Backup Documents 04/26/2011 Item # 9B \i 98 \1
" \
~ 0\ J.
-..... ~r
t~
G- I- ' I- .
v J <l::U: <l::U:
0 ci 0
~ 0 'r O:::C/) O:::C/)
0:: <l::W 0:: <l::W
<C . C/)O...J <C C/)0...J
CJ W tJ w en a.. a:: w w en a..
- <l:: - <l:: a::
::I: l!; ~wZ ::I: ~wz
C) > I - <( C) (l > I _ <(
z i=1-::::! ::I: z i=1-::::! ::I:
iIi Oo<l:: (J iIi Oo<l:: (J
0:: m <l::1-0::: w 0:: m V <l::1-0::: W
W I- ~ (9::.::1- ::I: w I- '1? (9::.::1- ::I:
zO:::- I- m 0 ZO:::- I-
m 0 -w~ -w~
:!: w >-...J<l:: >- :!: w ] >-...J<l:: >-
::J .., ~o~ ...J ::J ia \;1 ~o~ ...J
Z m '-- z Z Z
::J ow~ 0 ::J ow~ 0
:!: en .... ...JI :E en '1 ...JI
W W << >-1-1- en w w >-1-1- en
.!:: ::I: ZIC/) en .!:: ::I: ZIC/) en
I- ~ <l::1-<l:: W I- ... <l::1-<l:: W
<C 0 Z5:W 0:: <C 0 l ~5:W 0::
0 I- - ..- 0 0 l- f^. ..- 0
Z (90:::0 0 Z (9 0::: a 0
w 0:: zW("l') <C w 0:: ZW("l') <C
C) 0 .- -1-("1') C) 0 q -1-("1')
or:( 0:: ~ ~ - 0 or:( 0:: ~ ~ - 0
D.. (9(9(9 I- D.. (9(9(9 I-
:E zw~ w :E ~ zw~ w
wO:::o IX: 0 wO:::o 0::
0 -...J ~ - ...J
~ WC/)- <C 0 WC/)- or:(
0:::0:::::> ii 0:::0:::::>
0:: owen 0 0:: V owen 0
0 W LLZO::: Z 0 W LLZO::: Z
\, 0:: ::I: wOw <C >- 0:: ~ ::I: wOw <C
~ <C I- coU5Z <C I- co-z
0 en ...J 0 - C/) 0::: ~
~ 0:: 0 ..iC/)O:: I- 0:: 0 (>< j~::>
<C m ~ ...J-::> Z <C m 14 z
w w <l::~1- w w w '" <l::~1- w
<. ...J ::I: '" I~Z :E ...J ::I: ~ I~z :E
10 (J I- C/)oo :E (J I- C/)oo :E
lV\ C/)o~ C/)o~
"" I- Z ~ 1->-0::: 0 I- Z ~ 1->-0::: 0
z ~I-<l:: (J Z ~ ~I-<l:: (J
0:: ~ 0:: en
\J < . >-zI l:t: <C >-zI 0::
Q. 15 co::> :::::l Q. 15 en p co::> ::J
en co 0 ' ~ co 0 .
