Loading...
Spec Master Minutes 09/02/2005 September 2, 2005 TRANSCRIPT OF THE MEETING OF THE COLLIER COUNTY SPECIAL MASTER Naples, Florida, September 2,2005 LET IT BE REMEMBERED, that the Collier County Special Master in and for the County of Collier, having conducted business herein, met on this day at 8:30 a.m. in REGULAR SESSION in Building "F" ofthe Government Complex, East Naples, Florida, with the following members present: SPECIAL MASTER: Honorable Brenda Garretson COUNTY STAFF PRESENT: Leonardo Bonanno, Secretary to Special Master 1 HEARING OF THE COLLIER COUNTY SPECIAL MASTER AGENDA Date: September 2, 2005 8:45 A.M. Location: 3301 E. Tamiami Trail, Naples, Florida, Collier County Government Center Administrative Building "F", 3rd Floor NOTE: ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL A DECISION OF THE SPECIAL MASTER WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS PERTAINING THERETO, AND THEREFORE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. NEITHER COLLIER COUNTY NOR THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD SHALL BE RESPONSIBLE FOR PROVIDING THIS RECORD. 1. CALL TO ORDER A. HONORABLE SPECIAL MASTER BRENDA GARRETSON, PRESIDING B. HEARING RULES AND PROCEDURES 2. PUBLIC HEARINGS A. Stipulations 1. BCC YS. Roberto Conti & Gerarda Conti 2005070279 B. Imposition of Fines 1. BCC YS. Charles & Carrie Newman 2005040072 C. Requests for Extensions of Time 1. BCC YS. Martha Rego 2005031181 D. Requests for Foreclosure E. Hearings 1. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: SO 151 767 BETTY e. MOREKEN DEP.KELLER VIOLATIONS: ORD. SEe. 130-67 HANDICAPPED PARKING (BLOCKING ACCESS) 2. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: CE 1903 JEAN BELMONT ROBERT MANGIANTE VIOLA nONS: ORD. SEe. 130-66 PARKING IN UN LA WFUL AREA 3. CASE NO: CE 1340 OWNER: CARL P. ENGLAND OFFICER: EVERlLDO YBACET A VIOLATIONS: 130-66 PARKING IN UNLAWFUL AREA 4. CASE NO: CE 1899 OWNER: CHRISTINA ROBINSON OFFICER: RONALD MARTINDALE VIOLATIONS: ORD. SEe. 130-66 PARKING IN UNLAWFUL AREA 5. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: 20050411 04 MELISSA SPENCER/TERI ROTH AlK/A TERI DONOVAN JEAN NADEAU VIOLATIONS: ORD. 04-41 AS AMENDED SEe. 2.01.00 (A) UNLICENSED/INOPERABLE VEHICLES 6. CASE NO: 2005031370 OWNER: JEANNE LOUIZAIRE OFFICER: JEAN NADEAU VIOLATIONS: ORD. 04-41 AS AMENDED SEe. 10.02.06 & 105.5 STRUCTURAL IMPROVEMENTS WITHOUT PERMITS 7. CASE NO: 2005060225 OWNER: DELORIS ELAINE CHOICE OFFICER: ROBERT MANGIANTE VIOLA TIONS: ORD. 04-58 SEC 7 FAILURE TO REGISTER RENTAL PROPERTY 8. CASE NO: 2005051108 OWNER: RICHARD L. LICARE OFFICER: RONALD MARTINDALE VIOLATIONS: ORD. 04-41 AS AMENDED SEC. 2.01.00 ILLEGAL BOAT AND TRAILER STORAGE 9. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 10. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 2004070488 COLLIER REALTY CORP - JAMES KARL III, REG. AGENT ANDREW WUHRER ORD. 04-41 SEe. 10.02.06 UNPERMITTED POLE SIGN (CONTIUED FROM JUNE 3, 2005) 2004090671 SH & MA, LLC - JORGE MONTES, REG. AGENT ANDREW WUHRER ORD. 04-41 AS AMENDED SEe. 5.06.06 UNPERMITTED POLE/WALL SIGNS 11. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 12. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 13. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 14. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 15. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 16. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 17. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 18. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 2003081198 PORTER FAMILY I, LLC TRA VIS SNODERL Y ORD. 04-41 AS AMENDED SEe. 10.02.06 UNPERMITTED POLE/WALL SIGNS 2005030956 SCOTT & DENISE WEIKEL JOHN OLNEY ORD. 04-41 SEe. 10.02.06,104.1.1 & 106.1.2 GARAGE CONVERTED INTO LIVING SPACE 2005060322 WORTH B. JOHNSON JOHN OLNEY ORD. 04-41 AS AMENDED, SEe. 2.02.03 UNLICENSED/INOPERABLE VEHICLES/TRAILERS 2005060698 STEVEN A. HELFRICH IAN JACKSON ORD. 99-51 SEC 6 & 7 ACCUMULATION OF LITTER 2005060796 STEVEN A. HELFRICH IAN JACKSON ORD. 04-41 SEC. 5.03.01 CANOPY/TENT STRUCTURE INSTALLED WITHOUT PERMITS 2005060699 ROBERT R. ROBINSON IAN JACKSON ORD. 04-41 AS AMENDED SEC 2.01.00 UNLICENSED/INOPERABLE VEHICLES 2005051089 GARY W. & DONNA L. STUMBO EVERlLDO YBACET A ORD. 04-41 AS AMENDED SEC 2.01.00 UNLICENSED/INOPERABLE VEHICLES 2005060022 KEITH & DARLENE PURDY EVERlLDO PURDY ORD. 04-41 AS AMENDED SEC 2.01.00 UNLICENSED/INOPERABLE VEHICLES 19. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 20. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 21. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLA TlONS: 22. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 23. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 24. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 25. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 26. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 2005060680 ROBIN OKOLSKI JOE THOMPSON ORD. 04-41 AS AMENDED SEe. 2.01.00 UNLICENSED/INOPERABLE VEHICLES 2005060681 ROBIN OKOLSKI JOE THOMPSON ORD. 04-41 AS AMENDED SEe. 2.01.00 UNLICENSED/INOPERABLE VEHICLES 2005060695 ROBIN OKOLSKI JOE THOMPSON ORD. 99-51 SEC 6 ACCUMULATION OF LITTER 2005070672 EMILIO GUARRlDO JOE THOMPSON ORD. 99-51 SEC 6 & 7 ACCUMULA TION OF LITTER 20050040819 LUCILLE LAHAIE MCGOON LARRY SCHWARTZ ORD. 04-41 AS AMENDED SEe. 10.02.06 MOBILE HOME WITHOUT PERMIT 2003120348 RJS LLC - JEFF NOVA TT, REG. AGENT LARRY SCHWARTZ ORD. 99-51 SEC. 5, 6, 7 & 8 ACCUMULATION OF LITTER 2005020148 DIAMOND SHORE AFFORDABLE HOUSING - WILLIAM SCHWEIKHARDT, REG. AGENT LARRY SCHWARTZ ORD. 04-58 SEe. 6 NUMBEROUS MINIMUM HOUSING VIOLATIONS 2004120416 DIAMOND SHORE AFFORDABLE HOUSING - WILLIAM SCHWEIKHARDT, REG. AGENT LARRY SCHWARTZ ORD. 04-58 SEe. 6 NUMBEROUS MINIMUM HOUSING VIOLATIONS 27. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLA TIONS: 28. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 29. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 30. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 31. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 32. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 33. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 34. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: -~"~--<-_.-,. 2004120662 DIAMOND SHORE AFFORDABLE HOUSING - WILLIAM SCHWEIKHARDT, REG. AGENT LARRY SCHWARTZ ORD. 04-58 SEe. 6 NUMBEROUS MINIMUM HOUSING VIOLATIONS 2005070565 CRAIG & GLORIA PERLOWIN SHA WN LUEDTKE ORD. 91-102 SEe. 2.6.7.1.1 UNLICENSED/INOPERABLE VEHICLE(S) 2004100248 CHRISTOPHER GEHRING SHAWN LUEDTKE ORD. 2003-37 SEe. 5 EXPIRED RIGHT-OF-WAY PERMIT 2005060975 FLA VIO PINEROS & DEGNY AURORA SHA WN LUEDTKE ORD. 91-102 SEe. 1.5.6 & 2.6.7.1.1 UNLICENSED/INOPERABLE VEHICLE(S) 2005070557 JOSE RAMOS SHAWN LUEDTKE ORD. 91-102 SEC. 1.5.6 & 2.6.7.1.1 UNLICENSED/INOPERABLE VEHICLE(S) 2005050529 GRACIELA GUZMAN SHA WN LUEDTKE ORD. 91-102 SEC. 1.5.6 & 2.6.7.1.1 UNLICENSED/INOPERABLE VEHICLE(S) 2005070557 JOSE RAMOS SHAWN LUEDTKE ORD. 04-41 AS AMENDED, SEe. 10.02.06 ADDITION OF BLOCKS/POSTS 2005060165 DA VID C. ARNOLD JEFF LETOURNEAU ORD. 04-58 SEC. 6 NUMBEROUS MINIMUM HOUSING VIOLATIONS 35. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 36. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 37. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 38. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLA TIONS: 39. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 40. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 41. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 42. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: ___~_.W""'_' 2005060264 ALFONSE & GRETA BOTTINO JEFF LETOURNEAU ORD. 04-58 SEe. 6 NUMBEROUS MINIMUM HOUSING VIOLATIONS 2005060678 ALJO, INe. JEFF LETOURNEAU ORD. 04-58 SEe. 6 NUMBEROUS MINIMUM HOUSING VIOLATIONS 2005070309 ALJO, INe. JEFF LETOURNEAU ORD. 04-58 SEe. 6 NUMBEROUS MINIMUM HOUSING VIOLATIONS 20050060622 ALJO, INC. JEFF LETOURNEAU ORD. 04-58 SEe. 6 NUMBEROUS MINIMUM HOUSING VIOLATIONS 2005060623 ALJO, INe. JEFF LETOURNEAU ORD. 04-58 SEe. 6 NUMBEROUS MINIMUM HOUSING VIOLATIONS 2005050501 ALJO, INe. JEFF LETOURNEAU ORD. 04-58 SEe. 6 NUMBEROUS MINIMUM HOUSING VIOLATIONS 2005060621 ALJO, INe. JEFF LETOURNEAU ORD. 04-58 SEe. 6 NUMBEROUS MINIMUM HOUSING VIOLATIONS 2005060771 ALJO, INe. JOHN SANT AFEMIA ORD. 04-58 SEe. 6 NUMBEROUS MINIMUM HOUSING VIOLATIONS 43. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 44. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 45. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLA TIONS: 46. CASE NO: OWNER: OFFICER: VIOLATIONS: 3. COMMENTS 4. NEXT MEETING DATE SEPTEMBER 16, 2005 5. ADJOURN 2005060771 ALJO, INe. JOHN SANTAFEMIA ORD. 04-58 SEe. 6 NUMBEROUS MINIMUM HOUSING VIOLATIONS 20050600639 ALJO, INe. JOHN SANT AFEMIA ORD. 04-58 SEe. 6 NUMBEROUS MINIMUM HOUSING VIOLATIONS 20050600629 ALJO, INe. JOHN SANT AFEMIA ORD. 04-58 SEe. 6 NUMBEROUS MINIMUM HOUSING VIOLATIONS 2005060628 ALJO, INe. JOHN SANT AFEMIA ORD. 04-58 SEe. 6 NUMBEROUS MINIMUM HOUSING VIOLATIONS September 2, 2005 HEARING OF THE SPECIAL MASTER SEPTEMBER 2, 2005 Hearing Summary 1. Call To Order: · The hearing was called to order by Special Master Brenda Garretson at 8:50 a.m. · Hearing rules and procedures were explained by Special Master Brenda Garretson. · All those testifying at the proceedings did so under oath. 2. PUBLIC HEARINGS: BCC ys. Deloris Elaine Choice - Case No. 2005-060225 This hearing was requested by Officer Robert Mangiante, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Dolores Elaine Choice, Owner, was not present. Ms. Choice was represented by Jerome, agent for the property. Agent was present prior to hearing, but not at hearing. It was agreed between the parties prior to the hearing that the violation, failure to register rental property, has been abated and that operational costs of $186.77 would be paid by Respondent. Notice was properly given. The stipulation between the parties was accepted by Special Master Garretson. Operational costs in the amount of $186.77 will be imposed, to be paid in 30 days. A. Stipulations BCC ys. Roberto Conti & Gerarda Conti - Case No. 2005-070279 This hearing was requested by Officer John Olney, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Roberto Conti & Gerarda Conti, Respondents, were not present. Violation involves parking a vehicle in the driveway. NOV was given. Matter was brought before the Special Master. Written stipulation has been submitted. Respondents have agreed to plead guilty to violation dated August 16,2005. Respondents have agreed to pay operational costs of $156.90 and not to park vehicle in driveway/right-of-way. 2 -",------ September 2, 2005 Notice properly given and received. Special Master has received a written plea of guilty. Respondents' admission of guilt is accepted by Special Master. Operational costs are imposed in the amount of $156.90, to be paid within 30 days. Respondents are not to park vehicle in driveway/right-of-way in the future. B. Imposition of Fines BCC ys. Charles & Carrie Newman - Case No. 2005-040072 This hearing was requested by Officer John Olney, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondents were not present. Violation involves parking vehicle in right-of-way. Similar violation was first presented to the Special Master on July 15, 2005. Respondents were found to be in violation and were fined. On August 17,2005, van was again found be parked in right-of-way. Fine of $150.00 to be paid within 30 days was requested. Notice properly given by posting and phone call. Respondents have failed to appear. Respondents are found GUILTY of Second violation. Fine of $150.00 is assessed for this further violation to be paid within 30 days. C. Requests for Extension of Time BCC ys. Martha Re20 - Case No. 2005-031181 This hearing was requested by Officer Joe Thompson, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent, Martha Rego, was present. Extension of time to complete work on shed was requested, one week, September 9, 2005. Request for extension of time to September 9, 2005 to comply with Order was granted. Failure to comply with remaining items of the Order would result in a $50.00 per day fine. Officer John Olney will be the new investigator. A. Stipulations BCC Ys. Richard L. Licare - Case No. 2005-051108 This hearing was requested by Officer Ronald Martindale, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent, Richard L. Licare, did not appear. 3 ^'----.-----.... September 2, 2005 Violation of Ordinance 04-41 as Amended Sec. 2.01.00, Illegal Boat and Trailer Storage. Boat was parked in right-of-way. NOV was given. Violation has been abated. Respondent has agreed to operational costs of$163.47. Notice was properly given. Respondent has failed to appear voluntarily. Violation has been abated. Operational costs will be imposed in the sum of $163.47, to be paid within 30 days. BCC ys. Keith & Darlene Purdy - Case No. 2005-060022 This hearing was requested by Officer Ronald Martindale, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondents, Keith & Darlene Purdy, were not present. Violations, Ordinance 04-41 as Amended Sec. 2.01.00, Unlicensed/inoperable Vehicles. Unlicensed vehicle was parked in driveway. Vehicle has been removed. Respondent Keith Purdy has agreed to pay the operational costs. Proper notice was given. Respondents failed to appear voluntarily. Respondents have been found GUILTY of violating the Ordinance, but the violation has been abated. Respondents have stipulated to pay operational costs of$163.47, to be paid within 30 days. BCC ys. Robert R. Robinson - Case No. 2005-060699 This hearing was requested by Officer Ian Jackson, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent Robert R. Robinson was not present. Violation of Ordinance 04-41 as Amended SEC. 2.01.00, Unlicensed/Inoperable Vehicles. Officer Jackson submitted a stipulation signed by Mr. Robinson stating that the violations do exist and will be abated within seven days ofthe hearing or a fine of $50.00 per day per vehicle thereafter will be imposed. Proper notice was given. Respondent failed to appear voluntarily based on the stipulation entered into. Respondent has agreed to pay operational costs of $162.85, within 30 days and to abate the violations within seven days, by September 9,2005, by any of the ways provided by the Ordinance, removing the vehicles, licensing the vehicles or placing them within an enclosed structure. Failure to abate the violations by September 9, 2005, will result in a fine of $50 per day per vehicle being imposed. Respondent must notify Code Enforcement Officer that abatement has occurred. 