Agenda 11/10/2009 Item # 6A
f\genda Item No. 6A
November 10. 2009
Page 1 of 11
COLLIER COUNTY
OFFICE OF THE COUNTY MANAGER
3301 East Tamiami Trail. Naples, Florida 34112. (239) 252-8383. FAX: (:239) 252-4010
October 21, 2009
Lynn Smallwood McMillin
P.O. Box 310
Chokoloskee, FL 34138
Re: Public Petition Request to Discuss Waiver for Off-Premise Signage for the Ted
Smallwood's Store, Inc., Chokoloskee, FL
Dear Ms. McMillin:
Please be advised that you are scheduled to appear before the Collier County Board of
Commissioners at the meeting of November 10, 2009, regarding the above referenced
subject.
Your petition to the Board of County Commissioners will be limited to ten minutes.
Please be advised that the Board will take no action on your petition at this meeting.
However, your petition may be placed on a future agenda for consideration at the
Board's discretion. If the subject matter is currently under litigation or is an on-going
Code Enforcement case, the Board will hear the item but will not discuss the item after it
has been presented. Therefore, your petition to the Board should be to advise them of
your concern and the need for action by the Board at a future meeting.
The meeting will begin at 9:00 a.m. in the Board's Chambers on the Third Floor of the W.
Harmon Turner Building (Building "F") of the government complex. Please arrange to be
present at this meeting and to respond to inquiries by Board members.
If you require any further information or assistance, please do not hesitate to contact this
office.
Sincerely,
~.2- ~ ~
Leo E. Ochs, Jr.,...-v/l. ~
County Manager
LEO/jb
cc: Jeffrey Klatzkow, County Attorney
Joe Schmitt, CD&ES Administrator
-.-
'lID.
:Ai. ~
JAN-20-2007 12:22P FROM:
TO: *252413113 A diP ~,
gen a terri'-t'JO. 6A
November 10, 2009
Page 2 of 11
Reauest to Soeak under Public Petition
Plesse prinf'1ecl.5:rnct II UJod l 5h>re, :rhc..
Name:
Phone:
O. of the Board MeetioQ you wi~h to $peak:
Ou-ober ~'1) ~CllA
Must circle yea or no:
Is this subject matter under litigation at this time? Ves @I
Is this subject matter an ongoing Code Enforcement case? @ No
Note: If either answer Ie "y...., the Board will hear the item but will have no
discussion regarding the Item after It Is presented.
Please eXDlain in detail the reason YOu are reauestinG to soeak (attach additional
Page if neoessar():
C:\U8eIS\OwneMpp0at8\Local\MlcroBoft\WIndowa\Temporary I_met
FiIes\LDW\ContenL'E5\NPCRM8IM\Publk::%20Petltlon~orm%20-%202ClO8%20NI'lN%20f0nn[1].doc
~t"~\:"jI :# '::' .;.. -,ff "'y. E :t ~i\ ' , 1" .,., " ,1;\0 " ,~ ,k
JAN-20-2007 12:22P FROM:
-1-
TO: *252413113 ..!\gsnda IlJ?'.<~No. SA
~Jovenlber 10. 2009
Page 3 of 11
-:-~~~~~~ ~~ 1<Q~~rJ-=
~I~~~~~~~ ~~
~-~ -----"'
, JFlN-2e-2Bl1l7 12:23P FR01:
-;1-
TO: *2524eHI Agenda It~'n4No, 6A
November 10, 2009
Page 4 of 11
----- '
" .
eftr,'~ i (\tor~nt\{)1\ on the. I~i( l ~ ,.Q).(~ ",,"\I\'l> ~
a_~ {~ ~,- y- ~;. "T"--"C2. 111OC. f\' r;-.:wr."", ~ n 0 ~C\OQ...
".",c,kn"'-t"P'" C'tf J:'l'~~\". \\'M f,,~\<Q cJn-.- ~,IL' 11 nri M\R..
