Loading...
Backup Documents 01/14/2020 Item #11ARECOMMENDATION TO ACCEPT THE CONSULTANT’S REPORT ON THE FEASIBILITY OF CONSTRUCTING A PARKING STRUCTURE AT CLAM PASS BEACH PARK; DEFER DEVELOPMENT OF A PARKING STRUCTURE AT THIS TIME;PURSUE ALTERNATIVE METHODS FOR BEACH ACCESS AND IMPLEMENT PLANNED IMPROVEMENTS TO UNDERUTILIZED SECTIONS OF THE PUBLIC BEACH AT CLAM PASS PARK. BARRY WILLIAMS, DIRECTOR, COLLIER COUNTY PARKS AND RECREATION DIVISION Connor Park N. Gulfshore Access Barefoot Beach Access Marco South Access Clam Pass Park Tiger Tail Beach Barefoot Beach Preserve Vanderbilt Beach 9849 11860 27221 35656 62637 69054 117802 126541 9651 10393 25933 34508 41918 71067 102569 120335 8236 9065 36252 30359 65466 65751 135542 146431 Connor Park N. Gulfshore Access Barefoot Beach Access Marco South Access Clam Pass Park Tiger Tail Beach Barefoot Beach Preserve Vanderbilt Beach FY17 8236 9065 36252 30359 65466 65751 135542 146431 FY18 9651 10393 25933 34508 41918 71067 102569 120335 FY19 9849 11860 27221 35656 62637 69054 117802 126541 VEHICLE COUNTS FY17 FY18 FY19 Connor Park Tiger Tail Beach Clam Pass Park Barefoot Beach Preserve N. Gulfshore Access Vanderbilt Beach Barefoot Beach Access Marco South Access 5 12 29 30 39 46 73 211 1 8 10 24 16 29 54 177 9 13 36 40 32 71 83 156 Connor Park Tiger Tail Beach Clam Pass Park Barefoot Beach Preserve N. Gulfshore Access Vanderbilt Beach Barefoot Beach Access Marco South Access FY17 9 13 36 40 32 71 83 156 FY18 1 8 10 24 16 29 54 177 FY19 5 12 29 30 39 46 73 211 DAYS AT CAPACITY FY17 FY18 FY19 67 Spaces 96 Spaces 361 Spaces 38 Spaces 402 Spaces 198 Spaces 226 Spaces 156 Spaces Water Management Area with wetland dependent species that assist in filtration of runoff HOTEL VIEW –BASE FLOORS •Trellis to be present across entire top floor •Cement mix for top floor to be mixed with “go away green” •Trellis to be present across entire top floor •Cement mix for top floor to be mixed with “go away green” PELICAN BAY FOUNDATION BOARD •12/14/18—provided informational review of concept •01/25/19—follow up regarding Pelican Bay Foundation Board comments •02/28/19—follow up regarding Pelican Bay Foundation Comments •04/25/19—Pelican Bay Workshop on concept RECOMMENDATIONS FROM PELICAN BAY •Consideration for shorebirds—beach re-nourishment •Traffic concerns •Tram traffic •Plan for moving folks down the beach—beach utilization •Coastal hardening concerns about use of the dune trails •Dredge/Access to Clam Pass Bay •Suggestion to discuss with neighbors •Environmental Factors MEETINGS WITH OTHERS •Gulf Shore Association of Condos •Seagate HOA •Moorings Park HOA •City of Naples •Seagate Elementary School •St. William Catholic Church •United Church of Christ SUGGESTIONS FROM OTHERS •Off site parking •Beach circulator •Continue to monitor increased utilization •Accept that beach access is limited •Dynamic pricing for beach access, i.e., charge more at peak times, season OTHER CONCEPTS •CAT Beach Circulator •Naples One/Pewter Mug/Water Taxi •Bluebill Parking Structure •Delnor Wiggins State Park Parking Structure •Offsite parking with leased land from commercial entities Clam Pass Park Improvements RECOMMENDATIONS 1.Continue to review beach access issues in the community and determine alternate methods for managing beach access to include offsite beach parking,continue to support the beach circulator offered by CAT,and study dynamic parking pricing with higher fees associated with prime beach use times (e.g.10 AM-2 PM). 2.Pursue a phased approach to the parking/beach improvements at Clam Pass as follows: a.Finalize and present the proposed southern park improvements to the Pelican Bay Foundation Board and the Board of County Commissioners for approval. b.Market the availability of Clam Pass park for beach access to residents and visitors. c.Monitor parks utilization trends and evaluate that information annually through the Annual Update and Inventory Report (AUIR)review process-- reconsider expanded parking at Clam Pass as demand increases at this location. xi Z ?, 1 1 A D 0 cD su oanN R a CD CO r m cD 0 = O = sw 51CL C c DJ c) n Zc 0 z 12 mmmm - =00 m > 4 rncD © -. rD mg r- -� 0 _ CD � < � O 3 0 com M -_io = C) Z � m z oZ O mz D zm 1 g n 0 -1 p z ■ -H 0 cO r mz div -Immz - I = G-)) o O zmw c°m c TI r 0 m —I > O -n --i z cn xi OO w moa o m O 0D = � z iii Z T, -nZ o =-4o 0 G O C 0 D , CD = -1 Cr --1m a r mm Dcczy rn r- ocnz �D —I 0 -0 O Zzm NN O K0 C cc) o y —1 cn X Fd -I o 7 . 1 M � �_ Dmc�n 12. o I— cnO O zmD M � z no0z _. —1 x O n , c m neo O O m Z 0 0 o —1 On ccn00_� PmT1 O � Z mzrn D EZ D � � c , m Fz > Eom 0 1 MI m � �' �' \ "D D m ---I z �' D T m 1-Ti O O y lk,, zr 1n O * D cnO m PO Dmm m m -m_G N m 0 cn G� cn • �✓ r mm O � D . D oZ r *r- X ° p = W m 11 x m mx cn 0 � rn 22 m 70 0 v� _ C) m z 73 m n 1 1 A a co CD CD Ca CD o D .`�` CU E...- _ 0 � .1' r = o m � o e-F D UK r oWm o C) com � T73 = M c _1 KCD0 t ZOv -inmc zcm cc cmnz.5 0 C omz ° 1,; 0 M o z 73 m 0 D c 0 CI zF74----- m m c7zz ;r' 'T1 0 m V5 > m p3oW ,z] r- 1- z (- rO D ZT Z ,=-1 28-< a C -Izcr D CD = oc mo `' Q o Rt p N C7 n j 0- ,-- --I cD c w. DOI 70 '7l X < hI CCDCT Ma = O _� m %l r- '..... Mm ,'O -I Zomo k 0 rot.. M I--I ov O = 2 ° "? = o › ox ,' M oo n 7Jzo ".-ii. o m Pz O �W � � S10 'n -11 _, E rn = _1m 3 - n• -i O � W Z mOo Ti Kr W -•10 = o ° D r o D Eg � � p zoo L>17 � m D Z � n7 • ,- z cpo O it- > m _1 > p a 71 m m fD om D mgi0 M o * vo o m M cn = tV < Z co p W D --I m D V) "moo . 