Loading...
HEX Final Decision 2020-08 HEX NO. 2020-08 HEARING EXAMINER DECISION DATE OF HEARING. September 10, 2020 PETITION. PETITION NO. BDE-PL20190001536 — Michael J. Doheny, Trustee of the Michael J. Doheny Trust,requests a new boathouse pursuant to Section 5.03.06.F of the Collier County Land Development Code, and a 1.1 foot boat dock extension over the maximum 20 feet allowed by Section 5.03.06 of the Land Development Code,for a total protrusion of 21.1 feet, to accommodate an existing docking facility with one boat slip including one boat-lift,for the benefit of property described as Lot 15,Block S, of Conner's Vanderbilt Beach Estates Unit 3, also described as 250 Egret Avenue, in Section 29, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida. STAFF RECOMMENDATION. Approval with conditions. FINDINGS. 1. The public hearing for this Petition was properly noticed and conducted in accordance with all County and state requirements. 2. The public hearing was conducted electronically and in-person in accordance with Emergency/Executive Order 2020-04. 3. The Petitioner and/or Petitioner's representative executed the Hybrid Virtual Quasi-Judicial Public Hearing Waiver related to conducting the public hearing electronically and in-person. 4. The Petitioner and/or Petitioner's representative presented the Petition, followed by County staff and then public comment. ANALYSIS. Based on a review of the record including the Petition, application, exhibits, the County's staff report, and hearing comments and testimony from the Petitioner and/or the Petitioner's representative(s), County staff and any given by the public, the Hearing Examiner finds that there is sufficient competent,substantial evidence as applied to the criteria set forth in Section 5.03.06.H. of the Land Development Code to approve Petition. Page 1 of 3 DECISION. The Hearing Examiner hereby APPROVES Petition Number BDE-PL20190001536, filed by Bill Nelson and Sabrina Dobbins of Greg Orick II Marine Construction, Inc. representing Michael J. Doheny,Trustee of the Michael J.Doheny Trust with respect to the property as 250 Egret Avenue, further described as Lot 15, Block S, of Conner's Vanderbilt Beach Estates Unit 3, in Section 29, Township 48 South, Range 25 East of Collier County, Florida for the following: • To accommodate the after-the-fact 1.1-foot Boat Dock Extension,thereby allowing a 21.1- foot dock facility protrusion, and to allow for the permitting and construction of a boathouse in accordance with the plans provided. Said changes are fully described in the Proposed Plans attached as Exhibit "A" and are subject to the condition(s) set forth below. ATTACHMENTS. Exhibit A—Proposed Plans LEGAL DESCRIPTION. 250 Egret Avenue, further described as Lot 15, Block S, of Conner's Vanderbilt Beach Estates Unit 3, in Section 29, Township 48 South, Range 25 East of Collier County, Florida. CONDITIONS. 