Loading...
CEB Backup Documents 10/26/2018 Code Enforcement Board Backup October 26 , 2018 Code Enforcement Board Hearing AGENDA Board of County Commission Chambers Collier County Government Center 3299 Tamiami Trail East, 3rd Floor Naples, FL 34112 October 26, 2018 9:00 AM Robert Kaufman, Chair Gerald Lefebvre, Vice-Chair Kathleen Elrod, Member Ronald Doino, Member Robert Ashton, Member Sue Curley, Member Herminio Ortega, Member Vacant, Alternate Ryan White, Alternate Notice: Respondents may be limited to twenty (20) minutes for case presentation unless additional time is granted by the Board. Persons wishing to speak on any agenda item will receive up to five (5) minutes unless the time is adjusted by the Chairman. All parties participating in the public hearing are asked to observe Roberts Rules of Order and speak one at a time so that the court reporter can record all statements being made. Any person who decides to appeal a decision of this Board will need a record of the proceedings pertaining thereto, and therefore may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceeding s is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. Neither Collier County nor the Code Enforcement Board shall be responsible for providing this record. I. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE II. ROLL CALL III. APPROVAL OF MINUTES 3.1. September 27, 2018 Code Enforcement Board Minutes IV. APPROVAL OF AGENDA V. PUBLIC HEARINGS/MOTIONS A. MOTIONS MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME B. STIPULATIONS C. HEARINGS 1. CASE NO: CESD20180005203 OWNER: Deep Lake Ops LLC OFFICER: Jeff Letourneau VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code, 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(e) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(a). Renovations of, but not limited to, window, exterior doors, air conditioning unit (HVAC), new heating and cooling duct work, toilets, showers, hot water heater, kitchen area with sinks and appliances, sheet rock, metal studs, electric rough-in with boxes, master breaker panel, roof repairs, non-fire rated doors, French doors, all without first obtaining the required Collier County Permits and approvals. FOLIO NO: 00982880005 VIOLATION 20201 State Road 29, Naples, FL ADDRESS: 2. CASE NO: CEPM20180007088 OWNER: William E. Marten OFFICER: William Marchand VIOLATIONS: Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances, Chapter 22, Article VI, Section 22-231(12)(c). Roof and Fascia damage. FOLIO NO: 82940040009 VIOLATION 3880 Skyway Dr. Naples, FL ADDRESS: 3. CASE NO: CELU20180004729 OWNER: N-A Properties LLC OFFICER: Delicia Pulse VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code, 04-41, as amended, Section 2.02.03 and Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances, Chapter 130, Article III, Section 130-95. Several dumpsters on the ground on the property, miscellaneous items being stored outside consisting of but not limited to, metal, wood, tables, inoperable vehicles. FOLIO NO: 38169440007 VIOLATION 5630 Copper Leaf Ln., Naples, FL ADDRESS: 4. CASE NO: CESD20180008387 OWNER: Viviana Escobar OFFICER: Jonathan Musse VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code, 04-41, as amended, Section 10.02.06(B)(1)(a). Kitchen and Bathroom remodels without a valid Collier County permit. FOLIO NO: 30980200000 VIOLATION 700 Valley Stream Drive Unit 104, Naples, FL ADDRESS: 5. CASE NO: CEV20180008337 OWNER: Michael A. Dewitt OFFICER: Jon Hoagboon VIOLATIONS: Collier County Code Of Laws and Ordinances, Chapter 130, Article III, Section 130-95. Multiple unlicensed and inoperable vehicles stored on the property. FOLIO NO: 63405280006 VIOLATION 1072 Granada Blvd, Naples, FL ADDRESS: 6. CASE NO: CEAU20180009226 OWNER: Janice Masey OFFICER: Joseph Mucha VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 5.03.02(F)(5)(b). Chain link fence with barbed wire for residentially zoned property. FOLIO NO: 01134080005 VIOLATION 15985 Janes Scenic Drive, Copeland, FL ADDRESS: 7. CASE NO: CESD20180005375 OWNER: SA Equity Group LLC OFFICER: Steven Lopez-Silvero VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 10.02.06(B)(1)(a). Installed a new metal building, with electric, on improved occupied commercial property. FOLIO NO: 63864280003 VIOLATION 114 New Market Road East, Immokalee, FL ADDRESS: VI. OLD BUSINESS A. MOTION FOR REDUCTION/ABATEMENT OF FINES/LIENS B. MOTION FOR RE-HEARING C. MOTION FOR IMPOSITION OF FINES/LIENS 1. CASE NO: CEPM20160010841 OWNER: Community Association for Mill Run and Stonegate Collier County Inc OFFICER: Colleen Davidson VIOLATIONS: Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances, Chapter 22, Article VI, Section 22-228(1) and Section 22-240(2)(c). Failure to maintain lake/storm-water management retention by allowing silt and rocks to alter the slope and configuration of the lake. FOLIO NO: 29517500100 VIOLATION NO SITE ADDRESS ADDRESS: 2. CASE NO: CESD20150001965 OWNER: Fabricio Fernandez and Allison J Fernandez OFFICER: Boris Molina VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code, 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(e) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(a). Addition added to the existing structure without first obtaining the proper Collier County Building Permits. FOLIO NO: 36457240005 VIOLATION 5472 32nd Ave SW, Naples, FL ADDRESS: 3. CASE NO: CELU20180001084 OWNER: Judith Telfort OFFICER: Jonathan Musse VIOLATIONS: Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances. Chapter 54, Article VI, Section 54-179 and Collier County Land Development Code, 04-41, as amended, Section 1.04.01(A) and Section 2.02.03. Outside storage and/or litter consisting of but not limited to: furniture, bed frames, tables, chairs, cardboard boxes, foam, tarp, metals and plastic. FOLIO NO: 77214040009 VIOLATION 158 5th St, Naples, FL ADDRESS: 4. CASE NO: CELU20160010501 OWNER: Anthony V. Piccirilli EST OFFICER: Colleen Davidson VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 1.04.01(A), Section 2.02.03, Section 10.02.06(B)(1)(a) and Section 10.02.06(B)(1)(e)(i). Unpermitted alterations to the carport structure resulting in residential use of industrially zoned property. FOLIO NO: 249120000 VIOLATION 1891 Elsa St, Naples, FL ADDRESS: 5. CASE NO: CESD20170010243 OWNER: Jean Jorhel Decembre and Yoland Jean Domond OFFICER: Maria Rodriguez VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 10.02.06(B)(1)(a) and 2017 Florida Building Code, Sixth Edition, Chapter 4, Section 454.2.17. Unsecured swimming pool missing an approved pool barrier in the rear yard of improved occupied residential property. FOLIO NO: 35771000003 VIOLATION 4257 17th Ave SW, Naples, FL ADDRESS: 6. CASE NO: CELU20180001234 OWNER: Megan Gibson OFFICER: Michael Odom VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 2.02.03 and Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances, Chapter 54, Article VI, Section 54-181 and Chapter 130, Article III, Section 130-96(a). Prohibited accessory use without first having a permitted principal/primary use/structure. Unauthorized outside storage of items including, but not limited to, various pieces of furniture, two recreational vehicles, one storage container, one boat, appliances, two vehicles, and additionally, litter. FOLIO NO: 38502240000 VIOLATION 128 37th Ave NE, Naples, FL ADDRESS: 7. CASE NO: CESD20170004712 OWNER: IBO LLC OFFICER: Tony Asaro VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e). Converted part of the existing screened patio to an enclosed structure with electric and air conditioning without first obtaining all required Collier County Building Permits and approvals. FOLIO NO: 63866840001 VIOLATION 313 Nixon Drive, Immokalee, FL ADDRESS: 8. CASE NO: CESD20160020044 OWNER: Teresa Scoppettone OFFICER: William Marchand VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 10.02.06(B)(1)(a). Interior renovations/alterations done to interior including but not limited to; kitchen countertops, cabinets, sink, also bathroom cabinets, countertops, toilets and tile work. Work done includes electrical, plumbing and structural. FOLIO NO: 46770280004 VIOLATION 1714 Kings Lake Blvd, Naples, FL ADDRESS: 9. CASE NO: CESD20170003341 OWNER: Eliseo Viamonte OFFICER: Delicia Pulse VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, As amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a)(e) and (i). Alterations consisting of but not limited to: garage conversion into living space with full bathroom and a door installed in rear for private access, no Collier County Permits