CLB Agenda 02/20/2019COLLIER COUNTY
Board of County Commissioners
Contractor Licensing Board
AGENDA
Board of County Commission Chambers
Collier County Government Center
3299 Tamiami Trail East, 3rd Floor
Naples, FL 34112
February 20, 2019
9:00 AM
Kyle E. Lantz, Chair
Matthew Nolton, Vice-Chair
Robert P. Meister, III
Patrick G. White
Michael E. Boyd
Terry Jerulle
Richard E. Joslin, Jr.
NOTICE: All persons wishing to speak on Agenda items must register prior to presentation of the Agenda
item to be addressed. All registered speakers will receive up to three (3) minutes unless the time is adjusted
by the chairman.
Any person who decides to appeal a decision of this Board will need a record of the proceeding pertaining
thereto, and therefore may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record
includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based.
If you are a person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding,
you are entitled, at no cost to you, the provision of certain assistance. Please contact the Collier County
Facilities Management Division located at 3335 East Tamiami Trail, Suite 1, Naples, Florida, 34112 -5356,
(239) 252-8380; assisted listening devices for the hearing impaired are available in the Facilities
Management Division.
1. ROLL CALL
2. ADDITIONS OR DELETIONS
3. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
4. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
4.A. APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019
5. PUBLIC COMMENTS
6. DISCUSSION
7. REPORTS
8. NEW BUSINESS
8.A. ORDERS OF THE BOARD
8.B. MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL & PRESSURE CLEANING, LLC
– REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE
8.C. DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING LLC – REINSTATEMENT WITH
WAIVER OF EXAM & NAME CHANGE
9. OLD BUSINESS
9.A. CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF
A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE
9.B. JEFFREY BUMPUS – NORTHERN BREEZE – FOR FACTUAL FINDING OF
WHETHER PERMITS HAVE BEEN CLOSED BY JANUARY 19, 2019 AS
ORDERED BY THE BOARD ON DECEMBER 19, 2018
10. PUBLIC HEARINGS
11. NEXT MEETING DATE
11.A. WEDNESDAY, MARCH 20, 2019
Inquiries concerning changes to the Board’s Agenda should be made to the County Manager’s Office at
252-8383.
02/20/2019
COLLIER COUNTY
Contractor Licensing Board
Item Number: 4.A
Item Summary: APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019
Meeting Date: 02/20/2019
Prepared by:
Title: – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Lilla Davis
02/12/2019 8:40 AM
Submitted by:
Title: Supervisor - Operations – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Everildo Ybaceta
02/12/2019 8:40 AM
Approved By:
Review:
Contractor Licensing Board Lilla Davis Review Item Completed 02/12/2019 8:40 AM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Review Item Completed 02/12/2019 2:27 PM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Meeting Pending 02/20/2019 9:00 AM
4.A
Packet Pg. 3
January 16, 2019
1
MINUTES
OF THE COLLIER COUNTY
CONTRACTORS’ LICENSING BOARD
January 16, 2019
Naples, Florida
LET IT BE REMEMBERED that the Collier County Contractors’ Licensing
Board, having conducted business herein, met on this date at 9:00 AM in
REGULAR SESSION in Administrative Building “F,” 3rd Floor, Collier County
Government Complex, Naples, Florida, with the following Members present:
Chairman: Kyle E. Lantz
Vice Chair: Matthew Nolton
Members: Michael E. Boyd
Terry Jerulle
Patrick White
Excused: Richard Joslin
Robert Meister
Resigned: Gerard Shannon
ALSO PRESENT:
Everildo Ybaceta – Supervisor, Contractors’ Licensing Office
Kevin Noell, Esq. – Assistant Collier County Attorney
Jed Schneck, Esq. – Attorney for the Contractors’ Licensing Board
4.A.a
Packet Pg. 4 Attachment: January 2019 Minutes (8021 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019)
January 16, 2019
2
Any person who decides to appeal a decision of this Board will need a record of the
proceedings and may need to ensure that a verbatim record of said proceedings is made,
which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which any Appeal is to be made.
I. ROLL CALL:
Chairman Kyle E. Lantz opened the meeting at 9:02 AM and read the procedures to be
followed to appeal a decision of the Board.
Roll Call was taken; a quorum was established; five (5) voting members were present.
II. AGENDA- ADDITIONS, CHANGES, OR DELETIONS:
Addition:
• Minutes from the December 19, 2018 Contractors’ Licensing Board meeting
III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA:
Patrick White moved to approve the Agenda as amended. Vice Chairman Matthew
Nolton offered a Second in support of the motion. Carried unanimously, 5 – 0.
IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: DECEMBER 19, 2018
Vice Chairman Matthew Nolton moved to approve the Minutes of the December 19, 2018
Meeting as submitted. Michael Boyd offered a Second in support of the motion.
Carried unanimously, 5 – 0.
V. PUBLIC COMMENT:
(None)
VI. DISCUSSION:
(None)
VII. REPORTS:
(None)
VIII. NEW BUSINESS:
A. Orders of the Board:
Patrick White moved to approve authorizing the Chairman to sign the Orders
of the Board. Terry Jerulle offered a Second in support of the motion.
Carried unanimously, 5 – 0.
4.A.a
Packet Pg. 5 Attachment: January 2019 Minutes (8021 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019)
January 16, 2019
3
(Note: The individuals who testified in the following cases under Item VIII, “New
Business,” were first sworn in by the Attorney for the Board.)
B. Fernanda Rosa – Request to Qualify a Second Entity
(Currently qualifies: “Ocleano Services, LLC”
Proposed 2nd Entity: “Roca Granite and Cabinets, LLC”)
Chairman Lantz asked Ms. Rosa to provide background information concerning the
company she currently qualifies and the Second Entity she would like to qualify.
Fernanda Rosa stated:
• She is a managing member of Ocleano Services, LLC, and works as a
subcontractor performing tile installation,
• She is a licensed Tile and Marble Contractor in Collier County; her license is
active,
• The work in the new company will be focused on granite installation, some
tile installation, and cabinets,
• She and her husband own Ocleano Services, LLC,
• In the new company, she will still be partnered with her husband but there will
be a third partner,
• Her companies are in Fort Myers,
• Both companies are currently licensed in Lee County
Chairman Lantz: One of the issues that we tend to have here with people having a
Second Entity is – we want to make sure that the two companies aren’t going to
compete against each other.
Fernanda Rosa: Oh, no ... no ... they will be two different things. Like I said, the
first one I use just as a subcontractor, and the second one we have a shop in Fort
Myers, and we will be dealing straight with the customers. We will be the contractors
for granite countertops or tile flooring.
Chairman Lantz: So, both companies will be doing tile?
Fernanda Rosa: Well, you know, the major thing will be granite countertops.
Chairman Lantz: Any questions from the Board?
Vice Chairman Nolton: What’s the ownership of the companies ... the percentages?
Fernanda Rosa: Well, with the first one, I guess, I own 20% and my husband has
80%. And in the second one I know Aldo owns 50% [Aldemar Castro, the new
partner], I own 10%, and my husband owns 40%.
Vice Chairman Nolton: What’s your role in both companies?
Fernanda Rosa: I have worked with my uncle for a couple of years helping him
with construction and everything else. I have a lot of experience in the field, but –
right now – I’m just managing the company. I’ll be managing and supervising their
work – that’s what I’m going to do.
4.A.a
Packet Pg. 6 Attachment: January 2019 Minutes (8021 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019)
January 16, 2019
4
Chairman Lantz: Can you give us a little more detail of what “managing the
company” means?
Fernanda Rosa: Making sure they are doing their best work.
Chairman Lantz: So ... managing the production?
Fernanda Rosa: Pretty much, yes. And I take care of the paperwork ... the license
... the permits ... I do the accounting and everything else.
Chairman Lantz: Who pays the bills?
Fernanda Rosa: Me.
Chairman Lantz: Who purchases materials?
Fernanda Rosa: Me.
Chairman Lantz: Any other questions from the Board?
Patrick White: How often do you inspect the work that’s been done on jobsites?
Fernanda Rosa: Usually, I inspect all the jobs. I get there at the beginning – I stop
by again in the middle – and I’m always there at the final – to pick up the final
payment from the customer and make sure they are happy with their job.
Patrick White: On average, three or four times throughout the progress – from start
to finish?
Fernanda Rosa: Yea.
Patrick White: Not daily when they are at work?
Fernanda Rosa: No, I get there daily, too, but my husband has plenty of experience
doing the granite and everything else.
Patrick White: Okay
Terry Jerulle: Evy, I’m having a hard time reading this – I get an “error” page every
time I switch a page. The question I have is what’s the difference between the two
licenses? Does her current license allow her to do the same thing ...?
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes.
Terry Jerulle: ... that she’s applying for?
Everildo Ybaceta: The license that she has right now is a Tile and Marble
Installation Contractor’s license which also allows her to work with stones. Granite is
a stone ... marble is a stone ... it falls under that categor y. That’s where the overlap
comes into play with the Second Entity.
Terry Jerulle: Basically, she’s asking for the same license that she has?
Everildo Ybaceta: Correct – for the Second Entity, yes.
Terry Jerulle: So, the Second Entity is the same license as what she has?
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes.
Vice Chairman Nolton: I mean, with this license, can they do cabinetry?
Everildo Ybaceta: No. In speaking to Mrs. Rosa, she knows she is going to need a
separate Cabinetry license and she will apply for it. So, at this point, if you do move
forward with approving her application, we can restrict her license for the new
company to just the stone work until she gets the Cabinetry license.
Terry Jerulle: And the name of the [new] company – what is the name of the
Second Entity for which you want a license?
Everildo Ybaceta: Roca Granite and Cabinets, LLC.
4.A.a
Packet Pg. 7 Attachment: January 2019 Minutes (8021 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019)
January 16, 2019
5
Terry Jerulle: Okay. So, you’re asking us to give you a license for a company that
sells cabinets, but not do cabinets?
Fernanda Rosa: No, I do cabinets.
Terry Jerulle: But you don’t have a Cabinetry license.
Fernanda Rosa: That’s the thing – I have to apply.
Terry Jerulle: Okay. So then – and maybe I don’t understand – but why haven’t
you applied already?
Fernanda Rosa: That was the information that I was given ... that I should get my
Second Entity approved and then move forward with the cabinet license.
Terry Jerulle: Or you could have just licensed the Second Entity with cabinets?
Fernanda Rosa: I don’t know.
Chairman Lantz: Evy, if she were to have a Cabinetry license, would she be
allowed to do stone work ... stone counters?
Fernanda Rosa: No.
Everildo Ybaceta: No.
Chairman Lantz: To do both, she needs two licenses – right?
Everildo Ybaceta: Right ... yes.
Patrick White: Which makes me beg the question: why put the cart before the horse?
Everildo Ybaceta: When ...
Patrick White: ... without putting us in the position of having to issue a potentially
restrictive Second Entity license?
Everildo Ybaceta: No, I understand the question. Initially, in the discussions that
we had, the news that she had been told to apply for the Second Entity first was not
given to me. Later in conversations, after the application was finalized, is when I
found out. We have taken steps to make sure that it does not happen again.
Chairman Lantz: (to Fernanda Rosa) You currently license both – both companies
are currently licensed in Lee County – correct?
Fernanda Rosa: Yes.
Chairman Lantz: Lee County’s licenses are a little bit different than ours. What
other licenses do you hold in Lee County?
Fernanda Rosa: I have the same ones – Tile and Marble for the first company, and
Tile and Marble and a Cabinetry license for the second company.
Chairman Lantz: So, you have a Cabinetry license in Lee County?
Fernanda Rosa: Yes.
Chairman Lantz: You just don’t ... so, it’s not a matter of taking the test ... it’s more
a matter of applying?
Fernanda Rosa: Yes.
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes.
Chairman Lantz: Theoretically?
Everildo Ybaceta: Theoretically, if she passed the same examination and received a
75 or better on the examination, then yes – it could just be a letter of reciprocity.
Chairman Lantz: And, technically, that wouldn’t have to go through us?
Everildo Ybaceta: No.
4.A.a
Packet Pg. 8 Attachment: January 2019 Minutes (8021 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019)
January 16, 2019
6
Chairman Lantz: So, we could approve her Second Entity and say it doesn’t go into
effect until she gets her Cabinetry license?
Everildo Ybaceta: Correct.
Chairman Lantz: If we wanted to go that route.
Everildo Ybaceta: You could that route ... it’s not really putting the cart before the
horse – yes, there is the Cabinetry license, but you could name a company anything
you want and apply for a completely different license. You could call it “Scuba Pros”
and still be a tile and marble company. Are you really doing scuba?
Chairman Lantz: Can I name my company, “Naples Engineering Service” and be a
General Contractor, not an engineer?
Everildo Ybaceta: Again, you can name it whatever you want.
Chairman Lantz: I don’t think so.
Everildo Ybaceta: You can’t?
Chairman Lantz: As an engineer?
Vice Chairman Nolton: Well, there are certain Statutes apply to the use of the word,
“Engineering” ... so
Everildo Ybaceta: Okay. Then I was wrong on that one and I do apologize for it.
Chairman Lantz: I think people would frown at me if I had a company named
“Naples Law Firm” and I didn’t have an employee ... or “Naples Orthopedic
Surgeon” or “Naples Cabinetry” – same idea. If I’m issuing a license, I might frown
upon that.
Vice Chairman Nolton: I guess, for me, the real question is for two companies with
the same license, if you wanted to add services – you could have just expanded your
existing company and put it in there ...
Fernanda Rosa: Yes.
Vice Chairman Nolton: ... versus us authorizing two companies for the same entity
with the same license. Then, where you lose control, they could bid against each
other for a job and we would never know.
Everildo Ybaceta: You’re right.
Chairman Lantz: Me, personally, I am not a fan of the Second Entity, obviously.
But to me, they are two different companies: one does tile installation and one does
countertops. I mean, I know some countertop guys who dabble in tile and I know
some tile guys who dabble in granite, but I don’t know many companies who do both.
Maybe I’m wrong but at least, to me personally, there is a clear division. They are
two different trades almost. Yes, they can both be done by a Tile and Marble
Contractor but, to me, they are two different trades. I can’t imagine a granite
company that is going to be doing a whole bunch of tile work. The granite companies
in town ... you don’t see many granite companies setting tile. They may fix
something or do something really small here or there. They are licensed but are
typically not doing it.
Chairman Lantz: Anyone interested in entertaining a motion?
[Members stated they were experiencing technical difficulties with the computers.]
4.A.a
Packet Pg. 9 Attachment: January 2019 Minutes (8021 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019)
January 16, 2019
7
Chairman Lantz: Are there any other questions from the Board?
Patrick White: I don’t know how the other members feel but, at this point, I would
be uncomfortable issuing a second [license] until she has passed Cabinetry.
Terry Jerulle: I tend to agree with Mr. White.
Chairman Lantz: Would you be open to approving a Second Entity but having it
not going into effect until after she gets her Cabinetry issued? Theoretically, she can
get her Cabinetry license issued without coming to the Board.
Terry Jerulle: That’s true.
Chairman Lantz: So, for the sake of saving time, would you be opposed to ...?
Terry Jerulle: She still has to get her Cabinetry license separately – she doesn’t
have to come back before us.
Vice Chairman Nolton: If she wants to do countertops -- the way I’m understanding
this – she will. She still needs that license, too?
Chairman Lantz: Correct.
Vice Chairman Nolton: She needs both licenses?
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes, she does because she is doing granite and that is a stone.
Vice Chairman Nolton: So, we could approve this with a restriction that it’s only
for ...
Everildo Ybaceta: Correct and that’s what I initially ...
Vice Chairman Nolton: ... tile and marble as you just stated?
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes.
Terry Jerulle: There again, we’re back to the name of the entity and what she does
and how she does it.
Patrick White: Wouldn’t there have to be a second restriction as the Chairman
suggested that cabinets would be restricted until the Cabinetry license was approved?
Chairman Lantz: I’m suggesting the Second Entity doesn’t get qualified at all until
the Cabinetry license is approved.
Vice Chairman Nolton: It seems like we may be complicating this a little bit ... the
stone and the granite is the question because that’s the only reason for her to come
before us. We can limit it and say it is only for countertops, granite or quartz and
then she would not have to come before us. If she ever does need the Cabinetry
license, that would be up to her and she doesn’t have to come before the Board. I
don’t have a problem that the company name says, “Cabinetry.” That would be their
issue. If they do cabinetry without a license, then they have other ramifications that
will come into play.
Everildo Ybaceta: That is correct.
Patrick White: But that becomes an enforcement issue that requires resources. I
don’t know that I want to put the County in the position of policing something in a
preventive way when we can take responsibility for that today and preclude this from
happening.
Terry Jerulle: By her own testimony, she wants to do cabinets.
Patrick White: And have both do tile ... very limited ... but ...
Vice Chairman Nolton: So, that goes back to just the name issue? If she applied for
the Cabinetry license and used the same name that said ‘stone,’ she wouldn’t be in
front of us and she’d have the name because the County has nothing to do or say
about the name of the entity?
4.A.a
Packet Pg. 10 Attachment: January 2019 Minutes (8021 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019)
January 16, 2019
8
Everildo Ybaceta: That’s correct.
Chairman Lantz: She’d still be in front of us to qualify a Second Entity.
Vice Chairman Nolton: But the Cabinetry is totally different.
Chairman Lantz: Oh, no, no, no – the Cabinetry is totally separate. But if she
wants to do countertops ...
Vice Chairman Nolton: Right.
Chairman Lantz: ... she still has to come in front of us.
Patrick White: To put on top of the cabinets.
Chairman Lantz: Right.
Patrick White: Mr. Chairman, I ...
Terry Jerulle: But to me, I look at it a bit differently – she already has a license to
do stone through another entity ... if she were coming in front of us with a license in
hand for cabinets and then asking for a stone license, how is it different than coming
in front of us with a stone license and asking us for a Cabinetry license?
Chairman Lantz: So, let me ask you a question. You brought in a separate partner
to add the stone portion. What did that partner bring to the table? Did he bring a
bunch of equipment – knowledge – customers?
Fernanda Rosa: Knowledge.
Chairman Lantz: Did you have to buy new equipment to start making countertops?
Is that what you’re doing -- making them or just installing them?
Fernanda Rosa: No, we make them. We buy the slabs and we cut and fit them – we
do everything. We have a shop in Fort Myers.
Chairman Lantz: And did you have a shop before you started doing countertops?
Fernanda Rosa: No.
Chairman Lantz: And who fronted all the money for shop and the additional tools?
Fernanda Rosa: We had some saved and the other partner had some, too. I mean,
the cutting machine is financed – that’s the major expense.
Chairman Lantz: Right. So, bringing the new partner in – the new partner probably
doesn’t want to give a chunk of his money to the current company.
Patrick White: Understood.
Everildo Ybaceta: Question, if I may? You said you have a Cabinetry license in
Lee County?
Fernanda Rosa: Yes, I do.
Everildo Ybaceta: Do you remember what you did to get that Cabinetry license?
Fernanda Rosa: What I did?
Everildo Ybaceta: The testing that you had to take?
Fernanda Rosa: The business ...
Everildo Ybaceta: There was a Business and Law exam.
Fernanda Rosa: Yes.
Everildo Ybaceta: Okay. Do you remember the grade that you got?
Fernanda Rosa: I think 78 or 80 ... something like that.
Everildo Ybaceta: Okay. Our Cabinetry license is basically a Business and Law
test and you have to have a minimum grade of 75. So, with a letter of reciprocity, she
could send that to us and apply for her Cabinetry license without having to go through
testing.
4.A.a
Packet Pg. 11 Attachment: January 2019 Minutes (8021 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019)
January 16, 2019
9
Chairman Lantz: She’s already taken the same Business test ...
Everildo Ybaceta: She’s taken it there ... correct.
Chairman Lantz: So, it should be a very simple process.
Everildo Ybaceta: It should be a simple process.
Chairman Lantz: And in Terry’s defense, it could have been done yesterday.
What’s the pleasure of the Board? Does anybody want to make a motion?
Vice Chairman Nolton: The company, Roca Granite and Cabinets, LLC, is already
in place – it’s already licensed and already doing work in Lee County?
Fernanda Rosa: Yes.
Patrick White: Do you have any potential customers in Collier County at this point
for granite countertops or cabinets?
Fernanda Rosa: Right now, we have our Contractor – a General Contractor – he’s
the one we work with most down here. He builds houses on Marco Island. That’s
why I’m here – I want to get everything right and do what I can do.
Vice Chairman Nolton: Are you operating both business out of the same location?
Fernanda Rosa: Yes. Oh, both businesses ... you mean the first company? No, no,
no – I don’t have an office open for my Ocleano Services, no. We have an office and
a warehouse for Roca. Ocleano Services is just a subcontractor. We provide services
to Lowe’s ... that’s all we do. It’s totally different.
Chairman Lantz: You just send tile installers ...?
Fernanda Rosa: Yes.
Chairman Lantz: ... for Lowe’s jobs?
Fernanda Rosa: Yes.
Chairman Lantz: Anybody?
Vice Chairman Nolton: Any discussion? [No response from the members] I would
propose a motion.
Vice Chairman Matthew Nolton moved to approve the license with the constraint
that it is only for granite, quartz, and other stone for countertops.
Chairman Lantz: That means the company cannot install tile with the new license?
Vice Chairman Nolton: Correct.
Chairman Lantz: Okay. We have a motion on the floor – is there a Second?
Michael Boyd offered a Second in support of the motion.
Chairman Lantz asked if the members wished to discuss the motion. There was no
response and he called for a vote on the motion.
Motion carried, 4 – “Yes”/1 – “No.” Patrick White was opposed.
Chairman Lantz offered congratulations and strongly suggested to Ms. Rosa that she
obtain the Cabinetry license.
C. Ledyar Diaz – Review of Credit
(d/b/a “Atlas Door & Gate, Inc.”)
Chairman Lantz directed Mr. Diaz to the podium.
4.A.a
Packet Pg. 12 Attachment: January 2019 Minutes (8021 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019)
January 16, 2019
10
Everildo Ybaceta mentioned there could be some continuing technical difficulties
accessing the computer.
Everildo Ybaceta: Mr. Diaz is before the Board for a review of his credit. The
reason is because there were a few judgments noted in his application. His credit
score is good – it is 722. The Board needs to address the judgments.
Chairman Lantz: Are the judgments ... ones that have been issued or are they
pending lawsuits?
Ledyar Diaz: Numbers one through six are all things that we have been paying ...
some of them are paid off. It’s mostly machinery and stuff that we need for the
company that we’ve either been paying on or are paying off. And then number seven
...
Chairman Lantz: Let me just stop you right there. For one through six, have you been
taken to Court and had a Judgment placed against you or are they just loans that you ...?
Ledyar Diaz: No, they’re just loans.
Chairman Lantz: So, you are paying them under the terms?
Ledyar Diaz: (nodding his head as “yes”)
Chairman Lantz: You’re not late? You’re not anything like that?
Ledyar Diaz: No.
Chairman Lantz: Okay.
Ledyar Diaz: Number seven is a late penalty from a state tax review. A couple of years
ago we changed our location and they sent us a letter for something that we had to pay.
In all the confusion, we received a late fee but that has been settled. We paid it and it
was closed.
Chairman Lantz: And I think you had a form in our packed that showed it was paid –
correct?
Ledyar Diaz: Yes.
Chairman Lantz: Okay.
Ledyar Diaz: Number 8 is, I believe, a situation that we had with a company called
Controlled Products. We had ordered some parts from them and the parts came with
some deficiencies. When we asked them to fix the parts, they refused. We went to
another company who fixed the parts and what they charged us, we asked Controlled
Products to remove that cost from their bill and we would pay the rest. That caused
problems – we had to get a lawyer and we went to Court. We settled everything and
everything is paid off.
Chairman Lantz: Do you have any paperwork for that?
Ledyar Diaz: No.
Chairman Lantz: Okay. And what about number nine?
Ledyar Diaz: Number nine was ... a secretary of ours in Tampa where we were
doing work ... she had issues with another employee of ours. She had been working
for us for a couple of months and then randomly stopped showing up one day. Then
we received a letter from a lawyer saying that she was accusing one of my employees
and we had to go to Court to settle everything. We tried to contact her to see what
was going on, but she refused to talk to us. We talked to the employees and none of
them had witnessed anything there. We had supervisors and management on site
daily and we, ourselves, would visit weekly because we were stationed in Miami. We
4.A.a
Packet Pg. 13 Attachment: January 2019 Minutes (8021 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019)
January 16, 2019
11
got a lawyer to defend ourselves. We got rid of the employee who was causing the
problems because of stuff that was happening later with his work ... nothing to do
with that. We went to Court and for the past two years, she’s been getting new
lawyers because she doesn’t have sufficient evidence against us to really do anything.
Chairman Lantz: Is this going through your insurance company or you directly?
Ledyar Diaz: No, no – us directly.
Chairman Lantz: Okay. So, the case is still pending – it’s been going on for two
years?
Ledyar Diaz: Yes, almost. We haven’t really had any Court dates because they
don’t have enough ... I don’t want to say “evidence” ... but they are pinning it against
us for an employee ...
Patrick White: Well, they are required to do something at Court once a year.
Ledyar Diaz: We haven’t done anything. We have our lawyer – if we need it, I can
get paperwork from our lawyer stating that he is active on our case.
Patrick White: My point is if the Plaintiff – your former employee – has not done
anything in a legal sense within a year timeframe, you can get the case dismissed.
Ledyar Diaz: Well, I don’t know why the case hasn’t been dismissed then.
Patrick White: Can we turn to page 110 in the packet? I believe that the purpose of
this form entitled “Resolution of Authorization” is because there are multiple partners
in this business entity. If you look at the signatures there are, in fact, two signatures –
one for each partner and both were witnessed. However, below that, it says that the
form was only acknowledged by one of the two partners. I would be interested in
anyone’s opinion on whether that was legally sufficient or not.
Chairman Lantz: Who is the other partner?
Ledyar Diaz: I can’t really tell whose signatures are there as the witnesses, but it
was signed by my parents.
Patrick White: But you’re the one who acknowledged the instrument?
Ledyar Diaz: I believe ...
Patrick White: It was your drivers’ license?
Ledyar Diaz: Yes.
Patrick White: Again, I would ask if that is the appropriate manner in which the
Resolution form is to be completed? I don’t know.
Chairman Lantz: So, there are three partners – you, your mother, and your father?
Ledyar Diaz: (nodding his head as “yes”)
Chairman Lantz: All equal partners?
Ledyar Diaz: No. I believe I have ten percent – maximum, twenty – my mother has
the most at around fifty or sixty, and my dad has the remaining amount.
Terry Jerulle: “Around”?? You don’t know how much ownership you have in the
company?
Ledyar Diaz: I believe it is ten percent – I’m 99% positive. I had to fill out some
paperwork last week that had to do with this. But I don’t want to give you a number
that’s wrong.
Terry Jerulle: The name is “Atlas Pool and Gate?”
Ledyar Diaz: No, it’s “Atlas Door and Gate.”
4.A.a
Packet Pg. 14 Attachment: January 2019 Minutes (8021 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019)
January 16, 2019
12
Patrick White: Turning back to the Resolution of Authorization – you have not
signed it as a partner ... is that correct?
Ledyar Diaz: Yeah – I believe that the reason I didn’t sign it was because ...
Patrick White: You couldn’t authorize yourself as a Qualifier?
Ledyar Diaz: The reason I didn’t sign the remaining third slot is because I believe
that – I thought that the two other partners were supposed to sign to show that ...
Patrick White: Well, it’s not a form that I’m very conversant with or familiar with
but it seems to say that all the owners/partners/officers need to sign it. I’m not trying
to make to big a deal out of it but, I’m just trying to do my job in reviewing the
documents.
Chairman Lantz: Are your parents still married?
Ledyar Diaz: Yes.
Chairman Lantz: Any other questions from the Board? [There were none.] It
appears that he has passed the Business Procedures test. You’re licensed in other
counties – correct?
Ledyar Diaz: Yes, in Miami-Dade.
Chairman Lantz: Just Miami-Dade?
Ledyar Diaz: Miami-Dade.
Chairman Lantz: And how long have you been licensed in Miami-Dade?
Ledyar Diaz: We’ve had the company for more than ten years and I’ve been
working in the company since 2016, 2017.
Chairman Lantz: So, there was a different Qualifier before you?
Ledyar Diaz: Yes.
Chairman Lantz: And the company has been in business for more than ten years?
Ledyar Diaz: Yes.
Terry Jerulle: What is this pending case again? What is the specific charge that this
person made?
Ledyar Diaz: She accused our employee of sexual harassment.
Terry Jerulle: She is one of your employees?
Ledyar Diaz: A former employee.
Chairman Lantz: Personally, I see no problems with it. I mean, it seems fine to me.
Does anybody else have any questions or comments? Does anybody want to
entertain a motion?
Patrick White: I would ask whoever makes the motion and Second, which I am not
prepared to do, do so with the requirement that the Resolution of Authorization form
is properly executed and provided to the County because it is not sufficient at this
point.
Chairman Lantz: Assuming that the vote is for approval?
Patrick White: Yes, indeed.
Vice Chairman Nolton: Does the County’s Attorney have an opinion about that
form?
Assistant County Attorney Kevin Noell: I think with the Resolution ... it’s
essentially other individuals representing that they are agreeing that Mr. Diaz can act
on their behalf. He’s the actor – the one doing the acting. I don’t know that I would
agree that he has to also sign it. Basically, the other representatives have given their
4.A.a
Packet Pg. 15 Attachment: January 2019 Minutes (8021 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019)
January 16, 2019
13
authorization for him to act on their behalf. So, I don’t know that I agree that Mr.
Diaz has to sign it – I don’t see an issue. Though, in an abundance of caution, to have
him execute it as well.
Patrick White: Isn’t the other issue – the one that’s also important. I don’t know
what the intent of the form is to say that whoever signs it at the bottom and has
acknowledged it. There’s a statement above that, indicating that it’s supposedly a
sworn statement under penalty of perjury, so I am not clear on whether an
“acknowledgment” is the appropriate way to have someone execute the document,
number one. Nor am I clear on whether both people who signed it as partners should
at some point be the ones who acknowledge it and have their identities substantiated
by way of a drivers’ license or something else. So, I have a problem with the form,
and I have a problem with the way the form has been completed. Until those are
corrected, I am not comfortable with a license being issued because the application is
not complete.
Assistant County Attorney Noell: As far as my position on that, I tend to agree
with ... I’ve seen this form ... but if we’re having representatives sign that form on
behalf of the company, I think that it has to be notarized that they were the people
who, in fact, signed it and their identifies were confirmed by the Notary. So that we
don’t face an issue where – and I’m sure it’s not the case here – but individuals could
come back later and say their never signed it – they never authorized it.
Patrick White: Correct, and I agree with you that there is probably some necessity
to revise the form.
Vice Chairman Nolton: Let me take a stab at this.
Vice Chairman Nolton moved to approve granting Ledyar Diaz’ application for a
Garage Door Installation Specialty Contractor’s License after the Resolution of
Authorization has been correctly signed, notarized, approved by Collier County,
and included as part of the application. Patrick White offered a Second in support
of the motion.
Motion carried, 4 – “Yes”/1 – “No.” Terry Jerulle was opposed.
Chairman Lantz: Congratulations. I don’t know if you paid attention to all that ...
Ledyar Diaz: You approved me to qualify for the license, but it’s not passed until I
properly turn in that form.
Chairman Lantz: Correct.
Vice Chairman Nolton: It may not be you – it sounds like the form needs to be
modified by the County.
Chairman Lantz: Probably your mother and father will need to sign it in front of a
Notary.
Patrick White: Yes.
Chairman Lantz: But Evy will guide you on that. Good luck!
Ledyar Diaz: Thank you – have a wonderful day.
D. Leonardo Guerra – Review of Credit
(“A to Z Garage Door Services, Inc., d/b/a A2Z Garage Doors”)
4.A.a
Packet Pg. 16 Attachment: January 2019 Minutes (8021 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019)
January 16, 2019
14
Chairman Lantz: Sir, you are trying to obtain a Garage Door Installation Specialty
Contractor’s License as well and you had some issues with your credit. Would you
like to give us some background?
Leonardo Guerra stated that two years ago, when he attempted to file his taxes, he
found out that his paychecks had been shorted by $5,000. The payroll company
claimed that he had been paid. He filed a police report. The result: his identity has
been stolen and someone used his credit to obtain two credit cards and purchase two
vehicles. He further stated the credit report should reflect that it was straightened out.
There were “a couple” of items that were his but everything else was due to the
identify theft.
Chairman Lantz: A police report was filed?
Leonardo Guerra: Yes, sir. When I found out, I had to file a police report and then
go to the IRS. Then I had to go to the creditors – the ones that I saw weren’t mine –
and deal with them. Most of them cleared the debt, but a few didn’t want to clear me.
Chairman Lantz: And you’re still fighting?
Leonardo Guerra: Yes, sir. I’m in the process and trying to take care of it.
Chairman Lantz: You haven’t given us a copy of the police report or any of that –
correct? I don’t remember seeing anything.
Leonardo Guerra: I didn’t put it in there, but I have this right here [opening a
document] – just got it in the mail from the IRS. You’re more than welcome if you
want to read it.
Chairman Lantz: If you submit that to us, it’s ours.
Leonardo Guerra: Yes ...
Chairman Lantz: You won’t get it back.
Leonardo Guerra: Well ... it has my “pin”
Vice Chairman Nolton: We really don’t want to see your pin.
Leonardo Guerra: I need my “pin” ... I guess I have to keep it ... I can’t do my taxes
without it.
Everildo Ybaceta: Anything that is submitted is “public” under the Sunshine Law
and becomes a public record. I don’t think you want to do that.
Leonardo Guerra: No.
Vice Chairman Nolton: You said a couple of items on here were yours?
Leonardo Guerra: Yes, sir. There was a car loan for a Lexus that I took out for a
cousin of mine in Las Vegas – I don’t live in Las Vegas – he was going through a
hard time – I understood that and tried to help him out. Eventually, he couldn’t make
the payments on it. He called me and I told him to turn it in – I mean, my credit is
bad anyway because of this ... I’m in the process right now of getting that squared
away with the company. There was a rental agreement and the company zeroed it out
for me. There’s a Green Dot credit card that’s also mine. But that’s a pre-paid card
so I don’t know how that came in on there. You buy them a Wal-Mart ...
Chairman Lantz: But you’re not behind on that?
Leonardo Guerra: No – it’s pre-paid so I don’t know how that came in, but that is
mine. The Kia-Sorrento car loan is not mine ... there’s an “Atlas” something or other
that’s not mine ...
Chairman Lantz: For some reason, I thought there were only two open accounts ...
if I’m not mistaken. There are only two that are open right now.
4.A.a
Packet Pg. 17 Attachment: January 2019 Minutes (8021 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019)
January 16, 2019
15
Vice Chairman Nolton: Are you currently licensed in Lee County?
Leonardo Guerra: Yes, sir.
Vice Chairman Nolton: You’re in business and doing work in Lee County?
Leonardo Guerra: Yes, sir. And I’m also in Miami-Dade County.
Chairman Lantz: Do you have any employees?
Leonardo Guerra: No – it’s just me and my son.
Chairman Lantz: Is your son an employee?
Leonardo Guerra: Yes.
Chairman Lantz: So, is your son an owner of the company?
Leonardo Guerra: Yes, he is. It started between me and him and he has 10% and I
have 90%. I mean he’s ... but I do everything ... it’s just a ... it’s really my company
but, eventually, you know ...
Chairman Lantz: Do you have Workers’ Comp coverage for you son?
Leonardo Guerra: I’m sorry?
Chairman Lantz: I think I saw that you had a Workers’ Comp exemption for
yourself. Do you have coverage for your son or an exemption for your son?
Leonardo Guerra: I use him whenever I get an outside contract ... he works for
another garage door company, so whenever he has time off and I’m busy – he helps
me out ... I’ll sub him out. He’s not like directly with me. I do all my work by
myself most of the time.
Chairman Lantz: So, if he is helping you out and he falls off a ladder and is hurt ...
does he go to the company that he works for and says ...
Leonardo Guerra: No, no, no.
Chairman Lantz: So, who would pay his medical bills?
Leonardo Guerra: Well, I mean ... I would.
Vice Chairman Nolton: Is he on payroll or is he ...?
Leonardo Guerra: No ... he just helps me out whenever ... like I said, if I’m busy or
something, he’ll help me out. It’s no big deal.
Patrick White: How does he get paid for helping you out?
Leonardo Guerra: Well, he doesn’t ... I mean he’s not ... okay ... like, he helps me
out whenever I’m busy but, other than that, it’s mostly me.
Patrick White: So, he does it for free out of the goodness of his heart?
Leonardo Guerra: Well ... I mean ... wouldn’t you ... if you were extremely busy ...
Patrick White: We’re not talking about me.
Leonardo Guerra: Okay, yeah, he does it.
Patrick White: I would.
Leonardo Guerra: Yes, I would do it for him. If I’m extremely busy and he’s off
work and I’m up to eight o’clock at night – hey, help me out here – and he comes
over and helps me.
Vice Chairman Nolton: The more correct statement is the business is just you.
Leonardo Guerra: Yes.
Vice Chairman Nolton: Your son has no ownership in it?
Leonardo Guerra: I do everything solo, by myself – correct.
Terry Jerulle: You previously said your son has 10%.
Leonardo Guerra: Yeah – he helps me about ten percent of the time.
4.A.a
Packet Pg. 18 Attachment: January 2019 Minutes (8021 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019)
January 16, 2019
16
Vice Chairman Nolton: The question is about the legal entity. Does he own any
part of the company?
Leonardo Guerra: No.
Patrick White: The statement of ownership says that the Applicant owns 100%
of the company.
Chairman Lantz: Right.
Leonardo Guerra: I apologize – I got mixed up. How much time does he help me?
Probably about ten percent of it ... you know ... at night or something if I’m stuck.
Chairman Lantz: But you have no Workers’ Comp coverage for him?
Leonardo Guerra: No.
Chairman Lantz: Okay. Any other questions?
Patrick White: I see a lot of documents on the credit report that say, “Failure to
pay.” Can you explain some of those? In particular, I am interested in the ones that
were closed but not charged off.
Leonardo Guerra: Like, which one?
Patrick White: (experiencing technical difficulties locating an example) Let me page
down to find that for you. Normally, I would have had a little sticky note on the side
and could have turned right to the page.
Vice Chairman Nolton: There’s one on Page 147.
Patrick White: Thank you for that reference. It’s taking me longer to ...
Vice Chairman Nolton: It’s “Acceptance Now.”
Patrick White: That is not one that I would ...
Vice Chairman Nolton: It says, “closed,” But there’s still a balance.
Patrick White: True, but it doesn’t indicate a failure to pay ... it shows there were
late payments. There were some near the end of the packet that were, I think, more
clear examples of a creditor finding that the money was owed and let’s try, for
example, Page 157 of the packet ... it’s a closed account ... it’s older ... it was for a
collection agency apparently, for an apartment you may have occupied ... owing an
original balance of $1,912.00. The creditor has indicated there was a failure to pay
going back to the beginning of the debt ... sometime in May of 2012. Can you
explain why for all this time you have failed to pay it ... or have you paid it and the
record is incorrect?
Leonardo Guerra: No, the record is correct. It’s one of the scams. That place is in
Dallas, Texas. I did talk to them – I called the community – Steeple Way Downs
Apartments – I talked to them ... I can email it to you ... I showed that I never,
personally, lived there. Someone used my Social with another name and lived there
for about a year.
Vice Chairman Nolton: That’s part of the fraud?
Leonardo Guerra: Yes, sir.
Patrick White: Would I be correct in saying that the same thing would be true for
the creditor known as “Tempoe, LLC” for $239.00?
Leonardo Guerra: Most likely ... I don’t even remember them. It’s probably one of
those that I have no control over.
Vice Chairman Nolton: How long have you been in Florida?
Leonardo Guerra: Pretty much all my life. I lived in Houston, Texas, for about ....
4.A.a
Packet Pg. 19 Attachment: January 2019 Minutes (8021 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019)
January 16, 2019
17
Vice Chairman Nolton: I was just trying to understand – there’s a lot of these
from other states. So those ones that are part of the fraud?
Leonardo Guerra: Yes. I was only in Houston, Texas for a year and a half, and that
was it.
Vice Chairman Nolton: Like the one that says, “Stuart Lippman & Associates?”
Leonardo Guerra: Yea – I have nothing to do with them.
Chairman Lantz: When I was going through this last night, I wasn’t smart enough
to think “fraud” and I was thinking, ‘what kind of idiot takes out a loan and doesn’t
make a single payment on it’ – like, twenty-five times? Now that I understand there
was fraud, I get it and I would say a normal person would at least make one payment
before he stopped paying. So, I can totally understand.
Patrick White: Here’s a suggestion –
Leonardo Guerra: Yes, sir.
Patrick White: Get them removed.
Leonardo Guerra: That’s what I have tried to do. I’ve talked to Experian and
Experian said the creditor must remove it. I’ve talked to each creditor like Steeple
Way Apartments and they said that they didn’t see anything. I guess between the
time the person lived there and I found out, it had then gone to a collection agency. It
was such a mess that I just left it to a company called “Greenway” or something like
that ... they are here in Fort Myers and they are going to ...
Vice Chairman Nolton: You have hired a company to help you resolve this – is that
what you’re saying?
Leonardo Guerra: Yeah, yeah – exactly. I just found out about this last year. I was
unaware of this ... I really don’t ... like I said, I know the Lexus is mine and I take full
responsibility for it. It’s funny, when I talked to Lexus, nobody told me anything ...
everything was fine. But then when I started to do my taxes, that’s when I knew
because I got hit.
Patrick White: You don’t happen to know if Steeple Way is in Houston?
Leonardo Guerra: No, I think it’s somewhere in Dallas.
Patrick White: Almost a world apart. I have nothing further, Mr. Chairman.
Chairman Lantz: Okay. So, we have a case of somebody with very bad credit due
to fraud – a lot of mistakes due to somebody else – but still some mistakes are his
own.