~ ,~ w en ooS 0 w en OoS 0
> en w w > 'V en w w >-
::I: ...J _ <C ::I: ...J _
, <C 0:: ...JLLO::: 0:: ...JLLO:::
\j W I- 0 ...JOo 0:: >' W I- 0 ~ ...Joo 0::
...J LL 0 <l::oo C ~ ...J LL 0 <l::oo 0
''':) Q. 0 <C I-O:::...J LL Q. 0 or:( () 1-0:::...J LL
I- <l::<l::LL U. I- ~ <l::<l::LL en
LL I O:C 11 \A LL I O:C W
~ W I-en~ !: w ~ I-m~ I-
...J C/)w - ...J C/)w - ::J
WII- :2 q W WII- Z
0 w !fl-riJ f O:::I-Z i
:J ...J ::! ...J - W
m ::>(9~ I) m ::>(9~
<C OZI- - ~ OZI- -
'-- I- W-o::: C"': 0 ~ W-o::: (II)
'-' .... -
\L W O:::C/)<l:: u ~ W O:::C/)<l::
~ '<;t"C/)a.. '<;t"C/)a.. w
'0 ::I: C\lWW u J:"r .l C\lWW W
I- ,0:::0 0 I- ,0:::0 0::
~1 z 1'--0 J ~ z~ /^ 1'--0 ::I:
0 aoC/) I- o~ aoC/) I-
,<l:: 0 . <l:: 0
:E o -0::: ( ~ ~~ o - 0::: 0
0:: ii zoo I- 0:: ZOo I-
0 "" W wl-O , W wl-O 0
~ LL ~ Z oow IJ V1 Z oow w
0 zwo:: I- 0 zWO:: I-
0 <l::~o ; 0 <l::~o :ill
w ('IJ j:: ~ w j::
I- Z~Z I- Z~Z
W j:: o::::i<l:: W j:: o:J<l:: .:i
W ...J W O:::I-C/) L W ...J ~ W O:::I-C/) W
...J D.. a.. ...J D.. a..
I- :E QOW , I- :E QOW 0::
.= >-ZI- c .= ~ZI- <C
0 . . 1-1-::> 0 1-::>
C) . J C)
:!: 0 Z Z::J~ :E 0 -' Z Z::>~ ::J
w W ~ j:: ::JCO::2: c w w A j:: ::>CO::2: 0
..
.!:: 0 z o c5 0 .. .!::: 0 z o c> 0 >-
j w Ozo::: c( <C w Ozo:::
<C en ...J en
0 a.. o:::-<l:: 0 a.. .. O:::-<l::
Z W W woo Z w w woo
w :::E 0:: ::::i3en w :::E 0:: ::::i3en
C) <C D.. ...Jow C) c( D.. ...Jow
W W
or:( z a:: OZI or:( Z a:: OZI
0-=-1- 0-=-1-
98
j
~
I- . J I-..J
<ii <LL
ci o - 0
tv) o::(/) C o::(/)
0:: <W (() 0:: <w
<( (/)0-1 <( (/)0-1
\t w wcoa.. w wcoa..
- < - < ti
J: Cwz D: \ J: Cwz
C) > I - <i . C) ~ > I - <C
z j::1-:::! ::E ~ z j::1-:::! J:
jjj 00(2 CJ jjj 00< ()
0:: In <l- lL 0:: In ~ <1-0:: w
w I- C:>~I- ::E w I- C:>~I- J:
~ zO::- zO::-
In 0 -W2 ~ In 0 -W2 I-
:E W >--1< ~ :E W >--1< ~
::;) .., ~O~ ::;) .., I ~O~
Z In OW< Z Z In ~ OW~ Z
::;) ::;)
:E UJ ~ -III- e :E UJ -II 0
W W >-1-1- (f.I w w >-1-1- UJ
.t: J: ZI(/) (f.I .t: J: ZI(/) UJ
I- <1-< W I- <1-< W
<( 0 ~~~ ~ <( 0 Z~w 0::
~ C C e - ..- e
z I- '< c:>o::o e z I- c:>o::o e
w 0:: '1 ZW(\') <C W 0:: ZW(\') <C
C) 0 -I-(\') C) 0 -I-(\')
~ <C 0:: ~ ~(/) - 0 <C ~ ~ ~ - 0
~ D.. c:>(5C:> I- D.. c:>C:>C:> I-
:E ~ ZW~ w :E ZwZ w
WO::O 0:: WO::O 0::
VI 0 --I 0 --I
0 ~ W(/)- <C 0 W(/)- <C
o::o::::l ii o::o::::l
0:: ~ ii OwCO e ~ OwCO e
e w LLZO:: z e w LLZO:: Z
A, 0:: J: WOW <C ~ J: WOW <C
~ <( I- COU5Z >- ~ I- COU5Z
0 ~ ....I 0 UJ
~ 0:: 0 N -I(/) 0:: 0:: -I(/) 0:: I-
() <( In -I-::l Z <( In -I ~ ::l. Z
<21-
w w I2Z w w w 'j... <21- w
~ ....I J: ')<.l :E ....I J: V50Z :E
() I- (/)00 2: () I- 'IJ (/)O~ :E
rn (/)02 0 I- Z M 0
I- Z ~~o:: 1->-0::
~ z () z UJ ~I-< ()
it: UJ 5=z< it:
<( CO::lI 0:: <( >-zI 0::
a. is ::;) a. is CO::l ::;)
~ UJ co 0 . UJ co 0 .