obtained. FOLIO NO: 36321920008 VIOLATION 5428 27th Ave SW, Naples, FL ADDRESS: 10. CASE NO: CESD20140011921 OWNER: Omar Otero SR and Liliana L Portillo OFFICER: Michael Odom VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 10.02.06(B)(1)(a). Expired permits for fencing and structures on the property. FOLIO NO: 39651600008 VIOLATION 4886 16th St NE, Naples, FL ADDRESS: 11. CASE NO: CESD20140017894 OWNER: Jose F Garcia OFFICER: Paula Guy VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section 10.02.06(B)(1)(A). Incomplete home. FOLIO NO: 40420400004 VIOLATION 2087 Desoto Blvd North, Naples, FL ADDRESS: 12. CASE NO: CESD20160020990 OWNER: A&B Web Ventures LLC OFFICER: Joseph Mucha VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, Section(s) 10.02.06(B)(1)(a) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e). Screen enclosure removed prior to obtaining Collier County Permit(s). FOLIO NO: 33400000169 VIOLATION 408 La Peninsula Blvd, Naples, FL ADDRESS: 13. CASE NO: CESD20170002774 OWNER: N-A Properties LLC OFFICER: Delicia Pulse VIOLATIONS: Collier County Land Development Code 04-41, as amended, 10.02.06(B)(1)(a)(e) and (i). In ground swimming pool on property with no barrier and no permits obtained. FOLIO NO: 38169440007 VIOLATION 5630 Copper Leaf Ln, Naples, FL ADDRESS: D. MOTION TO RESCIND PREVIOUSLY ISSUED ORDER E. MOTION TO AMEND PREVIOUSLY ISSUED ORDER VII. NEW BUSINESS VIII. CONSENT AGENDA A. REQUEST TO FORWARD CASES TO COUNTY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE IX. REPORTS X. COMMENTS XI. NEXT MEETING DATE - FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 16, 2018 XII. ADJOURN 56 i BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS Collier County, Florida Petitioner, vs. Case No. CENA20180012534 Evergreen Trust Respondent(s), STIPULATION/AGREEMENTk Before me, the undersigned, Dct i ! on behalf of Evergreen Trust, enters into this Stipulation and Agreement with Collier County as to the ri olution of Notices of Violation in reference (case) number CENA20180012534 dated the 8th day of October, 2018. This agreement is subject to the approval of the. Code Enforcement Board. If it is not approved, the case may be heard on the scheduled Hearing date, therefore it is strongly recommended that the respondent or representative attend the Hearing. In consideration of the disposition and resolution of the matters outlined in said Notice(s) of Violation for which a hearing is currently scheduled for October 26th, 2018; to promote efficiency in the administration of the code enforcement process; and to obtain a quick and expeditious resolution of the matters outlined therein the parties hereto agree as follows: 1) The violations noted in the referenced Notice of Violation are accurate and I stipulate to their existence, and that I have been properly notified pursuant to Florida Statute 162. THEREFORE, it is agreed between the parties that the Respondent shall; 1) Pay operational costs in the amount of$59.33 incurred in the prosecution of this case within 30 days of this hearing. 2) Abate all violations by: Mowing or causing to mow all weeds, grass, or other similar non-protected overgrowth in excess of eighteen (18) inches in height on this lot to a height of less than 6 inches within I j days of this hearing or a fine $ 5 Q per day will be imposed until the violation is abated. 3) Respondent must notify Code Enforcement within 24 hours of abatement of the violation and request the Investigator perform a site inspection to confirm compliance. (24 hours notice shall be by phone or fax and made during the workweek. If the violation is abated 24 hours prior to a Saturday,Sunday or legal holiday,then the notification must be made on the next day that is not a Saturday,Sunday or legal holiday.) 4) That if the Respondent fails to abate the violation the County may abate the violation using any method to bring the violation into compliance and may use the assistance of the Collier County Sheriff's Office to enforce the provisions f this agreement and all costs of abatement shall be assessed to the property owner. I Respon•ent or Representativ-- (sign) Ta� rr�l� MAAQ , Supervisor for Midhael Ossorio, Director Code Enfor ement Division ,s7q //,>;1/0 fil;t4I G / 0 Respondent or Representative (print) D to Date REV 3-29-16 I. Lt QX ..4 3= J� 11003 a 31 j GO r .1. 7....:'-' ‘ ,...... .,...r . z ,/ v __ ___ __ _ __ _ ....4 ,. . . _, , __ „.. ... , , _ . . % . ... ..• •.2 f Jaj c xi •t41 41 ti r ie t yt ,.:11*.`. rte _M 1 M F0 fir, Cr. • Ve OH7::: \, *, i \ , ..•...:: �s r • IU 041 �f n0 CD I I , � M F s. 1 o /./ )0, —1 •,,, (�1 - I; / / . N D > Ir J , I . . 00 • �, \\\'-',s. Y i ' 1 )/)'n /�,r, c' , .111P,,i Q a _ r i 1: .1. ' `� I I . X J?n #- .o o - .r`So o n '= > t _ a - C 2. hi 1 1 - - - 4 I I T... C ;r .sr,s. -- -s, lgW� F :a. ¢i....iv- .x, . ' a, . ..,-.i..,,•547.''....-'''.! w.s € W a a o o c L a r`,, # :r } 4- r ayi u4 . �` `: ,,,,fr « --,,,,,--,,,,,,,,,,,.!,,,--''',-...73,:;'-''''''.--.1.,''-'''« .-; des Alt 1;if - w-, dig ' ' M!- ', $ ssyy i ,...#. , N � 4 . ,,:N,,,.;4-,;, --,• 1 -:,:,-.,,,,',,,•-, - - ... -_ .,,:'„:,,, aj N Ci Z T. r ; ''.''''S• a . g o i rim 3 01 c oLt e wemarten@live.com Front Tom LeRoy <2tomleroy@gmail.com> Sent Monday, May 07, 2018 11:49 AM To: Bill/Roberta Martin Subject: Wing South Roberta and Bill.... Enclosed please find a complaint we received From:Roy Myers<torgrol@embargmail.com> Date:Wed, May 2,2018 at 10:47 PM Subject:The state of Martens property To:Anne Daley<adalev01@gmail.com> Anne, Thank you for discussing this issue with me once again today. I'm sorry that I just can't let it go this time,however,I have a vested interest in what my next door neighbor's property looks like.God forbid if I were wanting to sell my property right now.I'm living next to a house that is overgrown and in extremely poor repair.It has been eight months since the hurricane passed through and very little has been done to repair or make presentable the Marten's house.Indeed the board had to send an email threatening to exercise the right of the Board to hire a landscaping crew to clean up the mess before any attempt was made to address the state of the property.There are two issues here.The first being the"ju a"t a R^berta h created around the home.I'm beginning to wonder if,perhaps,it's intentional to hide how disgusting the structure appears. Nevertheless,t e property in the airpark,for the most part,is the legal property of the entire community.Therefore,Roberta has no right to create the overgrowth that is now present outside of the immediate area around the structure. Frankly,I object to all of the plantings that extend deeply into community property, particularly on th East sid nd I'd like to see it all_ removed.As for the area between our houses,Roberta's-vegetation has infringed upon my"half"of the that area,as well. That needs to be addressed as well as the large tree that legally sits on community property,adjacent to the Marten's driveway on the North side.In the 2 r ears that I have lived here,I have never seen the tree groomed nor trimmed.I believe it to be unsightly as well as a potential hurricane hazard. I would request that the Board consider having a tree service remove the tree or,at least,cut the tree back to a much smaller size.Also,the trio of palm trees that exist closer to the curb,adjacent to the aforementioned tree,need to be removed.At least one of those trees is dead and presents a hazard. As for the structure itself,I would ask the Board to encourage the Marten's to make a significant effort to clean up what looks like an abandoned structure.If you view the house from the East,you'll notice that what remains of the aluminum cage, gutter and facia is literally falling off of the house.There has been absolutely no effort to address these issues.I understand that the insurance company plays a role in this,however,it has been eight months and I believe the least that the Martens should do is tidy up the torn up aluminum and the accumulated trash and other`junk'clutterin& t he_patio area.It's very much an embarrassment to me to have guest over and while trying to entertain in my pool area,have to deal with the view of my neighbor's abandoned,unkept property.Plain and simple the entire property is an eyesore and it is unfair that the community has to deal with the irresponsibility of the owners. Although I am writing to you personally, I would hope that you will share this letter to everybody concerned.I've made an attempt to hold my tongue and be a compassionate and understanding neighbor and member of the community.However, my patience has lapsed.The issues concerning this house need to be addressed promptly.It would be nice to keep this issue internal,however,if need be, I'm fine with involving Code Enforcement to whatever extent is applicable and of concern to the ..