Loading...
Agenda 10/27/2009 Item #16B 5Agenda Item No. 16B5 October 27, 2009 Page 1 of 22 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Recommendation to approve the payment of attorney fees and expert witness fees incurred by Dr. Gerald and Mrs. Rosemary Brown in defense of the taking of a portion of their property for the Collier Boulevard six - laning project (from Green Boulevard to Golden Gate Boulevard). Project No. 68058, Parcel Nos. 170FEE and 170TCE (Fiscal Impact: $22,879.25) OBJECTIVE: To approve the payment of attorney fees and expert witness fees incurred by Dr. Gerald Brown and Mrs. Rosemary Brown in defense of the taking of a portion of their property for the Collier Boulevard six -laning project (from Green Boulevard to Golden Gate Boulevard). CONSIDERATIONS: The original design of the stormwater detention and treatment system for the Collier Boulevard expansion between Green Boulevard and Golden Gate Boulevard necessitated the acquisition of the eastern 35 feet of the Brown property (as well as another 5 foot temporary construction easement) in order to construct a linear stormwater detention and treatment swale along the west side of Collier Boulevard. The Brown's property is located at the extreme northern end of the project at the Northwest corner of Collier Boulevard and First Avenue Southwest. (See the attached map and aerial photograph.) An estimate of the full compensation owing to Dr. and Mrs. Brown (an eminent domain real estate appraisal) was made and they were offered $155,900 by the County for the loss of the land, the loss of the improvements and landscaping in the take area, as a cure for the loss of their buffer, and for the temporary construction easement. In order to evaluate the reasonableness of the County's offer of compensation, the Browns' attorney, Ms. Bella Patel, hired an eminent domain real estate appraisal firm (Calhoun, Collister and Parham), a fixtures appraiser (Cawthra Consulting and Appraisals), a surveyor (Van Horn and Associates), a landscape consultant (Mr. Green Thumb Horticulturist), and a civil engineer (Tom Harrison). These consultants together arrived at an estimate of full compensation for the Browns in the amount of $417,000. After receiving the counter -offer from attorney Patel, County Right -of -Way Acquisition staff and the design engineers redesigned the project to delete the need for Parcels 170FEE and 170TCE. It is estimated that a significant savings to the County will result by deleting the parcels from the project. Because a bona -fide purchase offer was tendered to the Browns, along with a notice of statutory rights, they are entitled to recover fees and costs. As for the attorney fees and expert costs for which payment is being recommended, the real estate appraiser's fee was negotiated down from $4,354 to $3,915.50; the fixtures appraiser's fee was negotiated down from $1,875 to $1,500; the horticulturist's fee was negotiated down from $4,725 to $3,780; the engineer's fee was negotiated down from $4,575 to $3,660; the surveyor's fee was negotiated down from $3,177.50 to $2,667.50; and the attorney fee was negotiated down from $14,712.50 to $7,356.25. FISCAL IMPACT: The expenditure of $22,879.25 will be paid from Road Impact Fees or gas taxes. LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This item is legally sufficient for Board action — RNZ GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: "There is no growth management impact