CLB Agenda 12/19/2018COLLIER COUNTY
Board of County Commissioners
Contractor Licensing Board
AGENDA
Board of County Commission Chambers
Collier County Government Center
3299 Tamiami Trail East, 3rd Floor
Naples, FL 34112
December 19, 2018
9:00 AM
Robert P. Meister, III
Patrick G. White
Michael E. Boyd
Terry Jurelle
Richard E. Joslin, Jr.
Kyle E. Lantz
Matthew Nolton
NOTICE: All persons wishing to speak on Agenda items must register prior to presentation of the Agenda
item to be addressed. All registered speakers will receive up to three (3) minutes unless the time is adjusted
by the chairman.
Any person who decides to appeal a decision of this Board will need a record of the proceeding pertaining
thereto, and therefore may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record
includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based.
If you are a person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding,
you are entitled, at no cost to you, the provision of certain assistance. Please contact the Collier County
Facilities Management Division located at 3335 East Tamiami Trail, Suite 1, Naples, Florida, 34112 -5356,
(239) 252-8380; assisted listening devices for the hearing impaired are available in the Facilities
Management Division.
12.A.2
Packet Pg. 190 Attachment: Agenda December 19, 2018 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
1. ROLL CALL
2. ADDITIONS OR DELETIONS
3. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
4. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
4.A. OCTOBER 17, 2018 MINUTES
5. PUBLIC COMMENTS
6. DISCUSSION
6.1. ELECTION OF CHAIRMAN AND VICE CHAIR - 2019 TERM
7. REPORTS
7.A. RECEIVED CITATION THEN APPROVED LICENSE
7.B. RENEWAL TOTALS 7/1/18 - 12/5/18
7.C. UNLICENSED CITATION FEE REPORT
8. NEW BUSINESS
8.A. ORDERS OF THE BOARD
8.B. MELVIN ALFARO - OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL - CONTESTING CITATION
11231
8.C. OCTAVIO CALDERON - ALL IN 1 CONTRACTORS INC - REVIEW OF
EXPERIENCE
8.D. HUBLAR LOPEZ - SECOND ENTITY APPLICATION
9. OLD BUSINESS
9.A. JEFFREY BUMPUS - NORTHERN BREEZE - EXPIRED PERMIT FINAL
UPDATE
10. PUBLIC HEARINGS
10.A. CASE: 2018-10 – STEPHEN BOWLES – JACKSON POOLS – MISCONDUCT OF
A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR
11. NEXT MEETING DATE
11.A. WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 16, 2019
Inquiries concerning changes to the Board’s Agenda should be made to the County Manager’s Office at
12.A.2
Packet Pg. 191 Attachment: Agenda December 19, 2018 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
252-8383.
12.A.2
Packet Pg. 192 Attachment: Agenda December 19, 2018 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17. 2018
MINUTES
OF THE COLLIER COUNTY
CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARJ)
October 17,2018
Naples, Florida
LET IT BE REMEMBERED that the Collier County Contractors' Licensing
Board, having conducted business herein, met on this date at 9:00 AM in
REG(ILAR SESS/ON in Administrative Building 'lsp,r 3ra Floor, Collier County
Govemment Complex, Naples, Florida, with the following Members present:
Chairman: Michael Boyd
Members:Terry Jerulle
Richard Joslin
Robert Meister
Matthew Nolton
Patrick White
Absent: Gerard Shannon
ALSO PRESENT:
Everildo Ybaceta - Supervisor, Contractors' Licensing Office
Kevin Noell, Esq. - Assistant Collier County Attorney
Jed Schneck, Esq. - Attorney for the Contractors' Licensing Board
Reggie Smith - Contractors' Licensing Compliance Offlcer
Jack Gumph - Contractors' Licensing Compliance Officer
I
Excused: Kyle Lantz, Vice Chair
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 193 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
,
October 17,2018
Any person who decides to appeal a decisinn of this Board will need a record of the
proceedings and ma! need to ensure that a verbatim record of said proceedings is made,
whfuh record includes the testimony and evidence upon which any Appeal is to be made.
I. Roll Car.r,:
Chairman Michael Boyd opened the meeting at 9:02 AM and read the procedues to be
followed to appeal a decision of the Board.
Roll Call was taken; a quorum was established; six (6) voting members were present.
II. AGENDA- ADDITIONS,CHANGES. oR DELETIONS:
Deletions:
Under Item X,"PubLic Hearlngs," the County WITHDREW the following:
B. Case 2018-10: Board of County Commissioners vs. Stephen Bowles -
Misconduct of a State-certified Contractor
Everildo Ybaceta, Supervisor - Contractors' Licensing Office, stated the County will
reschedule the case.
III. APPROVALOFAGENDA:
Patrbk White moved to approve the Agenda as amend.ed.. Richard Joslin offered a
Second in support of the motion. Caried unanimously, 6 - 0.
IV. AppRovAL oF MINUTES: SEprElrnnn 19 ,2018
Richard Joslin moved to approve the Minutes of the September 19,2018 Meeting as
submitted. Terry Jerulle offered a Second in support of the motion.
Carried unanimously, 6 - 0.
V. PUBLIC COMMENT:
(None)
VI. DISCUSSI0N:
(None)
VII. REPORTST
A. Year-End Report: Fiscal Year October 1,2017 through September 30,2018
Everildo Ybaceta stated:
The first page indicated the number of open cases
o 1,173 cases were opened by Staff
o 970 cases have been closed
2
a
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 194 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17, 2018
Mr. Ybaceta provided additional details:
. 301 Citations were issued
. The total amount of fees collected was $314,400.00. The Financial Report contained several categories:
o License renewals
o New applications
o Fees collected
Patrick White requested clarification of the $314,400, i.e., what was included in the
figure?
Everildo Ybaceta stated the figure included the fines collected from the Citations.
Richard Joslin inquired about the status of the remaining 203 open cases.
Everildo Ybaceta replied the cases were "still running."
Terry Jerulle: You added 350 new General Contractors in Collier County in the last
year?
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes, sir.
Terry Jerulle: How many were there before? Do you have any idea?
Everildo Ybaceta: I didn't go back because the year before last was a crazy year
because of the Hurricane ("lrma"). The numbers may be a little skewed.
Terry Jerulle: You added 306 Roofing Contractors?
Patrick White: My guess is there's going to be a large overlap between the new and
the inactive/delinquent.
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes, sir. For the following months, if you wish, I can run the
Report again and show you what the difference is as they are dropping off- most of
the Contractors are probably going to move into a different area of the state or out of
the State.
Patrick White: To the Panhandle.
Everildo Ybaceta: Maybe ... but I don't want to guess.
Patrick White: Seems logical. I'd be interested in seeing some of that data and
would also be interested in understanding if there was any correlation between the
Citations that were issued.
Everildo Ybaceta: During the renewal process, we went back and looked at the
Citations that were issued and if they were correlated to the contractor - we picked up
the fees before we issued a Citation ... I mean, the license. We picked up the fee for
the Citation before we issued the license.
3
Mr. Ybaceta continued, noting the Report included a breakdown of the newly-
Iicensed Contmctors. The total was 1,393 of which 377 were Specialty Contractors.
The number of Contractors was broken down in categories of trades.
Patrick White stated he was trying to calculate the percentage of growth and asked
what was the number of renewals.
Everildo Ybaceta replied he did not have an exact figure for the total number of
renewals but stated the County was using an estimate of 7,900 with approximately
1,000 others that were either delinquent or inactive.
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 195 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17,2018
Richard Joslin: Got it. Did you see more Citations issued during the Hurricane
season for unlicensed contracting for out of state contractors?
Everildo Ybaceta: There were a few more. I did run the numbers from last year -
again, for the same period from October l't through September 30th - and there were
328 Citations issued between 2016 and 2011. The fees for the Citations were
$338,300.00
Patrick White: When you calculate the dollars that are in that "bucket," does it
include the late penalties or is itjust the result of disciplinary actions?
Everildo Ybaceta: Disciplinary action. That falls on the second page of the Financial
Report, but I did not break that down.
Chairman Boyd: In 2011, you had 241 cases, and in 2018, you had 1,173?
Everildo Ybaceta: Remember, this is starting from October 1'r
Chairman Boyd: Right.
Everildo Ybaceta: through September 30s ... so it is going to pick up the number
from October 1't through September 30,2017 and then it's going to pick up
November l't through December 31"'and then a different number for 2018, but those
numbers are all crunched into one number for the total.
Chairman Boyd: Would you explain that again?
Everildo Ybaceta: Okay. The County's fiscal calendar starts at...
Chairman Boyd: It's not a "calendar" ...
Everildo Ybaceta: Right. The County's fiscal year doesn't run from January to
December. It starts on October l't through September 30th The Report picks up the
last three months of 2017 but that's all incorporated into the County's fiscal year.
Patrick White: The licensing?
Everildo Ybaceta: The licensing. yes.
Terry Jerulle: And just like 2017 picked up ...
Everildo Ybaceta: 2016. Correct.
Terry Jerulle: But it's still "apples to apples."
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes, sir.
Chairman Boyd: But stili, with only one extra Investigator, you quadrupled the
number of cases.
Everildo Ybaceta: Oh, I see what you're saying.
Chairman Boyd: Is that all hurricane related?
Everildo Ybaceta: Um-m ....
Chairman Boyd: Catching people without a license?
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes, sir - there's a lot of that in there. I could also ... for the next
Report, if you wish ... I could break it down to "Unlicensed" versus "Other," i.e.,
misconduct.
Patrick White: That would be helpful because, for me, what it tells me is that how
we impose penalties has a consequence and I think it would help me to make a better
determination in which direction it might be that the disciplinary actions might move.
Everildo Ybaceta: Okay.
Chairman Boyd: Any other questions.
Terry Jerulle: The money collected goes ... where?
Everildo Ybaceta: I believe that goes into ...
Terry Jerulle: The General Fund?
4
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 196 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17, 20i8
Everildo Ybaceta: It may go into the General Fund. I'm not sure where it goes.
Terry Jerulle: I feel that my job is a profit center for the County as opposed to
trying to help the citizens of the County.
Everildo Ybaceta: If you look at it that way, then any job within the County that
issues Citations could be looked at in that way.
Patrick White: And some of them - if they're through the County's Courts where
there are limitations on where those funds go ... I may be mistaken because the law
could have changed ... but it would be, I think, worth this Board's time to understand
what that may be. I think there is certainly an argument that some of those funds, if
you will, from the General Fund are for the purposes of compensating new hires
(Investigators) has had a 'return on investment.' Whether it's direct or indirect, I
guess is a fair question.
Chairman Boyd: Any other questions or comments? (None) Okay, let's move on
to New Business.
Richard .Ierulle moved to approve authorizing the Chairman to sign the Orders
of the Board. Terry Jerulle offered a Second in support of the motion.
Carried unanimously, 6 - 0.
(No!g: The indtviduals who testified in the following case under ltem VII\ "New
Business," were ftrst sworn in by the Attorney for the Board.)
B, Richard McBride - Review of E xperience and Waiver of Exam
("McBride Home Watch Services, LLC, dlbla McBride Pro-Seat')
Patrick White: Mr. Chairman, before we get into the substance of this, I must ask for
some guidance from the Board's Attomey. I don't believe that I have any type of a
conflict of interest of an actual nature, but I want to avoid any appearance of a conflict
of interest because of my association with Ms. Stoner, seated here. We were in
"Leadership Collier" together and I have had a limited number of communications with
her regarding this matter - but only as to the process steps ... not as to any of the
substance ofthe matter. So, I'm putting myself in a position looking for guidance. I'm
perfectly comfortable if I must file a Form 88 entitled "Memorandum of Voting
Conflict." but on the other hand, I don't believe I have any pecuniary or other interest in
the outcome of today's consideration of this matter.
Jed Schneck, Esquire, Attorney for the Contractors' Licensing Board: I agree.
There's no special interest or special gain that you would receive from the outcome of
this application today. So, there is no conflict and you can vote.
Patrick White: Okay. Thank you. Sorry, Mr. Chairman.
Chairman Boyd: Mr. McBride, you are asking for a Waiver of Exams. Would you
explain your reasoning?
5
VIII. NEw BUSINESS:
A. Orders of the Board:
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 197 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17, 2018
Richard McBride: First of all, I go by Adrian McBride - Richard Adrian McBride.
I'm the owner/operator of Pro-Seal, paver sealing and pressure washing with my son,
Andrew, who is in attendance. We have no other employees - it's just Andrew and me.
I've taken the test four times - the first two times, I scored in the 60s. The third time, I
scored a 74 ... I needed a 75. I chose to do it a fourth time and scored in the 60s.
Patrick White: This is the Business and Law exam?
Mr. McBride: Yes, sir.
Patrick White: Thank you.
Mr. McBride: Yes, sir. We have a professional CPA who works with us on the
financial side and my wife has been in the investment business for thirty years, so she
helps with the back office also. We only do driveways and lanais - we're not doing
roofs or anything vertical. We don't take any deposits - the customer or homeowner
doesn't pay us a dime until the job is completed to their satisfaction. That's why I'm
here.
Patrick White questioned the Applicant:
Q, Can you offer us any explanation as to your theory as to why it is that, despite your
best efforts, you've come close but not gotten over the line regarding the test scores?
A. Quite honestly, it probably goes back 30 years. I went to the University of Missouri
and finished in 1985. I was a football guy for what it's worth. I had some
concussion issues and I'm in the middle of a concussion settlement now with the
NFL (National Football League). There's just a disconnect and I get anxiety when
I'm taking tests. Otherwise, I'm fully functional.
Richard Joslin questioned the Applicant:
Q. Who handles your payroll?
A. My wife and our CPA.
Q. Was there something in the test results that you had a problem with? Was it the test?
A. Yes, sir. It's my concentration ... I just don't do well with numbers.
Patrick White: Ifthat's the only thing before us for today, we certainly can inquire
about all the other aspects.
Richard Joslin: I see a Waiver of Experience also. I'm just questioning the Afhdavits.
Richard Joslin questioned the Applicant:
Q. You went to college, correct?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Is there something in this college packet that I missed that shows me some
experience for driveway sealing?
A. In college? No.
Q. I understand that you went to college.
A. Yes, sir.
6
Chairman Boyd: Is there only the Business and Law exam?
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes, sir.
Chairman Boyd: Okay.
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 198 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17,2018
0. But, actually you still have no experience with the trade that you want to be in.
A. I've got about twenty-five years of experience. We owned rental properties in St.
Louis and I was always in charge of taking care ofand manicuring the rentai
properties including our own house - cleaning and sealing, and trimming bushes and
everything - to make it look nice and have nice curb appeal.
Patrick White: All I'm seeing is a Waiver of the Business and Law exam. Is that
corlect?
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes, st.
Patrick White: Thank you.
Richard Joslin: This is Mr. McBride - right? I'm seeing "Waiver of Exams based on
Experience" in my packet (showing documents).
Patrick White: What I think that means, Mr. Joslin, is that he believes he has the
pertinent experience relative to operating a business that we ought to waive taking the
Business and Law exam. I don't think it goes to his qualifications or to the Scope of
Work, but rather the Business and Law exam.
Richard Joslin: It should be a Waiver of Exam then and not based on experience.
Everildo Ybaceta: You're correct.
Richard Joslin: It's not labeled correctly.
Everildo Ybaceta: Right.
Richard Joslin: Okay.
Everildo Ybaceta: It is a Waiver of Exam.
Richard Joslin: As long as I've been on this Board, that's how it's read. It's a Waiver
of Exams.
(An off-mic comment was made.
Mr. White: You may only speak if you are at the podium and have been swom in.)
Matthew Nolton: I believe Mr. White is correct. It's a Waiver of Exam based on the
Applicant's experience.
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes.
Patrick White: He's been operating a business, managing a business, conducting
whatever financial affaks - those are all pertinent areas ofinquiry.
Richard Joslin: Okay, I understand that, but what I'm driving at is the fact that I'm
looking at the experience level and the college level that he's taken. And no where in
there does it show his experience in the trade that he's trying to qualify. Because he
went to college doesn't mean that he's a sealing person other than the experience in his
affidavits.
Patrick White: Okay.
Richard Joslin: So that's why I'm questioning the fact of the exam because ifhe's a
contractor here in Collier County, he should know the laws and know the business
portion of that and not rely on a secondary avenue to get to it.
Terry Jerulle: Mr. Joslin, if you look atPage 23 - there is an affidavit - Verification of
Construction Experience ... and Page 22 ... is that what you're looking for?
Richard Joslin: Yes. I'm seeing several of them.
1
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 199 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17,2018
Terry Jerulle questioned the Applicant:
Q. The name of the company?
A. McBride Pro Seal.
Q Okay. And the owner?
A. Myself.
Q. 100% - You?
A, 9lo/o and 9% (indicating his son).
Q. If lmay ask you - is there any reason why your son since he's a part owner can't
take the test?
A. He doesn't have the experience?
Q. So, he wouldn't qualify ...
A. No.
Q. ... because of the experience.
A. Right.
Terry Jerulle: Would you say that if we gave you a license, that you son - in two years
- could take and pass the test?
Mr, McBride: I don't know why he couldn't --- I mean, yeah, because my intention -
at 55 years o1d - is to work for another five years and then slowly hand it off to my son
and let him run with it. So. yes. sir.
it
Richard Joslin: I'm just on the crossroads to say that to have a business, I think that
the Business and Law test is probably one of the most important ones that should be
passed. The sealing... I have no problem with how you're doing thejob because you do
have experience in the college and you have done it for other people, but it's the fact of
being able to handle and run that business conectly. If those people should leave you
for whatever reason, the business is going to have no one who knows what is going on.
Mr. McBride: For what it's worth, I've run my own business in St. t-ouis for several
years. It wasn't this particular business. I was a corporate headhunter for twenty-five
years in St. I-ouis. For twenty of those years, I was self-employed working with small
and medium-sized companies who didn't have an HR Department or intemal recruiters.
I've run my own business for over twenty years now. We run a clean ship - a tight
business - with no issues.
Richard Joslin: I appreciate that.
Patrick White: So, based on the testimony, the risk is with the fellow who came close
to passing the B&L exam by one point and is here because of the stated issues is going
to, suddenly, over the next twenty-four months, cause a circumstance to arise in a
business where - with no cash up front and records managed by a CPA for accounting
and tax purposes and payroll by a competent professional - is going to cause harm and
would warrant us withholding $anting a license to someone who is otherwise qualifred.
Richard Joslin: Doesn't this license allow him to do commercial work also?
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes, sir.
Mr. McBride: It would, but I have no interest. Single-family homes is basically our
niche.
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 200 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17, 2018
Richard Joslin: That was part of my reason... that could be, I suppose, if it was
restricted to residential ...
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes, sir, if you wish.
Chairman Boyd: Has your son done this work before ...
Mr. McBride: Yes, sir.
Chairman Boyd: ... with you ... he's had some experience?
Mr. McBride: Yes, sir.
Chairman Boyd: How much can you verify? A year ... two years?
Mr. McBride: A year and a ha1f.
Chairman Boyd: So, we could grant a probationary license and then, based on the son
who would take the test within a year ... would everybody be comfortable with that?
Mr. White?
Patrick White: If there's some reason to go that route, then we should consider a
limitation on the Scope of Work for the license. I'm certainly going to support that,
but I believe he has otherwise demonstrated an adequate level of protection for the
consumer. If there's anything that ought to be rightfully done with respect to the license
in terms of Scope of Work, that would seem to me to be more prudent at this point. I
don't know what's going to happen in six, eight, twelve or twenty-four months from
now, but I know that if, as long as he is in business and the Scope of the license is
limited to non-commercial, then I'm comfortable that the consumers are protected.
Terry Jerulle: One of the things that I'd like to see and be - as much as I probably fail
at it - is trying to be consistent. And I'm consistent about having people take and pass
tests. I had to do it for my license and several people on the Board had to do the same
and to maintain that license. Whenever someone comes before us, I always ask them
why they won't take it. Sometimes it's easier just to take the test than to come before
us. I tend to agree about giving some sort of probationary license so that his son can
take and pass the test. It not for the business than for his son, himself. I think it would
be good for him to know some of these things ifhe's going to take over the business.
Maybe a year is long enough ... maybe a year and a half or two years ... I don't know
what the timeframe is but ... I like the idea of giving you a license and I also like the idea
of having somebody take the test. And I like the idea of being consistent with
everybody who comes before us.
9
Everildo Ybaceta: If I may ask a question? Mr. McBride ...
Mr. McBride: Yes.
Everildo Ybaceta: Your son ... I'm sorry ... what is your name? Andrew. Has Andrew
gone to college?
Mr. McBride: Yes, sir. FGCU ("Florida Gulf Coast University").
Everildo Ybaceta: FGCU. What kind of ...
Mr. McBride: It was FSW ("Florida Southwestem State College") for one semester.
Everildo Ybaceta: For?
Mr. McBride: General business.
Everildo Ybaceta: So, that could be used... for every year of college, it's .75 of
experience that could be added to his record ...
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 201 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17.2018
Richard Joslin: But it was only one semester.
Everildo Ybaceta: Okay. Also, if we could extend the probation a little bit only
because family cannot verify experience ... or should not verify experience. So, if you
could add a little bit exfta to the probation so that he can gather the minimum amount of
experience of ...
Terry Jerulle: Two years ... 24 months.
Everildo Ybaceta: ... twenty-four months.
Patrick White: All right. I mean, I'm simply stating my view. As I indicated, I will
support a motion of either aspect or both because I believe it achieves the objective as
has been stated.
Richard Joslin: I'm fine with it as far as it is for residential only.
Terry Jerulle: After he takes the test, he can do commercial.
Richard Joslin: He can go to commercial, correct, if he chooses to.
Terry Jerulle: And in the future - who knows what the future will tell - he may want
to do commercial ... be more aggressive.
Mr. McBride: We've had the opportunity to do it, but I just don't want to pursue that
path. I don't know if that's a good thing or a bad thing, but I'vejust created my own
little niche and I'm trying to stick with it.
Patrick White: Mr. McBride, you've indicated that you prefer single family ...
Mr. McBrider Yes, sir.
