Agenda 11/10/2020 Item #16A 5 (Resolution - FEDP Application)16.A.5
11/10/2020
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to approve a Resolution supporting the County's applications to Florida
Department of Environmental Protection for Long Range Budget Plan Requests for Beach
Renourishment Projects for Fiscal Year 2021/2022. This action maintains the County's eligibility
for State Cost Share Funding for future renourishment projects.
OBJECTIVE: To approve a Resolution supporting the County's applications to the Florida Department
of Environmental Protection (FDEP) for Long Range Budget Plan Requests for Fiscal Year 2021/2022.
CONSIDERATIONS: Coastal Zone Management continues to seek funding from FDEP to augment
existing tourist taxes that have been budgeted for these projects. These requests, if approved by FDEP,
will provide partial funding for Collier County projects as listed below:
1. Collier County Nourishment
a. FY 2021/2022 physical, biological, turtle, and shorebird monitoring, and tilling for the
Collier County beach renourishment project;
b. FY 2021/2022 Renourishment of the Naples and Vanderbilt beaches, engineering, and
permitting.
2. Marco Island Nourishment
a. FY 2021/2022 physical, biological, turtle, and shorebird monitoring along with tilling for
the South Marco 2020/21 project area.
3. Wiggins Pass Dredging
a. FY 2020/2021 physical, biological, turtle, and shorebird monitoring of the interim
dredging conducted in FY 2019/20.
Approval of this Resolution is required as a condition of submittal to request long-range State funding to
renourish Collier County beaches and Inlet Monitoring.
FISCAL IMPACT: Tourist Development Tax funds are currently available and budgeted in Beach
Renourishment Fund (195) to accomplish this work. State approval will lead to future state cost -share
participation on these projects through the FDEP grant agreement and contract.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There is no impact to the growth management plan related to
this action.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This item is approved as to form and legality and requires majority vote
for approval. - CMG
ADVISORY COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS: This item was approved by the Coastal
Advisory Committee (8-0) on October 8, 2020 and the Tourist Development Council (8-0) on October
26, 2020.
RECOMMENDATION: For the Board of County Commissioners to approve a Resolution supporting
the County's applications to the FDEP for Long Range Budget Plan Requests for Fiscal Year 2021/2022.
Prepared By: J. Gary McAlpin, P.E., Coastal Zone Management, Capital Project Planning, Impact Fees
and Program Management
Packet Pg. 950
16.A.5
11/10/2020
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. Long Range Budget Resolution (PDF)
2. Collier Beaches - FY21_22 LGFR Beach Application (PDF)
3. Marco Beaches - FY21_22 LGFR Beach Application (PDF)
4. Wiggins Pass - FY21 22 LGFR Inlet Application (PDF)
Packet Pg. 951
16.A.5
11/10/2020
COLLIER COUNTY
Board of County Commissioners
Item Number: 16.A.5
Doe ID: 13798
Item Summary: Recommendation to approve a Resolution supporting the County's applications
to Florida Department of Environmental Protection for Long Range Budget Plan Requests for Beach
Renourishment Projects for Fiscal Year 2021/2022. This action maintains the County's eligibility for State
Cost Share Funding for future renourishment projects.
Meeting Date: 11/10/2020
Prepared by:
Title: — Capital Project Planning, Impact Fees, and Program Management
Name: Jessica Arencibia
10/06/2020 10:22 AM
Submitted by:
Title: Division Director - IF, CPP & PM — Capital Project Planning, Impact Fees, and Program
Management
Name: Amy Patterson
10/06/2020 10:22 AM
Approved By:
Review:
Procurement Services
Opal Vann
Level 1 Purchasing Gatekeeper
Zoning
Gary McAlpin
Additional Reviewer
Capital Project Planning, Impact Fees, and Program Management Andrew Miller
Growth Management Department
Judy Puig
Level 1 Reviewer
Procurement Services
Sandra Herrera
Additional Reviewer
Capital Project Planning, Impact Fees, and Program Management Amy Patterson
Growth Management Operations Support
Raquel Ovares
Growth Management Operations Support
Christopher Johnson
Growth Management Department
Thaddeus Cohen
Department Head Review
Grants
Valerie Fleming
Level 2 Grants Review
County Attorney's Office
Colleen Greene
Level 2 Attorney Review
Office of Management and Budget
Debra Windsor
Level 3 OMB Gatekeeper Review
Budget and Management Office
Ed Finn
Additional Reviewer
Office of Management and Budget
Laura Zautcke
Additional Reviewer
County Attorney's Office
Jeffrey A. Klatzkow Level 3 County Attorney's Office Review
Completed
10/06/2020 10:43 AM
Completed
10/06/2020 10:48 AM
Additional Reviewer Completed
Completed
10/06/2020 4:29 PM
Completed
10/13/2020 1:51 PM
Additional Reviewer Completed
Additional Reviewer Completed
Additional Reviewer Completed
Completed
10/15/2020 2:15 PM
Completed
10/21/2020 1:14 PM
Completed
10/27/2020 11:09 AM
Completed
10/27/2020 11:18 AM
Completed
10/27/2020 3:08 PM
Completed
10/27/2020 3:09 PM
Completed
10/28/2020 11:03 AM
Packet Pg. 952
16.A.5
Grants Therese Stanley Additional Reviewer
County Manager's Office Sean Callahan Level 4 County Manager Review
Board of County Commissioners Mary,lo Brock Meeting Pending
11/10/2020
Completed 11/02/2020 9:43 AM
Completed 11/02/2020 1:16 PM
11/10/2020 9:00 AM
Packet Pg. 953
16.A.5.a
RESOLUTION NO.20
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
SUPPORTING THE COUNTY'S "FLORIDA BEACH
MANAGEMENT PROGRAM 202I/2022 FUNDING REQUESTS"
TO THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION FOR LONG RANGE FUNDING REQUESTS FOR
FISCAL YEARS 202I/2022, AGREEING TO SERVE AS THE
LOCAL SPONSOR, SUPPORT PRQPOSED PROJECT
ACTIVITIES AND COMMITTED TO PROVIDING THE
REQUIRED LOCAL COST SHARE.
WHEREAS, Collier County's Coastal Zone Management, acting on behalf of the
Collier County Board of County Commissioners, has prepared Florida Beach Management
Program 2021/2022 Funding Requests to the Florida Department of Environmental
Protection (FDEP) for long range grant funding for Fiscal Years 2021/2022; and
WHEREAS, the funding requests are to fund the following three Collier County
Projects:
1. Collier County Nourishment
a. FY 2021/2022 physical, biological, turtle, and shorebird monitoring, and
tilling for the Collier County Beach Renourishment project;
b. FY 2021/2022 Renourishment of the Naples and Vanderbilt beaches,
engineering and permitting. 0
0
2. Marco Island Nourishment
r
a. FY 2021/2022 physical, biological, turtle, and shorebird monitoring along
m
with tilling for the South Marco 2021/2022 project area.
