The URL can be used to link to this page

Haldeman Creek MSTU Agenda 02/07/201962P,A tet, 2340m Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA -Bayshore Beautification MSTU Haldeman Creek MSTU Haldeman Creek MSTU Advisory Committee Meetin AGENDA February 07, 2019 4:00 PM Chairman Jack Bonzelaar Joseph Adams, James King, Kate Riley, Roy Wilson 1. Call to order and Roll Call 2. Pledge of Allegiance 3. Adoption of Agenda 4. Approval of Minutes 1anuary—M2019 Minutes 5. Community /Business —Presentations 6. Old Business a. Bathymetric Survey Update 7. New Business a. Haldeman Creek MSTU Boundary Map - Courthouse Shadows (Attachment) 8. Staff Report - a. Project Manager's Report — Tami Scott (Attachment) b. Maintenance Report — Shirley Garcia (Attachment) c. Financials- Shirley Garcia (Attachment) 9. Correspondence and Communication a. Debris Removal Report (Attached) b. Neighborhood Watch Training (Attachment) 10. Public Comment 11. Staff Comments 12. Advisory Board General Communications 13. Next meeting date: a. Joint Workshop February 19, 2019 @ 5 p.m. Naples Botanical Gardens b. March 7, 2019 Offices: 3570 Bayshore Drive, Unit 102, Naples, Florida 34112 Phone: 239-643-1115 Online: www.bayshorecra.com i Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA -Bayshore Beautification MSTU Haldeman Creek MSTU 14. Adjournment Offices: 3570 Bayshore Drive, Unit 102, Naples, Florida 34112 Phone: 239-643-1115 Online: www.bayshorecra.com Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA *Bayshore Beautification MSTU Haldeman Creek MSTU Agenda Item 4a- January 10 2019 meeting minutes HALDEMAN CREEK MSTU MINUTES OF THE JANUARY 10, 2019 MEETING The meeting of the Haldeman Creek MSTU Advisory Committee was called to order by Chairman Roy Wilson at 4:00 p.m. at the CRA Office, 3750 Bayshore Drive, Unit 102, Naples, FL 34112. I. Roll Call: Advisory Board Members Present: Chairman Roy Wilson, Jack Bonzelaar, James King, Kate Riley. Absent -Joseph Adams Coordinator; Tami Scott, Senior Project Mgr.; Debrah Forester, CRA Director; II. Pledge of Allegiance: Led by Chairman Roy Wilson. III. Adoption of Agenda: Request to add depth scan under Old business as Item 6c, Jim King made a motion to accept the agenda as amended, Kate Riley second passed unanimously. IV. Election of Officers — Chair and Vice -Chair- Roy Wilson made a motion for Jack Bonzelaar, second by Kate Riley, passed unanimously. Jack Bonzelaar made a motion for Roy Wilson for Vice Chair, Second by Kate Riley. Passed unanimously. V. Adoption of Minutes: James King made a motion to accept the Minutes as written. Second by Roy Wilson. Passed Unanimously. VI. Old Business: A. Debris Clean Up: Gino Santabarbara, Principal Planner informed the committee of the Haldeman Creek post Hurricane Irma clean-up is completed and finalized with all the areas that were critical. Mr. Santabarbara thanked CRA Staff and the community members for all their assistance. James King wanted to let them know what an outstanding job the contractors did and for their professionalism. Roy Wilson also wanted to say how cooperative and informative the contractor was. Gino provide the statistics on the