CLB Agenda 03/20/2019COLLIER COUNTY
Board of County Commissioners
Contractor Licensing Board
AGENDA
Board of County Commission Chambers
Collier County Government Center
3299 Tamiami Trail East, 3rd Floor
Naples, FL 34112
March 20, 2019
9:00 AM
Kyle E. Lantz, Chair
Matthew Nolton, Vice-Chair
Robert P. Meister, III
Patrick G. White
Michael E. Boyd
Terry Jerulle
Richard E. Joslin, Jr.
Jeffrey Williams
NOTICE: All persons wishing to speak on Agenda items must register prior to presentation of the Agenda
item to be addressed. All registered speakers will receive up to three (3) minutes unless the time is adjusted
by the chairman.
Any person who decides to appeal a decision of this Board will need a record of the proceeding pertaining
thereto, and therefore may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record
includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based.
If you are a person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding,
you are entitled, at no cost to you, the provision of certain assistance. Please contact the Collier County
Facilities Management Division located at 3335 East Tamiami Trail, Suite 1, Naples, Florida, 34112 -5356,
(239) 252-8380; assisted listening devices for the hearing impaired are available in the Facilities
Management Division.
1. ROLL CALL
2. ADDITIONS OR DELETIONS
3. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
4. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
4.A. APPROVAL OF MINUTES - FEBRUARY 20, 2019
5. PUBLIC COMMENTS
6. DISCUSSION
7. REPORTS
8. NEW BUSINESS
8.A. ORDERS OF THE BOARD
9. OLD BUSINESS
9.A. CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF
A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE
10. PUBLIC HEARINGS
10.A. PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02
MISCONDUCT
11. NEXT MEETING DATE
11.A. WEDNESDAY, APRIL 17, 2019
Inquiries concerning changes to the Board’s Agenda should be made to the County Manager’s Office at
252-8383.
03/20/2019
COLLIER COUNTY
Contractor Licensing Board
Item Number: 4.A
Item Summary: APPROVAL OF MINUTES - FEBRUARY 20, 2019
Meeting Date: 03/20/2019
Prepared by:
Title: – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Lilla Davis
03/11/2019 4:14 PM
Submitted by:
Title: Supervisor - Operations – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Everildo Ybaceta
03/11/2019 4:14 PM
Approved By:
Review:
Contractor Licensing Board Lilla Davis Review Item Completed 03/11/2019 4:15 PM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Review Item Completed 03/11/2019 4:49 PM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Meeting Pending 03/20/2019 9:00 AM
4.A
Packet Pg. 3
February 20, 2019
1
MINUTES
OF THE COLLIER COUNTY
CONTRACTORS’ LICENSING BOARD
February 20, 2019
Naples, Florida
LET IT BE REMEMBERED that the Collier County Contractors’ Licensing
Board, having conducted business herein, met on this date at 9:00 AM in
REGULAR SESSION in Administrative Building “F,” 3rd Floor, Collier County
Government Complex, Naples, Florida, with the following Members present:
Chairman: Kyle E. Lantz
Vice Chair: Matthew Nolton
Members: Terry Jerulle
Richard Joslin
Patrick White
Excused: Michael E. Boyd
Robert Meister
ALSO PRESENT:
Everildo Ybaceta – Supervisor, Contractors’ Licensing Office
Kevin Noell, Esq. – Assistant Collier County Attorney
Jed Schneck, Esq. – Attorney for the Contractors’ Licensing Board
Lilla Davis – Administrative Supervisor, Contractors’ Licensing Office
4.A.1
Packet Pg. 4 Attachment: February 2019 Minutes (8295 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - FEBRUARY 20, 2019)
February 20, 2019
2
Any person who decides to appeal a decision of this Board will need a record of the
proceedings and may need to ensure that a verbatim record of said proceedings is made,
which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which any Appeal is to be made.
I. ROLL CALL:
Chairman Kyle E. Lantz opened the meeting at 9:00 AM and read the procedures to be
followed to appeal a decision of the Board.
Roll Call was taken; a quorum was established; five (5) voting members were present.
II. AGENDA- ADDITIONS, CHANGES, OR DELETIONS:
(None)
III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA:
Patrick White moved to approve the Agenda as presented. Vice Chairman Matthew
Nolton offered a Second in support of the motion. Carried unanimously, 5 – 0.
IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: JANUARY 16, 2019
Patrick White moved to approve the Minutes of the January 16, 2019 Meeting as submitted.
Richard Joslin offered a Second in support of the motion. Carried unanimously, 5 – 0.
V. PUBLIC COMMENT:
(None)
VI. DISCUSSION:
(None)
VII. REPORTS:
(None)
VIII. NEW BUSINESS:
A. Orders of the Board:
Patrick White moved to approve authorizing the Chairman to sign the Orders of the
Board. Richard Joslin offered a Second in support of the motion.
Carried unanimously, 5 – 0.
(Note: The individuals who testified in the following cases under Item VIII, “New
Business,” were first sworn in by the Attorney for the Board.)
4.A.1
Packet Pg. 5 Attachment: February 2019 Minutes (8295 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - FEBRUARY 20, 2019)
February 20, 2019
3
B. Michael Haldie – Review of Experience
(d/b/a “Algae Eaters Pool & Pressure Cleaning, LLC”)
Chairman Lantz called Michael Haldie to the podium and asked the Applicant to
provide his background to the Board. He noted Mr. Haldie had applied for a Roof
Coating, Painting, and Cleaning Contractor’s license.
Michael Haldie:
• He is originally from Ohio and is 41 years of age.
• He began power washing as a teen-ager for a family member who owned a
power washing company.
• He has experience power washing cars, RVs, tractor trailer-semis, to homes.
• After the business was sold in 1999, the Applicant moved to Bonita Springs in
Lee County.
• He worked part-time for Andy’s Pool and Spa maintaining pools as well as
continuing with power washing.
• He has more than 20 years of experience in the power washing business.
• He has been licensed in Collier County as a Swimming Pool/Maintenance
Contractor since 2012.
Chairman Lantz questioned the Applicant:
Q. Are you licensed in Lee County to power wash?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And that license is ...
A. There isn’t a Roof Coating, Painting and Cleaning Contractor’s license in Lee
County – just an “occupational” license.
Q. If you have an “occupational” license in Lee County, are you allowed to power
wash a roof?
A. Yes, sir.
Terry Jerulle questioned the Applicant:
Q. I thought I heard you say you’re not allowed to coat roofs?
A. Well, power washing is essentially ... we use an algicide or a biocide – whatever
the customer choses – but it’s a “coating” that goes onto the roof to kill mold and
will prevent mold growth for approximately two to three years.
Chairman Lantz questioned the Applicant:
Q. So, in Lee County – what you want to do here, you can do in Lee County?
You’re licensed to do it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. We saw a bunch of affidavits verifying your experience --- they are customers?
A. They are customers. I also tried to include some before-and-after photos of the
work that we do. We’re also accredited by the Better Business Bureau. I’m not
sure how ... or what you guys are asking. I’ve been doing this for a long time ...
we’re very good at it ... we have a lot of referrals. I can get 50 more
recommendations if that’s what you need.
4.A.1
Packet Pg. 6 Attachment: February 2019 Minutes (8295 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - FEBRUARY 20, 2019)
February 20, 2019
4
Q. And do you have any employees?
A. It’s myself and I have one part-time guy who helps me when we do have roof jobs
because I have to have to guys onsite for a roof.
Terry Jerulle: Evy, why is he here?
Everildo Ybaceta, Contractors’ Licensing Office Supervisor: Collier County has
a Roof Coating and Pressure Washing License that requires him to take the Business
and Law exam as well as a minimum of experience to do the work. He does have the
experience in Lee County, but he doesn’t have anything that I can prove here so that’s
why ...
Terry Jerulle: He hasn’t taken the Business exam?
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes, he has.
Terry Jerulle: He has?
Vice Chair Matthew Nolton: He’s just here for his experience.
Patrick White: And it’s not the scope of the license that’s a concern – it’s just the
idea that he has no Collier County experience?
Everildo Ybaceta: Right. That’s correct.
Patrick White: Why would the jurisdiction where the experience is from be a
concern?
Everildo Ybaceta: It really isn’t – but the recommendations are from homeowners,
not from other contractors or other entities. And this is where ... I don’t have
heartburn over it ... I just want to make sure that I do cover my bases.
Patrick White: Understood. I think that, hopefully, answers your question.
Terry Jerulle: Yup. Does the County have any recommendation?
Everildo Ybaceta: I believe you can give him the license. I just wanted to make
sure that everyone was in favor of it.
Terry Jerulle: Thank you.
Chairman Lantz questioned the Applicant:
Q. I have a couple of questions. Do you have Workers’ Comp coverage?
A. We do not.
Q. Do you have a Workers’ Comp exemption?
A. It’s just one employee essentially ... one part-time employee. Under the law as we
understand it, we don’t meet the minimum requirement for coverage.
Richard Joslin: That’s not true.
Chairman Lantz: That’s not true.
Richard Joslin: No.
Chairman Lantz: Once you become a construction business, you follow a different
set of Workers’ Comp laws. You probably remember this from when you took your
Business and Law test.
Michael Haldie: When we got our ... for insurance purposes, they haven’t required
us ... but I’m more than happy to get that coverage, sure.
Patrick White: The issue isn’t required to have coverage ... the issue is you are
required to file for and have on record the request for an exemption from the
coverage.
4.A.1
Packet Pg. 7 Attachment: February 2019 Minutes (8295 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - FEBRUARY 20, 2019)
February 20, 2019
5
Michael Haldie: I believe that would be in the packet that I submitted.
Richard Joslin: That would cover himself – but that wouldn’t cover his employee ...
Chairman Lantz: It wouldn’t cover the employee.
Richard Joslin: ... unless it’s a corporation. If you’re a corporation, then you can
have that ...
Patrick White: They’re an LLC so they’re a business entity but, I think the Board’s
concern is correct. If you have an employee – whether – I’m assuming is a W-2
employee?
Michael Haldie: It is.
Patrick White: In that case – unless he/she’s an officer or manager or some
component of the business itself – the exemption does not apply.
Michael Haldie: It is my wife. When we do a roof, we must have someone on the
ground to spray everything and keep everything wet so we ...
Patrick White: So, she’s an employee?
Michael Haldie: We are 50/50 owners.
Patrick White: She’s also a managing member. That’s Megan Haldie, correct?
Michael Haldie: Yes, sir.
Patrick White: Yes – she’s a managing member of the LLC. So, under that
designation, regardless of being a W-2 employee as well, she is entitled to be
classified as part of the request for an approval of an exemption from Workers’ Comp
insurance coverage. But you need to have the paperwork correctly filed and in your
file which I don’t believe I saw but I may have missed it.
Vice Chairman Nolton: I didn’t see it in there. It’s a simple form – you and your
wife can get the exemption filed and that would take care of it.
Patrick White: Do you have any other questions, Mr. Chairman?
Chairman Lantz: I do not.
Patrick White: I would like to propose a motion.
Patrick White moved to approve the application of Michael Haldie for a Roof
Coating, Painting, and Cleaning Contractor’s license subject to providing evidence
of the requisite Workers’ Comp exemption to the Licensing Office Supervisor
before the license will be issued.
Richard Joslin: I have one thing for discussion first. Under the liability policy ...
maybe I’m missing some numbers but ... I’m seeing a liability policy where each
occurrence is $500.00 – or is it $5,000? And then the total company coverage is
$1,000? To be up on top of a roof?
Michael Haldie: I believe it’s $500,000 and one million.
Chairman Lantz explained the figures were on the side of the form.
Richard Joslin: Okay – I’m just making sure.
Patrick White: Is that your Second?
Richard Joslin: Yes.
Chairman Lantz: We have a motion and a second. Is there any more discussion?
Terry Jerulle: Do you understand what you are doing?
Michael Haldie: I get the proper paperwork for the exemption and then I’m back in
business.
4.A.1
Packet Pg. 8 Attachment: February 2019 Minutes (8295 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - FEBRUARY 20, 2019)
February 20, 2019
6
Terry Jerulle: Right.
Chairman Lantz: Or you could get Workers’ Comp insurance – either one.
Michael Haldie: Workers Comp ... provide that to Collier County ...
Chairman Lantz: Workers’ Comp insurance or an exemption – that’s your decision.
If you want insurance on yourself ... if you want to pay for it ... it’s about $50 for
each.
Michael Haldie: We already got a quote for it ... that’s about what we got.
Chairman Lantz: Alright. Any more discussion?
Chairman Lantz called for a vote on the motion. Carried unanimously, 5 – 0.
Chairman Lantz: As soon as you get the information, you can go to the County
Office on Horseshoe and talk to Evy.
Michael Haldie: Thank you very much for your time.
C. Darleen Rowe – Reinstatement of License, Request to Waive Exam, and Request
to Change Name
(d/b/a “Rowe Flooring, LLC”)
Chairman Lantz called Darleen Rowe to the podium.
Lilla Davis, Administrative Supervisor – Contractors’ Licensing Office, provided
background information to the Board:
• The Applicant has applied for full reinstatement of her Floor Covering
Installation Contractor’s license. She has also requested a Waiver of Exams
and a change of name.
• She also requested to apply the score of the Business Procedures test (86%)
that she took in 2012 to this reinstatement.
• Ms. Rowe previously appeared before the Board in August 2012 for a review
of her credit.
• The Board approved a probationary license of one year. She was to present
updated business and personal credit reports at six and twelve months.
• She appeared before the Board on February 20, 2013.
• The Board decided that she was to appear before them in February 2014, but
she did not return, and her license was suspended.
• Ms. Rowe does not currently hold a license in any other county in Florida.
Darleen Rowe stated:
• She has been in the flooring industry for more than 25 years between New
Jersey and Florida
• She incorporated her company in Florida in 2002.
• She and her husband separated in 2013-2014 and parted ways professionally.
• He former husband opened his own company.
• She left the flooring industry and is currently a manager at a Bank of America
branch.
4.A.1
Packet Pg. 9 Attachment: February 2019 Minutes (8295 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - FEBRUARY 20, 2019)
February 20, 2019
7
• Her divorce became final in 2018.
• She has decided to return to the flooring industry.
Chairman Lantz questioned the Applicant:
Q. How long have you been away from the flooring industry?
A. Since my license expired ... 2013 ... I think I dissolved my corporation in 2014.
Q. You haven’t been in the trade at all?
A. In a few years, yes.
Q. For the last couple of years. And the test that you say you took, that was in ...?
A. 2012.
Q. 2012.
A. When I moved to Florida, I was in Destin in Okaloosa County and testing wasn’t
required there. When I moved to Collier County it was required and I took it.
Terry Jerulle questioned the Applicant:
Q. How long have you been working for the Bank of America?
A. I’ve been in banking the whole time ... five or six years.
Chairman Lantz questioned the Applicant:
Q. Are you doing a name change or is it a new entity?
A. Technically, it’s a new entity with a new tax ID number. It’s because I don’t want
to be associated with anything that my ex-husband was associated with ... just,
you know ... personal reasons.
Q. And he is ...
A. My son.
Q. Okay.
A. He has also been in flooring for two decades.
Q. That’s a lot of experience between your name and Joel’s name.
A. We’ve both been in it.
Q. I thought I saw an experience letter that for Joel for the last few years ... working
for Hadinger Flooring doing carpet installation?
A. Yes. When I worked in Destin in Okaloosa County, Hadinger’s has relatives in
Destin and I worked for them. When I moved to Collier County, I worked for
them again and Joel continued to work for them under another company.
Q. We have a verification for Darleen Rowe and Joel Rowe ... from the Warehouse
Manager for Hadinger Flooring on Airport Road, Naples, from January 2012 to
December 2018 with the scope of work as carpet installation. So, you did carpet
installation at the same time you were working at the bank? Explain that for me.
A. Well, it has Joel’s name on the top.
Q. So that’s Joel’s verification?
A. Yes, and like I said – I’ve been affiliated with Hadinger for ... I don’t know ...
fifteen years in some sort or fashion. And I think in the packet there is also my
prior experience affidavits.
Q. Yes, yes.
There was a brief discussion among the members to clarify that the previously
4.A.1
Packet Pg. 10 Attachment: February 2019 Minutes (8295 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - FEBRUARY 20, 2019)
February 20, 2019
8
-submitted Affidavits of Good Character and Verifications of Construction
Experience from 2012 applied to Darleen Rowe/Dazzling Floors, Inc., and the new
Verifications, dated January 2019, labeled as “Darleen Rowe/Joel Rowe,” applied to
her son, Joel’s, current experience.
Q. One of the things ... for us to waive the exam for you is ... you must prove to us
for the Board to be comfortable that taking the exam would be a waste of time
because you have been active in the industry ... in your trade. One of the big
things is the Business and Law exam. Since you have not been doing anything
like running a construction business, it’s hard for us to say that we feel confident
that you can do it because you haven’t been active for a while. One of your duties
is to convince us that you don’t need to take it again.
A. Okay.
Richard Joslin: Also, we still have some issues with her credit from what I can
gather.
Darleen Rowe: There shouldn’t be any issues with my credit.
It was noted Ms. Rowe’s current credit score is 648 which is not that below the
County’s threshold of 660.
Chairman Lantz stated the packet contained Ms. Rowe’s credit report from 2012.
Patrick White confirmed the Board at that time did have issues with her credit
report.
Chairman Lantz asked the members if they had any questions for Ms. Rowe.
Terry Jerulle: Right now, I’m not convinced that you have had any experience in
the last five years. I think the burden is on you to convince us that you do. You have
been working at a bank and Joel is the manager of a warehouse. And you want us to
waive an exam that typically everybody else must take.
Darleen Rowe: First off – just to clarify – he is not the manager of the warehouse.
He is an installer. I don’t know why there is confusing about the papers. I think the
warehouse manager is the one who wrote the affidavit. Joel is an installer.
Vice Chairman Nolton: Another question we usually ask is why not take the test?
Darleen Rowe: Well, I could. It wasn’t fun – you know what I mean? And I still
have my books so if I had a question, I could refer to my books.
Vice Chairman Nolton: What is the date of the books?
Darleen Rowe: I took this exam in 2012.
Richard Joslin: Don’t you think things have changed since 2012?
Darleen Rowe: Maybe. But do you require people to go back periodically and re-
take the test?
Vice Chairman Nolton: Not when they’ve stayed in business – because they have
been in business, they have had to experience and conform to the changes in the laws.
Somebody who has been out of the business for four years or more may not know
what those changes are.
4.A.1
Packet Pg. 11 Attachment: February 2019 Minutes (8295 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - FEBRUARY 20, 2019)
February 20, 2019
9
Darleen Rowe: Okay. Well, it’s floor covering, and I feel confident that I am aware
of the laws for floor covering.
Chairman Lantz (directed his question to Staff): Are there two tests? There’s the
Business and Law. Is there also a floor covering test?
Everildo Ybaceta: There is the Business and Law test and I do believe there is a
floor covering test, too.
Chairman Lantz: One of the things that we tend to take issue with ...
Everildo Ybaceta: I’m sorry – I’m mistaken ... it’s just the Business and Law test.
Patrick White: It’s just the B&L.
Chairman Lantz: ... is the Business.
Patrick White: It’s 24-months of experience.
Chairman Lantz: I don’t think anyone is questioning that you have twenty-four
months of experience doing floor covering work.
Patrick White: I’m comfortable that someone who has can operate in the financial
world as the manager of a bank probably could handle a balance sheet, reconcile a
checkbook, manage to process invoices for Accounts Payable and Accounts
Receivable, as well as handle any payment for payroll.
Richard Joslin: What are you duties at the bank?
Darleen Rowe: I’m the manager.
Patrick White: And as the manager, in the past, have you held any of the other
positions that are reporting and responsible to you?
Darleen Rowe: What?
Patrick White: Such as tellers ...?
Darleen Rowe: Oh, yes. I started out ... when I was separated from my husband, I
started as a part-time teller. I worked at every position at the bank and was promoted
pretty rapidly in the past five years.
Patrick White: Thank you.
Chairman Lantz: Any other questions from the Board? [There were none.] It
sounds as if you’re ready to make a motion, Mr. White.
Patrick White moved to approve waiving the requirement for the Applicant to re-
take the Business and Law exam.
Chairman Lantz asked if there was a Second in support of the motion from a Board
member.
Vice Chairman Nolton offered a Second in support of the motion.
Discussion:
• Patrick White: I would simply indicate that I think the risk to the consumer
in this circumstance is minimal. The credit report having been improved and
explained in part because of the divorce which is now concluded, suggests to
me that she has figured out how to manage her own finances and in
combination with her business experience ... for the prior license and since in
the finance industry as a banker ... are adequate to be able to approve the
license and waive taking the Business and Law test.
4.A.1
Packet Pg. 12 Attachment: February 2019 Minutes (8295 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - FEBRUARY 20, 2019)
February 20, 2019
10
• Terry Jerulle: I don’t disagree with anything that Mr. White said. I’m not
preventing you from getting your license because I think you could take the
test which I think you should do and, in fact, your son should also take the
test.
• Darleen Rowe: And we had that discussion on the way here – that he should
take the test.
• Terry Jerulle: It would behoove you, as an entity, for him to take the test.
• Darleen Rowe: He’s had possession of the books for the past couple of years
because I told him since he was in flooring ...
• Terry Jerulle: It would be best for everyone if you did. My point is I think
you should take the test, but I don’t disagree with Mr. White.
• Patrick White: Let’s see where the vote goes.
• Richard Joslin: Is there anything in your divorce decree that ties you to the
past debts that you and your husband had?
• Darleen Rowe: There debts were all resolved.
• Richard Joslin: There were resolved, and you’re not involved any longer?
• Darleen Rowe: No, sir.
• Vice Chairman Nolton: Obviously, you are an intelligent person and you
have the experience in running the business but the things that you may not
know is what has changed with the new laws and other components that have
nothing to do with running a business or finances. That would be the value of
taking the test – to be sure that you knew all the updates and changes.
Personally, I don’t think there’s a lot of risk to the public for that business.
• Chairman Lantz: Not the business itself.
• Patrick White: Exactly. But the books that you have are, in a sense,
outdated. Although the fundamentals may be there, the precise points that
Matt raised are ones that would behoove you.
• Darleen Rowe: Right.
• Patrick White: If the motion doesn’t ...
• Darleen Rowe: I understand but I’m confident that I know about the current
laws ...
• Patrick White: It’s not that complicated ... it just requires you to meet the
common deadlines and file the proper paperwork.
Terry Jerulle questioned the number of votes needed and was told since only five
members were present, a majority was needed to pass the motion.
Chairman Lantz noted there was a motion and a second. He called for a vote on
the motion.
Motion carried, 3 – “Yes”/2 – “No.” Mr. Jerulle and Mr. Joslin were opposed.
Everildo Ybaceta requested to change the order of the Agenda – for the Board to hear
Mr. Bumpus case before hearing Mr. Bowles of Jackson Pools.
Chairman Lantz agreed.
4.A.1
Packet Pg. 13 Attachment: February 2019 Minutes (8295 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - FEBRUARY 20, 2019)
February 20, 2019
11
IX. OLD BUSINESS:
(Note: The individuals who testified in the following cases under Item IX, “Old
Business,” were first sworn in by the Attorney for the Board.)
B. Jeffrey Bumpus: Factual Finding – Were Permits Closed by January 19, 2019
as Ordered by the Board
(d/b/a “Northern Breeze Air Conditioning, Inc.”)
Patrick White: Are you making a report
Everildo Ybaceta: I can make a quick report, yes.
Patrick White: I’m suggesting it’s Staff and not Mr. Bumpus who is not here.
Everildo Ybaceta: He’s not here. Mr. Bumpus has, to date, four permits that are
still in re-activation status. There are nine that have been issued. He has another
three that ready for issuance and they are still open and active.
Patrick White: And active or inactive?
Everildo Ybaceta: Active.
Chairman Lantz: What you’re telling us is he has not the deadline to have all
permits closed out?
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes, sir.
Richard Joslin: Is it true that there are still 16 open permits?
Everildo Ybaceta: Those are considered “open” – they had been re-activated.
Patrick White: So, he hasn’t called for inspections?
Everildo Ybaceta: No.
Patrick White: And without inspections, they cannot be closed?
Everildo Ybaceta: Correct.
Richard Joslin: Have you heard from Mr. Bumpus?
Everildo Ybaceta: No, sir.
Patrick White: Have you attempted to contact Mr. Bumpus?
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes, sir, there was an attempt to contact him – he was supposed
to be here.
Patrick White: A hypothetical ... for example, if the Board today decided that he
was done, what happens next?
Everildo Ybaceta: That would be up to the Board’s attorney.
Jed Schneck, Esq. – Attorney for the Contractors’ Licensing Board: The next
step would be for the Board to request that Staff to send the letter of recommendation
to the State’s Construction Industry Licensing Board (“CILB”) for further
disciplinary action.
Chairman Lantz: So, we’ve already determined that it is what we will do if we
decide that he didn’t meet the deadline?
Attorney Schneck: Correct.
Chairman Lantz: If we do nothing, that automatically happens ... or we could
reconsider and draw a new “line in the sand.”
Patrick White: I think we must make a factual finding.
Attorney Schneck: That is correct. The Board could simply make a factual finding
that the Respondent has not complied with the Order and therefore Staff should
proceed.
4.A.1
Packet Pg. 14 Attachment: February 2019 Minutes (8295 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - FEBRUARY 20, 2019)
February 20, 2019
12
Chairman Lantz: To make a factual finding ... is that a motion that we make?
Patrick White: It is based on the testimony of Staff – have they been sworn?
Chairman Lantz: Evy, have you been sworn in?
Everildo Ybaceta: Me?
Chairman Lantz: Yes.
Everildo Ybaceta: No.
[Mr. Ybaceta was sworn in by the Attorney for the Board.]
Chairman Lantz: Well now that you’re under oath ...
Patrick White: Is what you said before, still true?
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes, sir.
Patrick White: Good.
Chairman Lantz: So, you are testifying, on behalf of the County, that Mr. Bumpus
has not closed out all of his permits.
Everildo Ybaceta: I am, sir.
Chairman Lantz: Is that enough? How about anybody else? Any other questions?
[There were none.] Does anyone want to make a motion?
Patrick White moved to approve finding that Jeffrey Bumpus has not complied with
the Order of this Board and a Finding of Fact to that effect. Richard Joslin offered
a Second in support of the motion.
Chairman Lantz asked if there was any discussion. [There was none.]
Chairman Lantz called for a vote on the motion. Carried unanimously, 5 – 0.
Chairman Lantz: This case is officially done with us as far as we know it – correct?
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes, sir.
Chairman Lantz: Yes. Perfect.
Richard Joslin: Do you want to read the penalty?
Patrick White: No.
Chairman Lantz: I think we already did that – last month or two months ago.
Attorney Schneck: That’s correct. The Board formalized the recommended penalty
last month and now County Staff will send the recommendation to the State.
A. Case #2018-10: Update – Stephen Bowles (d/b/a “Jackson Pools”)
Misconduct of a State-Certified Contractor
Chairman Lantz called Stephen Bowles to the podium and was sworn.
Chairman Lantz: The same rules apply from the Public Hearing that we held two
months ago. He asked the County to begin.
Jack Gumph, Contractor Licensing Compliance Officer was also sworn.
4.A.1
Packet Pg. 15 Attachment: February 2019 Minutes (8295 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - FEBRUARY 20, 2019)
February 20, 2019
13
Everildo Ybaceta: Mr. Schneck, Mr. Noell has some information to provide ... if
you would like to swear him in.
Assistant County Attorney Kevin Noell: I don’t think I need to be sworn – I’m not
going to provide testimony to the Board ... only a recommendation. I talked with the
party ... with Jackson Pools and their representatives ... there were some hiccups with
the permitting. If the Board will recall – last time that Jackson Pools was before the
Board, the Order was to get a permit, and to have it closed out by today. I talked with
both the representatives for Jackson Pools and with Staff. There have been some
hiccups with the permit process. It is now all set and ready to be issued – or has been
issued – and we would ask that it be rolled over for another thirty days to allow them
to close out the permit and this will probably be an issue that I will walk through with
Evy to make sure that we have a resolution within thirty days. But they have taken
significant steps, including driving to Sarasota to get some engineering records and
things of that nature, so they are putting forth a significant effort. I think that our
recommendation – issued from the Staff side – and I think from Evy as well – would
be to roll it for thirty days to ...
Patrick White: You would like the Board to table it for thirty days or do you want to
withdraw it and bring it back in thirty days? I’m not clear.
Assistant County Attorney Noell: I would ask the Board to table it for thirty days
just because the Board had made the previous motion that was agreed upon to bring it
back today for completion. I would just ask that it gets tabled until the next meeting.
Richard Joslin: What was the “hiccup” with the permit?
Assistant County Attorney Noell: There were several different issues that would
probably involve a lot of different testimony and things of that nature, so it would
probably ... my recommendation would be ... if the Board wants to go through that
process, we could. But my recommendation, however, would be just to give it an
additional thirty days and we will, hopefully, have it all wrapped up.
Chairman Lantz: Well, let me ask you this – let’s just say we decide to give another
thirty days, if he finals out the permit tomorrow – then we won’t see him ever again
... correct?
Assistant County Attorney Noell: Correct. If that’s the Board’s ...
Terry Jerulle: Mr. Bowles, can you convince us?
Stephen Bowles: Yes, sir. Well, it’s been a rigorous ...
Terry Jerulle: In the same fashion ... can you ...
Stephen Bowles: It’s been a ...
Terry Jerulle: I don’t care about the process ... looking forward ...
Stephen Bowles: We’re right there ... we’re
Terry Jerulle: Let me finish ... let me finish ...
Stephen Bowles: Oh, okay.
Terry Jerulle: ... please. Looking forward ...
Stephen Bowles: I thought you were asking a question.
Terry Jerulle: I am. Looking forward, can you convince us that what Mr. Noell is
saying will happen in the next thirty days?
Stephen Bowles: Absolutely, sir. We’re right there – the permits issued ... all the
paperwork is in ... they are still probably finishing up on their side. There’s one
inspection to come out and do and, like I said, we’re right there. And we’re been
4.A.1
Packet Pg. 16 Attachment: February 2019 Minutes (8295 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - FEBRUARY 20, 2019)
February 20, 2019
14
we’re getting it done. There’s been some paperwork that they thought they had, and
we thought they had ... and both parties found and ... so, we’re right there ... within
the next ...
Terry Jerulle: Materials ... manpower ... everything is set to ...
Stephen Bowles: Yes, sir.
Terry Jerulle: ... to be done within the next thirty days?
Stephen Bowles: More than likely, within the next week probably ...
Terry Jerulle: And you’re very clear about the inspections that you need to call in
and to pass?
Stephen Bowles: Absolutely.
Richard Joslin: Did I see in the packet where there are still three inspections to be
called in yet for final?
Stephen Bowles: Well, we’re still working that ... I don’t know exactly which three
is up to date now because we had some. I would maybe ask Mr. Ybaceta. I know we
had the final is what I was under ... assumption that it was down to the final
inspection.
Richard Joslin: I believe a couple of the inspections would be necessary before the
final is given on the permit ... or maybe I’m wrong?
Jack Gumph: Mr. Chairman, I would like to defer to Jonathan Walsh, the Collier
County Chief Building Official, for any questions as to the permit.
Chairman Lantz: Okay.
Jonathan Walsh, Chief Building Official for Collier County, was sworn in.
Richard Joslin: Mr. Walsh, I’m looking at one of the pages and it says that – from
what I can see – there are four inspections that are still pending. It’s showing the pool
bonding, the pool final, the pool shell reinforcement, and verify the permit is ready to
issue. I assume that one has been done.
Jon Walsh: The permit has been picked up. Unfortunately, there seems to have
been an issue with the payment, so the permit was placed on an inspection hold. I
don’t know the finance element of it ... all I know is ... there are two inspection holds
– one is for the Notice of Commencement that has not been recorded yet and they’ll
still need to get that done. But that may have been recorded but it just has not been
provided to us and that condition resolved. That’s a minor element. The other
element is to follow-up with cashiering to resolve whatever the payment issue was – I
don’t know ... I’m not a banker. There was something wrong at cashiering when the
payment was made ... it says “reversal” on it. I’m not exactly sure what that means.
As far as I am aware, the funds were not available. It could have been an error in the
transmitting ... it could have been a bunch of different things ... I have no idea. There
are three inspections that I am aware of: the shell, bonding, and final.
Richard Joslin: And these are the things that he was telling us would be done within
a week or ...?
Stephen Bowles: Yes. I have all the proper paperwork for all those and I think ... we
just found out this morning that everything was on hold because of the $100. I don’t
know. We picked up the permit and then, come to find out, there was one hundred
dollars that needed to be paid after-the-fact then everything got put on hold. For one
4.A.1
Packet Pg. 17 Attachment: February 2019 Minutes (8295 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - FEBRUARY 20, 2019)
February 20, 2019
15
hundred dollars? I mean .... (gesturing with his hands in the air) ... I didn’t realize
that until this morning and it’s one hundred dollars that’s holding us up ... like I said,
we’re so close.
Chairman Lantz: But you’ve got it?
Stephen Bowles: We’ve got it, yes, sir. We’ve got all the information.
Chairman Lantz: Are the inspections that are left to be done, are they being done
by the County or a private provider?
Stephen Bowles: When they have the proper engineering information ... private
providers.
Jon Walsh: It’s not technically done by a private provider. In this instance, they
have hired a licensed Engineer to perform the inspections that we cannot without
some destructive work being done.
Chairman Lantz: They will send you a report and then you – or somebody on your
staff – will then verify ...?
Jon Walsh: A letter was provided by email to me yesterday by the Engineer at 4:17
PM. Unfortunately, it is not completely compliant, and it is in review. I was having
conversations with him as early as 8:00 this morning.
Chairman Lantz: The ball is rolling?
Jon Walsh: Yep.
Vice Chairman Nolton: Let me ask a little more in-depth. I hear that there are some
questions about it. Mr. Bowles, that’s not satisfactory for those two inspections –
because we’re talking about two, and then you have the final. Are you saying to the
Board that you’re willing to do whatever it takes to make those two inspections
satisfactory?
Stephen Bowles: Yeah, I mean ... whatever is required.
Vice Chairman Nolton: Even if it includes some further inspection and testing ...
Stephen Bowles: Well, I don’t know ...
Vice Chairman Nolton: ... ... to satisfy that?
Stephen Bowles: ... I don’t know what in depth that he’s going to really need other
than ... like he said, he was talking with him as early as this morning. I don’t know if
he’s going to get all the information. If he’s not, I think there’s pictures that has
surfaced that might help ... because it’s been two years and I’ve been through a lot of
phones and I-Clouds so ... I don’t know the exact pictures yet.
Vice Chairman Nolton: That’s not my question – right? Let’s say that there isn’t
the data ... let’s say that there’s not the pictures. I’m asking the question ... if there’s
not, are you – in thirty days – going to do whatever it takes to pass those inspections?
Stephen Bowles: Absolutely.
Chairman Lantz: Even if it entails some demolition work ... some whatever ...?
Stephen Bowles: Well ... I ... I don’t know that ...
Patrick White: Which is it, sir? Are you absolutely going to do it, or are you not?
Stephen Bowles: I’m going to do, I guess, whatever Jon Walsh and the Building
Department requires me to do.
Patrick White: That’s a good answer.
Stephen Bowles: That’s what I’ll ... yes, sir.
Chairman Lantz: All right. Any other questions from the Board?
4.A.1
Packet Pg. 18 Attachment: February 2019 Minutes (8295 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - FEBRUARY 20, 2019)
February 20, 2019
16
Attorney Schneck: If I may ... just as a recommendation ... after going through the
Bumpus case, to leave it cleaner in this situation – as we’re extending it, adding
additional time – I would request that the Board amend its Order of December 19,
2018 to change the compliance date. That way we’ll have a new Order, and
everything is fresh. So, if there’s any appeal issue ... everything is new and proper.
It’s something that we’ve learned going through the Bumpus case – to move things up
as these cases go on.
Chairman Lantz: So, I guess the motion will be ... instead of saying, ‘we give you
thirty days’ ... the motion will be to amend the previous Order to ...?
Attorney Schneck: Correct. And I would state March 20, 2019 which is the next
meeting date as the new compliance date.
Patrick White: And would it also be possible to amend it in a fashion that if the
permit is closed out, that the case is closed?
Attorney Schneck: Correct. And I would authorize Staff to make that determination
if the Respondent has proven that the permit has been properly closed out, then Staff
can close out this case. If not, they can bring it back before the Board.
Patrick White: Are you comfortable writing that Order and providing it by way of a
motion that I’m prepared to make based on what you have suggested?
Attorney Schneck: I am.
Patrick White: Thank you. So moved, White.
Richard Joslin: One last comment. Mr. Walsh, are you comfortable with the
engineering that has been provided to you so far regarding these last two major
inspections?
Jon Walsh: At this moment in time, the only one that I am questioning is the
bonding.
Richard Joslin: Okay.
Jon Walsh: Sufficient information has been provided for the steel reinforcing, but I
am questioning the bonding.
Richard Joslin: Okay.
Vice Chairman Nolton: Second, Nolton.
Chairman Lantz stated there was a motion and a second. He asked the members if
they had any other questions, comments or discussion.
Richard Joslin: This motion is to ...?
Chairman Lantz: The motion is to amend the Board’s previous motion to change
the date of compliance to March 20, 2019. When the permit is final, then Staff may
administratively close the case.
Chairman Lantz called for a vote on the motion. Carried unanimously, 5 – 0.
Stephen Bowles: Thank you.
Terry Jerulle: The clock is ticking.
X. PUBLIC HEARING:
(None)
4.A.1
Packet Pg. 19 Attachment: February 2019 Minutes (8295 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - FEBRUARY 20, 2019)
February 20, 2019
17
NEXT MEETING DATE: WEDNESDAY, MARCH 20, 2019
BCC Chambers, 3rd Floor – Administrative Building “F,
Government Complex, 3301 E. Tamiami Trail, Naples, FL
There being no further business for the good of the County, the meeting was adjourned by
order of the Chairman at 10:00 AM.
COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS’
LICENSING BOARD
_____________________________________
KYLE E. LANTZ, Chairman
The Minutes were approved by the Chairman or Vice Chairman of the Contractors’ Licensing
Board on ______________________, 2019, “as submitted” [___] - OR - “as amended” [___]
4.A.1
Packet Pg. 20 Attachment: February 2019 Minutes (8295 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - FEBRUARY 20, 2019)
03/20/2019
COLLIER COUNTY
Contractor Licensing Board
Item Number: 8.A
Item Summary: ORDERS OF THE BOARD
Meeting Date: 03/20/2019
Prepared by:
Title: – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Lilla Davis
03/11/2019 3:41 PM
Submitted by:
Title: Supervisor - Operations – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Everildo Ybaceta
03/11/2019 3:41 PM
Approved By:
Review:
Contractor Licensing Board Lilla Davis Review Item Completed 03/11/2019 4:16 PM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Review Item Completed 03/11/2019 4:49 PM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Meeting Pending 03/20/2019 9:00 AM
8.A
Packet Pg. 21
03/20/2019
COLLIER COUNTY
Contractor Licensing Board
Item Number: 9.A
Item Summary: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT
OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE
Meeting Date: 03/20/2019
Prepared by:
Title: – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Lilla Davis
03/11/2019 4:00 PM
Submitted by:
Title: Supervisor - Operations – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Everildo Ybaceta
03/11/2019 4:00 PM
Approved By:
Review:
Contractor Licensing Board Lilla Davis Review Item Completed 03/11/2019 4:15 PM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Review Item Completed 03/11/2019 4:49 PM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Meeting Pending 03/20/2019 9:00 AM
9.A
Packet Pg. 22
C,a et Qounty
COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD
MARCH 20,2019
9:00 A.M.
ADMINISTRATIVE COMPLAINT - CASE 2018.10
STEPHEN L BOWLES _ MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR
STEPHEN BOWLES is the License holder for his company JACKSON CUSTOM POOLS, LLC (DBA)
JACKSON POOL SERVICE. A Contractor Licensing case (CEM1520160021439) was opened due to
a report of unpermitted pool construction at 539.1 Tamarind Ridge Drive. A permit application was
submltted on 4h812017. This permit was in a Void status, as it was originally rejected, and Mr.
Bowles never submitted any corrections.
Mr. Bowles was originally in front ol the board on December 19, 2018. The minutes from this meeting
are attached. Mr. Bowles was given 60 days to reapply and have the permit finaled. lf he didn't, he
needed to return to the Board and his permit pulling privileges from Collier County would be on hold
except for this permit plus we would send a letter to the state and recommend the maximum penalty.
Mr. Bowles came before the Board again on February 20,2019. The minutes from this meeting are
attached. The County asked for an additional 30 days for Mr. Bowles to final the permit as there were
some issues with getting the permit issued. The permit application was submitted on February 7th and
given permit number PRBD20190205517. The permit had 3 inspections that were needed. Two
inspections (700- Pool Bonding & 704 - Pool Shell Reinforcemenl) were passed via an Engineer
Letter approved by Jonathan Walsh. The Final Pool inspection was passed on 3/6/2019. The permit
received the Certificate of Completion on 3/6/2019, also attached. The permit is considered closed.
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 23 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292
Gontents
December 19,2018 CLB Minutes
February 20,2019 CLB [\rlinutes
Permit PR8D2019020551 7 Certificate of Completion
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 24 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292
December 19.2018
MINUTES
OF THE COLLIER COUNTY
CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOAR.D
December 19, 2018
Naples, Florida
LET IT BE REMEMBERED that the Collier County Contractors' Licensing
Board, having conducted business herein, met on this date at 9:00 AM in
REGULAR SESSION in Administrative Building 66F," 3rd Floor, Coliier County
Govemment Complex, Naples, Florida, with the following Members present:
Chairman:
Vice Chair:
Members:
Michael E. Boyd
Kyle E. Lantz
Terry Jerulle
Richard Joslin
Robert Meister
Matthew Nolton
Excused: Patrick White
ALSO PRESENT:
Everildo Ybaceta - Supervisor, Contractors' Licensing Office
Kevin Noell, Esq. - Assistant Collier County Attomey
Jed Schneck, Esq. - Attomey for the Contractors, Licensing Board
Jack Gumph - Contractors' Licensing Compliance Officer
Reggie Smith - Contractors' Licensing Compliance Officer
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 25 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292 :
December 19. 2018
stating if the permits are not closed out within the next thirty days, we will
recommend to the County that he is to be reported to the State with terms like a
suspension ofhis license and a $10,000 fine.
Vice Chairman Lantz: You are saying to recommend that if the permits are
not closed out within the next thirty days, we request the maximum penalty possible?
Matthew Nolton: Something like that so that we're done with it and we haven't just
left it to chance to someone else - we've put in a penalty to the options.
Vice Chairman Lantz: Is that a Second with the amendment?
Matthew Nolton: It would be.
Vice Chairman Lantzz I will modify my motion.
Chairman Boyd called for a vote on the motion. Carried unanimously, 6 - 0.
Chairman Boyd stated the case was closed.
X, PUBLIC HEARING:
A. Case 201E-10: Board of County Commissioners, Plaintiff, vs. Stephen Bowles,
dlbla Jackson Pools, Respondent - Misconduct of a State-Certified
Contractor
(Np1!s: The individuals who testified in the following case under ltem X, "Public
Hearing," h,ere rtr sworn in by the Attorney for the Boaril.)
Terry Jerulle: Mr. Chairman, my company has used Jackson Pools in the past. I
don't believe I know Mr. Bowles. I don't know if you know me.
Stephen Bowles: No, sir.
Terry Jerulle: It's been ten years or longer since I've used them. I am disclosing
this fact - I don't know that it would have any impact on my decisions or my thought
process.
Richard Joslin pointed out there are two "Jackson Pools" in business. There was a
Jackson Pool Construction and a Jackson Pool Service.
Stephen Bowles: We are Jackson Pool Service.
Terry Jerulle: Oh, then I take it back. My mistake. Thank you for pointing that out.
2t
Vice Chairman l-antz moved to:
. Continue the restrictions on the permit pulling pivileges of Jeffrey Bumpus
cunently in efJect in Collier County until the remaining permits are closed;
. Approve concluding the Board's heafing of this case, and
. Approve directing Collier Count! Staff to send. a written recommendation to
the Slale's Construclion Industry Licensing Board ("CILB") requesting
enforcement of ,he maximum penalties possible, i.e., suspension oJ Jeffrey
Bumpus' license and imposing afine of $10,000 if the remaining permits
are not closed out teithin thirty days.
Matthew Nolton offered a Second in support oj the motion.
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 26 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292
December 19,2018
Chairman Boyd requested a motion to open the Public Hearing for Case #2018-10:
Board of County Commissioners, Plaintiff, vs. Stephen L. Bowles, dlbla Jackson
Pool Semice, Misconduct of a State-Certified Contractor.
Richard loslin moved to approve opening the Public Heaing for Case #2018-10 as
previously referenced. Matthew Nolton olfered a Second in support of the motion.
Carried unanimously, 6 - 0.
Chairman Boyd outlined the process for the Hearing:
1. This Hearing will be conducted pursuant to the procedures set forth in Collier
County Ordinance #90-105, as amended, and Florida Statutes Chapter 49.
