Taylor - Item #9A Ex parte Items - Commissioner Penny Taylor
COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AGENDA
June 11 , 2019
ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS
9.A. This item requires that all participants be sworn in and ex parte disclosure be
provided by Commission members. Recommendation to approve an Ordinance
amending Ordinance Number 2004-41, as amended, the Collier County Land
Development Code, which established the comprehensive zoning regulations
for the unincorporated area of Collier County, Florida, by amending the
appropriate zoning atlas map or maps by changing the zoning classification of
the herein described real property from a Rural Agricultural (A) Zoning District
to a Mixed Use Planned Unit Development (MPUD) Zoning District for the
project to be known as the Baumgarten MPUD, to allow construction of a
maximum of 400 multifamily and/or townhouse residential dwelling units and
up to 270,000 square feet of commercial land uses at the southeast quadrant of
Immokalee Road and Collier Boulevard, in Section 26, Township 48, Range 26,
Collier County, Florida, consisting of 55.66+/- acres; and by providing an
effective date. [Baumgarten MPUD, PL20170000768] (This is a companion to
Agenda Item 11.A) (District 3, District 5)
NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM
SEE FILE ®Meetings ><Correspondence Xe-mails XCalls
Meeting with Developer and developer's attorney on Monday, June 10, 2019.
Many emails from constituents, monitored the Planning Commission meetings
CONSENT AGENDA
1.6A.18 This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission
members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to
be sworn in. Recommendation to approve for recording the final plat of
Currents of Naples an Esplanade Community — Phase 1, (Application Number
PL20180003018) approval of the standard form Construction and Maintenance
Agreement and approval of the amount of the performance security. (District 1)
D{ NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM
SEE FILE Meetings I (Correspondence I le-mails Calls
SUMMARY AGENDA
17.B. This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by the Commission
members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to
Ex parte Items - Commissioner Penny Taylor
COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AGENDA
June 11 , 2019
be sworn in. Recommendation to approve A Resolution of the Collier County
Board of County Commissioners amending the Town of Ave Maria Stewardship
Receiving Area (SRA) to revise the SRA master plan in accordance with Section
4.08.07.F.4 of the Land Development Code, and specifically to: remove from the
boundary of the SRA 12.19 acres of neighborhood general in the northeast
corner of the SRA; remove from the eastern boundary of the SRA .55 acres of
neighborhood general, at the intersection of Camp Keais Road and Pope John
Paul II Boulevard; and to add to the southern boundary of the SRA 12.74 acres
of neighborhood general, to the south of Bellerawalk Circle; and to revise
Appendix A of the Town Plan, the legal description. The subject property is
located north of Oil Well Road and west of Camp Keais Road in Sections 31
through 33, Township 47 South, Range 29 East and Sections 4 through 9 and
16 through 18, Township 48 South, Range 29 East in Collier County, Florida.
(District 5)
X NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM
SEE FILE I !Meetings I 'Correspondence le-mails Calls
17.C. This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission
members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to
be sworn in. Recommendation to approve Petition VAC-PL20180003283, to
disclaim, renounce and vacate the County and the public interest in a portion of
the Park and Preserve Area located in Block "K" and a portion of the Drainage
Easement located in Tract "N" of Royal Wood Golf and Country Club, Unit One,
as recorded in Plat Book 15, page 16 and a portion of the Drainage Easement
located in Tract "N" of Royal Wood Golf and Country Club, Unit Two, as
recorded in Plat Book 15, page 19 of the public records of Collier County,
Florida, located in the northwest quadrant of Rattlesnake Hammock Road and
Santa Barbara Boulevard in Section 17, Township 50 South, Range 26 East,
Collier County, Florida and to accept Petitioner's grant of a Conservation
Easement to replace the vacated portion of the Park and Preserve Area and
Drainage Easements. (District 1)
X NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM
SEE FILE Meetings Correspondence le-mails [ 'Calls
February 25, 2019
To: The Board of Commissioners of Collier County:
Burt L Saunders (District 3)Vice Chairman
Donna Fiala (District 1) Andy Solis Esq. (District 2) Penny Taylor(District 4)
William L. McDaniel (District 5) Chairman Mike Bosi : Zoning Director
RE: PUDZ-PL20170000768, Pelican Nursery Mixed-use Planned Unit Development (MPUD)
Dear Board of Commissioners,
Recently, via petition,the residents and property owners of Tuscany Cove have brought to your attention
the many concerns that our community has with the proposed PUD rezone application for commercial and
residential development of the 54-56 acres located at the South East corner of Collier Blvd & Immokalee Road,
the site where Pelican Nursery had been for many years.
Thank you in advance for your time and serious deliberation on this matter.
1. PLEASE SAY"NO"to HIGH DENSITY,MULTI-STORY DEVELOPMENT
The COMMISSIONERS SHOULD HOLD ANY CURRENTLY PLANNED and FUTURE PROPOSED PROJECT at the
corner of Immokalee Rd. and Collier Blvd to the CORRECT LIMITS, PROPER ZONING RESTRICTIONS, and
UTMOST SAFETY CONCERNS.
The proposed 400 multi-family residential units, a possible 100-150 room hotel, medical offices, restaurants, any
other commercial entities would overwhelm and NEGATIVELY IMPACT our already heavily saturated &
trafficked area. In the past few years, nine (9) residential communities and MANY commercial enterprises have
been developed at the corner of Immokalee Rd. and Collier Blvd. and environs — without the full consideration
of 1)the impact of the heavily increased traffic, or 2)enough improvement to the surrounding infrastructure
to accommodate such growth, or 3)the detrimental effect on our quality of life.
As someone who has lived and worked in business in North Naples, Collier County throughout the 1990s and
again since 2017, I am not naïve to development; however, it is somewhat surprising that Collier County
government (which seemed to pride itself for decades on attracting upscale developments and businesses,
taking into consideration zoning sensitivities and environmental concerns as well as financial gain)would
increasingly consider real estate development plans to degrade our beautiful area into a "Miami-type" high-
density SPRAWL. Wise regulation and reasonably-paced community growth will result in attracting discerning
tourists,snowbirds,and full-time residents who will enjoy the higher property values (converts to higher taxes
and revenues for the county)of the well-planned, upscale communities with amenities — including a decent
percentage of required adjacent open space with lower building density and single-story height ordinances.
This translates into long-term, positive,financial investment in our local economy. When did these sound
values change? Make NOTE,the voting citizens of Naples do not want to be Miami!
Developing and expanding the density of structures on the SE corner of Immokalee Rd. and Collier Blvd.
would compound the already serious traffic problem.This is UNSAFE and unacceptable to us as citizens who
moved this far out east to be away from the gridlock of Tamiami Trail, and the skyscrapers and multi-
story/multi-unit developments closer to the Gulf. When daily life becomes a hardship of this degree, the result is
that the very people(and resulting$dollars)that Collier County government has already attracted here may
very well choose another, more desirable, safer area to live and work. BAD WORD OF MOUTH is not
something we can afford. The resultant loss of LIFE, time, reputation, and money is not worth it, is it?