c
3. Wiggins Pass Dredging
c
0
a. FY 2020/2021 physical, biological, turtle, and shorebird monitoring of the J
c
a�
interim dredging conducted in FY 2019/2020. E
ca
CCNC
[19-CZM-00281I1489478I1] 1
Packet Pg. 954
16.A.5.a
WHEREAS, the timely maintenance and restoration of these high quality and readily
accessible public recreational beaches is critical to preserve their value and viability, and to
provide a boost to both the environment and the economy of Collier County tourism, including
hotels, restaurants and related commercial activities; and
WHEREAS, the role of the County government in maintaining and restoring beaches is
appropriate and crucial; and
WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners supports these three funding
requests and requests approval from the FDEP for each funding request for Fiscal Years
2021/2022; and
WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners agrees to serve as the Local
Sponsor; and
WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners is able and committed to providing
the required Local Cost Share; and
WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners agrees to support proposed project
activities; and
WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners supports funding contained in previously
approved funding contracts, and
0
WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners has enacted the Tourist o
U)
a�
Development Tax Ordinance No. 92-60, as amended, which commits funding to beach
a�
renourishment, beach maintenance and beach park facilities. m
a�
a�
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that: o
J
1. The Board supports the Florida Beach Management Program 2021/2022
E
[19-CZM-0028U1489478/11 2
Packet Pg. 955
16.A.5.a
Funding Requests prepared for submittal to the Florida Department of Environmental
Protection for long range funding for Fiscal Years 2021/2022, and requests approval from the
FDEP for each funding request;
2. The Board of County Commissioners is willing to serve as the Local Sponsor
and support the maintenance and renourishment projects. The Collier County's Coastal Zone
Management has the staff dedicated to provide Project Management and Administrative
support; and,
3. The Board of County Commissioners is committed to providing the required
Local Cost Share. The required funds have been committed through the Tourist
Development Tax Ordinance No. 92-60, as amended.
THIS RESOLUTION ADOPTED after motion, second and majority vote favoring
same, this day of , 2020.
DATE:
ATTEST:
CRYSTAL K. KINZEL, CLERK
As Deputy Clerk
Approved as to form and legality:
Colleen M. Greene
Managing Assistant County Attorney
[ 1 9-CZM-00281/1489478/ 11
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
Burt L. Saunders, CHAIRMAN
ca
a
3
Packet Pg. 956
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Collier County Beach Projects
PART I: GENERAL INFORMATION
Local Sponsor Collier County - Growth Management Department - Coastal Zone Management Section
Local Sponsor Federal ID Number (FEID) 59-60000558
Contact Name Gary McAlpin
Mailing Address Line 1 2685 S. Horseshoe Drive, Unit 103
Mailing Address Line 2
City Naples
Zip Code 34104
Email Address Gary. McAlpinCo)colliercountvfl.gov
Additional Contact Information
Title Manager
Telephone Number 239-252-5342
Andy Miller, Principal Project Manager, Coastal Zone Management, Andrew.Miller@colliercountyfl.gov
PART II: CERTIFICATION
I hereby certify that all information provided with thisapplicationis true and complete to the best of my knowledge.
Signature of Local Sponsor
Electronic or scanned signatures accept .
Printed Name Gary McAlpin
Date /O
12,6-/g,0
16.A.5.b
Packet Pg. 957
16.A.5.b
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Collier County Beach Projects
PART III: EVALUATION CRITERIA
1. Project Name: (as listed in the Strategic Beach Management Plan)
Collier County Beach Renourishment
2. Project Description: Include county, location with reference to FDEP range monuments,
brief project history, and description of proposed activities. (Note: The box will expand as
needed. To expand for printing purposes, click anywhere outside the box when complete.)
The project includes the periodic nourishment and monitoring of the Collier County beaches (Vanderbilt,
Park Shore and Naples), maintenance dredging of Doctors Pass as a sand source as for navigation and
erosion control structures adjacent to Doctors Pass for sand retention. The project area is located
between Florida FDEP reference monuments R-22+300 and R-79, and includes three "reaches":
Vanderbilt Beach, Park Shore, and Naples. Pelican Bay will be constructed by the County on a
reimbursable basis and is not considered as part of the project area. Vegetation will be planned for
select locations in the project area, and plans will be developed as needed. Dune growth will be
encouraged through planting and maintaining dune vegetation. Dunes will be restored to pre -storm
conditions when damaged.
A 2017 permit modification was approved by FDEP for the Park Shore segment (FDEP Permit 0331817-
001-JC) to extend the northern reach limit from R-43+500 to R-42 in order to incorporate the Clam Pass
Park disposal area that is permitted under the Clam Pass maintenance dredging permits into the
County's beach nourishment program. Collier County is currently teaming with the USACE in a Coastal
Storm Risk Management Study, which may lead to a Federal beach nourishment project as early as FY
2029/2030. Resiliency measures are being considered as part of this feasibility study.
Doctors Pass is utilized as a borrow area for the Collier County Beach Renourishment Project. Periodic
dredging of Doctors Pass and disposal south of the inlet (R-58A-457 to R-58+500) and Lowdermilk Park
(R-60 to R-61+816) will provide up to 20% (10,000 cy/yr) of the advanced nourishment fill material for
the County's beaches.
Currently, the permit design is to maintain a 100 ft. wide beach in Vanderbilt and Naples Beaches and an
85 ft. wide beach in Park Shore, with a 6-year project design life. The beaches have been nourished in
2005/2006 with an offshore sand source and from an upland sand source using truck haul methods in
2013, 2014, 2016, and 2019. The County dredged Doctors Pass in spring 2018 and placed 8,500 cubic
yards of sand within the nearshore disposal areas on Naples Beach.
Packet Pg. 958
Beach Management Fund ingAssistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Collier County Beach Projects
3. Use of Requested Program Funds: Provide a brief description of tasks to be completed in each
requested phase (Feasibility, Design, Construction, and/or Monitoring). Indicate which tasks are
cost reimbursement, if the work has already been completed.
It is the intention of the County to nourish the beaches of Naples and Vanderbilt in FY 21-22
through truck haul methods. Additionally, the county will continue to perform permit required
environmental activities turtle monitoring, hardbottom monitoring, tilling and physical
monitoring.
4. Map: Provide as an attachment. The map(s) of the project area must be formatted at a
minimum of 1" = 200'scale.
Project maps and list of property values are attached. Just Values calculated based on the Florida 2019
Department of Revenue Tax Roll Data.
Vanderbilt — The calculation is based on the 1995 and 2004 ECLs providing a total of $3,972,004,265
with three parcels that did not have any matching Just Values within the tax roll.
Park Shore — The calculation is based on the 2004 ECL and the 2016 MHW providing a total of
$5,438,048,093 with one parcel that did not have any matching Just Values within the tax roll.
Naples — (The calculation is based on the 1995 and 2004 ECLs providing a total of $4,441,376,867 with
two parcels that did not have any matching Just Values within the tax roll.
Project length: Total restored project length (in feet) of the critically eroded area (as listed in the Strategic Beach
Management Plan).
