The URL can be used to link to this page

Bayshore Gateway CRA Agenda 11/03/2020 Bayshore CRA Offices: 3299 Tamiami Trail E, Unit 103, Naples, Florida 34112 Phone: 239-252-8844 Online: www.bayshorecra.com Bayshore Gateway Triangle Community Redevelopment Agency AGENDA Hybrid Virtual Zoom Meeting 3299 Tamiami Trail 3rd Floor BCC Chambers, Naples, FL 34112 November 3, 2020 6:00 PM Chairman Maurice Gutierrez Karen Beatty, Larry Ingram, Dwight Oakley, Steve Main, Michael Sherman, Al Schantzen, Camille Kielty. Steve Rigsbee 1. Call to order and Roll Call 2. Approval of Agenda 3. Approval of Minutes a. October 6, 2020 Minutes (Attached) 4. Community / Business – Presentations a. Bayshore Wine Venue –Bob Mulhere 5. Old Business a. Camden Landing Presentation, Wayne Arnold (Action Item) b. Best Popcorn Company-Sharon Kurgis, Grant Agreement Extension (Action Item) c. Regulatory Changes – November 12th Special Meeting 5pm d. CRA Parking Lot e. Sabal Bay PUD f. Stormwater Subcommittee Recommendations (Attachments) (Action Item) 6. New Business a. Meeting Calendar 2021/ Joint Workshop 7. Other Agencies - a. Collier County Sheriff Department b. Collier County Code Enforcement (Attachment) 8. Staff Report a. CRA Directors Project Report b. Project Manager’s Report – Tami Scott (Attachment) V'L?iG�?Nv�4�, vYli � fiffl fI �'w Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA .Bayshore Beautification MSTU Haldeman Creek MSTU c. Private Development Update — Ellen Summers (Attachment) d. Maintenance Report- Shirley Garcia (Attachment) e. Financials (Attachment) 9. Communication and Correspondence a. Triangle Development Article (Attachment) 10. Public Comments 11. Staff Comments 12. Advisory Board General Communication 13. Next meeting a. December 1, 2020 @ 6pm 14. Adjournment Bayshore CRA Offices: 3299 Tamiami Trail E, Unit 103, Naples, Florida 34112 Phone: 239-252-8844 Online: www.bayshorecra.com to ) -B410rvv Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA .Bayshore Beautification MSTU Haldeman Creek MSTU Agenda item 3a— October 6, 2020 Meeting Minutes BAYSHORE/GATEWAY TRIANGLE COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT LOCAL ADVISORY BOARD MINUTES OF THE OCTOBER 6, 2020 MEETING The meeting of the Bayshore/Gateway Triangle Community Redevelopment Advisory Board was called to order by Chairman, Maurice Gutierrez at 6:01 p.m. I. Roll Call: Advisory Board Members Present: Maurice Gutierrez, Dwight Oakley, Steve Main, Al Schantzen, Camille Kielty, Karen Beatty, Steve Rigsbee and Michael Sherman. Larry Ingram had an excused absence. CRA Staff Present: Debrah Forester, CRA Director; Tami Scott, Project Manager, Ellen Summers, Principal Redevelopment Specialist, and Shirley Garcia, Operations Coordinator. II. Adoption of Agenda: Al Schantzen made a motion to adopt the agenda as written, Steve Main seconded the motion. Motion passed unanimously. III. Approval of Minutes: Camille Kielty made a motion to approve the minutes, Al Schantzen seconded the motion. Motion passed unanimously. IV. Community / Business - Presentations V. Old Business: a. Public Arts Plan- Ms. Forester introduced Linda Flynn from Cultural Planning Group who attended in the Board Room, and Jerry Allen who attended virtually. Ms. Flynn provided an overview of the history, plan process and the goals and strategies. In February and March, a Community Outreach was completed, and a draft plan was submitted. In September, the draft plan was posted for community review and comment. The Plan includes a recommendation to contract with the State of Florida's designated Arts Agency, the United Arts Council, to implement several elements of the Plan including a Public Art Committee (PAC). The PAC subcommittee should be comprised of art and design professionals, residents with art background and CRA Advisory Board Members. If approved, this program will be a pilot that could be extended to other parts of the County. Regarding funding, several options are included in the plan including a percentage art fund ordinance. Ms. Forester gave a summary of the percentage for art program that could be established. If approved, a new development would be required to either install art on the site of contribute to the fund. Money allocated to the fund would be used to install art throughout the district as well as provide funds to maintain the art. The Percentage for Art program is being reviewed by the legal department. Ms. Flynn reviewed the proposed mural changes and the process. She noted that public art is a very specialized field and not just any artist can do public art. Al Schantzen asked how long would it take for the County to adopt this program and take it over because the CRA sunsets in a few years and he feels it's a burden on the CRA. Ms. Flynn stated that an implementation matrix will be added to the final document that will to ) -B410rVV Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA .Bayshore Beautification MSTU Haldeman Creek MSTU provide short term, mid-term, and a long-term goals. Steve Main had a concern of one mural per year and locking us into that limited amount. He wanted to know if the CRA chose to do more than one would that prohibit the staff from doing so? Also, what if one year they chose not do to any what would happen if that was the case. Mr. Main just didn't want to put any limitations on how many a year and does not like being committed with that criteria. Ms. Flynn stated they would change the language in the draft plan to make it more flexible. Mr. Main agreed to that, he doesn't want the obligation and feels the flexibility gives the opportunity to install murals on a case by case basis not on a year by year basis. Mike Sherman raised some concern on the strong focus on murals and he believes all types of public art should be encouraged. Ms. Flynn agreed and noted the plan does provide language to include all types of public art and encourages a diverse collection. She did note that it will take time to implement the program. Jerry Allen mentioned Art Programs throughout the US typically fund all types of art and the reason murals got so much attention in this plan was due to murals being the impetus to get this plan developed but does not limit public art to just murals. Ms. Flynn said she will change the language to make it clearer. Al Schantzen asked if the PAC subcommittee would recommend directly to the Board of County Commissioners and bypass the CRA Board. Ms. Forester wanted to clarify the plan recommends that a CRA Advisory Board member would be on the subcommittee and report directly back to the CRA Advisory Board with their recommendations first. Mr. Schantzen wanted to know if there was a geographical location required for the subcommittee. Ms. Flynn said they are recommending a resident, business owner or a specific interest in the district to be a part of the Subcommittee. Mr. Gutierrez had a question about the timeline of the CRA sunsetting and how is that going to impact the public arts program. Ms. Forester stated the goal is to have this program self -funded. Steve Main asked if it could transfer to the MSTU to manage. Ms. Forester said she would look at the MSTU ordinance to see if that function would be consistent with the responsibilities. One option would be to include a member of the Bayshore Beautification MSTU member on the PAC subcommittee. Public Comment was opened on this subject: Matt Riley, past president of the UAC & lifelong resident of Naples, wanted to thank everyone for their support for the Arts in Naples and the CRA District and wanted to express his full support. Bill Drackett thanked the UAC and the CRA Advisory Board for these first steps to bring the arts of all types to the area and the County as a whole. Donna Fiala spoke about having an interest in the PAC and wanted to volunteer to be on the subcommittee because she has always been committed to the area and the arts within the district. Alyssa Haney, President of Board of Directors of UAC and long-time resident spoke about her support and encourages art in the area to keep the younger generation interested in staying and thanked everyone for their consideration. L Mural Ordinance Proposed Changes - Ms. Forester noted that the current language in the Land Development Code references the proposed Cultural to ) -B410rVV Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA .Bayshore Beautification MSTU Haldeman Creek MSTU District which doesn't include the entire BGTCRA boundaries. She would like some input on the where murals would be allowed. She did have some discussion with the Chair regarding limiting to Bayshore Drive. Murals are allowed on civic, institutional, and commercial buildings. Ms. Flynn recommended expanding the boundaries. Mr. Allen suggested maintaining privately owned properties as well with the PAC process of approach. Ms. Beatty supports opening it up and expanding through the Gateway Triangle and partnering with privately owned properties. Steve Main supports expanding and include the entire boundary of the CRA District, Ms. Beatty concurred. Maurice