Page 2 of 2
2. PLEASE REVIEW/IMPROVE TRAFFIC FLOW and SAFETY at U-turns, especially at ENTRANCE OF
TUSCANY COVE and at the major intersection of Immokalee Rd. and Collier Blvd
The recent change in allowing U-TURNS at the ENTRANCE OF TUSCANY COVE TO HEAD NORTH MAKES
EXITING AND ENTERING OUR COMMUNITY EXTREMELY DANGEROUS.The traffic heading north on Collier Blvd
is OFTEN BACKED UP from Immokalee Road to our entrance and exit, which creates severe bottlenecks,
gridlock, and increasing accidents. The reports of at least 202 ACCIDENTS —some fatal — over the last two
years, at the Intersection of Collier Blvd and Immokalee Road (and the most recent tragic fatal accident of a
young mother and small child), are most DISTURBING.
Even in the "off" season, there have been daily serious bottlenecks as well as frequent accidents/incidents. This
results in very congested and dangerous intersections, including at the ingress/egress to our small
community.
One of the main reasons we purchased in Tuscany Cove was because our community was not built on a corner
intersection;yet, because of re-routing and dangerous U-turns, we have experienced increased vehicular
traffic from the many commercial businesses and the major intersection of Immokalee Rd. and Collier Blvd., as if
we were a major intersection.This is NOT SAFE URBAN PLANNING. With the very busy Emergency Room at the
NE corner, a life-death hazardous situation can occur,when ambulances and other emergency vehicles (and
residents/visitors in their own vehicles who are trying to get to the hospital) have increasing difficulty getting
through the gridlock!
Please do not allow this slippery slope of detrimental urban planning that is NOT IN THE BEST INTEREST of our
citizens,tourists, and upscale businesses who have already invested in our community.This is unbecoming to
our treasured "lifestyle"that brought us here in the first place. Word of mouth travels fast, and as many of us
are not originally from "around here", it is imperative that those in power in government understand the
needs of our existing citizens and protect the positive reputation of Naples.
For the sake of our local community's safety and security— as well as the future positive "lifestyle" image
(and bottom line preservation)of Naples, Collier County, PLEASE REJECT granting variances on building height
and density for ANY proposed structures abutting our development.
The residents and owners of Tuscany Cove and adjacent existing communities hope to hear from you soon with
a positive resolution to protect our interests and our lives.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter.
Respectfully,
C /, 1
Terry Kennedy, owner, uscany Cove unit 15501 Cortona Way, Naples, FL 34120
Former publisher/editor, Naples Guide magazine
January 25, 2019
To: Collier County Commissioners
From: Craig and Michelle Shemon
RE: Development and Immokalee and Collier
My wife and I live in Tuscany Cove near the corner of Immokalee and Collier Blvd.
We are very concerned about future plans for the former Pelican Nursery property
which is owned by Barron Collier Company.
We understand current plans call for sixty-five foot tall/four story apartment buildings
designed to hold four hundred units. We also understand there are plans for an
equally tall hotel. If true, this would suggest improper zoning laws for this area. The
thought of hundreds of people peering down into our private yards of our single story
homes next door is unacceptable. Not to mention the fact that our property values in
Tuscany Cove will plummet drastically if this development is allowed.
Also, the traffic at Immokalee and Collier is unbearable and development along
Collier Blvd., north of the intersection, isn't even complete yet and includes the brand
new Addison Place apartments. Is your goal to cram as many people as possible in
this area? This is getting ridiculous. There were two fatalities at that intersection just
last weekend. Ambulances and accidents are a daily occurrence in our area. Some
mornings, it takes my wife eight minutes to make a simple right hand turn on Collier
just to exit Tuscany Cove.
It is our belief that County Commissioners must put local residences and their quality
of life ahead of local business interests. We will be single issue voters when it comes
to re-election of our local commissioners. How this situation is handled will
determine how we vote.
Our first preference would be for commissioners to hold the line on over-development
of this area and preserve green space. We have lived in concrete jungles like Detroit,
Los Angeles, and Houston. We moved to Naples to get away from overcrowded
cement filled cities to enjoy the quality of life and beauty Naples offers, or at least it
used to offer.
If commercial development on the corner of Immokalee and Collier is a fait accompli
we would suggest a closer look at the development at Immokalee and Logan. All
buildings are single story and remain below the area's tree line. There also appears to
be a large investment in beautiful landscaping. Also, there are no apartments and
hotels there towering over local neighborhoods and exponentially adding to traffic.
Thank you for your attention to this urgent matter.
Regards,
Craig and Michelle Shemon
Tuscany Cove
To: Collier County Commissioners
From:
We currently live in Tuscany Cove which is located near the corner of Collier Blvd.
and Immokalee Road. We have lived in Naples since 1976. The adjacent property
at Immokalee and Collier was owned by Pelican Nursery and is currently owned
by Barron Collier Company. We are concerned about the proposed development
on this property. At two previous meetings, the public was informed that the
developer would like to construct sixty-five-foot-tall apartment buildings for up to
four hundred multi-family units. This would mean four stories and we believe this
is not allowed by current zoning. If allowed that would-be high-rise apartments
right next to the existing one-story homes at Tuscany Cove. Those present, at both
meetings were very concerned about the proposed development. The traffic at this
corner is already a concern. Tuscany Cove is directly behind this proposed development.
No wall structure is planned to separate the properties. We will have to see and hear
not only the construction take place but the after effects of several sixty-five foot
structures, a hotel and commercial businesses behind our homes. If this proposed
development is approved, we would like a high wall and vegetation on the property
line with Tuscany Cove. At this time, there are several home developments, Bent
Creek, Richmond Park and La Morada, next to and just east of the property of concern.
In addition, newly constructed Addison Place apartments are just to the north and
west side of the corner of Immokalee and Collier.
It is discouraging to see the uncontrolled spread of development in our community.
I saw recently where Naples planning advisers were being asked by local community
HOA's to keep a "small town feel". We do not want our community to look like what
has happened to the east coast of Florida. Unfortunately, Naples is headed toward
over-development.
We would like to suggest a park such as Freedom Park on Golden Gate Parkway.
Having green space in this environment would be desirable. Trails for walking and
biking could be established. Picnic and a playground would be beneficial to families
in this area of Collier County. A pond could be established for water retention since
there is a canal adjacent to the property along Collier Blvd. However, this would not
be a money maker for the current owners, so at least decrease their density and have
them add more green space.
Thank you.
To: Collier County Commissioners
From: Thomas & Louise Campo
We currently live in Tuscany Cove which is located near the corner of Collier Blvd.
and Immokalee Road. We have lived in Naples since 2005. The adjacent property
at Immokalee and Collier was owned by Pelican Nursery and is currently owned
by Barron Collier Company. We are concerned about the proposed development
on this property. At two previous meetings, the public was informed that the
developer would like to construct sixty-five-foot-tall apartment buildings for up to
four hundred multi-family units. This would mean four stories and we believe this
is not allowed by current zoning. If allowed that would-be high-rise apartments
right next to the existing one-story homes at Tuscany Cove. Those present, at both
meetings were very concerned about the proposed development. The traffic at this
corner is already a concern. Tuscany Cove is directly behind this proposed development.
No wall structure is planned to separate the properties. We will have to see and hear
not only the construction take place but the after effects of several sixty-five foot
structures, a hotel and commercial businesses behind our homes. If this proposed
development is approved, we would like a high wall and vegetation on the property
line with Tuscany Cove. At this time, there are several home developments, Bent
Creek, Richmond Park and La Morada, next to and just east of the property of concern.
In addition, newly constructed Addison Place apartments are just to the north and
west side of the corner of Immokalee and Collier.
It is discouraging to see the uncontrolled spread of development in our community.
I saw recently where Naples planning advisers were being asked by local community
HOA's to keep a "small town feel". We do not want our community to look like what
has happened to the east coast of Florida. Unfortunately, Naples is headed toward
over-development.