____ In closing I would like to applaud the SOD for their efforts in making this community a better place to live.Although I have seen ups and downs over my years here,I believe that the community's appearance and the handling of its affairs has never been better.Thanks you,the remainder of the Board and all of the volunteer effort of those individuals who freely give their time and effort to make this community what it has become. 3 Dear Wing South BOD, As I wrote Tommy it would take a little time to get information back from several sources in order to respond to the letter forwarded to us from Roy Myers. Below is our response that I hope will make things clear. Please see the attached letter from Keys Claims issued to us on Friday. It has come to our attention that some of the BOD and the community are unaware of the steps we have been taking to repair our severely damaged home since Irma. I only learned this week that our home repairs have never been a topic at a Board meeting, therefore board member Rich Lytle, who we have kept informed on a regular basis, and President Ann Daley who knew that we hired a Public Adjuster in October had no reason to mention any of the things we have done. To rectify this development, I shall attempt to give you a clear indication of our actions as well as to respond to the allegations in the most recent letter from owner Roy Myers. We are both long time home owners and Realtors who know all to well how important community is and working together to recover from a storm. List of our actions since the hurricane: 1.Hired Keys Claims adjusters in October, 2017, after our insurance company sent an ill-prepared man who said we had $11,000 worth of damage. The estimate to date is over $400,000. Offered the opportunity for Keys Claims to Ann Daley as soon as we engaged them. 2.Hired a building contractor who uses the special software needed to communicate with insurance companies. 3. Had all estimates done as soon as possible and then repeated after the protocol developed by a forensic scientist was established. 4. Hired a forensic scientist to complete a mold evaluation and create a room by room protocol that must be accepted by insurance companies, which triggered new estimates of work. 5. Hired an architect to redesign the upper roof after being informed by the BOD that our flat roof must have metal or tile on it. 6. Hired an Engineer for the screen enclosure . 7. Hired a surveyor to prepare for permits. S. 2 weeks ago our insurance company responded to the package sent by our Public Adjuster and sent a person out to take photos and evaluate our losses. We had one roofing inspector supposedly sent by the insurance company that turned out to be a fraud and tried to get us to pay $15,000 to get a roof on. He will be dealt with by the State Insurance fraud department. 4 9. Almost every Sunday and many Saturdays we have worked in the house to prepare it to be fixed more quickly. Bill works on construction issues and I work on other aspects of the job. We have many file cabinets that date back to the development of Wing South( Billy Marten deceased wife, President and Real estate sales) which have required a page by page review to determine what should be kept and copied, recycled or shredded. Add to that all of our files for William E. Marten Inc. and you can perhaps imagine the scope of the job. We cannot have files in a storage building with no easy access. Both a POD and a camper have been suggested as potential storage/ office areas for us to use during the repair. The forensic protocol calls for a page by page cleaning of every file cabinet and every piece of paper on our shelf files. We have decided to start to clean, sanitize etc. small furniture and clothes. We have lived in so many places since the storm and many with tiny closets that half of our clothes are still in their WS closets. Because this repair process has taken longer than we could have ever dreamed, in an effort to lower costs we are now taking on some of the responsibilities that should be done by the experts. 10. I have had to add a Pulmonologist to my health care treatment because we were working in the house during the dangerous period after the storm with so much mold, in an effort to protect our home from further damage, unlike others who just walked away. 11. We have committed to date over $70,000 to this project without any help from our insurance company. Our Public Adjuster is supposed to hear from the insurance company this week and we will keep you informed as is appropriate of the process. As you are very aware of from your own experience, negotiations will be forthcoming and perhaps further legal actions. Responses to the letter that you referred to us from Roy Myers. , s 014' .. tl em p T y "very little has been done to repair and make presentable the Marten's house" 5. ANS: We removed most of this damaged vegetation from our property, a little was from a neighbor. We filled 4 Bagsters with wet sheetrock, molded insulation etc, from our 14' livingroom walls and other areas damat,e b 3 . ! "', vn. Ar „Aik, ...—„..,,, _by water. We removed 2 different visquine roofs that the insurance company had installed because they shredded. At the suggestion of an SBA staffer we researched vinyl that was located in Venice FL. After loading our car we brought back as much as we could carry and installed it neatly on the roof with batten boards all around and 16' specially ordered wood over the double faced taped joints. The unused sections of vinyl we donated to the hurricane victims in Everglades City. Our roof looks neater than the photo I took of the Pilots Lounge with shredded tarps hanging to the ground. 2. "22 years he Roy has lived here he has never seen the tree (on the North side) groomed or trimmed. " ANS: Since Marrying Bill 15 years ago I have seen the tree professionally trimmed twice and many times by Bill. Apparently Roy does not remember that in 2014 when he hired Signature Tree Service to trim his beautiful Kapok tree, he discussed with me his complaints about our tree getting close to his cage. To calm his concerned we hired Signature Tree to trim off the branches that Roy was concerned about, on the same day that he trimmed Roys' tree. Several years later when WS hired Angel Tree Service to do some work, we hired them to trim and prune both of our matching oaks, which is why they did well in the hurricane. Bill has maintained the trees and anyone who views the tree in question can see that it has been trimmed many times on Roys side in what appears to be a futile attempt to please him. We have also trimmed the trees at the suggestion of insurance company recommendations. (. 3. "gutter and facia on Lanai" ANS: We had to wait for the insurance company to come and take their own photos before we removed certain items. They only came 2 weeks ago. We removed the screen that was attached to a small piece of metal and then removed the facia.( there is no gutter) It was piled inside our garden area inner sidewalk, on Sunday. It will be removed to the dump rather than waiting a week for the county to pick it up for free if we piled it in the front yard. Much of the damaged materials that we are removing have been hauled away by car so as to keep a neater appearance at the front of the house, ATT00001.txt This photos shows the two small pieces that were still attached to the facia that Roy refers to in his letter. Everything else had either blown away, fallen in the pool or been removed by us immediately after the storm. You can also see the neatly covered wood that was specially purchased to repair the roof, on the right and several barrels that contain the flower pots and accessories that are part of our fully decorated Lanai, including furniture covered by tarps as well. It makes one wonder how Roy can characterize our belongings as "trash" when he cannot see in unless, Roy came directly behind our house and peered into our"private "Lanai. Our belongings are of our own design and choice and we do not believe that it is anyones' affair if we like one style and someone else likes bare. 4."Object to all of the plantings that extend deeply into community property, particularly on the East side and I 'd like to see it all removed" ANS: This statement is inaccurate in that we carefully measured from the taxiway