}..h~ n\l~~'~" ,\ ( {~-f \l* r,Pl'irl.r ,~ '~N ,\I.....; ,nl(\('tQ
r\r\<L ~,r: ;u,~ .-:::~ ~()\r\'5 fl.: -~\i '+1mp~... t"il~ij) 1 11\-
~-\-o. ~I"S 'rp. ~l,a.~ !l ~~4-m OOr\f~ ~ I'VI c..iflr ~J
....H'\ ,"1ln (\ l\-t I', ~~'l\ ,to ~I' \ ...c~.... -\-h i l\ (. f~~O \ 1\ - J~kA, ~
.D"~.lr- .nf: (\, ~"~.an ("\ (l ~\do~u ~"'~"'\V'\-Q vV\V'tf\,
~ ;~ JI ''lIoU(J . - U '-T~ .... ~', <; , ri or 'rtcr-f I r.Jf0J" V\~ (~I1 '
~I'W C:;~()V\~' ic.. Vl,(')tLl 'n o~nr~ crt- t\...rc~~ ~ 1)r,
;..; ~ '5.?r1' It ,- I I'Il -OC~ -J l~O fn I Df\ rtJ;~ i) t · r- ,,",~ ,\(It I, "
- - r' ./
~,
~
~~~~
L_ _
. JRN-20-2007 12:23P FRCI'!:
TO: *252401111 An""~r!'" lil?~5No Poi
t:. '" \"\ \tf){~~er. "IO.z;io09
age/:; ;\ 11
- h~I_"~~~~i:l
. JAN-2e-2007 12:24P FR01:
HISTORIC
SMALLWOOD
STORE
CIlr I"""" T-m., Pen
Buard of Din:aors
ALTON C. HANCOCK
Praitlmt
GARy ~ McMrLUN
S<<nr4"rTmrsurrr
NANCY B. HANCOCK
HARoLD E. PATR.ICOFF, EsQ..
J. ANniONY DAVIS
NANCY KAY Hou..1STER
Executive Director
LYNN SMAllWOOD
McMlWN
Direa:or
BRENOA C. JOHNSON
hu Oflk' Bwo J(j7
CboI:tJJ.sIt#. FltJritl4 34/38
(9-{ /) 695-2989
FlU: (941) 6954/5/
E-M1IiJ: 1heUmtnmt!@"J.m/f
~~_ "'~~B_~ -
TO: *2524010
Agenda~~~~~.~Ar.l
r.,jovemr,~9D
age 6 01 11
10,20G3
., ..ea.ty Coda EafoRement
. DawI
. ...1Iaiweeboo Drive
~'rT. Pbida 34104
I am writing on bebalf of the. Ted SmallWQDd's Store, Inc., a not-for-
lWfit orpttt7Ation. The Smallwood Storo-Museum is a state fimdccI
CDtity aDd the oldest Natioaal Register site b:re in CoBier County. The
StIte of Florida Ovcrs=l this orpni7Ation in the ft)9j~ of all of OlD'
AIP'9 fur this educational &cility.
l:WlIIklapprecilaeany IlliIt8DCe .in providing tbe code needed to bring
.our oft' premiscsigaap iDao compIiaDce with Collier County Code
~, YOlD' prompt ldteDIion in tbls matter is greatly appreciated.
'1, .
4A/lIJiL ·
S. McMillin
Exec. Director
Fax # 695-4454
-
---.--.-----
!II
. JR-I-20-CBJ7 12:24P FR(J'1:
TO: *2524010 f\oS<lcJa its:-(?~,I,, f,t
-' . ~ '\.\'. "~ I~
f\Jovember 10. 20',
Page 7 of ~, ;
COLlIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT
COMMl:""m' DEVELOPMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES orVISION
2l1OO N~~ Dl'l\'C . :-.iap\C$. ~oridt1 ~104 . nl).40~-2+10 · P^X ~Cl~~.~~4~
: ~ (i~'
. :<:'\tn~ "i',';1.-;" . r
'......,HI.?~~~~ S
.' 'P.O. Box. -. '.. .
ChockoJoskec. Ft. 341'39
Attn: Lynn ~MinaD
I am in receipt of your fax and its contents. By way of this Jetter r am closing your case regarding
the off premise direetionsl sign. I can find no reason Ilt this time that the non-profit org:lOitation
along with the State of Florida Historical Society Qvers=ing Its operations should have to relocate
such sign.
Typically offpremt.clil'8Ctional signs can only be in non-residential ~ and do require a permit..
