Loading...
HEX Final Decision 2020-24 HEX NO. 2020-24 HEARING EXAMINER DECISION DATE OF HEARING. November 12, 2020 PETITION. PETITION NO. PDI-PL20200001265 — Addison Commercial Corner, LLC requests an insubstantial change to the Addies Corner MPUD, Ordinance No. 11-08, for a sign deviation from LDC Section 5.06.04.F.4.to allow a maximum of two (2)wall signs for end units within shopping centers and multiple-occupancy parcels , or single occupancy parcels where there is double frontage on a public right-of-way,to allow Parcel 1 two(2)additional wall signs for a total of four (4) wall signs, and Parcel 3 one (1) additional wall sign for a total of three (3) wall signs. This deviation only applies to Tract A of the MPUD as shown on Exhibit C-1.The subject property consists of 4.44 acres, in the northwest quadrant of the intersection of Immokalee Road (CR 846) and Collier Boulevard (CR 951) in Section 22, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida. STAFF RECOMMENDATION. Approval with conditions. FINDINGS. 1. The public hearing for this Petition was properly noticed and conducted in accordance with all County and state requirements. 2. The public hearing was conducted electronically and in-person in accordance with Emergency/Executive Order 2020-04. 3. The Petitioner and/or Petitioner's representative executed the Hybrid Virtual Quasi-Judicial Public Hearing Waiver related to conducting the public hearing electronically and in-person. 4. The Petitioner and/or Petitioner's representative presented the Petition, followed by County staff and then public comment. ANALYSIS. Based on a review of the record including the Petition, application, exhibits, the County's staff report, and hearing comments and testimony from the Petitioner and/or the Petitioner's representative(s), County staff and any given by the public,the Hearing Examiner finds that there Page 1 of 3 is sufficient competent, substantial evidence as applied to the criteria set forth in Sections 10.02.13.E.1 and 10.02.13.E.2. of the Land Development Code to approve Petition. DECISION. The Hearing Examiner hereby APPROVES Petition Number PDI-PL20200001265, filed by Lindsay F.Robin,MPA of Waldrop Engineering, P.A. representing Addison Commercial Corner, LLC f/k/a WMG Development, LLC, with respect to the property as described in the Mixed Use Planned Unit Development(MPUD), Ordinance No. 2011-08, for the following: • An insubstantial change to the Addies Corner MPUD, Ordinance No. 11-08, for a sign deviation from LDC Section 5.06.04.F.4 to allow a maximum of two(2)wall signs for end units within shopping centers and multiple-occupancy parcels,or single occupancy parcels where there is double frontage on a public right-of-way,to allow Parcel 1 two(2)additional wall signs for a total of four(4)wall signs, and Parcel 3 one (1) additional