The URL can be used to link to this page

Ex-parte - Taylor 10/23/2018 Ex parte Items - Commissioner Penny Taylor COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AGENDA October 23, 2018 ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS 9A This item requires ex parte disclosure be provided by the Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve an Ordinance of the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida amending Ordinance Number 2005-36, the Regal Acres Residential Planned Unit Development, by increasing the permissible number of dwelling units from 184 to 300; by amending Ordinance Number 2004-41, the Collier County Land Development Code by amending the appropriate zoning atlas map or maps by changing the zoning classification of an additional 23.15+/- acres of land zoned rural Agricultural (A) to the Regal Acres RPUD; by revising the development standards; by amending the master plan; adding deviations; revising developer commitments; by removing the density bonus agreement for Parcel A approved in Ordinance Number 2005-36 as an attachment to the Ordinance and by approval of an affordable housing density bonus for the added 23.15 acres that will generate 46 bonus units for low or moderate income residents. The property is located on the west side of Greenway Road east of Collier Boulevard (C.R. 951), and north of U.S. 41, in Section 12, Township 51 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida consisting of 59.90+/- acres; and by providing an effective date [PL20170001733]. (This is a companion to Agenda Item 11.E.) NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SEE FILE XMeetings Correspondence Xe-mails Calls Phone calls with Nick Kouloheras and Lisa Lefkow. Watched the Planning Commission meeting. Attended the Affordable Housing advisory sub-committee and committee meeting. Toured the Regal Acres site on Tuesday, October 16th. Spoke with various staff members. Received emails from constituents for and against the project. Ex parte Items - Commissioner Penny Taylor COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AGENDA October 23, 2018 9B This item requires ex parte disclosure be provided by the Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve an Ordinance amending Ordinance No. 2004-41, as amended, the Collier County Land Development Code, which established the comprehensive zoning regulations for the unincorporated area of Collier County, Florida by amending the appropriate zoning atlas map or maps by changing the zoning classification of the herein described real property from a Rural Agricultural (A) zoning district with a portion of the real property in a ST overlay (Special Treatment) to a Residential Planned Unit Development (RPUD) zoning district for the project known as Russell Square RPUD to allow development of up to 230 multi- family dwelling units on property located east of Santa Barbara Boulevard and approximately 1/4 mile south of Davis Boulevard in Section 9, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida, consisting of 32.9+/- acres; and by providing an effective date. [PL20170004414]. NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SEE FILE ®Meetings Correspondence ®e-mails Calls Met with Rich Yovanovich, Dan Ciesielski, Michael Greenberg & Wayne Arnold on Monday, October22nd. Ex parte Items - Commissioner Penny Taylor COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AGENDA October 23, 2018 SUMMARY AGENDA 17A This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve Petition VAC-PL20180002425, to disclaim, renounce and vacate the County and the public interest in the two Raw Water Well Site Easements and the County Utility Easement (C.U.E.) located along the northerly border of Lot 1 of Alligator Alley Commerce Center Phase Two, as recorded in Plat Book 49, Page 60 of the public records of Collier County, Florida. The subject property is located in the southwest quadrant of the 1-75 and Collier Boulevard intersection, located in Section 34, Township 49 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida. (This is a companion to Agenda Item 17.B). NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SEE FILE Meetings Correspondence >Qe-mails Calls Emails from Rich Yovanovich's office to schedule a meeting then later cancelled the meeting. Ex parte Items - Commissioner Penny Taylor COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AGENDA October 23, 2018 17B This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by the Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve an Ordinance amending Ordinance Number 07-26, the I-75/Alligator Alley CPUD, to allow for the development of up to 425 multi-family dwelling units in addition to the existing permitted maximum 265,000 square feet of office and retail uses and a 107 room motel, subject to a maximum of 1,172 two-way p.m., peak hour trips for the entire PUD; to add an additional Master Plan to reflect the site layout if the property is developed with both residential and commercial uses, and to limit residential uses to the area identified as "C/R;" to add development standards for residential uses; to modify development commitments relating to environmental, transportation, utilities, water management, affordable housing, and land use and project phasing requirements; and to add deviations relating to preserve standards. The subject property is located on the northwest corner of the Collier Boulevard and Davis Boulevard intersection, in Section 34, Township 49 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida, consisting of 40.8± acres; and by providing an effective date. [PL20180000049] (This is a companion to Agenda Item 17.A) NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SEE FILE Meetings Correspondence ®e-mails Calls Emails from Rich Yovanovich's office to schedule a meeting then later cancelling the meeting. GrecoSherry q ., 1k From: GrecoSherry aCe6\ act--c3 ent: Friday, September 7, 2018 1:17 PM To: RummerJason Cc: TaylorPenny Subject: RE: Please confirm the project discussed today with Comm. Taylor Good morning, Yes and for # 5 compare regal acres to Naples Reserve and Reflection Lakes For # 6 Naples Manor compared to Lely Golf Estates # 7 Charlee Estates vs Fiddlers Creek # 8 other neighborhoods to compare Leeward Lakes vs Glen Eagle Country Club, and Leeward Lakes vs. Foxfire Country Club # 9 other commuunity appreciation rates including Moorings the Commissioner is seeking are: • Isles of Collier • Quail West • Port Royale • Pine Ridge • Treviso Bay • Collier Reserve # 10 and # 11 are correct Please do not hesitate to call if you have any questions and thank you very much as always for your help. Skerry ( reco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: RummerJason Sent: Friday, September 7, 2018 11:05 AM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> 1 Cc:TaylorPenny<Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov>; RummerJason <Jason.Rummer@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Please confirm the project discussed today with Comm.Taylor Sherry— Please confirm the project discussed today with Comm.Taylor and I will proceed with preparing it. Thank you, Jason 1. Due date—09.18.18 2. Compare appreciation from 2013 to 2018 3. Use Property Appraiser data 4. DO NOT include commercial properties 5. Regal Acres appreciation from 2013 to 2018 6. Naples Manor compared to Lely 7. Charley Estates to Fidler's Creek 8. Other Habitat to surrounding communities provided by Comm.Taylor 9. City of Naples community appreciation rates a. Moorings 10. Pelican Bay appreciation from 2013 to 2018 11. Pelican Marsh appreciation from 2013 to 2018 All the best, Jason Rummer Operations Analyst er County 3339 Tamiami Trail East, Building H, Suite 211, Naples, FL 34112 Phone 239.252.5505 Cell 239.777.7114 New email address:Jason.Rummer@colliercountyfl.gov Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 co N O N T t0 O O o 0 0 a N Jr) 01 CO CO l7 N O N N M u S 00 M M Jr) N y U o a LU N 0 co J .0 N U N _, V J LID N N > 00N w N y+ Y N U CO U O f- M C W0-; F- >- M Q tD U W w N Z V 00 H t0 N N rr ^ 00 H V to Q' CO oN , N 0 00 j m w m 0 J L 0 C7 w C1 U — >- - H 1 mO w N w m w oon 01 N ZN rel J 00 O w o , O O M Jco Z ,""i r•-• L!1 Ln C O N N O m CO N O W to O co . cN .-i to CO t/T VT t/T l/T I o 0 0 \ \ o 0 0 0 0 0 C N N N 01 M N N O N C V t0 t0 R V = O N M N M to N M 00 u = 01 00 00 V In V M to V in N N NND N CO U 1-1N N Ln N N 0 D. a VI d• M 0 1.11 N Cr V' 01 N ^ t0 CO t0 t0 C C11 00 01 N CO O V V LU V:3 N V N 0- O ^ O N CL 01 mt0 N N 0 ^ 00 t0 00 to N ^ N N 01 O1 Jr) M N 00 O N t0 l0 t0 00 00 N CO CO N ^ m M N oo N CY 00 W N N y N c N N N M N ^ N M M N C.Ci N H M w N w N 0 01 N N l0 N V .0'N 00 l0 T NN Q VT g in. Q in Z N in. M t0 4./1. M VT til. Q V} VT VT VT w 0 0 2 >- 0 0 w0 0 w J J _ 5 a d' CC M O O r` C V Q O1 LU O w O < 0O N d' . 01 N N lD LO to 2 O J N J LO z CC M N ^ CC N N N N Q1 o C}' LO t� tri oo a re; r; ri 00 00 cc of Di LU N N LD N LD Dl 0 C 00 00 0 0 CO LC M N 0' N L!1 00 O O N M on N M r- co- tri N O 0O 00 O7 M c-i O O 00 '-{ LD 0 Dl co 0' .1- 00 N 00 .-1 N N .-i N O N d' N 00 V lD N VT O {/T {/T LT t/T N V} N ,t {/T V1. N VT N in- N in 00 N O N O N Q1 0 CO 00 u N O 4O N to O CO a v 'm CO a a a E O T u M c N U o s 0 N U U E U 4 00 O > O N 0 4- O U O > u O Y Y 0 N CO •O OJ 0 C C U CO O 73 a) o 0J N E U tl0 0 w LM CO E E 0 --`_. W v O 0 E O UN c X U' L O T a — N O T u v L LE C7 w CO a _0 v O 0 O 0 CO O u 0 N 2 co v 0J 21 a 0 E a E v . O C a a U. CO '/' a , C 0 0 E Cl. CO 0 a O U U U O CO _ V1 o r0▪ O ? CO Y Y O a U U CO >' ro _ T u CO CO C — a• ? co t T v U m a w a a Q a Eta C C �0 Q O a > O O C CO Q CO Cl co t6 — — Q L O LL _ O u u CO Y •@ a •5 CO 3 3 �- z O CO o 7a, .� `o = v , t v v CO C U 2 a a a a. Cl cc H CO 0 -J Z CO co CO CO cc • • • • a GrecoSherry From: RummerJason Sent: Monday, September 24, 2018 4:38 PM To: GrecoSherry Cc: TaylorPenny; RummerJason Subject: Rates of Appreciation - by Community Comparison Attachments: Rates of Appreciation from 2013 compared to 2018.pdf; Rates of Appreciation from 2013 compared to 2018.xlsx Sherry, Please find attached the data the Commissioner requested a couple of weeks ago. My apologies for not presenting it sooner. Upon review, please keep the following in mind and let me know if you or the Commissioner have any comments or questions. I will be standing by(239.777.7114). 1. The Property Appraiser was not able to provide data from 2013 for the "Isles of Collier" or"Naples Reserve". Therefore I did not provide a comparison to 2018. 2. It appears due to the high percentages of appreciation growth from 2013 to 2018,that many new housing units were built. I checked Treviso Bay and found that in 2013 there were 187 active housing units and in 2018,those had grown to 1,006 (active housing units). If you would like me to revisit any of the files to look for similar occurrences, please let me know. 3. All data was sourced through the staff of the Collier County Property Appraiser's office (09.20.2018) All the best, Jason Rummer Operations Analyst er unty CCol 3339 Tamiami Trail East, Building H, Suite 211, Naples, FL 34112 Phone 239.252.5505 Cell 239.777.7114 New email address:Jason.Rummer@colliercountyfl.gov Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Percent Rates of Appreciation from 2013 compared to 2018 2013 2018 CHG •Single Family,Condos and Mobile Homes • Collier Reserve $267,577,314 $267,892,685 0.1% • Moorings $2,408,325,244 $3,653,757,164 51.7% • Pelican Bay $4,295,168,743 $6,171,730,463 43.7% • Pelican Marsh $484,424,393 $643,632,284 32.9% • Pine Ridge $442,263,220 $722,388,490 63.3% • Port Royal $2,640,597,270 $3,833,706,055 45.2% • Quail West $248,401,267 $623,878,792 151.2% • Regal Acres $8,046,764 $21,165,024 163.0% • Treviso Bay $49,084,954 $406,462,234 728.1%Please Note:TB had 187 units in 2013 and 1,006 by 2018 Percent Percent Rates of Appreciation Compared by Community from 2013 compared to 2018 2013 2018 CHG 2013 2018 CHG CHARLEY ESTATES FIDLER'S CREEK • Charley Estates compared to Fidler's Creek $11,283,409 $13,467,909 19.4% $401,730,203 $732,719,277 82.4% LEEWOOD LAKES GLEN EAGLE COUNTRY CLUB • Leewood Lakes compared to Glen Eagle Country Club $16,309,610 $37,281,947 128.6% $182,528,725 $238,544,887 30.7% LEEWOOD LAKES FOXFIRE COUNTRY CLUB • Leewood Lakes compared.to Foxfire Country Club $16,309,610 $37,281,947 128.6% $150,530,339 $199,483,014 32.5% NAPLES MANOR LELY GOLF ESTATES • Naples Manor compared to Lely Golf Estates $78,286,158 $199,129,666 154.4% $503,489,538 $794,966,326 57.9% Please Note:All data was sourced through the Collier County Appraiser's office(09.20.2018) GrecoSherry From: RummerJason Sent: Friday, September 7, 2018 11:05 AM To: GrecoSherry Cc: TaylorPenny; RummerJason Subject: Please confirm the project discussed today with Comm. Taylor Sherry— Please confirm the project discussed today with Comm. Taylor and I will proceed with preparing it. Thank you, Jason 1. Due date—09.18.18 2. Compare appreciation from 2013 to 2018 3. Use Property Appraiser data 4. DO NOT include commercial properties 5. Regal Acres appreciation from 2013 to 2018 6. Naples Manor compared to Lely 7. Charley Estates to Fidler's Creek 8. Other Habitat to surrounding communities provided by Comm.Taylor 9. City of Naples community appreciation rates a. Moorings 10. Pelican Bay appreciation from 2013 to 2018 11. Pelican Marsh appreciation from 2013 to 2018 All the best, Jason Rummer Operations Analyst COIe r Comity 3339 Tamiami Trail East, Building H, Suite 211, Naples, FL 34112 Phone 239.252.5505 Cell 239.777.7114 New email address:Jason.Rummer@colliercountyfl.gov Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 GrecoSherry From: Tom Custer <tcuster49@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, October 17, 2018 5:51 PM To: FialaDonna; SolisAndy; SaundersBurt; TaylorPenny; McDanielBill Cc: Mara Foley; Nick Kouloheras; Mike Yancon Subject: Regal Acres RPUD Rezoning Petition Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Flagged Commissioners, Related to the petition submitted by Habitat for Humanity to expand the existing Regal Acres RPUD, currently on the BCC Agenda for consideration on 10/23/2018. I am a resident of Naples Reserve who will be directly impacted by future developments if this petition is approved, and wanted to express my support for approval. Clearly however, due to misrepresentation by representatives of those whom I dealt with to purchase my home saying the beautiful reserve and the serenity of it and the wildlife would NOT ever be affected I would naturally oppose it. Notwithstanding, I/we clearly do not have the right to impact the opportunity for others who need affordable housing to do so since we have been so blessed to have what we have. Since learning of the petition, I, along with my neighbor, have met with Habitat leadership on several occasions to discuss reasonable options for improving the buffer zone between NR and the proposed expansion. The result of these discussions is an 8 ft concrete wall with heavy foliage on both sides (above and beyond what is required by code) to be installed and run along the north and east sides of Habitats property line. Habitat's Landscape Architect provided drawings indicating the physical location of the wall and what it would look like at installation and approximately 5-10 years from installation and submitted these to the CCPC during their 8/6/18 meeting to be considered as part of the overall development proposal. of which I attended and spoke. Considering all of the above, I feel Habitat's leadership team has gone above and beyond to address our concerns relating to the preserve area that will be developed. In addition, they agreed to communicate to their designers and Trade Contractors to ONLY remove what non-native plants that must be and preserve as many existing plants and trees from their landscape mound to the fence on NR property line with the hopes and expectation little has to be removed. Clearly, as can be seen in the next phase of Winding Cypress along the East Trail and in Beach Resort off 951, little care was given to the removal of trees and plants there. Respectfully, Tom Custer 14603 Topsail Dr. Naples FL 34114 1 GrecoSherry From: Nick Kouloheras <nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Sent: Tuesday, October 16, 2018 12:46 PM To: TaylorPenny Subject: RE: Regal Acres (Nicholas J. Kouloheras - Habitat for Humanity of Collier County) Good afternoon Sherry, I received your voicemail and completely understand. I have a meeting scheduled with Commissioner Fiala at 2:00 so I'm not sure if 1:30 will work. Can we do 1:00 of maybe 3:00 or after? Original Appointment From: Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov [mailto:Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov] On Behalf Of TaylorPenny Sent:Tuesday, October 16, 2018 10:56 AM To: Nick Kouloheras Subject: Regal Acres (Nicholas J. Kouloheras- Habitat for Humanity of Collier County) When:Thursday, October 18, 2018 1:30 PM-2:00 PM (UTC-05:00) Eastern Time (US & Canada). Where: 3299 Tamiami Trail East, 3rd floor, Naples, FL 34112 So sorry for the need to change the appointment due to a scheduling conflict but are you free at 1:30 the same day? Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 GrecoSherry From: RummerJason Sent: Friday, September 21, 2018 4:02 PM To: GrecoSherry Subject: RE: Project discussed today with Comm. Taylor Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Flagged Just got the files I needed. Will have the reports to you late Monday afternoon. All the best, Jason Rummer Operations Analyst Coffre-r County 3339 Tamiami Trail East, Building H, Suite 211, Naples, FL 34112 Phone 239.252.5505 Cell 239.777.7114 New email address:Jason.Rummer@colliercountyfl.gov From: RummerJason Sent: Friday, September 21, 2018 3:32 PM To: GrecoSherry Cc: RummerJason Subject: FW: Project discussed today with Comm. Taylor Importance: High Sherry, I have not received the information I have been requesting from the Property Appraiser's office to complete Commissioner Taylor's request (below). When I spoke with Vickie Downs and Daniel Chiros from the PA office this week,they said with the End of Year work, they do not have much time for special requests. As soon as I receive what I need to complete the project I will have it sent to you. Also, I am awaiting approval to send the City of Naples and East Naples Appreciation Comparison report from my superiors and as soon as I do, those reports will be on the way. My apologies for any inconvenience. 