Backup Documents 12/11/2018 Item # 7 ��
��
r
�
" �or}da Panther Range
~ ' ,
` ' ` ,
,~~--
�N��� �
����0
___-
-.0i --
In 2017, the agency recorded 49 panther attacks on pets or livestock resulting in i
!n2O17. theagencyrecorded4Spantherattacksonpetsor |ivesbocknasu0ngini jury or death in
Collier County. The FWC recorded 25 panther attacks in 2018. 20 Fatal panther collision deaths
since Oct 10. 2018. Data analysis of panther deaths from 2014 most of the 101 ofthe 175—were in
Collier County, where the Florida Panther National Wildlife Refuge and areas of panther habitat is in
preserve, This area has an established population of endangered panthers, Florida Fish and
Wildlife.
Golden Gate Estates Area of Collier County. near Naples. is the panthers' prime breeding area in
South Florida. Male panthers have been spotted in Central Florida, Osceola, Orange, Seminole,
Brevard. Volusia and Flagler counties.
The HCP endangering Panther's last habitat area and threatened species: Caracara. Wood Stork.
Indigo Snake. Bonneted Bat, Fox Squirrel, Deer and gopher tortoise among others. 20.000 acres
primary zone will be destroyed, creating 200 miles of new and expanded roadway, costing $7.8
Billion which will be taxpayer obligation, 10.008 homes, 300.000 additional residents converting
natural-rural lands into urban area equivalent to size of Washington, DC. The roads have not been
addressed by the US Fish and Wildlife Services that will destroy existing homes and uniqueness of
Rural Naples. In the proposed HCP configuration other projectwill likely take place in panther
habitat. The HOP will sever and fragment Camp Keais Strand and Summerlin Swamp panther
corridors. creating more encounters with homeowners, livestock and pets as they seek food.
1)) /
��
.
/2)1)1 (
7
:,.,*..i. r-
I *."* ia
, ' * ›
.-
t` x
is ` *' _ "ate ,
*V
�$ W Z _ t 414.40#4. ct
j ti "�cr
a.• -.'f-a,
il F`� �'_' •pM • w[. w4'"
'tea .,
_ ... §. w-.";-.---:',/,'-'qtr. _
4 ,,,,,, , ...- - ._;..1,11: .....:;,:' ,"= I
p
11
a ' < - d, '
3; o �" � *�''` 3�g � ,fit
}
-,N'-,,- t':, -,.."V,e- : , 1- . ,,. ',. . ..-_--,_-.4:4 -
,._. _-,.. ::;,,,,,,,3
c --'13'.-::-....--;,:43?!
,� VP*������ �i,s _ N
§ � 3r s ,,. }
gg
. 4:- ; ---;',- , ,.- g., -,--,,,st,ss,t ,.- '--t,'". ,,ig ';'' - -, 011- ittgr,,--,gi-J-g-----tC4-T.*-,-!= ., i
1,._0:, n„.,,,,,,,...,..-„, . .. i, .., ,/.**.t,f. „,..i.,-----.•-,,-''f, ,,-„,•;:-•:,-..,4,,,..i.,,,,,,x.,7,-..„,.,.,,,,,•:„. i-:.
1 u
I
,,T...,;(1)
{
,,.., _,_..„
,„,,,,,i ,, , ,,,,i„:„.,:„:„.if.,„.„, „. ..„ .,,,-. ,_ 1 firr- ,7-L,-;
t 3= ct
oli , „ . , .1,„,• ,_„„..,„,,,,,,,, . ...,.. r.,rr,...„,.. , ,.....,
jp,,,. , ctfa;
.4:
k y 4e { fi >.
s 444 Z. _
a e. t.. •
s
c
23 z
› 7
CDCI) m
> 0 73 2 m (1:2
Z 0 -I
-< r-- CD CD
r- Cl) • - CD
-< 6 FFi a> ..`,\ CD =
-0 0 co 33 = \ '. ia..,
CI.
ts: a sii‹..) co-) -=. \.-\ ._,) co
; SI)
E >
C) 2 c co
- 0 z -- --,-r,•-, \) K e-Y-
-4 c) > _.< CD .
-C7 S 0 m 0 e-t- , CD
--__
— < A' 5
cpm
2f. .
0 ---, Ff) M .
0 rnz 0 " .. m
o
g cc(n) 0 —I
73 ---i 0 c0
1-- -0 2 c..) „ , ,-.., C\•,,,
1T1
M ...j -i -I -72_ C) \,,
-I Cr) ril_., = pc,C- k \\
0 -II -1 z op
0 C,,,1 co 0 > ,: 1
. ."--
=4 m > r-- rn
o -c--5 > ,
— 73 z •I.J\ ----n en
z --x: -11 ED -=1 D 2 cri
2 0 > m
70om
-4 C) - -
i -1 C)
•
,_.
_F..,\
-4 0 0 -ii m > -73 '' (CIA - 11;
C J.
