The URL can be used to link to this page

CLB Agenda 10/17/2018 CoeT County COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD AGENDA OCTOBER 17, 2018 9:00 A.M. COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT CENTER ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS CHAMBERS ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL A DECISION OF THIS BOARD WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS PERTAINING THERETO, AND THEREFORE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THAT TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. I. ROLL CALL: II. ADDITIONS OR DELETIONS: III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA: IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: A. SEPTEMBER 19, 2018 V. PUBLIC COMMENTS: A. VI. DISCUSSION: A. VII. REPORTS: A. YEAR END REPORTS FROM OCTOBER 1, 2017-SEPTEMBER 30, 2018 VIII. NEW BUSINESS: A. ORDERS OF THE BOARD B. RICHARD MCBRIDE-WAIVER OF EXAM BASED UPON EXPERIENCE IX. OLD BUSINESS: A. JEFFREY BUMPUS- NORTHERN BREEZE - EXPIRED PERMITS UPDATE X. PUBLIC HEARINGS: A. CASE: 2018-09-ANDREW WOOD-MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR B. CASE:2018-10-STEPHEN BOWLES- MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFED CONTRACTOR XI. NEXT MEETING DATE: NO MEETING IN NOVEMBER WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 19, 2018 COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT CENTER ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING THIRD FLOOR IN COMMISSIONER'S CHAMBERS 3299 E. TAMIAMI TRAIL NAPLES, FL 34112 September 19,2018 MINUTES OF THE COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD September 19, 2018 Naples, Florida LET IT BE REMEMBERED that the Collier County Contractors' Licensing Board, having conducted business herein, met on this date at 9:00 AM in REGULAR SESSION in Administrative Building "F," 3rd Floor, Collier County Government Complex, Naples, Florida, with the following Members present: Chairman: Michael Boyd Vice Chair: Kyle Lantz Members: Terry Jerulle Richard Joslin Matthew Nolton Excused: Robert Meister Gerard Shannon Patrick White ALSO PRESENT: Everildo Ybaceta— Supervisor, Contractors' Licensing Office Kevin Noe11, Esq. — Assistant Collier County Attorney Jed Schneck, Esq. —Attorney for the Contractors' Licensing Board Reggie Smith — Contractors' Licensing Compliance Officer 1 September 19,2018 Any person who decides to appeal a decision of this Board will need a record of the proceedings and may need to ensure that a verbatim record of said proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which any Appeal is to be made. I. ROLL CALL: Chairman Michael Boyd opened the meeting at 9:01 AM and read the procedures to be followed to appeal a decision of the Board. Roll Call was taken; a quorum was established; five (5) voting members were present. II. AGENDA- ADDITIONS, CHANGES, OR DELETIONS: (None) III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA: Richard Joslin moved to approve the Agenda as presented. Vice Chairman Kyle Lantz offered a Second in support of the motion. Carried unanimously, 5— 0. IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: AUGUST 15,2018 Richard Joslin moved to approve the Minutes of the August 15, 2018 Meeting as submitted. Matthew Nolton offered a Second in support of the motion. Carried unanimously, 5—0. V. PUBLIC COMMENT: (None) VI. DISCUSSION: (None) VII. REPORTS: (None) VIII. NEW BUSINESS: A. Orders of the Board: Terry Jerulle moved to approve authorizing the Chairman to sign the Orders of the Board. Matthew Nolton offered a Second in support of the motion. Carried unanimously, 5— 0. 2 September 19,2018 (Note: The individuals who testified in the following cases under Item VIII, "New Business,"were first sworn in by the Attorney for the Board.) B. James Hinds—Review of Experience (Painting Contractor) (d/b/a"JR Construction Pros, LLC") Chairman Boyd noted the Applicant was appearing before the Board for a review of his experience. He applied for a Painting Contractor's License which requires 24-months of experience in addition to passing the required tests. He stated the Applicant had passed the tests. (Painting Contractor: Score— 88%; Business Procedures: Score— 80%) James Hinds stated: • He had been a Painting Contractor in Pennsylvania for approximately 3-1/2 years, but testing was not required. • He obtained his experience from family members who taught him and working for property management companies. He also worked as a subcontractor for six months—"I picked it up quick." • He later became a G.C. ("Home Improvement Contractor") • He stated it was difficult to verify his experience since "I was my own boss." Chairman Boyd asked the Applicant if he had been licensed while in Pennsylvania. James Hinds stated a copy of his license was included in the information packet that had been provided to the Board. Vice Chairman Lantz: What were your gross sales? James Hinds: About$80,000 a year in Pennsylvania. Vice Chairman Lantz: You had a licensed and you worked full time? James Hinds: Five days a week—whole days, sometimes doing construction, rehabs, stuff like that. Chairman Boyd: You had a license as a"Home Improvement Contractor?" James Hinds: Right ... which covered everything. Chairman Boyd: Which was valid until January of this year. How long did you have the license? James Hinds: I believe it was a total ... to this January, it would be four years. It was about three and one-half that I actually did it. Richard Joslin: I find it interesting, this "Home Improvement Consumer Protection Act." Is this what they used? James Hinds: Yeah, I was able to do electric,plumbing, flips—everything. And I came to Florida and it's, like, restrictions on everything ... and I can't do anything so thought I'd start with paining. Vice Chairman Lantz: Personally, I have no problem with this. Chairman Boyd: If he was licensed in Pennsylvania for three or four years,he should be qualified to be a Painting Contractor. 3 September 19, 2018 Vice Chairman Lantz moved to approve James Hinds' application for a Patnting Contractor's License. Chairman Boyd offered a Second in support of the motion. Carried unanimouslt, 5 - 0. C. Thomas Voss - Reinstatement of License with Re quest to Waive Exams (dlbla "Voss Carpentry, Inc.') Chairman Boyd noted the Applicant had applied for a reinstatement of his Carpentry Contractor's License and had also requested to waive the requirement for testing. Thomas Voss stated he had planned to move to Tennessee but changed his mind because of limited opportunities for work. "I'm a better framer than I am a farmer. I'd like to get my license back." Vice Chairman Lantz: You are licensed in other jurisdictions -- correct? Thomas Voss: Lee County, Sanibel, Port Charlotte, Cape Coral. Vice Chairman Lantz: Have you been - did you have any break in your license in those places? Thomas Voss: I had Fort Myers and Sanibel - I kept those going. Recently, I picked up Cape Coral and Port Charlotte. Richard Joslin: Why didn't you keep Collier going? Thomas Voss: I didn't think I was going to come back down but I have a few builders in Fort Myers who are coming back and building in Collier County. Matthew Nolton: When you came back to Florida, you thought you would work only in lre County? Thomas Voss: Yes, Lee County. Chairman Boyd: My problem with this lack of testing is - I just spent fifteen hours renewing my Continuing Education, and I know you did ... (indicating other Board 4 Vice Chairman Lantz: I'11 bring this up again because this is my standard thing when we come to this topic ... (to Staff) If he never had a Collier County license, what would we be this position right now? Everildo Ybaceta: No. Vice Chairman Lantz: Okay ... so I'11 make a motion ... Terry Jerulle: Can I ask a question? Last week and the week before, had you researched if he had any prior tickets or problems? I don't see anything here whether he has or hasn't. Have you ... Everildo Ybaceta: He has not had any prior ... complaints against him. Terry Jerulle: Any violations? Everildo Ybaceta: No. Terry Jerulle: Thank you. Seprember 19, 2018 members, Richard Joslin and Terry Jerulle) - we do that every two years. Even though it's a pain, I usually learn something. Vice Chairman Lantz: Carpenters don't have to do that. Chairman Boyd: I know they don't. But the last time he took the test was in 2004 (Business Procedures exam - 2O04 - Score: 80%) (Carpentry Trades test - 2005 - Score: 80%) Vice Chairman Lantz: Have you been actively working as a framer? Thomas Voss: Yes. Vice Chairman Lantz: Just not in Collier County? Thomas Voss: Just not in Collier. I used to do a lot for Harborside Custom Homes. Vice Chairman Lantz: And what kind of work do you do ... all new construction ... additions? Thomas Voss: New construction, yeah, no commercial. Chairman Boyd: Are you a one-man operation or do you have people working under you? Thomas Voss: Me and my wife. Terry Jerulle: What kind of carpentry? Thomas Voss: I do trim - that's what I came back to do ... I got out of the framing part Chairman Boyd: You're probably mainly working as a sub under a G.C. - not really looking for... Thomas Voss: I'm not building houses? No. Chairman Boyd: No. Thomas Voss: I just do the trim, windows, and doors. Vice Chairman l-antz moved to approve reinstating Thomas Voss' Carpentry Contractor's License and his request to waive the testing exams. Matthew Nolton offered a Second in support of the motion. Carried unanimously, 5 - 0. D. Marc Jimeson - Review of Experience (Rooftng Contractor) and Credit Review (d/bl a "J.P. Rooftng, LLC') Everildo Ybaceta noted Mr. Jimeson was not present. He stated he spoke with Marc Jimeson on Tuesday, September 186, who indicated he would attend the Hearing. He further stated he gave the address of the Administrative Building and the time of the Hearing to Mr. Jimeson. Consensus: The case was tabled - to be reviewed at the end of the proceeding IX. OLD BUSINESS: A. Jeffrev Bumpus Misconduct of State-Certified Contractor: E xpired Permits Update (dlbla "Northern Breeze Air Conditioning, Inc.) Chairman Boyd asked Everildo Ybaceta for an update. Everildo Ybaceta: We - Assistant County Attomey Kevin Noell, Contractor's Licensing Compliance Officer Reggie Smith, Joshua Lenio, and I - met with Mr. 5 September 19,2018 Bumpus to discuss his lack of progress. We also discussed the timeline and a finite number of days to accomplish clearing the permits. Mr. Bumpus stated he could work with the timeline and the County's expectations. Mr. Ybaceta continued: Since the meeting, Mr. Bumpus has come into the office quite a bit. He has met with Mr. Lenio who will give us an update. Assistant County Attorney Noell: I think it was clear through our conversation that Mr. Bumpus was able to see the bigger picture. Richard Joslin asked when Mr. Bumpus was required to wrap up—he understood that Staff was working with Mr. Bumpus to expedite the processing of the permits but stated something needed to be resolved after over six months because the homeowners still had expired, open permits. He asked Staff if the homeowners had been contacted. Everildo Ybaceta: No, we have not contacted them yet. It is difficult because we would have to find the homeowners and their telephone numbers. It is possible that ownership of a property may have changed several times already. The County does not have correct information but could issue a letter of explanation. Vice Chairman Lantz: Are you saying the County will do that or ...? Everildo Ybaceta: At the Board's discretion, I can but it is difficult to do. Assistant County Attorney Noell: That's one of the issues that the County will look at because I'm sure, as the Board knows, and as difficult as this is to say—it's also the homeowners' responsibility. Obviously, in this situation, we don't want to put that type of onus on the homeowner, who may be less sophisticated than the contractor, to make sure that permit was closed-out and the contractor was doing his/her job. There are a number of expired permits in the system to be addressed. Additional staff is needed to filter through the permits. There has been some movement and Mr. Bumpus was advised of today's hearing. Vice Chairman Lantz asked how many inspections have been called in to date. There was a discussion between the Board members and the Staff: • Concerning how Jeffrey Bumpus could obtain access to the various properties to allow inspections to take place. It was noted he was a property manager for the two communities involved. • When asked if Mr. Bumpus had renewed his license, Everildo Ybaceta stated he had not seen a renewal but would check on the status of Mr. Bumpus' license. • Chairman Boyd noted Mr. Bumpus would need a current license to pull new permits or reactive expired permits. • It was further noted that since Mr. Bumpus is a state-certified contractor, he would normally renew with the State of Florida before he renewed with Collier County. • Assistant County Attorney Noell stated since the goal was compliance and the close-out of the permits, the County would not have taken an action on Mr. Bumpus' license for the sake of the homeowners. • Everildo Ybaceta confirmed that Jeffrey Bumpus did renew his license with the State of Florida. Joshua Lenio and Reggie Smith were sworn in by the Attorney for the Board. 6 • September 19,2018 Joshua Lenio explained there were nine expired permits which the County re-opened. He stated a few modifications were made to allow Mr. Bumpus to schedule inspections without paying additional fees. Inspections had been scheduled by the County, but Mr. Bumpus was not comfortable with the dates and cancelled them. Of the nine permits that were in "Ready for Issuance" status, only two inspections have been completed. Mr. Lenio further explained of the twenty-seven permits which were in "void" status, Mr. Bumpus has re-applied for fourteen. "A majority are issued, some are under review and three are final." Thirteen permits remain to be re-applied for; the total number of permits to be closed out is 22. Chairman Boyd asked how many permits were still in "void" status and the response was thirteen. Matthew Nolton: Prior to your meeting, it appeared that Mr. Bumpus was not actively doing anything to resolve this situation. He asked Staff if their opinion was that Jeffrey Bumpus was trying. Joshua Lenio: Based on what he has done, I would say that he has taken a much bigger step than in previous months. Terry Jerulle: What is the County's recommendation? Everildo Ybaceta: Based on his history and what he has done in the past two weeks, I would suggest giving him an additional thirty days to close them out. Terry Jerulle: Does anyone want to make a bet that we'll still be dealing with this in six months from now? As I said last month, I don't want to "keep beating a dead horse," but I'm kind of done with him. I'd just as soon impose Sanctions and turn him in to the State. But you want to give him another thirty days? Matthew Nolton: We started this off with the County stating they had met with Mr. Bumpus and had given him a timeframe. What was that timeframe? Assistant County Attorney Noell: By today's meeting—all the permits should have been applied for. I also said the inspections would be completed once I learned he was a property manager for the two communities involved. Terry Jerulle: Was he invited to that meeting? Assistant County Attorney Noell: Yes. Matthew Nolton: There is the other part that I don't realize ... we can all think what we want about Mr. Bumpus, but the County was not "clean" in this situation because it allowed this to happen. The problem is these are permits open for owners that need to be corrected at some point in time. Otherwise, the real estate transactions will become a problem. Of the County is working with him and believes he is actually doing something that we talked about—we need to get these permits cleaned-up somehow ... otherwise they will fall back to the owner and become the owner's problem. I recommend that we consider extending it for thirty days—even though we know we probably don't want to—in the hopes that he will clean up as many of these as the County can help him clean up. Richard Joslin: I think the County is working diligently with him to try to get them cleaned up. Everildo Ybaceta: I would, in the recommendation, yes—give him the thirty days. If he does not meet the thirty-day deadline, I will not be required to bring him before the Board because we will take the next step. Let's be done with it. The Board can give him a deadline and state if he doesn't meet it, then his license will go. 7 September 19,2018 Richard Joslin: As of today, we can do that? Everildo Ybaceta: You could have done it before. I'm sorry, I'm still fairly new to this position. Richard Joslin suggested following the County's recommendation and extending the deadline for thirty days but stating if it is not met, the State will be requested to take further action against Mr. Bumpus. Matthew Nolton: What I heard was the County would take the next step and take him to the State without bringing him before this Board again. Everildo Ybaceta: Correct. Richard Joslin: But that wouldn't stop him from pulling permits here. Everildo Ybaceta: It would—if he doesn't meet the deadline, it basically turns off his license. Chairman Boyd: I don't think he wants to pull permits anyway. Everildo Ybaceta: That's true, too. Chairman Boyd: That being said --he could still do "service"because you don't need a permit to do service. Can we restrict him from even working in the County? Everildo Ybaceta: We can't restrict him from doing work that does not require a permit. But at the point where we close his license here, I must refer his case to the State. That's the selling point on this—Mr. Bumpus doesn't want to go before the State. I think Mr. Schneck can give the Board some advice. Jed Schneck,Attorney for the Board: For State-certified contractors, the Board has only two options to use for penalties. One, the Board can deny all permit-pulling privileges in Collier County or place a condition to limit his privileges ... for example, restricting him to just those outstanding permits. The second part is the recommended penalty to the State which could include revocation of his license, levying a fine of a specific dollar amount. If the Board decided to give him another thirty days, I would recommend that he come before the Board then to give him notice again and allow the Board to make the proper Finding of Law on the penalty. This is the second phase of the Administrative Hearing process which started back in March. You found him guilty of the violation. Now we are trying to determine whether the County can gain compliance and, if not, what the penalty should be. Richard Joslin: We would give him deadline and we would then have to act on that motion. If he doesn't do it, there would be no reason for him to come back before us. Vice Chairman Lantz moved to approve restricting Jeffrey Bumpus'permit pulling privileges to the outstanding permits of record, i.e., expired or void, and allowing him an additional thirty days to bring all the permits to final status. At the end of that period, if the permits are not finalized, a recommendation for further action will be made to the State of Florida. Richard Joslin offered a Second in support of the motion. Carried unanimously, 5— 0. Chairman Boyd noted Mr. Jemison was present and the Board would hear the previously tabled case under Item VIII, "New Business." 8 September 19,2018 VIII. NEW BUSINESS: D. Marc Jimeson—Review of Experience (Roofing Contractor) and Credit Review (d/b/a"J.P. Roofing, LLC') [Mr. Jimeson was sworn in by the Attorney for the Board.] Chairman Boyd noted Mr. Jimeson had applied for a Roofing Contractor's License but there were questions concerning his experience and his credit. Marc Jimeson stated: • He has been roofing for the past twenty years in Colorado, Texas, and Oklahoma • The negative credit is on his personal credit report. He stated he was divorced three years ago, and the bills were the responsibility of his former wife to pay. • His partner is the financially responsible party for the company. Terry Jerulle asked Mr. Jimeson if he was trying to license the company or himself. Marc Jimeson: I work with Jose Perez at J.P. Roofing, LLC and I was going to be the license holder. Terry Jerulle: And what is your relationship to that company? Marc Jimeson: I work as the Production Manager. Terry Jerulle: I see. You don't own any shares of that company? Marc Jimeson: No. Richard Joslin: Are you able to sign any checks? Marc Jimeson: No. Vice Chairman Lantz: Is that a requirement? Richard Joslin: I believe it is— 10 percent. Marc Jimeson: We opened in SunBiz ... something in Florida ... it's in this packet ... about ten percent but I'm not on the bank account to sign checks. Vice Chairman Lantz: Doesn't he have to be an authorized check signer? Everildo Ybaceta: No, he does not. Matthew Nolton: I'm confused—now you said ten percent. Does that mean you do have ten percent ownership? Marc Jimeson: I'm not sure how that works but we opened a new business for Florida ... I have all the paperwork to get a license in Florida and something I signed said it was ten percent. Terry Jerulle: So, this is the proof that you claim you know what you signed and what you're doing? Because you're qualifying a roofing company that is going to be taking money in the form of deposits from the citizens of Collier County? And you're 9 September 19,2018 financially responsible for that? It's important to me that you know the answers to these questions—especially in light of your low credit score. Marc Jimeson: Okay. Richard Joslin: To have check writing capacity in a business that you're going to license would be something, I think, would be smart only because of the bills that will be sent to that company and that you will be responsible for ... you can understand that —right? Marc Jimeson: Yes. Richard Joslin: That license will tie into creditors that you will pay for that company and if the person who does sign checks doesn't pay those bills—they will come after you. I would think that would be something that you would want to do. Terry Jerulle: And want to know. Richard Joslin: And want to know if you have shares in the company which, obviously, you don't know. You want to have an interest in this company and its part of the Ordinance which says it is how you can qualify a business. You're not qualifying your own business—you're qualifying someone else's business. We don't even know if you know the man—you may work for him, but money separates a lot of things. Vice Chairman Lantz: How long have you worked for J.P. Roofing? Marc Jimeson: Almost eight years. Vice Chairman Lantz: And do they do work just in Florida ... or ... ? Marc Jimeson: No, in Oklahoma City, Texas, and in Florida. Vice Chairman Lantz: And you set up a separate corporation in Florida? Marc Jimeson: Right. Vice Chairman Lantz: How many employees ...? Marc Jimeson: We have two residential roof crews and two office workers. Vice Chairman Lantz: And that's for everywhere? You guys travel between the states or you have two just in Florida? Marc Jimeson: Oh, we have one that's in Oklahoma City and they will travel when you need them. Richard Joslin: Who licenses the company now? Marc Jimeson: For where? Richard Joslin: For the roofing company you're telling me you want to license. Marc Jimeson: I'm trying to be the license holder—I took the tests ... and I got all the paperwork ... Vice Chairman Lantz: So, right now J.P. Roofing is ... Marc Jimeson: ... that's what I'm trying to get ... is the license here ... that's what I'm here for. Terry Jerulle: Are you working ... the question is which jobs are you doing right now? 10 September 19,2018 Marc Jimeson: Oh, we're working for Advanced Roofing in Fort Myers and Colonial Roofing in Lehigh Acres. We have been here for about six months, but this is just to do some jobs for our own company. Terry Jerulle: So, you're subcontracting for a roofing contractor? Marc Jimeson: Right ... that's what we've been doing while we've been here. Terry Jerulle: So, you're getting paid as a wage or being paid as a subcontractor? Marc Jimeson: Depends on which company that we're working for ... I'm not sure how that part works. Terry Jerulle: Sir, you need to know these answers. It's hard for me ... for me to be comfortable to give you a license, you need to know these answers. Marc Jimeson: Well, based on my roofing ... Terry Jerulle: It's just not a matter of getting a license and letting somebody else be in charge of it ... we'll give you a license,but you have to be in charge and you need to know these answers. You'll be responsible for the qualification of that company. Marc Jimeson: I don't know ... I don't understand the question on who we're subcontracting for ... we report to a couple of different companies ... and how they pay us ... I don't know if it's a subcontractor or ... Terry Jerulle: That's a basic question. I'm not trying to embarrass you, but it's a basic question that you should be able to answer. Marc Jimeson: Okay. A check to JR Roofing is what they gave us—one lump sum. Terry Jerulle: It sounds like you're acting as a subcontractor to a roofing contractor— or a sub-subcontractor in some cases ... it depends if the roofing contractor is working for somebody else. Marc Jimeson: Okay. Vice Chairman Lantz: I've been on this Board for ten-ish years. People don't come to us because they're bad roofers or bad builders or bad painters or whatever. You can be the best damn roofer out there. Typically, people come here because of the business side. Marc Jimeson: I'm new to this part in Florida, I haven't had to do ... Vice Chairman Lantz: Exactly. Marc Jimeson: In Oklahoma and Texas, it's more of the insurance ... Vice Chairman Lantz: The business portion in Florida ... every state is run completely different. There are different business laws. For a roof... for the most part, you do a roof the same way. If you're putting metal on, there's the same screw patterns or close enough ... come on, you can figure it out. You're smart enough to know how to do a lot of roofing ... Marc Jimeson: I took the business test and passed that also. Vice Chairman Lantz: People come to us mostly because they don't understand. You can give me a test on basket weaving and with the time enough to study, I guarantee I'll pass it. But I don't know the first thing about basket weaving. So, yes, you passed the test and that's a big plus but, from talking to us, you seem like you don't understand the laws. Marc Jimeson: I don't understand the question. He has a bank account under J.P. Roofing under Chase and he's 100% owner on that one. We just opened the one for Florida and we haven't used that one yet—and it is ten percent. So, this company 11 September 19,2018 would be J.P. Roofing. Richard Joslin: So, you have a "J.P. Roofing" in the other state that you're from which he handles? Marc Jimeson: Right. Richard Joslin: And he's licensed in that county and licenses that business there? Marc Jimeson: Right. Richard Joslin: And you want to have J.P. Roofing—basically the same company name—here? Marc Jimeson: Right. Richard Joslin: And you want to license it? Marc Jimeson: Yes. I want to be the license holder so we can pull permits and do business here. Terry Jerulle: There are a couple of things: He's working right now in roofing and he doesn't have a license. Richard Joslin: Exactly. That was my point. Terry Jerulle: By your own admittance, you were working as a roofer without a license. Marc Jimeson: We have done ... they guys that work with us also work for other companies under their license. Terry Jerulle: I just asked you specifically if you were a subcontractor or if you were getting paid by the company as an individual, and you said they give J.P. roofing a check. Marc Jimeson: Right, and then they pay ... Terry Jerulle: That is working as a subcontractor without a license. Marc Jimeson: Okay. Matthew Nolton: They're paying your company right no they are paying a company, not paying individuals ... and you're working for a roofing company, but they are paying a roofing company to work for them that is not licensed. Richard Joslin: They may be licensed in Oklahoma, but they are not licensed here. Right? Marc Jimeson: Okay. Richard Joslin: That's the point. Matthew Nolton: What's Kneal Roofing? Because it says in the packet—that's where you worked from 2009 to 2015 ... not J.P. Roofing. Marc Jimeson: Right. Kneal Roofing is where I worked first; that company dissolved but that's where I had the license for construction work in Oklahoma and that's where I got my experience. Matthew Nolton: So, that's where you worked before you came to Florida—Kneal Roofing? Marc Jimeson: I had worked there before. Then I still worked in Oklahoma for J.P. Roofing also. Matthew Nolton: You worked for both companies at that time? 12 September 19,2018 Marc Jimeson: No, I worked for J.P. Roofing and Kneal—it was still in Oklahoma ... and then ... Matthew Nolton: So, after 2015 until now, you worked for J.P. Roofing? Marc Jimeson: Right. Richard Joslin: Who is the license holder for J.P. Roofing in Oklahoma? Marc Jimeson: It's Jose Perez ... it's not ... they don't require a license like this. Richard Joslin: They don't. That's the point that Terry Jerulle just made ... that technically you are working—or have done work here n ow—I'm not sure—because there's been no testimony that says that—but technically, if you do work here, you are working as a subcontractor ... which means you don't have people on payroll who you are writing payroll checks to, or you're not receiving a payroll check from a company ... you are getting one big check and then you pay the people who helped you do the roofs or the work ... correct—that's how you're doing it? Marc Jimeson: Yeah ... Richard Joslin: Which means you are working in this County, at the moment, without a license. You are contracting without a license which is not good. Marc Jimeson: Okay. Richard Joslin: I'm not sure if you know that or not or ... Terry Jerulle: If he took the test, he should know that. Richard Joslin: He should know those answer—correct? Terry Jerulle: I'm looking at Page 28 where it says "Oklahoma Roofing Contractor Registration"—Kneal Roofing and Construction, Keith Neal is registered. So, there is a license requirement in Oklahoma from what this says. Marc Jimeson: Yeah, it's a registration which is proof of liability insurance and Workers' Compensation. Terry Jerulle: I'm going to summarize: I'm not comfortable with the packet that I have and some of your answers. And the fact that you're working for other roofing contractors without a license. Marc Jimeson: Okay, well, that's what I'm trying to do ... is get a license. Terry Jerulle: I understand that. Richard Joslin: Are you doing work here now? Have you done any work here yet? Terry Jerulle: He just said he's working for Advanced Roofing. Richard Joslin: Advanced Roofing has hired you as a subcontractor to do their roofs or some of their roofs or whatever? Marc Jimeson: Right. Richard Joslin: Okay. I would suggest that you ... Marc Jimeson: I stated that I'm helping with permitting and how their roofs because it's a little bit different in this area, but I had some experience doing roofing here. Everildo Ybaceta: Who is the gentleman in the audience? Marc Jimeson: The owner of J.P. Roofing, Jose Perez. [Mr. Perez was sworn in the by attorney for the Board.] Jose Perez: This is how we work ... they call us to do the roof. They got the license. 13 September 19,2018 Let's say you have a roof-- we know how to do the roof. You might be able to get the license easier, but we know how to do the work. Because that's something that we do. We're the workers. Richard Joslin: Okay ... so bottom line, technically, Advanced Roofing that hired you to go and do whatever roofs or whatever you can do, you are an employee of Advanced Roofing ... Jose Perez: They put us on payroll. Everildo Ybaceta: Their payroll? So, you're an employee of Advanced Roofing? Jose Perez: Not an full employee all the time ...just for the work. Chairman Boyd: So, they're writing checks for each individual who you have working under you? (No response.) Matthew Nolton: Does J.P. Roofing have Workers' Comp. insurance? Jose Perez: We do but they don't require it because they use their own ... we are like working for them. We are not working for us ... working for them. You know that I know how to do a roof, so you will save me money. I put you on my payroll and that's how it is working. Matthew Nolton: I understand that but there are two distinct things. One is that you're on their payroll and they write the check to you as an individual or ... [There was off-microphone conversation between Mr. Perez and Mr. Jimeson] Matthew Nolton: ... I'm not talking about Workers' Comp right now ... I'm talking about payroll. Advanced Roofing writes a check to you as an individual or they write a check to J.P. Roofing. Jose Perez: They write checks to my workers, too. Matthew Nolton: For each of your workers? Terry Jerulle: That's not what his [Marc Jimeson] testimony was. Jose Perez: You own your company and you need more workers. You know I know how to do the work and I have more people, so we just put them on your payroll. We're working for you. Matthew Nolton: I understand. Jose Perez: Then we try to get the license. We want to do jobs on our own ... we don't want to be doing jobs for somebody else. Matthew Nolton: I think the Board—we understand what you're doing—is roofers need workers right now and you're providing the work force for them. You're here to try to get a license so you can become a Roofing Contractor and can contract with individuals and pull permits. Jose Perez: That way we don't have to work for somebody else—we do our own roofs. Matthew Nolton: We understand that. We were a little concerned and confused because of some of the statements made it appear that you were working as a company for other roofers versus working as individual labor. Jose Perez: I'm not very good with my English. I asked him to help get the license and that way we can start working. 14 September 19,2018 Richard Joslin: The other item is the credit score. You mentioned in your testimony that you went through a divorce and there were some things on your credit report that tie into the divorce. For the cell phone bill, is there a way to show that it belongs to your ex-wife rather than you, so it can come off your credit report? Marc Jimeson: I didn't know it was on there until I pulled the report. I was told by the Licensing Office that the Board wasn't concerned with that type of negative line item more than judgments and liens that affect the company. Richard Joslin: Can you give us a little insight on what the other items are that are bringing your credit score down so low? Marc Jimeson: I don't have that much credit—just the Chase credit card that was charged off for$700 and the Verizon bill ... those are the two items. Everildo Ybaceta: Since learning of your credit scores, have you contacted these companies to get on a payment plan? Marc Jimeson: I contacted a credit repair service in Oklahoma City and she said she would be working on it—I don't know what's been done yet. I was just told within the last two weeks that it was denied because of the credit—that this application was denied. Matthew Nolton: Can you tell us what you did—what your role was at Kneal Roofmg? Marc Jimeson: I did estimates, inspections, most of the paper work. met with the adjusters for residential inspections, production manager, ordered materials, mostly helped the business owner. Matthew Nolton: He was the one who would write proposals and do the invoices to customers? Marc Jimeson: We both would do some of that. I would write the estimates and the bids. He would pay the vendors for materials and I would do the sales. Matthew Nolton: Did you actually do any roofing work yourself—installations? Marc Jimeson: I have—but not with them ... I've done hot tar roofing, shingle, I'm GiS-certified, HAAG engineering certification is what I have. Everildo Ybaceta: Are you aware of the Florida Building Code requirements for roofs? Marc Jimeson: Yes. Everildo Ybaceta: Were you aware of the affidavits that were needed? Marc Jimeson: Yes. Richard Joslin: The goal of this Board is to try to get people licensed who the Board feels confident that they will be able to do the job correctly for the residents of Collier County. Marc Jimeson: Yes, sir. Richard Joslin: Right now, I'm having a hard time trying to find a way to give you a license with all the negative things you've ... Marc Jimeson: Well, I was kind of confused—what I was told from the licensing persons and what questions you asked. I was prepared to come in here to talk about 15 September 19,2018 those two items and I didn't understand what some of the questions that were asked ... I don't know if it matters but J.P. Roofing as a company ... his credit rating ... Matthew Nolton: Frankly, for me, the credit rating is almost a non-issue. The experience, the conversation that we're having, and your knowledge is more the issue and that was also part of what was brought here. You're just not giving me that understanding or feeling about your experience. Marc Jimeson: I understand about manufacturer's specs and it's supposed to be installed here and he asked me about the Florida pattern ... I've been here since February. Terry Jerulle: You mentioned you have some certifications? Marc Jimeson: Yes. Terry Jerulle: Do you have them with you? Chairman Boyd: He has listed HAAG certified ... Page 19 ... Marc Jimeson: I had some schooling ... for professional management or something ... Terry Jerulle: Personally, what I would like to see is for you to come back with some documentation from Advanced Roofing stating that you were not a sub and that your employees were paid individually, and that you've contacted the creditor agency about repairing your credit ... Marc Jimeson: Okay, I ... Terry Jerulle: ... because right now, I don't see myself as voting in favor of giving you a license. Marc Jimeson: I didn't work with Advanced Roofing ... they worked with J.P. Roofing ... Terry Jerulle: But you have testified that you were a subcontractor and then we have testimony that you were not a subcontractor ... I have two testimonies that are confusing, and I don't know which one to believe. I will believe documentation from Advanced Roofing. Then I would like to see that you've contacted the credit company. Marc Jimeson: You want the confirmation from Advanced Roofing that J.P. Roofing as a company has done work for them? Terry Jerulle: Correct. Matthew Nolton: No, confirmation of how they did work—if they paid them as J.P. Roofing or if they paid them as individuals ... as employees ... is ... Marc Jimeson: Some of the guys that they paid individually and for J.P. Roofing ... Terry Jerulle: I've made my statement ... come back in thirty days with the documentation and that you contacted the credit company ... then I'd probably vote in favor. Right now, I don't see myself... Marc Jimeson: Okay. Richard Joslin: I'm on the same fence ... Matthew Nolton: I'd add one thing to it ... I'd also like to know the ownership ... it's not clear at all where the ownership is ... Chairman Boyd: He's listed as a director on some of the paperwork ... Matthew Nolton: I understand that ... but he couldn't even tell us that he owns ten percent, or he doesn't own ten percent. That's a basic fact that any business person ought to know. 16 September 19,2018 Richard Joslin: Just to let you know, on Page 41 ... under Section 8, there is a check by the statement, "I attest that I own at least ten percent or the corporation or limited liability company ..." I didn't see that on the Articles of Incorporation, but it is checked on that particular page. But it's a notice of election for an exemption, so I'm not really sure what ... Matthew Nolton: It says that ... it's great ... but my point is if I'm in business and if I'm going to be one of the responsible people—I'd know what I own. Vice Chairman Lantz: I want to ask a couple of questions about how you plan on running the business. Marc Jimeson: Yes, sir. Vice Chairman Lantz: So, there are two J.P. Roofings—right? There's one in Oklahoma and there's one in Florida. Two separate companies? Marc Jimeson: No. Well, the one in Florida—it hasn't ... we haven't done anything. Vice Chairman Lantz: The gentleman behind you is shaking his head, "no." Between the two of you—I'm not trying to put you on the spot—but I just want to know the real answer. Marc Jimeson: We haven't done anything in Florida. Matthew Nolton: You said there's a paycheck in your truck to J.P. Roofing from one of those two roofing companies. Marc Jimeson: Right. Matthew Nolton: Is it to J.P. Roofing, LLC in Florida or to J.P. Roofing, the Oklahoma company? Marc Jimeson: Right. Matthew Nolton: To the Oklahoma company? Vice Chairman Lantz: So, the Florida company—you haven't done anything with that ... is that what you're trying to ... Marc Jimeson: Yeah, we just filed that paperwork ... the licensing ... Vice Chairman Lantz: Do you have a bank account? Marc Jimeson: No, not yet. Vice Chairman Lantz: Do you have Workers' Comp insurance or general liability insurance? In the Florida corporation's name, not in the Oklahoma Marc Jimeson: Right. Yes, yes, it is—there's two different ones. Vice Chairman Lantz: So, you have a Workers' Comp policy. Marc Jimeson: Yes. Vice Chairman Lantz: Let me ask you—and I'm not trying to be mean to you but how did you pay that policy? If you don't have a bank account, did you pay with cash? Marc Jimeson: It could have been from the other bank account. I don't have his credit ... I didn't make the payment, so I don't know much about that ... how that was paid. Terry Jerulle: You realize you're the Financial Officer as a Qualifier? Marc Jimeson: Right. Terry Jerulle: You are financially responsible I should say as a Qualifier. These are simple questions that you should know. 17 September 19,2018 Vice Chairman Lantz: What my concern is—you will take a deposit from a company but it gets deposited into the Oklahoma account and then, conveniently, the Florida company has no money to pay its bills. Or maybe the Florida company is just in name only—you have a license but it doesn't actually do any work because the work is being done by the Oklahoma company. There are a lot of issues there with two companies having the same name and the same ownership in two different states. I don't know ... I would think ... what I would like to see is a detailed plan on how this will work because it's too easy to confuse— especially when you don't handle the money—but you're going to be responsible for the money. So, you're going to be on the hook. You know, if the business owes money—it's going to be you who will be on the hook. You can't say, "my partner handles the money ... he's responsible," —that's not the way it works in Florida. In Florida, the guy whose name is on the license card is the guy or girl who is responsible. Marc Jimeson: I understand, but I've worked with Jose for a long time and I'm confident in the financial part of it and being responsible for what he does. Terry Jerulle: And that's fine, but you should know a bit more about it since you will be responsible for it. By us giving you a license, we are telling Collier County citizens that you're responsible for what happens. But you not knowing the answers, it makes us look foolish for giving you that license. Marc Jimeson: I understand that. Terry Jerulle: So, what I'm asking is to find out the answers ... come back with the documentation ... come back after contacting the credit agency to repair your credit ... and have a bank account and have insurance. These are some of the simple basic facts. In thirty days come back more organized and more informed, and then ask us for a license. Chairman Boyd: Was that in the form of a motion? Richard Joslin suggested tabling the case and not voting on it. Matthew Nolton: He would be withdrawing his request ... his application ... is what he would be doing. Richard Joslin noted it was Mr. Jimeson's choice but suggested returning with the information that Mr. Jerulle had discussed as well as an understanding of what he was going to do with the business. He explained to Mr. Jimeson that it was important since his livelihood as a Roofing Contractor could be on the line because with one improperly installed roof, the company could go bankrupt. Marc Jimeson: I understand that part—that I'm responsible for it. But my experience of working for him, I'm okay with that. Matthew Nolton: We understand that but, as a Board, you're not going to get approval right now. You need to go back and get this all thought out and organized, then come back and present it to the Board. Marc Jimeson: Okay. Matthew Nolton: So, do you want to withdraw this? Marc Jimeson: The second option ... to table. Chairman Boyd: We need an option to table. Chairman Boyd called for a motion. 18 September 19,2018 Terry Jerulle moved to approve tabling the application until a future hearing. Chairman Boyd offered a second in support of the motion. Carried unanimously, 5—0. X. PUBLIC HEARING: (None) NEXT MEETING DATE: WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 17,2018 BCC Chambers, 3rd Floor—Administrative Building "F, Government Complex, 3301 E. Tamiami Trail, Naples, FL There being no further business for the good of the County,the meeting was adjourned by order of the Chairman at 11:30 PM. COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD MICHAEL BOYD, Chairman The Minutes were approved by the Chairman or Vice Chairman of the Contractors' Licensing Board on ,2018, "as submitted"[ 1 - OR - "as amended" [ 19 Contractor Licensing Year End Reports October 1 , 2017 - September 30, 2018 Cases Created Cases Closed Year Opened Inspector Number of Cases Year Opened Inspector Number of Cases 2017 Karen Clement 41 2017 Karen Clement 34 Jack Gumph 45 Jack Gumph 42 Jason Bridwell 8 Jason Bridwell 7 Joseph Nourse 64 Joseph Nourse 45 Juan Guzman 33 Juan Guzman 24 Reggie Smith 30 Reggie Smith 45 Everildo Ybaceta 20 Rob Ganguli 3 Total 241 Everildo Ybaceta 16 Total 216 I 2018 Karen Clement 103 Jack Gumph 137 2018 Karen Clement 100 Joseph Nourse 149 Ian Jackson 1 Juan Guzman 160 Jack Gumph 119 Reggie Smith 109 Jason Bridwell 1 Timothy Crotts 92 Joseph Nourse 135 Timothy Meulenberg 77 _ Juan Guzman 112 Everildo Ybaceta 105 Reggie Smith 94 Total 932 Rob Ganguli 4 Total Cases Created 1173 Timothy Crotts 44 Timothy Meulenberg 58 Everildo Ybnaceta 86 1 Total 754 Total Cases Closed 970 Y Licensing Financial Report Number of Fees Collected Transaction 2018 Oct 1098 $106,599 Nov 610 $69,946 Dec 436 $45,860 Jan 335 $39,650 Feb 282 $40,675 Mar 333 $47,925 Apr 270 $31,430 May 261 $38,840 Jun 276 $39,495 Jul 317 $32,360 Aug 1897 $163,580 Sep 2779 $238,955 8860 $895,315 New Contractors Added October 1 , 2017 - September 30, 2018 State Certified Amount Contractor Type 32 A/C CLASS A-CERTIFIED 60 A/C CLASS B-CERTIFIED 24 ALARM CONTR. I-CERTIFIED 4 ALARM CONTR. II-CERTIFIED 13 ALUM. SPECIALTY STRUCTURE CERTIFIED 203 BUILDING CONTR.