The URL can be used to link to this page

Ex-parte - Solis 10/23/2018 3 Ex parte Items - Commissioner Andy Solis COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AGENDA October 23, 2018 ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS 9.A. This item requires ex parte disclosure be provided by the Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve an Ordinance of the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida amending Ordinance Number 2005-36,the Regal Acres Residential Planned Unit Development, by increasing the permissible number of dwelling units from 184 to 300; by amending Ordinance Number 2004-41,the Collier County Land Development Code by amending the appropriate zoning atlas map or maps by changing the zoning classification of an additional 23.15+/-acres of land zoned rural Agricultural (A) to the Regal Acres RPUD; by revising the development standards; by amending the master plan; adding deviations; revising developer commitments; by removing the density bonus agreement for Parcel A approved in Ordinance Number 2005-36 as an attachment to the Ordinance and by approval of an affordable housing density bonus for the added 23.15 acres that will generate 46 bonus units for low or moderate income residents.The property is located on the west side of Greenway Road east of Collier Boulevard (C.R. 951),and north of U.S.41, in Section 12,Township 51 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida consisting of 59.90+/-acres;and by providing an effective date [PL20170001733]. (This is a companion to Agenda Item 11.E.) NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SEE FILE ®Meetings ❑Correspondence ®e-mails ['Calls MEETING: EMAILS: 6/18/18: Lisa Lefkow, Nick Kouloheras Many from nearby residents, attached 9.B. This item requires ex parte disclosure be provided by the Commission members.Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve an Ordinance amending Ordinance No. 2004-41, as amended,the Collier County Land Development Code,which established the comprehensive zoning regulations for the unincorporated area of Collier County, Florida by amending the appropriate zoning atlas map or maps by changing the zoning classification of the herein described real property from a Rural Agricultural (A)zoning district with a portion of the real property in a ST overlay(Special Treatment)to a Residential Planned Unit Development(RPUD)zoning district for the project known as Russell Square RPUD to allow development of up to 230 multi-family dwelling units on property located east of Santa Barbara Boulevard and approximately 1/4 mile south of Davis Boulevard in Section 9,Township 50 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida,consisting of 32.9+/-acres; and by providing an effective date. [PL20170004414]. NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SEE FILE ®Meetings I (Correspondence ®e-mails ®Calls MEETING: 10/19/18: Rich Yovanovich, Dan Ciesielski, Michael Greenberg & Wayne Arnold EMAILS: 10/22/18 from Rich Yovanovich CALLS: 10/22/18 with Rich Yovanovich Ex parte Items - Commissioner Andy Solis COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AGENDA October 23, 2018 SUMMARY AGENDA 17.A. This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve Petition VAC-PL20180002425,to disclaim, renounce and vacate the County and the public interest in the two Raw Water Well Site Easements and the County Utility Easement(C.U.E.) located along the northerly border of Lot 1 of Alligator Alley Commerce Center Phase Two, as recorded in Plat Book 49, Page 60 of the public records of Collier County, Florida.The subject property is located in the southwest quadrant of the 1-75 and Collier Boulevard intersection, located in Section 34,Township 49 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida. (This is a companion to Agenda Item 17.B). X NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SEE FILE Meetings [Correspondence He-mails ❑Calls 17.B. This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by the Commission members.Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve an Ordinance amending Ordinance Number 07-26,the 1-75/Alligator Alley CPUD,to allow for the development of up to 425 multi-family dwelling units in addition to the existing permitted maximum 265,000 square feet of office and retail uses and a 107 room motel, subject to a maximum of 1,172 two-way p.m., peak hour trips for the entire PUD;to add an additional Master Plan to reflect the site layout if the property is developed with both residential and commercial uses,and to limit residential uses to the area identified as"C/R;"to add development standards for residential uses;to modify development commitments relating to environmental,transportation, utilities, water management, affordable housing, and land use and project phasing requirements; and to add deviations relating to preserve standards.The subject property is located on the northwest corner of the Collier Boulevard and Davis Boulevard intersection, in Section 34,Township 49 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida,consisting of 40.8±acres; and by providing an effective date. [PL20180000049] (This is a companion to Agenda Item 17.A) ❑ NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SEE FILE (Meetings [Correspondence e-mails fCalis GoodnerAngela From: Raymond williams <raymondwilliamsjr@hotmail.com> Sent: Monday, October 22, 2018 8:01 PM To: SolisAndy Subject: Regal Acres II I'm a board member at Westwind Estates in East Naples. I'm contacting you today about the Regal Acres II project that Habitat for Humanity is doing. I wanted to let you know that they reach out to us late) April early May and had a meeting with us and we had concerns about their project. They listen to our concerns and address our concerns and came back with a proposal that was Far exceeded what we were expecting. I wanted to let you know that about the upcoming council meeting tomorrow and your decision process. Thank you Raymond Williams Westwind Estates Board of director Make everyday the best it can. Life is to short not too. Sent by Outlook for Android October 22,2018 Dear Commissioner Solis, I am writing in opposition to the expansion of Regal Acres.I am not against the concept of Habitat for Human- ity,but I do not believe building these large communities is the best solution.The HOAs do not run like other community HOAs in that they do not enforce any of the rules,the communities suffer,and less and less they take pride in their home ownership. I believe one of the reasons for this is many of the residents are from different cultures and prefer not to embrace ours,but rather want us to tolerate theirs.Do you know of any communities where you are allowed to park on the grass,have 5 or more cars parked day after day,don't keep up with landscaping,allow people to move in without being vetted by the association,or let repairs continue to pile up?Habitat says they are rectifying this, but we have not seen it come to fruition.How many times can a person call code enforcement when the issues are daily?Plus there is no way for anyone to verify who is actually living in a home except through the HOA, which appear not to be concerned and do not know if asked. Speaking of parking,on the proposed PUD changes,they state there are currently 121 PM peak hour two-way trips and the proposed additional 116 single family residential units will generate approximately 120 PM peak hour two-way trips.Note...184 units that are there now generates 121 trips(not even one car per household)and adding 116 would generate 120 trips(one car per household plus 4 extras)...makes no sense.The difference between 184 units and 116 units is 68. So the 116 units generates more trips than the 184 there now. They also state the bonus units are intended to accommodate housing opportunities for low or moderate-income residents.According to the Collier County affordable housing chart for 2 persons income,this is the 80% ($44,640)to 120%($66,960)category. According to Habitat their 2 persons criteria is maximum$36,000,so neither of these categories will actually be served. Habitat is already advertising this new community on their website before it has even be approved.This cer- tainly gives the impression if they ask for it,they get it.Again,is there anyone else in the county that assumes this.They have already purchased many parcels of acreage in that area that is zoned agricultural.Are we to assume the zoning and density will be approved on these parcels regardless?And we will have more concentra- tion in one area. I do not understand why these projects are not being built in other parts of the County.It is illegal to concentrate in one area,and anyone that lives in Collier knows where the more affordable homes are,East Naples.Or as the planning map also shows,South Naples.It's not a secret,but has been stated by County officials,it's not true. Habitat states the reason is land costs.Why are we not making it mandatory that any monies granted to them for land acquisition is to be used to subsidize their land costs,not the actual purchase price.This would make it more reasonable to pay more for land in higher priced areas and would spread the lower income properties throughout. So in closing,I would ask the Commissioners to reject this expansion,the adjacent residents do not want it,and East Naples has shouldered the majority of all"affordable"income housing in the County,aside from lmmokalee,which also has their fair share.The Regal Acres community is large enough already. Sincerely, 6(,, can Kungle Resident October 22,2018 Dear Commissioner Solis, I am writing in opposition to the expansion of Regal Acres.I am not against the concept of Habitat for Human- ity,but I do not believe building these large communities is the best solution.The HOAs do not run like other community HOAs in that they do not enforce any of the rules,the communities suffer,and less and less they take pride in their home ownership. I believe one of the reasons for this is many of the residents are from different cultures and prefer not to embrace ours,but rather want us to tolerate theirs.Do you know of any communities where you are allowed to park on the grass,have 5 or more cars parked day after day,don't keep up with landscaping,allow people to move in without being vetted by the association,or let repairs continue to pile up?Habitat says they are rectifying this, but we have not seen it come to fruition.How many times can a person call code enforcement when the issues are daily?Plus there is no way for anyone to verify who is actually living in a home except through the HOA, which appear not to be concerned and do not know if asked. Speaking of parking,on the proposed PUD changes,they state there are currently 121 PM peak hour two-way trips and the proposed additional 116 single family residential units will generate approximately 120 PM peak hour two-way trips.Note...184 units that are there now generates 121 trips(not even one car per household)and adding 116 would generate 120 trips(one car per household plus 4 extras)...makes no sense.The difference between 184 units and 116 units is 68. So the 116 units generates more trips than the 184 there now. They also state the bonus units are intended to accommodate housing opportunities for low or moderate-income residents.According to the Collier County affordable housing chart for 2 persons income,this is the 80% ($44,640)to 120%($66,960)category. According to Habitat their 2 persons criteria is maximum$36,000,so neither of these categories will actually be served. Habitat is already advertising this new community on their website before it has even be approved.This cer- tainly gives the impression if they ask for it,they get it.Again,is there anyone else in the county that assumes this.They have already purchased many parcels of acreage in that area that is zoned agricultural.Are we to assume the zoning and density will be approved on these parcels regardless?And we will have more concentra- tion in one area. I do not understand why these projects are not being built in other parts of the County.It is illegal to concentrate in one area,and anyone that lives in Collier knows where the more affordable homes are,East Naples.Or as the planning map also shows,South Naples.It's not a secret,but has been stated by County officials,it's not true. Habitat states the reason is land costs.Why are we not making it mandatory that any monies granted to them for land acquisition is to be used to subsidize their land costs,not the actual purchase price.This would