• Vanderbilt: R-22+300 to R-30.5 = 14,996 feet
• Park Shore: R-42 to R-54+400 = 12,976 feet
• Naples: Doctors Pass to R-79 = 19,340 feet
16.A.5. b
Packet Pg. 959
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Collier County Beach Projects
Eligibility:
16.A.5.b
Location/Name
R-
Monument
Type of
Access
Width of
Access/Frontage
Total Public
Units or
Parking
Spaces
Additional
Width from
Eligibility
Unit
Eligible
Shoreline
(feet)
Website Link for DBPF
License
Delnor Wiggins State
Recreation
R-22
Primary
60
340
2,640
2,700
NA
La Playa Beach Resort
R-26
Public
Lodging
597
189
0
597
https://www.mvfloridali
se.com/LicenseDetail.asi
ID=&id=6CB6F49EDEDCE
2DA35F0B1B03FF871
Vanderbilt Beach Blvd.
R-29
Primary
130
345
2,640
2,640
NA
Ritz Carlton Hotel
R-30
Public
Lodging
742
350
0
Overlap
https://www.mvfloridali
se.com/LicenseDetail.asi
ID=&id=51329BF412824
845881000E8BA9FEC
Park Shore
Clam Pass Park
R-43.5
Primary
2,540
172
2,640
5,180
NA
Seagate Drive
North
South
R-45.5
Secondary
100
38 (South) /
67 (North)
0
Overlap
NA
Horizon Way
R-52
Secondary
60
36
0
1,380
NA
Vedado Way
R-53
Secondary
60
j 40
j 1,320
1,380
j NA
Via Miramar
R-56
Secondary
60
1 40
1,320
1,380
NA
Naples Segment
Edgewater Beach
Hotel
R-59
Public
Lodging
265
0
0
265
https://www.myfloriC
cense.com/LicenseDe-
.asp?SID=&id=557545
59C2CC7C6775B8E72
DF24B
Lowdermilk Park
R-61
Primary
920
200
5,280
6,200
NA
Naples Golf & Beach
Club
R-63
Public
Lodging
939
319
Overlap
Overlap
https://www.myfloric
cense.com/LicenseDe-
.asp?SID=&id=1E14F6
1F14878E51E25E6FBC
C16B
8th Ave N (S. Golf)
R-63.5
Secondary
60
40
2,112
1,380
NA
7th Ave N
R-64
Secondary
60
12
634
694
NA
North Lake Ave
R-64.5
Secondary
60
40
2,112
1,380
NA
6th Ave N
R-65
Secondary
60
12
634
694
NA
Packet Pg. 960
16.A.5. b
Beach Management Fund ingAssistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Collier County Beach Projects
5th Ave N
R-65.5
Secondary
60
0
0
60
NA
4th Ave N
R-66
Secondary
60
16
845
905
NA
3`d Ave N
R-66.5
Secondary
60
16
845
905
NA
2nd Ave N
R-67
Secondary
60
16
845
905
NA
15t Ave N
R-67.5
Secondary
60
17
898
958
NA
Central Drive
R-68
Secondary
60
12
634
694
NA
1st Ave S
R-68.5
Secondary
60
12
634
694
NA
2nd Ave S
R-69
Secondary
60
12
634
694
NA
3rd Ave S
R-69.5
Secondary
60
12
634
694
NA
4th Ave S
R-70
Secondary
60
12
634
694
NA
5th Ave S
R-70.5
Secondary
60
12
634
694
NA
Hotel Escalante
R-71
Public
Lodging
150
10
Overlap
Overlap
https://www.myflorid
cense.com/LicenseDei
.asp?SID=&id=441346
722FFE31272B68944S
DB1A
6th Ave S
R-71
Secondary
60
12
634
694
NA
7th Ave S
R-71.5
Secondary
60
16
845
905
NA
8th Ave S
R-72
Secondary
60
12
634
694
NA
91h Ave S
R-72.5
Secondary
60
12
634
694
NA
10th Ave S
R-73
Secondary
60
12
634
694
NA
11th Ave S
R-73.5
Secondary
60
12
634
694
NA
Broad Ave
R-74
Secondary
60
31
1,637
1,380
NA
12th Ave S
R-74.5
Secondary
60
100
5,340
1,380
NA
13th Ave S
R-75
Secondary
60
12
634
694
NA
14th Ave S
R-75.5
Secondary
60
31
1,637
1,380
NA
15th Ave S
R-76
Secondary
60
12
634
694
NA
16th Ave S
R-76.5
Secondary
60
31
1,637
1,380
NA
17th Ave S
R-77
Secondary
60
9
475
535
NA
18th Ave S
R-77.5
Secondary
60
31
1,637
1,380
NA
19th Ave S / Shell Aly
R-78.5
Secondary
60
12
634
694
NA
215T Ave S
R-78.5
Secondary
60
12
634
694
NA
Packet Pg. 961
Beach Management Fund ingAssistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Collier County Beach Projects
5. Schedule and Budget:
16.A.5. b
Total
Federal
State Cost
Local Cost
Year
Proposed Phase
Description
Estimated
Cost
Share
Share
Cost
Share
Monitoring
Physical, Biological, Turtles,
$450,000
$0
$190,710
$259,290
Shorebirds, Tilling
2021/2022
Construction
Beach Renourishment Naples and
$9,400,000
$0
$3,983,720
$5,416,280
Vanderbilt Reaches
Construction
Engineering Services
$150,000
$0
$63,570
$86,430
Monitoring
Physical, Biological, Turtles, Tilling
$459,000
$0
$194,524
$264,476
2022/2023
Construction
Dredging Engineering Services
$40,000
$0
$16,952
$23,048
Construction
Collier Nourishment and Doctors
$600,000
$0
$254,280
$345,720
Pass Maintenance Dredging
2023/2024
Monitoring
Physical, Biological, Turtles, Tilling
$468,200
$0
$198,423
$269,777
Monitoring
Physical, Biological, Turtles, Tilling
$477,564
$0
$202,392
$275,172
2024/2025
Construction
Beach Renourishment - Park Shore
$4,000,000
$0
$1,695,200
$2,304,800
and Clam Pass Park Reaches
Construction
Engineering Services
$125,000
$0
$52,975
$72,025
2025/2026
Monitoring
Physical, Biological, Turtles, Tilling
$487,115
$0
$206,439
$280,676
Construction
Beach Renourishment - Naples and
Vanderbilt Reaches
2026/2027
Construction
Engineering Services
Monitoring
Physical, Biological, Turtles,
Shorebirds, Tilling
Monitoring
Physical, Biological, Turtles,
Tilling
2027/2028
Construction
Dredging Engineering Services
Construction
Doctors Pass Maintenance
Dredging
Construction
CORPS PAl Design
2028/2029
Monitoring
Physical, Biological, Turtles,
Tilling
Monitoring
Physical, Biological, Turtles,
Tilling
Construction
Beach Renourishment - Park Shore
2029/2030
CORPS PA1 Permitting, Engineering
Construction
and Design
Construction
Engineering Services
2030/2031
Monitoring
Physical, Biological, Turtles,
Tilling
Packet Pg. 962
16.A.5.b
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Collier County Beach Projects
Tourism -related impacts: Criteria is calculated by the Department. For reference, tax data can be
obtained from the Department of Revenue website:
https://floridarevenue.com/taxes/pages/colts from 7 2003.aspx.
X Current funding request includes construction and year one post -construction
monitoring
C' Project is managed by two or more counties
Additional comments: The applicant has determined the County -wide tourism -related sales tax
revenue July 2018 to June 2019 to be $54,343,118 and the tourist development tax from July
2018 to June 2019 was $29,951,728.