w w UJ 00$ ~ c0 w w en 00$ 0
UJ W -I _ ->- UJ W -I _ >-
<( J: 0:: -ILLO:: 0:: <( J: 0:: -ILLO:: 0::
1t w l- e -100 w l- e -100
....I U. e <00 0 ....I U. e <00 0
a. 0 <C 1-0::-1 u.. a. 0 <C 1-0::-1 u..
I- <<LL UJ I- <<LL UJ
U. I 0:1: W U. I 0:1: W
W \-l.-. I-co~ I- W I-co~ I-
....I (/)W - ::;) ....I (/)W - ::;)
WII- Z ~ WII- Z
W ~ O::I-Z :i W O::I-Z :E
....I -"J - W ~ ....I - W
In ::lC:>2 In ::lC:>2
<( '.Jj OZI- - 'J <( OZI- -
""'- CO) CO)
I- W-o:: - 6 I- W-o:: -
w '-.l V) O::(/)< w w O::(/)< w
-q-(/)a.. -q-(/)a..
J: C'\IWW W J: S- C'\IWW W
I- \J ,0::0 0:: I- ,0::0 0::
1'-0 J: --' Z <>-' 1'-0 J:
Z
0 \l) OO(/) I- ~ 0 OO(/) l-
. <( 0 \) . < 0
:E o -0:: 0 ~ :E IJ o -0:: 0
0:: ii zoo I- 0:: zoo I-
0 wl-O e \r\ 0 C) 0:: wl-U e
w w
u. Z UOW W u. Z OOW w
e '1 0 Zwa::: l- e 0 Zwa::: I-
W i= <co ~ w i= <(t:o ~
I- Z2Z ..::::i I- -.JL Z2Z ..::::i
w i= 0:J<( .. w i= 0:J<(
W ....I W O::I-(/) W W ....I S W O::I-(/) W
....I D.. a. QOW 0:: ....I D.. ~ a. cow 0::
I- :E ~ I- :ii:
.= ~ZI- <C .= >-zl- <C
0 <<iX C) I-::l 0 C) I-I-:J
:E 0 Z z:J~ ::;) :ii: 0 k Z Z:J~ ::;)
0 ~
w w <::..; i= :JCO~ >- W w i= :JCO~
.t: 0 z 00'0 .!:: 0 z 00'0
<( ~ w Ozo:: <( <( w Ozo::
UJ 0::-< ....I UJ 0::-<
c a. W w woo e a. w w woo
z :ii: 0:: :J3co z :ii: 0:: :J3co
w D.. W D..
C) <( -lOw C) <( -IUw
W OZI W OZI
<C Z 0:: 0';:::"'1- <C Z 0:: 0';:::"'1-
~ 9 B ~ ~.
~ ~ I- . I- .
ci ~ <I:~ ci <I:~
0 m 0
0::: 0::: en 0::: 0::: en
<C (/)<I:~ <C (/)<I:~
W wOQ.. W wOQ..
