Loading...
Agenda 07/09/2019 Item #16F 2 (Alternative Road Impact Fee Rate)07/09/2019 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Recommendation to approve the use of an alternative road impact fee rate, previously approved by the Board of County Commissioners for Taco Bell, for a Wendy’s Restaurant being constructed at Tamiami Crossings and for an addition to an existing Taco Bell converting to a Kentucky Fried Chicken in Immokalee. OBJECTIVE: That the Board of County Commissioners approves the use of an alternative road impact fee rate, previously approved for Taco Bell, for a new Wendy’s Restaurant being const ructed at Tamiami Crossings and for an addition to an existing Taco Bell being converted to a Kentucky Fried Chicken (KFC) in Immokalee. CONSIDERATIONS: On April 12, 2011, the Board of County Commissioners approved an alternative road impact fee calculation study for Taco Bell conducted in accordance with the provisions of Section 74-204 of the Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances; the review by Tindale-Oliver and Associates, Inc.; and the resulting 14% reduction from the adopted Road Impact Fee rate. The analysis provided that fast food restaurants that do not offer breakfast and are not open 24-hours generate less travel than the average fast food restaurant with a drive-through. Both Wendy’s and KFC are comparable in that they do not serve breakfast and are not open 24-hours. The current adopted Road Impact Fee rate for a Fast Food Restaurant with Drive -Through is $96,567.14 per 1,000 square feet. A 14% reduction will result in an adjusted rate of $83,047.74 per 1,000 square feet. Approval of the use of the alternative impact fee rate calculation to be used for Taco Bell and KFC is recommended by staff and the impact fee consultant. A copy of the Taco Bell Alternative Study is on file in the Impact Fee Administration Office. FISCAL IMPACT: If the Board accepts and approves the use of the alternative impact fee rate, the resulting rate is 14% lower than the current rate for a Fast Food Restaurant with Drive Through. This adjustment accurately reflects the demand created by the proposed facilities on public transportation facilities. GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: Impact fees provide financial resources for the construction and/or expansion of the County’s capital infrastructure, as necessary to accommodate growth. Consistent with Objective 2 of the Capital Improvement Element (CIE) of the Collier County Growth Management Plan (GMP), development is required to contribute its fair share of the costs of providing public facilities necessitated by growth, however impact fees may not be collected in excess of the amount reasonably anticipated to fund such improvements. The fees for Wendy’s and KFC are based on an alternative road impact fee calculation which represents a current, localized and accurate assessment of the facility’s impact and associated cost of providing transportation- related capital facilities attributable to the new development. LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This item has been reviewed by the County Attorney, is approved as to form and legality, and requires majority vote for approval. -JAK RECOMMENDATION: To approve the use of an alternative road impact fee rate, previously approved for Taco Bell, for a new Wendy’s Restaurant being constructed at Tamiami Crossings and for an addition to an existing Taco Bell converting to a KFC in Immokalee. Staff also recommends that the Board of County Commissioners approves the use of the alternative road impact fee rate on any future fast food restaurants with a drive-through that do not offer breakfast and are not open 24- 16.F.2 Packet Pg. 1903 07/09/2019 hours, until such time that the alternative rate can be added to the