2. The Hearing is quasi-judicial in nature and the Formal Rules of Evidence will not
apply.
3. Fundamental faimess and due process shall be observed and shall govem the
proceeding.
4. Irrelevant, immaterial, or inconclusive evidence shall be excluded but all other
evidence of the type commonly relied upon by reasonably prudent persons in the
conduct of their affairs shall be admissible whether or not such evidence would be
admissible in a trial in the courts of Florida.
5. Hearsay evidence may be used for the purpose of supplementing or explaining
any evidence but shall not be sufFrcient by itself to support a Finding unless such
hearsay would be admissible or objected to in civil actions in coun.
6. The Rules of Procedure shall be effective to the same extent that they would now
be hereafter recognized in civil actions.
7. The general purpose ofthe proceeding is for the County to set out its Opening
Statement which details its charges against the Respondent.
8. A Respondent may or may not make his/her Opening Statement setting out in
general terms the defenses to the charges.
9. The County then presents its Case in Chief, calling witnesses and presenting
evidence.
10. The Respondent may cross-examine these witnesses.
Jack Gumph, Contractor Licensing Compliance Officer, presented the County's
Opening Statement:
o The Respondent is a State-certified General Contractor and holder of License
Number CPC1456438.
. He is also registered in Collier County (#LCC20120001055) as a Certified
PooVSpa Contractor.. On December 29,2016, Contractor Licensing Compliance Officer Rob
Ganguli performed a site visit at 5391 Tamarind Ridge Drive, Naples, Florida
341 19, in response to a complaint of unpermitted pool construction.o Mr. Ganguli observed renovation work to an existing pool as well as
construction of a new spa unit.
Chairman Boyd confirmed the Public Hearing was open.
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 27 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292
December 19. 2018
. No permit had been issued. After it was determined that a permit was
required, Officer Ganguli posted a "Stop Work" Order at the site.
. The Contractor was Jackson Custom Pools. LLC d,rbla Jackson Pool Service
and Stephen L. Bowles was the Qualifier.. Jackson Poo[ Service was notified of the violation and the "Stop Work"
Order.
o A Notice of Non-Compliance was personally presented to Stephen Bowles
who signed the form on February 14,2017 acknowledging he had been
informed by Officer Ganguli of the permit violation against his license.
. In April 2017, a permit application was submitted. It was later rejected, and a
Correction Letter was sent.
. In June 2017, the permit application was still in rejected status;corrections
were submitted, and the permit was under review.
o In August 2017, the permit was still in rejected status; corrections were
submitted, and a Corrections Letter was sent.
o In October 2017, Stephen Bowles was sent a letter requesting a resolution of
the rejected smtus of the permit.
. In November 2017, Mr. Bowles indicated during a phone conversation that he
was attempting to resolve the matter with the Building Department.
. In March 2018, the permit application had expired and a notice was sent to the
license holder.
r In April 2018, the director ofJackson Pool Service stated the County had been
supplied with engineering reports in an effort to resolve the correction request.
o On August 10, 2018, a Notice to Appear was sent via certified mail to the
Qualifier. The hearing date was scheduled for October 17, 2018.
. On August 14,2018, the mailing was "undeliverable" per the USPS.
. On August 15, 2018, a site visit to 5291 Tamarind Ridge Drive was conducted
and the work to the pool had been completed. Later the homeowner called
and stated the work has been completed by Jackson Pool Service because they
had told the homeowner the issues with the Stop Work Order had been
resolved.
o On August 20,2018, the Notice to Appear was delivered and delivery was
confirmed by USPS.
. On October 16, 2018, Stephen Bowles requested a copy ofthe information
packet to review and the case was rescheduled to December 19, 2018.o The permit remains in VOID status because corrections were never submitted.. Stephen Bowles is in violation of Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as
amended, Section 4.2.2 which states "Willfully violating the applicable
Building Codes or laws of the state, city, or Collier County,,,
Chairman Boyd asked Stephen Bowles if he had a response
Stephen Bowles stated:o He has been a pool contractor in Florida since 1994.o He has built approximately 8,000 to 10,000 pools - permitted
23
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 28 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292
December 19. 2018
. ln25 years, he has never been involved in "anyhing like this."
. On July 12,2016, he signed a contract with the homeowner to remodel an
existing pool and spa that had been built in 1982.
. The spa was flush with the pool deck, but the homeowner wanted to raise the
existing spa by eighteen inches.
. The spa was raised, the plumbing was extended, and new tile was installed on
the deck. New lights, a new pump and hlter were also installed.
o "lt's a cut and dry situation that has been done hundreds of time in this
County."
o He did not think a permit was required to remodel an existing pool.
. Other remodeling work was being done to the to the home at the same time.
. The inspector saw the pool and said a permit was required.
. He was contacted and told a permit was necessary. He did not understand
why a permit was required to remodel an existing pool and spa. There was no
new construction.
. He began the process to pull a permit.
. The work was completed so there was nothing to inspect but he tried to
accommodate the Building Department. He supplied letters irom an engineer
and other documentation.
r He felt his attempts to come into compliance were being "stonewalled" by the
County. He spent thousand ofdollars and is "in the red on the project." He
hired engineers to supply letters and to inspect the site.
. He has had "zero" complaints made against his company.
o He has no idea what else he can do to satisfy the Building Department.
Richard Joslin questioned the Applicant:
Q. How did you change the bonding?
A. We didn't change the bonding.
p. You raised it?
A. No, sir.
Q. You said it was flush.
A. The spa was.
Q. The spa. How did you raise it?
A. We formed it and poured concrete around it?
Q. Did you put sealant around it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You said this was an existing pool with a flush spa?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How did you change the plumbing?
A. We extended it up.
Q. You had to pre-plumb it ro do that?
A. tught.
Q. How did you do the pressure test?
A. We pressure tested it.
Q. Who inspected it?
A. There was no inspection.
24
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 29 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292
December 19, 2018
0. My point. There was also a sun shelf added to it or was it already there?
A. Well, the pool was there. The sun shelf was put inside the pool. No, there was no
sun shelf there. We added it there - it's all one big chunk with no sealing - it's
just sitting inside the pool.
Q. So that was part of the pool at one point?
A. Right, but not a sun sheli
Q. You raised up the spa? The beam?
A. Right, yes, sir.
Terry Jerulle: Excuse me, Mr. Joslin. Mr. Bowles, did you go to the County at the
beginning of the project and ask if you needed a permit?
A. No, sir.
Q. It would seem to me - and I'm not an expert in pools - that you're notjust
remodeling the pool ... you're adding to the pool. By raising the beam ofthe spa,
you're adding to the it.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And in remodeling, it's incumbent upon us, as contractors, to know that we need
permits.
A. Well, that's a grey area.
Q. You can argue that, okay. But to me, it's not so much of a grey area and if it was
a grey iuea as you admitted - the frst step is to go to the County and ask if a
permit is needed.
A. Right -- you're absolutely right.
Q. It's black and white. Maybe you don't. Butif it's a grey area, you go to the
County and ask.
A. Based on my building pools and pulling permits since '94, this is done hundreds
of times. Even here - it's probably being done right now as we're talking.
p. And you know the Codes have changed in the last ...
A. Yes, sir.
Q. ... since you got your license, the Codes have changed several times.
A. Right.
Q. Okay? So, you can't say what you did ten or twenty years ago is the same thing
that you can do today.
Richard Joslin:
Q. Also, on the permitting section of it - years ago you didn't have to have the
hydraulic plumbing engineered and today you do.
A. Well, all the plumbing is under the ground. I cannot do - it's existing.
Q. Not all of it.
A. Just the spa - the spa - yes, you're right.
Q. l'm talking about an engineer coming in and telling you ifthe line sizes are right
for the volume that is going to go through to the jets which would be part of the ...
the engineer would do that when you apply for a permit. They would look at that.
This is the reason why it's a grey area because things have changed since '94.
Andthat's the reason why you're here. Like Terry said, I think it is up to youto
take a little more responsibility - to go in there and get the permit ... or at ieast ask
25
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 30 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292
December 19.2018
the question - do I need a permit or is it just like any other renovation? There
area a lot of people now who are draining pools and resurfacing. Some of them
need a permit. That's the way I would treat any kind of ...
A. And I did evaluate that like you said. But based on the criteria of today and I
came to the conclusion there as no permit involved ... based on - not back then -
but on what's going on today. And I'm paying the price for it because I comply.
I comply. I'm notthe guy out there who's not complying. Andthisone-
obviously, I missed it - I slipped and I'm paying the cost for it. But I did not
"willfully" do that. [t was not intentional or willful. I did not try to defraud the
permit - it's just not that situation. Now I'm trying to comply, but I don't know
how to satisfy the Building Department unless I tear the pool to pieces and let
them see the steel.
Jack Gumph requested to submit the information pack presented to the Board in
Case #2018-10 into evidence as Counw's Exhibit "A."
Vice Chairman l-antz moved to approve accepting the Counry's information pocket
in Case #2018-10 and entering it into evidence. Terry Jerulle offered a Second in
support of the motion. Carried unanimously, 6 * 0.
Richard Joslin continued:
Q. Since you found out a long time ago -- months ago - that you did need a permit,
or you were asked to obtain a permit for thisjob to complete, but you didn't.
A. Yes, sir, I have.
Q. This has gone on...
A. I have. Ifyou would see the paper trail ... you would see that I have been trying
to resolve this matter. And you're right ... the last permit application ... I got to a
wall and they wanted ... I don't know what they want now ... if I can get
clarification of exactly what is needed ... l'm here to comply ... I mean, there's no
reason not to.
Terry Jerulle:
Q. When did the homeowner starr the renovation - before you started the pool or
after?
A. He started the renovations on his house about the same time... a little before, I
guess.
Q. So, that leaves me to believe thar you, at that time, didn't willfully try to do
anything wrong because you knew there would be inspectors there.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. That leaves me to believe that you thought you were doing the right thing at the
time. But the problem is when the County did inform you that you did need a
permit and you didn't follow through the steps to get it. To me, that,s the
problem.
A. I did.
Q. Before that, I don't think you "willfutly" - in my opinion - didn,t willfully try
to cheat but what I think you didn,t do is what the County has been asking you
26
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 31 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292
December 19, 2018
to do after the fact. And another question is - if you had found out before you
started that you needed to get a permit, would you not have charged the client
more money?
A. Would I have charged the client more money ...
Q. Correct.
A. ... for a permit ... absolutely.
p. So why wouldn't you go back to the client now and ask him for more money?
A. Because...
Q. Because if it wasn't included - and I apologize -A. We'd gotten to the point where ...
Q. ... but if it wasn't included in the price in your bid to begin with because you
didn't know and now it is ... that may be enough ... and ['m saying that because
you need to comply.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You need to go through the steps and it's going to cost you more money and that
may be one of the reasons why you gave up.
A. We've not sent him a bill for this - we're eating it - I would not do my client like
that because it fell on me, not him.
Q, That's your business decision.
A. Right.
Q. But the point is that we have an outstanding permit that needs to be taken care of
and you kind of gave up on it.
A. You're right - I did give up ...
Q. And you can't do that.
A. See, Igaveup-notreallygaveup-Ijustgottoawall. I didn't know what else
to submit.
Q. Well, they listed it for you and it was pretty clear.
A. I got it. I gave everything ... everything that they've wanted, I've complied with.
And the last - to my recollection - the last correspondence with them was, 'we
want to know how the inspector or engineer came to his conclusion.' I don't
know if they want him to radar the steel or what - but that's where I'm at.
Vice Chairman Lantz:
Q. The pictures that you show here show the pool clearly under construction - right?
A. Yes. sir.
Jack Gump noted Jonathan Walsh, the Chief Building Official, was in attendance
and could address the issue.
Chairman Boyd stated the Applicant was presenting his case and after the Board
could hear from the County.
Q. We have pictures here of the pool under construction. This is about the point
when you got the 'Stop Work" Order - right? And they said you need to pull a
permit to continue.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How did we get here to pictures later showing a beautiful pool and beautiful
27
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 32 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292
December 19.2018
deck without getting a permit? How do we get from don't do any work until you
get a permit to a completed pool and we still don't have a permit? How? That's
my question.
A. The "Stop Work" Order was lifted once we applied for a permit.
Q. So. when you applied for a permit ...
A. Because I would never have kept going with that - it was lifted, or I would never
... so, the "Stop Work" was lifted once we applied for the permit. There are no
more inspections left from that point untii the hnal. Once we pulled the permit,
we had to get an Engineer's lefter to get to what you saw before it was finished.
There's no more permit other than the final permit and the hnal plumbing. We
went ahead and finished the pool because there were no more inspections until the
end. All the other - the previous inspections that we didn't get were going to be
in the Engineer's letter, so we went ahead and finished the customer's pool. I
mean, it's a beautiful pool.
Q. This "Stop Work" Order says in Remarks, "Must obtain required permits prior to
continuing any funher work." lt doesn't say, "Must apply for" - it says, "Must
obtain." Ifyou had to expose something, it would be pretty easy to do it when
you were in - clearly, you wouldn't want to chip up any concrete, but it would be
a lot less expensive to chip concrete before you had any product on top of it -
right?
Richard Joslin:
0, At that time, the actions should have stopped because you did not obtain the
permit - you just applied for it.
A. Well, we did obtain a permit.
p. The permit was applied for on April 28,2017 . Then it went into "rejected status."
Did you bother to check to see if the permit - why was it rejected?
A. It was because we didn't get inspected before we raised the spa, and that was
rejected - you're right. And then I was told we needed a letter from the Engineer
saying the steel and plumbing were correct.
p. There is something on June 26'h -the permit was still in "rejected status" for
corrections that were sent to you. Meanwhile, the pool was still continuing to be
built.
A. Right.
Vice Chairman Lantz:
Q. You said the permit was issued?
A. It was issued. It's been two years ... I might be ... my memory. So, then that was
another rejection because we didn't have a barrier ... a barrier affidavit with the
pool. That don't exist - the pool was built in 1982. The Department found out
that's in age [the term is "grandfathered"] ... we can't make them put up a cage or
put a barrier up on a pool that was already buitt in 1982 - and the yard is fenced
around. That went on for a couple of months.
Richard Joslin:
p. But if you were going to re-permit or submit a permit for a brand-new
28
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 33 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292
December 19,2018
spa - basically that's what happened and why you are here - the you would have
to comply with today's laws - not whatever happened to the pool in whatever
year you're talking about.
A. I can't say fbr sure on that - that's what I was told - that's why to this day there is
no barrier, there is nothing... the County dropped that. They said, 'okay. we're
not going to push the barrier.' [t was out. I don't know where I'm at or what I
need to do. I mean, we can go back - the damage is done, like you said - I made
a mistake. I wantto correct it because I comply. ['mapool guyandlhavea
passion for this. And when we don't comply with each other - that's what breaks
the whole system down. I'm that guy who complies and thrives on that. And in
25 years - with this one, I got zapped - and there's nobody to blame but me and I
accept that. I want to make it right. We could go back and forth we "he said/she
said" but I'm here at your mercy - I screwed up and that's the bottom line. I
should have done better - that falls on me. About my work, I know far as it
comes to procedures here - I've built ten thousand pools and Collier County
literally has more pools that are literally brand new that falling apart - cracking in
half. This guy [indicating Richard Joslin] knows what I'm talking about. I have
never seen nothing like it in my life. I've done ten thousand pools and none of
them have cracked - none of them have fallen apart. I put twice the rebar - they
don't even put seven bars anymore with a wrap around them. They don't put on
six inches center - two feet down - that's why all the pools crack from the top.
When it comes to the structure and the rebar of this pool, it's unsurpassed - that's
what I do. The weakest part of the pool is the top ofthe pool. And that's where
I'm at, guys - whatever you come up with. I just ask you to look at that. I've
been a licensed pool builder here for 25 years and never had a complaint.
Chairrnan Boyd: Thank you, sir. Are there any questions for Mr. Bowles? [There
were none.] Jack, any rebuttal?
Jack Gumph: I'd like to call Jonathan Walsh and Tim Riegle for the Board to
question.
Jonathan Walsh, Chief Building Official, stated the case started from an inspection
of the residence. The inspector noticed that the pool was being remodeled and I
believe we asked Contractors' Licensing to send an lnvestigator out to open the case
and subsequently asked if a permit was required. A ''Stop Work" Order was issued.
As it stated, the permit was to be issued - not applied for. It has never been applied
for. If anything, he would have been given an allowance to make the site safe while
the permitting process was underway. He never should have moved forward without
the permit being issued.
Chairman Boyd: So, a permit has never been issued?
Jonathan Walsh: Not for the pool.
Richard Joslin: As of today?
Jonathan Walsh: Today it is in "void" status.
Richard Joslin: Did the inspector for the home renovation know that pool was being
renovated as well as the illegal spa?
29
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 34 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292
December 19, 2018
Jonathan lValsh: To begin with, the spa would be a separate permit. It would not
be included in the house permit.
Richard Joslin: If it was just a plan renovation, a permit would not have been
necessary - correct?
Jonathan Walsh: A pool can be re-surfaced without a permit - that's allowed. But
they added steel and concrete - they affected the plumbing - all require a permit. My
largest concem on this construction is the steel not being grounded - not being
bonded. Since this pool is also an older pool - as you know - it probably doesn't
have the proper suction requirements which is also another concern. Regarding the
barrier requirement, we did agree that the property's fence provided a level of
protection, the existing pool not being modified. We agreed there were no increases
regarding life/safety concems, so we allowed the barrier requirement not to be
applied because it wasn't a new pool - it was an existing pool.
Matthew Nolton: Why was the permit never issued - what was missing? What data
was missing?
Jonathan Walsh: I didn't do the review, so I'm going to let Tim answer that
question.
Tim Riegle: I did the second review which was initially rejected because an affidavit
was submitted and not an Engineer's letter. I tried to be as clear as possible in the
Corrections Letter concerning what was required to be included in the Engineer's
letter, i.e., the date and time when the Engineer performed the site inspection and how
he performed the inspection to resolve the issues. It was a steel inspection and there
are multiple methods of inspection that could be used. I spelled it out as specifically
as I could. As you know, we haven't received anything back after I send the second
rejection.
Matthew Nolton: How would that prevent you from issuing a permit? That's a
missed inspection that would need some kind of investigation to do the inspection
after-the-fact. Would that prevent you from issuing a permit?
Tim Riegle: [n this case because it was an after-the-fact permit, we were asking for
what inspection the Engineer's letter was going to cover and ifany additional
inspections were going to be needed and added to the permit.
Matthew Nolton: So. you treated it as an after-the-fact process at that time?
Tirn Riegle: Yes.
Matthew Nolton: Ald is that where it fell apart - when you didn't get any additional
information or data?
Tim Riegle: There was never a response to the second correction letter. At that
point, the plans would sit in a folder waiting for a response from the contractor before
it would be sent out for a second review.
Matthew Nolton: Mr. Bowles, what prevented you from responding or submitting
additional information?
Stephen Bowles: To be honest with you, I really can't recall. I went down there
over and over, and I thought we were in compliance and then he sent this back. I
don't ... it got to be such a mess. I guess why I went ahead and finished the pool - to
be honest with you - if I hadn't, it would probably be sitting there with that Ii.e.,unfinished] today because I would have been waiting on the permit. That's no excuse
30
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 35 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292 :
December 19. 2018
but it slipped - I'm not going to make an excuse. I don't know how I didn't get ... I
was at a stonewall ...
Matthew Nolton: Excuse me but that's a separate issue - whether you continued to
work when you should not have continued to work. What I'm trying to understand is
- no, I don't hear "stone wall" - I hear they said, 'this is what you need to have.' and
then there was no further communication ... is what I hear.
Chairman Boyd: By the looks of it, you had it done. All you had to do was to go
back to the Engineer and stamp the letter with the date he inspected it. Ray Allen
Electric Service said it performed an electrical inspection. Atlas Design and
Engineering did an inspection of the pool plumbing equipment and the rebar. But
then the County asked them for the specific dates when it was done. So, it was all
done - you just didn't lollow up on it.
Stephen Bowles: And then, again, I don't know how that slipped right there. I'm
not going to blame it on nobody but me. I don't have an answer for you on why that
last notice he sent - why I didn't - I don't have an answer. Iwon'tmakeupan
excuse. For some reason - it must have been something because if it would have
been that simple - what we j ust talked about - I would have done it. It makes no
sense to me and like I said - it's been two years. According to him, if I had just one
more letter from the Engineer with the date, time, and how he did it- this would have
all been over?
Chairman Boyd: Basically, yes.
Matthew Nolton: Is that correct?
Jonathan Walsh: It's not that simple ...
Chairman Boyd: In the last corrections letter, all you asked for ..."The Engineer's
letter must include ( I ) the Permit number and site address " -- that's no big deal.
" (2) Specific ircpection performed with the corresponding Collier County lrspection
number; (3) Date and time the inspection was performed; (4) Method of inspection to
justify determination and resolution of the missed inspection-"
Jonathan Walsh: This letter did not state'how.'
Chairman Boyd: If the Engineer did the inspection, he should know how he did it.
Jonathan Walsh: The way it's written curently, this leaer did not state that.
Chairman Boyd: I understand that.
Matthew Nolton: Let me ask the County - if Mr. Bowles would have followed up
and if he would have done whatever he needed to, we wouldn't be here right now.
Jonathan Walsh: The letter from the Engineer would have resolved - for practical
purposes - the rough inspections and then we would have followed up with the finals.
Matthew Nolton: Right. As you know, I'm an Engineer and we've done inspections
like this. We send photos, and we send when we did it, and we send biometric testing
for continuity, and we send all that, so we can justib/ that it was built the way it was
supposed to be built.
Vice Chairman Lantz: So, if he gets his Engineer to do a good inspection or a fixer
inspection - whatever that is - and if he calls the Engineer and gets a letter that
satisfies what you need, then what's the process from there?
Jonathan Walsh: He would have to re-apply for the permit and pay whatever
outstanding fees there are; the old permit would go into ..cancelled., statusi the new
3t
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 36 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292 :
December 19, 2018
permit application would still need to address the comments; the Engineer's
inspection and, unfortunately, I'm not too sure how he would do a continuity test
on something that is finished. But that's not my problem.
Vice Chairman Lantz: Let's just say the Engineer does all that - he pays the fees
and re-applies. Then does the County go back out and perform a final inspection?
Jonathan Walsh: Yes, because the letter was only to cover the "rough" inspection.
Vice Chairman Lantz: He'll get the letter from the Engineer and he'll do whatever
he has to do, then the permit will be issued, and he will call in for a final inspection.
Jonathan Walsh: Yes.
Vice Chairman Lantz: Mr. Bowles, do you understand that?
Stephen Bowles: Absolutely. Yes, sir.
Vice Chairman Lantz: I'm sure there's more than one Engineer in town who knows
how to do that.
Stephen Bowles: We've got the Engineer's letter already, but it wasn't written with
the date and time and so forth.
Vice Chairman Lantz: Theoretically you've already paid for itand youjusthave to
ask him ...
Stephen Bowles: Yes, sir.
ISeveral comments were made concerning how the Engineer would conduct the
different required tests - the speakers were talking over each other. The homeowner
stated the only thing he wanted was a Code-compliant pool.l
Stephen Bowles: Can I just make one more statement now that calmness has
prevailed. If this was a simple as we are sitting here saying and everybody is saying,
I am looking you guys [Staffl in the eye and I am telling you, I would have done that.
If this is why it came to this point - why I am at this hearing - because of some
discrepancies on a letter? We're missing something. You can tell that I'm the type
of guy that - man - I would have been all over that - if thaf s all itwas. But I'm not
going to get into a bunch of"stuff'that is not going to change an),thing. I am telling
you guys - if that was as simple as it is now - when this was going on - it would have
been a done deal. It's too easy - it'sjust too easy to be true, but if it is, I can have
that done before the day is out.
Matthew Nolton: Mr. Bowles, it is true that we're here because the permit had not
been taken care of and ...
Stephen Bowles: Right.
Matthew Nolton: ... communication with the County had stopped. The County had
no way to move this forward other than by this methodology - this process - that
we're going through right now. Is it a simple process? It is basically a simple
process to do what is asked. You do not have to tear out the whole poo[. you may
have to jackhammer some stuff, you may have to expose or reinforce some steel.
There are ways to do it and do the continuity testing. There are ways to do it but you
stopped. You didn't pursue. What we're hearing is you didn,t figure out how to do
this because you don't remember it. The County says there was no communication
from you.
Chairman Boyd: Sir, you are out of order. Ifyou want to address the Board,
32
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 37 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292 :
December 19. 20t8
you can come up and be sworn in. Thank you. And you are? Come up and
be sworn in, please. State your name, please.
Richard Hudec, General Manager, Jackson Pool Service: What Steve is trying to
say is we were at the County. What we don't want to do is get into odds with the
Permitting Department in a "he said/she said." I personally met with Rob Garguli, I
tried to see Jon probably three times - Jon would not come out of his office. I spoke
to Fred, I spoke to the County Zoning Commissioner, but he Uonathan Walshl is
impossible to talk to. Impossible. The guy will never, ever talk to you. I don't want
to air dirty laundry - I just want to build pools and renovate pools and clean pools and
fix pools. I have personally been down there no less than hve times. Steve has been
down there how many times? Ten times. If you want to get into it, then let's get into
it. I saw Jack, I just called Andy - my County Commissioner ... you know Andy,
right?
Terry Jerulle: Excuse me a second ... we not getting into it... you're providing
testimony to ...
Richard Hudec: I'm a contractor...
Terry Jerulle: Now calm down and provide it. We have nothing to do with it...
[Mr. Hudec was visibly upset.]
Richard Hudec: All Jon had to do was call us ... there's a thing ...
Terry Jerulle: Calm down.
Richard Hudec: ... person called a gentleman .... be a gentleman - call us and say,
'all you need is this letter.' Do you guys really think ... we've built thousands of
pools. Some ofyou guys sitting here are sophisticated guys ... do you really believe
that we would be here over a letter from an Engineer that I could have had in twenty
minutes? Here's the homeowner, Todd Jacobs. How many times have I ever not
called you back, Todd?
Terry Jerulle: We can't take testimony ...
Richard Hudec: Here's the homeowner - we've talked to him several times and
he's a contractor. His family has been in this town for fifty years. We've never not
complied with one thing. I just had a situation with Jon Walsh - a family was moving
into their home last Friday - weren't they, Jon? They needed a temporary C ofO to
move into their house and you said you were too busy to do it. So, I got Dick to do it
and he did it in five seconds because you didn't want to come out ofyour office.
Terry Jerulle: That has nothing to do with this case.
Chairman Boyd: Enough, it has nothing to do with this case.
Richard Hudec: Do you want me to file a formal complaint with the County
Commissioner when I leave here?
Terry Jerulle: That is separate and not testimony for this case.
Richard Hudec: That is my testimony. You guys should know as the Board how
things are being handled in your County.
Chairman Boyd: Most of us are contractors.
Richard Hudec: Well - so you know. If you apply for a permit, it should be
handled professionally.
Richard Joslin: I'm a pool contractor, sir.
Richard Hudec: Iknow who you are.
33
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 38 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292 :
December 19. 2018
Richard Joslin: Thirty-five years - right here - there's never been a time when you
should not know and check your permits to see if they have been issued - that's
number one.
Richard Hudec: I know but when you make a mistake - no, we made a mistake
Richard Joslin: You can't wait for Jon to come and tell you ...
Richard Hudec: ... and then we tried to fix it, but we couldn't get it fixed after the
fact. I admit to the mistake. I'm not blaming Jon for the mistake - we made the
mistake without question. But we could not get it fixed. I went down there five
times. I talked to the plumbing guy. I said. 'okay - what exactly do you want?' I
could never get a straight answer. Then it was the barrier and we got the barrier
waived. Jon was kind enough to waive that. But I'm telling you - whatever you
want us to do. we'll do it. Jack drove the packet to my office the other day. We don't
duck anybody - we're not hiding from anybody. I spend 520,000.00 a month in
advertising. We don't hide from anybody. But if we need to fix it, we'll fix it.
Richard Joslin: We're not trying to tell you how to run your business or how you do
run your business - we're only saying that the permit was not issued. Numberone-
that's the priority. And as many pools as you've told us that you've built - and I'm
not doubting that you have - they all had the same inspection cards - they all had the
same things that are necessary for inspection - rhat's what you missed. Those
inspections were not done.
Richard Hudec: I understand that ...
Richard Joslin: You go after-the-fact and try to get them done. There is a way.
You find a way to get them done. If you would have stopped as the "Stop Work"
Order said, you could have followed through, went back in there and asked, 'how do I
get this done ... what does my Engineer need?' It's not up to him to call you. He
gave you the scenario of why you needed it - you guys should have planned to get it
done. And you did not.
Richard Hudec: But that's not true - it's not true.
Richard Joslin: It is, sir, otherwise you would have done it.
Steven Bowles: [He was not standing close enough to the microphone for his
comments to be fully recorded.l ... what you see here looks deceiving. If that was
really all it was - we wouldn't be here - we would have done that. If you look at that,
you will see that something is not right. You mean to tell me, guys, y,all spent
thousands ofdollars and y'all went through all of this and then youjust stopped at
that last letter? It don't add up.
Terry Jerulle: Excuse me, sir. The only thing that we can think is what you present.
What you are presenting ....
Assistant County Attorney Noell: Sir, sir, sir- if you can not speak over the Board
members as they are addressing you. And if you can wait until the Board addresses
you with a question so we can have proper decorum, okay? Thank you.
Terry Jerulle: The only thing that I have in front of me is the rast letter from the
County stating what you needed to do to complete the permit application. I have
nothing else from you. If I had documentation from you or a letier from you, it courd
help you with your case. But I don't have anlthing.
Richard Hudec: I'll find some stuff - I didn,t look ... we didn,t think it was going
to be a big deal ... all we need to do is get the letrer from the Engineer and ifJJn "
3.1
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 39 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292 :
December 19,2018
says, 'good luck with that' ... like you said, it's not hard to do.
Terry Jerulle: Certain parts of it aren't hard, I understand the pressure ...
(Mr. Hudec and Mr. Jerulle are talking at the same time - difficult to separate
the comments.)
Assistant County Attorney Noell: Sir, sir, sir- please, the same instruction for you
as a witness. When you testify before this Board, you cannot speak over the Board
member as he is addressing you. Wait until he is finished talking and if you have a
comment or if he asks a question and you want to respond, then you may do so at that
time. We're making a record of this proceeding and for it to be clear, we can't speak
over each other. Okay?
Richard Hudec: Okay.
Assistant County Attorney Noell: Thank you.
Terry Jerulle: What I believe Mr. Nolton was referring to is the steel in the bottom
and I think there's still the pressure test that must be done - from my understanding.
Richard Hudec: That's easy enough.
Stephen Bowles: (He was too far from the microphone - his comments were not
recorded in full.) .... it should be cut and dry ... (his remaining comments were not
captured.)
Terry Jerulle: From our point of view, sir, we have the history that you've agreed to
- that you made a mistake. You needed to get a permit to remove the "Stop Work"
Order which you didn't get. Work proceeded - which was another mistake. That's
two mistakes. All we have is a letter saying what you must do to get the permit. I
have no documentation that you have done anything after that. As I said earlier, it
appears that you gave up. I'm not saying that you did or didn't - I'm just saying trom
the information that was presented to us in this case, it appears that you had given up.
It is incumbent upon you to provide testimony or evidence that you didn't.
Stephen Bowles: (He was too far from the microphone - his comments were not
recorded in futl.) ... you guys are absolutely right ... you guys are seeing what you're
seeing ... I gave up, kinda/sorta because ... ['m not going to go there ... but anylvay,
we're all on the record - no matter how this winds up today - we're all on the record
stating ...
Terry Jerulle: That record has been there for a while ... ifyou understand what I'm
saying.
Stephen Bowles: (He was too far from the microphone - his comments were not
recorded in full.) ... I don't want to do that ... I don't know if he accepts everything.
Chairman Boyd: Gentlemen, are you done presenting your case.
Jonathan Walsh: That's all the County has.
Chairman Boyd: May I have a motion to close the Public Hearing?
Richard Joslin moved, to approve closing the Public Hearing for Case #2018-10.
Matthew Nolton offered a Second in support of the motion.
Carried unanimously, 6 - 0.
Vice Chairman Lantz: (dtected to the Respondent and the witness) Please
have a seat. You can't leave but you can sit.
35
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 40 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292
December 19,2018
Chairman Boyd: I guess we can start our deliberation on whether or not he's guilty.
Case #2018-10: Stephen L. Bowles, Jackson Pool Service.
Matthew Nolton: Well, for me, personally, it's fairly simple if he's guilty or not.
Yes, he did work without a permit and continued to do work without a permit. A
permit still has not yet been issued. I don't know why we have to deliberate.
Terry Jerulle: The first stage is finding whether he is guilty or not guilty.
Vice Chairman Kyle Lantz moved lo approve finding the Respondent, Stephen
L. Bowles, guilty of the violation of County Ordinance 2006-46, as amended,
Section 4.2.2, "Misconduct of a Slale-Certified Contractor," as slated in the
Administrative Complaint for "Wilfulb violating the applicable Building Codes
or laws of the state, city, or Collier Counly." Matthew Nolton offered a Second
in support of the motion.
Chairman Boyd asked if any discussion was needed. With no response from the
Board, he called for a vote on the motion.
Caried unanimously, 6 - 0.
Chairman Boyd deferred to the Board's Attorney.
Attorney Schneck: For the penalty phase for a State-certified contractor, as in the
Bumpus case, the Board is limited to denying, suspending, or revoking his permit-
pulling privileges in Collier County or limiting his ability to pull permits under
specific conditions. The second part ofthe penalty phase is the recommendation that
the Board can sent to the Saate's Construction Industry Licensing Board ("CILB") for
further action. When considering these penalties, the Board should also consider the
testimony and all the evidence presented, as well as:
o The gravity of the violationl
. The impact ofthe violation on the public health/safety/welfare;
. Any actions taken by the violator to correct the violations;
o Any previous violations committed by the violator; and
o Any other evidence presented at the Hearing relevant to the Sanctions which are
appropriate to the case, given the nature of the violation.
Terry Jerulle: Mr. Bowles, do you want to complete the permit application?
Stephen Bowles: Yes, sir.
Terry Jerulle: And if you complete the permit application, do you think you can
comply with the terms written on the permit?
Stephen Bowles: Yes, sir.
Terry Jerulle: How long do you think it will take you to complete it?
Stephen Bowles: Thirty days - by the end ofJanuary.
Terry Jerulle: Thirty days and by the end ofJanuary are two different time frames
I do know that Christmas is coming. I'm asking you.
Stephen Bowles: By January 3l't.
Terry Jerulle: Thank you.
Stephen Bowles: And I want to comply - I don't want this hanging - I like
36
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 41 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292
December I9,2018
my license to be clean. There's a stain on it and I want to clean it up.
Matthew Nolton: Mr. Bowles, I assume you are still active in business. Do you
have active permits for pools that you are currently building or renovating?
Stephen Bowles: Yes, sir.
Vice Chairman Lantz: How many permits would you say you have out there? I
don't need an exact number - 5 - 10 -100?
Stephen Bowles: Probably ten ... eight to ten.
Terry Jerulle: And in the future - in any grey areas, you are going to do what?
Stephen Bowles: I will take my paperwork to the Building Department and ask to
talk about it because ['ve never been through this and I don't want to go through this
again. Hindsight is 20i20 - these are self-inflicted wounds. But I comply - I'm a guy
who, like I told you, I have a passion for my industry and that's what it's about... to
comply.
Terry Jerulle: Thank you, sir.
Vice Chairman Lantz: Personally, when I break down the five criteria: First, the
gravity of the situation - the gravity of the situation is it didn't fall apart -- it's an
issue but not a huge one, so I'd put that on the low side. The impact of it- he didn't
get a permit and should not have continued with the pool, but he did. Theoretically, I
don't think any public health/safety/welfare was in danger. so I'd put that very low.
Actions taken after - actions that were taken -- l'd put that about as high as you can
get as far as what he did wrong. He just gave up. He had plenty of opportunities to
make it right and he didn't- he continued working on the pool before the permit was
issued. I'd say that's very high. As far as previous violations, he doesn't have any so
that's very low. And other evidence ... there's no change. So, overall, on a scale of
onetoten: Gravity - I or2; Impact - 1or2; Actions - l0or 12 if Icouldgothat
high; Previous violations - 0; and Evidence - 0. Averaging it out on a scale of 1 to
10, it's a 2 or 3 ... maybe. We've definitely seen a lot worse going on - it's the fact
that it happened. I don't think it's a super-bad crime but it's something that needs to
be resolved.
Richard Joslin: I disagree with you as far as the public healthisafety/welfare goes
only because the spa was built up without any bottom steel and without an inspection.
It's one ofthe first inspections that's done because ofthe electrical factor. How it's
going to be resolved is if there was steel tied to the top beam that he poured and if it
was grounded. It will be a challenge to an Engineer to find out and get it done.
That's an imponant factor and inspection.
Terry Jerulle: Does the County have an opinion?
Everildo Ybaceta: The County will defer to the Board's decision.
Matthew Nolton: He will have to re-apply for the permit and there's the opportunity
to pay penalty of "x" times the permit fee in that process?
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes. The cost is four times the original permit fee because the
permit wasn't issued, because it is an active case, and because the contractor of record
was involved. It is to be done from issuance through completion.
Vice Chairman Lantz: I have a question for Jonathan Walsh. Mr. Bowles said he
could have everything done by January 3 I't. My definition of "done" is a final
permit. Knowing the workload of the County and what need to be done between
31
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 42 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292
December 19, 2018
now and getting finished product - in your opinion, what is the latest date to get
the Engineer's letter to you?
Jonathan Walsh: We're starting from scratch. He must apply for a new permit.
Vice Chairman Lantz: So, if he comes in with a new permit application and the
new letter on January l5d, is it possible the permit could be issued by January 3 I "
or no?
Jonathan Walsh: Not knowing the current load of the Planning Reviews, we could
probably facilitate a quicker turn-around. Ifyou're looking for a date, I would
probably say five to ten days, give or take.
Vice Chairman Lantz: Business days?
Jonathan Walsh: Yes. We're currently 30 to 45 days for permit reviews. We could
probably facilitate turning this one around a little bit quicker. Ifthe letter that's in
lieu of County inspections is acceptable, then the only requirement would be three
inspections - final plumbing, final electric, and final pool.
Vice Chairman Lantz: Those inspections could be done in a day.
Jonathan Walsh: Theoretically, they could be done in one day once the permit is
issued.
Vice Chairman Lantz: Realistically, Mr. Bowles needs a good letter fiom an
Engineer as well as a new permit application package. Are you still saying you can
be done by January 31't -- because it's notjust getting the letter - it's getting the
whole process done.
Stephen Bowles: The permitting process might throw it back a linle bit - maybe
February l5s? I don't want to say something and then we're still ...
Vice Chairman Lantz: That's exactly the point. I want to make sure you
understand its notjust obtaining a letter from an Engineer - there's more ...
Stephen Bowles: Yeah, we've got to get - start over, basically, and push everlthing
through.
Matthew Nolton: Mr. Walsh, I'm a little confused. Would this be a permit by
affidavit process or would this be that he is to submit plans and submit Engineer's
letters for the missed inspections?
Jonathan Walsh: We treated the rough on this permit knowing the history of it and
we will try to facilitate turning the permit around by getting the Engineer's letters in
case there are any concerns, they can be fixed before it is finished. But his permit
will still be considered a partial after-the-fact. For the inspections that I cannot
perform, they must be done by an Engineer with supporting documentation and the
Engineer must document how he came to his conclusions.
Matthew Nolton: The packet would be the full site plan with the elevation ...
Jonathan Walsh: All the piping requirements, all the reinforcing steel ...
Matthew Nolton: ... all the bond connections - you'd have a[[ that and the equipment
... it would have all that, just as ifyou were going to start this job from scratch.
You'd need to get a permit and a packet with all the documents which I am sure you
are aware ofsince you do this all the time. You would need that plus the Engineer's
letters to cover the inspections that were missed.
Stephen Bowles: Yes, sir. I don't know if January 3 I st might be pushing it. I know
I can get the letters but, like he said, I don't really know about the plumbing review ...
38
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 43 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292
December 19, 2018
Jonathan Walsh: Our plumbing plan reviewer is ... if we're informed that the permit
is in ... we wiII do our best to facilitate a quicker turn-around, but I don't want to ...
Matthew Nolton: I understand... with the holidays and with ... it's not as simple as
you think with the Engineer's letters. I happen to know that firm was sold, so
whoever was involved is even there. I think you will probably need two months -
sixty days - to get this done.
Stephen Bowles: That sounds more reasonable. But it will get done. And I have
started over before - first it was the barrier, and the pool has been there since 1982. I
just want to submit everything so it goes through without something that I have no
control over.
Matthew Nolton: I understand. Thank you. Back to our deliberations.
Vice Chairman Lantz: What I'm proposing - I'm ready to make a motion but I
want to hear how everyone feels - we give him until the February meeting ...
provided that the permit is final before then, we will take no more action. However,
if the permit is not final by then, we will cancel his permit-pulling privileges until it
is final. It's giving you a lot of leeway but if you fail, there will be a lot of
repercussions.
Stephen Bowles: I understand. yes. sir.
Chairman Boyd: In essence, you are going to continue it until the February
meeting?
Vice Chairman Lantz: No.
Matthew Nolton: No - I would like the motion to be right now - we're in the
penalty, so we're recommending to the County that they pull his - the company's
permit pulling privileges and inspection privileges at that point in time unless the
permit has been closed out properly.
Vice Chairman Lantz: If he closes it out by the February meeting, he will go on his
way. If he doesn't, he will have a world of problems for his business.
Matthew Nolton: And this way, he would not have to come back before the Board.
Yice Chairman Lantz: Does anybody have any - does this sound reasonable?
Terry Jerulle: Mr. Bowles?
Stephen Bowles: It sounds reasonable.
Terry Jerulle: And that may - I think the homeowner is here - you may have to ...
in the worst-case scenario, you may have to drain the pool and chip the bonding on
the spa to get verification. I don'tknow- I'm not apool contractor.
Stephen Bowles: Verification of the bonding?
Richard Joslin: One of the engineers may have an ex-ray machine.
Matthew Nolton: It won't show the bonding. There will have to be continuity
testing. And you're going to need to be able to contact the steel in two places - the
original beam on the pool and on the spa- you have to do conrinuiry testing.
Stephen Bowles: Was the original beam on the pool in 1982? [t didn'r require that.
Matthew Nolton: Code may not have required it but, to build the spa, you would
have had to connect to that steel. And you would have had to ground it, so ...
Stephen Bowles: I bonded the whole pool and I bonded the spa, so whether it shows
up on radar ... but that's the most important thing that you can do. Forget everything
else - bond that baby.
Richard Joslin: Lots of things happen it you don'r.
39
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 44 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292
December 19. 2018
Stephen Bowles: Bond that baby - your handrails, your lights ... so, the pool is
bonded and grounded. How we're going to get to making sure they know that ... like
you said ...
Terry Jerulle: As I said, think worst-case scenario in that sixty-day time frame.
Stephen Bowles: Yes, sir.
Terry Jerulle: And you can do that in the worst-case scenario.
Stephen Bowles: I think so - I think so.
Richard Joslin: Weren't permit pulling privileges part of the motion?
Vice Chairman Lantz: Well, I didn't make the motion yet... but my suggestion is
permit pulling privileges are good now but if he fails to meet the deadline, they're
gone.
Richard Joslin: Okay.
Terry Jerulle: Any recommendation to the state?
Vice Chairman Lantz: No.
Terry Jerulle: If he doesn't complete this pool, he will not have any permit pulling
privileges. So, what happens with the state?
Vice Chairman Lantz: Then there's a recommendation to the state.
Vice Chairman Kyle ltntz moved to approve granting a period of srl/y days to
Stephen Bowles to final out the permit duing which time the permit is to be
issued in final status and the job completed with a C of O. If the sixty-day
deadline is missed, his permit pulling privileges and inspection pulling privileges
in Collier County will be immediately cancelled except for this specific permit,
and the County will be aulhorized lo send a letter to the State's Conslruction
Industry Licensing Board ('CILB") recommending imposition of the maximum
penalties. Richard Joslin offered a Second in support of the motion.
Assistant County Attorney Noell: The Board's February meeting is scheduled for
February 20ft which is four days later than your deadline. If the Board is considering
taking away the Respondent's permit and inspection pulling privileges, I would be
more comfortable if the deadline was February 20th. If it is complied with and closed
out, the matter is done. If not, then he is to come before the Board.
Vice Chairman Lantz: That is against my motion. And the reason is that I don't
want to have another Jeffrey Bumpus here every month. 'Here's the line and we're
not crossing it.'
Assistant County Attorney Noell: I understand. From my perspective with possible
due process considerations, etc., my fear is if the Board makes - and whatever the
Board does, respectfully, the Board does, and I understand that, but I am telling you
the County's position. Ifthe Board makes his suspension pending on a future event
and that automatically happens, the Respondent will have the ability to appeal that in
Circuit Court, I don't necessarily want to go through all those hoops when we,re
talking aboutjust four days. Ifhe's not in compliance and it,s the automatic
suspension, he would have the right to be heard before that is finally taken - if that
makes sense.