Patrick White: The way that this tlpically breaks down between residential and
commercial is because building permits for condominiums are "commercial" ... does
your business make a distinction between those two in terms of what you think
residential is? I live in a residential condominium and its not a commercial operation if
you will but if your license were restricted to "residential" - I think we want to be clear
on what that would or should include for your perspective ... if they are condominiums
or not... or one or two-story condominiums ... I don't know.
Mr. McBride: We haven't done that ...
Patrick White: When you say single family, you are talking single-family homes or
any duplexes.
Mr. McBride: There's been a duplex or two in there, but we've done nothing ... we're
not going vertical. And we're not going on roofs either - that's something we have no
interest in.
Patrick White: I think residential would include duplexes.
Richard Joslin moved to approve granting a two-year Probationary License Sealing
and Striping Contractor's License to R. Adrian McBride with the Scope of Work
limited to residential properties. Patrick White offered a Second in support of the
motion. Carried unanimously, 6 - 0.
t0
Richard Joslin: What about a fourplex?
Mr. McBride: A fourplex?
Everildo Ybaceta: A fourplex is commercial.
Richard Joslin: Okay.
Mr. McBride: Our niche is a single-family home of Mr. and Mrs. Smith, you know, a
driveway and lanai.
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 202 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17, 2018
(Note: The individuals who testified in the following case under ltem IX, *OA
Business," were ftrst sworn in by the Attorney for the Board.)
IX. Oln Busrurss:
A. Jeffrev Bumpus - Misconduct of State-Certified Contractor: Expired Permits Update
(dlbla "Northern Breeze Air Conditioning, Inc.)
Chairman Boyd: Mr. Bumpus, you are here today to provide an update on the expted
permits.
Jeffrey Bumpus: Yes.
Chairman Boyd: Reggie, do you have a report for us?
Reggie Smith, Contractors' Licensing Compliance Officer, and Josh Lenio stated:o Seven permits in are "void" status;. Four permits are in "re-activated" status;
. One permit is in "ready to issue" status;
o Twelve permits have been issued;
. One permit is in "Inspection commenced" status;
. One permit is in "Inspection completed" status
. There are seven outstanding permits and the remainder of them have been
actively pursued.
Josh Lenio clarified the seven permits in "void" status are considered as the
outstanding permits that must be addressed.
Patrick White requested further clarification.
Josh Lenio explained the seven "void" permits are expired and the contractor must
submit a re-application for each. The remaining seven are "outstanding" permits which
means that Mr. Bumpus acted in good faith by either applying for an extension or
submitting a re-application. He has called for inspections and is working toward
getting those permits completed.
Patrick White: So, it's fair to say that over the past seven days, he has moved four of
the original eleven from "void" to some other status?
Josh Lenio: That's correct. The seven that are in "void" status - when you look at the
properties - he has not submitted re-applications for those permits.
Patrick White: Okay. From my perspective, that's the area of inquiry for us with Mr.
Bumpus. I appreciate the update - it's very helpful. The one number I missed was
"ready for issuance."
Josh Lenio: lnstead of four, it's now one.
Patrick White: Okay. So, that's where the three went ... into "issued."
Chairman Boyd: Reggie, when we flrrst started this, we were told there were 44
permits.
Reggie Smith: Approximately, yes, sir. That was a total of expired and void.
Patrick White: Currently, the seven "void" are expted -- correct?
Josh Lenio: That's correct.
l1
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 203 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17, 2018
Richard Joslin: That's going to require him to re-apply totally for those seven
permits?
Josh Lenio: (nodding his head in agreement)
Richard Joslin questioned Jeffrey Bumpus:
Q. You have heard the results so far.
A. Yes.
Q. What is your plan for the seven void permits?
A. I'vejust got to get the application - there's two in process right now. One of them
was kicked back yesterday because they want a drawing of the location. They
didn't know which one it was. I've gottwo in the same building andoneof them
has been re-issued. Yesterday it was rejected - I got an email and I need a drawing.
It was done in 2012. I've got it scheduled for an inspection for tomorrow on the
other system so I'm hoping to work it out where they can check them both and sign
them both off.
Patrick White questioned Jeffrey Bumpus:
Q. And the other five?
A. I haven't done the paperwork on them yet. Two of them, I don't know who the
owners are yet. They are rental houses that I did for friends of friends, so I'm trying
to get the information on two of them. The other two, I've just got to do the
paperwork and turn it in.
Q. And the fifth?
A. One of them is ... I had a hearing - some Iady turned me for putting in an air-
conditioner in and I went to a hearing. It was five years old. So, with the person
who was in charge at the time - after the hearing, he went in and issued a permit ...
it was supposedly signed off ... I called Reggie on it, but he wasn't the hearing
offrcer at the time. So that's just a matter of talking to Mr. Noonan and hopefully
we can clear that one up totally without even applying for it. He charged me $50 or
$25 for the permit and said that we didn't need an inspection.
Q. And that's five -- total?
A. Yeah. I don't know the sixth ... I have to check for sure. I got two in there now ...
one of them is the wrong name - the old owner, not the new owner. I'vejustgotto
change the name and re-apply. I've got, like, twenty of them completed - inspected
- done.
Q. Okay.
A. And I've got two scheduled for tomorrow ... or three ... once I go back and call the
third one in and, hopefully, they will do the fourth cause it's in the same building ...
it's the office for the project. So, I'm trying to get them done. So far, wehaven't-
that I know of - failed any. I've been with the Inspector on everyone. I usually do
four at a time - it takes twenty minutes for him, basically. twenty minutes to an
hour to run through and do four.
Q. How much time do you think it's going to take to finish off the ...?
A. I've got more people coming in now, so ... by next month, they all should be 100%.
I was hoping to have them all done by now but they're not.
t2
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 204 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October l?.2018
Richard Joslin: How does Staff feel about this - the results so far? Reggie?
Reggie Smith: This is a burden for the homeowners. My priority is to protect the
homeowners and their properties. My Bumpus has come approximately half-way.
We've been before the Board quite a few times. We will not have a Contractors'
Licensing Board hearing in the month of November due to the holiday. So, depending
on your Order today, if it's added time, then we will be coming back in December.
Hopefully, we really can have them all done by then.
Patrick White: I think I heard you say either thirty or sixty days. Once he gets them
all out of void status, we're effectively at a point where we could reconsider the
already-imposed disciplinary action.
Everildo Ybaceta: I don't believe that a disciplinary action has been imposed yet.
(Several Board members were making comments at the same time.)
Richard Joslin: I-ast month, he had until this meeting to do everything, I'm pretty sure
... if you look at the last page of the minutes.
Patrick White: He was restricted to no new ones - that's my understanding. He is
limited to only the ones currently outstanding. What I'd like to do, Mr. Chairman, if
we've ha.d an adequate discussion so far, is to make a motion to continue the matter
to the next meeting for a determination of any nodification to the disciplinary action
to be imposed.
Chairman Boyd: Is that the form of your motion?
Richard Joslin: 1'l/ second the motion.
Terry Jerulle: I'm sorry - I didn't hear the motion.
Patrick White moved to approve continuing the matter to the next Board meeting for
further deliberation. The disciplinary action that has alrea.dy been imposed remains
and at the next meeting, the Board will consi.der any modification to it.
Terry Jerulle: So, you want to do the same thing that we've done in August and the
same thing we did in September?
Patrick White: I believe it was September.
Terry Jerulle: It was continued in August.
Jeffrey Bumpus: I wasn't here in August.
Terry Jerulle: That's my point - you were invited but didn't show up. You were
invited to last month's meeting and didn't show up either.
Jeffrey Bumpus: Last month, I didn't but the month before, I did show up. - I thought
I did.
Terry Jerulle: No. You were here in May.
Jeffrey Bumpuss That was the first meeting. It says on the Complaint that in August,
Mr. Bumpus was scheduled to retum to the Board, but he did not show up. In
September, he was scheduled to retum to the Board and was given proper notice but did
not show up. You weren't here in August and you weren't here in September. I don't
know about the rest of you, but I'm ready to go to the State. I'm done.
Jeffrey Bumpus: Okay.
13
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 205 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17,2018
Terry Jerulle: I mean, you give us enough just to keep it going - I don't know why
you don't just finish it!
Jeffrey Bumpus: I'm actually getting....
Terry Jerulle: Why didn't you come to the meeting last month?
Jeffrey Bumpus: I wasn't around.
Terry Jerulle: Pardon me?
Jeffrey Bumpus: I wasn't around ... I was in Fort Myers.
Terry Jerulle: And why didn't you come to the meeting in August?
Jeffrey Bumpus: I was out of town ... I was in Orlando for my birthday. I even told
[gesturing to StafIl that I wouldn't be here for that one.
Richard Joslin: I can see Mr. Jerulle's point and I can go along with it somewhat ...
I'm going to second this motion only because ... I think at this moment you've been
here many times in the past ...
Jeffrey Bumpus: Yes ... correct.
Richard Joslin: ... and we're a little frustrated with your being here ...
Jeffrey Bumpus: I realize that.
Richard Joslin: ... and not getting these permits done.
Jeffrey Bumpus: Right.
Richard Joslin: But on the other side of the coin, I look at the residents of Collier
County who are sitting there with no final inspections on their units ...
Jeffrey Bumpus: Correct.
Ricard Joslin: ... and it seems like you are just doing a piece at a time. Unfortunately,
we don't have a meeting in November - otherwise, I would definitely make a different
motion and it would be all over. But, under this circumstance, I will go along with Mr.
White's...
Patrick White: I heard Staff say we are presently not scheduled to meet in November
... the form of the motion was "the next meeting" ... so if it's November - it's
November, if it's December - it's December, if it's January - it's January. To the point
of clarification on what happened last month ... I want to be certain - it's my
understanding and I believe that the Board, last month, restricted his license. That's a
different disciplinary or Board action than what took place in August or in May because
it imposed an additional limitation on his license. The only other "next step" is - as
you suggested Mr. Jerulle and I think that Mr. Bumpus hasn't quite caught the essence
of our concems here - or he would have gotten these last seven off "void." He knows
what's going on. I know what I'm going to do. I'm not trying to pre-judge the case,
but I can tell you with almost certainty that I would adhere to your position 100% at
that point. If there wasn't a good faith effort on his part, and to Mr. Nolton's point as I
read it in the minutes for last month, and as Mr. Joslin said, I've come down on the side
of the people who may or may not be in the process of trying to sell one of these units
that have the seven voids, and they're going to have to get to cleared up. We can't do it
without him. He's not only the lock, if you will, but he's also the key. I don't want to
take the key away from them by referring him to the State until we are absolutely
certain that it's no longer his intention to correct this mess.
Richard Joslin: I'm not content with the time or....
Patrick White: No.
Richard Joslin: ... the speed that he's been doing them ... but at least we're getting
14
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 206 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17,2018
Assistant County Attorney Kevin Noell: If Icouldjustadd... I'mthe "lawyer"...
Jeffrey Bumpus: I'm sorry ... the Assistant County Attomey.
Assistant County Attorney Noell: I met with Mr. Bumpus and Staff and explained
to him ... because I wanted to get a feel for what had happened in other Counties with
a situation like this. I certainly understand and can appreciate the Board's frustration
with - as Mr. White had alluded to - him holding the lock and the key and seeming to
move at his own pace. In looking at this type of factual scenario, when I talked with
the State - they referenced a recent case in Sarasota where a similar HVAC company
t5
something accomplished ... at least some of the residents are going to be satisfied
with inspections. Again, I'm not content with the time span.
Jeffrey Bumpus: I've been trying to pull the permits for the ones that I can get
inspected - for the ones I know are here. I didn't realize it was such a big deal to get
all the paperwork 100% -- I met with the lawyer [Assistant County Attomey Noell]
and he told me to get them done.
Patrick White: Yeah.
Jeffrey Bumpus: And, like I said, I think I've filed 17 of them or something like
that, or half of them in the next ... Ijust picked up the final three yesterday and paid
for them, and they're ready to go. I've got to do two corrections and I'll get two more
and then fill out whatever paperwork I've got left and I know the ones I have left are
not in communities - they are single-family houses that I've done for rentals so it's
just a matter of finding out who the name is and get the records, I guess, pull up all
the old stuff. I have no idea who owned them then and who owns them now.
Patrick White: The Property Appraiser's database can tell you that based on the
address.
Jeffrey Bumpus: Okay. Well, I'll sit down with Josh and we'll see if we can't work
it out. Like I said, there's one or two other ones that I need to try to work out with
him.
Patrick White: You have a plan and you believe that this plan can be implemented
within the time frame that it sounds like ...
Jeffrey Bumpus: No, I've got three or four more ready that are on my other project
will be scheduled next week ...
Patrick White: Do you think it will take longer?
Jeffrey Bumpus: What? To schedule the permit? No, no, no, no ... like I said, if
you had a meeting next week - I'd be totally close... I'd be 99o/o done. There might
be one or two that aren't done. That's the best I can say.
Patrick White: How much time do you need?
Jeffrey Bumpus: Next month. But I mean, I'm doing my best. I'm just trying to get
them inspected and get them done.
Patrick White: Is it your intention to pursue and complete all of them?
Jeffrey Bumpus: Yes.
Patrick White: Correct?
Jeffrey Bumpus: Yes. For all the ones that he [Josh Lenio] did the extensions for, I
wrote a check for $900 and got them done. There were two that were already
inspected - maybe three - so they should be signed off. I should have about twenty
out of ... what is it ... thirty-five or forty completed ... 100% ... signed off and done.
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 207 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17,2018
was fined roughly $60,000.00 for these types of violations - so I explained to Mr.
Bumpus the urgency to the task he needs to now have. So, I have no thoughts on
what the Board might decide but I think he understands it's much more than him
holding the cards here and the next step would be a step that would probably
significantly would change his business if he's not going forward. So, that was
basically the scope of our conversation.
Richard Joslin: Too bad that we didn't know this back in September or October or
August and September when this first started. It maybe may have put a little bit of a
fire under him because it can get serious.
Jeffrey Bumpus: I don't have $60,000 to pay a fine. So, I definitely don't want to
do that.
Terry Jerulle: I'd like to call your attention to Page 51 ... the last paragraph ... the
Board voted unanimously to give him thirty days.
Patrick White: Correct.
Terry Jerulle: And ... if all the permits are not in final status, a recommendation for
further action will be made to the State of Florida. That's how I'm going to vote. And
by me voting that way does not prevent him from still completing his permits.
Patrick White: So, you're going to vote "no" on this motion?
Terry Jerulle: I am.
Patrick White: Okay.
Terry Jerulle: Because I want to be consistent.
Patrick White: That's fine. I have no issue with consistency. I think we all strive for
that.
Terry Jerulle: And it doesn't prevent him from still being the key to the lock. In my
mind, it's going to motivate him to even get it done faster. Because if hedoes-it's
going to take time to get to the State - and by the time it gets to the State - he better be
done with the permits.
Patrick White: Mr. Jerulle, I don't know if it's a tremendous burden on Staff to go
tfuough that exercise. If I thought it was necessary, I'd certainly withdraw my motion
and support it. But I believe we're on the right path and I don't know that we need to
go that distance yet. The form of my motion is one that I believe takes what the Board
did last month and effectively continues the later part without changing the restriction
on his license.
Chairman Boyd: We have a motion and a Second. Does anybody else have a
comment?
Richard Joslin: I'm only seconding this motion because as I read Page 51 with Mr.
Jerulle, at this moment, that could apply right now. There would be no more time span
... you already worked out your time span as far as I am concemed. However, again
I'm going to go back to the residents of Collier County. You're showing due diligence
to get this done. If we go to the State, that may all stop and then you may not have a
reason to do it any longer. And then we're going to have a whole bunch of people out
there who aren't being satisfred ... which is going to open another can of worms. So,at
this moment, I made a Second on that motion and as I say, I may have done it with
good intentions but I'm willing to, I guess in a sense, recant it for the moment only to
see that this happens before this next meeting. And if itdoesn't, Ijustdon'tknow what
to tell you.
16
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 208 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17,2018
Chairman Boyd: So, do we have a Second or we don't have a Second?
Richard Joslin: You have a Second.
Chairman Boyd: We have a Second. Also, from the get-go, when he agreed, we gave
him sixty days to get 44 permits cleared out. At that time, I thought it was a myth -
there was no way he could do that and now we're about where I thought we'd be with
him getting these closed out because it's not a simple process.
Richard Joslin: kt me ask another question - real quick. Would Staff ... if by some
chance he was to ... he said he could do this within a few weeks - correct? Is that what
I heard?
Jeffrey Bumpus: The paperwork is just a matter of filling out a form.
Richard Joslin: If this happens ... if this does happen before our so-called non-
November meeting and he brings it before Staff, could this then be rectified by Staff
and not have to come before the Board in December? I'm only trying to eliminate the
fact of waiting until the December meeting to hear it again and then come back and see
what's going on. If we give him until November... can Staff handle it?
Patrick White: Not going to step in on Staff s response, but my understanding and the
basis for the form of the motion was that whenever our next Bo.ud meeting is, we're
going to have an update and a report. We are still at a point where we have a final
determination of disciplinary action to be made, and a potential to change the
restrictions on the license. Assuming - for the sake of discussion - we are at a point
where the restrictions could be lifted, I don't know that I would vote in favor of that at
all. Suffice it to say that some of that will depend upon what happens in the interim and
on what Mr. Bumpus' intentions are with respect to losing his license or not. He may
choose to let it lapse - I don't know. Based on what I've hear in the prior months, he's
looking to dojust "maintenance" and he may not need a license. So, that's why I think
that a more prudent course of action today is to give him the time and to protect the
residents and not impose a burden on Staff to go through a process that seems the
Respondent has already received the message about.
Chairman Boyd: How much time are you giving him, Mr. White?
Patrick White: Until our next Board meeting.
Chairman Boyd: Until our next Board meeting?
Patrick White: Yes.
Chairman Boyd: Have you considered limiting that to thirty days?
Patrick White: Even if we did, there's no way that until we next meet, we can do
anything differently about it.
Chairman Boyd: Staff can. You can put that in the motion.
Patrick White: I am not a fan of self-executing Orders except when there is a very
clear and bright line of how to proceed.
Assistant County Attorney Noell: I think one of the issues is that the Board maintains
jurisdiction of this issue ...
Patrick White: Yes.
Assistant County Attorney Noell: ... because the Board collectively voted - heard the
evidence - and found a violation ...
Patrick White: Right.
Assistant County Attorney Noell: ... or several violations ... many of which still
exist.
t'7
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 209 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17.2018
Patrick White: Correct.
Assistant County Attorney Noell: So, it still has to come back before the Board -
even if it's been abated - when the Board found the violations, they weren't abated.
The Board has the jurisdiction to act on what sort of penalty or punishment would be
involved.
Richard Joslin: It has to be heard.
Patrick White: Beyond what we've done so far. And I understand Mr. Jerulle's
point that - in a sense - part of the motion that was approved last month in terms of
the disciplinary action is that there should be a referral made at this time. The form of
my motion simply holds off on doing that until our next Board meeting.
Chairman Boyd: We have a motion and a second. Does anyone else have a
comment? I will call for a vote.
Motion carried, 4 - "Yes" and 2 - "No." Chairman Boyd and Mr. Jerulle were
opposed.
Matthew Nolton: I've been quiet, but I want to say something to Mr. Bumpus. So,
we expect this to be cleared up by the next time you come before us. We have the
ability to recommend to Staff to take this to the State and we can recommend what
fine we think the State should impose. They may not listen to us but I, as one
member, will vote very strongly for a stiffpenalty if this has not been taken care ofby
our next meeting.
Chairman Boyd: Thank you. sir.
Richard Joslin: Good luck.
X. PUBLIC HEARING:
A. Case 2018-09: Board of County Commissioners, Plaintiff, vs. Andrew Wood,
dlbla AMW Construction Semices,Izc., Misconduct of a
State-Certified Contractor
(Np1!s: The individuals who testified in the following case under ltem X, "Public
Hearing," were ftrst sworn in by the Attorney for the Board.)
Chairman Boyd noted that Respondent, Andrew Wood, was not present.
Patrick White: Mr. Chairman, as a point of order, if you wouldn't mind reading the
"anyone who decides to appeal" verbiage for the record.
Chairman Boydz "Any person who decides to appeal a decision of this Board will
need a record of the proceedings and may need to ensure that a verbatim record of
said proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evi.dence upon
which any Appeal is to be made."
Chairman Boyd outlined the process for the Hearing:
. This Hearing wili be conducted pursuant to the procedures set fo(h in Collier
County Ordinance #90-105, as amended, and Florida Statutes Chapter 49.
l8
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 210 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17,2018
The Hearing is quasi-judicial in nature and the Formal Rules of Evidence will
not apply.
Chairman Boyd requested a motion to open the Public Hearing for Case #2018-09:
Board of County Commissioners, Plaintiff, vs. Andrew W ood, dlbla AMW
Construction Services, 12c., Misconduct of a State-Certified Contractor.
Patrick White moved to approve opening the Public Hearing for Case #2018-09 as
previously referenced. Richard Joslin offered a Second in support of the motion.
Carried unanimously, 6 - 0.
Chairman Boyd conflrmed the Public Hearing was open.
Jack Gumph, Contractors' Licensing Compliance Officer, requested to introduce
the information packet in Case #2018-09 into evidence as County's Exhibit "A."
Patrick White moved to approve the County's request. Richard Joslin offered a
Second in support of the motion. Carried unanimously, 6 - 0.
Jack Gumph presented the County's Opening Statement:o The Respondent is a State-certified General Contractor and holder of License
Number CCC1507208.
o He is also registered in Collier County (#LCC201120001969) as a General
Contmctor.
. The Respondent installed five windows in a condominium at 709 Palm View
Drive, Naples, Florida 341 10, without first obtaining a permit.
