The URL can be used to link to this page

CCPC Backup 02/07/2019 COLLIER COUNTY PLANNINU COMMISSION BACKUP February 7 , 2019 (REGULAR MEETING ) COLLIER COUNTY Collier County Planning Commission 1� 1, " Jay► .� AGENDA Board of County Commission Chambers Collier County Government Center 3299 Tamiami Trail East,3rd Floor Naples,FL 34112 February 7,2019 9:00 AM Mark Strain-Chairman Karen Homiak-Vice-Chair Edwin Fryer-Secretary Patrick Dearborn Karl Fry Stan Chrzanowski,Environmental Joseph Schmitt,Environmental Thomas Eastman,Collier County School Board Note: Individual speakers will be limited to 5 minutes on any item. Individuals selected to speak on behalf of an organization or group are encouraged and may be allotted 10 minutes to speak on an item if so recognized by the chairman. Persons wishing to have written or graphic materials included in the CCPC agenda packets must submit said material a minimum of 10 days prior to the respective public hearing. In any case, written materials intended to be considered by the CCPC shall be submitted to the appropriate county staff a minimum of seven days prior to the public hearing. All material used in presentations before the CCPC will become a permanent part of the record and will be available for presentation to the Board of County Commissioners if applicable. Any person who decides to appeal a decision of the CCPC will need a record of the proceedings pertaining thereto, and therefore may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made,which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. Collier County Planning Commission Page 1 Printed 1/31/2019 February 2019 1. Pledge of Allegiance 2. Roll Call by Secretary 3. Addenda to the Agenda 4. Planning Commission Absences 5. Approval of Minutes 6. BCC Report-Recaps 7. Chairman's Report 8. Consent Agenda 9. Public Hearings A. Advertised 1. ***This item has been continued from the January 17,2019 CCPC meeting*** PL20170004419/CP-2018-1: A Resolution of the Board of County Commissioners proposing amendment to the Collier County Growth Management Plan,Ordinance 89-05,as amended,specifically amending the Future Land Use Element and Map Series to add the Livingston Road/Veterans Memorial Boulevard East Residential Subdistrict to the Urban Mixed-Use District,to allow up to 420 multi family dwelling units,and furthermore directing transmittal of the amendment to the Florida Department of Economic Opportunity. The subject property is located on the south side of Veterans-Memorial Boulevard,just east of Livingston Road,in Section 13,Township 48 South,Range 25 East,Collier County,Florida,consisting of 35.57±acres.Per the applicant,item continued per CCPC 12/6/2018 meeting. [Transmittal hearing] (Coordinator: Corby Schmidt,AICP,Principal Planner) 2. ***This item has been continued from the January 17,2019 CCPC meeting.***An ordinance providing for establishment of a Water Pollution Control and Prevention Ordinance,providing for repeal of Ordinance No.87-79,as amended,and Resolution No.88-311; providing for inclusion in code of laws and ordinances; providing for conflict and severability; and providing for an effective date. (Coordinator: Danette Kinaszczuk,Pollution Control Manager] Collier County Planning Commission Page 2 Printed 1/31/2019 February 2019 3. LDC Amendments-An Ordinance of the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County,Florida,Amending Ordinance Number 04-41,as amended,the Collier County Land Development Code,which includes the comprehensive land regulations for the unincorporated area of Collier County,Florida,to add outdoor lighting limitations on single family dwellings,two family dwellings and duplex dwellings;to provide standards for tree replacement and tree removal in shopping centers; to allow additional pricing signage for facilities with fuel pumps and allow electronic message boards for price signage; to add standards and requirements for permanent emergency generators for single family and two family dwellings; by providing for: Section One,Recitals; Section Two,Findings of Fact; Section Three, Adoption of Amendments to the Land Development Code,more specifically amending the following: Chapter Four—Site Design and Development Standards, including Section 4.02.01 Dimensional Standards for Principal Uses in Base Zoning Districts,Section 4.02.08 Outside Lighting Requirements,Section 4.06.02 Buffer Requirements and Section 4.06.05 General Landscape Requirements,Chapter Five —Supplemental Standards,adding Section 5.03.07 Permanent Emergency Generators,and including Section 5.05.05 Facilities with Fuel Pumps,Section 5.06.00 Sign Regulations and Standards by Land Use Classification,and Section 5.06.06 Prohibited Signs; Section Four,Conflict and Severability; Section Five, Inclusion in the Collier County Land Development Code; and Section Six,Effective Date. [Coordinator: Jeremy Frantz,AICP,LDC Manager] B. Noticed 10. New Business A. Codifying Regularly Approved Deviations 11. Old Business 12. Public Comment 13. Adjourn Collier County Planning Commission Page 3 Printed 1/31/2019 CCPC February 7, 2019 LDCA —PL2O18-2769, PL2OO18-2632, Martha S. Vergara PI 7018-3669 & PL2O18-3486 From: CasanovaAlexandra <Alexandra.Casanova@colliercountyfl.gov> Sent: Thursday, January 10, 2019 11:43 AM To: Minutes and Records Cc: Ann P. Jennejohn; bellows_r; BosiMichael; RodriguezWanda; ashton_h; kendall_m; FrantzJeremy; SmithCamden; VelascoJessica Subject: Ad request for your review for ( LDCA) PL2018-2769, PL2018-2632, PL2018-3669, P12018-3486 Attachments: Ad Request.docx; Signed Ad request.pdf Good morning, Please process the attached and acknowledge receipt at your earliest convenience. The ordinance for these items are to follow, also just as a reminder,please be advised that, the (4) items for this ad request do not require a map. Thank you in advance, ,ore eUtd a &14,414044, Operations Coordinator-Zoning Division 2800 North Horseshoe Drive, Naples, FL 34104 Phone:239-252-2658 Note: Email Address Has Changed Alexandra.casanova{)colliercountv:i:i,.gov Tell us how we are doing by taking our Zoning Division Survey at http://bit.ly/CollierZoning. Co i r •ante Exceeding Expectations Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. if you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead; contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 January 9, 2019 Collier County Planning Commission Public Hearing Advertising Requirements Please publish the following Advertisement on January 18, 2019 and furnish proof of publication to the attention of Jeremy Frantz, LDC Manager in the Growth Management Department, Zoning Division, Zoning Services Section, 2800 North Horseshoe Drive, Naples, Florida 34104. The advertisement must be a 1/4 page advertisement, and the headline in the advertisement must be in a type no smaller than 18 point. The advertisement MUST NOT BE placed in that portion of the newspaper where legal notices and classified advertisements appear. Please reference the following on ALL Invoices: DIVISION: ZONING [Zoning Services Section] FUND & COST CENTER: 131-138326-649100-00000 PURCHASE ORDER NUMBER: 4500186698 Account Number: 076397 Authorized Designee signature for CCPC Advertising NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE OF INTENT TO CONSIDER AN ORDINANCE Notice is hereby given that a public hearing will be held by the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) at 9:00 A.M.,February 7, 2019, in the Board of County Commissioners meeting room, third floor, Collier Government Center, 3299 East Tamiami Trail,Naples FL.,to consider: AN ORDINANCE OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, AMENDING ORDINANCE NUMBER 04-41, AS AMENDED, THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, WHICH INCLUDES THE COMPREHENSIVE LAND REGULATIONS FOR THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, TO ADD OUTDOOR LIGHTING LIMITATIONS ON SINGLE FAMILY DWELLINGS, TWO FAMILY DWELLINGS AND DUPLEX DWELLINGS; TO PROVIDE STANDARDS FOR TREE REPLACEMENT AND TREE REMOVAL IN SHOPPING CENTERS; TO ALLOW ADDITIONAL PRICING SIGNAGE FOR FACILITIES WITH FUEL PUMPS AND ALLOW ELECTRONIC MESSAGE BOARDS FOR PRICE SIGNAGE; TO ADD STANDARDS AND REQUIREMENTS FOR PERMANENT EMERGENCY GENERATORS FOR SINGLE FAMILY AND TWO FAMILY DWELLINGS; BY PROVIDING FOR: SECTION ONE, RECITALS; SECTION TWO, FINDINGS OF FACT; SECTION THREE,ADOPTION OF AMENDMENTS TO THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, MORE SPECIFICALLY AMENDING THE FOLLOWING: CHAPTER FOUR — SITE DESIGN AND DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS, INCLUDING SECTION 4.02.01 DIMENSIONAL STANDARDS FOR PRINCIPAL USES IN BASE ZONING DISTRICTS, SECTION 4.02.08 OUTSIDE LIGHTING REQUIREMENTS, SECTION 4.06.02 BUFFER REQUIREMENTS AND SECTION 4.06.05 GENERAL LANDSCAPE REQUIREMENTS, CHAPTER FIVE — SUPPLEMENTAL STANDARDS, ADDING SECTION 5.03.07 PERMANENT EMERGENCY GENERATORS, AND INCLUDING SECTION 5.05.05 FACILITIES WITH FUEL PUMPS, SECTION 5.06.00 SIGN REGULATIONS AND STANDARDS BY LAND USE CLASSIFICATION, AND SECTION 5.06.06 PROHIBITED SIGNS; SECTION FOUR, CONFLICT AND SEVERABILITY; SECTION FIVE, INCLUSION IN THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE;AND SECTION SIX,EFFECTIVE DATE. All interested parties are invited to appear and be heard. Copies of the proposed ORDINANCE will be made available for inspection at the Collier County Clerk's office,fourth floor,Collier County Government Center, 3299 East Tamiami Trail, suite 401,Naples, FL, one week prior to the scheduled hearing. Written comments must be filed with the Zoning Division, Zoning Services Section, prior to February 7,2019. Any person who decides to appeal any decision of the Collier County Planning Commissioner will need a record of the proceedings pertaining thereto and therefore,may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made,which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based. If you are a person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding, you are entitled, at no cost to you,to the provision of certain assistance. Please contact the Collier County Facilities Management Division, located at 3335 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 101, Naples, FL 34112-5356, (239)252-8380, at least two days prior to the meeting. Assisted listening devices for the hearing impaired are available in the Board of County Commissioners Office. Collier County Planning Commission Mark Strain, Chairman Acct #068779 January 10, 2019 Attn: Legals Naples News Media 1100 Immokalee Road Naples, FL 34110 Re: LDC Amendments (PL2018-2769, PL2018-2632, PL2018-3669 & PL2018-3486) Dear Legals: Please advertise the above on Friday, January 18, 2019 and send the Affidavit of Publication, to this office. Thank you. Sincerely, Martha Vergara, Deputy Clerk P.O. #4500190197 January 9, 2019 Collier County Planning Commission Public Hearing Advertising Requirements Please publish the following Advertisement on January 18, 2019 and furnish proof of publication to the attention of the Board's Minutes and Records Department, 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 401, Naples, Florida 34112. The advertisement must be a 1/4 paqe advertisement, and the headline in the advertisement must be in a type no smaller than 18 point. The advertisement MUST NOT BE placed in that portion of the newspaper where legal notices and classified advertisements appear. Please reference the followin. on ALL Invoices: DIVISION: ZONING [Zoning Services Section] FUND & COST CENTER: 131-138326-649100-00000 PURCHASE ORDER NUMBER: 4500186698 Account Number: 076397 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE OF INTENT TO CONSIDER AN ORDINANCE Notice is hereby given that a public hearing will be held by the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) at 9:00 A.M.,February 7, 2019, in the Board of County Commissioners Meeting Room, Third Floor,Collier Government Center, 3299 Tamiami Trail East,Naples FL.,to consider: AN ORDINANCE OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, AMENDING ORDINANCE NUMBER 04-41, AS AMENDED, THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, WHICH INCLUDES THE COMPREHENSIVE LAND REGULATIONS FOR THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, TO ADD OUTDOOR LIGHTING LIMITATIONS ON SINGLE FAMILY DWELLINGS, TWO FAMILY DWELLINGS AND DUPLEX DWELLINGS; TO PROVIDE STANDARDS FOR TREE REPLACEMENT AND TREE REMOVAL IN SHOPPING CENTERS; TO ALLOW ADDITIONAL PRICING SIGNAGE FOR FACILITIES WITH FUEL PUMPS AND ALLOW ELECTRONIC MESSAGE BOARDS FOR PRICE SIGNAGE; TO ADD STANDARDS AND REQUIREMENTS FOR PERMANENT EMERGENCY GENERATORS FOR SINGLE FAMILY AND TWO FAMILY DWELLINGS; BY PROVIDING FOR: SECTION ONE, RECITALS; SECTION TWO, FINDINGS OF FACT; SECTION THREE,ADOPTION OF AMENDMENTS TO THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, MORE SPECIFICALLY AMENDING THE FOLLOWING: CHAPTER FOUR — SITE DESIGN AND DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS, INCLUDING SECTION 4.02.01 DIMENSIONAL STANDARDS FOR PRINCIPAL USES IN BASE ZONING DISTRICTS, SECTION 4.02.08 OUTSIDE LIGHTING REQUIREMENTS, SECTION 4.06.02 BUFFER REQUIREMENTS AND SECTION 4.06.05 GENERAL LANDSCAPE REQUIREMENTS, CHAPTER FIVE — SUPPLEMENTAL STANDARDS, ADDING SECTION 5.03.07 PERMANENT EMERGENCY GENERATORS, AND INCLUDING SECTION 5.05.05 FACILITIES WITH FUEL PUMPS, SECTION 5.06.00 SIGN REGULATIONS AND STANDARDS BY LAND USE CLASSIFICATION, AND SECTION 5.06.06 PROHIBITED SIGNS; SECTION FOUR, CONFLICT AND SEVERABILITY; SECTION FIVE, INCLUSION IN THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE; AND SECTION SIX, EFFECTIVE DATE. All interested parties are invited to appear and be heard. Copies of the proposed ORDINANCE will be made available for inspection at the Collier County Clerk's Office, Fourth Floor, Collier County Government Center, 3299 East Tamiami Trail, Suite 401, Naples, FL, one week prior to the scheduled hearing. Written comments must be filed with the Zoning Division, Zoning Services Section, prior to February 7,2019. Any person who decides to appeal any decision of the Collier County Planning Commissioner will need a record of the proceedings pertaining thereto and therefore, may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based. If you are a person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding, you are entitled, at no cost to you, to the provision of certain assistance. Please contact the Collier County Facilities Management Division, located at 3335 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 101,Naples, FL 34112-5356, (239)252-8380, at least two days prior to the meeting. Assisted listening devices for the hearing impaired are available in the Board of County Commissioners Office. Collier County Planning Commission Mark Strain, Chairman Martha S. Vergara From: Martha S. Vergara Sent: Thursday, January 10, 2019 1:13 PM To: Naples Daily News Legals Subject: LDCA PL2018-2769, 2632, 3669 &3486 (CCPC 2/7/19) Attachments: LDCA PL2018-2769, PL2018-2632, PL2018-3669 & PL2018-3486 (CCPC 2-7-19).doc; LDCA PL2018-2769, PL2018-2632, PL2018-3669 & PL2018-3486 (CCPC 2-7-19).docx Hello, Please advertise the following attached ad Friday, January 18, 2019. Please forward an ok when received, if you have any questions feel free to call me. Thanks, Martha/Vergaew, 13 MR Senior aerki PI I/nate*Er Reco-rths,Dept. Clerk,of the arcuit Er Vataei A dirkstinentt Bo-Gucci/ Office,: (239) 252-7240 Fcou (239) 252-8408 vnctethcv.verv.ea@collier- k4comi 1 Martha S. Vergara From: NDN-Legals <legals@naplesnews.com> Sent: Friday, January 11, 2019 8:24 AM To: Martha S. Vergara Subject: RE: ad 2207539 Attachments: ND-2207539.pdf External Message: Please use caution when opening attachments, clicking links, or replying to this message. Attached is your proof. From: Martha S.Vergara <Martha.Vergara@collierclerk.com> Sent:Thursday,January 10, 2019 1:13 PM To: NDN-Legals<legals@naplesnews.com> Subject: LDCA PL2018-2769, 2632, 3669 & 3486 (CCPC 2/7/19) Hello, Please advertise the following at/ached ad Frida �, Januar 1 , 2019. Please forward an ok when received, if you have any questions feel free to call me. Thanks, Martha/Vorgat-cv, i .ti -o ~ C Miiiirtutek Er Recorc14,Dept: Clerk/of the,C%,ar ' Court E Vc. A tment"/3 O : (239) 252-7240 Fooei (239) 2.52-8408 Please visit us on the web at http://prat k t us.mi e*castcomjs fth CL91 KBfRrn: D5sBicKN?domain colli*rcierrk.com This electronic communication is confidential and may contain privileged information intended solely for the named addressee(s). It may not be used or disclosed except for the purpose for which it has been sent. If you are not the intended recipient,you must not copy,distribute or take any action induced by or in reliance on information contained in this message. Unless expressly stated,opinions in this message are those of the individual sender and not of the Office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County. If you have received this communication in error, please notify the Clerk's Office by emailing klpdcsk(gcoliierderk.,corn quoting the sender and delete the message and any attached documents.The Collier County Clerk's Office accepts no liability or responsibility for any onward transmission or use of emails and attachments having left the aille!Ciel k c tor domain. Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 NOTICE OF.PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE OF INTENT TO CONSIDER AN ORDINANCE Notice is hereby given that a public hearing will be held by the Collier County Planning Commission(CCPC)at 9:00 A.M.,February 7,2019,in the Board of County Commissioners Meeting Room,Third Floor,Collier Government Center,3299 Tamiami Trail East,Naples FL.,to consider: AN ORDINANCE OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTYY, FLORIDA, AMENDING ORDINANCE NUMBER 04- 41, AS AMENDED, THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, WHICH INCLUDES THE COMPREHENSIVE LAND REGULATIONS FOR THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, TO ADD OUTDOOR LIGHTING LIMITATIONS ON SINGLE FAMILY DWELLINGS, TWO FAMILY DWELLINGS AND DUPLEX DWELLINGS; TO PROVIDE STANDARDS FOR TREE REPLACEMENT AND TREE REMOVAL IN SHOPPING CENTERS; TO ALLOW ADDITIONAL PRICING SIGNAGE FOR FACILITIES WITH FUEL PUMPS AND ALLOW ELECTRONIC MESSAGE BOARDS FOR PRICE SIGNAGE; TO ADD STANDARDS AND REQUIREMENTS FOR PERMANENT EMERGENCY GENERATORS FOR SINGLE FAMILY AND TWO FAMILY DWELLINGS; BY PROVIDING FOR: SECTION ONE, RECITALS; SECTION TWO, FINDINGS OF FACT; SECTION THREE, ADOPTION OF AMENDMENTS TO THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, MORE SPECIFICALLY AMENDING THE FOLLOWING: CHAPTER FOUR — SITE DESIGN AND DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS. INCLUDING SECTION 4.02.01 DIMENSIONAL STANDARDS FOR PRINCIPAL USES IN BASE ZONING DISTRICTS. SECTION 4.02.08 OUTSIDE LIGHTING REQUIREMENTS,SECTION 4.06.02 BUFFER REQUIREMENTS AND SECTION 4.06.05 GENERAL LANDSCAPE REQUIREMENTS, CHAPTER FIVE — SUPPLEMENTAL STANDARDS, ADDING SECTION 5.03.07 PERMANENT EMERGENCY GENERATORS, AND INCLUDING SECTION 5.05,05 FACILITIES WITH FUEL PUMPS,SECTION 5.06.00 SIGN REGULATIONS AND STANDARDS BY LAND USE CLASSIFICATION, AND SECTION 5.06.06 PROHIBITED SIGNS; SECTION FOUR,CONFLICT AND SEVERABILITY;SECTION FIVE,INCLUSION IN THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE;AND SECTION SIX, EFFECTIVE DATE. All interested parties are invited to appear and be heard. Copies of the proposed ORDINANCE will be made available for inspection at the Collier County Clerk's Office, Fourth Floor, Collier County Government Center. 3299 East Tamiami Trail, Suite 401, Naples,FL,one week prior to the scheduled hearing. Written comments must be filed with the.Zoning Division,Zoning Services Section,prior to February 7,2019. Any person who decides to appeal any decision of the Collier County Planning Commissioner will need a record of the proceedings pertaining thereto and therefore,may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made,which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based. If you are a person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding,you are entitled,at no cost to you.to the provision of certain assistance. Please contact the Collier County Facilities Management Division,located at 3335 Tamiami Trail East,Suite 101,Naples.FL 34112-5356,(239)252-8380,at least two days prior to the meeting. Assisted listening devices for the hearing impaired are available in the Board of County Commissioners Office. Collier County Planning Commission Mark Strain,Chairman January 18,2019 NPY10153Y ❑ PROOF O.K.BY: ❑ O.K.WITH CORRECTIONS BY: PLEASE READ CAREFULLY•SUBMIT CORRECTIONS ONLINE ADVERTISER:BCC_ZONING DEPARTMENT PROOF CREATED AT: 1/10/2019 4:51 PM SALES PERSON: Gloria Kennedy PROOF DUE:- PUBLICATION:ND-DAILY NEXT RUN DATE:01/18/19 ND-2207539.INDD SIZE:3 col X 9.25 in Martha S. Vergara From: Martha S. Vergara Sent: Friday, January 11, 2019 8:34 AM To: RodriguezWanda; FrantzJeremy; CasanovaAlexandra; VelascoJessica; SmithCamden Cc: NeetVirginia Subject: LDCA - CCPC 2/7/19 Meeting Attachments: ND-2207539.pdf Morning All, Attached is the ad proof for the LDCA going before the CCPC on 2/7/19. Please let me know if any changes are needed. Thanks, ivfmrtha,Vei' , a, BMR Senior Cle * MCv►,u ted Er R ecords-Dept. Clerk'of the-CCrcait Coourt F.r Value,Adjws"►nent Bcrvwd' Office/ (239) 252-7240 Fay' (239) 252-8408 E-m a l ,nw than verc6waecotl_.t.e__ttder__.coYw Martha S. Vergara From: NeetVirginia <Virginia.Neet@colliercountyfl.gov> Sent: Friday, January 11, 2019 11:33 AM To: Martha S. Vergara Cc: CasanovaAlexandra; VelascoJessica; RodriguezWanda Subject: FW: LDCA - CCPC 2/7/19 Meeting-gas station and batch Attachments: ND-2207539.pdf From:AshtonHeidi Sent: Friday,January 11, 2019 11:00 AM To: NeetVirginia <Virginia.Neet@colliercountyfl.gov> Cc:StoneScott<Scott.Stone@colliercountyfl.gov>; CrotteauKathynell <Kathynell.Crotteau@colliercountyfl.gov>; RodriguezWanda <Wanda.Rodriguez@colliercountyfl.gov>; HayesJessica <Jessica.Hayes@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: FW: LDCA-CCPC 2/7/19 Meeting-gas station and batch Approved! JeidsiiSon-tiico Heidi Ashton-Cicko Managing Assistant County Attorney Office of the Collier County Attorney 2800 North Horseshoe Drive, Suite 301 Naples, FL 34104 (239) 252-8400 From: NeetVirginia Sent: Friday,January 11, 2019 9:41 AM To: StoneScott<Scott.StoneC@colliercountyflpv>; AshtonHeidi<Heidi.Ashton(c@colliercountyfl,gov> Cc: CrotteauKathynell <Kathynell.Cmtteau_(;rccoil ercountt fl.gov>; RodriguezWanda <Wanda.Rodriguez@coiliercauntyfLgpv>; HayesJessica <Jessica.Haycs(c)colliercountyfl,,goy> Subject: FW: LDCA-CCPC 2/7/19 Meeting See attached for approval. Dinny Virginia A. Neet, FRP Office of the Collier County Attorney Telephone(239) 252-8066 - Fax (239) 252-6600 tlrtc1 F•lo da f. ,• r;•A(•''• • ••,c 0.=)[ . r..(.0 (h):101 'ecaionimail •":r 1 Martha S. Vergara From: Martha S.Vergara Sent: Friday, January 11, 2019 11:59 AM To: Naples Daily News Legals Subject: RE: ad 2207539 Hello, This ad has been reviewed and approved by the legal department. Please proceed with publishing as requested. Thanks, Martha From: NDN-Legals<legals@naplesnews.com> Sent: Friday,January 11, 2019 8:24 AM To: Martha S. Vergara <Martha.Vergara@collierclerk.com> Subject: RE: ad 2207539 External Message: Please use caution when opening attachments, clicking links, or replying to this message, Attached is your proof. From: Martha S.Vergara <Mdrtha.Vergargcpcollierclerk con» Sent:Thursday,January 10, 2019 1:13 PM To: NDN-Legals<legalsPnapiesnows.com> Subject: LDCA PL2018-2769, 2632, 3669 & 3486 (CCPC 2/7/19) Hello, Please advertise the following attached ad Friday, January 18, 2O19 Please forward an ok when received, if you have any questions feel free to call me. Thanks, Plourtha,Ver, * as MAR Sol/114Yr CLeek, 1+4Crukre4,Er Reccrrci*Dept. aerie/of the,Circwit Court Er Voakte/AdAustateint Board Office/: (239) 252-7240 Fag% (239) 252-8408 1 Martha S. Vergara From: FrantzJeremy <Jeremy.Frantz@colliercountyfl.gov> Sent: Friday, January 11, 2019 3:13 PM To: Martha S. Vergara; RodriguezWanda; CasanovaAlexandra; VelascoJessica; SmithCamden Cc: NeetVirginia; ashton_h Subject: RE: LDCA - CCPC 2/7/19 Meeting I have no changes. Respectfully, Jeremy Frantz,AICP Land Development Code Manager From: Martha S.Vergara <Martha.Vergara@collierclerk.com> Sent: Friday,January 11, 2019 8:34 AM To: RodriguezWanda <Wanda.Rodriguez@colliercountyfl.gov>; FrantzJeremy<Jeremy.Frantz@colliercountyfl.gov>; CasanovaAlexandra<Alexandra.Casanova@colliercountyfl.gov>; VelascoJessica <Jessica.Velasco@colliercountyfl.gov>; SmithCamden <Camden.Smith@colliercountyfl.gov> Cc: NeetVirginia <Virginia.Neet@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: LDCA-CCPC 2/7/19 Meeting Morning All, Attached is the ad proof for the LDCA going before the CCPC on 2/7/19. Please let me know if any changes are needed. Thanks, Mcu Ve4 ra, 13MN San' Clc-,rici Cruttes,Er R,ecord.