6. Federal involvement: The documentation to verify authorization, federal cost share
percentage, and status of funding award must be provided with the application materials
for the award of points.
Is the project Federally authorized by the USACE? No
Authorization Year: Expiration Year:
Does this project have a signed USACE Chief's report for authorization of the requested
phase?
Pending September 2021
USACE federal cost share percentage for this project (excluding FCCE): NA
Select all that apply for the requested project phase(s):
Executed USACE project agreement
Included in USACE work plan
Approved FEMA Project Worksheet
Included in Congressional Appropriations Act X Other documentation:
Collier County and the USACE have executed a federally funded feasibility study and the
project is listed in a current federal budget document.
Packet Pg. 963
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Collier County Beach Projects
/. Storm damage reduction benefits: Criteria is calculated by the Department.
What is the volume (cy) of advanced nourishment lost since the last sand placement event
of a beach restoration or nourishment project as measured above the Mean High Water
contour? Data should be consistent with the annual post -construction monitoring reports.
Data based on analysis of the upland volume change from 2006 to 2020 from the Collier
County Beach Nourishment Project 2020 Post -Construction and Annual Monitoring
Summary (H&M, 2020)
• Vanderbilt: R-22 to R-30.8 (-3,510 CY)
• Park Shore: R-42 to R-55 (49,500 CY)
• Naples: Doctors Pass to R-60 (-3,630 CY) and R-60 to R-79 (26,880 CY)
For restoration projects, what is the historical erosion rate? Using the historical MHW data,
the average rate of erosion for the project shoreline is -0.61 foot/year.
8. Cost effectiveness: Criteria is calculated by the Department. A project design analysis and
supporting documentation must be provided with the application materials for the
award of points.
What is the proposed sand placement volume (cy)? Vanderbilt Beach (120,000 cy) and Naples
(145,000 CY)
What is the nourishment interval (years)? 6 years.
Explain: Although construction by truck haul requires segmentation of the project into
reaches done in separate years, the project is designed for a 6-year nourishment
interval.
Select all that apply for the current project funding request:
Enhanced longevity: Propose structural or design components that could extend the
beach nourishment interval
Dune addition: Incorporate new or enhanced dune structures or new or
existing dune restoration and revegetation projects
Innovative technology: Propose innovative technologies designed to reduce project
costs
Regionalization: Two or more local sponsors manage projects together
or projects propose regional sediment management strategies to
conserve sand resources or reduce project costs
Additional comments for storm damage reduction benefits and cost
effectiveness
16.A.5.b
Packet Pg. 964
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Collier County Beach Projects
9. Previous statecommitment
Has the Department previously reviewed, approved, and cost -shared on a feasibility or design
phase for this project? Y
Has the current proposed project phase(s) received a partial appropriation within 3 years of
phase completion? N
Additional comments
10. Accessible beach area: Criteria is calculated by the Department. Provide data to be considered
for the calculation.
Describe the landward and seaward edge of the accessible beach width
• Vanderbilt: Using the 2014 MHW the beach area was calculated to be 645,632 sq. ft.
• Park Shore: Using the 2014 MHW the beach area was calculated to be 370,532 sq. ft.
However, in some areas the ECL is front of the MHW.
• Naples: Using the 2014 MHW the beach area was calculated to be 1,685,295 sq. ft.
Provide the project boundaries (R-monuments) - 15 Year Beach Nourishment
• Vanderbilt: R-22+300 to R-30.5 = 14,996 feet
• Park Shore: R-42 to R-54+400 = 12,976 feet
• Naples: Doctors Pass to R-79 = 19,340 feet
Provide citations of reference sources
Collier County, Florida Hardbottom Biological Monitoring Plan for Permits Collier County
Beach Nourishment Project (FDEP Permit No. 033187-004-JM) and Wiggins Pass Navigation
Channel Expansion and Maintenance Project (FDEP Permit No. 0142538-008-JC)
11. Recreational benefits: Provide the percentage of linear footage within the project
boundaries which is zoned recreational or open space; for commercial use; or to allow for
public lodging establishment, orthe equivalent.
Project
Parcel Recreation
Length (ft)
Recreation
Percentage
Vanderbilt
1,866
12
Park Shore
2,544
20
Naples
929
5
16.A.5.b
Packet Pg. 965
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Collier County Beach Projects
c. Mitigation of inlet effects: Criteria is calculated by the Department.
Additional comments
Approximately 37,600 cy were dredged from Doctors Pass and bypassed south with
nearshore disposal of Naples Beach in 2018. Utilizing volumes from the Department's
FY19/20 Coastal Engineering memo, the volume of inlet sand bypassing between 2005 and
2020 has been approximately 7,180 cy/yr. Supplemental nourishment is achieved by Collier
County via beach nourishment sand placement events to mitigate for the approximate 2,820
cy/yr bypassing deficit.
13. Successive unfunded requests
Is the current proposed project phase(s) a successive, unfunded request? If so, how many
years of successive request(s) is the current application? No
Does the successive request add the construction phase? N/A
14. Environmental habitat enhancement: Criteria is calculated by the Department.
Is the project within a designated critical habitat area for threatened or endangered species
that is subject to extensive shoreline armoring? No
Is the project within a non -designated area where extensive shoreline armoring threatens the
habitat of threatened or endangered species? No
If yes to either of the above, does the project exceed best management practices to
incorporate turtle- friendly designs and management strategies to protect resources or
benefit critical habitat preservation?
Provide an explanation and supporting documentation for the strategies which exceed best
management practices
15. Readiness toconstruct - It is the intention of the County to perform a truck haul project for
the Naples and Vanderbilt segments in FY 20/21
Does the project have an active state permit? Yes
Does the project have an active federal permit? Yes
Collier County Beach Nourishment 15-Yr Permits
FDEP Permit No. 0331817-001-JC. Issued Oct. 2, 2015, expires Oct. 2, 2030.
Doctors Pass Erosion Control Structures
FDEP Permit No. 0338231-001-JC. Issued May 27, 2016, expires May 27, 2026.
Collier County Beach Nourishment 15-Yr Permits
USACE Permit No. SAJ-2003-12405
Authorization Date: April 6, 2016, expires April 6, 2031
16.A.5.b
Packet Pg. 966
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Collier County Beach Projects
Have all necessary easements been acquired for the upcoming or proposed construction
phase? Yes
Has the necessary local funding been secured for the proposed project? If so,
provide a copy of the draft Resolution. Yes
The signed Resolution is due by November 20, 2020.
Is an Erosion Control Line established along the project length? Yes
Provide additional information and comments below or attach separate documents.
16.A.5.b
Packet Pg. 967
r—*k
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Collier County Beach Projects
�a
L
ATTACHMENT 1.
LGFR MAPS
Packet Pg. 968
r—*k
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Collier County Beach Projects
�a
L
ATTACHMENT 2.