-CERTIFIED 2 DRYWALL GYPSUM STATE CERTIFIED 139 ELECTRICAL CONTR.-CERTIFIED 28 ELECTRICAL SPECIALTY CERTIFIED 2 ELEVATOR STATE CERTIFIED 5 FIRE EQUIP. DEALER-CERTIFIED CLASS D 2 FIRE EQUIPMENT PERMITTEE-CERTIFIED CLASS IV 16 FIRE MARSHALL CONTR. II-STATE CERTIFIED 6 FIRE MARSHALL CONTR. I-STATE CERTIFIED 1 FIRE MARSHALL CONTR. IV-STATE CERTIFIED 3 FIRE MARSHALL CONTR. V-STATE CERTIFIED 350 GENERAL CONTR.-CERTIFIED 4 GLASS & GLAZING - STATE CERTIFIED 5 IRRIGATION SPECIALTY CONTRACTOR - CERTIFIED 5 LIQUID PETROLEUM GAS - STATE LIC. 17 MECHANICAL CONTR.-CERTIFIED 5 MOBILE HOME INSTALLER-STATE LIC. 53 PLUMBING CONTR.-CERTIFIED 51 RESIDENTIAL CONTR.-CERTIFIED 306 ROOFING CONTR.-CERTIFIED 2 SEPTIC TANK CONTR.-STATE CERTIFIED 1 SHEET METAL - CERTIFIED 12 SOLAR HEATER INSTALL-CERTIFIED 17 SWIMMING POOL COMMERCIAL-CERTIFED 5 SWIMMING POOL MAINT. & REPAIR-CERTIFIED 6 SWIMMING POOL RESIDENTIAL-CERTIFIED 8 UNDERGROUND UTILITY & EXCAVATION STATE CERTIFIED 6 WELL DRILLING-STATE CERTIFIED 1393 Total New Contractors Added October 2017 - September 30, 2018 Specialty/Registered Amount Contractor Type 3 A/C CLASS B-REGISTERED 1 A/C JOURNEYMAN 1 ACOUSTICAL 11 ALUMINUM W/CONCRETE 2 BUILDING CONTR.-REGISTERED 30 CABINET INSTALL CONTR. 6 CARPENTRY CONTR. 5 CONCRETE FORMING AND PLACING 1 DECORATIVE METAL CONTR. 3 DEMOLITION OR WRECKING CONTR. 6 DRYWALL CONTR. 3 ELECTRICAL CONTR.-REGISTERED 3 EPDXY STONE CONTR. 3 EXCAVATION CONTR. 9 FENCE CONTR. 33 FLOOR COVERING CONTR. 19 GENERAL CONTR.-REGISTERED 3 GLASS & GLAZING CONTR. 3 HURRICANE SHUTTER/AWNING CONTRACTOR 3 INSULATION ALL TYPES 20 IRRIGATION SPRINKLER CONTR. 40 LANDSCAPING RESTRICTED CONTR. 1 MARINE SEAWALL & DOCK CONSTRUCTION 4 MASONRY CONTR. 1 NON RECREATIONAL POND WATERFALL FOUNTAIN 48 PAINTING CONTR. 2 PAVING BLOCKS 3 PAVING CONTR. 7 PLASTERING & STUCCO CONTR. 2 PLUMBING CONTR.-REGISTERED 1 REINFORCED STEEL CONTR. 5 RESIDENTIAL CONTR.-REGISTERED 7 ROOF COAT/ROOF PAINT/ROOF CLEAN CONTR. 4 ROOFING CONTR.-REGISTERED 4 SEAL AND STRIPING CONTR. 3 SIGN CONTR. NON-ELECTRICAL 1 STRUCTURAL STEEL CONTR. 13 SWIMMING POOL CLEANING ONLY 1 SWIMMING POOL COMMERCIAL-REGISTERED 2 SWIMMING POOL MAINT. & REPAIR-REGISTERED 2 SWIMMING POOL RESIDENTIAL. - REGISTERED 32 TILE & MARBLE CONTR. 2 TILE MARBLE &TERRAZZO CONTR. 21 TREE REMOVAL&TRIMMING CONTR. 2 WATER CONDITIONING PUMP INSTALLATION 1 WATERPROOFING CONTR. 377 Total Go ev County COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD October 17, 2018 9:00 A.M. RICHARD MCBRIDE - WAIVER OF EXAMS BASED ON EXPERIENCE RICHARD MCBRIDE is coming before the board today looking to be approved for the Sealing and Striping license. He is asking for a waiver of the required Business exam based upon his previous years of experience in the field and education. He has provided his work history in Missouri, as well as his college transcripts. Sealing and striping contractor requires 24 months experience, a passing grade on a business and law test, and means those who are qualified with the experience and skill to seal or stripe driveways, parking lots, sidewalks, and patios. The scope of work shall include asphalt patching incidental to sealing up to 20 square feet per patch in a manner that does not use a mechanical spreader or paver (Ordinance 2006-46, as amended, Section 1 .6.3.38). Table of Contents 1 Letter to go in front of the Board 2 - 6 Application 7 - 9 Personal Credit Report 10 - 12 Company Credit Report 13 - 15 Sunbiz Documents 16 Resolution of Authorization 17 Statement of Ownership 18 - 20 Transcripts from University of Missouri 21 Work History from 1988 - 2014 22 - 24 Verification of Construction Experience 25 - 26 Affidavit of Integrity & Good Character 27 Drivers License 28 - 29 Insurance certificates 30 Board Hearing Letter Collier County Contractor Licensing 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr. Naples, FL 34104 To Whom It May Concern: Attached you will find my application to receive my Collier County Sealing and Striping license. When reviewing my application, you will notice that I do not have a passing exam score on file. Please note that in lieu of the required exam, I am requesting a variance, based on County Ordinance Sec. 22-184. (c), which states: "When an application is referred to the contractors'licensing board, the board shall take testimony from the applicant and shall consider other relevant evidence regarding whether the application meets the requirements of this division. Upon the evidence presented by the applicant and the contractor licensing supervisor, the contractors' licensing board shall determine whether the applicant is qualified or unqualified for the trade in which application has been made. Findings of fact and conclusions of law regarding the approval or denial of the application shall be made by the contractors' licensing board. The board may consider the applicant's relevant recent experience in the specific trade and based upon such experience may waive testing requirements if convinced that the applicant is qualified by experience whereby such competency testing would be superfluous." Under this County ordinance, it is my hope that i can prove to the contractor's licensing board that my competency and many years of experience in the field of sealing/striping should outweigh the need to take the required examination. I understand and accept that by taking this course of action, I will need to meet with the board directly to prove my case. Attached, you should find all of the necessary documents to expedite my application. If you have any questions, please contact my associate Lisa Adams at (239) 777-8321. Regarding the board meeting, I will be happy to accommodate any date/time the board members propose. Thank you for your consideration, Richard Adrian McBride McBride Home Watch Services, LLC dba McBride Pro-Seal o°oto Contractor Licensing Co*-r Gr County OCT Q 9 2018 b�� 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr. Naples, FL 34104 Growth Management Department LOGGED !H SAFE \ Phone-239-252-2431 Fax-239-252-2469 APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY FIRM APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY This application must be typewritten or legibly printed. The application fee must be paid upon approval and is NOT refundable. All checks should be made payable to: Collier County Board of County Commissioners. For further information, consult Collier County Ordinance No. 2006-46, as amended. TYPE OF CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY: ❑ General $230.00 ❑ Electrician $230.00 ❑ Building $230.00 ❑ Plumber $230.00 ❑ Residential $230.00 ❑ Air Conditioner $230.00 ❑ Mechanical $230.00 ❑ Swimming Pool $230.00 ❑ Roofing $230.00 B Specialty $205.00 Specialty Trade: Sealing and Striping I. APPLICANT PERSONAL INFORMATION: Name: Richard Adrian McBride First Middle Initial Last Address: 8840 Savona Ct., Naples, FL 34119 Street City State Zi p Email: AdrianMcBride63@gmail.com Telephone:(239) 641-7325 *SS#(Last 4 digits only): Date of Birth:03/23/1963 Driver's License#(Last 4 digits only): *Pursuant to Chapter 1-19,Florida Statutes and Collier County Contractor Licensing Ordinance 2006-46 Section 2.1.1.,all applicants are required to submit their social security number(SSN)for the following purposes:a)Assess applicant's ability to satisfy creditors by reviewing their credit history. b)Verification of applicant's test scores and information.Our office will only use your SSN noted above for those reasons pursuant to Chapter 1-19, Florida Statutes,and as may otherwise be authorized by law. We are fully committed to safe-guarding and protecting your SSN and once collected,will be maintained as confidential and exempt under Chapter 1-19,Florida Statutes. FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4/12/18 Page 3 of 15 Contractor Licensing ' G o iev County 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr. Naples, FL 34104 Phone Management Department -239-252-2431 Fax-239-252-2469 APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY Provide the names and telephone numbers of two persons who will always know your whereabouts. Name:Regan McBride Name:Andrew McBride Telephone:(.... ---1_,- ) ,1.--3 _ 8 )-- -C Telephone:(636) 448-1500 II. FICTITIOUS NAME OF APPLICANT'S BUSINESS: 1 Business Name: McBride Home Watch Services, LLC dba McBride Pro-Seal (If no company name will be used,write"Individual") Business Address: 8840 Savona Ct., Naples, FL 34119 Street City State Zip Telephone: (239 )641-7325 Federal ID Tax No.: 47-3294004 III. FINANCIAL RESPONSIBILITY YES NO ALL APPLICANTS MUST ANSWER THE QUESTIONS BELOW: lUndertaken construction contracts or work that a third party, such as a bonding or surety company, completed or made financial statements on? VHad claims or lawsuits filed for unpaid or past due accounts by your creditors as a result of construction experience? Undertaken construction contracts or work that resulted in liens, suits, or judgments being filed? Had a lien filed against you by the Internal Revenue Service or Florida Corporate Tax Division? (V Made an assignment of assets in settlement of construction obligations for less than the debts outstanding? Been charged with or convicted of acting as a contractor without a license, or if licensed as a contractor in this or any other state, been "subject to"disciplinary action by a state, county, or municipality? VFiled for or been discharged in bankruptcy within the past 5 years? Been convicted or found guilty of, or entered a plea of nolo contendere to, regardless of adjudication, a crime in any jurisdiction within the past 10 years?* NOTE. If you have answer YES to any of the questions below, you must attach a written explanation including the nature of the charges, dates, and outcomes, sentences of conditions imposed. You must also attach proof of payment, satisfaction of lien or judgement, bankruptcy discharge, or agreements for payment. *If you have had a felony conviction, proof that your civil rights have been restored will be required prior to licensure. FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4/12/18 Page 4 of 15 Contractor Licensing CO ieY County 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr. Naples, FL 34104 • Growth Management Department Phone-239-252-2431 Fax-239-252-2469 APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY IV. EXPERIENCE VERIFICATION EDUCATION: List below and provide transcripts for any formal education you have obtained in the area of competency for which this application is being made: See attached college transcripts. List below non formal education (on the job training) you have obtained in the area of competency for which this application is being made: Please see attached for my employment history. CURRENT/PREVIOUS LICENSE: List below and attach copies any other certificates of competency/licenses you hold/have held in Collier County or any other jurisdiction. Include the license#,Type, and county you hold it in. None AFFIDAVIT Under the penalties of perjury, I declare that I have read the foregoing application and the facts stated in it are true. / d// 2- /1-7/i Applicant please print) Signature of Applicant State of f /24.0(Ar County of Co i1(D t The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this k&S fi 2--C1 a Richard Adrian McBride ,�/Al/ / da by who has produced I" (a(L4ou) 2.sv c.;243 LSC 0 name of person acknowledging(applicant) type of identification or known as identification and did not take an oath. •--"4 .,1 aY PL William J.O'Brien ft\i � State of Florida ��'� 1,7 My Commission Expires 08118/2018 (SI� � E OF NOTARY) " OF e�.°Q� Commission No.FF 152136 NOTARY'S SEAL L FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4/12/18 Page 5 of 15 Contractor Licensing CO ler County - 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr. Naples, FL 34104 Growth Management DeparIf r rent Phone - 239-252-2431 Fax-239-252-2469 APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY CERTIFICATION OF APPLICATION The undersigned hereby makes application for Certificate of Competency under the provisions of Collier County No. 2006-46, as amended, and under penalties of perjury. I declare that I have read the foregoing qualifier information and that the facts stated in it are true. The undersigned hereby certifies that he is legally qualified to act on behalf of the business organization sought to be licensed in all matters connected with its contracting business and that he has full authority to supervise construction undertaken by himself or such business or organization and that he will continue during this registration to be able to so bind said business organization. The qualified license holder understands that in all contracting matters, he/she will be held strictly accountable for any and all activities involving his license. Any willful falsification of any information contained herein is grounds for disqualification. Richard Adrian McBride Applicant(please print) McBride Home Watch Services LLC dba McBride Pro-Seal Name of Company Allle Signature of Applicant State of: (/;:70/ll County of: CSO I((ek The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me thisA. )t-LS .2C( 5 date by Richard Adrian McBride who has produced RU/-(CJi j LUa'-A1 _ name of person acknowledging(applicant) type of identification or known as identification and did not take an oath. I rAk aY Pu, William J.O'Brien / ��!r.� otia e�. W� �J ) State of Florida URE OF NOTARY) Jo My Commission Expires 08118/2018 h l'''4'OF FtOQ Commission No.FF 152136 NOTARY'S SEAL 1 5 FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4/12/18 Page 6 of 15 Contractor Licensing ,:1 -ev County ty 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr. Naples, FL 34104 Growth Management Depai I,i lent Phone - 239-252-2431 Fax-239-252-2469 APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION AFFIDAVIT It is understood and acknowledged by the Collier County Contractors' Licensing Board and myself that if I fail to acquire, or maintain at all times effective Workmen's Compensation Insurance it will result in the possible revocation of my Certificate of Competency. Richard Adrian McBride Applicant(please print) McBride Home Watch Services LLC dba McBride Pro-Seal Name ompany .-- Signa Signa ure of Applicant BEFORE ME this day personally appeared Richard Adrian McBride who affirms and Applicant(please print) says that he has less than one employee and does not require Workmen's Compensation understands that at any time he employees one or more persons he must obtain said Workmen's Compensation Insurance. State of 6(;(t... County of CO [I( Q.;2 The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this 9 zO 1 g date by Richard Adrian McBride ,..,who has produced r(t)0_104 n (- - name of person acknowledging(applicant) type of identification or known as identification and did not take an oath. `�� =,,RY P&oec, William J.O'Brien '�L�j41,� State of Florida (SIG. ATUI OF NOTARY) a=My Commission Expires 08/1812013 ''"'OF F--Q Commission No.FF 152136 NOTARY'S SEAL FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4/12/18 Page 7 of 15 886 110th Ave. N. Suite#6, Naples, FL 34108 x - _ Phone:239.777.1028 tf (it s Fax: 877.275.3593 www.LicensesEtc.com PERSONAL CREDIT REPORT (Compiled From National Records) <FOR> <SUB NAME> <MKT SUB> <INFILE> <DATE> <TIME> (I) P NP7771028 LICENSES ETC 16 NP 2/87 10/05/18 09 :57CT <SUBJECT> <SSN> <BIRTH DATE> MCBRIDE, RICHARD ADRIAN JR. 1928 3/63 <CURRENT ADDRESS> <DATE RPTD> 8840 SAVONA CT. , NAPLES FL. 34119 11/14 <FORMER ADDRESS> 647 94TH AV. , NAPLES FL. 34108 9/14 8023 CRESCENT DR. , SAINT LOUIS MO. 63105 5/12 <CURRENT EMPLOYER AND ADDRESS> <VERF> <RPTD> PICKLEMANS LLC 9/09 9/09 MODEL PROFILE * * * ALERT * * * ***FICO -SCORE& SCORE +:690 : SERIOUS DELINQUENCY;TOO FEW ACCOUNTS CURRENTLY ***PAID AS AGREED;PROPORTION OF BALANCES TO CREDIT LIMITS IS TOO HIGH ON ***BANK REVOLVING OR OTHER REVOLVING ACCOUNTS;LACK OF RECENT INSTALLMENT ***LOAN INFORMATION*** IN ADDITION TO THE FACTORS LISTED ABOVE, THE NUMBER ***OF INQUIRIES ON THE CONSUMER' S CREDIT FILE HAS ADVERSELY AFFECTED THE ***CREDIT SCORE. PUBLIC RECORDS HAVE BEEN SEARCHED AT THE COUNTY,STATE AND FEDERAL LEVELS-NONE FOUND TRADES SUBNAME SUBCODE OPENED HIGHCRED TERMS MAXDELQ PAYPAT 1-12 MOP ACCOUNT# VERFIED CREDLIM PASTDUE AMT-MOP PAYPAT 13-24 ECOA COLLATRL/LOANTYPE CLSD/PD BALANCE REMARKS MO 30/60/90 SANTANDER F 1R18003 9/09 $19.0K 072M389 10/12 2121111121 103 10/12A $0 03 C AUTOMOBILE 10/12C $0 CLOSED 10 3/ 0/ 0 WELLS FARGO B 908N750 4/16 $30.4K MIN180 111111111111 R01 9/18A $28. 0K $0 111111111111 A FLEX SPND CRT CRD $8971 28 0/ 0/ 0 WELLS FARGO B 908N750 3/17 $16.9K MIN106 111111111111 R01 9/18A $15. 0K $0 1EEEEE I FLEX SPND CRT CRD $5296 18 0/ 0/ 0 CB/ZGALLERI H 1NZ8098 10/14 $4322 EEEEEEEEEEEE R01 4/18A $4000 $0 EEEEEEEEEEEY I CHARGE ACCOUNT 4/18C $0 CLSD BY CRDT GRANTOR 41 0/ 0/ 0 DSNB MACYS D 2A5T001 7/11 $782 2/12 EEEEEEEEEEEE R01 Page 1 of 3 3/18A. $100 $0 $75 02 EEEEEEEEEEEE I CHARGE ACCOUNT 6/12C $0 ACCT CLSD BY CONSUMER 80 3/ 0/ 0 CHASE CARD B 26QK001 10/13 $12 .2K 11EEEEEEEEE1 R01 1/18A $11.0K $0 11EEE1111E1E I FLEX SPND CRT CRD 1/18C $0 CLOSED 51 0/ 0/ 0 SYNCB/JCP DC B 235060H 2/06 $0 EEEEEEEEEEEE R01 4/17A $500 $0 EEEEEEEEEEEE I CREDIT CARD 4/09C $0 CLOSED 82 0/ 0/ 0 WELLS FARGO B 908N750 4/16 $21.5K 1111E R01 9/16A $25 . 0K $0 A FLEX SPND CRT CRD $0 5 0/ 0/ 0 CRDT FIRST A 3835003 11/10 $397 1/12 R01 5/16A $1000 $0 $65 02 I CHARGE ACCOUNT 5/16C $0 INACTIVE ACCOUNT 66 2/ 0/ 0 WFDILLARDS D 21GJ610 12/10 $132 EEEEEEEEEEEE R01 2/15A $200 $0 EEEEEEEEEEEE I CHARGE ACCOUNT 7/13C $0 CLSD BY CRDT GRANTOR 50 0/ 0/ 0 CTRLBKBNECTY F 977A001 2/11 $15 .7K 060M301 12/11 111111111111 101 4/13A $0 02 111211111111 I SECURED 4/13C $0 CLOSED 26 1/ 0/ 0 KOHLS/CAPONE D 12EN005 5/10 $866 5/12 EEEEEEEEE321 R01 3/13A $900 $0 $115 03 111111111111 I CHARGE ACCOUNT 5/12C $0 CLSD BY CRDT GRANTOR 34 1/ 1/ 0 CAPITAL ONE B 1DTV208 8/10 $868 2/12 EEEEEEEE1111 R01 3/13A $750 $0 $52 02 211111111111 I CREDIT CARD 6/12C $0 ACCT CLSD BY CONSUMER 30 1/ 0/ 0 CAPITAL ONE B 1DTV001 11/10 $2771 5/12 E14321111111 R01 8/12A $2500 $0 $373 04 11111111E I CREDIT CARD 6/12C $0 ACCT CLSD BY CONSUMER 21 1/ 1/ 1 BMOHARRISBK B 9733006 2/08 $9874 060M189 111111111111 101 2/11A $0 111111111111 C AUTOMOBILE 2/11C $0 ACCT CLSD BY CONSUMER 36 0/ 0/ 0 DISCOVERBANK B 9616003 5/03 $11.2K 111111111111 R01 8/10A $11.1K $0 111111111111 A CREDIT CARD $0 61 0/ 0/ 0 BANRAMERICA B 427S002 7/08 $169K 360M1367 111111111111 M01 6/10A $0 1111111111 C CONV R.E MORTGAGE 6/10C $0 CLOSED 22 0/ 0/ 0 BMOHARRISBK B 9733006 2/08 $18.2K 072M299 111111111111 101 10/09A $0 11111111 C AUTOMOBILE 10/09C $0 ACCT CLSD BY CONSUMER 20 0/ 0/ 0 WFHM B 82TE004 9/95 $135K 360M985 111111111111 MO1 7/09A $0 111111111111 C CONV R.E MORTGAGE 7/09C $0 CLOSED 78 0/ 0/ 0 qb Page 2 of 3 INQUIRIES DATE SUBCODE SUBNAME TYPE AMOUNT 10/05/18 PNP7771028 (FLA) LICENSES ETC 3/14/18 SLA5945535 (CAL) FLORIDA MOTO END OF REPORT Page3of3 886 110th Ave. N.Suite#6,Naples,FL 34108 Phone: 239.777.1028 p -- R,{! Fax: 877.275.3593 www.LicensesEtc.com BUSINESS CREDIT REPORT as of: 10/05/18 11:00 ET McBride Home Watch Services, LLC dba McBride Pro-Seal Fed Tax ID# 47-3294004 Address: 8840 Savona CT Key Personnel: Owner: Adrian McBride Naples, FL 34119-9533 United States SIC Code: 7389-Business Services, Nec Phone: 607-206-1634 7299-Personal Services, Misc, Nec Experian BIN: 996103544 NAICS Code: 561499-All Other Agent: McBride Adrian Adrian Business Support Services Agent 8840 Savona Court 812990-All Other Personal Address: Naples, FL Services Business Type: Corporation Experian File February 2015 Established: Experian Years on File: 3 Years Years in Business: More than 3 Years Total Employees: 1 Sales: $41,000 Page 1 of 2 cJ Filing Data Provided Florida by: Date of Incorporation: 01/26/2015 Public Records PUBLIC RECORDS HAVE BEEN SEARCHED AT THE COUNTY, STATE AND FEDERAL LEVELS. V`Bankruptcies: 0 V Liens: 0 V Judgments Filed: 0 V Collections: 0 END OF REPORT Page 2 of 2 Contractor Licensing CO ler County 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr. Naples, FL 34104 Growth Management Department 239-252-2400 APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY COLLECTION OF SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBERS Date: APRIL 12, 2018 To: Applicants for Certificate of Competency From: Everildo Ybaceta, Contractor Licensing Supervisor Pursuant to Chapter 1-19, Florida Statutes and Collier County Contractor Licensing Ordinance 2006-46 Section 2.1.1.,all applicants are required to submit their social security number(SSN)for the following purposes: a) Assess applicant's ability to satisfy creditors by reviewing their credit history. b) Verification of applicant's test scores and information. Our office will only use your SSN noted above for those reasons pursuant to Chapter 1-19, Florida Statutes, and as may otherwise be authorized by law. We are fully committed to safe-guarding and protecting your SSN and once collected,will be maintained as confidential and exempt under Chapter 1-19, Florida Statutes. \I FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4/12/18 Page 15 of 15 Electronic Articles of Organization FILED 8 00 0AM 0 For January 26, 2015 Florida Limited Liability Company Sec. Of State jshivers Article I The name of the Limited Liability Company is: MCBRIDE HOME WATCH SERVICES, LLC Article II The street address of the principal office of the Limited Liability Company is: 8840 SAVONA COURT NAPLES, FL. 34119 The mailing address of the Limited Liability Company is: 8840 SAVONA COURT NAPLES, FL. 34119 Article III The name and Florida street address of the registered agent is: ADRIAN MCBRIDE 8840 SAVONA COURT NAPLES, FL. 34119 Having been named as registered agent and to accept service of process for the above stated limited liability company at the place designated in this certificate, I hereby accept the appointment as registered agent and agree to act in this capacity. I further agree to comply with the provisions of all statutes relating to the.proper and complete performance of my duties, and I am familiar with and accept the obligations of my position as registered agent. Registered Agent Signature: ADRIAN MCBRIDE Article IV The effective date for this Limited Liability Company shall be: 01/26/2015 Signature of member or an authorized representative Electronic Signature: ADRIAN MCBRIDE I am the member or authorized representative submitting these Articles of Organization and affirm that the facts stated herein are true. I am aware that false information submitted in a document to the Department of State constitutes a third degree felony as provided for in s.817.155, F.S. I understand the requirement to file an annual report between January 1st and May 1st in the calendar year following formation of the LLC and every year thereafter to maintain "active" status. D!V:S!ON OF CORPORATIONS r _ fpfl org f Previous on List Next on List Return to List No Filing History Fictitious Name Detail Fictitious Name MCBRIDE PRO-SEAL Filing Information Registration Number G17000003453 Status ACTIVE Filed Date 01/10/2017 Expiration Date 12/31/2022 • Current Owners 1 County COLLIER Total Pages 1 Events Filed NONE FEI/EIN Number NONE Mailing Address 8840 SAVONA COURT NAPLES, FL 34119 Owner Information MCBRIDE HOME WATCH SERVICES, LLC 8840 SAVONA COURT NAPLES, FL 34119 FEI/EIN Number:47-3294004 Document Number: L15000015000 Document Images 01/10/2017—Fictitious Name Filing View image in.PDF format Previous on List Next on List Return to List No Filing History �\ 2018 FLORIDA LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY ANNUAL REPORT FILED DOCUMENT# L15000015000 Jan 16, 2018 Entity Name: MCBRIDE HOME WATCH SERVICES, LLC Secretary of State CC0163903883 Current Principal Place of Business: 8840 SAVONA COURT NAPLES, FL 34119 Current Mailing Address: 8840 SAVONA COURT NAPLES, FL 34119 FEI Number: 47-3294004 Certificate of Status Desired: Yes Name and Address of Current Registered Agent: MCBRIDE,ADRIAN ADRIAN MCBRIDE 8840 SAVONA COURT NAPLES, FL 34119 US The above named entity submits this statement for the purpose of changing its registered office or registered agent,or both,in the State of Florida. SIGNATURE: ADRIAN MCBRIDE 01/16/2018 Electronic Signature of Registered Agent Date Authorized Person(s) Detail : Title OWNER Name MCBRIDE,ADRIAN Address 8840 SAVONA COURT City-State-Zip: NAPLES FL 34119 I hereby certify that the information indicated on this report or supplemental report is true and accurate and that my electronic signature shall have the same legal effect as if made under oath;that lam a managing member or manager of the limited liability company or the receiver or trustee empowered to execute this report as required by Chapter 605,Florida Statutes;and that my name appears above,or on an attachment with all other like empowered. SIGNATURE:ADRIAN MCBRIDE OWNER 01/16/2018 Electronic Signature of Signing Authorized Person(s)Detail Date Contractor Licensing Colt-- Comity 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr. Naples, FL 34104 Growth Management Department 239-252-2400 APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY RESOLUTION OF AUTHORIZATION Complete this form if multiple people own part of the company the license will be attached to. If there is only 1 owner, then this form is not required for the application. McBride Home Watch Services LLC In accordance with Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as amended, dba McBride Pro-Seal proposes Company Name to engage in contracting as Owners in Collier County where Richard Adrian McBride Officers/Owners/Partners McBride Home Watch Mcesrin proposes to qualify for a Certificate of Competency with company dba McBride Pro-Seal Compa�nY Owners McBride Home Watch Services LLCdb� It is hereby agreed upon that we the undersigned of MrRridP Prn-SPal Officers/Owners/Partners Company resolve and represent to the Collier County Contractor's Licensing Board that the proposed qualifying agent, Richard Adrian McBride , is active in all matters connected with the company named A McBride H�Ime Wa ceh Services LLC dha McRride Pro-Seal .We further resolve and represent that Richard Adrian McBride is legally Company McBride Home Watch Services LLC Applicant Name empowered to act on behalf of dba McBride Pro-Seal in all matters connected with its contracting Company McBride Home Watch Services LLC business and has the authority to supervise construction undertaken by dba McBride Pro-Seal any Officers/Owners/Partners Witness –-"— \S Cv\ Officers/Owners/Partners Witness Officers/Owners/Partners Witness Officers/Owners/Partnerssof the above mentioned company need to sign on the right and a witness to the signature signs on the left. State of (�(p(ZAC4 County of N f((�� The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this C It ck5 r — 9 20( 8 date by Richard Adrian McBride who has produced �(b(�t� �„ 1� Lt C A 3 Q__ name of person acknowledging(Officers/Owners) type of identification or known as identification and did not take an oath. ar rp ' '=-'__ =P ee William J.O'Brien �. :'1 ►� State of FloridayC�� litoir My Commission Expires 08118/2018 lVATU RE OF TARY) t9C:ARY' kton No.FF 152136 \\.9 FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4/12/18 - Page 8 of 15 Contractor Licensing CO 7eY County 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr. Naples, FL 34104 Growth Management Depot U rent 239-252-2400 APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY STATEMENT OF OWNERSHIP This certifies that I Richard Adrian McBride am a member or managing APPLICANTS NAME(please print) member of McBride Home Watch Services LLC dba McBride Pro-Seal (LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY NAME) I own 90 % of the units issued by the Limited Liability Company listed above. Affidavit of Applicant: I certify under penalty of perjury that the information contained is a true and correct statement to the best of my knowledge. Richard Adrian McBride Applicant(please print) McBride Home Watch Services LLC dba McBride Pro-Seal Name of Company Signature of Applicant State of ,lDa--tG County of 6 (((-62 _ The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this ' -7 cgD( a ate( Richard Adrian McBride by who has produced (02t <a(c,-Q. ' name of person acknowledging(applicant) type of identification or known as identification and did not take an oath. are :►�i►(� ogPPY PUe�i William J.O'Brien j t►`;eir- I NPState of Florida (sir OF NOTARY) 95. )*My Commission Expires 08/18/2018 $.0FFt-o" Commission No.FF 152136 NOTARY'S SEAL FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4/12/18 - - Page 9 of 15 University of Missouri - Columbia Date:02/24/2017 Page: 1 of 2 Official Transcript Name: McBride,Richard Adrian Course Number Course Title Grade Hours Remarks Student ID: 081 7151 7 Date of Birth: 03/23/XXXX FALL 1982 Univ of MO-Col Ugrd Non-Degree-N-DG Soc.Sec.Number: E Ad S 535 Perspectives in Educ S 1.0 Math 3 Basic Algebra F 3.0 P E Ed H104 Coaching of Baseball B 2.0 P E Ed H185 Basic Drivers Education B 3.0 PE Ac 1 PE:Beginning Tennis A 1.0 R P Ad 191 Tpc:Leisr Modem Society C 3.0 This transcript has been produced for: GPA Hrs Att Hrs Ern Qual Pt GPA richard adrian mcbride UGRD Term: 12.0 10.0 25.00 2.083 UGRD CUM: 12.0 29.0 25.00 2.083 WINT 1983 Univ of MO-Col Ugrd Recreation&Park Admin-BS Com Dv 190 Individ Part Chg Amr Corn B 3.0 Englsh 1 Composition English D 3.0 Lib Sc 105 Library Skills C 1.0 PE Ac 1 PE:WeightTraining C 1.0 Course Number Course Title Grade Hours Remarks R P Ad 10 Intro to Leisure Studies F 3.0 R P Ad 11 Cr Ornt Rec-Prk Les Sry S 1.0 R P Ad 140 Camp Ldrshp and Mgmt C 3.0 FALL 1981 Univ of Tennessee-Knoxville Biol 1210 General Biology F 2.6 T GPA Hrs Att Hrs Ern Qual Pt GPA Ed Psych 2210 Academic Development C 2.0 T UGRD Term: 14.0 12.0 22.00 1.571 Ed Psych 2299 Developmental Laborat C 0.6 T UGRD CUM: 26.0 41.0 47.00 1.808 English 1011 English Composition NC 0.0 T SUM 1983 Univ of MO-Col Ugrd WINT 1982 Univ of Tennessee-Knoxville Recreation&Park Admin-BS Biol 1210 General Biology F 2.6 T C I T41 Classroom Communication B 3.0 English 1011 English Composition NC 0.0 T Mil Sci 1110 Fund Leadership&Mgt C 2.0 T GPA Hrs Att Hrs Ern Qual Pt GPA Philos 1510 Intr Phil Hum Nat Val F 2.6 T UGRD Term: 3.0 3.0 9.00 3.000 Pub Hea 2040 Sem in Hum Sexuality NC 0.0 T UGRD CUM: 29.0 44.0 56.00 1.931 SPNG 1982 Univ of Tennessee-Knoxville FALL 1983 Univ of MO-Col Ugrd Anthro 2530 Human Cultures D 2.6 T Recreation&Park Admin-BS English 1010 English Composition NC 0.0 T Anthro 153 Intro to Cultural Anthro D 3.0 Mil Sci 2120 Appl Leadership&Mgt D 2.0 T R P Ad 10 Intro to Leisure Studies B 3.0 Phys Ed 2781 Tennis Elementary B 1.3 T R P Ad 111 Intr Pln&Eval Lsr Envr C 3.0 Physics 1420 The Nat of Phys World F 2.6 T Sp Dra 75 Intro to Spch Communictn C 3.0 GPA Hrs Att Hrs Ern Qual Pt GPA JUNE 1982 Univ of Tennessee-Knoxville UGRD Term: 12.0 12.0 24.00 2.000 Sociol 1510 General Sociology B 2.6 T UGRD CUM: 41.0 56.0 80.00 1.951 SUM 1982 Univ of Tennessee-Knoxville WINT 1984 Univ of MO-Col Ugrd Mil Sci 2110 Appl Leadership&Mgt B 2.0 T Recreation&Park Admin-BS Philos 1510 Intr Phil Hum Nat Val F 2.6 T Englsh 60 Exposition English D 3.0 Phys Ed 2764 Softball B 1.3 T P E Ed H106 Coaching of Football A 2.0 Physics 1420 The Nat of Phys World F 2.6 T P E Ed H58 First Aid C 2.0 Pub Heal 3210 First Aid&Emer Care F 2.6 T R P Ad 107 Orgn of Aquatic Programs C 2.0 R P Ad 151 Intro to Leisur Sry Mgmt D 3.0 AUG 1982 Univ of Tennessee-Knoxville GPA Hrs Att Hrs Ern Qual Pt GPA Sociol 1520 Sociol of Social Prob C 2.6 T UGRD Term: 12.0 12.0 22.00 1.833 UGRD CUM: 53.0 68.0 102.00 1.925 /1 -.-10‘"L--- _K-(1/--t6e- r-.0P-r-- \C10 University Registrar University of Missouri - Columbia Date:02/24/2017 Page: 2 of 2 Official Transcript Name: McBride,Richard Adrian Course Number Course Title Grade Hours Remarks Student ID: 081 71 51 7 Date of Birth: 03/23/XXXX SUM 2006 Univ of MO-Col Ugrd Non-Degree-N-DG Soc.Sec. Number: Englsh 1000 Exposition&Argumentatn F 3.0 GPA Hrs Att Hrs Ern Qual Pt GPA UGRD Term: 3.0 0.0 0.00 0.000 UGRD CUM: 95.0 101.0 163.00 1.716 This transcript has been produced for: richard adrian mcbride Course Number Course Title Grade Hours Remarks FALL 1984 Univ of MO-Cal Ugrd Recreation&Park Admin-BS Econom 1 Fundmtl Macroeconomics C 3.0 PE Ac 1 PE:WeightTraining A 1.0 R P Ad 205 Pers Mgnt&Ldshp Lsr Sv C 3.0 R P Ad 226 Intro to Leis&Sp Popin C 3.0 R P Ad 230 Intro Prks&Outdr Rec S C 3.0 GPA Hrs Att Hrs Em Qual Pt GPA UGRD Term: 13.0 13.0 28.00 2.154 UGRD CUM: 66.0 81.0 130.00 1.970 WINT 1985 Univ of MO-Col Ugrd Recreation&Park Admin-BS C I T371 Prod of Instr Media Matr C 3.0 * R P Ad 206 Prgm Dvlpmnt in Leis Sry C 3.0 R P Ad 316 Adminstrtn of Leis Srvcs D 3.0 R P Ad 355 PM&Com Rec Pm&Prc C 3.0 GPA Hrs Att Hrs Ern Qual Pt GPA UGRD Term: 12.0 12.0 21.00 1.750 UGRD CUM: 78.0 93.0 151.00 1.936 FALL 1985 Univ of MO-Col Ugrd Recreation&Park Admin-BS Englsh 185 Introduction to Folklore F 3.0 Hist 11 Themes in Americn Histry D 3.0 R P Ad 91 Intro Descript Statistic B 2.0 R P Ad 151 Intro to Leisur Sry Mgmt D 3.0 Sociol 1 Intro to Sociology F 3.0 GPA Hrs At Hrs Ern Qual Pt GPA UGRD Term: 14.0 8.0 12.00 0.857 UGRD CUM: 92.0 101.0 163.00 1.772 University Registrar \°\ University of Missouri-Columbia credit is expressed in semester hours. In April 2007,the School of Law converted from a 55-100 to a 65-100 • grading scale. Grades are reflected on the 55-100 scale for Winter 2007 Explanation of Remarks and all prior semesters. Grades are reflected on the 65-100 scale for C =Computer and Information Proficient Summer 2007 and all subsequent semesters. All cumulative GPAs were H =General Honors adjusted to the new scale by a one-time adjustment at the conclusion M =A course including a substantial amount of mathematics reasoning of the Winter 2007 semester. R =Repeated course,grade not figured in CUM GPA(eff.Fall 2000) S =Service Learning NOTE:TO RECEIVE GRADUATE CREDIT IN ANY COURSE,THE STUDENT W =A course requiring 5000 words of writing and revision MUST HAVE BEEN ENROLLED IN GRADUATE SCHOOL OR AS A POST =An official change has been made to this record BACCALAUREATE SPECIAL. ALL COURSES TAKEN IN GRADUATE SCHOOL OR AS A POST BACCALAUREATE SPECIAL ARE GRADUATE LEVEL. Explanation of Grading System A =Outstanding Course Numbering System Through Summer 2004 B =Superior 1 to 99 courses primarily for freshmen and sophomores C =Adequate 100 to 199 courses primarily for undergraduates:no CR =Credit graduate credit D =Marginal 200 to 299 courses for undergraduates,appropriate E =Exam professional students,and for graduate F =Unacceptable students except those whose graduate major is in H =Unare cc pt Auditor the department in which the course is offered. Honors Medicine only,beginning Fall 1997 300 to 399 courses for undergraduates,appropriate HN = professional students,and for graduate I =HoIncomplete students without restriction to major. IP =In Progress 400 to 499 primarily for graduate students and LC =Letter of Commendation-Medicine only,beginning Summer 1998 appropriate professional students in special NR =Not Reported PR =Preregistered programs; undergraduates admitted only with S =Satisfactory the approval of the instructor of the course S• =Satisfactory with Honors-Medicine only and the dean of the division in which the T =Non UM system transfer course course is offered. U =Unsatisfactory 500 to 599 law,medicine or veterinary medicine courses W =Withdrew Passing Course Numbering System Effective Fall 2004 WF =Withdrew Failing 0000 to 0999 skill development courses: courses that The grade of D is not awarded to Graduate Students do not count towards degree requirement 1000 to 1999 freshman-level courses Grade Point Values for Grading System 2000 to 2999 sophomore-level courses A =4.00 D =1.00 3000 to 3999 junior/senior level courses(upper division) B =3.00 F =0.00 4000 to 4999 junior/senior level courses(upper division) C =2.00 WF=0.00 5000 to 6999 professional-level courses Plus-Minus Grading Effective Fall 1995 7000 to 7999 beginning graduate courses A plus(+)sign following a letter grade adds an additional 0.33 grade points 8000 to 8999 mid-level graduate courses per credit hour. A minus(-)sign following a letter grade subtracts 0.33 per 9000 to 9999 upper-level graduate courses credit hour. Plus/Minus grade points apply to undergraduate students only. In accordance with the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Plus-Minus Grading Effective Fall 1998 Act of 1974,information from this transcript may not be released A plus(+)sign following a letter grade adds an additional 0.3 grade points to a third party without written consent of the student. per credit hour,however no additional grade points are awarded for an A+. A minus(-)sign following a letter grade subtracts 0.3 per credit hour. IMPORTANT Plus/Minus grade points apply to undergraduate students only. When official paper transcript is photocopied in color or on the darker settings of black and white copiers,the word "copy"will Plus-Minus Grading Effective Fall 2011 appear several times in large letters. A black and white paper Plus/Minus grade points apply to undergraduate and graduate students. transcript is not official. Law Numeric Grading System Effective Summer 2007 Important Note: Since 1987,the University of Missouri-Columbia has only used a numeric grading system. There are no definitive numeric grade to letter grade translations. NOTE:To view the complete guide of transcript information go to http://www.transcripts.missouri.edu. ADDRESS University of Missouri-Columbia Office of the University Registrar 125 Jesse Hall Columbia MO 65211 573-882-4249 Addendum to Section IV: I attended the University of Tennessee from 1981 - 1982 and transferred to the University of Missouri, where I graduated in 1985. Upon graduation, I played in the NFL for two years and have then held the following positions: • 11/1988-07/1992 Corporate Recruiter/Sales & Marketing at Christopher & Long located in St. Louis, Missouri • • 07/1992-01/2003 Recruiter/Career Coach at The McBride Group, LLC located in St. Louis and Columbia, Missouri • 01/2003—03/2012 Career Coach/Recruiter/Founder at Athletes-In-Transition located in St. Louis, Missouri • 03/2012—05/2014— While living in Missouri, I was a Sole Proprietor performing general maintenance, power washing, and sealing/striping work for rental properties Contractor L'cens•ng OLL1ev Comity 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr. Department Naples, FL 34104 Growth Management P 239-252-2400 APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY VERIFICATION OF CONSTRUCTION EXPERIENCE Applicant's Name Richard Adrian McBride Cert'fcate Category Requested Sealing and Striping The applicant's seeking a Colyer County Cert'f tate of Competency'n the trade indicated above.As part of the appi'cat'on for this cerffcate,the applicant must verify his/her experience within this trade.You are being requested to prov'de'nformafon that will aid the applicant'n meeing this requirement. You should verify time of active experience working as an apprentice or a skilled worker(e.g.,as a worker commanding the wage of mechanic or better'n the trade).Tme served solely'n a supervisory or adm'n'strafve role should be described, but may or may hot be considered suffc'ent to demonstrate requ•red trade experience. The person verifying trade experience for the above-named applicant must provide the follow"ng 'nformaVon• Name- Sandra L. Stoner Ttle.Property Manager Business Name Sandra L. Stoner, Sole Proprietor License No.(1 applicable) No License Necessary in MO Bus Hess address 8023 Crescent Dr., St. Louis, MO 63105 Street C'ty State Z'p The applicant was employed by me from 03/2012 to 05/2014 Applicant's rte. Foreman The applicant's scope of work(spec'fc duties)included• From 03/2012 to 05/2014, Adnan McBride took care of sealing and striping the driveways and pavers on all of my residential properties in various locations through the MO area. Add'fonal comments Adrian is a great worked and I would highly recommend him to receive his Sealing&Striping license. NOTE TO LICENSED CONTRACTORS. Falsifying any information provided herein may subject your license to revocation. Under penalty of perury, I declare that the facts stated here are true. Afr n F gnatur-of person prov'd'ng the statement State of f-U County of � ief The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this date by Sandra L. Stoner who has produced name of person acknowledging type of'denffcat•on or known as'dent'fcat'on and did not take an oath. (SIGN TURE OF NOTARY) es'Y Pote, MOLLY CAROLINE EV/SEER NOTARY'S SEAL r; MY COMPASSION#GG 075403 w� I I gEXPIRES;February 212021 �jFOf Ft.0% Bonded ihru Budget Notary Services. FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4/12/18 Page 10 of 15 Contractor Licensing C #1.4 er County 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr. Naples, FL 34104 Growth Management Department 239-252-2400 APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY VERIFICATION OF CONSTRUCTION EXPERIENCE Applicant's Name: Richard Adrian McBride Certificate Category Requested: Sealing and Striping The applicant is seeking a Collier County Certificate of Competency in the trade indicated above.As part of the application for this certificate,the applicant must verify his/her experience within this trade.You are being requested to provide information that will aid the applicant in meeting this requirement. You should verify time of active experience working as an apprentice or a skilled worker(e.g., as a worker commanding the wage of mechanic or better in the trade).Time served solely in a supervisory or administrative role should be described, but may or may not be considered sufficient to demonstrate required trade experience. The person verifying trade experience for the above-named applicant must provide the following information: Name: Jim Maxedon Title: Previous Client Business Name: Not Applicable License No. (if applicable): Not Applicable Business Address:706 East Evergreen, Effingham, IL 62401 Street City State Zip The applicant was employed by me from 06/2012 to 05/2013 Applicant's title: Foreman While Adrian was living in Missouri, I hired him to do the sealing and The applicant's scope of work(specific duties)included: striping work for my driveways and pavers. I was very pleased with the work Adrian did.When the job was finished,our driveway/pavers looked great! I would definitely hire Adrian again in the future.Please let me know if you have further questions. Additional comments: NOTE TO LICENSED CONTRACTORS: Falsifying any information provided herein may subject your license to revocation. Under penalty of perjury, I declare that the facts stated here are true. .44A414 il i. ature of person providing th- statement State of e_r ro/9- County of az__"�� ed before me this acknowledged /'O The foregoing instrument as c g date by Jim Maxedon who has produced / _ name of person acknowledging .pe of identifi -tio or known as identification and did not take an oath. MYRNA TRUJILLO ( G j URE sw'STA' / ��`' �m Notary Public,State of Florida Commission#FF 170148 My comm.expires Oct.20,2018 --,— 40 .6-d-t--,1 .11611, - NOTARY'S SEAL FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4/12/18 Page 11 of 15 Contractor Licensing Go Co 0e* N. Horseshoe Dr. Naples, FL 34104 Growth Management Department 239-252-2400 APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY VERIFICATION OF CONSTRUCTION EXPERIENCE Applicant's Name: Richard Adrian McBride Certificate Category Requested: Sealing and Striping The applicant is seeking a Collier County Certificate of Competency in the trade indicated above.As part of the application for this certificate,the applicant must verify his/her experience within this trade.You are being requested to provide information that will aid the applicant in meeting this requirement. You should verify time of active experience working as an apprentice or a skilled worker(e.g., as a worker commanding the wage of mechanic or better in the trade).Time served solely in a supervisory or administrative role should be described, but may or may not be considered sufficient to demonstrate required trade experience. The person verifying trade experience for the above-named applicant must provide the following information: Name: Marilyn Briscoe Title: Previous Client Business Name: Not Applicable License No. (if applicable): Not Applicable Business Address: 178 Kendall Bluff, Chesterfield, MO 63017 Street City State Zip The applicant was employed by me from 03/2013 to 07/2013 Applicant's title: Foreman The applicant's scope of work(specific duties)included: I was previously a customer for Adrian McBride. He performed sealing and striping work on my driveway in Missouri. I can verify that Adrian did t3 fantastic job and I would be happy to hire Additional comments: him again or recommend him to someone looking for this type of work.Please contact me if you have questions. NOTE TO LICENSED CONTRACTORS:Falsifying any information provided herein may subject your license to revocation. Under penalty of perjury, I declare that the facts stated here are true. 711 -P hL,L G- -4-4_. -� — � ,,I Signature o perspprov(iing the statement State of I n-Y-t(,�1�- County of C l :: / /� /�/ r/ (Q The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this C `A(9/VI�� / ! 