&Dept. Clerk/of the/Circuit' Court E Value/A44 sttyne4At P o rc Office:: (239) 252-7240 Fax.: (239) 252-8408 E-rrux i,7i.' wt a t t a.v7Q. ° v Please visit us on the web at www.collierclerk.com This electronic communication is confidential and may contain privileged information intended solely for the named addressee(s). It may not be used or disclosed except for the purpose for which it has been sent. If you are not the intended recipient,you must not copy,distribute or take any action induced by or in reliance on information contained in this message. Unless expressly stated,opinions in this message are those of the individual sender and not of the Office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Collier County. If you have received this communication in error, please notify the Clerk's Office by emailing helpcilesk@col,lierclerkcom quoting 1 BMW ;ArwE1 NaplesNews.com Published Daily Naples,FL 34110 Affidavit of Publication State of Florida Counties of Collier and Lee Before the undersigned they serve as the authority, personally appeared Natalie Zollar who on oath says that she serves as Inside Sales Manager of the Naples Daily News, a daily newspaper published at Naples, in Collier County, Florida;distributed in Collier and Lee counties of Florida;that the attached copy of the advertising was published in said newspaper on dates listed.Affiant further says that the said Naples Daily News is a newspaper published at Na- ples,in said Collier County, Florida,and that the said newspaper has heretofore been continuously published in said Collier County, Florida; distributed in Collier and Lee counties of Florida,each day and has been entered as second class mail matter at the post office in Naples, in said Collier County, Florida,for a period of one year next preceding the first publication of the attached copy of advertisement; and affiant further says that he has neither paid nor promised any person, or corporation any discount, rebate, commission or refund for the purpose of securing this advertisement for publication in the said newspaper. Customer Ad Number Copyline P.O.# BCC/ZONING DEPARTMENT 2207539 PUBLIC HEARING 4500186698 Pub Dates January 18,2019 / ,ttL&LCY. 'i (Sig/?1/: ture of affiant) ;;;;;' KAROL E KANGAS I t.:, War/Public-StateofFlodda Sworn to and subscribed before me ,p( • Commlsslon#GGt26Ax1 •�.•v My Comm.Expires Jul 29,2021 This January18 2019 an ` � aanddll.aph WUaWKalryMn ard (J (Signature of affiant) 26A 1 FRIDAY,JANUARY 18,2019 1 NAPLES DAILY NEWS TSA absentee rate lower, but still high ASSOCIATED PRESS pay,for working over the Christmas 2,200 safety inspectors back to work. - , and New Year's holidays. The percentage of TSA officers ; Transportation Security Admini- Meanwhile, air traffic controllers missing work rose steadily last week kY stration officials say the rate of airport who also are working without pay lost but has declined slightlythis week,ac- .' 'r screeners missing work during the an effort to force the government to cording to the agency. partial government shutdown has sta- pay them.A federal judge Tuesday re- The agency said that only 4.6 per- l f- blitzed-but still at unusually high jeered their union's request for an inn- cent of passengers-or about 80,000 1., "' numbers -just before a three-day mediate temporary restraining order. out of 1.79 million people screened- A' holiday weekend that is likely to bring The National Air Traffic Controllers waited 15 minutes or longer in check- bigger airport crowds. Association and the Treasury Depart- point lines Wednesday. - oPi The TSA said Thursday that 6.1 per- ment employees'union argued that TSA could be facing a test by Friday cent of its airport screeners missed the Trump administration is violating of its ability to process airport crowds _---� work Wednesday. the Constitution and federal labor law with fewer workers. That's higher than the 5 percent ab- by requiring members to work without Last year,nearly 8 million people sentee rate on the same day last year pay.Another hearing in the case is set flew between Friday and Monday of but the second-straight decline after for Jan.31 the Martin Luther King Jr.Day holiday. �_e the sick-out rate surged to 7.7 percent The ranks of unpaid federal workers While that is less than the 9 million _ Sunday are growing.This week,the IRS said it who flew around the Memorial Day The percentage A TSA official said screeners this will recall thousands of workers to holiday,it is busier than most January i 9e a Tyi missing work rose steadily last week week should have received$500 bo- handle tax returns,and the Federal weekends. but has declined slightly this week, nuses and,for some,an extra day's Aviation Administration plans to bring according to the agency.RICK eowm ER/Aa NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING FREE SEMINARS NOTICE OF INTENT TO CONSIDER AN ORDINANCE Florida Domicile Notice is hereby given that a public hearing will be held by the Collier Comity Planning Commusiou(CCPC)at 9:00 A.M.,February 7,2019,in the Board of County Commissioners Meeting Room.Third Floor,Collier Government Center,3299 Tamiami Trail East,Naples FL.,to consider: AN ORDINANCE OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, AMENDING ORDINANCE NUMBER 04- A No State Income Tax 41,AS AMENDED,THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, WHICH INCLUDES THE COMPREHENSIVE LAND REGULATIONS FOR 1., Asset THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA,TO ADD A Favorable Asset Protection Laws OUTDOOR LIGHTING LIMITATIONS ON SINGLE FAMILY DWELLINGS,TWO FAMILY DWELLINGS AND DUPLEX DWELLINGS;TO PROVIDE STANDARDS A No State Estate or Gift Tax FOR TREE REPLACEMENT AND TREE REMOVAL IN SHOPPING CENTERS, TO ALLOW ADDITIONAL PRICING SIGNAGE FOR FACILITIES WITH Homestead Exe m p t i o n FUEL PUMPS AND ALLOW ELECTRONIC MESSAGE BOARDS FOR PRICE SIGNAGE;TO ADD STANDARDS AND REQUIREMENTS FOR PERMANENT 3 EMERGENCY GENERATORS FOR SINGLE FAMILY AND TWO FAMILY A Cap on Real Estate Tax Increases DWELLINGS; BY PROVIDING FOR: SECTION ONE, RECITALS; SECTION TWO,FINDINGS OF FACT;SECTION THREE,ADOPTION OF AMENDMENTS TO THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE,MORE SPECIFICALLY AMENDING Find out if Florida Domicile and the 2018 Tax Cuts can benefit you! ' THE FOLLOWING:CHAPTER FOUR-SITE DESIGN AND DEVELOPMENT y STANDARDS,INCLUDING SECTION 4.02.01 DIMENSIONAL STANDARDS FOR Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday PRINCIPAL USES IN BASE ZONING DISTRICTS,SECTION 4.02.08 OUTSIDE LIGHTING REQUIREMENTS,SECTION 4.06.02 BUFFER REQUIREMENTS AND January 22nd January 23rd January 24th January 25th SECTION 4.06.05 GENERAL LANDSCAPE REQUIREMENTS,CHAPTER FIVE 10:00am or 2:00pm 9:30am or 2:30pm 9:00am or 1:00pm 10:00am or 2:00pm - SUPPLEMENTAL STANDARDS, ADDING SECTION 5.03.07 PERMANENT EMERGENCY GENERATORS AND INCLUDING SECTION 5.05.05 FACILITIES WITH FUEL PUMPS,SECTION 5.06.00 SIGN REGULATIONS AND STANDARDS BY LAND USE CLASSIFICATION,AND SECTION 5.06.06 PROHIBITED SIGNS; - c SECTION FOUR,CONFLICT AND SEVERABILITY;SECTION FIVE.INCLUSION Location: IN THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE;AND SECTION SIX, EFFECTIVE DATE. Grey Oaks Building -� ' All interestedparties are invited to 2640 Golden Gate Pkwy 4206 appear and be heard. Copies of the proposed Naples,FL ORDINANCE will be made available for inspection at the Collier County Clerk's Office, (Corner Golden Gate Pkwy& ers.a Maw I Fourth Floor,Collier County Government Ccntcr,3299 East Tamiami Trail.Suite 401. Gary T.Crisci Airport Pulling Rd.) EdwardVSmith Naples,FL.one week prior to the scheduled hearing.Written comments must be filed with 044050 ADPAA,CRPOO AMMO, the Zoning Division,Zoning Services Section,prior to February 7,2019. Ren v ogrohosM"anagle, =a vera,ttP Any person who decides to appeal any decision of the Collier County Planning Commissioner rarvnrr will need a record of the proceedings pertaining thereto and therefore,may need to ensure C R I S C I weALrN N.t.t,,r rsi f K.1 that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made,which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based. MIA F., wwrrw. adydeahweaItti nen If you are a person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate inthisproeeeding,you are entitled,at no cost to you,to the provision of certain assistance -OR RESERVATIONS please.contact Jenne at 239-919-5901 or gcrisci@crisc,pwm.com Please contact the Collier County Facilities Management Division,located at 3335 Tamiami _. _..._ ___. Trail East,Suite 101,Naples,FL 341125356,(2399252-8380,at least two days prior to the meeting. Assisted listening devices for the hearing impaired are available in the Board of me news el i co.ir an.nn n: y County Commissioners OfficeFILL ryKAaalwe<tcv akeal«.,amara.mem r a v as.. I Rolm INlnembn SlPC,a rename broker-dealer.ser FARM el a .er Co Management is a generale entity Iron KAM IWJIx carp Khmers rmanael Rnnri PP n1 mats,eserml Collier County Planning Commission Mark Strain,Chairman January 18,2019 wwo.. io�?&I, LONGEST TRACK RECORD OF FOOT&ANKLE SURGERY towv A SUCCESS IN COLLIER COUNTY ,f. *..= 4 Facts About Your Feet & Ankles Advanced medicine 0 Heel pain in the morning can be easily resolved without surgery. & technologies for 0 Feel pebbles in the balls of your feet?May be a nerve tumor. fast pain relief 0 Diabetic foot infections kill more people than breast cancer and Now featuring AIDS. If diabetic or on blood thinner,see us now. custom total ankle 0 Ingrown toenails can lead to bone infection;we treat them fast. replacements! Board Certified In Reconstructive Anlde Surgery.Board Certaleo in Foot Surgery. (239)430-3668.www.NaplesPodiatrist.com OL Glenn W00dI0Y.DPM.AACE45 Ih RR1kR Patel,DPM.AACFAS Or.W.Drew Chapman:: .;_:>. Request Appointments Online Dr.KeIll Lam 'A--'[=S.DAPS Request 1 Avenue Noeh.Suite 83 '225:Tamiami Ira I EaSt S ' Quick Access To Appointments ® - C2 - 26A FRIDAY, JANUARY 18, 2019 1 NAPLES DAILY NEWS NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE OF INTENT TO CONSIDER AN ORDINANCE Notice is hereby given that a public hearing will be held by the Collier County Planning Commission(CCPC)at 9:00 A.M.,February 7,2019,in the Board of County Commissioners Meeting Room,Third Floor,Collier Government Center,3299 Tamiami Trail East,Naples FL.,to consider: AN ORDINANCE OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, AMENDING ORDINANCE NUMBER 04- 41, AS AMENDED, THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, WHICH INCLUDES THE COMPREHENSIVE LAND REGULATIONS FOR THE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, TO ADD OUTDOOR LIGHTING LIMITATIONS ON SINGLE FAMILY DWELLINGS, TWO FAMILY DWELLINGS AND DUPLEX DWELLINGS; TO PROVIDE STANDARDS FOR TREE REPLACEMENT AND TREE REMOVAL IN SHOPPING CENTERS; TO ALLOW ADDITIONAL PRICING SIGNAGE FOR FACILITIES WITH FUEL PUMPS AND ALLOW ELECTRONIC MESSAGE BOARDS FOR PRICE SIGNAGE; TO ADD STANDARDS AND REQUIREMENTS FOR PERMANENT EMERGENCY GENERATORS FOR SINGLE FAMILY AND TWO FAMILY DWELLINGS; BY PROVIDING FOR: SECTION ONE, RECITALS; SECTION TWO, FINDINGS OF FACT; SECTION THREE, ADOPTION OF AMENDMENTS TO THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE, MORE SPECIFICALLY AMENDING THE FOLLOWING: CHAPTER FOUR — SITE DESIGN AND DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS, INCLUDING SECTION 4.02.01 DIMENSIONAL STANDARDS FOR PRINCIPAL USES IN BASE ZONING DISTRICTS, SECTION 4.02.08 OUTSIDE LIGHTING REQUIREMENTS,SECTION 4.06.02 BUFFER REQUIREMENTS AND SECTION 4.06.05 GENERAL LANDSCAPE REQUIREMENTS, CHAPTER FIVE — SUPPLEMENTAL STANDARDS, ADDING SECTION 5.03.07 PERMANENT EMERGENCY GENERATORS, AND INCLUDING SECTION 5.05.05 FACILITIES WITH FUEL PUMPS, SECTION 5.06.00 SIGN REGULATIONS AND STANDARDS BY LAND USE CLASSIFICATION, AND SECTION 5.06.06 PROHIBITED SIGNS; SECTION FOUR,CONFLICT AND SEVERABILITY;SECTION FIVE,INCLUSION IN THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE;AND SECTION SIX, EFFECTIVE DATE. All interested parties are invited to appear and be heard. Copies of the proposed ORDINANCE will be made available for inspection at the Collier County Clerk's Office, Fourth Floor, Collier County Government Center, 3299 East Tamiami Trail, Suite 401, Naples,FL,one week prior to the scheduled hearing.Written comments must be filed with the Zoning Division,Zoning Services Section,prior to February 7,2019. Any person who decides to appeal any decision of the Collier County Planning Commissioner will need a record of the proceedings pertaining thereto and therefore,may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made,which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based. If you are a person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding,you are entitled,at no cost to you,to the provision of certain assistance. Please contact the Collier County Facilities Management Division,located at 3335 Tamiami Trail East,Suite 101,Naples,FL 34112-5356,(239)252-8380,at least two days prior to the meeting. Assisted listening devices for the hearing impaired are available in the Board of County Commissioners Office. Collier County Planning Commission Mark Strain,Chairman January 18,2019 ND-2207539 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING Notice is hereby given that the Collier County Planning Commission sitting as the Local Planning Agency and the Environmental Advisory Council, will hold a "Special" public meeting on January 31, 2019, commencing at 10:00 A.M. at CareerSource, Large Conference Room, located at 750 S. 5th Street, Immokalee, FL 34142. The purpose of the hearing is to consider: A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS PROPOSING AMENDMENTS TO THE COLLIER COUNTY GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN, ORDINANCE 89-05, AS AMENDED, RELATING TO THE IMMOKALEE AREA MASTER PLAN RESTUDY AND