4 September 2, 2005 BCC vs. Porter Familv I. LLC - Case No. 2003-081198 Hearing was requested by Officer Travis Snoderly, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent Porter Family I, LLC, was not present. Violations, Ordinance 04-41 as Amended Sec. 10.02.06, Unpermitted Pole/Wall Signs. Violation involves unpermitted pole/wall signs. Frank Campamore, Esquire, of Quaryles & Brady, representing the property owner, submitted a signed stipulation. Respondents have agreed to pay operational costs as identified in the stipulation agreement, will obtain permits and CO within 60 days of to day's hearing or will incur a fine of$75 per day. If they chose not to permit the signs, they will remove the signs within 60 days oftoday's hearing or incur a fine of $75 per day. Code Enforcement Officer will be notified upon completion so that a site inspection can be performed. Notice was properly given. Based upon the written stipulation, Respondent has chosen voluntarily not to appear and has admitted the violation. Respondent is represented by counsel, Frank Campamore of Quarles and Brady who has executed the stipulation on beh alf of the Porter Family 1, LLC. Respondent is found GUILTY of violating the Ordinance and is ordered to abate the violation within 60 days by one of two ways; either, by obtaining a permit or removing the sign. If neither of those two things occur within 60 days, afine of $75 per day will be imposed for each day the violation continues. Operational costs will be imposed in the amount of $294.73, to be paid within 60 days. CO, Certificate of Completion must be obtained within 60 days, and Code Enforcement Officer must be notified when violation ceases. D. Requests for Foreclosure Edward & Sally Callahan Ray Van Tassell CEE Investment Randolph Shelton Joseph Lombardo Robert Dietz Rosa Quinones & Jairo Lavarde Fabian & Maria Luzardo Jose Luis Fernandez Catherine & Robert Wilson CO 2004090039 SO 134158 CO 2004061169 CO 2004090636-0708-0716 CO 100120 CE 0903 CO 2004100006 CO 2005010315 CO 2004090757 SO 133210 Request has been made for the Office of the Special Master, Secretary to the Special Master, to be able to proceed to foreclosure proceedings on the above-named matters. The request is granted and it is directed that foreclosure proceedings begin on all of the above cases. 5 September 2, 2005 BCC vs. Jean Belmont - Case No. CE 1903 This hearing was requested by Officer Robert Mangiante, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent, Jean Belmont, was present. Violations, Ordinance Sec. 130-66, Parking in Unlawful Area. Respondent was issued a ticket for parking vehicle in right-of-way. Photo was submitted to Special Master. Vehicle was parked in residential area. There were no signs that vehicle was in distress. Respondent pushed car to the side of the road, went to his house, came back in 45 minutes and found the ticket. Respondent questioned Officer Mangiante who informed Respondent that he would have to resolve matter through Code Enforcement. Respondent pulled his car back to his house with another car, master cylinder was leaking. Respondent NOT GUILTY o/violation. BCC vs. Christina Robinson - Case No. CE 1899 This hearing was requested by Officer Ronald Martindale, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent, Christina Robinson, was present. Violation, Ordinance Sec. 130-66, Parking In Unlawful Area. Respondent indicated there is flooding in Naples Park area and that is why she did not park in her driveway. Officer Martindale agreed to dismiss the citation. Citation was dismissed. BCC vs. SH&MA. LLC - Jorl!e Montes. ReI!. Al!ent - Case No. 2004090671 This hearing was requested by Officer Andrew Wuhrer, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent was present with counsel, Michael Durant, Esquire. Violation, Ordinance 04-41 as Amended Sec. 5.06.06, Unpermitted Pole/Wall Signs. Respondent has agreed to pay operational costs of$269.87, will abate existing problems which are three signs and a pole sign. Three signs will be converted to two permit numbers. Sign company has already been contacted. Pole sign will have to be taken care of by Florida Power and Light, and will require extra time. Requested until October hearings. Violation can be abated by either moving or converting sign into a street or parking lot light or to remove the sign. Notice was properly given, Respondent is present with counsel and has stipulated to the violation and to paying operational costs 0/$269.87, to be paid within 30 days. Respondent has agreed to abate the violation. Permits will be pulled to bring PolelWall 6 September 2, 2005 signs into compliance; poles that need to be removed will be removed. Three/two signs will be permitted and have COs by October 7, 2005. October 7, 2005 will be compliance date. If there is not compliance by October 7, 2005, a fine of $50 per day will be imposed. BCC vs. Melissa Spencer/Teri Roth AIKJA Teri Donovan - Case No. 2005041104 This hearing was requested by Officer Jean Nadeau, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondents were not present. Violation: Ordinance 04-41 as Amended Sec. 2.01.00(A), Unlicensed/Inoperable Vehicles. Property is being exchanged from Ms. Spencer to Ms. Donovan. "Spencer" will be used on Order. Notice was posted at residence to owner of record. Tax records as of five o'clock last night show Melissa Spencer is owner; courtesy copies sent to Ms. Donovan and Attorney Gal. Violation has been abated. Proper notice was given. Respondent not present. Respondent GUILTY of violation. Violation has been abated. Operational costs are imposed of $224.04, to be paid within 30 days. Owner of record as of end of business day yesterday was Melissa Spencer and so operational costs are imposed on Melissa Spencer as owner of property. Courtesy copy of Order shall be sent to Alfred Gal, Esquire, and Teri Donovan. BCC vs. Jeanne Louisaire - Case No. 2005031370 This hearing was requested by Officer Jean Nadeau, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent, Jeanne Louizaire, was present. Interpreter, Esler Dorse (sp.), cousin, sworn. Violation, Ordinance 04-41 as Amended Sec. 10.02.06 & 105.5, Structural Improvements Without Permits. New windows were installed without permits. NOV was mailed to owners; house was sold to Jeanne Louizaire. NOV was given to new owner on 4/7/05 along with explanation of what needed to be done. On 8/1l/05 hearing notice was posted on property. Permits were obtained after property was posted for hearing. Last two inspections were failed. Recommendation is property must pass all inspections, get Certificate of Occupancy or Compliance within 30 days of the date of this hearing; if not, a fine of $50 per day to be incurred for each day the violation continues. Recommended that Respondent call Officer Nadeau when violations are abated for further inspection. Code Enforcement Officer is concerned structural integrity of windows have been compromised. Respondent indicated architect posted in permit office has been back three times and failed to get it right, they have to keep redoing and she needs another architect. Proper notice was given. Respondent was found GUILTY of violation. Violation must be abated by October 2, 2005. Operational costs are imposed in the sum of $257.29, to be paid within 60 day. 7 September 2, 2005 BCC vs. Robin Okolski - Case No. 2005060680.2005060681. 