1 All the best, Jason Rummer Operations Analyst o er oiLnt 3339 Tamiami Trail East, Building H, Suite 211, Naples, FL 34112 Phone 239.252.5505 Cell 239.777.7114 New email address:Jason.Rummer@colliercountyfl.gov From: RummerJason Sent: Friday, September 21, 2018 3:15 PM To:dchirinos@collierappraiser.com Cc:VickieDowns<vdowns@collierappraiser.com>; GiblinCormac<Cormac.Giblin@colliercountyfl.gov>; RummerJason <Jason.Rummer@colliercountyfl.Rov> Subject: FW: Project discussed today with Comm.Taylor Importance: High Hi, Any progress? Estimated completion to me please. All the best, Jason Rummer Operations Analyst r County Co*e 3339 Tamiami Trail East, Building H, Suite 211, Naples, FL 34112 Phone 239.252.5505 Cell 239.777.7114 New email address:Jason.Rummer@colliercountyfl.gov From: RummerJason To:VickieDowns<vdowns@collierappraiser.com>; 'dchirinos@collierappraiser.com' <dchirinos@collierappraiser.com> Cc: RummerJason <Jason.Rummer@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Project discussed today with Comm.Taylor Importance: High Ms. Downs and Daniel, 2 I know I have requested much information from you recently and thank you for the support and help. I have been given a task from Commissioner Taylor to compare appreciation rates of various housing developments throughout the county. I thought I could pull the data from the Property Appraiser web site and that said have not been able to do so. Hence, I need to request this data from you unless you can share how I can pull the data myself. Additionally, Ms.Taylor would like to review said data this weekend before the next BCC meeting. What I have been requested to do is below.As soon as possible, please let me know if fulfillment of this request is possible and by when.Thank you. 1. Compare rates of appreciation from 2013 to 2018 for the following communities. a. Provide the market rate residential (single family, condos, mobile homes) property value in 2013 b. Provide the market rate residential (single family, condos, mobile homes) property value in 2018 i. I will compare the communities and provide the rates of appreciation c. The communities are: i. Charlee Estates ii. Collier Reserve iii. Fiddlers Creek iv. Foxfire Country Club v. Glen Eagle Country Club vi. Isles of Collier vii. Leeward Lakes viii. Lely Golf Estates ix. Moorings x. Naples Manor xi. Naples Reserve xii. Pelican Bay xiii. Pelican Marsh xiv. Pine Ridge xv. Port Royal xvi. Quail West xvii. Reflection Lakes xviii. Regal Acres xix. Treviso Bay All the best, Jason Rummer Operations Analyst + er County 3339 Tamiami Trail East, Building H, Suite 211, Naples, FL 34112 Phone 239.252.5505 Cell 239.777.7114 New email address:Jason.Rummer@colliercountyfl.gov 3 From: GrecoSherry To: RummerJason <Jason.Rummer@colliercountyfl.gov> Cc:TaylorPenny<Penny.Taylor(a@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: RE: Please confirm the project discussed today with Comm. Taylor Good morning, 1. Yes and for # 5 compare regal acres to Naples Reserve and Reflection Lakes 2. For # 6 Naples Manor compared to Lely Golf Estates 3. # 7 Charlee Estates vs Fiddlers Creek 4. # 8 other neighborhoods to compare Leeward Lakes vs Glen Eagle Country Club, and Leeward Lakes vs. Foxfire Country Club 5. # 9 other community appreciation rates including Moorings the Commissioner is seeking are: a. Isles of Collier b. Quail West c. Port Royale d. Pine Ridge e. Treviso Bay f. Collier Reserve 6. # 10 and # 11 are correct Please do not hesitate to call if you have any questions and thank you very much as always for your help. sicerrj Clreco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: RummerJason To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Cc:TaylorPenny<Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov>; RummerJason <Jason.Rummer@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Please confirm the project discussed today with Comm.Taylor Sherry— Please confirm the project discussed today with Comm.Taylor and I will proceed with preparing it. Thank you, Jason 1. Due date—09.21.18 2. Compare appreciation from 2013 to 2018 3. Use Property Appraiser data 4. DO NOT include commercial properties 4 5. Regal Acres appreciation from 2013 to 2018 6. Naples Manor compared to Lely 7. Charley Estates to Fidler's Creek 8. Other Habitat to surrounding communities provided by Comm.Taylor 9. City of Naples community appreciation rates a. Moorings 10. Pelican Bay appreciation from 2013 to 2018 11. Pelican Marsh appreciation from 2013 to 2018 All the best, Jason Rummer Operations Analyst Co i er Comity 3339 Tamiami Trail East, Building H, Suite 211, Naples, FL 34112 Phone 239.252.5505 Cell 239.777.7114 New email address:Jason.Rummer@colliercountyfl.gov Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 5 GrecoSherry From: RummerJason Sent: Friday, September 7, 2018 2:16 PM To: GrecoSherry Cc: TaylorPenny Subject: RE: Please confirm the project discussed today with Comm. Taylor Ok,great. Will get on it. Very welcome and my pleasure. All the best, Jason Rummer Operations Analyst Coffre frT County 3339 Tamiami Trail East, Building H, Suite 211, Naples, FL 34112 Phone 239.252.5505 Cell 239.777.7114 New email address:Jason.Rummer@colliercountyfl.gov From: GrecoSherry Sent: Friday, September 7, 2018 1:17 PM To: RummerJason <Jason.Rummer@colliercountyfl.gov> Cc:TaylorPenny<Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: RE: Please confirm the project discussed today with Comm.Taylor Good morning, Yes and for # 5 compare regal acres to Naples Reserve and Reflection Lakes For # 6 Naples Manor compared to Lely Golf Estates # 7 Charlee Estates vs Fiddlers Creek # 8 other neighborhoods to compare Leeward Lakes vs Glen Eagle Country Club, and Leeward Lakes vs. Foxfire Country Club # 9 other commuunity appreciation rates including Moorings the Commissioner is seeking are: • Isles of Collier • Quail West • Port Royale • Pine Ridge i • Treviso Bay • Collier Reserve # 10 and # 11 are correct Please do not hesitate to call if you have any questions and thank you very much as always for your help. sties qreco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: RummerJason Sent: Friday, September 7, 2018 11:05 AM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Cc:TaylorPenny<penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov>; RummerJason <Jason.Rummer@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Please confirm the project discussed today with Comm. Taylor Sherry— Please confirm the project discussed today with Comm.Taylor and I will proceed with preparing it. Thank you, Jason 1. Due date—09.18.18 2. Compare appreciation from 2013 to 2018 3. Use Property Appraiser data 4. DO NOT include commercial properties 5. Regal Acres appreciation from 2013 to 2018 6. Naples Manor compared to Lely 7. Charley Estates to Fidler's Creek 8. Other Habitat to surrounding communities provided by Comm.Taylor 9. City of Naples community appreciation rates a. Moorings 10. Pelican Bay appreciation from 2013 to 2018 11. Pelican Marsh appreciation from 2013 to 2018 All the best, Jason Rummer Operations Analyst 2 Co er County 3339 Tamiami Trail East, Building H, Suite 211, Naples, FL 34112 Phone 239.252.5505 Cell 239.777.7114 New email address:Jason.Rummer@colliercountyfl.gov Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 3 Hi, Any progress? Estimated completion to me please. All the best, Jason Rummer Operations Analyst Calker 9Jun1Y 3339 Tamiami Trail East, Building H, Suite 211, Naples, FL 34112 Phone 239.252.5505 Cell 239.777.7114 New email address:Jason.Rummer@colliercountyfl.gov From: RummerJason To:VickieDowns<vdowns@collierappraiser.com>; 'dchirinos@collierappraiser.com' <dchirinos@collierappraiser.com> Cc: RummerJason <Jason.Rummer@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Project discussed today with Comm. Taylor Importance: High Ms. Downs and Daniel, I know I have requested much information from you recently and thank you for the support and help. I have been given a task from Commissioner Taylor to compare appreciation rates of various housing developments throughout the county. I thought I could pull the data from the Property Appraiser web site and that said have not been able to do so. Hence, I need to request this data from you unless you can share how I can pull the data myself. Additionally, Ms.Taylor would like to review said data this weekend before the next BCC meeting. What I have been requested to do is below. As soon as possible, please let me know if fulfillment of this request is possible and by when. Thank you. 1. Compare rates of appreciation from 2013 to 2018 for the following communities. a. Provide the market rate residential (single family, condos, mobile homes) property value in 2013 b. Provide the market rate residential (single family, condos, mobile homes) property value in 2018 i. I will compare the communities and provide the rates of appreciation c. The communities are: i. Charlee Estates ii. Collier Reserve iii. Fiddlers Creek iv. Foxfire Country Club v. Glen Eagle Country Club vi. Isles of Collier vii. Leeward Lakes 2 viii. Lely Golf Estates ix. Moorings x. Naples Manor xi. Naples Reserve xii. Pelican Bay xiii. Pelican Marsh xiv. Pine Ridge xv. Port Royal xvi. Quail West xvii. Reflection Lakes xviii. Regal Acres xix. Treviso Bay All the best, Jason Rummer Operations Analyst ear County 3339 Tamiami Trail East, Building H, Suite 211, Naples, FL 34112 Phone 239.252.5505 Cell 239.777.7114 New email address:Jason.Rummer@colliercountyfl.gov From: GrecoSherry To: RummerJason <Jason.Rummer@colliercountyfl.gov> Cc:TaylorPenny<Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: RE: Please confirm the project discussed today with Comm. Taylor Good morning, 1. Yes and for # 5 compare regal acres to Naples Reserve and Reflection Lakes 2. For # 6 Naples Manor compared to Lely Golf Estates 3. # 7 Charlee Estates vs Fiddlers Creek 4. # 8 other neighborhoods to compare Leeward Lakes vs Glen Eagle Country Club, and Leeward Lakes vs. Foxfire Country Club 5. # 9 other community appreciation rates including Moorings the Commissioner is seeking are: a. Isles of Collier b. Quail West c. Port Royale d. Pine Ridge e. Treviso Bay f. Collier Reserve 6. # 10 and # 11 are correct 3 Please do not hesitate to call if you have any questions and thank you very much as always for your help. Sferry Clreco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: RummerJason To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Cc:TaylorPenny<Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov>; RummerJason <Jason.Rummer@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Please confirm the project discussed today with Comm.Taylor Sherry— Please confirm the project discussed today with Comm.Taylor and I will proceed with preparing it. Thank you, Jason 1. Due date—09.21.18 2. Compare appreciation from 2013 to 2018 3. Use Property Appraiser data 4. DO NOT include commercial properties 5. Regal Acres appreciation from 2013 to 2018 6. Naples Manor compared to Lely 7. Charley Estates to Fidler's Creek 8. Other Habitat to surrounding communities provided by Comm.Taylor 9. City of Naples community appreciation rates a. Moorings 10. Pelican Bay appreciation from 2013 to 2018 11. Pelican Marsh appreciation from 2013 to 2018 All the best, Jason Rummer Operations Analyst Co er Comity 3339 Tamiami Trail East, Building H, Suite 211, Naples, FL 34112 Phone 239.252.5505 Cell 239.777.7114 New email address:Jason.Rummer@colliercountyfl.gov Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 4 00 N 0 N T t0 0 0 0 o e. C a n to Cl CO 0J 0 N O N n m tJ 2 00 M M to N CO U o a m N D 0 J C N U n 0 yl N r 00 u N W N Y N tY 00 0 F- m C w Ci F- a' > m Q 00 Z 00 N CL Z a F CO F- N 0 U n Ln z ''r w Ct co N to M O oc D ClLL V a N U N O N l J Cl CO J if). J V} 0 in ..n. r a 0 w a — } — i- LL O w N LL m w m isi N Z N X 00 J 00 O LUCO O of m J Z •-1 N C9 t0n 00 a O .H N O rn CO N o 0o 0 O CO 4 N N to a 0 0 N° 0 0 0 \ 0 0 0 0 0 0 C N N N Cl M N N 0 N C V t0 t0 or OJ O N m N M to N m oi, Cl 00 00 R U = tf1 V M t0 V to 0N l., = N N N N c`J U N N N CO LI N N N CL a to 'ct M 0 N N V rt Cl n N 00 CO 00 0 V CI M C1 N M 0 V V t0 t0 N [F1 N Cr O n O N Cl Cl Cl t0 N N 00 ili. 00 to N N N N Cl Cl to M N 00 O n t0 t0 t0 00 co N CO 00 n n 1 M n 00 N C 00 W R N co N 00 N N n M c-i N M M N 00 N F- M — N LU N 0 Cl O t0 1.11 N M N MN N 0 0 Q N Y M Y Mon N N 0 N a N CO 0 V) 4 N F- in. in. in- z N N Cl t0' in. (Yf in- in Q t/T in t/} i/} w 00 0 > 0 0 UJ O O w J '— _- J J Y a N CO Cr O 0 N c? � Q LU 0 U) 0 < co CO N N CN N N N Cl 0 0 J l0 J LD z N CO Ln N N CO N N N N U V N tf1 00 7 cry N N lD V (Cl Cl Cl l0 N N t0 N l0 Cl 0 ct CO 07 0 O CO Cl) (Cl N Cr N V1 ,:r' 0 0 N (Cl (Cl N M N CO V7 7 N O CO W 01 M t-i CO tei W N l0 0 Cl CO cr ct L} d' N N N N N 0 N N V V l0 N CO O L} L} L} L} N L? N Cr L} L} N L} N L} L? i../1. N N 0 N O N C1 O CO 00 V N 0 0 N ti O Cl., 13 ti CO CO 03 p_ a a E o >, U M C N 3 0 _cD O N C U U s 00 5 m N 0 p N >, 3 vn U 0,,0 C v 0 C CO Y M CO CO o V, CO E N an U w s CO 5 as 4- m m E w CO o o U v c co C9 E 0 = T -0 CO x T ate-_ O� C) .0 ii 00 LU CO -0 m — 'no O O J CO N a CO O u No f0 v -0 _0 -O 0 a CO CO o E E no as ro 0 C 0 a a 0. CO CC @ U o 0 o E 3 0 O U 0 0 O CO N 0 ? sv, CO CO Y O CO -C 'V U T i Y T '0 ( CO CO C — 0J >: > (c6 v — 0) CO OJ J J COCCr a3(-.6- c UJ -0 13 C a Cl CC C C - O 5 < O a N O O CC CO 00 _ — v, y CO _ CO 0 3 3 Q LL CO U Ua. ra ¢ 0 0 v O N N E O 0 COon 0 ro Sco ti al U a a a a U cc F- . 0 COJ J Z N CO C CO CO CO in CO CO 00 • 00 • • • • a Rates of Appreciation from 2013 compared to 2018 2013 2018 Percent CHG •Single Family,Condos and Mobile Homes • Collier Reserve $267,577,314 $267,892,685 0.1% • Moorings $2,408,325,244 $3,653,757,164 51.7% • Pelican Bay $4,295,168,743 $6,171,730,463 43.7% • Pelican Marsh $484,424,393 $643,632,284 32.9% • Pine Ridge $442,263,220 $722,388,490 63.3% • Port Royal $2,640,597,270 53,833,706,055 45.2% • Quail West $248,401,267. $623,878,792 151.2% • Regal Acres $8,046,764 $21,165,024 163.0% • Treviso Bay $49,084,954 $406,462,234 728.1%Please Note:TB had 187 units in 2013 and 1,006 by 2018 Rates of Appreciation Compared by Community from 2013 compared to 2018 2013 2018 Percent 2013 2018 Percent CHG CHG CHARLEY ESTATES FIDLER'S CREEK • Charley Estates compared to Fidler's Creek $11,283,409 $13,467,909 19.4% $401,730,203 $732,719,277 82.4% LEEWOOD LAKES GLEN.EAGLE COUNTRY CLUB • Leewood Lakes compared to Glen Eagle Country Club $16,309,610 $37,281,947 128.6% $182,528,725 $238,544,887 30.7% LEEWOOD LAKES FOXFIRE COUNTRY CLUB • Leewood Lakes compared to Foxfire Country Club $16,309,610 $37,281,947 128.6% $150,530,339 $199,483,014 32.5% NAPLES MANOR LELY GOLF ESTATES • Naples Manor compared to Lely Golf Estates $78,286,158 $199,129,666 154.4% $503,489,538 $794,966,326 57.9% Please Note:All data was sourced through the Collier County Appraiser's office(09.20.2018) GrecoSherry From: GiblinCormac Sent: Friday, September 7, 2018 1:51 PM To: GrecoSherry Cc: GrantKimberley; SonntagKristi; CarnellSteve Subject: Habitat Appraised Values Presentation Attachments: Regal Acres II CCPC Appraiser Presentation 090718 .pptx Sherry- Jason Rummer from my staff let me know that the Commissioner called him this morning and asked that he run some value comparisons for several areas of the county using data from the Property Appraiser's Office as he has done for her in the past. Jason is coordinating with the Property Appraiser to get the needed data and is working on her request. Also of interest to the Commissioner might be the attached presentation/analysis that was given by a professional real estate appraiser on behalf Habitat at yesterday's CCPC meeting. The presentation is very thorough and well sourced. Several of the CCPC members commented publicly that the quality of the study"swayed" them to vote in favor of the project. I believe it may get to some of the answers that the Commissioner is seeking with Jason's research. Let me know if you have any questions. Respectfully, Cormac Giblin,AICP Housing and Grant Development Manager Colter Comity Community and Human Services "Making our Community Stronger: One life, one home, one project at a time." Collier County Government 3339 East Tamiami Trail, Building H., Suite 211, Naples, FL 34112 Phone: 239-252-2399 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 0 0,) 2 co U cn CC 1— W �— CI- J C J W (13 4-1Q °)_ .• . . Q m gym.; 0 Cill Z Ztin E***7**ff#0...**W.A. N 11111:11( ‘0 1.4 0 C ce O, :,,Filliiiii N r- N Q m , = ›M O a O ;; y Q . uc E w m y a a ,,,,iiii. t/) l I- I i.: 0:1 a� aa al 0111) a a) N ce CI 'a V J r a U to CD } i * a H 4 3y t .., H i ) 1 y °� l ✓ � ,,,N ,,,,, . J • ...'T.A.,.. /7, ....,__,A, _..4, '10.-4 , ',..4144i' N. R !G \,/itil 1 iiiY W itO �_t 8 '�,, Y Z--......Z--......-}....ter 5 ? S Qh. 0 r- }}}g???m i � _ .1 -,` *-it r ! ,-- 111.5_i?. t. . t $iEli <IC 1 -.'. .t.,,,,,-'V,, 7 LiJ Fa cC inm ge W _ ta� ., W �� W 2 NW J N - ¢'g V -• O Q } I . �O O C 14) i's � yt o CN r- .. ,.: N .,-� ..-f ..-i m o yv m Tr .,. m " . .. _ K E N OA 0 ON .-1 NNN 0 o46 .-I I-1 iR N .-I C C VP W A' O MO C•J = O i H O L inn= 0 0 0 0h N ri.0 0 00 0 N t00 t00 In 0 MIMEO (1) W CO N In N 0 t0 LC 0 ri co InN0 Ch a) a C CO M 7 N Ib M co a CD CD to •) tR df tR til til if) iR illm Q o �mini 2 CO 0CCO3 QCle � L e N inM 7 0 0 CO) 0 CO 0 t0 N N O N 0 N a. N O o si N O O N ti O 00 n V1 1( in. N N 4-1 H H H M U i LL. O Q Q -I-. _ O ➢ C C C CO) -O il O C O C C _O 'd - 03 O i cn > O o(0 0 m .m Q V U O0l aC +�N i3C (OroIQNVMmO C ° A tDotn_° W� No 79 0 c OO N 1 0x - U N C 4N) C wmNNOowCOOV C28 N 2 ::../_...,,,,,r4.4.:',..A.......,. CI c 73 CO C -p) O O U 0 N OC O "O a . a m c aV . `ii)@ , Uaa 'V - a) Z •Ua a -oo o m m H adm m 0 uN .,, c c 0U O VV N :2 l'''') a+ [, N- i LU EO o CI 4 " _ co I 0.w • • 0 Z W :. • , Os . C ` C Q P..4. `,• . ' ' a) LU —.II 1-, may" 1. m 0 0 M o 0- L[) Q + — o NO; _ �; 8 . p a� v400) o � Mj _ � a p C O N 8 p 00 - LL am13 0 U. jV N c Q G • 4- N W Q Z X c J Cr '47 E- W a) `c() c N H ti)ce O O coo N W 41 O N 47)- 0 lift - 01-- Oce L Li `*' O O O W O 0 O 4. ..,.