote or update their voter information at CollierVotes.com. — Jennifer Edwards, Collier County Supervisor of Elections GALAS AND EVENTS What you do matters ®❑ "We hope to share the message that even in our worst of conditions, we still care about preserving the memory of the Holocaust and raising awareness," said Felicia and Kenneth Anchor. International Holocaust Remembrance Day is on Jan. 27 this year, marking the 76th anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz. One Naples leadership. Her team truly admires her and routinely expresses gratitude for her compassion, support and openness to ideas to help with staffing so more people can access life-saving emergency care on the Crisis Unit. Tammy goes above and beyond and volunteers to handle difficult tasks with a resolved nature and pleasant attitude. In her new role as supervisor, she assists with training, employee engagement, DLC's nursing student program and graciously stepped into the challenging role of Infection Control Officer amid the pandemic. — Scott Burgess, David Lawrence Centers for Behavioral Health IN THE SUNSHINE Boost your well- being by walking Al The goal? Track your Trek to the moon with fellow Blue Zones organizers. patients. Their work is inspiring, and the need for more nurses continues to grow. You can learn more when we host our next virtual Bachelor of Science in Nursing degree information session at 4:00 p.m. on Monday, Feb. 8. You will learn in our state-of-the- art nursing labs from professors who are nurses. You'll find out what makes Hodges BSN program top notch and how it will prepare you for a rewarding career. Click here to register. — Dr. John Meyer, Hodges University BUSINESS The beginning of the year is a good time for an HR tuneup a Molly Eyerman is your chief people partner for growing agencies. She strives to get CEOs out of the Michael/Toby mentality with HR and actually enjoy their people -focused initiatives. (Photo courtesy of Unsplash) couple hopes to inspire others to remember the lessons of the Holocaust and prevent future genocide. Felicia and Kenneth Anchor are chairing the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum's 2021 Southeast Virtual Event on Feb. 11. Featuring special guests Morgan Freeman, Jamie Lee Curtis, Jason Alexander, Ray Allen and others, the event will underscore why the choices we make matter. The Anchors also played a key role in supporting the Naples Holocaust Museum, engaging a community of survivors and expanding services. — Cyndee Woolley, APR, C2 Communications BUSINESS Biomedical engineer wins grant to grow cartilage for facial reconstruction ®❑ Biomedical engineer Wendy Brown is creating tissue for facial reconstruction. Photo courtesy The longest -lived people in the world do not necessarily spend their lives doing strenuous exercise in a gym. Instead, they move naturally (which is a Blue Zones Power rin i le) through daily activities like gardening or walking. Walking has many benefits. A study published in the British Journal of Sports Medicine found that those who adhered to a walking program showed significant improvements in blood pressure, slowing of resting heart rate, reduction of body fat and body weight, reduced cholesterol, and increased measures of endurance. Boost your well-being with Blue Zones Project's community walking challenge. Sign up here for free. — Sebastien Saitta, Blue Zones Project --0E---0r--7 BUSINESS The importance of mentorship ®❑ Wow, 2021 is off to a roaring start! Clients are setting new people goals and companies are reaching out to get their HR house in order. Have you looked at your people operations recently? If not, here are some key areas for you to consider: • Performance expectations: do you have updated job descriptions for everyone and a clear feedback process? • Employee engagement: do you know how engaged your team is with each other and with the company? • Benefits program: when did you last get your team's pulse on your current benefits? What people areas will you focus on this year? — Molly Eyerman, The Agency 100 he SWFL 100 Wendy Brown Millions of people worldwide suffer from facial damage due to cancer, burns or genetics. Wendy Brown, a postdoctoral scholar in biomedical engineering at UC Irvine, was named a 2020 Women in Science Fellow by L'Oreal USA for her efforts to heal them. Brown received a $60,000 grant to continue her research into engineering cartilage for facial reconstruction. She is working to grow cartilage in various anatomical shapes and sizes for surgical implantation. Since 2003, L'Oreal USA has awarded $4 million in grants to 80 female scientists. Internationally, L'Oreal - UNESCO has recognized more than 3,400 women scientists from more than 116 countries. — Donna Scaramastra Gorman, The Engineering 100 0 A mentor doesn't necessarily have to be older. In the workplace, younger employees now oftentimes mentor superiors, most notably in technology. (Photo courtesy of SHRM.com) What better time to start mentoring someone, finding your own mentor or perhaps both as the new year kicks off with National Mentoring Month in January. Having a mentor is important for providing support and guidance to teenagers and young adults. It can also be a useful tool for adults, providing a pivotal step in reaching full potential both personally and professionally. Professionally, a mentor can help navigate a career path by helping with networking, challenging one on workplace tasks, offering encouragement and more. A mentor can also help with guidance in areas of personal growth, family and overall life. — MaryGrace Williams, The Atlanta 100 The stories, photos, videos and podcasts contained herein are written by The 100 Companies LLC and its members for the benefit of its members, partners, sponsors, clients and readers. We hope you'll enjoy our content and share it with other members of your community. View our Privacy Policy. © The 100 Companies, LLC 2021 All Rights Reserved. Member of The 100 Companies National PR Publishing Platform. Follow all our stories and videos online at TheSWFL100.com or on Facebook, Twitter or Instagram. If you'd like to suggest an interesting profile or a story idea, please email editor(a)theswf1100.com. The SWFL 100 5660 Strand Court, #A137 Naples, FL 34110 United States Have friends or family that would enjoy receiving The SWFL 100? Forward them a copy so that they can subscribe to receive their own. Unsubscribe From: The SWFL 100 To: TavlorPennv Subject: Boost Well -Being, Stay Voter -Ready and Discover Naples" Booming Housing Market Date: Wednesday, January 27, 2021 8:43:52 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Unsubscribe It appears that you have subscribed to commercial messages from this sender. To stop receiving such messages from this sender, please unsubscribe View in Browser I Subscribe to The SWFL 100 1 Unsubscribe RESIDENTIAL REAL ESTATE Naples housing market demand continues to outpace inventory ®❑ During December, continued buyer interest was demonstrated with a 65% increase in showings. ®❑ THOUGHT LEADERS Be an informed voter in 2021 Ci Get ready for local elections. Visit CollierVotes.com to register to vote, update your voter information, and request your Vote -by -Mail ballot through 2022. It's a new year, and a fresh REPUTATIONS Tammy Seyler named Employee of the Year OR Tammy Seyler not only stands out in her role as Nursing Supervisor, but also has stepped into the challenging role of Infection Control Officer during the pandemic. Enthusiastic homebuyers did not waste time making offers in December. Pending sales for homes in Naples increased 88.6% to 1,535 pending sales from 814 pending sales in December 2019. While demand remains strong, the market's available inventory in December 2020 decreased 49.1 % to 3,140 homes, down from 6,163 homes during the same period in 2019. As a direct result of the effects of the pandemic, 2020 was one of the first years in history where we saw more buying activity during the second half of the year than the first half of the year. Read the NABOR Market Report here. — Mike Hughes, Downing -Frye Realty, Inc. ❑❑❑ WELLNESS Interested in Nursing? a Hodges BSN students graduate a full semester faster, and they are start to being a conversant and engaged member of your community. By being an informed voter and participating in elections, you are helping shape our country's and community's government. Upcoming elections include local elections such as the Everglades City Election on Nov. 23, 2021, and the City of Naples Election on Feb. 2, 2022. Citizens must be registered to vote 29 days prior to each election and must be residents of each municipality in order to vote in their respective elections. Citizens can register to vote or update their voter information at CollierVotes.com. — Jennifer Edwards, Collier County Supervisor of Elections ■� GALAS AND EVENTS What you do matters ®❑ "We hope to share the message that even in our worst of conditions, we still care about preserving the memory of the Holocaust and raising awareness," David Lawrence Centers for Behavioral Health has named Acute Care Nursing Supervisor Tammy Seyler their 2020 Employee of the Year for her sound leadership. Her team truly admires her and routinely expresses gratitude for her compassion, support and openness to ideas to help with staffing so more people can access life-saving emergency care on the Crisis Unit. Tammy goes above and beyond and volunteers to handle difficult tasks with a resolved nature and pleasant attitude. In her new role as supervisor, she assists with training, employee engagement, DLC's nursing student program and graciously stepped into the challenging role of Infection Control Officer amid the pandemic. — Scott Burgess, David Lawrence Centers for Behavioral Health IN THE SUNSHINE Boost your well- being by walking ready for the licensing exam and providing exceptional patient care. Florence Nightingale is synonymous with nursing. This past year has raised the profile of the role nurses play in the health and wellbeing of patients. Their work is inspiring, and the need for more nurses continues to grow. You can learn more when we host our next virtual Bachelor of Science in Nursing degree information session at 4:00 p.m. on Monday, Feb. 8. You will learn in our state-of-the- art nursing labs from professors who are nurses. You'll find out what makes Hodges BSN program top notch and how it will prepare you for a rewarding career. Click here to register. — Dr. John Meyer, Hodges University -11" 1:1 =9-1-1 The beginning of the year is a good time for an HR tuneup said Felicia and Kenneth Anchor. International Holocaust Remembrance Day is on Jan. 27 this year, marking the 76th anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz. One Naples couple hopes to inspire others to remember the lessons of the Holocaust and prevent future genocide. Felicia and Kenneth Anchor are chairing the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum's 2021 Southeast Virtual Event on Feb. 11. Featuring special guests Morgan Freeman, Jamie Lee Curtis, Jason Alexander, Ray Allen and others, the event will underscore why the choices we make matter. The Anchors also played a key role in supporting the Naples Holocaust Museum, engaging a community of survivors and expanding services. — Cyndee Woolley, APR, C2 Communications BUSINESS Biomedical engineer wins grant to grow cartilage for facial reconstruction The goal? Track your Trek to the moon with fellow Blue Zones organizers. The longest -lived people in the world do not necessarily spend their lives doing strenuous exercise in a gym. Instead, they move naturally (which is a Blue Zones Power 9 principle) through daily activities like gardening or walking. Walking has many benefits. A study published in the British Journal of Sports Medicine found that those who adhered to a walking program showed significant improvements in blood pressure, slowing of resting heart rate, reduction of body fat and body weight, reduced cholesterol, and increased measures of endurance. Boost your well-being with Blue Zones Project's community walking challenge. Sign up here for free. — Sebastien Saitta, Blue Zones Project uuu BUSINESS a Molly Eyerman is your chief people partner for growing agencies. She strives to get CEOs out of the Michael/Toby mentality with HR and actually enjoy their people -focused initiatives. (Photo courtesy of Unsplash) Wow, 2021 is off to a roaring start! Clients are setting new people goals and companies are reaching out to get their HR house in order. Have you looked at your people operations recently? If not, here are some key areas for you to consider: • Performance expectations: do you have updated job descriptions for everyone and a clear feedback process? • Employee engagement: do you know how engaged your team is with each other and with the company? • Benefits program: when did you last get your team's pulse on your current benefits? What people areas will you focus on this year? — Molly Eyerman, The Agency 100 ®❑ Biomedical engineer Wendy Brown is creating tissue for facial reconstruction. Photo courtesy Wendy Brown Millions of people worldwide suffer from facial damage due to cancer, burns or genetics. Wendy Brown, a postdoctoral scholar in biomedical engineering at UC Irvine, was named a 2020 Women in Science Fellow by L'Oreal USA for her efforts to heal them. Brown received a $60,000 grant to continue her research into engineering cartilage for facial reconstruction. She is working to grow cartilage in various anatomical shapes and sizes for surgical implantation. Since 2003, L'Oreal USA has awarded $4 million in grants to 80 female scientists. Internationally, L'Oreal - UNESCO has recognized more than 3,400 women scientists from more than 116 countries. The importance of mentorship .0 A mentor doesn't necessarily have to be older. In the workplace, younger employees now oftentimes mentor superiors, most notably in technology. (Photo courtesy of SHRM.com) What better time to start mentoring someone, finding your own mentor or perhaps both as the new year kicks off with National Mentoring Month in January. Having a mentor is important for providing support and guidance to teenagers and young adults. It can also be a useful tool for adults, providing a pivotal step in reaching full potential both personally and professionally. Professionally, a mentor can help navigate a career path by helping with networking, challenging one on workplace tasks, offering encouragement and more. A mentor can also help with guidance in areas of personal growth, family and overall life. ❑ ❑ ❑ — Donna Scaramastra — MaryGrace Williams, Gorman, The Atlanta 100 The SWFL 100 The Engineering 100 o The stories, photos, videos and podcasts contained herein are written by The 100 Companies LLC and its members for the benefit of its members, partners, sponsors, clients and readers. We hope you'll enjoy our content and share it with other members of your community. View our Privacy Policy. © The 100 Companies, LLC 2021 All Rights Reserved. Member of The 100 Companies National PR Publishing Platform. Follow all our stories and videos online at TheSWFL100.com or on Facebook, Twitter or Instagram. If you'd like to suggest an interesting profile or a story idea, please email editor(a)theswfl100.com. The SWFL 100 5660 Strand Court, #A137 Naples, FL 34110 United States Have friends or family that would enjoy receiving The SWFL 100? Forward them a copy so that they can subscribe to receive their own. Unsubscribe 0 From: Ken Melkus To: SaundersBurt; TavlorPennv; LoCastroRick; McDanielBill; anita.ienkins(c colliercountvfl.com; SaboJames; SolisAndv Cc: pen ny.fisher(obnaplesnews.com; laura.layden(a naplesnews.com Subject: Collier Residents Deserve a Fair and Safe Venue Date: Saturday, December 19, 2020 11:28:07 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. On March 3, 2020, a state required Neighborhood Information Meeting (NIM) was conducted to hear about the proposed development of One Naples by Stock Development. The meeting was held at St. John's Evangelist Church where an estimated 400-450 people attended. Based on a show of hands, 8 people supported this highly controversial development with the remainder opposed, some so vehemently that they were escorted away from the microphone by state police. The final meeting by the County Commissioners is now scheduled for March 1, 2021. If the number of online signatures opposing this development (in excess of 3,000) is a proxy of the number of people who will attend to voice their opposition, the specific venue is important to assure an orderly and safe environment. Isn't it curious why the Commissioners by a vote of 3-2 selected a site (County offices) with limited capacity despite crowds that are likely to triple the size of those opposing at the NIM? Let's call if for what it is ... an attempt to disrupt the proceedings and stifle our freedom of free speech! Using an inadequate venue will create chaos and a dysfunctional public hearing. Further, the Commissioners supporting the County offices show blatant disregard for the health and safety of their constituents. We continue to battle the COVID virus and every effort should be made to host such a substantial gathering in as large a facility as possible and even show preference to an outdoor setting. Other sites options such as North Collier Park, St John's Evangelist or the Phil at Artis would be more conducive to a fair, open and safe hearing. The argument that alternatives outside the County facilities are not "technologically" equipped to handle such crowds is a shallow argument. County staff could make one of these sites compliant during the next two months at minimal costs and effort. Commissioners, please reconsider your venue decision. Failure to do so will simply reinforce the public's perception that the Commissioners continue their bias for Developers at the expense of the rights and desires of their constituents. If the hearing on March 1 st is to have any legitimacy, let's not stack the deck against the public at the outset! If One Naples development is evaluated on its merits, I am confident it will be disapproved. If the final review is politicized as I fear, the quality of life that we all treasure in Collier will quickly unravel and give way to nothing more than a Dade look alike! Advocate For Responsible Development in Collier County Ken Melkus Sent from my iPad From: Ken Melkus To: SaundersBurt; TavlorPennv; LoCastroRick; McDanielBill; anita.ienkins(c colliercountvfl.com; SaboJames; SolisAndv Cc: pen ny.fisher(obnaplesnews.com; laura.layden(a naplesnews.com Subject: Collier Residents Deserve a Fair and Safe Venue Date: Saturday, December 19, 2020 11:28:07 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. On March 3, 2020, a state required Neighborhood Information Meeting (NIM) was conducted to hear about the proposed development of One Naples by Stock Development. The meeting was held at St. John's Evangelist Church where an estimated 400-450 people attended. Based on a show of hands, 8 people supported this highly controversial development with the remainder opposed, some so vehemently that they were escorted away from the microphone by state police. The final meeting by the County Commissioners is now scheduled for March 1, 2021. If the number of online signatures opposing this development (in excess of 3,000) is a proxy of the number of people who will attend to voice their opposition, the specific venue is important to assure an orderly and safe environment. Isn't it curious why the Commissioners by a vote of 3-2 selected a site (County offices) with limited capacity despite crowds that are likely to triple the size of those opposing at the NIM? Let's call if for what it is ... an attempt to disrupt the proceedings and stifle our freedom of free speech! Using an inadequate venue will create chaos and a dysfunctional public hearing. Further, the Commissioners supporting the County offices show blatant disregard for the health and safety of their constituents. We continue to battle the COVID virus and every effort should be made to host such a substantial gathering in as large a facility as possible and even show preference to an outdoor setting. Other sites options such as North Collier Park, St John's Evangelist or the Phil at Artis would be more conducive to a fair, open and safe hearing. The argument that alternatives outside the County facilities are not "technologically" equipped to handle such crowds is a shallow argument. County staff could make one of these sites compliant during the next two months at minimal costs and effort. Commissioners, please reconsider your venue decision. Failure to do so will simply reinforce the public's perception that the Commissioners continue their bias for Developers at the expense of the rights and desires of their constituents. If the hearing on March 1 st is to have any legitimacy, let's not stack the deck against the public at the outset! If One Naples development is evaluated on its merits, I am confident it will be disapproved. If the final review is politicized as I fear, the quality of life that we all treasure in Collier will quickly unravel and give way to nothing more than a Dade look alike! Advocate For Responsible Development in Collier County Ken Melkus Sent from my iPad From: ei)ircioCabverizon.net To: LoCastroRick; SaboJames; TavlorPenny; SaundersBurt; McDanielBill; SolisAndv Subject: Current view up Southbay Dr from Barefoot Pelican walkway - picture 1 Date: Tuesday, January 5, 2021 2:26:09 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioners: I own a condo in Barefoot Pelican at 271 Southbay Dr. which abuts the One Naples properties. This is a picture of our current view up Southbay Dr. towards Vanderbilt Beach. We often spend our afternoons sitting, reading and socializing on our walkways. This is picture 1 of 3 that I will be sending you. Respectfully, Elizabeth (Betty) Pircio Barefoot Pelican Condominium 271 Southbay Dr. Naples, FL This is the view we currently epircio@verizon.net -----Original Message ----- From: Ralph Cowie <ralphcowie1 @gmail.com> To: epircio@verizon.net Sent: Wed, Nov 4, 2020 4:25 pm - © f .<y 2�<� .. �© . ���a-a• . 6 From: ei)ircioCabverizon.net To: LoCastroRick; SaboJames; TavlorPenny; SaundersBurt; McDanielBill; SolisAndv Subject: Current view up Southbay Dr from Barefoot Pelican walkway - picture 1 Date: Tuesday, January 5, 2021 2:26:09 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioners: I own a condo in Barefoot Pelican at 271 Southbay Dr. which abuts the One Naples properties. This is a picture of our current view up Southbay Dr. towards Vanderbilt Beach. We often spend our afternoons sitting, reading and socializing on our walkways. This is picture 1 of 3 that I will be sending you. Respectfully, Elizabeth (Betty) Pircio Barefoot Pelican Condominium 271 Southbay Dr. Naples, FL This is the view we currently epircio@verizon.net -----Original Message ----- From: Ralph Cowie <ralphcowie1 @gmail.com> To: epircio@verizon.net Sent: Wed, Nov 4, 2020 4:25 pm - © f .<y 2�<� .. �© . ���a-a• . 6 From: Bill Mcclayton To: TavlorPennv Cc: bill.mcclayton(cbamail.com Subject: Email Date: Tuesday, January 5, 2021 12:12:42 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Penny.. A copy of youremail of January 4th was forwarded to me .... it was the most sensible summary of the process for getting the vaccine.... so thank you I have yet to be successful in gaining a spot for my wife and for me .... hopefully soon So... Pls add my name to your email distribution list .... thank you And Pls add my name to the long list of those strongly against any change in zoning et al for the stock development ...One Naples.... an arrogant branding for sure. I won't bore you with repeating all the reasons this is wrong and unfair.... and I see no reason why we the people should give a gift of a major financial gain to the developer. He bought the property knowing the zoning and restrictions .... and he should live with them. I am happy to expand or clarify or amplify if you wish I appreciate all you do on our behalf.... thank you. All the best Happy and healthy 2021. Cheers WmMcC Sent from my Wad From: Bill Mcclayton To: TavlorPennv Cc: bill.mcclayton(cbamail.com Subject: Email Date: Tuesday, January 5, 2021 12:12:42 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Penny.. A copy of youremail of January 4th was forwarded to me .... it was the most sensible summary of the process for getting the vaccine.... so thank you I have yet to be successful in gaining a spot for my wife and for me .... hopefully soon So... Pls add my name to your email distribution list .... thank you And Pls add my name to the long list of those strongly against any change in zoning et al for the stock development ...One Naples.... an arrogant branding for sure. I won't bore you with repeating all the reasons this is wrong and unfair.... and I see no reason why we the people should give a gift of a major financial gain to the developer. He bought the property knowing the zoning and restrictions .... and he should live with them. I am happy to expand or clarify or amplify if you wish I appreciate all you do on our behalf.... thank you. All the best Happy and healthy 2021. Cheers WmMcC Sent from my Wad From: Ken Melkus To: TavlorPennv; GrecoSherry; Grea Stuart; George Marks; mee3eaa(ciaol.com Cc: mstra5050(@amail.com; jcleveland(cbe-wasteonline.com; buzz(abunitedstor-all.com; enircio(overizon.net; ckawer(alhullinc.com; russell(cbsocial-impact. com; dennis aoettsch(caicloud.com; bamaher55(�amail.com; pbbpoa(a pbbpropertyowners.org; mee1943(abgmail.com; kathyrobbins(ftahooxom; bill(u weo-oe.com; William Schuman; David N Galloway, krosenb(cahotmail.com; nancv.nbooa(aamail.com Subject: February 24th Meeting re One Naples Development Date: Tuesday, February 2, 2021 11:39:34 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor and Sherry Greco, Thank you for the opportunity to meet with Commissioner Taylor in the County offices at 10:00 am on Feb. 24th regarding the proposed One Naples Development. I am hopeful of having three colleagues, Greg Stuart (Expert Land Planner), George Marks (Founder and Principal of Kramer Marks Architectural/Planning firm and Mark English, (President of Pelican Bay Property Home Owners Assoc) join me in person. I have taken the liberty of preparing the following agenda to guide our discussion: I) Intro of team referenced above ... Ken II)Review of 3D Model... Greg III) Summary of Planning Staff Comments... Greg IV)SVB Executive Summary and Rationale for Denial of GMP... George V) Overview of "Final Push" Campaign ... Ken VI) Review Process, GMP vs Zoning... Greg VII) Implications for Collier County ... Mark VIII)Questions and Answers... Group and Virtual Attendees IX) Additional Information Needs for Commissioner Taylor We also expect a number of individuals who have been active and instrumental to our community opposition to participate virtually and they will join via zoom @873 3913 3526; passcode 901487 as Sherry instructed. They are being shown as copied above. We look forward to a productive discussion and appreciate Commissioner Taylor's time. Feel free to contact me should you have any questions and assume Sherry will clear those attending in person through security. Thank you. Ken Melkus Sent from my iPad From: N Milenkovich To: andvsolis(a)colliercountyfl.gov; SaundersBurt; LoCastroRick; McDanielBill; TavlorPennv Subject: Fw: nedmilenkovich@yahoo.com - Let Commissioners Know - Eye to Eye in Safety Date: Tuesday, December 22, 2020 11:06:40 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Greetings Commissioners. I live at Vanderbilt Beach. I support the One Naples project. I am offended that "Save Vanderbilt Beach" is hijacking the entire community and representing itself as the sole voice for the area. They do not! I have no financial interest in any of this. I simply want to support the improvements and development of the area. It is time to stop the arguing and start building. The people who are opposed to this have provided no reasonable argument as to why the project should not be constructed. It will help everyone! Get the density to the level of everyone's satisfaction and support the development please. Mr. LoCastro and Ms. Taylor, I have you marked as opposing this project. I ask you... WHY? What is your problem? Stop getting in the way of the growth and development of an area that is open field. If Victor Buzz is somehow financing your campaigns let me know because I will start financing people who are opposed to you! Get out of the way and let the developer make the area more appealing for everyone. Thanks! ----- Forwarded Message ----- From: Save Vanderbilt Beach <info@savevanderbiltbeach.com> To: "nedmilenkovich@yahoo.com" <nedmilenkovich@yahoo.com> Sent: Friday, December 18, 2020, 02:16:40 PM EST Subject: nedmilenkovich@yahoo.com - Let Commissioners Know - Eye to Eye in Safety 0 December 18, 2020 H Be Heard - Your Voice Matters ►V/ No::I =I 97_11:4 MARCH 1, 2021, 8:OOAM Collier County Office Building Mark your calendar now 0 New Meeting Venue Needed In a special meeting, held on December 15, 2020, the Collier County Commissioners determined the and location of the One Naples hearing. Discussion was held regarding the location of the hearing with options being St John the Evangelist Church on 111th Avenue, the North Collier County Regional Park on Livingston Road, and the Cour office building, where the commissioners traditionally meet. All of the Commissioners acknowledged that the turn out for this hearing was going to be unusually and cumbersome, with COVID-distancing requirements to hold the meeting at the County office built but there was a concern on the part of several commissioners that if one of the other options was us would not have adequate IT capability to handle virtual attendees, live TV, etc. A motion was made by Commissioner McDaniel to hold the meeting at the County office building an motion carried in a three to two vote with Commissioners Taylor and LoCastro voting no. All Commissioners vowed that everyone wanting to be heard would be heard. Staff was directed to figure out the logistics. Holding the meeting at the Commissioner's office building puts us at a disadvantage in our effort to influence the Commissioners' vote on One Naples. Our hope is that the Commissioners will reconsider their decision for the safety and security of the residents and easier flow for speaker impact. Once again, we need your help, calling or writing the Commissioners. We have created a new letter that you can send specifically requesting a different meeting venue. With one click, you can send a letter to all the Commissioners. Or, you can call each Commissioners' office at the phone numbers provided below. On a related matter, we hope that you have seen our communications regarding The Final Push, our intensive multi -pronged plan to convince the Commissioners to deny Stock's request for a change in the County's Growth Management Plan. If you have not learned about it, read the story below. Write Commissioners How to Donate Here's how to donate. https://aivinatools.com/aive/l 133/2877 Remember, it's not just the money. Please take a moment to call or write your own County Commissioner and in form him or her of your 8 opposition. Here's how to do that.. Click Here to Donate Save Vanderbilt Beach 1 1415 Panther Lane, Naples, FL 34109 Unsubscribe nedmilenkovich(Jlyahoo.com Update Profile I About our service provider Sent by info@savevanderbiltbeach.com powered by ®❑ Try email marketing for free today! From: N Milenkovich To: andvsolis(a)colliercountyfl.gov; SaundersBurt; LoCastroRick; McDanielBill; TavlorPennv Subject: Fw: nedmilenkovich@yahoo.com - Let Commissioners Know - Eye to Eye in Safety Date: Tuesday, December 22, 2020 11:06:40 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Greetings Commissioners. I live at Vanderbilt Beach. I support the One Naples project. I am offended that "Save Vanderbilt Beach" is hijacking the entire community and representing itself as the sole voice for the area. They do not! I have no financial interest in any of this. I simply want to support the improvements and development of the area. It is time to stop the arguing and start building. The people who are opposed to this have provided no reasonable argument as to why the project should not be constructed. It will help everyone! Get the density to the level of everyone's satisfaction and support the development please. Mr. LoCastro and Ms. Taylor, I have you marked as opposing this project. I ask you... WHY? What is your problem? Stop getting in the way of the growth and development of an area that is open field. If Victor Buzz is somehow financing your campaigns let me know because I will start financing people who are opposed to you! Get out of the way and let the developer make the area more appealing for everyone. Thanks! ----- Forwarded Message ----- From: Save Vanderbilt Beach <info@savevanderbiltbeach.com> To: "nedmilenkovich@yahoo.com" <nedmilenkovich@yahoo.com> Sent: Friday, December 18, 2020, 02:16:40 PM EST Subject: nedmilenkovich@yahoo.com - Let Commissioners Know - Eye to Eye in Safety 0 December 18, 2020 H Be Heard - Your Voice Matters ►V/ No::I =I 97_11:4 MARCH 1, 2021, 8:OOAM Collier County Office Building Mark your calendar now 0 New Meeting Venue Needed In a special meeting, held on December 15, 2020, the Collier County Commissioners determined the and location of the One Naples hearing. Discussion was held regarding the location of the hearing with options being St John the Evangelist Church on 111th Avenue, the North Collier County Regional Park on Livingston Road, and the Cour office building, where the commissioners traditionally meet. All of the Commissioners acknowledged that the turn out for this hearing was going to be unusually and cumbersome, with COVID-distancing requirements to hold the meeting at the County office built but there was a concern on the part of several commissioners that if one of the other options was us would not have adequate IT capability to handle virtual attendees, live TV, etc. A motion was made by Commissioner McDaniel to hold the meeting at the County office building an motion carried in a three to two vote with Commissioners Taylor and LoCastro voting no. All Commissioners vowed that everyone wanting to be heard would be heard. Staff was directed to figure out the logistics. Holding the meeting at the Commissioner's office building puts us at a disadvantage in our effort to influence the Commissioners' vote on One Naples. Our hope is that the Commissioners will reconsider their decision for the safety and security of the residents and easier flow for speaker impact. Once again, we need your help, calling or writing the Commissioners. We have created a new letter that you can send specifically requesting a different meeting venue. With one click, you can send a letter to all the Commissioners. Or, you can call each Commissioners' office at the phone numbers provided below. On a related matter, we hope that you have seen our communications regarding The Final Push, our intensive multi -pronged plan to convince the Commissioners to deny Stock's request for a change in the County's Growth Management Plan. If you have not learned about it, read the story below. Write Commissioners How to Donate Here's how to donate. https://aivinatools.com/aive/l 133/2877 Remember, it's not just the money. Please take a moment to call or write your own County Commissioner and in form him or her of your 8 opposition. Here's how to do that.. Click Here to Donate Save Vanderbilt Beach 1 1415 Panther Lane, Naples, FL 34109 Unsubscribe nedmilenkovich(Jlyahoo.com Update Profile I About our service provider Sent by info@savevanderbiltbeach.com powered by ®❑ Try email marketing for free today! From: OchsLeo To: TavlorPennv Cc: KlatzkowJeff; RodriguezDan; CohenThaddeus; GrecoSherry Subject: FW: Proposed Procedure for One Naples Date: Tuesday, February 16, 2021 9:53:49 AM Attachments: Procedural Memo One Naples Final.doc Res. 95-376 ex parte communication.pdf Procedures -quasi judicial - Res 98-167.odf Commissioner, I misspoke this morning when we were discussing the procedural process for the One Naples Hearing. The attached information has not yet been distributed to the Board. Jeff K. has worked with our staff to develop the attached procedures for the conduct of the hearing and has asked that this information be included as backup documentation in the BCC packet for the hearing. Please contact Jeff and/or me if you would like to discuss further. Thanks. VR, Leo Leo E. Ochs, Jr. Collier County Manager Ieo.ochs0coIIiercountyf1.gov 3299 East Tamiami Trail Naples FL 34112 239.252.8383 From: KlatzkowJeff <Jeff.Klatzkow@colliercountyfl.gov> Sent: Wednesday, February 03, 2021 2:19 PM To: SaboJames <James.Sabo@colliercountyfl.gov> Cc: OchsLeo <Leo.Ochs@colliercountyfl.gov>; RodriguezDan <Dan. Rod riguez@colliercountyfl.gov>; AshtonHeidi <Heidi.Ashton@colliercountyfl.gov>; JenkinsAnita <Anita.Jenkins@colliercountyfl.gov>; BellowsRay <Ray.Bel lows@colliercountyfl.gov>; CohenThaddeus <Thaddeus.Cohen@colliercountyfl.gov>; KlatzkowJeff <Jeff.Klatzkow@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Proposed Procedure for One Naples James: All changes accepted. Please include this, together with the attached Resolutions, as back-up to the Executive Summary when you load the item. will distribute the Memo and Resolutions to the Commissioners prior to the Hearing. Jeffrey A. Klatzkow Collier County Attorney (239) 252-2614 From: SaboJames <James.Sabo(@colliercountyfl.gov> Sent: Wednesday, February 3, 2021 1:55 PM To: KlatzkowJeff <Jeff.Klatzkow(LDcolliercount)zfl.gov>; CohenThaddeus <Thaddeus.Cohen(@colliercountyfl.gov> Cc: OchsLeo<Leo.Ochs(@colliercountyfl.gov>; RodriguezDan <Dan.Rodriguez(@ col Iiercountyfl.gov>; AshtonHeidi <Heidi.Ashton(@colliercount)tfl.gov>, JenkinsAnita <Anita.Jenkins(@colliercountyfl.gov>; Bel lowsRay <Ray. Bellows(@ col IiercountyfLgov> Subject: RE: Proposed Procedure for One Naples Suggested changes to the procedural document attached. Respectfully, C. James Sabo, AICP Principal Planner Coter C014fity Zoning Division James.Sabo@colliercountyfl.gov 2800 North Horseshoe Drive, Naples Florida 34104 Phone: 239.252.2708 "Tell us how we are doing by taking our Zoning Division Survey at htt12s://goo.g1/eXivaT." Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: KlatzkowJeff <Jeff.KlatzkowPcolIiercountyfl.gov> Sent: Friday, January 29, 2021 2:58 PM To: CohenThaddeus <Thaddeus.Cohen(@colliercountyfl.gov> Cc: OchsLeo<Leo.Ochs(@colliercountyfl.gov>; RodriguezDan <Dan. Rod riguez(@colIiercountyfl.gov>; AshtonHeidi <Heidi.Ashton(@colliercountyfl.gov>; SaboJames <James.SaboCo)colliercountyfl.gov>; JenkinsAnita <Anita.Jenkins(@colliercountyfl.gov>; BellowsRay <Ray. Bellows(@ col Iiercountyfl.gov> Subject: Proposed Procedure for One Naples Thaddeus: This is in furtherance of Mr. Sabo's attached email to me of January 22nd Attached is a proposed procedure for the conduct of the One Naples Hearings. The procedure (and memo) is substantially identical to those we have utilized in similar hearings. I would appreciate you and your staff s review and comments. Once finalized, my intent is to distribute the memo to the Board, with a copy included in the back-up to the Executive Summary, which would give the public notice of what to expect that day. As always, please feel free to call me on this. Jeffrey A. Klatzkow Collier County Attorney (239) 252-2614 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: OchsLeo To: DLCOMM; izziAix ; FilsonSue; GoodnerAnaela; GrecoSherrv; LvkinsDave Cc: RodriguezDan; CohenThaddeus Subject: FW: Updated hearing projections Date: Thursday, January 21, 2021 9:47:28 AM Attachments: 1-20-21 - Public Hearina Proiections (Sent to CMO).xlsx Good Morning Commissioners, Please find attached a summary of the current schedule of BCC public hearings through May of this year. This is only a snap shot as of this date. This schedule often changes due to CCPC hearing continuances, petitioner requests for continuances, etc. I will continue to provide periodic updates as we progress through the year. VR, Leo Leo E. Ochs, Jr. Collier County Manager Ieo.ochs&coIIiercountyf1.gov 3299 East Tamiami Trail Naples FL 34112 239.252.8383 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: ei)ircioCabverizon.net To: LoCastroRick; TavlorPenny; McDanielBill; SolisAndv; SaundersBurt; SaboJames Subject: Fwd: Barrier is 19 feet long and is 20 feet from man Picture 2 of 3 Date: Tuesday, January 5, 2021 2:59:02 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioners, You might wonder what this photo represents. The One Naples Mid -rise building next to Barefoot Pelican will be 37 feet back from the property line for their side yard setback. However, One Naples front yard setback will only be 10 feet back from their property line and will be 87 feet tall. Barefoot Pelican has a regulatory 28 foot front yard setback and is a regulatory 48 feet tall. What this means, is that residents of Barefoot Pelican will be looking at 19 feet of concrete when they try to look up Southbay Dr. from their walkways. So when we are on the walkways reading and socializing, we sill be in the shadows of One Naples mid -rise and will be unable to even look up the street. This is what happens when developers try to circumvent the Zoning Laws when they come in to an existing neighborhood that has complied with the Zoning. The Zoning Laws should remain the same in these neighborhoods lest developers become unjustly enriched at the expense of the current neighbors of which I am one. Respectfully, Elizabeth (Betty) Pircio 271 Southbay Dr. Naples, FL 781-690-0486 epircio@verizon.net -----Original Message ----- From: Ralph Cowie <ralphcowiel @gmail.com> To: epircio@verizon.net Sent: Wed, Nov 4, 2020 4:24 pm From: ei)ircioCabverizon.net To: LoCastroRick; TavlorPenny; McDanielBill; SolisAndv; SaundersBurt; SaboJames Subject: Fwd: Barrier is 19 feet long and is 20 feet from man Picture 2 of 3 Date: Tuesday, January 5, 2021 2:59:02 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioners, You might wonder what this photo represents. The One Naples Mid -rise building next to Barefoot Pelican will be 37 feet back from the property line for their side yard setback. However, One Naples front yard setback will only be 10 feet back from their property line and will be 87 feet tall. Barefoot Pelican has a regulatory 28 foot front yard setback and is a regulatory 48 feet tall. What this means, is that residents of Barefoot Pelican will be looking at 19 feet of concrete when they try to look up Southbay Dr. from their walkways. So when we are on the walkways reading and socializing, we sill be in the shadows of One Naples mid -rise and will be unable to even look up the street. This is what happens when developers try to circumvent the Zoning Laws when they come in to an existing neighborhood that has complied with the Zoning. The Zoning Laws should remain the same in these neighborhoods lest developers become unjustly enriched at the expense of the current neighbors of which I am one. Respectfully, Elizabeth (Betty) Pircio 271 Southbay Dr. Naples, FL 781-690-0486 epircio@verizon.net -----Original Message ----- From: Ralph Cowie <ralphcowiel @gmail.com> To: epircio@verizon.net Sent: Wed, Nov 4, 2020 4:24 pm From: ei)ircio(fterizon.net To: TaylorPenny; SolisAndy; McDanielBill; SaundersBurt; SaboJames Subject: Fwd: Naples one Commissioners Two Date: Wednesday, January 6, 2021 3:07:41 PM Attachments: Scan. DdfCOMMISSION ERS TWO.odf EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioners: These next two pages are the most important because they show the inconsistencies and lack of compatibility of the One Naples development to the neighborhood. As said before,the project must be consistent and compatible with the neighborhood in order to receive a Zoning change, otherwise, the County will be enriching the developer at the expense of the neighbors. Diagram 1 - Prepared by Greg Stuart a City Planner retained by the Regatta Condominium Complex on Vanderbilt Beach Road. He has listed what the current C-3 Zoning will allow on the parcels, versus what Stock wants to be allowed. Please keep in mind that Stock Development bought all these parcels knowing that the Zoning would not allow what he wanted to build. He bought the parcels and did not make their purchase contingent on his receiving the approvals necessary. it. We are all business people in some way whether we run the County, our households, or work outside. Well, I am a practicing CPA in Mass. and I don't have to tell you, that it is a poor business practice to purchase something for 25,000,000 and not be sure that what you want to build is going to be allowed! Should Collier County be in the business of a bail out of a bad business decision? I hope not! a. Units allowed are a total of 87---------------------------------------------------------units wanted -172 b. Height allowed is 100 feet --------------------------------------------------------------- height wanted - 208 feet for towers, 87 for the mid -rises c. Setbacks allowed are 25 feet ---------------------------------------------------------- setbacks wanted are 15 feet for the towers, and one mid -rise, and 10 feet for the other mid -rises. Diagram 2 Prepared by Greg Stuart shows in green the setbacks on Gulf Shore Dr. As you can see, most of the condos have a setback from the road of at least 25 feet except for the Lighthouse, which is 2 stories and setback 17 feet from the road. The average setbacks on Gulf Shore Drive are 49 feet. The setbacks allow the residents to see down the street from their lanais. It offers landscaping and open space for the enjoyment of their residents. One Naples concrete towers will be set 15 feet from the road and even the parking garage will tower 35+ feet over the people and autos. This will create a cavern effect, create shadows instead of sunshine and will increase the wind velocity for the pedestrians. The impact of these towering structures will effect the neighbors, the pedestrians, and the autos. All to enrich the coffers of Stock Development. To my mind the most important deviation from the Zoning Laws is the Setback requirements. Increasing the setbacks to that which is allowed, (25 feet) will cure many of the other problems. If the setbacks are increased, the density will also increase. One Naples setbacks effect the neighborhood greater than any other deviation, in my opinion. I hope you find this information pertinent. I know it is not easy reading and it has also taken me a long time to gather it in a manner that will make a bit easier to assimilate. By the way, all of the information I am sending you is part of the public record. And, in case Stock objects, it is also being forwarded to James Sabo the Chief Planner for the County on this project as part of the public record. Respectfully submitted Elizabeth (Betty) Pircio Barefoot Pelican Condominium 271 Southbay Dr. Naples, FI 781-690-0486 epircio@verizon.net -----Original Message ----- From: epircio@verizon.net To: epircio@verizon.net Sent: Wed, Dec 30, 2020 4:32 pm Subject: Naples one COmmissioners Two epircio@verizon.net From: ei)ircio(fterizon.net To: TaylorPenny; SolisAndy; McDanielBill; SaundersBurt; SaboJames Subject: Fwd: Naples one Commissioners Two Date: Wednesday, January 6, 2021 3:07:41 PM Attachments: Scan. DdfCOMMISSION ERS TWO.odf EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioners: These next two pages are the most important because they show the inconsistencies and lack of compatibility of the One Naples development to the neighborhood. As said before,the project must be consistent and compatible with the neighborhood in order to receive a Zoning change, otherwise, the County will be enriching the developer at the expense of the neighbors. Diagram 1 - Prepared by Greg Stuart a City Planner retained by the Regatta Condominium Complex on Vanderbilt Beach Road. He has listed what the current C-3 Zoning will allow on the parcels, versus what Stock wants to be allowed. Please keep in mind that Stock Development bought all these parcels knowing that the Zoning would not allow what he wanted to build. He bought the parcels and did not make their purchase contingent on his receiving the approvals necessary. it. We are all business people in some way whether we run the County, our households, or work outside. Well, I am a practicing CPA in Mass. and I don't have to tell you, that it is a poor business practice to purchase something for 25,000,000 and not be sure that what you want to build is going to be allowed! Should Collier County be in the business of a bail out of a bad business decision? I hope not! a. Units allowed are a total of 87---------------------------------------------------------units wanted -172 b. Height allowed is 100 feet --------------------------------------------------------------- height wanted - 208 feet for towers, 87 for the mid -rises c. Setbacks allowed are 25 feet ---------------------------------------------------------- setbacks wanted are 15 feet for the towers, and one mid -rise, and 10 feet for the other mid -rises. Diagram 2 Prepared by Greg Stuart shows in green the setbacks on Gulf Shore Dr. As you can see, most of the condos have a setback from the road of at least 25 feet except for the Lighthouse, which is 2 stories and setback 17 feet from the road. The average setbacks on Gulf Shore Drive are 49 feet. The setbacks allow the residents to see down the street from their lanais. It offers landscaping and open space for the enjoyment of their residents. One Naples concrete towers will be set 15 feet from the road and even the parking garage will tower 35+ feet over the people and autos. This will create a cavern effect, create shadows instead of sunshine and will increase the wind velocity for the pedestrians. The impact of these towering structures will effect the neighbors, the pedestrians, and the autos. All to enrich the coffers of Stock Development. To my mind the most important deviation from the Zoning Laws is the Setback requirements. Increasing the setbacks to that which is allowed, (25 feet) will cure many of the other problems. If the setbacks are increased, the density will also increase. One Naples setbacks effect the neighborhood greater than any other deviation, in my opinion. I hope you find this information pertinent. I know it is not easy reading and it has also taken me a long time to gather it in a manner that will make a bit easier to assimilate. By the way, all of the information I am sending you is part of the public record. And, in case Stock objects, it is also being forwarded to James Sabo the Chief Planner for the County on this project as part of the public record. Respectfully submitted Elizabeth (Betty) Pircio Barefoot Pelican Condominium 271 Southbay Dr. Naples, FI 781-690-0486 epircio@verizon.net -----Original Message ----- From: epircio@verizon.net To: epircio@verizon.net Sent: Wed, Dec 30, 2020 4:32 pm Subject: Naples one COmmissioners Two epircio@verizon.net From: rlmoore52Ca1aol.com To: TavlorPenny Cc: rick(d)ricklocastro.com; McDanielBill; andy.soltis(d)colliercount fy_I.aov; burt.saunder(a)colliercountyfl.00v; rlmoore52Ca1aol.com; office(a�i mtspropertymaintenance.com; colbofclIcom; iordanifl0(a)aol.com; wolfram 111Ca1hotmai I.com Subject: Fwd: One Naples has crossed the line... Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 11:17:28 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Commissioner Taylor's comment in the Naples Daily New 2/9/21 that the $287,827 to Fish and Wildlife Service from the Eastern Collier Property Owners' Group "likens the arrangement to a bribe" is not much different from the $550,000 from Stock Development to the Barefoot Pelican Condo Association. As I have cited in my previous memos to Collier County Commissioners, Stock Development needs to comply with Collier County Codes without Commissioners granting exemptions on height, density and set backs to which all other Collier Condo Associations must adhere. Respectfully, Robert L. Moore 9375 Gulf Shore Drive #502 Naples, Florida 34108 239-566-1543 -----Original Message ----- From: Pelican Bay Property Owners Association <pbpoa@pbpropertyowners.org> To: Robert <rlmoore52@aol.com> Sent: Mon, Feb 8, 2021 8:15 pm Subject: One Naples has crossed the line... View this email in your browser �J One Naples Has Crossed the Line of Decency... Now for the Payoff! Stock Development has now presented the Barefoot Pelican Condominium Association, one of the buildings most affected by One Naples as proposed, with a formal proposal, a 'Memo of Understanding' (MOU) in their terminology, that will give the Barefoot Pelican Condo Association nearly $550,000 in cash and services in exchange for their support of the One Naples project. The money being offered is for various projects around the Barefoot Pelican property such a painting and landscaping. Folks, this is not about Brooks Brothers giving you a tie if you purchase a shirt or Nike paying Michael Jordan to endorse Air Jordan's. This "understanding" is for the sole purpose of altering opinions, changing opinions and buying opinions. The trade off, of course, is that 0 the Barefoot Pelican Condominium Association agrees to support Stock Development's actions in securing County approval to proceed with One Naples as proposed. In the Naples Daily News article, 'One Naples isn't just controversial, it's become divisive' (January 21, 2021), Collier County Commissioner, Andy Solis, stated that there is nothing "nefarious" about it and that he would be surprised if some inducement wasn't offered to gain favor. When accused of buying votes, Brian Stock of Stock Development in that article said, "I take offense to that." Mr. Stock also said he did not initiate the negotiations with the two condo boards involved and said that they approached him first. Please explain, Mr. Stock, what possible difference this makes. Reality is, Mr. Stock responded to these condo associations' expressed concerns, not out of the goodness of his heart or to be neighborly, he responded to them because he (fully) knew the extent of the negative impact his proposed One Naples development had on these neighboring buildings. He was trying to do 'damage control!' When a developer pays people to 'buy' into a plan or project, many consider such action to be underhanded and reprehensible. 0 Thousand of Collier residents see this proposed project as an insidious monstrosity that violates current zoning codes, covenants and rules, making it neither compatible nor consistent with the existing neighborhood. More so, many view this Growth Management Plan Amendment (GMPA) as the developer's self-seeking attempt to profit from a 'bad' business deal at the expense of the neighborhood and community. If our County Commissioners continue to do 'business as usual' and turn a blind eye to this overreaching amendment request, thousands of lives for a hundred years or more will be negatively affected by this project and the 'domino effect' of its precedent! The developer's latest antics of trying to 'divide and conquer' these neighboring associations only serves to prove how flawed and undesirable this project is to the surrounding neighborhood and the Collier County beach community as well! Mr. Stock, would you try to build this project in your Naples neighborhood on 5.42 acres? We must continue to make our voices heard right up until the Board of County Commissioners meeting on March 1st, 2021. What matters is what's right. And One Naples is wrong! We must have two Commissioner's votes to DENY One Naples! We need your help... Please take a few moments to complete this brief Growth Management Survey. This polling survey, being done with SaveVanderbiltBeach, will be used to let our Commissioners know what is important to you. This information will be shared with the Board of County Commissioners at the One Naples hearing on March 1st, 2021. your opinion matters! Also, please continue to write, call and email the five County Commissioners and make your voice heard. Their contact information is below. Mark E. English, President along with your friends at the Pelican Bay Property Owners Association P.S. You'll be hearing and 'seeing' more about One Naples in the coming weeks. We are grateful for your continued support in helping us to contain overreaching urban sprawl! Collier County Commissioners: • Andy Solis, Esq. (239) 252-8602 Andy. Sol is&colIiercountyfl.gov • Penny Taylor (239) 252-8604 Penny.Taylor(2colliercountyfl.gov • Rick LoCastro (239) 252-8601 Rick. LoCastro&colliercou ntyfl.gov William L. McDaniel, Jr. (239) 252-8605 Bill. McDaniel&colliercountyfl.gov Burt L. Saunders (239) 252-8603 Burt.Saunders&colliercountyfl.gov V Copyright © 2021 Pelican Bay Property Owners Association, All rights reserved. You are receiving this email because you signed up at our website. Our mailing address is: Pelican Bay Property Owners Association 1110 Pine Ridge Rd Ste 303 Naples, FI 34108 Add us to your address book Want to change how you receive these emails? You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list. From: ei)ircio(fterizon.net To: TaylorPenny; LoCastroRick Subject: Fwd: One Naples Hearing Date: Saturday, December 19, 2020 9:32:41 PM Attachments: Docl.docxPICTURE OF MARCH 3 2020 MEETING.docx EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioners: I understand that you were the only two Commissioners who voted to change the venue of the One Naples Hearing to a location outside of the regular hearing location in view of the Covid-19 health risk and the numbers of people who will want to speak to their concerns. I am attaching a copy of an e-mail that I sent to Commissioner Solis this afternoon for your information. Attached to the e-mail is a photo of the people who attended the NIM on March 3, 2020. 1 believe the photo speaks for itself in that there were 400-500 people attending and many wanted their turn to speak. This will be happening at your meeting of March 1, 2021 but we expect more people will want to speak. I thank you for your consideration to us in attempting to change the venue to something larger where all of us will be able to attend and to listen to the others speak. We appreciate your concern for our health and well-being as we try to participate in this process of voicing our concerns and trying to encourage the developer to scale down his project to something that we can all live with. Respectfully, Elizabeth Pircio 271 South Bay Drive Naples, FL 34108 epircio@verizon.net -----Original Message ----- From: epircio@verizon.net To: andy.solis@colliercountyfl.gov<andy.solis@colliercountyfl.gov> Sent: Sat, Dec 19, 2020 4:29 pm Subject: One Naples Hearing Dear Commissioner Solis, I have been told that you do read all of your e-mails. I also read all of the a -mails that you send to me as well as your other constituents. You voted to conduct the One Naples Hearing scheduled for March in the County Officers because all of the technical equipment is located there. I have attached a picture of the One Naples Hearing that was held on March 3, 2020 in St. John's Church. This hearing took place before anyone realized the dangers of Covid-19. As you can see, there were approximately 400 to 500 people in attendance and some 29 of them spoke at the mike. When a speaker asked for those in favor of One Naples as submitted to raise their hands and stand, 8 people stood up, the rest were firmly opposed.. Some of the speakers were so passionate in their opposition that police officers had to escort them to their chairs. This is the forum that our Constitution allows the people to use when government is not abiding by the will of the people. Forcing your constituents to sit in their cars and wait for their opportunity to speak circumvents the process of Free Speech. It does not allow the Commissioners to hear what all the people are saying. Furthermore, it will stifle our opportunity to hear what others are saying. Commissioner, I would not like to think that by keeping the people segregated in their respective rooms or in their cars, you would be effectively silencing our ability to comment on our concerns about this project. I am urging you do the right thing here. There is plenty of time to find the correct venue to allow anyone who wants to speak to this massive project, the opportunity to speak. Florida had exactly 13,000 new Covid-19 cases yesterday according to Johns Hopkins. This is very disturbing to me and should be to you as well. I know you voted for the mask mandate and I agree with that position. However, crowding speakers in rooms waiting their turn to speak will be placing them in danger and many will be reluctant to show up. Now I am again asking you to allow the people who want to address this monster project, a large enough venue so that we can exercise our rights to speak freely, but more importantly, to speak safely. Please re -consider your vote on the venue It will be very much appreciated by all of us who want to use this forum. Respectfully, Elizabeth Pircio 271 South Bay Drive Naples, FL 34108 epircio@verizon.net From: ei)ircio(fterizon.net To: TaylorPenny; LoCastroRick Subject: Fwd: One Naples Hearing Date: Saturday, December 19, 2020 9:32:41 PM Attachments: Docl.docxPICTURE OF MARCH 3 2020 MEETING.docx EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioners: I understand that you were the only two Commissioners who voted to change the venue of the One Naples Hearing to a location outside of the regular hearing location in view of the Covid-19 health risk and the numbers of people who will want to speak to their concerns. I am attaching a copy of an e-mail that I sent to Commissioner Solis this afternoon for your information. Attached to the e-mail is a photo of the people who attended the NIM on March 3, 2020. 1 believe the photo speaks for itself in that there were 400-500 people attending and many wanted their turn to speak. This will be happening at your meeting of March 1, 2021 but we expect more people will want to speak. I thank you for your consideration to us in attempting to change the venue to something larger where all of us will be able to attend and to listen to the others speak. We appreciate your concern for our health and well-being as we try to participate in this process of voicing our concerns and trying to encourage the developer to scale down his project to something that we can all live with. Respectfully, Elizabeth Pircio 271 South Bay Drive Naples, FL 34108 epircio@verizon.net -----Original Message ----- From: epircio@verizon.net To: andy.solis@colliercountyfl.gov<andy.solis@colliercountyfl.gov> Sent: Sat, Dec 19, 2020 4:29 pm Subject: One Naples Hearing Dear Commissioner Solis, I have been told that you do read all of your e-mails. I also read all of the a -mails that you send to me as well as your other constituents. You voted to conduct the One Naples Hearing scheduled for March in the County Officers because all of the technical equipment is located there. I have attached a picture of the One Naples Hearing that was held on March 3, 2020 in St. John's Church. This hearing took place before anyone realized the dangers of Covid-19. As you can see, there were approximately 400 to 500 people in attendance and some 29 of them spoke at the mike. When a speaker asked for those in favor of One Naples as submitted to raise their hands and stand, 8 people stood up, the rest were firmly opposed.. Some of the speakers were so passionate in their opposition that police officers had to escort them to their chairs. This is the forum that our Constitution allows the people to use when government is not abiding by the will of the people. Forcing your constituents to sit in their cars and wait for their opportunity to speak circumvents the process of Free Speech. It does not allow the Commissioners to hear what all the people are saying. Furthermore, it will stifle our opportunity to hear what others are saying. Commissioner, I would not like to think that by keeping the people segregated in their respective rooms or in their cars, you would be effectively silencing our ability to comment on our concerns about this project. I am urging you do the right thing here. There is plenty of time to find the correct venue to allow anyone who wants to speak to this massive project, the opportunity to speak. Florida had exactly 13,000 new Covid-19 cases yesterday according to Johns Hopkins. This is very disturbing to me and should be to you as well. I know you voted for the mask mandate and I agree with that position. However, crowding speakers in rooms waiting their turn to speak will be placing them in danger and many will be reluctant to show up. Now I am again asking you to allow the people who want to address this monster project, a large enough venue so that we can exercise our rights to speak freely, but more importantly, to speak safely. Please re -consider your vote on the venue It will be very much appreciated by all of us who want to use this forum. Respectfully, Elizabeth Pircio 271 South Bay Drive Naples, FL 34108 epircio@verizon.net From: ei)ircioCabverizon.net To: TavlorPenny; SaundersBurt; McDanielBill; SolisAndv; SaboJames Subject: Fwd: One Naples Information -One Date: Sunday, January 3, 2021 6:59:13 PM Attachments: Scan.odf COMMISSIONERS ONE.odf EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. January 3, 2021 Dear Commissioners: Thank you for the opportunity to forward information to you regarding the One Naples Submission. This submission has resulted in towers of paperwork and it has taken me some time to sift through it all and cull out the important information for you. Formerly, I was on the Planning Board of my town in Mass which was located 10 miles from Boston at the intersection of 3 major highways. Because the town was so well run, we even had our own electric company, a great school system, etc.; many developers tried to come in and maximize their buildings on scarce parcels of land. So I quickly became used to their efforts to build as big, as high, and as dense as they wanted to maximize their profits. Collier County is becoming similar to my former town, especially near the Gulf. Many want to live in Naples and real estate seemingly can sell itself. But Collier County has to use their discretion in what they allow to come in lest the overgrowth results in an unlivable crowded area of future blight. Collier County has a Master Plan which they call the Growth Management Plan. This Plan sets out all the zoning districts and what is allowed in each one. If a developer wants to build something that is not allowed in a particular zoning district, the County allows the developer to come before them and ask for a change in the Zoning. This is supposed to be an "exception" and not the normal course of events - for otherwise -why have a master plan at all? That is why a "super -majority vote" of the Commissioners is required to change a Zoning District and Amend the Growth Management Plan. There are certain guidelines that the developer must prove his project adheres to. His project must be compatible and consistent with the neighborhood. That means, the project must "fit' into the zoning that is currently in place. That is why you will not get a gas station next to a high rise tower, or an industrial building next to a residential subdivision. The surrounding neighbors who followed the Zoning Laws, cannot suffer because an owner wants to come into the neighborhood and build what he wants, regardless of the Zoning in place or what is already there. This would result in a developer being enriched at the expense of his neighbors, and that would be against the law. It would also be contrary to the Master Plan. This is the argument that is being made against Stock Development. They have bought parcels of land totaling less than 5 acres and want special treatment by the Commissioners to allow them to change the Zoning of these parcels in order to maximize their investment at the expense of the neighbors. The attached pictures illustrate their impact on the neighborhood. 1. Save Vanderbilt Beach (SVB) diagram of the two towers to scale showing the 35+foot parking garage set 15 feet in from their property line. This garage is 700 feet long and will encompass the whole corner. See the scale to the people and the autos. The walls are so tall, the palm trees will not hide it. 2. Scale of the buildings from the parking lot of Daruma Restaurant creating a huge shadow along with winds over the restaurant -again look at scale to people and autos I Again from SVB - even the mid rise buildings will dwarf Barefoot Pelican Condominium (where I own a condo). 4. Again from SVB- Because of the lack of setbacks, we at Barefoot Pelican will not be able to see up Southbay Dr. because their mid -rise will have 10 foot setbacks and we complied with Zoning and have a 28 foot setback. Commissioners, this is the first of the packets of information I will be sending you. I am available should you have any questions or comments as we go along in this process. I have been involved in this project since 2017 when it was first proposed. The developer has constantly discounted the concerns of the neighbors which has resulted in a large group of unhappy and angry residents who have become fairly knowledgeable about this. For this reason, I would urge you to again vote to reconsider and change the Hearing venue to one that will allow all the concerned residents the ability to speak, as well as more importantly, the ability to listen to what others, including yourselves, have to say. Respectfully submitted ELizabeth (Betty) Pircio 271 Southbay Drive Barefoot Pelican Condominium Naples, FL 781-690-0486 epircio@verizon.net From: ei)ircioCabverizon.net To: TavlorPenny; SaundersBurt; McDanielBill; SolisAndv; SaboJames Subject: Fwd: One Naples Information -One Date: Sunday, January 3, 2021 6:59:13 PM Attachments: Scan.odf COMMISSIONERS ONE.odf EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. January 3, 2021 Dear Commissioners: Thank you for the opportunity to forward information to you regarding the One Naples Submission. This submission has resulted in towers of paperwork and it has taken me some time to sift through it all and cull out the important information for you. Formerly, I was on the Planning Board of my town in Mass which was located 10 miles from Boston at the intersection of 3 major highways. Because the town was so well run, we even had our own electric company, a great school system, etc.; many developers tried to come in and maximize their buildings on scarce parcels of land. So I quickly became used to their efforts to build as big, as high, and as dense as they wanted to maximize their profits. Collier County is becoming similar to my former town, especially near the Gulf. Many want to live in Naples and real estate seemingly can sell itself. But Collier County has to use their discretion in what they allow to come in lest the overgrowth results in an unlivable crowded area of future blight. Collier County has a Master Plan which they call the Growth Management Plan. This Plan sets out all the zoning districts and what is allowed in each one. If a developer wants to build something that is not allowed in a particular zoning district, the County allows the developer to come before them and ask for a change in the Zoning. This is supposed to be an "exception" and not the normal course of events - for otherwise -why have a master plan at all? That is why a "super -majority vote" of the Commissioners is required to change a Zoning District and Amend the Growth Management Plan. There are certain guidelines that the developer must prove his project adheres to. His project must be compatible and consistent with the neighborhood. That means, the project must "fit' into the zoning that is currently in place. That is why you will not get a gas station next to a high rise tower, or an industrial building next to a residential subdivision. The surrounding neighbors who followed the Zoning Laws, cannot suffer because an owner wants to come into the neighborhood and build what he wants, regardless of the Zoning in place or what is already there. This would result in a developer being enriched at the expense of his neighbors, and that would be against the law. It would also be contrary to the Master Plan. This is the argument that is being made against Stock Development. They have bought parcels of land totaling less than 5 acres and want special treatment by the Commissioners to allow them to change the Zoning of these parcels in order to maximize their investment at the expense of the neighbors. The attached pictures illustrate their impact on the neighborhood. 