Gutierrez agrees with all the Board members to benefit the whole district. Al Schantzen wanted to ask if there is a tax implemented as additional fee and the answer was no. Mr. Schantzen raised the issue on cost to implement the program. Ms. Forester noted the proposed contract with United Arts Council to implement the program which is $60,000 plus $15,000 to have UAC to have an office in the CRA. She also noted, an estimated $50,000 for the first year to have funds to begin the art installations in the district. Ms. Forester clarified again the Plan would cover the entire district and there is an opportunity to install art throughout the district. Ms. Forester requested to 2 separate motions for clarification on what was being asked tonight. Recommendation to approve the draft plan with the changes reflected during the meeting and taking it to the Board of County Commissioners and a separate motion on the contract with United Arts Council. Karen Beatty made a motion to move forward with the draft plan with the amendments as noted and recommend the changes to the BCC. Camille Kielty second the motion. Approved unanimous. ii. United Arts Council Contract — Steve Main made a motion to approve the $75,000 contract with United Arts Council and Camille Kielty second. Passed 7-0 and Karen Beatty abstained since she is a board member of UAC. b. CRA Parking Lot- Tami Scott stated that the contract with the lowest bidder - Fort Construction Group of Naples, Inc. for a total contract amount of $472,772.25, will be going to the BCC October 271h. Ms. Scott went over the description of the design and amenities that will be included in the parking lot and costs associated with that and discussed the management of the parking lot. Staff looked into several options before regarding managing the parking lot. Johnson Engineering provided an assessment that was included in the package. Staff is recommending a master meter to manage the lot and provide some revenues for maintenance. Users can pay hourly, daily, monthly on the machine, get a ticket and leave it on the dashboard. Ms. Scott needed to have the discussion early on in case she needs to amend the site plan to accommodate the placement of the master meter and electric needs. Al Schantzen was not in favor of metered parking he made a motion for selling the spots to businesses who needed parking to recoup some of the money. Maurice Gutierrez supported planning for future meter needs but not installing a meter now and he doesn't support selling the spots right now because we haven't seen the need yet. Ms. Scott is to ) -B410rVV Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA .Bayshore Beautification MSTU Haldeman Creek MSTU recommending putting a conduit with sleeve first and then can decide on how to manage the lot later. All the Board Members oppose a gate around the lot. Camille Kielty had one concern, if one particular business took over the parking lot with all their patrons and there not be an available parking spot for the public. Mr. Gutierrez was okay with that because it would have accomplished the goal of needing the parking lot. Ms. Forester wanted to recap what the advisory board expressed for the parking lot. They do not want to charge for parking now, staff to look at options for selling the spaces, and staff will be able to put in the necessary infrastructure for future need. Public Comment - Sandra Arafet is not in support of selling all the parking spots for businesses because as a resident she would like the opportunity to park there and walk if she wanted to and if all the spaces are sold for those businesses than the public would not have an opportunity to utilize the parking lot. She is in support of no gate, and it open for the public. Karen Beatty made a motion to put infrastructure first and develop an action plan to selling spaces for developments who need it for their required parking, Steve Main second the motion. Approved 7-1. c. Regulatory Changes update- Ms. Forester mentioned the Community outreach for October 29th and the letter that was sent out to the property owners that would be impacted by the changes. People are invited to attend via Zoom or in person. This is not a CRA Advisory Board meeting but a community forum. d. CRA Plan Quarterly projects update- Ms. Forester went over our short- term quarterly projects that was in the redevelopment plan. Al Schantzen requested more information on the connection to East Naples Park via Republic. Ms. Forester noted that project should be coordinated with the expansion/improvements of East Naples Community Park. The top priority is the connection to Sugden Park via the 17 acres. e. Stormwater Update — Ms. Forester reviewed the areas of concern and priorities identified by the Stormwater Subcommittee. Areas identified include Becca, Pine and Weeks; Gateway Triangle was divided into four quadrants - quadrant 1 and quadrant 4 were listed as top priorities out of the four. Staff is also recommending that when the design for the 17 acres is being completed, stormwater needs are incorporated for future development on the site as well as reviewing the needs of Jeepers Drive. Also noted was the alley way between US41 and Washington Ave. Ms. Forester mentioned the short time fix that was completed by Road Maintenance but noted it was not a long-term solution. The final area, Palmetto Court, the road is considered private and is not maintained by the County. Doing any improvements along it is challenging. Staff has meet with the staff from Naples Botanical Garden, who have worked with the residents along Palmetto Court to assist with drainage solutions. The subcommittee will be reviewing these sites at their next meeting and will be making a final recommendation to bring back to the Advisory Board. There are funds allocated to stormwater improvements in FY21 budget and Ms. Forester to ) -B410rVV Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA .Bayshore Beautification MSTU Haldeman Creek MSTU would like to partner with the stormwater department to move forward on design this year for one project in Bayshore and one in the Gateway Triangle area and then construction the following year. Steve Rigsbee noted his concern with raising the area in the point of the Triangle and its impact on the stormwater pond and all the maintenance issues in the neighborhood. Ms. Forester noted it can be discussed at the next subcommittee meeting. Steve Main wants to address the residential areas first and as a priority before anything else. Maurice Gutierrez agreed and that was one of the reasons why donating the Francis Ave lot to Stormwater Department was so important. Amy Patterson, Director of Capital Projects & Planning discussed the many maintenance issues they have in the Gateway Triangle, and they are looking at upgrading the Stormwater Pond automation now to prevent some of the issues they see now. Al Schantzen asked Amy Patterson if Windstar ever completed their outfall in their development because they were causing flooding to the neighboring properties. She will look into the matter. VI. New Business: a. December 1, 2020 meeting date change to December 8, 2020 — Ms. Forester asked the Advisory Board members if Thanksgiving holiday was too close for the regularly scheduled December 1" meeting or if they were okay with leaving the meeting on December 1st, the Board all agreed to leave it on December 1st no one anticipated to be out of town for the holiday. VIII. Staff Report: a. CRA Directors Report: Ms. Forester highlighted some of the projects within the area, the Mini -Triangle is scheduled to close on November 13; Del's Acquisition staff is continuing the due diligence and is conducting a Phase 2 environmental study and they may install a monitoring well if necessary. ROOF — staff assisted with a donation of another County owned property on Francis Avenue that will allow the organization to move forward on building a home in the area. Ms. Forester wanted to give another compliment to Road Maintenance for their work and cooperation for both resurfacing Becca and Pine and for filling in the pothole on the Washington Alley way. Staff is working on branding scope of work and staff is meeting to discuss the shuttle and community outreach via the coasters and posters that were discussed earlier this year. b. Project Manager Report: Tami Scott highlighted a few of the projects on her report: • Fire Suppression Phase II. The contractor almost done and working on the reimbursement from the City of Naples. • Fire Suppression Phase III. The bids have been completed and the contractor - Andrew Site Work- has been selected as the lowest bidder, this is another partnership with the City of Naples and needs to be to ) -B410rVV Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA •Bayshore Beautification MSTU Haldeman Creek MSTU completed by April 30, 2021. Staff anticipates work starting December I". Staff will have a kick-off meeting with the property owners for those streets included in this project. Construction of the CRA parking lot will begin