GGELTC Agenda 09/24/2018A G E N D A
Golden Gate Estates Land Trust Committee
Monday, September 24, 2018 - 5:30 p.m.
Greater Naples Fire Rescue Station 71
100 13th Street SW
Committee Members
Chairman: Mark Fillmore
Vice-Chairman: Annette Kniola
Member: Pat Humphries
Member: Jeff Curl
Member: Carol Pratt
County Staff
Michael Dowling: Collier County Real Property Management
___
1. Call to order
2. Approval of current agenda
3. Approval of the Minutes for the July 30, 2018 Regular Meeting
4. Treasurer’s Report
5. Greater Naples Fire Rescue District request for funding update
6. Consideration and Recommendation to the Board of County Commissioners for
the reappointment of Annette Kniola to the Golden Gate Estates Land Trust
Committee
7. Discussion of current land values and recommendation to the Board of County
Commissioners to release some or all of the properties currently on hold, and
discussion regarding properties previously reserved by governmental agencies
8. Other Business
9. Public Comment
10. Next meeting – November 26, 2018
11. Adjourn
20.A.2
Packet Pg. 483 Attachment: Agenda September 24, Meeting (6811 : GGE Land Trust Advisory Committee - September 24, 2018)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
A B C D E F G H I J K L M
GAC Land Sales List of Properties
March 22, 2018
RESERVED FOR GOVERNMENT AGENCIES
PHASE UNIT TRACT LEGAL ACRES OR BK/PG RESERVED FOR FOLIO NUMBER EST VALUE DATE
I 7 81 All of Tract 81 9.11 1257/794 Parks and Recreation (3 - 2016)36915200008 7.92 x $22,000ac = $174,240 3/25/2018 *PA shows 7.92 acres
I 20 2 All of Tract 2 8.78 1257/794 School Board 37590080008 8.78 x $22,000ac = $193,160 3/25/2018
I 195 85 All of Tract 85 4.77 1257/794 School Board 45967400009 4.77 x $25,000ac = $119,250 3/25/2018
I 95 53 W 180 3.92 1257/794 School Board (3 - 2016)41824360008 3.92 x $80,000ac = $313,600 3/25/2018
I 96 121 All of Tract 121 4.52 1257/794 School Board (3 - 2016)41887560007 4.52 x $98,000ac = $442,960 3/25/2018
III 67A 110 All of Tract 110 1.49 1361/2029 North Naples Fire and Rescue 40120440005 1.49 x $15,000ac = $22,350 3/25/2018
1,265,560 *
RESERVED FOR FUTURE SALES
I 14 127 All of Tract 127 5.77 1257/1757 Future Marketability 37289560004 4.53 x $22,000ac = $99,660 3/25/2018 *PA shows 4.53 acres
I 17 89 All of Tract 89 4.62 1257/1757 Future Marketability 37445840005 4.62 x $22,000ac = $101,640 3/25/2018
I 24 97 All of Tract 97 5.00 1257/1757 Future Marketability 37807880001 5.00 x $23,000ac = $115,000 3/25/2018
I 49 126 All of Tract 126 5.61 1257/1757 Future Marketability 39271840002 5.61 x $19,000ac = $106,590 3/25/2018
I 18 55 All of Tract 55 4.43 1257/794 Future Marketability 37493920003 4.43 x $22,000ac = $97,460 3/25/2018
II 78 116 E75/W180 1.17 1361/2019 Future Marketability 40749320001 1.17 x $13,000ac = $15,210 3/25/2018
II 78 116 E75/E150 1.17 1361/2019 Future Marketability 40749320001 1.17 x $13,000ac = $15,210 3/25/2018
II 78 158 All of Tract 158 6.66 1361/2019 Future Marketability 40752400002 6.66 x $12,000ac = $79,920 3/25/2018
III 42 1 All of Tract 1 7.38 1361/2029 Future Marketability 38840040001 7.38 x $10,000ac = $73,800 3/25/2018
704,490 *
I 50 66 S 105, S 180 1.59 Available 39326920000 1.59 x $18,000ac = $28,620 3/25/2018
I 51 3 N 75, N 150 1.17 Available 39380200009 1.17 x $18,000ac = $21,060 3/25/2018
I 51 35 S 75 / S 150 1.13 Available 39384040003 1.13 x $18,000ac = $20,340 3/25/2018
II 73 59 E 75 / W 180 1.14 Available 40474920006 1.14 x $11,000ac = $12,540 3/25/2018
II 73 83 E 75 / W 150 1.14 Available 40476840003 1.14 x $11,000ac = $12,540 3/25/2018
II 73 103 S 75 / S 150 1.17 Available 40478280001 1.17 x $11,000ac = $12,870 3/25/2018
IV 47 52 W 105 / W 180 1.59 Available 39145640008 1.59 x $13,000ac = $20,670 3/25/2018
II 93 48 W105/W180 1.17 Available 41714000009 1.17 x $11,000ac = $12,870 3/25/2018
II 93 48 E75/W180 1.14 1361/2019 Foster Inquiry 41713880000 1.14 x $11,000ac = $12,540 3/25/2018
154,050 *
NOTE: Vacant land lots smaller than 2.25 acres may not be developable, research is required.
