The URL can be used to link to this page

Agenda 06/24/2008 Item #17D Agenda Item No. 170 June 24, 2008 Page 1 of 42 ~. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY SV-2008-AR-12943, Glen Weldon of Glen Weldon & Associates, LLC, representing Woolbright Development, Inc., requesting six variances. The first three variances are from the Land Development Code (LDC) Section 5.06.04 c.!. which requires a minimum separation of 1,000 lineal feet between signs to allow a sign separation of 70:!o feet, 705:!o feet and 775:!o feet. The fourth variance is from LDC Section 5.06.04 C.!. which permits a maximum of two pole signs per street frontage to permit a maximum of three signs along a street frontage. The fifth variance is from LDC Section 5.06.04 C.16.b.i. which allows a maximum sign area of 12 square feet for an off-premise directional sign to allow a 76:!o square foot off-premise sign. The sixth variance is from LDC Section 5,06.04 C.16.b.ii. which allows a maximum sign height of 8 feet for an off-premise directional sign to allow a maximum sign height of 9-foot 4-inches. The subject property (Collection at Vanderbilt) is located at the northwest corner of the intersection of Airport Road (CR 31) and Vanderbilt Beach Road (CR 862), in Section 35, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida. OBJECTIVE: - To have the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) consider the above-referenced Sign Variance petition and render a decision pursuant to Section 5.06.00 ofthe Land Development Code (LDC) in order to ensure that the project is in harmony with all applicable codes and regulations and that the community's interests are maintained. CONSIDERATIONS: The sign variances are for five (5) proposed wall monument signs for "The Collection at Vanderbilt," a commercial shopping center. The applicant's request is to install residential style, ground monument style signs with the name of the shopping center. It is important to note that while these signs appear to be wall monument signs, the LDC considers signs such as this to be by definition, pole signs. The LDC defmition for a pole sign is: "a sign, eight (8) or more feet in height which is independent of support from any building, that is mounted on freestanding poles or other supports, and shall include a pole cover that is between fifty (50) percent and one hundred (100) percent of the overall sign width." - The petitioner is requesting six (6) variances from LDC Section 5.06.00 for the installation of five (5) identical wall monument style signs at a commercial shopping center called the "Collection at Vanderbilt." Four (4) of the signs will mark the street entrances to the shopping center from Vanderbilt Beach Road and Airport-Pulling Road as shown in the Overall Site Plan (Exhibit A) on the previous page. One of these street entrance signs, the Vanderbilt Beach Road entrance sign, is located on an outparcel, and is therefore considered an otf-premise sign and is subject to the reduced size standards of an off-premise sign. The fifth sign is located at the southwest comer of the intersection of Airport-Pulling Road and Galleria Drive. Signs A-2 and B-2 have sign permits. Sign A-2 has a sign permit and has been constructed. Page I of 4 Agenda Item No. 17D June 24. 2008 Page 2 of 42 The requested variances for each sign are as shown on the attached site plan (Exhibit A) and as follows: 1. Sign A-I, for a proposed variance from LDC Section 5.06.04 C.16.b.ii. which requires each off-premises sign to be no more than eight (8) feet in height to allow a sign that is 9'- 4" in height. 2. Sign A-I, for a proposed variance from LDC Section 5.06.04 C.16.b.i. which requires an off-premises sign to be no more than twelve (12) square feet in area to allow a sign that is 76'"'- square feet in area. 3. Sign B-1 and B-2, for a proposed variance from LDC Section 5.06.04 c.!. which requires a minimum separation of 1,000 linear feet to allow a separation of 70'"'- feet between sign B-1 and B-2. 4. Sign C-I and B-1, for a proposed variance from LDC Section 5.06.04 C.!. which requires a minimum separation of 1,000 linear feet to allow a separation of 705'"'- feet between sign C-I and sign B-1 as shown on the Overall Site Plan. 5. Sign C-I and B-2, for a proposed variance from LDC Section 5.06.04 c.!. which requires a minimum separation of 1,000 linear feet to allow a separation of 775'"'- feet between sign C-I and B-2 as shown on the Overall Site Plan. 6. Signs B-1, B-2 and C-l, for a proposed variance from LDC Section 5.06.04 c.!. which allows a maximum of two ground signs per street frontage to allow the three signs along Airport- Pulling Road street frontage as shown on the Overall Site Plan. The sign variances are for five (5) proposed wall monument (as depicted in Exhibit "A") signs for "The Collection at Vanderbilt," a commercial shopping center that has recently opened this past year. The commercial shopping center is part of the Pelican Marsh DRI and is located in Activity Center # ] I. The applicant's request is to install residential style, ground monument style signs (see Exhibit "B") with the nan1e of the shopping center. FISCAL IMPACT: Approval of this Sign Variance petition would have no fiscal impact on Collier County. GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN (GMPl IMPACT: Approval of this Sign Variance would not affect or change the requirements of the Growth Management Plan. AFFORDABLE HOUSING IMPACT: Approval of this Sign Variance would have no affordable housing impact. Page 2 of 4 Agenda item No. 170 June 24, 2008 Page 3 of 42 ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES: There are no environmental issues associated with this Sign Variance. ENVIRONMENTAL ADVISORY COUNCIL (EAC) RECOMMENDATION: The EAC did not review this petition as they do not normally hear Sign Variance petitions. COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION (CCPC) RECOMMENDATION: The CCPC heard petition SV-2008-AR-12943 on May 15, 2008, and by a vote of 8-0 recommended to forward this petition to the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) with a recommendation of approval and is in agreement with staff conditions listed below. Because the CCPC approval recommendation was unanimous and no letters of objection have been received, this petition has been placed on the Summary Agenda. LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: The Petitioner is requesting six sign variances. The granting of such variances is permitted under LDC S9.04.02. The attached staff report and recommendations of the Planning Commission are advisory only and are not binding on you. Decisions regarding variances are quasi-judicial, and all testimony given must be under oath. The Petitioner has the burden to prove that the proposed variance is consistent with all the criteria set forth below, and you may question Petitioner, or staff, to satisfy yourself that the necessary critelia have been satisfied. LDC Section 9.04.02.A requires that "based upon the evidence given in public hcaring; and the tindings of the planning commission" you "should determine to the maximum extent possible if the granting of the variance will diminish or otherwise have a detrimental effect on the public interest, safety or welfare." Should you consider denying the variance, to assure that that your decision is not later found to be arbitrary, discriminatory or unreasonable, the denial must be based upon competent, substantial evidence that the proposal does not meet one or more of the listed criteria below. Approval of this request requires three aftirmative votes of the Board. In granting a sign variance, the Board of Zoning Appeals may prescribe the following: ]. Appropriate conditions and safeguards in conformity with this Code or other applicable county ordinances. Violation of such conditions and safeguards, when made a part of the terms under which the variance is granted, shall be deemed a violation of this Code. 2. A reasonable time limit within which the action for which the variance required shall be begun or completed or both. (MMSS for JW) Page 3 of 4 Agenda Item No. 17D June 24,2008 Page 4 of 42 Criteria for Sil!n Variances I. There are special conditions and circumstances existing which are peculiar to the location, size, and characteristics ofthe land, structure, or building involved. 2. There are special conditions and circumstances which do not result from the action of the applicant, such as pre-existing conditions relative to the property which is the subject of the variance request. 3. A literal interpretation of the provisions of the LDC work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant or create practical difficulties on the applicant. 