1. Save Vanderbilt Beach (SVB) diagram of the two towers to scale showing the 35+foot parking garage set 15 feet in from their property line. This garage is 700 feet long and will encompass the whole corner. See the scale to the people and the autos. The walls are so tall, the palm trees will not hide it. 2. Scale of the buildings from the parking lot of Daruma Restaurant creating a huge shadow along with winds over the restaurant -again look at scale to people and autos I Again from SVB - even the mid rise buildings will dwarf Barefoot Pelican Condominium (where I own a condo). 4. Again from SVB- Because of the lack of setbacks, we at Barefoot Pelican will not be able to see up Southbay Dr. because their mid -rise will have 10 foot setbacks and we complied with Zoning and have a 28 foot setback. Commissioners, this is the first of the packets of information I will be sending you. I am available should you have any questions or comments as we go along in this process. I have been involved in this project since 2017 when it was first proposed. The developer has constantly discounted the concerns of the neighbors which has resulted in a large group of unhappy and angry residents who have become fairly knowledgeable about this. For this reason, I would urge you to again vote to reconsider and change the Hearing venue to one that will allow all the concerned residents the ability to speak, as well as more importantly, the ability to listen to what others, including yourselves, have to say. Respectfully submitted ELizabeth (Betty) Pircio 271 Southbay Drive Barefoot Pelican Condominium Naples, FL 781-690-0486 epircio@verizon.net From: Virginia Shanlev To: TavlorPennv Subject: Fwd: One Naples Project Date: Monday, February 8, 2021 9:22:56 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Ms. Taylor Please do NOT let the greed and avarice of another large corporation beat up on regular citizens who only are trying to maintain the current and future best interests of their neighborhood. One Naples is a David and Goliath battle for which the neighborhood will pay dearly into the next millennium should Stock Development persevere. You have the opportunity to stop this monstrosity. Please do the right thing and vote "NO"! !! Thank you for "listening". Virginia Shanley Pelican Bay resident From: ei)ircio(fterizon.net To: TaylorPenny; SolisAndy; SaundersBurt; McDanielBill Subject: Fwd: One Naples THREE Date: Monday, January 18, 2021 6:06:49 PM Attachments: Scan.pdf COMMISSIONERS THREE.pdf EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioners: This is another piece of information from the Planning Commission Hearing for One Naples This attachment is from the transcript of the Planning Commission meeting of October 15, 2020. 1 can send you the whole transcript if you would like. These 2 pages concern testimony from James Sabo, the Chief Planner and Chairman Fryer. I participated in many meetings with the Planning Staff over One Naples. James Sabo worked with the neighbors as well as others in the Planning Department to try to come up with a solution that would benefit the neighborhood as well as the developer, except the developer would not cooperate. James is stating that the development is too dense and does not meet the Zoning Code by asking for twice the density.He goes on to say that he would agree to a height of 125 feet for the towers if the developer would agree to 25 feet for setbacks. James would also allow just 15 feet for setbacks at the corner of Vanderbilt Beach Road and Gulf Shore Drive if the developer would put in some small commercial stores that would benefit the residents. He was talking about a deli, a small restaurant, retail shops and the like. He was not talking about a bar such as the Beach Box which has created problems. The step back architecture he refers to is like a wedding cake design with tiers that come gradually to a point, not the mass of concrete that they show in their towers. James wants the building masses to fit in with the neighborhood and not overwhelm everything. This dialogue was very important because it showed that the Planning Department was trying to work with the developer in finding a solution. Later James told me that he had sat down with Anita Jenkins, Thaddeus Cohen and other department heads to try to encourage this development to work with and be consistent and compatible with the neighborhood. This idea that he spoke about was the culmination of these discussions. These ideas would be something that Save Vanderbilt Beach would endorse as well. However, the attorney for Stock, Mr Yovanovich took exception to Chairman Fryer and asked him to remove himself from the Hearing which he did. This was done because the Chairman had prepared a diagram of the setbacks on Gulf Shore Drive and had passed them out to the others, thus, according to Mr. Yovanovich, making himself a witness. While this might have made Mr Yovanovich look good to his client, it did not endear him to anyone else. That this bully succeeded was distressful. Without this action, we may have come to a real solution to this problem. Again, thank you for the opportunity to present this information. Respectfully submitted, Elizabeth (Betty) Pircio Barefoot Pelican Condominium 271 Southbay Drive Naples, FL 781-690-0486 epircio@verizon.net -----Original Message ----- From: epircio@verizon.net To: epircio@verizon.net Sent: Wed, Dec 30, 2020 5:12 pm Subject: One Naples THREE epircio@verizon.net From: ei)ircioCabverizon.net To: TavlorPenny; McDanielBill; SaundersBurt; SolisAndv; LoCastroRick Subject: Fwd: Stock Deal with Barefoot Pelican Date: Friday, February 5, 2021 8:03:33 PM Attachments: Scan.pdfTHE DEAL WITH STOCK.pdf EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioners: Attached is the "deal" with Barefoot Pelican Condominium and Stock Development illustrating the "incentives" that Stock Dev. is willing to pay to Barefoot Pelican for their endorsement of One Naples. It distresses me to see that it appears that this is how a developer has to do business in Collier County in order to get what he wants. I ask you, if this development was so great for Collier County, would all this be necessary? Would Mr. Stock be willing to pay out this much money if he did not have to do it? Of course not. Why is this happening? Is this business as usual? I hope not! Commissioners, I hope you will do the right thing with One Naples. This kind of behavior should not be condoned. This taints the whole permitting process, the staff as well as the elected officials who allow this behavior to continue and be rewarded. Respectfully Elizabeth Pircio 271 Southbay Dr. Barefoot Pelican Condominium Naples, FL 34108 From: Try To: TavlorPennv Subject: Fwd: Stock Development One Naples Date: Saturday, January 2, 2021 5:17:55 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Sent from my Wad Begin forwarded message: From: Tracy <tracylogan50@aol.com> Date: January 2, 2021 at 5:16:43 PM EST To: AndySolis@colliercountyfl.gov Subject: Stock Development One Naples I am writing to vehemently express my displeasure of Stock Developments One Naples Project. As a resident of that area, I see daily that the area CANNOT support such a large development. I walk that road 5 times per week. On weekends and during season, traffic is frequently backed up to 41 on Vanderbilt Beach Road. And there are usually multiple cars just sitting in the center lane, waiting for a space to free up in the public parking garage. That should tell you there is not enough parking in that area without Stock development Please, do not approve this project. If you desire this type of development, kindly relocate your family to the concrete jungle of the east coast. This type of development is certainly not in line with our illusion of Naples on the Bay. Tracy Logan Sent from my Wad From: Try To: TavlorPennv Subject: Fwd: Stock Development One Naples Date: Saturday, January 2, 2021 5:17:55 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Sent from my Wad Begin forwarded message: From: Tracy <tracylogan50@aol.com> Date: January 2, 2021 at 5:16:43 PM EST To: AndySolis@colliercountyfl.gov Subject: Stock Development One Naples I am writing to vehemently express my displeasure of Stock Developments One Naples Project. As a resident of that area, I see daily that the area CANNOT support such a large development. I walk that road 5 times per week. On weekends and during season, traffic is frequently backed up to 41 on Vanderbilt Beach Road. And there are usually multiple cars just sitting in the center lane, waiting for a space to free up in the public parking garage. That should tell you there is not enough parking in that area without Stock development Please, do not approve this project. If you desire this type of development, kindly relocate your family to the concrete jungle of the east coast. This type of development is certainly not in line with our illusion of Naples on the Bay. Tracy Logan Sent from my Wad From: Paul bennett To: SolisAndv; TavlorPennv; LoCastroRick; McDanielBill; BurtSaunders(abcolliercountvfl.aov Subject: One Naples Project Date: Tuesday, February 16, 2021 12:25:50 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear County Commissioners, I implore you not to support the zoning variance for the One Naples project. We do not want Naples to become the next Miami. Naples is unique like it is and we do not want to see it change. It is a desirable place to live because of the current zoning. Please do not attempt to change that. Sincerely, Paul Bennett From: tarmalCabaol.com To: TavlorPennv Subject: Letter in opposition to Naples One Date: Tuesday, February 2, 2021 7:33:38 AM Attachments: Commissioners Letter February 2021.docx EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Please read the attached letter. Thank you. Todd Brodie From: Berkey, Kathleen To: LoCastroRick; SolisAndv, SaundersBurt; TayIorPenny; McDanielBill Cc: Tourangeau, Tara; Farmer, Shaiyan Subject: Letter of Support / One Naples (PL20190000696 and PL20190000697) Date: Thursday, February 11, 2021 5:25:48 PM Attachments: imaae366499.Dna image 144423.pnna_ imaae895678.Dna image 166515.pnng imaae904167.Dna image576059.pnng imaae398455.Dna image783656.pnng imaoe997689.Dna Letter of Support re One Naples - Barefoot Pelican.pdf EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Good evening, Attached please find a Letter of Support from Barefoot Pelican Condominium Association, Inc. for the proposed "One Naples" project scheduled for consideration at the March 1, 2021 Board of County Commissioners hearing. Thank you, Katie Berkey On behalf of Barefoot Pelican Condominium Association, Inc. Kathleen O. Berkey, AICP Shareholder and Certified Land Planner Board Certified Attorney, City, County, and Local Government Law ElecWr Becker & Poliakoff Six Mile Corporate Park 12140 Carissa Commerce Court Suite 200 Ft. Myers, FL 33966 r 239.628.4919 239.433.5933 j KBerkey@beckerlawyers.com www.beckerlawyers.com C 'Rib �i 01 Y. COUN I Y a LOCAL CXMPNMENT LAW Follow Becker on... 93(M rn a Al CP CERTMED Confidentiality Note: This message, together with any attachments, may contain privileged and confidential information. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any examination, distribution, or copying of this communication is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us by reply e-mail and permanently delete the original message, along with any attachments. Thank you. From: tarmalCabaol.com To: TavlorPennv Subject: Letter re: Naples One Date: Tuesday, February 2, 2021 7:52:05 AM Attachments: Commissioners Letter February 2021.docx EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Please read the attached letter. Thank you. Todd Brodie From: Kay Woolley To: Betty Pircio; TaylorPennv Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 11:54:21 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. As an owner at Barefoot Pelican I find the behavior of the Commission to be deplorable. This One Naples project should have never gotten this far. As an owner I find the Board of Barefoot Pelican equally reprehensible for trying to encourage owners to vote for this project. That is not their duty and they have overstepped their function. It is their function, as is yours, to present information and listen to people. Then adhere to the rules set up by the Commission in the past and VOTE THIS PROJECT DOWN. Kay Woolley From: nottubrat(abaol.com To: TaylorPenny Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 10:29:50 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I urge you to vote AGAINST the One Naples project. I have been a resident of Naples for over 35 years, and of Pelican Bay for over 23 years ... this project will have a huge negative impact on our quality of life in many areas. Do not be swayed by the promises and "tokens" offered by the developer. Follow the recommendations of your own planning dept. and wishes of your constituents and stay true to the historical guidelines of quality of life and low environmental impact for our beautiful Naples. Layne Tarbutton 8930 Bay Colony Dr #301 Naples FL 34108 From: Buzz Victor To: TavlorPennv Subject: March 1 Meeting Date: Monday, February 15, 2021 2:53:09 PM Attachments: First 900 Survey Results.pdf EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Hi, Commissioner, Thank you for your time on the phone late last week. I am working with our experts to determine how much time they feel they will need, and I will have that to you in a day or so. I have had several other thoughts since we last spoke. I continue to believe that trying to shuttle hundreds of people through the hearing room will be a nightmare, possibly taking many hours and being productive only in the sense that it covers the legal need for everyone who want to speak be heard. What if, instead of Mohamad coming to the mountain, we did it the other way. Suppose we could schedule one or more times throughout the hearing for people to come to the building, to remain in their cars or group, safely distanced from one another outside the building and then have the Commissioners leave the hearing room, come down to the exterior of the building and see the large number of opponents? Perhaps we could have a spokesperson for the entire group read a statement, etc. Is there a way that could be filmed/televised as part of the hearing's agenda and record? If there are other people who want to come before the Commissioners with their three minutes, we would encourage them to do so virtually, being both seen and heard by the Commissioners. Give that some thought, possibly converse with your IT folks and with the County Attorney to see if such an idea might be workable. I know that you are aware of the 24-minute presentation that we have made and are sharing publicly. I am not sure that you have actually watched it. I am wondering if it could be played for the Commissioners with 8 people in the hearing room giving up their three minutes? I believe that I sent you the survey we are conduction when we had 600 respondents. I am attaching the 900 respondent update. As of this very moment, we have had 1,077. I will be back with you soon. Let me know if you need further information from me. Thanks, Buzz President, Save Vanderbilt Beach Inc Buzz Victor 5650 Greenwood PI. BI. Suite 143 Greenwood Village, CO 80111 303-290-9100 303-290-1886 Fax 303-810-7374 Cell buzz(@ unitedstor-all.com Naples Office: 1415 Panther Lane Naples, FL 34109 239-591-6212 From: Ken Melkus To: TavlorPennv Subject: Meet Date: Tuesday, January 19, 2021 8:29:17 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor, My name is Ken Melkus and I am an active member of Save Vanderbilt Beach. I have been an outspoken critic of One Naples. I would like to arrange for a brief meeting to personally say hello and to summarize our plans over the next 45 days as we launch our "Final Push" to defeat Stock's ill conceived project. Could you please advise how I can connect with your scheduler? Looking forward to meeting and thanks for your commitment to public service with particular emphasis on development activities affecting Collier County. Ken Melkus Sent from my Wad From: Richard Yovanovich To: GrecoSherrv; Keith Gelder; bstock0stockdevelooment.com Cc: TavlorPennv Subject: Meeting w/Commissioner Taylor re: One Naples Start: Wednesday, February 24, 2021 12:00:00 PM End: Wednesday, February 24, 2021 12:30:00 PM Location: 3299 Tamiami Trail East #303 EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. From: Janice Wieland To: TavlorPennv Subject: my understanding that one of the condo associations most affected by the One Naples project has received a tentative proposal from Stock Development offering several monetary "incentives" to the condo association if they agree to drop their opposition ... Date: Thursday, December 31, 2020 5:29:09 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. my understanding that one of the condo associations most affected by the One Naples project has received a tentative proposal from Stock Development offering several monetary "incentives" to the condo association if they agree to drop their opposition to the One Naples project. They must also agree to speak publicly in favor of One Naples, and write a supporting letter to the Board of Collier County Commissioners on Stock's behalf. The package is very significant, estimated to be between $300,000 - $400,000. If this is true, it poses a significant conflict of interest because the motivation of such a condo association would not necessarily be what is in the best interest of the community, but rather what is in the best financial interest of the association. Therefore, I urge you to require that anyone testifying in writing or in person at the One Naples March Board of County Commissioners meeting disclose whether they, or the community association in which they live, have received any compensation from Stock Development, its affiliates or representatives and if so, the amount of such compensation. While such association has a right to voice its opinion on the project, such disclosure would allow you the full transparency to a significant motivating factor. Respectfully, Janice From: Janice Wieland To: TavlorPennv Subject: my understanding that one of the condo associations most affected by the One Naples project has received a tentative proposal from Stock Development offering several monetary "incentives" to the condo association if they agree to drop their opposition ... Date: Thursday, December 31, 2020 5:29:09 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. my understanding that one of the condo associations most affected by the One Naples project has received a tentative proposal from Stock Development offering several monetary "incentives" to the condo association if they agree to drop their opposition to the One Naples project. They must also agree to speak publicly in favor of One Naples, and write a supporting letter to the Board of Collier County Commissioners on Stock's behalf. The package is very significant, estimated to be between $300,000 - $400,000. If this is true, it poses a significant conflict of interest because the motivation of such a condo association would not necessarily be what is in the best interest of the community, but rather what is in the best financial interest of the association. Therefore, I urge you to require that anyone testifying in writing or in person at the One Naples March Board of County Commissioners meeting disclose whether they, or the community association in which they live, have received any compensation from Stock Development, its affiliates or representatives and if so, the amount of such compensation. While such association has a right to voice its opinion on the project, such disclosure would allow you the full transparency to a significant motivating factor. Respectfully, Janice From: Janice Wieland To: TavlorPennv Subject: Naples one Date: Monday, December 28, 2020 5:53:38 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. It is my understanding that one of the condo associations most affected by the One Naples project has received a tentative proposal from Stock Development offering several monetary "incentives" to the condo association if they agree to drop their opposition to the One Naples project. They must also agree to speak publicly in favor of One Naples, and write a supporting letter to the Board of Collier County Commissioners on Stock's behalf. The package is very significant, estimated to be between $300,000 - $400,000. If this is true, it poses a significant conflict of interest because the motivation of such a condo association would not necessarily be what is in the best interest of the community, but rather what is in the best financial interest of the association. Therefore, I urge you to require that anyone testifying in writing or in person at the One Naples March Board of County Commissioners meeting disclose whether they, or the community association in which they live, have received any compensation from Stock Development, its affiliates or representatives and if so, the amount of such compensation. While such association has a right to voice its opinion on the project, such disclosure would allow you the full transparency to a significant motivating factor. Respectfully, Janice From: Janice Wieland To: TavlorPennv Subject: Naples one Date: Monday, December 28, 2020 5:53:38 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. It is my understanding that one of the condo associations most affected by the One Naples project has received a tentative proposal from Stock Development offering several monetary "incentives" to the condo association if they agree to drop their opposition to the One Naples project. They must also agree to speak publicly in favor of One Naples, and write a supporting letter to the Board of Collier County Commissioners on Stock's behalf. The package is very significant, estimated to be between $300,000 - $400,000. If this is true, it poses a significant conflict of interest because the motivation of such a condo association would not necessarily be what is in the best interest of the community, but rather what is in the best financial interest of the association. Therefore, I urge you to require that anyone testifying in writing or in person at the One Naples March Board of County Commissioners meeting disclose whether they, or the community association in which they live, have received any compensation from Stock Development, its affiliates or representatives and if so, the amount of such compensation. While such association has a right to voice its opinion on the project, such disclosure would allow you the full transparency to a significant motivating factor. Respectfully, Janice From: Janice Wieland To: TavlorPennv Subject: Naples one Date: Monday, December 28, 2020 5:53:38 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. It is my understanding that one of the condo associations most affected by the One Naples project has received a tentative proposal from Stock Development offering several monetary "incentives" to the condo association if they agree to drop their opposition to the One Naples project. They must also agree to speak publicly in favor of One Naples, and write a supporting letter to the Board of Collier County Commissioners on Stock's behalf. The package is very significant, estimated to be between $300,000 - $400,000. If this is true, it poses a significant conflict of interest because the motivation of such a condo association would not necessarily be what is in the best interest of the community, but rather what is in the best financial interest of the association. Therefore, I urge you to require that anyone testifying in writing or in person at the One Naples March Board of County Commissioners meeting disclose whether they, or the community association in which they live, have received any compensation from Stock Development, its affiliates or representatives and if so, the amount of such compensation. While such association has a right to voice its opinion on the project, such disclosure would allow you the full transparency to a significant motivating factor. Respectfully, Janice From: Janice Wieland To: TavlorPennv Subject: Naples one Date: Monday, December 28, 2020 5:53:38 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. It is my understanding that one of the condo associations most affected by the One Naples project has received a tentative proposal from Stock Development offering several monetary "incentives" to the condo association if they agree to drop their opposition to the One Naples project. They must also agree to speak publicly in favor of One Naples, and write a supporting letter to the Board of Collier County Commissioners on Stock's behalf. The package is very significant, estimated to be between $300,000 - $400,000. If this is true, it poses a significant conflict of interest because the motivation of such a condo association would not necessarily be what is in the best interest of the community, but rather what is in the best financial interest of the association. Therefore, I urge you to require that anyone testifying in writing or in person at the One Naples March Board of County Commissioners meeting disclose whether they, or the community association in which they live, have received any compensation from Stock Development, its affiliates or representatives and if so, the amount of such compensation. While such association has a right to voice its opinion on the project, such disclosure would allow you the full transparency to a significant motivating factor. Respectfully, Janice From: Miguel E. Lopez To: TavlorPennv Subject: Naples Park Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 9:27:49 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: Miguel E. Lopez To: TavlorPennv Subject: Naples Park Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 9:27:49 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: GrecoSherry To: Sarah Spector; TavlorPennv; Schlake. Erin <ESchlakeCabralaw.com> Subject: One Naples - Regatta at Vanderbilt Commons Association Start: Wednesday, February 24, 2021 11:00:00 AM End: Wednesday, February 24, 2021 12:00:00 PM Location: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/83980359643?pwd=QTZmWG1jUmNLQ2ZKUFNDUWVtY2NLdz09 Attachments: RE Regatta at Vanderbilt Commons Association Inc.Meeting Reauest.msg RE Regatta at Vanderbilt Commons Association Inc.Meeting Request.msg RE Regatta at Vanderbilt Commons Association Inc.Meetina Request.msg RE Regatta at Vanderbilt Commons Association Inc.Meeting Request.msg Sherry Greco is inviting you to a scheduled Zoom meeting. Join Zoom Meeting https://us02web.zoom.us/j/83980359643?pwd=QTZmWGIjUniNLQ2ZKUFNDUW VtY2NLdz09 Meeting ID: 839 8035 9643 Passcode: 984411 One tap mobile +16468769923„83980359643#*984411# US (New York) +13017158592„83980359643#.... *984411# US (Washington D.C) Dial by your location +1 646 876 9923 US (New York) +1 301 715 8592 US (Washington D.C) +1 312 626 6799 US (Chicago) +1 346 248 7799 US (Houston) +1 408 638 0968 US (San Jose) +1 669 900 6833 US (San Jose) +1 253 215 8782 US (Tacoma) 833 548 0282 US Toll -free 877 853 5257 US Toll -free 888 475 4499 US Toll -free 833 548 0276 US Toll -free Meeting ID: 839 8035 9643 Passcode:984411 Find your local number: https://us02web.zoom.us/u/kdNNUHDyW8 <https://us02web.zoom.us/u/kdNNUHDyW8> Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: GrecoSherry To: Sarah Spector; TavlorPennv; Schlake. Erin <ESchlakeCabralaw.com> Subject: One Naples - Regatta at Vanderbilt Commons Association Start: Wednesday, February 24, 2021 11:00:00 AM End: Wednesday, February 24, 2021 12:00:00 PM Location: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/83980359643?pwd=QTZmWG1jUmNLQ2ZKUFNDUWVtY2NLdz09 Attachments: RE Regatta at Vanderbilt Commons Association Inc.Meeting Reauest.msg RE Regatta at Vanderbilt Commons Association Inc.Meeting Request.msg RE Regatta at Vanderbilt Commons Association Inc.Meetina Request.msg RE Regatta at Vanderbilt Commons Association Inc.Meeting Request.msg Sherry Greco is inviting you to a scheduled Zoom meeting. Join Zoom Meeting https://us02web.zoom.us/j/83980359643?pwd=QTZmWGIjUniNLQ2ZKUFNDUW VtY2NLdz09 Meeting ID: 839 8035 9643 Passcode: 984411 One tap mobile +16468769923„83980359643#*984411# US (New York) +13017158592„83980359643#.... *984411# US (Washington D.C) Dial by your location +1 646 876 9923 US (New York) +1 301 715 8592 US (Washington D.C) +1 312 626 6799 US (Chicago) +1 346 248 7799 US (Houston) +1 408 638 0968 US (San Jose) +1 669 900 6833 US (San Jose) +1 253 215 8782 US (Tacoma) 833 548 0282 US Toll -free 877 853 5257 US Toll -free 888 475 4499 US Toll -free 833 548 0276 US Toll -free Meeting ID: 839 8035 9643 Passcode:984411 Find your local number: https://us02web.zoom.us/u/kdNNUHDyW8 <https://us02web.zoom.us/u/kdNNUHDyW8> Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Schultz Prooerty Management To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Date: Monday, January 4, 2021 12:57:23 PM Attachments: Tavlor.pdf EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Please see attached. Thank you, Sue Schultz -Moriarty From: Nancy Contardi To: TavlorPennv Subject: ONE NAPLES Date: Wednesday, February 10, 2021 8:20:31 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. In this town, greedy developers always seem to win ! Stock is proposing this huge development on this tiny piece of land at a location that is already congested... please listen to the people on this one ... VOTE NO.!! Sent from my Whone From: maureen trerice To: TaylorPenny; McDanielBill; SaundersBurt Cc: Pelican Bay Subject: One Naples Date: Friday, January 15, 2021 5:20:34 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear commissioners, recently I got out of my car at the One Naples site and measured 25 feet from the curb where the proposed 3 storied wall would rise. I walked 5 feet back towards the street, figuring.that would be the landscaping area. I watched people with all their gear, strollers, wagons, skateboarders, bikes on their way back and forth to the beach, while thinking, this isn't a normal season and look at all the activity. 