The URL can be used to link to this page

Agenda 06/24/2008 Item #17E Agenda Item No, HE June 24, 2008 Page 1 of 70 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY CUE-2008-AR-13066, Dieudonne Brutus, of the Tabernacle of Bethlehem, represented by David Sneed, Kuhlman Engineering, Inc" is requesting a one-year extension of a Conditional Use approval for a church granted in Resolution No, 05-134 in the Village Residential (VR) Zoning District, pursuant to Subsection 10.08.E.3 of the Land Development Code. The 0.69 acre subject property is located at 305 3rd Street South (Immokalee), in Section 4, Township 47 South, Range 29 East, Collier County, Florida. OBJECTIVE: To have the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) approve a Conditional Use Extension (CUE) for a Conditional Use to allow a church in the Village Residential (VR) Zoning District. CONSIDERATIONS: The Tabernacle of Bethlehem Conditional Use was originally approved by the Board of County Commissioners acting as the BZA on March 23. 2005; by Resolution No, 05-134 (see Exhibit A to the attached Resolution), The approval permitted the petitioner to use the existing structure for a house of worship, Expansion or enlargement of the existing structure was prohibited, In conjunction with this Conditional Use, the petitioner also received approval of variances from the I-acre minimum lot area requirement to allow the existing O,69-acre site to be used for a church, and a reduction of the 35-foot required front yard setback to allow a 20-foot setback, a reduction in the nunlber of parking spaces by 14 spaces from the required 33 parking spaces to 19 spaces, and a reduction in the landscape buffer by 5 feet on the north and south property lines from a 15-foot wide type "B" to allow a 10-foot wide type "B" buffer in Resolution No, 05-135, Those variances are still in full force and effect and do not require additional action to extend them, Per Section IO,08,E,1. of the Collier County Land Development Code (LDC), Conditional Uses automatically expire three years from their date of approval if activity on the project has not commenced, The petitioner has not stated a reason why the use has not yet commenced, In any case, Section 10,08,E,3, of the LDC pennits the BZA to grant a maximum one year extension of a Conditional Use upon written request of the petitioner; no reason is required to be provided, ,- The original Conditional Use was approved by the BZA in conjunction with favorable findings made based on the following criteria, pursuant to LDC Section IO,08,02,D: · Granting of the Conditional Use would not adversely affect the public interest; · The specific requirements governing the individual Conditional Use, if any, will be met by the petitioner or variances have been granted to address the requirement; · The proposed change was deemed consistent with the Growth Management Plan (GMP) and the LDC; · Ingress and egress to the property, with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety, convenience, traffic flow, and access in case of fire or catastrophe was addressed; · The potential effects of noise, glare, economic or odor effects were mitigated; and CUE-2008-AR-13066: rabernacle of Bethlehem 1 of3 Agenda Item No. 17E June 24, 2008 Page 2 of 70 . The proposed land use was compatible with the existing land use pattern, As the area surrounding the subject site has remained unchanged since the original approval, the subject Conditional Use remains consistent with the GMP and the LDC, Furthermore, all issues relative to access, impacts and compatibility that were addressed at the time of the original approval and made subject to various stipulations that will be carried fOlward with approval of this CUE, FISCAL IMPACT: The Conditional Use Extension approval by and of itself will have no fiscal impact on Collier County, There is no guarantee that the project, at build out, will maximize its authorized level of development, however, if the Conditional Use Extension is approved, and the church use is established in the existing vacant building. the new use could have an impact on Collier County public facilities, The County collects all applicable impact fees before the issuance of building permits to help offset the impacts of each new development on public facilities, These impact fees are used to fund identified projects in the Growth Management Plan Capital Improvement Element as needed to maintain adopted Levels of Service (LOS) for public facilities, Additionally, in order to meet the requirements of Section 1O,02,07(C) of the Land Development Code, fifty percent (50%) of the estimated Transportation Impact Fees associated with the project are required to be paid simultaneously with the approval of each final local development order. Other fees collected before the issuance of a building permit include building permit review fees and the remainder of all applicable impact fees, Finally, additional revenue is generated by application of ad valorem tax rates, and that revenue is directly related to the value of the improvements, Please note that impact fees and taxes collected were not included in the criteria uscd by Staff and the Planning Commission to analyze this petition, GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN (GMP) IMPACT: The subject property is designated Urban Residential. High Residential District, on the Immokalee Area Master Plan Future Land Use Map of the Growth Management Plan, Relevant to this petition, this Subdistrict permits non-residcntial uses such as community facilities, which includes churches, Therefore. staff concludes the proposed use for the subject site can be deemed consistent with the Future Land Use Element. TRANSPORTATION IMPACT: No outstanding transportation issues are associated with this petition, The applicant would be required to comply with all applicable developmental regulations when development approvals are sought. The Traffic Impact Statement associated with the original Conditional Use application did not reveal any potential transportation issues, To alleviate concerns about parking congestion, the original Conditional Use approval contained several conditions to either limit the scope of the use or reiterate that all parking must be contained on site; parking within the right of way would not be allowed, CUE,2008,AR-13066: Tabernacle of Bethlehem 20f3 Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 3 of 70 ENVIRONMENT AL IMPACT: There are no outstanding environmental issues associated with this petition, LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: No legal issues are presented by this Application, Approval must be by supermajority vote, - JAK RECOMMENDATION: Staffrecommends that the Board of Zoning Appeals approve CUE-2008-AR-13066 to permit a one year extension of the Conditional Use until March 23, 2009, PREPARED BY: Kay Deselem, AlCP, Principal Planner Department of Zoning & Land Development Review CUE-2008-AR-13066: Tabemacle of Bethlehem 3013 Item Number: Item Summary: Meeting Date: Page 1 of2 Agenda Item No. 17E June 24, 2008 Page 4 of 70 COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS 17E This item requires that all participants be sworn in and ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members CUE-200B-AR-13066: Dieudonne Brutus, of the Tabernacle of Bethlehem, represented by David Sneed, Kuhlman Engineering, Inc., is requesting a one- year extension of a Conditional Use approval for a church granted in Resolution No. 05-134 in the Village Residential (VR) Zoning District. pursuant to Subsection 10,OB.E.3 of the land Development Code. The 0.69 acre subject property is located at 305 3rd Street South (Immokalee), in Section 4, Township 47 South, Range 29 East Collier County, Florida. 6124/2008 9:0000 AM Prepared By Kay Deselem, Ale? Community Development & Environmental Services Principal Planner Date Zoning & Land Development Review 5/22/20089:49:31 AM Approved By Susan Murray, Ale? Community Development & Environmental Services Zoning & Land Development Director Date Zoning & Land Development Review 5128/20088:54 AM Approved By Ray Bellows Community Development & Environmental Services Chief Planner Date Zoning & Land Development Review 5128/20089:00 AM Approved By Judy Puig Community Development & Environmental Services Operations Analyst Community Development & Environmental Services Admin. Date 5/2B/2008 10:37 AM Approved By Jeff Klatzkow County Attorney Assistant County Attorney Date County Attorney Office 5129/2008 8:47 AM Approved By Nick Casalanguida Transportation Services MPO Director Date Transportation Planning 5/2912008 1 :54 PM Approved By Joseph K. Schmitt Community Development & Environmental Services Community Development & Environmental Services Adminstrator Date Community Development & Environmental Services Admin. 6/10120088:04 PM Approved By file://C:IArrendaTestIFxnortl 11 O-.I11ne%)024,%)0200~1 17%?OSllMM A RY%?OAGFNDA I till R/?OOR Page 2 of2 Agenda Item No, 17E .June 24, 2008 Page 5 of 70 Norm E. Feder, Alep Transportation Division Administrator Date Transportation Services Transportation Services Admin. 6/12/200811:08 AM Approved By OMS Coordinator OMS Coordinator Date County Manager's Office Office of Management & Budget 6/12/20082:13 PM Approved By Mark Isackson Budget Analyst Date County Manager's Office Office of Management & Budget 6/13/200811:11 AM Approved By James V. Mudd County Manager Date Board of County Commissioners County Manager's Office 6/16/2008 12:44 PM tile:/!c:IA0endaTestlF.xnmtl 11 0-,hl11p%?0?4 %?O?OORI 17 %?OSI lMM A RY%?OA"FNnA I A/1 R/?OOR COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW WWW.COLLIERGOV.NET <;) Agenda Item No, 17E June 24,2008 Page 6 of 70 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES. FLORID~ 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX (239) 252-6968 I:;; ; ,'i,;i j::.{ J" APPLlCA'tJc:t) '", B PUSLI'O' HIiARING" ;"~:,' ,"~,)" "1,;" "/,:",,. ~~:'~L{i:'~:~;';;,J'::;'\,'~';:") ;:~'.:2,ft I'l,,',';c';':f:',f'ic:, ':'~:,~:~' " "~ ' " , ''I',:~;;tP: ,'",0"", : , J' ",' "<:P eO~Pf11~t " ' 8_la~T,t:NSJON ;",,,' ;'/.:::'i:';';' ';;- ;" '; ;;'~,r': :.,';,;" " ;' -,",,' -,,~i._'<',' ;,,--; ",~,:j" i;;;::-,;j" :~: :,\-:\';i{::;:J:('?~~;,:')~~';;/:<'~".-~:,:t:jl~~~t,r::T';:\: ~/':::';:;',,?',:'Jr'f:\:;. . ".'.,\,':"":;~~t>,~"': PETITION NO (AR) PROJECT NAME PROJECT NUMBER DATE PROCESSED ASSIGNED PLANNER CUE-2008-AR-13066 REV: 1 ] TABERNACLE OF BETHLEHEM 2002060036 DATE: 3/20/08 DUE: 4/3/08 ABOVE TO BE COMPLETED BY STAFF ."".;_..-:,:,. ~".,. ", ;-:'.";",;';:J,';,~;:),,-,, ,',' ,'ApPLlG~NT,INFqRIVIATI9N " ,,-,,-:-:,-,":::;""\1"; i,'_i -:i:Y~!:'.;;<':.".'~';'-:lMP,:%'!f~;~;~h;2Ai7i:i~~'P:;:~':;;" NAME OF APPLlCANT(S) TABERNACLE OF BETHLEHEM ADDRESS PO BOX 3085 CITY IMMOKALEE STATE FL ZIP 34143-3085 TELEPHONE # 353-0916 CELL # FAX # E-MAIL BETHSHEBAQ27@AOL.COM NAME OF AGENT DAVID SNEED FIRM KUHLMAN ENGINEERING, INC ADDRESS 2223 TRADE CENTER WAY CITY NAPLES STATE FL ZIP 34109 TELEPHONE # 254-8219 CELL # 591-5465 FAX # 514-4905 E-MAIL ADDRESSDAVIDSNEED@YAHOO.COM BE AWARE THAT COLLIER COUNTY HAS LOBBYIST REGULATIONS. GUIDE YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY ANO ENSU~E THAT YOU ARE IN COMPLIANCE WITH THESERE::GULATIONS. Page 1 of 8 Conditional Use Extension lpplicatian - Feb. 2008 Agenda Item No, 17E June 24 2008 r'age f aT / , DISCLOSURE OF INTEREST INFORMATION a. If the property is owned fee simple by an INDIVIDUAL, tenancy by the entirety, tenancy in common, or joint tenancy, list all parties with an ownership interest as well as the percentage of such interest (Use additional sheets if necessary). Name and Address Percentage of Ownership b. If the property is owned by a CORPORATION, list the officers and stockholders and the percentage of stock owned by each. Name and Address Percentage of Ownership c. If the property is in the name of a TRUSTEE, list the beneficiaries of the trust with the percentage of interest. Name and Address Percentage of Ownership Tabernacle of Bethlehem International Mission Oieudonne & Lunie Brutus 100 Page 2 0 f 8 Conditional U~e Extension Application - Feb. 2008 Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 8 of 70 d. If the property is in the name of a GENERAL or LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, list the name of the general and/or limited partners. Name and Address Percentage of Ownership e. If there is a CONTRACT FOR PURCHASE, with an individual or individuals, a Corporation, Trustee, or a Partnership, list the names of the contract purchasers below, including the officers, stockholders, beneficiaries, or partners. Name and Address Percentage of Ownership Date of Contract: f. If any contingency clause or contract terms involve additional parties, list all individuals or officers, if a corporation, partnership, or trust. Name and Address Page 3 of 8 Conditional Use Extension Application - Feb. 2008 g. Date subject property acquired D leased D Term of lease Aaenda Item No, 17E - June 24, 2008 Page 9 of 70 yrs./mos. If, Petitioner has option to buy, indicate the following: Date of option: Date option terminates: , or Anticipated closing date: h. Should any changes of ownership or changes in contracts for purchase occur subsequent to the date of application, but prior to the date of the final publiC hearing, it is the responsibility of the applicant, or agent on his behalf, to submit a supplemental disclosure of interest form. I',' , .' ,..