impact fee rate schedule in early 2020. Prepared by: Amy Patterson, Director, Capital Project Planning, Impact Fees and Program Management ATTACHMENT(S) 1. Alternative Study - Taco Bell (PDF) 16.F.2 Packet Pg. 1904 07/09/2019 COLLIER COUNTY Board of County Commissioners Item Number: 16.F.2 Doc ID: 9331 Item Summary: Recommendation to approve the use of an alternative road impact fee rate, previously approved by the Board of County Commissioners for Taco Bell, for a Wendy’s Restaurant being constructed at Tamiami Crossings and for an addition to an existing Taco Bell converting to a Kentucky Fried Chicken in Immokalee. Meeting Date: 07/09/2019 Prepared by: Title: Senior Grants and Housing Coordinator – Capital Project Planning, Impact Fees, and Program Management Name: Gino Santabarbara 06/13/2019 9:02 AM Submitted by: Title: Division Director - IF, CPP & PM – Capital Project Planning, Impact Fees, and Program Management Name: Amy Patterson 06/13/2019 9:02 AM Approved By: Review: Growth Management Department Judy Puig Level 1 Reviewer Completed 06/13/2019 9:53 AM Growth Management Department Gino Santabarbara Deputy Department Head Review Skipped 06/13/2019 9:01 AM Growth Management Department Thaddeus Cohen Department Head Review Completed 06/13/2019 12:20 PM County Attorney's Office Jeffrey A. Klatzkow Level 3 County Attorney's Office Review Completed 06/14/2019 7:28 AM Office of Management and Budget Valerie Fleming Level 3 OMB Gatekeeper Review Completed 06/14/2019 11:40 AM Office of Management and Budget Laura Zautcke Additional Reviewer Completed 06/17/2019 10:18 AM County Manager's Office Leo E. Ochs Level 4 County Manager Review Completed 06/25/2019 1:36 PM Board of County Commissioners MaryJo Brock Meeting Pending 07/09/2019 9:00 AM 16.F.2 Packet Pg. 1905 -findale-Oliver & Associalcs, Inc. Pliutrrrng ;rtrcl l,,rrgru'cnrrg March 2,20ll Mr. Nick Casalanguida Collier County Growth Management Division 2880 North Horseshow Drive Naples, FL 34104 Re: Review of Taco Bell Independent Impact Fee Study Dear Mr. Casalanguida: We have completed a review of the Revised Independent Impact Fee Calculation Study for the proposed Taco Bell site to be located at420l E. Tamiami Trail, at the intersection of E. Tamiami Trail and Lakewood Boulevard. The study, dated February 2,2011, is completed by Nunner Engineering Services (the Consultant). TOA reviewed the trip length and percent new trips data with regard to the issues mentioned in the letter to Collier County dated December 8, 2010. r The calculation of trip lengths of diverted trip ends has been clarified and no change was necessary. o The Consultant has reviewed and revised both trip type categorizations and trip lengths associated with Sites I mdZ. The trip lengths observed are now accurately reflected in the final variables. o The Consultant does not weigh the trip characteristics by study site size as required by the County's Administrative Manual. [t is recommended that the variables obtained at each individual site be accepted by the County and that the trip characteristics variables be weighted for the final impact fee calculation. Table I on the next page presents the results of the values for the three trip characteristics variables and suggested change to be incorporated to obtain the weighted average values for each variable. Table 2 shows the adopted transportation impact fees in comparison to the fees calculated for Taco Bell using the Phase I and Phase [I transportation impact fee variables. 1000 North Ashley Drive, suite 100, Tampa, Florida 33602 r phone: (813) 224-gs62 o Fax: (813) 226-21061595 $outh Semoran Boulevard, Building 7, suite 1540, winter Park, Florida 327g2 c phone: (407) 657-9210 o Fax: (407) 657-9106195 South central Avenue, Bartow, Florida 33830 . Phone: (863) 533-8454 r Fax: (g63) 533-84g1 16.F.2.a Packet Pg. 1906 Attachment: Alternative Study - Taco Bell (9331 : Alternative road impact fee rate) Tinclzrle-()liver & Associates, Inc. ttn Ntck Casalangulda Mareh 2,2011 Page 2 of 2 Table I :i!