4. The variance, if granted, wi]] be the minimum variance that wi]] make possible the reasonable use of the land, building, or structure and which promote standards of health, safety, or welfare. 5. Granting the variance requested will not confer on the petitioner any special privilege that is denied by these zoning regulations to other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning district. 6. Granting the variance wi]] be in harmony with the intent and purpose of the LDC, and not be injurious to the neighborhood, or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare. 7. There are natural conditions or physica]]y induced conditions that ameliorate the goals and objectives of the regulation, such as natural preserves, lakes, golf course, etc. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) approve petition SV-2008-AR- 12943 subject to the fo]]owing conditions: 1. The sign copy for Signs A-I, A-2, B-1, B-2 and C-l as shown on Exhibits A and B sha]] be limited to 76ctc square feet. 2. Signs A-I, A-2, B-1, B-2 and C-I as shown on Exhibits A and B sha]] be limited to the name of the shopping center and sha]] not contain the names of individual tenants. PREPARED BY: Nancy Gundlach, AICP, Principal Planner Departmcnt of Zoning and Land Development Review Attachments: Exhibit A: Overa]] Site Plan Exhibit B: Entrance Sign Wa]] Elevation Page 4 of 4 Item Number: Item Summary: Meeting Date: Page ] of 2 Agenda Ilem No. 170 June 24,2008 Page 5 of 42 COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS 17D This item requires that all participants be sworn In and ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members: SV-200B-AR-12943 Woolbright Development, Inc., represented by Glen Weldon of Glen Weldon & Associates. LLC, of Anderson, South Carolina, requesting six variances. The first three variances are from the Land Development Code (LOC) Section 5.0604 C.1 which requires a minimum separation of 1.000 lineal feet between signs to allow a sign separation of 70 feet, 705 feet and 775 feet. The fourth variance is from LOG Section 5.0604 G.1 which permits a maximum of two pole signs per street frontage to permit a maximum of three signs along a street frontage. The fifth variance is from LDC Section 5.06.04 C.16.b.i. which allaws a maximum sign area of 12 square feet far an off-premise directional sign to allow a 76 square fool off-premise sign. The sixth variance is from LOG Seclron 5.06.04 G. 16.b,ii. which allaws a maximum sign height of 8 feet for an off-premise directional sign to allow a maximum sign height of 9-foat 4-inches. The subject property (Collection at Vanderbilt) is located at the northwest corner of the intersection of Airport Road (CR 31) and Vanderbilt Beach Road (GR 862) in Section 35, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida. 6/24/200890000 AM Prepared By Nancy Gundlach Community Development & Environmental Services Principal Planner Date Zoning & Land Development Review 6/2120089:25:10 AM Approved By Joseph K. Schmitt Community Development & Environmental Services Community Development & Environmental Services Adminstrator Date Community Development & Environmental Services Admin. 6/212008 3 :20 PM Approved By Judy Puig Community Development & Environmental Services Operations Analyst Community Development & Environmental Services Admin. Date 6131200811:06 AM Approved By Nick Casalanguida Transportation Services MPO Director Date Transportation Planning 6/41200B 4:59 PM Approved By Ray Bellows Community Development & Environmental Services Chief Planner Date Zoning & Land Development Review 6110/200812:19 PM Approved By file"//r.\A (lpnrl~Tp<;;.t\1='YnC'lrt\ 11 ()_ TlInpO/-.. ,(l,Lt o/^ ')n')nnQ\ 1 7 O/.. '1{\C"T 11\ AI\ If ^ D \10/ '"II) ^ r<rll. Tn. A \ r/1 0 1....""0 Page 20f2 Agenda Item No. 17D June 24. 2008 Page 6 of 42 Jeff Wright Assistant County Attorney Date County Attorney County Attorney Office 6/11/20082:03 PM Approved By Susan Murray, Alep Community Development & Environmental Services Zoning & Land Development Director Date Zoning & Land Development Review 6/11/20083:30 PM Approved By Norm E. Feder, AICP Transportation Division Administrator Date Transportation Services Transportation Services Admin. 6/12/200811:05 AM A pproved By OMS Coordinator OMS Coordinator Date County Manager's Office Office of Management & Budget 6/12/20082:13 PM Approved By Mark Isackson Budget Analyst Date County Manager's Office Office of Management & Budget 6/13/20088:28 AM Approved By James V. Mudd County Manager Date Board of County Commissioners County Manager's Office 6/15/20085:15 PM file://r'\A Pf'n(bTf>~t\J=;Yn()rt\ 1 1 (L 11l1"1po/h ,)(),)A o/~ ')()')()(lQ\ 1"'7 0/ "",\e I n. n A ^ n Hn/ '"\'" ~ r'r.... lr.. . \ AG~I9~J~.p~~~ Page 7 of 42 Co~r County - ~~ - STAFF REPORT COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FROM: DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION HEARING DATE: MAY 15, 2008 SUBJECT: PETITION SV-2008-AR-12943, THE COLLECTION AT VANDERBILT PROPERTY OWNER/AGENT: APPLICANT: Woolbright Development, Inc. 3200 NOlth Militaty Trail Boca Raton, FL 33431 AGENT: Glen Welden Glcn Wcldcn & Associatcs, LLC 349 Kllo11wood Drive Anderson, SC 29625 REOUESTED ACTION: The applicant is requesting a total of six (6) sign variances from Section 5.06.00 of the Land Development Code (LDC) to permit five (5) pole signs. GEOGRAPHIC LOCATION: The subject propelty, The Collection at Vatlderbilt, is located at the nOlthwest corner of the intersection of AhpOlt-Pulling Road (CR 31) and Vanderbilt Beach Road (CR 862), in Section 35, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida. (See the location map on the following page.) PURPOSEIDESCRIPTION OF PROJECT: The sign variances are for five (5) proposed pole signs that are designed to resemble wall monument signs (as depicted in Exhibit "A") signs for "The Collection at Vanderbilt," a commercial shopping center that has recently opened this the past year. The location of the signs are depicted in the Overall Site Plan attached as Exhibit "A." Thc commercial shopping center is part of the Pelican Marsh DRI and is located in Activity Ccnter # 11. The applicant's request is to install residential style, ground monument style signs (see Exhibit "B") with the name of the shopping center. It is important to note that while these signs appeat- to be wall momllnent signs, the LDC considers signs such as this to be by definition, pole signs. The LDC definition for a pole sign is: "a sign, eight (8) or more feet in height which is independent of support from any SV-2008-AR-12943 Page 1 of 10 OCON ,-0,," ~O~ .N 0 o .ct) Z~ w fl:Q)Ul iDc'" =:::;0.. ",' ~ iii Ul <t: ------------ -------- lVN~~ (~r .UJ} ovo~ ~Nnlllo;l-HIO<JUrl . cd ii~ ~ ~ o . ii ~ '0 ii ~ ~ Cl :> Q Cl. w,"" (L,.- 'W:)) (JltOU nN1TlOd-lllOdUN ~ Cl ^ :> . Cl. i ~ " " ~ Cl ~ Ii ii ~ ~ . 0 m ~ u.." u~ Cl ~< :> _N Cl. ~2 lTl'y';Q'.lON I ~ ~~ ~ ~ !"j.~' ..1 S l'l _ : I' . '~;;;;;;-, I 1I..!l.L....LllllliJA e 6, l!l ~'= 0' j , ~K 0') ! ~n"" ~Y.Hr>3~ ~ roo ~000l\ ~';JlWJl ,< 11, i, ~eg j IK ~~ ~~ ;~ ;t"U".l.8lHIJi; 8~<:, j,S ,1 LJ'- . j~ .'1 ch ;e " di " \:i;:: ,,< , , ~g ~~ , ,. ~fi'" , ! ,,!3R - ~>- <~ . s ! II! 5, !~_ ~ ~ "t tj r l.., 8 Il!i !; --'C ! '''1 ~ !. 11 ., 'j- , .. , - ..' i'~ II II ~l ; , , ":J~ - ~3t c;..,.....,..".:w,1O)OO i---~~~T- '"""v 011. ~ !trl ,., >IImi4 ~ ~ III I- I' ib ' --(lr'Gl1l6.w.rl t'~ .. I . '.2 " I , i Ii a.. <( ~ <.9 z z o N '" ., Ol N ~ ~ '" '" . > (I) '" z o >- .... uJ Q. a.. <( ~ z o f- e::( () o ....J EXHIBIT "A" The Collection at Vanderbilt GROUND MONUMENT DISPLA Y VARIANCE APPLICATION EXHIBITS (~._,.~l",,, _,L~:~.-;;l"J,,)I!lL\.. L,.,,~) I~ --.-...,..~..:"...,.~-'"- ....~_.: ~~_,.-_ _t~~ :::,) :,i;:'-~- -,=--.. ".~ ~- ; ".J_'-.:-~~:'::',~,..-,-::i<:=-- '=~. - ':.--- -----""::::---=- ~..----~ =."--+I"".;::::;=",....~...,...".:..,,_ c..4. J..:-. <~..: . '1'':':'::'' , . ~~~....:- - "";:" " .. '.,- - - -- .;.;.-----:- ". . ...' ~ '2i If f?I '.. '~"".O'-.. .- - I J, ._~~':.\~!Ilfl.(( i~: ~;;:-.. .. ' = ~- ",a ~~I \ ! . :JI It': I . -- i' _:-:~__ !./ ".w 1\ lr-' ~,: I , I"'t. ' ~'1- -,h r ,.,.. ":;I'" fJl)jt)\ -s:' ,l.'L; - :\It. \ ~Jf1 \, -......../. ;'::::::;--'-:11' . . __.....J 1...1 ::: -;:--;-i! . '.. '1~ (~ -'~." '1,..,: J-,),..ot{ ,01(", I { i ;' I jll I ill , iJ. \ .d , " .:1 I ,. " jl I :1)'1\ I l(i1 ! i~~\ ;', ::..__:- ~~ri::'-Z_=:::-'L "'i I I _.-"~'II' .lo..-----l.l. ---'",..f ---- _.~.~4!f.~:.-::_ -~ :l.:~:~:.:::..~l:::t .....,---......._........~......,....,,-~~.:..;;;;'t~::::===._.;\-3.......... LOCATION A ~=...===,.-=-==-., SIGN A-1 (loca:ed on ~hmk Pfupcrt).') ~-= ~~~:fflr~-~~-~ . '" .........""".....c_.,..,,__...__-___,_..~ __. -.,..""",,.-:r.,,,,",,,",,.,,,,::,.~"''''''',, ;;:;-:""c'=:. , I --..-----\;TT1I IfjOVERALL SITE PLAN I:m""""""'- __..l ....~l'~~ .tI:IIJ<......."-;IJ'Dl':'V~ l"''''''iflI'\!'''';~'''~:;;~~~ tr.;;;l:.