However. Chockol05~ Island is unique in its way of being' entirely zoned reswmtfal.village and
pun:uing.lhis signs' exIstence would onJy cause problems for this extremely old historical landmar" ,
This landmarR of. tb; Smallwood Store is vlsited by hundred of touriSl ea.ch year in pursuit of
leaming the history ~que ar:a.
If you have IrtY futlft.probJcms or have furtbcT questions, please contact Michaelle Crowley at 403-
2487. She is th,e ~.upervi50r over the Signs Division of f:odc Enforcemenl and ~i11 be abfe;to help
YOll. ' ".
~l1nky.
. . - : . , .
". ..' , c..:l. +......'"
.~ " _ ~~,~ -'~'1 '
Andrea DuVal .
Code Enforcement
"-
........... '
.....-.~
--............
I::,'.
" .L
--
..-.----'-
i
"';j:"U:~i'''''''':'''--''''_UI'---'''~~
.JAN-20-2007 12:25P F'RCI1:
,
TO: *2524010 Agenda IteR-\. f.3Jo. 6A
, . ., ~ Novem~:~~ 08 ~r;8 Ii
CO~RC~CODEENFORCEMENT
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DMSION
~
~fD
~
~
auo It. ....-hoe Ik · Naples, Florida 34104 · 239-403.2440 ·
~ ; :. , ,;
vs.
COLLIER COUNTY. FLORIDA
COOS ENFORCEMENT BOARD
~~~
~~
BOARD OFCOU~IONER.S
, . . "J i
COLLIER ~;fILOIt.lDA
"\~'r;; 'tF:W;:'i::.
, ._J r-(.~.tbener,
INC
(s)
NOTICE OF HEARING
To: TED SMAU..WOOD'S STORE rNC
PO BOX 367
CHOKOLOSKEE. fL 341380367
CASE #: 2003080274
Pursuant to Set.1ion 162.06 and 162.12. Florida Statutes. and Collier County Ordinance No. 92-80, you are
hereby ordered 10 appear at a PUBLIC HEARING in the above-styled cause. pending and undetermined by
the Board, tentadvel)' ~h~uJed on DECEMBER 12, 2003, at 9:00 A.M. Ilt the Collier County
GovC<l:llmenr Cc;nrer. 3301 e. Tamiami Tr., Administrative Building. ThIrd Floor. Nopl~, Flonda 341 n.
The Board may make findings of fact, supported by the testimony and evidence pertaining to the matters
alleged in the Statemenl of Vtolalion and Request for Hearing. Staff'li recommendation to Ihe Board will
II finding of violation to the code and the maximum fine, not to exceed IWO hundred and fifty dollars
($250) per day, may be imposed each day the violation remains.
..
.,
---
If ou choose t &he violation and become 'n r
schedule a rcilllSlJCCtioliJ.IOconfirm comDli~ of the site.
I
I
PLEASE GOv'GRN YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY.
Dated this J!J!!~<<~, 1/Il:S
e..... --
· . . MrCl_ J( . "IlI'h...
EIpiIII 0aIIIlIJ 11. ."
COLLIER COUNTY. Fl...ORIDA
CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD
BY:~, A . ~ -6..--
Shanelle Hilton. as Secr~ry to
the Code ~ntorcement Hoard
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
*!
ro ~
Qj
~
~
I HEREBY CERTIFY that 8 true nnd correct copy of thiS NOTICE has been sent by US mu'il to TEn
SMALLWOOD'S STORE INC. PO BOX 367
CHOKOLOSKEE. Ft, i41JR0367
c
(~~
Bd:::J.G...- ~~,
Shanc:llc: Hilton, IlS ecretar)' to
th... rode Enforcement Board
. r ""'t:::; .... .. " t: ..y
o
.. . " \ __~:;"t
.;.
6
. JA'-I-20-2007 12: 25P FRCrI:
TO:*2S24010 Agenda itEfr,;,~~o. 6A
f\!ovember 1 O. 2~,JQ /1
Page 9 of 1 f.,)
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
~"'-DINANCE VIOLATION AND ORDER TO CORRECT
=~?r~~==1::r~=
SEC. 36 .TWN. 53 , RNG. at
BUC.31 . LOT 00. ,
~~TJ!.i RBCORD. . .