� a) Lc) Li) O ...I m H r- N N � ce) H �O NF..... 1-t)-- ,ttl v>. Z Li_ ,a� u.' O c 'all").....1 te) -1—C } QO Oa) 0 0- ceOd '2 O ZQ IN E E ce Z cx D _ Q L,uE .E .0 .5 W •� >C -.� 0 a) m Q Ln .z.... ...1 Q Q —‘ eq\-AfriA W ; 4CC (,) u) ti ,t Z5 E Lo — p il 0 Om O MU M N !. ILLI ILL. a) 3 0 0 -. W H 08 = CX isal a) O m i o% O co csi U.. c/) & V" O ' a 0 CI. 4) p 0 •z....V } N A, ` : ,Q 0 W 0 Ca Q� 0 ET...I <4W Q 4) Q ,›Q • 4 . 4( I% tt' Z. T, iii w . Greenway Rd.. ,:i.4'.7.4"'" Ni. 1"\ 4--I / ,.klit { ; '''' '-'. i 'cf. ti fe, W amu► 44.y tet-* •*', H I _ 4. c,`° J Y _- +r; " . « , it ./�'Y *4*,,` A. t a e I 1 t r at. 3 a _ . � c= it z4 Yea `tii . )i�1� 'I 1481111111 17;t'' i*" �. - 9858 Lh *'14'11-44-":11'4':...1:1111 r : 1':140; : ' ° : ' M�jeuadwt pn#H�ssa�e �,� �- � �`a a! �, 1' .,X + ; t 'rMxr�l, x .. .rtii . Q 1 - . , 1• 1 . to'. C ,) I..., 00 I _1 4-; N u_ . _c) - >- 0 $._ c) 42/ 0- CCS 0 U_ (1.) = . L_ C 0 0- cl) cc; t.r) vs cs.. t...0 Lrs ,:-..,.., I' ,' .- 1. N N E ...;1,-.. .,. ,„::::.- , - -v)- o , '-.7z:: -;-;.".* ;',..4. .. . _ - r.,,... ,,,,.,•. ,..... ,..--.. ' - „ . o V) .• 2 rn ... ,-- i'•' ,.; . . , .. 1 >. (13 II C ..; (I) CU -: :3LIM 7 CU -,: . f...„-u•-.$.;:A - ' .... ._ 4 0 ',-11V. - .. b r . .' 11 '41111 4 ,11i11 1, , 1$1Akti 00 = 1:litt/4"N 00 < = ( 1 f / (N1 J (.9 .1-.) u_ . >- - ,_ © . - A tax C 42, 0 ii -- — vo 4:3 ,i,, ,1(it 4.s 0 . - I " ,,1— I-L- If) LO N i.n- < 5-4,:::i!'er..„,::'//i .:,.;i',--4i---,,5-, C 71" Ln ..*.itv''''''"ii •— N N N _ _. . 0 -1- -''' *it. ._....,,..,-....., I-------i ,-.;;... . ., . ".;." 0 , 0 - Nis ,,, 01 1-..„, . 9 CD �s N \I...11 \ > , C.C.y t 0 / ,. r,. �.E - . . 0 4 'a- , r ir,i1:- ,,,,,,,, 4:1( , ‘°, s' r b 'k dP "�.. .114 #� J r.,, ':k i. 2 .:-.. N :ate xt-:==-4-.w ' + : , , a itir-4:71 '1 o Itti3aisi csi4;1- N CNI M tali' . . a . . 0 !# W H .6 . N a t/1 0 t/) 0 0 i ...,,, W .t� .V 0 °"..''' m � m0 _ . .- a . a 0 N V-) L 42 0 tt +- c •- O I \Jgilt O 2 �, i O ---fi.1 it ::1,;41'il:::1,:i.4,I-..t--I ••-',,,;'...4..,t,1-,vt,-;,,,-',„„,.;.,::.-_.,.::,, F --i----- U c, . Q c O 0 CU1 CU 0 CI) ro C c .11114,/,,... . 4";,• ``.;) :.l'',..,:..'Xi:*,C16..;7'. -.r.7. ' -.;'7 .1'W.4.C.t.11i,,,, '''' .41.77,i.. ,,, s f. 71; ?� —Q Y� r T Al ° ;U z . a a i 0 : U = W 4J ' O 43it i 1 1, Co .° r Gra ‘2,.. o, s= O ,P ' ,t-'"dl d o_ > t - -,-::. („3.'• 0 ..-0 - ' °,,,,._ 7°' . : . ..-; '-,„. _ -- (1,-*-,s....‘ .4.,,,,,,, ,0 •`' :-...0.,...„4:---- o_ E �� a cb`0 ; ,. 1.-,, T ,7_ .,.4 ,, Ct "I` , ::r i , 4 , . , . .,..,....,- , . - 1\ ,.:. co 4 : , fr.,- - 0 _ .. r' w N � ' _. w x M W Z W Z Q W Z Q N 111111111111111 ( 4 Z 0 N �' 1 Q N J `` ..L 4 }' g 6 Z ,, .. 410 ay u ,. } t� - L_1 8 (N ci) r— I * . . Lt) v- LI) v. N N H N CD I. OW 1, U. I ' LL. • M .., M N •<ic ..,-,-,:i _ ( ) O N O t/n O Nn O...,. LD 1.1 f. , = ::. . (1) Q N O N O N O LU - .V 0 .V -p .V V . -O 0 : .- a_ y CL y y 0. y r' m Ntn Mm - 0 ,,,,...:,....,,i, 0 N N 0 1 "e' 'IA it. '!'t' ''-' T- .-...,174r , - "' '.; ''. 4. '1-- ' - , '',`: '-' "..„4. . ' ' , 4 :_l.Iiiitiliti t _ - , a .� o do ; , s- _jnom 4. N 016104 () v ek N-1--a- 7.--, .., ----..-".."4*,,ei."... ° - .0 *i- Co �i, i. t i :.: ._. p ..' z ac ''',..'::_,,,49f,...!,,,,, Y ar', o IYl 1. LU a 'tmini 1- 0- t Z --__ N g a m cz N CN _ N _ • ''.7.'.-5, --N %O.O O � • � ;.W imill r•• tn r"." t.") .40i-r-,-17,1,-,4).*e ,,,I=f-,,,,,,,,,-...„.„,... ,.., - ...r. <c t. ', ti}, .ti>. = ,=_,___..... ,.,: ,, ,=. =,,,,= =,-. . . - , .LL W tJ LLO� �- 11.4O F— :.4,-_. O wON (11, alt • 41) (I�'g 1 LI O O :- C • (D ' OO N N 1. a Nf •_ a .? o -o (D a) -C = O •= OO C .y t1 O O •_ 0 0) .0 C .? H — > O C 'y D . O — O U a. x O DC4cE N O 0 a� t/) = c ..co0) N iii O C D = D :1 D - O O 0 V :Cy ° ' � a0 * a) u) o W .71 ci- v wFiL LU 0 c >, "c ii;" OD H = O N (..) o a D e_0) 4••• L 0 Q coa. oma° a� 0) y 'O ,O 'O I `�' .� s OC " 0 . C -�- 3 Cu'CHO = i O � � OQV 0) - • V o g = O O .0 d? f , Collier CountyCommunity ,. .s_ Housing Plan ,. , ,._ ., , . ., „.•„,,,,,,.• , _ ._. ... . ._.. .., ....,._____ .. _ , . .. ___. ,, __ G ___ ,__• ,_ . . .. r_______ _i . ,-. . . , . _ __.__ .......... ,,-.7. , ; - Affordable Housing Dispersion 5/31 /18 A. 1 ,i,..""j', 1.1r, •al• t . Dispersion FL Statues Section 163.3177(6)(f)1 g 163.3177 Required and optional elements of comprehensive plan; studies and surveys. (6) In addition to the requirements of subsections (1)-(5), the comprehensive plan shall include the following elements: (f)1. A housing element consisting of principles, guidelines, standards, and strategies to be followed in: a. The provision of housing for all current and anticipated future residents of the jurisdiction. b. The elimination of substandard dwelling conditions. c. The structural and aesthetic improvement of existing housing. d. The provision of adequate sites for future housing, including affordable workforce housing as defined ins. 380.0651 (3)(h), housing for low-income, very low-income, and moderate- income families, ... e. Provision for relocation housing and identification of historically significant and other housing for purposes of conservation, rehabilitation, or replacement. f. The formulation of housing implementation programs. M ?he creation or preservation of affordable housing to minimize the need for additional local servrces and avoid the concentration of affordable housing units only in specific areas of the iurisdiction. Dispersion Florida Statute 163.3177 Florida Statute 163.3177 is a State Statute, not a local regulation The statute specifies regulatory process requirements (specifically the Comprehensive Plan) It does not specify, limit, or oversee market decisions by an individual land owner It prohibits planning or regulatory restrictions that allow the development of affordable housing only in specific areas leading to concentration Periodic analysis of County County's regulations confirm that there are no local codes or restrictions that lead to concentration of affordable housing The intent of the regulation is to encourage affordable housing everywhere, which, when allowed or required by regulation, has the effect of avoiding concentration in any one area Collier County Housing Plan 4 Updated Defi .nit.ion Affordable Housing Definition Under 30% spent on housing Tracking and Restricted Unrestricted, Market Rate Re•ortin• 6,798 78, 127 >National Standard Definition Collier County Housing Plan Updated Definition Extremely Low Affordable Housing- Housing is c o - 30% affordable to a household when a Very Low � residential dwelling unit with 0 31 - 50% monthly rent or monthly mortgage = 0 Low payment, including property taxes .72 51 - 80% and insurance, is not in excess of 30 Moderate 0 percent of that amount which 12. 81 - 120% represents the percentage of the Q Gap median annual gross income for the 120 - 140% household. Dispersion- Approved Affordable Units ...LIAR C COMM. NOOSING LOCATION Nu•r C•0111111,111001 ourus♦ uasmNSIrust usLam N District 1 - 758 built ( 11 %) �' �,. c i District 2- 766 built ( 11 %) '`— l' �- t._ District 3- 2,002 built (29%) 4 � District 4- 1 ,200 built ( 180) =rc --'� �, - �� District 5- 2,072 built (31 %) 1, Y , - Total built 6,798 units • r L -,. . _ .1 iy Dispersion- Reasonably Priced Units p7 Property Appraiser Residential Unit Market Values December 2017 it 4, ..':;4 fi_`' Total Units lessrtent of P'''''' Commissl0n 5s0,000- $1 32'00 To6 its less natl.,. $250,000+ Than$250,000 In Total Units DI t Su5,000 5200,000 5250, 044ViR.. 1 01St 1cT in $2506Min ,,s.H..., 5 2,818 6,155 7 % ,084 7,701 16,062 23,763 11.6% 67.6 3 1,723 9,791 8152 14,378 19,666 34,044 16.6% 57.8% 1 5,811 12,566 14,579 27,178 32,956 60,134 29.3% 54.8% 4 2,390 9.624 7,664 22,028 19,678 41,706 20.3% 47.2% rrtiaA« 950 5.938 10,383 28,542 17,271 45,813 22.3°£ 37.7% 11115:MIEFIEMIIIMMINICESEMEMEMMUMEMEI100.0% MEZIWW12111.1EMMEMIIIIETZEMIMTIM= 100.0% -- Property Appraiser Residential Unit Market Values December 2017 District , AMI<80% AMI B0-120% AMI 120-1404: AMI 140% n Disk M District SrtUnits in County District 5 20.6% 14.0% 14.8% 7.7% 16,062 23,763 11.6% 67 6% 3 12.6% 22.2% 17.0% 14.4% 19,666 34,044 16.6% 57.8% 1 42.4% 28.5% 30.5% 27.2% 32,956 60.134 29.3% 54.8% 4 17.5% 21.8% 16.0% 22.1% 19,678 41.706 20.3% 47.2% 2 6.9% 13.5% 21.7% 28.6% 17,271 45,813 22.3% 37.7% Total 13,692 44,074 47,867 99,827 105,633 205,460 100.0% 51.4% Percent 6.7% 21.5% 23.3% 46.6% 51.4% 100.0% Property Appraiser Data 11/12/17 Anclys0 of Property Appraiser's'Market Value'of all Residential Units Methodology Includes:Sngle Family, Multi-Famihy,Condos,Mobile Homes,&Trailers,Excludes:Timeshares,Boarding Homos,Co-opt,Miit. Saturation and Need Zillow.com Search 5-3-18 All Units for Sale Less than $250,000 (incl.Single Fam,Multi-Fam,Condo,Townhouse,& Manufactured e^,, seri «,.,wx: asm:rw3, «uma :..W. n..o .. .:.:,.,w q mow ,,.,,. _.. 4 •+ix,,,.. row""..trwk- o,ox..- _.w as>m,• ,w.. s..... mow :.......-. q •r„u.. asM:.szus- n.h,.- ,..�. s,. k,,.. vA warn Naples FL Rea Naples FL Real 111211 = MR a C ' (4 trIm, . m ci 024- nits r-ove a, •' ®e_ 4. i vitt V d ..„„a,_, ...„ - ,� { `' 7a 499• r Ens eit H ,i,, V evkw S"Zgr---is:. s 83 .—a�rw US41 East & Collier Blvd Immokalee Rd & I-75 Saturation and Need 9 NABOR Search 5-3-18 All Units for Sale Less than $250,000 (incl.Single Farn,Multi-Far,Condo,Townhouse, &Manufactured Residential lot Md Land Rentals Residential Income Colnrnerci. .. Residential ISOMIXt 684`Rdntaia' ;... :- Number of Matching••• iiiipNumber of Matching Pro•iiiiiiip I Lr .. +• .... N Price: ti are' ar:h • • ® N Preference ... max.PrieC. -r' Satellite a'Ss ...... • 3 5250.000 ... .. ». 'ww - n-.::-a J 1.. iY -., Hold Cntl.Tel4d.-aelvR .....- 4a per, .�tYx .� .�" ,. ,„.. sew ti,••• ,w ...y Mtn.Sy.Ft.: t P._ • .• . .... No Preference •• e i w ... Max.S Preference w aYm P en .-.. y • w • NP efe r v ii _ _. _ »-[tel._—___—. 1 BaEl _ t.�1 atP SdE:'yS� tttt MI fl 4N r `� ♦ {'i k«t ka, kill nod sou b-�a..N«t F- • ..e . r. . ` ' ' Building g 0 gn: y Budding Design: i Single Feely - gle amM L {5e(1-3; Low 4S 1 3 •` Mid Mid Rtse(4-7) t • � Yriftila hg,Ri a e M gh Rise(8+; ,rq„� ., iM�q, E y I)R �9 RI (s+ Townhouse ''% \il ,. villaat * s x:, Waterfront Description: , WMertont Description: 1 mac+ 'y 2 El i tii7,0„,„.teen d Basin ' Google 1 --•.. 1 Bay Google _ ...+"_' +v ,. xma_ +.y, ',caul US41 East & Collier Blvd Immokalee Rd & 1-75 collier county Rental Apartments " i n Process" Possible #Approved #Under # Estimated Affordabilty Units Units Construction Completed Completion Area Comment Restrictions to date Springs @ Sabal Bay 340 340 0 0 2020 East Naples No SDP None Ave Maria Apartments 264 250 0 0 2022 Ave Maria No SDP None Inspira at Lely Resort 304 304 304 0 2018 East Naples Under Constuction None Journeys End 483 483 0 0 2021 East Naples Rezoning to Condo None Milano Lakes 296 296 216 80 2018 East Naples rents:1/1=$1,420;2/2=$1,720;3/2=$1,: 0 60 Units ESP Preferance Briarwood Apartments 320 320 0 0 2020 Central Naples No SDP None 111, Legacy Naples New Hope Ministries 304 304 304 0 2020 Central Naples Under Constuction None Under Addison Place(Addles Corner PUD) 250 250 240 0 2020 North Naples Under Constuction None 175 Alligator Alley PUD 425 0 0 0 can not determine Golden Gate No Plans Submitted None GMP Amendment in Process.PUD Pine Ridge Commons 400 0 0 0 2022 North Naples Continued None Courthouse Shadows 300 0 0 0 2022 East Naples PUD Amendment Required None Livingston Rd/GG Pkwy Residential Subdist 382 0 0 0 2022 Central Naples GMP and PUD Amendments Required None The Crest(in Vecentian PUD) 200 200 200 0 2020 East Naples Under Construction 2 Units Gap Preferan Totals 4268 2747 1264 80 Orchid Run Apts**Market Comparison** 1/1=$2190 2/2=$2648 3/2=$3164 Saturation and Need - Jobs are everywhere1.1 Census Mapping Tool Jobs Concentration ' . � S. ' .. .44; 4' ' c., 'i ' ..‘" * a a ; US41 East & Collier Blvd Immokalee Rd & 1-75 17,233 Jobs 16,266 Jobs 22%Less than$15,000/yr 21%Less than$15,000/yr 46%$15,000-$40,000/yr 32%$15,000 $40,000/yr 32%$40,000+/yr 47%$40,000+/yr Questions 2 aJ �+ i s GrecoSherry From: Nick Kouloheras <nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Sent: Thursday, October 4, 2018 2:42 PM To: TaylorPenny Subject: Accepted: Regal Acres (Nicholas J. Kouloheras - Habitat for Humanity of Collier County) 1 GrecoSherry From: Sue Thomas <KAMConcretePumping@live.com> Sent: Wednesday, September 5, 2018 1:31 PM To: TaylorPenny; FialaDonna; SolisAndy; SaundersBurt; McDanielBill; StrainMark Cc: Vicki Smith Subject: A must read before your Habitat Vote tomorrow Richard and Susan Thomas 14579 Manchester Drive Naples Florida 34114 Sept 5, 2018 Collier County Commissioners and Planning Commission Liaison Growth Management Dept. /Zoning Services Section 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 Dear Mr. Bosi, Mr. Cohen, Mr. Bellows, Ms. Fiala, Mr. Solis, Mr. Saunders, Ms. Taylor, Mr. McDaniel, Mr. Mark Strain,Mr. Feyer, Mr. Schmitt, Mr. Dearborn, Ms. Homiak, Mr. Sabo: I feel that this is a done deal all ready and this board doesn't care about this area at all. I hope and pray that I am wrong. Do you realize that we are saturated with low income housing all ready which is why Costco and Sam's won't put a store here because the area is saturated with low income families. You have heard concerns about over flowing trash cans, street racing along Greenway, kids cutting through woods into our development, the noise level is all ready loud, boom boxes in the middle of the night, kids where they don't belong yet you are probably going to approve more two story residences behind our homes. This new development will make things even worse because there will be no garages—so that's more people in the home, more cars outside and no place to put the garbage cans—which has created a bear problem —no one in the older development puts the cans in the garage. Nick Kouloheras will tell you have they have an HOA but obviously the people who live there really don't care and don't have ownership pride. Nick Kouloheras, glibly stated that he would look into a wall for us and then the next meeting he said they really don't have the money for it. Additionally, my son owns a concrete pump company and I offered a discount on doing the fill cells in the wall, I have received no call from Habitat which tells me they have no intention of protecting Reflection Lakes. Habitat, no money? Really— I think not, I would like to know the amount of the last fund raising letter sent out brought in. They have plenty of funds and the cost to install the wall is minimal when you are looking to divide that between so many units. If this was your home Penny Taylor, what would you want? I know that you don't care at all about East Naples. You must put in a wall—preferably on top of a berm. I lived in Golden Gate City for over 10 years, it took me a long time to save enough to move out of there and now you want to put a getto behind my home. Nick Kouloheras says it won't affect the appraised value—probably not since that's the taxable amount but when you make an area undesirable, which this vote will do,you have just cast a death sentence on property values in this area. I'm 61, I have no time to recover from this vote. I was planning on being able to refinance my home so I can stay in it—but that won't happen because you will be cutting the value of our property tin Reflection Lakes. Here is a visual of what you are destroying just in case you can't understand what I am saying. 114,14. 4' ' 'il,Ickt,,,,,t4 1 r. , _ .7,,,`',,e::1::-„,..„,,,,''- ' -, ;.,1 ,,,,,,,:,__:,..-4.,,,,.., *it +,"y,�, *t''* - I ft ' t?t I can't imagine this gone—the deer come all the time to Reflection Lakes, 4-5 of them at a time. This is Regal Acres 1 -:`-' --' ' 4141** ... _0 a _ " ,-. fr a There were at least 9 homes that had full driveways and flowing in the street 2 ��'. ., ��M;.:o- ,'• 1'y£�,� ::..- eft s s Uncut grass and garbage cans outside—this is our bear problem r it Oft 444* ,w„,„ 11111111111.1111111 be ,f 3 4, :4»... a✓8 More can's outside t . `� ._.mss _ z Driving commercial vehicles on the grass i IN I If the wind blew it over—couldn't you pick it up- no pride in ownership here. 4 nu v: g � � 11 And finally—the boat and ry storage yard—but I have to pay to store mine but I will have to look at theirs. Please do the right thing—Give us a wall, on a berm—not a fence—your sticking a basketball court in our backyard—the noise and the boom boxes will be never ending. Please help Reflection Lakes maintain their safety and quiet. Sincerely Rick and Sue Thomas 14579 Manchester Dr Naples, Fl 34114 5 Blessings, Sue Thomas KAM Concrete Pumping Inc. PO Box 990237 Naples, FL 34116 Office: 863-223-5176 Dispatch: 239-913-7277 FAX: 888-413-7844 Ilk, 6 GrecoSherry From: Michael Yancon <michael.yancon@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, October 17, 2018 3:05 PM To: FialaDonna; SolisAndy; SaundersBurt; TaylorPenny; McDanielBill Cc: Tom Custer; Mara Foley Subject: PERTINENT INFORMATION > Regal Acres RPUD Rezoning Petition Attachments: Naples Reserve Rezoning Support Flyers.pdf Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Flagged Commissioners, Relating to the petition submitted by Habitat for Humanity to expand the Regal Acres RPUD, currently on the BCC Agenda for consideration on 10/23/2018. I am a resident of Naples Reserve who will be directly impacted by future developments if this petition is approved, and wanted to express my support for approval. Since learning about the petition, several residents of Naples Reserve and I have met with Habitat on multiple occasions to discuss reasonable options for improving the buffer zone between NR and the proposed expansion, above and beyond what is required by code. The result of these discussions is an 8ft wall with heavy foliage on both sides to be installed and run along the north and east sides of Habitats property line. Habitat commissioned the creation of sketches and diagrams showing the physical location of the wall and what it would look like, and submitted these to the CCPC during their 8/6/18 meeting to be considered as part of the overall development proposal. Considering above, I personally feel the Habitat team has gone above and beyond to address our concerns relating to the preserve area that will be developed. I have also attached signed flyers from 31 other Naples Reserve residents indicating their support for re-zoning, most of whom own homes that will in some way be immediately impacted by this development. Respectfully submitted, Michael Yancon 269-720-9702 Naples Reserve 14595 Topsail Dr, Naples FL 34114 michael.yancon@gmail.com GrecoSherry Subject: Nick Kouloheras - Regal Acres Location: conf call - he will call our office I Start: Fri 10/19/2018 10:00 AM End: Fri 10/19/2018 10:30 AM Recurrence: (none) Organizer: TaylorPenny 1 GrecoSherry From: Lisa Lefkow <Ilefkow@habitatcollier.org> Sent: Friday, September 7, 2018 11:13 AM To: GrecoSherry; TaylorPenny Subject: Matt Simmon's presentation Attachments: Appraiser's Report.pptx; Affordable Housing Dispersion 053118-1153.pdf Here you go! Please let me know if you need anything else! I want to be sure that you also have the county housing staffs presentation on dispersion of affordable housing. Blessings, Lisa Rev. Lisa B. Lefkow Chief Executive Officer Habitat for Humanity of Collier County 11145 Tamiami Trail E. Naples, FL 34113 239-775-0036 (office) 239-595-1111 (cell) 1 0 -4—) 2 = 2 c (:-...,,, 0 c) Om cr, CI N Z (z) W L = Q COJ J 0 W ) Q co 2 s 0 CI Z 'C N ill< = IX O O% 0L: %C. y N 0 X ›M .Q he CL m N < 1 C a)<IC .MI 0 a o E W v _ W _ .,,. ., _,,,„,,,,,_.