~. SC...IE,....,sIK~'~ aie"" W/~.~;. WOOLBRIGHT ./" D EVE LOP MEN TIN C . :l100NOIl.THriIUlAJ,Y TfWL 4TH ROOR BOCAIlA'tor~,~u>>JOAUOI l419.19.ltSO EIl\,jmmn~ntRI Graphic De:slgl1: Glen Welden & Associates, LLC ~'19 KnoUMlM Dl'iI~ R~~~S'.l'~bSfi:i19~Il'ICI\'.\b..I.R<"" Agenda Item No. 170 June 24, 2008 Page 9 of 42 . _I LOCATION C SIGNC-1 705' between Sign C.l and Sign B-1 775' between Sign C-l And Sign B-2 LOCATION B SIGN B-1 SIGN B-2 70' i- 70' between Sign B.l and Sign 8.2 299' I " \, r=j .j-_..::7~:=-.i N '* Wj?~E S t'llV.\\1lolC" 1.\0\.11:,11,\'.,:-1,'1 CV-7 ~C'.t~""'Sl'lI()'\\'l\l 1\~"\1~1ON; Agenda Item No. 17D June 24, 2008 Page 10 o.!.iL_. '. the Collection at Vanderbilt ~,- _......-..~.----,_.~,."....- GROUND MONUMENT DISPLAY VARIANCE Al'PLlCATION EXHIBITS EXHIBIT "B" 'Chlll1l'o!'ldeplhmaybeBnlaUeriorUmfllbrication 3.5U'd('f1lfabriCo1lcdi)luminumch~nl1cIMtcrs witn.OOO filet's ..nd min. ,063 rcNrns. .All W<.'lded constnlctill...withwl!l!Jlhol15pro...idedl~Ye"'geoltw()) for..achlelter. Glo!I:J"II~llI,,1 finish tu tlllIteh MAP MP 30132 Rll1ek f,,-;\.r Day_Time Appearance ~. ~~, Isometric I LED Reverse Channel Letter ""0..;4: ~Evening- Ap~ance ii.~~ 21'-2" .'.: 3'-3" ;'1?jm~~'lprilll:25O" Ihlck'rompuler rot ~lr ;";i,r~~;~~r~or~,plnmO~f\tro fro~y~:.:, M.1lnl1fpdured alunwlWIl ~v~se~Jle ~qp]!~llo'(llnd :A~VANDB~I}l~T':#Jtti ~~ to:ii!i,;y..:fcIr LIIDlig~~~ - >,:'_."i .,.,~ -' =-01 '~. '~' '. ...- ,If."'" '" .. "1 ATVAND~f{IJlcr. .)1B" ..<,:," .' -,.,,;., I~Ji$ Entrance Sign Wall Elevation for Locations A, B & C ~,:,j'E~ SCALE; AS SHOWl'-' Client: W"'~""'" WOOLBRIGHT ./ DEVELOPMENT If"C . , , . " nCONOIITHMIUTAAYTRAlL,(THfLOOR WCAAAlO'.....ROIllD^JH]1 ~61"a7 IY~O ~-~--- 4 (h ,- [I "j'~'" " . tlf?ri11~'li:::; -',- ;:;v::\-~ ~_~i~~ ~,:~ " ,~~: -ti;:n~:i~-;.~n~i~:~~';atcs, LLC j ::,1:,\'\1. Jlcv IJ }19 Knollwood Drive SChLH,AS:lHO'W1" ~ AndersonSC2%25 864-353,1:1016 O""'8"C;WAlhalrom P.EVfSION, . -.. .--.- ...- ( Agenda Item No. 17D June 24, 2008 Page 11 of 42 PHOTO building, that is mounted on fi'eestanding poles or other supports, and shall include a pole cover that is betweenfifty (50) percent and one hundred (100) percent of the overall sign width." The request is for six (6) variances from LDC Section 5.06.00 for the installation of five (5) proposed, identical signs. Four (4) of the signs will mark the street entrances to the shopping ccnter from Vanderbilt Road and AirpOlt-Pulling Road as shown in thc Overall Site Plan (Exhibit A) on the previous page. One of these street entrance signs, the Vanderbilt Road entTance sign, is located on an outparccl, and is thereforc considered an off-premise sign and is subject to the reduced size standards of an off-premise sign. The fifth sign is located at the southwest corner of the intersection of AirpOlt-Pulling Road and GaIleria Drive. Signs A-2 and D-2 have sign permits. Sign A-2 has been constructcd and is shown in the photo above. Thc rcqucsted variances for each sign are as follows: I. Sign A-I, for a proposed variancc from LDC Section 5.06.04 C.16.b.ii. which rcquircs cach off-premises sign to be no more than eight (8) feet in height to allow a sign that is 9'-4" in height. 2, Sign A-I, for a proposed variance from LDC Section 5.06.04 C.16.b.i. which requires an off-premises sign to be no more than twelve (12) square fect in area to allow a sign that is 76" square feet in area, SV-2008.AR-12943 Page 5 of 10 Agenda Item No. 170 June 24. 2008 Page 12 of 42 3. Sign B-1, for a proposed variance from LDC Section 5.06.04 C.J. which requires a minimum separation of 1,000 linear feet between pole signs to allow a separation of 700C feet between sign B-1 and B-2. 4. Sign C-l, for a proposed variance from LDC Section 5.06.04 C.I. which requires a minimum separation of 1,000 lincar feet between pole signs to allow a separation of 70S", feet between sign C-I as shown on the Overall Site Plan. 5. Sign C-I, for a proposed variance from LDC Section 5.06.04 C.1. which rcquircs a minimum separation of 1,000 linear feet between pole signs to allow a separation of 775 "' feet between sign C-I and B-2 as shown on the Overall Site Plan. 6. Signs B-1, B-2 and C-I, for a proposed variance from LDC Section 5.06.04 C.J. which allows a maximum of two pole or ground signs per street fi'ontage to allow the three signs along Airport-Pulling Road street frontage as shown on the Overall Site Plan. AERIAL PHOTO SURROUNDING LAt"'<D USE AND ZONING: North: Gallcria Drive, then omces and retail in the Pelican Marsh DR! South: Vandcrbilt l3each Road (CR 862) then retail in the Walgreen's PUD SV-2008-AR-12943 Page 6 of 10 Agenda Item No. 170 June 24, 2008 Page 13 of 42 ( East: AirpOli-Pulling Road (CR 31) then Bolero at Tiburon, a residential development in Pelican Marsh DR! West: retail and offices in Pelican Marsh DRI GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN (GMP) CONSISTENCY: The subject property is located in the Urban Designation, Mixed Use Activity Center Subdistrict of the Future Land Use Map of the Growth Management Plan (GMP). The GMP does not address individual Variance requests but focuses on the larger issue of the actual use. The Pelican Marsh DR! is consistent with the Future Land Use Map. Based upon the above analysis, staff concludes that the proposed use for the subject site is consistent with the Future Land Use Element, although the Variance request is not specifically addressed. ANALYSIS: Section 9.04.00 of the LDC gives the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) the authority to grant Variances. The Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) is advisory to the BZA and utilizes the provisions of Section 9.04.03.A through 9.04.03.H as general guidelines to assist in making a recommendation. Staff has analyzed this petition relative to the evaluative criteria and offers the following responses: a. Are there special conditions and circumstances existing which are peculiar to the location, size and characteristics of the land, structure or building iuvolvcd? Yes. The shopping center is setback approximately 750 fcct from Vanderbilt Beach Road and Airport-Pulling Road. The entire Airport-Pulling Road and Vanderbilt Beach Road frontage is occupicd by outparccl style development. (Note: two (2) sites are subdivided outparcel sites, the other five (5) sitcs appear to be outparcels but are not because they have not been subdivided from the main parccl). The outparcel sites currently developed along Vanderbilt Beach Road create a partial visual batTier, making it difficult to see the shopping center from Vanderbilt Beach Road. The outparcel sitcs along Airport-Pulling Road are cUlTently undcveloped. As theses are developed, it can be anticipated tllat that shopping center frontage along Airport-Pulling Road will be obscured as well. b. Are there special conditions and circumstances which do not result from the action of the applicant, such as pre-existing conditions relative to the property, which is the subject of the variance request? No. The applicant wishes to install a sign that is different from that which is typically crected at commercial shopping centers. The type of sign that is typically erected at a commercial shopping center is a 15-foot high directory pole sign with the names of up to eight (8) tenants. The applicant wishes to install a 9'-4" sign that is a residential style monument wall sign. The proposed monument wall sign will not have the names of any tenants; it will only have the name of the shopping center. SV-2008-AR-12943 Page 7 of 10 Agenda Item No. 170 June 24, 2008 Page 14 of 42 c. Will a literal interpretation of the provIsIOns of the LDC work unnecessary and undue hal'dship on the applicant or create practical difficulties for the applicant? No. The shopping center would not suffer undue hardship since a literal interpretation of the LDC would allow the applicant to construct one pole sign for each set of monument style signs proposed in the same strcet cntrance locations along Vanderbilt Beach Road and Airport-Pulling Road. d, Will the variance, if granted, be the minimum variance that will make possible the reasonable use of the land, building or structure and which promote standards of hcalth, safety and welfare? No. The purpose of the requested sign variances are to allow monument style wall signs to anchor either side of the shopping center street entrancc at the comers of the public streets that are uscd to access the site. However, Staff is of the opinion that the size of the wall is an appropriate size and is in proportion to the size of the shopping center it is representing. The residential character of the sign is in keeping with the aesthetic quality of the residential neighborhood, thereby promoting standards of health, safety and welfare. e. Will