400 people an hour was the figured clocked for the planning commissioners report, on a busy day. Dropping an entire walled resort at the end of two, two lane roads is not beneficial to the larger beach community. No wonder residents need more room on March 1, to express the depth of their disapproval, at your meeting to vote on this project.They are worried about their own investment, not Stock Development's. This is the wrong area for this resort complex, as it is designed presently. Keep the zoning in place, until a better plan emerges. Most sincerely, Maureen Trerice 8171 Bay Colony Dr. Apt 2004 Naples, Fl. 34105 From: Don Armstrong To: TavlorPennv; SaundersBurt; McDanielBill; SolisAndv; LoCastroRick Subject: ONE NAPLES Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 10:26:37 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. I am very much in favor of continued development in Collier County. I am a FL resident owner at 6670 Beach Resort Drive #13, Naples FL 34114. ONE NAPLES could be a beautiful and valuable addition to the Naples area. I understand the proposed plan would violate several restrictions about height, setbacks and etc. It certainly requires careful consideration before moving forward. I trust the Commissioners to make a decision that is best for our growing community. Don Armstrong From: KENTON SICCHITANO To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples abomination Date: Thursday, January 7, 2021 8:20:14 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: First, thank you for the time and expertise you bring to Collier County. Much appreciated here. I am a fifteen year resident of Pelican Bay, the last three years in Bay Colony. I spend 7-8 months a year here. It is my home and the place I love. When I decided to make South Florida my home I strongly considered the east coast as well as Southwest Florida. Having lived for years in Manhattan, I was eager to go in a different direction than the concrete jungle that is Manhattan, and which I found on the east coast. I selected Naples specifically as the anti -congestion, charming alternative to what I left. Now I am afraid.... afraid that the character of Naples will change. The One Naples proposal is an egregious example of what will happen if you allow this development to take place. It will bring all manner of bad things to a heretofore quiet area. It will be a Manhattan-ization blight on Naples/Collier County, a blight that will drive attactive prospective residents elsewhere. Collier County would never recover from building this development. It doesn't have to be this way. I lived and worked in the Boston area even longer than I lived in Manhattan. The Boston Redevelopment Authority could have destroyed the character of Boston, especially with ill-conceived development of the Seaport District. Instead, the BRA took a thoughtful approach to the long-term vision of Boston and has spearheaded a magnificent, open development to a treasured area. You can do the same. Please, PLEASE do not allow this development, a development that would destroy the Naples I love. Thank you for listening. Sincerely, Kenton J. Sicchitano 8960 Bay Colony Drive Apt 804, Naples FL 34108 From: KENTON SICCHITANO To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples abomination Date: Thursday, January 7, 2021 8:20:14 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: First, thank you for the time and expertise you bring to Collier County. Much appreciated here. I am a fifteen year resident of Pelican Bay, the last three years in Bay Colony. I spend 7-8 months a year here. It is my home and the place I love. When I decided to make South Florida my home I strongly considered the east coast as well as Southwest Florida. Having lived for years in Manhattan, I was eager to go in a different direction than the concrete jungle that is Manhattan, and which I found on the east coast. I selected Naples specifically as the anti -congestion, charming alternative to what I left. Now I am afraid.... afraid that the character of Naples will change. The One Naples proposal is an egregious example of what will happen if you allow this development to take place. It will bring all manner of bad things to a heretofore quiet area. It will be a Manhattan-ization blight on Naples/Collier County, a blight that will drive attactive prospective residents elsewhere. Collier County would never recover from building this development. It doesn't have to be this way. I lived and worked in the Boston area even longer than I lived in Manhattan. The Boston Redevelopment Authority could have destroyed the character of Boston, especially with ill-conceived development of the Seaport District. Instead, the BRA took a thoughtful approach to the long-term vision of Boston and has spearheaded a magnificent, open development to a treasured area. You can do the same. Please, PLEASE do not allow this development, a development that would destroy the Naples I love. Thank you for listening. Sincerely, Kenton J. Sicchitano 8960 Bay Colony Drive Apt 804, Naples FL 34108 From: Nancy Schahctman To: SolisAndv; TavlorPennv; RickLoCastro(abcolliercountvfl.aov, McDanielBill; SaundersBurt Subject: One Naples Affects Date: Tuesday, February 16, 2021 11:58:22 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioners, We appreciate all of the hours and time you are spending and have spent on this issue. My husband and I were drawn to Naples originally because of the wonderful feel of the area. We have been here over 20 years and are very comfortable in Naples. However, we are extremely concerned about the affects of this Real Estate Project, One Naples, that is proposed. Please consider all of the concerns and then cast your ballot. I am sure that you will not allow this developer to buy your vote. Thank you for your consideration of this issue. Sincerely, Nancy and Steve Schachtman Pelican Bay Residents From: Bonnie Michaels To: TavlorPenny Subject: One Naples Development Date: Saturday, February 13, 2021 12:07:51 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am a resident of the Beachwalk Community and currently there is a safety issue turning left out to Vanderbilt Beach road. If One Naples is built, 172 new residents, their visitors and cars will increase the safety issue. It has been debated that having commercial on the 5.4 acre property would bring more traffic. Our traffic expert says no. Other issues: Traffic study: the consultant for Stock and the county did a traffic study which wasn't long range... it didn't include new towns being built in the eastern rural lands which will increase traffic substantially. It also didn't include traffic in and out from Beachwalk, Pelican Bay, the Ritz and Regatta. The study was done in January and May ... not in season. Compatibility: CCPC debated whether or not it was compatible. Stock quoted from a dictionary. This is insulting! We live in the neighborhood and know what is compatible. Zoning and GMP: It is not zoned for this tall and dense development. Keep the CODES! The set -backs are too small. The Regatta has 150 foot set back. Stock quotes 25. C-3 Commercial: Many residents in the area would prefer some type of commercial. This is our community and we get nothing from the current proposal except headaches, lack of safety, and more traffic. What about a combination of residential, a neighborhood restaurant, deli, boutique, green space or flower garden? This is a neighborhood not a resort for millionaires. Landscaping: It has been pointed out many times by Stock that landscaping will hide the concrete bemouth. It won't. It is still 2 towers of 16 stories on top of a garage on 5.4 acres. We are not against development but the community would like something on a human scale that includes something for us. Many options were presented at the CCPC meeting but were vetoed. Please listen to our ideas and reasons why the proposed Stock development is inappropriate for the small acreage and neighborhood. Regards, Bonnie Michaels Bonnieupside@aol.com 847-308-0919 From: Jack Lentz Subject: One Naples Development Date: Thursday, February 11, 2021 11:13:21 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. I am a current board member at Falling Waters Beach Resort, and I am asking you, as our representative, to not let the Big Money of Stock Development influence you and allow them to disregard the current zoning laws of Collier County, with their current plans for One Naples. Their design plan for this site looks very enticing, but it goes against our current zoning restricting's. Letting Stock Development get away with this will open a Pandora's Box for all the other Big Money Developers to ruin the look of our beautiful Collier County. They have already started to sway public opinion with their very expensive ads promoting the One Naples plan. I think we all know these developers are only concerned about making money. They have many very talented people on their payroll to develop these plans and entice us with their WOW factor, without any regard to the people who live in and visit our little corner of Paradise. I am quite sure, if you as our representative's will stand together and turn their plan down, they will have a secondary plan to submit that will follow our zoning guide lines. It may take them two or three times before they get it right, but once they know you can't be swayed by their fancy designs and opulent presentations, they will get it right. I ask that you all stand together and send Big Money a strong and loud message. If, as a county, this area is something that needs to be developed, then sooner or later the right plan and developer will come along. Stock Development is not the only game in this very prosperous area. Thank you so much, John Lentz 6670 Beach Resort Dr. #8 Naples, FI. From: Robert Feerick To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Growth Plan Amendment Date: Monday, December 21, 2020 10:28:27 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing to you with the request that you deny the One Naples Growth Plan Amendment for rezoning, which will be coming up for your review in early January. I am in agreement that some form of development should be done on the subject property. (I have been a full-time resident in Pelican Bay for over twenty years.) However, a project of this magnitude with significant deviations in architecture, landscape buffers, parking, sidewalks, setbacks, and right of ways is not in keeping with the rest of our North Naples community. Moreover, it poses great safety risks for pedestrians, bicyclists, cars, and emergency vehicles. As you undoubtedly know, Vanderbilt Beach Road can become heavily congested. While parking does exist in the public parking garage, the road also requires street parking for people going to the beach during the day and to watch the sunset. 172 residences with 2-16 story towers is simply incompatible with the neighborhood and will, I believe, depress property values. This site should be redeveloped but in a thoughtful manner to address citizen concerns and safety. I am not opposed to some form of reimagined One Naples project proceeding. However, it must be done with fewer stories in the buildings and the appropriate setbacks, number of units, etc. I urge you to vote "No" on One Naples as proposed. Thank you for your consideration in this matter. Best wishes, Robert W. Feerick Robert M. Feerick Chairman Horizon Partners, Ltd. 3838 Tamiami Trail N., Suite 408 Naples FL 34103 Milwaukee Office: 9099 West Dean Road Milwaukee WI 53224 Direct: 239.261.5989 Main: 239.261.0020 Fax: 239.261.0225 Skype: robert.m.feerick Email: rfeerickl@horizonpartnersltd.com My Lin �R From: Robert Feerick To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Growth Plan Amendment Date: Monday, December 21, 2020 10:28:27 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing to you with the request that you deny the One Naples Growth Plan Amendment for rezoning, which will be coming up for your review in early January. I am in agreement that some form of development should be done on the subject property. (I have been a full-time resident in Pelican Bay for over twenty years.) However, a project of this magnitude with significant deviations in architecture, landscape buffers, parking, sidewalks, setbacks, and right of ways is not in keeping with the rest of our North Naples community. Moreover, it poses great safety risks for pedestrians, bicyclists, cars, and emergency vehicles. As you undoubtedly know, Vanderbilt Beach Road can become heavily congested. While parking does exist in the public parking garage, the road also requires street parking for people going to the beach during the day and to watch the sunset. 172 residences with 2-16 story towers is simply incompatible with the neighborhood and will, I believe, depress property values. This site should be redeveloped but in a thoughtful manner to address citizen concerns and safety. I am not opposed to some form of reimagined One Naples project proceeding. However, it must be done with fewer stories in the buildings and the appropriate setbacks, number of units, etc. I urge you to vote "No" on One Naples as proposed. Thank you for your consideration in this matter. Best wishes, Robert W. Feerick Robert M. Feerick Chairman Horizon Partners, Ltd. 3838 Tamiami Trail N., Suite 408 Naples FL 34103 Milwaukee Office: 9099 West Dean Road Milwaukee WI 53224 Direct: 239.261.5989 Main: 239.261.0020 Fax: 239.261.0225 Skype: robert.m.feerick Email: rfeerickl@horizonpartnersltd.com My Lin �R From: Barry Fidelman To: SolisAndv; TavlorPennv; LoCastroRick; McDanielBill; burl.saunders(c colliercountv.aov Subject: One Naples March meetings!! Date: Sunday, February 14, 2021 8:24:51 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Please schedule these meetings in a location where everyone can be socially distanced in the same room (eg Artis Naples, St John's Episcopal Church, Veterans Park). We MUST not allow this project to move forward without allowing your constituents an in -person pubic forum for sharing serious deficiencies that will create irreversible damage to the neighborhood. Barry Fidelman 6897 Grenadier Blvd Naples F134108 Sent from my iPhone From: Nestor Popowych To: SolisAndv; TavlorPennv; McDanielBill; SaundersBurt; LoCastroRick Subject: One Naples Project March Board of Collier County Commissioners Meeting Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 12:43:17 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. TO: Collier County Commissioners: Mr. Andy Solis Ms. Penny Taylor Mr. William L. McDaniel, Jr. Mr. Burt L. Saunders Mr. Rick LoCastro It is our understanding that one of the condominium associations most affected by the One Naples project has received a tentative proposal from Stock Development offering several monetary "incentives" to the condo association if they agree to drop their opposition to the One Naples project. They must also agree to speak publicly in favor of the One Naples Project, and write a supporting letter to the Board of Collier County Commissioners on Stock's behalf?? The package is very significant, estimated to be between $300,000 - $400,000. We hope that this is not factual but if it is true, it poses a significant conflict of interest because the motivation of such a condo association would not necessarily be what is in the best interest of the community, but rather what is in the best financial interest of the association. Therefore, we urge you to require that anyone testifying in writing or in person at the One Naples March Board of County Commissioners meeting disclose whether they, or the community association in which they live, have received any compensation from Stock Development, its affiliates or representatives and if so, the amount of such compensation. While such association has a right to voice its opinion on the project, such disclosure would allow you full transparency to a significant motivating factor. Nestor and Olya Popowych 10851 Gulf Shore Drive, Unit 1202 Naples, FL. 34108 Nestor Popowych, A.I.A. Architect Nestor. Popowych (cDamail. com 312-953-6777 From: Rooers E-mail To: SolisAndv; TavlorPennv; McDanielBill; SaundersBurt; LoCastroRick Cc: Vanderbilt Gulfside.Wayne Dammert Subject: One Naples Project March Board of Collier County Commissioners Meeting Date: Tuesday, December 29, 2020 11:35:24 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Collier County Commissioners: Mr. Andy Solis, Esq. Ms. Penny Taylor Mr. William L. McDaniel, Jr. Mr. Burt L. Saunders Mr. Rick LoCastro It is my understanding that one of the condo associations most affected by the One Naples project has received a tentative proposal from Stock Development offering several monetary "incentives" to the condo association if they agree to drop their opposition to the One Naples project. They must also agree to speak publicly in favor of One Naples, and write a supporting letter to the Board of Collier County Commissioners on Stock's behalf. The package is very significant, estimated to be between $300,000 - $400,000. If this is true, it poses a significant conflict of interest because the motivation of such a condo association would not necessarily be what is in the best interest of the community, but rather what is in the best financial interest of the association. Therefore, I urge you to require that anyone testifying in writing or in person at the One Naples March Board of County Commissioners meeting disclose whether they, or the community association in which they live, have received any compensation from Stock Development, its affiliates or representatives and if so, the amount of such compensation. While such association has a right to voice its opinion on the project, such disclosure would allow you the full transparency to a significant motivating factor. Respectfully, Roger Thomas and Georgeanna Thomas 10851 Gulf Shore Drive Naples, Florida 34108 rogerthomasl@easytelmail.com From: Michael Roe To: SolisAndv; TavlorPennv; McDanielBill; SaundersBurt; LoCastroRick Subject: One Naples Project March Board of Collier County Commissioners Meeting Date: Monday, January 4, 2021 7:47:01 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Collier County Commissioners: Mr. Andy Solis, Esq. Ms. Penny Taylor Mr. William L. McDaniel, Jr. Mr. Burt L. Saunders Mr. Rick LoCastro It is my understanding that one of the condo associations most affected by the One Naples project has received a tentative proposal from Stock Development offering several monetary "incentives" to the condo association if they agree to drop their opposition to the One Naples project. They must also agree to speak publicly in favor of One Naples, and write a supporting letter to the Board of Collier County Commissioners on Stock's behalf. The package is very significant, estimated to be between $300,000 - $400,000. If this is true, it poses a significant conflict of interest because the motivation of such a condo association would not necessarily be what is in the best interest of the community, but rather what is in the best financial interest of the association. Therefore, I urge you to require that anyone testifying in writing or in person at the One Naples March Board of County Commissioners meeting disclose whether they, or the community association in which they live, have received any compensation from Stock Development, its affiliates or representatives and if so, the amount of such compensation. While such association has a right to voice its opinion on the project, such disclosure would allow you the full transparency to a significant motivating factor for their testimony. Respectfully, Michael Roe 10851 Gulf Shore Dr #1003 Naples, FL 34105 From: Nestor Popowych To: SolisAndv; TavlorPennv; McDanielBill; SaundersBurt; LoCastroRick Subject: One Naples Project March Board of Collier County Commissioners Meeting Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 12:43:17 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. TO: Collier County Commissioners: Mr. Andy Solis Ms. Penny Taylor Mr. William L. McDaniel, Jr. Mr. Burt L. Saunders Mr. Rick LoCastro It is our understanding that one of the condominium associations most affected by the One Naples project has received a tentative proposal from Stock Development offering several monetary "incentives" to the condo association if they agree to drop their opposition to the One Naples project. They must also agree to speak publicly in favor of the One Naples Project, and write a supporting letter to the Board of Collier County Commissioners on Stock's behalf?? The package is very significant, estimated to be between $300,000 - $400,000. We hope that this is not factual but if it is true, it poses a significant conflict of interest because the motivation of such a condo association would not necessarily be what is in the best interest of the community, but rather what is in the best financial interest of the association. Therefore, we urge you to require that anyone testifying in writing or in person at the One Naples March Board of County Commissioners meeting disclose whether they, or the community association in which they live, have received any compensation from Stock Development, its affiliates or representatives and if so, the amount of such compensation. While such association has a right to voice its opinion on the project, such disclosure would allow you full transparency to a significant motivating factor. Nestor and Olya Popowych 10851 Gulf Shore Drive, Unit 1202 Naples, FL. 34108 Nestor Popowych, A.I.A. Architect Nestor. Popowych (cDamail. com 312-953-6777 From: Rooers E-mail To: SolisAndv; TavlorPennv; McDanielBill; SaundersBurt; LoCastroRick Cc: Vanderbilt Gulfside.Wayne Dammert Subject: One Naples Project March Board of Collier County Commissioners Meeting Date: Tuesday, December 29, 2020 11:35:24 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Collier County Commissioners: Mr. Andy Solis, Esq. Ms. Penny Taylor Mr. William L. McDaniel, Jr. Mr. Burt L. Saunders Mr. Rick LoCastro It is my understanding that one of the condo associations most affected by the One Naples project has received a tentative proposal from Stock Development offering several monetary "incentives" to the condo association if they agree to drop their opposition to the One Naples project. They must also agree to speak publicly in favor of One Naples, and write a supporting letter to the Board of Collier County Commissioners on Stock's behalf. The package is very significant, estimated to be between $300,000 - $400,000. If this is true, it poses a significant conflict of interest because the motivation of such a condo association would not necessarily be what is in the best interest of the community, but rather what is in the best financial interest of the association. Therefore, I urge you to require that anyone testifying in writing or in person at the One Naples March Board of County Commissioners meeting disclose whether they, or the community association in which they live, have received any compensation from Stock Development, its affiliates or representatives and if so, the amount of such compensation. While such association has a right to voice its opinion on the project, such disclosure would allow you the full transparency to a significant motivating factor. Respectfully, Roger Thomas and Georgeanna Thomas 10851 Gulf Shore Drive Naples, Florida 34108 rogerthomasl@easytelmail.com From: Michael Roe To: SolisAndv; TavlorPennv; McDanielBill; SaundersBurt; LoCastroRick Subject: One Naples Project March Board of Collier County Commissioners Meeting Date: Monday, January 4, 2021 7:47:01 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Collier County Commissioners: Mr. Andy Solis, Esq. Ms. Penny Taylor Mr. William L. McDaniel, Jr. Mr. Burt L. Saunders Mr. Rick LoCastro It is my understanding that one of the condo associations most affected by the One Naples project has received a tentative proposal from Stock Development offering several monetary "incentives" to the condo association if they agree to drop their opposition to the One Naples project. They must also agree to speak publicly in favor of One Naples, and write a supporting letter to the Board of Collier County Commissioners on Stock's behalf. The package is very significant, estimated to be between $300,000 - $400,000. If this is true, it poses a significant conflict of interest because the motivation of such a condo association would not necessarily be what is in the best interest of the community, but rather what is in the best financial interest of the association. Therefore, I urge you to require that anyone testifying in writing or in person at the One Naples March Board of County Commissioners meeting disclose whether they, or the community association in which they live, have received any compensation from Stock Development, its affiliates or representatives and if so, the amount of such compensation. While such association has a right to voice its opinion on the project, such disclosure would allow you the full transparency to a significant motivating factor for their testimony. Respectfully, Michael Roe 10851 Gulf Shore Dr #1003 Naples, FL 34105 From: jinn career To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Project Venue Date: Friday, February 12, 2021 5:14:50 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. > Please strongly consider holding the March 1-2 meetings at a venue which will allow all interested to attend in a democratic manner. > Thank you. > > Dr Jim Greer > 6001 Pelican Bay Blvd > Naples FL 34108 From: John O"brien To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Project Date: Sunday, February 14, 2021 9:09:00 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: Below is the blanket email for our cause. I whole heartily agree with all points below. YOU CANNOT go against what the community is telling you. WE DON'T WANT THIS PROJECT! It's a money grab at the expense of the community. VOTE NO! STICK TO THE CODES IN PLACE! NO EXCEPTIONS! DO YOUR JOB AND REPRESENT US! On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. From: Bill Hawthorne To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Proposed development Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 7:21:01 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear CommissionerTaylor, The area on which One Naples is proposed is working well for residents and beach users as is. These tax paying users are respectful of parking. There is not currently any traffic issue on Vanderbilt Beach Road. The One Naples development will have a serious negative impact on many Naples residents. Surely you have considered this and the significant changes One Naples will cause. Yes, growth and development of cities does occur. What development and impact of One Naples portends is ruinous and clearly predictable. Please consider the dramatic change to traffic both pedestrian and vehicular. Beach use and traffic are working well currently. Tax paying users of the involved roads and beaches provide wonderful happiness, appreciated beach activities and relaxation. Please consider the impact of One Naples on our citizens who enjoy what is already wisely provided and used. Please also consider the fact that this impact would be on many long tax paying Naples citizens and visitors. Thank you for your consideration. William A. Hawthorne 706 Willowwood Lane Naples, Florida 34108 (239) 591-2691 From: Schultz Prooerty Management To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Date: Monday, January 4, 2021 12:57:23 PM Attachments: Tavlor.pdf EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Please see attached. Thank you, Sue Schultz -Moriarty From: maureen trerice To: TavlorPennv; SaundersBurt; McDanielBill; LoCastroRick Cc: Pelican Bav Subject: One Naples Date: Saturday, February 6, 2021 2:00:34 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. What was not locked down during the 3 days of the Planning commission's discussion about the One Naples Development Project, were the easements between buildings and roads and the relationship to the current condos on Vanderbilt Beach Dr and Gulf Shore North. How far from the road were their setbacks? Not 15 to 25 feet, I'm afraid. If One Naples becomes a special case, why couldn't we begin to see a rash of 4,6 and 8 story condos wanting to do the same thing? Tear down and Go up and out, to the new road easement limit? Why not? One Naples did it? A can of worms. Vote to turn down One Naples and re -think keeping it commercial. After all with all the high tech that seems to be moving to Miami now, This site might be worth looking into by a more family oriented company. Maureenpenn From: Thelma Irene Giamoaoa To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Date: Monday, February 8, 2021 9:56:11 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am a florida resident and reside in Beachwalk Gardens only a block from the proposed One Naples project. Below is the email I just sent to Commissioner Solis but thought you too should see it. Thank you in advance for reading it and your thoughtful consideration. Dear Commissioner Solis, There is an old adage not to let someone else make their problem your problem. And it appears that may be what is happening here. You and your fellow commissioners do not have a problem here; you have an opportunity. An opportunity to serve your constituents, enhance your district, and leave a very positive legacy of contribution. Is the current One Naples proposal the best possible solution to this opportunity? The second observation is that if this project moves forward in a form close to the current proposal, it will be the gift that just keeps giving (and not in a positive way). The law of unintended consequences can be brutal and is almost certain to rear its ugly head when so little of the bigger, long term picture is visible. So like the overwhelming majority of my neighbors, I strongly encourage you to vote "NO" to the current proposal. There's a better solution. Let's find it. Sincerely, Thelma Irene Giampapa 631 Beachwalk Circle F202 Naples, FL 34108 From: Sheldon Gofbero To: TavlorPennv; SaundersBurt; McDanielBill; LoCastroRick Subject: One Naples Date: Monday, February 8, 2021 5:10:26 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Hello Commissioners et at As a Naples resident for the last fifteen years, I have watched the rapid development of our community. Naples is, as you know, a gem of the southwestern Florida landscape. I am fearful of the overdevelopment in Naples. People, traffic, overcrowding, resource limitations of fresh water, and general lifestyle in Naples. I am writing to urge you to reject In hand, the proposed "One Naples" project. It violates current zoning laws and will open the door to additional high-rise complexes on water's edge. You, as one of our Commissioners, have the responsibility to protect our communities from over zealous developers who by greed alone, want to impact our lifestyles. Towering buildings built on our beaches is not in the interest of the citizens of Naples. Thank you, Sheldon Gofberg 133 Big Springs Dr. Naples, Florida 34113 Sent from my iPad From: Barbara Rosen-Goldenziel To: SolisAndy; TaylorPennv; LoCastroRick; McDanielBill; SaundersBurt Subject: One Naples Date: Monday, February 8, 2021 8:50:34 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Please oppose the Stock development project. We believe this proposed project is an insidious monstrosity that violates current zoning codes, covenants and rules, making it neither compatible nor consistent with the existing neighborhood. Your immediate action to stop this project is requested. These developers have shown themselves to be reprehensible. Barbara and Gene Goldenziel 34108 From: Arthur C Mueller To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 5:42:43 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Comm. Taylor, The more I read about the the proposed One Naples development, the more I find it impossible that anyone, including Stock, would think this is good for our area. Profitable for Stock, yes, but good for our area? No. While we have owned property here for 8 years, we became residents of Florida yesterday. We do not need unrelenting, unmitigated growth. I urge you to vote with your constituents, and not with developers who refuse to follow the rules. Art and Ellen Mueller Naples Sent from my iPad From: Linda Chirieleison To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 7:48:14 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. Linda & Alfred Chirieleison From: Martin Baecker To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 8:54:14 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. This project is far to large and should be greatly reduced Sent from Mail for Windows 10 From: Sheila Varnum To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 8:56:13 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner: Please do not let Stock be rewarded for this egregious behavior of resorting to bribery to gain acceptance for this project. The reason they do not have widespread acceptance is that it is too big, and does not fit with surroundings. It will be a massively big project, in too small an area, and completely overwhelm the whole area with traffic, cars, and buildings that are terribly out of scale. Please hold them accountable to abide by the rules now in place. Thank you, Sheila Varnum Pelican Bay resident From: Bets Hill To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 11:00:15 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Writing to oppose this possible future construction by stock development. We don't want collier county to become a Miami. It will ruin the beauty and class of our Naples. Elizabeth Hill Sent from my iPhone From: Roger To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 11:18:53 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner, We strongly oppose One Naples. We live nearby at The Pointe in Pelican Bay. Please vote against it. Respectfully, Roger Mann & Tessa Tilden -Smith From: Don and Suzanne Scheu To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 3:11:07 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Board Member, As a long time owner of a home within Pelican Bay, I am opposed to One Naples and what it will do to the western end of the Vanderbilt Beach Road area. As you well know, VBR narrows to two lanes west of Route 41 and is congested "in season" with vehicles and pedestrians going to the beach. One Naples will result in even MORE congestion in the area. Additionally, with the building of five new high-rise condos at Kalea Bay with approximately 650 units, even more vehicles will use VBR as well and Pelican Bay Blvd. to avoid Route 41. There is already an increase in both vehicle and bicycle traffic on PBB. The Collier County Sheriffs Dept. recently completed a one -month survey of the number of vehicles using PBB. Over 94,000 vehicles in ONE MONTH!! One Naples and Kalea Bay will add even more! VOTE NO for One Naples and over development in North Naples!! Sincerely, Don Scheu From: John Loaan To: SaundersBurt; McDanielBill; SolisAndv; LoCastrolkick; TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 3:14:24 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. While we generally support economic development, the One Naples proposal represents a dangerous departure from the current vision for Collier County coastal development, and would erode what makes our area a desirable alternative to Miami -Dade. Leadership requires a focus on long term impact, and an appreciation for precedent. Please hold the line by rejecting One Naples. Thank you! John & Gerrie Logan 7944 Tiger Lily Drive Naples, FL 34113 Sent from my iPad From: richroni aallaaher To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Date: Thursday, February 11, 2021 8:37:11 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. I am contacting you today to voice my opposition to the One Naples Living Project as presently proposed by Stock Development and urge you consider the following question and request: Question Where else in all of SWFL is there a building with a height of 208'* rising up from a 15' setback* for two lengths of 195' each* immediately adjacent to a public sidewalk along which 400 pedestrians per hour* walk to the beach (in peak season)? *Data cited by Stock Development in their own testimony at CCPC Public Hearing on 10/1. Request Please don't fall into the same trap as did Commissioner Joseph Schmitt with the Collier County Planning Board who incredulously stated just before voting that the public failed to comprehend the complexities of the One Naples Project and he knew what was best for us. implore you to listen to your constituents. Thank you for your consideration. Richard M. Gallagher From: Arnold Saslayskv To: SolisAndy; McDanielBill; SaundersBurt; Donna Fiala; TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Date: Saturday, February 13, 2021 11:09:45 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioners: I have viewed the website and video presentation created by Save Vanderbilt Beach. I am in total agreement with the arguments they put forth and encourage you all to put an end to the inappropriate overdevelopment going on in Collier County. One Naples current design is a prime example of this. The image below shows just how incompatible this design is with the Vanderbilt Beach neighborhood. Remember, this is outside of Pelican Bay, NOT a part of it. And that huge wall running alongside Vanderbilt Beach Rd and Gulfshore Dr. is absolutely unacceptable, creating a canyon -like effect for passersby. The Stock Development's One Naples high-rise project fundamentally disregards the Collier County Growth Management Plan (GMP) and Land Development Code which residents and neighborhoods rely on to protect their quality of life and home investment. For this reason, ... the Collier County Board of Commissioners must deny the proposed GMP amendment. The community fully understands that in doing so, the property will retain its current C-3 zoning, which will provide much needed walkable and bikeable neighborhood services. I implore all of you to vote against variances being requested that would allow this design to come to fruition. Your constituents will thank you when you are up for reelection! Thank you, Arnold Saslaysky, The Pinnacle at The Strand From: 0"Neill, Bettyann To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Date: Sunday, February 14, 2021 10:06:04 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Ms Taylor, I am writing as a concerned citizen regarding the proposed One Naples project on Vanderbilt Beach Rd. I have owned property in Pelican Bay since 2004 and have watched how growth in and around our community has been reasonably handled. The One Naples project however is a stark departure from anything I have ever seen proposed and is a threat to our community - it's quality of life, safety and the beauty that attracted me (and many thousands of visitors each year). If I wanted to live in Miami with high rises packed on top of each other and traffic that never ends I would have moved there. This project is too large and will create not only an eye sore but dangerous traffic flow and congestion. Even more foreboding, it sets a standard that will erode the essence of Naples. I urge you to vote no. Thank you for the countless hours of dedication you give to our community