-', . ,..... . " ,',-,. ....;." ,':r;o"',- ~ .. ",- ;~ . ,'; ': ',r'PRCP,ERr(L(:?tATION " ., ., ry,:"r':~" 'i_ '; :'.~, :_":""i.:.--" . :',\~:~,.'....... -. "'W<.o; ,,', I Detailed leaal descriDtion of the DrODertv covered bv the aDDlication: (If space is inadequate, attach on separate page. Applicant shall submit two (2) copies of a signed and sealed boundary survey (completed within the last six months, maximum 1" to 400' scale) if required to do so at the pre-application meeting. NOTE: The applicant is responsible for supplying the correct legal description. If questions arise concerning the legal description, an engineer's certification may be required. SectionlTownship/Range 4/47S/29E Lot: Block: Subdivision: Plat Book Page #: Property 1.0.#: 00124960000 Metes & Bounds Description: See attached SIZE OF PROPERTY: ft, X ft. = Total Sq. Fl Acres 0,59 ADDRESS/GENERAL LOCATION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: 305 South 3rd Street, Immokalee, FL Page 4 0 f 8 Conditional Use Extension Application - Feb. 2008 Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 10 of 70 I")/~'i;':, ;,,;-,.: ,,' '.,. I.,ADJACeNT~ZONING;AND .LAND USE;:;, . '''-..' ',_,' '-.. '.. .-',' ",,-, .' .' ,......,.." -'", ..' ',_ u" .'.' .~,..,. ." '."__..~ ..,.' .~. -,.,'.. ....."...... ._, '.,____,'.'_, .~~fd:';~i.~AJ;~:1::{!1:~:' ,:-.~~, L;i~i~~,,'::;'~;':~\'~;',\:,t~,.:.',':;::':'!, \ J Zoning when CU approved land use CU approved Current Zoning Current land use N VR S VR E VR W VR I VR VR VR VR " CONDITIONAL USE REQUeST DETAil TVDe of Conditional Use: This application is requesting a conditional use extension allowed per LDC Section 2,04,03 of the VR zoning district for Church (type of use), EVAlUATIONCRl'rERIA' , Evaluation Criteria: Provide a narrative statement describing this request for conditional use extension. NOTE: Pursuant to Section 10,08,00, of the Collier County Land Development Code, staff's recommendation to the Planning Commission and the Planning Commission's recommendation to the Board of Zoning Appeals shall be based upon a finding that the granting of the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and that the specific requirements governing the individual conditional use, if any, have been met, and that further, satisfactory provision and arrangement have been made concerning the following matters, where applicable. Please provide detailed response to each of the criterion listed below. Specify how and why the request is consistent with each. (Attach additional pages as may be necessary). a, Describe how the conditional use remains consistent with the Collier County Land Development Code (LOC) and Growth Management Plan (GMP) (include information on how the request remains consistent with the applicable section or portions of the future land use element): The use remains the same as the original Conditional Use Approval. Project is consistet with GMP, Site development approval shall comply with current LDC, b, Discuss whether any GMP amendments have been adopted since the conditional use was approved that may affect this site, Page 5 0 f 8 Conditional Use Extension Application - Feb. 2008 NA Agenda Item ~Jo, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 11 of 70 c, Describe any development or redevelopment that has occurred on adjacent parcels and what affect, if any, an extension of this conditional use may have on those uses, None d, Please provide any additional information which you may feel is relevant to this request. Previous land use petitions on the subiect prODertv: To your knowledge, has a public hearing been held on this property or any abuttina DroDerties within the last year? If so, what was the nature of that hearing? ' No Additional submittal reauirements: In addition to this completed application, the following must be submitted in order for your application to be deemed sufficient, unless otherwise waived during the pre-application meeting, a, A copy of the pre-application meeting notes; b, Five (5) copies of the previously approved conditional use site plan [and one reduced BYz" x 11" copy of site plan]. [Additional copies of the plan may be requested upon completion of staff evaluation for distribution to the Board], c, A copy of the resolution that approved this conditional use, d, A copy of the complete original Conditional Use Application for Public Hearing, Page 6 0 f 8 Conditional Use Extension Application - Feb. 2009 . . Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 12 of 70 CONDITIONAL USE EXTENSION (CUE) APPLICAnON - $UI!lMITTAL. CHECKLIST .c""~;',;/_ ':,:~~fr>:"i" '-', THIS COMPLETED CHECKLIST IS TO BE SUBMITTED WITH APPLICATION PACKET IN THE EXACT ORDER LISTED BELOW W/COVER SHEETS ATTACHED TO EACH SECTION. IINOTE: INCOMPLETE SUBMITTALS WILL NOT BE ACCEPTED.II #OF NOT REQUIREMENTS COPIES REQUIRED REQUIRE[ STANDARD REQUIREMENTS: Cover letter brieflY eXolainina the orOiect 5 [XJ I Application (completed & signed) (download from website for 5 [8J 0 current forml Resolution that aooroved the Conditional Use 1 ComDlete oriciinal Conditional Use Apclication for Public Hearino 1 Site Plan 24' X 36" Diusrone 6 Y, X 11 copv) 5 Copies of Warranty Deed(s) 2 [8J 0 Completed Owner/Agent Affidavits, Notarized 1 [8J D Traffic Impact Statement (TIS), or waiver 2 [8J 0 Electronic copy of all documents and plans (CDROM or 1 [8J 0 Diskette) BoundarvSurvey (no more than 6 months old) 2 [X l Economic Development Council (EDC) Projects: 2 D 0 EDC "Fast Track' must submit aooroved coov of official EDC aoolication Additional set if located in the Bayshore/Gateway Triangle 1 D 0 Redevelonment Area OTHER - OTHER - OTHER - PLANNERS -INDICATE IF PETITION NEEDS TO BE ROUTED TO REVIEWERS BELOW: 1 Trans ortation Division 1 1 Utilities - Zamira Deltoro 1 1 Ba shore/Gatewa Trian Ie Redevelo ment Area 1 OTHER - 03/vloB ( BATE :::T)A--i/ID -< L>ee:I) ApplicanVAgent PRINTED Name Page 7 of 8 Conditional Use Extension Application - Feb. 2008 Age:1da item No. 17E June 24, 2008 Page 13 of 70 AFFIDA VlT Well. Dieudonne Brutus being first duly sworn, depose and say that well am/are the owners of the property described herein and which is the subject matter of the proposed hearing; that all the answers to the questions in this application, including the disclosure of interest irifOrmation, all sketches, data, and other supplementary matter attached to and made a part of this application, are honest and true to the best of our krwwledge and belief Well understand that the iriformation requested on this application must be complete and accurate and that the content of this form, whether computer generated or County printed shall not be altered. Public hearings will not be advertised until this application is deemed complete, and all required infOrmation has been submitted. As property owner Well further authorize Kuhlman Engineering, Ine, to act as ourlmy representative in any matters regarding this Petition. Jl~/47~ Signature of Property Owner Signature of Property Owner Dieudonne Brutus Typed or Printed Name of Owner Typed or Printed Name of Owner The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this 24? day of F ~ 20 Pt3, hy-:[), .<U~~ l?e<77"'S who is personally known to me or has produced f"LSll. 13 II!>:!! I t,P~/'I~~ as identification. State of Florida County of Collier Notary Stamp ..'~ DAVlDC,SNEEIl J'~-"'~ MVCOMM~S~'DD~ . · EXPIRES: January 7, 2009 ... ">_llruBudIOt"*Y- "~r1Ff\.~ CUE-2008-AR-13066 REV: 1 TABERNACLE OF BETHLEHEM 2002060036 DATE: 3/20/08 DUE: 4/3/08 . . COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT DEPT, OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW WWW.COLLlERGOV.NET 6968 Agenda Item No. HE 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIRl8 NAPLES, FLORIDA 34'ilM8 14 of 70 (239) 403-2400 FAX (239) 643- @ CONDITIONAL USE EXTENSION PRE-APPLICATION MEETING NOTES & SUBMITTAL CHECKLIST Date: 3-I2:-D~ Time: 11'00 Planner:J\A.\{\)~""'J::K Project Name: IABEl<NA.c.u;: OF ~<'EHE.M Project Addr/Location: 305 ~ ~l2.D Sf": ~KA LEE" Applicant Nam:DAVI D ~ l-J ~ Phone: '6q~stfb5 Firm: Current Zoning: VR . Owner Name: Owner Address: Phone: Meeting Attendees: (attach Sign In Sheet) ~~ito-.cW Niti'". . ~ Ce-.."..e~71f ~$. .fJJ~ Ira"'; ~ [I II II /I "fhl{j~ TG\l ~ LDMM .H) t-s u)l~ NOTES: <5J)~ 1 CUE-2008-AR-13066 REV: 1 TABERNACLE OF BETHLEHEM 2002060036 DATE: 3/20/08 DUE: 4/3/08 CONDITIONAL USE EXTENSION (CUE) APPLICATION SUBMITTAL CHECKLIST Agenda Item No, 17E ...---mTe .:." 008 Page 15 f 70 THIS COMPLETED CHECKLIST IS TO BE SUBMITTED WITH APPLICATION PACKET IN THE EXACT ORDER LISTED BELOW W/COVER SHEETS ATTACHED TO EACH SECTION. NOTE: INCOMPLETE SUMBITTALS WILL NOT BE ACCEPTED, #OF NOT REQUIREMENTS COPIES REQUIRED REQUIREI STANDARD REQUIREMENTS: Cover letter brieflv exotainina the proiect 5 i:8J 11 Application (completed & signed) (download from website for 5 i:8J 0 current fonn I Addressina Checklist signed by Addressina 1 Pre-Aoolication meetina notes 5 Site Pia " . one 8 Y, X 11 coov\ <. Mo.l \ CJY\W 5 Copies of Warranty Deed(s) ("\ 2 [8:1 0 Completed Owner/Agent Affidavits, Notarized 1 [8:1..,..... 0_ Traffic Impact Statement (TIS), or waiver 2 [8:1 \:t..J .:gr Electronic copy of all documents and plans (CDROM or 1 [8:1 0 Diskette) Boundarv Survev \ lie.. "'" 1\ 1r\l1C. 2 IXI Tl Economic Development Council (EDC) Projects: . 2 EDC 'Fast Track" must submit approved copy of official EDC ~ apolication .Additional set if located in the Bayshore/Gateway Triangle 1 0 ':1/ Redevelopment Area OTHER - OTHER - OTHER - 7 IY .... , PLANNERS -.NDICATE IF PETITION NEEDS TO BE ROUTED TO REVIEWERS BELOW: Trans ortation Division Utilities - Zamira Deltoro Ba shore/Gatewa Trian Ie Redevelo ment Area OTHER - 2 FEES: Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 16 of 70 ~ Pre-application Fee $500,00 (Applications submitted 9 months or more after the date of the last pr....app meeting shall not be credited towards application fees and a new pre- application meeting will be required.) ~ $3,000.00 $363.00 Application Fee Estimated Legal Advertising Fee. Bee Meeting (any aver- or under-payment will be reconciled upon receipt of Invoice from Naples Daily News). Transportation Fees, If required: B o $500,00 Methodology Review Fee, if required o $750,00 Minor Study Review Fee, If required o ,$1,500.00 Malor Study Review Fee, if required ~19a~~rh-h fJ1L ~t-o...f'F OTHER REQUIREMENTS: o o o o Applicant/Agen'Signature Date . 3 . I: I ~ III . WOO;;:: II: r--oi.- a ~~,o a o ' . z~[~ .... - (D (D :c t: c:: 0) 2::Jro ~ ~ ;; ;1 GI ;;2 .- > Q; GI OJ Ill: <{ - c Cl CD z E ;::: a.. ~ w 0 II: w :E "ii w > iIll "- CD - :E ('l 0 Q ;:) w "lS Z .... ... I . c Z IS (YJO .... 0 oil :z: Do ~ lSI = C .- ..... c 'SE-l 0 N ~~ - ... 0 c: ~~ - -i:-. :E C 0- lD GI II: 800 E on i!: ~ 'C 0 ~ M GI 0 ~ 5~ 8- 0: .... lI> Do ~ II lI> ... Q CD a =z .. -.. ~ "lS Z Q..~ "lS 0 Q..~ oc( in ca - :> ij 100 '0 '" is .. e ~ 'S: ~ ~ l!? ;.. ell w ~ Gj z g ;:) 't! VI 0 ~ U N 0 ~ - II [i1 M " .c '" Co! ,5; u.. I c: M '" 0 - ';; Co! 