Patrick White: Maybe ... I have one more question.
Chairman Lantz: Absolutely – go ahead.
Patrick White: Did the folks who are helping you out with your credit reporting
issues give you any idea of how long they think it might take them to fix things and
get your credit report back into shape?
Leonardo Guerra: They gave me a couple of options. They said the easiest and
fastest way – I should see a difference between six months to one year – they said the
easiest way is to contact each one and try to get to a settlement on each one. They
ones that don’t want to comply aren’t understanding that this is fraud and not me.
There are some ... like Atlantic or Atlas or whatever ... they don’t want to budge.
Patrick White: At that point, your credit report ought to indicate that it is something
you are disputing. There is no indication that I’ve seen in any of the documents that
4.A.a
Packet Pg. 20 Attachment: January 2019 Minutes (8021 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019)
January 16, 2019
18
we have been provided. The reason for my question is ... I’m thinking that we will
want to see your credit report again – I would like to – I don’t know if the rest of the
Board feels that way. But I will need it if we’re going to make it part of the motion ...
to give you a probationary license for six months or one year. We need to know how
long it will take or that someone told you it would take to get things fixed so that we
don’t have you come back here next month and find nothing has been fixed. That’s
why I asked you were told it may take to get things fixed.
Leonardo Guerra: They told me between six months and one year. They’re trying
to get them all together so ...
Patrick White: Correct.
Leonardo Guerra: I made one payment.
Patrick White: So, the ones that are legitimately believed by you to be your
responsibility –you can work out a settlement and make whatever in payments ... that
would be something that you could document, and it would show on your credit
report I believe ...
Leonardo Guerra: Yes, sir.
Patrick White: The others that are incapable of being resolved, you would – at that
point – show they were in dispute. At that point, I would say, we would be done in
terms of a full review of your credit. I don’t want to impose something that will make
us have to do more work if you keep coming back here. If we do it once, then it’s
better.
Chairman Lantz: It sounds like you’re prepared to make a motion.
Patrick White: I am if no one else has any other questions. [There was no response
from the Board.]
Patrick White moved to approve granting the application for a Garage Door
Installation Contractor’s License on a probationary basis for a term of six months.
At the end of the probationary period, Mr. Guerra is to appear before the Board
with an updated credit report, both personal and business.
Everildo Ybaceta: Question? Do you, in your motion ... are you asking him to
come before the Board again?
Patrick White: Yes, in six months with those reports. Now, are you asking me – by
way of your question – whether we should be comfortable with you reviewing the
credit reports and, if you think they are fine, then – administratively – are you
allowed to approve it? Is that what you’re asking?
Everildo Ybaceta: That would be the second part of my question.
Patrick White: Sorry to anticipate.
Everildo Ybaceta: No, but that is correct.
Everildo Ybaceta: I do not want ... if I can, I would prefer not to waste the Board’s
... let me re-phrase this ... bring something back to the Board that may not need to
come before the Board. If you wish me to bring this back before the Board, I am
happy to do that – I don’t have an issue with that.
Patrick White: Mr. Chairman, I am fine to re-state the form of my motion.
4.A.a
Packet Pg. 21 Attachment: January 2019 Minutes (8021 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019)
January 16, 2019
19
Patrick White moved to approve granting a probationary six-month license for a
Garage Door Installation Contractor’s License, subject to returning before the
Board for a review of personal and business credit reports at the discretion of the
Contractors’ Licensing Office Supervisor.
Terry Jerulle: Mr. Chairman?
Chairman Lantz: Yes, sir.
Terry Jerulle: By Mr. Guerra’s own admission, he has had his son work on-site
with him without Workers’ Compensation and if I were to hire him or another
contractor or a homeowner would hire him ... and he has his son on-site without
Workers’ Compensation – I can’t vote for that. It’s his testimony.
Chairman Lantz: He could get a Workers’ Compensation exemption and solve that
problem very quickly. He could have done that ...
Terry Jerulle: That’s correct.
Chairman Lantz: ... when he [the son] started working for him.
Terry Jerulle: If he does fall and get hurt, it either goes back to the Contractor’s
insurance or the homeowner’s insurance. Isn’t it our responsibility to protect those
people?
Chairman Lantz: Yes, sir.
Patrick White: I will amend my motion to add a second condition.
Patrick White moved to approve granting a probationary six-month license for a
Garage Door Installation Contractor’s License, subject to returning before the
Board for a review of personal and business credit reports at the discretion of the
Supervisor of the Contractors’ Licensing Office.
Additionally, Mr. Guerra is to provide proof to the Supervisor of the Contractors’
Licensing Office within thirty (30) days of obtaining either: (1) an exemption from
Workers’ Compensation for his employee – even if the employee receives zero pay –
or (2) Workers’ Compensation insurance coverage for his employee. If neither is
provided in a form adequate for review by the Supervisor, then the probationary
license will not be issued, and Mr. Guerra will again appear before the Board.
Chairman Lantz: I would like to ask a question for clarification: does he need to
show this before the license is issued, or does he have thirty days to do it?
Patrick White: He needs to show it and if it’s not done within thirty days and the
Supervisor wishes to bring it back, we’ll see Mr. Guerra again to determine whether,
in fact, we would grant the probationary license.
Chairman Lantz: I’m confused. So, if doesn’t show it, does he get the probationary
license ...?
Patrick White: Nope.
Chairman Lantz: He doesn’t get the probationary license?
Patrick White: He doesn’t get the license until he provides the documents to the
satisfaction of the Licensing Office Supervisor. If it is not done within thirty days,
there is no license. But if it is done within thirty days and is satisfactory, a
probationary license will be issued for six months subject to review by the
Contractor’s Licensing Office Supervisor of the required updated business and
4.A.a
Packet Pg. 22 Attachment: January 2019 Minutes (8021 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019)
January 16, 2019
20
personal credit reports. If the documents are provided and the Supervisory is
satisfied, then the license will become a full license. No more probation.
Chairman Lantz: Complete?
Patrick White: Yes. Sorry.
Chairman Lantz: No problem. I just wanted to make sure. We have a motion. Is
there a Second?
Terry Jerulle: Mr. Guerra, did you understand that?
Leonardo Guerra: Yes, I understand. I have to get the Workers’ Compensation for
my son now and take in the creditor report in six months.
Patrick White: That’s correct and the easiest way to do the first two is to make him
an Officer of the Corporation ...
Leonardo Guerra: Of the LLC?
Patrick White: ... of whatever the entity is.
Leonardo Guerra: Okay.
Vice Chairman Nolton: Then you can file for an exemption for him.
Leonardo Guerra: Okay.
Vice Chairman Matthew Nolton offered a Second in support of the motion.
Chairman Lantz noted there was a motion and a Second on the floor. He asked if
there was any discussion. There was no further response from the Board.
Chairman Lantz called for a vote on the motion. Carried unanimously, 5 – 0.
Chairman Lantz: Congratulations!
Leonardo Guerra: Thank you very much.
Chairman Lantz: And you clearly understood what needs to be done on your end?
Right?
Leonardo Guerra: Yes.
Chairman Lantz: Okay.
Leonardo Guerra: Thank you.
Chairman Lantz: Good luck.
IX. OLD BUSINESS:
Chairman Lantz: Do you have any old business?
Patrick White: Kind of. Under Item VIII-C (“New Business”) in the application, there
were a series of Department of State – Division of Corporation print-outs provided for
entity names that were unrelated to the applicant entity. I’m just wondering why they
were in there. Was is an attempt to confuse – because I was. The name of the entity that
was applying was Atlas Door & Gate, Inc. Initially what I looked at and reviewed the
printout ...
Vice Chairman Nolton: On Page 114 ...
Patrick White: Yep ... correct ... and I was just wondering why those were in there.
After I looked at them, my assumption was – and I didn’t verify it was – maybe these
were here because the search was done with the guy’s name and, somehow, the other
4.A.a
Packet Pg. 23 Attachment: January 2019 Minutes (8021 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019)
January 16, 2019
21
ones came up. When I first looked at one of the forms, I saw that the entity was
administratively dissolved. My question would have been, ‘why are we dealing with an
inactive entity?’ But – Atlas Door and whatever – the Applicant is legit and active. Was
wondering why the other ones were in there and didn’t want to take the time to make
them part of the discussion. One of the ones on Page 112, for example, is “Garage Doors
Corporation” ...
Everildo Ybaceta: That’s North American Eagle Garage Doors Corporation.
Patrick White: ... correct. So ... I was just kind scratching my head wondering why it
was there.
Everildo Ybaceta: We can definitely look into that ...
Patrick White: Okay.
Everildo Ybaceta: ... and why it is there.
Patrick White: Let me know – even though I have to look at it on my tiny little screen
to see this stuff, I do catch things. I just can’t go back and point them out to you ...
apparently, I must adopt a different methodology of reviews now that I know how it
works on this end.
Everildo Ybaceta: And this is why I greatly appreciate your presence on the
Contractors’ Licensing Board.
Patrick White: Can I ask for a raise?
Vice Chairman Nolton: We’ll double what you’re getting paid!
(Laughter)
Michael Boyd: Now that Mr. White has brought it up – if you look at the Verification of
Construction Experience on Page 115, there is only one month where he worked with
somebody. They crossed out “employed” and put “worked with.”
Chairman Lantz: But he had a couple of different – if I’m not mistaken, he had a
couple of different ones.
Michael Boyd: Yes – the other one was a year ... 6/1 ... and then they crossed out “was
employed” and put “work with” – 06/01/17 to 06/01/18.
Everildo Ybaceta: The Verification of Construction Experience – we’re going to amend
that to show where he got the experience and, in some cases, we have to talk to different
contractors that he’s worked with to show verification of experience. The application –
I’ve talked to Staff about it and we’re in the process of doing it – we’re going to change
the wording to reflect the differences.
Patrick White: And which of them – if not both – tracks the verbatim from the Code as
to the stated requirements for the scope of prior employment or work? Just so long as
we’re all ...
Everildo Ybaceta: And as long as we meet the minimum requirements of the Code ...
yes, I understand what you’re asking for ...
Patrick White: Okay.
Everildo Ybaceta: ... and will definitely put that in there.
Patrick White: Cool. And I guess you’re dealing with – at the same time – the
Resolution of Authorization?
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes, I’ve had this issue come up before and we’ve had the very same
discussions within our group as to which one falls in better and that’s why we’ve had
discussions about amending the application itself or that form.
4.A.a
Packet Pg. 24 Attachment: January 2019 Minutes (8021 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019)
January 16, 2019
22
Patrick White: One other thing I would encourage you to consider is, effectively, a self-
authentication – a statement made under penalty of perjury – Florida Statutes allows you
to do that, so you don’t need to have it “notarized.” It could simplify things for the
Applicant and the County; it could reduce the potential for errors – like today when
somebody signed something on behalf of somebody else. You can use either way of
doing it, of course, and people will probably do both because they don’t read the forms.
It’s just a suggestion.
Chairman Lantz: All right – any other “Old Business?” No “Public Hearings?” The
next meeting date is Wednesday, February 20, 2019 at 9:00 AM, right here.
X. PUBLIC HEARING:
(None)
NEXT MEETING DATE: WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 20, 2019
BCC Chambers, 3rd Floor – Administrative Building “F,
Government Complex, 3301 E. Tamiami Trail, Naples, FL
There being no further business for the good of the County, the meeting was adjourned by
order of the Chairman at 10:10 AM.
COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS’
LICENSING BOARD
_____________________________________
KYLE E. LANTZ, Chairman
The Minutes were approved by the Chairman or Vice Chairman of the Contractors’ Licensing
Board on ______________________, 2019, “as submitted” [___] - OR - “as amended” [___]
4.A.a
Packet Pg. 25 Attachment: January 2019 Minutes (8021 : APPROVAL OF MINUTES - JANUARY 16, 2019)
02/20/2019
COLLIER COUNTY
Contractor Licensing Board
Item Number: 8.A
Item Summary: ORDERS OF THE BOARD
Meeting Date: 02/20/2019
Prepared by:
Title: – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Lilla Davis
02/12/2019 8:48 AM
Submitted by:
Title: Supervisor - Operations – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Everildo Ybaceta
02/12/2019 8:48 AM
Approved By:
Review:
Contractor Licensing Board Lilla Davis Review Item Completed 02/12/2019 8:48 AM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Review Item Completed 02/12/2019 2:29 PM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Meeting Pending 02/20/2019 9:00 AM
8.A
Packet Pg. 26
02/20/2019
COLLIER COUNTY
Contractor Licensing Board
Item Number: 8.B
Item Summary: MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL & PRESSURE CLEANING,
LLC – REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE
Meeting Date: 02/20/2019
Prepared by:
Title: – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Lilla Davis
02/12/2019 8:43 AM
Submitted by:
Title: Supervisor - Operations – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Everildo Ybaceta
02/12/2019 8:43 AM
Approved By:
Review:
Contractor Licensing Board Lilla Davis Review Item Completed 02/12/2019 8:46 AM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Review Item Completed 02/12/2019 2:29 PM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Meeting Pending 02/20/2019 9:00 AM
8.B
Packet Pg. 27
aRfu, couvr ty
COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD
TUICHAEL HALDIE_ APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE
MICHAEL HALDIE is coming before the board today to review his experience and to be approved for
the Roof Coat, Paint, and Clean Contractor License. Mr. Haldie provided letters from customers and
pictures of his work.
Mr. Haldie has been licensed with the county with a Swimming Pool Clean Only license since
121512012. During that time, he did not renew in 2013 and reinstated on 410312014. He also didn't
renew in 2016 and was reinstated on 211012017 .
ln July 2012, Mr. Haldie was on site doing roof cleaning when a compliance officer observed him
working. He said he was from Algae Eaters Pool and Pressure Cleaning and the license holder was
Megan Hughes. An investigation was conducted, and a citation was issued to Megan Hughes
(Haldie) on711612012 for unlicensed Roof Coat, Paint, and Clean. The citation number 7071 for $300
was paid on 12113112.
Roof coating, roof painting, and roof cleaning contractor requires 24 months experience, a passing
grade on a business and law test, and means any person who is qualified to clean, paint or coat a
roof by means of pressure-operated equipment, hand application or otherwise. This category does
not include roof repair. Ordinance 2006-46 (1.6.3.35)
February 20,2019
9:00 A.M.
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 28 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
Gontents
Letter to go in Front of the Board
Application
lndividual Credit Report
Company Credit Report
IRS EIN Documents
Resolution of Authorization
Statement of Ownership
Letters from Previous Clients
Pictures Showing Before & After Work
Affidavit of lntegrity & Good Character
Certificate of lnsurance
Driver's License
Board Hearing lnformation
Business Test Score
Sunbiz Documents
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 29 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
Mv name is Michael Haldie, I am requesting to be seen before the licensing board for
approval of Roof CoaV Paint & Clean license. My company is Algae Eaters Pool & pressure
Cleaning, LLC.
Mike Haldie
3823 Valentia Way
Naples FL 341 19
Thank
1/31/2019
State CDuntY of
$tBcrib€d and s$rom befo(€ rns on
l 1a/
llI
OF
7
C.a,-t'" t-
ere^a
t
Cortlt
Argnt 1l0,2clt
o. GG tao17
,_EJ-
llt
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 30 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
-R3., -r Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
Phone - 239-252-2431
Fax ' 239 252-2469
u'tn)/
Grs,vtr Managernent Departrnefi t
APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
Q Lutz-3teo FIRM APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY
CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
CZov- 4$oto
This application must be typewritten or legibty printed. The application fee must be paid upon approval and is NOT
refundable. All checks should be made payable to: Collier County Boatd of County Commissioners. For further
information, consult Collier County Ordinance No- 2006-46, as amended.
TYPE OF CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY:
! General
tr Building
! Residential
E Mechanical
n Roofing
$230.00
$230.00
$230.00
$230.00
$230.00
! Electrician
I Plumber
tr Air Conditioner
tr Swimming Pool
B-Specialty
t Co"Ju"Jovtr)o. r cl'\Specialty Trade
I. APPLICANTPERSONALINFORMATION:
I b.
t /r,fd /*
Name u
Last
Address 3 taJ
Middle lnitia
Clty
/ drl
r0 , //--<-
sIt
Street State zip
Emair: cr ladl . (rt'lb t Q /otru;/'
/
Telephone 8lE - 3a1' )Jro -SS # (Last 4 digits only)/2J{
Date of Birth:Ao ad
FIRM APPLiCATION Rev 4/12f18 Page 3 of 15
$230.00
$230.00
$230.00
$230.00
$20s.00
Q o o-\
Business Name:
Driver's License # (Last 4 digits only)
iPursuant to Chapter l-19, florida Statutes and Collier Coonty Conuactor Licensing O.dinance 2fl)6-46 Section 2.1.1., all applicant5 a.e required to
submit their sociel s€curity number (55N) for the followinS purposes: a) Assess applicant', ability to satisfy creditors by reviewing their credit history.
b)Verification ofapplican(s test scores and infonnation. our offce willonly use your SSN noted above Iorthose reasons puEuant to chapter t-19,
Florida Statutes, and as mav otherwise be authoriued by law. We aretully committed to $fe-guardinS end protectint your SSN and once (ollected, will
be maintained as confidential and exempt under Chapter l-19, tlorida Statutes,
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 31 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
-z--c,fiff.,Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
Phone - 239-252-2431
Fax - 239-?52-2469
Cott*tt!
Grow{h Managernert Departrnefl t
Provide the names and telephone numbers of two persons who will always know your whereabouts
Nam e lLl,4 l(Name ?
Telephone:--?tr LA{ 7 Telephone .) ]1-9/f-1?6 7
II. NAME OF APPLICANT'S BUSINESS:
1 t)4 LE
zip
Business Name:e
Business Address
Telephone: t t3? I 5
A/q f-z 3q4
CitySt State
Q lo/^o,Ema I
Federal lD Tax No.:o
III. FINANCIAL RESPONSIBILITY
NOTE. lf you have answer yESto any of the questions below, you must attach a written explanation including the
nature of the charges, dates, and oulcomes, sentences of conditions imposed. You must also attach proof of
payment, satisfaction of lien or judgement, bankruptcy discharge, or agreements for payment.tlf you have had a felony conviction, proof that your civil rights have been restored will be required prior to
licensure.
YES NO ALL APPLICANTS MUST ANSWER THE OUESTIONS BELOW:
x Filed for or been discharged in bankruptcy within the past 5 years?
E Had a lien filed against you by the lnternal Revenue Service or Florida Corporate Tax Division?
Undertaken construction contracts or work that resulted in liens, suits, or judgments being filed?
tr
E lvlade an assignment of assets in settlement of construction obligations for less than the debts
outstanding?
Been convicted or found guilty of, or entered a plea of nolo contendere to, regardless of
adjudication, a crime in any jurisdiction within the past '10 years?'
tr Had claims or lawsuits filed for unpaid or past due accounts by your creditors as a result of
construction experience?
tr Been charged with or convicted of acting as a contractor without a license, or if licensed as a
contractor in this or any other state, been "subject to" disciplinary action by a state, counly, or
municipality?
FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4/12/18 Page 4 of 15
APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
N
tr Undertaken construction contracts or work that a thlrd party, such as a bonding or surety company,
completed or made financial statements on?
tr tr
tr
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 32 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
C,Rff",Cor,t*rt3t
Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
Phone - 239-252-243'1
Fax - 239-252-2469
Gror/th Management Departrnert
APPLICATION FOR COIIIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
IV. EXPERIENCE VERIFICATION
EDUCATION:
List below and provide transcripts for any formal education you have obtained in the area of competency for which
this appl ication is bein g made:
lJor,.l6
List below non formal education (on the job training) you have obtained in the area of competency for which this
application is being made:
s o {e4_.asa.k;r/k
CURRENT/PREVIOUS LICENSE:
List below and attach copies any other certilicates of competency/licenses you hold/have held in Collier County or
any other jurisdiction. lnclude the license #, Type, and county you hold it in.
,5+ Y'L c"rrrrrl L'qrr" on {or / /ea np ?*,.1;.->1--
c
AFFIDAVIT
Under the penalties of perjury, I declare that I have read the foregoing application and the facts stated in it are
true
M,.hqrl /oU;o
Applicant {please print)
state or ( Lo. i lo
County of Coll;,r
The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this o/-2s-lq
by AicV'o.\ \\o\ tl<who has produced as identilication
name ol person ackfo nl)type of identilicatlon or known
Applicanl
NOTAR
FIRM APPLICATI
L
r v
Cotrrn.M,
2Blt2r0,Afld
25m$@t{o.
ON Re ll
ATURE OF NOTARY)
Page 5 ol 15
FL- DLtu
and did not take an
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 33 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
-a-c,frF.,Cor,t*tt!Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
Phone - 239-252-2431
Fax - 239 -252-2469
Growth Managernent Departrr€fl I
APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
CERTIFICATION OF APPTICATION
The undersigned hereby makes application for Certilicate of Competency under the provisions of Collier County
No. 2006-46, as amended, and under penalties of perjury. I declare that I have read the foregoing qualifier
information and that the facts stated in it are true.
The undersigned hereby certifies that he is legally qualified to act on behalf of the business organization sought to
be licensed in all matters connected with its contracting business and that he has full authority to supervise
construction undertaken by himself or such business or organization and that he will continue during this registration
to be able to so bind said business organization. The qualified license holder understands that in all contracting
matters, he/she will be held strictly accountable for any and all activities involving his license.
Any willful falsilication of any in{ormation contained herein is grounds for disqualification.
N,c
Applicant (please print
€r*"rr ({C
Name Company
Si gnature ol Applicant
State of F/c,-.,tr,
County of /'olltor
The foregoing inslrument as acknowledged before me this o/- 2s - /?
date
by A; cL,a"l l/" lJi .who has produced FL -b Ltc as identification
name of peGon acknowledging (applicant)
and did not take an oath.
type of identitication or known
Itll lll,
L
TURE OF NOTARY)
tlc,.,
oFr,r,llll
M,y Cqnlri. ErPlt.
Arqrrl t9. 2042
XSEEdcors
Page 6 of 15FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4/12l1 8
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 34 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
-a-C,fiF.,Corauty Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34'1 04
Phone - 239-252-2431
Fax 239-252-2469
GrDwth Managemer( Departrnent
APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
WORKIvIEN'5 COMPENSATION AFFIDAVIT
It is understood and acknowledged by the Collier County Contractors' Licensing Board and myself that if I fail to
acquire, or maintain at all times etfective Workmen's Compensation lnsurance it will result in the possible revocation
of my Certificate of Competency.
Applicant (please print
(lonICv.c ,o/,a(
Name of pany
S]ol Applicant
BEFORE Nil E this day personally appeared who affirms and
Applicant (please print)
says that he has less than one employee and does not require Workmen's Compensation understands thal at any
time he employees one or more persons he must obtain said Workmen's Compensation lnsurance.
State of
ll; " ho.l ll,tJi,
/h; "\u"
rt _ eLlLwho has produced t t'
type ot identificatlon or known
The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this O/- ts - /7
date
by
name ol person acknowledging (applicant)
and did not take an oath.
rtllll,,,
RE OF NOTARY)
as identif lcation
L
TA D
FlRl\,4 APPLICATION Rev 4112/18 Page 7 of 15
fl o., ,l
County of
I
OF
lllt
Conrn-
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 35 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
PRoMe rnrc "i..
EXAMINATION RESULTS NOTIFICATION
Augusl22,2012
Michael D Haldie 005-99-6489
15438 Puffin Dr
Bonita Springs, FL 34135
Dear Candidale:
We are pleased to inform you that you achieved a passlng score on your recent Collier County examination.
Your score(s) are as follows:
OA[U2012 Bonlta Sprlngs, FL
Eusiness and Law 78 Pass
Collier County requires a passlng percentago of 75%.
Pledse note that passage of the exam is no guarantee a certiflcate of qualification will be issued by the Licensing
8oard.
To help you gain the recognition you deserve, Prometric has prepared a Certificate of Achievement, beautilully
designed and very suilable for framing (8-1/2 x 1 1) for only $30.00 per category.
Please fill out the order form below, cut along ths dotted line, then send the completed form to Prometric .
Payment options: check, money order, Visa or Mastercard. Crsdit card orders may be faxed to (800)813-6670. Alt
others send to Prometric , 1260 Energy Lane, St. Paul, N4N 55108. Allow 2-3 we8ks for delivory.
Certificate of Achievement Request
Miohael D Haldie
15438 Puffin Dr
Bonita Springs, FL 34135
005-99-6489
Ouantily
Coliier County - Business and Law - 0811812012
x $30.00 =
For credit card payment, complete the following.Card Type: Visa N4astercard
Card No.Exp. Date
Signature
Fl59 - n-bohsp .C
PROMETRIC , 1260 Energy Lane , St. paut, MN 55108
TollFroo: 800.280.3926 ' Fa& 80O.Bl g.667O . www.promerrjc.com
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 36 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
Prepared By:
Henit Credit
(239) 277 -3202
(8OO) 37L-3348
TRANSUNION CREDIT REPORT
lFoRl [su8 NA,ilE](r) z NP6284423
IMKT SUB]
16 NP
IINFItE]
L7/95
IDATEI [rrtlE]LL/25/r8 LgitTCf
12/O6
IRPTD]
4/18
lsuBJEcrl [ssN ]tlu)rE, IICHAEL D.
IALSO KNO,'IN AS]
HALDIE, MIKE, D
ICURRENT ADDRESS]
3823 VALENTIA WY., NAPLES FL. 34119
IFORMER ADDRESS ]0 SHAHID R0., NORTH CHARLESToN SC. 29418
23640 WALDEN CENTER DR., #206. BONITA SPRINGS FL. 34134
[cuRRENTEMeLOvERAt{DADDRESS]
[oot"'o*]lrraq
AGEA EATERS INC SUPERVISOR
4/raa
IFORHER EMPLOYER AND ADDRESS]
ALGAE EATERS OttNER
IBIRTH DATE]-1225 6/77
6/L7A 4/L8
M0DEL PR0FILE **+ALERT***
***FfCO SCORE 4 SCORE +771 : g3g, Otz, gL4, OO3*** IN ADDITION TO THE***FACTORS LISTED ABOVE, THE NUMBER oF INQUIRIES oN THE coNsUI,lER.s CREDIT***FILE HAS ADVERSELY AFFECTED THE CREDIT SCORE.
CREDIT SUMMARY If,*)I TOTAL FILE HISTORY
PR=O COL=0 I{EG=O HSTNEG=O TRD=24 RvL=16 INST=7 MTG=O OpN=1 INQ=9
HIGH CRED CRED tIM BALANCE PAST DUE MNTHLY PAY AVAILABLEREVoLVING: $15.3K $28.1K $527 $A $3S gBX
INSTALLIiIENT: $12sK $ $110K $O g2}s2oPEN: $3281 $ $2185 go $ 33XrorAls: $L4/K $28.1K $112K $O 92087
TRADES
SUBNANTE SUBCODE OPENED HIGHCRED TERI{S MAXDELQ PAYPAT 1-12 MOPACCOUIIT# VERFIED CREDLIH PASTDUE AI4T.I,IOP PAYPAT 13.24
ECOA CO L LATR L/ LOANTYPE CLSD/PD BALANCE REMARKS MO 30/6g/90
SEARS/CBNA D 6256M3 rLlL3 gO 111111L11111 RO15O4994t467rO Lr/78A 92506 gO 111111111111r CHARGE ACCOUT'IT 9/t5C $0 ACCT CLSD By CONSUI"IER 48 O/ Ol O
DrscovERBANK B 9616A03 s/76 $87L2 MrN35 111111111111 ROl6911,49948473 11l18A 917.5K $g 111111111111I CREDIT CARO $527 DISP INV CIi,IP- BY GRNTR 3A O/ g/ O
Ar.rEx B 2LWBOO\ rO/75 $32813499922776097213 11/184I CREDIT CARD $2185
BBY/CBNA H 292FOr4 at14 $4000643s35023893 t/rBA g4eP,gI CHARGE ACCOUNT 2/r8 $O
$o
$o
$o
111111111111 001
1 1 11 1111 11 1136 s/o/o
111111111111 R01
1111111111114A slo/o
111111111111 RO1
1 11 11 1111 11 1
48 0/olo
SYNCB/JCP D Z35O58O 72/L26008491,49521 L!/L8AI CHARGE ACCOUNT 1!/I5
$4oo
$soo
$o
IDATE RPID]
ro/n
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 37 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
f{FDs F A39NO77 rglL7
5776s53629M LO/78A
I AUTOMOBI LE
sut'lTRUsT BK B 423AO22 5/t7
2LsOOOO2t57523636 rglaAAI AUTOT.IOBI LE
CoMPASS BK B 9a4900r 2/786756409083 aOltAAI UNSECURED
FIDELIry BK B 416600A 4/7A84as226120 tgltaAI AUTOI,,IOBI LE
ALLY FINCL F 2592371 5/L5
673922499987 4/7AA
I AUTO LEASE 4/!8C
GRDT FIRST A 3A35gO3 4/L3
61963 9/17A
r CHARGE ACCoUNT 7 /L4C
SYNCB HOME B 567ROO6 8/L6
601977024/-37 9/L7A
I CHARGE ACCOUNT 5/A7C
SYNCB/CCTUFY F 9992L9F !21T3
650A59083721, 9/a7A
r CHARGE ACCoUNT 5/t7C
SYNCB/SA|,,!S D 2359465 7 /13604599223444 5/17A
I CHARGE ACCOUNT L2/L5C
BRCLYSBANKDE B TZZBOOL 3/I79oo2837497a 4lDAI FLEX SPND CRT CRD 3/17C
SYNCB/ICP O 23s6580 LL/9960O889283746 4/L7AI CHARGE ACCOUNT 3/r2C
CAPITAL ONE B IDTYOa3 LA|I2468836980901 3/L7AI CREDIT CARD 3IL7C
SYNCB/BSMITH F 9992OAB A/I4603O09027q02 ro/76aI CHARGE ACCOUNT 8/L4C
ALLY Frr'rCL F 259237N 4/736LL9796992AO 6/L5AI AUTO LEASE 6Ir5C
$20.9K
$17 .7K
$o
g72n32g
$o
072t4
$o
CLOSED
$o
CLOSED
039A429
$o
CLOSED
11111111111 I01
11 s/Ols
$36.4K OA4!4499
$a
$30.3K
$1s. oK o364480
$s
$t2.oK
9s2. eK 085M753
$o
$49.9K
$16. 6K o39M
$o
CLOSED
$192
$r4os
$o
111111111111 IO1
1111
16 0/O/O
11111111 r01
8 s/o/o
111111 r01
6 0/ols
111111111111 I01
11111111 1111
34 0/O/O
111111111111 I01
1 11 11 11 11 111
28 0/OlO
111111111111 R01
11111111111148 o/s/0
111111111111 I01
1 1111.111 111124 slolo
$a47
$ss00
$s
$s77
$1200
$o
$s
$724
$o
$5e8
$7so
$o
R01
$o
ACCT CLSD BY CONSUMER 48 Ol O/ O
111111111111 R01$oL
ACCT CLSO BY CONSUMER 13 gl O/ O
111111111111 RO1
$0 111111111111
ACCT CLSD BY CONSUMER 45 O/ gl A
$2t.7K
$o
$5s71
$15.0K
$o
$1291
$L300
$o
$s
CLOSED
$o
$7s .oK
$o
111111111111 R01
1 11 111111111
46 0/OlO
1 R01
$o
ACCT CLSD BY CONSUMER T Ol O/ O
111111111111 R01
$o 111111111111
ACCT CLSD BY COitSUt4ER 40 Ol O/ O
$o
$3soo
$o
111111111111 R01$o 111111111111
ACCT CLSD 8Y CONSUMER 48 6/ O/ s
111111111111 R01
$o 111111111111
ACCT CLSD 8Y CONSUMER 26 Ol gl O
CHASE CARD B 26QK0O1 5/15
$L6.7K
$o
$s R01
ALLY FINCL F 259237L L/Ls
L9922537934 6/L7A
I AUTOMOBILE 6/I7C
CHASE CARo B 26QKOO7 72/1,34644rA20a659 4/L7AI FLEX SPND CRT CRD 3/I7C
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 38 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
426684142926
I CREDIT CARD
6/asA
s/7sc
$o
ACCT CLSD BY CONSUMER O
TDRC/ASHLEY C 7427940 12/13
6OO6TOLOO2OO 1Ut4
I CHARGE ACCOUNT 1L/t4
I"iFFNB RETAIL B 2IGJ6A5 6/14577/E22t7g:.4 lL/a4A
I CHARGE ACCOUNT 7 /L4C
$2OOO
$o
$2277
$s700
$o
$o
$1900
$o
1111 R01
$o
ACCT CLSD BY CONSUMER 4 Ol O/ O
INQUIRIES
DATE SUBCODE
LL/26/18 2NP6284423 ( F LA)
4/02/18 FPCL246538 (NrL )
LO/a9/77 BCr178O81s(DAY)
6 / 70 / L7 F PC1246538(NrL )
5 / 23 / L7 F CEO6O9018(CHr )
3/LLlL7 BWL339O3 54 ( Wr L )r/L9/7t ZArO63L3s4( F LA)
r/ 02/ r7 QPHa0€6079 ( EAs )
12/24/76 FPC1246s38 ( NTL )
ryPE AT.IOUNT
CREDIT REPORT SERVICED BY:TRANSUNIoN 800-888-4213
2 BALDT^iIN PLACE, p.O. BoX 1000 CHESTER, pA 19016
CONSUMER DISCLOSURES CAN BE OBTAINED ONLINE THROUGH TRANSUNION AT:
HTTP : //I^'I"iUJ. TRANSUNIOI{. COI,4
(8oo)
( 800)
(888)
(800)
(8o0)
(8oo)
(866)
(888 )
(8oo)
(8oo)
aoa-6950
955-7070
232-07AO
237-5089
874-27L7
964-L9L7
227 -52a3
925-2559
925-2559
945-2099
(216) 362-5OsO
(404) 639-6sss
(877 ) s96-s4a7
(866) 3e6-82s4
(8OO) 289-8OO4
(8so) 347 -2683
11111111111 R01
$o
ACCT CLSD BY CONSUMER 11 gl O/ O
SUBNAI,.IE
MERIT CREDIT
COAF
FIFTH THIRD
COAF
DISCOVE R
BRCLYSBANKDE
cB5
UNIVERSAL CR
COAF
CREDITOR CONTACT INFORMATION
TDRC/ASHLEY CZL42794O
1000 IIACARTHUR BV MHIIAH Nl. 07430
CAPITAL ONE BC1DTVAAS
PO BOX 30281 SALT LAKE CITY UT. 84130
BRCLYSEANKDE AZLZZBOOT
P.O. BOX 8803 I.iILI4INGTON DE. 19899
I.iFFNB RETAIL BC21GJ6O5
CSCL DISPUTE TEAI4 DES TIOINES IA. 50306
AI{EX BC21WBOOT
P.0. BOX 981537 EL PASO TX. 79998
SYNCB/SAI.IS OV2350465
PO BOX 96s0A5 oRLANDO FL. 32896
SYNCB/JCP DC2350580
PO BoX 965007 oRLANDO FL. 32896
ALLY FINCL FA259237L
P.O. BoX 380901 BL@iIINGTON MN. 55438
ALLY FINCL FA259237N
P,O. BoX 380901 BLoo|!INGTON MN. 55438
CHASE CARD BC26QK001
P.O. BOX 15298 WILMINGTON DE. 19850B8Y/CBNA HE292FOI4
P0 BOX 6497 SIOUX FALLS SO, 577L7
CRDT FIRST AZ3A35Oa3
POB 81315 CLEVELAND OH. 44181
FIDELITY BK 8741660aA
POB LO5O75 ATLAT{TA GA. 30348
SUNTRUST BK BY423AO22
P0 Box 8ss26 RICHMOND VA. 23ZAs
SYNCB HOHE BC561ROo6
c/0 Po Box 965036 oRLANDO FL. 328965EARS/CBNA DC62s6443
P0 BOX 6217 SIOUX FALLS SD. 57117WFDS FS839NO77
P.O. BOX 1697 WINTERVILLE NC. 28590DISCoVEREANX BC96:i6OO3
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 39 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
POB 15316
COI4PASS BK
PO BOX 11830
SYNCB/BSMITH
c/o Po Box 955035
sYNCB/CCTUFY
c/o Po Box 965036
DISCOVER
25AO LAKE COOK RD,
cBs
3503 NORTH OIXIE H
MERIT CREDIT
12734 KENT{@O LANE
UNIVERSAL CR
370 REED ROAD SUIT
BRCLYSBAI'IKDE
PO BOX 8803
FIFTH THIRD
38 FOUNTAIN SQUARE
COAF
3905 N DALLAS PARK
I.JILMINGTON DE. 19850
829849007
BIRMINGHA},i AL. 35202
F29992088
ORLANDO FL. 32895
FF999219F
ORLANDO FL. 32896
F O6090aA
RIVERWOODS IL. 60015
z 963L354
OAKLAND PARK FL. 33334
z 62a4/.23
FORT MYERS FL. 139O7
Q OS06079
BROOHALL PA. 19008
B 3396354
I.JILMINGTON DE. 19899
B 1780815
CINCII{NATI OH. 45263
F 7246538
PLANo TX. 75091
(2os) e33-30o0
(866) 396-82s4
(a66) 657 -0)76
(es4)
(23e)
(61e)
(866)
(s13)
(800)
56L-t400
277 - 3242
284-7000
370-5931,
579-5353
946-9332
END OF TRANSUNION REPORT
t',!ERIT CREDIT HAS RETRIEVED THE ABOVE PERSoNAL cREDIT REPORT FoR
LICENSING PURPOSEs AS REQUESTED BY THE BUSINESs
OI,JNER/PROPRIETOR. PUBLIC RECORDS FOR THIS REPORT HAVE BEEN
CHECKED AND VERIFIED AT THE COUNTY, STATE AND FEDERAL LEVELS.
PUELTC RECORDS HAVE ALSO BEEN VERIFIED FOR PINELLAS COUNTY.
PUBLIC RECOROS LEARNED O
SOURCES OF INFOR 4ATIoN: TRANS UNION LLC
IRS LIEI'I SECTION
COUNTY COURTHOUSE RECORDS
IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS REGARDING THIS REPORT, PLEASE
CoNTACT MERIT CREDIT AT: L-AaO-377-3348 0R (239) 277-3202.
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 40 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
Premier Profile . ALGAE EATERS POOL & PRESSURE CLEANING
Subcode:970135 Ordered: 11/26/20'18 10:32:16 CST
Transaction Numbort C5O2747 4Aa
Soarch lnquiry: Algae Eaters Pool Pressuro Cleanirv3823 VALENTIA WAY/Naples/FU34119/US/Phone N/A
/931170236
Model Description: lntelliscore Plus V2
Current lntelliscore Plus Score: 23
r@@E,
t&perion.
ror Q
ro. C
ror Q
ror Q
ALGAE EATERS POOL & PRESSURE CLEANING
LLC
3823 VALENTIA WAY
NAPLES. FL 34119-7512
Doing Buslness
As:
Primary Address
Tar lD: 27-0644318
Score range: I - 100 percantile
lntelliscore Plus Financial Stability Risk
MEDIUM TO
HIGH RISK
MEDIUM TO
HIGH RISK
Credit Limit Recommendation: $1,100
Company DBT
DAT
Unavarlable
Original Filings High Risk Alerts
YeaB on File:
State of lncorporation:
Date of lncorporation:
Business Type:
Contacts:
8 (FrLE ESTABLTSHED 04/2010)
FL
07 t1812012
profit
I\,IICHAEL D HALDIE . IVANAGER
SIC Code: SPECIAL IRADE CONTRACTORS, NEC - 1799
BUSINESS SERVICES. NEC. 7389
NAICS Code: Other Spscialty Trade Contractors - 238900
All Other Professional, Scientific, and lechnical Services - 541990
Commercial and lnstitutional Building Construction - 236220
Number of Employeos: 5Sales: $1,318,000HALDIE MEGAN - MANAGER
Business Facts
Active Business lndicator:Experian shows this business as active
Possible OFAC Match:No OFAC match found
Business Viclim Stalement:No victim statement on file
tr
trl
BUSINESS ADORESS IDENTIFIED AS
RESIDENTIAL
Premier Profile - ALGAE EATERS POOL & PRESSURE CLEANING
Risk Class: 4
114
Crodit Rlsk Score: lntelllscors plus
Busrness Name
ALGAE EATERS POOL & PRESSURE CLEANING
LLC
{,:.,
Business ldentification Number
931170236
Risk Dashboard
Rlak Scoros 8nd Credit Limit Rscommsndltlon Day5 B.yond Tems Dfogatory Lsg.l Fraud Alerts
723 0 1
Commercial Fraud Shield
EVaIUAtion foT: ALGAE EATERS POOL & PRESSURE CLEANING,3823 VALENTIA WAY, NAPLES, FL34119.7512
Busine39 Alerts Voaification Triggers
a
Credit Risk Score and Credit Limit Recommendation
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 41 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
Premier Profile - ALGAE EATERS POOL E PRESSURE CLEANTNG
214
This score predicls the likelihood ot serious credil delinquencies for this business
within the next 12 months. Payment history and public record along with other
variablcs are used to predict future risk. Higher scores indic€te lower risk.
Factoas lowering the score
} RISK ASSOCIATED WITH THE COMPANY'S INDUSTRY
} COMPANY'S BUSINESS TYPE
' NUMBER OF EMPLOYEES
The risk class groups scores by risk anto ranges of similar
performance. Range 5 is the highest risk, range 1 is the
lowest risk-
lndustry Risk Comparison
22% of businesses indacate a higher likelihood of severe
delinquency.
Quarterly Score Trends
0
n ol+lo €s-F9s F$l'\lt" tsu6.oc1
100
80
The lntelliscore Plus Ouarterly Score Trends provide a
view of the likelihood of delinquency ov€r the past 12
months for this business. The trends will indicate if the
score improved, remained stable, fluctuated or declined
over the last 12 months
60
40
:0
@!E@E
This score predicts the likelihood offinancial stability risk within the next 12 months.
