Loading...
Backup Documents 06/22/2010 Item #10ARAINER OLBRICH 9848 LUNA CIRCLE C -103 NAPLES, FLORIDA 34109 June 22, 2010 Collier County Board of Commissioners Mrs. Donna Fiala and Messrs. Halas, Coletta, Henning, Coyle Dear Members of the Board: � c" ve CZ � My name is Rainer Olbrich. I live at 9848 Luna Circle in North Naples and am a longtime resident of Collier County, a retiree and a regular beach goer (at least twice, sometimes more each week. I do not speak for any group, but only for myself. I believe the issue before you today is a "NO BRAINER". We all know that the public beach facilities near the Ritz Carleton Hotel are inadequate and must be improved. The proposed plans developed by the County's Staff are a well - thought out, professional presentation and an appropriate use of Tourist Tax Funds - which I believe totaled last year around 12 -13 million dollars. Regrettably, there have been some within our community who have tried to "POLFIUE" this issue through Letters to the Editor and other communications, even calling for a delay in Board action UNTIL the replacement of Mr. Halas has been duly elected. Many of these concerns appear to be of the "NOT IN MY BACK YARD" variety, some with innuendos - some emotionally charged. These voices are well - heeled and well- connected, and include the Ritz Carleton Hotel and the Pelican Bay Foundation, both neighbors and other residents in close proximity to the proposed facilities. There has been however, broad -based support within the County for these desperately needed improvements of Public Beach Facilities, as witnessed by an outpouring of support at various public gatherings like the one held in April 15th at the Village Walk Country Club, attended by nearly 80 representatives from various organizations across the county. Further, the Naples Daily News, in its Editorial of April Ie, copy attached herewith, added its unequivocal support to the proposed improvements. Finally, I commend other community activists including Mary Lou Smart and her Keep Our Beaches Open (KOBO) Group for their continued commitment in getting the whole story out to the entire community. Dear Board, I urge you to act now on behalf of the community. We all know most of the principal stake holders and most avid beach goers - our tourists and snow birds - have already left us this year. Visit one of our fine beaches and you will agree that these improved facilities are needed and that they will indeed enhance the enjoyment of life here. Thank you! Cordial Rain r J. Oltlrich Attachment: Naples Daily News Editorial of April 14. 