Terry Jerulle: It does to me now. Ifthere,s a flood in the County and nobody can
pull permits for two weeks, that puts him injeopardy.
40
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 45 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292 :
December 19, 2018
Vice Chairman l-antz agreed to amend his motion to extend the deadline to
February 2Oh and Richard Joslin agreed to amend his Second.
Chairman Boyd called Jor a vote on the amended motion.
Carried unanimously, 6 - 0.
Terry Jerulle: And just for my record - I know you guys were upset but Jonathan
Walsh didn't create the problem. In my experience with Jonathan Walsh, he helps
solve problems. But he is extremely busy with thousands and tens of thousands of
permits and inspections, and even I can't get ahold of him ... a lot ofpeople ... it's not
just you, singularly, that can't get an answer from him - nobody can
Chairman Boyd stated:
o This cause came for a Public Hearing before the Contractors' Licensing Board
on December 19, 2018 for consideration of the Administrative Complaint
filed against Stephen L. Bowles, d./b/a "/cckson Pool Service.
. Service of the complaint was made by certified mail, personal delivery, or
publication in accordance with Collier County Ordinance lE0-105, as
amended.o The Board having heard testimony under oath, received evidence, and heard
arguments respecrive to all pertinent matters hereupon issues its Findings of
Facts, Conclusions of Law and Order of the Board as follows:
Conclusions of Law, Findings of Fact, and Orders of the Board:
. Stephen L. Bowles, dlbla Jacl<son Pool Service, is the holder of record of a
Collier County Certificate of Competency, License Number
LCC20120001055.
o Mr. Bowles is also a State-certified PooVSpa Contractor and holder of License
Number CPC1456458.
e The Coliier County Board of County Commissioners is the Petitioner in this
matter and Stephen L. Bowles is the Respondent.
. Mr. Bowles was present at the December 19, 2018 Public Hearing and was
not represented by counsel.
o All notices required by Collier County Ordinance #90- 105, as amended, have
been properly issued or personally delivered.. The Respondent acted in a matter that is in violation of Collier County
Ordinance and is the one who committed the act.o The allegation set forth in the Administrative Complaint as to Collier County
Ordinance #2006-46, as amended, Section 4.2.2 - Misconduct of State
Certified Contractor states: "Wilfu y violating the applicable Building Codes
or law of the State, City, ot Collier County. "
o The allegation was supported by the evidence presented at the Hearing.
Conclusions of Law:
o The allegations set forth in the Administrative Complaint as to Count One is
approved, adopted, and incorporated herein, to wit:
4I
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 46 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292
o
December l9- 2018
The Respondent violated Ordinance #2006-46, as amended, Section 4.2.2
in Count One in the performance ofhis contracting business in Collier
County by acting in violation of the Section set out in the Administrative
Complaint with particularity.
Orders of the Board:
o Based upon the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions ofLaw, and
pursuant to the authority ganted in Florida Statutes, Chapter 49, and Collier
County Ordinance #90-105, as amended, by a vote of six (6) in favor and zero
(0) opposed, a majority vote ofthe Board members present, the related
Sanctions and following Order are hereby imposed upon the holder of
Certificate of Competency #LCC20120001055:
o The deadline for the Respondent, Stephen L. Bowles, to final out the
permit is February 20,2019, during which time, the permit is to be
issued in final status and the job completed with a C of O.
o If the deadline is missed, the Respondent's permit pulling and
inspection pulling privileges in Collier County will be automatically
cancelled except for this specific permit.
o Ifthe deadline is missed, the County will be authorized to send a letter
to the State's Construction Industry Licensing Board ("CILB")
recommending position of the maximum penalties.
Chairman Boyd: The hearing is concluded
Matthew Nolton: The case that we didn't hear [Melvin Alfaro, d.hla"Oasis Builders of
SWFZ" - Contesting Citationl- can we do something and not have that guy come back?
Everildo Ybaceta: He's not coming back. His time has been allotted.
Matthew Nolton: So, we don't need to take action on it? One question to Mr. Schneck
... is the Citation being tabled or ...?
Everildo Ybaceta: No, he had ten days to contest the Citation. He requested a Hearing
to contest the Citation and he didn't show for the hearing.
Matthew Nolton: So, he can't contest it.
Attorney Jeb Schneck: I would recommend that the Board hold a hearing, have the
Contractors' Licensing Compliance Officer enter documentary evidence into the record
as well as a brief summary of the case just to establish a substantial evidentiary standard.
Everildo Ybaceta: The Ofhcer is no longer here but I can make a brief statement if you
wish.
Attorney Jeb Schneck: It's an Administrative Hearing process, in the sense that you
have witnesses and take testimony, deliberate and make a finding.
Everildo Ybaceta: We don't - well, no.
Attorney Jeb Schneck: The process for contesting a Citation is: the alleged violator
receives a Citation and has ten days to notify the County in writing that heishe wants to
contest the Citation at hearing before this Board. He has nodrled the county and there is
correspondence verifying the date of the hearing. That takes care of the notification
42
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 47 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292 :
February 20, 2019
MINUTES
OF THE COLLIER COUNTY
CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARI)
February 20,2019
Naples, Florida
LET IT BE REMEMBERED that the Collier County Contractors' Licensing
Board, having conducted business herein, met on this date at 9:00 AM in
REGUI-LR SESS/ON in Administrative Building "F," 3'd Floor, Collier County
Govemment Complex, Naples, Florida, with the following Members present:
Chairman:
Vice Chair:
Kyle E. Lantz
Matthew Nolton
Members:Terry Jerulle
Richard Joslin
Patrick White
Excused'.Michael E. Boyd
Robert Meister
ALSO PRESENT:
Everildo Ybaceta - Supervisor, Contractors' Licensing Office
Kevin Noell, Esq. - Assistant Collier County Attomey
Jed Schneck, Esq. - Attorney for the Contractors' Licensing Board
Lilla Davis - Administrative Supervisor, Contractors' Licensing Office
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 48 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292
February 20,2019
Chairman Lantz: To make a factual finding ... is that a motion that we make?
Patrick White: It is based on the testimony of Staff - have they been swom?
Chairman Lantzz Evy, have you been swom in?
Everildo Ybaceta: Me?
Chairman Lantz: Yes.
Everildo Ybaceta: No.
[Mr. Ybaceta was swom in by the Attorney for the Board.]
Chairman Lantz: Well now that you're under oath ...
Patrick White: Is what you said before, still true?
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes, sir.
Patrick White: Good.
Chairman Lantz: So, you are testifying, on behalf of the County, that Mr. Bumpus
has not closed out all of his permits.
Everildo Ybaceta: I am. sir.
Chairman Lantz: Is that enough? How about anybody else? Any other questions?
[There were none.] Does anyone want to make a motion?
Chairman Lantz asked if there was any discussion. [There was none.]
Chairman l-ant7 called for d vote on the motion. Carried unanimously, 5 - 0.
Chairman Lantz: This case is officially done with us as far as we know it - correct?
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes, st.
Chairman Lantz: Yes. Perfect.
Richard Joslin: Do you want to read the penalty?
Patrick White: No.
Chairman Lantzt I think we already did that - last month or two months ago.
Attorney Schneck: That's conect. The Board formalized the recommended penalty
last month and now County Staff will send the recommendation to the State.
A. Case #2018- l0:Update - Stephen Bowles (d,/b/a "lackson Pools,')
Misconduct of a State-Certified Contractor
Chairman Lantz called Stephen Bowles to the podium and was swom.
chairman Lantz: The same rules apply from the public Hearing that we held two
months ago. He asked the County to begin.
Jack Gumph, Contractor Licensing Compliance Officer was also swom.
t2
Patrick White moved to approve ftnding that leffrey Bumpus has not complied with
the Order of this Board and a Finding of Fact to that effect. Richard Joslin offered
a Second in support of the motion.
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 49 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292 :
February 20,2019
Everildo Ybaceta: Mr. Schneck, Mr. Noell has some information to provide... if
you would like to swear him in.
Assistant County Attorney Kevin Noell: I don't think I need to be swom - I'm not
going to provide testimony to the Board ... only a recommendation. I talked with the
party ... with Jackson Pools and their representatives ... there were some hiccups with
the permitting. If the Board will recall - last time that Jackson Pools was before the
Board, the Order was to get a permit, and to have it closed out by today. I talked with
both the representatives for Jackson Pools and with Staff. There have been some
hiccups with the permit process. It is now all set and ready to be issued - or has been
issued - and we would ask that it be rolled over for another thirty days to ailow them
to close out the permit and this will probably be an issue that I will walk through with
Evy to make sure that we have a resolution within thirty days. But they have taken
significant steps, including driving to Sarasota to get some engineering records and
things of that nature, so they are putting forth a significant effort. I think that our
recommendation - issued from the Staff side - and I think from Evy as well - would
be to roll it for thirty days to ...
Patrick White: You would like the Board to table it for thiny days or do you want to
withdraw it and bring it back in thirty days? I'm not clear.
Assistant County Attorney Noell: I would ask the Board to table it for thirty days
just because the Board had made the previous motion that was agreed upon to bring it
back today for completion. I would just ask that it gets tabled until the next meeting.
Richard Joslin: What was the "hiccup" with the permit?
Assistant County Attorney Noell: There were several different issues that would
probably involve a lot of different testimony and things of that nature, so it would
probably ... my recommendation would be ... if the Board wants to go through that
process, we could. But my recommendation, however, would be just to give it an
additional thirty days and we will, hopefully, have it all wrapped up.
Chairman Lantz: Well, let me ask you this - let's just say we decide to give another
thirty days, if he finals out the permit tomorrow - then we won't see him ever again
... correct?
Assistant County Attorney Noell: Correct. If that's the Board's ...
Terry Jerulle: Mr. Bowles, can you convince us?
Stephen Bowles: Yes, sir. Well, it's been a rigorous ...
Terry Jerulle: In the same fashion ... can you ...
Stephen Bowles: It's been a ...
Terry Jerulle: I don't care about the process ... looking forward ...
Stephen Bowles: We're right there ... we're
Terry Jerulle: Let me finish ... let me finish ...
Stephen Bowles: Oh, okay.
Terry Jerulle: ... please. Looking forward ...
Stephen Bowles: I thought you were asking a question.
Terry Jerulle: I am. Looking forward, can you convince us that what Mr. Noell is
saying will happen in the next thirty days?
Stephen Bowles: Absolutely, sir. We're right there - the permits issued ... all the
paperwork is in ... they are srill probably finishing up on their side. There,s one
inspection to come out and do and, like I said, we're right there. And we,re been
l3
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 50 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292
February 20, 2019
we're getting it done. There's been some paperwork that they thought they had, and
we thought they had... and both parties found and ... so, we're right there ... within
the next ...
Terry Jerulle: Materials ... manpower ... everything is set to ...
Stephen Bowles: Yes, sir.
Terry Jerulle: ... to be done within the next thirty days?
Stephen Bowles: More than likely, within the next week probably ...
Terry Jerulle: And you're very clear about the inspections that you need to call in
and to pass?
Stephen Bowles: Absolutely.
Richard Joslin: Did I see in the packet where there are still three inspections to be
called in yet for final?
Stephen Bowles: Well, we're still working that... I don't know exactly which three
is up to date now because we had some. I would maybe ask Mr. Ybaceta. I know we
had the hnal is what I was under... assumption that it was down to the final
inspection.
Richard Joslin: I believe a couple of the inspections would be necessary before the
f,rnal is given on the permit... or maybe I'm wrong?
Jack Gumph: Mr. Chairman, I would like to defer to Jonathan Walsh, the Collier
County Chief Building Official, for any questions as to the permit.
Chairman Lantz: Okay.
Jonathan Walsh, Chief Building Official for Collier County, was swom in.
Richard Joslin: Mr. Walsh, I'm looking at one of the pages and it says that - from
what I can see - there are four inspections that are still pending. It's showing the pool
bonding, the pool final, the pool shell reinforcement, and verify the permit is ready to
issue. I assume that one has been done.
Jon Walsh: The permit has been picked up. Unfortunately, there seems to have
been an issue with the payment, so the permit was placed on an inspection hold. I
don't know the finance element of it ... all I know is ... there are two inspection holds
- one is for the Notice of Commencement that has not been recorded yet and they'll
still need to get that done. But that may have been recorded but it just has not been
provided to us and that condition resolved. That's a minor element. The other
element is to follow-up with cashiering to resolve whatever the payment issue was - I
don't know ... I'm not a banker. There was something wrong at cashiering when the
payment was made ... it says "reversal" on it. I'm not exactly sure what that means.
As far as I am aware, the funds were not available. It could have been an error in the
transmitting... it could have been abunchof different things... Ihavenoidea. There
are three inspections that I am aware of: the shell, bonding, and final.
Richard Joslin: And rhese are the things that he was telling us woutd be done within
a week or...?
Stephen Bowles: Yes. I have all the proper paperwork for all those and I think ... we
just found out this moming that everything was on hold because of the $100. Idon't
know. We picked up the permit and then, come to find out, there was one hundred
dollars that needed to be paid after-the-fact then everything got put on hold. For one
1.1
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 51 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292 :
February 20, 2019
hundred dollars? I mean .... (gesturing with his hands in the air) ... I didn't realize
that until this moming and it's one hundred dollars that's holding us up ... like I said,
we're so close.
Chairman Lantz: But you've got it?
Stephen Bowles: We've got it, yes, sir. We've got all the information.
Chairman Lantz: Are the inspections that are left to be done, are they being done
by the County or a private provider?
Stephen Bowles: When they have the proper engineering information ... private
providers.
Jon Walsh: It's not technically done by a private provider. In this instance, they
have hired a licensed Engineer to perform the inspections that we cannot without
some destructive work being done.
Chairman Lantz: They will send you a report and then you - or somebody on your
staff - will then verify...?
Jon Walsh: A letter was provided by email to me yesterday by the Engineer at 4: l7
PM. Unfortunately, it is not completely compliant, and it is in review. I was having
conversations with him as early as 8:00 this moming.
Chairman Lantz: The ball is rolling?
Jon Walsh: Yep.
Vice Chairman Nolton: kt me ask a little more in-depth. I hear that there .ue some
questions about it. Mr. Bowles, that's not satisfactory for those two inspections -
because we're talking about two, and then you have the final. Are you saying to the
Board that you're willing to do whatever it takes to make those two inspections
satisfactory?
Stephen Bowles: Yeah, I mean ... whatever is requted.
Vice Chairman Nolton: Even if it includes some further inspection and testing ...
Stephen Bowles: Well, I don't know ...
Vice Chairman Nolton: ... ... to satisfy that?
Stephen Bowles: ... I don't know what in depth that he's going to really need other
than ... like he said, he was talking with him as early as this moming. I don't know if
he's going to get all the information. Ifhe's not, I think there's pictures that has
surfaced that might help ... because it's been two years and I've been through a lot of
phones and I-Clouds so ... I don't know the exact pictures yet.
Vice Chairman Nolton: That's not my question - right? Let's say that there isn't
the data... let's say that there's not the pictures. I'm asking the question ... ifthere's
not, are you - in thirty days - going to do whatever it takes to pass those inspections?
Stephen Bowles: Absolutely.
Chairman Lantz: Even if it entails some demolition work ... some whatever ...?
Stephen Bowles: Well ... L.. I don't know that ...
Patrick White: Which is it, sir? Are you absolutely going to do it, or are you nor?
Stephen Bowles: I'm going to do, I guess, whatever Jon Walsh and the Building
Department requires me to do.
Patrick White: That's a good answer.
Stephen Bowles: That's what I'll ... yes, sir.
Chairman Lantz: All right. Any other questions from the Board?
l5
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 52 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292
February 20, 2019
Attorney Schneck: If I may ... just as a recommendation ... after going though the
Bumpus case, to leave it cleaner in this situation - as we're extending it, adding
additional time - I would request that the Board amend its Order of December 19,
2018 to change the compiiance date. That way we'1l have a new Order, and
everything is fresh. So, if there's any appeal issue ... everything is new and proper.
It's something that we've leamed going through the Bumpus case - to move things up
as these cases go on.
Chairman Lantz: So, I guess the motion will be ... instead of saying, 'we give you
thirty days' ... the motion will be to amend the previous Order to ...?
Attorney Schneck: Correct. And I would state March 20, 2019 which is the next
meeting date as the new compliance date.
Patrick White: And would it also be possible to amend it in a fashion that if the
permit is closed out, that the case is closed?
Attorney Schneck: Conect. And I would authorize Staff to make that determination
if the Respondent has proven that the permit has been properly closed out, then Staff
can close out this case. If not, they can bring it back before the Board.
Patrick White: Are you comfortable writing that Order and providing it by way of a
motion that I'm prepared to make based on what you have suggested?
Attorney Schneck: I am.
Patrick White: Thank you. So moved, While.
Richard Joslin: One last comment. Mr. Walsh, are you comfortable with the
engineering that has been provided to you so far regarding these last two major
inspections?
Jon Walsh: At this moment in time, the only one that I am questioning is the
bonding.
Richard Joslin: Okay.
Jon Walsh: Sufficient information has been provided for the steel reinforcing, but I
am questioning the bonding.
Richard Joslin: Okay.
Yice Chairman Nolton: Second, Nolton.
Chairman Lantz stated there was a motion and a second. He asked the members if
they had any other questions, comments or discussion.
Richard Joslin: This motion is to ...?
Chairman Lantz: The motion is to amend the Board's previous motion to change
the date of compliance to March 20, 2019. When the permit is final, then Staff may
administratively close the case.
Chairman Lantz calledfor a vote on the motion, Carried unanimously, 5 - 0.
X. PUBLIC Hr.q.nlNc:
(None)
t6
Stephen Bowles: Thank you.
Terry Jerulle: The clock is ticking.
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 53 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292
GOLLIER GOUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY GOMMISSIONERS
CERTIFICATE OF COMPLETION
This Certificate is issued pursuant to the requirements of the Florida Building Code certifying that at the time of
issuance this structure was in compliance with the various ordinances of the county regulating building construction
or use. For the following:
PERMIT NBR PR8D2019020551701 CONBR: STATUS: Finaled
COMP ISSUED DATE: March 06,2019
5391 Tamarind Ridge DR, Naples
CO TYPE:
ADDRESS:
SUBDIVISION:
LOT:BLOCK T.R.S
SLUC CODE UTILITY COMPANY
JOB DESC: renovation ofexis ting pool and spa, including height ofspa shell with no change to pool or deck
footprint /pool barrier /na pool constructed in 1982
5321 Tamarind Ridge Dr.NUMBER OF METERS:
OWNER: JACOBS, TODD
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
GOLDEN GATE EST UNIT 32 W
l 80FT OF TR 33 0R 1685 PC 134
Note: A new certificate is required if the use of the building or premises is changed, or if alterations are made to
the building or properfy described. A new certificate voids any certificate or prior date.
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 54 Attachment: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8292
03/20/2019
COLLIER COUNTY
Contractor Licensing Board
Item Number: 10.A
Item Summary: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02
MISCONDUCT
Meeting Date: 03/20/2019
Prepared by:
Title: – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Lilla Davis
03/11/2019 4:12 PM
Submitted by:
Title: Supervisor - Operations – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Everildo Ybaceta
03/11/2019 4:12 PM
Approved By:
Review:
Contractor Licensing Board Lilla Davis Review Item Completed 03/11/2019 4:15 PM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Review Item Completed 03/11/2019 4:50 PM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Meeting Pending 03/20/2019 9:00 AM
10.A
Packet Pg. 55
Aftrcovtn ty
MARCH 20,2019
9:00 A.M.
ADMINISTRATIVE COMPLAINT - CASE 2019-02
PETER E. WOZNIAK_ MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR
PETER E. WOZNIAK is the License holder for his company FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES, LLC. There are 5
separate Code Cases against Mr. WOZNIAK:
Case #cEMts20190002317. EXPIRED PERMTTS (4) - PR8D20180533950 , PR8D20180104959,
PR8D20180105389, and PR8D20170936849
Case # CEM1S20180015337, Reves - Com plaint from the property owner was submitted on
12/1012018 regarding a deposit that was paid to the contractor, the work commenced before the permit
was issued, and the permit later expired. The rool is now leaking, as shown by photographs attached.
The permit (PR8D20180529401) was reactivated and inspected on 31712019.
Case # CEM|S201 80014738, Quiqley - Com plaint f rom the property owner was submitted on
1112812018 regarding roof work that started, but has not been completed since the last inspection on
811312018. The permit (PRBD2o180745475) expired and was later reactivated on 212012019.
Case # CEMlS201 80008081 R. Simon -Complaint f rom the property owner was submitted on
61612018 regarding money that was paid to the contractor and uncompleted roof work with the last
inspection being on 51312018. The permit (PR8020180422436) expired, was later reactivated on
212012019, and inspected on 31712019.
Case # CEM1S20190002603, V. Simon - Complaint from a site visit to address 5329 Mitchell St. by
Contractor Licensing Supervisor, Evy Ybaceta. This address has a permit application
(PRBD2O181266458) that was submitted on 1211012018, that currently sits in Rejected status. Roof
work has already commenced as shown by the pictures attached.
Mr. WOZNIAK is in violation of the Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as amended, Section 4.2.2, Misconduct
ol a State Certified Conlractor, which states "Willfully violating the applicable building codes or laws ol the
state, city or Collier County" f or having expired permits (FL Building Code 105.1 ), commencing work prior to
the issuance of a building permit (FL Building Code 1 05.1 ), taking a deposit of more than lOo/o and didn't apply
for the permit within the time limit (FL Statute 489.126(2)), and abandoning a project and failed to perform work
for ninety (90) consecutive days (2006-46, Section 4.1 .3). He is going in front of the board to hear possible
disciplinary actrons due to his violation(s).
COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 56 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Table of Contents
Administrative Complaint
FormalComplaint.
State of Florida, Department of Business & Professional ReBulation Licensee Detail
Collier County Contactor Licensing Section Registration Detail
State of Florida, Division of Corporations, Limited Liability Company Detail
Notice of Hearing sent via Certified Mail
Signed Return Receipt for accepted Certified Mail
Case Detail Reoort(s) for current Misconduct Violation (s).
Case f CEM1S20190002317, ExPIRED PERMITS (4)
EXPTRED P ERM tTs-P R 8D20180533950, PR8D20180104959, P R8D20180105389, and
PR 8D20170936849.
Case fl CEM1S20180015337, Reves
PERMIT APPLICATION fl PR8020180529401 (Reyes)
Contracts/Check copies
Emails
NOTICE OF NON COMPLIANCE- (Reyes)
Photographs (Reyes residence)
Case # CEM|520180014738, Quigley
PERMIT APPLICATION fl-PR8D20180745475 (Quigley)
Contracts/Check copies
Emails
NOTICE OF NON COM PLIANCE-(Quigley)
Case # CEM1S20180008081 R. Simon
PERMIT APPLICATION f PR8020180422436 (R. Simon)
Contracts/Check copies
Case fl CEM1S20190002603 V. Simon
Permit Application # PR8D20181266458 (V. Simon)
Corrections Letter
Photogra phs
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 57 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Collier County Ordinance 2005-46, as amended, Section 4.2.2., for MISCONDUCT- State Certified
Contractors and 4.1.3. for abandoning a construction project.
Florida Building Code (A) 105.1, "PERMlT5".
Florida Building Code (A) 105.3.2, "Time Limitations of Application".
Florida Building Code (A) 105.4, "Conditions of Permlt".
Florida State Statute, Chapter 489, Section 489.126(2) lall lor... - took more thon 70% oI the controct
price ond did not apply for the permit within the 30 doy limit
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 58 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
BEFORE THE COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS, LICENSING BOARD
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS,
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, CONTRACTORS,
LICENSING BOARD
Petitioner,
Case Number: 2Ol9 - 02
License Number: CCC1331225
WOZNIAK, PETER EDWARD
FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES tLC
Respondent
ADMINISTRATIVE COMPLAINT
Collier County (County) files the Administrative Complaint against Peter Edward Wozniak (Respondent), a
State of Florida, Certified Roofing Contractor (CCC1331226) registered in Collier County (license #
1CC20170002115), and states the following facts and allegations in support of the cited violations below:
1. The Respondent is currently licensed by the State of Florida as a Certified Roofing Contractor with
License number CCC1331225 and registered in Collier County with license 1CC20170002115.
2. U nder the provisions of Collier County Ordinan ce 2006-46, as amended, Section 4.2 M isconduct -
State Certified Contractors, the following actions by a holder of a State Certified Roofing Contractor
/ Collier County registered Contractor (s 1CC20170002115) shall constitute misconduct and
grounds for discipline pursuant to Section 4.3 (Disciplinary proceedings).
3, ltem #1 ExDired Permit{s) - Four I4) count Case f CEM1520190002317
4.2.2. - "Willfully violating the applicable building codes or laws of the state, city or Collier
County." - EXPIRED building permits (State Building Code violotion 105.1).
b Peter Wozniak has willfully allowed multiple building permits PRgD2018053j950,
PR8D20180104959, PR8D20180105389, ond PR8O20170936849)to become ExPIRED in
a.
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 59 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Collier County. As a result, Case f CEM 1520190002317 was opened. As per Collier County
Building Official, Jonathan Walsh, this contractor has committed willful code violations.
4. Collier County brings the below charges in this formal complaint against the Respondent. See
count 1.
5. ltem#2-f cEMrs2018001s337
a On December 10, 2018, Jack Gumph, Collier County Contractor License Officer received the
written complaint (Case # CEM 1S20180015337) through Contractor Licensing Office, Customer
Service from homeowner, Josephine & George Reyes,4484 Dunlin Ct., Naples, FL against the
roofing contractor. The contractor is listed as Florida Roof Services LLC with License
Holder/Qualifier listed as Peter Edward wozniak, State License # CCC7337226 (Certified Roofing
contractor). A contract was siened 3/25/2oL8 for 542,500.00 with deposit of S14,200.00.
b. Florida Roof Services LLC made application for permit on 5/l/2O18.
c,Florida Roof Services LLC commenced work on 5l9l2OLB (tear off & underlayment)
d. Research indicated Permit# PRBD20180529401 was issued 5/2412018 (15 days AFTER work
commenced.
e lnspection verified on 6/7 /20L8 with a FAILED status
f. The permit EXPIRED on 17/21/2078
g. Several attempts were made to contact the Iicense holder and other representatives of the
company (Mr. Jeff Rayl).
i. No attempt to resolve the issue has been taken by the contractor.
j, On the dale of f/15/2079, I observed the contractor working on the roof while the permit was
listed in EXPIRED status. A Stop Work Order was issued and contractor was notified through
voice mail.
m. The Permit was Re-Activated on the date of 2/20/2019
h. A Notice of Non-Compliance was sent on the date of 72/13/2018.
k. A Notice of Hearing was sent on the date of l/L5/2079.
l. The contractor did subsequent work in while permit still in EXPIRED status and under Stop
Work Order.
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 60 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
The EXPIRED permit violation was then abated by the contractor
The contractor commenced the work prior to the original building permit being issued.
p. The contractor took more than 10% ofthe contract price and did not apply for the permit
within the 30 day limit.
6. Thereafter, pursuant to Collier County Ordinance 2005-46, as amended, Section 4.3.2. and Section
4.3.3., the complaint was investigated and found sufficient cause to file formal charges.
7. Collier County brings the below charges in this formal complaint against the Respondent. See
counts 2,3, and 4.
On November 28, 2018, Tim Meulenberg, Collier County Contractor License Officer received the
written complaint (Case # CEM 1S20180014738) through Contractor Licensing Office, Customer
Service from homeowner, Thomas & Angela quigley, 1965 lsla De Palma Cr Naples, FL against
the roofing contractor. The contractor is listed as Florida Roof Services LLC with License
Holder/Qualifier listed as Peter Edward Wozniak, State License f CCC1331226 (Certified Roofing
Contractor). A contract was signed 5/2812018 for S34,250.00 with deposit of $11,520.00.
n
o
a
b. Research indicated Permit # PR802018O745475 was issued 7/31/2078.
e A Notice of Non-Compliance was sent on the date ot ),L/3O/2OL8.
f. Several attempts were made to contact the license holder Wozniak and other representatives
of the company (Mr. Jeff Rayl).
g. No attempt to resolve the issue was been taken by the contractor
h. A Notice of Hearing was sent on the date of 7/15/2OI9
i. The permit expired on 2/1L/20f9
j. The Permitwas Re-Activated onthe date o12/2012079.
9. Thereafter, pursuant to Collier County Ordinance 2000-4G, as amended, Section 4.3.2. and Section
4.3.3., the complaint(s) were investigated and found sufficient cause to file formal charges.
8. ltem S 3 - Quiplev - Case S CEM1S20180014738
c. Work commenced on 8/9/2018 and 'Dry-ln' lnspection on 8/73/2OL8.
d. NO WORK has been completed from the date o18lL3l2O!8 (lnspedion Date) to present,
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 61 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
10. Collier County brings the below charges in this formal complaint against the Respondent. See
count 4.
a. On June 5, 2018, Juan Guzman, Collier County Contractor License Officer received the
written complaint (Case # CEM 1S20180008081) through Contractor Licensing Office,
Customer Service from homeowner, Rolex Simon,4841 12th St NE Naples, FL against
the roofing contractor. The contractor is listed as Florida Roof Services LLC with License
Holder/Qualifier listed as Peter Edward Wozniak, State License # CCC1331226 (Certified
Roofing Contractor). A contract was signed 4/3/2Ot8 for S38,650.00 with deposit of
S12,984.00. The homeowner paid an additional S12,983.00 on 412512ot8.
b. Research indicated Permit # PR8D20180422435 was issued O4/04/2OL8.
c. Work commenced in April 2018 and '0ry-ln' lnspection on5/3/20L8 (PASS with notes).
d. No woRK was completed from the date of June 2018 (after inspection Date) to December
2018.
e. The permit Expired on t0/3L/2O18.
f. Several attempts were made to contact the license holder Wozniak and other representatives
of the company (Mr. Jeff Rayl).
g. ln mid-January 2019, the contractor applied a second underlayment as the first had exceeding
the exposure limits per the "NOA".
h. The work was conducted while the permit was in Expired Status.
l. A Notice of Hearing was sent on the date of Ll15/2O19.
j. The Permit was Re-Activated on the date of 2/2012019.
k. A second 'Dry{n' lnspection took place on 3/7/2019 (Pass Status).
12. Thereafter, pursuant to Collier County Ordinan€e 2006-46, as amended, Section 4.3.2. and Section
4.3.3., the complaint(s) were investigated and found sufficient cause to file formal charges.
13. Collier County brings the below charges in this formal complaint against the Respondent. See
count 4.
11. ltem fr 4 - R. Simon - case # c8M1S20180008081
14. ltem fl 5-V. Simon-CaseS CEM1S20190O02503
a. On March 7, 2019, Jack Gumph, Collier County Contractor License Officer received the written
complaint (Case S CEM 1S20190002503) through Contractor Licensing Office, Supervisor, E.
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 62 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Ybaceta reference the residence at 5329 Mitchell St. Naples, tL. The contractor is listed as
Florida Roof Services LLC with License Holder/Qualifier listed as Peter Edward Wozniak, State
Ljcense # CCC1331226 (Certified Roofing Contractor).
b. Florida Roof Services LLC made application for permit on t2/lO/2O18
Permit S PR8020181266458, Application ONLY in REIECTED Status with roof work commenced.c
d. I researched the application and found the application date to be listed as 12/10/2018. The
application was rejected, and a Corrections Letter sent out to the contractor of record, Florida
Roof Services LLC (State License # CCC133L226,Mr. Peter Wozniak, License Holder).
Supervisor Evy Ybaceta personally drove to the address in question, 5329 Mitchell St. At the
location, he found a single family detached structured (house). Mr. Ybaceta observed that the
roof work had commenced prior to the issuance of the permit # PRBD201AtZ66458.
f. Supervisor Evy Ybaceta observed that approximately one half ofthe roof had been torn off and
new underlayment placed installed. Supervisor Evy Ybaceta took photographs of the roof work
(which are attached to this case report).
g. The contractor commenced the work prior to the buildint permit being issued.
15. Thereafter, pursuant to Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as amended, Section 4.3.2. and Section
4.3.3., the complaint was investigated and found sufficient cause to file formal charges.
16. Collier County brings the below charges in this formal complaint against the Respondent. See
count 2.
17. Below are the counts Collier County is bringing against the Respondent
18. Collier County Ordina nce 2006-46, as amended, Section 4.2.2., M iscond uct - State Certified
Contractors, states: "Willfully violating the applicable building codes or laws of the state, city or
Collier County." - EXPIRED building permits PR8D2018053i950, PR8D201.80104959,
PR8D20180105i89, ond PR8D20170936849 (stote Building Code violation 105.7).
COUNT 2
19. Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as amended, Section 4.2.2., Misconduct - State Certified
Contractors, states: "Willfully violating the applicable building codes or laws ofthe state, city or
collier county." - commence work prior to issuonce of o building permit (stote Building Code
violotion 105.7). Permits Applicotions involved ore PR8D20180529401 for Reyes ond
PR8D20181266458 for V. Simon.
e
COUNT I
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 63 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
COUNT 3
20. Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as amended, Section 4.2.2., Misconduct - State Certified
Contractors, states: "Willfully violating the applicable building codes or laws of the state, city or
Collier County." - took more thon 70% of the controct price ond did not opply for the permit within
the i0 doy limit (Florido Stote Stotute, Chapter 489, Section 489.126(2) (o)). Cose involved is Reyes.
COUNT 4
21. Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as amended, Section 4.2.2., Misconduct - State Certified
Contractors, states: "Willfully violatinB the applicable building codes or laws of the state, city or
Collier County." - Abondoning o construction project in which he/she is engoged or under controct
as d controctor. A project moy be presumed abondoned il the controctor terminotes the project
without just cause, or foils to no fy the owner in writing oI terminotion of the controct ond bosis for
some, or foils to perform work for ninety (90) consecutive doys without just couse ond no soid notice
to the owner (Collier County Ordinonce 2006-46, os omended, Section 4.1.j.). Coses involved ore
Reyes, Quigley, ond R. Simon.
WHEREFORE, the Petitioner asserts the above facts and charges are grounds for disciplinary action
under Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as amended, Section 4.2., as amended, and
WHEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing, the Petitioner respectfully requests the Collier County
Contractors' Licensing Board to find the Respondent guilty of the violations charged.
Oated:Ze 5igned:
.n9h
Cdll.r County Con tr.cto.r' tic6EinE
Supawilor o. Olri3rEe
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 64 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Contractors' Licensing Board
2800 North Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, Fl. 34104
Complainant: Any person who believes that a Contractor holding a State Certification or Certificate of
competency has violated Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as amended, may submit a sworn complaint
to the Contractor Licensing supervisor, or his / her designee. The complaint shall be in substantially the
form prescribed by the Contractor Licensing Supervisor. The complainant shall pay a fee of S50.00 to
defray the costs of administering the complaint, at the time of filing the complaint. The complaining
party shall state with particularity which section(s) of this Ordinance he or she believes has been
violated by the contractor and the essential facts in support thereof.
Complaint:
Please print or type and return signed copies of the complaint.
Date: EsblssEAE-Zq!!!
Aga inst:
Contractor's Name: WOZNIAK, PETER EDWARD
Phone: 877-844-8300
Business Name: FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES ttc
License Number if known: Certified Roofins Contractor (State license fl CCC1331226)
Collier County Registration number: LCC20170002U5
Contractor's Business Address: 2605 FOREST PARKWAY N
LARGO, Ft 33771
Filed By:
Com plaint N umber- 29!9102
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 65 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES
PRBD 20180533950. pRgD701 0495 PR8D2018010538901 and BD80qol1PR 20170916849O1.
Have you communicated by letter with the licensee? YES
Date: 1/15/2019. Do you have a reply? YES
Please attach to this form all copies of the purchase agreement, building contract, home improvement
contract, copies of receipts and/or cancelled checks available and any additional evidence to
substantiate your allegations. List any subsections of Section 4 of Collier County Ordinance number 90-
105, as amended, which, in your opinion, have been violated by the contractor which is the subject of
this complaint, (list subsection number):
Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as amended, Section 4.2.2., Misconduct - State Certified
Contractors, states: "Willfully violating the applicable building codes or laws of the state, city or
Collier County."
Name: Collier Countv Contractors' Licensinq Office (rack Gumph)
Address: 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr., Naples, FL 34104
Business Phone: 239-252-2468
Address(s) where work done:4484 Dunlin Ct (Reves), 1965 lsla De Palma Cir (Quislev),4841 12th St. NE
(R. Simon), 5329 Mitchell ST (V. Simon) and multiple addresses concernine multiole oermits
City: NAPIES, FL 34U9
County: COLLIER
Date of contract(sl:3l25(2OLB (Reyes), 6/2812018 (QuiCley), a/3/2018 (R. Simon), N/A (V. Simon) and
multiple permits dating from 2017 to 2018 (Permits)
Date job started: 5/9/2018 (Reves). 8/9/2019 (Quielev). 5/2018 (R. Simon). Unknown (V. Simon) and
2017 (Permitsl
Date job completed or new home occupied: NOT Complete
Were there plans and specifications? Unknown
ls there a written contract? ves. lf yes, amount of contract: s42.600.00 {Reves). s34.260.00 (Quiqlev).
S38,650.00 (Simon) & Unknown for Exoired Permits,
Has Contractor been paid in full? No. lf not, what amount? 328,400,00 (Reves), 523,040.00 (Quislev),
S25.967.00 {Simon} & Unknown for Expired Permits.
Was a Building Permit obtained? YES
Building Permit number if known: PR8D20180529401 {Reves). PR8D20180745475 (Quiglev),
PR8D20180422435 (R. Simon), PR8D20181266458 (V. Simon) and EXPIRED PERMITS-
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 66 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Please state the facts which you believe substantiate your charge of misconduct against the subject
contractor. List facts separately for each subsection number above:
A. Peter Wozniak has willfully allowed multiple buildinS permits to become EXPIRED in Collier
County Case f C8M1520190002317. As per Collier County Euilding Official, Jonathan Walsh, this
contractor has committed will code violations.
L On December 10, 2018, Jack Gumph, Collier County Contractor License Officer received the
written complaint (Case I CEM1520180015337) throu8h Contractor LicensinB Office, Customer Service
from homeowner, Josephine & George Reyes,4484 Dunlin Ct., Naples, FL against the roofing
contractor. The contractor is listed as Florida Roof Services LLC with License Holder/Qualifier listed as
Peter Edward Wozniak, State License S CCCl331225 (Certified Roofing Contractor). A contract was
signed fl25l2OLB for $42,600.00 with deposit of S14,200.00. Florida Roof Services LtC made
application for permit on 5lL/2018. Florida Roof Services LLC commenced initial work on5l9l20Lg
(tear off & underlayment). Research indicated Permit f PRBD20180529401 was issued 5124/a0tg l,-s
days AFTER work commenced. lnspection verified on 6/7 tzOtB with a FAILED status. The permit
EXPIRED on L,.l27l2OL8. Several attempts were made to contact the license holder and other
representatives of the company (Mr. Jeff Rayl).
A Notice of Non-Compliance was sent on the date oI 721L312O18. No attempt to resolve the issue has
been taken by the contractor. On the date of 1/LS|aOL9,l observed the contractor working on the
roof while the permit was listed in EXPIRED status. A Stop Work Order was issued and contractor was
notified through voice mail, A Notice of Hearing was sent on the date ot ].lLslz0l9.fhe contractor
did subsequent work in while permit still in EXPIRED status and under Stop Work Order. The
Permit was Re-Activated on the date of 2/2O12079. The EXPIRED permit violation was then abated by
the contractor. The contractor commenced the work prior to the original building permit being issued.
The contractor took more than 10% of the contract price and did not apply for the permit within the
30 day limit. Permit remains Open.
C. On November 28, 2018, Tim Meulenberg, Collier County Contractor License Officer received
the written complaint (Case S CEM1520180014738) through Contractor Licensing Office, Customer
Service from homeowner, Thomas & Angela Quigley, 1965 lsla De Palma Cr Naples, FL against the
roofing contractor. The contractor is listed as Florida Roof services LLC with License Holder/Qualifier
listed as Peter Edward Wozniak, State License # CCC1331226 (Certified Roofing Contractor). A contract
was signed 6/2812Of8 tor $34,260.00 with deposit of $11,520.00. Research indicated Permit fl
PR8O20180745475 was issued 7 /3712018. Work commenced on 8/9/2018 and 'Dryln' lnspection on
81L312018. NO WORK has been completed from the date of 8/13/2018 (lnspection Oate) to present.
A Notice of Non-Compliance was sent on the dale ol7Ll3Ol2O18. Several attempts were made to
contact the license holder Wozniak and other representatives of the company (Mr. Jeff Rayl). No
attempt to resolve the issue was been taken by the contractor. A Notice of Hearing was sent on the
date ol ,.llsl20L9. The permit expied on 2/7U2OL9. The Permit was Re-Activated on the date of
2120l2Of9. Permit remains Open.
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 67 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
D On June 5,2018, Juan Guzman, Collier County Contractor License Officer
received the written complaint (Case # CEMl52018q)08081) through Contractor
Licensing Office, Customer Service from homeowner, Rolex Simon, 4841 12th St
NE Naples, FL against the roofing contractor, The contractor is listed as Florida
Roof Services LLC with License Holder/Qualifier listed as Peter Edward Wozniak,
State License f CCCl331226 (Certified Roofing Contractor). A contract was
signed 413l2OL8lor S38,650.00 with deposit of S12,984.00. The homeowner
paid an additional S12,983.00 on 412512OL8. Research indicated Permit f PR8O20180422436
was issued 04/(N/2018. Work commenced in April,2018 and'Dry-ln'lnspectionon5l3l2Ol8
(PASS with notes). NO WORK was completed from the date of June, 2018 (after inspection
Date) to December, 2018. The permit Expired on 10/31/2018. Several attempts were made
to contact the license holder Wozniak and other representatives of the company (Mr. Jeff
Rayl), ln midJanuary, 2019, the contractor applied a second underlayment as the first had
exceeding the exposure limits per the "NOA". The work was conducted while the permit
was in Relected Status. A Notice of Hearing was sent on the date of 1/15/2019. The Permit
was Re-Activated on the date of 2/ZOl2Ol9. A second 'Dry-ln' lnspection took place on
3/7l2OL9 lPass Status). Permit remains Open.
On March 7, 2019, Jack Gumph, Collier County Contractor License Officer received the written
complaint (Case f CEM1S20190002503) through Contractor Licensing Office, Supervisor, E.
Ybaceta reference the residence at 5329 Mitchell St. Naples, FL. The owner listed as VLADMIR
SIMON. The contractor is listed as Florida Roof Services LLC with License Holder/Qualifier
listed as Peter Edward Wozniak, State License f CCC[33L226 (Certified Roofing Contractor).
Florida Roof Services LLC made application for permiton LZl7Ol2018. Permitfl
PRBD20181265458, Application ONLY in RUECTED Status with roof work commenced. I
researched the application and found the application date to be listed as !2/lO/2018. The
application waslgjgg[g! and a Corrections Letter sent out to the contractor of record, Florida
Roof Services LLC (State Lic. fl CCC1331226, Mr. Peter Wozniak, License Holder). Spv E. Ybaceta
personally drove to the address in question, 5329 Mitchell St. on March 7, 2019. At the
location, he found a single family detached strusture (house). Mr. Ybaceta observed that the
roof work had commenced prior to the issuance of the permit fl PR8D20181256458. Spv E.
Ybaceta observed that approximately one half of the roof had been torn off and new
underlayment placed installed. Spv E. Ybaceta took photographs of the roof work (which are
attached to this case report). The contractor commenced the work prior to the building permit
being issued.
E.
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 68 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
(Complainant's signature)
State of FLORIDA
County of COLLIER
Sworn to (or affirmed) and subscribed before me this I ffic,r*t 2ot1lq,day of
by kl-
(signature of Notary Public)
Print, type or stamp commissioned name of Notary Public:
Personally known llnuon or produced identification
ffi:
Iuloflr
5f ooslrcilrrFffoqrrE&rrte
IfllIIt*aErm
(signature of person making statement).