PUDII..l--. ~'~~'"
OR _. PACE ---.:...: ;''}';', .
A..K.A. (ADDRESS) ,38...... .
~...ilfIIIIIt..~... or FL
"i;" PENALTIES MAY BE IMPOSED : Failure to correct the
NlW'Ml'I! violations on or before the date specified above will result in , I) the
PURSUANT TO COUJBR. COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT filing of an affidavit of violation with the Collier County Code
BOARD (C E B) ORD 192-80 and 97-35. AS AMENDED. YOU Enforcement Board, ''C.E.B.'', charging you with the violation(s) as
ARE NOTIFIED THAT A VlOLATION{S) OF 1HE described on this form. You willlhave receive(d) notification that a
FOllOWING COLLIER COUNTY ORDlNANCE{S) EXISTS AT hearing will be held which you and/or a legaJ representative may
THE ABOVE DESCRIBED LOCATION. attend. Failure to appear may result in the Board proceeding and
making a determination in your absence. If the Code Enforcem:::nt
Board finds a violation exist&, 8 maximum fine of $250.00 per day
in the case of a first violation, a maximum fine of $500.00 per day
for a repeal violation and a maximum fine of $5000.00 per violation
in me event the ''C E B" finds the violation to be of an irreparable 0'
irreversible nature. Fines may be imposed on a per day basis fo.
each day each violation exists. Costs of prosecution and/or repairs
DESCRIPTION OF CONDmONS CONSlTIUI1NO THB may aJso be assessed against you for any violation. or, 2) the
VIOLATION(S). issuance of a Notice to Appear before the Collier County Court
where penalties of up to $500 + costs may be imposed, or, 3) the
DID WITNESS. ON AtJGUST 14, 2003, AN issuance of a citation which you may payor contest in the Collier
OFF PREMISEDllU?CTIONAL SIGN County Court where penalties of up to $500 + costs may be
(UNPERMITTED) C~y TO THE imposed.
LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE.
PROPERTY:
TED SMALLWOODS Sl'ORB' -
PO BOX 367 . ; ; _'.d "i!'l-k
CHOCIWLOSKEE. ElL 34B/:~"i'F!<;. ;'
, ' .,. ';;';:~I;'~:;l~n;:'~ . .
,{.~ T ft2ft
'h~
. rSDP#
i...:" i't . ..:_-..;...;
ORDINANCE '1.102~SEcnON 2.5.12.1
ORDINANCE 91.102 AMENDI!:D. SECl'JON 2.5.13.1.
OIIDINANCE '1.1OZ~SECTlON z.s.5.2.S.12
INQUIRIES AND COMMBPmi SHoou> BS 1>IRf!CreI) TO (''ODS
'ENFORCBMB1.n'SUPERVISOR ANDREA DUVAL
2800 No. ~ Dr. Naplca. PI. 341()4
PHONE (m)W FAX (~) 403-2345
..__,s...'~ l~L
VIOLATION STATUS:
xx INITlAL _RECURRING _REPEAT
I,' of
'"''
-..
ORDER TO CORRECT VIOLA TION(S):
YOU ARE DIRECTED BY THIS NOTICE TO TAKE THE
FOLLOWING CORRECl'IVE ACI10N:
1) OBTAIN V AUD PERMIT NUMBER FOR THE OFF
PREMISE DIREC'I10NAL SIGN
2) ENSURE THA T SIGNS MEETS CURRENT SIGN CODE
3) OBTAIN ALL Jl'lNAL COVNTv INSPECTIONS
ON OR BEFORE SEPTEMBER 15, 2003
SERVED BY: XX CERTJFIEDMAIL _POSTED
PERSONAL SERVICE
FAX
I acknowledge that I have received, read, and understand this notice
of violation.
Signature and Title of Recipient
Print
DATED THIS 15TH DAY OF AUGUST, 2003
E
. ,~ . .~, 1"-"
. Jll'-I-21!H:Ba7 12: 2SP FRCJ'I:
I
TO: *252401111
Agenda IteRi'I:L.~.~. ."
November 1 O. 20 . .