We would like to suggest a park such as Freedom Park on Golden Gate Parkway.
Having green space in this environment would be desirable. Trails for walking and
biking could be established. Picnic and a playground would be beneficial to families
in this area of Collier County. A pond could be established for water retention since
there is a canal adjacent to the property along Collier Blvd. However, this would not
be a money maker for the current owners, so at least decrease their density and have
them add more green space.
Thank you.
To: Collier County Commissioners
From:
I currently live in Tuscany Cove which is located near the corner of Collier Blvd.
and Immokalee Road. We have lived in Naples since 1982. The adjacent property
at Immokalee and Collier was owned by Pelican Nursery and is currently owned
by Barron Collier Company. We are concerned about the proposed development
on this property. At two previous meetings, the public was informed that the
developer would like to construct sixty-five-foot-tall apartment buildings for up to
four hundred multi-family units. This would mean four stories and we believe this
is not allowed by current zoning. If allowed that would-be high-rise apartments
right next to the existing one-story homes at Tuscany Cove. Those present, at both
meetings were very concerned about the proposed development. The traffic at this
corner is already a concern. Tuscany Cove is directly behind this proposed development.
No wall structure is planned to separate the properties. We will have to see and hear
not only the construction take place but the after effects of several sixty-five foot
structures, a hotel and commercial businesses behind our homes. If this proposed
development is approved, we would like a high wall and vegetation on the property
line with Tuscany Cove. At this time, there are several home developments, Bent
Creek, Richmond Park and La Morada, next to and just east of the property of concern.
In addition, newly constructed Addison Place apartments are just to the north and
west side of the corner of Immokalee and Collier.
I am currently under contract to purchase a home being built in Bent Creek. The rear of my
property faces directly West at the NW boundary of Bent Creek, thus this new development
would affect me considerably, both regarding personal quality of life and the market value of
my property. I believe a multilevel Condominium of the projected height and density would
have a dramatic negative effect on me in both regards. I would hope you would not allow this
to happen.
It is discouraging to see the uncontrolled spread of development in our community.
I saw recently where Naples planning advisers were being asked by local community
HOA's to keep a "small town feel". We do not want our community to look like what
has happened to the east coast of Florida. Unfortunately, Naples is headed toward
over-development.
We would like to suggest a park such as Freedom Park on Golden Gate Parkway.
Having green space in this environment would be desirable. Trails for walking and
biking could be established. Picnic and a playground would be beneficial to families
in this area of Collier County. A pond could be established for water retention since
there is a canal adjacent to the property along Collier Blvd. However, this would not
be a money maker for the current owners, so at least decrease their density and have
them add more green space.
Thank you.
Geoffrey Klein
15125 Cortona Way
Naples, FL 34120
Realtor,
Premiere Plus Realty Company
northnaplesrealtor@gmail.com
To: Collier County Commissioners
From: Bertha &Joe Caiazzo
We currently live in Tuscany Cove which is located near the corner of Collier Blvd.
and Immokalee Road. We have lived in Naples since 2005. The adjacent property
at Immokalee and Collier was owned by Pelican Nursery and is currently owned
by Barron Collier Company. We are concerned about the proposed development
on this property. At two previous meetings, the public was informed that the
developer would like to construct sixty-five-foot-tall apartment buildings for up to
four hundred multi-family units. This would mean four stories and we believe this
is not allowed by current zoning. If allowed that would-be high-rise apartments
right next to the existing one-story homes at Tuscany Cove. Those present, at both
meetings were very concerned about the proposed development. The traffic at this
corner is already a concern. Tuscany Cove is directly behind this proposed development.
No wall structure is planned to separate the properties. We will have to see and hear
not only the construction take place but the after effects of several sixty-five foot
structures, a hotel and commercial businesses behind our homes. If this proposed
development is approved, we would like a high wall and vegetation on the property
line with Tuscany Cove. At this time, there are several home developments, Bent
Creek, Richmond Park and La Morada, next to and just east of the property of concern.
In addition, newly constructed Addison Place apartments are just to the north and
west side of the corner of Immokalee and Collier.
It is discouraging to see the uncontrolled spread of development in our community.
I saw recently where Naples planning advisers were being asked by local community
HOA's to keep a "small town feel". We do not want our community to look like what
has happened to the east coast of Florida. Unfortunately, Naples is headed toward
over-development.
We would like to suggest a park such as Freedom Park on Golden Gate Parkway.
Having green space in this environment would be desirable. Trails for walking and
biking could be established. Picnic and a playground would be beneficial to families
in this area of Collier County. A pond could be established for water retention since
there is a canal adjacent to the property along Collier Blvd. However, this would not
be a money maker for the current owners, so at least decrease their density and have
them add more green space.
Thank you.
GrecoSherry
From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com>
Sent: Friday, May 31, 2019 12:47 PM
To: TaylorPenny
Subject: Accepted: Baumgarten (Collier and Immokalee) - Rich Yovanovich & David Genson
(Barron Collier)
1
GrecoSherry
From: Nicole Lauren <nicole.lauren@winknews.com>
Sent: Wednesday, April 17, 2019 9:57 AM
To: TaylorPenny
Subject: 400 homes proposed to be built
Nicole Lauren
Morning Reporter
516-780-1662
https://www.naplesnews.com/story/opinion/editorials/2019/04/15/agendas-week-naples-beach-hotel-redo-
Iee-school-bus-stop-safety/3437518002/
400 homes proposed
On Thursday, the Collier County Planning Commission will get a look at the proposed Baumgarten
development at the southeast corner of Immokalee Road and Collier Boulevard.
The developers are seeking a zoning change for 55 acres of the current Pelican Nursery property to allow
up to 400 apartments and townhouses, a 140-room hotel and up to 370,000 square feet of commercial
space. Under the proposal, building heights could reach up to 65 feet.
County staff say there's adequate road capacity on the adjoining roads to serve the new development.
The planning commission is one step of the approval process. Collier County commissioners will have the
final say.
Agenda:
https://www.colliercountyfl.gov/home/showdocument?id=86350
PL20170000768: An Ordinance of the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida amending
Ordinance Number 2004-41, as amended, the Collier County Land Development Code, which established the
comprehensive zoning regulations for the unincorporated area of Collier County, Florida, by amending the
appropriate zoning atlas map or maps by changing the zoning classification of the herein described real
2
property from a Rural Agricultural (A) Zoning District to a Mixed Use Planned Unit Development (MPUD)
Zoning District for the project to be known as the Baumgarten MPUD, to allow construction of a maximum of
400 multifamily and/or townhouse residential dwelling units and up to 140 hotel/motel rooms and up to
370,000 square feet of commercial land uses at the southeast quadrant of Immokalee Road and Collier
Boulevard, in Section 26, Township 48, Range 26, Collier County, Florida, consisting of 55.66+/- acres; and by
providing an effective date. [Coordinator: Nancy Gundlach, AICP, Principal Planner
Vincent Postiglione
Senior Executive Producer
WINK News
2824 Palm Beach Blvd
Fort Myers, FL 33916
Mobile: 321-439-2821
3
GrecoSherry
From: Boutin, Gary <gary.boutin@sap.com>
Sent: Tuesday, April 2, 2019 7:54 AM
To: FialaDonna; SolisAndy; SaundersBurt;TaylorPenny; McDanielBill; BosiMichael;
markstrain@collier.gov; HomiakKaren; KarlFry; FryerEdwin; StrainMark; ChrzanowskiStan;
SchmittJoseph; eastmath@collierschools.com; pdearborn@johnrwood.com
Cc: Gregory Paquette; gbfahmy@aol.com; Ipdifusco@aol.com;jtaglietta@aol.com
Subject: PUDZ-PL20170000768, Pelican Nursery Mixed-Use Planned Unit Development (MPUD)
Tuscany Cove petition contd.