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 69 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
DBPR - WOZNIAK, PETER EDWARD; Doing Business As: FLORIDA ROOF SERVI... Page 1 of 1
1 18:22 PM Y12019
Licensee Details
Licensee Information
Name:WOZNIAK, PETER EDWARD (Primary Name)
FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES LLC (DBA Name)
2605 FOREST PARKWAY NORTH
LARGO Florida 33771
PINELLAS
Main Address:
County:
License Mailing:
LicenseLocation:
License Information
License Type:
Rank:
License Number:
Status:
Licensure Date:
Expires:
Special Qualifications
construction Business
Certif ied Roof ing Contractor
Cert Roofing
ccc1331226
Current,Active
06/L6/2OL7
oa/3L/2O2O
Qualification Effective
06/L6/2Or7
Alternate Names
View Related License Information
View License Complaint
2601 Blair stone Road. Tallahassee FL 32399 :: Emall: customer Contact center :: Customer Contact Cente 8S0.487.1395
The State of Florida ts an AAIEEO emptoyer. Copvrioht 2OOZ-2OlO State of Ftorida, privacv Statem.nt
Under Flonda law, emaal addresses are public records. If you do not want your email address released rn response to a public-records.equest, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact the offlce by phone or by traditionat matf. ffyou'nave any- -_
questrcns, olease contact 850.487.1395. rPursuant ro section 455.275(t), Flodda Statutes, effeclve occoue. r, ioiz,l,."*J".l,censed under chapter 455, F.s. must provrde the Department with an em;it address if they have one. The emaits provided m;; beused for offrcial communtcation with th€ licensee. However emait addresses are pub|c record. tf y* ao not *"n ro iuppiylp".joi"raddress, please provide the Department with an emait address which can be made avaitabte to the oubiia.
h@s:/iwww.myfloridalicense.com/LicenseDetail.asp?SID=&id=8117795D405C845C4FA0... 311/201g
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 70 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
License Application Status - Cityview Portal
License Application Status
- Licens. Applic.tion summary
GMD Public Poftal
Page I of 1
Noter Yoe ca. colhps. and axDrDd individu.lscctions by clicting tha h.ader of the s..troo you wrsh to oll.ps€/.$r.d
Appllc.tion Number:
Business Name:
ucense Typei
Application Status:
Descrlption of Business:
M.ilin9 Address:
1CC20170002115
FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES LLC
4505 9TH STREEI EAST
2605 FORESI PARKWAY NORTh LARGO fL
ELUNGTON FL ]4222
]WRAYL@YAHOO,COM
437 /1
ROOFING CONTR..CERf IFIEO 09/25/20rA oa/31/2020 201700001091
There are no submittals tor this license appli.iton
Therp are no reviews for this license application.
PLYMOUTH INS,
AGENS
wc7L949 01/01/2018 0L/ot/2024 $0.00
Expiration Processedr
Producer Phone Number:
No
7279372134
PLYI,IOUTH INS
AGENCY
3AA1410304 o7/2t/20t7 07/21,/201,9
Explration Processed:
P.oducer Phone Number:
NO
7276824040
http:/i$portal.colliergov.nevcityviewweb/License/Status?licenseld=150619 31112019
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 71 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Detail by Entity Name
Detail by Entity Name
Florida Limited Liability Company
FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES LLC
Filino lntormation
DocumentNumber L16000102116
FEUEIN Number 8l-3988250
Date Filed O5D5DO16
Effective Date 06/01/2016
State FL
Stahts ACTIVE
Last Event REINSTATEMENT
Event Date Filed 11lO1f2O1A
Princloal Address
2605 FOREST PARKWAY N
LARGO, FL 337/1
allino Address
2605 FOREST PARKWAY N
|-ARGO, FL 33771
ReoisGred Aoent Name & Address
WOZNIAK, PETER E
2605 FOREST PARI(WAY N
LARGO, FL 3321
Name Changed: 1 1 101 t2O1 I
Authorized Person(s) Detail
Name & Address
Title MGR
\A/OZNIAK, PETER E
2605 FOREST PARKWAY N
LARGO, FL 33771
Annual Reports
Report Year
2017
2014
Filed Date
o5n1t2017
11t01t2018
Document lmaoes
11O1l2018 REINSTATEMENT view iBage in POF fmar
o5t21t2O17 Mew image rn PDF iomat
05/25/2016 Frorida Lrmrted Liabit[v View image rn POF tomal
http://search.sunbiz.orgfiaqwy/corporationSearch,/SearchResultDetail?inquirytype:Entity...3t1t2019
Page 2 of 2 10.A.1
Packet Pg. 72 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES
e'r Cotrtt-3rt
Gro'*'th l\I anageurcnt Divisiorr
Planning & Ikgulation
Opcrations f)cpurtmrnt
[,iccns ing Scctio n
Certified Mail #7017 0530 0000 8339 6286
Date: January 15, 2019
Peter Edward Wozniak d/b/a - Florida Roof Services LLC
2605 Forest Parkway N
Laryo,FL3377l
RE: PERMIT # PRBD2Or80529401, PR8D20180422436, PR8D20180745475
Dear Mr. Wozniak,
A complaint has been filed against you by the above referenced entity. A hearing of this
complaint will be held by the Contractors' Licensing Board on Wednesday March 20,2019 at
9:00 AM in the Board of County Commissioner's Room, Third Floor, Administration Building
(W. Harmon Tumer Bldg.), at 3301 East Tamiami Trail, Naples, Florida 34112. Your presence
before the Collier County Contractors' Licensing Board is required at this time.
In the event the Contractors' Licensing Board finds you in violation ofSection(s) 4.2 of Collier
County Ordinance # 2006-46, as amended, the range ofdisciplinary sanctions which may be
imposed are from an oral reprimand to a suspension or revocation ofyour Collier County
Certificate issuance (N/A), and/or suspension or revocation ofyour permit privileges against
your State license # CCCl33l226.
Sincerely,
ump h (239-2s2-2468)
L ing Compliance Officer, Collier County Contractors' Licensing
tions and Regulatory Management, Growth Management Department
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL. 34104
Growth Management Division'plannioB & Regotation'2800 North Horserh oe OnverNaplet Florida 34104'239-252,24O0rwww.coIier8ov net
The packet conceming your case marked composite exhibit "A" will be delivered to the
members of the Contractors' Licensing Board one week prior to the hearing. If you wish to
receive acopy of this packet, please notifo the Contractor Licensing Customer Service Office. If
you wish to prepare a defense packet and have it delivered in conjunction with composite exhibit
"A", you must make fifteen copies and have them in our office by 8:00 AM on Wednesday, one
week prior to the hearing. In your packet, you may give a summary ofevents. At this meeting,
you may presenl evidence and be represented by an aftorney ofyour choice.
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 73 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES
/ -'T- -
r Completo lt6ms 1, 2, and 3.
r Prlnt your nams and address on lha lBvera€
so lhat wo can rBtum tho cad to You.r Attach this cad to tho back oI the mallplocE,
or on the tront lf spac€ Permlts.
1. Arllclo Addrsss€d to:D. ls dolk€ry sdd.6a dtfioont fom
lf YES, €ntor dolivory addr@s b€low:
3. S.rvloo IYp6
D Adu[ Slqflltllr
tr AAit shllrtu/r F..lrlct d o.lh.rlO{rtt d M.ilO
L tr
C. Date of D€li
I
kldz Wloz Nt4<-
Fwetp^ Pottr f€tz,tr cc;';*;, i";;,; i*e c-' ^ 7 t't'
Lne4$, trL a571
ililil] ill llllltllill lt |l illl |! ilil ill I I ill
9590 9402 3463 7275 0756 52
t? E Yeo
ENo
El ftlodty Mall Etprer0
O n.gbl.rd MdlB
O R€cblrld Mdl Aodrtclcd
Dofl$tic Betum Reoslpt
2. Atllcle Numb€a Alal,sl€r fion aa l., t'te,r
?01,? 0530 t]000 8333 teSE
; es Form 381 1, July 2015 PsN 7530-04-000-9053
o
Do
C..irLd Mlll F6ldci.d Oetv€.y O Fdum A€colpt lor
Co[.cion D.lh€rv Mdcitrdho
couel d Ddiv; B.rtlci€d Dr.llrcry tr Slgn tul! Csflinallon
hr O SlgMtul! Co.'idu!,on
'rll8..tticl.dD.llvsy B"tld!'dotilvtry
A.S
x
byffAt u)
COMPLE|E IHIS SECTION ON DEUVENYSENDEB: COMPLETE THIS SECrION
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 74 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER
lillililill illtfiflilililtil
1ilil!
Flrstclass Mall
Postage & F€es Pald
USPS
Pormil No. G-i0
ln this box'
1530 1q0e rl ?475 075h 5a
prlnt your name, address,
Growth Management Divison
Planning & Regulation
Contractor Licensing Section
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples Fl. 34104 57
tt,t,, lil llt llt N,, llt, ilil,, tll,, t l,t ltlil,l,il ilt t tht ilt,t,
l
United States
Postal Sorvico
#
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 75 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER
oa,net Report Title:Code Case Details
Date 3/4/2019 '11:28:55 AM CaseNumber: CEM1S20190002317
Case Number:cEMts20190002317
Case Type Misconduct
Normal
lnspector:JackGumph
Jurisdiction Collier County
Origin Complaint
Detail Description Multiple Building Permits are EXPIRED in violation of Florida Building Code.
Location Comments
Status lnvestigation
Date & Time Entered 3/1/2019'12:30:09 PM
JackGumph
Case Disposition Case Pending
Contractor FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES LLC
1
Business Management & Budget Office
Priority:
Multiple locations
Entered By:
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 76 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Execution Dale 31412Q19 1 1 :28:55 AM
Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome
Preliminary lnvestigation JackGumph 3t1t2019 3t4t2019 On or about December '10, 2018, while
conducting the investigation of case file #
CEMlS201 8001 5337 (Reyes residence
roofng rssues). l(Jack Gumph) had occasron
to speak to both Juan Guzman and Tim
Meulenberg (Collier County Contractor
Lrcensing) who both advised me of on€oing
cases of a similar nature with Florida Roof
Services LLC (Peter Wozniak, State License #
CCC1331226 (Certified Roofing Contractor).
and respectively. lwas also advised of
several other expired permits on record for
the contractor.
lnvestigation JackG um ph 3t4t2019 Pending Florida Roof Services - Four (4) Expired
Permits
Cont. lnvestigation Jackcumph 3t4DAI9 3t4t2019 Complete I (J. Gumph) researched the Collier County
Permitting database and found several
permits listed as Status- Expired for
contractor, Florida Roof Services LLC. These
expired permits included the three cases
assigned to myself, Tim Meulenberg (Case #
CEM1S20180014738) and Juan Guzman
(Case # CEM1S20180008081). All three
investigators indicated they had attempted
several times to have the contractor abate the
expired permits, but have been unsuccessful.
Notices of Non-Compliance were forwarded to
Oualifier, Wozniak and were NOT returned
with signature.
Vvhen voice mails were left for either Peter
Wozniak or company representative Jetf Rayl,
it was related the scope of Expired status
pemits and the need to re-activate and
complete the roofing iobs.
Cont. lnvestigation JackGumph 3t4t2019 3t4t2019 Complete Having been unsuccessful at any contact with
contractor Wozniak or company
representative, Rayl, on the date of
111512019,I (J. Gumph) drafted a "Notice of
Hearing' to Peter Wozniak for a requirement
before the Contractor Licensing Board on the
date of March 20, 2019. The letter was sent
USPS, Certified Mail (#7017 0530 0000 8339
6286) on the date of 1/15/2019. The letter
was also forwarded to both Mr. Woznaak and
Mr. Rayl by email.
Cont. lnvestigation JackGumph 3t4t2019 3t4t2019 Complete 2/5i2019: Received the USPS database for
delivery (returned'GREEN CARD') for# 7017
0530 0000 8339 6286. Research revealed
successful delivery signed Contractor, Peter
E. Wozniak. USPS 'GREEN CARD' attached
to the file. The card was signed for by Peter
Wozniak on 113012019.
2Business Management & Budget Office
Code Case Details
Comments
Needs
lnvestigatio
n
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 77 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Code Case Details Execution Dale 31412019 11:28:55 AM
Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments
Cont. lnvestigation JackGumph 3t4t2019 3t4t2019 Complete 2127l2O'19: Research revealed that the
following permits were reactivated and issued
an Extension on the dale ot 212012019.
Permit # PRBD20180529401 - Case #
CEM1S20180015337 (J. Gumph case)
Permat # PRBD2018O745475- Case #
CEMlS201 800'14738 (T. Meulenberg case)
Permrt # PR8D2018U22436 - Case #
CEM1S20180008081 (J. Guzman case)
Although the contractor has abated those
specific permit violations of Expired Status
listed above, research revealed that there
were four (4) permits still listed in Expired
Status:
PR8D2018010495901. 5975 Green BLVD.
Expiration Date- 07i28l201 8
PR8D2018010538901, 4430 18th ST NE,
Expiration Date - 08/2012018
PRBD2018053395001, 2545 39rh AVE NE,
Expiration Date - 1112112018
PRBD20'17093684901. 2322 54th AVE NE,
Expiration Date - 07116/2018
Violation Description Status Entered Corrected Amount C om me nts
4.2 Misconduct State Certified
Contractors
Open 3t1t2019 50
Title Reason Result Compliance Fine/Day Condition
3
usiness Management & Budget Office
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 78 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES
Permit Application Status - CityView Portal
Permit Application Status
In order to schedule inspedions, you need to be signed in.
Applicatio. Oate
lssued Oate
Explratioo oate
1-2 Famity or comm
Page 1 of2
GMD Public Portal
PR4D20180533950
Building
FLORA, ROEERT R &TAMMY DEE
R€sid€ntial, One and Two Family New or Guest Bous€
375QS CONCRETE TIIE OVER POLYGLASS TU-MAX UNDERTAYMENT 5:T 2
PITCH
2545 39TH AVE NE
05/23tzo\a
05/25/2OlA
lttz\/zot8
1-2 Family
Qualifier:
FLORA, ROBERT R &TAMMY OEE, Addr€ssr2545 39TH AvE NE
WOZNIA(, PEIER EDWARO, Add.ess:2605 FORESI PARXWAY NOR H ,
Phone:(877) 844-8300, rl.ensee r 1CC20170002114
Llcense Status
FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES LlC, Address:4505 9TH STREET EAST, Phone
{877) E44'8300, State Reg *',s CCCI131226. ricensee *
1CC201700021r5
I]ll!5eltillrl
Pe.mits (click to See Revlews)
Structural - Appll.ation fee $50.00 $50.00 05/25/20rA
$90.00 t90.00 05/25/20rA
Structural - Review Fee $50.00 $50-00 05/25/20t8
6CAi $2.85 $2.8s a5/25/20t8
$2.00 92.00 05/25l2013
t194.45 $194.45 lo.oo
PLEASE DO NOT SUBMIT ANY PAYTIENTS UNTII A COLLIER COUNTY PAYMENT SUP I5 OTSTRIBTITED
169 - Dry-in/Flashl.g
lim tleisberger ((239) 292-3954) S.nd Emait
6/t5/20ta 6/t5/2018 06/t5/2AtA
http://cvportal.colliergov.nevcityviewweb/pennit/Status?permitld=263 g00 3/U2019
Application Number:
Application Type:
Application Status:
Property owner's Full Name:
Category of wo.k:
Occupancy Coder
OescnpLion of Workr
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 79 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES
Permit Application Status - Cityview Portal Page 2 of 2
Oocuments & tmag6
Correction 1
Status
Oate Status Changed
Comments
06/15/2018
Iospector Notes: Pdpemork Not Dosted at
gate. Gate locked . 2:55 pm. Pecl and stick
ok. Call ln 169 .nd 170 the same ttme with
Aftidavit complete. lCM,
http://$portal.colliergov.net/CityViewWeb/PermiVStatus?permitld=263800 3n/2019
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 80 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
ler Cowfit BU I LDING PERMIT APPLICATI ON
2800 N. HORSESHOE DR., NAPLES, tL 34104 I TEL \2391.252-2400G.r*Or fr*6€enEr{ Depa,ffi
Dircctions: Appliconts nlun complete oll ield, Pleose folhw the Petnit lnstructions to complete this Applbotion.
B.z Master Permlt ! F/o,,yI
6\&zrantint dvl.lir9tno*r,t *r" Q tuoa4Manuhctured hsne O Reidential3. uniG/Multitamiv
ffir,uoo,
8.3. SiJndrETyp€
S.4. Permltee TVpe
Ptoperty lnformation
8.5. Parcel/Foliod:
B 6. lob Street Address:
8.7. Owner Name:
8.8. Owner Phone:
8.9. Subdivision:
LoVBlocly'Unit:
B.10.SDP/PL#:
8.11.'PL{ Fllename:
?qqa -1e,oooG
O oesign Professional
Cortrador lrformatbn
g.12.l,icense#:
B.1jl. Compa.ry Name:
8.14. Qualifier Name:
8.15. Contact Name:
8.16. CompanyAddress:
cc
Q omer Builder
2f
Co.nmeroal
4eil-t
e
/.LrZ4
n
ia;ktg/ (D !a.4a c.,*t
t/foft- .4 {o
E7/catd>L, Fz e1??2
8.17. Company Phonei
8.18. tax $:
B.19.a. "Email 1:
8.19.b. "Email2:
a"Do notrf,c EntuNs) os ptitgty contcrt npM.
El Septic E LowVoltage
C.8. Fire Sprinkled:
C9. Permit by Affidavit:
C10. Pri te Prcir'ide.:
C.11. Threshdd Building:
C.12. Ve8efdtion Oea.ing:
E Shutten E EtfcT from house E Gas
c.13. Retated ro DAMAGES TNCURRED By HURR|CANE tRilA: Qves Qruo
' OprioNl - *orch odniry fi lenon6 on EA!@t@!.
DELEC EIPLUMB fl MECH
C2. Permit Type
C.3. Fire PermitType:
C4. Constructjon Type:
C.5. Ocorpancy:
C.6. Water SeMce:
C7. SewerSeMce:
Sectk n C &Dncatim lnbrme$on
D.1. Des.ription of Work (p'o,*,.trt:,y).. D.2. Project Name dorl.,:D.3. kared Value:
O.4. Airidertialsq. Ft:
NewConSL {Co.,rbie ar a S A4h)
Addiliot', (cun*E U4.a 8, D.4.ht
Alteratjon tcdnpbE oa.rl
D.5. orrhme{q?Fq. F!: ;
New Conn /Gnpkea5a & oj.bl
Addition l.znpkte 0.5o. & D.S.b. )
AlterdEon r/co.4DleE 05.,
D.4,a, Nee/ Consl D.4.b. Wqk Arca (q. Ft)
o 4 [i Uving:
o.a.b.r. No.living: _TOTAL O
D.a.c Wqt Aea (Sq, FL)
D a.c-j tivin8:
o 4.cii. Non-lMng: _TOTAL O
D.4.d. Totals W Area
IOTr,r lFEj 0
rcTAtNolr\rE 0
S Stori6:
f Units:
fl Bedrooms
# Bathrooms:
05.a, Nfl/ ConsL
{ Stories:
i Units:
Ds.b. Wo*ArEa (Sq- Ft)
lnterioc
€xterion
TOTAI: 0
E.2. Nunlber ofPlan sets.8.3. Review Days: WT 1 10 155
Setdm E. StaffSedion
E.1. Final Review Date:
Reesed OBle: 11/29117 v2 This is pate I oI3 pages ofthe Building permit Applicetion. please submit all3 pates when rornpleted
8i7- t'/4' rSoa
5 l.4,.mn I
D.S.cWo*&ea (&. FL)
lnterior:
--
Exterior: _TOTAL O
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 81 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
.1f,;.-*,
NOTICE OF COLLIER COUNTY ADDITIONAL REGULATIONS
NOTICE OF ADDITIONAL RESTRICTIoNS: tn alditirin tst'h,b iebuir6mentr.b!ifis dermit, there may be
additional restrictions applicable to th is property th;t may be found in the public records ofthis County,
and there may be additional permits required from other governmental entities such as the Water
Management District, State agencies, or Federal agencies.
WARNING OF POSSIBLE DEED RESTRICTIONS: The land sub.iect to this permit may be subject to deed,
and other restrictions that may limit or impair the landowner's rights. Collier County is not responsible
for the enforcement of these restrictions, nor are Collier County employees authorized to provide Iegal
or business advice to the pu blic relative to these restrictions. The landowner or any applicant acting on
behalf of the landowner is cautioned to seek professional advice.
WARNING OF WORK lN THE COUNTY RIGHT-OF-WAYS: This permit does not authorize construction or
installation of any structure or utility, above or below ground, lvithin any right of way or easement
reserved for access, drainage or utility purposes. This restriction specifically prohibits fencing, sprinkler
systems, landscaping other than sod, signs, water, sewer, cable and drainage work therein. lf such
improvements are necessary, a separate permit for that purpose must be obtained from the Growth
Management Department.
NOTICE OF CLEARING RESTRICTIONS: The issuance of a building permit for a single-family dwelling
allows up to one (1) acre of native vegetation to be cleared. Clearing more than one (1) acre may be
allowed for accessory structures and requires a separate Vegetation Removal Permit. Properties
located in the following zoning district overlays may not be allowed to clear one (1) acre: Rural Fringe
Mixed Use District (RFMU), Big Cypress Area of Concern (ACSC), and Special Treatment Overlay (ST).
There may be additional restrictions related to clearing native vegetation and impacts to wetlands or
protected species found on the property. State and Federal agency permits may be required. Contact
the Growth Management Department's Environmental Services at (239) 252-24OO for additional
information. lssuance of a Demolition Permit for a structure does not authorize removal of vegetation
beyond the footprint of the structure. A Demo Permit is not a clearing permit.
WORK lN THE SPECIAI FLOOD HAZARD AREA: Be advised that Substantial Da mage/Substa ntia I
lmprovement requirements will apply to structures located in the Special Flood Hazard Area with
Finished Floor Elevations below the Base Flood Elevation.
By initialing, I am acknowledging that I have read and understand this Notice of Collier County
Additional Regulations.
lnitia
Own or Agent of Ownet's or Controctor's initiols ore required
Rev 11-29_2017 v2
BUII.DING PERMTT APPUCATION
2800 N. HORSESHOE DR., NAPLES, FL 34104 | TEL: (239) 252-2400
Thit is paBe 2 of 3 pages ol the guilding Permit Application' Please submit all 3 pages when completed-
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 82 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
o,18,.-*,BUII.DING PERMIT APPUCA]ION
2800 N. HORSESHOE DR., NAPLES, FL 34104 | TEL: (239) 252'2400
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF COLI-IER COUNTY REGULATIONS
Application is hereby made lo obtain a permit to do the work and installatio.s as indicated. I certify that no work or installation ha!
commenced prior to the issuance of a permit and that all work wrll be performed to meet the standards of all ,ews regulating
const.uction in this jurisd;ction. The permit or application fee may have additional fecs imposed for failing to obtain permits prior to
commencement of construction-
The approved permit and/or permit application expires if not commenced within 180 days from the date of issuance. The permittee
further understands fhat only licensed contractors may be smployed and that the structure will not be used or occupied until a
certificate of occupancy is issued. By signing this permit application, I agree that I have been retained by the owner/permittee to
provide contracting services for the trade for which I am listed. Furthermore, it is my responsibility to notify the Building plan Review
and lnspection Division should I no lonBer be the contractor responsible for providing said .ontracting services. I further agree that I
understand that the review and issuing of this permit does not exempt me from complying with all Counly 6o6"r "n, Ordinances. tt
is further understood that the property owner/permittee is the owner oI the permit.
Note: An Owner-EuildeI must complete sections A and B and the Own€t-Builder Affidavit form.
SECIION A. OWNER or AGENT OF OWNER ACKNOWLEDGEMENT. The Contractor m ay sign as the Agent of Owner so long as
Co ,s ntract with Owne r permits such action:
ignature of Owner o
The f
nt of
twa
erJ
s acknowledged before me this /./diy oforesoinp in stru?tt"r t)o|i ci/,(name ol person) who
(Print name of Owner or Agent of Cwner)
men
cation (type of identificatl
ACKNOWTEDG EM ENT
l5
,2otz_6y
produced identifi
Notary SiBnature
sEcTto 8. CONr
si f Contra
b)a ral
The for oing instrument was acknowledBed before me this u{l day ol
ak name of erson)who
(Print name ot Contractor)
t5
zo /f by
has
produced identification (typ eof tifac
Notary Signature
NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT INFORMATION
Per Florida statutes 713.135 a Nottce of commencement (Noc) is required for construction of improvements totaring more than
S2,500, with certain etceptaon 5. For A/C Repairs or Replace ments a n otice of com m encement is requ ired for imp rovemen ts more than
or equal to S7,500. The applicant shall file with the jssuing authority prjor to the firsl inspectjon either a certrfied copy of the recorded
NOC or a notarized statement that the NOC has been filed for recording, alonB with a copy thereof. tn order to comply with the state
requirement, permits will be placed in inspection hold until proof of the Noc is filed with the buildinB permittrng and inspe.tion
department. The issuing authoraty shall not perfo.m or approve subsequent inspectaons until the applicant files by mail, fac5imile,
hand delivery, email or any other means such as cenified copy with the issuing autho.lty.
WARNING To owNER: YouR FATLURE To REcoRD A NoflcE oF COMMENCEMENT MAy
RESULT IN YOUR PAYING TWICE FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO YOUR PROPERTY. IF YOU INTEND
TO OBTAIN FINANCING, CONSULT WITH YOUR TENDER OR AN ATTORNEY BEFORE RECORDING
YOUR NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT. A NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT MUST BE RECORDED
AND POSTED ON THE JOB SITE BEFORE THE FIRST INSPECTION.
Aev l1'29 2017 v2 rhis i5 paEe 3 or 3 pates of the Suildins Permit Application. please submit 3ll3 page, when completed.
na
JEFFERY W RAYL
UY COMMISSION I FF?06995
exorars rni8f,li:. zo,g
JEFFERY W RAYL
MY COMMTSSTON f FF206995
ExPrR€S March fFibrs
D+*t)k
who has
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 83 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
PERMIT #: PR8D2018053395001ISSUED: BY:MASTER#: COA:
JOB ADDRESS: 2545 39th AVE NE
PERMIT
PER\'IIT TYPI]: RO
APPLIED DATE: 05-23-18 APPROVAL DATE: 05-25-l 8
JOB DESCRIPTION: 375QS CONCRETE TILE OVER POLYGLASS TU-MAX JOB PHONE;
LTNDERLAYMENT 6: I 2 PITCH
2545 39TH AVE NE
SUBDI\'ISION #BLOCK:
ELEVATION:
LOT:
FLOOD MAP ZONE:
FOLIO #: 39893680006 SECTION-TOWNSHIP-RANGE: I 8-48-28
Q'dD{E&INFORMATION CONTRACTOR INFORMATION
FLORA, ROBERT R & TAMMY DEE
2545 39TH AVE NE
NAPLES, FL 34120-
FCC ODE
CONSTRUCTI O^* CODE: 0220
JOB VAIUE: $33,000.00
SETBACKS FRONT:REAR:
FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES LLC
4505 9TH STREET EAST
ELLINGTON, FL 34222
CERTIFICATE #: .NoucENsEb PHONE:
TOTAL RES SOFT| 0 TOTAL CO]T{M SOFT:0
RIGHT:
SEWER:
CONTACT NAME: FLORA, ROBERT R & TAMMY DEE
CONTACT PHONE: <NO PRIMARY PHONE>
Per Collier County Ordinance No. 2002-01, as it may be amended, all work must comply with all applicable laws, codes, ordinances, and any additional
stipulations or conditions ofthis permit. This permit expires if work authorized by the permit is not commenced within six (6) fionths from the date of
issuance ofthe p€rmit. Additional fees for failing to obtain permits prior to the cornmenc€ment ofconstruction may be imposed. Permittee(s) further
understands that any contractor that may be employed must be a licensed contractor and that the structure must not be used or occupied until a
Certificate of Occupancy is issued.
.T"OTICE: PRIOR TO THE RENIOVAL OF ASBESTOS PRODUCTS OR THE DEMOLITION OF A STRUCTURE, FEDERA,L
AND STATE LAWS REQUIRE THE PERMITTEE (EITHER THE OWNER OR CONTRACTOR) TO SUBMIT A NOTICE OF
THE INTENDED WORK TO THE STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVTRONMENTAL PROTECTION (DEp). FOR IUORE
TNFORMATION, CONTACT DEp AT (239) 344-5600.
In addition to the conditions of this permit, there may be additional restrictions applicable to this property that may be found in
the public records of this county, and there may be additional permits required from other governmental entities such as water
management districts, state agencies, or federal ageocies.
WARNING TO OWNER: YOUR FAILURE TO RECORD A NOTICE OF
COMMENCEMENT MAY RESULT IN YOUR PAYING TWICE FOR IMPROVEMENTS
TO YOUR PROPERTY. IF YOU INTEND TO OBTAIN FINANCING, CONSULT WITH
YOUR LENDER OR AN ATTORNEY BEFORE RECORDING YOUR NOTICE OF
COMMENCEMENT,
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
LEFT:
WATER:
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 84 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Permit Application Status - Cityview Portal
Permit Application Status
In order to s.hedule inspections, you need to be signed in.
GMD Public Portal
Page 1of2
APPlication Number
Application Type
Appllcation Status
Property Owne.'s Full Name
Category of Work
Occlpancy Cod€
Oescrlption of Work
PRBD2018010,(959
Buildio9
Expired
KIBURN ESTi MARY EUZABETH
Residentlal, One and Two Family New or Guest House
RE-ROOF SHINGLE ROOF OVER PEEI & STICK MAIN HOUSE ONLY 5:12
PITCH
Application Dale:
Isssed Date:
Expi.ation Dat€:
1-2 Family or Comm:
5975 GREEN BLVD
ot/24/2Ot8
0t/29/2OLa
07 nat2ola
1-2 famlly
Qualine.:
KIIBURN EST, MARY ELIZABETH, Address:5975 GREEN BLVO
WOZNIAK, PETER EOWARO, Address:2605 FOREST PARKWAY NORTH ,
ft one:(877) 844-8300, ti€ense€ t 1CC20170002114
License Status
FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES ItC, Address:4505 9TH STREET EAST, Phone
(877) 844-8300, State Res *'s CCC1331226, Ucensee *
tcc20170002t,15
Li.ense Status
Permitr (Click to See Reviews)
Structural - Application Fee $50.00 $50.00 o\/26/20tA
$90.00 $90.00 ot/26/2ALA
Structural - Review Fee $50.00 $50.00 0t/26/2ALA
ACAI $2.85 92.85 ot/26/20tA
t2.00 $2.00 oll26/2ota
No outstandrn9 lees,
1194.45 4194.85 to.oo
PLEASE DO NOT SUBMIT ANY PAYMENTS UNT]! A COLUER COUNTY PAYMEt,IT SLIP IS OISTRIBUTED
There are no inspections for this apDlication
Docu.n.nts & Imaq.r
http://cvportal.colliergov.net/CityViewWeb/PermiVStatus?permitl d=238249 3n/2019
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 85 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Qouttw
Go.vh r,fanagerrEr( Departnert
BUITDING PERMIT APPLICATION
2800 N. HoRSESHOE DR., NAPLES, FL 34104 | TELi (239)252-2400
Directbns: Appliconts mun complete ol Jieds. Please folhw the tion lrstructbns to
a:: uast"i Pi#i
this Applicotion.
Mobile/Manufactured home O Resjdential3+urits^lulti-fam./ O Cornmercial
eropefi lrifomiiti6n
85. Parcel/Folio f:
8.5. lob Street Addressi
h6a
8.7. Or'rneJ Name:
8.8- Owner Phone:
83. SubdMsion:
l-ovglodvunit:
8.10. SDP/PL#:
8.11. 'PLs Fllename:
'Opt:toral -borch e\ining filenomes ot1 9!!!42q!9!.
O oesign nrofessionat
Contractor lnf oimation
8.12. LicerBe*
8.13. Company Name:
B.14. QualifierName:
-r4 8.15. Contact Name:
8.15. Compahy Addrqrs:
C2. Permit Type:
C3. Fire Permit Type:
C4. Cor6truction Type:
CJ. Occupancy:
C5. WaterSeMce:
C7. Sewer Service:
1& 2 Family dwellnglTo\rnhcuse
gd.oo,
tr] ELEC EPLUMB D MEO1 Rooi
8.1.7. Company Phone
8.18. Fax t:
B.19.a. "Email 1:
B.l!) b. "Email ?:
J"b not ose En,oil(s) ds ptiiey cotltoct nethd-
E Septic E lowvolbge E Shutters E E[Cf fromhouse EGas
C8. Fire Sprinkled:
C9. Permit by Affidrvit
C10. Private Pror'ider
C11. Ihreshold Building:
C12. Vegetation Oearing:
c13. Related to DAMAGEs TNCURRED Sy HURRTCANE IRMA: oyes o No
D.1. Description ofwo* lsa e@: D.2. P.oject Name afdy,/:D.3. Declared Value: S
t/€:,
+e
. D_:4tiiixiidj:iithlsil.Et,r -
New C@rst. {CorrpbeA4.o & 046l
Additic/.' (csty*re oad 8, Dah)
l\keGtion (con*t o4c)
Pd; Co_rr.lmeld-41.,E: Fr. i.,
New ConsL /compkE A5a & oib./
Addinon (dn*E asa & o.td)
Alteration /Conplre OJ c./
E.1. Final Review Date:
D.4.a. New Consl 0.4.b. Worii Area {Sq. FL)
D.4.bi. Living:
D.4t.i. Non-lMng: _
TOTAL: 0
D.4.c Work Area (q. Ft.)
D 4.ci. Living:
0.4.c[ NoG]Mng: _
TOTAL O
0.4.d. Totals by Area
fOIAt virEr 0
IOT&N{ntuiE: 0
# Stories:
S Units:
Bedrooms:
# Bathroomsr
S Stodesi
# Units:
Ds-a. Net.\,/ Cor]'t.Ds.b. Work Area (Sq. Ft )
loterior:
Exerior:
TOTAL:
D.s.c Work Area (5q. FL)
lnterior _'-
Exterior:
O TOTAL
E.2. Numb€rof Plan kt5:E.3. Review Day5 51015
Revised Oater 1il29/17 v2 is i5 page 1of3 pagesofthe Blil ng Permi'l Application_ Please submi.! all 3 pages when comDleted
. 83: Birlldih8:rype: .
B.a, Per.,inlii6e Typq O Owrer Euilder
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 86 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
_?f._
BUII.DING PERMTT APPUCATION
2800 N. HORSESHOE DR., NAPLEs, FL 34104 | rEt: (239) 252-2400
NOTICE OF COLLIER COUNTY ADDITIONAL REGULATIONS
NOTICE OF ADDITIONAI RESTRICTIONS: ln addition to the requirements of this permit, there may be
add itional restrictions a pplica ble to this property th at may be fou nd in th e pu blic records of th is County,
and there may be additional permits required from other governmental entities such as the Water
Management District, State agencies, or Federal agencies.
WARNING OF POSSIBLE DEED RESTRICTIONS: The land subject to this permit may be subject to deed,
and other restrictions that may limit or impair the landowner's rights. Collier County is not responsible
for the enforcement of these restrictions, nor are Collier County employees authorized to provide legal
or business advice to the public relative to these restrictions. The landowner or any applicant acting on
behalf of the landowner is cautioned to seek professional advice.
WARNING OF WORK lN THE COUNTY RIGHT-OF-WAYS: This permit does not authorize construction or
installation of any structure or utility, above or below ground, within any right of way or easement
reserved for access, drainage or utility purposes. This restriction specifically prohibits fencing, sprinkler
systems, landscaping other than sod, signs, water, sewer, cable and drainage work therein. lf such
improvements are necessary, a separate permit for that purpose must be obtained from the Growth
Management Department.
NOTICE OF CIEARING RESTRICTIONS: The issuance of a building permit for a single-family dwelling
allows up to one (1) acre of native vegetation to be cleared. Clearing more than one (1) acre may be
allowed for accessory structures and requires a separate Vegetation Removal Permit. Properties
located in the following zoning district overlays may not be allowed to clear one (1) acre: Rural Fringe
Mixed Use District (RFMU), Big Cypress Area of Concern (ACSC), and Special Treatment Overlay (ST).
There may be additional restrictions related to clearing native vegetation and impacts to wetlands or
protected species found on the property. State and Federal agency permits may be requtred. Contact
the Growth Management Department's Environmental services at (239) 25?-2400 for additional
information. lssuance of a Demolition Permit for a structure does not authorize removal of vegetation
beyond the footprint ofthe structure. A Demo Permit is not a clearing permit.
WORK lN THE SPECIAL FLOOD HAZARD AREA: Be advised that Substantial Da mage/Su bstantial
lmprovement requirements will apply to structures located in the Special Flood Hazard Area with
Finished Floor Elevations below the Ease Flood Elevation.
By initialing, I am acknowledging that I have read and understand this Notice of Collier County
Additional Regulations.
lnitial
o wner or
8ev i1-2+2017 v2 This is page 2 of 3 pager ofthe Euilding Permit Application. Plea5e submit all3 page5when completed
Agent of Owne/s or Controctor's initiols ore required.
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 87 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
_16_
Notary Signature
SECTI
of Cont
4+
of'person)
{
who
n/F q
BUII.DING PERMITAPPUCATION
2800 N. HORSESHOE DR., NAPLES, FL 34104 I TEt: (239) 252-2400
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF COLLIER COUNTY REGUTATIONS
Application is hereby made to obtain a perrnit to do the work and installations as andicated. I certify that no work or installation has
commenced prior to the issuance of a permit and that all work will be performed to meet the standards of all laws regulating
construction in this jurisdiction. The permit o. apptication fee may have additional fees imposed for failing to obtain permits prior to
commencement of construction.
The approved permit and/or permit application expires if not commenced within 180 days from the date of issuance. The permittee
further understands that only licensed contractors may be employed and that the structure will not be used or occupied until a
certificate of occupancv is issued. By signin8 this permit application, I agree that i have been retained by the owner/permittee to
provide contracting services for the trade for which I am Iisted. FUrthermore, it is my responsibility to notifY the EuildinE Plan Review
and lnspection Division should I no longer be the contractor responsible fo. providing said contracting services. lfurther agree that I
understand that the review and issuing of this permit does not exempt me f.om complying with all CountY Codes and O.dinances. lt
is further understood that the property owner/permittee is the owner ol the permit
Note: An Owner-guildet mun complete sections A and I and the Owner-Builder Affidavit form,
SECTTON A. OWNER or AGENT OF OWNER ACXNOWLEOGEMENT. The Contractor may sign as the Agent ol Owner so long a5
Contr rontract Owne,r permits such adionl
re ofowner or
produced identification (ty
(Print name ofOwner o. Agent of owner)
e fore8oin instrument was acknowledBed before me this day of
rsona lly known to r who has
ON R ACK LEDG EMENT:/rn
^),,o,
JEFFERY IY RAYL
MY CO\l[rrSSlON ' FF206995
ExtlRES Match 13 2019
4 v
fi icat i
(Pnnt name of ContractorJ
e foreg c
{neme of person)who or who has
produced identification (nti
Notary Signature Sea I
NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT INFORMATION
per tlorida Statutes 713.135 a Notice of Commencement (NOC) is required for construction of improvements totaling more than
S2,5OO, with certain exceptions. For A/C Repairs or Replacer.ents a notace of commencement is required for imp.ovements more than
or equal to 57,500. The applicant shall file with the issuing a uthority prior to the l;rst inspection either a cenified copy of the recorded
NOC or a notarized stalement that the NOC has been filed for recording, along with a copy thereof. ln order to comply with the state
requirement, permits will be placed in inspedion hold until proof of the NOC is filed with the building permittjng and inspection
department. The issuing authority shall not perform or approve subsequent nspections until the applicant files by mail, facsimile,
hand delivery, email or any other means such as certified copy with the issuinB authorrty.
WARNING TO OWNER: YOUR FAILURE TO RECORD A NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT MAY
RESULT IN YOUR PAYING TWICE FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO YOUR PROPERry. IF YOU INTEND
TO OBTAIN FINANCING, CONSULTWITH YOUR LENDER OR AN ATTORNEY BEFORE RECORDING
YOUR NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT. A NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT MUST BE RECORDED
AND POSTED ON THE JOB SITE BEFORE THE FIRST INSPECTION.
8ev 1r-29'2017 v? This is page 3 of 3 pages ofihe Building Perrnit Application. ptea5e submit all 3 pages when compieted.
B instrument was acknowledged before me this 3/day of zo/y' ay
er5onal y known to
JEFFERY W RAYL
Y CO\{.rlssloN I EF206995
ExPIRES March 13 2019
i:U
o, Owner)
(name
Seal:
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 88 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
PERMIT
PERMIT TYPE:RO
APPLIED D.ATE: 0l-24-18
JOB ADDRESS: 5975 Green BLVD
JOB DESCRIPTION: RE-ROOF SHINGLE ROOF O\.ER PEEL & STTCK MAIN JOB PHONE
HOUSE ONLY 5:12 PITCH
5975 GREEN BLVD
SLIBDIVISION #:
O\\NER INFORIT4ATION:
KILBIIRN EST, MARY ELIZABETH
5975 GREEN BL!'D
NAPLES, FL 34I I6.
FCC COD
CONSTRUCTION CODE: 0220
JOB VALUE: $ 15,300.00
SETBACKS FRONT:REAR
SHIP-RANGE t7 -49-26
CONTRACTOR INFORMATION
FLORIDA ROOF SER\'ICES LLC
4505 9TH STREET EAST
ELLINCTON, FL 34222
ICATE #
TOTAL RES SQFT: O
APPROVAI DATE:0l -26-18
PHONE:
ZONE:
BLOCK:
ELEVATION:FLOOD MAP:
FOLIO #: 38336880005 S
SEWER:
CONTA NAME:
CONTACT PHONE
Per Collier County Ordinarce No. 2002-01, as it may be arnended, all work must comply with all applicable laws, codes, ordinances, and a.ny additiona!
stipulations or conditiorN ofthis permit. This permit expires ifwork authorized by the permit is not commenced within six (6) months fiom the date of
issuance ofthe permit. Additional fees for failing to obtain permits prior to the commencement ofconstruction may be imposed. Permittee(s) further
understands that any contractor thal may be employed must be a licensed contmctor and that the structure must not be used or occupied until a
Certificate ofOccupancy is issued.
PERMIT#: PRBD2018010495901ISSUED: BY:
MASTER #: PR8D20180104953 COA:
LOT:
TOTAL COMM SOFT: 0
RIGHT:LEFT:
WATER:
NOTICE: PRIOR TO THE REMOVAL OF ASBESTOS PRODUCTS OR THE DEMOLITION OF A STRUCTURE, FEDERAL
AND STATE LAWS REQUIRE THE PERMITTEE (EITHER THE OWNER OR CONTRACTOR) TO SUBMIT A NOTICE OF
THE INTENDED WORK TO THE STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVTRONMENTAL PROTECTION (DEp). FOR IttORE
TNFORMATION, CONTACT DEp AT (239) 344-5600.
In addition to the conditions of this permit, there may be additionrl restrictions applicable to this property that may be found in
the public records ofthis county' and there may be additional permits required from other governmental entities such as wrter
management districts, state agencies, or federal agencies.
WARNING TO OWNER: YOUR FAILURE TO RECORD A NOTICE oF
COMMENCEMENT MAY RESULT IN YOUR PAYING TWICE FOR IMPROVEMENTS
TO YOUR PROPERTY. IF YOU INTEND TO OBTAIN FINANCING, CONSULT WITH
YOUR LENDER OR AN ATTORNEY BEFORE RECORDING YOUR NOTICE OF
COMMENCEMENT.
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 89 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Permit Application Status - CityView Portal
Permit Application Status
In order to schedul€ inspections, you need to be signed i..
Application Dat€
Issued Oate
Explration Oat€
1-2 Famlly or Comm
Page I of2
GMD Public Portal
Aooll.ation Number:
Apptacation Typ€:
Application Status:
Propedy Own€r's Full Name:
Calegory of work:
Occup.ncy Code:
DesolpUon of work:
PRBD20180105t89
Bulldlo9
Explred
RAVELO, CARTOS YAIIITE LEAL
ResldenUal, Ona.nd Two F;mily Ncw or Gulst House
REROOF SHTNGLES OVER PEEL & SnCl( 5:12 PTICH 27 SQ
4430 lEth ST NE
o1/25/zOtA
ot/29t2ota
oa/20/zotg
!-2 Famlly
Quallner:
RAVELO, CARLOS YArrIlE LEAL, Address:4430 ISTH 5T NE
WOZNIAK, PETER EDWARO, AddTess:2605 fOREST PARKWAY NORTH ,
Phone:(877) 844-8300, Lacensee * tCC20l70002l14
lEllselldlJr
FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES LLC, Address:4505 9TH STREEI EAST, Phone
(877) 844-8100, State Reg t s CCC1331226, Ucensee *
1CC20170002115
License Status
Permits (Click to Sec Reviews)
Strudural - Appll€alion Fee $50 00 $50.00 ot/29/20ra
s90.00 $9o.oo 0r/29/20tA
Strudural - Review Fee $s0.00 $50.00 ot/29/2018
ACAI 12.85 s2.85 ot/29/2018
DAPR Surcharge t 2.00 $2.00 at/29/2ArA
No outstandrn9 fees.
9194.45 t194.85 to,oo
PLEASE DO NOT SUBMIT ANY PAYI4ENTS I]NTIL A COLLIER COUNTY PAYI.4ENT SLIP IS DISTRIBUTED
170 - Re-root Final
lim Meisberger ((239) 292-39sa) SslllE@al
2/24/2014 02/24/2OtA2/2412018
http://cvportal.colliergov.neVCityViewWeb/Permit/Status?permitld=238615 311t2019
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 90 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Permit Application Status - CityView Portal Page 2 of 2
Corection l:
status:
Date st.tus Changed:
Comments;
02/2At20rA
Inspedo. Noles: No damD on power pole
boot at top. Jcll.