-nn I \{a'rrt' :::r. _,irl EAril.,*,*iiiif$E \ftilr{-, 2224 ETamiamiTrail 1.754 39s.61 1.58 70.67o/c 441.8C 8835 Davb Blvd 2,441 414.11 2.67 47.7201 s27.7C 28320 Trails Edse 2,404 414.17 2.15 62.500t 556.54 Iotal 6,595 Ave nase (Consultant's calculation)408.00 2.r3 60.3o/o 524.83 Weiehted Averase (TOA method)(2)409.25 2.19 59.204 s30.58 Calculated by multiplying trip rate, trip lengths and percent new trips. Weighted by site size Table 2 ':;iEr:lrl1!:1,,:r f ifi i:l :!: t:l::.1 ':l'1r :;$liti -.i. , ,'ir.*ffi$ri :::lljl #{+e!!{ r;i,,iil rie{hiiaut.L$s:@r{ lft; ,ffill r*,ffi': Fast Food with Drive Throush 621.4C $91,307 s79,737 Prooosed Taco Bell 530.58 $78,272 $68,393 The analysis suggests that fast food restaurants that do not offer breakfast (or another meal, such as lunch or dinner) generate less travel than the average fast food restaurant with drive through. As such, it is recommended that the County accept the hip characteristics variables and calculated impact fee. Please let us know if you have any questions. We appreciate this opportunity to serve the County. Very Truly Yours, Tindale-Oliver and Associates, Inc. (l) Q) fu,q&,sa Steven A. Tindale, President 1000 North Ashley Drive, Suite 100, Tampa, Florida 33602 o Phone: (813) 224-8862 o Fax: (g13) 226-2106 1595 South Semoran Boulevard, Building 7. suite 1540, \Mnter Pa*, Florida 32792 o phone: (407) 657-9210 e Fax: (407) 657-9106 195 South Central Avenue, Bariow, Florida 33830 . Phone: (S63) 533-9454 Fax: (g63) S33-g4g1 16.F.2.a Packet Pg. 1907 Attachment: Alternative Study - Taco Bell (9331 : Alternative road impact fee rate) 'l'in<lale-Oliver & Associatcs, Inc. l'laruilg artd linginccrir rg December 8, 2010 Mr. Nick Casalanguida Collier County Growth Management Division 2880 North Horseshow Drive Naples, FL 34104 Re: Review of Taco BeIl Independent Impact tr'ee Study Dear Mr, Casalanguida: We have completed a review ofthe Independent Impact Foe Calculation Study dated October 28, 2010 for the proposed Taco Bell site to be located at 4201 E. Tamiami Trail, at the interseotion of E. Tamiami Trail and Lakewood Boulevard, submitted by Nunner Engineering Services (the Consultant). TOA reviewed the trip generation rate, trip length, and poroent new trips data. The calculations for trip genoretion rate were found to be oorrect; however, three issues were identified with the final hip characteristics variablos: o The Consultant do€s not weigh the trip characteristics by study site size (based on 1,000 square feet) and instead uses a straight average. . Based on the sample of origin-destination surveys, the Consultant does not appear to multiply the diverted trip lengths by 2, as stated in the county's Administrative procedures Manual as it pertains to altemative transportation impact fees. o The sample of origindestination surveys validated the trip characteristics obtained from Site 3 (within l0%); however, the results obtained from TOA's sample are fundamentally different than the variables computed by the Consultant for Sites I and 2. Specifically, in about one-third ofthe sample surveys evaluated for Site 2, the Consultantls results incorrectly categorized trip types and the subsequent trip lengths. The table on the next page presents the results ofthe sample taken of origin-destination surveys for all three study sites. The table shows the results calculated by the Consuttant and the results ofthe ToA review, as well as, the percent different between the two. 1000 North Ashrev Drive, suite 1oo, Tampa, Florida 33602 . phone: (813) 224-8862 . Fax: (8131 226-2106,unr .*,1;.."