PARAB Minutes 04/17/2019MINUTES OF TFIE MEETING OF TI{E PARKS AND RECREATION
ADVISORY BOARD
North Collier Regional Park
Naples, Florida
April 17,2019
LET IT BE REMEMBERED, the Collier County Parks and Recreation Advisory
Board in and for the County of Collier, having conducted business herein, met on
this date at 2:00 P.M. at North Collier Regional Park, 15000 Livingston Road,
Naples, FL, with the following members present:
CHAIRMAN: Mr. Edward "Ski" Olesky
VICE-CFIAIRMN: Ms. Mary Bills, Advisory Board Member
Mr. Phil Brougham, Advisory Board Member
Mr. Joshua Fruth, Advisory Board Member
Mr. David Saletko, Advisory Board Member
ALSO PRESENT:
Mr. Barry Williams, Division Director, Parks and Recreation Division
Mr. Rick Garby, Superintendent, Parks and Recreation Division
Ms. Jeanine McPherson, Assistant Director, Parks and Recreation Division
Mr. Miguel Rojas, Jr., Administrative Assistant, Parks and Recreation Division
Ms. Nancy Olson, Regional Manager, Parks and Recreation Division
Ms. Erin Murphy, Supervisor, Immokalee Sports Complex
Ms. Kim Sblendorio, Hamilton Harbor Yacht Club
Page I
31.A.4
Packet Pg. 626 Attachment: PARAB Meeting Minutes - April 17, 2019 (signed) (9173 : Parks and Recreation Advisory Board - May 15, 2019)
I.
il.
Call to Order
Pledge of Allegiance and Invocation
The Pledge of Allegiance was recited, and a moment of silence observed.
Mr. Murdo Smith was recognizedby Mr. Williams as a highly regarded member of the
Parks family, having served on the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board for many years.
Mr. Smith passed away unexpectedly at his home the week prior. Mr. Smith was
remembered as a thoughtful and insightful individual who contributed significantly of his
time, energy, and expertise to further Parks endeavors. Mr. Smith was greatly appreciated
and will be sorely missed. A celebration of life memorial service will be held for Mr.
Smith at North Collier Regional Park on Wednesday, April 17,2019 at 5:00 p.m.
III. Approval of the Agenda
Mr. Brougham entered a motion to approve the April 17, 2019 meeting agenda. Ms.
Bills seconded the motion. All members were infavor. The motion was carried.
IV. Approval of March 20,2019 Minutes
Ms. Bills entered a motion to approve the March 20, 2019 meeting minutes. The
motion was seconded by Mr. Brougham- All members were infavor. The motion was
carried.
Capital Projects Update - Mr. Williams
+Mr. Williams noted several administrative changes within Facilities Management. Mr.
Michael Cherbini has been hired as a replacement for Mr. David Berra, and has been
assigned to Parks and Recreation projects. Ms. Margaret Bishop will also be working on
more Parks related projects and is planned to attend future PARAB meetings.
*Big Corkscrew Island Regional Park (BCRP) - Mr. Brougham attended the Surtax
Oversight Committee meeting to speak on behalf of PARAB in support of use of surtax
funding for the construction of BCRP, as approved by Collier voters. Extended
discussion was had by the Committee regarding ballot language and whether the BCRP
project met all parameters for funding eligibility. Mr. Brougham pointed out that $40M
had been earmarked for BCRP within the referendum, with strong community support in
Eastern Collier County for the project. This funding would in turn allow for the use of
impact fees for other Parks projects. The Committee ultimately voted in favor of use of
surtax funding for the BRCP project by a 4-3 margin.
Construction bids for the BCRP project will be solicited June 1, 2019. The winning bid
will be presented to the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) in September 2019, with
construction of Phase I anticipated to begin on October 1,2019. Planning of Phase II of
the park is underway and is presently in the permitting phase.
v.
Page 2
31.A.4
Packet Pg. 627 Attachment: PARAB Meeting Minutes - April 17, 2019 (signed) (9173 : Parks and Recreation Advisory Board - May 15, 2019)
*Sports Complex - This project is advancing, with fields anticipated to be available for
play in early 2020. Discussions are underway between Collier County representatives
and SFI, a private firm based in Atlant4 Georgia for management ofthe Sports Complex
facility. A site visit by a Naples contingent was recently done in Sandusky, Ohio at a
facility managed by SFI.
Feedback regarding this site visit will be presented to PARAB at the May 2019 meeting.
SFI brings much experience and extensive contacts within the sports community and is
anticipated to work with the Naples Convention and Visitors Bureau in attracting large
events to the Sports Complex venue.
*Clam Pass Parking Garage - Three meetings have been held to date between Parks
Staff and the Pelican Bay Foundation Board regarding the lifting ofdeed restrictions to
allow lor the expansion of parking at Clam Pass with the addition ofa parking garage.