:I: ~ _co <I: :I: _co <I: Ii
~ !::wz ~ !::wz
z ;::: I _ Z ;::: I - <
jjj I-I-...J jjj I-I-...J :I:
0::: r:a 00<( 0::: r:a 00<( 0
w <I: 1-0::: W <I: 1-0:::
r:a I- (9::.:::1- r:a I- (9::.:::1- w
:E 0 zo:::- :E 0 Zo:::- :I:
W ~ -w:2: w -w:2: t-
;:) .., >-...J<I: ;:) ii1 >-...J<I:
Z r:a OJu- Z OJu- ~
;:) OJ :2: ;:) OJ :2:
:E en OW~ :E en OW~ z
w W ...JI W W ...JI 0
~ >-1-1- ~ >-1-1-
:I: ZI(/) :I: ZI(/) en
<( I- <I:I-<I: <C I- <I:I-<I: en
c 0 ~~UJ C 0 ~~UJ w
Z I- Z I- 0:::
w 0::: (90:::"- W !.J (90:::0 c
~ 0 zwg ~ zWM C
<C 0::: 6ti)M <C 6ti)M <C
a.. <I:~ - <I:- - 0
:E (9(9(9 (9(9(9 t-
zwZ zwZ
0 "- wO:::o wO:::o w
0 W -...J 0 W -...J 0:::
0::: ~ it: 0:::(/)5 0::: )! it: 0:::(/)5 <C
c l) w offico c w offico c
N >- 0::: :I: LLZO::: >- 0::: :I: LLZO::: Z
...J <( " I- wOw ...J <C I- WOw <C
0::: 0 0 OJ-z 0::: 0 0 OJ-z
- (/) 0::: .J'~O::: en
<( r:a ...J(/) <C r:a
~ w ...J-::::> w - ...J-::::> I-
...J w <I::2:1- ...J w ~ <I::2:1- z
0 :I: I:2:Z 0 :I: I:2:Z w
I- (/)00 I- (/)00 :E
I- Z I- Z :E
z (/)u:2: z (/)u:2:
0:: en 1->-0::: 0:: en 1->-0::: 0
<( ~I-<I: <C ~I-<I: 0
a. >-zI a. >-zI
C " " OJ::::> C " " OJ::::> 0:::
w en OJ 0 . w en OJ 0 . ;:)
en w en gus en w en gus ~
<( :I: W <C :I: W
W I- 0::: ...JLLci W I- 0::: ...J LL 0:::-
...J LL C ...JOo ...J lL C ...JOo 0:::
a. 0 c <I: 00 a. 0 c <I: 0 0 0
I- <C I-O:::...J I- <C I-O:::...J LL
LL <I:<I:LL LL <I:<I:LL en
w ~ I 0'" W I 0'" W
...J I- co I- ...J I- co l-
(/) V (/) V I-
W w w - w w w - ;:)
...J 0::: II- ...J 0::: I I- Z
_ Z _ Z
r:a ::::>I-w r:a ::::>I-w ~
~ ~ 0(9:2: <C 0(9:2:
wZI- I- wZI- -
(II)
W o:::wO::: W o:::wO::: -
:I: v(/)<I: :I: v(/) <I: W
I- NWQ.. i~ NWQ.. W
Z ~ ,o:::w ,o:::w 0:::
1"-00 1"-00
0 ao(/) ao(/) :I:
:E . <I: 0 . <I: 0 t-
o::: it: o -0::: 0::: f"\ it: o -0::: 0
0 ZOO 0 ZOO t-
LL W wl-O i /1 W wl-O 0
0 z oow z oOW w
w ~ 0 zwo::: 0 zwo:: I-
" " I- i= <I:!::o "" i= <I:!::o :i
w w i= ~~z w i= ~~z
...J ...J W O...J<I: ...J W O...J<I: .:i
I- a.. a. O:::I-(/) I- ~--3 a. O:::I-(/) w
.= :E oow .= oow 0:::
:E 0 ~ >-zl- :E o ..:> " " >-zl- <C
0 ~ I-I-::J ~i-=S ~ 1-1-::::>
W W Z Z::::>~ w z Z::::>~ ;:)
1:: 0 i= ::JOJ~ ~ i= ::JOJ~ ~
<( :s z o cj 0 <C <C z o c5 0
c w uzo::: 0 ...J W uzo:::
z a. " " en o:::-<I: z D.. "" en o:::-<I:
w W W woo W W W woo
C) ::iE 0::: :J::::>(() ~ :E 0::: :J::::>CO
<C <C a.. ...J...J <l <C a.. ...J...J
Z W oOw Z w oow
D::: U~I ~ () ~~ 2:
-I-
"2.