2 U l 7) (... date } . Marilyn Briscoe 1—L ` r' - , L__/(L i1Se by who has produced name of person acknowledging ty•e of'.entifica ion or known as identification and did not take an oath. I 9 r / r X40:1,,`/o HEATHER MARIE LEBERT (SIGNATURE OF NOTARY) ,* �tiy *,MY COMMISSION#GG 047120 S.' !MI'.,, EXPIRES:November 14,2020 9jFOF F`0 Bonded Thru Budget Notary Services NOTARY'S SEAL n I\ FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4/12/18 Page 12 of 15 / Contractor Licensing co 7eY County 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr. Naples, FL 34104 Growth Management Department 239-252-2400 APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY AFFIDAVIT OF INTEGRITY AND GOOD CHARACTER STATE OFbVlc '_ COUNTY OF C Sandra L. Stoner , having been first duly sworn, state and affirm: I am a resident of N. County, ID)nck.N__. (State)and have resided here for more than five (5) years. During the last five(5)years I have known Richard Adrian McBride (applicant). I have had the opportunity to observe his or her business and personal dealings and find him or her to b: a pers.. o honesty, integrity and good character. Signature Sandra L. Stoner Printed Name Address:9110 Strada Place Street Naples FL 34108 City State Zip Telephone: (314)614-4484 The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this VteV2"°\ by Sandra L. Stoner who has producedas identification name of person acknowledging type of identification and did not take an oath. ( 1 ,.osParv�e�s MELISSA A.PULED Notary Public-State of Florida 1 _ * , 4NA O NOTARY) * uri 4. ` Commission #FF 194623 1 o�o? My Comm.Expires Feb 15,2019 1 NOTARY'S SEAL FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4/12/18 Page 13 of 15 Contractor Licensing C.O TeY Coi.uity 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr. De ai 6�rent Naples, 25 32100 Growth Management P 239-252-2400 APPLICATION FOR COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPETENCY AFFIDAVIT OF INTEGRITY AND GOOD CHARACTER STATE OFOGz-f } COUNTY OF 6,4.,4_,/&----( Jim Maxedon , having been first duly sworn, state and affirm: I am a resident of 61.,di' County, F/.V r ' d G'" (State)and have resided here for more than five (5) years. During the last five(5)years I have known Richard Adrian McBride (applicant). I have had the opportunity to observe his or her business and personal dealings and find him or her to be a person of honesty, integrity and good character. Signature. Im Maxedon Printed Name Address:8836 Savona Ct. Street Naples FL 34119 City State Zip Telephone: (636) 346-6997 The foregoing instrument as acknowledged before me this g/P 7 //7 l date by Jim Maxedon who has produced .FL-Tb12 Li c as identification name of person acknowledging type of identificati.• or known and did not take an oath. £ xo MYRNATRUJILLO 4 zV �_ .i. •:; ltNotary Public,State of Florida °'" FF 170148 (SI A��RE OF '�) :i ' My comm.expires Oct.20,2018 NOTARY'S SEAL (1 V FIRM APPLICATION Rev 4/12/18 Page 14 of 15 ✓ ,. 4' - rte§ -: +� a - •T • • • a. --,7,•,.'-.?',f, v t' 'r �. rw-- 'v te ��w ca' s t._ 1:;--=%r. 4 r" _ ""a"x '- V1 — '"I'll' ' :7,41:V.� . { i • • 4.7 yi 4Y I } ^- • 4 .-i Y Y. 41'SY• .m.. .1Ee}�Y' •�Sr '6i + F ..."a. .n^ _ -� 0. 4d4- �y �j _ _ .1:-.0tkiW . *moo= COD JIMMY PATRONIS CHIEF FINANICAL OFFICER STATE OF FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCIAL SERVICES DIVISION OF WORKERS' COMPENSATION * *CERTIFICATE OF ELECTION TO BE EXEMPT FROM FLORIDA WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAW** NON-CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY EXEMPTION This certifies that the individual listed below has elected to be exempt from Florida Workers'Compensation law. EFFECTIVE DATE: 11/9/2017 EXPIRATION DATE: 11/9/2019 PERSON: MCBRIDE RICHARD A FEIN: 473294004 BUSINESS NAME AND ADDRESS: MCBRIDE HOME WATCH SERVICES, LLC MCBRIDE PRO-SEAL 8840 SAVONA CT , NAPLES FL 34119 SCOPE OF BUSINESS OR TRADE: Janitorial Services By Contractors-No Window Cleaning Above Ground Level& Drivers IMPORTANT:Pursuant to Chapter 440.05(14),F.S.,an officer of a corporation who elects exemption from this chapter by filing a certificate of election under this section may not recover benefits or compensation under this chapter.Pursuant to Chapter 440.05(12),F.S.,Certificates of election to be exempt_,apply only within the scope of the business or trade listed on the notice of election to be exempt.Pursuant to Chapter 440.05(13),F.S.,Notices of election to be exempt and certificates of election to be exempt shall be subject to revocation if,at any time after the filing of the notice or the issuance of the certificate,the person named on the notice or certificate no longer meets the requirements of this section for issuance of a certificate.The department shall revoke a certificate at any time for failure of the person named on the certificate to meet the requirements of this section. DFS-F2-DWC-252 CERTIFICATE OF ELECTION TO BE EXEMPT REVISED 08-13 QUESTIONS?(850)413-1609 ACc QR ® pATE`M'�DD"Y"' CERTIFICATE OF LIABILITY INSURANCE 12/24/2017 THIS CERTIFICATE IS ISSUED AS A MATTER OF INFORMATION ONLY AND CONFERS NO RIGHTS UPON THE CERTIFICATE HOLDER. THIS CERTIFICATE DOES NOT AFFIRMATIVELY OR NEGATIVELY AMEND, EXTEND OR ALTER THE COVERAGE AFFORDED BY THE POLICIES BELOW. THIS CERTIFICATE OF INSURANCE DOES NOT CONSTITUTE A CONTRACT BETWEEN THE ISSUING INSURER(S), AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE OR PRODUCER,AND THE CERTIFICATE HOLDER. IMPORTANT: If the certificate holder is an ADDITIONAL INSURED,the policy(ies) must be endorsed. If SUBROGATION IS WAIVED, subject to the terms and conditions of the policy,certain policies may require an endorsement A statement on this certificate does not confer rights to the certificate holder in lieu of such endorsement(s). PRODUCER CONTACT NAME: Hiscox Inc. PHONE LAIC.No.Fact): (888) FAX 202-3007 (A/C,No): 320 Madison Avenue 32nd Floor E-MAIL pDCS: contact@hiscox.com New York,NY 10022 INSURER(S)AFFORDING COVERAGE NAIC 3 INSURER A: Hiscox Insurance Company Inc 10200 INSURED INSURER B: MCBRIDE PRO-SEAL INSURER C: 8840 SAVONA CRT NAPLES,FL 34119 INSURER D: INSURER E: INSURER F: COVERAGES CERTIFICATE NUMBER: REVISION NUMBER: THIS IS TO CERTIFY THAT THE POLICIES OF INSURANCE LISTED BELOW HAVE BEEN ISSUED TO THE INSURED NAMED ABOVE FOR THE POLICY PERIOD INDICATED. NOTWITHSTANDING ANY REQUIREMENT, TERM OR CONDITION OF ANY CONTRACT OR OTHER DOCUMENT WITH RESPECT TO WHICH THIS CERTIFICATE MAY BE ISSUED OR MAY PERTAIN, THE INSURANCE AFFORDED BY THE POLICIES DESCRIBED HEREIN IS SUBJECT TO ALL THE TERMS, EXCLUSIONS AND CONDITIONS OF SUCH POLICIES.LIMITS SHOWN MAY HAVE BEEN REDUCED BY PAID CLAIMS. LTR TYPE OF INSURANCE ADDL SUER INSD_WYD POLICY NUMBER (MWDD/Y OUCY EFF POLICY Y(P LIMITS I]/YYYY)_(MMlpD/YYYY) X COMMERCIAL GENERAL LIABILITY EACH OCCURRENCE S 300,000 CLAIMS-MADE X OCCUR DAMAGE TO RENTED PREMISES(Ea occurrence) $ 100,000 MED EXP(Any one person) $ 5,000 A UDC-1906247-CGL-18 02/11/2018 02/11/2019 PERSONAL BADV INJURY s 300,000 GEN'L AGGREGATE LIMIT APPLIES PER GENERAL AGGREGATE $ 300,000 X POLICY PRO- JECT LOC PRODUCTS-COMP/OP AGG $ 300,000 OTHER: AUTOMOBILE LIABILITY COMBINED SINGLE LIMIT $ (Ea accident) _ANY AUTO BODILY INJURY(Per person) S ALL OWNED SCHEDULED AUTOS AUTOS BODILY INJURY(Per accident) S HIRED AUTOS NON-OWNED PROPERTY DAMAGE S _AUTOS (Per accident) $ UMBRELLA LIAR OCCUR EACH OCCURRENCE S EXCESS LIAB CLAIMS-MADE AGGREGATE S DED RETENTIONS S WORKERS COMPENSATION PER AND EMPLOYERS'LIABILITY Y/N STATUTE OTH- ER ANYPROPRIETOR/PARTNER/EXECUTI VE OFFICER/MEMBEREXCLUDED? - N/A E.LEACHACCIDENT S (Mandatory In NH) E.LDISEASE-EAEMPLOYEE 5 K es,RdIPTION esrnbe uOndF O DESCer OPERATIONS below E.L DISEASE-POLICY LIMIT S DESCRIPTION OF OPERATIONS/LOCATIONS I VEHICLES(ACORD 101,Additional Remarks Schedule,may be attached If more space Is required) li CERTIFICATE HOLDER CANCELLATION SHOULD ANY OF THE ABOVE DESCRIBED POLICIES BE CANCELLED BEFORE THE EXPIRATION DATE THEREOF, NOTICE WILL BE DELIVERED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE POLICY PROVISIONS. AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE a n / ©1988-2014 ACORD CORPORATION. All rights reserved. CORD 25(2014/01) The ACORD name and logo are registered marks of ACORD Co��ryCou-�.-Cy Growth Management Department Planning & Regulation Operations Division Licensing Section October 9, 2018 • RICHARD A. MCBRIDE 8840 SAVONA CT. NAPLES, FL 34119 RE: WAIVER OF EXAM BASED ON EXPERIENCE MR. MCBRIDE, You have been added to the agenda for the Contractor Licensing Board meeting on Wednesday, OCTOBER 17, 2018. Please attend and feel free to bring in any documents you would like the board to see. The meeting is held at 9:00am at the W. Harmon Turner Building (Bldg. F, Admin. Bldg.), 3299 Tamiami Trail. E., Naples, FL 34112 in the Commissioner's Meeting Room on the 3rd floor. There is a security checkpoint you will need to go through, so please allow enough time to make it to the meeting. If you have any questions or concerns, please call (239) 252-2431. Sincerely, T i11a Davis Administrative Supervisor Contractor Licensing Collier County Growth Management Department 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 CUSTOMER SIGNATURE ' //9 DA DA ERE EIVED Growth Management Department*Contractor Licensing*2800 North Horseshoe Drive*Naples,Florida 34104'239-252-2400*www.colliergov.net o er County COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD OCTOBER 17, 2018 9:00 A.M. ADMINISTRATIVE COMPLAINT - CASE 2018-04 JEFFREY BUMPUS- MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR JEFFREY BUMPUS is the License holder for his company NORTHERN BREEZE AIR CONDITIONING, INC. The license (CAC054719- A/C CLASS B-CERTIFIED) is currently in Active status. A Contractor Licensing case (CEMIS20170001422) was opened due to multiple building permits going into a VOID status from 2013 & 2014 without being resolved. Mr. Bumpus was originally in front of the board on March 21 , 2018. There was a total of 44 permits that were in an Expired or Void status. At the March meeting, Mr. Bumpus was given 60 days to return to the Board with his permits completed. On May 16, 2018, Mr. Bumpus returned to the Board to check on his progress. The Board granted Mr. Bumpus an additional 60 days to clean up his permits. Since we did not have a July meeting, Mr. Bumpus went before the board August to review his permits. On August 15, 2018, Mr. Bumpus was scheduled to return to the Board. He did not show up citing personal reasons for missing the meeting. The Board voted to continue this case to the September meeting. On September 19, 2018, Mr. Bumpus was scheduled to return to the Board. He was given proper notice, but still did not show up. The Board voted and approved that Mr. Bumpus is restricted to only pulling permits for the outstanding expired and void permits. He is also to return in 30 days to review his progress and hear a recommendation for further action that will be taken with the State of Florida. He is before the Board today to review his progress and hear any recommended actions. Below are the current statuses of all the permits that need to be fixed by Mr. Bumpus: 11 in Void status 5 in Reactivate status 4 in Ready for Issuance status 9 in Issued status 1 in Inspections Commenced status 2 in Inspections Completed status Table of Contents 1 - 10 March 21 , 2018 CLB Minutes 11 - 18 Original Expired/Void Permit List from March meeting 19 - 30 May 16, 2018 CLB Minutes 31 - 34 Emails between Joshua Lenio and Mr. Bumpus 35 Email from Reggie Smith to Mr. Bumpus, CLB Reminder 36 Mr. Bumpus reply email to Reggie Smith 37 - 38 Permits with status as of 8/7/18 39 - 46 August 15, 2018 CLB Minutes 47 - 48 Permits with status as of 9/12/18 49 - 51 September 19, 2018 CLB Minutes 52 - 53 Permits with status as of 10/9/18 54 Email from Reggie Smith to Mr. Bumpus, CLB Reminder March 21,2018 MINUTES OF THE COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD March 21, 2018 Naples, Florida LET IT BE REMEMBERED that the Collier County Contractors' Licensing Board, having conducted business herein, met on this date at 9:00 AM in REGULAR SESSION in Administrative Building"F," 3 Floor, Collier County Government Complex,Naples, Florida, with the following Members present: Chairman: Michael Boyd Vice Chair: Kyle Lantz Members: Terry Jerulle Richard Joslin Matthew Nolton Patrick White Excused: Robert Meister ALSO PRESENT: Everildo Ybaceta— Supervisor, Contractors' Licensing Office Kevin Noel!, Esq. — Assistant Collier County Attorney Jed Schenck, Esq. Attorney for the Contractors' Licensing Board Jonathan Walsh— Collier County Chief Building Official Karen Clements—Contractors' Licensing Compliance Officer Reggie Smith — Contractors' Licensing Compliance Officer March 21.2018 Patrick White: And your recommendation would be? Matthew No1ton: I would say 30-60-90. Thirty days for restitution-he has S7.500 of their money. I don't believe in giving more time to give that back. Patrick White moved to amend his motion to add tinting provisions to the payment of each of the three items as discussed: Restitution, reimbursement of prosecution costs,and fines to thirty days,sixty days, and ninety days, respectively. Terry Jerulle offered a second in support of the amended motion. Chairman Boyd called for a vote on the motion. Motion carried, S- "Yes"/1- "No." Vice Chairman Lantz was opposed. RECESS: 11:24 AM RECONVENED: 11:33 AM Chairman Boyd called the meeting back to order. C. Case#2018-04: The Collier County Board of County Commissioners vs.Jeffrey Bumpus,d/bla "Northern Breeze Air Conditioning,Inc."-Misconduct of a State. Certified Contractor Vice Chairman Kyle Lantz moved to approve opening the Public Hearing in Case #2018-04. Richard Justin offered a Second in support of the motion. Carried unanimously, 6- 0. Chairman Boyd noted that neither Jeffery' Bumpus nor anyone representing Mister Bumpus was present_ Reggie Smith, Contractors' Licensed Compliance Officer, presented the County's Opening Statement: • On January 25, 2017, I received and began an investigation of a complaint of a Building Code violation of fifteen expired and void permits. • The complaint was submitted by Jonathan Walsh. Collier County Chief Chief Building Official. against Jeffrey FL Bnrnpus, dfb/a"Northern Breeze Air Conditioning. Inc.- • Mr. Bumpus is a State-certified Air Conditioning Contractor, License -gCAC054719 and holder of a Collier County Certificate of Competency. License#16194. • On February 15,2018, Mr. Bumpus was served a Notice of Hearing for this Hearing via USPS certified mail delivery for the violation of Collier County Ordinance#2006-46, as amended, Section 4.2. • The County will show that Jeffrey Rumpus has allowed numerous permits to expire and become void for a total of 44 expired permits. 37 March 21.2018 • Furthermore, Mr. Bumpus has received three Notices of Non-Compliance in the pasts for performing air-conditioning work without first obtaining a permit • On March 16, 2018. Mr. Bumpus received a copy of the same information packet which the Board received via USPS certified mail delivery. Richard Joslin asked if the Respondent had contacted Mr. Smith concerning attending the Hearing. • Reggie Smith replied Mr. Bumpus indicated he would attend the Hearing. • During my investigation, I noticed Mr. Bumpus had stopped pulling permits in 2016. • Air-conditioning work typically requires a permit • On March 19, 2018. 1 drove to the Falling Waters community(off Davis Blvd.)to see if he was there doing air-conditioning work. • I found Mr. Bumpus standing before a condominium speaking with an individual. • When I arrived in my truck.he saw me and approached my window. • I asked him if he had received Notices and the information packet and he stated that he had. • I asked him if he was in the neighborhood that day to perform any air- conditioning work and his response was. "no." He stated he was more of a handy-man and a home watch person. He said he no longer performed air- conditioning work. • When I asked if he would attend today's Hearing, he stated he didn't know if he could make it because he would be in Fort Myers in the morning. He did request the case to be presented in the latter partofthe Hearing. • I advised him to contact the Contractors' Licensing Office to speak with Lilla Davis concerning the scheduling of his case. He was given her phone number. • Ms. Davis confirmed that Mr.Bumpus had contacted her to request that his case be scheduled during the latter part of today's Hearing. • Mr. Davis signed for the certified mailings and I have the green cards for each. Richard Joslin: The issue before the Board is that this air-conditioning company has outstanding permits that have not been finalized. Is that correct? Reggie Smith: Correct. Richard Joslin: The equipment has been installed but not finalized? Reggie Smith: Correct. Vice Chairman Lantz: What is the difference between an expired permit and a void permit? Regie Smith: Collier County switched its software package from"CD Plus" to "CityView." Approximately four years ago, the records from the old system were transferred to the new system. The software placed the expired permits, some were 38 March 21.20 13 several years old, into a"void" status. If a permit is "void," an extension cannot be obtained under`CityView." A contractor must apply for a new permit Vice Chairman Lantz: If a permit is in the void status, it would have been issued more than four years ago,theoretically? Reggie Smith: Typically,yes. Vice Chairman Lantz: So.they would have to apply for a new permit and meet the new Building Code requirement versus the Code in existence at the time the work was done? Reggie Smith: I would think so. Richard Joslin pointed out an individual was standing at the podium. Chairman Boyd: Are you Mr. Bumpus? Let the record show that Jeffrey H. Bumpus is in attendance. Mr. Bumpus was sworn in by the Board's attorney. Attorney Schenck explained the proceeding to the Respondent, Jeffrey H. Bumpus: • Today's proceeding is an Administrative Hearing seeking disciplinary sanctions against you as a licensed contractor. • The County has the burden to prove the alleged violations as set for in the Administrative Complaint. • You may testify on your behalf and offer documented evidence into the record.as well as question or cross-examine any of the County's witnesses. • The formal Rules of Evidence will not apply to these proceedings, but fundamental fairness and due process shall be observed and will govern these proceedings. • At the conclusion of the Hearing, the Board will make a Finding of Fact based • on the record and Conclusions of Law and they may impose disciplinary sanctions, if warranted, against you and your license. Patrick White: Mr. Chairman, 1 think it's also fair to say that we've concluded the Opening Statement by the County. We're now talking about void versus expired. Procedurally,would you want to have Mr. Walsh offer his clarification as part of the Opening Statement? Reggie Smith: It would be nice. It was noted Jonathan Walsh,Chief Building Official, had been sworn in previously and was still under oath. Jonathan Walsh: For the record, Jon Walsh, Chief Building Official for Collier County. The question is the difference between null and void and expired. The Code states all three. I offer two different types of status: an"expired"' status which then triaaers a Notice letter to be issued. If you have an expired permit, it will appear in a report which is run monthly. We send a letter stating the permit has expired and you have 30 days to address it or it will go into a"void- status. If there are any pending 39 March 21,2018 fees on the permit and they are not paid,your license will be place on"hold." It is basically a warning. If nothing happens during the 30-days,the status of the permit is changed to"void." There are some extenuating circumstances and I will reinstate a "void"status permit to"expired"to allow the contractor to apply for an extension. It is not done often. For the most part, if a permit enters "void,"the contractor must re- apply for it as a built-in penalty for not addressing the original Notice. The Board's question on whether the work that was done needs to meet the current Code will depend on the status of the permit. If a contractor re-applies for a permit, any work that has not yet been done on a project has to meet the current Code. In some instances,such as energy compliance, it is more restrictive. It is to a conuactor's benefit to extend the permit rather than to re-apply for it. The void permits were not transferred from CD Pius to City View. We only take on the ones that must be addressed. Typically, they are addressed through a real estate transaction when it appears on a property search. Usually the ones that are transferred into City View to be closed out have a penalty fee to be collected. The old progtain is no longer tied to a cashier—it is put into City View to collect that money, or to reinstate the permit and then to perform the necessary inspections. If all we are missing is some paperwork, the old permits are typically closed out in CP Plus. Vice Chairman Lantz: I want to know about air-conditioning inspections. Jonathan Walsh: There is typically only one inspection. Vice Chairman Lantz: So that final inspection—I will assume that out of fifteen probably fourteen were never called in for an inspection. If they never got called in for an inspection,then the homeowner would have to re-apply and now meet the new Energy Code. Jonathan Walsh: Yes, if it comes down to an owner,it would have to be the contractor. Vice Chairman Lantz: Theoretically,the air-conditioner that some homeowner has paid for to install might not meet today's Code and they may—if the contractor is a dead beat—pay to have a new unit installed. Is there an option...? Jonathan Walsh: What would happen is if the permit expired, the contractor would be informed via an Expired Permit Notice. The Notice would state whether there were any pending fees and if there was an open inspection. Usually it is one or the other, If it is not addressed within 30 days,the permit status would change to"void." If the permit goes into void status,the contractor would re-apply for the permit utilizing the old Code if the work was done. A permit could have been issued and the contractor had not yet done the work but planned to do it,then the permit would be re-issued under the current Code. Vice Chairman Lantz: Even though it hasn't been inspected, people have common sense and say I have a 2012 air conditioner... Jonathan Walsh: It's typically noted by a date stamp on the unit when it was manufactured and that would be the Code that we would utilize. Chairman Boyd: Mr. Bumpus,you are here due to a Complaint that you have 31 void permits and 13 expired permits that need to be resolved. You have taken no action. Do you want to make a statement? 40 March 21,2018 The Respondent stated: • I do have thirteen that expired.. They weren't called in for an inspection. * The voided—I didn't really look at them. • I know a couple I didn't pick up because they failed the Fire Inspection at the review process. I know there are three or four of those. • What the other ones are. I am not really sure. • I'm willing to have them re-inspected— I've done it before. * I've done it for other companies when they go to sell at real estate time. I've gone in and extended the permits and gotten them through inspection. * Like I say. normally when I pull a permit I give it to the customer. They are home all day and can call it in—and I get a call the day before. • Yeah, I never follow up on final inspections. Vice Chairman Lantz: Why? Respondent: Because I'm there for two hours doing the change out. I never follow up getting the inspection. Vice Chairman Lantz: But you're responsible ... Respondent: It is my responsibility ... I should check the next day and make sure it is inspected. Richard Joslin: Don't you go back to see if the unit is working properly and the customer is advised on how it works? Respondent: I did all the work myself—me and my son would do it. He left me a couple of years ago,so I am pretty much not doing ale anymore. I do repair work. I do home watch and I do handy work. Richard Joslin: Repair work—meaning on air-conditioning units? Respondent: On air-conditioning units, so that's yes. Richard Joslin: But you still need a license to do that. Respondent: Yes. Correct. Vice Chairman Lantz: You don't even call in for final inspections? You just leave the paperwork for the homeowner? Respondent: Correct Vice Chairman Lantz: On the day you enter their home, you're responsible. Respondent: Basically, you have to be home. If nobody is home, they are not going to get an inspection. I'd go back the next day and sit and wait. They have a process now where I can request a text message thirty minutes prior to inspection—the system is better now. It's just—I blew it off... it's my fault. Richard Joslin: What's your plan for the future? Respondent: Right now. I talked to Mr. Smith yesterday and I'm trying to get my Workers' Comp re-instated and once the insurance has been reinstated, I can go down and get the permits issued. I'm with Staff Leasing but I found out the Workers' Comp was cancelled in November. I talked to them and they are re-instating it. Hopefully in a few days, I will have the Workers' Comp. March 21.2018 Chairman Boyd: If you are workinc. on your own and you don't have any employees, you don't.need Workers' Comp. Respondent: The way my license is, it was done as a d/b/a and I can't be exempt unless I'm a corporation. At the time,my son was with me,so I had to carry insurance. I could only get Staff Leasing to write me— I couldn't get an insurance company to write me.. It was all done through Staff Leasing. I didn't do anything wrong to get it cancelled. they just didn't renew it and nobody at Staff Leasing picked it up. I got my audit the other day and it said it ended in November. Patrick White: Do you have an estimate of about how long it will take to clear out the backlog of these void and expired permits? Respondent: No more than a month I would think. I's.e got to get it done now because most of my customers are seasonal and I have to get the inspections before they go back. Like I said. I should have insurance by the end of the week at the latest. I've got to call her back today and get the certificate sent out today. Patrick White asked Staff: What is the status of his license now? Respondent: According to the letter. I have eight permits that are voided that I have to take rare of before I can pull anything. Patrick White asked Staff: Were there any fees owed? If fees are owed, from what Mr. Walsh just stated. I believe your license would be in a'hold* status. Respondent: That's what it says—I have eight outstanding fees or something ... there was a note on there when I read it. Vice Chairman Lantz: He's still active as a State contractor, so he's still active. I mean,he's an active State Contractor—he just can't pull permits in Collier County. Your license is still Respondent: Yeah, I'm still "active'... Vice Chairman Lantz: You're still a licensed contractor. Respondent: Correct. I can't pull any peewits without active insurance anyway. Nobody would issue any permits. But if you're not registered. if they don't have my certificate of insurance, they consider me to be inactive until I physically go in there and show them a copy. Patrick White: In my mind there are maybe a couple of ways we can handle this. We can continue to go through the process. I believe you're making an admission that you're in violation. Respondent: Oh. yeah—there's no doubt I'm in violation. It's me. Patrick White: And not to burden the process anymore than we need to, it's up to the County if they want to continue this case for thirty days. I understand you have everybody here and you want to get a finding of violation but if he's willing it's up to you... Richard Joslin: How old are these permits? Reggie Smith: Some of them date back to 2012 and 2013—and as recent as when he stopped pulling permits in 2016. 42 March 21.201 S Richard Joslin: The units that are in at this moment are working and the people in Collier County aren't sweating,right? Ten-v Jerulle: That's irrelevant. Patrick White: The only other way it will work is if we impose a time period and make a finding of violation,then move into a suspension of his license but I don't know if that's the wise thing to do or not. I don't think he can get the permit work done with that. Regardless.what I suggestis we could hang up to a$10,000 fine over his head—if the violations aren't abated within a specified period of time.then the fine would be imposed. Chairman Boyd: He's State-certified. Matthew Nolton: If he's State-certified, we can't do that. Patrick White: Okay. We're down to the permits. Matthew Nolton: It looks to me as if the County has been trying to clear this since 2016 ... I'm not sure what we cast do. Patrick White: There is another mechanism that I'm aware of which is that we would withhold notification to the CILB. The permits certainly need to be abated and we would not revoke his license because we can't. Terry Jerulle: There's a couple of things here. It makes it sound as if all he has to do is call in for the inspections. But he has to pass the inspections. And we don't know what the status is of those units. They may not meet Code. That may be the reason why he didn't call them in, in the first place. Reggie Smith: On the voided permits,a new application is needed. Matthew Notion: He has to re-apply and ea through that whole process. I'm assuming there are a lot of fees associated with that. Patrick White: Well, it's a whole lot less than ten grand, I'm guessing. Vice Chairman Lantz: Assuming that it's 5100 per permit and we're at 44 permits, we're talking about 54.400 as a baseline. Can you do that? I mean, realistically,do you have the money to do that? Respondent: (Nodded his head affirmatively) Terry Jerulle: Let me ask the uncomfortable question: You say you can go that:but they [the County) have been trying to get you to do that and you said you were going to do it previously. Why should we believe you? Respondent: They handed me a packet of 13 permits to do. I got mad because it was S125 to send a letter to have them extended. The permit was$112. So, I basically didn't do it. Terry Jerulle: So, convince me that you're going to do it now. Respondent: I mean I don't have a choice. See— I'd lose my license and get a S 10,000 fine and the State would take ray license away. I need to get it done. I'm not hiding anything. I don't have any problems with the units. Granted it may fail if one locking cap is missing or something like that, but the units are all brand-new units— high efficiency units ... Patrick White: What is the warranty on those? Respondent: If they're registered. they get ten years on parts and one year on labor. There was one a lady turned me in for that I bad put in five years prior to the day she turned me in,and I still got that one through. I had one lady in this subdivision who 43CIO March 21.2018 hated me. She would call the County. Within tea minutes of me showing up. the lady was out there after fifteen minutes making the phone call. Patrick White: Looking up your verification is a beautiful thing. Respondent: Well. I've been doing this since I was nineteen ... I'm fifty-five now so, basically, I've run my company, I've had hand-on everything. I was in new construction .. condominiums .., and when the construction died, I got rid of my employees and it was me and my son. We basically never pulled permits ... up until then. New construction was all permitted.change-outs were not permitted we were told. We stopped pulling permits and I got caught the first time. I paid the fine—it was two times the permit amount. I've been violated twice when I was wrong. One time I was running a new charge line—it was$700. I figured I didn't need to pull a permit—well, she turned me in after I was done. It cost me$300 or so for the permit on a$700 job, so I wasn't happy, but I did it.The one other time I was sweeping a earaee door and the lady said I couldn't put the air-conditioner in and the County came out with a picture of the unit. It's on the back of the complaint it was done five years prior. I met with the head at the time and he said to permit it. I said I couldn't permit it because it was not a complete change-out. He said it matched the coil,so you can do it and I did it. They charged me $50 bucks and it was done. I know a lot of people don't get inspections and when it comes down to the real estate closing—you can't close unless you get Patrick White: I can assure you that as a now-retired land use lawyer. I assisted my real-estate, Board-certified attorneys regularly in getting through the County process to do this. It has become a cottage industry. It is not going to get less ... it is only going to get more and more. Respondent: It's all on the computers. Everything is stored on computers and it sends up a red flag. Patrick White: Terrific. Respondent: Like I said, I permitted what I didn't put in and I went out and checked it and everything_was okay. I charged the owner for the permit,went down and the County came out and inspected it and it was fine, I've done it on a couple that I've sold that I pulled permits for and never had inspected. I had it renewed and then inspected. Richard Joslin: Are you willing at this moment to get these permits finalized, done and completed and to take care of the items that you need to keep your license active? Respondent: Yes, I don't have a choice. Richard Joslin: How long will it take you to do that? Respondent: I would say if you give me a month. I should be fine. Patrick White: Does the County have a position on this,having heard his testimony? EveriIdo Ybaceta: We would like the permits to be taken care of. We would suggest giving him 30 to 60 days—do you feel 30 days? Respondent: I think I can get most of them done in 30 days. What are the ones that I have to re-apply for? I don't know getting through Fire ... Everildo Ybaceta: So. let's say 60 days. Respondent: Okay. 44 March 21,2018 Everildo Yhaceta: Let's say you 60 days to give you some time,and if you don't get it done in 60 days, what we will do is suspend your license and send it to the DBPR (Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation). Respondent: Okay. Assistant County Attorney Noell explained the Board would state the Finding of the violation as admitted and grant a Continuance for 60 days, and then the Respondent would return to appear before the Board. Patrick White Are you suggesting we split the Finding of Violation and the penalty imposition? Assistant County Attorney Noell: The Board can continue the matter. Patrick Whine moved the approve closing the Public Hearing. Richard Joslin offered a Second in support of the motion. Carried unanimously, 6— 0 Patrick White moved to approve finding the Respondent, Jeffrey H. Bumpus, in violation as stated in the Administrative Complaint in Case#2018-04 mire Chairman Lantz offered a Second in support of the motion. Carried unanimously, 6—g Patrick Jfhite moved to approve tabling any consideration of the imposition of a penalty in this Case until such time as the County places it on the Board's Agenda, not to exceed two monthly cycles from today's Hearing date. Richard Joslin offered a Second in support of the motion. Patrick White explained when the Case is brought t back before the Board.the members will consider the penalty phase. Matthew Nolton requested clarification of the permits— Patrick White stated the Administrative Complaint stated "multiple." Whatever the County believes is the appropriate number—it might find another one. In my mind, it is any and all of them that the County believes are either void or expired,and they all need to be resolved within the sixty days—otherwise, we're back here. Richard Joslin stated he hope, considerinv. the number of outstanding permits that may be voided, the County's Staff would work with Mr. Bumpus to make the process go smoothly to not delay the 60-day period. Patrick White noted the thing that took the longest was to get the permits transferred from CD Plus into City-View. Everildo Yhaceta: It a process*yes. Chairman Boyd called for a vote on the motion. Carried unanimously, 6— 0. Everildo Yhaceta: Just to clarify, Mr. Bumpus has 60 days or two meetings? Patrick White: My expectation is you will be putting it on the Agenda two months from now. And it will be 'nip and tuck' down to the day of the Hearing for the May meeting. 45 \ic) GP-ID Pubic Portal _ search for Permits rr � �1(05earc?. NORTHERN BRUZE in 1 Got Enter an ea pert ed a permit number,aeereds.Parcel rwsnper d na.ndaoc>rss or a.mntart Cr the r-+a ar).1 tr•..e,da Me Sc dot e. ✓= 01 art 4 M o \ Gam y 5 Permit Applications Permit P umber• PFiSY201312310Q1 E — d/� p�r`- J pen-nit Type Med'ianiCal Status Finaiect Locations: 1715 Wiry Pines DR,timtz6 710550006-'2 Permit Stang Permit Number: PS.V20131026210 1 Permit Type: Metenkal Status: Void Cocci ne. 2420 Hiceen Lake DF,unit:4 3239:002485 Pe^nit St3ttr5 Pernd Number Ffti:-.V2 121024E$5 Pr-mit Type, Mechar.cal Status. Void Locator's 705 Sentwater C1R 66675091009 per'ni:5t4tv.5 Perrn:t Number; PRNV20131024S50 ✓J Pe::771;Type. Mechanical 5tat:5. Vele Lccace:is. B45 109th AVE N 624.1 360005 Permit Statin �// Permit t umber: PRe 2G131Q24379 T Permit Tom: Mechanical Status: Void L3 1 a s' 2332 M3rrnoliia L:,Untt:1 5633000014e 'PS. itw t Stat Penis:Num er• PR1\120130523746 1 Ftrmit Type. Mechanical Sats: Void Locations.. 755 eertrrater CR,Unit:201 24724011740 Permit Statut Per Num er: PS}V20130523743 Permit Type. Mechanical Stat:-s. Void Lacaocrs 725 7-rt-Aa: -C2R,Urit:203 24720600463 permit Status Permit Number: PP.I'V-4130922361 Permit Type. Mechanical Status Fnal Lccatcr•,s: 7444 Tr'erne OR 614625000605 httplicvpartal.colliergov.net/CityVieviViebiPermititecator 4111:LV ID rermtt hppi xln JCritgi•..IIyworr TVri tt Perritt Statu'3 7e r.vt Number: PRMV201.3C819832 Permit Type: Methartica Status; Void Locations: 2255 Linvro0d AVE 61630240004 Permit 5i t4 Permit Number: PPHV2013C819377 permit Type. Med emiral Status: Expired Locations: 2274 Midden Lake DR,Unit:3. 32390001266 permit Statu2 Pewit Number: PR4-'120130819375 Permit Type: Mechanical Status: Finaled Locations: 2372 hidden Lake D .Unit_6 32390002126 permit S atu^s Perr:r+t Number. K}:Y20I30202810 Permit Type: Mechanical Status: Fatale' Locations: 7887 Vizcaya WAY 80940005664 pt r^it Stat' Permit Number: PR020120510824 Peri Type: Building Status: Fnaied Locations: 7887 Vizcaya WAY 80940005664 permit Status Permit Number; P 0201203304466 Pemlit Type, Building Status: Finale Locations: 3049 Mona Lisa 81vO 29734000962 Pt<rmit Status Permit Number: Fr+.`:V201201C0540 Permit.Type: Me thanical Status: Finated L c tiors: 6812 Pei n aay 6Lvt3 663807E2002 permit Status Permit Number: CUP2010090335 Permit Type: Med'er tat Status: Firaled Lucations; 4845 Martinique WAY 52250018366 Permit Status i �I httn llevanrtai r niliarinv natinitv1JlnwWNohab.n an Y /'• .^ Poi. Gi• - searcti1nr PernI1. Sesrth: NORTHERN saFF7C Goin eater ill or part 0 a p!nH nuretter,adtrass.Parcel number el name/aeCrr s 0.a urtact en ft•:pram ane tern ckze 7+s qe Pueten. - Pena t AppiLca cns Permit Number PRHV2Oi5D517113 Perrrit Type: Mechanical Status: Expired Locations: 2349 Hidden Lake D .Unit:6 32390041923 Permit Ste'ug Permit Number: Pf 1V2D150514679 Permit Type: Mechanical Status: Expired b Labors: 810 Breakaway LN,Unit:2O4 24720015649 Permit Status Permit NumberPRKI20I50411587 Permit Ty^„e: F!ea,anicdl Status. Fnalecl _ccatons. 9937 Soca CIA 2434!C0530£ P+ mit Stahz Penn::Number: PRY.V20150411477 Permit Type: Meolanicai 6 Status: Ere Locations: 2344 Magnolia LN,Unit:S 56330000394 Permit Status Permit Number. ROW-29150410606 Permit Type: Melt anicai Status: Expired LCcattonS: 6512 Pelican Bay BLVD 66330762002 Permit Status Permit Nurrlber: PRI,W2C15,3410566 Permit Type Mec7tanicat Stats Fx_ eC tocatcru. 73d CM,Unit,204 24720000324 permit Status Permit Number: PRJV20I41235547 Permit Type: Mechanicai 411' Status: Void Locations: 16.5 Wlnfly-Pines DR,Unit:8. 71055002040 Perm4 StatLs Pe.-rat Number: PRhV2014123:5542 Permit Type: Mechanical Stat: Void Letavens 2.345 ridden Lake DR,Unit:1 81090000521 h ttp licvpertal,col liergov,ne UCilyViewyyeb/PertRiL2ocatar I4 IQ rern1i;t - ry.)p��;aciJn:�ca,�iruirrrcw rt:r w. Permit Status Permit Number. FRHV20140926474 Permit Type: iMecJ apical Status: Void Locations 69:Arremcre LN 66674600906 Perms Status Permit Nurrtce : PAriv2014O824599 Permit Type. Mechanicai Statta. Void Locations: 2265 hidden Lake DR,Linit:8 52595000364 Permit St2tyl Permit Number: Pt;HV2G140822134 Permit Type: Mechanical Situs` Vcid L:^cettGrs: 2235 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:7 57.5950005A7 permit 5tzri:s Permit Number: PAHV201407194.97 Permit Type: M .anii Status: Void toca;cns: 4976 Rustic Oaks OR 22730000523 perm t Stabil Permit Number: PRHV20L40615043 Permit Type: Mechanical $;ztus: Finaled Locations: 2375 Bayou LN,Unit:3 22035800305 permit Status Permit Number: PRHV2C:4C-b15040 Permit Type: Mechanical Stata Void Locations: 2332 Macrotia LN,Urit:3 56330000:8C PrRrtit Status Permit N rrnbtr: PAH8/20140515025 Permit Type: Mechanical Status: Void Locations: 1615 Windy Pines DR,Unlit:9 71055000355 Permit Status Pernit Number: PRH V20 1 4 05 128 53 Permit Type: teethanicai Status. Expired Lo tiord: 2332 Magnolia IN,Unit:3 56330000180 Permit S;at;,rs Permit Number: PRlaV2C140203292 Permit Type: Med-, nical Status: Volt; Locations 700 5ent'wacer CIA,Unit:102 2472r,;015(147 Psrrr- 'tit 5—t�L': httol/cvoortal.Cctlierocv netlCit'.ViawWPt1/PRr,TtitA ru atnr • Per:nit tit:j rnt ar. PR4V20 4020 3 291 PR MIA 7ype_ Mechanicaf Status! void Locatons: 1545 vitooy Panes DR.Linit:d 71055002008 Permit Staruil ‘07 - Permit Nur:liner: PCLMV201402.03267 Pefmit Type: Mechanical Statas- Wks locatons- 2325 Kideen Lake OR.Lmit 4 52595000650 Permit 5tatt4 Permit Number: PitHV20131221004. Perroit Type: MechaniaT Stat.is: Void Locations: 1515 Windy Pints OA,Urfa:2 71055000246 ptrrnit Status Next Previous Ic . httplicyportaL=iliergov.netiCt/Vie,vWetdPerrnitiLccator rLI.cant sv.}an.atws'a.,eoa..rr-v4!y V'C..ru.we • Gr-7D Public P r<<-=:-.1 i T Search.for Permits Stare' Noq-nieR7 BR'_ zE Goi 5-a.-ac car-.;a x,t,:.r:n:ntc,ta:ess. rarriaceress see pict or rC 5a+,0 Ten Oa ttIc Qc L•u . _ Permit Applications Permit t3urrber_ PR1-V20;6O534525 Permit Type: Meclsanicai Sras: Void Locators: 2405?Midden Lake CR,Un t:S 61090001740 Permit Status Permit Number: PRHV20i.0831780.. Permit Type: Mechanical Lots ons: 2336 C ,iic`es CR,Urit.14 25735000055-4 permit Status Permit Number; PRI V2016072S773 Perm Type. Mechanical Status; Vr Lccaiors: 237S Mzgnelia AVE,Unit:1 5633500660 permit statin Permit Number: PR.W20150727653 Ferr tit Type. Med;an'rCal Situs: Vold Locations; 23x5 Magnolia Lk,unit:6 56339000369 permit Status Permit Number: PRHV2D16072 694 Permit Type: Meehan,cal 5:a::s. Void Locations. 2370 Magriciia AVE_,Ur,t.7 5533000625 pernit Status Permit Number: PRI V2016fl 20:17 Permit Type, Mecranica! 5 _s: Expired. Locations: 705 Eeritwater C1R 66675051009 permit Status Permit Number: PRein 1675L9552 Perri Type. Mechenic,al Status. Es red Lo attons. 2324 M:zzien Lake DR,Unit.3 323 0001664 perrnit Status Pe^rit NLr ober: PRH%?01.604.12341 Permit Type; Methanicai !•"+ Status. Void (11 Lora rs: 1665.WindyPriemDR,Ur.t;9 71055001659 http:// c�+�ortaf.cx�ilierrov.netlGityViewiNeblf'errriitll.ocatcr 1.1l1xrults--_____ Fern?Appficauon Searzn-t:ftyView Portal Permit Status Permit Nurnter• :S0]2016031OE6G Permit Type. FAA:ding 5tt:,us Vele .Mar:PCrS: 1685 Wintry Pines DR.Uri;:8 7:055r:01245 Permit sum]: Pernik'Numeer PRHV20160308.383 i=ermit Type: !jedialica! Status: Exafre4 LOC3tiarls: 2004 Cascades DR,Unit:7 2573500:029 Perr nit Stktus Per-»t Nurn er; PRrfv:20160206359 Pe-n' Type- Merhantcai Stats Errpired Locations: 2415 Midden take DR,Urtit:2 81090001805 Permit Stat413 Pr--it Number PR1-N2 160 03853 Pen-rot Type: MCChanic- Status: Vo,d Lecatian3: 2004 Cascades DR,Unit;B 25735001045 Perm It Status Permit Number: PRtiV20I51237830 Permit Type; Mectartical Status. Void Locations: 2332 Magnolia L14,Unit:2 56333000164 Permit Status Fennit Number: FahV20151135619 Permit Type: Me+.-har,3ca! Status: Expired Locations: 770 Bentwate-C1R,Unit:102 24720010656 Pe ,it Stat•,n Porn:Number: PRtiV2015:135615 Permit Type: Med.:a:11c t Status: Expred Locations. 2329 tirdCen Lake DR,Unit:9 81090000121 Permit Status Rerrn4 N.;m►ber: PR-V20150827614 Permit Type Mechanica! 543:us Void Locations. 2100 Cascades CR,Unit:8 25735000169 Permit Status Permit Nurser PRNV20150825900 Permit Type: Metnanical Status: Careened Locations: 2036 Cascades DR,Unit:14 25.73 5000 8 84 Perin t Status @,r+n-lir-.,',,,- r..,u;o...........�lr:h,�l......1.Al..�.lOw.�.:�i1......,... i itc.110 remit Appicaticn earcr-Latyviear rcrtai Permit Nurft FRSV20150722425 Permit Type ('tecnanica; Status'. Vt.d Lcfacicns. 1645 Windy Pines OR,Unit:5 7105500198E permit Status Perrnil Number` PRHV201S0722421 Perrot Type: Mechanical Status. Void Lccatirins: 3329 Hidden Lake OR,Unit:5 81090000107 Permit Status Permit Number: PR-KV20150618951 Permit Type: Mechanical Status: Vo+C Locations: 2365 Hidden Lake DR.Unit:4 81090000848 Permit Status Next http:itctipartalcotiiergov.net'CitliViewWeb/Pe 1cs:ator May 16,2018 MINUTES OF THE COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD May 16, 2018 Naples, Florida LET IT BE REMEMBERED that the Collier County Contractors' Licensing Board, having conducted business herein, met on this date at 9:00 AM in REGULAR SESSION in Administrative Building"F," 3rd Floor, Collier County Government Complex, Naples, Florida, with the following Members present: Chairman: Michael Boyd Vice Chair: Kyle Lantz Members: Terry Jerulle Richard Joslin Robert Meister Patrick White Excused: Matthew Nolton ALSO PRESENT: Everildo Ybaceta—Supervisor, Contractors' Licensing Office Kevin Noe11, Esq. — Assistant Collier County Attorney Jed Schneck, Esq.—Attorney for the Contractors' Licensing Board Reggie Smith—Contractors' Licensing Compliance Officer Jack Gumph —Contractors' Licensing Compliance Officer Richard Noonan — Collier County Building Department Inspector 1 19 May 16,2018 IL OLD BUSINESS: (Note: The individuals who testified in the following cases under Item IX, "Old Business,"were first sworn in by the Attorney for the Board.) A. Case No.: 2018-04: Jeffrey Bumpus-Misconduct of a State-Certified Contractor- Expired Permits (Update) Everildo Ybaceta,Supervisor-Contractors' Licensing Office: • Mr. Bumpus appeared before the Board during its last meeting. He was granted sixty days to bring the expired permits up-to-date-re-activate them. • May 16, 2018 is the deadline. Jeffrey Bumpus: • He obtained Workers' Compensation insurance on May 9th; • He submitted twenty applications on May 9th; • He has arranged to obtain keys and access to the various properties and as soon as he obtains the extensions, he will start obtaining inspections. Patrick White questioned Mr. Rumpus: Q. Does 20 equal the number of... A. No, it's 43, I believe. I submitted 20 of them. Q. And what are your intentions regarding the remaining 23? A. As soon as I get them,I'll bring the rest-as soon as I get the ones I've got done, I'll submit other applications. Q. Help me to understand what"reactivation-means. A. I filled out a one-page application asking for them to be extended. I figured once the 20 were done, I'd pay the money and submit the next ones. I'm trying to round up keys and access. Some people say they don't want inspections. I will call them in and if they fail, they fail. Most people have been cooperative. They have given me"Home Watch"people to contact, and some people have mailed their keys to give me access to their places. Q. We originally believed that sixty days... A. I asked for thirty and you gave me sixty, but it could be at least another sixty. 