wall sign for a total of three (3)wall signs. This deviation only applies to Tract A of the MPUD. Said changes are fully described in the Updated MPUD Master Plan attached as Exhibit "A", Addie's Corner Wall Sign Site Plan attached as Exhibit "B", Chick-fil-A Wall Sign Site Plan attached as Exhibit "C", Aldi Wall Sign Site Plan attached as Exhibit "D", and are subject to the condition(s) set forth below. ATTACHMENTS. Exhibit A—Updated MPUD Master Plan Exhibit B—Addies Corner Wall Sign Site Plan Exhibit C—Chick-fil-A Wall Sign Site Plan Exhibit D—Aldi Wall Sign Site Plan LEGAL DESCRIPTION. See Ordinance No. 2011-08 CONDITIONS. 1. All other applicable state or federal permits must be obtained before commencement of the development. DISCLAIMER. Pursuant to Section 125.022(5)F.S.,issuance of a development permit by a county does not in any way create any rights on the part of the applicant to obtain a permit from a state or federal agency and does not create any liability on the part of the county for issuance of the permit if the applicant fails to obtain requisite approvals or fulfill the obligations imposed by a state or federal agency or undertakes actions that result in a violation of state or federal law. Page 2 of 3 APPEALS. This decision becomes effective on the date it is rendered. Pursuant to Ordinance 2013-25, as amended, a Hearing Examiner Decision may be appealed to the Board of County Commissioners or the Board of Zoning Appeals, as appropriate. Appeals must be filed within 30 days of the date the Hearing Examiner Decision is rendered. RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS AND EXHIBITS: SEE CLERK OF COURT, MINUTES AND RECORDS DEPARTMENT. DECISIONS OF THE HEARING EXAMINER FOR VARIANCES, CONDITIONAL USES, AND BOAT DOCK EXTENSIONS SHALL BE NOTED ON THE ZONING MAP FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES. id.9.) 61-------- November 23, 2020 Date Andrew Dickman, Esq., AICP Hearing Examiner Page 3 of 3 EXHIBIT "A" p . .WI.. ..N..o..e..ww m....m OR"-.a+w..M-..A?..^'^Oly, 1 t 'i 1 [ �� a� W4111; w QJ U e(n PLATEAU ROAD FUTURE COLLIER BOULEVARD XT VS ON COLLIER BOULEVARD R. cn w I � z v a c u 5o:w W •W .e mu 3< N E a w m Vx0 w w - -I COLU f ra 0 w� D_ 0 n s W K o V IQ W ) .1 re w §z wz p g0 w C LL C2 5 E _ - t I-` GoLL W aCO W R NM MkI 1 `— — 1.11 Osfn I I •ou I .1_ Sz w 1 \ z Wm - co IIfl11r O wc < I ! 1 a.7 3 0 ' a I &IZ 0 in .0. N0 '- I 1 jaw ,-, Z o p to g oW I a OO Q / I z� w 0O 00a 0 = LL ` U @ F �- \ p v. I I a �p p m 2 , o : W Q I_1 9 . CC> • 1. w a� Z 0 7 W I • m> Wm - i 0 jZ x w0 , , X0. c �/ u I ` 3 � I CO et. • b a ~ -•, L- IKLIN3WV \ - I 6„ ' LILL i € w Z F . §?IZ 5 o ID et Q0w Dm <ao z ww Z-' I c •� '`- D. fOg wuW, wLL w o w aLL o< c ,. W 27dr� �m �m �m �u�� w� wm z�3 I e L LL WW ww0 0. 