back to the point where all owners have the opportunity to place personal plantings and our furthest east planting is our Mulberry tree which does not extend past that line and is in a very similar distance from the taxiway 7. as the huge palm tree that Roy planted. Based on Roys letter admitting that he had to be standing across from our Lanai and peering in , is exactly why we planted flowers and placed a garden and walkways to keep out some of the dogs, prying eyes from walkers and cart drivers. We have used native and non- native plants to create some semblance of privacy. The organic raised garden had to be fenced because Roys dogs have been consistently allowed to roam free and defecate in the yard on my vegetables and the dogs have growled at me several times and forced me to run into the house because he has no control over them. 5 As for the" plants and flowers between our homes" we designed the garden outside our dining room with three purposes in mind. ANS: 1. a pretty view from our formal dining room windows 2 to eliminate his view directly into our house from his top steps of his Lanai and to stop the strange optical situation that allow a bodiless head of Roy to glide back and forth across my sliding glass dining room doors creating a creepy feeling of an invasion of privacy as you sit in your nightclothes having breakfast. We also spent years looking at the ragged, half dead bougainvillea that were along the pool wall. When they were finally removed to paint, the glare off the wall was extremely harsh inside our dining room. 3 Additionally I planted a firebush as a backdrop knowing that it would provide a beautiful view of masses of flowers throughout the year that would, I thought be appreciated by Roy as well as us. Our gardens are designed to be viewed from the house. Our front yard is framed by 2 beautiful mature trees which are the bedrock of the rest of the plantings. 4 I find that people who are unfamiliar with plants will characterize all native plants as weeds. As former head of the Landscape Committee for WS I had master gardeners come speak to several committee members about the value of using native plants instead of exotics to save money on water and to stop the unnecessary use of poisons that destroy our drinking water supply. Our yard embodies the guidelines of the Audubon Certified Yard except for our inability to control those areas of grass controlled by our community. We attract butterflies and hummingbirds and have a safe haven from chemicals close around our house. 5."God forbid if I were wanting to sell my property right now"etc ANS: Bill and I are both Real Estate agents and as a Broker I am very aware of the reasons houses do not sell. Both Roys house and ours have very unique features that don't always excite the majority of buyers. I have had 2 realtors through our home recently and both have indicated that Roys house, in their g opinion was over priced by six figures. He chose to buy a home with a closed pool area with no view and an upper patio and living room that looks onto the side and roof of his neighbors' house. These are issues for which we are not responsible. Other homes on the taxiway have openings on both sides of their hangers for convenience, his does not. To suggest that our home is his problem is not valid. Bill and I have physically worked hard to keep our house in the best shape that we can. Bill works5- 6 days a week most weeks and we have spent most Sundays/Saturdays at our home working. We want nothing more than to fix our home and get back to normal. We hope that the rest of our neighbors can put themselves in our place and see that we are working very diligently to rebuild. We want to thank Rick and Elaine Lytle for helping bring in the cans that we put out on Sunday, so that the street is clear and always offering a helping hand when we need it. We would request that this response be shared with the entire community so that there will be no questions about our actions. Also, please include the letter from Keys Claims which is also attached. Sincerely, Bill and Roberta Marten j 4 - t 14 • Y xy rp I E / in �° f t 1bh 4 4 , •� _ 10 2. iliz4,:i P. ;‘,„0,4-die,.,....,, lt►" - - , wa • • 4 _ --EA.' i/ ,--4/-••.- -,-•-•;-. i . `mss..Y ,'4{. " ; t"1` ,Y !7"., e.-., -. .. ..,,-t-, ? _ r•:#fjr 'L- :� f, , . ? /It x tii � �. y� w, ,! 'f• r x f v..,1_ m 4 `'+5. k•.,;, a ;^ +,1 r 'of f . 4 . _ _ +�4 ' _ +' L .. {•.t4 - rye+ Jy _ w'r / .. t.� t •w _.;t -r .r A. S- �.+,:. .,d •• + i .41, •••,.. i • , 11 i t. t .; - �`, �y4 a r *4 d- 3-, 4.4. \ r'T0:4 !k •I. ✓ ' t. i • • , ,/ a' ,.. Alp j 3f rip.. .•t t : .. ` - r* 't F- •. ' - �• v f,""11`. f' !� i i =s_.. 1uc wY;'�►' '. • te.• { 4 Ilk s+ .. J` r3 •♦ riilk # 4so Ig * f moi.k'...�.. � . 1 w/ S_ F - . 11:* .,., _, .., . 4 .* 11 ,jam ...1 . ,.'t, , .‹.-40( f -"I- -- to, i*4 4 . ItV /s • A " .: } Jillp' ! • Fri► ' #� `,'+ 4t , 'AY* ,. `. .-^"; utly } jw $ a/ . ,. �Ai , ,tom` :,r --- '- , } . )5,........ , , 1: : „t, . „ i,„ il } iiIt ' � a } T`r ~• 'f. st + ', te - 14 ,r.4.44 :,, V' ,,, .,; 4, ,,ti.:: _ 4;lorlik iiir . f - F i� s 1 4 i a -t 404 '4 IIP Y �, 1 r j A -. 'a I 4-c, ‘;1 • r ,, .•4 << •elf� I� • .4114414, t j ,-,,,,,,,-.-,-_ _„,.-i-,..-..„--„„4-_ ��-L` r — *fie-- :s- e %^ T ^'1=' p ��£.` J yep. , fi• X SS!-i E° . 1 2 { i • ?.. v.t.a.•`..e .ate , { 'S `t 1 sem, �,�esm-�- . .,. ' . . ;: � -tet i , fi 4 w R • "-m. 9_____-•,„ .. _,,,,L._, ,.....,17., '"+"', 3 'r '�i r .�' f•t % • li • -_;- .1-_,,-,,,- — ',-.',-- r-l'.;,Z',,, ,,_,7; ,-,4„,k,.;.$,', ..,-",_#,-I-,4'^' 4. �z .,, `x{44.. y yI "S' el �� t t. tie•' J. .' . ,711/4 YEA d t f • } -.. 1 sem.�_ - (' t. �Y e ,t< ! ` 4.....T i�. 1`N. `i _ ' ,':'--- '.T. 3� , , t , N om.. 1.,,,, - �, ,f. ., 4 it 4 la ...--�., e. .,w. .tea .__ x ... IL Response timeline to Roy Myers Letter 5-2-2018 Date Roy Myers sent letter of complaint,to the Wing South BOD 5-7-2018 Date we received the letter from the BOD asking us to work it out between owners 5-9-2018 Date Roy Myers made formal complaint to Collier County 5-12-2018 Date we sent a letter to the BOD outlining out response to the lies and false statements in the letter. It took time to get arborists to find statements concerning tree work done, and other data. See copy of our reply. /3 4 • p v ; r t ,,„,.._,..----t.7 - a" SM'�1 x f43+ . '�a ',,-,47:1:,4*::::'',';',,,,'",,,--: x" -L. t7'S 'e `*w R^_ 'R x'4 'fes �. � YliNtX� � 'S '. - r r ix f p9` j -- 'bi s k hh, i. t� 1° p 1�. r ✓ Y •* M : ' I , / � '� .1,'""$•::-.!... * ,. r t : i`: --,14' ' ..'y' . Y 1' 1 J�. t'� �l ��� $� l ��; �4 wemarten@live.com From: Rich Lytle <richlytle727@gmail.com> Sent: Saturday, May 12, 2018 7:33 PM To: Tom LeRoy Cc: Anne Daley; Neil Fogle; Bob Ross;Orville Robert Etter;Scott/Delana Harrison/DECKER; Bill/Roberta Martin Subject: Re:WS BOD Myers response This letter clarifies the Marten's situation. I feel that a lot of the"neighbor"problems are just personal preferences on landscaping.The Martens do come out every weekend and work on the place. Rich Sent from my iPad On May 12, 2018,at 6:24 PM,Tom LeRoy<2tomlerov@gmail.com>wrote: Gentlemen/Anne.... I am forwarding on to you all an email received from Roberta and Bill Marten.... Wishing everyone a terrific Mother's Day weekend.. Tom Forwarded message From: Roberta Marten<wemarten@live.com> Date:Sat, May 12,2018 at 5:45 PM Subject:WS BOD Myers response To: "Tom LeRoy(2tomlerov@gmail.com)"<2tomlerov@gmail.com> Cc: Roberta Marten<wemarten@live.com> Tommy, Thank you for sending our response to the BOD. I have also asked that it be sent to the entire community to help them understand the work that we are doing to repair our home. Someone turned us in to the county and we will be calling them Monday for a meeting. Sincerely, 1 iS Roberta and Bill From: Roberta Marten<wemarten@live.com> Sent:Saturday, May 12,2018 5:33 PM To: Roberta Marten<wemarten@live.com> Subject:WS BOD Myers response <Roy letter response 5-11-18.docx> <keys Claim 2018-5-11 Ltr to Marten re time for settlement(003).pdf> 2 11 wemarten@live.com From: Tom LeRoy <2tomleroy@gmail.com> Sent: Saturday, May 12, 2018 8:06 PM To: Rich Lytle Cc: Anne Daley; Neil Fogle; Bob Ross; Orville Robert Etter;Scott/Delana Harrison/DECKER; Bill/Roberta Martin Subject: Re:WS BOD Myers response Sounds like the county and the neighbors will get it sorted out eventually.... On Sat, May 12, 2018 at 7:32 PM, Rich Lytle<richlytle727@gmail.com>wrote: This letter clarifies the Marten's situation. I feel that a lot of the"neighbor"problems are just personal preferences on landscaping.The Martens do come out every weekend and work on the place. Rich Sent from my iPad On May 12, 2018,at 6:24 PM,Tom LeRoy<2tomleroy@gmail.com>wrote: Gentlemen/Anne.... I am forwarding on to you all an email received from Roberta and Bill Marten.... Wishing everyone a terrific Mother's Day weekend.. Tom Forwarded message From: Roberta Marten<wemarten@live.com> Date: Sat, May 12,2018 at 5:45 PM Subject:WS BOD Myers response To: "Tom LeRoy(2tomleroy@gmail.com)"<2tomleroy@gmail.com> Cc: Roberta Marten<wemarten@live.com> Tommy, Thank you for sending our response to the BOD. I have also asked that it be sent to the entire community to help them understand the work that we are doing to repair our home. Someone turned us in to the county and we will be calling them Monday for a meeting. 