RESOLUTION
Packet Pg. 969
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Beach Projects Application
South Marco Island Beach Renourishment
PART I: GENERAL INFORMATION
Local Sponsor Collier County - Growth Management Department - Coastal Zone Management Section
Local Sponsor Federal ID Number (FEID) 59-60000558
Contact Name Gary McAlpin
Mailing Address Line 1 2685 S. Horseshoe Drive, Unit 103
Mailing Address Line 2
City Naples
Zip Code 34104
Email Address Gary.McAlpin@colliercountyfl.gov
Additional Contact Information
Title Manager
Telephone Number (239) 252-5342
Andy Miller, Principal Project Manager, Coastal Zone Management, Andrew. MillerPcolliercountyfl.gov
PART II: CERTIFICATION
I hereby certify that all information provided with this application is true and complete to the best of my knowledge.
Signature of Local Sponsor _ /�-A_
or
Electronic or scanned signatures accepted.
Printed Name Gary McAlpin
01,
Date !� �S Zd
16.A.5.c
Packet Pg. 970
16.A.5.c
Beach Management Fund ingAssistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Beach Projects Application
South Marco Island Beach Renourishment
PART III: EVALUATION CRITERIA
1. Project Name: (as listed in the Strategic Beach Management Plan)
South Marco Island Beach Renourishment
2. Project Description: Include county, location with reference to FDEP range monuments, brief
project history, and description of proposed activities. (Note: The box will expand as needed. To
expand for printing purposes, click anywhere outside the box when complete.)
The South Marco Island Beach Renourishment Project is located on the southwest Florida
coastline of Collier County between Florida Department of Environmental Protection monuments
from reference monument R-144 to R-148+600 (G-4). This project has a design beach width of 100
ft. from the baseline and is nourished on an approximate 8-year interval. The project's borrow
area is the Caxambas Pass Borrow Area with upland sand mines permitted as supplemental sand
sources.
This project includes yearly physical beach monitoring, beach tilling, and environmental
monitoring as required by FDEP and USACE permits.
In 2013, Collier County placed approximately 77,800 cubic yards of beach compatible material to
restore approximately 2,300 feet along South Marco Island (400 feet south of R-146 to G-4). The
beach fill was within the 2005 permitted project limits. The main goals of the project were to
restore storm protection, natural resource habitats, and recreational beach areas to offset the
storm damage caused by Tropical Storm Fay in 2008. Additionally, the structural repair of five
existing erosion control structures was completed in 2013/14.
The South Marco Island Beach Renourishment Project was then renourished through truckhaul
methods in November of 2016 with approximately 13,200 cubic yards of beach compatible
material to offset storm damages caused by Tropical Storm Debby.
Approximately 80,000 cy of dredged material from Caxambas Pass was placed in the South Marco
Island Beach project area in March of 2020.
3. Use of Requested Program Funds: Provide a brief description of tasks to be completed in each
requested phase (Feasibility, Design, Construction, and/or Monitoring). Indicate which tasks are
cost reimbursement, if the work has already been completed.
Funds requested for FY 2021/2022 will be utilized for physical monitoring, turtle monitoring,
shorebird monitoring and tilling.
Packet Pg. 971
16.A.5.c
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Beach Projects Application
South Marco Island Beach Renourishment
4. Map: Provide as an attachment. The map(s) of the project area must be formatted at a minimum
of 1" = 200'scale.
Map elements must include:
Compass rose with North arrow, scale, and legend.
Project boundary, including the length of critically eroded shoreline
FDEP range monuments
Beach access: indicate primary or secondary access, and includethe accesswidth, numberand
location of parking spaces, bus stops, bike racks, and public restroom facilities
Public lodging establishments: include the width fronting the project shoreline (for recreational
benefits ranking points and eligibility determination), and include the length of street -side
frontage within one -quarter mile walking distance of a secondary public access point (for
eligibility determination)
Comprehensive list of current land use designations of properties along the project shoreline
(for recreational benefits ranking points)
Include one -quarter mile buffer and provide a comprehensive list of the values of properties
that are enclosed or intersected by the buffer (for value of upland property ranking points)
Project maps and list of property values are attached. Just Values calculated based on the Florida
2019 Department of Revenue Tax Roll Data.
The calculation is based on the 1990 ECL providing a total of $1,723,304,641 with zero parcels
that did not have any matching Just Values within the tax roll.
5. Project length: Total restored project length (in feet) of the critically eroded area (as listed in the
Strategic Beach Management Plan).
The permitted project extends from R-144 to R-148+600 (G4), 4,730 feet. The project area
designated as critically eroded extends from R-144 to R-148, resulting in a total length of 4,130
feet.
Packet Pg. 972
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Beach Projects Application
South Marco Island Beach Renourishment
6. Eligibility:
16.A.5.c
Total
Additional
Location/Name
R-mon
Type of
Access
Width of
Access/
Frontage
Public
Units or
Parking
Width
from
Eligibility
Eligible
Shoreline
(feet)
DBPR License
Spaces
Units
https://www.myfloridalicense
com/LicenseDetail.asp?SID=&
Surf Club of
Marco
R 144
Public
Lodging
297
44
0
297
id=B4BE7E07A37451A42D27E
037A5432937
Hilton Marco
Island Beach
Resort and Spa
R-144
Public
Lodging
500
320
0
500
https://www.mVfloridalicense
com/LicenseDetail.asp?SID=&
id=488C114245D7F52516AA0
5FAD517FF46
https://www.mVfloridalicense
com/LicenseDetail.asp?SID=&
Marriott Crystal
Shores
R-144.2
Public
Lodging
362
71
0
362
id=0053F469FA707AE7B5FA4
01B4C3EEFF5
https://www.myfloridalicense
com/LicenseDetail.asp?SID=&
Swallow Ave
R-148
Secondary
20
72
1860
1880
id=CB55BC6479D13BEC3774B
939D47A6BD5
Packet Pg. 973
16.A.5.c
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Beach Projects Application
South Marco Island Beach Renourishment
i. Schedule and Budget:
Cost Reimbursement: Specify eligible costs incurred during the three years prior to the current
application's fiscal year that have not been reimbursed. Eligible costs will be included in the
funding request for the current application.
Current and Future Costs: Specify eligible costs for the current application's fiscal year that are
not in a current DEP agreement and have not been reimbursed. Include the estimated costs for the
next S years and the proposed phases for the next 10 years.
Year
Proposed
Description
Total
Estimated
Federal
State Cost
Local Cost
Method
Turtle,
Shorebird, Tilling
Cost
Cost Share
Share
Share
2021/2022
MonitoringPhysical,
$102,937
$0
$27,773
$75,165
2022/2023
Monitoring
Physical, Turtle,
Shorebird, Tilling
$104,996
$0
$28,328
$76,668
Monitoring
Physical, Turtle,
$107,096
$0
$28,895
$78,202
Shorebird, Tilling
2023/2024
Design
Engineering Design,
$55,000
$0
$14,839
$40,161
P&S and Pre -Con
Monitoring
Physical
$35,000
$0
$9,443
$25,557
2024/2025
Nourishment and
Construction
Construction Services
$2,050,000
$0
$553,090
$1,496,910
2025/2026
Monitoring
Physical, Turtle,
Shorebird, Tilling
$105,000
$0
$28,329
$76,671
2026/2027
Monitoring
Physical, Turtle,
Shorebird, Tilling
2027/2028
Monitoring
Physical, Turtle,
Shorebird, Tilling
2028/2029
Monitoring
Physical, Turtle,
Shorebird, Tilling
Monitoring
Physical, Turtle,
Shorebird, Tilling
2029/2030
Nourishment and
Construction
Construction Services
2030/2031
Monitoring
Physical, Turtle,
Shorebird, Tilling
Packet Pg. 974
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Beach Projects Application
South Marco Island Beach Renourishment
8. Tourism -related impacts: Criteria is calculated by the Department. For reference, tax data can be
obtained from the Department of Revenue website:
https://floridarevenue.com/taxes/pages/colls_from_7_2003.aspx.