-
~
~
cD
~
w
m
::E
:J
Z
::E
w
.!::
c(
o
z
w
C>
<
W
....I
I-
~
::E
w
1::
c(
o
z
w
C>
<
>-
....I
~
c(
W
....I
o
I-
Z
ii:
a.
w
en
c(
w
....I
a.
ci
~
c(
W
:I:
C>
Z
jjj
m
I-
o
W
""')
m
:J
en
w
:I:
I-
o
I-
~
o
~
a..
::E
o
o
~
o
~
c(
o
m
w
:I:
I-
Z
en
c(
i5
w
:I:
I-
u.
o
I-
u.
W
....I
W
....I
m
c(
I-
W
:I:
I-
Z
o
::E
~
o
u.
o
W
I-
W
....I
a..
::E
o
o
w
o
c(
....I
a.
..
w
::E
c(
Z
D::
w
:I:
I-
o
I--..i
<(LL
o
0:: en
<(W
eno....J
wrna.
-......<(
t:wZ
> I -
~I-:::!
00<(
<(1-0::
<9~1-
Zo::-
-W:2:
>-....J<(
ffio~
o W 1-<(
....JI
>-1-1-
ZIen
<(1-<(
~~~
<90::0
ZW~
-I-~
<9 en _
<(-<9
<9@z
~o::o
-....J
wen-
O::O:::J
owm
ll.ZO::
WOW
C!l(j)Z
3enO::
....J-:J
<(:2:1-
I:2:Z
enoO
enO:2:
~~o::
5=z<(
C!l:JI
C!l0::>
00>
....J _
....Jll.0::
....JOO
<(00
I-O::....J
<(<(ll.
I OI
I-m~
en w -
WII-
Q;I-~
:J<9:2:
OZI-
W-o::
o::en<(
Vena.
NWW
,0::0
1'-0
ooen
. <( 0
o -0::
ZOO
wl-O
OOW
zWO:::
<(t:O
z:2:z
o::::i<(
O::I-en
OOW
>-ZI-
I-I-:J
Z:J~
:JC!l~
o c9 0
Ozo::
0::-<(
WOO
::::i3m
....JOw
OZI
Oc-I-
oi:
:;;;:
:I:
o
W
:I:
I-
>-
....I
Z
o
en
en
w
~
o
o
<
o
I-
w
~
<
o
z
<
U)
I-
Z
w
::E
::E
o
o
~
:J
o
>-
~
o
LL
en
w
I-
:J
~
::E
..
~
'~ '.-.
")-
-
Cot)
-
w
w
~
:I:
I-
o
I-
o
W
l-
i
.:i
w
~
<
:J
o
>-
\,,',
s--
"-...
~
t
\
~
~
~
1\)
~
~
~
'\)
y
.{
~
~
-.....(
--S
?J
e
. s
K
.....,
'"
...)
'--"
~
~
w
m
::E
:J
Z
::E
w
.!::
c(
o
z
w
C>
<
<:)
:J
v
--'
0.
W
....I
I-
~
::E
w
1::
c(
o
z
w
C>
<
~
~
c(
W
....I
o
I-
Z
ii:
a.
w
en
c(
w
....I
a.
ci
~
c(
W
:I:
C>
Z
jjj
m
I-
o
w
ii3~
:J
en~
Lli\"
:I:.....
~f"'\
~)
OP
~
::E\~
ON "\
~~
o .-
~~ ~
~ IX.) (\.;
~~}
~
~
i5
w
:I:
I-
u.
o
I-
u.