. On June 1 , 2017 , a complaint was made by the homeowner, Deirdre Ventry.
o On June 9, 2017 , a site inspection was performed. The tenants stated
windows had been replaced in the unit approximately two years earlier. The
owner later arrived and confirmed that she hired a contractor in September of
2015 to install five windows in the condominium.
o On August 9 ,2017 , the homeowner provided the name of the contractor and
Andrew W. Wood of AMW Construction Services, Inc. was contacted by
telephone.
o Mr. Wood was informed that a permit was required to install windows
in a condominium in compliance with Code regulations.
o Mr. Wood stated his registration in Collier County had lapsed but he
would re-active it and then apply for the permit.
o On August 16,2017, a Notice of Non-Compliance was emailed to Mr. Wood.
o On November 6,2017 , following a message left on Mr. Wood's phone, he
retumed the call and stated he had re-activated the registration in Collier
County and was preparing to submit an application to obtain a permit for the
window installation.
o On December 4,2017, an application for a permit had not been submitted. and
a Notice of Hearing was issued to appear at on February 2 I , 20 1 8 . The Notice
was sent to Mr. Wood via certified mail.
l9
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 211 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17, 2018
On December 26,2O1'7 , rhe signed proof of delivery to Andrew Wood was
received from the US Postal Service.
On February 16,2018, the February 21't Contractors' Board meeting was
rescheduled to March 21, 2018 and Mr. Wood was again notified of the new
Hearing date by certified mail.
On February 28,2018, the signed proof of delivery to Andrew Wood was
received from the US Postal Service.
Patrick White: Mr. Chairman - Point of Order. I think we're at the point where
we're supposedly receiving information about a summary of the County's case, i.e.,
the Case in Chief, which is what I guess we are hearing now. But if there is anything
that is za, already in the written record that has been submitted into evidence, that can
be added, I am certainly willing to hear that. But I would prefer to not have to listen
to what I have already read be stated again because it's already in the record. I
apologize, Mr. Gumph, but I am interested in anything new that you can tell me ...
such as why Mr. Wood is not here today ... such as the conclusion and inference that
has been drawn is this is a willful violation is being substantiated in the record today.
So, Point if Order, Mr. Chairman. I don't know how the other members feel but I've
heard enough because I do my homework, I review the file.
Richard Joslin: Mr. Gumph, Mr. Wood received a certified mail that he was
required to be here today - correct?
Jack Gumph: That's correct, and the certified mailing was his signature because it
was the same signature of the previous certified mailing. I'd like to enter into the
record that Mr. Wood came into the office on the day before the March 21't meeting
and provided a receipt for the permit application which he had submitted. I believe
that he had abated the violation. At the time I advised him that he had to follow
though with the permit application because there had been a Code violation which he
did not.
Patrick White: Understood.
Chairman Boyd: But you haven't seen or spoken to him since?
Jack Gumph: I've emailed him on several occasions ... no. One point to note is that
his State license is not delinquent ... he hasn't paid up.
Patrick White: You see, that's a key fact for me because what you're asking me and
this Board to do is to infer from his action or his non-action that his conduct is willful,
i.e., intentional. So, being aware that he had to renew his license in order to be able
to complete going through the permitting process to abate the violation that otherwise
would have been heard "back when"... is readily apparent to me that his failure to
renew his license and allowing it to continue to be in the delilquent status prohibits
him from being able to move forward on the permit that he applied for and, thus, is
intentional, i.e., willful, as a violation today without having to have - as we've had in
the past for consistency's sake - a statement from the Building Official ... which I
may have missed in the packet, but I don't see the Building Official here today - that
the Building Official's conclusion and opinion as a professional is that the violation
was willful. So, hopefully we've gotten to the point - at least in my mind - and I
don't know how the Board members feel - where I ... I think the County has
a
20
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 212 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17.2018
cemented its case, if you will, in terms of the testimony today. I appreciate you
adding that piece of information. Again, that was the most critical keystone for me in
the arch that we're trying to build to go from an alleged violation to a Finding of
Violation. Just so in the months and hearings ahead, I am clear on what the
expectation is on how we complete that arch and get from one side to the other.
Jack Gumph: I agree with you, sir. I think that's something that needs to be
discussed Staff on how we go forward with these. There has been some discussion
about that and there needs to be some more discussion.
Patrick White: But not today. From my perspective, I think you have all done your
jobs.
Chairman Boyd: Is the permit is still in the rejected status - is that correct?
Jack Gumph: It's expired.
Chairman Boyd: It was never approved - it was always in rejected status?
Jack Gumph: Correct. He was sent a Correction Notice, but he never responded to
ir.
Richard Joslin: It appears that it was dehnitely willful, there's no doubt. I mean,
for someone to not renew his license and not get this particular permit and get it
finalized - it's pretty clear-cut ... this is a pretty much "done deal" as far as I can see.
I don't think it needs a whole lot of discussion. I know there are only certain things
we can do to a State-certified contractor but is he licensed in other Counties also?
Everildo Ybaceta: I'm sorry, what is the question?
Richard Joslin: He is a State-certified contractor -- correct?
Everildo Ybaceta: Correct.
Richard Joslin: One of the things we can do is to stop his permit pulling privileges.
Everildo Ybaceta: In Collier County, yes, sir.
Richard Joslin: But ifhe's not licensed, it's not going to matter an)'\ ay.
Terry Jerulle: It will matter because we can make a recommendation to the State ...
Richard Joslin: Right.
Everildo Ybaceta: Correct.
Terry Jerulle: ... and if he goes to renew his license, he may or may not be able to.
Richard Joslin: You're right.
Patrick White: But, flrst things first.
Chairman Boyd: Obviously, moving forward, we have no Respondent to present his
case. So, can I have a motion to close the Public Hearing.
Patrick White moved to approve closing the Public Hearing for Case #2018-09.
Richard Joslin offered a Second in support of the motion.
Caried unanimously, 6 - 0.
Patrick White: Thank you, Mr. Gumph
Patrick White moved to approve finding the Respondent guilty of the violation
consistent wilh Count One as stated in the Administration Complnint for a willful
violation of misconduct by a State-certijied contfactor. Richard Joslin offered a
Second in support of the motion.
21
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 213 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17,2018
Chairman Boyd asked if there was any discussion needed. With no response from
the Board, he called for a vole on the motion.
Carried unanimously, 6 - 0.
Patrick White suggested asking the Board's Attorney for advice on what the Board
was allowed to do.
Attorney Schneck: There are two options. The Board can suspend or conditionally
restrict his permirpulling privileges in Collier County. The Board can make a
recommendation to the State's Construction Industry Licensing Board ("CILB") for
further action - whether its penalties or a State-level suspension.
Patrick White addressed his question to Staff: Since the permit has expired and his
license is inactive, in order for Mr. Wood to be able to perform any work under a
permit, he must come in and pay and he's good to go?
Everildo Ybaceta: No, sir.
Patrick White: What does he have to do?
Everildo Ybaceta: Since he is a State-certified Contractor, much like Mr. Lantz is, if
he does update his license with the State, he can come in and show his certificate and
his insurance and he can be issued a permit. The voluntary registration that we do is
only for the use of the portal. Since he has not updated his Collier regisuation and
paid for the use of the portal, that's why he shows up as "inactive" in our system.
Patrick White: What is the status of his license relative to the State's DBPR
("Department of Business and Professional Regulation")?
Everildo Ytraceta: Delinquent.
(An off-mic comment was made.)
Patrick White: If you're going to offer testimony, Mr. Gumph, you must be at the
podium.
Patrick White: So, the same question but at the State level. If he just goes into the
State in delinquent status and pays whatever he has to pay to renew his license, does
the State automatically renew it?
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes.
Patrick White: Okay. What I'm trying to get to is ... is it worth us doing anything
relative to his license in Collier County given his status relative to his State license.
What I hear you saying is, it is because we want to avoid a circumstance where he
simply has to renew with the State by paying some money, then comes in and shows
you a certificate and thus he's now "clean and green."
Everildo Ybaceta: At the point where the Board finds him in violation and either
restricts or suspends his permitting privileges in Collier County, I have fifteen days to
submit that information to the State.
Patrick White: My point is the distinction between the first of the two opportunities
we have for disciplinary action versus the second. I understand if we find him in
violation, you're going to report that. But-just thinking out loud - if wedon'tfor
whatever crazy reason don't impose some restriction on his license, you're still going
22
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 214 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17,2018
There was a general discussion among the members; the consensus was to also
restrict the Respondent's permit pulling privileges in Collier County to this specijlc
permit. The recommendation to the State was to allow renewal of his State-certified
license conditioned upon completing the permit application in Collier County.
Richard Joslin: I don't think that's going to work.
Terry Jerulle: Well, I'm not saying they will do it, I'm saying I don't know.
Patrick White: Therefore, I think we should simply make the recommendation - the
State understands our authority to restrict ...
Richard Joslin: ln other words, what you're trying to say is he can't get his State
license - or if he does get his State license - it is govemed by cleaning up this
particular permit in Collier County?
Patrick White: That he would be limited in Collier County to this permit only until
the permit is otherwise closed. He can re-apply.
Matthew Nolton: I think it's a little more complicated than that. If you go back
further and read what the County rejected, I don't think he can get a permit because
what the County rejection was there was no evidence of the windows being the right
size for egress - means of egress. So, I'm fairly positive the reason why he didn't
follow through is because he couldn't follow through without changing out these
windows.
Patrick White: And if the Building Official were here, I would inquire of him as to
the specifics of what the physical design of the unit was and whether, in fact, a
window could be a second means of egress or not. It may not be a size issue, it could
23
to have the reporting recommendation ...
Everildo Ybaceta: Correct.
Patrick White: ... or the reporting requirement with or without a recommendation
from the Board. I'm just trying to unravel the two threads and make sure that there's
a point to us going forward in resaicting his license. I believe we certainly should ...
at least in Collier County... whatever he does at the State level. I further believe that
we should make a recommendation to the State for an imposition of some type of
limitation on his license at the State level, unless or until he makes a commitment to
come in and deal with the permit. I mean, he shouldn't be allowed to operate
elsewhere in the State until he addresses the matter here in Collier County.
Richard Joslin: We can make the recommendation but whether it happens or not is
another thing.
Patrick White: I understand that - we're not the CILB. So, that was the whole point
of my inquiry.
Everildo Ybaceta: It as a long road to get there.
Patrick White: Well, but at least now, I'm 100% certain we have to take that course
of action. And I didn't want to put Staff through the mechanics of doing something
that really didn't matter. Since he can get around us by going to the State and simply
paying money - that's not a good safeguard for me.
Richard Joslin: We have a case and we've found the Respondent guilty - we have
to make a Finding of Fact to proceed. The Finding of Fact is the penalty and the
penalty that we can impose is to contact the State.
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 215 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17. 2018
be simply the manner in which it opens. In my unit, I had to go with a 90" opening,
casement-style crank out to provide that secondary egress even though I had double
sliders right there.
Terry Jerulle: We don't know that it wouldn't pass ...
Patrick White: Exactly.
Terry Jerulle: ... it might pass ... he just may have not provided that information.
Regardless, it's his duty to get a window that does pass the NOA ("Notice of
Acceptance") and it is his duty to get a window that is the correct size.
Matthew Nolton: You're right - we do not know, but he did go through the effort of
getting the permitting. He re-appiied to obtain a permit, but it was rejected and that's
where he stopped for whatever reason. So, we found him guilty.
Patrick White: If that were all that he had done, I wouldn't be in a position where I
was comfortable finding him to be "willful." It's the fact that he failed to get his
iicense and keep it active to be able to work on the permit before it expired that to me
makes it willful.
Terry Jerulle: If I can summarize this, are we in agreement to restrict his Collier
County permit pulling privileges to this case only?
Richard Joslin and Patrick White stated they agreed.
Terry Jerulle: And are we comfortable recommending to the State that if he gets a
license that he takes care of this case before he's allowed to do any other work?
Richard Joslin: Yes.
Terry Jerulle: I don't know how to put that into the form of a motion, but I think
that we are all in ...
Matthew Nolton: Well, the exact wording is "restriction of the registration." So
that's what we're saying - we would recommend that the State restricts his
registration until he has rectified this permit.
Terry Jerulle: There's no permit.
Patrick White: The "subject matter" of the case.
Matthew Nolton: Correct.
Patrick White: Specifrcally, the address and the issues regarding the expired permit.
Matthew Nolton: We can do that. But I haven't heard anybody say anything about
a monetary fine that we could recommend to the State.
Everildo Ybaceta: For clarification, the permit was never issued. It is still an
application.
Matthew Nolton: Conect.
Terry Jerulle: Does the County have any administrative costs?
Everildo Ybacetar For this? No.
Chairman Boyd: The maximum fine we can impose is the maximum fine we can
recommend.
Terry Jerulle: I'm not worried about a fine, I just want that condo to be safe. The
homeowner paid for windows that were impact resistant and Code compliant - and
they may or may not be - we don't know.
Patrick White: And that's the other factual thing I would have inquired of the
Building Official was if part of the reject was if the contractor hadn't provided
shutters if the windows weren't impact resistant, or if the shutters that were there
24
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 216 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17, 2018
are not Code compliant. I thought the way Mr. Jerulle stated it was adequate relative
to the form of a motion. And I would second that if Staff believes that, from their
perspective, if they have enough direction from the Board on how to proceed in terms
of the disciplinary action. Do you feel you need greater clarification?
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes, sir, I do.
Patrick White: What is it that may not be clear?
Everildo Ybaceta: The restriction regarding the permit pulling privileges - you're
restricting it to one application and I'm not entirely certain what that means.
Patrick White: It means as to the specific factual basis for the complaint of the
property in question - the permit that was applied for but not issued. It has to at this
point - because of its expiration - to be re-applied.
Terry Jerulle: If I may ... form a motion ...
Terry Jerulle moved to approve restricting the permit pulling privileges of Andrew
Wood until he satisftes Case #2018-09, referencing 709 Palm View Dive, Naples,
Florida...
Everildo Ybaceta: So, you're allowing him to pull one permit or to continue with
this permit but no other?
Terry Jerulle: That is correct.
EverildoYbaceta: Okay.
... and that the Board recommends to the State's Constluction Industry Licensing
Board to restrict his license until Case #2018-09 is abated.
Everildo Ybaceta: Okay - that's understandable.
Patrick White offered a Second in support of the motion.
Richard Joslin directed his question to the Board's attorney: One quick clarification
-- does that terminology make sense for what we're trying to do?
Attorney Schneck: Yes, it does. The only other thing that I would recommend is ...
there was some discussion regarding administrative costs and penalties. Would you
like that included or some more general language ofany further action the CILB
deems...
Patrick White: Staff indicated they had no administrative costs and we did discuss
the notion of a fine, but I don't believe a fine is going to do us or the State any good.
If the State wants to fine him, God bless them.
Terry Jerulle: I'm done.
Chairman Boyd stated there was a motion and a Second on the Jloor. He asked if
there was a need for further discussian. Having no response, he called for a vote
on the motion. Carried unanimously, 6 - 0.
25
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 217 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17,2018
Chairman Boyd stated:
. This cause came for a Public Hearing before the Contractors' Licensing Board
on October l7 ,2018 for consideration of the Administrative Complaint filed
against Andrew M. Wood, d,lbla AMW Construction Services, Inc.
. Service of the complaint was made by certified mail, personal delivery, or
publication in accordance with Collier County Ordinance #90-105, as
amended.
o The Board having heard testimony under oath, received evidence, and heard
arguments respective to all pertinent matters hereupon issues its Findings of
Facts, Conclusions of Law and Order of the Board as follows:
Conclusions of Law, Findings of Fact, and Orders of the Board:
. Andrew M. Wood, dhla AMW Construction Senices,1nc., is the holder of
record of a Collier County Certificate of Competency, License Number
LCC20120001969.
. Mr. Wood is also a State-certified General Contractor and holder of License
Number CGC 1507208.
o The Collier County Board of County Commissioners is the Petitioner in this
matter and Andrew M. Wood is the Respondent.
. Mr. Wood was not present at the October l7 ,2018 Public Hearing and was
not represented by counsel.
o All notices required by Collier County Ordinance #90-105, as amended, have
been properly issued or personally delivered.
o The Respondent acted in a matter that is in violation of Collier County
Ordinance and is the one who committed the act.
o The allegation set forth in the Administrative Complaint as to Collier County
Ordinance #2006-46, as amended, Section 4.2.2 - Misconduct of State
Certified Contractors states: "Willfully violating the applicable Building
Codes or law of the State, City, or Collier County."
. The allegation was supported by the evidence presented at the Hearing.
Chairman Boyd: And that's it.
Richard Joslin: Ijust have one quick question for Staff. Since we have seen Mr.
Bumpus for the past several months, I'd like to know if there are any other
con[actors who have this many or maybe more outstanding permits that are not being
finalized who are not before us yet?
Patrick White: There's a can of worms.
Richard Joslin: I'm quite certain that there are.
Matthew Nolton: Before you get the answer, let me ask you does the answer in any
way affect how you may choose to vote on Mr. Bumpus' case in the future?
Richard Joslin: No, not at all. I'd just like to know if there will be more cases
coming before us.
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes, there are. There are quite a few that are ...
Patrick White: ... somewhat similarly situated!
Everildo Ybaceta: Yes, very well put. Some are extreme.
26
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 218 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
October 17, 2018
Richard Joslin: Are we actively going to pursue this situation?
Everildo Ybaceta: We are actively looking into all of them and pursuing them.
Richard Joslin: Okay.
Everildo Ybaceta: We are trying to bring them into compliance.
Terry Jerulle: Has the County come up with a system or plan to prevent this from
happening in the future?
Everildo Ybaceta: The Building Official is working on updating the Administrative
Code to touch on the subject.
Patrick White: From my understanding of the technology behind this, it could be
effectively computer-driven in terms of capturing when permits lapse, expire, or
become void - whatever the case may be - and I think what you're suggesting is that
the AdminisEative Code would impose a set of guidelines and circumstances on the
Building Department that would require them to monitor those things and take
appropriate action.
Everildo Ybaceta: You're right. I don't wish to comment any further on what the
Building Official is planning to do. Basically, he is working hard on trying to get this
passed and it's still an active document that ...
Terry Jerulle: You have answered my question.
Patrick White: If at any time the Building Official believes the views or support of
this Board would assist in that process, I certainly would be willing to take the time to
invest in understanding and offering recommendations. Additionally, I understand
what you are not saying and recognize that the County has choices as to the form it
wishes to take these types of cases to. They do not always have to come before the
Conftactors' Licensing Board. My understanding is there may be other forms that
would give the County greater latitude. For example, the County Court could impose
equitable ckcumstances where an injunction could arise. I encourage that
conversation. My point is a Judge can do things that we can't. We can't impose an
injunction on someone to take corrective action, but a Judge can. If they fail to
adhere to the terms of the injunction, they can get a weekend at "steel beach."
Richard Joslin: Is there anything in process right now to help Mr. Lenio to speed up
some of the process? Time goes on and this has been going on for seven months.
I'm sure there are more cases in the background that haven't been touched on yet.
Everildo Ybaceta: Right. He has been given more staffing to help with the process.
Richard Joslin: Okay.
B. Case 2018-10: Board of County Commissioners, Plaintiff, vs. Stephen Bowles,
Misconduct of a State-Certified Contractor
(Nq!e: This case was withdrawn by the County, pursuant to the Amended Agenda.)
WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 19, 2018
BCC Chambers, 3'd Floor - Administrative Building "F,
Govemment Complex, 3301 E. Tamiami Trail, Naples, FL
2'7
NEXT MEETING DATE:
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 219 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
i
October 17, 2018
There being no further business for the good of the County, the meeting was adjourned by
order of the Chairman at 11:30 PM.
COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS'
LICENSING BOARD
MI OYD,
The Minutes \rere approve{byDcc l(-l
the Chairman or
Board on .2018 , ,,as
Vice Chairman of the Contractors' Licensing
submitted" I v I - OR - "as amende?'I I
28
12.A.3
Packet Pg. 220 Attachment: October Minutes Signed (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
Received Citation then Approved License
January 1, 2018 - December 5,2078
Qualifier
Name Companv Name Case Number Violation
Citation
Number
Citation
Amount
Amount
Paid
Frazier Gardella Architectural Design Shutters c8UL20180002477
Unlicensed Hurricane
Shutter Contractor 11924 s1,000 $ r,000
Kevin Benito
Marco Home Serwices LLC (DBA)
Screens Over Marco cEUL20180003310
Unlicensed Aluminum
Contractor 10320 $1,000 $ 1,000
Kevin Benito
Marco Home Services LLC (DBA)
Screens Over Marco c8UL20180006950
I Inlicensed Aluminum
Contractor 1 1132 $2,000 $2,000
Matthew Rose Matthews Meg Construction Corp cEUL20180007342
Unlicensed
DrywalVMetal Frame 10331 $ L,000
$300
(abated)
Matthew Rose Matthews Meg Construction Corp cEUL20180007723 UnLicensed Painting 11106 $ 1,000
$300
(abated)
Robert Fanning Pressure Pushers, LLC cEUL20180009970
Unlicensed Roof
Pressure Washing 10,108 $ 1,000 $1,000
12.A.4
Packet Pg. 221 Attachment: RECEIVED CITATION THEN APPROVED LICENSE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
Renewal Totals
From July lst - December 5th
Renewed their information
Not Renewed
* now in a Delinquent status
State Certified 3529
Specialty 2961
TotaI 6490
State Certified
(with a 2018 expiration date)2tt7
Speciaity*
(with a 2018 expiration date)426
Total 2543
12.A.5
Packet Pg. 222 Attachment: RENEWAL TOTALS 7.1.18 - 12.5.18 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
Contractor Licensing Citation Fee Report
Total Amount lssued $283,400.00
Total Amount Paid $1 39,150.00
Total Amount Unpaid $144,250.00
Total # of lssued Citations 275
Violation - Unlicensed
October 1. 2017 - September 30. 2018
12.A.6
Packet Pg. 223 Attachment: UNLICENSED CITATION FEE REPORT (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
t
COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD
December 19,2018
9:00 A.M.