1. All other applicable state or federal permits must be obtained before commencement of the development. DISCLAIMER Pursuant to Section 125.022(5)F.S.,issuance of a development permit by a county does not in any way create any rights on the part of the applicant to obtain a permit from a state or federal agency and does not create any liability on the part of the county for issuance of the permit if the applicant fails to obtain requisite approvals or fulfill the obligations imposed by a state or federal agency or undertakes actions that result in a violation of state or federal law. APPEAL OF BOAT DOCK EXTENSION TO BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS. As to any boat dock extension petition upon which the Hearing Examiner takes action, an aggrieved petitioner, or adversely affected property owner, may appeal such final action to the Board of County Commissioners. Such appeal shall be filed with the Growth Management Department Administrator within 30 days of the Decision by the Hearing Examiner. In the event that the petition has been approved by the Hearing Examiner, the applicant shall be advised that he/she proceeds with construction at his/her own risk during this 30-day period. Any construction work completed ahead of the approval shall be at their own risk. Page 2 of 3 RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS AND EXHIBITS: SEE CLERK OF COURT, MINUTES AND RECORDS DEPARTMENT. DECISIONS OF THE HEARING EXAMINER FOR VARIANCES, CONDITIONAL USES, AND BOAT DOCK EXTENSIONS SHALL BE NOTED ON THE ZONING MAP FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES. 2' .- ir--....----'—. iPe October 6, 2020 Date Andrew Dickman, Esq., AICP Hearing Examiner Page 3 of 3 . y+ i "4" .n.. `l OF j„1 , ,, ., -L , 14 . , ik ime $ -F .,. . , _. „ ...,4„.: - ._.,:,. t - lc iii : `� cc, ._ , „ 0 :,,,,, 't-'cs 1._:',.' , cA I t a i CD Q. Qr ^I , o CC / .b I 7 O CD y ' I COu-rr ` C CDO N 11 4=0 ti F Y: :,x ._ . i Go o -as 7 E 150 CV t ►:i N Z O O. -cs h,e�lp • c, 7:: Cd y { ri, • , 4 ''-.— 44.41"/".........reff,""ff rit - z 00 wa: lLOW �'r . 1 o In . ;' P. j•• 0) It ..., Lk— 00 ti pill . .. . -. P' W� Z N // ( 4 v fl-J e ti j O C O a) i CO 0 6 O Nesi to rt Q V 7 -o a) 0 • 4• ) O O as- E N N —C 4-1 j a C I C N O 0 -0 T i >N. .. I O J I oCD- t 1 t N O 0 00 a) `° 0 „ � 0 \ :- .! � o O "01 O2 > M (� n' ET: `° N O G0 r-) b Y Q! d7 w rl w 40 © v om = I n ' �r N p = c N 0 0o to vi O tilc'� m I N _ N A W 1 ,1 C. M n�m w >,� _c VI .0 w o m ei eC N 11) o N Z M 4J ! h ID �N I a) ice. b. m o c� N Z d Q 0 wm Or W C 0 ti Eoo CL 8 ui u N of v ii Nr z W N o C Z In to c m N .a I- a) 4 Li- 11�� 4 V CD ',. I. al 00 CO C O ~ N — D Y O [_,. 0) pp O O o 4) -c � 1^ CI I a (A w N W W ("J EU -a a� Z cj N 0 N T. T 5 t 0 " u/ a - C J i .Y - I 0 � � a) � = 00 J Ct .2 tl C L ♦ ♦ 1 H - ..—.1,11A—-- _. k-- - V i_ s. • f Ste, cC bA ct cip CI c- - -so 0 N O O O. p., Q CI • • 00 cu 8 O © zm° >0 co Il ♦1 N U © COa S ice. w Cit N �,� o M o' A fl,a� O re xNzM CI)co a) cA >~ z < W • Z Z 00 re . 