make it more reasonable to pay more for land in higher priced areas and would spread the lower income properties throughout. So in closing,I would ask the Commissioners to reject this expansion,the adjacent residents do not want it,and East Naples has shouldered the majority of all"affordable"income housing in the County,aside from Immokalee,which also has their fair share.The Regal Acres community is large enough already. Sincerely, 6( ean Kungle Resident October 22,2018 Dear Commissioner Solis, I am writing in opposition to the expansion of Regal Acres.I am not against the concept of Habitat for Human- ity,but I do not believe building these large communities is the best solution.The HOAs do not run like other community HOAs in that they do not enforce any of the rules,the communities suffer,and less and less they take pride in their home ownership. I believe one of the reasons for this is many of the residents are from different cultures and prefer not to embrace ours,but rather want us to tolerate theirs.Do you know of any communities where you are allowed to park on the grass,have 5 or more cars parked day after day,don't keep up with landscaping,allow people to move in without being vetted by the association,or let repairs continue to pile up?Habitat says they are rectifying this, but we have not seen it come to fruition.How many times can a person call code enforcement when the issues are daily?Plus there is no way for anyone to verify who is actually living in a home except through the HOA, which appear not to be concerned and do not know if asked. Speaking of parking,on the proposed PUD changes,they state there are currently 121 PM peak hour two-way trips and the proposed additional 116 single family residential units will generate approximately 120 PM peak hour two-way trips.Note...184 units that are there now generates 121 trips(not even one car per household)and adding 116 would generate 120 trips(one car per household plus 4 extras)...makes no sense.The difference between 184 units and 116 units is 68.So the 116 units generates more trips than the 184 there now. They also state the bonus units are intended to accommodate housing opportunities for low or moderate-income residents.According to the Collier County affordable housing chart for 2 persons income,this is the 80% ($44,640)to 120%($66,960)category. According to Habitat their 2 persons criteria is maximum$36,000,so neither of these categories will actually be served. Habitat is already advertising this new community on their website before it has even be approved.This cer- tainly gives the impression if they ask for it,they get it.Again,is there anyone else in the county that assumes this.They have already purchased many parcels of acreage in that area that is zoned agricultural.Are we to assume the zoning and density will be approved on these parcels regardless?And we will have more concentra- tion in one area. I do not understand why these projects are not being built in other parts of the County.It is illegal to concentrate in one area,and anyone that lives in Collier knows where the more affordable homes are,East Naples.Or as the planning map also shows,South Naples.It's not a secret,but has been stated by County officials,it's not true. Habitat states the reason is land costs.Why are we not making it mandatory that any monies granted to them for land acquisition is to be used to subsidize their land costs,not the actual purchase price.This would make it more reasonable to pay more for land in higher priced areas and would spread the lower income properties throughout. So in closing,I would ask the Commissioners to reject this expansion,the adjacent residents do not want it,and East Naples has shouldered the majority of all"affordable"income housing in the County,aside from Immokalee,which also has their fair share.The Regal Acres community is large enough already. Sincerely, itcz, can Kungle Resident GoodnerAngela From: Jean Kungle <jeankungle@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, October 22, 2018 6:12 PM To: SolisAndy Cc: GoodnerAngela Subject: Regal Acres II RPUD Attachments: Commissioner Solis - Regal.pdf Dear Commissioner Solis, Please see attached letter referring to the Regal Acres expansion on the BCC agenda tomorrow. Thank you for your consideration, Jean Kungle Jean Kungle Naples, FL 34112 mobile (239) 269-2511 BrownleeMichael From: Kim Pojeta 2<pojetabodrl@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, June 04, 2018 7:27 PM To: FialaDonna Subject: tonight meeting at the church on Regal Acres Categories: PRINTED First thank you for attending. And secondly, I apologize for handing the mike back when I finished my question. But I asked if Habitat looks at affordable housing as a whole throughout the county by district prior to choosing a location to build since Collier residents work all over the county too. The response was about land value/cost. I suggested they consider looking at all affordable housing locations including existing value properties that can be bought by district before determining where need is and looking at land in areas that lack affordable housing even though the bottom dollar of the product may be higher because commuting 45 minutes to work or more is tough too. I also realized after I left that looking by district and by build-able amounts of district could be valuable too. Thanks again for attending and for your support, Kim 1 BrownleeMichael From: Janet OConnell <janetoc8@yahoo.com> Sent: Tuesday, June 05, 2018 9:59 AM To: FialaDonna Subject: Habitat on our Preserve Zoned Agricultural Categories: ATTENTION, PRINTED Hello again Mrs. Fiala...I have been one of your very loyal supporters ever since I moved here from Broward County in 2004.Thank you for talking to me as you were leaving the meeting last night. More people spoke after you left, including another RL owner who expressed her disgust especially at that nasty female lawyer. I don't know if you noticed that she did interrupt me and reached out to take the microphone away from me! I told her that I had every right to speak. It sounds like Habitat considers this a DONE DEAL, since the other Commissioners will give them the Rezoning! It's even much worse than the approval of the recent storage facility across from Naples Reserve Blvd entrance! I said what I did last night because I watched Broward County get over-developed over my 30 plus years over there.The end result in Broward is terrible...traffic a total nightmare, high crime,disgusting density, and even Lighthouse Point where I had a cute condo looks old and crappy. Coral Springs is now also horrific. I'm sure my prediction for Naples is correct if the County leaders continue to sell off to the developers including Habitat. It doesn't surprise me what you said about your trying to get a few decent stores out this way. Look at Freedom Square and the blight there! The old Kmart building remains a huge problem. Even Dollar Tree is moving into a much needed new location behind the 5th/3rd Bank across 41! You have tried so hard but your colleagues don't care. PLEASE STAND UP TO THEM AND TRY TO STOP THE REZONING! Yes, Habitat does much good but to listen to their slick presentation along with their horrible lawyer was so AWFUL.They even have land down by the Links! Habitat in Broward has built disgusting homes that are NOT maintained. So, it looks like Collier County could be renamed Broward County West in the near future! Horror. Is this what our Commission wants? We the People and owners with our lifetime investments sunk into Collier County do NOT. I'm guessing what I'm saying here will not make a difference, a very hard pill for me to swallow as a retired FL educator. Most Respectfully, Janet M. O'Connell 14160 Winchester Ct. #1801 Naples, FL 34114 Reflection Lakes Sent from Yahoo Mail on Android 1 BrownleeMichael From: Janet OConnell <janetoc8@yahoo.com> Sent: Tuesday, June 05, 2018 12:49 PM To: FialaDonna; bod@reflectionlakesatnaples.com; Jane Kraska; Errol Devore Subject: Fw: Your meeting last night in southeast Naples Categories: PRINTED Sent from Yahoo Mail on Android Forwarded Message From: "Janet OConnell" <janetoc8@yahoo.com> To: "nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org" <nkouloheras@habitatcollier.org> Sent: Tue, Jun 5, 2018 at 12:47 PM Subject: Your meeting last night in southeast Naples To Mr. Kouloheras: I was at the meeting last night and spoke about the overbuilding, etc and mentioned what has happened in Broward County.The attempt by your insulting and overcontrolling attorney to interrupt and take the microphone away from me was totally inappropriate and close to violating my 1st Amendment rights. I have always been a supporter of Habitat and often visit your Restore on 41 to buy some smallish item for a few dollars which is all I can afford. I have worked hard since age 16...1 am now closing in on 68. I have known very hard times and have never asked nor expected any help from anyone. I still do tutoring part time when available which has helped me to pay off the huge Hurricane Assessment of$1800 at Reflection Lakes. My final $600 payment is due on June 15th. I live on the cheaper street of Winchester Court(condo/villa area)and in April 2016 I paid less than $200K.The Preserve behind us is exactly that.Your presentation was very slick, as our Master Association President said to you. He didn't even indicate his title, because most of us in Reflection Lakes are very down to earth, many years hard working, middle class folks.The majority of us are definitely NOT racist nor discriminatory.Yes, most of my life savings went into my condo/villa where I figured I could live peacefully for maybe 15-18 years before my life ends. Now your organization comes along wanting to build on the Preserve and I guess you consider it a DONE DEAL since you have already figured that the Rezoning will go your way! If it does, which will be very sad and beyond disturbing, our beauty will end and the density factor that you don't really care about will continue to take over and yes,this is already on the way to Broward County West! My other point and direct question is...What if you had a tract of land down in Port Royal or the Estates area of Marco Island? How would you handle a major outcry of opposition from many million dollar owners in luxury areas? I realize that this is a mute point. But you need to also look at your building in Broward County and how poorly maintained those have become! The years go by and blight comes because of overbuilding. The developers have made their many millions at our expense.You too have a huge budget of over$90million! I am a nobody who has dedicated her life to helping many thousands of students and parents over 30 years. I made a pittance salary and my state pension is pathetic, not to mention the lack of decent medical and dental benefits! My mother and I lived in a tiny house in Pompano Beach and then when I could afford a small condo in Lighthouse Point, I moved us to the other side of Federal Highway to a little bit better area. I drove every day out to Coral Springs. As I said, I never expected anything to be made easier for me. Your expectations are a bit too much since you think Rezoning is appropriate and you already have your plans to build. In my mind that is putting the cart before the horse, but you must already know that the winds are going to blow favorably your way. Moreover,there are plenty of affordable housing dwellings off of Manatee Road and along 41 west of here. And by the way, how on earth do you expect the extra kids to be taken into the already very sad, decrepit Manatee schools that Collier County Schools could care less about improving?! Frankly, those portables should be condemned. I am a realist. I am also 100%honest and have always done the right thing. Finally,your lawyer should also do the right thing and at least send me an email apology. Respectfully, Ms Janet M. O'Connell 14160 Winchester Ct.