> --I ;17 ,-.., 0 0 C) 0
rn i , 1/4..../ > Cr-) -, • •
m -11 71 -‹ g2; --'-') \J r\''
r...1
0 22. X c z z r•,) P•.' ('•
-0 el
-6 —
rn -n -i '• ' M C::' , \0
--ri 11 x 7z] 0 . CI
-4 jo . rn rrcl) c) c' ')) r---\, • \\
0 cSj LO 0 0c
-n ..,:. E -4 •20 -71 r;s, -e,'s: \c
Ns4,
=
p > cp
- -.=-1
m 0 - m
z -0 -H 0
> -"-- c---
F--7
.N.,,,...) ..."'"..'...',„..t
I CO CI)-ID m 1111 -.7 _i (D
M
1 3 > M -4 Ill
0
Fr) ?c: m -(1-5 >-4 ,-
> cilr311 1-73 > Zrr„ ---,....
, --,
to _i 0) 0 . i, 1 •,-1-, • Ci:,.;--
Ur-
rn 0 --:*:_r.: 0 cn b .
"ID r- - 70 "" oj `,.. ,-,
-ij m -) ,.... -;0 cn , v
'--.
........ > Ill m
17.7 < z (1) G) c-7)
Li 1C) (i)
-H >
C) E (7) 0 m
r- mm z 3) > ..,,
r-
> o ---7-- -
I1 C > _< 7-A CO C..,.,
r• L.- C:) ---1
-< 77- m = a: 0 NI \
a) ill m33 ,
E7) (-)
'\1\
a: m Z ; ,
C,'5 >
73 -IC)
0 2 \
IL s\ o
rn z
\'',
\\ ,
z
, co "S
a
to CD
...< (p o =
0 0 = la)
c..s. .....- r...-
* CD Ow
03 C
E > co
-,--1 c-) i'" > t.• cc. ' ma*
02: 0 m
r- rn z7, r--
— — r•-• c-)- 1-- Cr.
0c -n0
--.
m : -- OC)7--
co -- -- ,
C) 2 E5
m ,g PR S. - - Z
n m
--
=g, cn 0
--1. z Z _-1. '
1
"V —I 0 M G> 0)
Al
, , 0
,--• - m m 0 2. z
-n r- C) M -66 > 2
0 , 1
_....i _A z
3:1
=I rn :„.. 0
0 z.--.5 > ..-.... 1:..1- ES (7 n
z
25 m z = -‹ 2
(%
C) C --4 2 &I
--1 = o 9-,rnx ,4,--',
m F1 -A 2g
4 0 t, _ r ,
3> ----4 '-75 7,
--1 m ..„.
"
--
,T1 ---1----
---i 0 -0 c) m z 0
0 2j (= M 0 To
CD ......$0
...S. 0 no r- -- , =
TH-1 Cp K XJ 0 F, 0 cs.4 N,..."4,,:' _.,-.._ ,,,,,,,,,,a1
00 f--1 > ,....., ) " i ( ->„„, _
m -n -1 e ,,,,•-' - (4?,,, Cs
r. 0) 0 1/4-i cp p') -7...,„:,
'--„,
m in F,.„,,,1 > tx, , t.4.4
--,-. ---1 17,,
In -n ,..". _. a \ 0'
m = ---4 m , — 0
0co z m (-,' rs-1
--4
....1 5 cr)
> EZ a, 'a '14C"r\
= -.A c) tr.., 70 - °' ,,, ,',,,)
m 5 ,,,,- ---- 0 - ..
--- Z -.
, -FA i ..:z.„
0 -... .5
> *- m 2. c,'\
F-- 2: -,... c --I r\.) r.., -
.21#'*-- --I 2. --•
1 03 0) '''''''' M > –4 ='-' t e,
M M m (I) 0 N.,' CD ; i, ' \
0 > rn ....1 > 0 sp,.. :-", ,
-ri rN
rn x Fri C) rn hmi
1..\t,
> .,,
> mo 3zi i?Pri cc-,,l3 0 t ,
Cn _.1 w C: 2 c:
M 0 .`,: tz) 0 G) 55, ''' r' °
13 r-- -1- ;Ct 7:3 ---1 '65 , - N
m ,-'0 lc -I '1/4, ,
— m m
Z -‹ . . 00 0 rn ,
- „
-1 - 0 CO M 5 i N::"---
1"-- m Z 73 0 I
M 7) -.;.-- r. ,1, r- rt.-- "*""-t,
1
> 0 ..< Pi -91
20 ri > rr\r\
— ° ---4 a)
1— c: < c) _< ,
-4( K. m a:6
'
JI z _,
---1
rt\r-
-cii 4,7)
2 =
0
t.
>
:7•13 ,..
„,--
7
„,„ z
CD DJ CD
-t; 3
,
CO CD = I
(1) — to CD
-.< (t) ID =
-0 0 :73 ID
CO :I ',,,'
CO i a)
5 > cn
..." ,
> " -DCD .'