'i .. I '" Ill: 0- 'S: ~... M ~ W N Z c. Z a. ~~ .. " oc( CD e .... .J:I 0.. a- E :S 9 Q ~ u: w z lOo z GI <' C '" in 0 Do r- ~ .c a- COLtlER COUNTY GOVERNMENT . ADDRESSING DEPARTMENT (i) Agenda Item No. 17E 2800 NORTH HORS6S~ NAPLES, FLORIDA 3"'~ 18 of 70 ADDRESSING CHECKLIST Please complete the following and fax to the Addressing Department at 239-659-5724 or submit in person to the Addressing Department at the above address, Form must be signed by Addressing personnel prior to pre-application meeting, Not all items wlJl apply to every project, Items in bold type are required, Forms olderthan 6 months will require additional review and approval by the Addressing Department, PETITION TYPE (check petition type below, comp/ete a separate Addressing Checklist for each Petition Type) o BL (Blasting Permit) o BD (Boat Dock Extension) 6Zl CU (Conditional Use) o EXP (Excavation Permit) o FP (Final Plat o LLA (Lot Une Adjustment) o PNC (project Name Change) o PPL (Plans & Plat Review) o PSP (Preliminary Subdivision Plat) o PUD Rezone o RZ (standard Rezone) DSDP (Site Development Plan) o SDPA (SOP Amendment) o SDPI (Insubstantial Change to SDP) o SIP (site Improvement Plan) o SIPI (Insubstantial Change to SIP) o SNR (street Name Change) o SNC (street Name Change - Unplatted) o TOR (Transter of Development Rights) o VA (Variance) o VRP (Vegetation Removal Permit) ,0 VRSFP (Vegetation Removal & Site Fill Permit) o OTHER LEGAL DESCRIPTION of subject property or properties (copy of lengthy description may be attached) y ~ c..L..-1 ~4- . z.. "b u... - 4- l - z.., FOLIO (Property 10) NUMBER(s)of above (attach to, or associate with, lagal description if more than one) 00 I '-4-llI'c..o 000 STREET ADDRESS or ADDRESSES (as applicable, if already assigned) 30 S ~rd S"T "=>, LOCATION MAP must be attached showing exact location of projeclJsite in relation to nearest public road right-of-way SURVEY (copy - needed only for unplatted properties) PROPOSED PROJECT NAME (d applicable) PROPOSED STREET NAMES (if applicable) SITE DEVELOPMENT PLAN NUMBER (for existing projects/sites only) SOP orAR# Page 1 of2 'ADDRESSING CHECKLIST - Page 2 Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 19 of 70 Project or development names proposed for, or already appearing In, condominium documents (if application; indicate whether proposed or existing) Please Check One: 0 Checklist Is to be Faxed back o Personally Picked Up APPLICANT NAME: UAvIO PHONE: 2'5 ~- Ii' 2. /9 s ~e::e;.;J FAX: Signature on Addressing Checklist does not constitute Project and/or Street Name approval and is subject to further review by the Addressing Department. FOR STAFF USE ONLY Primary Number 7....0 I ~ Address Number Address Number Address Number Approved bY:.L'~ VI ~ A Updated by: rY\.~a ........ Date: 0"3> - \ 'Z.. - 0 <g Date: IF OLDER THAN 6 MONTHS, FORM MUST BE UPDATED OR NEW FORM SUBMITTED Page 2 of" . DeselemKay Subject: Location: Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 20 of 70 "....- Pre-App CU; David Sneed, Agent; Kay Deselem, Planner Conference Room C Start: End: Show Time As: Wed 3/121200811:00AM Wed 3/1212008 11:45 AM Tentative Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Not yet responded Required Attendees: CDS-C; DeselemKay; PiotrowiczClaudia; SawyerMichael; AblerKennelh; AuclairClaudine; beard_I; BuchheitDavid; callis_m; CasalanguidaNick; DeltoroZamira; jarrell..,p; mulleu; PodczerwinskyJohn; seaLs; wiley-r Meeting Request Number: 3801 Meeting Type: preapplication Requested By: David Sneed on 26-Feb-08 Phone: 5915465 eMaiI: davidsneed@yahoo.com Representing: Tabernacle of Bethlehem Church Folio: 00124960000 Zoning CU SPDISIP Subject Type: Conditional Use Location: 305 sOUT5H 3RD Street Immokalee Description: Conditional Sue Extension CU-2003-AR-4326, Kay Deselem was the planner for the CU, Mike Sawyer will be assigned the CU extension r ,-' 1 . . 00 ~ooo 0 I 0 C- O ~o....... .... ,N 0 . :b~ . NN - <;Q)Q) ,., ill c 0) :::=::ld: ro~ i 00 '0 C I .,., '" I-t"' 0\ OJ .. Zs: 00 <{ .. .. 0:::> 0\ u UJ&1t:;trt e ~ . W Q " t-= ;; ~~ .....m......,..o j ;:- U'JQoW;:::1O ~ = " 00 CNu.WN 15. ~ u ::I .!! lllO ~!;;OU)u) .!i 00 .!! .. i ..:::> .,..t15!z ~ ~ :e- O!. ~ N!!! '" . ~ ~ 0 . ~o lil=~..o I i . 0 . 0 ~ ~ .. 0 80' .0 ;:::0 .. .. " 1.:5 Ei.~wm i . .. . . . - .! .'C"'o .. 'i .. ~ '!i ~ zulLl.LQ. u .. i Eo: ",~000 : . . ;; .. t ~ .. .. .. .. " :::lI CD tt: C:!..... z.. I 0 . ,gfi! ii~~t~ " ~ .fz3.,!,zo~~ ~ g f ~ ...J t .. 0. .s OS " ~ I ~ . ~ ~ u s rn e Q g ~ .~ ~! 1 !:s ~ ... '': == ro ~5 0 'C G.~ ~ . 01 Q) B. '': ro i"='. .. ",,5 OS 'E ~ II E= .. 8s ':;::l ... iE: "0 li" ><: -" 0. e,e ~ ~ cj ~ ~ '': 0. 0. c. OS " .€ c . 0 ~ " g S 15 .L:l " ~ .. " S ~ 0 " ~ ti . ~ "' ~ '8 :t l:i. i' 0. ~ OS E .... c. ,!l " ~ = -=; . 8 i- , j or E 15 S " l ~ "" i:i. : N Jl , 0 v ~s INSTIlUMENT nu....l\ED ll~: ~ K, TboI'AJ'IOD. ~ul'" 1150 Lee BouIevord. SUlle 1 Lehiah Acm. Florida 33936 1'11',,011,0, No: 0007760001 Agenda Item No, 17E 0" J. -COC: -.oJ.&. ,... June 2.f, "2tJ08 P~GI?a~2> 22 of 70 292~ ui: 2974 PG: 3169 1IC08IJ 10 OIrIC1~ UfO" s! CjlWll amY. II 11/11I1tI1 l\ II :llllllllilll. ::. Gl~toI"'o III nl 11.11 tot'.ll III." ~-~ wV ~~ ~u'~ua uJ~n~ Dru~u~ ~~'21'20e2 ~9'5B 194)3G.",~3 -- Itt.ll IUII11 I ftIIIPlOl nlllli 1m IU ~noN""'> " TRUSTEE'S nun nus TRUST DEEn made the I ~cIIy of )IIlUll}'. 2002. by MARGARET HAZEL CREWS u Trustee oflbe JIM PAUL 2Uws I.d MARGAREI' HAZEL CREWS TRUST AGRJ:Et.u:NTullld 11122196. who.. mlUiIlgl4dl'eu t.l'ortOlllce:E\ox 1S7,lmmokalee, AC>rid. 34143 hcainalUr ..fenod 10.. "G_tot," for ""d ill collliderauon of the S1IllI of TEN AND NO/IOO DOLLARS (510.00) and oW:!' vllu.ble tollslderatlatl. l'KCillt whCfCOf is hCteby Ic1aIowledpd,llll4 by T.....ERNAO-It OF BETHLEHEM INTERNATIONAL MISSION. HOLINESS TO TIlE LORD, INC.. I 1IOl-(or-prollt Florida "orporID~ whole /lddrcss is ~ Wilt Om, OpeIoeb, Florida 330~ who.. Tax IcIentlfic:&1ion No, is ~-m ..s:l~'1D and DIEUDONNI: BR1lTUS ODd LUNU: BRvnJS, hUlb.nd IIDCI wife. who." mallina Iddrw _ J. !IOO Opapoclca Boulevard Mini. Ftorida 33054. IIId whole Social Security NOlI, OR ~ S"/_I'1~..1;~'1 Z;-~i."A..J..~.u~jnafterrefcnedtoas"OraDtoct"conVC)'lto GrolltM the lolloWllll tcaI JlI"jlCIty in CoIJier CoIIII\)', FIorida.1o-wit: BeJlnnlng IUhe NorIbce1 come: of lit. We51JIO l'ectofthe EIII 1070 feet oflbe North halfofthe Sotslhel5lqllllllerofSecli0ll4. TDWlISblp 47 SoIltll,R~29Eut, Collier County, Florida; !hence lUll South alona the East bolllldlll}' line of said lI'Iet We'l 310 feet of the Ea.1 1070 reet traet I lItSllllcc of 150 feet 10 the point of bcsizuUnl oC tract !le..ln ""scribed; 'bence COD1inuirJ& Soulb alo", ";4 Bul boundll)' lin. ofuId tnlOt a dllllllCC oC250 feet; Ibcnc. nIlI Watt 120 feet; lhonoa ~ Nonh 250 feel; d1e_ NIl But 120 feel 10 . poilJl Dr beginning. Sold property bo.ns al.o de.oribcd u LoIS 3, 4, S, 6...d 7 ofa IlIIp ofuUbdlvision proj>Oscd to be rec:ordtd under the name ofLalte Vi..... PtOjlellies. GRANTOR COVENANTS with Qranw, that O:uttor hu ,ood rilht and lawful aulh~1ity II> sell ~ convey lht.propcny and GrIIltor ~t. the titl.to the Jll'OI'Clt)' for allY &Cia ofOranlur .... WIll defend lite mle agaJlllt tho lawful clllllllll of all potlom clolrniq by, tbruu,h or under Gnntor, IN WITNESS WHElU:OF. the .lld Onntorr have hereUnto ..Ithair ban.. and Hall Che day 8Dd y<.ar rust above wrincn. Signed, ..aled and deUvered in 111. Jl.l1"ClICe of: ~:E: g~~~~__ J CUE_2008-AR-13066 REV: 1 TABERNACLE OF BETHLEHEM 2002060036 DATE: 3/20/08 DUE: 4/3/08 CU_2003-AR-4326 PROJECT #2002060036 DATE: 6/17/03 M~k ~"C!c:l....- Kil..'r ':"1:3El.E~t (COMPANJO~ ~O_ V ~_~0~~A~~3~~ _ Agenda Item No. 17E -- -JuA@..24,-2008 Page 23 of 70 CUE-2008-AR-13066 REV: 1 -- TABERNACLE OF BETHLEHEM 2002060036 DATE: 3/20/08 DUE: 4/3/08 LEGAL DESCRIPTION CU-2003-AR-4326 LEGAL DESCRIPTION BCGINNING AT THC NORTHCAST CORNCR OF THC VCST 380 FCCT OF THC CAST 1070 FCCT OF THC NORTH HALF OF THC SOUTHCAST QUARTCR OF THC SOUTHEAST QUARTCR OF SCCTIo.", 4, roVNSHIP 47 SOUTH, RANGE B9 CAST, COLLICR COUNTY, FLORIDA THCNCE RUN SOUTH ALONG THF: CAST BOUNDARY LINF: OF SAID TRACT 'WEST 380 FCET OF THE EAST 1070 FCET TRACT A DISTANCe OF 150 FeET TO THC POINT OF BEGINNING OF TRACT HE:RClN DESCRIBE:D; THENCE: CONTINUING SOUTH ALONG SAID CAST BOUNDARY LINF: OF SAID TRACT A DISTANCC OF 250 FCeT; THE:NCE RUN 'WEST 120 FCET; THENCC RUN NORTH B50 FEET, THENce RUN EAST 120 nET TO A POINT OF BEGINNING, SAID PROPE:RTY BE:ING ALSO DESCRIBCD AS LOTS 3, 4, 5, 6 AND 7, OF A HAP OF A SUBDIVISION PRopaSED TO. BF: RCClJRDF:D UNL'ER THE: NAMF: OF LAKE VIF:I.I PROPE:RTIES. bhibit :3 . . Q.r J>.a.tION~IlN,....t2IWlJlDIlM:I1:W'" IUI 1111 11I1 l\li~1 lml 111!11 i! flil I! !b' IIi' 'I ! JIt'1 " - I I . I I I J( , ' " . I ~ II 1 I " J J I I J J I J J I -~ I r,.. Ii' " \ I f.. ",j \t I I "'. \ I l~, "'" < Ii al' I I """" '" \\ 1:.-. I I', ' l:&~ I "'. ", "'i J i ",,' \ ~e; I.', .. g I k ". I I : I "'t "t J f, '" l~-.l ", I ", , )1 ''to, ( '11-1"1 t.", "\ t I, I l "'" ' I" '.. 1:'0, ", I j ", J I, "',,' t J I', " I I', ' \111: "" I I l,. -', "IIl{, """ " '-J.. ". 1J "\ ---~- ... - I ( I I I \ \ \ \ \ \ I I -i i l~ '\....,/ \ I ,- _L~rL,---..-- ,_,_..~, --- _r_ t , ~ -, ~ "", ' .. r IVanu.._iiit -=:; ;..:;.:,- ~ Daylor _ ~_ :.:::=. .. ,...."...,. ......,.. .... ;w __, - ....,.,.... -....'- - --.- r;.=~~ I 5":1:5:.. ' Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 24 of 70 ~ I '. ". ~l*A ,~ N . - ;Ytu/dnuuv G~~ #IUY. Agenda item No. 17E June 24, 2008 Page 25 of 70 CIVIL & STRIX'TURAL ENGJr.:EER1NG CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORlZAT10N 00003388 2223 TRADE CENTER WAY NAPLES, FLORIDA 34109 (239) 254-8219 FAX (239) 514-4905 ~- -- March 16, 2008 CUE-2008-AR-13066 REV: 1 TABERNACLE OF BETHLEHEM 2002060036 DATE: 3/20/08 DUE: 4/3/08 Ms, Kay Deselm, Principal Planner Department of Zoning & Land Development Review Community Development and Environmental Services Division 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 RE: Conditional Use Extension (CU-2003-AR-4326) Dear Ms, Deselm: Attached please find an application for the extension of CU-2003-AR-4326, A Conditional Use for the Tabernacle of Bethlehem in Immokalee and a check for $3,000, Our client intends to pursue a Site Development Plan for the property, meeting the Conditions of Approval, as soon as the extensi on is granted, If there is any other information required, please do not hesitate to ask, Sincerely, ctJ;v: c David &feed Kuhlman Engineering, Inc, # ~ , wroo I'-or-- ~o_ .-..N 0 ".-to -NN EQ)Q:l <DC'" -,,'" -;--:lD.. v C <D '" <{ o --- C/) ~~~=~ o r-~f--~ ~ <c r-~ ~ :----... J, t--~ g: ~ - i-- ~IyI1J.St'~IP';;--- - ~ ~Nvu.L -~ ,~ -~ '<I' U) -~ '0 =~ UU) _U ::iE - I i ~ 133 S S3Nor - ~- < ~ l~ , ~ u. ~_o ~~iYJ;:- ~ ? II I ~:::::.::....., ,w >so. '-- ~ I~III~~ 133W-S INnVO + o ~ ~ '0 o U) ~ :I: 0 OZO Z<Z ~ U) ~~~ <c::i: ~ Ii; 91'8 ',,1'0) avo~ mv:>lOf'jt'11 S3'ldVN - Z o w- !::t( ..0 9 I aso sw-; -:> > e < o 'S 133Ci1.S Pyt ~ w ~ ~ < ~ l m co , u. ::iE c:: w -~ -~- -<- -~- -~- - - N '! < e < ~ o ~ :I: w :5 ~ , <c ~ z ~ -smw.s / ~t / / / ~w ~-Ii; II -~- -~- ! -I OCJJO f -~ -~ -< o ~~',,^lS>l3>IOO8 -. II _ ~ . a . - '--= -== ",-- 'e'~---.......... '" ~ >~- <- e ~- <- z g o -g o 'S .l.:33ill.S"", PJr ~ =;;J~J~~~3 '. '1 e /~ / n.':ISlll..lD!l / ___ - ...' ! ; e- N + ,., bZ wQ ,!;: 00 ::=g '" N m N -- a.. <( ~ c:> z z o N c:: > '" '" o '" , '" <( , '" o o N W ::> (j .. Z o f- f- W 0. ~ a.. <( ~ ~ z o I- <( () o --l ::: Agenda Item No. 17E June 24, 2008 Page 27 of 70 RESOLUTION 05 - 134 RELATING TO PETITION NUMBER CU,2003-AR,4326 REQUESTING CONDITIONAL USE APPROVAL IN THE VILLAGE RESIDENTIAL (VR) ZONING DISTRICT FOR A CHURCH OR HOUSE OF WORSHIP PURSUANT TO SECTION 2.04.03, TABLE 2 OF THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE FOR PROPERTY LOCATED IN SECTION 4, TOWNSHIP 47 SOUTH, RANGE 29 EAST, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, WHEREAS, the Legislature of the State of Florida in Chapter 125, Florida Statutes, has conferred on all counties in Florida the power to establish, coordinate and enforce zoning and such business regulations as are necessary for the protection of the public; and WHEREAS, the County pursuant thereto has adopted a Land Development Code (Ordinance Number 2004.41, as amended) which establishes regulations for the zoning of particular geographic divisions of the County, among which is the granting of conditional uses; and WHEREAS, the Board of Zoning Appeals, being tbe duly elected constituted Board of the area hereby affected, has held a public hearing after notice as in said regulations made and