„:_.,,, gMl P.M" 11111 $1CC (/) 3 0 13 cea 13 U vJ } H v H Y ', {4 {2 F f,�, v '11,4e,\I -74 f.;' • i 1 /„..,,:tif;.11 - 't . i I ; ' 1 lit t'Iff.'Nf. .: If-- If: i I . .-Af ' -f 1 t , 'r I. p, ,,,,.,,,,,, ,_ ,, £ t In t\a ,t , r `�e -:„:47,'0' .1... 4.1 a 3 dr ,,,, jj _ 1,rr A. 4 ' ., . .X.:- ,, Jig.--4 �} 0 X jJ x -t t 1 2 0 ;„, 4CC ''' ' , i ' - *dam -+.,�c-•>, ..y-` ` NI . ` . r tee; 'a © <IIC ..'ty # I'' - * IJ ii e L Iz C o Oui C QO • 5 ♦.... o Q a_ o= 4 § . `41:1O 2 T � • wNr r . • • • . . ._ . . , ,.0 d„. , 1., ,,- Q o�/ �_W !.::,:s 1,i21.;i1L �-0 I o NcO Oo -m c W ic..: !.,% :,,, r,..,,,,,,,,o mONm �$wY_tNOYU: N11O N tO0`YWM i NMaM N(1)o . ,, aCkL wN I00 0 0OO oN MUQ °H o. C U) "> m O N NN V C Q VP C J N C C N oO p C C U dNm ( 0 . Eam mm2o- m 2 o Z - 8 3 O F3 8 o ,w V . 7a8 m mn Y E . -Q o0 va ,Ilm -° s c > m ° m 08mommmo t CU o 4_, O LI_ CC u C0 m I- 1-= 2 = e-1 N M Cf LA to N 00 al * = %%us/ c > cO0 a + 1 , . . a W = $ ,- O b zr ` ,1 N i t,µ • CC �� U • rl[.`ta _i Q o O O* z. .- V2 M 0 N p i DC O C CO O 13) 401F I,LO. 73 0 L •-LCCO c Q C • H W §f `t*T 1 Q Z _• _. _• ci. COm el O O o0oi, N UJLift i 0 V o O O CL W � ......II c1:11 r- N N �— %4::z O N 'CC ZZ Law } LLI O i.. } Q a) _ a. a) Z Q E ce Lt) E E o Z 1:e•ct uji en � c .15. E . (D ..... c o ...., uj, _um. ....., Q Lr) 1Q 1 W Cr 4C (/) tit C Z a) UUmJ E k 0 Q 0 1111111111111116. O Csi Liml Li.. a) 8 Q F,„„ N O O 'W 4) cp.tL NI- 0c° •_ cp. O u.. M W u` O 0 Q. 4) O } 0 rift% Co •v H W .4:. _ 10 CO Ce W Q CD Q ......Q r. ,` I ` _,, ., ., o` . . .._6: ,f'-6-'..1 - „r.,,, .,..,,,,. ..:... .. ..,_, „.,, 10 **- y* re **, t T., } s a--+ . Nr W11, I a) • a� `� CO U t%� =o' �� N— rr` �a Q LU i, J N ?� M 7,"•' _ mown , r, r Q ,*. . '�. *..\ * ftoyAWw! �tta< ,, # #� e i0 '"+i s} tfFuadw� � JPLAitlsl pNt hi �`' ' � ?,'1 ► . � I 1. 1 /i D 0CO 2 o � w U Q >.• O fB O L = p C O O- Q1 (7Ln V) Q Q t�%1 up l fl v1 N I va, v;'s ". V •1 I (/') (13 ,yt ;'t2 . -2 , +Ar , ,0, C :g tIi lf1' S if CO • p I,11/illlt! .—i tt t L O L i _a Ln p 4I O ,s to Lc) N Q k! c �n y O I J e- W :r � ... N 1 O lowt.. , ii Ortrl CV O _, E3 0 N ., , I 14( ,-''.• '''''4;",„,,,, .:_::;;* L''''‘'..-'' 1 f k. . CV N O� Oa l'. r-... M W H�G _ (Ni H N ZH v). t/} p00Ars W N a I )V 0 O 0 N p a) p LU . -� .V !, .....A.A..7...:0 Im Nm 0 ,,e >77- _ a _ • C • a00 N fi O O cn _ C D E s .� .--'' &II U _ z O c6 U O - Ojot .1 . 'a. —1 _1_ ,I, u 4..,,,,:;----.. ' '.:DQ.--, IS) A k CSA ``+t' .• S.... -C '•-'''.' : ' 1,11 ,- 0 _.:, '..'4, v rt9 ,,a *114 ,_ .1).. " f'. / ,., r. CUA t .-� Cj —=z = - ' c� ' ---_ - 7 .. T ism +t4 z a) Z 0 a a I— 0 U CU 0 , � 14' ji*O plitit,,,, CO w' u £'., Gra O0 ''. a 0 f � ��CO 0_ E � 4 � a$t r OmaeV c ` a hk O rtii.: ' ' °,,°6:--1,...',....:::::: - '..,L'-'-',:4,-. '''.'*;;;-\:-71/4,,„,---..\,444.--;:„:42,...'::,----t.-''''''-..8---';---',..4,:%';i1-,,..,.7: -.4..,..-:' a M W Z 4,4r W Z O v) W Z O N v) Z O N > . ON Q Z _, Q I. w W 01 M J '' o 44:74.1, et) CO t11) Cr o N N N N y t/} a) t/� N N. N t. . N W a — a a -i- t/v. -i- t/) t t/) -i- N LI— LL N 1L LL 41Pottlill v. CT CT .� cn OQ � t/ O /) OO (/) OO0a)O v DV vzs a .V � .W . 0 ''' 'oe CL 41) O O O :ii 0 -. . --s--;-!,,I..,;-..- Q f a� ',_ O O O O N N N N f ;m 1.: ,� 0 - , --- ., ''''.',.'":..„_,„,„.".--2----.:4e,:,--. . ,, ,. . . /1-Th8 1 O CC4 d s�.s v o� o�� '..-• .. _ '"':..-.. + # �� • . d CO « i—+- . ,).1 ,1 .4;IF---Or- ! :^ 110 i-i , b c%*) ,,..-- ..., ',k,. ....> 11 i ! 4-:;- it Fit ; tit sit . .,, o •5s i' o �: ti cn . 1 r _, ,,, 3:..3 Z 0 . '* _ _ Q41/41 Q N W ,o a ) o J . 0 ' 0 .- Q •CC t/)- � VI) . . - . . '4,40 M WCT O • O <iic ,.. - ----,„ 0 • 0V - V73 LJ.1 a. 113e 111 1 r'" CO N CO 0 • • 0 O O -� N H • ita a) •F. a) > . ''- O O 0 cr) Li 0 a) a c •c o E >.c c ? •y o Oma- o 2 u 0 .c • C CD CD i C .� N 15 > o 0 .O o O vs } = Q = >` 0 V C� � � o - - oC a, H< 00 -00ar O (D '6 g E 2 uu ..c c Lu 44 c _c 0 u, >' '- -O a) o •y 3 Ce > 1 C D •_ D � O 0 N V • - = t >% c cD o —' o a� 'y Q.o L1J0 > s nap P. 0 c > N = 0 0 QN i0:5 2 run Q 0 o0- .I- C Sr. N � L o 0 .O .N o o Q O� o. O c4,0 N D a O O ,O .o I H t a) • O C : • C 5 � � N H = N N o •— c } = H 230 O y N O m 1 � � �? O QV y C � N c� > a, N C O O w 73 sf) } •N j QO o C o O Q C N .0 > . GrecoSherry Subject: Planning Commission Meeting - Regal Acres Start: Thu 9/20/2018 12:00 AM End: Fri 9/21/2018 12:00 AM Show Time As: Free Recurrence: (none) Organizer: TaylorPenny Categories: For Your Information 1 GrecoSherry From: Nick Kouloheras <nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Sent: Tuesday, October 16, 2018 10:38 AM To: GrecoSherry Subject: RE: Habitat for Humanity Attachments: Capture.PNG Good morning Sherry, Sorry for just getting back to you. I have been feeling a little under the weather and am just now looking at my emails. A Regal I address is 10408 Majestic Cr. I have attached an aerial of the Regal II property which is immediately to the West of Regal I. Via a separate email I will also send a few renderings of the proposed Regal II site. Let me know if there is anything else you may need. Thanks, Nick From: GrecoSherry [mailto:Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov] Sent:Tuesday, October 16, 2018 8:32 AM To: Nick Kouloheras<nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Subject: RE: Habitat for Humanity Good morning, Can you please give me the address for the Regal Acres site the Commissioner plans on visiting the site today. Thank you. SIierrj Greco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: Nick Kouloheras<nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Sent:Thursday, October 4, 2018 11:42 AM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: RE: Habitat for Humanity October 18th at 10:00 a.m.would work better. From: GrecoSherry [mailto:Sherry.Greco(Wcolliercountyfl.gov] Sent:Thursday, October 4, 2018 10:55 AM 10 Are you available on Wednesday, October 17th at 10 AM or Thursday, October 18th at 10 AM. Please advise which date and time are suitable for you and please provide a subject for the meeting. Thank you. sherry 6reco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: Nick Kouloheras<nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Sent:Thursday, October 4, 2018 10:23 AM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Habitat for Humanity Good morning Sherry, I was hoping to grab 30 min of the commissioners time. Any day the 15th through the 19th work best for me but I'll take any date or time I can get. Thanks for your help and I hope you are doing well. Nick Nicholas J. Kouloheras President tif Habitat for Humanity' Habitat for Humanity of Collier County 11145 Tamiami Trail East I Naples, FL 34113 Office: 239-775-0036 I Fax: 239-775-0477 Donate Notii www.HabitatCollier.org Follow Habitat for Humanity of Collier County... Tube "I Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 9 GrecoSherry From: Nick Kouloheras <nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Sent: Tuesday, October 16, 2018 10:40 AM To: GrecoSherry Subject: RE: Habitat for Humanity Attachments: Home-View-Final-3DAS.jpg; Neighborhood-view-Final-3DAS jpg Attached Regal II renderings. From: GrecoSherry [mailto:Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov] Sent:Tuesday, October 16, 2018 8:32 AM To: Nick Kouloheras<nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Subject: RE: Habitat for Humanity Good morning, Can you please give me the address for the Regal Acres site the Commissioner plans on visiting the site today. Thank you. SSierrj Clreco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.GrecoCc@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: Nick Kouloheras<nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Sent:Thursday, October 4, 2018 11:42 AM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: RE: Habitat for Humanity October 18th at 10:00 a.m.would work better. From: GrecoSherry [mailto:Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov] Sent:Thursday, October 4, 2018 10:55 AM To: Nick Kouloheras<nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Subject: RE: Habitat for Humanity Good morning, 8 GrecoSherry Subject: Regal Acres (Nicholas J. Kouloheras - Habitat for Humanity of Collier County) Location: 3299 Tamiami Trail East, 3rd floor, Naples, FL 34112 Start: Thu 10/18/2018 1:30 PM End: Thu 10/18/2018 2:00 PM Show Time As: Tentative Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Not yet responded Organizer: TaylorPenny Required Attendees: Nick Kouloheras So sorry for the need to change the appointment due to a scheduling conflict but are you free at 1:30 the same day? 7 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 GrecoSherry From: GrecoSherry Sent: Tuesday, October 16, 2018 3:59 PM To: Nick Kouloheras Subject: RE: Regal Acres (Nicholas J. Kouloheras - Habitat for Humanity of Collier County) Sorry just seeing this message after I sent you a reminder. The Commissioner has stated that she has listened closely to the Planning Commission meeting, reviewed the agenda item and viewed the actual site today. She has suggested setting up a conference call. She is available on Friday morning at 10 AM if you would like but the Commissioner feels comfortable about the item. sherry CTreco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco(a@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: Nick Kouloheras<nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Sent:Tuesday, October 16, 2018 12:46 PM To:TaylorPenny<Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: RE: Regal Acres (Nicholas J. Kouloheras- Habitat for Humanity of Collier County) Good afternoon Sherry, I received your voicemail and completely understand. I have a meeting scheduled with Commissioner Fiala at 2:00 so I'm not sure if 1:30 will work. Can we do 1:00 of maybe 3:00 or after? Original Appointment From:Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov [mailto:Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov] On Behalf Of TaylorPenny Sent:Tuesday, October 16, 2018 10:56 AM To: Nick Kouloheras Subject: Regal Acres (Nicholas J. Kouloheras- Habitat for Humanity of Collier County) When:Thursday, October 18, 2018 1:30 PM-2:00 PM (UTC-05:00) Eastern Time (US & Canada). Where: 3299 Tamiami Trail East, 3rd floor, Naples, FL 34112 So sorry for the need to change the appointment due to a scheduling conflict but are you free at 1:30 the same day? 1 s-ftr Habitat for Humanity' Habitat for Humanity of Collier County 11145 Tamiami Trail East I Naples, FL 34113 Office: 239-775-0036 I Fax: 239-775-0477 Donate Now` www.HabitatCollier.orq Follow Habitat for Humanity of Collier County... f 'Ur You Lao I be Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 6 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: Nick Kouloheras<nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Sent:Thursday, October 4, 2018 11:42 AM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: RE: Habitat for Humanity October 18th at 10:00 a.m. would work better. From: GrecoSherry [mailto:Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov] Sent:Thursday, October 4, 2018 10:55 AM To: Nick Kouloheras<nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Subject: RE: Habitat for Humanity Good morning, Are you available on Wednesday, October 17th at 10 AM or Thursday, October 18th at 10 AM. Please advise which date and time are suitable for you and please provide a subject for the meeting. Thank you. siierrj Clreco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: Nick Kouloheras<nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Sent:Thursday, October 4, 2018 10:23 AM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Habitat for Humanity Good morning Sherry, I was hoping to grab 30 min of the commissioners time. Any day the 15th through the 19th work best for me but I'll take any date or time I can get. Thanks for your help and I hope you are doing well. Nick Nicholas J. Kouloheras President 5 GrecoSherry From: GrecoSherry Sent: Tuesday, October 16, 2018 3:39 PM To: Nick Kouloheras Subject: RE: Habitat for Humanity Thank you and did you get my message about needing to change the October 18th meeting time to 1:30 PM? siierr� 4reco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: Nick Kouloheras<nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Sent:Tuesday, October 16, 2018 10:40 AM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: RE: Habitat for Humanity Attached Regal II renderings. From: GrecoSherry [mailto:Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov] Sent:Tuesday, October 16, 2018 8:32 AM To: Nick Kouloheras<nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Subject: RE: Habitat for Humanity Good morning, Can you please give me the address for the Regal Acres site the Commissioner plans on visiting the site today. Thank you. sherrj CTreco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 4 GrecoSherry Subject: Canceled: Regal Acres (Nicholas J. Kouloheras - Habitat for Humanity of Collier County) Location: 3299 Tamiami Trail East, 3rd floor, Naples, FL 34112 Start: Thu 10/18/2018 1:30 PM End: Thu 10/18/2018 2:00 PM Show Time As: Free Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Not yet responded Organizer: TaylorPenny Required Attendees: Nick Kouloheras Importance: High So sorry for the need to change the appointment due to a scheduling conflict but are you free at 1:30 the same day? 3 a) c 'S • a, 7° iv E � v 0) a) 0 C 0 'H O O _a o ii 0 '� 0 a a) _ •'ia):7 'in N > = I O O O O 0 4- V a _ 2o °' 4 oc o � ° E 6.,<C **-- 0"8 73 o0 tWi) � E � 0) H LU >' ' T3a) o 'y3 > 1 _ D = s 0 en _ • — ci) W O 4- ? 0 a) .y O H LU o > sa0 00 O _ } a) ° z o � Q(i 0 a D 0) 14-o 0c 73 O H •i a) O O a 0) 0. o _ = a) a 0 O t O • v 0 = O = D _ NHO • - O O H O L V } V O AlA+ V N > W W = 0.1 oaa) a' 4- > > R W ,-...,..,,,,t,.........„:1;... -( O N � I 0 ' " tit = d ! /e A 1, 4t- t) ci, -.- r r I II I II ..4.,..._ ,-_ -4, ,t.•.• --44,1-,T...,;•-•-- • I. . i 0 -"-- ,H,..4.-' .3, 0 44...,1--:.ii0,41,40at , .,i.i,isitit.e,' Ir-',-V'm',,-- '''.'7; 71,1,717 'id. .0 „..„,:..„. :, J ,« fig "" N. �'+= —.,,, , 2�r ' l'- -' ' - ' - ''-'11°4'1:' rw---,- -' - ,.,„!, ,„„ , ., . ..,_, . c„, , . �` len ti ' 4 '`t1 "- .�; .k.; ; 'al g i " ,:-...;.„--..—...z,-.;...."..- ,� 0:3 _ ` o t/) ;ZO .--- Q 1)Voi � 0 Z � _- N -�. N ;41 i UJ -1 N 0 ^ Q � U')- V) toli . W ' O O " . fig; N y r .. Q 0. 4. 0 no W ;` R- m Nm 0 _ C • r • II 0 0 0 N lik ,a 73 O O _ -7.- �r Q O . � o N a • 1) u.0 Z LU Z 0 C/1) W Z 0 N C,) Z O N >- 171' 7 0 N J N . ; <E LI'':.' A d. Zmg E , 0 I t I oCIIC -';',...„---:.. , ..„..,.. I N M COW `' •O MJ © • 1.0 G • 'Cr LO acC ,oi -.1-- sr,,s :4 LO N N N N / d' LI— (NI v W 1.A CT .4-_' Omow-O� .�Ot/) ----.44 =t) Cr �t/) O t/) O 0 OOCD W CD . CL N N H CL N �Mr,"3 e,..%L � 0 C • C • _ • . Q0 N N 0 N (I) y_ 4) - O (I) c D •Ez 1-',... " ' *Ili L u _0 g z • O 4J O 1 - a� UvCY '-- ` Q c O , „., E C ,. ter � � o : Wit- > z I,*� -- 13 eto _. , - , .... , L.1 . .4 4 „,,,;.*- .,..J r, _ _ .._ ,,,,,.., ..: , ' ,, „..e.:__- , 4.1. ._ cn I ,,,,,,, ' 4`1.... _ ! �I, i L x . �, . o t1A � - f ? � � 4 • : /11 c Y ^-,, +t-- W 0 U N 4-J 0 CO N _.,� f 0 /` .pvii0/.. - r 'a 0 �n -, 0f CN ,, i ' may . CO .g a O 0 " 1 -, ary w a iiiiiiw drool s, iID O a 4"--ae ail_ ,i r,,a, �O . , x ICC '‘.1 4 S.'-'1'416.'0';'*4• "":' • 4"' "r./ - + -.6. ' + t iciC ,`, - s,"` • 4'r ' .' ' 1 '.... t: ' , 4„iit---...0‘,- i W M g. .� 7��--` Qr O sass N H N H Z t p�W i 4_ ..iiria, u_ N '''Cl( � o � o C.D ...., = W Vv v ..4t i N li m CN m 0 0 ?.. • C Q N 0 el )91 C O 00 I r+ a) Q r� a C L o rrs L O CO Ln Q a Ln E '54N N io O Ni m w 0 ri N cM 6 c Q N (1) Ca (/") . co 4#4, � �fR R bb '.' .; li co Q +_eX o° t. 1/ N Ju dCJ I ',d'd iO c,- lid Lc) (13 1. ,, C O i: i a)e ' ln Qi a1 In�O L as 410 ID Q '' TM: C V} d' Ln TD f _ fir. ,::,..,..::. A t ;,fie a = -7. - craenway Rt .. i ; .. e ... > ' _ 4--t1 dE e (ICI • y W --; y ul e` N d4 y C6 2 t ' _° '# ;; - - R- 1 - �� ^: I _' _.- r 7 y�r�, t i� y A� p Q ''' f s c ' d ,f to, C d 74i x,. da - ''''N'F-- i/Ni44.. • '. . + t CI 9�r,• ,Ls : l ... V ' Lll -',..,Q0.0 i '' -.. ,.."..- "4.0# '4(7'4O)6 : ''''';';1-'- - u a 4‹..,.. m c 1111246,,, i, Q.. ' ...;,`Pd-' ,,,.',,..t.,,,—,4•444-(,,I.:-4.- ._, ----i - - , ''... : f ' 9. i -1;1- -.11 -,.- .. . , u. � _ °i < " <rq• It �Q�i „a ...--4.—,,t7 _: k ~! • •:tuig-L-, , 1,14l1ti►.ij• ..1 •4!.•.1 ilt .SAI .'- " , fl1fDI -.tcp ,It 1 A�. .. Q W ....I 14 . I Q = H I- O o O N a ce WL ..-E...11 } 0 = Q 6!).1 I... 0 p � V o E co o'' 0 4O L o% O el oi uj Li- 2 1 1 0 O ci. (I) p } Q 00 •i y _ o— .� W p C p --4 Q ,a D Cr caLu Q 4D ziQ Q Q Z tiz. c,„ 3 . ar & ar W N H H F-- O O) N r- U. 1... O N t/} tn. t/} p I--V O O O O �u -0 o o o °` Lno m....1t0 0 r- N N Q •_ .. r— �O N ; C ) H t/l- t/'}LL = UJ O 4� } J t/� C C 1 = 0 IDC la w Z .; E ce Z1.0 E D D E 0 %t uj E •__ J •_ x •„„.... * *Q 1111111111111Q ,...