MELVTN ALFARO - CONTESTTNG CTTATTON(S) 11231
Citation # - 11231
lssued By - REGGIE StvllTH
lssued Date - OCTOBER 01, 2018
Case # - CEUL20180011900
Violator - tUELVIN D. ALFARO
Company - OASIS BUILDERS OF SW FL, LLC
Reason - UNLICENSED POOUSPA CONTRACTOR - WORKING AT 512 WHISPERING PINES
LANE. NAPLES, FL 34103
Couuty
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 224 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
Table of Gontents
1-4 Case Summary by Reggie Smith
5 Citation 11231 - 512 Whispering Pines Ln - CEU12018001 1900
6-7 Aerial lmages of Property Before Work Commenced
8-12
13 - 16 Estimate of Work to be Done
17-19 Checks Paid to Oasis Builders & Oasis Pools
20-22 City of Naples Permitting
23-24 Oasis Builders of SWFL, LLC License lnformation
25 Rock Star Pools & Waterfalls, lnc License lnformation
26-27 County Ordinance 2006-46
28 State Ordinance 489.105 Residential Contractor Defined
29-31 Florida Attorney General Legal Opinion
32 Letter to Contest Citation
33-34 Board Hearing Letter
Pictures of Work that was Done
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 225 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
Report Title: Code Case Details
Date: 111612018 2:36:00 PM Case Number: CEUL20180011900
Case Number cEUL201 8001 1 900
Case Type:Unlicensed
Priority Norma!
lnspector ReggieSmith
Jurisdiction City of Naples
Origin Building Department
Detail Description UNLICENSED RESIDENTIAL POOL CONTRACTOR, ALFARO, MELVIN D., CITATIONl1231,
$2OOO.OO,2ND OFFENSE, RESIDENTIAL CONTRACTOR, STATE CERTIFIED, CONTRACTING TO
INSTALL/BUILD SPA ONTO EXISTING POOL, RESURFACE POOL, NEW TRAVERTINE POOL
DECK, AND PAVER DRIVEWAY
NO PERMTT FOR DRIVEWAY, OASTS BUILDERS, tNC.
Location Comments 512 WHISPERING PINES LN
CITY OF NAPLES
Status:Citation
Date & Time Entered:912112018 4:50:12 PM
Entered By:ReggieSmith
Case Disposition Unpaid
Property 1 6057000005
Violator Alfaro, Melvin D.
Business l\rlanagement & Budget Office
vilt .R. r
1
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 226 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
Code Case Details Execution Date 111612018 2:36:00 Plt/
Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments
Preliminary I nvestigation ReggieSmith 912112018 101212018 Citation
Required
09-21-18 RECEIVED CASE COMPLAINT
FROM CITY OF NAPLES, BUILDING
DEPARTMENT; IAN JACKSON ARRANGED
TO MEET ON SITE TO MEET THE
PROPERTY OWNERS AND VIEW THE
WORK. UPON ARRIVAL WE MET MR. AND
MRS. SLUGH, WHO ALLOWED US TO VIEW
THE WORK IN THE REAR OF THE
PROPERTY (SWtMMtNG POOL AND DECK
AREA). MR. JACKSON ADVTSED A
VIOLATION OF NOT HAVING A SAFETY
BARRIER AROUND THE NEWLY
RENOVATED POOL WITH NEW SPA ADDEI
IN WHICH HAS BEEN FILLED WITH WATER.
MY RESEARCH REVEALED OASIS
BUILDERS OF SW FL, LLC, CRC1331523,
QUALIFER, MELVIN D. ALFARO AND HIS
BUSINESS PARTNER LUIS PATINO,
CONTRACTED FOR THE ENTIRE PROJECT
TO RENOVATE THE POOL, CONSTRUCT A
SPA, AND PLACE TRAVERTINE ON POOL
DECK, ALONG WITH PAVER BLOCK THE
FRONT DRIVEWAY. THE CONTRACT IS
DATED 12-04.2017. OASIS BUILDERS
THEN SUBCONTRACTED THE POOL, SPA,
AND DECK TO ROCKSTAR POOLS &
WATERFALLS, INC., CERTIFIED
COMMERCIAL POOL CONTRACTOR,
QUALIFER, JOHN C. RICHARD, 954-495-
1222, ROCKSTAR THEN WAS ISSUED A
CITY OF NAPLES PERMIT 181331 AND
BEGAN REMODELING THE POOL AREA
AROUND MID MARCH 2018. IN SPEAKING
WITH THE PROPERTY OWNERS, THEY
STATED THEY HAD NO IDEA WHO OR
HOW ROCKSTAR WAS INVOLVED IN THEIF
CONTRACT WITH OASIS BUILDERS. I
BEGAN TO CONTACT MR. ALFARO TO
DISCUSS THE CASE AND ADVISE AS A
CRC HE CANNOT CONTRACT FOR POOL
CONSTRUCTION OR REPAIR. I
REQUESTED ALL CONTRACT AND
PAYMENT INFORMATION TO BE
PROVIDED BY THE PROPERTY OWNERS.
IAN JACKSON POSTED A STOP WORK
ORDER PERTAINING TO THE FILLED POOL
AND LACK OF SECURITY FENCING. CITY
OF NAPLES ADVISED A DRIVEWAY PERMI-
WAS JUST SUBMITTED TODAY, ALTHOUGI
THE DRIVEWAY HAS ALREADY BEEN
INSTALLED. PHOTOS X 5. RS
2Business [t/lanagement & Budget Office
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 227 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
Code Case Details Execution Date 111612018 2:36:00 PM
Desc Assigned Required Completed Gomments
lssue Citation (Licensing)ReggieSmith 101112018 10t212018 Complete 10.01-18 AFTER MULTIPLE PHONE CALLS
ADVISING MY CASE, MELVIN ALFARO AND
LUIS PATINO AGREED TO MEET TODAY A'I
1OAM. MEETING HELD IN THE LICENSING
oFFrcE wrTH MELVTN, LUrS (AND SPOUSE
wHo WANTED TO COMMENT), EVY
YBACETA, AND MYSELF. OASIS BUILDERS
ATTEMPTED TO ARGUE THAT A CERTIFIET
RESIDENTIAL CONTRACTOR MAY
CONTRACT FOR RESIDENTIAL POOL
CONSTRUCTION/REPAIR SO LONG AS
THE WORK IS SUBCONTRACTED OUT TO
A LICENSED POOL CONTRACTOR.
SUPERVISOR YBACETA ULTIMATELY
DECIDED TO ISSUE CITATION 11231 AND
THEY MAY CHOOSE TO CONTEST IT
BEFORE TH E CONTRACTORS' LICENSING
BOARD. CITATION 11231 WAS ISSUED TO
MELVIN D. ALFARO, 2ND OFFENSE,
$2000.00;WHO SIGNED FOR AND
ACCEPTED HIS COPY ALONG WITH
REVERSE SIDE INFORMATION.
SUPERVISOR YBACETA ALSO ADVISED
BOTH MEN THAT THEY HAVE NOW BOTH
RECEIVED THE MAXIMUM AMOUNT OF
CITATIONS TO BE ISSUED AS PER
COLLIER COUNTY ORDINANCE 2006-06,
AS AMENDED. MELVIN AND LUIS WERE
ADVISED ANOTHER VIOLATION SHALL
RESULT IN THE CASE BEING SENT TO THE
STATE OF FLORIDA, STATE ATTORNEY'S
OFFICE FOR INVESTIGATION AND
POSSIBLE PROSECUTION. I DIRECTLY
ASKED OASIS BUILDERS, DIRECTED TO
LUIS PATINO HOWEVER HEARD BY
MELVIN ALFARO, IF THEY HAVE ANY
OTHER CONTRACTED PROJECTS TO
ANNOUNCE AT THIS TIME. NO ANSWER
WAS PROVIDED. I IMPLORED A SECOND
TIME TO ANNOUNCE ANY AND ALL OTHER
PROJECTS NOT WITHIN THE SCOPE OF
ANY LICENSING THEY CURRENTLY HOLD,
TO NOW ADVISE SUPERVISOR YBACETA.
NO RESPONSE WAS PROVIDED BY OASIS
BUILDERS. THE MEETING WAS
ADJOURNED UPON THEIR REQUEST.
AFTERWARDS, SUPERVISOR YBACETA
AGREED THAT IF ANOTHER VIOLATION OF
THIS NATURE ARISES, IT MAY BE
FORWARDED TO THE STATE OF FLORIDA.
RS
Attach Picture(s)ReggieSmith 101212018 10126t2018 Complete ATTACHED SCANNED CASE
INFORMATION. PHOTOS X 5. RS
Citation Paid/Contested lVlichelleCasto 1011612018 11t5t2018 Payment
Not
Received
Generate Follow Up Letter lVlichelleCasto 11t5t2018 11t5t2018 Complete
Citation Paid MichelleCasto 11t16t2018 Pending
Business lVlanagement & Budget Office
\ll.f4. b
3
Outcome
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 228 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
Code Case Details Execution Date 111612018 2:36:00 Plt/
Violation Description Status Entered Corrected Amount Gomments
Unlicensed Pool Residential Repair Open 10/212018 $o
Title Reason Result Compliance Fine/Day Condition
Business lVlanagement & Budget Office
VIII.b.4
4
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 229 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
C€dlfrotg oo /l?od
7Ciq'
No.
Issued Tb
Address
!'ehicle
I-ncation of
State
SIG}iA
JNSTRLC.TIONS]
zip
TORT
I acccpt lhis
prnvided in
112 31
citation
5lG\r1 ]'LiRE
{if applicable)
(sEE R"&vgRsu pOR
Yrar Color
COLL}ER CcUruTy C oil,iRACToR$ IICEIt$E
secti0n
vllLb"b
wlrose
by
I have beenI
a)
b)
c)
d)
e)
*)
i)
hl
Fursuant
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 230 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
FtLOlr,
@
c)c!
ItrIL
GI
coroo{
t
Z6
o
oc{
Ia{!3
ts1
>a(l(,ooco-
?6
q)
azUDJ
U] UJ12sil
u1o
)z-ryazu4rl.
ul
{5tr
5
e
$
is+-VIILB,U
ffiw!g)W:-:!.!-:q: ..-.- a
*,,*,*
I
EUffiw,. $.'
ara.
sc
I
*
t
,ff.F
L
A
[l##
rqI
L.
/
. -J&i#>*.2
/
";b"J
%tI
%
I
b
?,
u
Er
r
Bffi#i&**i-- 'r
;#{
s.;*
4d"0h il
E
EIt:
ia
J
s
1'
uo.6
lfl|
Efl
FIl
k8l
I
h
#L"
mt.f,
i
i.
N!
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 231 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
rB
al,
,:
*
*P
=
:: :
t'
.41
l
4W
d
xr.i
ei
.,fr"1,,11
-.>.#*I
..i:,
,!E
w
t-t!,
I
*r_
{#
1:.,
::<
anrn
F,i
T;*At( r
il
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 232 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
a!
\rT
r-!
"Fj
,r-
I
I
I
I
t
flIIlL-I'll
-=--t *
7
L
I
E1
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 233 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 :
T
Vtu
rF!
1'
ns....*.,G'
7.* i
r
,-
{
7
-!
-\_
-..-
,re@
I
':ilr',-..,,\
-!
-N
7)\
@{
!
!
!
!t
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 234 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 :
-
{
r-..ril
?<
''JJ5G
r\
F*"--*ffitl--r,
. *,1
I
1).i
i Il lir' '
i
i r. i'
'i'1,
.
..'rliW
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 235 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 :
m.
t=\rl{
I
*s
7
'1
ry\:'
a \
et
F
I t
:fffi/te-fr*,{;a
-r
rl
\
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 236 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 :
{
*tr
aF r-*
ADDRESS 5tz
REASON
-
f EMOVE
BUILDING DEPARTMENT
ALL WORK SIISPENDED
PER FLOBIDA BUI {G CODE
r
STOP ORDER
I f
I
WAR}II]IG : GINTI N U ED UNAUT}IOHIZE D
iidhioi rHls PHoJEcr coulD HEsuLr
in-Ciliine PENALTIEs' FoR lNFoRMArloN
YOU UAV CALt n13'50?e I
J
I
I
n ull .b.
oxlHE
6UL;
A
lr
.aa
"1
-i
-tI
w
I
N
tn .t
t( 'I{
Y l ,tl,
I &0 rlr.0
t
A
rttt I
\
ff
I1
IZ
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 237 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
Oasis Builders of S\/ FL, LLC
1239) 272-1344
leo@ oasisbullde rswf l.com
www.oasisb uiiderswf lco.co m
ADDRESS
Amy cartwright
Dumpster:Dumpst€r
Dumpster
Damolition
Remove Shell Slone
Concrete & Coping around
the pool
Demolition
Remove Front Drive Way
oA5'uS
ESTIMATE # 1053
DArE fi/04t2A17
'l
2,819
1,600.00
3,800.00
1.50
1,600.00
3,800.00
4,228.50
1
Remove Front Porch Entry
Slab
Remove Fountain
Relocate Fountain
Plumbing
V I\\3 13
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 238 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
Residsntial : Residential Spa
Swirnming Spa:200SF
1466.08 Gallons
Turnover based
onaggregate remaining for
305 unit service design
Spa layout and excavation
Spa Beam to be Faised
24" Wlspill over into pool.
Form & Steel(#3 Flebar
per Engineered Plans)
Gunite Pool Shell {4,000
PSI @ 28 Days)
Tile bench with 1x1 tile
selected by client
Pool lnterior Finish
(Collectors edition w{ewels
Caribbean Blue)
(1) Spa LED Light Fixtures
& Niches
Travertine Spill over
Variable Speed Pump
Filtration System by pentair
tile throughout pool
Spa light LED WHT
Spa Main Drains (Virginia
Baker Compliant)
RESIDENTIAL
All Flough Plumbing SCH
40 PVC per Engineered
Plans
Circulation and Beturn
System per Engineered
Plans
Electrical Con nection f rom
owner supplied breaker
panel to SUB Panel.
Required life safety alarm
for slider doors.
Clean-up & Trash Removal
Heatars:ULTBA TEMP
140,000 BTU
Ultra Temp 140,000 BTU
by Pentair
lvory 6 x24 Coping
lvory6x24Coping
Coping:Coping install
Travertine coping install
per LN FT
Travertine:SH ELL STON E
French pattern shell stone
Traverti na :Travartine I nstall
Travertine lnstall Per Sq Ft
'l
1
55
90
2,647
2,382
23,544.14
4,251 .18
16.34
22.00
4.99
)4, qan 1 n
4,251 .18
898.70
1,980.00
13,208.53
10,719.004.50
vrrr b lLl
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 239 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
.:,
Pavers:Boader Concrote
Band
Boarder Protection Band
W Material
Pool Control Panel:Easy
Touch I
Easy Touch 8 Control
Panel Wlnside Controller
Deco Drain:Deco Drain 2'
10'
Deco Drain 2" 10' TAN
Sepair
Replace Skimmer
Add Bypass for main Drain
and Skimmer.
Pavers:Pavsr Install
Drive Way
1
1 1,860.97
1 46.89
'l 1,243.26
3.75
542.53
3.75
2.759A422
0.00
,1 :.,
542.53
1,860.97
328.23
1,243.26
9,735.00
3,693.75
9,880.13
0.00
2,596
lnstallation of Pavers
Turf Graded
Sand included
Pavers:Paver lnstall
Court yard
Cut Garden Pad out 26 x 4
Cut Garden pad out (ieft
side) 8 x 4
lnstallation of Pavers
Mud Set
All Equipment will have 3
year warranty
Pavers:Flat BricldCharcoal
Grey
6x9 Charcoal Grey Flat
Brick
TERMS
spa
10% Deposit upon
acceptance
307" Draw upon
commencement
30% Draw upon passing
shell inspection.
Balance upon completion.
985
3,581
't
\ll r-B I5
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 240 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
0.00
.::
0.00TEBMS
Pavers
507o Draw upcn
commencement
50% Draw upon passing
shell inspection.
Balance upon completion.
Thank you for your business!
Accepted By
TOTAL
Accepted Date
$91 ,513.92
\ l\\B lu
:
1
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 241 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
Frocessing Date Actlvltf Date Accoum
AB/1912CI18 A3l19nA18 Portfolio Management - 9800
Front of Che€k
NAP|"DS, FL 3.1103
UilTrcD STAI'L!
MorganStantey 11s6MR MARC STUGHi*8. Dltsr,lrr RUSSSSLUGH
{775 WHNPEBINCHNEWAY 3lt r {F
Checkl{umber Amount
1136 $25,000.00
2$sifi10
Pav to
Clrder
the l&-r-s $a4 O$'rt t
of
UuBtur& tiJ.XsCerttOr.!&.6!)yat
4l{Etpwa
iadyer
Irl
It
Vttr B l-7
Fa*
,.........%
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 242 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
Frsnt of check
Jl/J
-'--Ln. feB?
HQ0b
at*UUS BrrL r{/L,(sCiry.ll0r{00{l}116,
3br
I
fd ?3.#r4[
2,)tE-
MorganStantey fi02
(t {*" rr $/i
&arrt*e
Atalyw
MB- MARC SIUCH
MNS. DAI\IIEIIE BUSSOSLI,GH
4775VHISPERINS PINEVAY
Back af Check
\ttt, 13 lb
to the
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 243 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
ront ofcheck
I
lrxlS*Lrl,^XnrCi!r.ll0aal0dl"rgl.0*t4al
MR MARC STUGH
MNS. DANIELTE RUSS+SLUGS
{U5 TqHISTESINE ?INE ITAY
NArrJS, FL 34103
- _Tf
Stantey 1 1go
fi-&01a18
(5 Lt $l7aoa eY
f(,4t
fiffi
Etrp*llca
"tdlra
For
I t I lqo
\\\\ b,
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 244 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
9t18t2018
General
Application lnformation
Permits and Inspections
Application Information Return to permits and inspections
Application reference
Status
Receiv*d
Applicant
Owner
Owner ID
Locatian
Parcel ID
Subdivisisn
181331
ACTIVE / PIRMIT ISSUED
3/12/20L8
ROCK STAR WATERFALLS
cPC14573tg/6t7tsz Isitc.
SLUGH, MARC=&, DANIELLE
RU550
2454L
512 WHISPERING PiNE
LANE
NAPLTS
16057000005
PARK SHORE UNIT 4
30
lo\
{q 5
$4
5,hd1 *-r{0t
^A*
'
ur{u
pr
., $#7
0
I
c
,{q
I
{-tr
Lot
Project Details
Projeet/Activity SWIMMING POSL - REStrDE|.JTIA{-
Description
ASD NEW SPA TO EXISNNG
POOL NO PILINGS W/ ELE
HEATER
RCCK STAR WATIRFALL-
cPC14573L9/6L7152
617152
Contractor
Contractor ID
Zoning RES DIST-SINGLE FAMILY
https://mss.naplesgov.com/MSS/citizenSPermitslnspections/Applicationlnformation.aspx Vttt B
-.'j;,i:1...r
-
.4:
i::i ;.;';i1:.:J-;?
re
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 245 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
9t18/?018 APP|ication I nformatt'on
SIhIGLT TAMILY RTSIDTNCTExisting Ure
Propax*d Use SIhlfiLE FAMILY RES:DINCI
Estirnat*d Cost $24,CI00.00
Attarhments
No attarhments were found for this
applicaticn
'l92018 Tyl*r T*chn*l*gi*s, Inc.
V\\\ Bhltps:/lmrs.naplasgov.*om/MS$Jdtizens/PermitslnspectionslAppllcationlnformation.aspx LL
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 246 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
ProperQr Summary '- i a,-,, ,":;:;:. : , r:1 ,. ,
Site
Parcel No 15O5700OOO5
Name / SLUGH, MARC=8I DANIELLE RUSSO
Address
512 WHISPEruHG PINE IANE
City NAPLES
Map Ntt.
4AL6
Legal PARK SHORE UttIIT 4 BtK 32 LOT 30 OR 1422 PG 711
Millage Area * 4
Sub.lCondo 112900 - PARK SHORE UNIT 4
Use Code O 1 - SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 5.049
Site
Address
(Not all Sales arg listed due to Confidantiality)
Date Book-Page Amount
LOl27 /L7 5446-3242 $ 1,235,000
LO/L7|L7 s444-874 $ O
State FL Zip 34103
Strap No.Section Township Range SstimatedAcres
112900 32 304A16 16 49 25
5L2
WHISPTRIHG
PINE tN
Site
City *NoteNAPLESZone 34103
0.35
Schso Other
5.19s3
Total
LO.24J3
$ 790,481
Latest Sales History 2$18 Preliminary Tax Roll
(Subject to Change)
Land Value
(+) Improved Value
1=1 Market Value
$ 102,361,
$ 892,842att ,rt-r ratA !rt- al{
V\\\ B LL
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 247 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
License Application Status - CityView Portal
Application Number:
Business Name:
License Type:
Application Status:
Description of Business:
lvlailing Address:
GMD Public Portal
Page I of I
License Application Status
Note: You can collapse and expand individual sections by clicking the header of the section you wish to collapse/expand.
Llcense ADDlication Summaru
LCC20 1 7000 1006
OASIS BUILDERS OF SW FL, LLC
Contractor
Inactive
MUST PAY ALL CITANONS BEFORE RENEW]NG LICENSE. (7 TOTAL)
CITATION NUMBERS: ll240,11247,11242, !1243, t1244, rL245, L723L
(MC)CastoMichelle 08/09/2018 5:33 PM
15275 COLLIER BLVD 201-327
Naples FL 341 19
Melvin@oasisbuilderswfl .com
Issuancs
Type Date Issued Date Expires Status N umber
RESIDENTIAL CONTR..CERTIFIED 05/26/2077 o8/3r/20t8 Expired 20 1 700000453
Submittals
There are no submittals for this license application.