removal: 2,732.65 cubic yards of debris was pulled out of the creek, more than they anticipated. They are also working on pre -storm maintenance, so the next storm will not be as bad the issue is funding and reviewing the option to getting a blanket permit, so they won't have to wait to do any work in the case of another event. Roy Wilson brought up that the City of Naples has an ordinance that makes the property owners responsible for cutting back the exotics that hang off of their property into a waterway. The County never passed the Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA •Bayshore Beautification MSTU Haldeman Creek MSTU ordinance, but one was drafted but not approved. CD Mcquire is the consultant for the County and Gino Santabarbara has been working with for grant opportunities and will see if we can leverage any grant dollars for future dredging. B. Scan of Creek Depth and Markers% Chris D'arco, County Coastal Zone and Roger Jacobs from City of Naples attended to give update on markers in the creek. Chris and his group installed marker 15 with a can buoy because they could not drill into the lime rock at the bottom of the creek with the poles. Roger Jacobs stated the City is missing 2 marker pilings. There are no immediate plans to replace these markers since he has not received any complaints and currently there are no funds allocated for the replacement. Mr. Jacobs recommended that in the event the MSTU was going to proceed with a dredging project that they consider including the marker replacements with the contract, which he anticipated would save money. He ._.. ... .. ___A XXO' TT fi.ti. fimAinn Roy Wilson brought up some concerns about the speed in the Creek, signage is slow speed and Chris stated that the State governs those signs and speed. VII. New Business: A. CRA/MSTU's Joint Meeting -goals & priority — February 19,2019- Debrah Forester mentioned that staff will be holding a joint goals workshop with the CRA and MSTU's scheduled for February 191h at 5pm. B. 2019 HCMSTU Calendar A. Staff Report: Tami Scott, Senior Project Manager, highlighted several projects. Fire Suppression Phase II we have received 100% drawings and is probably going to start in June. The office space for the CRA has received the revised plan layout and will be going through the permitting process. There is a master pump station pump project that will start at Thomasson Dr and Thomasson Lane and wanted to let everyone know it is a county project and there is a contact information if anyone needed it. Race Trac was approved, permitting should begin soon. Sara Bay Marina will be coming in the February CRA meeting. Food Truck parking lot has submitted their second round of revisions including the crosswalk and other revisions. Courthouse Shadows has submitted amended plans to redevelop that plaza into residential. Compass Pointe has a new contract on the property and keep the existing site plans already approved in the County. B. Maintenance Report—Is attached if anyone has any questions C. Financials (Attachment)- For committees review. t4l-B&0f*V Bayshore Gateway Triangle CRA •Bayshore Beautification MSTU Haldeman Creek MSTU