›Q N E O U tl0 CC 0.1.1% 7 N W O m \/ C3 co N MUr ifi- UULT . . Q O ' Q ce " e o 0 0 1111 N tff rl O i.°1 0 N N O O rl O OO Ili �� N N L y M Q •° � � _v) . — cooU "O N (6 N U U C g { m O w c 0 0 0 -0 c N Q 3' O .0 'C 0 "O 2 O t (0 C O C O U U c:,_ 0: =, Z O m ° a o- a) m , c a U o CD Q •� IP (6 U Q U K O C O 0 O (0 U U •y a O -0 O -o U o w -L-,' m m o g O Q D y O , O n1 o C t0 U U O. t0 V d O O_ N N O" "L' y O N C (0 (0 O U �O (0 U Q M U "O a) U (0 O • ,, N /� 0 l_ CO O to cn U O CO m M F- CC T ..iii +' e-4 N CO '1 lf1 LC) N CO 01 O i `� N LU › c a Q .— E C a d S w S I0 11..10'.--' ~ I Z N 7 •'"o li : ''1 ' IX .4..... h ,4 C Q t -� ,• _ . .41) d) a . W cl' t1 *7 '''''' E -4 y r .i �[, t J Om daMy ro osvk a) 0o - • 13) Ci) _ W O C WI.0O CV L O73 O N 4 G • 4— NJ L. V 7. Ott .• / - : til -- yi�� -b sk,- i -" ØJ::; �. w j ' ,, s xi.- ,.. . . r 1A -• T ` . A s ♦ r,i t� g'k ' Ria 4� �� ., :„: „.\ ,_ ... _ .„„ - ,,,,, .::; ,..„4 :,,,.,.,-, . -- -,_, „-, .,,..;,,,.. . 4 .,„..47- ,i, It' - ' ''•,-'4.4i0 /ri . ' ..,,, W i U . �� i 4 a '/- jIJ uQ , 0 ,yft.'i.; 1, 'f'-'.;''' /, �Dgl?, W isill L Ce - N Cr, l W fai F 2 CO N ti, � z W C 0 N sO a5 V p i r Q Q h 7 %,0 O a CN 4— . CI Z tiel) N IIICIIIL. r• .p LO CaO ce O. IIIIIIMM 0 'el). V' y N ea he 0 X >I. 0_ m N Q i O a O '13 '' ' H _0-m W a) H J vi CH W 7 .....,=11-imIIICIC tiel) (I) N C INU J i _W CICe U a I1111111111111 0 urn) z c O NCn O V♦ U (,) (6 W = Q J c' J W cc, Habitat for Humanity of Collier County 11145 Tamiami Trail East I Naples, FL 34113 Office: 239-775-0036 I Fax: 239-775-0477 'Donate Now www.HabitatCollier.org Follow Habitat for Humanity of Collier County... Yai 1. rr.,) Tube Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 GrecoSherry From: Nick Kouloheras <nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Sent: Thursday, October 4, 2018 11:42 AM To: GrecoSherry Subject: RE: Habitat for Humanity October 18th at 10:00 a.m. would work better. From: GrecoSherry [mailto:Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov] Sent:Thursday, October 4, 2018 10:55 AM To: Nick Kouloheras<nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Subject: RE: Habitat for Humanity Good morning, Are you available on Wednesday, October 17th at 10 AM or Thursday, October 18th at 10 AM. Please advise which date and time are suitable for you and please provide a subject for the meeting. Thank you. scierrr &eco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: Nick Kouloheras<nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Sent:Thursday, October 4, 2018 10:23 AM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Habitat for Humanity Good morning Sherry, I was hoping to grab 30 min of the commissioners time. Any day the 15th through the 19th work best for me but I'll take any date or time I can get. Thanks for your help and I hope you are doing well. Nick Nicholas J. Kouloheras President •1 Habitat for Humanity. 1 To: Nick Kouloheras<nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Subject: RE: Habitat for Humanity Good morning, Are you available on Wednesday, October 17th at 10 AM or Thursday, October 18th at 10 AM. Please advise which date and time are suitable for you and please provide a subject for the meeting. Thank you. sherry greco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: Nick Kouloheras<nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Sent:Thursday, October 4, 2018 10:23 AM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Habitat for Humanity Good morning Sherry, I was hoping to grab 30 min of the commissioners time. Any day the 15th through the 19th work best for me but I'll take any date or time I can get. Thanks for your help and I hope you are doing well. Nick Nicholas J. Kouloheras President *HAIM for Humanity Habitat for Humanity of Collier County 11145 Tamiami Trail East I Naples, FL 34113 Office: 239-775-0036 I Fax: 239-775-0477 Donate Now www.HabitatCollier.orq Follow Habitat for Humanity of Collier County... Mnr TYLthe 11 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 12 GrecoSherry From: GrecoSherry Sent: Tuesday, October 16, 2018 8:32 AM To: Nick Kouloheras Subject: RE: Habitat for Humanity Good morning, Can you please give me the address for the Regal Acres site the Commissioner plans on visiting the site today. Thank you. Sherry Greco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.GrecoC«@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: Nick Kouloheras<nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Sent:Thursday, October 4, 2018 11:42 AM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: RE: Habitat for Humanity October 18th at 10:00 a.m.would work better. From: GrecoSherry [mailto:Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov] Sent:Thursday, October 4, 2018 10:55 AM To: Nick Kouloheras<nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Subject: RE: Habitat for Humanity Good morning, Are you available on Wednesday, October 17th at 10 AM or Thursday, October 18th at 10 AM. Please advise which date and time are suitable for you and please provide a subject for the meeting. Thank you. 13 Scierr� Greco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: Nick Kouloheras<nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Sent:Thursday, October 4, 2018 10:23 AM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco(a@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Habitat for Humanity Good morning Sherry, I was hoping to grab 30 min of the commissioners time. Any day the 15th through the 19th work best for me but I'll take any date or time I can get. Thanks for your help and I hope you are doing well. Nick Nicholas J. Kouloheras President iftf Habitat for Humanity' Habitat for Humanity of Collier County 11145 Tamiami Trail East I Naples, FL 34113 Office: 239-775-0036 I Fax: 239-775-0477 Dctoato Now www.HabitatCollier.orq Follow Habitat for Humanity of Collier County... Mr. lite- Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 14 GrecoSherry From: Jean Kungle <jeankungle@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, October 22, 2018 6:09 PM To: TaylorPenny Cc: GrecoSherry Subject: Regal Acres II RPUD Attachments: Commissioner Taylor - Regal.pdf Dear Commissioner Taylor, Please see attached letter referring to the Regal Acres expansion on the BCC agenda tomorrow. Thank you for your consideration, Jean Kungle Jean Kungle Naples, FL 34112 mobile (239) 269-2511 Jean Kungle, Realtor Licensed Real Estate Broker Port of the Islands Realty 24998 Tamiami Tr. E. Naples, FL 34114 mobile (239) 269-2511 office (239) 394-7304 fax (239) 394-8090 poirealty.com portoftheislandsrealty.com The information contained in this transmission may contain privileged and confidential information. It is intended only for the use of the person(s) named above. If you are not the intended recipient,you are hereby notified that any review, dissemination, distribution, or duplication of the communication is strictly prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender by reply email and destroy all copies of the original message. October 22,2018 Dear Commissioner Taylor, I am writing in opposition to the expansion of Regal Acres.I am not against the concept of Habitat for Human- ity,but I do not believe building these large communities is the best solution.The HOAs do not run like other community HOAs in that they do not enforce any of the rules,the communities suffer,and less and less they take pride in their home ownership. I believe one of the reasons for this is many of the residents are from different cultures and prefer not to embrace ours,but rather want us to tolerate theirs.Do you know of any communities where you are allowed to park on the grass,have 5 or more cars parked day after day,don't keep up with landscaping,allow people to move in without being vetted by the association,or let repairs continue to pile up?Habitat says they are rectifying this, but we have not seen it come to fruition.How many times can a person call code enforcement when the issues are daily?Plus there is no way for anyone to verify who is actually living in a home except through the HOA, which appear not to be concerned and do not know if asked. Speaking of parking,on the proposed PUD changes,they state there are currently 121 PM peak hour two-way trips and the proposed additional 116 single family residential units will generate approximately 120 PM peak hour two-way trips.Note...184 units that are there now generates 121 trips(not even one car per household)and adding 116 would generate 120 trips(one car per household plus 4 extras)...makes no sense.The difference between 184 units and 116 units is 68. So the 116 units generates more trips than the 184 there now. They also state the bonus units are intended to accommodate housing opportunities for low or moderate-income residents.According to the Collier County affordable housing chart for 2 persons income,this is the 80% ($44,640)to 120%($66,960)category. According to Habitat their 2 persons criteria is maximum$36,000,so neither of these categories will actually be served. Habitat is already advertising this new community on their website before it has even be approved.This cer- tainly gives the impression if they ask for it,they get it.Again,is there anyone else in the county that assumes this.They have already purchased many parcels of acreage in that area that is zoned agricultural.Are we to assume the zoning and density will be approved on these parcels regardless?And we will have more concentra- tion in one area. I do not understand why these projects are not being built in other parts of the County.It is illegal to concentrate in one area,and anyone that lives in Collier knows where the more affordable homes are,East Naples.Or as the planning map also shows,South Naples.It's not a secret,but has been stated by County officials,it's not true. Habitat states the reason is land costs.Why are we not making it mandatory that any monies granted to them for land acquisition is to be used to subsidize their land costs,not the actual purchase price.This would make it more reasonable to pay more for land in higher priced areas and would spread the lower income properties throughout. So in closing,I would ask the Commissioners to reject this expansion,the adjacent residents do not want it,and East Naples has shouldered the majority of all"affordable"income housing in the County,aside from Immokalee,which also has their fair share.The Regal Acres community is large enough already. Sincerely, <, can Kungle Resident GrecoSherry From: Donna M. Messer <dmc@carlryanassoc.com> Sent: Monday, October 22, 2018 4:44 PM To: SolisAndy; McDanielBill; TaylorPenny; FialaDonna; SaundersBurt Subject: October 23, 2018 Agenda Items 9A & 11E Good Afternoon Commissioners, I have been a Collier County resident for 13 years and believe in being an active part of the community. To that end, I've been involved with several projects designed to study housing affordability issues through the Collier Citizens Council as well as Greater Naples Leadership.Through CCC, I worked on a team assisting Kim Grant with research in preparation for the Community Housing Plan. It's my belief those who work in and support our community and are not able to take advantage of living here, should be given increased opportunities to facilitate that effort. I urge you to vote YES on Habitat's project, endorse the rezoning, and advocate for those who support us everyday. Thank you! Donna M. Messer I Carl Ryan Associates LLC 1214.870.1915 1 GrecoSherry From: Raymond williams <raymondwilliamsjr@hotmail.com> Sent: Monday, October 22, 2018 8:07 PM To: TaylorPenny Subject: Regal Acres II I am a board member at Westwind Estates in East Naples. I wanted to reach out to you today about the upcoming vote tomorrow on Habitat for Humanity's project that's being developed behind our development. Habitat for Humanity reached out to us end of April 1st part of May and met with the board and residents of West Winds we had some concerns. They went back and addressed those concerns and came back with a proposal that far exceeded what we were expecting to be done. I just wanted you to know that were totally in favor of this development. Thank you Raymond Williams Westwind Estates Board of director Make everyday the best it can. Life is to short not too. Sent by Outlook for Android 1 GrecoSherry From: RummerJason Sent: Thursday, October 18, 2018 5:53 PM To: GrecoSherry Cc: TaylorPenny; GiblinCormac; RummerJason Subject: GREENWAY ROAD DATA 2018 COMPARED TO 2017 Attachments: GREENWAY RD AREA PA VAL 2018 2017 COMM Taylor 10.18.18jnrvl.xlsx; GREENWAY RD AREA PA VAL 2018 2017 COMM Taylor 10.18.18 jnrvl.pdf; Naples_Reserve_2018.xlsx Sherry, Please find attached the requested data about Greenway Road and the surrounding area. Please let me know if the Commissioner or yourself have any questions. 225 RESIDENCES TOTAL $28,502,467 $27,264,761 10 STREETS AVERAGE $126,678 $121,177 PERCENTAGE CHANGE INCREASE 4.5% COMPARED TO NAPLES RESERVE 139 RESIDENCES TOTAL $59,861,110 $27,327,516 11 STREETS AVERAGE $430,655 $196,600 PERCENTAGE CHANGE INCREASE 119.1% PLEASE NOTE: EVEN THOUGH THE PROPERTY COUNT FOR NAPLES RESERVE ARE THE SAME IN 2018 AND 2017, MANY OF THE SINGLE FAMILY HOMES WERE NOT FINISHED/OR STARTED All the best, Jason Rummer Operations Analyst r County Colfre Operations Analyst, Tourism/Community and Human Services Naples, Marco Island, Everglades Convention &Visitors Bureau 2660 Horseshoe Dr. N.#105, Naples, FL 34104 P (239) 252-5505 C (239) 777-7114 How are we doing?Click here to take our 5-minute feedback survey I ParadiseCoast.comheParadiseCoast I V@paradisecoast 1 ACCD%TED O 44404 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 2017 LY MARKET USE SITE ADDRESS TY MARKET VALUE VALUE SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14167 NAUTICA CT 356185 338261 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14163 NAUTICA CT 415242 383679 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14155 NAUTICA CT 370271 333969 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14151 NAUTICA CT 362188 329037 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14147 NAUTICA CT 390473 355680 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14143 NAUTICA CT 450536 160607 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14139 NAUTICA CT 452680 415612 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14135 NAUTICA CT 490773 160607 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14131 NAUTICA CT 440864 426171 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14127 NAUTICA CT 437932 149959 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14123 NAUTICA CT 366894 114026 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14087 NAUTICA CT 397844 356168 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14079 NAUTICA CT 380179 341765 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14067 NAUTICA CT 394828 353152 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14176 NAUTICA CT 377140 338952 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14150 NAUTICA CT 378791 339968 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14138 NAUTICA CT 412330 370500 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14134 NAUTICA CT 377333 105996 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14061 NAUTICA CT 396498 145939 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14060 NAUTICA CT 433188 145811 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14780 LEEWARD DR 488733 31464 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14784 LEEWARD DR 526297 31464 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14713 LEEWARD DR 367676 19323 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14709 LEEWARD DR 457771 497111 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14822 WINDWARD LN 474098 24462 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14818 WINDWARD LN 527289 24462 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14752 WINDWARD LN 581600 684977 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14720 WINDWARD LN 497273 581407 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14716 WINDWARD LN 498736 507474 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14712 WINDWARD LN 512572 574529 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14708 WINDWARD LN 464858 74480 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14704 WINDWARD LN 480429 548700 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14700 WINDWARD LN 407506 74515 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14722 NAUTILUS PL 376532 24320 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14726 NAUTILUS PL 508405 74480 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14753 WINDWARD LN 472300 95509 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14741 WINDWARD LN 469679 92774 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14729 WINDWARD LN 443481 74480 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14725 WINDWARD LN 521568 545412 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14721 WINDWARD LN 450994 515383 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14717 WINDWARD LN 441663 24320 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14713 WINDWARD LN 467255 474601 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14714 LEEWARD DR 464799 525906 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14718 LEEWARD DR 454485 517435 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14727 NAUTILUS PL 409222 18240 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14721 NAUTILUS PL 428645 26790 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14738 LEEWARD DR 454609 24890 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14742 LEEWARD DR 511056 24890 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14746 LEEWARD DR 481947 24320 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14587 TOPSAIL DR 319790 15105 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14591 TOPSAIL DR 322245 16946 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14595 TOPSAIL DR 372302 18126 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14599 TOPSAIL DR 348290 18180 