#1801 1 BrownleeMichael From: Janet OConnell <janetoc8@yahoo.com> Sent: Wednesday, June 06, 2018 9:49 AM To: FialaDonna Subject: A followup to yesterday's email Categories: ATTENTION, PRINTED Hello again Mrs. Fiala...I had sent a decent email to the Collier Pres. of Habitat yesterday. His reply back to me was not nice. I can forward it to you if you want to read it. He accused me of not doing my homework, not living long enough in Collier County, and he has no interest in even knowing about Habitat in Broward County. I replied back that I have lived in Collier Cty for 14 years,that as a retired educator with advanced degrees (also Phi Beta Kappa from the University of Florida) I always have done My Homework, and that he should drive over to Broward if he doesn't believe my facts! Frankly, I am now angry which I seldom allow myself to become! Our Master Board at Reflection Lakes and Naples Reserve are also angry and what Habitat needs to understand is: WE DO NOT WANT TO BE REZONED FROM OUR CURRENT AGRICULTURAL TO WHAT ANY DEVELOPER WANTS IN ORDER TO BUILD. Habitat's attitude with their nasty attorney wants NO OPPOSITION and they are determined to get what they want. Furthermore, Habitat's normal Modus Operandi is to go into blighted areas to improve housing for those less fortunate. Naples Reserve and Reflection Lakes are NOT BLIGHTED, nor do we want to have that happen since our investments here range from$220K-$1million plus(especially at Naples Reserve)! But again the point is to stop the building in our Preserved area which is ZONED AGRICULTURAL!This has nothing to do with racism or discrimination. We have a diversity in RL, and my neighbors are minority and great people who work very hard and pay a very high rent! You will get flooded with mail and emails which are now becoming a full fledged campaign. We are begging you and the other County Commissioners to NOT REZONE OUR AREA. Please do NOT make this a DONE DEAL for Habitat which is what they already figure they have. We recently lost to the Storage facility that is being built across from Naples Reserve Blvd entrance on 41. We will NOT stand idly by and accept any rezoning to allow any additional acreage to be bought and built on by any entity that destroys our beautiful Preserve area. As always, thank you a million times for your hard work! Most respectfully, Ms.Janet M.O'Connell Reflection Lakes Sent from Yahoo Mail on Android BrownleeMichael From: Janet OConnell <janetoc8@yahoo.com> Sent: Thursday, June 07, 2018 9:31 AM To: FialaDonna Subject: No Rezoning to benefit Habitat Categories: ATTENTION, PRINTED Thank you Commissioner Fiala for Micael's reply.There are a few more serious issues that prove the bullying tactics of Habitat. More children going to the Manatee schools that are already Title Nine and in terrible condition...is the Collier School Board going to build much needed new buildings over on that site?Where is that money going to come from? It doesn't seem likely that Habitat is going to contribute any money from their$93 million budget to help the Manatee schools! Is the Federal government going to supply more free meals, etc for these additional children? Lely High School is also overcrowded! Now Greenway Road. Naples Reserve closed the use of that road for construction trucks over a year ago. That road is in terrible condition and will need to be redone and improved. Will the County provide money for that since Habitat won't? Also the Collier Sherrif does go back into Regal Estates 1 quite often for crime calls. Building a wall with foliage by Habitat that will cost$600,000 out of Habitat's coffers is now NOT a guarantee as you heard the other night from Habitat's Collier President. He made it clear that that would be a lot of money that Habitat may NOT be able to fork out! Well, how much more duping is the Collier County Commission going to stand for?Our communities are NOT BLIGHTED. Habitat normally goes into blighted areas to do some good work. Unfortunately,the improvements in these blighted areas do not last, because the so-called "sweat equity" is not long term. I have seen this in NY and in Broward County, FL As a retired Florida educator on a very limited budget who has worked very hard all of my life and NEVER expected any handout from anyone, this entire "Bill of Goods" smells terrible. We do NOT WANT REZONING TO satisfy any additional building that also has a huge potential for corruption. Florida, where I have lived most of my life, has always had too much corruption by developers, politicians, local governments. Collier County was once a safe haven and known for decency.Along with out of control building now in full swing, many of our local leaders are being swept along to satisfy those with the money responsible for Collier's reputation going downhill. This is totally reprehensible. So much corruption destroyed Broward.The lessons are very clear and being ignored now in Collier. ( I will now fade into the background as many others will also be standing up.) Respectfully, Janet M. O'Connell Sent from Yahoo Mail on Android 1 Brown leeMichael From: Lenore Meurer<lenorem@aol com> Sent: Saturday, June 02, 2018 9:06 PM Subject: Habitat for Humanity NIM for more low income housing 6/4/18 attached Attachments: Habitathomebuyer(1) (1).pdf; HFH Regal Acres NIM meeting 642018, adding more low income housing to over concentration in East Naples.pdf Categories: ATTENTION, PRINTED NIM Well of course its scheduled in dead of summer with noone around, in the middle of a rain storm like last year to deter attendance and opposition. No surprises there, this is more low income housing to add to Regal acres out on 41, like we need anymore. I want to require where they are moving from since Cormac insisted at the last AHAC that these people were Naples residents? and from here, though I never knew that we had such a huge Haitian population. Where are they employed, can't look like the past incomplete documents which confirmed noone working in East Naples, not even close. Take a look.. I am submitting my questions, such as how they comply with the statute to avoid overconcentration of low income housing in this target area and do they have that assessment? No bonus housing or any AF housing should be approved without establishing a methodogy for criteria that ensures compliance with the statute. We have 52% of all Affordable housing in Collier County located right here in East Naples, we know there is no way they comply with the law. Who is responsible to ensure Collier staff comply with the law and apply methodology/ assessment with every development application submitted? Where is the data that proves these areas are not saturated? Do all development applications evaluate the equitable distribution of AF housing? Should they? Obviously no one is concerned about the big picture since we have such a huge disparity in housing numbers. Will North Naples citizens be concerned about the housing disparity when we implement bussing their children to Avalon, and other East Naples schools? We are definitely heading in that direction folks just like Fort Myers, because its unconstitutionalto not provide a quality education to children in schools having up to 98% economically disadvantaged attending. This must be reported at the Federal level and immediately addressed. While Collier staff can continue to ignore the statute regarding overconcentration in low income housing in East Naples, there is no ignoring the LAW. We need to demand enforcement of the law to protect us, our children and our communities. Please attend this NIM and be heard, ask these critical questions, where is the analysis that safeguards our communities? We need the data analysis since we must prevent further over saturation and concentration. Habitat has the Largest Affordable Housing Communities in the WORLD located right here, in little Naples, its what we're known as, 'Habitat County' and they're buying up land out on 41 and everywhere, and we let this happen, we've done nothing to stop it, and we will suffer with the repurcussions of doing nothing, saying nothing... LENORE MEURER 1 PRESIDENT Lely Landings Of-Southwest Florida LerjoreMciP ol.com 239-234-6236 2 i d f' J .Lt\ \hIE1S1I Direct adial:(239)336.6233 _,_, IA\7r7 FIR Email:NealaManiga t aQusveselaw.c 35 1833 Hendry Street,Fort Myers,Florida 33901 I P,O,Drawer 1507,Fort Myers,Florida 33902-1507 1(239)334-2195 I Fax(239)332-2243 May 18,2018 Dear Property Owner: JPlea"se be a3vlsbdhiat abitat orumanl o`Co1Iiettounty has subml`fred a`lseti tori seeking Rezoning approval for the following described property: Property located on the west side of Greenway Road to be accessed via Majestic Circle The petitioner is asking the County to approve an application to amend the Regal Acres Residential Planned Unit Development by changing the zoning classification of 23.15+1-acres of land zoned Rural Agricultural (A) to the Regal Acres RPUD. This change will amend the master plan to include the additional land and will increase the permissible number of dwelling units from 184 to 300. The request includes an affordable housing density bonus agreement for the added 23.15 acres that will generate 46 bonus units for low or moderate income residents on the described property. In compliance with the Land Development Code requirements,a Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held to provide you an opportunity to become fully aware of the intended development associated with this application. The Neighborhood Information Meeting will be held on Monday,June 4 at 5:30 p.m.at the First Haitian Baptist Church of Naples located at 14600 Tamiami Trail E,Naples,FL 34114. At this meeting the petitioner will make every effort to illustrate how the property will be developed and to answer any questions. Should you have questions prior to the meeting,please co:tact me. Sincerely, �, rat .4.1`;\1/4\ N e Mon '�rr� P NM/kac I • 4632 VINCENNES BLVD.,SUITE 101 4524 GUN CLUE ROAD,SUrr5203 CAPE CORAL,FLORIDA 33904 WEST PALM BEACH,FLORIDA 33415 (239)542-3148 (561)471-I366 BrownleeMichael From: Ronald Wahl <rkwahl98@msn.com> Sent: Friday, June 08, 2018 10:05 PM To: FialaDonna Subject: Habitat for Humanity Regal Acres II Categories: ATTENTION, PRINTED Dear Commissioners: We are very concerned about the consideration of sacrificing preserve land for housing. Preserve land was designated so land would be preserved. We all thought that was an environmental responsibility. WE ARE RESIDENTS OF REFLECTION LAKES.TAKE A LOOK AT HOW REFLECTION LAKES WAS FORCED TO PRESERVE LAND IN HENDRY COUNTY WHICH IS A HARDSHIP FOR OUR COMMUNITY! WHY WOULD YOU LET HABITAT FOR HUMANITY BUILD REGAL ACRES ON PRESERVE LAND???? Ron and Sheila Wahl 14704 Cranberry Ct. Naples, FL 344114 Brown leeM ichael From: Lynn Livingston <redwingnut1@me.com> Sent: Friday, June 08, 2018 10:30 AM To: FialaDonna Subject: Regal Acres II Categories: ATTENTION, PRINTED My family is strongly opposed to any expansion of the Habitat for Humanity development called Regal Acres,which we understand will be called Regal Acres II.The current community called Regal Acres is an eyesore.80%of the community has homes that are not maintained and yards that are worse.Some of the homes have 3-4 cars in the driveway,even during working hours.These are supposed to be single family homes but obviously have extended families that have moved in. Even now,we can hear the noise and loud partying at night from existing Habitat homes.Teenagers from Regal Acres have been coming along the canal and trespassing on Reflection Lakes private property.We have seen groups of 3-8 teenagers run through our and our neighbors'yards.Having more Habitat homes only 150 feet from the east side of Reflection Lakes will be a horrible eyesore,more noise and possible increase in trespassing. Respectfully submitted, Aubrey Livingston 14587 Manchester Dr Naples,FL 34114 BrownleeMichael From: Tom Custer<tcuster49@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, June 11, 2018 7:16 PM To: FialaDonna Subject: HH proposed expansion to Regal Acres, Categories: ATTENTION, PRINTED Donna, I have received your Tidbits for some time now and understand you have petitioned your other commissioners to appropriately distribute affordable housing developments equally in Collier county and not focus on East and South Naples. I agree whole heartedly with that to maintain proper diversity in the neighborhoods as being economically sound and essential for property values and diversification. Mike Yancon, sent you an email asking for support to defeat the proposed Zoning Change Habitat for Humanity is proposing by expanding the existing Regal Acres to add approximately 118 more homes that will be contiguous to Naples Reserve. Many in the surrounding neighborhoods attended the first meeting on June 4th at the Haitian Church and vehemently opposed it for the reasons noted above. I am Mike Yancon"s neighbor and will be adversely affected by this expansion if approved as well along with many families along the fence line there. What help you can provide would be greatly appreciated.. In addition, I have been searching Collier County's websites to find a graphic map that inidicates all the