1 mean-as far as the process goes-it's just a matter of getting in every place. Q. What basis do you think there might be for me to make a motion to extend this by sixty days? A. I didn't have insurance and I couldn't pull a permit without insurance. Q. I understand that-it sounds like it took maybe 45 days to get insurance. A. I got insurance through one company and they cancelled because I'm a one-man operation-they said they're not writing in Florida anymore-that's the excuse they gave me. So, right now, I just was written on Wednesday by a company out of New York. Chairman Boyd questioned Mr. Rumpus: Q. Is this Workers' Comp or liability? 3 May 16,2018 A. Workers' Comp. I have lability until June 2018. Q. As a one-man operation, I don't think you really need Workers' Comp. You could be an exemption. A. My license is a dlbla. I'm a corporation but it was never changed so it's been Jeff Bumpus doing business as'Northern Breeze Air Conditioning, Inc." They won't let me be an exemption. I already went to the State for that. Q. Okay. A. I had one employee who is my son—we had to go through an agency for our paychecks because nobody would write it. I went through Paychex and then they cancelled it because they said they weren't renewing anything in Florida, but Paychex never told me ... so now I've gone through this other insurance agency in New York. I must pay for three people to get Workers' Comp. They won't write for one person. Patrick White continued questioning Mr. Bumpus: Q. What would your plan of action be if, for example, today we didn't take any action to change what we decided on two months ago? A. I promised I would get the inspections done. That's all I can do—is get them done. Q. You don't have a"Plan B?" If you don't have a license,how would you do it? A. I would have to go to somebody else, I guess. Q. Which means those people who were your customers would then deal with somebody that they don't know. A. I'd have to get somebody who is authorized to let me do it and I'd still do it. I'm not going to charge my customers to do it. One of my customers got a thing in the mail for a water heater and they didn't even own the house at the time, so they were charged S100 to renew the permit. Q. Understood. A. I'm trying to do it for my customers and I still deal with my customers daily. In response to a question, Mr, Bumpus said he had filled out 20 renewal applications. He said he didn't do them all at once. There were 23 more to do. Terry Jerulle questioned Mr. Bumpus: Q. I'm a little confused. You said you still have`'customers?" A. Yes. Q. How do you have customers if you don't have insurance? A. I have liability insurance just not Workers' Comp. Q. But you're still working ... A. I'm still working. Q. I'm not an expert on insurance but it took you 53 days to find insurance? A. I thought I had it, but I didn't have it. Workers' Comp—I got it through Paychex but when I went to get the Certificate. I was told I didn't have it. Q. That takes one day. A. Okay. Well, I got it on March 28th and then I found out it's not applicable when I asked for the Certificate to be sent. 4 20 May 16,2018 Richard Joslin questioned Mr. Bumpus: Q. On March 28th you found out you didn't have insurance? A. I didn't have it again. I called as soon as I left the meeting to activate the insurance through Paychex. They sent me a policy and I sent everything back. i thought they were taking money out,but they didn't take any money, so I called. She said they won't write you. I said I thought I had insurance. She got me insurance and I just got it on Wednesday. Hopefully the Certificate got sent it. I got an email. Vice Chairman Lantz questioned Mr. Bumpus: Q. Are you still doing alc work? A. No, I'm not I'm doing service and Home Watch—I have a Home Watch business. Q. You're only doing a/c service? A. Yes. Q. Not the kind that needs a permit? A. Right. Preventive maintenance and repair work. Q. So, in all reality,even if we revoke his permit-pulling privileges, he's not going to do anything. A. No,basically... I said my son left almost two years ago and I haven't done any. a/c. I'm just doing preventive maintenance,warranty work—the product I sell has a I 0-year warranty. Chairman Boyd: In all honesty, I never thought you'd get it done in 60 days. Jeffrey Bumpus: I really thought I could but... Terry Jerulle: I would have thought he would have had something done ... he has done absolutely nothing in sixty days except get insurance. Patrick White: And file the 20 applications. Richard Joslin: But none of them have been finalized—right? Jeffrey Bumpus: I haven't done anything except email the application ... Chairman Boyd: And it may be a week or two before you hear back, Jeffrey Bumpus: Normally it's two days. Chairman Boyd: Reggie,can you confirm that he has submitted the 20? Reggie Smith,Contractors' Licensing Compliance Officer: Of the 20 referenced, in my recent research, I found 17 ... which is close. However, the information I need to provide to you would be that most of those 17 that were applied for on an extension form for Collier County Permitting were for void permits. And that can't be done— you cannot extend a void permit. You must re-apply completely when a permit is void. So out of the 17 that I found, 15 were for void permits and 2 were for expired permits which would be allowed to go through. Jeffrey Bumpus: Why were they void if they are expired permits? Reggie Smith: These were permits that were so old that they ... that,as the Collier County Chief Building Official explained to you two months ago, the process of how a permit becomes expired, and then after that—after so many days, it becomes void. 5 May 16,2018 Chairman Boyd: In the old computer system. Reggie Smith: It just depends on how old the permit is. Patrick White: How many days before it transitions from expired to void? Reggie Smith: If you look at Page 40 from the minutes... Patrick White: Yes—I just want it on the record. Reggie Smith: this is the record from March Zit, at the bottom of Page 39, begins the statements of Jonathan Walsh,Collier County Chief Building Official. If you'd like to read that.., I believe it says`'thirty." Evy Ybaceta: For the record, yes. On Page 40,per Jonathan Walsh's testimony, it does say thirty days. [Excerpt from the March 21, 2018 Minutes: ".., the permit has expired...you have 30 days to address it or it will go into a "void"status. If there are any pending fees on the permit and they are not paid your license will be place on -hold" It is basically a warning. If nothing happens during the 30 days, the status of the permit is changed to "void."] Patrick White: I think that's the answer,Mr. Bumpus, thirty days. Jeffrey Bumpus: I've done permits that were four or five years old for other contractors and all I did was an extension form. Before, we had to submit a letter asking—this time they have a new form that just says, "Extend Permit." If they're void,that means they don't need to be inspected—correct? Patrick White: That means you must apply for a new permit to get the inspection. Jeffrey Bumpus: But we talked about the old permits were going to be under the old Codes at the time and the efficiency ratings at that time. Patrick White: And I believe that the standard for the new permits would relate back to those. Jeffrey Bumpus: Okay. Patrick White: That's my understanding,but I'm not the Chief Building Official. Reggie Smith: That information is also explained on Page 40. Richard Joslin: I'm not one to stick up for the County but l know for a fact that, as a pool contractor,I've had permits that were probably 25 years old that never got inspected for some reason ...even though I thought they were ... and I was just able to go in and re-apply ... basically call for a final inspection to be done, It was done through the director of Collier County. Reggie Smith again referenced Mr. Walsh's comments on Page 40 of the March 215; minutes, Richard Joslin: So, it is possible, I suppose. Chairman Boyd: And how many actual voided permits do you have—was it 60 or was it 43? Jeffrey Bumpus: They are all over two years old,every permit there. Reggie Smith: In my original case, there were 15 voided permits. And then,before the March 21'Hearing,I did find more void permits on record and many more expired. I think the total for expired and void permits was 44. 6 May 16,2018 Patrick White: Here's what I'm thinking—I may be wrong—but it seems to me that you made an effort. Jeffrey Bumpus: Yes. Patrick White: An honest effort. It may not have been the most diligent ... Jeffrey Buutpus: Right. Patrick White: But I'm here to say that as long as you're going to keep your foot on the gas pedal, I'm not adverse to giving you the time to get it done because I think that's in the best interests of not only the consumers ... Jeffrey Bumpus: .., the homeowners ... Patrick White: You're third on my list—consumers are first, the County is second, and the contractor is third. It seems to me that if I triangulate those three things—at least for my vote—it makes the most sense to extend the time for you to do this but with the stipulation that you'd have weekly reports to make to the Contractors' Licensing Office to review the status. And if the Staff is willing to consider that,then I'd be prepared to put it in the form of a motion. I don't know what Staff's perspective is on committing resources to work with this gentleman on at least a weekly basis to monitor him. Evy Ybaceta: I can agree to that. Patrick White: Right. Richard Joslin: Also, one other thing, Mr. White—I would like to say.., you've already had a problem with your Workers' Comp policy that you thought you had but was cancelled .., Jeffrey Bumpus: Right. Richard Joslin: I think I would like to see something in writing or an active policy,.. Jeffrey Bumpus: Okay. Richard Joslin: Because it could be cancelled—that's how it happened before. Jeffrey Bumpus: Right. Patrick White: But to get the re-applied for permits, you would likely have to demonstrate either the exemption or the Certificate of Insurance. Evy Ybaceta: He would need to be active in our system so, either way, yes. Richard Joslin: But that could be a matter of days or a week if they cancel him for whatever reason—so something that would be concrete .., he paid in advance... so that suddenly,he couldn't get a permit. Patrick White: Let me ask it a different way: Is the County ever notified of a cancellation of an insurance certificate? Evy Ybaceta: No. Patrick White: So, his circumstance is no different than any other contractor whether he demonstrates an exemption or a Certificate. Evy Ybaceta: I would ask that i f we're going to do this and—yes—he does have a list of voided permits ... some of them have money owed... I know we have not put in a final Order on this,but the money needs to be paid back to the County. Patrick White: Are you referring to permit dollars or inspection dollars ...? Evy Ybaceta: Yes. Patrick White: Understood. I would think that it would be part of the administrative process regardless. If it's not,now is the time to say so. 7 May 16.2018 Richard Joslin: Isn't it when you call in for a final inspection,before you can pick up the C/O on the permit, you must pay the inspection fees on it? Evy Ybaceta: That is correct,yes. Again, there may be some permits that ... Jeffrey Bumpus: There are four permits that didn't go through the final inspection ... the Fire Inspector failed them at review,so they aren't paid for. Evy Ybaceta: While they were still under review,they did incur some fees. These are the fees that I'm talking about and,at a very minimum,I would like the County to collect them or try to collect them. Reggie Smith: 1 have a recent list made up by Joshua Lenio, Administrative Supervisor, in the Permitting Department, provided to me yesterday of just the voided permit fees that are still pending and by my count Patrick White: I apologize for interrupting,but I want the information to be accurate ... would that be the 15 that were reviewed, or would that be the totality of 44 that are void? Reggie Smith: That's the original 15. Patrick White: Okay. Reggie Smith: And these are only the void permits its not the expired permits— and the total by my count is $704.00 in pending fees. Patrick White: And as to the other 25 that the County has not yet analyzed? Reggie Smith: I don't have a report on any of the expired permits. But I would agree with the Board Member Joslin that before you can finalize a permit,all fees must be paid before they will issue a CIU. Jeffrey Bumpus: The 5700 in fees that's the four permits? There's a$250 fee for filing review and then the$100 permitting review. Reggie Smith: Seven of those 15 permits have fees pending, totaling 5704.00. And moving forward, if the Board decides to grant more time for Mr. Bumpus to accomplish this, I would reiterate to him, once again, the process that this needs to take for the void permits. These are not extensions. He needs to work closely with Joshua Lenin who does this with hundreds and hundreds of contractors—with the massive dilemma that we have with expired and void permits in Collier County. Patrick White: I would characterize the dilemma as a market opportunity for a variety of professionals--I've seen it first-hand,multiple times. But the point is from our perspective as a Board and looking to ensure protections for consumers--whether they are buyers of real estate or otherwise—that the contractor closes out the permits. I wish there was more specific information about the other 25 permits relative to which of them are void, which are expired, and which of them may or may not have fees. I believe we are at a point where we could make a motion, with conditions,to extend the time. Terry Jerulle: Won't he be back here talking about the same thing--thirty days from now—sixty days from now—ninety days from now? Patrick White: And what's the alternative? Terry Jerulle: Let's just tell the State that we think that his license should be pulled. Patrick White: And what happens to the people who don't have those inspections? Terry Jerulle: The same thing that's going to happen anyway because nothing is going to get done. 8 May 16,2018 Patrick White: If I honestly believed that,I wouldn't be interested in having this conversation. Reggie Smith: A lot of these homeowners are up north now and you're not going to have access into the condos or homes to inspect them. Patrick White: Understood. And I think there were statements on the record under oath that he's made contact. He may not have made the County's administrative piece of this very effectively,but it sounds like he understood the process of contacting unit owners,the residential owners, and taken the steps—whether it's through Home Watch, or being given keys,or people being present,and so ... Richard Joslin: It's kind of a Catch-22 ... getting himself into a situation where he can't get into the home to get it inspected—how would an Inspector get in to inspect it? Again, I'm not on his side,but I'm saying that he has, I guess, demonstrated some type of wanting to get this handled but if he doesn't have communication with the homeowner, everybody's hands are tied—aren't they? Reggie Smith: I would agree. Patrick White: But the probability of getting communication with the homeowner, if it's not this"contractor,"and if it's someone else who is a substitute and gets involved with that process,is even more remote. That's why Pm saying—from a consumers' perspective— it makes more sense to me to put him in a position to keep his word and do a better job of it by monitoring his progress. In a sense, the weekly contact with the County sounds like it would be with the Operations Coordinator, If there are issues that are not being resolved timely, it will come up the chain either to you or to Evy and we will know. Reggie Smith: I have no problem working with Mr.Bumpus on that. I would just request that the Board have an open mind with these 44 permits—you won't see the final one be inspected until probably November or December by the time all the folks come back Patrick White: And I don't have any illusions that when we may be putting a chain on this, in a sense,on this to monitor it but—given the alternatives —none of them are any better. And if we can do this in a more formal way, through reports and not necessarily having Mr. Bumpus appear, that kind of works for me. But 1 want to be comfortable that Staff—not only in this instance but more generally— is operating under the kind of set policies and procedures where these things are being worked through the system itself. It sounds like the County's resources are being committed to getting it done and to understand what's going on out there in the market. It is a bit of a 'cottage industry" especially for condos. Terry Jerulle: But what is the cost—you said 17 permits must be renewed or pull new permits? Patrick White: Fifteen out of 17 must be re-applied. Reggie Smith: Mr. Bumpus filled out extension forms in early May for 15 out of 17 which will be denied—they are denied. They will need to be re-applied for ... I don't know the exact price of a permit—he's essentially starting all over. Board members asked about the price of the permits. It was noted the fee to submit an extension form was$100. 9 May 16,2018 Reggie Smith: I can tell you on the extension forms that were filled out, there has been no payment thus far. They get reviewed, they get put in the system, and then Mr. Bumpus will receive a payment schedule in the mail. Jeffrey Bumpus: They email a payment schedule—you bring it in,pay it, and they give you the permit. That's why I'm saying ,..the re-up fee is$100—that's what it used to be. And the permit itself is$110, $112, or$103 ... it's all on the value of... there's no big difference in the money ... that's why it's just a paperwork thing. Patrick White: From your perspective, Mr. Bumpus, what we're talking about is from a cost perspective—past fees, fees that would be added on for re-applications and inspections, etc. Those are all things that you understand the magnitude of... Jeffrey Bumpus: Yes ... Patrick White: ... and are prepared to bear? Jeffrey Bumpus: ... yes ... it's coming out of my pocket, yes. Evy Yhaceta: Richard Noonan who was the Acting Building Official and used to be a Mechanical Chief who dealt with HVAC and other permits—he may have some information as to how much the fees would be for some of the new permits for air conditioning. (It was noted that Richard Noonan was sworn in.) Richard Noonan: For the record, Richard Noonan, Collier County Building Department Inspector and past Chief Inspector. A new Fee Schedule has come in .., I'm not—I don't know the current fees, but Mr. Bumpus is correct ... all permits are running right around$100 as before and I think maybe they may be cheaper now. I just don't know for certain. The applications are the same—as it has been stated, you submit the application—it's a two to three-day turnaround—he will receive an email stating it's ready and the payment slip, he comes in to pick it up and off he goes. Richard Joslin: Thank you. And the re-application portion of this—is this something —is he going to have to furnish all the technical information ... Richard Noonan: No... Richard Joslin: ... or just a re-application and pay the fee and get the inspection? Richard Noonan: What I remember—and the policy may have changed since I've been in the field and not in the office anymore when somebody's permits are under the old Code system ... as what has happened here .., we apply the Code that was in effect at the time when the equipment was installed ... and that's what we inspect to. Patrick White: Under the void permits that he must re-apply for the new permits, it would be the old permit date that would be used roughly as the Code requirement. Richard Noonan: In our system, it comes up when they apply for another permit .., there are letters in front of the permit numbers and that tells us it is under the old system and.if.I'm not mistaken, it may even have that old permit number— when it comes up on the computer, we know immediately we are dealing with an old permit and old Codes and old requirements. Jeffrey Bumpus: The new application is going to ask for physical—the size of the unit --- model and serial numbers of the new and the old ... that's going to create a disaster if I must fill out new applications for every unit. If they could bring it up ... I don't know how ... 10 May 16,2018 Richard Noonan: Under the old system, we didn't require the model numbers, we didn't require the serial numbers Jeffrey Bumpus: Yeah, but when the Fire Department re-wrote the application for the permits . Richard Noonan: When was that? In 2010 or 2014? Jeffrey Bumpus: 2014. Okay,everything they asked for were all fire questions—does the building have alarm systems ... does it have Richard Noonan: I understand, but under the permits you are dealing with,you don't have"Fire." You can go with the old one—reference the old permits—reference the old size and go from there, Jeffrey Bumpus: If we can get that information without me running around and checking everything Evy Ybaceta: Usually that information is in the Records Room—we do keep those records safe—you can go to the Records Room and ask for them. They could make copies of them for you. Richard Joslin: That would be listed on the old permit—correct? Evy Ybaceta: Correct. It would be part of the packet for the permit you are pulling. Patrick White: But you can only find it in Records. Jeffrey Bumpus: It would drag me down. Patrick White: Honestly, Mr. Bumpus, the commitment of time, over whatever period of time that we will give you—if we do—needs to be more than what you have been able to commit so far. Jeffrey Bumpus: I've got from now until basically June le and then my liability runs out and there's even more issues, so (mumbled) (Richard Joslin asked Mr. Bumpus to repeat his statement) Jeffrey Bumpus: My liability policy runs out in June ... on June 18th and if I don't renew it,then I—you know—that runs out, so be running into that issue. Shouldn't be a problem to renew my liability. Richard Joslin: Okay. That's what I wondered. Jeffrey Bumpus: Right. Patrick White: The part I don't understand your state of mind is you"guess"you have to ...? Jeffrey Bumpus: No— I know, I have to get it done. Patrick White: That more affirmative stance is what I'm really hoping for— not only in words but ... Jeffrey Bumpus: I was hoping to extend permits, not have to re-apply for permits because if they're void,they're void they're not there no more, you know? Patrick White: Let me tell you how it works ... Jeffrey Bumpus: I know—I see it. Patrick White: Okay. Chairman Boyd:Does anyone want to make a motion—anymore discussion? Patrick White: I'm prepared to make a motion,Mr. Chairman. Patrick White moved to approve extending the time currently granted by another sixty days with the condition that Mr. Rumpus is to provide weekly reports to 11 May 16,2018 and contact with the county's Operations Coordinator on the status of the void, expired,pending, and new permits so we may have tracking on all forty-four. All previously unpaid, outstanding fees will be paid in addition to current permit, inspection, and other fees. Jeffrey Bumpus: That's a lot—does that include the 5704? Patrick White: Yes, it does, and that would be sixty days from today. Mr. Bumpus, just so you understand.. I'm not likely to be here in two months. Jeffrey Bumpus: Okay. Richard Joslin offered a Second in support of the motion. Richard Justin: Also, the insurance policy? Patrick White: He's going to have to keep that in force. Richard Joslin: We're going to have to see a liability policy. Vice Chairman Lantz: I think that's all in the permit process. We don't care about the liability policy if he's not doing the permits wrong, Richard Joslin: Right but it's in the middle of June .,. Vice Chairman Lantz: I get it—I get it. Chairman Boyd: We have a motion and a second on the floor. Any discussion on the motion? Discussion: • Reggie Smith: I just had a question concerning Mr.Bumpus' comment about his company being a"d/b/a." I have him down as"'Northern Breeze Air Conditioning, Inc." • Jeffrey Bumpus: That's the way it is,but when I signed up with you guys, it has to be the way it is in your records. I incorporated back in '96 and never changed my State license. My accountant_.. • Reggie Smith: He could become Workers' Comp exempt ... • Jeffrey Rumpus: I tried to deal with the State— I have a 40-page application and it's all over—they don't grandfather anything. One lady I talked to said to send the papers and I sent the papers—they sent me back a rejection and I needed 40 pages to start all over wain. I've been in business since '93 —I incorporated in, I think, '95 or '96 and we never notified the State, so it's Jeff Rumpus doing business as ... and when I brought in the insurance policy, the County turned it down because of the way they have it in the computer ... Reggie sent me the paperwork and said everything was turned in ... it was all done. But it reads in the filing: "Jeff Bumpus doing business as" so my insurance company set up all the policies that way. It was rejected and re-sent. It took me two or three weeks and the head of Regale's department gave me some leeway and I got it re-done because I had it online. I don't remember when that way. • Patrick White: I understand what you're saying but it sounds like the County may be able to help you out relative to what the records show to simplify things 12 May 16.201 S for you and it could reduce your costs. That, to me, increases the probability that you will pay the back fees and get the work done. a Jeffrey Bumpus: I just spent$4,000 on Workers' Comp so any help would be good. • Reggie Smith: For the record, the County is not telling Mr. Bumpus either for his policy or ... • Patrick White: Understood. Those are the administrative details that you can work out. • Jeffrey Bumpus: Can I ask—who do I meet at the County? Do I go to you with everything? • Reggie Smith: For the permitting—it would be Joshua Lenio,but I will go back over that with you in detail. • Jeffrey Bumpus: Okay. Chairman Boyd called for a vote on the motion. Motion carried, 5— "Iles"/,l-- "No." Mr. Jerulle was opposed. X. PUBLIC HEARING: (Note: The individuals who testified in the following cases under Item X, "Public Hearings,"were first sworn in by the Attorney for the Board.) A. Case#2015-07: The Collier County Board of County Commissioners vs. Stephen Purciello—Misconduct of a State-Certified Building Contractor (Stephens Remodeling Co., d/b/a Certapro Painters of S1i'FL) (License Number: CBC 1250129) Chairman Boyd: We used to have a set way of conducting the Public Hearing. I don't have the instruction sheet. Evy Ybaceta: I will make sure I get it to you. (It was noted that a conversation between the Chairman and the Board's Attorney was off microphone—their comments were not on the record.) Richard Joslin directed his comment to the Board's Attorney: A little louder, please. (The microphone for the Board's Attorney was not turned on and his comments were not on the record.) (The microphone was turned on. The comments from the Board's Attorney were recorded in progress ...) Jed Schneck, Attorney for the Board: • ...these formal Rules of Evidence will not apply to these proceedings, but fundamental fairness and due process shall be observed and shall govern the proceeding. 3. Any of the Board Members may also question you. 4. The Chairman may conduct the proceedings. 13 DavisLi Ha From: Lenioloshua Sent: Tuesday,August 07, 2018 4:14 PM To: DavisLilla Subject FW: Meeting —Original Message--- From:Jeff[mailto:jbumpwatch@aol,com] Sent:Thursday,July 19,2018 10:58 AM To: LenioJoshua<Joshua.Lenio@colliercountyfi,gov> Cc: SmithReggie<Reggie.Smith@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Meeting Joshua ifs jeff from northern breeze any chance of meeting up with you today or tomorrow go over some repermitting Sent from my iPhone Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 /6\ DavisLilla From: Lenioioshua Sent Tuesday,August 07,2018 4:14 PM To: DavisLilla Subject: FW: Meeting ----Original Message---- From:Jeff[mailto:jbumpwatch@aol.com] Sent:Thursday,July 19,201811:12 AM To: Lenioloshua<Joshua.Lenio@colliercountyfl.gov> Subject: Meeting Ok i*II stop over after 10 tomorrow Sent from my iPhone Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 DavisLilla From: LenioJoshua Sent Tuesday,August 07,2018 4:14 PM To: DavisLilla Subject: FW: Meeting ---Original Message---- From:Jeff[mailto:jbumpwatch@aol.com] Sent: Friday,Juty 20,2018 9:43 AM To:Lenioioshua<Joshua.Lenio@colliercountyf.gov> Subject: Meeting Can't make meeting en route to sanibel wife has car issue Sent from my iPhone Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Davisl_illa From: Lenioloshua Sent Tuesday,August 07, 2018 4:14 PM To: DavisLilia Subject FW: Meeting ----Original Message- From:Jeff[mailto:jbumpwatch@aol.com] Sent:Wednesday,August 01,20181:15 PM' To: Lenioloshua<.Joshua.Lenio@colliercountyfLgov> Subject: Meeting Due youhave any free time this afternoon to meet with me Jeff northern breeze Sent from my iPhone Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Davislilla From: SmithReggie Sent: Wednesday,AugustO1 2018 435 PM To: jbumpwatch©aol.com Cc: YbacetaEverildo; DavisLilla Subject: Upcoming Contractors' Licensing Board Hearing on 15 August, 2018 Importance: High Mr, Bumpus, This is a friendly reminder of the upcoming CLB meeting on 15 August,9am;in which the Board has directed your attendance for your testimony referencing your progress in abating the violations described in your case. Please call or write if you have any questions concerning this, Thanks. Respectfully, Reggie Smith Licensing Compliance Officer CA; Ceou tty GMD Operations NOTE Email Address Has Changed 2800 Horseshoe Dr.N.,Naples Florida 34104 Phone:239 252 2432 Fax:239 252 6928 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead.. contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 DavisLilla From: SmithReggie Sent: Tuesday,August 07,2018 2:26 PM To: DavisLilla Subject: FW: Bocc fya --Original Message-- From:Jeff[mailto:jbumpwatch@aol.com] Sent:Thursday,August02,2018 1:13 PM To:SmithReggie<Reggie.Smith@colliercountyfi.gov> Subject: Bocc I received your email still haven't got together with josh S emailed him yesterday didn't here back.We did have a meeting set up but had to make emergency trip to sanibel wife locked her keys in car. I am stoppingat county today to try and get some instructions on how to get permits maybe you will be there. Not sure about August meeting my birthday is the 14th and normally leave town. I'm on standby to fly to Arizona this month daughter is due to have a baby. So when it comes I'm gone.Jeff Sent from my iPhone Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 \%*1/4C) Permits By Contractor - NORTHERN BREEZE AIR CONDITIONING .. . Permit Number Full Address (Permit Declared Permit Status Apply Issued Expiration Type Valuation Date Date Date PRHV2014020328701 2325 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:4 Mechanical 3200 Cancelled 2/10/2014 2/1812014 08/1 7/2014 PRHV2015082590001 2036 Cascades DR,Unit:14 Mechanical 3500.Cancelled 8/11/2015 02/0.74616 PRHV2015041058101 6812 Pelican Bay BLVD .Mechanical 2800 Entered In Error 418/2015 10/05/2015 PRI4V2015041057601 6812 Pelican Bay BLVD Mechanical 2800 Entered In Error 418/2015 10/05/2015 PRHV2015051467901 810 Breakaway LN,Unit:204 Mechanical 4000 Expired : 5/11/2015" 6/16/2015 12/13/2015 PRHV2015113561901 770 Bentwater CR,Unit:102 Mechanical 3200 Expired 11/1212015 12/3/2015 05/31/2016 PRHV2015041056601 730 Bentwater CIR,Unit:204 Mechanical 3500 Expired 418/2015 4/14/2015 10/11/2015 PRHV2016052011701 705 Bentwater CIR Mechanical 4000 Expired 5/26/2016• 7/20/2016 01/16/2017 PRHV2016020635901 2415 Hidden Lake DR,Unit2 Mechanical 3500 Expired 2/25/2016 3/7/2016 09103/2016 PRHV2015041147701 2344 Magnolia LN,Unit:5 Mechanical 3000 Expired 4/15/2015 4/24/2015 10/21/2015 PRI-R014051285301 2332 Magnolia LN,Unit3 Mechanical 3000 Expired 5/9/2014 11/05/2014 PRI-42015113561601 2329 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:9 Mechanical 3200 Expired 11/12/2015 121312015 05/31/2016 PRHV2016051650201 2324 Hidden Lake bR,Unit:3 Mechanical 4200 Expired 5/23/2016 7/20/2016 01/16/2017 ' PRHV2016030838301 2004 Cascades DR,Unit:7 Mechanical 2900 Expired 3/10/2016 3/23/2016 09/19/2016 _. PRA V2615041158701 9937 Boca CIR Mechanical 3600 Finaled 4/15/2015 4/24/2015 10/2112015 PRI-IV2013020281001 7887 Vizcaya WAY Mechanical 8000 Finaled 2/7/2013 218/2013 08/1372013 PIRAV2613092260101 744neetine DRechanical - 441 4000 Finaled 9112/2013 9/20/2611 05/254015 PRHV2015041060601 6812 Pelican BeiBLVD Mechanical 2800 Finaled 4/8/2015 4/14/2015 01/06,2019 PRHY2012010054001 6812 Pelican Bay BLVD Mechanical 2600 Finaled 1/11/2012 1/11/2012 07/09/2012 ab02010090165ai 4845 Martinique WAY 'Mechanical 3600 Finaled 9/8/2010 9/8/2010 05/15/2016 , . PRO20140615043bl 2375 Bayou LN,Unit:3 Mechanical 500 Finaled 612/2014 8/2612014 04/274015 PRHV2013081937501 2372 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:6 Mechanical 2800 Finaled 8/7/2013 8/8/2013 08/19/2015 PRHV2015051711301 2348 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:6 Mechanical 2800 Finaled 5/29/2015 6/16/2015 01/05/2019 PR/41/20.16663178001 2036 Cascades DR,Unit:14 Mechanical 3500 Finaled 8/18/2016 8118/2016 02/18/2017 PRHV2013123100101 1715 Windy Pines DR,Unit:6 Mechanical , 3000 Finaled 12/17/2013 12127/2013 02/10/2016 PRHV2013081937701 2274 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:3 •Mechanical 2800 Inspections Completed 8/7/2013 8/8/2013 02/04/2014 PRHV2018084685401 2325 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:4 Mechanical 2800 Issued 8/2/2018 8/6/2018 02/02/2019 PRHV2013102488001 845 109th AVE N Mechanical 3300 Void 1017/2013 10/17/2013 04/15/2014 PRHV2013092374601 765 Bentwater CIR,Unit:201 Mechanical 4000 Void 9/23/2013 10/4/2013 04/02/2014 PRHV2013092374001 735 Bentwater CIR,Unit203 Mechanical 3200 Void 9123/2013 10/4/2013 04102/2014 PRHV2013102488501 705 Bentwater CIR Mechanical 3900 Void 10/7/2013 10/17/2013 04/15/2014 PRHV2014020329201 700 Bentwater Clii,Unit:102 Mechanical 3200 Void 2/1012014 2/14/2014 08/13/2014 PRHV2014092647401 692 Annemore LN Mechanical 3500 Void 9/18/2014 9/18/2014 03/17/2015 PRHV2014071949701 4976 Rustic Oaks CR Mechanical 3500 Void 7/10/2014 7/11/2014 01/07/2015 PRHV2013102621001 2420 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:4 Mechanical 3000 Void 10/21/2013 12/16/2011 06114'2014 PRHV2016093484801 2405 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:9 Mechanical 3000 Void 9/12/2016 03/11/2017 PRHV2016072877361 2378 Magnolia AVE,Unit 1----rmechanical 3000 Void7/28/2016 01/24/2017 . , 31 Permits By Contractor - NORTHERN BREEZE AIR CONDITIONING Permit Number Full Address Permit Declared Permit Status Apply Issued Expiration Type Valuation Date Date Date PRHV2016072769401 2370 Magnolia AVE,Unit:7 Mechanical 2800 Void 7/20/2016 01/16i2017 PRHV2015061895101 2365 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:4 Mechanical 2800 Void 6/16/2015 12/13/2015 PRHV2016072769801 2345 Magnolia LN,Unit:6 Mechanical 3000 Void 7/20/2016 01/16/2017 PRHV2014123554201 2345 Hidden Lake DR,uniiii Mechanical 3000 Void 12/23/2014 06/21/2015 PRHV2014061504001 2332 Magnolia LN,Unit3 Mechanical 200 Void 6/2/2014. 11129/2014 PRHV2015123783001 '2332 Magnolia LN,Unit2 Mechanical 4500 Void 12/4/2015 06/01/2016 PRHV2013102487901 2332 Magnolia LN,Unit:1 Mechanical 1800 Void 1017/2013 10/17/2013 04/15/2014 PRHV2015072242101 2329 Hidden Lake DR,Unit,5 Mechanical 2800 Void 7/8/2015. 01/04/2016 PRHV2014082213401 2285 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:7 Mechanical 2800 Void 8/5/2014 815/2014 0210112015 PRHV2014082459901 2265 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:8 Mechanical 3200 Void 8/28/2014 02/24/2015 PRHV2013681983201 2255 Linwood AVE Mechanical 3100 Void 8/13/2013 9/12/2013 03/11/2014 ,.. PRHV2015082761401 2100 Cascades DR,Unit:8 Mechanical 3000 Void 8/27/2015 02i23/2018‘ PRHV2016020385301 2004 Cascades DR,Unit:8 Mechanical 4100 Void 21812016 08/08/2016 PRED2016031066001 1685 Windy Pines DR,Unit:8 Mechanical 4000 Void 3/25/2016 09/24/2016 PRHV2016041214101 1665 Windy Pines DR,Unit:9 Mechanical 2800 Void 415/2016 10/02/2016 PRHV2014123554701 1645 Windy Pines DR,Unit:8 Mechanical 3000 Void 12/23/2014 0612112015 PRHV2014020329101 1645 Windy Pines DR,Unit:6 'Mechanical 3200 Void 2/10/2014 2/14/2014 08/13./2014' PRHV2015672242501 1645 Windy Pines DR,Unit:5 Mechanical 4000 Void _ 7/8/2015 01/04/2016 PRHV2014051502601 1615 Windy Pines DR,Unit:9 Mechanical 3000 Void 51362014 7/10/2014 01/06/2015 Pki4V2013123100401 1615 Windy Pines bR, Unit2 Mechanical 3000 Void 12/17/2013 12/27/2013 06/25/20.14 ‘1.%) MINUTES OF THE COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD August 15, 2018 Naples, Florida IX. OLD BUSINESS: A. Jeffrey Bumpus (d/b/a Northern Breeze) —Expired Permits Update Chairman Boyd called for Mr. Bumpus to take the stand and be sworn. Everildo Ybaceta noted Mr. Bumpus had been notified of the meeting. He called the office on August 14th and spoke to a member of Staff, stating that he would be in Tampa on August 15th and would not attend the meeting. In response to questions concerning whether the trip was due to a personal emergency, Mr. Ybaceta answered that Mr. Bumpus would be in Tampa through the weekend because it was his birthday. Everildo Ybaceta introduced Josh Lenio who is the Supervisor for extensions, cancellations and withdrawals. Josh Lenio and Contractors' Licensing Officer Reggie Smith were sworn. Terry Jerulle complimented Staff on the new format of the information packets provided to the Board members. Everildo Ybaceta stated Lilla Davis, Administrative Supervisor, was responsible for the packets. Chairman Boyd asked Mr. Smith to present his report. Reggie Smith stated Mr. Lenio would present his report concerning his efforts to bring the 10 expired permits and 30 void permits into compliance. Terry Jerulle asked Mr. Lenio to provide a description of his duties for the County. Joshua Lenio: I am the Administrative Supervisor of the Permit Cancellation and Re-Activation section in the Building Department. The group oversees all the open, expired and void permit applications. We help contractors and owner/builders see their permits through to completion. If a property is underneath a closing, we help the homeowners navigate their open or expired permits. Terry Jerulle: Is this a new position? Joshua Lenio: This is a new position within the Building Department. Joshua Lenio: • Jeffery Bumpus is the Qualifier for Northern Breeze Air Conditioning. • A report was run on May 15, 2018 as requested by Reggie Smith; 31 permits were listed as void. • The information was provided to Reggie Smith who provided it to the Board. • Another report was run prior to this meeting. Mr. Bumpus has modified four of the void permits and one of the expired permits for a total of 5 out of the original 41. • There is a difference between "void" and "expired"peuuits. 239 • Mr. Bumpus can do nothing for a void permit. He could submit a"cancellation" which states • that no work has been done or he could submit a re-application to obtain a new permit. • For an expired permit, Mr. Bumpus can submit an application for an extension. (Up to three extension are allowed—90-days each.) • The Building Official will decide if extension will be allowed for these permits. • There were originally 31 void permits. Currently, there are 27 void permits. • Mr. Bumpus was advised by Staff that it would be less expensive to submit a re-application for a new permit rather than to apply for an extension. • Currently there are 9 expired permits. • The four re-applications submitted by Mr. Bumpus two days earlier are under"review" status and no action has been taken. Mr. Lenio noted that most homeowners are not aware that they are responsible to schedule an inspection with the County. They have no idea what the requirements are to obtain a Certificate of Occupancy. He stated it would be better for the homeowners if Mr. Bumpus followed each permit through to completion even though his efforts have been minimal. Vice Chairman Lantz: Do any of these homeowners know that this is going on with their places? Joshua Lenio: Not that I am aware. Everildo Ybaceta: When he initially came before the Board, he did state that he would pull the permits and then ask the homeowners to call in for an inspection. Matthew Nolton: I remember him stating that he couldn't be there for each inspection—that's why they were to call in for an inspection ... so the homeowner could be there and give the inspector access to the property. Is he still actively pulling permits? Everildo Ybaceta: No, not that I am aware. Reggie Smith: The last permit that he applied for was in 2016. He also stated in other meetings before the Board that he is out of the installation business—he has his State license as an A/C Contractor to perform repairs that do not require obtaining a permit, he operates a Home Watch service, and works as a handyman in various communities. Patrick White: I think the dilemma we faced previously was if the Board tried to impose any type of Sanctions, it would decrease the probability that Mr. Bumpus would go through the process to properly close out the permits. I am not sure where we are without the benefit of Mr. Bumpus to give us any assurance—other than his birthday was more important than his work obligations. Richard Joslin: Since he is a State-certified Contractor, there's not a whole lot of Sanctions that the Board can impose—correct? He's not pulling permits anymore. Terry Jerulle: Can I make an observation? Have you offered him any type of solution with the inspections? What I'm trying to say is ... if I am him and I'm going to paraphrase: I'm semi-retired and don't care about the past and I'm just going to do what I want to do in the future ... and the you guys can't do anything to me because I'm retired and have a State license and I'm not going to pull any more permits. So, what's the incentive for me to get this done? Everildo Ybaceta: Sadly, I do agree with that. Terry Jerulle: So ... thinking out loud ... can you offer him an Inspector for a day to go to all these different places to try to ... instead of having the homeowners call in the old-fashioned way ... where they will show up between 8:00 am and 12:00 Noon ... have him go to ...? Patrick White: I think the issue is that it's possible, perhaps, with the expired permits but I think that the problem is that you would have to pay for the 27 void permits that need to be renewed. Terry Jerulle: I think we should get the expired ones. Richard Joslin: There are dollars and cents that probably could be worked out. If I remember correctly when this all came about and there were those 10 permits that he said he was going to get straightened out, the question did come up ... was the County going to work with him as far as the inspections go? And the answer, I believe, was "yes" at the time. It does not sound, in my opinion, as 140 if they are putting him in a win-win situation. As Terry said, what's his incentive to get this done if he still has to go through all the hoops to try to get permits for systems that have been in these homes for how many years and are still working? Everildo Ybaceta: Obviously we ... the situation here is, no matter what, the contractor always has some responsibility to re-activate the permit and once he re-activates the permit then, yes, -- and I've done it before because in my previous life I was in his shoes [indicating Joshua Lenio] —I can request that an Inspector to go out to the property the following day. I believe now that we have a dedicated Inspector—or you did have— Joshua Lenio: The County has contracted with NOVA; we now have an Inspector who helps us with the expired permits but is specific to residential only—not commercial. We would use the County's Inspectors for commercial or multi-family. Everildo Ybaceta: In every way, yes, we are willing to work with the contractor—we have always been willing to work with the contractor. The County is always trying to put its best foot forward here to work with contractors and to get the homeowner that Certificate of Completion. Patrick White: What opportunities are there—what options exist relative to the void permits? I recognize the County's commitment to support and your flexibility, and I commend it. My understanding of the bigger problem—percentage-wise and number- wise—is with the void permits and the process that exits. From my understanding, it seems to handcuff the County relative to what options exist to deal with void permits that don't involve greater costs to Mr. Bumpus in order to re-invigorate those permits. I'm just trying to be creative. Joshua Lenio: With all due respect, that's a conversation for the Building Official to make that call rather than myself. Patrick White: Relative to the Building Official's discretion afforded under the Building Code, is it your understanding that he has some capability to handle a void permit in a fashion other than renewing the peuniit at the existing fee established for the permit? Joshua Lenio: Yes, in certain circumstances—but each one is case-by-case. I have seen where void permits have been reinstated to where the County allowed the contractor to pursue it ... given certain circumstances. Patrick White: Based on your experience and degree of familiarity with the void permits, do you feel that it would be advantageous for Mr. Bumpus to have that conversation with the Building Official? Joshua Lenio: I do. Patrick White: Okay. Matthew Nolton: It seems to me there are two issues here: one is all these permits and the individual owners and how to resolve that—and the Building Official certainly can waive that fee. He's done it before—I've been involved when he's done that, so he can do that. The County has an issue in that it allowed these permits to be out there and not hold this guy accountable for them. The County has a reason to want to waive the fee and