[:,Tll::]:"],j::::1.ff r:':l1r:.,-u]9,.y:n,l:l.n, Ftonda-327s2. phone: (407) 607_szro . i"",-1oorl osz-s1oo19s south centratAvenue, Badow. Fronda 33830 . phone. (863) s33-*uo . il"i-ti'ufrlirJ-ioi., 16.F.2.a Packet Pg. 1908 Attachment: Alternative Study - Taco Bell (9331 : Alternative road impact fee rate) v 'finclirle-Olir,'er & Associates, Inc. Mn Niclt Casalangulda December 8, 2010 Page 2 of 2 It is recommended that the Consultant correct the trip types and trip lengths of the origin-destination data for at least Sites I and 2 (ideatly for all sites), as well as, correct the calculation for diverted trip lengths, before the County accepts the study findings. These calculations are explained in the article titled "Measuring Travel Characteristics for Transportation Impact Fees" by W.E. Oliver, which was referenced in the County's Administrative Procedures Manual. Please let us know if you have any questions. We appreciate this opportunity to serve the County. Very Truly Yours, Tindale-Oliver and Associates, Inc. &n Site Trip Length 7o New Trips Trip Length x Yo New Trips TOA vs. Consult.Consultant TOA Consultant TOA Consultant TOA | -2224 E. Tamiami Tr 1.79 1.83 67%78o/o t.20 t.43 l60/o 2 - 8835 Davis Blvd 2.76 2.63 3r%560/o 0.86 r.47 42% 3 -28320 Trails Edse 2.33 2.08 64%67%1.49 1.39 -7% Averase 2,29 2.18 54o/o 67o/o 1.18 1.43 17o/o Steve A. Tindale 1000 North Ashley Drive, suite 100, Tampa, Florida 33602 o phone: (g1 3) 224-ss62 o Fax: {813) 226-21061595 south semoran Boulevard, Building 7, suite 1540, \Mnter Park, Florida 327g2 o phone; (407) 657-9210 o Fax: (407)657-9j06195 South central Avenue, Barlow, Florida 33830 r Phone: (s63) 533-845 4 _ Fax: (863) 533€481 16.F.2.a Packet Pg. 1909 Attachment: Alternative Study - Taco Bell (9331 : Alternative road impact fee rate) Taco Bell Restaurant Collier CountY, Florida October 28' 2010 Revised Data FebruarY 3,2011 Prepared bY: Nunner, L.L.C. 8 I I 3 Lowbank Dr. Napleq Florida 34 1 09 239.591.1328 NUNNER Enginsering Scrviccs IndePendent TransPortation Impact Fee Calculation StudY P. E. Nilmher 45336 16.F.2.a Packet Pg. 1910 Attachment: Alternative Study - Taco Bell (9331 : Alternative road impact fee rate) NUNNER Eltglneering Servlceg FebruarY 3, 201 I Amy Patterson lmpact Fee Coordinator Collier CountY Government 2800 N. Horseshoe Drive Naples, Florida 341M Re: Taco Bell- -- eitemative tmpact Fee Analysis dated October 28' 20 I 0 Revised data and results Dear Ms. Patterson: please find attached five (5) certified copies of revised alternate impact fee analysis for a i,iOA rqrr* f*t Taco Beli resta,rant to be located at 4201 E Tamiami Trail at interseciion of E' Tamiami Trail and Lakewood Boulevard' The attached information hss been revised based on December 8, 2010 review letter by Tindale - Oliver and subsequent conversations and emails with Tindale - Oliver reviewer Amanda J. Haas. Enclosed are revised trip type and trip lengths for sites 1 and 2 as recommended. The other Tindale - Oliver recommendation is not required because the calculation for diverted rips was corr€ct in the original reporL Also enclosed is revised calculations based on revised above. Tindale - Oliver has accepted the enclosed data as documented in emails attached the last email dated February 2, 201 l. The resulting impact fee based on the revised snrdy is $77,180 compared to the current county rate of$91,307 for a typical fast food restaurant. Please contact me ifyou have any questions or need any additional information. I El l3 Lowbank Drive Naples, Florida 34109 239.591.1328 Fax: 239.591. l35E t:h*-.. Cc: Craig Welch 16.F.2.a Packet Pg. 1911 Attachment: Alternative Study - Taco Bell (9331 : Alternative road impact fee rate) lll lmpact Fee Calculations . Proiect Taco Bell;\r' Fetruary 3, 2011 Fixed Criteria Lane Capacily Consbuction Cost Gas tax credit 10,217 trips per day $4,285,778 