associated with this Executive Summary. Agenda Item No. 1685 October 27, 2009 Page 2 of 22 RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida approve the payment of $22,879.25 to the Trust Account of Bella Y. Patel, for further disbursement to the various expert witnesses hired by Dr. and Mrs. Brown. Prepared by: Kevin Hendricks, TEC11.3 Right -of -Way Acquisition Manager Attachments: (1) Aerial Photograph; (2) Photographs from Appraisal; (3) Legal Description and Sketch; (4) Invoices and backup documentation Page 1 of 2 Agenda Item No. 1685 October 27, 2009 Page 3 of 22 COLT ihR COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS Item Number: 1665 Item Summary: Recommendation to approve the payment of attorney fees and expert witness fees incurred by Dr. Gerald and Mrs. Rosemary Brown in defense of the taking of a portion of their property for the Collier Boulevard six - laning project (from Green Boulevard to Golden Gate Boulevard). Project No. 68058, Parcel Nos. 170FEE and 170TCE (Fiscal Impact: $22,879.25.) Meeting Date: 10/27/2009 9:00:00 AM Approved By Kevin Hendricks Right Of Way Acquisition Manager Date Transportation Services TECM -ROW 10/8/2009 3:56 PM Approved By OMB Coordinator Lisa Taylor Management/Budget Analyst Date Transportation Services Transportation Administration 10/912009 9:16 AM Approved By Najeh Ahmad Director Date County Attorney Transportation Engineering 8 10/14/2009 12:32 PM Transportation Services Construction Management 10112!2009 3:17 PM Approved By Executive Secretary Date Norm E. Feder, AICP Transportation Division Administrator Date Transportation Services Transportation Services Admin. 1011312009 9:35 AM Approved By OMB Coordinator Therese Stanley Grants Coordinator Date Transportation Transportation Administration 1011 312009 11:20 AM Approved By Robert N. Zachary Assistant County Attorney Date County Attorney County Attorney Office 10/14/2009 12:32 PM Approved By Pat Lehnhard Executive Secretary Date Transportation Services Transportation Services Admin 10/14/2009 1:43 PM Approved By OMB Coordinator OMB Coordinator Date County Manager's Office Office of Management & Budget 10/1412009 1:50 PM Approved By Jeff Klatzkow County Attorney Date file: / /C: \AgendaTest \Export\137- October 27,2009\16. CONSENT AGENDA \16B. TRAN... 10/21/2009 County Attorney County Attorney Office Page 2 of 2 Agenda Item No. 16135 October 27, 2009 Page 4 of 22 10/1412009 2:17 PM Approved By Susan Usher Senior Management/Budget Analyst Date County Manager's Office Office of Management & Budget 10/16/2009 5:53 PM Approved By Mark Isackson Budget Analyst Date County Manager's Office Office of Management & Budget 10119/2009 9:15 AM file: / /C:\AgendaTest \Export \137- October 27,2009\16. CONSENT AGENDA \16B. TRAN... 10/21/2009 06/15/2009 15:19 8136432612 TO: Joan Smith BELL_APA 1 EL LAW OFFICE OF BELLA. Y. P.ATEL 13026 Waterford Rua Drive Riverview, Florida 33569 (813) 643 -2762 !"AX (813) 643 -2612 Email Address: BellaPateiPA@aaa.eom RE: Collier Blvd, #68056 — Brown Parcel 170Pee /170TCE Fax Number: 239 -252 -6652 From: Bella Y. Patel, Esquire Date: June 15, 2009 'hone Number: (813) 643 -2762 Fax Number: (813) 643 -2612 Total pages, including cover: 18 CO,,MNIENTS Dear Ms. Smith, ❑ Urgent ❑ Reply ASAP L3 Please review and comment ❑ For your information ❑ Facsimile and email ❑ Facsimile Only ❑ Original to follow via US Mail Agenda Item No. 1685 October 27, 2009 Page 5 of 22 PAGE 01 Enclosed are the