and for acting in its best interest. Sincerely, Bettyann O'Neill 8960 Bay Colony Dr Apt 804 Naples, FL 34108 Sent from my Wad From: Sal Dias To: TaylorPenny Subject: One Naples Date: Monday, February 15, 2021 8:56:32 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor, I am writing to you for the sole purpose of going on record to oppose One Naples. I am an owner at the St. Simone Condominium in Pelican Bay and see this proposed project as compromising the quality of life in this immediate area should it be built. I would respectfully ask that you not support this project. Sincerely, Sal J Dias From: Elaine Olson To: SolisAndy; TaylorPenny; McDanielBill; SaundersBurt Subject: One Naples Date: Monday, February 15, 2021 9:39:01 AM Attachments: letter to commissioners.raaes EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioners, I wish I were younger. I'd be out on the street in front of Mr. Stock's office with protesting signs. I am so upset that he is more interested in personal gains than he is with protecting the environment and being respectful to people who have followed rules and earned the right to keep their homes as they are. He is making superfluous superficial temporary offers trying to squash the rights of fellow human beings. We NEED our commissioners to protect us all. I am in my eighties and quite possibly will not be around to see how this works out. I am concerned about the children, grandchildren, and great-grandchildren who will be affected by Mr. Stock's greediness. What you decide will affect generations of people. Please think ahead for future residents. Please fight to keep Mr. Stock from building his project. It would be good for everyone to stop him. I answered your survey and had some trouble with it. I hope I answered your questions in a way that lets you know how important this issue is. I feel fairly sure that many others who tried to answer the questions to express feelings such as mine found the questions confusing. I have written before and am attaching that letter to express more fully my thoughts. Thank you, Elaine Olson 7718 Pebble Creek Circle Apt. 304 Naples, FL 34108 From: bestcutter2CcDaol.conn To: TaylorPenny Subject: One Naples Date: Monday, February 15, 2021 9:45:22 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Ms. Taylor, This is Ronald and Barbara Baughman. We live in L'Ambiance, Naples Florida, just down Vanderbilt Beach Road from the proposed One Naples project. We have owned property in L'Ambiance since 1995. This portion of Florida is precious. We appreciate that there will always be changes. Any changes need to enhance our area. They should improve the quality of life in the neighborhood. We are STRONGLY OPPOSED to the One Naples project. This project will harm all the surrounding neighborhoods and especially ours, just down the street. The main benefit would be to the developers. When the time comes, you must vote AGAINST this project. My wife and I are watching closely and will be taking notes about who does the right thing for us and our neighbors and who supports the developer. We hope and pray that you will be our advocate and NOT support this terrible project. PLEASE vote AGAINST the One Naples development! Sincerely, Ronald and Barbara Baughman From: Donna D"Adamo To: SolisAndy; TaylorPenny; LoCastroRick; McDanielBill; burl.sanders(acolliercountvfl.gov Subject: One Naples Date: Tuesday, February 16, 2021 8:53:13 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioners: I have been a resident of Collier County in Pelican Bay since 1986. I am writing to kindly request you do not let One Naples go ahead. This area already has enough congestion. Since there is no way Vanderbilt Beach Road can be widened this development will cause more traffic problems then residents are already experiencing. Most days the travel west between 41 and the beach is a nightmare. One lane going west, usually backed up to 41 ! Please take the time now to visit this area. I know that most if not all of you have lived in Collier for years. If for some reason you have not traveled to this area during "season", please do so before you vote. Thank you. Donna D'Adamo 239 821-4393 From: Chris Pisani To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Date: Tuesday, February 16, 2021 9:25:52 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Ms Taylor, Please put a stop to this pending development and the absurd overreach. Thank you for your time. Respectfully, Chris Pisani ( resident for 45 years ) Chris Pisani 239-595-2051 ChrisPisani1110na gmail.com From: Cathy Wheaton To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Date: Tuesday, February 16, 2021 9:34:55 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Please vote NO for development of One Naples. Thank you, Cathy Wheaton Owner in Pelican Bay From: Maureen Corcoran To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Date: Tuesday, February 16, 2021 9:47:00 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Penny, This project as currently proposed is way too dense for the area. Pls oppose as currently configured and leave some breathing room for everyone. Do not let this lovely spot turn into Miami Beach. Sincerely, Maureen and Tom Corcoran 6573 Marissa Loop Naples 34108 Sent from my iPad From: HAGGERTY To: TaylorPenny Subject: One Naples Date: Tuesday, February 16, 2021 9:53:59 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Commissioner Taylor, As a resident of Beachmoor, I have a bird's eye view of the traffic along Gulf Shore Drive and Vanderbilt Beach Road. When the weather is good (which is most of the time) traffic backs up in all directions. The garage entrance quickly becomes a 20 car line with several cars usually impeding the passing lane. One Naples will, without a doubt, make this situation much worse. Fire rescue, police and ambulance access time will increase as a public safety issue. I don't know when Stock Development did their traffic study but must assume it was on a rainy 60 degree day midweek. I understand their right to develop the property but they MUST be held to existing codes. I appreciate your time and efforts as a commissioner and hopeful for a no vote from you. Sincerely, Steve Haggerty From: Klatzkowleff To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Date: Tuesday, February 16, 2021 9:55:52 AM Attachments: Procedural Memo One Naples Final 2-4-21.pdf As discussed. Jeffrey A. Klatzkow Collier County Attorney (239) 252-2614 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Wolman, Martin To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples Date: Tuesday, February 16, 2021 10:05:21 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Please vote against this abomination. One of your constituents. Martin Wolman From: Carolyn Ferrari To: TavlorPennv Subject: One Naples. Date: Tuesday, February 16, 2021 9:07:05 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Please deny the project as is and allow a lower less congested plan. To much for the area and the neighbors. Carolyn jasiul ferrari. Barefoot pelican N Sent from my Whone From: Don Armstrong To: TavlorPennv; SaundersBurt; McDanielBill; SolisAndv; LoCastroRick Subject: ONE NAPLES Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 10:26:37 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. I am very much in favor of continued development in Collier County. I am a FL resident owner at 6670 Beach Resort Drive #13, Naples FL 34114. ONE NAPLES could be a beautiful and valuable addition to the Naples area. I understand the proposed plan would violate several restrictions about height, setbacks and etc. It certainly requires careful consideration before moving forward. I trust the Commissioners to make a decision that is best for our growing community. Don Armstrong From: craigamatthews To: AndvSolis(cbcolliercountvfl.aov, TavlorPennv; RickLoCastro(c colliercountvfl.aov; McDanielBill; BurtSaunders(c colliercountyfl.aov Subject: Opposition to One Naples Date: Monday, January 11, 2021 3:33:31 PM Attachments: One Naples.docx EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Please see my attached email opposing the One Naples Project. Thank you. From: craigamatthews To: AndvSolis(cbcolliercountvfl.aov, TavlorPennv; RickLoCastro(c colliercountvfl.aov; McDanielBill; BurtSaunders(c colliercountyfl.aov Subject: Opposition to One Naples Date: Monday, January 11, 2021 3:33:31 PM Attachments: One Naples.docx EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Please see my attached email opposing the One Naples Project. Thank you. From: Kitty C Lynch To: TavlorPennv Subject: Over population Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 11:09:19 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. The area near where where I live was a strawberry field. Now it is a large shopping center surrounded by acres and acres of condos. Traffic is horrendous. Now I hear that you will be considering high-rise buildings such as One Naples. I have no problem with high-rise buildings, but cannot conceive of anyone permitting such construction in this area. Wildlife is already being displaced. How can you possibly consider making the Naples more like Miami? KItty Lynch 6600 Beach Resort Drive, 15 Naples, FL 34114 Sent from my iPad From: BillODDenheirrer To: McDanielBill; Rick LoCastro; TaylorPenny Subject: OVER -DEVELOPMENT in Collier County Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 8:52:13 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. My vote is NO! Regards, Bill Oppenheimer To: Collier County COA's From: www.Savevanderbiltbeach.com Please join us —WE NEED YOUR HELP! We are writing to share some information. Stock Development is proposing a huge high-rise project at the intersection of Vanderbilt Beach Road and Gulf Shore Drive called One Naples One Naples will double the intensity in this area which is in the Coastal High Hazard Zone and will pave the way for permission to double the allowable building height, reduce the setbacks by 70% and reduce the open space by 50%. Their two towers will be 186 feet tall and will be situated atop a 35- foot-tall podium that will be set a mere 15 feet from the sidewalk and will be 700 linear feet long. This development fundamentally disregards the current Zoning which should limit the intensity of this project and will begin the process of a "Miamification" of Vanderbilt Beach. This development is a radical departure from the type of development allowed in Collier County and its approval will set a dangerous precedent for the County. Developers will use this as a "foot in the door" to buy small parcels of land and erect high-rise buildings. We all have a voice in how we want to see the future of Collier County. It's easy to allow the developers to build higher and higher and closer and closer to the street, resulting Miami/Dade. We would need wider streets to accommodate the increased traffic, longer waits at our restaurants, less availability at the beaches, more gridlock at the intersections, etc. All of Collier County will be impacted if the Commissioners grant permission for this development and we are appealing to all of our neighbors to contact your Commissioners and write to oppose this project specifically, but, more generally, the over- development of Collier County. One Naples needs the votes of 4 of the 5 Commissioners to be allowed to build. I know you're not directly impacted by One Naples, but the Commissioners often vote for the developers over the wishes of the community. The City of Naples recently ousted their Mayor and a couple of Commissioners for not paying attention to the community. Our fate lies in the hands of our 5 County Commissioners some of which have a history of ignoring the will of the people. On March 1, 2021 these Commissioners will meet and vote on the One Naples project at Vanderbilt Beach. We need YOUR HELP to stop the runaway train of over- development in Collier County. If we don't stop it now, it may be too late tomorrow. Please write to your Commissioners listed below and include your address. Add your voice to ours that over- development is not wanted in our community and we are willing to fight for this. Also go on www.savevanderbilt beach.com and read more about this development. Penny Taylor ...... Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov Burt Saunders...... Burt.Saunders@colliercountyfl.gov Bill McDaniel ...... Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov Andy Solis ...... Andy.Solis@colliercountyfl.gov Rick LoCastro ...... Rick.LoCastro@colliercountyfl.gov -IF-IF-] Falling Waters Beach Resort I We i Fn ■❑ ■❑ Mswebservices 1 1045 Tarpon Cove Dr., Naples, FL 34110 Unsubscribe Iarryandbevfoley(a arnail.com Update Profile I Customer Contact Data Notice Sent by tomcampbll@icloud.com powered by ®❑ Try email marketing for free today! From: Buzz Victor To: TavlorPenny Cc: GrecoSherry Subject: Phone Meeting Feb 12 Re Naples One Date: Thursday, February 11, 2021 6:50:29 PM Attachments: First 600 Survey Results Word.docx EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Hi, Commissioner, I am looking forward to our call tomorrow. I am sorry that this is going out so late, but the Presentation to which the link, below, connects was just finished this afternoon. It's a 24 minute narrated PowerPoint that tells the story of why we feel the One Naples amendment to the GMP should be denied. This is late notice, but if you have a chance, I'd love it if you would take a watch/listen. The link is: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L2en4xE3iFw You may also be interested in the results of the first 600 responses to a survey the we (Save Vanderbilt Beach) and the Pelican Bay property Owners Association have put out requesting input from the general public about life in Collier County and thoughts about One Naples. I have attached a Word file with those results to this email. Thanks, Buzz Buzz Victor 5650 Greenwood PI. BI. Suite 143 Greenwood Village, CO 80111 303-290-9100 303-290-1886 Fax 303-810-7374 Cell buzz(@unitedstor-all.com Naples Office: 1415 Panther Lane Naples, FL 34109 239-591-6212 From: ei)ircioCabverizon.net To: LoCastroRick; TavlorPenny; SolisAndv; SaundersBurt; McDanielBill; SaboJames Subject: Picture 3 of 3 showing impeded line of sight up Southbay Dr. from Barefoot Pelican Date: Tuesday, January 5, 2021 3:39:01 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioners: This is the last of the 3 photos I will be sending to you illustrating the impact to Barefoot Pelican owners caused by allowing One Naples to reduce their front yard setbacks from the 25 feet allowed to a mere 10 feet. The man is seated at approximately where he would be seated on his walkway. Note the wall- this illustrates the side of One Naples that has a front yard setback of only 10 feet versus the 28 foot setback of Barefoot Pelican. Note that the individual is in shade thus showing the effect of One Naples on his enjoyment of the walkway. Now picture that plywood wall towering 87 feet in the air. Will One Naples "lush landscaping" even mitigate this loss of line of sight? I think not, yet that is what the developer would have you believe. Please consider the neighbors when you are deliberating on this project. We have been at Barefoot Pelican for years and love it here. Do not let a "new boy on the block" come in and take away things that we hold most dear. Respectfully Submitted, Elizabeth (Betty) Pircio 271 Southbay Drive Naples, FL 781-690-0486 epircio@verizon.net -----Original Message ----- From: Ralph Cowie <ralphcowie1 @gmail.com> To: epircio@verizon.net Sent: Wed, Nov 4, 2020 4:24 pm From: ei)ircioCabverizon.net To: LoCastroRick; TavlorPenny; SolisAndv; SaundersBurt; McDanielBill; SaboJames Subject: Picture 3 of 3 showing impeded line of sight up Southbay Dr. from Barefoot Pelican Date: Tuesday, January 5, 2021 3:39:01 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioners: This is the last of the 3 photos I will be sending to you illustrating the impact to Barefoot Pelican owners caused by allowing One Naples to reduce their front yard setbacks from the 25 feet allowed to a mere 10 feet. The man is seated at approximately where he would be seated on his walkway. Note the wall- this illustrates the side of One Naples that has a front yard setback of only 10 feet versus the 28 foot setback of Barefoot Pelican. Note that the individual is in shade thus showing the effect of One Naples on his enjoyment of the walkway. Now picture that plywood wall towering 87 feet in the air. Will One Naples "lush landscaping" even mitigate this loss of line of sight? I think not, yet that is what the developer would have you believe. Please consider the neighbors when you are deliberating on this project. We have been at Barefoot Pelican for years and love it here. Do not let a "new boy on the block" come in and take away things that we hold most dear. Respectfully Submitted, Elizabeth (Betty) Pircio 271 Southbay Drive Naples, FL 781-690-0486 epircio@verizon.net -----Original Message ----- From: Ralph Cowie <ralphcowie1 @gmail.com> To: epircio@verizon.net Sent: Wed, Nov 4, 2020 4:24 pm From: Paul Pashibin To: TavlorPennv Subject: Please consider changing location of March 1st meeting. Date: Monday, December 28, 2020 8:21:45 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Hello Penny, Please consider changing location of March 1 st meeting. I want to be heard at the meeting. We need to provide a large, open space, where we can social distance while still allowing for people's voices to be heard on the topic of One Naples. I opt for an outdoor venue. Thank you, Pash Paul Pashibin From: Paul Pashibin To: TavlorPennv Subject: Please consider changing location of March 1st meeting. Date: Monday, December 28, 2020 8:21:45 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Hello Penny, Please consider changing location of March 1 st meeting. I want to be heard at the meeting. We need to provide a large, open space, where we can social distance while still allowing for people's voices to be heard on the topic of One Naples. I opt for an outdoor venue. Thank you, Pash Paul Pashibin From: Anita Wilcheck To: TavlorPennv Subject: Please deny Stock"s request for the current One Naples plan Date: Monday, February 15, 2021 6:26:05 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am asking you and all of the Commissioners of Collier County to deny Stock Development's request for their One Naples project. I live across from Buzz's Lighthouse Restaurant and have been here almost 16 years. I lived at the north end of the street for 12 years prior to this, so I've seen a lot of changes over the years. I love my neighborhood. What's not to love? It's so hard for me to understand how there is even a consideration of allowing this project to move forward. To give them the density, the limited setbacks, and the heights of the buildings they're asking for is incomprehensible to me. Unless you live here you can't really know what is best for the neighborhood. For Stock to try their scare tactics of a gas station being built here or another Publix is ludicrous. If that was ever a consideration then it would've already been built. I disagree completely with Stock's insistence that their project would bring far fewer cars than a small commercial development. If it is financially feasible to build a small commercial development with shops and restaurants I'd say let's go for it. That would at least benefit all of Collier County. Stock's proposal doesn't benefit all of the county at all. What Stock wants is completely contrary to what was written in the Master Growth Management Plan for Collier County. I don't understand how the the Commissioners can vote yes for this project as it is currently drawn. Please listen to me and my neighbors (and not the ones who are saying yes because Stock is going to make improvements to their existing condo buildings for their yes vote.) On March 1 you and your fellow commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am begging you today to oppose the development as Stock has currently proposed it. I assure you that I do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning and I am asking you to vote to deny his proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan. I will be there on March 1 to show all of the Commissioners that we are committed to saving this area. Vanderbilt Beach belongs to all of Collier County and not just the people who live on Gulf Shore Drive. I truly want what I personally feel is best for our county and all of its residents. Voting against Stock's request for an amendment to the Growth Management Plan will send him back to the drawing board. Perhaps he can come up with a plan what is more suited to the location. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, Anita Wilcheck From: cricli(cacomcast.net To: TavlorPennv; SaundersBurtSaunders.(alcolliercountvfl.aov; mcdanielbill.mcdaniel(@colliercountvfl.aov; solisandy.solis(c colliercountyfl.00v; LoCastroRick.LoCastro(c colliercountyfl.00v Subject: Please do not allow Stock Construction to ruin Naples Date: Sunday, February 14, 2021 10:18:59 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioners, I have been reading and following the proceedings on One Naples. I hope you vote against it as a development of that magnitude is going to ruin the ambiance of the Vanderbilt Beach area. Not only will it provide more congestion to the area that is already very congested, Naples will begin to look like little Miami. We do not need all those high rises in that area. We are frequent visitors to the Vanderbilt beach restaurants and certainly would hate to see it lose its charm. I also ask you before voting on this project is to please look into the lawsuits facing Stock Construction and their history of construction problems in large scale communities such as Ole and Paseo. I ask you to please vote against this project to maintain the beauty of the Vanderbilt Beach area and avoid overcrowding of our most valuable resource in Naples. Ron Johns, (Full Time Naples Resident) From: Sarah To: SolisAndv; TavlorPennv; LoCastroRick; McDanielBill; SaundersBurt Subject: Please reject One Naples Date: Monday, February 8, 2021 11:15:25 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear County Commissioners, I'm a resident of Collier County and live in Pelican Bay. I love Naples, and I love that it's a charming coastal town that has not lost itself to overcrowding, more buildings/cement than natural beauty, and does not have a big city feel. In order to preserve the charm of this beautiful coastal town, I'm asking you to please vote NO to One Naples. This is our town and you have the power to keep Naples special. Please use your power to vote no. Please keep Naples unique and lovely. Thank you for your time, Sincerely, Sarah Sharma From: Bob Massev To: TavlorPennv Cc: Sue (Dublin); Bob Massey Subject: PLEASE Vote "NO" Date: Friday, January 8, 2021 6:35:02 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Penny Taylor; Thank you for the work you have done in the past for our community. We know you have a very challenging job and have encountered many difficult resolutions. The proposed One Naples project is a potential disaster waiting to happen. Your conclusion regarding One Naples should be straight forward considering all the facts including precedents, strict enforcement of well thought out building codes, plus protecting the environment, quality of life for your constituents and the citizens in the surrounding developments. The latest rumor is a payoff by Stock of $300,000 to $400,000 to one of the neighboring developments if they agree to support the One Naples project. In my business career we commonly referred to such action as pure BRIBERY and such offers may be extended to other groups. Some have inferred it may even be offered to County Officials. What has this community come to in this crazy political environment? We know we can trust the County Commissioners and implore you to use proper judgement in this proposal. We are opposed to Stock Development's One Naples high-rise project because it fundamentally disregards the Collier County Growth Management Plan (GMP) and Land Development Code which residents and neighborhoods rely on to protect our environment, quality of life and home investment. We are asking you, as a responsible County Commissioner, to DENY the proposed GMP amendment. Sincerely, Robert & Sue Massey 10620 Gulf Shore Drive From: Bob Massev To: TavlorPennv Cc: Sue (Dublin); Bob Massey Subject: PLEASE Vote "NO" Date: Friday, January 8, 2021 6:35:02 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Penny Taylor; Thank you for the work you have done in the past for our community. We know you have a very challenging job and have encountered many difficult resolutions. The proposed One Naples project is a potential disaster waiting to happen. Your conclusion regarding One Naples should be straight forward considering all the facts including precedents, strict enforcement of well thought out building codes, plus protecting the environment, quality of life for your constituents and the citizens in the surrounding developments. The latest rumor is a payoff by Stock of $300,000 to $400,000 to one of the neighboring developments if they agree to support the One Naples project. In my business career we commonly referred to such action as pure BRIBERY and such offers may be extended to other groups. Some have inferred it may even be offered to County Officials. What has this community come to in this crazy political environment? We know we can trust the County Commissioners and implore you to use proper judgement in this proposal. We are opposed to Stock Development's One Naples high-rise project because it fundamentally disregards the Collier County Growth Management Plan (GMP) and Land Development Code which residents and neighborhoods rely on to protect our environment, quality of life and home investment. We are asking you, as a responsible County Commissioner, to DENY the proposed GMP amendment. Sincerely, Robert & Sue Massey 10620 Gulf Shore Drive From: James Hormensteadt To: SolisAndy; SaundersBurt; TaylorPenny; McDanielBill; LoCastroRick Cc: OchsLeo; Jane Brown; "John Gandolfo'; Kim Rosenberg; Larry Baumann; Melanie Miller; "Mike Foley"; Mike Ruffolo; Suzanne Minadeo; Trent Waterhouse; RodriguezDan; KlatzkowJeff Subject: Proposed One Naples Project Date: Wednesday, February 10, 2021 7:06:14 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Commissioners, I originally sent this email on October 30, 2020. The County's process, has been appropriately thorough, and understandably time-consuming. Between the end of October 2020 and now, the One Naples project has gone through the Planning Commission, multiple public meetings, plan modifications, and importantly, a new Commissioner has been elected to the Board of County Commissioners. There does seem to persist however, an ongoing commentary that compares the One Naples project to Pelican Bay. Therefore, the Foundation wishes to reiterate our position. Re: Proposed One Naples project Dear Commissioners: The Pelican Bay Foundation (Foundation) recognizes and values the importance of redevelopment to maintain property values and the quality of life in our community. We appreciate both the multiple and complex considerations of the criteria provided for in the land development code, the comprehensive plan amendments, the rezoning requests, etc., and, further, respect the concerns, objections, or support, of various community interest groups, individuals, or businesses. The Foundation expressly neither supports nor opposes the proposed One Naples project. In fact, we appreciate the open communication with which Stock Development has approached this proposed project. However, because properties within Pelican Bay have been cited as compatibility justifications for the One Naples project, the Foundation believes it has an obligation to clarify how Pelican Bay differs from the area to the north of Vanderbilt Drive since it is not part of Pelican Bay. Pelican Bay was created years ago as a comprehensive, well -planned, mixed -use Planned Unit Development, and it is vastly different from the neighborhoods to our south, north, and east. The planning, the PUD regulations and the applicable private declarations and covenants that govern Pelican Bay and have controlled its development include a myriad of factors, controls, constraints and planning techniques to regulate and manage development. The allowance of high-rise construction and mixed -use development are regulated and controlled by multiple different and important factors and controls. To compare only height in Pelican Bay to other areas, without also considering the overall planning and multiple other constraints that apply to Pelican Bay, seems like selective cherry picking. It is not an apt comparison. For example, the maximum height of principal structures within the Pelican Bay PUD is two hundred (200) feet above finished grade, provided that minimum yards must be maintained, from tract or development parcel lines, right-of-way lines and/or the edge of the gutter of a private road, of fifty (50) feet or one-half (1/2) the height of the structure, whichever is greater. Simply stated, Pelican Bay is a well -planned, well -organized and well -run large-scale development that should not be compared or used in a comparative analysis to justify any position (for or against) relative to development outside of its jurisdictional boundaries unless the entire Pelican Bay regulatory scheme of controls and constraints are similarly included. We wish you well in your deliberations of the value and appropriateness of the proposed One Naples project for the Vanderbilt Beach neighborhood. Sincerely, jivw }f oppevv4teadt President / COO Pelican Bay Foundation 6251 Pelican Bay Blvd. Naples, FL 34108 239-260-8460 direct 239-597-6927 fax ***** The information transmitted is intended only for the person or entity to which it is addressed and may contain confidential and/or privileged material. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this message in error and that any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this message including any attachments is strictly prohibited. If you received this in error, please contact the sender and delete the material from any computer. ***** From: GrecoSherry To: TavlorPennv Subject: RE: Meet Date: Wednesday, January 20, 2021 11:07:32 AM Ok Cf S'herT Cireco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 Board of Collier County Commissioners 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco(@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: TaylorPenny <Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov> Sent: Wednesday, January 20, 2021 10:15 AM To: GrecoSherry <Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Fwd: Meet Short zoom..... 15 minutes Penny Taylor Board of Collier County Commissioners Commissioner, District 4 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 303 Naples, FL. 34112 Office (239) 252-8604 Fax (239) 252-6393 Penny.Taylor(@colliercountyfl.gov Begin forwarded message: From: Ken Melkus <KMelkus(@wcas.com> Date: January 19, 2021 at 8:29:17 PM EST To: TaylorPenny <Penny.Taylor(@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Meet EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor, My name is Ken Melkus and I am an active member of Save Vanderbilt Beach. I have been an outspoken critic of One Naples. I would like to arrange for a brief meeting to personally say hello and to summarize our plans over the next 45 days as we launch our "Final Push" to defeat Stock's ill conceived project. Could you please advise how I can connect with your scheduler? Looking forward to meeting and thanks for your commitment to public service with particular emphasis on development activities affecting Collier County. Ken Melkus Sent from my iPad Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Laden, Laura To: TavlorPennv Subject: re: One Naples Date: Monday, December 21, 2020 9:27:40 AM Attachments: Outlook-1475677247. pno EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Good morning. Is One Naples something you can talk about? Thanks. Laura Layden Senior Business Reporter �I r j D zI �1� IIIs r� row Mobile: 239.253.8953 Office: 239.263.4818 Laura. Laydena_NaplesNews.com NaplesNews.com Support LOCAL JOURNALISM and become an all access -digital subscriber to naplesnews.com with this special offer: naplenews.com/subscribe Sign up for our Breaking Ground newsletter: https://www.napiesnews.com/featured-newsletter/breaking ground/ From: Laden, Laura To: SolisAndv Subject: re: One Naples Date: Wednesday, January 13, 2021 10:58:48 AM Attachments: Outlook-1475677247. Ana EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Hi. I'm working on a story about One Naples and how it's pitted neighbor against neighbor. Some have accused the developer of trying to "buy support" by making community and neighborhood improvements. One of them shared a letter they sent to you about it. I'm wondering if you can make a few comments about any concerns you might have about this, or the project. Thank you for any help you can provide. Laura Layden Senior Business Reporter NIETWORK Mobile: 239.253.8953 Office: 239.263.4818 Laura.Layden(a)NaplesNews.com NaplesNews.com Support LOCAL JOURNALISM and become an all access -digital subscriber to naplesnews.com with this special offer: naplenews.com/subscribe Sign up for our Breaking Ground newsletter: httns://www.napiesnews.com/featured-newsletter/breaking ground/ From: maureen trerice To: TavlorPennv; SaundersBurt; McDanielBill; LoCastroRick; SolisAndv Cc: Pelican Bav Subject: Re: One Naples Date: Monday, January 25, 2021 4:52:07 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. > On Jan 25, 2021, at 4:41 PM, maureen trerice <emtrerice@gmail.com> wrote: > The beauty of the Bay Colony neighborhood, as shown in Sundays, excellent front page story, is due to the correct use of space, good planning and easements. In the same photo, a few blocks North, is the proposed One Naples project, which is seeking to appeal the current commercial zoning for a residential designation. > If approved, it will be seen as a very special case, due to the lack of easements between buildings and roads. It will also set new precedents for multi -storied parking garages in front of residential developments, only 15feet from the road. This is typical of a very urban environment. > If you look at the photo on 7A, the wall is behind the landscaping, and runs down the last block of Vanderbilt Beach Road, turns the corner heading North on Gulf Shore N. > What is not shown in the same photo, is the sidewalk, which in high season, has been clocked at 400 people an hour, with strollers, wagons, bikes and trikes, etc.. There was a picture showing parked car spaces, but no sidewalks. > This is a walled, exclusive resort dropped onto a laid back beach community. Keep it commercial until we know more. > This comprehensive article about a very complicated subject, had just one issue that is not up for debate. A bribe is a bribe whatever it's painted. > Maureen Trerice > 8171 Bay Colony Dr. Apt 2004 > Naples, Florida 34108 > 239-3548778 > In the County Planning sessions, I watched on zoom, the footage from the wall to the road, was all over the map. Mostly, in the 15 to 25feet level and then 10 feet, if a store could be worked into the wall, or whatever would pass. I have no intent to deceive. It's bad enough. From: Laden, Laura To: LoCastroRick; McDanielBill; TavlorPennv, SaundersBurt; SolisAndv Subject: re: One Naples hearing Date: Monday, February 1, 2021 4:06:21 PM Attachments: Outlook-1475677247. ina EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Good afternoon. It appears that the One Naples hearing will be held at commission chambers? Is that correct? What are your thoughts about it? It seems from the county manager's report that it will be the best venue, given COVID limitations and event conflicts. Thank you. Laura Layden Senior Business Reporter Mobile: 239.253.8953 Office: 239.263.4818 Laura. Layden(a)NaplesNews.com NaplesNews.com Support LOCAL JOURNALISM and become an all access -digital subscriber to naplesnews.com with this special offer: naplenews.com/subscribe Sign up for our Breaking Ground newsletter: https://www.napiesnews.com/featured-newsletter/breaking ground/ From: Laden, Laura To: TavlorPennv Subject: re: One Naples Date: Monday, December 21, 2020 9:27:40 AM Attachments: Outlook-1475677247. pno EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Good morning. Is One Naples something you can talk about? Thanks. Laura Layden Senior Business Reporter �I r j D zI �1� IIIs r� row Mobile: 239.253.8953 Office: 239.263.4818 Laura. Laydena_NaplesNews.com NaplesNews.com Support LOCAL JOURNALISM and become an all access -digital subscriber to naplesnews.com with this special offer: naplenews.com/subscribe Sign up for our Breaking Ground newsletter: https://www.napiesnews.com/featured-newsletter/breaking ground/ From: maureen trerice To: TavlorPennv; SaundersBurt; McDanielBill; LoCastroRick; SolisAndv Cc: Pelican Bav Subject: Re: One Naples Date: Monday, January 25, 2021 4:52:07 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. > On Jan 25, 2021, at 4:41 PM, maureen trerice <emtrerice@gmail.com> wrote: > The beauty of the Bay Colony neighborhood, as shown in Sundays, excellent front page story, is due to the correct use of space, good planning and easements. In the same photo, a few blocks North, is the proposed One Naples project, which is seeking to appeal the current commercial zoning for a residential designation. > If approved, it will be seen as a very special case, due to the lack of easements between buildings and roads. It will also set new precedents for multi -storied parking garages in front of residential developments, only 15feet from the road. This is typical of a very urban environment. > If you look at the photo on 7A, the wall is behind the landscaping, and runs down the last block of Vanderbilt Beach Road, turns the corner heading North on Gulf Shore N. > What is not shown in the same photo, is the sidewalk, which in high season, has been clocked at 400 people an hour, with strollers, wagons, bikes and trikes, etc.. There was a picture showing parked car spaces, but no sidewalks. > This is a walled, exclusive resort dropped onto a laid back beach community. Keep it commercial until we know more. > This comprehensive article about a very complicated subject, had just one issue that is not up for debate. A bribe is a bribe whatever it's painted. > Maureen Trerice > 8171 Bay Colony Dr. Apt 2004 > Naples, Florida 34108 > 239-3548778 > In the County Planning sessions, I watched on zoom, the footage from the wall to the road, was all over the map. Mostly, in the 15 to 25feet level and then 10 feet, if a store could be worked into the wall, or whatever would pass. I have no intent to deceive. It's bad enough. From: Ken Melkus To: SolisAndv; TavlorPennv; SaundersBurt; LoCastroRick; McDanielBill Subject: Re: Vaccine Appointments Available! Date: Wednesday, December 30, 2020 6:14:51 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Commissioner, good news indeed! Please exhibit the same leadership and concern for the health and safety of your constituents by supporting a change of venue for the One Naples meeting of March 1 to a larger facility and perhaps even outdoor. State Sunshine law encourages the Commissioners to find an appropriate venue when the anticipated size of the participants is expected to be large. Given the fact that nearly 4,000 residents have signed on-line positions opposing Stocks ill-conceived proposal, the attendance is likely to be record setting. This should give you and the other Commissioners every reason to reconsider your recent action to use County offices and find a larger and safer facility. Respectfully, Ken Melkus Sent from my iPad On Dec 30, 2020, at 4:50 PM, Commissioner Andy Solis <Andy.Solis@colliercountyfl.gov> wrote: North Naples News and Collier County Updates View this email in your browser ®❑ Share 0 Tweet R. Forward Hello Ken, I am very happy to announce that the Florida Department of Health in Collier County (DOH -Collier) will begin distributing the vaccine on Jan 3. (Note: DOH has a limited initial supply, but will continue to receive the vaccine in the following weeks.) I am also happy to announce that DOH will NOT be distributing it on a first -come -first -served basis, but in an by -appointment schedule. (Read my letter to the DOH urging them for an appointment -only process HERE.) Click on the image below to open a PDF file with links to appointments for each day -- go schedule your appointment now and then come back to read the rest of the newsletter! 