The score uses tradelin6 and collections information, public filings as well as other
variables lo predict future risk. Higher scores indicate lower risk.
Factors lo{rering the score
I LACK OF ACTIVE TRADES
} RISK ASSOCIATED WITH THE BUSINESS ryPE
I EN4PLOYEE SIZE OF BUSINESS
, RISK ASSOCIATED WiTH THE CoMPANY,S INDUSTRY SECToR
Current Financial Stability Risk Score: 7 Risk Class: 4
The risk class groups scores by risk into ranges of simitar
performance. Range 5 is the highest risk. range 1 is the
lowest risk.
lndustry Risk Comparison
6% of buslnesses indicate a higher likelihood of financiat
stability risk.
0 10 25 50 75 100
Hiqh
R irk 1E-&Low
Ris k
lntelliscore Plus Ouartgdy Score Trends
Flnanclal Stablllty Rlsk Quartorty Score Trend.
CrEdit Rlsk Score: Flnancial Stablllty Risk
-&I
I
1
6503
Hish
Ris k
Low
R isk
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 42 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
Quarterly Score Trends
r 00
The Financial Stabilaty Risk Ouarterly Score Trends
p.ovide a view of the likelihood of flnancial stability risk
over the past 12 months for this business. The trends will
indicale ifthe score improved, remained stable,
fluctuated or declined over the last 12 months.
to, c
ror c
8o
b0
40
20
0
o,o'I+s\ ?gs'F9s .rD.{'\$ }u6'd
THE FOLLOWING INFORMATION WAS PROVIDED BY TH
State of Origin: FL
Date of lncorporationi 07/1812012
Current Status: Active
gusiness Typo: Profit
Charto.Numbor: L120000929
AgENt: HALDIE MEGAN
Credil Limit Recommendation
s1.100
This rocommendation comparss this business against similar businesses in the Experian business
credit database. lt is based on trade information. induslry, age of business and the lntelliscore
Plus. The recommendation is a guide. The final decision must b€ made based on your company's
business policios.
Current DBT: Not Available
Predicted OBT: N/A
Monthly Average DBT: 0
Higho8t DBT Previous 6 ilonths: 0
Highest DBT Prevlous 5 Quariers: 0
Payment T16nd lndication:
Payment trend indicator not available
Bankruptcy:
Tax Lien tilings:
Judgment lilings:
Sum of legal filings:
UCC filings:
Cautionary UCC lilings:
$0
$o
$0
$0
No
0
0
$0
0
No
lndustry OBT Range Compari3on
The cunent DBT of this business is Not Available
DBT for this business: Not Available
DBT Range 0-5 6-15 16+
Payment and Legal Filings Summary
Additional Eusiness Facts
Premier Profile - ALGAE EATERS POOL A pRESSURE CLEANTNG
E STATE OF FLORIDA. THE DATA IS CURRENT AS OF 11126120,18
31 4
Credlt Llmit R6commendatlon
Payment Performanc6 Legal FilingsTrade and Collsction Balance
Total trado and collection (0):
All trades (0):
All colloctions (0):
Continuous trade (0):
6 month average:
Highest credit amount extended:
Most trequent industry purchasing terms:
lnduslry purchasing terms not available
qt of bujinesies 80o,/o 11,,
lnduetry Comparlson
Corporate Reglstratlon
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 43 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
Agent Address: 3823 VALENTIA WAY NAPLES, FL
ro. c
Expetian prides itself on the depth and accuracy ol lhe data mainlalned on our databases. Repofting your cuslomerbpaymenl behavior lo Experian will furlher slrenglhen and enhance the power of the information available for making sound
credit decisions. Give credit where credit is due- Call l-8OO52O-f221, option tl4 for more information.
End of report 1 of I report
The inlomation he/ein b fumished ih contidence lor youl exclusive
lnfomlalion So/ulions, /oc., nol lheir ,ouees ol dislnibuloE wanant
use lol legilimale busiaess puqoses and shall not be Ep/oduced. Neither Expeian
such infotmallon no/ shall lhey be liable lor youl use or Ellance upon jt.
@ Experian 2018. All righls reserved. Privacv policy-
Experian and the Experian ma*s herein are servics marks or registered trademarks of Expenan.
Premier Profile - ALGAE EATERS POOL & PRESSURE CLEANING
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 44 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
{}
W Merit Credit rxc
Fast, Accurate & Secure.
MERIT CREDIT EAS RETRIEVED TEE ABOVE BUSINESS REPORT EER LICENSING PI'RPOSES AS
REQT'ESTED BT TEE BI'SINESS OTAIER/ PROPRIETOR. PT'BLIC RECORDS !!R IEIS REPORT IIAVE
BEEX CIIECXED AND VERIFIED AI IIIE COSDIIY ( INCLUDI}IG PINELIAS), STATE AND EEDERA',
IEVELS.
PUBLIC RECORDS I.E,ARNED: O
SOITRCES OF INIORItIAIION: EXPZRIAII BOSINESS INEORT,TAIION SER\,IICES
IRS LIEN SECIIO}I
COT'NTY COI'RTIIOUSE RECORDS
IF YOU IIAVE elIY QUESTIONS REGARDINC TErS REpORr, prEtASE CONIACT MERrr CREDIT Ar: 1-800-371-3348 0A 239-217 -3202.
COMPANY NAME: ATGAE EATERS POOL & PRESSURE CLEANTNG LLC
FEDERAL lD: 27-O 43L8
CURRENT STATUS: ACTIVE
PRINCIPAL(S): MEGAN HALDIE TTTLE: MGRM
MIKE HALDIE TITLE: MGRM
DATE INcORPORATED: o7 h8/2O12
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 45 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
C,Rff.,Qor,tttty Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34'104
239-252-2400Grc^,vtn Management Depart'rEfi t
APPLICATION FOR COTLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
COLTECTION OF SOCIAT SECURITY NUMBERS
Date: APRIL 12, 2018
To: Applicants for Certificate of Competency
From: Everildo Ybaceta, Contractor Licensing Supervisor
Pursuant to Chapter l-'19, Florida Statutes and Collier County Contractor Licensing Ordinance 2006-46
Section 2.1.1., all applicants are required to submit their social security number(SSN) for the following
purposes:
a) Assess applicant's ability to satisfy creditors by reviewing their credit history.
b) Verification of applicant's test scores and information.
Our office will only use your SSN noted above for those reasons pursuant to Chapter l-19, Florida
Statutes, and as may otherwise be authorized by law.
We are fully committed to safe-guarding and protecting your SSN and once collected, will be mainlained
as confidential and exempt under Chapter l-19, Florida Statutes.
FlRt\,4 APPLICATION Rev 4/12y'18 Page 15 ot 15
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 46 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
I t23t2019 Detail by FEI/EIN Number
ISION OF UORPORATIONS
r--1ir-\
urvlJK.tt aj
Cai*c-t;:tv't'JrL,t
t!1, alfuit ttu, 0f Flrrul, *at
Qepadned_elslelg / Division ol Coroorations ,/ Seardr Records / Detail Bv Document Numb€r j
Detailby FEUEIN Number
Changed: 091242013
Mailing Address
3823 Valentia Way
Naples, FL 34119
Changed: 0912U2013
Registered Agent Name & Address
HALDIE, MEGAN
3823 Valenlia Way
Naples, FL 34119
Address Changed: 0912212013
Authorized Person(r) D€tail
Name & Address
Title MGR[.4
HALDIE, MEGAN
3823 Valentia Way
Naples, FL 34119
Title MGRl,,4
HALDIE, MIKE
3823 Valentia Way
NaDles. FL 34119
"#"
httpJ/search.sunbiz.org/lnquiry/CorporationSearch/S€archResultDetail?inquirytype=FeiNumber&directionType=lnitial&searchNameorder=2706/4318... 1t2
Florida Limited Liability Company
ALGAE EATERS POOL & PRESSURE CLEANING LLC
Filing lnformation
Documont Number L12000092970
FEUEIN Number 274644318
Date Filed 07118120'12
State FL
Status ACTIVE
Principal-lk&tess
3823 Valentia Way
Naples, FL 34119
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 47 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
1t23t2019 Detail by FEUEIN Number
Annual Rep_gih
Reporl Year
2017
2018
2019
Filed Date
o1108t2017
01114t2018
o1t05t2019
Document lmagel
OI/05/2019 - ANNUAL REPORT
O1/1412018 - ANNUAL REPORT
o1lo8/2017 i ANNUAL REPORT
O1/10/20,I6 - ANNUAL REPORT
O1/24120'5 - ANNUAI REPORT
OZlOl2014 _ ANNUAL REPORT
09/222013 - ANNUAL REPORT
07/18,2012 - Floride Limited Uability
Vjew lmag6 in PDF lormat
Vi6w imag€ in PDF format i
Viav image in PDF format
View image in POF format
Vre image in POF format
Vi6x imago in PDF format
View image in PDF fomat
Vie* image in POF fonnat
r!;o. Df CoD3.at.".
http://search.sunbiz.org/lnquiry/CorporationSearch/SoarchResultDetaal?inquirytype=FeiNumber&dirsctionTypg=lnitjal&searchNam€Ordet=270€/.4318...212
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 48 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
Electronic Articles of OreanizationFor
Florida Limited Liability Company
Article I
'l'he name of the Limited l,iability Cornpany is:
AI,GAE EATERS POOL & PRE,SSURE CLEANING LLC
L12000092970
FILED 8:00 AM
Julv 18.2012Sei. Of'State
kasaly
Article II
The street address of the principal offrce of the Limited Liabililv Company is:
15438 PUFFIN DR.
BONITA SPRINGS. FL. US 34135
The mailing address of the Limited Liability Company is
15438 PUFFIN DR.
BONITA SPRINGS, FL. US 34135
Article III
The purpose for which this Limited Liability Company is organized is:
ANY AND ALL LAWFUL BUSINI,SS,
Article IV
The name and Florida street address of the registered agent is:
MEGAN HALDIE
15438 PUFF'IN DR.
BONITA SPRINGS, FL. 34135
Having been named as registered agent and to accept service olprocess for the above stated limited
liability company at lhe place designated in this certificate. I herebv accept the appointmenl as registered
agent 6nd agiee io act inthis capac"ity. I further agree to comply riirh thd provisi6ns of all statutel
relahng lo the^ proper and complete pcrlbrmancc of my duties. and I am fahiliar with and acccpt thc
obllgatlons ot my posrhon as reglslered agent.
Registered Agent Signature: MEGAN HALDIE
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 49 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
Article V
The name and address of managing members/managers are:
Title: MGRM
MEGAN HALDIE
15438 PUFFIN DR.
BONITA SPRINGS, FL. 34135 US
Title: MGRM
MIKE HALDIE
15438 PIJ'FFIN DR.
BONITA SPRINGS, FL. 34135 US
Signature of member or an authorized reprcsentative of a membcr
Electronic Signature: SHEILA DANG, LEGALZOOM.COM, INC.
L12000092970
FILED 8:OO AMJulv 18.2012Sei. Of'State
kasaly
I am the member or authorized represenlative submitting these Articles of Organization and affirm that the
lacts stated herein are true. I am aware that false information submitted in a docurnent to the Department
ol Stale constitules a third degree felony as provided for in s.8l 7.I 55. F.S. I understand the requirement lo
file an annual reporl betwcen lanuary Ist and Mal lsl in the calendar year follo*ing formation o[the LLC
and everv vear drereafler 1o maintain "active" status.
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 50 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
2019 FLORIOA LIMITEO LIABIL COMPANY ANNUAL REPORT
oocuMENT# L1 2000092970
Entity Name: ALGAE EATERS POOL & PRESSURE CLEANING LLC
Current Principal Place of Business:
3823 VALENTIA WAY
NAPLES, FL 34119
Current Mailing Address:
3823 VALENTIA WAY
NAPLES, FL 34119 US
FEI Number:27-0644318
Name and Address of Current Registered Agent:
FILED
Jan 05, 2019
Secretary of State
8819242607CC
HALDIE, I\,4EGAN
3823 VALENTIA WAY
NAPLES. FL 34119 US
The above named entity submits this stalement for the pueose of changing ils re4islercd oltice or registercd egent, or both, in the Slale of Floida.
SIGNATURE:
Electronic Signature of Registered Agent
Authorized Person(s) Detail :
Title MGRI\.4
Name HALDIE, MEGAN
Address 3823 VALENTIA WAY
City-State-Zip: NAPLES FL 34119
SIGNATURE: l\,4lKE HALDIE
I he@by cetuly that the dmtan i.dicdted on this repod ot suppletuntal @pod is tM encl aMte and thet my elet@ic signatu@ sha have lha sane legat efrad Es n a.do oodet
oath: lhal I atu e Nnaging tenber ar nanage. ol lhe liniled tiEbility @npany or lhe @@itq or ttste@ edpMrd to execota this rpod es rquted by Chaplet 605, Fbnda Stalutes: and
thot hy oatua appeaB abow, ot on an allach enl filh au other tke enpose.ed.
Title
Name
Address
City-State-Zip:
MGRM
HALDIE, MIKE
3823 VALENTIA WAY
NAPLES FL 34119
Date
01105t2019
Electronic Signature of Signing Authorized Person(s) Detail
OWN ER
Date
Certificate of Status Desired: Yes
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 51 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
-Rff.' -r Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
239-252-2400
L*aW
Grc^,vu-r Management Departrnent
APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
RESOLUTION OF AUTHORIZATION
Complete this form if multiple people own part of the company the license will be atla
lf there is only 1 owner, then this form is not required for the application.
ln accordance with Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as amended,orE"/r, Pro 1c
ched to
C La^,1 //z
poses
?.4 "7 /t<
frrsr..t
to engage in contracting a" Ao-n'rt in Collier county where
Otf icerYOwners/Partners
r*:c)o.1 ko/,ltu.
Applicant Name
proposes to qualify for a Certilicate of Competency with company a
Company
It is hereby agreed upon that we the undersigned 0o.ntr{ol qe €q
Off icers/Owners/Partners Company
resolve and represent to the Collier County Contractor's Licensing Board that the proposed qualifying agent,
ft,clat/ k/rl", is active in all matters connected with the company named
4
(/eo-^g, /1 c
Ah
Applicant Name
at Fa/,.r 2.1 "/rcr,.. da^,- //C
ComPanY 7
empowered to act on behalf of
We further resolve and represent that
a [oh4 lc Cle^ ot
in'all
Appl can t Name
matters connected with its contracting
is legally
business and has the autho U
Company
ise conslruction undertaken by fr la c € ot+c 2orl g/or rs--.(/,2",^7 / /<
T W<--=-
rs/Part ers
a
rs/Owne ners
Otficervowners/Partners Witness
Oflicers/Owners/Partners of the above mentioned company need to sign on the left and a witness to the signature signs on the right
"r^r"
o1 €/o ,. L <
County of
The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this
(- zt- zo/1
date
by /yl..c }r.t ( Hl.ld<- + trrcn^ 0<l at&who has produced DL € e
type ot iOE.,titication oiGo,rr--
Coll'' r
asr
FIR
(SIGNATURE OF NOTARY)
Page 8 of 15
Company Name
/l,rl"r/ /"il"
ltc
name ol person acknowledging
OF
NOTARY'S
February
No. GG
Cornm.My Erpires
05,2021
69702
, rl
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 52 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
I
\ata!la!ltat
a
o4oq
F0
Noa.
a-oE.+
CD
I
a
ot
o
cr)
F0e+o
o$)
\1
r-.'o
l-<
B
.-.-+
z
3
o
oo€o
ts
o
I
,-]
v)o
rDFtc+
)+
(Da
N
@
o
o
a-ot
H)
a
FD4o
U)
t
e+
o
U)
f-t
(Da
ot
(D
o
tD
a
oo
A
aa
op-
d(z
(D
F0o.o
(D
tD,-t
CDa.oo,3
o4
FD
oH
a
o'l<_l+ F',l)J IIrD -t ^
€ENo4l
ai il.+ ;loil5Jl
3t
etII
3t
I
I
oF+)
(./)
o()
ao
oa-
='o
(,/\
o
oo
.j-+,
(D
o
,3
0)
A)
o
A'
oo-
o
(D
0,
F
No
c).
B
o
FD
-l
U)
(D
a.o
ooa
r'.oo\
o+)
a-+
;Jo
.-|
-l.tD
(/,
pDtoa
y5',a)Iilsot\ o-
Ngl. oa
(D
o-
o
o-
ra
3g
I
I
t
1
t
I
aq
t
aI
a
\
II
t
1lI
-t
I!l
,
I
,I
l\D
I
D
L
,
@
(o'
o,
o
\o
:to
o
!o
oi.of
II,-\
I!l LD
I
,
,
t
I
I,
ID,
-I
C..r\
o
t
,tIatt\
L
,1
Jt
a!l
I
{
L
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 53 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
-z-C,fiF.,Contraclor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
239-252-2400
C,ottttt1l
Growth Manag€rnent Departrnefi t
APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
This certilies that I,/ll, rho"l am a member or managing
APPLICANI-S NAME {please print)
member of llaco Fal<rl tol I ilnc,.,0\i""'rl- Ucffirr-rw coruFnwfueruey
I own KtL % of the units issued by the Limited Liability Company listed above
Affidavit of Applicanl: I certily under penalty o, perjury that the inlormation contained is a true and correct
slatement to the best of my knowledge.
/l'l;rhoe I
llqld,*-
Ahae i"L'i &/ d O"ttt. (/*-,,-
N;;;;r compa/
-rhtub
lol,lon
NI
state of
County of (nil,,r
The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this o/- x,s - /?
Signature of Applicant
by
,.,
who has produced t L' DLIL
type of identification or known
TURE OF NOTARY)
flrn.la
ll,"Io"l lJ^l);.
name ol person acknowledging (applicant)
as identification and did not take an oath.
tl rttllllr,
L
My Cotttm' E efl.
Aigd 10,2fi22
I{o. GG
OF,,l,t,
FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4/12118 Page9of15
STATEMENT OF OWNERSHIP
Applicanl (please print)
dale
25mr3
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 54 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
February 7,2019
Matt Eberhard
17828 Oakmont Ridge Circle
Ft. Myers, FL 33967
To Whom lt May Concern,
I am preparing this letter on behalf of Mike Haldie. Mike has been
providing power wash services at our home for the last 4 years. We
have used him for our roof, as well as our entire property. We have
found Mike to be competitively priced, professional, honest and above
expectation in the job he does. Mike is the most thorough
professional that I have come across-we will never use anyone to
power wash our roof but him!
Sincerely,
Matt Eberhard
4
;lrlt
SIIEFIL A. SITflL
MY C!i,$,llssoi{ I FF $4755
EXPIFES: A4ust 19, Aig
Bond.d nw tlotty Putlc lhddt r'3
a/x-0/7
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 55 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
February 7,2019
Julie Hart
20671Groveline Ct.
Estero, FL 33928
To Whom lt May Concern,
lm sending this letter on behalf of Mike Haldie with Algae Eaters.
Mike has been power washing our home (including the roof) for
the last 10+ years. Mike came highly recommended from our
family, who also has used his services for years. Mike has
always proven to do a superior job. We continue to contact him
every year because of his work ethic and the professionaljob
that he does.
S rely,
u lie
NicDte Shaz?
'nlt 14 W-
z\t\r4
}IEOTE SMRP
Comtorloo , Gc 2,l1500
E{rrlsMl 25, 2022
8od.d ntll Tot F*r frru. t0l67[tl
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 56 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
February 8,2019
To Whom It May Concern:
I am sending this letter on behalf of Mike Haldie with Algae Eaters Pool
& Pressure Cleaning. Mike has been power washing our roof and
maintaining our pool for the last 9 - l0 years.
We have continued to use Mike over the years due to his work ethic, the
outstanding he does on our home and because we have always felt that
he is honest and fair.
Thank you for your time.
Linda Swanson
18871 Cypress View Drive
Fort Myers, FL 33967
(23e) 994-1229
Notary State of Florida, County of Lee
Swom to and subscribed before me this 8th day of February, 2019
By Linda Swanson, who is Personally Known to me.
Notary Signatur$1 "- l-s4a-r-rr.==, My Commission Exp ires: oa (\J
frNlc T. GaPPoP
Notary Stamp:
#ffimffi"
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 57 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
To Whom lt may Concern;
I understand Mike Haldie is being considered for a license to
power wash the roof of homes in Naples. Mike and his company
Algae Eaters has been providing the power washing of my property
and maintenance of my swimming pool here in Bonita for the last 9 or
'10 years. He is very professional and courteous 100% of the time,
Every time. The first time I used Mike, I was instantly impressed. He
showed up on time with impressive Equiptment and He quickly
showed me how much money I have been wasting over the years
with inferior service. Our roof was covered in mold for our recent
cleaning. (lt had been since before the last hurricane that I had the
roof cleaned). He used a biocide treatment and my roof looks brand
new again!
Mike definitely knows what he's doing.
Thank You
7t/ar* lt/u'"ooAn
Marie Weinacker
24066 Rocky Rd
Bonita Springs FL 34135
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF t ee-
inBtrumgi wa5
Bwhris to
PuUic
'-r,--
AI.JAXEI E^RBEREM
rY cofrMrsstoN t 6015511'l
EXPIRES: February 26, 2022
Bod.d Thtu
etl* T!,p./tllfl? N..m of Nol,y
al by
producld
brtort fiil
i&aunc.dm.
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 58 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
FEB 7,2019
I am writing to attest to the character and job performance of Mr. Mike
Haldie. He has been maintaining my properties for several years. He
provides the power washing of my roof and home as well as providing
pool service for our new home in Bonita Springs.
Mike always makes our roof look brand new. He also maintains my son's
propefty and does a wonderful job there. I have never had an issue with
the service or treatment provided by Mr Haldie. He is always professional
and couneous and always knows exactly what to do. As a homeowner, it
is very refreshing to have someone I trust.
Thank You
Tom Harl
27098 Harbor Dr
Bonita Springs FL 34135
S tate ot FL, County of Lee
The f instrument
me this day ol
U/hom is
ID
Notary Signa tu re
before
#fr-
JUAN SERRANO
Notary Public, Slate ol Florida
commission# GG 129956
My comm erprrgs JulY 31,2021
Dear Collier Contractor Licensing Board
G,^
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 59 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
'19) Untitled Album
I
Untitled Album
GAN'ES YOUR FRIENOS PIAI MCE
GGG
SedF
Q5 o,s"" e","," eoo,",.,
It r-esri"roa-s
}.i Algae Eaters Pooland Pres!
Cleaning, LLC
Page Liked. Oclqber 1Z ?018.
Add a description ln Bonita Springs,
T.s Photo g r.s P.oducr3
^Taq p'odrJcls frorn yo1rr lhop m lhrs photo
t:
Help
Create Ad Creare Page Developors Caree.s Privacy Cookies d Choices Te.ms Account Security togin Help
English(US) Espanor F.anqais (r.ance) +l(i6ft) r.>.Jr Po.tuguk (8.asil) tratiano ttol Dsursch G+ EIE
httpsr/www.facebook.com/MIKEALGAE/photos/ms.c-eJxFzsENBOElQgGO...R-;o--.bps.a.2482067141Ai8424124A2O,134181AOO4l?type=3&theeter page 1ot l
I
6e r6n<-
1125119,7:23 AM
l
b-
A '^A./a----r-.
---/:1 a&/Y/'.--
2884 3
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 60 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
{1S) Untitled Album
-
Untitled Album
GAMES YOUR FRICNDS PIAY *OP:
ft o,n"" t"t"," ooo,"n... u
It resrie eoams
f /1,.
11251'19,7:23 AM
Algae Eaters Pooland Pres!
Cleaning, LLC
Page Liked. October 1Z 2018.
Tas Phoro e Tag Producls
^
Creale Ad Cr€ale Page Oevelopers Careors Privacy Cookies Ad Choices Terms Accouot secu.ity Login Hetp
English(Us) Espanol Francais (France) +l{m,t) o".}.lr pdrugues (8Bsil) ualiano tlEol Deutsch fta EAE
GGG
&eH*t
- il*.
Add a description ln Bonita Springs,
x*
A.Write a comment...
"'as
Lg pnoducts trom you. shoo in this photo s
-
28S45
t
httpsr/www.facebook.com/MIKEALGAE/photos/ms.c-eJxFzsENBDElQ96O...R-;o--.bps.a.24A2067141818424124A207131A4A46791?type=3&theater page 1of 1
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 61 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
!19) Untitled Album
5n--Q"<
1125119,1:22
^M
6
GGG
aaJqIAMES YOUF TRIENDS PTAY MORE
Algae Eaters Pool and Pressure
Cleaning, LLC
Page Liked . Ocrob€r 1Z 201a .
Add a description ln Shell lsland, Florida
Tag Photo lE Tag Products Edit
Share F
l:Write a comment
-https://www.facebook.com/MIKEALGAE/pholos/ms.c.eJxFzsENgDEIQgGo...R-;o--.bps.a.2482067141a1842412482083435150128/?type= 3&theater page 1 of .l
':3'
r
0r
ry.\
L-rE
7 r-I
I a
I I
l\
f
I (
J q
\
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 62 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
{19) Untitled album 1125119,7:22 AM
4 (r-+'I
GGG
aad&GAMES YOUi FRIENOS PLAY UORE
Algae Eaters Pool and Pressure
Cleaning, LLC
Page tikecl. October'lZ 2018 .
Add a description ln Shell lsland, Florida
tF
Tag Photo |ft Tag Products
^.
6
Edit
share 0.
https://www.tacebook.com/MIKEALGAE/pholos/ms.c.eJxFzsENBDEtegGO...R-;o--.bps.a.24B2O6j$1A1A424124820832S1816813/?type:3&theater page t of 1
E I
-/rr
ft Write a comment...
,ir't
)
\3
U-'<-
i:[ "'
r.l7
\
I
\{.-
\
-\
\-
\
a I
\
I
\
\a
\IT
lr t -
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 63 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
119) Uniitled Album 1125119,7:23 AM
GCG
aaG
}.5 Algae Eaters Pool and Pressure
Cleaning, LLC
Page Liked. October 1Z 2018 .
Tag Photo & Tag Products Edit
Share i.
ft
-
6
Fn/0..
OAMES YOUR FRIENOS PLAY MOP'
a
-E
Add a description ln Lely, Florida.L
I
r
fl
\tffi I \.
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 64 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
(19) Untitled Album
,4 l/..GGG
A4AJB,
GAMES YOUF FRIENDS PLAY MOPE
Algae Eaters Pool and Pressure
Cleaning, LLC
Page tiked . October 1Z 2018
Share k
Write a comment
https://www-facebook.com/MIKEALGAE/pholos/ms.c.eJxFzsENBDElQeG...R-;o--.bps.a.248?0671|41A"€424124A2083488483456/?type=3&theater page 1of 1
-.1
112511e,7:23 AM
R
Add a description ln Lely, Florida.
T.g Photo t&, Tag Products
-4.
Edit
t;
05
6"-, I
,-t
FF
I
",--,'
-\*'x
-1
\L
F .,1
n
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 65 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
119) Untitled Alb!m
.<_6AMtS YOt'R FNIENOS PLAY Oi
GGG
&*$,+
fu ^r0"".","," "oo,"o.. "
coirlacrs
It .uJu o0","
11251't9,7t24 AM
Algae Eaters Pooland Pres:
Cleaning, LLC
Page Liked. oclobe.lz 201a.
r.9 Pholo a T.g Product3
_^.
httpsr/www.facebook.com/MIKEALGAE/photos/ms.c.eJxFzsENBOEtOgGO...R-;o--.bps.a.24A2061141A1tr4241248207637S1S0834/?type:3&theater page 1 of 1
}..
vJ
!1
,h
Add a description ln Bonila Springs,
,S.H
,*.f&H
Trq producls tn n vo
br-- /
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 66 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
i'19) untitled Atbum
|6 o,s." r","," ooo,"n
[t reste roams
GAMTS YOUR fRIENOS PLAY MOR
T.g Phoro g T.g Prcdu.ts
GGG
A.
1125119,7.24 AM
https://www.facebook.com/MIKEALGAE/photos/ms.c.eJxFzsENBOEtOgGO...R-;o--.bps.a.24820671|4i81B424l2482O764O515OB3U?type=3&theater page 1 of l
I [+*-
Add a description ln Bonila Springs,
&*{F
tu Algae Ealers Pool and Pres!
Cleaning, LLC
Page Liked. ocrobd 1z 2018.
Write a comment,.,
-z L
td
-t
4
T.g products trom yo0r shop
I
-4
'/-/
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 67 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
(19) Untitled Album 1125119,7,21 AM
ta areae Eate's Pooran... 6
a":"^.","
CAMTS YOUN fRIENDS PLAY MORT
GGG
tu Algae Eaters Pool and Pres!
CIearting, LLC
Page Liked Oclober 17, 2018 .
Add a description ln Bonila Springs
Iag Pholo 3 T.s Products
}-
https://www.fecebook.com/MIKEAL6AE/photos/ms.c.eJxFzsEN8DElo9Go...R-;o--.bps.a.24a2o671418184241248207,141848466g1?type=3&theater page 1 of 1
U
GqF,$r
F4
*t,;.,1' ,E0 |,rodiJcts fro.n yo(lf shop r.r lfis Fholo S
'1.1
r"
En
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 68 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
119) untitled aib!m
I
GGG
&*,,s
GAMES YOUR FRIENOS PLAY MOP'
t-oNracTs
fu ereae raters eooran... o
tr Algae Eaters Pooland Pressure
Cleaning, LLC
Page Liked . october tz 2018 .
Add a description
rag Phoro * Tag Products
-4.
Like Comment Share G
Write a comment
Tag products f
Hel
Eng
1125119, /:2't AM
https://www.tacebook.com/MIKEALGAE/photos/ms.c.eJxFzsENBDElQgGO...R-;o--.bps.a.24A2067141A1A424l24A2O712i51S1g46l?type= 3&thearer page 1 of 1
I-d7
ftr
7,
I
T
7 l
,7
I
I ..AFTER
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 69 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
C,R3.,Cov*rX3l
Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 341 04
239-252-2400Gru /lh Managerner Deparfnent
APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
AFFIDAVIT OF INTEGRITY AND GOOD CHARACTER
STATE OF
COUNTY OF
(
Gr ttl
o.. ), having been first duly sworn, state and affirm:
I am a resident of
more than five (5) years
During the last five (5) years I have known \\
to observe his or her business and personal dealings and find him
good character.
Iorir].a-(State) and have resided here lor
(applicant). I have had the opportunity
r her to be a person of honesty, integrily and
Signature
Cr\\r County,\.(v
Address:
Street
State
Printed Name
Zj
tq
Clty
Telephone .Q-la -S
The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me thls l-Zl'2or1
date
Sor.{-1 O,,'J L who has produced
type ol identification
NOTARY'S
qr,-Aq{
as identification
FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4/12l18
(SIGNATURE OF NOTARY)
I,
OF
by
name of person acknowledging
and did not take an oalh.It (
My Cornm.Expiros
05,m21
69702
ll I
Page 13 of 15
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 70 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
C,Rff.,Corati-3l
Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
239-252-2400Groxth Managernerit Departrnent
APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
AFFIDAVIT OF INTEGRITY AND GOOD CHARACTER
STATE OF
f,
COUNTY OF bllt.,
t, f4 / CHf'l& Hfl@//, havins been rirst dury sworn, srare and afrirm
Co ll;",County,FLI am a resident of
more than tive (5) years
During the last five (5) years I have known 14tc4ftEl HfiD/E
to observe his or her business and personal dealings and find him or her to
good character
Address:
(State) and have resided here for
(applican AV th o rtunily
ne tegrity and
r'-l-,
Signature
6an)
Printed Name
l),E,}R
Street
/YrfPlfS Fz_ 34/t7
City State zip
Telephone
The loregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this o/- 2s - /q by
date
l1 ;alro"l \\"oT\who has produced FL- bL\L
name ol person ackn owledging type ol identiflcation or known
and did not take an oath.
/tl
II
L
IIIt ,,
tOF
ItIII t,
I
as identif ication
o,l
,,I
FIRN,1 APPLICATION ReV 4/,1 2/18
RE OF NOTARY)
Page 14 of 1 5
Catltl.xfrie,
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 71 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
o.Qo'CERTIFICATE OF LIABILITY INSURANCE
oaTE ( &DO/YrrY)
&220r E
THIS CERTIFICATE IS ISSUED AS A iIATTER OF INFORiIATIOTI ONLY AIID CONFERS r{O RIGHTS UPO'{ THE CERTIFICATE HOLDER. THIS
CERTIFICATE OOES NOT AFFIRMATIVELY OR NEGATIVELY AMET{O, EXTEND OR ALTER THE COVERAGE AFFOROED BY THE POLICIES
BELOW. THIS CERTTFICATE OF lt{SURANCE DOES NOT CO STITUTE A CONTRACI BETWEET{ THE TSSUTNG INSURER(S), AUTHORTZEO
REPRESENTATIVE OR PRODUCER, AND THE CERTIFICATE HOLDER
IIiIPORTANT: lf the cenncate holder ls an ADDITIONAL INSURED, the pollcy(les) must have ADDIIONAL INSURED provisions or bo endorrsd.
lf SUBROGATION lS wAlVED, gubiect lg lhe te.m! and conditions of the policy, certain policie! may .equire an endorgement. A etatement on
thls cerlltlcale does not conler ri ghts to tho certificate holder ln lleu of such ondorsemont(s).
Ln go FL 31778
NAjVE. t Dfl5tln( (01Lrm0us
EI 727--:9+1890
ADORESS:tim(@paJronsiosurancc.com
lNsuRERls) aFFoRDIXG COVERAGE
||{SURERA: Crum & Forester {1510
IN SU RED
ALCAI EATDRS R)OL & PRI,SSLIRE ( fEANINC. LL(
182: Valentia Way
N.rpler FL l-+ I 19
INSURER C
ftSUREN D
COVERAGES CERTIFICATE NUMBER:REVISION NUMBER:
THIS IS TO CERTIFY TI]AT THE POLIC]ES OF INSURANCE LISTEO BELOW HAVE BEEN ISSUED TO THE INSURED NAMED ABOVE FOR THE POLICY PERIOD
INDICATED. NOTWTHSTAND NG ANY REOUIREMENT, TERM OR CONDITION OF ANY CONTRACT OR OTHER D@UMENT WTH RESPECT TO WHICH TNIS
CfR TITICAfE MAY BE ISSUED OR MAY PERTAIN, THE INSURANCE AFFORDED 8Y THE POLICIES DESCRIBED I.JEREIN IS SUBJECT TO ALL THE IERMS
SXCLUSIONS AND CONDITIONS OF SUCH POLICIES. LIMITS SHOWN MAY HAVE BEEN REDUCED BY PAID CLAIMS.
TYPE OF INSURANCE INSO uutrs
x COITMERCIAL GENERAL LjAEtJTY
CL-AIM9(4ADE CCCUR
GEI'J' AOGREGAIE LIMITAPPLIES PER
x
r8l105974 0&02,2018 08.02 :019
tAc! (,cariRRENca s
PREI SES (Ea o.tlrlrehe)r t01).(xx)
MEO D(P (/.rly on6 poM)$5,000
$500,m0
GFNERAL AGGREGATE $t.r)l)r).fix)
FIIC)IJUT] IS, COMP/OP AGG r.000.000
$
AUTOf!OALE UAAUTY
Ol/VNED
AUIOS ONLY
HRED
AUTOS ONLY
SCHEDULED
AUTOS
NOI+O/!NED
AUTOS QNLY
$
BOUTYINJURY (Per peGm)
BODTY INJURY (Per r.cide.t)
TXUT'EXIY UAMAGE
UfBRELLA UAB
EXCESS r.lAB
OCCUR
CLAIIJ}MADF
EACH OCCURRENCE $
AGGREGAiE $
REIENI]ON $$
uroRr(ERs coxPEirsaroN
AI{D E PLOYERS' UABIUIY
ANY PROPRIETOR/PARINERIEXECUllvE
OFFICER/MEMEER E(CLUOED?
DFscRtpnoN oF opFRATtoNs rd"-
SIATIJTE ER
E I. FACH ACCIDENT s
EL, OISEASE. EA EMPLOYEE $
E,L, DISEASE. POLICY LIMII $
DESCEmOll OF OPERAnOIS, LOCATIONS/VEHrcLES (ACORD lol. A.lditond R.mrtt Sch.dul.. t be.thEh..l f lmD 3p!@ Ir r.qui.td)
CATE H DER N
O'198&2015 ACORD CORPORAT|ON. A|l rtghts reserved.
The ACORD hame and logo are reglstered ma*s of ACORO
SHOULD ANY OF THE AAOVE OESCRIBED POUCIES BE CAT{CELLEO BEFORE
THE EXPIR TIOiI DATE THEREOF,
'{OTICE
wlLL BE DELIVERED IN
ACCORDAiICE $,lTH THE POUCY PROVISIONS.
2800 North Horscshoc llrivc
Napl.s.IL 34104
AUTHOEZED REPRESENTATIVE
ACORO 25 (2016103)
PRODUCER
CLroslll Elite Insrrnnce Group. Inc.
I I321 Scminolc Blv.
I SURER E l
INSURER F r
500.000
PERSONAL & ADV INJIJRY
$"o,"" f]!El fl.o"
OTHER:
E
DEO
Collicr County Contractor Liccnring Board
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 72 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
.202-0 ii,
.dr.d rc fr lo!.Lrrd r<d.a bv r.*
DR]VE
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 73 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
Cct ev Cc>t, ,x,j't
Grorvth iVlanagemcnt l)epartnrrnt
Planning & Rcgulation
Ope rations l)ivision
l- iccnsing Section
February 4,2019
MICHAEL HALDIE
3823 VALENTIA WAY
NAPLES FL 34119
RE: REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE
Mr. HALDIE,
You have been added to the agenda for the Contractor Licensing Board meeting on
Wednesday, FEBRUARY 20,2019. Please attend the meeting so the board may review
your application packet for the Roof Coat, Paint, & Clean license.
The meeting is held at 9:00am at the W. Harmon Turner Building (Bldg. F, Admin.
Bldg.), 3299 Tamiami Trail. E., Naples, FL 34112 in the Commissioner's Meeting Room
on the 3rd floor. There is a security checkpoint you will need to go through, so please
allow enough time to make it to the meeting.
lf you have any questions or concerns, please call (239) 252-2431 or you may email me
at contractorslicensing@colliercou ntyfl. gov.
Sincerely,
Lilla Davis
Administrative Supervisor
Contractor Licensing
Collier County Growth Management Department
2800 North Horseshoe Drive
Naples, FL 34104
Growth Managemenl Deparlment'Contraclor Lrcensing '2800 North Ho6eshoe Drive'Naples Floida 34114'239-252-2400.w\r ,v.colieeov net
8.B.1
Packet Pg. 74 Attachment: MICHAEL HALDIE - ALGAE EATERS POOL - REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE (8017 : MICHAEL HALDIE – ALGAE EATERS POOL &
02/20/2019
COLLIER COUNTY
Contractor Licensing Board
Item Number: 8.C
Item Summary: DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING LLC – REINSTATEMENT WITH
WAIVER OF EXAM & NAME CHANGE
Meeting Date: 02/20/2019
Prepared by:
Title: – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Lilla Davis
02/12/2019 8:43 AM
Submitted by:
Title: Supervisor - Operations – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Everildo Ybaceta
02/12/2019 8:43 AM
Approved By:
Review:
Contractor Licensing Board Lilla Davis Review Item Completed 02/12/2019 8:43 AM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Review Item Completed 02/12/2019 2:30 PM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Meeting Pending 02/20/2019 9:00 AM
8.C
Packet Pg. 75
et Covtnty
COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD
FEBRUARY 20,2019
9:00 A.M.
DARLEEN ROWE - REINSTATEMENT APPLICATION WITH
WAIVER OF EXAMS & NAME CHANGE
DARLEEN ROWE is coming before the board today asking for a Reinstatement of her
Floor Covering license. She is also changing the name of her company from DAZZLING
FLOORS, INC to ROWE FLOORING, LLC. She is asking that the exams she took in
2012 with Collier County Sponsorship can be used in the application.
Ms. Rowe first received her license on a probationary period with us in 2012. She had
issues with personal and business credit reports, so she went before the board on
August 15, 2012. ll was decided that she would be on probation for twelve months and
should return to the board at six and twelve months from the date of that meeting.
On February 20,2013 she returned to the board for her six-month credit check. lt was
determined that there are some improvements, but the probationary term was still in
effect and she needed to return again with the updated credit.
On February 19,2014 another meeting was held. Ms. Rowe did not contact staff and
her phone was disconnected. Since she was unreachable and could not provide the
information requested, the board decided to put her license in a Suspend status. The
minutes and Finding of Facts for each case is included in the back of this packet.
Floor coverings installation contractot requires 24 months experience installing the
specific product and a passing grade on an approved business and law test and means
any person who is qualified to install carpet; sheet vinyl and/or all types of wood
flooring. This category does not include, tile, marble, ot teftazzo. Ordinance 2006-46
(1.6.3.20)
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 76 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
Gontents
Letter to go in Front of the Board
Application
Business Test Score
lndividual Credit Report
Company Credit Repg4
Sunbiz Documents
IRS EIN Documents
Resolution of Authorization
Statement of Ownership
Verification of Experience
Affidavit of lntegrity & Good Character
Certificate of lnsurance
Worker's Comp Exemptions
Driver's License
Board Hearing lnformation
Aug ust 15, 2012 [\Iinutes and Finding of Facts
February 20,2013 lr/inutes and Finding of Facts
February 19,2014 Minutes and Finding of Facts
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 77 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
To Whom it May Concern,
I would like the opportunity to go before the Board to request a waiver of retesting of the required
exam.
I previously score d 86% on this exam.