Attachments: scan petition part 2 - 4 2 2019.pdf
Follow Up Flag: Follow up
Flag Status: Flagged
Tuscany Cove HOA and Community of Residents
15076 Toscana Way, Naples,F134120
239-348-9650
To: The Collier County Planning Commissioners:
Karen Homiak, Patrick Dearborn, Karl Fry, Edwin Fryer, Mark
Strain,
Stan Chrzanowski,Joseph Schmitt; and :
The Collier County Commissioners:
Donna Fiala, Andy Solis, Burt Saunders, Penny Taylor, Bill
McDaniel and:
Director of Zoning, Mike Bosi
1
RE: PUDZ-PL20170000768 (Pelican Nursery Mixed Use Planned
development)
Dear Ladies and Gentlemen,
On March 15, 2019 we emailed you our 2
PAGE PETITION LETTER with 9 pages of 131 signatures from our
VERY CONCERNED TUSCANY COVE RESIDENTS.
Today we are enclosing an additional 4 pages of
50 + more signatures from OUR VERY CONCERNED RESIDENTS
along with another copy of our petition letter for your convenience.
Again, we thank you in advance for taking our many concerns into your
considerations and we look forward to seeing you at your April 18, 2019
Planning Commission Hearing,
Respectfully,
The Concerned Residents of Tuscany Cove
Gary J Boutin cissP
HCM Cloud Operations
53 State Street
Boston, MA 02109
T 617-715-7346
E •a .boutin • sa..com
i,
.HCM
2
GrecoSherry
From: Terry Kennedy <tkennedy@ideastraining.com>
Sent: Wednesday, March 27, 2019 6:27 PM
To: ChrzanowskiStan; Schmittioseph; HomiakKaren; pdearborn@johnrwood.com;
karlfry@comcast.net; Strain Mark; FryerEdwin
Cc: eastmath@collierschools.com; FialaDonna; SaundersBurt; McDanielBill; TaylorPenny;
SolisAndy; gbfahmy@aol.com
Subject: Proposed Development at SE Corner of Immokalee Rd. &Collier Blvd.
Attachments: TK-CollierCommissionersLetter-22519[1].pdf
ATTN: Collier County Planning Commission
CC: The Board of Commissioners of Collier County
RE: Proposed Development at SE Corner of Immokalee Rd. &Collier Blvd.
From: one of many Concerned Property Owners and Taxpayers
Date: March 27, 2019
Due to:
• extreme traffic congestion and intersection hazards—resulting in loss of life,
• negative impact to Collier County environment,
• negative impact to neighboring established single-story community,Tuscany Cove, and
• unnecessary overly-increased density,
It is imperative that there NOT be multi-story units built on the 54-56 acres located at the South East corner of
Collier Blvd & Immokalee Road (previously Pelican Nursery).
• PLEASE REJECT granting height variances above two(standard height)stories on ANY proposed structures on
said parcel.
• PLEASE REJECT high density or increased density variances for said parcel abutting our development.
• PLEASE REJECT any other requested or pending variances that would further impact and harm our expected
quality of life and environmental safety.
Please LISTEN to and seriously consider the VALID CONCERNS of your Collier County Taxpaying Customers(owners
and renters,taxpayers and citizens).
Please see PETITIONS submitted to Collier County Commissioners in February and March 2019 from Tuscany Cove.
See synopsis below and previous letter sent and attached(February 25, 2019)
February 25, 2019
To:The Board of Commissioners of Collier County:
Burt L Saunders(District 3)Vice Chairman
Donna Fiala (District 1) Andy Solis Esq. (District 2) Penny Taylor(District 4)
William L. McDaniel (District 5) Chairman Mike Bosi : Zoning Director
RE: PUDZ-PL20170000768, Pelican Nursery Mixed-use Planned Unit Development (MPUD)
Dear Board of Commissioners,
Recently,via petition,the residents and property owners of Tuscany Cove have brought to your attention the
many concerns that our community has with the proposed PUD rezone application for commercial and residential
3
development of the 54-56 acres located at the South East corner of Collier Blvd & Immokalee Road, the site where
Pelican Nursery had been for many years.
Thank you in advance for your time and serious deliberation on this matter.
1. PLEASE SAY"NO"to HIGH DENSITY, MULTI-STORY DEVELOPMENT
The COMMISSIONERS SHOULD HOLD ANY CURRENTLY PLANNED and FUTURE PROPOSED PROJECT at the corner of
Immokalee Rd. and Collier Blvd to the CORRECT LIMITS, PROPER ZONING RESTRICTIONS,and UTMOST SAFETY
CONCERNS.
The proposed 400 multi-family residential units, a possible 100-150 room hotel, medical offices, restaurants, any other
commercial entities would overwhelm and NEGATIVELY IMPACT our already heavily saturated &trafficked area.
PLEASE: Do not proceed—without the FULL CONSIDERATION of 1)the impact of the heavily increased traffic, or 2)
enough improvement to the surrounding infrastructure to accommodate such growth,or 3)the detrimental effect on
our quality of life.
Developing and expanding the density of structures on the SE corner of Immokalee Rd. and Collier Blvd.would
compound the already serious traffic problem.This is UNSAFE and unacceptable to us as citizens who moved this far
out east to be away from the gridlock of Tamiami Trail, and the skyscrapers and multi-story/multi-unit developments
closer to the Gulf. When daily life becomes a hardship of this degree,the result is that the very people(and resulting$
dollars)that Collier County government has already attracted here may very well choose another, more desirable, safer
area to live and work. BAD WORD OF MOUTH is not something we can afford. The resultant loss of LIFE, time,
reputation, and money is not worth it, is it?
2. PLEASE REVIEW/IMPROVE TRAFFIC FLOW and SAFETY at U-turns,especially at ENTRANCE OF TUSCANY
COVE and at the major intersection of Immokalee Rd. and Collier Blvd.
The recent change in allowing U-TURNS at the ENTRANCE OF TUSCANY COVE TO HEAD NORTH MAKES EXITING AND
ENTERING OUR COMMUNITY EXTREMELY DANGEROUS.The traffic heading north on Collier Blvd is OFTEN BACKED UP
from Immokalee Road to our entrance and exit,which creates severe bottlenecks,gridlock, and increasing accidents.
The reports of at least 202 ACCIDENTS— some fatal — over the last two years, at the Intersection of Collier Blvd and
Immokalee Road (and the most recent tragic fatal accident of a young mother and small child), are most DISTURBING.
Even in the "off' season, there have been daily serious bottlenecks as well as frequent accidents/incidents.This results
in very congested and dangerous intersections, including at the ingress/egress to our small community.
One of the main reasons we purchased in Tuscany Cove was because our community was NOT built on a corner
intersection;yet, because of re-routing and dangerous U-turns,we have experienced increased vehicular traffic from
the many commercial businesses and the major intersection of Immokalee Rd. and Collier Blvd., as if we were a major
intersection.This is NOT SAFE URBAN PLANNING. With the very busy Emergency Room at the NE corner, a life-death
hazardous situation can occur,when ambulances and other emergency vehicles (and residents/visitors in their own
vehicles who are trying to get to the hospital) have increasing difficulty getting through the gridlock!