VIII. Correspondence and Communications: IX. Public Comments: X. Staff Comments: N/A XI. Advisory Committee Comments: Kate Riley raised a concern regarding the noise level at Celebration Food Truck park, she wanted to state it on the record that she cannot even sit out on her porch. Jim King agreed and he is further away from Celebration Food park from where Kate lives. Jim King requested clarification on the boundaries of the MSTU in relationship to Courthouse Shadows. Staff will review the maps and bring the item back to the Committee next meeting. XII. Next Meeting Date: February 7, 2019 XIII. Adjournment: 5:15 pm Chairman Jack Bonzelaar Haldeman Creek Storm Debris and Silt Project Haldeman Creek is a Collier County owned and maintained channel. Dredging is required to get the channel back to its pre -storm flow capacity and depth. • —1 mile (5,280ft) has been affected by storm deposited silt and debris • Average width is —100 feet wide. • Average storm infill is —3 feet deep Approximate cubic yardage of silt and sediment • 5,280ft L x 100ft W x 3ft D=-58,667cy Historical Dredging Costs • —$1,300,000.00 The applicant is currently working on a more accurate storm impact scope. This could not be completed until the storm deposited vegetative debris removal was completed. Please add this to project #42436 as Work to be Completed. Please see attached map and pictures. \«2 ~« * 1 N1: try «*I�or I AFAa Y i{� t � 1m A t t ! 1 k l 1 Y� �f eY' Y try «*I�or I AFAa Y i{� t � Haldeman Creek 11 4�x € ��frll tf Sii�f 1a•. go �VT��yyJJ�� Yl. op Flop 0 AVE w4t, W j'[�y�'��Iy✓`M�x1 Tf if 4 Fft 4 data �d too s r=- j€6. art+- "�'(�li•-M"�-Cri''�j,p{1�'��.—.,,+-. ��./ ,rit+qy.:.� l/ J,.,, �� (. q�,y M-°• FlY ��I k le Earth Earth Bayshore CRA Report Case Date Case Number T e Description Entered Inspector Location Description 61840560008 -2801 THOMASSON DR Kimberly Pitts - Property Manager Headwaters Development, Inc - kpitts.distinction@gmaii.com -239.249.1953 CELU20180013224 LU Open 10/23/2018 JohnJohnson CEW20180013293 LU Open 10/23/2018 JonHoa boon 2364 Linwood Way CEW20180013725 LU Open 11/02/2018 JonHoa boon 1651 Avondale St 3172 Van Buren - CELU20180013731 LU Open 11/02/2018 JohnJohnson 52700160007 3612 bayshore Drive - Leo's Sod -81730040003 omplainant.—Tanya (239) CELU20180013991 LU Open 11/08/2018 JohnJohnson 961-4086 CELU20180014005 LU Closed 11/08/2018 JonHoa boon 2390 Linwood Way (5085 bayshore drive) 61838760001 rear of property near park **********Duplicate Case: CELU20180014109 LU Closed 11/09/2018 Johnlohnson CELU20180011299******** 3048 holland house Naples CELU20180014120 LU Closed 11/12/2018 JohnJohnson fla 34112 CELU20180014150 LU Open 11/13/2018 JohnJohnson 71580220009 vacant lot CELU20180014212 LU Open 11/14/2018 JohnJohnson 3048 Lunar street CELU20180014453 LU Open 11/20/2018 JonHoa boon 2085 Tamiami Trl E CENA20180013209 NA Open 10/23/2018 JonHoa boon 2054 Davis Blvd 2455 Tamiami Trall CENA20180013274 NA Open 10/23/2018 JonHoa boon CENA20180013415 NA Closed 10/25/2018 WilliamMarchand 2721 Van Buren CENA20180013454 NA Open 10/26/2018 WilliamMarchand 3000 Cottage Grove CENA20180013518 NA Closed 10/29/2018 WilliamMarchand 