1 Sincerely, Roberta and Bill From: Roberta Marten<wemarten@live.com> Sent:Saturday, May 12,2018 5:33 PM To: Roberta Marten<wemarten@live.com> Subject:WS BOD Myers response <Roy letter response 5-11-18.docx> <keys Claim 2018-5-11 Ltr to Marten re time for settlement(003).pdf> 2 William E. Marten Roberta J. Marten 3880 Skyway Drive Naples, FL 34112 Hurricane Irma Timeline 9-11-17 Called Tower Hill Insurance 9-12-17 Hinspeter Roofing arrived with large tarp, leaked on flat surface 9-13-17 New Hope Church 7 hours to meet with FEMA, SBA and Tower Hill staff, photos 9-18-17 Northeast Disaster Restoration roofers, sent by Tower Hill $ 1,000.00 10--17 Hired AA Contracting to manage repair 2,087.10 10-4-17 meetings withFEMA/SBA Small Business Admin. For additional mortgage 10-17 Hinspeter Roofing Est. 10-25-17 Hired Keys Claims Public Adjusters----expected cost ,$35,000- $ 40,000.00 10-22-17 Elaine Lytle artist murals Est. 10-26-17 Tower Hill Ins. preferred roofing inspector,Joe Bryant visits 10-4-17 4 Bagsters for debris removal-, all wet material from walls and insulation removed 556.00 plus labor 144-17?Tower Hill sent roofers with Visquine, lasts about 3 weeks then disintegrates 11-17 Mary Randall artist painted furniture Estimate Nov 17-17 Alex Bower from Keys Claims does full inspection. 11-9-17 Dry Zone Inc. disinfect. Clean tile removal etc Est. 10-17-17 Jays Electrical Co. Est. 11-11-17 Edwins Contracting and Painting, sheetrock etc. Est. 11-17-17 Text from Joe Bryant "Play ball "and split approx.. $17,000 12-5-17 Met again with SBA for mortgage/loan 12-8-17 Drove to Venice to pick up used billboard covers/tarps from Berlin Sign Co. 12-9-17 Bill put up billboard tarps on roof with2x4x16 purchased lumber 12-12-17 Sent 12 billboard covers to emergency relief staff in Everglades City •6`! 12-29-17GIass Doctor, windows and doors Est. 12-17 All Stat AC Est 11-1-17 Aluminum Store Lanai repair Est. 12-14-17 Advanced Building Forensic mold protocol and testing $2,500.00 12-15-17 Daane Labs mold enumeration report 12-27-17 JW Insulation and Acoustics Est 10-25-17 Lenore Mattoff inside painting Est. 11-17 Hilton Moving and Storage Est. 12-17 Wing South Assoc. special assessment for cleanup 500.00 12-17 Rubin Leon roof blueprints Est. 1-9-18 Survey and Elevation needed for permit $ 600.00 1-18-18 Guardian Hurricane Protection windows and sliders Est. 1-23-18 Givens Drafting construction drawings for permit 2,000.00 1-23-18 Panther amphibian pool repair Est. 7-30-18 Honk Industries demolition Est 8-1-18 Dallis demolition Est 8-1-18 GCI Consultants window and door assessment 2,500.00 8-8-18 Rice Insulation updated estimate Est. 8-24-18 Hinspeter Roofing new estimate w/o center roof redo required Est. 10-15-18 Kaleb Blake Company Insurance Umpire fee $ 1475 Monthly cost to run WS home estimate $2,300 mo. Case Number: CEPM20180007088 Date:July 17, 2018 Investigator:John Johnson Phone:239-252-2601 COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT NOTICE OF VIOLATION Owner: MARTEN, WILLIAM E 3880 SKYWAY DR NAPLES, FL 34112 Location: 3880 Skyway DR Unincorporated Collier County Zoning Dist: Property Legal Description:WING SOUTH INC A CONDOMINIUM LOT 1 Folio:82940040009 NOTICE Pursuant to Collier County Consolidated Code Enforcement Regulations, Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances, Chapter 2, Article IX, you are notified that a violation(s) of the following Collier County Ordinance(s) and or PUD Regulation(s)exists at the above-described location. Ordinance/Code: Buildings and Building Regulations, Property Maintenance Code, General Provisions. Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances Chapter 22, Article VI, Section 22-228(1) Compliance with housing standards. Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances Chapter 22 Buildings and Building Regulations, Article VI Property Maintenance Code , Section 22-231(12)(c) Compliance with housing standards. Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances Chapter 22 Buildings and Building Regulations, Article VI Property Maintenance Code . Section 22-231(12)(i) Unauthorized accumulation of litter. Collier County Code of Laws , Chapter 54 Environment, Article VI Weeds Litter and Exotics, Section 54-181 Maintenance. Equipment systems, devices and safeguards required by this Code or a prior code under which the structure or premises was constructed, altered or repaired,shall be maintained in good working order. The requirements of this code are not intended to provide the basis for removal or abrogation of the fire protection, safety systems and devices in existing structures. Except as otherwise specified herein,the owner shall be responsible for the maintenance of buildings,structures and premises: Exterior and interior structures of dwelling units.All the following component of a dwelling unit shall be maintained in good condition. c. Roofs. Roofs shall be maintained in a safe manner and have no defects which might admit rain or cause dampness in the wall or interior portion of the bUthe buirding. Windows and exterior doors. Every window, exterior door, shall be properly fitted within its frame, provided with lockable hardware, and shall be weather-tight and weatherproof, and maintained in good repair. Every window required for light and ventilation for habitable rooms shall be capable of being opened easily and secured in a position by window hardware.Windowpanes or approved substitutes shall be maintained without cracks or holes. Openings originally designed as windows and doors shall be maintained as such, unless approved by the building official for enclosure.The closing in of a window or door shall be by bricking the opening, blocking the opening with concrete blocks and stuccoing the exterior, utilization of an authorized building material and finishing the exterior with like material of the original exterior surface,or boarding the opening.When boarding is used, it shall be trim fit, sealed to prevent water intrusion, and painted or stained to conform with the other exterior portions of the building. The boarding shall remain in place no longer than 18 months, unless an extension is granted by code enforcement special master. Any unauthorized accumulation of litter in or upon any property, vacant or improved,or on or upon any public street, alley or other public or private place is a violation of this article.Any property owner,tenant,occupant, agent, manager,or other person who owns, maintains,or controls private property,whether improved or unimproved, is hereby declared to be in violation of this article where any such unauthorized accumulation of litter is maintained or is allowed to remain on such property.: Violation Status- Initial DESCRIPTION OF CONDITIONS CONSTITUTING THE VIOLATION(S). Did Witness: I observed roof and soffit damage, missing window, and accumulation of litter and debris. �6ne fol -do /e4a - L6-s re. 1:1/1 s r . 4;// c? . e) s6A-mexkl Pvu B siA U.S. SMALL BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION (817)868-2300 *,� .. ,t4 �* Disaster Assistance 1(800)366-6303 ,.: ? Processing and Disbursement Center Hearing Impaired o�� 1953 ,`0 14925 Kingsport Road (817)-267-4688 N.sTar- Fort Worth, Texas 76155-2243 July 17, 2018 WILLIAM E. MARTEN and ROBERTA J. MARTEN 3880 SKYWAY DR NAPLES, FL 34112 RE: Application Number: 1000752105 LM: 3 Loan Number: 2209447008 Dear WILLIAM E. MARTEN and ROBERTA J. MARTEN: We have received information regarding your eligible loss, project cost, or expenditures which affects the terms and conditions of your loan. Based on our review of this information, we modified your loan. We have made the following amendments to your Loan Authorization and Agreement: Your loan amount has increased from$64,400.00 to $240,000.00. The payment amount is increased from $240.00 to $893.00 monthly and will begin 12 months from the date of the promissory Note. Your loan maturity remains unchanged at 30 year(s) from the date of the Note. (Note: If your payment is made through an automatic withdrawal from a checking or savings account, please contact our Customer Service Center at 1-800-659-2955 for assistance in changing the amount of your withdrawal.) 