Please do not allow this slippery slope of quick-income,detrimental urban planning that is NOT IN THE BEST INTEREST
of our citizens,tourists,and upscale businesses who have already invested in our community.This is unbecoming to
our treasured "lifestyle"that brought us here in the first place. Word of mouth travels fast, and as many of us are not
originally from "around here", it is imperative that those in power in government understand the needs of our existing
citizens and protect the positive reputation of Naples.
For the sake of our local community's safety and security— as well as the future positive "lifestyle" image (and
bottom line preservation)of Naples, Collier County, PLEASE REJECT granting variances on increased density and
building height above two stories and for ANY proposed structures abutting our development.
4
The residents and owners of Tuscany Cove and adjacent existing communities are COUNTING ON YOU,
Commissioners,to have the foresight to represent and defend our positive community interests—for the health and
safety of Collier County's future.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter.
Respectfully,
Terry Kennedy, owner, Tuscany Cove unit 15501 Cortona Way, Naples, FL 34120
Former publisher/editor, Naples Guide magazine
5
GrecoSherry
From: Boutin, Gary <gary.boutin@sap.com>
Sent: Friday, March 15, 2019 12:13 PM
To: FialaDonna; SolisAndy; SaundersBurt; TaylorPenny; McDanielBill; BosiMichael;
markstrain@collier.gov
Cc: gbfahmy@aol.com; Linda Miller; Louis Difusco;jtaglietta@aol.com;
imskooter@yahoo.com; sharikole@aol.com
Subject: PUDZ-PL20170000768, Pelican Nursery Mixed-Use Planned Unit Development (MPUD)
Attachments: tuscany cove 2.pdf
Tuscany Cove HOA and Community of Residents
15076 Toscana Way, Naples, FI 34120
239-348-9650 March 15, 2019
To:The Board of Collier County Commissioners:
Donna Fiala: District 1. (Donna.Fiala@colliercountyfl.gov)239-252-8601
Andy Solis: District 2. (Andy.Solis@colliercountyfl.gov) 239-252-8602
Burt Saunders: District 3 (Burt.Saunders@colliercountyfl.gov)239-252-8603
Penny Taylor: District 4(Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov)239-252-8604
Bill McDaniel: District 5(Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov)239-252-8605 Chairman
And,
Mike Bosi; Director of Zoning(Michael.Bosi@colliercountyfl.gov)239-252-6819
RE: PUDZ-PL20170000768, Pelican Nursery Mixed-Use Planned Unit Development (MPUD)
Dear Ladies and Gentlemen,
The residents of Tuscany Cove are concerned about how our community will be impacted by
the above mentioned Planned Development. We have enclosed a petition with our resident's signatures, addresses,
and contact info; even as we continue to get more interest,concern, and residents who want to sign this petition.
We have been told that a Public Hearing will take place next month in April or early May.
With that in mind,we ask that you read our enclosed petition letter and signatures, make a physical visit here, and
grant our Community and Resident Representative,official time to be heard at the upcoming Public Hearing.
Please see our enclosed 2 page petition letter and 9+pages of concerned resident's
signatures.
Thanking you for your time and considerations given this matter,we remain:
Respectfully,
On behalf of the Concerned Residents of Tuscany Cove
Gary J Boutin cissP
HCM Cloud Operations
53 State Street
Boston, MA 02109
T 617-715-7346
E gary.boutinRsap.com
6
7
GrecoSherry
From: Terry Kennedy <tkennedy@ideastraining.com>
Sent: Wednesday, February 27, 2019 12:01 AM
To: FialaDonna; SolisAndy; SaundersBurt; TaylorPenny; McDanielBill
Subject: Proposed Development at SE Corner of Immokalee Rd. &Collier Blvd.
Attachments: TK-CollierCommissionersLetter-22519[1].pdf
Please see letter attached for hard copy signature. Thank you.
February 25, 2019
To:The Board of Commissioners of Collier County:
Burt L Saunders (District 3)Vice Chairman
Donna Fiala (District 1) Andy Solis Esq. (District 2) Penny Taylor(District 4)
William L. McDaniel (District 5) Chairman Mike Bosi : Zoning Director
RE: PUDZ-PL20170000768, Pelican Nursery Mixed-use Planned Unit Development(MPUD)
Dear Board of Commissioners,
Recently,via petition,the residents and property owners of Tuscany Cove have brought to your attention the
many concerns that our community has with the proposed PUD rezone application for commercial and residential
development of the 54-56 acres located at the South East corner of Collier Blvd & Immokalee Road,the site where
Pelican Nursery had been for many years.
Thank you in advance for your time and serious deliberation on this matter.
1. PLEASE SAY"NO"to HIGH DENSITY, MULTI-STORY DEVELOPMENT
The COMMISSIONERS SHOULD HOLD ANY CURRENTLY PLANNED and FUTURE PROPOSED PROJECT at the corner of
Immokalee Rd. and Collier Blvd to the CORRECT LIMITS, PROPER ZONING RESTRICTIONS,and UTMOST SAFETY
CONCERNS.
The proposed 400 multi-family residential units, a possible 100-150 room hotel, medical offices, restaurants, any other
commercial entities would overwhelm and NEGATIVELY IMPACT our already heavily saturated &trafficked area. In the
past few years, nine (9) residential communities and MANY commercial enterprises have been developed at the corner
of Immokalee Rd. and Collier Blvd. and environs —without the full consideration of 1)the impact of the heavily
increased traffic, or 2) enough improvement to the surrounding infrastructure to accommodate such growth, or 3)the
detrimental effect on our quality of life.
As someone who has lived and worked in business in North Naples, Collier County throughout the 1990s and again since
2017, I am not naïve to development; however, it is somewhat surprising that Collier County government(which
seemed to pride itself for decades on attracting upscale developments and businesses, taking into consideration zoning
sensitivities and environmental concerns as well as financial gain)would increasingly consider real estate development
plans to degrade our beautiful area into a "Miami-type" high-density SPRAWL. Wise regulation and reasonably-paced
community growth will result in attracting discerning tourists,snowbirds,and full-time residents who will enjoy the
higher property values(converts to higher taxes and revenues for the county)of the well-planned, upscale
communities with amenities — including a decent percentage of required adjacent open space with lower building
density and single-story height ordinances. This translates into long-term, positive,financial investment in our local
economy.When did these sound values change? Make NOTE,the voting citizens of Naples do not want to be Miami!
8
Developing and expanding the density of structures on the SE corner of Immokalee Rd. and Collier Blvd.would
compound the already serious traffic problem.This is UNSAFE and unacceptable to us as citizens who moved this far
out east to be away from the gridlock of Tamiami Trail, and the skyscrapers and multi-story/multi-unit developments
closer to the Gulf. When daily life becomes a hardship of this degree, the result is that the very people(and resulting$
dollars)that Collier County government has already attracted here may very well choose another, more desirable, safer
area to live and work. BAD WORD OF MOUTH is not something we can afford. The resultant loss of LIFE, time,
reputation, and money is not worth it, is it?
2. PLEASE REVIEW/IMPROVE TRAFFIC FLOW and SAFETY at U-turns,especially at ENTRANCE OF TUSCANY
COVE and at the major intersection of Immokalee Rd.and Collier Blvd.