get them resolved for the homeowners. Mr. Bumpus doesn't get to go "scot-free"—we, as a Board, need to resolve him once and for all. We keep kicking that can down the road for thirty or sixty days. We do have the ability to make a recommendation to the State—and even ask the State for a fine—we can ask that. So, there are two parts to this for the Board to look at, I think. Patrick White: We can't get blood from a turnip. Matthew Nolton: I understand that—but to resolve it once and for all ... Patrick White: I understand and what I was hoping to be able to fashion was the type of conversation between Mr. Bumpus and those in the County who have a familiarity with the specific sets of permits to derive a mechanism where he, Mr. Bumpus, would be more inclined to participate in an effective way if we gave him some encouragement to do so. I understand the potential of"the stick" may help to encourage him. But at the end of the day, having seen Mr. Bumpus live and at the podium, I think he would react negatively. I think it would be just a ... Terry Jerulle: And what's the point? Patrick White: How many times do you want to be ... Terry Jerulle: We must draw a red line and not move it. Nothing is happening. He may be out there working, and a lot of people today check-up on people simply by using Google. If we can make his life uncomfortable by doing some sort of public notice and saying something to the State, so when people google his name—they may not use him in the future. Because he's out there working—doing maintenance—I think we should let people know that, well, he's not one of the good guys. Matthew Nolton: And the State—if we made the recommendation to remove his license—he wouldn't be doing maintenance anymore ... correct? He wouldn't have any license, so he couldn't work in air-conditioning. Everildo Ybaceta: It's a Catch-22 no matter what ... at what point do you let these permits continue to fly ... the residents at some point will have to work on these permits. If they want to sell their property and they have an expired permit, it falls on them. So, you have to weigh the options here. I agree with you ... you've kicked the can, and this will be the third time that you're gonna kick it down the road. Terry Jerulle: You're assuming? I'm not ... I'm done with Mr. Bumpus. Everildo Ybaceta: You're right—I am assuming. Terry Jerulle: I'm done with it. Matthew Nolton: Wait a minute. The problem with kicking it down the road is why would we expect anything different to happen unless the County is going to say, "Okay, we'll waive all these fees—we'll fill out the forms for you—we'll do most of the work for you." Why would we expect anything different? Reggie Smith: I'd like to remind the Board that, initially, Mr. Bumpus thought he could tackle the permits within a month—30 days. We talked him into taking 60 days. When he came before the Board again, he had some applications made, I think. I had testified that he may need longer than 60 days because at some point most of residents were seasonal and would not return to provide access to the units until the fall. Since then, I had a conversation with Mr. Bumpus who maintained he could accomplish this before the fall because of his Home Watch business—he claims he has access. Patrick White asked if the County had a recommendation. Reggie Smith: I am not ready to say anything specific but if there is some way that the Board could put a timeframe on getting these done and if the time limit expires, then bring him back before the Board to ... Patrick White: I would be very happy to "draw a line in the sand," and the consequence would be whatever Sanctions we could impose—automatically occurring if it's not done. Reggie Smith: In my mind, it's more than just allowing him to try to solve these issues for these homeowners and it's not just for when they want to resell their properties—it's more serious than that. You may have an a/c unit that was installed several years ago and is still running fine, but if it still hasn't passed an inspection, you will have insurance issues. What people may not realize is when we are done with this case, the permits will be turned over to the Building Official to send to the Code Enforcement department and they will become Code Enforcement cases with violations against the property owners. If they attempt to sell the property, the homeowners will be forced to hire another contractor and pay the fees ... Patrick White: I am aware of that and have sought to try to avoid that consequence for the homeowner. But I think the point that Mr. Nolton makes is a very valid point. It isn't a perspective that I've thought much about before, but it really resonated strongly with me today. I say this in the open forum having been a former County employee that there is an obligation, I think, on the County's part relative to closing the loop with the homeowner that the permits are either going to expire or become void. It's in the County's own best interest to have the permits closed out because that's the governmental service of health/safety/welfare that the County is in business to provide. To have allowed contractors to "get away with it"—so to speak—is a problem shared by the County and the community of contractors because it involves the homeowners. From my perspective, I am very appreciative that Josh has the job that he has and that the County is making those efforts—that's going in the right direction. But my recommendation is that we find a way to be more programmatic when • dealing with contractors about getting them into a position to be able to resolve these things with the least amount of cost and effort. Joshua Lenio: To speak to your point, Mr. White, more recently I've had discussions with Evy and management within the Building Department because a lot of the times, as with Mr. Bumpus, the process is reactive. We are looking at implementing newer practices to address the old and to maintain the new. The direction into which that is going to go is still up in the air, but we are starting a trend to formalize some practice. Patrick White: I am encouraged to hear that. Thank you. Vice Chairman Lantz: I've done work not just in Collier County but all over the State. Maybe 10 or 12 years ago, I had a job in the City of Naples and I let the permit expire. I went to get an inspection on another peiuiit, but it was not allowed—I couldn't do it. If you had an expired permit you couldn't get an inspection or apply for a permit or receive a permit—you couldn't do anything until the expired permit was fixed. The City of Naples would not let me get 3 —4—5— 10—40 permits down the road. About two years ago, I did a job in Estero. It took a bit longer and the permit expired while we were still doing the work,but I didn't get an extension. Tom DeGram, the Building Official, sent a "love letter" to the homeowner—but not to me—and it said that the homeowner would have problems if the expired permit issue wasn't resolved right away. Let me tell you—my phone rang pretty quick! I went in, paid the $50 fee, and got it. If Collier County sent out 49 "love letters"—and made that a practice for the future—49 homeowners will be calling Mr. Bumpus and telling him to get his butt in gear. Maybe that's better than the seven of us telling him the same thing one day every month. If the homeowners are calling him all the time, telling him to get this straight, it might solve the problem. Patrick White: And they [the homeowners] have the capacity to create other legal issues for him that will have cost consequences beyond the mere licensure. Matthew Nolton: Even if they all wanted to take him to Small Claims Patrick White: Exactly. Vice Chairman Lantz: If they all called him once a week, that's enough to drive him nuts! Sometimes, that's all it takes—enough harassment to ... Patrick White: Encourage him. Richard Joslin: I think since the March meeting that he was originally in here for, we have given him —what— 120 days to try to get this handled? He's only done 5 permits. Matthew Nolton: And 4 were in the last two days! Richard Joslin: Yeah. I think it is time that the Board probably stops fooling around and just makes the recommendations that we need to make. Terry Jerulle: You bring up a very good point, Mr. Lantz. Josh, have the home-owners been notified of these permits? The answer is no? Everildo Ybaceta: The homeowner is not ultimately the owner of the permit. Terry Jerulle: Why don't we .... why can't we ... Patrick White: The County's current practice is that the homeowner will find out if it elevates to the level of a Code case and it goes from, effectively, Contractors' Licensing to Building Permitting to Code compliance/Code Enforcement. Reggie White: It's the level of responsibility—it's the contractor's responsibility at this point. Everildo Ybaceta: And the other issue with that is ... in Josh's defense ... you have how many staff? Terry Jerulle: You don't have to defend him ... we're not ... Everildo Ybaceta: He has a staff of three to deal with all of the items that he's dealing with and if we have to add more staffing just to contact the homeowners ... at the end of the day here, we're going to be affected by it. Terry Jerulle: It's just a form letter. Vice Chairman Lantz: If you had done this 47 permits ago, we probably wouldn't be 49 permits into it now. And maybe he'd be able to get by with only two people on his staff. Patrick White: I think everyone understands that and our responsibility today is to deal with one individual and to try to set what I consider to be the right balance of encouragement versus threat. The �3 only way I know how to do that would be by way of a motion that would—I don't know if the right word is "continue" the matter for 60 days and, at that time, if the void and expired permits are not addressed completely, the Board will impose Sanctions. I would ask Mr. Schneck to let us know what are the options that we have relative to the Sanctions ... I know we reviewed them once before but if you could refresh our memories. Attorney Schneck: The Sanctions that may be imposed upon a State-certified contractor are limited to: • Revoking the contractor's permit-pulling privileges; • Placing conditions upon the contractor's permit-pulling privileges; • Sending a written recommendation to the State requesting review and further action Chairman Boyd: Can we revoke his ability to even work in the County? Attorney Schneck: No, we cannot. Assistant County Attorney Noell stated he thought it would be beneficial to schedule a meeting so he could explain to Mr. Bumpus the ramifications of his actions concerning the void and expired permits and explain what the County's recommendation to the Board would mean to him. He also thought it would be beneficial for Mr. Ybaceta and him to speak with a State Investigator to discuss the case and what the Investigator intends to do concerning the Board's recommendation. He further stated he hoped meeting with Mr. Bumpus to explain the gravity of the situation and the number of permits involved would be the leverage needed to convince him to close out the permits. If Mr. Bumpus does not comply, Mr. Noell will explain that the County will pursue every option available as well as explaining the level of Sanctions the Board will impose. Attorney Noell further recommended that the Board should red-line a date for compliance and if the date is not met, the County will present its recommendations to the Board. Patrick White: What is the difference be between that and a recommendation from the County to continue for 30 days for you to have that conversation with a clear expression—and I'm not trying to pre judge the matter as to when it would be heard next—that the strong probability is that this Board will, at that point, impose a 30-day time limit. And thereafter, the Sanctions that are available to the Board will be imposed. Assistant County Attorney Noell: Your approach, Mr. White, would be the better approach because we would find out where Mr. Bumpus is when we explain the exposure to him. If he decides not to show for that meeting, then it gives us a much quicker avenue to come before this Board. Patrick White: I think we're talking about the same time frames—at least in my mind—I don't want to speak for the Board members—but I would like to see this thing done and over from our perspective in no more than 60 days. I would not have an issue if Mr. Bumpus failed to respond or participate. You could come back in 30 days from now and I think we would be done with this case. Richard Joslin: Would it be advisable to have the Building Official at that meeting? Assistant County Attorney Noell: I would recommend a Continuance for 30 days. I would not want to set a deadline of sixty days ... Patrick White: Right—it would give him more time to just goof off... Assistant County Attorney Noell: If we set the Continuance for 30 days, then we can come back with either a full recommendation or the status of how things have changed. Terry Jerulle: I don't disagree with anything that has been said but—in my mind—if I'm a homeowner and County and the Contractors' Licensing Board have been talking about these permits for months,but no one has told me that I have a problem with my air-conditioner, I would be upset. Right? If there any reason why we can't do a form letter to the residents to let them know there is a problem with their inspection? Everildo Ybaceta: It's never been done. Terry Jerulle: You're saying Collier County hasn't done it, but it's been done in other counties. Matthew Nolton: The question was—is there any reason why we can't— and I didn't hear you say, "no." It's just about manpower. • Everildo Ybaceta: I can't answer that portion of it because I would need to meet with Managers and Directors to see how they would want to handle that. Assistant County Attorney Noell: I think there could be potential legal issues involved with that, for example, if we called an individual and the County made a mistake because their permit was fine ... Terry Jerulle: With a form letter, you will know what permits are not closed. Assistant County Attorney Noell: I understand. Terry Jerulle: The address is on the peunit ... Assistant County Attorney Noell: Right. Terry Jerulle: ... you just take that information and send a form letter ... Assistant County Attorney Noell: I understand how to do it, yes. Terry Jerulle: ... it's a simple ... Matthew Nolton: Are you worried about the accuracy of the data? Assistant County Attorney Noell: Not only that, but my issue now becomes a legal issue that I would need to think through and would probably need to do some research on it because what then happens is that we, as a County,become more proactive into individual permits with individual owners on a level that may be one step too far where the onus starts to become on us to ensure that a contractor is doing what he is supposed to be doing what the Board holds him to do. When the County starts taking on that kind of a duty—in this case, it may be completely fine—I like the idea of that ... the County is not against it ... I just need to look at the legalities of if we are taking on an affirmative role of doing that kind of a job ... Patrick White: If I'm representing Mr. Bumpus as an attorney, my argument would be that the County has somehow interfered with the procedural due process rights he has to close those permits out, and have now put my client, Mr. Bumpus, in a position where he is being sued by a homeowner. Terry Jerulle: You've come up with a reason not to do anything. Assistant County Attorney Noell: Oh, no ... no ... Patrick White: I was ready to make a motion, Mr. Jerulle. Terry Jerulle: You were asking us for our opinions. My opinion is to do the letter. Listen, if it doesn't get settled here, it will go to Code Enforcement or Code Compliance—is that what we said ... correct? Patrick White: It can. Terry Jerulle: So, what's going to happen then? The same thing, right? Assistant County Attorney Noell: I advise the Code Enforcement Board and I prosecute cases before that Board. There are outliers in every system so if you have a big funnel where the standard violations—people who knowingly do it—homeowners who knowingly allow it, you have this big filter. And in every situation—this is a great example—you have certain outliers and you look at those on a case-by-case basis, but the challenge legally is to apply the same law to the outlier and there is a level of"wiggle room" that's allowable. But when you start to get into the issues that we are talking about the risk from an attorney—and not just because we don't want to it—the risk is we start taking on affirmative duties to get in between a contractor and the homeowner. At that kind of a level, one of the risks that the County faces is that the County becomes judge,jury, and executioner. This case involves violations. The Board has not yet made its determination—because it has been continued. I'm not saying that this is why we would not do it—I need to research it, so I can advise my client— Collier County Board of County Commissioners—so I don't subject the County to a lawsuit because we have become too aggressive—that's all I'm saying. Matthew Nolton: And that could be crafted into the letter—just a simple letter saying, "Hey, Homeowner, we are notifying you that you have an expired permit or one that is void which could be an issue in the future ... Patrick White: I think we are well past"could." Matthew Nolton: Fine. Patrick White: I think it's a fact, and I think that's what Mr. Noell is saying. And there's nothing as a directive from this Board simply by agreeing to continue this case for thirty days that precludes the County from doing that. I don't think we have the jurisdiction to order but if I were in Mr. Noell's 1``-) shoes, I certainly would take it under advisement as a tool to address those outliers. Believe me, I've been in his chair relative to the prosecution of those cases—hundreds of them—and I understand what the challenges are. To find a way past, that's what I've always sought to do on this Board. Matthew Nolton: What is more concerning for me—I don't know if this is an outlier. Josh, how many permits do you have in the County right now that are void or expired? The last I knew it was 30,000. Joshua Lenio: The figure is 77,000. Matthew Nolton: 77,000. As a matter of fact, the guy that didn't come today—I looked him up and he's got a whole bunch listed as expired. We let him off on one,but he's got the same condition it seems like when I looked at his record. This isn't an outlier to me. It's a problem that the County has allowed to happen through the years. I understand—two different systems and everything—but somehow, the County must figure out how it is going to handle that monster once and for all so that we can get through it. Assistant County Attorney Noe11: I agree with you. When I use the term, "outlier," what I'm saying is ... at the level of the County Attorney's Office addressing it—to my knowledge—this is the first time somebody with 44 expired permits on an issue and a desire to have people come into compliance —the fact that it is at this level, for me, is an outlier. I don't deal in the world of issuing permits— that's not my function. Your point is well taken. I think Evy and his staff have addressed the proactive nature now of what they are trying to do to close out these permits and closing this procedural loop hole. With that is going to come more of these things. I need to make sure legally that we are on solid ground as we put a procedure in place to close them and that we're also exerting the proper legal leverage to get them closed or to figure out if someone is just stalling. We're going to move forward with a strong recommendation to the Board and a strong recommendation to the State. Patrick White: Having been the attorney who helped negotiate the contracts for a lot of the databases that are currently being used, I understand that it was a problem that couldn't exist in the past when it was a far more paperwork-driven system. So, the efficiency of the newer databases to be able to track and provide the information that Josh has shared with us is a good thing. But what's come from the "good thing" is the cottage industry in the real estate market where there's this opportunity for people to hold up a closing and gain the advantage of having the permit properly closed out, which I think is certainly appropriate. I think we're struggling with how to solve a problem that only computers have helped us to create. Chairman Boyd: Mr. White, you never did make your motion—Mr. Jerulle stopped you. Patrick White: I did make the motion. Chairman Boyd: You did? Patrick White moved to approve continuing the hearing of Case#2018-04: Jeffery Bumpus— Misconduct of a State-certified Contractor to the September meeting. Richard Joslin: That's thirty days. Patrick White: Yes. Terry Jerulle: Are we having a meeting next month? Everildo Ybaceta: Yes, sir. Richard Joslin offered a Second in support of the motion. Motion carried; the vote was 5— "Yes"12 — "No." Chairman Boyd and Terry Jerulle were opposed. • Permits By Contractor - Northern Breeze As of September 12,2018 Permit Number Full Address i Permit Type.Permit Apply Date Issued Date Expiration• Status Date . .. g PRHY2016020635901 ;2415 Hidden Lake DRTUnit:2 i Mechanical ICancelled ! 2/25/2016; 3/7/26167 :-.69/03/2616. • PRHV2015082590001 2036 Cascades OR,Unit:14 :Mechanical Cancelled 8/1112015 02/07/2116 . / PRHV2015072242501 1645 Windy Pines DR,Unit:5 :Mechanical Cancelled 7/8/2015 ; 01/04/2016. !PRHV2014051502601 1615 Windy Pines DR,Unit:9 Mechanical ;;Cancelled 5/30/2014: 7/10/20141 01/06/2015' PRHV2014020329iii 1645 Windy Pines DR,Unit:6 Mechanical Cancelled 2/1012014, 2/14120147- 08/13/2014 PRHV2014020328701 :2325 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:4 Mechanical 1Cancelled I 2/10/2014' 2/18/2014, 08/17/2614: ORHV2015041058101 6812 Pelican Bay BLVD Mechanical F.-Entered In Error ; 4/8/2015 i 10/05/2015: PRHV2015041057501 6812 Pelican Bay BLVD Mechanical Entered In Error ; 4/8/2015 ; 10105/20151 ,... 'IPRHV2018664855401 :1645 Windy Pines DR,Unit:5 Mechanical iFinaled 8/14/2018 9/6/2018 03/06/2019: TORHV2018084855301 1645 Windy Pines DR,Unit:6 Mechanical f,Finaled . 8114/2018 916/2018: 03/06/2019: . , PRHV2018084855201 :1615 Windy Pines DR,Unit:9 I Mechanical ;;Finaled . 8E4/2018- 9/6/2018 03/06/20191 'Oft:Iii2016664655101 2415 Hidden Lake DR,.Unit2 1Mechanical :Finaled 8/14/2018 9/6/2018 03/06/2019' FRZTI-V-2016-664685401 -;2325 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:4 Mechanical 1Finaled , 8/2/2018 --- 8/67-26-117 ---62/09/2-0-4; " PRHV2016083178001 2036 Cascades DR,Unit:14 -"Mechanical Finaled : 8/18/2016:-- 8/1 8/28161 02)18/2017 ORI-ohoi 506V711301 ;2348 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:6 Mechanical Finaled • • . 5/29/2015 6/1612015, 01/05/2019: I OiRHV2015041158761 9937 Boca CIR Mechanical Finaled ; 4/15/2015 4/24/2015i: -10/21/20151 TID-fiill;ii6 10-km1 6812 Pelican Bay BLVD Mechanical :Finaled 4/8/2015 4E4/2015: 01/08/2019 i6kciii20-1a I 80-4301— -:2375 Bayou LN,Unit:31- - :Mechanical Finaled 6/2/2014 8/26/2014: 04/27/2015: I , •,._ „ 13FtHV2013123100161 i1715 Windy Pines DR,Unit:6 IMechanical !Finaled : 12/17/2013 12/27/2013; 02/10/2016: Fi3iiii:iii616-6-42'286101 :7444 Treeline DR : Mechanical Finaled . 9/12/2013 9/2012013 05/25/2015 , . - PRHV2-6136-61637501 2372 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:6 !Mechanical 1Finaled : ' 8/7/2013 8/8/2013 06/19/2015 PfiHV20f6020281001 ;7667 Vizcaya WAY Mechanical ;Finaled 2/7/2013 2/8/2013, 08/13/2013; , 1-F3kITV26-12610054001 6812 Pelican Bay BLVD i Mechanical -!Finaled - !-- 1/11/2012 -. 1/11/2012: 07/09/2012: Tb-O-02016-0603-3501-- (.4845 Martinique WAY • Mechanical Finaled 9/8/2010' 9/8/2010 05/15/2016. —.________.........__ .........____ PRHV2013081937701 !2274 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:3 i Mechanical :Inspections 8f7/2013 8/8/2013 02/04/2014: ;Completed . PRHV2016052011701 :7:-76-5 Bentwater CIR Mechanical I Reactivate 5/26/2016: 7/20/2016 12/07/2018 PRA-V261-6-0-51959201 :2324 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:3 ;Mechanical Reactivate 5/23/2016: 7/20/2016! 12108/2018: l'014-f-iChoi 6030838301 2004 Cascades DR,Unit:7 Mechanical Reactivate 1 3/10/2016 3/23/2016! 12/08/2018: P jifii:iii2016113561901 770 Bentwater CIR,Unit:102 Mechanical Reactivate 11/12/2015; 12/3/2015 12/07/2018: PA-AV/161:5113561501 2329. Hidden Lake- DR,Linit:9 Mechanical Reactivate ; -1-1E272015: 12/3/2-615: 12/07/201-6-i , 46.-V-2615061467901 810 Breakaway LN,Unit:204 Mechanical Reactivate 5/11/2015 6/16/2015 12/08/2018: i PRHV2015041147701 2344 Magnolia LN,Unit:5 IMechanical I Reactivate 4/15/2015! 4/24/2015: 12/08/2018; • , , : PRi-V2615041056601 730 Bentwater CIR,Unit:204 :Mechanical 1Reactivate 4/8/2015. 4/14/2015. 12107/2018: PRHV2014051285301 2332 Magnolia IN,Unit:3 'Mechanical i Reactivate • 5/9/2014 12/07/2018' PRHV2018095289201 2265 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:8 Mechanical :Ready for • 9/10/2018 : 03/11/2019 PRHV2018095289101 2420 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:4 Mechanical •Ready for 9/102018. ! 03/11/2019 PRHV2016095289001 f2365 Hidden Lake OR,Unit:4 Mechanical Ready for 9/10/2018 ! 03/11/2019 ;PRHV2018095211901 :2329 Hidden Lake OR,Unit:-5 Mechanical 'Ready for 1 9/10/2018 . ; 03/11/2019 , ,• _ _ • _______ __ ________ PRHV201809528886T 11615 Windy Pines DR,Unit:2 :Mechanical Ready for 9/10/2018 ; 03/11/2019; PRHV2018095288701 - :1-646 Windy Pines DR,Unit:8 ' Mechanical----Ae-idy for 9/10/2018 ; 03/11/20191 PRHV2018648iiss&if • 1865 Windy Pines DR,Unit:9 1Mechanical l'Ready icr 9E6/2018: "- - r. --6/11/2616. riiiii:iiiiii i 13-646idiiiii---1 21 oo-Cascades b-R,Unit ' r 6-/10/2018 -------- --::T'--- 03iiii2iS19! PRHV2018095288001 2370 Magnolia AVE,Unit:7 Mechanical !Ready for 9/10/2018 03/11/2019 PRHV2018095267601 692 Annemore LN Mechanical I Ready for 9/10/2018, ; 03i11/2619i L41 Permits By Contractor - Northern Breeze As of September 12,2018 Permit Number i Full Address Permit Type:Permit Apply Date Issued DatelExpiration Status Date . - OR14V.2016093482901 2405 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:9 Mechanical ;Void 9/12/2016 : 03/11/20171 : . PRHV2016072877301 .2378 Magnolia AVE,Unit:1 Mechanical :Void 7128/2016 , 01/2412011 f=i41W2616072769801 12345 Magnolia LN,Unit:6 T,4echanical -Void 7/20/2016 ; 01/1612017; PRHV2016072769401 2370 Magnolia AVE,Unitf7 Mechanical Void 7/20/2016 1 01/16/2617 l'POcii2016041214101 1665 Windy Pines DR,Unit:9 'Mechanical Void 4/5/2016 --- ; 10/02/2016; PR6b201666.11666.061 7685 Windy Pines DR,Unit:8 Mechanical Void 3/25/2016 i 09/24/2018"; PRI-111E16020385301 ;2004 Cascades DR,Unit8 :Mechanical Void • 2/8/2016 ! 08/08/2016. [P.RHV2015123783001 ;2332 Magnolia LN,Unit:2 i Mechanical 2Void , • 12/4/2015 06/01/2016; ; • ; 031-1V2015082761401 ;2100 Cascades DR,Unit:8 IMechanical ;Void 8/2712015 - 02/23/2016 r , :PRHV2015072242101 2329 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:5 !Mechanical -Void i 7/8/2015 01/64/2616i TPRHV2015061895101 2365 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:4 •Mechanical Void 6/16/2015 12/13/2015: i; • I PRHV2014123554701 1645 Windy Pines DR,Unit:8 Mechanical Void 12/23/2014 06/21/2015' iPRFIV2014123554201 .2345 Hidden Lake OR,Unit:1 :Mechanical Void 12/23/2014 06/21/2015 PRHV2014092647401 692 Annemore LN Mechanical :Void 9/18/2014 9/18/2014 03/17/2015: PRHV2014082459901 2265 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:8 Mechanical !Void I 8/28/2014 02/24/2015 :.PRHV2014082213401 ;2285 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:7 , !Mechanical Void 815/2014 8/5/2014 02/01/2015! . I PRHV2014071949701 :49.76 Rustic Oaks CIR !Mechanical ;Void i 7/10/2014. 7/11/2014' 01/07/2015: PRHV2014061504001 „2332 Magnolia LN,Unit:3 Mechanical Void ! 6/2/2014 ; 11/29/2014 . • PRHV2014020329201 .700 Bentwater CIR,Unit:102 ;Mechanical !Void 2/10/2014 2/14/2014 08/13/20141 • , ., PRHV2013123100401 11615 Windy Pines DR,Unit:2 Mechanical :Void 12/17/2013 12/27/2013- 06/25/20141 PRHV2013102621001 ;2420 Hidden Lake OR,Unit:4 Mechanical Void 10/21/2013 12/16/2013. 06/1412014 PRHV2013102488501 705 Bentwater CIR Mechanical .'.Void i 1 0/7/20 1 3 10/17/20131 04/15/2014 PFil-11./2013.102488001 ;845 109th AVE N Mechanical !Void i 10/7/2013 16/17/2013 04/15/2014: PRHV2013102487901 2332 Magnolia LN,Unit:1 f Mechanical i Void 10M2013, 10/17/2013 04/15/2014 PRHV2013092374601 :765 Bentwater CIR,Unit201 Mechanical Void 7 4/23/2013 1.074/2012 04/0272014i — . 4)41-112013092374061 735BaniwaterCIR,Va203 !Mechanical I Void 9/23103 161=iTiofii- aloWirm 4; i i ffiiV2013081e83201 2255 Linwood AVE Mechanical !Void ! 8/13/2013 9/12/2013 03111/2014: /4 ‘, • MINUTES OF THE COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD September 19, 2018 Naples, Florida VIII. OLD BUSINESS: A. Jeffrey Bumpus—Misconduct of State-Certified Contractor: Expired Permits Update (d/b/a "Northern Breeze Air Conditioning, Inc.) Chairman Boyd asked Everildo Ybaceta for an update. Everildo Ybaceta: We—Assistant County Attorney Kevin Noell, Contractor's Licensing Compliance Officer Reggie Smith, Joshua Lenio, and I—met with Mr. Bumpus to discuss his lack of progress. We also discussed the timeline and a finite number of days to accomplish clearing the permits. Mr. Bumpus stated he could work with the timeline and the County's expectations. Mr. Ybaceta continued: Since the meeting, Mr. Bumpus has come into the office quite a bit. He has met with Mr. Lenio who will give us an update. Assistant County Attorney Noell: I think it was clear through our conversation that Mr. Bumpus was able to see the bigger picture. Richard Joslin asked when Mr. Bumpus was required to wrap up—he understood that Staff was working with Mr. Bumpus to expedite the processing of the permits but stated something needed to be resolved after over six months because the homeowners still had expired, open permits. He asked Staff if the homeowners had been contacted. Everildo Ybaceta: No, we have not contacted them yet. It is difficult because we would have to find the homeowners and their telephone numbers. It is possible that ownership of a property may have changed several times already. The County does not have correct information but could issue a letter of explanation. Vice Chairman Lantz: Are you saying the County will do that or ...? Everildo Ybaceta: At the Board's discretion, I can but it is difficult to do. Assistant County Attorney Noell: That's one of the issues that the County will look at because I'm sure, as the Board knows, and as difficult as this is to say—it's also the homeowners' responsibility. Obviously, in this situation, we don't want to put that type of onus on the homeowner, who may be less sophisticated than the contractor, to make sure that permit was closed-out and the contractor was doing his/her job. There are a number of expired permits in the system to be addressed. Additional staff is needed to filter through the permits. There has been some movement and Mr. Bumpus was advised of today's hearing. Vice Chairman Lantz asked how many inspections have been called in to date. There was a discussion between the Board members and the Staff: • Concerning how Jeffrey Bumpus could obtain access to the various properties to allow inspections to take place. It was noted he was a property manager for the two communities involved. • When asked if Mr. Bumpus had renewed his license, Everildo Ybaceta stated he had not seen a renewal but would check on the status of Mr. Bumpus' license. • Chairman Boyd noted Mr. Bumpus would need a current license to pull new permits or reactive expired permits. • It was further noted that since Mr. Bumpus is a state-certified contractor, he would normally renew with the State of Florida before he renewed with Collier County. 49 • Assistant County Attorney Noell stated since the goal was compliance and the close-out of • the permits, the County would not have taken an action on Mr. Bumpus' license for the sake of the homeowners. • Everildo Ybaceta confirmed that Jeffrey Bumpus did renew his license with the State of Florida. Joshua Lenio and Reggie Smith were sworn in by the Attorney for the Board. Joshua Lenio explained there were nine expired permits which the County re-opened. He stated a few modifications were made to allow Ms. Bumpus to schedule inspections without paying additional fees. Inspections had been scheduled by the County, but Mr. Bumpus was not comfortable with the dates and cancelled them. Of the nine permits that were in "Ready for Issuance" status, only two inspections have been completed. Mr. Lenio further explained of the twenty-seven permits which were in "void" status, Mr. Bumpus has re-applied for fourteen. "A majority are issued, some are under review and three are final." Thirteen permits remain to be re-applied for; the total number of permits to be closed out is 22. Chairman Boyd asked how many permits were still in "void" status and the response was thirteen. Matthew Nolton: Prior to your meeting, it appeared that Mr. Bumpus was not actively doing anything to resolve this situation. He asked Staff if their opinion was that Jeffrey Bumpus was trying. Joshua Lenio: Based on what he has done, I would say that he has taken a much bigger step than in previous months. Terry Jerulle: What is the County's recommendation? Everildo Ybaceta: Based on his history and what he has done in the past two weeks, I would suggest giving him an additional thirty days to close them out. Terry Jerulle: Does anyone want to make a bet that we'll still be dealing with this in six months from now? As I said last month, I don't want to "keep beating a dead horse,"but I'm kind of done with him. I'd just as soon impose Sanctions and turn him in to the State. But you want to give him another thirty days? Matthew Nolton: We started this off with the County stating they had met with Mr. Bumpus and had given him a timeframe. What was that timeframe? Assistant County Attorney Noell: By today's meeting—all the permits should have been applied for. I also said the inspections would be completed once I learned he was a property manager for the two communities involved. Terry Jerulle: Was he invited to that meeting? Assistant County Attorney Noe11: Yes. Matthew Nolton: There is the other part that I don't realize ... we can all think what we want about Mr. Bumpus, but the County was not "clean" in this situation because it allowed this to happen. The problem is these are permits open for owners that need to be corrected at some point in time. Otherwise, the real estate transactions will become a problem. Of the County is working with him and believes he is actually doing something that we talked about—we need to get these permits cleaned-up somehow ... otherwise they will fall back to the owner and become the owner's problem. I recommend that we consider extending it for thirty days— even though we know we probably don't want to—in the hopes that he will clean up as many of these as the County can help him clean up. Richard Joslin: I think the County is working diligently with him to try to get them cleaned up. Everildo Ybaceta: I would, in the recommendation, yes—give him the thirty days. If he does not meet the thirty-day deadline, I will not be required to bring him before the Board because we will take the next step. Let's be done with it. The Board can give him a deadline and state if he doesn't meet it, then his license will go. Richard Joslin: As of today, we can do that? Everildo Ybaceta: You could have done it before. I'm sorry, I'm still fairly new to this position. Richard Joslin suggested following the County's recommendation and extending the deadline for thirty days but stating if it is not met, the State will be requested to take further action against Mr. Bumpus. Matthew Nolton: What I heard was the County would take the next step and take him to the State without bringing him before this Board again. Everildo Ybaceta: Correct. Richard Joslin: But that wouldn't stop him from pulling permits here. Everildo Ybaceta: It would—if he doesn't meet the deadline, it basically turns off his license. Chairman Boyd: I don't think he wants to pull permits anyway. Everildo Ybaceta: That's true, too. Chairman Boyd: That being said--he could still do "service"because you don't need a permit to do service. Can we restrict him from even working in the County? Everildo Ybaceta: We can't restrict him from doing work that does not require a permit. But at the point where we close his license here, I must refer his case to the State. That's the selling point on this —Mr. Bumpus doesn't want to go before the State. I think Mr. Schneck can give the Board some advice. Jed Schneck, Attorney for the Board: For State-certified contractors, the Board has only two options to use for penalties. One, the Board can deny all permit-pulling privileges in Collier County or place a condition to limit his privileges ... for example, restricting him to just those outstanding permits. The second part is the recommended penalty to the State which could include revocation of his license, levying a fine of a specific dollar amount. If the Board decided to give him another thirty days, I would recommend that he come before the Board then to give him notice again and allow the Board to make the proper Finding of Law on the penalty. This is the second phase of the Administrative Hearing process which started back in March. You found him guilty of the violation. Now we are trying to determine whether the County can gain compliance and, if not, what the penalty should be. Richard Joslin: We would give him deadline and we would then have to act on that motion. If he doesn't do it, there would be no reason for him to come back before us. Vice Chairman Lantz moved to approve restricting Jeffrey Bumpus'permit pulling privileges to the outstanding permits of record, i.e., expired or void, and allowing him an additional thirty days to bring all the permits to final status. At the end of that period, if the permits are not finalized, a recommendation for further action will be made to the State of Florida. Richard Joslin offered a Second in support of the motion. Carried unanimously, 5—0. Permits By Contractor - NORTHERN BREEZE AIR CONDITIONING Permit Number Full Address Permit Declared ;Permit Status (.Apply ;Issued Expiration k ;Type z Valuation 'Date Date :Date rPRHV2014092647401 _ 692 Annemore LN !Mechanical 1 35001Cancelled 9/18/2014- 9/18/2014, 03/17/2015: PRHV2013102621001 2420 Hidden Lake DR,Unit 4 Mechanical 1 3000 Cancelled i10/21/2013 12/16/20131 06/14/2014`• PRHV2014051502601 — 11615 Windy Pines DR,Unit:9 ;,Mechanical 1 30001Cancelled �_ 1 5/30/20141 7/10/2014 01/06/20151 !PRHV2016020385301 ',2004 Cascades DR,Unit:8 -Mechanical 1 4100ICancelled I 2/8/2016: ! 08/08/20161 PRHV2013092374601 :765 Bentwater CIR,Unit:201 Mechanical 4000;Cancelled 9/23/2013 10/4/2013; 04/02/2014 PRHV2015072242101 2329 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:5 ;Mechanical 1 2800 Cancelled 1 7/8/2015: 01/04!2016 PRHV2016072877301 12378 Magnolia AVE,Unit:1 Mechanical 1 3000;Cancelled ? 7/28/2016 01/24/20171 1PRHV2013092374001 735 Bentwater CIR,Unit:203 :Mechanical 3200 Cancelled 1 9/23/2013; 10/4/2013 04/02/20141 PRHV2014082459901 ;2265 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:8 1Mechanical 3200;Cancelled 1 8/28/2014 02/24/2015; PRHV2013123100401 1615 Windy Pines DR,Unit:2 !Mechanical 3000 Cancelled 12/17/2013; 12127!2013 06/25/2014 ,,PRHV2014020329201 1700 Bentwater CIR Unit 102 ;Mechanical 32001 Cancelled 11 2/10/2014= 2/14/2014 08/13/2014£ IPRHV2015082590001 :2036 Cascades DR,Unit:14 Mechanical 3500€Cancelled 8/11/2015mm 02/07/2016: 1 PRHV2015072242501 11645 Windy Pines DR,Unit:5 Mechanical 4000Cancelled 1 7/8/20151 01/04/20161 PRHV2014020328701 12325 Hidden Lake DR,Unit4 Mechanical 32001Cancelled 2/10!2014:. 2/18/2014 08/17/2014 1PRHV2016020635901 12415 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:2 Mechanical 35001Cancelled 1 2/25/2016: 3/7/2016 09/03/20161 1PRHV2014020329101 ;1645 Windy Pines DR,Unit:6 :Mechanical , 3200:Cancelled 2/10/2014 2/14/2014, 08/13/2014' PRHV2014123554701 1645 Windy Pines DR,Unit:8 ,Mechanical 30001Cancelled ' 12/23/2014: 1 06/21/20151 __ i . .. ,PRHV2015082761401 ;2100 Cascades DR,Unit:8 1Mechanical 3000;Cancelled 1 8/27/2015; 02/23/20161 PRHV2016072769401 12370 Magnolia AVE,Unit:7 ;Mechanical 2800 Cancelled 7/20/20161 01/16/20171 PRHV2015061895101 12365 Hidden Lake DR Unit4 ;Mechanical 1 2800 Cancelled 16/16/2015i 1 12/13/2015# PRHV201604121410111665 Windy Pines DR,Unit:9 1Mechanical 1 2800 Cancelled L 4/5/2016; € 10/02/20161 PRBD2016031066001 1685 Windy Pines DR,Unit:8 ;Mechanical 4000£Cancelled 3/25/2016 09!24/2016'1 :PRHV2015041057501 -6812 Pelican Bay BLVD Mechanical 2800 Entered In Error E 4/8/2015: 10/05/20151 `PRHV2015041058101 16812 Pelican Bay BLVD sMechanical 2800 Entered In Error 1 4/8/2015, 1 10/05/201511 _ _. PRHV2018084855301 1645 Windy Pines DR,Unit:6 ;Mechanical 28001Finaled 1 8/14/2018. 9/6/20181 03/06/20191 1PRHV2018084855101 12415 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:2 !Mechanical ' 3000=Finaled I 8/14/2018€ 9/6/20181 03/06/20191 PRHV2018084685401 12325 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:4 Mechanical 2800 Finaled f 8/2/20181 8/6/2018i 02/09/20191 PRRHV2013020281001 7887 Vizcaya WAY 'Mechanical 8000t Finaled 2/7/2013; 2/8/2013' 08/13/2013, 1 PRHV2013123100101 !1715 Windy Pines DR,Unit:6 1Mechanical 3000 Finaled 1 12/17/20131 12/27/2013 02/10/20161 PRHV2018095418201 12405 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:9 Mechanical 2806 Finaled I 9/18/2018: 10/2/2018 04/03/2019; 1PRHV2018095288501 11665 Windy Pines DR,Unit:9 ?Mechanical 2800:Finaled 1 9/10/2018£ 9/13/20181 03/19/20191 PRHV2013092286101 17444 Treeline DR Mechanical 4000,Finaled 1 9/12/2013= 9/20/2013: 05/25/2015= PRHV2015041060601 16812 Pelican Bay BLVD ;Mechanical 2800 Finaled 1 4/8/20151 4/14/2015: 01/06/20191 IPRHV2018084855401 11645 Windy Pines DR,Unit:5 ;Mechanical 7 28001Finaled 8/14/2018, 9/6/2018, 03/06/2019; PRHV2014061504301 12375 Bayou LN,Unit:3 ;Mechanical i 5001 Finaled 1 6/2/20141 8/26/20141 04/27/2015 PRHV2018095289001 _ 12365 Hidden Lake DR,Unit4 ;Mechanical ! 3200 Finaled9/10/2018 9/13/2018 03/13/2019' 1 PRHV2013081937501 12372 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:6 Mechanical 1 2800 Finaled 1 8/7/20131 8/8/2013; 08/19/20151 _ X / mmT ,PRHV2018095410001 MagnoliaAV d9/18/20183 102/2018 04(03/2019 • PRHV2015051711301 2348 Hidden DR Unrt.6 Mechanical 2800;Finale 5/29/20151 6/16/20151 01/05/20191 PRHV2018095288801 11615 Windy Pines DR,Unit 2 ;Mechanical 28001Finaled_ 18 9/10/2018, "m 9/13/20 ' 03/13/20191 PRHV2018095288901 12329 Hidden Lake DR,Unit 5 ;Mechanical 2800=Finaled 1 9/10/2018; 9/13/2018; 03/13/2019 . PRHV2018095288001 „ „ 2370 Magnolia AVE Unit:7 ;Mechanical 2800£Finaled` _.__ { m 9/10/20181 9/13/2018 03/13/20191 Permits By Contractor - NORTHERN BREEZE AIR CONDITIONING Permit Number Full Address Type Permit ... Valuat'Declared Permit Status `Dately ilssueD to d Dateration :PRHV2016083178001 2036 Cascades DR Unit:14 Mechanical 1 3500.Finaled 8/18/2016' 8/18/2016 02/18/2017; PRHV2018084855201 .1615 Windy Pines DR,Unit:9 ?Mechanical , 2800;Finaled 8/14/2018? 9/6/2018 03/06/2019' PRHV2018095407501 11685 Windy Pines DR Unit:8 (Mechanical 2800'Finaled ! 9/18/20181 10/2/2018 04/03/20191 1PRHV2012010054001 16812 Pelican Bay BLVD Mechanical 1 . 2600 Finaled 1/11/20121 1/11/20121 07/09/20121 PRHV2018095418001 12332 Magnolia LN Unit:2 'Mechanical f 2800£Finaled 1 9/18/2018' 10/2/2018; 04/03/20191 _. _ . w._ i_... .. -- __.. IPRHV2015041158701 9937 Boca CIR Mechanical 36001 inaled " 4/15/2015:£ 4/24/2015" 10/21/20151 CDP201009033501 4845 Martinique WAY Mechanical 36001Finaled 9/8/20101 9/8/2010 05/15/20161 PRHV2018095289201 _ TM,2265 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:8 =Mechanical 1 28001.Inspections Commenced 9/10/20181 9/13/20181 03/12/20191 1PRHV2015113561501 12329 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:9 :Mechanical 3200;Inspections Completed 11/12/2015 12/3/20151 03/12/2019 1PRHV2013081937701 2274 Hiden dLake DR Unit:3 "Mechanical , 28001 inspections Completed 8/7/20131 8/8/2013 - 02/04/20141 PRHV2018095431501 2004 Cascades DR,Unit:8 Mechanical 1 28003lssued 9/18/2018 10/2/2018 03/31/20191 f.PRHV2018095288401 2100 Cascades DR,Unit:8 'Mechanical 1 28001Issued t 9/10/20181 10/6/20181 04/04/2019: PRHV2016030838301 12004 Cascades DR Unit:7 ',Mechanical 2900 Issued 3/10/2016 3/23/2016"12/08/2018- 1PRHV2016052011701 1705Bentwater CIR :Mechanical 1 400611s—sued 1 5/26/2016:: 7/20/20161 12/07/2018;. 1PRHV2016051959201 12324 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:3 :Mechanical 1 4200 Issued 5/23/20161 7/20/2016€ 03/12/20191 PRHV2018095418101 12345 Magnolia LN,Unit:6 1Mechanical 28001Issued 1 9/18/20161• 0/2/2018; 03/31/20191 PRHV2018095288701 11645 Windy Pines DR Unit:8 -Mechanical 1 280011ssued I 9/10/201819/13/2018° 03/12/20191 1 1PRHV2018095289101 12420 Hidden Lake DR,Unit 4Mechanical 28001Issued 1 9/10/2018 9• /13/2018��€ 03/12/20191 1 PRHV2018095287601 1692 Annemore LN 1Mechanical 1 35001Issued i 9/10/2018 9/13/2018 03/12/20191 1PRHV2015113561901 ;770 Bentwater CIR,Unit:102 ,Mechanical 32001 Reactivate i 11/12/2015: 12/3/2015 12/07/20181 PRHV2015051467901 810 Breakaway LN,Unit:204 Mechanical 4000:Reactivate 1 5/11/2015 6/16/20151 12/08/20181 1PRHV2015041056601 730 Bentwater CIR,Unit:204 :Mechanical 3500;Reactivate 4/8/2015: 4/14/2015" 12/07/20181 PRHV2014051285301 2332 Magnolia LN Unit:3 Mechanical 3000 Reactivate 5/9/2014 12/07/2018' "PRHV2015041147701 2344 Magnolia LN Unit:5 Mechanical 3000"Reactivate 4/15/2015 4/24/2015 12/08/2018 P.RHV2018095518601 12332 Magnolia LN Unit:3 1 Mechanical 2800;Ready for Issuance £ 9/24/2018 1 03/27/2019# a PRHV2018095406101 1765 Bentwater CIR,Unit:201 i Mechanical 1 40001 Ready for Issuance 9/18/20181 03/20/20191 1 PRHV2018095418701 1735 Bentwater CIR,Unit:203 Mechanical ' 3600;Ready for Issuance 9/18/20181 ` 03/19/20191 fPRHV2018095409601 ?700Bentwater CIR,Unit:102 `.Mechanical 3200;Ready for Issuance 1 9/18/20181 03/19/20191 PRHV2014061504001 ;,2332 Magnolia LN,Und 3 Mechanical , 2001 Void i 6/2/2014" 1 11/29/2014" PRHV2016072769801 12345 Magnolia LN,Unit:6 .Mechanical I 30001 Void � 1 7/20/20161 01/ 16/2017 I PRHV2014082213401 12285 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:7 "Mechanical 1 28001 Void i 8/5/20141 8/5/2014 02/01/2015; 1PRHV2016093482901 12405 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:9 'Mechanical , 30001 Void 1 9/12/2016: 1 03/11/20171 PRHV2015123783001 :2332 Magnolia LN,Unit:2 =Mechanical - 4500`Void 1 12/4/201511 06/01/20161 PRHV2013102488501 705 Bentwater CIR Mechanical i 39001Void10/7/20131 10/17/20131 04/15/20141 1PRHV2013081983201 2255 Linwood AVE 'Mechanical € 31001 Void 1 8/13/2013! 