SPECIFICALLYAMENDING THE IMMOKALEE AREA MASTER PLAN ELEMENT AND THE IMMOKALEE FUTURE LAND USE MAP; AND FURTHERMORE RECOMMENDING.TRANSMITTAL OF THE H AMENDMENTS TO THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY. [PL20180002258] } a.'eE Rzs. a30E IMMOKAL€E FUTURE LAND USE MAP 0 ' a I - p t I<Lt CC . z 0 All interested parties are invited to appear and be heard. Copies of the proposed ,1 RESOLUTION will be made available for inspection at the GMD Zoning Division, Comprehensive Planning Section, 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr., Naples, between the hours Q of 8:00 A.M. and 5:00 PM., Monday through Friday. Furthermore,the materials will be toa made available for inspection at the Immokalee Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA) during the month of January 2019 located at 750 5th Street, Immokalee, FL. 34142. Any questions pertaining to the documents should be directed to the GMD Zoning Division, Community Planning Section. Written comments shall be filed with Principal Planner,Anita Jenkins prior to January 31,2019 will be read and considered at the public hearing. Any person who decides to appeal any decision of the Collier County Planning Commission will need a record of the proceedings pertaining thereto and therefore, may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based. If you are a person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding, you are entitled, at no cost to you, to the provision of certain assistance. Please contact the Collier County Facilities Management Division, located at 3335 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 101, Naples, FL 34112-5356, (239) 252- 8380, at least 1 week prior to the meeting. Assisted listening devices for the hearing impaired are available in the Board of County Commissioners Office. Mark P. Strain, Chairman Collier County Planning Commission January 11,2019 ND-2200066 3 CD SD CD zo- - 3 cmc. to < ' cD m =' n D _.v = Om -< . M CD 3 cn r% Z c�no --► r- z 0 m. m--1O C O r m oz = � W o C7 Do m C_W XI O 01/4-' CA)w O > C° of O -1 m O m O c-) a � u Z � -r1 z C � O 1 e=n-C12 Oo m -rl wm O g Q.i-i 0nr o � 0 > c M pmi r - z CD al O0 XI � Zzm ' 4--O C CG7o —i cn m O nCr) m o Ozi r- � o W " m z Mooz m -0 -f - • 33o ,I uc mmoo n -n° oro � p O o C7 p n N _ -1 n O) O -h m oo > cjc J ED z � Z 3 O D * m D > < c C n I--- -z-I -1 O m 0 OZ) cn P � cn m -o 171 z - --i cD rte- CDD -1 _{ CDD -s m mm O oD 'l7 rcoo m 3-r- c:..:,.......,:h4L? EnZ m ,- _-zej rm:C1C � � D(75 np1. � 73 0 > '< -i W o - z X M m7 =i nm n , 1 z = m z Liv O z ,\. rn 2 CD SU m D CD CD CO CI) CLI CD vC rt =C I 11) n D Ci) ►. 2 w 20 m Do F D � � _r 0- r- ,�; CD 0 oom M � m33 = O mcn e � m � �� n 2c7) m Z Cl)i00 p--1 z0 z -H 'p --I 0 m O �\ J m xi -zi —1 v , ,x ji. --9 --I u) m 2 r< o 0 >ZZ Al .-L7 Mm m G� Zz \ ' O -0 -1 rn ---Izm "4 XIO O Coi.i m -G z . -- W � r .. Z7 r-- 0 ^-1 Al --IM G0N D D o �/� Z M Z 2 -WG w z 0 C --I Z en D CD "'I 0 xi -i 2 G7 w Q = O m m D D o ^^m m 73 n CCD -0 CL -"I O O m -1 D to c co m ' O � m c, 0 0 o — m-n i � m r' co O mnQ x C <W g 3 -I0 oor- 0c0 = O 0 0 D a m r- coo O 0 � a O O moo m mZry T o r- 0O0 0O O0 o _ C7 DO r o 7:3 cri rTl Oz � Z cm > D 0 0 D � m z Cn r- -I .,,%„„, � Oo rt0 I op CD 7,1 D � S Dm m_iiDD -4 mm OOmcm D � xD mn vn mi) -I C1 0 Z - 11 O0 V71 m i) 7 ` Dm m cnm = Z < z V) D -I M 0 V) m O -D-I C) 20 0 DDD Ni I- M Z � 6r D pz I-' K0C xi 0D -C z �' c - Em 2 -' oma 73 m zU' cn C) -< z 2 0 D 73 Z a) m zo 3 ^: CO W C � n D ZCO CO P a) D 5 � r < 73 o C 0co m o ° m z =ccn -i I D " -'b z � m � Z • 0� � o1 � p c xlmm -1 z o 2 ir M Oo m o > W c M -+ D O v o z Cr)Xi o ca caOD --1 m m. DOr�- ,17 - m Z 2Sm zo o CC2 = c� � -1 - �' W © a - CD a QT � � mm .Cmm --1 _< -" cox' y o m � T Danz 3 ow p x x O Z Z 'r' �` J) O Ccoo OO C7 CnmT Tzo Qrc, 0O coD • MzM0OZ T M x mp V O occu Z Opo C —I On C1 ° n -V. C- m o o Doo r'> v z 5 Z m z m > * m O D -< � F z x n - n cn r --1 D '� Om O �) C 'O m mmK = m D mxi zoD 1 r- m og v �o ':I m O=Al 50 Z < z co 0 cc,„ r rnm � ] D O mT DOO Z r * F. `^ _o D "< -I 00 V' r C < -I = T xi m mx I n Z z 2 m X -1 c) ',C oz - m � 2 CD aa) C -a 3 CO � CD co CD C co C = . m E —I 0 DC7 cD 1 .=.... 2 0 m r 0 D � � r o0 0 o % C') op E � m � = f- 2 m o f =a o o Cz � m CLI:,) .- ZO rv zmz r, Og oo -I z --i ` VII rr- rnz O X > 0 m -1 --I co 0 7 x --I cnm 2 z0 To ...5)m O z xi m y 1 v y m m G) z �� T! r D m cn D 0 10 , 0 0 W m -< z g rpI �... * r0 p o D W o Z � m Z = -< o -2 o C x _i -� z6, D CD = 0c rn0 ` ' o - o O m CI). D O -I 0pm m , D C N c SU pap r O � -C-i m ( _s• r_ rnm P3 -1mz , 0 mO 707 rn �-. W --1 cn . ooo = 0. -- 1moo 2OnXo rt O r- cnp cj0zm ill .� TI iZ -ICz OA 'a• =■ o � C m mzN C1 I O 0 CO D• O o - R IQ m O Z o -=I D v rnz (*CI CO o � D apo O 71 m o '"' W � m Cf) �- Q N CD m � m o omm cn m cn m o � v oc v xi xi m0 �Tl C7 --icn •1 D m m cn m = z (n 0 W D m G7 CA m O 11 0 2 GD) 0 D D D r- m m Z o 1- D oz r moo oo z0W -V.),., -< � m 2 SOH (IA m z u' Vt c5 C7 -< 0 > (.1'1 XI G lc) SD CD D CO� . . co CD ECO , A) xi -v =0 m Do `rt° _. _ CD C) w z � � � = 1--___. 0 zv) m cnmc O � z CP omz 14 O 0) 0 -1 z z ---I , -< • r -- r - m - O o > o 0i oz = 0 -370 oc 7 D ymm G) zz C TI r0 m cnDn 73 0 0 w m z 1- co ' - r0 � m * W ) D Z m Z = moo t z 0 c -1 z cs, D (D --1 7) _, = G7 w Q T M � � � n � Fr3 v -� O p .TI m D N 0 a. cn co = � O � -=-im . . _� r mm xl --imz c) 0 —1 m ?' -G -O- m "-- 0 co o O = z Q 373 c mow m —1 c � opo = —I m oo , 7320 10 r Co O D02 .� .71 7,1,11 DCz d\ �• .. O 073co m mzN T C _I o° �O o _1 0 n C/) y r _ O D :C7 R- a �P, D zo , Z � mz rn 0 z D co 1- --I 73 D Fri O 1 m -u m cn D ' s ' CD N. p K-) ?., DD --I z p m � m O omm o 73 D mc0 ci)m o * co oz � = c 0 m m0 e1 0 --Icn 7) D mm w rn = -1 mGZ-) � m0 - O i C )= 0 O D D D r m m Z p - m pz r- 0r D oD mmED -rG � m 2 � O -< x m z � cn 0 -< z 2 G.) D X CD SI) CD D CCO `° CD -<-CI0 = = c s 'r O. E_ SU _ M -= ncco momD 0 m D 0 r-r r I- 611 r 0orom- 0 C7 corn m � m � = 1 3 m ccn -z-I Cn .ZO7 p c•-D. I, m � 0 cnmc Z z 0 m z 101 0 -p � _-1 0 m 0 � Ah m mz 0 W0 � e...."'".� M o z 2 � G z '�, 0 iti D mo m o z z- T r 0 m cn D m xi 0 ZS _OC m m r co * ON)r 0 \ `p N Z Z J CQ 2 0 � _,4m0w Q. m G7 o MD D M 0 CSD '-1 OOm --1 D r Cn c 03 -I 73 0 j m •- a - m r ; -< 0CnCD o CD -I— m 0 3C maw m 2 --1 ccnn oco - m= O 0 C7D 0 —1 -r1 -I 77 z D 0 I— v.) o O coz mrn_ z m 110° z G ; 7. -I • m = C') 0 X Z m6N 72 -1 o n co Dco cp OC o 2 =1 0 D x c4 D m oz Z om �b * 0 zc) � "7 -I Cn i-- --I D N---I 0 0 m CO-IJ GIN CD 13 D m _1 D c . - 't kb M mm 0 cpm oc mw0 m o * p o0m "O m0 XI X -Icmn - D m m cn m = lik Z < z CO o m D co m O D C) = 0 0 D D D r m m Z 73 o I- M oz r roo E. D -< m m W r- c < -I -I 0 -< m m z (' v. C) -< z 2 o D P3 CD nn)i //�� z O a iii rr CD -. =CO CD 0 W x FFI = a O D zc COi` SU n xl 0 z '� = n M D -< cD O D � K r- < 70 CCD C) o, m M � o 5 -/- CCn -zi --I D (D ,.l O m �" m ^ o Z 22 o — 0 z 0 - c O -iI cnm O oo -, � Z o Z = --� 0 00 o, 0'1 'Ti r- o T -c-I> O m _ zOD) ,?'i xi 0 O D D Z .- T Z oho- —1CO _ � � --i � oco ,N, a co -rn-I oo o W> o ^' D 6 CC/ -173DOop v. o �" m > ° z = .m, M �7 m 0 m D p.�,. --1 O -n "< Cncf) C7 F`' CD 0 C coo —I Cn K "0 rrrl --I p /'-'1 M -n ___I n Amo �--( r" wo O zcoD rn IC-n- z M o � z "0 21 m Mxxo -no CI� o (77\ jV ci N O O -i.2n Cn 0 c rn OS Z � zm Q� 0a -< C )C::?. � m I m -o M z ---1Dm -IUjS O o M m y mT z � CA o � 0 mr . t rn = 0 2b y r cj Z < z V) 0 {''S v —I '" D Cn U..) --i n r mm O mz �> (A)Z > D oz r- * p I- c < -I mm s -< � m 2 = O rn m x C`a cn 0 nm z 2 mz 0 > 23 0 -73 o 0 z -I _ � m 2 CD es D D 0 C 3 rt CO -< CD F.' = CD TJ 0 W 70 _ - a cia c _ 0.Fir n 17 = O m 0 -G IR. !/V 0 C z M _I � I CD = 3 m � � -I � D � C) zv, m z1 z O rn z v 2 I 0 -1O c O r mz oN 3.m O m = 0 oo ti v > o m � w (� m --1D O '0 --I zcn CoW0 -- 0 O o > - X .-- z z m Z 0 0 iCO --1 0x c -1oo n -, CD rn � m Cnmp0 Cr-Ct. a , y oX � 0 0 Cf) c� tU r- mcn Ox, xz m � � pmz p 2 � Oz - m 3 --i co 0 c -i08 m mm C7 Amo 0 o O r ( o O zco> 0 m O r- Z S'' 0 z NO 77 ?7 M Z7 .ZD1 0 .- �. ON ^ CI O _ ...4pO o m 00 D 0zm v z 0 D ` D Fz al055 W m O r w m m 73 m D D '-I m rri' O o › ` _ (q � cn 0 m r � -1 m0 cn O � r mm z m = > D p z z * �F-a 77 0 D -< --I W I- cc -I = m m = = m0 I _. 73 m m ti cn C) m 0 D Xz X) o0 -i z _ � mz CDD SU C -a 3 al. CO C m (0 CD m p =- m r C = r �D 0. n D co CO n) _ - limim s r m0 m r- o CDrh Au 0:1 Fri CDn K = �� 3 corn m m � mzC ,,cn -1 I O0 4 n zc m com0 " Z O cnz ' 5 m z z J 0 cnoo —I zz -I S . r mz ADO G M xi -i --I cn G) , M co m0z zo UV M r0 171 cnDO M X 00 C m � z r co •••••-• r 0 =gym * WN Z -Dn Z = -<83 o CO 2 C --1z6, n _ CD = G� C �--1 m 0 w O. m M 0K M CPDD a o ^^mv 33 -n CA r0 � CD -0 0.i > =o O X < m co _� �i r mm Xi � mz 0 m � r OCno on �..�' mm -i= m m Q � x O mnw W 3 --I m0 C cor - m K O C 0 = 0 0 0 D 2 - S -• Or- cn0 O 0Go �TmzM -IC n Z �.. -n r --I CO �O o c` CI) _ O > X> R F.?, I. r D � m 0 zoo 7 �7 r cn I- - D -I0o 't QQ 1 CO cn U.im D - TJ r CDD � Zoe n �.` m mm p DCmnm G --1 m0 co m ,D O o z 0 O D D D rm m Z p r (. M 0 z P" K O r m 133 D '� z O xi � -< 0 co m 2 -' oma M 0 cn C) -< z 2 0 a Xi CD Q3 CDCD DC7 a a CO --<< r0 CSD CD = CD r -< om esw -o O al Xi = C -< o = �., O. r D Z c CQ - 23 C)0 z CD 3 m com � � c = C) z Iri `- z ) N z O m v' c� I�r M � o ---1 CI P- z i, "0 -a c o �` mzcs, p\ 0 y m ITI co w TI r c ITT --I D O 'U - Z co xi 00 to 030 > -i > — . r' m D Z m Z o � o „� -I 0 � C -D-� o o D CD -o 2 c --i co _ M o � m s -< a .� O m (� m O o CDD 5 D -IX mono � n Ala fld O 0 CDC HHH ? ._.I M mm -I xDmw 'a O Ir mp O2w > mn ; z m o , z m o �` n-1v op 3 rt O o z000- ---IQ n cn 2 C7 . (� f 2 -+ o D om c� "' o c D � m �7D � nc �� :r:; Cn rr- --I-I � � 0al 0 m0Im y m z --I CD }mm o D D o �cr) D zr- m o < v cno73 m � xi - mZ < z Cm/? 73 Ca r -< `t � m-I y Cn w �►� n zo O m = �l r- mm xiD D o0Z r- *� 0 oD -< =1W ri r- c c -4 = m 1 -G m 2 = m X m mX cn 0 n r z D mz c' 73 > 1 o0 _ 0 m 73 CD ID Cl) D 13 3 CO CD-c C `° CD -D O = v co c - IS g Q rD � � a) n 13 IP' -I 0 73 D 2 .� = p ITI r O ,--1- Dr. C7Wrr- = CD m � z - � � � � 3 v—' —i --I cn00 . 1r- C) Z � m cnmc ' O O � O z v m oE► g cn 0 ---I z z --I `. I— -E1 -1 D O m � - -I cnc7 2D N- -I U, m zo Cr) N m pzxi FOZ ri -n r0 m CnD—I z m �1 U 00 Z3 m -< Z O � co � r0 � m _ * WN D Z m z = -°< � CO z o c --1 z U, D CD m OC mCi) 1---CmjDD ° ^� C0 Cr) C-13 -0 "'i Op m = D cn c W = � O � � m vi _s A) r mm X) --Imz 0 m -< oho o -I Om O = zD O x73 C m0 --I m O co r -< = 00 0 D D X r- opo O D 0 E O m r z m D W Z �•1. O 73c m N mz Or- Z Oo n > -4 2 N —I OCno , mpDr ��oDSD M z D -' N O Ci) rr- -Z1 mOo ,_,. ►k I m � m cn 0 " C P r >cn D z CSD. m � m 0 omm C./) o * nli 73 m O O = > m M cn m = 1 < _ --II m07 Cl) m0 -DIrp C) = GD7 0 DDD a- mm Z mor r > oz r K X/ D D -< Z -ncor m = —I p0 -0 °< X m Z U' C n -< c D 4-1- 0 CCD CU CD 3 rt co -< o CD P �' _ -13 o W7, = �v c CC o� • Q 0D z c CQ CD -<Dv 2Omn2= _ nr =i = '•,... �D Owm � z �• 3 m m z � D • Z C7 v, --, n .-, m c o -1 Pz ( O '1o c O r- mZ oN cp Dm m CO vl o - -+ �" zCC,, XJ O D om V OO , �. O o > - x � z Z m Z o11-10 -MO -I o m c -Di 0 0 n o CD = O C m --"I -I 00 Q c O CO D 'I) C m o Ooo Cl)•• o Mi r mm iv x3Z 3 M fir-- 0M _ = o bHo cn - .� M m0 _O n D m a m mz M 0Oz `"� •T1 i m x x o O O � ZOoo C) --I O 0 j o o ` _ -Icy cnO v p Z ozm D * m O D40 5 0) r -1 -IOm 70 0 55 Q i co m --o m2 -I � � MoD M o (I) ° w lx i. iD mi m0 m xi r30 M -< Z -Z-1 m o 0) 0 cn r mm O mm 6 [� y mz r 73 r_. xi 0 D -< co r- c < --I mm "< m = 2oT M m X !* -1nm P3 0 O -1 4 Z " m CD 0 D D 0 -a 2 :D CO -z< r0 N 5D �' -‹ CD p m CD 0 0 w t su co C -< o 3 C > z c an Li A) -f c) ' > ---1 CD i ......... mi. > ;U - 3Ccom _1z z� " cD n za' rn ` z -I' Z O m p z M cO -1 co ,...? . r mz O oN -Icc)m m 2 G) ✓ ) yoITI co o m O -D --1 z co0-% 73 O CO 0 CAI O O EZEZ m D r m O 0D xR- Z Z � „ Z o .� o ;GQ 0 C Dmm o m o rn = -' MI 0. a y 0O O �1 00 p x N n CI _ � o o to 0 17 xi m m D 2 4� Z -I cn 2 m o `i•-•1 -a a- J co m TOGO Dci) mw 1" �7 r Cn O O z w D m ['Liz M oOz CI - CI l m � m 73 x0 �. O (j) -r_ Z 00C3 ra --I o ° wo-p Zzmv 0 m z _ v > -< mm - rn z = I- cD„ D -I ' cn � CD I m m O p � - 1 r- D m o * p ___,(7,3o 1 , �73 m O � D m rn m t ? �6 &)- -iZmo 5 -H r mm O mm Z D k. D01:3 Z.- < * � p3 o D -< I pp CD = m -< m 2 = 0 � �` x m 7333 C) m z 2 zm z o y mz " J CDD cC D0 , 3 r° CO -< r- m 5D �' CD -< pm CDD 0 m O cox = a, 03 c o = Er - tC2.' > Z c Ca 1 iU TI = 0 m 0 � ( - 0 co M ,__,x = C7 (r) -I I1 c' z � Z � Z O mz 0 zm O)) 0 -I P z O r rnz O o0 N L ) v oo m �_W U T1 r o 171 --I S xi O Cu V 0 O D OHHI nCO n o m —I 0 v � T mm If� 0 CD Ct. cr• D 0O 00DoX N o w co = x 000 to O p kr' 71- -0 O zzm = tD = K0 C coo LiN y cn m o m m00 •0 Amb 0 D cn • 74. —I � 2 m m0N n O O ZOO n• ° C7N 0 0 _ v � 0 D * m enc IWcn XIm � cmn 55 St O ;n m -o STI z --I cc, ) _ ) � M � A O � o --I-I D oCn n zr O = D X I- ? 