DARLEEN ROWE DATE
State of Florida
County of Collier
Th
By
cknowledged before me this day -L ./
who has prod
ldentification
NATURE OF RY
1
efo oing instru
.$#.'',
1irffiss
G8€TA L, B, F, DOS SANTOS
State ol Ftorrda-Notsry pubtic
Commissaon * GG 225970
My Commis
June 0
sion Expiras
9. 2022
n
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 78 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
To Whom it May Concern,
I previously qualified another company; Dazzling Floors, lnc. Dazzling Floors, lnc. is now closed
lam now seeking to qualify Rowe Floorin g, LLC
2(/
DARLEEN ROWE
NOTARY:
STATE of Florida
COUNTY of Collier
Acknowle ed remet da
prod uced
DATE
Si gnature
ntification
who
GRETA t, B. F. DOS SANiOS
Stcle of Florida-Notary Public
Commilrion i GG 225970
My Commission Expires
June 09,2022
by
lr
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 79 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
C,RF.,C-an*rx3t Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34'104
Phone - 239-252-2431
Fax - 239-252-2469
Gtor tth Manag€rrEnt DeparfrEnt
APPLICATION FOR COTIIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
FIRTVI APPLICATION FOR COttIER COUNTY
CERTIFICATE OF COMPEIENCY
This application must be typewritten or legibly printed. The application fee must be paid upon approval and is NOT
refundable. All checks should be made payable lo:. Collier County Boad ot County Commissroners. For further
information, consult Collier County Ordinance No. 2006-46, as amended.
TYPE OF CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY:
OldCo t /,(Cdore-33s1C.qnc,<\\t^ .. j l 3ol Zo r s
n General
tr Building
E Residential
[] Mechanical
tr Roofing
$230.00
$230.00
$230.00
$230.00
$230.00
D Electrician
n Plumber
tr Air Conditioner
fl Swimming Pool
dspecialty
$230.00
$230.00
$230.00
$230.00
$205.00
Specialty rod", Fl
I. APPLICANT PERSONAL INFORMATION:
Darl,ernName:?or.
Fi.st Middl.lnitial Last
Address 3ztoz b}b S Sro tb
Street City State ztp
Telephone 'SS # (Last 4 digits only)303L
Date of Birth I l- ts- /9b0 Driver's License # (Last 4 digits only):qt
Zu' J'l't'LlaSZ - Dartorrt
tt\laiua to Orapter l-19, Ilorida Statutaa aod Collc. Cosity ConF.ctor Ucr.rslnt OrdiDnca 2(xlH6 Sccdon 2.1.l., allapdkanta al! llqultld to
subhft lHi rocLl s€orrlty numhar (SSl{l lb. th€ Iollowlng Fl.po..* .) Arr€...t9lk .rdr.UIty to stbf,.rldlto6 by rcrlGxl,r3 rMr dldlt hbto.y.
b, vartfedon of apglkant's tcn acores aild lntonnadon, our ofllca wlll only ult your SSI notld .bova fo. tfiolo at-oir pulluam b Orapta, F19,
Florld. statut i, and .a tnry oth.rvls. b. .uthork d by hu, W. er. fulty commhad fo t.i,|urrdlnf and prod.E you. SS .nd orrc colLct d, wll
b. rnalntai d a3 coifrdarthl and dartpt und.r Or.ptcr l-19, Flo.id. St trrt 5.
Email CAJE
23q-rtr,- q.t?3'Xo{'\
Lrcense # 2012-3359
REINSTATEMENT FEE: $205 00
3 BACKYEARS FEES: $555 00
NEW LICENSE FEE: 205.00
FIRM APPLICATTON Rev 4112118 Page 3 of '15
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 80 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
eftfr,eon Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horceshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
Phone - 239-25?-2431
Fax - 239-252-2469
nW
Groatlh Managernent Deparfnent
APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
Provide the names and tslephone numbers of lwo persons who will always know your whersabouts.
Name , ar', /Y)arL.ltr't
Telephone 5b -v0
II. FICTITIOUS NAME OF APPLICANT'S BUS]NESS:
Name
Telephone 231-717- /03b
{ irt LCBusiness Name
Business Address:
(tf
Street
KT &)3t1
City ztp
Telephone z1 11b - q183
?z -3to 1Federal lD Tax No.
III. FINANCIAL RESPONSIBILITY
YES NO ALL APPLICANTS MUST ANSWER THE QUESTIONS BELOW:
Undertaken construction contracts or work lhat a third party, such as a bonding or surety
company, completed or made financial statemonts on?
J Had claims or lawsuits filed for unpaid or past due accounts by ),our creditors as a result of
construction gxpcrience?
I Undertaken construction contracts or work that resulted in liens, suits, or.ludgments being
filed?
I Had a lien filed against you by the lntemal Revenue Service or Florida Corporate Tax
Division?
Made an assignment of assets in settlement of construction obligations for less than the
debts outstanding?
Been charged with or convicted of acting as a contractor without a license, or if licensed
as a conlractor in this or any other state, been "subiect to" disciplinary action by a state,
county, or municipality?
Filed for or been discharged in bankruptcy within the past 5 years?
J Been convicled or found guilty of, or entered a plea of nolo contendere to, regardless of
adjudication, a crime in anyjurisdiction within the past 10 years?'
NOTE. lf you have answer YES to any of the questions below, you must attach a written explanation including the
nature of the charges, dates, and outcomes, sentences of conditions imposed. You must also attach proof of
payrnent, satisfaction of li6n orjudgement, bankruptcy discharge, or agreements for payment.
'lf you have had a felony conviction, proof that your civil rights have been restored will be required prior to
licensure.
FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4112hB Page 4 of 15
State
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 81 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
leT C-or,*rql
Grorlh NaanagerrEnl Oepartrpnt
Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Or.
Naples, FL 34104
Phone - 239-252-243'l
Fax - 239-252-2469
APPLICATION FOR COLTIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
IV. EXPERIENCEVER]FICATION
EDUCATION:
List below and provide transcripts for any formal oducation you have obtained in the area of compotency for which
this application is being made: .
^/ar/[
List below non formal education (on the job training) you have obtained in the area of competency for which this
application is being made:Eric aoD n't\r
arah riPv-
CURRENT/PREVIOUS LICENSE:
List below and attach copies any oth6r certificates of competoncy/liconsas you hold/hav€ held in Collier County or
any other jurisdiction. lnclude the license #, Type, and county you hold it in.
t W C0/{,4J
AFFIDAVIT
Under the penalties of perjury, I declare that I have read the foregoing appl ication and the facts stat€d in it are
true.
Dqrler.,7u*"
County of Co LI . t r-{z
The foregoing instrument as acknowledgedorblstR,w
Applicant (please print)
State of r--iJo-
namo of po6on acknowledging (applicant)
as identmcation and did not take an oath
NOTARY'S SEAL
Signsture of Applicant
before me this /- tt-a/
date
who has produced
of
czot
'.]ffi
GRETA L, B. F. DOS SANTOS
Slato of Florid.-Nota.y Public
Commitlion I GG 225970
My Commit!ion Expirc!
Juna 09 2022
FIRIV APPLICATION Rev 4112118 Page 5 of 15
\(.( I
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 82 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING LLC
tev Qot*rtJ
Gro,lifr lvbnagertent Departnent
APPLICATION FOR COTLIER COUNIY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
CERTIFICAIION OF APPTICATION
The undersigned hereby mak6s application for Certificate of Competency under the provisions of Collier County
No. 2006-46, as amended, and under penalties of perjury. I declare that I have read the foregoing qualifier
information and that the facts stated in it are true.
The undersigned hereby cedmes that he is legally qualified to act on behatf of the business organization sought to
be licensed in all matters connected with its contracting business and that he has full authority to supervise
construction undertaken by himself or such business ororganization and that he will continue during this registration
to be able to so bind said business organization. The qualified license holder understands that in all contracting
matters, he/she will be held strictly accountable for any and all aclivities involving his license.
Any wiltful falsification of any information contained herein is grounds for disqualification.
Applicant (please p.int)'l Ou/e €loxt LLL
Cornpa
Signature of Applicant
Stale of:
County
A
of: L-a\lJrr
b."prfi,,n--
The forogoing instrument as acknowledged before mo this /- /?-&ot
by
nam6 oI porson acknowledging (applicant)
as identification and did not take an oath
NOTARY'S SEAL
who has produced
of idenlification or kno*n
'.,,ffi
GRETA L. B, F, DOS SANTOS
Stale o, Florad6-Notary Pubtic
Commission fl cG 226970
My Commission Expi.gs
Jun€ 09, 2022
FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4t'12t18 Page 6 of 15
Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
Phone - 239-252-?431
Fax - 239-252-2469
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 83 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
Cor*rxl
qowtrr ManagerrEnt OepartrrEnt
Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
Phone - 239-252-2431
Fax - 239-252-2469
APPLICATION FOR COTTIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
WORKMEN's COMPENSATION AFFIDAVIT
It is understood and acknowledged by the Collier County Contractors' Licensing Board and mysetf that if I fail to
acquire, or maintain at all times effective Workmen's Compensation lnsurance it will result in the possible revocation
of my Certificate of Competency
Da,r(t...
Applicant (please print)
L Odl r l,LC.
of Applicant
D"ben-To*-BEFORE ME this day personally appeared who atfirms and
Applicant (plesso print)
says that he has less than one employee and does not require Workmen's Compensation understands that at any
time he employees one or more persons he must obtain said Workmen's Compensation lnsurance.
County of
'Za
date
by who has produced
nam€ ol person acknowledging pplicant)
NOTARY'S SEAL
of
GRETA L, B, F. DOS SANTOSSlrr. ol Flo dr-Nolory public
Commi!!ron I GG 22SS7O
My Commistion Expira!
Juna 09 2022
FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4l't2118 Page 7 of 15
State of
The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this
as identification and did not take an oath.
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 84 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING LLC
GITS, LLC Examination Operations Division
Providing the services and producls to assist Government Agencies to make informed educated decisions.
Official Examination Score Report
April 18,2012
Official Score Report:
Candidate Information:
Name Darleen Rowe
Candidate #: 73669150R
Testing Site: Panama Ci tv, FL
Final Score Result:
Business Procedures Score: 860%
These results represent the grade that has been achieved on the Business Procedures
examination(s) administered by Gainesville Independent Testing Service for Collier County,
Florida on April 18,2012.
If you have any fi.rther questions, please do not hesitate to contact us.
Sincerely,
Jay E. Bowermeister
President
PO Box 831'127 Ocala , Ftond,a 3448!1121 - Voice (352) 369€tTS _ Fax (35213E7-2443
800 997 2.t29
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 85 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
F6b 08 19, 10:03a Corporats Fax 239-2884968
Prepared 8yl
M€rit credit
(23s\ 277 -3202
(8OO) 37L-),44
TRANSUNION CREDIT REPORT
[FOR] [SU8 Nrr'rE](r) z NP6284423
IrlKr suB]
16 NP
IINFILE]
12/a4
IDAIE] [rrHE ]a1-/1A/79 A9:4lCT
[su8]Ecrl [ssN]
RCi^rE, DARLEEN rrACKLr.r (IIlEg32
IALSO KiTCUN aS]
ROdE,DARLENE
I"ACKLIN, DARLEEN, MACKLIN
!.IACKLIN, DARLENE
ICURRENT ADDRESS]
8285 KEY ROYAL CI., #1211. NAPLES FL. 34119
IFoR|4ER ADDRESS]
1690 REIATSSANCE CO €NS BV,, #1412. BOYNTOi'I BEACH FL. 33426
3224 TURTLE CV, WEST PALrvt BEACH FL. 3341L
ICURRENT EHPLOYER AND ADDRESS] [VERF] [RPID]
LA! OFFICE OF GIACOIIO IXJVA
9/75V 8/L5
IFORI4ER EMPLOYER AND ADDRESS]
hELLS FARGO
9/7rA 9/L3
IBIRTH DATE ]
L7/ 66
IDATE RPTD]
12/ 15
p.2
8/18
SPECIAL ]IESSAGES
r,'-ADDRESS ALERT: CURRE T INPUT AODRESS DOES iDT IIATCH FILE AODRESS(ES)
I4ODEL PROFILE ***ALERT+*+
***FICo SCoRE 4 SCoRE +648 : MO, gro, 418, 013*** IN AoDITION T0 THE
'*'IFACTORS LISTED ABOr'E, THE NUITBER OF INQUIRIES ON THE CONSUJqER'S CREDIT***FILE I-IAS ADVERSELY AFFECTEO THE CREDIT sCORE.
CREDIT
PR=O COL=1
REVOLVING:
II'ISTALLMENT:
TOTALS :
5U11 I4ARY *iI' TOTAL FILE HISTORY
NEG=1 HSTNEG=1-1 rRD=8 RVL=5 INST=3 t4T6=0 OPN=A INQ=3
HIGH CRED CRED LITV1 BALANCE PASI DUE IYNTHLY PAY AVAILABLE
$66a7 $67so $s184 $o 9tz9 23/
926.7K $ 94so2 $a $456t33.4K $67sO $e686 $0 $s8s
COLLECTIONS
SUSNA,IE SUBCODE ECOA OPEIIED CLOsEO $PLACEDACCOUNT# VERIFIEO EALANCE
CREDTT COLL Y 1GZDOO5 r s/ts $2005708a2)7 a/r9A $ZOO
cB/vrcscRT c 16u500L ?/La $2r58s637s33033 7/r9A $2sOI CHARGE ACCOUNT 3/LA $S
CRDT FrRST A SalSOO3 LO/as $94L
65793 uAgA $7200I CHARGE ACCO.JI{T $63+
$0
$0
111111111111 R€1
1 11 11 1 1111 21
30 7/A/6
CREOITOR HOP
REMARKS
96 PROGRESSIVE O9B
ACCT INFO OSP BY CsH
T RAD E S
suBNAl.rE suBcooE oPENED HIGHCRED TER!15 |4AXDE LQ pAypAT 1-12 HOpACCOUNT* VERFIED CREOLIM PASTDUE AIi'IT-HOP PAYPAT 13'24
ECOA COLLATRL/LOANTYPE CLSD,/PD BALANCE RE]\IARKS AO )0/69/90
cAP ONE AUIO F LWZKOO1 LOIO6 $t2.2K O72t457A 111111111111 rO2
6ZO6ZL5AASS4€1OOL v,lazv $A 111111111111
I AUTO'IOBILE T1/A2C $O DISP INV CIIP-BY GRNTR 25 6/ O/ O
1111111111 R01
to oloto
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 86 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
Feb 08 19. 10:03a Corporate Fax
ALLY FINCL F 259237L 9/I3
29921O52867 L2|aAA
I AUTOI,TOSI LE
239-288-4968 p.3
$26.7K o72tM56
$o
111111111111 IA1
111111111111
48 A/O/O
CBITORRID C 1l'rZ81S5 3,/15
9A5637952597 L2|aAA
T CHARGE ACCOUNT 3/TA
S668
$7oo
$o
s@
111111111111 RO1
111111111111)2 AlO/s
CAPITAL ONE B 1DTVOO1 6,/15
,77805A72744 LI|IAA
I CREDIT CARD
$239A
$z3ao
$2274
N: 73
96
{^:i'i.t
r,lELLS FAR@ B 904N664 7lr2
446542059638 L?/aAA
I CREDIT CARD
$2667
$230@
t2276
NIN56
9o
111111111111 R01
11111111111148 O/Olg
039M
$o
CLOSED
TNQUIRIES
OATE SUBCODE SUBNAI1E
7/,8lL9 Z.NP62A4423 ( F LA) PlERrr CREDTT
2/e3/aa ePC2699a24(NT L) CAP Or,/ E
8/OL|L7 8PC2699424(NrL) CAP ONE
TYPE AMOUNT
CREDIT REPORT SERVlCED BY:
TRANSUNTON 8gO- 888- 4213
2 BALDI.III( PLACE, P.O. BOX LO@ CHESTER, PA 19S16
CONSUMER DISCLOSURES CAN BE OBTAINED ONLINE THRO,',GH TRANSUNION AT:
HTTP://UT .J. TRANSUNIOII. COM
CREOITOR CONTACT INFORMATIONcBlvrcscRT cz76us@r
PO SOX 1a2789 COLUT{BU5 0H. 43218
CAPITAL ONE BC1DTVOO1
PO 8OX 30281 SALT LAKE CITY UT. 84130
CB/TORRTD CZ1NZa155
P0 BOX 182789 COLUFIBUS OH. 43218
CAP ONE AUTO FA1II2KOO1
CREDIT BURIAU DISP PLANO TX. 75025
ALTY FINCL FA259237L
P.O- BoX 380901 BLm TNGTON MN. 55438
AUTOPRTFTSRV FAZDATOOL
PO BOX 4097 ENGLET{OOO CO. 80111
CRDT FIRST AZ3A35OO3
POB 81315 CLEVELAND OH. /+419L
I'lEtLS FARGO BC9O8I'1664
CREDIT BUREAU OISP OEs I'IOINES IA, 50306
CREDTT CoLL YCaGZD€OS
PO 80X 607 NORlrooD l4A, OZO6Z
M€RIT CREDIT. Z 628.423
12734 KEI*IOOO LAN E FORT I{YERs FL. 33907
cAP OflE S 2699424
PO 80X 30281 SALT LAKE CrTY UT. 84130
946-O)32
e25-2559
767-3177
362-5gOO
642-4729
570-4784
277-3242
955-7070
<aos) 9ss-7o7a
END OF TRANSUNION R€PORT
MERIT CREDIT HAS RETRIEVED THE ABOVE PERSONAL CREDIT REPORT FOR
LICENSI'']G PURPOSES AS REQUESTED BY THE BUSINESS
OII'IE R,/ PROPR IETOR . PUELIC RECORDS FOR THTS REPORT I.IAVE BEEN
CTIECXED AI,ID VERIFIED AT THE COUNTY, STATE AND FEDERAL IEVELS.
PUBLIC RECORDS HAVE ALSO AEE VERIFIED FOR PINELLAS COUNTY.
AUTOPRTFLSRV F 2DA7@1 7 T1.2t37299 t2/a3^
r AuTor'oBr LE L2/1.3C
$45O2
$12 ,0K
$o
111111111111 RA1
111111111111
41 0/O/@
r01
16 0/O/O
(8oa)
(888)
<877 )
(216)
(8ao)
(603 )
(23s)
(8s0)
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 87 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
Feb 08 19, 10:03a Corporate Fax
PUBLIC RECORDS LEARNED O
239-288-4968 p.4
SOURCES OF INFORfiATIOiI: TRANS UNIOI{ LLC
IRS LIEN SECTION
COUNTY COURTHOUSE RECOROS
IF YOU HAVE AI{Y QTJESTIOAjS REGAROING THIS REPORT, PLEASE
CoNTACT MERIT CREDIT AT; 1-aaa-31f-))48 OR (239) 277-3202.
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 88 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
Feb 08 19, 10:03a Corporats Fax 239-288-4968
Fast, Accu ra te & Secure
Phon€: 1-23+277-3202 or 1-80G371-1344
Fax Cover Sheet
p1
ffi ngetrrt Credf,t
To:439 a 5a s, 4 t"1
AfiN:
Re:P u" ro n.dq.-bo" 1u.., .R..,.-r-
or L
4 Pages lncluding Cover Sheet
Requested Credit Report Attached ! Please call if you have any questions-
CONFIDENTIALffY NOTICE: Thls communication with its corrtents may contain confidential
and/or legally privileged inlormation. lt is solely for the use ofthe intended recipient(s).
Unauthorized interception, review, use or disclosure is prohibited and may violate applicable
laws inctudingthe Electronic Communications Pri\racy Act. lf you are not the intended
recipient, please conta€t the sender and destroy all copies of the communication.
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 89 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
p.2
'i.',,,.,i.].
li..ml6. hnl. " OAZIIIX(} FLOORS, ll.lc
Stb.od.. $nll3! O.d.rod: 0?rO6/2Oi9 12:17 11 CST
Iinnracilor llurntGr. C$O:865065
S}&!h heuiry: {:}&:ilk$ Prc!r*, 1n.J7033 Arpo{ P'rlllog n&Naplns/rui}41 i9
nto{r(, Orlcnplron: lnldiist re Plt s V?
!&perion,
&r3ines€ Narne
DAZZUNG FLOORS, INC.tffi- Busheslrdemfi caiio t'lu'roer
Dolng Brr3lnocn Asi DAZZLING FIOORS, INC
P.im.r'f Addra$!: FO BOX 5835
oEST1N. !L 32540-s835
Trr tD: 41-2025049
*
Tl}ls b{rs,n65s,s lhe ultirnal€ paren(
5g!. &lorpqGts-itera&.ty Dyjllcktng ttgrs
Rbk 5co.6 and Credit Llmit Rlco.nmeMadc{oiys 8.yond T.rms Fr"aud Al.r:9
H gh Ris& ,!.?.;Cornpanr/ OBI
DBT
Sale6
r.D a
:cc Q
D.rogalory t g.l
O.iqinalFilirgs
x:ry
lnlsllis.gro Plus
.!7 MEDIUMZl RrsK
FilrarcrslStabiriy Rbk
6 i urorur,,r toI HIGH RISK 1
5.or. .ar€q I - 100 pe.csndle
Yet s c, Fil6i
Slate of lncorrorationl
Oat€ of lncofpo.itlonl
Bu3&!ess Type:
STC COd€: FLOOR @VEF, NG S;CP.ES . 5/13
FLOOR LAYING A OTHER FLOOR 'AOfr{. NEC - 17S2
LEGISi-A;rVE BOOTES - sr2r
tlAlCS Code: Floo. CoyelrE Slo@s - 4!22tI
Floori.{ C.drlr8.icrs - :r3s33a
Legislalive ecJ er - 92' 1 2,:
16 (F|LE ESTABLtShEo 07A0O3J
FL
0M 4i2002
p.ofii
sr - ${9-.
Credil Lrrit Rs.ornneo,alrcn: 51,100
Rlsk Dashboard
Euslness Fa0t5
'3'o
Commerclal Fraud Shield
E,/,eluatien i : DAZZUT{G FLOOiS, ltlc, PO EOX 5335, OESnN, F1325106835
Bual'|olr Alorts
Actlv€ Ellsltess Indletoi:
Possibl€ OFAC fa.rch:
Businesa Vrctirn S|.t nlerrtt
{
:t,
ir'ii
Varllication Trigg€rs
INACf IvE DOtvl-:STrC CCRFOa{IE FILI'tG
FOUNT)
Expenrn shows lhis busiiess as ac!..e
No OFAC malch foond
hb lnlkrl $tllement on litr
tlldi Rbk Sco.rr lotillsco'r Ptus
Currenl lntelliscoro Prus Scor€; 27
Cradil EisI $cori erd C.3dL Umit E conmsndalion
fcr';e.gratio - OrZL,t\,3 FLOS-S, l:,lc
Rbk Clas3: 3
r,A&SlM RttX
rir O
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 90 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE
:>3E-2AO-{t6A p3
eb qi ,S. i) t ;ap (..orP(,,dt6 F.rx
lli{h
0lni5
thi3 3(nrc pl!}Sclr llti lfiothood of !Gti!iu5 .rodit delliquerciee lor lhb bus'nlss
t {irio ire n;n l2 m<i.ll'ls. Psymenl Nsld'y and puSlic reaofd elono w}h ofi€r
\a.al.ba orn tl36d lo p.sdict{ulure risk. }lBhcr sc<)rei inclealo lollcr rck'
Flclors lorvoring the 3cart
' RISK.ASSCCIATEO WITI.I TIIE COIIPANY'S
'NDUSTRY} CCI.{PANyS 6USI\ESS TYPE
r tru}.IBER OT EI.IPIOYEES
lm.ltl8coro P!6t Ou.ttdl, 6cor. Tr€nds
Quartcrly Score Trends
1C0
Tti3 .l3t d85 groupB !t5rs !v nlk inlt.angst ol gmir3'
p€rlormsnce ti8n06 6 t6 lne hiohnlt nsl. r€r{e 1 G rhe
lo!?vtrrl d3*.
lndusky Rl6k Cotnpattson
26y. ofbudness€s inCicale s iigtEl lik€lhood oisevore
dellnquerEy.
Tba htel'rscore Plus Quarterly Sco.e lrends pre,ide s
vl€vr ot ttE lllelitlood ot delinql€n ay ovar iha pesl 12
fioltf s for lfiis b!5ln€39. The:tEnds t{I incical€ I ie
scofe iflproved, rsmained stabi6,lluatusled o' dedin€c
over lhe !61 12 mc{ls.
Risk Class: 4
Ld',
ekL
c 104
tBo
60,
.tc ,
0
t?g'ifA $r':+JL |$Goc\ lro'r'iN
cr.dE Rbt scoo: Flltatlcl.l S$l0tft Rlst
Current Flnaacial Stability f,isk score: 5
:-iigl
l.i!k
!te!:F--:r!1.ll]ililiilia,LEll*lil
Tne risk cless grsJps sco.Es by Esk hto l.elgqs of silnlar
peraomance. Renge 5 is Ule highesl .istq raruc 1 13 ttl€
lndust'y Rlsk Cornp.rison
a% 01butin€ss$ indicalo € hiltcr lrtelihood ol lln6tcrl
3tablr[r4 nsk
5
03 t0 30
This $..e Itedr':ls t\e likel lcod of fin3ncral elstll tv risl e' ilh h ll e u exl I 2 :nonlt s
Tie acors lses trade!,re ard collad'gns nfirr.aiicn, publc
';lings
as w'il as clhe'
vori!fules to orediC fulure d.sl. lllgier scoles lndicate l5v'er nsk'
Frctort lo*.aaing the scols
, l.ACr< OF ACTI?E 'l RAbES
' RISKASSOCTATEO iIfih THE BUSTNESS TYraE
' E$,LOY€F SIZE OF AUSINSSS
' RISK ASSOChTM W:TH IIIE COI!1PANYs INOUSTRY SEC.IOR
FlnaEI.l Sarbtl{(t Rbt qur.t rty &6. Trltdt
,,.rr,!r Profi. . 0AZa-N,3 rLO0RS. llJC
!r
i
j
I
l
i
i
I
)
I
I
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 91 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE –
ral, 06 19. t], :$p Corpo.6l6 Fax
(trerteriy scora Trends
lcr
'i0
o
th6 Fhrtd.l Stsaritty Rier (hE&riy ScE . Ttetui8
trovide a vl.w ot ba liketihood of firancle' s$bl rty rur(
o!8r the p..31 t2 ,nonth$ tcr thls bt,!ino6!' 1it lrBnd$ w{l
indbato l, th€ gc('a improt'ed. rolsninod tlebL,
tucl!,atBd or deddrec over ihe lasi 12 nrcnlis.
-.{*t;,&oi*ft &-i
rtg-\eA $F'{ \$L nuood por "}N
Crldt Lhlt it€comrErld.lhn
Cr?dil Limit Reaomm$dation
s 1.1r8
Tlns reaomfi€ndaiion cornpafeg lhis blsinegs aSainst srrnrla. bu5mesres 'n t-c Expenen bLs,Tess
s€drtdatabsse. lt is based'on trade informator iniJuslry' ag€ of busiress ?nd tns lntelli'ctte
Plus Th6 recomm€ndalion is a -auide. The fi.}al d€cisio1 rnucl b€ rnaoe b3ssd 01 yarr ciree ,]y s
busina$ pdloia6-
r*Q
PsFrsrt Pstlorl{tanla
cur.€nt ogl: Nol A.'.iab:
PrEdrctEd DBT: I\/A
Mo.'rthty Aver.ge OBT: )
Higt6st OBt Pt€vious 6 Moi*ts: 0
Hiqhe6t OgT Previoss 5 Clsart rs: 0
Pr).&ant l.end ladicdion:
Pa)me:rltend lndloatcr noi a€irstie
Tr.& rtd Collcadon B&ncs
Total tr.de and coll€ctlon (O):
All tradas (0)l
AII co{cclloos {0};
Continuoos tlado lo)i
6 moo l aveEga:
tlighort alsdil tmourlt erlend€d:
M(st treqoe'lt lhdirstry purchaalng terms
Irdustry Brrchasi,tg t3rns rol 6'.'aila5le
f0
SD
$l
N/i.
N,iA
f'ra I
tridisery Crriipt .ron .
tndultrY 0BT Rrngr CompariE!.l
Th! nutront CBT of l'i5 t!./!ress ts Nol Av.rrlable
OBT tor thls busi&6s: Not Avallable
$gT R6nge 0.5 &.15 16+
Paymotrt and L€gal Filings Summary
ro' O
Corlorrtr Radl.rrdldr
'?ie FoLr&A,tNo INFoRMATioN wA$ pRovlD€D By rHE srAT! or fLoRroA THEDATA's:!rRR[f.TASo.o2oeri19
St . oforigin: FL
Dt}! ot lncgrpor'llan: Clll.lC0C?
C.rrant Slrt6: hac,lln
Errdo.t3tyfr: Profl
Cirrtsrxrtnlrn P02!(&0{'l
Agent: oAifEfN R0sE
I',!lrle. ftcdr - ) :ZL,N3 FLOoRS. l:tc
I
i
I
i
L.grl Fli&rgs
Bar*ruptcy:
?ax Llcn flllngr:
Judgmoltt filing3:
Surn oftagalfihogs:
UCc rllings:
Crulionary UCC filin95:
I
I
2!
Additional Eusil|ess Facls
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 92 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE
..:, li .ir \rJ _i!,j .. ' 1 ! i
'
, I ) I , I I I . I ir\
p5
?!:|5 N PI-ES, r-l
Locadon
bu3ines., DAZZLING FLOORS, lNC, is lhc Ulllnrqt€ Pafent
PO BOX 5835 . D=STIN.FL
BIN
t33397a57
la, o
ior o
oArzu(G FLCORS. lNa
Eranchcs ot ttle rnqulr€d upofl brrsiiess.
TLOORS. INC
DAZZLNG FLOORS. Ii{C
33? T€OUSST^ DR. DESTIN,IL
,
7935 AIRPONT PULLI{G RO N - N'"E!ES,FL
r3002c635
s81:ac336
ExBqltn $ldes ,EeX oa lhe dqth and ac€.,racy of the dtla maintained on out dalabases. Repoftrng your cuslomerb
': Nyn eflt ,shaylorto 6xpa,,an wll LNhN s*engthdo and en raoce tfie po$'€raf the thlormatlon atsilable fol rnaking soaod
crzdit dacislons, 6irre cladd yhe.e cadit is duo. Ca/] l4OO-l2O-122/, optlon #1 for more inlamratiolj.
,End of tcpgrt i. ,. 1 oi 1 rec'ri
ft| fut t*r*i ts ,tt ir-,,d i, caa$enee br yo* e:dxive usa la? /sq*./.rle buj,.rf]ss ptooscs ,ac ata, ,ol be nindr.ed r',gn€. Ffr:..
,.ntn!!.{& So}ri37t ,tc. trdraf "sdtarts.dshbdals ,ca,refi sa,E* LlkNRat n ha. cra/i tllof b! kde ld laa lsa a'rtlaoro toitl;
Pttt.it PaF:a .9l.-zzL$n RCC'.15. laic 4itr
23$-?88*$68
i ,1{a,rl Aildr.*el
Corpot,{o Llnlago
I
I
lg E eeislr 2Ol-.. A3 nlhls .6!3ltsd. Aivlq nnlib_.
a9?lran am tl' a$€rbn $aits h!l!{l are 5elY,te marks or rca6l€rsl klaemad(s of Erp(,3r
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 93 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE
L')6 r ir. arl -:1tj l]orporate trx 23{i-2AA-{968
WMerit Credit
Fnlt, A<rutatf & 54curc
USRIT GED:! BS REIRIEVED TBE ABC1IE B(ISINESS NEPOR? rOR I,:SSNSINE P{JR.POSZS A.sxEgrlglED at rB BUSINESS d*teR./mosRiEtoF, psBr,IC FACOB.DS roR rtsIS REpo.Rt E;,vEBASN CmeGD l}tD VBn1Etf,b AT frrE cot Nfr (TNCIIJDINC PINELI.A.S), S!A!E ArID r"DrFAL
PUBLTC T.ECORIS LEITII?D: 1
EXPSRI.AI| ASSIXESS INFOEMAITON SERVTCES
IRS
',IAN
SEC'TONcouslr coERtsousE ?rcoRls
!r you girvx, ax! QsEs{lrcNs REGtsDr}lG ttrls FrpoRr , ?I,EASIS CONTACT UERI? CRxDIt -A!: 1-
COiVPANY NAME: DAZTIIIG F!.ooRs, INc.
FEDERAL lD: 41-2025049
CURRENT STATUS: INACTIVE
PRTNCIPAI(S): DARLEEN ROWE
]OEL T.,'I ROWE
DATE TNCORPORATEO: At/t4lZOO2
TITLE: D
TITLE: O
p.0
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 94 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE
C,Rft,Qor*tt3t Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
239-25?-?400Gto\ /tt Managernent DeparfrEnt
APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
COLTECTION OF SOCIAI SECURITY NUMBERS
Date: APRIL 12, 20'18
To: Applicants for Certificate of Competency
From: Everildo Ybaceta, Contractor Licensing Supervisor
Pursuant to Chapter l-19, Florida Statutes and Collier County Contractor Licensing Ordinance 200646
Section 2.1.1., all applicants are required to submit their social security number(SSN) for the following
purposes:
a) Assess applicant's ability to satisfy creditors by reviewing their credit history
b) Verification of applicant's test scores and information.
Our office will only use your SSN not6d above for those reasons pursuant to Chapter l-19, Florida
Statutes, and as may otherwise be authorized by law.
We are fully committed to safe-guarding and protecting your SSN and onco collected, will be maintained
as confidential and exempt under Chapter l-19, Florida Statutes.
FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4112t18 Page 15 of 15
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 95 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
Detail by Officer/Registered Agent Name
Florida Limited Liability Company
ROWE FLOORING LLC
Filinq lnfo.mation
Page 2 of 2
Document Number
FEUEIN NumbeT
Date Filed
Effective Date
State
Status
L'19000007274
NONE
011c/.t2019
01t04t2019
FL
ACTIVE
Principal Address
3262 6OTH ST SW
NAPLES, FL 34116
Mailino Address
3262 6OTH ST SW
NAPLES, FL 34116
Redisrered Aoent Name & Address
ROWE, JOEL M
3252 6OTH ST SW
NAPLES, FL 34116
Authorized P ls) Oetail
Name & Address
Title MGR
ROWE. JOEL M
3262 6OTH ST SW
NAPLES, FL 34116
Title AP
ROWE, DARLEEN
3262 6OTH ST SW
NAPLES, FL 34116
Annual Regorts
No Annual Reports Filed
Document lmaoes
019 .. r o a Lim ied Liabilrlr Vew inrige d PDF lormal
http://search.sunbiz.org/lnquiry/CorporationSearch/SearchResultDetail?inquirytype=Offic... lll I l20lg
Detail by Officer/Registered Agent Name 8.C.1
Packet Pg. 96 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
Electronic Articles of OrsanizationFor
Florida Limited Liability Company
Article I
'l'he name of the Limited Liability Company is:
ROWI,] 1-I,OORING I-LC
L19000007274
FILED 8:00 AMJanuarv 04.2019
Sec. ofState
cmwood
Article II
The street address of the principal offrce of the Limited Liability Company is
3262 6OTH ST SW
NAPLES, FL. US 34116
The mailing address of the Lrmited Liability Company is:
3262 6OTH ST SW
NAPI-ES. FL. US 34I16
Article III
The name and Florida street address ofthe registered agent is:
JOEL M ROWE
3262 6OTH ST SW
NAPLES, FL. 34116
Having been named as regislered agenl and to accept service of process ficr the above stated limited
liability company at lhe place designated in this cerlificate, I hereby accepl the appointrnenl as registered
agent and agree lo act in this capacity. I furdrer agree to comply wift the provisions of all slatules
relafing to fie proper and complete performance of my duhes. and I am familiar with and accept the
obligations ofmy position as regislered agenl.
Registered Agent Signature: JOEL ROWE
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 97 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING LLC
Article IV
The name and address of person(s) authorized to manage LLC:
Title: MGR
JOEL M ROWE
3262 6OTH ST SW
NAPLES, FL. 34116 US
Title: AP
DARLEEN ROWE
3262 6OTH ST SW
NAPLES,FL. 34116 US
Article V
The effective date for this Limited Liability Company shall be:
0U04/2019
Signature of member or an authorized representative
Elsctronic Signature: JOEL ROWE
L19000007274
FILED 8:OO AMJanuarv 04.20'19
Sec. ofState
cmwood
I am the member or authorized representalive submittins these Articles of Organizafion and allrm thal the
lacls stated herein are true. I am iware that false infoniiation submitted in a ilocumenl to the Depar0nent
of State constihrtes a third degree lelony as provided for in s.817.155, F.S. I understand the requirement to
file an annual reporl between-January lll and May lst in the calendar'year following formation of the LLC
and every year thereafter to maintain "active" statirs.
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 98 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
EEIB I
Your Progress: L ldentity y' 2. Authenticate y' 3. Addresset y' 4. Detaits y'
EIN Assistant
Congralulationsl Your EIN has been successfully asslgned.Help Tr
IMPORTANT:
Save and/or print tiis page and the confrmation letter b€low for your penranent records.
The confirmation letter below is your official IRS notice and contains important information regarding your
EIN-
? CUCX HERE for Your EIN Contirmation Letter Help with savinq and
p-r}n!nq-vwdcler
Once yor have saved or printed your l.tter. click 'Continue" 10 get addilional
information about using your new ElN.
( Con}nue >> i
ffimS.go,
EIN Assigned: 83-31 07574
Legal Name: ROlltE FL(IRING LLC
IRS Privacy_EgIay I Accessibilitv
0wr
t6
Oc.
lat
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 99 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
c,RF., co,wtw Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
239-252-2400Gro\ itt tvtanagerrEnt Oeparfnent
APPTICATION FOR COLTIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
RESOLUTION OF AUTHORIZATION
Complete this form if multiple people own part of the company the license will be attached to.
lf there is only I owner, then this form is not required for the application.
ln accordance with Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as ame Ouve Qlour;u LLc-
to engage in contracting as O$Aze,s
1.,"'\ AoDlicant Nams- (a,a.Q*rw LLca;;il1
empowered to act on
business and has the autho
. We further resolve and represent that
o.n"tt i&cpz 4Qor,r.< LLC;.
",,
r"n"r"!
Apdic€ht Name
connected with its contracting
L c
na;L
in Collier County where
Off ic6rYowners/Partners Applicant Name
proposes to qualify for a Certificate of Competency with com Q*.,UC
It is hereby agreed upon that \,r€ the undersigned O{$i"B L
Otfi cers/O$nors/PartneE Company
resolve and represent to the Collier County Contractor's Licensing Board that the proposed qualifying agent,
T\.tn {?,",-, is active in all matters connected with the company named
*3 proposes
Ur/C,
of
on undertaken by
is legally
olLttn
Of fi c6rs],OwnorsPadngrs
Jd?1 ?N<
The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this
by who has produced
name ot pe6on acknowiedging (Offic€6/Ovfiers)
d not take an oath
NOTARY'S SEAL
--Po
Witn6ss
Off icerYowne.s/Partners Witness
Off icerrowners/Partners Witness
Officers/Owne6/Partners of the above montioned company need lo sign on the right aDd a witngss to the signature s ions on the l6i.
State
County of
a aL
date
con
ATURE OF
GRETA L. B, F, DOS SANTOS
Sl€te of Florid!-Notrry pubtic
Commrrtion, GG 225970
My Commitrion Expir€!
Junr 00 2022
FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4t'12118 Page I of '15
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 100 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
C,Rfr,Cor,tt,.t3l Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34'104
239-252-2400G.E^i,lft Managerneot DeparfrEnt
APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
member of
This certifies that l,
STATEMENT OF OWNERSHIP
am a member or managing
APPLICANTS NAME (pleas6 print)
C
(LIMITED Lrw CoMPANY NAME)
c-
date
502I own % of the units issued by the Limited Liability Company listed above
Affidavit of Applicant: I certity under ponalty of perjury that ths lnformatlon contalnod is a true and correct
statoment to the b.st of my knowledgo.
LLL.
NEme ofcompany
Signature ofApplicant
State ot
County of
The foregoing
by
name of p€con acknowlodging (applicant)
as identification and did not take an oath.
NOTARY'S SEAL
.I,instrument as acknowledoedz---\
[un Mu,"-Fwho has produced L
typ€ of identification or k
.s#&ir,rffi
GREIA L. B. F. DOS SANTOS
Strte o, Flotida-Notsry Pt blic
Commillion I GG 225970
My Commislioo Erpires
Juno 09,2022
OF NOT
FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4112118 Page 9 ol 15
l>rl"-^-*-
Applicant (pleas€ print)
before me rhis l- t:k- -zot n __-
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 101 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
C,Rfr,Qor,tttxy Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
239-?52-2400Gro,vh fvbnagernent DepartrEnt
APPLICATION FOR COTLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
VERIFICATION OF CONSTRUCTION EXPERIENCE
'?o*o
Applicant's Name un
Certificate Category Requested:
The applicant is seeking a Collier County Certificate of Competency in the trade indicated above. As part of the application for
this certificate, the applicant must veify his/her experience within this trade. You are being requesled to provide information that
will aid the applicant in meeting this requirement. You should veriry time of active experience working as an apprentice or a
skilled worksr (e.9., as a worker commanding the wage ot mechanic or better in the trad6). Time served solely in a sup€rvisory
or administra$ve rol€ should be describ€d, but may or may not be consid€red suffci€nt to domonstrate required trade
experience. The poBon verifying trado experionco for the above-named applicant must provida the tollotylng
information:
Name D e'.^*'.s D i "lo-e"5o.^
Business Name H"\F loo.i.'^r
Noy,l-L Ai" or.t
Licarc€ No. (if applicable)
R t fVo p\.1 FL 1"{ loqBusiness Address L 1d I
Street I
l0 11-
Crty I
to\)
State
Lo\x
zip
The
App
applicant was €mployod by ms from
ticant's tiue: f ^r t't ll. -
The applicant's scope of work (specific duties) included .\ r^t" ll"0]r'1
Ja.^<a
State or FL Signature of person providing the statement
County of Colt're/
The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this llh duqa{So,a.xr,.r-r olq-- r tate
?erlttaatt. L zorra Jo tl\(-
(
by l')aarr Dt ekeAo,l who has produced
name of person acknowledging
as identification and did not take an oath
NOTARY'S SEAL
typ. ot id""tfic"ffi;in r.