Habitat communities and all other affordable housing communities and how they are populated throughout Naples.This would clearly show all the concentration areas for discussion. Please help with this so we can defer growth here and relocate to other areas of Naples. Respectfully submitted and look forward to hearing from you soon. I believe the next meeting with the planning commission or zoning board for this request in June 23 or. 24th. Thanks so much-Tom Custer Thanks- Tom C. 1 BrownleeMichael From: Meltem Tanner<ems_meltem@hotmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, June 13,-2018 12:32 AM To: SolisAndy; FialaDonna; SaundersBurt; TaylorPenny; McDanielBill; ems-matt@msn.com Subject: Habitat for Humanity Regal Acres II Categories: PRINTED Hi Dear Commissioners, I am a homeowner at Reflection Lakes, Manchester Dr. We regretfully found out that there would be a possibility to replace the agricultural zone in Regal Acres II ( off Rt 41 and Greenway Rd ) to a housing project. When we've purchased our property we were assured by Neal Communities that we would have a large preserve in the back of our property that is not buildable. This is the only reason why we purchased our property. Also I believe there should have more green space in our county. I feel it is becoming out of hand when I see ongoing construction all over the place and replacing our beautiful nature with ugly structures. You and other commissioners should plan very well, Please don't let our beautiful community become like any other city. We will seek our rights through legal systems in case of a decision that would destroy our preserve or replace it with housing. It's imperative that you and other commissioners make your decisions responsibly. Thank you Meltem Tanner 14359 Manchester Drive Naples, FL 34114 BrownleeMichael From: Janet OConnell <janetoc8©yahoo.com> Sent: Wednesday, June 27, 2018 5:49 PM To: FialaDonna Subject: Habitat Categories: ATTENTION, PRINTED Hello again Mrs. Fiala...just an update concerning our most recent meeting last evening(June 26th)with Habitat's President in our clubhouse per his request. We again faced another very difficult meeting, as Habitat's President considers it a DONE DEAL and that we need to accept it. He had two Xeroxes: one showing a viewpoint of scope/line of elevation from us to their tops of many little houses;the second was a map in color showing their development and proximity to Reflection Lakes.This upset most of us and his monotonous litany of descriptions, etc.We fired back with many questions and also making it clear that we want NO REZONING AND NO FURTHER BUILDING ENCROACHING ON OUR PRESERVE AND INCLUSIVE THEREOF. HE could have cared less but said maybe he could include a fence. We said A TALL WALL WOULD BE NECESSARY. I brought up the Manatee schools and would Habitat be donating some of their$93 Million to help on that and also Greenway Road? He said that he's not concerned about the schools, because according to him there are 16 empty classrooms! When I asked if these were damaged portables, he would not reply.As for Greenway Rd he left that up in the air with us presuming that the County will have to fund that disastrous road! He said the$93 Million has to be allocated for buying more land behind us for their 184-300 little houses and the mortgages for the owners! Plus the density will be 5 units per acre.We all feel very defeated and angry.We hope that the Rezoning will NOT happen and are begging the County Commission, Planning Commission, and Zoning to make an intelligent decision to keep our Preserve and disputed tract of land Agricultural.Again and again...The building MUST STOP. Please share with your colleagues. Most respectfully, Ms Janet O'Connell ( retired Broward County educator) Reflection Lakes Sent from Yahoo Mail on Android 1 14534 Manchester Drive Naples Florida 34114 June 27,2018 Collier County Commissioners and Planning Commission Liaison Growth Management Dept./Zoning Services Section 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples,FL 34104 Dear Mr. Bosi,Mr.Cohen,Mr. Bellows,Ms. Fiala, Mr. Solis, Mr. Saunders,Ms.Taylor, Mr. McDaniel, Mr. Mark Strain: Our community gathered for a meeting with Habitat for Humanity representatives last evening, June 26,2018 in Reflection Lakes. The goal was to reach agreement to stop the rezoning or facilitate compromise via additional building plan modifications to reduce noise and privacy to those residents bordering the preserve area separating both developments. Increased housing from 184 to 300 units will only increase noise and opportunity for trespassing to our quiet retirement neighborhood. This was the second meeting and this the second letter Reflection Lakes homeowners have voiced their concerns.As homeowners,we foresee inevitable security issues since several incidents have already occurred with teenagers infringing on Manchester Drive properties that abut this preserve. Destroying further woodlands only opens both our developments for more transient trespassing and risk.Neighbors located on the east side of Manchester Drive in Reflection Lakes not only paid larger premium fees for lots that were to border permanent woodland,but stand to suffer damage or injury to their property which derogates from their reasonable use and pleasure. Rezoning compromises what now provides privacy and security;the extensive woodland area that insures distance between developments. As discussed with Habitat at the meeting,we strongly advocate for the DENIAL OF REZONING. In the event you refuse to support our community, we expect the following at Habitat's expense: 1. No less than an eight-foot solid wall between developments to block noise and trespass. 2. Move the playground and basketball court closer to Greenway Road from current planned location 3. Do not construct 22 Habitat homes closest to the preserve thus maintaining the preserve's trees and allowing room for a barrier wall on Habitat's property. 4. Consider the financial impact of upgrading roads leading to these Habitat homes as current conditions threaten optimal access by emergency personnel and vehicles. Sincerely Robert J. and Vicki L. Smith BrownleeMichael From: Ashley Kennedy<ashinosh@icloud.com> Sent: Thursday, June 28, 2018 10:16 AM To: FialaDonna Subject: Concern from Reflection Lakes Categories: PRINTED 14717 Sonoma Blvd. Naples Florida 34114 June 28,2018 Collier County Commissioners and Planning Commission Liaison Growth Management Dept./Zoning Services Section 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples,FL 34104 Dear Ms.Fiala, Our community gathered for a meeting with Habitat for Humanity representatives last evening,June 26,2018 in Reflection Lakes.The goal was to reach agreement to stop the rezoning or facilitate compromise via additional building plan modifications to reduce noise and privacy to those residents bordering the preserve area separating both developments.Increased housing from 184 to 300 units will only increase noise and opportunity for trespassing to our quiet retirement neighborhood. This was the second meeting and this the second letter Reflection Lakes homeowners have voiced their concerns.As homeowners,we foresee inevitable security issues since several incidents have already occurred with teenagers infringing on Manchester Drive properties that abut this preserve.Destroying further woodlands only opens both our developments for more transient trespassing and risk.Neighbors located on the east side of Manchester Drive in Reflection Lakes not only paid larger premium fees for lots that were to border permanent woodland,but stand to suffer damage or injury to their property which derogates from their reasonable use and pleasure.Rezoning compromises what now provides privacy and security;the extensive woodland area that insures distance between developments. As discussed with Habitat at the meeting,we strongly advocate for the DENIAL OF REZONING.In the event you refuse to support our community,we expect the following at Habitat's expense: 1. No less than an eight-foot solid wall between developments to block noise and trespass. 2. Move the playground and basketball court closer to Greenway Road from current planned location 3. Do not construct 22 Habitat homes closest to the preserve thus maintaining the preserve's trees and allowing room for a barrier wall on Habitat's property. 4. Consider the financial impact of upgrading roads leading to these Habitat homes as current conditions threaten optimal access by emergency personnel and vehicles. Sincerely, Ashley Allison Kennedy 1. SolisAndy From: Vicki Smith <vicki14534@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday,August 29, 2018 1:58 PM To: McDanielBill; FialaDonna; StrainMark;TaylorPenny; SolisAndy Subject: CFO for Habitat Dear Mr. Bosi, Mr. Cohen, Mr. Bellows, Ms. Fiala, Mr. Solis, Mr. Saunders, Ms. Taylor, Mr. McDaniel, Mr. Mark Strain: The CFO, Dean Kakos, now sold his home in Reflection Lakes.This sends a big message to neighbors he does not want to live near the Habitat community. Without a clear dividing wall, our property values will suffer. Shame on him and what he represents. Vicki L Smith SolisAndy From: Meltem Tanner <ems_meltem@hotmail.com> Sent: Wednesday,June 13, 2018 12:32 AM To: SolisAndy; FialaDonna; SaundersBurt; TaylorPenny; McDanielBill; ems-matt@msn.com Subject: Habitat for Humanity Regal Acres II Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Completed Hi Dear Commissioners, I am a homeowner at Reflection Lakes, Manchester Dr. We regretfully found out that there would be a possibility to replace the agricultural zone in Regal Acres II ( off Rt 41 and Greenway Rd )to a housing project. When we've purchased our property we were assured by Neal Communities that we would have a large preserve in the back of our property that is not buildable. This is the only reason why we purchased our property. Also I believe there should have more green space in our county. I feel it is becoming out of hand when I see ongoing construction all over the place and replacing our beautiful nature with ugly structures. You and other commissioners should plan very well, Please don't let our beautiful community become like any other city. We will seek our rights through legal systems in case of a decision that would destroy our preserve or replace it with housing. It's imperative that you and other commissioners make your decisions responsibly. Thank you Meltem Tanner 14359 Manchester Drive Naples, FL 34114 SolisAndy From: Sue Thomas <KAMConcretePumping@live.com> Sent: Wednesday, September 5, 2018 1:40 PM To: SolisAndy Subject: FW: A must read before your Habitat Vote tomorrow I am not sure you got this so I am resending as I feel it is extremely important that a wall is on those plans before approval is given, not a fence, a wall. Blessings, Sue Thomas KAM Concrete Pumping Inc. PO Box 990237 Naples, FL 34116 Office: 863-223-5176 Dispatch: 239-913-7277 FAX: 888-413-7844 From: Sue Thomas Sent: Wednesday, September 5, 2018 1:31 PM To: 'Penny taylor Collier County Gov'<penny.taylor@colliercountyfl.gov>; 'Donna Fiala Collier County Gov' <donna.fiala@colliercountyfl.gov>; 'Andy Solis Collier County gov'<andy.solis@colliercountyfl.gov>; 'Burt Saunders Collier County Gov' <burt.saunders@colliercountyfl.gov>; 'Bill Mcdaniel Collier County Gov' <bill.mcdaniel@colliercountyfl.gov>; 'Mark Strain Collier County Gov'<markstrain@colliergov.net> Cc: 'Vicki Smith' <vicki14534@gmail.com> Subject:A must read before your Habitat Vote tomorrow Richard and Susan Thomas 14579 Manchester Drive Naples Florida 34114 Sept 5,2018 Collier County Commissioners and Planning Commission Liaison Growth Management Dept. /Zoning Services Section 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples,FL 34104 Dear Mr. Bosi, Mr. Cohen, Mr. Bellows,Ms. Fiala,Mr. Solis,Mr. Saunders,Ms. Taylor,Mr. McDaniel, Mr.Mark Strain,Mr.Feyer, Mr. Schmitt, Mr. Dearborn,Ms. Homiak,Mr. Sabo: I feel that this is a done deal all ready and this board doesn't care about this area at all. I hope and pray that I am wrong. Do you realize that we are saturated with low income housing all ready which is why Costco and Sam's won't put a store here because the area is saturated with low income families. You have heard concerns about over flowing trash cans,street racing along Greenway, kids cutting through woods into our development,the noise level is all ready loud, boom boxes in the middle of the night, kids where they don't belong yet you are probably going to approve more two story residences behind our homes. This new development