0IkCN �- - D m0 m m -< L -I CA —I m 0 -65 0 ---I \\ r mm O 73D r\ D00 z z * p 73 oD 'G =I co - Em 2 -im !v j , x m me N 0 nm D V5 Z --I m 2 CSD c a a (O -< I CD CD = -< o m o co mm 0 . x KI) WC7 ^2 - -< Oa r D Z CCQ CUO --I MOM= 'V = o m (D) �. Z rF I- ! � _r < o =* Co �~ CD 0CmM -� z =� `� 1 3 C7 "' -4 m ? z - ' zN f Z O � z D zm E C„ O ,( Pz 1 0 c O , I" m z p • -Icnm = z0 z w 6') --\ 0 z ° m" 1 TI r 0 m --I > O -u) ,_,--1 --. z Cr) A7 > 7-\ r � 000 -'gym DCm D o T�Z m Z oo� � CDoon �D-I -1 = co m = -, m� 0 —I OO m coDxi y n _ x po0o W03 o CO r x m ow m D ^ 3 rF IT 1 m --n -i � cT nct) CD p � � O zzm 6-\' cn m Too 0 m � \/V O m ,[m- o M o � z "0 -n m � 73xo �' .... - W mnoo nO Z O VnOr 1, -I on V) U, O4' ('� m o � D 0zm D � z � f � mIT I CO CO m z _ CD m � D O � w > .. rmox ' "CI r = co 73 Dmm� -ZI m a CO G5 - -1 D r mm O m = Z = D xi 0 > c I- c --I = m -< ri-i 2 ?x m mx w 0m n O D X/ o0 z _ � m CDD 3 C Da 0 3 at: Co -< O N cD (Ct CD -< oo o m -u p co = r Co C 00 =' m o D 0z CCI 1 co 11 2 0 m D C . r �• e-h cD 1" r_" K r- --lo C ) CD mcom m =' o =cr. 1 0 z -i m - z • z C c�; 0 v nm0 r-Co Z H r- mz oN -mi cnZ= 0w C no m co -0 O 73 --Izccn C. xi rOW WOD I.1 O =I -_c° m DCm z a > Z 0 = O ;,CQ 2 ox C --ioci D o M xm CO m- 0 m a- CL D0O T °° oma Cl) 0 haN al _ o 0 cn o 73m �7 � mD 3 - M m7' -� o � n N. cp CD p x 7 O z z ''' - 3 M moo iMill n > mo S.73 0 r Ci) 0 OzCD A� m nz ooz -TT 71M 73 7J o � C m noo CI O 0 � Z 00c) Z --ice > w0 1; m O ° mC- z � r vK v D � DzC70n � r -I mm OX/ Kc mm m z � _ 0 WIK)> m � O o � ,1 xi Dm9. 0 m xco m0 CO G) --c- -I i -ID r mm O m = D D O0z r * r_). `� ri u c2 D -‹ -1 0o r- C _i = m v :, -< m 2 ? x m m x ►,, cn n n in 0 n m0 D Z1 O O Z r S m 73 CD IV 2 D - 3 N CD ea CD v CD73 co W C S mCL � DJ 20 m xi rO rt CD n x �rn r odor 0 3 0 ED M 11 rn m w �� cnOC) Z O zx0 0) m c N p m z • O- z (o p m0 � 1 r � z D zXG Vm � c_ Jz = 73 z +rnocD zmm zt 'l iD 'TI r- 0 m vD z -I z i Om —I .—. 'M 0 OW m �m k- � M MI 5- p00 0 Z m Z = , w ..._-1 0 C m 0`W 0. T O '- m DD 0. o m mcn rocas a) --I OO mJD co a D = � m0 ? < m cn maw co =1 �" r xrxi 00) o `�- - o m m - -� -I=' m �D O � � C mow kT1 g 2 = O p n D -II 73 m m -1 7) 22 O r- cnp O 0G) z M � z �Wz \�� -0 O � 00-13 m mzN � 71 "\- 0r °° O� o fU —I On Cr) > r -1.(7) m o � Z o = > • (\ � D D * m p zoo (� r —I D F z > m 0 8 O co M u rn � 0N C -0 D m y 0 m � O omm mm � m cn v � mw � m 0 * p oc -- p m 73 Dm0 m gym = Z < z to 0WD -1 m0 V) m0 -i 0 _ 0 O Dxr I- mm Z _7.3101- m13 p r mmpz r X06 m -n ° - m = O 7, - m m � w 0 -< z = GD > 73 D C7 co 'a = -< O N it? CO CD m cDv = O Wx Q n y zc CO � Pa G) Z "\ > 53 - o 5 {- \ 3 m u) -I --I-I m D : f V O izv' zn -� �. o M � o - I Pz \' N . --1 Q c 0 , r mz oN m oz 2 caw \ D cm m C_w `1 m r a m -I D f pj 00 ca co0 > f MI -gym m > r- m Z m Z oo o� z0 C > mm D g tD X 0K m = 0 -< 0- a (/) m- • 0- -n O cD n 00 A. 000 Cn o r Ico m m � mD \r ' rD O0 � 73 O zzN `v „ o C coc) m 2 CD � m = o '� M TO �p 0 � m0 Q 0 r- cn0 O z - > m rrliz M 0Oz - • -7-1 � 73c __ —. o � W z000 C7 -n rXmIv -74 -I o0 V) (904 � m Cn F. � D nom O J I CO 71 Dm m -ivi = ... r Cn D Cn D C7 D o r f� m o * p Cno g ximpm xW G Z m z CO 00 &5 r Z m m O X > D 0 z r * P x 0> = W 0 �� m '< 4 � � m 2m = o C7 0 m 1\ z 2 m z �` D � > 71 0z `Vv -I 0 mz t' ,0 i CD ill CD 2 _ GQ CD(I) co Q CD D O = _� = C = 0. nCU Mt 73 _ -o = o m i- o el CD D � � - oWro C) corn K m 3 MZ i =1 cKn � o 554 0 z � m cnmc Z O Nz D 0mz M cn0 --1 zz7<1 -0 z0 O m O co0 ° D m C Dm m G) zz (J "Ti r o m (7) D m xi rO 0 z \O o 'No CO Z � -Dn Z = � w '�J z O _ 2 0c _f mew T = CL o O m D D /� R7 ', �I r O W m D i i —I p p m D to a cr CO 03 = �m - r- m -� m z 0 el. r O cn o O x7 C mom rt--1 cP3 0c0 oo n70zN o �: O I— a, 0 O oc) z m D - D �1 S. 'mil T z C n'�' o 7' W m mzN (� C7 Yl K r --1 0 0 \� —I O C7 w Don O r- .cb a ol \ Oz - Z 0mz \� D * m CI D z0D I= > Cpoo O fn r -I -1 co mu) FN m' T Drn --1 > 004 n m � 0 oma o > m Co p \r` m o ,_ 0 oc -0 r = M X) -Icmn D m0 m cn - < z cn p WD D Cn O 0 = p 0 DDD \ 73 I- m m Z 7j o � Q D (--)73 z- 1"' mm ° mmW 1- c < -1 -zio � - m = cN x m z _i cn 0 -< o D D D0 -0 2 r° tO -< Or CD 51? p m cD c0 CD -n O W0 = 11) v CZ CI. C -< O = N n D z c cQ f, CU co z ' MIIMMI v = O m 0 �T' — CD r, m r -1 O > 55 3 m rn _,c �z nz - n zm - Z O mz 0 zm 0 1— m Z O N C (� -m-I cnm = Zc �' \16, N, M 0 ' C, Dm m c° (23 TI r 0 m D p3 Op W p3OD V ) E oo p --I K ;a --Im _� Dr- m Zm Zo o c� z0 c Dmp g m 2 G7C ""I -�� c lor m p � m = O � –.°‘ a fn m CL - -I Op m co > 70 y n Ma W m :L7 ,-‘ 000 0 N O r- mm P3 x73D -4 or+. M ter- omz Q x x O Z Z N CD W = = m „ - 71 n D m 0 0 m � pz E 0Sz ''� -n „ E azo CI -I �° cm (mj0N8 (I .71 -I O � to oo� x vm zz Z mczm P. C D " m t P. Fz DOO 71 Co NIDm = C 11m ..I D > o X D Or431 D r o * 0 c,, o H mW 4\ P Z < Z Cl)0c --I m 0 cn 1. — mm Z 73D 1 0 z r rr- J` l 00 = oo - m == m p 2.1 X m '1 mw cn 0 m c-- 0z Z m G) y D 73 -1 O ()IJ O Zrb -1 G) m r nJ. CD MI m m CD OCO -< CD CO CD rt n ----\ Fp:- 0- D Cl) co ID 73 = 0 m XJ r- 0 r° rMIMI 0 COM M � � CD 33 =CD r� M cn --� _� - x o z 0 2- -c7) m M-rjc"im, 0 0 z z -Zi (r`1 0 � _I O mG) < m oz = � 0z (T\ 0 Dmm m � zz m r0 m CADO r 0 M 0 0 W m -< Z 7] r co v X r 0 ZT Z = -< w 20 C --iz6, D —1 0x - G, w -1 = CD Ill 0 m m D D Q o Q � �, to r- C� Cn m v 0 o m = D N c D = < U) a' aro co IIIIM mN 0 a =im l M i O cn m n - 0 O xpoC mom g 2 o_ o �mmooz mrii z M -1 -1-1i T -. —. Oft ' 1 73 I M '1 73 73 m X Z N , v TI 0r -Z..1 0000 F. V. _ OO D Oro m O Z o = D � m 0 zoo d f-- 0 Cn r- � ffi moo 0 Ei r m y m O N M 1� r� mOommm m mmmox D mre� 0 10 m0 XI o —Icn d Drr, m cn = -� —ZI m0 0) ooD i� `N C) _ o O D 73 SD S r- mm Z Elor 1)\ n oz r Koo G� rxi oD -% m0 co -< mm m E :' w Cl --I o O D (1\ X 73 CD sy c -< o N CD = Ca CD m CD co C _WG O �o n D 2z co 13 vd. Q ` rimA) _° _= O rn nCD \ CD I– m 1-- --i 0 .-t' � < 73 p� O com M -_-io = 171 cz m cD �'�.. no z � m � z - Z gym„ z 0 z m v' 0 p c z PO r � z 0 . M oo x � � T O Dm rn Cw TI r o rn -1 > c-- O 'y — z w C S' ,-- coto 0O� D vQm -im M DCm Z m ZD10 ,. O=n� zo c > oo D - CD n -IO TI 00o (� N n aai DO m � ODoz ' i 3 r-F r xm omz 2 co wFr Cl1 Z = O xi73OZzr., .r.- . O a,.„ CG) o y o " Cr) 73 Fil I IT= O p 0 03 rnM b fl a. O7 m Ozm r o COO D CA1 m m � p D z 77 O � o mQoC) -n Or 73 -1 ' Z 0 n 0No OQ C Z7 • V zm v -0 D � n - 1 co � - m � � 0 r `yD � � D -o 71 > Zr- -q t m cn o *cn � jo o � m rn - mW = < z V) GG)) E5 m .' CI _ 0 O m = r mm z uD Dzr * ,-o =xi oo w --J rn zo- gym = x rn m73 2 n rm z = mz G) D 0 73 o 0 z ---I _ � m M W ! >- = o z V 65 / CW rx Q.1 5O = w � >- 0 U z F- < 0 J _i LL LU O m J Z O Q 0 m W < < < 0 ¢ ►2 v r Q m w V) CD w I- 2w0 CO w > Z woo ix 0w no- w z 0 C O W Cu Ctwo YY W eb, � d=a < I- wQ a GA 14.§ oQw canm J c p oOz Q z - CO �' wQ Q1 z o ' Z o O w N � w Z m � p V w I- = W D a. .— ..- USI— o- � I- �.o < ca < 5 z „ w O Z0-a p Ocn -I OC w 0¢cc, V 0 0 W m U w = XCC O milmia U ZO UO F-w ›"n o - w W cZ wF- (L __I CU 41 y Q > w o o � a .0 a 0 f- J w 0 ct H o -0 4. ¢ ¢ U W 0 LU = I- = Oa 0) �' om = Z LLY Z a No § M WI m I r� zz } L C) mO Q w Z I- I- Cl- 0 Z Z O W w < a �'' ZCDCt ' z0 W EIz _ = w , J- Lu T _ fx 3 Eii Q c i— Z w J - d O QQ F- ZZ IO Oc 5 Z Zw0 o Zw "� 0X _n W —Z UO E r Uwp � F- z � W CD o oo Lu co Q = El: :=Ii— U W o = J E- 0.. U S re U ~ d. co Q U J >.. wC am O a W 0) U) = 0 0 0) a M z IX AI D DC7 -03 f. � -< o n c? m' Wx =p W o = co C = D z 0 m D -< CD \k X. I— 111 -i 0 ;:g It CD3 cco —zi —I ,mD -� zus mZ M 0 ) o 0z 0 E rr- m z o0 t_m rrqoz x, _ N l'" Dm m co N m -+ D O -1:7 --I zcn Xi 0 0 O 17-1 M nD — o R. z Z -- m Z 0 0 =rr(12--. � � C Di0O D -1 m C2. 13 M % mm6p � a 00 coO cD Zi TI co CO � � .zD7 :oD a ... ,m- pmZ 3 O xI Ozzm - = Ho Ccoo m oTp C') � rno r. p O z W D Lk\ I 0"j� TI -�nz M �O � p .v.■ -' 10rn mpr" n o Opg Z ODv -i 0 n co DC7 .p 2 -i n cn p c � D m O � Z czm � m vD -< 0 Cl) r --� n O m 0 M CD CD m O � pD lir....13--rTlir_ortox" c�nDm �O � p c2 00 t Xi M OX OD Zm0 E5 � -1 > Cn -I C7 = O o m = 1-' m m Z 23 D n 002 P" * r F I"' C C —4 = O \ r''[ .'1C. ' ' -t � m = x m m cn 0 p m CV 2 _ mz n D xO o N' —I zV _ �' rnz 'D C m R. 3 fa G.0 -‹ Cl)` a CD c O rt o CO C. = �D 0. E: > CQ 2) "0 2 0 Al 2 I- p N , iimmi I' rn 0 m r r eg: f -. - D r' o ao m pCD m Cz T � - 3 es cn -i -1 � O :� lb 0 z � m Z z m p 0 0 � — O X)> ° M x ._Z_, --I ..c-i) G� , i/\ -I a, m = - zg v zZ m° m crnizz -n r0 m c7i > a ( O mo .� mzm Z7 r- cov -- r- 00 Z A � Z 2 -< C3 Ca w m 0 m m > y 0 o - T r- o w et WO 0 -n m i D to = � O � � m cn _a_ S� 1""' � m 047 "1 m z m „ c -< 0 0 ,c`� CD O '� m O m z CO 3 .�i n _ 2 � xi 0 0 0 m 00 0 › o73 _ _ "_I r- cno O o0z O m rnz M ?_10:1 D E""0 -T1 Ti C Win• 'n 0r _. W rri Oo (/ —1 O0 Cn DOro C, Oz � Z 0m ` r D * m v zoo Cn r-r-= 73 C0 c ) �O `� r5 m -0 m N 00 ry CD .p M m O 0mm J m -rcn v 0z - O = p OOm xp m0 m o2cn �ti 'Z1 mz C/) 0o° D I 0 = 0 O yODoD \ r- mrn Z trr- C` m Op r-- Z r- O • xi ....,-< z m co --G � m 2 � O —,G m � 1 c > 7 0 m m cn ' ' -� co CD c O co = C 0o m' m 0. E: su D w C7 ► 2 m r =mum. �7 P" C7 rr-- = CD C') corn M' omxj = � M cz �, 'Ll, 3 cn -� m 0 00 Z n z � m o m z mz _ _ Vmcn � o -i m = - z m 0z xl xo2- Dm m 02z \ [---- -11 r 0 m E5 > o O 'D _ _ -I z m xl 00 W m -< z ' ) I Zn Z =--i co CO zO C � -I z �+ DCD = 0c m mOw 0 m x , 0) r 0 C Q T D -71 ox T X < � ) N a al m v, O -_1 m \t i : m � T '� 0cmo N n �- O XmZoo tr _ O C co r- -< m cn Xi K O c O N m 0 0 Dom _ ".I -i Ozo 00 0 1- cnp O ° Oz ; Z -Diez -§P-0 -4 vc m 2 � m n• O o W W o o 2 O0 � rb m O � Z c mz D * m p Zoo F= z D C 8 N co aoa 73 Fri O C M -v m ImOorr-- cnD Z m X n ox D xcn0m E m -,06 p rzc o � 007 m0 m o =cmn (%) m m = M C) C0oo2 C7 2D > > > 1- mm Z JoF 47 Do z 1"' � 0 ' �. xi _oD -< mmm !°J --<< cm = � O � � 33 m zN cn 0 _< D XI \ D CO m m C = Co N CO CD 0 CDco g = a4 CLEr_ _ S. MI = p m r- O r°- e-�- v � � r 0� � �: CD mCzcum _ � -n rb cn -I -I mop SR `J 0 z (-„ m Z z z C7 r 1D 0 x > 0 rI m m --1 —I W G) 3 -I C„ m 2 — z o Dm m c_mizz -i7 r0 m cn > 0 c Xi p0 C m -< z 5 1m m * 002 2 WN z0 = OC mOw Q -Ti m 0 � m nDD sz o ^^"" � m cn r0Cn 1 FD -0 CL r mm 73 -irnz / n .�. O w 0 -� o r"�` 0 -b 0 mnaw �; 3 CD C OJ r - m --I cn XI O c O i ' '+ C7o c�1 O p ) 0 - Wp L OOZ �0 lb — o m TIz z r, -- M -_, S0 1 0' ■ O xiW m m6N3 y} n T r CO O o J -I 0n •Cn DOra' c _� v m z > * m v z00 rt -IN Cl) 1- -- D -- -. CD O "� I mm m wD �, �- ', h m 0 0m � v D ox y mm0 CN m o � v 0z- ti v 1- Dm m cnm = -1 m , C: G--) (J.)((/) m OD D 0 = � 0 Dnp I- m m Z � o � _I- oz r apo X m z -I v- cn C') � 0 > 0 q' w -H CDm CD D 3 a CO 43 -`D to CD -0 OO CD v CO C = P. D vi CQ SD CJ 70 _ C� -o m m O h CD r c-)-r- _ CD 0 � � Oc° m O 3 corn mz 7- � m � = C) z_ ET) m co (.1 z 0 O mz pmz m .cn -1 0. m � _< .� M O z X m D 0 z m cizz b -, D o m c 5 > m r' O -0 —{ -i 00 W mr0 7 r co ('1 � m * 0o O nDCao Z m Z = -< w CD --i x C = zw 0 Q o= 7 C � DDm ,cJ (n 0U) Fe, -0 C D oI o -n 73 < cn Er su 0 = O =imii- I- xim O � p 0 !.'1 073 , cm0W 33 r ' ° ° G) z 1 ,‘(A) m � z > wz o� � �i 0■ -I -0C m = . rn O 7m Z moo 0 � m 0 zoo ' C � D Fz > X00 O n � r -I m' o) n 1 m Cr) Irl cn D CD m D � -z CO rP1 73 D rn CC/f3p al m 0 * 0 0 070 Q In Xi ym INTI � m = • N Z < z Cn 0coD -1 -I n cn -0 -, CJ 0 = 0 C) > E:- D r mm Z m01 m oz r � OosZ xi oo - i z0 � n -< � m == co oca-n - - � m cn 0 -< 'l z = 0 > 73 XI Z CD fl) C 3 -< I 2 CD CD c1 cn -< p m m O co n Ct) = co c I0. mo- C O = > z c cS EU G) z -I 0 0 MII = O m 0 r° — 1 m CD —' 1- -I O D D m < 0 o' TE z m z CD cn —I -� cn D oz c-,-) m z Z cm„ z z^ m 0 cn O 0 z .----; • -r m z 0 p m oz 2 c 8 (4416 D DM m � W -n r0 m —ID 0 - —I _ Z U) xi E r0 00 c...) 0 O D D —1 Mm y r m Z _ m Z o o oT� zO C > mm D 9. CD 2 G7C "'� � � ao Q c M Cn m O a Om -I O p ••1.1 co > N n A) co m 0 DO o 2 N = _- m ter" cm2 M MD mTI m m0 p x , 0 zzN KO C coo v, 2 � ' • m = om c Oo n comp .. o 1- cnp O zoo > \' m � z o � z U\ � -n TT Mxixio n --1 -oC muco O oW ZOTOo --I o 5 c o 8 '''. wO • _ - o D ocx v ZOO ma m ib v yam = 0 mm m z 111m rcnn --� mD 0 p > D > 2r ►I. cf) p 73 �mov om 17J I—ITIO co M m0° Z < z V) � N . r m G")Z Xi D ' Z D m z r- � p X oo < = 00 -G m 2 = m X m m73 Go C') m � m z 2 m XI o0 z -1 0 _ _ mz Z O c.a r r N CQCD m CD ^^ C O W C7 = v i.�. CO C 0 = CO c° I- D 2 z CO m > �.ai CD n mm m ---i2 = \ m z - 1 m D CDDcf) o z2c7 rn - z ma D zm O O E w -i Pz ■ 13 -I 0 cO I- 17)mz oiv -I ccn m 2 0 o N m O Z w D D om m co_W T r- c:7 M -ID X 00 C 0 > �� O W 0 O D . - 0 _c5 > Z o z l CO � gCD ZO C > oo D m 9 2 m = oma a a -I 0 -no D � c�i� �, ty _ 73 O ° cam co 0 r co mm x> RI e� M m ; 0cn0 CD �D -I 0 -0 O zzm - m Oo ncnmo Co m m5 ° zoD "� Fl -n M j - D ■ � c R1 mco C7 O 0Oco z00 —I O n CO cn = O > 0 c x y Fz Xi 0 D -lom 0 I XIK � 'C) m m m ' vi = D D Cn D I- cn M Tm O0D Il 7j > z r- rn 0 Dv 30 iX m 0 m 3' W z < z C/) GG) cmc-i5 r' m -I n = G O fl = I- mm Z 7:3D rn p z r * p '' xi oo = p0 ;N -< � m 2 = p R1 m m cn C) Pm z 2 m 0 D � D— xp o0 z _ � mz CD CD DZS B lD mCl) CS:2 CDS 0 Q- C c • ,00 = • 0 D _ �� = 0 I Dr O CD — "Mita "O m rr Fa 1 CD D K0 cam r O W rnr-Tilwi O - '_ —� mc„ -zi -=� cnOc) El O mz 0 irlomz s 0 m m2 I cn0o --� --I cnm = z — p zzo m 0zz -n r m () > 0 rn -o m -zG z ,� OO �-• 73x0 174r'' - °' o Z E7zo CQ = -< W Z C -Izen -D CD o -I = 7G' _ mnD �. o m � -n � 0.,-n m � D N a 13) CO = cn O � --II z cn c� e-'F . m 7' r- 70 o `� m 3 CD m -n --I— o 3 -I o -0J30 O 2 -I cn2 71 000 - —1 = 00- n jzo �. 