Solis Ex parte Items - Commissioner Andy Solis
COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AGENDA
February 25, 2020
ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS
9.A. This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a
hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to
approve an Ordinance amending Ordinance Number 2004-41, as amended, the Collier County
Land Development Code, which established the comprehensive zoning regulations for the
unincorporated area of Collier County, Florida, by amending the appropriate zoning atlas map
or maps by changing the zoning classification of the herein described real property from a
Rural Agricultural (A) zoning district to a Mixed Use Planned Unit Development(MPUD)zoning
district for the project to be known as KASE MPUD, to allow for construction of a maximum of
76 residential dwelling units or 212 group housing units for seniors, on property located on the
east side of Livingston Road, approximately one quarter mile south of Immokalee Road in
Section 30, Township 48 South, Range 26 East, consisting of 7.58± acres; and by providing an
effective date. [PL20180002453]
NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM
SEE FILE ®Meetings ®Correspondence De-mails 1 'Calls
1-14-20 letter, Jesse & Phyllis Hoskins
2-24-20 meeting, Clay Brooker & Andrew Saluan
CONSENT AGENDA
16.A.8. This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a
hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to
approve for recording the final plat of Silverwood at Ave Maria (Phase 2), (Application Number
PL20190002347) approval of the standard form Construction and Maintenance Agreement and
approval of the amount of the performance security.
X NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM
SEE FILE ❑Meetings flCorrespondence De-mails (Calls
16.A.9. This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a
hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to
approve for recording the minor final plat of Del Webb Naples Parcels 209-212 Tract"B" Replat,
Application Number PL20190002497.
X NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM
SEE FILE ['Meetings I (Correspondence De-mails ❑Calls
il1lt1-'
ED—
Honorable Andy Solis, Esq.
JAN 142019
3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 303
By.
Naples, FL 34112
Subject: Planned Unit Development Rezone PUDZ-PL 20180002453
Dear Commissioner Solis:
We live in the Livingston Lakes WCI Community on Livingston Blvd,
District 2. We received notice on October 11, 2019 regarding the above
rezoning application from D.E. Davidson Engineering on behalf of
property owners William Donovan and Patrice Donovan.
In August of 2017 we purchased our Carriage home at 15165 Butler
Lake Drive, Unit 102 right before Hurricane Irma. We previously lived
at 4000 Stonesthrow Ct., Naples FL 34109. In 2012 we relocated from
Las Vegas Nevada after my retirement. Prior to our relocation we
researched several States and Cities for our final move. We considered
several factors including: population, crime, environment commitment,
and actual landscaping features of the communities and cities. With
respect to the latter factors it was extremely essential that our home
was surrounded with natural preserve and views and animal habitat.
We were told when we purchased our Carriage home in 2017 that the
County was not developing the natural preserve surrounding our
community. Now we find out about this project including several
preceding this application i.e. Germain and Oaks Farm Seed to Table.
This particular project is extremely negative on several counts. It will
contribute to continued adverse traffic congestion, negatively affect
animal habitat and preserves, create a negative impact on our natural
views of the sun sets, and negatively impact our property values. We
have already heard from several residents their intent on selling and
moving which is adverse to our small community. Financially, we do
not have the ability to consider another buying and selling transaction.
We are on a fixed income and because of Irma we lost monies on the
sale of our previous home. Therefore we have little financial flexibility
as others in our community might have.
The current traffic pattern approaching north to Immoklee for right
turns to the interstate and east communities is congested and
negatively impacts egress from our community and those communities
currently residing on Livingston. Based on a consideration of adding
another development with up to four floors negatively impacts the
traffic and other factors mentioned before. If the County
Commissioners approve further development of the above project
several negatives will result: increased traffic, less preserve, affect
animals in their natural habitat, create an eye sore with three to four
story structure, negatively impact our property values, and negatively
affect our ability to choose to stay or sale our home if the application is
approved. Our community is very upset and taken aback by yet a
another promise not kept. We feel a con was unfolded by the
developers of this property and we are extremely upset.
2
The Commission may think the development may seem a small matter
but respectfully it is not small to us. Believe us this is a big deal for us
living in Livingston Lakes. If we wanted to live in City with less preserve
and animal habitat we would have purchased surrounded by tall
structures, less preserve, and little regard for traffic and population
size. We don't want a large city feel that's why we selected North
Naples. We like the fact that homes and communities cannot be seen
from County roads. We love that about this area.