provided, and has considered the advisability of Conditional Use approval under Subsection 2.03.04.Table 2, in the Village Residential Zoning District for a church or house of worship on the property hereinafter described, and has found as a matter of fact, Exhibit "A", that satisfactory provision and arrangement have been made concerning all applicable matters required by said regulations and in accordance with Subsection 10.08.00; and WHEREAS, all interested parties have been given opportunity to be heard by this Board in a public meeting assembled, and the Board having considered all matters presented; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA that: The petition, CU.2003-AR-4326, filed by Ronald F, Nino, AICP of Vanasse Daylor, representing Dieudonne and Lunic Brutus, with respect to the property hereinafter described in Exhibit "B" attached hereto and incorporated by reference herein, be and the same hereby is approved for a Conditional Use pursuant to Subsection 2.04.03, Table 2 in the Village Residential (VR) Zoning District to allow for a church or house of worship in accordance with the attached Conceptual Site Plan, Exhibit "e", and subject to the conditions found in Exhibit "0" which is attached hereto and incorporated by reference herein. Page 1 of2 Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 28 of 70 BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Resolution relating to Petition Number CU- 2003-ARA326 be recorded in the minutes of [his Aoard. This Resolution adople~ after motio~., second and super-majority vote. ,J , ! Done this ./_A ' day of _ 111t1! t! 7 ,2005, ATTEST: DWIGHT E BROCK, CLERK BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS COLLIER COUNTY, n,ORlDA ':~ ' ,~,i{' BY '1uJ- w, r ~ Q" rRED W, COYLE, CI~-:::: lerk 'Attest.. ,t~,Clli1_n's S i OIltllr"o.i1 1. Approved as to Form and Legal Sufficiency: ~h~ Assistant County Attorney Attachments: A. B- e. 0, Findings of Fact Legal Description Conceptual Site Plan Conditions Page 2 of2 ) ) -", Agenda Item No. 17E June 24, 2008 Page 29 of 70 .FIl'illIJ'TG JF 7AC:- 3"'.:' CCLL:E.:1::JUi';,'! ':>~rlJ'!NING CQf;/H!{I.?:C-:: ?GR A CONDITIONAL USE p~:-rT:cr" CD-:003-AR-4326 ~h~ j~O;iowing facts are found: , " Section 2,6,33A,l of the Land Development Code ~uthori2ed ,':e cnnd;tionai"e. , Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the pUDiic eme,est ::nd .,'111 .00: adversely affect other propeny ur uses in the same district O[ :-:eighbornDod ::'~::;}U5e of: .\, Consistency witlvthe Lilla De':eiopment CJde end GrO',\lh \lanagcmem ,"1m: Yes / No 3, Ingress and egress to propeI":}' Wld proposed :,rructurcs ~~;~r20n ".'1[;1 :""'arT; :::'.1]::U reference to automotjn~ :md ;:edestri.1..:."1 safety ::.nc ,:on':,:nienc2. ";.:lIT;cllj\\' and control,.IDd acce~s if; case ofiire Of catJ.stf0pne: ,\c.lequate ingress & egre~;s Yes ---.U.... No " ~, Affects neighboring propenies in relation :0 noise. :..darc. .conomlC : I[ '1{jer effects: _ \/" :'10 ~f[cc[ Dr ,.lJfect mitigated by Affec[ C'UlnO[ :,e milig~ted :J. CompatlCility with u.dj3.cem ~ropenies and nrhcr f'r071Cr:'. -:1 '~e ciistrict. Comp31ible l:se '"vithin district YeS ,/ '\10 ;32..r.;I,;j ~m the above rindings. 'lhis conciitior:all:..se ~jhouid. ',/i\h :::~iDU1;,111_::':;"!lS. ;ccpy ~..n..::;.cr.cc) ~,e '~'-'~':E::~;r:~~d ~or :J.pproval to the i30JrG \)r' Zoni~~ . '.r'pc~:s. '/11 <) ;"\ '\ ./ (-\\ - ? _ ___~ v.'. ,. >/lE=,iBEE: ~ .\:'" t ' . - " './~ /'vv.}\........- .:.~H!3IT .... Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 30 of 70 FINDING OF FACT BY C:JLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION CU-2003-AR-4326 'Ille foil owing facts are found: I, Section 2,6.33.4.1 of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use, 2, Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and wiB not adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A, Consistency with the Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan: ,/ Yes v No B. Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with particular reference to automotive and pedesnian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe: Adequate ingress & egress Yes ~ No C, Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor effeeto;: -2- '\0 affect or _ Affect mitigated by _ Affect cannot be mitigated D, Compatibility 'With adjacent properties and other property in the district: Compatible use within district / Yes~, No Based on the above findings, this conditional use should, with stipulations, (copy attached) be 'ec0!11mended for approval to the Board of Zoning Appeals, "'1 '. ~'::. .:..: /3... ,:1-'-1 MEMBER: ;.J,<-rJ/lCi. ~"d (ltu'_ ,<--t...J EXHIBIT A Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 31 of 70 FINDING OF FACT BY C::JLLlER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION CU-2003-AR-4326 The foilowing facts are found; L Section 2.6,33.4,1 of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional Use, 2. Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will not adversely meet other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A, / Consistency ~d Development Code and Growth Management Plan: Yes No 3, Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and contrDl, and access in case of fire or catastrophe: Adequate ingress &y:Gess yes.L No_ c. '. boring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor No affect Dr _ Affect mitigated by _ Affect cannot be mitigated 1), Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district; Compatible u7in district Yes No Based un the above lindings, this conditional use should, with stipulations, (copy attached) be ",commended for approval to the Board of Zoning Appeals, ~',3/o.5 MEMBER: d3-f -, : it., EXHIBIT A W".',~,',.",~,,'''';'': .,--*',"~~ .". ~"~'.. .(;, " . '':'~.?, Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 32 of 70 FINDING OF FACT BY COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION CU-2003-AR-4326 'The following facts are found: 1. Section 2,6,33,4,] of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use, 2, Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will not adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A, Consistency with the Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan: Yes ,,>- No B, Ingress and egress to property and proposed stIUctures thereon with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case offrre or catastrophe: Adequate ingress & egress Yes y.. No C. Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor effects: .~ "10 arTect or _ Affect mitigated by _ Affect cannot be mitigated D, Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district: Compatible use within district YesL No_ i3ased on the above findings, this conditional use should, with stipulati ~opy a ched) be -'~commcnded for approval to the Board of Zoning Appeals, "'. " d':) 5j ~ ~ EXHIBIT A Agenda Item No, 17E June 24,2008 Page 33 of 70 FINDING OF FACT BY COL:"'lER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION CU-2003-AR-4326 Tnc following facts are found: I. Section 2,6,33.4.1 of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use, 2, Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will not adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A. Consistency with the L~velopment Code and Growth Management Plan: Yes N~ Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and comrol, and access in case of tire or catastrophe: B, Adequate ingress & egress Yes No C, Affccts neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor etfects: No affect or _ Affect mitigated by _ Affect cannot be mitigated D, Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district: Compatible use within district (j\~r 33,cd on the above findings, this conditional use should>'r~li. '~cc:nmended for appro'cal to the Board of Zoning Appeals, Yes No , III,.: ~: ........_"'-.:fo~1 be ,~"":. ;) j 6?r "_..-.~_.... ,r MEMBER: lit- {:is 1Cc;- EXHIBIT A ) ,) ) Agenda Item No. 17E June 24. 2008 Page 34 of 70 FINDING OF FACT BY C DLLillR COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION CU-2003-AR-4326 The following facts are found: 1, Section 2,6,33,4,1 of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use, 2, Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will not adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A, Consistency with the Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan: Yes ,< < ~o B. Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fIre or catastrophe: Adequate ingress & egress Yes v No C, Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor effects: No affect or Affect mitigated by _ Affect cannot be mitigated 0, Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district: Compatible use within district Yes 0/ No Based on the above llndings, this conditional use should, with stipulations, (copy attached) be cecommended for approval to the Board of Zoning Appeals, ',.'.",::."r ... ',-;- OS"" _"..........., J MEMBER: lLjcvl fA '- EXHIBIT A ---------------. Agenda Item No. 17E June 24, 2008 Page 35 of 70 FINDING OF FACT BY CDL:"JER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION CU-2003-AR-4326 The following facts are found: I. Section 2,6,33.4,1 of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use, 2, Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will not adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A, CDnsistency with the Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan: Yes.A.. No B, Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control. and access if' case of fire or catastrophe: Adequate ingress & egress Yes:L... No C. Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor effects: -L '10 affect or _ Affect mitigated by _ Affect cannot be mitigated 0, Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district: Compatible use within district Yesi No_ Based on the above iindings, this conditional use should, with s . u1ations, (CDPy attached) be ,ecnmmcnded for approval to the Board of Zoning Appeals, C".' ~~ "'-HI ,"" ~\ ~'--\ . c: \-c..fY.... _ --'~ t. MEMBER: EXHIBIT A ~~~~ ) :I ) Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 36 of 70 FINDING OF FACT BY CaLLIER {:OUNTY PLANNING COMMISSIO~ FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION CU-2003-AR-4326 The following facts are found: 1, Section 2,6.33.4 J of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use, 2, Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will not adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A, Consistency with the Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan: Yes~o_ B, Ingress and egrcss to property and proposed structures thereon with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe: Adequate ingress & egress Yes~ No_ C. Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor effects: ~ 0 affect or _ Affect mitigated by _ Affect cannot be mitigated D, Compatibility with adjacent propenies and other property in the district: Compatible use within district Yes -1L' No_ Based on the above lindings, this conditional use should, with stipulations, (copy attached) be recommended for approval to the Board of Zoning Appeals, ~ ,"~, - i '\ IIJ :r '---.-..:..L.:. ;...,.... MEMBER: ~ ~_ EXHIBIT A Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 37 of 70 FINDING OF FACT BY COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION FOR CU-2003-AR-4326 The following facts are found: 1, Section 2,6,33,4,1 of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use, 2, Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will not adversely affect other propeny or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A, Consistency with the Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan: Yes,1 No_ B, Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with panicular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and ~ontrol. and access in case of fire or catastrophe: Adequate ingress & egress Yes L No C, Affects neighboring propenies in rclation to noise, glare, economic or odor effects: / -~ No affect or _ Affect mitigated by _ Affect cannot be mitigated D, Compatibility with adjacent propenies and other propeny in the district: Compatible use within district Yes 1 No 9ased on the above findings, this conditional USe should. with stipulations, (copy attached) be cecommended for approval to the Board of Zoning Appeals, DA TE: Z /3 loc;- I I CHAIRMAN: QA~@ /I tJ; EXHIBIT A '-Agenda Irem1\Ju.17E ..