169 - Ory-in/flashing 2/2t/20ta 2/21,/20tA a2/2t/2AtA
Steve Belyea ((239) 438-5163) Send Emell
Correction 1:
Status:
Date Status Changed:
Comments:
P.sE wlth lnspedor Notes
02/21/2478
Pass wath hspector Notes: Peel-n-stick,
6090 shingled, Aff. to nle.
- Documents & lm.ges
http:/icvportal.colliergov.neUCityViewWeb,/PermiVStatus?permitld=238615 3nt2019
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 91 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
PERMIT #: PRBD2018010538901
ISSUED: BY;
MASTER #; PR8D20180105383 COA:
O\\NER INFORMATION
RAVELO, CARLOS YAMILE LEAL
4430 I8TH ST NE
NAPLES, FL 34120-
FCC CODE:
CONSTRU ON CODE: 0220
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
PERMIT
PERMIT TYPE: RO
APPLIED DATE:0t-25- r 8
BLOCK
TION
FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES LLC
4505 9TH STREET EAST
ELLINGTON, FL 34222
CERTIFICATE #:,.ro ucexs*,
AILROYAL DATE: 01-28-l 8
LOTSLIBDIMSION #:
FLOOD MAP:
FOLIO #: 39655960003
ZONE: ELEVATION:
SECTION-TOWNSHIP-P-,NGE: I 2-48.27
P}tONE:
TOTA, RES SQFT: 0 TOTAL COMM SOFT: 0JOB VALUE: $ 10,000.00
SETB,{CKS FRONT:LEFT;
WATER:
RICHT:
SEWER:
CONTACT NAME:
CONTACT PHONE
Per Collier Couoty Ordinance No. 2002-01, as it may be amended, all work must comply with all applicable laws, codes, ordinances, and any additional
stipulations or conditions oflhis permit. This permit expires ifwork authorized by the permit is not commenced within si\ (6) months fiom the date of
issuance ofthe permit. Additional fees for failing to obtain permits prior to the commencement ofconstruction may be imposed. Permittee(s) further
understands that any contractor that may be employed must be a lic€nsed contractor and that the structure must not be used or occupied until a
Certificate of Occupancy is issued.
NOTICE; PRIOR TO THE REMOVAL OF ASBESTOS PRODUCTS OR THE DEMOLITION OF A STRUCTURE, FEDERAL
AND STATE LAWS REQUIRE THE PERMITTEE (EITHER THE OWNER OR CONTRACTOR) TO SUBMIT A I.OTICE OF
THE INTENDED WORK TO THE STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION (DEP). FOR MORE
INFORMATTON, CONTACT DEp AT (239) 344-5600.
In addition to the collditions of this permit, there may be additional restrictions applicable to this property that may be found in
the public records ofthis county, aDd there may be sdditional permits required from other governmental entities such as water
management districts, state agencies, or federal agencies.
WARNING TO OWNER: YOUR FAILURE TO RECORD A NOTTCE OF
COMMENCEMENT MAY RESULT IN YOIJ'R PAYING TWICE FOR IMPROVEMENTS
TO YOUR PROPERTY. IF YOU INTEND TO OBTAIN FINANCING, CONSULT WITH
YOUR LENDER OR AN ATTORNEY BEFORE RECORDING YOUR NOTICE OF
COMMENCEMENT.
JOB ADDRESS: 4430 I8th ST NE
JOB DESCRIPTION: REROOF SHINGLES OVER PEEL & STICK 5:12 PITCH JOB PHONE:
27 SQ
4430 l Sth ST NE
REAR:
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 92 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
C,owtty
Glufi lildEe.rEi Dep.rtrE i
I
md @n*te ol fP.lds- Pl@se the Emit Applit tirl lnsbuctiru to
BUI 1DING PERMIT APPUCATION
2800 N. HORSESHOE DR., NAPLES, FL 34104 | TEL: (239)252-2400
thbDircf,tia,s
E.3jE {dii'ETiH 6rr*"nr n"*rt ",rrn-*6**,O r.,rotne/il.rrf.*n"dtr-r* O nesUenue +uitvfvrr:frftmfu Q C--r-.U
O ou<***oro*l O om€r&r der
B.12" tkense *
8.1:!.oompany Narne:
8.14. Qualifier NanE:
8.15. Contact Narne;
8.16. CompanyAddress;
85. Parcel/Folio S ,qL{iqhbn
8.6. Job Sred Addre-is:o
8.7. O,vner N ne:
8.8. O^/ner Phone
8.9. Subdivisim:
. LovBlody'UniL
8.10. SDP/Ptif
B.1l- 'Pt"S tilename:
C2. PermitType:
C3, Flre Permil
C4. Construct-on Type:
6 5t'
l'ioile,t Go* Eotlx
4", / I,o < 7,ffr .J Al t {, h fe //
L t-t- t a 4 , 2 2/
f'/
&17, Comp3fly Phone
&1& Faxtr
8.1!,i. -Emall I
8.19.b. -Emafl 2:
J'otX,Av t I y'r}n. t"-
C5. O(rupancy:
C5. Water Servke:
C7. Ser,ver 9rvte-
l"u tt u* tn4 s1 a Nntuy @1M mtu.
EETEC EPLUMB O MEo]E Roof tr Septt El bvrvoltace E shutters E El.Egrfrom hous€ E cas
C8. tire Sprinlded:
C9. Permit byAfidaviE
C10. Priyate Prq/iJen
Cl]. ThrEstpH EuiHirB:
C12" Vege6ion Oearing:
C13. Relatedto DAMAGES INClJRRED 8Y HURRICANE IRMA:
Section A, Pemit Number
Section B. General Permit lnformation
dwo* lsolb tu): D.2. Proje[t Narnedd,yI D3. fuared Value:S /O? DOID '
-o,c.O;w"* rr9" 1q. ri) , '.,1b.4,q\1/"rk Ar"ils. o irj :D.4.d. Totals bJ Area
. D.5; commerd;lso;R: "
Nev,/ Const- lorrpfuoiaE o5n,
A iho{]. (c-*E os.a e o5d)
Alteration $odpbtosci
$ Storiet
# Units
S Bedrooms:
# Bathrooms:
o.1.b,I tivir€:
D.4.hi NorF{iling;
TOTAI.:
D.4.ct Livlng:
D4ci Non-lMng:
TOT**
lnterior:
IOIAI.U*f:
lIIUrr&|t!iE
0
0
00
Ds.a- NEvConst Ds.b.WorkArea [Sq. Ft.)-D5.c Wo,*Area(Sq. lt.)
S Storles:
# Units:
lnterior:
Exterion
TOTAI.:
Exterion
o TorAL 0
WI 1E.1.. Flnal Revie.r,/ Date:E.2. Number of P{ao Sets:510t5
Revlsed oare: 8/10/17 Ve6lol 1.0
&o*
D.1.
..- _...__.1 .. " _ -".-
-Q.4 Reslde4$l$.ftr: , . =.
Ns^? Con*. {6rpka4d.& oatJ
Mdi6(Ii (cd@ a4,.&btb)
pJj.eralion (cd*n aa.cl
EJ. R9./iew Daysi
This is page 1oI3 pages oi i5e Building Permit Application. Pleasi submlt al,3 pages when completed.
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 93 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
.$;."*,zuIIDING PMM]T APPUCATION
2800 N. HoRSESHOE DR., NAPLES, rL 34104 | TEL: (239) 2s2-2400
lnitia Is
Owner, or Agent of Owner, or Contractotls initiols ore tequired.
This is page 2 of 3 pages o1 the 6uild:ng Permit Application. Please submit all 3 pa:es when compteted
NOTICE OF COLLIER COUNTY ADDIT]ONAL REGUTATIONS
NOTICE OF ADDITIONAL RESTRICTIONS: ln addition to the requirements of this permit, there may be
additional restrictions applicable to this property that may be found in the public records of this Cou nty,
and there may be additional permits required from other governmental entit;es such as the
Water Management District State agencies, or Fed,:ral agencies.
WARNING OF POSSIBIE DEED RESTRICTTONS: The and subject to this permit may be subject to deed,
and other restrictions that may limit or impair the landowner's rights. Collier County is not responsible
for the enforcement of these restrictions, nor are Collier County employees authorized to provide legal
or business advice to the public relative to these re!;trictions. The landowner or any applicant acting on
behalf of the landowner is cautioned to seek profe:,sional advice.
WARNING OF WORK lN THE COUNW RIGHT-OF-WAYS: This permit does not authorize construction or
installation of any structure or utility, above or below ground, within any right of way or easement
reserved for access, drainage or utility purposes. Tl is restriction specifically prohibits fencing, sprinkler
systems, landscaping other than sod, signs, water, sewer, cable and drainage work therein. lf such
improvements are necessary, a separate permit fcr that purpose must be obtained from the Growth
Ma nagement Department.
NOICE OF CLEARING RESTRICTIONS: The issuanr;e of a building permit for a single.family dwelling
allows up to one (1) acre of native vegetation to t,e cleared. Clearing more than one (1) acre may be
allowed for accessory structures and requires a separate Vegetation Removal permit. properties
located in the following zoning district overlays may not be allowed to clear one (1) acre: Rural Frihge
Mixed Use District (RFMU), Big Cypress Area of Concern (ACSC), and special Treatment overlay (ST).
There may be additional restrictions related to clearing native vegetation and impacts to wetlands or
protected species found on the property. State and Federal agency permits may be required. Contact
the Growth Management Department's Environmental Services at (239) 252-?4OO for additional
information. lssuance of a Demolition Permit for a structure does not authorize removal of vegetation
beyond the footprint of the structure. A Demo Permit is not a clearing permit.
By initializing, I am acknowledging that I have read and understand this Notice of Collier County
Additional Regulations.
Revlsed Date:8/r0117 Verion 1.0
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 94 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
..#..***BUITIXI\IG PERMTAPNPqTION
2800 N. HORSESHOE DR., NAPLES, FL 34104 | IEL: (239) 252-24OO
s
Ow Agen of Owner
, ACKNOWTEDGEMENT OF COLLIER COUNTY REGUI-ATIONS
Application i5 hereby made to obtain a permit to do the work and installations as indicated. I certify that no work or installation has
commenced bribr to the issuance of a permit and that atl wort will be performed to meet the standards of all laws regulating
construaion In ihis lurisdiction. The permit or application fee may have additional fees imposed for failing to obtain permits prior to
commencement of construction.
The approved pJrmit and/or permit application expires if not commenced within 180 days from the date of issuance. The permittee
further understands that only licensed contradors may be employed and that the structure will not be used or occupied until a
certificate of occupancy is issued. By siSning this permit application, I agree that I have been retained by the owner/permittee to
provide contrirctln6 services for the trade for which I am listed. Furthermore, it is my responsibility to notifu the Building Plan Review
and lnspection Division should I no longer be the contractor responsible for providing said contracting services. I further agree that I
understand the review and issuing of this permit does not exempt me mplyinB with allCounty Codes and ordinances. lt
is furth th rty owner/permittee is the owner of it.
Sign:
e of county of
The foreSoin8 instrument was aclno\,yledged before me this The fore8oing instrument was acknowledged before me this
,2 day of .fr, r or,zot{-W ,4 4 a"v ot
(name of person) who i or who has (name of person) who i t6-.-6ii"lty---iiin-id--'dorr^lhoh",
(type produced
of identification) as identificr entifi cation) as identifi cation MY COMmSSTON l
f/aii,h .A//r", stateot F/o*iab the County of
RrlYL
r;20G995
EXPIRES March 13.2019
t kr.r.fb:n\5s,.o .m
Notary Signature:ry SiSnature:
Notary (Seal)Notary (Seal)
For change of contractor, please provide the following: Permit Number:
Email: Phone:
per Frorida statutes 713.13s " "",,.":,o.t"'::;t":"tf#tii:H:l:HffiL'I or improvements totarins more than
52,500, with certairi exceptions. For A"/C Repairs or Replacements a notice of commencement is required for improvements more than
or equalto 57,500. The applicant shall file with the issuing authority priorto the first inspection either a certified copy ofthe recorded
NOC or a notari.ed ttatement that the NOC has been filed for recording, alonS with a copy thereof. ln order to comply with the state
requirement, permits will be placed in inspection hold until proof of the NOC is filed with the building permitting and inspection
department. The issuinB authority shall not perform or approve subsequent inspections until the applicant files by mail,
facsimile, hand deliuery, email or any other means such as certified copy with the issuing authority.
WARNING To owNER: YouR FAILURE To REcoRD A NoIcE oF COMMENCEMENT MAy
RESUTT IN YOUR PAYING TWICE FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO YOUR PROPERTY. IF YOU INTEND
TO OBTAIN FINANCING, CONSULT WITH YOUR LENDER OR AN ATTORNEY BEFORE RECORDING
YOUR NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT. A NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT MUST BE RECORDED
AND POSTED ON THE JOB SITE BEFORE THE FIRST INSPECTION,
rsonally known
JEFFERY VJ RAYLof
cor\rllnssroN, FF206995
EXPTRES M.rch 13.?019
,!:
N
Revased Dare:8/10/17 Ve6ion 1.0 Ihis is page 3 of 3 pates ofthe Buildlnt Permit Appllcation, please submit all 3 paSes when .ompleted.
C//;,.,
20)t-by
produced
-
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 95 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Permit Application Status - CityView Portal
Permit Application Status
In order to schedule rnspections, you need to be signed in.
GMD Public Portal
Page 1 of2
appllcation Numb€r:
Appllcatlon Typ.l
Application Status:
Property Owne/s full Nam.:
Category or Wo.k:
Ocorpancy Cod€:
Description or Work:
PRBO2o170936a49
Auildhg
Explr€d
MARQUEZ, RUOOLPH ] & DORA
Residential, One and Two Famlly New or Guest Hous€
REIIOVE AND REPTACE TITE ROOF
2322 54th AVE NE
09/2912017
09/29/201,7
oTtrStzotS
Apglication Date:
Issued Date:
Expa.ation oate:
1-2 Family or Comm:
Property Owner:
contrador: Historical:
Qualifier:
MARQUEZ. RUDOLPH J & DORA, AddTess:2322 54TH AVE NE
MARQUEZ, RUOOLPH .] & OORA, AddTess:2322 54TH AVE NE
WOZNIAK, PETER EDWARD, Address:2505 FORESI PARKWAY NORIH ,
Phone:(877) 844-8300, Licensee * 1CC20170002114
llllDse-staur
FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES !!C, Address:4505 9TB fREET EAST, Phone
(877) 8,!r-8300, Star€ R€9 *'s CCC1331225, Ucensee *
1CC20170002115
Llcense Status
Permits (Cllck to Sec Revlews)
srrudur.l Fee - Residential
AFplic.tion (Viluation
=<$s000)
150.00 $50.00 09/29/20t1
$100.00 ,100.00 09/29/ZOL7
Strudural fee Residentlal -t60.00 $60.00 09/29/24t7
BCAI $3_ 15 $3.1s 09/29/20r7
DAPR Surcharge $2.10 $2.10 09/29/2Or7
Change of Contractor or sub $40.00 $40.00 04/19/2018
Reinspedion F€e for Buildi.g t65.00 $65.00 04/19/20rA
$100.00 1100.00 04/t9/20rA
J420.25 t420_25 lo.oo
PlEAsE DO NOT SUBI'!IT ANY PAYMENTS UNTIL A COLUER COUNTY PAYMEITT SUP 1S DISIRIAUTED
http://cvportal.colliergov.neVCityViewWeb/PermiVStatus?permitl d=219472 31112019
l
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 96 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Permit Application Status - Cityview Portal Page 2 of 2
169 - ory-lnlFlashinq 3/r/20rA 3/7/20rA 03/01/20tA
Jim Meisberqer ((239) 292-3954) send Em.il
Corection r:
Status:
oate Status Changed:
Comments:
03to1t20La
tnspector Notes: No Afiidavit or permit
Post€d o. Job gte. FBC 107.3.1 .rCM.
Documents & Imag6
http://cvportal.colliergov.net/CityViewWeb,/Permit/Status?permitl d:219472 3/12019
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 97 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
JOB ADDRESS: 2322 54th AVE NE
JOB DESCRIPTION: REMOVE AND REPLACE TILE ROOF
2322 54th AVE NE
ZONE;
FCC CODE:
CONSTRUCTION CODE: 0218
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
PERMIT
BLOCK
ELEVATIO^N:
SECTION-TOWNSHIP-RANGE: 6-48-28
JOB VALLIET $20 ,000.00
PRBD2017093684901
BY:
COA:
PERMIT TYPE: RO
APPLIED DATE: 09-29-17
PHONE:
TOTAL RES SQFT: 0 TOTAL COMM SOFT: 0
APPROVAL DATE: 09-29-17
RIGHT
OWNER INFORMATION:
MARQIJ'EZ, RI'DOLPH J & DORA
2322 54TH AVE NE
NAPLES, FL 34I20-
REAR;LEFT:
WATER:
NOTICE: PRIOR TO THE REMOVAL OF ASBESTOS PRODUCTS OR THE DENIOLITION OF A STRUCTURE, FEDERAL
AND STATE LAWS REQUIRE THE PERMITTEE (EITHER THE OWNER OR CONTRACTOR) TO SUBMIT A NOTICE OF
THE INTENDED WORK TO THE STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION (DEP). FOR MORE
TNFORMATTON, CONTACT DEp AT (239) 344-s600.
PERMIT #:
ISSUED:
N{,{STER #:
SETBACKS FRONT:
SEWER:
CONTACT NAME:
CONTACT PHONE:
JOB PHONE:
CONTRACTOR INFORMATION:
CERTIFICATE #:
LOT:SI1BDTVISION #:
FLOOD MAP:
FOLIO #: 38960200006
Per Collier County Ordinance No. 2002-01, as it may be amended, all work flust comply with all applicable laws, codes, ordinances, and any additional
stipulations or conditions ofthis permit. This peftnit expires if work authorized by the permit is not commenced within six (6) months ftom the date of
issuance ofthe permit. Additional fees for failing to obtain permits prior to tle commencement ofconstuction may be imposed. Permittee(s) further
understands that any contractor that may be employed must be a licensed coltractor aod that the structure ftust not be used or occupied until a
Cenificate ofOccupancy is issued.
In additior to the conditions of this permit, there may be additional restrictions applicable to this property that may be found in
the public records of this coutrty, and there may be additional permits required from other governmental entities such as lrater
management districts, state agencies, or federal agencies.
WARNING TO OWNER: YOUR FAILURE TO RECORD A NOTICE OF
COMMENCEMENT MAY RESULT IN YOUR PAYING TWICE FOR IMPROVEMENTS
TO YOUR PROPERTY. IF YOU INTEND TO OBTAIN FINANCING, CONSULT WITH
YOUR LENDER OR AN ATTORNEY BEFORE RECORDING YOUR NOTICE OF
COMMENCEMENT.
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 98 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
c,iE Coutttjt
RECEIVED
APR I 0 2018
l)"\? f
2600 N. Horseshoe Dr
Naples. FL 34104
Main 239-252-2400: Direct 239-252-2493
cancellahonsaMExlension@colliercountyfl . govGro.dh MarEgement Departrnenl
EXTENSION OR REACTIVATION FORTVI
Date of Request:
-....-Permit No,
PROPERW INFORMATION:
Property/ob Address:a
Parcel/Tax Folio No.:o
o
Company Name
Qualifier Name:
EmailAddress:
Primary Permit No, (if applicable):
FORM COMPLETED BY TYPE OF QUAL|F|ER: {r*r,"rro, Q
qUAtIFIER INFORMATION:
Owner-Euilder Design Professional
LLC_
Phone:Q44- rq4- gD
Justification {or extension request: .
Number of previous requests: fuHas work commencedl Qv"r Qn
Qu r State License No.:cc/
o
Type ofldetiication p
Extension/Reactiva6on
D APPROVED , Extension Period _ days
?
(Printed Name of Oualifi er/Owner-Builder)
, who i5 perronally known or p ced identific.ton _
f Florida)
(Print. Type, or Stamp Commissioned Name of Notary)
OEFICE U5E ONLY
a ner'Builder ure)
by {Qualifa Namel
EXPIRES March 13.2019
J
Staff lnitials
Pate I of 1
F .r*a ?49
Aabr
NOTARY
State of FI,ORIDA
CouotyofCOLU€R
The forego,rg ;nstrument was SWORN TO {or AFFIRMEO)and SUBSCRIgED before me this _ day of _ ZO_
! DENIED - Reason:
extentionandreactivation 01-16 2018 v2
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 99 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
G.o^ri' IkBgcnErr Dq-fn nl
BUI1DING PERMTT APPUCATION
28OO N. HORSESHOE DR., NAPLES, Ft 34104 | TEL: (239)252-2400
Pbae the hr-nnJdirls to thl.sOiedions:
A1. Permit f /sdrbpudl 0 -?o 1
8,1 . Primary Permit f t/oiyl PR 8D20170936509 82 Master Permitf fa.'yi
O I & 2 Famity dudlineffol^f,|house Q Reiiential 3 or more units^4uttifamiv
Q C-t "a". Q Oedgn erofesdonaf
Contrrtor lnformatbn
8.12. License fr
8.13. CompanyName:
8.14. QualifierName:
8.15. C-ontadName:
8.16. Comtrany Addr€ss:
Qco--"rcirt
Orrner &rib6
2322 flth ave n6
Naolas FL 34120
8.7. OrrE Narne:
8.8. O^nEr PID.E:
8.9. Subdivisbn:
Lcd/Blody'uniL
8-10- SDP/flJt
8.11. 'Ptfl Filenarne:
Rudolph Marquez
cell 480-272-4563
Golden Gate Estates
Unit 44 N 260FT of TR 5
' q*vd - tu diatg Flean . crt gjlyj!!!jj@!
8.17. cornpany PhorE:
8-1& Far f:
B.19.a. "Ernail1:
B-19.b. "Email2:
marquezrm@yahoo.com
D"b Nt ue Enrnl{ osptii-y@1tod iprtu.
Section A. Fern$t Number
Secion C. Apy'iration lnldrtstion
CL Srbonffi.s:
C2. PermitType:
C3. Fire Permit Type:
C4. Condnrtir Type:
C5. Ocurpancy:
C5. Water Service:
C7. S€\ rer Service:
O ELEC trIRUMB
Roof
E MEGI EIR6f E Septic El Lo\./Voh€e tr Stutters E ElEcffrom horse EGas
Residontial, 1 & 2 Family New or Guest Hou
C& Fire sp.inkl€d:
C9. Permit bry Arffdavit:
ClO Pri\6te P.orld€r:
C11. Ihrghold guilding:
C12. Veaebtion Oearing:
C,13. RCIAICd tO DAMA6TS II']CUFRED 8Y H1JRRICANE IRMA @ve' Qruo
Sedion D. Prdecr lrfsrfiation
D.1. Dg.ription of Wo.t lpw,x'.1t/,tr. D.2. Projed tleme ftdryI Marquez Residence
D.4. Resuential 5q. FL:
Ntrv Crnst lc-r'dlt a4 a a aarrJ
&tlit,\ lco& D.'. aa1'b)
l{rr,atbn.(WAacl
D5. Cornmercial Sq. Ft.:
N6 , Consl lcrrplE a5a & a5b)
Additifir tc6d.rD5.a a olh)
Alt6rati6 fcarlfi?an,
D.4.a. Neh/ Cor6t D.4.b. Wqk tua (sq. ft.)
o4.b,i Living:
o..ht NcGlMn$ _
IOTAI: o
D.4.c. Wdt Area (S+ Ft.)
o4.c.i Living:
o4.ci Nc.Flivirts: _
TOTAL: o
O.4.d. Totak hry Arla
tolnuiS 0
tunriElti!: 0
# Stori6:
C UriE:
f 8.dr6rnt:
# Bathrooms:
0.5.a. Ne+,/ Const 05.b. WqI Area (5q. Ft.)
lnterior:
ErHor: _TOTAL.: 0
D.5.c Work Area {Sq. Ft)
lntenbr: _
Efterica: _
I[nA! 0
f Sto.ie.:
{ Urits:
Section E stafl Section
E.1. Final R6ri5,./ Date;E.2. Nu.nber of Plan Sets:E.3- Re{ew Days:1510L5
R!vi!.d D.t i8/10/17 Vcttktn 1.0 This is page 1 of 3 paSs of the guildin8 Permit Appli.rtion. Pl€ate submil allf paSerwhen completed
-18",-",*,*
-^,^.-a----
8.3. EuidirE Type:
8.4. Pennitt€e Tlfe:
Property lnbrmatbn
85. Parcsl/Folio #:
8.6. lob Street Addre.s:
D.3. OedaredValue: S 20,0O0
1
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 100 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
ffi,y:!Repoft Title: Code Case Details
CaseNumber: CEM|S20180015337
cEMts201800 t 5337
Misconduct
Priority Normal
JackGumph
Jurisdiction Collier County
Origin Complaint
Detail Description On the date of December 10, 2018, ( J. Gumph) received the written complaint through
Contractor Licensing Office, Customer Service from homeowner, Josephine & George Reyes,
4484 Dunlin Ct., Naples, FL against the roofing contractor. The contractor is listed as Florida
Roof Services LLC (877-844-8300). The homeowner stated that a contract was signed on
312512018 with a deposit paid.
Location Comments 4484 Dunlin Ct., Naples, FL 341 19 (Folio # 56105511901)
Status lnvestigation
Date & Time Entered 121'i.212018 1 0:54:36 AM
Entered By JackGumph
Case Disposition Case Pending
Propedy
Complainant REYES, GEORGE E & JOSEPHINE C
Contractor FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES LLC
Business Management & Budget Office
Dale 31112019 2:37i38 PM
Case Number:
Case Type:
lnspector:
s610551 1901
1
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 101 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Code Case Details Execution Date 3/1/2019 2:37:38 PM
Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments
Preliminary lnvestigation JackGumph 12112t2018 12t12t2018 Needs
lnvestigatio
n
12t5t2018
On the date of December 10, 2018, (J.
Gumph) received the written complaint
through Contractor Licensing Offi ce,
Customer Service from homeowner,
Josephine & George Reyes, 4484 Dunlin Ct.,
Naples, FL against the roofing contractor. The
contractor is listed as Florida Roof Servrces
LLC (877-844-8300). The homeowner stated
that a contract was signed on or about
3/2512018 with deposits paid in the amount of
$28,3p0.
lnformation supplied by the homeowners
indicate that they hired 'Florida Roof Services
LLC" (Florida Roof) on or about 3/2512018 fot
a total of $42,600. The homeowner paid a
deposit at that time of $14,200. On
05/09/2018, the old roof tiles were removed
and the'underlayment' put down. The
inspection on the underlayment failed
(subsequently found to be dated
06/07/2018).There have been water leaks
occuning after the undedayment installed.
The company came back and said they 'fixed"
the problem however the leaks still exist.
Homeowner, George Reyes spoke to
company representative, Jeff Rayl in October,
2018 who told him the company would come
to the home to resolve. There has been no
work since that time with communication with
Florjda Roof being unsuccessful.
I loc€ted Permit # PR8D20180529401,
Applied for on 05/01/20'18, lssued on
05/2412018 and listed as STATUS: EXPIRED
The contractor is listed as Peter Edward
Wozniak, (dba) Florida Roof Services LLC
(877-844-8300), Certified Roofing Contractor,
# CCC1331226. As noted in the permit, the
"Dry-ln' lnspection has FAILED on
o6t07t2018.
Business Management & Budget Ofllce 2
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 102 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Code Case Details Execution Date 3/1/201 9 2:37:38 PM
Desc Assigned Required Outcome Comments
Cont. lnvestigation JackGumph 12113t2018 12/13t2018 Complete 12t13t201A
On the date of December 12, 2018, I (J.
Gumph) traveled to 4484 Dunlin Ct., Naples,
FL. I observed the home to be a single family
dwelling. I met vvith homeowner, Ms.
Josephine Reyes. Ms. Reyes showed me to
several areas inside the home where I
photographed water stains in the ceiling
reportedly from the leakage of the roof work
previously done by Florida Roof. I explained
to Ms. Reyes that the permit was now expired
and that I would be contacting the roofing
company to re-activate the permit and
complete the work.
On the date of December 13, 2018. I placed a
telephone callto the phone number on record
for Qualifier, Peter Edward Wozniak, (dba)
Florida Roof Services LLC (877-844-8300).
There was no answer and I left a message
reference the expired permit, to re-contact
me.
On this same date, ldrafted a Notice of Non-
Compliance for the violation of Building Code,
Expired Permit. I emailed the notice to the
company under the email for Jeft Rayl at
iwrayl@yahoo.com.
Cont lnvestigation JackGumph 1t2t2019 1t2t2019 Complete 11212019 I (J Gumph) reviewed permit and
found no change. Vvill need to attempt contact
again with contractor.
JackGumph 1t10t2019 1t10t2019 Complete 1/9/2019: On the date of January 9, 2019, I
placed a telephone callto the phone number
on record for Qualifier, Peter Edward
Wozniak, (dba) Florida Roof Services LLC
(877-844-8300). There was no answer and I
left a message reference the expired permit,
to re-contact me.
Business Management & Budget Office 3
Completed
continues...
Cont. lnvestigation
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 103 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Code Case Details Execution Date 3/112019 2:37:38 PM
Desc Assiqned Required Completed Outcome Comments
Cont. lnvestigation JackGumph 1115t2019 Complete 01t15t2019
I (J. Gumph) have had follow up contact with
the homeowner who related they have not
been contacted by Florida Roof Services
about completing therr roof project There rs
still leak damage from the underlayment that
has FAILED inspection.
As I have had no response trom Peter
Edward Wozniak, (dba) Florida Roof Services
LLC, I did on this date ofJanuary 15, 2019,
drafted a 'Notice of Hearing'to Mr. Wozniak
(Qualifier) to answer the complaint of the
EXPIRED permit and FAILED inspection. The
letter was sent certified mail (7017 0530 0000
8339 6286) to Peter Edward Wozniak, (dba)
Florida Roof Services LLC, 2605 Forest
Parkway North, Largo, FL 3377 1.
continues
Cont. lnvestigation JackGumph 1t15t2419 1t15t2019 Complete 01115t2019
On the date ofJanuary 15, 2019, I 9J Gumph)
placed a telephone call to homeowner, Ms.
Josephine Reyes to alert to the issuance of
the Notice of Hearing to Qualifier, Peter
Edward Wozniak. At the time, Ms. Reyes
related that at the present time, Florida Roof
Services is on her roof doing work. I
immediately travelled to the Reyes home,
4484 Dunlin Ct., Naples, FL where I observed
two (2) men working on the home roof. I
identified the workers as Juan Gonzalez and
Abdiel Rodriguez who stated they worked for
Florida Roof Servic€s. Mr. Gonzalez related
that they were sent to the home by Jeff Rayl
(Florida Roof Services)to complete repairs for
the re-inspection of the underlayment. I
attempted phone contact to Mr. Rayl (727417
-2719) at a phone number supplied by Juan
Gonzalez but went to voice mail.
It should be noted that research of Permit #
PR8D20180529401 indicated an EXPIRED
Permit (dated 1112012018). Noting that there
was work ongoing. I issued and posted a Stop
Work Order for working on an expired permit.
Cont. lnvestigation JackGumph 1t23t2019 Complete 112312019. Researched the USPS database
for delivery for # 7017 0530 0000 8339 6286
Found attempted delivery, "No Authorized
Recipient Available". A slip \,,/as left at door.
Cont. lnvestigation JackGumph 1t28t2019 1t28t2019 Complete
Business Management & Budget Of{lce 4
1t15t2019
1t23t2019
112812019: Researched the USPS database
for delivery for # 7017 0530 0000 8339 6286.
Found attempted delivery, "No Authorized
Recipient Available". A slip was left at door.
- on this date, a RE-Delivery was scheduled.
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 104 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Code Case Details Execution Date 3/1/2019 2:37:38 PM
Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Com ments
Cont. lnvestigation JackGumph 2,1t2019 2/1t2019 Complete 113112019 Researched the USPS database
for delivery for # 7017 0530 0000 8339 6286.
Research revealed successful delivery. USPS
Tracking sheet attached to the file.
Cont. lnvestigation 2t5t2019 2t5t2019 Complete 2/5/2019: Received the USPS database for
delivery (returned 'GREEN CARD') for # 7017
0530 0000 8339 6286. Research revealed
successful delivery signed by contractor,
Peter E. Wozniak. USPS 'GREEN CARD'
attached to the file.
Cont. lnvestigation JackGumph 2t20t2019 2t20t2019 Complete 2t20t2019
On this date I (J. Gumph)did observe the
perm( (#PRBD20180529401) was re-
activated this date. Icontacted Ms. Desiree
Suarez, daughter of the homeowner to notify.
Ms. Suarez related information that the
company had come back to the home and
installed some new underlayment a "couple
weeks ago" (still under a Stop Work Order for
Expired Permit). She related they still have
not scheduled a re-inspection of the FAILED
original underlayment. ladvised that no
inspections could take place with an expired
permit.
Cont. lnvestigation JackGumph 2t27 t2019 2t27t2019 2t27 t2019.
Research revealed that the permit (#
PRBD20180529401) was reactivated and
issued an Extension on lhe dale of 212012019
lnvestigation JackGumph 3/20t2019 Pending
Violation Description Status Entered Comments
4.2 Misconduct State Certified
Contractors
Open 12112t2018 $0
Title Reason Compliance Fine/Day Condition
Business Management & Budget Office 5
JackGumph
Complete
THIS CASE IS SCHEDULED FOR THE
CONTRACTOR LICENSING BOARD
MARCH 20, 2019 FOR Reyes, 4484 Dunlin
Ct - Contractor lS Florida Roof Services LLC
Corrected Amount
Result
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 105 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Cott*txy
Growih Management Deparh-nent
/.Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
Phone - 239-252-2437
Fax - 239 -252-2469
PRETIMINARY COMPLAINT FORM
Please complete this form to the best of your abilities. Also include with this form any documents you would like to
be reviewed as evidence forthis case. This can include Contracts, Copies of Checks, Permits, Liens, etc.
rO
Home address .rtir.., C-+-.llt"-L
Street City zip
Email R.-Z des I cr'L . C{>i'a1
Telephone a Ar't>
Address of Complaint 8 f,)"...\.,, L+ N Vs ?L Lill
Street City
rUi(,_STt-.tla- R*P S"L-L(-
State
?A.- O. r,xz^;(*. r J.+f, Er.y u
Contractor/Person in Charge
S+a.- QZ+- ccc t 13 | ZzU
License #: Lrc 2Dl1 D cr> 2 rl
-J a+-+V*
l erepnone
1J-l- Ltll-.>1tq
[ll- g{q- g:Do
tle..:i,t €"L-' 111->'i t- l'?11
Date of Contract )I
D"ul.l r' bu.ilE.le./ 6., Q',r-t, {;,r ylo Z - r+ c,L,+,-,.,..-+t
J.*l L 1l fbi,L U' 4 lco'wi<--.g w+.,,-,.<A. +1*t.*l.,-l-. --+ M?!l
v-,* ().* i^;g**i-a.JL-l \'c 4*-.f;.t-
s'l*\
h4,<- C-'*.-.),r-!. ,1".)
-,t:-t.le
,{ ,l*t..1 ( o"y- li\,-i+S+r,tt
lq>w 4+1_--.
(*^-\-nt-A rb+ t^)l- * ;( ;t
l) ?t")
.dilJ{ A
\l 1211..,-- 1,. L, >
a-A V- 94"t
---lt1
x t^*.- l.---l - =trv<, \" -/]+(.?l
D L.^L4 .f
Qt- <.z-\ $hish +Lr- -o*. H- als' F,,
D.+a-d-.<r'
aJ insleri iz.)
L. r,ocr-\A DriL /. t.-t-t-^ S i"..s tL..t-<,a- Co aJ h-t,-.L l.,
rryj;E.Wc,J-^'-t Lt^.- .t&a
DF+ e*.,\ a-b
i ^1 !,v\- +z..'--S
Ar,<*n--*Ys +,r-,|.:.e-.L +1*-lY"<-
JP !o-+q 2tr.
h.I,J
'3;P L.x4
r15.'14^q
,'nc*,
I
SIG NATU RE 1
PRELIMINARY COMP rNT FORM REV 4112/18J.-++f..',wr.,.-t t r'> a-F'rv--'D^-. tr .^-r. .\z ,WL .{.ov-', a^., .va "** ('**-'L---LU
Complainant's Name:Josr+l.,, ^* . + Ce.cr1n- P-,r*-t Date:
0
Siate
COMPLAINT INFORMATION:
zip
Company Name:
COMPLAINT DETAILS (ATTACH ADDITIONAL SHEETS IF NECESSARY)
t-
t--r
L4- WL.a- A w-..+-)
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 106 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Directions:
Cort,,tty
GDlrrh l,lrBqe.rsr Depa-trrEd
m05t complete Pleote folbw llP
8.2. Master Pemiit f fforyf
@fr a z rarnitya*a[ns,/rrn',],o.lr" O v,o,,"rra"nlt"** trolr* O
(fc-*"oo" O oesign erofessio.ar
BUITDING PERMIT APPUCATION
2800 N. HORSESHOE DR., NAPLES, FL 34104 | rEti (239)252-2400
lnstruct-Dns to comphte thi5
* troiryl
S3. BufldingTyre
&4, Permittee fFei
PrDperty hformation
8.5. Parcel/Folio #:
8.6. lob Street Address:
k e9
/] /2t
Cont6ctor lrrbrmatbn
8.12. License *
8.13. Company Name:
8.14. Quali,fierName:
8.15. Contact Name:
B-15. CompanyAddress:
'Optidnl - k-di d&g Ftefirn6o!1CTNVEW Pdlol.
O EIEC EPLUMB E MECH
C2. Permit Type
C.3. Fire Permit Type:
C.4. Construction Type:
C.5- Occupancy:
C6. Water Se ,/i.e:
C7. Sewer Service:
0.1. Description ofWork lpoeide&?b\t . D-2. Project Name fy'aq,l:
tusid€ntial 3+ units/vluhi-la mily Commeroal
O Owner Builder
aclt'33t 9ct-,floi o(a Ra€sztli,z<
511a,71an-, Ft .?{23*
8.17. Company Phone: <7r- 6{c/ - q?
8.18. Fax f:
B-19.a. "Email 1:
9.19.b. "Email2:
l"U,ot;6e frrqsl os Fri,aycottoct ncthd.
E S€ptic E l-o,Voltate E Shutters E EtIcT hom houle EGas
c8. Fire Sprinkled:
C9. Permit byAffdavit:
C1O Private Prq,ridec
C11. Threshold Building:
C12. Vetetatioo Oearing:
C,13. Related to DAN4AGES INCURREDBY HURRICANE IRMA
D.3. DeclaredValue: 5 cb
O*o
_D.4. Re5identhlsq ft: . ,.
NewConst. (Coa,rbte A4o & oa.b.l
Mditon lcdn*re D4o. & o 1.n)
Alteration fcrynpbk oac)
D.sj &inmerdalsi. tu
Ne:N CffsL lcdn*E O.to. & Dib)
Mditio,r lcoq*E D.Sa & D-Sb )
Alteratjon /Ca'nplere a5c/
D.Aa. Ne\ ,Consl D4"b. WdkAEs{&. FL)
D 4.b.i Ljving:
o 4 b.i Nm]MnB _
TOTAL O
O.4.e Wo*AI€a (Sq. Ft)
D.4.ci. Living:
O.4-c.i Non-lMng: _
TOTAIT o
0.4.d. TsEls by &ea
I(,TAUunEr 0
TOIANdltJis: 0
g Stories:
# Units:
f Bedroorns:
I Bathroomg
Ds-a Nalrconst D5!. WorkArEa (Sq. Ftl
lnterioc
Exterior: _TOTAL O
DS.c WorkArea (5q. tt)
lnterior: _
Exterior:
TOTAL 0
{Stories:
I Units:
E.1. FlnalRe\aee Date E.2- Number ofPlan Sets: _ E.3. RBr'iew Days:1510 15
Revrsed 0ater 1l129/17 v2 This is page 1 of 3 pages of the Surlding permit Application. please submil all 3 pages when completed
8.7. owner Name:
8.8. O^ner Phone:
8.9. SubdMsion:
LoVE ock/Unit
8,10. SDP/Pu:
8.11.'PLfl Filename:
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 107 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
o*sg...,BUII.DING PERMTT APPUCATION
2800 N. HORSESHOE DR., NAPLES, FL 34104 I TEL: (239) 252-2400
NOTICE OF COTLIER COUNTY ADDITIONAL REGULATIONS
NOTICE OF ADOITIONAL RESTRICTTONS: ln addition to the requirements of this permit, there may be
additional restrictions applicable to this property that may be found in the public records of this County,
and there may be additional permits required from other governmental entities such as the Water
Management District, State agencies, or Federal agencies.
WARN,NG OF POSSIBtE DEED RESTRICTIONS: The land subject to this permit may be subject to deed,
and other restrictions that may limit or impair the landowner's rights. Collier County is not responsible
for the enforcement of these restrictions, nor are Collier County employees authorized to provide legal
or business advice to the public relative to these restrictions. The landowner or any applicant acting on
behalf ofthe landowner is cautioned to seek professional advice.
WARNING OF WORK lN THE COUNTY RIGHT-OF-WAYS: This permit does not authorize construction or
installation of any structure or utility, above or below ground, within any right of way or easement
reserved for access, drainage or utility purposes. This restriction specifically prohibits fencing, sprinkler
systems, landscaping other than sod, signs, water, sewer, cable and drainage work therein. lf such
improvements are necessary, a separate permit for that purpose must be obtained from the Growth
Management Department.
NOTICE OF CLEARING RESTRICTIONS: The issuance of a building permit for a single-family dwelling
allows up to one (1) acre of native vegetation to be cleared. Clearing more than one (1) acre may be
allowed for accessory structures and requires a separate Vegetation Removal Permit. Properties
located in the following zoning district overlays may not be allowed to clear one (1) acre: Rural Fringe
Mixed Use District IRFMU), Big Cypress Area of Concern (ACSC), and Special Treatment Overlay (ST).
There may be additional restrictions related to clearing native vegetation and impacts to wetlands or
protected species found on the property. State and Federal agency permits may be required. Contact
the Growth Management Department's Environmental Services at (239) 252-2400 for additional
information. lssuance of a Demolition Permit for a structure does not authorize removal of vegetation
beyond the footprint of the structure. A Demo Permit is not a clearing permit.
WORK tN THE SPECIAL FIOOD HAZARD AREA: Be advised that Substantial Damage/Su bstantial
lmprovement requirements will apply to structures located in the Special Flood Hazard Area with
Finished Floor Elevations below the Base Flood Elevation.
By initialing, I am acknowledging that I have read and understand this Notice of Collier County
Additional Regulations.
lnitials
Ownet or Agent oI Owne/s or Controctor's initiols ore required
BPv 11.29-2017 v2 This is page 2 of 3 pa8es of the Building Permit Application Plea!e 5ubmit all 3 pa8€s when completed'
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 108 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
_rf _
roduced identification (tYP of identifi
SE B. CO ACKNOWLEDGEMENT:
BUII.DING PERMIT APPUCAIION
28OO N. HORSESHOE DR., NAPLES, FL 34104 | IEL: {239) 252'24OO
SECT|ON A. OWNER or AGENT OF OWNER ACKNOWTEDGEMENT. The Contractor may siSn as the Agent of owner so long as
Co r contract with Owner permits such action:2e*/r-bz-r) e /r
ature Owner or nto e.)(Print name of Owner or Agent of Owneri
The fore8oing instrument was acknowledged before me this day oI 20 /i by
AP 4?(name of person) who rs pe r who _has
p
/t+-n u,.i af
ature of Cont
The fore8oing ins ument was acknowledged before me this day of
/efur ./^hzh)cl3
(Print name of Contractor)
lname ol person) who 1y'$ly known
zo/9 at
n me, or who
--has
produced identification (iden n
NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT INFORMATION
per Florida Statutes 713.135 a Notice of Commencement INOC) is required for construction of improvements totaling more than
52,500, with certain exceptions. For A/C Repairs or Replacements a dotice of commencement is required for improvements more than
or equal to S7,SOO. The applicant shall file with the issuing authority prior to the first inspection either a certified copy of lhe .ecorded
NOC or a notarized statement that the NOC has been filed for recordin8, along with a copy thereof. ln order to comply with the state
requirement, permits will be placed in inspection hold until proof of the NOC is filed with the buildin8 permittin8 and inspectron
department. The issuing authority shall not perform or approve subsequent inspections until the applicant files by mail, Facsimile,
hand delivery, email or any other means such as certified copy with lhe issuing authority
WARNING TO OWNER: YOUR FAILURE TO RECORD A NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT MAY
RESULT IN YOUR PAYING TWICE FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO YOUR PROPERTY. IF YOU INTEND
TO OBTAIN FINANCING, CONSULT WITH YOUR LENDER OR AN ATTORNEY BEFORE RECORDING
YOUR NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT. A NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT MUST BE RECORDED
AND POSTED ON THE JOB SITE BEFORE THE FIRST INSPECTION.