9/12/2013', 03/11/2014 iPRHV2013102487901 12332 Magnolia LN,Unit:1 ;Mechanical — 18001Voidrn 10/7/2013111 10/17/2013- 04/15/20141 1PRHV2014123554201 2345 Hidden Lake DR,Unit:1 Mechanical 3000 Void 1 12/23/2014 1 06/21/20151 PRHV2014071949701 14976 Rustic Oaks CIR "Mechanical 1 i 3500 Void 7/10/2014= 7/11/2014: 01/07/2015 PRHV2013102488001 845 109th AVE N 'Mechanical j 33001Void i 10/7/2013 10/17/2013 04/15/20141 ,.....__________________..........„..,,,..„._ 5'5 DavisLilla From: SmithReggie Sent: Wednesday, October 03, 2018 9:56 AM To: Jeff Cc: YbacetaEverildo; DavisLilla Subject: Contractors' Licensing Board Hearing set for 17 October 2018, 9:00 Am Mr. Bumpus, As per Supervisor Ybaceta, I am notifying you of the next upcoming Contractors' Licensing Board Hearing set for 17 October 2018, 9:00 Am,Collier County Government Center,Administrative Building,Third Floor in Commissioner's Chambers, 3299 E.Tamiami Trail, Naples, FL 34112. Your presence has been requested to meet and speak to the Board Members about your case. Please respond to advise your intentions to be present at this meeting. Thank you. Respectfully, Reggie Smith Licensing Compliance Officer C reatlintY GMD Operations NOTE:Email Address Has Changed 2800 Horseshoe Dr.N.,Naples Florida 34104 Phone:239 252 2432 Fax:239 252 6926 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 �� Co eif County COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD OCTOBER 17, 2018 9:00 A.M. ADMINISTRATIVE COMPLAINT - CASE 2018-09 ANDREW WOOD - MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR ANDREW WOOD is the License holder for his company AMW CONSTRUCTION SERVICES, INC. A complaint was filed by a homeowner in regards to window installation without a permit. This case was going to be seen by the Board in March 2018, but Mr. Wood was able to receive a permit right before. This permit now sits in an Expired status, as it was originally rejected, and Mr. Wood never submitted any corrections. Mr. Wood is in violation of the Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as amended, Section 4.2.2, Misconduct of a State Certified Contractor, which states "Willfully violating the applicable building codes or laws of the state, city or Collier County". He is going in front of the board to hear possible disciplinary actions due to his violation. BEFORE THE COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD Petitioner, V. Case Number: 2018-09 License Number: CGC1507208 WOOD, ANDREW M D/B/A—AMW CONSTRUCTION SERVICES, INC. Respondent. ADMINISTRATIVE COMPLAINT Collier County(County)files the Administrative Complaint against Andrew M Wood (Respondent), a State licensed Certified General Contractor(license#CGC1507208), and states the following facts and allegations in support of the cited violations below: 1. The Respondent is currently licensed by State of Florida as a Certified General Contractor with License number CGC1507208. 2. Under the provisions of Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as amended,Section 4.2.2.,the following actions by a holder of a State Certified General Contractor/Collier County registered Contractor(#LCC20120001969)shall constitute misconduct and grounds for discipline pursuant to Section 4.3. a. On or about September, 2015, Deirdre Ventry, homeowner at 709 Palm View Drive, Naples, Florida 34110 hired Mr.Andrew M Wood (dba)AMW Construction Services, Inc.to replace five windows.The work was completed by Mr.Wood (dba)AMW Construction Services, Inc. without the issuance of any building permit. b. Mr.Wood was summoned before the Collier County Contractor's Licensing Board in March, 2018 for not obtaining the Permit, however before the case could be heard,the permit application was submitted (03/20/2018).The permit application has EXPIRED as of 09/30/2018. 3. Thereafter, pursuant to Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as amended, Section 4.3.2. and Section 4.3.3.,the complaint was investigated and found sufficient cause to file formal charges. 4. Collier County brings the following charge in this formal complaint against the Respondent. COUNT I 5. Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as amended,Section 4.2.2, Misconduct—State Certified Contractors,states: "Willfully violating the applicable building codes or laws of the state, city or Collier County." WHEREFORE, the Petitioner asserts the above facts and charges are grounds for disciplinary action under Ordinance 2006-46,as amended, Section 4.3.,as amended, and WHEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing,the Petitioner respectfully requests the Collier County Contractors' Licensing Board to find the Respondent guilty of the violations charged. Dated: /d _ / Signed: / J.ck .umph Collier County Contractors' Licensing Supervisor or Designee C.L.B. CASE # 2018 — 09 Andrew M Wood dba - AMW Construction Services, Inc. TABLE OF CONTENTS El / E3 — Formal Complaint. E4 — Collier County Certificate Detail Report. E5 — State of Florida, Department of Business & Professional Regulation Licensee Detail E6 / E7 - State of Florida, Division of Corporations, Florida Profit Corporation Detail. E8 / E9 — Notice of Hearing sent via Certified Mail / Return Receipt. E10 - Signed Return Receipt for accepted Certified Mail. E11 / E16 — Case Detail Report for current Misconduct Violation. E17 — NOTICE OF NON COMPLIANCE E18 / E20 — PERMIT APPLICATION # PRBD20180318752 (3/20/2018) E21 — Payment Slip - # PRBD20180318752 E22 — Receipt for Payment - # PRBD20180318752 E23 - Outstanding Corrections Letter (4/3/2018) E24 / E29 - Emails with attachments to/from Andrew M Wood E30 — Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as amended, Section 4.2.2., for MISCONDUCT — State Certified Contractors E31 /E32 - Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as amended, Section 4.3. for Disciplinary Proceedings E33 / E34 — Florida Building Code (A) 105.1, "PERMITS". Contractors' Licensing Board 2800 North Horseshoe Dr. Naples, Fl. 34104 Complaint Number-2018-09 Complainant:Any person who believes that a Contractor holding a State Certification or Certificate of competency has violated Collier County Ordinance 2006-46,as amended, may submit a sworn complaint to the Contractor Licensing supervisor,or his/her designee.The complaint shall be in substantially the form prescribed by the Contractor Licensing Supervisor.The complainant shall pay a fee of$50.00 to defray the costs of administering the complaint,at the time of filing the complaint.The complaining party shall state with particularity which section(s)of this Ordinance he or she believes has been violated by the contractor and the essential facts in support thereof. Complaint: Please print or type and return signed copies of the complaint. Date: October 3,2018 Against: Contractor's Name:Andrew M Wood Phone:239-464-0469 Business Name:AMW CONSTRUCTION SERVICES, INC. License Number if known: CERTIFIED ISSUANCE#CGC1507208(Certified General Contractor) Collier County Competency number:C27544 Contractor's Business Address: 122 RICHMOND AVE S LEHIGH ACRES, FL 33936 Filed By: Name:Collier County Contractors' Licensing Office(Jack Gumph) Address:2800 N. Horseshoe Dr.,Naples, FL 34104 Business Phone: 239-252-2468 Address where work done:709 Palm View Drive City: NAPLES, FL 34108 County:COLLIER Date of contract: Unknown Date job started: Unknown Date job completed or new home occupied: Unknown Were there plans and specifications? Unknown Is there a written contract? Unknown. If yes, amount of Contract: Unknown Has Contractor been paid in full?Unknown. If not,what amount? Unknown Was a Building Permit obtained?NO—APPLICATION ONLY Building Permit number if known: PRBD20180318752—APPLI. Have you communicated by letter with the licensee?YES Date: 8/17/2018. Do you have a reply? YES Please attach to this form all copies of the purchase agreement, building contract, home improvement contract, copies of receipts and/or cancelled checks available and any additional evidence to substantiate your allegations. List any subsections of Section 4 of Collier County Ordinance number 90- 105,as amended,which, in your opinion, have been violated by the contractor which is the subject of this complaint, (list subsection number): Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as amended, Section 4.2.2., Misconduct—State Certified Contractors,states:"Willfully violating the applicable building codes or laws of the state,city or Collier County." Please state the facts which you believe substantiate your charge of misconduct against the subject contractor. List facts separately for each subsection number above: Contractor,Andrew M Wood (dba)AMW Construction Services, Inc.was hired by homeowner,Ms. Deirdre Ventry,709 Palm View Drive, Naples, Florida 34110 to replace five windows.The work was completed by Mr.Wood (dba)AMW Construction Services, Inc.without the issuance of any building permit. Mr.Wood was summoned before the Collier County Contractor's Licensing Board in March, 2018 for not obtaining the Permit, however before the case could be heard,the permit application was submitted (03/20/2018).The permit application has EXPIRED as of 09/30/2018. (Complainant's signature) State of FLORIDA County of COLLIER 3rd Sworn to(or affirmed) and subscribed before me this day of C)0_,-1-0\0QC , 2018, by (signature of person making statement). V�` 1' (signature of NotaryPublic) ( g Print,type or stamp commissioned name of Notary Public: Ve.)(C'A c hel 1Q. east° Personally known / " or produced identification fk.YP4e VERA MICHELLE CASIO * Commission#GG 140208 N� 41'-'4, Expires August 31,2021 9j.FOF FLO Bonded Tlru Budget Notary Services License Application Status - CityView Portal Page 1 of 1 GMD Public Portal License Application Status Note:You can collapse and expand individual sections by clicking the header of the section you wish to collapse/expand. - License Application Summary Application Number: C27544 Business Name: AMW CONSTRUCTION SERVICES,INC. License Type: Contractor Application Status: Inactive Description of Business: All Certificates from CDPIus:27544 Mailing Address: PO BOX 940 LEHIGH ACRES FL 33970- Drew@amvvconstructionservices.com — Issuances Type Date Issued Date Expires Status I Number GENERAL CONTR.-CERTIFIED 08/22/2017 08/31/2018 Expired 27544 _ Submittals There are no submittals for this license application. — Reviews There are no reviews for this license application. — Insurance I f I I Producer I Type Policy Effective Date Expiry Date I Limit I EDSON INSURANCE General Liability 1085FL00098267-0 06/30/2017 06/30/2018 $600,000.00 SERVICES INC Expiration Processed: Yes Producer Phone Number: (239)267-4042 WOOD,ANDREW M Worker's Comp i 09/24/2015 10/03/2019 Exemption 1 Expiration Processed: No EQ' http://cvportal.colliergov.net/CityViewWeb/License/Status?license1d=101016 10/3/2018 DB1 R----W-OQD,-ANDREW M; Doing Business As: AMW CONSTRUCTION SERVIC... Page 1 of 1 12:00:07 PM 10/3/2018 Licensee Details Licensee Information Name: WOOD, ANDREW M (Primary Name) AMW CONSTRUCTION SERVICES INC (DBA Name) Main Address: P 0 BOX 940 LEHIGH ACRES Florida 33970 County: LEE License Mailing: LicenseLocation: 122 RICHMOND AVENUE S LEHIGH ACRES FL 33936 County: LEE License Information License Type: Certified General Contractor Rank: Cert General License Number: CGC1507208 Status: Delinquent,Active Licensure Date: 05/12/2004 Expires: 08/31/2018 Special Qualifications Qualification Effective Construction Business 01/13/2005 Alternate Names View Related License Information View License Complaint 2601 Blair Stone Road,Tallahassee FL 32399 :: Email: Customer Contact Center :: Customer Contact Center: 850.487.1395 The State of Florida is an AA/EEO employer.Copyright 2007-2010 State of Florida.Privacy Statement Under Florida law,email addresses are public records. If you do not want your email address released in response to a public-records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact the office by phone or by traditional mail.If you have any questions,please contact 850.487.1395. *Pursuant to Section 455.275(1),Florida Statutes,effective October 1,2012, licensees licensed under Chapter 455,F.S.must provide the Department with an email address if they have one.The emails provided may be used for official communication with the licensee. However email addresses are public record.If you do not wish to supply a personal address,please provide the Department with an email address which can be made available to the public. https://www.myfloridalicense.com/LicenseDetail.asp?SID=&id=2A9FOFC7CB 17CA 1 EA... 10/3/2018 ' ." � Detail by Entity Name Page 1 of 2 Florida Department of State DIVISION OF CORPORATIONS i1 f.tuVbrg , j i f Department of State / Division of Corporations / Search Records / Detail By Document Number/ Detail by Entity Name Florida Profit Corporation AMW CONSTRUCTION SERVICES, INC. Filing Information Document Number P03000063466 FEI/EIN Number 56-2403856 Date Filed 06/09/2003 Effective Date 06/09/2003 State FL Status ACTIVE Last Event REINSTATEMENT Event Date Filed 09/18/2013 Principal Address 122 RICHMOND AVE S LEHIGH ACRES, FL 33936 Changed:04/28/2017 Mailing Address PO BOX 940 LEHIGH ACRES, FL 33970 Registered Agent Name&Address WOOD,ANDREW M 122 RICHMOND AVE S LEHIGH ACRES, FL 33936 Address Changed:04/28/2017 Officer/Director Detail Name&Address Title P WOOD,ANDREW M 122 RICHMOND AVE S LEHIGH ACRES, FL 33936 Annual Reports Report Year Filed Date 2016 04/30/2016 E6P http://search.sunbiz.org/Inquiry/CorporationSearch/SearchResultDetail?inquirytype=Entity... 10/3/2018 Detail by Entity Name - Page 2 of 2 2017 04/28/2017 2018 04/30/2018 Document Images 04/30/2018—ANNUAL REPORT View image in PDF format 04/28/2017—ANNUAL REPORT View image in PDF format 04/30/2016—ANNUAL REPORT View image in PDF format 04/24/2015—ANNUAL REPORT View image in PDF format 04/29/2014—ANNUAL REPORT View image in PDF format 09/18/2013—REINSTATEMENT View image in PDF format 01/06/2011—REINSTATEMENT View image in PDF format 01/16/2009—REINSTATEMENT View image in PDF format 06/29/2007—ANNUAL REPORT View image in PDF format 05/01/2006—ANNUAL REPORT View image in PDF format 04/30/2005—ANNUAL REPORT View image in PDF format 04/30/2004—ANNUAL REPORT View image in PDF format 06/09/2003—Domestic Profit View image in PDF format Florida Department of State,Division of Corporations http://search.sunbiz.org/Inquiry/CorporationSearch/SearchResultDetail?inquirytype=Entity... 10/3/2018 E-r +C©un ty Grow th Management Division Planning S.: Regulation Operations Department Licensing Section Certified Mail#7017 0530 0000 8339 6200 Date: August 14, 2018 PERMIT#PRBD20180318752 Andrew M. Wood d,/b/a-AMW Construction Services,Inc. 122 Richmond Ave S Lehigh Acres, FL 33936 RE: Permit Expiration on 9/30/2019-Window Replacement; 709 Palm View Drive. Dear Mr. Wood, A complaint has been filed against you by the above referenced entity. A hearing of this Complaint will be held by the Contractors' Licensing Board on Wednesday October 17,2018 at 9:00 AM in the Board of County Commissioner's Room,Third Floor,Administration Building (W. Harmon Turner Bldg.),at 3301 East Tamiami Trail,Naples, Florida 34112. Your presence before the Collier County Contractors' Licensing Board is required at this time. .The packet you will receive marked composite exhibit"A" will be delivered to the members of the Contractors'Licensing Board one week prior to the hearing. If you wish to prepare a defense packet and have it delivered in conjunction with composite exhibit "A",you must make fifteen copies and have them in our office by 8:00 AM on Wednesday,one week prior to the hearing. In your packet,you may give a summary of events.At this meeting,you may present evidence and be represented by an attorney of your choice. In the event the Contractors'Licensing Board finds you in violation of Section(s)22-201.1(2)) of Collier County Ordinance#90-105, as amended,the range of disciplinary sanctions which may be imposed are from an oral reprimand to a suspension or revocation of your Collier County Certificate issuance(N/A),and/or suspension or revocation of your permit privileges against your State license#CGC1507208.If abated,your name will be removed from the docket. Sincerel , Jac umph Lie ing Compliance Officer,Collier County Contractors' Licensing Operations and Regulatory Management,Growth Management Department 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr. Naples, FL. 34104 a r 1 Di.=icv r,n[ . !<<i .,` ( 1 es o: Lrr e' ta.._} i1 t3_ 25? ES Rammaluzuj.„,......„,,,,,......... Co ll ear County Growth Management Department 2800 N.Horseshoe Drive• Naples,Florida 34104 7017 0530 0000 8339 6200 ',_..._ Andrew M. Wood AMW Construction Services, Inc. 122 Richmond Ave S Lehigh Acres, FL 33936 I ENDER;COMPLETE THIS SECTION COMPLETE THIS SECTION ON.DELIVERY + U.S. Postal SèrvjcTM our website I Complete items 1,2,and 3. A Signature CERTIFIED MLTM® RECEI • I Print your name and address on the reverse I Domestic MOnly so that we can return the card to you. X Agent For delivery informatiai! on,visit at i 0 Addressee I I Attach this card to the back of the mail iece, B. Received by(Printed Name I p-- I I > L or on the front if space permits. p 1 C. Date of Delivery i m Article Addressed to: rn D.Is delivery address different from item 1? 0 Yes ��t}lam/ n M • �/�//, ` If YES,enter delivery address below: I Extra Services$Fees / .1'*.b„�I'� •M. • v o L 0 No I 0 ❑Return Receipt(hardcap k _ appropriate) //�� ci ❑Return Receipt(electronic) $—� 4 M w l.�/ ett STI.N iJ!(f s .�,c p ❑Certified Mail Restricted Delivery $---------- ! CII . . l�iC14M /� °A-)d E i 0 O fSgnature Required $ ---_ t J J- Signature Restricted Delivery$— L rt1t,ti 4-eels, F�-- 33536 -. :._ m Ill IIII1I III!11111111111111111111111111111111ci0 1 3, Service Type ❑Priori Mail ' Adult Signature Priority Express® (, ❑RegisteredMailT^' SenFTo 9590 9402 3772 8032 4619 66 Ad It Signature Restricted Delivery ❑Registered MaitRestr,ted i 0 edit Signalurt e Ste--5i - JV V t.No IP ER:COMPLETE THIS SECTION COMPLETF;;;!S SECTION ON,DE;_IVERY ps State,aoo 4 :75-13-02-7001-17904-7See/IFI__r :•Xf /lea ��wnplete items 1,2,and 3. Ira i I I al/ ps Eoim3sao April 2015 int your name and address on the reverse ❑Agent _ : that we can return the.card to you. 0 Addressee t t tach this card to the back of the mailpiece, 'mil—inted Name) N _ D ate of■e,liry on the front if space permits. , �� ostal Sel'VICeTM tide Addressed to: D. Is delivery address different from item 1'7 ❑ a TI FI E D MAIL® R ECE 1 PT If YES,enter delivery address below: @�2 tic Mail Only 1`1.1)a61-1 M M. WOdt> ! t- , f•r - . , l • -• t- . ll I ,r,, • - • Atnl dI Tet•tTI43N ll1U5 1_I-+C. « F C : A U �-�-// !Rict ti.n,.id #4,.)E S• n Fee ati v/7 4-eery/ , 3 5 g.5es a Fees(check box add fee as appropriate) 1111 111 ')EMI I I I1111111 I I L I I I I eipt(hardcopy) $ 3: Service Type 0 Priority Mail Express® eeipt(electronic) $ i O et ur ❑Registered MaiITM la c Rest Restricted Delivery $ Postmark ❑Ady It Signa re Restricted Delivery ❑Registered Mail Restricted ature Required $ Here 9590 9402 3772 8032 4619 66 lo.Oertified Mail® Delivery ❑Certified Mail Restricted Delivery 0 Return Receipt for alalic Restricted Delivery$ ' 0 Collect on Delivery Merchandise 51 0 Collect on Delivery Restricted Delivery ID Signature Confirmationrm r--�. �a.uf o InhallID Signature Confirmation 7 017 0530 0000 8339 6200 estricted Delivery Restricted Delivery ie and Fees 'arm 3811,July 2015 PSN 7530-02-000-9053 Domestic Return Receipt tit. V`'/ (.4.4457. `'/ 5/_��M�'Cr— . v e Street anciApt.No.,or PO o&'x .7v qECity,State,ZN+4i C ergov.net Report Title: Code Case Details • Date: 10/3/2018 11:50:24 AM Case Number: CECV20170009802 Case Number: CECV20170009802 Status: Investigation Case Type: Code Violation Date&Time Entered: 6/7/2017 9:28:42 AM Priority: Normal Entered By: webAnonymousUser Inspector: JackGumph Case Disposition: Case Pending Jurisdiction: Contractor's Licensing Origin: Public Portal Detail Description: Unit owner installed all new windows in their condominium without obtaining a permit Location Comments: 709 Palm View Drive, Naples, Florida 34110 (Folio#26280440008) Property 26280440008 Complainant Connie Comunale Contractor Amw Construction Services Inc Business Management &Budget Office E lO 1 • Code Case Details Execution Date 10/3/2018 11:50:24 AM Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments Preliminary Investigation JackGumph 6/7/2017 6/7/2017 Needs 06/07/2017 lnvestigatio n I (Jack Gumph)received a referral reference the unit owner installing all new windows in the condominium without obtaining a permit at 709 Palm View Drive, Naples, Florida 34110 (Folio#26280440008). A site visit will be necessary Addressing Review webAnonymo 6/7/2017 6/12/2017 Complete usUser Cont. Investigation JackGumph 6/8/2017 6/8/2017 Complete 06/08/2017 On the date of June 8, 2017, at 2:02 PM, I (Jack Gumph)traveled to 709 Palm View Drive, Naples, Florida 34110 in an effort to observe the possibility of new windows installed in the unit.At the address, no one was at home. I observed what looked to be a newer looking window on the front of the unit next to the front door. I will check back for contact with the owner/occupant. Follow up necessary Business Management& Budget Office 44 2 Code Case Details Execution Date 10/3/2018 11:50:24 AM Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments Cont. Investigation JackGumph 6/12/2017 6/12/2017 Complete 06/09/2017 On the date of June 9,2017, I (Jack Gumph) again traveled to 709 Palm View Drive, Naples, Florida 34110 in an effort to contact the homeowner reference the referral on new window installation. I knocked on the door and made personal contact with Denise Cross& Duane Moran who advised me they are renting from the homeowner,who is Ms. Cross's sister, Deirdre Ventry. I advised them of the referral reference the window replacement. Denise Cross related that they had a window replacement approximately two years ago but not anything recent. I inquired if he had any documentation and Ms. Cross stated that the owner, (Ms. Ventry)would have the same. At this time,the owner, Deirdre Ventry arrived at the unit and contacted me. I explained the circumstances of the referral to Ms. Ventry. Ms.Ventry related that approximately September of 2015, she(Ms.Ventry)hired a company to replace the windows(5)in the condominium(#709). She remembered this company was a contractor from Fort Myers area but she could not recall the name. I requested that Ms.Ventry attempt to locate any documentation she has on the window replacement of September, 2015. I supplied my business card and asked Ms.Ventry to email me any document. Follow up required. Cont. Investigation jackgumph 8/9/2017 8/9/2017 Complete 08/09/2017 Subsequent information provided by homeowner, Deirdre Ventry(239-409-9781) included the name of contractor to be Andrew M.Wood(dba)AMW Construction Services, Inc. (#CGC1507208). I (Jack Gumph) subsequently was able to contact Mr.Wood (239-464-0469)via telephone whereby advising him of the issue at 709 Palm View Drive, Naples, Florida 34110. Mr.Wood did relate that he was the contractor who installed the windows at the location. I explained to Mr. Wood that a permit would be required to satisfy code regulations. Mr.Wood informed me that his registration has lapsed in Collier. Further, he would take the necessary steps to re-activate his registration, then apply for the permit. I will continue to monitor this case for permitting. Business Management & Budget Office Ele9 3 ' Code Case Details Execution Date 10/3/2018 11:50:24 AM Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments Cont. Investigation JackGumph 8/16/2017 8/16/2017 Complete 08/16/2017 A Notice of Non-Compliance sent to Mr. Wood via email. Cont. Investigation JackGumph 11/6/2017 11/6/2017 Complete 11/6/2017 On this date of November 6,2017, I conducted follow up on this case report.After leaving a phone message, I received a phone message from the contractor(Andrew M. Wood(dba)AMW Construction Services, Inc. (#CGC1507208))that he has re-activated his registration in Collier County and is preparing to submit the application for the window replacement. I will monitor for permit issuance. Cont. Investigation JackGumph 12/4/2017 12/4/2017 Complete 12/4/2017 On the date of December 4, 2017, research indicates that NO permit has yet been applied for. As of this date of December 4,2017, I (Jack Gumph)have received no communication from Andrew Wood/AMW Construction Services, Inc. reference his attempts to resolve the permit situation. On this date, I issued a Notice of Hearing for February 21, 2018, Contractor Licensing Board for willful code violation. If violation is abated before hearing, I will pull case from agenda. Notice mailed Certified Mail Return Receipt on 12/4/2017(USPS#7017 0530 0000 8339 5982). Follow up necessary Cont. Investigation JackGumph 12/27/2017 12/27/2017 Complete 12/26/2017 On the date of December 26,2017, I (Jack Gumph)received the signed USPS Receipt for Certified Mailing#7017 0530 0000 8339 5982("Green Card")sent to Andrew Wood/ AMW Construction Services, Inc. Follow up necessary Business Management & Budget Office L J3 4 Code Case Details Execution Date 10/3/2018 11:50:24 AM - Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments Cont. Investigation JackGumph 2/16/2018 2/16/2018 Complete 02/16/2018 On the date of February 16,2018,the Contractor Licensing Board Hearing scheduled for February 21, 2018 has been rescheduled for Wednesday March 21,2018 at 9:00 AM. . If violation is abated before hearing, I will pull case from agenda. Notice mailed Certified Mail Return Receipt on 2/16/2018(USPS#7017 0530 0000 8339 6040). Cont. Investigation JackGumph 3/1/2018 3/1/2018 Complete 2/28/2018 On the date of February 28,2018, I (Jack Gumph)received the signed USPS Receipt for Certified Mailing#7017 0530 0000 8339 6040("Green Card")sent to Andrew Wood/ AMW Construction Services, Inc. Follow up necessary Cont. Investigation JackGumph 3/20/2018 3/20/2018 Complete 03/20//2018 On the date of March 20,2018, I (Jack Gumph)personally met with Andrew Wood (dba)AMW Construction Services, Inc. at the Growth Management Department Offices.At that time, Mr.Wood supplied the returned "Notice of Non-Compliance"with signature (attached). At that time, Mr.Wood also supplied to me, the receipt for the submitted permit application#PRBD20180318752(attached). At this point, I advised Mr.Wood that the hearing scheduled before the Contractor Licensing Board on March 21,2018 will be cancelled and I will monitor the case for the issuance of the permit. Monitoring for the issuance of the Permit. Cont. Investigation JackGumph 4/5/2018 4/5/2018 Complete 4/5/2018 On the date of April 5, 2018, I (Jack Gumph) researched the submitted permit application# PRBD20180318752 and found it to be in "Rejected"status as of 4/3/2018. continued... Business Management & Budget Office E/4- 5 • Code Case Details Execution Date 10/3/2018 11:50:24 AM Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments Cont. Investigation JackGumph 4/18/2018 4/18/2018 Complete 4/18/2018 On the date of April 18, 2018, I (Jack Gumph) researched the submitted permit application# PRBD20180318752 and found it still in "Rejected"status as of 4/3/2018. An email was sent advising contractor Wood that I have noticed a'Rejected'status on the permit and would he please address the corrections required to resolve. continues Cont. Investigation JackGumph 5/17/2018 5/17/2018 Complete 5/17/2018 On the date of May 17, 2018, I(Jack Gumph) researched the submitted permit application# PRBD20180318752 and found it still in "Rejected"status as of 5/17/2018. continues Cont. Investigation JackGumph 6/12/2018 6/12/2018 Complete 6/12/2018 On the date of June 12, 2018, I (Jack Gumph) researched the submitted permit application# PRBD20180318752 and found it still in "Rejected"status as of 6/12/2018. Cont. Investigation JackGumph 7/9/2018 7/9/2018 Complete 7/09/2018 On the date of July 9, 2018, I (Jack Gumph) researched the submitted permit application# PRBD20180318752 and found it still in "Rejected"status. I sent an email to contractor Wood with copy of'Correction Letter'with information to proceed with corrections. Continues Cont. Investigation JackGumph 7/23/2018 7/23/2018 Complete 7/23/2018 Research permit--shows still Rejected, Expiration 9/30/2018. continues... Cont. Investigation JackGumph 8/7/2018 8/7/2018 Complete 8/7/2018 Research permit--shows still Rejected, Expiration 9/30/2018. continues.. Business Management &Budget Office Ei 6 Code Case Details Execution Date 10/3/2018 11:52:00 AM Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments Cont. Investigation JackGumph 8/14/2018 8/14/2018 Complete As of this date of August 14,2018, I (Jack Gumph)have received no communication from Andrew Wood/AMW Construction Services, Inc. reference his attempts to resolve the permit situation. On this date, I issued a Notice of Hearing for October 17, 2018,Contractor Licensing Board for willful code violation of Expired Permit. If violation is abated before hearing, I will pull case from agenda. Notice mailed Certified Mail Return Receipt on 12/4/2017 (USPS#7017 0530 0000 8339 6200). NOTE: It should be noted that the permit expires on 9/30/2018.This letter is attempting to be proactive for the Contractor Licensing Board because of upcoming holidays,the schedule would flow into 2019. Follow up necessary Cont. Investigation JackGumph 8/24/2018 8/24/2018 Complete 08/24/2018 Received the Certified Mail Return Receipt on 8/24/2018(USPS#7017 0530 0000 8339 6200)signed(Green Card). Cont. Investigation JackGumph 9/4/2018 9/4/2018 Complete 09/04/2018 Permit#PRBD20180318752 still in Rejected Status...Application will expire-09/30/2018 ...Contractor scheduled for CLB on 10/17/2018. Cont. Investigation JackGumph 10/3/2018 10/3/2018 Complete 10/3/2018 Research indicates that the Permit Application #PRBD20180318752 shows EXPIRED, 09/30/2018.The Contractor is scheduled for CLB on 10/17/2018 for the violation. Investigation JackGumph 10/4/2018 Pending (PERMIT)709 Palm View Drive Violation Description Status Entered Corrected Amount Comments Commencing Work Without A Permit Open 6/7/2017 $0 Title Reason Result Compliance Fine/Day Condition Business Management& Budget Office Eg 7 Notice of Non-Compliance BE IT KNOWN THAT I,the person whose signature appears below,do hereby formally acknowledge, agree and consent as follows: THAT a certain case,case#CECV20170009802, involving me has recently been investigated by the Collier County Contractor Licensing Department. That the said Department had made it known to me that, in the Department's view, I violated State (Florida Building code section 105.1)and county(ordinance 2006-46,as amended,4.1.6&4.1.18) licensing laws in said case, by commencing work without first obtaining a valid Building Permit. Type of Work: Window Replacement Location of work:709 Palm View Drive,Naples,Florida 34110 Date of work:June 8,2017(Observed),09/2017(Completed) THAT the said Department has explained to me that all contracting work,including BUT NOT LIMITED TO: home or business improvement, residential or commercial, remodeling, renovation,addition, repair, alteration,plumbing,electrical, roofing, pool construction,air conditioning,sheet metal,aluminum and alarm contractor work,all require the issuance of a valid Building Permit prior to commencement. THEREFORE, BEING FULLY ADVISED, I DO AGREE that I will obtain all Building Permits required by Statutes and fully understand that if I commence work without obtaining necessary Building Permits in the future,the Contractor Licensing Department will consider that a willful code violation where penalties and restrictions to Building Permit privil ge y follow. ,, Witness my signature(Co ractor) Print-4A_Nk.Iex,0 State of: Issuance#: County of: Issuance#: The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this (date) by who has produced as identification and who did not take an oath. Signature of Notary ./M. Al._ _ censing Investigator, in lieu of Notary. Date: Z/ I, dilturr1ph, Collier County Contractor licensing,239-252-2468 RJU �-- (roMh cow IV. f7V f\.J C7nVC UR.,ivMr'Lc ,rt..341.L1,1. i ICL. tL77JL7 L-L4 motions:Applicants must complete all fields.Please follow the Building Permit Application Instructions to complete this Application. on A.Permit Number - • A.1rPermit#(Stoftapnwde): * `i-:, g 1a, d 17)-;- Section ) '"TSection B.General Permit Ii rfoo i r cation B.1.Primary Permit#(tfany): 8.2.Master Permit#(if cry): B.3.Building Type: O 1&2 Family dwelling/Townhouse 0 Mobile/Manufactured home k Residential 3+units/Multi-family 0 Commercial BA.Permittee Type: 0 Contractor 0 Design Professional 0 Owner Builder Property Information Contractor Information B.5.Parcel/Folio#: 26280440008 8.12.license#: CGC 1507208 8.6.Job StreegF dress: 709 Palm View Drive Naples,FL 34110 8.13.Company Name: AMW Construction Services,Inc. B.14.Qualifier Name: Andrew M.Wood 8.7.terName: Deirdre M.Ventry 8.15.Contact Name: Andrew M.Wood B.8.Owner Phone: (239)404-9781 B.16.Company Address: PO Box 940 Lehigh Acres,FL 33970 B.9.Subdivision: 223300-COCOHATCHEE MANOR Lot/Block/Unit: Unit DP-3 B.17.Company Phone: (239)464-0469 B.10.SDP/PL#: 8.18.Fax#: 8.11.'PL#Filename: 8.19.a."Email 1: drew@amwconstructionservices.com B.19.b."Email 2: 'Optional—Search existing Filenames on GtvV'iew Portal. []*'Do not use Emoil(s)as primary contact method. t C.. icatrnn information CL Subcontractors: 0 ELEC 0 PLUMB 0 MECH 0 Roof 0 Septic 0 Low Voltage 0 Shutters 0 ELECT from house 0 Gas C.2.Permit Type: Shutters/Doors/Windows El C.8.Fire Sprinkled: C.3.Fire Permit Type: C9.Permit by Affidavit: C.4.Construction Type: C.10.Private Provider. C.5.Occupancy: 0 C11.Threshold Building: C6.Water Service: C12.Vegetation Clearing: C.7.Sewer Service: C n.Re!ateri to DAMAGES INCURRED BY HURRICANE IRMA. 0 Yes C)ti< Section D.Project tjiuiuration D.1.Description of Work(pwidebeiaw): D.2.Project Name(fany). Ventry Window Replacement D.3.Declared Value: $4,500 Remove existing windows and replace with new impact rated windows in like for like openings. D.4.Residential Sq.Ft:` D.4.a.New Const D.4.b.Work Area(Sq.Ft) D.4.c.Work Area (Sq.Ft.) D.4.d.Totals by Area New Const(complete D.4.a.&D.4.t2) #Stories: D.4.b.i.Living: D.4.ci.Living: TOTAL liAng: 0 Addition(Complete0.4.a&D.4b.) #Units: D.4.by.Non-living: D.4rJ.Non-living: TOTALNor-i ig 0 Alteration(Carnpletea4.c) #Bedrooms: TOTAL: 0 TOTAL 0 #Bathrooms: D.5.Commercial Sq.Ft: D.S.a.New Const D.5.b.Work Area(Sq.Ft.) D.S.c Work Area(Sq.Ft.) New Const.(CnmpleteD5.a.&D.5.b) #Stories: Interior. Interior: Addition(CanpteteD..5a&D.5.b.) #Units: Exterior: Exterior: Alteration(CwnpleteDS.c) TOTAL 0 TOTAL 0 SeCOOn E.Staff SeCtiOn E.1.Final Review Date: E.2.Number of Plan Sets: E.3.Review Days: WT 1 ( 5; 10 15 Revised Date:11/29/17 v2 This is page 1 of 3 pages of the Building Permit Application.Please submit all 3 pages when completed. ec Cot BUILDING PERMIT APPUCATION 2800 N. HORSESHOE DR.,NAPLES,FL 34104 I TEL:(239)252-2400 NOTICE OF COLLIER COUNTY ADDITIONAL REGULATIONS NOTICE OF ADDITIONAL RESTRICTIONS: In addition to the requirements of this permit, there may be additional restrictions applicable to this property that may be found in the public records of this County, and there may be additional permits required from other governmental entities such as the Water Management District, State agencies, or Federal agencies. WARNING OF POSSIBLE DEED RESTRICTIONS: The land subject to this permit may be subject to deed, and other restrictions that may limit or impair the landowner's rights. Collier County is not responsible for the enforcement of these restrictions, nor are Collier County employees authorized to provide legal or business advice to the public relative to these restrictions.The landowner or any applicant acting on behalf of the landowner is cautioned to seek professional advice. WARNING OF WORK IN THE COUNTY RIGHT-OF-WAYS:This permit does not authorize construction or installation of any structure or utility, above or below ground, within any right of way or easement reserved for access, drainage or utility purposes.This restriction specifically prohibits fencing,sprinkler systems, landscaping other than sod, signs, water, sewer, cable and drainage work therein. If such improvements are necessary, a separate permit for that purpose must be obtained from the Growth Management Department. NOTICE OF CLEARING RESTRICTIONS: The issuance of a building permit for a single-family dwelling allows up to one (1) acre of native vegetation to be cleared. Clearing more than one (1) acre may be allowed for accessory structures and requires a separate Vegetation Removal Permit. Properties located in the following zoning district overlays may not be allowed to clear one (1) acre: Rural Fringe Mixed Use District (RFMU), Big Cypress Area of Concern (ACSC), and Special Treatment Overlay (ST). There may be additional restrictions related to clearing native vegetation and impacts to wetlands or protected species found on the property. State and Federal agency permits may be required. Contact the Growth Management Department's Environmental Services at (239) 252-2400 for additional information. Issuance of a Demolition Permit for a structure does not authorize removal of vegetation beyond the footprint of the structure. A Demo Permit is not a clearing permit. WORK IN THE SPECIAL FLOOD HAZARD AREA: Be advised that Substantial Damage/Substantial Improvement requirements will apply to structures located in the Special Flood Hazard Area with Finished Floor Elevations below the Base Flood Elevation. By initialing, I am acknowledging that I have read and understand this Notice of Collier County Additional Regulations. Initia s Owner or Agent of Owner's or Contractor's initials are required. Rev 11-29-2017 v2 This is page 2 of 3 pages of the Building Permit Application.Please submit all 3 pages when completed, Cf/) tt BUILDING PERMIT APPUCATION "'"x"°""" 2800 N. HORSESHOE DR., NAPLES,FL 34104 I TEL: (239)252-2400 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF COLLIER COUNTY REGULATIONS Application is hereby made to obtain a permit to do the work and installations as indicated.I certify that no work or installation has commenced prior to the issuance of a permit and that all work will be performed to meet the standards of all laws regulating construction in this jurisdiction.The permit or application fee may have additional fees imposed for failing to obtain permits prior to commencement of construction. The approved permit and/or permit application expires if not commenced within 180 days from the date of issuance.The permittee further understands that only licensed contractors may be employed and that the structure will not be used or occupied until a certificate of occupancy is issued. By signing this permit application, I agree that I have been retained by the owner/permittee to provide contracting services for the trade for which I am listed.Furthermore,it is my responsibility to notify the Building Plan Review and Inspection Division should I no longer be the contractor responsible for providing said contracting services.I further agree that I understand that the review and issuing of this permit does not exempt me from complying with all County Codes and Ordinances. It is further understood that the property owner/permittee is the owner of the permit. Note:An Owner-Builder must complete Sections A and B and the Owner-Builder Affidavit form. SECTIO : • N • or . E 0 OWNER ACKNOWLEDGEMENT. The Contractor may sign as the Agent of Owner so long as -•ntractor's c.J , I ' h • n permits such action: / Andrew M. Wood (Signature of Owner or Ag .f• ner) (Print name of Owner or Agent of Owner) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this day of r it\)Q optel ,20 ($ by PtimciQCiA tut_ 1. (name of person)who is personally known to me,or who—has produced identification(type f ide ification):F L SDLP 11. )--a 13'ls/"1-O(O 1-0 • Notary Signature: k Seal: 4 .P:-{,I I Olfrb:a 5ra e of u,d� i ON B.CO 'r AR OWLEDGEMENT: '-y r °T =xatesSeo ,a �•w 1 A. _ . Contractor) '� ""SC (Print name of Cortractor) L The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this day of pc Ec ,20 I b by 1\0Q cu3 . t... }d (name of person)who is personally known to me,or whoK has produced identification(ty f i entification): (.. A : . a —, — s — - �..,,..... YCR tiNY FaiU Notary Signature: L Seal: _, Notay c-stacL+r'ene, at.k).l• Corr s:ni CC:2b/1,4 ,.. .,'"CN �: MyComm Expres Sep 20 2i.21 F ! O NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT INFORMATI• Per Florida Statutes 713.135 a Notice of Commencement (NOC) is required for construction of improvements totaling more than $2,500,with certain exceptions.For A/C Repairs or Replacements a notice of commencement is required for improvements more than or equal to$7,500.The applicant shall file with the issuing authority prior to the first inspection either a certified copy of the recorded NOC or a notarized statement that the NOC has been filed for recording,along with a copy thereof.In order to comply with the state requirement, permits will be placed in inspection hold until proof of the NOC is filed with the building permitting and inspection department. The issuing authority shall not perform or approve subsequent inspections until the applicant files by mail, facsimile, hand delivery,email or any other means such as certified copy with the issuing authority. WARNING TO OWNER: YOUR FAILURE TO RECORD A NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT MAY RESULT IN YOUR PAYING TWICE FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO YOUR PROPERTY. IF YOU INTEND TO OBTAIN FINANCING, CONSULT WITH YOUR LENDER OR AN ATTORNEY BEFORE RECORDING YOUR NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT. A NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT MUST BE RECORDED AND POSTED ON THE JOB SITE BEFORE THE FIRST INSPECTION. Rev 11-29-2017 v2 This is page 3 of 3 pages of the Building Permit Application.Please submit all 3 pages when completed. E Collier County Payment Slip - Permits Date: March 20, 2018 Contact: AMW CONSTRUCTION SERVICES, INC. PO BOX 940 LEHIGH ACRES, FL 33970-- Owner: VENTRY, DEIRDRE M Permit Location: 709 Palm View DR FEES: Description IApplication Number Permit Number. Fee Paid Fee Structural -Application Fee PRBD20180318752 PRBD2018031875201 $50.00 $0.00 Total: • $50.00 $0.00 Total Owing: $50.00 Bonds: . Item :Type Balance Job Description: REMOVE EXISTING WINDOWS AND REPLACE WITH NEW IMPACT RATED WINDOWS IN LIKE FOR LIKE OPENINGS. 709 Palm View DR' • Collier County Growth Management Division 2800 Horseshoe Drive N. Naples, FL 34104 239-252-2400 RECEIPT OF PAYMENT Receipt Number: 2018484242 Transaction Number: 2018-022990 Date Paid: 03/20/2018 Amount Due: $50.00 Payment Details: Payment Method Amount Paid Check Number Check $50.00 1017 Amount Paid: $50.00 Change / Overage: $0.00 Contact: WOOD, ANDREW M 122 RICHMOND AVE S LEHIGH ACRES, FL 33936 FEE DETAILS: • Fee Description Reference Number Original Amount GL Account Fee Paid Structural - Application Fee PRBD20180318752 $50.00 $50.00 113-138900-322110-000000 Cashier Name: RichardKoenigsknecht Batch Number: 7173 Entered By: AarabhiVarathan COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIVISION / BUILDING REVIEW & INSPECTION 2800 N. Horseshoe Drive, Naples FL 34104 * Phone (239) 252-2400 Outstanding Corrections Date: April 03, 2018 PERMIT NO: PRBD2018031875201 Contact Name: AMW CONSTRUCTION SERVICES, INC. APPLICATION NO: PRBD20180318752 Address: PO BOX 940 JOB SITE ADDRESS: 709 Palm View DR City, State Zip: LEHIGH ACRES, FL 33970-- Fax: <NO FAX NUMBER> Email:Drew@amwconstructionservices.com Dear Applicant: Plans submitted with the referenced permit have been reviewed. We are unable to approve your permit application for the reason(s)indicated below. For Applications Submitted on Paper: • Review the corrections below to identify each document you will need to submit. • All corrections must be clouded. • Corrections to paper documents must be submitted in person; the GMD office receiving corrections is open until 4:30 pm. • Submit 3 sets of corrected documents. • Submit 3 copies of the Letter of Response summarizing the changes made to address each correction comment below. JOB DESCRIPTION: REMOVE EXISTING WINDOWS AND REPLACE WITH NEW IMPACT RATED WINDOWS IN LIKE FOR LIKE OPENINGS. 