Backup Documents 10/02/2006 W
....
',~
.....::;.:::~
~
'.
--"'--::::'._'~.
""i:i
AGENDA
October 2, 2006
9:00 a.m.
BCC "Permitting" Workshop
3rd Floor Boardroom
W. Harmon Turner Building
Frank Halas, Chairman, District 2
Jim Coletta, Vice-Chairman, District 5
Donna Fiala, Commissioner, District 1
Tom Henning, Commissioner, District 3
Fred W. Coyle, Commissioner, District 4
NOTICE: ALL PERSONS WISHING TO SPEAK ON ANY AGENDA ITEM MUST REGISTER PRIOR TO
SPEAKING. SPEAKERS MUST REGISTER WITH THE COUNTY MANAGER PRIOR TO THE
PRESENTATION OF THE AGENDA ITEM TO BE ADDRESSED. ALL REGISTERED PUBLIC SPEAKERS
WILL RECEIVE UP TO THREE (3) MINUTES UNLESS THE TIME IS ADJUSTED BY THE CHAIRMAN.
COLLIER COUNTY ORDINANCE NO. 2004-05, AS AMENDED, REQUIRES THAT ALL LOBBYISTS SHALL,
BEFORE ENGAGING IN ANY LOBBYING ACTIVITIES (INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, ADDRESSING
THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS), REGISTER WITH THE CLERK TO THE BOARD AT THE
BOARD MINUTES AND RECORDS DEPARTMENT.
IF YOU ARE A PERSON WITH A DISABILITY WHO NEEDS ANY ACCOMMODATION IN ORDER TO
PARTICIPATE IN THIS PROCEEDING, YOU ARE ENTITLED, AT NO COST TO YOU, TO THE PROVISION
OF CERTAIN ASSISTANCE. PLEASE CONTACT THE COLLIER COUNTY FACILITIES MANAGEMENT
DEPARTMENT LOCATED AT 3301 EAST TAMIAMI TRAIL, NAPLES, FLORIDA, 34112, (239) 774-8380;
ASSISTED LISTENING DEVICES FOR THE HEARING IMPAIRED ARE AVAILABLE IN THE COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS' OFFICE.
1. Pledge of Allegiance
2. Permitting Overview
a. Joe Schmitt, Administrator, Community Development and Environmental
Services Division
b. Kim Grant, Senior Management and Operations Consultant, Office of
Management and Budget
c. Brenda Talbert, Executive Vice President, Collier Building Industry Association
3. Commissioners' Questions and Concerns
4. Public Comment
5. Adjourn
INQUIRIES CONCERNING CHANGES TO THE BOARD'S AGENDA SHOULD BE MADE TO THE COUNTY
MANAGER'S OFFICE AT 774-8383.
CJCJ
Community Development and Environmental Services Division
Joseph Schmitt, Administrator
October 2, 2006
'"......"--'<._----''''''''*''_...'''''''''-'"'"'''-,,,,"'''''''''''''''''"'';'''.,'~ ","",,"--_...;...~,_-..'~.,.',-,..
"".""~~"'.'".,~._~,-----_...,-"'"~;..-.,_."';,,".......,..,.._...,,,.-~-'~-"~-'-'-"'-'-'".""-
[I In
~ ~
~; ~
.I.
jn
~
~
~
jR
~
~ ~ ]
i ~ g
. ~ ~ ~
f ~ m
-.
a
~ l!l !f ~
. i~
[
[ ~ j:l ~
~ ~
i i ~
I ~ i
M'^"''''''-''_,_,___"_,,~,+,,, ".....~,.,.,..."...~.."",...~""".""'"...........""'__~"'".........<"""'""""'"""',...........~""...,__._"'''''''''''__".,_,,__...."'.'''".,;''"'''',..,..
-
. (Ill
i
i ~ i ~
I I
Q,
!
[ t 0 i I . I I I I I I
f
-.
! ;~Ii ~.
.
f
-
s: !
ii :II ~~i~ ~ &I
0
i ~ ~
~
Q, . ~~I~ ~
!
[ ~~!I i
.
I
s:
ii
.....~ .' III .. __.......".""~....,'_~;^_~___."'."....~__.- ..........4.' .' _..,,,,.,,,__..,,~_,
Square Fee'
[~ .l. N W ~ !
r:: "C ~ ~ ~N
(1) =
c. CD
c.
0' Q
., ~
N ~
~
w w
(II ~
CD W
Q) W
N Q)
~ N ,
N W
~ Q)
CD
~ .