experts' invoices and Bella's invoice regarding the above referenced property. Thank you, Elaine Johns Assistant to and for Bella Y. Patel, Esquire INTORTANTNOTIM The information contained in the facsimile is iatcnded only for the personal and confidential use of the designated recipient(s) named above, The facsimile may contain information that is privileged, confidential or othcrwise protected from disclosure, If the reader of this facsimile is not the designated recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution, or copy of the said facsimile is-prohibited. If you receive this in error, please notify us immediately by telephone and return the facsimile tdi�above addrzss via U.S. mail. Thank you, 06/15/2009 15:19 6136432612 BELLAPATEL INVOICE BELLA Y. PATEL, P.A. 13026 Waterford Run Drive Riverview, Florida 33569 Ph. (813) 643 -2762 Fax (813) 643 -2612 Collier County Attorney's Office Robert Zachary, Esquire 3301 E. Tamiami Trail Naples, FL 34112 REFERENCE: Collier Boulevard #68056 Parcel No. 170Fee and 170TCE Gerald and Rosemary Brown Agenda Item No, 1685 October 27, 2009 Page 6 of 22 PAGE 03 "Rate $275/hr D�T� M _ ,..: ,. :N SII►i�E�i 10/ Sign client and open rile 1 5 $ 412.50 10/812007 Advise County of authorization and reauest 0.51 $ 137.50 documents 1019/2009 Hire horticulturist, discuss Parcel 0 5 $ 137.50 10/22/2007 Hire FF &E *X rt; discuss percel 0.5 $ 137.50 Dec. 2007 lReceived and reviewed FF &E report 1.5 $ 412.50 1 211 8/2 0 0 7 Sent FF &E report to client w/ cor7espondence 0.a $ 137.50 Ito review 1 f2/20081 Received and reviewed Collier Countv's 0.5 $ 137.50 notification 1/2/2008 Email sent to Countv appraiser re: parcels; 0.5 $ 137.50 scheduling inspections with our office 1/3/2008 Correspondence with client reaardina the 1,5.-$ 412.50 County Notification, correspon ence to County - reaarding receiving notification and scheduling inspections 1/7/2008 Hire engineer: discuss parcel 0.5 137.50 1/17/2008 Hire surveyor; discuss instructions 0.�J $ 137.50 2/26/2008 Receive horticulturalist report. review: mail report 25 $ 687.50 to clients for review 2/27/2008 Receive email from our engineer reauestina 1 $ 275.00 parcel r/w information; requested information from County 2/29/2008 Reoelve email from our engineer followin2 up an 1 275.00 reauest for maps 3/3120081 Requested rtw maps from County 051 $ 137.50 4 1 one call from client re: status of project 0.5 137.50 411412008 1 Phone call to client to discuss status 0.5 $ 137.50 611 11200al Mail out update to client re: status of project 1 1 5 275,00 SUBTOTAL 15.51 5 4,262.50 05/15/2009 15:19 8136432612 BELLAPATEL Agenda Item No. 1685 October 27, 2009 Page 7 of 22 PAGE 04 INVOICE BELLA Y. PATEL, P.A. 13026 Waterford Run Drive Riverview, Florida 33569 Ph. (813) 643 -2762 Fax (813) 643 -2612 Collier County Attorney's Office Robert Zachary, Esquire 3301 E. Tarniarni Trail Naples, FL 34112 REFERENCE: Collier Boulevard #68056 Parcel No. 170Fee and 170TCE Page 2 'Rate $275/hr _ aw r'F40UR;: N t 6/231200$ Receive and review Umcial 1, urchase offer from 1, 5 S 4 County: discuss offerwith cient June. 2009 _ Discuss enoineerinq issue with expert 0.51 $ 137.50 7/3/2008 Receive email from our engineer requesting 0.5 $ 137.50 stormwater drainage calculations 7/3/2008 Rgquested stormwater drainage calculations 0.5 $ 137.50 fmm County 7/7/2008 Received email from County re: our request for 0.5 $ 137.50 stormwater drainaae calculations 719/2008 gire appraiser, discuss the parcel 0.5 $ 137.50 7/14/2008 Receive and review survey suggest changes 1 275.00 7/15/2006 Follow up email to County re: stormwater 0.5 77 ralnage ca cu ation request 7/22/2058 Forward engrneerinq report to appraiser discuss 0.5 S 137.50 7/25/2008 Mail correspondence and engineennq report to 1 5.00 client and discuss with client 19/2008 Email with appraiser re: proverkv inspection 0 $ 137.50 9/12/2008 one con T. with client re: aporaisal 01 137. 