around the same time so there will be two construction projects at the same time in the same area. • Thomasson Drive - The project is on schedule. Sidewalks will start going in on the opposite side of Thomasson Drive. Phase II of the Hamilton Ave improvement is getting ready to go out to bid. • The Bridge area continues to have small improvements implemented to refresh the area in the short-term. Christmas decorations will be installed in November. c. Private Development Update- Ellen Summers, provided updates on the new developments submitted into the County. Brookside Marina has come in to do a PUD rezone, proposing a commercial PUD boat rental and memberships, add 311 wet and dry slips, Camden Landing, PUD will be presenting to the advisory board soon. Steve Main asked who gives the density bonus units and what do they have to give for those density bonus units. Ms. Summers noted staff will be meeting with the developer to address that item. Ms. Forester reminded the board that they are working with Johnson Engineering to put some verbiage in the code to address the density unit allocations, the draft language will be presented to the Board at the next meeting. Sabal Bay PUD amendment to expand the boundary and add 230 units is scheduled for the Planning Commissioner on October 15ffi. The Hookah Lounge has submitted for building permit and the owner has plans to start construction as soon as the building permits are issued. The former Trio property on the point of US41 and Thomasson Drive, is under review for a SDP modification. d. Maintenance Report: Ms. Forester provided the current maintenance report. e. Financial Report: Ms. Forester provided the current financial report. IX. Other AI!ency's: a. Collier County Code Enforcement: Mr. Johnson noted his report included in the agenda packet and asked if anyone had any questions. Maurice Gutierrez asked about a privacy fence installed on a residential lot that the Marina is using as part of a commercial business. Mr. Johnson stated he had addressed the issue with Mr. Oreck, the owner, and he should no longer being using the lot to store boats. Maurice Gutierrez asked about temporary use parking for the old Marina on Bayshore Drive and Riverview, Mr. Johnson will investigate it. Al Schantzen asked about the 3 properties on Shoreview Drive. Mr. Johnson said the owner has been trying to evict the tenants but since COVID there was a ban on evictions. That ban has been lifted and the owner will pursue that avenue. Al Schantzen asked about the panhandlers in the area and Mr. Johnson will contact the Sheriff's Office to enforce the rules. He reminded everyone that if they see something unlawful to contact the Sheriff's Office immediately. to ) -B410rVV Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA .Bayshore Beautification MSTU Haldeman Creek MSTU b. Collier County Sheriffs Office: No Representative attended. X. Communications and Correspondence: a. City of Naples Height Restriction Article was provided if anyone had any questions. b. Sabal Bay public hearing date and time was provided if anyone wanted to attend that. c. Bayshore Arts and the Arts Plan Article was provided if anyone was interested. XI. Public Comments: None XII. Staff Comments: None XIII. Advisory Board General Communications: Maurice Gutierrez asked if all the Board members were all caught up with the purchase of Del's and closing of the gateway triangle properties. Maurice asked when we close does that help with addressing the tire shop that is out of the warehouse of Del's, Ms. Forester said yes, the tenants will receive a 60 day notice to vacate once the closing is complete. She also noted the buildings are not up to code so they would most likely be demolished. Al Schantzen wanted to say thank you for the work on the bridge and is looking good, Karen Beatty also thanked staff. There was discussion on the November 3rd meeting since it was voting day if they would like to move the meeting date, but the board was good with having it on the 3rd still. Everyone thanked Commissioner Fiala for all she has done for our district. Maurice Gutierrez thanked Commissioner Fiala for always supporting, being present and supporting the Community and for everything she has done for all these years. Karen Beatty thanked Commissioner Fiala for her initiative and efforts on the Bayshore Arts District and all she has done for this community as well. XIV. Next Meeting Date: a. November 3, 2020 @ 6pm XV. Adiournment — The meeting adjourned at 9:06 p.m. Chairman Maurice Gutierrez Item 5b EXTENSION OF PROJECT COMPLETION DATE FOR GRANT AGREEMENT BETWEEN COLLIER COUNTY COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY AND GRANTEE FOR COMMERCIAL BUILDING IMPROVEMENTS FOR BAYSHORE GATEWAY TRIANGLE COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AREA THIS AGREEMENT ENTERED this day of 2020 by and between the Collier County Community Redevelopment Agency (hereinafter referred to as "CRA") and Kurgis 1996 Irrevocable Trust (hereinafter referred to as "Grantee"). RECITALS: WHEREAS, On January 14, 2020, the Board of County Commissioners approved a Commercial Building Improvement Grant Agreement ("Agreement"), attached and incorporated by reference as "Exhibit A" in the amount of $6,854.50 dollars with a project completion date of January 14, 2020; and WHEREAS, Fire Code and Building Code permitting issues have prolonged the permitting process for timely completion of the project; and WHEREAS, the Commercial Building Improvement Grant Program allows time extensions of the project completion date if the applications for permits were submitted to Collier County within four months after execution of the grant agreement and construction of the improvements commenced within eight months after execution of the grant agreement; and WHEREAS, the applications for permits were submitted to Collier County on March 30, 2020 and construction of the improvements have commenced on August 27, 2020; and WHEREAS, the Board finds that circumstances exist to grant a time extension and finds that an extension of the project completion date to June 14, 2021 is appropriate. NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual covenants contained herein and other valuable consideration, the parties agree as follows: 1. The foregoing Recitals are true and correct and are incorporated by reference herein. 2. The project completion deadline set forth in Paragraph 4 of the Agreement is extended to June 14, 2021. This is the first extension of the project completion deadline. 3. All other terms and conditions of Agreement remains unchanged and are in full force and effect. This First Amendment merges any prior written and oral understanding and agreements, if any, between the parties with respect to the matters set forth herein. Item 5b IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have executed this Agreement on the day and year first written above. (1) (2) Witness Signature Printed/Typed Name Witness Signature Printed/Typed Name ATTEST: CRYSTAL K. KINZEL, Clerk , Deputy Clerk Approved as to form and legality: Jennifer Belpedio Assistant County Attorney GRANTEE: KURGIS 1996 IRREVOCABLE TRUST : Karen Kurgis Laws, Trustee COLLIER COUNTY COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY an , Chairman 2 Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA -Bayshore Beautification MSTU Haldeman Creek MSTU Item 5.e Sabal Bay PUD Rezone PL20190002305 South Bayshore Drive CCPC Hearing to be held on November 5 This PUD is expanding the boundaries to add 102 acres and 230 additional residential units. The developer has committed to continue informational meetings with the CRA Advisory Board until the construction on Tract R9 is completed (Section 8.9C of the PUD Ordinance). Additionally, Transportation Planning staff has reviewed the PUD petition for compliance with the GMP and the LDC and recommends approval with the following conditions of approval: Stipulation for Approval 1: "Upon request of the County, the developer of Tract R9, or its successors and assigns, shall pay its fair share payment and coordinate with Collier County on traffic calming improvements under the Neighborhood Traffic Management Program (NTMP) including but not limited to striping, signage, and speed tables on Bayshore Drive from the project access to Thomasson Drive. This commitment will expire the earlier of: 2 years after buildout of Tract R9 or turnover to the HOX Stipulation for Approval 2: "The developer of Tract R9 and its successors and assigns consent to Collier County including the entirety of the Tract R9 property in the Bayshore Beautification Municipal Service Taxing Unit (MSTU). This commitment is specific to Tract R9 and will expire 2 years after buildout of Tract R9." V—`� JCS �.L� — n'll , . • • . • • Y _ ` 1 _ • _ I /�/ i xv HNiu�u vriu�z[a nw��ceim wsrortrc .0 i • IhT NNI - Y- TYPEL' • i 6TRVLTr1RE mxr uses nma.vaan sw� �� 01FFER 116MNI r IIFROVEb — 2 r BRYSrOPE ORNE AMI �'11: RrGxT OFVVAV rb MIIWIM 9 � �� I HG FEAIHETEk YE•R Pf Iw{14 �s IE�TkTgN FFb6r b IRL MIf� �HyµlCl � iLL 1 R•9 Iz �1 PRESERVE TO PRINCIPAL STRuCTu RE,^...;; `��' PROPOSED NOT RESIDENTIAL THE ISLES ---ucLULUDED OF COLLIER 5 b Q 11 PRESERVE . _ - - � R IxPRCrvEO SwV9.ORE ORNE RIGxT CR Nuv I i by UiNE xT _ C MCI EAEEIAFHi _ . � ee a n zue. MIN POSSI&E _ h1TRALL _ rya' MIN. . • • _ • _ _ • nB SIiFFFR (:EE NOTEI `PRESERVE - TO SERVE AE - �• _ HIT xGTE�RI . ,•a�: _ INCLUDED PRESERVE TO LACE R� PROPOSED RESIDENTIAL OPEN SPArF SASAL SAY PUD A7DFrION ,a yAc-xbeu roz.oe Ac IOCu PRowEo MAIUMum DENSITY PRESERVE 39.9k ax ou.rarnE orxER rb.vk MAIUMUM DWELLING UNITS IYH b.61L For the complete staff report, please visit https://cvportal.colliercountyflgov/CitvViewWeb/Home/ and search for PL20190002305 under the Planning Department — Status and Fees link. 5.f - Gateway Triangle Stormwater Improvments Quadrant 4 - Priority 1 `+ '_�4 Yam! { A� '•� `row 16'JagJew s k. C. YNv harn��o"IillkrcIsrouper Dr IL • ;.