8085 Bayshore CENA20180013537 NA Closed 10/30/2018 JonHoa boon 1695 Commercial Dr CENA20180013540 NA Closed 10/30/2018 JonHoa boon 2193 Kirkwood Ave 3097 Coco Ave - CENA20180013581 NA I Closed 10/30/2018 JohnJohnson 71781280000 2224 Tamiami Trail E, (Old CENA20180013719 NA Closed 11/01/2018 JohnJohnson Taco Bell -51690720008 Near 3125 BAYSHORE DR in CENA20180013853 NA Closed 11/06/2018 JohnJohnson the creek CENA20180013986 NA Closed 11/07/2018 JohnJohnson 2800 Pine Street 4040 Bayshore Drive - 61836280004 CENA20180014047 NA Open 11/08/2018 JohnJohnson Super Star Food Market Complainant is CRA Bayshore 3385 Bayshore Dr- CENA20180014163 NA 0 en11 14 2018 JohnJohnson 71781320009 3049 Coco Ave - CENA20180014168 NA Closed 11/14/2018 JohnJohnson 71781120005 2668 Tamiami Tri E, Naples, FL 34112 (Gulfgate Plaza) Bravo Store Manager: Juan 239-234-5136, CENA20180014254 NA Open 11/15/2018 JohnJohnson bravonapies@comcast.net CENA20180014263 NA Oen 11/15/2018 WIIIiamMarchand 2564 Van Buren CENA20180014458 NA Oen 11/20/2018 WilliamMarchand 2805 Van Buren 2224 Tamiami Trail E, (Old CENA20180014463 NA Oen 11/20/2018 JohnJohnson Taco Bell) — 51690720008 CENA20180014484 NA Open 11/21/2018 JohnJohnson 3073 Coco 2675 Storter Ave CEPM20180013202 PM Closed 10/23/2018 JohnJohnson Owner 239-777-4280 3863 Bayshore Dr, A -Z CEPM20180013715 PM Closed 11/01/2018 JohnJohnson Beverage, 52701320008 CEPM20180013967 PM Closed 11/07/2018 StephenAthey 3339 Canal St. CEROW20180013546 ROW I Closed 10/30/2018 1 MicheleMc ono le 3065 TERRACE AVE Outer Drive & Thomasson Lane Near Abaco Bay on CES20180013199 S Closed 10/22/2018 JohnJohnson Bayshore Drive CES20180013729 S Closed 11/02/2018 JonHoa boon 1600 Airport Rd S 3224 Bayshore - "Hair 4 CES20180013934 S Closed 11/07/2018 JohnJohnson You" new business CES20180014223 S Closed 11/15/2018 JohnJohnson 4315 Bayshore Dr 3172 Van Buren Ave - CESD20180013580 SD Closed 10/30/2018 JohnJohnson 52700160007 3085 ARECA AVE - CEV20180013327 V Closed 10/24/2018 JohnJohnson 71781920001 2647 Becca Ave - CEV20180013717 V Closed 1101/2018 3ohn]ohnson 81271000007 61837880005 - Vacant lot on south side of Bayshore CEV20180013783 V 0 en 11/05/2018 JohnJohnson near Holl 52701280009 - corner of CEV20180013784 V Closed 11/05/2018 JohnJohnson Bayshore & Van Buren CEV20180014184 V Closed 11/14/2018 MicheleMc ono le 2615 Andrew Dr. CEV20180014185 V Closed 11/14/2018 MicheleMc onagle 2579 Andrew Dr. CEV20180014404 V Open 11119/2018 JohnFuentes 2401 23rd stsw 2836 Bayview - CEV20180014509 V Open 11/21/2018 John3ohnson 48170120005 HALDEMAN CREEK MSTU BOUNDARY MAP O 0.25 0.5 1 Miles Author: Mike Dumals, GMDN GIS Team I Dale: 8/27/2018 Data Source: Ordinance 18-04 ( 02-13-18) I t I Doc Path:M:\UrhanPlannin0\MSTUs\HaidemanCreek\HCMSTUBoundaryUnshaded.mxd Page 1 of I CoMer County Property Appraiser http://www.collierappraiser.com/main_searchIDoeviewer.html?sid=199482998&ccpave1=1710181149&... 