- -- June 24, 2008 Page 38 of 70 LEGAL DESCRIPTION CU-2003-AR-4326 -- ~ _____.___ n"_ LEGAL DESCRIPTiON BEGINNING A T THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF THE: VEST 380 FE:ET OF THE EAST 1070 FEET OF THE: NORTH HALF OF THE SOUTHEAST QUARTER OF THE: SOUTHE:AST QUARTE:R OF SECTION 4, TOVNSHIP 47 SOUTH, RANGE: 29 E:AST, COLLIE:R COUNTY, FLORIDA THE:NCE RUN SOUTH ALONG THE CAST BOUNDARY LINE: OF SA/D TRACT WCST 380 FE:F:T OF THE: E:AST 1070 FE:E:T TRACT A DISTANCE: OF 150 FETT TO THE: POINT OF BE:GiNNING OF TRACT HE:RnN DE:SCRiBE:D; THE:NCE: CONTINUING SOUTH ALONG SAID E:AST BOUNDARY LINE: OF SA/D TRACT A DISTANCE: OF 250 FE:ET; THENCE RUN WEST 120 FETTi THENCE /?UN NORTH 250 FEET, THENCE RUN E:AST 120 FE:ET TO A POINT OF BE:GINNING. SAID PROPE:RTY BnNG ALSO DE:SCRIBt:D AS LOTS 3, 4, 5, 6 AND 7, OF A HAP OF A SUBDIVISION PROPOSED TO BE RECORDED UNL'ER THE NAME: OF LAKE VIEV PROPERTIES. E:::hibit 8 +' ,',r.:. ,.,,' i>.' I 'I, f I J' 'i~~...;;;-;-;,;;;;:;~ , I ....""'" I "-"r-----r--'.---' -j---"!, I ", i' I' " 'I I I I ~~ ~ ' I :i; I I' [, I; I -~~~~t-~~fl~~:? I I ~~ 0" ~H , " " ;;--:,.. L I , ;1 , I I i f f f\ ~"'''''''J''.'i"11 '''''SM'"'''''t'~ I' ....,..n'~ Qrtl;t 1J ""''''''1 ~grG roq '?'d """"I""""""""l' ~1fI1fJrw.qrll::::::~, -'-:--r;:-~~ ~ 7~r~~ ~:H i I ., / / , i i ---I -~r~---~' -, " ..... i , , ----:-'--~-t-;--.- , , ~ T . / , , , 'I I I I ~ , I _J ."'1 _~r.,,; , ~,,~ "'. 'oif I~} ''\, I, -," " " " 's" ""-' c ~ . , .' ~ ~-" ~ ;, ~~ -~1 I , , I !:' " .' I I .-'~OO" I ;, --\~I----!'o!..--T--'\;~~ : '-:,-~ ""--r '~'1: :~ 2' ~.~ , - -:;;:r-- -. ,F - '-----:-,.,-)--'-- ---- I -----,---~ Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 _.ItsIl........,1 ~/O~r~rl :I -~~:~-,._~ JOI^~n .. -,:::~:: --- -","',,;-;--,., .:' ...~,,~.- '" lC~y:\", I{< ['If, ~ I~I' if ~! ik" '.. ! ::,; ~ .. ~ , ~: ~~ '-'--:--- i~J;' ~ ': !llc,.' 1<J~, , "1'-" I~ ' :; i !'i" 'i, ' ,~I,' ",.' '.' ',1 ,," Iii Ii;:':: ~:!\ " ~.. . . . 7 :" ~ , , ~;~ q cO L' .~Uj~ 1,,~. ,'.'"p ,- '-c. .j"~.,' Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 40 of 70 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL Clf-2003-AR-4326 1, The Conditional Use is limited to what is shown on the conceptual site plan, identified as "Tabernacle of Bethlehem Conceptual Site Plan," prepared by Vanasse Daylor, last revised December 7, 2004, The site plan nOled is conceptual in nature for conditional use approval. The final design must be in compliance with all applicable federal, state, and county laws and regulations, 2, The Conditional Use is limited to the use of the existing building for a house of worship, No expansion or enlargement of the existing building is permitted, 3, Parking within 3'd Street right-of-way is prohibited, All parking must be contained on-site, 4, The Conditional Use approval is subject to compliance with any conditions or stipulations placed upon the companion request petition, V A-2003-AR-4327, 5. The petitioner must seek development approval, i,e" SOP or SIP, for this conditional use, The SOP/SIP plans must reflect all improvements depicted on the site plan and the conditions noted above, A final local developer order (SOP or SIP and building permits) must be issued before the building's use as a church/house of worship, Revised: 2/3/05 to Incorporate the Collier County Planning Recommendation Exhibit D RESOLUTION NO, 05'1.;15 Aaenda Item No. 17E - ,Iune 24, 2008 Page 41 of 70 REIAIING TO PETITION NUMBER VA-2003-AR,4327 REQUESTING VARIANCES IN TIlE VILLAGI' RLSIDI':NTIAL (VR) ZONING DISTRICT ,\S Hll.l,OWS: I) I'ROM Till,: ~1INIMIIM LOT ,\REA RUJIIIRUl H)R 1\ CONIlITION,\L I !SI', TO A 1.1 ,OW A'-' I'XISTIN(; U 6~ ACRE SITE J() BE IlEVEl.OPI'D '.'OR A CIIlJl{CII: 2) TO REDUCE THE 35,I.'OOT FRONT Y ARIl SETBACK TO 20 FEET; 3) TO REDUCE TilE 33 PARKING SPACES TO 19 SPACES: AND 4) TO REDUCE Till: LANDSCAPE BUFFER ON TilE NORTII AND SOU l'II I'ROPERTY liNES FROM A 15,HJOT TYPE "11" J() A IO-FOOT WlDlo TYPE "B" BUFFI':R, FOR PROPERTY LOCAl Ell IN SECTION 4, TOWNSIlIP 47 SOUTIl, RANGI' 2') EAST IN COLLIER COllNTY, FLORIDA, WHEREAS. the Legislature of the State of Florida in Chapter 115, Florida Statules. has conferred on all counties in Flurida the power to establish. coordinate and enforce zoning and such business regulations as arc necessary for the protection or the public; and WIlEREAS, the COllnty pursuant 1hereto has adopted a Land Development Code (Ordinance No. 2004-41, as amended) which establishes n:gulations for the zoning of particular geographic divisions of the County, among which is the granting of variances; and WHEREAS, the Board of Zoning Appeals, being the duly elected constituted Board of the arca hereby afkclcd, has held a public hearing after notice as in suid rcgululions Jlwdc <.tnu provided. and has considered the advisability of vurjancL's to ,,1low tkvelopmclll of Ll chun..:h (I DC 94.02.02.E.) as a Conditional Use on an existing tract containing 0.69 acres instead of one acre; 10 reduce front yard setback from 35 feet to 20 feet; to reduce the number of parking spaces from 33 to 19 spaces (LDC S4.04.04.G.Tablc 17); and 4) to reduce the landscape buffer on the north and south property lines from a 15-foot Lype "0" La a 10-foot wide type "R" burrer (LDC ~4.06.02 Table 24), as shown on the attached site plan. Exhibit "A", in a Village Residential (Vir) Zone ti)f the property hereinafter described, and has found as a matter of fact that satisfactory provision and arrangement have been made concerning all applicahle matters required by said regulations and in accordance with Section 9.04.00 of the Zoning Regulations of said Land Development Code for the unincorporated area of Collier County; and WHEREAS, all interested parties have been given opportunity to be heard by this Board in public meeting assembled, and the Board having considered aU matters presented; NOW, THEREFORE. BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that: The Petition V A-2003-AR-4327 filed by Ronald F. Nino, AICP, of Vanasse & Daylor. representing Dieudonne and Lunie Brutus, with respect to the property hereinafter described in Exhibit "9" attached hereto and incorporated by reference herein, be and the same hereby is approved for variances in the Village Residential (VR) Zoning District to allow develupment of a Page 1 of 2 church (subject to separate conditional use approval) on an existing tracl containing 0.69 acres Agenda Item No, 17E June 24. 2008 Page 42 of 70 instead of one acre; to reduce front yard setback from 35 feet to 20 feet; to reduce the number of parking spaces from 33 to 19 spaces; and 4) to reduce the landscape buffer on the north and south property lines from a 15~foot type "B" to a to-foot wide type "8" buffer, as shown on the attached site plan, Exhibit "A", subject 10 the conditions found in Exhibit "e" which is l.lttach~d hereto and incorporated by reference herein. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Resolution relating to Petition Number VA,2003- AR-4327 be recorded in the minutes of this Board. This Resolution adopted after motion, second and majority vote. Done this ;?J kJ ~.:. day of h7drefi ,2005, A lTEST: DWIG:jf1fi3j(()(;K, CLERK BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORfDA .h '~';d,ct~rld; l'-'~',' ,.", ',' O(J " t~.t ls)q n.lr'1l1an's' U~'~0Il11. FRED~~TA~---- Approved as to Form and Legal Sufficiency: ~A9L__ Patrick G. White Assistant County Attorney Exhibits; A. Conceptual Site Plan, entitled, "Tabernacle of Bethlehem," prepared by Vanasse Daylor, last revised August 26, 2003. B. Legal Description C. Conditions Page 2 of2 Agenda Item 2~o'266~ June Jl~ f 7n n~.....~ -""~""'" ... IIIfoIIC"""'i i-- ",.",..., "" - ~~~11.,;; .........,- IloOJl!; P'l: GOo\" ~II(" '" ....,.. fill! --, 'I, -~, . \ll"ID1J_ !!!!OW " ',. - -- JOI,(.O I:' L-' -- nr~... Vd .. oSs.u. ^ 1i;L , ---. ."..-., """'10 .~"'"..... c......., ,. ,"'-"-,, , :.:;;-~~ J ~IO~.L ..-.... ...,~:..~~ "'N_''''_''''d''''''~''.'=, '. '......... - - - . -- " N 'l'w '*' </ [~i,; . ,t '\ -i s i ~ ',., " " " ,I ", '~~~---, j 'r-- :,~i~, "I j II ,i: I \ !:,":.J ,i i li./;' " !! I I I 1Y i ' \ r>/ ::J,' Ii I ~/0;J 'I '!>---{\ ' i ~ ( ''', ~: I: J:l I I' , '-."""- I, ':::;_. I ; -------r----;D( I ----J" ~'I '":, /11, IY'),I C'. ! I " ' I I ~~I I I I Ii'" i', I i j' "I' ',1 '! I" ') : I :,1 , i L.. - II I" '-!i." 'h. II i ,/ " \'" 'I ~ '~-; ~ ,I", '-~ I . ' " :~'-li ?r.J '. ~' ~' I I ~ ir-, -,: ~ 'I . I 'I') ~ !', ." ;', I ~ ~ ~ I r,. , I'; , ,Ih i lj i '. l , , ~!2 's', I ~ I \ , "1'" I "" I " I I (\ I t i : i ~ " II LL' i r'I'..",,: ',,-.J;;' ! ,/ I , \, ./', I' ) I' i ~"..\o/:... ---""-=___l,\ --'~: H,y: ' " I I r I, , \, " _: '11 '- il,',;1 '- \ ~. ~ : I. Y , : "-, , --L-;c---t_--l""',' , L ; ~:--',-j- :!i,! I ,II,' ''-i. '! \ ,---"":'--,--" """ ,~~;~ L__,___,,:::'____~, '1 VA-2003-AR-4327 Exhibit A ~ ! li!'EHI !.II, I ;!il Ii' : ;~n j. !~i'i I". I h, 1:5 I $~~~ Ii . ,,'I, ., '~Ml! I 'j"L._", ~i~ '~:: I i !I,:',"I II" , I. " illiil," , "Ii :/ I' "Ii",.', .I~j ! I' I~ ~ 'il~ ! i!!!'!'i I~ I~:; : I " ~ ~ 'M1 ~E:D " 0001:l~~I<:. -liMe ~~5-:iOrot-\9Oi:O~\tO.'~l"",""", ':l Aaenda Item No, 17E , June 24, 2008 Page 44 of 70 LEGAL DESCRIPTION BEGINNING A T THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF THE VEST 380 FEET OF THE EAST 1070 FEET OF THE NORTH HALF OF THE SOUTHEAST QUARTER OF THE SOUTHEAST QUARTER OF SECTIDN 4, TOVNSHIP 47 SOUTH, RANGE 29 EAST, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA THENCE: RUN SOUTH ALONG THE EAST BOUNDARY LINE OF SAID TRACT VEST 380 FEET OF THE EAST 1070 FEET TRACT A DISTANCE OF 150 FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING OF TRACT HERnN DESCRIBED; THENCE CONTINUING SOUTH ALONG SAID EAST BOUNDARY LINE OF SAID TRACT A DISTANCE: OF 250 FEET; THENCE RUN VEST 120 FEET; THE:NCE RUN NORTH 250 FEET, THENCE RUN EAST 120 FEET TO A POINT OF BEGINNING. SAID PROPERTY BnNG ALSO DESCRIBED AS LOTS 3, 4, 5, 6 AND 7, OF A HAP OF A SUBDIVISION PROPOSED TO BE RECORDED UNL'ER THE NAME OF LAKE VIE:V PROPERTIES. VA-2003-AR-4327 Exhibit B CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL V A-2003-AR-4327 Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 45 of 70 The foregoing variance petition approval is subject to the folJowing conditions: 1. The variances granted are limited to the use of the existing structure for a house of worship, as depicted and more particularly described in the applicant's site plan entitled. "Tabernacle of Bethlehem Conceptual Site Plan." prepared by Vanasse Daylor, last revised December 7, 2004, 2, The yard variance being granted is limited to allowing the encroachments of the existing building solely for use as a church, Any other conditional use is subject to re-review of the variance issues, 3, Parking within 3rd Street South right-of-way IS prohibited, All parking must be contained on-site, 4, No variances have been granted to reduce any buffer requirements except for width or to provide relief from the requirement to provide a wall along any project boundary, Buffering materials for the church use must be provided in compliance with the LDC requirements unless separate administrative variance relief is sought and approved in compliance with the LDC. 5, No expansion or enlargement of the existing building is pennitted, 6, The developer wilJ maximize the subject site's land area to provide additional parking spaces, up to the maximum number of parking spaces that can be accommodated on the site, in the area between what is shov.n on the site plan as "paved aisle" and the western property boundary, (Revised February 3, 2005 to incorporate the CCPC recommendation) EXHIBIT C .%.I.'