2010 Editorial: Collier County ... proposed beach pavilion would make good bett... Page 1 of 1 mpk?s mws. om Read Mwe at naplesnows Corn Editorial: Collier County ... proposed beach pavilion would make good better Staff Reports Wednesday, April 14, 2010 One of Collier County's most popular public beach parks, at Vanderbilt Beach, now features two public restrooms in a rustic, worn sort of hut. Close by is a makeshift stand on the beach for renting umbrellas and chairs and selling cold drinks. Collier County government proposes a modest update of those services — more restrooms, hot dogs and an observation deck for beachgoers in wheelchairs, for example — and we have a debate. Some Vanderbilt neighbors, including a contingent from Pelican Bay, and the Ritz - Carlton, Naples, say the county's plans are too grand. Others, including beachgoers from Naples Park, across Vanderbilt Beach Road from Pelican Bay, are saying the improvements would be welcome. We tend to agree with them. This new and improved beach- services pod would not attract more beachgoers; it would better serve the ones already there. We also believe there would be plenty of business left for private concessionaires now selling food and drinks a block or so from the beach. Families who come with children who get hungry do not consider a trek to those shops to be convenient. Adequate facilities help make a trip to the beach more pleasant for residents and tourists alike. A pier at Vanderbilt Beach was deemed too much. Nicer restrooms and a snack bar for the public seem to be a better fit. When the county meets in an effort to get the two sides together, there ought to be plenty of opportunities to do the right thing for public service- 0 2010 Scripps Newspaper Group — Online http:// www .naplesnews.com /news/2010 /apr/ 14 /proposed- beach - pavilion -wo... 6/21/2010 "There may be some debris along the boardwalk leading to Clam Pass ParK" Gary McAlpin on March 27th at Pelican Bay Foundation Meeting. The following quantities of "debris" were observed that same afternoon TYPE OF DEBRIS NORTH OF SOUTH OF TOTAL BOARDWALK BOARDWALK GLASS BOTTLES 26 25 51 PLASTIC BOTTLES 30 38 68 CANS (1) 76 75 151 CUPS (2) 5 9 14 PLASTIC CUPS 36 69 105 PLASTIC (3) 44 52 96 TENNIS BALLS 3 1 4 BALLS 1 3 4 FOOTBALLS 4 1 5 SHOES 3 2 5 RAGSITOWELS 1 5 6 GOLF BALL 1 1 BIG CANVASS 1 1 TOTALS 229 282 511 (1) INCLUDES BEER, SODA, SPRAY, ETC (2) CUPS REFERS TO PAPER OR FOAM (3) PLASTIC REFERS TO PLASTIC BAGS, SPOONS, PAPER BAGS, PIECES OF PLASTIC, ETC NOT INCLUDED ARE A WIDE VARIETY OF SMALL ITEMS C 2 W to 2 7 z 2 W H a ❑ Z W O 21 G 2 w Q ❑ Z w a G J W J U zI z 2- CL w Q J CL Q W 2 0 z w m F W m W 2 F O H w a