granting the variance confer on the applicant any special privilege that is denied by these zoning regulations to other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning district? Yes. A Variance by definition confers some dimensional relief from the zoning regulations specific to a site. The granting of this Variance request would allow the proposed signs to have Icss than the code required 1,000 lineal feet between signs to allow a sign separation 70:f: feet, 705:f: feet, and 775:f: feet. It would also allow three (3) signs along Vandcrbilt Beach Road street frontage, which is one more than the code allows. The off-premise sign, which is subject to smaller size standards, would havc an additional 64 square feet of sign area and 16 inches more height than what is prescribcd by the LDC, thereby confen'ing on the applicant a special privilege. f. Will granting the variance be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of this Land Development Code, and not be injurious to the neighborhood, or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare? Yes. Section 5.06.01.A. of the LDC states that the purpose and intent of the LDC relative to signage is to ensure that all signs are: I, Compatible with their surroundings; 2. Designed, constructed, installed and maintained in a manncr that docs not endanger public safety or unduly distract motorists; 3. Appropriate to the type of activity to which they pertain; 4. Large enough to convey sufficient information about the owner or occupants of a particular property, the products or services available on the property, or the activitics conducted on the property, and small enough to satisfy the needs for regulation; 5. Reflective of the identity and creativity of the individual occupants. SV -2008-AR-12943 Page 6 of 10 Agenda Item No. 170 June 24. 2008 Page 15 of 42 In staffs opmIOn, the requested off-premises sign advances all of these objectives. Therefore, approval of the Variance would be consistent with the purpose and intent of the LDC. g. Are there natural conditions or physically induced conditions that ameliorate the goals and objectives of the regulation such as natural preserves, lakes, golf courses, etc.? Yes. The signs are a residential style monument wall sign that are less obtrusive than the typical shopping centcr pole sign. h. Will granting the variance be consistent with the Growth Management Plan? Yes. Approval o[this Variance petition would be consistent with the GMP since it would not affect or change any ofthe GMP's requirements. EAC RECOMMENDATION: The Environmental Advisory Council does not normally hear Variance petitions and did not hear this one. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) forward Petition SV- 2008-AR-12943 to thc Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) with a recommendation of approval subject to the [ol1owing conditions of approval: 1. The sign copy for Sib'll A-I, A-2, B-1, B-2 and C-l as depicted on Exhibit "A" Overall Site Plan shaH be limited to 76", square feet. 2. The signs for A-I, A-2, B-I, B-2 and C-I as depictcd on Exhibit "A" Overall Site Plan shall be limited to the name of the shopping center and shall not contain the names of individual tenants. SV-200B-AR-12943 Page 9 of 10 PREPARED BY: ( ,~ REVIEWED BY: JE 'F . WRIGHT A I TANT COUNTY ATTORNEY ~~~tL . RAY~ ND .BELL WS,MANAGER DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW .he-- sus , M. I TENES, AICP, DIRECTOR II DEPA TMENT OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW APPROVED BY: ~.. ..........~ P K. SCHMITT, ADMINISTRATOR UNITY DEVET ,OPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL ICES DIVISION A;lenda item No. 17D June 24. 2008 Page 16 of 42 -4'~O' 00 DATE _#Z-2/0~ DATE 4-(7,9/0'(, I DATE A:/t-q/or: D~TE i ~ /I~ I @ATE Tentatively scheduled for thc May 15,2008 Board of County Commissioners Meeting. COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION: VV M/L 11~h MAR ,Po STRAIN, CHAIRMAN SV-200B-AR-12943 Page 10 of 10 s- /1 S-/o ~ DATE Agenda Item No. 170 June 24, 2008 Page 17 of 42 ''l. COLLIIiR COUNTY GOVERNMENT DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW "'~WROOV_ (i) 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 403..2400 FAX (239) 643-6968 i:-~~-'I ~_ :tr-'~ ~~,::~ :-':'~"'f ~~~:"I~h;~.::~~;r:~:rI~~~~ :~~. 'l=-!:~~::::~~~ JE~~~1f~ t=1s"ir,}J;:; ~c::.!-'~~ ~j' {f~] [-., '1) ",' " . 1 \ .', ,.~. n" '", i.~11 I "..\ .1,. '-lt~ ,1__, ,"_,_ I, .". ( - "r" F Ji. "r,' :,,'. _ ~ - vr d>\, (";j~. .)_ I, ,;:~~~,-- ~ ,"I'~;--'''''-'_ 'I ,_ -; __,' 1'- . -'. ' . - -c" ,~::' :'.:l~~<~-l," .t':.".')'I:h'",-'!) /1:,)1 .l',:~ h_tb';.~f,;-4,d 'J! r'~.h~ -=- 1< .;, " :::::~~-i!-:'o:l~7 -I=; '?"'- -; ~. ~,;:... ~~- ::II (: -. ','" L. " ~;::-=-, "'I'-~~C:C"'~'O '~i;'~-l],'r' '(~"-l' 1~)f,~ - ~-..,-u,-':::,~'.'::.-~,i"::=--'7r01.,t.:t:,~"'~~'!.Q:'::':'':::_ -:__,_--=-!_ ',. - ~,- ",- '-fl'" -j .lj'~ ,- j,.r 1~)[ ,'")=101 r.Jij,lt$!rJ1G{SL~_=;-' ,../, ('..:;;~':-''''''~~'~'iC;-:i,~''''-:''W~;:~''!_'==-''\~l L. 2~" ,~:~~ > ,~~:;< i~i.~~~t~~-~~;-.l.;ilt~~i~~~,~:~z~r ~~i;u~;:itl~~~~:'~~~~l~f-:~~~~~~ill-1]:;i~~ii~~~~~S_:~ PETITION NUMBER (AR) PROJECT NAME PROJECT NUMBER DATE PROCESSED COORDINATING PLANNER For SlaFf Use ABOVE TO BE COMPLETED 8Y STAFF frc) ":,,,;;--:~~~:--,~:;:---r;- ~~ ~~!;o.~~s:j-2'"-:;:~~8 ~'~~l~~_~-.:7T='--~~;~G:;' ;~:;~:.f~:.F:-~~';;-)~0._.. ?~~~~ '_, ~.,>-;~'";,,,"'7B----;:-:1 [-,:C -~ '-~:- .:~'..~~~~, = - J;, ~;-~" L- .~".~~tlfj!:m~~i:~~_h1!~Cr;.('iHIJ;n~t1L{JJ~l;1i'i(J!r.LUi(1"5~::~"~~~'~~~<.6~-=-':::'l ~::~~~L~ill PETITIONER'S NAME. !\N'~I-6f2:.lbffi"' ~~ AbDR.SS, ~;2'eO }l&>1Zf.I.I. l\l1t.llhIo/ ~~ 'S-.-... 2".I.'lZI>J Slale H'P'"'""- Illl ~<.I~ J PHONE# ~1- t1efl~ I'f~ CELL# FAX ~I_ "E6. ;;::.r~ E-MAIL ADDRESS, ~ ~,Nj;j" . AG.NT, ~ LU~ FIRM. r.:{.t.fi.l lAl~ <4 ^C:""'~IA~ " ".. ADDRESS, ~ k/..!""'" 'N~ ~e. Cllv lWl::8~N Slale ~ Zln zelt.?.$ PHONE#S1;t/~~IY-fl6nz cm# e.su~S5~~Pn?-b FAx# At;q. 31l./~ s%z E-MAIL" ADDRESS t:E~/6Na-wA ti? }v,/... &J1A . Be aware Ihal Callier Counly has lobbyist regulations, Guide yourself accordingly and ensure that you ora in compliance with Ihese regulations, Agenda Item No. 170 June 24, 2008 Page 18 of 42 ...._-:'1"- j "~;-J.,.'3!2''''';'~ '"..........';.;.0ll,1"~ ,... .:ii}'f.~~rii..re.t).~~.~.~'h~; ;'..~~:~~~;";...i-'=\;-!.ar I ..;~.._t ~l ....~ ~~_:m.;. :~~ f.'IT'",:':"~'e.-? .'-r:'":'. ...."i;;" SECTlON/TOWNSHIP/RANGE, * IlfeLJ Ue.. PROPERTY I.D.# SUBDIVISION NAME. ~IC,W lV!JZGl-I- 1'lJD UNIT BLOCK LOT METES & BOUNDS DESCRIPTiON, Wun.IF ~I;?h'l'~.en ZONI,* ."CTllJrry /',;,. t=? _ , -IU z.. , ~ , '" \61 /.I!ir(i!4toP ~ . . LAND USE OF SUBJECT PARCEL, l:: II~F.SlI::r ~ (eWI;:>- . ADDRESS OF SIGN LOCATIO~ CURRENT ZONING ~.IJb-l.. Length & HeIght of wall upon which the Sign will be secured. J~I.d' >4 eL.:cll "!:lII- wlo:lL. ~ C$"~AlC (IF Wo" SIgn) Width of Subject Property. V~",cr ~ /Z<<!>AI:):= II2D r A1~ -pt.>U>/>J.b- 12'<lAt>"" llzil (Raod Fran/age) ~ " ~~_r[~)J;~:~.>f!~~\.~;.;~~5~~;.k~.. .i~~~';;~~~~f?1~?;;t~~~'~ Provide a detailed explanatJon of the variance request Including what signs are exlsllng and what Is propDsed; the amount of encroachment propDsed using numbers, I.e. reduce setback from IS' to 10'/ why encroachment is necessary, how exisllng encroachment came to be; etc. W&<:>UZ17JI.+fr ~Ig, (l~~ I~ ~Mh- A ~~IS~ /.Jp UJI.~.' /'liPmlJl:> ~ Cl.\r:alP-D I'IAnllfllM~ -!.lkIoJ~ Vol/ 11-1>,1-&>_ /..11 ~ .cJWJfJB.!_ '''S~ It:>eN1'qy '1i:>e 'j)le: ";~/lJ... ~11"= It-! we" --= 11/e. 1lu.t:>b."T1f.N.bL) ~I ThJI. IJJ.U,"'lJb"Im> M[)t-il-'fE1NoNr' -7/btJ7, ~ ~All MOklUM.6Oi' w!..ll.:;. />lz;I;;. ~~ ~ 'ElbCH- SIbIa- bF 1Iha ~ 1..mJ 'TIle. (;".~. t!JIJ(A)\lbtJPaz.&u:;r _.w.M< lUl/>lD. /l.112:F''''1 F'''U,\1.b!, IYl~B) .. , <; (l1>lZ~ 0;:'. ~ 'p!Z16.. 'l:;J:>1v;;. 4 bll2'.~ -PLJu..'IoI.t- 1'Z'llQ::>. CL/....,.. ~ , '. b. 1I1!:o1Z.1~,W~ 11' ~ ~ ~ ~>...r,oJ.\..s ~ l.N>.:l1r.IJ.'!> AJ ~:l S. t::. ~$ It~.JL /1.<;;. !. \J!.lZ~ :I;')g A-I />,c, 1'Ili". 'D171'~ I ~ UY.= 6'1-! \''&JJk. ~/,I ~ ~ t..o).),;.~~ "'j3)1 ~ 1t> -p.e. Aor-.l 11l>A" -~ II $t!t-l. Please note that stoff ond the ColI/er County Planning CommissIon sholl be guided In .helr recommendallon to the Boord of :zoning Appeals, ond Ihat the Boord of :zoning appeals shall be guided In Its delermlnallon to approve or deny 0 variance p,etltJon by the below listed crIteria (1-6), (Please oddress thll crlterlo using additional page. If necessary,) ), Are there spedal condlllons and clrcumstonces existing whIch ore peculiar to the locallon, size ond characteristic< of the land, structure, or buildIng Involved, '1fI".tlb/., 1"""'''"''IPciIJ d, ') "'/41-J 1.ll(lA..TlOU~ b.) -g.";' c. ~ 1~Z>f 1\1;<. ~~ ~ce> . Il-tI1l ~'flZDJP..tf 4 . t.d ~ I,Q&:Iu.t.. (..,Ix;tqllll.lS ~12 ~ Wrlkllhil,p;r:ii ~~ 10 Q,o~ ~L- 1~n1J ~ iUI1,'o/' ~ M1ZllI.J~,> ~ f.,~ ~ lOM'1ll5/tifJ"lff, ~f\L C.1OO',,^~'r;" "'_) ~l~. A-I t~ I.oo.J'2p ~ ~k.