0 geot. 2008 22-Sep-05 Ravi ew anpraisa report _ eat appraisal report to avent: requested 1 0.5 ffi 275.00 13T50 settlement con me is ion eceiv and responded o email from County 0. 137.5 spent re: appraisal repo , disc, ss with client 1 011 3/2068q mail sent to our engineer regar rag report 0.5 _ 137.5 20 Email sea to endricks re: the 5 .5 137,50 sitE meetings an review o our Sppn &sal 10/1412058 hone cont. with client re: our request for 1 $ 275,00 me iation / Email to K. Hendricks reques inq me iation date 0.5 137. $ TAL 5 j,437.00 Agenda Item No. 16135 October 27, 2009 Page 8 of 22 06/15/2009 15:19 813643261'7 BELLAPATEL PAGE 05 INVOICE BELLA Y. PATEL, P.A. 13426 Waterford Run Drive Riverview, Florida 33569 Ph. (813) 643 -2762 Fax (813) 643 -2612 Collier County Attorney's Office Robert Zachary, Esquire 3301 E. Tamiami Trail Naples, FL 34112 REFERENCE: Collier Boulevard #68056 Parcel No. 170Fee and 170TCE Gerald and Rosemary Brown Page 3 "Rate $275/hr 1211/2008 Correspondence to cliet regarding values and 0.51 137,50 mediation dates 1211!2008 Mailed appraisal report to K Hendricks; 0.5 $ 137.50 requested mediation dates 12/5/2006 Phone call from client re_ mediation dates 0.5 $ 137.50 12/15/2008 Email to K. Hendricks requesting settlement 0.5 $ 137.50 conference/mediation dates 12/17/2008 Received and reviewed email from K. Hendricks 0.5 $ 137.50 re: values 1/12/2008 Phone conf with client re: values and mediation 0.5 $ 137.50 dates 1/3012009 Letter to Mr. Klatzkow regardina requesting 1 $ 275.00 settlement conference /mediation 1/30/20091 Letter to client re: correspondence with the 2 S 550.00 (County; Mr. Klatzkow and K. Hendricks request- ing settlement conf /mediation 2/23120091 Email sent to K, Hendricks re: swales /ditches, 0.5 $ 137.56 construction plans, etc. Received email from K. Hendricks re: design of­ 0.5 $ 137.50 swales, etc. 3/24/2009 Email to K. Hendricks regarding update /status 0.5 $ 13750 on client's parcel 3/25/2009 Email received from K. Hendricks re: followin 0.5 $ 137.50 uD on status 5/4/2009 _ Phone call from client re: status 0.5 $ 137,50 5/6/2009 Email to agent re: decision on drainage ditch by 0.51 S 137.50 the County, discuss with client 5120120091 Receive and review email from agent re: changes 0.5 $ 137.50 Ito be made to design, discuss with client I _ SUB -TOTAL 9.5 S 2,612.50 06/15/2009 15:19 8136432612 3ELLAPATEL INVOICE BELLA Y. PATEL, P.A. 13026 Waterford Run Drive Riverview, Florlda 33569 Ph. (8 13) 643 -2762 Fax (1313) 643 -2612 Collier County Attomey's Office Robert Zachary, Esquire 3301 E. Tamiami Trail Naples, FL 34112 REFERENCE, Collier Boulevard #68056 Parcel No. 170Fee and 170TCE i Agenda Item No, 16135 October 27, 2009 Page 9 of 22 PAGE 06 vPage.4; �ar�lal *Rate $2751hr vc,a Mt , W—v OK_...,, 5/2012009 ', . ,. forward County's email to engineer for review 0.5 $ 137-50 5/21/2009 Phone conf with client discussing County's 0.5 $ 137.50 desi n 6/212046 Phone conf with client re: client's request to 0.5 $ 137.50 s ak with the County 