Rev 1l-29.2017 v2 This is page 3 of I pages ol the Euilding Permit Application. Pleaie submil .ll 3 pa8es when completed.
nown to
:i:,::'.'."s.:. JEFFERY W RAYL
MY COr,rMrSSrON r FF2C$395
ExerRES Ma'ch 13*fl4
Ir-dr'i.;1t.i,Er :.n.
EXPIRES t lsrch 13. 20rg
, ri,r,.lj!.r:1slY,.! :s-
Rt:
FF REJ w A YL
hl oc r,t SS gd,f 995206
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF COILIER COUNTY REGULATIONS
Application is hereby flade to obtain a permit to 66 ths 1/e1l 36d installations as indicated. I certify that no work or installation has
commenced prior to the issuance of a permit and that all work will be performed lo meet the standards of all laws .egulating
construction in thig jurisdiction The permit or application fee may have additional fees imposed for failing to obtain permits prior to
commencement of construction-
The approved permit and/or permit application expires if not commenced within 180 days from the date of issuance. The permittee
further understands that onlv licensed contractors may be employed and that the structure will not be used or occupied until a
certificate of occupanry is issued. By signing this permit application, I a8ree that lhave been retained by the owner/permittee to
provide contracting services for the trade for which I am listed. Furthermore, it is my responsibility to notifY the Building Plan Review
and lnspection Division should I no longer be the contractor responsible for providing said contractinB services. I further agree that I
understand that the review and issuing of this permit does not exerhpt me from complying with all County Codes and Ordinances lt
is further understood that the property owner/pe/mittee is the owner of the permit'
Notei An Owner-Builder must complete sections A and B and the owner-Builder Alfidavit form,
Notary Signature:
i:
Notary SiEnature:
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 109 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
-.4.c,#8",Aovn+W
Growth Management Department
Building Plan Review & lnspection Division
Re-Roofing Mitigation Package
To be filled out and included with all Residential Re-Roofingapplications
For the purpose ofthis document, sections cited are from Florida Building Code Sixth Edition (20171, Existing
Building.
Secondary Water garrier: Section 705.7,2
A secondary water barrier shall be installed using one of the following methods when roof covering is removed
and replaced:
FOR: Asphalt shingles, Metal roof shingles, Mineral-surfaced roll roofing, Slate and slate type shingles,
Wood shingles, Wood shakes, Metal roof panels, Photovoltaic Shingles:
Outside the High-Velocity Hurricane Zone (Collier County). (Preose CIRCLE 7, 2, ot 3 below, to indicote
the uncierloyment occordinq to the attdched FBC Res 6th Ed. Chg Toble R905.1.1.):
Underlayment shall comply with Section R905.1.1 of the Florida Building Code,
Residential.
1 2 or
Specify Secondary Water Barrier:
Manufacturer P roduct approval number
FOR:ay or Concrete Tile
Shall comply with the manu facturer instructions or the FRSA/TRl Florida High Wind Concrete and
) Clay Roof Tile lnstallation Manual,56 Edition{r
Specify Seconda ry Water Barrier;
Exceptions:
1.
Re-Roof Mitigation Peckage 01'29'2018 v4
z
Roof slopes < 2:12 having a continuous roof system shall be deemed to comply with
Section 706.7.2 requirements for a secondary water barrier'
c|ayandconcretetileroofsystemsinstalledasrequiredbytheFloridaBuildingcodeare
deemed to comply with the requirements of section 706'7 2 lor Secondary Water
Barriers.
&JdE HalR(le'r& lr6pedtm DiYiim'2m0 Nqlh tbFe$oeodve' l'@es Fbida 341M'239252'24m 'u$x cdiE.go'r'rct
Page 1 ot 2
p,op"rty aaa,"rr, 4/ 6/ fi " t n /r' a (/y', Permit Number:
fr 'r q,' ,, , ' brl '/;[
Manul$.ufr' Product approval number
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 110 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Re-Roofing Mitigation Package
iv. Any applicable docu ntation specified above.
5t.t{
Sign lder/
Aut d
Print Name of Qualifier/Owner Builder/
Authorized Agent
Re-Roof Mitigation Pack.Se 01-29-2018 v4
Date
Page 2 ol 2
8@l-0!e!necrE
Contractor acknowledges that as required by Florida Building Code Sixth Edition (2017), Existing Building
Section 707.3.2 the structure's Diaphragm will be evaluated and noted within Re-roof affidavit
Roof to wall connections: FBC-E Section 705.8
1. w a s the building permit for the home construction applied for on or after Sefternber 141993?-/'a. YES
-NO
,/
2. lftheanswertoquestionnumber lisYES,thenproceedtosignatureandpermitsubmittal. (Documentation
required substantiating th is application).
3. lftheanswertoquestionnumberlisNO,applicantmustprovidedocumentationforthevalueofthebuilding
(indicote type provided below):
a.
-
Copy of current home insurance summary sheet
b.
-
Copy of latest tax bill or Property AppBiser office webpage for the home
Note: the appraised value ofthe improvement determines the threshold amount.
4. Based on documentation provided, is the value of the building 5300,000 or more?
a. YES_NO_
5. lf the answerto question 4 is NO, proceed to signature and permit submittal.
6. lf the answerto question 4 is YE5, then, willevaluation and connections at prioritized and non-prioritized areas
be completed for 15% of the cost of roof replacement? YES-NO-
(Hurricane Retro-fit affidavit will be required per FBC-E section 705.8 prior to Certificate of Completion and
retro-fit contractor shall be noted on permit)
7. lf the answer to question 6 is NO, provide documentation of the cost of evaluation/installation and indicate
"prioritized" areas in which will be enhanced up to 15% of roof replacement, See 8(a) for additional
requirements. NOTICE: This documentation will be reviewed for appropriateness, since prescriptive methods
of mitigating roof to wall connections provide necessary designs to accomplish roof to wall connection
improvements. Misrepresentation of information above may be construed as a willful codeviolation.
8. An additional 15% of the cost ofthe re-roofing must be spent on enhanced connections,but the mitigation is
not required to exceed that. The roof to wall connections must be enhanced to comply with FBC'E section
706.8. The priorities for upgrading are outlined in section 706.8.7.7. At least 15% shall be provided to the
prioritized elements.
a. These items are required to besubmitted:
i. Permit description to include notation that Mitigation Retro-fit will be installed (Retro-fit work to be
conducted by a residential, building or general contractor)
ii. Sub affirmation form for contractor whom will install retro-fit components
iii. A plan indicating areas to be retro-fitted, connectors used, and fastener requirements,
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 111 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
2017 Flotida Building code - Residential, Sixth Edition
CHAPTER 9
ROOF ASSEMBLIES
SECTION RgO5
REQUIREMENTS FOR ROOF COVERINGS
httDs://codes. iccsafe. o tolo Ub lic/documenUFRC20 1 7/chaDter-9-roof-assemblies
R905.1.1 Underlayment.
Unless otherwise noted underlayment for asphalt shingles, metal roof shingles, mineral-surfaced roll
roofing, slate and slatetype shingles, wood shingles, wood shakes and metal roof panels shall conform
to the applicable standards listed in this chapter. Underlayment materials required to comply with ASTM
D226, D197O, D4869 and D6757 shall bear a label indicating compliance to the standard designation
and, if applicable, type classiflcation indicated in Table R905.1 .1. Underlayment shall be applied and
attached in accordance with Table R905.1 .1 .
Exception: A reinforced synthetic underlayment that is approved as an altemate to underlayment
complying with ASTM D226 fype ll and having a minimum tear strength in accordance with ASTM
D1970 or ASTM D4533 of 20 pounds shall be permitted. This underlayment shall be installed and
attached in accordance with the u nderlayment attachment methods of Table R905. 1 .1 for the applicable
roof covering and slope, except metal cap nails shall be required where the ultimate design wind speed,
V",, equals or exceeds '1 50 mph.
Table R905.1.1(1) Underlayment Types.
Reserved.
TABLE R905.1.1
UNDERLAYMENT TABLE
Roof covering
Section
Roof Slope 2:12
and Less Than 4:12
Underlayment
Underlayment Attachment'Root Slope 4;12 and
Greater Underlayment Underlayment Attachmenf
Asphalt
shingles R905.2
ASTM D226 Type I
or IIASTM D4869
Type ll, lll or
IVASTM D6757
1
ASTM D226 Type IIASTM
04869 Type lVASTi,
D6757
2
ASTM D1970 3 ASTM D,1970
Concrets and Clay
Tile R905.3 See Secl,on R905 3.3
Metal roof shlngleg
R905.4
ASTM D226 Type I
or IIASTM D4869
Type ll. lll or
IVASTM D6757
ASTM D226 Type IIASIM
D4869 Type lV 2
ASTM D1970 3 ASTM D1970 3
Minelal-surfaced
roll roofing R905.5
ASTM 0226 Type I
or IIASTM D4869
Type Il, lll or
IVASTM D6757
1
ASTM D226 Type IIASTM
D4869 Type lV 2
AST[' D1970 3 ASTM D1970 3
slale and slate-
type shingles
R905,5
ASTM D226 Type I
or IIASTM D4869
Type ll, lll or
IVASTM D6757
1 2
ASTM D1970 3 ASTI\,,I D1970 3
Attachment lo: Re-roof Mitigation PackaSe 'January 04, 2018 v2 Page I of2
1
ASTM D226 Type IIASTM
D4869 TYPe lV
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 112 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Roof Covering
Section
RoofSlope 2:12
and Les8 Than 4:12
Underlaymenl
Underlayment Attachmene Roof Slope 4:12 and
Greater Underlaymenl underlayment Attachmenf
ASTM D226 Type I
or IIASTM D4869
Type ll, lll or lV
1
ASTM D226 Type IIASTM
D4869 Type lV 2
Wood shakes
R905.8
ASTM D226 Type IIASTM
D4869 Type lV 2
Metal roof panels
R905.10
ASTM D226 Type I
or ASTM D4869
Type ll, lll or
IVASTM 06757
ASTM D226 Type IIASTM
04859 Type IVASTM
067 57
2
ASTM D1970 3 ASTM D1970 3
ASTM D226 Type I
or ltAsTM M869
Type ll, lll or
IVASTM D6757
1
ASTM D226 rype IIASTM
D4mg Type IVASTM
D6757
2
ASTM D1970 3 ASTM D1970 3
"Underlayment Attachment
1. Roof slopes from two units vertical in 12 units horizontal (17-percent slope), and less than four units vertical
in 12 units horizontal (33-percent slope). Apply a 1g-inch (483 mm) strip of underlayment felt parallel to and
starting at the eaves, fastened sufficiently to hold in place. Starting at the eave, apply 36-inchwide (914 mm)
sheels of underlayment, overlapping successive sheets 19 inches (483 mm), end laps shall be 6 inches and
shall be offset by 6 feet. The underlayment shall be attached to a nailable deck with corrosion-resistant
fasteners with one row centered in the field of the sheet with a maximum fastener spacing of 12 inches (305
mm) 0.c., and one fow at the end and side laps fastened 6 inches (152 mm) o.c. Underlayment shall be
attached using metal or plastic cap nails with a nominal cap diameter of not less than 1 inch. Metal caps
shall have a thickness of not less than 32-gage sheet melal. Power-driven metal caps shall have a minimum
thickness of 0.0'10 inch. Minimum thickness of the outside edge of plastic caps shall be 0.035 inch. The cap
nail shank shall be not less than 0-083 inch for ring shank cap nails and 0.091 inch for smooth shank cap
nails. Cap nail shank shall have a length sufficient to penetrate through the roof sheathing or not less than
3/4 inch into the roof sheathing.
2. Roof slopes of four units vertical in 12 units horizontal (3$percent slope) or greater. Underlayment shall be
applied shingle fashion, parallel to and starting from the eave and lapped 4 inches (5'l mm), end laps shall
be 6 inches and shall be offset by 6 feet. The underlayment shall be attached to a nailable deck with two
staggered rows in the field of the sheet with a maximum fastener spacing of 12 inches (305 mm) o.c., and
one row at the end and side laps fastened 6 inches (152 mm) o.c. Underlayment shall be attached using
metal or plastic cap nails wth a nominal cap diameler of not less than 1 inch. Metal caps shall have a
thickness of not less than 3z-gage sheet metal. Power-driven metal caps shall have a minimum thickness of
0.010 inch, Minimum thickness of the outside edge of plastic caps shall be 0.035 inch. The cap nail shank
shall be not less than 0.083 inch for ring shank cap nails and 0.091 inch for smooth shank cap nails. Cap
nail shank shall have a length sufiicient to penetrate through the roof sheathing or nol less than 3l inch into
the roof sheathing.
3. Roof slopes from two units vertical in 12 units horizontal (17-percent slope) and greater. The entire roof deck
sflall be covered with an approved self-adhering polymer modified bitumen underlayment complying with
ASTM D1970 installed in accordance with both the underlayment manufacturer's and roof covering
manufacturer's installation instructions for the deck material, roof ventilation configuration and climate
exposure for the roof covering to be installed.
Exception: A minimum 4-inch-wide (102 mm) strip ot self-adhering polymer-modified bitumen
membrane complying wilh ASTM D1970, installed in accordance with the manufacturer's instructions for
the deck material, shall be applied over all joints in the roof decking. An approved underlayment in
accordance with Table R905.1 .1 for the applicable roof covering shall be applied over lhe entire roof over
the +inch-wide (102 mm) membrane strips.
Attachment to: Re-roof Mitigation Package - January 04, 2018 v2 Page 2 of 2
Wood shingles
R905.7
Limited lo roof slopes 4112
and Greater
Photovoltaic
Shingle3 R905.17
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 113 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Permit Application Status - CityView Portal Page 1 of 2
GMD Public Poftal
Permit Application status
In orde. to schedur€ hspedions, you oe€d to b€ signed in.
Application Numb.r: PRB020180529401
applicatlonType: Building
ApplicationStatus: InspedionsComm€nced
P.operty Owner's Full Namer REYES, GEORGE E & IOSEPHINE C
Category of workr Alteration
Occupanca Coder Residentlal, On! and Two Family New or Guest House
Description of Work: CONCRETE TILE OVER POLYGLASS IH 5112 PITCH 45
4484 DUNUN CT
Applic.tion Drte: O5l01/2018
Issued Oate: O5/24l2018
Expkation oate: 05/21/2019
l-2 Famlry or Comln: 1'2 ramily
Quali6erl
Pe.mlts (cUck to See Revlews)
Owing
$s0.00 $50.00
$90.00 $90.00 05/24/2OtA
Strudural - Review Fee $50.00 t50.00
SCAI t2.85 $2.85 os/24/2074
DBPR SUTchaT9e ,2.00 $2.00 05/24/20tA
$100.00 $100.00 03/01/2019
Reinspectron Fe€ for Buildinq $50.00 $0.00 i $60.00
s354.as a294.AS s6o.oo
SLructural - Application Fee
PLEASE DO NOT SUBMTT ANY PAYI4ENTS UNNL A COLLIER COUNTY PAYMENT SLIP I5 DISTRIBUTEO
169 - o.y-in/fl.shing 6/ 7 /2074 5t7/2A14 06/o?/20ra
REYES, GEORGE E & )OSEPHINE C, A(i'TES9:4484 DUNLIN CT
DAVID A. BuCKNER.lR., Addressr1020 FAIRWAY LANE, Pho6€r(321) 536_
8302, Ucensee * Q28108
ulel,ssr !s
WOZNIaX, PEIER EOWARD, Address:2505 FOREST PAR(WAY NORTH ,
Phone:(877) 84{-8300, Ucensee * tCC20170002114
Uc€ns€ Status
FLORIOA ROOF SERVICES LLC, Address:4505 9TH STREEI EAST, Phone:
(877) 8114-8300, State Reg *',s CCC1331226, Ucensee *
1CC20170002115
License sLatus
Property Owner:
Qualifier - Histo.lcal:
http://cvportal.colliergov.net/CityViewWeb/Permit/Status?permitld:259216 3nt2019
05/24/2O\A
05/24/201,8
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 114 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Permit Application Status - CityView Portal Page 2 of 2
Thomas winkler ((219) 877-2502) slldElodl
Cor.ection 1:
Stitus:
Date Status Changed:
Comments:
Miscellaneous Corections
06/07 /2OrA
l,4iscellaneous Cor€ctions Owne. states
Polystlck TU Max unde-l.ym€nt.
1, no nolice ol commencement,
2, no manufadurE p.odud approval on
slte- 107,3.1
3, underl.yment does not appe.r to be
lnstalled per manufadures installation
A, laps have not been rolled, See photos in
B, ve.tlcal over laps 1/2'only on right sid.
ot garage. see photos ln 6ocuments.
4, mlssing metal ddge, hlp, valley, and
drip edge- 107.3.r not per mrnufacture
innallalron inskudion. // Tw 6/7/18
170 - R€-roof Final
169 - Ory-in/Flashinq
Emailr N/A
Corredion 1
5t.aus
Date St.tu5 Chanqpd
Comments
Mtscellaneous Corrections
Oulstanding
06/07 /20t8
Miscellaneous Corredions Owner states
Polystlck TU Hax unde-layment,
1, no notice ofcommencement,
2, no manufactures orodurt .DDroval on
3, u.derlayment (bes not .ppear to be
install.d per manufadur€s lnstallation
A, laps have not been roll€d. See photos ln
B, v.rti(ll over laps 1/2' only on right srde
ofgarage. See photos ln documents.
4, mlssing meLal ndge/ hip, valley/ and
drip edge. 107.3.1 not per manufactur€
installation Instrudion. // Tw 5/7/18
oo.uments & tmag.5
D.tc
Uplo.d.d
05/01/2018
ost24/20t8
05/24/2AtA
05/24/2ArA
05/24/20tA
06/07t2or8
06/07/2OtA
06/07/20ta
oz/20/20t9
02/20/2019
01/0r/2019
PRBD201AO52q40t.ndl
Pavment Slin IPR)
errllil
Insm.tlon tob Ca.d
Recelot fortrrnsactloni 2014-045095
lmrde Roofind horlzontrl oao betw.€n seams. .ineo
imaoe Roofno l..oe bubbles at rido. ll.e-i.€o
2 inch.ioe
EXT, PRAD2ora052a401 - reb 20 201q 14,40-51.ndf
Pavment Slio (PRl
Receiot lortransactlon: 2019-018553
http:/icvportal.colliergov.net/CityViewWeb/permit/Status?permitl d:259216 3/1t20t9
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 115 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
PERMIT
PERMIT TYPE ROPERMIT#: PRBD2Ol8052940l0l
ISSUED: BY:MASTER#: COA:
JQB ADDRESS: 4484 Dunlin CT
JOB DESCRIPTION
SLIBDIVISION #:
FLOOD \trAP:
FOLIO #: 5610551l90l
OWNER INFORMA ION
REYES, GEORGE E & JOSEPHINE C
4484 DUNLIN CT
NAPLES, FL 34I 19.
APPLIED DATE: 05-01-18 APPROVAL DATE: 05-24-l 8
CONCRETE TILE O!'ER POLYGLASS TH 6: 12 PITCH
45
44E4 DIJNLIN CT
JOB PHO\E:
BLOCK
ELEVATION
SECTION-TOWNSHIP-RANGE: 20-48.26
CONTRACTOR INFORMATION:
FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES LLC
4505 9TH STREET EAST
ELLINGTON. FL 34222
CERTIFICATE #: .No LrcENsEr>PHONE:
TOTAI RES SOFT: 0 TOTAL CO\{M SQFT: O
ZONE:
FCC CODE:
CONSTRUCTION CODE: 0220
JOB VAILTE: $4 2,300.00
1'BA KS FRONT RIGHT:
SEWER
CONTACT NAME: REYES, GEORGE E & JOSEPHINE C
CONTACT PHONE: <NO PRMARY PHONE>
Per Collier County Ordinance No. 2002-01, as it may be amended, all work musl comply with all applicable laws, codes, ordinances, and any additional
stipulations or conditions ofthis permit. This permit expires if work authorized by the permit is not commenced within six (6) months from the date of
issuance ofthe permit. Additional fees for failing to obtain permits prior to the conunencement ofconstruction may be imposed. Permittee(s) further
understands that any contractor that may be employed must be a licensed contractor and that the strucfure must not be used or occupied until a
Cenificate ofOccupancy is issued.
NOTICE: PRIOR TO THE REMOVAL OF ASBESTOS PRODUCTS OR THE DEMOLITION OF A STRUCTURE, FEDERAL
AND STATE LAWS REQUIRE THE PERMITTEE (EITHER THE OWNER OR CONTRACTOR) TO SUBMIT A NOTICE OF
THE INTENDED WORK TO THE STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION (DEP). FOR MORE
TNFORMATTON, CONTACT DEP AT (239) 34+5600.
ln addition to the conditions of this permit, there may be additional restrictions applicable to this property that may be fouod in
the public records of this county, and there may be additional permits required from other governmeotal entities such as wrter
management districts, state agencies, or federal agencies.
WARNING TO OWNER: YOUR FAILURE TO RECORD A NOTICE OF
COMMENCEMENT MAY RESULT IN YOUR PAYTNG TWICE FOR IMPROVEMENTS
TO YOUR PROPERTY. IF YOU INTEND TO OBTAIN FINANCING, CONSULT WITH
YOUR LENDER OR AN ATTORNEY BEFORE RECORDING YOUR NOTICE OF
COMMENCEMENT.
REARI LEFT:
WATER:
COLLIER GOUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
LOT:
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 116 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
w
sTATE CERTIFIED ROOFING CONTRACTOS LICENSE i CCC1331226
sTATE CERTIFIED RESIDENTIAL BUILDING CONTBACTOR LICENSEN CRCl331782
FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES LTC
2605 FOREST PARKWAY NORTH LARGO, FIORIDA 33771
pHoNE 877-844-8300 FAX941_722_8982
SALES AGREEMENT
BETWEEN THE CONTRACTOR AND THE CUSTOMER NAMED BELOW
fi|-lix'3rs,
J'"Y
NAME 1ri 2-37 _541- /PH ONE
PHONE
44'?1 /t,"l,i^3/t.AODRESS ctTY/zrP
EMAIL
TfIE CONTRACTOR HERETN AGREES TO FURNISH MATERIALS AND LABOR TO COMPLETE THE FOLLOWING:
"EF\U(?)
F,.t:
"-i /'-6i INSTALL NEW LEAD BOOTS A P!Uinat N
7.1 |NSTAL! llEW s (.)
VER EN-TIRE DECK.
TI ON5 AND NEIY VENT HOODS AT AIR EXHAUsT PORTs.
ROOF SHINGLE, METAL OR TILE ROOF:
REMOVE OLO ROOF tO SMOOTH hIORKAALE SUtFACE. REPLACE ANy ROTTED WOO D XfEA a S9O per she.t &S7 per tooi.
REI{AII WOOOEI{ ROOF DECI$I'G TO RAFTERS YYITH RING SHANI( NAILS IN ACCORDAI{CE WIIH CUiREI{T CODEs.
APPLY NEW eSECOitDARY tyATER RES|STfNT BAFRtER" Ut{OERLAyMENT O
tNsraLL NEw FHAva Eave onrp.--wxrte-Jeeowx...sLAcK...caLvANtzEo.
INSTALL NEW VALLEY METAL AND MEIAL FLASHING WHERE NECESSARY,
t RGI.AsSSHING
RIDGE VE'II
(cor.oR)
coLoR)
,L..' ttlstor-r- '.1- FEET oF RrDGE vENr / 6 ,.., o, ow
I.9. ; CLEAI{ UP JOBSIIE OF ALI YIORK RELAIED DEBRTS AND HAUL AITIAY
10. CONTRACTOR YVtL! COORDINATE V'ORX RELAIED TO THE FOLLOWING AT AODITIONAL CHARCES-. SOLAR U ITS, ROOFIOP
AIR COrlDlllOtlERS, ROOFTOP l.V. Dls|lEs, SI{YLIG}lTS. AtlrD fALLEt{ SOFFITT & FAsclA DOE TO EXCESSIVE wooD RoT.
RE
't.
3,
6,
7.
E.
INSTALL NEI\I TPO MEMBRAIIE COVER OR GRANULATED TORCH OO\IN...COLOR - WHITE.
CLEAN UP JOBSITE OF ALL WORX RELATED DEBRIS AND HAUL AWAY.
,rl1 wort 1o-* Frforh.d ir
compl.te ah.l joSsit
shall notlneludethej
.Fpli6ble! qlit.n w-r.ant!, ...1 insurece miltgation
300-00
11L, .; f -:---7/ )-- '.:'
5
s
s'r 11 *'
SltE FllilE PRDaT"
l. CONI8ACT DOCUMT!iT5. Tli. @oftd co{n6 oI t!! d@ur.dt, r*: -od rutlori:rtjoD plu anI -@d :rpl.ea'dt. i{ rnr, ud iI pryE.n6 r. 6ur.at, rU
6n,.irl dodrarr No proELa otla r lr! lllok rp..incdl] .* t6rt! i! il$ 6!a.e dD.6!rE tAr! l. Hogni&a ),y .i.-hs prr9.
2. l! { vld.stEd lnd .!,dd $.t r-hi, earr..! ndl aot b. hidi"g {!,o. !t. dE!6oi lrtn.ig!!d fud a@pl.d by u .nE 6r rh. @,hdo r,
L rn. oohcbr laFs !!. r+Lt to .,htiht. ErtdirL oI lqErl .r srur:r ?.hL ,uy drng6 lrqolrd iy "i J"iriido.d ord6 b., r-ult in .ddjt.lal ci{tB.
'l. r,y ld.r &d.E Aqun.d !. &Ie! 6ocia du. lsda tln.grluar viu b.h.qir i! r Pinlou Cd"r; n!;J.,6!..d d].h..!6 includi,r irr@r ari.rbm.t
i6 rh.[ b! rhc ouig.rio! 6l r.L. puEl,rr. TIG @F.do, ffi6 norld oapanrion rld !a.r!.Ilnb it iMnne.pptiEi,l. @ .!? v.* b.ug pqror.d
5. BItYEas llctTlO cAi{cE- tltou do 'or -.n rh. a..<L sa ..-iq r.r dy a,d rhn {,6d by prwiai!! rind ndie & lii clnrEdG; pdio.. !!!d.su b, aril.Tle ldieqd idiaE tLr !d doer H't r.L. aoo& or ,riB rDd ali l. d.tr.,.d or po.h.,lea h.d@ nilnigLl ofrl. l]lrn Suina dtr
docuhent3tion sh.ll b. Frovided withan 30 d.ys ol fi.al EALANCE UPOTI COMPIETJOTt,
ADD 3!/" IF PAYING BY CREDI'T CARD S
ilE Fu .i!! thir .{rar6! . Tf,; ,ork ru.tl .oEEoa dr d rLou!Mn b. co,npl.r.d hy !pfhnh.!.l),
BUI'EI I,CKOIILEDGES P.ECEPT OT r{ COPY OT'TBI5 ]{GREXi,IXA'ITEIS Y Ol_. 20_
Do Nor srcN TEIS EolG DdPRoLEunNr coI{TR A,cr IF Brr!.NK. yo u anE Etrrrrl,aD m A copy oF Tffrs coNrnrrcr
AT TEE TD{E YOU SIGN. TEIS COYIRACT M1Y CREATE.q.I-EDi ON ON YOUR PAOPERTY IF NOT PA]D
(*(DAIE}
6. Tl'. cdHco. rl.[ !r*. dDc .a ]on.y*. i! n ua6hd ..d laEJ Ll[r &. lu:.q hold. !h. co' rrcror hnrnls! aor rn-r, J.eagE !k. Eiy oEur b r'!! &iv rlyruiru otlk' litu or rh. psrcny dui'g rhc d.liv.ry .a ulBj.]l tld t5! lacvd .t d6 n.! cl,rld d.i,rtr F!.drdmr.t r!. 6n;dor n !d! ttfuld rlr u,d.q+a.o ,C l!..! ddi..r tDB, pl!B!i,6liu ud E, otlq 'n..!dial dEpo,gn drrr ur h,v. !d iepEp.i, iqrdl.d e. ctDB r. !h? eE!< i..t -Ei. Jd qilr or re LLa5 6 !a.dE or 6! .r, ol ...a
? CliprE 5,58 oa r!. ll,ridr Srrt.e dui! iEr.tulr r.$;d6b )fl Ec a,Iry !.ton ,ou !ry !.i!g ey rc..] n.ror ror d JL?n sn,h.ti.r d.rEt n ,@,nolu SLtr d:7r b.roE yo! Eilg E, IErl .di!D rd tu d.liE 6 o.sE p..V ro tln 6nBr r ri!6 rotie '.r@in! to chp6 558 of &y .ll.gd oE6u.do!
d!lE: Ed b 6.&a E*:tr u oEa b Etrir or lar Gr i!. .t.gst cdlrib. d.aa Y6 !E ro r ohli+rd 6 i6gr .r, ora !!Li.h D.y !. ardL Tift .E rbd
dc.dti.d @d6 r.lr! tlo;dr S!!tulr rti..L Ed b. Ea ad touoi.a b DEE r@ i!!.6u.
8. Co,rftdio! I u.Eia n@v*, ruld i'y8an ur L! .-dru. toa ra. C!!p nrou b.. E6!4v 6n . !rcjd F,r idcr.riu ,trour th ,.oo!.r, tund Dd 6ii!g r
cl:ib manct r. F.rid. Couh.tio. llautry Lic i'€ B@d .r t!. loU.,i.s rdqrLd? !u!$., uJ ddBr..9o+?2?.6530--. ?960 &linaton Erpr!rys, S;!.300
J t&.!lill. Il.id. 3r2i 1.746?.
^ctisca
7ln42ga5 ,,
ECLOS
iOATE)
J
ROOF... (TPO INSULATED ROOF SYSTEM) OR ({.PLYTORCH SYSTEM)
REMOVE OLD ROOFTO
RENAI! ltOODEl'l RooF
SURfACE. REPI.ACE aNY ROTTED WOOO XTRA @ 59o per Eh.Et &57 per foot
DECXttiG WIA}| FIIIC SHANK NAILS IN ACCORDANCE WiIH CURFENT COOES.
A'gLY I, EYI VSECO!.DARY ovER altneE DEc& ,_ _
trsaAI.I. _ lt{sur.artoN BOARD FOE TPO SYSTEM U II9ER 1.PLY TORCH SYSTEIt],
INSIALL NEW fIIS/'VA EAVE DRIP oF cltolcE) __
lr{saal.l- NEtt LEAD BOOTS, AiF VENT HOOOS ANDIOR FLASHINGS WHERE nECESSARY,
-,..]
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 117 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Purchaser Copy
CASHIER'S CHECK
Purchaser Copy
May 10,2018
volD rF ovER us $ 14,200.00
NON-NEGOTIABLE
Oflice AU I
11-24
121O(8)
JOSEPHIRE SUAREZ REYE.S'^^--,..-.- -.' . ^EZ REYES
SERIAL #:
ACCOUNT#:
?urchoser Accouot
Operalot LD.: u612157 ul79t69
Fundt1g Source El.ctrontc [6rnr{3l p.per ,lefnrli)pAyrorHE oRDERoF **"FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES LLC*"*
Fffi
r'
'0066511
\1.;lt1i
**$14,200.00"*
I
"*"Fourteen thousand two hundred dollars and no cents***
ayee Adclress:
E'rrO ROOF REPAIR
ELLS FARGO 8ANK, A/.A.roSr*,voAryJ''-'..,.... NOTICE rO PURCHASER _ tF THIS TNSTRUMENT lS LOSI,
?LES, FL34110 SToLEN OR DESTROYED, you MAy REOUEST CANCELT_ATTON
I rNeu,RrES .ALL (4 Bo) 3s4.3122 liB!5^'^'"?l^,?1ffA:Bi?1,_"1^lir.fli:?t'.Xrl?i llB
REOUIRE AN INDEMNITY AGREEMENT AND BOND.
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 118 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER
o066511 11-24 CASHIER'S CHECK
NOTICE TO PURCHASER - IF THIS INSTRUMENT IS LOST.
STOLEN OR DESTROYED, YOU MAY,REOUEST CANCELLATION
ANO REISSUANCE. AS A CONDITION TO CANCELLATION AND
REISSUANCE, WELLS FARGO BANK MAY IMPOSE A FEE AND
REOUiRE AN INDEMNIry AGREEMENT AND BOND. .
Purchaser Copy
Otrtce AU *121O18)
JOSEPHINE SUAREZ REYESi^aeosr!r: sr taREz REYES
aotitsza u379169
Reilitler.
Purhaser
Purchaser Accounl
Operalor I D.:
Funding Soutce: PaPer rtenls(s)
PAY TO IHE ORDER OF *"*FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES LLC***
volD tF ovER us $ 14,20
NON.NEGOTTA
"**Fourteen thousand two hundred dollars and no cenfs***
Payee Address:
Uemo: ROOF REPAIR
\!:?3
SERIAL #:
ACCOUNT#:
April 20,2018
**$14,200.00**
)
VELLS FARGO BANK, N.A,
ilo SIRAND BLVO
|PLES, FL U110
)R INQU'RIES C LL (480) 394-3122
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 119 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 :
GumphJack
From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Attachments:
GumphJack
Thursday, December 13, 2018 11:34 AM
jwrayl@yahoo.com
GumphJack
RE: Permit # PR8D20180529401, 4484 Dunlin Ct., Naples, FL
12132018112018.pdf
Mr. Rayl,
Attached please find a violation notice for Permit fl PRBD20180529401, 4484 Dunlin Ct., Naples, FL. The permit is listed
as EXPIRED. Pleased re-activate the permit. Please have Qualifier, Peter Wozniak sign the violation form and sent back
to me via email. lt is essential you take the necessary steps to resolve the homeowner's issues: Underlayment is expired-
leakage lnto the home, completing the roof and finalizing the permit.
Thank you,
lack Gumph
Compliance Offi cer, Contractor Licensing
Collier County Growth Management Department
2800 North Horseshoe Drive
Naples, FL 34104
239-252-2468 (Office)
239-438-5195 [Cell)
Iack.Gumph@CollierCountvFL.gov
-,L-c,fiff",Qownty
Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. lf you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a
public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. lnstead, contact this office by telephone or in writing.
1
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 120 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES
GumphJack
From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Attachments:
GumphJack
Tuesday, January 15, 2019 11:40 AM
jwrayl@yahoo.com
GumphJack; GuzmanJuan; MeulenbergTimothy
FW: RE: Permit # PRBD20180529401. 21484 Dunlin Ct., Naples, FL
01152019110722.pdf
Mr. Rayl/Woznia k,
Attached, please find a 'Notice to Appear' before the Contractor Licensing Board to answer charges of violations on
permit B 's PR8D20180529401, PR8D20180422436 and PR8D20180745475. lf you have questions, please don't hesitate
to contact me.
Thank you,
Jack Gumph
Compliance Officer, Contractor Licensing
Collier County Growth Management Department
2800 North Horseshoe Drive
Naples, FL 34104
239-252-2468 (Offrce)
2 39-438-5195 (CellJ
Iack.Gumph@CollierCountyFL.gov
C'"?ffi,Coanxy
From: GumphJack
Sent: Thursday, December 13, 2018 11:34 AM
To: jwrayl@yahoo.com
Cc: GumphJack <Jack.Gumph@colliercountyfl.gov>
Subject: RE: Permit # PR8D2018052940L, 4484 Dunlin Ct., Naples, FL
Mr. Rayl,
Thank you,
lack Gumph
Compliance Offlcer, Contractor Licensing
Collier County Growth Management Department
2800 North Horseshoe Drive
Attached please find a violation notice for Permit S PR8D20180529401, 4484 Dunlin Ct., Naples, FL. The permit is listed
as EXPIRED. Pleased re-activate the permit. Please have Qualifier, Peter Wozniak sign the violation form and sent back
to me via email. lt is essentialyou take the necessary steps to resolve the homeowner's issues: Underlayment is expired-
leakage into the home, completing the roof and finalizing the permit.
1
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 121 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Notice of Non-Complia nce
BE lT KNOWN THAT l, the person whose signature appears below, do hereby formally acknowledge,
agree and consent as follows:
THAT a certain case, case S CEM1520180015337, involving me has recently been investigated by the
Collier County Contractor Licensing Department.
THAT the said Department had made it known to me that, in the Department's view, I violated State
(Florida Building code section 105.1) and county {ordinance 2006-46. as amended,4.1.6 & 4.1.18)
licensing laws in said case, EXPIRED PERMIT S PR8D20180529i81. receives, as initial payment, money
totaling more than 10 percent ofthe contrect price, having failed or refuse to pertorm any work for a
90{ay period that has subjected occupants to potential water damage. Dry-in inspection FAlt€D {on
5h hal, Underlayment erpired over 6 months.
Type of Work: CONCRETE TltE OVER POLYGIASS TH 6:12 PITCH 45
Location ofwork: 4484 Dunlin Ct., Naples, FL 34119
Date of Site visit - December 12, 2018
THAT the said Department has explained to me that all contracting work, including BUT NOT tlMlTED
TO: home or business improvement, residential or commercial, remodeling, renov3tion, addition, repair,
alteration, plumbing, electrical, roofing, pool construction, air conditioninB, sheet metal, aluminum and
alarm contractor work,all reouiae the issuance an d m aintenance of a valid Buildins Permit grior to
commencement and throushout worki g on a oermit reouired buildins oroiect.
THEREFORE, BEING FUTLY ADVISED, I DO AGREE that I will obtain and maintain in current status, all
Building Permits required by Statutes and fully understand that if I commence work without obtaining or
maintaining necessary Building Permits in the future, the Contractor Licensing Department will consider
that a !{illlgllgd9Jiqbli9! where penalties and restrictions to Building Permit privileges may follow.
Witness my signature (Contractor)Print
Peter Edward Wozniak
State of: Florida, lssuance 8:ccc1331 226 WOZNIAK, PETER EDWARD
County of: Collier, lssuance f:1CC2017m02115-FLORIDA ROOT SERVICES, LLC.
The foresoin8 instrument was acknowledged before me this (date) by
ffihotasproduced
Signature of Notary
Licensint lnvestigator, in lieu of Notary. Date:
Tim Meulenberg, Collier County Contractor licensing, 239-252-AOZ3
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 122 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
PHOTOG RAPHS ARE OF 4484 DU N LIN CT
- REYES RESIDENCE
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 123 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
/i
,i
,/
W,#
':i. -
,l
,
.-(r'i 'i1;'t-=$*li'**,.
,#,,|:-
:
\\" '
.'l ,i.:-
z.alt
n'ri,
i^
.,ltf,'rs.
;"'{mi.,:
'* ^ r;ilr'9{
}h**.S..:
- rv_,- 'lt
,i 1t-l
' r.
,.1
\-
{"ti
- \1i
-tn
- ,:- A,-,i'l-?.
\r
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 124 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER
rii
t!
t ,..
;t',
tt':;.\'l
'"
1
t
l.
.a
.dl
.!a
lr i
i
.' -\
*'.
it)
,:,,
\
., -., ,. L,.
.:i
L,l41
Ill
;W IM r - .'--r.* .-:_ > ''r l. ' ,:.' -1.,,' i'-- I'"a{'NIt
L?
i-
.l .r
.t. I
, llffi
I
tv
z
lt
i.$
-n
'yl
,-al
,.ddM
J
I ,{.r
tti
/
,i*a
1
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 125 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER
I
)
,
\r!
'rr.Jl
i{ryi'
II
t
t
l)
\*'\7 (
ri'
T_
,
I2J
I
?.
t.
t )-l
li.i!'
., lr,,tr*I'I.
*.
..7
F,l
tl
l
!
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 126 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER
\\
I
,..
x
.J,*
,r.
st
I,
;,
l$
.-.cir..rB,.
'y
',"1
I
..;'.
I
li ..
. trlr
t
a
lit,
/i'"''
fit
r.
r.i'1";4
r"l: .';
!
:\ /x
,i.
:il...!
,j
.jw.
.1 .1
,
.,i
:(,
I
'6i
{N'::
t
i:r
a,
{I
5r)
::'
\
c.'tt'
lil\r,
t,,-
r(
,' ;.1L'',!ii'.
' I 'i:t'il
a.',?i.
_'1.-..:
\
{
':\
frit.5t' I
.,:'it '.J
t;
2"t
..#ril+'.'.!i:s .. ]
, ..'.1'Ir,.,,',;
r}:
',ll
I lz,1'
'., //-
,
-{a;
| ,,ai'
i .-
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 127 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER
s. aaai trt orlrl t tFa rei r riiad. t, a,-lt !.,*r9r! r.,ral -ii-ia5 .\.r r*.trro,aa{l.--rt*trai..r*r. :-ga.r{E .i rtrlr.X r. {-.;-q,t ..-i a.-rrr !b =- -.i.lED - r- E-i.- rra rr- rlD.,|{ r--i,hi
-
,;r.r*El-llanat
O+.r!.ranf
:*
A COa,t
!roTtcE
al nls Lernoai
Gc*.r Caint
f.{alil oo ror
RESOVE
t
I
ARB APPROVED PROJECT
r:Bt*Etr,rL Er rnorill rltr,l6/r rfrltfr
-a€.8
thllt-EEilr[t
.-!-,-*
r-
I
s 7
i-
t-
e /\slror tjLi1..nkeLrl\5
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 128 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
I
\a
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 129 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
/x
/
\
\
\I
\\'l
\
\
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 130 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
III
I
I
I
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 131 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
/
.i
!
\-
I
UL
,/l t
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 132 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Dare. 31112019 2:54:35 ?M
Report Title. Code Case Details
CaseNumber: CEM1S20180014738
Case Number cEMts20180014738
Case Type M iscon d uct
Priority Normal
lnspector TimothyMeulenberg
Jurisdiction Contractor's Licensing
Complaint
Detail Description Florida Roof Services has taken two payments of $11,250 and not ordered the tile after 4
months since the permit was issued. Florida Roof Services: Office, Leslie (727)687-7630; JEFF
787 .452.3881i DAVE 239.248.17 71. EMAIL jwrayl@yahoo.com
Location Comments QUIGLEY, THOMAS=& ANGELA; 1965 ISLA DE PALMA GIR; NAPLES, FL 341 19: FOLIO #
(726s00122431
CELL; 239.784.8250
HOME; 239.596.2420
Status
Date & Time Entered 1112812018 3i17:27 PM
Entered By TimothyMeulenberg
Case Disposition Case Pending
Property 72650012243
Contractor Florida Roof Services LLC
Qualifier WOZNIAK, PETER EDWARD
tu
Origin:
lnvestigation
Busrness Management & Budget Office 1
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 133 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Code Case Details Execution Dale 31112Q19 2:54:35 PM
Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments
Preliminary lnvestigation TimothyMeule
nberg
11D4t2018 11t29t2018 Needs
lnvestigatio
n
'1 1/29/18: At 8:57 am, I placed a call to Leslie
727 687.7630lefta message wth inquiry as
to the status of the tile installation at '1965 lsla
Ed Palma ClR. At 9:03 am I called
877.844.8300 and kied to leave a message
but mail box is full. At 9:20 am, I called
727.452.3A and left a message with Jeff
Rayl and sent an email to jwrayl@yahoo.com
regarding re-roof permit at 1965 lsla De
Palma ClR. I will be meeting the property
owner Thomas Quigley at 10:00 am
Cont. lnvestagation TimothyMeule
nberg
1U8t2018 12t8t2018 Complete 12108118: I have sent three emails due to a
lack of response to phone messages.
The first was sent 1 1/29118 documenting a
history of poor response to the property
owner and no follow through on construction
activity since the 8i 13/18 dry-in inspection.
Additionally, the owner has made two
payments of $11,520 with not evidence of
ordering the tile. I further requested a
response on the status of tiie delivery.
The second email was sent 1 1/30/18
forwarding the email sent on 11/29/18 and the
inclusion of an attached Notice of Non-
Compliance requesting a signature. I
additionally requested an update as to the
status of the tile delivery.
On 12lMl18t I received a response from Jeff
Rayl stating the tile mfgs have been vague
and non committal with their response as to
tile delivery. The further stated they will make
every effort to communicate this infomation
to their customers. There was no mention of
the Notice of Non-Compliance. lthen
investigated by contacting the local distributor
of Crown Tile and found the order delivery for
1965 lsla De Palma was processed about a
month ago so I followed up with a response to
Jeff Rayl statjng I was aware of approximate
date they ordered the tile and suggested it
placed the tile order well after the two
payments of $1 1,520 had been paid. l further
requested a return of the signed Notice of
Non-Compliance. All emails have been
included in DOCS. TM
Business Management & Budget Office 2
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 134 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Code Case Details Execution Dale 31112019 2:54:35 PM
Desc Assig ned Required Completed Outcome Comments
TimothyMeule
nberg
12127t2018 12t27t2018 Complete 1427118: I sent another email to Jeff Wrayl
requesting he obtain the signature of Peter E.