~t-J ~b- (t!> lJ12A2.) Agenda Item No. 17D June 24, 2008 Page 19 of 42 2, Are there .peclal conditIon, and cIrcumstances whIch do not result from the actIon of the applicant such as pre-exktlng condlllon. relative to the property whIch Is the sublect of the varlonce reque.t, '\ .' [tol3r.J 1,1t.N k-l boN ~. "f'!Zf!\uI'7 II ?lB.!. e.fJk. \l.tb Glin\9.J ~ ~''''L ~-nll;2 ~(l1J_~~ ~ ~ r:v", ~IY, 3. WUI a IIterollnterpretallon of the provIsions of this zoning code work unnecessory and undue hardship an Ibe applicant or create practical difficulties an the appllcont, I ~~I ~ lMn ~ ..;~t.>n"lJ ~ <;,tf.AJ~ WIll- f-)/rI !.Il...n ')1le. I',Lolt:ll..1r' 11' .t;O~I'Ie.t.rr~Y l~rPj 11l1? l8.1l'~ w/-nm \.OJJ., GaalOt> VlIflIJU'Mll'Aili '7[b\:l~.1 4. Will the varlonce, If granted, be the minimum varIance that wUI make possible the reasonable Use of the land, buildIng or .tructure ond whIch promote standard. of health, safety or welfare. '{~I 111I2: U~IW~ WIll. ~IU ~ c.lAa:Ir' 11) It::a..1\'""Y ~ ~~ wi 1\fi;. ~\..O. vii ) fru.;az\JI,;['\\!l!l' Ll!.l11l\'~ m<.,,~~ _~IU" \~~ fl?.Df<I1.e1M. II&&: ~ 1I!e I~ w~ ~ lA\\.\~ 11> ~ 1JwJ~ ~ ~ ~~ IJI.JI>{ wI w "F.o.Il~I'" 'RlZ t.LtlI,,11- f~bMf \l~. S. WfII granting the varIance requested confer on Ihe pelltloner ony speclol prIvilege thot 1$ denied by these zonIng regulations to other land., buildIngs, or ,!ructures In Ihe .ame zoning district, NO I 'flit. c.~ l>1l.cwl? ~ ~ ~'71bwt:>n..IH ZOI1l>!J.. 11'MO~J\}Ma:ii'" 4~ 'I' ll.l.U"'ltJbm'D j:>\:>-pu..y 1\}Ia" Q.oUIIb 'I"eI<ru~ 4 i2> t; ~~, _1\\\~ UWIl:.1Jat ~ ~ ~lU! 61zDUlJD tNI/JIUUY\l.~ u.Y>Utb ~ f'btt ~ hl(,d..JI~llWI 1I\1>N 1~1It.-r 11:> NOlWAbLt"l I;.Wmltb "PJY CtfOO., 6. WfII granting the vorlance be In hormony with the Intent and purpose of thl> zonIng code, and not be Inlurlous to Ihe neighborhood, or .otherwise detr/mentol to the public .wer/ore, ~~l ~ ~1Jf.::. 1'l-;:.1\h~ \/b1'Z.tl..1Jt,f;::, ~D()CP l>f'fY....op A- /...OW 1<:Ery,) lZes.lDfatf'i..L ~~IMb . atr~\Y/l~Il)~~<;yt;'ROtIh Jl1tir\bllJ~1:> . ~ 1l,.utblZMO~ . iJ,)}'1lIe lSllh:ri' ~sll:>li;N.Tlb.!- ~~I&Jj-sO~ ~3. IN ~ ~\JrmIJOIJbIJJk b,geb :; 1OO1II'P t;;-AIh.Nt;::!. 1J.h:&.. ee...ro.6J..\'(1l>l.- ftbIJOtZ- nt: ~ .;.1!trr11.\k' ('~.. .. 7. Are there natural condll/on. or physically Induced cond/nons thot ameliorate the goals and obJectIves of the reglJlanon such as nafural preserves, lokes, golf course, efc. i\genda Item No. 170 June 24. 2008 Page 20 of 42 ~hlJ A.-I I~ L.rm.."\l1D 0..J 'SNoI~~' il!tq' 1 t.~6Il- I? ~ ~ ~ ~llJb r?-~ 'Pl1D. toO; 1'.tlL"\Sl1x:sruJl':> lit.( :ilhil ' \\ 'I 11111", ~ 1It1!~ VIl~ '7lbJ A-I nl ~'J'Ui""I:> ?1f:tJ . 8. Will granting the variance be conrlslent with the growth monaeement plan. '/!fIt I ~ ~I!>Ik Of" 1lle 1Ih17.1"""'1P II~ ~111t.I.lde.1)\e ~I.m. ~t:5clr ~ ~'-" If" ~~ 1\.l1;a IllIu. r-.tn.",,",,, WII?"'l""~ , ... '~j..tflfl~ "{D ~ \~ 6.So !l,JJ. ~ N;:: \ h.1~'tJt.m IJ ~ l'If It:1'FMrny ~ 11J1u,. t-lo1'" ~~ ~ll * LbN'Jy",~ It-J ~l\.l'" or: ~X.!:~ t.wfl'ea.. M:: ~ l1'-"'IsOU\.....,~ ",1 ....'l:!hmrt>'b--I '"' . , 1"i2'wrn"IoJf>1t ~\! ~ Il ~l~rv:.::. Agenda Item No. 170 June 24, 2008 Page 21 of 42 ,~i+~~;'~?\rr(::~,~:':{'?'~:i~~:,:~t';i~f;~\;;~ THIS COMPLETED CHECKLIST IS TO BE SUBMITTED WITH APPLICATION PACKET IN THE EXACT ORDER LISTED BELOW W/COVER SHEETS ATTACHED TO EACH SECTION. NOTEIINCOMPLETE SUMBITTALS WILL NOT BE ACCEPTED. REQUIREMENTS #OF NOT COPIES REQUIRED REQUIRED Completed Application 12 Completed OwnerlAgent Affidavit, Notarized 1 Pre-application notes/minutes 12 Surveyor Site Plan of property depleting the 12 following: a) All property boundaries & dimensions b) North arrow, date and scale of drawing c) All existing and proposed signs-(Iabeled as such) d) Existing sign setbacks & proposed sign setbacks Location map depleting major streets in area for 1 reference Fees: Application Fee = $2000.00 Legal Advertising Fee for BCC = $363.00 Legal AdvertIsing Fee for ccpe = $760.00 Checks shall be made payable to: "Co/ljer County Board of County Commiss/oners" As the authorized ngentlnppUesnt for this petition, I attest that all Or the il!CorDlatjon indicated On this checklist Is included In this submittal paclmge. I understand tbat failure to include ail necessary submiltlll inConnatio ay resnlt in the lay of process tbis petition. /'. Appllcant/Agenl Signature ...... "z/1/.?8... J ale Agenda Item No. 17D June 24. 2008 Page 22 of 42 COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT ADDRESSING DEPARTMENT (i) 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAF'LE,S, FLORIDA 34104 ADDRESSING CHEc;KLIST Please complete the following and fax to the Addressing Department et 238-659-5724 or submit In' perscm to the Addressing Department at the above address. FOlTll must be signed by Addressing personnel prior to pre'appUcation meellng. Not all Items wUl apply 10 every project. Items In bold type are required. Forms older than 6 months will require additional review and approval by the Addressing Department. PETITION TYPE (check petition type below, complete a separate Addressing Check/1st for: each Petition Type) o BL (8lasUng Peonn) o BD (Boat DOCK ExIenslon) o CU (Condillonal Use) o EX? (Excavallon Pennn) o FP (FInal Plat . o LLA (Lot Line Adjustment) o pNC (project Name Change) o ppL (plans & Plat Review) o PSP (preliminary Subdivision Pial) o pUD Rezone o RZ (standard Rezone) o SOP (Site Development Plan) o SDpA (SOP Amendment) o SOl'I O~~ubslanllal Change to SOP) o SIP (Sltlflmprovemenl Plan) o SIl'l (lnsubslarrtlal Change to SIP) o SNR (Street Name Change) o SNC (Straet Name Change - Unplatted) o TOR (Transfer of Development Rights) o VA: (Variance) o VRP. (Vagetatlon Removel Perml\) il VRSFp (Vegetation Removal & sne 1'11I Pennl!) 1i2I" OTHER l?\lN~ LEGAL DESCRIPTION of subjecl property or properties (co ~ of lengthy description may be attached) G ~ ~~l- ":\? \(:\ 0T A FOLIO (Property 10) NUMBER{s) of abova (attach to, or associate with, legal description if more than one) ~J-\.~ <.oq;S ~('\a(:) STREET ADDRESS or ADDRESSES (as applicable, If already assigned) LOCATION MAP must be aflaohed showing exact locatIon of project/sne In relation to nearest public road right-of-way SURVEY (copy - needed only for unplalled properties) PROPOSED PROJECT NAME (If applicable) PROPOSED STREET NAMES (If applicable) SITE DEVELOPMENT PLAN NUMBER (for exisling proJer:tslsTtes only) SDp 2CO.."="j - or AR # l.\-l ct a... . -Page1 of2 Agenda Item No. 17D June 24, 2008 Page 23 of 42 ADDRESSING CHECKLIST - Page 2 Project or development names proposed for, or already appearing In. condominium documenls (If appliOllUon; Indicate whether proposed or exIsting) Please Check One: o Checldlst Is to be Faxed back ~ersonany Picked Up APPLICANT NAME: PHONE: t;l,1i'-l- 6r~~~1 FAX: ~l(- ~/t/- 116IJ2 Signature on Addressing CheCklist does not oonstltute Project and/or Street Name approval and is subject to further review by the Addressing Department. FOR STAFF USE ONLY Pr!mary Number n.-b2l9?lj (') Address Number "3 "'f'i1? ()6 Address Numbar iO"eS,?C'l c:; Address Number APprovedbCsJ4HAA p ~p Updated by: Dale: \ - lO ...o~ Date: IF OLDER THAN 6 MONTHS, FORM MUST BE UPDATED OR NEW FORM SUBMITTED Page20f 2 Agenda Item No. 170 June 24,2008 Page 24 of 42 ?UNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE ,)NING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 "OV.~J (i) "'" ,,,.- 'AX 'D. ........ ~~~ ~,,~ ~ VARI:~~E PETITION \J II '" IfIJ ~ ~ ?:1ib'O I \l'l"t€. O}\~. (j{'a . PRE-APPLICATION MEETING NOTES '\ ,- & SUBMITTAL CHECKLIST Date..hJ12i:f2 Tlmei J\ '.(JO C' Prolect Name. ltJLh b1~ 66~/- ~IS - etJ~ ~k1~t ~~R~ bJ~~?/~ ~(f1 /<:NbU- wa.?. j)Plfle. A/VJ:l;pSIJ!J S'c iaJ "~Ov}'. ..e~ZJ Phone, ,. Prolect Addr/Locallom Applicant Name. r9uia.t tAJ &;f1I:>Jf;. / FI,mi~~":\ Current Zoning. I viti Owner Name. Owner Address: Phone, Meeling Attendees: (attach Sign In Sheet) NOTES. \ . Q., ~ ~~ J {):/o- ~.p! 0, 1 .;,; Agenda Item No. 170 June 24, 2008 Page 25 of 42 .. . .",:.. SIGN"VAin/.N.CE PS1'1'ION (Sv)A1>:i>"UC;,tfQN : . SI,it!MltJ'~~G;REll;I(Ysj . THIS COMPLETED CHECKLIST IS TO BE SUBMITTED WITH APPLICATION PACKET IN THE EXACT t1RDER LISTED BELOW WjCOVER SHEETS ATTACHED TO EACH SECTION. NOTE, INCOMPLETE SUMBITTALS WILL NOT BE ACCEPTED, #OF NOT . REQUIREMENTS A COPIES REQUIRED REQUIRED Comaleted As>allcallan (download from webs/Ie for currenl form n... Pre-A""llcallan meeJln" notes It.:.:: '1.2. "- Com"leted Addresslna Checklist 51aned by Addresslno De"ortmenl I , 5"rveyar 511e Plan of properly depicting Ihe followIng. ';;><\ ~"M. ~ All property boundarIes & dimensions X ~ North arrow, dole and scale of drawing ~ All exl,llng and proposed signs (labeled as such) ~ Exlsflng sIgn setbacks and proposed sIgn setbacks Owner/Agent Affidavit signed & notorlzed t ^ locallon mop depIcting molar streets In areo for referenc.. t X ~ ,K.I Pre-application Fee $500.00 (Applications submlHed 9 monlhs or more after Ih. dale oflhe lasl pr.....pp meellng shall no! be credited towards appllcalion fees and a new pre-applicaJlon meeting will be req"lred,) . RevIew Fees, ~ .