4. USE OF LOAN PROCEEDS has been amended as follows: A. Property located at 3880 Skyway Dr.,Naples,FL 34112 Subparagraph(1): Modify as follows: (1) Approximately $40,000.00 to repair/replace disaster damaged personal property (excluding motor vehicles) in similar kind and quantity. Subparagraph(2): Modify as follows: (2) Approximately$195,000.00 to repair/replace disaster damaged real estate. Subparagraph(3): Add as follows: (3) Approximately$5,000.00 to repair/replace disaster damaged landscaping. Page 1 ALL RISK AGREEMENTI � J THIS AGREEMENT is between owl 1"i i , _./ /�"/,�DPC �_�L -_261.1 _ (+`Owner") 0 f / •g 5/../,/ --____,_- and Keys Claims Consultants, address: r . . '''.1 ��� Inc.,(KCC).1025 5th Avenue aples,FL 34102(phone 239-774-5040)and arises out of a UjkA t�--, _ _ insured by location: .5. ja ' _.._..N._..."69/1"'"5-,,, -L._ y��_l . -.� eqA N S'�--civ c" r _c O yr'I i?�.t Keys Claims /�l_ '� ��r"'-nN _, policy number NCot fultants, Inc. (KCC) will prepare a detail accounting of the damages and present them to the insurance company. KCC. will negotiate the damages with the insurance company representative(s).Should the claim not be settled pt. nptly,the Owner authorizes KCC to demand and invoke the Appraisal provision of the policy and is naming KCC as Owner's Appraiser. 1. Owner agrees to pay to KCC in consideration thereof,and hereby assign to KCC,a contingency fee of `i0 of all insurance funds,contractual and extra contractual,received after the date of this agreement The fee will be based on the gross amount of the insurance proceeds after the application of the deductible(s)and in conformance with Florida Statutes. 2. Owner will pay expert costs KCC deems necessary to substantiate this claim.Possible experts are listed and insured has read and acknowledged these projected costs on the attached Addendum. 3. If Appraisal is necessary,the Umpire's fee,shall be paid 50%by the Insurance Company and 50%by the Insured according to the terms of the policy. 4. KCC employees are not lawyers and do not provide legal representation,nor do they provide legal advice or make legal interpretations of the policy. The fees and costs including experts associated with legal representation, if necessary,are not part of this agreement. 5. Owner assigns to KCC the right to be paid as a joint payee by the insurance company. .6-//(J I©Sib sicfcx. c. �'-'-e",,,,- 6. As of the date of this agreement, Owner directs the above named Insurance Company to add Keys Claims Consultants,Inc.,as joint payee on any and all payments made by the Insurance Company pertaining to the above captioned claim. 7. KCC is an independent party and is not affiliated with any insurance company. 8. This agreement with its Addendum contains the entire agreement between the parties and there are no oral or written representations, promises, agreements or arrangements between the parties other than those set forth in this agreement 9. Should Owner default in the payment of KCC's fee,interest will accrue on the unpaid balance at the rate of eight percent per annum. Owner agrees to pay all attorney fees and costs for pre-litigation efforts, litigation and any appellate proceedngs associated with the enforcement of this agreement Owner shall be responsible for all attorney's fees and costs associated with any Court proceedings required to assess the amount of attorney's fees recoverable by KCC. 10.Arbitration:Disputes are to be arbitrated pursuant to the commercial arbitration rules of the American Arbitration Association (herein"AAA.") 11.Enforceability of Arbitration:The decision made by the arbitrator is enforceable in a court of appropriate jurisdiction. 12.Costs of Arbitration:Each party of arbitration will be responsible for his,her,or its own costs to arbitrate.Costs to arbitrate will consist of,but are not limited to,all personal expenses and attorney fees. The costs of arbitration will be split equally between the parties of such arbitration.The costs of arbitration will consist of the arbitration fee to A A A and the arbitrator's fee. Pursuant to S.817234,Florida Statutes,any person who,with to be presented a proof of loss or estimate o!t nal or repair of intent to injure,defraud,or deceive a�ins srer of insure of loss or estimate of claim or tOPetty d' �"e+Pt�ents,of causes teptirs or as fall P m support of a claim under n iosirtawe poiiry knowing that the proof commits a felony of the third d P cacomplete, or midteadiag information concerning any fact or thing egree,punishable as rovided in 5.775.082,S.775.083,or S.775•A84,Florida Statutes material to the claim Signatu ,`� CC: Signature by Insured: /- Keys Clai,,,,-;< a 1— ;.�/ YWinks s,Inc Printed Name r 'U Title r stopher e Crosaan,PA , se#W241989 j , ____Da`� t ��..� Phone Number f ' . __Date mac? :'":7,Re arms Consultants,Inc. 2.�� Title e: ��lj � Jo rn P. Waligora,Sr.,PA License #D Printed .... .f. , - ,1 • . ' 11;,4,.... - -''":"..-f-'-r.::-..,--T :1:'-'-''...---. --,- , • ,..... .....• (- -..-41.;.- • , •.,1 - . . „ I C.. ...; % 1.......... .4_,..... r..,f) N '--- Q. .... ., .--- .' -., -... .....--:.. ...,..-- .., .:.. ,, r. 'i.4,41-' ,.. t , .,. li. .., -- :, 11. II\ \-, \ . , --,-, . ‘,,... \- , . . , ---*'-.-...4. -. -- •f .-. ...N. Se. • ' I!', .;t . ' ff..• ,..101'•4-1,e, 11!il .. ',. . -;i• .. ,,. . , ,, ' - - . •=,.. -. . • . . , . : 7..' *' 't,',71'.141-.' • ' .'-. ' . . ., .•.e. -,, , . .. . .., . . . . , .. , . .. - 41,,•.V. -IF* " ••,, ,..- - t:),,ri ..:.r....- . . . Keys Claims Cc SuR ante, Inc May 11, 2018 SENT VIA EMAIL TO: WEMARTEN(a,,LIVE.COM Roberta Marten 3880 Skyway Dr. Naples, FL 34112 RE: Insured: William & Roberta Marten Location of Loss: 3880 Skyway Dr., Naples, FL 34112 Policy Number: 8002497020 Claim Number: 3300217699 Date of Loss: September 10, 2017 Dear Mr. and Mrs. Marten: You have inquired as to the time frame that is expected before there is a settlement on your claim from Hurricane Irma for damages to your home as you are living away from your home due to the damages it sustained. It is impossible to give you a precise answer to that question. As you are aware, Hurricane Irma did massive damage to the lower part of Florida, making a second landfall here in Marco Island and then moved North through the center of the state. This has created a shortage of adjusters and claims personnel to handle and process these claims, experts to determine the repairs that may be necessary, and a shortage of qualified contractors to do repairs once the claims have been settled. Unfortunately, you have been caught up in these shortages as well. While we have been involved in your claim since late October, the claim is just now beginning to get the attention of the insurance company as we have presented them with your full claim and supporting documentation in March. As you are aware, we recently had an inspection with an adjuster and a roofing consultant that represent your insurance company. While we await their position and hope to receive a fair offer after their reports are submitted, we won't know if we will need to proceed further to settle your claim fairly or what route we will need to take to have it resolved. We can only estimate the time frame that is expected until the claim is fully settled. I think that it is a minimum of 6 months away, with a potential that it could take up to a year before a final settlement is reached. As to the repair time, I know of several contracting companies that are turning work away, saying that they are booked 3 to 6 months ahead and we do not anticipate this will be cleared up in the immediate future. With that said, i believe that it will be in excess of a year before the claim is settled and repairs completed, and 1 'A years is well within the possibilities. I hope that this will assist you in making determinations that you need to make as to living arrangements during this interim. Please feel free to contact me with any additional questions. Kindest regards, Alex Bowen, PA, CPAU For the Firm Bayfront Professional Center • 1333 3rd Avenue South, Suite 407, Naples, Florida 34102 Phone 239-774-5040 • Fax 239-774-4027 01S? wemarten@live.com From: Anne Daley <adaley0l@gmail.com> Sent: Thursday, July 12, 2018 12:14 PM To: rvmarten@icloud.com; Neil