2005060695 This hearing was requested by Officer Joe Thompson, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent, Robin Okolski, was present. Violation, Ordinance 04-41 as Amended Sec. 2.01.00, Unlicensed/Inoperable Vehicle and Ordinance 99-51 Sec. 6, Accumulation of Litter. Case No. 2005060681, parking and storage of vehicle without tag has been abated. Case No. 2005060680, commercial vehicle has been abated. Case No. 2005060695, dealing with litter, has been abated. Operational costs are being sought. Respondent is requesting a reduction in the fine. Proper notice was given. Operational costs of $245.57 will be imposed, to be paid within 30 days subject to a payment plan. BCC vs. Emilio Guarrido - Case No. 2005070672 This hearing was requested by Officer Joe Thompson, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent, Emilio Guarrido, was present. Interpreter, Susan O'Farrell. Violation, Ordinance 99-51 Sec. 6 & 7, Accumulation of Litter. NOV was posted in courthouse. Violation has been abated. Request only operational costs be incurred. Proper notice was given. Respondent was found GUILTY of violating ordinance. Operational costs were imposed of $169.42, to be paid within 30 days. BCC vs. RJSLLC - Jeff Novatt. Rei!. Ai!ent - Case No. 2003120348 This hearing was requested by Officer Larry Schwartz, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent not present. Violation, Ordinance 99-51 Sec. 5,6, 7 & 8, Accumulation of Litter. Received a signed stipulation from Richard Yanovich, Esquire, agreeing to remove all litter to a site intended for final disposal with 30 days of hearing or a fine of $100 per day will be imposed until the violation is abated. Respondent must notify Code Enforcement within 24 hours of abatement of the violation and request the investigator perform a site inspection to confirm compliance. Proper notice was given. Based on the stipulation Respondent is not present but was previously represented by Richard Yavanovich, Esquire, who has entered into this stipulation on behalf of the LLC and order that the violation did occur but is going to be abated within 30 days; ifnot abated within 30 days, afine of$100 per day will be imposed. Operational costs of $262. 99 were imposed, to be paid within 30 days. 8 September 2, 2005 Respondent must notify the Code Enforcement Officer of the abatement of the violation within 24 hours and request the Inspector to perform a site inspection. BCC vs. Collier Realty CorD - James Karl III. Rei!. Ai!ent - Case No. 2004070488 This hearing was requested by Officer Andrew Wuhrer, Collier County Code Enforcement Officer, who was present. Respondent Collier County Realty was represented by Fatima Karagoz who has authority to enter into stipulation. Violation, Ordinance 04-41 Sec. 10.02.06, Unpermitted Pole Sign. Violation has been abated. Operational costs of $219.64 have been stipulated to. Proper notice was given. Violation of Ordinance has been abated. Operational costs have been imposed of $219. 64, to be paid within 30 days. BCC vs. Gary W. & Donna L. Stumbo - Case No. 2005051089 This hearing was requested by Officer Everildo Ybaceta, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondents were not present. Violation, Ordinance 04-41 as Amended Sec. 2.01.00, Unlicensed/Inoperable Vehicles. Respondents have agreed to pay operational costs of $163.4 7, move the R V to the rear of the property within 45 days oftoday's hearing; if not, a fine of $25 per day for each day the violation continues will be imposed. Proper notice was given. Respondents have entered into a written stipulation agreeing that they are in violation of the ordinance, they will come into compliance within 45 days or a fine of $25 per day for each day the violation continues after the 45 days will be imposed. Respondents will pay operational costs of $163.45 within 45 days. (The hearing recessed from 10:15 a.m. to 10:55 a.m.) BCC vs. Jose Ramos - Case No. 2005070557 This hearing was requested by Officer Shawn Luedtke, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent Jose Ramos was present. Violation, Ordinance 91-102 Sec. 1.5.6 & 2.6.7.1.1, Unlicensed/Inoperable Vehicles(s). Violation has been abated and Respondent has agreed to pay operational costs. Proper notice was given. Respondent was found GUILTY of violating ordinance. Violation has been abated. Operational costs are imposed in the sum of $153.90, to be paid within 30 days. 9 September 2, 2005 BCC vs. Graciela Guzman - Case No. 2005050529 This hearing was requested by Officer Shawn Luedtke, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent Graciela Guzman was present. Ms. Guzman's daughter Gabriella Guzman is interpreting. Interpreter was sworn. Violation, installed fence around property without getting a permit. Respondent has agreed to stipulate to the violation, obtain permits or remove the fence within 30 days, or incur a fine of $50 per day and to pay operational costs. Proper notice has been given. Special Master Garretson has accepted the stipulation between the parties, who is present. The violation will be abated within 30 days or a fine of $50 per day will be assessed. The operational costs will be imposed in the amount of $190. 60, to be paid within 30 days. BCC vs. David C. Arnold -Case No. 2005060165 This hearing was requested by Officer Jeff Letourneau, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent David C. Arnold was present. Violation, Ordinance 04-58 Sec. 6, Numerous Minimum Housing Violations. Stipulation has been entered into. Agreement is that Respondent will pay operational costs of $200 rental inspection fee, also to abate the violation by obtaining a Collier County demolition permit within seven days of this hearing and removing the mobile home within 60 days after obtaining the permit or a fine of $60 per day will be imposed for each day the violation continues. Proper notice has been given. Respondent was found GUILTY of violating the ordinance. Written stipulation between the parties was accepted by Special Master Garretson. Respondent must obtain demolition permit by September 9, 2005 and remove the mobile home by November 9, 2005 or incur a fine of $100 per day for each day the violation continues. Operational costs are imposed in the amount of $189. 02, to be paid within 60 days. Must acquire a Certificate of Occupancy/Completion. Must contact Code Enforcement for inspection after violation is abated. BCC vs. Worth B. Johnson - Case No. 2005060322 This hearing was requested by Officer John Olney, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent Worth B. Johnson was not present. Violation, Ordinance 99-51 Sec. 6 & 7, Accumulation of Litter. Agricultural Land is being used to store derelict automobiles, boats, trailers. Noticed via registered mail, green 10 September 2, 2005 card received back. Recommendation is that Respondent be given until October 15,2005 to complete the removal ofthe unlicensed, inoperational items illegally stored on his land and that he pay operational costs within 60 days of the date of this hearing, and ifhe is not in compliance after October 15,2005 that a fine of$50 per day be assessed. Proper notice was given. Respondent was not in attendance but has stipulated that he will abate the violation within 60 days of the date of this hearing, October 15, 2005 to come into compliance with the ordinance. If Respondent has not come into compliance with the ordinance by October 15, 2005, then a fine of $50 per day will be imposed for every day thereafter. Operational costs are assessed in the amount of $156.90, to be paid by November 2, 2005. Respondent Alfonse Bottino has requested a continuance on all cases. David Schribner, Collier County Code Enforcement Supervisor, objected to any continuance of the cases as the violations are severe and should have already been corrected. Request for continuance is denied. BCC vs. AIJo. Inc. - Case No. 2005050501 This hearing was requested by Officer Jeff Letoumeau, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent AlJo, Inc., was represented by its Registered Agent Cathleen Lawler. Violation, Ordinance 04-58 Sec. 6, Numerous Minimum Housing Violations. At 600 Finch Drive, Naples, FL. Violations include faulty plumbing, faulty electric, water damage resulting from a leak in the roof, rot, holes in roof and ceiling, renters had to supply their own refrigerator, no hot water in main bathroom, cracks in the master bathroom tub and second bathroom shower, and no door attached to the Second