~
N 0 I
w ~
... 0 r
0
.. CD CD
.. N Q)
g Q) ~
(II w
~
- ~
~ i
i ~ CII
~ ~ ~
(II I ~ 8
CD
N N
g ~
.. ~ t
(II 0
0
CII
~
~ w
~ ~ ~
(II N
~ ~
CD
~ N (II
W ~
~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~
Q) (7)
Percent Reveiws Com pleted by Deadlines
~
~ ~ ~ ~ c.n en -.. CC) CD c:::>>
c:::>> c:::>> c:::>> c:::>> c:::>> c:::>> c:::>> c:::>> c:::>> c:::>> c:::>>
'?ft. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ '?ft. ~ ~ ~
co co co co co co co co co
q,
~~
.1"
4;,
v~ + []
.'t
I:',
~~ )>
~~s n-
c:::
Q)
~
~~B
~
<1~~
"Q.
~ ii"
::s
tn
~~ C'"
'6' 5.
.. ..... .. i5:.
S'" ""C
~ (Q a
"Q
~~ .(1) (Q
... a
3 en
:;:::;:....<P.... en
~ tn -c en
- CD
I>> - --
~~~ ;:::;: :::::s m
.:::s....SL
Q.. :::s :s: :::::s
o en <
9- C'D --
~ CD. -c C'D a
... ... ~
0 :::::s
3 "CD" :::::s
~~B en" S1 (Q 3
(") ""C C'D
:::::s
~ i5i" Dr
:::::s
q~ ::::0 ::::0
'6' C'D C'D
< <
~~ (i)- (i)-
:e :e
~~~ c
C'D
D)
~ a..
-
~~B --
:::::s
C'D
en
q,
~~
.t>
~
y~
.'<t'
()to.
~~
.1"
~
~~B
~
~~A'
~
~~
'6'
10
~~B
~
::Y~B
~
~~B
~
Q4pB
..,~
~~B
~
:;t1~B
Percent Reveiws Com pleted by Deadlines
c:::>
'?ft.
~
c:::>>
~
co
~
c:::>>
'?ft.
~
c:::>>
~
co
~
c:::>>
'?ft.
Con
c:::>
~
co
CJ')
c:::>
'?ft.
~
c:::>
c:::>
'?ft.
...:;-..
9-
c:
0.
.. . .......... C'" ..('I)....
c: tII
.. .....i5: ...9!......
=;"
c.a a:r
"C :::s
..('1) .0.
_ c:
3 tII
. ;:::;:..C'D ..
tII "C
- C'D
I>> -
~
:::s 0
Q. :::s
o tII
..9-.....
('I) "C
.... 0
3 q;"
en" ~
(")
C/)-C
c::;O
C/)O
-IDJ
)>1
m
ZS:
)> ..
DJZ
10
m-l
=IE =IE
c
(I)
D,)
c..
-
--
::::J
(I)
en
,.,--.--"'.......,--...<____,..,'"",..~.,~"""." . H.",,".......,_. ' "'I
-..
c:::>
'?ft.
CC)
c:::>
'?ft.
CD
c:::>
'?ft.
c,C)
c,C)
~
m
~. ~
(j) <
"'C CD
(1) :E
o
iir ~
- a.
(ii'
r+ C
CIl
CD
"C
..,
o
CO'
o
-
CIl
D.l
:J
a.
om
<c:J
<CIl-
o --<
.., 0
"'3 CD
- CD <
ii) .., CD
o CIl ..,
"'CD'"
_. ""] \11
:J <; <
co -.
-.
m
~
<
en
"'C ..,
CD CD
o D.l
~ r0-
o.
ur
r+ D.l
o
-
<'
a:
CD
CIl
m
~
<
en
"0
(1)
o
Qi'
-
u)'
....
:E
;::;:
::r
:J
o
..,
CD
D.l
CIl
:J
co
CD
<
~
CIl
o
....
..,
CD
CIl
"C
o
:J
CIl
C"
;::;:
'<
~ :u
... CD D.l
"C < - ~
"C CD CIl -.
o-OCD
;:+ S' .., :E
-. CD
O::!:CIlD.l
.., D.l "C :J
O::!:Oo.
o < :J
o.CDCIlC
CD CIl -'CIl
o.CIlC"CD
CDcCD"C
< 0 0''''
CD ::r .., .2.
o D.l CIl CD
"CCIlCDg.
3m:JCIl
CD )> o' D.l
:J0"':J
~ a.
m
::J
<
U'J
"0
(1)
o
Qi'
Cir
....
o
)>~<
:J 0 ~
o.~CIl
_-CD
0...... .., 0 CD
D.l D.l
.., -. a. D.l
o.I:J =
:;. ::0 :J 2' "C
~ 3 CD ~ a
-D.l:E_o
m ~ !i o' m
"C CD D.l :J CIl
.., .... CIl
o CIl ;-+i' 0
it IOo
. D.l :J
:J < ~
c.~Q.