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14603 TOPSAIL DR 374781 22678 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14611 TOPSAIL DR 375168 20140 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14627 TOPSAIL DR 309682 20710 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14635 TOPSAIL DR 383588 20140 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14639 TOPSAIL DR 334861 20140 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14643 TOPSAIL DR 369934 20957 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14647 TOPSAIL DR 387271 22105 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14651 TOPSAIL DR 341096 22105 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14655 TOPSAIL DR 387596 22732 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14659 TOPSAIL DR 390756 22732 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14663 TOPSAIL DR 373119 16578 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14671 TOPSAIL DR 344237 15105 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14675 TOPSAIL DR 398250 15105 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14679 TOPSAIL DR 320360 15533 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14683 TOPSAIL DR 291561 15533 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14687 TOPSAIL DR 319790 15105 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14691 TOPSAIL DR 289139 15173 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14614 TROPICAL DR 331760 24083 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14618 TROPICAL DR 360797 24459 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14622 TROPICAL DR 327758 113815 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14626 TROPICAL DR 337413 75525 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14630 TROPICAL DR 371141 75525 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14634 TROPICAL DR 385897 75525 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14638 TROPICAL DR 380525 77663 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14642 TROPICAL DR 386965 77663 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14646 TROPICAL DR 334861 75525 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14650 TROPICAL DR 379464 75539 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14654 TROPICAL DR 391187 81881 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14660 TROPICAL DR 362992 80555 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14664 TROPICAL DR 392298 400894 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14672 TROPICAL DR 379688 413541 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14676 TROPICAL DR 337619 367967 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14680 TROPICAL DR 338628 364894 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14684 TROPICAL DR 371194 396215 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14688 TROPICAL DR 308614 75525 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14692 TROPICAL DR 384776 415045 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14696 TROPICAL DR 339708 367672 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14616 TOPSAIL DR 377402 24065 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14600 TOPSAIL DR 420937 25825 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14584 TOPSAIL DR 346404 24936 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14670 TOPSAIL DR 413876 20543 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14664 TOPSAIL DR 339636 21326 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14658 TOPSAIL DR 310822 21318 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14593 TROPICAL DR 346502 86925 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14601 TROPICAL DR 388967 86284 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14613 TROPICAL DR 380267 96857 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14629 TROPICAL DR 348079 96857 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14637 TROPICAL DR 305873 73929 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14641 TROPICAL DR 308614 75525 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14645 TROPICAL DR 369074 75525 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14649 TROPICAL DR 385897 75525 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14653 TROPICAL DR 353571 86213 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14657 TROPICAL DR 373087 83562 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14661 TROPICAL DR 415431 83562 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14669 TROPICAL DR 343740 373982 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14673 TROPICAL DR 386793 390457 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14677 TROPICAL DR 319306 370287 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14681 TROPICAL DR 363206 416208 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14799 DOCKSIDE LN 586559 66690 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14803 DOCKSIDE LN 547947 66690 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14807 DOCKSIDE LN 573808 66690 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14811 DOCKSIDE LN 554792 659826 i SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14815 DOCKSIDE LN 552679 673185 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14819 DOCKSIDE LN 630204 81336 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14823 DOCKSIDE LN 592001 79797 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14827 DOCKSIDE LN 552815 674096 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14831 DOCKSIDE LN 538279 70897 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14835 DOCKSIDE LN 568255 66690 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14839 DOCKSIDE LN 590809 724381 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14571 REGATTA LN 632181 39330 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14575 REGATTA LN 536599 115040 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14579 REGATTA LN 625878 79246 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14583 REGATTA LN 568800 71703 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14587 REGATTA LN 546037 69221 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14786 DOCKSIDE LN 543838 78207 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14790 DOCKSIDE LN 571660 701245 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14794 DOCKSIDE LN 521948 78207 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14788 SPINNAKER WAY 561530 682310 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14784 SPINNAKER WAY 625705 66690 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14768 SPINNAKER WAY 533686 67973 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14760 SPINNAKER WAY 554033 71721 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14789 SPINNAKER WAY 536293 66690 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14820 DOCKSIDE LN 570892 700532 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14832 DOCKSIDE LN 615007 738202 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14844 DOCKSIDE LN 607325 736801 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 14852 DOCKSIDE LN 543318 649993 COMM DIST DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 DIST 5 REQUESTED AREA 2018 TY MARKET 2017 LY MARKET USE SITE ADDRESS VALUE VALUE SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL ACHILL $187,838 $169,733 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 2781 CECIL RD $194,419 $190,092 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 2755 CECIL RD $162,662 $160,258 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $113,725 $110,935 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $113,725 $110,935 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $113,725 $110,935 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $114,951 $112,161 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $114,951 $112,161 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $113,725 $110,935 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $113,725 $110,935 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $113,725 $110,935 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $115,081 $112,291 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $117,724 $114,934 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $114,922 $112,132 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $114,922 $112,132 MOBILE HOMES EMPEROR $114,922 $112,132 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $114,922 $112,132 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $112,838 $110,128 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $113,942 $111,232 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $113,942 $111,232 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $112,838 $110,128 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $112,838 $110,128 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $112,838 $110,128 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $114,605 $111,895 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $114,266 $111,556 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL FRITCHEY $306,616 $272,207 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $172,467 $172,057 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $97,125 $96,490 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $89,192 $88,749 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $112,727 $109,823 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $214,777 $211,158 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $247,656 $241,781 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $276,266 $270,811 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $229,989 $226,219 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $229,173 $225,403 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $140,125 $137,434 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $434,751 $42,450 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $238,099 $233,921 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $191,215 $186,798 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $98,987 $84,449 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $185,678 $168,999 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $146,205 $137,951 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $501,380 $491,772 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $387,093 $356,984 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL JAMES $68,108 $61,922 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL JAMES $93,796 $85,703 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL JAMES $236,581 $224,456 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL JAMES $157,903 $148,021 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL JAMES $135,695 $125,100 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL JAMES $156,656 $156,308 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL JAMES $109,006 $99,571 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL JAMES $143,927 $134,357 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL JAMES $164,598 $154,691 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $122,760 $120,050 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,632 $111,922 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,384 $111,674 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,051 $111,338 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,384 $111,674 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,384 $111,674 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,384 $111,674 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,051 $111,338 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $113,942 $111,232 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,826 $112,116 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,826 $112,116 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,493 $111,780 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,493 $111,780 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,493 $111,780 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,493 $111,780 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,493 $111,780 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,493 $111,780 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,493 $111,780 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,493 $111,780 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,493 $111,780 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,003 $111,290 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $124,874 $122,161 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $121,243 $118,530 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $121,375 $118,662 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $122,780 $120,067 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $122,780 $120,067 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $122,780 $120,067 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $122,780 $120,067 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $122,780 $120,067 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $122,780 $120,067 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $119,092 $116,379 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $120,205 $117,492 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $118,151 $115,438 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $111,308 $108,595 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $111,308 $108,595 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $113,725 $110,935 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $113,725 $110,935 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,338 $111,548 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,338 $111,548 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,338 $111,548 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,338 $111,548 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $113,725 $110,935 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $113,725 $110,935 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $113,831 $111,041 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,325 $111,535 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $111,818 $109,028 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $114,395 $111,605 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $115,110 $112,320 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $116,876 $114,086 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $114,073 $111,360 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $109,529 $106,800 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $112,954 $110,241 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $112,954 $110,241 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,719 $111,006 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $127,683 $124,943 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $115,035 $112,187 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,214 $110,417 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,318 $110,654 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,214 $110,417 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,214 $110,417 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,214 $110,417 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 MOBILE HOMES MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 MOBILE HOMES MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 MOBILE HOMES MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 MOBILE HOMES MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 MOBILE HOMES MAJESTIC $116,239 $113,449 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $116,239 $113,449 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $116,356 $113,527 i CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,339 $112,503 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,468 $112,630 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $116,642 $113,806 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $116,584 $113,748 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $116,589 $113,753 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $116,506 $113,677 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $117,266 $114,378 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,427 $112,591 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,181 $112,352 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,181 $112,352 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,431 $112,595 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $122,441 $119,612 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $125,585 $123,266 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $126,359 $123,471 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $126,242 $124,080 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,670 $112,841 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,912 $113,076 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,666 $112,837 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,666 $112,837 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,067 $112,238 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $117,152 $114,264 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,010 $112,181 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $116,321 $113,492 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $116,321 $113,492 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,010 $112,181 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,606 $112,770 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,360 $112,531 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,666 $112,837 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,670 $112,841 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $121,814 $118,985 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $123,528 $120,699 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $123,528 $120,699 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $121,814 $118,985 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $112,799 $109,970 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,010 $112,181 