-all'& 2223 TRADE CENTER WAY . Agenda Item No. 17E June 24, 2008 Page 46 of 70 ~ aVIL.I: ST.nrCTURAL ENGINEERING: (."ERTIFICATf.: OF AliTHORIZA,TION ??oo3381 . NAPLES. FLORIDA 34109 (239) 254-8219 FAX (239) 514-4905 May 23, 2007 Ms, Kay Deselem Collier County Development Services 2800 Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 Re: CUE-2008-AR-13066, Tabernacle of Bethlehem Dear Ms, Deselem: Attached please find (5) copies of the updated background traffic and original TIS as requested by John Podczerwinsky, Please call if you have any questions or comments, Thank you, CUE-2008-AR-13066 REV: 2 TABERNACLE OF BETHLEHEM PROJECT: 2002060036 DATE: 4/18/08 DUE: 5/2/08 Agenda Item No. 17E June 24, 2008 Page 47 of 70 CUE-2008-AR-13066 REV: 2 TABERNACLE OF BETHLEHEM PROJECT: 2002060036 DATE: 4/18/08 DUE: 5/2/08 Vanasse __ Daylor MEMORANDUM Urban Planning Landscape Architecture C~II E"Iineering Traffic Englneerlnc FL Uc LCOOOO366 To: From: David Sneed, Kuhlman Engineering E, Randy Spradling, P,E" Director of Transportation Cc: Date: April 16, 2008 Tabernacle of Bethlehem Church, CUE-2008-AR-13066 Re: Attached is the original Trip Generation Opinion for the subject project, As directed in the rejection letter dated April 7, 2008, 5-year growth projections were estimated on the nearby arterial links identified in the AUlR, Table 1 shows the information derived from the 2007 AUIR for the two arterial links nearest the project. Table 2 shows the derivation of the 5-year projections based on Collier County AADT volumes for the links being studied, Table 1 Data from 2007 AUIR 2007 PK f;{RQir.. Trip Total Rem LO Road # l.ink f!=lI2 I!..1.nl >1:_ YQ/ ~ YQ/ ~ S CR846 Immokalee Rd Oil Well Road to Sr 29 2U 0 860 330 85 415 445 8 SR29 State Road 29 CR 29A South to N, 15th 5t 40 C 1,860 630 85 715 1145 B Table 2 Background Traffic Projections Location 2003 2007 2008 2013 MDT MDT PK DIR Growth MDT PI< DIR MDT PK D1R 1st St 5 (CR 8<46) 5 of Main 5t (5R 29) Main 5t (5R 29) W of 5 1st 5t (CR 8<46) 12945 14671 330 13,45 I 14,081 630 3,3% 15,200 340 1.2% 14,200 640 17,900 400 15,100 680 The site-generated trips for the weekday PM peak hour of adjacent street traffic were assigned to the arterial network, Since the site is estimated to generate slightly over I trip end in each direction, a single vehicle value was used to estimate was conducted for the subject project. The trips were added to the projected peak hour link volumes to derive estimated total trips, The 1l7l0 New Brittany Boulevard, Suite 600, Fort Hy.rs, Florida mOl T l)9,m,4601 f 239,437.4636 w vanday,tOm 1:\Projecu\.0402\40206\Traffic\AUIR Update 2008\040206 AUIR Update Naf"ntiYe Tables.dot Job Number: 40206.03 Agenda item No. 17E June 24, 2008 Page 48 of 70 projected volumes were then compared to the link performance standard maximum service flowrates (SFMAX) to enSUre that the threshold values were not exceeded, Table 3 shows the results of those computations, Table 3 Link LOS Analysis Results Site as 2013 PKHR W/in SF "we? PCTor Se~ent Will Slm IQli\ Sf""" .I.\KGQ IQli\ Sf""" 1 st St S (CR 846) S of Main St (SR 29) 400 401 860 Y Y 0,2% Main St (SR 29) W ofS 1st St (CR 846) 680 681 1,860 y y 0,1% The results clearly show the proposed use is within the service volumes of the nearby arterial links and is not projected to significantly impact the links, It should therefore be considered consistent with Policy 5,1 within the 5-year planning period, Also attached are supporting source documentation, 12710 N.w Brillany Boulevard, Suit. 600, Fo" Mym, Florida 33'07 T 23',437,4601 I m,437,4636 w ..nday,com f:\Projeas\402\40206\Trafflc\AUIR Update 2008\40206 AUlR Update Narrative Tables.doc Job Number: 40206.03 Agenda Item No, 17E ,June 24. 2008 Page 49 of 70 TRIP GENERATION TABERNACLE OF BETHLEHEM CHURCH Prepared for: Tabernacle of Bethlehem Church Dieudounne Brutus 305 South 5th Street Immokalee, Florida Prepared by: VanasseDaylor 12730 New Brittany Blvd" Suite 600 Fort Myers, Florida 33907 #40206,03 September 2002 Agenda Item No, HE June 24, 2008 Page 50 of 70 INTRODUCTION Tabernacle of Bethlehem Church is proposing to construct a 4,200 square foot church on 3rc1 Street South in lmmokalee, Collier County, Florida, This trip generation will determine the amount of trips generated by the church, TRIP GENERATION The proposed project traffic generation was determined using rates from the Institute of Transportation Eneineers' TriD Generation Manual (Sixth Edition), The trip generation equations are shown below, Church (LV 560): ADT: T=9,II(X) AM PkHr,: T=O,72(X) PM Pk Hr,: T = 0.66(X) Sunday: T = 36,63(X) Sunday Pk Hr,: T = 9.49(X) The above equations were used with the land use data provided to generate the estimated trip generations for the project as shown below in the table. PROJECT TRIP GENERATION AM PM Sunday Land Use ADT Peak Enter Exit Peak Enter Exit Sunday Peak Hr Church (LU 560) 4,200 SF 38 3 2 3 154 40 Totals 38 3 2 1 3 1 1 154 40 l:\ProtectI\402\4020l1\40206-Trtp.Gen.doe SR84 881 81l W.rtc1oz !.zt.Nio CazKlll Rd. 810 6051 LU:. Trdfbrd 55! 08:1 Collier County Department of Transportation Operations Immokalee City Area Trame Count Stations 591 063 SR29 (North L5th Su..t) S90 CR846 619 SR25i' (MUll. hwe ISITE I CRB46 (l,t Slrm S) 820 Stock... Rd. Immokalee Area Map Page 14 of 15 N J r Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 51 of 70 06.\ / 654: CR .40 East 3 miles east of 29 South January, 2008 Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 52 of 70 Collier County Average DaUy Trame (ADT) Counts (Five Year History Listed Alphabetically) S n A. T t n y a . 2 P 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 Change mO ADT ADT ADT ADT t e Location ADT IS.. 06-071_ . 0 IS.. IS.. Note (SaaNota (8.. Nom I I 7 Note 11 11 1) N""1 11 ."'2) 0 I . 520 Q County Barn "" """" 0/ Rattlesneke Hem Rd ICR '64 ) (C...nty -6,55% Fdty Roed MlIlnte,.-,ce FllCiIlty moved to o.vts Blvd. 2005) 11,354 11,474 8,552 12,078 11,275 641 A CounlY Barn Rd 80uth 01 CC R&B Fecilitv 15,00~ 13,777 17426 15,273 -12,35% 519 Q Coun'" Barn Rd 10uth 01 Davis Blvd /SR 64' 14,124 13837 11406 14461 13,377 -7,50% 559 Q Davis Blvd /SR 64' eest 01 Almort Rd CR 311 30183 307981 32083 30 985 28,576 -7,77% 558 Q Devls Blvd rSR 64' wast 01 A1rnort Rd /CR 31' 32 686 33,94~ 34,686 31,394 .9,49% 801 Q Davis Blvd (SR 64) wast of Collier Blvd fCR 951' 22 920 25,969 26441 24,495 -7,36% 560 Q Davis Blvd /SR 84' west of Radio Rd /CR 858' 14,200 14,965 16475 17045 15667 -8,08% 538 C Q Devis Blvd rSR 84' west 01 Sents Berbe", Blvd 30,789 32,561 34,781 33 289 638 A Dssoto Blvd north of Golden Gats Blvd fCR ,ii' 1365 1,585 2,254 2,207 2,597 17,57% 639 A Dssoto Blvd 80uth of Golden Gote Blvd /CR '78' 1522 2,039 2324 2,861 2,543 -4,43% 704 S Elkcsm Circle eesl of Bald Eaolo Dr fCR '53 7,756 6,940 Discont. Discont Discont 705 S Elkcsm Clrcls wast of Bald Eeole Dr;cR '53 4345 4686 Discont. Dlscont. Discont. 636 S Evo..ledes Blvd north of Golden Gate Blvd 'CR 878' 5,817 6,520 5108 8,090 7,490 -7,41% S S Evemladel Blvd north of 011 Well Rd fCR '58 ~:~~ J:i~~ [ ~itJ;;MeIIOU~ OIM~ ] ~ 12945 12886 13782 14671 COO n CR 87B eas r CR 951 15'801 17190 19,885 19:0891 17,626 m 652 Q Golden Gete Blvd (CR '71 eesl 01 Wilson Blvd 678 C Q GoIdsn Gele Blvd (CR '7. west 01 Wilson Blvd 2056~ 508 C Q Golden Gete Pkwv /CR ...' eest 01 Aimort Rd /CR 311 25 877 29 636 691 Q Golden Gete Pkwv /CR'" eest of Llvlnaston Roed rCR II" 28860 34,585 605 C Q Golden Gets Pkwv /CR ,..' east of Sente Berbera Blvd 31,042 29,124 29,669 28,562 507 C Q Golden Gets Pkwv ICR ",., welt 01 Ai.nort Rd'CR 3il 44 592 45 594 38,779 510 Q Golden Gats Pkwv rCR... west 01 Collier Blvll'CR 95" 16640 17,783 16959 17,906 -5,55% 530 Q Golden Gets Pkwv ICR ...> we.t of Goodlette Rd /CR '51' 23119 21,677 21942 27,904 509 Q Golden Gete Pkwv ICR'" west of Sente Barbare Blvd 29194 24,413 26611 16,01% 505 C Q Goodlette Rd /CR 181' north of 22nd Ave north 33,093 31414 31,411 595 Q Goodlette Rd fCR IS1 north of 0", e Blossom Dr 17 302 20,289 20,263 .(),03% 581 Q Goodlette Rd ICR 8511 north of Pine R....." Rd 'CR 'os, 24,892 25,763 3,56% 569 Q Goocllette Rd ICR '811 south of Flrsl Avo south 28,824 29,084 29,288 29,304 27,956 -4,59% 504 Q Goodlette Rd CR 8511 10Uth of Golden Gets PkWv 'CR "'" 37,7201 38,2431 30,771 35,368 35,591 0,63% 594 Q Goodlette Rd rCR 8511 south of Immokalee Rd 'CR 84" '~ 11,8061 12,987 14,286 13446 -5,75% 596 Q Goodlette Rd ICR '511 south of O"'n e Blossom Dr f' 21,284 23,150 23,346 0,85% 506 C Q Goodlette Rd fCR 'S1I louth of Pine Rldoe Rd rCR '9S' 31,450 29,881 27,287 642 Q G...en Blvd eest of Sente Berba", Blvd 13,862 14,261 14,214 13,213 11,319 -14,33% 643 Q Green Blvd welt 01 Collier Blvd CR '81' 7,B93 8,582 8,749 8519 7,208 -15,39% 563 A Gulflhore Dr louth of Bewtew Dr 5,545 5,723 7245 4,988 3,954 -20,53% 714 S Heethwood Dr north of Sen Marco Dr rCR '2' 5,918 6,711 Discon!. Dlscon!. Discont. 715 S Heathwood Dr south of San Merco Dr rCR 92' 5,459 5515 Dlscon!. Disconl Discont. 675 C Q Immokeiee Rd 84' eesl of Wilson Blvd 23,577 25,970 625 c Q Immokeles Rd CR Me) eest of Goodlelle Rd rCR '511 40,590 45,385 46,620 44,234 567 C Q Immokelee Rd CR Me) eest of A1roort RdlcR 311 44,916 46,051 593 C Q Immokaiee Rd rCR 046,eest of Collier BlvdlCR 951' 24,231 23,363 26 895 568 C Q Immokelee Rd fCR 046'eest of 1-75 (SR 931 IT,"':!"" 42,933 45 488 46,794 566 C Q Immokalee Rd fCR Me' east of US 4 f'SR'5 amiami TI'IIII 38,985 42 086 40 288 520 Q Immokalee Rd rCR 64., north 01 Stockede Rd 8,685 8,217 8422 10,285 10,548 3,52% 586 C Q Immokelee Rd CR 84" eouth of 011 Well Rd rCR es" 16,537 18,172 555 Q Immokelee Rd fCR 046' west of US 4 fTcR .5\ITiimlaml T"" 17481 18991 19,168 165641 15,886 -5,87% 856 C Q Immokalee Rd CR Me' west of Collier Blvd CR 95" 25,787 27431 872 Q Immokeles Road 846 2 miles eest 01 Evemlades Blvd, 4,733 4,806 5881 6,0891 5,431 -10,80% 584 Q Immokalee Road (CR 846 East) 3 mll"._ of 29 South 1,382 1,434 1,488 679 C Q Immokelee Roed ICR Me) ..... of 1-75 (SR 83) l'iT-,,""";" 45,345 674 Q Immokslee Road fOR: 8.48) west of Wilson Blvd 121380 21,277 21,523 NOTES: 1. All stations wtth .n .nomalie do not show.n ADT; reference the Querterly Report. 2. The Chllfl9. 08..01 Is not .hown If. station shows en .nomene. Pages 3-8 of 15 Januery , 2008 ,Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 53 of 70 Collier County Average Daily Tram. (ADT) Counls (Five Year History Listed Alphabetically) S n A . T I n y a . 2 P 2003 2004 2005 2007 mO ADT ADT ADT 2008 ADT Change I . 0 e Location ADT IS.. D~7 ,_ I I 1 (S.. -- fS.. Not. Note1J ,...- N"'21 Notal) 1) I) I) 0 I . 677 a Immokalee Road East of Everalades Blvd 5,224 5,205 5,406 5777 6,81% 671 a ImmOkelee Roed south of Co/1<Screw Sanctu...Road 6,033 5,348 7,193 7,548 5,750 -23,81% 631 a J & C Blvd wesl of Aimart Rd ICR 31 11946 12,131 12110 11,686 10,222 -12,53% 614 A Jane's Scenic Or west of SR 29 998 705 655 705 702 -0,43% 707 S Kendan Dr wesl of COllier Blvd SR 0" 3,470 3,454 DisconlillCOnl. Dllconl. 609 a Lake Trafford Rd 'OR .90' west of Cerson Rd 6679 6320 6769 7741 551 a Lake Trall'ord Rd CR '90' welt of North 15th Sl ISR 29 12,280 12337 12,435 13,653 12658 -7,29% 890 a LMnaston Rct feR ae1 1.5 m north of Gokten Gate CR 888 20.947 29759 37,032 30.396 -17,92% 574 1 Uvlnaslon Rd 'CR "" north of MedRerra 15,086 17.324 15,242 -12,02% 575 Uvlnolton Rd 'CR .." north of Pine Rldoe Rd 'OR ...' I 16,409 26258 24 543 -5,39% 597 a Livinaston Rd (eR 881) south of Immokalee Rd leR 846\ I 25 729 22,702 -11.77% 576 a LMnoslon Rd OR ,.,, south ofVanderbll1 Beach Rd CR .'2'- 13,935 37,412 27,678 -26.02% 673 a LMnoAlon Road CR .." north of Immokalee Road 'CR..e' "io": 19090 23,077 18,337 -20,54% 686 a LMnoston Road CR 881l north of Redlo Road CR 8561 16,466 19,083 22,9341 24327 24 496 0,69% 687 a LMnoston Road CR .." south of Golden Gate Pkwv ICR .se' 23314 276961 33 2091 36241 33 392 -7,86% 687 C a Laoan Blvd north of PI.. Rldoe Rd ICR ... 11,883 10,094 10,254 9440 644 Now a Laoan Blvd north of Vanderbltt Beach Rd CR 862\ I I 0,. I Q ILaoan Blvd ooulh of Pine R e Rd CR'" ~Li 12:'~~~ I a Maln~west of South lsl SI 'OR ..S' 13451 13627 14327 14,061 ana eel 0 Ilf 1) , . , , , . 592 a Naol.. Blvd west of Caeco Enlrance 11683 812 a New Markel Rd SR 29A'easl of North 15th 51 'SR 20' 8,137 8,633 8,364 9,006 8,969 -0.41% 550 a New Markel Rd SR 2&AI south of Braward SI 7,576 8405 8,993 7,710 7,578 -1,71% 663 a North 15th SI SR 201 north of Lake Trafford RdlcR SOO 11,085 11,565 12,285 14199 12,517 -11,84% 683 C a North 15th SIISR29\ south of Lake Trall'ord Rd' CR .00' 17574 16525 20,954 590 a North III SI north of Main SI 'SR 29' 7,304 7,977 8,551 9771 8,953 -8,37% 692 a North Road wesl of Aimort Road ICR 311 2,474 2,915 3,056 3,043 2,543 -13,14% 545 a Oakes Blvd north of Vanderbltt Beach Rd fCR 862\ 12,803 13,920 11,401 11,672 9,688 -17,17% 8B2 a Oakes Blvd south of Immokalee Rd 'CR ".' 