The recent change in allowing U-TURNS at the ENTRANCE OF TUSCANY COVE TO HEAD NORTH MAKES EXITING AND
ENTERING OUR COMMUNITY EXTREMELY DANGEROUS. The traffic heading north on Collier Blvd is OFTEN BACKED UP
from Immokalee Road to our entrance and exit, which creates severe bottlenecks,gridlock,and increasing accidents.
The reports of at least 202 ACCIDENTS — some fatal — over the last two years,at the Intersection of Collier Blvd and
Immokalee Road (and the most recent tragic fatal accident of a young mother and small child), are most DISTURBING.
Even in the "off" season,there have been daily serious bottlenecks as well as frequent accidents/incidents.This results
in very congested and dangerous intersections, including at the ingress/egress to our small community.
One of the main reasons we purchased in Tuscany Cove was because our community was not built on a corner
intersection;yet, because of re-routing and dangerous U-turns,we have experienced increased vehicular traffic from
the many commercial businesses and the major intersection of Immokalee Rd. and Collier Blvd., as if we were a major
intersection.This is NOT SAFE URBAN PLANNING.With the very busy Emergency Room at the NE corner, a life-death
hazardous situation can occur,when ambulances and other emergency vehicles (and residents/visitors in their own
vehicles who are trying to get to the hospital) have increasing difficulty getting through the gridlock!
Please do not allow this slippery slope of detrimental urban planning that is NOT IN THE BEST INTEREST of our
citizens,tourists,and upscale businesses who have already invested in our community.This is unbecoming to our
treasured "lifestyle"that brought us here in the first place.Word of mouth travels fast, and as many of us are not
originally from "around here", it is imperative that those in power in government understand the needs of our existing
citizens and protect the positive reputation of Naples.
For the sake of our local community's safety and security—as well as the future positive "lifestyle" image (and
bottom line preservation)of Naples, Collier County, PLEASE REJECT granting variances on building height and density
for ANY proposed structures abutting our development.
The residents and owners of Tuscany Cove and adjacent existing communities hope to hear from you soon with a
positive resolution to protect our interests and our lives.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter.
Respectfully,
Terry Kennedy, owner,Tuscany Cove unit 15501 Cortona Way, Naples, FL 34120
Former publisher/editor, Naples Guide magazine
9
GrecoSherry
From: Jane Dean <boatersearay@icloud.com>
Sent: Wednesday, February 13, 2019 8:30 AM
To: TaylorPenny
Subject: Letter to Commissioner.docx
Attachments: Letter to Commissioner.docx; ATT00001.txt
From James&Jane Dean
10
GrecoSherry
From: Craig Shemon <cshemon@hotmail.com>
Sent: Thursday,January 24, 2019 10:44 PM
To: McDanielBill; TaylorPenny; SaundersBurt; SolisAndy; FialaDonna
Subject: Attached citizen letter re: Overdevelopment at Immokalee and Collier
Attachments: Collier County Commissioners.docx
Thank you,
Craig and Michelle Shemon
11
GrecoSherry
From: chris@chrisneaves.com
Sent: Sunday, January 20, 2019 9:58 PM
To: TaylorPenny
Subject: Concern about development at corner of Immokalee Rd and Collier Blvd
Attachments: Letter to Commissioner Re Tuscany Cover.pdf
Dear Ms Taylor
We currently own a property in Tuscany Cove which is located near the corner of Collier Blvd. and Immokalee Road. We
have lived in Naples since 2002. The adjacent property at Immokalee and Collier was owned by Pelican Nursery and is
currently owned by Barron Collier Company.
We are concerned about the proposed development on this property. At two previous meetings,the public was informed
that the developer would like to construct sixty-five-foot-tall apartment buildings for up to four hundred multi-family
units. This would mean four stories and we believe this is not allowed by current zoning. If allowed that would-be high-
rise apartments right next to the existing one-story homes at Tuscany Cove. Those present, at both meetings were very
concerned about the proposed development.
The traffic at this corner is already a concern. Tuscany Cove is directly behind this proposed development. No wall
structure is planned to separate the properties. We will have to see and hear not only the construction take place but the
after effects of several sixty-five foot structures, a hotel and commercial businesses behind our homes. If this proposed
development is approved,we would like a high wall and vegetation on the property line with Tuscany Cove. At this time,
there are several home developments, Bent Creek, Richmond Park and La Morada, next to and just east of the property
of concern. In addition, newly constructed Addison Place apartments are just to the north and west side of the corner of
Immokalee and Collier.
It is discouraging to see the uncontrolled spread of development in our community. I saw recently where Naples planning
advisers were being asked by local community HOA's to keep a "small town feel". We do not want our community to look
like what has happened to the east coast of Florida. Unfortunately, Naples is headed toward over-development.
We would like to suggest a park such as Freedom Park on Golden Gate Parkway. Having green space in this environment
would be desirable. Trails for walking and biking could be established. Picnic and a playground would be beneficial to
families in this area of Collier County. A pond could be established for water retention since there is a canal adjacent to
the property along Collier Blvd. However, this would not be a money maker for the current owners, so at least decrease
their density and have them add more green space.
Thank you.
Chris Neaves and Cindy Williams
15241 Cortona Way
Naples FL 34120
chris@chrisneaves.com
12
GrecoSherry
From: torn campo <tomcampo@yahoo.com>
Sent: Sunday, January 20, 2019 5:17 PM
To: McDanielBill; TaylorPenny; SaundersBurt; SolisAndy; FialaDonna
Subject: Letter of concern
Attachments: Letter to Commissioner.docx
Thank You
Thomas & Louise Campo
13
GrecoSherry
From: caiazz1@aol.com
Sent: Sunday, January 20, 2019 5:11 PM
To: McDanielBill; TaylorPenny; SaundersBurt; SolisAndy; FialaDonna
Subject: Letter regarding rezoning in North Collier
Attachments: Letter to Commissioner.docx
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Joe & Betha Caiazzo
14
GrecoSherry
From: Mary A. Sellers-Pici <mary.pici@verizon.net>
Sent: Friday, January 18, 2019 3:18 PM
To: TaylorPenny; McDanielBill; SaundersBurt; SolisAndy; FialaDonna
Subject: FW: Development of Pelican Nursery Site
To: Collier County Commissioners
I currently live in Tuscany Cove which is a community of approximately 300 single family, one story
homes and villas located near the corner of Collier Blvd and Immokalee Road. When we purchased our
property in 2011, we were concerned about future development on adjacent parcels of land. We were
advised that the "Pelican Nursery had been there forever and not to worry about it". As you are aware,
Pelican Nursery sold to Barron Collier Company and now zoning concessions are being sought to add
another high density development to this property.
Since we purchased in 2011, new home developments of Bent Creek, Richmond Park and La Morada
have been added next to and just east of the Pelican site. On the Northeast corner of Immokalee and
Collier there has been an Emergency Room added along with countless commercial restaurants and
businesses. In addition, newly constructed Addison Place apartments are just to the north and west side
of the corner of Immokalee and Collier and we are told an Aldi's is going to be added to this
corner. Apparently, Collier is going to be extended to Bonita Beach Road as well. All this new
construction is in addition to the large Pebblebrooke Plaza which was already there and creates a lot of
traffic.
All this development has already made this corner one of the most dangerous corners in
Naples. There was a horrific accident this past Sunday involving 4 vehicles and causing 2 deaths. There
was another accident in August resulting in loss of life. This corner is just too congested now. Adding
multifamily high rise apartments, a hotel and commercial development will just add to this unsafe
situation. The County removed the "No U-turn" sign in front of our community which has made it unsafe
for those exiting Tuscany Cove.