„�'- .� 0 0 all im MTot _ WO mlow + i� OLou low.0 M FI61r1Ckef.DF :.� OW L-10 ply Y e 1i• Li - f g. #ns OM :416 On GQ s v, . :� . : " f rVIM IL Y 1, do Aerr': * ,#ice kLA # j'. `age no }p �} R r p 5 i f RPrfi" VAvra 1 , ., Uo w,T % ci 10 twin moo ��- �..�5L34�i3C t1 � � .� � � CS.. uN�� l ,�� LiiiiiilW ,j��- � •� t > Item 6a Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA ■Bayshore Beautification MSTU Haldeman Creek MSTU CRA Advisory Board Meeting Calendar 2021 Meetings are held on the first Tuesday of each month at 6:00 PM unless otherwise notified • January 12, 2021 — (Second week due to Holiday) • February 2, 2021- (Joint Meeting MSTU/CRA) • March 2, 2021 • April 6, 2021 Joint CRA/MSTU/BCC meeting 9am & 6pm CRA Advisory Meeting_ tentative • May 4, 2021 • June 8, 2021- (Second week due to Holiday) • July 13, 2021 - (Second week due to Holiday) • August 4, 2021- Summer Break tentative • September 1, 2021- Summer Break tentative • October 5, 2021 • November 2, 2021 • December 7, 2021 BCC Holiday Schedule 2021 The Board of County Commissioners recognizes the following holidays in 2021, observed on the dates listed below: • New Year's Day Friday, January 1, 2021 • Martin Luther King, Jr. Day Monday, January 18, 2021 • President's Day Monday, February 15, 2021 • Memorial Day Monday, May 31, 2021 • Independence Day Monday, Observed July 5, 2021 • Labor Day Monday, September 6, 2021 • Veteran's Day Thursday, November 11, 2021 • Thanksgiving Day Thursday, November 25, 2021 • Day After Thanksgiving Friday, November 26, 2021 • Christmas Eve Friday, December 24, 2021 • Christmas Day Monday, December 27, 2021 Offices: 3299 Tamiami Trail E, Unit 103, Naples, Florida 34112 Phone: 239-252-8844 Online: www.bayshorecra.com Bayshore CRA November2020 case iyumner case Type Description Late Enterea location Description lietanea Description j Windstar property causing flooding close topumps to drain directly into caller's yard causing flooding at 2533 CESD20200010394 SD Closed 09/24/2020 ;the end of Barrett Ave. ;Barrett Ave. ------------ - y---------------------------------- Windstar - at the end of Lakeview (actually ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Condo construction by Windstar is causing flooding on callers CEPM20200010398 --------------------------------------------- PM Closed 09/24/2020 ;Barrett is the flooding_ location) ---------------------- ;property ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Grass & weeds in excess of 18". Also - vegetative debris. CENA20200010414 ------------------- NA Open - 09/24/2020 ------- 50891000007 - 2596 HOLLY AVE - ----------------------------------------------------------- ;Inclusion to Mandatory lot Mowing propgram as of today 10/8/2020 - --------------------------------------------------------------------------- SS Closed 09/24/2020 --------- ;Frederick St & 41 ROW - ----------------------------------------------------------- ;Viral disinfection & Mold removal snipe signs in ROW t ------------------- ------------------------------ NA Closed 09/24/2020 Shadowlawn & US 41 - -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ;Abandoned shopping cart in the ROW CENA20200010530 NA Closed 09/28/2020 12721 Van Buren Ave ;Weeds/grass over 18 inches. CENA20200010531 I NA Closed 1 09/28/2020 12721 Van Buren Ave Weeds/grass over 18 inches. --------------------------------------------- +------------------------------- t--------- ---------------------- t----------------------------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------- t-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- CENA20200010533 NA Closed 1 09/28/2020 29281140003 Weeds/grass over 18 inches. __4------------------------------- F------------------------------- + + -----------------------------------------------------------t----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ;Bayshore CRA reports that a property is in severe stress and may not CEPM20200010542 ------------------- ------------------------------ PM Closed 09/29/2020 1942 Danford St - 61380360001 - ------------------------------------------------------------ -be inhabitable (email attached). NA Closed 10/05/2020 Pineland Ave./Lois St. near water towers ;several shopping carts in ROW + i + t-- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- CENA20200010844 --------------------------------------------------------------------------- NA Closed 10/06/2020 71780240009 - 3181 BAYSHORE DR ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Grass & weeds in excess of 18" on an unimproved parcel. CENA20200010923 ------------------- ----------- NA Closed - 10/08/2020 -------1 Bayshore & Lunar -------------------------------------------------- Snipe sign -Junk Cars - nailed to a utility pole ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- CENA20200010954 ---------------------------------------------•------------------------------'•-------------------------------'----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------1------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------' NA Open 10/08/2020 26880200101 - 1841 FREDERICK ST Grass & weeds in excess of 18' CENA20200010955 NA Open i 10/08/2020 26880240006 - 1885 FREDERICK ST ;Grass & weeds in excess of 18" ---------------------------------------------}-------------------------------------------------------------- +----------------------------------- ------ ____________________________---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------' CENA2020001095-- ------ ----02 --------- --------- NA ---------------- t -Open----------i---------10/08/2020--------+26880320007 ------------------------------------------------------------ Grass & weeds-in-excess-of-18' CENA20200010957 NA Open 10/08/2020 26880280008 Grass & weeds in excess of 18" CENA20200010959 _____________________________________________}_______________________________}_______________________________}________________________________________+__________________________________________________________________________________________-________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________. NA Closed 10/08/2020 ' Shadowlawn & 41 'Abandoned shopping carts in the ROW CEV20200011019 V 1 Open 10/10/2020 161380360001 - 1942 DANFORD ST ;Pick-up truck with no license tag. Vehicle may not run. i---------------------- F --------------------- i---------------------------------------- t------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ t------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ CESS20200011022 SS Closed 10/11/2020 ;Davis & Shadowlawn ;Junk Cars sign nailed to a utility pole in the ROW CEVR20200011023 -----------------------t-------------------------------t-------- VR Closed -------- 1 10/11/2020 ----------------------------------------t------------------------------ 12124 Frederick Street Naples F134113. ---------------------------t------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ::New Australian Pines growing on property CENA20200011066 NA Closed 10/12/2020 Weeks Ave & Bayshore Dr 'Abandoned shopping cart inth ROW ---------------------------------------------}-------------------------------------------------------------_-------- _______________________________________________________----------------------------------- t------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------, CENA20200011068 ----------- NA Closed -' 10/12/2020 ......... ;Thomasson Drive near the west wall of ICP -------------------------------------------------------------- ;Abandoned shopping cart in the ROW - NA Closed 10/12/2020 ;Orchard Lane & Thomasson Drive ;Abandoned shopping carts in the ROW CESS20200011074 SS Closed 10/12/2020 ;Orchard Lane near Thomasson Drive ;Junk Cars sign connected to county_ street sign in the ROW -` ------- b3�3 River Drive npermitted fence, see Contractor Licensing base TECV20200010963. CESD20200011144 SD Open 10/14/2020 Harmony Shores (61841680000) Bayshore CRA November2020 Neighbor buried a couple of construction steel bars in front of their CEPM20200011210 PM Open 10/15/2020 2556 STORTER AVE - 81732680005 property, so no one would park there. Inside their property. 