1 o = 0 O D3jD F r m m Z 11 p r m oz r moo co -I -I (--) co - � m 2 cON Xi m z —+ z 2 0 D 73 Z gn 1 1 A 3> 0CD CO tQ o N `• to CD -< Wm m m-o eW � o Q cS_CJr- __ z c Qo oz v — rr- -1r r— —1 = CD > o < o a oom E 10 =m z '' nn ccn -i =1 c L Z 0 z vi m z g 0 p c o n N O m 70rn --I ZNo 0 -I cn z 2 o w M a � m cc -n r- C m --I O -0 -i w zcn �� 0 72 om � cDom D n O 0D 7 z In =nCC Z � m ZDm � U o -1 oxi _1 -100 c = c eL M rn O `� � Q n O1 � 'n co o0o -i cn 0 mi W = O D 0 z lc •• - ii I— � m 27) 7J 3 ° 73 O zzm --1 cn � Xm —Ig m o0 � Dcn mu, 0 r cpO O z0° D15 -r1 T ExxCI m PZ oDo .S _II i ....• TO o1 z o -n � S ‘"1 , -I o , to cn o n7 z Z mzm lo O XI co r 1 m Z K -1 m m DD � mDr ciO m mO y ci 7J > C "' mr -{- -p Or =C W mil m 0 Z < z 0) Gm_) c7) - m r mm O mD Z 2_ D pz r =� r Ern, x m m7 E5 C') r- m z 2 m o D D z _ � _L mz 0 CDD) C n 1 1 A -a 3 �. CO ii;N cfl CD -< co C v -' O= '"' CI. � m DO -O 0 > � � - Omm o ,- CD CD') co _,m � Tx = 3 o O mz D v_' mz - i Q g (no --I OZ Oi • vQ Z xi m Y /�/ l0 •1 N zmm m 0zz o m D D m 5 z m M = m m * mN o Z -n Z = -< w � Cz D.= w CD = c m CL o nDm � cCpn CD ett _I , T � « CI) 6 Or = O _� m 0' I- xm 73 ocmnm o as M 1- = z 0W o oo i "-N 0 re- . 1= OO 0 Dp ..� y_ Om m --IOc o -� I— cnO o z S "11 72 m = gym v O 7° = Z mOo t --i O 0 V) OD r' al. �11 m O , Z p -I D - D m D ZEN r N m xi m O o stO 1 mm m Dpi cD r w > O oma D o � n mcn0 —~ .-I � D 0 -2 - —V M O * p O G� m J XJ m0 m ccnn = = �, 2 < z Cl) 0WD �! --1 m G) (n m O � = c O � o0- mm z � 5- M z r' m0 - p D 00 E -1 -+ T7 p n � m z r� Z = a \PI xi mD3 m n 1 1 -aCD `- MitU) P. 2 CD -< CD o = c • ,Il CD 0. 03 _ � m Do iJ CD rD.- ; K r 000m at -40 0 0 Wm S � � Xi = 3 rn w -zi -1 _ Oce - z O mz v 5mz 0 M w o -I z z cam • . m 73% � CP—g : m- o o Z7 m _ D Q r___ cizm m 02- z ... .k) T D O m ( z m 71 r0 W v .Z7rz r0 A M = m m * 2iv o CO Z zT Z = -< w 2 en > .� CD -I G) C = t2 -n 0 = Oc MmDD 1' CI' -i O p -n m D N s WO m 03 � m Ocmi� o CD T T O oxiO -a O = zW �y, C 3J cn0 73 W c0 1 , Lf\ '.I = Op ODgX S y M -n .- n XzD e v . .� Q -71 TA gym i .3.13. n - 73m = Omoo ln ToWW _ =- I 8 5 en Orb rn Oz -m. 13 =1 0 m CI zoo ,l+ - F z > a 18 0 Z.-- Y WN M -,,,..-I = ' m m _I cn D o rcDnz O omr ( "' - rn � m m O o � m � t.- t, Cn mac' O 02 M 0 * D 00T° X m O M o = Z < z Cl) Q W D ▪ m s.•— C) O DSD r m m Zp r D 0 z r m m r0 W -< m = c ( 73 m z -1 77 e 73 Z CO M n ilA CD 13 `° CO CD SR 2 CD o CD CJ CL co a Cl)• CO `� CO -o = o m I- o - �- r m � r o-r- = f (\ CD 0 Dom � mca xi 3 m cZ Koc) c 0 2 En conn m pc N Z O �m, z vm pmz � V 0 0 g N O -{ z z 0 • c0z = 70z m m 00 m - D ID Z m m 0 z z -17 Dr 0 m Cn D m O -up^ mz I- W 7j - p s =i m m * o iv n o CO Z x 'rt z = -WGw CD -I GG) C = C O i I = O c m m D D 4 Cl- o D o � T xi « Cl) FT S1) r = O � -i m • xmm XI Ocmno F o rF ---I eri O 'n C) =z - �► 3 — p 7Jm C moC �Q 3 3 --I CK 73 oco ► -I X OTO- C7 73zo `1- 47. Q r w O 002 o m P E Dco -• T-I -� = m = gym " n O W Z mOo C +) M r=.18 -� W --I o ::ti -I O n Cl) � I- 7- F. zz � z 0mz r C D o0 , I M m CnoN CD Q- V' D m —I D 0 a n __ if m x m O 0 m m C- o X > m m Co (t3� � v 0z - li m p * 0 ppm mo 73 o = O) w Dm m Wm = Z < z C!) o W D -m-ID Cn -oO -I r m m O .1 o D Z 2 D pz r m00 .