$2000,00 SIgn Variance i After-The-Poet Zonlng/Lond Use Petlllons 2x Ihe normal petition fee $760.00 Esllmated Legal AdvertIsIng Pee - CCPC MeeJlng $363,00 EstImated Legal AdvertisIng Fee - BCC Meellng (any over. or under-poyment will be reconciled upon receIpt of Invoice from Naples Dally News), OTHER REQUIREMENTS, o o n Agent/Owner Signature Date * ~Olt.~. ~\ICOJYlt V\tLb ~'2,~(7h,~ N21o/lw ~lAf1f.l~ w 81Al&1vv1T s e1fl~ ~ oj %~_. t~. . 2 OCON ~g::: NO o -u;:-, Z~N :::: Q) m, I' ii) r- '-J11". ., .., =3~'i~~ ., CO -, :-. " .. ~ .. '. ~ ,.:-. '.:~" <t: \ ""'bl ,~ :~ .:.; 1.=:. ';'" .. . I ;'.;',. ':' ,_ 1 ,",'. ::~ : l;' ~: ~~ .... " .... !.\r;:.:~. ..' :.~ i. ,~ !" .!,: 1-'" .:.1:;::"1, : ,Ii i1 '. ~ :.."~'~: . ".,.. ~ . ':;"'~~ ~r'~ ,~!;;X ~...,..,., ';':.::. !:~,};!t:~.i;';;j . , -:.. ('; 1~' t":~. - !~,~. i;~;~,J:: ~: ,. , f ';" i .'~. "::.~.~' -' . ~ ~ T~;~;~~'~ , I!I Z ;:: w w ::e ... o w . ~ Q w ~ Z I- U ., q~ ~ l - r: III E lZ. o Gi ii Q "D C D ... 011 Dl l: 'c o N ... o - C III .E h D n. III Q .<: u D =ti l: :3 t!l u l: t:I Z ~ W Z Z <( ... a.. Q w Z l!) Vi tIl <( - III r: '> o u r: 1:1 r: ., ~ .. "t:I ~ ~ == ! ::1 . : 2: '. W. il!:l' 0:".1 te",. .. ~/ :: ~ ~ j" Ii I,' 'f ~ .; ~:,', 'I ;.1 ,': j.,,'" ~ -. z Q:iE iiii2 ~ii: is .. ~ cO 2::',,', 8/ ::a .. o (0 q ~ lXI ~ I M o ~ M C'I .. III ..l:l E :) Z III r: 1:1 ~ c;: :.' ::.i- '. .... ..- .. ~ ;;:; '.' ~ ~ ~ r '5j '" ~ " ~ 10 9. ... '5 lD '6 c " (!l i'r ia z , Ii:i w J: '" l!:: z CI ~ c " E ~ a i2 " c " (!l '" u. ., Agenda Item No. 17D . June 24. 2008 Page 27 of 42 AFFIDA vir We/I, l.try,lbtiql\1\h['lL?lbl+LLC. being "flt duly sworn, depose and say that we/I am/are the owners of the properly desalbed herein and which Is Ihe .sub;ect matler of the proposed hearing; that all the answers to the queslions In this applicallon, indudlng the disclosure of Interest information, all sketches, data, and olher supplementary mailer allochad to and made a pari of this applicaflon, are honest and !rue to the best of our knowledge and belief. We/I understand thaI the Informal/on requesled on Ihls applica/ion must be complete and accurate and Ihal #he eonlent of Ihls form, whelher compuler generaled or Counly printed shaH not be altered. Public hearings will not be advertised until this application is deemed complete, and all required Information has been submitted. As properly owner We/I fur/her aulhorlze t1u;v 1I"~,'Dl!1oJ ,/~...:" ~ '! ~. 10 oct as our/my representalive I y moilers regarding Ihls Petition, Slgnalure 0 roperly Owner Larry Bern id.,Y P Signature of Properly Owner Wcql\:'ritjl1+\/arderl::i!\tU.c 0. Delo.ware . \irni~ I. obi 1\'\;\con:f?3r!~' ~Il Wcdloril1V1t \farderbi H ___ M~IY\ \::er Ll.C, a: Flan8;) llrni:rea I lObi 1;+-!-<s::':vr1jX1o'l, i+';iV'Kl.~\n'jMeW\l::ey- Typed or Printed Name of Owner Typed or Printed Name of Owner inslrumenl was acknowledged before me fhis J ~h day of .~~ . 200~ . by . 'Y\I vi who Is personally known 10 me or has produced as Identiflcalion. Slate of Florida County of Collier ~cj/ ture of Notary pili, . Stale of Florldo) ,'y"', T L R .#' p~ racy . osarlo ~: ,hit ~E Commission # OD292932 ~<l;~ of Expires June 23, 2008 :fr.~'8inledTIII)'FIlD.~/IlI:.QQQ..U$.1Q111 --rr-uGvJ L-VUJ '2>CU10 (Print, Type, or SIamp Commissioned Name of Notary Public) @ Agenda Item No. 17D June 24, 2008 Page 28 of 42 The Collection at Vanderbilt GROUND MONUMENT DISPLAY VARIANCE APPLICA nON EXHIBITS APPLICANT ..t. WOOLBRIGHT ~ DEVELOPMENT INC 3200 NORTH MILITARY TRAil. 4TH FlDOR BOCA RATON. FlORICl/\ 33431 5619B9-1950 AGENT '\ - - ''l\\'" - ,-:.. 1 -.' 'i: ;r: Environmental Graphic Design: Glen Welden & Associates, LLC 349 Knollwood Drive Andenon SC 29625 864-353-8026 DesignGWA@aol,com TABLE OF CONTENTS _Page CV-l Typical example of monument walls for locations A, B & C depicting halo-lit reverse channel letter identity statement and non-illuminated decorative "wrought" iron logo element. _Page CV-2 Fabrication and installation details by licensed sign manufacturer of identity lettering with all vertical and horizontal size specifications depicted. Plan view of CBS wall shows identity placement. I Pages CV -3 through CV -5 Enlarged depictions site plan with placement of identity statement walls shown I Page CV -6 Overall Site Plan with locations A, B & C shown including dimensions of separation, measured in feet, between each subject location. Bank Property shown in Blue Outline. Footage shown in Red The Collection at Vanderbilt .". ...... u .- .____.'________..._.__.__..._. __'."__ _..... _'''_'_'''_'''"''U_~__^''______~______.._.___._~~_.___.___ GROUND MONUMENT DISPLA Y VARIANCE APPLICATION EXHIBITS Agenda Item No. 170 June 24, 2008 Page 29 of 42 ~iJ)<1J:.'~~~!I:l_~..~ rl~~~~~~r.'.~_~~____.,__ tl.'MI1.\,'''f"''l'''lIh...,n''':''I'l'h',lt,,,,,, jnl<.,....1 ,lJmnj,..,ti,,,,,-,,,,,, "..i...IHl "~np.."...,,,, f~' "I'I'li,~I'kl I."fl<-' 1").\"I"""ll>t"''''''''lonj'h"t,,-hll''l1o.1Ik ;; . .1"." t..lot',~I\.',I.,I"r"""uT\ .'h~",,,'ll'''I<"'' "nl. l~.'I,~.... ..,..i ",;n ,...; ,.".."" '.\11 ",'I.l<~1 """"U""\"",'h""Th"I''''f'r'''"i,'di~h.t''J.\'','II'''''1 1.",-...111"110"' Lh"".".ltn,'II,,,,,II"''''''kh\l..\I'~IJ'1,(,].\: Ill..,.. 'j h.."",-Jdq"h".... h.. ,,"..Jl..tt...' I l-Jlii.h"",,,..,, 14 !~,Io" ,,,,,.t..,,,,,, AI'-"o',,;,"'1 ~ I"" k11o:, fI!,;_'2~!!:i~ LED Reverse Channel Letter IE ~~!!~!1S.~EP;~~E~~~..._~.___ 21'-2" -., [ /h',':' :~;i<;:',_ 4;{::'1_,, ~ c, ':"",w i :"'''',',:,::'.:- ':""o,L':);:""". ";."" 3'-3" ..--/. 1f:_ntr_'!.~<:~l'i.!J!1J:VaIL EI5:vatio~_[,!!...Locatio~s A. B & C ~C:\LE; A~ SHl'\X':'-J u".", ...t. WOOLBRIGHT ~ DfV[LOPMfNT INe llOONOltTH ,""UTUT TlIAIl_ 'rH~loo. aQC.t.AA.TQN IlOM)A,U.11 \.6,"'-'1tSO Ii , ' f,,' . . . [!WIT,.nlln:nta[ l ir:tr!u(' Il~""i~ll: : 1'1>- \"'1"; Glen Welden & Associates, LLC HI{ ,~'.. \-1" t-..ll"n...",J 1."1",' " .\11 \~ "'.1 "l" '\,~b~"" '!'t.'2~2\ ..f>-!.HI_""JIi th,,,,~,,\.\~...,,,,,, l~~,~1 I' i L. j The Collection at Vanderbilt GROUND MONUMENT DISPLAY VARIANCE APPLICATION EXHIBITS .l\genda !tsm No. 170 June 24. 2008 r'i::lge Ju 01 'fL 10'-0" 1'-10" 2'-6" 1'-1 % 3'-6" 0.1 LETTERS DETAIL SCALE: W' - ".()" COPY SQ FT. 44.2 ,TRANSFORMERS WIRING ALUM. i COVER PAINTED TO MATCH WAlL .....'-- _._-~ - 1'--' -- PlAN VIEW @:'AN VIFW N.T-S. INDIVIDUAL REVERSE LED CHANNEL LETTER """",--....-.. ~ <D v.- ALUM. FLAT CUT OUT PIN MOUNTEO \'\" OFF. BLACK FINISH. @ ILLUMINATED REVERSE LED CHANNEL LETTERS. 1ft @ ~L~::~~,~R~F rllANNFt ~'rTlrtN """"',... OIl(I'lcrrf)tlll\'Pl$fUTow.oft(fTTlJISWllIjl.Eo.U_~ ~lJ[~ Ml TDfIP:DU~IIElIIMWEUlEDm,lr.l. A/.l&\IIUIIFAClFNSHILWt WSlllllFc-.m.SPIIAl'Hl_. loG ~IUD MJ ~UNll.fllMCfMflSOHua::llFOWINEl ~ tmIlCOINC'f~lIE1MlHlEllllllOCllAn IlII Ill'lI\'Ol.I!L.f.D.MM1l~Y_ .. PVtSMCflII;MIllIolClllNJ'IrIG;IWIlIWME 1m F'.VOUfOIlGUASIIfl:UIlfD ... CUAIl~l:lJ'I 1M ClIMl),l.WMlf.NClMIIrwrffl'llTOMAJOlWAUCllI.llII "'10 lOI.~TrwnClt Mil J.tllXIS_lZOvrowtJl;lYo.TtPS @ _...~ ~- . . -.' - SlGNMUSTIlfOflOUNDm 0NI'1l12llAW. ...CQMlIIt.JAHaWlfH IXlYOlT AI!TlCl..EIOOOJl14E ClM:U!TOEDlC...no _M'f1OfUolELECT1llCCOOl'; fDll1GNONl.Y ATVANPERij, . 3 N,~ . CURVED MASONIII'SIGN lit OlHERS OMDINAll>>ol1 DIMWN: 1CAl.I., ~1"2ClO7 ....NOTED .......NMCll't: __.." .....- "-""- .......~ _~ft: Q7Sa.11 A2 tZJtMf II~.JII/J~~~.bl ,.." CNML IT~ LAROO. fL 11777 ...... rmJ M1oII7I fAX In,) 144-1741 WWWJNTUlNATIOtMI.IIGtlCOM BACK COVER. -- / nP.A1ll1NG, 1.'An.110M'1 CY,2 :"(:.-\U."SSlI(l\l;'N RI'.VIS10N The Collection at Vanderbilt GROUND MONUMENT DISPLAY VARIANCE APPUCA TION EXHIBITS Agenda Item No. 170 June 24 2008 Page 31 of 42 - - - - - - T .. I ~ .. .. VANDeiSilT'SE'ACH RQN) I ~ -- ~ "" ". Own" ....t. WOOLBRIGHT ~ DEVELOPMENT INC UOONORTH HlUTAltY T1IM... 4TH fl.OOll. IOCAJlATON,FJ..OlllC>>,J14Jl S61.....'9S0 LOCATION A N SIGN A-1 (located 00 ."'. Property* SIGNA-2 W j/ ~ E S I LOCATION A) Environmental Graphic Design: Glen Welden & Associates, LLC J19 Knuliwood Drive Anden.:on, SC 296Z~ !\61.JS3-80Z6 ~"(;WA-.u..... DP.A~lNO: PATE: l1.oMl1 CV,3 SI::AU,.",SSHo:'WN n\.'l'dON The Collection at Vanderbilt GROUND MONUMENT DISPLAY VARIANCE APPUCA TION EXHIBITS Agenda Item No, 170 June 24, 2008 I-'age J.i. OT 4L LOCATION B SIGN B-1 B-2 1-1- ;::J I .1A1I' /~nlll'I-C!:} JI , ........ ! 1111111 11111 III v1" ') Ill!} r 11 . I ,< > " 11\ ~I . ':~~rJ:;" l I . ! .18 ~.. I :W:::1ION r ~ I~ ".... I \,'- .~) .I. t-:: ,I ~";~ ~"<..t ~y'(")<,,X ><'V Q<X ><x 1 .' ,~ , 'X.",Y. ~:u F-'X).: /v -:.::::::: ~." xv, >)< I' :X~~' , )(l)( lJ{ ,~ y x 'X, >i-:;.