,$H;.,lw
FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4/1218
(srG o ARY)
Paqe 10 of 15
'l'itle: Wq"tLlrlt fAar"aq{"
-
Additional comments:
NOTE TO UCENSED COI'ITRACTORS; Farsilying any infonpt@ Wvided hercin may subjocl ywr liconse to rcvocatioo.
Under penalty of perjury, I dedare that the facts stated here are tru6.
SHINYLAYEOMAN5
NotaryPublic - 5lata ol florida
^4y
Colnm. tupirer Ag 23, 2021
Llo.ded lh.ough i.lidDl tot.ry turl
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 102 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
C,Rft,Cotrrtqt Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
239-25?-2400Gro,rrtr ManagerrEnt DeparEnent
APPLICATION FOR COLTIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
VERIFICATION OF CO TRUCTI EXPERIENCE
Applicant's Name lun
Certifi cate Category Requested
The applicant is seeking a Collier County Certilicat€ of Competency in the trade indicated above. As part of th6 application for
this certifcate, the applicanl must verit his/her exp€rience within this trade. You are being requested to provide informalion thal
will aid the applicant in meeting this requirement. You should verify time of active expedence \,lrorking as an apprentic€ or a
skilled worker (e.9., as a worksr commanding the wage of mechanic or better in the trade). Tim6 served sol€ly in a sup€rvisory
or administrative role should be describsd, but may or may not be clnsidered suffcient to demonstrate required kade
experience. The pcrson vartf$ng trado oxparlonca for the aboys.named appllcant must proyide the following
lnfoImatlon:
Name:Bt,r Bct,rs Title Sqle S - 6fatwhons rt7 drt 9A e-r-
Business Name H4.ci,,),, 17 License No. (if applicable):
.1:e s lJofBusiness Address 6lo t rJ. At r+ A.l il1//rtt
Street City State zip
The applicant was employed by me from l/eorx )^ leottto
Applicant's title C41.1"., //ct^
The applicant's scope of work (specific duties) included:laglallalr (e 'T
J'rT i l"irl _-6 -T.; rtAdditional comments
NOTE TO LICENSED CONTRACTORS: Falsifying any infomation provided herein may subioct your liconse to rcvocation
{4/K)
Signature of person providing the statemenl
State of PI
County of
The foregoing instrument as acknowledged betore me this l1a clut ../.-tan*r,zotq
by Bilt Bou.m
name of p€6on acknod€dghg
as identfication and did not tako an oath
NOTARY'S SEAL
._late
os,cn.vrltvtwho has produced h Itncvn h,(u4
tvpe?tlnmratro" &ino,r,n
A,-,1 4o-on,,
.iffi;,,
'*W
SHERYI.AYIOMAN5
llotery Puuac _ st.ta ot tloridd
Commit5ion I GG Cfi978
[,ty comm Expitel Afl 23. 2021
0ond€d thiolgh NtlioDl Nolxy Are'
FIRM APPLICATION REV 411?,18
----(arcNAlu{EoailorAif
Cott'i"/
Under penalty of porjury, I declare that the fac{s stated hsre are true.
Page 11 of 15
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 103 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
c,&fr,C.ott*tX!Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
239-252-2400G6^^fr Managernent OeparfiEnt
APPTICATION FOR COTLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
VERIFICAT!ON OF CONSTRUCTION EXPERIENCE
Certilicate Category Requested :
The applicant is seeking a Colli€r County Certificate of Competency in the trade indicated above. As part of the application for
this certificate, the applicant must verify his/her expsrience within this trade. You are being requested to provide information that
will aid the applicant in meeting this requirement. You should verify time of activo oxpsrience working as an apprentice or a
skilled worker (€.9., as a worker commanding the wage of mechanic or better in lhe trado). Time served solely in a suporvisory
or administrative role should be described. but may or may not ba considered sufficient to demonstrate required trade
experience. The peBon verlfying trade axperlence for tho above-named applicant must provlds the tollowlng
information i
Name Ti
License No. (if applicable)
Business Address
St oet
The applicant was employed by me from otA to 0.-
Stat€
&c>tR
-?rUr,g
atpCity
1.-,^
Applicant's title:
Additional comments
NOTE TO LICENSED CONTRACTORS; Falsitying any information prcided herein may subjoct your license to revocation.
Undor penalty of perjury. I declaro that ths facts stated here are true
State of FL providing the statem€nt
Callic/
The foregoing instrumsnt as acknowledgod before me this
as identification and did not take an oath.
NOTARY'S SEAL
JS ot7
o, llrolrn knqcl=Lind snohasprcducad
namg' ot porson addowl€dgirg L
typ€ of
rRlr,,lw
5HERYLAYEOMAN5
Notary Public - State ol Flolida
Commission I GG 096978
^{y
(o(t1m. hprrel Ag 21, 202l
lbidod lhilugh N.nor.l I'rotr, Arv
FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4112118
GNATURE OF
Page '12 of 15
Applicant's Name:
eusiness Nane: //,aJ,, - a,r ?1"-a ;.a3
-t^,rl,"r/-
The applicant's scope of wort (specific dutjesl inctuoeo: f,.r -y {n-11 a{ ) o ^,, ^ f CAR PaT.
County of
-date I
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 104 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
HA INGER
941. l?31
To Whom It May Concern:
I have worked with Joel Rowe since January 2012. During that time I
have known him to be honest and reliable. He is organized, responsible and
straightforward. He has a good reputation and is respected by his peers.
He is a very skilled carpet installer and is very conscientious in his
work and his dealings with others.
I have had the opportunity to obserue his business and personal
dealings and can vouch for him to be a person ofhonesty, integrity and good
character.
Dennis Dickerson
\1 \i- )u- l1
Name Date
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 105 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
CATIONOF CONSTBUCTIONE(P
G!{D O parations & Begulatory Management Dopartmoltt
Llconsiog Soction
2E0ll N. Iloncrhoc Drlve
Naplg' FL 341{l,l
Appli€ant's Name:'a
Ccrtificatc Crtcgory Rc4ucsed rft
Thc ,ApPllc!- ! *ttirg r Cotticr Conrty C.rtlfic.L of Cornpct !rc, ln th. grd. lttdldtcd .boya Ar F tl of &eippllcrlion for ttlt ec lrlcrta thc Appllcror rrrur verify ttclr e:'perterl rvithia ahh trrda You .ro bdrg rcqBlrLd lo
ProYu. lntonasdo! lhrt lTfla rtd tir Appllcrrt in mettirg tbir r:quire ont. you rhoutd vcrlfy tin. of.cliw rrpcri.lcctorkloi r' aa .pPr€ntlce or r 3!,llH workcr 1r.g. ar r roikcr comurandiog lhe rvrge of mcchiric or Dctt r b all! lrd!).
Tttlc -trrved rotcly tn r npcrebory or rdnlnirtrative rolc sho{td be <ticribcd,-but |!ry or rr.y noa b. .{oru!ftdslllclc[l to dcarolltttrla r.qrircd lrudc qrp€ricrc4, The prrsor ve.ifyirg trrdc crpcrhmc nrut provlde rtc bllo ag
hforr[rabtr:
Nitnc, Tide 8nd liaanre aumber ofthe persot signing belo!.y srd vcising Appt;eanl! relevsrt experierc4:
Nrnc ?,*relaq- €- *,\.-.-ao.O __*. s\.IL\I.ElaCrF|l1*E},S. i€Ar-
Titb.RQs*tis&lL--_-LiceDseNumber(ifapplicabie):@?la?.
N&.mc ofBusincs3
Busincss Addrc$:a 8$
Bu"in,o phooc:fi4 !3BS? zef, Thr Appiicart's years oiexperiencc trom llal. ro F\aat*.{
{te applicanls scope of work (spocific dutiee) included: -tsN<--r"rr"' t.as\cr^,\ ct -€t$E.l8 .
A&litiortl Commcnts:-5S.
:
FibifyiBg rllY ,nfonlstioo ProY ided hereit! mrY !ubj!c{ yoor licrtrsc lo revocailo&
SigntuJrc
Paint N6!tr!
$ate of Florida
County ofCollisr
hgu,neol rrs adoro*hdgcd of J
Ettr,*sSi
oarn.
k plrJotrrlly koolvt to $produqcd
2,
8nd who did
si ofN
'Itc
not tik an
#jffi
hurlep^?r,,,e I .llr-liir.i pl,rr,,
r
\lt^r.,2 r-, lirGOirrr.re ,'rr r.rr ? r.$c*trlc<r I u;tD trl)e$utF€- \le:r.,
-a.E{.*
by
!8
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 106 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN
GMN Op erati ona & R€gulatory Matrrgemont Depart rr
Llcenslug flectiol
2800 N. Horr..&o. Drtrc
Nrphr, fL 3at0l
\u1_Dczzt,Appllcrnt's Name:a ke
Grtific*c Catcgory Rcqrcncd ID
Namq Titlc lIld licc{I!?
Namc:Lcrrr
sr)Tide:e € r--'1 +
e(;
T:,.1q$ryt f .*crirq r Co[iar Cornry clrri0ot of compcrcDlj, to rhc trtdc ,.dtcrtGd rDrva A! prrt of rtcrpptle'tior for tib ccrtlllcat at! Apptic.nt aurt vGrify thcir crpcrhrce rrithln this tnd.- You rtr Hnt raqEctlcd to
Pno"UG tofonrldol ahrt tU dd UJ ipplicut io mcctilg th1 rcqqlrcocnr yos tiould vcrlfy tinc of ectivc crprriclcc
nortlag ra rr eppru0cc or e rtillcd rorkcr t"g. .. . roii.r *ii.rraiug tf. .r3c of Ecctuic or bcltcr b th; frdc).Tlta.tcrved soLly h r Ip.trbory or rdrrhigtntivc roh sho8H br d;ribr4-bot rrry or r'.y ioa bc co6H!r"d
:rIcht to ormonttrrlc rcquircd trtdr erpcrbnc!. Tic p.non vcrtfying t".a. irp""f-i tDrrf provLa tic lollowleg
iufofl[ation:
tlc pcEon signilrg b€lo md veiryin8 ApplicanG rclsvsnr erp€riencc:
UrY'\€
Liccnse Numb€r (if )r
Namc ofBusiness;l.P lr L
Busincss Addrcss;
Broincss phonc: e@ t aLR' bBqnt" Applicsnr,s yca,. of cxperi.nc.tun l9Cl
w
+
-,fusfnr-r,Cflor..J otr Cqr d+P
FL
The a ppe of work (speci6c duti,ee) induded:
tAroJ tI.J -liL€
f4r
Addiaionsl CJxnmcnB:-J Wo.K
Frkifyhg rrY irlorrrtioo provldGd lcrct! r.Y robicct }our licclr to ravott
L C ,(L
Print
C
troducd
sl\t(
rnrsr
Sarc of Rortda
Comty of Colliff
Thc forcgoint iaSruml'la
by
la
a5 snd eho did rpl ti.o sn o.th
of
OF CONSTRUCTIONIffiFi
Y.l)
(=
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 107 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE –
ATIFIC oN Fo N0 ED(P RIENoCNSCTIUTB
GMI)Oper stions & Begulatory Msnagement Doparrao't
Licensing Section
tr&X) N. Ilorrtrhoc Drlve
Napler, FL 3t104
CLZZIi
e(tn(
t
Applk;rnt's Name
Ccrtificafc Catcgory Rcquestcd:-.Lrl
Tlc Appuc.lt L 3iekirg r Colticr Co{rty Clrultcrte of Cor!i.r ti! tr.dt lodkrl.{ rboY& A! prrt of th3pltr0gYtpplicrtior for lhii ce rtlrlclte the Applir{ol must !r.i fy thoir erpsricnre xtthh ahlr trade. You ,r. blhg rcqulsacd to
proylde inforulnliorr thrt will rid tlc Applicrnt in merling thh rrquirlnerlt, You rhould veruy tlitre of rctive experiersertorhlog rr an apprrnt he or r,klllcd $orlrr (e.g.ai l qorkcr cotrnardinB thc rage of mlalunie or b.tter h tho ande).'nm. olrvrd solely lo a slpcrvlso.y or adlritrlrtralivc mle should be dcscrlbcd, blt mry or mry ,oa bc conridcrcd
suflicicnr to dem onstr.lc rcquired tred! frporicncc. The person verifying tr.de arpcricncc mrrt pro!,ldr thc followlog
laform
Namc,
Name:
alioa:
Title ,icen$ numbcr of lhc pe(3on sigoing below and veiSing Applicaa(s relcvant experielc€:
Titlc:
Name ofBusiness:
Busincss Address:
ar
a,f,.)
Busincas Phooe: *A'SCI aSAS *e Applicant's ycars o f experie ilct from
The s s<npe of wor (8peci c includod;
Addit ioflal C,{rmm€ltq:
rny itrfgnnition idsd heciir otsy tubject r tireffo to
l)nrt NEme
$Etc of Florlda
&unty of collkr
Ths focgoittg irFlrsrsent w!5 lckno* lldged b€fo.. mc on this_Lir2- dty ot
produ.
by
13
oi Notrrv
o
7
ard who did no1 lrko an gath
o rs pcrsorla
Sign
ffiffi-.ffi
ken'Rot
I
b*r/,n
#rJo:d"no nrmb€r (itsppl jcabtc):
I xv| r?(t ")
I
d c
a-
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 108 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE
"ret C-,ovrrt1t
Gro,titt Managernefit OeparurEnt
APPLICATION FOR COTTIER COUNIY CERTIFICATE OF COAAPETENCY
AFFIDAVIT OF INTEGRITY AND GOOD CHARACTER
z,JoaSTATE OF
COUNTY OF (,
O ll,er €/lr, do-I am a resident of County,(State) and have resided here for
more than five (5) years
During the last five (5) years I have (applicant). I have had the opportunity
to observe his or her business and personal dealings and find him or her to a person of honesty, integrity and
good character.
Signature
Printed Name
ea',."",5b0 E Wbub.J
City
Telephone z1- b)t-
The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this t-+-2 r1
who has produced
St
date
type of identification
zip
ification
State
\
by
name of person acknowiedging
and did not take an oath
NOTARY'S SEAL
NOT..:r'i{{3,-ffi TAGft L B F 00 s TSAN osaNotorid6-a Prrb ccosmisnGG221590coMmmisoE€3
J ne 09 2 202
FIRM APPLICATION Rey 4112118 Page 13 of 15
Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horsesho€ Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
239-252-2400
,,AdICU-LM44L,havinsb6enfi rsrdurysworn,srareandarfi rm:
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 109 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
C,Rfr,Caunxy Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
239-252-2400Grouih Managernent DeparfiEnt
APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
STATE OF
AFFIDAVIT OF INTEGRlTY AND GOOD CHARACTER
COUNTY OF
Jnn;Q. GhrnI,
I am a resident of
, having been first duly sworn, state and affirm:
County,(State) and have resided here forGll,.r ?trv,'1"'-
N;1,,*.During the last five (5) years I have known (applicant). I have had the opportunity
to observe his or her business and personal dealings and flnd him or her to be a person of honesty, integrity and
good character.lr*,a- t4*-
Printed Name
3z?0 l?t"r4/?So.Address
Telepho
Street 3
State 2ip
..,?r/c: u.s?: bar3
The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this oI
identification
data
by -Jen.,, Q' Gtn^
namo ot person acknotrledglng
and did not take an oath.
who has produced
of
GREIA L. B, F. OOS SA
Stato ot Floridr'NotErY
Commialion I GG 225970
NTOS
Public
i e smtioocpsMy
2 02n09aJ
FIRM APPLICATION ReY 4112118 Page 14 of 15
more than five (5) years.
NOTARY'S SEAL
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 110 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
AFTIDAYIT OT
INTEGTTITT AND GOOD CHAf,ACIEB
I \*Nftq< €- $\cb&!p.,t,am a roaident of 6\
(Stats) and have resided here for more thaa frve (6) ysars'
(Srgnature
County,
.. During tbe laet five years I have known Lli r f+€r r IOLUS=-.- applicrnt). I have hsd
tbe opportuniry to obs€rve hic or her businees and fersonal deahnga and find him or her to be a p€r8on or
honoety, integrity and good charaeter.
ST}$E OT I.OR,IDA
COUNTY OF
'Ihe foregoing inotrument was acknowledged before me this
1?.1 cts who has produced
(Name) R.rir;< rL-".r\<*>Ltf,{
(Address) r!1lrl SlRS'ldR'a- !R"r
#re
telephone; 8SF SDE ?ZJFC
by
(Date)
of i.dentifrcation)
SILi RE F NO?ARY
NAME OI.'NO1'AA))
NOTARY PLELIC
a0q
(name of Peraon acknowledging)
an identifrcation and who did not t'ke an oath
ffiffiffi
NOTARY'S SEAL
I
(P
0)'pe
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 111 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE
i Lor.,hqJ-re
ATTIDAVITOT
INTEORITY AND COOD CIIARACTAB
am a reerdent of f 0
County.6 A (State) and bave reeided here for more than 6ve (6) yeara
During tbe laat fir,e yeare I have know, DAalar", 'Ro--app licant). I have hed
the opportrioity to obserr,e hi.s ot her businees and peraonal dealings and fird him or her to e pereon of
honesty, htagrity and guod character
(Srgnaiure)
(Name)
(Ad
Telephone)6s -qrq *b,o
STAT6 OF FIOAIDA
COUNTY OF
The ioregoiag ilstrupent w8s acknolr'ledged trefore me this by
psbS
Jr^ n.- i lrtl
(aa-ue of Penon acknowledgrng)
(Date)
who has produecd lr(',.r',-' i"pt"r^otl\'(lypc of identification)
an identificatirm and who ilid noi take an oath'
ffiffi
NOTAR}'S SDAL
SIC NO?ARY
{P&r NAME OF NOTARY)
NO1ARY PUBLIC
J*
6
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 112 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN
ATTTDAVITOTINTEGBXTY ANI} COOD CIIARACTEB
I
am a residont of
County,(State) and have resided here for more than fve (6) years'
Duriag the laat five yeare I have h *.^ T\uteen'?aux appticani).I hava had
the opportuni$ to obs€rve Lig ar Ler bu sinaes aad peroonal dealings and fuid him or hor to be a person ol
bo ne8ty. irtegriF and. good charactsr
(Sigtraiur6)
(Na.ae)
(eddress)
Telephone)
pr.*/
SIATSOFFT,OBTDA
colnilTroF
Tbe eragoilg irchu!rcnt eaa aaknowladged befrre me this a byI
who has produced ppr!.( n tully l< rr or't-' (Ilpe of ideniiEcatioa)(nore pereoa ac&nowledging)
aa ide.ntifcati<m and who did not take an oith-
siG NOfARY
NAI{E OF NOTABNNO?ARY?UBLIC
NOTA.RYSST,AL
*$,flry.fi,1]'f;ssiffi
#,ffiltr*
(
c.
(P
8
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 113 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE –
o.Qo*DAIE (illll/ODft1m
0111612019
THIS CERTIFICATE IS ISSUEO AS A MATTER OF INFORMATION ONLY AND CONFERS NO RIGHTS UPON THE CERTIFICATE HOLDER. THIS
CERTIFICATE DOES NOT AFFIRMATIVELY OR NEGATIVELY AMEND, EXTEND OR ALTER THE COVERAGE AFFORDEO BY THE POLICIES
AELOW. THIS CERTIFICATE OF INSURANCE DOES NOT CONSTITUTE A CONTRACT BETWEEN THE ISSUING INSURER(S), AUTHORIZED
REPRESENTATIVE OR PRODUCER, AND THE CERTIFICATE HOLOER.
IMPORTANT: lf the certificate holder is an ADOITIONAL INSURED,lhe policy(ies) must have ADOITIONAL INSURED provisions or be endorsed.
lf SUBROGATION lS WAIVED, subject to the terms and conditions of the policy, certain policies may require an endorsement. A statement on
lhis certiticate does not confer rights to the certificate holder in lieu of such endorsement(s).
PRODUCER
PO 4or 60787
Palo Allo, CA 94306
(855)222-5919
support@nexl-insurancs.com
llrsu RER(s) aFFoRorNG covERAGE
rxsuRERA. Slale National lnsurance Company, lnc 12831
INSUREO
Rowe Flooring LLC
3262 60rh Sr SW
Naples, FL 34116
CERTIFICATE OF LIABILITY INSURANCE
cERTtFiCATE NIJMBER. 8683833COVERAGES REVISION NUMBER
THIS IS TO CERTIFY THAT THE POLICIES OF INSURANCE LISTED BELOW HAVE EEEN ISSUED TO THE INSURED NAMED ABOVE FOR THE POLICY PERIOD
INDICATED, NOTWITHSTANDING ANY REOUIREMENT. TERM OR CONDITION OF ANY CONTRACT OR OTHER DOCUMENT WIIH RESPECT TO WHICH THIS
CERTIFICATE MAY BE ISSUED OR MAY PERTAIN, THE INSURANCE AFFORDEO BY THE POLICIES DESCRIBED HEREIN IS SUBJECT TO ALL THE TERMS,
EXCLUSIONS AND CONDITIONS OF SUCH POLICIES, LIMITS SHOWN MAY HAVE BEEN REDUCED BY PAID CLAIMS.
I
EACI] OCC!RRENCE s1,000,000.00
PRFMISFS rF, m.Lrenel s100,000.00
MEO EXP (Any one 0€60.)$ 10.000.00
PERSONAL & AOV INJURY
GE NE RAL AGG REGATE
$1,000,000.00
$2,000,000.00
PRODUCTS COMP/OP AGC $2,000,000.00
COIt! MERCIAL G ENERAL LIABIfITY
X
GEN'L AGGREGATE LiMITAPPLIES PER
x
LOCJECI
OTHER:
NXTZI\IH2NMP OO GL 01t1112019 01t1112024
S
5
AOOTY INJURY (Pe. peM.)5
BOOILY INJURY (Pq a@ident)s
S
OWNEO
AUIOSONLY
HIREO
AUIOS ONLY
SCHEDULEO
AUTOS
NON.OWNED
AUTOS ONLY
AUIOMOAILE LIABIL'TY
S
EACI]OCCURRENCEUI'BREILALIAB
EXCESS IIAB
OCCUR
AGGREGATE
DED RETENTION $S
OTH-
EL EACH ACCIOENT
E L O SEASE EA EMPLOYEE
WORXERS COMPENSATION
AIIO EMP LOYERS' LIABILlrY
ANYPROPR ETOFYPAR'TNEFYEXECIJT VE
OFFICEFTMEMAER EXCLI.]DEO?
ESCRIPTION OF OPERATIONS be ow
11
o E L, O]SEASE - POLICY LIMIT
S
S
Contracto6 E(ors and Omissions 0111112020
$25,000.00
$50,000.00
oESCRIPTION OF OPERATIONS / LocATIoNS /VEHICLES {ACORD l0l, Addition.l Rar Jr*s i chodL rd fray .oanached ilmoEsp.ce is roquired)
NXTZMH2NMP-OO-GL o1t11t2019
SHOULO ANY OF THE ABOVE DESCRIBED POLICIES BE CANCELLEO BEFORE
THE EXPIRATION DATE THEREOF, NOTICE WILL BE DELIVEREO IN
ACCORDANCE wlTH THE POLICY PROVISIONS.
CERTIFICATE
Rowe Floodng LLC
3262 60rh Sl SW
Naples, FL 34116
il^W
R CANCELLATION
O 1988-2015 ACORD CORPORATION. All rights reserved
The ACORD name and logo are registered marks of ACORDACORD 2s (2016i03)
s
E
Aggregate:
AI]TI]ORIZED REPRESENTATIVE
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 114 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
JIMI\4Y PATRONIS
CHIEF FINANICAL OFFICER
Floor Covering lnslallalion
Res enl Floo.ing Carpel and
STATE OF FLORIDA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCIAL SERVICES
DIVISION OF WORKERS' COMPENSATION
- - CERTIFICATE OF ELECTION TO BE EXEMPT FROM FLORIDA WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAW - -
CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY EXEMPTION
This certifies that the individual listed below has elected to be exempt from Florida Workers' Compensation law
EFFECTIVE DAIET 111512019 EXPIRATION DATE: 111412021
PERSON; JOEL M ROWE EMAIL: JROWE8867@GMAIL.COM
FEIN: 833107574
BUSINESS NAME AND ADDRESS:
ROWE FLOORING LLC
3262 6OTH ST SW
NAPLES, FL 341 16
SCOPE OF BUSINESS OR TRADE:
lI\TPORTANT: Pursuant to Chapter 440.05(14). F.S., an officer of a corporation who elects exemption from this chapter by filing a certilicate of election under
this section may not recover benefrls or compansation under this chapter. Pursuant to Chapter 440-05(12), F.S., CerUicates of election to be exempt... apply
only wilhin the scope of lhe business or trade listed on the notice of election to be exempt. Pursuant to Chapter 440.05(13), F-S., Notices of election to be
exempl and certficates of election to be exempt shallbe subject to revocalion jf, at any time after the filing ofihe notice orthe issuance ofthe certilicate,lhe
person named on the notice or certific€te no longer meets the requirements of lhis section for issuance of a certjfcate. The departmenl shall revoke a
certificate at any time for failure of the person named on the cerlificate to meet lhe requirements ofthis sectjon.
DFS-F2-DWC.252 CERTIFICATE OF ELECTION TO BE EXEI\,4PI REVISED 08-13 QUESTTONS? (850)413-1609
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 115 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
Floor Covering lnslallation-
Resilient Floorlng' Carpet and
Laminate Flooring
STATE OF FLORIDA
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCIAL SERVICES
DIVISION OF WORKERS' COMPENSATION
" " CERTIFICATE OF ELECTION TO BE EXEMPT FROM FLORIDA WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAW'-
CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY EXEMPTION
This certifies that the individual listed below has elecled to be exempt from Florida Workers' Compensalion law
EFFECTIVE OATE 111712019 EXPIRATION OATET 111612021
PERSON: DARLEEN ROWE EMAIL: FUNGETAWAY@HOTMAIL.COI\4
FEIN: 833107574
BUSINESS NAME AND ADDRESS:
ROWE FLOORING LLC
3262 6OTH ST SW
NAPLES, FL 341 16
SCOPE OF BUSINESS OR TRADE:
llt{ PORTANT: Pursuant to Chapter 440.05(14), F.S., an oflicer of a corporation who elects exemption from this chapter by filing a cerlificate of election Lrnder
this seclion may not recover benefits or compensation under this chapter. Pursuant to Chapter 440.05(12), F.S., Certificates of election to be exempt... apply
only within the scope of the business or trade listed on the notice of election to be exempt. P!rsuant to Chapier 440.05(13), F.S., Notices of election to be
exemptand certjfcates ofelection tobe exempt shal be subjectto revocation if, atany lime afterthe filing ofthe noticeorthe issuanceofthe certificate, the
person named on the notice or certificate no longer meets the requirements of this seclion for issuance of a certjficate. The departmenl shall revoke a
certjlicale at any time for failure of lhe person named on lhe certificate to meet the requircmenls of this section.
DFS-F2-DWC-252 CERTIFICATE OF ELECTION TO BE EXEIVIPT REVISED 08-13 ouESTroNS? (850)4 1 3-1 609
JIMMY PATRONIS
CHIEF FINANICAL OFFICER
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 116 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
o.--c.-*..-r
I
5-0
OAF. I
FOrVI
,1727 SAN BERlrADltiO llAY
a
FL Saloi-r1:o
5 1966 Str F
1-t2'2o17 H(:.
'rt,t5.202a
E
t.:r 1-1t
a'L
I
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 117 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
e'r Cott*tljtt
(,1 rorvth Mana gement I)epartment
l'hnning & ll.ogulation
Operations Division
l,icensing Scction
February 7 ,2019
DARLEEN ROWE
3262 6OTH STREET SW
NAPLES, FL 34116
RE: WAIVER OF EXAMS
Ms. ROWE,
You have been added to the agenda for the Contractor Licensing Board meeting on
Wednesday, FEBRUARY 20,2019. Please attend the meeting so the board may review
your application packet to waive testing on your reinstatement application.
The meeting is held at 9:00am at the W. Harmon Turner Building (Bldg. F, Admin.
Bldg.), 3299 Tamiami Trail. E., Naples, FL 34112 in the Commissioner's Meeting Room
on the 3'd floor. There is a security checkpoint you will need to go through, so please
allow enough time to make it to the meeting.
lf you have any questions or concerns, please call (239) 252-2431 or you may email me
at contractorslicensing@colliercountyfl.gov.
Slnce
Davis
Administrative Supervisor
Contractor Licensing
Collier County Growth Management Department
2800 North Horseshoe Drive
Naples, FL 34104 5oe\ Eo"'<
USTOMER SIGNATURE
RE EI D
Growth Management Departmenl'Conlraclor Licenslng'2800 Norlh 9olseshoe Dnve'Naples. Ftorida 34104'239-252-24Oa.www co iergov fel
a/t tp
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 118 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
August 15, 2012
MINUTES OF THE
COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD
MEETING
August 15,2012
Naples, Florida
LET IT BE REMEMBERED that the Collier County Contractors' Licensing
Board, having conducted business herein, met on this date at 9:00 AM in
REGULAR SESSION in Administrative Building "F," 3rd Floor, Collier County
Government Complex, Naples, Florida, with the following Members present:
CT1AIRMAN:
Vice Chair:
Lee Horn
Richard Joslin
Michael Boyd
Terry Jerulle
Thomas Lykos
Robert Meister
Jon Walker
Excused:Kyle Lantz
Patrick White
ALSO PRESENT:
Michael Ossorio - Supervisor, Contractors' Licensing Office
James F. Morey, Esq. - Attomey for the Contractors' Licensing Board
Jeff Wright, Esq. - Assistant County Attomey
Rob Ganguli - Licensing Compliance Officer
Karen Clements - Licensing Compliance Officer
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 119 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
August 15,2012
and laws of Collier County. He stated the Respondent could have put a client and
the client's property at risk because there may not be adequate insurance protection
in the case of a problem.
Mr. Visser stated he was "quite willing to put it right and not buck the system."
Choirman Horn calledfor o vote and restated the Motion to uplrold the Citation.
Motion carried unanimously, 7 - 0.
Mr. Visser indicated he would file an appeal.
Attorney Morey advised Mr. Visser to consult with his counsel and asked the
County Attomey to provide information conceming the appeals process to the
Respondent.
B. l)arlene Rowe - Credit Re port(s)
Ms. Rowe explained she was appearing before the Board to qualify her company,
Dazzling Floors, Inc. (Trade: floor covering installation) The company has been in
business since I 999 in Florida but is new to Collier County.
Michael Ossorio stated:
. The application is for approval ofa floor covering license.
. The Applicant took and passed the Business Procedures Test.
o Ms. Rowe is licensed in other jurisdictions that do not require taking and
passing the Business Procedures Test.
. There was a question conceming her business credit report which is why the
application was presented to the Board.
Chairman Horn stated he had read Mr. Rowe's letter of explanation conceming the
2006 judgment against her company in the sum of $l1,269.00.
Ms. Rowe explained she has not yet paid anlthing on the judgment. At the request
of Vice Chairman Joslin, she reiterated the background conceming thejudgment.
She stated her company was subcontracted to install tile and was supplied the tile by
Destin Floors. There were no complaints about the workmanship. Approximately
lour months later, she was requested to replace the tile for free because the client's
wife changed her mind about the color and she refused.
When questioned about a collection on her personal credit report, she stated she had
undergone three surgeries and lost two houses to foreclosure.
Mr. Ossorio stated if a business has been open for l2 months or longer, more
emphasis is placed on the business credit report. He noted medical issues or a.
foreclosure was not an indication that a contractor could pay his/her business
expenses.
8
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 120 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
C
August 15,2012
Vice Chairman Joslin stated, in the past, the Board had approved granting a
probationary license when there were credit issues. He noted she had achieved an
8670 score on the Business Procedures Test as evidence ofher knowledge ofher
trade.
Ms. Rowe stated she had worked for Carpet One for l3 years in Okaloosa County,
Florida, without any problems.
Michael Ossorio stated the County recommended granting a probationary license
for six months. lf there are no problems at the end of the six month period, her
Certificate should be changed to "active status."
Thomas Lykos suggested a one year probationary period with review ofher credit
reports at six and twelve months to give her time to demonstrate some improvement.
Thomas Lykos moved to approve issuing a probationary licensefor a period of
twelve months, The Respondent will relurn to present her current business and
personal credit repotts lo the Board at six and twelve months. The Board will
make alinal determination concerning her license al the end of lhe probationary
period.
Second by Terry Jerulle. Canied unanimously, T - 0.
Jeff Yineline - Review Credit Report
Chairman Horn welcomed Mr. Yingling who was appearing to qualily the
companyJ "Paints & Coatings, Inc." He asked the Applicant if he knew a Frank
Jackson of North Port, Florida.
Mr. Yingling responded, "Yes."
Chairman Horn explained there were some minor discrepancies ("housekeeping
issues") conceming the Verification of Construction Experience that Mr. Jackson
submitted. He noted Mr. Jackson's Affidavit of lntegrity and Good Character was
also inconectly completed. He requested that Stalf review the documents.
Chairman Horn asked the Respondent to explain the Company's "maj or" credit
ISSUES.
Jeff Yingling stated:
. He and his partner began the company in 1994 and have devoted their time
to compliance and safety issues forjobs with confined spaces. They were
field-oriented and worked each job site.
o In 2008, the Office Manager and another employee were found to have
embezzled several hundred thousand dollars from the company, including
the theft ofpayroll tax deposits.
o The employees were fired, prosecuted by the State's Attomey, and convicted
ofFirst Degree Grand Theft -- they are serving sentences injail.
9
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 121 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
Findings of Fact Conclusions of Law and Decision of the Board
Collier County Contractors' Licensing Board
For Applications Submitted to the Board for Review
Type of Application:X Credit Report Review
Waiver of Testing Requirements
Reinstatement of License
Request to Qualify Second Entity
Other (specify)
1
293442.1 1t25t2012
THIS CAUSE came on for public hearing before the Contractors, Licensing Board
(hereafter Board) on August 15,2012, for consideration of the application submitted to
the Board for review. The type of application is set out above, The Board having heard
testimony under oath, received evidence, and heard arguments relative to all
appropriate matters, thereupon issues its Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and
Order of the Board as follows:
FINDTNGS OF FACT
1. That Darleen Rowe d/b/a Dazzling Floors, lnc. (the ?pplicant") has submitted an
application to the collier county contractor Licensing supervisor or his designee for a
Certificate of Competenoy as a Floor Covering lnstallation Contractor qnd based on the
credit reports supplied by the Applicant the Licensing superviser determined a review of
the credit by the Board is necessary.
2. That pursuant to section 2z-1a4(b) of the collier county contractors, Licensing
ordinance (ordinance 90-105, as amended) applications which do not appear on their
face to be sufficient require refen'al to the Board for a decision regarding approval or
denial of said application.
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 122 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
3. That the Board has jurisdiction over this mafter and that Darlene Rowe d/b/a
Dazzling Floors, lnc. was present at the public hearing on August 15, 2012, and was not
represented by counsel.
4. All notices required by Collier County Ordinance No. 90-105, as amended, have
been properly issued.
5. The facts in this case are found to be:
a. Appllcant has adequately demonstrated through testimony and evidence
presented at this hearing that her licensure will not result in risk of
economic loss resulting from the Applicant's ability to pay laMul
conlractual obligations, subject to her satisfaction of the terms set out
herein.
b. Credit report does not meet the standards of Florida Rule 61G4-15.006 for
Financial Responsibility.
c, lt is appropriate for thc Applicant to bo issucd a probotionary liconso and
subject to further credit review.
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Based upon the foregoing facts, the Board concludes that the applicant has met
the standard set out in ordinance 90-105, as amended, subject to the restrictions and
stipulations set out herein.
ORDER OF THE BOARD
1. Based upon the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, and
pursuant to the authority granted in chapter 489, Florida Statutes, and collier county
Ordinance No. 90-105, as amended, by a vote of I in favor and 0 opposed, a
2
253902.1 1k5t2012
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 123 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
unanimous vote of the Board present, the Applicant's credit report is approved so that a
license may be granted subject to the following conditions:
a. One year probationary license shall be issued;
b. Applicant is to provide updated business and personal credit reports to the
Contractor Licensing Supervisor six (6) months from the date of the
hearing held August 15, 2012 and one (1) year from the date of the
hearing lreld on August 15, 2012 and shall appear before the Board for a
review of the credit reports at the next regularly scheduled Board meeting
after submitting the reports.
ORDERED by the Contractors Licensing Board effective the 'lsth day of August,
2012.
CONTRACTOR'S LICENSING BOARD
COLLIER COU LORIDA;.F
,r. r-
By: Lee Horn, Chairman
I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy ot the above and toregoing
Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Order of the Board has been furnlshed the
Applicant, and Michael Ossorio, Licensing Qompliance Supervisor, 2800 North
Horseshoe Drive, Naples, FL 34103 ontnis,-1////th dayof August,2012.
ec ry/Contractor's Licensing Board
3
203902j 112512012
I
I
i
I
I
i
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 124 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
February 20, 2013
MINUTES OF THE
COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD
MEETING
February 20,2013
Naples, Ftorida
LET IT BE RBMEMBERED, that the Collier County Contractors' Licensing
Board, having conducted business herein, met on this date at 9:00 AM in
REGULAR.SESSION in Administrative Building "F," 3rd Floor, Collier County
Govemment Complex, Naples, Florida, with the following Members present:
Vice Chair: Patrick White
Terry Jerulle
Kyle Lantz
Thomas Lykos
Robert Meister
Jon Walker
Excused:Richard Joslin, Chair
Michael Boyd
Ronald Donino
ALSO PRESENT:
Michael Ossorio - Supervisor, Contractors' Licensing Office
Jeff Wright, Esq. - Assistant County Attomey
James F. Morey, Esq. - Attomey for the Contractors' Licensing Board
Rob Ganguli - Licensing Compliance Officer
Members:
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 125 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
February 20, 2013
VII. OLD BUSINESS:
A. Orders of the Boa rd
Kyle Lantz moved to dpprove authorix.ing the Vice Chairman to sign lhe Orders of
the Board. Second by Thomas Lykos. Csrried unanimously,6 - 0.
B. Darlccn Rowe - Review Credit Re port (6-month)
Michael Ossorio provided background information:
o Ms. Rowe was placed on probation six months earlier due to credit issues
. She has provided a current credit report as well as her past credit report
o No complaints have been filed against the company, "Dazzling Floors. Inc."
o The County recommends terminating the probation
Darlene Rowe:
o Since the credit report that was provided to the Board, three items were
removed
o Some items were listed in error
o Other items were paid
Thomas Lykos noted current report has improved and past due amounts were
reduced but the outstanding debt had increased.
Ms. Rowe explained she financed a vehicle for work.
Thomas Lykos stated the original Order of the Board imposed a l2-month
probationary period. While there has been progress, it was not substantial enough
to terminate probation earlier than initially ordered. He recommended adhering to
the original Order and reviewing her progress in six months.
Thomas Lykos moved lo approve accepting the current credil reporls and to
adhere to tlte original probationary period. The opplicant is ordered to appear
belore the Board in six months to present o current, updated credit report.
Second by Vice Chairman While. Carried unonimously, 6 - 0.
BREAK: l2:00 Noon
RESUMED: l2:07 PM
VIII. PUBLIC HIARINGS:
A. Case #2013-01:BCC vs. Brenton L. Mongan, d/b/a "Naples Property Pros"
Respondent, Brenton L. Mongan, was not present and was not represented by
Counsel.
Thomas Lykos stated, in the interests offull disclosure to the Board, that he knows
Brent Mongan through the Collier Building Industry Association ("CBIA"), but
has never conducted business with Mr. Mongan's company. He further stated his
objectivity will not be affected.
22
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 126 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
February 20,201,3
Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Decision of the Board
Collier County Contractors' Licensing Board
For Applications Submitted to the Board for Review
Fype of Application:X Credit Report Review
Waiver of Testing Requirements
Reinstatement of License
Request to Qualify Second Entity
Other (specify)
THls cAUsE came on for public hearing before the contractors' Licensing Board
(hereafter Board) on February 20,2013, for consideration of the application submitted to
the Board for review, The type of application is set out above. The Board having heard
testimony under oath, received evidence, and heard arguments relative to ali
appropriate matters, thereupon issues its Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and
Order of the Board as follows:
FINDINGS OF FACT
'1 . That Darleen Rowe d/b/a Dazzling Floors, lnc. (the "Applicant") had previously
submitted an application to the collier county conkactor Licensing supervisor or his
designee for a Certificate of Competency as a Floor Covering lnstallation Contractor
and based on the credit reports supplied by the Applicent the Licensing superviser
determined a review of the credit by the Board was necessary.
?, Tho Board proviouoly ioouod thc rcqucstcd license subjeut to a pr ul,ratiur rerry
period and a slx (6) month review period.
3. That pursuant to section 22-184(b) of the collier county contractors, Licensing
ordinance (ordinance 90-10s, as amended) applications which do not appear on their
307375.1 3/6/2013
1
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 127 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
face to be sufficient req uire referral to the Board for a decision regarding approval or
denial of said application,
4. That the Board has jurisdiction over this matter and that Darlene Rowe d/b/a
Dazzling Floors, lnc. was present at the public hearing on February 20,2013, and was
not represented by counsel.
5. All notices required by Collier County Ordinance No. 90-10S, as amended, have
been properly issued.
6. The facts in this case are found to be:
a. Applicant has adequately demonstrated through testimony and evidence
presented at this hearing that her licensure will not result in risk of
ecr.rrrornio loss resultlng from the Applicant's abtltty to pay lawful
contractual obligations, subject to her satisfaction of the terms set out
herein.
b. Credit report does not meet the standards of Florida Rule 61G4-15.006 for
Financial Responsibility.
c. lt is appropriate for the Applicant to be issued a probationary license and
subject to further credit review.