Wosniak and return a signed notice of non-
compliance for the case file. lplacedacall to
the property owner, Thomas Quigley to
update him and he informed me that George,
the Crown Tile Distributor estimates the tile
delivery aroung March. TM
Cont. lnvestigation Timothy[4eule
nberg
1t15t2019 1t15t2019 Complete 1/15/19: No response to Notice of Non-
Compliance. Notice to Appear before the
Contractor Licensing Board on Wednesday
March 20, 2019 at 9:00 AM in the Board of
County Commissioneis Room was sent to
Mr. Rayl and Mr. Wozniak by Contractor
Licensing Officer Jack Gumph. Scanned to
docs. TM
TimothyMeule
nberg
2t1t2019 z1t2a19 Complete Z1119: Obtained confirmation that certified
mail was delivered to Florda Roof Servrces in
Largo FL 33771 on 1/30/19. Scanned to
documents. TM
Cont. lnvestigation TimothyMeule
nberg
2t15t2019 2t15t2019 Complete On 25h9, attached to documents a sign
receipt that Peter Wosniak received the notice
of Licensing Board Hearing for March.
Cont lnvestigation TimothyMeule
nberg
3t1t2019 3t1t2019 Complete 3/1/19; at 8:51 am, I spoke with Thomas
Quigley to inform him of the March 20, 2019
Contractor Licensing Case with Florida Roof
Services that will be submitted to the
Contractor Licensing Board. I asked him if he
would complete a Sworn Statement
sumarizing his experience with the contractor.
He expressed concern and stated at this time
he would rather not submit a sworn statement
because his tiles are scheduled to be in this
month. I informed Mr. Ouigley that the case
would involve the length of time that has
lapsed since the contractor last worked on the
roof and that I would let him know the
outmme of the case to the board. TM
lnvestigation TimothyMeule
nberg
3t15t2019 Pending 1965 lsla De Palma NoNC???? The Crown
Tile distributor believes that the tile for this job
will be in the month of March. 20'19 or so. TM
Violation Description Status Entered Corrected Amount Comments
4.2 Misconduct State Certifed
Contractors
Open 11t28/2018 $0
Tifle Reason Result Compliance Fine/Day Condition
Busjness Management & Budget Oflice 3
Cont. lnvestigation
Cont. lnvestigation
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 135 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
-RffL, -,/
u $TN
1,L1,LLY
Growh N,4anagement Deparh-nent
Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
Phone - 239-252-2431
Fax - 239-252-2469
(- *O-tUco'-rs
PRELIMINARY COMPLAINT FORM
Please complete this form to the best of your abilities. Also include with this form any documents you would like to
be reviewed as evidence for this case. This can include Contracts, Copies of Checks, Permits, Liens, etc.
-t'l-hmns Qvr4t<'l Date a6 /€
lqb4 fuh brlnL6 (,s,1<t"o{Ps fL 3y(9
Street City State zip
Email Qttt 1y1t\t 0 AoL .cont
az\ 1gq- <)so
Address of Complaint:/11,s bla be(otnt trkl< tufif/es /L 3y/n
Street City State zip
Company Name oRna oo (e (//c5
Contractor/Person in Charge bfrve J beK License #
Telephone 911-gq(/-83oo Date of Contract:
c cc t33l;D6
u/r, f ,s
/]4,tpTls t^)AtTir(: Frn f,u. ftteLi ail/ r"T 16/t ,lre w/,ro rterl oloort,D
R*kn ul u'7 Apsrr,rr 4p/ cfrlts /ta.,-, ttte tE Ber, {
fiLe o 2* rtlho- bts/A)fqL Plz*t a,kfi ll/t< t". /e,.76 o(--,ile
fun Ctn,rclruqAat { q //na o
fur @ ouf 141t4,tq firt k/2,tr l,aettv 1,ty fl.nt4 .
SIGNATU RE
PRELIM INARY COMPLAINT M REV 4/t211-8
RECF]I\i ED
i\l:]ii "r ,. ;jliii
Complainant's Name:
Home address:
Telephone:
COMPLAINT INFORMATION:
COMPLAINT DETAILS (ATTACH ADDITIONAL SHEETS IF NECESSARY)
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 136 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
C C,ow4lt
Grci(h l{rtagsrEr{ DepatrEnt
must @.nplete oll Pleose Jolbw the
BU II.DING PERMlT APPUCATION
2800 N. HORSESHOE DR., NAPLES, FL 34104 I TEL: (239)252-2400
Diections
83, 8ur'klirETyp€:
8.4 PErinittee Tpe:
Property lrformation
8.5. ParceYFolio l:
8.5. lob Street Addr6s:
8.7. OwnerName:
8.8 Owner Phone:
8.9. tubdMsion:
LoVBloddunit:
8.10. SDP/Prr:
8.11. 'PLH Filename:
ffi z untty twen.gyr o*nxwse
@n.ao,
J q
.17eryrrs € *rncla i)uia /ttt.
O oes6n *ofession"t
Contrador lnformation
B.U. License H:
8.13. Company Name:
8.14. QualifierName:
8.15. Contact Name:
8.16. Company Address
lnstruct;ons to thls Appltotbn.
8.2. Master $ (fo'rl:
Q vobil{tvtanufactr.red home O Residential3+ oniB/Muhi-famity Q Commeroat
Q Owner Builder
ZV 4&tr q#- 9. E-
to-;;a La l-.rs
L4/qf Tarcr lor 44
'Opttorxrl-kqd1 ati*ir,q Ftlerrrt'fs d't GNVa, PatloL
54 ts-/1..)t7a,,L.J./22+
8.17. Company Phone:
8.18, Faxlt
8.19.a, "Email1:
8.19.b. "Email2:
l"W na rne tr*4t1cr, Nirnory @id nethd.
Secdon C AnCialbn lnfrmrtion
E ELEC EPLUME E MECH -Septic trl Low VoltaEe El Shutters E ELtcTfrom house El6a5
C8. FireSprinkled:
C9. Permh by Affidavit:
C10. Prirate Pror'ider
C11. Threshold BuildinB:
C.12. Vegetation Oelrin8:
C,L},REIAtEd tO DAIVI,AGES tI'ICURRED BYHURRICANE IRMA
C.2. PermitType:
C3. Fre Permjt Type:
C4. Construction Typ€
C.5. Ocnipancy:
C.6. Water Service;
C.7. Sewer SeMce:e:l .,1o
0.1.lqavkklrku): D 2. Project Name Ao,y/i D.3. Declared Value 5 jq,^be. '_
D.4 iti*He;tEr sq. Fr:
NeN ConsL lcan*E D a-a & oa.h)
^dditc,r
lUrp* o.t.o A aa.t)
Alteration /co.rph. o4cl
D.i|.b. Wq* Ar€B (Sq. Frl
o..!i tivingi
D.1.hi. NsrlMng: _TOTAI: 0
0.4.L Wor*Area {Sq. Fr)
0.4-ci. Uving:
D-a.cii Nol-living: _IOTAL O
0.4.d. Totals by Area
IoIAI tiwE 0
IOIArt{o.iaC 0
I Stori6:
, Units:
S Bedrooms:
# Eathrooms
D:5. €oiimedatss Fr:
New C.Dnst (cohpbtE o.So. & D.5.b)
Addi6o^' Eqn*e D.5a & D rh)
AJteration /cr4ptsre o 5'./
D''a Ne$, Consl D56.WqkAIea lsq. Fr)
lnterior
E t"rio. -=---
TOTAfi - o
0.5.c Work Area (Sq. FL)
# Stories:
# Units:
lnterion
Exterior
IOTAti 0
E.2. Numberof plan Sets:E.3. ReviewDays: WI 5r0r5E.1. FinalReview Date:
Revised Date. 11/29l17 v2 This is pa8e 1of 3 pa8es of the Build int Permat Application. plea5e s!bmit all3 pages rrt,en co.pt"t"d
'?tbE oo t ai./t@
D.4,a, New Const
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 137 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
..#..-."BUI[DING PERMIT APPUCATION
2800 N. HORSESHOE DR., NAPLES, FL 34104 I TEL: (239) 252-2400
NOTICE OF COLLIER COUNTY ADDITIONAL REGULATIONS
NOTICE OF ADDITIONAL RESTRICTIONS: ln addition to the requirements of this permit, there may be
additional restrictions applicable to this property that may be found in the public records of this County,
and there may be additional permits required from other governmental entities such as the Water
ManaBement District, State agencies, or Federal agencies.
WARNING OF POSSIELE DEED RESTRICTIONS: The land subject to this permit may be subject to deed,
and other restrictions that may limit or impair the landowner's rights. Collier County is not responsible
for the enforcement of these restrictions, nor are Collier County employees authorized to provide legal
or business advice to the public relative to these restrictions. The landowner or any applicant acting on
behalf of the landowner is cautioned to seek professional advice.
WARNING OF WORK lN THE COUNW RIGHT-OF-WAYS: This permit does not authorize construction or
installation of any structure or utility, above or below ground, within any right of way or easement
reserved for access, drainage or utility purposes. This restriction specifically prohibits fencing, sprinkler
systems, landscaping other than sod, signs, water, sewer, cable and drainage work therein. lf such
improvements are necessary, a separate permit for that purpose must be obtained from the Growth
Management Department.
NOTICE OF CLEARING RESTRICTIONS: The issuance of a building permit for a single-family dwelling
allows up to one (1) acre of native vegetation to be cleared. Clearing more than one (1) acre may be
allowed for accessory structures and requires a separate Vegetation Removal Permit. Properties
located in the following zoninB district overlays may not be allowed to clear one (1) acre: Rural Fringe
Mixed Use District (RFMU), Big Cypress Area of Concern (ACSC), and Special Treatment Overlay (5T).
There may be additional restrictions related to clearing native vegetation and impacts to wetlands or
protected species found on the property. State and Federal agency permits may be required. Contact
the Growth Management Department's Environmental Services at (239) 252-24OO for additional
information. lssuance of a Demolition Permit for a structure does not authorize removal of vegetation
beyond the footprint of the structure. A Demo Permit is not a clearing permit.
WORK lN THE SPECIAL FLOOD HAZARD AREA: Be advised that Substantial Da mage/Substa ntial
lmprovement requirements will apply to structures located in the Special Flood Hazard Area with
Finished Floor Elevations below the Base Flood Elevation.
By initialing, I am acknowledging that I have read and understand this Notice of Collier County
Additional Regulations.
ln iti
Ownet ar Agent of Owner's or Controctor's initiols ore required
Rev 11-29-2017 v2 This is page 2 of 3 pages of the Building Permit Applicalion Please submit all 3 pages when completed
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 138 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
..f-..*'
contraat th Owr permits such action
(s ture of Owner or A
The for egoing instru ent was acknowledged before me this !-/tG dav ot
BUITDING PERMIT APPUCATION
28oo N. HORSESHOE DR., NAPLES, FL 34104 | TEL: (219) 252-2400
a
(name of p erson) who !d6,lly known to
ner)
zoJS-ay
me, or who
-has
Seal
)at
Sea I
sEcIlo owNER or AGENT OF OWNER ACKNOWLEDGEMENT. The Contraclor may sign as the Agent of owner so long as
(Print namB of Owner or ABent ot Ow
son a
produced identification (type of identi fication
Notary Signatu
SECTI CONTRACTO c I-EOGEMENT:
o
Bnatu Contra r)(Print name ol Contractor)
The fore inE instrument was acknowledged before me this t#day of zo& w
/t J),ak (name of person) wh o -=tU$ersonally known to me, or who has
cation (tYP e of identification)produced identifi
Notary Signature
NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT INFORMATION
per Florida Statutes 713.135 a Notice of Commencement (NOC) is required lor constrLlction of improvements totaling more than
s2,5OO, with certain etceptions. For A/C Repairs or Replacements a notice of commencement is required {or improvements more than
or equal to 57,SOO. The applicant shall file with the issuinB authoritY prior to the first inspection either a certified copy of the recorded
NOC or a notarized statement that the NOC has been filed for recording, alonS with a copY thereof. ln order to comply with the state
requirement, permitt will be placed in inspection hold until proof of the NOC is filed with the building permitting and inspection
department. The issuing authority shall not perform or approve subsequent inspections until the applicant files by mail, facsimile,
hand delivery, email or any other means such as certified copy with the issuing authority.
WARNING TO OWNER: YOUR FAIIURE TO RECORD A NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT MAY
RESULT IN YOUR PAYING TWICE FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO YOUR PROPERTY. IF YOU INTEND
TO OBTAIN FINANCING, CONSUTT WITH YOUR LENDER OR AN ATTORNEY BEFORE RECORDING
YOUR NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT. A NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT MUST BE RECORDED
AND POSTED ON THE JOB SITE BEFORE THE FIRST INSPECTION.
Rev 11 29-2017 v2 This ts pa8e 3 of 3 pages of the 8lildtng Permit Application. Plerse submit all I pages when complcred.
JEFFERY Tr, RAYL
Y COfrt t,ssroN I FF2069-05
EXPIFIES March l3 2t!-o
,:u
JEFFERY IV RAYL
nY co[rM'SStON # FF206995
E.XPIRES March l3 2cr19
rrfr!rf$ i,,5j.|:r:6
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF COLLIER COUNTY REGULATIONS
Application is hereby made to obtain a permit to do the work and installations as indicated lcertifY that no work or installation ha5
commenced prior to the issuance of a permit and that all work will be Performed to meet the standards of all law5 regulating
construction in this jurisdiction. The permit or application fee may have additional fee5 imposed for fa'lin8 to obtain permits prior to
commencement of construction.
Theapprovedpermitand/orperm.tapplicationexpiresifnotcommencedwithinl8odaysfromthedateofi5sUance.Thepermittee
further understands that only licensed contractors may be employed and that the structure will not be used or occupied until a
.ertificate of occupancy is irsued. 8y signing this permit application' lagree that lhave been retained bY the owner/permittee to
provide contracting services for the trade for which I am listed. Furthermore, it is my responsibility to notify the Euilding Plan Review
and lnspection Division should I no longer be the contractor responsible for providing said contractinB services. I fu her atree that I
understand that the review and issuing of this permit does not exempt me from complying with all county codes and ordinances lt
is lurther understood that the property owner/permittee is the owner of the permit'
Notei An owner-Builder must complete Sections A and B and the owner-Builder Affidavit torm'
k
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 139 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Permit Application Status - CityView Portal Page I of2
GMD Public Portal
permit Application Status
ln order to scheatule inspections, you need to be signed an.
- Sunm.ry
Applacation Numbe.: PR8D20180745475
Application Type: guilding
Appric.aionStatus: Reactivate
ProOerty Owner's Furt Name: QUIGLEY, THOMAS & ANGELA
Category or Work: Alteration
Ocorpancy Cod€: Regdentialt One and Two Famity New or Gu€st House
Descnptioo of Work: tile re{oor 5:12 pitdr 45 sq potygtass tumax undertayment
1965 isla de paho clr
Application Date: 0712612018
rssued D.te: 07131/2018
ExptahonDrte: 05/21120!9
1-2 F.mily or Comm: 1-2 Famity
Qualifier
QUTGLEY, THOMAS & ANGELA, Address:1965 ISLA OE PALMA CIR
WOZNIAK, PETER EDWARD, Addressr2605 rOREST PARKWAY NORTH,
Phone:(877) 844-8300, Licensee # 1CC20r70002114
License Statu<
FLORIDA ROOF SER!.ICE5 LLC, Addr.ss:4505 9TH SIREFI EAST, Phone
(877) 844-8300, State Reg *'s CCC1331226, Ucensee *
1CC201700021r5
License Status
P€rmlts (Cllck to See Revlews)
Owing
Structural - Applicaton Fee $50.00 $50.00 o7/3t/20rA
$90.00 $9r1.00 07t37/20r4
Structural - Revlew Fee $50.00 *50-oo a7/31/2014
6CAI $2.85 32.85 07/3r/20tB
DBPR 5urch.r9e $2.00 $2.00 01/3r/2074
$100.00 $0.00 $100.00
s294.85 t194,45 t100.oo
PLEAsE OO NOT SUBMIT AiIY PAYMENTS UNTII A COLUER COUNTY PAYMEI{T SLIP IS DISTRIBUIED
Keith Maloney Sen.r Emdil
a/ L3l20L8 8/13/2018 08/13/2018
h@://cvportal.colliergov.neVCityViewWeb,/PermiVStatus?permitl d=27 5435 311t2019
t69 - Ory-in/Flashing
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 140 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Permit Application Status - CityView Portal Page 2 of 2
Oo.uments & I6ages
Oate File Type
Uplo.d.d
o7 /26l20ta
07/27 /2014
o7 /27 t20r8
o7 /27 l20tg
07/3t/2OrA
oz/20t2ot9
02/20/2019
rr 003.odr
Eeldt
Pevm.nt Slip lPRl
lnsm.tion lob Card
Receipt for tcn$ction: 2018-065896
EXr- PR4D2018074547501 - Feb 20 2019 14-50-16.odf
Pavment Slip lPRl
Cor.don l:
st t!B:
o.tc St.tus Ch.ngcd:
Commcnts:
Pass with Inspector Notes
08/r3/2018
P.ss with Inspedor Notes:
- Peel and stid, ridge, valley and edg€
8.13.18//(M
170 - R.-1661Final I
hftp://cvportal.colliergov.neVCityViewWeb/PermiVStatus?permirl d=27 5435 3/t/2019
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 141 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
ISSUED:
NTASTER #:
PR8D201807454750t
BY:
COA:
PERMIT
PERi\{I'I #I
JOBADDRESS:1965 Isla De Palma CIR
JOB DESCRIPTION: tile re-roof 6il2 pitch 45 sq polyglass tumax underlayment
1955 isla de palmo cir
GOLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
JOB PHONE
BLOCK
ZONE:ELEVATION:
SECTION-TOWIISHIP-RANGE: 28-48-26
CONTRACTOR INFORMATION:
APPROVAL DATE: 07-27-l 8
SEWER:
CONTACT NAME
O\\NER TNF ORMATION
QUIGLEY, THOMAS & ANGELA
I965 ISLA DE PALMA CIR
NAPLES, FL 34I 19-
FCC CODE
CONSTRUCTIONCODE: 0220
JOB VALUE: $34,260.00
SETBACKS FRONT:
FLOzuDA ROOF SERVICES LLC
4505 9TH STREET EAST
2605 FOREST PARKWAY NORTH LARGO FL
33771
ELLINGTON, FL 34222
CERTIFICATE #:PHONE
REAR:
TOTAL RES SOFT: 0
LEFT:
TOTAICOMM SOFT: 0
RIGHT:
WATER:
CONTACT PHONE
Per Collier County Ordinance No. 2002-01, as it may be amended, all work must comply with all applicable laws, codes, ordinances, and any additional
stipulations or conditions ofthis permit. This permit expires if work authorized by the permil is not commenced within six (6) months from the date of
issuancr ofthe permit. Additional fees for failing to obtain permits prior to the commencement ofconstruction may be imposed. Permiftee(s) further
understands that any cantmctor that may be employed must be a licensed conlractor and that the strucfure must not be used or occupied until a
Certificate ofOccuparcy is issued.
NOTICE: PRIOR TO THE REI\IOVAL OF ASBESTOS PRODUCTS OR THE DEN{OLITION OF A STRUCTURE, FEDERAL
AND STATE LAWS REQUIRE THE PERMITTEE (EITHER THE OWNER OR CONTRACTOR) TO SUBMIT A NOTICE OF
THE INTENDED WORK TO THE STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION (DEP). FOR MORE
INFORMATION, CONTACT DEP AT (239) 344-5600.
In addition to the conditiolls of this permit, there may be additional restrictions applicable to this property that may be found in
the public records of this cou[ty, and there may be additional permits required from other governmental entities such as water
management districts, state agencies, or federal agencies.
WARNING TO OWNER: YOUR FAILURE TO RECORD A NOTICE OF
COMMENCEMENT MAY RESULT IN YOUR PAYING TWICE FOR IMPROVEMENTS
TO YOUR PROPERTY. IF YOU INTEND TO OBTAIN FINANCING, CONSULT WITH
YOUR LENDER OR AI{ ATTORNEY BEFORE RECORDING YOUR NOTICE OF
COMMENCEMENT.
STIBDIVISION #:
FLOOD MAP:
FOLIO #: 72650012243
PERMIT TYPE: RO
APPLIED DATE: 07-26-18
LOT:
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 142 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
STATE CtRTtFIED ROOFING CONTRACTOR LICEIISE '" CCC1331226
S-IATE CERTIFIED RESIDENTIAL BUTLDING CONTRACIOB LICENSI T CRC13Ei792
F[.OR[DA RCI@F SERVICES [-{.C
2505 FOREST PARKWAY NORTH LARGO, FLORIDA 33771
PHONE 8?7-844-4300 FAx941-7?2-8982
SALES AGREE|YIENT
BETWEEN THE COI\ITRACTOR AND THE CUSTAMER NAMED BELOW
PE{@NE Z3 F4-?4o
FFtr@NE o
ADDR.ESS a clT'Y/zIP
EIlflA[[-Dpn q coln
TI{E GO CTOR HEREIN AG REES ro F RNTSH MATERIALS aru-o laeoc ro CoMPLETE THE FoLLowtNG:
!zuGLE, flIl ETA!-ooF:
OLD ROOF TO SMOOTH WORIOABLE SURFACE- REPLACE ANY Ro'rTED wooD XTRA @ S9o Pcr sheet &S7 per foot'
RENAIL WOODEN ROOF DECKING TO RAFTER S }YITH RING SHANK NAJLS tN AGCORDANCE WTTH CURRENT CODES.
APPLYNEw4sEcoNDARYWATERREStsTANiaARRtER.UNDERLAYMENToVERENTIREDEctc
INSTALL NEW FHA.TVA EAVE DRIP..'YiIHITE...BROI/VH...ELACK..'GALVANIZED
HERE NECESSARY
NS AND NEW VENT HOODS AT AIR EXHAUST
NAME
Additional conditions-
FI BERGLASS SHIN
PORTS. .
-{coLoR)-- __ (coloR)
INSTALL NEW VALLEY METAL AND ME-I AL FLASHING W
INSTALL NEW LEAD BOOTS AT PL.UMBING PFNETRATIO;;;;;;u ,u,.'. _cpac&
-ru (coLoR)
A. INSTALL _ --. FEET OF RIDGE VENT --
-
FEET OF OFF RIDGE VENT"'WHITE..'BROWN..'BLACH..'
,G') cleatt up JoBsrrE oF .aLL woRK RELATED DEBRIS AND HAUL awaY'
--- aont*otaoR wrr-r cooRDINATE woRK REr-arED To yHE FoLLovuNG ar AoomoNAL cHARGES-' soLAR uHlrs' RooFToF
ArR CONDIT|oNERS, ROOFTOP r-v- D!SHE5, SKYLIGHTS. AND FALLEN SOFFlrr & FASC]A DUE TO EXCESSIVE WOOD ROf.
OOF "LOW SI-OFE" ROOF.., (-fFO !NST'[-ATED ROOF SYS-TEM) OIE (f -PLY TORCH SYS'rEIV})
REM ROOF TO SMOOTH I,IIIOREAtsLE SURFACE. REPLACE ANY ROTTED WOOD XTRA @ S9O PE ShEEt &S7 PET fOOt'
RENAIL WOO F DECKING TO RAFTERS WITH RTNG SHANK NAILS tN ACCORDANCE WTTH CURRENT CODES'
APPLY NEW ASECON RESISTANT BARRIEP.' UNDERLAYMEHT OVER ENTIRE DECK. .--
INSiALL-
-
INSULATI
INS-I ALL NEIA, FHS/VA EAVE
ONB OR TPO SYSTEM (NO TNSULATTON UNDER t-gLY TORCH SYSTETVI.
DRrP -,-lltrlllTE---..ELACK...GALVANIZED...(CTRCLE COLOR OF CHOICE}
INS-I ALL NEW LEAD BOOTS' AIR VENT HOODS AND/OR NGS WHERE I'ECESSARY, -
INS?ALL NEW TPO MEMBRANE COVER OR GRANULATED TO ,COLOR - WHITE.
CLEAN UP JOBSITE OF ALL WORK RELATED DEBRIS AND HAUL AWAY.
ill $or}: ro 'oc pcriom,ed ;n i sortrEnlit. nt,rulcr 3,id ilt conrPltaDc. Ni$ starc aDd locrl cod!'i E'OR THE S0)I O
R
1.
2-
3.
4.
5-
6.
7.
s 4 40P
NOTE . completion is when iostallation work is
complete and iobsite is cleaned. The term completron
shall notinclude thejurisdictional final ;nspection date. tf
applicable, written lr.arranty and iosurance mit;gation
documentation shatl be provided within 3(] days of final
paymeot-
MUNICIPLE & PERMTT FEES
TO?AL
DEPOSIT
Coo q
o o
Roo TII.E
DRA}II A3'(DRY-IN' PLUS WOOD CHARGES
BALANCE UPON COMPLETION
ADD 3i'" !F PAYING BY CREDIT CARD
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 143 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
.?IIE FINE PRIN?"
STATE CERNFI€D ROOFING CONTRACTOR UCENSE # CCC1331226
SIATE CEPJNFIED RESIDENTI]AL BUILDING CONTRACTOR UCENSE # CRC],:}31782
FI.ORfiEA R@OF SERV,"$CES [.N.C
2605 FOREST PARI(VUAY NORTH LARGO, FLORIDA 33771
PHONE 8Z-844-8300 FA;(9D.a-722-A982
S/-\LES AGREE14ENT
EEIIIJEEN TiiE CO$TRACiOB At\!D TI..IE CUSTOI\'3LB iUAfulED BEI-OW
sfter t oB 3t! tLL s5rcolcnt . T1ri .-r: ilsn cosEae or or oloc
GEncirl docs6a& fo prcml.c orira tho tLo5..Fci6<.d\ s€I fott!:n dtc corlFct dodecnE erralr b. *coiEi?d br- cirtrG pirE],.
3. ft i. Ed.rttaod .nd .grea thi. tLiB cortEct 5l!ll nol bc l,ildirg upor tlrc corrndoi urril signrd ,!d accrptcd bt, rn otficcr oadrc collrrcroa
3. Thc con=actor rca.i'a t:,e d:J,t to bidrDii o.rrcrinli oI cqual or grcrtcr r=luc. ,.1n1' c\'rgc: equir.d bv n6rjui:diccioa:J mdr= uy {al]t i! .a.tdo!d .}&Ee-
ftc shall bc tlc ohl;gadon of (ltc pEdr.9.r- fLe @uu'actor crciec vo*cr coaper=rjoo ord gcocEl l!:5ility iurane appliebtc to rlc !.orl bci'g Ptrfor €C-
5. f U-\:EES ITIGST t0 C-1-\C-EL II jro do not rrat ihc goo& rd *iie:, yoo al..ry crrcd dd, f,:r"-cE.,r by prolldiog Nrirre @!ie ro rlc c.d!'i.ror ir p.rso!. ira
t&gno or $' a:!- T]]is:oric. r,o,! ino-icatc l}.aFu do Eot rin! th. goodi r *-ic.- f,nd,Et;. dalii'crcd o, po.tarJrdl 5.foc E;dEi-hr of rt. rid bE;jled-
ud bc ooolzed Lr:oD6-i'_r.k
6.
aarlror otltr prr6 of t}. IIopcEl auring drc ddn'!D'of natcridr aui thr rcarocnl oltht 1ro!:r Flir.d dcbli1 Fsl.,Bor. rle conaaao: ir lFld trale ic ort-
Cm:cr !o -1.|C lilr3. clectn-ot liar-:, pluabins lirE ana any otlr i.cLadel co*po.cne t!"r E:-... L:u bcs ;E5lopcrlv ;Etl]Ica r@ doE. ro tLE t@rDr d...]ll a E
to allat ,6-L or s. tladE to D6.t1itc o, 6t ut of rele
noac- Sirq'dry: bcfo= you 5r;g anl lcgJ "cEcr t'ou E-5'. drlirrr to oth$prrt}'to lii.ortica a b:irtcJ! Dorie rfcllirs ro chapttr sss of uy rtl.g.a 6ErEaio!
d!',.r. od ro dsid-r EiE!S !a ofrc. to rcpa;r o:g:y for tlc ellegcd o":rneion defe-- f'o rc ror obltrr.d !o.cc?p! ey ora dri& ray be rade. ?llt't ari:ti
dadliac uder thir Fio;di5t!!o!c slicll EusL bc nrt sod (ollord to plotect l-oEr iot rrjtr-
CoD.riucio! IDdui:i.r n.cora)- Fund pa)'trenr mry bE ariilihlc GoEr tlc CIEP if1'or lorc ronrl' oo a pojecr For iafornerior rbont thc rorcr; fuod erd 6liag c
cldE coEt ct tl. FloriCu Cortncdor Indus5'IjeEi€ B€rd rr tltc foUotr;g id.?I&,c EEat . !!d :ddrFr-.,90,!-t:7{S30... :960 jrlia3:oo Esprcamn Scitc 3
J.c*ac! . Ftoi& 32:11-?.'6?.
AUIEB {CtrO\S'I;EDGES RECEIPTOtr{ COPI OFtf S -:I,GREEUE:\-T:[nS
-
.D-l.Y OIr-....'...-
DO NOT SIGN IIIIS EO}II,] TIIPRO\T]IENT CONTR.{CT IE BLANK. YOU ,.!RE EN'TITLED TO -4. COPY Ol' IIIIS CO]\TR.{(T
.,I.T TEE TttTE YOU SIGN. TIIIS CONTRACT }I.{Y CR},,{T1.] ..\ I,DI}i OR FOFF:CI,OSURE ON YO LiN PROPERfi' IF I{OT PAII
{purctEser)(DA?E)
(sal on)(purchaser)(DAiE)
Ravi<-C 7 lrz4lztt'.5
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 144 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Prootor Flnanclal lnc,
5225 Crooks Rdl
Troy, Ul !aO€8-2823 BAYVIE\^/'
LOARSEnv]CTNO
IH' FACE OF TI]IS DodJMENT HAs A COTOBEO SACKO BOU NO ON WII]IE PAPEB
Tho Huntington Bank
660
0001056773
DO NOT CONVERT TO ACH
03i7
0721
AMOUNT
***$11,520,00
VOIO IF N OT CASHEO WTIIIN 90 DAYS
Da"*-ft^rX'
AUTHORIZEO SIGNATURE
TO
THE ORDER
OF
THOMAS J QUIGLEY and
Florlda Roof Sorvtcss LLC
{965 ISLA DE PALMA CIR
NAPLES, FL 34119
5
'n55555
luungl@msunaouqfiqnq nlE 8 aR OF TIIS OOCUMEIII CONT TNS AN AnTlFlClA! WATEBI{AR,<-IIOLO Ar A,t ANGLE IOVIEW
N
(.',
ccount
mount
aak
ate
outing
SD
rquence
:rial
Lta I
ta2
,tllll llh,L
Nr.'(\
1 1017
1012001
[-eEEaRT6.-'l [-m/DAYri R -l
1ifim61
FOR PAYI4ENT OF RESTRICTED ESCROW
PAY,..
Elsvon Thousand Flve Hundr6d Tw€nty Dollars and 00 Cents
o
$11,s20.00
101
20180730
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 145 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
iIE FAC€OF S -\OC' 'C'I HAS A COLOREO EACKGFOIJND ON 9JHIIE PAPEFI
... Srodgr Flnorlclaljnc. , ., ':: 5225 CrookS Rl:, ,'' , .:
.., i.oiilt{aros8.r€23' ' .BI\YVIEW'
. .The Hunungton Bank ,
': ;'- '.-'.669 ,. . ,:...!
,: ;,.000105-6773 ';.
..'.,,oo,ror coNGnliolcH,,,.l0AllSERYlclflB r:
Florlda Roof Servlces LLC
0347
0f24
8t09t2018
AI,IQUNT I***$11,520.00
IFNOT CASHEDWTHJN90DA
FOR PAYMENT OF RESTRICTED ESCROW
PAY
ereven rtriusdii{ rlve rlunorau.rw;;il Dd1iirS,11a oo Cr:nts ,r ,
:
TO THOMAS J OUIGLEY and -
THE ORDER'oF ..
...".::,. . i, .-, j:. 1
:ij. :i -. j 'I i
NAPL,:]ES,
f965 ISLA DE PALMA CIR
34119 D**./**y
nr€B^ck oF iHls oocuMElrr coM rNs !N ABTlFrclaL warEBMAnK-HoLD Ar AN aNGLEio vlEw
:. AUTHORIZEO SIGNATURE
MO,DAYI/R
t-
N.N
I.,
!CCOrlnt
\mOunt
lank
latE
-outing
sn
equence
erial
alal
*a2
$11,520.00
101
720913801
11195
720912196
1012001
,J.
...:
t,;
I
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 146 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Gum phJack
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Attachments:
MeulenbergTimothy
Friday, November 30, 2018 10:09 AM
Jwrayl@yahoo.com'
FW: 1965 Isla De Palma CIR. Permit #PBRD20L80745475
Notice of Non-Compliance (Expired Permit)-Florida Roof Services, LLC
Wosniak.docx
- Peter E
Mr. Jeff Rayl (in care of Peter E. Wozniak)
Please deliver this Notice of Non-Compliance to Mr. Wozniak for his signature and return. I have included the email sent
yesterday that I have yet to receive a response. I am trust this job must have slipped someone's attention with the
amount of work allocated to addressing damage related to Hurricane lrma but this case needs to be given greater
consideration.
ln add ition to the return of this notice, I would a ppreciate an update as to the status of the tile order and planned date
of installation. The owner has experienced some leakage and based upon his record of communication and my personal
experience, someone needs to take responsibility for improved communication.
Respectfully,
Tim Meulenberg
Licensing Compliance Officer
(2391 2s2-8023
C,M,
From: MeulenbergTimothy
Sent: Thursday, November 29, 2018 9:42 AM
To:'jwrayl@yahoo.com' <jwrayl@yahoo.com>
Subject: 1965 lsla De Palma ClR. Permit #PBRD201,8O745475
I have been assigned the task to follow up on the status of this perm it with an a pplicatio n date of 7 /26/78 a nd a Dry-in
inspection passed with inspector notes on 8/13/78. Since 8/13/18, there has not been any subsequent activity on this
project and the owner has made payments of S11,520 each on 7/25/78 and 8/9/L8.
I have left a message at 727.687.7630 a nd I have attempted to leave messages on 877 .844.8300 but the mail box is
full. Please advise as to the status of tile delivery and installation for the reference subject property.
Respectfu lly,
Tim Meulenberg
Licensing Compliance Officer
(239\ Zs?-8O23
Qounty
1
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 147 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
G u m phJack
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
MeulenbergTimothy
Thursday, November 29, 2018 9:42 AM
Jwrayl@yahoo.com'
1965 Isla De Palma ClR. Permit #PBRD201.80745475
I have been assigned the task to follow up on the status of this permit with a n application date of 7 /26/LB and a Dry-in
inspection passed with inspector notes on 8/13/18. Since 8/13/18, there has not been any subsequent activity on this
pro.ject and the owner has made payments of S 11,520 each on 7 /25/tg and 8/9/18.
I have left a message at 727.687.7630 and I have attempted to leave messages on 877.844.8300 but the mail box is
full. Please advise as to the status of tile delivery and installation for the reference sub.ject property.
Respectfully,
Tim Meulenberg
Licensing Compliance Officer
(239) 252-8023
nL-,
cfiffi,Cownxy
1
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 148 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
GumphJack
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Attachments:
J eff,
I checked on the status of the order of Crown Tile for 1965 lsla De Palma Circle and it appears it was placed
approximately a month a.go which would place the order well after the date of the owner making a second payment on
August 8, 2018. ln the mean time if there is a better phone number for me to use, please let me know. At this end, I will
continue to explain to the public, the significant demand on roofing contractors and the shortage of specific tile choices
at my end.
jeff, as a reminder, lwill still need the attached Notice of Non-Compliance signed by Peter E. Wozniak and returned to
me.
Tim Meulenberg
Licensing Compliance Officer
(239) 2s2-8023
-Ac,fiffi,Qovtnty
From: jwrayl <jwrayl@yahoo.com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 04, 2018 8:14 AM
To: MeulenbergTimothy <Timothy.Meulenberg@colliercountyfl.gov>
Subject: Re: 1965 lsla De Palma ClR. Permit SPBRD2018O7 45475
Tim,
We have been requesting delivery dates on our tile loads on a regular basis. The manufacturers have been vague and
non committal with their responses. We have tile orders for 5 jobs on the books right now for the collier county area.
The most recent tile order release (oddly enough) has been for the most recent order we placed. lt has created a very
frustrating situation for contractor and homeowner alike.
We will make an effort to communicate this information to our customers this week.
Thanks,
Jeff
Florida roof services
Sent on my Boost Mobile Samsung Galaxy 58
MeulenbergTimothy
Tuesday, December 04, 2018 10:45 AM
lwrayl'
RE: 1965 Isla De Palma CIR. Permit #P8RO20180745475
Notice of Non-Compliance (Expired Permit)-Florida Roof Services, LLC. - Peter E.
Wosniak.docx
Respectfu lly,
1
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 149 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
I have been assigned the task to follow up on the status of this perm it with a n a pplication dale of 7 /26/1,8 a nd a Dry-in
inspection passed with inspector notes o n 8/1,31L8. Since 8/13/18, there has not been any subsequent activity on this
project and the owner has made payments of S11,520 each on 7/Z5lLB and 8/9/L8.
I have left a message at 727 .687 .7630 and I have attempted to leave messages on 877.844.8300 but the mail box is
full. Please advise as to the status of tile delivery and installation for the reference subject property.
Respectfully,
Tim Meulenberg
Lice nsing Compliance Officer
(239\ 2s2-8023
Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. lf you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a
public records request, do not send electronic mail to this eotity. lnstead, contact this office by telephone or in writing.
2
----- Origina I message --------
From: MeulenbergTimothy <Timothv.Meulenberq(acolliercountvfl.sov>
Date: !L/29178 8:41 AM (GMT-06:00)
To : jwlay@ya_b-q9=!9-!0
EI
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 150 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Gu m phJack
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
jwrayl <jwrayl@yahoo.com>
Tuesday, December 04, 2018 8:14 AM
MeulenbergTimothy
Re: 1965 Isla De Palma CIR. Permit #P8RD20L80745475
Tim,
We have been requesting delivery dates on our tile loads on a regular basis. The manufacturers have been vague
and non committal with their responses. We have tile orders for 5 jobs on the books right now for the collier
county area. The most recent tile order release (oddly enough) has been for the most recent order we placed. It
has created a very frustrating situation for contractor and homeowner alike.
We will make an effort to communicate this information to our customers this week.
Thanks,
Jeff
Florida roof services
Sent on my Boost Mobile Samsung Galaxy S8
------ Origiral message --------
From : MeulenbergTimothy <Timothy. Meulenberg@colliercountyfl . gov>
Date:11129118 8:41 AM (GMT-06:00)
To: jwrayl@yahoo.com
Subject: 1965 Isla De Palma CIR. Permit #P8RD20180745475
I have left a message at727.687.7630 and I have attempted to leave messages on 877.844.8300 but the mail box
is full. Please advise as to the status of tile delivery and installation for the reference subject property.
Respectfully,
Tim Meulenberg
Licensing Compliance Offi cer
I have been assigned the task to follow up on the stafus ofthis permit with an application date of 7/26118 and a
Dry-in inspection passed with inspector notes on 8/13/18. Since 8/13/18, there has notbeenany subsequent
activity on this project and the owner has made payments of $ I I ,520 each on 7 /25/18 and 8/9/1 8.
1
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 151 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Notice of Non-Compliance
BE lT KNOWN THAT l, the person whose signature appears below, do hereby formally acknowledge,
agree and consent as follows:
THAT a certain case, case S CE M 1520180014738, involving me has recently been investigated by the
Collier County Contractor Licensing Department.
THAT the said Department had made it known to me that, in the Department's view, lviolated State
(Florida Building code section 105.1) and county (ordinance ?006-46, as amended,4.1.6 & 4.1.18)
licensing laws in said case, by neglecting oversite of a re-roof permit, receiving money in excess of the
value of work performed and having failed or refuse to perform any work for a 90-day period that has
subjected occupants to potential water damage. Dry-in inspection passed with inspector notes on
8/13/18 no work since and no proof of tile order as of the date of this notice,
Type of Work: Tile re-roof 6:12 pitch 45 sq. Polyglass Tumax Underlayment and Tile that must conform
with HOA requirements of Crown Tile Tuscany Style - Tan, (specifically) Sand Dollar ATSS011.
THAT the said Department has explained to me that all contracting work, including BUT NOT LIMITED
TO: home or business improvement, residential or commercial, remodeling, renovation, addition, repair,
alteration, plumbing, electrical, roofing, pool construction, air conditioning, sheet metal, aluminum and
alarm contractor work,all reouire the issuance and nalntenance of a valid Building Permit prior to
mencement and thro hout workin on a rmit re uired bu ild in
P rint
r
Signature of Notary
ffi :iff J ffi:', "x%l.l'ii 311,"" " " "
Location of work: 1965 lsla De Palma CIR; Naples, FL 34119
Date of Site visit - November 29, 2018
THEREFORE, BEING FULLY ADVISED, I DO AGREE that I will obtain and maintain in current status, all
Building Permits required by Statutes and fully understand that if lcommence work without obtaining or
maintaining necessary Building Permits in the future, the Contractor LicensinB Department will consider
that a willful code violation where penalties and restrictions to Building Permit privileges may follow.
Witness my signature (Contractor)
Peter Edward Wozniak
State of: Florida, lssuance f: CCC1331225, WOZNIAK. PETER EDWARD
County of: Collier, lssuance f: 1CC20170002115, FtORIDA ROOF SERVICES. LtC.
The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this _ (date) by
., id"ntifi..ti-lnd *ho diliii-t. k" r'l'hohas
ProoJced
-
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 152 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
C
Date 3/7/20'19 3:18:28 PM
.net Report Title:Code Case Details
CaseNumber: CEM1S20180008081
Case Number cEMts20'180008081
Misconduct
Normal
JuanGuzman
Contractor's Licensing
Origin Complaint
Homeowner reports that roofing company, Florida Roof Services, LLC' installed the
underlayment improperly and now has several leaks. Homeowner is requesting another 169'
Dry-in/Flashing inspection, before the roofing company proceeds with job'
Permit# PRBD201 80422436 EXPIRED as ot 1?J2U18
4841 1xh ST NE, Naples
(FLN 39597840003)
lnvestigation
6/6/2018 10: :01 AM
Entered By JuanGuzman
Case Disposition Case Pending
Address 4841 l2th ST NE, Naples
Complainant SIMON, ROLEX N NATACHA C SIMON
Contractor
Prope(y Owner SIMON, ROLEX N NATACHA C SIMON
Oualifier WOZNIAK, PETER EDWARD
Business Management & Budget Offlce
Case Type:
Priority:
lnspector:
Jurisdiction:
Detail Description:
Location Comments:
Status;
Date & Time Entered:
Propedy 139597840003
FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES LLC
1
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 153 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Code Case Details Execution Oale 31712019 3:18:28 PM
Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments
Preliminary lnvestigation JuanGuzman 6t6t2018 6t6t2018 Unfounded Complaint ot roofing company installing
underlayment improperly, causing several
leaks on roof. On 6/6/18 I called homeowner
Rolex Simon, he indicated that he has called
the roofing company, Florida Roof Servrces.
LLC. and they will not return his calls.
I spoke to Jeffrey Rayl of Florida Roofing
Services, LLC. her stated that he was
surprised that irr. Simon filed a complaint with
this office, since, he (Jeffrey) has had crews
at Mr. Simon's house, attempting to identity
the leak He said that he understands Mr.
Simons frustration and believes they have
made the proper corrections. He said he
would be more than willing to call for another
inspection before moving forward on the roof,
if that satisfies Mr. Simon. At this time I am
unable to establish a Conkactor Licensing
Violation, ladvised Mr. Simon acf,ordingly,
(GuzmanJuan 06/06/2018'12r56 PM) this
case is submitted as unfounded pending any
further developments.
Generate Closure Documentation JuanGuzman 6t6t2018 6/6/2018 Complete
Preliminary lnvestigation JuanGuzman 12t26/2018 12t26t2018 Needs
lnvestigatio
n
On 12126118 Homeowner, stopped by GMD
office to advise that his roof has not been
completed and the dryway is starting to
appear mold. lrr. Simon left his contact
information with contractor licensing front
desk. Research shows that permit
#PRBD2018022436 is expired. lcalled Mr.
Simon and anformed him that lwould reopen
his case and would also contact the
contractor to inform of the expired permit.
I contacted Florida Roof Services. LLC. at 1-
877-844-8300 (Guzm anJuan 1212612018
'12:33 PM) and left a detailed message
regarding this matter.
Cont. lnvestigation JuanGuzman 12t28t2018 12t28t2018 Complete I emailed contractor and advised him oI
expired permit status, also on Mr. Simon's
new complaint on the mold.
Cont lnvestigatjon JuanGuzman 1t3t2019 1t3t2019 Complete Called Peter Wozniak, qualifier of Florida
Roof Services and left message.
Cont. lnvestigation luanguzman 1t24t2019 1t24t2019 Complete Mr. Simon called inquiring about case, he has
submitted complaint to DBPR. I advised him
that Florida Roof Services, LLC., has not
returned our calls. I also called Florida Roof
again and left another message.