bedroom. Only repairs done in past few months were some temporary patches that might have stopped the roof from leaking. There is mold. Ceiling has caved in. Photos of unit were provided. Respondent does not deny there is a lot of damage. Respondent stated that the roof was not patched but a new roof was put up. Respondent indicates that it is difficult to communicate with Monahans to get into unit to fix interior. No permit was obtained for new roof. Lela Monahan: Tenant at 600 Finch, stated that during three and-a-half years she has lived there, it has been extremely difficult to get Mr. Bottino to fix even the most basic needs. Ms. Monahan stated Mr. Bottino would not provide a working refrigerator when the one in her unit broke down, she had to buy her own, it has taken several days to get water problems fixed during which time there was no water. Sewage pipes have leaked with raw sewage running across sidewalk in front of her house and it took Mr. Bottino six month to fix situation, only after intervention by Code Enforcement. Ms. Monahan stated that she has been to Registered Agent's house several times asking for repairs. Ms. Monahan's daughters both have keys to unit and can let repair people in at any time. There have been many times when repairmen were scheduled to show up to 11 September 2, 2005 do repairs, tenants waited, no one showed up. Ms. Monahan stated a new roof was put up by Ms. Lawler's husband. No other repairs have been done. Francis Ganig: Spoke in support of Ms. Monahan's testimony, complaints are ignored, water is unsafe to drink, toilets don't work, steps front and back slant down and cause falls, there is no hot water, complaints get no response. Indicated that unlicensed people have done any repairs that have been done. Mr. Ganig indicated he and his young son suffer from allergies. Proper notice was given. Violator/Respondent has been found GUILTY of violating the ordinance. The Violator/Respondent is ordered to correct all minimum housing violations in accordance with all applicable County ordinances (i.e., minimum housing, permitting) on or before September 9, 2005 or a fine of $250 will be imposed for each day any violations remain thereafter. Violator/Respondent is ordered to use only licensed contractors to perform work. Violator/Respondent is ordered to inform County as work is accomplished so that work can be inspected. Operational costs will be imposed in the sum of$195.59, to be paid in 30 days. County is ordered to abate the violations and charge the costs back to the owner if the owner does not take responsibility for abating the violations himselfwithin seven days. BCC vs. Alfonse & Greta Bottino - Case No. 2005060264 This hearing was requested by Officer Jeff Letourneau, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondents Alfonse & Greta Bottino were represented by their Registered Agent Cathleen Lawler. Violation, Ordinance 04-58 Sec. 6, Numerous Minimum Housing Violations at Unit 108 Acacia, Naples, FL. Violations included faulty plumbing and electric, water damage, rot, holes in floors, ceilings and walls, windows and doors not weather tight or lockable. Further violations included central air conditioning broken with no screens on windows, and interior doors were missing. Violations still exist. Paperwork on this unit was forwarded directly to Mr. Bottino. Mr. Bottino signed the NOV. Ms. Lawler does not have paperwork on this unit in her possession. Proper notice was given. Violator/Respondent is voluntarily absent from hearing. Violator/Respondent has been found GUILTY of violating the ordinance. The Violator/Respondent is ordered to correct all minimum housing violations in accordance with all applicable County ordinances (i.e., minimum housing, permitting) on or before September 9, 2005 or a fine of $250 will be imposed for each day any violations remain thereafter. Violator/Respondent is ordered to use only licensed contractors to perform work. Violator/Respondent is ordered to inform County as work is accomplished so that work can be inspected. Operational costs will be imposed in the sum of$189.02, to be paid in 30 days. County is ordered to abate the violations and charge the costs back to the owner if the owner does not take responsibility for abating the violations himself within seven days. 12 September 2, 2005 BCC vs. AlJo. Inc. - Case No. 2005060678 This hearing was requested by Officer Jeff Letourneau, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent Al Jo, Inc., was represented by its Registered Agent Cathleen Lawler. Violation, Ordinance 04-58 Sec. 6, Numerous Minimum Housing Violations. Violations at 513 Ensis Drive included roofleaking in numerous places, water damage in ceilings, walls and cabinets; front door not water tight and leaking, no central air conditioning and no screens, insect infestation. Ms. Lawler indicated that home is empty as it is uninhabitable. Ceiling is caved in. Proper notice was given. Violator/Respondent has been found GUILTY of violating the ordinance. The Violator/Respondent is ordered to correct all minimum housing violations in accordance with all applicable County ordinances (i.e., minimum housing, permitting) on or before October 2, 2005 or a fine of $250 will be imposed for each day any violations remain thereafter. Violator/Respondent is ordered to use only licensed contractors to perform work. Violator/Respondent is ordered to inform County as work is accomplished so that work can be inspected. Operational costs will be imposed in the sum of$189.02, to be paid in 30 days. Unit may not be rented out until all violations are corrected and a Certificate of Occupancy has been issued. County is ordered to abate the violations and charge the costs back to the owner if the owner does not take responsibility for abating the violations himself within seven days. BCC vs. AlJo. Inc. - Case No. 2005070309 This hearing was requested by Officer Jeff Letourneau, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent AlJo, Inc., was represented by its Registered Agent Cathleen Lawler. Violations, Ordinance 04-58-Sec. 6, Numerous Minimum Housing Violations. Violations at 501 Ensis included water damage to the kitchen counter, refrigerator not working, porch, patio and hall lights not working, three interior doors missing, central air conditioning not working with no screens on the windows, skylight leaking and rotting, rot in the ceiling and no working smoke detectors. Some violations have been abated, but the major ones still exist as of Officer Letourneau's last visit. Ms. Lawler stated unit has been furnished with a new refrigerator, unit still has no screens. Roof is responsibility of Diamond Shores, which is the condo association that owns the parks. They are responsible for the roofs, trash, dumpsters, grounds, and pool and grounds and any water leaks that come before the main to the house. Diamond Shores is not responsive to requests for repairs. No documentation outlining Diamond Shores' responsibilities was provided. Proper notice was given. Violator/Respondent has been found GUILTY of violating the ordinance. The Violator/Respondent is ordered to correct all minimum housing 13 September 2, 2005 violations in accordance with all applicable County ordinances (i.e., minimum housing, permitting) on or before September 9, 2005 or a fine of $250 will be imposed for each day any violations remain thereafter. Violator/Respondent is ordered to use only licensed contractors to perform work. Violator/Respondent is ordered to inform County as work is accomplished so that work can be inspected. Operational costs will be imposed in the sum of $189.02, to be paid in 30 days. County is ordered to abate the violations and charge the costs back to the owner if the owner does not take responsibility for abating the violations himselfwithin seven days. BCC vs. Christopher Gehrinl! - Case No. 2004100248 This hearing was requested by Officer Shawn Luedtke, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent Christopher Gehring was present. Violation, Ordinance 2003-37 Sec. 5, Expired Right-of-Way Permit. Violation involves a swale had been filled in at 11020 Third Street NW. Permit was obtained but expired before Certificate of Occupancy was obtained. Parties have stipulated that Respondent will have 30 days to obtain a new permit and obtain a Certificate of Occupancy or incur a $50 per day fine. Mr. Gehring is concerned that it took eight weeks to get the right-of- way permit the last time. Proper notice was given. Special Master Garretson accepted the stipulation between the parties. Respondent was ordered to abate the violation within 30 days which includes getting permit reissued and obtaining a Certificate of Occupancy. l/violation is not abated within 30 days, afine of$50 per day will be imposed for every day thereafter. Operational costs were imposed $170.51, to be paid within 30 days. If permit is not issued within 30 days due to the County'sfault, contact the Officer who can ask for an extension of time. Respondent must advise Officer when violation is abated so that Officer may confirm abatement. BCC vs. AIJo. Inc. - Case No. 20050060622 This hearing was requested by Officer Jeff Letourneau, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent was represented by Cathleen Lawler, AlJo's Registered Agent. Violations, Ordinance 04-58 Sec. 6, Numerous Minimum Housing Violations. Violations at Unit 608 Finch Drive, Naples, FL, included stairs and railing to the front door were rotting and dangerous, skirting around mobile home was falling down. No hot water, no water pressure, rear slider was not lockable, water damage to walls, ceiling and floor; insect infestation. Ms. Lawler indicated a new water heater element has been provided for unit. Has been unable to fix water pressure because of debate of which entity is responsible. 14 September 2, 2005 Proper notice was given. Violator/Respondent has been found GUILTY of violating the ordinance. The Violator/Respondent is ordered to correct all minimum housing violations in accordance with all applicable County ordinances (i.e., minimum housing, permitting) on or before October 2, 2005 or a fine of $250 will be imposed for each day any violations remain thereafter. Violator/Respondent is ordered to use only licensed contractors to perform work. Violator/Respondent is ordered to inform County as work is accomplished so that work can be inspected. Operational costs will be imposed in the sum of$189.02, to be paid in 30 days. Unit may not be rented out until all violations are corrected and a Certificate of Occupancy has been issued. County is ordered to abate the violations and charge the costs back to the owner if the owner does not take responsibility for abating the violations himself within seven days. BCC vs. AlJo. Inc. - Case No. 2005060623 This hearing was requested by Officer Jeff Letourneau, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent AlJo, Inc., was represented by Cathleen Lawler, its Registered Agent. Violation, Ordinance 04-58 Sec. 6, Numerous Minimum Housing Violations. Violations at Unit 526 Ensis Drive, Naples, FI, included rotted kitchen counter, bathroom light exposed, skylight in kitchen not weather tight, bathroom window not up to code and floor and wall rot around both tubs. Officer Letourneau believes conditions still exist as he has not been called in to reinspect. Skylight has cardboard covering it. Christina Garmaster: Tenant in Unit 526 Ensis Drive. Tub works, shower is usable. All three members of family are sick. Witness testified that it is sometimes difficult to get into unit if no one is home, but that landlord does need to fix things and should be able to get in. Witness testified that she is at home all the time. Skylight is fixed, still leaks a little, but not as bad. Sink is fixed. Tub is fixed. Witness replaced caulking in bathroom herself. Proper notice was given. Violator/Respondent is voluntarily absent from hearing. Violator/Respondent has been found GUILTY of violating the ordinance. The Violator/Respondent is ordered to correct all minimum housing violations in accordance with all applicable County ordinances (i.e., minimum housing, permitting) on or before September 9, 2005 or a fine of $250 will be imposed for each day any violations remain thereafter. Violator/Respondent is ordered to use only licensed contractors to perform work. Violator/Respondent is ordered to inform County as work is accomplished so that work can be inspected. Operational costs will be imposed in the sum of $189.02, to be paid in 30 days. County is ordered to abate the violations and charge the costs back to the owner if the owner does not take responsibility for abating the violations himself within seven days. BCC vs. AIJo. Inc. - Case No. 2005060621 This hearing was requested by Officer Jeff Letourneau, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. 15 September 2, 2005 Respondent AlJo, Inc., was represented by its Registered Agent, Cathleen Lawler. Violation, Ordinance 04-58 Sec. 6, Numerous Minimum Housing Violations. Violations at Unit 520 Ensis Drive, Naples, FL, included no heating equipment provided, no screens for windows, water damage to the second ceiling, water to the master bedroom floor, insect infestation, bottom of the tub rotted and no working smoke detectors. Also, kitchen skylight and surrounding ceiling was rotted and not up to code. Ms. Lawler stated they were not able to get into the unit. Roofwas patched. Tenants are being evicted so they are uncooperative. Proper notice was given. Violator/Respondent is voluntarily absent from hearing. Violator/Respondent has been found GUILTY of violating the ordinance. The Violator/Respondent is ordered to correct all minimum housing violations in accordance with all applicable County ordinances (i.e., minimum housing, permitting) on or before September 9, 2005 or a fine of $250 will be imposed for each day any violations remain thereafter. Violator/Respondent is ordered to use only licensed contractors to perform work. Violator/Respondent is ordered to inform County as work is accomplished so that work can be inspected. Operational costs will be imposed in the sum of$195.59, to be paid in 30 days. County is ordered to abate the violations and charge the costs back to the owner if the owner does not take responsibility for abating the violations himself within seven days. BCC vs. AIJo. Inc. - Case No. 2005070422 This hearing was requested by Officer Jeff Letoumeau, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent AlJo, Inc., was represented by its Registered Agent, Cathleen Lawler. Violations, Ordinance 04-58 Sec. 6, Numerous Minimum Housing Violations. Violations at Unit 505 Ensis Drive, Naples, FL included faulty refrigerator, community trash in unsanitary condition, leak around skylight causing water damage and rot to the kitchen ceiling, rear porch and stair railings in rotting condition, no screens on windows, insect infestation and inoperable smoke detectors. Ms. Lawler testified that she has paid out of pocket to have trash cleaned up and then gotten paid back. Cannot get ABC Pest Control to come out and spray because they have not been paid for the past six months. Proper notice was given. Violator/Respondent is voluntarily