CONCLUSI ONS OF LAW
I . Based upon the foregoing facts, the Board concludes that the applicant has met
the standard set out in ordinance uu,1ub, as amended, subject to the restrictions arrcl
stipulations set out herein.
ORDER OF THE BOARD
2
307375.1 3t6/2013
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 128 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
1. Based upon the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, and
pursuant to the authority granted in Chapter 489, Florida Statutes, and Collier County
Ordinance No. 90-105, as amended, by a vote of 6 in favor and 0 opposed, a
unanimous vote of the Board present, the Applicant's credit report is approved so that a
license may be granted subject to the following conditions:
a. One year probationary license shall be issued;
b. Applicant is to provide updated business and personal credit reports to the
Contractor Licensing Supervisor six (6) months from the date of the
hearing held February 20,2013 and one (1) year from the date of the
hearing held on February 20,2013 and shall appear before the Board for
a review uf Ure credit reports at the next regularly scheduled Board
meeting after submitting the reports.
ORDERED by the Contractors Licensing Board effective the 20th day of
Feburary,2013.
CONTRACTOR'S LICENSING BOARD
OLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
?mqr 6.WAfg-J rL V\(kc,HA)B
I HFRFBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of tho abovo and forogorng
Firrr,lirrgr r.rI Far-:[, Cut rr-'lusit-,r ts ol Law, arrd Order of the BOard haS been fUrnlSh6d the
Applicant, and Michael Ossorio, Licensi s Supervisor, 2800 North
Horseshoe Dnve, Naples, l-L 34103 on this ebruary,2013
Sec Contractor's Licensing Board
th day of
34137513t6t2013
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 129 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
MINUTES OF THE MEETING
OF THE
COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARI)
February 19,2014
Naples, Florida
LET IT BE REMEMBERED, that the Collier County Contractors' Licensing
Board, having conducted business herein, met on this date at 9:00 AM in
REGULAR ^SESSION in Administrative Building "F," 3rd Floor, Collier County
Govemment Complex, Naples, Florida, with the following Members present:
Chairman:
Vice Chair:
Patrick White
Thomas Lykos
Members:Ronald Donino
Terry Jerulle
Richard Joslin
KyleLantz
Gary McNally
Excused:Michael Boyd
Robert Meister
ALSO PRESENT:
Michael Ossorio - Supervisor, Contractors' Licensing Office
Colleen Greene, Esq. - Assistant County Attorney
James F. Morey, Esq. - Attorney for the Contractors' Licensing Board
Rob Ganguli - Licensing Compliance Officer
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 130 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
February 19,2014
Chairman White stated the priority should be to resolve the larger amounts
either by payment or negotiated installment plan within three months.
Vice Chairman Lykos noted the two Midland accounts have not been paid, as
ordered by the Board. He suggested allowing the Applicant a period of six
months to adhere to the terms ofthe Board's order to avoid placing the Board's
Members in a position where it might be necessary to take action to revoke his
license.
Michael Ossorio noted the Respondent has pulled Permits and asked if he had
ever been issued a "Stop Work" Order for Building Permit issues.
,4. No.
Q. Have you pulled all necessary Building Permits to take care of your clients?
,4. Yes.
Terry Jerulle asked for a recommendation from the County.
Mr. Ossorio replied, "We'll see Mr. Dean in six months."
Vice Chairman Lykos noted the original Order of the Board placed the
Respondent on probation for a period of six months.
Richard Joslin stated the Applicant had made noticeable improvement.
Vice Chairman Lykos concurred Mr. Dean had made a substantial improvement
but had not fulfilled all olthe conditions ofthe Order. He stated whether the
Applicant is grant three or six months, if the terms ofthe Order have not been
followed at the end of the time period, he will advocate to revoke the license.
Richard Joslin supported extending the probation for another six months.
Vice Chairman Lykos moved to approve extending the probationary periodfor
six months and to require lhe Respondent lo fulJill the Order of the Board
dated August 21, 2013. The Respondent is to appear belore the Board in six
months. Ronald Donino offered a Second in support of the motion.
Carried unanimously,6 - 0.
C. Darleen Row - Six Month Credit Review
(l/b/a "DoTzling Floors, Inc.")
Michael Ossorio stated he has been unable to contact Ms. Row; a certified letter
was sent to her address in January, 2014, with no response; her phone has been
disconnected. Ms. Row was not present for the Hearing.
Coun R ndation: To revoke or s uspend Ms. Row's license
BREAK: 1l:32 AM
23
Vice Chairman Lykos moved to approve suspending the Collier County
CertiJicate of Competency as a Floor Covering Installation Contractor issued to
Darleen Row, d/b/a "Douling Floors, Inc." Terry Jerulle oflered o Second in
supporl of the Molion. Carried unanimously,6 - 0.
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 131 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
Findings of Fact, Conclusions ot Law and Decision ot the Board
Collier County Contractors' Licensing Board
For Applications Submitted to the Board lor Review
Type ol Application:X Credit Report Review
Waiver of Testing Requirements
Reinstatement of License
Other (specify) _
THIS CAUSE came on for public hearing before the Contractors' Licensing Board
(heroaftor Board) on February 19,2014, for a six month review of the Applicant's credit
report as set forth in a previous Order of the Board. The Board having heard testimony
under oath, received evidence, and heard arguments relative to all appropriate matters,
thereupon issues its Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Order ol the Board as
follows:
FINDINGS OF FACT
1. That Darleen Rowe d/b/a Dazzling Floors, lnc. (the "Applicant") had submitted an
application to the Collier County Contractor Licensing Supervisor or his designee for a
Certificate of Competency as a Floor Covering lnstallation Contractor and based on the
credit reports supplied by the Applicant the Licensing Superviser determined a review of
the credit by the Board was necessary.
2. Thal pursuant to Section 22-184(b) of the Code of Laws and Ordinances of
Collier County, Florida applications which do not appear on their face to be sufficient
require relerral to the Board for a decision regarding approval or denial of said
application.
Page 1 of 3
322557_13n12014
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 132 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
3. That the Board has jurisdiction over this malter and that Darlene Bowe was not
present at the public hearing on February 19, 2014, and was not represented by
counsel.
4. All notices required by the Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collier County,
Florida, have been properly issued.
5. The facts in this case are found to be:
a, Applicant did not supply an updated credit report and therelore has not
adequately demonstrated through lestimony and evidence that his
licensure will not result in risk of economic loss resulting from the
Applicant's ability to pay lawful contractual obligations.
b. An updated credit report was nol provided.
c. lt is appropriate (or the Applicant to be suspended at this time.
CONCLUSIONS O F LAW
1. Based upon the foregoing facts, the Board concludes that the applicant has not
met the standard set out in Section 22-184, Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collier
County, Florida.
ORDER OF THE BOARD
1. Based upon the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, and
pursuanl to the authority granted in Chapter 489, Florida Statutes, and the Code ol
Laws and Ordinances of Collier County, Florida, by a vote ol 6 in favor and 0 opposed,
a unanimous vote of the Board present, the Applicant's certiticate of competency is
hereby suspended.
Page 2 of 3
32255? .1 3t7 t201 4
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 133 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
ORDERED by the Contractors Licensing Board eflective the 19'h day ol
February,2014.
CONTBACTOR'S LICENSING BOARD
ER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By: P hite, Chairman
I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the above and foregoing
Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Order of the Board has been furnished the
Applicant, and Mr. Michael Ossorio, Lice Su rvisor, 2800 North
Horseshoe Drive, Naples, FL 34103 on this 2014.
ntractor's Licensing Board
Page 3 ol 3
322557 -1 3t7t201a
8.C.1
Packet Pg. 134 Attachment: Darleen Rowe - Rowe Flooring - Reinstatement with exam of exam & name change (8018 : DARLEEN ROWE – ROWE FLOORING
02/20/2019
COLLIER COUNTY
Contractor Licensing Board
Item Number: 9.A
Item Summary: CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT
OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE
Meeting Date: 02/20/2019
Prepared by:
Title: – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Lilla Davis
02/12/2019 12:12 PM
Submitted by:
Title: Supervisor - Operations – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Everildo Ybaceta
02/12/2019 12:12 PM
Approved By:
Review:
Contractor Licensing Board Lilla Davis Review Item Completed 02/12/2019 12:12 PM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Review Item Completed 02/12/2019 2:30 PM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Meeting Pending 02/20/2019 9:00 AM
9.A
Packet Pg. 135
Co ET County
COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD
FEBRUARY 20,2019
9:00 A.M.
ADMINISTRATIVE COMPLAINT - CASE 20.I8-10
STEPHEN L BOWLES - IVISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR
STEPHEN BOWLES is the License holder for his company JACKSON CUSTOM POOLS, LLC (DBA)
JACKSON POOL SERVICE. A Contractor Licensing case (CEM1S20160021439) was opened due to
a reporl of unpermitled pool construction at 5391 Tamarind Ridge Drive. A permit application was
submitted on 411812017. This permit now sits in a Void slatus, as it was originally re.jected, and Mr.
Bowles never submitted any corrections.
Mr. Bowles was originally in front of the board on December'19, 2018. The minutes from this meeting
are attached. Mr. Bowles was given 60 days to reapply and have the permit finaled. lf he didn't, he
needed to return to the Board and his permit pulling privileges from Collier County would be on hold
except for this permit plus we would send a letter to the state and recommend the maximum penally.
He is before the Board today to review his status with this permit and see if additional action will be
taken.
On Thursday, January 31st a representative from Jackson Pools was in our office to submit some
information. They were advised by Plans Reviewer Tim Rygiel the list of items that were needed in
order to submit the new permit. See attached letter from Mr. Rygiel about the interaction. A new
permit application (PRBD20190205517) was submitted on February 71h and is currently in Ready for
lssuance status as of February 1 1th.
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 136 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-
Gontents
December 19,2018 CLB lr/inutes
Original permit information for 5391 Tamarind Ridge Dr
First Correction Letter - April 26,2017
Second Correction Letter - June 29,2017
Tim Rygiel lnteraction from January 31st
New Permit PRBD201 9020551 7 Application
Emailfrom Jack Gumph to Mr. Bowles, CLB Reminder
Letter for Board Hearing
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 137 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
December 19, 201 8
MINUTES
OF THE COLLIER COUNTY
CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD
December 19,2018
Naples,, Florida
LET IT BE REMEMBERED that the Collier County Contractors' [.icensing
Board, having conducted business herein, met on this date at 9:00 AM in
REGIILAR SESSIONin Administrative Building "F," 3rd Floor, Collier County
Govemment Complex, Naples, Florida, with the following Members present:
Chairman:
Vice Chair:
Michael E. Boyd
Kyle E. Lantz
Mcmbers:Terry Jerulle
Richard Joslin
Robert Meister
Matthew Nolton
Excused: Patrick White
ALSO PRESENT:
Everildo Ybaceta - Supervisor, Contractors' Licensing Office
Kevin Noell, Esq. - Assistant Collier County Attorney
Jed Schneck, Esq. - Attomey for the Contractors' Licensing Board
Jack Gumph - Contractors' Licensing Compliance Officer
Reggie Smith - Contractors' Licensing Compliance Officer
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 138 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
December 19. 201 8
stating if the permits are not closed out within the next thirty days, we will
recommend to the County that he is to be reported to the State with terms like a
suspension ofhis license and a $10,000 fine.
Vice Chairman Lantz: You are saying to recommend that ilthe permits are
not closed out within the next thirty days, we request the maximum penalty possible?
Matthew Nolton: Something like that so that we're done with it and we haven't just
left it to chance to someone else - we've put in a penalty to the options.
Vice Chairman Lantz: Is that a Second with the amendment?
Matthew Nolton: It would be.
Vice Chairman Lantzz I will modifu my motion.
Vice Chairman Lantz movetl to:
o Continue lhe restrictions on the permit pulling privileges of Jeffrey Bumpus
currently in effect in Collier County until the remaining permils are closed;
. Approve concluding lhe Board's hearing of this case, and
. Approve directing Collier Counly Stoff to send a writlen recommendation to
the State's Construction Industry Licensing Board ("CILB") requesting
enforcement of the maximum penalties possible, i,e,, suspension of Jeffrey
Bumpus' license and imposing aJine of 510,000 if the remaining permits
are not closed out hrilhin thirty days.
Motthew Nolton ofered a Second in support of the molion.
Chairman Boyd calledfor a vote on the motion. Carried unanimously,6 - 0.
Chairman Boyd stated the case was closed.
X. PUBLIC HEARING:
A. Case 2018-10: Board of County Commissioners, Plaintiff, vs. Stcphen Bowles,
dlbla Jackson Poals, Respondent - Misconduct of a State-Certificd
Contractor
(fu1!s: The individuals who testified in thefollowing case under ltem X, "Public
Hearing," were Jirst sworn in b! the Attorney for the Board.)
Terry Jerulle: Mr. Chairman, my company has used Jackson Pools in the past. I
don't believe I know Mr. Bowles. I don't know if you know me.
Stephen Bowles: No, sir.
Terry Jerulle: It's been ten years or longer since I've used them. I am disclosing
this fact - I don't know that it would have any impact on my decisions or my thought
process.
Richard Joslin pointed out there are two "Jackson Pools" in business. There was a
Jackson Pool Construction and a Jackson Pool Service.
Stephen Bowles: We are Jackson Pool Service.
Terry Jerulle: Oh, then I take it back. My mistake. Thank you for pointing thal out.
2t
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 139 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
December 19. 2018
Chairman Boyd requested a motion to open the Public Hearing for Case #2018-10:
Board of County Commissioners, Plaintiff, vs. Stephen L. Bowles, dlbla Jackson
Pool Service,, Misconduct of a State-Certified Contractor,
Richartl Joslin moved to approve opening the Public Hearingfor Cose #2018-10 as
previously reference.l. Malthew Nolton offered a Second in supporl of te motion.
Carried unanimously,6 - 0.
Chairman Boyd outlined the process for the Hearing:
l. This Hearing will be conducted pursuant to the procedures set lorth in Collier
County Ordinance #90-105, as amended, ertd Florida Statutes Chapter 49.
2. The Hearing is quasi-judicial in nature and the Formal Rules of Evidence will not
apply.
3. Fundamental faimess and due process shall be observed and shall govern the
proceeding.
4. Irrelevant, immaterial, or inconclusive evidence shall be excluded but all other
evidence of the type commonly relied upon by reasonably prudent persons in the
conduct of their affairs shall be admissible u'hether or not such evidence would be
admissible in a trial in the courts of Florida.
5. Hearsay evidence may be used for the purpose of supplementing or explaining
any evidence but shall not be sufficient by itselfto support a Finding unless such
hearsay would be admissible or objected to in civil actions in court.
6. The Rules of Procedure shall be effective to the same extent that they would now
be hereafter recognized in civil actions.
7. The general purpose ofthe proceeding is for the County to set out its Opening
Statement which details its charges against the Respondent.
8. A Respondent may or may not make his,4rer Opening Statement setting out in
general terms the delenses to the charges.
9. The County then presents its Case in Chief, calling witnesses and presenting
evidence.
10. The Respondent may cross-examine these witnesses.
Chairman Boyd conlirmed the Public Hearing was open.
Jack Gumph, Contractor Licensing Compliance Officer, presented the County's
Opening Stalement:o The Respondent is a State-certified General Contractor and holder ofLicense
Number CPC1456438.. He is also registered in Collier County (#LCC20120001055) as a Certified
Pool/Spa Contractor.o On December 29,2016, Contractor Licensing Compliance Officer Rob
Ganguli performed a site visit at 5391 Tamarind Ridge Drive, Naples, Florida
341 19, in response to a complaint ol unpermitted pool construction.o Mr. Ganguli observed renovation work to an existing pool as well as
construction of a new spa unit.
22
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 140 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
December 19. 2018
. No permit had been issued. After it was determined that a permit was
required, Officer Ganguli posted a "Stop Work" Order at the site.
o The Contractor was Jackson Custom Pools, LLC d/b/a Jackson Pool Service
and Stephen L. Bowles was the Qualifier.o Jackson Pool Service was notified of the violation and the "Stop Work"
Order.
o A Notice of Non-Compliance was personally presented to Stephen Bowles
who signed the form on February 14,2017 acknowledging he had been
informed by Officer Ganguli of the permit violation against his license.
o In April 2017, a permit application was submitted. It was later rejected, and a
Correction Letter was sent.
o In June 2017 ,lhe permit application was still in rejected status; corrections
were submitted, and the permit was under review.
o In August 2017, the permit was still in rejected status; corrections were
submitted, and a Corrections Letter was sent.
. In October 2017, Stephen Bowles was sent a letter requesting a resolution of
the rejected status of the permit.
r In November 2017 , Mr. Bowles indicated during a phone conversation that he
was attempting to resolve the matter with the Building Department.
o ln March 2018, the permit application had expired and a notice was sent to the
license holder.
. In April 2018, the director ofJackson Pool Service stated the County had been
supplied with engineering reports in an effort to resolve the correction request.
o On August 10,2018, a Notice to Appear was sent via ce(ified mail to the
Qualifier. The hearing date was scheduled for October 17,2018.
r On August 14,2018, the mailing was "undeliverable" per the USPS.
o On August 15, 2018, a site visit to 5291 Tamarind Ridge Drive was conducted
and the work to the pool had been completed. Later the homeowner called
and stated the work has been completed by Jackson Pool Service because they
had told the homeowner the issues with the Stop Work Order had been
resolved.
o On August 20,2018, the Notice to Appear was delivered and delivery was
conlirmed by USPS.
o On October 16,2018, Stephen Bowles requested a copy of the information
packet to review and the case was rescheduled to December 19,20i8.
. The permit remains in VOID stafus because corrections were never submitted.
. Stephen Bowles is in violation of Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as
amended, Section 4.2.2 which states "Willfully violating the applicable
Building Codes or laws of the state, city, or Collier County."
Chairman Boyd asked Stephen Bowles ilhe had a response
23
Stephen Bowles stated:. He has been a pool contractor in Florida since 1994.o He has built approximately 8,000 to 10,000 pools - permitted.
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 141 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
December 19. 2018
. h25 years, he has never been involved in "anything like this."
o On July 12,2016, he signed a contract with the homeowner to remodel an
existing pool and spa that had been built in 1982.
. The spa was flush with the pool deck, but the homeowner wanted to raise the
existing spa by eighteen inches.
. The spa was raised, the plumbing was extended, and new tile was installed on
the deck. New lights, a new pump and filter were also installed.
. "lt's a cut and dry situation that has been done hundreds of time in this
County."
. He did not think a permit was required to remodel an existing poo['
o Other remodeling work was being done to the to the home at the same time.
o The inspector saw the pool and said a permit was required.
. He was contacted and told a permit was necessary. He did not understand
why a permit was required to remodel an existing pool and spa. There was no
new construction.
. He began the process to puli a permit.
. The work was completed so there was nothing to inspect but he tried to
accommodate the Building Department. He supplied letters from an engineer
and other documentation.
o He felt his attempts to come into compliance were being "stonewalled" by the
County. He spent thousand ofdollars and is "in the red on the project." He
hired engineers to supply letters and to inspect the site.
. He has had "zero" complaints made against his company.
. He has no idea what else he can do to satisfy the Building Department.
Richard Joslin questioned the Applicant:
Q. How did you change the bonding?
.4. We didn't change the bonding.
Q. You raised it?
,4. No, sir.
Q. You said it was flush.
..4. The spa was.
Q. The spa. How did you raise i1?
l. We formed it and poured concrete around it?
Q. Did youput sealant around it?
,4. Yes, sir.
Q. You said this was an existing pool with a flush spa?
,4. Yes, sir.
Q. How did you change the plumbing?
.4. We extended it up.
Q. You had to pre-plumb it to do that?
.4. tught.
Q. How did you do the pressure test?
,4. We pressure tested it.
Q, Who inspected it?
l. There was no inspection.
24
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 142 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
December 19, 2018
Q. My point. There was also a sun shelf added to it or was it already there?
l. Well, the pool was there. The sun shelf was put inside the pool. No, there was no
sun shelf there. We added it there - it's all one big chunk with no sealing - it's
just sitting inside the pool.
Q. So that was part of the pool at one point?
,4. Right, but not a sun shelf.
Q. You raised up the spa? The beam?
,4. Right, yes, sir.
Terry Jerulle: Excuse me, Mr. Joslin. Mr. Bowles, did you go to the County at the
beginning ofthe proj ect and ask if you needed a permit?
,4. No, sir.
Q. It would seem to me - and I'm not an expert in pools - that you're notjust
remodeling the pool ... you're adding to the pool. By raising the beam ofthe spa,
you're adding to the it.
l, Yes, sir.
Q. And in remodeling, it's incumbent upon us, as contractors, to know that we need
permits.
,4. Well, that's a grey area.
Q. You can argue that, okay. But to me, it's not so much of agreyareaandif it was
a grey area as you admitted - the first step is to go to the County and ask if a
permit is needed.
l. Right -- you're absolutely right.
Q. It's black and white. Maybe you don't. But if it's a grey area, you go to the
County and ask.
,4. Based on my building pools and pulling permits since '94, this is done hundreds
of times. Even here - it's probably being done right now as we're talking.
Q, And you know the Codes have changed in the last ...
,4. Yes, sir.
p. ... since you got your license, the Codes have changed several times.
,4. Right.
Q. Okay? So, you can't say what you did ten or twenty years ago is the same thing
that you can do today.
Richard Joslin:
Q. Also, on the permifting section of it - years ago you didn't have to have the
hydraulic plumbing engineered and today you do.
,4. Well, all the plumbing is under the ground. I cannot do - it's existing.
Q. Not all of it.
,4. Just the spa - the spa - yes, you're right.
Q. I'm talking about an engineer coming in and telling you ifthe line sizes are right
for the volume that is going to go through to the jets which would be part ofthe ...
the engineer would do that when you apply for a permit. They would look at that.
This is the reason why it's a grey area because things have changed since '94.
And that's the reason why you're here. Like Terry said, I think it is up to you to
take a little more responsibility - to go in there and get the permit ... or at least ask
25
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 143 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
December 19,2018
the question - do I need a permit or is it just like any other renovation? There
area a lot of people now who are draining pools and resurfacing. Some of them
need a permit. That's the way I would treat any kind of ...
,4. And I did evaluate that like you said. But based on the criteria of today and I
came to the conclusion there as no permit involved ... based on - not back then -
but on what's going on today. And I'm paying the price for it because I comply.
I comply. I'm not the guy out there who's not complying. And this one -
obviously, I missed it - I slipped and I'm paying the cost for it. But I did not
"willfully" do that. It was not intentional or willful. I did not try to defraud the
permit - it's just not that situation. Now I'm trying to comply, but I don't know
how to satisfy the Building Department unless I tear the pool to pieces and let
them see the steel.
Jack Gumph requested to submit the information pack presented to the Board in
Case #2018-10 into evidence as Countv's Exhibit "A."
Vice Chairman Lonlz moved to approve accepting the Counr!'s information packet
in Case #2018-10 and entering it into evidence. Terr1, Jerulle offered a Second in
support of lhe motion. Carriecl unanimously, 6 - 0.
Terry Jerulle:
Q. When did the homeowner start the renovation - before you started the pool or
after?
,4. He started the renovations on his house about the same time ... a little before, I
guess.
Q. So, that leaves me to believe that you, at that time, didn't willfully try to do
anything wrong because you knew there would be inspectors there.
.4. Yes, sir.
Q. That leaves me to believe that you thought you were doing the right thing at the
time. But the problem is when the County did inform you that you did need a
permit and you didn't follow through the steps to get it. To me, that's the
problem.
,4. I did.
Q. Before that, I don't think you "willfully" - in my opinion - didn't willfully try
to cheat but what I think you didn't do is what the County has been asking you
26
Richard Joslin continued:
Q. Since you found out a long time ago -- months ago -- that you did need a permit,
or you were asked to obtain a permit for thisjob to complete, but you didn't.
.4. Yes, sir, I have.
Q. This has gone on ...
A. lhave. Ilyou would see the paper trail ... you would see that I have been trying
to resolve this matter. And you're right ... the last permit application ... I got to a
wall and they wanted ... I don't know what they want now ... if I can get
clarification ofexactly what is needed ... I'm here to comply ... I mean, there's no
reason not to.
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 144 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
December 19, 2018
to do after the fact. And another question is - if you had found out before you
started that you needed to get a permit, would you not have charged the client
more money?
,4. Would I have charged the client more money ...
Q. Correct.
,4. ... for a permit ... absolutely.
Q. So why wouldn't you go back to the client now and ask him for more money?
.4. Because...
Q. Because if it wasn't included - and I apologize -
,4. We'd gotten to the point where ...
Q. ...br;r. if it wasn't included in the price in your bid to begin with because you
didn't know and now it is ... that may be enough ... and I'm saying that because
you need to comply.
,4. Yes, sir.
Q. You need to go though the steps and it's going to cost you more money and that
may be one ofthe reasons why you gave up.
.4. We've not sent him a bill for this - we're eating it - I would not do my client like
that because it fell on me, not him.
Q. That's your business decision.
,4. fught.
Q. But the point is that we have an outstanding permit that needs to be taken care of
and you kind ofgave up on it.
A. You're right - I did give up ...
Q. And you can't do that.
,4. See, I gave up - not really gave up - I just got to a wall. I didn't know what else
to submit.
Q. Well, they listed it for you and it was pretty clear.
A. I got it. I gave everlthing ... everything that they've wanted, I've complied with.
And the last - to my recollection - the last correspondence with them was, 'we
want to know how the inspector or engineer came to his conclusion.' I don't
know ifthey want him to radar the steel or what - but that's where I'm at.
Vice Chairman Lantz:
p. The pictures that you show here show the pool clearly under construction - right?
,4. Yes, sir.
Jack Gump noted Jonathan Walsh, the Chief Building Official, was in attendance
and could address the issue.
Chairman Boyd stated the Applicant was presenting his case and after the Board
could hear from the County.
p. We have pictures here of the pool under construction. This is about the point
when you got the "Stop Work" Order - right? And they said you need to pull a
permit to continue.
,4. Yes, sir.
Q. How did we get here to pictures later showing a beautiful pool and beautiful
27
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 145 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
deck without getting a permit? How do we get from don't do any work until you
get a permit to a completed pool and we still don't have a permit? How? That's
my question.
,4. The "Stop Work" Order was lifted once we applied for a permit.
Q. So. when you applied lor a permit ...
,4. Because I would never have kept going with that - it was lifted, or I would never
... so, the "Stop Work" was lifted once we applied for the permit. There are no
more inspections left from that point until the final. Once we pulled the permit,
we had to get an Engineer's letter to get to what you saw before it was finished.
There's no more perrnit other than the final permit and the final plumbing. We
went ahead and finished the pool because there were no more inspections until the
end. All the other - the previous inspections that we didn't get were going to be
in the Engineer's letter, so we went ahead and finished the customer's pool. I
mean. it's a beautiful pool.
Q. This "Stop Work" Order says in Remarks, "Must obtain required permits prior to
continuing any further work." It doesn't say, "Must apply for" - it says, "Must
obtain." If you had to expose something, it would be pretty easy to do it when
you were in - clearly, you wouldn't want to chip up any concrete, but it would be
a lot less expensive to chip concrete before you had any product on top of it -
right?
Richard Joslin:
C. At that time, the actions should have stopped because you did not obtain the
permit - you just applied for it.
,4. Well, we did obtain a permit.
Q. The permit was applied for on April 28,2017. Then it went into "rejected starus."
Did you bother to check to see if the permit - why was it rejected?
,4. It was because we didn't get inspected before we raised the spa, and that was
rejected - you're right. And then I was told we needed a letter from the Engineer
saying the steel and plumbing were correct.
Q. There is something on June 26th - the permit was still in "rejected status" for
corrections that were sent to you. Meanwhile, the pool was still continuing to be
built.
,4. Right.
Vice Chairman Lantz:
Q. You said the permit was issued?
,4. It was issued. It's been two years ... I might be ... my memory. So, then that was
another rejection because we didn't have a barrier ... a barrier affidavit with the
pool. That don't exist-the pool was built in 1982. The Department found out
that's in age [the term is "grandfathered"] ... we can't make them put up a cage or
put a banier up on a pool that was already built in 1982 - and the yard is fenced
around. That went on for a couple of months.
Richard Joslin:
Q. But if you were going to re-permit or submit a permit for a brand-new
December 19. 2018
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 146 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
December 19. 2018
spa - basically that's what happened and why you are here - the you would have
to comply with today's laws - not whatever happened to the pool in whatever
year you're talking about.
,4. I can't say for sure on that - that's what I was told - that's why to this day there is
no barrier, there is nothing... the County dropped that. They said, 'okay, we're
not going to push the barrier.' It was out. I don't know where I'm at or what I
need to do. I mean, we can go back - the damage is done, like you said - I made
a mistake. I want to correct it because I comply. I'm a pool guy and I have a
passion for this. And when we don't comply with each other - that's what breaks
the whole system down. I'm that guy who complies and thrives on that. And in
25 years - with this one, I got zapped - and there's nobody to blame but me and I
accept that. I want to make it right. We could go back and forth we "he said/she
said" but I'm here at your mercy - I screwed up and that's the bottom line. I
should have done better - that falls on me. About my work, I know far as it
comes to procedures here - I've built ten thousand pools and Collier County
literally has more pools that are literally brand new that falling apart - cracking in
half. This guy [indicating Richard Joslin] knows what I'm talking about. I have
never seen nothing like it in my life. I've done ten thousand pools and none of
them have cracked - none of them have fallen apart. I put twice the rebar - they
don't even put seven bars anymore with a wrap around them. They don't put on
six inches center - two feet down - that's why all the pools crack from the top.
When it comes to the structure and the rebar of this pool, it's unsurpassed - that's
what I do. The weakest part of the pool is the top of the pool. And that's where
I'm at, guys - whatever you come up with. I just ask you to look at that. I've
been a licensed pool builder here for 25 years and never had a complaint.
Chairman Boyd: Thank you, sir. Are there any questions for Mr. Bowles? [There
were none.] Jack, any rebuttal?
Jack Gumph: I'd like to call Jonathan Walsh and Tim Riegle for the Board to
question.
Jonathan Walsh, Chief Building Official, stated the case started from an inspection
of the residence. The inspector noticed that the pool was being remodeled and I
believe we asked Contractors' Licensing to send an lnvestigator out to open the case
and subsequently asked il a permit was required. A "Stop Work" Order was issued.
As it stated, the permit was to be issued - not applied for. It has never been applied
for. If anlthing, he would have been given an allowance to make the site safe while
the permitting process was underway. He never should have moved forward without
the permit being issued.
Chairman Boyd: So, a permit has never been issued?
Jonathan Walsh: Not for the pool.
Richard Joslin: As of today?
Jonathan Walsh: Today it is in "void" status.
Richard Joslin: Did the inspector for the home renovation know that pool was being
renovated as well as the illegal spa?
29
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 147 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
Matthew Nolton: Mr. Bowles, what prevented you from responding or submitting
additional information?
Stephen Bowles: To be honest with you, I really can't recall. I went down there
over and over, and I thought we were in compliance and then he sent this back. I
don't ... it got to be such a mess. I guess why I went ahead and finished the pool - to
be honest with you - ill hadn't, it would probably be sitting there with that Ii.e.,
unfinished] today because I would have been waiting on the permit. That's no excuse
30
December 19. 2018
Jonathan Walsh: To begin with, the spa would be a separate permit. It would not
be included in the house permit.
Richard Joslin: If it was just a plan renovation, a permit would not have been
necessary - correct?
Jonathan Walsh: A pool can be re-surfaced without a permit - that's allowed. But
they added steel and concrete - they affected the plumbing - all require a permit. My
largest concem on this construction is the steel not being grounded - not being
bonded. Since this pool is also an older pool - as you know - it probably doesn't
have the proper suction requirements which is also another concern. Regarding the
barrier requirement, we did agree that the property's fence provided a level of
protection, the existing pool not being modified. We agreed there were no increases
regarding life/safety concerns, so we allowed the barrier requirement not to be
applied because it wasn't a new pool - it was an existing pool.
Matthew Nolton: Why was the permit never issued - what was missing? What data
was missing?
Jonathan Walsh: I didn't do the review, so I'm going to let Tim answer that
question.
Tim Riegte: I did the second review which was initially rejected because an affidavit
was submitted and not an Engineer's letter. I tried to be as clear as possible in the
Corrections Letter concerning what was required to be included in the Engineer's
letter, i.e., the date and time when the Engineer performed the site inspection and how
he performed the inspection to resolve the issues. It was a steel inspection and there
are multiple methods of inspection that could be used. I spelled it out as specifically
as I could. As you know, we haven't received anything back after I send the second
rejection.
Matthew Nolton: How would that prevent you from issuing a permit? That's a
missed inspection that would need some kind of investigation to do the inspection
after+he-fact. Would that prevent you from issuing a permit?
Tim Riegle: In this case because it was an after-the-fact permit, we were asking for
what inspection the Engineer's letter was going to cover and ifany additional
inspections were going to be needed and added to the permit.
Matthew Nolton: So. you treated it as an after-the-fact process at that time?
Tim Riegle: Yes.
Matthew Nolton: And is that where it fell apart - when you didn't get any additional
information or data?
Tim Riegle: There was never a response to the second colrection letter. At that
point, the plans would sit in a folder waiting for a response from the contractor before
it would be sent out for a second review.
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 148 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
Decembcr 19, 2018
but it slipped - I'm not going to make an excuse. I don't know how I didn't get ... I
was at a stonewall ...
Matthew Nolton: Excuse me but that's a separate issue - whether you continued to
work when you should not have continued to work. What I'm trying to understand is
- no, I don't hear "stone wall" - I hear they said, 'this is what you need to have,' and
then there was no further communication ... is what I hear.
Chairman Boyd: By the looks of it, you had it done. All you had to do was to go
back to the Engineer and stamp the letter with the date he inspected it. Ray Allen
Electric Service said it performed an electrical inspection. Atlas Design and
Engineering did an inspection of the pool plumbing equipment and the rebar. But
then the County asked them for the specific dates when it was done. So, it was all
done - you just didn't lollow up on it.
Stephen Bowles: And then, again, I don't know how that slipped right there. I'm
not going to blame it on nobody but me. I don't have an answer for you on why that
last notice he sent - why I didn't - I don't have an answer. I won't make up an
excuse. For some reason - it must have been something because if it would have
been that simple - what we just talked about - I would have done it. It makes no
sense to me and like I said - it's been two years. According to him, if I had just one
more letter from the Engineer with the date, time, and how he did it - this would have
all been over?
Chairman Boyd: Basically, yes.
Matthew Nolton: Is that correct?
Jonathan Walsh: It's not that simple ...
Chairman Boyd: ln the last corrections letter, all you asked for ... "The Engineer's
letter must include (l) the Permit number and sile oddress" -- that's no big deal.
" (2) Specific inspection performed with the corresponding Collier County Inspection
number: (3) Date and time the inspection was performed; (1) Method of inspection to
justify determination and resolution of the missed inspeclion."
Jonathan Walsh: This letter did not state 'how.'
Chairman Boyd: If the Engineer did the inspection, he should know how he did it.
Jonathan Walsh: The way it's written currently, this letter did not state that.
Chairman Boyd: I understand that.
Matthew Nolton: Let me ask the County - if Mr. Bowles would have followed up
and if he would have done whatever he needed to, we wouldn't be here right now.
Jonathan Walsh: The letter from the Engineer would have resolved - for practical
purposes - the rough inspections and then we would have iollowed up with the finals.
Matthew Nolton: Right. As you know, I'm an Engineer and we've done inspections
like this. We send photos, and we send when we did it, and we send biometric testing
for continuity, and we send all that, so we can justify that it was built the way it was
supposed to be built.
Vice Chairman Lantz: So, if he gets his Engineer to do a good inspection or a fixer
inspection - whatever that is - and if he calls the Engineer and gets a letter that
satisfies what you need, then what's the process from there?
Jonathan Walsh: He would have to re-apply lor the permit and pay whatever
outstanding lees there are; the old permit would go into "cancelled" status; the new
3l
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 149 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-
December 19. 2018
permit application would still need to address the comments; the Engineer's
inspection and, unfortunately. I'm not too sure how he would do a continuity test
on something that is finished. But that's not my problem.
Vice Chairman Lantz: Let's just say the Engineer does all that - he pays the fees
and re-applies. Then does the County go back out and perform a final inspection?
Jonathan Walsh: Yes, because the letter was only to cover the "rough" inspection.
Vice Chairman Lantz: He'll get the lefter from the Engineer and he'll do whatever
he has to do, then the permit will be issued, and he will call in for a final inspection.
Jonathan Walsh: Yes.
Vice Chairman Lantz: Mr. Bowles, do you understand that?
Stephen Bowles: Absolutely. Yes, sir.
Vice Chairman Lantz: I'm sure there's more than one Engineer in town who knows
how to do that.
Stephen Bowles: We've got the Engineer's letter already, but it wasn't written with
the date and time and so forth.
Vice Chairman Lantz: Theoretically you've already paid for it and youjust have to
ask him ...
Stephen Bowles: Yes, sir.
ISeveral comments were made concerning how the Engineer would conduct the
different required tests - the speakers were talking over each other. The homeou'ner
stated the only thing he wanted was a Code-compliant pool.]
Stephen Bowles: Can I just make one more statement now that calmness has
prevailed. If this was a simple as we are sitting here saying and everybody is saying,
I am looking you guys [Staffl in the eye and I am telling you, I would have done that.
If this is why it came to this point - why I am at this hearing - because of some
discrepancies on a letter? We're missing something. You can tell that I'm the type
ofguy that - man - I would have been all over that - ifthat's all it was. But I'm not
going to get into a bunch of ''stuff' that is not going to change anlthing. I am telling
you guys - if that was as simple as it is now - when this was going on - it would have
been a done deal. lt's too easy - it'sjust too easy to be true, but if it is, I can have
that done before the day is out.
Matthew Nolton: Mr. Bowles, it is true that we're here because the permit had not
been taken care ofand ...
Stephen Bowles: Right.
Matthew Nolton: ... communication with the County had stopped. The County had
no way to move this forward other than by this methodology - this process - that
we're going through right now. Is it a simple process? It is basically a simple
process to do what is asked. You do not have to tear out the whole pool. You may
have to jackhammer some stuff, you may have to expose or reinforce some steel,
There are ways to do it and do the continuity testing. There are ways to do it but you
stopped. You didn't pursue. What we're hearing is you didn't figure out how to do
this because you don't remember it. The County says there was no communicalion
from you.
Chairman Boyd: Sir, you are out oforder. Ifyou want to address the Board,
32
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 150 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
December 19. 2018
you can come up and be swom in. Thank you. And you are? Come up and
be swom in, please. State your name, please.
Richard Hudec, General Manager, Jackson Pool Service: What Steve is trying to
say is we were at the County. What we don't want to do is get into odds with the
Permitting Department in a "he said/she said." I personally met with Rob Ganguli, I
tried to see Jon probably three times - Jon would not come out of his office. I spoke
to Fred, I spoke to the County Zoning Commissioner, but he [Jonathan Walsh] is
impossible to talk to. Impossible. The guy will never, ever talk to you. I don't want
to air dirty laundry - I just want to build pools and renovate pools and clean pools and
fix pools. I have personally been down there no less than five times. Steve has been
down there how many times? Ten times. If you want to get into it. then let's get into
it. I saw Jack, I just called Andy - my County Commissioner ... you know Andy.
right?
Terry Jerulle: Excuse me a second ... we not getting into it ... you're providing
testimony to ...
Richard Hudec: I'm a contractor...
Terry Jerulle: Now calm down and provide it. We have nothing to do with it ...
IMr. Hudec was visibly upset.]
Richard Hudec: All Jon had to do was call us ... there's a thing ...
Terry Jerulle: Calm down.
Richard Hudec: ... person called a gentleman .... be a gentleman - call us and say,
'all you need is this letter.' Do you guys really think... we've built thousands of
pools. Some ofyou guys sitting here are sophisticated guys ... do you really believe
that we would be here over a letter from an Engineer that I could have had in twenty
minutes? Here's the homeowner, Todd Jacobs. How many times have I ever not
called you back, Todd?
Terry Jerulle: We can't take testimony ...
Richard Hudec: Here's the homeowner - we've talked to him several times and
he's a contractor. His family has been in this town for fifty years. We've never not
complied with one thing. I just had a situation with Jon Walsh - a family was moving
into their home last Friday - weren't they, Jon? They needed a temporary C of O to
move into their house and you said you were too busy to do it. So, I got Dick to do it
and he did it in five seconds because you didn't want to come out ofyour office.
Terry Jerulle: That has nothing to do with this case.
Chairman Boyd: Enough, it has nothing to do with this case.
Richard Hudec: Do you want me to file a formal complaint with the County
Commissioner when I leave here?
Terry Jerulle: Thal is separate and not testimony for this case.
Richard Hudec: That is my testimony. You guys should know as the Board how
things are being handled in your County.
Chairman Boyd: Most of us are contractors.
Richard Hudec: Wel[ - so you know. If you apply for a permit, it should be
handled professionally.
Richard Joslin: I'm apool contractor, sir.
Richard Hudec: I know who you are.
33
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 151 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
Decernber 19. 2018
Richard Joslin: Thirty-five years - right here - there's never been a time when you
should not know and check your permits to see ifthey have been issued - that's
number one.
Richard Hudec: I know but when you make a mistake - no, we made a mistake
Richard Joslin: You can't wait for Jon to come and tell you ...
Richard Hudec: ... and then we tried to fix it, but we couldn't get it fixed after the
fact. I admit to the mistake. I'm not blaming Jon for the mistake - we made the
mistake without question. But we could not get it fixed. I went down there five
times. I talked to the plumbing guy. I said, 'okay - what exactly do you want?' I
could never get a straight answer. Then it was the barrier and we got the barrier
waived. Jon was kind enough to waive that. But I'm telling you - whatever you
want us to do, we'll do it. Jack drove the packet to my office the other day. We don't
duck anybody - we're not hiding from anybody. I spend $20,000.00 a month in
advertising. We don't hide from anybody. But if we need to fix it, we'll fix it.