� 0EU 0 Z0coo r-! � m m c conn 0 z 2 C) > 73 CD CD -� c� 1 1 A CD CD - 2 CD -c m "ti 0 = rup w CD �. w 03 n CO su n _ � -o C.7 _— et r m0-i 0 r" r- or rt J CD � K r occur O o oom Erni 7z, a m � m -_-� mon _cn Z c zv) m (i) moc O O mZ 0 omz v0 0 m0 i •1 M m2 CDG) - , m op 7GmozD 0 Zm m ozz v\ r -n p m 5zm O OOCA) x1 rZ 8 CC Z OT. m Z = mow -I CD zX C = zW Q -n 2 oc m m >> o ' m 70 V) 2 0 cn cD -p -I OT m - > N s D � � « co co = O rn C) _� m -n -m -.. = o '� 3 —1 0k O = z CD O c�no ° I— 4' 0 0Co - O r- cn0 O ooz ,�;� ;11:•� m z ca z J' 5• —. m -� s -4 c 0 f' ^ --1 v c m = m `, 7° Ca mz8 O � r -Z-1 Op 0 O Cl) � o X oo n o a v z � v moo D � z n m8o O m -0 m Cn p 1.3 CCD ji m > p .. M cr, m 0 Omm PIX > m � 0 1 --.0Cn � ° 0 0zc M O * 0 oo ,u -u r = 73 o -Icn DOM m cnm = n 1 1 A -D 3 CD CQ N •`D CD v -< C (N I r- D ( CO Sy n = ifi - -v 0 � D Pm K r mT 00 W On mmm . T2:13 = I m t =a Koc) o z �n m c�nmpc O mz O omZ j I_ 0 cin 0 —1 m 0 �� • m m -I O� � G c J M o 0 xi m 0 D v z m m G) z z E T D0 m c) > 0 1 CJ 0Om . m -GZ r O 5 ern m * mo Z DCO r, Z = --GGw CD -1 C) ;C =0 _w Q ca. 97 1- -4 O p -�-� m D N o• CO W = � O X -- mFC I . M -�(IMO �p c r-!k M � T -G o� cnm 0 0 m -1 0 =p O = zc 11 P 2 � o c Wp J -1 cnXI 0 = 0 = oo CD073 M m - G y O � zOozH 6 �mM �W . . c m ;I m `+ -I - J= 0 PIW m z N 7 0 -F=. 4-- -1 O > 0n In 7-Po ccb -'}� I m O � z 0 -1D j� U D "_i Z00 'I rz Cpo O V fn m -a m cn0N 0 , ,,� m � m 0 0mm > ox D' m � 0 � w v 0 2- m p * p oc) rn -CI71 m - M �cii _ -I T )1 Z < z Cl) 0 W D 'J _ I m-ID (n mO � 8 > -53 ?L" E r m m O o r Z Z _:1_, D oz -< mOr0 - XI 0 D c0 —1 -4noo --< � m = Oct -C- m � -2 r � D 73 Xr CDCU n 1 1 A -o 3 `° CO C CD CD c rt (.1\ -u m o0 m r- 0 rt > � K r OWrn o� CD CD 0 Wm s � T � m M v -a � oc� \ O Cl FAz 0 omz 0 - cn 0 0 z z 3. 1 . m mz _O � G) X d . M- O zo xi m Glz -- _. D zm m G0zz -n Dcm -�Izm xi O m 70 I z r O Z Am Z = -< E.,:i CO c m CL tn 0o = W O z -im ._� r � m Omo 0 CD 1T7 -1 71 --I [^ m (� o m -i 0 = O m - W 3 Cn M O0 _ o0 n 2Jo . 1 m C_3 7,-) -_ mzoG - . p i � Wz 15 -11 � _ = gym v n O � W Z m08 .n O co 0 0 11 DC7 co Ora 2 OO > � K8n v \ �. OzID - Z , mz oD mcD o 8 0 v) 1- -I o mm m im > 0.-Y` ;+ -; omm ArTO ma C.." cn> oX n mWJO UN v oz - --C--) ) ,� 1 M om p OG� m �1 "Q m =O o = cn 70 � m m cnm = Z < z Cn 0W = (� -I me Cn m O --t C0 _ 0 O D > ), ' . _ I- mm Z � pr M 0z r moa _� r- ID -I -zi6 � -< � m cOcn 70 m z .� cci� C') z 2 0 D XI f