Zoning rules are there for a reason. They should not be waived unless there is an overwhelming reason
to do so. I realize that the Barron Collier Company has a significant investment in this parcel but they
purchased it knowing the then current zoning regulations. Barron Collier was known for his contributions
15
to Naples. Perhaps the development of this land could be done to add something to our area such as a
park. If the development is approved, all current zoning should be followed. In addition, particular
attention should be paid to the traffic safety impact. In addition, some concessions should be made to
mitigate the impact of construction on Tuscany Cove residents.
Thank you for your help. I can be reached at 716-572-3383 if you have any questions.
Sincerely,
Mary Sellers-Pici
Mary Sellers-Pici
15306 Cortona Way
Naples, FL 34120
H: 716-662-0120
C: 716-572-3383
Mary.pici@verizon.net
16
GrecoSherry
From: Tina Chisholm <tinachis@gmail.com>
Sent: Friday, January 18, 2019 6:16 AM
To: TaylorPenny
Subject: Immokalee Proposal
To: Collier County Commissioners
From:
We currently live in Tuscany Cove which is located near the corner of Collier Blvd.
and Immokalee Road. The adjacent property at Immokalee Road and Collier
Boulevard was owned by Pelican Nursery and is currently owned by Barron
Collier Company. We are concerned about the proposed development
on this property. At two previous meetings, the public was informed that the
developer would like to construct sixty-five-foot-tall apartment buildings for up to
four hundred multi-family units. This would mean four stories and we believe this
is not allowed by current zoning. If allowed that would-be high-rise apartments
right next to the existing one-story homes at Tuscany Cove. Those present, at both
meetings were very concerned about the proposed development. The traffic at this
corner is already a concern. Tuscany Cove is directly behind this proposed development.
No wall structure is planned to separate the properties. We will have to see and hear
not only the construction take place but the after effects of several sixty-five foot
structures, a hotel and commercial businesses behind our homes. If this proposed
development is approved, we would like a high wall and vegetation on the property
line with Tuscany Cove. At this time, there are several home developments, Bent
Creek, Richmond Park and La Morada, next to and just east of the property of concern.
In addition, newly constructed Addison Place apartments are just to the north and
west side of the corner of Immokalee and Collier.
It is discouraging to see the uncontrolled spread of development in our community.
I saw recently where Naples planning advisers were being asked by local community
HOA's to keep a "small town feel". We do not want our community to look like what
has happened to the east coast of Florida. Unfortunately, Naples is headed toward
over-development.
We would like to suggest a park such as Freedom Park on Golden Gate Parkway.
Having green space in this environment would be desirable. Trails for walking and
biking could be established. Picnic and a playground would be beneficial to families
in this area of Collier County. A pond could be established for water retention since
there is a canal adjacent to the property along Collier Blvd. However, this would not
be a money maker for the current owners, so at least decrease their density and have
them add more green space.
Thank you.
17
Sincerely,
Daniel & Tina Chisholm
14946 Volterra Ct
Naples, FL 34120
18
GrecoSherry
From: Isabelle Aubin <isabelle.aubin2@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, January 17, 2019 4:15 PM
To: TaylorPenny
Subject: Immokalee rd and Collier development!
Dear Ms Taylor
We currently live in Tuscany Cove which is located near the corner of Collier Blvd.
and Immokalee Road. We have lived in Naples for now 5 years in Tuscany Cove. The adjacent property at
Immokalee and Collier was owned by Pelican Nursery and is currently owned
by Barron Collier Company. We are stunned by all the development that is happening now in this area! We
can barely get out of our property to collier blvd at traffic time.
We are VERY concerned about the proposed development on this property. At two previous meetings, the
public was informed that the developer would like to construct sixty-five-foot-tall apartment buildings for up
to four hundred multi-family units. This would mean four stories and we believe this is not allowed by current
zoning. If allowed that would-be high-rise apartments right next to the existing one-story homes at Tuscany
Cove. Those present, at both
meetings were very concerned about the proposed development. The traffic at this
corner is already a concern. Tuscany Cove is directly behind this proposed development.
No wall structure is planned to separate the properties. We will have to see and hear
not only the construction take place but the after effects of several sixty-five foot
structures, a hotel and commercial businesses behind our homes. We certainly do not want this development
to be approved. If ever this proposed development is approved, we would like a high wall and vegetation on
the property line with Tuscany Cove. At this time, there are several home developments, Bent Creek,
Richmond Park and La Morada, next to and just east of the property of concern.
In addition, newly constructed Addison Place apartments are just to the north and
west side of the corner of Immokalee and Collier. This is an oversaturation of this beautiful area. Since the fall
18, I must add 30 minutes to my commute to work. Some morning it takes 20+ minutes just to get from collier
to 1-75 on Immokalee , 3 miles distance. This is already way too much traffic
It is discouraging to see the uncontrolled spread of development in our community.
I saw recently where Naples planning advisers were being asked by local community
HOA's to keep a "small town feel". We do not want our community to look like what
has happened to the east coast of Florida. Unfortunately, Naples is headed toward
over-development.
We would like to suggest a park such as Freedom Park on Golden Gate Parkway.
Having green space in this environment would be desirable. Trails for walking and
biking could be established. Picnic and a playground would be beneficial to families
in this area of Collier County. A pond could be established for water retention since
there is a canal adjacent to the property along Collier Blvd. However, this would not
be a money maker for the current owners, so at least decrease their density and have
them add more green space.
Thank you,
Isabelle Aubin
19
20
GrecoSherry
From: Anita Tailor <anitatailor@cinci.rr.com>
Sent: Thursday, January 17, 2019 11:36 AM
To: TaylorPenny
Subject: Proposed development next to Tuscany Cove
To: Collier County Commissioners
From: Kaushik ft Anita Tailor
We currently own a property in Tuscany Cove which is located near the corner of Collier Blvd.and
Immokalee Road.The adjacent property at Immokalee and Collier was owned by Pelican Nursery and is
currently owned by Barron Collier Company. We are concerned about the proposed development on this
property. At two previous meetings, the public was informed that the developer would like to construct
sixty-five-foot-tall apartment buildings for up to four hundred multi-family units. This would mean four
stories and we believe this is not allowed by current zoning. If allowed that would-be high-rise apartments
right next to the existing one-story homes at Tuscany Cove. Those present, at both meetings were very
concerned about the proposed development. The traffic at this corner is already a concern. Tuscany Cove
is directly behind this proposed development. No wall structure is planned to separate the properties. We
will have to see and hear not only the construction take place but the after effects of several sixty-five foot
structures, a hotel and commercial businesses behind our homes. If this proposed development is approved,
we would like a high wall and vegetation on the property line with Tuscany Cove. At this time, there are
several home developments, BentCreek, Richmond Park and La Morada, next to and just east of the
property of concern.
In addition, newly constructed Addison Place apartments are just to the north and
west side of the corner of Immokalee and Collier.
It is discouraging to see the uncontrolled spread of development in our community.
We saw recently where Naples planning advisers were being asked by local community
HOA's to keep a "small town feel". We do not want our community to look like what
has happened to the east coast of Florida. Unfortunately, Naples is headed toward
over-development.
We would like to suggest a park such as Freedom Park on Golden Gate Parkway.