8 Welcome back! Some other things to keep in mind: COVID-19 testing has been cancelled for all sites with the exception of Thursday, January 7, 2020 at North Collier Regional Park Soccer Fields per the schedule above. Remember: • For Healthcare personnel with direct patient contact and persons 65+ ONLY • No referral needed. No cost. No residency requirement. • Please wear a face mask and bring identification. • Healthcare personnel with direct patient contact will be asked to provide identification indicating they are healthcare staff. • Each person must schedule a separate appointment. • Clients will be asked to complete a registration form prior to receiving the vaccine. • Please plan to remain up to 30 minutes after vaccination for observation. • Lightning, heavy rain, or gusty winds can slow operations or shut down the site. If the sites are shut down, the DOH will contact those with appointments to re -schedule. I am so happy this day has arrived for our community; I know how many of you are anxiously awaiting the opportunity to be vaccinated. Please share this with others who might be interested. If all the appointments are full, remember that more will become available, and I will continue to notify you as they do. I applaud our local health department staff for working so hard to create a better process for our community than we've observed elsewhere. And I'm proud of the coordination of County leadership, and all the support County staff will be providing to the DOH in executing this enormous effort. It will take time for us all to be protected. And I'll be back later this week with other, non-COVID news. In the meantime, please remember patience -- we are all doing this for the first time -- and remember to keep your guard up: wear your mask, keep your distance, wash your hands, and stay safe! The best sources for clear information on the pandemic are our state health department or the CDC. The Florida hotline above is staffed 24/7. Florida Department of Health Florida COVID-19 Dashboard (updated daily at mid -day; contains county -specific data) Centers for Disease Control COVID-19 site World Health Organization Copyright © 2020 Andy Solis, District 2 County Commissioner, All rights reserved. You are receiving this email because of your association with Collier County Commission District 2. Our mailing address is: Andy Solis, District 2 County Commissioner 3299 Tamiami Trail East Suite 303 Naples, FI 34112 106 • • .•• - .•• Want to change how you receive these emails? You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list ®❑ From: Ken Melkus To: SolisAndv; TavlorPennv; SaundersBurt; LoCastroRick; McDanielBill Subject: Re: Vaccine Appointments Available! Date: Wednesday, December 30, 2020 6:14:51 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Commissioner, good news indeed! Please exhibit the same leadership and concern for the health and safety of your constituents by supporting a change of venue for the One Naples meeting of March 1 to a larger facility and perhaps even outdoor. State Sunshine law encourages the Commissioners to find an appropriate venue when the anticipated size of the participants is expected to be large. Given the fact that nearly 4,000 residents have signed on-line positions opposing Stocks ill-conceived proposal, the attendance is likely to be record setting. This should give you and the other Commissioners every reason to reconsider your recent action to use County offices and find a larger and safer facility. Respectfully, Ken Melkus Sent from my iPad On Dec 30, 2020, at 4:50 PM, Commissioner Andy Solis <Andy.Solis@colliercountyfl.gov> wrote: North Naples News and Collier County Updates View this email in your browser ®❑ Share 0 Tweet R. Forward Hello Ken, I am very happy to announce that the Florida Department of Health in Collier County (DOH -Collier) will begin distributing the vaccine on Jan 3. (Note: DOH has a limited initial supply, but will continue to receive the vaccine in the following weeks.) I am also happy to announce that DOH will NOT be distributing it on a first -come -first -served basis, but in an by -appointment schedule. (Read my letter to the DOH urging them for an appointment -only process HERE.) Click on the image below to open a PDF file with links to appointments for each day -- go schedule your appointment now and then come back to read the rest of the newsletter! 8 Welcome back! Some other things to keep in mind: COVID-19 testing has been cancelled for all sites with the exception of Thursday, January 7, 2020 at North Collier Regional Park Soccer Fields per the schedule above. Remember: • For Healthcare personnel with direct patient contact and persons 65+ ONLY • No referral needed. No cost. No residency requirement. • Please wear a face mask and bring identification. • Healthcare personnel with direct patient contact will be asked to provide identification indicating they are healthcare staff. • Each person must schedule a separate appointment. • Clients will be asked to complete a registration form prior to receiving the vaccine. • Please plan to remain up to 30 minutes after vaccination for observation. • Lightning, heavy rain, or gusty winds can slow operations or shut down the site. If the sites are shut down, the DOH will contact those with appointments to re -schedule. I am so happy this day has arrived for our community; I know how many of you are anxiously awaiting the opportunity to be vaccinated. Please share this with others who might be interested. If all the appointments are full, remember that more will become available, and I will continue to notify you as they do. I applaud our local health department staff for working so hard to create a better process for our community than we've observed elsewhere. And I'm proud of the coordination of County leadership, and all the support County staff will be providing to the DOH in executing this enormous effort. It will take time for us all to be protected. And I'll be back later this week with other, non-COVID news. In the meantime, please remember patience -- we are all doing this for the first time -- and remember to keep your guard up: wear your mask, keep your distance, wash your hands, and stay safe! The best sources for clear information on the pandemic are our state health department or the CDC. The Florida hotline above is staffed 24/7. Florida Department of Health Florida COVID-19 Dashboard (updated daily at mid -day; contains county -specific data) Centers for Disease Control COVID-19 site World Health Organization Copyright © 2020 Andy Solis, District 2 County Commissioner, All rights reserved. You are receiving this email because of your association with Collier County Commission District 2. Our mailing address is: Andy Solis, District 2 County Commissioner 3299 Tamiami Trail East Suite 303 Naples, FI 34112 106 • • .•• - .•• Want to change how you receive these emails? You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list ®❑ From: dave(aboritchard.cc To: TavlorPenny Subject: Request regarding One Naples project hearing Date: Tuesday, December 29, 2020 11:05:27 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. It is my understanding that one of the condo associations most affected by the One Naples project has received a tentative proposal from Stock Development offering several monetary "incentives" to the condo association if they agree to drop their opposition to the One Naples project. They must also agree to speak publicly in favor of One Naples, and write a supporting letter to the Board of Collier County Commissioners on Stock's behalf. The package is very significant, estimated to be between $300,000 - $400,000. If this is true, it poses a significant conflict of interest because the motivation of such a condo association would not necessarily be what is in the best interest of the community, but rather what is in the best financial interest of the association. Therefore, I urge you to require that anyone testifying in writing or in person at the One Naples March Board of County Commissioners meeting disclose whether they, or the community association in which they live, have received any compensation from Stock Development, its affiliates or representatives and if so, the amount of such compensation. While such association has a right to voice its opinion on the project, such disclosure would allow you the full transparency to a significant motivating factor. Respectfully, Robert D Pritchard 1405-1 Vanderbilt Gulfside From: dave(aboritchard.cc To: TavlorPenny Subject: Request regarding One Naples project hearing Date: Tuesday, December 29, 2020 11:05:27 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. It is my understanding that one of the condo associations most affected by the One Naples project has received a tentative proposal from Stock Development offering several monetary "incentives" to the condo association if they agree to drop their opposition to the One Naples project. They must also agree to speak publicly in favor of One Naples, and write a supporting letter to the Board of Collier County Commissioners on Stock's behalf. The package is very significant, estimated to be between $300,000 - $400,000. If this is true, it poses a significant conflict of interest because the motivation of such a condo association would not necessarily be what is in the best interest of the community, but rather what is in the best financial interest of the association. Therefore, I urge you to require that anyone testifying in writing or in person at the One Naples March Board of County Commissioners meeting disclose whether they, or the community association in which they live, have received any compensation from Stock Development, its affiliates or representatives and if so, the amount of such compensation. While such association has a right to voice its opinion on the project, such disclosure would allow you the full transparency to a significant motivating factor. Respectfully, Robert D Pritchard 1405-1 Vanderbilt Gulfside From: GarciaShirlev To: GarciaShirlev Cc: SummersEllen; ForesterDebrah Subject: Sabal Bay BCC Public Hearing - Jan. 12 Date: Thursday, January 7, 2021 4:45:25 PM Attachments: 2021-01-12 Board of County Commissioners - Public Aaenda-1803.Ddf image001.png imaae002.Dna Good Afternoon, Please see the attached Collier County Board of County Commissioners Agenda for the January 12, 2021 Meeting. The Sabal Bay PUD-Rezone will be presented at this meeting as Agenda Item 9.A. At this meeting, an additional item will be presented related to a recommendation for the BCC consider providing an economic incentive to P6NT, LLC for the redevelopment of two parcels located in the Bayshore gateway Triangle Community Redevelopment Area. This item is 14.13.1. If you would like to participate or provide public comment during this meeting you may do so by attending in person, or by registering to speak via Zoom utilizing the following link: https://us02web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_TWgkRKQQSleiOX95dXKyCw Thank you! Ellen Summers, MPA Principal Redevelopment Specialist Community Redevelopment Agency - Bayshore Gateway Triangle 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Bldg. F I Suite 103 Naples, FL 34112 Phone I Office — (239) 252-8847 1 Cell (239) 276-3058 "HOW ARE WE DOING?" Please CLICK HERE to fill out a CUSTOMER SURVEY. We appreciate your feedback! VIP 0flY4WXCGW TriNgleCRA.BMY4hnMl3CE1MifkM;iQ9MSTV #Iaklkwan Crek+ MS 1 i Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: GarciaShirlev To: GarciaShirlev Cc: SummersEllen; ForesterDebrah Subject: Sabal Bay BCC Public Hearing - Jan. 12 Date: Thursday, January 7, 2021 4:45:25 PM Attachments: 2021-01-12 Board of County Commissioners - Public Aaenda-1803.Ddf image001.png imaae002.Dna Good Afternoon, Please see the attached Collier County Board of County Commissioners Agenda for the January 12, 2021 Meeting. The Sabal Bay PUD-Rezone will be presented at this meeting as Agenda Item 9.A. At this meeting, an additional item will be presented related to a recommendation for the BCC consider providing an economic incentive to P6NT, LLC for the redevelopment of two parcels located in the Bayshore gateway Triangle Community Redevelopment Area. This item is 14.13.1. If you would like to participate or provide public comment during this meeting you may do so by attending in person, or by registering to speak via Zoom utilizing the following link: https://us02web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_TWgkRKQQSleiOX95dXKyCw Thank you! Ellen Summers, MPA Principal Redevelopment Specialist Community Redevelopment Agency - Bayshore Gateway Triangle 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Bldg. F I Suite 103 Naples, FL 34112 Phone I Office — (239) 252-8847 1 Cell (239) 276-3058 "HOW ARE WE DOING?" Please CLICK HERE to fill out a CUSTOMER SURVEY. We appreciate your feedback! VIP 0flY4WXCGW TriNgleCRA.BMY4hnMl3CE1MifkM;iQ9MSTV #Iaklkwan Crek+ MS 1 i Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Sam Price To: TavlorPennv Subject: sam@lp-pc.com Date: Monday, February 15, 2021 9:41:15 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. The massive change to the zoning is not justified and would seriously injure the neighborhood. It too massive and out of place. We live in beachwalk. Thank you for your consideration. Sam From: Ann Andersen & Tom Hurvis To: TavlorPennv Subject: Save Vanderbilt Beach Date: Wednesday, February 10, 2021 6:33:23 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan Ann Andersen & Tom Hurvis From: Rick Tonis To: TavlorPennv Subject: Stock Development, One Naples project Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 11:34:50 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Ms. Taylor, As with many, I am opposed to the Stock Development, One Naples project. I would encourage you to announce your opposition as soon as possible. Best regards, Rick & Mary Tonis 6657 Trident Way Naples, FL 34108 From: David J Burns To: TaylorPennv Subject: Stock/Naples One and Vanderbilt Neighborhood Date: Saturday, January 2, 2021 12:45:18 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: David J Burns To: TaylorPennv Subject: Stock/Naples One and Vanderbilt Neighborhood Date: Saturday, January 2, 2021 12:45:18 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: Cindy Goorlev To: TavlorPennv Subject: STOP One Naples PLEASE Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 3:28:16 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Please VOTE NO in March to the One Naples overdevelopment of our beautiful Collier County. Didn't we learn from the Covid/Miami influx? It saddens me to think this could be the future of this quiet beauty I've just moved to from the Midwest. We came here to escape the stress of crazy, busy, overpopulated Chicago suburbs. The beaches here are such incredible testaments to nature, we're already losing our historic Naples Beach Club, and high rises will only add pollution and destruction to our already fragile ecosystem. Can't you please solve the red tide destruction before adding more population, waste and pollution? Thank you for reading this. I pray you vote No to the One Naples development, and keep Collier County a quiet place of beauty. Respectfully, Cindy Goorley 5754 Woodmere Lake Cir H-103, Naples 34112 Sent from my iPhone From: Grea Stuart To: TavlorPennv Cc: Jim Cleveland; Craig A. Kasper; Buzz Victor Subject: The Gaps In The Record One Napes MPUD Brief Date: Monday, January 11, 2021 1:33:25 PM Attachments: 5Dec21 DRAFT SVBtoBOCC BriefCoverLetter.odf 17DecStuart GapsInTheRecordBrief. pdf EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Good Afternoon Commissioner Taylor: I am copying you with a brief that I discussed with and sent to Commissioner LoCastro (please see the attached brief). The brief identifies the 5 specific Collier Code items that have been omitted or inaccurately addressed by Staff and Applicant through the One Naples MPUP review process. If you are interested I am available at any time to discuss further. Good luck in your deliberations and have a great week! Greg Stuart, MAURP GREGSTUART (c) 239 677 6126 www.Stuarturbandesian.com www.GregStuartFineArt.com Both Greg Stuart and Stuart and Associates Planning and Design Services intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged, confidential and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please permanently dispose of the original message and notify Greg Stuart immediately at 239 677 6126. From: Grea Stuart To: TavlorPennv Cc: Jim Cleveland; Craig A. Kasper; Buzz Victor Subject: The Gaps In The Record One Napes MPUD Brief Date: Monday, January 11, 2021 1:33:25 PM Attachments: 5Dec21 DRAFT SVBtoBOCC BriefCoverLetter.odf 17DecStuart GapsInTheRecordBrief. pdf EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Good Afternoon Commissioner Taylor: I am copying you with a brief that I discussed with and sent to Commissioner LoCastro (please see the attached brief). The brief identifies the 5 specific Collier Code items that have been omitted or inaccurately addressed by Staff and Applicant through the One Naples MPUP review process. If you are interested I am available at any time to discuss further. Good luck in your deliberations and have a great week! Greg Stuart, MAURP GREGSTUART (c) 239 677 6126 www.Stuarturbandesian.com www.GregStuartFineArt.com Both Greg Stuart and Stuart and Associates Planning and Design Services intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged, confidential and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please permanently dispose of the original message and notify Greg Stuart immediately at 239 677 6126. From: Scott Zumstein To: SolisAndy; burt.sanders(c colliercountvfl.aov; McDanielBill; TaylorPennv; donna.fiala( lcolliercountvfl.gov; ieff. klatzlow(alcolliercountyfl.aov Cc: scott(alzumsteins.com; Ken Oehler; dnet95 gmail.com; cahendriks(abcomcast.net; "Mike Dillev"; "Ted Norris"; awilli9412(abaol.com; info(obcaptainsforcleanwater.org; max.chesnes(abtcpalm.com; info(abcalusawaterkeeper.org; robm(cbconservancy.org; ConservationCollier; info everciladesfoundation.org; brent.batten (abnaplesnews.com; investigations(abwinknews.com; awilliams(alnews-press.com; patrick.riley(o naplesnews.com; kschneider(( oannett.com Subject: Urgent -Commissioners toxic dump Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 10:44:37 AM SWFWM & SFWM, C.C. Commissioners, Let's call it what it is. Not pumping but dumping! Let's identify what's being dumped. Storm water is a kind term. How about toxic, dangerous, life, wild life and environment destroying sludge water. Flooded businesses, homes, garages and sheds off gassing, flooded septic tanks/field with fecal matter, flooded vehicles with oils and fuels, dead decaying animals all with a variety of pesticides, herbicides and fertilizers mixed in. As Erin Brockovich once stated "go ahead, I had that brought in especially for you". There are thousands if not tens of thousands of Collier County tax paying citizens living, and supposedly enjoying their water front access, all along the water ways you want to toxic dump into. Waterways effected by toxic dumping; Coco Canal, Cocohatchee River, The Palm River, Wiggins Pass, North Channel to Imperial River and Estero Bay, South Channel to Turkey Bay and all the surrounding estuaries. Just to name a few. You cannot control where it goes. Home communities and Condo Towers effected by toxic dumping; Palm River, Horse Creek and Willoughby Acres (et al), Colliers Reserve, Gulf Harbor, Pelican Isle Yacht Club, Aqua, Kalea Bay, Marina Bay Club, The Dunes, Audubon Country Club, Wiggins Bay Club, Tarpon Cove, Wiggins Lake, The Old Florida Golf Club, All of Connors neighborhood off Vanderbilt Dr and all condo towers on Gulf Shore Dr. and lastly, but probably missed a few, the proposed (hopefully not) One Naples by Stock Development. State and Collier County Parks effected by toxic dumping; Delnor-Wiggins Pass State Park and Collier County's Lely Barefoot Beach. Both of the parks have inland estuaries. The immediate concern; You are violating your own disclosure and notification protocals. Have you notified all the citizens in these communities? Are you willing to go against these communities concerns of clean water and safe environments? Are you willing to pollute the quality of life of the neighborhood citizens and families? Are you willing to drive down property equites and values with a toxic dump? Concerned for a quality of life, Scott Zumstein scottn_ zumstems.com 239-860-9025 cell Scott Thanks for keeping me in the loop Pumps - when I read'pumps' Quail West immediately came to mind. Quail West has illegally used pumps to divert flood waters from their golf course; I say illegally, because they were fined for taking that action; they paid the fine, apparently because they were of the opinion that it would be less money than repairing their flooded golf course. One would think that the flood waters would flow SW everywhere south of Bonita Beach Road; perhaps not, as pumps were need to move the water to where it would naturally flow away from their golf course; maybe there are lands south of Bonita Beach Road that are 'naturally' part of the Imperial River Drainage Basin?? One can bet that the powerhouse golf/gated developments along Immokalee Road, including Quail Creek, Quail West and Grey Oaks are players in this unfolding 'who gets the flood waters' drama. The water that we are all trying to deal with, wants to move South and West. The Imperial River Basin has always flooded, and Lee County has done a miserable job of managing the development of the Bonita Springs area; they want the problem to be someone else's. Couple that with Collier County's desire/need to ever expand the Sanitary Treatment Facilities on Goodlette - Frank Road, and you have what to me at least, is a clear motive for the continued proposals to divert the flood waters into the Cocohatchee River; the golf/gated communities are in lock -step with whatever proposal routes the water away from them. IMHO the water wants to predominantly flow South to Picayune Strand, Fakahatchee Strand and to Big Cypress. There is a Coastal Ridge on both coasts of Florida that funnels the water South into Florida Bay. The Coastal Rivers that, in our case, flow West are diminutive and are incapable of handling the water that careless development has diverted into them, and proposes to divert into them. Once more, we are banging our heads against nature _ that never works out good. From: Ken [mailto:kenoehler@comcast.net] Sent: Monday, February 8, 20215:58 PM To: Scott Zumstein <scott@zumsteins.com> Subject: Fwd: Big Cypress Basin Scott You may already be aware that the state sfwmd is in effect backfiring Bonita springs attempt to send their flood waters to Palm River and Cocohatchee River and on to your waters. Here is an email Danette huff who lives on sharwood sent to commissioners. I will send a similar but less lengthy demanding they prevent this from happy. Let Lee county solve its own flooding problem. Ken Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: Danette Huff <dnet95n.umail.com> Date: February 8, 2021 at 5:51:38 PM EST To: Ken <kenoehlern.comcast.net> Subject: Fwd: Big Cypress Basin Hi Ken, here is the email address for Saunders. Burt. Saunders&CollierCountvFL.Gov Please give me a call if you have any questions. 239-595-5610 ---------- Forwarded message --------- From: Danette <dnet95ggmail.com> Date: Mon, Feb 8, 2021 at 4:58 PM Subject: Fwd: Big Cypress Basin To: Ken <kenoehlergcomcast.net> Hi Ken, Here is the email I sent to Craig -the attachment has the language. I will send you Comm. Saunders email when I get a minute. Thank you, Danettep Sent from my Whone Begin forwarded message: From: Danette Huff <dnet95ggmail.com> Date: February 8, 2021 at 2:51:22 PM EST To: Craig Hendriks <cahendriksg.comcast.net> Subject: Big Cypress Basin Craig, The attached document has the language. Subject: Item 11 D Big Cypress Basin (BCB) Boundary Expansion Commissioners, First of all, thank you Commissioner Taylor for recalling this item. An expansion of the Big Cypress Basin has no benefit to Collier County. It will negatively impact a large portion of North Naples residents. This bill opens the door to diversion of water from Lee County down through Collier County, specifically to the Immokalee Road Canal and out into the sensitive Cocohatchee River Estuary and into Wiggins Bay which is an Outstanding Florida Waterbody. Regardless of how this is being presented, if you are familiar with the history it's obvious that moving water south from Lee County into Collier County is the ultimate goal of this bill. Palm River, Cocohatchee River Estates, the Bay House, and Colliers Reserve had a meeting with Big Cypress Basin and County staff about this two years ago. Residents had a lot of questions and very few answers were provided. We were promised this wouldn't move forward until our questions were answered and there were assurances that water wouldn't be moved south or if it was, it wouldn't affect our properties. Our trust was rewarded with a bill being pushed through via a budget document and no discussion with the stakeholders. The term "scientific" is being used very loosely. While this may have been valid pre -development, it is no longer the way water flows in the existing built environment. Although SFWMD states they reviewed existing permits, the reality doesn't reflect their study results. If you need evidence, look at the pumps that would have been required for the Bonita diversion project. If water flowed that way naturally, a pump wouldn't be required. You may recall a former SFWMD board member used the term "shared adversity" when he spoke of taking the flood water from Bonita Springs and pumping it south to the Immokalee Road Canal out to the Cocohatchee River and Estuary. The term "shared adversity" was used to describe the damage from flooding the Bonita stormwater would cause in residential areas such as Palm River, Collier's Reserve, Horse Creek, and Cocohatchee River Estates. He spoke specifically of lessening the duration of flooding for a few hundred houses in Bonita Springs by flooding some homes in Palm River. While I sympathize with the residents of Bonita Springs, I object to becoming the affected area as we purchased our property in good faith after doing our due diligence about stormwater management. Regulations for stormwater design criteria were created and development was permitted, inspected, and approved by the SFWMD and Lee County and other government agencies. It is unrealistic to expect that the Collier County property owners calmly accept that their properties will now flood or at best, be de -valued due to government agencies that acted in bad faith, allowing areas of Lee County to be overdeveloped to the point of flooding. The burden of Lee County's and/or municipalities Growth Management Divisions and SFWMD's failure to plan sufficiently; allow development to go beyond what their stormwater management system can handle; or meet their concurrency requirements should not be placed on our shoulders and flood us out of our homes or drive our property values down. Before you provide support to this bill, could you please answer the following questions? If you are unable to answer them, could you please actively work to ensure this bill is not passed until answers are provided? 1. There is not enough capacity in Collier County's existing stormwater management system as evidenced by existing flooding events. The existing stormwater management system infrastructure is also failing. What is being done to address those issues as well as meet the challenges of sea level rise? What are the costs of those improvements? I recall a stormwater funding issue that was attempted to be addressed in the form of a stormwater utility that failed. Why would you add stormwater from another County when stormwater management issues aren't able to be appropriately funded here? 2. Collier County is already struggling with water quality, 36% of Collier County watersheds are impaired, including the Cocohatchee River watershed. Polluted stormwater runoff is causing algae blooms and other issues in stormwater ponds, in the canals, the estuaries and in the Gulf of Mexico. Some of the algae blooms give off toxins of which very little is known about the potential adverse health effects. Allowing more stormwater will make it worse. How would you require Lee County to treat their water before it is allowed to be shipped south? How would you be able to mandate and ensure treatment is working? What are those costs? Or conversely, how much will that treatment and monitoring cost Collier County residents? 3. Water management issues will continue to worsen due to sea level rise. The areas that would be required to share the adversity are adjacent to a tidal waterbody. As sea level rise is making these properties vulnerable to repeated inundation, why would you allow the addition of water from another county to worsen Collier County property owners' situations? 4. How are you assuring Collier County's stormwater management system is concurrent? 5. Have the areas downstream of the primary water management system been modeled? Why take on additional water without knowing if there is capacity or if the system is concurrent? 6. What are the impacts from the addition of Bonita National stormwater? 