Richard Joslin: We're not trying to tell you how to run your business or how you do
run your business - we're only saying that the permit was not issued. Number one -
that's the priority. And as many pools as you've told us that you've built - and I'm
not doubting that you have - they all had the same inspection cards - they all had the
same things that are necessary for inspection - that's what you missed. Those
inspections were not done.
Richard Hudec: I understand that ...
Richard Joslin: You go after+he-fact and try to get them done. There is a way.
You find a way to get them done. If you would have stopped as the "Stop Work"
Order said, you could have followed through, went back in there and asked,'how do I
get this done ... what does my Engineer need?' It's not up to him to call you. He
gave you the scenario ofwhy you needed it - you guys should have planned to get it
done. And you did not.
Richard Hudec: But that's not true - it's not true.
Richard Joslin: It is, sir, otherwise you would have done it.
Steven Bowles: [He was not standing close enough to the microphone ior his
comments to be fully recorded.] ... what you see here looks deceiving. Ilthat was
really all it was - we wouldn't be here - we would have done that. If you look at that,
you will see that something is not right. You mean to tell me, guys, y'all spent
thousands of dollars and y'all went through all ofthis and then youjust stopped at
that last lefter? It don't add up.
Terry Jerulle: Excuse me, sir. The only thing that we can think is what you present.
What you are presenting ....
Assistant County Attorney Noell: Sir, sir, sir - il you can not speak over the Board
members as they are addressing you. And if you can wait until the Board addresses
you with a question so we can have proper decorum, okay? Thank you.
Terry Jerulle: The only thing that I have in front of me is the last letter from the
County stating what you needed to do to complete the permit application. I have
nothing else from you. If I had documentation from you or a letter from you, it could
help you with your case. But I don't have an).thing.
Richard Hudec: I'll find some stuff - I didn't look... we didn't think it was going
to be a big deal ... all we need to do is get the letter from the Engineer and ifJon
j,t
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 152 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
December 19, 2018
Chairman Boyd: Gentlemen, are you done presenting your case.
Jonathan Walsh: That's all the County has.
Chairman Boyd: May I have a motion to close the Public Hearing?
Richard Joslin moved to approve closing the Public Hearingfor Case #2018-10.
Matlhew Nolton offered a Second in support of the motion.
Carried unonimously, 6 - 0.
Vice Chairman Lantz: (directed to the Respondent and the witness) Please
have a seat. You can't leave but vou can sit.
35
says. 'good luck with that' ... like you said, it's not hard to do.
Terry Jerulle: Certain parts of it aren't hard, I understand the pressure ...
(Mr. Hudec and Mr. Jerulle are talking at the same time - difficult to separate
the comments.)
Assistant County Attorney Noell: Sir, sir, sir - please, the same instruction for you
as a witness. When you testifu before this Board, you cannot speak over the Board
member as he is addressing you. Wait until he is finished talking and if you have a
comment or ilhe asks a question and you want to respond, then you may do so at that
time. We're making a record of this proceeding and lor it to be clear, we can't speak
over each other. Okay?
Richard Hudec: Okay.
Assistant County Attorney Noell: Thank you.
Terry Jerulle: What I believe Mr. Nolton was referring to is the steel in the bottom
and I think there's still the pressure test that must be done - from my understanding.
Richard Hudec: That's easy enough.
Stephen Bowles: (He was too far from the microphone - his comments were not
recorded in full.) .... it should be cut and dry... (his remaining comments were not
captured.)
Terry Jerulle: From our point of view, sir, we have the history that you've agreed to
- that you made a mistake. You needed to get a permit to remove the "Stop Work"
Order which you didn't get. Work proceeded - which was another mistake. That's
two mistakes. All we have is a letter saying what you must do to get the permit. I
have no documentation that you have done any'thing after that. As I said earlier, it
appears that you gave up. I'm not saying that you did or didn't - I'm just saying from
the information that was presented to us in this case, it appears that you had given up.
It is incumbent upon you to provide testimony or evidence that you didn't.
Stephen Bowles: (He was too far from the microphone - his comments were not
recorded in full.) ... you guys are absolutely right ... you guys are seeing what you're
seeing ... I gave up, kinda/sorta because ... I'm not going to go there ... but anyway,
we're all on the record - no matter how this winds up today - we're all on the record
stating ...
Terry Jerulle: That record has been there for a while ... if you understand what I'm
saying.
Stephen Bowles: (He was too far from the microphone - his comments were not
recorded in full.) ... I don't want to do that ... I don't know if he accepts everything.
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 153 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
December 19. 2018
Chairman Boyd: I guess we can start our deliberation on whether or not he's guilty
Case #2018-10: Stephen L. Bowles, Jackson Pool Service.
Matthew Nolton: Well, for me, personally, it's fairly simple if he's guilty or not.
Yes, he did work without a permit and continued to do work without a permit. A
permit still has not yet been issued. I don't know why we have to deliberate.
Terry Jerulle: The first stage is finding whether he is guilty or not guilty.
Vice Chairman Kyle Lantz moved to approve finding lhe Respondent, Stephen
L. Bowles, guilty of the violation of Counlt Ordinance 2006-46, as amended,
Section 4.2.2, "Misconduct of a State-Certified Controctor," as slaled in the
Administrative Complaintfor "llillfully violating the applicable Building Codes
or laws of the state, city, or Collier Counry+'." Matthew Nolton offered a Second
in support of the motion.
Chairman Boyd asked if any discussion was needed. ll/ith no response from the
Board, he calledfor a vole on lhe molion.
Carried unanimously,6 - 0.
Chairman Boyd deferred to the Board's Attorney.
Attorney Schneck: For the penalty phase for a State-certified contractor, as in the
Bumpus case, the Board is limited to denying, suspending, or revoking his permit-
pulting privileges in Collier County or limiting his ability to pull permits under
specific conditions. The second part ofthe penalty phase is the recommendation that
the Board can sent to the State's Construction Industry Licensing Board ("CILB") for
further action. When considering these penalties, the Board should also consider the
testimony and all the evidence presented, as well as:
. The gravity ofthe violation;
o The impact of the violation on the public health./safety/welfare;
. Any actions taken by the violator to correct the violations;
. Any previous violations committed by the violator; and
. Any other evidence presented at the Hearing relevant to the Sanctions which are
appropriate to the case, given the nature ofthe violation.
36
Terry Jerulle: Mr. Bowles, do you want to complete the permit application?
Stephen Bowles: Yes, sir.
Terry Jerulle: And il you complete the permit application, do you think you can
comply with the terms written on the permit?
Stephen Bowles: Yes, sir.
Terry Jerulle: How long do you think it will take you to complete it?
Stephen Bowles: Thirty days - by the end ofJanuary.
Terry Jerulle: Thirty days and by the end ofJanuary are two different time frames.
I do know that Christmas is coming. I'm asking you.
Stephen Bowles: By January 3 1'1.
Terry Jerulle: Thank you.
Stephen Bowles: And I want to comply - I don't want this hanging - I like
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 154 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
December 19. 2018
my license to be clean. There's a stain on it and I want to clean il up.
Matthew Nolton: Mr. Bowles, I assume you are still active in business. Do you
have active permits for pools that you are currently building or renovating?
Stephen Bowles: Yes, sir.
Vice Chairman Lantz: How many permits would you say you have out there? I
don't need an exact number - 5 - I 0 -100?
Stephen Bowles: Probably ten ... eight to ten.
Terry Jerulle: And in the future - in any grey areas, you are going to do what?
Stephen Bowles: I will take my paperwork to the Building Department and ask to
talk about it because I've never been through this and I don't want to go through this
again. Hindsight is 20120-these are self-inflicted wounds. Butlcomply-lrmaguy
who, like I told you, I have a passion for my industry and that's \.\'hat it's about ... to
comply.
Terry Jerulle: Thank you, sir.
Vice Chairman Lantz: Personally, when I break down the five criteria: First, the
gravity of the situation - the gravity ofthe situation is it didn't fall apart -- it's an
issue but not a huge one, so I'd put that on the low side. The impact of it-hedidn't
get a permit and should not have continued with the pool, but he did. Theoretically, I
don't think any public health./safety/welfare was in danger, so I'd put that very low.
Actions taken after- actions that were taken -- I'd put that about as high as you can
get as far as what he did wrong. He just gave up. He had plenty ol opportunities to
make it right and he didn't - he continued working on the pool before the permit was
issued. I'd say that's very high. As far as previous violations, he doesn't have any so
that's very low. And other evidence ... there's no change. So, overall, on a scale of
one to ten: Gravity - I or 2; Impact - I or 2; Actions - 10 or 12 if I could go thal
high; Previous violations - 0; and Evidence - 0. Averaging it out on a scale of I to
10, it's a 2 or 3 ... maybe. We've definitely seen a lot worse going on - i1's the fact
that it happened. I don't think it's a super-bad crime but it's something that needs to
be resolved.
Richard Joslin: I disagree with you as far as the public health./safety/welfare goes
only because the spa was built up without any bottom steel and without an inspection.
It's one ofthe first inspections that's done because ofthe electrical factor. How it's
going to be resolved is ifthere was steel tied to the top beam that he poured and ilit
was grounded. It will be a challenge to an Engineer to find out and get it done.
That's an important factor and inspection.
Terry Jerulle: Does the County have an opinion?
Everildo Ybaceta: The County will defer to the Board's decision.
Matthew Nolton: He will have to re-apply for the permit and there's the opportunity
to pay penalty of"x" times the permit fee in that process?
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes. The cost is four times the original permit fee because the
permit wasn't issued, because it is an active case, and because the contractor of record
was involved. It is to be done from issuance through completion.
Vice Chairman Laatzz t have a question for Jonathan Walsh. Mr. Bowles said he
could have everything done by January 3 l'1. My definition of "done" is a final
permit. Knowing the workload of the County and what need to be done between
37
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 155 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
December 19. 2018
now and getting finished product - in your opinion, what is the latest date to get
the Engineer's letter to you?
Jonathan Walsh: We're starting from scratch. He must apply for a new permit.
Vice Chairman Lantz: So, if he comes in with a new permit application and the
new letter on January 151h, is it possible the permit could be issued by January 3 1"
or no?
Jonathan Walsh: Not knowing the current load of the Planning Reviews, we could
probably facilitate a quicker tum-around. If you're looking for a date, I would
probably say five to ten days, give or take.
Vice Chairman Lantz: Business days?
Jonathan Walsh: Yes. We're currently 30 to 45 days for permit reviews. We could
probably facilitate tuming this one around a littte bit quicker. Ifthe letter that's in
lieu of County inspections is acceptable, then the only requirement would be three
inspections - final plumbing, final electric, and final pool.
Vice Chairman Lantz: Those inspections could be done in a day.
Jonathan Walsh: Theoretically, they could be done in one day once the permit is
issued.
Vice Chairman Lantz: Realistically, Mr. Bowles needs a good letter from an
Engineer as well as a new permit application package. Are you still saying you can
be done by January 3l't -- because it's notjust getting the letter - it's getting the
whole process done.
Stcphen Bowles: The permitting process might throw it back a little bit - maybe
February l5th? I don't want to say something and then we're still ...
Vice Chairman Lantz: That's exactly the point. I want to make sure you
understand its notjust obtaining a letter from an Engineer - there's more ...
Stephen Bowles: Yeah, we've got to get - start over, basically, and push everything
through.
Matthew Nolton: Mr. Walsh, I'm a little confused. Would this be a permit by
affidavit process or would this be that he is to submit plans and submit Engineer's
letters for the missed inspections?
Jonathan Walsh: We treated the rough on this permit knowing the history of it and
we will try to facilitate tuming the permit around by getting the Engineer's letters in
case there are any concerns, they can be fixed before it is finished. But his permit
will still be considered a partial after-the-fact. For the inspections that I cannot
perform, they must be done by an Engineer with supporting documentation and the
Engineer must document how he came to his conclusions.
Matthew Nolton: The packet would be the full site plan with the elevation ...
Jonathan Walsh: All the piping requirements, all the reinforcing steel ...
Matthew Nolton: ... all the bond connections - you'd have all that and the equipment
... it would have all that, just as if you were going to start thisjob from scratch.
You'd need to get a permit and a packet with all the documents which I am sure you
are aware ofsince you do this all the time. You would need that plus the Engineer's
letters to cover the inspections that were missed.
Stephen Bowles: Yes, sir. I don't know ifJanuary 3l't might be pushing it. I know
I can get the letters but, Iike he said, I don't really know about the plumbing review...
38
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 156 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
December 19. 2018
Jonathan Walsh: Our plumbing plan reviewer is ... if we're informed that the pennit
is in ... we will do our best to facilitate a quicker tum-around, but I don't want to ...
Matthew Nolton: I understand ... with the holidays and with ... it's not as simple as
),ou think with the Engineer's letters. I happen to know that firm was sold, so
whoever was involved is even there. I think you will probably need two months -
sixty days - to get this done.
Stephen Bowles: That sounds more reasonable. But it will get done. And I have
started over before - first it was the barrier, and the pool has been there since 1982. I
just want to submit everything so it goes through without something that I have no
control over.
Matthew Nolton: I understand. Thank you. Back to our deliberations.
Vice Chairman Lantz: What I'm proposing - I'm ready to make a motion but I
want to hear how everyone feels - we give him until the February meeting ...
provided that the permit is final before then, we will take no more action. However,
if the permit is not final by then, we will cancel his permit-pulling privileges until it
is final. It's giving you a lot of leeway but if you fail, there will be a lot of
repercussions.
Stephen Bowles: I understand, yes, sir.
Chairman Boyd: In essence, you are going to continue it until the February
meeting?
Vice Chairman Lantz: No.
Matthew Nolton: No - I would like the motion to be right now - we're in the
penalty, so we're recommending to the County that they pull his - the company's
permit pulling privileges and inspection privileges at that point in time unless the
permit has been closed out properly.
Vice Chairman Lantz: If he closes it out by the February meeting, he will go on his
way. If he doesn't, he will have a world of problems for his business.
Matthew Nolton: And this way, he would not have to come back before the Board.
Vice Chairman Lantz: Does anybody have any - does this sound reasonable?
Terry Jerulle: Mr. Bowles?
Stephen Bowles: It sounds reasonable.
Terry Jerulle: And that may - I think the homeowner is here - you may have to ...
in the worst-case scenario, you may have to drain the pool and chip the bonding on
the spa to get verification. I don't know - I'm not a pool contractor.
Stephen Bowles: Verification of the bonding?
Richard Joslin: One of the engineers may have an ex-ray machine.
Matthew Nolton: It won't show the bonding. There will have to be continuity
testing. And you're going to need to be able to contact the steel in two places - the
original beam on the pool and on the spa - you have to do continuity testing.
Stephen Bowles: Was the original beam on the pool in 1982? It didn't require that.
Matthew Nolton: Code may not have required it but, to build the spa, you would
have had to connect to that steel. And you would have had to ground it, so ...
Stephen Bowles: I bonded the whole pool and I bonded the spa, so whether it shows
up on radar... but that's the most important thing that you can do. Forget everlthing
else - bond that baby.
Richard Joslin: Lots ofthings happen it you don't.
39
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 157 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
December 19, 2018
Stephen Bowles: Bond that baby - your handrails, your lights ... so, the pool is
bonded and grounded. How we're going to get to making sure they know that ... like
you said ...
Terry Jerulle: As I said, think worst-case scenario in that sixty-day time frame.
Stephen Bowles: Yes, sir.
Terry Jerulle: And you can do that in the worst-case scenario.
Stephen Bowles: I think so - I think so.
Richard Joslin: Weren't permit pulling privileges part of the motion?
Vice Chairman Lantz: Well, I didn't make the motion yet ... but my suggestion is
permit pulling privileges are good now but if he fails to meet the deadline. they're
gone.
Richard Joslin: Okay.
Terra Jerulle: Any recommendation to the state?
Vice Chairman Lantz: No.
Terry Jerulle: If he doesn't complete this pool, he will not have any permit pulling
privileges. So, what happens with the state?
Vice Chairman Lantz: Then there's a recommendation to the state.
Vice Chairman Kyle Lantz moved lo approve granting a period of slrty days to
Stephen Bowles toJinal out the permit during which lime the permit is to be
issued in linal status and the job completed with a C of O. If the sLxty-day
deadline is missed, his permit pulling privileges and inspection pulling privileges
in Collier County will be immediately cancelled exceptfor this specific permit,
and lhe County will be aulhorized to send a lelter to the Stale's Conslruction
Industry Licensing Board ("CILB") recommending imposition of the maximum
pen ties, Richartl Joslin offered a Second in support of the motion.
Assistant County Attorney Noell: The Board's February meeting is scheduled for
February 201h which is four days later than your deadline. lf the Board is considering
taking away the Respondent's permit and inspection pulling privileges, I would be
more comfortabte if the deadtine was February 20th. If it is complied with and closed
out, the matter is done. Ifnot, then he is to come before the Board.
Vice Chairman Lantz: That is against my motion. And the reason is that I don't
want to have another Jeffrey Bumpus here every month.'Here's the line and we're
not crossing it.'
Assistant County Attorney Noell: I undersland. From my perspective with possible
due process considerations, etc., my fear is if the Board makes - and whatever the
Board does, respectiully, the Board does, and I understand that, but I am telling you
the County's position. Ifthe Board makes his suspension pending on a future event
and that automatically happens, the Respondent will have the ability to appeal that in
Circuit Court, I don't necessarily want to go through all those hoops when we're
talking aboutjust four days. If he's not in compliance and it's the automatic
suspension, he would have the right to be heard before that is finally taken - ifthat
makes sense.
Terry Jerulle: It does to me now. If there's a flood in the County and nobody can
pull permits for two weeks, that puts him in jeopardy.
40
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 158 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
December 19. 2018
Vice Chairman Lantz agrced to amend his molion to qitend the deadline lo
February 2Oh and Richard Joslin agreed lo amend his Second.
Chairman Boyd cdledfor a vote on lhe amended motion,
Carried unanimously, 6 - 0.
Terry Jerulle: And just for my record - I know you guys were upset but Jonathan
Walsh didn't create the problem. In my experience with Jonathan Walsh, he helps
solve problems. But he is extremely busy with thousands and tens ofthousands ol
permits and inspections, and even I can't get ahold of him ... a lot ofpeople ... it's not
just you, singularly, that can't get an answer from him - nobody can
Chairman Boyd stated:
. This cause came for a Public Hearing before the Contractors' Licensing Board
on December 19, 2018 for consideration of the Administrative Complaint
filed against Stephen L. Bowles, d,/b/a -/ackson Pool Service.
o Service of the complaint was made by certified mail, personal delivery, or
publication in accordance with Collier County Ordinance #90-105' as
amended.
o The Board having heard testimony under oath, received evidence, and heard
arguments respective to all pertinent matters hereupon issues its Findings of
Facts, Conclusions of Law and Order ofthe Board as follows:
Conclusions of Law, Findings of Fact, and Orders of the Board:
. Stephen L. Bowles, dhla Jackson Pool Service, is the holder of record ofa
Collier County Certificate of Competency, License Number
LCC20120001055.
o Mr. Bowles is also a State-certified Pool/Spa Contractor and holder ofLicense
Number CPC1456458.
o The Collier County Board of County Commissioners is the Petitioner in this
matter and Stephen L. Bowles is the Respondent.
o Mr. Bowles was present at the December 19,2018 Public Hearing and was
not represented by counsel.
. All notices required by Collier County Ordinance #90-105, as amended, have
been properly issued or personally delivered.
. The Respondent acted in a matter that is in violation of Collier County
Ordinance and is the one who committed the act.
. The allegation set forth in the Administrative Complaint as to Collier Corurty
Ordinance #2006-46, as amended, Section 4.2.2 - Misconduct of State
Certified Contractor slates: " IYillfully violating the applicable Building Codes
or law of the State, City, or Collier County. "
o The allegation was supported by the evidence presented at the Hearing.
Conclusions of Law:
. The allegations set forth in the Administrative Complaint as to Count One is
approved, adopted, and incorporated herein, to wit:
4t
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 159 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
o
December 19. 2018
The Respondent violated Ordinance #2006-46, as amended, Section 4.2.2
in Count One in the performance ofhis contracting business in Collier
County by acting in violation ofthe Section set out in the Administrative
Complaint with particularity.
Orders of the Board:
o Based upon the foregoing Findings ofFact and Conclusions of Law, and
pursuant to the authority granted in Florida Statutes, Chapter 49, and Collier
County Ordinance #90-105, as amended, by a vote of six (6) in favor and zero
(0) opposed, a majority vote ofthe Board members present, the related
Sanctions and following Order are hereby imposed upon the holder of
Certificate of Competency #LCC20120001055:
o The deadline for the Respondent, Stephen L. Bowles, to final out the
permit is February 20,2019, during which time, the permit is to be
issued in final status and the job completed with a C of O.
o If the deadline is missed, the Respondent's permit pulling and
inspection pulling privileges in Collier County will be automatically
cancelled except for this specific permit.
o If the deadline is missed, the County will be authorized to send a letter
to the State's Construction Industry Licensing Board ("CILB")
recommending position olthe maximum penalties.
Chairman Boyd: Thc hearing is concluded.
Matthew Nolton: The case that we didn't hear [Melvin Alfaro, dlbla"Oasis Builders of
SIIFL" - Conlesting Citation]- can we do something and not have that guy come back?
Everildo Ybaceta: He's not coming back. His time has been allotted.
Matthew Nolton: So, we don't need to take action on it? One question to Mr. Schneck
... is the Citation being tabled or...?
Everildo Ybaceta: No, he had ten days to contest the Citation. He requested a Hearing
to contest the Citation and he didn't show for the hearing.
Matthew Nolton: So, he can't contest it.
Attorney Jeb Schneck: I would recommend that the Board hold a hearing, have the
Contractors' Licensing Compliance Officer enter documentary evidence into the record
as well as a brief summary of the casejust to establish a substantial evidentiary standard.
Everildo Ybaceta: The Officer is no longer here but I can make a brief statement if you
wish.
Attorney Jeb Schneck: It's an Administrative Hearing process, in the sense that you
have witnesses and take testimony, deliberate and make a finding.
Everildo Ybaceta: We don't - well, no.
Attorney Jeb Schneck: The process for contesting a Citation is: the alleged violator
receives a Citation and has ten days to notify the County in writing that he/she wants to
contest the Citation at hearing before this Board. He has notified the County and there is
correspondence verifying the date of the hearing. That takes care ofthe notification
42
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 160 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
Permit Application Status - CityView Portal
Permit Application Status
GMD Public Portal
Pagc I of3
appIcanon Number:
applrahon Typel
Applrcanon Status:
Prope.ty owner s rull Name:
category of work:
Occupancy Code
D€scrlotion of work:
pR8O20170414670
Building
)ACOBS, fODD
Residential, one a.d Two F.mrly New or Guest House
MASTER POOL PLAN, PROVIDE SIIE SPECIFIC OE9IGN, TOH, PIJMP MAI(E,
MODEL AND CURVE, BARRIER PROTECTION, DECK MATERIAL AND LIGHT
SELECI'ON
REMODELING Or ExISTING pOOL. BARRIER: ri/A POOL 6UILT lN 1982
539t TAMARIND RIDGE DR
12l29l16. A.T,r. fees to be applred SeNlce /
04l t8/201-,
,2t26/2011
Le2.92?AAAa1
Sl9lle4!j!!!-84se-08
p.rnrt (clEk ro s.. Rcvl.wr)
)aCOSS, TODD, Address:5391 TAMARITI O RIOGE OR
aowLEs, STEPHEN L-. Addrcssi1109 rHoMPsoN avE, Phonet(:39) 368_
1555. LicenEe * 1CC20110001614
ule!ll_s!&/r
)ACKSON CUgTO POOLS lLC (DBA) TACXSON pOOL SERVICE,
Addressr11a60 LACY LANE, Phore:(239) 425-0300, State Reg ,'.
cPc145&58, tic€nse€ * LCC20120001055
Li.ense st.tus
Final Revi.w 5 Day Review
P.rmlt Numb.r: Ptlo2o1roa146r001
Pernrt Tyoe: Pool
Pe'mrt Stat!9 Vord
3 Rc-Ssblnltt l St tu3: P.ndlnt
2 R€-Submitt.l corr I status: R€tur.ed lor co.rection
IEGACYT w.rrram Church vEN 5lltLftlitil
06/29120r7
06t29/2017PlunbinC rnd H.ndiep ievi€w
Revlewer
Corr{ton5
06/27t20r7
r,m Ryqiel {(219) 252-2455) Send-Ilonjl
riliscellaneous corrections
06/29/20t1
Provrde complete of scope ns to what
rnspections are to be by engineer All
lette.s frcrn enginee.s muit state whe
and how rnspectrons were prefor.red
Contracto. can not €e.tify {ork
06/29/2017
http:i/cvportal.colliergov.neVCityViewWeb/PermiVStatus?permitl d=200532 2t5t20t9
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 161 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
a6/27/20t7
Permit Application Status - CityView Portal Page 2 of 3
Pl€aee provide a certfi€d site plan,
prepared, srg.ed, and sealed by a
lrcensed Flo.rda profeseonal surueyor
and mapper, architst or engrneer,
showrng legar des.rrnon, p.operty
lrnes, setbacks, easeftnts, wate.
bodr6, and all ex'sthg and propored
sructures to be slbmined with th.
burld'.g p€rmt appli.ation. The ptan
sh.ll rndentify the el€vat'on of the
crown of rh€ road, Erood zone, FEMA s
B.se Flood Elevaton, and show that
the elevation o, the de.k m€et or E
qreater than the crown ot road.
Miscelhn@us Corrections
o6t29/20r,
Gabnera cast.o {(219) 2s2 2408) Send Email
2nd.ele.tion: €nqjneers lette. must
incrude: 1. Fermit number and srte
address. 2. specrnc inspe.tiont
oertormed with corresDondrnq CollEr
co!nty rnspection numb€.. L Date and
om€ rnsoedions perlorrn€d. 4. Method
of rnsoe.non to lusuy detemhation
and rerolunon of the missed
rnspertlon contractd affd.vrts .re not
.n acceptable substitution for conrer
06/29/20t7
aorr€.tion I i4rscellar&lsCorrectio.s
statos Resolved
Date Status changed 06/29/2017
I I.itial subnitt.l o9l04/201t statss: Returned for corr..tio.
Ptease orovde a cert!fied site 9lan,
prepared, signed,.nd s€aed bY a
l'(enred Florida professiooal sutueror
.nd mapper, arch'te.t o. engieer,
showin9 leq.l des.i9ron, property
hnes, setbacks, easerents, watet
bodies, and all erisnng and proposed
structur.s to be submitt€d wth the
buidino permt application, The plan
sharl nldentify the elevation otthe
fiown ol the r(Fd, flo.d Zone, rEr,la's
Bas€ Flood Elevation, and show that
the el€vanon of the de.k meet or i5
qreater th.n the crown of road.
Final Raviaw 5 Oay Reviaw
Pl{mbing and H.ndlc.p trvi.w
Revrewer
Corre(tons
a4/2612011
LEGACY: Bob Garee ((219) 252'4232) send Eroil
M6(ellana@s Cerections
06122120L7
Provide.omplete or scope as to what
rnspections are to be by engin€'er. All
leR€rs from enqr.eers must state whe
and how inspections were ?reformed.
Connactor (an not certify work.
04/26/20r)
tll.cellaneous Cor€ctbns
06/22/201'
o4126/20t704126/2O1/
lohn Martin se0llElla!
LEGACY: Bob Garee ((239) 252-a282) send Emarl
04/24/2Or7
04124/20t7
Gabnela cast,o {{219) 2s2 2408) se!(LE!!3jl
http://cvportal.colliergov.net/CityViewWeb/PermiVStatus?permitl d=200532 21512019
-/"t-r;--@;-:7
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 162 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-
s50 0o
t50 00
i25 00
t0.00
Pcrmit Application Status - CityView Portal Page 3 of 3
l-
t50 00
$50.00
$25.00
04t19/2011
04/1912017
Resrdentral Appli€ton
tt25.o0 t125.OO
PLTASE DO NOT SUaMI ANY PAYHENTS l]NTIL A COLLIER COIJNw PAYI'IENT SLIP IS DISTRIBUTED
There are no deposits or bonds for thls applranon
Th€re a.€ io anspsbms for thrs appliantion
> Elevatron Certin.ate
cohdrion Typ€: co Hold
> Notrce ofcommencement OR 5340
Condilo.Type: Irfo.manonal
> spot suNey cO Hold: Spot sutu€y
wrll be required wthin r0 dayr or
passinq a 103 or 133 rnspe.tion of
slab, at whrch Pornt an "hsp€dion
rioLD'will be placed on thls Permrt.
NOTE| SPot s!ruey must verifY sbb
meets setbacks and mrnrmum
er€vation ,€r ch.pter 62, colli€.
Counly Code ot Laws (h'ghe. of BFE or
r.5 above crown of road, o. pe.
Co.dlton ryp€: CO Hold
Oocuments & ImaCes
04/ 18/2017
041tal2otl
04l\9t20r7
04l26120r'
06/2912017
02/2tl20tA
02/2U20tA
04tta/20ta
tr/09/20t0
z91t!1Ji519.N
Pavftnt Slio (PR)
R€.eiot tor transactrd: 2017-024101
corr<tions tltr.r Pa@r - outstandim corratds
Correxons tett€r Paoer Outstandino Cor6nons
leuol!t5!&c8)
Exptred Apphc.tron l'{on.e
Be!9ht&rlti!Indro!.-2ugD.}t!2
PR8D201704146r0 pdf
http://cvportal.colliergov.net/CityViewWebiPermit/Status?permitl d=200532 215t2019
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 163 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
Outstanding Corrections
Date: April 26, 2017
Contact Namer JACKSON CUSTOM POOLS LLC (DBA)
JACKSON POOL SERVICE
Address: 1 3401 RICKENBACKER PARKWAY
City, State Zip: FT MYERS, FL 33913-
PERMIT NO: PR8D2017041467001
APPLICATION NO: PR8D20170414670
JOB SITE ADDRESS: 5391 Tamarind Ridge DR
Email:
Dear Applicant
Plans submitted with the referenced permit have been reviewed. We are unable to approve your permit application for the
reason(s) indicated below.
For Applications Submitted on Paper:. Review the corrections below to identify each document you will need to submit.
. All corrections must be clouded.. Corrections to paper documents must be submitted in person; the GIVID office receiving corrections is open until 4:30
pm.. Submit 2 sets of corrected documents.. Submit 2 copies of the Letter of Response summarizing the changes made to address each correction comment
below.
JOB DESCRIPTION: ITiIASTER POOL PLAN. PROVIDE SITE SPECIFIC DESIGN, TDH, PUMP MAKE, MODEL AND CURVE,
BARRIER PROTECTION. DECK IVIATERIAL AND LIGHT SELE CTION
REMODELING OF EXISTING POOL. BARRIER: N/A POOL BUILT lN 1982
5391 TAMARIND RIDGE DR
12129116. A.T.F. fees to be applied Service /
Rejected Review: Plumbing and Handicap Review
Reviewed By: Bob Garee
Phone:239-2524282 Email:robertgaree@colliergov.net
Correction Comment 1: Provide complete of scope as to what inspections are to be by engineer.
All letters from engineers must state whe and how inspections were preformed.
Contractor can not certify work.
Rejected Review: Zoning Review
Reviewed By: Gabriela Castro
Phonei239-252-2408 Email:GabrielaCastro@colliergov,net
Correction Comment'1: Please provide a certified site plan, prepared, signed, and sealed by a licensed Florida professional
surveyor and mapper, architect or engineer, showing legal desciprion, property lines, setbacks, easements, water bodies, and
all existing and proposed structures to be submitted with the building permit application. The plan shall indentify the elevation
of the crown of the road, Flood Zone, FEIvIA's Base Flood Elevation, and show that the elevation of the deck meet or is greater
than the crown of road.
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIVISION / BUILDING REVIEW & INSPECTION
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive, Naples FL 34104 * Phone (239) 252-24OO
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 164 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
ATTENTION:
Collier County PIan Review and lnspections routinely reviews all outstanding permit applications in order to determine their
status. The review process includes appropriate responses from the permit applicant when the permit cannot be approved.
When the applicant is advised of deficiencies and does not respond within 180 days with corrected plans or an appeal to the
Code Enforcement Board, the permit application will be canceled as pet Collier County Ordinance 2002-01, Section,
104.5.1.1 to 104.5.1.4 (as amendedL
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 165 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
Outstanding Corrections
Date: J une 29,2017
Contact Name: JACKSON CUSTOM POOLS LLC (DBA)
JACKSON POOL SERVICE
Addfess: 1 340,I RICKENBACKER PARKWAY
City, State Zip: FT MYERS, FL 33913-
Fax: (239) 425-0251
Dear Applicant:
plans submitted with the referenced permit have been reviewed. We are unable to approve your permit application for the
reason(s) indicated below.
For Applications Submilted on Paper:
. Review the corrections below to identify each document you will need to submit
. All corrections must be clouded.
Corrections lo paper documenfs must be submitted in person, the GMD office receiving corrections js open until 4:30
pm.
Submit 2 sets of corrected documents.
Submit 2 copies of the Letter of Response summarizing the changes made to address each correction comment
below.
JOB DESCRIPTION: MASTER POOL PLAN. PROVIDE SITE SPECIFIC DESIGN, TDH, PUIVIP MAKE, MODEL AND CURVE,
AARRIEN PROTECTION, DECK MATERIAL AND LIGHT SELECTION
REMODELING OF EXISTING POOL. BARRIER: N/A POOL BUILT lN 1982
5391 TAMARIND RIDGE DR
12129116. A.T.F. fees to be applied Service /
Reiected Review: Plumbing and Handicap Review
Reviewed By: Tim Rygiel
Phone:239-252-2455 Email:TimothyRygiel@colliergov.net
Correction Comment 2: 2nd re.lection: Engineers letter must include:
1 Permit number and site address.
2. Specific inspections performed with corresponding Collier County inspection number
3. Date and time inspections performed.
4. Method of inspection to justify determination and resolution of the missed inspection.
Contractor affidavits are not an acceptable substitution for Collier County inspections.
ATTENTION:
Collier County Plan Review and lnspections routinely reviews all outstanding permit applacations in order to determine their
status. The review process includes appropriate responses from the permit applicant when the permit cannot be approved.
When the applicant is advised of deficiencies and does not respond within 180 days with corrected plans or an appeal to the
Code Enforcement Board, the permit application will be canceled as pet Collier County Ordinance 2002-01, Section,
104.5.1.1 to 104.5.1.4 (as amended).
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIVISION / BUILDING REVIEW & INSPECTION
28OO N. Horseshoe Drive, Naples FL 34LO4 * Phone (239) 252-24OO
PERMIT NO: PR8D2017041467001
APPLICATION NO: PRBD201 704'14670
JOB SITE ADDRESS: 5391 Tamarind Ridge DR
Email:
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 166 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
DavisLilla
From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Attachments:
RygielTimothy
Monday, February ll, 2Ol9 12:02 PM
DavisLilla
Jackson Pools
Jackson Pools interaction 1.docx
Lilla,
Evy asked me to forward this document to you.
Regards,
Tim Rygiel, CFM
Plumbing Plans Examiner and lnspector
-,L-c,fiff",Covmty
Building Plans Review and lnspections Division
Exceeding Expectations, Every Day!
NOTE: Email Address has changed.
Timothy.Rygiel @colliercountyfl . gov
2800 North Horseshoe Dr. Naples, Florida 34104
Phone: 239-252-2455
How are we doing?
The Building Plan Review and lnspection Division wants to hear from you!
Please take our online SURVEY.
We oppreciote your feedbock!
Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. lf you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a
public records request. do not send electronic mail to this entity. lnstead, contact this offrce by telephone or in wrting.
1
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 167 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
Jackson Pools i nteraction 71 3U 2079
Justin from Jackson Pools came to the counter trying to reactivate permit
20170474670 and submit an Engineers letter.
He was told by Robert Moore and me that the permit was voided and pursuant to
the Board of Licensing decree Jackson Pools was required to submit for a new
permit on th is project.
Since this is considered a new permit I informed him that a set of site-specific
Engineering detail drawings were required to show how the spa addition was
completed. I explained that the plans needed to indicate how the new concrete
system would be attached to the old. l.E dowel with epoxy, connection of new
bonding to old...etc.. Any new work that was performed must be included on the
plans. This is consistent with Collier County policy and Florida Building Code
requirements.
I also explained what inspections would be loaded on the permit and needed to
be addressed by the Engineers letter he had with him. I explained how the
content of the letter needed to include who performed the inspections, date and
time of inspections, methods used to determine code compliance, Collier County
inspection numbers to be referenced, Collier County permit number, and address
of the property.
Justin was under the impression that he would be able to just submit the
Engineers letter he had with him and an application and that should be sufficient
to resolve the issues with the voided permit.
2-o /,2
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 168 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
Corotty BUITDING PERMIT APPUCATION
2800 N. HORSESHOE DR., NAPLES, FL 34104 I TEL: (239)252-2a00
Ct1Prtiot.6:must
A"1. Petmit S tgdrDsl,/*I
&1 . Ptirnary P€rmit tft.ry|
freg:c the Euibing Pemit krj,tnxtbtu to
B.Z tt k Fennit f {tdyl
@ :. a z rrr*ry o.a*g,norrntto,"" O rraOienr*daar*io,t"R€siJentid 3+ lriG^tltilanily Qccrr"r=*lB3.Ai&gTpe
84. F!.ridr3Tf.F
*opertymnna*xl
8.5. Parc€UFol'0lt
8.6. ,ob Street Address:
38282200001
Cofitracto.O oe*n procslrrrar
Corfacbr&mdhrt
8.12 Lic€nse *
B.I|. Cornparry NarYte:
8.14. Qualifur llanE:
8.15. Contact tlame:
8.16. Comparry Address:
Q orner auiUer
cPC1456458
5391 Tama,ind REge O.ive, Naples, FL
Stephen Bowles
8.7. Orvner llatne:
B3. Orvner Phooe:
8.9. i:bdiviitx:
Loi/Bloddunia
B.1O. sDP/Pr*:
8.11. 'PLf Filename:
Todd Jacpbs
239-52T516/
Golden Gate Estates
Tract 33, Unit 32
'qtqpl-tu\airing frbpn6oo Otlvan mL
Rich Hudec
1 1 860 Lacf Lane. Ft Myers, FL 33966
8.17. Comoany Phqle:
B.18. Fax ri
8.19:. "Ernail 1:
8.19.b. "Ernail 2:
l"U na,e ara1sl os pthsy qffi ndtd.
239-42$O300
rich@ackson poolservice.com
S€ctim C ApCi€Bb. lntonnaticr
Cl- $a.Enfrce.s
C2 Permit Type:
C3. Fire PermitType:
c.4. Construdiff Type:
C5. OccuparEy:
C6. Water S€rYice:
C7. Sarer Service:
E] Er.Ec EPIUME
Pool
E MECH E RoofE E Septc trl b^rvotaSe
C& Fre Spririlded:
C9. Fermit bylffidavit
ClO. Pri€te Provfrr€c
C11.'Ihre$dd &ilding:
clz Vegetation OearirE;
E shutteE B $Icffrom hou-E Gas
c13. Related ro DAIVTAGES INCURRED SYHURRTCANE IRMA: Qvet Q r'r.
Secriol,t D, Proied lnfrmaix
O.l- Oes.ription o Wo* (a,w*x*5. D2 Proied Narne fd,yj: Jacobs Residsnce D.3. Ha{€d Value: S 70
Renovation of existing pool and spa, including elitending height of spa shell, with no change to pool or deck footprint
Pool Barriec N/A pool constructed in 1982
D.a ReCderdd Sq..tu
tler., Cdrst (Co"!trD,a.a & Aah/
pdditiqt t@Daa. aD4.b.)
AlEration /omplroaEl
DSCoilrEaCS+fti
Ns,v Cor&. /caanbEAs.a & Ds!,
Additim rcmrkas.a. & Din/
Alteration lcoaplteosc/
D.{.a l,ieli, Cord.
$Sries:
# Units:
# Bedrmms:
# Batrrmms:
D..5.a. tln| Const
D.ilb. UrbriA€a Fq, FL)
D.4.l lnir8:
D.A"b.e l.ls iving: _
ETAL O
DAc VlbAArre F+ Rl
D&i Livi18:
0.4.i Nd iving: _
TOTAI: 0
DadTebryArta
Torrrrii3 0
Xrnrxs}l*y 0
C Stories
S Units:
lnterion
Exterbc
IUTAI:
O.'hrift*rltgFq.R.)
lntenbn
Bderioc
TCTTAL 0
D.tc Work Ar€B (5q, ru)
0
Section E Staff Section
E.1. Final Rer'ielv Me:wT1s10t5
ievir.d oate: 1U29/17 v2 This is page l of 3 page5 ofthe BuildinS permit Application. please submit all 3 page5 when completed,
GJorat }bryrEf Orytrgr
thb
Jackson Pool Service
kmitlnfumatmSection B.General
E.2. Number of Plan seB: _ E.3. Revi€w Oa),s:
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 169 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
Vrew 14aster Proiect
Permit Application
Application Number
Application Typc
work clas5
Construction Type
Plan Checker
Inspcctor
ViewAll Activitie5 on thir Application
PR8D2(}19{}205517
Accessory
Add occupancy Code
trnk Occuparrv Code
, One and Two Famil
Add new pElEg! or b!:iE5E to Addres! Book
New Application (current project)New Application (no project)
Ready for Isguance
o2/o zor9
E
Building Review and Permitting
ApplicBtion Statu'
Date Entcrrd
E tered By
D!parbnent
luri5diction
Land Use
Fira zooe
oatc Issucd
Datc ErpirEtion
D.t. Finaled
Total Valudtion
Collier County
occupaflcy cod.(s)
0811,u20L9
$0.00 Insoector Notf
Dcscription of work renovation of existing pool and spa, including height of spa shell with no change to pool or deck footprint
lorc,ol barier lna pool construded in 1982
5321 Tamarind Ridge or.
Show Permit AoolicEtion Proiect Tvoes
Show Elo.e Fields
Business Name Electronic Documents No
ISO Report Code ISOR06-Res/Other Non-Building
au ding P€rmit Applkation attributes
zoning Aft ributei (PRPermit)
Utalities Attribut€s (PRPermit)
Property/Grs attrabutes (PRPermit)
Add new p3g59g or business to Address Book
To link a contact to this application, enter contact information below
Go to Alerts Add a Contact
Cityviewwill suggest possible matches as you type:
Go I-rnk Type Des6ipto.r Cmtact Aefr ftinrary?