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $112,229 $109,479 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,010 $112,181 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $113,997 $111,207 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,308 $112,518 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $116,086 $113,296 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $113,997 $111,207 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $114,653 $111,863 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $114,653 $111,863 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $113,997 $111,207 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $114,861 $112,071 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $116,814 $114,222 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,549 $112,759 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,014 $112,224 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $116,239 $113,449 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $116,239 $113,449 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,014 $112,224 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,426 $112,636 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,426 $112,636 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $114,715 $111,886 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $113,163 $110,373 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $113,984 $111,155 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,210 $112,381 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,291 $112,462 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $117,376 $114,488 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $114,597 $111,768 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $114,597 $111,768 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,984 $111,155 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,984 $111,155 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $118,340 $115,452 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $118,328 $115,440 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $116,623 $113,794 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $116,623 $113,794 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $120,004 $113,198 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $117,252 $114,423 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $121,229 $114,423 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $116,027 $113,198 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $116,504 $113,675 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $116,504 $113,675 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $115,994 $113,165 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $115,459 $112,630 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,984 $111,155 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $115,311 $112,444 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $114,197 $111,407 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $114,197 $111,407 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,214 $110,417 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,214 $110,417 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,214 $110,417 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $114,764 $111,974 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $115,461 $112,664 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MARETE $126,002 $109,348 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MARETE $97,196 $88,976 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MARETE $198,182 $181,604 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MESQUITE $81,210 $66,907 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MESQUITE $34,181 $27,996 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MESQUITE $118,661 $110,468 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MESQUITE $94,192 $100,322 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL SANDFIELD $218,393 $213,004 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL SANDFIELD $60,040 $58,263 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL SANDFIELD $131,864 $128,512 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL SANDFIELD $66,812 $64,782 225 RESIDENCES TOTAL $28,502,467 $27,264,761 10 STREETS AVERAGE $126,678 $121,177 PERCENTAGE CHANGE INCREASE 4.5% COMPARED TO NAPLES RESERVE 139 RESIDENCES TOTAL $59,861,110 $27,327,516 11 STREETS AVERAGE $430,655 $196,600 PERCENTAGE CHANGE INCREASE 119.1% REQUESTED AREA 2018 TY MARKET 2017 LY MARKET USE SITE ADDRESS VALUE VALUE SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL ACHILL $187,838 $169,733 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 2781 CECIL RD $194,419 $190,092 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 2755 CECIL RD $162,662 $160,258 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $113,725 $110,935 1 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $113,725 $110,935 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $113,725 $110,935 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $114,951 $112,161 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $114,951 $112,161 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $113,725 $110,935 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $113,725 $110,935 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $113,725 $110,935 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $115,081 $112,291 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $117,724 $114,934 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $114,922 $112,132 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $114,922 $112,132 MOBILE HOMES EMPEROR $114,922 $112,132 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $114,922 $112,132 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $112,838 $110,128 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $113,942 $111,232 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $113,942 $111,232 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $112,838 $110,128 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $112,838 $110,128 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $112,838 $110,128 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $114,605 $111,895 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL EMPEROR $114,266 $111,556 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL FRITCHEY $306,616 $272,207 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $172,467 $172,057 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $97,125 $96,490 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $89,192 $88,749 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $112,727 $109,823 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $214,777 $211,158 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $247,656 $241,781 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $276,266 $270,811 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $229,989 $226,219 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $229,173 $225,403 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $140,125 $137,434 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $434,751 $42,450 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $238,099 $233,921 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $191,215 $186,798 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $98,987 $84,449 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $185,678 $168,999 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $146,205 $137,951 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $501,380 $491,772 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL GREENWAY $387,093 $356,984 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL JAMES $68,108 $61,922 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL JAMES $93,796 $85,703 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL JAMES $236,581 $224,456 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL JAMES $157,903 $148,021 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL JAMES $135,695 $125,100 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL JAMES $156,656 $156,308 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL JAMES $109,006 $99,571 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL JAMES $143,927 $134,357 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL JAMES $164,598 $154,691 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $122,760 $120,050 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,632 $111,922 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,384 $111,674 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,051 $111,338 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,384 $111,674 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,384 $111,674 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,384 $111,674 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,051 $111,338 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $113,942 $111,232 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,826 $112,116 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,826 $112,116 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,493 $111,780 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,493 $111,780 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,493 $111,780 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,493 $111,780 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,493 $111,780 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,493 $111,780 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,493 $111,780 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,493 $111,780 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,493 $111,780 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,003 $111,290 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $124,874 $122,161 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $121,243 $118,530 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $121,375 $118,662 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $122,780 $120,067 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $122,780 $120,067 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $122,780 $120,067 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $122,780 $120,067 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $122,780 $120,067 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $122,780 $120,067 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $119,092 $116,379 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $120,205 $117,492 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $118,151 $115,438 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $111,308 $108,595 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $111,308 $108,595 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $113,725 $110,935 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $113,725 $110,935 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,338 $111,548 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,338 $111,548 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,338 $111,548 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,338 $111,548 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $113,725 $110,935 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $113,725 $110,935 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $113,831 $111,041 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL KINGDOM $114,325 $111,535 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $111,818 $109,028 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $114,395 $111,605 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $115,110 $112,320 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $116,876 $114,086 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $114,073 $111,360 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $109,529 $106,800 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $112,954 $110,241 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $112,954 $110,241 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,719 $111,006 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $127,683 $124,943 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $115,035 $112,187 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,214 $110,417 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,318 $110,654 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,214 $110,417 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,214 $110,417 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,214 $110,417 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 MOBILE HOMES MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 MOBILE HOMES MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 MOBILE HOMES MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 MOBILE HOMES MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 MOBILE HOMES MAJESTIC $116,239 $113,449 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $116,239 $113,449 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $116,356 $113,527 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,339 $112,503 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,468 $112,630 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $116,642 $113,806 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $116,584 $113,748 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $116,589 $113,753 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $116,506 $113,677 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $117,266 $114,378 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,427 $112,591 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,181 $112,352 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,181 $112,352 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,431 $112,595 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $122,441 $119,612 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $125,585 $123,266 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $126,359 $123,471 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $126,242 $124,080 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,670 $112,841 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,912 $113,076 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,666 $112,837 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,666 $112,837 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,067 $112,238 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $117,152 $114,264 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,010 $112,181 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $116,321 $113,492 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $116,321 $113,492 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,010 $112,181 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,606 $112,770 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,360 $112,531 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,666 $112,837 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,670 $112,841 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $121,814 $118,985 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $123,528 $120,699 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $123,528 $120,699 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $121,814 $118,985 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $112,799 $109,970 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,010 $112,181 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $112,229 $109,479 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,010 $112,181 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $113,997 $111,207 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,308 $112,518 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $116,086 $113,296 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $113,997 $111,207 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $114,653 $111,863 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $114,653 $111,863 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $113,997 $111,207 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $114,861 $112,071 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $116,814 $114,222 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,549 $112,759 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,014 $112,224 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $116,239 $113,449 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $116,239 $113,449 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,014 $112,224 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,426 $112,636 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,426 $112,636 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $114,715 $111,886 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $113,163 $110,373 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $113,984 $111,155 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,210 $112,381 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $115,291 $112,462 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $117,376 $114,488 CONDOMINIUM MAJESTIC $114,597 $111,768 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $114,597 $111,768 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,984 $111,155 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,984 $111,155 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $118,340 $115,452 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $118,328 $115,440 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $116,623 $113,794 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $116,623 $113,794 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $120,004 $113,198 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $117,252 $114,423 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $121,229 $114,423 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $116,027 $113,198 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $116,504 $113,675 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $116,504 $113,675 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $115,994 $113,165 