1/31/2019 2018 ROol Estate Parcel ID: 28760000020 Mllage Area: 0063 Use Code: 16 Mailed on: 0080/2010 Silos Address: 32DOTAMIAMITRL E Legal Descdptlon: COURTHOUSE SHADOWS TRACTA la�lll�lil�l'111�II�IIIIBIII'll�ll'ilr��lll�l�l IIIIIIrIIIAI�I��B 692'•194031""""""'AUTO"ALL FOR AADC 460 KRG COURTHOUSE SHADOWS LLC 30 S MERIDIAN ST STE 1100 INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46204-3565 r p.: Rif e M Y :k9 •e 4 3"; et - --9 as _ __ :,-r s Market Value 2017 2018 IwNad7aaxebPSWM.w r. 2391262.8141�ssrolrrlMYem4evAw,wX asnmlWdbmmapfmw<IesY¢wlmNrllsolxAMMOdo, 5,398,991 41 560,1S8 IIHe PropeA7AARva8MR 09alluuNebrer0¢reMmelOrssb9emeMNvaW.daul&aWM1 w mexxrplm,younW I.ee pNlmfwedysertnlxMPeVNeAd}�sYnml Beed. Pealmfmns enmleNe ham9n04W7PxpxyApwasx>k nuslb L9dmwbekA:6 PM SEPTEMBER 14, 2018 Texln9Aulhedtlee Aessssed Blue Exam ons TaxableValue LeslYear Trus Yea, LesiYeat I TN9Yea! I L651 TOW 7hk Year County 5.398.991 450 158 0 i0 5 398 993 4 560 ]58 Pubac SchoO6 5 398 991 1 4 560 158 0 0 5 398,99A 4 360 150 Menkl aR 0 e 0 0 0 0 SO fbdde B(¢!M l0utdd 5 398 991 560 150 0 0 5 396 991 4 560 ISB Inde ndenlS ¢tial DieldcD B 91 1 4. 5Q0 150 1 S.398.9926 e ..... educt o e Iso u Exem Ilona A eeTo Armu 1 Al ata ad e 0 10% No a Hemeslead Ca NomSchoolTexw Wenner Homestead Non SdwolTexes 0 Wral ClaseM¢elbn Al Taxee1 0A normo SeNor Court Taxw WO,q Waed'od I AlTws 1 0lbnAed lMOmo SodOr C' Taxes Other Al Taxes 0ADVACORWAMESSMEMA 09M, Y9Fbvr,Ohabled, Owar NlTexes 0 . W . w COLUMN to COLUMN 2' COLUMN 3' TAXING AUTHORITIES Your PropedYyTaxes uslYEar ustYeae, Actual Tax Rale YOWTOMSTNBYea, IF NO Buudda9aal1 change IsAdapled ywlr. NIe7Ns W-WRO"tel OAm9e0AdapHd YouRT"Os This Yea I If PRDI''OSED BotlpalbAdoDled 7WYoede PROPoSE0 Tex Rale PueLICII6ABwnwroluanax Arya&baMp m 9xp,BP4� wen Mdwd9slxnell MMllOO ID Nema Number Dale Time A c.uno, OeleRunxe $19,402.09 3.5938 $15,917.69 3.4906 $16,388.29 3.5938 1W06/201605:05 PM Nero: w iI OAPODI.M M 54YOOAE eEwnercAnon $4,356.45 $12,743.78 0.8069 2.3604 $3,584.28 $10,411.75 0.7860 2.2832 $3,679.59 $10,763.80 0.8069 2.3604 1 1 9/06/2018 09106t20io 05:05 PM 051.05 PM M MWn .80eo01e0ARD-aTA3Euw $15,624.68 2.8940 $12,927.14 2.8348 $12,064.21 2.8210 2 9/1112018 05:45 PM SCHOOL BOARD. LOCAS ROARB $12,028.95 2.2280 $9,952.09 2.1824 $10,160.03 2.2280 2 9/11M018 06:46 PM u sem rv4: WATER NUMS10 CYPRESS6ASRI $1,374.04 0.2545 $2,112.68 0.2440 $1,112.68 0.2440 6 9/13/2018 05:16 PM MUIR OREATE 1"LE8roRE REM aAPAiERIWLEa 11PERESCUE q8 $909.30 $8,098,49 0.1032 1.5000 $009.43 $6,635.03 0.1775 1.4550 ,809.43 $6,840.34 0.1775 1.5000 7 9 6/13/2010 0/12/201005:05 05:01 PM PM Total Property Taxes $74,618.38 13.0208 $61,350.09 13.4593 $63,638.37 33.7316 'Boo RovoTa.S1 Por Explanation IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 5 NIIIIIn IIOIIII0 IIII II III A 2 8 7 5 0 0 0 0 0 2 8+ http://www.collierappraiser.com/main_searchIDoeviewer.html?sid=199482998&ccpave1=1710181149&... 1/31/2019 Print Map Page 1 of 1 courthouse shadows I MAP LE Major Roads R JS' Street Names Pamela Aerials 2070 IS trf�F ® Collier Count] J , Sp,• I Folio Number: 2876 �'p s Name: KRG COURT SHADOWS LLC W 1,.. vny . ; • `% ,} 1' StreeN/ & Name: 32 t 'S. 0, .,, y^drr.' E e9`, Build#/Unit#:A/1 Legal Description: I SHADOWS TRACTI 2004. Collier County Property Appraiser. While the Collier County Property Appraiser is committed to providing the most accurate and up -lo -date information, no warranties expressed C for the data herein, Its use, or Its interpretation. http://maps.collierappraiser.com/mapprint.aspx?pagetitle--courthouse%2Oshadows&orient=LANDSCAP... 