Current funding request includes construction and year one post -construction monitoring
Project is managed by two or more counties
Additional comments: The applicant has determined the County -wide tourism -related sales tax
revenue July 2018 to June 2019 to be $54,343,118 and the tourist development tax from July 2018
to June 2019 was $29,951,728.
9. Federal involvement: The documentation to verify authorization, federal cost share percentage,
and status of funding award must be provided with the application materials for the award of
points.
Is the project Federally authorized by the USACE? No
Authorization Year: Expiration Year:
Does this project have a signed USACE Chief's report for authorization of the requested phase?
NA
USACE federal cost share percentage for this project (excluding FCCE): 0%
Select all that apply for the requested project phase(s):
C Executed USACE project agreement
C Included in USACE work plan
C Approved FEMA Project Worksheet
Included in Congressional Appropriations Act
Other documentation:
16.A.5.c
Packet Pg. 975
16.A.5.c
Beach Management Fund ingAssistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Beach Projects Application
South Marco Island Beach Renourishment
10. Storm damage reduction benefits: Criteria is calculated by the Department.
What is the volume (cy) of advanced nourishment lost since the last sand placement event of
a beach restoration or nourishment project as measured above the Mean High Water
contour? Data should be consistent with the annual post -construction monitoring reports.
Marco Island was nourished in March of 2020. Prior to that the previous survey was conducted
by Humiston & Moore in January and February 2019. The South Marco Beach Nourishment
Project, 2019 Annual Construction Monitoring Summary, May-2019, prepared by Humiston &
Moore Engineers, contains the most recent monitoring report available to the Department. This
report (page 23) states: "The 2013 project area retained 38% of the sand placed in 2013 as of
February 2019". The dry beach width is approximately 148 feet from an average post -
construction width of 193 feet. The pre -construction width was 114 feet which equates to a
beach width decrease of approximately 57%. Assuming the volume loss above MHW follows
the same percentiles, the assumption is a 62% to 57% volume loss above MHW.
For restoration projects, what is the historical erosion rate?
The project area's entire shoreline has been designated by FDEP as critically eroded shoreline.
The Department has previously calculated the average rate of erosion for the project shoreline
based on historical MHW data from 1973 to 1990 between monuments R-144 and R-148 and
determined the average rate of erosion is -2.3 ft/yr.
11. Cost effectiveness: Criteria is calculated by the Department. A project design analysis and
supporting documentation must be provided with the application materials for the award of
points.
What is the proposed sand placement volume (cy)? Approximately 80,000 cy of dredged material
from Caxambas Pass was placed in the South Marco Island Beach project area in March of 2020.
What is the nourishment interval (years)? 7 years.
Explain: Initially restored in 1991, The project area has been maintained with previous
beach nourishment in 2006, 2013, 2016 and 2020. Therefore, the average nourishment
interval is eight years.
Packet Pg. 976
16.A.5.c
Beach Management Fund ingAssistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Beach Projects Application
South Marco Island Beach Renourishment
Select all that apply for the current project funding request:
Enhanced longevity: Propose structural or design components that could extend the beach
nourishment interval
Dune addition: Incorporate new or enhanced dune structures or new or existing dune
restoration and revegetation projects
Innovative technology: Propose innovative technologies designed to reduce project costs
Regionalization: Two or more local sponsors manage projects together or projects propose
regional sediment management strategies to conserve sand resources or reduce project costs
Additional comments for storm damage reduction benefits and cost effectiveness
12. Previous statecommitment
Has the Department previously reviewed, approved, and cost -shared on a feasibility or design
phase for this project? Y
Has the current proposed project phase(s) received a partial appropriation within 3 years of
phase completion? N
Additional comments
13. Accessible beach area: Criteria is calculated by the Department. Provide data to be considered
for the calculation.
Describe the landward and seaward edge of the accessible beach width
Using the CEC estimated MHW the beach area was calculated to be 916,482 sq. ft.
Provide the project boundaries (R-monuments) - The entire project area from R-144 to R-
148+600 (G4) is designated as critically eroded, resulting in a total length of 4,423 feet.
Provide citations of reference sources
FDEP Permit No. 0235209-008AM, Authorization Date: 9/27/2016, Expiration Date:
10/11/2027
USACE Permit No. SAJ-2005-2726 (IP-MN) & mod USACE Permit No. SAJ-1996-02789,
Authorization Date: 3/9/2016 Expiration Date: 3/9/2026
14. Recreational benefits: Provide the percentage of linear footage within the project boundaries
which is zoned recreational or open space; for commercial use; or to allow for public lodging
establishment, orthe equivalent.
The project length is 4,130 feet. A total of 1,559 feet are designated as commercial and
recreational, therefore 37.7% of total project length.
Packet Pg. 977
16.A.5.c
Beach Management Fund ingAssistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Beach Projects Application
South Marco Island Beach Renourishment
15. Mitigation of inlet effects: Criteria is calculated by the Department.
Additional comments The Marco Island project is nourished in synergy with maintaining
Caxambas Pass for navigation. This practice meets the objective of the Strategic Beach
Management Plan and returns sand eroded from the beach back to the beach for a high level
of sustainability. In 2013, approximately 78,000 cy was dredged from the pass for
nourishment of the beach. The nourishment from the pass was supplemented in 2016 by
13,228 cy from an upland sand source to restore the beach. Most recently, a nourishment in
2019 placed approximately 80,000 cy within the project area.
16. Successive unfunded requests
Is the current proposed project phase(s) a successive, unfunded request? If so, how many years
of successive request(s) is the current application? No
Does the successive request add the construction phase? N/A
17. Environmental habitat enhancement: Criteria is calculated by the Department.
Is the project within a designated critical habitat area for threatened or endangered species that
is subject to extensive shoreline armoring? No
Is the project within a non -designated area where extensive shoreline armoring threatens the
habitat of threatened or endangered species? No
If yes to either of the above, does the project exceed best management practices to incorporate
turtle- friendly designs and management strategies to protect resources or benefit critical habitat
preservation?
Provide an explanation and supporting documentation for the strategies which exceed best
management practices
18. Readiness toconstruct
Does the project have an active state permit? Does the project have an active federal permit?
FDEP Permit No. 0235209-008-JM, Authorization Date: 9/27/2016, Expiration Date:
10/11/2027
USACE Permit No. SAJ-2005-2726 (IP-MN) & mod USACE Permit No. SAJ-1996-02789,
Authorization Date: 3/9/2016, Expiration Date: 3/9/2026
Have all necessary easements been acquired for the upcoming or proposed construction
phase? Yes
Packet Pg. 978
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Beach Projects Application
South Marco Island Beach Renourishment
Has the necessary local funding been secured for the proposed project? If so, provide a copy of
the draft Resolution. Yes
The signed Resolution is due by November 20, 2020.