Having green space in this environment would be desirable. Trails for walking and
biking could be established. Picnic and a playground would be beneficial to families
in this area of Collier County. A pond could be established for water retention since
there is a canal adjacent to the property along Collier Blvd. However, this would not
be a money maker for the current owners, so at least decrease their density and have
them add more green space.
Thank you.
21
GrecoSherry
From: Georgiana <georgyana_g@yahoo.com>
Sent: Thursday, January 17, 2019 11:18 AM
To: McDanielBill;TaylorPenny; SaundersBurt; SolisAndy; Donna.Fiola@colliercountyfl.gov
Subject: Concern resistant Pelican Nursery construction
To: Collier County Commissioners
From: Georgiana and Robert Highley residents of Tuscany Cove .
We currently live in Tuscany Cove which is located near the corner of Collier Blvd.
and Immokalee Road. We have lived in Naples since 2004. The adjacent property
at Immokalee and Collier was owned by Pelican Nursery and is currently owned
by Barron Collier Company. We are concerned about the proposed development
on this property. At two previous meetings, the public was informed that the
developer would like to construct sixty-five-foot-tall apartment buildings for up to
four hundred multi-family units. This would mean four stories and we believe this
is not allowed by current zoning. If allowed that would-be high-rise apartments
right next to the existing one-story homes at Tuscany Cove, right behind my house .Those present, at both
meetings were very concerned about the proposed development. The traffic at this
corner is already a concern. Tuscany Cove is directly behind this proposed development.
No wall structure is planned to separate the properties,that will impact our pool and lanai cleaning and maintenance,
but also the air that my 6 year old daughter will need to break when going out side. This will have a big impact in our
lives. We will have to see and hear
not only the construction take place but the after effects of several sixty-five foot
structures, a hotel and commercial businesses behind our homes. If this proposed
development is approved, we would like a high wall and vegetation on the property
line with Tuscany Cove. At this time,there are several home developments, Bent
Creek, Richmond Park and La Morada, next to and just east of the property of concern.
In addition, newly constructed Addison Place apartments are just to the north and
west side of the corner of Immokalee and Collier.
It is discouraging to see the uncontrolled spread of development in our community.
I saw recently where Naples planning advisers were being asked by local community
HOA's to keep a "small town feel". We do not want our community to look like what
has happened to the east coast of Florida. Unfortunately, Naples is headed toward
over-development.
We would like to suggest a park such as Freedom Park on Golden Gate Parkway.
Having green space in this environment would be desirable. Trails for walking and
biking could be established. Picnic and a playground would be beneficial to families
in this area of Collier County. A pond could be established for water retention since
there is a canal adjacent to the property along Collier Blvd. However, this would not
be a money maker for the current owners, so at least decrease their density and have
them add more green space.
Thank you.
Sent from my iPhone
22
GrecoSherry
From: Lo P <mainstreetnaples@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday,January 17, 2019 11:11 AM
To: McDanielBill;TaylorPenny; SaundersBurt; SolisAndy; FialaDonna
Subject: Propose Construction Of Apartment & Hotel @ Immokalee Rd &Collier Blvd
To: Collier County Commissioners
From:
We currently live in Tuscany Cove which is located near the corner of Collier Blvd.and Immokalee Road. We
have lived in Naples since 1976. The adjacent propertyat Immokalee and Collier was owned by Pelican Nursery
and is currently owned by Barron Collier Company. We are concerned about the proposed development on
this property. At two previous meetings, the public was informed that the developer would like to construct
sixty-five-foot-tall apartment buildings for up tofour hundred multi-family units. This would mean four stories
and we believe this is not allowed by current zoning. If allowed that would-be high-rise apartments right next to
the existing one-story homes at Tuscany Cove. Those present, at both meetings were very concerned about
the proposed development.
The traffic at this corner is already a concern. Tuscany Cove is directly behind this proposed development. No
wall structure is planned to separate the properties. We will have to see and hear not only the construction
take place but the after effects of several sixty-five foot structures, a hotel and commercial businesses behind
our homes. If this proposed development is approved, we would like a high wall and vegetation on the
property line with Tuscany Cove. At this time,there are several home developments, Bent Creek, Richmond
Park and La Morada, next to and just east of the property of concern. In addition, newly constructed Addison
Place apartments are just to the north and west side of the corner of Immokalee and Collier.
It is discouraging to see the uncontrolled spread of development in our community. I saw recently where
Naples planning advisers were being asked by local community HOA's to keep a "small town feel". We do not
want our community to look like what has happened to the east coast of Florida. Unfortunately, Naples is
headed toward over-development.
We would like to suggest a park such as Freedom Park on Golden Gate Parkway. Having green space in this
environment would be desirable. Trails for walking and biking could be established. Picnic and a playground
would be beneficial to families in this area of Collier County. A pond could be established for water retention
since there is a canal adjacent to the property along Collier Blvd. However, this would not be a money maker
for the current owners, so at least decrease their density and have them add more green space.
Best Regards,
Lo Paul
23
GrecoSherry
From: Geoffrey Klein <geoffreyklein@comcast.net>
Sent: Thursday, January 17, 2019 9:48 AM
To: TaylorPenny
Subject: Proposed Development at the SE Corner of Collier Blvd and Immokalee Rd
Attachments: Letter to Commissioner.docx
Geoffrey Klein
Flooring Consultant
Hadinger Flooring
6401 N. Airport Road
Naples, FL 34109
239-566-7100
geoffreyk@hadinger.com
24
GrecoSherry
From: Dale Walters <dale@mooringscc.com>
Sent: Monday, January 7, 2019 12:47 PM
To: McDanielBill;TaylorPenny; SaundersBurt; SolisAndy; FialaDonna
Subject: The Point
To: Collier County Commissioners
From: Dale and Connie Walters
We currently live in Tuscany Cove which is located near the corner of Collier Blvd.
and Immokalee Road. We have lived in Naples since 1976. The adjacent property
at Immokalee and Collier was owned by Pelican Nursery and is currently owned
by Barron Collier Company. We are concerned about the proposed development
on this property. At two previous meetings, the public was informed that the
developer would like to construct sixty-five foot tall apartment buildings for up to
four hundred multi-family units. This would mean four stories and we believe this
is not allowed by current zoning. If allowed that would be high rise apartments
right next to the existing one story homes at Tuscany Cove. Those present, at both
meetings, were very concerned about the proposed development. The traffic at this
corner is already a concern. Tuscany Cove is directly behind this proposed development.
No wall structure is planned to separate the properties. We will have to see and hear
not only the construction take place but the after effects of several sixty-five foot
structures, a hotel and commercial businesses behind our homes. If this proposed
development is approved, we would like a high wall and vegetation on the property
line with Tuscany Cove. At this time, there are several home developments, Bent
Creek, Richmond Park and La Morda, next to and just east of the property of concern.
In addition, newly constructed Addison Place apartments are just to the north and
west side of the corner of Immokalee and Collier.
It is discouraging to see the uncontrolled spread of development in our community.
I saw recently where Naples planning advisers were being asked by local community
HOA's to keep a "small town feel". We do not want our community to look like what
has happened to the east coast of Florida. Unfortunately, Naples is headed toward
over development.
We would like to suggest a park such as Freedom Park on Golden Gate Parkway.
Having green space in this environment would be desirable. Trails for walking and
biking could be established. Picnic and a play ground would be beneficial to families
in this area of Collier County. A pond could be established for water retention since
there is a canal adjacent to the property along Collier Blvd. However, this would not
25
be a money maker for the current owners, so at least decrease their density and have
them add more green space.
Thank you.
26