48171200005 - 2800 Shoreview Dr Apt A's CEV20200011282 V Open 10/18/2020 parking spot Red GMC truck without a license plate CENA20200011318 NA Open 10/19/2020 2332 Sunset Ave - 75761920001 Over grown lawn a/c is leaking, mold in the carpet and the bathrooms, and she has a rat problem. She is moving,m but doesnt want next tenant to suffer a she CEPM20200011324 PM Open 10/19/2020 2715 Holly Ave - 50890360007 has. ITEM 8a — CRA PROJECT UPDATES — November 2020 1. MINI -TRIANGLE — 5.27 ACRE CATALYST SITE On April 26, 2016, approved a Real Estate Purchase Agreement with Real Estate Partners International, for $6,372,959. Cell tower lease has been terminated and the tower has been demolished through a cost sharing with REPI. Extension to Closing Date resulted in $25,000 additional non-refundable deposit and $2,118,000 additional deposit into escrow that can be used to purchase Del's property or other uses as authorized by the Board. Developer assigned the agreement to Metropolitan Naples, LLC. Closing scheduled for November 13, 2020. Developer's Agreement was approved by the BCC on October 27, 2020. 2. DEL'S PROPERTY ACQUISITION Due to additional due diligence requirements, closing date was extended to November 23, 2020. Review is complete and staff is proceeding to closing which is tentative scheduled November 20, 2020. Once CRA takes ownership, tenants will be given 60 days to vacate the property. Demolition of storefront buildings will be next step. 3. PUBLIC ART PLAN 4. 17 AC BOARDWALK Request for Proposal (RFP) is being drafted to include boardwalk and other park amenities and evaluate stormwater capacity. Due to cost of entire project RFP is required. The process for selection of consultant will take several months. M:1CLA01U1I01[el Paradise Advertising and Marketing, Inc. — New contract was approved by the BCC on October 13, 2020. Scope of work is being drafted. 6. COASTERS/SHUTTLE SERVICE — Staff is coordinating with Transit to initiate the survey. Anticipate starting it November 20 just before Thanksgiving. 7. LAND USE REGULATIONS — Property Owner meeting held on October 29. BGTCRA Advisory Board Special meeting scheduled for November 12 @ 5 p.m. Item 8b i Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA • Bayshore Beautification MSTU Haldeman Creek MSTU PROJECT UPDATES Tami Scott, November 3, 2020 Fire Suppression System- Phase 3: Phase 3 fire suppression contract is going before the Board of County Commissioners, on November 10, 2020, this project included Areca Ave., Coco Ave, Basin Street, Canal Street and Captains Cove. The CRA is jointly constructing this project with the City of Naples. The City of Naples retained the services of Johnson Engineering, Inc. Johnson Engineering is the engineer of record and has provided Construction Documents and Specifications for the project. The BGTCRA received an award of $300,000 fi•om the FY2018- 2019 U.S. Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) program. The Board approved the subrecipient agreement for that award at its June 25, 2019 meeting (Agenda Item # 16B). The Board also previously approved an Interlocal agreement with the City of Naples on September 10, 2019. That agreement outlines the County and City's responsibilities as to the project. The CRA is utilizing the HUD CDBG funds identified above, which is the extent of its monetary contribution, and the City is responsible for remitting the balance of the construction cost. The CRA is providing project management oversight and agreed to procure the contractor recommended for constructing the project, On August 14, 2020, the Procurement Services Division posted Invitation to Bid No. 20-7787 for the Bayshore Fire Suppression Phase 3 - Grant Funded project. The County sent 29,762 notices, and interested contractors downloaded sixty-three (63) bid packages. On September 15, 2020 the County received four (4) bid responses as summarized below. Staff recommends that the contract be awarded to Andrew Sitework, LLC, the lowest responsive and responsible bidder for a total contract amount of $658,560.00. Bidder Amount 1 Andrew Sitework, LLC $658,560.00 2 Douglas N. Higgins, Inc. $706,303.00 3 Quality Enterprises USA, Inc $709,442.60 4 Haskins, Inc. $770,324.50 CRA staff will provide the neighborhood with information once the contract has been approved, the contract schedule requires a 150-day substantial completion and a 180-day final completion. The scope of this project is limited to the replacement of the existing waterlines and installation of fire hydrants. This project does not include any stormwater enhancement or roadway upgrades. CRA parking lot: On October 13, 2020 the Board of County Commissioners, acting as the Community Redevelopment Agency Board, approved project No. 20-7773, Bayshore CRA Community Parking Lot, located at Coco Ave & Bayshore Drive, to Fort Construction Group of Naples, Inc., for the Base Bid in the amount of $481,317.25, plus add Substitution Line Item 56 in the amount of $22,165 and deleting Line Item 25 in the amount of $30,710, for a total contract amount of $472,772.25, and authorize the Chairman to sign the attached agreement. CRA staff will provide the neighborhood with information once the schedule has been established, The contract schedule requires a 150-day substantial completion and a 180-day final completion. Thomasson Drive: Phase 1 (Thomasson Drive including roundabout) CONTRACTSTATUS Time: October 21, 2020: Original Contract Time: Time Extensions Weather: Time Extensions Holidays: Time Extensions Other: Allowable Contract Time: Remaining Contract Days: Percent Complete: Original Completion Date: Current Adj. Completion Date: Sched. Substantial Completion Date: Sched. Final Completion Date: Finances: Original Contract Amount: Approved Change Orders: Current Contract Amount: % Paid to Date: Next Cut -Off Date: Day 169 of 373 335/365 1 Days 7 Days 0 Days (31 Days Pending for CO #2) 373 204 45.31% 04/05/202105/05/2021 04/13/202105/13/2021 04/01/2021 OS/01/2021 $6,022,618.68 $0.00 $6,022,618.68 Amount Paid to Date (as of 9/30/20): $1,417,205.64 23.53% 10/31/2020 This project is broken down into three phases, the conhactor is currently working on phase 2 and is expected to start phase 3 on or around January 1, 2020. Phase 1 Thomasson Dr west Phase 2 Thomasson Dr. East Phase 3 Roundabout Bayshore Bridge: Work is progressing in and around the bridge area, this is an ongoing process Bridge Planters The new bridge flower baskets were planted on 9-21-2020 they have been in place for approximately 8 weeks. The first set of baskets cost approximately $ 26.00 per basket, 14 baskets for a total of approximately $360.00. We have had few of the individual plants go missing, however no baskets have been removed or vandalized. The irrigation to the baskets does not appear to work, staff has not relied on the irrigation to water the baskets, staff hand waters the baskets three times a week. Baskets $ 360.00 Median planting $ 160.00 Bridge painting $3,400.00 Large ceramic planters $ 750,00 Misc. landscape maintenance $3,200.00 (removal of dead landscaping, install drip irrigation) Total $7,870.00 Holiday Decorations The next wave of work will focus on the holiday decorations. New flower baskets will be installed at the bridge and pagoda, holiday signs at the pagoda. Decorative lights on the royal palm trees, pagoda and palms in the bridge median will be installed the week of November 16". Staff will be installing the bromeliad tree and menorah that same week. Wooden platforms are being constructed and installed in median 18 and 19 to secure the bromeliad tree and menorah, the platforms will remain in place for future holiday decoration and community exhibits. Bromeliad holiday frame $1,940.00 Bromeliad holiday planting $1,500.00 Wooden platforms $ 480.00 Misc. landscape maintenance $ 500.00 (Banners, drip Irrigation) Baskets $ 420.00 Trimmers lighting $11,000.00 Misc. Planting $ 600.00 (Pagoda. Planters) Total $16,440.00 Hamilton Avenue: Phase 2 Barry Williams- Division Director - Parks & Recreation and Michael Cherbini- Project Manager 100% Construction documents have been issues to County staff for review and comment. The Parks & Recreation department attended the July 8, 2020 MSTU meeting to update the community on the project. FPL- Underground service: Associated with Thomasson drive project. PO has been opened and NTS sent to contractor. Florida Power and Light is scheduled to start on or about November 1, 2020. Landscape agreement: Staff has completed the editing of the existing landscape contract to include additional services. Staff is working with procurement to put the solicitation out to bid. �izear�ir�v'� vrt. �J�vv�w Item 8 c Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA -Bayshore Beautification MSTU Haldeman Creek MSTU Private Development Update Zoning Petitions Brookside Marina, CPUD Rezone: PL20190001540 Location: 2015 and 2025 Davis Blvd. Status: First GMD Review Letter sent out on 8/24/2020. Pending resubmittal from applicant. The applicant is rezoning this property to a Commercial PUD in order to restore wet slips