CD CIl D.l
CD :J
CD a.
en
CD
::J
<:5'
.,
o
.,
1)
::::!,
:J
o
-0.
m
-
:E
.... -.
o -
.., ::r
o.ICDO
:;. D.l 3 <
..,CD:J"CCD
CDOo.::rCil
CIl - - D.l
"C .., CD CIl CD
o CD I -. CD
:J "C CIl D.l
CIlO:UO-
0:;:+ CIl 3 :J ....
_. c
;::;:' D.lm:J
~ OJ~co g.
CD C -.
C .., _ 0
o.CIlD.l:J
co - CIl
CD 0
- -<
1
2
3
4
5
6
27,425
26,731
28,li8lI
27,472
30,096
33,3:U
32,846
40,(138
37480
47800
4640lI
I_ Applied for . Issued I
7
3lIOlJO
25lXIJ
24684
I\tl.nDer d
Pem_1s
2IDOlJO
19O1JO
1??oo
9OlJO
o
F1..
~
M.-AMew
orAMew
1418 1413 1408 1237
3648 6173 7383 lI023
16482 1ll21l2 16801 21612
8141 7E111 7611 92C7
Fiscal Year
. Are . 0\Ier~ 0 Mnor RwIew. MEljor RevIew
8
9000
9000
7OllO
9000
IIIurri:Iw 01 PemIIs
AaluII UnIls
IIIurri:Iw 01 PemIIs I8aued
AaluII UnIls
4188
6924
3101
8096
402ll
7'9lI2
3922
8316
illcHer
Issued
RacaI Year
. IIUriJer d AInriIB Applied _ Actual U1IlB 0 IIUriJer d AtrrritBI88ued _ Actual U1IlB
3488813 1600044
300921I6 1682006
Fiscal V_
3721927
17611673
I- Applied for _ Issued I
9
RscaI V...
~ What we actually do!
Process applications for over ~
~,
Coordinating the applications with up to ~
~
Reviewers responsible for checking over 100
technical areas, using over ~
references.
16 ualit assurance checks are performed at the
permit issue counter.
In addition work with over 100 other walk-ins
looking for assistance with inspections,
revisions, certificates of occupancy and general permitting
matters;
totaling more than 50,000 visitors a year.
10
11
12
_.._,.."""--"'~-..-"'-_......--".,,.-,--~---,..,~"
13
14
15
16
17
18
We've heard our customers concerns.
We've identified some major root causes.
We're working to improve the experience and
outcome for our customers.
19
100'~
:: 90%
c
:: 80%
...
~ 70%
-; 60%
...
-;;. 50%
E
o
'-' 40%
'"
.~ 30%
>
...
~ 20%
c
~ 10%
...
D-
0%
~<:.""
~c.
~
,l,'
~o
~..,
~
~..,
~
),~<::-
~
.....~
~<:.'"
+'"
!cl
~'jS
,,~
~
~<::i.
+~
~...
),;:,~
~<:.'" ~'c: ~...
),'1> ,,;:,~ ""~~
20
:;;; 80%
...
<l>
~ 70%
.Q
D Actual
"~ Target
99%
100%
:: 90%
- 1----- ~- "--_..... - ..-- ".--1
c:
-:: 60%
<l>
-;;. 50%
E
~ 40%
'"
.~ 30%
>
<l>
~ 20%
c:
~ 10%
<l>
a.
0%
PROBLEM: NOT
SUST AINABLE
w
w Deadlines
. . - .
Irn:ludes ~Iland use petltions, project
plans, builcling p,rmlts, and other mise
pernilts
~ ~
:-:I::S" ~'Si>.
~... ~Q
~ ~ ~
~<&.... \~~ ~~
!c:o
1..'Si>
..,,,,
&: ~
~~ ~I::S
"t-~ ..,~
~
\~<::i
~~'<:, ....~ \:l'<:,
\"> "t-~"" f:.:,,<&<::/.
21
22
23
Oversee all process control and
Workload functions. Oversee
And train new staff. Handle
HR matters
for direct reports.
Senior or Plfncipa'
Entry level revi
Customer servi
Work tracking.
Review land use projects and
also responsible for senior
level initiatives such as EAC
support or code development.
Review land use projects and related activities, with increasing levels of responsibility.
Eml SplIlcial.t
Env SplIlcillllat
en... ~..
E:nv SplIlciall8t
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33