m O 0 ❑ Q O LM W 2 Z 0 W 2 F LL O LL w J W J Q F- W 2 r z O O U- 0 w r W J IL m O U W Q J CL y W O W U) V) LU ix ❑ ❑ Q a W O Z v F- w IL 6 Z Z w U) W � a ZLLI QJ LL ❑ U) < w U) 0 a_ L m Q �wZ > S F F � a Qom C7 Y F Z CL < r� Q mU2 Q O = F F - z z x � Q ~ Z W ono Z w Cl) 7 U) C 0 w z w w Cn a�0� m O Z cC W O w m�Z J :D Q F- U) O ZO Cl) g m z_ p U J 0 S J O O Q ❑ o J w = o Cm� w F- W O Z LU (n Q w a_ N w r ❑ � o ❑ n Q ❑ O - S zoo w U U L w Z ly z °° ❑ J Q U) OoLli z z � D ' O U z Q W O J J m O z x K Q 2 U W 2 J Z O U) N W K ❑ Q O H w a ❑ Z a CO z Z w O U 0 0 K O LL U) w r z Z Cl) W LLI K x F O F- W F J w Q O r � � % } 2 \ 2 \ � _\ $ � o I ƒ \ LLI -j ) w \ \ ai j � ) § §, \ } 2 ( \ \ m k 7 LL � 7 / 6 LU \ \ ]< I / § E \ LU \ \ CL k z »/ o \i\ / §» 2 PI § /}\ & \\/ \ &`« ` /J6 § } \§ \ }9\ / /(\ ¥ LLI Cl) 0 LL z u[± \ \7I \\\ \ T- (1) ° »2= § \(� 7 / \\ ) /0 w e2\ \ \/L j/r Cl) :y\ _ /»± $ w \\ \ 2 G Lu ( g 3 \g S j 0 Cl) } e « Z :D \ § \ {\ �D ED W \ \/ PIN y V Q \` O O w W fll Z 2 W r ❑ z w 0 ao w VC J Q EF ti N V 2 W t- ❑ Z W (i ao J W J U z a w a w J a S w X z Z W fL U W m 0) W S r O r a w CL 2 O w ❑ a O m W S I-- z U) a 0 W S r LL O LL r w W J %T- ER W J r w x r Z O K O LL ❑ W W J a 2 O U w J a J s wZ w CT, = M r O LLI N N N S ❑ Q 0 N L! J C s W a Z M W H 09 S W z 0 H W CL QJ LL < c(j) O W a W m a F- W Z J U O Q V Q H z K } j Q mU 2 Q o = F z G F W z ZWo �mm � O Z W w � � W<n� 0 W [0 w O W m c z J U � Q cn O p (D U U � a m D _> O U 0 0 O O a ❑ o J Q Q LL Fob CO W or M W CW1 Z � � Q �t Wa N a, W N ❑ � O Z Or U U W z o K F z 2 ❑z � J Q K ~ CO pow > z (9 z z � co O w U Z a w W ° O w J J m W O Z 2 w U -- i- W x J Z O y N LLI w in ❑ Q O H w Q ❑ Z a N r Z W 0 O V O r K O LL U) w r z Z W w K S O F- W r J w Q P r r w W m D Z 2 w r a z w �Q }J v ,-J r, W J r F- ui w ❑ z w 0 M J ¢ W J U r Z a W ¢ J a o .., a w S ..,,a z w m U W m 7 W O r IL O 0 a 1 M w S r z N a 0 W S V.- LL O r W LU w J a r w S r Z O O LL ❑ w W J IL 2 O U w a J CL w R' ❑ ❑ ao W r u w --\ W 1 z w a Z a Qu LL Q J W m Q Q twZ a F>-- � J Z 0 0 t U a r of H Z } J Q co C) a o = F } r- F- ¢ F—W Z z No w z Z ° J � W Df ui ow O W m N Z J Cl) � Q 00 cn U a } Z = p U J LL CC J O O Q ° O J Q o w Foy Nm W LLI F F- w a z � U) a w a N Be W . C 0 W O O W Z °W d' F- O Z 2H °Z r J Q W K H W a ooui U z - ? z � mg O w U z ° a w W °o I Jm J Q) LLI W U =� W S J Z O N N K Q O F- w Q ❑ Z Q zZ W O U K O r K O LL w I.