Fogle;Tom LeRoy; Rich Lytle; Robert Etter; Bob Ross; Delana Harrison/DECKER Cc: Roberta Marten Subject: Re: Update Marten residence Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Flagged Roberta and Bill, We wish you the best as you proceed. Gentlemen, I am forwarding the update the Marten's have sent regarding their residence. Regards, -Anne On Thu,Jul 12, 2018 at 11:20 AM Roberta Marten<rvmarten@icloud.com>wrote: Dear BOD, We wanted to update the board and the community on the activities concerning our home. We have now moved into the appraisal part of our negotiations with the insurance company. We had the two appraisers meet at our home to evaluate the extent of the damage.The insurance company has 90 days in which to respond and negotiate with our appraiser. If that does not work out then we will move on to the next phase which is a type of arbitration. We have also sent an update to the county inspector. We would appreciate all of you helping us to protect our property by watching out for anything unusual.There seem to be a fair number of strange cars on the taxiway and many new faces walking by. We are usually there on Sunday afternoons and you are all invited to stop by. We may even consider selling the house. Thank you, Bill and Roberta Marten 3880 Skyway Dr 239-289-3233 Sent from my iPhone f'`1 Insurance Company Timeline 9-11-17 Called Tower Hill Insurance 9-13-17 Tower Hill staff assisted us at sending all photos to office from their trailer at the new Hope Church Disaster Center. 11-17 Estimator from Tower Hill Report 12-9-17 $ 14,379 total vs $479,000 6-26-18 Tower Hill Appraisal 9-4-18 Tower Hill Umpire meeting 10-11-18 Umpire decision on payment ---4 Gi1 02 ? $ C * LIG5,4/11 $ 78% 5:47 <- (321 ) 527-6145 ko i 4:04 PM Exact est on Marten. $88,750 0 It's submitted. And Craig, ProGuard Restoration is a great company. It really is. Hands on just like you. With a signed wa (work authorization form) I can have that number approved by next Fri. 100% guaranteed. There's plenty of money there for both of us. If you can help in getting that done, it's a done deal. Were getting these ap- provals over the wire in droves hourly. I can show anyone that on my phone. My phone is linked directly with Alacrity Services. Owned by Lowe's. And Alacrity is approving this storm, not Tower Hill. Tower Hill li . 111 A * 114 - Ali a 0 Type an SMS message 41 0 0 33_ 14 GE as 13 ? 10 C * Lim,do . 78% 5:48 <-- (321 ) 527-6145 ka i deal. Were getting these ap- provals ever the wire in droves hourly. I can show anyone that on my phone. My phone is linked directly with Alacrity Services. Owned by Lowe's. And Alaci-rty is approving this storm, not Tower Hill. Tower Hill has turned over thousands of claims to Alacrity Services, and given them full authorization to approve or estimates based on eagle view reports, pies, and xactimate estimates. Give Mr and Mrs Marten this info asap. They trust you. I know that you're working with their best interest in mind. I am too. An est is just an est without a signed wa. It is a TH generated wa. If they want their tile roof 0 approved at $88,750, tell them to play ball and everyone wins. 4:15 PM kt... 0 Type an SMS message < 0 0 December 04,2017 g 0 I RE: Company: cn Omega insurance Company cv en insured: William Marten m g Claim Number: 3300217699 Policy Number: 8002497020 o o Date of Loss: 09/09/2017 o 8 CNI 0 4 o Dear William Marten: (NI o 0 Based on our current tn. formation, the estimated damages for Property claim are 1ess than your policy deductible. Therefore,no payment is due at this tinle. Dwelling/Structure 5 6,657.31 Screen Enclosure $ 4,403.74 Personal Effects(Contents) S 0.00 Additional Living Expense(ALE) $ 0.00 Emergency Services $ 3,336.76 Gross Loss $ 14,397.81 Less 4 :::':,*..`".tt'-•=f,.,;-.!\.,-'•;:•;.,,-.,,',,,'',AT'''''k'4,:',..M4,04'''' '.+, 4,,g—tok.e.,°b,,g;' ,,A.,••,4.,,kfe40.' i14,,,7 ,,,,,,,,„..:','„,, ,,,,'..- ._,-: +:, ,, •,,,-:,,i ,', :.':04:t:-,':',.,, 04' f1,,, R :-,,/—;:,' -,,::-„A:-::-1, -,r-'7 $ Nt,,N,,:..:70WI''9: s,' ';'',:, Actual Cash Value $ 14,397.81 .:,,,',J,:.4,..,,;-zN:,:c.-n,-,,iik,';!'.0•,:!. - ,.„.2ii4;,-ti,, $/,,g- rlAtil,', NETAMOUNTPAID,-- $.1'''.::,-,,,s: 'AA02.19 _ . /\ 71-ise. 1esh&laic Keys Claims Consultants, Inc. +,,...,,_„....'.a..x. , ... 1025 5th Avenue North Naples FL 34102 Phone 239-774-5040 ww w.keyselainis.coni 312,028.14 65.10% ..-. O&P Items Subtotal Material Sales 141 a 6.000% 4,295.64 0.90% Coverage: pwelling a 9971% - 4.283 34 Coverage: Other Strictures a 0.29% - 12.3() • Overhead a 10.0% 31,632.72 6.60% Coverage: Dwelling a 98.36% - 31,11349 '',.. Coverage:Other Structures (/ 1.64% - 519.23 Profit a 10.0% 31,632.72 6.60% Coverage: Dwelling 'a 98.36% - 31.11149 Coverage:Other Structures a• 1.64% -- 519.23 -- Total S 479,33 152 100.00% f.-1 Need‹..,e E5- 1 From: Alex Bowen alexbovverkeysciairriscom Subject: RE: Award Date: Oct 11, 2018, 9:01:47 AM To: Roberta Marten r vmarten.cPictoud.corn Cc: Patrick Gibson patrickgibson4keysclaims CORI Payment should be issued as follows: Coverage A $290,000.00 (This includes the mold remediation and absorbs the deductible) Coverage B $5,800.00 Coverage C $23,797.54 Coverage D $40,000.00. TOTAL PAYMENTS NOW SHOULD BE: $$359,597.54. Aay trleint 36, Financial Evaluation Potential Insurance payout $359,597.54 Repair estimate $479.000 AS of Oct.11,2018 Keys Claims Pub. Adj 10%fee- 35,960.00 Insurance rem 310,400 $ 323,637.54 Short <-$ 168,600> Payment to Umpire/Arbitrator - 1,475.00 $ 322,162.54 Other bills pd on timeline - 11,743.44 Total remaining $ 310,419.44 Tear down home; Insurance $ 310.419 Pay off mortgage - 160,000 Value BEFORE Irma $ 600,000 $ 150,419 AFTER Irma lot ? $ 200,000 Replace Personal loss-- 40,000 Insurance ? + 53,419 $ 110,419 $ 253,419 Demolition Estimate-$ 25,000 $ 85,419 Value BEFORE $ 600,000 Disinfect, pack, move- 32,000 Value AFTER - 253,419 Store 6 mo. unpack, <LOSS $ 346,581> $ 53,419 maybe 37 ,,.- krone Seeed, 4. a Hv man.F lrkt 1'?Red,stT fir.an,e trout Hr�r H�!o,d.h �yrrn ..,Cr1ena ,]Slap J Newts Checked Sere Page 0,1War Single L. • at 25 • per Page h.', .• M'S a St. Ls1 Prics041-ess C:. 5,b Cando Nan*Derelamnant 8eds/Bath, Living Area GEO Area DOM Soil Pres Sox!Date f• Lf���U 7170'0204 a 8699,000 4119 SKYWAY DR PH NAPLES WING SOWN A1F WING SOUTH AIRPAR 3 Bed/3(0) 2,154 NA19 391 m®t • g 146 4o) 'v,_;218030534 v 5810,000 3961 SKYWAY DR 611 NAPLES WING SOURS AIF WING SOUTH SIRDAR 4 Bed/3(0) 2,861 NA18 132 al t �.g�f^�q(� ;, 326006056 S 833'.000 4108 SKYWAY DR 031 NAPLES WING SOOTN A¢WING SOUTH AIRPAR 3 Bedf3(0) 2,583 WAIN 356 5290,800 02,22'17 m ! [�j'6 "t 316046107 S $390-000 4109 SKYWAY OR 035 NAPLES WING 501378 AE WING SOUTH AIRPAR 2 8erN2(1) 2,249 9A38 244 1365,000 4431777 ®® � '4N xt U j 117971500 5 $693.040 39552 54YWAY DR NAPLES WING SORT',AN WING SOOTH AIRPAR 3+Oen,3(0) 2,992 5416 8 $646,510 05112'17 m a t ♦. ,g() V 2170373'6 5 $799,000 3976 SKYWAY DR 452 NAPLES WING SOOTH A11 WING SOUTH AIRPAR 3+4>en/2(2) 2,699 NA38 182 5741 000 12/15737 m®t Refne Save Cars Sold Homes past 2 years(4) all within 300 Sq. Ft. of subject property (Which is what an appraiser would use) Average Sold Price$500,375 1 Sold for an Average of 89.87%of Asking Price and the average took 198 days to sell Average Asking Price$556,750 Active Listings: (2 currently on market) 1 Larger than subject `yc�-amw wa. Home Swrch _.*_, "h M�C< Erks LT3 Rta3aI7x F,nance IPP-t He{D� 69113,kA'.A krnl.i,. }3 A 5T 4 'r 1T 7 l Saarcho1• s CrYsria 17 Map Results GNAW, Siegle L=ee •at 25 • Par Page,,4 MS s S.. mai Drice A3�-ess Cay Sub Conde Nance Develop,nent Sedti oaths Long Area 600 Area DON Sold PripSotd Hate .17 R., 40'170284 a 5699.000 4119 SKYWAY DR 436 NAPLES WING SOUTH AIF WING SOUTH AIRPAR 3 Bed/3(0) 2,154 N418 341 ®O ,) 21E140134 a $833,000 3961 5015948 DR 011 NAPLES WING SOUTH AN WING SOUTH AIRPAR 4 Bed/3(0) 2,861 NA18 132 ®O Cgs ,mai Refine Save Carts 111' �''- One has ibeen on the market 341 days the other 132 days...No current offers +�"'^•`, •,.! '" Hone Search S'03, •6.#09ix Links 106 finance Input He;p HeRP,BPBLayout Coterie Map J Resifts Next•1-11 of 11 Checked 5 All•None-Page Display Single Une • at 25 • per P196 U,I NS 4 Sts List Pnoear/dress Sub Cordo Warne Lot Frontage Lot Left Block Lot Unit Acres 0054 5484 Prica50[d Date 4'..1 C!214035449 A $122,000 4009 SKYWAY DR L0T421 WING SOUTH AIRPARN 75 111 D 21 0.250 1,586 ®■t g 0 „J a 18028425 A $129,000 3987 SKYWAY DR LOT*18 WING SOUTH AIRPARP 75 130 D 18 0.250 182 ®■! 