Now we feel trapped expecting Livingston Lakes will be surrounded by
commercial and tall structures. Thank God we have the Collier County
Regional Park located South of our development. Please no more with
all due respect enough development has been done around us. The
positive features used in our decision to purchase her almost 8 years
ago is now eroding before our eyes. The quality of our life is shaken
and we are very unhappy about the changing zoning circumstances
after we invested all our monies in another home purchase. We
respectfully we request the Commissioners to deny this application and
future applications for this parcel and others negatively affecting our
community of 230 home owners.
If you need any additional information or request additional input
please contact me at 239-293-0071. Thanking you in advance for
consideration.
incerely You ,
e E. and Phyllis Hoskins
3
MW'r ---''7ft.*,•,..4,
_..
DAVIDSON
1
1 Yrtlerve WAY(..•.,,'CIF ' Nmrao Hike Iht
r? AstoniDRT57(Svc0..,_
r - '<\
h f
, n _ VI
. et
1...;
L '.I
r to
r
^I I
C. Ir ...
ilAY A '1 NIO.ID 1111U
o n
SD %.,..e.
0
•-•,-; .,,... .
r—iirristIL t_.t11.71
O —. ' ,,.
" ,, —
, ,___ r'
., ....
lay et
-,
- -Htl-StIfP4IPILIAS- -- El •••"' -----,,_z_.
ri) 7. •-,..,‘
o -....!
77
,T.
- jiI1
9 'T
/('Y'k\' or ,13 7.q.• 0•••!..,--
.„„,•-•
13 ,7
-1
••••• V• 7,;. ....., .„..--0‘.f>
0 n T1 C
= ''' _____} • o 0
z -I .....
..., ,..''P
Z ,.,. ...,
.ii let BLN'11...., c•,•der Spring'.DR
Strand
0 7.,
s:
CD
71
z "......--
r-
N...)
cp o
i-n- -0
As,tOn -r-0-9 T.
'VensWAY z—
CZ) NI C2
z 0
,.....„-- _ _____ _ - - , = --- •-
CD
cD
N.)
-ttu
C
--v - ,
c.A., .
u°7 "147,. )'
13 0
------------- - - - -- 0 R . 'Eli --. _ .
. 1
0
LIm
-
.—• 'A- z :, -
(0 . • •
. . ..
- , ,r- x • . , - ': 1413.144--------* .
En ',.. ! --;7,• m
- c
CD 1 t) 1 '',,,- ..,, • 0 4
73
. ,
Ar.
Bu er a e . _.
,1
4_1
•:.•t•:H '-,-,- c.-' -P 0
, • ri
i
;! ri ''"
• ;, Zi ;II
0
,1-'\•4, !"3-.,., X 1 F I I
9 ,,,c, u i •
-..
GoodnerAngela
Subject: KASE MPUD: Clay Brooker, Andrew Saluan
Location: BCC Office
Start: Mon 2/24/2020 12:00 PM
End: Mon 2/24/2020 12:30 PM
Recurrence: (none)
Meeting Status: Meeting organizer
Organizer: SolisAndy
Required Attendees: Andrew I. Solis
Categories: Commission Chambers
From:Clay C. Brooker<ccbrooker@napleslaw.com>
Sent: Monday, February 17, 2020 10:28 AM
To:SolisAndy
Cc:Andrew Saluan;Jessica Harrelson
Subject:2-25-2020 BCC meeting--KASE MPUD
EXTERNAL EMAIL:This email is from an external source.Confirm this is a trusted sender and use extreme caution when opening
attachments or clicking links.
Good morning,Andy. I am assisting Andrew Saluan with a relatively small rezoning that will be on the BCC's 2-25 agenda. The
property is comprised of about 7.6 acres,and it is located on the east side of Livingston Road a little bit south of Immokalee
Road. Both County staff and the CCPC(unanimously) have recommended approval. Although the agenda is not yet out, I wanted to
contact you in advance as the property is located in your district. Are you willing to meet to allow us to explain the project to
you? Thanks,and I look forward to hearing from you.
[cid:image001.jpg@01D5E57C.F12225B0]<http://napleslaw.com/>
Clay C. Brooker?
Board Certified City,County and Local Government Lawyer
Cheffy Passidomo, P.A.
821 Fifth Avenue South
Naples,
FL
34102
(239)261-9300<tel:(239)%20261-9300>
telephone
1
(239)261-9782
fax
www.napleslaw.com<https://www.napleslaw.com/>
ccbrooker@napleslaw.com<mailto:ccbrooker@ napleslaw.com>
2