<)'.x ,'X..., 'v I '."" :x ~I>(XX)<_,'*~~ ''>I >!r:>.,l'xx"\' , . A 0xI>..Xxx;x >< X;l-< >.x X X I" 1. X lX~~-"" 'v 0. :.)< ~~v I ,7'Y. II( X ':'xX ''XX x")<x~ I"" )(y ~ /y \ ~ .J<,i. r,t' ,'~xx xX""1h{ Y IY X K; /~ 0J 1,;><. x...'<x"x":'>Y~.)<' x~ )( 0 r1 ~ x ,( 'T X '<x v."< J. )('?<Z' )( bO Y '>!'!:,lY y' Y ,/ X rx: I ".... x)<x;,( f~~v' X ~ ~~ '1 hV ~ 1 ill .":'f~,)( V x:.%..t<x )<~~. W,/ X >()( X t"x \ I I " ~ xxX..;!- t ~ YJ<\G~'I(l.S< >Q< I~I " !, :~ ~ x : ~ ~.'X h xXy'<.l.Kt-'<x" X x~ I ~~',:~ 'I: ,^, V X\-l: X X X XxXIX: X X >',^ I ,_---:: I' - -- ..........,.. -' , I LOCATION B) Oien" . ~~o~~~~~~T J20lI NOIl.TH I1UTA,RT TIVolL 4TH fl.OOII ~ItATON.FL.OllII;>>.nUl UI..,.t~ Envinmmenral Graphic Design: Glen Welden & Associates, LLC J19Kn..J1I"",,-.:IDrive ~3~~l~~~WA"""~""" SIGN \\ ~ ',/ \ ,/ Q ~ 0:: I (!) ~ .... :5 ll.. '" f.!- 0:: 0 '" ~ [,.. '<( lr ../ ,/ ^ ^ / , ^ 1,... / " N *cI Wj/~E S ~ 11flA\l1Nfi; PA1:E,IH.'If>,.('I1 CY,4 ~AU;"'~~~O\l'N IlE\1SkJN The Collection at Vanderbilt GROUND MONUMENT DISPLAY VARIANCE APPLICATION EXHIBITS Agenda Item No, 170 June 24, 2008 r-dSjt:..),) VI <-tL LOCATION C SIGN C-1 J(C~:~:R-dA ~ \ IV j , ~~JI!l' -..... ~ ;,~"_ _ ~ ~~ G~LLERIA ~R~~ - .,. / ...-- ! I ~..r ) I ., ~ BVIlr"Il <<XJ ... WATERJIA/H I LOCATION C) I -~ ~ W~E S Own" ....t. WOOLBRIGHT ~ DEVElOP'HENT IHe )'1llONOI(1'JoII'tUTMYT1lAl..4THfLDOfl, BOCt.RATON.f~J"J. 561""1f$ll ill - , ~ " Environmental Graphic Design: Glen Welden & Associates, lle .H9 Kn..II....nJ OJi\..: An.kDllll, SC 196Z' 86i-JSJ-BOl6 ~W"'-.L'"'''' llRAWING, ['A~ IliC\6,C, v's SCALE,A.~~ !lfVlSlllN The Collection at Vanderbilt GROUND MONUMENT DISPLAY VARIANCE APPLICATION EXHIBITS Agenda Item No, 170 June 24, 2008 rdYt,;; 0";' VI '-t.!. - -,,--- L......-..-. l,,~"':f..! ~~! L'- . .~>~.":,.-: ";..J' :: ii i I ii, \ ~ \ I ),' I ,I, :1 I I : I :~Ii I; I' I' , : I , , , i ! LI ' , ",~....'i'f' ,II" " :' ,:X'_ -. . -. ,,-- ~ I =___.L, --l: ' , ' I \'~ ...-J .' l--L. _i ' .il --;--,. " i:_ ~ --L. . '.... -_.~,-=--~~~ ". i _,......~ --; II ~~t.,. '~ ' --- - -.... -'.. ~. ~- :7: . "..':: __ .....__~... _ _.....,-----.,.:5: _k~ LOCATIONA ~~-------~~-==- i SIGN A-1 (located on Bank Property) SIGN A-2 ~~""==<:::"'oo,.-~~",,,,~:.:.....~..!:.~...._y II IOVERALL SITE PLAN SC"'LL-\S'iH\l\l'N Oien', . ~~o~~~~~~T nooNOltTH MlUTAA'I'TJWL4TH Ft.00ll. &OCA.MTON.'l.OJllIJo\U4)1 UI.....t9S0 Envinmmental Graphil: Dcsilln: Glen Welden & Associates, LLC H91(nlJUwIlud Drivl' AnJm..n. sc lW.l~ liM-151-8016 o...i~WA""""'''''' LOCATION C SIGN C-l 705' between Sign C-l and Sign B-1 775' between Sign C-1 And Sign B-2 LOCATION B SIGN 8-1 SIGN 8-2 70' 70' between Sign B-1 and Sign B-2 29\l' I , \,. c:1 ~==ti N " Wj/~E S fill.AWlNO 1v..1E- 1'_\"',~1 CV,7 Sl.":AU.k;:'>l-tl."1'&'N 1lE\1SJ<lN aCON ~ ,-0,", ~ ~~ ~ . n.~~O g Co o > ~~ ::> ~! ~-I..O Z ::> m l1.~ .NO") 3r\lHC NQilllBU WQ i :::mQ.l mcOl !::!;( ::::::;)rf. ",0 ~ ro' 9 " ."NY<> ."NY<> iii {~S: 1lO) OVOll rnm1ncl- illOdHtY (l.to<r:l) avo~ f>Hmnd-illOdNi'l' a.. en <( <( ~ ~ o. ::>~ " l1. " C~ ~ (!) ir~ z ~ - ~ . Z g~ 0 ~ l1. ~ N " I I.l." o~ C .~ '" ::>" ..,. l1.~ '" N - '" < , '" 0 0 JlI':J&O.!..ulN / N - Z- > CJl 'It I~ . ! , z i, i, IK. h. ! 0 II " llJii ~ ii !l ' i, f- l- , -, f- I II I '; w I c.. lI.-lIJ.V.l.Wh/II 1m01.IiI.IIIlIX>".OXI8OOOMllll3lW:l ll.I.-aLV.!JRaUI J~ ilK jig !_ a.. . ilK > i~ <( t)z II wQ ~ ,!:< ~o ..g ~ -I ill IK z ! 0 I III .~i I II - I- - <( 0 0 0 ....J ,. Of\OlI'f'Oli~3rm'Ollt' \ ,. . . I! t~'vnl "1I'AI1'-.l . \6..,','..., ,'. ..,., , ".' THE FOUNDAI.'ION OF .lP'EUCAN IVIARSH, K;'ic. . . .;" ..;~ . . :, ' .~' 1504 Pelican !vlars!z fJoulel'ard ,',.~ ~; II' "'~. Naples, FL 34109 "'""'.:.,:":"':'/' (239) 594-7800. Fax (239) 594-1811 Aaenda Item No. ~17D ~ June 24, 2008 Page 36 of 42 May 14,2008 Woolbright Dcvelopment Corp, 3200 N, Military Trail, Fourth 1']001' Boea Raton, Florida 3343] Re: Approval of Ground Monument Signage and Sign Variances from Collicr County Code Dear Mr, Troxell, The Foundation ofPeliean Marsh, lne, Design Review Committce recommended to The foundation of Pelican Marsh, Ine, Board of Directors APPROVAL of your request for five (5) ground monument signs at three (3) separate entraneeways within The Collection at Vanderbill. At a duly noticed meeting on Tuesday, May] 3,2008 at 7:00 PM held at TIle Pelican Marsh Community Center, 1504 Pelican ]\'Iarsh Blvd" Naples, florida 34109, The Foundation ofPeliean Marsh, Ine, Board of Directors voted 7/0 in favor of approval of five (5) requested height, distance. and number of grand monument sign variances at three (3) separate locations within "The Collection at Vanderbilt", The Dcsign Rcview Committee and The Board of Directors is b'rateful to and commends Woolbright Dcvelopmcnt Inc, for working with our Design Rcview Committee in continuing our theme of wound monument signagc throughout Thc Pelican 1I'larsh Community, For any additional inf()rmation or supporting documentation, pleasc contact our Foundation Manager, Jim Clancy, Again, thank you for your consideration and coopcration in this mailer. Sincercly, I /(((1 };;) .I " Bill Rapps, Chairperson The Foundation of Pc Ii can Mnrsh, lnc, Design Review Commitlec " 'I" "I Cc: Agcnll'or Woolhright Developmcnt Glen \Velden & Associates 349 Knoll Wood Dr. Anderson, SC 29626 Roeco Tamburro, MD President Agenda Item No, 170 June 24, 2008 Page 37 of 42 RESOLUTlON NO, 08-_ A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF ZONJNG APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, RELATJNG TO PETITION NUMBER SV.2008-AR-12943, GRANTING SIX VARIANCES FROM SECTION 5,06,04, OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, CONCERNING THE SEPARATION OF SIGNS, THE NUMBER OF SIGNS ALONG A STREET FRONTAGE, THE NUMBER OF SIGNS ON A PARCEL, AND THE SIZE OF AN OFF-SITE PREMISES DIRECTIONAL SIGN ON PROPERTY HEREINAFTER DESCRIBED IN SECTION 35, TOWNSHIP 48 sourn, RANGE 25 EAST, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, WHEREAS, the Legislature of the State of Florida in Chapter 125, Florida Statutes, has conferred on an counties in Florida the power to establish, coordinate and enforce zoning and . such business regulations as are necessary fDr the protection of the public; and WHEREAS, the County pursuant thereto has adopted a Land Development Code (LDC) (Ordinance No, 04-41, as amended) which establishes regulations for the zoning of particular geographic divisions of the County, among which is the granting of variances; and WHEREAS, Petitioner wishes to ereet five identical pole signs as depicted in Exhibit A. Two ofthe signs will be located at the Vanderbilt Beach Road (CR 862) development entrance, one of which will be an off-premises directional sign, Two of the signs will be located at the Airport Road (CR 3]) development entrance. One sign will be located at the southwest comer of Galleria Drive and Airport Road; and WHEREAS, Petitioner wishes to seek three (3) variances from LDC Section 5,06,04 C.l., which requires a minimum separation of 1,000 lineal feet between signs to allow Jess separation between signs as fonows: 70:1: feet between sign B-] and B-2, 705::1:: feet between sign C-l and B-1. and 775::1: feet benvcen sign C-l and B-2, as s.hown in Exhibit A; and WHEREAS, Petitioner wishes to seek a fourth variance from Collier County LDC Section 5.06.04 C.l.. which allows a maxitnum of two pole signs per street frontage to allow three signs along a street frolltage alo~g Airport Road (CR 31); and VlHEREAS, Petitioner wishes to seek a fifth variance from LDC Section 5.06.04.C.l6.b.i., which requires an off-premise directional sign to be no more than twelve (12) square feet in area to allow a sign that is 76::1: square feet in area; and \VHEREAS, Petitioner wishes to seek a sixth variance from LDe Section 5.06.04.C.16.b.ii., which requires an off-premise directional sign to be. no more than eight (8) feet in height to allow a sign that is 9'-4" in height; and Page t of2 Agenda Item No. 'i 7D June 24, 2008 Page 38 of 42 WHEREAS, the Board of Zoning Appeals has held a public hearing with due notice 'Uade, and ha.s con~idered the advisability of granting these v~lIiances; and "WHEREAS I the Board has found as a matter of fact that satisfactory provision and arrangement have been made concerning all applicable matters required by the Land Development Code; and WHEREAS, all interested parties have been given opportunity to be heard by this Board in public meeting assembled and the Board having considered all matters presented. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF ZONING AJ>PEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that the Board herehy approves a variance fi'om LDC 5,06,04,C,1, 5,06,04,C,l6,b,i, and 5,06,04.C,16,b.ii., including a distance of 70", feet between sign B-1 and B-2, 705:1: feet between sign C~I and B-I, and 775f: feet between sign eMl and B-2 as shown in Exhibit A. The Board also approves three signs along Airport Road as shown in Exhibit A, an approximately 76" square foot, 9'-4" height off-premises sign (sign A-I) as depicted in Exhibit B, as requested in Petition SV-2008-AR-12943, filed by Glen Weldon of Glen Weldon and Associates, LLC, of Anderson South Carolina concerning the suhject property described in Exhib~t C. All signs sball be subject to the conditions set forth in Exhibit D, BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Resolution relating to Petition Numher SV- 2008~1\R-12943 be recorded in the minutes of this Board. This Resolution adopted after motion, second and majority vote, this ___ day of ,2008. ATTEST: DWIGHT E, IlROCK, Clerk 1l0ARD OF ZONING APPEALS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA By: , Deputy Clerk By: TOM HENNING, CHAIRMAN Approved as to form and legal sufficiency: ~ Exhibits (attached): A. Il, C. D, Overall Site Plan Entrance Sign Wall Elevation for Locations A, Band C Legal Description Conditions of Approval Pagc2of2 The Collection at Vanderbilt GROUND MONUMENT DISPLAY V ARIANCE APPLICATION EXHIBITS EXHIBIT "A" Agenda Item No. 170 June 24, 2008 Page 39 of 42 ( ,,_ ~ I i....".J~ 1'\\ : '--....r) I~ .~,,_. 1 l '(I~\~'''HI,\..t''\I!f L-...;~__... _ ---'-=-~"""'-~::.""-..-.~.._......-r._ , '" ~ -.~it-~~'J'--""i"I'~J;.di.l!i:::"~ - ~:;;, :i;:-::: __~-:"~:'-' ~- -- --'~"~~~~._.,...._~t ~~#iJfk~~rc -;, :~_.~-:-- )F~~:4(:~:--'"'~::"'~'~ ,~.. ....,--=-'c.. - ,,--.., .' , ,-~ i 1'Jld "J J),lI "r-l S:(I lnr, \ ;:;:~)J ! " ,~:/ i, -"1_ .... If i , 1;---J'~~L \ 'I "111, =-f' ffi\~,V~i \ I -Al:: I \ ' 11 ,t ,,- " --..- /j"\ -- ,':'::;-'-:Ii ' . _-J} I;;)' ~::.~-:;--::~~\ . )l ..... :: ~ - " ') .ii)r-"r'r' J:! '>' , " ---1 LOCATION C SIGNC-1 -"" <<_u 705' between Sign C,1 and Sign B-1 775' between SIgn C-1 And Sign B-2 LOCATION B SIGN B-1 SIGN B-2 70' 70' between Sign B-1 and Sign B-2 29P' \ "- --.~ ...--..1_;) ,\ ::':'_)"-::-"...L=:::...::::}::...:::::::-=,=-,J' ~ ........r.,~~i"..~'=....~ . ""~-=,,",,'.i.'---"""""""'------'-"'" "--=.Ol"==~""""=""'''''' '.. , __'::-.._': ' --------'\r-r;c-I '_"__"~' ". 1 Ilil t '~ 1 _.-1';-11" sr.::e:.- ,t'1 -.- _.~. -~::;:..-:'i.~~::92=l .....d-.........._...~~_~.......~-.:..;,~~.::::.~....~3-....... LOCATION A ~~_--=-==~C'=- SIGN A-1 (located on BRnk Propc"y) ~J .\~-;:~.-.i ""...~ 0 :,.:.~.=.~__ ~=~~""""""""__ 5L:"'U:,M~IIOI\'N N *c:/ Wj/~E S OVERALL SITE PLAN CIi'n" 9/'~">WOOLBRIGHT ,;/ DEVELOPt1EiNT lNC '/ nIlONOll.lIiMl1JTAAYTfVo.IL~THFlOl:lk Boo.AATON.FlOll;),l,lHll >>19i9.l'SO Environmental Gmphk Dl:':sigm Glen Welden & Associate" LLC H9Knollll~....IDr1\'e ~tJr~8b~6l%~BnCW^~ol.,"m l'l/l"WI!oItil 11.h1," lH"~'l CV,7 5~:A~'~'~1<11O\\'J..I l\Ii'1~lo.'l< The' Collection at Vanderbilt EXHIBIT "B" _~.' _~.~~__~_,_~,:.,~,.,~,__,___"""_~O'_""_~~_"'~_'_'~.'~,~~'~.,.~,",._<..~ _"".,w",~___~,_~_",,'~_,",. ~~,~,^__,_a"'_~,~ GROUND MONUMENT DISPLAY VARIANCE APPLICA TlON EXHIBITS Aaenda Item No, 170 o June 24, 2008 ,'"_..._.. P...agaAD"af ,42.....,_ 'CnDnneldeptllmil}'Ul-$Jl'I!llc-rforL[jOfabTicatioll 3.5n.de.eprabrlcllledalumlnumchannelleIlCnI wilh .090 faCelIllnd mill. .061l1!t..ms. "All welded CllIllltructioll with weep haleB provided (<'IveraKeof two) forClll:hleltet. GlOOll eoamel fjnl.iih to match MAP MP 30132. Black f~: IJ!!y_:LiIDe Al:lI',,_a!!!f!.~_..__ LJ. .l<~.., .. \ '1 i __ _.1 ,..__ ,,;LIsom..~_t!'is..L,!:'~QJ{e:::~~ ChE.1'll2e~,.Letter__,,_. "2 Evening..AI'~'!f!!!',C~.__ 21'-2" 3'.3" Dj~~onal.2SQ'" lhlck cornpull!r cutalu ~:7I)ughr_ wlIrk., pin mllUl'\led [rOrnC~; MnDuflichHeu I!Ilwnlnurn revetSechanrwl ~~I_l~11m(8nd ~ AT V ANDI!RIlILT"'wttl1 eri\l,a~ t,oal101:vforUm hg~\~.: "'"~ ~ '-.' ~ ;,:...." '. ' '';C',:,.,' -,'.' s,~:,'a:.;':2.~-:,:j:,~~ , 'lF~10 %11. , -; ATVANDERBIET ,J 10'; '\,---,...._, ;?~(").::~:~;. ",'e" ,:' '/i Entran_~e Sign Wall Elevation for Locations A, B..~_<;;__,_._ SCALE, AS SHOW"' Chen" .""'~'/WOOLBRIGHT ." DEVELOPMENT INC ," / )lOONO~THMJUTARYTRIIlL.~THFlOOR WCARATo,"l,FLOIUD..,lHll S~I9S9_I~SG J ..' ~~~n~;~e('~t~:S~~;atcs, LLC 1 ::'~:m ~CV 1 349 Knollwood Dove SCAI f ASSHQWN ~ AndeulIlI SCZ9625 ~64.3jJ 8026 D<:s'gnG\"'^,,~.nl,..,m REVlSJON, --------.-J EXHIBIT "e" THE COLLECTION AT V ANDERBIL T LEGAL DESCRIPTION Parcel I: Tract A, Galleria Vanderbilt Phase One, according to the plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 32, pages 88 through 90, inclusive, Public Records cfeollier County, Florida. Parcel II: All that part of Section 35, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida and being more particularly described as follows: Commencing at the Southeast comer of said Section 35; thence along the South line of said Section 35, South 89 degrees 38 minutes 54 seconds West 100,00 feet to a point on the West right-of-way line of Airport-Pulling Road (CR3I); thence continuing along said section line, South 89 degrees 38 minutef:l54 seconds West 771.70 feet; thence leaving said scction line, North 00 degrees 21 minutes 06 seconds West 160.00 feet to the North right-of-way of Vanderbilt Beach Road (CR862); thence North 00 degrees 20 minutes 33 seconds West 566,13 feet to the POINT OF" BEGINNING of1he parcel herein described; thence South 89 degrees 39 minutes 27 seconds West 409.51 feet; thence North 00 degrees 20 minutes 33 seconds West 639.97 feet; thence Easterly 226.41 feet along the arc of a circular curve concave Northerly having a radius of 1780.0 feet through a central angle of 07 degrees 17 minutes 16 seconds and being subtended by a chord which bears South 86 degrees 53 minutes 15 seconds East 226,26 feet; thence North 89 degrees 28 minutes 07 seconds East 183,66 feet; thence South 00 degrees 20 minutes 33 seconds East 626,94 fcet to the POINT OF BEGINNING, 'mel III: .11 that part of Section 35, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida, being more particularly described as follows: Commencing at the Southeast comer of said Section 35; thence along the South line of said Section 35, said line also being the Southerly right-of-way line of Vanderbilt Beach Road (CR862) (160' rigbt-of-way) South 89 degrees 38 minutes 54 seconds West 100,00 feet to a point on the Westerly right,of-way line of Airport-l'ulling Road (CR3 t); 1hence along said Westerly right-of-way line, North 00 degrees 31 minutes 59 seconds West 160,00 feet to a point on the Northerly right-of-way of said Vanderbilt Beach Road; thence continue ",long said Westerly right-of~way line North 00 degrees 31 minutes 59 seconds West 623,28 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING; thence leaving said Westerly right-o[,way line, South 89 degrees 28 minutes 01 seconds West 769.12 feet; thence North 00 degrees 20 minutes 33 seconds Wesl572.23 feet; 1hence North 89 degrees 28 minutes 07 seconds East 742,22 feet; thence Southeasterly 39.27 feet along the arc of a circular curve concave Southwest having a radius of 25,00 feet through a centrat anglc of 89 degrees 59 minutes 54 seconds and heing subtcnded by a chord which bears a South 45 degrees 31 minutes 56 seconds East 35.35 [eel to the Westerly right'of-way of said Airport-Pulling Road; thence along said Westerly right-of-way line South 00 degrees 31 minutcs 59 ,ecouds East 547,20 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING, Parcel N: All that part ofSeetion 35, Township 48 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida and being more particularly descrihed as follows: Commencing at the Southeast comer of said Section 35; thence along the South iin~ of said Section 35, South 89 degree. 38 minutcs 54 seconds West 100.00 feet to. point on the West right-of-way line of A1rp0l1-Pulling Road (CRJ 1); thence continue along said section linel South 89 degrees 3& minutes 54 seconds West 771.70 feet; thence leaving said section, North 00 degrees 21' 06" West 160.00 feet to the Point of Beginning ofthe parcel herein described; thence South 89 degrees 38 minutes 54 seconds West 409.51 fect; 1hence Nortb 00 degrees 20 minutes 33 seconds West 566, t9 Jeet; thence North 89 degrees 9 minutes 27 seconds East 409.51 feet; thence South 00 degrees 20 minutes 33 seconds Enst 566.13 feet to the Point of Beginning. Agenda Item No. 170 June 24, 2008 Page 4,1 of 42 Agenda Item No, 170 June 24, 2008 Page 42 of 42 EXHIBIT "D" CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL FOR SV -2008-AR-12943 I. The sign copy for Sign A-I, A-2, B-1, B-2 and C-I as depicted on Exhibit "A" Overall Site Plan shall be limited to 760< square feet. 2, The signs for A-I, A-2, B-1, B-2 and C-I as depicted on Exhibit "A" Overall Site Plan shall be limited to the name of the shopping center and shall not contain the names of individual tenants. G: Currentl Gundlachl Variances for Signs[The Collection at Vanderbilt /Exhlbit 0 Conditions 4-23-08