Page 10 of - ~. -
COUJER COUNTY, FLORIDA
" NIl'I"K"R OF ORDINANCE VlOLA11ON AND ORDER TO CORR'R.(7
~ >~.:~'~{-:~>.T" .J
.~,l'.f.!1.'''ilkl . f,i!'t',;~ ,
LOCATJONOF 'd '.' ._ .,,~
WlI'BJN rnr J om" : CX)JG(
. ',t.!
SBC. 36 .TWN. : 1,t";'
DLIC. 31 ,LOT oot. I ". ~ ' ,';:.lYV J ~
COUNTY RBCORD. . C5IOOO9
....."...~.'"
PUDI . TR.Acnt~~:~;~ SDN--o
OR ,PAOB ~;~L:~;:~i~; ON OR BEFORE SEPTEMBER 15,2003
...~-\ "nnDIK'm:~~. ' . "
~;,. , . :;.~~::-=~~l~:..co:,c:):::
PURSUANT TO COUJBR. cotnn"Y CODE EtfFORCBMENT filing of an affidavit of violation with the Collier County Code
BOARD (C E B ) ORD #92-80 ... 97.35, AS AMENDBD, YOU Bnforcement Board, "C.B.B.", charging you with the violation{s) as
ARB NOT.IPIBD THAT A VlOLATION(S) OF THe described on thlJ form. You will/bavc receive(d) notification that a
FOlLOWING COlLlBR. COUNTY OR1>~CE(S) EXISTS AT hearing will be ~Jd 'which you and/or a legal representative may
THE ABOVE DESCRIBED LOCATION. attend. Failure to appear may result in the Board proceeding and
mating a determination in your absence. If the Code Enforcement
Board finds ,~yioliftiCfn exists, a maximum fine of $250.00 per day
in trIfls:asc 9fa~violation, a maximum fine of 5500.00 per day
, for ,. ~t.ivio1ation.imd a mu111Wm fine of $5000.00 per violation
in the cventthe..C E B" finds the violation to be of an irreparable or
imMnib1e nature. Fines may be imposed on B per d4y basis for
each day each violation exists. COBtI of prosecution and/or repairs
DESCRIPTION OF CONDrrIONs CONSTm.rI1NO THE may also be assessed agaiDllt you for any violation, or, 2) the
VIOLATION(S). isau nee of a Notice to Appear before the Collier County Court
, where ties of up to $SOO + costs may be imposed. or, 3) the
DID .WlTNESSt. . ,G. ,.... ~...:.~ '......181. T 14, 2883, .AN. issuance citation whiehyou may pay or contcst in the Collier
OFF" PltEMISB?~:',_ SIGN ~ whIR pcaaldcs of up to $SOO + costs may be
(UNPERMIITEB) cOiDttAJty TO THE imposed.
LAND DEVEWPMENTCODE.
PROPBRTY:
TBD SMALLWooDS S'nJRB .,
PO BOX 367
CHOCKOLOSKEB, FL 34138
).
ORDINANCE 91-101 ~BD, SECTION 2.5.12.1
ORDINANCE '1-102/~t ~ON 2.5.13.L
ORDINANCE '1-101 ~~~ON 2.5.5.2.5.12
, .
. . .
.. ~.. .. '" .
,
INQUIIUBS AND OOMME!NTS SH(Q.D _I*BCTBD TO COOS
BNR)RCBME!NTSUPIlRvmR. ~ au'V AL . , .
2800 No. Hanesboc Dr. Napla. R;. 34J04
PHONE (239)
FAX (239~-403-2345
'.'
. ; ~
~ ~, .
VIOLA TlON ~ATUS:
.'1'-'-
.,
xx INl'nAL ~
RIP'EAT
~
'.J- -;_
ORDER TO COItRIU'T VIOLA TION(~i
YOU ARB DIRBC."I'BD BY THIS NOTICE TO T AICB THE
R>U.OWING CORRBCTIVB ACl'ION:
1).' 0IfrlUN VALID .....,. NUMBER FOR THE OFF
'PRDIISB DIIlECl'IONA.L SIGN
2) BI8'UIIB 'l'IIAT SIQ!8. MBBTS CURRENT SIGH CODE
3) OBTAIN ALLftNAL CCJVNTY INSPBCTIONS
"
SER~Bt:
..~
. .' ' .', 'j
CER'n.n.E'i:J MAn. ~POS1'ED
~
PERSONAL SERVICE
\\
FAX
t
I acknowledge that I bave received, read, and understand this notice
of violation.