11,596 11,963 9765 10,388 8,204 -21,03% 725 E S DU Well Rd (CR "") easl of Bio Cvoress Elem 5ch M92 6,119 6,788 7,289 724 S 011 Well Rd (CR .SS _ oIlmrnokalee Rd (CR ..el S.. ..I 8,124 9,0~B'sconl. Discont. 549 a 011 Well Rd fCR 8585' easl of Immokalee Rd ICR 5461 11629 9,587 -17,56% 547 E a Old US 411CR 88'" al Lee Countv Une 14,933 16312 16,490 16,317 547 a Oren"" Blossom Dr east of rlll1bll~lne Dr -"~ -6,26% 526 Q Pine Rid"" Rd ICR "" .asl of Almart Rd ICR 311 51 986 55097 56,659 52827 -6,76% 514 a Pine RIdOA Rd ICR "'" ..11 of Goodlelte Rd ICR 1511 ~ 59193 53729 -9,23% 628 C a PI.. Rldoe Rd fCR 8961 easl of Llvinoslon Rd fCR 881'- 64248 535 a Pin. Rid"" Rd 'CR ...' east of Loaan BlvdlSanta Barbara 21,625 23,481 24892 24954 23,336 -6,60% 512 Q Pine Rkio. Rd ICR 9ee east of US 41 ISR 45lTTamiaml TrY 1;,:\' 39,369 43775 41027 -6,28% 515 a Pine RldOA Rd ICR 1..' wesl of Aimort Rd ICR 311 4M64 48 034 43,532 54 400 46 881 -10,18% 600 a Pine Ride. Rd fCR "" west of Lonan Blvd 39,563 41,965 44,995 47 092 36,775 -17,66% 634 A PlanlaUon Parkw~ east of CR 29 642 730 670 613 673 9,79% 544 a Radio Rd CR 858\ east of Aimort Rd leR 31 23,677 25 538 26,989 26914 24 630 -8,49% 589 C a Radio Rd CR ISII e..1 of Santa Barbara Blvd 15,443 17599 19,456 19.623 685 a Radio Rd CR a..' west of Davie Blvd 'SR ..' 10.008 11,435 12,750 13601 11,169 -17,88% 527 C a Radio Rd lOR .56' Wesl of Santa Barbar. Blvd 23,858 25,619 25,091 686 C a Radio Road 'CR .56' .esl of Llvinoslon Road 'CR aS1I 28,593 32,238 32,996 32,510 689 a Radio Road CR 856\ west of Livinaston RoadieR ssp- 22,754 25,778 24,455 28,079 26,694 -4,93% 651 a Randall Blvd east of Immoka)ee Rd leR 8-46-'- 7,135 7,882 9,139 10417 11,205 7,56% 534 a RatUesnake Ham Rd CR 884\ east of Countv Barn Rd 14537 15,588 14921 15478 13,412 -13,35% 518 a Rattlesnake Ham Rd leR 8641 east r:A US 4flSR 90fTamiaml Tr' 16703 17509 15,30~. 17,522 -8.45% 518 C a ReUlesnake Ham Rd-ICR B641 west of Collier Blvd 'CR 95' 10051 10,876 10,091 517 a Rattlesnake Ham Rd CR B64' weat of Coun'" Barn Rd 14,852 15,062 13712 16275 14,804 -9,04% 719 S San Marco Dr 'CR 9'" ee'l of Floral SI 4,140 4,506 Discont. IDisconl Disconl NOTES: 1. All stations wfth an .nomall. do not show an ADT; ,.fe,..nc8 ttw QullUrly Report. 2. The Change 01-07 '- not shown If. station shows In anomaD.. Pages 3wB rA 15 January , 2008 wroo ,,-or- ~-~~o -.i--.q- 'N'" E '" '" I Q.) C O'! 1 ::::::J~ .. ","" '0 C '" 0> <l: i . I I I I I i !l .' ................................"",...... '.'. .,."........,., . . , , . ....... . . . , . , . , . . , , , ! - , E ~ ~ ~ ~ If Jf f i tun i js . i '1i/5. f ~IJ i 5 ~ ~ If rll~t~J~ ~ ~ ~ .1 ! I I . . u u u u . . . u . u u . 0 . . 0 . u . . . . . u u u u u E. ~ ~ i . i I , ~ ~ . I ~ . , , 'E . ~ . i . ! ~ I ! , ! i ~ I ! I ! - , . . . ~ . I . ;; I . , 0 , I , ! - ! . . . . ~ . . , , - - . . - - . - - - - 0 - - . I I . I . . , , . . I . . . . I , , I o. S , , - , . , i , , . . . , . , , , , , , 'I I~I' I I I I . , . I ~ I , I I . = I ! I I I I . . ! I I I " - - - - . ! , .Idl, I ! ! ! . . I . ~ I . ~~ I ! . I ! . . I I . I ! I I I I ! - , . - - - - . . , , . . I .. . . . , 0 0 . . . . 0 . , 0 0 0 . . . . . . . . 0 0 0 . . " . u u u u u u u . I ii i i , , , , . i i i , , , , , . i , . ii . . . . . . , . . . , , , . , , , , ;; ;; , , I . " . ! I . , , . . I J ! , i . i 0 . J . I ! , I . . ! ! , . , I , . - I j ~ Ii !IIII~I/ : . , I . . I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I . .' . i . I ! i ! . ! 1 . . . ! . " . . . . , . . . . " 1 . ~ . . . I ! , ! ! . . I ; l~. ii I = I I ~ . . . . 1 > > ] , , i I i J ~ 1I" . J I , , , " , J J i i i , , , . , . l I , , . . I I I ] I J ~ I , I , j I I I . . . I I I I I ! ! ! . , i . . . . . . . ! I i , I ! ! ! . ! . . , I i I I - i ! I I I i i i . i I ii . 0 i , , . . , , . , - , , 0 , - . , .. . , , . . . , , , , , - rial, . . I , . ; a . . ; ; . , i ; . ; . I . . . 1 . ; . . I . . i . ; . ; . I - , , - - 0 0 00 . , . , . , 0 , - I f ! I ! I II -, I ! t lU~ P'I 011 I ! I . t i I f I I WOJO r-Or- ~o_ ,N 0 o '''' Z~!.() E CD CD J' CD c 0) r :=::J CO jo ro--,D. "0 c Q) OJ <{ I I .. ................................,......"." .., "",.",.""".1."., .,.......,.,.....,., U , E ~ E ! ! . ~ ! . I f ! 'PI' II f5 ~ f il!. 'I ,5. ~15 5 ~ ~ H I I 5 ~ ~ ~ j " !A I < I I . " " . . . " . " . " . " . . . . . . " . . " . " " " Ii ~ - - . . i . . , e . I . . e. 0 ! I ! ! . I -llIl. ! . - . . - - . . - . J I~~ . I . ~ - < - . I i I , S :i: . . I . 0 . , i 5 - ! ! e I - - . - . - . . i I . I I . . . - I . I , I . . . I . . , ea . . - ! - . - a . . . - . . . - ! . . I ! , ! , I , , . ! 5 , I ! , I . I ! l I I ! I .. . . - - -- , . . - ! I~~ . . I 0 I ! ! , . . l . . , ~~ ~ ! ! ! I ~ I - E - E E . - . . . . - I . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . v " " " " . v " v I . , , , . . . . . . . . . . . , . . . . . . , , . . I . , . J ; ; ! ~ ; j I j I , ! j ! . . , . , I ! . ! l i . ! I I I . j , ! ! , . . ! . . , I . J . . . I I I . .' I . ! . ; . i . . , . j I . . ~ , I U . . . . . . " . . @ ; . ! . . . . . . . . . ; t . ~ . . , l I . . . , . j I . t . t : . . . 'Jl! . 1 I ! ; . . . , ~ , , I ! , ! . ! < , 1 : , Ii ~ . 1 ' - - J i I , j i , , , I I I ! ! , . ! I I I I I I i . . . Iii ~ I I l . I ! I ! i . . I I I ! III' I ] " ! i B B . . i i i i A A A IA ! i B B ! . l II i I i ! . ! i - i I . I ! i i i r r I i i i . i . - i j I . . i i . . i 8 - . - . . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . ., , . . . . . . . . . - , . ; . ; ; . ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; . ; . ; .- ; ; I . ; . . . ; . . . . ; I . ; ; . . ,. , , . - - . " - . . . . I . ! I I I I Ii ~ .. J ! t ml 1III .Ill ! ! , . i i ! i f I Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 56 of 70 RESOLUTION 2008-_ A RESOLUTION OF THE COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS RELATING TO PETmON NUMBER CUE-2008-AR-13066, TO PROVIDE FOR A ONE-YEAR EXTENSION OF A CONDITIONAL USE IN THE VILLAGE RESIDENTIAL (VR) ZONING DISTRICT FOR A CHURCH. PURSUANT TO SUBSECTION IO,08,E,3 OF THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE (WC), FOR PROPERTY LOCATED IN SECTION 4, TOWNSHIP 47 SOUTH, RANGE 29 EAST, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA. WHEREAS, the Legislature of the State of Florida in Chapter 125, Florida Statutes, has conferred on all counties in Florida the power to establish, coordinate and enforce zoning and such business regulations as are necessary for the protection of the public; and WHEREAS, the County pursuant thereto has adopted a Land Development Code (Ordinance No. 2004-41, as amended) which establishes comprehensive zoning regulations for the zoning of particular divisions of the County, among which is the granting and extending the time period of Conditional Uses; and WHEREAS. on March 23, 2005, the Board of Zoning Appeals enacted Resolution No. 05-134, attached hereto and incorporated by reference herein, as Exhibit l'A," which granted a conditional use for a church on property described in Exhibit B of Resolution No. 05-134; and WHEREAS, Subsection IO,08,E,3 of the Land Development Code provides that the Board of Zoning Appeals may grant a one~year extension for a conditional use which has not been commenced. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that: Good cause being shown. the petition, filed by David Sneed of Kuhlman Engineering, Inc., representing DieudOIme Brutus, of the Tabernacle of Bethlehem Church, requesting a one-year extension of the Conditional Use: approval granted in Resolution No. 05-134, is hereby approved. and the expiration date for Resolution No. 05-134. attached hereto as Exhibit "A," and all conditions applicable thereto. is hereby extended for one additional year until March 23, 2009. BE IT FURTIlER RESOLVED that this Resolution be recorded in the minutes of this Board, This Resolution adopted after motion, second and super.rnajority vote, this _ day of , 2008, ATTEST: DWIGHT E, BROCK, Clerk BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA By: , Deputy Clerk By: TOM HENNING, CHAIRMAN Exhibit A: Resolution Number 2005.134 Aoenda Item No, 17E " June 24, 2008 Page 57 of 70 RESOLUTION 05 - 134 RELATING TO PETITION NUMBER CU-2003-AR-4326 REQUESTING CONDITIONAL USE APPROVAL IN TIlE VILLAGE RESIDENTIAL (VR) ZONING DISTRICT FOR A CHURCH OR HOUSE OF WORSHIP PURSUANT TO SECTION 204.03, TABLE 2 OF THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE FOR PROPERTY LOCATED IN SECTION 4, TOWNSHIP 47 SOUTH, RANGE 29 EAST, COLLIEP COUNTY, FLORIDA. WHEREAS, the Legislature of the State of Florida in Chapter 125, Florida Statutes, has conferred on all counties in Florida the power 10 establish, coordinate and enforce zoning and such business regulations as are necessary for the protection of the public; and WHEREAS, the County pursuant thereto has adopted a Land Development Code (Ordinlll1ce Number 2004.41, as amended) which establishes regulations for the zoning of particular geographic divisions of the County I among which is the granting of conditional uses; and WHEREAS, the Board of Zoning Appeals, being the duly elected constituted Board of the area hereby affected, has held a public hearing after notice as in said regulations made and provided, and has considered the advisability of Conditional Use approval under Subsection 2.03.04.Table 2. in the Village Residential Zlming District for a church or house of worship on the property hereinafter described, and has found as a matter of fact, Exhibit "A", that satisfactory provision and arrangement have been made concerning all applicable matters required by said regulations and in accordance with Subsection 10.08.00; and WHEREAS. all interested parties have been given opportunity to be heard by this Board in a public meeting assembled, and the Board having considered all matters presented; NOW, TIlEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA that: The petition, CU-2003-AR-4326, filed by Ronald F, Nino, AICP of Vanasse Daylor, representing Dieudonne and Lunie Brutus, with respect to the property hereinafter described in Exhibit "B" attached hereto Bnd incorporated by reference herein, be and the same hereby is approved for a Conditional Use pursuant to Subsection 2.04.03, Table 2 in the Village Residential (VR) Zoning District to allow for a church or hOWie of worship in accordance with the attached Conceptual Site Plan, Exhibit "C", and subject to the conditions found in Exhibit "0" which is attached hereto and incorporated by reference herein. Page 1 of2 Agenda Item No. 17E June 24, 2008 Page 58 of 70 BE IT FURTHER RESOl. VED that this Resolution relating to Petition Number CU. 2003~^R-4326 Ix: rccorl.kd in the minutes of this Roard. This Resolution adople~ after motion.. second and super-majority vote. " ,j ( L Done this ./_A dayof___1J)drc/? ,2005, A ITEST: DWIGHT E SR0CK, CLERK BOARD OF ZONING APPEAI.S COl.L1ER COUNTY, FLORlDA '.. lerk ,J~r1~I,Q> lttest, M t/l,C!iilrw4.' S si...t.....,tNi1,. BY ';l-uJ... W, t --. ~ FRED W, COYI.E, CH~ Approved as to Farm and Legal Sufficiency: Attachments: A. B. C, D, Findings of Fact Legal Description Conceptual Site Plan Conditions Page 2 of 2 Agenda Item No, 17E June 24,2008 Page 59 of 70 ) F:tTDING JF JAC' 3'! CGL.LlE~ C:)Ui"T! :?~A]'!l'1ING C9Mi'/jI:::., FeR A CONDITIONAL USE P!:.':'!T:Cl"T CD-2003-AH.-4326 .;lI~ r'oiiowing facts are founa: , " Section 2.6,33.4,1 of the Land Development Code ::.uthorizeci the eonditionai "se, , Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the pubiic :nterest :nd ',\1:1 ,Jot adversely affect other property or uses in the same district Of :--.eighbornood >~cause or": A, Consistency witrthe Lmo De':eiopment Code :md Gro',nh :,lanagcmem ?Ian: Yes Ji.- No ], Ingress and egress to vropcrry and proposed :;rrucrurC$ ~hercon "~'l(h :':Iar:12u!::u reference to automotive ~md pc:desnian safety ;mc ;";Ol1'.'.::nienc:. ~rnIfic :low and control, and acce~s in case of fire or cJ.tastro?ne: ) Adequare ingress & egre~s Yes~ No_ C. Affects neighboring properties in relation 10 nOlse. ~iarc. .'conornk 'Jr ')dor effects: --'>10 affect or ,-\ffect mitigated by _ Affect cannot be mitigated :), Compatibility with adjacent rr0po!1ies and mher "r0:1cr," ,] 'he district: Compatible use 'xithin district .. ,j " \05_ ,,0 , ~3<2s~d 1.1n the above rindings, rhis conditior.ai use :.houid. 'vt\h :::tloul;:lt1.:)o.n3. ; ~opy ~~tL:lcncc 1 !;e ~~:':;.iT'..::::!r.Qed ~br approval to L1e Board i)t' ;:cnin~ .'\PFe~:s. ' "', i , ...... 