Reviews
There are no reviews for this license applicataon
Insurance
V\\I B LZ
Producer Type Policy Effective Date Expiry Date Limit
FIVE COUNTY
INSURANCE AGENCY
General Liability G1P023876700 o4/20/2017 04/20/201,9
Expiration Processed: No
Producer Phone Number: (239)- 939-1400
FIVE COUNTY
INSURANCE AGENCY
Worker's
Compensation
wcv023360701 01126/2017 07/26120t9
Expiration Processed: No
Producer Phone Number: (239)- 939-1400
http ://cvportal. colliergov.net/CityViewWeb/License/Status?licenseld =l 49 5 12 tU8t20t8
I
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 248 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
fGE t6 Al€.rtg
Contractor Infonnatirn
Name / Description
Type
lurisdiction
Activity Description
5 ugg e s t tnla i { i n g Address
Licensee Number {iCEzarrccarcce StatuE
OASIS BUILDERS OF 5W FL, LLC Start Date
End Date
Bs!?512u77
0s/26/2018
'submitted a" loiiiaizotz
r,lUST PAY ALL CITATIONS BEFORE R.ENEWING LICENSE. (7 TBTAL) CITATI8II FIUIIIBEES: 11248, 11241,
7724?, L1243, 11244, 1.1245, L1?31 {t{C)CasteMichelle 08/09/2018 5:33 ptvt
Oepartment i
Exclude from Auto-Suqqest? [
15275 CfiLLIER. tsLV* e01-327 I Add Contact Nurnber
Ext.
Mailing &ddr:ess
Address Line 2
Address Line 3
Cityl5tate/Zip
Country
Email
ples FL f,+A IY
Preferred Contact Method
Confidential? [
DOB
Locations
License fssuances
I
l'telvinG:oasisbuilderswfl.com
Receive SMS Text
Notifications?
Contractor Type
Drivers License Number
inactive
Contractor
Collier County
Shovo lvleire F
Eusiness
Date lssr-eed i lsslxa*ce Nurnber:SIDENTIALIfiHTR.-CER.TIFIED ;Expired 0s125i2017 :201?0000fi453
t Add I*r"*"
,=:.-k
lxtc
Comments
Show tr,lore Fields
State Reqistration Number cRC1331523License Category
Unique Identifier LCCg010
Contacts
Add new. person or business to Address Booh f-__-----]
i Go to Alerts I i -_ Add a Contact
To link a contact to this licenseer enter contact information below. CityViewwill suggest Fossible matehes a=
State - Certified
Psrtal User? i
EUILDERS OFSW FL. LLC,Address:15?75 COLLIER BLV
ysu tyFe:
flnrnno, FIELVTN D., Ada ressr1141 24TH A11E NE, Phone:{239) z8s-914.8, Licensee # LCCzc1s00035,$5
Gr Type CcGtBct Alert Erd Date
Applicant OASIS m
I'l
| $ew Contractor [no projecti
l-l
New Contractor {current project}
*ldd this lqailing Addresr al a Location
?85-S143:
l,lELVIN D", &ddr*sc ;1L41 2.+.TH AVE NE,
Itt o re
:'l
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 249 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
9/18/2018 License Application Status - CityView Porlal
G{vl* Fub{ic P*r*af
License Application Status
llcte: yo,r cEf, (c,l{p:;e e16 (xtard ind;yidsii 5ect'anr by atj.king the hsader of the sectiotl yrs s15h !0 ca,iepse/expand'
Llccn3. Appllcation Summ.rY
Application Number:
Business Name:
Licenss Type;
App:lcatian Status:
Bescription of BLisiness:
Mailing Address:
1CC20160001619
ROCK STAR POOLS & WATERFALI-S. iNC.
Contractor
Inactive
6017 PINE RiDGg KOAD *226
NAPLES FL 341 19
Phil @rockstarpools. cotn
Issuanceg
Typ*Date tssued Prte f,xFilat l{umber
201600000804strrltiltrlllrlc pool
CEN.TIFED
COI{MERCIAL.a9/29t2416
+.-
Status
Ispired*$,r31i 2018
cxhai*rlc
Th€ra ars xa rfibtxittals fot this lil€n5e sppiicstion
Tiere ,re no reviews for this license applicalion.fi',,, {u,/A',
rype Effectiv€ Dat€
General Liability 103C100 1 437401 06109/20 r6
Explrat;on Processed: N0
Producer Pfion€ l\urfiber; 239-939-140fi
Limit
osl09l2a79 $2,000,000.o0
Producer
rIVE COUNN'
lI.ISURANCE AGTNtrY
' FIVE CoUNw INS. \rycrker's !r/c{0207$10 0?auo:./28x7 or/18i 20 19
Compensation
Expiration Processed: I$o
Produc€r pflon€ Number; 219-939-14OG
*.fi ,&
?,* #6 -;fr? I
B7s
,4/
{ao r
"{*;
Expiry DatePolicy
http://cvportal
{o Lil*L1L* nryV \N\111
,
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 250 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
COLLIER COUNTY ORDINANCE NO. 2A06-46
SECTION ONE: ORDINANCE NO. 90-105, AS AMENDED, tS Er163Y AMENDED AS
FOLLOWS:
PART ONE: CERTIFICATES OF COMPETENCY REQIIRED.
1.1. Unla*ful to Contract w{thout a Certilicate of Competency. It shall be unlara.ful
for aay person" firm, pafinership, corporation or other legal entity to: eagage in any constuction
contracting business, advertise or represent him5slf.a,s.self or a busiaess organization as available
to eagage in any construction conkacting business, or act in the capacity of a contactor or
subcontractor for any of the trades listed in Section 1.6 of this Ordinance, within the unincorpo-
rated area of Collier County and the incorporated ar:ea within the boundaries of the City ofNaples
and within the City of Marco Island- rn'ithout having first made application for and having beea
issued a cu:rent and valid Collier Count/Cit-v Cefiificate of Competenc,v or an applicable State
Certified License. Nothing hereia shall be construed to mean that there carnot be employees in a
nade u'ho are not qualified or cerlified u'itirinthe defrnitions herein set forth if such employees are
employed by a licensed contractor who exercises supen'ision and cont'ol over said employees-
Indicia of an employynent reiationship shall include rhe employer's reeular palm.ent of wages and
compensation, FICA deductions, tax witlrholding and provision of Workers' Compensation to the
employees, all as prescribed by larv.
\l \\\ b Lto
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 251 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
COLLIER COUNTY ORDINANCE NO. 20O6-46
SECTION ONE: ORDINANCE NO. 90-105, AS A]\{ENDED, IS IIEREBY AMEhIDED AS
FOLLOWS:
PART ONE: CERTIFICATES OF COMPETENCY REQUIRED.
1.6. Definitions and Contractor Qualifications.
1.6.1. Contactor mea:rs the person ra,bo is qualified for and responsible for the entire
project contracted for and, except for &ose herein exempted the person who, for compeasatioa
undertakes to, or subrnits a bidto, or does himself or b,v others, any or all ofthe fo[owing construc.!
repair, alter, remodel, add to, demolish, subkact from, or improve any building or structure,
including related improvements to real estate, for others, or for resale to others, as hereinafter
defined in Sections 1 .6.1 through 1.6.3 of this Ordinance^
vrrr B L1
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 252 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
Chapter 489 Section 105 - 2018 Florida Statutes - The Florida Senate Page 1 of6
The Florida Senate
2018 Florida Statutes
Title XXXII
REGULATION OF PROFESSIONS
AND OCCUPATIONS
Chapter 489
CONTRACTINC
Entire Chapter
SECTION 105
Definitions.
489.105 Definitions.- As used in this part:
(1) "Board" means the Construction Industry Licensing Board.
(2) "Department" means the Department of Business and Professional Regulation.
(3) "Contractor" means the person who is qualified for, and is only responsible for, the project contracted for and
means, except as exempted in this part, the person who, for compensatiory undertakes to, submits a bid to, or does
himself or herself or by others construct, repair, alter, remodel, add to, demolish, subtract from, or improve any
building or structure, including related improvements to real estate, for others or for resale to others; and whose job
scope is substantially similar to the job scope described in one of the paragraphs of this subsection. For the purposes of
regulation under this part the term "demolish" applies only to demolition of steel tanks more than 50 feet in height;
towers more than 50 feet in height; other structures more than 50 feet in height; and all buildings or residences.
Contractors are subdivided into two divisions, Division I, consisting of those contractors defined in paragraphs (a)-(c),
and Division II, consisting of those contractors defined in paragraphs (d)-(q):
(a) "General contractor" means a contractor whose services are unlimited as to the type of work which he or she
may do, who may contract for any activity requiring licensure under this part, and who may perform any work
requiring licensure under this parf except as otherwise expressly provided in s. 489.113.
(b) "Building contractor" means a contractor whose services are limited to construction of commercial buildings
and single-dwelling or multiple-dwelling residential buildings, which do not exceed three stories in height, and
accessory use structures in connection therewith or a contractor whose services are limited to remodeling repair, or
improvement of any size building if the services do not affect the structural members of the building.
(c) "Residential contractor" means a contractor whose services are limited to construction, remodeling, repair, or
improvement of one-family, two-family, or three-family residences not exceeding two habitable stories above no more
than one uninhabitable story and accessory use structures in connection therewith.
(d) "Sheet metal contractor" means a contractor whose services are unlimited in the sheet metal trade and who has
the experience, knowledge, and skill necessary for the manufacture, fabrication, assembling handling erection,
installation, dismantling conditioning adjustment, insulatiory alteratiory repair, servicing, or design, iI not prohibited
by law, of ferrous or non-ferrous metal work of U.S. No. 10 gauge or its equivalent or lighter gauge and of other
materials, including, but not limited to, fiberglass, used in lieu thereof and of air-handling systems, including the
setting of air-handling equipment and reinforcement of same, the balancing of air-handling systems, and any duct
cleaning and equipment sanitizing that requires at least a partial disassembling of the system.
(e) "Roofing contractor" means a contractor whose services are unlimited in the roofing trade and who has the
experience, knowledge, and skill to install, maintain, repair, alter, extend, or design, if not prohibited by law, and use
materials and items used in the installation, maintenance, extension, and alteration of all kinds of roofing
waterproofin& and coating except when coating is not represented to protect, repair, waterproof, stop leaks, or extend
the life of the roof. The scope of work of a roofing contractor also includes skylights and any related work, required
roof-deck attachments, and any repair or replacement of wood roof sheathing or fascia as needed during roof repair or
replacement and any related work.
(0 "Class A air-conditioning contractor" means a contractor whose services are unlimited in the execution of
contracts requiring the experience, knowledge, and skill to install, maintain, repair, fabricate, alter, extend, or design,
if not prohibited by law, central air-conditioning, refrigeratiory heating, and ventilating systems, including duct work
Vrtt B L7
http://www. fl senate. gov/Laws/Statutes/20 I 8/489. 1 05 1U8t2018
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 253 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
Advisory Legal Opinion - General contractors; authority to build pools
Florida Aftorney General
Advisory Legal Opinion
Number: AGO 82-83
Date: October 12,1982
Subject: General contractors; authority to build pools
Page 1 of3
Mr. Edward R. Flynn
Director
Construction Industry Licensing Board
Palm Beach County
Post Office Box 1548
Iflest Palm Beach, Florida 33402
RE: CONSTRUCTION IIIDUSTRY LICENSING LAlt--Authority to build swimning pools
Dear Mr. E1ynn:
This is in response to your request for an opinion on sr:bstantially t}re
foLlowing questions reguiring an interpretation of general. Iaw:
1. To what extent are general. contractors authorized to build swirnming
pooJ.s?
2. To wtrat extent are residential. and building contractors authorized to
construct swimming pools?
Question One
Your first question requires an anal.ysis of tl.e scope of work of a general.
contractor as set forth in Ch. 489, F.S., ttre Construction Practice Act.
Section 489.105(3) (a), F.S., defines ttre term f'general, contractorrr to mean:
" [a] contractor whose services are unlimited as to ttre tlpe of work which
he may do, except as provided in ttris act." (e.s.)
The only restriction found in Ch. 489, upon the scope of work of a general
contractor is set forth in s. 489.113(3), F.S., which prowides in pertinent
part:
"A contractor shalJ. subcontract the electrical, mechanical, pJ.umbing,
roofing, sheet metal, and air conditioning work for which a 1ocal
examination for a certificate of competency or a license is required,
unless such contractor holds a state certificate of competency or license
of the respective trade eategory, as rclqluired by ttre appropriate local
auttrority. This subsection does not apply if ttre loca1 authority does
not require a certificate of competency or license for such trade. . . 'r
The foregoing statute reguires all contractors to subeontract the work
\\r
http://www.myfloridalegal.com/ago.nsf/printview/I659871C40996CA2852565 ty6t20t8
2q
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 254 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
Advisory Legal Opinion - General contractors; authority to build pools Page 2 ol3
1j-sted therein if the 1ocal. gowernment requires a certificate of comPetency
or license for the respectiwe trade category. However, slti-tlmj.ng pool
construction or repair and servicj-ng is not one of the categories listed iD
s 489.113(3). Unde! these circumstances. it seees c]-ear that the PrinciPle
of statutory construction stating that the Legislature's express mention of
one thing imp].ies the exclusion of atrother ( errpressio unius est exclr]sio
alteri1u.sl j-s applicable. See, e.9., Dobbs v. Sea IsIe Hotel, 56 So.2d 341
(FIa. 1952); Idea} Farms Drainage Dist. v. Certain Lands, 19 so.2d 234
(F1a. 1944).
Therefore. since ttre scope of work of a general contractor j.s un].imj-ted,
such contractors are authorized to engage in ttre construction of swimning
pools under their general contractor c1assification without limitation.
Cqrare, AGO 82-45 (authorization of genera1 contractors to insta].]. shingle
roofing pulsuant to s. 489.113(3), 4.s., not limited to structures such
contractors have under construction) .
guestj-on Two
The scol)e of work of a residential corttractor is defined to include:
rr [c] onstruction. rerodeling, repair, o! improvement of one-family, two-
fa.ui1y, or ttrree-family resideaces not exceeding two stories in height and
accessory use structures in connection therewith. " Section 489.105(3) (c),
F.S.
simi]-ar].y. a bui]-ding contractor is defined to mean:
" [a] contractor w]rose serwices are ].imited to construction of commercial
buildings and single-dwel1ing or multj-ple-dwe11ing residential- bui1dings,
wtrich comnercia1 or residential buildings do not exceed three stories in
height, and accessory use struclures in connection therewj-th or a
contractor wtrose serwices are ].imited to remode].ing, repair, or improvement
of any size bui]-ding if the services do not affect the structural mefibers
of the building. " section 489.105(3) (b), E.s.
The question then becomes whether ttre construction or repair of a swirnming
poo]- constitutes an rtaccessory use structure't within ttre rneaning of the
definitions of building and residential contractor. In AGO 76-239, rny
predecessor considered ttre question of whether the activity of constructing
tennj-s courts was included wj.thin the term Istructure't and "accessory use
structure" for purposes of the definitions of building contlactor and
residential contractor. In answering these questions in the affireatiwe,
A@ 76-239 noted that the definition of t'accessory'r was defined as:
"Anythj-ng which is joined to another thing as an ornament, or to render it
more perfect, or which accompanies it, or is connected wittr it, as an
http://www.myfloridalegal.conl/ago.nsf/printview/I659871C40996CA28525658500677BCF 111612018
These definitj-orls do not include the construction, repair or servicing of
swiming pools within their terms. Swirnming pooJ. contractors and pool
serwicing contractors are separately provided for and defined by paragraphs
(j), (k) and (1) of subsection (3) of s. 489.105 F.S. Thus, a contractor
(other than a general contractor) who engages in swiuning pooJ. work must be
either registered or certified as a swiming poo]. contractor or swimming
pool serwicing contractor unl.ess ottrerwise provided in Ch. 489.
\ \\,Tb
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 255 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
Advisory Legal Opinion - General contractors; authority to build pools Page 3 of3
incident, or as sr.rbordinate to it, or which belongs to or with it. rl
Although not mentioned in that opinion, Part fI of Ch. 468t F.S. L9'15, did
not provide for or purport to regrrJ.ate or define "tennis court
contractors.rr Although a swimmingpooJ. might also be deemed to faIl wittrin
the broad definition of accessory or accessory us€r, for certain purposes
such as zoning restrictions, unless and untiJ. it is legislatively or
judicia1J.y determined otl:erwise, I am unalele to so conclude in this
particular context, in J.ight of ttre Legislaturers e:<press creation of a
separate cJ.assification for swimmingr pooJ. contractors and swiming pool
servicing contractors. This legislative definition when coupled wit-tt the
fact that the scope of work of residential and building contractors is not
unlimited, Ieads me to conclude t}at swimming pool construction or repair
and servicing does not faII witJlin the statutory definitions and prescribed
scope of work of residential and buiLding contractors. This conclusion is
buttressed by the fact ttrat ttre Construction Industry Licensing Board, ttre
agency ctrarged with ttre administration of Ch. 489, has long elq)ressed the
wiew that residential and building contractors are not authorized to build
swirnraing pools under their respective classification. Under these
circr:mstances, it is appropriate to note the well-established principle
ttrat long-standing statutory interpretations made by officials charged wittr
ttre administration of ttre statutes are to be given great weight and will
not be overturned by the courts unless clearly erroneous. See, €.g., State
ex rel. Biscalme Kenne1 C1ub v. Board of Business Regrrlation, 276 So.2d 823
(EIa. L9731,' Gay v. Canada Dry Bottling Co. of Florida, 59 So.2d 788 (Fla.
19s2) .
Therefore, I am of the view that the scope of work of state certified or
registered building and residential contractors does not include ttre
construction or repair and servicing of swimming poo1s.
In summary, it is ny opinion ttrat: (1) a state certified or registered
general contractor, whose scope of work is unlimited, is auttrorized to
engJage in ttre construction or repair of swinning pools under his general
contractor cJ.assification without J.imitation. (21 Unless and until
J.egisJ-ativeJ.y or judicialJ.y determined otherwise, swimming pooJ.
construction or repair and servicing does not falJ. within the statutory
definitions and prescribed scope of work of building and residential
contractors.
Sincerely,
Jim Smith
Attorney General.
Prepared by:
Patricia R. Gleason
Assistant Attorney General
\\\\3t
http ://www.myfl oridalegal.com/ago.nsf/printvieWT 65987 | C40996C A2852565 85 006 7 TECF rU612018
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 256 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
-*A5 '' 5
ID) EGEn\ytrn
Itll ocrrbzor ,il)
BY
mM 11- 2S18
m-EM*!r
ellffieaunty &arsfion* & Bryulatwg eisrrry€ntcr* Divbhln
Erctrer Managommt Srya*rnent
Caltfsetor l-lcerairg
ilaar itr. fr*sriHo Ybaoste:
Pxyour augrgr*t*ian, we are $ritin( b fo{mally rsgusata hesrirq in ragar$*tr
fhs oi*etkn ue hglm tgffilt& r*cahmd,
$!ts*krl:
1. effit * eUXLI0ISmtlA0$, elffion: 'rt}$ {Sa*i* &rilderc d S/UFL
tLC)
Pbsas *dvis6 whsn our saas ca* hc frear" Thenlt you in advarma"
Raupwtft'rtly
Mehin Alf*ro
Oari* Br;ild*rs d $}A,FL LtC
15?75 Cotl*er Btq,d. Suitg 281-&27
t*apla*, Ft 341r8
Dlrtse {438} e8$,&'t*3
S't'&1't1 {,}t' l-t.{}Rll}A
{:rl- r-{ll I .t r.k
lxfr.itr* ltl* thrr I l" *l.l1 r{ {}ctrrher l{.1 i}i,M*ltin Allnm.
l?rrrrrull:'liQ, Itr;.v)tttt;: LJ*tttilli:;rltrrtr . I .t'1tt: r'rl lrlijririfirr *tirt.1Pm&rmd:-*
\rrt % bL
*rffit&w
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 257 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
Covtvtl3t
Growth Management Department
Planning & Regulation
Operations Division
Licensing Section
October 16, 2018
OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL LLC
ATTN: TUELVIN ALFARO
15275 COLLIER BLVD SUITE 201-327
NAPLES, F134119
RE: Contesting Citation(s) 11231 (CASE # CEU12018001 1900)
tUR. ALFARO,
You have been added to the agenda for the Contractor Licensing Board meeting on
Wednesday, DECEIT/BER 19,2018. Please attend and feel free to bring in any
documents you would like the board to see. We will put together a packet of the case
and provide it to you by mail or in person.
The meeting is held at 9:00am at the W. Harmon Turner Building (Bldg. F, Admin.
Bldg.), 3299 Tamiami Trl. E., Naples, FL 34112 in the Commissioner's [Veeting Room
on the 3'd floor. There is a security checkpoint you will need to go through, so please
allow enough time to make it to the meeting.
lf you have any questions or concerns, please call (239) 252-2431 or you may email me
at contracto rslicensi n g@co I I ierco u ntyf l. gov
Sincerely,
Lilla Davis
Administrative Supervisor
Contractor Licensing
CoIIier County Growth Management Department
2800 North Horseshoe Drive
Naples, FL 34104
ru
--utlt
ru
ITrr)
ru
Etrl
EI
Ef
Ef
ru
-Tru
ftrlEf-
eiii-Sititii ZiP+Za
Here
Postmark
U.S. PostalService*
CERTIFIED MAIL@ RECEIPT
Domestic Mail
(]ertified Mail Fee
$
Extra Serytces & FeeS (check box, addfee as apprcpratel
LJ Return Rseipt (hardcopy) $ . =-
E Return Rrceipt (etectrcnic) $ -
-
E Certilied Mail Restricled Detivery O .
-
f]Adult Signature RequiEd $ - _-
EAdutt SignatuE Restrtcted Deltvery $ - _-
Postage
$
Total Postage and Fes
$
information, visit our weOslte atFor
See Ret efsetor.PS Form 33Og April 2015 psN 753G02.{'0Ge047
Growth lrrlanagement Department.contractor Licensing .2900 North Horseshoe Drive-Na1
rl rtt b bb
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 258 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
I Complete items 1,2, and 3.
r Print your name and address on the reverse
so that we can return the card to you.
r Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece,
or on the front if space permits.