W
....I -----
W '--
....I
~. (\j
I- ---:..
w
:I:
I-
Z
o -:J
::E
~
o
u.
o
W
I-
W '--
....I _
a..
== \IJ
8 '-------
w
o
c(
....I
a.
q B 14
.~
~
l,
.......
.J
\J
en
en
w
~
o
o
<
w
::E
c(
Z
D::
w
:I:
I-
o
~ii
o -
0:: en
<(w
enO....J
wrna.
-...... <(
t:wZ
> I -
~I-:::!
00<(
<(1-0::
<9~1-
zO::-
-w:2:
>-....J<(
ffio~
OW<(
....JII-
>-1-1-
ZIen
<(1-<(
zS=W
->T""
<90::0
ZW~
-I-~
<9 en _
<(-<9
<9<9z
zW-
WO::O
-....J
wen-
O::O:::J
owm
ll.ZO::
WOW
C!l(j)Z
3enO::
....J-:J
<(:2:1-
I:2:Z
enOo
enO:2:
1->-0::
~I-<(
>-ZI
C!l:J
C!l0::>
00>
....J _
....Jll.0::
....J00
<(00
I-O::....J
<(<(lJ..
IOI
I-m~
en w -
WII-
Q;I-~
:J<9:2:
OZI-
w-o::
o::en<(
Vena.
NWW
,0::0
1'-0
ooen
. <( 0
o -0::
ZOO
wl-O
oow
zwo:::
<(t:O
z:2:z
o::::i<(
O::I-en
OOW
>-zl-
I-I-:J
z:J~
:JC!l~
o c9 0
Ozo::
0::-<(
WOO
::::i3m
....JOw
OZI
Oc-I-
D::
w
z
o
i=
i=
w
a.
C>
z
i=
z
w
en
w
~
a..
w
c:::
oi:
:;;;:
:I:
o
W
:I:
I-
~
z
o
U)
en
w
~
o
o
<
o
I-
w
~
<
o
z
<
en
I-
Z
w
::E
::E
o
o
~
:J
o
>-
~
o
LL
en
w
I-
:J
Z
::E
-
Cot)
-
w
w
~
:I:
I-
o
I-
o
W
l-
i
.:i
w
~
<
:J
~
Presented by:
9 f:3 Meet;ng Date · ~
t"~1f7)~ <<: (-Ie- ~
Agenda Item #
...' .-.
''"''''
.. .. . ~ . ...
4/26/2011 Item 9.B.
Cj B'~ f
COLLIER COUNTY
Board of County Commissioners
Item Number: 9.B.
Item Summary: To discuss a private developer"s closure of Mamie Street and the
resulting cutting off of access to the historical Ted Smallwood"s Store and other residents of
Chokoloskee and to recommend that the Board direct the County Attorney"s Office to work
with staff and Commissioner Coletta to investigate and review this matter, attempt to amicably
resolve the issue, and report back to the Board for further direction. (Commissioner Coletta)
Meeting Date: 4/26/2011
Prepared By
Approved By
Name: IsacksonMark
Title: Director-Corp Financial and Mgmt Svs,CMO
Date: 4/20/2011 10:54:57 AM
Packet Page -624-
......
-
1FT
.' .... . .,-.-.--..,.......
98;c 1'2, ,
4/26/2011 Item 9.8.
.' '
ti ". C 12, t"(,
---'-.""-'-
4/26/2011 Itern 9.8.
T ... __~~_ PW
,_,_."'<i-~.,..i>;., _., ""\V""
9 B/c~
CG
'L__..I
L__J .
9 Bd~o
~\\~
z~e7
v
b'
i
1
i
,
I
Rl!SOLUTION !