'n1 ...., "~I j ,~,\\ - '.,.1 ...:....... v._ \ \1E:.1BER: l":.' , I'V ~ ' l' ;. ..-0./.)\\",-''/, ;;~HISIT '\ Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 60 of 70 FINDING OF FACT BY C:-JLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION CU-20(13-AR-4326 ne foiJowing facts are found: I. Section 2,6,33.4.1 of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use, 2, Granting the conditional use wilI not adversely affect the public interest and will not adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A, Consistency with the Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan: Yes t/ No [3, Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience. traffic flow and control, and access in case of tire or catastrophe: Adequatc ingress & egress Yes~ No C, Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor effect~: v :\'0 atTect or _ Affect mitigated by _ Affect cannot be mitigated D, Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district: Compatible use within district / Yes ~ No Based on the above findings, this conditional JSe should, with stipulations, (copy attached) be c~e~mmendcd for npproval to the Board of Zoning Appeals, '""1 ", :",1:'. , ' .- /.., , '_"' / -, i ,'I/-I -'I, -'. MEMBER: ;.J.....-n/14. ~...d (71.:/'_ ,""--' EXHIBIT A Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 61 of 70 FINDING OF FACT BY C:;'LLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION CU-2003-AR-4326 Tho following facts are found: I. Section 2,6.33.4,1 of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use, 2. Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will not adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A. Consistency r Development Code and Growth Management Plan: Yes No B, Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe: Adequate ingress ~ess Yes.k No_ C, boring propertie" in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor No affect or _ Affect mitigated by _ Affect cannot be mitigated D. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district: Compatible US7~ district Yes_ No dosed on the above findings, this conditional use should. with stipulations, (copy attached) be '""Gmmended for approval to lhe Board of Zoning Appeals, .:'.~. rE: /) '2_0< ./') -' ) - .-- MEMBER: Iff EXHIBIT A -w""" ~",(,' , "i\l(T _..~ . ..' Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 62 of 70 FINDING OF FACT BY COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION CU-2003-AR-4326 The following facts are found: 1. Section 2,6,33.4,} of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use, 2, Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will not adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A, Consistency with the Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan: Yes ,)L No B. Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or catllStrophe: Adequate ingress & egress Yes ,)'- No C. Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor effects: .::i.. No affect or _ Affect mitigated by _ Affect cannot be mitigated D, Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district: Compatible use within district Yes~ No_ Rased on the above tindings, this conditional use should, with stipulati ~eopy a hed) be ',commended for approval to the Board of Zoning Appeals, :_:'2:d-:J-:ij ~,~ EXHIBIT A L Agenda Item No. 17E June 24, 2008 Page 63 of 70 FINDING OF FACT BY COL:"lER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION CU-2003-AR-4326 The following facts are found: J, Section 2,6,33.4,1 of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use, 2, Granting the conditional USe will not adversely affect the public interest and will not adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: B, Consistency with the L~evelopment Code and Growth Management Plan: Yes_ Nop Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with panicular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case' of fire or catastrophe: A, Adequate ingress & egress Yes No C, Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor effects: No affect or _ Affect mitigated by _ Affeet cannot be mitigated D, Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district: Compatible use within district ~r Jascu on the above findings, this conditional use should.-rj1L~f, ceco:nmended for approyaJ to the Board of Zoning Appeals, MEMBER: ){ 1r- Pi-S ~ LL /~ Yes No - : 4; ..........~-~) be .................. .... ." ..\ -1 .--; t'" ?,.. 6~r EXHIBIT A ) ',) ) I - Agenda Item No. 17E June 24, 2008 Page 64 of 70 FINDING OF FACT BY COLLIER. COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION CU-2003-AR-4326 The following facts are found: 1, Section 2.6.33.4,1 of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use, 2. Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will not adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A, Consistency with the Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan: Yes ~ No B, Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon witb parti::ular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe: Adequate ingress & egress Yes .. No C, Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare. economic or odor effects: No affect or _ Affect mitigated by _ Affect cannot be mitigated D, Compatibility with adjaccnt properties and other property in the district: Compatible use within district YesL No Based on the above tindings, this conditional use should, with stipulations, (copy attached) be recommended for approval to the Board of Zoning Appeals. ". "::,', ,:) - O( -".\....... ,", . MEMBER:.&lwl f A,,-- EXHIBIT A Agenda Item No. 17E June 24, 2008 Page 65 of 70 FINDING OF FACT BY COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETmON CU-2003-AR-4326 The following facts are found: 1. Section 2,6,33.4,1 of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use, 2, Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public in~rest and will not adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A, Consistency with the Land De'felopment Code and Growth Management Plan: Yes.:h... No B, Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience. traffic flow and control. and access in case offrre or catastrophe: Adequate ingress & egress Yes~ No_ C, Affects neighboring propenies in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor effects: i "10 affect or _ Affect mitigated by _ Affect cannot be mitigated D, Compatibility with adjacent propenies and other property in the district: Compatible use within district Yesl No_ Based on the above findings, this conditional use should, with s' ulations, (copy attached) be recommended for approval to the Board of Zoning Appeals, ",~~, 1'1-(' <: ZfY''' .....\tc. ~.':l. -. -'\.." MEMBER: EXHIBIT A ~~~ , Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 66 of 70 ) ,,'~ c~ ) FINDING OF FACT BY CDLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETmON CU-2003-AR-4326 The following facts are found: 1, Section 2,6.33.4,1 of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use, 2. Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will not adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A, Consistency with 'Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan: Yes~No_ 8, Ingress and egress to property and proposed struetures thereon with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience. traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe: Adequate ingress & egress Yes~No_ C, Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor effects; ~o affect or _Affect mitigated by _ Affect cannot be mitigated D, Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district: Compatible use within district Yes -1L" No_ Based on the above findings, this conditional use should. with stipulations, (copy attached) be recommended for approval to the Board of Zoning Appeals, ....', "-, " i "l11~ :,- :.....-.'...:.i.:.. ...:.. ' v MEMBER: ~ ~_ I EXHIBIT A Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 67 of 70 FINDING OF F ACf BY COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION FOR CU-2003-AR-4326 The following facts are found: I, Section 2,6,33,4,) of the Land DevelC\pment Code authorized the conditional use, 2, Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will not adversely affect other propeny or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A, Consistency with the Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan: Yes --'- No_ B, Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety !IIld convenience. traffic flow and ~ontrol, and access in case of fire or catastrophe: Adequate ingress & egress Yes / No C. Affccts neighboring properties in relation to noise. glare. economic or odor effects: / No affect or _ Affect mitigated by _ Affect cannot be mitigated D, Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district: Compatible use within district Yes1 No gased on the above findings. this conditional use should, with stipulations, (copy attacl1ed) be recommmded for approval to the Board of Zoning Appeals, DATE: 2 /3/0r:;' I ! QJ4~JJ , CHAIRMAN: EXHIBIT A LEGAL DESCRIPTION CU-2003-AR-4326 LEGAL DESCRIPTlDN B~(jlNNING A T THE: NORTHE:AST CORN~R OF TH~ v~ST 380 FE:~T OF THE: F:AST 1010 FF:~T OF THF: NORTH HALF OF THE SOUTH~AST QUART~R OF TH~ SOUTHE:AST QUARTER OF SE:CTION 4, TOVNSHIP 41 SOUTH, RANGE: 29 E:AST, COLLI~R COUNTY, FLlJRIDA THE:NCE: RUN SOUTH ALONG THE: E:AST BOUNDARY LINE: OF SAID TRACT WEST 380 FE:U OF THE: EAST 1070 FE:ET TRACT A DISTANCE: OF 150 FE:E:T TO THE: POINT OF BE:GINNING OF TRACT HE:RF:lN DE:SCRIBE:Di THE:NCE: CONTINUING SOUTH ALONG SAID EAST BOUNDARY LINE: OF SAID TRACT A DISTANCE: OF 250 FE:Ui THE:NCE: RUN 'oIE:ST 120 FE:ETi THENCE i?UN NORTH 250 FE:E:T, THENCE: RUN EAST 120 FE:ET TO A POINT OF BE:GINNING. SAID PROPERTY BE:lNG ALSO DESCRIBED AS LOTS 3, 4, 5, 6 AND 7, OF A MAP OF A SUBDIVISION PROPOSED TO BE: REClJRDE:D UNDER THE NAME OF LAKE: VIEV PROPE:RTIE:S, ~hibit B Agenda Item No, 17E '-Jtmri'4;-z6ee - Page 68 of 70 Agenda Item NO,'lrr-- June 24, 2008 Page 69 of 70 '.."_' ~"?..... .'>>'.l "~,1 '~"OlVn""" 0< l~...... ::::1,111' ; 11111, i: ~i , '-:.~ Ii ,:-::I!I ~(.: : :C. l~ -nl, "; "1;1 'i ill :;,-:~I!l ", .:1 ,\;:',f',i ...........- _.._- - _:-..:~-.- --~ . r=~!'~~-::''-==--i . ,-. -- I ------ .. "'. I ... $:, ~... '", '\ I \:l~ , '~+'" "r- ", II' ...2:::--+, --'''---,' . '. "~< i:' I I j/ I I I' : : I , , I [T i lm~ i I ~ I -:.. ~ I I ,~~, I "', I r ',t I ' ~ I ~ _.J: I "'"( I :1:":"':- I " T " --- I ;1; -';.;- I, I :, :i;' t II l1 ~ I "I : IH~', I " I ""-.l .... :, I '] i I :ri-i ---"~,---'-----'" l I : -.,....-. L i'l, ~i--~: I t I ~-lf"~_.;,~ I "~ /-' I '/,,1 /-~-1,'=-- L-, '," 'Ill I hi I" J ~ ~ i; I 1""'" 'f!!: '...., . I ._,.~:...::.:..L-...;.,_.._,,_._....:' ,..,. ",,,. ,.., , " I ----1 f I I , " \t , , +- I: :i Va:;asse" -::';::"A. ,~:ij~lII''''''''' .: Daylor...... ~2::=:2=---~:~:;;:o ::o.;.L .~...;'::.._ '....."1.u:1J11 ';-.;;;; 01..... I u........." ~ _ .h ~ ,"-"...-Ia,o'\M 0:.0.... '-"'". r_ :~::~:. ~ ~.~,.;~~~j~;i,~ Agenda Item No, 17E June 24, 2008 Page 70 of 70 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL CU-2003-AR-4326 1. The Conditional Use is limited to what is shown on the conceptual site plan, identified as "Tabernacle of Bethlehem Conceptual Site Plan," prepared by Vanasse Daylor, last revised December 7, 2004, The site plan noted is conceptual in nature for conditional use approval. The final design must be in compliance with all applicable federal. state, and county laws and regulations, 2, The Conditional Use is limited to the use of the existing building for a house of worship, No expansion or enlargement of the existing building is permitted, 3, Parking within 3'" Street right-of-way is prohibited, All parking must be contained on-site, 4, The Conditional Use approval is subject to compliance with any conditions or stipulations placed upon the companion request petition, V A-2003-AR-4327, 5, The petitioner must seek development approval, i.e" SOP or SIP, for this conditional use, The SDP/SIP plans must reflect all improvements depicted on the site plan and the conditions noted above, A final local developer order (SDP or SIP and building permits) must be issued before the building's use as a church/house of worship, Revised: 2/3/05 to Incorporate the Collier County Planning Recommendation Exhibit D