- z w uj S F" O F ❑ W r_ J w Q 0 O <c 4 § § \ \ 0 \ / & I � § � a n'T > / § 0 El B � a ( § ) 0 { 0 0 k \ \ § § LLI \ { ( \ LLI LLI \ k C� � � « i § R 1� I } 2/ o (u\ ¥ //c f 00 o g }t F- >- * (\/ k § ®G © )(6 § )UJ/ \ \cn CO 0 22g R ` \ \\ § 2 K m/b « o \5J co \ \\ 0 of Q con § 00 / cr < 0 ƒ }\ � 2 e =g e ( +z ) G/ \ \�IL E ` \\\ F- . \\ § 2 )S@ r \ \/ CL 3\/ \ DCO� ( \5< § \»5 ) \ \/ .5s, c § ) k § § § uj { \ 0 Lo I -i k \ § [ k � \ , ( ; E � 0 \ \ \ z \ \ 0 § \ z § E § \ \ CL C � S § 8 § \� % % � 22 @j� } \/\ o o& \ \\ / fu\ ) \\j o & -G 2 )E$ ƒ }LU \ F3 o . }2� L6 \ w \/d 2 �0w \ § \>[ 2 })\ ■ U) < \ {2} � 0C) § /\0 ƒ }`° a Ime \ \/f )7/ Cl) } §/ u \ \\ / k \\ \ w g /Sy e < S § \g \\\ \ 5�k \ § W < \3 § % IL \ \\ W . &/ ®6 a /§ i %5/ \ \/\ ) z op} o m /tee 2 § e z w § ° m\/ >i 2 % />6 3 ! ` 2`G 2 6 / } / \\ k § E v \ g`a k 0 2 \[« o ® 2 g §2 § 2 ) })§ 2 L z > \ \/ƒ : 0 $ 2 \/{ ! q e ,00 § \ \\ � 2`^ § U ° CO (\ >- LU; j 2 \ )\j § /\\ k `� : } § C +z ) s `~ LU 3 w \[± G _y \3 z &±G f § - . \ \ \ 2 2 z 0Lu § § < § } ) \ \ \ § p ZED § . ti 0 & \ § \ }E / @ _ \ \ \ \ / 2} k ui G/\ eel \ \\ \ OD � b f77 \ } % \\j 3 ` § 2 u \ z LU \ \( k oL o ) I L %u e Lti @ } Lu U5 w 0w \ �(\ 7 uf ± « ! ~ § ca -j r % UJ \)Z E 7 moo 2 U) j - 2 /g7 Q� , 2 2: § 00 \ C) . § k \\ L . & a \ 0\ . a . g \ w %/§ s 2 j2( R 3 © r G \%± u » a / \6 } z \ 92@ \ L �0w 0 LL ` LLI ui z G Q p a z \ u . CL 00w / k ^\ ® `z) z ■ ° ` » 0 r \ \ B \ }y z .. 2 §§\ \ z ) LLI C) 1 FJ w w m 3 Z W r a z Z w O 20 J a J U z a w a J a r� 2 w r a z Z W a 2 6 a i O Z W m uj U m D N W r O �. It 0 O Oa, 0 a O m r z 0) LU a p N N r o O Q ui r LL J J m a r w S r Z O 0 O LL In W W J IL 0 O r U W J 4. W Q Z w s r A i ul w Z 0 r W IL QJ LL U) � W ¢ J Lu O a w m ¢ twZ J_ U O ¢ ¢ F- � z K i J ¢ m U o = � z F- F- ¢ - W z � Z W O CO U u M CD w Z Z LLJ U) owm w o w m �) z J U ¢�F (n O p cn U g a >z= m n p U LL K � O O H oe O ¢ ¢ LL T-o� m W W F- W d O W Z K N ¢ C a N w K W r ) WO O w C) � of F- Z O Q J ¢ ~ W 0 Z C7 z�z z 5m� O w U z cr in w w o O w ::i J m IL J U W W O z 2 2 U�-,F- W H J Z O N N LU 0 Q O H w Q z Q N r z w 2 rt O U 0 O r O LL N w r z Z_ Cl) W w w x r O D w r J W a' Q 0 O It W m Z 2 W r J rt � JV r� 2 W a ❑ Z w a ao J w J U r Z a w w J CL ❑ m a w x z z Mu m U W m U) W S r O r R' O w IL 2 O K O m w x r z N ¢ a w x r LL O r w w J J m r w x r z O S O LL ❑ w r w J EL E O U W J CL J U W r \_ O w ❑ ❑ a f� L3J '+J rZ t W a Z Ul W Z O P w CL Z z w N LU w a w QJ LL K o W n a W m ¢ F- W Z > x Qom C7 Y r Z_ Q Y g WJ Q m U 5i o = F-- r�� O Q F W �a�o Z W M U F,- M Q U 0 W Z Z Of o x Lij � :D m O Z K W O W m Z;5 z J U) � co O O O U 2 a ED : _ co 00 J LL O 0 J O Q ❑ = o �m� W K F W O U' :2 d Z F- W � Q V W a N W CD ❑ ❑ O Q CO O Z O O W O ZLU ❑W d H z � ❑z J Q Of H U) O O LU Z F- Z Zm� O U Z of a w O J J m 0 z 7 Lu U F- d x U W x r J Z O N w W ❑ Q O H w Q ❑ Z Q m r Z W O U K 7 O r O LL U) w r z Z_ Cl) W w R' S O F- ❑ W I.