absent from hearing. Violator/Respondent has been found GUILTY of violating the ordinance. The Violator/Respondent is ordered to correct all minimum housing violations in accordance with all applicable County ordinances (i.e., minimum housing, permitting) on or before September 9, 2005 or a fine of $250 will be imposed for each day any violations remain thereafter. Violator/Respondent is ordered to use only licensed contractors to perform work. Violator/Respondent is ordered to inform County as work is accomplished so that work can be inspected. Operational costs will be imposed in the sum of $189.02, to be paid in 30 days. County is ordered to abate the violations and 16 September 2, 2005 charge the costs back to the owner if the owner does not take responsibility for abating the violations himseljwithin seven days. BCC vs. AIJo. Inc. - Case No. 2005060771 This hearing was requested by Officer John Santafemia, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent AlJo, Inc., was represented by its Registered Agent Cathleen Lawler. Violations, Ordinance 04-58 Sec. 6, Numerous Minimum Housing Violations. Violations at Unit 527 Ensis Drive, Naples, FL, included skirting was missing from exterior of trailer, the front stairs were rotted and the boards were loose, ftont window broken, door missing, interior doors not fitted properly, holes in walls, area around trailer was littered with debris, no smoke detectors. NOV was served. No repairs have been made. Ms. Lawler stated that litter is fault of tenants as is broken window. Proper notice was given. Violator/Respondent is voluntarily absent from hearing. Violator/Respondent has been found GUILTY of violating the ordinance. The Violator/Respondent is ordered to correct all minimum housing violations in accordance with all applicable County ordinances (i.e., minimum housing, permitting) on or before September 9,2005 or afine of$250 will be imposed for each day any violations remain thereafter. Violator/Respondent is ordered to use only licensed contractors to perform work. Violator/Respondent is ordered to inform County as work is accomplished so that work can be inspected. Operational costs will be imposed in the sum of $182.23, to be paid in 30 days. County is ordered to abate the violations and charge the costs back to the owner if the owner does not take responsibility for abating the violations himseljwithin seven days. BCC vs. AIJo. Inc. - Case No. 20050600639 This hearing was requested by Officer John Santafemia, Collier County Code Enforcement, who is present. Respondent AlJo, Inc., was represented by its Registered Agent Cathleen Lawler. Violation, Ordinance 04-58 Sec. 6, Numerous Minimum Housing Violations. Violations at Unit 511 Ensis included oven not operating, numerous outlets not operating, wiring was reversed, skirting on trailer was missing, roof was leaking, sliding door did not lock, no latches or locks on the doors, floors and doors were rotted with holes, property was littered with debris, infestation of roaches, kitchen sink fixtures was leaking, no smoke detectors. Ms. Lawler stated she has new stove waiting for them but cannot gain access. Tenant changed locks. Proper notice was given. Violator/Respondent is voluntarily absent from hearing. Violator/Respondent has been found GUILTY of violating the ordinance. The Violator/Respondent is ordered to correct all minimum housing violations in accordance with all applicable County ordinances (i.e., minimum housing, permitting) 17 September 2, 2005 on or before September 9, 2005 or a fine of $250 will be imposed for each day any violations remain thereafter. Violator/Respondent is ordered to use only licensed contractors to perform work. Violator/Respondent is ordered to inform County as work is accomplished so that work can be inspected. Operational costs will be imposed in the sum of $182.23, to be paid in 30 days. County is ordered to abate the violations and charge the costs back to the owner if the owner does not take responsibility for abating the violations himself within seven days. BCC vs. AIJo. Inc. - Case No. 20050600629 This hearing was requested by Officer John Santafemia, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent AlJo, Inc., was represented by its Registered Agent Cathleen Lawler. Violation, Ordinance 04-58 Sec. 6, Numerous Minimum Housing Violations. Violations at Unit 519 Ensis Drive, Naples, FL. included missing covers on electrical outlets, outlets not operating, front door very difficult to open causing safety hazard, front door missing handle, west wall of trailer sustained water damage and was soft, infestation of roaches, and smoke detectors were not operable. Ms. Lawler indicated that problems have been fixed and is ready to be inspected. Proper notice was given. Violator/Respondent is voluntarily absent from hearing. Violator/Respondent has been found GUILTY of violating the ordinance. The Violator/Respondent is ordered to correct all minimum housing violations in accordance with all applicable County ordinances (i.e., minimum housing, permitting) on or before September 9, 2005 or a fine of $250 will be imposed for each day any violations remain thereafter. Violator/Respondent is ordered to use only licensed contractors to perform work. Violator/Respondent is ordered to inform County as work is accomplished so that work can be inspected. Operational costs will be imposed in the sum of$176.56, to be paid in 30 days. County is ordered to abate the violations and charge the costs back to the owner if the owner does not take responsibility for abating the violations himself within seven days. BCC vs. AlJo. Inc. - Case No. 2005060628 This hearing was requested by Officer John Santafemia, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent AlJo, Inc., was represented by its Registered Agent Cathleen Lawler. Violations, Ordinance 04-58 Sec. 6, Numerous Minimum Housing Violations. Violations included non-operable oven, electrical outlets missing covers, several not operating; outside light fixture broken, entry wood stairs rotten and unsafe, porch railing at entryway were rotten and unsafe, windows in rear inoperable, screens missing with no air conditioning, rotten floor with hole straight through to ground, area around trailer littered with debris, no smoke detectors and unsanitary plumbing fixtures. Ms. Lawler stated unit has a brand new stove. Has not gotten back in for other items. 18 September 2, 2005 Proper notice was given. Violator/Respondent is voluntarily absent from hearing. Violator/Respondent has been found GUILTY of violating the ordinance. The Violator/Respondent is ordered to correct all minimum housing violations in accordance with all applicable County ordinances (i.e., minimum housing, permitting) on or before September 9, 2005 or a fine of $250 will be imposed for each day any violations remain thereafter. Violator/Respondent is ordered to use only licensed contractors to perform work. Violator/Respondent is ordered to inform County as work is accomplished so that work can be inspected. Operational costs will be imposed in the sum of $176.56, to be paid in 30 days. County is ordered to abate the violations and charge the costs back to the owner if the owner does not take responsibility for abating the violations himself within seven days. Special Master Garretson stated her reasons for finding Respondent Bottino guilty and indicated she has read his letters. BCC vs. Steven A. Helfrich - Case No. 2005060698 This hearing was requested by Officer Ian Jackson, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent Steven A. Helfrich was not present. Violation, Ordinance 