Signa~ and Title of Recipient
Print
/
DATED THIS 15TH DAY OF AUGUST, 2003
0-
J~-20-2007 12: 26P FRCI"I:
TO: *25240113
Agenda Ite~"~~,~~ A.
November 1 Q,iiC .' q
Page 11 aT
2.5.5.2.5.11..2
COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE
I,' 4:~'i;:'id.}: ,L,. "J
'!.,..'li~j!~ . ~I>,it,;";.',,,
."~l':r~~:~';. ;"'''1-'~-'':''':'' - ...~>....":~..:
, 1~' .' -; .." ,,_ _, ..... .
~ :~- .~~ ,.l'.: '
::~l t"'. ~tion of crops to various parts of the county. Such signs sbaH be
:~,,41~: . ';-!~ Car 8 period Dot to exceed 30 days and may be issued only twice in
"'i:'~it~mlendar]'88r. Such signa ahall require a buildUag permit.
2.5.5.2.fi.~~,::.:Uk~ .1Iign.s. One U-Pic sign located at the entrance on each street frontage.
. " " ,:~ :' wa.' lIIIowable 8icD area for each U-PIe sign shall not exceed 32
,e. .', .
.' ia,,, aDd a 1ft""; mum, height ofteD. feet, and shall be located a
. . -. " .J."~.., ,
, '~ of.... fnIiI.any property line. public.. private right-of-way or
.~ eIMopy 01" awnin8 6i8na witbin. ~ districts. Wall.
....~I ' , " .' , - "J, , _ .
. . . -11 rill.:" .. ..~ I aigu ebaD be 1-.-~ witbiD agriculturally
......;.. used. ~Ly, fell. agri-commercia} w.. dm"fld within the Collier
zoning ordinance only. and subject to the following restrictions:
1.
One w:all or mansard,' canopy or awnin( sign slfiJJ be permitted for each
principal use structure on the parcel. Comer parcels or double-frontage
parcels shall be allowed one sign per streetfrontagtl, but such signs sbaIl
noi be combined for the purpose of placing the combined area on one wall.
The maximum allowable display area for any sign shall not be more than
20 percent of the tota1square footage oCthe wall to which it is affixed, and
shall not in any case exceed 250 square feet in area per sign.
..
2.5.5.2.5.12. aff-~IJd.irecUonal signal Off-premises directional signs are permitted
~ to review and appnwaJ of the design and location of such signs by the
community development and environmental services administrator, or his
I'
~, if the fonowing requirements are met:
'~i\{Ofi"..premi88..dir""ahigns shall only be permitted in nonresidentially
v ,,~j---. or agtiettItuIral di8tricta.
,.;..< "
,,~. ":';';"'No more than two one-aided or one double-sided off-premise directional
'.j./1SigM shall bep8l'lllitted. identifying the location end nature of a building, j...'
, t~~_r . " ~ 01! use wbic:h is not visible from the arterial roadway serving I
I'" '.! j .. . , " ~
" 1" ~*,:n'1Wc::Ia building, ~ or U_, provided:
; ... -:0_.-..
a. Each sign is not more than 12 square feet in area.
b. The sign is not more than eight feet in height above the lowest
center grade of the arterial roadway.
c. The sign is located no closer than ten feet to any property line. ,,'
I
d:' The applicant must submit with the pennit application notarized, ,i
written permission from the property owner where the off-site sign
is located.
'e. The sign shall only be located within 1tooo feet of the intersection of
.i ;~., the arterial roadway serving the building, structure, or use.
I!
Supp. No. 13'
',;'1? '..~.
LDC2:176
j
I
II
u
.~WR_
;.,.< J./;I"..: 'I "t - l' ,,'" .l,;
I ,~~,:' i,
: ;,., f1;t:i:~itiT: .', :. ~ _' ,
. ';,f.~",~...;-.e""'l"