0 m � o O LI Z> S _0. —1 -13 --7) m-71 71 s = zm ,Dip Z m N O o r_'71 O o0 � 0 Or -? 3 —I Oo n co > chs, m O O D C3 -1 D D Z D coo p cn W � 71 mD � cn 9 D - DI z �� m � m O Dmm cn jiX D mwp \ Cl) Cn t7 0 z - M 0 * p o0 -0 m =p 70 o = cm�n . Xi Dm n cnm = z < z Cn 0 W D .-1 m 0 Cl) m 0 --i rmrrM 17 _ Z --IoP DOzr< mmp XI p z cL!7 -'I ---i C703 -< m m o � n z = 0 > 73 73 CD D)Ccp 'V 3 a c Cl) `Dcct CD O0 CD 0 Q. CTs Cf) ( 21) a. _. . _ D E2 r c7 r E (" i CD � 0 W r O 0Q, m -r ,, 2 , mc - = 00 0 zv3mwOG _s JZ Qmz D 5rz "-, O —I rzn � � -0 -o O 73 D 0 mm --� ,C-n- G') o --�. —I c�nz 2 7o0z mD Zm m c zz -n r0 m c7) > ,c) ^ m - - xi 0 0 r 0 M =1im * WN 0CC Z =)- s` m Z = -< o —I 0 X -4 --I 0_W o = M0 � m co C7nccr) cCD -0 Q. - O p - 2) s > < N c r- �_ O = m - ._ m ov o o CD m 1-- I 0 -n 0 mZp O 730 C mco r -< rt —1 0) K 70 0 c 0 — m omo� n Xz0 N O r O O D02 o"3 n ^■ O Z mZ •F `/ m iv Cil m O- n —i ,c° CDSt _ —1 O (7 cin rk) v z v moo 3 I al w m DZ Cmm pDC D --- r � O � o rn m mm m ,3D mWp ocp D nz - m o � D 0G) "O m0 0 = cmn - > mm Wm = Z < z Cl) 0oz, > -1 0D Cl) v 0 -1 Tmm Z 0 MoD z r D O '< m m0 70 o8 00 Icm — -1- 2 c ) m m z --1 cn 0 -< z Z c� D XI CD � D m N •`D CD • D Q = v Q. C 9? CD o D _ -0 j MMUS -o � 0 m r- 0 `. �---- Dicto r 0 °7 m o j �—. 3 0 oom 'S � � x m cz roc- i v� O me '' omo z O r' mz � � � D m -1 nmO z 0 z �-n m Wn > mo x7 v —m -< z W r 0 t 0 = m Z = -< � CD —1 0 � mG0)w Q -n = o m 7 � m PncDn iD v CL --1 0 0 -n m —� D N Cr eil D = � 0 � � m CO) ci MMINE 03 om m o oa)rm - o cn m . mr ,-n -1^ c m oo n azo- O r o O ° G) z 0 -ci m mz >mz 5- —. 0c m = -1m c m z 0 p W Z mr-ThO o C7 Cn 5r- g - m zz � Z � mz D o o _____--- > � z D coo p li •, I mm m > o - - r cnz 0 oom � M m m 73 c„ m Q D ox D mcn0 W -i cn O 0 '2 M 0 p OG) ) 13 rmO 73 6 --i* cmi) Xi y m IT1 cn m = Z < z fA o � y -1 m0 CO mO --I mm Z A r or D 0z -rG mm0 p D z w C -{ -1 o a 03 - � m m c n z = 0 > X � Su C g CO w ea CD c c = W D w `'G = O HT1 1- O I r- r---1 t D r O w mm E _, =, K 0 0 O , a 0 „.= Omzocmz 2 0 z g wo —1 zZ -' -11 m mz-1 O v-�iGo M 0z = M _ z DZFi mmczz .n � o m -c/5zrn O mo W C rm -< z xi 73 r 0 Z -n Z =-< o-1 CD z0 c --izcs = Oa' Q oT = to X m 70 omo o O cn mj 00T 0 =zw , m 2 O � 0 C mi- -< —1 U xi o o O - --1 m mo n 70zo rt O m z M liOOz - + a• ..... T-1 -'Tom m = ' m m 0 p -Z-1 ril O c n O 1 C. 2 z Z D � m D 200 t. 1 w U) m m > --,--1rn -Vc' -0D Dm _I D0 -N) - m � � 0 0mm M D o � > mCCn0 ' v) � w a 0z _ m oD oc� � 0 rno XI o = c" • _ > m m cnm = Z < z Cn o w > f` t. ...gym-1 D v O -1 rmmzfior -a D O ,,j(- z r m m 0 73 � D c'< z w o —1 -1 n w C. m = c c75x m z -i1 c5 0 -< 2 = 0 > CP-18-1 Feb o7 presntatn stff rprt wth notatns_drft2 Agenda Item 9.A.1 «««« Updates Appear in a Different Color Print, Black Print,and/or Are Hi-Lighted» »» » FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT II. IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY *** *** *** *** text break *** *** *** *** Policy 1.5 The URBAN Future Land Use Designation shall include Future Land Use Districts and Subdistricts for: B. URBAN MIXED USE DISTRICT [Page 9] *** *** *** *** text break *** *** *** *** 18. Vincentian Mixed Use Subdistrict 19. [RESERVED] 20. Goodlette/Pine Ridge Mixed Use Subdistrict Livingston Road/Veterans Memorial Boulevard East Residential Subdistrict *** *** *** *** text break *** *** *** *** FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION DESCRIPTION SECTION *** *** *** *** text break *** *** *** *** II. URBAN DESIGNATION *** *** *** *** text break *** *** *** *** A. Urban Mixed Use District [Page 49] *** *** *** *** text break *** *** *** *** Livingston Road/Veterans Memorial Boulevard East Residential Subdistrict The Livingston Road/Veterans Memorial Boulevard East Residential Subdistrict consists of ±35.57 acres and is located in the southeast quadrant of the intersection of Livingston Road and Veterans Memorial Boulevard and is within a Transportation Concurrency Management Area (TCMA). The purpose of this Subdistrict is to allow for a multi-family development at a density of up to 9.84 units ek per acre and to fulfill the intent of the TCMA, as stated in FLUE Policy 6.1. Additionally. ten percent '` Ids of the dwelling units constructed shall be set aside for-per96ns who earn between 80% and 120% of the Naples-Marco Island Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA) annual median income*ypwrorAtj Development in this Subdistrict shall be subject to the following: a. The Subdistrict site shall be rezoned to Residential Planned Unit Development (RPUD). b. Allowable uses are limited to multi-family rental dwellings and shall not exceed 350 units. c. The RPUD shall demonstrate consistency with FLUE Policy 6.1 by providing two or more of the following: —26— AGOG PL20170004419/CP-2018-1 aZ/ ? 11 '1 For a Residential Subdistrict in the Urban — Mixed Use District in FLUE T VI � 14- 1 CP-18-1 Feb o7 presntatn stff rprt wth notatns_drft2 Agenda Item 9.A.1 «««« Updates Appear in a Different Color Print, Black Print,and/or Are Hi-Lighted» » » » i. A transit shelter within the RPUD in a location and design approved by Collier County Public Transit & Neighborhood Enhancement (PINE) Division; ii. Bicycle and pedestrian facilities, with connection to the abutting commercial property to the west; and, iii. Vehicular interconnection to the abutting commercial property to the west. Certificates of occupancy shall not be approved for more than 249 multi-family units(a density of 7.0 units per acre)until the applicable facilities and/or interconnections, as described above and approved as Development Commitments in the RPUD, have been completed. d. The RPUD shall include development standards and buffers to insure compatibility with surrounding land uses. households e. Ten Percent of the dwelling units constructed shall be set aside for .peoderts who earn between 80% and 120% of the Naples-Marco Island Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA) annual median income at th- time of • -lifi -tion — - - --— As an alternate to all of the above, this Subdistrict may be developed in accordance with the Urban Residential Subdistrict. *** *** *** *** text break *** *** *** *** FUTURE LAND USE MAP SERIES [Page 144] *** *** *** *** text break *** *** *** *** Logan Boulevard/Immokalee Road Commercial Infill Subdistrict Map Mini Triangle Mixed Use Subdistrict Map East Tamiami Trail Commercial Infill Subdistrict Map Livingston Road/Veterans Memorial Boulevard East Residential Subdistrict Map —27— P L20170004419/CP-2018-1 For a Residential Subdistrict in the Urban — Mixed Use District in FLUE KendallMarcia (� tm4�r) n r-4 et") From: KendallMarcia Sent: Friday, February 1, 2019 7:55 AM To: ChrzanowskiStan; FryerEdwin; HomiakKaren; 'Joe Schmitt'; 'Joseph Schmitt'; KarlFry; Patrick Dearborn; 'Patrick Dearborn (pdearborn@johnrwood.com)'; 'schrzanowski2@comcast.net'; StrainMark; 'Thomas Eastman' Cc: BosiMichael; WeeksDavid; SchmidtCorby; PuigJudy Subject: Additional Emails received regarding ALLURA Apts. - PL20170004419/CP-2018-10 -Continued to CCPC February 7, 2019 meeting Attachments: Additional Emails ALLURA Apartments.pdf Please see the attached emails combined and forwarded for your review. Respectfully, Marcia R. Kendall, Senior Planner Zoning Division/Comprehensive Planning Section Phone: 239.252.2387 EFax:239.252.6675 New Email: Marcia.Kendall@colliercountyfl.gov Collier County Motto: "To exceed expectations." Tell us how we are doing by taking our Zoning Division Survey at http://bit.ly/CollierZoning 1 KendallMarcia From: SchmidtCorby Sent: Thursday, January 31, 2019 11:12 PM To: KendallMarcia Subject: FW: Allura Development 14th of 14, and final item for 2/7 CCPC Corby Schmidt,{ICP 1'rioci?al 1Plavivler 23e1.252.2ei44 Corby.SchtmidtZcolliercoavltyf I,0ov From:StrainMark Sent: Friday,January 18, 2019 10:01 AM To: SchmidtCorby<Corby.Schmidt@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: FW: Allura Development Please process as typical. Marl/ 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Rob Conforti<conforob@gmail.com> Sent:Thursday,January 17, 2019 3:59 PM To:StrainMark<Mark.Straint colliercountyfl.gov>; andy.solis@cilliercountyfl.gov Cc: Patti Manoogian<patti.manoogian@comcast.net>;John Pender<ipender6412@gmail.com> Subject:Allura Development Dear Misters Solis and Strain, I am writing as a Naples constituent from the Strand development to protest the re-zoning the property at the Southeast corner of Veterans Parkway and Livingston Road (ALLURA development). No doubt you have heard from several concerned constituents in the nearby developments. I am strongly opposed to changing zoning regulations especially after the area has been developed with single family homes. This area is already quite congested with traffic. The proposed ALLURA development would significantly increase congestion and reduce safety of residential and school traffic. It would also hinder emergency vehicle traffic from the North Naples Fire station. I encourage you to drive on Livingston Road from Veterans Memorial to Bonita Beach Road at 5:00 PM. It currently takes approximately 30 minutes to travel that 2 mile stretch. I've attached a photo facing north from that intersection. The back up continued to the south to the fire station. In addition to the traffic issues, I am concerned about negative influence on nearby property values. I agree with the following bullet points you have no doubt seen by now: 1 • The proposed apartment complex zone changes, if approved would be an example of'spot zoning',an example of bad development.Almost every property within two miles of the proposed apartments is a single-family home. • The proposed apartment complex will have no standards or controls such as the developments near the site have that control the operation, maintenance and behavior of the owners and controlled by a board of directors. • The developer, Stock,will have no control of over what this proposed apartment complex will look like in 10 years and beyond.They will most likely sell the project to any investor who could then do anything they desired. During a downturn in the real estate rental market,the owner could forgo maintenance work, hence reducing the'luxury' apartment to something much less than "luxurious." • The incompatibility of the apartment architecture,given the architecture of the surrounding single-family homes in neighboring developments, is of a density that requires 3 to 4 levels.This will do doubt negatively affect property values of adjoining real estate. • Buyers looking to purchase a single-family home in the area may be negatively influenced by an apartment complex in the middle of a single-family home area.This could negatively affect single family home values in a very significant way. • Zone changes or variances are generally granted due to a hardship on the part of the property owner. However,this does not seem to be the case in this instance.The land in question has been zoned for a long period of time.All the surrounding property has been developed in compliance with the current zoning. The folks who purchased in the surrounding single-family home developments did so relying on the fact that neighboring projects would be of a like kind. Changing the adjoining land to allow an apartment project is unfair to those taxpayers P. i40111k. , .- as Thanks you for your time an effort in this matter. I am happy to discuss in more detail. Sincerely, Rob Conforti,SPHR, HCS President/CEO 312.909.8664 conforob@gmail.com leadershiplaunchconsulting.com 2 SchmidtCorby From: StrainMark Sent: Monday, February 4, 2019 6:33 AM To: SchmidtCorby Subject: FW: ALLURA Development Please process as typical. Mark 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law.e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. From:jody moody<smithmoody@comcast.net> Sent: Sunday, February 03, 2019 7:32 PM To:SolisAndy<Andy.Solis@colliercountyfl.gov> Cc: StrainMark<Mark.Strain@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject:ALLURA Development Dear. Mr. Solis and Mr. Strain, We are writing in opposition of the proposed re-zoning of the property at the southeast corner of Veteran's Parkway and Livingston Road. We purchased our home in the Strand in 2001. Since that time, other communities have been built in our surrounding area and have all been developed within the guidelines of the current zoning. We use Veteran's Parkway on a daily basis, particularly driving to and from work. The traffic has become substantial over time and we frequently encounter delays already. Adding another 350 units on this corner would be significantly detrimental to our commute or to anyone traveling on Livingston Road. Not to mention,the proposed structures will surely decrease the property values of many long time Collier County taxpayers. We are asking that you maintain the current zoning and not allow this ALLURA project to proceed in our area. Thank you, Chris and Jody Moody 6036 Fairway Court Naples, FL 34110 Sent from Mail for Windows 10 1 x i February 3, 2019 Commissioner Andy Solis Collier County Hearing Commissioner Collier County Government Collier County Government 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 303 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34112 Naples, FL 34104 Re: Proposed Allura Project North Naples To All Concerned: Many pertinent topics have been raised concerning the development of the Stock apartment complex proposal for Livingston Rd/Veterans Parkway. To be brief, I would like to highlight a few of the most important issues. Traffic issues As pointed out by members of the Commission, the traffic study is inadequate. My request would be for the Commission to require that Stock have a traffic study performed including actual counts and projections for the Livingston Rd/Veterans Parkway intersection. As a 15 year resident of this area, I would note that the post 2008 recession housing boom has had a significant noticeable traffic impact in Naples in the last few years including the following anecdotal observations: 1. Before I-75 was widened to 6 lanes around 2013, accidents clogged the interstate daily during morning and afternoon rush hours. After I-75 was widened, accidents dropped dramatically and there were very few occurrences of backups. Today, I 75 has seen such an increase in traffic that it is back to bumper to bumper traffic with daily accidents during morning and afternoon rush hours. 