These discussions have included traffic, environmental issues, beach access, etc. Various
meetings between Parks Staff and local area businesses and housing communities have
also been had in order to solicit feedback regarding the possibility of a parking garage,
with concems voiced of increased traffic congestion, as well as a potential for exceeding
park capacity. Parks Staff remains tasked with addressing significant beach access
challenges, with the growing County population, as well as booming tourism. Q Grady
Minor & Associates have been hired as consultants to conduct a feasibility study ofthe
parking garage concept. Another meeting is scheduled with the Pelican Bay Foundation
Board in May 2019 for further deliberation regarding lifting the deed restriction, with
disposition to be presented to the BCC in June 2019 for panel discussion and further
direction regarding this issue.
Mr. Brougham inquired as to the possibility ofincreased beach access via ferry by water,
with construction ofa pier or dock; however, the shallowness ofthe water near the beach
presents a challenge. Mr. Fruth inquired as to the size of the area in question for the
proposed parking garage. Mr. Williams reported that the parking area is presently
comprised of 198 spots. Mr. Fruth suggested consideration ofa stacking, serpentine
roadway behind the parking area in order to alleviate traffic concems in that the
"stacking" of traffic would occur onsite and not on the roadway. Mr. Williams stated that
several design options to address congestion and noise have been discussed and these
ideas will be presented to PARAB at the May 2019 meeting.
*Manatee Community Park - Mr. Brougham requested clarification of the notation on
the Capital Projects list of a study done regarding Manatee Community Park. Mr.
Williams suggested a meeting in early May, to include Mr. Brougham and Mr. Elliott
Miller, to begin to conceptualize next steps, including possible community meetings. Mr.
Brougham was in favor ofthis idea and suggested the initial meeting include ideas for
multiple local community meetings, as ultimately, the design should encompass feedback
lrom all East Naples residents.
Page 3
31.A.4
Packet Pg. 628 Attachment: PARAB Meeting Minutes - April 17, 2019 (signed) (9173 : Parks and Recreation Advisory Board - May 15, 2019)
*Eagle Lakes Community Park expansion - Mr. Brougham inquired as to the status of
plans for expansion of the park. Mr. Williams noted having received ideas and feedback
at a town hall meeting led by Commissioner Fiala. Parks funds have been budgeted for
the next fiscal year towards this end. An engineering firm will be utilized to
conceptualizethe plan, with further feedback solicited from the community following
this. Expansion of the fitness center, possibly with a gym, as well as additional
classrooms have been suggested to address current deficits in the community center.
Advancement in terms of funding will occur October 1,2019.
VI. New Business
a. TDC Grants - Ms. Nancy Olson
+TDC grant funding in the amount of $ 170K is being requested in support of the Sea
Turtle Protection Program for beach renourishment and Pass maintenance, to commence
October I,2019, for a period of one year.
Ms. Bills entered a motion to approve the Tourist Development Council grant
application in the amount of $170,000for Beach Renourishment and Pass
Maintenance of the Collier County Sea Turtle Protection Program/Environmental
Compliance. Mr. Saletko seconded the motion. All were infavor. The motion was
carried.
+TDC grant funding in the amount of $185K is being requested to replace 7 Parkeon
Strada Pay Stations at Beach Park Facilities due to age and for technology upgrades, as
wellas to purchase 3 pay stations for additional coverage (not including boat launch
meters). The upgraded pay stations will have report generating capabilities, as well as be
adaptable over time. The meters will continue to be maintained by the Park Rangers.
Ms. Bills entered a motion to approve the Tourist Development Council grant
application in the amount of $185,000for the replacement of (7) Parkeon Strada Pay
Stations at Beach Park Facilities and the purchase of (3) additional Pay Stations for
ancillary coverage. Mr. Fruth seconded the motion. All were infavor. The motion
was caruied.
b. Alcohol Permissio[ - Mr. Williams clarified that permission to serve alcohol
must be granted by the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board prior to any event held on
Park premises, with the groups/vendors following all specified guidelines. Mr. Williams
will provide PARAB with a current listing of specific requirements which must be
met by groups or vendors requesting to serve alcohol at Park site events.
Page 4
31.A.4
Packet Pg. 629 Attachment: PARAB Meeting Minutes - April 17, 2019 (signed) (9173 : Parks and Recreation Advisory Board - May 15, 2019)
+Ms. Erin Murphy, Supervisor, lmmokalee Sports Complex addressed PARAB to
request permission for the sale of alcohol at the upcoming Cinco de Mayo Festival being
held on May 4,2019 at the lmmokalee Sports Complex from 4:00 p.m. to 9:00 p.m.,
sponsored by the Immokalee Chamber of Commerce. A beer garden will be provided,
with appropriate security on hand.