Acreage is based on size, location and utility of the lot.
TOTAL VALUE $2,124,100 *
*The valuation is a desk top review of values, this means the vacant lots have not been inspected. The highest and best use for the vacant lots are homestead
due to size and location. No enviromental or other adverse factors that may exist has been taken into consideration.
20.A.3
Packet Pg. 484 Attachment: 2018 GAC LANDS ANNUAL VALUATION (6811 : GGE Land Trust Advisory Committee -
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
A B C D E F G H I J K L M
20.A.3
Packet Pg. 485 Attachment: 2018 GAC LANDS ANNUAL VALUATION (6811 : GGE Land Trust Advisory Committee -
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
A B C D E F G H I J K L M
20.A.3
Packet Pg. 486 Attachment: 2018 GAC LANDS ANNUAL VALUATION (6811 : GGE Land Trust Advisory Committee -
M I N U T E S
Golden Gate Estates Land Trust Committee
Monday, July 30, 2018
5:30 p.m.
Greater Naples Fire Rescue District Headquarters – Conference Room
14575 Collier Boulevard, Naples, Florida 34119
Committee Members
Chairman: Mark Fillmore - Absent
Vice-Chairman: Annette Kniola
Member: Pat Humphries
Member: Jeff Curl
Member: Carol Pratt - Absent
County Staff
Michael Dowling: Collier County Real Property Management
Guests
Tara Bishop, Deputy Director, Finance and Administration, Greater Naples Fire Rescue District
Wayne Martin, Deputy Director Planning, Greater Naples Fire Rescue District
___
1. Call to order: Chairman Mark Filmore was unable to attend so Vice -Chairman
Annette Kniola called the meeting to order at 5:30 pm.
2. Approval of current agenda: Annette asked if there were any changes or questions,
there were not. Annette called for a motion to approve as submitted, Jeff made the
motion to approve the current agenda as submitted, Pat seconded the motion, the
vote was called, and all were in favor.
3. Approval of the Minutes for the Special Meeting of July 30, 2018: Annette asked
if there were any changes or questions, there were not. Annette called for a motion
to approve as submitted, Jeff made the motion to approve the cur rent minutes as
submitted, Pat seconded the motion, the vote was called, and all were in favor.
4. Treasurer’s Report: Michael provided the available balance of $880,746.58.
5. Greater Naples Fire Rescue District request for funding : Tara Bishop and Wayne
Martin with the Greater Naples Fire Rescue District explained that the District was
20.A.4
Packet Pg. 487 Attachment: Minutes July 30, 2018 Meeting (6811 : GGE Land Trust Advisory Committee - September 24, 2018)
in need of funding to purchase a new brush truck to assist in fire control in Golden
Gate Estates. The cost of the Brush Truck is $212,725.44. The District is unable to
fund the entire cost since there are five other trucks coming online that will be
paid for over seven years by the District. Tara said that she attempted to apply for
a grant for the Brush Truck but there are no grants available for that type of
equipment. Wayne provided a handout showing the type o f truck that is being
discussed (attached). Pat asked how the District would fund the truck if the GGE
Land Trust Committee were to refuse the funding request. Tara said the District
would have to request the fundi ng from their Board and with the other trucks on
order, the request may not be granted and that is why she was petitioning the
Committee for assistance. Jeff said that the Committee’s funds were low and that
the Committee would be reviewing the values of p roperties that are currently on
the hold and will consider a recommendation to the Board of County
Commissioners to release some or all in order to take advantage of the current
market and to regain funds in its account to satisfy these types of requests. With
that, Jeff made a motion to fund fifty percent of the cost of the Brush Truck, which
equals $106,362.72. Michael said that he can prepare the Executive Summary and
submit the item on the next available BCC meeting which would be September 11,
2018, since the Board is on vacation until that date. Tara said her Board meets on
August 14 and will inform Michael if her Board does not agree to fund the second
half of the cost so that an Agreement would not have to be processed. Annette
called for a second, Pat seconded the motion, the vote was called, all were in
favor.
6. Other Business: Tara informed the Committee that the Safety Trailer was
damaged during Hurricane Irma. Tara said that their insurance carrier will provide
$43,000 for repair/replacement. Tara said that she is obtaining quotes since the
new Safety Trailers have new technology and are in the $160,000.00 range. Of
course, the insurance money would go towards the purchase of the new trailer.
Tara said she is not asking for funds at this time since she is applying for grants
for the Trailer but wanted to make the Committee aware that she may petition the
Committee at a future date should the grant not be approved. The new Trailers
have more computer-technology and more educational interaction f or visitors.
7. Public Comment: None
8. Next meeting – September 24, 2018
9. Adjourn: 6:50 p.m.
20.A.4
Packet Pg. 488 Attachment: Minutes July 30, 2018 Meeting (6811 : GGE Land Trust Advisory Committee - September 24, 2018)