5,Wci. ww WyvOw CC(1) oa wW I 1 - -,,� wa V 3O12 §< b , ° NZd o �=o OFwoD- ;.,o b o � o g8za F U0 0 oZ K z <z 4-3 gg x U N 0p I gngw - •c 5°W i+ 38 I Oo U �1 .1FE o ` O. o ��j3 D V) VI-� IN _1 0 00 W O I- W m Z N O Z i:�: J. yea >.a;aQ Ux 0 Zw� Q7 aOLLQ QZ Jn r pse a ix Q r 0 ' Q Z 0 y W p l- W O W O J u_ J J t'� �R�ir Z�NOfo o.N u. O 0°Da()Z �ZN�Ua W►=~>zp ¢� '°cov.. co- 0Mw— x x �.., a, O ~ �WWmco HOzwwo•,_ <Z0p mm N^ 1 0 �VUUwWCC O :W .r -Ipz zQ2mDLL1—pWceu�NzO �. n WwW O¢Q �mULri WOW -O-1Z° ZOWaNO F-m cLzgF ua'U F•MWX NH9VQ¢ 2 W mW� OyLLLLO JLL� wWO� NWmt) } <0< Z°,��¢+I.i� 0mU o> ��-aJ QOOd �(�WC7 VwFtwn �Qj • M+IM M' . I""Y •N 2LLQ ii +1 NubLLWJs 1- 2 a'00~¢ DR'O_1d¢V C)O cc! W�. ' LLc.,jO , 7 OF--N -Qw > a z w 0 DEL N NON �F�O�F-V 2ON wMzM i2w-ci0 0 O z IL CC 0 W¢ p m W F H Vl Z x W u. a ¢ �qQ�¢��a z Hz a� O �ui ¢UQ�cW7� -ac$ C9 m 6z¢ �t auwln w ��W- oo C) gwwz¢ �mW w z K byQ Z -�N o -1paN MM cAOmoF-pz >Vuwiw N a ww3x¢UW �p�W�Qa VO H p HL Ii ! d ¢Zg� Z cc= W ~ x OQ I-oU¢>gin Way o w a OcACw zAm�a Q��W j VD 0 �001 WOW-wCCw 1_201_ O F-in O 1Ozco N zzoLu� upmp m uW m IA °Sw W OW2mQD §C)WI a §K O O N 0 LL Z m 0¢n.>m I- I- I- 0 0 N ai EXHIBIT " B " . "1""flJ wmn swa«war uuw.uru nin r vwrrrv�w um�we wu�nru�u L..... wwrmrw 1181HX3'4O11V007 7VIN3N NDIS 11VA1 I-D IIHIHX1 x 9N11133N19N3 UfldIAI IIIN1IOD S.HIQQV dQO,UlVM S13WOD M.N1100 N3d SIA3I OZOZROSO Y SNOISI,%Ali Ndld y g = 9 c 0 J z ♦ Y 3 w 0 Q\ a rn rn LL X H 40 I--- N w rn � Z rr N z Z J aw U to h S J J J Q Q • 3 i. _ . . w M:t.: U at cn W a cn QS a 0 y N: ,_ ,u:--- iii illesi 1\1\1\i\ 12 x 4 i�'4 . z CO U ce M w LL w �JJ L u. ittle55 r+rL— —;r 1 3S 061.9 I , u. co 3AI2I0 301rld NOSIOOV e- f5:== `o Jy 6MP'Z01031.006S1 L%sueld lueun3ldeiN uopeool AS leueV 103-10o'69t 0311g11x3-s6uwteJ0Nesodoid IOd(iewo0 sappy)100-6911{slaelOJd+.8 EXHIBIT " C" uI Z v I . I F- Q H 0. I Q .� -- -- A.,m. -- �s V Y o Alla a .m. -- `— I fix+ - CF • • l ( o qlElajl ©- f`�I 1■■ I / g; o I st• ® iI Y : NEp! - ; - ",IR MINI, . � IR 1y o 0 m 11 S o ).../. I ) 1 1 II1I1U ! _ o ■■:,.- ey ®�w■ ►4 ►AJ Ig _ j GSA "'''1—T! %I ti CUSTOM O' INO I .1 aIL I I iI I' \ I ram,,, I � i �-.��. ,� - \ I 11 1,1-�,r® %■ ■■� j I I i �rg�ti�C� �_ i Ii, \ t _1 \� 3AR10 33Mld NOSIOOY i' y�„' ' ` _ _I I 1 1 = W o a $ d < o o po o N N N Z 01 t0 o m m m 5 in a a,6' L TT N t- N N .•' .- N N 1- ,- 11 C 10 L LC 111. �' E c c p q c 2 - 's o 0 8' Si 9t n a d o W S 3 a o 1A 1A 1A O1 0 .- ^ N L O� Y M 01 c Z rn JQ a n t 0. 0. o p y� G c 8 to `�i w v v t 0 c O 9 i �` a Z,g%s oI . . . . a C0 a1 a a Z a P E m - o z v 7 N C C C C a1 m "0 O 0 0 7 a 3 N y ap M o rn rn o1 rn x S G1 Ut V1 O V m m L^ °' in in in in 1. 0. g C = = = = . . . . . I- I- C C M 01 i 3 3 3 3 0 $ 8 o 0 0 0 1 8 s ,„ V.-- N an _ LLI 1 w < oo V o w E y y J 2 Z 0 a\ 2 = V LL > ''� Y-. ET. J h _ II b k . . 0 ) w ■ 01 P § r.l,!!; ! §|!E . : \/\» | . g; \ /� 2I=�- f>{;;|§ I ■■" 4 41 / 3 2 .4|• _0 \/\@ !g&!!