in the western basin and allow for recreational boat rental operations (Freedom Boat Club). Generally, the CPUD is proposing 3 tracts, with permitted uses that range from marina, rental boat operations, wet slips and associated uses. This site qualifies for 311 wet and dry slips, due to their `preferred' ranking under the County's Manatee Protection Plan. HOLIDAY LANE ^ot HARBOR U+NE 1 I I - I � O qM DAVIS BOULEVARD (SR 80) 9M 9� F9S S gmeensite Camden Landing, PUDA and GMPA: PL20190001364 and PL20190001387 Location: 2801 Thomasson Drive, Folio 61840560008 Status: Under review, and pending CRA comments Proposed amendment to the Cirrus Point PUD to rename to Camden Landing to allow 127 multi -family dwelling units, utilizing 97 units from the Bayshore Density Pool. This project is proposing market rate housing, with development standards allowing 4 stories above parking. This project is also seeking a GMPA to receive the 97-density bonus unit as it currently does not meet the GMPA criteria without an amendment. Page 1 of 5 �izear�ir�v'� vrt. �J�vv�w Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA -Bayshore Beautification MSTU Haldeman Creek MSTU Item 8 c Sabal Bay PUD Rezone: PL20190002305 Location: South Bayshore Drive Status: CCPC Hearing to be held on 11-5-2020. This PUD is expanding the boundaries to add 102 acres and 230 additional residential units. snenL Bar au❑ PROPOSED Naples Boat Yard PUD Rezone: PL20200000007 Location: 2775 Bayview Drive Status: Pre -Application Meeting held on 1-22-2020; no applications have been submitted at this time. This rezone requests to allow commercial uses in the single-family home district and the vacant lot located next to it. No additional information at this time. Bayshore Food Wine Venue Alcohol Beverage Distance Waiver: PL20120001934 Location: NE Area of Bayshore Drive and Becca (Folio 71580240005, and 71580220009) Status: Under Review The request for a waiver of the 500-foot separation between establishments whose primary function is the sale of alcoholic beverages for consumption on -site, to allow for a 100.3-foot separation between the Celebration Food Truck park and the Bayshore Wine and Food Venue. Page 2 of 5 �izear�ir�v'� vrt. �J�vv�w Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA -Bayshore Beautification MSTU Haldeman Creek MSTU Item 8 c Development Review Petitions Gateway of Naples SDPA: PL20200000526 Location: Corner of Davis Blvd and US41 (Folio 00386880009 and 00386840007) Status: Corrections letter issued on 10-09-2020. Pending resubmittal from applicants. This site has a previously approved Site Development Plan. The applicant is requesting a redesign. This project includes 24 condo units, 120 hotel units, restaurant space, 204 parking spaces, and 9 stories in height. WSA Bayshore Boutique Hotel SDP: PL2020001971 Location: SE of Bayshore Drive and Lunar St (Folio 5335336000, 53353320002, and 53353400003) Status: Pre -Application Meeting held on 10-20-2020. Plans have not yet been submitted for review This project proposes a two-story commercial building. The first floor will consist of retail commercial. The second floor will contain a 5-bedroom boutique hotel room. srre;�_h euFFEa �•-- -�- — moo: W ovEUNE�_ t I w 6uILI�� I x --LI".F � T,.. I O O 0 I e — FFIE 1 I1tl' 11' Arr�'_E -II A—L i'T FLrz,- - nI.— ,.F INE � awLo y -T 11 Q --7 — .ter =.� J L—;--f - ' --c — •7-- • — — — — —• ---- a �. ` WSA - BAYSHORE CONCEPT SITE PLAN Page 3 of 5 �izear�ir�v'� vrt. �J�vv�w Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA •Bayshorc Beautification MSTU Halcicinan Creek MSTU Item 8 c Bayshore Food Wine Venue SDP: PL20190002611 Location: NE Area of Bayshore Drive and Becca (Folio 71580240005, and 71580220009) Status: Pending Resubmittal. Last review letter went out on 3/03/2020 Proposed 9,350 sq. ft. retail/office/restaurant/warehouse on vacant land. This project is currently seeking to remedy potential turn lane requirements prior to continuing SDP review. Courthouse Shadows SDPA: PL20200000554 Location: 3290 Tamiami Trail East, Folio 28750000028 Status: Utility Relocation Approved and work has commenced. Pending submittal for SDP for the redevelopment Things I like by Catherine LLC SIP: PL20190002153 Location: 3954 Bayshore Drive Status: SIP has been approved, CBIG approved, and pending final building permit approvals. Redevelopment of existing residential structure into a commercial art gallery. Naples Botanical Garden Horticultural Campus SDP: PL20190002586 Location: 4820 Bayshore Drive Status: Pre -application meeting held on 12-18-2019. Plans have not yet been submitted for review. The purpose of this application is to modify and expand the previously permitted grow house and recycle center to include the new horticultural center. The horticultural center will include several new various grow/green houses, office building and maintenance shop. Fifth Third Bank SDPA: PL20190001097 Location: 2898 Tamiami Trail East Status: Corrections letter issued on 10-19-2020. Pending resubmittal from applicant. New Fifth Third Bank at the corner of Tamiami Trail and Bayshore Blvd Doggy Day Care & Storage Units SDP and APR: PL20200000020 and PL20200001991 Location: 2435 Pine Street Status: Under Review This project proposes approximately 7,156 square feet of a dog daycare facility, and a private storage building of approximately 7,852 square feet. The APR requests the reduction of 2 required parking spaces. Page 4 of 5 Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA •Bayshore Beautification MST Haldeman Creek MSTU Item 8 c Sunbelt Rentals SDP: PL20200000188 Location: 2560 Davis Blvd. Status: Approved and construction to commence Sunbelt Rentals is currently leasing three properties along Davis Boulevard. They are looking to construct a new building on the far east parcel, leave the existing business operational, receive a temporary CO on the new building and complete the site by demolishing the existing building and constructing a new parking and storage area. Law Offices SDP: PL20200001177 Location: 3080 Tamiami Trail East Status: No submittals following pre -application meeting This project proposes to demolish the existing structure and replace with a new 3-story office building. Gateway Mini Triangle PPL: PL20200001193 Location: Mini -triangle parcels 2054 Davis Blvd. Status: No submittals following pre -application meeting. This project proposes to create 3 separate parcels with the intent to have separate SDP's for each parcel. Final Plat - Barrett Ave: PL20200000908 Location: 2556 Barrett Avenue Status: No materials have been submitted following pre -application meeting Project proposes to split current lot into 4 lots. Compass Place SDP: PL20180003671 Location: 3010-3050 Thomasson Drive Status: Under construction This project consists of two 15,788 square feet, 10-unit, multi -family structures. Nick's Restaurant and Houka Lounge: PRBD 20200206652 Location: 3091 Tamiami Trail East (Corner of US41 and Andrew Dr.) Status: Under Review This project proposes a restaurant and houka lounge with mainly outdoor dining. The existing building will be renovated to increase the square footage under air and will include an open-air addition. Page 5 of 5 Item 8d October 2020 Maintenance Report MOE Need to replace speed limit and pedestrian Field Check on all Will walk the district to sign on missing signs in determine all signs Install the week of Completed all 8 Bayshore Dr district needed to be replaced 1 /30/2020 9/28/20 signs replacements 10/11 /2020 Received a call back was on schedule to Supervisor Marshall from Road Maintenance remove the week of Miller from RM Reported that rusty was waiting for Traffic 10/22/20 emailed emailed it is Culdesac old guardrail needs Ops to let them know to supervisor for status scheduled for Jeepers Dr to be removed remove 10/6/2020 report 10/27/20 removal 10/28/20 Drove down and determined 2 lights it was reported lights Had to wait until Changed out the before colonial turning off when it is Purchase Order was necessary lumins Lights on down to holly ave still dark outside from open to submit work and rescheduled South was not working Colonial down to holly order for repair timer turn off Bayshore properly Ave 9/28/2020 received PO dawn to dusk. 10/5/2020 Maintenance Hire contractor to Out to bid to hire received one Bayshore fix Pavers on an as annual contractor for No bids received as of contractor as of Drive request need basis two year period 10/1 /2020 10/12/20 10/22/20. C RA Low Mowing Out to bid to hire Waiting on request for Maintain all 15 CRA annual contractor for Lowest bidder DM&tl Purchase order to quotes owned properties- two year period 10/1 /2020 Lawn Services begin Small Projects To assist staff with Out to bid to hire Waiting on Request for any small projects annual contractor for 2 Lowest bidder YRY insurance from quotes needed year period 110/1 /2020 Homes vendor Fund 187 Bayshore/Gateway Triangle Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt Budget Tot Adopt Budget Carr F Amendme Tot Amend Budget Commitment Actual Available **** Grand