6/3/2009 Email to K. Hendricks requesting a phone conf. 0.5 $ 137.50 with fella and client to discuss property 6/4/2009 Received email from K. Hendricks re: redesign 0.5 $ 137.50 of the projects water management system, discuss with client 61412009 Email from agent regarding si nificant changes 0.5 $ 137.50 to be made, discuss with client 6/4/2009 J 137.60 6/412009 Email from agent discussing changes in process 0.5 $ 137.50 that will reduce, athwavisidewalk; will not effect property 616/2009 Forward the County's response to client re: the 0.5 $ 137.50 design change and not effecting property 6,15/2009 Email to a ent requesting.new design drawings 0.5 $ 137.50 6/5/2009 Email from agent notfying notifying us to close our file 0.5 $ 137.50 and submit invoices, discuss with client 6.x5/'1009 i0iscussed the design plan with engineer 0.5 $ 137.50 6/5/2009 Verifying with County that client's property will 0.5 $ 137.50 not be effected by widening 6812009 Re uested revised enoineerin plans from K. 0.5 $ 137.54 Hendricks re_ client's parcel 6/8/2009 Received email from K. Hendricks re: new plans. 2 $ 550.00 reviewed the same, forwarded plans to engineer for review and res onse. SUB -TOTAL 9 $ 2,475.40 06/15/2009 15:19 8136432612 BELLAPATEL Agenda Item No. 16135 October 27, 2009 Page 10 of 22 PAGE 07 INVOICE BELLA Y. PATEL, P.A. 13025 Waterford Run Drive Rlvervlew, Florida 33599 Ph. (813) 643 -2762 Fax (813) 643 -2612 Collier County Attomey's Office Page 5 Robert Zachary, Esquire 3301 E. Tamiami Trail Naples, FL 34112 REFERENCE: Collier Boulevard #68056 Parcel No. 170Fee and 170TCE *Rate $275/hr Gerald and Rosemary Brown i3kil.:.._ IF�#'Tit3!! ff.11 AAllltQlUt�iT 619/2009 Received engineer's analysis on the new design 05 $ 137.50 plans re: client's property 6/9/2009 Sent official notification to client that the County 0.5 $ 137.50 will not arAuire property 6/9/2009 Close file and submit invoices, negotiate invoices 6 S 1,650.00 of experts, distribute funds to experts SUB -TOTAL 7 $ 1,925.00 06/1512009 15:19 8186492612 6ELLAPATEL INVOICE BELLA Y. PATEL, P.A. 13026 Waterford Run Drive Riverview, Florida 33569 Ph. (813) 643 -2762 Fax (813) 643 -2612 Collier County Attorney's Office Robert Zachary, Esquire 3301 E. Tamiami Trail Maples, FL 34112 REFERENCE: Collier Blvd. #68056 Parcel No. 170Fee /170TCE i Agenda Item No. 1665 October 27, 2009 Page 11 of 22 PAGE 02 "Rate $275/hr NT Pa e 1 Sub -Total 15.5 $ 4,262.50 Page 2 Sub -Total 12.5 $ 3,437.50 Page 3 Sub -Total 9.5 $ 2,612.50 Page 4 Sub -Total 9 $ 2.475.00 Page 5 Sub -rata! 7 $ 1,925.00 Invoice Total 53.5 $ 14,71250 Agenda Item No. 1685 i October 27, 2009 Page 12 of 22 06/15/2009 15:19 8136432612 SELLAPATEL PAGE 08 Van Horn & Associates, Inc., Land Suveyors 12610 Sydney Road Dover, FL 33527 Phonc: 8131684 -4565 or 813!413 -5494 Fax; 813/567 -5578 dan@varLhornstirveying.com Bella Y. Patel, Esquire Bella ,(. Patel, P.A. 13026 Waterford Run Drive Riverview, FL 33569 INvo10E Dated: Suns: 9, 2009 lt. voice#- 1652 ' lob#: 2008.005 4055 1st Ave SW, Naples ('Gerald & Rosernary Brown) Parcel 9170 01117/08 Secretarial - lb - :Prepare File -.5 hrs Cc), $55.00 /hr $27.50 01.117(08 Professional Land Surveyor - Set Up File, Research Deeds - 1.0 hrs @ $150,00 $1.5 0.00 /br 03/01/08 Field Crew - Set Up Baseline, Property Lire & Beech Run • 8.0 hrs @ $720.00 $90.00 /ht 03x29/08 Field Crew - Topographic Survey oflmprov-etneMs - 8,0 hrs @ $90.00/11r $720.00 04/28/08 Auto Cad Technician - dvh - Drawing - 8.0 Ilrs @ y75.00 1hr $600.00 04/29/08 Professional I-and Surveyor - dvh - Review Drawing - 2.0 hrs @r $150.00 /hr $300,00 07/02/08 Field Crew - Measure [louse and Driveway - 4.0 hrs C $90,00 /hr $360.00 07/03/08 Auto Cad Technician - cw - Added House & Drive -21.0 hrs @ S75.00 /hr $150.00 07/03/08 Professional Land Surveyor - dvh - Review Revision - 1.0 hr @ $150.00 /hr $150.00 Subtotal: 53,177,50 Credit for Payments Received: $0.00 Amount Due: $3,177.50 Agenda Item No. 1685 October 27, 2009 Page 13 of 22 06/15/2009 15:19 8136432612 BELLAPATEL PAGE 09 CAWTHRA CONSULTING & APPRAISALS, INC. Professional Consultants for Commerce and Industry November 28, 2007 Bella Y. Patel, Esq, 13026 Waterford Run Dr. Riverview, FL 33509 Subject: invoice Request for Payment of Work Tasks to Date Construction Cost Estimate Re, Brawn Property 4055 1 It Avenue SW Naples, Florida 34119 Activities including but not limited to: physical inspection of the facility, coordination with legal counsel, real estate appraiser and business concern's principal. Field description of facility, descriptions, measurements and layout drawing and photographs plus exhibits. Development of reproduction replacement and estimated costs. Report writing and assembly of findings. Total Request for Payment Work Tasks to bate ............................. ............................... $1,875 (per attached Time Sheet, 15 man -hours x $125 per hour = $1,675.00) CERTIFICATION I certify that the preceding charges have been performed and that none of these charges have been previously reimbursed and that all activities, work tasks, and expenditures comply with the authorized contract and wit he contractual scope of services and /or have been performed by direction from the client a r legal counsel. Charles E. Cawthra III, ASA President, Senior Appraiser SS#266 -87 -2375 6080 Eagles Nast Drive • Jupiter, Florida 33458 (561) 746 -5708 •Fax: (561) 746 -5105 • (888) 950-6 950 -6597 AswW141 �„�„��y�,,,, pafvr,,,,� E- mail:charles@c;awthr&c.com as x..a •.xd eaareW, 06/15/2009 15:19 8136432612 Property: Brown Property 4055 1 ""Avenue Sw Naples, Florida 34119 Client: Bella Y. Patel, Esq. Agenda Item No. 1685 October 27, 2009 Page 14 of 22 FELLAPATEL PAGE 10 TIME SHEET Cawthra Consulting & Appraisals, Inc. Page 2 of 2 Day Date Activity Hours Fri 11/23/07 Physical inspection of the facility, coordination with attorney, business 2.5 owners /on -site manager. Descriptions and review of Fixtures, equipment and layout drawing plus photographs. C.E, Cawthra 111, 12 :00 PM — 2:30 PM Mon 11/26/07 Development of Technical Cost, estimatelreproduction replacement 6.0 cast new. Contact with manufacturers and dealers, comparable data sales research., estimate of cost of the facility. C,E. Cawthra 111, 9:00 AM — 12:00 PM, 2:00 PM — 5:00 PM Tue 11/27/07 Final report data research, report conclusions, report writing, cost and 5.5 value review of assets, report assembly, G.E. Cawthra 111, 9:00 AM — 11:30 AM, 2:30 PM — 5:30 PM 11123107 Telephone coordination with owner's attorney, real estate appraisers, 1.0 to business valuation consultants, construction/cost estimator and traffic present engineer. Assembly of all reports, work product papers, data and information for status of case. Total Hours Work Tasks to Date 15.0 (invoice 15 hours x $125 per hour = $1,875.00) CAWTW(A CONSULTING & APPRAISALS, LNc, Professional Consultants for Commerce aad Industry Fixture & Equipment Appraisals 06/15/2009 15:19 8136432612 BELLAPATEL Feb 21 08 09s Sa Stan DeF'rettas tf 1 Y 303 Arlington Avenue, West O!d- .tmar, F!