99-51 Sec. 6 & 7, Accumulation of Litter. Violation has been abated. Seeking operational costs. Proper notice was given. Violation existed at time of NO V. Violation has been abated. Respondent was present this morning, knew what was going to be imposed and chose not to be present for the hearing. Operational Costs are imposed in the sum of $168.57, to be paid within 30 days. BCC vs. Steven A. Helfrich - Case No. 2005060796 This hearing was requested by Officer Ian Jackson, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent Steven A. Helfrich was not present. Violation, Ordinance 04-41 Sec. 5.03.01, Canopy/Tent Structure Installed Without Permits. Violation abated, seeking operational costs. Respondent was present this morning and is aware of the operational costs. Proper notice was given. Violation existed at time of NO V. Violation has been abated. Respondent was present this morning, knew what was going to be imposed and chose not to be present for the hearing. Operational Costs are imposed in the sum of $162.85, to be paid within 30 days. 19 September 2, 2005 BCC vs. Craie: & e:loria Perlowin - Case No. 200570565 This hearing was requested by Officer Shawn Luedtke, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondents Craig & Gloria Perlowin were not present. Violation, Ordinance 91-102 Sec. 2.6.7.1.1. NOV was given. Violation has been abated. Violation involved inoperable Honda up on blocks in the driveway for approximately two week. Operational costs are being requested. Proper notice was given. Respondent was in violation at the time of the NO V. Violation has been abated. Operational costs are assessed in the sum of$158.92, to be paid in 30 days. BCC vs. Flavio Pineros & Dee:nv Aurora - Case No. 2005060975 This hearing was requested by Officer Shawn Luedtke, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondents Flavio Pineros & Degny Aurora were not present. Violation, Ordinance 91-102 Sec. 1.5.672.6.7.1.1. Violation involved an expired license on a Capri station wagon. Vehicle has been removed. Operational costs are being requested. Proper notice was given. Respondents were in violation of the ordinance at time of NO ~ but violation has been abated. Operational costs are assessed in the sum of $158.92, to be paid in 30 days. BCC vs. Lucille Lahaie McGoon - Case No. 2005040819 This hearing was requested by Officer Larry Schwartz, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent Lucille Lahaie McGoon was not present. Violation, Ordinance 04-41 as Amended Sec. 10.02.06, Mobile Home Without Permit. NOV came back unclaimed. Property was posted, posted at Courthouse. Proper notice was given. Respondent did not appear. Respondent is GUILTY of violating the ordinance. Respondent is ordered to comply with the ordinance within 60 days, must obtain all permits, inspections and Certificate of Occupancy or a fine of $100 per day will be imposed. Operational costs are imposed in the sum of $? ? ? ?, to be paid in 30 days. Respondent must contact the investigator so that he may ascertain that compliance has occurred. 20 September 2, 2005 BCC vs. Diamond Shore Affordable Housini! - William Schweikhardt. Rei!. Ai!ent _ Case No. 2005020148 This hearing was requested by Officer Larry Schwartz, Collier County Code Enforcement, who is present. Respondent Diamond Shores was not present. Violation, Ordinance 04-58 Sec. 6, Numerous Minimum Housing Violations. Violations included infestation of fleas and roaches, front door hinge was not on, no heat or air conditioning, no screen, broken bedroom windows, only two burners on stove were working, bathtub was leaking, hole in ceiling, mold in bathroom and kitchen drawers were broken. Inspector is in possession of signed NOV. Tenant is no longer living there because of violations. Proper notice was given. Violator/Respondent is voluntarily absent from hearing. Violator/Respondent has been found GUILTY of violating the ordinance. The Violator/Respondent is ordered to correct all minimum housing violations in accordance with all applicable County ordinances (i.e., minimum housing, permitting) on or before September 9,2005 or afine of$250 will be imposed for each day any violations remain thereafter. Violator/Respondent is ordered to use only licensed contractors to perform work. Violator/Respondent is ordered to inform County as work is accomplished so that work can be inspected. Operational costs will be imposed in the sum of$239.13, to be paid in 30 days. County is ordered to abate the violations and charge the costs back to the owner if the owner does not take responsibility for abating the violations himself within seven days. BCC vs. Diamond Shore Affordable Housinl! - William Schweikhardt. Rei!. Ai!ent _ Case No. 2004120416 This hearing was requested by Officer Larry Schwartz, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent Diamond Shores was not present. Violation, Ordinance 04-58 Sec. 6, Numerous Minimum Housing Violations. Violations included water damage in bedroom and living room ceiling, damage to the bathroom and exposed wire in the kitchen. Proper notice was given. Violator/Respondent is voluntarily absent from hearing. Violator/Respondent has been found GUILTY of violating the ordinance. The Violator/Respondent is ordered to correct all minimum housing violations in accordance with all applicable County ordinances (i.e., minimum housing, permitting) on or before September 9, 2005 or a fine of $250 will be imposed for each day any violations remain thereafter. Violator/Respondent is ordered to use only licensed contractors to perform work. Violator/Respondent is ordered to inform County as work is accomplished so that work can be inspected. Operational costs will be imposed in the sum of $204.54, to be paid in 30 days. County is ordered to abate the violations and 21 ~--_..,._- September 2, 2005 charge the costs back to the owner if the owner does not take responsibility for abating the violations himself within seven days. BCC vs. Diamond Shore Affordable Housinl! - William Schweikhardt. ReI!. Al!ent _ Case No. 2004120662 This hearing was requested by Officer Larry Schwartz, Collier County Code Enforcement, who was present. Respondent Diamond Shores was not present. Violations, Ordinance 04-58 Sec. 6, Numerous Minimum Housing Violations. Violations included mold throughout house, water heater broke leaking water all over the trailer, numerous holes in the walls, Family and Children came and removed her children from the home because ofthe mold. Proper notice was given. Violator/Respondent is voluntarily absent from hearing. Violator/Respondent has been found GUILTY of violating the ordinance. The Violator/Respondent is ordered to correct all minimum housing violations in accordance with all applicable County ordinances (i.e., minimum housing, permitting) on or before September 9,2005 or afine of$250 will be imposed for each day any violations remain thereafter. Violator/Respondent is ordered to use only licensed contractors to perform work. Violator/Respondent is ordered to inform County as work is accomplished so that work can be inspected. Operational costs will be imposed in the sum of$210.30, to be paid in 30 days. County is ordered to abate the violations and charge the costs back to the owner if the owner does not take responsibility for abating the violations himself with in seven days. 3. COMMENTS: None 4. NEXT HEARING DATE: September 16, 2005 There being no further business for the good the County, the Hearing was adjourned by order of the Special Master at 1 :05 p.m. FOR THE COLLIER COUNTY SPECIAL MASTER Leonardo Bonanno, Secretary to the Special Master 22