per lane mile $22,085 Calculatbn attached a.4% 408.00 triP ends / '1000 sf 60.3 % 2.13 mileg Gas Tax Gredit Calculation Fixed Variables Fuel Efficiency $/gallon to capital Present value Variables per study Trip rate Assessable trip length % non - passeby 17.92 0.253 14.0939 408 2.63 0.603 Transportation lmpact Fee Worksheet Collier County lnterstate red. Factor Variable Criteria Trip Generaton Rale Percent Nelrv Trips Average TriP Length Compute Trip Ends Per Day per 1000 sf Trip generation rate x size x percent new trips = Trip ends per day 4O8.OO 'l 0.603 246'024 TtiP Ends per day Gompute Lane Miles Per DaY (Trip ends /Day x Average Trip Lengthy(Lane Capacity x 2) = Lane Miles per day 2&.024 -2.13 20434 0 025645058 Compute Net lmPact Fee Per 1000 sf (LanemilesperdayxCostperlanemilexinterstatereductionfactor)-gastaxcredit' o.ozsoisosa 4285778 0.916 $23'497 Annual Gas Tax Equation ((TripratoxTotalT,ipLeflgthx%nonpasse.by)/2)xeffectivedays/yearx$/gallontocapital)/Fuelefficienct Annual Gas Tax Gas Tax Credit Equation Present Value x annual gas tax $1,667 Gas Tax 23 16.F.2.a Packet Pg. 1912 Attachment: Alternative Study - Taco Bell (9331 : Alternative road impact fee rate) Idplsoglh '6 LewTrips Calcuhli,on Shoot Aae6sabb Trip Lal€ h 1 .58 mil€s Assessabl€ Tiip Length 2.67 mileg Assessable Trip Length 2.'15 miles Results A8rorlabb Trip Longth Zt3 m e! altltt 16.F.2.a Packet Pg. 1913 Attachment: Alternative Study - Taco Bell (9331 : Alternative road impact fee rate) a/s /u Store Day tlc orimarv #miles sec #mibs diverted #miles Gaptured 1 1 x 74 104.6 10 12.t 20 21.6 25 2 x 34 69.4 t0 21.4 36 39.6 14 3 x 64 '129.6 4 5.8 42 32.8 22 totatt 172 303.6 u 39.5 98 9,1 6' 2 1 x 32 ao.2 t0 55.2 26 45 33 2 x 28 74.4 4 12 30 50.6 31 3 x 36 71 4 16.3 18 21.8 39 to[al5 96 225.6 t8 8:t.5 71 117.4 103 3 1 x 52 '| 19 4 8.3 22 17 29 2 x 66 153.3 2 5.3 18 22 20 e x 62 145.8 0 0 14 11.6 23 iotrls 180 4t8.1 6 13.6 50.6 72 16.F.2.a Packet Pg. 1914 Attachment: Alternative Study - Taco Bell (9331 : Alternative road impact fee rate) RE: Taco Bell - Site 2 Sample Maps Jeff Nunner \-/ From: Amanda J. Haas fAHaas@tindaleoliver.com] Sent Wednesday, February 02,20114:01 pM To: Jeff Nunner SubJect RE: Taco Bell- Site 2 Sampte Maps leff, I am comfortable with the adjustments. please proceed. Thank you, Amanda Amanda J. Haas Senior Planner, Public Finance & lnfrastructure Planning ffi fin.t.lc-Olivc.r & Associarcs. tnc.\1r 1000 N. Ashley Dr., Suite 100 Tampa, FL 3360 P:813.224.8862 x 296 Fz 813.226.21A8 ahaas@tindaleoliver. com www. tindaleoliver. com Page I of4 Flom: Jeff Nunner [mailto:j nunner@comcast. net] Senh Wednesday, February 02, 2011 11:10 AM To: Amanda J. Haas Ce 'BreffnuerPaula'; 'Jeff Nunne/ SubJect: FW: Taco Bell- Site 2 Sample Maps Amanda - sent Jan 17th below - please confirm receipt. Jeff Nunner From : Jeff Nunner [mailto:jnun ner@comcast. net] SenE Monday, January 17, z0tl tl:47 AM To:'Amanda J. Haas' Cc: 'FleishmanPaula' SubJectt RE: Taco Bell- Site 2 Sampte Maps Thanks Amanda, I have attached site 1 and 2. revised trips for your review based on our discussions and emails. site 3 isapproved- Please confirm these are acceptable and I will complete remainder of stuOy. - I have the following comments when you review each site: Site 1. l ' You indicated Nunner trip type for survey 1 1 1 as diverted but I labeled it as secondary as you did. 2/3t20tt 16.F.2.a Packet Pg. 1915 Attachment: Alternative Study - Taco Bell (9331 : Alternative road impact fee rate) \/ \-, RE: Taco Bell - Site 2 Sample Maps Page 2 of 4 2. You indicated Nunner trip type for survey 131 as primary but I labeled as diverted as you did. I did adjust length. 3. I made other adjustments per your review. 4. Day 1 is not attached as there were no changes. Site 2. l. Local knowledge motorists will use Collier Blvd. and east - west roads instead of US 41 N and US 41 E. This is incorporated in my trip analysis. 