709 Palm View DR Rejected Review: Structural Review Reviewed By:Tom Umscheid Phone:239-252-2433 Email:TomUmschied@colliergov.net Correction Comment 1: This review shall be considered incomplete pending receipt of requested and required information. Subsequent review(s) may reveal additional deficiencies. Correction Comment 2:Although the product approval numbers have been provided the building official Jonathan Walsh requests that with each submittal provide product approvals from the state of Florida or the Miami/Dade-NOA's for the products being used in this project, information must include the cover sheet showing code compliance,the approved manufacturer specifications,the model number and installation instructions. Correction Comment 3: Per the FBC section 1029 a second exit is required from all sleeping rooms in buildings less than 4 stories in height or shall have other means of protection for the occupants. Windows shall meet the requirements for operation, height from floor and minimum clear opening size per the code. CLEAR EGRESS OPENING SIZE NOT GROSS OPENING OR WINDOW SIZE shall be included in the plans submitted for review for all sleeping rooms or indicate other method of escape or protection. ATTENTION: Collier County Plan Review and Inspections routinely reviews all outstanding permit applications in order to determine their status. The review process includes appropriate responses from the permit applicant when the permit cannot be approved. When the applicant is advised of deficiencies and does not respond within 180 days with corrected plans or an appeal to the Code Enforcement Board, the permit application will be canceled as per Collier County Ordinance 2002-01, Section, 104.5.1.1 to 104.5.1.4(as amended). ��a3 GumphJack From: GumphJack Sent: Wednesday, September 27, 2017 9:06 AM To: Andrew Wood Cc: GumphJack Subject: RE:709 Palm View Drive(Deidre Ventry) Hello Andrew, Just a quick note to inquire the progress of the permit. Thanks, Jack Gumph Compliance Officer Collier County Growth Management Depar Unent 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples,Fl 34104 239-252-2468 (Office) 239-438-5195 (Cell) jackgumph@colliergov.net From:Andrew Wood [mailto:drew@amwconstructionservices.com] Sent:Tuesday,August 15, 2017 10:46 PM To:GumphJack<JackGumph@colliergov.net> Subject: RE:709 Palm View Drive (Deidre Ventry) Good morning Jack, I will be re-registered by weeks end and will be submitting for permit next week. I will keep updated on the progress. Thanks, Andrew M. "Drew" Wood AMW Construction Services, Inc. PO Box 940 Lehigh Acres, FL 33970 P: 239-464-0469 drew(a�amwconstructionservices.com CGC 1507208 1 E�L( • On August 9, 2017 at 8:54 AM GumphJack<JackGumph@colliergov.net>wrote: Drew— This is confirming our conversation this date reference 709 Palm View Drive(permitting). Please keep me appraised of your progress on resolution. Thank you, Jack Gumph Compliance Officer Collier County Operations and Regulatory Management Growth Management Department 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, Fl 34104 239-252-2468 (Office) 239-438-5195 (Cell) jackgumph@colliergov.net Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 `' I - GumphJack From: GumphJack Sent: Tuesday, March 20, 2018 10:01 AM To: NoellKevin Cc: GumphJack Subject: RE:Andrew Wood, CLB Case 2018-005 Kevin, Mr.Wood came in and met with me this morning. He did submit the application for permit(#PRBD20180318752). I have conferred with Evy and we are removing the case from the CLB scheduled for tomorrow. Thanks, Jack Gumph Compliance Officer, Contractor Licensing Collier County Growth Management Department 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples,FL 34104 239-252-2468 (Office) 239-438-5195 (Cell) Jack.Gumph@CollierCountyFL.gov Co -le-r County Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. C:26 1 GumphJack From: GumphJack Sent: Wednesday,April 18, 2018 3:06 PM To: Andrew Wood Cc: GumphJack Subject: 709 Palm View DR Andrew—Reference 709 Palm View Drive, I have noticed a `Rejected'status on the permit. Would you please address the corrections required to resolve. Thank you, Jack Gumph Compliance Officer,Contractor Licensing Collier County Growth Management Department 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 239-252-2468 (Office) 239-438-5195 (Cell) Jack.Gumph@CollierCountyFL.gov CAT County Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. GumphJack From: GumphJack Sent: Monday,July 09, 2018 10:07 AM To: Andrew Wood Cc: GumphJack Subject: 709 Palm View DR Attachments: Corrections Letter Paper-Outstanding Corrections.pdf Andrew, I am following up on 709 Palm View DR permit. I have attached the'Corrections Letter'. Please submit the corrections as soon as possible to complete this permit process. Thank you, Jack Gumph Compliance Officer,Contractor Licensing Collier County Growth Management Department 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 239-252-2468 (Office) 239-438-5195 (Cell) Jack.Gumph@CollierCountyFL.gov Co 1Er County Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 0-6 1 COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIVISION / BUILDING REVIEW &INSPECTION 2800 N. Horseshoe Drive, Naples FL 34104 * Phone (239) 252-2400 Outstanding Corrections Date: April 03, 2018 PERMIT NO: PRBD2018031875201 Contact Name: AMW CONSTRUCTION SERVICES, INC. APPLICATION NO: PRBD20180318752 Address: PO BOX 940 JOB SITE ADDRESS: 709 Palm View DR City, State Zip: LEHIGH ACRES, FL 33970-- Fax: <NO FAX NUMBER> Email:Drew@amwconstructionservices.com Dear Applicant: Plans submitted with the referenced permit have been reviewed. We are unable to approve your permit application for the reason(s) indicated below. For Applications Submitted on Paper: • Review the corrections below to identify each document you will need to submit. • All corrections must be clouded. • Corrections to paper documents must be submitted in person;the GMD office receiving corrections is open until 4:30 pm. • Submit 3 sets of corrected documents. • Submit 3 copies of the Letter of Response summarizing the changes made to address each correction comment below. JOB DESCRIPTION: REMOVE EXISTING WINDOWS AND REPLACE WITH NEW IMPACT RATED WINDOWS IN LIKE FOR LIKE OPENINGS. 709 Palm View DR Rejected Review: Structural Review Reviewed By:Tom Umscheid Phone:239-252-2433 Email:TomUmschied@colliergov.net Correction Comment 1:This review shall be considered incomplete pending receipt of requested and required information. Subsequent review(s) may reveal additional deficiencies. Correction Comment 2:Although the product approval numbers have been provided the building official Jonathan Walsh requests that with each submittal provide product approvals from the state of Florida or the Miami/Dade-NOA's for the products being used in this project, information must include the cover sheet showing code compliance,the approved manufacturer specifications,the model number and installation instructions. Correction Comment 3: Per the FBC section 1029 a second exit is required from all sleeping rooms in buildings less than 4 stories in height or shall have other means of protection for the occupants.Windows shall meet the requirements for operation, height from floor and minimum clear opening size per the code. CLEAR EGRESS OPENING SIZE NOT GROSS OPENING OR WINDOW SIZE shall be included in the plans submitted for review for all sleeping rooms or indicate other method of escape or protection. ATTENTION: Collier County Plan Review and Inspections routinely reviews all outstanding permit applications in order to determine their status. The review process includes appropriate responses from the permit applicant when the permit cannot be approved. When the applicant is advised of deficiencies and does not respond within 180 days with corrected plans or an appeal to the Code Enforcement Board, the permit application will be canceled as per Collier County Ordinance 2002-01, Section, 104.5.1.1 to 104.5.1.4(as amended). Et39 a ,,..1 0 e) C. a 0 A ' 0 ^ — .s..V N LI +NVa t r, tE"} •o Gco � —°' G fr C vC, rt "'f 2,• r. ' Q IV Q 01:1 r te0 CA '. r* t Wi C"., r ?DI O i% et r.. t ,..... ....4. ..., C 0.. 0 7t s 0 0k til V 0 l A0- � r `J tP ...• 0, n T3 r # fl0 C• C H a 0 cT 0 P hfo, c 5 v G C 0 ry G V' t ✓ V 0cA t� (1 0 G r, ro �' ps N ' ' a - 0 6 f O• 0 Q r -.• k+. -6- r.. tid Sj A V. 0 Ga 0 N G W 0P' O 0 r G H 0 'i. G 0 5 Q st r4 cr Od .+. .. via G 0 Vi G a p. would have been fraud or a willful violation if committed in Collier County or within the respective City. 4.2.4. Fraud. 4.3. Disciplinary Proceedings,including Minor Violations. 4.3.1. There are three (3) categories of violations: (i) Violations of subsection 489.127(1), Florida Statutes; Violations of subsection 489.132(1), Florida Statutes; and (iii) other violations within the jurisdiction of the Contractor's Licensing Board. a. Subsection 489.127(1),Florida Statutes, is incorporated herein. (Lack of required license,certificate,or registration). The following are designated to enforce subsection 487.127(1),Florida Statutes:Collier County Building Official,all License Compliance Officers, the Chief Building Inspector, Chief Electrical Inspector, Chief Plumbing/Mechanical Mechanical, and/or other inspectors authorized from time-to-time by the Building Official. Procedures specified in this Ordinance shall apply except to the extent, if any, that Section 489.127 or Section 489.132, may require different procedure(s). The penalties for each uncontested violation of subsection 489.127(1) and/or 489.132(1), Florida Statutes, are three hundred dollars ($300.00)for the first uncontested violation and five hundred dollars($500.00) for each subsequent uncontested violation by the same individual or entity. Penalties for contested violations of subsection 489.127(1),Florida Statutes,are as now or hereafter specified in Section 489.127,Florida Statues. Penalties for contested violations of subsection 489.132(1), Florida Statutes, are as now or hereafter specified in Section 489.132, Florida Statutes. The Citation form attached hereto as exhibit "A" is approved, which form may be amended from time-to-time by Resolution of the Board of County Commissioners. b. Minor Violations: The Contractor Licensing Supervisor or designee shall issue a "Notice of Noncompliance" as the County's first response to a minor violation of any provision of any regulatory law,including this Ordinance,when (i)it is reasonable for Staff to assume that the violator,at the time of violation,was not aware of the provision that was violated or it can be assumed that it was not clear to the violator how to comply with the violated provision;and(ii)that violation has not then resulted in economic harm or physical harm to any person;and(iii)the violation has neither adversely affected the public health,safety,or welfare, nor created any significant threat of any such adverse affect. The Notice of Noncompliance should identify the specific provision that was violated, should provide information on how to comply with that provision and should specify a reasonable time for full compliance. The Notice of Noncompliance shall not be accompanied with any immediate threat of any monetary fine or any other disciplinary penalty,but may specify that failure of the violator to correct the violation within the time specified in the Notice for Compliance may result in disciplinary proceedings. Each violation that is not a"minor"violation is a"major"violation. 38 t31 Words st eug§are deleted;words underlined are added. c. Major Violations. The Contractor Licensing Supervisor,or his designee, may initiate disciplinary proceedings against a licensed contractor for major violations of this Ordinance by filing a sworn complaint with the Clerk to the Collier County Board of County Commissioners. d. Failure of Non-State Certified Individual to Promptly Pay Penalty to County. The Collier County Building Department should not issue any permit or any other required authorization to any Collier County Certified individual who then has an obligation to pay a penalty to the County imposed with finality under this Ordinance for any violation of this Ordinance(including a citation that is not contested)and that individual has not paid that penalty in full by the applicable deadline date, plus reimbursement of the County's costs, such as recording fees and court costs. An appeal of uncontested citations stays all such withholdings. e. Failure of Non-State Certified Individual to Meet Permit Conditions. The County's Building Department may withhold issuance of any further permit(s) or any other authorization(s)to any individual who,or entity that,has not then complied with any condition of all County-issued permit(s) issued to that individual or entity, including every follow-up inspection or any other act then capable of being complied with,although late in time. f. Withholding Permit Pulling Privileges of State Certified Contractor. Before the CLB may withhold any permit pulling privilege(s)of a State Certified Contractor,the CLB, after public hearing,must find that the Contractor violated a provision of Section 4.2 of this Ordinance. 4.3.2. Any person who believes that a contractor holding a Certificate of Competency has violated this Ordinance may submit a sworn complaint to the Contractor Licensing Supervisor,or his/her designee. The complaint shall be in substantially the form prescribed by the Contractor Licensing Supervisor. "-_ _... ..... :: _ !,!! . -•- . .... . . - -.... ... , . _ ..._ •. •- . : . . The complaining party shall state with particularity which section(s)of this Ordinance he or she believes has been violated by the contractor and the essential facts in support thereof. 4.3.3. Upon the submission of a sworn complaint,the Contractor Licensing Supervisor, or his/her designee, shall conduct a preliminary investigation and determine whether the complaint submitted warrants the filing of formal charges. If charges are warranted, the Contractor Licensing Supervisor, or his/her designee, shall file the complaint with the Clerk to the Collier County Board of County Commissioners and shall send, by certified mail, return receipt requested,a letter to the licensed contractor at his local address,or if applicable the local agent's address,as shown by the records of the Contractors'Licensing Board,enclosing a copy of the complaint and indicating: a. The name of the complainant; b. The date(s)of the commission of the alleged offense(s); 39 Words are deleted;words underlined are added. • The letter we issued to the contractor has the code sections in which would be considered as the basis for your case. However, ! am including all code sections that could be applied. 101.2 Scope. The provisions of this code shall apply to the construction, alteration, relocation, enlargement, replacement, repair, equipment, use and occupancy, location, maintenance, removal and demolition of every building or structure or any appurtenances connected or attached to such buildings or structures. 101.3 intent. • The purpose of this code is to establish the minimum requirementslo safeguard the public health, safety and• general welfare through structural strength, means of egress facilities, stability, sanitation, adequate light and ventilation, energy conservation, and safety to life and property from fire and other hazards attributed to the built environment and to provide safety to fire fighters and emergency responders during emergency operations. 105.1 Required. Any owner or authorized agent who intends to construct, enlarge, alter, repair, move, demolish, or change the occupancy of a building or structure, or to-erect, install; enlarge, alter, repair, remove, convert or replace any impact- resistant-coverings, electrical, gas, mechanical or plumbing system, the installation of which is regulated by this code, or to cause any such work to be done, shall first make application to the building official and obtain the required permit. 105.3.2 Time limitation of application. • An application fora permit for any proposed work shall be deemed to have been abandoned 180 days after the date of filing, unless such application has been pursued in good faith or a permit has been issued; except that the building official is authorized to grantone or more extensions of time for additional periods not exceeding 90 days - each. The extension shall be requested in writing and justifiable cause demonstrated 105.4.1 Permit intent. A-permit issued shall be construed to be a license to proceed with the work and not as authority to violate, cancel,. alter or set aside any of the provisions of.the technical codes, nor shall issuance of a permit prevent the building official from thereafter requiring a correction of errors in plans, construction or violations of this code. Every permit issued shall become invalid unless the work authorized by such permit is commenced within six months after its issuance, or if the work authorized by such permit is suspended or abandoned for a period of six months after the time the work is commenced. • 105.4.1.1 If work has commenced and the permit is. revoked, becomes-null-and void, or expires because of lack of progress or abandonment, a new permit covering the proposed construction shall be obtained before proceeding with the work. 105.4.1.2 If a new permit is not obtained within 180 days from the date the initial permit became null and void, the • - building official is authorized to require-that any work which has been commenced or completed be removed from the building.site. Alternately, a new permit may be issued on application, providing the work in place and required to complete the-structure meets all applicable'regulations in effect at the time-the initial permit became null and void and any regulations which may have become effective between the date of expiration and the . date of issuance of the new permit. • 105.4.1.3 Work shall be considered to be in active progress when the permit has received an approved inspection within • 180 days. This provision shall-not be applicable in case of civil commotion or strike or-when the building-.work - is halted due directly to judicial injunction, order or similar process. 105.4.1.4 • - • The fee for renewal reissuance and extension of a permit shall be set forth by the administrative authority. • • E33 • - i SECTION 105 PERMITS 105.1 Required. Any owner or authorized agent who intends to k:.onstruct, cnlanze, alter, repair, 1110\ e. demolish. or change the occupancy of a building or structure. or to erect, install, enlarge, alter, repair, remove, convert, or replace any impact resistant coverings, electrical, gas, mechanical or plumbing system, the installation of which is regulated by this code. or to cause any such work to be done. shall first make application to the building official and obtain the required permit. iday, Mar 05,2018 01:30 PM - i Co er County COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD OCTOBER 17, 2018 9:00 A.M. ADMINISTRATIVE COMPLAINT - CASE 2018-10 STEPHEN L BOWLES - MISCONDUCT OF A STATE CERTIFIED CONTRACTOR STEPHEN BOWLES is the License holder for his company JACOSON CUSTOM POOLS, LLC (DBA) JACKSON POOL SERVICE. On 12/29/2017, Collier County Compliance Officer, Rob Ganguli, responded to a report of unpermitted pool construction at 5391 Tamarind Ridge Drive. After speaking with the Building Official, Jonathan Walsh, confirmation was given that the scope of work that was going on required a permit. A permit application was submitted on 4/18/2017. This permit now sits in a Void status, as it was originally rejected, and Mr. Bowles never submitted any corrections. Mr. Bowles is in violation of the Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as amended, Section 4.2.2, Misconduct of a State Certified Contractor, which states "Willfully violating the applicable building codes or laws of the state, city or Collier County". He is going in front of the board to hear possible disciplinary actions due to his violation. BEFORE THE COLLIER COUNTY CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, CONTRACTORS' LICENSING BOARD Petitioner, V. Case Number: 2018-10 License Number: CPC1456458 BOWLES, STEPHEN L Jackson Custom Pools, LLC(Dba)Jackson Pool Service Respondent. ADMINISTRATIVE COMPLAINT Collier County(County)files the Administrative Complaint against Stephen L Bowles (Respondent), a State licensed Certified Pool/Spa Contractor(license#CPC1456458), and states the following facts and allegations in support of the cited violations below: 1. The Respondent is currently licensed by State of Florida as a Certified Pool/Spa Contractor with License number CPC1456458. 2. Under the provisions of Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as amended,Section 4.2.2.,the following actions by a holder of a State Certified Pool/Spa Contractor/Collier County registered Contractor(#LCC20120001055) shall constitute misconduct and grounds for discipline pursuant to Section 4.3. a. On 12/29/2016, Rob Ganguli,Collier County Contractor License Officer responded to the address of 5391 Tamarind Ridge Dr. Naples, FL. 34119 on a report of un-permitted pool construction.At the location, Officer Ganguli observed renovation work to existing pool as well as construction of a new hot tub.On site database research revealed no permits in issuance for work observed. Chief Building Official,Jonathan Walsh determined a permit was required and a STOP WORK ORDER was posted.Jackson Pool Service was advised of ti. violation of STOP WORK ORDER and requirement for permit. Permit Application# PRBD20170414670 was submitted on 04/18/2017. b. The permit application was'Rejected'and certain corrections required. c. The permit application expired on 12/26/2017. d. No attempt to resolve the issue has been taken by the contractor. 3. Thereafter, pursuant to Collier County Ordinance 2006-46,as amended,Section 4.3.2.and Section 4.3.3.,the complaint was investigated and found sufficient cause to file formal charges. 4. Collier County brings the following charge in this formal complaint against the Respondent. COUNT I 5. Collier County Ordinance 2006-46,as amended,Section 4.2.2., Misconduct—State Certified Contractors, states: "Willfully violating the applicable building codes or laws of the state,city or Collier County." WHEREFORE,the Petitioner asserts the above facts and charges are grounds for disciplinary action under Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as amended,Section 4.2.,as amended,and WHEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing,the Petitioner respectfully requests the Collier County Contractors' Licensing Board to find the Respondent guilty of the violations charged. Dated: I 67 11 Signed: ` �( �.umph Collier County Contractors' Licensing Supervisor or Designee of C.L.B. CASE # 2018 — 10 Stephen L Bowles Jackson Custom Pools, LLC (Dba) Jackson Pool Service TABLE OF CONTENTS El / E3 — Formal Complaint. E4 / E5 — Collier County Certificate Detail Report. E6 / E7 — State of Florida, Department of Business & Professional Regulation Licensee Detail E8 / E15 - State of Florida, Division of Corporations, Florida Profit Corporation Detail. E16 / E17 — Notice of Hearing sent via Certified Mail E18 / E19 - Signed Return Receipt for accepted Certified Mail. E20 / E26 — Case Detail Report for current Misconduct Violation. E27 / E31 — Photographs E32 — Chief Building Official, Jonathan Walsh (requirement-permit) E33 — NOTICE OF NON COMPLIANCE E34 / E36 — PERMIT APPLICATION # PRBD20170414670 (04/18/2017) E37 — Outstanding Corrections Notice, dated 4/26/2017 E38 — Outstanding Corrections Notice, dated 6/29/2017 E39 — Letter to Stephen Bowles, dated 10/26/2018 E40 — EXPIRED Application Notice, dated 2/21/2018 E41 / E43 - Emails with attachments E44— Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as amended, Section 4.2.2., for MISCONDUCT— State Certified Contractors E45 /E46 - Collier County Ordinance 2006-46, as amended, Section 4.3. for Disciplinary Proceedings E47 — Florida Building Code (A) 105.3.2, "Time Limitations of Application". • Contractors' Licensing Board 2800 North Horseshoe Dr. Naples, Fl.34104 Complaint Number-2018-10 Complainant:Any person who believes that a Contractor holding a State Certification or Certificate of competency has violated Collier County Ordinance 2006-46,as amended,may submit a sworn complaint to the Contractor Licensing supervisor,or his/her designee.The complaint shall be in substantially the form prescribed by the Contractor Licensing Supervisor.The complainant shall pay a fee of$50.00 to defray the costs of administering the complaint,at the time of filing the complaint.The complaining party shall state with particularity which section(s)of this Ordinance he or she believes has been violated by the contractor and the essential facts in support thereof. Complaint: Please print or type and return signed copies of the complaint. Date:October 3,2018 Against: Contractor's Name:BOWLES,STEPHEN L Phone:239-450-0223 Business Name:Jackson Custom Pools,LLC(Dba)Jackson Pool Service License Number if known:Certified Pool/Spa Contractor(State license#CPC1456458), Collier County Competency number: LCC20120001055 Contractor's Business Address: 11860 Lacy Lane Fort Myers,FL 33966 Filed By: Name: Collier County Contractors' Licensing Office(Jack Gumph) Address:2800 N. Horseshoe Dr., Naples, FL 34104 Business Phone: 239-252-2468 Address where work done:5391 Tamarind Ridge Dr. City: NAPLES, FL 34119 County: COLLIER Date of contract: Unknown Date job started: Unknown Date job completed or new home occupied: Unknown Were there plans and specifications? Unknown Is there a written contract?Unknown. If yes, amount of Contract: Unknown Has Contractor been paid in full? Unknown. If not,what amount? Unknown Was a Building Permit obtained? NO—APPLICATION ONLY Building Permit number if known: PRBD20170414670—APPLI. Have you communicated by letter with the licensee?YES Date:8/17/2018. Do you have a reply? YES Please attach to this form all copies of the purchase agreement, building contract, home improvement contract, copies of receipts and/or cancelled checks available and any additional evidence to substantiate your allegations. List any subsections of Section 4 of Collier County Ordinance number 90- 105, as amended,which, in your opinion, have been violated by the contractor which is the subject of this complaint, (list subsection number): Collier County Ordinance 2006-46,as amended, Section 4.2.2., Misconduct—State Certified Contractors,states:"Willfully violating the applicable building codes or laws of the state,city or Collier County." Please state the facts which you believe substantiate your charge of misconduct against the subject contractor. List facts separately for each subsection number above: A. On 12/29/2016,Robin Ganguli, Collier County Contractor License Officer responded to the address of 5391 Tamarind Ridge Dr. Naples, FL.34119 on a report of un-permitted pool construction. At the location,Officer Ganguli observed renovation work to existing pool as well as construction of a new hot tub.On site database research revealed no permits in issuance for work observed.Chief Building Official,Jonathan Walsh determined a permit was required and a STOP WORK ORDER was posted.Jackson Pool Service was advised of violation of Stop Work Order and requirement for permit. Permit Application#PRBD20170414670 was submitted on 04/18/2017.The permit application was 'Rejected'and certain corrections required.The permit application EXPIRED on 12/26/2017. No attempt to resolve the issue has been taken by the contractor. (Complainant's signature) State of FLORIDA County of COLLIER Sworn to(or affirmed)and subs ribed before me this c-1tir‘ day of CIA `Q.Q.Ar 2018, by (signature of person making statement). lir IWO ►.�� (signature of Notary Public) Print,type or stamp commissioned name of Notary Public: Li t Personally known or produced identification 2o, Y Puk, ULLA DAMS * MY COMMISSION#F'F 980149 *0 '7' � EXPIRES:May 6,2020 License Application Status-CityView Portal Page 1 of 1 GiviD Public Portal License Application Status Note:You can collapse and expand individual sections by clicking the header of the section you wish to collapse/expand. - License Application Summary Application Number: LCC20120001055 Business Name: JACKSON CUSTOM POOLS LLC(DBA)JACKSON POOL SERVICE License Type: Contractor Application Status: Active Description of Business: 10/4/13-QUALIFIER(JASON A.WILKINS)NO LONGER QUALIFING COMPANY AS OF 8/31/13 PER LETTER TO FILE. Mailing Address: 13401 RICKENBACKER PARKWAY FT MYERS FL 33913 — Issuances Type Date Issued ;Date Expires !Status Number SWIMMING POOL COMMERCIAL- 10/03/2018 08/31/2020 Active 201400002077 CERTIFED 'SWIMMING POOL COMMERCIAL- 03/15/2012 08/31/2013 Cancelled 201200000559 CERTIFED — Submittals There are no submittals for this license application. _ Reviews There are no reviews for this license application. _ Insurance Producer Type Policy Effective Date Expiry Date Limit ALAN WILLIAMS& General Liability GL001617105 11/21/2015 11/21/2018 $2,000,000.00 ASSOC INSUR AGENCY INC Expiration Processed: No • Producer Phone Number: 239-418-1100 ALAN WILLIAMS& .Worker's TWC3586234 11/04/2015 11/04/2018 ASSOC INSUR E Compensation AGENCY INC Expiration Processed: No Producer Phone Number: 239-418-1100 ELI http://cvportal.colliergov.netlCityViewWeb/License/Status?licenseId=128325 10/4/2018 Name I Description JACKSON CUSTOM POOLS LLC(DBA)JACKSON POOL SERV Start Date 03/15/2012 Type Contractor End Date 03/15/2013 • Inspector Submitted On [03/15/2012 Jurisdiction Collier County Department Operations Activity Description 1014/13-QUALIFIER(JASON A.WILKINS) NO LONGER QUALIFING COMPANY AS OF 8/31/13 PER LETTER TO FILE. - Suggest Mailing Address I Exclude from Auto-Suggest? Add this Mailing Address as a Location I I Add Contact Number Mailing Address 113401 RICKENBACKER PARKWAY T Contact Number Ext Primary (239)425-0300 Address Line 2 Cell (239)848-0371 Address Line 3 I Fax (239)425-0251 City/State/Zip FT MYERS FL 1.• 133913 Country iv Email 1 - Preferred Contact Method Receive SMS Text Show More Fields 1 Notifications? — Confidential? Contractor Attributes Contractor Type Business DOB Drivers License Number Sponsorship Appliction Date Workers Competionsation i • Business Tax Receipt? Yes Expiran Date 1 Location Add Related Parcels and Addresses ' Add a Locatio To link a location to this Licensee,enter location information below. CityView will suggest possible matches as you type: Link i Description Ty Proportv Alert Primary?! Status_ Contacts Add new person or business to Address Book I Go to Alerts Add a Contact To link a contact to this Licensee,enter contact information below. CityView will suggest possible matches as you type: 'BOWLES,STEPHEN L., Address:1109 THOMPSON AVE, Phone:(239) 368-1555, Licensee# LCC20110001614 Go Inn T Description ContactAlert End Date Primary?' Clsde) Qualifier BOWLES,STEPHEN L.,Address:1109THOMPSO—N AVE, Pho Qualifier WILKINS,JASONALLAN,Address:8080 PELICAN ROAD,Ph 08131/2013 ..... Applicant JACKSON CUSTOM POOLS LLC(DBA)JACKSON POOL SERV 1.4.± DBPR-BOWLES, STEPHEN L; Doing Business As: JACKSON POOL SERVICE, Cert... Page 1 of 2 8:17:15 AM 10/4/2018 Licensee Details Licensee Information Name: BOWLES, STEPHEN L (Primary Name) V440-444'444 44:444- ra JACKSON POOL SERVICE (DBA Name) Main Address: 1109 THOMPSON AVE LEHIGH ACRES Florida 33972 County: LEE License Mailing: LicenseLocation: 11860 LACY LANE FORT MYERS FL 33966 County: LEE License Information License Type: Certified Pool/Spa Contractor Rank: Cert Pool License Number: CPC1456458 Status: Current,Active Licensure Date: 05/16/2002 Expires: 08/31/2020 Special Qualifications Qualification Effective Commercial Pool/Spa 05/16/2002 Contractor Construction Business 02/20/2004 Types of Work Licensee Can Perform Commercial Pool/Spa Contractor This contractor can build or repair any swimming pool or spa, both public and private. This contractor's scope of work includes the installation and repair of equipment, work on interior finishes, the installation of package pool heaters, the installation of perimeter and filter piping, and the construction of equipment rooms or housing for pool/spa equipment. This contractor cannot make direct connections to water or sewer lines. Water treatment and cleaning that does not require the installation, construction, replacement, or modification of equipment does not require a license. Filters may be changed without a license. Alternate Names https://www.myfloridalicense.com/LicenseDetail.asp?SID=&id=47D21356DBC41 B4EA3... 10/4/2018 • DBPR-BOQVLES, STEPHEN L;Doing Business As: JACKSON POOL SERVICE,Cert... Page 2 of 2 View Related License Information View License Complaint 2601 Blair Stone Road,Tallahassee FL 32399 :: Email: Customer Contact Center:: Customer Contact Center: 850.487.1395 The State of Florida is an AA/EEO employer.Copyright 2007-2010 State of Florida.Privacy Statement Under Florida law,email addresses are public records.If you do not want your email address released in response to a public-records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact the office by phone or by traditional mail.If you have any questions,please contact 850.487.1395.*Pursuant to Section 455.275(1),Florida Statutes,effective October 1,2012,licensees licensed under Chapter 455,F.S.must provide the Department with an email address if they have one.The emails provided may be used for official communication with the licensee. However email addresses are public record.If you do not wish to supply a personal address,please provide the Department with an email address which can be made available to the public. • https://www.myfloridalicense.com/LicenseDetail.asp?SID=&id=47D213 56DB C41 B 4EA3... 10/4/2018 sunbiz.org -Florida Department of State Page 1 of 1 Florida Department of State DIVISION OF CORPORATIONS fr'`.'`` , ! •VVI _ J ;° Previous on List Next on List Return to List Fictitious Name Search Filing History Submit Fictitious Name Detail Fictitious Name JACKSON POOL SERVICE Filing Information Registration Number G14000030333 Status ACTIVE Filed Date 03/26/2014 Expiration Date 12/31/2019 Current Owners 1 County MULTIPLE Total Pages 2 Events Filed 1 FEI/EIN Number NONE Mailing Address 13401 RICKENBACKER PARKWAY FORT MYERS,FL 33913 Owner Information JACKSON CUSTOM POOLS,LLC 13401 RICKENBACKER PARKWAY FORT MYERS,FL 33913 FEI/EIN Number:27-2419419 Document Number:L10000038067 Document Images 03/26/2014--Fictitious Name Filing View image in PDF format 11/13/2014—CHANGE NAME/ADDRESS View image in PDF format Previous on List Next on List Return to List Fictitious Name Search Filing History Submit Florida Department of State,Division of Corporations http://dos.sunbiz.org/scripts/ficidet.exe?action=DETREG&docnum=G14000030333&rdoc... 10/4/2018 rg) • Detail by Entity Name Page 1 of 2 Florida Department of State DIVISION OF CORPORATIONS /.ors; Department of State / Division of Corporations / Search Records I Detail By Document Number/ Detail by Entity Name Florida Limited Liability Company JACKSON POOL SERVICE LLC Filing Information Document Number L10000038067 FEI/EIN Number 27-4970969 Date Filed 04/08/2010 State FL Status ACTIVE Last Event LC NAME CHANGE Event Date Filed 04/04/2018 Event Effective Date 09/25/2017 Principal Address 11860 Lacy Lane FORT MYERS, FL 33966 Changed:09/25/2017 Mailing Address 11860 Lacy Lane FORT MYERS, FL 33966 Changed:09/25/2017 Registered Agent Name&Address Goede Adamczyk Deboest Cross 11860 Lacy Lane FORT MYERS, FL 33966 Name Changed:04/30/2018 Address Changed:09/25/2017 AuthorizedPerson(s)Detail Name&Address Title MGR Hall, Kimberly 11860 Lacy Lane FORT MYERS,FL 33966 El http://search.sunbiz.org/Inquiry/CorporationSearch/SearchResultDetail?inquirytype=Entity... 10/4/2018 Detail by Entity Name Page 2 of 2 Annual Reports Report Year Filed Date 2016 04/27/2016 2017 09/25/2017 2018 04/30/2018 Document images 04/30/2018—ANNUAL REPORT View image in PDF format 04/04/2018—LC Name Change View image in PDF format 09/25/2017—REINSTATEMENT View image in PDF format 04/27/2016—ANNUAL REPORT View image in PDF format 11/30/2015—REINSTATEMENT View image in PDF format 10/09/2014—LC Name Change View image in PDF format 03/25/2014—REINSTATEMENT View image in PDF format 02/06/2012—ANNUAL REPORT View image in PDF format 03/11/2011—ADDRESS CHANGE View image in PDF format 01/27/2011—ANNUAL REPORT View image in PDF format 04/08/2010—Florida Limited Liability View image in PDF format Florida Department of State,Division of Corporations EiD http://search.sunbiz.org/Inquiry/CorporationSearch/SearchResultDetail?inquirytype=Entity... 10/4/2018 (4) (RequesN. 3 , 11 , (Address) cc Ji '1 1432660 (Addies (City/Staze, n 01/YA/IE!--U102S——00E1 **25.00 El PICK-UP MAIL cbusines_, Liit 4 r...m:2) (Docuri it e2xD Certified Copies Critificitcs of Status z. Special Instructions to Filing C r: .7.141.• Crily V SULY'r,'F- 1-\!'R 05 ?Ali E ti • • CON/ER Li7m-r."-'' TO: Registration Section Division of Corporations SUBJECT: 0015 1.iaLility Company The enclosed Articles of Amendment and lee(s)are submitted for filing. Please return all corre.spondence coieerning this c.rdt.7.r to the 7-7 C_Cr7-35 S— i iiineO )';:rson .r.)1 Arit e- (ixt:GS l'Iml/Company Address ) ' (M(2,:liid Zip Code \• C r csn 13-mail ado,es:;:-to be used for futu annual report notification) For further information concerning this inntter,plense,cid!: at( ) 2i 5o Name ol Pe, Area(:)))..! P:iyhine Telephone Number Enclosed is a check for the l'illowin? amount: L ' 25.00 Filing Fee E .-;30.00 Filing Fee fi CI 555.00 Filing Fee& El $60.00 Filing Fee, Certificate of Status Col-tilted Copy Certificate of Status& is rnc:10,t':1) Certified Copy (additional copy is enclosed) M. LTNC A nnPFQS: STREET/COURIER ADDRESS: Registration b ion Registration Section Division of Corporations Diviaun of Corporations P.O. I.ox (Si?? Clinn Buil)Thc Ttlilah) .::e 7231.1 r! N.,.ect]:b..:Center Circle "i'rllinhassee,_FL 32301 Ele2- ARTICLES OF AMENDMENT TO ARTICLES CF ^. AMZATION '137n. e (ftiame of rhe t_in,i(cd I,iabiikm Companv as it now appears on our records.) I' n (A ods Limited Lability Company) The Articles of Organization for this Limited Liability Company were filed on rn Oce b jo and assigned Florida document number ion 3c6 6 `--r This amendment is submitted to amend the following: A. If amending name,enter the new name of the limited li::hilit" company here: The new name must be r,istinguishahle and contain the words"Limited l.i::hiliiv Company,"the designation"LLC"or the abbreviation"L.L.C." Enter new principal offices address,if applicable: (Principal office address `11'7 B"A STR FET AD:0 RF.`'P • Enter new mailing address,if applicable: (Mailing address MA YBEA POSTOFFIC IF,Bea )O '`- -t;' I . , • B. If amending the registered agent and/or regktnred om'e address on our records, enter the nam of the..new registered agent and/or the re,'rr'pistered ice irrl iter ]sere Name of Nev.,PetTictc:red A cent: -. ' New Registered( " rs: Err,'r Florida sneer address ,Florida Carr, Zip rode New RegisteredApent's Signatnrt',it ch annino Pet4ictered Agent: I hereby accept the appointment as registered agent and agree to act in this capacity. If rrther agree to comply with the provisions of all statutes relative to the proper and complete performance of my duties, and I am familiar with and accept the obligations of my pori!ion a.s rcrti cterc'd open: as provided for in Chapter 605, F.S. Or, if this document is beingfiled to merely ret/,','.." cr v:C!!::'S]ii 1%:,'register Iri.'S.C, !/lereoy confirm that the limited liability company has been r: :2 • r?!'�) . .. If Changing Registered Agent,Siennrure of New Registered Aeent Page I of 3 E13 If amending Authorized Person(s) authorized to manape, enter the title, name,and address of each person being added or removed from our recons: MGR= Manager AMBR= Authorized Member Title Name Address Type of Action 'D Add ❑ Remove 0 Change Add ❑Remove ❑Change ❑Add • 0 Remove bCha[%g ❑•Adds. • - 1 • ❑Reve i.. 714 • ❑Change • ❑Add ❑Remove O Change ❑Add 0 Remove ❑ Change Page 2 of 3 ,/ D. If amending any other information,enter ehange(s)here: (Attach additional sheets, if necessary) —a r-. t• far eta,. !a, ! , E. Effective date,if other than the date of filing: (optional):?;.. . - (if an effective date is listed,the date must he specific and cannot be prior to date of filing or more than 90 days after filing.),Pursuanl4 605.0207(3)(b) Mote: If the date inserted in this block does not meet the applicable statutory filing requirements,this date will not be listed as the document's effective date on the Department of State's records. If the record specifies a delayed effective date, but not an effective time, at 12:01 a.m. on the earlier of: (b) The 90th day after the record is filed. Dated 3 cli p 1 , :u:uw„r r c;uti . eve of a member inicd mine of si•gr.ec Page 3 of 3 ':,ding r't'e: $25,00 V CO err �✓o'114..H.ty 4-018 tit °la it tgernent Planning& Regulation Operations Depart irmcnt tsing Section Certified Mail#7017 0530 0000 8339 6194 Date:August 14,2018 Stephen Bowles Jackson Pool Service 11860 Lacy Lane Fort Myers,FL 33966 Permit Application:PRBD20170414670,Application Date: 04/18/2017(VOID PERMIT APPLI.) Job Description: master pool plan.provide site specific design,tdh,pump make,model and curve, barrier protection,deck material and light selection remodeling of existing pool.barrier: n/a pool built in 1982 Job Location: 5391 Tamarind Ridge Dr,Naples,FL 34119 Dear Mr.Bowles, A complaint has been filed against you by the above referenced entity.A hearing of this Complaint will be held by the Contractors'Licensing Board on Wednesday,October 17,2018 at 9:00 AM in the Board of County Commissioner's Room,Third Floor,Administration Building (W. Harmon Turner Bldg.),at 3301 East Tamiami Trail,Naples,Florida 34112.Your presence before the Collier County Contractors'Licensing Board is required at this time. The packet you will receive marked composite exhibit"A"will be delivered to the members of the Contractors'Licensing Board one week prior to the hearing.If you wish to prepare a defense packet and have it delivered in conjunction with composite exhibit"A",you must make fifteen copies and have them in our office by 8:00 AM on Wednesday,one week prior to the hearing.In your packet,you may give a summary of events. At this meeting,you may present evidence and be represented by an attorney of your choice. In the event the Contractors'Licensing Board finds you in violation of Section(s)22-201.1(2)of Collier County Ordinance#90-105,as amended,the range of disciplinary sanctions which may be imposed are from an oral reprimand to a suspension or revocation of your Collier County Certificate issuance(N/A),and/or suspension or revocation of your permit privileges against your State license#CPC 1456458. -Sincerely, L. Jac Gtimph edlliertounty Contractors' Licensing Operations and Regulatory Management,Growth Management Department 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr. Naples,FL.34104 2018 FLORIDA LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY ANNUAL REPORT FILED DOCUMENT#L10000038067 Apr 30, 2018 Entity Name: JACKSON POOL SERVICE LLC Secretary of State CC3430105773 Current Principal Place of Business: 11860 LACY LANE FORT MYERS, FL 33966 Current Mailing Address: 11860 LACY LANE FORT MYERS, FL 33966 US FEI Number: 27-4970969 Certificate of Status Desired: No Name and Address of Current Registered Agent: GOEDE ADAMCZYK DEBOEST CROSS 11860 LACY LANE FORT MYERS,FL 33966 US The above named entity submits this statement for the purpose of changing its registered office or registered agent,or both,in the State of Florida. SIGNATURE: BRIAN CROSS 04/30/2018 Electronic Signature of Registered Agent Date Authorized Person(s) Detail : Title MGR Name HALL,KIMBERLY Address 11860 LACY LANE City-State-Zip: FORT MYERS FL 33966 I hereby certify that the information indicated on this report or supplemental report is true and accurate and that my electronic signature shall have the same legal effect as if made under oath;that tam a managing member or manager of the limited liability company or the receiver or trustee empowered to execute this report as required by Chapter 605,Florida Statutes;and that my name appears above,or on an attachment with all other like empowered. SIGNATURE:KIMBERLY HALL MGR 04/30/2018 Electronic Signature of Signing Authorized Person(s)Detail Date _ m ,e '., .. Coer County Growth Management Department 2800 N.Horseshoe Drive• Naples, Florida 34104 13-138930-51' 7017 0530 0000 8339 6194 a' _ Yackson Pool Service LLC, Stephen Bowles C/O Registered Agent Goede Adamczyk Deboest Cross 6609 Willow Park Dr#201 Naples, FL 34109 U.S: Postal ServicetM E, ibER.COMPLETE THIS SECTION COMPLETE THIS SECTION ON DELIVERY C ,.,. .. ERTIFIED MAIL° RECEIPT , i Complete items 1,2,and 3. A. Signature Q- Domestic Mail Only a Print your name and address on the reverse Agent F�% y' , -i•r ou r f , 0 Addressee so that we can return the card to you. �-" F (Tr.i Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, B. Received by(Printed Name} C. Date of Delivery m certified Mail, Fee or on the front if space permits. m $ Article Addressed to: D. Is delivery address different from item 1? 0 Yes `O Extra Services rS Fees(check hex,add fee as appropriate) ) E)�-J 1�t}�tnC 2 yr,pC 13jo('51-, CQQSS If YES,enter delivery address below: 0 No ❑Re um Rete pt(el tropq) $ ^� ❑Return Receipt(electronic) $ P (j_I ©q W i 1 l vw?he z 1.2-t #.AO 1 ,. 2 ❑Certified Mall Restricted Delivsry $ r GYM !� 0 ❑Adult Signature Required $ ❑Adult Signature Restricted Delivery$ N Q�r['�.' s 1 r(_ 3 LI I 69 c3 Postage M ul Total Postage and Fees III III III 111111 11111 1111 1 111 Ill 3. Service Type 0 Priority Mail Express® r. $ ❑Adult Si nature m Sent Tp 9 Q Registered tvtail 1-1 -11 -� L �. - Cdos S ❑Adu ignature Restricted Delivery 0 Registered Mail Restricted:: O Stris an ot.No.,or Box Na 9590 9402 3772 8032 4619 73 [�E�rhfied Mail® Delivery o Certified Mail Restricted Delivery 0 Return Receipt for ___ _ lA_S_�(Iv__t_e•--: �v �❑Collect on DeliveryMerchandise Gift',StateP+4 Jf' i O Article Number(Transfer from service/abe/l D Collect on Delivery Restricted Delivery 2 Signatureonfirmationta 1 �yt� /Z 7 017 0530 0000 8339 619 4 ❑Re nactee Confirmation PSFcrtd fQO,Ariri(2415 PSN 7530,02 D6D•sp;ii ' See F`ieve estricted Delivery Restricted Delivery ' --.. .QR11 I,,i,9111S PSN 7530-02.-.000-9053 Domestic Return Receipt S. Postal Service,' COMPLETE THIS;SECTION COMPLETE THIS SECTION ON DELIVERY ate items 1,2,and 3. t TIFIEDXNI�►IL° RECEIPT, .. r; A. Signature `�. stic Mall Only .z )ur ane and address he on tthee reverse ❑Agent elivet"wt'l atio sou v.feb§(tea ospscot1 this card toet the back of the mailpiece,u. X rl kalik, 0 Addressee =. Received iy(Printed Name) ie front if space permits. C. D to.f Delivery ddressed to: �r� fieri Mail Fee r3 D. Is del very address different from item� �es '7 b1tJ�C 2 ylc,DE-1306'5r, C&Ss If YES,enter delivery address below: ®No ac um'Receip(ha dcopy)ck box,a d fee as appropriate) JW-Theg y IZ.r Postmark IOW rT a® 1 Return Receipt(electronic) $ Hal Certified Mail Restricted Delivery $ Her �� Adult Signature Required $ Iqq Adutt Signature Restricted Delivery$ nage ll 3 Service Type al Postage and Fees i 1111 ill1111/ 1 III11 11I�1111 111111 111 O Adult Signature ❑0 Relgiste ed MaiPMessO nt T 9402 3772 8032 4619 73 Adutified ature Restricted Delivery ❑Delivery elivery Mail Restricted t, p ��5 le'rtified Mails Delive ee an z.No.,or sox Nc. ❑Certified Mail Restricted Delivery 0 Return Receipt for r,j Gl �- �" ❑Collect on Delivery Merchandise -" " t,- y Tiber(Transfer from service label) 0 Collect on Delivery Restricted Delivery ❑Signature Confirmationre fly,State, P-r., • L i 2017 0530 0000 8339 6194 f'z -[ 1 ❑Signature Confirmation " "* .' _stricted Delivery 1,�Zt .'_'w 'b�t- . k'��°�'-. ii , � 4;°�,_ __:: Tracking Number: 7017053C10000S339.6 94 Status ‘Itylif• trn was . st.i.to an•- o,a a;tre scidress C'1,,,or Delivered 12:13 p,:r Au ,; 17.2Ct PLES, L34Oi?, ast Lipastes 11/1/1/11/1/81/11111/111/1/1111111/11111111111F /NNI/f/ I Delivared Text&Email Updates Tracking History August 17,2018,12:10 pm Deiivarect Lett war.Individual NAP:FS F_:4109 Y .