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $115,459 $112,630 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,984 $111,155 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $115,311 $112,444 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $112,971 $110,181 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $114,197 $111,407 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $114,197 $111,407 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,214 $110,417 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,214 $110,417 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $113,214 $110,417 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $114,764 $111,974 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MAJESTIC $115,461 $112,664 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MARETE $126,002 $109,348 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MARETE $97,196 $88,976 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MARETE $198,182 $181,604 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MESQUITE $81,210 $66,907 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MESQUITE $34,181 $27,996 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MESQUITE $118,661 $110,468 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL MESQUITE $94,192 $100,322 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL SANDFIELD $218,393 $213,004 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL SANDFIELD $60,040 $58,263 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL SANDFIELD $131,864 $128,512 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL SANDFIELD $66,812 $64,782 225 RESIDENCES TOTAL $28,502,467 $27,264,761 10 STREETS AVERAGE $126,678 $121,177 PERCENTAGE CHANGE INCREASE 4.5% COMPARED TO NAPLES RESERVE 139 RESIDENCES TOTAL $59,861,110 $27,327,516 11 STREETS AVERAGE $430,655 $196,600 PERCENTAGE CHANGE INCREASE 119.1% PLEASE NOTE:EVEN THOUGH THE PROPERTY COUNT FOR NAPLES RESERVE ARE THE SAME IN 2018 AND 2017,MANY OF THE SINGLE FAMILY HOMES WERE NOT FINISHED/OR STARTED P.GL5C6/ / GrecoSherry 5eIttdk-Crr& From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent: Tuesday, October 9, 2018 3:47 PM To: GrecoSherry ‘---1-6 11/161 6 Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Alligator Alley & Russell Square Correct! Dianna Quintanilla CYK Legal Assistant The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com COLEMAN 1 Y O V A N O V C H ! K O E S T E R Visit cvklawfirm.com to learn more about us. A,4 4�r#q, 8 ., 11 ,. Trusted & Verified t Pte. .04-po Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. From: GrecoSherry [mailto:Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov] Sent: Tuesday, October 9, 2018 3:46 PM To: Dianna Quintanilla Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Alligator Alley & Russell Square Ok, alligator alley (Right?) is 9:30 Am and Russell square is 10 AM Sherry 4reco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent:Tuesday, October 9, 2018 3:45 PM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Alligator Alley& Russell Square 3 r Yes,thank you and confirmed. Dianna Quintanilla CYK Legal Assistant The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com COLEMAN 1 Y O V A N O V I C H I K O E S T E R Visit cvklawfirm.com to learn more about us. s B trig a M ' 1. .% Trusted & Verified "vi t 4 Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman, Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. From: GrecoSherry [mailto:Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov] Sent: Tuesday, October 9, 2018 3:45 PM To: Dianna Quintanilla Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Alligator Alley & Russell Square Are these 2 separate meetings, if so then 9:30 and 10 AM on the 17th sherry t reco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent:Tuesday, October 9, 2018 3:35 PM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Meeting Request:Alligator Alley& Russell Square Good afternoon, Rich is requesting to meet with the Commissioner on the following two items that are on the BCC agenda for October 23rd: 1. Alligator Ally— also attending: Jesse Houghtalen &Wayne Arnold 2. Russell Square—also attending: Dan Ciesielski &Wayne Arnold 4 Rich did mentioned that the two items might be on consent agenda but at this point he is not sure. He requested that I get the meetings scheduled and if we have to cancel we will. Availability: Tuesday October 16t": 9:00—1:30 Wednesday October 17t": anytime Thursday October 18t": 3:00 Friday October 19t": 1:00, 2:00 Monday October 22"d: 9:00—12:00, Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla CYK Legal Assistant The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 Pdquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com 239.435.35351yFawfir23435.1218 COLEMAN I Y©VANOV CH I KOESTER dquintanilla(�cyklawfirm.com Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. sott * Trusted & Verified .40 Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman, Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 5 GrecoSherry From: GrecoSherry Sent: Tuesday, October 9, 2018 3:46 PM To: 'Dianna Quintanilla' Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Alligator Alley & Russell Square Ok, alligator alley (Right?) is 9:30 Am and Russell square is 10 AM Sherry greco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent:Tuesday, October 9, 2018 3:45 PM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Alligator Alley& Russell Square Yes,thank you and confirmed. Dianna Quintanilla CYK Legal Assistant The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 # h / g{ dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com Visit cvklawfirm.com to learn more about us. Trusted & Verified ,„.r Verified _.„, Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cvklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. From: GrecoSherry [mailto:Sherry.Greco(acolliercountyfl.gov] Sent: Tuesday, October 9, 2018 3:45 PM To: Dianna Quintanilla Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Alligator Alley & Russell Square 6 Are these 2 separate meetings, if so then 9:30 and 10 AM on the 17th Scierry C7reco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent:Tuesday, October 9, 2018 3:35 PM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Meeting Request: Alligator Alley & Russell Square Good afternoon, Rich is requesting to meet with the Commissioner on the following two items that are on the BCC agenda for October 23rd: 1. Alligator Ally— also attending: Jesse Houghtalen &Wayne Arnold 2. Russell Square—also attending: Dan Ciesielski &Wayne Arnold Rich did mentioned that the two items might be on consent agenda but at this point he is not sure. He requested that I get the meetings scheduled and if we have to cancel we will. Availability: Tuesday October 16th: 9:00—1:30 Wednesday October 17th: anytime Thursday October 18th: 3:00 Friday October 19th: 1:00, 2:00 Monday October 22"d: 9:00—12:00, Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant CYK The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com COLEMAN I Y O V A N O V I C H I KOESTER 7 Visit cvklawfirm.com to learn more about us. )or t t,l'''' - 8 Trusted & Verified C ` 44 'r .. tP Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 8 GrecoSherry From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent: Tuesday, October 9, 2018 3:45 PM To: GrecoSherry Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Alligator Alley & Russell Square Yes,thank you and confirmed. Dianna Quintanilla CYK : Legal Assistant The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.3535i F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com C O L E M A N f Y O V A N O V II C H [ K O E S T E R Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. sit 4` k Trusted Verified ...0. ,44,4.4 *- Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman, Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. From: GrecoSherry [mailto:Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov] Sent: Tuesday, October 9, 2018 3:45 PM To: Dianna Quintanilla Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Alligator Alley & Russell Square Are these 2 separate meetings, if so then 9:30 and 10 AM on the 17th Stierry ( reco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent:Tuesday, October 9, 2018 3:35 PM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Meeting Request: Alligator Alley& Russell Square 9 Good afternoon, Rich is requesting to meet with the Commissioner on the following two items that are on the BCC agenda for October 23rd: 1. Alligator Ally— also attending: Jesse Houghtalen &Wayne Arnold 2. Russell Square—also attending: Dan Ciesielski &Wayne Arnold Rich did mentioned that the two items might be on consent agenda but at this point he is not sure. He requested that I get the meetings scheduled and if we have to cancel we will. Availability: Tuesday October 16th: 9:00—1:30 Wednesday October 17th: anytime Thursday October 18th: 3:00 Friday October 19th: 1:00, 2:00 Monday October 22"d: 9:00—12:00, Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla CYK Legal Assistant The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 Pdquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com F: 239.435.1218 C MAN I YOVANOVICH I KOESTER dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com Visit cvklawfirm.com to learn more about us. 4,141 44.4 :'Trusted & Verifiead rr.r.r 1►11 Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman, Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cvklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 10 GrecoSherry From: GrecoSherry Sent: Tuesday, October 9, 2018 3:45 PM To: 'Dianna Quintanilla' Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Alligator Alley & Russell Square Are these 2 separate meetings, if so then 9:30 and 10 AM on the 17th SSierry 4reco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent:Tuesday, October 9, 2018 3:35 PM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Meeting Request: Alligator Alley& Russell Square Good afternoon, Rich is requesting to meet with the Commissioner on the following two items that are on the BCC agenda for October 23rd: 1. Alligator Ally— also attending: Jesse Houghtalen &Wayne Arnold 2. Russell Square—also attending: Dan Ciesielski &Wayne Arnold Rich did mentioned that the two items might be on consent agenda but at this point he is not sure. He requested that I get the meetings scheduled and if we have to cancel we will. Availability: Tuesday October 16th: 9:00—1:30 Wednesday October 17th: anytime Thursday October 18th: 3:00 Friday October 19th: 1:00, 2:00 Monday October 22nd: 9:00—12:00, Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant 11 The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North. Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103CYK P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com COL EMAN I YOVANOVICH KOESTER Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. *purr 4.0Trusted & Verified • Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. 12 • GrecoSherry From: GrecoSherry Sent: Tuesday, October 9, 2018 3:43 PM To: 'Dianna Quintanilla' Subject: RE: Meeting Request:Alligator Alley& Russell Square How about the 17th at 10 AM and is 1/2 hour enough? SSierry c reco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent:Tuesday, October 9, 2018 3:35 PM To: GrecoSherry<Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Meeting Request:Alligator Alley& Russell Square Good afternoon, Rich is requesting to meet with the Commissioner on the following two items that are on the BCC agenda for October 23rd: 1. Alligator Ally— also attending: Jesse Houghtalen &Wayne Arnold 2. Russell Square—also attending: Dan Ciesielski &Wayne Arnold Rich did mentioned that the two items might be on consent agenda but at this point he is not sure. He requested that I get the meetings scheduled and if we have to cancel we will. Availability: Tuesday October 16th: 9:00—1:30 Wednesday October 17th: anytime Thursday October 18th: 3:00 Friday October 19th: 1:00, 2:00 Monday October 22"d: 9:00—12:00, Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant 13 The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103CYK P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com COLEMAN I YOVANOVtCH I KOESTER Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. itr Trusted & Verified 9'itfsirg t'# Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. 14 GrecoSherry From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent: Tuesday, October 9, 2018 3:35 PM To: GrecoSherry Subject: Meeting Request: Alligator Alley& Russell Square Good afternoon, Rich is requesting to meet with the Commissioner on the following two items that are on the BCC agenda for October 23rd: 1. Alligator Ally— also attending: Jesse Houghtalen &Wayne Arnold 2. Russell Square—also attending: Dan Ciesielski &Wayne Arnold Rich did mentioned that the two items might be on consent agenda but at this point he is not sure. He requested that I get the meetings scheduled and if we have to cancel we will. Availability: Tuesday October 16th: 9:00—1:30 Wednesday October 17th: anytime Thursday October 18th: 3:00 Friday October 19th: 1:00, 2:00 Monday October 22nd: 9:00— 12:00, Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant CYK The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com CCHEMAN I O V A N C V I C H I K O S T E R Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. ytrt fTrusted & Verified • Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman, Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you hove received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. 15 GrecoSherry From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent: Tuesday, October 16, 2018 1:20 PM To: GrecoSherry Subject: Meeting Request: Russell Square Good afternoon, We just found out that Transportation Staff have changed their minds and now Russell Square will be on regular agenda on October 23`d Rich is requesting a meeting with the Commissioner. Dan Ciesielski, Michael Greenberg &Wayne Arnold will also be attending. Availability: Wednesday October 17th anytime Thursday October 18th: 9:00, 10:00, 1:30—5:00 Friday October 19th: 9:00—2:00 Monday October 22"d: 9:00-12:00 Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant CYK The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 t dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com C � L " MAN O V A O V C Y O E s F .;' Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. yoff# . 4 M Trusted Verified Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman, Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. 1 GrecoSherry Subject: Russell Square - Yovanovich, Dan Ciesielski, Michael Greenberg &Wayne Arnold Location: 3rd floor conf rm Start: Mon 10/22/2018 9:30 AM End: Mon 10/22/2018 10:00 AM Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Meeting organizer Organizer: TaylorPenny Required Attendees: Dianna Quintanilla 1 GrecoSherry 7 Subject: Alligator Alley - Rich Yovanovich,Jesse Houghtalen &Wayne Arnold Location: Taylor office apijarito r Start: Wed 10/17/2018 9..0 AM End: Wed 10/17/201: 0:00 AM //al Show Time As: Tentative Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: No et responded Organizer: TaylorPenny Required Attendees: - Dianna Quintanilla rp. CC( L.-- 2 GrecoSherry Subject: Canceled: Alligator Alley - Rich Yovanovich, Jesse Houghtalen &Wayne Arnold Location: Taylor office Start: Wed 10/17/2018 9:30 AM End: Wed 10/17/2018 10:00 AM Show Time As: Free Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Not yet responded Organizer: TaylorPenny Required Attendees: Dianna Quintanilla Importance: High GrecoSherry From: Dianna Quintanilla <DQuintanilla@cyklawfirm.com> Sent: Tuesday, October 9, 2018 3:45 PM To: GrecoSherry Subject: RE: Meeting Request:Alligator Alley& Russell Square Yes,thank you and confirmed. Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant The Northern Trust Building CYK 4001 Tamiami Trail North,Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 COLEMAN I YOVANOVICH KOESTER P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com Visit cvklawfirm.com to learn more about us. ,r t r,t Trusted & Verified a Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman, Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited.If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. From: GrecoSherry [mailto:Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov] Sent:Tuesday, October 9, 2018 3:45 PM To: Dianna Quintanilla Subject: RE: Meeting Request: Alligator Alley& Russell Square Are these 2 separate meetings, if so then 9:30 and 10 AM on the 17t" siierr� 4reco Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Penny Taylor, District 4 239-252-8604 Fax 239-252-6393 Sherry.Greco@colliercountyfl.gov Click here to sign up for our District 4 newsletter 1 From: Dianna Quintanilla Sent:Tuesday, October 9, 2018 3:35 PM To: GrecoSherry Subject: Meeting Request: Alligator Alley& Russell Square Good afternoon, Rich is requesting to meet with the Commissioner on the following two items that are on the BCC agenda for October 23rd: 1. Alligator Ally—also attending:Jesse Houghtalen &Wayne Arnold 2. Russell Square—also attending: Dan Ciesielski &Wayne Arnold Rich did mentioned that the two items might be on consent agenda but at this point he is not sure. He requested that I get the meetings scheduled and if we have to cancel we will. Availability: Tuesday October 16th: 9:00—1:30 Wednesday October 17th: anytime Thursday October 18th: 3:00 Friday October 19th: 1:00, 2:00 Monday October 22nd: 9:00—12:00, Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla Legal Assistant The Northern Trust Building CYK 4001 Tamiami Trail North,Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 COLEMAN 1 YOVANOVICH I KOESTER P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cvklawfirm.com Visit cyklawfirm.com to learn more about us. spell, .4 0.4..a 8 Trusted & Verified Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman, Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited.If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla(Wcvklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. 2