00 d ZU) XOIn Fal V U ,l o= .f .R ry. __per s M w 0 110 }NNW IIIIIS _C, 0. O (I) CI 1 W Z CV NII rot O V 0 I i A . , fo c! I I o I I 0 cn I I X I i w .6 fl i I I & I I c Io II Q. Q, a, I I I j_1 d d E. i I l , / n o o o 0 co l m° 0 I r^ t73 m I I IN 1 Vl I T aa) ± I o I I O a a H. «_ o 0 1� I ( C C.) c 1 r 4o71. A I _ � � o C Il ( � A W ': N c� 1 12 12 ,o m N ao i ' z — I � 1 :- x el Z -et. 1-1 o I I" t "' = Ii ' ,41 ( (.i I I j 1 I U N ... ll 11._. -1 . Z (, 00 1B101141p0 u � _ _ _i-1 Z In i 0 In IiiIHHIHIUP! ' o �, u u u u W Z N _n_n_n_nEn=_n _ _ 1 0 "rum, , r ri o D w CD �$ qp ,,= p M (N0N ¢vi z z ; _ c C3SnH g" 8, 5 N z d m u COC �_.a 0 N > N w p p \V v u A^->'.G m ��.m. J O� Cl, [�l� µwQ Z1 W X a 0 W W I -1 tl N 2 N La v:ra ¢z ~ ce o o m 3 °o U H a ..J,-g_ a z a w ow N ¢r o qg ��nQ p r LL Or L. E •E> o - ZQ„m,vi¢ _ '- "' i,; `;pz`^�"• w >�ro p i^ w m•,hyo any : 1 �� a.zv , FN m z ,,i , x � y,2,'. = rn ,-z } Paz o' ,. �'y'1`. ppp... r, w F ga m qq a C • 9 <gc Ow ,- C7 I � p N o : flE: o CY i¢ ~ w o '-'-m- a a z v< CO O =�po a r ri zz > N O Z mC / c I Wa ,aa Ow a Z Z C ¢ orQ Z U F W > gp F.w / O a (n Q aZg'� J om z _`„¢a Z WAN ZH E o o U F- !1UI ne z.7a C o p ¢crw <L N 4. 6 IN w 0U w F40 =0 \ J\ J s a or. > >o ��oaa�zx x�z cwi ^ N a .n �ce a o as m 3a OQOa3aV / <VO �O C O O6 x zs 8- J w o o z M D O �p w o0 0C o • T °g • • M „F0,90.00 S n • • D• • w Z ; ? w • O C _ O C N W C m O N ccMCr) a M zLa II z- O ,0'DZt o§ 3 „FC,80.00 N • 0 I C • • z C 0 z O • O • • J Q i U ! N CDl m r> 8 y .0 o m / " ,-----, 0 U E z F s O N U -�o • H B Z� v1!1Q a t'3 o 0 ,I w :I', ri a 1£�, N Q ai QZmQ x f..i ❑ Z T OW2 W UJ❑ 9 S W 0❑7d gN N O m M C Z i w O DmnN ¢000 :f _ N m Uj W Q w>oao ¢fes x• F y`� m C K o Z Z , p a,* w Eo❑ 0 y CD Nw • n• 'I w X U • m cc w Y U (n Lti O �, L' U a Z J d I w in w it Occ LW� 37 11. N' ww F w TZ (Ili max CIO 0 9'9 LA_ ai J R� O N I LA c O b ZneN.' % 7.5' Clal 0 NN Z r¢ I .-iIII'I,I'I'I LWi N (� W !:i w { J z_ C NZ�.' �_�_I al U ..z ny_J'; --X-C_.x i'. W • 3:v 0 to NX N sll9Ii�II!NI in F w Ii,6,66,1i1i.�liii,,P iii w l'xo 19.5' w d'lZ I nn co II• r r -II:i'' Q H o d Z Q F 1)Zx x' U Q t9U Ow O F- ❑Z Z 5 co NC Z W N • O XOO iv w 0 Z n 4 II w Lin' 5 O l'w Z z N N O 37 w V w II _s-Z--< t L. 0 CJ Cn . i M ..¢Q N Fit O'. (° z 01 -9434i N !l'u 0# m n -I:: c� a 5 m > 5 oa eJ a rn 5 Q ��'t! 2 O �Y1C W W a mo t O o -IW-Z Q $&... anr h*m 0 %k O >- oW°tlwg w Z x1(7 N w OUp,a�`�� e Q = w0'uF c p d � 'my�z {RS 2, o 5_aQpcF g ym_OU a Q gwT,mm -,, ` i LLI `1 aZl g�/ t C 9w t j F2 a 0 W u i y - (.9`5 .$ a yar atl Zp tm W 02p woa i" ® UaU° 01, Kc L.,.., Z ¢ aSo wg o ■u o a N e� q u Z q fN W- N.- U N Z ii N X J W W 4)1 O 2 r 71 W y LZZ ° m D L'OZ 165. z c� a g W n �,' W 7 a , .1 VWJ O M> q!Ii o ITo - a z_, ���III�II m a0 M N O W F-_ w .BZZ O �3 O°w II zg ir IH / W a QU U Z L J M ¢ 3 ¢ i, W W� M N J O W Z N VI O 5-4w N II W J Q U N id'ASNOOD 8311103 Fn.:1= n��na-ss ry�sne oNry a�.�o„a.awov 4 4NI- ,... NOUJfl LLSNO)3NIHVV, w....,.a.. a _ '�" NDRiO 93219 awV i3a93 OSz '+e i a „/�ao'. .... ..... ... ...„ 'MOJ 3Sf1OH iIOS AN3HOO .a..............m.a..._�ONI"'1-J'MS 3O 9NRl33NIDN3 8r L.x>@ =�s,�,�.3, �` A a 9 a Id"LI 1 v 0 m it L CD 0?: K ` L.1- I S! 0ppC NI k �z IP'Ii Oao r O lHIIIIIIliIIlg I"l. HHIIMMEMEN■ oz MI li2 eE 3k/ III, h I fh I Ion w L 1Q ININMEMENNEMMINI A-- w 0 pl Z W iN I g III U a7I f r. :g o o { i 53 > iio tT. o O b a V S '5 S 2a� W v o - • a o Y"2 �m �� sue t! w d � 4' �$ LU 3d 3 P 4 II - ,, 7 N 4, -AVO I1VMV3S 3ACC3V,O'S I XV' -- N; X 5.n