Property Own€r
BOWLES, STEPHEN L, Addres5:1109 THOMPSON AVE, Phone:(239) 3Qualifie r
TAcKSON CUSTOM POOLS LLC(DBA) IACKSON pOOLSERVICE, Addr
Di ?
F.t
Building
Owner BuiH€r
Is the property o\rrner dorng
work?
Natural Disaster
Location
Contacts
r-l
IJACOBS, TODD, Address:s391 TAMARIND RIOGE OR
JACOBS, TODD, AddTessI5391 TAMARIND RIDGE DR n
tr
tr
trtr
:js Contractor
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 170 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
Apolicatior Nqmbcr
Typc
Stahrs
Inspectgr
PRE}D20190205517
Buildinq
Ready fo. Issuarrce
Descri T Alert
Property33282300001
5391 Tamarind Ridoe DR I ld_!r::
Application Information
view Nla5ter Proiect
Show Permitr on this Aoplication
Show Inspection zone! on this Aoolication
Activity Tracking
Add a new ps.!E-g.t or bgi!!5s to Addrers Book
show tl€All Pe.mit and Irlspedion Adivities Refresh Generate Email Add Activity
Comments Bulk lnspection LJ p date
l'-rnkGo ToASSr 0ate OutcorE Date
Approved
ou77/2079
Normal Not Required
;Normal ouL4l7D79
Final Revrew 5 Day Review Ti o2ltu20t9
0u12/2019
Complete o2l7u2019
Pending
Pending
Norma
: 0u7u2019
Normal nu7uzn\9 Complete
endinq
Normal : 0U08/2019 :Complete
r0ormal u1+lZO79
rNorma
I : OUla/2019 :Approved
Norrr1al 0213/2019 complete
Lisa Elacklidge
: OUlU2Or9
Pending
Approved
Not Required
l gz_12?91?
a oulu2o79
I outuzoTe-, dutuioii
Normal
rvoi-ir
uormit
noimai
Iim. Ryelel
lrm Kygrel
ii- R./;l;i
Irm Rygrel
n1eelt!le1!r
ltrylI:IPl!r
AngelTarpley
= r::=, -G:TIl-8.D:11-'ll R:Yf $ :*
: i* i Plans Routed
: :s r FEl.lA Review
Stdrt Timc
End Time
Hours Spcnt
Complcted By
Category
Itlotifi cation Phonr Numbcr
Permit Type
ActiYity Checklist
James Forma
Responsible DcparEnent
Resource Group
Datc Rcque5ted
Rrqucsted Time Frame
lurisdiction
Notification Email
Building Review and Permitting
Permit Intake
Collier County
Show More Field!
ElectronicDocuments No
Permrt --PR8D20190205s1701
FI
Show Activity Comments Historv
Show Activitv Extended Descriotion
Show Activity P ublic Notes
Added by Add Actlvrty
Button? (fla qA d dA ctiv ity B LU
Manual Achvtty?
( attFld a lt4 an ua lA ctiv ity )
()
v
Y
Y
PL Submittal Number 1
i-l
;ctrvrt/Pnorit'/
lEria Diaz
Maria Diaz
Zoning Review
Plumbing and Handicap Revie
Normal :0219/2019 Complete
Generate Permit Fees
All Fee5 Venfied Normal l
700 - Pool Bonding
701. - Pool Final
:704 - Pool Shell
Verify Permit ready to Issue
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 171 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
DavisLilla
Faom:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Attachments:
GumphJack
Tuesday, February 05, 2019 11:43 AM
stephen@jacksonpoolservice.com
.Justin@.jacksonpoolservice.com; GumphJack; DavisLi lla
RE: Permit Application: PR8D20170414670
02052019113219.pdf
RE: 5391Tamarind Ridge Dr, Permit S PR8D20170414670 ApPlication
Mr. Bowles,
Attached please find Notice of Hearing appearance reference your December 19,2018 Hearing. You will be required to
appear on February 20, 2019 before the 'Board'. As stated in the 'Board' record, if you have met the requirement of a
Certificate of Completion by that date, you will be removed from the agenda.
Thank you,
lack Gumph
Conrpliance Officer, Contractor Licensing
Collier County Crowth Management Department
2800 North Horseshoe Drive
N aples, FL 34104
239-252-2468 (Otfice)
2 39-43 8-5195 (Cell)
Iack.Gumph(aCollierCountyFL.gov
-.L-cfrF",Qovtnty
Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. lf you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a
public records request. do not send electronic mail to this entity lnstead, contact this office by telephone or in writing.
1
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 172 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
er Cor.wrt3l
Date: February 4, 2019
Stephen Bowles, Jackson Pool Servrce
I 1860 Lacy Lane
Fort Myers, FL 33966
Permit Application: PRBD20170414670, Application Date: 04/18/2017 (VOID PERMIT APPLI.)
Job Description: master pool plan. provide site specific design, tdh, pump nrake, rnodel and cun'c.
barrier protection, deck material and light selection remodeling ofexisting pool. barrier: n/a pool built in
r982
Job Location: 5391 Tamarind Ridge Dr, Naples, FL 34 I I 9
Dear Mr. Bowles,
A complaint has been previously filed against you by the above referenced en(ity. A hearing of this
Complaint was held by the Contractors'Licensing Board on Wednesday, December 19,2018 at
9:00 AM in the Board of Coungv Commissioner's Room, Third Floor. Administration Building
(W. Harmon Tumer Bldg.), at 3301 East TamiamiTrail, Naples, Florida 341 12. You were present during
the Hearing.
The Contractor Licensing Board found you guilty ofthe violation. At that time, the'Board'dictated a 60
day period for you to finalize the violation.
The 'Board' requests your presence at the Contractors' Licensing Board on Wednesday, February 20,
2019 al 9:00 AM in the Board of County Commissioner's Room, Third Floor, Administration Building
(W. Harmon Tumer Bldg.), at 3301 East Tamiami Trail. Naples, Florida 341 l2 to address this matter.
Should you fulfill the requirement ofthe 'Board' that a Certificate of Completion is issued prior to that
date, the matter will be removed from the agenda.
Sincere v,
Operations and Regulatory Management, Crowlh Management Depanmenl
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL. 34104
Jack mp
Co Coun ty ontractors'Licensing
Norlh Hor5eshoc Drive. ttapler, glorraGrowth Managemedt Oivision.PlrnninB & Re8(htroni :8OO
(inrrl th \lanagerncnt l)ir ision
l'lanning & llcgulation
()pcratiorrs l)tpu rtnrtn t
l,iccnsing Scction
9.A.1
Packet Pg. 173 Attachment: STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR – UPDATE (8019 : CASE: 2018-10
02/20/2019
COLLIER COUNTY
Contractor Licensing Board
Item Number: 9.B
Item Summary: JEFFREY BUMPUS – NORTHERN BREEZE – FOR FACTUAL FINDING OF
WHETHER PERMITS HAVE BEEN CLOSED BY JANUARY 19, 2019 AS ORDERED BY THE
BOARD ON DECEMBER 19, 2018
Meeting Date: 02/20/2019
Prepared by:
Title: – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Lilla Davis
02/12/2019 8:42 AM
Submitted by:
Title: Supervisor - Operations – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Everildo Ybaceta
02/12/2019 8:42 AM
Approved By:
Review:
Contractor Licensing Board Lilla Davis Review Item Completed 02/12/2019 8:42 AM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Review Item Completed 02/12/2019 2:30 PM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Meeting Pending 02/20/2019 9:00 AM
9.B
Packet Pg. 174
.RftrCoun w
FEBRUARY 20,2019
9:00 A.M.
ADMINISTRATIVE COMPLAINT - CASE 2018-04
JEFFREY BUMPUS- MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR
This case is before the Board again today for factual findings of whether permits have been
closed out by January 19, 2019, as ordered by the Board at the Decembet 20,2018 meeting
Below are all of the updates on this case:
JEFFREY BUMPUS is the License holder for his company NORTHERN BREEZE AIR
CONDITIONING, lNC. The license (CAC054719- A/C CLASS B-CERTIFIED) is currently in
Active status. A Contractor Licensing case (CEM 1520170001422) was opened due to multiple
building permits going into a VOID status from 2013 &2014 without being resolved.
Mr. Bumpus was originally rn front of the board on March 21 ,2018. There was a total of 44
permrts that were in an Expired or Void status. At the March meeting, Mr. Bumpus was given 60
days to return to the Board with his permits completed.
On May 16, 2018, Mr. Bumpus returned to the Board to check on his progress. The Board
granted Mr. Bumpus an additional 60 days to clean up his permits. Since we did not have a July
meeting, Mr. Bumpus went before the board August to review his permits.
On August 15, 2018, Mr. Bumpus was scheduled to return to the Board. He did not show up
citing personal reasons for missing the meeting. The Board voted to continue this case to the
September meeting.
On September'19, 2018, Mr. Bumpus was scheduled to return to the Board. The Board voted
and approved that Mr. Bumpus is restricted to only pulling permits for the outstanding expired
and void permits. He is also to return in 30 days to review his progress and hear a
recommendation for further action that will be taken with the State of Florida.
On October 17,2018, Mr. Bumpus was before the Board to review his progress. He still had
many issues with is open permits. The Board determined Mr. Bumpus needs to return to the
next meeting with all of the permits cleared.
On December'19, 2018, Mr. Bumpus was before the Board in which they decided he had 30
days to complete the rest of the permits and they received their certificate of completion. lf not,
the Board suggested a letter goes to the State recommending the maximum penalty.
COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD
9.B.1
Packet Pg. 175 Attachment: JEFFREY BUMPUS - ADMIN COMPLAINT 2018-04 MISCONDUCT [Revision 1] (8020 : JEFFREY BUMPUS–NORTHERN BREEZE –
Gontents
Permits as ol 218119 - 16 p ermits still considered open
December 20, 2018 Minutes
9.B.1
Packet Pg. 176 Attachment: JEFFREY BUMPUS - ADMIN COMPLAINT 2018-04 MISCONDUCT [Revision 1] (8020 : JEFFREY BUMPUS–NORTHERN BREEZE –
Permits By Gontractor - NORTHERN BREEZE
AS OF FEBRUARY 8,2Ot9
Permit Numbel Full Address Permit
Type
Declared
Valuation
Application
Status
Permil
Slatus
Applv
Date
lssued
Date
Expiralion
Date
PRHV20151 13561901
PRHV2015051467901
PRHV2013081937701
PRHV2015041056601
PRHV20r 6051959201
PRHV2o18126580601
PRHV201603o838301
PRHV2o1809543r 5o1
PRHV2018095288701
PRHV2018126681001
PRHV2018095287601
PRHV2018126583601
PRHV2o1605201 1701
PRHV2oi 8126779001
PRHV20r 8126779601
PRHV2018095289201
PRHV2018095288001
PRHVzo18095418101
PRHV2013081937501
PRHV2018oS541oO01
PRHV2o151 13561501
PRHV20180S5518601
PRHV2018084855301
PRHV2018105807601
PRHV2018095406101
PRHV2018126762601
PRHV2018095289101
PRHV2018084855201
PRHV2018095407501
PRHV201S084685401
PRHV2018084855101
770 Bentwater CIR, Unit:102
810 Breakaway LN, Unit:204
2274 Hidden Lake DR. Unitr3
730 Bentwater ClR. Unitr204
2324 Hidden Lake DR. lJnit:3
2285 Hidden Laks DR, Unit:7
2OO4 Cascades OR, Unit:7
2OO4 Cascades DR, lJnit:8
1645 Windy Pines DR, LJnit:8
845 109th AVE N
692 Annemore LN
2345 Hidden Lak€ DR. Unil:6
705 Bentwaler CIR
2255 Linwood AVE
2332 lvlagnolia LN, Unit:3
2265 Hidden Lake DR, Unil:8
2370 Magnolia AVE, Unil:7
2345 Magnolia LN, Uniti6
2372 Hidden Lake OR, Unit:6
2378 Magnolia AVE, Unit:1
2329 Hidden Lake DR, Unit:g
2332 Magnolia LN, Unit:3
1645 Windy Pines OR, Uniti6
705 Bentwater CIR
765 Bentwater ClR, LJnit:201
2332 Magnolia LN, Unit:1
2420 Hidden Lak€ DR, Unit:4
1615 Windy Pines DR, Unit:g
1685 Windy Pines OR, Unit:8
2325 Hidden Lake DR, Unit:4
2415 Hidden Lak6 DR. Unil:2
M€chanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
irechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
I\rechanical
Mechanical
I\,lechanical
I\,{echanical
Mechanical
I\,lechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
I\,{echanical
I\rechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
3200
4000
2800
3500
4200
2800
2900
2800
2800
3300
3500
2800
4000
3100
200
2800
2800
2800
2800
2800
3200
2800
2800
3600
4000
1800
2800
2800
2800
2800
3000
R€activate Reaclivate
Reactivate Reactivat€
Reactivato Reactivat€
Reactivate Reactivate
lssued lssued
lssued lssued
lssued lssued
lssued lssued
lssued lssued
lssu€d lssued
lssued lssued
lssued lssued
lssued lssued
Ready ror R6ady lor
lssuance lssuance
Ready lor Ready lor
lssuance lssuance
lnspeclions lnsFections
Commenced Commenced
I-rnaled Frnaled
Finaled Finaled
Finaled Finaled
Finaled Finated
Finaled Finaled
Final€d Finaled
Finaled Finalsd
Finaled Finaied
Finaled Finaled
Finaled Finalsd
Finaled Finaled
Finaled Finaled
Finaled Finaled
Finaled Finaled
Finalod Finaled
12J18/2018
9t1012014
8/-14t20-18
9t18/2014
uz201a
8t14t201A
1?J19t20.18
9113/2018
9/6/2018
1012J2018
4t6t2018
9/6/2018
11/1212015
5/1112015
8t712013
4t412015
5/2312016
12412018
3110D016
9/18/2018
9/r 0/2018
12111t2018
9/10/2014
12,5/2018
5/26/2016
tztstzola
12J19t2014
9t1012018
9n0/2018
gt18DO18
gfit2013
gt18l2o18
1111212015
912412018
4t14t2018
10/1 1/20r 8
9t1A/2018
12]312015
6t16t2015
wat2013
4/14/2015
7120/2016
12/4t20.18
3123/2016
firu201A
gt13t2o1a
'12t14/2018
9/13/2018
12t14120ft
7/2012016
9t13t2014
9/13/2018
10/22018
a/at2o13
rjizzorc
1?]3/2015
12]14t20't8
9t6/201A
12]14t2018
1ot16t2o$
o3t17t2019
ost-1712019
o3t17/2015
03/1712019
03/'t2/2019
06/o2t2019
03117 t2019
03/31/2019
o31122019
o6t1212019
ost122019
o6t12,2019
03/1712019
o6t26t2019
06/26/2019
03t1212019
03/13/20r 9
06/15/2019
08/19/2015
04/03/2019
03112J2019
06/16/2019
03/06/2019
06/16ii2019
04116/2019
06/18/2019
06/1 1/2019
03/06/2019
04/0312019
02109/2019
03/06/2019
9.B.1
Packet Pg. 177 Attachment: JEFFREY BUMPUS - ADMIN COMPLAINT 2018-04 MISCONDUCT [Revision 1] (8020 : JEFFREY BUMPUS–NORTHERN BREEZE –
Permits By Gontractor - NORTHERN BREEZE
AS OF FEBRUARY 8,2(J19
Pe.mit Number Full Addless Permil
Type
Declared
Valuation
lssued
Date
Expiration
Date
Applv
Date
PRHV2015041 147701
cDP2o1oo9o335o1
PRHV2o15041 158701
pnsvzor gozozgr riiir
PRHV2013123100101
PRHV2018095288501
PRHV201 8095418201
PRHV2013092286101
PRHV2015041060601
PRHV2018oS5288401
PRHV2018084855401
PRHV2016083178001
PRHV2018095418701
PRHV2018126678001
PRHV2or 2ol0o54oo1
PRHV2018095418001
PRHV20180S5409601
PRHV2or5o51711301
PRHV2018o9528880 1
PRHV2o18o95288901
PRHV201406r 5o4i)01
pnHvzor eogszego0r
PRHV2013102488001
PRHV2013081983201
PRHV2015072242501
PRHV2015082590001
PRHV2013102487901
PRHV2o1402o3292o1
PRHV2013092374601
PRHV2015072242101
PRHV2016072877301
23,14 Magnolia LN, Unit:5
4845 Maninique WAY
9937 Boca CIR
7887 Vizcaya WAY
1715 Windy Pines DR, Unit:6
1665 Windy Pines DR, unit:g
2405 Hidden Lake DR, Unit:g
7444 Treeline DR
6812 Pglican Bay BLVD
21OO Cascades DR, Unit:8
1O45 Windy Pines DR, Unil:5
2036 Cascades OR. Unit:14
735 Eentwater ClR, Unit:203
4976 Rustic Oaks CIR
6812 Pelican Bay BLVD
2332 Magnolia LN, Unit:2
7OO Bentwater ClR, Unit:102
2348 Hldden Lake DR, Unit:6
1615 Windy Pines OR, LJnit:2
2329 Hidd€n Lake OR, Unit:s
2375 Bayou LN, Unit:3
2365 Hidd€n Lake OR, Unit:4
845 r09th AVE N
2255 Linwood AVE
1645 Windy Pines DR, Unit:s
2036 Cascades DR, LJflit:14
2332 Magnolia LN, Ljnit:1
7OO Bentwater ClR, Unit:102
765 Bentwater ClR, lJnit:201
2329 Hidden Lake DR, Unit:s
2378 Magnolia AVE, Unit:1
M€chanical
Mechanical
il€chanical
Mechanacal
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
I\r6chanical
lvl€chanical
M6chanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
I\r6chanical
M6chanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
M6chanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
M6chanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Finaied
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Final€d
Finaled
Finaled
3000
3600
3600
8000
3000
2800
2800
4000
2800
2800
2800
3500
3600
3500
2600
2800
3200
2800
2800
2800
500
3200
3300
3100
4000
3500
1800
3200
4000
2800
3000
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Final6d
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Fiflaled
l- rnaled
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Finaled
Final€d
Cancsll€d
Cancell€d
Cancelled
Canceiled
Cancelled
Cancell€d
Cancell€d
Cancelled
Cancelled
4/-1512015
9/8/2010
4115t2015
217t2013
1?,17t2013
gtl0/2018
9/14t2014
gl12,2013
418t2015
9/10/2018
81/14t2014
8/1&2016
9/14/2014
12J-1112018
1t1112012
9,1a201a
9/18/2018
5l2g/2015
9/10/2018
s/10/2018
6/212014
gt10/201a
fin/2013
an312013
7ta2015
811112015
rcn2o1g
ztotzoli
9/23t2013
7,e,2015
7 12A2016
4t24/2015
9/81/2010
4124t2015
?Ju2013
1212712013
9t1312014
101212014
g/20t2013
4114t2015
10/6/2014
9/6/2018
8r/18/2016
10/1612014
12J1412018
1111t2012
10t2J2018
10n 6/2018
6/16/2015
9113/2014
9/13/2018
w2612014
9t13t2014
10/17t2013
9t1212013
10t1712013
2t14/2014
10t4t2013
07/1412019
05/15/2016
10121t2015
o8n3/2013
oa10/2016
03/19/2019
04to312019
05t25t2015
01/06/2019
06/11/2019
03/06/20r9
02,18t2017
04/16t2015
06/16/2019
07/0912012
o4t03/2419
06/16/2019
o1/05/2019
ag13/2019
03/13/2019
04/27/2015
mn3/2019
04/15/2014
o3/11/2014
01t04/2016
0za7pol6
04/1512014
o}t13/2014
0410212014
01to4t2016
01124/2017
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Application
Stalus
Permit
Status
9.B.1
Packet Pg. 178 Attachment: JEFFREY BUMPUS - ADMIN COMPLAINT 2018-04 MISCONDUCT [Revision 1] (8020 : JEFFREY BUMPUS–NORTHERN BREEZE –
Permits By Gontractor - NORTHERN BREEZE
AS OF FEBRUARY 8r2fJ19
Permit Numbe,Full Address Permit
Type
Declared
Valuation
lssued
Oate
Expiration
Oate
PRHV2o1 3102621001 2420 Hidden Lake DR, Ljnit:4
PRHV2o1409264740I 692 Annemore LN
PRHV2014061504001 2332 Magnolia LN, Unit:s
PRHV2O 16072769801 2345 Magnolia LN, Unit.6
PRHV2ol4020328701 2325 Hidden Lake DR, Un(:4
PRHV2O t 4071949701 4976 Rustrc Oaks CIR
PRHV2016020635901 2415 Hidden Laks DR. Unit:2
PRHV2O1506l895101 2365 H'dden Laks DR, Unit:4
PRHV201604l2141O1 1665 Wrndy Prnes OR, Unit:g
PRBD2O]6031066001 1685 Windy Pines DR, Unit:8
PRHV2014082213401 2285 H'do€n Lake DR, Unit:7
PRHv2ol4o51 502601 r 615 windy Panes DR, unir:g
PRHV2016093482901 2405 Hidden Lake OR, Unit:g
PRHV2O 14051285301 2332 Magnoha LN, un'l:3
PRHV2o14123554201 2345 Hidden Lake DR, Unit:t
PRHV2O I3092374001 735 Bentwater ClR, Unrt:203
PRHV2014082459901 2265 Hidden Lake DR, Ljnit:8
PRHV2O 13102488501 7OS Eentrvater CIR
PRHV2014020329101 1645 Windy Pines 0R. Unit:6
PRHV2O I4123554701 1645 Wrndy Prnes DR, Unrt:8
PRHV2O I5082761401 2lOO Cascades DR, unil:8
PRHV2Ol607276S40 1 2370 Magnolia AVE, Unit:7
PRHV2O1312310O4O 1 1615 Windy Pines DR, Unit:2
PRHV2O]5123783OO 1 2332 Magnolia LN, Unit:2
PRHV2O1602038530 1 2OO4 Cascades DR, Unit:8
PRHV2O15O4I05750I 6812 Pelican Bay BLVD
PRHV2O15O4l0581O1 6812 Pelican Bay BLVD
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
I\rechanical
Mechanical
I\rechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
lllechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
I\rechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
I\rechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Mechanical
Canc€lled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Canc€lled
Canc€lled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancellsd
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
'Entered
ln
Error
Ent€red ln
Efior
3000
3500
2AO
3000
32AO
3500
3500
2800
2800
4ooo
28oO
3000
3000
3000
3000
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
10t21DO13
911e/2014
6/22014
7120/2016
210t2014
7/10t2014
225t2016
6,/16/2015
4t5t2016
3/25/2016
a1512014
5/30/2014
9t12J2016
5t9t2014
1?,23t2014
gt23/2013
at2a/2014
10nn013
z'10t2014
12123/2014
4t27 t2015
7t2012016
1211?/2013
1?,4t2015
28/2016
41u2015
4t8t2015
12.116t2013
9/14t2014
214t2014
7 t11/2014
3nPO16
4t5t2014
7/1012014
06114/2014
03/17/2015
11129/2014
01t16/2017
oall7/2014
01to7t2015
09/03r/2016
1?,1312015
10/0212016
ogt24t2o16
02101/2015
01/06/2015
03t1112017
1ZO7t2018
o6t21/2015
o4/02t2014
02J24t2015
o4115t2014
04t13t2014
06121t2015
oz23t2o16
01/16DO17
o6t25t2014
06/01/2016
0&08/2016
10/05/2015
l0/05/2015
3200
3200
39oO
3200
3000
3ooo
28oO
3oo0
4500
4100
2AOO
28oO
1U17n013
2114t2014
101412013
12]27120-13
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Cancelled
Enlered ln
Erlor
Enlered ln
Etror
Appllcatlon
Stalus
Applv
Oale
Permit
Slalus
9.B.1
Packet Pg. 179 Attachment: JEFFREY BUMPUS - ADMIN COMPLAINT 2018-04 MISCONDUCT [Revision 1] (8020 : JEFFREY BUMPUS–NORTHERN BREEZE –
December 19. 2018
MINUTES
OF THE COLLIER COUNTY
CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD
December 19,2Ol8
Naples, Florida
LET IT BE REMEMBERED that the Collier County Contractors' Licensing
Board, having conducted business herein, met on this date at 9:00 AM in
REGUIA,R SESS/ON in Administrative Building "F," 3'a Floor, Collier County
Government Complex, Naples, Florida, with the following Members present:
Chairman:
Yice Chair:
Michael E. Boyd
Kyle E. Lantz
Members:Terry Jerulle
Richard Joslin
Robert Meister
Matthew Nolton
Excused: Patrick White
ALSO PRESENT:
Everildo Ybaceta - Supervisor, Contractors' Licensing Office
Kevin Noell, Esq. - Assistant Collier County Attomey
Jed Schneck, Esq. - Attomey for the Contractors' Licensing Board
Jack Gumph - Contractors' Licensing Compliance Officer
Reggie Smith - Contractors' Licensing Compliance Officer
I
9.B.1
Packet Pg. 180 Attachment: JEFFREY BUMPUS - ADMIN COMPLAINT 2018-04 MISCONDUCT [Revision 1] (8020 : JEFFREY BUMPUS–NORTHERN BREEZE –
December 19, 2018
Maria Gomez: We are here because the County told us to come - we did it many
times - we tried to do whatever you guys said had to be done to be able to get a
Second Entity. We understand. We are a licensed Building Contractor. We are not
looking for two entities to do the same job. We are looking for the Second Entity
only to do block and slab. If ithas tobe only a Specialty license forthat-it's fine
with us. That's what we are looking for.
Richard Joslin: We understand that. To do that, you will need to submit another
application to make it legal and to make your license valid.
Maria Gomez: That's okay.
Richard Joslin: Go back to Collier County - to Mr. Ybaceta - and apply again.
Now, the credentials &at you have as a Building Contractor probably will apply
because you have the experience. But a test may be required. We can't say yes or no
- we will let you decide. Since we can't make a decision today, we are asking you if
you are willing to withdraw this - it will go away for the moment - you can son it out
and then come back if ...
Maria Gomez: Alrighty - we can withdraw, and we will sit down with Collier
County and will be able to move forward in that direction. Okay?
Richard Joslin: And you will get the license that I think you want.
Maria Gornez: Alrighty - okay.
Terry Jerulle: I'm sorry for the confusion. Good Luck and Merry Christmas!
Maria Gomez: Bye, bye ... Merry Christmas.
IX. OLD BUSINESS:
(Ng!B: The individuals who testified in the following case under ltem IX, "OA
Business," werefirsl sworn in by the Altorney for the Board.)
Reggie Smith, Contractors' Licensing Compliance Olficer, thanked the Board for
its patience during the process and stated Joshua Lenio would provide a report of the
latest information concerning the status of the expired permits.
Josh Lenio stated that as of December 19, 2018, technically, Mr. Bumpus had no
expired or void permits. He clarified there were some permits that were in "issued
status - inspections completed" and one that is "pending - under review." Mr.
t6
an equal - a like for like - then, yes, it will come before the Board.
Vice Chairman Lantz: But if he's gefting a masonry license without taking the
masonry test -- using a different test -- the Board doesn't have to approve that?
Everildo Ybaceta: He would have to take that test, yes.
Vice Chairman Lantz: But he could request a Waiver for the test?
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes, that is correct. There are a lot of options here that are on the
table. I think the f,rst step is to go to my office and figure out what you need to do
frst.
A. Jeffrev Bumpus - Final Update: Expired Permits
(dhla "Northern Breeze Air Conditioning, Inc.)
9.B.1
Packet Pg. 181 Attachment: JEFFREY BUMPUS - ADMIN COMPLAINT 2018-04 MISCONDUCT [Revision 1] (8020 : JEFFREY BUMPUS–NORTHERN BREEZE –
December 19,2018
Bumpus has permits that are "open" which means he has not yet received a
Certificate of Completion." He is still actively pursuing these permils.
Vice Chairman Lantz: So, the even though the permits aren't closed out - they are
still active, and he is within the law?
Josh Lenio: Correct.
Yice Chairman Lantz: On every single permit that he has?
Josh Lenio: Correct. So, all the ones that he currently has open, he is technically
within the requirement that he pursue a Certificate of Completion.
Jeffrey Bumpus: Don't thank me. I went to his office and there is a lady in his
office who really took care of me. She did. I was there this moming and submitted
two sets of plans and everything is 100%.
Richard Joslin: Congratulations.
Jeffrey Bumpus: When I get done here, I'm going to get her a card and a gift
certificate because she was exceptional.
Richard Joslin: And then you're going to say to us that you will never let this
happen again - right?
Jeffrey Bumpus: I certainly hope not. She gave me a list of 17 on Monday that
were to have final inspections. My biggest problem now is that I have a couple of
people who said to wait until after Christmas. Yesterday, we were like the police -
knocking on doors - people were sleeping but they let us in because I said I was with
the County and we had to inspect the a/c. Basically, I have two or three more who are
after Christmas. The rest should be done on Monday. And $800.00 later, I got
renewed.
Richard Joslin: Is this something now that you're comfortable with as far as the
permits are concemed?
Josh Lenio: I don't know if I would say "comfortable," but technically he is actively
pursuing them. The goal here is, obviously, to see that they are receive a final
inspection. Some ofthem are still lingering, some ofthem haven't been inspected but
he still has the 180 days.
Everildo Ybaceta: For the record, County employees cannot accept gifts.
Jeffrey Bumpus: You can't?
Everildo Ybaceta: A card would be nice ...
Jeffrey Bumpus: I get it.
Everildo Ybaceta: ... or a letter to the Board of County Commissioners saying that
we were helpful would be great.
Jeffrey Bumpus: There was one girl who was very helpful to me five years ago and
I brought her a giant cookie basket. I appreciate it. She summed it up in five minutes
and made me a list that I could work with of what needed to be done. She told me one
had failed inspection in 2012 but when I was there, the homeowners told me it had
passed.
Everildo Ybaceta: At this point, I believe we are at the stage where we need to close
this out.
Chairman Boyd: That would be nice. Just make sure that all of the other ones are
inspected so you are not back again.
Jeffrey Bumpus: Okay.
t7
9.B.1
Packet Pg. 182 Attachment: JEFFREY BUMPUS - ADMIN COMPLAINT 2018-04 MISCONDUCT [Revision 1] (8020 : JEFFREY BUMPUS–NORTHERN BREEZE –
December 19,2018
Richard Joslin: What's the time span on the rest of them - I know some are "after
Christmas" but ... ?
Jeffrey Bumpus: Yeah ... by the hrst of the year, everybody should be back from up
north and I've got four or five that I'm calling on Friday. If I leave a note on the
door, nobody calls. So, I'lljust take a chance for $75.00 and call in a re-inspection.
Assistant County Attorney Noell: To go back to the procedural history of this
matter, my recollection is that he was found in violation. That decision was made and
then the Board was waiting to see what actions he would take during this interim
period before they discussed imposition of a penalty. From the County's perspective,
I don't think the matter is resolved. There as a violation that was found, and he has
taken steps to correct that. The steps that he has taken - even though he is in
compliance by moving to close out the permits - that doesn't resolve the violations
that were there. He has attempting to mitigate so when this Board does make a ruling
on the penalty phase, he will be able to represent the actions that he has taken the past
couple of months. He is pursuing closing them out, but they are not closed out at this
juncture. So, unless the Board is going to rule now as far as a penalty and trust that
over the next couple of months, he's not going to come back before under new
violations for these permits - then, technically, it would be continuing this on until
they are closed out if the Board wishes to hear that the mitigation has been fully
resolved and completed. At this point, the fact that the things Mr. Bumpus has done
to mitigate has been pulling the permits which are still open. Now if he does not
close these out, it could be a new violation for him. I hope I'm making sense as far as
the distinction here.
Jeb Schneck, Attorney for the Board: If I may add on to what Kevin said ... the
Board in the September Order found the Respondent guilty of the violations and of
misconduct. The Board also put a limit, or a restriction, on his permit pulling
privileges. Right now, he cannot pull a permit unless it is associated with the
outstanding permits. That restfiction remains today and will remain so until the
Board takes further action. The second part of the Board's Order as far as discipline
and penalties is the recommendation to the State's Construction Industry Licensing
Board ("CILB"). The Board has withheld sending any recommendation to this point
- awaiting the results of the last thirty days and his addressing the outstanding issues.
The Board can continue to follow this matter on a monthly basis obtaining status
reports until all the permits are closed out. Then the Board can make another Finding
and rescind its Order to remove the restriction on Mr. Bumpus' permit pulling
privileges and make any type of recommendation to the CILB at that time. If there
are additional violations, the Board can take the appropriate action.
Richard Joslin: I don't want to open a new can ofworms but if, by some chance, he
does not close them out - it probably would be better to continue this to the next
meeting. He said he could get the permits closed out by Christmas ... it's Chdstmas.
Do you think you will be able to close out all the permits?
Jeffrey Bumpus: Yes. I believe you said at the last meeting that as long as
everyhing was 1fi)% completed, that the Building Department could make the
decision to put everything back into effect. If I get them all completed on Friday, the
Building Department could put my license into "active" and I wouldn't need to come
back before the Board. It doesn't matter - whatever you want to do.
18
9.B.1
Packet Pg. 183 Attachment: JEFFREY BUMPUS - ADMIN COMPLAINT 2018-04 MISCONDUCT [Revision 1] (8020 : JEFFREY BUMPUS–NORTHERN BREEZE –
December 19,2018
Richard Joslin: Technically, the Order is still open - all we've done is modifu it to
allow you to finish out the permits that were void and open.
Jeffrey Bumpus: Correct.
Richard Joslin: That was the question then. There is still the penalty phase and we
can pursue it.
Jeffrey Bumpus: Right.
Richard Joslin: Because of the time delays, it's not quite over yet. It's yourjob to
finish the permits so we can make a decision and that's up to the Board. At the
moment, I would continue it.
Chairman Boyd asked the members for thet opinions ... closing this out or
continuing it.
Richard Joslin asked Staff for a recommendation.
Terry Jerulle: I believe at the last meeting, I recommended that we inform the State
of the violations, but I was voted down - which is okay. If I understood Mr. Bumpus
correctly - you were at the County last Friday?
Jeffrey Bumpus: Yes.
Terry Jerulle: And you didn't do anything last month until last Friday?
Jeffrey Bumpus: Correct.
Terry Jerulle: You have proved my point. You only do things at the last minute -
just to get by, instead ofjust finishing it. I'm still of the same opinion - we should
just tell the State and by the time it gets to the State, it will give him the opportunity
to finish this. You're right - Christmas time is the hardest time of the year to do
anlthing because people aren't around. But that's not my problem or the Board's
problem.
Richard Joslin moved to approve continuing Case #2018-04 for an additional thirf
days or until the next Board meeting. If the remaining pennits have not received a
Certificate of Completion b! the next meeting, the Board will send its
recommendation lo lhe Slate's Construclion Industry Licensing Board ("CILB").
The Board will also decide the penalty phase at its next meeting.
Terry Jerulle: We just keep moving along.
Richard Joslin: I know.
Terry Jerulle: And next month, we'll still keep moving along.
Richard Joslin : I know - I' m caught between a rock and a hard place here as for as
the motion goes. But I think for the residents of Collier County, I think this is the
best decision.
Chairman Boyd called for a Second on the motion. (There was none.)
(The motion died.)
Vice Chairman Lantz pointed out Mr. Bumpus' permit pulling privileges were still
restricted until such time as all the permits were closed out.
l9
Vice Chairman l-a,ntz moved to:. Continue the restrictions in effect on the permit pulling privileges of Jeffrey
Bumpus until remaining permils are closed,
9.B.1
Packet Pg. 184 Attachment: JEFFREY BUMPUS - ADMIN COMPLAINT 2018-04 MISCONDUCT [Revision 1] (8020 : JEFFREY BUMPUS–NORTHERN BREEZE –
December 19, 2018
o Approve concluding the Board's hearing ol this case, and
. Approve sending a recommendationJorfurlher action to lhe Slale's
Construction Induslry Licensing Board ("CILB").
Assistant County Attorney Noell: For the record, I think the same leverage will be
on Mr. Bumpus because I am sure that when the State starts looking into the matter,
the Regional Investigator will have questions concerning whether or not the permits
are closed out. That may be a month or two down the road before the State contacts
Mr. Bumpus -- if it decides to do so. It's may be even stronger leverage for Mr.
Bumpus to close the permits out.
Chairman Boyd asked for a Second on the motion.
Attorney Jeb Schneck: Just for clarification, Mr. Chairman, as far as the penalty
recommended that the Board will send to the State along with the case, would you
like a general statement to ptusue all penalties under Chapter 49 or does the Board
have a specific recommendation?
Richard Joslin: That's one of the reasons why I didn't go that route - because the
penalty phase hasn't come up yet.
Vice Chairman Lantz: We don't have to ...
Attorney Jeb Schneck: The action you are taking now is, essentially, a follow-up
letter to the State with the Order from last month's meeting and having a specific
recommendation that the State's CILB take further action. You can identiff certain
actions, i.e., suspension of a license or permit restrictions or monetary penalties such
as fines ... or you can make a broad statement to take any further action that is
deemed to be appropriate.
Vice Chairman Lantz: Personally, I would like to see a general statement.
Chairman Boyd asked if the Vice Chair was willing to amend his motion and Mr.
Lantz agreed.
Chairman Boyd again called for a Second on the motion.
Matthew Nolton: I'm not sure I fully understand the motion. I'd like to hear it
again.
Vice Chairman l-antz moved to:
. Continue the restictions on the permit pulling privileges of leffrey Bumpus
currently in effect in Collier County until the remaining permils are clased;
. Approve concluding the Board's hearing of thk case, and
. Approve sending a general recommendation to the Slate's Construction
Industry Licensing Board ("CILB") for further action.
20
Everildo Ybaceta: Mr. Bumpus, are you going to pursue your license or your
business as far as pulling permits in the future. I believe previously you said you
were just going to do maintenance work.
Jeffrey Bumpus: Yes, chances are I'm not going to use my license once I get all this
done - it will probably be closed. I can't be 100%, but I'm pretty close.
Matthew Noltonl I think that whatever motion you make has to have some penalty
recommendation - whether it's generic or general - something like "to the fullest
extent possible." I don't know if we could contemplate making it more specific -
9.B.1
Packet Pg. 185 Attachment: JEFFREY BUMPUS - ADMIN COMPLAINT 2018-04 MISCONDUCT [Revision 1] (8020 : JEFFREY BUMPUS–NORTHERN BREEZE –
December 19,2018
stating if the permits are not closed out within the next thirty days, we will
recommend to the County that he is to be reported to the State with terms like a
suspension ofhis license and a $10,000 hne.
Vice Chairman Lantz: You are saying to recommend that if the permits are
not closed out within the next thirty days, we request the maximum penalty possible?
Matthew Nolton: Something like that so that we're done with it and we haven't just
left it to chance to someone else - we've put in a penalty to the options.
Vice Chairman Lantz: Is that a Second with the amendment?
Matthew Nolton: It would be.
Vice Chairman Lantzt I will modify my motion.
Vice Chairman lantz moved to:
c Continue the restrictions on the permit pulling privileges of Jeffrey Bumpus
currently in effect in Collier CounE until the remaining permils are closedl
. Approve concluding the Board's heafing of this case, and
. Approve directing Collier Counry Stuff to send a written recommendation to
the State's Construclion Induslry Licensing Board ("CILB") requesting
enforcement of the maximum penahies possible, i.e., suspension of leffrey
Bumpus' license and imposing aJine of $10'000 if the remaining permits
are not closed out within thifi days.
Matthew Nolton offered a Second in support of the motion.
Chairman Boyd called for a vote on the motion. Carried unan nously, 6 - 0.
Chairman Boyd stated the case was closed.
X. PUBLIC HEARING:
A. Case 2018-10: Board of County Commissioners' Plaintiff, vs. Stephen Bowles,
dlbla Jackson Poals, Respondent - Misconduct of a State-Certified
Contractor
(No1!9: The individuals who testified in the following case under ltem X, "Public
Hearing," were Jirst sworn in by the Attorney for the Board.)
Terry Jerulle: Mr. Chairman, my company has used Jackson Pools in the past. I
don't believe I know Mr. Bowles. I don't know if you know me.
Stephen Bowles: No, sir.
Terry Jerulle: It's been ten years or longer since I've used them. I am disclosing
this fact - I don't know that it would have any impact on my decisions or my thought
process.
Richard Joslin pointed out there are two "Jackson Pools" in business. There was a
Jackson Pool Construction and a Jackson Pool Service.
Stephen Bowles: We are Jackson Pool Service.
Terry Jerulle: Oh, then I take il back. My mistake. Thank you for pointing that out.
2l
9.B.1
Packet Pg. 186 Attachment: JEFFREY BUMPUS - ADMIN COMPLAINT 2018-04 MISCONDUCT [Revision 1] (8020 : JEFFREY BUMPUS–NORTHERN BREEZE –
02/20/2019
COLLIER COUNTY
Contractor Licensing Board
Item Number: 11.A
Item Summary: WEDNESDAY, MARCH 20, 2019
Meeting Date: 02/20/2019
Prepared by:
Title: – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Lilla Davis
02/12/2019 8:47 AM
Submitted by:
Title: Supervisor - Operations – Contractor Licensing Board
Name: Everildo Ybaceta
02/12/2019 8:47 AM
Approved By:
Review:
Contractor Licensing Board Lilla Davis Review Item Completed 02/12/2019 8:47 AM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Review Item Completed 02/12/2019 2:28 PM
Contractor Licensing Board Everildo Ybaceta Meeting Pending 02/20/2019 9:00 AM
11.A
Packet Pg. 187