7. What assurances do we have that no negative impacts to our properties will result from this boundary expansion? We know that this bill is the first step in moving water south from Lee County to Collier County to alleviate flooding in Lee County. In addition to all of these unanswered questions and there is a huge negative impact to Collier County residents, I can't imagine why you would support the expansion of the Big Cypress Basin Boundary. I can only hope that you will actively work to make sure the bill doesn't pass. Please, as our representatives, speak for us as if it were your home being threatened. From: Dustin D Nelson To: TaylorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt Beach and the One Naples Development proposal Date: Sunday, February 14, 2021 10:19:33 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: As a real estate lawyer who has for over 30 years been involved in zoning matters, I find it unfathomable that the massive departure from current rules would be considered at all. I find myself wondering if consideration of this unneeded and unwanted and ill-conceived development is suggestive of something rotten to the core within local government. On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. Over the past 40 years, I have witnessed the changes. There has been growth beyond belief, but it has been managed — for the most part — with some care and respect for the charm that attracted my family to the community in the first place. This would not be just a nail in the coffin to that charm. It would be dropping an anvil on an egg. Please vote against the proposed amendment to the existing C-3 zoning. Sincerely, Dustin D. Nelson, Esq. From: Louise To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt Beach Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 4:19:15 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. I am writing to urge you to vote against the Stock Development who are proposing a huge high-rise project at the intersection of Vanderbilt Beach Road and Gulf Shore Drive called One Naples. This is not what Naples needs and goes against all current regulations that were set for a reason. Live, hope, learn! Louise Pearson 5580 Cynthia Lane Naples 34112 From: carolyiasiul ferrari To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood One Naples Date: Friday, December 18, 2020 2:31:44 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: carolyiasiul ferrari To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood One Naples Date: Friday, December 18, 2020 2:31:44 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Don Nealon To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Tuesday, January 12, 2021 10:36:47 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Anne Eckhart To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood -- One Naples Date: Tuesday, January 5, 2021 9:53:47 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I have been an owner of a condominium at the Regatta at Vanderbilt Beach since 2004. I purchased in the Regatta because I loved the location and the low key neighborhood. The area was not over developed with high rises and had a really local, non -touristy feel to it. The beach was pristine and sparsely occupied even in February and March. But if you have been to Vanderbilt Beach at any time in the last couple of years then you know that (due to the public parking garage) it is completely overcrowded every single day of the week, even in the off season. It is often difficult to find a spot where others are not right on top of you. People are sitting so close to each other that you might as well be vacationing together. Frankly, with the current state of the beach, I am truly surprised that Stock wants to build this many high end condos overlooking a beach so crowded that million dollar buyers would probably not even want to go there themselves, much less take their guests there. Nevertheless, they are moving forward. This project is so disproportionate to the surrounding area. It is in no way comparable to the Pelican Bay planned development and should not be considered in that light. The negative and lasting impact on the area would be irrecoverable. The precedent this would set for all of Vanderbilt Beach (and for Collier County) would be horrendous. What would stop developers from over building on the rest of Vanderbilt Beach if this development is approved. The snowball effect could not be stopped. There is a reason the County has development standards in place — to promote reasonable development that is compatible with its surroundings. If the county code and standards are to be ignored, then why do they exist? Certainly, as an owner in the Vanderbilt neighborhood, I never thought a development of such disproportionate scale and magnitude could come to us. That's one reason I chose this neighborhood. Please protect the integrity of Vanderbilt Beach and don't allow this project to open the flood gates of over development in this area. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, Anne E. Eckhart, Esq. From: Anne Eckhart To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood -- One Naples Date: Tuesday, January 5, 2021 9:53:47 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I have been an owner of a condominium at the Regatta at Vanderbilt Beach since 2004. I purchased in the Regatta because I loved the location and the low key neighborhood. The area was not over developed with high rises and had a really local, non -touristy feel to it. The beach was pristine and sparsely occupied even in February and March. But if you have been to Vanderbilt Beach at any time in the last couple of years then you know that (due to the public parking garage) it is completely overcrowded every single day of the week, even in the off season. It is often difficult to find a spot where others are not right on top of you. People are sitting so close to each other that you might as well be vacationing together. Frankly, with the current state of the beach, I am truly surprised that Stock wants to build this many high end condos overlooking a beach so crowded that million dollar buyers would probably not even want to go there themselves, much less take their guests there. Nevertheless, they are moving forward. This project is so disproportionate to the surrounding area. It is in no way comparable to the Pelican Bay planned development and should not be considered in that light. The negative and lasting impact on the area would be irrecoverable. The precedent this would set for all of Vanderbilt Beach (and for Collier County) would be horrendous. What would stop developers from over building on the rest of Vanderbilt Beach if this development is approved. The snowball effect could not be stopped. There is a reason the County has development standards in place — to promote reasonable development that is compatible with its surroundings. If the county code and standards are to be ignored, then why do they exist? Certainly, as an owner in the Vanderbilt neighborhood, I never thought a development of such disproportionate scale and magnitude could come to us. That's one reason I chose this neighborhood. Please protect the integrity of Vanderbilt Beach and don't allow this project to open the flood gates of over development in this area. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, Anne E. Eckhart, Esq. From: Anita Cariati To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Sunday, January 10, 2021 3:26:03 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: Ellen Gilmore To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Wednesday, January 6, 2021 1:09:35 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Roaer Dolden To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Tuesday, January 5, 2021 8:11:58 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. Roger Dolden I agree that some form of development is warranted at the Naples One corner, but the scale, density and set back proposed would be destructive to this neighborhood and to Naples as a whole. From: Thelma Giamoaoa To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Saturday, January 2, 2021 7:55:25 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: Catherine Lusk To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 7:16:23 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, Catherine Lusk From: Judi Mudarri To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 3:11:08 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, Judith Mudarri From: George and Kristine Sayrafe To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 11:41:46 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: Judi Loisi To: TavlorPenny Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 11:30:12 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: Judi To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 11:28:12 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: Judi To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 11:25:07 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Colleen Hoolev To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 11:13:00 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: kav barton To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 10:12:08 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: Joe Garaano To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 10:10:49 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, joe Gargano From: Anne Garaano To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 10:04:15 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, Anne Gargano From: John & Nancy Hogan To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 8:28:05 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. John & Nancy Hogan Residents: 10951 Gulf Shore Dr #202 Naples, Fl. 34108 From: Richard Duarte To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 8:24:40 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: Jill DenHerder To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 7:09:36 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, Jill DenHerder From: Lee Gostomski To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 7:05:09 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Patricia Van Almkerk To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Sunday, December 27, 2020 10:31:54 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Joseph Falasco To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Thursday, December 24, 2020 7:03:14 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, Joseph Falasco From: Linda Cifani To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Thursday, December 24, 2020 7:02:08 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, Linda Cifani From: Philip Dobbs To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Wednesday, December 23, 2020 11:17:13 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Michele Tamarkin To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Wednesday, December 23, 2020 8:52:04 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. M. Tamarkin From: Paul A Cullis To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Wednesday, December 23, 2020 7:50:53 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. Paul Cullis MD From: Peter Smith To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Tuesday, December 22, 2020 3:27:24 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Kim Jacob To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Tuesday, December 22, 2020 2:23:29 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Judi Loisi To: TavlorPenny Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Tuesday, December 22, 2020 12:30:48 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: William Schuman To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Sunday, December 20, 2020 5:36:04 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: John Bamberaer To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Saturday, December 19, 2020 3:49:56 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Don Wilber To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Saturday, December 19, 2020 1:22:07 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. Don Wilber From: kim W. Suchv To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Saturday, December 19, 2020 10:00:37 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I really want to preserve the sanctity of the neighborhood! I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. Kim W. Suchy From: Bob Karll To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Saturday, December 19, 2020 9:04:39 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Patti Krug To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, December 18, 2020 5:25:04 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Michael Elleman To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, December 18, 2020 2:51:05 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. Michael Elleman From: Don Nealon To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Tuesday, January 12, 2021 10:36:47 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Don Nealon To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Tuesday, January 12, 2021 10:36:47 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Anita Cariati To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Sunday, January 10, 2021 3:26:03 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: Justine Cifani To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Thursday, December 24, 2020 7:04:21 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. I PLEAD WITH YOU TO DO WHAT THE PEOPLE WANT AND VOTE AGAINST THIS PROJECT!! In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, Justine Cifani From: David Darlina To: TaylorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, December 18, 2020 2:31:11 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, David Darling 5 Bluebill Ave Apt 406 From: Kim Freedman To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood and One Naples Date: Monday, February 15, 2021 3:17:22 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has amendment to the Growth Management Plan. I know you have received many, many emails about this project so I will be brief. This project is just too big for the site in so many ways. I live diagonally across from the proposed site and already traffic is very difficult in this area during high season. The project offers very little, if anything that would benefit the neighborhood. Maybe a coffee/sandwich shop would be there, all other amenities will be for residents only. Please do not let Stock Development build something for their financial gain that will have such a negative impact on the neighborhood. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. From: Hanley Kanar To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood and please don't turn Naples into a Miami wannabe Date: Thursday, February 11, 2021 12:52:17 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: Dear Commissioner Solis: I am sending the prewritten letter opposing the Stock One Development project One Naples because it does a good job delineating the main issues, but I want to add a personal note as well. One of the most appealing things about Naples is that it has an old Floridian beauty about it, with lovely smaller buildings and a walkable neighborhood feel, and Vanderbilt Beach is a perfect jewel. The two buildings and either side of the proposed towers are smaller and set back a great deal, allowing better and nicer beach access. The proposed monstrosity is planned for the area, surrounding Daruma and right along S. Bay Dr. and Vanderbilt Beach Road will hog the waterfront block views and hamper access. Both of these are set back quite a distance from the road, particularly the Ritz. This project is actually much closer geographically than either the Beechmoor or Ritz and would set a new precedent for density, bleeding over into virtually every future project for the county. On March 1 you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. Frankly, knowing how much opposition there is to the project's design, I am amazed that this is a hard decision for you. From what I understand of your logic, you feel that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that you, alone, know what is good for us. When you tell people, `Be careful what you wish for." you are saying that we don't know what we are asking. I assure you that we do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning, and I am asking you to vote to deny his proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan. I cannot be more direct. You have for too long and for too often voted to allow developers to run slipshod over the wishes of your taxpaying constituents. It must stop! I will be watching and listening on March 1 st to hold your feet to the fire. Please don't "33234" Naples to death. Please don't "33234" this beautiful and distinctive area. I am watching and I have a long memory and I vote. Sincerely, Hanley Kanar From: Kathryn McCaffery To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Beachwalk Date: Sunday, January 3, 2021 8:28:09 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, kathryn McCaffery From: Patrick McCaffery sr To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Beachwalk Date: Thursday, January 14, 2021 7:43:34 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, Patrick M McCaffery sr From: Kathryn McCaffery To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Beachwalk Date: Sunday, January 3, 2021 8:28:09 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, kathryn McCaffery From: Patrick McCaffery sr To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Beachwalk Date: Thursday, January 14, 2021 7:43:34 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, Patrick M McCaffery sr From: Judi Loisi To: TavlorPenny Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood district 2 Date: Sunday, February 14, 2021 8:51:42 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. From: Anita Cariati To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Sunday, January 10, 2021 3:26:03 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: Ted & Betty Ziemann To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Wednesday, December 23, 2020 12:54:43 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, Ted & Betty Ziemann From: Robert Duquette To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Saturday, December 19, 2020 11:54:29 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: m To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Saturday, December 19, 2020 2:23:10 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: Susan Walters To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Saturday, December 19, 2020 1:01:18 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. Susan Walters From: Robert L Moore To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, December 18, 2020 10:56:49 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Miguel E. Lopez To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, December 18, 2020 5:10:57 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Dee paul To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, December 18, 2020 3:46:56 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Muriel Longlade To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, December 18, 2020 3:45:52 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: David Darlina To: TaylorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, December 18, 2020 2:31:11 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, David Darling 5 Bluebill Ave Apt 406 From: Anita Cariati To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Sunday, January 10, 2021 3:26:03 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: marta meda To: TaylorPenny Subject: Vanderbilt Neighborhood Date: Thursday, January 28, 2021 5:52:56 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor, It appears that the gov't website patched a form letter to you rather than my personal letter, so I'm resending it via my email account. I am a full time resident of Naples who has witnessed 25 years of growth and development in Collier County. As the county's population has mushroomed from 71,000 to nearly 400,000 residents in that time, what has become abundantly clear to me is how critical it is that our elected county commissioners make sound, insightful and responsible decisions in determining how expansion within our county is done. There are no 'do-overs' when it comes to what's at stake near the main entrance onto Vanderbilt Beach. This decision that you're making as county commissioners will forever impact this unique parcel of land and its' beach - surrounded neighborhood. This point cannot be overstated. Stock Development is solely interested in maximizing investors' profits regardless of how it impacts our community and county residents. Wanting to over -build and over -populate the critical location leading up to the entrance to our beach means profits over people and based on expert studies, it would forever negatively impact thousands of residents and visitors. Brian Stock made a substantial financial investment in this parcel of land knowing full well that the property purchased wasn't zoned for the project he wants to build. Who does that? My sister has been in the surveying business for 30 years in NYS and has never encountered such a tactic. What's even more unsettling is that Mr. Stock continues to spend thousands upon thousands of dollars advertising One Naples as a 172 resident complex in magazines as if it's a done deal. What does that imply? Is it false advertising or is he 100% convinced that he already has enough commissioners to push his lucrative project through? Mr. Stocks actions seem dismissive, as if he's going to bulldoze right over the existing zoning that was put in place decades ago to protect us and it worries me whether a bona fide ethical process still exists with regards to responsible development in this county. My final point is that, in evaluating all of the information presented by both sides, taking into consideration all of the facts presented by both Stock and our Save Vanderbilt group, the Collier County Planning Board COULD NOT in good conscience give their approval to recommend Stock's development plans and rezoning request to you as commissioners. This should speak volumes to you and the clear message is: "This is the wrong project for the wrong piece of land. " Please do not force an inappropriate project on our neighborhood. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Marta Meda 364 Seagull Ave. Naples, FL From: marta meda To: TaylorPenny Subject: Vanderbilt Neighborhood Date: Thursday, January 28, 2021 5:52:56 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor, It appears that the gov't website patched a form letter to you rather than my personal letter, so I'm resending it via my email account. I am a full time resident of Naples who has witnessed 25 years of growth and development in Collier County. As the county's population has mushroomed from 71,000 to nearly 400,000 residents in that time, what has become abundantly clear to me is how critical it is that our elected county commissioners make sound, insightful and responsible decisions in determining how expansion within our county is done. There are no 'do-overs' when it comes to what's at stake near the main entrance onto Vanderbilt Beach. This decision that you're making as county commissioners will forever impact this unique parcel of land and its' beach - surrounded neighborhood. This point cannot be overstated. Stock Development is solely interested in maximizing investors' profits regardless of how it impacts our community and county residents. Wanting to over -build and over -populate the critical location leading up to the entrance to our beach means profits over people and based on expert studies, it would forever negatively impact thousands of residents and visitors. Brian Stock made a substantial financial investment in this parcel of land knowing full well that the property purchased wasn't zoned for the project he wants to build. Who does that? My sister has been in the surveying business for 30 years in NYS and has never encountered such a tactic. What's even more unsettling is that Mr. Stock continues to spend thousands upon thousands of dollars advertising One Naples as a 172 resident complex in magazines as if it's a done deal. What does that imply? Is it false advertising or is he 100% convinced that he already has enough commissioners to push his lucrative project through? Mr. Stocks actions seem dismissive, as if he's going to bulldoze right over the existing zoning that was put in place decades ago to protect us and it worries me whether a bona fide ethical process still exists with regards to responsible development in this county. My final point is that, in evaluating all of the information presented by both sides, taking into consideration all of the facts presented by both Stock and our Save Vanderbilt group, the Collier County Planning Board COULD NOT in good conscience give their approval to recommend Stock's development plans and rezoning request to you as commissioners. This should speak volumes to you and the clear message is: "This is the wrong project for the wrong piece of land. " Please do not force an inappropriate project on our neighborhood. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Marta Meda 364 Seagull Ave. Naples, FL From: Roaer Dolden To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Tuesday, January 5, 2021 8:11:58 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. Roger Dolden I agree that some form of development is warranted at the Naples One corner, but the scale, density and set back proposed would be destructive to this neighborhood and to Naples as a whole. From: Thelma Giamoaoa To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Saturday, January 2, 2021 7:55:25 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: Catherine Lusk To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 7:16:23 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, Catherine Lusk From: Judi Mudarri To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 3:11:08 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, Judith Mudarri From: George and Kristine Sayrafe To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 11:41:46 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: Judi Loisi To: TavlorPenny Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 11:30:12 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: Judi To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 11:28:12 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: Judi To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 11:25:07 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Colleen Hoolev To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 11:13:00 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: kav barton To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 10:12:08 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: Joe Garaano To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 10:10:49 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, joe Gargano From: Anne Garaano To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 10:04:15 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, Anne Gargano From: John & Nancy Hogan To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 8:28:05 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. John & Nancy Hogan Residents: 10951 Gulf Shore Dr #202 Naples, Fl. 34108 From: Richard Duarte To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 8:24:40 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: Jill DenHerder To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 7:09:36 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, Jill DenHerder From: Lee Gostomski To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, January 1, 2021 7:05:09 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Patricia Van Almkerk To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Sunday, December 27, 2020 10:31:54 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Justine Cifani To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Thursday, December 24, 2020 7:04:21 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. I PLEAD WITH YOU TO DO WHAT THE PEOPLE WANT AND VOTE AGAINST THIS PROJECT!! In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, Justine Cifani From: Joseph Falasco To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Thursday, December 24, 2020 7:03:14 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, Joseph Falasco From: Linda Cifani To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Thursday, December 24, 2020 7:02:08 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, Linda Cifani From: Ted & Betty Ziemann To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Wednesday, December 23, 2020 12:54:43 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, Ted & Betty Ziemann From: Philip Dobbs To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Wednesday, December 23, 2020 11:17:13 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Michele Tamarkin To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Wednesday, December 23, 2020 8:52:04 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. M. Tamarkin From: Paul A Cullis To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Wednesday, December 23, 2020 7:50:53 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. Paul Cullis MD From: Peter Smith To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Tuesday, December 22, 2020 3:27:24 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Kim Jacob To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Tuesday, December 22, 2020 2:23:29 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Judi Loisi To: TavlorPenny Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Tuesday, December 22, 2020 12:30:48 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: William Schuman To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Sunday, December 20, 2020 5:36:04 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Robert Duquette To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Saturday, December 19, 2020 11:54:29 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: John Bamberaer To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Saturday, December 19, 2020 3:49:56 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: m To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Saturday, December 19, 2020 2:23:10 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, From: Don Wilber To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Saturday, December 19, 2020 1:22:07 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. Don Wilber From: Susan Walters To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Saturday, December 19, 2020 1:01:18 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. Susan Walters From: kim W. Suchv To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Saturday, December 19, 2020 10:00:37 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I really want to preserve the sanctity of the neighborhood! I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. Kim W. Suchy From: Bob Karll To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Saturday, December 19, 2020 9:04:39 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Robert L Moore To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, December 18, 2020 10:56:49 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Patti Krug To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, December 18, 2020 5:25:04 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Miguel E. Lopez To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, December 18, 2020 5:10:57 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Dee paul To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, December 18, 2020 3:46:56 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Muriel Longlade To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, December 18, 2020 3:45:52 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Michael Elleman To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Friday, December 18, 2020 2:51:05 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. Michael Elleman From: Marta Meda To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Thursday, January 28, 2021 5:40:37 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Mrs. Taylor, I am a full time resident of Naples who has witnessed 25 years of growth and development in Collier County. As the county's population has mushroomed from 71,000 to nearly 400,000 residents in that time, what has become abundantly clear to me is how critical it is that our elected county commissioners make sound, insightful and responsible decisions in determining how expansion within our county is done. There are no `do-overs' when it comes to what's at stake near the main entrance onto Vanderbilt Beach. This decision that you're making as county commissioners will forever impact this unique parcel of land and its' beach -surrounded neighborhood. This point cannot be overstated. Stock Development is solely interested in maximizing investors' profits regardless of how it impacts our community and county residents. Wanting to over -build and over -populate the critical location leading up to the entrance to our beach means profits over people and based on expert studies, it would forever negatively impact thousands of residents and visitors. Brian Stock made a substantial financial investment in this parcel of land knowing full well that the property purchased wasn't zoned for the project he wants to build. Who does that? My sister has been in the surveying business for 30 years in NYS and has never encountered such a tactic. What's even more unsettling is that Mr. Stock continues to spend thousands upon thousands of dollars advertising One Naples as a 172 resident complex in magazines as if it's a done deal. What does that imply? Is it false advertising or is he 100% convinced that he already has enough commissioners to push his lucrative project through? Mr. Stocks actions seem dismissive, as if he's going to bulldoze right over the existing zoning that was put in place decades ago to protect us and it worries me whether a bona fide ethical process still exists with regards to responsible development in this county. My final point is that, in evaluating all of the information presented by both sides, taking into consideration all of the facts presented by both Stock and our Save Vanderbilt group, the Collier County Planning Board COULD NOT in good conscience give their approval to recommend Stock's development plans and rezoning request to you as commissioners. This should speak volumes to you and the clear message is: "This is the wrong project for the wrong piece of land. " Please do not force an inappropriate project on our neighborhood. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Marta Meda 364 Seagull Ave. Naples, Fl From: Rick OBrien To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Tuesday, February 2, 2021 12:14:38 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March I st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. Richard OBrien 586 Beachwalk Circle Unit 105 From: Douolas Weber To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Saturday, February 6, 2021 6:21:10 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. _Douglas Weber From: Beth M Garofalo To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Sunday, February 7, 2021 9:48:32 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. From: Michael Garofalo To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Sunday, February 7, 2021 9:52:58 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. From: Mea Catanzarita To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Monday, February 8, 2021 8:44:00 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. Meg Catanzarita From: ssaltz To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Monday, February 8, 2021 8:58:18 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. s saltz From: Lyn Shirley To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Monday, February 8, 2021 9:00:41 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. lyn Shirley From: Robert Baroer To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Monday, February 8, 2021 9:21:09 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. Robert & Sandra Barger From: Robert Baroer To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Monday, February 8, 2021 10:19:14 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. Bob Barger From: Mary M Ethinaton To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 12:32:13 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March 1 you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I have been coming to Naples in the winters since 1973. When friends of ours from the Midwest talk about where they want to purchase a condo in FL, many are starting to say — not Naples — it has gotten too crowded. By allowing this Stock development to proceed, you will be proving them right! The over -sized buildings will make Vanderbilt Beach Road overly congested and will make the lifestyle we all have come to Naples to enjoy more similar to the congestion we are trying to get away from in our northern cities. Please consider the wishes of the area residents and vote "no" on this proposal. Sincerely, Mary Ethington 7515 Pelican Bay Boulevard From: Mike Hughes To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 4:47:32 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. From: Rosa B To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 8:04:55 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds by of others will be there on March 1 st to support you in making the right decision. _Rosa Barrueto From: Judy zazworsky To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 10:55:19 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March 1 you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I live in the District of the proposed One Naples project and know that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown our opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that we do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March 1 st to support you in making the right decision. Sincerely, Judy Zazworsky From: Paul Bennett To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 11:24:23 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. I do not want to see Naples turn into a Fort Lauderdale or Miami. Naples is distinctly different with our clear skyline. We need to keep it that way. Stick with current C-3 zoning and don't turn us into something we don't want. Sincerely, Paul Bennett From: C A Bruckermann To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 1:50:28 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan Please don't enable the "quick buck" massive -development mentality at the expense of what makes Naples special. Don't urbanize the beach front with this out -of -all -proportions project. Cynthia Bruckermann From: Hugo Paiz To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 5:59:02 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. From: Renee Gauthier To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Wednesday, February 10, 2021 1:58:56 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. Renee Gauthier From: Barbara Rouaraff To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Thursday, February 11, 2021 8:19:08 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today to voice my opposition to the One Naples Project. I realize that there have been a lot of back and forths and compromises by Stock Development, but I still don't think it is enough in line with the current zoning requirements. Thank you, Barbara Rougraff From: Karen Cobin To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Saturday, February 13, 2021 1:32:10 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well this development is not in our District, but I also know that Commissioners typically in favor with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. This should not be and as such I ask that you act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly expressed their opposition. The hundreds of emails that you have received confirms thus, making you fully aware of their position on this matter. It is felt that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. He is quite arrogant in thinking that the residents in his district are not capable of understanding the details surrounding this project, believing that he alone knows what is best. To be quoted as saying `Be careful what you wish for." He is implying his constituents don't know any better. Well rest assured they do understand the ramifications of respecting the existing C-3 zoning. He could stand to take pause and reflect on that. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March 1 st to support you in making the right decision. Karen Cobin From: Kim Suchy To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Sunday, February 14, 2021 7:32:33 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I know you receive countless letters on this matter but please note that there are countless residents who care and would appreciate your steadfastness and vote against this project. On March 1 you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March 1 st to support you in making the right decision. From: Gale Morgan To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Sunday, February 14, 2021 8:07:19 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March 1 you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March 1 st to support you in making the right decision. From: Geoffrion Suzanne To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Sunday, February 14, 2021 8:31:56 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. Suzanne Geoffrion From: Carla Kretschmann To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Sunday, February 14, 2021 8:48:07 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. From: Michael fontana To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Sunday, February 14, 2021 8:55:57 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. From: Steve Valdivia To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Sunday, February 14, 2021 8:56:54 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: We live here and am deeply concerned for the future of the area. The overcrowdedness, the water and air quality but most of all, WHAT IT IS TURNING INTO. On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March 1 st to support you in making the right decision. From: Ken Cowan To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Sunday, February 14, 2021 9:11:52 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. From: Paul R Albv To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Sunday, February 14, 2021 11:31:38 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March 1 you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March 1 st to support you in making the right decision. Paul R. Alby From: dmcardle(cbzrfmlaw. com To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Sunday, February 14, 2021 5:41:22 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. david mcardle From: Theodore J Raia To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Sunday, February 14, 2021 6:04:35 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing in reference to your possible support for the One Naples project. Since retiring to Naples some 25 years ago I have witnessed the operation of development in Collier County. On the surface there is a very impressive Land Development Code. Unfortunately, it is not very effective because the real LDC is what ever the County Commissioners approve. Couple this with the subliminal system that most commissioners will vote to approve any application that is submitted from a district if the commissioner of that district recommends it. This is essentially a quid pro quo, "you approve mine and I will approve yours". Where does this leave the tax paying residents of Collier County. Just as this is one country, our country, — it is one county, our county. The deviations from the LDC for the One Naples project are an insult to the people. The developers claim that he is saving us from a commercial development is farcical. That corner is at the end of a dead-end road. It is not at the intersection of two principal roads. Commercial development there would be to serve the local community and beach goers, something that is more practical but not nearly as profitable. COL (Ret) Ted Raia, USA From: Marian Freund To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Sunday, February 14, 2021 6:40:54 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan There is nothing in Naples One as currently proposed that is in the best interests of your constituents! Marian Freund From: David Freund To: TaylorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Sunday, February 14, 2021 6:48:11 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan You were elected by your constituents to regulate. So "regulate!" Davie Freund From: Jodie Stahl To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Monday, February 15, 2021 8:21:51 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. I assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. Jodie L Stahl From: pat haaaerty To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Monday, February 15, 2021 8:50:46 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. pat haggerty From: Clark Price To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Monday, February 15, 2021 9:44:36 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. As a Beachwalk resident, I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in your District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan Clark Price From: Felix Zulauf To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Monday, February 15, 2021 10:24:25 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March 1 you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan. Would you like to enter the history book as the one who helped to destroy our beautiful neighborhood? I along with hundreds of others will be there on March 1 st to support you in making the right decision. Felix W. Zulauf 8787 Bay Colony Drive NAPLES, FL 34108 From: David Solomon Bloomfield To: TaylorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Monday, February 15, 2021 12:00:39 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. From: Norm Price To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Monday, February 15, 2021 1:02:00 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March 1 you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March 1 st to support you in making the right decision. From: Derald Dosland To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Monday, February 15, 2021 1:21:46 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March 1 you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March 1 st to support you in making the right decision. From: Jeannine moran To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Monday, February 15, 2021 1:48:46 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. From: James D Walker To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Monday, February 15, 2021 3:11:26 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. James Walker From: Becky Ruth Macik To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Monday, February 15, 2021 6:32:25 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. Becky R Macik From: Susan Camino To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Monday, February 15, 2021 7:46:37 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. From: Walter Cami To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Monday, February 15, 2021 7:49:58 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. Walter Camino From: Kathy Pezzuti To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Monday, February 15, 2021 8:20:52 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. From: Wendy Ryan To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Tuesday, February 16, 2021 9:52:58 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. From: Howard Wallin To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Tuesday, February 16, 2021 11:28:56 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March 1 you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March 1 st to support you in making the right decision. Howard Wallin From: Kathy dunne To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Tuesday, February 16, 2021 11:50:20 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March 1 you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. As a full time resident, who lives and exercises in this area, too much development, as proposed by Stock will be detrimental to the environment and people living in and visiting the area. Additionally, as a frontline healthcare worker, I believe that the health of Naples residents will be negatively impacted, if such a development were allowed to be built. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March 1 st to support you in making the right decision. From: Colin Kanar To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood. Please say No. Date: Thursday, February 11, 2021 9:26:30 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March 1 you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I am fully aware this development is not in your District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. I implore you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District, including myself, have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. This includes the residents of condominium complexes whose silence is being bought but Stock in exchange for improvements to their buildings, seawalls and so on. I never expected to hear that such a technique was being used by a respected developers such as Stock. This practice was outlined in a recent article in the Naples Daily News quoting Commissioner Solis as implying this is normal and expected behavior. I know that you are aware of all these matters as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. Unfortunately, I believe, as do many, that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan, despite the overwhelming opposition of the majority in his district. I can only conclude that any commissioner who votes in favor of this project, feels the thousands standing in opposition are not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter, and that the commissioners, alone, know what is good for the District and community. When a commissioner states, `Be careful what you wish for." it implies they believe the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. There are many bright people who oppose this project and I am confident they understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March 1 st to support you in making the right decision. Very Respectfully, Colin Kanar From: Patrick McCaffery sr To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood. Beachwalk Date: Sunday, January 3, 2021 8:12:38 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, _Patrick McCaffery sr From: Patrick McCaffery sr To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood. Beachwalk Date: Sunday, January 3, 2021 8:12:38 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing you today to express my opposition to the Stock Development One Naples as it is currently proposed. I was encouraged by the action of the Planning Commission and their inability to recommend approval not only of the current Stock plan, but of a watered-down version that reduced the outrageous tower heights by almost 25%, and extremely diminished setbacks. They did their job, protecting the community. Now it's your turn. Planning Commissioner Frye said it best when he asked the other Commissioners how they could ignore the outpouring of sentiment from the community. These are your constituents, your voters. Isn't it your responsibility to listen to those who will live with this atrocity for decades to come and to vehemently deny the developer the right to build it? If hundreds of emails exhorting you to deny the project are not enough, if more than eighty people who signed up to speak against the project at the Planning Commission are not enough, if the 1,100 members of Save Vanderbilt Beach, forty percent of whom have contributed more than $100,000 to engage experts and fight the development are not enough, what exactly will be enough to persuade you to do the right thing? Please, when it comes before you, vote to deny the project as it is currently proposed. If you do approve something for the site, and remember we are not opposed to reasonable development, please approve the project with the conditions that your own Planning Staff proposed. They are reasonable and result in a project that is compatible with and complementary to the neighborhood. In hopes of a more reasonable project, I am respectfully, _Patrick McCaffery sr From: Don Nealon To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighborhood Date: Tuesday, January 12, 2021 10:36:47 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: I am writing today in my continued opposition to the One Naples project as proposed. I understand that, at a recent special meeting of the Commissioners, a decision was made to hold the March 1 st hearing at the Commissioners' chamber in the County office building. Because of the COVID-19 virus, and the social distancing it requires, this venue is not conducive to the very large turnout by all those who have an opinion about One Naples, pro or con. I hope that you and your fellow Commissioners will reconsider. Better locations might include St John the Evangelist Church, North Collier County Regional Park, a Collier County School auditorium, or even the Phil at Artis. Thank you for your consideration. From: Richard Dubois To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vanderbilt neighbourhood Stock Development One Naples Date: Monday, February 15, 2021 7:09:14 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor: On March I you and your fellow Commissioners will be hearing Stock Development's application for One Naples. I am writing you today to express my strong opposition to the development as Stock has proposed it. I know full well that this development is not in our District, and that Commissioners generally tend to vote with the Commissioner in whose District the project lies. But, in this case I ask you to act independently. Residents of Commissioner Solis' District have overwhelmingly shown their opposition. I know that you are aware of that as I know that you have received hundreds of emails telling you so. I believe that Commissioner Solis intends to vote in support of the Stock amendment to the Growth Management Plan. His reason for doing so is flawed. He feels that the neighborhood is not capable of understanding the nuances of the matter before you, and that he, alone, knows what is good for his District. When he tells people, `Be careful what you wish for." he is saying that the residents of the affected neighborhood don't know what they are asking. assure you that they do understand the ramifications of asking that Stock respect the existing C-3 zoning. One Naples is not simply a District 2 issue. Its approval would send a message that it's "business as usual," and that the "Miamification" of Collier County will continue. That must stop! I am asking you to vote to deny Stock's proposed amendment to the Growth Management Plan I along with hundreds of others will be there on March I st to support you in making the right decision. Commissionner Taylor, I have been a owner in Naples (Vanderbilt Beach) for at least 40 years and have enjoyed all of what Naples implemented in their rules and building codes ans was enforced for many years by their management plans. I do personally know about all because 23 years ago I built a project on Vanderbilt Beach called Le Dauphin 9811 and 9790 Gulf Shore dr. and had to respect all rules and building codes. (Wish I could have built 18 to 20 stories) One Naples is asking all of you to change all of those rules plus disregarding the recommendations of your group management plan officials.(GMP) One Naples is offering financial incentives to condominium associations to side with them on their project are they that desperate to destroy our community.And are you ready to break all existing rules ?. Please respect all of the GMP recommendations this is all we ask for. You all live in Naples and there was a reason why you chose Naples. I would think they knew the rules when they purchased the individual land for their development. Thank you Richard Dubois From: Katherine Tardio To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Thursday, January 14, 2021 12:22:23 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Please Vote "NO". Since when is offering large sums of money to residents who live nearby to influence their VOTE- legal! That's blackmail! You have to change the Zoning to allow One Naples to proceed. Please Vote "NO". Katie Tardio Bay Colony Resident From: kafralCabaol.com To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Saturday, January 9, 2021 12:40:56 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Please don't ruin another corner of Naples ... think of the little guys for a change!! Katy Serr From: Lester Frank To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Thursday, January 7, 2021 2:41:04 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Please vote no for the latest proposed design. With the proposed population density you'll have to widen Vanderbilt Rd. and Vanderbilt Beach Rd. to six lanes to accommodate the traffic. as far as aesthetics, it is a monstrosity. I am a 22 year voting resident of Barrington Club in Pelican Bay. Thank you for your service. Lester Frank From: Cathy Silver To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Thursday, January 7, 2021 1:34:58 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor, Please vote no for the One Naples project! It will destroy the ambience of the Vanderbilt Beach area. The size and shape of the building is not in keeping with the rest of the area. The increased numbers of people and increased traffic will make an already crowded situation worse. Stock Development will try every ploy to get neighbors to agree to drop opposition to the project. Stock's vision of that area is not the vision shared by area residents. The company is only interested in selling condos and making money. I hope you and the other commissioners will see that this is not a good direction for Collier County and especially the charming Vanderbilt Beach area to take. Stock Development should move their project elsewhere. Please vote no for the One Naples project! Sincerely Cathy Silver From: Pea McCausland To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Thursday, January 7, 2021 12:45:21 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Peg McCausland From: KRISTIN HARVEY To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Thursday, January 7, 2021 11:01:28 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Penny, Please stop the Naples One Project! You cannot get down Vanderbilt Beach Road off 41 without a 15 minuet drive right now and with 300,000 more residents it will be impossible. Please remember that Pelican Bay will put up Gates to prevent people from traveling through PB who are not residents of PB, then what will happen to the overrun of traffic? Please think about us who are born and raised in Naples and have watched out town turn into a Miami. So very Sad! Don't let Stock development ruin the last of North Naples. Thank you, Respectfully, Kristin Harvey From: Diane Reed To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Wednesday, January 6, 2021 8:28:10 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Ms. Taylor, I can't believe this continues to be an issue. When you drive through the Vanderbilt neighborhood it is hard to think that a development the size of the one that Stock has proposed fits in to our community in any way. Unfortunately, in this day and age money seems to carry more weight then the desires of the people who live in the community. Commissioners are elected to represent the majority of the people. It's very clear that the majority of the people do not want a development of this size or without the proper required setbacks. Please listen to the people who live in the neighborhood and will still be here long after Stock has gone. We are a West Coast gulf city with charm and character and have no desire to be a high rise community full of concrete. Please represent us appropriately and listen to our concerns and wishes. Thank you, Diane Reed 450 Launch Circle Regatta Sent from my iPhone From: Nelly Dastain To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Wednesday, January 6, 2021 8:12:41 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. This building looks like the ones you find in Moscow, built after the war. Terribly outfashionned, missing everything one wants to find comming in Naples. Too BIG Nelly Dastain Paris (33) 6 14 6139 65 Naples, FL (1) 347 481 3124 From: sharin kusek To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Wednesday, January 6, 2021 7:00:17 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Hello, Please consider the neighbors of the one Naples proposed development. We care about our neighborhood. We do not want massive buildings built that would bring in people that do not care about anything but why they can buy. This is not the right location for this project. It is the town beach. For all of Collier county. Where are the people from other parts of the county going to go? Delnor Wiggins has limited space. Families from immokolee spending a day at the beach will be replaced by people from chicago and nyc. The expected million plus dollar price tag of the condos does not represent the people of the general neighborhood surrounding Vanderbilt beach. Naples park. Regatta, Beach walk, Bear foot pelican. Check the town records to see what the neighborhood real estate sells for. Do not include waterfront. You'll see how out of character with the neighborhood this proposal is. This will definitely bring down the value of regatta and bear foot pelican property. This project is offensive to many of us. We know it will bring in taxes. But that should not be at our expense. Thank you Sharin and Paul Kusek 400 flagship drive Naples. Florida From: Rosemary Pace To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Wednesday, January 6, 2021 6:48:39 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. No! Rosemary Pace Sent from my iPhone From: Ruth Lennon To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Wednesday, January 6, 2021 6:23:45 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. From: Ruthann McCarty To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Wednesday, January 6, 2021 6:11:22 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Sent from my iPhone From: Jackie Corbett To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Tuesday, December 22, 2020 5:59:52 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. NO ! From: Brennan, Michael To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Saturday, December 19, 2020 9:28:25 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Ms. Taylor, I live at 9653 Gulf Shore Dr. Naples and have a strong opposition to the proposed Stock development at Vanderbilt and Gulf Shore Dr. The scope of their proposal will very adversely effect the area and I think anyone looking at it will know it will adversarial effect current property owners. Please do the right thing and make Stock Development reduce their proposal to conform with the current community zoning plans. Mike Brennan 630/767-7600 Sent from my iPad From: Katherine Tardio To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Thursday, January 14, 2021 12:22:23 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Please Vote "NO". Since when is offering large sums of money to residents who live nearby to influence their VOTE- legal! That's blackmail! You have to change the Zoning to allow One Naples to proceed. Please Vote "NO". Katie Tardio Bay Colony Resident From: kafralCabaol.com To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Saturday, January 9, 2021 12:40:56 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Please don't ruin another corner of Naples ... think of the little guys for a change!! Katy Serr From: Lester Frank To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Thursday, January 7, 2021 2:41:04 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Please vote no for the latest proposed design. With the proposed population density you'll have to widen Vanderbilt Rd. and Vanderbilt Beach Rd. to six lanes to accommodate the traffic. as far as aesthetics, it is a monstrosity. I am a 22 year voting resident of Barrington Club in Pelican Bay. Thank you for your service. Lester Frank From: Cathy Silver To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Thursday, January 7, 2021 1:34:58 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Commissioner Taylor, Please vote no for the One Naples project! It will destroy the ambience of the Vanderbilt Beach area. The size and shape of the building is not in keeping with the rest of the area. The increased numbers of people and increased traffic will make an already crowded situation worse. Stock Development will try every ploy to get neighbors to agree to drop opposition to the project. Stock's vision of that area is not the vision shared by area residents. The company is only interested in selling condos and making money. I hope you and the other commissioners will see that this is not a good direction for Collier County and especially the charming Vanderbilt Beach area to take. Stock Development should move their project elsewhere. Please vote no for the One Naples project! Sincerely Cathy Silver From: Pea McCausland To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Thursday, January 7, 2021 12:45:21 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Peg McCausland From: KRISTIN HARVEY To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Thursday, January 7, 2021 11:01:28 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Penny, Please stop the Naples One Project! You cannot get down Vanderbilt Beach Road off 41 without a 15 minuet drive right now and with 300,000 more residents it will be impossible. Please remember that Pelican Bay will put up Gates to prevent people from traveling through PB who are not residents of PB, then what will happen to the overrun of traffic? Please think about us who are born and raised in Naples and have watched out town turn into a Miami. So very Sad! Don't let Stock development ruin the last of North Naples. Thank you, Respectfully, Kristin Harvey From: Diane Reed To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Wednesday, January 6, 2021 8:28:10 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Ms. Taylor, I can't believe this continues to be an issue. When you drive through the Vanderbilt neighborhood it is hard to think that a development the size of the one that Stock has proposed fits in to our community in any way. Unfortunately, in this day and age money seems to carry more weight then the desires of the people who live in the community. Commissioners are elected to represent the majority of the people. It's very clear that the majority of the people do not want a development of this size or without the proper required setbacks. Please listen to the people who live in the neighborhood and will still be here long after Stock has gone. We are a West Coast gulf city with charm and character and have no desire to be a high rise community full of concrete. Please represent us appropriately and listen to our concerns and wishes. Thank you, Diane Reed 450 Launch Circle Regatta Sent from my iPhone From: Nelly Dastain To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Wednesday, January 6, 2021 8:12:41 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. This building looks like the ones you find in Moscow, built after the war. Terribly outfashionned, missing everything one wants to find comming in Naples. Too BIG Nelly Dastain Paris (33) 6 14 6139 65 Naples, FL (1) 347 481 3124 From: sharin kusek To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Wednesday, January 6, 2021 7:00:17 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Hello, Please consider the neighbors of the one Naples proposed development. We care about our neighborhood. We do not want massive buildings built that would bring in people that do not care about anything but why they can buy. This is not the right location for this project. It is the town beach. For all of Collier county. Where are the people from other parts of the county going to go? Delnor Wiggins has limited space. Families from immokolee spending a day at the beach will be replaced by people from chicago and nyc. The expected million plus dollar price tag of the condos does not represent the people of the general neighborhood surrounding Vanderbilt beach. Naples park. Regatta, Beach walk, Bear foot pelican. Check the town records to see what the neighborhood real estate sells for. Do not include waterfront. You'll see how out of character with the neighborhood this proposal is. This will definitely bring down the value of regatta and bear foot pelican property. This project is offensive to many of us. We know it will bring in taxes. But that should not be at our expense. Thank you Sharin and Paul Kusek 400 flagship drive Naples. Florida From: Rosemary Pace To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Wednesday, January 6, 2021 6:48:39 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. No! Rosemary Pace Sent from my iPhone From: Ruth Lennon To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Wednesday, January 6, 2021 6:23:45 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. From: Ruthann McCarty To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Wednesday, January 6, 2021 6:11:22 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Sent from my iPhone From: Jackie Corbett To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Tuesday, December 22, 2020 5:59:52 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. NO ! From: Brennan, Michael To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Saturday, December 19, 2020 9:28:25 AM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. Dear Ms. Taylor, I live at 9653 Gulf Shore Dr. Naples and have a strong opposition to the proposed Stock development at Vanderbilt and Gulf Shore Dr. The scope of their proposal will very adversely effect the area and I think anyone looking at it will know it will adversarial effect current property owners. Please do the right thing and make Stock Development reduce their proposal to conform with the current community zoning plans. Mike Brennan 630/767-7600 Sent from my iPad From: Patricia Weber To: TavlorPennv Subject: Vote NO on One Naples Date: Friday, January 15, 2021 9:10:45 PM EXTERNAL EMAIL: This email is from an external source. Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening attachments or clicking links. We are the owners of 577 Beachwalk Circle We've paid Collier County taxes since 1986 and have seen many changes take place on Vanderbilt Beach Road and Gulfview Dr. over the years. The Stock proposed development, in our opinion, is totally capable of ruining a beautiful beach and the community that has long enjoyed the public access to it. Please vote NO . Thank you, Patricia and Douglas Weber Sent from my iPhone