- J w a w W m 7 Z 2 w F- a Z w O a J a W J U z z_ a ar � � � r 2 W a Z w 0 :10 2 a W 2 Z tv FU \ m w W LLI w O O IL O` it i Of a ,.J m W J S z� � y O ❑ a LL ui i M r w x r z O O ? LL ❑ W F- LU J IL O U w a J IL a Z i' W S F el U ii w Z 0 F wW a zZ F z w w w IL IL w _. 2 J LL O LU U) OW a W m ¢ �wZ F Q Qow U Y F Z � � } W Q m U 2i O Q = F z a: U) z x < Q ~w z � Zoo Z W M (7 M Q T O W z w p W [n J w w W m w O w m Z J V :D g n ° Z co U g U—) a m : _ CD 0U� J LL 0 J O O Q p O J F- 01 m V w F-- w Z U) Q w a CV K W r 00 oaa z O o W U cl W z w Z 2 z Q J Q CC co QO 0 M z >- � z j m O U z cc w o O J J m O z = K Q x U W 2 F- J z O y U) w x ❑ ❑ a O H w a ❑ Q, N z Z w O U z O O LL U) w H z Z_ M_ W w x O H ❑ w F J w w a D O i m W m z 2 W H z z W O 0 r 2 W F z z W O E+ J W J U z z K CL. W Q W J IL S W S U z w m (i W mm 3 N W 2 H O H CL CL 2 O K O 4 O m W S z N ¢ 0 W 2 F- LL O H LL W J W J ¢ w z O O LL 0 w F- W J (L E O U W J a K w x F- A U) N LLI D 2 S W z O F W IL 0 z F z w U) �j W 0. ¢ a Z w QJ LL. UJ cn OW a W m Q W z = � J Q 0 F CD x ! J Q mU2 a 0 =F- }AU) Z I < z ~ W (9 Q� O Z W M C M (-D w z w w cn Q� a Oo OLL z w O w m z J � � cn O p cn U a m � _ OU Zi J LL LL' J O O Q D O J Q Q LL CO V W F W d Z Z;) a LL N W row .<0 Q Z O O LLI F— U Lu z � z 2 zz J Q F CO 00LLI Z Z �m� O U Z m W O J J m J U w U Q x U w x H J z O N w K O O a O F- w Q z z a U) F Z W 0 O U d' O LL N W H z z v w W O' x F- O F- O W r J w a' a } s l 2 W zZ w O zo _w I� Q r— W 2 Z w IO C. W m D U) W 2 w Z J IL L 0 o u ❑ d' O w W 2 r Q 0 W 2 r LL O r LL w J a r w 2 r j Z 0 O LL ❑ W r w J a 0 0 U W a N W ❑ O w 2 r u W a Z a W z 0 r F w a Z z z w N w (L w 7I Q LL oU) < o w � a w pp a w Z = � J Q F- Z K g > LLI a co CO U O = F r U) Z x < ~ W Z !j ly O Z w Cl) 0 � Cl) CD W Z w W o w cn af �m ow z w O w ED F Z co O z0 wU g U) m7= 0U� J w K J O O Q p O Q Q LL F M Q- W = z r w 0 C7 2 ui Q Z U a a N w W oaaf Zoo LU U C) LJJ Z L H Z � Z o a Q co U O w -mn O U Z W O J J m Jo z w K Q 2 U w 2 H J z O ui N ❑ a O H w K a z a N r Z w O U D O O LL U) w r z z_ Cl) w LLJ ❑ W r J w It a 0 0 l J v W m 7 Z ui ui ,`) Q ❑ Z r W � (7 va J U --� z r K a w U) J a _ s l 2 W zZ w O zo _w I� Q r— W 2 Z w IO C. W m D U) W 2 w Z J IL L 0 o u ❑ d' O w W 2 r Q 0 W 2 r LL O r LL w J a r w 2 r j Z 0 O LL ❑ W r w J a 0 0 U W a N W ❑ O w 2 r u W a Z a W z 0 r F w a Z z z w N w (L w 7I Q LL oU) < o w � a w pp a w Z = � J Q F- Z K g > LLI a co CO U O = F r U) Z x < ~ W Z !j ly O Z w Cl) 0 � Cl) CD W Z w W o w cn af �m ow z w O w ED F Z co O z0 wU g U) m7= 0U� J w K J O O Q p O Q Q LL F M Q- W = z r w 0 C7 2 ui Q Z U a a N w W oaaf Zoo LU U C) LJJ Z L H Z � Z o a Q co U