- 34677 Stan LsPreltas October 9.2007 Arbod!st UIC Work Performed for: Bella Y. Patel, P.A. 13026 Weterfbrd Run T?rive Riverview, FL 33569 Agenda Item No. 1665 October 27, 2009 Page 15 of 22 PAGE 11 P.n DATE WC1l2K,2&-9CWFT1QN �s. GCN_T 10 -9-2007 Case Review BROWN, GERALD and ROSEMARY Collier County /Parcel 1O 4.5 675.00 10 -25 -2007 Site inspection. 4055 2" Ave.. SW irs Maples. FL 34190 Plant material count/photos/tmeasuremenm 6 900.00 11 -5 -2007 Met w/Willow Tree Nursery /Tree Mart Plant material value /comparison 4.5 675.00 12 -13 -2007 Pin. Cty Extension Service /plant ID Met Wvrban horticulturist 5.75 862.50 1 -21 -2008 Case review photos current values 4.5 675-00 2 -20 -2008 Report/review 6.25 ?37.5 TOTAL 31_50 S 4,725.00 r Stan DeFreitasvffarticul gist Arbori;,t 813 -$25 -3030 Fax: 813-9x53031 I .. 06/15/2009 15:19 8136432612 RELLAPATEL Calhoun, ColfisW'4 Parhaniv i1ne:. 10151 Doerwood F'ilrk F104A-?ve7j (y But/ding 200, SUN(,, ?X) 1--7orilij 42256-0 )67 phorlo: (904), 76,d-0I?00 ?,()I) F,vq, (009) ;?60-3140 r:F7x: (90411 754 17006 'oij F1 t4j�.' (0001 200-El Apt' 06 Agenda Item No. 16B5 October 27, 2009 Page 16 of 22 PAGE 12 7 77 3(>t/ltT e-'lVYJ0J 01WO Saito 8(10 • Wort Te,)—r W,jf pr�Jrtj VW)ri(M XW01 f-tj()nq: (5()fl 00f) -3176 Toll Frfm, (,9()(,)) 2610-8140 i'vK 909--,'(177 Ms, 1-3eiia fated Attorney at L-aw 132C>6 Waterford Rk,in DrlvF; Riverview Florida 33569 (CULL IER SLVID) 17() COUN", COLL!EH r-If 11 j-'Vo '3015 N N7 0! C E LN � f k. -, ff 0 ( RS collistor. j 0 75 W!yt",rs' n, 10.75 Bull-,Ke, Ci. 4, (: 0 Total Invoice Arnount prc)-rwed with other' roh(tt) C.r,.ScN Ref TL ST,717-07AL v of5,00 $2,L) (3 `64,:351• Sincn ly, �i r n e i ­1 06/15/2009 15:19 8136432612 BELLAPATEL Agenda Item No. 1665 October 27, 2009 Page 17 of 22 PAGE 13 -- -- -A-� -- °" _ J_SS COLLISTER OWNER BROWN FILE,NO 3015 PROJECT" CR 951 (COLLIER BLVD) jpA R c L(S) 170 COUNTY COLLIER ,TOURS DATE TYPE OrSFRVIC s 2 25 INSPECT 2120!2008 SUBJECT PROPERTY AND SURROUNDING MARKET AREA. SU ALSO IN ATTENDANCE WAS BRETT MEYERS AND TO HARRISON. 7/14/2008 ASSIST WITH DATA RESEARCH, 8/1/2008 ADDITIONAL DATA RESEARCH. pHyCALLY ©CO 8/1112008 PREPARED FOR THEN LAND SALES THROUG OUPT COLL ERI IMpRtJ UNTY. WITH SUBJECT VARIOUS ISSUES OF CASE. . BRETT MEYRS TO DILUSS RE- INSPECT SUBJECT PROPERTY. 9/4/2008 11/11/2008 DICTATION OF VALUATION AND ANALYSIS SECTIONS OF APPRAISAL. 11/12/2008 ASSIST WITH FINALIZING REPORT. TOTAL HOURS 1.25 1,00 2.00 0.25 2.00 1.aa 9.75 Agenda Item No. 16135 October 27, 2009 Page 18 of 22 15 /2' 0 09 15:19 81 ? -1 _ 2 b 12 PAGE 14 BRET] MEYERS 0 i PR(-)JF,CT (','R 9,51 (COLIJER 13',Tl1)) PA Rlf'71.T(N) 170 coum'y OF S.r, R VICE, TIOURS _�R=A TED'SALES C(---)I-jNTY LAND SALES, 1.00 C, T'7: D f ALFS RE-SEARCH " A N T i-A N 0 S CONID!lll1:1TE*0 ON r= ORECLOSURE PROPERTIES IN 0.75 N TY i., 'r i L I ry-PRAC. 2/11/2006 CONDUCTED S(jBjEC,r vAESEARCH IN COLLIER COUNTY 075 INCLUDING TAX r'40RDS -T-,'kX MAPS, DEEDS, AND AERIALS, 2/20/2008 CONDUCTED PHYSIUAL iNSFEC-1 i6N OF SUBJECT 2.50 PROPERTY IN COLLIER COUNTY. TOOK PHOTOGRAPFIS AND FIELD NOTFS AE-IP,,AiS-Al_ REPORT, 21211200,9 ORGANIZE _'. / -SE ',.IA_FzRIAL. CONDUCTED VACANT L AND 0.25 SAILS PESE,^RCH 3/1012 00 e COND' _,ICTED IMPROVPD RESIDENTIAL SALES RESEARCH IN 1.50 FY 0/1 1;2008 "-"0N[„JC-T ED IMPROVED RESIDENTIAL SALES RESEARCH. 