2. In the last 2 years, traffic has increased so dramatically that Livingston Rd routinely sees backups for traffic heading north during the afternoon rush hour. This traffic backup begins at Bonita Beach Road and often reaches the Mediterra entrance and occasionally reaches the intersection at Veterans Parkway. 3. Immokalee Rd has immense traffic issues as the Commission seems aware of. 4. The Strand as approximately 1,070 doors. The main entrance & exit to the Strand is off Immokalee Rd. There are substantial delays to those using that exit & entrance. Thankfully, The Strand has a rear exit & entrance off Veterans Parkway which is far easier to use. I live a Trophy Club in The Strand and never use the exit/entrance off Immokalee Rd. The addition of hundreds of cars from the Allura project onto Veterans Parkway will certainly reduce the efficiency of this means of access to The Strand and may ultimately affect property values if the 2 means of access get traffic bound. 5. The intersections of Veterans Parkway/Livingston Rd and Livingston Rd/Learning Ln have signalization which only fully operates during school arrival and exit hours. Otherwise it operates on demand for exits from Veterans Parkway, Learning Ln and Ravina Way onto Livingston Rd. With this limited signalization, southbound backups during morning rush hour on Livingston Rd are normal these days. Any additional traffic will certainly make it worse. Page 1 6. The future of the intersections of Livingston Rd and Veterans Parkway, Learning Ln &Ravina Way does not look good. The addition of the announced High School in this area will certainly cause the full time operation of the traffic lights at these intersections. Stock's Allura project with its 500 to 600 potential vehicles will exacerbate traffic at the Livingston Rd/Veteran's Parkway intersection. 7. We have noticed these traffic changes in the last 2 years and they occur whether the snowbirds are here or not. 8. The traffic study presented by Stock at the first hearing does not accurately depict what we see every day on the highways near the Allura Project. Spot Zoning As stated by a few speakers and the Commission Board during the first hearing, The Allura development is a classic example of spot zoning. That Allura is a residential project does not make it compatible with the single-family developments that surround this property for greater than a mile. Attached is a chart that demonstrates how incompatible The Allura project is with the existing single family developments. Earning Additional density At the last Commission meeting, it was explained that Stock is allowed 4 units per acre, can add 3 units per acre at the Boards discretion and can earn additional units per acre by contributing to better the community, satisfying master plan goals or mitigating traffic. My thoughts are: 1. There is no hardship travelling with the land that would warrant relief from the granted 4 unit base. 2. Stock was granted additional units on the Della Rossa parcel in 2008 and has not utilized them. 3. Any additional development in the Livingston Rd/Veterans parkway area will make traffic worse. 4. The Allura project may add to the Collier County tax base but the loss of value in the adjoining single family home projects will partially or completely offset those gains. 5. The bus enclosure and interconnection with adjoining land are insignificant contributions and not worthy of discretionary additional units. 6. Allura would contribute to master plan goals at the expense of being completely incompatible with the surroundings. If fact, it could be argued that the commercial use at the corner of Livingston Rd & Veteran's Parkway if done in 2 stories and sufficiently buffered is more compatible to single family homes that 3 and 4 story apartment buildings. 7. The Allura project renderings show almost complete lot coverage with buildings, garages, sidewalks, and paving. There was very little area dedicated to landscaping- an indication that the unit density is too high. Della Rossa Development The Developer received site plan approval a decade ago. One can only guess,but it would seem the Commission approved the plans to encourage apartments in the area to satisfy a need and follow the master plan goals. Stock chose not to proceed with approved plans while other developers constructed Milano, Verona Point, Barrington Cove and Talis Park and the school district constructed an Elementary and Middle School. These developments changed the character of the area making it almost completely single family homes and making an apartment development completely out of place. I can't help but think that had Stock constructed the Della Rossa project, the discussion now would be different. Stock still has the right to construct the Della Rossa project and there was mention at the meeting that they might proceed. They have that right. The surrounding neighbors are best protected(fewer will suffer) if the Board acts to minimize any incompatible development like apartments on the Della Rossa project. Page 2 Additionally, Stock has a good reputation in Collier County. I've not heard anything bad about them. To protect that reputation, Stock should not build a project like Della Rossa in spite. Miscellaneous 1. While Stock presented details on sight lines of folks in Barrington Cove viewing Allura buildings, one should consider the view people on the top floor of the Allura Buildings peeking into the homes in Barrington. During the last meeting's testimony, The Commission expressed an interest in the credentials of those submitting written or oral opinions. I have a masters degree in engineering and was a partner in a real estate development firm in upstate New York who constructed, owned and managed commercial real estate. Additionally, my experience includes 12 years on the Dewitt,NY Planning Board and 12 years on the Board of Trophy Club at the Strand Condominium Association where I live. In summary, I think the Commission should reject this application. The negative impacts on the area far outweigh any minimal benefit building apartments will accomplish. Please accept my apology for this long letter. It was not my goal when I started. Sincerely Richard & Linda Ahlquist Trophy Club at the Strand 5983 Trophy Drive Unit 1504 Naples, FL 34110 rahlquistjr@hotmail.com 239-438-4146 Page 3 Comparison of Single Family Zones & Apartment Use Item Single Family Apartments Land density Building heights Typically one or two story Allura wants some 4 story buildings and the remainder 3 stories Building architecture Single family developments typically Apartment buildings are large blocky have multiple models arrayed along buildings with little architectural roads interest. These buildings stand out and dwarf single family homes. Landscaping Landscaping around a single family Landscaping may be well done but homes is typically well done. cannot screen the massive size of the Owners will supplement what is buildings. planted by the developer. Property values The single family homes' values in The Allura Owner will not suffer any the developments surrounding Allura decrease in value resulting from being will go down if the project is surrounded by single family homes. approved. Ownership Homes are owned by individuals who Apartment complexes are owned by a are interested in maintaining the single entity whose priorities include value of their properties making a profit. This motivation can directly affect the maintenance of the property. Stock may develop this project but there is no guarantee they will not sell it to another entity in the future. So there is no guarantee on the appearance or tenancy of an apartment project. Dwelling maintenance In the developments surrounding The appearance of apartment Allura, a homeowner's association buildings depends of the expenditures controls the exterior appearance & of the Owner. The more spent on maintenance of the buildings. maintenance reduces the profits to the Owner& Owners generally place their priority on profits and spend less on maintenance. Landscaping A Homeowners association controls A The Owner of the apartment maintenance maintenance of the landscaping and complex decides the level of replacement of materials that die. maintenance. This is generally done on a budget with profits as a conflicting interest. View from adjacent Most single family homes in this area The 3 story buildings won't be roads are behind precast walls hidden by screened from the roads. With Allura generous landscaping. One might see being the only apartment complex in a roof from the adjacent roads. the area, it will readily be seen from the surrounding roads and will stick out like a white elephant. Page 4 t— O O Lc) a) co -7t- �t N O f-- CO O N N co- co. b9. big- co- . E O O C ti SO M m M _ N CN- 69- {f} bg b9- y co LC) CN � O O CO CO J N ♦..� M-. N CN- Va. b9- b9- .69 - CD CO L) ti CO CO CO N CD r CO CO b9 - b9. b9- co- w c 0 0 0 0 VO� CO N d' L 03 co CD 0 CD 0 A W N N 8 O N tD DC V O I' to r A m D o 0 0 -I Z o a Z m P, x 3 c < 0 C 0 - - = o cd ;; g"' RI m 3 m 9 O O m m m o (D 3 0- o- v ^ n.3. . 6"-g _ C U V T $ w °c °c c c 3.v n a 3 c - h -p x d ° 3 < O o.g - �: a o c oc ,7 o 2 c O fl. m 3 C 0 ° N on N. A 2- x 3 - m ; v N O < N O N N • o. a' • n E c ° c �. S. o m m f o D' 0 cm ro t a m < ' '^^ 2.< ^ 3 w ° a o N o < T 'm '•''. 0 3 nam( D c < N m ° v < O a m °' 3 c r 0 .. ° -. o ro n O o p w - N N w C co CU c N 3 c a 3 F, I" ' 3 n F << 5-< - m 6 \ \ c. \ 3 m O W Q n ° -. n o r m < 0. I m ° 77, N N - N F+ N fD ^° .� (°0 fse p N C N 6 N O ° \ w 1='1 0 • c -.on• w N " v o. Z r e m t05 o = 3 N < N a < S O I N ° m * = o. m O x x to IR N Vf Vf 0 ,O O 7 0 tn+ a ° o 2' c O G O D 0 CD 1,..1 A 00 A W o co N 0 c A fp w N 3 p Q 0 v m o N N in O o V S 0 H 3 S 3 0 n m o m N rr N A Co o 0 0 In 00 0 O O s h o o ^ • v 3 r _ 0 0 0 0 0 a w 7. a a o N m • - '^ -°� a m o m o , W d A ° O N Oo w °� V1 o x E �.�, n v to to to w O 0 = N w N —1 VT -I N N O Ol N M "7. -73 -9 O '° 9. 0.0 win n ^ o = F+ • 0 3 m d rp o m o m in 00 v 00 S o y o O O O O N m• e V 3 o 0 0 N OOO CS p m - oW a o O 0 O 0ro . n O < m " ico N F,▪ m - l0 G W l0 'D O ill z o it o N 3 V w A up N 1O > > 00 d m O w ov n N ry -1 < o c T ▪ m ° o D D A Eu-, ua Vp - O FC -O vi N • t C CO O O N 'n NO C. C n V F .i ' 01 cnW No ' n Q0 N ro2 m d d N A 0 o w m N 0 e°. • O w W CO COUl 0 to A N N O N 0 3 ° O V A . w J W r N co • O w V N A 1-, 'D N OV A D m 0 N 3 2 H` up, m C5 G 7 3 m d c' 5 1.1) ? I 71L1 w m O 3 O • 9' Q N W I-, 4'. N J W 0 N 3 C 3 S d Lc) I-' 'O l0 W A 'n N _. • Pc f O l0 uj IL m 1 d C O • o - = N F+ a7 N O or N c• o — O O Z 2 2.Q - o' .,c O O N N W N W < Q m d 0 C 3 O _ Or O OAo '0 N 0o N CD f� CD ? O o V G Oi O d vii s 5. o C• o o Ll ° Z -1 CD O N N '^ W A al 00 'On d 0? N A Cr) w W w N O O. 7 I.-,Crt .0 _ WO , H A m 0 C C 3 Z C D Z m w N U D D c 3. m N o to N 'AO LID W 0 0 N O D S N p1 N 0o Ol UJ NJ 'O O 0 A N G Q CO , 3D 00 rD Z N <O vu- . 1 CN = Op i T N 7' Z rD V �1 ? ? N N VI N V G d 0! A N N D D A 'O O d N N w W <... d 0�0 Collier County Community and Human Services Division Quarterly Rental Apartment Inventory Survey 11.01.18(revised 01/07/2019) ***Information deemed reliable,hut should he independently verified*** 9 Available as of Property Name Property Address Phone 9 1/1 Rental 2/2 Rental 3/2 Rental JY of Units in Occupancy Rate 11/1/18(revised Rate Rate Rate Development 1/7/19) GEORGE CARVER APTS 35010th St N Naples,FL-34102 (239)261-4595 $954 $1,312 $1,434 70 100% 0 (810)750-7000 GOODLETTE ARMS 950 Goodlette Rd N Naples,FL-34102 (239)262-3229 $812 iis 242 100% 0 JASMINE CAY 100 Jasmine Circle Naples,FL-34102 239-643-3900 $843 $975 72 100% 0 (844)853-8441 Briar Landings 1385 Wildwood Lakes Blvd,Naples,FL 34104 239-537-3481 $1,100 $1,200. 