Is an Erosion Control Line established along the project length? Yes
Additional comments
Provide additional information and comments below or attach separate documents.
16.A.5.c
Packet Pg. 979
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Beach Projects Application
South Marco Island Beach Renourishment
ATTACHMENT 1.
LGFR MAPS
16.A.5.c
Packet Pg. 980
Beach Management Fund ingAssistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Beach Projects Application
South Marco Island Beach Renourishment
ATTACHMENT 2.
RESOLUTION
16.A.5.c
Packet Pg. 981
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Inlet Projects Application
Wiggins Pass
PART I: GENERAL INFORMATION
Local Sponsor Collier County - Growth Management Department - Coastal Zone Management
Section
Local Sponsor Federal ID Number (FEID) 59-60000558
Contact Name Gary McAlpin Title Manager
Mailing Address Line 1 2685 S. Horseshoe Drive, Unit 103
Mailing Address Line 2
City Naples Zip Code 34104
Email Address GarvMcAlpin@colliergov.net
Additional Contact Information
Telephone Number (239) 252-2966
Andy Miller Principal Project Manager Coastal Zone Management, Andrew.Miller(@colliercountvfl.gov
PART II: CERTIFICATION
I hereby certify that all information provided with this application is true and complete to the best of my
knowledge.
j/) Ir
/V Signature of Local Sponsor 6 2d 2,0
Electronic or scanned signatures accepted.
Printed Name Gary McAlpin
16.A.5.d
Q
Packet Pg. 982
Beach Management Fund ingAssistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Inlet Projects Application
Wiggins Pass
PART III: EVALUATION CRITERIA
1. Project Name: As listed in the Inlet Management Plan (IMP) or Strategic Beach Management Plan
(SBMP)
Wiggins Pass Inlet Management
2. Project Description: Include county, location with reference to FDEP range monuments,
brief project history, and description of proposed activities. Note: The box will expand as
needed. To expand for printing purposes, click anywhere outside the box when complete.
The Wiggins Pass Project is located on the southwest Florida coastline in Collier County
between Florida Department of Environmental Protection monuments R-16 and R-17 and
the project is adjacent to approximately 2,300 feet of critically eroded Gulf shoreline. The
dredge sites are located within Wiggins Pass, South and North Channels and the Gulf of
Mexico. The nearshore and beach disposal sites are located north of the inlet, between DEP
Reference monuments R-12 to R-15.5, and south of the inlet, between R-18 and R-20. The
ebb shoal disposal area is located offshore of Wiggins Pass, approximately 300-1,000 feet
north of the authorized inlet channel. The entire project is located in Collier County,
Sections 17 and 20, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Gulf of Mexico, Class III Waters.
Portions of the project are within Outstanding Florida Waters associated with Barefoot
Beach Preserve, Delnor-Wiggins Pass State Park and Wiggins Pass Estuarine Area and
Cocohatchee River System.
The initial phase of the latest Inlet Management Plan Study was implemented in 2013 by
dredging approximately 107,000 cy for maintenance dredging and initial realignment of the
channel. Per the Inlet Management Plan study, Wiggins Pass is currently dredged at regular
intervals of approximately 4 years to maintain navigable depths for recreational boaters,
with optional interim dredging events every two years to address shoaling across the
navigation inlet gulf entrance. In 2015, an interim maintenance dredging project excavated
13,000 cy to clear the shoal across the main inlet entrance channel. Material was placed in
the ebb shoal disposal area north of the channel and within the flood shoal disposal. FDEP
finalized the inlet management plan in April 2018.
In Spring 2018, dredging removed approximately 100,000 cy with disposal split 2/3 of the
total volume (67%) to the north and 1/3 of the total volume (33%) to the south. The 2018
dredging aimed to maintain the navigation of the inlet, refine and reinforce the alignment
begun with the 2013 project, and implement the new inlet management plan distribution
for bypassing of the dredged material. Dredging of Wiggins Pass was concurrent with the
dredging of Doctors Pass as a means for sharing of common costs, such as mobilization to
reduce costs.
In March 2020 the County conducted a small interim dredging project which removed
approximately 15,000 cy with placement in the nearshore zone north of Wiggins Pass along
Barefoot Beach from FDEP reference monument R-12 to R-14.
16.A.5.d
Packet Pg. 983
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Inlet Projects Application
Wiggins Pass
3. Use of Requested Program Funds: Provide a brief description of tasks to be completed in
each requested phase (Feasibility, Design, Construction, and/or Monitoring). Indicate which
tasks are cost reimbursement, if the work has already been completed.
Reimbursement of engineering, permitting and construction funds are requested
associated with the interim channel dredging in 2020. Additionally, monitoring funds are
being requested for the current year.
4. Map: Provide as an attachment to the application. The map of the project area must be
formatted at a minimum of 1" = 200' scale.
Map elements must include:
Compass rose with North arrow, scale, and legend.
Project boundary, including the location of the inlet and length of critically eroded
shoreline
FDEP range monuments
Area of inlet influence
Permitted sand bypassing placement area
The mapping is included with this application.
5. Project length: Total restored project boundary (in feet) as listed in the IMP or SBMP
Inlet influence north and south of Wiggins Pass was initially investigated in 1986 (Hine, et
al). By examining the offshore contours in the vicinity of Wiggins Pass, the authors
concluded that the length of influence along the updrift beach (north) was approximately
3,300 feet. It is at this distance north of the inlet, that the offshore contours become parallel
to one another. The authors also found that the corresponding inlet effects downdrift
(south) of Wiggins Pass extended approximately 2,040 feet (CPE, 2012).
16.A.5.d
Packet Pg. 984
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Inlet Projects Application
Wiggins Pass
v. Schedule and Budget:
Proposed
Total
Federal
State Cost
Local Cost
Year
Phase
Description
Estimated
Cost
Share
Share
Cost
Share
Construction
Interim Channel Dredging and
$250,000
$0
$125,000
$125,000
2020/2021
Construction Services
Design
Engineering and Permitting
$75,000
$0
$37,500
$37,500
2021/2022
Monitoring
Environmental & Physical
$100,000
$0
$50,000
$50,000
Monitoring, and Tilling
Monitoring
Environmental & Physical
$102,000
$0
$51,000
$51,000
Monitoring, and Tilling
Construction
Channel Dredging and Rock
$1,800,000
$0
$900,000
$900,000
2022/2023
Removal
Construction
Dredging Construction Services
$75,000
$0
$37,500
$37,500
Design
Dredging - Engineering and
$55,000
$0
$27,500
$27,500
Permitting
2023/2024
Monitoring
Environmental & Physical
$104,000
$0
$52,000
$52,000
Monitoring, and Tilling
Monitoring
Environmental & Physical
$106,000
$0
$53,000
$53,000
Monitoring, and Tilling
Construction
Interim Channel Dredging
$600,000
$0
$300,000
$300,000
2024/2025
(150,000 CY)
Construction
Dredging Construction Services
$50,000
$0
$25,000
$25,000
Design
Dredging - Engineering and
$75,000
$0
$37,500
$37,500
Permitting
2025/2026
Monitoring
Environmental & Physical
$108,000
$0
$54,000
$54,000
Monitoring, and Tilling
Environmental & Physical
Monitoring
Monitoring, and Tilling
Construction
Channel Dredging
2026/2027
Construction
Dredging Construction Services
Dredging - Engineering and
Design
Permitting
2027/2028
Monitoring
Environmental & Physical
Monitoring, and Tilling
Environmental & Physical
Monitoring
Monitoring, and Tilling
Design
Engineering and Permitting
2028/2029
Interim Channel Dredging
Construction
(150,000 CY)
Construction
Construction Services
2029/2030
Monitoring
Environmental & Physical
Monitoring, and Tilling
Monitoring
Environmental & Physical
Monitoring, and Tilling
Construction
Dredging Construction Services
2030/2031
Construction
Channel Dredging
Dredging - Engineering and
Design
Permitting
Design
USACE PA1 PED
16.A.5.d
Q
Packet Pg. 985
Beach Management Fund ingAssistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Inlet Projects Application
Wiggins Pass
Sand reaching the inlet
Provide the estimated annual quantity (cubic yards) of beach quality sand reaching the
updrift boundary of the improved jetty or inlet channel:
The bypass objective determined in the adopted Wiggins Pass Inlet Management
Plan is 20,600 cubic yards per year. Based upon recent data, the annual volume of
sediment reaching the inlet for the period 2014-2018 is 27,350 cy/yr.