§ / /If \f r -- f7;q;#Al 1— |!■■■■ °-°° . a IT |k \ . , ; |I!�®: fit ■ WI + _ £ i Es a & I .... ' 5 § =— �: % S d - - • . ! ff | _ �� . ! ! " - - - ¥ ! ! ! i d `3 . : .- E _ a a \� \ / \/ § . 922 /m% • $ ii , _ J G • LU k IH ƒ \ - ` . ^ �i / \ } § § \ 9 §7 : . ..le"I o< .8 z�m� . . T & e ` ` 16/ S Q [5d $ ) . . ,LaCi ) . $ $ \ \ w & o § 2 .d:> -111 LU VI t £3 . § .1111 § cc I o \� Ei / �y / �. / • \J� , \ ity § § I § • - �,� § 0 L710 ' • 0 j z b .. ) z �- _ ) § § § I Q i _ ° & 7 ¢ - § / SZ @Zk § � | ; -. k � k dj 2§ , ) i• � / \ k § � / k§ co, § co x2 0 � § . ` 2 4 ) S ! | I ! ■ • 2 / \ ik \ ! i ! : Aems| dui ¥ ` � § ° Om M O 0 \ $ a �, Coi \ \ ' , r _w0 k •§!,�| 4 z , k if y,§ q ! z &� 1 � ! § -@ % k) ) § ) 7% !| • & [ 3©kJ � ' . % ▪§§ \ ���# o— / ■/§ = Ik k� / _ ' ' \\\} ; $0$K ■§ §� j `| || a a `- §\ &§ - 3 2§-z 2£ ;O K ■ |� /�( " ,z vzlz �:/`gym z I d. �: \ k)q§)kk k■§kk§ a.m L. 0 vi_ ,- \ dna R Lj zdkka ril ' [ ' «) 77dd§ o � � §eece-' \\ \ �woom [ � ] co °°(kk { x \ §§�/§ e k - § §§��; _ z �� 2 . 2y $ � ( . § � zzj� 0 § @ . \ / ( ] 2 » 2 q § .rz2§ E � 7 a e . wa6 tow §/a_!2 §. • cc u Lu2 \ j zz 0 � } u,.ka3§. VI - \ } / k ƒ 9w 7 ; 0 ow - 5 }\0.�/\ c, < wee - < — 0 � « , > 'lice §» § � , w ? - - « u � ! _ § $ 0.9 .9 z 1 -I © ! ! liJi $ / T ) } & / § § [ e l•;.--- Ii.m ■ . | I gD $ 2= O - 0 o " ` < / i z1 � § z • 6 - z 2 ' § f 04 a < < ' , - j ) 2 e : 7ii m 1w !ai■ { #-�| , flRi E o .a. j© e -1 §§ z\ 0 - V1 \}e \ 0 §§2 ))u§3 § § �| }\)f z r #Gkwlma &,f 2 2 , V ) § k\ $ O � d2 § L = )t «k# di WvM§§ 2r \ i2 § § flU a `D=w0< z»77 . « �1 §f ;=g ?. v2cC§ 'wzAso-}§§}( W {. . EXHIBIT " D " 1iII. .. ' Rt•1i"' 'I',' ,f,Yt^) L N p Jpa�,j N i ter,rri4 '—il GI 3k SA s w • y 2 j Iry al ' !! / MI E fit' i1H " N 8 Ll•+ 41- t Ii0 1- 40- -40- * . 4 _.- [1.. ION. �' U f i .a �I ° O .01 �:. rlp.: ,41IiI '/0 rza4 9:119 ' I`° T--- u Al O IIIIIIIII,I, ,1,1,11,11'1'1;1;1 "'I41,1 ,1 O ;piro,.,.I t ,I; I, 4 O :,, 1,,, • ,yen, t-, [ 1,II 0 I 41 -h44�i4 T 1� I ° 11 1',I i i,il,i,i,i, LLLI ll kW I�ION. F['1 , 0 ill t1111111 I11,1 I i :� 1.'11I11I3IlI ,1,,1�1 M e- Ild . I II�I,, r III 0 8'+ .} A�� IC- , • ' tll 1 Lit{I 1 - b IAA• .. 1 _ ?;•':, } Il III , . , F':' .,.I I I , - ,llo .. a • '}:, I•r, I hh�l 1 t , '. 'I Ig , I' .., yiiiiirii " ,U iiti° ',vih I II1iilliiil' 0 i 11 :,o, I; ;II111r :L i „s: I ill I i 3 �® I 1 I rt I A. o : . A I�i °• + o > Q a I_,I 1 N o i r _1 t : Y W :'I, 1 N I' 'n l', 1r^l o t rti 11 0� .,rol I,1, 1,.,.,.,"," 44 �, 161,111 1® P 'I a1 0It1,; I •ii.,,, . li„1.,:, 9 li Z r ' 1 gg p 11 �i1e a t 1 i 2 1 F t Y s 11i ^' 11! Y` a y 2 ii a -, t i i i F 0 �� ii Lb_ ; I/ it zt a i1 it 91 11 1 ,� t B , s rill Y 4+ ti g l lit 1, f s lith1t1 iN N • 11131e i' I • , ¢ J1! PI!ijik , 1iisi - x6t 3 jbltl1p �`►► ' fit' II)II j Niiiii ! ,; ii -• i ;I' 1-1)) t3M1-111-1.-0 tki '111 ii IT ill I o. Kit.,, el ORIOld