1.50 1.25 "C 5, R F, 3 1_A R C H. 7/1 1/2008 RC--S0EN:TIAL SALES 1.00 R, E S E_ A 9 C 1 IN C 7 Y 7/30/21008 ,ND ,�"Al �-S, RESEARCH N 0 — I COLLIER 0,50 Ij N TY 8/11!2008 �)J: C!'L)VIPW\/\SLE LAND AND 2,00 -WED SALES IN COLLIER COUNTY, f :MPR( 8 i2 0 00 JET C IF L'a,ND SALES, 2.25 9/1912008 VIERIFICA I FION 01_'GufvlPARAB1_E LAND SALES. 1,75 1.75 1 r)/2 L PEART' jl')L R'S 19.75 06/15/2009 15:19 8136432612 BELLAPATEL Agenda Item No. 16B5 October 27, 2009 Page 19 of 22 PAGE 15 BRENDAN BURKE ow1V.i;R BROWN FILE NO 3015 PROJECT Glt 9S1 (C�)/.LIEs'R BLVD) pARCL^L(S) 170 COUNTY COLLIE XXOURS 1?ATE :,C'YPL OFS'l,-RVXCE OF CONDEMNOR LAND SALES. 0.50 7!1112008 CREATED AERIAL EXHIBITS FORMATION INTO THE SALES 1.00 8/29/2008 INPUT COMPARABLE DATABASE USE IN THE ADDENDA OF THE AP RAISAL REPURT• IMPROVED SALES INFORMATION 0.25 812912008 VERIFIED COMPARABLE /SELLING AGENT, GRA�ITC�ROOR WITH THE LISTING MAPS AND APPRAISAL THE ADDOENDA OF THE E EXHIBITS FOR USE REPORT. INPUT COMPARABLE SALE INFORMATION INTO) THE SALES ,) 25 9/2/2008 DATABASE AND BEGAN VERIFYING /PROPERTY INFORMATION WITH GRANTEE TRANSACTION OR GRANTORS OF COMPARAALE SALES. VERIFIED COMPARABLE SALE INFORMATION WITH 1.00 9!3!2008 GRANTEES /GRANTORS OF THE TRANSACTIONS AND CREATED MAPS AND EXHIBITS FOR COMPARABLE SALES. W.- 4.00 TOTAL HOURS 06/15/2009 15:19 8136432612 SELLAPATEL INVOICE Gerald and Rosemary Brown / Parcel 170 October 10, 2008 Ms. Bella Y. Patel, Esquire 13026 Waterford River Run Drive Riverview, F133569 RE: Itern/Segment: State /County Road County: Parcel No.: Property Owner: Property Address: 68056 Collier Boulevard (CR -951) Collier 170 Gerald and Rosemary Brown 4055 1 st Avenue Southwest Naples, Florida 34119 Agenda Item No. 16135 October 27, 2009 Page 20 of 22 PAGE 16 rp Ff �?f CCT T U fill � U, This invoice is for all costs and fees for the Engineering Report, Redevelopment Plan and services provided for the above case as of October 10, 2008. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to call. Sincerely, Patricia H. Harrison, MBA Page 1 MTI"'t 3" e'.1 �.'.:. PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER 26 $150 $3,900 DRAFTSMAN 9 $75 $675 TOTAL $4,575 If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to call. Sincerely, Patricia H. Harrison, MBA Page 1 06/1512009 15:19 8136432612 Professional Engineer SELLAPATEL INVOICE Gerald and RosemarY Brown / Parcel 170 October 10, 2008 Jan 12, 2008 MEETING, ACCEPT AND OPEN CASE Feb 15, 2008 PRINT RIGHT OF WAY AND CONSTRUCTION DRAWINGS Feb 20, 2008 SITE INSPECTION WITH COUNTY APPRAISER Feb 24, 2008 SITE INSPECTION, MEASUREMENTS, PHOTOGRAPHS May 23, 2008 PREPARE PRELIMINARY REPORT May 24, 2008 PREPARE PRELIMINARY REPORT May 25, 2008 PREPARE PRELIMINARY REPORT Jun 27, 2008 PLAN, TAKE AND COSESTIMATE QUANTITY OFF AND Jun 30, 2008 MEETING WITH EXPERTS AND ATTORNEY PREPARE PRELIMINARY REPORT REVIEW SFWMD STORMWATER PERMIT Jul 17,2008 Jul 21,2008 Oct 3, 2008 TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH APPRAISER PREPARE FINAL REPORT Oct 6, 2008 Page 2 Agenda Item No. 1685 October 27, 2009 Page 21 of 22 PAGE 17 TOTAL 0.5 1.5 0.5 2 4 4 4 3 0.75 2.75 1 0.5 1.5 26 Agenda Item No. 16135 October 27, 2009 Page 22 of 22 06/15/2009 15:19 8136432612 SELLAPATEL PAGE 18 INVOICE Gerald and Ros.-Mary Brown / Parcel 170 October 10, 2008 Draftsmar> ..t ai Frll �rfrY} r FY< 71t; .,) 213 11' n }y 5 Jan 24, 2008 PREPARE EXHIBITS 3 Jan 28, 2008 PREPARE EXHIBITS 2 Feb 4, 2008 PREPARE EXHIBITS 2.75 Feb 6, 2008 PREPARE EXHIBITS 1.25 TOTAL 9 Page 3