1. Article Addressed to:
OASIS BUILDERS OF SWT'L LLC
ATTN:NIEL\1N.{IF.{RO
{5275 COLLIER BLV1D SIIITE 2OI-327
NAPLES. FL ts4119
x 0,r,tz,- M EG"nt
A. Signature
lc
D. ls delivery address different from item 1?
lf YES, enter delivery address below;
E Address,
c.Delive
Yes
ENo
9590 9402 3772 8032 4614 92 t Certiiied Mail@
Service Type
rdult Signature
Signature Restricted Oelivery
tr Certified Mail Besticted Delivery
D Collect on Delivery
E Coltect on Delivery Hestricted'l lnsured Mail
E Priority Mail Express@
E Registered Mdln
tr Begistered Mail Flestrk
Delivery
El Fleturn Recelpt for
Merchandise
Deliverv tr Signature Conrirmatior' E Signature Confimatior;
B.Name)Receivd by-(Pintedrtr\A
01? PEeo EE00 Prtff3 -iEs",BE;{:
PS Form 381 1 , .tuty zot s esm
Restricted Delivery Bestdcted Delivery
Domestic Return Receit
d''-i+"-1, ,, tii . i i.
!ru t bq
12.A.7
Packet Pg. 259 Attachment: MELVIN ALFARO OASIS BUILDERS OF SWFL CONTESTING CITATION 11231 (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19,
C,R&,Qounty
December 19,2018
9:00 A.M.
OCTAVIO CALDERON _ APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE
OCTAVIO CALDERON is coming before the board today to review his experience and to be approved for the
General Contractor - Registered Contractor License. Mr. Calderon was previously before the Board on August
19, 2015, in which the Board rejected his application due to lack of experience. He is now demonstrating
experience from three different licensed contractors with multiple years of experience. Previous meeting
minutes and Finding of Facts included.
General contractor requires 48 monlhs experience with a passing grade on an approved tesl and a business
and law test and means a contractor whose services are unlimited as to the type of work which he/she may do,
except as provided in this article or in the Florida Slatutes. Ordinance 2006-46 (1.6.1.1)
COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 260 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
Table of Gontents
1-5 A lication
6-7
8-13 Credit Re rts
14-17 Sunbiz Documents
18 - 20 IRS EIN Documenls
21 Stalement of Ownershi
22-27 Verif ication of Ex rience Letters
28-30 Affidavit of lnte n & Good Character
31 -32 Workers Com Exem ion A lication
33 Driver's License
34-39 Au ust 19,2015 Board Meetin Minutes
40-42 Findin of Facts for Au ust 19,2015
43 Board Hearin Letter
Test Scores
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 261 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
Cottvrt3/
Gro\ dh ManagerrEnt DepartrBnt
C)uop-cla I - C2ot - 2oll2
Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
Phone - 239-252-2431
Fax - 239-252-2469
APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
FIRM APPLICATION FOR COLIIER, COUNTY
CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
This application must be typewrittcn or legibly printed. The application fee must be paid upon approva I and is NOT
Commissioners. For furtherrefundable. All checks should be made payable to'. Collier County Board of County
information, consult Collier County Ordinance No. 2006-46, as amended.
TYPE OF CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY:HS5
--q
\
$
Gs
E General
tr Building
fl Residential
! Mechanical
n Roofing
$230.00
$230.00
$230.00
$230.00
$230.00
! Electrician
! Plumber
n Air Conditioner
[1 Swimming Pool
n Specialty
00
00
00
00
30
30
30
$230
$2
$2
$20
2$
$att
Rt
E
r\\{
eR
s$
GENERAL CONTRACTOR^ Speciaw Trade:
('alno:;l.u A-:ln-LL Att i,v Coru1r,1c___T
I. APPLICANT PERSONAL INFORMATION:
OCTAVIO E CALDERON
First Middle lnitial Last
4467s$. 5291 23RD PL SW NAPLES FL 34116-6801
Street City State zip
Email:allin 1 drywall.painting@comcast.net
Telephone .239-398-6850 "SS # (Last 4 digits only):
Driver's License # (Last 4 digits only)4070
ocT 18 t0lt
FlRl\.4 APPLICATION Rev 4hU18
VIII C
Name:
Oc{ou''o 2400
oate ot wrrt 1110711977
rPursuantto Chapte.l-19, Florida Statutes and Colller County Contr.ctor ticensing Ordinance 2(x,6il6 S€dion 2.1.1., all appllcants a.e requh€d to
submftthek so.ial t€curtty numb€. (SSN) for lhe followlnt purpos€s: a) Arsess applicant'i abllity to satigfy creditoB by ieviewingth€ir credit hinory.
b) Veriffcetion ol applicant's test sco.es and inlormatlon. Our oftice wlllonly use yourSSll noted abov€ for those.easons pursuentto Chapter 119,
Florida Statutes, and as may otherwlse be authorized by law. We 6re fully comrhitted to safe-Suarding and protectlnS your SSN and once collected, wlll
be malntained as confidentlaland exemptunder Chapter l-19, Florida Statutes.
l'
.Page 3 of 15
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 262 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
CouttXy
Grcl\ ih Managernent DeFrfrEnt
Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
Phone - 239-252-2431
Fax - 23V252-2469
APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
Provide the names and telephone numbers of two persons who will always know your whereabouts.
Name *r.".Juan Rordan
Telephone Telephone 239-595-1733
NAME OF APPLICANT'S BUSINESS:
Business Name. ALL lN 1 CONTRACTORS, lNC.
(lf no company narnewillbe used, write "lndividual")
5291 23RD PLACE SW NAPLES FL 34116Business Address:
Street City State zip
139 )398-6850
Federal lD Tax No.:
III. FINANCIAL RESPONSIBILITY
YES NO ALL APPLICANTS MUST ANSWER THE QUESTIONS BELOW:
r'Undertaken construction contracts or work that a third party, such as a bonding or surely
company, completed or made financial statements on?
r'Had claims or lawsuits liled for unpaid or past due accounts by your
construction experience?
creditors as a result of
r'Undertaken construction contracts or work that resulted in liens, suits, or judgments being
filed?
4 Had a lien filed against you bythe lnternal Revenue Service or Florida Corporate Tax
Division?
r'Made an assignment of assets in settlement of construction obligations for less than the
debts outstanding?
Been charged with or convicted of acting as a contractor without a license, or if licensed
as a contraclor in this or any other state, been "subject to" disciplinary action by a state,
county, or municipality?
r'
r'Filed for or been discharged in bankruptcy within the past 5 years?
r'Been convicted or found guilty of, or entered a plea of nolo contendere to, regardless of
adjudication, a crime in any jurisdiction within the past 10 years?'
NOTE. lf you have answer YES to any of the questions below, you must attach a written explanation including the
nature of the charges, dates, and outcomes, sentences of conditions imposed. You must also attach proof of
payment, satisfaction of lien or judgement, bankruptcy discharge, or agreements for payment.
'lf you have had a felony conviction, proof that your civil rights have been restored will be required prior to
licensure.
FIRM APPLICATION Rey 41121'18
\/l\\ e'.'."L
Jose Borro
239-2314277
Telephone:
83-2124619
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 263 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
-efu Aoefl4$Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
Phone - 23*252-2431
Fax - 23,}252-2469
Goafi lvtan<Bment Depaftnent
APPTICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICAIE OF COMPETENCY
IV. EXPERIENCEVERIFICATION
EDUCATION:
List below and provide transcripts for any formal education you have obtained in the area of competency for which
this application is being made:
NONE
List below non formal education (on the job training) you have obtained in the area of competency for which this
application is bei
LIFE EDUCTED
ng made:
BY WORKING IN CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY SINCE 1999
HAVE MY OWN PAINTING COMPANY ALL IN 1 DRYWALL & PAINTING, INC. SINCE 2013
CURRENT/PREVIOUS LICENSE:
List below and attach copies any other certificates of competencyflicenses you hold/have held in Collier County or
any other jurisdiction. lnclude the license #, Type, and county you hold it in.
ALL IN 1 DRYWALL & PAINTING, INC. PAINTING, DRYWALL, FINE CARPENTRY
AFFIDAVIT
Under the penalties of perjury, I declare that I have read the foregoing application and the facts stated in it are
true.
Applicant (please print)ofApplicant
s1s1se1 FLORIDA
County of COLLIER
The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this 0c{ l\ 'b|l<
by OCTAVIO E CALDERON who has produ ced FL DLcr6d*r<07-o
name of pe6on acknowledging (applicant)
as identification and did not take an oath.
type ol identification or known
NOTARY'S SEAL
Page 5 of '15
,,
"t-)
ilo[ry Puuc Staa of Flond.
Nolton A Vatquaa
My Colnrnl..lon OG 1C9079
Erg... lZ2Ol2041
FlRl\4 APPLICATION Rev 4l'l2l1a
(st ARY)
3V\\\ L
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 264 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
County
Gru\^nh ManagErnent OepartrrEnt
Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
Phone - 239-?52-2431
Fax - 239-252-2469
APPTICATION FOR COLTIER COUNTY CERIIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
CERTIFICAIION OF APPTICATION
The undersigned hereby makes application for CertiJicate of Competency under the provisions of Collier County
No. 2006-46, as amended, and under penalties of perjury. I declare that I have read the foregoing qualifier
information and that the facts stated in it are true.
The undersigned hereby certifies that he is legally qualified to act on behalf of the business organization sought to
be licensed in all matters connected with its contracting business and that he has full authority to supervise
construction undertaken by himself or such business or organization and that he will continue during this registration
to be able to so bind said business organization. The qualified license holder understands that in all contracting
matters, he/she will be held strictly accounlable for any and all activities involving his license.
Any willful falsffication of any information contained herein is grounds for disqualification.
,O ro b
Applicant (please print)
ALL IN 1 CONTRACTORS, INC
of icant
State of:FLOR!DA
County of:COLLIER
The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this c\.
S
by
name of pe6on acknowledging (applicant)
as identtfication and did nol take an oath
who has produced
type of identification or known
(SIGNATU
Page 6 of 15
,t)
Not.ry PublE St a of Flond.
l.lclEon A Varquor
My Cofi.fi.rlon GG 169079
ErBr.. 1 2NXYIIO21
FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4112118
VII\ C
NOTARY'S SEAL
Name of Company
OCTAVIO E CALDERON FL DL C@rEgrE407-0
4
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 265 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
QounXy
GrDr /tr Managernent OepaltrEnt
Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
Pnone - 239-252-2431
Fax - 239-252-2469
APPLICATION FOR COTLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
It is understood and acknowledged by the Collier County Contractors' Licensing Board and myself that if I fail to
acquire, or maintain at all times effective Workmen's Compensation lnsurance it will result in the possible revocation
of my Certificate of Competency.
OCTAVIO E CALDERON
Appli6nt (please print)
AL IN ,I CONTRACTORS, INC
Name of Company
sls natu
OCTAVIO E CALDERON
BEFORE ME this day personally appeared who affirms and
Apdicant (pl6aso print)
says that he has less than one employee and do6s not require Workmen's Compensation undsrstands that at any
time he employees one or more persons he must obtain said Workmen's Compensalion lnsurance.
State of FLORIDA
County of COLLIER
The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this
OCTAVIO E CALDERON
cl \l )ot
by who has produced
name of person acknowledging (applicant)
as identification and did not take an oath
type of identification or known
NOTARY)
NOTARY'S SEAL
Page 7 of 15
"# I'jliil*t${tr
FIRM APPLICATION Rev 41121'18
\JI\\, L b
WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION AFFIDAVIT
FLDLC€,8ryB78t407-0
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 266 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
GITS, LLC Examination Operations Division
Providing the services and products to assist Govemment Agencies to make informed educated decisions.
Official Examination Score Report
November 15,2012
Offrcial Score Report:
Candidate Information :
Name - Octavio E. Calderon
Candidate #:57704070C
Testing Site: Plantation, FL
Final Score Result:
Painting Contractor
Business Procedures
Score: 80% (8129/12)
Score: 80o/o
These results represent the grade that has been achieved on the Business Procedures
examination(s) administered by Gainesville Independent Testing Service for Collier County,
Florida on November 13, 2012.
If you have any further questions, please do not hesitate to contact us.
Sincerely,
Jay E. Bowermeister
President
Po Box 831127 ocala, Florida u483-1127 - Voice (352) 369-ctrs - Fax (352) 3gt-2443
800 997 2129
\] \\\ C U
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 267 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
GITS, LLC Examination Operations Division
Providing the services and products to assist Government Agencies to make informed educated decisions.
Official Examination Score Report
results
Florida on June 13,20
has on
hesitate
I
If you have any further questions,please do not to us.
Sincerely,
Jay E. Bowermeister
President
Po Box 831127 ocala, Florida 3483-1127 - Voice (352) 369-ctrs - Fax (352) 387-2443
800 997 2129
\] \\\ C,
I
Official Score Report:
Candidate Informatton :
Name - Octavio E. Calderon
Candidate #:45774070C
Testing Site: Naples, FL
Final Score Result:
General Unlimited Contactor Score: 75olo
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 268 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
CREDIT CHECtr(-CONFIDENTIAL
lndividual Credit Report
ame...: CALDERON, OCTAVIO E.Ordered By :41-L6
Customer 29999
Received 2]-0 / 05 / La
Comp Lered :1,0 / 05 / L8
ddress:5291, 23RD PLACE SW
NAPLES, FL 341-1.6-6801
ocia1#: Applicant: r 2400
REDIT SCORE:
PPLICANT FICO SCORE:734 (scores range from 300 to S5O)
UBLIC RECORDS:
UBLIC RECORDS HAVE BEEN CHECKED AT THE LOCAL, STATE AND FEDERAL LEVELS WITH
HE FOLLOWING RESULTS AS OF 10/05/18: DETAILS FOLLOW CREDIT RECORD
CREDIT RECORD
Credit histo rV has been checked for a D eriod of seven years or from open date. )
editor
count. Number
Date
Reported opened
Date High
Credit
Unpaid
Balance
PaSE
Due
Hist.oric Stat
30 60 90
Current
Slatus
Mos
Rev ECOA
/ I BANK CC
;444
)LA= 09 / 1,8
NC BA}TK
1302008]-2859l..257
)LA= 08 /1,8
YNCB/CARECR
;01918324954
)LA= 1,0 / t6
HEMONEYSOUR
1940030207401
)LA= 05 / L8
ELLS FARGO
14654245931,7
)LA= 09 /18
CRLD OMNI F
110000002055959
)LA= 03 / 1,2
0e/78 04/13 234
08/18 04/LB 29393 27 605
to / t6 L2 /1,2 0
05/L8 L2/15 787200
0e/tB ]-1,/t2 17Oe 348
03/L2 L1,/01 31s98 0
AS AGREED0 00 00 00 R01 48 r
AS AGREED0000000roL04c
AS AGREED0 000000R01 4s r
AS AGREED0 000000MoL 26 r
AS AGREED0000000R0148r
AS AGREED0000000r0148C
0
0
0
Total- tr ade lines on this porL: 6
UBLIC RECORDS:
UBLIC RECORDS SEARCH IS AS FOLLOWS:
rdered by: APPLICANT - SEE NAIvtE ABOVE vl\\ t 6eporting Agency: Credit Check, lnc. - 3017 Excha nge Court, Suite H, West palm Beach, FL 33409 . (561) 616_5556
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 269 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
CREDIT CHECR-CONFIDENTIAL
AME: CALDERON, OCTAVIO E.
UBLIC RECORDS - continued:
-- TRANSUNION PUBLIC RECORD --.)URCE DATE ]-,, ]AB ECOA COURT ASSETS
YPE
o5o;43o4 os/Lt go c FE
FIAPTER 7 BANKRUPTCY DISCHARGED
]URCE (S) : EXPERIAN TRANSUNION
Customer:9999 Page..2
PAID DOCKET#
PLAINT 1 FF /ATTORNEY11/11 1109905
HENRY HERNANDEZ
rlQUlRlES:
+/27/78 by FOURSTGHT CA (ru) #34094s0
ESIDENCE HISTORY:
291 SW 23RD PL, NAPLES FL 34115 (05/05/16)
170 WASHINGTON LN, APT 102 NAPLES FL 3411-6 (L0/LL/08ll
75 QUAIL RN, FORT DENAUD FL 33935
OMMENTS:
***oFAC NAIi,lE SCREEN ALERT - CLEAR***
FAC (OFFICE OF FOREIGN ASSET CONTROL) IS A FEDERAL AGENCY WHICH MAINTAINS
DATABASE OF TERRORISTS. DRUG TRAFFICKERS AND CRIMINAL ORGANIZATIONS.
RAUD RECORDS HAVE BEEN SYSTEMAT] CALLY CHECKED BY THE ACCESSED BUREAUS.
HECKS FOR IDENTITY THEFT, FAKE SSN, DECEASED SSN AND OFAC DATABASE PERFORMED.
REDITOR PHONE DIRECTORY:
HILLSBORO BK ZP5O643O4801 N FLORIDA AVE TAMPA FL. 335345/3 BANK cc BC21AV061
5O5O KINGSLEY DR CINCINNATI OH. 45263
i{ORLD OMNI F FA2CC4OO2
P O BOX 91514 MOBILE AL. 36691IHEMONEYSOUR FM2 FEMO O ].
5OO S BROAD ST MER MERIDEN CT. 06450
PNC BANK 826613A12
PO BOX 3180 PITTSBURGH PA. 15230
i\JELLS FARGO BC9 O 8N5 54
CREDIT BUREAU DISP DES MOINES IA. 50306SYNCB/CARECR F 2999206.1c/o Po Box 95s036 oRLANDO FL. 32895
SREDIT CHECK Z 06302733017 EXCHANGE COUR WEST PALM BEAC FL. 33409
FOURSIGHT CA F 3409450265 E 1OO S SALT LAKE CITY UT. 84111
(813 )
(800)
(800)
(856)
(800)
(866)
le77 )
(38s)
301-5065
o?)_1n1n
301-3s1s
867-0330
642 - 47 20
396 - 8254
616-5556
242 -'7 20A
rdered by:
eporting Agency
APPLICANT SEE NAME ABOVE \ \\\
Credit Check, lnc. - 3017 Exchange Court, Suite H, West palm Beach. FL 33409 (561) 616-5556
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 270 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
CREDIT CHECI(,CONFIDENTIAL
AIT'e : CALDERON, OCTAVIO E .
rdered by: APPLICANT SEE NAME ABOVE
*** END OF REPORT ***
Customer:9999 Page:3
VII\ C ID
eporting Agency. Credit Check, lnc. - 3017 Exchange Court, Suite H, West palm Beach, FL 33409 (561) 616-5556
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 271 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
CREDIT CITECI(,CONFIDENTIAL
Date: Lo / 05 / Ie
Cust. No: 9999
Ordered By: 4tt6
Page: 1
(X) Corporation
EIN:83-2124619
Commercial Credit Report
Corprny,o"" rN 1 coNTRACToRS, rNC.
Address.529t 23RD PLACE sw
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34115
elephone: (239) 398-58s0
'RINCIPALS:
]RESIDENT
\ddress:
iocial Security Number:
itock Ownership:
CALDERON, OCTAVIO E.
529]- 23RD PLACE SW
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34116
100
100u
\ddress:
iocial Security Number:
itock Ownership:
\ddress:
iocial Security Number:
itock Ownership:
\ddress
iocial Security Number:
itock Ownership:
.LL IN 1 CONTRACTORS, INC. was INCORPORATED in the county of COLLIER, state ofLORIDA, orl 09/27, 2078. The charter number is P1BOO008t62B. The registeredgent is CALDERoN, oCTAVIo E. of 5291 23RD PLACE SW, NAPLES, floR.toA 34LL6.ffices are LEASED from N/A at N/A per month. The company employs N/A.
IET WORTH: oN FILE wrrH srATE
he company maintains banking relations with N/A
he officer handling the account is N/A
\\I Lleported for: Appl,rCANT - SEE NAME ABOVE
leported by: Credit Check, lnc. - 3017 Exchange Court, Suite H, west palm Beach, FL (561) 616-5556
I\
,,4oy
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 272 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
SM
CREDIT CHECK CONFIDENTIAL
Commercial Credit Report
Company: ar,r, rN 1 CoNTRACToRS, rNC.
Address.529\ 23RD PLACE sw
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34116
Date:
Cust. No:
to/os/ts
9999
Ordered By: 4tt6
Page: 2
,UBLIC RECORDS WERE CHECKED FOR GOLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA. A SEARCH OF LOCAL, STATE,
'ND FEDERAL RECORDS HAS BEEN CONDUCTED WITH THE FOLLOWING RESULTS: CLEAR AS OF
0/05/18 . SEVEN YEAR SEARCH.
*** Credit Profile **"
Credit.or Opened High Balance Rating
/a
I.EtI/ARKS:
/t = Nor APPLTcABLE/Nor AVATLABLE
.EPORT WORKED BY RENEE
ND OF REPORT.
tl ttr r. lL
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 273 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
Qovttrty
Gro\,rrh Managef rEnt DepartrEnt
Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34'l04
239-252-2400
APPLICATION FOR COTLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
COLLECTION OF SOCIAI SECURITY NUMBERS
Date: APRIL 12,2018
To: Applicants for Certificate of Competency
From: Everildo Ybaceta, Contractor Licensing Supervisor
Pursuant to Chapter l-19, Florida Statutes and Collier County Contractor Licensing Ordinance 200646
Section 2.1.'l., all applicants are required to submit their social security number(SsN) for the following
purposes:
a) Assess applicant's ability to satisfy creditors by reviewing their credit history.
b) Verification of applicant's test scores and information.
Our office will only use your SSN noted above for those reasons pursuant to Chapter l-19, Florida
Statutes, and as may otherwise be authorized by law.
We are fully committed to safe-guarding and protecting your SSN and once collected, will be maintained
as confidential and exempt under Chapter l-19, Florida Statutes.
FlRl\.4 APPLICATION Rev 4112l1g
VI\\ C
Pag€ 15 of '15
\b
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 274 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
Detail by Entity Name
Florida Department of State
Page I of2
OtvrsroN oF CoRPoRATroNs
Otutruru o/
C oigoiuyllIor.JS
w e#"id fui af Fbt#,t x;*dtt
Deoadment of State / Division of Corporations / Search Records / Detail Bv Document Number /
Detail by Entity Name
Florida Profit Corporation
ALL IN 1 CONTRACTORS,INC.