will make things even worse because there will be no garages—so that's more people in the home, more cars outside and no place to put the garbage cans—which has created a bear problem—no one in the older development puts the cans in the garage. Nick Kouloheras will tell you have they have an HOA but obviously the people who live there really don't care and don't have ownership pride. Nick Kouloheras,glibly stated that he would look into a wall for us and then the next meeting he said they really don't have the money for it. Additionally, my son owns a concrete pump company and I offered a discount on doing the fill cells in the wall, I have received no call from Habitat which tells me they have no intention of protecting Reflection Lakes. Habitat, no money?Really—I think not, I would like to know the amount of the last fund raising letter sent out brought in. They have plenty of funds and the cost to install the wall is minimal when you are looking to divide that between so many units. If this was your home Penny Taylor,what would you want? I know that you don't care at all about East Naples. You must put in a wall—preferably on top of a berm. I lived in Golden Gate City for over 10 years, it took me a long time to save enough to move out of there and now you want to put a getto behind my home. Nick Kouloheras says it won't affect the appraised value—probably not since that's the taxable amount but when you make an area undesirable, which this vote will do,you have just cast a death sentence on property values in this area. I'm 61, I have no time to recover from this vote. I was planning on being able to refinance my home so I can stay in it—but that won't happen because you will be cutting the value of our property tin Reflection Lakes. Here is a visual of what you are destroying just in case you can't understand what I am saying. ‘411144X44 ' #- d i 1i' 444 iiiiir .�N I ,, S.., -.J4p .-et ,� , i '{ Ig a ' I can't imagine this gone—the deer come all the time to Reflection Lakes, 4-5 of themri ata time. This is Regal Acres,1 A r t There were at least 9 homes that had full driveways and flowing in the street Iv ., a ,. - -, xae,- VIIII Ogl VW ^w Uncut grass and garbage cans outside—this is our bear problem . t v y s Vs q - aim 111111111111.11 More can's outside Driving commercial vehicles on the grass tot..T i I ..cam.. § If the wind blew it over—couldn't you pick it up- no pride in ownership here. Ass iF lit And finally—the boat and ry storage yard—but I have to pay to store mine but I will have to look at theirs. Please do the right thing—Give us a wall, on a berm—not a fence—your sticking a basketball court in our backyard—the noise and the boom boxes will be never ending. Please help Reflection Lakes maintain their safety and quiet. Sincerely Rick and Sue Thomas 14579 Manchester Dr Naples, Fl 34114 Blessings, Sue Thomas __;a Concrete Pumping Inc. PO Box 990237 Naples, FL 34116 Office: 863-223-5176 Dispatch: 239-913-7277 FAX: 888-413-7844 i -, „ SolisAndy From: Michael Yancon <michael.yancon@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, October 17, 2018 3:05 PM To: FialaDonna; SolisAndy; SaundersBurt; TaylorPenny; McDanielBill Cc: Tom Custer; Mara Foley Subject: PERTINENT INFORMATION > Regal Acres RPUD Rezoning Petition Attachments: Naples Reserve Rezoning Support Flyers.pdf Commissioners, Relating to the petition submitted by Habitat for Humanity to expand the Regal Acres RPUD, currently on the BCC Agenda for consideration on 10/23/2018. I am a resident of Naples Reserve who will be directly impacted by future developments if this petition is approved, and wanted to express my support for approval. Since learning about the petition, several residents of Naples Reserve and I have met with Habitat on multiple occasions to discuss reasonable options for improving the buffer zone between NR and the proposed expansion, above and beyond what is required by code. The result of these discussions is an 8ft wall with heavy foliage on both sides to be installed and run along the north and east sides of Habitats property line. Habitat commissioned the creation of sketches and diagrams showing the physical location of the wall and what it would look like, and submitted these to the CCPC during their 8/6/18 meeting to be considered as part of the overall development proposal. Considering above, I personally feel the Habitat team has gone above and beyond to address our concerns relating to the preserve area that will be developed. I have also attached signed flyers from 31 other Naples Reserve residents indicating their support for re-zoning, most of whom own homes that will in some way be immediately impacted by this development. Respectfully submitted, Michael Yancon 269-720-9702 Naples Reserve 14595 Topsail Dr, Naples FL 34114 michael.vancon@gmail.com SolisAndy From: Raymond williams <raymondwilliamsjr@hotmail.com> Sent: Thursday,August 16, 2018 9:03 AM To: SolisAndy Subject: Habitat for Humanity Regal Acres II project Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Completed Good morning. I am one of the board of directors at Westwind Estates in East Naples. Habitat for Humanity reached out to us back in the spring and had a meeting with the residents and board members to discuss their Regal Acres II project. We brought up a few concerns about noise and what we would like to see done. They listened to our concerns and went back and addressed those problems. And came back with a solution that was more than acceptable to us. And we would welcome them as Neighbors. Raymond Williams Board member Westwind Estates Make everyday the best it can. Life is to short not too. Sent by Outlook for Android Make everyday the best it can. Life is to short not too. Sent by Outlook for Android SolisAndy From: Ronald Wahl <rkwahl98@msn.com> Sent: Friday,June 8, 2018 10:09 PM To: SolisAndy Subject: Fw: Habitat for Humanity Regal Acres II From: Ronald Wahl Sent: Friday,June 8, 2018 10:04 PM To: Donna.Fiala@colliercountyfl.gov Subject: Habitat for Humanity Regal Acres II Dear Commissioners: We are very concerned about the consideration of sacrificing preserve land for housing. Preserve land was designated so land would be preserved. We all thought that was an environmental responsibility. WE ARE RESIDENTS OF REFLECTION LAKES.TAKE A LOOK AT HOW REFLECTION LAKES WAS FORCED TO PRESERVE LAND IN HENDRY COUNTY WHICH IS A HARDSHIP FOR OUR COMMUNITY! WHY WOULD YOU LET HABITAT FOR HUMANITY BUILD REGAL ACRES ON PRESERVE LAND???? Ron and Sheila Wahl 14704 Cranberry Ct. Naples, FL 344114 SolisAndy From: Vicki Smith <vicki14534@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, September 5, 2018 11:50 AM To: McDanielBill; FialaDonna; StrainMark; TaylorPenny; BellowsRay; SolisAndy; Sue Thomas; HomiakKaren; penny.fisher@naplesnews.com Subject: Rezoning decision on 9/6 People bought land in Reflection Lakes,wasn't cheap and promised woodland preserve behind their homes. Habitat buys land; intends to build in what you folks know is already saturated with low income housing per your own 2015 report. It is your decisions that created lower income areas,own it. Just because one buys land doesn't mean you must let them build. Let them farm the land. Clearly there is bias towards, Habitat,who has the most money and it is not our community who has money to fight this. If you don't say no,then add stipulations to divide our communities. Habitat has the money. Millions. This Rezoning is devastating to what we were promised. Plans to build there must not be granted OR, Habitat must augment plans under new stipulations. The current development out there is not well cared for. We all thought East Naples was the new direction for Growth. No one will buy here if you press forward with more subsidized housing communities. Build these people houses or renovate houses in other neighborhoods to help their property maintain its value. Building subsidized neighborhoods is not the answer. Vicki L Smith SolisAndy From: Vicki Smith <vicki14534@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday,August 21, 2018 9:28 PM To: McDanielBill; SaundersBurt; FialaDonna;TaylorPenny; SolisAndy Subject: Say no to Rezoning between Reflection Lakes and Naples Reserve It appears Habitat's rezoning is very political and obviously very bias towards neighboring communities that have sent all of you letters to block this rezoning. We even tried to compromise ; however now Nick is trying to make deals so no one fights the rezoning decision near Reflection Lakes for the Sept 6 meeting. He met with 3 members of our community. See the report of this meeting below. When commissioners make decisions without respecting letters opposing this, then Habitat makes deals so there is no push back at their meeting despite our requests for compromise( solid wall, limit houses, and relocate basketball court since this development is in our backyard), and government ignoring compromise; what recourse does any law abiding citizen do? Many letters were sent to all board members for their consideration. Our future votes will need to be our recourse. "Hi Vicki...Pat Cogswell, Jane Kraska, and myself were asked to go to a meeting with Habitat's President Nick at his office last week. It was informative and courteous. Unfortunately, the 3 items we were hoping for are probably not going to happen. Pres Nick is planning a 6ft chain- link fence with some tree buffers along Manchester line. When I asked him to please be open to the Wall, he wasn't promising. He has found RL's attitude troubling and he doubts that he can convince his Board to be more conciliatory. There is a possibility that if we don't fight Habitat on Sept 6th , then Habitat might be open to some possibilities. The 22 houses closest to Manchester will also be built due to costs, and the playground area cannot be moved due to lack of more space. I gave a full report via email of all of this to our Master Board and have told them that they have to take this on, because they can't ignore it and will need to talk directly to Pres Nick. Frankly, any kind of filibuster idea is not going to work and is too late. I am 99.99% certain that the Rezoning will be done for Habitat. I for one have tried to help our community, but lack of support from Master Board and the majority of our residents has not been there. Pres. Nick does want to be a Good Neighbor and we in turn have to also consider the same. You cannot fight the wealthiest, most endowed Habitat in the USA. Naples Habitat has a $93+MILLION budget for 2018 and a month ago the Collier County Commission gave them another Million in taxpayers Grant! Habitat has also finalized the purchase of the entire 23 acres behind us. It truly is almost a Done Deal. You can't fight this kind of money. Thank you for your suggestions! You can also blame the prior Board for doing nothing about any of this, because sounding the alarm 2 yrs ago would have given us more time to organize and maybe could have helped our cause." Vicki L Smith SolisAndy From: Ashley Kennedy <ashinosh@icloud.com> Sent: Tuesday, September 4, 2018 12:07 PM To: BellowsRay; BosiMichael; SolisAndy;TaylorPenny; SaboJames; StrainMark; patrickdearborn@collergov.net; SchmittJoseph; HomiakKaren; McDanielBill; FialaDonna Subject: 9/6 decision re: rezoning PL20170001733 Mrs. David C. Kennedy 14717 Sonoma Blvd. Naples, FL,34114 To: Collier County Commissioners and Planning Commission Liaison Growth Management Dept./Zoning Services Section 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 Dear Mr. Bosi, Mr. Cohen, Mr. Bellows, Ms. Fiala, Mr.Solis, Mr. Saunders, Ms.Taylor, Mr. McDaniel, Mr. Mark Strain,Mr. Feyer, Mr. Schmitt, Mr. Dearborn, Ms. Homiak, Mr. Sabo: You have on file many letters (June 27, 2018) against rezoning the west side of Greenway Road that borders 300 feet from Reflection Lakes community pool cages and Naples Reserve properties. Retired residents payed significant fees for their land that is immediate to this reserved agricultural land up for a rezoning decision. Recently three members our community met with Nick Kouloheras from Habitat with hope of stopping the rezoning or compromising by placing a solid sound- proof wall between our communities. Reports back from that meeting indicate Nick discouraged having 200 residents come to the 9/6/18 planning meeting. If our residents avoid fighting rezoning, he said he might consider building a solid wall between our communities. His coercive and bias statements meant to influence our attendance on 9/6 does not minimize our true objections to this rezoning; but does emphasize that money