Total-Fund/CI *** 187 BAYSHORE/GATEWAY TRI 813,856.11 34,455.99 848,312.10- ** REVENUE Sub Total 9,111,900.00- 9,111,900.00- 621,999.00- 9,733,899.00- 9,733,899.00- REVENUE - OPERATING Sub -Total 6,437,900.00- 6,437,900.00- 6,437,900.00- 6,437,900.00- 361180 INVESTMENT INTEREST 40,000.00- 40,000.00- 40,000.00- 40,000.00- 364220 SURPLUS LAND SALES 6,397,900.00- 6,397,900.00- 6,397,900.00- 6,397,900.00- CONTRIBUTION AND TRANSFERS Sub-T 2,674,000.00- 2,674,000.00- 621,999.00- 3,295,999.00- 3,295,999.00- 481001 TRANS FRM 001 GEN FD 1,915,000.00- 1,915,000.00- 1,915,000.00- 1,915,000.00- 481111 TRANS FRM 111 UNINC 433,500.00- 433,500.00- 433,500.00- 433,500.00- 481163 TRANS FRM 163 BAYSHO 125,500.00- 125,500.00- 125,500.00- 125,500.00- 481164 TRANS FRM 164 HALDEM 11,300.00- 11,300.00- 11,300.00- 11,300.00- 481186 TRANS FRM 186 IMM RE 74,100.00- 74,100.00- 74,100.00- 74,100.00- 489200 CARRY FORWARD GENERAL 436,500.00- 436,500.00- 436,500.00- 436,500.00- 489201 CARRY FORWARD OF ENC 621,999.00- 621,999.00- 621,999.00- 489900 NEG 5% EST REV 321,900.00 321,900.00 321,900.00 321,900.00 ** EXPENSE Sub Total 9,111,900.00 9,111,900.00 621,999.00 9,733,899.00 813,856.11 34,455.99 8,885,586.90 * PERSONAL SERVICE 446,200.00 446,200.00 446,200.00 58,513.00 10,212.76 377,474.24 * OPERATING EXPENSE 406,400.00 406,400.00 21,999.00 428,399.00 155,343.11 24,243.23 248,812.66 631400 ENGINEERING FEES 50,000.00 50,000.00 50,000.00 22,278.12 27,721.88 631600 APPRAISAL FEES 7,500.00 7,500.00 7,500.00 7,500.00 634207 IT CAPITAL ALLOCATION 2,400.00 2,400.00 2,400.00 2,400.00 634210 IT OFFICE AUTOMATION 13,300.00 13,300.00 13,300.00 13,300.00 634970 INDIRECT COST REIMBU 60,500.00 60,500.00 60,500.00 60,500.00 634980 INTERDEPT PAYMENT 6,000.00 6,000.00 6,000.00 534.00 5,466.00 634999 OTHER CONTRACTUAL SE 207,100.00 207,100.00 21,999.00 229,099.00 45,091.93 23,495.96 160,511.11 640300 TRAVEL PROF DEV 6,000.00 6,000.00 6,000.00 6,000.00 641230 TELEPHONE ACCESS CHG 1,800.00 1,800.00 1,800.00 1,800.00 641700 CELLULAR TELEPHONE 1,300.00 1,300.00 1,300.00 1,300.00 641900 TELEPHONE SYSTEM SUP 1.37 1.37- 641950 POSTAGE FREIGHT AND UPS 1,000.00 1,000.00 1,000.00 1,000.00 643100 ELECTRICITY 552.22 47.78 600.00- 643400 WATER AND SEWER 2,200.00 2,200.00- 644620 LEASE EQUIPMENT 2,000.00 2,000.00 2,000.00 3,696.84 1,696.84- 645100 INSURANCE GENERAL 3,300.00 3,300.00 3:300.00 3,300.00 645260 AUTO INSURANCE 500.00 500.00 500.00 500.00 646180 BUILDING RM ISF 45.38 45.38- 646430 FLEET MAINT ISF 200.00 200.00 200.00 200.00 646445 FLEET NON MAINT 300.00 300.00 300.00 300.00 647110 PRINTING AND OR BIND 5,000.00 5,000.00 5,000.00 5,000.00 648170 MARKETING AND PROMO 5,000.00 5,000.00 5,000.00 5,000.00 649100 LEGAL ADVERTISING 4,500.00 4,500.00 4,500.00 1,425.00 75.00 3,000.00 651110 OFFICE SUPPLIES GENERAL 3,000.00 3,000.00 3,000.00 3,000.00 651210 COPYING CHARGES 7,000.00 7,000.00 7,000.00 7,000.00 Fund 187 Bayshore/Gateway Triangle Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt Budget Tot Adopt Budget Carr F Amendme Tot Amend Budget Commitment Actual Available 651910 MINOR OFFICE EQUIPMENT 1,500.00 1,500.00 1,500.00 1,500.00 651930 MINOR OFFICE FURNITURE 1,500.00 1,500.00 1,500.00 1,500.00 651950 MINOR DATA PROCESS 1,000.00 1,000.00 1,000.00 1,000.00 652210 FOOD OPERATING SUPPLIES 1,000.00 1,000.00 1,000.00 1,000.00 652490 FUEL AND LUB ISF 200.00 200.00 200.00 200.00 652920 COMPUTER SOFTWARE 3,000.00 3,000.00 3,000.00 3,000.00 652990 OTHER OPERATING SUPP 2,000.00 2,000.00 2,000.00 99.00 43.74 1,857.26 654110 BOOKS PUB SUBS 500.00 500.00 500.00 500.00 654210 DUES AND MEMBERSHIPS 4,000.00 4,000.00 4,000.00 4,000.00 654360 OTHER TRAINING EDUCA 4,000.00 4,000.00 4,000.00 4,000.00 * CAPITAL OUTLAY 1,500.00 1,500.00 600,000.00 601,500.00 600,000.00 1,500.00 763100 IMPROVEMENTS GENERAL 600,000.00 600,000.00 600,000.00 764900 DATA PROCESSING EQUI 1,500.00 1,500.00 1,500.00 1,500.00 * TRANSFERS 7,207,300.00 7,207,300.00 7,207,300.00 7,207,300.00 910010 TRANS TO 001 GEN FD 53,800.00 53,800.00 53,800.00 53,800.00 912870 TRANS TO 287 CRA 3,253,000.00 3,253,000.00 3,253,000.00 3,253,000.00 917870 TRANS TO 787 BAYCRA 3,200,000.00 3,200,000.00 3,200,000.00 3,200,000.00 921600 ADV/REPAY TO 160 700,500.00 700,500.00 700,500.00 700,500.00 * RESERVES 1,050,500.00 1,050,500.00 1,050,500.00 1,050,500.00 991000 RESV FOR CONTINGENCI 85,000.00 85,000.00 85,000.00 85,000.00 993000 RESV FOR CAPITAL OUT 965,500.00 1 965,500.00 1 1 965,500.00 1 1 1 965,500.00 Fund 787 Bayshore CRA Project Fund Comm Item BCC Adopt Budget Tot Adopt Budget Carr F Amendme Amendments Tot Amend Budget Commitment Actual Available **** Grand Total-Fund/CI *** 787 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 6,198,515.53- 6,198,515.53- REVENUE Sub Total 3,200,000.00- 3,200,000.00- 2,998,515.53- 6,198,515.53- 6,198,515.53- CONTRIBUTION AND TRANS 3,200,000.00- 3,200,000.00- 2,998,515.53- 6,198,515.53- 6,198,515.53- 481187 TRANS FRM 187 3,200,000.00- 3,200,000.00- 3,200,000.00- 3,200,000.00- 489201 CARRY FORWARD 2,998,515.53- 2,998,515.53- 2,998,515.53- EXPENSE Sub Total 3,200,000.00 3,200,000.00 2,998,515.53 6,198,515.53 6,198,515.53 * OPERATING EXPENSE 100,000.00 100,000.00 133,400.00 200.00 233,600.00 233,600.00 631650 ABSTRACT FEES 7,600.00 7,600.00 7,600.00 631800 ENVIRONMENTAL 25,000.00 25,000.00 25,000.00 634999 OTHER CONTRAC 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 639990 OTHER CONTRAC 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 649030 CLERKS RECORD 800.00 200.00 1,000.00 1,000.00 * CAPITAL OUTLAY 1,400,000.00 1,400,000.00 2,618,000.00 4,018,000.00 4,018,000.00 761100 LAND CAPITAL 2,118,000.00 2,118,000.00 2,118,000.00 763100 IMPROVEMENTS 1,400,000.00 1,400,000.00 500,000.00 1,900,000.00 1,900,000.00 * GRANTS AND DEBT SERVIC 200,000.00 200,000.00 247,115.53 200.00- 446,915.53 446,915.53 884200 RESIDENTIAL R 200,000.00 200,000.00 247,115.53 200.00- 446,915.53 446,915.53 * RESERVES 1,500,000.00 1,500,000.00 1,500,000.00 1,500,000.00 993000 RESV FOR CAPI 1,500,000.00 1,500,000.00 1,500,000.00 1,500,000.00 Fund 787 Project 50197 Residential Grants Fund Comm Item BCC Adopt Budget Tot Adopt Budget Carr F Amendme Amendments Tot Amend Budget Commitment Actual Available **** Grand Total-Fund/CI *** 50197 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 100,000.00 100,000.00 77,327.00 177,327.00 177,327.00 ** EXPENSE Sub Total 100,000.00 100,000.00 77,327.00 177,327.00 177,327.00 * OPERATING EXPENSE 173.00- 173.00 649030 CLERKS RECORD 173.00- 173.00 * GRANTS AND DEBT SERVIC 100,000.00 100,000.00 77,500.00 173.00- 177,327.00 177,327.00 884200 RESIDENTIAL R 100,000.00 100,000.00 77,500.00 173.00- 177,327.00 177,327.00 Fund 787 Project 50198 Commercial Grants Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt Bud et Tot Adopt Bud et CarryF Amendme Amendments Tot Amend Bud et Commitment Actual Available **** Grand Total-Fund/CI *** 50198 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 100,000.00 100,000.00 169,588.53 269,588.53 269,588.53 ** EXPENSE Sub Total 100,000.00 100,000.00 169,588.53 269,588.53 269,588.53 * OPERATING EXPENSE 27.00- 27.00 649030 CLERKS RECORD 27.00- 27.00 * GRANTS AND DEBT SERVIC 100,000.00 100,000.00 169,615.53 27.00- 269,588.53 269,588.53 884200 RESIDENTIAL R 100,000.00 1 100,000.00 1 169,615.53 1 27.00 269,588.53 1 1 1 269,588.53 Fund 787 Project 50203 Stormwater Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt Budget Tot Adopt Budget Tot Amend Budget Commitment Actual Available **** Grand Total-Fund/CI *** 50203 BAYSHORE CRA PROJE 550,000.00 550,000.00 550,000.00 550,000.00 ** EXPENSE Sub Total 550,000.00 550,000.00 550,000.00 550,000.00 * CAPITAL OUTLAY 550,000.00 550,000.00 550,000.00 550,000.00 763100 IMPROVEMENTS 550,000.00 550,000.00 550,000.00 550,000.00 Fund 787 Project 50204 Linwood Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt Budget Tot Adopt Budget Tot Amend Budget Commitment Actual Available **** Grand Total-Fund/CI *** 50204 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 ** EXPENSE Sub Total 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 * CAPITAL OUTLAY 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 763100 IMPROVEMENTS 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 Fund 787 Project 50206 Ackerman -Dells Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt Budget Tot Adopt Budget CarryF Amendme Tot Amend Budget Commitment Actual Available **** Grand Total-Fund/CI *** 50206 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 600,000.00 600,000.00 2,151,600.00 2,751,600.00 2,751,600.00 ** EXPENSE Sub Total 600,000.00 600,000.00 2,151,600.00 2,751,600.00 2,751,600.00 * OPERATING EXPENSE 100,000.00 100,000.00 33,600.00 133,600.00 133,600.00 631650 ABSTRACT FEES 7,600.00 7,600.00 7,600.00 631800 ENVIRONMENTAL 25,000.00 25,000.00 25,000.00 639990 OTHER CONTRAC 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 649030 CLERKS RECORD 1,000.00 1,000.00 1,000.00 * CAPITAL OUTLAY 500,000.00 500,000.00 2,118,000.00 2,618,000.00 2,618,000.00 761100 LAND CAPITAL 2,118,000.00 2,118,000.00 2,118,000.00 763100 IMPROVEMENTS 500,000.00 500,000.00 