2/8035165 A $239,020 4085 SKYWAY DR 1OT*33 WING SOUTH AIRPARN 78 130 D 33 0.260 162 ®■t L2 y% 215009838 A $249,000 3955 SKYWAY DR L0T410 WING SOUTH AIRPARP 78 130 0 10 0.260 1,351 ®® 'S`L, 34.5 216073175 A $250,000 4234 SKYWAY DR SW 1OT915 WING SOUTH AIRPARP 135 135 B 15 0.360 701 ®® I'.®IR 216073107A $250,0004230 SKYWAY DR SW LOT114 WING SOUTH AIRPARII 515 135 B 14 0.360 701 ®®t e fg0 216073105 A 5250,000 4226 SKYWAY DR SW LOT413 WING SOUTH 619066E 115 135 B 13 0.360 701 mote • 21() 216000524 A $250,000 4222 SKYWAY DR SW LOT*12 WING SOUTH A1RPAR8 115 135 B 12 0.360 969 ®®t IS a'g®$„3 211073110 P $265,000 4238 SKYWAY DR SW LOT*16 WING SOUTH AIR0ARP 165 135 B 16 0.530 695 ®®e !$ 217066657 5 $199,900 3893 SKYWAY DR LO704 WING SOUTH AIRPARP 92 84 D 4 0.250 154 $151,001 05-08-20(5 5t gA(4 ,,2/5000046 S $289,100 4072 SKYWAY DR 101444 WING SOUTH AIRPARP 100 125 D 44 0.250 1,329 $200.000 09-06 20155 t The average lot of their size ((5) of them) have been on the market an average 753 days with no sales in past 2 years. Two smaller lots sold 1 @ $150,000 and the other @ $200,000.And they averaged 742 days on the market. Keep in mind this was during a seller's market and there is much evidence we are going into a buyer's market. wemarten@live.com From: Robert M. Burns <breakthrumarketing@comcast.net> Sent: Tuesday, October 23, 2018 8:04 PM To: Roberta Marten Subject: Re: Fwd:Wing South "Extension" Lot Offer Roberta This is just one more commission free competitor...Make sure you let the County people know this! I take it this is one of the smaller lots! Bob On October 23, 2018 at 5:11 PM Roberta Marten <wemarten@live.com>wrote: FYI outside the gate close to Rattlesnake Roberta Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From:Tom LeRoy< 2tomlerov@gmail.com> Date:October 23, 2018 at 3:30:45 PM EDT To: undisclosed-recipients:; Subject:Wing South "Extension" Lot Offer Wing South owners.... Your president has asked that we again remind all owners that the real estate commission free opportunity to buy one of our remaining lots will expire at the end of the year December 31st The original reasoning behind the discounted commission free opportunity was to promote a lot sale to a Wing South owner so that Wing South had sufficient funds.... without an assessment....to finish the infrastructure effort developing our 5 lots as it turned out our easement sale to the County provided the funds to complete the 5 lot "extension" development in May your Wing South Board accepted a commissioned offer of$200,000 for lot#12 which would have been a net to Wing South of$188,000 that 1 acceptance at that date set a price acceptable to Wing South should an owner want to purchase lot#12 after months of extensions and issues the commissioned contract was terminated.... Should any owner be interested in one of our lots in our "extension" the Board of Directors will accept a sale of$188,000 net to Wing South so long as it is presented and closes no later than December 31st of this year on January 1st of the new year this opportunity will no longer be available... Fondest regards to everyone Wing South Board Of Directors ra,.„a 11,,, _ it ............ 1 N 2 11 '4 y I , BREAKTHRU TEAM PARTNERS The Mi0Dollar Ment 0 (a;9 ° I o � . . :II tai M ook.c 0 Robert M. Burns 2 4-6 To Whom It May Concern My Team is listing the property of William Marten at 3880 Skyway Dr. Naples Florida 34112 Under a Value RANGE Marketing Concept "As IS" The home had bad roof damage and the roof will have to be replaced. For them to minimize their losses they need they need a minimum of six months marketing time. Provided under separate cover is a history of sales of both houses & lots at Wing South Inc. Robert M. Burns RE/MAX Affmity Mercato 877 9P Ave N #2 Naples, FL 34108 ogonowd p : SI Request for Extension With the realization that we will not be able to recoup our losses through working longer hours,we have decided that we must abandon the idea of repairing the house. • To maximize our losses and provide ourselves with the hope of a proper place to live we have engaged a Re Max Realtor to assist us in selling our property. We realize that any new home we purchase will be less than half of the value of our former home. • A market analysis has been done and a plan of action created to market the home AS IS. • Working against us, and all present sellers', is the Wing South BOD decision to continue to market the 5 large lots that are owned by the association to owners with no commission, until Dec 31St • Market analysis shows lots taking an average of 742 days on the market before selling. • Our only hope to recover even a small part of our losses is to sell the home AS IS. • If that becomes impossible,then we must tear down the house and sell this prime lot. Demolition company recommendations are 3 months to get that done. The Realtors letter requests a minimum of six months to market the home and longer, if this board would agree.At the end of the agreed upon time, if it is not sold AS IS,then we will proceed to tear it down. We understand that this Code Enforcement case will transfer to the new owner REQUEST Therefore, we are requesting 8 months in which to market our home for sale and at the end of that time, if not sold,we will proceed with demolishing the house. \\/ 3 COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD IMPOSITION OF FINES/LIEN HEARING CEB CASE NO. CELU20180001084 Hearing Date: October 26, 2018 Board of County Commissioners vs. Judith Telfort Violation(s): Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances, Chapter 54, Article VI, Section 54- 179 and Collier County Land Development Code, 04-41, as amended, Sections 1.04.01(A) and 2.02.03. Location: 158 5TH ST, NAPLES, FL Folio: 77214040009 Description: Outside storage and/or litter consisting of but not limited to: furniture, bed frames, tables, chairs, cardboard boxes, foam, tarp, metals, plastics, etc. Past Order(s): On April 27, 2018, the Code Enforcement Board issued a Findings of Fact, Conclusion of Law and Order. The Respondent was found in violation of the referenced ordinances and ordered to correct the violation. See the attached Order of the Board, OR 5506 PAGE 1638, for more information. The violation has been abated as of August 2, 2018. FINES AND COSTS TO DATE ARE AS FOLLOWS: Fines have accrued at a rate of$100.00 per day for the period from May 12, 2018 to August 2, 2018. (83 days) for a total fine amount of$8,300.00 Previously assessed operational costs of$59.63 have been paid. Operational Costs for today's hearing: $59.49 Total Amount: $8,359.49 A. The gravity of the violation: Moderate B. Any actions taken by the violator to correct the violation: Property owner removed the outside storage from the property. C. Any previous violations committed by the Respondent/Violator: Property owner currently has an open case pertaining to an unpermitted fence, owner has obtained the permit and it is active. D. Any other relevant factors: None C7 COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD IMPOSITION OF FINES/LIEN HEARING CES CASE NO. CESD20170004712 Hearing Date: October 26, 2018 Board of County Commissioners vs. IBO LLC Violation(s): Collier County Land Development Code, 04-41, as amended, Sections 10.02.06(B)(1)(a) and 10.02.06(B)(1)(e). Location: 313 NIXON DR, NAPLES, FL Folio: 63866840001 Description: Converted part of the existing screened patio to an enclosed structure with electric and air conditioning without first obtaining all required Collier County Building Permits and approvals. Past Order(s): On November 17, 2017, the Code Enforcement Board issued a Findings of Fact, Conclusion of Law and Order. The Respondent was found in violation of the referenced ordinances and ordered to correct the violation. See the attached Order of the Board, OR 5456 PAGE 1400, for more information. The violation has been abated as of September 4, 2018. FINES AND COSTS TO DATE ARE AS FOLLOWS: Part B of the Order: Fines have accrued at a rate of$250.00 per day for the period from February 16, 2018 to September 4, 2018. (201 days) for a total fine amount of$50,250.00 Part C of the Order: Fines have accrued at a rate of$100.00 per day for the period from November 19, 2017 to September 4, 2018. (290 days) for a total fine amount of$29,000.00 Previously assessed operational costs of$59.91 have been paid. Operational Costs for today's hearing: $59.42 Total Amount: $79,309.42 A. The gravity of the violation: Not a health and safety violation B. Any actions taken by the violator to correct the violation: Property owner secured a building permit correcting the violation C. Any previous violations committed by the Respondent/Violator: None D. Any other relevant factors: None