• -en- a an n:;vii-loa,at tne address at 12:10 pr cri August 17.2015 In NAP..,cS F_341C? Monday,Aug 20,2018 08:48 AM q " - v affergo .ttet Report Tide: Code Case Details Date: 10/4/2018 8:27:35 AM Case Number: CEMIS20160021439 Case Number: CEMIS20160021439 Status: Investigation Case Type: Misconduct Date &Time Entered: 12/29/2016 3:00:10 PM Priority: Normal Entered By: robinganguli Inspector: JackGumph Case Disposition: Case Pending Jurisdiction: Contractor's Licensing Origin: Complaint Detail Description: Complaint received regarding unpermitted swimming pool renovation I spa construction by Jackson Pool Service/#CPC1456458. Location Comments: 5391 Tamarind Ridge Dr. Naples, FL. 34119 Property 38282200001 Contractor JACKSON CUSTOM POOLS LLC (DBA)JACKSON POOL SERVICE Property Owner JACOBS,TODD Ed Business Management& Budget Office 1 Code Case Details Execution Date 10/4/2018 8:27:35 AM Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments Preliminary Investigation robinganguli 12/29/2016 12/29/2016 Needs 12/29/16.Complaint received regarding lnvestigatio unpermitted swimming pool renovation/spa n construction by Jackson Pool Service/ #CPC1456458 at jobsite located at 5391 Tamarind Ridge Dr. Naples, FL.34119.On site observed renovation work to exising pool as well as construction of a new hot tub. Database research reveals no permits in issuance for work observed.(separate permit issued to another contractor for another scope of work)Photos reviewed by Chief Building Official,Jonathan Walsh who determined a permit was required.STOP WORK order posted.Contacted office manager for Jackson Pool Service,"Kelly",to advise of violation and SWO. Notice of Noncompliance sent to qualifier,Steven Bowles,via e-mail for signing and notarizing. Cont. Investigation RobinGanguli 1/24/2017 1/24/2017 Complete 1/24/17. No permit application submittal received as of yet.Message left and e-mail sent to qualifier for update. Cont. Investigation RobinGanguli 3/20/2017 3/20/2017 Complete 3/20/17. Still no permit application received over 1 month after meeting with Chief Building Official,Jon Walsh,for directives on what work needed to accounted for. Phone message left for qualifier,Stephen Bowles, requesting update. Cont. Investigation RobinGanguli 4/28/2017 4/28/2017 Complete 4/28/17. Permit application #PRBD20170414670 submitted and currently in REJECTED status.Contractor notified of outstanding corrections required. Cont. Investigation RobinGanguli 6/12/2017 6/12/2017 Complete 6/12/17. Permt still in REJECTED status. Inquiry made with qualifier regarding status of corrections and re-submittal. Cont. Investigation RobinGanguli 6/26/2017 6/26/2017 Complete 6/26/17.Corrections submitted. Permit #PRBD20170414670 in UNDER REVIEW status. Cont. Investigation jasonbridwell 6/30/2017 8/9/2017 Complete 08/09/2017: Permit PRBD20170414670 is currently in Rejected status. Cont.Investigation JackGumph 8/17/2017 8/17/2017 Complete 8/17/17.Corrections submitted.Permit #PRBD20170414670 in Rejected status. Corrections Letter sent 06/29/2017. Cont.Investigation JackGumph 9/26/2017 9/26/2017 Complete 09/26/2017 8/17/17.Corrections submitted.Permit #PRBD20170414670 in Rejected status. Corrections Letter sent 06/29/2017. E2 Business Management& Budget Office 2 Code Case Details Execution Date 10/4/2018 8:27:35 AM Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments Cont. Investigation JackGumph 10/26/2017 10/26/2017 Complete 10/26/2017 On this date, I researched the permit to remain in the"Rejected"status.On this date, I drafted a letter to license holder,Stephen Bowles requesting resolution within a 30 day period(or Nov.26,2017). Continues Cont. Investigation JackGumph 11/29/2017 11/29/2017 Complete 11/28/2017 On the date of November 28,2017, I(Jack Gumph)had telephone contact with the Qualifier,Stephen Bowles(239-450-0223) reference the"Rejected"status of the permit. Mr. Bowles acknowledged the receipt of the letter sent by myself reference the permit.Mr. Bowles indicated that he is attempting to resolve the matter with the Building Department at this time. Continues Cont. Investigation JackGumph 3/26/2018 3/26/2018 Complete 03/26/2018 Research indicates the permit Status has changed,dated 2/21/2018 from"REJECTED" to"EXPIRED PERMIT APPLICATION". Notice has been sent to license holder to correct. continues Cont. Investigation JackGumph 4/12/2018 4/12/2018 Complete 04/12/2018 On the date of April 5,2018,I(Jack Gumph) had telephone contact with Lisa Hudec(239- 425-0250), Director,Jackson Pool Service, reference the'Void'Permit Application (#PRBD20170414670). Ms.Hudec related that the company(Jackson Pool Service)had previously supplied Collier County with all engineering reports to resolve the correction request. I subsequently emailed Ms.Hudec the latest 'Outstanding Corrections'letter for her review to ascertain if Jackson Pools have submitted paperwork for the corrections. Continues... Business Management& Budget Office 3 . Code Case Details Execution Date 10/4/2018 8:27:35 AM Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments Cont. Investigation JackGumph 5/4/2018 5/4/2018 Complete 05/04/2018 On the date of April 26,2018, I again spoke to Lisa Hudec(239-425-0250).Ms. Hudec stated that the matter has been turned over to Justin Henderson,Controller/Permit Coordinator for Jackson Pools.That Mr. Henderson is currently working on the project. Cont. Investigation JackGumph 7/26/2018 7/26/2018 Complete 07/26/2018 I (Jack Gumph)per policy have conferred with Joshua Lenio who advised would be sending the"30 Day Letter"to Jackson Pools to commence the process of taking the company before the CLB. I am awaiting Mr. Lenio's drafting of the letter. continues... Cont. Investigation JackGumph 8/10/2018 8/10/2018 Complete 08/10/2018 On the date of August 10,2018, I(Jack Gumph)reviewed the case file. Research indicates that the"30 Day Letter"from 'Permitting'had been sent on the date of February 21,2018 and there was no response as of March 23,2018 then the permit was set to Status-VOID. My follow up on the case file indicated that I had on the dates of 4/5/2018 and 4/26/2018, spoken to Lisa Hudec, Director,Jackson Pool Service reference this matter and was advised they would resolve.Also,on the date of 4/12/2018, I emailed Lisa Hudec, Director with'corrections letter'information and received no response. Research indicates there has been no effort to resolve the permit application matter and the permit sits at STATUS-VOID. On the date of August 10,2018, I drafted correspondence to license holder/Qualifier, Stephen Bowles(State Lic.#CPC1456458, Collier County#LCC20120001055)of a 'Notice to Appear'before the Collier County Contractors'Licensing Board on Wednesday, October 17,2018.The correspondence was sent USPS,Certified Mailing(7017 0530 0000 8339 6170)to Stephen Bowles,Jackson Pool Service, 11860 Lacy Lane, Fort Myers, FL 33966 on this date. C)-3 Business Management&Budget Office 4 Code Case Details Execution Date 10/4/2018 8:27:35 AM Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments Cont. Investigation JackGumph 8/14/2018 8/14/2018 Complete 08/14/2018 On the date of Aug. 14,2018, I(Jack Gumph) researched the USPS Certified Mailing for 7017 0530 0000 8339 6170 and found that the mailing had been determined to be "undeliverable". On the date of Aug. 14,2018, I drafted correspondence to license holder/Qualifier, Stephen Bowles(State Lic.#CPC1456458, Collier County#LCC20120001055)of a 'Notice to Appear'before the Collier County Contractors'Licensing Board on Wednesday, October 17,2018.The correspondence was sent USPS,Certified Mailing(7017 0530 0000 8339 6194)to Stephen Bowles,Jackson Pool Service, do Registered Agent,Goede, Adamczyk, Deboest, Cross,6609 Willow Park Dr,Suite#201, Naples, FL 34109 on this date. 08/14/2018 On the date of Aug. 14,2018, I(Jack Gumph) researched the USPS Certified Mailing for 7017 0530 0000 8339 6170 and found that the mailing had been determined to be "undeliverable". On the date of Aug. 14,2018, I drafted correspondence to license holder/Qualifier, Stephen Bowles(State Lic.#CPC1456458, Collier County#LCC20120001055)of a 'Notice to Appear'before the Collier County Contractors'Licensing Board on Wednesday, October 17,2018.The correspondence was sent USPS,Certified Mailing(7017 0530 0000 8339 6194)to Stephen Bowles,Jackson Pool Service, do Registered Agent,Goede, Adamczyk, Deboest, Cross,6609 Willow Park Dr, Suite#201, Naples, FL 34109 on this date. Ep4 Business Management& Budget Office 5 Code Case Details Execution Date 10/4/2018 8:27:35 AM Desc Assigned Required Completed Outcome Comments Cont. Investigation JackGumph 8/16/2018 8/16/2018 Complete 08/15/2018 On the date of August 15,2018, I(Jack Gumph)traveled to the address of record, 5391 Tamarind Ridge Dr.in an effort to contact the homeowner,Todd Jacobs.At the location,there was no one at home.A business card was left at the door to contact me.While at the location, I did have the occasion to observe the swimming pool in question and found the pool to be completed as far as construction repair and re-modeling. On the same date of August 15,2018, I received a telephone call from the homeowner,Todd Jacobs(239-253-5164). I explained to Mr.Jacobs the circumstances of this case file(#CEMIS20160021439) regarding the Void'status of the permit application submitted by Jackson Pool Service.Mr.Jacobs related that well over a year ago, he previously was aware of the Stop Work Order placed on the pool work.At the time,the contractor(Jackson Pool Service)told him that they had taken care of the issues and then completed the pool work. Mr.Jacobs was unaware of any issues and thought all issues resolved. He(Mr.Jacobs) related that he would contact the contractor about the permit issue and attempt to have them resolve. continues Cont. Investigation JackGumph 8/20/2018 8/20/2018 Complete 08/20/2018 On this date, I(Jack Gumph)researched the USPS Certified Mailing for 7017 0530 0000 8339 6194 and found that successful delivery on the date of August 17,2018 @ 12:10 PM. continues... Cont. Investigation JackGumph 8/24/2018 8/24/2018 Complete 08/24/2018 On this date, I(Jack Gumph)received the USPS Certified Mailing for 7017 0530 0000 8339 6194(Green Card)and found that successful delivery on the date of August 17, 2018 @12:10 PM. Cont.Investigation JackGumph 10/4/2018 10/4/2018 Complete 10/3/2018 This case has been scheuled for the Collier County Contractor Licensing Board, Case# 2018-10,for the date of October 17,2018. Investigation JackGumph 10/17/2018 Pending (PERMIT)Rob G.Case-Jackson Pools-- PRBD20170414670 Business Management& Budget Office 6 Code Case Details Execution Date 10/4/2018 8:27:35 AM Violation Description Status Entered Corrected Amount Comments 4.2 Misconduct State Certified Open 12/29/2016 $0 Contractors Title Reason Result Compliance Fine/Day Condition Business Management& Budget Office 7 1 a �U # _ a I - e s s Y fi h t '—' ' '''' vueY+e e 4' 4 $ i S Y t$. E 27 g. i s ' '4 il I Y ' S ,jif. A _ .. ... 'ts4,:.4, ..:::..t'..,,,:,,..„it,„ e'. 'y 2 ".0 .. 4 11# " "; • 1 'Zy� _ t \ _- nT4. is F . , ,a k" _ _.—...-— ,,, liirpt 1 , ,, ,' ,.. :1. :- ,_ .. - -_-___ — rr apt moi , ., f b t't M. , fix $ , .:,, .,,,,,,,., , ,, ,,, ', .' .:4_ a 1 \� ,' t ` 4 -'47;':--- ''--- •-•-'-'1A,'''''-' \ 40-. - , „4,4 , 7 ,..1,_ ;.. ,.._,,* „..4„,:,:._.,-„,-,,,,.-_:,.„__...-1•,.,4::::,.. -- - - ;,_,,,,,.04----a t ` E7c f /f/ #3 w F � r mss.. s` w .� s Ar.1 . t .. --}i :‘,,,‘, . f Y ff _A ,a.' a fes'« m c4 _ 1 s I,, a z a� r ; :"!;,.-'-!4,---,-:'- ;� f . .: " I If . 'f �., rii,1,',. ',t,.. ,, , ::1 ' .: ri,.._ �. , _-. :-:.:-'''.'„'1:,'-'1'1:- '1...1,-':',...',.., a . ,ir.li w -'''' _*--'i....,1'' '' r {` j 4 r �' .1 ...... ...„...,„_- ittiff --.,--......1 .:,-,-... _.-- !,.... fl ., -- - i . , fi '',, li .,..i.:.-r,'S:',.,..',:.'... ,,....7,,, . . ii,i;!Iii i ,il- N.:: *4-7 i,,. .- i',.. ''" .,., !'''' '' ; : 'g tlitii 1;11 .1 fin.,,,ittc'''.1 4 P*''::::„..;:;717:: .,: ' --------------------- .i,ftli ill ft fit!.fttip-:!,,,,,r ...„,j, _,,,,,1` if: Atigi , )^ `#b � d� t. . litift , 4 0 C C < > C7 I a (3. c) 2) ( 4.4. 0 Cii 0 (--3 ' a) ;k1- 0 C7 C7 a ... "."11rall: il -- > Xi 3> n**- 7* 'Il M .1114 *\,.. 0 (f) ileif EP% 4 c-.. . ---- . _ Pf _- ‘. 1 mm . i IN: ,1/437 0 Zei (:--1)" P-._ \ w • g i If's 010011 p. CD ,....• s7...7 0 ci) C.1: 0 (0) CI fi') --4 ES '1 11- \.!', —I 011111 11110111111 - 7 -0 5D 3 CD CD 0 3- ,Q 0 1111,1111, Allik 7:3 3 '71 Z. .< 0 0 CD :-'' kp -‘, „j1 NMI c —... ia) 0 _ F 2 3 am 5)(1) clom -, m ..t:, 4.4. 0rr, 5 CI) 0 63 (7)- c 0 --t, ..... ? Cl) L'1116.4 ' 7- = - -* MIIIII s C'4 o a ' - ' C 5- (1? — ., ...„. GO - --0 -/ Cl) —7 I CD 5' •=*. a (i) ''' .. 3 -1-.-J .!-,- -- 0 `ir ,---, r•,. la" . = c7 ,,--- — riZ Z X' Raw : : :, p ainot , cr z sa) ''I'' ,„ -1. C) a_ c —7 i 1 ----‹ o •`=-..' \,,,..4 CD 2 0 ct, _ (1:1 77 0 ) OO Z mat < 1 a . malt m i o n —• a) 0 7 —,i .(4) Ir.. nt ,--1" r.1 1 I t—d i/ i GanguliRobin From: WalshJonathan Sent: Thursday, December 29, 2016 3:25 PM To: GanguliRobin Subject: Permitting requirement for pool alteration As discussed the alteration and/or addition to the existing pool we reviewed this morning requires a permit.There are no exemptions from permitting for the scope of work noted. Thank you, Jonathan Walsh,PE Chief Building Official Building Plans Review&Inspections Division Growth Management Department 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, Florida 341.04 239-2.52-2962 www.colliergov.net -ov.net Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. C30. STE.Q t't-F.-N L . Roi c_tS 3:04‘1,(50 KS ' OZ)C SEAL VLtd 'Q it--15 L4 CSS Notice of Noncompliance BE IT KNOWN THAT I,the person whose signature appears below,do hereby formally acknowledge, agree and consent as follows: THAT a certain case,case#: C.1Akt 5 ")..01t--. r,:'..f LI 31 , involving me,has recently been investigated by the Collier County Contractor Licensing Department. THAT the said Department had made it known to me that, in the Department's view,I violated State (Florida Building Code section 105.1)and County(Ordinance 2006-46,as amended,4.1.6&4.1.18) licensing laws in said case, by commencing work without first obtaining a valid Building Permit. Type of Work: _ cc .;t.. .so ATle.- / S.PA- C J % L.s fc,ly Location of work: Sl(1i ` ,•4- i ;iti (2,... t)&e.. OR _ 8s,j ric-ltj_; -t�_ ?Li Itct r Date of work: (,.j.. i /b UA THAT the said Department has explained to me that all contracting work,including BUT NOT LIMITED TO: home or business improvement,residential or commercial,remodeling, renovation,addition, repair,alteration,plumbing,electrical, roofing, pool construction,air conditioning,sheet metal, aluminum and alarm contractor work,all require the issuance of a valid Building Permit prior to commencement. THEREFORE,BEING FULLY ADVISED,I DO AGREE that I will obtain all Building Permits required by Statutes and fully understand that if I commence work without obtaining necessary Building Permits in the future,the Contractor Licensing Department will consider that a willful code violation,where penalties and restrictions to Building Permit privileges may follow. Witness my signature(Contractor): "ilk- 11`" ( Print: ,51. E P if E-,J d '-c-)/Z--5 State of: fi-e,6-t DA Issuance#0- c PL-f L`3( L4 5 g County of: C c?L-L-' e g_ Issuance# —Ottoc.c.t,2-0 - The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this (date)by who has produced as identification and who did not take an oath. Signature of Notary Y its" ) Licensing Investigator,in lieu of Notary. Date: ,2- 11`-t ( i-74- E3 3 4- E33 COLLIER COUNTY BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION Growth Management Department 12800 N.Horseshoe Drive,Naples,Florida 34104 TEL: 239-252-2400 please fold plans with the plain side out. Ensure doctlmeuts art,stapjed inside each set of plans. 0 Reside al 1 or 2 Units(Sin le Family/Duplex)0 Residential 3 or more Units(Multi-family)1:3 Commercial Permit No. P R Ct i 7 0 9)4 tv 70 Master Permit No.1)1?-1:20. 015-09,9&51(40 ParceliFolio: 38282200001 1 ['Contractor []Design Professional ['Owner Builder t Job Address: 5391 Tamarind Ridge DR Licemse#State CeruReg.-Prefix:FL #, CPC1456458 Owner's Phone No.: `= Company Name:Jackson Custom Pools O Owner's Name:Todd Jacobs Stephen Bowels Qualifier/Professional Name: _.. E , Lot: Block: Unit: z Contact Name:Kelly 0 Subdivision: O Address: 13401 Rickenbacker Parkway gi Township:49 Range:26 Section: 9 U City:Fort Myers State:FL Zip:33913 h FEMA: BFE: Flood Zone: ; Phone 239-4254300 Fax: +'SDPIPL: z kell ools.com 0 E-mail Address: y@jacksoncustompools.com Code Case: i COA: U [['Alteration 1 IDMechanical Clean Agent System I DLP Gas Z Convenience Book101 Mobile Home Fire Alarm DPre-Engineered Fire RDemoNew Construction ['Fire Alarm Monitoring D Suppression Door'Windowlumbing ! z; ([' Fire Pumps Standpipes Electric/Low Voltage ✓BPPool C 7 Fire Sprinkler System Spray Booths t.; ,2 ['Electric from House DRe-roof Fossil Fuel Storage System C Tent, wa Fence Screen Enclosure y a (Hoods } ['Underground Fire Lines a BGas BShutter F 11 r?- [JMarine ['Sign/Flagpole OTHER Q Solar (, [j Private Provider []Plumbing JNon-sprinkled [Sprinkled O Q Roofing 0 Electrical U D Septic [D Low Voltage ;,4 DIA DIB ODA DUB r r Q Shutters D Mechanical 44 a. >4 DMA OHM DIVA [JIYB 0 Q Permit by Affidavit C OVAVQVB Occupancy Classification(s): Description of work: remodeling of existing pool. Barrier: N/A pool built in 1982 O I i9 EI t _- 3 I Project Name: Jacobs 100858Declared value$: 70,000 i c, i NEW CONSTRUCTION/ADDITION AREA ALTERATION WORK AREA- SQ,FT. z " If: ,plicable: #Stories/Floors:_ #Units: #Tons: 5 #Bedrooms: #Baths: RESIDENTIAL: Living: Non-living: m.-, !!I' RESIDENTIAL: Living: Non-living: Total sq.ft,: TOTAL SQ.FT.: a, COMMERCIAL: COMMERCIAL: Interior: Exterior: #Fixtures: Interior: Exterior: Total: TOTAL SQ.FT.: SEWAGE: Q Septic Q Ave Maria[City of Naples Collier County [� [['Golden Gate City Tmmokaloe a WATER SUPPLY: Q [�Orange Tree 0 Other C7 Weil 0 Ave Maria Deity of Naples [:I Collier County CD Golden Gate City a immokalee 0 Orange Tree[]Other — Application/Plans Discrepancies—Customer Acknowledgement of possible rejection for the following missed information: 1 I.Square footage discrepancies 2.Occupancy Classification/Construction type not provided I I 1 3.Required documents not certified 4.Incomplete Plan Sets or 5.Sets not identical Drawings I NOV.1,2014—PMR Date: Das Review: _Days # Set of PIans: L`34 • QUALIFIERS PAGE ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF COLLIER COUNTY REGULATIONS Application is hereby made to obtain a permit to do the work and installations as indicated. I certify that no work or installation has commenced prior to the issuance of a permit and that all work will be performed to meet the standards of all laws regulating construction in this jurisdiction. The permit or application fee may have additional fees imposed for failing to obtain permits prior to commencement of construction. The approved permit and/or permit application expires if not commenced within 180 days from the date of issuance. The permittee further understands that only licensed contractors may be employed and that the structure will not be used or occupied until a certificate of occupancy is issued. By signing this permit application, I agree that I have been retained by the owner/permittee to provide contracting services for the trade for which I am listed. Furthermore, it is my responsibility to notify the Building Review and Permitting De partment should 1 no longer be the contractor responsible for providing said contracting services. I further agree that I understand that the review and issuing of this permit does not exempt me from complying with all County Codes and Ordinances. It is further understood that the property owner/permittee is the owner of the permit. _ Note: If change of contractor, please provide the following: • Permit Number: E-mail Address: Tel: L _ COMPANY NAME: Jackson Pool Service STATE LICENSE NO:CPC1456458 QUALIFIER'S NAME(PRINT): Stephen Bowles QUALIFIER'S SIGNATURE: STATE OF: \C.)( `O O COUNTY OF: L- SWORN TO(OR AFFIRMED)AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME THISb._ I�� / / ,a,n,/„,. RELLY NEYHARD WHO IS PERSONALLY KNOWN:'KOR AS PRODUCED ID: ;''-t` s Notary Public-Statist of Ftoridx • • = Commission N GG 034551 TYPE OF ID: •,,ty - QQ, My Comm Expires Sap 28.2020 `,, aonneu!..,° , ugh National NOW ASSP NOTARY PUBLIC SIGNATUR • . �'� L, tosle a Wats NOTICE I IN ADDITION TO THE REQUIREMENTS OF THIS PE- , THERe MAY BE ADDITIONAL RESTRICTIONS APPLICABLE TO THIS PROPERTY THAT MAY BE FOUND IN THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF THIS COUNTY, AND THERE MAY BE ADDITIONAL PERMITS REQUIRED FROM OTHER GOVERNMENTAL ENTITIES SUCH AS WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT,STATE AGENCIES,OR FEDERAL AGENCIES. WARNING OF POSSIBLE DEED RESTRICTIONS THE LAND SUBJECT TO THIS PERMIT M AY BE SUBJECT TO DEED, AND OTHER RESTRICTIONS THAT MAY LIMIT OR IMPAR THE LANDOW NER'S RIGHTS. COLLIER COUNTY IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR THE ENFORCEMENT OF THESE RESTRICTIONS, NOR ARE COLLIER COUNTY EMPLOYEES AUTHORIZED TO PROVIDE LEGAL OR BUSINESS ADVICE TO THE PUBLIC RELATIVE TO THESE RESTRICTIONS. THE LANDOWNER OR ANY APPLICANT ACTING ON BEHALF OF THE LANDOWNER IS CAUTIONED TO SEE K PROFESSIONAL ADVICE. WARNING ON WORK IN COUNTY RIGHT-OF-WAYS THIS PERMIT DOES NOT AUTHORIZE CONSTRUCTION OR INSTALL ATION OF ANY STRUCTURE OR UTILITY, ABOVE OR BELOW GROUND, WITHIN ANY RIGHT-OF-W AY OR EASEMENT RESERVED FOR ACCESS,DRAINAGE OR UTILITY PURPOSES. THIS RESTRICTION SPECIFICALLY PROHIBITS FENCING, SPRINKLER SYSTEMS, LANDSCAPING OTHER TH AN SOD, SIGNS, WATER, SEWER, CABLE AND DRAINAGE WORK THEREIN. IF SUCH IMPROVEMENTS ARE NECESSARY, A SEPARATE PERMIT FOR THAT PURPOSE MUST BE OBTAINED FROM TRANSPORTATION/ROW PERMITS MD INSPECTIONS(239)252-8192. WARNING TO OWNER: YOUR FAILURE TO RECORD A NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT MAY RESULT IN YOUR PAYING TWICE FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO YOUR PROPERTY. IF YOU INTEND TO OBTAIN FINANCING, CONSULT WITH YOUR LENDER OR AN ATTORNEY BEFORE RECORDING YOUR NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT. Per Florida Statutes 713.135 a Notice of Commencement(NOC)is required for construction of improvements totaling more than$2,500,with certain exceptions.For A/C Repairs or Replacements a notice of commencement is required for improvements more than$7,500. The applicant shall file a th the issuing authority prior to the first inspection either a certified copy of the recorded NOC ora notarized statement that the NOC has been filed for recording,along with a copy thereof.In order to comply with the state requirement,permits will be placed in inspection hold until proof of the NOC is filed with the building permitting and inspection department.The issuing authority shall not perform or approve subsequent inspections until the applicant files by mall,facsimile,hand delivery,email or any other means such certified copy with the Issuing authority. 6 f' *** INSTR 5388602 • OR 5380 PG 1995 E—RECORDED 4/6/2017 3:07 PM PAGES 1 *** DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA REG $10.00 Notice of Commencement Permit No: STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER The undersigned hereby gives notice that improvements will be made to certain real property,and in accordance with section 713.13 of the Florida Statutes,the following information is provided in this Notice of Commencement. Legal Description of Property: A parcel of land identified as the West 180 feet of Tract 33 of Unit 32 of Golden Gate Estates as recorded in OR Book 1685 at Page 334 of the Public Records of Collier County,Florida General Description of Improvements: Pool and Spa Renovation,including Enclosure and/or Fence Owner: Jacobs,Todd Owner's Address: Todd Jacobs,5391 Tamarind aples,FL 34119 , Owner's Interest in site of the improv- ' �' ,-4 Fee Simple Title Holder(if other than o .i. N/A �\ Contractor: Jackson Custom Poo '------___J--, Contractor's Address: 13401 Ri eni�acker Pk F era,FL\33913 Surety: N/A I I( i 1 , Address: N/A I f`,' ) Any person making a loan for the ction of the improv ts: /A 1 0/ Person within the State of Florida by owner upon who r�i/or other documents may be served as provided by Section 713.13(lxa)7.,F / Name:N/A N .' E CI-" Address: N/A Expiration Date of Notice of Commencement (1 year from date of recording unless�ijrtl'crent date is specified.) Signature:�// G� / Printed Name:-'1;( aCe7'�s STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER Sworn to and subscribed before me this day of) (t 20 by .N°w"ch o is, .rally known tome. "'- — • . Signature of Notary Public: * ik t Li.,A,u`111 keLLY NEYNMtp Mike 1 PlOWy Pu •State of Florida Name of Notary Public: ,! , '� i:blic . 1a; ','e Coarmutton a GG 034681 ayyl My Comm Eyrnes Set.:;'8 2020 80.4e0 UN a o KNimo 4.4Yr Am. E.-36 COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIVISION / BUILDING REVIEW &INSPECTION 2800 N. Horseshoe Drive, Naples FL 34104 * Phone (239) 252-2400 Outstanding Corrections Date: April 26, 2017 PERMIT NO: PRBD2017041467001 Contact Name: JACKSON CUSTOM POOLS LLC (DBA) APPLICATION NO: PRBD20170414670 JACKSON POOL SERVICE Address: 13401 RICKENBACKER PARKWAY JOB SITE ADDRESS: 5391 Tamarind Ridge DR City,State Zip: FT MYERS, FL 33913- Fax: (239)425-0251 Email: Dear Applicant: Plans submitted with the referenced permit have been reviewed. We are unable to approve your permit application for the reason(s) indicated below. For Applications Submitted on Paper: • Review the corrections below to identify each document you will need to submit. • All corrections must be clouded. • Corrections to paper documents must be submitted in person;the GMD office receiving corrections is open until 4:30 pm. • Submit 2 sets of corrected documents. • Submit 2 copies of the Letter of Response summarizing the changes made to address each correction comment below. JOB DESCRIPTION: MASTER POOL PLAN. PROVIDE SITE SPECIFIC DESIGN,TDH, PUMP MAKE, MODEL AND CURVE, BARRIER PROTECTION, DECK MATERIAL AND LIGHT SELECTION REMODELING OF EXISTING POOL. BARRIER: N/A POOL BUILT IN 1982 5391 TAMARIND RIDGE DR 12/29/16.A.T.F. fees to be applied Service/ Rejected Review: Plumbing and Handicap Review Reviewed By: Bob Garee Phone:239-252-4282 Email:robertgaree@colliergov.net Correction Comment 1: Provide complete of scope as to what inspections are to be by engineer. All letters from engineers must state whe and how inspections were preformed. Contractor can not certify work. Rejected Review:Zoning Review Reviewed By: Gabriela Castro Phone:239-252-2408 Email:GabrielaCastro@colliergov.net Correction Comment 1: Please provide a certified site plan, prepared, signed, and sealed by a licensed Florida professional surveyor and mapper, architect or engineer, showing legal desciprion, property lines, setbacks,easements,water bodies, and all existing and proposed structures to be submitted with the building permit application. The plan shall indentify the elevation of the crown of the road, Flood Zone, FEMA's Base Flood Elevation, and show that the elevation of the deck meet or is greater than the crown of road. COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIVISION / BUILDING REVIEW &INSPECTION 2800 N. Horseshoe Drive, Naples FL 34104 * Phone(239) 252-2400 Outstanding Corrections Date: June 29, 2017 PERMIT NO: PRBD2017041467001 Contact Name: JACKSON CUSTOM POOLS LLC(DBA) APPLICATION NO: PRBD20170414670 JACKSON POOL SERVICE Address: 13401 RICKENBACKER PARKWAY JOB SITE ADDRESS: 5391 Tamarind Ridge DR City,State Zip: FT MYERS, FL 33913- Fax: (239)425-0251 Email: Dear Applicant: Plans submitted with the referenced permit have been reviewed. We are unable to approve your permit application for the reason(s)indicated below. For Applications Submitted on Paper: • Review the corrections below to identify each doC:ment you will need to submit. • All corrections must be clouded. • Corrections to paper documents must be submitted in person;the GMD office receiving corrections is open until 4:30 pm. • Submit 2 sets of corrected documents. • Submit 2 copies of the Letter of Response summarizing the changes made to address each correction comment below. JOB DESCRIPTION:MASTER POOL PLAN. PROVIDE SITE SPECIFIC DESIGN,TDH, PUMP MAKE, MODEL AND CURVE, BARRIER PROTECTION,DECK MATERIAL AND LIGHT SELECTION REMODELING OF EXISTING POOL. BARRIER: N/A POOL BUILT IN 1982 5391 TAMARIND RIDGE DR 12/29/16.A.T.F.fees to be applied Service/ Rejected Review: Plumbing and Handicap Review Reviewed By:Tim Rygiel Phone:239-252-2455 Email:TimothyRygiel©colliergov.net Correction Comment 2:2nd rejection: Engineers letter must include: 1. Permit number and site address. 2. Specific inspections performed with corresponding Collier County inspection number. 3. Date and time inspections performed. 4. Method of inspection to justify determination and resolution of the missed inspection. Contractor affidavits are not an acceptable substitution for Collier County inspections. ATTENTION: Collier County Plan Review and Inspections routinely reviews all outstanding permit applications in order to determine their status. The review process includes appropriate responses from the permit applicant when the permit cannot be approved. When the applicant is advised of deficiencies and does not respond within 180 days with corrected plans or an appeal to the Code Enforcement Board, the permit application will be canceled as per Collier County Ordinance 2002-01, Section, 104.5.1.1 to 104.5.1.4(as amended). October 26,2017 Stephen Bowles Jackson Pool Service 13401 Rickenbacker Parkway Fort Myers, FL 33913 Permit Application:PRBD20170414670 Job Description:REMODELING OF EXISTING POOL. Job Location: 5391 TAMARIND RIDGE DR,NAPLES, FL 34119 The Collier County Building Plan Review and Inspection Division has referred the above permit to the Collier County Contractor Licensing Section for review to resolve the permit to completion.Collier County Contractor Licensing Section has generated an open Misconduct case(#CEMIS20160021439)on your License#CPC1456458(Certified Pool/Spa Contractor)in regard to expired permit# PRBD20170414670.You and your office(Kelly)have been contacted previously about the permit. Please make every effort to contact the Plan Review and Inspection Division at joshualenio@colliergov.net or call 239-252-2493 to resolve this matter. If no action has been taken within 30 days or by November 26,2017,you will be scheduled for Hearing before the Collier County Contractors'Licensing Board(CLB)for violations of Collier County Ordinance 90-105,as amended,Section 22-201.1,"Willfully violating the applicable building codes or laws of the state,city or Collier County". In the event the CLB finds you in violation,disciplinary action which may be imposed are suspension or revocation of your permit privileges against your state license# CPC1456458. Sincerely, i Jack ' hn is sing Compliance Officer Collier County Contractors'Licensing Operations and Regulatory Management/Growth Management Department 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr. Naples, FL.34104 239-252-2468 f3q +C '„a► ler County Growth Management Department Building Review and Permitting EXPIRED APPLICATION NOTICE Date: February 21,2018 JACKSON CUSTOM POOLS LLC(DBA)JACKSON POOL SERVICE 13401 RICKENBACKER PARKWAY FT MYERS, FL 33913- Permit Application:PRBD20170414670 Job Description:MASTER POOL PLAN.PROVIDE SITE SPECIFIC DESIGN,TDH,PUMP MAKE, MODEL AND CURVE,BARRIER PROTECTION,DECK MATERIAL AND LIGHT SELECTION REMODELING OF EXISTING POOL.BARRIER:N/A POOL BUILT IN 1982 5391 TAMARIND RIDGE DR 12/29/16.A.T.F.fees to be applied Service/ Job Location:5391 Tamarind Ridge DR The Collier County Building Plan Review and Inspection Division routinely reviews all outstanding permit applications in order to determine their status.During our most recent review,we have found that the above referenced permit application has not been issued, and it has been over 180 days since any action has been conducted. Florida Building Code section 105.3.2 time limitation of application states: An application for a permit for any proposed work shall be deemed to have been abandoned 180 days after the date of filing, unless such application has been pursued in good faith or a permit has been issued." If no action has been taken by March 23, 2018,your application will be set to void for lack of good faith or abandonment. In addition,there are outstanding fees that must be paid for building plan review services performed in the amount of<$25.00>. It is considered a willful building code violation to file an application for a permit and not actively address said application to completion,whether that is permit issuance or cancellation of the application. Any expired or void status on an application for a permit may receive further action through Code Enforcement and/or Contractor Licensing to resolve the permit to completion. As a courtesy, we will hold your application package and plans for a period of 30 days. If plans are not picked up within that time frame,they will be recycled.The building copy and permit application will be sent to the Records Room, If you need any further assistance, please contact Client Services at 239-252-2493 or stridpermitextensionacolitergov.net and reference this letter. Sincerely, Jonathan Walsh Jonathan Walsh,P.E. Chief Building Official Collier County Building Review and Permitting Growth Management Department 2800 North Horseshoe Drive,Naples,Florida 34104 GumphJack From: GumphJack Sent: Thursday,April 12, 2018 9:53 AM To: lisa@jacksonpoolservice.com Cc: GumphJack Subject: JACOBS,TODD,Address :5391 TAMARIND RIDGE DR Attachments: 04122018094435.pdf Lisa, Reference our conversation of 4/5 on the above expired application#PRBD20170414670. I have attached the latest 'Correction Letter'.Could you research to determine if the items of correction were submitted for review. If they have, I will be able to follow up on my end. Thank you, Jack Gumph Compliance Officer,Contractor Licensing Collier County Growth Management Department 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 239-252-2468 (Office) 239-438-5195 (Cell) Jack.Gumph@CollierCountyFL.gov CD ler County Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. F41 1 GumphJack From: GumphJack Sent: Monday,August 20, 2018 9:21 AM To: stephen@jacksonpoolservice.com Cc: GumphJack Subject: Permit Application: PRBD20170414670 Attachments: 08202018091115.pdf Dear Mr. Bowles, Please see attached 'Notice of Hearing'for: Permit Application:PRBD20170414670,Application Date:04/18/2017(VOID PERMIT APPLI.) Job Description:master pool plan. provide site specific design,tdh, pump make, model and curve, barrier protection, deck material and light selection remodeling of existing pool. barrier: n/a pool built in 1982 Job Location: 5391 Tamarind Ridge Dr,Naples, FL 34119 A complaint has been filed against you by Collier County Growth Management Department.A hearing of this complaint will be held by the Contractors' Licensing Board on Wednesday,October 17,2018 at 9:00 AM in the Board of County Commissioner's Room,Third Floor,Administration Building (W. Harmon Turner Bldg.),at 3301 East Tamiami Trail, Naples, Florida 34112.Your presence before the Collier County Contractors' Licensing Board is required at this time.Should the permit issue be resolved prior to the hearing date,your name will be removed from the docket. Jack Gumph Compliance Officer,Contractor Licensing Collier County Growth Management Department 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples,FL 34104 239-252-2468 (Office) 239-438-5195 (Cell) lackLumph@CollierCountyFLgov Cts 7e-r County Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. E-1:4g 1 Grow,tti Management Division Planning& Regulation Operations Department Licensing Section Certified Mail#7017 0530 0000 8339 6170 Date:August 10,2018 Stephen Bowles Jackson Pool Service 11860 Lacy Lane Fort Myers,FL 33966 Permit Application:PRBD20170414670,Application Date:04/18/2017(VOID PERMIT APPLI.) Job Description:master pool plan.provide site specific design,tdh,pump make,model and curve, barrier protection,deck material and light selection remodeling of existing pool.barrier:n/a pool built in 1982 Job Location: 5391 Tamarind Ridge Dr,Naples,FL 34119 Dear Mr.Bowles, A complaint has been filed against you by the above referenced entity.A hearing of this Complaint will be held by the Contractors'Licensing Board on Wednesday,October 17,2018 at 9:00 AM in the Board of County Commissioner's Room,Third Floor,Administration Building (W.Harmon Turner Bldg.),at 3301 East Tamiami Trail,Naples,Florida 34112.Your presence before the Collier County Contractors'Licensing Board is required at this time. The packet you will receive marked composite exhibit"A"will be delivered to the members of the Contractors'Licensing Board one week prior to the hearing.If you wish to prepare a defense packet and have it delivered in conjunction with composite exhibit"A",you must make fifteen copies and have them in our office by 8:00 AM on Wednesday,one week prior to the hearing.In your packet,you may give a summary of events.At this meeting,you may present evidence and be represented by an attorney of your choice. In the event the Contractors'Licensing Board finds you in violation of Section(s)22-201.1(2)of Collier County Ordinance#90-105,as amended,the range of disciplinary sanctions which may be imposed are from an oral reprimand to a suspension or revocation of your Collier County Certificate issuance(N/A),and/or suspension or revocation of your permit privileges against your State license#CPC1456458. Sincerely, .leek Gumph Collier County Contractors' Licensing Operations and Regulatory Management,Growth Management Department 2800 N. Horseshoe Dr. Naples,FL.34104 ;;< 4,,,;., D€ann, S Rem '?. .: assn;North^?e ;t0,,da 34:- E 43 2 E43 4.1.13. Failing to maintain a current mailing address. 4.1.14. Failing to appear in person or through a duly authorized representative at any scheduled hearing on a complaint filed against the contractor. 4.1.15. Being convicted or found guilty,regardless of adjudication,of a crime in Collier County which directly relates to the practice of contracting or the ability to practice contracting. 4.1.16. Allowing another to take a qualifying examination on the applicant's behalf. 4.1.17. Engaging in contracting business in Collier County or the City when prohibited from doing so by the Contractors'Licensing Board of Collier County. 4.1.18. Proceeding on any job without obtaining applicable permits or inspections from the City building and zoning division or the county building review and permitting department. 4.1.19. Failing in any material respect to comply with the provisions of this Ordinance as a contractor or as a qualifying agent for a business entity engaging in contracting. 4.1.20. Signing a statement with respect to a project or contract falsely indicating that the work is bonded;falsely indicating that payment has been made for subcontracted work,labor,or materials which results in a financial loss to the owner, purchaser, or contractor; or falsely indicating that Workers'Compensation and public liability insurance are provided. 4.1.21. Failure of a qualifying agent for a firm/legal business entity to comply with the requirements set forth in Sections 489.119 and 489.1195,Florida Statutes. 4.1.22. Falsifying or misrepresenting any material fact to another person with the intent or for the purpose of engaging in the contracting business, providing materials or services, or soliciting business for an employer,as a contractor,or as an employee,regardless of any financial consideration. 4.1.23. Failing or refusing to provide proof of public liability and property damage insurance coverage and workers compensation insurance coverage. 4.1.24. Misconduct in the practice of contracting(See section 4.2,below). 4.2. Misconduct- State Certified Contractors The following actions by State Certified Contractors shall constitute misconduct and grounds for discipline pursuant to Section 4.3 of this Ordinance. 4.2.1. Failing or refusing to provide proof of public liability and property damage insurance coverage and workers compensation insurance coverage as required by Florida Statutes. 4.2.2. Willfully violating the applicable building codes or laws of the state, City or Collier County. 4.2.3. If the CLB finds through its public hearing process that the contractor was found by another county or municipality within the past twelve(12)months,to have committed fraud or a willful building code violation and the CLB finds that such fraud or other willful violation 37 Words s tlireagl3 are deleted;words underlined are added. would have been fraud or a willful violation if committed in Collier County or within the respective City. 4.2.4. Fraud. 43. Dbciplinary Proceedings,inching 1M inor Violations. 4.3.1. There are three (3) categories of violations: (i) Violations of subsection 489.127(1), Florida Statutes; Violations of subsection 489.132(1), Florida Statutes; and (iii) other violations within the jurisdiction of the Contractor's Licensing Board. ' I a. Subsection 489.127(1),Florida Statutes,is incorporated herein. (Lack of required license,certificate,or registration). The following are designated to enforce subsection 487.127(1),Florida Statutes:Collier County Building Official,all License Compliance Officers, the Chief Building Inspector, Chief Electrical Inspector, Chief Plumbing/Mechanical Mechanical, and/or other inspectors authorized from time-to-time by the Building Official. Procedures specified in this Ordinance shall apply except to the extent, if any, that Section 489.127 or Section 489.132, may require different procedure(s). The penalties for each uncontested violation of subsection 489.127(1) and/or 489.132(1), Florida Statutes, are three hundred dollars($300.00)for the first uncontested violation and five hundred dollars($500.00) for each subsequent uncontested violation by the same individual or entity. Penalties for contested violations of subsection 489.127(1),Florida Statutes,are as now or hereafter specified in Section 489.127,Florida Statues. Penalties for contested violations of subsection 489.132(1), Florida Statutes, are as now or hereafter specified in Section 489.132, Florida Statutes. The Citation form attached hereto as exhibit "A" is approved, which form may be amended from time-to-time by Resolution of the Board of County Commissioners. b. Minor Violations: The Contractor Licensing Supervisor or designee shall issue a "Notice of Noncompliance" as the County's first response to a minor violation of any provision of any regulatory law,including this Ordinance,when(i)it is reasonable for Staff to assume that the violator,at the time of violation,was not aware of the provision that was violated or it can be assumed that it was not clear to the violator how to comply with the violated provision;and(ii)that violation has not then resulted in economic harm or physical harm to any person;and(iii)the violation has neither adversely affected the public health,safety,or welfare, nor created any significant threat of any such adverse affect. The Notice of Noncompliance should identify the specific provision that was violated, should provide information on how to comply with that provision and should specify a reasonable time for full compliance. The Notice of Noncompliance shall not be accompanied with any immediate threat of any monetary fine or any other disciplinary penalty,but may specify that failure of the violator to correct the violation within the time specified in the Notice for Compliance may result in disciplinary proceedings. Each violation that is not a"minor"violation is a"major"violation. 38 Words are deleted;words underlined are added. c. Major Violations. The Contractor Licensing Supervisor, or his designee, may initiate disciplinary proceedings against a licensed contractor for major violations of this Ordinance by filing a sworn complaint with the Clerk to the Collier County Board of County Commissioners. d. Failure of Non-State Certified Individual to Promptly Pay Penalty to County. The Collier County Building Department should not issue any permit or any other required authorization to any Collier County Certified individual who then has an obligation to • pay a penalty to the County imposed with finality under this Ordinance for any violation of this Ordinance(including a citation that is not contested)and that individual has not paid that penalty in full by the applicable deadline date, plus reimbursement of the County's costs, such as recording fees and court costs. An appeal of uncontested citations stays all such withholdings. e. Failure of Non-State Certified Individual to Meet Permit Conditions. The County's Building Department may withhold issuance of any further permit(s) or any other authorization(s)to any individual who,or entity that,has not then complied with any condition of all County-issued permit(s) issued to that individual or entity, including every follow-up inspection or any other act then capable of being complied with,although late in time. f. Withholding Permit Pulling Privileges of State Certified Contractor. Before the CLB may withhold any permit pulling privilege(s)of a Stare Certified Contractor,the CLB, after public hearing, must find that the Contractor violated a provision of Section 4.2 of this Ordinance. 43.2. Any person who believes that a contractor holding a Certificate of Competency has violated this Ordinance may submit a sworn complaint to the Contractor Licensing Supervisor,or his/her designee. The complaint shall be in substantially the form prescribed by the Contractor Licensing Supervisor. .:.. .. .. . e.!t, .._ . . ..:. . . : .... .. :_ The complaining party shall state with particularity which section(s)of this Ordinance he or she believes has been violated by the contractor and the essential facts in support thereof. 4.3.3. Upon the submission of a sworn complaint,the Contractor Licensing Supervisor, or his/her designee, shall conduct a preliminary investigation and determine whether the complaint submitted warrants the filing of formal charges. If charges are warranted, the Contractor Licensing Supervisor, or his/her designee, shall file the complaint with the Clerk to the Collier County Board of County Commissioners and shall send, by certified mail, return receipt requested,a letter to the licensed contractor at his local address,or if applicable the local agent's address,as shown by the records of the Contractors'Licensing Board,enclosing a copy of the complaint and indicating: a. The name of the complainant; b. The dates)of the commission of the alleged offense(s); 39 Words laugh are deleted;words underlined are added. rip& 105.3.2 Time limitation of application. An application for a permit for any proposed work shall be deemed to have been abandoned, becoming null and void 180 days after the date of filing, unless such application has been pursued in good faith or a permit has been issued; except that the building official is authorized to grant one or more extensions of time for additional periods not exceeding 90 days each. The extension shall be requested in writing and justifiable cause demonstrated. Thursday,Oct 04,2018 09:59 AM f