Business Management & Budget Office 2
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 154 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Code Case Details Execution Dale 31712019 3:'18:28 PM
Desc Assigned Required Comploted Outcome Comments
Cont. lnvestigation JuanGuzman 2t5t2019 2t5t2019 Complete After several attempts to contact Mr. Wozniak,
by myself, CLO Jack Gump and Tim
Meulenberg; all who have cases on Florida
Roof Services, LLC, CLO Jack Gump sent
qualifier Mr. Wozniak a Notice to Appear
before the Contractor Licensing Board to
answer to charges of violations on permit #'s
PRBD201 80529401, PRBD20'l 80422436 and
PR8D20180745475
The notice was sent certified mail on 1/15/19:
USPS records show that letter was delivered
on 1/30/19 at 1 l:52 am.
Green Card return receipt, received on 2/5/19
confirmed by Mr. Woznrak's signature.
Cont. lnvestigation JuanGuzman 2t21t2019 2t22t2019 Complete Florida Roof Services, LLc, has not contacted
our office regarding this complaint or 2 others,
however records show that they submitted an
Permit Extension form which was processed
on 2120119.
Cont lnvestigation JuanGuzman 2t22t2019 2t25t2019 Complete On2l22l19l did a site visit and spoke to
Rolex Simon. He stated that Jeffrey Rayl had
been in contact with him, and delivered
several pallets of roof tile. He said, he was
informed by Mr. Rayl that the tile would be
going up in the next few days.
JuanGuzman 3t712019 3t7t2019 Complete Mr. Simon emailed me copy of contract,
payment and DBPR complaint confirmation
Records show that he signed contract with
Florida Roof Services LLC on, 4/3/18 and
made an initial payment of 12,984, then on
4/25118 an additional payment of $'12,983.
A permit application was submitted on 4i3l18
and issued the next day.
Once he was satisfied of Florida Roof
Services response to his complaint, and the
contractor was in compliance this case was
closed.
On '12126118 Mt. Simon requested case
reopen, as it had been over 180 days that
Florida Roof Services LLC. had not been at
his house, and permit was expired.
Several attempts to contact Florida Roof
Services LLC have gone unanswered
Subsequent to scheduling board hearang,
FRS, LLC, has done a second layer
underlayment in January 2019, during which
time permit was expired. The tiles were
delivered and the permit was reactivated on
21221'19. On 3/7/19 a scheduted and passed
'169 - Dry-in/Flashing inspection was made,
however they have not made contact with this
offlce.
3
Cont. lnvestigation
Business Management & Budget OfFlce
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 155 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Code Case Details Execution Dale3l7l2O19 3:18:28 PM
Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments
lnvestigation JuanGuzman 3t20t2019 Pending PRBD201 80422436 Reactivated permit,
Florida Roof Servic€s, LLC. Contractori '1-877
-844-8300
4821 12th St NE, Naples, Rolex Simon
property owner.
Pending Board hearing 312012019
Entered Corrected Amount CommentsFI'ft?IViolation Description
IE
ConditionTitleReasonResultCompliance@@
Business Management & Budget Office 4
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 156 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
&3.8uIdrBlype
8.4- P€tmitt€e Tlpe:
Property lnbrmation
8.5. Parce/Folio :
8.6. lob Street Address:
CounL!
C.o,r0t ira16oorYE f DopsrfiEar
must
. Prlmary Pennft f O',y,
BUI IDING PERMII APPUCANON
2800 N. HORSESHOE DR., NAPLES, Fl 34104 I TEL: (239)252-2400
8.7. O\rner Name:
8.8. G^,ner Phqle:
B.9.SubdMsion:
Lot/8lod,/Unit:
8.10.sDP/Prr:
8.11. 'Pff Filena.ne:
'Opt tpl -ssqch t,ittiv FktunB@ 5tvvew Pottol.
lnstructiJrls to
&2. Master Pennit { doryI
Motile,4vlanulactured horn€
O Design erolesslonal
O Residentiallunts,/irult-family QCo.nmerc'at
Q Our,er SriU.t
Contractor lnformatbn
8.12. Ucene fr:
8.13. Conpany Name:
8.14. Qualifier Name:
8.15. Contact Nam€:
8.15. Conpany Addreis:
f//?-1l7tw .i/aec.
Pleose
(t'r a z ran,ity owetr,,E no,rnhoose
@cIx,tGla*
''%1't84oooJ
491/ nrt ..f/r tt€
Slry,Eazl
/to Ftl oi fi l3 ;r rlTo 4 7 / 8.17. Corrparry Phoe:
8.18. Fax f:
B.19.a. "Email 1
B.19.b. "Email2
tr "lb rd o* EnlE,;lls)6 yinory cdltxt n*M
Sectim C Aldicatifi lrfonnation
Ltc EPLUMB Cl MEcr-l
L2.
c3.
C4. CqEtuction TWe:
C5. Occupancyi
C5. Water S€rvice:
C7. s€\rer S€rvice:
D.1. Desqiptron of Work le,a**btu|: D.2. Project Name ay'diyl:
o
E s€ptic E Lor./vdtage E shutters E EtECtlrom hou!€ EGas
C8. tire SprinkH:
C.9. Pemit byAffid it
C1O. fti!.ate Pro,/ir6:
C.11, Ihreshold Building:
C-12. Ve8etation Oearing:
c.13.Reiared ro 0AMAGES |NCURREDSy HURRTCANE |RMA: or* o
D.3. Declared Value: S
S€diorl D. Pr*rt lnfnmatiot
D,4. R€sHertbl S+ ft.:
New Const (colrpbre o4o e a4h,
Mditio^' lb"'dete DAa a a1.h)
AJteration rcry,pbk D, ( ,
05. Cor rt€ ddsq. Ft:
New Const. /Conpk P a5 a & o-tb,
Ad,diltcrfl lcd'r*t osa &Dtb.)
Alteration larnpElE asc,l
D.4.a. New Const.Or.b. Wort Area (Sq. ft)
D t h, Living:
D.4.hr Noo.lMnS: _
TOTAI O
0.4.c Wo* Area {5a. FL)
o.4c' ti\ring
D.4.i. Non-livinS: _
TOTAI-: 0
O.4.d. Tota& by Area
fuI^lNclii,g 0
f Sto.i6:
f Unitsi
f Bedrooms:
I gathrooms:
0.5.a. N6./ Consl Ds.b. wolk &ea (5q. FL)
lnterio.l
Exterioc
TOTAi o
O.5.c Wod( &ea {5C, Fl)
lnterior: _
Exterior:
TOTAL:
, Stories:
f Unats:
S€rdon E, Stafi Secudt
E.2. Number of Plan S€ts .
-
E.3. Review Days:wr 1510 15
E.1. FinalReview Date:
qev!:ed 0atei 1ll29/17 v2 Thrs rs page 1 oi f pages of the Buildin8 Permrt Applicalion Plea5e submit all 3 paSet when completed
Diedbns:
LL Pe,Irili 6db p.ei
?7? 8*/ R3@_
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 157 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
o6.::..'BUII.DING PERMIT APPIJCA]]ON
2800 N. HORSTSHOE DR., NAPLES, FL 34104 | IEL: (239) 252'2400
NOTICE OF COLLIER COUNTY ADDITIONAL REGULATIONS
NOTICE OF AODITIONAL RESTRICTIONS: ln addition to the requirements of this permit, there may be
additional restrictions applicable to this property that may be found in the public records of this County,
and there may be additional permits required from other governmental entities such as the Water
Management District, State agencies, or Federal agencies.
WARNING OF POSSIBLE DEED RESTRICTIONS: The land subject to this permit may be subject to deed,
and other restrictions that may limit or impair the landowner's rights. Collier County is not responsible
for the enforcement of these restrictions, nor are Collier County employees authorized to provide legal
or business advice to the public relative to these restrictions. The landowner or any applicant acting on
behalf of the landowner is cautioned to seek professional advice.
WARNING OF WORK lN THE COUNTY RIGHT-OF-WAYS: This permit does not authorize construction or
installation of any structure or utility, above or below ground, within any right of way or easement
reserved for access, drainage or utility purposes. This restriction specifically prohibits fencing, sprinkler
systems, landscaping other than sod, signs, water, sewer, cable and drainage work therein. lf such
improvements are necessary, a separate permit for that purpose must be obtained from the Growth
Management Department.
NOTICE OF CLEARING RESTRICTIONS: The issuance of a building permit for a single-family dwelling
allows up to one (1) acre of native vegetataon to be cleared. Clearing more than one (1) acre may be
allowed for accessory structures and requires a separate Vegetation Removal Permit. Properties
located in the following zoning district overlays may not be allowed to clear one (1) acre: Rural Fringe
Mixed Use District (RFMU), Big Cypress Area of Concern (ACSC), and Special Treatment Overlay (ST).
There may be additional restrictions related to clearing native vegetation and ,mpacts to wetlands or
protected species found on the property. State and Federal agency permits may be required. Contact
the Growth Management Department's Environmental Services at (239) 252-24OO for additional
information. lssuance of a Demolition Permit for a structure does not authorize removal of vegetation
beyond the footprint of the structure. A Demo Permit is not a clearing permit.
WORK lN THE SPECIAL FLOOD HAZARD AREA: Be advised that Substantial Da mage/Substantial
lmprovement requirements will apply to structures located in the Special Flood Hazard Area with
Finished Floor Elevations below the Base Flood Elevation.
By initialing, I am acknowled8ing that I have read and understand this Notice of Collier County
Additional Regulations.
ln it ia
o er or Aqent of Owner's or Controctor's initiols ore required.
n€v 1l 29 2Or7 v2 This
'5
page 2 ol 3 pager o, the Eurlding permit Application. please ,ubmit all 3 pa8e5 when completed_
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 158 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
.1L..-.-"BUII.DING PERMIT APPt'CANON
2800 N. HORSESHOE DR., NAPtEs, tl 34104 | IEL: (2191152-24oO
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF COTTIER COUNTY REGULATIONS
Application is hereby made to gbtain a permat to do the work and installations as indicated. I certity that no work or installation har
commenced prior to the issuance of a permit and that all work will be performed to meet the standards of all laws re8ulating
construation in thi5 iurisdiction. The permit or application fee may have additional fees imposed for failing to obtain permits prior to
commencement of construction.
The approved permit and/or permit applacation expire5 if not commenced within 180 days from rhe date o, issuance. The permittee
further understands that only licensed contractors may be employed and that the structure will not be used or occupied until a
certificate of occupancy is igsued, By signinS this permit application, I a6ree that I have been retaaned by the owner/permittee to
provide contractjng services for the trade for which I am listed. Furthermore, it is my responsibility to notify the Suilding Plan Review
and lnspection Division should I no lon8er be the contractor responsible for providing said contracting services. I further agree that I
understand that the review and issuing of this permit does not erempt me from complvinB with all County Codes and Ordinances. lt
rs rurther understood that the propeny owner/permittee is the owner of the permit
Note: An owner-8uild€r must complete Sectionr A and I and the owner-Suildei Aftidavit form.
SECTI . OWNER or AGENT OF OWNER ACKNOWLEDGTMTNT. The contractor rrlay sign as the Agent of owner so long as
Co sco act Owner pe its su.h action:?a+u tlt 2t\a ll/
6r Ow Ag
Th regoinB instrument was acknowledged before me thas
ame of Owner o, Agent ofOwner)lPr'nt n
/n) o"r*
cation of identifici
(name of person) who ersonall
, zo1$_oy
kn to me, or who hasrs.
JEFFERY W RAYL
MY COMMTSSTON ' FF206995
d8trhes u",.r, r: zo,s
tLrrlfi.ri 1*(, ,.r : dr
produced identifi
Notary Signature
SE CONTRACTOR OWLEOGEMENT:
gnature o f Contract "/(Prini name of Cont.actor)
The foregoing instrument was acknowledged belore me this ,{o/ a"y ot ,. zotjS av
(name kn to ha5
produced identific
Notary Signature:
ation (type of dentific
NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT INFORMATION
Per tlorida Statutes 713.135 a Notice of Commencement (NOC) is required ior construction of improvements totaling more than
52,5O0, with certain exceptions. For A/C Repai15 or Replacements a notrce of commencement rs required for ,mprovementt more than
or equal to S7,S0O. The applicant shall file with the is5uing authority prior to thc Iirst inspection either a certified copy of the recorded
NOC or a notarited statement that the NOC has been filed for recording, along with a copy thereof. ln order to comply with the state
requarement, permits will be placed in inspection hold until proof ol the NOC is filed wrth lhe building permitting and inspection
department The assuing authority shall not perform or approve sub5equenl inspectrons until the applicant files by mail, fa(sloile,
hand delivery, email or any other means such as certified copy with the issuing ai.rthorrty
WARNING TO OWNER: YOUR FAILURE TO RECORD A NoTlcE oF COMMENCEMENT MAY
RESUTT IN YOUR PAYING TWICE FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO YOUR PROPERTY. IF YOU INTEND
TO OBTAIN FINANCING, CONSULT WITH YOUR LENDER OR AN AfiORNEY BEFORE RECORDING
YOUR NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT. A NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT MUST 8E RECORDED
AND POSTED ON THE JOB SITE BEFORE THE FIRST INSPECTION.
rlpv 1t iq 2ot 7 v2 This is page 3 ot I paSes of rhe EurldinS Permit Appli.arrr . pleasc submrl all 3 page! when completed
JEFFERY W RAYL
€xPlftguarch 13 2019
ri,6r\.i rSc'.r!..n
995
of Owner)
/)?
I
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 159 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Permit Application Status - CityView Portal
Permit Application Status
In order to schedule inspections, you need to be signed in.
application Datei
Issued Dale:
Expir.tion Date:
l-2 Family or Comml
GMD Public Portal
Applacalion Number:
Appllcation Typ€:
Applicatlon Status:
Prop€rty Owner's Full N.me:
Category of work:
Occupanc, Cod€:
O€ssiption of work:
PR8020r80422436
Buildin9
hspedions Commenced
SIMON, ROIEX N NATACHA C SIMOIT
Resid€ntial, One and Two Family New o. Guest Hous€
50 SQFT COI{CREIE TILE OVER POLYGL SS r.lAx PEEL N' STICK 6: 12
PTTCH
4841 12TH ST NE
o4lo3l2ot8
04to4l2ot8
09to3t2ot9
1-2 Eamily
Qualrfler
SIMOll, ROLEX N NATACIIA C SIHON, address:4841 l2IH ST NE
!1IOZNIAX, PETER EDWARD, Address:2605 FOREST PARKWaY NORTH ,
Phone:(877) 844-8300, Licens€€ I ICC20170002rl4
ti.€ns€ Status
FLORIDA ROOf SERVICES LLC, Addr€ss:4505 9TH STREET EAST, Phone
(877) 844-8300, Stat€ R€9
'',s
CCC1331225, U.ens.e *
1CC20170002115
u!!0rs.St4trl
Permllr (Clack to S.. Rcvlcw3)
169 - Ory-ln/fl.shlrg
169 - Dryin/Flrshlng
r7O - R.-root Final
3/7/20t9 o3/o7 /2Ot9
Alejandro Pnntoja ((219) 272-96ss) SroAEEril
3t7/2019
5/3/2OtA 05/03/2018
Outstanding
03/o7l20L9
(rBcto7.6) Provide updated altidavit for
s€cond layer of undenayment-.. 03/07lr9
"Tumax underlayment match.s NOA'S
provided,, ok to contjnue hav€ amdavit on
site for 170-.. 03/07l19 AP
LEGACY| Thomas Decram VEN S.nd Email
5/3/zotA
Corre.tion I
Status
Oate Status Cha.ged
Comments
Conecuon 1
Status
oate Status Changed
Comments
o5/o3t20La
Inspe.tor Notes: Affidavit to trlel/oEGRAM
http://cvportal.colliergov.neVCityViewWeb/Permit/Status?permitl d=2527 56 3/812019
Page I of2
Irvr*r:"
l
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 160 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
JOB ADDRESS: 484I I2Ih ST NE
JOB DESCRIPTION: 50 S
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF GOUNTY COMMISSIONERS
PERMIT
PERMIT TYPE: R o
APPLIED DATE: 04-03-18
QFT CONCRETE TILE OVER POLYGLASS MAX JOB PHONE
PEEL N'STICK 6:12 PITCH
48.II I2TH ST NE
APPROVAL DATE: 04-04- l 8
LOT
ZONE: ELEVATION:
SECTION-TOWNSHIP-RANGE: I l-48-27
OWNER INFORMATION
SIMON, ROLEX N NATACHA C SIMON
484I I2TH ST NE
NAPLES, FL 34I20-
FCC CODE
CONSTRUCTIONCODE: 0220
JOB VALUE: $40,700.00
BLOCK
TOTAL COMM SQFT: 0
SETBACKS FRONT:
SEWER:
CONTACT NAME:
LEFT:
WATER:
RIGHT:
CONTACT PHONE
Per Collier County O.dinance No- 2002-01, as it may be amended, all work must comply with all applicable laws, codes, ordioances, and any additional
stipulalions or conditions ofthis permit. This permit expires ifwork authorized by the permit is not conmenced within six (6) monlhs from the date of
issuance oflhe permil. Additional fees for failing to obtain permils prior lo the commencement ofconstruction may be imposed. Permittee(s) furrher
understands that any contmctor that may be employed must be a licensed contractor and that the structure must not be used or occupied until a
Certificate ofOccupancy is issued.
NOTICE: PRIOR TO THE REMOVAL OF ASBESTOS PRODUCTS OR THE DEMOLITION OF A STRUCTURE, FEDERAL
AND STATE LAWS REQTIIRE THE PERMITTEE (EITHER THE OWNER OR CONTRACTOR) TO SUBMIT A NOTICE OF
THE INTENDED WORK TO THE STATE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONJ\IENTAL PROTECTION (DEP). FOR MORE
INFORMATION, CONTACT DEp AT (239) 344-5600.
In addition to the conditions of this permit, there may be additional restrictions applicable to this property that may be found in
the public records of this county, and there may be additional permits required from other governmental entities such as water
management districts, state agencies, or federal agencies.
WARNING TO OWNER: YOUR FAILURE TO RECORD A NOTICE OF
COMMENCEMENT MAY RESULT IN YOUR PAYING TWICE FOR IMPROVEMENTS
TO YOUR PROPERTY. IF YOU INTEND TO OBTAIN FINANCING, CONSULT WITH
YOUR LENDER OR AN ATTORNEY BEFORE RECORDING YOUR NOTICE OF
COMMENCEMENT.
REAR:
PERMIT #: PRBD20t 8042243601
ISSUED: BY:
MASTER#: PRBD20180422433 COA:
SUBDIVISION #:
FLOOD MAP:
FOLIO #: :19597840003
CONTRACTOR INFORMATION:
FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES LLC
4505 9TH STREET EAST
ELLTNGTON. FL 34222
CERTIFICATE #; .NoucENsEb PHONE:
TOTAL RES SOFT: 0
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 161 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
STATE CERTIFIED ROOFING CONTRACTOR TICENSE S CCC1331226
SIATE CERTIFIED RESIDENTIAL BUILDING CONTRACTOR LICENSE # CRC1331782
FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES LLC
2605 FOREST PARKWAY NORTH TARGO, FLORIDA 33771
pHoNE 877-844{300 FAX941-722-8982
SALES AGREEMENT
BETWEEN THE CONTRACTOR AND THE CUSTOMER NAMED BETOW
NAME PHONE
PHONE
ADDRESS 4t GITY/ZIP
EMAIL
THE CONT RACTOR HER REES T FURNISH MATERIALS AND LABOR TO COMPLETE THE FOLLOYYING:
REROOF OH|NOLE, METAL OR T|LE ROOF;
REMOVE OLD ROOF TO SMOOTH WORXABLE SURFACE. REPLACE ANY ROTTED WOOD XTRA @ $90 per sheet &97 per toot,RENAIL WOODET{ ROOF DEGXING TO RAFTERS WITH RIt{G SHANK NAILS IN ACCORDANCE
APPLY I{EU' TSECOT{DARY WATER IIIT BARRIEN' UNDERLAYMENT OVER E TTRE D
WITH CURRENEcK. al)T COOES,
,!tINSTALL NEW FHAJVA EAVE ITRIP BROWI{.,.BLACK,..GALVAt{rZED.
INSTALL NEW VALLEY METAL AND L FLASHING WHERE NECESSARY.
AT MBING PENETRATIONS AND NEW VENT HOODS AT AIR EXHAUST PORTS,
BERGLASS SHINGLESINSTALL N
ttl 5 (coLoR
(coLoR,
(coLoR
1.
2,
3.
4,
5.
6.
7.
8
Additional conditions
BROlt N...BL.ACl(..
REMOVE OLD R OOF T O SMOOTH WORKABLE SU ACE. REPLACE ANY ROTTET' WOOD XTRA @ $90 pe.r sheet &97 per foot.RE WOODEN ROOF D ING TO RAFTE RING S}IANX LS IN ACGORDANCE WITH CURRENT CODES.APPLY "sEcot{oA RESISTA ND YME}IT OVER ENTIRE DECX.INSTALI ULATION UNDER I.PLY TORCH SYSTEM.INSTALL NEW F ..G NtzED...(crRGLE coLOR OF CHOTCE)INSTALL N HOO INGS NECESSARY.INSTALL N TPO MEIIIB ER OR GRAN EO TORCH DOWN,.,CO R - WI TE.CLEAN U JOASITE OF ALL RELATED DEBRIS AND HAUL AWAY.
All work to be pcrfonnad fu a workmonlike rnamcr atrd in complisnce with stalc aod local cod6 FOR TEESUM OF o F
msrALL ........
-
FEEI oF RrDGE VENT F ,.* o
CLEAN UP JOBSITE OF ALL WORN NEIATEO OTANIS AND HAUL10' coNTRAcToR wlLL cooRDl ATE woRK RELTATEII ro rHE FolLowtr{c AT ADDtTtol{AL CHARGES.,. soLAR ut{tTsr RooFTo,AIR CONDITIOT{ERS' ROOFTOP T'V; DISHES, SXYLIGHTS. AND FALLEN SOFFITT & FASCIA DUE TO EXCESSIVE WOOD ROT.
REROOF ..LOW SLO PE" ROOF... (TpO aNSULATED ROOF SYSTEM) OR ({-PLY TORCH SYSTEM)'t.
2,
3.
4.
5.
5,
7.
a,
s
NOTE: Completion is when insta[ation work Igc9Tplot? and jobsite is cte.ned. The t rJtl comptetionshall notinctud-etheiuiisdictionatfinal inspeciio;eat;. i;applicable, written warranty and insuranco mitigafio;documentatigh shall be provlded wlthin 30 days of tinalpalment.
rTHE FINE PRINT!
S1 ?egDE
MUNICIPLE & PERMIT FEES s 300.oo
TOTAL 3
t ranr the Elooda and !eryjc.!.may qlcel rhi. a€tlcDrcr! by idin g writtcn rotice to the coutractor ur penor, bys! hdicrrc thar you do not want the ces ud murt be detivered or t\ratked before drlnight ofttre ttr
az.
POSIT
DRAW T(D LUS WOOD CHARGES 5
lrcE uPoN GOMPLETTON $..--.-.......-.' -.-....--''---
l. CONTRACT DOCUIIEIITS. Thir contract consirt. otthis at €xtra vood authorizsriom plur aay wood replucemeut, iI a,ly, and ifpaymclt,are fiuanccd, allfinancial docutuenr!. No promilc! ottrer than tholc rpccincdly 66t fortL ir tte conrracr documeuts slull bc rcognizcd by eirher panyItir undecrood and ag6d rlar tLi! contacr.Lalt rot Lc birdiD8 upo! LLc colrrsclo! uDtit signed and accepted by ax officer of the contmctor.lhe cootmctor recrves th. right to !ubEriturc naterials of equal or geater value. Ar y clongcr requircd by ucs iurildicrioasl codc! EAy r:ruh in additioaal c[argcsAay Icgat actious required to coltect oonics du c urdcr drir ogrcencrt wiU b. bmugLt h a Pirdla! County lrlorida vcnue and all charger induding i,rtdart ald artorre.
2.
4.
5.
fe6 sl,al be tLe obligarion ofthe pu
BU.r-ERS RIGHT TO CANCEL.if
rcl'aso. Tl !e contractor crrries \sorkerr coraperxa tior oDd geDerll liabiliry iDsursrce appticrble to t[a work bcing pcrforned.
telegram or by mail. TLir noticc mu
after you rigu dris agreemeut . Thir
F RIDGE
TPO SYSTEM
..BROWN.,.B
BARRI
D/O
DRIP ...WHEAVE
LATION B
AIR VE
E
work cLaI comD,ence on o. nbout and be colrpletcd by
td busiuers dr
INSTALL NEW LEAD
+L w lifc TILE
ADD 3% IF PAYTNG BY CREDIT GARD
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 162 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Carse + zolE- ov+2L\
1908
o+f ozf aor&
F
rl l
s *Iiffi
$ tzjt+
ROLE( N. SIMON
NATACHA SIMON-CI'ERY
aaal l?rH sr NE
NAn ES t!gra,
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 163 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES
Qnse # obY2z3
$e\.O
EI(^ -t-
Yp
R.\j6h.
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 164 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
C n.e + 20 16 ' }bVzz3
19'10
d-&5- tx--.-_---.-_-.r
/idri. S{ncoast
rl
$ /?983:
ROLEX N. SIMON
NATACIIA SIMON<HERA
atal l2fH st NE
N/tlLEs, tt- 3,rrz
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 165 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
CRse S 2or's- obtf 223
$r
ss
h'\
s
\
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 166 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
fu'y"Report Title:Code Case Details
Date. 3/8/2019 11:24:13 AM CaseNumber CEM1S20190002603
TII
Case Number:cEMts20't 90002603
Case Type Misconduct
Priority Normal
lnspector:JackGumph
Jurisdiction Collier Cou nty
Origin Complaint
Detail Description Received the packet from Permitting Department reference Permit # PRBD20181266458,
Application ONLY in REJECTED Status with roof work commenced.
Location Comments 5329 Mitchell ST (Folio # 62254640005)
Date & Time Entered 31812019 11:04i27 AM
Case Disposition Case Pending
Property 62254540005
Contractor FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES LLC
Business Management & Budget Office
Status llnvestigation
Entered By.lJackGumph
1
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 167 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES
Code Case Details Execution Date 3/8/201 9 1 1 :24:1 3 AM
Oesc Assigned Required Completod Outcome Comments
Preliminary lnvestigation JackGumph 318t2019 3t8t2019 Needs
lnvestigatio
n
0310712019: On the date of 3rl2019 I (J.
Gumph) received a packet from Spv E
Ybaceta, reference Permit Application #
PR8O20181266458. I researched the
application and found the application date to
be listed as 1211012018. The application was
rejected and a Corrections Letter sent out to
the contractor of record, Florida Roof Services
LLC (State Lic. # CCC1331226, Mr. Peter
Wozniak, License Holder).
lnvestigation Jac.kGumph 3t8t2019 Pending Florida Roof Services -- Mltchell Street
Cont. lnvestigation JackGumph 3t8t2019 Pending
CommentsViolation Description Status Entered Corrected EEM
Commencing Work Wthout A Permit Open 3t8t2019 IE
@E
Fin6/Day ConditionTitleReason
I
Result
2
Business Management & Budget O{fice
Compliance
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 168 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
Qowutl
Gll,rh tvkEgs.YEri D€partrEnl
must com*te Plfuse the
a $frb )
8.1 . Prlmbry Perm,t # ttr',y}
@r a z ra.rya^aigro,,r,tor!€ Q rr,r**vvaufaauear,or: O
p.-uoo.
BUI1DING PERMIT APPUCANON
28OO N. HORSESHOE OR., NAPLES, FL 34104 I TEt: (239)252-2400
lnnnrlk lsto this
t 5
8.3. EuiHing Type:
8.4. Permitt€e Tlfe:
Property lnformation
8..5. ParEeYFolio Hl
8.5.lob Street Mdress:
8.7. OrnerN ne:
8.8. Owner Phone:
8.9. tubdvision:
LoVBody'Unit:
8.10. SOP/Ptf:
8.11. 'PLt Filename:
/./APt I 4U 9
[ 12/4L v 00aJ'
8.2 Master Permit I 6ory)
O oesgn eroiessiona
Contractd lnfoamatbn
B 12. Ucense #:
8.13. C-oripany Name:
8.14. OualifierName:
8.15, Cmtact Narie:
9.16. Cornparry Address:
8.17. Cornporry Phme:
8.18. Fax t:
8.19i. -E nail 1:
8.19.b. "Ema[ 2:
l" U,* r* *rag c ptay a*oct nc$d.
fir)1tr1.aL
EV'/rt/4-,?
t//Al tl f ) )rrol
ilap'liJ mA lt
Dtr l,-o/ 24
,'utta u ) P wz/vo.t *,
' Optu - tu1 c,dJnj{g Fle.f,nts on @Wegg!
secti'on A. P€miii Number
Secion B- Gerirral Pemii lnfumatiqn
Seaion C. Apdicabon lnfrmration
It
C2. PetmitType: Re - fuo f
C.3. Fire PermitTlpe:
C4. Constmctim Type:
C5. ocsipancy:
C6. W*er Seryice:
C7.Sorer Sewice:
,. E EtEc EPLUMB E MEC}I O septii O Lo^,vat"g. E $utt6s trl ELECr from ho.re O Gas
ves Qtto
D.3. kared Value: S ooo g
D.1. Dessipdql ofworl lsr,riktuvt O.2. Proiect Narne dqvl
D.5. Commercbl 5q' FL:
New Consl /CoTplt O5d A AsD/
Addit gl ltunpbEasd &asa,
Alteration rrozptE Dsc/
E.1. Final Revierr Date:
O.4.a. New Cohst D,4"b. wdk Are, (Sq. FL)
D.4.br tiving:
o.ahi. Nm.living: _
TOTAU O
Dr4.c WorkA.eo (5q. FL)
D,1.cl. tivhgi
o.4r.ii Noftlivin8: _TOrAI: 0
o.4.d. Totds by Area
IOTAL!ts:
IolAltcrilg- 0
0I Stories:
I Urits:
f gedrooms:
f Batitooms:
D.sr. New Const.Ds.b. WorkAEa (5q. Ft)
lnterior:
Exterioa _-IOTAL O
D.5.c Wor* Area {&. Ft)
lnterio.: _
Extedo|:
TOTAL
# St6i6:
f Unilrs:
E.2. Number of Pbn Sets:510 15
Revscd Oate: 1l/29/17 v2 Thr5 ii p.te 1 oI3 p.8rs of the Buildi4 Permil Application. Please submit all 3 pate5 when completed
Diectbrs:
fa?q
neiiknC}+uiq/lt b{..rt Qc-.t-r.r
Q on er errue,
CJ. Fre Sprir{ded:
C9. P€rmit bv Affdevit
C10. Prh/ate Pruvider
C1l- Tkesttdd Euiuitf:
C12. V€getatim OeatinB:
C 13, REIAIEd tO OAMAGES INCURRED 8Y HURRICAN E IRMA
D.4. ResldentblSq Ft:
Net ,/ Co.tst. (@€ Aaa A Oah.)
,dd,iljor. (t-d#aaa AD.ah)
t&q io.\(cq& o4.c)
E3. Reliew Day5:
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 169 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES
.-ff-..**BUII.DING PERMIT APPIJCATION
28OO N. HORSESHoE DR., NAPLES, Ft 34104 | TEt: (239) 252-2400
NOTICE OF COLLIER COUNTY ADDITIONAT REGULATIONS
NOTICE OF ADDITIONAL RESTRICTIONS: ln addition to the requirements of this permit, there may be
additional restrictions applicable to this property that may be found in the public records of this County,
and there may be additional permits required from other governmental entities such as the Water
Management District, State agencies, or Federal agencies.
WARNING OF POSSIBLE DEED RESTRICTIONS: The land subject to this permit may be subject to deed,
and other restrictions that may limit or impair the landowner's rights. Collier County is not responsible
for the enforcement of these restrictions, nor are Collier County employees authorized to provide legal
or business advice to the public relative to these restrictions. The landowner or any applicant acting on
behalf of the landowner is cautioned to seek professional advice.
WARNING OF WORK lN THE COUNTY RIGHT-OF-WAYS: This permit does not authori2e construction or
installation of any structure or utility, above or below ground, within any right of way or easement
reserved for access, drainage or utility purposes. This restriction specifically prohibits fencing, sprinkler
systems, landscaping other than sod, signs, water, sewer, cable and drainage work therein. lf such
improvements are necessary, a separate permit for that purpose must be obtained from the Growth
Management Department.
NOTICE OF CLEARING RESTRICTIONS: The issuance of a building permit for a single-family dwelling
allows up to one {1) acre of native vegetation to be cleared. Clearing more than one (1} acre may be
allowed for accessory structures and requires a separate Vegetation Removal Permit. Properties
located in the following zoning district overlays may not be allowed to clear one (1) acre: Rural Fringe
Mixed Use District (RFMU), Big Cypress Area of Concern (ACSC), and Special Treatment Overlay (ST).
There may be additional restrictions related to clearing native vegetation and impacts to wetlands or
protectdd species found on the property. State and Federal agency permits may be required. Contact
the Growth Management Department's Environmental Services at (239) 252-2400 for additional
information, lssuance of a Demolition Permit for a structure does not authorize removal of vegetation
beyond the footprint of the structure. A Demo Permit is not a clearing permit.
WORK lN THE SPECIAL FTOOD HAZARD AREA: Be advised that Substantial Da mage/Substantial
lmprovement requirements will apply to structures located in the Special Flood Hazard Area with
Finished Floor Elevations below the Base Flood Elevation.
By initialing, I am acknowledging that I have read and understand this Notice of Collier County
Additional Regulations.
lnitials
Owner ot Agent of Owner,s or Controctor,s initiols ore required.
Acv l1-29.2017 v2 Thi5 it paSe 2 of 3 pages of the guilding permat Application Please sublrlit all3 patel when completed
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 170 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES
.l&se",,
(Sisnature ot Owner or nt of Owner)
The foreS o'n instrument was acknowledted belore me this
produced identifi
Notary SiEnaturc
cati on (tvpe of identification)
SECIION OR owtE MENT:
ure of
Th fo instrument wa s acknowledged befo.e ae lhis /A day of
BUITDING PERM]T APPUCATION
2800 N. HORSESHOE DR., NAPLES, FL 34104 | TEL: (239) 252-2400
/rr* L./rzu ,,h)(
{Priot name ofOwner o. Agent ofOwner)
day of /)u-*,b",a zo /r? ty
(name of person) who y'{r.rsonally known to me, or who _has
(Print name of Contractor)
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF COLIIER COUNTY REGUTATIONS
Applicatioh is hereby made to obtain a permit to do the work and installations as indicated. I certifY that no work or installation has
commenced prior to the issuance of a permit and that a,l work will be perfotmed to meet the standards of all laws reBulating
constru.tion in this jurisdiction. The permit or application fee may have additional fees imposed for lailing to obtain permits prior to
commencement of construction.
The approved permit and/or permit application erpires if not commen€ed within 180 days from the date of issuance.Ihe p€.mittee
further understands that only licensed contractorg may be emploYed and that the structu.e will not be used or occupied until a
certificate of occlpancy is issued. By signing thas permit application, I agree that I have been retained by the owner/Pe.mittee to
provide contracting 5ervices for the trade for whjch I am listed. Furthe.more, it is my responsibility to notify the Building Plan Review
and lnspection Division should lno tonger be the contractor responsible ror p.ovidint said contracting services. I further agree that I
understand that the review and issuing of this permjt does not exempt me from complying with all CountY Codes and Ordinances. lt
i5 further understood that the property owner/permittee is the owne/ of the permit
Note: An Owner-Builder must complete Sections A and B and the owner-Sulldel Aflidavit form,
SECIION A. OWNER or AG OWNER AC(NOWLEOGEMENT. The Contractor may si8n a5 the Agent oI Owner so lont a5
Contraator'5 contiacl its actlon:
(name of person)*noGI"ally known to me, or wh
grrr^o,La,20Ji-by
o_has
produced identif ication (tYP eof cation)
Notary SiSnature:
NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT INFORMATION
per Florida statutes 713.135 a Notice of cqmmencement (NOC) is required for construction of improvements totalinB more than
s2.5OO. with certain exceptions, For A/C Repairs or Replacements a notice of commencem€nt is .equired for improvements more than
or equal to 57,5oo. The applicant shall file with the issuinB authority prior to the first inspection either a certified copy of the recorded
NOC or a notarized statement that the NOC ha5 been filed for recording, alonB with a copy thereof ln order to comply with the 5tate
requirement, permits will be placed in inspection hold until proof of the Noc is filed with the buildinS permittin8 and inspection
department. The issuing authority shall not perform or approve subsequent rnspections until the applicant filet by mail' facsimilc'
hand delivery, email or any other means such 's certilied copy with the issuinB authoritY
WARNING TO OWNER: YOUR FAILURE TO RECORD A NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT MAY
RESULT IN YOUR PAYING TWICE FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO YOUR PROPERTY. IF YOU INTEND
TOOBTAINFINANCING,CONSULTWITHYOURLENDERORANATTORNEYBEFORERECORDING
YOUR NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT. A NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT MUST 8E RECORDED
AND POSTED ON THE JOB SITE BEFORE THE FIRST INSPECTION.
Rev 11-292017 vz This is page 3 of 3 pages of the Suilding Permit Application. Please submit all 3 pages when comoleted
EFJ RYFE RAw YL
MY IrssroNCOMM F206995
xE s !9PIREm3
': MY COMMTSSTON f FF206995
EXPIRES Mircn 13.2019
W RAYL
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 171 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERN M ENT
GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIVISION / BUILDING REVIEW & INSPECTION
28OO N. Horseshoe Drive, Naples FL 34104 * Phone (239) 252-24OO
Outstanding Corrections
Oate: December 14, 2018
Contact Name: FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES LLC
Address: 4505 gTH STREET EAST, 2605 FOREST
PARKWAY NORTH LARGO FL 33771
City, State Zip: ELLINGTON, FL 34222
Fax: <NO FAX NUMBER>
Dear Applicant:
Plans submitted with the referenced permit have been reviewed. We are unable to approve your permit application for the
reason(s) indicated below.
For Applicatiorc Submitted on Paper:
. Review the conections below to identify each document you will need to submit.. All corrections must be clouded.. Corrections to paper documents must be submitted in person; the GMD office receiving corrections is open until 4:30
pm.
. Submit 2 sets of corrected documents.. Submit 2 copies of the Letter of Response summarizing the changes made to address each correction comment
below.
JOB DESCRIPTION: MASTER RIB METAL RE-ROOF OVER PEEL & STICK. 17 SQS 4:12 PITCH 1-PLY MEMBRANE
ROOF ON FLAT AREA 8 SOS LOW SLOPE
5329 I/itchell ST
Rejected Review: Residential Review
Reviewed By: Ada Mejia VEN
Phone: Email:Ada.Mejia@colliercountyfl.gov
Correction Comment 1: MISSING THE INSTALLATION INSTRUCTION FOR THE METAL ROOF, I HAVE EMAIL SEVERAL
TIME BEFORE REJECTING THIS PERMIT. PLEASE DOWNLOAD THE INFORMATION AND BRING IN TO THE
CORRECTION DEPARTMENT; HERE lS THE LINK: https://www.floridabuilding.org/prlpr_app_srch.aspxFLl27'13-R4 THERE
ARE .I1 DIFFERENT ryPES
ATTENTION:
Collier County Plan Review and lnspections routinely reviews all outstanding permit applications in order to determine their
status. The review process includes appropriate responses from the permit applicant when the permit cannot be approved.
When the applicant is advised of deficiencies and does not respond within 180 days with corrected plans or an appeal to the
Code Enforcement Board, the permit application will be canceled as pet Collier County Ordinance 2002-01, Section,
104.5.1.1 to 101.5.1.4 (as amended).
PERMIT NO: PR8D2018126645801
APPLIcATION NO: PR8D20181266458
JOB SITE ADORESS: 5329 Mitchell ST
Email: JWRAYL@YAHOO.COM
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 172 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
tt
d
I
iI
I
7
j
'f.
{
,i
t:
^
1,
?
|,;t'
X:i:-n/
r
\
-il
Ua
i{I,.il -
tr
.{it
I ll
/
;,,
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 173 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 :
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 174 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER
COLLIER COUNTY ORDINANCE NO. 2006-46
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING COLLIER county ordinance NO. 90-
105, AS AMENDED, THE COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING
BOARD ORDINANCE
PART FOUR: STANDARDS OF CONDUCT AND DISCIPLINE
4.2, Misconduct - State Certified Contractors
The following actions by State Certified Contractors shall constitute misconduct
and grounds for discipline pursuant to Section 4.3 of this Ordinance.
4.2.2. Willfully violating the applicable building codes or laws of the state, City or
Collier County.
4.1.3. Abandoning a construction project in which he/she is engaged or under
contract as a contractor. A project may be presumed abandoned ifthe contractor
terminates the project without just cause, or fails to notify the owner in writing of
termination of the contract and basis for same, or fails to perform work for ninety
(90) consecutive days without just cause and no said notice to the owner.
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 175 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES
SECTION ,I O5 PERMITS
required permit.
SECTION 105
PERMITS
mechanical or pl
shall flrst maka
alter,
install,alter, repair,v
Friday, Mar01,2019 03:19 PM
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 176 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
2O17 Florida Building Code -
Building, Sixth Edition
trECHAPTER 1 SCOPE AND ADMINISTRATION
Thursday, Jan 04, 2018 12:'17 PM
Y
IAJ 105.32 Time limitation of application.
An application ior a permit for any proposed work shall be deemed to have been
abandoned 180 days aflerthe date offiling, unless such application has been pursued
in good iaith or a permit has been issued: except that the building official is authorized
to grant one or more extensions of time for additional periods not exceeding 90 days
each. The extension shall be requested in writing and justifiable cause demonstrated.
t)
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 177 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES
2017 Florida Building Code - Building, Sixth Edition
CHAPTER 1 SCOPE AND ADMINISTRATION PART 1-sCOPE AND APPTICATION SECTION 1O1 GENERAL
105.4 Conditions of the permit.
105.4,1 Permit intent. A permit issued shall be construed to be a license to proceed with the work and
not as authority to violate, cancel, alter or set aside any of the provisions of the technical codes, nor
shall issuance of a permit prevent the building official from thereafter requiring a correction of errors in
plans, construction or violations of this code. Every permit issued shall become invalid unless the work
authorized by such permit is commenced within six months after its issuance, or if the work authorized
by such permit is suspended or abandoned for a period of six months after the time the work is
commenced.
105.4.1.1 lf work has commenced and the permit is revoked, becomes null and void, or expires because
of lack of progress or abandonment, a new permit covering the proposed construction shall be obtained
before proceeding with the work.
705.4-7.2lf a new permit is not obtained within 180 days from the date the initial permit became null
and void, the building official is authorized to require that any work which has been commenced or
completed be removed from the building site. Alternately, a new permit may be issued on application,
providing the work in place and required to complete the structure meets all applicable regulations in
effect at the time the initial permit became null and void and any regulations which may have become
effective between the date of expiration and the date of issuance of the new permit.
105.4.1.3 Work shall be considered to be in active progress when the permit has received an approved
inspection within 1.80 days. This provision shall not be applicable in case of civil commotion or strike or
when the building work is halted due d
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 178 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
The zor8 Florida Statutes
Titte xxxll Chapter 489 View Entire Chapter
REGULATION OF PROFESSIONS AND OCCUPATIONS CONTRACTTNG
489.176 Moneys received by contractors.-
(1) For purposes of this section, the term 'contractor" includes att definitions as set forth in s.
489.105(3), and any person performing or contracting or promising to perfoml work described
therein, without regard to the licensure of the person.
(2) A contractor who receives, as initial payrnent, money totaling more than I0 percent of the
contract price for repair, restoration, improvement, or construction to residential real property
must:
(") Appty for pernrits necessary to do work within 30 days after the date payment is made,
except rvhere the viork does oot require a permit under the applicable codes and ordinances, and
(b) Start the rvork within 90 days after the date a[[ necessary permits for work, if any, are
issued,
unless the penon who made the payment agreed, in writing, to a longer period to apply for the
necessary permits or start the vrork or to [onger periods for both.
Friday, Mar01,2019 03:21 PIU
10.A.1
Packet Pg. 179 Attachment: PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF SERVICES - CASE 2019-02 MISCONDUCT (8294 : PETER WOZNIAK - FLORIDA ROOF
03/20/2019
COLLIER COUNTY
Contractor Licensing Board
Item Number: 11.A
Item Summary: WEDNESDAY, APRIL 17, 2019
Meeting Date: 03/20/2019
Prepared by:
Title: – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Lilla Davis
03/11/2019 4:00 PM
Submitted by:
Title: Supervisor - Operations – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Everildo Ybaceta
03/11/2019 4:00 PM
Approved By:
Review:
Contractor Licensing Board Lilla Davis Review Item Completed 03/11/2019 4:15 PM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Review Item Completed 03/11/2019 4:50 PM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Meeting Pending 03/20/2019 9:00 AM
11.A
Packet Pg. 180