and politics have more influence on your decisions than the rights of other Naples'citizens. Please see the highlighted areas below,as the planning commission and county commissioners are accountable and responsible for creating low- income zones in Collier County. Collier County Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing(2015) https://www.colliercountyfl.gov/home/showdocument?id=66401 The Fair Housing Act and similar state fair housing laws list seven prohibited bases for housing discrimination:11 race, color, national origin,gender,familial status, disability,and religion.The socioeconomic analysis appearing earlier in this report contains information on race,ethnicity, and other related factors, but is concerned with the county's composition as a whole.This protected class analysis addresses each of the federally protected groups and their geographic distribution within Collier County to illustrate where concentrations exist. Taken together with this further analysis of affordable housing, labor market participation, education, land use, and other issues,the report as a whole attempts to provide answers as to why protected class concentrations exist where they do. While Collier County is one of the wealthiest counties in Florida,with a per capita income that is approximately 1.4 times that of the state,there are significant poverty indicators and geographic areas of poverty. Four Collier communities have per capita incomes ranging from $9,496 to$24,556, according to the 2010 Census: Immokalee and three communities in the Greater Naples area (Naples Manor,Golden Gate City, and Naples Park).Additionally,Collier County has 5 zip codes designated as Low Income Areas by U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (34142, 34114, 34104, 34113, and 34116). One goal of zoning is to balance individual property rights with the power of government to promote and protect the health, safety, and general welfare of the overall community. Land development codes regulate how a parcel of land in a community may be used and the density of development. Local governments may divide their jurisdiction into zoning districts by adopting a zoning map consistent with the comprehensive plan;define categories of permitted and conditional uses for those districts; and establish design or performance standards for those uses. Zoning may regulate the height,shape, and placement of structures and lot sizes or shapes.Jurisdictions also can expressly prohibit certain types of uses within zoning districts. • We ask that you block this rezoning; keep it agricultural preserve • Do not rezone; balance our property rights to promote the general welfare of our community OR • Regulate the placement of structures;so woodland can be viewed from RL community, not houses • Restrict the number of buildings closest to our land which is 20 Habitat houses • Habitat must build an eight-foot solid wall between our developments • Habitat must move the playground and basketball court closer to Greenway Road from current planned location Rezoning compromises what now provides privacy and security to Reflection Lakes and Naples Reserve;this extensive woodland area insures distance between developments. We do not condone extortion or coercion by any politician or Habitat leadership. Please share this letter at the 9/6 meeting since our community received notice from Nick Kouloheras, not to attend. As discussed with Habitat at several meetings,we strongly advocate for the DENIAL OF REZONING. Sincerely, Robert J. and Vicki L. Smith Mrs. David Kennedy SolisAndy From: Tom Custer <tcuster49@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, October 17, 2018 5:51 PM To: FialaDonna; SolisAndy; SaundersBurt;TaylorPenny; McDanielBill Cc: Mara Foley; Nick Kouloheras; Mike Yancon Subject: Regal Acres RPUD Rezoning Petition Commissioners, Related to the petition submitted by Habitat for Humanity to expand the existing Regal Acres RPUD, currently on the BCC Agenda for consideration on 10/23/2018. I am a resident of Naples Reserve who will be directly impacted by future developments if this petition is approved, and wanted to express my support for approval. Clearly however, due to misrepresentation by representatives of those whom I dealt with to purchase my home saying the beautiful reserve and the serenity of it and the wildlife would NOT ever be affected I would naturally oppose it. Notwithstanding, I/we clearly do not have the right to impact the opportunity for others who need affordable housing to do so since we have been so blessed to have what we have. Since learning of the petition, I, along with my neighbor, have met with Habitat leadership on several occasions to discuss reasonable options for improving the buffer zone between NR and the proposed expansion. The result of these discussions is an 8 ft concrete wall with heavy foliage on both sides (above and beyond what is required by code)to be installed and run along the north and east sides of Habitats property line. Habitat's Landscape Architect provided drawings indicating the physical location of the wall and what it would look like at installation and approximately 5-10 years from installation and submitted these to the CCPC during their 8/6/18 meeting to be considered as part of the overall development proposal. of which I attended and spoke. Considering all of the above, I feel Habitat's leadership team has gone above and beyond to address our concerns relating to the preserve area that will be developed. In addition,they agreed to communicate to their designers and Trade Contractors to ONLY remove what non-native plants that must be and preserve as many existing plants and trees from their landscape mound to the fence on NR property line with the hopes and expectation little has to be removed. Clearly,as can be seen in the next phase of Winding Cypress along the East Trail and in Beach Resort off 951, little care was given to the removal of trees and plants there. Respectfully, Tom Custer 14603 Topsail Dr. Naples FL 34114 SolisAndy From: Asher Hada <akhada33@hotmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, September 5, 2018 6:36 PM To: TaylorPenny; FialaDonna; SolisAndy; SaundersBurt; McDanielBill; StrainMark Subject: A must read before your Habitat Vote tomorrow September 5, 2018 Collier County Commissioners and Planning Commission Liaison Growth Management Dept. /Zoning Services Section 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 Dear Mr. Bosi, Mr. Cohen, Mr. Bellows, Ms. Fiala, Mr. Solis, Mr. Saunders, Ms. Taylor, Mr. McDaniel, Mr. Mark Strain,Mr. Feyer, Mr. Schmitt, Mr. Dearborn, Ms. Homiak, Mr. Sabo: My fellow neighbor Vecki Smith has already written you about our concerns about rezoning and the inevitable need for a solid sound barrier wall should the zoning request be granted to Habitat. No one fells that Rezoning is good for anyone in the Reflection lakes community. But progress and money marches on. Lets at least do the right thing here. If Habitat wants to bully our community into accepting the rezoning, then give us the FIG LEAF and require Habitat to build a barrier wall isolating us from some of the negative impact that low income housing brings with it. If rezoning is inevitable .Then build us a wall and protect what will be left of the Green Belt that was a promised to Reflection Lakes by Builders of the community. Asher Hada 14535 Manchester Drive Naples Florida 34114 <Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov>, Donna Fiala Collier County Gov <Donna.Fiala@colliercountyfl.gov>, Andy Solis Collier County gov <Andy.Solis@colliercountyfl.gov>, Burt Saunders Collier County Gov <Burt.Saunders@colliercountyfl.gov>, Bill Mcdaniel Collier County Gov <Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov>, Mark Strain Collier County Gov <Markstrain@colliergov.net> SolisAndy From: Jerry <gmgodshaw@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, October 22, 2018 2:14 PM To: SolisAndy; GoodnerAngela Subject: Regal Acres zoning item on October 23 BCC Agenda Dear Commissioner Solis, It may be late in the game, but I am writing to urge you to vote in favor of the zoning change for Regal Acres. This would create more opportunities for Habitat to build affordable housing in the county. As you know, Habitat housing creates neighborhoods of responsible homeowners with little criminal activity, hurricane resistant homes and strong communities. Interestingly,even though many neighbors may show up tomorrow to voice opposition, earlier meetings with the neighboring associations did not generate significant opposition. If we are to make progress in the housing arena, such zoning allowances need to proceed in all districts, including the proposed development of rental units on the corner of Pine Ridge and Goodlette. Hope to see you soon. Jerry Godshaw Sent from my iPad SolisAndy From: Lynn Livingston <redwingnutl @me.com> Sent: Friday,June 8, 2018 10:30 AM To: SolisAndy Subject: Regal Acres II Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Completed My family is strongly opposed to any expansion of the Habitat for Humanity development called Regal Acres,which we understand will be called Regal Acres II.The current community called Regal Acres is an eyesore.80%of the community has homes that are not maintained and yards that are worse.Some of the homes have 3-4 cars in the driveway,even during working hours.These are supposed to be single family homes but obviously have extended families that have moved in.Even now,we can hear the noise and loud partying at night from existing Habitat homes.Teenagers from Regal Acres have been coming along the canal and trespassing on Reflection Lakes private property.We have seen groups of 3-8 teenagers run through our and our neighbors'yards.Having more Habitat homes only 150 feet from the east side of Reflection Lakes will be a horrible eyesore,more noise and possible increase in trespassing. Respectfully submitted, Aubrey Livingston 14587 Manchester Dr Naples,FL 34114 SolisAndy From: DAVID KENNEDY <kennedydc@icloud.com> Sent: Tuesday, September 4, 2018 1:58 PM To: SolisAndy Subject: PUDZ-PL20170001733 Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Completed I am writing to express my serious concern about Habitat For Humanity's plans to expand up to the boundaries of Reflection Lakes and Naples Reserve. They have waited twelve years to complete their original plans for this area. In the meantime these two new communities have appeared, but Habitat is proceeding with little regard or concern for the effect their new development will have on these communities. Their development will clearly have a detrimental impact on the value of a number of homes in Reflection Lakes and Naples Reserve, not to mention the quality of life for these residents. Any planning for such a project should be done in a way that meets the needs of ALL residents in the area, or else the project should be rejected by the county. It disappoints me deeply that so far there is little evidence that the county or Habitat is interested in looking after the needs of those who would be adversely affected by Habitat's plans. I hope you all will give this further consideration. Thank you. David Kennedy 14717 Sonoma Blvd. Naples, FL 34114 239-596-8489 SolisAndy Subject: Lisa Lefkow, Nick Kouloheras; Habitat for Humanity(Regal Acres) Location: BCC Office Start: Mon 6/18/2018 2:30 PM End: Mon 6/18/2018 3:00 PM Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Meeting organizer Organizer: SolisAndy Required Attendees: Andrew I. Solis (ASolis@cohenlaw.com) Categories: Commission Chambers Good afternoon,Angela, I am hoping to set an appointment for Nick Kouloheras and myself to meet with Commissioner Solis sometime next week. Monday afternoon? Tuesday afternoon? Wednesday morning? Many thanks for your help! Blessings, Lisa Rev. Lisa B. Lefkow Chief Executive Officer Habitat for Humanity of Collier County 11145 Tamiami Trail E. Naples, FL 34113 239-775-0036(office) 239-595-1111(cell) Modified Site Plan - Regal Acres Expansion i �► . 4erIC. Y' fir. �„'Wilt� 4'.•'•.-�`i ... �.. 1 o w { ax,:r 't �4.y;Ai' AV 1 j� ` • Aq.s r � 'P �{,(:e v.,. i�.c o-'°' :1.7 '� '"� + lail ,�'� e. arhip'4?A tef:iis AV -4,'I•atc-ft .1=41`,..;",,,•*-*-4.4:t4.41.„. IA /+` S0 !'"' c• 1t , �.. : cM1r-fir �` ..- "� e �y '�' A- -„,p,, y I.�`.y A. * tr .� ?..._•440,74. iii i�VJ"' G '��1�'1 �`i'_.� -! 4 k..'it x _">.: �1 i'A: "t S x F c. uN.+ ' +iSi=n�tY. �f ..