2. Santa Barbara Blvd. has been extended to Rattlesnake - Hammock Rd. This is incorporated in my trip analysis. 3. Trips traveling along Collier Blvd. passing Davis are considered captured per our emails. This is incorporated in my trip analysis. Thanks and please let me know if you have any questions. Jeff Nunner From: Amanda J. Ham [mailto:AHaas@tindaleoliver.comJ SenE Mondry, January t7t20ll8:53 AM To: Jeff Nunner SubJect RE: Taco Bell - SiE 2 Sample Maps That's fine. Amanda Amanda J. Haas Senior Planner, Public Finance & lnfrastructure Planning ffi fln,tolc-Olivcr & r\ssociatcs. lrrc. rrl ^ l, aa.r.E .aa t.frcrif 1000 N. Ashley Dr., Suite'100 Tampa, FL 3360 P:813.224.8862 x 296 F:813.226.21A8 ahaas@tindaleoliver. com www. tindaleoliver. com From: Jeff N unner [mailto jnunner@comcast. net] SenE Saturday, January 15, 2011 9:38 AM To: Amanda J. Haas Ce Nilgun Kamp SubJect RE: Taco Bell - Site 2 Sampte Maps Amanda, I agree - would you then confirm that trip 2-152 would also be captured - same condition.your review changed to diverted. Please confirmm. Thanks, Jeff Nunner From: Amanda J. Haas [mailto:AHaas@tindaleoliver.comJ 2/3t20tt I had as captured but 16.F.2.a Packet Pg. 1916 Attachment: Alternative Study - Taco Bell (9331 : Alternative road impact fee rate) RE: Taco Bell - Site 2 Sample Maps Sent Friday, January t4,20t19:17 AM To: Jeff Nunner Cc Nilgun Kamp Sublectu RE: Tao Bell - Site 2 Sample Maps teft, I believe the primary trip rectangle would be drawn to encompass the site for those trips. "captured". Thanks, Amanda Amanda J. Haas Senior Planner, Public Finance & lnfrastructure planning ffi fin.trlc-Olivcr & r\ssociarcs. lnc. - -- tftfrnt.aaantfrG.l 1000 N. Ashley Dr., Suite 100 Tampa, FL 3360 P:813.224.8862 x 296 F:813.226.2106 ahaas@tindaleoliver. com wunr. tindaleoliver. com Frcm: Jeff Nun rrer [mailto :jnunner@comcast. net] Sen$ ThuMay, January 13, 2011 8:05 AM To: Amanda J. Haas SubJect RE: Taco Bell - Site 2 Sample Maps Amanda, Trip 185 attached with stop off for site. Thanks, Jeff From: Amanda J, Haas [mailto:AHaas@tindaleollver.com] SenB Wednesday, January 12,}OLL 4:08 pM To: Jeff Nunner SubJect RE: Taco Belt- Site 2 Sample Maps Jefi Please provide a sample map for issue #2. Thanks, Amanda ---Original Message--- From; Jeff Nunner [rnailtojnunncr(r]conrcast.nct] Sent:'l'ue UllnDl I l0:59 AM To: Amanda J. Haas Page 3 of4 Lefs categorize it as \-/ 2t3t20n 16.F.2.a Packet Pg. 1917 Attachment: Alternative Study - Taco Bell (9331 : Alternative road impact fee rate) RE:'l'aco Bell - Site 2 Sample Maps Cc: Nilgun Kamp Subject: RE: Taco Bell - Site 2 Sample Maps Amanda Please review this map as it is a common condition that brings up 2 issues: l. Google maps takes first route away from Collier Blvd. My local experience is that driver would use Collier Blvd. as I have shbwn. 2. {!el pqsing by Davis Blvd. (store close to corner) on Collier BIvd.would thjs be a capturcd trip or diverted. Not far enough to register distance? #2 above is especially common condition. As we discussed yesterday regarding the other sites: Site I. I will review and adjust based on your comments. Sire 3. This site is acceptable. Thankg JeffNunner Page 4 of4 From: Amandal. H* tmaitto:a Haasfratin SenI Monday, December 13,2010 t0:4? AM '- To: JeffNunner Cc: Nilgun Kamp Subject: Taco Betl - Site 2 Sample Maps \-, See attached sample maps for Site 2. Amanda J. Haas Senior Planner, Public Finance & Infrashucture planning <htto://www.tindalfu TOA Long 1000 N. Ashley Dr., Suite 100T*ps FL 3360 P: 813.224.8862 x296 F:813.226.2106 ahaas@ti ndaleol iver.com rvww.tindaleoliver.com <http:,{www.tind 213t2011 16.F.2.a Packet Pg. 1918 Attachment: Alternative Study - Taco Bell (9331 : Alternative road impact fee rate)