Filino lnformation
DocumentNumber P18000081628
FEI/EIN ilumber NONE
Date Filed Ogn7PO18
Effecfive Date 09l27nVg
Stato FL
Status ACTIVE
Principal Address
5291 23RD PLACE SW
NAPLES, FL 34116
Mallinq Address
5291 23RD PIACE SW
NAPLES, F134116
Reqistered Aqent Name & Address
CALDERON, OCTAVIO E
5291 23RD PLACE SW
NAPLES, FL 34116
OflicerrDirector Detail
Name & Addrcsa
Title PSTD
CALDERON, OCTAVIO E
5291 23RD PI.ACE SW
NAPLES, F134116
Annual Reports
No Annual Repotts Filed
Document lmaqes
View image in PDF format
V\\\ Thttp://search.sunbiz'org/Inquiry/CorporationSearch/SearchResultDetail?inquirytype{ntit... l0/12120
tLl
l8
.or9
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 275 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
State of frtori[a
Oepmtmcnt of Sute
I certif from the records of this office that ALL IN I CONTRACTORS, INC. is a corporation
organized under the laws ofthe State ofFlorida, filed electronically on September 27,2018,
effective September 27, 2018.
The document number ofthis corporation is P18000081628.
I further certifu that said corporation has paid all fees due this office through December 31, 2018,
and its status is active.
I further certiry that said corporation has not filed Articles of Dissolution.
I further certifr that this is an electronically transmitted certificate authorized by section I 5.16,
Florida Statutes, and authenticated by the code noted below.
Authentication Code: I 8 1 00 I 0837 57 -2003 I 9054 I 52# |
Given under my hand and the
Great Seal ofthe State of Florida
at Tallahassee, the Capital, this the
First day of October, 2018
\(l.. 0,k*
&en Erttiur
Serntery of Ste
\\\\ e. l 5
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 276 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
Electron ic Articles of Incorporation
For
ALL IN 1 CONTRACTORS. INC
The undersigned incorporator, for the purpose of forming a Florida
profit corporation, hereby adopts the following Articles of Incorporation
Article I
The name of the corporation is:
ALL IN 1 CONTRACTORS. INC.
Article II
The principal place of business address:
5291 23RD PLACE SW
NAPLES, FL. 34116
The mailing address of the corporation is:
529T 23RD PLACE SW
NAPLES, FL. 34116
Article III
The purpose tbr which this corporation is organized is:
ANY AND ALL LAWFUL BUSINESS.
Article V
The name and Florida street address of the registered agent is:
OCTAVIO E CALDERON
5291 23RD PLACE SW
NAPLES, FL. 341T6
I certi$, that I am familiar with and accept the responsibilities of
registered agent.
Registered Agent Signature: OCTAVIO E. CALDERON
P1 8000081 628
FILED
Seotember 27.2018
Seb. Of State '
cmwood
\l\\\ t lu
Article IV
The number of shares the corporation is authorized to issue is.
7500
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 277 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
Eleclronic Signature of Incorporator: OCTA\,'IO E. CALDERON
I am fte incorporator submitting these Articles of Incorporation and affrrn that dre facls stated herein are
true. I am awhre that false information submitted in a document to the Deparfrnent of State constitutes a
third dcgree lelony as provided for in s.817.155, F.S. I understand the require'ment lo frle an annual reporl
between Januarv 'lst and Mav I st h fte calendar year lollowing f,ormation of this corporation and every
vear hereafler io maintain "a'ctive" status.
Article VII
The initial officer(s) and/or director(s) of the corporation is/are:
Title: PSTD
OCTA\TIO E CALDERON
5291 23RD PLACE SW
NAPLES, FL. 34116
Article VIII
The effective date for this corporation shall be:
09/27120tE
Article VI
The name and address of the incorporator is
OCTAVIO E. CALDERON
5291 23RD PLACE SW
NAPLES. FL 341I6
P18000081628
FILED
Seotember 27.2018
Seb. Of State '
cmwood
vru L 11
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 278 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
flSms DEPARTMENT OE THE TREASURY
INTERNAL REVENIIE SERVICE
CINCINNATI OH 45999-0Q23
ALL IN 1 CONTRACTORS INC
% OCTAV]O E CAIDERON
5291 23RD PL SW
NAPLES, FL 34116
Date of this notice: 10-05-201-8
Employer Identificatj-on Number:
83-2L246L9
Form: SS-4
Number of this not.ice: CP 575 A
For assistance you may call us at
1-8 00-82 9-4 933
]F YOU WRITE, ATTACH THE
STUB AT THE END OF THIS NOTICE
WE ASSIGNED YOU AN EMPLOYER IDENTIEICATION NUMBER
Thank you for applying for an Employer Identification Number (EIN). We assj-gned you
EI'N 83-2124619. This EIN wj-l-I j-dentify you, your business accounts, tax returns, and
documents, even if you have no employees. Please keep this notice in your permanent
records.
When filj-ng tax documents, payments, and related correspondence, it is very important
that you use your EIN and complete name and address exactl-y as shown above. Any variation
may cause a delay in processing, result in incorrect informatlon in your account/ or even
cause you to be assigned more than one EIN. If the lnformation is not correct as shown
above, please make the correction using the attached tear off stub and return it to us.
Based on the information received from you or your representative, you must file
the following form(s) by the date(s) shown.
Form l-120 04/L5/20L9
If you have questions about the form(s) or the due date(s) shown, you can call us at
the phone number or write to us at the address shown at the top of this notice- If you
need help in determining your annuaf accounting period (tax year), see Publ-lcatron 538,
Accounting Periods and Methods.
We assigned you a tax classification based on information obtaj-ned from you or yourrepresentative. It is not a lega1 determination of your tax cl-assification, and is not
bindi-ng on the IRS. If you want a 1egaI determination of your tax cfasslficatj-on, you may
request a private l-etter ruling from the IRS under the guidelines in Revenue Procedure
2004-1, 2004-\ I.R.B. 1 (or superseding Revenue Procedure for the year at issue). Note:
Certain tax classification elections can be requested by filing Form 8832, Entity
CJ-assification ETection. See Form 8832 and its i-nstructions for additional information-
III{PORTANT INFORIATION FOR S CORPORATfON ELECTION:
If you intend to elect to fil-e your return as a smal1 business corporaLion, ane]ection to file a Form 1120-5 must be made within certain timeframes and thecorporation must meet certain tests. A11 of this information is included in thei-nstructlons for Form 2553, Election by a sna77 Business corporation.
Vtrt c lt
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 279 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
(IRS USE ONLY) 575A 10-05-2018 ALL] B 9999999999 SS-4
If you are required to deposit for employment taxes (Forms 941, 943, 940, 944, 945,
CT-1, or t042) , excise taxes (Form 720), or income taxes (Form 1120), you wj-Il receive a
Welcome Package shortly, which j-ncLudes instructions for making your deposits
el-ectronically through the E.l-ectronic Federal- Tax Palment System (EFTPS) . A PersonalIdentification Number (PIN) for EFTPS will also be sent Lo you under separate cover.
Please activate the PIN once you receive j-t, even if you have requested the services of a
tax professional or representatj-ve. For more j-nformatlon about EFTPS, refer to
Publication 966, ETectronic Choices to Pay Al,f Your Federal Taxes. If you need to
make a deposit immediatelyr you w111 need to make arrangements with your FlnancialInstitution to complete a wire transfer.
The IRS is committed to helping al1 taxpayers comply with their tax filingobligations. If you need help completing your returns or meeting your tax obligatlons,
Authorized e-file Providers, such as Report.ing Agents (payrol1 service providers) are
available to assist you. Visit the IRS Web site at www.j-rs.gov for a li-st of companies
that offer IRS e-file for business products and services. The list provides addresses,
telephone numbers, and links to their Web sj-tes.
To obtai-n tax forms and publicaLions, lncluding those referenced in this notice,
visit our Web site at www.irs.gov. If you do not have access to the Internet, call
1"-800-829-3676 (TTY/TDD 1-800-829-4059) or vj-sit your local IRS office.
I}IPORTAI{T RB{INDEF"S :
Keep a copy of this notice in your permanent records. Ttris notice is issued only
one ti-rrp and ttre IRS ril-l not be able to generate a dtrpJ.icate eopy for you. You
may give a copy of this doeument to anyone asking for proof of your EIN.
Use this EIN and your name exactly as they appear at the top of thi-s notice on all
your federal tax forms.
Refer to this EIN on your tax-related correspondence and documents.
If you have questions about your EIN, you can call us at the phone number or write to
us at the address shown at the top of this notice. If you write, please tear off the stubat the bottom of this notice and send it along with your letter. If you do not need to
write us, do not complete and return the stub.
Your name control associ-ated with this EIN is ALLI. You wi]l need to provide thisj-nformation, al-ong with your EIN, if you file your returns electronically.
Thank you for your cooperation.
V\II L I?
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 280 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
(IRS USE ONLY) 575A 10-05-2018 ArLr B 9999999999 SS-4
Keep this part for your records.CP 575 A (Rev. 7-2001)
Return this part with any correspondence
so we may identify your account. Please
correcL any errors in your name or address.
Your Telephone Number Best Time to Ca11()
CP 575 A
9999999999
DATE OF THIS NOTICE: 10-05-2018
EMPLOYER IDENTIFICATION NUMBER: 83-21.24619
FORM: SS-4 NOBOD
]NTERNAI REVENUE SERVICE
CINCINNATI OH 45999-0023
l,l,,l,l,l,l,l,,l,l,,l,l,,ll,,,ll,,,,,l,l,,ll,l,l,,l
AIL IN 1 CONTRACTORS INC
t OCTAV]O E CAIDERON
5291 23RD PL SW
NAPLES, FL 34LL6
\ \\\ (,7o
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 281 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
Growth Management Deparhnent
Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
239-252-2400
APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
STATEMENT OF OWNERSHIP
O*a\,,,o €C,tt{e (0NThis certifies that l,
member
lown \o
State of Thr,'C+
County of 0o I l; e L
The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this
io cl ^)who has produced
name of person acknowledging (applicant)
as identification and did not take an oath.
NOTARY'S SEAL
am a member or managing
APPLICANT'S NAME (please print)
/Je
(LTMTTED LTABTLTTY COMPANY NAME)
% of the units issued by the Limited Liability Company listed above
Affidavit of Applicant: I certify under penalty of perjury that the information contained is a true and correct
statement to the best of my knowledge.
C t q.",o i: CAlCerrn
Fr- Dl t{ 0) -,
Applicant (please print)
nt,rq( to, s
Name of Company
Signature of Applicant
tt o\by
date
type of identification or known
ARY)
e
\\\\ L ZI
#.i
tlot!ry Puuic St tG of Floncla
Nelson A Vazquez
My Comrnr3sEn GG 109E79
Etpres 1212U2O21
FlRl\4 APPLICATION Rev 4t12t18 Page 9 of 15
^4 Art f
L
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 282 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
Grrnnth lManaganent Departrrent
Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
239-252-2400
VERIFICATIO N OF CONSTRUCTION EXPERIENCE
Applicant's o
Certif icate Category Requested :6resw.& 6xr
The applicant is seeking a Collier County Certificate ol Competency in the trade indicated above. As part of the application forthis certiticate, the applicant must verify his/her experience within this trade. You are being requested to provide iniormationthat will aid the applicant in meeting this requirement. You should verify time of active exp-erience working as an apprentice ora skilled worker (e.9., as a worker commanding the wage ol mechanic or better in the trade). Time served solely in asupervisory or administrative role should be described, but may or may not be considered sufficient to demonstiate requiredtrade experience' The person verifying trade experience lor the above-named applicant must provide the following infoimation:
Name:
B'"r LtlF-l C-ruo
c,Rffii",
Business Name All L
Phone:License No. (if applicable)Lbc tAsa3q b
Business Address:Sas t LAqo Vr LL eftto W+Y N Arugs n-74toA
The applicant was employed by me from 1 (oh.\
Applicant's title:o$Ntrl-
The applicant's scope of work (specific duties) included:
Dooos
Additional comments 5',.
State zip
rvt b-l- &oof 70 W€srfu'ff
Street City
tl - u€r"r, tr
NOTE TO LICENSED
- Cx3.o;l1 ,
CONTRACTORS
Lb- Otto
-o53t5 - o5v5 tg Cott{t7- 6
1., tb-o3l?)-. xS-1ETb.
ififormation provided herein may sudjedt
L5- l bvl
your ficense to
->11 L/
4,61
Falsifying any
Under penalty of perjury, I declare that the facts stated here are true.
State of 0ri.,{
County of Cott i c (?-
The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this
L.Gi*e't-
of person acknowledging
and did not take an oath.
who has nroou""oFL Drtvr, (i-*rs" GEWffi;Po'o
type of identification or known
tJ\\t I 7L
statement
by
date
n
(
S
i,ffi,
Notary Public SLt of Flonde
Nelson A Varquez
My Comm[ron GG 169879
AR)pslm$iLo21
FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4/12118
Page 10 of 15
I
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 283 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
Anchor Builders CorP
5551 Lago Villaggio Way, Naples Fl. 34104
239 -7 32-9 495, 239 -269'60 59
I Gary Gionet, president of Anchor Builders Corp,
have contracted octavio calderon for the following
services listed below:
*Supervision
*Framing
* Drywall
*Painting
*Carpentry
Sincerely: Gary Gio t
(
ibLry PublG 9Lta ol Fbndt
Nrlson A Vazquez
MY Commrllon GG 169879
Ergu.. 1212U2O21'--?-;
\\\\ L LZ
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 284 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
C,RP.,
Growlh [/anagement Deparlr'ent
APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
VERIFICATION OF CON STRUCTION EXPERIENCE
Applic€nt's Name c-6r dYa
Certilicate Category Requested
The applicant is seeking a Coltier Cou nty Certificate ol Comp€tency in the trade indicated above As parl ol tho applicalion lorthis certificate, ihe applicant must verity h is/her experience wjthin this trade. you are bein g requested to provide intormationthat will aid the applicant in meei ng this r€quirement. You should veriry time ol acfive experience working as an apprenlice ora skilled worker (e,g., as a worke r commanding the wage of mechanic or better in th e trade). Time s€rv€d solely in asupervisory or administrative role should be described, but may or may not be consi dered sullicient to demonstrate requiredtrade experience. The person verilyin g trade experisnce tor lhe above-named ap,pli cant must provide the lollowing inlormation
Name At ?Tille
n s
Phone License No. (il appticabt€)cB( t >6 o.5 >I
Business Address t4
Street
The applicant was employ€d by me lrom
u trc-td
c,ry Slate zip
n t-L(Jrab"r t4, )or ??r.s -*to
Applicant's titte Ut
The spplicant's scope of work (specillc duties) included
Additional commenls
t()
e of person acknowledging
vided hercin may subje your license to revocation
ignature ol person provlding the statement
by
date
asi
"o)-O
entification
type of identilicaflon or known
h+ru,
NOTE TO LICENSED CONTRACTORS: Fatsitying any intotmation pro
Under penalty ol perjury, I declare that the lacti statejhere are truef
-
state ot F(a riJr^
County of
The lorsgoing instrument as acknowledged before ms this Ocl
aen D.4 L)Drduced I L, 'who has pro
ARY
Page 12 of 15
LLI
tZOZnZat saJKhl
i.ai:9, g'J uo'ssturtlo3 1^
,eibzen v ucsraN
NO.trCft YdSrSEAlc.a
^re::N
,:#
FIRM APPLICATTON Rev 4t12ha
SIGN TU
VI\\ C
Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
239-252-2400
Business Nam€:
and dld not take an oath.
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 285 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
^3 ALEMAN BUILDERS, INC.
To Whom lt May Concern:
The reason of this letter is to confirm that Octavio Calderon has been working at Aleman
Builders lnc. Since December 18th, 2017 to the present day. His scope of work has involved
supervising(superintendent) our guys on site, helping with permitting process, working on
rough framing, demolition and all the process that involve homes remodel and restoration.
Octavio is an excellent person, very truthful worker that I recommend to any organization.
Any question or concern, feel free to contact me at anytime.
Sergio D. Aleman
Owner
Aleman Builders lnc.
STATE OF FLORIDA
COLLIER COUNTY
My commission expires:
N LIC
\/\\\ 0 7.5
tift
ltoiary PublE St'i' ol Flondr
HBS}X"io38"u*"
a;ello.12t2u2oz1
building the hfiure. resfr,ring lhe post.
4(\5 5th Ave South Suite 7-3
Naples FL,34102
inf o@alemanbuilders.com
Offtce:(239) 673-OOrt4
Fax: (239) 3'14Oil2
fgr_lhe Ioregoing instrument was acknowledge before me on october 16. 201 g. by sERGlo D.ALEMAN who is personally known to me.
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 286 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
Cau**g
Growth Management Deparfnent
Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
239-252-2400
Applicant's
Name
Certificate Category Requested ta€"_yA-X,- bo;<a*uG>?-
The applicant is seeking a Collier County Certlficate of Competency in the trade indicated above. As part of the application for
this certificate, the applicant must verify his/her experience within this trade. You are belng requested to provide information
that will aid the applicant in meeting this requirement. You should verify time of active experience working as an apprentice or
a skilled worker (e.9., as a worker commanding the wage of mechanic or better in the trade). Time served solely in a
supervisory or administrative role should be described, but may or may not be considered sufficient to demonstrate required
trade experience. The person veriiying trade experience for the above-named ust provide the Iollowing information
C.fg** Ca.a9o,rl o2&4.?6A(
VERIFICATION OF CONSTRUCTION EXPERIENCE
$2ri6J ro &xuveao,{
fJC-L Ca,sre.ac,r, JA VLCBusiness Name:
Phone 6n a4e ?qoq License No. (if applicable)L((e{oegg
3€-t\ A..€Eocd (.p $" *r (oz Jor-g' €- zAtDsBusiness Address:
Street
The applicant was employed by me from
City State zip
(qqn ro Lbt{
Applicant's title:
The applicant's
4tri'u
scopq
b1
of wo rkdsRecific duties) included:
7 n-r r.\(3*eL'.\(G"rDAoJr
{€u lnn.,ta QeQ,,co,r--
Additional comments:
NOTE TO LICENSED CONTRACTORS: Falsifying any information
Under penalty of perjury, I declare that the facts stated here are lrue.
may subject Iicense to revocation.
r/\,./\-'-
Signature of person providing the statement
State of
(r^*.**
County of tOr,-rZL
The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this
C+a.s Crcarg who has produced C.4pr.U<-r-{ KJr.rS
type of identification or
\o- r l- L&
by
date
name of person acknowledging
and did not take an oath.
ARY'S SEAL
I\\ C LIO
S
as identification
ARY#";
Not ry Public StsE of Flonda
Nelson A Vazquel
My Commrsson GG 1i0079
erctes 12t2w20?1
FIRIM APPLICATION Rev 411?/18 V Page 11 of 15
APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY
Nlame'
/
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 287 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
TRUSSES & IIiETAL FRAMING, PLASTERING
DRYWALL & PAINTING
381I AIRPORT PULLING RD. N. #102
NAPLES FL 34105
PH:(239) ef9-7909 FAX:(239) 649-7971
website: www,vccof naples.com
email: vcccontractinqllc@qmail.com
October 17,2018
To Whom lt May Concern
I am writing this lefter to confirm that Octavio Calderon has worked with VCC Contracting and our
previous company Vasquez Carson Construction periodically since 1999. He worked in the
scopes of framing, dryvvall, stucco, and painting. He also worked in the capacity of a
Superintendent operating multiple projects simultaneously. Octavio is a hard worker with
impeccable ethics. He would be an excellent addition to any company's workforce and he is
always eligible for rehire with VCC Contracting LLC.
at the information provided above is accurate and truthful
CHRIS CARSON
VICE PRESIDENT
VCC CONTRACTING, LLC.
STATE OF FLORIDA
COLLIER COUNTY
The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me on OCTOBER 17. 2018, by SS_
CARSON who is personally known to me.
My commission expires:
#Notary Public SLt ot Flonda
Nalson A Vazquez
Mv Coffrnt.3on GG 169879
e;9fi. 12t2uzs21
\\\\ 0 ?1L./'
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 288 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
C,RP",
Gru,vd't ManagerrErn Deparb-rEnt
STATE OF F toriA
COUNTY OF ic/
I am a resident of Cr>t
more than five (S) y6ars.
During the last five (5) years I have known
to obsorve his or her business and perso
good character.
County,€to,,l,*-
Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 94104
239-252-2400
(Stats) and have resided here for
had the opportunity
nesty, inlegrity and
APPLICATION FOR COLLI
AFFIDAVIT OF INTEGRITY AND GOOD CHARACTER
t
I i.,..-
t (applicanl). I have
nal dealings and find him or her to be a pe rson of ho
Signat!re
Pri nted Name
r
zip
0
ntificalion
gaL
Telephone
c1.)ol
c(tob A\has produced
Address:Be LL).-t ra
Street
lc FL,3.1 to .<
State
9<t7-5 t7-
by
L 0o?'as rden acknowledging
and did not take an oath.
NOTARY'S SEAL
typ€ of identificatjo.
IG RE OF OTARY)
Page 13 ot 15
#i Nltary Prbla itato 9l t''J'da
Nalson A Vrrqust
Mt Cc mrsill)n Gc '6"379
erg r€1 t l')o/ilor1
FIRM APPLTCATTON Rw 4t12fi8
V\\\ E L\
I,So.X*' 0. A(.r,^.,.-having been first duly sworn, state and affirm:
L
The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this
name
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 289 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
Qou*rty
Growtfr Management Deparlrnent
having been first duly sworn, state and affirm
Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
239-252-2400
(State) and have resided here for
I have had the opportunity
.Person of nesty, integrity and
Signature
AFFIDAVIT OF INTEGRITY AND GOOD CHARACTER
STATE OF f'-r.t l
COUNTY OF 0ro- t
Lsur* C**r,.,<
I am a resident of County,C--Z-ts"\
more than five (5) years.
During the last five (5) years I have known J. o 1,r,."
to observe his or her business and personal dealings and find him or
good character.
Address
City
%rt l-rvzrat ?oo toz
TL\
Street /\YcL9 f t-.4to5
a
C *r.* t 4ttlrc, )-[
Printed Name
State Zip
Telephone zgq,- G4q--1q6q
The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this a8 f,D
date
I by
as identificationname of person acknowledging
and did not take an oath
NOTARY'S SEAL
who has produced o,^qi \^r--
Vttt
type
0Lq
ffi JENNIFER VASQUEZ
Notary Public - Srate of Florid.