240 98% 5 Meadow Lakes 105 Manor Blvd,Naples,FL 34104 (239)403-4130 $1,254 $1,490 $1,625 252 94% 15 OSPREYS LANDING 100 Ospreys Landing,Naples,FL 34104 (239)261-5454 $710 $835 $951 176 100% 0 River Reach 1970 River Reach Dr 9179,Naples,FL 34104 (239)643-2992 $1,300 $1,500 556 93% 39 SADDLEBROOK VILLAGE 8685 Saddlebrook Cir,Naples,FL 34104 (239)354-1122 $889 $1,019 140 100% 0 TUSCAN ISLE 8650 Weir Dr,Naples,FL 34104 (239)304-3668 $821 $976 $1,121 298 100% 0 VILLAS OF CAPRI 7725 Tara Cir,Naples,FL 34104 (239)455-4600 $741 $889 $1,019 235 100% 0 Belvedere At Quail Run 260 Quail Forest Blvd,Naples,FL 34105 (239)434-0033 $1,350 $1,425 $1,700 162 85% 25 EDEN GARDENS 1&II 260 Quail Forest Blvd,Naples,FL 34105 (239)657-7900 $770 $835 88 100% 0 ORCHID RUN 10991 Lost Lake Drive,Naples,FL 34105(833)676-4450844 $1,661 $1,887 $2,545 282 96% 10 8159861 Alvista at Laguna Bay 2602 Fountainview Cir,Naples,FL 34109 (239)254-7889 $1,295 $1,595 456 97% 13 BEAR CREEK 2367 Bear Creek Dr,Naples,FL 34109 (239)514-0600 $867 $1,012 108 100% 0 Bermuda Island 3320 Bermuda Isle Cir,Naples,FL 34109 (877)377-4289 $1,340 $1,575 $1,970 360 99% 3 Oasis Naples 2277 Arbor Walk Cir,Naples,FL 34109 (239)598-9944 $1,220 $1,460:,. 216 100% 0 SUMMER LAKES 1&2 5520 Jonquil Ln,Naples,FL 34109 (855)342-6413 $768 $927 51,076 416 100% 0 ARIUM GULFSHORE 5301 Summerwind Dr,Naples,FL 34109 (239)597-6605 $1,361 $1,546 368 94% 21 WINDSONG CLUB 11086 Windsong Cir,Naples,FL 34109 (239)566-8801 $649 $784 $900 120 100% 0 Meadow Brook Preserve 1130 Turtle Creek Blvd,Naples,FL 34110 (239)514-4449 $1,350 $1,470 $1,575 268 97% 8 Somerset Palms 15985 Arbor View Blvd,Naples,FL 34110 (888)479-3911 - r $1,505 $1,705 169 98% 3 Naples 701_ 3531 Plantation Way,Naples,FL 34112 (239)775-8000 $999 188 95% 10 The Point at Naples(Heron Park) 2155 Great Blue Dr,Naples,FL 34112 (239)417-5500 $1,150 $1,350 $1,575 248 99% 2 Wild Pines of Naples 1&2 2580 Wild Pines Ln,Naples,FL 34112 (239)793-6419 $950 Ai, 200 100% 0 Aster at Lely Resort 8120 Acacia St,Naples,FL 34113 (239)919-8375 $1,830 $2,205 $1,984 308 89% 34 COLLEGE PARK 6450 College Park Cr,Naples,FL 34113 239.732.7707{. $918 $1,068 210 100% 0 Inspira Apartments "Final C/O 11/1/18 Grand Lely Dr,Naples,FL 34113 (239)298-5680 $1,527 $1,830 $2,040 304 24% 215 Sierra Grande at Naples 6975 Sierra Club Cir,Naples,FL 34113 (239)529-5631 $1,361 $1,418 $1,600 300 93% 21 WHISTLER'S COVE 11400 Whistlers Cove Blvd,Naples,FL 34113 (239)417-3333 $765 $925 $1,075 240 100% 0 Advenir Aventine 9300 Marino Cir,Naples,FL 34114 (239)793-4603 $1,524 $1,857 $1,990 350 97% 9 Milano Lakes Rotunda Lakes Circle,3713 Milano Dr,Naples,FL 34114 (239)330-4181 $1,420 $1,590 $1,720 296 100% 0 Berkshire Reserve(Daili of Naples) 3536 Winifred Row Ln,Naples,FL 34116 239)455-8174 $1,850 146 85% 22 LAUREL RIDGE 5460 Laurel Ridge Ln,Naples,FL 34116 (239)353-7766 ,. 4 $1,088 78 100% 0 Mer Soleil 4250 Jefferson Ln,Naples,FL 34116 (239)354-1155 $1,080 $1,270 $1,567 320 99% 4 Naples Place I-III 45444626 Sunset Rd,Naples,FL 34116 (239)455-5155 $775 $1,050 $1,100 330 100% 0 NOAHS LANDING 10555 Noah's Cir,Naples,FL 34116 (239)775-7115 $844 $1,005 $1,153 264 100% 0 Sabal Key 1600 Wellesley Cir,Naples,FL 34116 (239)353-1211 $1,230 $1,350, r% 200 98% 4 Waverley Place 5300 Hemingway Ln,Naples,FL 34116 (239)353-4300 $1,286 $1,437 $1,897 300 99% 3 WHISTLER'S GREEN 4700 Whistlers Green Cir,Naples,FL 34116 (239)352-2999 $699 $840 $961 168 100% 0 BRITTANY BAY 1&2 14815 Triangle Bay Dr,Naples,FL 34119 (239)354-2002 $1,195 $1,575 $1,650 360 100% 0 Malibu Lakes 2115 Malibu Lakes Circle,Naples,FL 34119 239.596.0035 $1,375 $1,595 $1,910 356 98% 7 Monterra at Bonita Springs 28151 Dovewood Ct,Bonita Springs,FL 34135 (239)948-3826 $1,265 $1,450 $1,550 244 98% 4 Sub-Total Naples 10,704 96% 477 BROMELIA PLACE 612 N 11th St Immokalee,FL-34142 (844)796-3474 $575 $675 30 97% 1 (239)657-3000 CRESTVIEW PARK 1&2 715 Crestview Dr,Immokalee,FL 34142 (239)658-8267 $902 $920 304 96% 13 CYPRESS RUN 550 Hope Cir,Immokalee,FL 34142 (239)657-9032 $665; 39 95% 2 ESPERANZA PLACE 210$1st St,Immokalee,FL 34142 239.657.2009 $549 $639 $699 48 92% 4 FARM WORKER VILLAGE(non- 2225 Chadwick Cir,Immokalee,FL 34142 239-842-0327 $485 $536 $567 276 88% 33 farmworker) WILLOW BROOK PLACE 1836 Ash Ln,Immokalee,FL 34142 (239)657-3204 $484 $584-.` 65 89% 7 GARDEN LAKE 1050 Garden Lake Cir,Immokalee,FL 34142 (239)657-3204 $443 $535 65 97% 2 HERITAGE VILLAS 1810 Lake Trafford Rd,Immokalee,FL 34142 (239)8442505248 657-3204 $461 $517 41 90% 4 Immokalee Apartments 601 W Delaware Ave,Immokalee,FL 34142 (239)657-6185',. $777 $923 100 100% 0 MAIN STREET VILLAGE 104 Anhinga Cir,Immokalee,FL 34142 239-657-6576 $565 $565 $635 79 90% 8 OAK HAVEN 580 Oakhaven Cir,Immokalee,FL 34142 (239)658-5920"k r $640 $730 160 100% 0 SANDERS PINES 2449 Sanders Pine Cir,Immokalee,FL 34142 239-657-8333 $545 $595 41 100% 0 SOUTHERN VILLAS 1802 Custer Ave,Immokalee,FL 34142 (239)657-3204 5553 $669 $815 35 86% 5 SUMMER GLEN 1012 Summer Glen Blvd,Immokalee,FL 34142 (239)657-3204 $488 $599 45 98% 1 TIMBER RIDGE 2711 Wilton Ct,Immokalee,FL 34142 239-657-8333: $705 35 100% 0 WILLOWBROOK PLACE 1836 Ash Ln,Immokalee,FL 34142 239.657.3204 $485 $595 41 90% 4 Sub-Total lmmokolee 1,404 94% 84 Grand Totals 12,108 95% 561 Collier County Planning Commission February 7, 2019 RE: ALLURE PROJECT Dear Commissioners, I submit this comment as a homeowner's response to the proposed Allure Project before the commission. My wife and I are year-round residents residing at 16453 Celebrita Court, a single-family home we purchased in 2009 inside the Mediterra reserve. We will be directly impacted by this project due to our proximity to the corner of Veterans and Livingston, a distance of less than 200 feet. If this project is approved, it will negatively impact the appeal of the area. Development in the form of single-family homes and small apartment complexes limited in height was expected, not three-or-four story gigantic apartment buildings. A proposed project with this high of unit concentration will change the neighborhood aesthetically. This project would be the largest and tallest, residential project between Immokalee Road and Bonita Beach Road in the Livingston corridor. Beyond the contour of the area being dramatically impacted, the "parking area" for what will possibly be over 600 cars will be forever changed. In addition, the amount of impervious surface that will added to this land between building and parking lot will create demand on our already stretched draining system. In season, traffic on Livingston already backs up from Bonita Beach Road to Veterans at 5 o'clock, making it virtually impossible to leave either Mediterra gate on Livingston and difficult for first responders to address emergencies during this time of day. The majority of traffic in this proposed project will primarily use the intersection at Veterans for ingress and egress, creating more congestion and more noise. East bound on Veterans will forever be impossible due to Interstate 75. I could continue on the downsides of this project, but the largest impacts will be on our quality of life and home valuations. This is not what the current area residents signed up for when they invested in this section of Collier County. When I look for what the primary motivation for the developers to pursue this project I can only come up with greed, maximizing future income for the property with no regard for what the neighborhood has already created. There is plenty of space in other parts of Collier County to build a project of this size to meet demand without leveraging the investments of current homeowners. It's obvious the landowner has "limitations" on how much of this land he can develop, so his answer is to spread the land costs over more units, more prospective renters by seeking to become a "skyscraper" in a single- family area. The developers' interest will get "enhanced" at the expense of current taxpayers The ALLURE zoning request should be denied. z espectfully Submitted, i 6-k 4iii Wry Garland ._ ._._ 16453 Celebrita Court DA) 61) CD C N co CD -0 0 = v c E C7 D cn e X1 = -0 = 0 m Dr O CD D - � m oCar Fri o , C7 Wm M � x Z 3 rn v_ -I =-I moo " _ Z zcn rn wmcc 0 � z O 5rnz 0 cn Oo ---I z z -4 ! ■ 17 O N N rn 0m0m = _ 2 m � Dz D z m G) zz TI rr o PTI D m xi -0 0 ^ m -G 1- 00 � r0 = Wo CO m Z = -G ca � wQ D -i 0 mo -rio= 0 E m Q rn � r �T o - m ocn a- SU> - O cn DJ — m x 0 m ma c- O � m O m0W ` g 2 -i cn0 P3 CO 0c0 o o M oo n � 2o a 0m0 Lo 0 o, lk 0a -n -nm c0 -1 ° m n cm = Om f O -4W oE C -I O0 O Dr = = 8 > 7o a- o C/ m o Zo m '1 z z D O zoom r z > coOC/ r -I ximo I ca 03 m o• D mm - 1 >om� Oxm > ox D mc�i) 0 C\ rn 0 - 0 o0m 73 m -Ci rTht 73 Dmm m om = < z Cl) ocoy Al il, 0 = 0 O DSD 1— mm Z fpr D Oz r mho ,� I- ro C o -I -- 0 1 00 Do �- 1.". -G � m = Oct rn -� I' . n Xi IN D Da CD D n Fp Co -c '' to CD 13 p o = W C S m Q. E D (/) CM LU Do MIMES r m o m r O 0 p.F. D r■ 00 w r- ri:_ / CD m COM - � � � --� 3 n zv, rn Z z m p M 650 —1 zz - o r" m � � � -m-I corn =Xi azo -1 r 0 m "c)5 > Om ;l �`` xi Op 0 W m -< z S.- rpo _rim Z m Z = .°< o CO zo CD -I G) x � _ 0zjw Q 11'1 O m 0DD Q 'n (� r O Cn CD -1 OO m = D to c co _ � O 11 x _1m • - Sy r- mm7:1 --imz 0 M xr 0co0 on C —I Ojr3 O = 2C B --I Cr) Pa p C O _ \ _ '1 = O O 0 D 2 � r w O O ° O 2 \/ r O m y D o -n rz M ---Ic �_ .�■ O0 7300 m mzN C7 -n 0 r -1 00 O0 o -1 O n Cn - r o m Oz Zmoo D � z ,A D * m 0 z ):. . -ir- -.j co r -1 D --I O o rt0 1corn m c >D c M � n7 0 omX o � > mm0 C =O G7 m XI m •--I cn ym m cm = Z < z C/) 0 —I m D CA -0 o -Di . D r- mm 0 DD D pmz r mOo o D '{ m m 0 co -< � m 2 � O -< x m z (75 cn C') -< z = o D Lumens for Light Source Watts Luminous Efficacy Lumens Incandescent LED Light Source Luminous Watts Watts Efficacy (Lumens/Watt) 375 25 6 Incandescent 12-18 450 40 10 Halogen 16-24 800 60 15 LED 30-90 1100 75 19 1600 100 25 2600 150 38 3000 200 50 'Data from Federal Trade Commission. Shop for Landscape Lighting Bulbs Shop for Landscape Lighting Fixtures Landscape Lighting Learning Center Share Subscribe for articles,news and offers Enter your Email Address SUBSCRIBE Return to Articles lir Start Shopping I, fl View Photo Gallery V I Norton' 4.9 . -,. (%e9 GSa3i Customer Reviews G ,PC z/- 1 19 LUMENS TO WATTS CONVERSION: CHOOSE THE RIGHT LED REPLACEMENT BULB The old days of selecting light bulbs by watts are over. Let's learn how to select the right LED bulbs by using lumens. It's not so hard. Step 1. Understand Watts: Watts are a measure of energy consumption.When we pay our electric bill,we pay for the number of watts we use.A 60-watt bulb consumes 60 watts of energy.Since we've used 60-watt bulbs for so many years,we associate a certain level of brightness with 60 watts.We can't do that anymore since we have new light sources that give us more light with fewer watts. Instead,we need a measurement for visible light energy-lumens. Step 2. Understand Lumens: A lumen is a measure of visible light energy.More lumens equals a brighter light.All lighting manufacturers are starting to tell us how many lumens are produced for each of their lighting products.We see these lumen numbers on the new Lighting Facts labels found on all new LED bulb packages.It will take awhile for us to get used to using lumens instead of watts,but if we want to make the best lighting choices,we need to search for and compare these lumens. Step 3. Understand Efficacy(Lumens/Watt). Now that we understand watts and lumens,we can use both terms to come up with efficacy or lumens/watt. Sometimes the term"luminous efficacy"is used.This is a measure of how well a light source converts energy (watts)into light(lumens).The old technology of tungsten incandescent bulbs only had an efficacy of about 15 lumens/watt;LED technology can produce about 60 lumens per watt.In other words,LEDs are about 4 times more efficient at producing light than incandescent bulbs.This 4-1 ratio is a rough guide of how to calculate what LED bulb to use when replacing an incandescent bulb. For example,if you need to replace a 60 watt incandescent bulb with an LED bulb,then divide 60 watts by 4 to get 15 watts-that will be a good guess. But we should note that efficacy varies wildly from manufacturer to manufacturer so you should check the Lighting Facts label and try to match lumens.Also,a label will sometimes tell you that an LED bulb has an equivalent brightness,but sometimes it doesn't. Refer to the charts below for a 1 ready reference.Also,note that all VOLT®Low Voltage Landscape LED bulbs have the incandescent or halogen 1/40, equivalent wattage displayed on each of their product pages.We make the switch-over to LED easy. NOrtOn usotot umens and watts conversion charts for your reference':