, .4m.
D-4-
-0 = 0 M F"--- P = % 2
cD
r- niKr- o- r-- =
> 70 - 0 no m 0
M z :4 0 0 !Li
cn -I Z,-o Z
x 0 •• 'D.,.
0_ 2 FT) 1,7:1,, cn edam c i
vs,D-
c...) ,rcTilz c,,, ornz ''',,,, ', 0
cn 0 -i z ,..Z., :::-<1 ,. ,, 1
-13 -I
t•--
M 1--cri 2 7;,1
cn 0 73 N s ,
7D --i ••••4 .., , - 0
-4 CD ,rn X. x 6 -2- \
0 --, — z rn
30
0 (.,4 --4 M -‹ z 7, r. 0
r-- 00 ........,
g 7--1 m g 0 N)
> CD
----1 0 0 .9-' 0... m
-, M r
0i-1,/ » 0...
in :-.,u - co (73 70 C2.
-ri
0— X < cn
.. =.
--i m t, MOM.
c:c1 1-T, cn ';cli -1 rfi z 0 r-ii,
mm -‹ - 3 I- m 3
.„„„,,_
0 .3.9 x c rn 0 cz) Pc, 2
---I C0 :5::- X 0 c:
= 0 0 0 > 2
\ - ....I
m m - 0
1-, co 5 1/4..., 0/ G.) 2
ni
—4 r) 2 m m --i, m
0
rt -Ic6-1
--4 0
= 14",
m 5 .,'‘-•-,-- c,,,,,, 0 7-1 > ,
z ...-, —
a ..„-- f.. a - C)- 0 -
z
hi 2
pm Ci) ss,
r-
CD -'• 0
'.5.
m m in m s......
cn
Xi) _HU) 0 0 3777* C.:4
In o '. 0 00 -,--;-; fl -,z,
--,-
2:1 rn rn w —I
.,z < Z Csn
-I ni 0 Cn rn 0 -1
--4 > .7) > >
r"*„.., m m Z 0 r-
> 0 -‹ m -ri rio-
2o F.--.. > Z 0 „,
03
m z _eeei
-e-el --ei Ace.
cr) 0 -‹
0 >
Xi Ns,
Cv,ks-t's ...D'
7
ct, w 0
..0 = >309:Tml< 7: g CI CC2CD7:
CD
'"'r......t
''t =
— (.0
r- to
0
13 0 ao 23 F.-6-
c co 0 — .„ 0.
(711;) — o z -..0
---1 0
—I 0 > 0.4.-
=4 ° ttr•
. . ,
,...„-..,'
. .
,
-•..1-,. ‘&
C) ,..../ :5
op I., =. --1 .7-
= Z (1) \ •:' • .
n1 al
C Z =4
C) 2' "CiS m — 0
M , 0
0 z c1 2,-, m
g &50 —4 F-, z • \
-o
1— m x ._,4 _.-..-_- .r,,, '• „, • -..„
-4 (j) 7.,1 = ,0 -
M C,,,), 6- 7) OJJ'
a -2- ni M c:..5-° r,- '-.... ---,:' •
-n —
> 0 M -A
0 -0 e-.---i ' Z CD
' I >
g 7-4 m g > rILI. MI I
0 "e5 > -,,,,— ?-2);
z -n ......
z a a > m
Li
ED C
-- '
ii 0 -4
Ti 7j0 -flo Ti mow->0 20: -V:
= 0 .z..
0 w
0
> ----..r!
rn rii 0
mi ---,
r- 2z3 rm
-r1 -an -< T (•(//?)
r. E
--.40 -o 0 ,--; 2 m
0 :). C L- 0 -4
.ki ...
:. ...i
m
= CD a 0 co
M -Tr --I
r., w 0 %.1 z CO j› ,• --'mC3
rn 0 0 z
M r-- --- > 0 4 • 0
-II -71 z 7:1 20 . ,
— ni c3 Na pi,
--4 10 -cl rri 0 .. • .
= . ,
oe)) F) z 0
_
-n -e
g,., —i 2.) 0 '1,-). , . • '----
= -.1 o33 r, , • ' , _
ril b
z _, „ ---i c) •.,,, — , ' -
.,,,.
rn 33 0
,IP --1 m
Ci) r-
, p rn 0
C.0 rri m __.1
m -0 ," z ....._ T ....,
-0 7p. 7,-1> —4 -A D, -
r- w 0
rn m o >
rcr:1)
1u) ....i w, 0
1111 0 0 0? C)
IT) 71 - Erlj
3,:'
m 12R -‹
z < cn 0-) Fii
_..4 m o CO
--i > --4 er)
C) =E 0 0 1.11 17,E
I-- nm z
M 7:1 21--
>
.< =.1 00
-.< ?... ni = L0
, .
. .
.„,„..
• -
M m 70
(/) 0 r-
,,,. •
23 '164 22
-A 0