500,000.00 500,000.00 Fund 787 Project 50207 Bayshore Parking Lot Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt Budget CarryF Amendme Amendments Tot Amend Budget Commitment Actual Available **** Grand Total-Fund/CI *** 50207 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 500,000.00 500,000.00 500,000.00 ** EXPENSE Sub Total 500,000.00 500,000.00 500,000.00 * CAPITAL OUTLAY 500,000.00 500,000.00 500,000.00 763100 IMPROVEMENTS 500,000.00 500,000.00 500,000.00 Fund 787 Project 50208 17 Acre Site Fund / Comm Item BCC Adopt Budget Tot Adopt Budget CarryF Amendme Tot Amend Budget Commitment Actual Available **** Grand Total-Fund/CI *** 50208 BAYSHORE CRA PROJEC 250,000.00 250,000.00 100,000.00 350,000.00 350,000.00 ** EXPENSE Sub Total 250,000.00 250,000.00 100,000.00 350,000.00 350,000.00 * OPERATING EXPENSE 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 634999 OTHER CONTRAC 100,000.00 100,000.00 100,000.00 * CAPITAL OUTLAY 763100 250,000.00 250,000.00 250,000.00 250,000.00 IMPROVEMENTS 250,000.00 250,000.00 250,000.00 250,000.00 TRYING TO BUILD ON THE TRIANGLE Developer has ideas; commission wants to discuss Laura Layden Naples Daily News I USA TODAY NETWORK — FLORIDA A buyer has emerged with serious plans for a long -eyed redevelopment site in East Naples. The multimillion -dollar deal, however, is anything but certain. Whether the deal closes could depend on whether Collier County agrees to provide tax rebates to the interested buyer David Parker, a developer with P6NT LLC, who has the high -profile site at the corner of U.S. 41 and Davis Boulevard under contract. Naples land -use attorney Rich Yovanovich, who represents the developer, asked county commissioners Tuesday to consider the request for taxpayer -funded incentives to support a proposed condo -hotel project on the property at a future board meeting. Commissioners voted 4-1 to bring the request back for an indepth discussion and final decision in a few weeks, with Penny Taylor casting a firm vote of no. Taylor argued the once -sleepy Bayshore/Gateway Triangle redevelopment area where the property sits has awakened, attracting projects without the need for county incentives. When the developer asked why she didn't support the incentives in a discussion before Tuesday's meeting, when it's offered by other The slte ILI G The #riwgle site In !' - gaet Napfesw here Trio '�.. Wag once planned r`ow 'til 1 hasa neW devekper 5 +Or a rgdenned } {4n�4-�i4#el QL4f eit Gn Me roughly two -acre Property, .} but whather it pets built caved depend on re ' whether Cpltipr 'Y Cou nfyiNrccs. M ie appma tam mbpW i. 'v :} r Jol TRYING TO BUILD Taylor counties, such as Palm Beach, she told her fellow commissioners her answer was simple. "You're within walking distance to the Naples beach, within walking distance to Fifth Avenue. That's why," she said. While other commissioners voted to bring the request for incentives back for a vote, they all did so with reservations and caution fl ❑ ags. Commissioner Donna Fiala, who represents East Naples, pointed out the rebates were a big ask by the developer — with an estimated value of more than $1.9 million through 2030. For that reason, she said it's not something she could support, although she voted in favor of allowing it to come back for more discussion. "We can't give this away because it leaves us with about nothing," she said of the requested dollars. "So I'm really opposed to it." The money would come from a tax increment fi ❑ nancing district, which has allowed the county to capture gains on real estate values since 2000 to make community improvements and spur private development through a Community Redevelopment Agency, or CRA. While the county has provided incentives to other developers as "inspiration money" to reinvigorate the area, Fiala said, the commission has decided to bring the CRA to an end by 2030, rather than to extend its life, over her objections. In the past, Fiala has argued there's still much work to be done in the area with the remaining dollars, from repairing roads and improving sidewalks to adding more parking and street lighting. The Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA covers 1,800 acres north and south of the Bayshore Drive-U.S. 41 East intersection, including the triangle where U.S. 41 and Davis Boulevard come together like a pizza slice. Commissioner Bill McDaniel made the motion to bring the requested incentives back for more board discussion. It was seconded by Commission Chairman Burt Saunders. During a brief discussion, Saunders said the developer will have to overcome some "very signifi ❑ cant concerns" about his request, including the precedent it could set for others to ask for the same kind of dollars. "What about the next guy that is going to come in and ask for the same thing? That would be a real hard hurdle for me to get over," he said. With such a big investment from the county, Saunders said he would also need to see more detail about the kind of return it would get. McDaniel shared the concerns raised by other commissioners, including Fiala. He said the money shouldn't be "a slam dunk" for this developer or any others and the request should be looked at from "a policy standpoint." Commissioner Andy Solis said the developer and his attorney should get the chance to "make their case" for why the county through its CRA should help fund the project. He said county staff❑ is "not necessarily behind it," but they should study it further so they can make a formal recommendation one way or the other. "There have been some issues that have been identifi ❑ ed already," he said. "But I think in fairness we should at least let them do their analysis." The roughly 2-acre site targeted for redevelopment has a rocky past. The property — at 1705 and 1807 U.S. 41 East — sits vacant after several failed attempts by others to redevelop it. Originally, it was targeted for a luxury condo -hotel called Trio. That project fell apart after the developer Anthony Fortino fi ❑ led for personal bankruptcy in 2018. The property has diff ❑ erent owners now. Parker has also proposed a high -end condo -hotel project, with a planned investment Yovanovich valued at nearly $100 million. The project would include a 120room hotel, along with 24 residential condos and a restaurant, which would be open to guests and owners, as well as local residents and visitors alike. Yovanovich argued the county should consider the same incentives for the developer as it awarded for a neighboring project on county -owned land. That land is still under contract by developers Jerry Starkey and Fred Pezeshkan with Real Estate Partners International in Naples, whose proposed project includes a 200-plus hotel. While Starkey and Pezeshkan have had the county's property under contract for nearly four years, Parker is poised to close on the adjacent property and to quickly start construction, Yovanovich said, arguing it would come fi ❑ rst — acting as the real catalyst the county has sought in the mini- triangle area for 20 years. "We still don't have really the fi❑rst project to come out of the ground for this redevelopment area," the attorney said. "And Mr. Parker is hopeful to be the fi ❑ rst project to actually come out of the ground." While the original design for Trio had "many, many fill aws," those have been addressed in a new design, Yovanovich said, and the quality of its architecture is sure to spur development all along Davis Boulevard. The developer has already submitted a site plan for the project to the county. Yovanovich gave a run-down of the timeline and performance goals the developer has committed to that would have the project "up and running" by July 2023. "There are performance guidelines that must be met in order for there to be any rebate of any tax," he said. "So we are not asking for a hope and a wish. We have a specifi ❑ c timeline that we will meet in order to be able to get the tax rebate." To further his arguments for the tax incentives, Yovanovich shared the expected economic impact from the project. During build -out, the project is anticipated to create roughly 200 construction- related jobs. The hotel would have about 100 employees and it's expected to indirectly support another 900 jobs in the local economy, Yovanovich said. He told commissioners that Parker has opportunities to develop elsewhere on Florida's east coast, namely Palm Beach, taking his roughly $100 million investment with him. "He would rather develop here," Yovanovich said. "Over here and take the risk. And it's a signifi ❑ cant risk to be the fi ❑ rst developer to come out of the ground in this triangle piece of property." The developer, he said, will fund a feasibility study that will be shared with county staff[] to help with its review and analysis before coming up with a recommendation for county commissioners. For the commission's vote, Yovanovich said he would be ready to address the many hurdles and concerns they've raised. Fiala Saunders (c) Naples Daily News Powered by TECNAVIA Thursday, 10/15/2020 Page .A01 (c) Naples Daily News