-r e 1 .... s sir t....,,,,,, k J,- :q•a! h r dt °�t� I would support the below modifications: Decrease impacts of sight and sound; 8' Tall Concrete Wall - Aesthetically Pleasing (following yellow lines) Hide the wall: Heavy foliage on both sides of wall to make as opaque as possible Make sure plans ares op ton_: Opportunity to review and submit feedback on pr. iosed wall & foliage a4",,,_ t - . Modified Site Plan - Regal Acres Expansion 4.,,,, z;fr.A__, - ...•--.4. - •,.. f`Pkes, - otileetimze 7Ir i jareF.:„,,, *-45r.0 -Avii *11 �:M '�_ ' `�'-ft + .,40, .,‘,0, tut, 'fa :+Y k a fR 4 ` .lic ' ' # s, ;, ie I would support the below modifications: 1 Decrease impacts of sight and sQjjnd: 8' Tall Concrete Wall - Aesthetically Pleasing (following yellow lines) Hide the wall: Heavy foliage on both sides of wall to make as opaque as possible I Make sure plans are spot on: 1 0 rt ity evi and submit feedback on proposed wall & foliage 1 , i t-/C i E-4ce-k- (prld iv), r Modified Site Plan - Regal Acres Expansion r ., -►: 'f,d1041011, Vidal 110= :•1, 1.. i �' r'if i * 4 , , '•}. { ` a ..J, -,, Lr1y 4 • i J • X t00, j Tr , ' r 7 L.' k dtfec, ,-"...,i 4:0044:1134 ----7,v. .7., -- -,Le tr, ,......„7: .,_be, jhb 44 ..,.0.,,,,,,... • .... • .. =' .+,,.... . 4),L'..--..'. '1.,,, A , , I i. ,, -,,.. . zr4.0,,,,,,.".,..„.....,,,.,,,—.40.44, 11;:„;,: .4.7.1.1z,".," . ,Atikt& ,4*,,,,s 41'01 741-0,,t dip ..?ticir •f �:tt YaH".Feh Y 4tErf 1 1 •x.f:ie4 - `411:014,. ._ Ai,6.,.. _..,, , -dr:f,.1.;* , ,...t- , ., ,,,.... r ,, ,..,.,,., 144" _'� . „iv r) 1 would support the below modifications: Decrease impacts of sight and sound; 8' Tall Concrete Wall - Aesthetically Pleasing (following yellow lines) Hide the wall: Heavy foliage on both sides of wall to make as opaque as possible Make sure plans are s oft on: Opportunity to review and submit feedback on proposed wall & foliage • Modified Site Plan - Regal Acres Expansion • mi. + .:... • 4.,4„..,.. „--70,,,,,,-, •• ,..„.,... 4„ - - - ,. _ _ . .1.4„. , ♦ � �.t ''e'e'^” . r , '^ i K ,firi iia.M+►� +!.A% wa rrr�rY "Toric kri: 15 414:4, 11110, oVtg•if44, 0+44 Ar,7*14,... --*:-.1r-ci:at -A r lib of fe-.‘' r 1,:or.. ltqu'lpitz- it • ., ' ,a,-,77`):-.. vi,„ ' .3 ,44;4:,:,' ,,,i, . ° .i,or Nat `4,q011.. st ,0,,,,,.40,,,,b0 , -,:40 : .,,„ „ .. -, _ .. ,., ,, , 1_‘, ....„..;.„ " At .. ."4 d',.,044141T",(744,447e4T.V.'' ;,•••• '' .--^- ik'tr , .",,,,, ‘,...,,,,,,,,,,,, „, , I- r ,,z, 4,4 I would support the below modifications: Decrease impacts of sight and sound; 8' Tall Concrete Wall - Aesthetically Pleasing (following yellow lines) Hide the wall: Heavy foliage on both sides of wall to make as opaque as possible Make sure plans are spot on; Opportunity to review and submit feedb.ck on prraposed wall & foliage ___id4,4,,,; ' Cippt,' , IF Modified Site Plan - Regal Acres Expansion IMS a i ti' • A ,.., ',.':% 11,. r :i A,›0 Or '''"' , `t z ,,.....icca 7 a " T ''' , 114 fi .. a .,:..`' : 1 ,• 4 4V :).4.r.." s-0010. ,,, Or "� ,r .is ,:„,,,,,--::::,,.....1. �11 r! iA K., Nom`$ tea. ' } ,, ti„�, ,,,..: „ �..-„ems-. ar„ ,r,.,.. l ,r�„ err t 1 ,►. rte ,, 41 .. 4- 4. Ai- :111M. .., tl+.. "fid ' •_; IP lt M \e+ ,,, of -fi r F_. ,_R. �.¢A z; k. 'q',..4.y 44411 'kttif . *Or ja t , .. f tin „, ��"� - .� j` ff vim* iQ ��'i3 �7 :: ## .T' - was Z 4 x I would support the below modifications: Decrease impacts of sight and sound: 8' Tall Concrete Wall - Aesthetically Pleasing (following yellow lines) Hide the wall: Heavy foliage on both sides of wall to make as opaque as possible Make sure plans are spot on: Opportunity to review and submit feedback on proposed wall & foliage I L-i cp Li frbpi CSL I pg- . Modified Site Plan - Regal Acres Expansion _� .��_. � ."'��- sem_ z w. 1 ::::: : isi 44. es Y, ., ,., ..4"S'+�:;4 �,�✓ ram,_�•�.�! ` ,! .. . ..... ,.„ ..,..., ... .,: „. ... 7 =7 * � , ,g a SP£F. +,..!+f�1.�A_'_'22"F • ... c `3S,F,.. 'ifila .41r- - Ati:,-;;Ielp,=1;:a.tte, 4t-'/-. iir*,- ,. , *tificat4,4 ,,-...,...„1,, ir,.„..kAL..fit,,...-,.. ,..„..,,, Intifsi 4`s,'•-:. - 440'. '-..', : - ' . by/ 1,,,,,..„,,l'ao—v.,,erA c4f,415k4.,..14. '-.3.0-t-.4.7., riv-z!,-74.-4., ',ft. ' __,„ k....-isivizt.d, 0,,:t.,„votly., . -, . ..i,....:IF givi . *I 4441,,,,,Ailr, 04 c.. LI)* °':.-11:2.--,,:j„,--?.•`+MMS „,. t).00, Tit ,t ,/� 'SS+++ ,-, 4 is u.� 'S,,j . - ,-, , `1 '� "�l ^-"�+ .s +k. artE '? �” .vasa = iX'.Eh= .' /,.. 1,,n 4,14„ti {�t.l�r �c S .�1:i�� ra ....kik I support the below modifications: Decrease impacts of sight and sound: 8' Tall Concrete Wall - Aesthetically Pleasing (following yellow lines) Hide the wall: Heavy foliage on both sides of wall to make as opaque as possible Make sure plans are spot on: Opportunity to review and submit feedback on proposed wall & foliage Protect our agreement against future changes; Habitat agrees to submit plan as condition of approval for re-zoning "7' 1/L/ / '///0/, 4/ef ,,,„71, Si nature: � CommUrIt} . / ` Modified Site Plan - Regal Acres Expansion «4, rOtt I , 4 .. §8.Y2jn -- FY .1kes,: ,,,,Z/1.:. � ading4,: . ky ''}, tt- ',,..:... ..04 , -TSR t;,x , _•�' ".4n,,` ' ,-.7 ;.—"sem. 14 s�.;} 7. ;1:' ':14 4k, ,t;,.:,.....144critics ,t,Ikr447,- JW'f.- ' '_....„..1.kic.,.........„.4. _ _. , ,,,.., _ 4.0„iittkc,:. ..--,,Aett # .,c, 0 c t�- .., ;: 0,‘„,,, ,.. ", .....„.... .. . , _ .... . . ef ft'-—-tr'' 'Z''. t i.j; r' A4 1-:644 1-7".:. ". 4:,r4z7.41.67.: 2446„. I would support the below modifications: Decrease impacts of sight and sound: 8' Tall Concrete Wall - Aesthetically Pleasing (following yellow lines) Hide the wall: Heavy foliage on both sides of wall to make as opaque as possible Make sure plans are spot on: Opportunity to review and submit feedback on proposed wall & foliage ________ _ , .. - Modified Site Plan - Regal Acres Expansion _ - - ..z-1.,-... . . ... • .4i.ecimiggia _ . . _ _ _ _ , . , ..--ac..ci.. .44=. '.......,„,4- 4.6444"0"`- 44a . .-- _., �r . e:,_. -'S;1." — y see nc yw.# ,F - g....l.ir#. —7 -' g ... .F--1.*'1., 1f :r, 4,.k.-41-in. 3-':,----1,,,dingg.;,..--, a" nom. r it,. y 4 l # 5 4 i' 1 •fi t!1,,.".‘ s .w. , P cry....'-. fy ,.c ,4%44.�` "ilii • , ,2i.....12: x x_w.,,,,,(`...:%.}1.,,,,,,, x r►�' ' sem . . ,,., k f � « +i 0:;.-w �.*' h iti�a x , , , .,„ E„,,,,,,,,,„...,, 4, .., . ,.,Note 'IL1114 7 is 470,,,„ , r.,„„,,,,iiss., _ _pr.) , ,.... .tii... „..,,,.;,,, tirr AF.r,„.7 7:14to, . ...,4 I,,,.41,tc ialiag .., „0.0 0.0,714,00110,,, i 7` `'` * �! ¢` ikinolt,,, r,26��_,�a -l.. r, • "vel - eo.,jok, w-,..4 ,i,,,. ,.. .4 11404%tt ' ^..A.,-,2,ff 's....,04, li ...iji,,,' ,Ldit.i4/442.w . 1,-;,,tgl 4 -lift"ilictamil I would support the below modifications.' Decrease impacts of sight and sound: 8' Tall Concrete Wall - Aesthetically Pleasing (following yellow lines) I Hide the wall: Heavy foliage on both sides of wall to make as opaque as possible Make sure plans are spot on: Opportunity to review and submit feedback on proposed wall & f , iage • *-2./......-7 ,/' _ . . Modified Site Plan - Regal Acres Expansion 712:A.'" al -alk4111111p .i' . "`e.,4-4t:47 '� -. 4 ,.." '"'..h e - , t ,: SMI a i'` ". 4 'f j .t ' ii,1 � gip . �, YI'yy • ii, i.. ` x`A 10,,,-,''': -f� Y$,, _ , "P 4- M t , ... ..,,fit► '�R +, I/CP.( ),1 F4?•41P1' ,.,4,,...A4 - .-*j, - fl,1.-„,, z4.tr-thir 40,„ ---ateaki i "e4b.,i;13.4p41:4A*44;47 , ,. ' mitt*Vi6g4 i t r , �3 • � � S,it ;e6 ?r k rF staff. 114 • �}t4. � PP' r e_...1°_ft,4-1:1•* • ' _ li 1( 4 r 3iia''n... .a t ,..: f s f,.u. mien► !moi I would support the below modifications: ---_ Decrease impacts of sight and sound: == 8' Tall Concrete Wall - Aesthetically Pleasing (following yellow lines) Hide the wall: Heavy foliage on both sides of wall to make as opaque as possible Make sure plans are spo •. Opp. unity to review and s ,bm't feedback on proposed wall & foliage Assatimmil Modified Site Plan - Regal Acres Expansion { +t �`'.`. y sir: w i lv - 1.T".°7 I " �'n'iti':r ' Odin „„` 1- ,....:04-k, iJ ,..dophi _ to bai".`".."."-$ 11L,"tiket,INAtgil .414ez. N, iwr.." • v".1Aeket4 -Vit..- — '-+.' 1 414t‘ I .. � r`%J '{ �i' �'� ,,_ -Pi`s , ,„.., , ,n,.. it, , , it. t „ .., ,,,,,,,,„ ‘'.•',I',,.„ 4170,11k.AVA,7,444k., ,._ al Ac r s «...,- 1 n � f fr would support the below modifications- . ns. I Decrease impacts of sigtand sound. I 8' Tall Concrete Wall - Aesthetically Pleasing (following yellow lines) I Hide the wall: Heavy foliage on both sides of wall to make as opaque as possible Make sure plans are spot on: Opportunity to review and submit feedback on proposed wall & foliage d.tm....v.„..‘i a.iku-of ! 1 Modified Site Plan - Regal Acres Expansion ...AAA' ,„ , . /�!* a.... of -.M ,„.I'Ii C.: rkk a7 t I • 4'.. R. ,., .«1 _ ,., 'A.. ', ... p. • 9w. f '-.11".4'0, i*..& ! •,,f ''M. per' } L-E--40. _dee r , c,„,,,,,,, ,,. .,, iii, 4thr, • _ ‘_, -. -f,i: , .. : ' „, ,,,,,, .„,,,,„....„......., ,,44,,,,„,....... ., 64 " = *"4 A, 'NV, .• k::.1 f.1,i,, . 4 r , ` � j +� am ' s 't t " ...1.i .44,7ak:-”""L. ,,,,, . ,, ,.. ,wr•0 ,f Ask. . , ,,,,,,,...,.**431ki'4 At . ' 04,, je *A:N. ..IV,4;', 1 l''W;• - .davr," ' 4,-,At l';'104--.1"-* b y‘ii,4 "II. 41 417.*. ' oe ' --..ertc 4- rb,A me._ 440 of , .. . .... ,„ i� .,1 3. . . . 'h7 � i ' # 1F rJ K ,,,"•t.. !� �, Expo ,,, , ;• olt,.t, J t 3:"- 4 R... 'sts , ,, ' 3• 1�+ a4 �AI 4. Itermaire4 I would support the below modifications: Decrease impacts of sight and sound: 8' Tall Concrete Wall - Aesthetically Pleasing (following yellow lines) }fide the wall: Heavy foliage on both sides of wall to make as opaque as possible Make sure plans are spot on: Opportunity to review and submit feedback on proposed wall & foliage ,,/� Alto ��/7 Z., C-3- . 1‘,417,/,‘"4- / / ,',3 -7-5,11.c.,y.4,402,1_60--3,7;,.. Modified Site Plan - Regal Acres Expansion - ""`'" r?a -----mg y , n'u-+rc a Yjr � i, �„"".,1�'t��SJ1I7 ,.F „.....„..e. , ...„, .. .;„.„46s- _ • .• ji *.ir Ay' 77 S e. ' < '1'tIt{e':j1 4.. sr.. t � 3 v'.!1 if2'°i'!1,. w '- r4 t .. a `'1"'�'.., 1a '''TTTTT''' V .' "� 011,, ` , r,, ;0 i, ,� .,4 ""' {`' a, - , . F, ,s-/1,,,_,- oft.. 4 . 1„ . °r i a .SFr J .�q►.�-r, y,,_, _ '� ,r . ��y�, ''414Wali �►t� ` + }4a., . ,,,kri 4 K`�- 4 ...ittro ..„,,,_.:,,,i..„,,,. 44 .... ` > .i �'1 ay'y� F�'yM,,�. ANCR/•`. {}•�/ Wi. .. may; • ' �# #.+ y'f�R}�I, n.s'', �r",'_A>. t #.I ,a.s6 �, yi', ., ..;.1.‘1 lfr„„1,„, • .4 , ..;� ft,„.01 , r • ,•S, ,t �.Tom.-t:.�?b :. ppy`a, ,..,.}- _ r am.. I would support the below modifications: Decrease impacts of sight and sound; 8' Tall Concrete Wall - Aesthetically Pleasing (following yellow lines) Hide the wall: Heavy foliage on both sides of wall to make as opaque as possible Make sure plans are spot on: Opportunity to review and submit feedback on proposed wall & foliage 1 1Lqs 1ofs .,' ) Q(..) Modified Site Plan - Regal Acres Expansion i"'-"�',"?iac . -vs _ �"." `_' 1- `-ate . —' f...:• ... - T' S ,; 4 ;,L - it., + tt a► X* om• .. 44. y.F� {A'Y < �1, a[ 04yJr a ' 4_7441'1.� 'y a .�,„ . f • l � � 1 ,L, taw it•nor";"."11 lb, ,� Pik ,itafiv i it.- , ,, , tz"..4., Aril, A.I.,.. -C,71,411 tOtliv-"aro):4, 'C'44 l'iv l. ..--C'''4',.. . � ' ' ^41,10P ` ;� e , /4l i 'g rte } I would support the below modifications: Decrease impacts of sight and sound: 8' Tall Concrete Wall - Aesthetically Pleasing (following yellow lines) Hide the wall: Heavy foliage on both sides of wall to make as opaque as possible Make sure plans are spot on: Opportunity to review and submit feedback on proposed wall & foliage 1'+'7 '& 14),AUJ40A2D LAJL . NA OCE S FL 4f-ijii- i -- — —______ _ _ ...___ __________ Modified Site Plan - Regal Acres Expansion . , . __ . - 111b717 ' - - ',-+- At 2., :-....::.. ..,..t,-_,....._4„,tr,Atc.xosizaiga :. f.4ke&.0 '""� .. ,,.f' .4411Pf•. -s a..;. " .,,,,L,•#**" + r..bre• -4 , ' . '"::' •4,Aoso ....i *:,:ic _...,,,.:: :f..,,A.4 -,-;;;„ t--., ,t-',.4.f-• --Pj1;fdingi,;:„:: r. Yfe yy . e .. si,..--0.:-.„_' , • ,aff i+r.. 'wa li--itsti,.- 4c.i.0,-. !_""77" r Aftar///4144‘4444y"%r:,,,,Z,0 _ ' .04-41,--e dr"r-7".ri ,44.-'2.iitL' V.41/..kier,,111,.... 14 41,r-r-- 411tdue., k' * , iiks- - 4 rt . may,, rte'), IR" At '"° .` ;44•,1 yr;f 0, _ r3:,-;.4 s . sr ow ..._,.....a .G � ...4 �,�: i I would support the below modifications: I i Decrease impacts of sight and sound: 8' Tall Concrete Wall - Aesthetically Pleasing (following yellow lines) Hide the wall: Heavy foliage on both sides of wall to make as opaque as possible Make sure plans are spot on; Opportunity to review and submit feedback on proposed wall & foliage 1.?„,,, Jt}7SL 0t� 4 Modified Site Plan - Regal Acres Expansion fi, 4__ C3 r f y }' bean I .... - .„,t;:t.tke.p.',.;'- AN44Lije -- - ' .4r- g,:l PI' A 16.. . s., . :At.'"' .... , .70.414W M ...::: ' "I. .40.1/4, ..,.....: .7-' . ::: . 411‘7:W.' j.•`Kies•. .'".'".4'""*: .*: 1 �'!� '.. 4 ...44.44,4L)4„, � +:'; ' Ir . , 4 ', " .��-mems ' .. •. 