1/31/2019 Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser http://www,collierappraiser.com/main_searchIDoeviewer.html?sid=369704265&ccpaver=1710181149&... 1/31/2019 2018 Reel Es1ole PwwIID: 2a750OD0523MIlagoAma:0111 Use Code: 16 Malledon:OW2012019 SIIusAddfass: 3420TAMIAMIT13L E Legal DescdpBo9: COURTHOUSE SHADOWS TRACTS IIIIIIIIIIII III�Ie�11IpIneI611JRL6I1�i�n�I�ell�"11'1'1 692"194032""""""'AUTO"ALL FOR AADC 460 KRO COURTHOUSE SHADOWS LLC 30 S MERIDIAN ST STE 1100 INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46204-3565 FSHI Market Voluel 2017 2018 I r-rvapdrw'wru,el 9)262.8141�osalnAdgYrenelv9w,aXw a flYdb ax mpsmaeYstisnlmPullsml«AMabdux, 1,417,2051 1,438,816 Il Oe RafeMkMalMfe 00telswaebresdn Mmenaeslo4p maAelveUe,dws7u[axaen PM EPEMB M1R 14,20laedNfWxnlnM as Vete04PSVeenl SEPTEMBER Board. Pellmfam>ere anieNe Ynn9a0ouMy P,rye,hApptNsaen4muslbelkdmabelae:6 PM SEPTEMBER 14, 2018 TexingAulhodges Aaeued Value Exaambone Tax.blelf.us LaslYeer ThbYaer IodYeal TN'Yoar Leu Yew This Year Coon 1,135,200 1 248 120 0 0 2.135.200 1 248 720 Pu blb SrAooB 1,417,20S 1 M.815 1 0 0 1 417 205 1 438 815 Mun 'all 0 0 0 0 0 0 SouN RoddeWeter lD'nVa 2,135.2 1,248,770 01 0 1.235.200 1,248 720 Indo Menl$ del DisNcb 1,135,200 2,248 2 1 135 200 2 B 720 e ed e e dam lions A Iles To Amount sr�As s II ea 0 10% Non Homeskad Ca He.School ee 00 A�MbnN Homaale14 Nan School Taxes 0 ioWNral Cless$xelpn NTaxes Boma n fc9unlyTaxes WorliraWateffiont Al Taxas I I Ci Taxes Other ASTaxes Blind, Widow, Disabled, Oliver I AIITexes I0 qrfff. A�:EB6�t. AU <9 <A6) vR Pi3a,.vi3�: COLUMN 1a COLUMN 2' COLUMN 3' TAXING AUTHORITIES Your Pfepertp was 1aAllor IaelYeals Actual Tom Bale YoufTelesTulyou IFNOBWgel ChaiV bAdopled vwruftl. + Yea IFNOMPI CnenaelsAWpkd YourTamsThisTNsYeels Yomr IIPROPOSEO BudgellsAdepled PROPOSER T"Rele PUaIWNFMNOWFOlboVku T A PAee neaNg on Ne pppW M Ms M46udgelxel6aneB as ,MGA ID Nems Number Dab The A C.Wy: earanusws $4,079.68 3.5930 $4,358.78 3.4906 $4,407.65 3.5938 2 0910wola 08:05 PM More URIC(APCol. MUD $915.99 0.0069 $981.49 0.7860 $1,007.59 0,8069 1 9106201805:05 PM IAYM0REMWrrlFle4na1 $2,679.53 2.3664 $2,051.08 2.2832 $2,947.48 2.3604 1 9!08201805:05 PM rw09rwr4Rx MAMUCRIE IMM $034.14 0.7348 $856.50 0.6859 $1,249.72 1.0000 1 9/00201805:05 PM SM100134M9-STATEIAW $4,101.39 2.8940 $4,078.75 2.8348 $4,058.90 2.8210 2 091111201C 05:45 PM $0*XL0WD-to 1MsAA) $3,157.53 2.2280 $3,140.07 2.1024 $3,205.68 2.2280 2 9/11201005:45 PM wAraR auwiocrenam eAsw $288.91 0.2545 $304.69 0.2440 $304,69 0.2440 6 3911=0180516PM CttIlFn aweourro cpNrnos $207.97 0,1832 $221.65 0.1775 $221.65 0.1775 ] 39VI312018 05:01 PM pnEAranrWxaannanaaWlwe $1,702.80 1.5000 $1,810.89 1.4550 $1,873.00 1.5000 9 9/12201806:05 PM Property Texes $17,967.94 14.5556 $18,609.90 14.1994 $19,355.44 24.7316 SsoExplanallolna For traversTotal IIIIIIIVII NTI VIIII IV IVIII V IIIL IVIII IIIIIII 7za7so0 00523e http://www,collierappraiser.com/main_searchIDoeviewer.html?sid=369704265&ccpaver=1710181149&... 1/31/2019