O w -mn O U Z W O J J m Jo z w K Q 2 U w 2 H J z O ui N ❑ a O H w K a z a N r Z w O U D O O LL U) w r z z_ Cl) w LLJ ❑ W r J w It a 0 0 hil w W m Z 2 w F- a 0 z W 0 2 } J x a W J U z Z x a W ¢ J a W J F_ F- LU w F- 0 Z w 0 El a W 2 z Z w ED F- U W w x 0 w a 2 O 0 R' m W 2 z N Q 0 W x F LL O LL W J W J m FQ- w x F Z O 2 d' O LL 0 w r W J M 2 O U w a J IL V y w W K D El W Z W S A uj W Z O F- F- W IL 0 z p z w W w w IL w QJ LL D � < O W O a W m Q W Z > 2 � � J Q CD Y } J Q mU Q =F zF-co Z = < a ~w ��o Z W CO -U � M a w z w J_ W (n K � O m O O LIJ w m Z X O z0 U) U a m D _ O U Zi J LL if J O O F¢- C) O Q Q LL = O FCo d LLj W �F-w O W Z K Q a N K W a D D O D(l) Q O - K Z O O LLI F- U Z DW d LU z :5 z p J Q K F- U) °O F- ui Z F- F z 7 m O D U z < w ° 0 J J m JO Z W L) Q U W x F- J Z O U) V) uj 0 0 a O F- w a O Z a N z Z W 0 0 U K 0 } R' O LL U) w F- z Z_ Cl) W ul R' x H O F- 0 W F- J W a 0 O } O w W [D z 2 W r ❑ Z W a • 2 W a ❑ Z w CD al J a w J U z z a w a W J a w 2 z z w m r W C N w 2 r 0 w a 2 O Q O m w 2 r z 0 W 2 r LL O r LL w J J m r w 2 r z O O LL w w J (L 2 O U W J IL N N R' O ❑ 2 W a Z K W 2 r U �� K w z O p W IL Q) z z w N w IL IL w Qu p � < Q w J W m Q w Z > I QQ OM C Y F Z } J Q CD U 2 LLI a } H i- Q F W 9 K O Z w CO � M w z Z w ( p 00 o Lj O w m 0 Z O O O U) C) F- a mom= 0 J LL 0 J O O Q p O J Q Q LL U) w w W (w'1 Z Cl) Q w 0- N a, w r p U) .<0 o Z O O w w z o z oz O J Q K F- (n p O w z �- z z D m O U Z � a W D O J J m JO Z w U Q 2 U W 2 r J z O N N w ❑ O a O F- Ix a ❑ a z Z w O U a n O r LL' O LL N w r z Z_ M_ W w a' 2 F- 0 F- ❑ w r J W a O IZZI- J m W m Z V E LU S� F- �a O Q 2 w t- Q z Z w O 4 J w w J U z z 2 a W Q W J a w x z z uw m U W m N W 2 F- O F K w IL 2 O 0 R' O m w 2 z y 0 W x LL O F- LL W J J a w 2 r z O O LL 0 w w J IL 2 O U W Q J IL 3 O N LLI D 1 J� Lq 3 0 NJ J W Q Z iY W 2 H Al it w z O p W IL 6 Z F- z W ui ui IL w T QL p < Cf) w O O a [o ¢ w_ Z > J Q P F- z w g Y J ¢ m U 2i F- F- } F- ¢ - W Z Z LLil O CO U � Q w z w w (0 0 w m O O w CO Z T 2i J � � O O 0 U) C) 2 In D 0U� J 0 0 J O O ¢ p O J = o F- m� w p 02 O z F- �C/)Q w LL N w W Fn no 000 Z 0 0 w w z Lu of - z Z Z J ¢ K F- cn p p w Z F- �m z g O U z W O J J m UH F- ci x U w X F- J z O N N W LL' D Q O F- w Q z Q zZ w O U m O LL 0) w z Z M.r w w w x F- O w w f- J W K Q D O } � � § ) § § 0 ao � j § \ � o � c w § IL \� C A k § c El .� r w ; �! k� < g � c b \ � m ( 2 2 * (� § a 3 / y z U) / & % § ( k\ z 7v 2 § k ao � ¢ Q z [ a k § § LLI 9 \2 \�\ //a ) ep} w 0 ze = j// z /y{ o } §j ) \W§ \ 6 CD / g)z ° \ \id 2 m {3 « \e< z \C\ k 0 \`J § 0C) / /\\ ƒ /0. a & ) )/ z s LLI LLI Cl) \\) } \ \\ § z z -1 j\\ \ »®S « 2// 7 \ (\ M §2 \ \/