8. Severity of erosion
What is the annual bypassing objective (cubic yards/year) adopted by the IMP or SBMP
or as determined by a Department -approved study?
The Strategic Beach Management Plan for Wiggins Pass states that on an average annual
basis, the initial target inlet sand bypassing quantity shall be 20,600 cubic yards per
year, with approximately one-third placed to the south of the inlet and
approximately two-thirds placed to the north.
9. Balancing the sediment budget
What is the current annual average of bypassed material (cubic yards) since the adoption of a
bypass objective?
Annual average bypass 110,873/2 = 55,436.5 (CY)
Provide a brief description of when the last sediment budget engineering analysis
was completed for the inlet and area of inlet influence. Discuss any proposals to
update the sediment budget.
In 2011, 49,900 cy of material was removed from Wiggins Pass. In 2013 a total 107,370
cy was dredged from Wiggins Pass. The 2015 interim dredging excavated 9,400 cy from
the inlet entrance channel and the connecting south channel. The 2018 project removed
approximately 95,900 cy from Wiggins Pass. The 1995 Inlet Management Study and
corresponding strategic beach management plan was implemented starting in 2001. A
new study was completed in 2012, permitted and initiated in 2013. FDEP approved the
final plan in April 2018.
The bypassing plan adopted in April 2018 was first implemented with the 2018 dredging
event. Since the IMP adoption, the bypassing objectives have been met.
16.A.5.d
Packet Pg. 986
16.A.5.d
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Inlet Projects Application
Wiggins Pass
Historical bypassing volumes: In the table below, provide the annual bypassing volumes
(cubic yards/year), for the previous ten years (from the last calendar year or the most recent
calculation). Attach additional documentation as needed.
Quantity
Bypassed
Quantity Bypassed (cy) - Dredging
Dredge
Year
(cy) - Sand
Location
Placement or Disposal
Transfer
North
South
Area
Plant
2008
2009
38,927
12,373
Ebb Shoal
R11.5-R14 and R18-R20.5
2010
2011
49,900
0
Ebb Shoal
R12-R14.2
2012
66,064
41,306
Ebb Shoal
R12-R16
2013/2014
2015
9,400
0
Ebb Shoal and
R15.5-R16
Interior Channel
2016
2017
Ebb Shoal and
Nearshore R12-R14, R15.7-
2018
57,986
37,887
Interior Channel
R16, and R17.8-R20
2019
2020
15,000
0
Ebb Shoal
Nearshore R12-R14
Total per method
237,277
50,260
Total bypass
287,537 CY
volume
Years since IMP
2 years
adoption
Annual average
bypass since IMP
36,493 CY
25,130 CY
adoption
Bypass objective
2/3
1/3
Percentage of
65%
35%
bypass objective
Q
Packet Pg. 987
16.A.5.d
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Inlet Projects Application
Wiggins Pass
Increased bypassing and cost-effectiveness
Provide the estimated increase in annual bypassing of sand (cubic yards/year) proposed for the
project:
None proposed at this time
Provide the estimated shortfall of annual bypassing of sand (cubic yards/year) within the inlet
system:
The adopted bypassing objective is currently being met.
Is the proposed project requesting construction phase funds for a major inlet management
project component?
Construction phase funds are requested at this time.
If yes, and for the award of points for the cost-effectiveness of using inlet sand criteria, provide
an opinion of probable cost per unit volume of the inlet and all other sand sources, certified by a
licensed professional engineer.
The cost per cubic yard for this project has been determined by Steve Keehn, PE to be
approximately $15.35/cy based on a weighted unit cost of a two -inlet project.
11. Inlet Management Plans
Select all that apply:
X Existing IMP: The proposed project has an existing IMP or completed Inlet Management
Study that has been approved by the Department.
Updated IMP: The Department has received and approved an update to an existing IMP in
the form of a current Inlet Management Study/sediment budget analysis within the
previous five years, or there is an update proposed to an existing IMP in the current
application.
NewIMP:A new inlet management study is proposed for submission to the Department
for an adoption in an IMP.
Packet Pg. 988
Beach Management Fund ingAssistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Inlet Projects Application
Wiggins Pass
12. Enhanced longevity of proximate beach nourishment projects: Criteria is calculated by the
Department.
Annualized beach nourishment volume of proximate beach nourishment project:
In March 2020 the County conducted a small interim dredging project which removed
approximately 15,000 cy with placement in the nearshore zone north of Wiggins Pass along
Barefoot Beach from FDEP reference monument R-12 to R-14. Since the adoption of the inlet
management plan 39,493 CY has been placed on average per year along the northern shoreline
adjacent to Wiggins Pass and 25,130 CY has been placed average per year on the southern
shoreline adjacent to Wiggins Pass.
13. Active permits
Does the project have an active state permit? Yes Does the project have an active federal permit? Yes
FDEP Permit No. 01452538-008-JC Permit number SAJ-2004-07621(IP-MJD)
Permit Modification No. 0142538-014-JN Authorization date 2/13/2013
Authorization date 1/2/2013 Expiration date 2/13/2023
Expiration date 1/2/2023
14. Federal fundsavailable
Does the proposed project have federal funds available? If so, provide supporting
documentation. No
15. Secured localfunds
Has the necessary local funding been secured for the proposed project? Yes
If so, provide a copy of the draft Resolution. The signed Resolution is due by November 20,
2020.
Additional comments
16.A.5.d
Packet Pg. 989
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Inlet Projects Application
Wiggins Pass
ATTACHMENT 1.
LGFR MAPS
16.A.5.d
Q
Packet Pg. 990
Beach Management Funding Assistance Program
FY 2021/22 Local Government Funding Request
Inlet Projects Application
Wiggins Pass
ATTACHMENT 2.
RESOLUTION
16.A.5.d
Q
Packet Pg. 991