Mr. Brougham entered a motion to approve lhe application for the sale of alcohol at
the Cinco de Mayo evenl on May 4, 2019from 4:00 p.m- lo 9:00 p.m. at the Immokalee
Sports Complex- Ms. Bills seconded the molion. All were favor. The motion was
carried
+Ms. Kim Sblendorio of Hamilton Harbor Yacht Club addressed PARAB to request
permission to serve alcohol at a Staff Appreciation event to be held at East Naples
Community Park on May 14,2019 from 4:00 p.m. to 7:30 p.m. Approximately 40
participants are expected. All licensing, insurance, and security parameters will be met.
Ms. Bills entered a motion to approve the application to serve alcohol at lhe Hamilton
Harbor Yacht Club Slaff Appreciation Event to be held at Easl Naples Community
Park on May 14, 2019from 4:00 p.m- to 7:30 p.m- Mr. Fruth seconded the motion.
All were in favor. The motion was carried
VII. Director's Highlights
+The 2019 U.S. Open Pickleball Championship will be held April27-May 4. Mr. Garby
was commended on the upgrades done at the park, including additional ADA
accessibility. The promoters of the event have signed their commitment to the County to
continue to hold the event in East Naples. Mr. Brougham stated that shade structures had
been recommended by Mr. Ludwig, concessionaire. Mr. Williams noted that temporary
shade structures had been put in place. A request had also been made to add plastic
roiltops to the chain link fencing surrounding the courts. Mr. Williams noted that the East
Naples Community Park master plan included these types of amenities, with five phases
ofthe plan. Phase 1, following the 2019 U.S. Open includes electrical upgrades, as well
as a focus on improvement of bathrooms and the maintenance facilities. Phase 2 will
address the need for expanded parking. Discussion and negotiation of a possible land
swap with the School Board for property adj acent to the Park remains ongoing. The
largest phase of the master plan involves the replacement of the existing community
center and rebuilding it elsewhere on the property.
+Mr. Jim Ludwig, concessionaire at East Naples Community Park, has also begun work
at Veterans Park as well.
Page 5
31.A.4
Packet Pg. 630 Attachment: PARAB Meeting Minutes - April 17, 2019 (signed) (9173 : Parks and Recreation Advisory Board - May 15, 2019)
*Consideration for the purchase of the Golden Gate Golf Course will be given by the
BCC at the April 23,2019 meeting. The property is eligible for purchase with impact
fees. How the property would be developed remains a question, with input from the
sellers, the County, as well as neighboring residents. Under consideration is a large
portion of the property used for recreation, as well as potential surtax funded projects for
the land along Collier Boulevard.
*Preparations are underway for upcoming summer camps, including the addition of
approximately 150 part-time employees. Mr. Williams noted that the lifeguard deficit
continues. The current salary for the lifeguard position is $1 1.87, with the hope to
increase to $13-$14 in order to remain competitive. Outreach for potential lifeguards has
been done to local high schools, swim teams, and fire stations.
+Mr. Fruth inquired as to the status of the Golden Gate Community Park kiddie pool.
Mr. Williams noted that the kiddie pool will remain closed for a period of time. Parks
Staff is working with a consultant who has been contracted by the county, Omni
Aquatics, who will obtain an engineering assessment as to the scope of work. The
assessment is being done in order to circumvent issues similar to those recently
experienced with repair of the kiddie pool at the Immokalee Aquatic Facility. Further,
management and responsibilities of the aquatics facilities is being restructured, with
Public Utilities assuming responsibilities for pumps and motors, Parks managing pool
maintenance/cleaning, and capital projects shifted to Facilities Management. Mr. Garby
noted that it will be at least three years before useable data may be ascertained from the
Asset Management program, with new information being added weekly.
V[I. Board/Public Comments
*Mr. Michael Cherbini introduced himself to PARAB members as the replacement for
Mr. David Berra, Facilities Management. Mr. Cherbini previously worked with Collier
County for two years in the Public Utilities Division and has recently been named Parks
Project Manager.
+Ms. Bills requested confirmation that all Adopt A Park issues are to be entered in to the
311 system and no longer brought to PARAB meetings. Mr. Williams confirmed,
however stated that he would bring a report of PARAB 311 entries to the monthly
meeting for discussion.
Page 6
31.A.4
Packet Pg. 631 Attachment: PARAB Meeting Minutes - April 17, 2019 (signed) (9173 : Parks and Recreation Advisory Board - May 15, 2019)
Adjournment
There being no further business for the good ofthe County, the meeting was adjoumed.
These minutes approved by the Board/Committee ". < / f f / fl
^s
presented, or as amended.
Parks and Recreation Advisory Board
Page 7
31.A.4
Packet Pg. 632 Attachment: PARAB Meeting Minutes - April 17, 2019 (signed) (9173 : Parks and Recreation Advisory Board - May 15, 2019)