Commlsrion f GG 093427
My Comm. Expirel A91 21,2021
Bmded lhrough Nrlim,rl Noldry A!!tr.
FIRM APPLTCATION Rev 4/12/18
(s oF NOTARY)
Page 13 of 15
t,
LL
be
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 290 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
I am a resident of uul
more than five (5) years.
During the last five
to observe his or h
good character,
Groudh Management Deparhnent
STATE OF fi-oPr D4
couNry oF _CoLLlE-p_
6cor,.:
CE €.(?-
AFFIDAVIT OF INTEGRITY AND GOOD CHARACTER
Contractor Licensing
2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.
Naples, FL 34104
239-252-2400
having been first duly sworn, state and affirm:
County,vt oot (State) and have resided here for
6ro
Signature
Printed Name
Address l#o Vr*lo
Street
zip
!\\\ t, 3o
(5) years I have known Of*Vf O C*uDAAo ( (appticant). I have had the opporruniry
er business and personal dealings and find him or her to be a person of honesty, integrity and
City State
The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this f.q ,)orK by
date
L,,t-
who has produced tL uriwt crerx 6ffi-o
type of identification or known
of person acknowledging
#.)
No[ry PuDllc Strf ot Flofld.
Ncl.on A Vuqurr
My CorYnxrrtm OO 1tet7g
Etpttt 12fr10t2021
FIRM APPLICATTON Rev 4/12/18
,TURE ARY)
Page 14 of 15
l,
Ft.34 (o4
r"t"pnon", ?71' 761 -G6\
and did not take an oath.
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 291 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
NOTICE OF ELECTION TO BE EXEMPT
lf this application contains incomplete or inaccurate information, it may cause a delay in the issuance of your exemption. An
officer electing an exemption under Chapter 440, Florida Statutes, is not entitled to benefits under this chapter.
Social Security Numbor (last four digits): 2400
Email Address: ALLINI DRWVALL.PAINTING@COMCAST.NET
CALDERONOCTAVIO
State Drive/s License Number:State lD Number:Stato: FL
111711977
E
Section 1 :
APPLICANT INFORMATION
First & Last Name:
q 070
Dato of Birth:
CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY APPLICANT ($50 FEE REAUIRED)
Section 2:
cer of a Corporation
Section 3:
This section should be completed with information specific to your corporation or to the limited liability company in which you are
a member. The name of the corporation or limited liability company listed on this application MUST match the name of the
corporation or limited liability company as registered with the Florida Division of Corporations,
Name of Corporation or LLC: ALL lN 1 CONTRACTORS INC
Business Name (DBA):
Applicant's Address of Record: 5291 23RD PL SW
City: NAPLES State: FL
Phone: 2393986850
Scope 4:Scope 2Scope 'l
County: COLLIERZip 341 16
05606 CootractorProj€ct
Manager, Consvuction
Exe
FEIN: 832124619
Section 4:
The corporation of which you are an officer or limited lisbility company of which you are a member must be registered and in ACTIVE status
"itt in" iOrlO" Oinision of Corporations. Applicants applying as in ortcer of a corporation mustbe listsd as an officrr of the corporation with
ti," fioiida Oiri"ion of Corporaiions. List tha document number on file with the Florida Oivision of Corporauons.
P18000081628
Soction 5:
pursuant to chapter 4gg, F.s. (contractor liconsing law),.list certified or registered licenses related to the scope of business or
irJo" ri.ilJ i" Sdction 3 trero ui tne appricant, or ti'e ceriified or registered license numbers held by the qualifielfor the
.
corooration or limited tiaoirity companyiisiJJ on tnis application. Tie business name listed on the license MUST match the name
#i#';;il;i;;'".. ririt"Jiir6iri[-"irp"nv i" iegi"idreo *ith the Florida Division of corporations and on this Notice of Eleclion
to be Exempt,
This section is not applica ble to my business
Vrtr C.3\
Scope 3:
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 292 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
Section 6:
lf you have submitted an electronic payment for this application, the transaction confirmation number is listed in the following space:
Confirmation Number: 6QZT044NDW Application Number: E00879479
Sectlon 7: Yes
Are you affiliated with any corporation or limited liability company other than the corporation or limited liability company to which
this application applies?
Name: ALL lN 1 DRYWALL & PAINTING, INC FEIN: 462047626
Seffin 8: CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRYAND NON-CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY LLC MEMBERS ONLY
To be eligible for a construction industry exemption or a non-construction limited liability company exemption, an applicant must
have the required ownership of the corporation or limited liability company.
I am a shareholder owning at least ten percent(10Yo) of stock of the corporation listed on this application.
Section 9:
I certify that any employees of the corporation or members of the limited liability company listed in Section 3 are covered by
workers' compensation insurance. Please identifo the workers' compensation insurance carrier that covers any non-exempt
employees.
Carrier Name:My business does not have any non-exempt employees; or, my business is not required to obtain workers'
compensation.
Section 10: FRAUD NOTICE
A. Any person who, knowingly and with intent to injure, defraud, or deceive the department or any employer or employee,
insurance company or any other person, files a Notice of Election to be Exempt containing any false or misleading
information is guilty of a felony of the third degree.
B. Attestation of applicant - By providing my name below, I attest that I have read, understand and acknowledge the
foregoing notice.
C. Acknowledge that this Notice of Election to be Exempt does not exceed limits for corporate offie,ers, including any
affiliated corporations as provided in Section 440.02, Florida Statutes.
First Name: OCTAVIO Last Name: CALDERON
Note: The Division has 30 days to review your application to determine if it meets the eligibility requirements for the issuance of
an exemption. The Division will either issue a Certificate of Election to be Exempt or notify you that your application is incomplete
The Division reviews and processes exemption applications in the order they are received.
Exemption information is reflected on the Proof of Coverage database the day following the issuance of the exemption. Visit the
Division's website at http://www.myfloridacfo.com/division/wc to print your certificate.
\\\\ c. 6L
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 293 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
\ttr c- 3\
:soit
telt
I 3Fo
tG,
t
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 294 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
August 19,2015
MINUTES
OF THE COLLIER COUNTY
CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD MEETING
August 19,2015
Naples, Florida
LET IT BE REMEMBERED, that the Collier County Contractors' Licensing
Board, having conducted business herein, met on this date at 9:00 AM in
REGaLAR SESS/ON in Administrative Building "F," 3rd Floor, Collier County
Government Complex, Naples, Florida, with the following Members present:
Chairman:
Vice Chair:
Patrick White
Thomas Lykos
Members:Michael Boyd
Terry Jerulle
Richard Joslin
Kyle Lantz
Gary McNally
Robert Meister
ALSO PRESENT:
Michael Ossorio - Supervisor, Contractors' Licensing Office
Kevin Noell, Esq.- Assistant County Attorney
James F. Morey, Esq. - Attorney for the Contractors' Licensing Board
Rob Ganguli - Collier County Licensing Compliance Officer
1
\r\r c,u
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 295 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
August 19,2015
(Note.: With reference to the cases heard under Section VI, the individuals who
testified were first sworn in by the Attorney for the Board.)
[8. David M. Jones - Waiver of Exam(s) - Withdrawn per amended Asenda)
C. Octavio E. Calderon - Yerification of Experience
(dlbla"All in I Drywall & Painting, Inc."\
Michael Ossorio referenced the definitions under Section 22 - 162 of Collier County
Ordinance #90-105, Section 6.1:
General Contractor requires 4S-months of experience with a passing grade
on an approved test, and a Business and Law test, and means a Contractor
whose services are unlimited as to the type of work which he/she may do,
except as provided in this article or in the Florida Statutes.
He continued:
o Mr. Calderon applied for a General Contractor's license and has applied to be
a State registered General Contractor;
o He has a licenses for Dry-Wall and Painting;
o He was referred to the Contractors' Licensing Board due to lack of affrdavits
regarding his previous experience.
Mr. Ossorio noted the Scope of Work for a General Contractor is "unlimited" and
the State of Florida expects each candidate to provide detailed proof of hislher
experience in several areas: supervision, commercial/multi-story building jobs, and
residential construction.
Chairman White noted the materials provided by Mr. Calderon did not sufficiently
detail his experience.
Kyle Lantz requested specifics regarding the type of structural work experience and
the time required for each component.
Michael Ossorio responded the State accepts W-2s to verify employment and has
become stricter on the content of the affidavits. He stated the County follows the
State's lead. He reiterated to become a General Contractor, the Candidate must prove
that he/she has unlimited skills and the skill level required by the County includes
commercial/multi-story construction experience, residential construction experience,
the ability to pull appropriate permits, and supervision experience. He confirmed
both the State and the County accept payroll records as proof that a Candidate had
worked for a General Contractor.
Kyle Lantz noted Mr. Calderon appeared to have very limited structural experience.
He asked if there was a specific requirement for structural experience, in particular-
Michael Ossorio confirmed a Candidate's structural experience should be mentioned
in an affidavit. He stated it was a difficult license to obtain and the County verifies
the information contained in each affidavit.
J
\nr c 35
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 296 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
August 79,2015
He continued that Mr. Calderon has been a licensed Dry-Wall Contractor and a
licensed Painter for several years. He will need to testify to the Board concerning the
extent of his experience.
Chairman White questioned the Applicant:
Q. Can you tell us whether you have experience in the construction of or supervising
the construction of and the permitting for buildings of three stories or more that
are either of a single-family, residential-type construction or a commercial
construction of a condo or something like that?
A. I have worked in residential construction for a builder; I have done remodeling
including a lot of experience in framing and dry-wall installation and tile. I have
not been able to pull a permit because I did not have a license.
Q. We understand that and we are glad to hear that you didn't try to. But the point is
to be able to do that as a Registered General Contractor, we need to hear from you
because it is not in the papers that you have given us that you have experience
with construction of buildings of three stories or more and, in particular, the
structural aspects of those. Framing is framing - but when you do commercial
construction of three or more stories, there are a lot of structural plans and other
kinds of reviews and construction techniques that you have to be familiar with -
and because the type of license that you are asking us to give you would allow
you to do those things.
A. I have been working on trusses - I know how to do roofing trusses and how to
read plans. Everything is in the plans when you are building houses - everything
is in the plans they give you - what kind of materials you need. With the plans,
you do not need to be 100% structural to be able to build. I didn't have that much
experience in building but I will be learning, little by little.
Q. Well, there's the thing - once you have the license, the assumption is you're not
going to do on-the-job training. The assumption is that in order to get the license,
you spent four years - 48 months - on the job working for someone else who was
a licensed General Contractor and you learned how to do those things and you
were under their "umbrella" or protection so that they helped you to do those
things. I would be very uncomfortable approving a license for someone who was
telling me they would learn how to do the job once we give him a license.
A. I have been working in construction sites for more than 15 years. I never built a
house by myself because I never had an opportunity to do that. But if I do have a
license, I know for sure ...
Q. But here's the point I'm trying to make - you're not asking us for a type of
General Contracting approval for a license that's limited to just residential
construction. You're asking us for a type of Registered General Contractor's
license that allows you to build anything - anything. And you haven't yet.
A. I don't understand what I need.
Terry Jerulle questioned the Applicant:
p. You said you have done framing before?
A. Yes, I have.
4
\\\t c.\le
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 297 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
August 79,2015
Q. Okay. But by the time you get to the framing aspect of a house, or a building, the
structural aspect of it - the concrete structural aspect of it is pretty much
complete, correct?
A. Yes.
0. So you're not on-site observing how they do the structural concrete aspect of the
building. You are coming in after that point. I'm not confident you understand
what to do or how to build a structural component of the building with concrete
because you haven't shown any experience. If you have experience, explain it to
us but I'm not sure that you do - compared with the information that you have
provided.
A. No, I don't - I don't have experience with concrete.
0. So you've never installed pilings? You don't know what a deep foundation is?
A. I know what it is but I've never done it.
Q. You've never done it. You've never poured footings?
A. No.
Q. Never formed or poured footings? Never installed steel in the footings or had
inspections completed with the footings?
A. I've never done it but I've been in the house where ...
Q. Do you know what a sheer wall is?
A. Yes, I know what it is.
Q. What is a sheer wall?
A. Sorry - I can't explain it.
Q. I'm not sure you have the structural experience with a concrete structure to give
you a license, as Mr. White said, for a three-story building or more. There is a lot
of difference between doing a single-family home and a three-story structure that
requires a deep foundation.
A. Let me explain to you the reason why I tried to do a General Contractor license is
because I have many customers already who ask me to replace the front door, or
to replace windows, or do tile and remodel the bathroom - things like that. I want
to be able to have one license to cover me for all that. I am not planning to build
a high-rise or house and that's why I decided to take that test. It is a very hard test
and it took me a long time to do it but I passed. I know it's not easy to learn
everything about building a high-rise or a house - nobody learns it in five years or
ten years - it takes longer than that. But you will get that experience everyday
learning little by little in the field. In the book or if somebody else tells you,
you're not learning that. You learn by practice.
Q. Well, the license you are applying for is a license that gives you the authority to
build a three-story building unless we restrict it somehow.
A. I understand that part, but my dream was, you know - I do have a Painter's
Contractor license and Dry-Wallbut I was only allowed to do framing and light
metal framing but I have many customers who ask if I can replace their front
door. I know to replace a front door, I have to pull a permit; to replace a window,
I have to pull a permit.
Q. That's correct.
A. You know, and I know when I need a permit or not. That is the reason - you
know, I say I need each license to do carpentry or windows - it's too mally
licenses so I decide to take only one license to be able to cover everything.
5
vrrr L7:
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 298 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
August 19,2015
Chairman White asked Mr. Calderon why if the things that he wanted to do were
limited to residential buildings he asked for a Registered General Contractor's license
as opposed to a Residential Contractor's license.
Octavio Calderon replied when he read the book, he thought he should go for the
bigger license rather than the Residential Contractor's license. It took him two years
of studying to be able to pass that test. He stated he knew his language was "not that
good" and he had to translate everything but he did it. He further stated it was a good
challenge for him.
Chairman White: We are certainly pleased that you have the desire to do these
things - we're confident that what you have shown us, you probably would be very
good at doing a single-family residence. But the point is, you are the one who has
chosen to be in a place where you are asking to build, essentially, anything. And
we're hearing from your testimony - at least I am - that you do not have any
experience in one aspect of that which is very critical . . . in particular, the structural
components. And so, given that you are supposed to have forty-eight months of that
type ofexperience, I'm not sure how you can expect us to approve considering the
amount of experience you do have is enough. It's certainly not enough for an
unlimited Registered General Contractor's license. That's why we're asking if all
you are intending to do is residential work, why didn't you just ask for that license?
Mr. Calderon: The thing is with residential, I cannot be able to work on high-rise
buildings or condominiums - most of my customers live in high rises or
condominiums. That is the reason. If I go residential, I can only go two-stories high
to work.
Chairman White stated he understood Mr. Calderon's reasoning. He further stated it
seemed clear that Mr. Calderon understood the differences in the various license
categories.
Terry Jerulle stated what Mr. Calderon wanted was a Residential General Contractor's
license and a Carpentry license which would allow him to replace windows and doors,
and build single-family homes. The Carpentry license would allow him to work in the
high-rises as opposed to a Building Contractor's license. He could work up to three
stories.
Kyle Lantz stated he would be reluctant to approve that since Mr. Calderon does not
have the structural component.
Vice Chairman Lykos agreed, stating you must be able to understand wind loads
when installing windows in high rises. There is a lot of structural - even just doing
windows and doors. When you enclose a lanai in a condo, you must know the Fire
Codes and sprinkler systems. There is a reason a General Contractor's license is hard
to get - a more broad-based amount of information is needed.
Kyle Lantz stated he appreciated Mr. Calderon's efforts to study and take the test.
He recognized Mr. Calderon seemed to know a great deal about the administrative
portions of the test. He suggested Mr. Calderon work for a licensed General
Contractor, even if it is just part-time, to obtain the experience he needs. He
acknowledged Mr. Calderon would not make as much money working for someone
else versus what he could make on his own, but it is part of his educational program.
6
\ut.cj\
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 299 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
August 79,2015
Kyle Lantz moved to deny Octavio Calderon's application to obtain a Registered
General Confiactor's license. Richard Joslin offered a Second in support of the
motion.
Chairman White asked Mr. Calderon if he wanted one last opportunity to convince the
Board to grant his application.
Octavio Calderon replied he knew he could not prove his experience to become a
General Contractor. He asked what he should do next. He stated he passed the test and
had his own business which would make it difficult for him to work on a part-time
basis for a General Contractor.
Chairman White concurred that working for a General Contractor was a helpful
suggestion and stated Mr. Calderon should confer with the Licensing Office to discuss
what other options he may have for a different type of license. He concluded although
the Board admired what he did, they could not get him to the place he wanted to be yet.
He stated just passing the test was not enough - Mr. Calderon needed to demonstrate
good credit and 48 months of experience. The Board was not convinced that the
amount of experience or the type of experience that Mr. Calderon possesses was
enough. He must either obtain the required experience or apply for a different type of
license. He reiterated Mr. Calderon should speak with the Contractors' Licensing
Office to discuss his options.
Chairman White calledfor a vote on the motion. Carried unanimously, 8 - 0.
D. William Orr - Contesting Citation #09365
Citation: #09365 ("Unlicensed Advertising")
Date Issued: July 15,2015
Fine: $2,000.00 (2nd offense)
Description of Violation:
Engage in the business or act in the capacity of a Contractor, or advertise self or
business organization as available to engage in the business of, or act in the capacity
of a Contractor, without being duly registered or certified.
Chairman White asked Mr. Orr to explain why the Board should consider not
upholding the Citation.
William Orr stated:
o He never intended to do anything illegal and it was not willful;
o He met with the two Licensing Compliance officers, Joe Nurse and Reggie
Smith;
o He stated he only received the packet of information prior to the meeting;
o He referenced the Verona Walk website which he stated was a private
website;
o He maintained he never received a call from the website for his services,
never had any business or inquiries
7
\rrr c 7q
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 300 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Decision of the Board
e ollier Ceiunty Contractors' l..icerrsing Boarel
For Applications Submittecl to the Board for Review
Type of Application:
Credit Report Review
Waiver of Testing Requirements
Reinstatement of License
Request to Qualify Second EntityX Other (specify) Review of
Experience
fHlS CAUSE came on for public hearing before the Contractors' Licensing Board
(hereafter Board) on August 19,2A15, for consideration of the application submitted to
the Board for review. The type of application is set out above. The Board having heard
testimony under oath, received evidence, and heard arguments relative to all
appropriate matters, thereupon issues its Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and
Order of the Board as follows:
FINDINGS OF FACT
1. That Octavio E. Calderon dba All in 1 Drywall & Painting, lnc. (the "Applicant")
has submitted an application to the Collier County Contractor Licensing Supervisor or
his designee for a Certificate of Competency as a General Contractor and based on the
information supplied by the Applicant the Licensing Supervisor determined a review of
the application by the Board is necessary"
2. That pursuant to Section 22-154(b) of the Code of Laws and Ordinances of
Collier County, as amended, applications which do not appear on their face to be
sufficient require referral to the Board for a decision regarding approval or denial of said
application.
1
394992.1 812512015
\ttt c 4D
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 301 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
3. That the Board has jurisdiction over this matter and that Octavio E. Calderon was
presenl at the public hearing on August 19, 2015, and was not represented by oounsel.
4. All notices required by the Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collier County, as
amended, have been properly issued.
5. The facts in this case are found to be:
a. Applicant has not demonstrated enough required experience in the
construction trade.
b. The Applicant needs to obtain more experience in the trade to meet the
criteria established by the Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collier
County.
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Based upon the foregoing facts, the Board concludes that the applicant has not
met the standard set out in Code of Laws and Ordinances of Collier County, as
amended, to qualify for a general contractor license at this time.
ORDER OF THE BOARD
1. Based upon the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, and
pursuant to the authority granted in Chapter 489, Florida Statutes, and Code of Laws
and Ordinances of Collier County, as amended, by a vote of B in favor and 0 opposed, a
unanimous vote of the Board present, the Applicant's application is denied.
ORDERED by the Contractors Licensing Board effective the 19th day of August,
2015.
394992 1 8t212415
2
\nr c 4l
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 302 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
By:
TRACTOR'S L.ICENSING BONRD
ER UNTY
Chairman
s Licensing Board
394992.1 8t2512015
I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the above and foregoing
Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Order of the Board has been furnished the
Applicant, and Michael Ossorio, Licensing Compliance Supervisor, 2800 North
Horseshoe Drive, Naples, FL 34103 on this 19th day of August, 2015
J
\\\\,c Llt
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 303 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)
Covt?aty
Growth Management Department
Planning & Regulation
Operations Division
Licensing Section
November 26,2018
ALL IN 1 CONTRACTORS, INC.
5291 23RD PLACE SW
NAPLES, FL 34116
RE: REVIEW OF EXPERIENCE
MR. CALDERON,
You have been added to the agenda for the Contractor Licensing Board meeting on
Wednesday, DECEIVBER 19,2018. Please attend the meeting so the board may
review your submitted application and ask you questions regarding your experience
The meeting is held at 9:00am at the W. Harmon Turner Building (Bldg. F, Admin.
Bldg.), 3299 Tamiami Trl. E., Naples, FL 34112 in the Commissioner's lVeeting Room
on the 3'd floor. There is a security checkpoint you will need to go through, so please
allow enough time to make it to the meeting.
lf you have any questions or concerns, please call (239) 252-2431 or you may email me
at contractors licensin g@col I iercou ntyf l. gov.
Li-lla Davis
Administrative Supervisor
Contractor Licensing
Collier County Growth Management Department
2800 North Horseshoe Drive
Naples, FL 34104
Growth Management Department*Contractor Licensing .2800 North Horseshoe Drive'Naples, Florida 341 04'239-252-2400'www colliergov net
S
\ttt c Llb
12.A.8
Packet Pg. 304 Attachment: OCTAVIO CALDERON - APPROVAL OF EXPERIENCE (7589 : Contractor Licensing Board – December 19, 2018)