NAMING OF S'mEETS ON CHOKOLoS$ ISLAND
I
I
,
WHER~S, the Board ot County Commissio~ers are
authorized pursuant to the authority in D.SJ 336.05 to name
I
or rename streets and Roads, except state Rqads; and
I
,
I
' I
WHEREAS, a number ot Streets located o~ Chokoloskee
Island are owned and mainta1ned by the Boar~ ot County
. CODml1ss1oners, and I
,
WHEREAS, it is desirable tor ident1f1c~tion purposes to
name these Streets, I
j
.erta~n unnamed Streets
I
Chokoloskee Drive i
Smallwood Drive !
Demere Lane I "
Hamilton Lane I
Mamie Street I
Worley Street I
and more par.t1cularly identified by the Plat lor Map filed and
be reference made a part of these minutes an4 attached as
Exhibit "All and I
I
BElT FURTHER RESO~VED that the County ~gineer,is hereby
d1rected to install the npproprintp. Street n~e 9ign~ and
that this Resolution be recorded in the PUbli~ Records of
Collier County and that the Clerk be directed to note the same
in the Public Records. and plats.
tJ
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that
are named and designated as follows:
Commissioner KurIte offered the fOregOinglaesolution and
moved its adoption, seconded by Commiss1oner rancock, and upon
roll call the vote was: I
Ayes: Commissioners Wenzel, Kutke, Hancock
and Moore.~
Nays: 0 .
Absent and not voting: Commiss oner Whitaker, Sr.
I
I
Adopted this -JQ day ot May ,1972, injregu1ar session.
j
I
BOARD OFCOUNTr ICOMMISSlONERS
OF CO CO , FL IDA
~ (S~L) ,
.h~-li' ~&#
Cle(J
ah
IUi
ft .1
Jill
o .LH'
()
I. _-1 ~j
II II
Ek:... .T ~
,<t~B; t "
G~OKOLOSKE~ \SL~~D
'~
N~114
....~ /
,~
. .'- ""'......
....
_.,../' .'
"
I
. \
\
]
9 B':-e,d
GEORGE ARCHIBALD
5201 CYPRESS LANE
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34113
April 22, 2011
Mr. Leo Ochs
Collier County Manager
County Manager's Office
3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 202
Naples, Florida 34112-5746
Jeffrey Klatzkow, Esquire
Collier County Attorney
Attorney's Office
3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 800
Naples, Florida 34112-5749
Subject: Mamie Street; Chokoloskee Island, Collier County, Florida
Dear Mssrs. Ochs and Klatzkow:
I am writing in my capacity as a private citizen who is interested in the general welfare of the Chokoloskee
community, and in my capacity as former Transportation Director for Collier County (where I served from
1975 until 1995). During my tenure as Transportation Director, it was well known that Mamie Street was a
public road insofar as it was improved and later maintained by Collier County, and provided public access to
the historic Ted Smallwood's Store. Mamie Street's status as a public right of way is based on the
following:
a) Collier County's improvement, operation and maintenance of Mamie Street during my employment
with Collier County between 1975 and 1995, which includes at least one instance in which the
County surfaced Mamie Street.
b) Section 95.361(1), Florida Statutes, which provides that a road that is maintained for 4 or more years
by a county or municipality "shall be deemed dedicated to the public. . . whether or not the road has
been formally established as a public highway."
c) Mamie Street is shown as a public road on the July 1978 Florida Department of Transportation
General Highway Map for Collier County, which map delineates private roads by a separate
designation.
The foregoing is based on the 20-year time period that I served as Transportation Director and I have not
separately inquired whether the public rights in Mamie Street that were established by the County's
improvement and maintenance of Mamie were abandoned or otherwise extinguished. To my knowledge, the
County has never abandoned Mamie Street. Nor have I inquired regarding any separate private rights that
may have been created by adverse possession or common-law principles.
As an added note, there are an additional 10 streets or more on Chokoloskee that are 'private' and not subject
to County operation/maintenance, including Calusa Drive.
Upon review of the above, I remain available to provide additional information as may be necessary.
Sincerely, ~
~~- --
George Archibald