4f.I. - .i. 4i.er t,'?:e7t41... , -1,4v4,,,,,-,,#iz An% /44,4,„„„..„ ' - - 44tt4t ir... f•itsztelii 14,,e--714'.AV et/"tkv- ' ,,,,d-t -- it--k15:2:446.-....,16.44%, '''''*---Ek„,z04, e,!� 4, y� 1A T. 1.4564 . d y y '. 44,4 ,, tit .* i d7 l� "KKlku �r 3Il/.R f q ,4Z+ I would support the below modifications: Decrease impacts of sight and sound: 8' Tall Concrete Wall - Aesthetically Pleasing (following yellow lines) Hide the wall: Heavy foliage on both sides of wall to make as opaque as possible Make sure plans are spot on: Opportunity to review and submit feedback on proposed wall & foliage <e}..4.41 /<5.„...:ali ERIbe ems,tt , ,4 s - ,, 1 tbf Modified Site Plan - Regal Acres Expansion rA ti., aaes,- „t - . i r„, . . .sy iiir •. ;1sti,"',j �aR"� ' � W ♦ P tom, yyi,�,- Sr' 1 47441114)414, -—4,,,1 irk,/ 4444,4,40( -kr- tWi.,1-31i,te t ,'4".' -..... kr ..At.-'7141..,..„ qr.., '�° '" +�� y It., +i.s + v ` ,1' PI # :'5y ` `0 ` ell . ., "'Ir.4- 4! ". ' I '4...t I would support the below modifications: Decrease impacts of sight and sound; 8' Tall Concrete Wall - Aesthetically Pleasing (following yellow lines) Hide the wall: Heavy foliage on both sides of wall to make as opaque as possible Make sure plans are spot on; Opportunity to review and submit feedback on proposed wall & foliage ( gc) - idpse,1D-v-, -, „,,, . ( 3,,,D:L6),,„, F.__ efJ--a4Acititc 1 44' r>elftitiA3---:— Modified Site Plan - Regal Acres Expansion C `� <`�vnna:r �► ' .: ,fir a , 44 if„ +�% : ,1„` a fit'•i'r , ?'" rt t :' T 61.0,,irr,„�y4; 1 1 Modified Site Plan - Regal Acres Expansion _ r �,i. ,reap Jo, s.^ Lakes �;, iial!� - -I, „, .t" . . .., , , . , ...*. s,%,..,,,, , ..4....4...??' , , 4-- --77:1:17clingg....7.1 -;,t_.!,,,kr. . ",trt. V,'Id.'s,y. -,,--t , p ":,4,14k X4'1. -, .f " ms vme ...*' 4 „ '' ” ' ,:'r ^ sem"mss : 4,4 f,.. . I ' -444144b "z 444; '- d* t 4-1 Abs' ''''' • 1 44. ,,,.."! * mi. Atei 04741 1%...v.1,...;,01 i!..../ r 1,,, , , 4'4 w irk,? At . W `E '7`x°` yi pw. p� .. " ' 1 -i -,,401.. 4*1^ . ;, 'gal Aa` ' ;'t.'F�3 ,gic -0.Y"t.... � o 411 ave e �' y �' _ " - +r 446,11 f Mrd .116,4a AR fii I would support the below modifications: Decrease impacts of sight and sound: 8' Tall Concrete Wall - Aesthetically Pleasing (following yellow lines) Hide the wall: Heavy foliage on both sides of wall to make as opaque as possible Make sure plans are spot on: • Opportunity to review and submit feedback on proposed wall & foliage Ck ,2Pdt€A✓ i4 , " / ` la-re.,3 ,2,#/.:f2 G 117 E �f d I I Modified Site Plan - Regal Acres Expansion f: �`"_�►" ':rr�� ,tip 4 .. . 00P rs a , :e �,:.-.7 ' te -.w el"-..."" -I gli .-2 r .w..Ift, wd'�i -- „� Ir let S •' A 0 b ( �'4' li• ittal*,1 4`:{1JW'��1 .• 'AIt.4.tv:tr.,i,.. .ix il '1 ' In'' .,, .,41, -... .,.._, . Itratirt ., $ , ' , ,, 4,-:-:-?,-,f-,1• .,.;'',. ...- , `yyyy. .447: ,a4:111;'', -� yy WXi lF53 'x -�1M4`islT 2. I would support the below modifications: Decrease impacts of sigh�and soured: - s. Tall Concrete Wall - Aesthetically Pleasing,`'�Ilowingyellow lines> Hide the wail: Heavy foliage on both sides of wall to make as opaque as possible Make sure plans are spot on: Opportunity to review and submit feedback on proposed wall &foliage . dr,. .16 ____ Aa_p___ e_42-1—___)-‘ i, ._\ (e 5 `P L 41 ( 1 Li x.. I t GoodnerAngela From: Donna M. Messer <dmc@carlryanassoc.com> Sent: Monday, October 22, 2018 4:44 PM To: SolisAndy; McDanielBill;TaylorPenny; FialaDonna; SaundersBurt Subject: October 23, 2018 Agenda Items 9A& 11E Good Afternoon Commissioners, I have been a Collier County resident for 13 years and believe in being an active part of the community. To that end, I've been involved with several projects designed to study housing affordability issues through the Collier Citizens Council as well as Greater Naples Leadership.Through CCC, I worked on a team assisting Kim Grant with research in preparation for the Community Housing Plan. It's my belief those who work in and support our community and are not able to take advantage of living here,should be given increased opportunities to facilitate that effort. I urge you to vote YES on Habitat's project, endorse the rezoning, and advocate for those who support us everyday. Thank you! Donna M. Messer I Carl Ryan Associates LLC 1214.870.1915 GoodnerAngela From: Laura S. DeJohn <LKS@johnsoneng.com> Sent: Monday, October 22, 2018 4:52 PM To: SolisAndy Cc: Nick Kouloheras Subject: FW: PERTINENT INFORMATION > Regal Acres RPUD Rezoning Petition Attachments: Naples Reserve Rezoning Support Flyers.pdf Andy, I'm just following up to make sure this email below and attached flyers of support from the adjacent Naples Reserve residents made it to your inbox. Thanks, Laura Laura DeJohn,AICP Director of Planning&Landscape Architecture JOHNSON ENGINEERING,INC. Direct:(239)280-4331 Cell:(239)229-1726 IdelohnPiohnsoneng.com From: Michael Yancon [mailto:michael.yancon@gmail.com] Sent:Wednesday, October 17, 2018 3:05 PM To: Donna.Fiala@colliercountyfl.gov;Andy.Solis@colliercountyfl.gov; Burt.Saunders@colliercountyfl.gov; Penny.Taylor@colliercountyfl.gov; Bill.McDaniel@colliercountyfl.gov Cc:Tom Custer<tcuster49@gmail.com>; Mara Foley<mfoley@habitatcollier.org> Subject: PERTINENT INFORMATION > Regal Acres RPUD Rezoning Petition Commissioners, Relating to the petition submitted by Habitat for Humanity to expand the Regal Acres RPUD, currently on the BCC Agenda for consideration on 10/23/2018. I am a resident of Naples Reserve who will be directly impacted by future developments if this petition is approved, and wanted to express my support for approval. Since learning about the petition, several residents of Naples Reserve and I have met with Habitat on multiple occasions to discuss reasonable options for improving the buffer zone between NR and the proposed expansion, above and beyond what is required by code. The result of these discussions is an 8ft wall with heavy foliage on both sides to be installed and run along the north and east sides of Habitats property line. Habitat commissioned the creation of sketches and diagrams showing the physical location of the wall and what it would look like, and submitted these to the CCPC during their 8/6/18 meeting to be considered as part of the overall development proposal. Considering above, I personally feel the Habitat team has gone above and beyond to address our concerns relating to the preserve area that will be developed. I have also attached signed flyers from 31 other Naples Reserve residents indicating their support for re- zoning, most of whom own homes that will in some way be immediately impacted by this development. Respectfully submitted, Michael Yancon 269-720-9702 Naples Reserve 14595 Topsail Dr,Naples FL 34114 michael.yanconAgmail.com SolisAndy From: BrownleeMichael Sent: Thursday,June 28, 2018 11:03 AM To: FialaDonna Cc: CohenThaddeus; FrenchJames; BosiMichael; DLCOMM; EbertDiane; StrainMark; Mr. Andrew Ignatius Solis; Mr.Thomas G. Eastman; RomanCharlette; Ms. Karen Joyce Homiak; ChrzanowskiStan;Wafaa F. Assaad Subject: Regal Acres Rezone Application Attachments: 20180628105515872.pdf ONE-WAY COMMUNICATION—Please Do not Reply All Commissioner Fiala asked to forward the attached correspondence received in her office in opposition to the Regal Acres Rezone application (PL20170001733) Regards, Michael Brownlee Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Donna Fiala, District#1 W. Harmon Turner Building- Bldg "F" 3299 Tamiami Trail East,Suite#303 Naples, FL 34112 P: (239)252-8601 F: (239) 252-6578 NOTE:Our County Email Addresses have changed. My new email address is Michael.Brownlee@CollierCountyFL.gov Colt County Subscribe to Commissioner Fiala's Newsletter here. Under FLorida Law, e-maiL addresses are pubLic records. If you do not want your e-maiL address reLeased in response to a pubLic records request, do not send eLectronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. SolisAndy Subject: call with Rich Yovanovich, Russell Square Location: phone call Start: Mon 10/22/2018 8:30 AM End: Mon 10/22/2018 9:00 AM Recurrence: (none) Organizer: SolisAndy SolisAndy Subject: Rich Yovanovich, Dan Ciesielski, Michael Greenberg &Wayne Arnold: Russell Square Location: BCC Conference Room - reserved Start: Fri 10/19/2018 10:00 AM End: Fri 10/19/2018 10:30 AM Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Meeting organizer Organizer: SolisAndy Required Attendees: Andrew I. Solis (ASolis@cohenlaw.com) Good afternoon, We just found out that Transportation Staff have changed their minds and now Russell Square will be on regular agenda on October 23rd Rich is requesting a meeting with the Commissioner. Dan Ciesielski, Michael Greenberg&Wayne Arnold will also be attending. Availability: Wednesday October 17th anytime Thursday October 18th: 9:00, 10:00, 1:30—5:00 Friday October 19th: 9:00—2:00 Monday October 22nd:9:00-12:00 Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla CYK Legal Assistant The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com COLEMAN YOVANOVICH K O E S T E R Visit cvklawfirm.com to learn more about us. st • t 8. t' s. Q4,. d` Trusted & Verified .. ''lase t` Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. SolisAndy From: Richard Yovanovich <ryovanovich@cyklawfirm.com> Sent: Monday, October 22, 2018 8:21 AM To: SolisAndy; OchsLeo Cc: Michael Greenberg Subject: Russell Square Commissioner Solis, Engineer Gary Butler has submitted an email regarding alleged access for his client across the property being purchased by Neal Communities to develop the Russell Square project. Mr. Butler is incorrect in his allegations that there is an easement benefiting his client. We have been working with Heidi Ashton Cisco in the County Attorney's office regarding this matter. We will be prepared to address any alleged title issues regarding this property. My client cannot agree to a continuance of this matter.There are contractual obligations that will not permit my client to continue the BCC hearing. Please feel free to contact us. Rich Yovanovich Sent from my iPhone SolisAndy Subject: Rich Yovanovich, Dan Ciesielski, Michael Greenberg &Wayne Arnold: Russell Square Location: BCC Conference Room - reserved Start: Fri 10/19/2018 10:00 AM End: Fri 10/19/2018 10:30 AM Recurrence: (none) Meeting Status: Meeting organizer Organizer: SolisAndy Required Attendees: Andrew I. Solis (ASolis@cohenlaw.com) Good afternoon, We just found out that Transportation Staff have changed their minds and now Russell Square will be on regular agenda on October 23`d Rich is requesting a meeting with the Commissioner. Dan Ciesielski, Michael Greenberg&Wayne Arnold will also be attending. Availability: Wednesday October 17th anytime Thursday October 18th: 9:00, 10:00, 1:30—5:00 Friday October 19th: 9:00—2:00 Monday October 22nd:9:00-12:00 Thank you. Dianna Quintanilla CYK Legal Assistant The Northern Trust Building 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples, Florida 34103 P: 239.435.35351 F: 239.435.1218 dquintanilla@cyklawfirm.com COLEMAN YOVANOV1CH KOESTER Visit cvklawfirm.com to learn more about us. ysiti+ # i s' Trusted & Verified Both Dianna Quintanilla and Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A.,intend that this message be used exclusively by the addressee(s). This message may contain information that is privileged,confidential,and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. Unauthorized disclosure or use of this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify Dianna Quintanilla immediately at dquintanilla@cvklawfirm.com or call(239)435-3535,and permanently dispose of the original message. SolisAndy From: Richard Yovanovich <ryovanovich@cyklawfirm.com> Sent: Monday, October 22, 2018 8:21 AM To: SolisAndy; OchsLeo Cc: Michael Greenberg Subject: Russell Square Commissioner Solis, Engineer Gary Butler has submitted an email regarding alleged access for his client across the property being purchased by Neal Communities to develop the Russell Square project. Mr. Butler is incorrect in his allegations that there is an easement benefiting his client. We have been working with Heidi Ashton Cisco in the County Attorney's office regarding this matter.We will be prepared to address any alleged title issues regarding this property. My client cannot agree to a continuance of this matter.There are contractual obligations that will not permit my client to continue the BCC hearing. Please feel free to contact us. Rich Yovanovich Sent from my iPhone SolisAndy Subject: call with Rich Yovanovich, Russell Square Location: phone call Start: Mon 10/22/2018 8:30 AM End: Mon 10/22/2018 9:00 AM Recurrence: (none) Organizer: SolisAndy